diff --git a/q0/random_k2/question.json b/q0/random_k2/question.json index 54170932f5279b99ea4e767d8ac4b7c65df9e08f..e03ff76a92bce7ee3707f9c85b50a3e8327e70da 100644 --- a/q0/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q0/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "PH_2016.06.08_Economy-Final.pdf", - "web_24c4662e4f9e6338.pdf", - "web_d455d7d1e8416aea.pdf" + "web_3cd8fd0905eadfd3.pdf", + "web_4af2298618127c8a.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q0/random_k2/random_1.md b/q0/random_k2/random_1.md index 132a7a3a1eb856bf1ac3b2a8f7f839b34c78bc6d..0157c79493366431cd66d8105491fdfb94260f43 100644 --- a/q0/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q0/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1593 +1,663 @@ - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Thursday April 9 -About the National Science and Technology Council +Topics for this Lecture: +•Thermal Physics -The National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) is the principal means by which the Executive -Branch coordinates science and technology policy across the diverse entities that make up the federal -research and development enterprise. A primary objective of the NSTC is to ensure science and -technology (S&T) policy decisions and programs are consistent with the President’s stated goals. The -NSTC prepares research and development strategies that are coordinated across federal agencies -aimed at accomplishing multiple national goals. The work of the NSTC is organized under committees -that oversee subcommittees and working groups focused on different aspects of science and -technology. More information is available at www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/nstc. +• Temperature & Heat +• Temperature measurement +• Thermal expansion -About the Office of Science and Technology Policy +•Thermal Physics -The Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) was established by the National Science and -Technology Policy, Organization, and Priorities Act of 1976 to provide the President and others within -the Executive Office of the President with advice on the scientific, engineering, and technological -aspects of the economy, national security, homeland security, health, foreign relations, the -environment, and the technological recovery and use of resources, among other topics. OSTP leads -interagency S&T policy coordination efforts, assists the Office of Management and Budget with an -annual review and analysis of federal research and development in budgets, and serves as a source of -scientific and technological analysis and judgment for the President with respect to major policies, -is available at -plans, and programs of -www.whitehouse.gov/ostp. +• Phases & Latent Heat +• Calorimetry -federal government. More +• TF = (9/5)(TC) + 32 +• “Temperature” is not “Heat” +• Thermal linear expansion: -information +• ΔL = αL0ΔT [α] = K-1 -the +• Heat energy flow: +• Q=c*m*ΔT +• Qlost = Qgained -About the NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure +See the course webpage for slides, +video links, and google docs Q&A links +• Assignment 11 due Friday +• Pre-class due 15min before class +• Help Room: via Teams, 6-9pm +Wed/Thurs, also via email on Wed/Thurs +• SI: via Teams +• Office Hours: via email +(meisel@ohio.edu) -The Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure (RDI) coordinates federal investments -in infrastructure supporting research and development (R&D) across the nation under the auspices of -the NSTC’s Committee on Science and Technology Enterprise. This coordination ensures that U.S. R&D -infrastructure and the scientific and engineering workforce it supports remain preeminent, relevant, -and ready to address the nation’s economic and national security priorities. +• Phase changes: -About this Document +Q=m*L -Consistent with Section 1007 of the America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote -Excellence in Technology, Education, and Science (COMPETES) Act, the National Science and -Technology Council is required to “produce a report identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in -research facilities and major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities -at academic institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.” This -document fulfills that requirement by providing an assessment of issues facing the United States’ -research and development infrastructure (RDI) and their impact on the nation’s status as a global leader -in S&T. It aims be a tool for agencies to assess and address RDI concerns based on individual needs and -resources. The assessment identifies four major issues affecting U.S. RDI: aging and inadequate -research infrastructure; cascading impacts from substandard facilities; a widening gap in global S&T -outcomes; and challenges in recruiting and retaining top talent. This assessment also offers four -opportunities for agencies to meet future S&T needs: strategic planning, identifying gaps, -benchmarking, and interagency collaboration). +*If your circumstances +hinder your completion of +any of this class’s +assignments, please let +me know +*These slides are +recorded and posted in +advance for your +convenience. +Administrative details +may be out of date. Keep +an eye on your email +please. -– i – + Thermal Physics - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Why can we only see +warm things in infrared +and not cold objects? -Copyright Information +Why do bridges have +these sorts of joints? -This document is a work of the United States government and is in the public domain (see 17 U.S.C. -§105). Subject to the stipulations below, it may be distributed and copied with acknowledgment to -OSTP. Copyrights to graphics included in this document are reserved by the original copyright holders -or their assignees and are used here under the government’s license and by permission. Requests to -use any images must be made to the provider identified in the image credits or to OSTP if no provider -is identified. Published in the United States of America, 2024. +How much +energy does it +take to bring +water to a boiling +temperature? -– ii – + Temperature & Heat +• Temperature: - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +– A measure of the internal kinetic energy of atoms & molecules within an object. +– This is a property of an object. -NATIONAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL +• Heat: -Chair +– A measure of the transfer of energy between two objects. +– This is a property of an interaction, not of a single object. +– Heat is the energy moving from a high temperature object to a low temperature object. -Arati Prabhakar, Assistant to the President for -Science and Technology; and Director, Office -of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) + Temperature Scales -Executive Director +• A few common units are used for temperature: -Kei Koizumi, Principal Deputy Director for -Science, Society, and Policy, OSTP +– Fahrenheit, Celsius, & Kelvin +• Fahrenheit is related to Celsius by: + TFahrenheit = (9/5)TCelsius + 32 + ΔTFahrenheit = (9/5)ΔTCelsius +• Celsius is related to Kelvin by: + TKelvin = TCelsius + 273.15 -NSTC SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT -INFRASTRUCTURE +20C is about +room +temperature. -Co-Chairs +Zero C is +freezing, +10C is cold, +20C is nice, +30C is hot. -Executive Secretary +• Zero Kelvin is “absolute zero” (lowest possible T) +• Zero Celsius is the freezing point for water, +which is 32 Fahrenheit and 273.15 Kelvin. -Harriet Kung, Department of Energy +• 100 Celsius is the boiling point for water, -Mariam Elsayed, Department of Energy +which is 212 Fahrenheit and 373.14 Kelvin. -Linnea Avallone, National Science Foundation + Thermal Expansion of Solids: Linear expansion -Jagadeesh Pamulapati, Department of +• Objects expand when their temperature increases. +• The amount of expansion depends on the material +properties and is known as +the expansion coefficient: α +• α depends on the particular material +(and one the phase of matter). SI unit: K-1 +• α describes how much an object expands +in a linear dimension for a given temperature +increase -Defense + ΔL = αL0ΔT -Cole Donovan, Office of Science and +• The fractional change in length is: -Technology Policy + ΔL/L = αΔT + ΔT must be in Celsius or Kelvin -Members +• Typical α values are (at 20 degrees C): -Aliya Iftikhar, Office of Science and +–Aluminum, Copper, Silver: ~2x10-5 K-1 +–Concrete, Glass, Steel : ~1x10-5 K-1 +–Diamond: ~0.1x10-5 K-1 -Jason Boehm, National Institute for Standards +This is why you need special +joints for, e.g. bridges -Technology Policy + An 0.5m-long rod with a thermal expansion coefficient of α ~ 10-5 K-1 is heated +from room temperature (~293K) to the boiling temperature for water (~373K). +How much extra length does the rod have after heating? -and Technology +2 -Gordon Hengst, Department of Defense +(A) 4x10-6 m +(B) 4x10-4 m +(C) 4x10-2 m +(D) 4 m -Gary Matlock, National Oceanic and +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(373K - 293K) +3. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(80K) +4. ΔL = 0.0004m = 400μm This is ~4 human hair widths. -Atmospheric Administration + A bi-metallic strip is composed of one metal sandwiched together with +another, so one metal is on top and another metal is on the bottom. +If the metal on the top half has a smaller thermal expansion coefficient +than the metal on the bottom half, which picture best represents what +happens after the bi-metallic strip is heated? -Terence Lynch, National Oceanic and +3 -Atmospheric Administration +(A) 1 +(B) 2 +(C) 3 -Bob McDonald, National Institutes of Health +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. The top strip has a +smaller α and so it +will expand less than the +bottom strip. -Angela Hadley, Environmental Protection +3. To achieve the extra +length on the bottom, +without lengthening the +top-half by the same +amount, the strip is +forced to bend upwards. -Agency +Leonard G. -Kartik Sheth, National Aeronautics and Space +This is how some of the +older spring-based +thermostats work. +Temperature changes cause +the spring to bend, +ultimately completing a +circuit to turn on/off the +heat/AC. -Administration + Heat -Scott Miller, Smithsonian Institution + Sect 14.1 -Alexander Kurien, General Services +• Heat is thermal energy that flows from a high- -Administration +temperature object to a low-temperature object. -Paul Strang, Department of Homeland +• Heat depends on parameters of a process. -Security +These are so-called “state variables” +– Internal energy (U) of the objects, -Joon Park, Department of Agriculture +i.e. the kinetic energy of atoms/molecules inside -Mike Villarreal, Department of Agriculture +– Temperature (T) of the objects -Geoff Plumlee, U.S. Geological Survey +• Your body radiates heat to the surrounding -Dan Hayba, U.S. Geological Survey +environment as light. +• We see that light in the +infrared wavelengths. -Esha Mathew, State Department + Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy? -– iii – +6 - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +(A) Raising 1kg of water by 10K -Acknowledgements +(B) Raising 2kg of water by 10K -OSTP and the NSTC thank the members of the Writing Team for their time, expertise, and significant -contributions to the report: Michelle Buchanan, Shelby Walker, Skip Vaughn, Gordon Hengst, Mariam -Elsayed, Aliya Iftikhar, and Cole Donovan. OSTP and the NSTC also thank the Oak Ridge National -Laboratory science writing team—Betsy Sonewald, Holly Haun, Marissa Mills, and Jackie Kerr—for their -efforts in shaping and finalizing the report, and the Institute for Defense Analysis, Science and -Technology Policy Institute team—Walter Valdivia, Gifford Wong, Kush Patel, Skandan Ananthasekar, -and Matthew Diasio—for their literature review and contributions. +(C) Raising 2kg of water by 20K -– 1 – +(D) All the same - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +1. More heat will be required to create a larger temperature change. +2. The more material you have to heat-up, the more energy it will take. -Table of Contents + Heat: Heat-energy required to change an object’s temperature -Executive Summary ........................................................................................................... 4 +• More heat is required to raise the temperature of a larger object. +• More heat is required to induce a larger temperature change. +• The exact amount of heat will depend on properties of the material. -Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 7 +– These are described the the “specific heat capacity”, c +– c is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of a given -Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure ....................... 10 +mass of a particular material by a certain temperature change -Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure .................................................................................... 11 +– The SI unit of c is: J/(kg*K) +– Typical values of c are ~100J/(kg*K) -Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities .................................................................................. 15 +Aluminum is 10X higher than this +(which is atypically large for a solid). +Meaning it is hard to heat-up. +Though, liquid water is even higher. -Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes ............................................................................................... 18 +• In a formula: -Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent .................................. 20 + Q=c*m*ΔT -Opportunities ................................................................................................................... 22 +• If the temperature of an object decreases, +it will release heat into an environment -Strategic Planning .................................................................................................................................. 23 +• This does not describe phase changes (e.g. liquid water to solid ice) -Identification of Gaps ............................................................................................................................. 23 + You want to heat a 1kg block of aluminum and 0.5kg of water by 20K. +Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy? -Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations ........................................................ 24 +7 -Sharing RDI Strategies ........................................................................................................................... 24 +(A) the aluminum block -Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination ................................................... 25 +(B) the water -Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise ................................................................. 25 +(C) both the same amount of heat -Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors ......................... 26 +1. Q= mcΔT +2. Qal= malcalΔT = (1kg)(900J/(kgK))(20K) = 18,000J +3. Qwater= mwatercwaterΔT = (0.5kg)(4000J/(kgK))(20K) = 40,000J +4. The water will require more heat. -Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs ...................................................................................... 26 +caluminum ≈ 900 J/(kg*K) +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 26 + Calorimetry: Measuring heat-energy transfer via temperature changes -– 1 – +• Suppose I want to measure how much heat-energy a chemical reaction - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +dumps into a fluid. How do I do it? -Abbreviations and Acronyms +• By measuring the temperature before and after the reaction, we get ΔT. +• If we measure the mass of our fluid and know the specific heat, -AI +then the heat energy is given by Q= mcΔT -Artificial Intelligence +• The energy “lost” by the chemical reaction is gained by the surrounding -ALMA +environment: -Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array + Qlost = Qgained -AOML +• A key detail is that the stuff you care about (the system), +e.g. the chemical reaction stuff + the water in this picture, +must be thermally isolated from the surrounding environment +(here by coffee cups) -NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory + Sect 14.2 -ARS + Two liters of water at 353K is added to 1.5-liters of water at 293K. +No energy is lost to the surroundings. +What is the final equilibrium temperature of the water? +Note, 1liter of water has a mass of 1kg. -Agricultural Research Service +8 -CERN +(A) 293 K -European Organization for Nuclear Research +(B) 323K -DoD +(C) 327K -DOE +(D) 353 K -Department of Defense +1. Qlost = Qgained +2. (mcΔT)2liters = (mcΔT)1.5liters +3. (2kg)(353K - Tfinal) = (1.5kg)(Tfinal - 293K) +4. 706kg*K - (2kg)Tfinal = (1.5kg)Tfinal - 439.5kg*K +5. 1,145.5kg*K = (3.5kg)Tfinal +6. Tfinal = (1,145.5kg*K)(3.5kg) ≈ 327K -Department of Energy +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -ECMWF European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting + You have two beakers of water, each with 1kg of water (c=4186J/(kgK)) at 293K. +You drop one 353K block of 1kg of metal into each beaker, but one block is made +of aluminum (c= 900J/(kgK)) and the other is made of copper (c= 386J/(kgK)). +Once each beaker reaches thermal equilibrium with the block, which beaker of +water has a higher temperature? -EIC +9 -EOP +(A) beaker with aluminum -EPA +(B) beaker with copper -Electron-Ion Collider +(C) both reach same equilibrium temperature -Executive Office of the President +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -Environmental Protection Agency +1. Aluminum has a larger specific heat capacity than copper. +2. This means it takes more energy to change the temperature of aluminum. +3. It also means that more energy is deposited by a change in temperature of the -FAST +aluminum block, relative to copper. -Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope +Math answer: +1. Qlost = Qgained +2. (mcΔT)block = (mcΔT)water +3. mblockcblock(Tblock - Tfinal) = mwatercwater(Tfinal - Twater) +4. mblockcblockTblock - mblockcblockTfinal = mwatercwaterTfinal - mwatercwaterTwater +5. mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater = (mwatercwater + mblockcblock)Tfinal +6. Tfinal = (mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater)/(mwatercwater + mblockcblock) -FY + Thermal Energy Storage -fiscal year +• Large objects can be used as energy reservoirs -FFRDCs +by storing energy as heat. -federally funded R&D centers +• Excess energy can be stored as heat to be +released later, or to smooth-out the power +distribution from a different energy source. +• E.g. store extra solar energy from the day or +wind energy from a windy day to use later +during the night. -NIST +• The earth itself is a large hot object -National Institutes of Standards and Technology +(where the heat comes from radioactive decays +inside the earth’s core). +This heat forms the basis of geothermal energy. -IT + A 1kg block of aluminum (c=900J/(kgK)) has an initial temperature of 300K. +The block is placed over an electric heater which provides 150W of power +for 300 seconds. +After this heating episode, what is the temperature of the aluminum block? -information technology +10 -JWST +(A) 50K -James Webb Space Telescope +(B) 300K -LBNF +(C) 350K -Long Baseline Neutrino Facility +(D) 450K -NAIRR National AI Research Resource +1. Q = mcΔT +2. ΔT = Q/mc +3. Q = P*t = 150W*300s = 45,000J +4. ΔT = (45,000J)/(1kg*900J/(kgK)) = 50K +5. Tfinal = Tinitial + ΔT = 300K + 50K = 350K. -NASA +1W = 1J/s -National Aeronautics and Space Administration + Phases: Definitions -NASEM National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine +• Solid: Stays the same shape +• Liquid: Takes the shape of the container*, but preserves volume +• Gas: Fills the volume of the container -NIH +*To be clear, +cats are not liquids -National Institutes of Health + Phase Changes -NIST +• Latent heat describes the amount of energy that needs to be absorbed to change phases -National Institute for Standards and Technology +or the amount of energy that is released upon a phase transition +due to breaking/forming molecular bonds -NMNH +• Energy must be absorbed (“endothermic”) for solid->liquid or liquid->gas +• Energy is released (“exothermic”) for gas->liquid or liquid->solid +• Latent Heat of Fusion, LFusion: solid ↔ liquid +• Latent heat of Vaporization, LVaporization: liquid ↔ gas -Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History + Latent Heat -NOAA +• Latent heat adds/removes heat during a phase transition: +• Following the heat added to bring water from ice to water-vapor: +𝑄𝑄 = 𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚 +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration +QA QB QC -NSF +QD -National Science Foundation +QE -NSTC +QA=mciceΔT +QB=mLfusion +QC=mcwaterΔT +QD=mLvaporization +QE=mcsteamΔT -National Science and Technology Council + How much energy is required to melt 0.5kg of ice? -OSTP +1 -Office of Science and Technology Policy +(A) 1045 J -PRC +(B) 2090 J -R&D +(C) 2093 J -RDI +(D) 16.7x104 J -People’s Republic of China +1. This is a phase transition: use Q=mL +Ice to liquid transition: Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +2. +3. Q=(0.5kg)*(33.533.5x104 J/kg) = 16.7x104 J -research and development + Calorimetry -research and development infrastructure +• Qlost-from-hot-object = Qgained-by-cold-object +• T is positive in this definition; i.e. subtract +the higher temperature from the lower one -RDT&E +• The calorimeter is a classic tool to take -research, development, test, and evaluation +advantage of this -SC +• For the example on the right, -DOE Office of Science +mwatercwaterΔTwater + mcupccupTcup = +mobjectcobjectTobject -– 2 – + Consider 1kg of material A (Blue) and material B (Green). +Which requires the most energy to change from the liquid to the +gas phase? - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +2 -S&T +(A) A (B) B (C) They require the same amount -science and technology +A longer horizontal stretch +corresponds to more added heat +to achieve a phase transition -STEM +C -science, technology, engineering, and math +º -USDA +p +m +e +T -U.S. Department of Agriculture +B -– 3 – +A - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +gas -Executive Summary +liquid -President Biden is delivering an "Infrastructure Decade" that will unlock access to economic -opportunity, create good paying jobs, boost domestic manufacturing, and grow America's economy -from the middle out and bottom up. As the President has said, “To have the best economy in the -world…you have to have the best infrastructure in the world.” That starts with investing in America and -building on our leadership in American research and development (R&D). +Solid -The America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote Excellence in Technology, Education, and -Science (COMPETES) Act of 2007 (“the Act”) requires that the National Science and Technology Council -(NSTC) produce an annual report “identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and -major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic -institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.”1 +Heat -This report focuses on the Act’s charge to address the growing deficiencies at federal and national -laboratories. This report provides an overview of those deficiencies and (short of additional -appropriations) makes suggestions about practices that could be more widely adopted throughout -government agencies. The report builds on the 2021 National Strategic Overview for Research and -Development Infrastructure,2 which provided a broad overview of the management and policy tools -used in the development and management of federal research and development infrastructure (RDI). + A 500g aluminum cylinder at T=20C is heated using steam at T=140C. +What is the minimum mass of the steam required to raise the +temperature of the aluminum cylinder by 40C? -In spite of the challenges facing the federal RDI ecosystem, since the last report was written there have -been several major developments in U.S. research and development infrastructure. For example, on -December 25, 2021, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) launched and has sent back unparalleled -insight into exoplanets, the origins of our universe, and more. The National Ignition Facility announced -that on December 5, 2022, it achieved fusion ignition for the first time. Major construction projects like -the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) and Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) have hit critical milestones -and announced significant international partnerships. On the planning and competition front, both the -Department of Energy (DOE) and Department of State have engaged in global surveys of international -RDI capabilities to help inform our future competitive landscape, and the DOE advisory committees are -undertaking a broad-based prioritization effort to identify critical capabilities through the next -decades. Significant progress has been made through community planning processes in all fields -relevant to research and development infrastructure (RDI), supported by our federal advisory -committees and the decadal planning processes undertaken by the National Academies of Sciences, -Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM). +3 -This report identifies four trends that can be found across federal research agencies. They are as -follows: +(A) 7mg -• Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure +(B) 0.7kg -• Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities +(C) 7kg -1 America COMPETES Act of 2007. Public Law 10-69, Section 1007. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/PLAW- +(D) 70kg -110publ69 +1. Qgained = Qlost +2. Heat Gained by Aluminum = Heat Lost by the Steam (1. Cooling, 2. Condensing, 3. Water Cooling) +3. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteamcsteam(ΔT)steam + msteamLvaporization + mwatercwater(ΔT)water +4. msteam = mwater (note csteam ≠ cwater) +5. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteam[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water] +6. msteam = mAlcAl(ΔT)Al /[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water] +7. msteam = [(0.5kg)(900J/kgC)(60C-20C)]/[2010J/kgC(140C-100C) + -2 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021. +2.2x106J/kg+ 4186J/kgC(100C-60C)] -https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf +8. msteam = 7.18x10-3kg ≈ 7mg -– 4 – +Aluminum: +cAl = 900 J/kg*C - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -• Widening Gaps in Global Science and Technology (S&T) Outcomes + A slug of copper (0.2kg) at 800C is immersed in 0.4kg of water at 80C. +The final temp is 100C. Part of the water boiled off as steam. +What was the mass of the water converted to steam? -• Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent +4 -To address these, the report identifies four areas that agencies can currently use within their existing -budgets and legal authorities to help address these deficiencies: +(A) 7mg -• Strategic Planning +(B) 8mg -o Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to -budget planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if -such investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable -impacts to mission execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are -difficult to attribute. +(C) 9mg -o The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of -facilities’ maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well- -defined prioritizations developed by each agency, and these assessments should be -updated regularly. +(D) 10mg -• +1. Qgained = Qlost +2. Heat lost by copper= Warms-up water + Converts some water to steam +3.mCucCu(ΔT)Cu = mwatercwater(ΔT)water + msteamLvaporization +4.msteam = [(mCucCu(ΔT)Cu) - (mwatercwater(ΔT)water)]/Lvaporization +5.msteam = [(0.2kg)(387J/kgC)(800C-100C) - (0.4kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C- -Identification of Gaps +80C)]/(2.26x106J/kg) -o Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning -efforts to identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research -community, including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in -academe, industry, and government. +6.msteam = 9.16 x10-3 kg ≈ 9mg … which is 9mL of liquid water -o Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in -U.S. dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those -capabilities are no longer possessed by the United States or its allies. +Copper: +cCu = 387 J/kg*C -• Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -o Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their -respective mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by -DOE’s Office of Science (SC) federal advisory committees, the State Department’s -survey of international facilities, and through the decadal survey process. + It takes 10 minutes for your stove burner to bring 2 quarts of water +(~1.9kg) to boiling (100C) from room temperature (20C). +What is the minimum power output of your stove burner? +(I.e. assume 100% efficiency of heat transfer) -o To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the -Florence Agreement Program3 and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate -both national and international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in- -kind contributions, materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and -technologies importation. +8 -• Sharing RDI Strategies +(A) 1060 W (B) 600 W (C) 4186 W (D) 640,000 W -o The NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure will coordinate -an interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, -with activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, +1. Power = Energy/Time +2. Energy = Heat = Q = mwatercwaterΔT = (1.9kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-20C) = 636,272J +3. Time = 10min=600s +4. Power= (636,272J)/(600s) = 1060 J/s = 1060 W -3 Statutory Import Programs,” (International Trade Administration, n.d.). www.trade.gov/statutory-import- +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kgC +csteam = 2010 J/kgC +cwater = 4186 J/kgC +ρwater = 1000kg/m3 -programs + You will NOT be asked about the material below on +any homework or exam. Therefore you CAN IGNORE +IT, if you like. -– 5 – +We had to trim the following from this year’s course content due to the pandemic. +However, I think some of you may be curious. - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security + A washer is made of some metal with some thermal coefficient of linear +expansion, α. +If the washer is heated, what happens to R1 and R2? -identifying gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and -international collaborations in facilities. +(A) R1 decreases, R2 increases -Being a science superpower carries the burden of supporting and maintaining the advanced underlying -infrastructure that supports the research and development enterprise. Congressional appropriations -have not kept pace with maintenance needs across multiple administrations, resulting in multibillion -dollar maintenance backlogs across multiple government agencies, forcing government managers into -a position where they must choose between executing science missions or maintaining their facilities. +(B) R1 increases, R2 increases -These challenges come at a time when the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and other parts of the world -are able to provide newer, state-of-the-art facilities offering improved access that attracts U.S. and -other international researchers.4 Without action to remedy the situation, deferred maintenance will -only increase in both cost and impact to the U.S. taxpayer and to many of the nation’s critical S&T -programs. +(C) R1 increases, R2 decreases -Finally, to support the continued development of a robust federal RDI ecosystem, agencies should -continue to support the opportunities mentioned in the 2021 National Strategic Overview:5 +(D) R1 decreases, R2 decreases -• Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. This means all linear dimensions increase. +3. The radii are linear dimensions, so both will increase. -• Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise +For instance, consider what would +happen if our washer were made- +up of separate square components. +All sides would lengthen and “R1” +and “R2” would both increase. -• Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors + Thermal Expansion of Solids: Volume expansion -• Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs +• Sometimes we want to consider how the volume of an object changes -4 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the +when we heat it. This is the volume expansion -BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf +• Volume expansion: ΔV = βV0ΔT +• The fractional change in volume is: ΔV/V0 = βΔT +• β is the coefficient of volume expansion (SI units: K-1) -5 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021, vi. +– For solids: β≈3α +– For liquids: More complicated, so look-up in table -https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf +Most materials expand in volume when +they heat-up. However, water doesn’t. -– 6 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Introduction - -“The race for technological dominance is -inextricably intertwined with evolving -geopolitics and is increasingly shaped by -broader political, economic, and societal -rivalries, particularly those associated with -the PRC’s rise. - -The United States has a rich history of investing -heavily in its S&T enterprise, its S&T workforce, as -well as RDI, including laboratories, specialized -facilities, and equipment. A focus on S&T expanded -during the 1950s as the Cold War escalated. Under -the GI Benefits Bill, thousands of returning veterans -were trained as scientists and engineers to establish -the nation’s leadership in S&T, and this growth -continued as the generation of baby boomers, who -grew up during the Sputnik era, pursued careers in -S&T. During the 1950s and 1960s, the federal -government greatly expanded research programs -across multiple agencies to catalyze growth in -research and development (R&D). Concurrently, the -U.S. government invested millions of dollars in -to -building -accommodate the nation’s growing R&D enterprise. -These facilities, constructed at federal agencies and -federally funded R&D centers (FFRDCs), included -new laboratory buildings and specialized facilities -and equipment, such as accelerators, ground- and -space-based telescopes, reactors, and X-ray sources, to study fundamental and applied science. This -investment helped build the nation’s research and development infrastructure (RDI), which is defined -as the “facilities or systems used by scientific and technical communities to conduct R&D or foster -innovation.”6 - -Amassing the resources to sustain broad -technology leadership, including the -concentration of human talent, -foundational knowledge, and supply -chains, requires decades of long-term -investment and visionary leadership. Those -focusing their resources today are likely to -be the technology leaders of 2040.” +*Note the change in density is tiny, so we +can usually get away with ignoring it, +until the phase-transition to ice happens. -“Global Trends 2040: A More Contested World,” -National Intelligence Council, 2021, 56. -http://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessm - -laboratories and other - -ents/GlobalTrends_2040.pdf - -facilities - -These substantial investments propelled the United States to global science leadership and led to -technology breakthroughs that served as a foundation for the nation’s economic growth and national -security. Even under the Congressionally-authorized levels in the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022, -Federal RDI construction and maintenance has not seen the same level of prioritization as in prior -decades. One result has been an aging of the infrastructure at federal research laboratories and -facilities that is reducing scientific output and, in some cases, impacting the ability of departments and -agencies to meet their mission needs. - -The existing federal scientific infrastructure served the nation well in the 20th century, enabling the -United States to become a global leader in scientific discovery, talent development, and innovation. -Having reached that pinnacle, however, many U.S. scientists and engineers are now faced with -conducting 21st century R&D in many facilities designed in the 1950s that cannot support modern -research and current laboratory practices in health and safety. Many do not have sufficient, clean, -reliable, and secure electrical power necessary to support today’s instrumentation and high- -performance computers. Some also lack modern information technology (IT) capabilities needed to - -6 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure,” Subcommittee on Research and - -Development Infrastructure of the National Science and Technology Council, October 2021, iii. -www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf - -– 7 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -protect against data loss and cyberattacks (assuming such networking capabilities are even present). -Older HVAC systems are inefficient and costly to operate, and buildings were not designed to allow the -strict environmental controls needed for today’s laboratory operations. In many cases, infrastructure -has reached end-of-life for systems that manage water and sewage, steam and chilled water -distribution, and electrical networks. - -Departments and agencies have reported that the average age of their facilities exceeds the 40- to 50- -year design life of most facilities, with half rated to be in poor or critical condition. Because these -facilities are operating well beyond their expected lifetimes, the risk of failures is high. The risk is further -compounded by aging water, steam, gas, electrical, and other types of distribution systems that are -often inefficient, difficult to repair, and do not meet modern safety codes. Failing infrastructure is -causing interruptions in research activities lasting weeks or months and has resulted in significant -setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to -research programs. Another critical issue facing federal RDI is that facilities built in the mid-20th century -generally cannot support the needs of modern research, which requires clean, reliable electrical power, -strictly controlled environments, robust internet networks, and integrated cybersecurity infrastructure, -among other requirements not found in older facilities. Further, investments in new scientific user -facilities are needed to provide U.S. researchers with world-leading capabilities. Without RDI designed -for advancing critical and emerging technologies, such as quantum information S&T, engineering -materials, biotechnologies, sensors, and microelectronics, U.S. leadership in these areas will be -seriously and adversely impacted. - -The challenges that the U.S. RDI enterprise is experiencing are not new and reflect decades of -inadequate funding due to deprioritizing maintenance at existing facilities, development of new -facilities, and decommissioning of outdated facilities. Further, these challenges are occurring -simultaneously with intensified S&T competition with other nations. This is especially true of the PRC, -which is vying to become the preferred partner on large RDI projects for other nations. For instance, the -PRC has invested in new RDI outside of its borders, building supercomputers,7 earth observing satellite -constellations,8 telescopes,9 and even biosafety labs10 in Africa and South America. In 2022, PRC -President Xi Jinping committed to increase the number of international laboratories built in countries -participating in the Belt and Road Initiative to 100 over five years.11 As the PRC develops such novel -capabilities, the pressure for U.S. scientists to seek partnerships in order to utilize those capabilities in -order to say at the top of their fields correspondingly increases. - -7 High speed computer donated to Tunisia's scientific research field. China Global Television Network, retrieved - -from YouTube, June 25, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzLJ8qi_XGk - -8 Special Report: China’s Space Collaboration with Africa: Implications and Recommendations for the United - -States. U.S. Institute of Peace, September 2023. https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/2023-09/sr- -524_china-space-collaboration-africa-implications-recommendations-for-us.pdf - -9 South America is embracing Beijing’s science silk road. Nature, May 8, 2019. - -https://www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-019-01127-4/index.html - -10 Africa CDC and China CDC Commit to Deepen their Cooperation. Africa Centres for Disease Control and - -Prevention. https://africacdc.org/news-item/africa-cdc-and-china-cdc-commit-to-deepen-their-cooperation/ - -11 China’s Belt and Road Initiative is boosting science — the West must engage, not withdraw. Nature, October - -24, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-03299-6 - -– 8 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Some international facilities possess certain advantages due to their structuring as international -organizations or state-supported commercial enterprises with stable, multiyear funding. Europe, in -particular, has substantial experience leveraging investments from multiple countries through -organizations like the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), the European Southern -Observatory, and the European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network. While many of these facilities, -like CERN, provide open research platforms that mirror the U.S. model of facility access based on merit, -other international facilities either require membership in an international treaty or fee-based access -for outsiders. Others, like the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) and -COSMO-SkyMed satellite constellation charge for access to products and services. This has direct -consequences for broad U.S. access to and utilization of significant RDI capabilities. The challenges -associated with U.S. participation in such facilities (to include limitations due to the appropriations -process and Anti-Deficiency Act) often means that the United States does not have a seat at the table -when setting the rules for international RDI governance, providing an opening for competitors like the -PRC and Russia to have greater say in the governance of platforms that may require the development -of novel or dual-use technology. - -In addition to buildings and facilities, other capabilities factor into the way the United States conducts -research. High-performance computers, combined with new modeling and data analysis techniques, -such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, allow large sets of diverse data to be assimilated, -analyzed, and modeled, accelerating the pace of discovery and development. For example, -computational tools can be used in conjunction with multiple types of structural data combined with -measured material properties to yield insight into the relationship of a material’s structure with its -properties. Such an approach would expedite the discovery of new materials critical to emerging -technologies, including electronics, quantum materials, and engineering materials. Similarly, data from -infrastructure distributed across the nation, such as multiple types of air, water, and soil monitors and -satellite data, could be rapidly analyzed and modeled to provide more complete and timely -assessments of ecosystems. - -While the United States continues to lead the world in many fields of S&T at present, urgent efforts must -be made to ensure that federal RDI is ready to serve the nation’s research community in the future. -Numerous efforts to develop world-leading R&D capabilities have been deployed or are underway. -These include the successful commissioning and deployment of JWST12 and major R&D facilities -construction projects like the EIC13 and LBNF hitting critical milestones14 and announcing international -partnerships. Designed to facilitate a shared national research infrastructure for responsible artificial -intelligence (AI) discovery and innovation for the broad research and education community, the -National AI Research Resource (NAIRR) launched its pilot on January 24, 2024, with 10 government - -12 “NASA’s Webb Telescope Is Now Fully Ready for Science.” (NASA. July 11, 2022). - -https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2022/07/11/nasas-webb-telescope-is-now-fully-ready-for-science/ - -13 “Electron-Ion Collider Set to Begin Long-Lead Procurements.” (Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 2, 2024). - -https://www.bnl.gov/newsroom/news.php?a=121812 - -14 “Excavation of colossal caverns for Fermilab’s DUNE experiment completed.” (Fermi National Accelerator - -Laboratory. February 9, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/02/excavation-of-colossal-caverns-for-fermilabs- -dune-experiment-completed/ - -– 9 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security + You fill-up your 12-gallon fuel tank in your sedan up to the brim and +forget to put on your gas cap. Your friend makes the same mistake after +filling-up the 18-gallon fuel tank in her truck to the brim. +It gets really hot outside and the gasoline heats-up. +Who loses the most gas? -agency partners and 25 nongovernment partners.15 DOE/SC’s federal advisory committees have -released international benchmarking studies comparing RDI capabilities of the United States with -those in other parts of the world. The Department of State conducted a survey assessing planned RDI -capabilities issued to all diplomatic and consular posts. +5 -Major prioritization and assessment efforts, such as the 2023 Particle Physics Projects Prioritization -Panel report16 have been released. Agencies continue to actively commission RDI prioritization -exercises from their relevant federal advisory committees and through the decadal survey process, -where agencies seek community input via NASEM. Within the context of the RDI subcommittee, the -Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections on November 29, 2023 released the “The Unique -Role of Federal Scientific Collections,” assessing the varied ways that federal scientific collections have -served the nation in diverse areas of American life.17 Historically, these activities have focused primarily -on addressing the immediate scientific needs of the community; additional effort could be given to -assessing and enhancing the competitive position of the United States. +(A) You do -To sustain world S&T leadership, the United States must continue to make strategic investments to -maintain and renew federal facilities and supporting infrastructure, as well as phase out and -decommission federal RDI that is no longer needed. These critical investments in new, modern facilities -will underpin S&T innovation well into the future. These investments are also vital for training the next -generation of U.S. scientists and engineers who will conduct research, develop new technical -innovations, and manufacture new products. The challenge is to maintain a consistent and intentional -revitalization of the U.S. RDI while balancing competing needs and ensuring well-coordinated -prioritization decisions. +(B) Your friend does -Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure +(C) You both lose the same amount -The Act requires that the National Science and Technology Council produce an annual report -“identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and major instrumentation located at -federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic institutions that are widely accessible for -use by researchers in the United States.” This report answers that requirement. - -Four issues put the future success of the nation’s R&D enterprise at risk: Aging and Inadequate Research -Infrastructure, Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities, Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes, -and Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent. Together, these -issues present a serious threat to the country’s continued scientific innovation, output, and global -leadership in S&T. Understanding the context and consequence of these issues can shape action plans -for revitalizing the nation’s RDI. - -15 “Democratizing the future of AI R&D: NSF to launch National AI Research Resource pilot.” (National Science - -Foundation, January 24, 2024). https://new.nsf.gov/news/democratizing-future-ai-rd-nsf-launch-national-ai - -16 “Exploring Our Quantum Universe.” (Report of the 2023 Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel, - -December, 2023). https://www.usparticlephysics.org/2023-p5-report/assets/pdf/P5Report2023_121023- -DRAFT_single-pages.pdf - -17 “The Unique Role of Federal Scientific Collections: Infrastructure Generating Benefits, Serving Diverse Agency - -Missions” (A report of the Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections). -https://smithsonian.figshare.com/articles/book/The_Unique_Role_of_Federal_Scientific_Collections_Infrastr -ucture_Generating_Benefits_Serving_Diverse_Agency_Missions/24559996/1 - -– 10 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure - -Outdated and deficient RDI across the federal government is threatening U.S. leadership in R&D and -impeding technology breakthroughs. - -Aging infrastructure in many federal research laboratories and facilities is impacting the ability of -federal agencies to meet their current missions. Many facilities are rated as being in very poor condition. - -• A 2023 survey of Department of Energy (DOE) facilities at its 17 national laboratories showed -that the average age of these facilities was 46 years, close to the end of the planned 40- to 50- -year design life. This study further stated that nearly 40 percent of DOE facilities have been rated -as substandard or inadequate to serve DOE’s mission.18 - -• A survey of research facilities at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) -showed that 73 percent of facilities are 60 to 70 years old, and over 60 percent of the square -footage is classified as in “poor to critical condition.”19 - -• A 2019 report noted, “The buildings and facilities at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) -Bethesda Campus are in need of significant improvement and upgrading to sustain their current -mission and ongoing functionality. The 12 million facility square feet have an average Condition -Index of 83.3, which is considered poor.”20 - -• - -In an annual report to Congress in 2024, the Department of Defense’s (DoD) unfunded research, -development, test, and evaluation (RDT&E) infrastructure requirements were shown to have -grown significantly since annual reporting began in 2018, putting the military at risk of losing -its technological superiority.21 - -• A 2024 National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) report stated that 75 percent of -its facilities are beyond their designed lifetime, and as of 2022, had an estimated deferred -maintenance backlog of $3 billion.22 - -• The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Agricultural Research Service (ARS) has -approximately 3,000 facilities and structures in its inventory, with an average age of over 48 -years, and a $1.6 billion deferred maintenance backlog. - -Failures due to aging RDI can result in costly and significant interruptions in research activities lasting -weeks or months. For example, failures over a nine-month period that led to inadequate back-up power -and power conditioning at one NIST research facility cost an estimated $9 million and loss of 47,000 - -18 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure - -19 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 31. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684 - -20 Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical - -Research Environment, National Academies Press eBooks, 2019. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483 - -21 U.S. Department of Defense Fiscal Year 2025 Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction -Projects. February 2024. Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Report to -Congress on Section 2806 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91). - -22 NASA’s FY 2024 Volume of Integrated Performance. www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/fiscal-year- - -2024-volume-of-integrated-perfomance.pdf - -– 11 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -researcher hours.23 These failures can be compounded by the need to repair outdated equipment with -scarce replacement parts as well as a lack of personnel familiar with older components and systems. -These older systems also lack modern safety and security protection features that are standard in -equipment purchased and installed today. For example, modern electrical switchgear often -incorporates optical arc flash reduction systems, and today’s natural gas distribution systems have -built-in safety features absent in older systems. Moreover, the configurations of old steam, chilled -water, natural gas, compressed air, sewer, and other types of support systems make it difficult to -maintain sections of pipe or valves without extended outages. Another looming issue is that older -buildings do not meet today’s more stringent seismic standards, and the failure of susceptible buildings -could indefinitely halt research activities. Finally, many of these older buildings are contaminated with -materials that pose significant environmental and health concerns, including radioactive materials, -beryllium, asbestos, and lead. - -Today’s research is vastly different than that conducted when these buildings were designed in the mid- -20th century; thus, even well-maintained facilities do not meet the requirements of modern research. -First, older buildings were designed with laboratories that accommodate a lead investigator and a few -support staff, whereas today’s science is most often conducted by larger, collaborative teams of -investigators who require flexible space that can be readily reconfigured to meet changing research -directions. Second, research today is governed by robust environmental, health, and safety standards -that were not in place when these buildings were designed. For example, 50 years ago, nearly all -experiments were conducted at open laboratory benches, and laboratories included only a limited -number of ventilation hoods. Today, research standards require hoods for nearly all chemistry, -molecular biology, materials, and nanoscience experimental procedures. Also, updated fire codes -restrict the types and quantities of chemicals and gases that can be stored and used in a single fire zone; -older buildings were designed with a limited number of fire zones, and some have only one designated -fire zone for an entire building encompassing thousands of square feet. Further, modern research has -very different demands for utilities and other infrastructure that were not anticipated even a decade -ago. For example, outdated and inefficient HVAC and electrical systems are incapable of controlling -temperature and humidity within the exacting requirements of sensitive equipment, such as ultra-fast -laser systems and microscopes used in materials science and biology studies. Often, this type of -sensitive equipment also requires specialized environments with low vibration and electromagnetic -interference. - -In addition to these concerns, the cost to maintain aging facilities, even without bringing them up to -modern standards, continues to grow. For example, in annual DoD reports to Congress on RDT&E -revitalization, these costs were estimated to be $4.7 billion in 2019, growing to $7.7 billion in 2024.24 -Similarly, a 2019 study commissioned by the NIH and led by NASEM reported that the backlog of - -23 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 44. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684 - -24 Report to Congress on Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction Projects. February 2019. -Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Section 2806 of the National Defense -Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91) - -– 12 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -maintenance and repair for NIH’s Bethesda campus was $1.3 billion and growing rapidly.25 At the end -of fiscal year (FY) 2023, the Bethesda backlog had grown to $3.4 billion and, taking into account all NIH -sites in Maryland, Montana, and North Carolina, the backlog was reported to be $3.8 billion at the end -of FY 2023. The NASEM study triggered Congressional interest, which resulted in increases in NIH’s -Buildings and Facilities appropriation from $200 million in FY 2019 to $350 million in FY 2023. However, -even at the higher investment amount, the backlog continues to increase. - -Construction and renovation of research infrastructure provides the opportunity to incorporate agile, -efficient, and resilient designs that can adapt to new technologies, new operating standards, new work -environments, and changing missions. Effective modernization and design will lead to savings in -energy, cost, and space while improving laboratory functionality and capability (see sidebar “Modern -Chemical and Materials Science Building”). - -A successful renovation of an older building is exemplified by Building 1 on the NIST campus in Boulder, -CO, a structure that was dedicated by President Eisenhower in the 1950s. After renovation, a wing of -this building became the new home to quantum information science and technology research, -supporting experiments that demonstrated quantum entanglement of microresonators, an innovation -recognized as the Physics World 2021 Breakthrough of the Year. This research could never have been -accomplished in the original laboratory, which lacked necessary environmental controls for these -sensitive experiments.26 - -Some agencies have already taken steps and devised innovative solutions to address inadequate RDI. -For example, DOE’s Office of Science (SC) instituted the Science Laboratories Infrastructure program, -which invests over $300 million annually to transform and modernize foundational infrastructure at -its national laboratories. To facilitate this strategic program, the DOE Laboratory Operations Board,27 -which includes federal and national laboratory representatives, assesses facilities and infrastructure -across the DOE national laboratory complex. These enterprise-wide assessments result in a rigorous -and consistent analysis of the condition, utilization, and functionality of the facilities and -infrastructure that are most critical to accomplishing the mission. Building on these assessments, SC -works with each of its laboratories to develop comprehensive campus strategies used to establish -infrastructure priorities. - -25 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital -Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical Research Environment. Washington, DC: The -National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483 - -26 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 34, https://doi.org/10.17226/26684. - -27 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure - -– 13 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Modern Chemical and Materials Science Building - -Chemical and Materials Sciences Building constructed in 2011 at -Oak Ridge National Laboratory. [Courtesy ORNL] - -With more than 300,000 square feet, Building 4500S at DOE’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory was -built in the 1960s to house dozens of materials science and chemistry laboratories with associated -offices. As was typical during this era, the labs in this facility were constructed with only one or two -chemical hoods and a handful of electrical circuits. HVAC systems were designed to condition -outside air and exhaust it through the chemical hoods, turning over the entire volume of air in the -building at a rate of 30 times per hour; this made the building exceptionally expensive to operate. - -A new Chemical and Materials Sciences Building was constructed in 2011 and received Gold LEED -certification by employing many energy saving innovations, such as reducing air flow in hoods not -being actively used. To meet modern research requirements, these laboratories contain up to six -hoods for use by teams of researchers and many electrical circuits and internet connections to -accommodate modern laboratory equipment and computers. Compared to the single fire zone in -the old building, the new building was designed with multiple fire zones and special storage rooms -on each floor to facilitate high chemical loading and reduce fire hazards caused by storing chemicals -in the laboratories. - -These features allowed lab space to be consolidated with a 30 percent savings in space compared -to the old facility, while adding new functionalities, such as highly controlled environments required -for laser spectroscopy and imaging. The labs were also designed to be readily reconfigurable to -accommodate changing programs, with all benches equipped with wheels and special utility hook- -ups enabling their easy removal. Importantly, the building was also designed with features that -support collaborations across disciplines that are critical for today’s scientific enterprise. As a result, -an influx of both student and staff researchers have joined the research programs of the -organizations in this modern laboratory building. - -Similarly, the DoD has a variety of authorities to assist in the modernization and revitalization of its RDI. -One of these, 10 U.S.C § 4123, also known as “FLEX-4,” authorizes laboratories to allocate between two -percent and four percent of their total RDT&E funds toward workforce development, basic research, -technology transition, and repair of laboratory infrastructure and equipment. DoD laboratories can use -revitalization and recapitalization projects to adapt facilities and infrastructure to support new - -– 14 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -technology missions. Since the inception of the FLEX-4 Program in 2009, DoD laboratories have invested -more than $4 billion across the four categories, funding improvements not possible otherwise. - -Since 2012, USDA ARS has reviewed its laboratory RDI and developed a long-term plan for future capital -investments, as outlined in “Capital Investment Strategy” (CIS) reports. Since 2013, ARS has adopted -the U.S. Corps of Engineers BUILDER assessment program28 to conduct assessments and assign a -condition index to each facility assessed. This index takes into consideration facility age, capacity, -safety and health issues, security, time since last repair/renovation, new capabilities needed, and -current and future research priorities. Since 2015, ARS has received funding to modernize 30 projects of -the 138 outlined in the most recent ARS CIS update. - -Many other agencies, such as the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have developed plans for -building renovations, but due to the lack of funds are unable to complete needed renovations at many -of their laboratory sites. - -In summary, aging infrastructure can cause research setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, -and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to research programs. Further, outdated RDI -impedes research that requires specialized infrastructure for sensitive experiments and equipment to -advance tomorrow’s technologies. Some agencies have taken steps to address these issues by -developing processes for prioritizing needs and by funding facility modernization and revitalization; -however, more fully addressing these needs will require strategic planning across the federal R&D -enterprise, as well as increased budgetary planning. - -Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities - -Aging and inadequate federal facilities can impact research efforts of government, universities, and -industry. - -Federal laboratories are home to many types of RDI that provide unique capabilities needed to sustain -the United States as a world leader in S&T. In addition to research facilities that support specific agency -missions, federal agencies also host specialized facilities that serve the nation. These critically -important facilities are not found in the private sector or academia due to their high construction and -maintenance costs, as well as their support of highly specialized equipment. Such equipment includes -the world’s largest vacuum chamber at NASA Glenn Research Center, radiation measurement and -calibration laboratories at NIST, DOE’s suite of scientific user facilities, and the National Science -Foundation’s (NSF) Antarctic research stations (see sidebar “Improving Antarctic Infrastructure”). - -Many of the nation’s unique federal research assets are operating well beyond their design lifetimes -and RDI failures can have a serious impact on the nation’s research enterprise. For example, in the -summer of 2022, the underground utility distribution system failed on the NIST campus in Gaithersburg, -MD, along with HVAC systems, resulting in a shutdown that lasted 14 days and impacted nearly all 1,700 -campus laboratories. The effects of this shutdown lasted much longer, compromising NIST’s ability to -provide measurement standards and support to multiple federal agencies, the private sector, and -universities. In turn, the research conducted by these customers, who require standards for quantum - -28 BUILDER Sustainment Management System. https://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/Media/Fact-Sheets/Fact- - -Sheet-Article-View/Article/476728/builder-sustainment-management-system/ - -– 15 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -science and technology, radiation physics, and other important traceable measurements, were -significantly delayed. - -National laboratories have long documented the broader impact of facilities investments on local -economies.29 While it is generally acknowledged that certain facilities have developed reputations as -training grounds for scientists and engineers in specific fields, relatively less attention has been paid to -the impact of facility degradation, incidents, and changes in facilities’ reputation on local universities, -business, and other stakeholder communities. Given the importance of RDI to local economies, as well -as their distribution around the country in diverse communities, greater attention to that relationship -may be warranted. - -Impact of Investment on the U.S. National Collections - -Helianthus annuus [Courtesy NMNH] - -The United States National Herbarium is one of the world’s largest and most diverse botanical -collections, accounting for more than 4 million specimens. The Smithsonian National Museum of -Natural History’s (NMNH) multi-year, approximately 7-million-dollar effort to digitize the herbarium -resulted in 3.8 million new specimen images, 2.8 million new label transcriptions, and over 80,000 -new taxonomic names added to the data catalog. This provides full access to the collection using -digital technology and shared online platforms. Full digitization also improves management and -enhances the long-term preservation of these fragile collections. Reliance on an industrial approach -rather than specimen by specimen actions reduced the average cost per specimen of digitization -from $3.32 and 555 seconds to $1.85 and 102 seconds. Deep learning tools have already been used -to identify past specimen preservation methods that are hazardous prompting remediation efforts. -The 500 percent increase in the past five years in web inquiries demonstrates that digital -accessibility is serving research: in 2015, 14 million botanical records were queried via the online -page. In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, this number exploded to 70 million records queried. - -29 “Fermilab drives economic growth in Illinois and South Dakota.” (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, -March 28, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/03/fermilab-drives-economic-growth-in-illinois-and-south- -dakota/ - -– 16 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Improving Antarctic Infrastructure - -Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station at dawn. [Courtesy Raffaela Busse and -the National Science Foundation. Reused under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.] - -The National Science Foundation (NSF) oversees three facilities in Antarctica that support important -and unique experiments sponsored by multiple U.S. agencies, ranging from astronomy to -environmental studies. However, maintaining and operating infrastructure at these facilities present -unique and costly challenges due to the harsh environment in Antarctica. For example, buildings are -in danger of becoming buried in snow, resulting in structural damage, and even collapse. -Environmental satellite grounds systems, which are crucial for weather forecasting, flight planning, -aviation safety, station operations, and science support, are beyond their end-of-life timelines and -in danger of failure. Even fuel transport to the South Pole Station has become more challenging due -to aging and increasingly unreliable equipment for traverses that carry 100,000 gallons of fuel -annually. - -A 2012 NSF report noted that “U.S. activities in Antarctica are very well managed but suffer from an -aging infrastructure, lack of a capital budget, and the effects of operating in an extremely unforgiving -environment. …when the…[NSF]…and its contractors must choose between repairing a roof or -conducting science, science usually prevails. Only when the science is seriously disrupted because -the roof begins to collapse will it be replaced; until then, it is likely only to be repaired. ...The status -quo is simply not an option ...Failure to [recapitalize]... will simply increase logistics costs until they -altogether squeeze out funding for science. A ten percent increase in the cost of logistics will -consume 40 percent of the remaining science budget.” - -NSF established a recapitalization program of $60 million a year that comprises a portfolio of -investments to mitigate aging infrastructure, assure safe working conditions, enhance operational -efficiencies, and support continued U.S. science leadership on the continent. - -More and Better Science in Antarctica Through Increased Logistical Effectiveness: Report of the U.S. Antarctic Program -Blue Ribbon Panel, 2012. www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/usap_special_review/usap_brp/rpt/antarctica_07232012.pdf - -– 17 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes - -Lagging U.S. RDI investment compared to other nations can erode U.S. leadership and influence in science -and technology. - -Significant investments in specialized RDI catalyzed U.S. scientific innovations in the 20th century. -These investments included large particle accelerators, wind tunnels, X-ray and neutron sources, and -large outdoor test ranges, as well as state-of-the-art research laboratories. With these capabilities, the -United States dominated for decades innovations that fueled the American economy, increased -security, and improved quality of life—including advances in computers and personal electronics, -breakthroughs in healthcare, and development of electric vehicles, among others. Today, however, -increasing investments in RDI in other nations, if unanswered, may lead to loss of U.S. global leadership. - -An example of the threat to U.S. S&T leadership is clearly seen in the area of high-performance -computing and computer science over the last decade. As shown in Figure 1, in 2015, the United States -contributed the most supercomputers30 to the Top500 list globally, backed by strong support from the -federal government for the development of leading high-performance computers. However, only seven -years later, in 2022, the PRC surpassed the United States in number of supercomputers on the Top500 -list, due in part to the PRC’s increased investment in R&D. The impact of the PRC’s investment is readily -apparent when comparing research output: the PRC is the top overall producer of S&E publications and -international patents and has the greatest knowledge- and technology-intensive (KTI) manufacturing -output.31 The United States remains the world leader in KTI services. - -Figure 1. Comparison of the 500 most powerful commercially-available supercomputers per country (from -www.top500.org). - -30 Supercomputers are used to model and simulate complex, dynamic systems that would be too expensive, - -impractical or impossible to physically demonstrate. Supercomputers are changing the way scientists explore -the evolution of our universe, biological systems, weather forecasting and even renewable energy. See more -at https://www.energy.gov/supercomputing-and-exascale - -31 “Translation: U.S. and Global Science, Technology, and Innovation Capabilities.” The State of U.S. Science and -Engineering 2024. Figures 21, 25. https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20243/translation-u-s-and-global-science- -technology-and-innovation-capabilities - -– 18 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Maintaining and improving U.S. computing infrastructure is critical for many applications. For example, -accurate and timely climate and weather models are critical to missions that protect and support the -U.S. economy and national security. However, evidence shows that the National Oceanic and -Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA’s) Global Forecast System lags behind the capabilities of systems -developed by other countries, such as the ECMWF.32 - -A 2021 NOAA Advisory Board report noted the lack of investment in computing power “indicates that -not only are we underserving the American public, but also that the United States has the potential to -provide more accurate and reliable weather information. The public benefits of NOAA regaining a -leadership role would be increased forecast accuracy, longer lead times, and finer-scale detail for -severe weather, flooding and hurricanes.”33 Further, many agencies including NOAA34 and DOE35 have -highlighted the growing demand to provide expanded and updated computing infrastructure to -complement experimental capabilities to facilitate efficient data sharing, integration, and analysis. - -In August 2023, the Defense Science Board reported in its briefing to the Office of Science and -Technology Policy (OSTP) on Balancing Openness and Security, “China (the PRC) is outpacing the U.S. -in global competition for key emerging technologies, leading in 37 out of 44 critical and emerging -technologies (e.g., electric batteries, hypersonics, quantum computing, and others). Western -democracies risk losing the global competition for research output and technological innovation.”36 -Leadership in this competition is enabled by state-of-the-art RDI, such as X-ray and neutron sources, -nanoscience facilities, biotechnology centers, accelerators, and specialized testing facilities, among -others (see sidebar “Broader Impacts of Accelerator Science and Technology”). - -Proactively planning and prioritizing federal infrastructure improvements and modernization can -benefit from benchmarking with other countries. For example, the Basic Energy Science Advisory -Committee, tasked by DOE/SC with benchmarking U.S. capabilities in basic research, concluded that -“advanced research facilities in the United States funded by DOE’s Office of Basic Energy Sciences are -world leading … largely because of long-range strategic planning, ongoing stewardship, and -investments.”37 This type of planning can protect the nation’s research enterprise and have far-reaching -effects. If DOE failed to develop and maintain capabilities at its five X-ray sources, the impact could -affect the 10,000 users served annually, which include scientists from universities, government, and - -32 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 72. - -sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf . - -33 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 22. - -sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf - -34 “NOAA ‘Omics Strategy: Strategic Application of Transformational Tools” (NOAA, February 2020). - -sciencecouncil.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/2020-Omics-Strategy.pdf - -35 “Basic Energy Sciences Network Requirements Review Final Report” (DOE/SC, November 2023). - -science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2023/ESnet-Report.pdf - -36 “Balancing Openness and Security Across the DoD Academic Research Enterprise” (Defense Science Board, - -July 2023), 11, apps.dtic.mil/sti/trecms/pdf/AD1212739.pdf - -37 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the - -BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. -science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf - -– 19 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -industry. For example, the pharmaceutical industry is highly dependent on X-ray crystallography for the -development of new drugs, and more than 30,000 samples are characterized annually on just a single -beamline at the DOE Advanced Photon Source. - -Broader Impacts of Accelerator S&T - -Accelerators broadly impact science, industry, medicine, defense, and other sectors. Annually, -particle accelerators are used to treat more than 5 million cancer patients; ion implantation is -used to produce $300 billion worth of semiconductors; and e-beam irradiation is used to -manufacture over $85 billion worth of consumer products, such as tires and insulation. - -Advances in accelerator technologies are also critical for maintaining the nation’s leadership in -many high energy and nuclear physics experiments, as well as X-ray and neutron sources used -broadly by the scientific community in studies on nanomaterials, vehicle batteries, -pharmaceuticals, and more. - -For years, the United States has been a major supporter of accelerator technology advances, but -its leadership position is being surpassed now by other nations. For example, growth in ultra-high -intensity lasers, an accelerator-based technology, has been stagnant in the United States while -development has increased significantly in Europe and Asia in the last several years. - -Maintaining leadership in this area requires investing in new accelerator infrastructure that can be -used to develop new capabilities and applications. Investment is also needed in training and -retaining experts who can create, operate, and further advance these technologies. - -“Ultra-High Intensity Lasers Facilities Across the Globe Over Time,” 2020. www.icuil.org/downloadss/laser-labs.html - -In some cases, optimizing RDI investments may include establishing international collaborations that -benefit the U.S. S&T enterprise. For example, NSF partnered with S&T funding agencies from Europe, -Japan, and Chile to build the Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array (ALMA)—the most powerful -telescope at these wavelengths in the world. Similarly, NASA partnered with the European and -Canadian space agencies and 14 additional countries to build the JWST. Additionally, such -collaborations offer untapped opportunities to enhance U.S. leadership. - -Proactive planning and prioritization of new and upgraded RDI is needed to ensure the nation’s global -S&T leadership is not eclipsed. Strategies are needed to plan for and prioritize future RDI investments, -including forming collaborations with domestic and international partners. - -Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent - -The declining state of infrastructure is affecting the United States’ ability to recruit and retain scientific -talent. - -Departments, agencies, and federal advisory committees report that sub-optimal research -infrastructure and project cancellations are factors that contribute to the loss of S&T talent in the -federal workforce, impacting researchers at every stage of their careers.38 These conditions affect - -38 “Can the United States Maintain its Leadership in High Performance Computing? (A report by the ASCAC - -Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021). 49. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/ascr/ascac/pdf/charges/2023/Report_20230627.pdf - -– 20 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -students and post-doctoral researchers when they cannot achieve an acceptable rate of productivity -due to aging RDI, which limits their career opportunities. More established researchers are affected -when their productivity and impact declines, preventing them from advancing their agency’s mission -and reaching their career goals. Together, these factors can affect the morale of researchers and drive -them away from the federal research arena. - -The research and often awe-inspiring technologies at the center of our federal laboratories have -inspired generations to pursue technical careers and to push the boundaries of human knowledge, -contributing to U.S. S&T leadership. For instance, NASA supports approximately 2,000 interns, annually, -at all NASA facilities. DOE/SC hosts thousands of students, accounting for about one third of total -unique users at scientific user facilities each year. In 2023, the Smithsonian Institution hosted 510 -interns and 355 fellows at its science units. Altogether, federal RDI facilities make up an important -contribution to developing STEM talent around the country. - -Despite this, external assessments of some federal laboratories have identified major concerns in the -workforce due to recruitment and retention problems which are straining existing staff to their limits. -This can affect the nation’s ability to attract and retain a strong federal S&T workforce, which can in -turn impact leadership and innovation in critical and emerging technologies, such as artificial -intelligence, biotechnology, quantum information S&T, and microelectronics, particularly as other -countries develop similar or more advanced capabilities. Breakthroughs in these areas are imperative -for the development of new products and jobs that fuel the nation’s economy. Solving the RDI problem -should help maintain the federal S&T workforce and R&D leadership to produce innovations critical to -the nation’s economy, security, and well-being. - -One example of how aging infrastructure is impacting the ability to attract and retain researchers is -NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory (AOML). This laboratory, housed in a -building that opened in 1973, is responsible for real-time hurricane-related measurements and -associated activities that include hurricane science, model development, sustained observational -platforms, and maintaining the global oceanographic climate data record. However, the 2019 AOML -Laboratory Review Summary Report stated, “AOML’s physical infrastructure is no longer sufficient to -support cutting-edge science and to attract a world-class scientific workforce.”39 (see Figure 2). - -39 “2019 AOML Laboratory Review Summary Report” (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, - -November 19, 2019), 17, www.aoml.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/AOML-2019-Review-Summary- -Report-FINAL-.pdf - -– 21 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Figure 2. “When AOML started [in 1973], keypunch cards seemed cutting edge, and leisure suits seemed -appropriate for the office.” [Courtesy NOAA] - -Foreign RDI investments are also prompting some U.S. researchers to leave the country to build state- -of-the-art facilities and to find longer-term employment. For example, U.S. diplomats reported in 2018 -that numerous fusion energy researchers and technologists began traveling to the PRC following the -shutdown of several U.S.-based magnetic confinement fusion facilities. U.S. scientists, technologies, -and companies often engage with international facilities where the U.S. government is not present, -such as the Extreme Light Infrastructure (ELI) in Czechia, Hungary, and Romania and the Square -Kilometer Array (SKA) in South Africa to stay on the leading edge of their respective fields. - -The importance of planned investments in maintaining, upgrading, and building (where warranted) -new RDI cannot be overstated, particularly given that many infrastructures may require decades of -planning for successful execution. Such efforts require the development of specialized workforces -around individual projects. Likewise, unexpected cancellations and inadequate communication with -foreign partners can affect the reputation of the United States as a reliable partner, limiting the -willingness of foreign experts to provide their unique expertise to major undertakings.40 Without -significant efforts to address these issues, the nation risks losing the S&T workforce that is critical for -maintaining its role as a global leader in S&T and innovation, which will have far-reaching impacts on -the future economy and security of the United States. - -Opportunities - -Agencies must continue to revitalize RDI critical to the nation’s S&T enterprise, otherwise U.S. RDI will -continue to deteriorate while costs for maintenance and replacement will continue to escalate. -Although agencies need to plan and prioritize investments based on individual needs and budgets, the -following four opportunities—Strategic Planning, Identification of Gaps, Benchmarking International -RDI and Identifying Collaborations, and Sharing RDI Strategies—represent high-level steps required to -ensure the nation’s RDI is prepared to meet future U.S. S&T needs. - -40 “The Path to Global Discovery: U.S. Leadership and Partnership in Particle Physics.” (A report of the High - -Energy Physics Advisory Panel. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/hep/hepap/pdf/202203/International_Benchmarking_HEPAP_2023112.pdf - -– 22 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Strategic Planning - -Assessment and prioritization of investments are necessary to maintain and renew legacy facilities, as well -as establish new infrastructure to realize future S&T advances. - -It is clear that the overall state of federal research facilities will continue to require substantial -investments to meet future research needs. Federal agencies and departments must prioritize and -develop short- and long-term strategies for addressing their RDI needs, including sufficient -recapitalization, operations, and maintenance investments in facilities, and disposition of excess -facilities, along with a strong workforce. As part of strategic planning for RDI, agencies should also -develop and maintain standards for assessing total facility and infrastructure costs, including -construction, annual operating costs, maintenance, and renovations, and regular recapitalization. For -example, modernization efforts should address updated requirements for safety (e.g., changes in -building codes), security, and specialized research. Where applicable, agencies should ensure a -proactive lifecycle approach to real property management that aligns with the federal Real Property -Reform Act of 2016, the associated Government Accountability Office framework. Agencies can also -look to external resources, strategies, and best practices like the 2023 NASEM report titled “Strategies -to Renew Federal Facilities.” The specific approaches employed may differ for the various agencies and -their specific RDI requirements. For instance, planning for construction and lifecycle costs of a -conventional laboratory building is quite different than the planning needed for a high-energy -accelerator-based facility that serves thousands of users annually. - -• Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to budget -planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if such -investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable impacts to mission -execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are difficult to attribute. - -• The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of facilities’ -maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-defined prioritizations -developed by each agency, and these assessments should be updated regularly. - -Identification of Gaps - -Agencies and departments should identify gaps in RDI needs and opportunities for collaborations with -other federal, industrial, academic, and international partners. - -Effective planning for RDI first requires input from the federal and non-federal research community, as -well as RDI managers, to help reveal or underscore serious gaps and to identify the potential impact of -these gaps on the U.S. federal S&T enterprise and agency mission execution. This input can be gathered -by various means, such as surveys, requests for information, workshops, and other avenues. For -example, federal research agencies frequently convene researchers from the national and international -communities to identify needs in research infrastructure, such as electron and X-ray sources, -computers, distributed measurement networks, sequencing centers, and other key areas. This gap -analysis could also be used to identify potential partnerships—with other agencies and departments, -the private sector, universities, and international partners—that could provide opportunities for cost- -sharing and result in more impactful RDI that serves a larger research community. - -• Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning efforts to -identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research community, - -– 23 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in academe, industry, -and government. - -• Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in U.S. -dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those capabilities are no -longer possessed by the United States or its allies. - -Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations - -Regular benchmarking should be performed to assess the global position of U.S. RDI and to identify -opportunities for international collaborations. - -Understanding the nation’s global standing in S&T is critical for prioritizing RDI investments and -identifying areas for international collaboration. Benchmarking studies should include documented -data on relevant topics, such as global development of large-scale and mid-scale research facilities, -research outputs and impact, and workforce trends. These assessments would provide foundational -data for the Quadrennial Science and Technology Review and National Science and Technology -Strategy, as well as for other reports and activities related to global competitive assessments. - -These benchmarking studies will also identify opportunities to develop new collaborations and -enhance existing partnerships as well as highlight strategic investments to restore and preserve U.S. -leadership in critical areas while strengthening federal RDI and the scientific workforce. For -international collaborations, processes must be established to reduce the administrative burdens often -associated with developing cutting-edge scientific capabilities, including the importation of materials -and technologies. Efforts should also be made to welcome the participation of international scientific -experts in these benchmarking studies. - -• Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their respective -mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by DOE’s SC federal -advisory committees and the State Department’s survey of international facilities. - -• To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the Florence -Agreement Program and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate both national and -international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-kind contributions, -materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and technologies importation. - -Sharing RDI Strategies - -Establishing an interagency working group would support the modernization of RDI for the future. - -RDI planning would greatly benefit from having regular meetings where representatives from federal -agencies discuss RDI strategic plans and needs at both the agency level and across the federal -government. These discussions would catalyze collaborations and cost-sharing on upgrading or -establishing new RDI. Although federal agencies and departments have unique business practices and -operating principles, they share common issues facing RDI modernization. Therefore, establishing an -interagency RDI working group could also be a platform for sharing best practices and ensuring access -to state-of-the-art RDI across the federal government. - -• The NSTC’s Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure should coordinate an -interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, with -activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, identifying - -– 24 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and international collaborations -in facilities. - -Additionally, departments and agencies should continue to look to the policy opportunities identified -in the National Strategic Overview on RDI, released in 2021: - -Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination - -• Adopt a cohesive definition of RDI that encompasses experimental, observational, as well as - -knowledge- and cyber-infrastructure, in federal planning processes - -• - -Identify complementary RDI—and their capabilities—across the federal government and -external R&D communities to inform agency priority-setting processes. - -• Plan for, invest in, and deploy the necessary knowledge infrastructure and research -cyberinfrastructure to keep pace with the rate of growth of data acquisition in research, as well -as published research data, to ensure the efficiency and trustworthiness of scientific pathways -and pipelines. - -• Ensure consistent, sufficient, and timely RDI capabilities, strategically addressing episodic - -efforts that can undermine the ability to meet long-term needs - -• Regularly review and document RDI needs and develop planning processes that encompass - -repurposing, reusing, or decommissioning low-priority RDI. - -Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise - -• Foster R&D community engagement to inform federal RDI planning and prioritization, for - -instance through assessments and cross-sector coordination. - -• Seek input from Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) and NSTC committees, as these -committees are capable of providing valuable insight on future RDI needs and coordination -possibilities. - -• - -Integrate agile design and decision processes in planning and maintaining RDIs so that -capabilities keep pace with the growth in data and advancements in computing and analytics. - -• Support remote access to RDI capabilities, tools, and platforms, where appropriate. - -• Build strategic, long-term relationships with contractors and suppliers to enable agility in - -procurement, development, design, and portability of RDI systems. - -• - -• - -Incorporate lifecycle considerations, such as upfront costs of construction, operation, and -maintenance, and anticipate future modernization needs for planned and existing RDIs. - -Incorporate lifecycle resourcing considerations to ensure RDIs sustain or enhance privacy and -other legal protections. - -• Ensure large or complex RDI projects are managed by staff with appropriate design and project - -management experience to safeguard delivery on schedule and within budget. - -• Continue to create and promote STEM education programs that directly engage with and - -support the use of RDIs as education and training platforms. - -– 25 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -• Ensure processes that allow the nation’s R&D enterprise to thrive by fostering the participation - -of talent that reflects the diversity of America. - -Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors - -• - -Invest in RDIs that complement core disciplinary needs while identifying opportunities to -enhance connections across disciplines and sectors. - -• Consider the potential use of RDIs beyond a single agency’s mission context in developing - -coordination efforts, especially for the Nation’s largest RDI investments. - -• Ensure RDIs foster convergence through partnerships and research information exchange. - -Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs - -• Seek international collaborations for the development of RDIs as appropriate to foster - -international cooperation - -• Operate RDIs using research security frameworks that balance open science with appropriate - -levels of vigilance and that uphold U.S. principles of integrity - -• Ensure proper protections for RDIs that are vital to competitiveness, public health and safety -resilience, and national security (e.g., intellectual property, certain classes of research data, -implications from climate change) - -Conclusion - -Just like the investments in research facilities that were built during the Cold War, investments in -modern federal RDI will support the development of new technologies and generate new jobs. -Revitalizing federal RDI will also ensure the development of a workforce trained to discover, develop, -manufacture, and use next-generation technologies. - -The nation can take immediate action to revitalize RDI and support a vibrant research enterprise for -years to come. Federal departments and agencies should develop actionable strategic plans with -priorities for RDI investments. These plans should be informed by input from the S&T community across -government, university, and private-sector institutions, and from international benchmarking. This -input can also identify opportunities to partner with both domestic and international institutions. An -RDI working group can share approaches and identify where collaborations can be forged to provide -enhanced capabilities to a broader research community. The time to act is now; prioritizing federal RDI -will support generations of future researchers and allow the United States to maintain global leadership -in science, technology, and innovation. - -– 26 – +1. ΔV = βV0ΔT +2. β*ΔT is the same for both of you. +3. But, V0 is greater for the 18-gallon fuel-tank for the truck. +4. So, ΔV will be larger for the truck and it will lose more fuel. diff --git a/q0/random_k2/random_2.md b/q0/random_k2/random_2.md index f1acb0854be2920866b2127b008e7c6e2f57b22b..35a7eb473c0028e63514bfe2ddbd9a16bdb5c94f 100644 --- a/q0/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q0/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,3733 +1,3030 @@ -GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +FOR RELEASE January 29, 2026 -Table of Contents +Confidence in Trump +Dips, and Fewer Now Say +They Support His +Policies and Plans -Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments? -What background information must I know? -How do I ensure that IT investments are linked to and support agency strategic plans? -What special terms should I know? -How do I determine whether I must report? +Rising share of Democrats want their party’s congressional +leaders to stand up to Trump -How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due? -If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year? -How is Exhibit 53 organized? -How is Exhibit 53 coded? -What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53? -Agency IT Investment Portfolio -Agency IT Security Portfolio -Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio -Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments +BY Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley -1. -2. -3. -4. -5. +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: -53.1 -53.2 -53.3 -53.4 -53.5 -Ex53A -Ex53B -Ex53C -Ex53D +Jocelyn Kiley, Director of Political Research +Steven Shepard, Associate Director of Political +Research +Nida Asheer, Senior Communications Manager -300.1 -300.2 -300.3 -300.4 -300.5 -300.6 -Ex300A/B IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification, Performance Plan and Measurement Report +202.419.4372 -What is the purpose of the section? -Does Exhibit 300 apply to me? -How will agencies manage capital assets? -What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill? -What must I report on Exhibit 300A&B and when? -How will OMB use Exhibit 300A&B? +www.pewresearch.org - Updates and consolidates special terms related to information technology (IT) and E-Government +RECOMMENDED CITATION -Summary of Changes +Pew Research Center, January 2026, “Confidence in +Trump dips, and fewer now say they support his +policies and plans” -(Section 4) + 1 -Significantly updates Exhibit 53 requirements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Requires agencies to submit a draft Fiscal Year (FY) 2014 Exhibit 53A by August 27, 2012 and the +About Pew Research Center -agency budget request Exhibit 53s on September 10, 2012 +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan, nonadvocacy fact tank that informs the public about the +issues, attitudes and trends shaping the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center +conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, computational social science research and +other data-driven research. It studies politics and policy; news habits and media; the internet and +technology; religion; race and ethnicity; international affairs; social, demographic and economic +trends; science; research methodology and data science; and immigration and migration. Pew +Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. - Adds two new 53 Exhibits: Cloud Computing and Reductions and Reinvestments per budget guidance - Adds requirement for Functional/Business Sponsor identification for all investments - Adds several fields to the Exhibit 53A for reporting government FTE, HSPD-12, and cloud +© Pew Research Center 2026 -alternatives analysis +www.pewresearch.org - New FEA BRM 3.0 Service Mappings + 2 -Significantly updates Exhibit 300 requirements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Requires agencies to submit the FY 2014 Exhibit 300A/Bs between September 10-14, 2012. +About this research -Agencies may submit Exhibit 300Bs for any investment for which a 300A has been successfully -submitted/updated +This Pew Research Center report looks at how the U.S. public feels about Trump’s job +performance, their expectations for his administration, and their views about whether +congressional leaders should work with each other and the president. - Adds a requirement to submit specific investment artifacts/documents - Updates questions for areas of current policy emphasis - Changes Summary of Funding to Life Cycle Costs - Clarifies project and activity concepts and extends reporting time period - Clarifies reporting of actuals for performance metrics - Adds question on modular contracting - Adds question on return on investment +Why did we do this? -Page 1 of 45 +Pew Research Center conducted this research to check in on how the public is feeling about the +Trump administration. It is part of our regular work to understand how Americans feel about the +policies, actions and events that occur during the presidency – as well as to understand how +Americans feel about current events. - (2012) +Our research on presidents dates back to the 1980s, and has continued through the current Trump +administration. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +Learn more about Pew Research Center and our politics research. -1. Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments? +How did we do this? -The required information allows the agency and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to review and -evaluate each agency's IT spending and to compare IT spending across the Federal Government. Specifically, -the information helps the agency and OMB to: +We conducted a survey from January 20 through January 26, 2026 among 8,512 U.S. adults +recruited through our American Trends panel. - Provide a report on all IT investments for the agency, as required by the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996; +Here are the survey questions used for this report, the detailed responses and +the survey methodology. - Understand and compare the amount spent on the development of new capabilities (Development, +www.pewresearch.org -Modernization and Enhancement [DME], which may appropriately be treated as capitalized costs) and -in support of operation and maintenance (O&M) for all agency IT investments; + 3 - +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Identify and report IT security costs for all IT investments and for agency and bureau IT security -programs, as required by the Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA); and +Confidence in Trump dips, a +they support his policies and plans +Rising share of Democrats want their party +to stand up to Trump - +nd fewer now say -Identify and report on agency financial management systems. +’s congressional leaders -Agencies must provide required formation using the Exhibit 53 reporting format. This information should be -consistent with information required in Section 51 of OMB Circular A-11. In addition, as an output of your -agency's internal IT capital planning and investment control process, your budget justification for IT must -provide results-oriented information in the context of the agency's missions and operations, as expressed -through the agency’s enterprise architecture (EA). Your budget justification, including the status and plans -for information systems, should be consistent with your agency's submissions for Exhibit 300 submissions -(see guidance on Exhibit 300), regarding major IT investments. +By Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley -Investment costs must include all Federal budgetary resources (e.g., direct appropriation, working capital -fund, revolving funds). Federal budgetary resources are defined in Section 20 of OMB Circular A-11. These -investment costs and performance benefits must be formulated and reported order to support the Clinger- -Cohen Act's requirement that the OMB Director shall submit to Congress a report on the net program -performance benefits achieved as a result of major capital investments made by executive agencies in -information systems and how the benefits relate to the accomplishment of the goals of the executive agencies. +A year into his second administration, +Americans’ views of President Donald Trump – +already more negative than positive – have +continued to slip. -2. What background information must I know? +Half of Americans say Trump’s actions +have been worse than they expected -The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public -resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition, and management of -capital assets into the Budget decision-making process. It is intended to assist agencies in improving asset -management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of: +% who ___ of the way Donald Trump is handling his job +as president - The Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996, which requires agencies to use a disciplined capital planning and +▪ Trump’s approval rating stands at 37%, -investment control (CPIC) process to acquire, use, maintain, and dispose of IT in alignment with the -agency’s EA planning processes. OMB policy for the management of Federal information resources -is detailed in Circular A-130, Management of Federal Information Resources. +down from 40% in the fall. - The Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993, which establishes the foundation for +Approve -Budget decision making to achieve strategic goals in order to meet agency mission objectives. -Instructions for preparing strategic plans, annual performance plans, and annual program performance -reports are provided in Part 6 of OMB Circular A-11 (see Section 220). +Disapprove - The GPRA Modernization Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-352), which requires quarterly performance +37 -assessments of Federal Government priorities and establishes agency Performance Improvement -Officers and the Performance Improvement Council. +61 -Page 2 of 45 +▪ By more than two-to-one, Americans say +the administration’s actions have been +worse than they expected (50%) rather than +better (21%). - (2012) +▪ Only about a quarter of Americans today +(27%) say they support all or most of +Trump’s policies and plans, down from 35% +when he returned to office last year. That +change has come entirely among +Republicans. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +% who say the Trump administration’s actions since +taking office last year have been ___ expected - The Federal Managers Financial Integrity Act of 1982, Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990 (CFO +Better than -Act), and Federal Financial Management Improvement Act of 1996, which require accountability of -financial and program managers for financial results of actions taken, control over the Federal -Government's financial resources, and protection of Federal assets. OMB policies and standards for -developing, operating, evaluating, and reporting on financial management systems are contained in -Circular A–127, Financial Management Systems and OMB Circular A-11, Section 52. +About as - The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, which requires agencies to perform their information +Worse than -resources management activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner. +21 - The Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, which requires agencies to integrate IT -security into their capital planning and EA processes, conduct annual IT security reviews of all -programs and systems, and report the results of those reviews to OMB. +28 - The E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107–347), which requires agencies to support government-wide -E-Government (E-Gov) initiatives and to leverage cross-agency opportunities to further E-Gov. The -Act also requires agencies to establish a process for determining which government information the -agency intends to make available and accessible to the public on the Internet and by other means. In -addition, the Act requires agencies to conduct and make publicly available privacy impact -assessments (PIAs) for all new IT investments, administering information in an identifiable form -collected from or about members of the public. +50 - The National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act of 1995 (P.L. 104-113) and OMB Circular -A-119, which state that voluntary consensus standards are the preferred type of standards for Federal -Government use. When it would be inconsistent with law or otherwise impractical to use a voluntary -consensus standard, agencies must submit a report to OMB through the National Institute of Standards -and Technology (NIST) describing the reason(s) for the agency's use of government-unique standards -in lieu of voluntary consensus standards. +% who support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and +plans - The Federal Records Act, which requires agencies to establish standards and procedures to ensure -efficient and effective records management. The National Archives and Records Administration -(NARA) issues policies and guidance for agencies to meet their records management goals and -requirements. NARA also provides policies and guidance for planning and evaluating investments in -electronic records management. +All/Most - The Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. § 552a), which is an omnibus "code of fair information practices" -that attempts to regulate the collection, maintenance, use, and dissemination of personal information -by Federal executive branch agencies. +Some - NIST Special Publication 800-146 concepts and definitions regarding cloud computing. +Few/None - Recent OMB IT policies and guidance, including: +27 -o 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management -o Federal Information Technology Shared Services Strategy -o The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture -o Digital Government Strategy: Building a 21st Century Platform to Better Serve the American +20 -People +52 -o OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat -o The Federal Cloud Computing Strategy +A new Pew Research Center survey of 8,512 +U.S. adults, conducted Jan. 20-26, also finds +that – across six key qualities and abilities +needed to serve as president – more Americans +express little or no confidence in Trump than say they are extremely or very confident in him. -Page 3 of 45 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - (2012) +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +Confidence is down on all six measures since last year, particularly among Republicans. -o Security Authorization of Information Systems in Cloud Computing Environments +Related: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions -(FedRAMP) +www.pewresearch.org -o OMB memo M-12-13 - Fiscal Year 2014 Budget Guidance + 4 - Executive Order 13514, Federal Leadership in Environmental, Energy, and Economic Performance +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Executive Order 13423, Strengthening Federal Environmental, Energy, and Transportation +Trump’s qualities and abilities as president -Management +Today, 34% of Americans say +they are extremely or very +confident that Trump has the +leadership skills needed to +serve as president. A larger +share (51%) are not too or not +at all confident. Another 14% +are somewhat confident. - Federal Acquisition Regulation, including Subchapter B, Parts 5 through 12 and Part 23 +Similarly, about half say they +are not too or not at all +confident Trump has the +mental fitness (52%) or +physical fitness (50%) to do +the job. Roughly three-in-ten +express confidence on these +measures. - Federal Management Regulation, including Subchapters B and C +Many Americans lack confidence in Trump on several +measures, including his ethics in office - Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, including Sections 431 through 435 and 523 through +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they +are ___ confident that Donald Trump … -525 +No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - Energy and Policy Act of 2005, including Sections 103, 104, 109, and 203 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -3. How do I ensure that IT investments align with and support the agency’s strategic plans? +Even fewer say they are confident that Trump respects the country’s democratic values (25% are +extremely or very confident) or that he picks good advisers (25%). -Each IT investment must clearly demonstrate that the investment is needed to help meet the agency's strategic -goals and mission. The agency must demonstrate how the investment supports a business line or enterprise -service performance goal as documented in the agency’s EA and annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to -OMB. Agency IT investment business cases (and other documents), the IT Capital Asset Summary (Exhibit -300A), and Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) must demonstrate the agency’s management of IT -investments and how governance processes are used to plan, select, develop, implement, and operate IT -investments. Documents used to manage the planning, development, implementation, and operation of IT -investments and documents that demonstrate the outcomes of agency, branch, and bureau governance -decisions should be maintained and made readily available if requested by OMB. +Americans express the least amount of confidence in Trump to act ethically in office. Just 21% are +extremely or very confident he does this, while 60% express little or no confidence. -The individual agency's Exhibit 53A and Exhibit 300A submissions are used to create an overall "Federal IT -Investment Portfolio," which is published as part of the President's Budget. Agency and OMB portfolio -reviews and Budget processes will ensure the selection of IT investments that support the agency’s strategic -goals, as captured in the agency’s High Priority Performance Goals and Strategic Plan. +www.pewresearch.org -4. What special terms should I know? + While overall confidence in +Trump’s ethics in office was +already relatively low last +February (29%), it has +declined 8 percentage points +since. And nearly all of that +drop has come among +Republicans: At the +beginning of Trump’s second +term, a 55% majority of +Republicans and Republican- +leaning independents said +they were confident that +Trump acts ethically in office, +but that share now stands at +42%. -Alternatives Analysis refers to an analysis of alternatives for addressing the performance objectives of an -investment. The analysis is performed prior to the initial decision to implement a solution and updated -periodically, as appropriate, to capture changes in the context for an investment decision. Alternatives -analysis documentation must be submitted along with Exhibit 300 for all major IT investments. Alternatives -Analysis should be performed for investments with projects in the planning or DME stages, whereas strictly -operational investments should instead perform operational analyses until such time as a decision is made to -re-evaluate the investment or to resume development, modernization or enhancement. - -Asset refers to anything that has value to an organization, including, but not limited to: a computing device, -IT system, IT network, IT circuit, software (both an installed instance and a physical instance), virtual -computing platform (common in cloud and virtualized computing), and related hardware (e.g., locks, cabinets, -keyboards). Assets are the lowest level at which IT is planned, acquired, implemented, and operated. - -Benefit-Cost Analysis refers to the recommended technique to use in a formal economic analysis of -government programs or projects. Guidance for Benefit-Cost Analysis is described in OMB Circular A-94. - -Page 4 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Business Reference Model (BRM) refers to one of six reference models of the Federal Enterprise -Architecture (FEA). It is a classification taxonomy used to describe mission sectors, business functions, and -services that are performed within and between Federal agencies and with external partners. IT investments -are mapped to the BRM to identify opportunities for collaboration, shared services, and solution reuse. -Exhibit 53 allows for one primary service and up to four secondary service codes to be identified for each IT -investment. BRM service codes can be found in the FEA Reference Model document library. -Note: Updated definitions are scheduled for release in version 2 of the FEA. - -Capital Assets refer to land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and IT (including the -output of IT service contracts) that has been acquired by the Federal Government and have an estimated useful -life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more complete -definition of capital assets. - -Capital Investment (or Investment) refers to the planning, development, and acquisition of a capital asset and -the management and operation of that asset through its usable life after the initial acquisition. IT capital -investments may consist of one or more assets, which provide useful components in an operational -(production) environment. - -Capital Planning and Investment Control (also called capital programming) refers to a decision-making -process that ensures IT investments integrate strategic planning, budgeting, procurement, and management of -IT in support of agency missions and business needs. The term was introduced in the Clinger-Cohen Act of -1996 and generally is used in relation to IT management issues. - -Capital Programming refers to an integrated process within an agency that focuses on the planning, -budgeting, procurement, and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve the agency’s -strategic goals and objectives with the lowest overall cost and least risk. - -Cloud First Policy (IT Reform) refers to the Cloud First policy, launched in December 2010, which is -intended to accelerate the pace at which the government realizes the value of cloud computing by requiring -agencies to evaluate safe, secure cloud computing options before making any new investments. Per the -Federal Cloud Computing Strategy, agencies should evaluate their technology sourcing plans to include -consideration and application of cloud computing solutions as part of the budget process. Agencies should -seek to optimize the use of cloud technologies in their IT portfolios to take full advantage of the benefits of -cloud computing in order to maximize capacity utilization, improve IT flexibility and responsiveness, and -minimize costs. When evaluating options for new IT deployments, OMB requires that agencies default to -cloud-based solutions whenever a secure, reliable, cost-effective cloud option exists. Additionally, agencies -shall continually evaluate cloud computing solutions across their IT portfolios, regardless of investment type -or life cycle stage. - -Contributions (or expected contributions) refers to both monetary contributions and fees for services -provided by partner agencies to managing partners or shared service providers of a multi-agency -collaboration. Contributions should only apply to multi-agency collaborations. - -Cost refers to the expenditure of funds or use of property to acquire, produce, operate, or maintain an asset. -Examples include, but are not limited to: sunk costs, operational costs, acquisition costs, and disposition costs -(including variable costs such as labor hours). - -Cost Avoidance refers to from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease costs in the -future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). - -Cost Saving refers to the reduction in actual expenditures to achieve a specific objective (as defined in OMB -Circular A-131). - -Page 5 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Data Center refers to a closet, room, floor, or building for the storage, management, and dissemination of data -and information. Such a repository houses computer systems and associated components, such as databases, -applications, and storage systems and data stores. A data center generally includes redundant or backup -power supplies; redundant data communications connections; environmental controls (e.g., air conditioning, -fire suppression); and special security devices housed in, leased (including by cloud providers), owned, -collocated, or situated in stand-alone facilities. This definition excludes facilities exclusively devoted to -communications and network equipment (e.g., telephone exchanges, telecommunications rooms). Neither -square footage nor Uptime Institute tier classifications are required to define a facility as a data center. This -definition of a data center applies to all agency IT assets, mission or otherwise. See March 2012 OMB Federal -Data Center Consolidation Initiative Memorandum for more detail. - -Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) of 1990 (P.L. 101-510) refers to a congressional -act that established for the Department of Defense an Acquisition Corps to professionalize the acquisition -workforce in the Department of Defense through education, training, and work experience. - -Dependency refers to the identification of relationships between projects and operational assets within an -investment as well as the identification of relationships between investments. Identification of dependencies -is critical to the management of project, program, and portfolio risk. - -Development, Modernization and Enhancement refers to costs for projects and activities leading to new IT -assets/systems and projects and activities that change or modify existing IT assets to: substantively improve -capability or performance, implement legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet an agency leadership -request. As part of DME, capital costs can include hardware, software development and acquisition costs, -commercial off-the-shelf acquisition costs, government labor costs, and contracted labor costs for planning, -development, acquisition, system integration, and direct project management and overhead support. - -Disposition Cost refers to the cost of retiring a capital asset once its useful life is completed or a replacement -asset has superseded it; disposition costs may be included in operational activities near the end of the useful -life of an asset. - -Earned Value Management (EVM) refers to a project management tool that effectively integrates the project -scope of work with a schedule and cost elements for optimum project planning and control. The qualities and -operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in American National -Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard–748–1998, Earned Value -Management Systems. Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/evm. - -Enterprise Architecture refers to the explicit description and documentation of the current and desired -relationships among business and management processes and IT of an organization. It describes the “current -architecture” and “target architecture”. An EA includes the rules and standards and systems life cycle -information to optimize and maintain the environment which the agency wishes to create and maintain -through its IT portfolio. An EA must provide a strategy that enables the agency to support its current state and -provides a roadmap for transition to its target environment. An EA defines principles and goals and sets a -direction on such issues as the promotion of interoperability, open systems, publics access, end-user -satisfaction, and IT security. The agency must support an EA with a complete inventory of agency -information resources including: personnel, equipment, systems, services, and funds devoted to information -resources management and IT, at an appropriate level of detail. - -Enterprise Roadmap refers to an annual submission from each agency to OMB that describes the business -and technology plan for the entire organization using EA methods. The Roadmap provides current views, -future views, and transition plans at an appropriate level of detail for all IT investments, services, systems, and -programs. The Enterprise Roadmap also contains an IT asset inventory using the FEA Reference Models and -other attachments or appendices for CPIC, EA, shared service, and other planning products requested by -OMB that provide additional information regarding Roadmap plans. - -Page 6 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Evaluation (by Agency CIO) refers to the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment -in terms of its ability to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, -including, but not limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical -performance, human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to the forecasting future success. -Each evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation. - -Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) refers to a certification -program that was established to clearly identify general training and experience requirements for program and -project managers (PMs) in civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for -program managers and PMs. The certification program does not include functional or technical competencies, -such as those for IT or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar certification program -under DAWIA. Agencies were required to be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available -levels are Entry/Apprentice, Mid/Journeyman, and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2, and 3 for -DAWIA. For more information about these programs, refer to the following links: -http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf -http://whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf - -Federal Enterprise Architecture refers to a business-based documentation and analysis framework for -government-wide improvement. The FEA allows agencies to use standardized methods to describe the -relationship between an agency’s strategic goals, business functions, and enabling technologies at various -levels of scope and complexity. The FEA is comprised of documentation in six domain areas (strategic goals, -business services, data and information, systems and applications, infrastructure, and security) that includes -required and elective artifacts. There are six reference models to support the six domain areas that should -facilitate standardized design; analysis; reporting; and the identification of duplicative investments, gaps, and -opportunities for collaboration within and across Federal agencies. More information about the FEA is -available in The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture (OMB, May 2, 2012) and at FEA -Reference Model document library. - -Federal Enterprise Architecture Mapping Codes refers to a framework for describing important elements of -the FEA in a common and consistent way. Through the use of this common framework and vocabulary, IT -portfolios can be better managed and leveraged across the Federal Government. The first three-digit code -indicates the primary service area served by this investment (the three-digit BRM service code). The second -through fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with this investment. Guidance on -the codes for these mappings can be found at FEA Reference Model document library. - -Financial Management refers to activities that support the interrelationships and interdependencies among -budget, cost and management functions, and information associated with business transactions. - -Financial Management Systems refers to systems necessary to support financial management, including -automated and manual processes, procedures, controls, data, hardware, software, and support personnel -dedicated to the operation and maintenance of system functions. The following are examples of financial -management systems: core financial systems, procurement systems, loan systems, grants systems, payroll -systems, budget formulation systems, billing systems, and travel systems. See OMB Circular A-127 for -additional information and guidance at www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a127. - -Full Funding refers to a situation where appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete an asset or a -useful segment of a capital asset before any obligations may be incurred. Incrementally funding the planning -and acquisition of capital assets or (useful segments) without certainty if or when future funding will be -available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets acquisition, higher acquisition costs, -project delays, cancellation of projects, the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate -the assets. Budget requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see Section 31.6 of -OMB Circular A-11). - -Page 7 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Funding refers to providing the budgetary resources to plan for, acquire, develop, sustain, or operate an asset. - -Funding Source refers to the direct appropriation or other budgetary resources an agency receives for an IT -investment. When “original paying accounts” within agencies are transferring resources to a different agency -account that ultimately supports the IT investment (for example, when bureau accounts are paying into a -central CIO office account or a working capital fund), the funding source provided in Exhibit 53A should be -the account that ultimately pays contracts and other costs for the investment directly (not the original -account(s) for the funds). - -Note: For agencies on the IT Dashboard, funding sources are planned as the primary drivers in the algorithm -to display “spending by bureau,” rather than using the bureau code associated with investments. It is critical -that valid funding source codes be provided in agency submissions. - -Government Information refers to information created, collected, processed, disseminated, or disposed of by -or for the Federal Government. - -Information Resource Management (IRM) Strategic Plan refers to a document that addresses all information -resources management of an agency. Agencies must develop and maintain their IRM strategic plans as -required by 44 U.S.C. 3506(b)(2) and OMB Circular A-130. IRM strategic plans should support the agency's -strategic plan that is required in OMB Circular A-11; provide a description of how information resources -management activities help accomplish the agency’s missions delivery area and program decisions; and -ensure IRM decisions are integrated with management support areas, including organizational planning, -budget, procurement, financial management, and human resources management. - -Information Security refers to all functions necessary to meet Federal information security policy -requirements. It includes the development, implementation, and maintenance of security policies, procedures, -and controls across the entire information life cycle. These functions should include implementation and -activities associated with NIST 800-37, Security Awareness training (but not the technical infrastructure -required for the delivery of training), FISMA compliance reporting, development of a security policy, and -security audits and testing. It does not include the physical protection of facilities such as those described in -Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP). - -Information System refers to a discrete set of IT, data, and related resources, such as personnel, hardware, -software, and associated IT services organized for the collection, processing, maintenance, use, sharing, -dissemination, or disposition of information. - -Information Technology refers to any equipment or interconnected system or subsystem of equipment that is -used in the automatic acquisition, storage, manipulation, management, movement, control, display, switching, -interchange, transmission, or reception of data or information by an executive agency. IT is related to the -terms capital asset, IT investment, program, project, sub-project, service, and system. - -Integrated Program Team (IPT) refers to a cross-functional or multidisciplinary group of individuals -organized and collectively responsible for the specific purpose of delivering a project, product, or process to -an external or internal customer. Each IPT should include experts in program and project management, -resource management, procurement, systems engineering, system security, and other disciplines, as necessary, -to plan and evaluate all aspects of the project. In order for OMB to approve the investment budget, an IPT -must include at a minimum: a qualified, fully dedicated IT program manager; a contracting specialist, if -applicable; an IT specialist; an IT security specialist; and a business process owner or subject matter expert -(SME). Other members of the IPT might include enterprise architects; IT specialists with specific expertise in -data, systems, or networks; capital planners; or performance specialists. Key members of the IPT should be -co-located during the most critical junctures of the program, to the maximum extent possible. Agencies -should establish IPT members’ individual performance goals to hold team members accountable for both - -Page 8 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -individual functional goals and the overall success of the program. The investment IPT should be defined in a -program or an IPT charter. - -Interagency Acquisition refers to the use of the Federal Supply Schedules; a multi-agency contract (i.e., a task -order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by multiple government agencies to obtain -supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535) or a government-wide acquisition -contract (i.e., a task order or delivery order contract for IT established by one agency for government-wide -use operated by an executive agent, as designated by OMB pursuant to Section 11302(3) of the Clinger-Cohen -Act of 1996). - -IT Dashboard refers to a website (www.itdashboard.gov) that enables Federal agencies, industry, the general -public, and other stakeholders to view details regarding the performance of Federal IT investments. The IT -Dashboard is used by the Administration and Congress to inform budget and policy decisions. - -IT Investment refers to the expenditure of IT resources to address mission delivery and management support. -An IT investment may include a project or projects for the development, modernization, enhancement, or -maintenance of a single IT asset or group of IT assets with related functionality and the subsequent operation -of those assets in a production environment. All IT investments should have a defined life cycle with start and -end dates, with the end date representing the end of the currently estimated useful life of the investment, -consistent with the investment’s most current alternatives analysis if applicable. - -IT Program Managers and IT Project Managers refers to the IPT members responsible for IT investments -and lead the required IPT for the investment. In some cases, IT program managers and PMs can hold -positions in other classification series; however they must still meet the requisite Federal certification and/or -IT program management experience requirements. Further definitions are available in the Office of Personnel -Management’s Job Family Standard for Administrative Work in the Information Technology Group (series -2200 in the Federal Classification and Job Grading Systems). - -IT System refers to a discrete set of information resources organized for the collection, processing, -maintenance, transmission, and dissemination of information, in accordance with defined procedures, whether -automated or manual. - -Life Cycle Costs refers to all investment costs (including government FTEs) from the commencement of the -investment through its estimated useful life (or the composite estimated useful life of the assets within the -investment), independent of the funding source (e.g., revolving fund, appropriated fund, working capital fund, -trust fund). For more information about life cycle costs, see the Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular -A-11 and OMB Circular A-131. - -Maintenance refers to the activity necessary to keep an asset functioning as designed during the O&M phase -of an investment. Some maintenance activities should be managed as projects and reported in Section B of -Exhibit 300B. Examples of maintenance projects may include, but are not limited to: operating system -upgrades, technology refreshes, and security patch implementations. As defined in the Federal Accounting -Standards Advisory Board Statement of Federal Financial Accounting Standards Number 10, “Maintenance -excludes activities aimed at expanding the capacity of an asset or otherwise upgrading it to serve needs -different from or significantly greater than those originally intended.” Maintenance costs refer to all costs -(including all related personnel costs) needed to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance -levels. - -Major IT Investment refers to an IT investment requiring special management attention because of its -importance to the mission or function to the government; significant program or policy implications; high -executive visibility; high development, operating, or maintenance costs; unusual funding mechanism; or -definition as major by the agency’s capital planning and investment control process. OMB may work with the - -Page 9 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -agency to declare IT investments as major investments. Agencies should consult with assigned OMB analysts -regarding which investments are considered “major.” Investments not considered “major” are “non-major.” - -Managing Partner refers to the lead agency that is responsible for coordinating the implementation of the E- -Gov or Line of Business (LoB) initiative. The managing partner is also responsible for coordinating and -submitting Exhibit 300 for the initiative; Exhibit 300 will be represented as part of the managing partner's -budget portfolio. For additional information on managing partner reporting requirements for IT investments, -refer to the OMB MAX portal. - -New IT Investment refers to an IT investment and its associated projects that is newly proposed by the agency -and that has not been previously reported/funded by OMB. - -Non-Major IT Investment refers to any IT investment in the agency's IT Portfolio that does not meet the -definition of “major IT investment.” All non-major investments must be reported in Exhibit 53. - -Ongoing IT Investment refers to an investment and its associated assets, including both maintenance projects -and operational activities that have been through a complete Budget Cycle with OMB with respect to the -President's Budget for the current year (CY)—in this case, for FY 2013. - -Operational Analysis refers to a method of examining the ongoing performance of an operating asset -investment and measuring that performance against an established set of cost, schedule, and performance -goals. An operational analysis is, by nature, less structured than performance reporting methods applied to -developmental projects and should trigger considerations of how the investment's objectives could be better -met, how costs could be reduced, and whether the organization should continue performing a particular -function. Guidance for Operational Analysis is described in the Capital Programming Guide. - -Operations refer to the day-to-day management of an asset in the production environment and include, but are -not limited to, activities that operate data centers, help desks, operational centers, telecommunication centers, -and end-user support services. Operational activities are reported through Section C of Exhibit 300B. -Operations costs include the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in the production environment; costs -to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including Federal and contracted labor -costs; and costs for the disposal of an asset. - -Operations and Maintenance (O&M) refers to the phase of the life cycle in which the asset is in operations -and produces the same product or provides a repetitive service. Also commonly referred to as steady state. - -Partner Agency refers to the agency for an E-Gov or LoB initiative that is designated to provide resources -(e.g., funding, full-time equivalents [FTEs], in-kind) for the management, development, deployment, or -maintenance of a common solution. The partner agency is also responsible for including the appropriate line -items in its Exhibit 53 and reflecting the amount of the contribution for each of the E-Gov or LoB initiatives -to which the agency provides resources. - -Performance-based Acquisition Management refers to a documented, systematic process for program -management, which includes the integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, the establishment -of a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and the use of earned value techniques for -performance measurement during execution of the program. This type of management includes prototypes -and tests to select the most cost-effective alternative during the planning phase; the work during the -acquisition phase; and any developmental, modification, or upgrade work done during the O&M phase. A -performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulation 37.101) or -contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance standards/measures -should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase. - -Page 10 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Planning refers to preparing, developing, or acquiring the information used to design the asset; assess the -benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted costs of alternative solutions; and establish realistic cost, schedule, and -performance goals for the selected alternative, before either proceeding to full acquisition of the capital -project or useful component or terminating the project. Planning must progress to the point where the agency -is ready to commit to achieving specific goals for the completion of the acquisition before proceeding to the -acquisition phase. Information gathering activities to support planning may include market research of -available solutions, architectural drawings, geological studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes. -Planning may be general to the overall investment or may be specific to a useful component. - -PortfolioStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an agency's IT portfolio. Reviews can be used -to identify and address a broad range of issues, including management of commodity IT, duplication of -investments, and alignment with the agency’s mission and strategy. More detail regarding the PortfolioStat -process is described in OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat. - -Post-Implementation Review (PIR) refers to an evaluation of how successfully the investment or project -objectives were met and how effective the project management practices were in keeping the investment or -project on track. A PIR can be conducted after a project has been completed, or after an investment concludes -the implementation phase. Additional details regarding the PIR process is described in the Capital -Programming Guide. - -Privacy Impact Assessment is a process for examining the risks and ramifications of using IT to collect, -maintain, and disseminate information from or about members of the public in an identifiable form. The -process also is also used to identify and evaluate protections and alternative processes to mitigate the impact -to privacy of collecting such information. Consistent with OMB guidance (M-03-22) regarding implementing -the privacy provisions of the E-Government Act, agencies must conduct and make publicly available PIAs for -all new or significantly altered IT investments that administer information in an identifiable form collected -from or about members of the public. - -Project refers to a temporary endeavor undertaken to accomplish a unique product or service with a defined -start and end point and specific objectives that, when attained, signify completion. Projects can be undertaken -for the development, modernization, enhancement, disposal, or maintenance of an IT asset. Projects are -composed of activities. When reporting projects in Exhibit 300A and 300B, to the maximum extent -practicable, agencies should detail the characteristics of “increments” under modular contracting as described -in the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996 and the characteristics of “useful segments,” as described in OMB Circular -A-130. - -Project Manager Level of Experience refers to the specific certification(s) or number of years of direct -project management experience that the PM holds. Examples of PM certifications include FAC-P/PM, -Project Management Institute/PMP, and other recognized certifications. - -Records refers to all books, papers, maps, photographs, machine-readable materials, or other documentary -materials, regardless of physical form or characteristics, made or received by an agency of the United States -Government under Federal law or in connection with the transaction of public business. Records may also -include items that are preserved or appropriate for preservation by that agency or its legitimate successor as -evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the -Federal Government or because of the informational value of data in them. Library and museum material -made or acquired and preserved solely for reference or exhibition purposes, extra copies of documents -preserved only for convenience of reference, and stocks of publications and processed documents are may not -be included as records. - -Risk Management refers to a systematic process of identifying, analyzing, and responding to risk. It includes -maximizing the probability and consequences of positive events and minimizing the probability and -consequences of adverse events to overall objectives. - -Page 11 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Risk Management Plan refers to a documented and approved plan developed at the onset of the investment -and maintained throughout that specifies the risk management process - -Shared Service Provider refers to the provider of a technical solution and/or service that supports the business -of multiple agencies using a shared architecture. - -TechStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an IT program with Bureau/Agency leadership and -OMB as appropriate. TechStat sessions enable the Federal Government to turn around, halt, or terminate IT -investments that do not produce dividends for the American people. More detail regarding the TechStat -process is described in the TechStat Training Deck. - -Unique Investment Identifier (UII) refers to a persistent numeric code applied to an investment that allows -the identification and tracking of an investment across multiple FYs of an agency’s investment portfolio. The -UII is composed of a three-digit agency code concatenated with a nine-digit unique investment number -generated by the agency. Some nine-digit numbers are reserved for OMB to assign and may not be assigned -by agencies, as controlled by the restrictions described in the section on “Variable Information.” - -Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J, -“Principles of Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions.” - -5. How do I determine whether I must report? - -Agencies must submit an agency IT investment portfolio (Exhibit 53A, Exhibit 53C, Exhibit 53D, and -Exhibits 300), if the government agency is subject to Executive Branch review (see OMB Circular A-11 -Section 25.1). All CFO Act agencies and any others directed to do so must submit an agency security -portfolio (Exhibit 53B). - -The following agencies must also submit this information to the IT Dashboard: - -Department of Agriculture -Department of Commerce -Department of Defense -Department of Education -Department of Energy -Department of Health and Human Services -Department of Homeland Security -Department of Housing and Urban Development -Department of the Interior -Department of Justice -Department of Labor -Department of State -Department of Transportation -Department of the Treasury - -Department of Veteran’s Affairs -U.S. Agency for International Development -U.S. Army Corps of Engineers -Environmental Protection Agency -General Services Administration -National Aeronautics and Space Administration -National Archives and Records Administration -National Science Foundation -Nuclear Regulatory Commission -Office of Personnel Management -Small Business Administration -Smithsonian Institution -Social Security Administration - -The agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions/revisions of the Exhibit 53 -prior to submission. - -Page 12 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -53.1 How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due? - -Agencies must submit a draft and updated versions of Exhibit 53s using the following schedule: - - Draft Exhibit 53A: August 27, 2012 - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: September 10, 2012 - President’s Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: Early January 2013 (tentative) - -Specifically, a draft version of Exhibit 53A shall be completed by the agency and submitted to OMB. This -draft will allow the agency and OMB to agree on which major and non-major IT investments will be reported -as part of the next President's Budget Request and to confirm the mapping of agency investments to agency -architectures. The initial draft of Exhibit 53A must conform to a template described later in this section, -which will be published on the OMB MAX portal. Specific steps for completing the submission will be -available on the OMB MAX portal. The completion of the initial draft of Exhibit 53A should be coordinated -by the agency’s IT capital planning lead. At a minimum, the draft Exhibit 53A should include the legacy UIIs -and current UIIs, investment name, investment description, and the FEA BRM Primary services mappings. +5 -All subsequent updates to the Exhibit 53s will be submitted to the IT Dashboard or otherwise as directed. The -agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions of Exhibit 53 prior to -submission. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Additional updates to Exhibits 53A and 300A may be required after final budget decisions or if the agency -requests supplemental funds that require changes to Exhibits 53A and 300A. Specific instructions and -deadlines for submitting updates, corrections, and final submissions of these exhibits will be available on the -OMB MAX portal. +Republican confidence in Trump to respect country’s +democratic values, act ethically in office declines -53.2 If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year? +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are +extremely/very confident that Donald Trump … -If your agency submitted Exhibit 53 for the FY 2013 Budget, the revised FY 2014 Budget must be compliant -with the specified format or it will be rejected. Agencies must note “changes in status” for each investment -and provide descriptions for any changes in status. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -It is important that the agency updates its Exhibit 53 to reflect prior year (PY) for FY 2012, current year (CY) -for FY 2013, and budget year (BY) for FY 2014. Exhibit 53A also requires MAX funding codes for all -"Funding Sources" line items. Consistent with prior submissions, "Investment Descriptions" will be limited to -255 characters. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -53.3 How is Exhibit 53 organized? +There’s a similar pattern +across all six qualities we asked about. -Exhibit 53 is composed of four parts: +For example, 60% of Republicans said last February that they were extremely or very confident +Trump respects the country’s democratic values – it’s 52% today. And while 66% of Republicans +say he has the mental fitness to do the job, that’s down from three-quarters last year. -1. Exhibit 53A, “Agency IT Investment Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget and +Democrats’ confidence in Trump on these measures remains very low. -architecture information; +For full trend on each of the qualities asked on the survey, refer to chart appendix. -2. Exhibit 53B, “Agency IT Security Portfolio,” which includes a summary of agency and bureau IT +www.pewresearch.org -security information, including IT security costs; and + 6 -3. Exhibit 53C, “Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget information +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -by cloud computing deployment model and service model. +Support for Trump’s policies -4. Exhibit 53D, “Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments” (see OMB M-12-13) +There has also been a significant decline over +the last year in the share of adults who say they +agree with Trump’s plans and policies. -Agencies should compare all relevant portfolios to ensure consistency. For example, the sum of columns 41 -to 43 on Exhibit 53A should equal the sums of each table in Exhibit 53C. +Republican support for Trump’s agenda +has declined over the last year -Page 13 of 45 Exhibit 53 +% who say they support all/most of Donald Trump’s +plans and policies - (2012) +▪ Last year, 35% said they supported all or +most of his plans, 17% supported some of +them and 47% supported only a few or +none. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +▪ Today, 27% say they support all or most, -Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) +20% support some and 52% support few or +none. -(a) Overview +The decline in support has come +exclusively among Republicans. Last +year, 67% said they supported all or most +of Trump’s plans and policies. Today, 56% do. -Exhibit 53A is a report of all agency IT investments. Investment costs are to be provided in millions of -dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, although -agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Information reported in Exhibit 53A should be consistent with data reported in MAX schedule O, object -classification (specifically, object classes 11.1 through 12.2, 23.1, 23.2, 25.2, 25.3, 25.7, 26.0, 31.0, and 41.0). -All major and non-major IT investments must be reported in Exhibit 53A. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Agencies must note all Federal budgetary resources (includes carryover and new budget authority) used to -fund an IT investment, including discretionary or mandatory funding sources, user fees, or gifts. Funding -should represent only Federal budgetary resources. Agencies should not include funding provided by non- -Federal sources, such as in matching funds for grant programs provided by state or local governments. +Very small shares of Democrats say they support his policies. Most (87%) support only a few or +none. -Funding levels in Exhibit 53A should represent: +Related: Few Americans support Trump’s proposed takeover of Greenland. - Estimated budgetary resources for BY (this may be different from the estimated obligations on the +For full trend details, refer to the appendix. -Exhibit 300 for some investments) +www.pewresearch.org - Estimated budgetary resources for CY (based on enactment where applicable) (this may be different + 7 -from the estimated obligations on the Exhibit 300 for some investments) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Expended budgetary resources (actuals) for PY (or the best current estimate) (this cost should +Republicans increasingly say GOP +members of Congress aren’t obligated to +support Trump if they disagree with him -represent the actual costs reported to the Exhibit 300) +% of Rep/Lean Rep who say Republicans in Congress … -These levels should be consistent with program-level funding and branch, bureau, and agency summary -funding tables. Funding from supplemental appropriations and the Recovery Act should also be included in a -manner consistent with other budget submission displays of program data. +Do Republicans in Congress have an +obligation to support Trump? -Exhibit 53A has six major parts: +Today, 38% of Republicans and Republican- +leaning independents say that congressional +Republicans “have an obligation to support +Trump’s policies and programs because he is a +Republican president.” But a far larger share +(61%) say GOP members of Congress do not +have an obligation to support Trump if they +disagree with him. -Part 1. -Part 2. -Part 3. -Part 4. -Part 5. -Part 6. +The share saying Republicans in Congress do +not have this obligation is up since last year, +from 55%. -IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support -IT Investments for Infrastructure, Office Automation, and Telecommunications -IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions -IT Investments for Grants Management Systems -National Security Systems IT Investments -Grants to State and Local IT Investments +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -All parts use the following common data elements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Agency Description of Change in Investment Status is used when an indicator has been chosen for “Change -in Investment Status” in order to provide a description of the rationale for the change which may include -impacted UPIs, specific references to legislative requirements, or governance board decisions and effective -dates. +www.pewresearch.org -Agency Funding is the agency’s budgetary resources for a given investment. + 8 -Change in Investment Status is used when an investment has a change in status (e.g., downgraded to non- -major investment, eliminated, retired, consolidated, split) for the current budget submission relative to the -previous budget cycle. The change of status should be indicated with one of the following reasons: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Page 14 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Other key findings from the survey - (2012) +Democrats increasingly say their congressional +leaders should stand up to Trump on their issues - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +% of Rep/Lean Rep who say +Donald Trump should … -1. Upgrade -2. Downgrade -3. Split -4. Consolidation -5. Reorganization -6. Eliminated by funding -7. Eliminated by split -8. Eliminated by consolidation -9. Eliminated by reorganization -10. New -11. No Change in Status +% of Dem/Lean Dem who say +Democratic congressional leaders +should … -Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation specifies whether, as of the date of the submission, a cloud -alternative was evaluated for the investment or components/systems within the investment, per the Cloud First -policy. All investments should answer this question regardless of the overall lifecycle stage of the investment, -as operational investments may consider performing such an evaluation during or as a result of an operational -analysis. The evaluation should indicate one of the following answers: +▪ Democrats -1. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative and chose a cloud alternative for some or all of the investment. -2. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative but did not choose a cloud alternative for any of the investment. -3. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative but plans to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of the BY. -4. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative and does not plan to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of +overwhelmingly say +their congressional +leadership should +stand up to Trump. +Today, 82% (up from 70% +last year) want to see their +leaders pushing back +against Trump, even if that +makes it harder to address +problems. A smaller +majority of Republicans +(61%) say Trump should +stand up to Democratic +leaders. This is similar to +their views a year ago. -the BY. +▪ Nearly half of -Cloud Computing Spending refers to implementation and operational costs directly attributable to the cloud -computing systems “within” the investment for the specified year. +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Cross-Boundary Information Sharing is an activity that crosses a bureau or agency boundary, including -information sharing with international, state, local, tribal, industry, or non-governmental organization partners. -If the investment supports reusable, standardized information exchanges, agencies must indicate which of the -following were used: - -1. NIEM -2. UCORE -3. XBRL -4. Other -5. None - -Current UII includes an agency code and a nine-digit unique identifier. Variable information formerly -included in the UPI of previous years is not part of the UII primary key. Details are provided in Section 53.4. - -Development/Modernization/Enhancement Expenditures are the costs for projects leading to new IT assets -and projects that change or modify existing IT assets to: improve capability or performance, implement -legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet agency leadership requests. These expenditures correspond to -capitalized costs, and expenses may include: hardware; software; Federal and contracted labor for system -planning, development, acquisition, and integration; and direct overhead and project management. If non- -repairable or non-working IT hardware or software is replaced to continue the operation of an asset, and as a -result improves the capability or performance of an asset, the expense should be categorized as operations. - -FEA BRM Services include three-digit codes that indicate the service area served by the investment. The first -three-digit code indicates the primary service area (the three-digit BRM service code) and the second through -fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with the investment. Guidance on providing -appropriate FEA BRM Services mapping codes can be found at FEA Reference Model document library. - -Page 15 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -Functional/Business Sponsor is the name of the agency official who is responsible for the program or -function supported or implemented by the investment {44 U.S.C. 3501 (a) (4)}. The sponsor is responsible -for expressing the value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for -the IT investment to the agency CIO and OMB. The designated person may (or may not) be the same as the -“Business Process owner/Subject Matter Expert” listed for a major investment on the Exhibit 300A under -Integrated Program Team. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must include the name -of the functional/business sponsor as well as the individual’s title, phone number, and e-mail address. - -Funding Source means for each investment, the agency must identify the funding source and budgetary -resources, including the MAX funding codes used for the investment. An agency should add as many funding -source line items as are appropriate for the investment. To avoid double counting or under counting, the totals -of the funding amounts for an investment must match the main investment line item, represented with the -investment category of "00," "24," or “48.” See definition in section 4. - -Government FTE Number and Percentage means the number of government FTE included in the BY -funding and the percentage of the total BY cost represented by the number of government FTE. This applies -to all investments, both major and non-major. If an FTE’s costs are included in the investment costs for BY, -the FTE or portion of the FTE should be reported, regardless of the FTE’s role in the investment (technical, -managerial, functional, etc.). - -Homeland Security Priority Identifier means an IT investment supporting the homeland security mission -areas of 1) Intelligence and warning, 2) Border and transportation security, 3) Defense against catastrophic -threats, 4) Protection of critical infrastructure and key assets, 5) Emergency preparedness and response, 6) -Other, 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which one(s) by -listing the corresponding number(s) listed above. - -Homeland Security Presidential Directive-12 (HSPD-12) Costs refer to all costs to implement or provide -logical access to the systems within the investment for the PY, per HSPD-12. HPSD-12 costs should be -provided for all relevant investments, both major and non-major. - -Investment Description means a short public-facing description (limited to 255 characters) for each -investment (major, migration, partner contribution, and non-major). This description should explain the -purpose of the investment and what program(s) it supports, including the value to the public. The description -should be understandable to someone who is not an expert of the agency. If the investment is part of a multi- -agency initiative or another business case, the agency should describe where that business case is located in -the appropriate agency Budget submission (e.g., managing partner UII). For example, if the investment -represents your agency's participation in one of the Presidential initiatives, the description should state this -information and refer to the UII of the managing partner's business case. - -Investment Title means a definitive title explaining the investment. For "funding source" information, -provide the 10-digit OMB MAX account code (OMB Circular A-11, Section 79.2). To the extent that they are -not part of the name used by the agency, other identifiers such as bureaus or other numeric codes should not -be included as part of an Investment Title. - -Operations & Maintenance (Steady State) Costs describes the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in -the O&M life cycle phase. Operations expenses include maintenance projects and operation costs needed to -sustain the IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including: Federal and contracted labor -costs, corrective hardware and software maintenance, voice and data communications maintenance and -service, replacement of broken or obsolete IT equipment, and overhead costs. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Previous UII means the identifier depicting agency code and unique investment number used to report the -investment in the previous BY Exhibit 53 submission to OMB. Indicating the UII used for a previous +Americans (47%) now +say Trump will be an +unsuccessful president +in the long term. This share is up 14 points since last year, with most of this change +occurring among Democrats. A majority of Republicans continue to say Trump will be +successful in the long run. -Page 16 of 45 Exhibit 53 +▪ Trump’s approval among Republicans is now 73% – down slightly since - (2012) +September. Older Americans, White adults and those without a college degree continue to +approve of his performance more than others. See detailed tables for additional demographic +breaks. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +www.pewresearch.org -submission allows cross-walk and historical analysis crossing FYs for tracking purposes. Previous UII is -mandatory, with the exception of new investments. To indicate consolidations/splits/reorganizations, agencies -can provide more than one entry and separate UIIs with commas. -Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding refers to an IT investment that supports the -information sharing, access, and safeguarding mission areas of: 1) The national network of state and major -urban area fusion centers; 2) Assured interoperability across Controlled Unclassified Information /Sensitive -but Unclassified networks targeting Federal, state, local, and tribal law enforcement, public safety, homeland -security, and intelligence personnel; 3) Assured interoperability across classified SECRET networks; 4) -Nationwide suspicious activity reporting initiative; 5) Alerts, Warnings and Notifications; and 6) Case and -event deconfliction; or 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which -one(s) by listing the corresponding number(s) listed above. + 9 -(b) Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery Areas and Management Support Areas1 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report all IT investments directly supporting an agency-designated mission delivery area or management -support area (“Mission delivery area” means programs or activities that execute the agency mission as -outlined in the agency strategic plan. “Management support area” means activities such as human resource -management, financial management, and command and control.). The investments support these mission -deliveries should be consistent with your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. Include capital -costs (planning, development, modernization, and enhancement) and O&M expenses for each IT investment. +Appendix: Additional charts -Agencies must include an area titled “Financial Management,” and it must be reported as the first area. -Report all IT investments for major financial management systems in this area. +Confidence in Trump on several key qualities and +abilities needed to serve as president -(c) Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are +extremely/very confident that Donald Trump … -Report all IT investments supporting planning, development, modernization, enhancement, operation, and -maintenance of common user systems such as IT infrastructure and IT security. Each agency may submit -multiple Exhibits 300 encompassing office automation, infrastructure, security, and telecommunications for -the agency. These investments may be defined at the bureau level and/or by functional components of the -infrastructure. These IT infrastructure investments may support multiple mission areas and should include -end-user services and support, mainframes and servers services and support, and telecommunications services -and support. IT infrastructure includes direct costs—those that produce tangible IT products or services for -business users—and indirect costs—those that do not lead to a tangible product or direct support of business -users—such as IT program management costs and overhead expenses. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Agencies are encouraged to report these investments as they are managed. If IT infrastructure is managed at -both the agency and bureau levels, agencies should report both agency and bureau-level infrastructure -investments. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -(d) Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions +www.pewresearch.org -Report all IT investments supporting the strategic management of IT operations (e.g., business process -redesign efforts that are not part of an individual investment, EA development, capital planning and -investment control processes, procurement management, IT policy development and implementation). IT -investments in this part of Exhibit 53A should include costs for CIO functions. + 10 -(e) Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -1 For the purpose of Exhibit 53, IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions remain in Part 3 and IT -Investments for Grants Management Systems remain in Part 4. +Will Trump be a successful president in the long term? -Page 17 of 45 Exhibit 53 +% who say Donald Trump will be a(n) ___ president in the long run - (2012) +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report all IT investments supporting information regarding the planning, development, modernization, -enhancement, and operation of grants management systems. +Have the Trump administration’s actions since taking +office in 2025 been better or worse than expected? -(f) Part 5. National Security Systems Investments +% who say the Trump administration’s actions since taking office last year +have been ___ expected -Report all IT investments that represent planning, development, modernization, enhancement, and operation -of national security systems. Only the Department of Defense should report investments in Part 5. +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -(g) Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report amounts for grants to state and local agencies that fund the planning, development, modernization, -enhancement, and operation of state and local IT systems. Agencies should only use Part 6 to report "Grants -to State and Local” and not the systems that support these grant activities. Before using Part 6 for anything -other than these types of investments, check with your agency’s OMB E-Gov analyst. +www.pewresearch.org -Agency Security Portfolio (Exhibit 53B) + 11 -The Agency Security Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual investment level. -Exhibit 53B uses the following data elements (as they appear in Exhibit 53B). Note that eight data elements -that were previously provided separately (see the BY2012 Exhibit 53B guidance) are to be reported in the -aggregate of “Total IT Security Tools Costs.” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Virus)—a program that monitors desktops/laptops to identify all +Public support for Trump’s policies and plans -major types of viruses and prevent or contain virus incidents. +% who say they support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and plans - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Malware)—a program that monitors a computer or network to +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -identify all major types of malware and prevent or contain malware incidents. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Data Leakage Protection Tools)—systems designed to detect and -prevent the unauthorized use and transmission of confidential information including encryption for -PII. +www.pewresearch.org - Total IT Security Tools Costs (E-mail Filtering Software)—software that organizes e-mail according + 12 -to defined criteria, most commonly used for detecting and eliminating spam and malware. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Detection System [IDS])—software that looks for suspicious +Trump’s approval rating in first year of +his second term -activity on networks and alerts administrators. +% who approve of the way Donald Trump is handling +his job as president - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Prevention System [IPS])—systems that can detect an -intrusive activity on networks and attempt to stop the activity, ideally before it reaches its targets. - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Security Information Management [SIM]/Security Information and -Event Management [SIEM])—software/systems that collect security data (e.g., event logs) into a -central repository for trend analysis. +84 - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Web filtering software—also known as Content-Control software or -Censorware)—software designed and optimized for controlling what content is permitted to a reader, -especially when it is used to restrict material delivered over the web. Content-control software -determines what content will be available. +Rep/Lean Rep -Page 18 of 45 Exhibit 53 +80 - (2012) +75 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +78 -Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio (Exhibit 53C) +74 -The Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual -investment level. Exhibit 53C is comprised of two tables to report the following data elements for each year -(PY, CY, BY). Note that the sum of each year should match across the two tables and this sum should match -the sum of columns 41 to 43 of Exhibit 53A. For definitions of terms used in Exhibit 53C, see NIST Special -Publication 800-146. Only costs directly attributable to cloud computing implementations, operations or -services should be reported, which may only be a portion of the total cost of contributing/associated -investments. +Total -(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (PY, CY, BY) +47 - Public Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Private Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Community Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Hybrid Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending +40 -(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (PY, CY, BY) +41 - Software as a Service (SaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Platform as a Service (PaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending - +38 40 -Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending +Dem/Lean Dem -53.4 How is Exhibit 53A coded? +10 -Use the following UII 12-digit line number coding, and additional six 2-digit variable information fields, to -categorize investments and line structure for your Exhibit 53A. Each investment identified in the agency's -portfolio must have a unique UII. +7 -Entry +7 -Description +6 -Unique Investment Identifier Primary Key +6 -XXX- -xxxxxxxxx +73 -xxx- -XXXXXXXXX +37 -The first three digits represent your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +5 -The last nine digits serve as your unique identifier. This identifier should be system -generated and applied at the agency level. It will allow agencies up to one billion unique -identifiers to associate with IT investments. Once used, the unique identifier must be -retired. If an IT investment is retired, discontinued, or merged with another IT -investment, the unique identifier persists with that IT investment. +Feb '25 -Note: “99999XXXX” codes are reserved for approved multi-agency investments, -including E-Gov and LoB initiatives +Jan '26 -Page 19 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - (2012) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +www.pewresearch.org -Variable Information: The following attributes extracted from the FY 2012 Budget cycle and prior years’ -UPI should continue to be supplied. + 13 -XX-xx- -xx-xx- -xx-xx +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -xx-XX- -xx-xx- -xx-xx +Acknowledgments -xx-xx- -XX-xx- -xx -xx +This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals: -xx-xx- -xx-XX- -xx-xx +Research team -xx-xx- -xx-xx- -XX-xx +Communications and editorial -00 = Code for all investments other than those coded “24” or “48” +Jocelyn Kiley, Director, Political Research +Steven Shepard, Associate Director, Political +Research +Hannah Hartig, Senior Researcher +Baxter Oliphant, Senior Researcher +Gabe Borelli, Research Associate +Andrew Daniller, Research Associate +Andy Cerda, Research Analyst +Joseph Copeland, Research Analyst +Shanay Gracia, Research Analyst +Ted Van Green, Research Analyst -24 = E-Gov initiatives or an individual agency's participation in one of the E-Gov initiatives +Nida Asheer, Senior Communications +Manager +Maya Pottinger, Communications Associate +David Kent, Senior Editorial Specialist +Anna Jackson, Editorial Specialist -48 = Any multi-agency collaboration or an individual agency’s participation in one of the multi-agency -initiatives, excluding E-Gov initiatives +Graphic design and web publishing -The next two digits indicate your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). If this is -a department level or an agency-wide activity, use 00 as your bureau code. +Peter Bell, Associate Director, Design and +Production +Alissa Scheller, Senior Information Graphics +Designer +Reem Nadeem, Digital Producer +Beshay Sakla, Associate Digital Producer -These two digits indicate the six parts of Exhibit 53: +Methodology -01 = Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support Area +Andrew Mercer, Senior Research +Methodologist +Dorene Asare-Marfo, Senior Panel Manager +Dana Popky, Associate Panel Manager +Arnold Lau, Research Methodologist -02 = Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications +www.pewresearch.org -03 = Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions + 14 -04 = Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -05 = Part 5. National Security Systems IT Investments (Department of Defense Only) -06 = Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments +Methodology -These two digits indicate the mission delivery and management support areas. Agencies should -assign a unique code for each mission delivery and management support area reported. +The American Trends Panel -These two digits indicate your agency's type of investment. Select one of the following two digit -codes according to the type of investment you are reporting: +survey methodology -01 = Major IT investments (see definition in Section 4) +Overview -02 = Non-major IT investments (see definition in Section 4) +Data in this report comes from Wave 185 of the American Trends Panel (ATP), Pew Research +Center’s nationally representative panel of randomly selected U.S. adults. The survey was +conducted from Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. A total of 8,512 panelists responded out of 9,302 who +were sampled, for a survey-level response rate of 92%. -03 = IT migration investment portion of a larger asset and for which there is an existing business case for the -overall asset. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of -the managing partner. +The cumulative response rate accounting for all stages of nonresponse and attrition is 3%. The +break-off rate among panelists who logged on to the survey and completed at least one item is 2%. +The margin of sampling error for the full sample of 8,512 respondents is plus or minus 1.4 +percentage points. -04 = Investments where the business case for the major IT investment is reported in another agency's Exhibit -53. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of the -managing partner. +The survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 in order +to provide more precise estimates of the opinions and experiences of these smaller demographic +subgroups. These oversampled groups are weighted back to reflect their correct proportions in the +population. -xx-xx- -xx-xx- -xx-XX +SSRS conducted the survey for Pew Research Center via online (n=8,272) and live telephone +(n=240) interviewing. Interviews were conducted in both English and Spanish. -These two digits identify the nature of the “line item” in the Exhibit 53 structure. The digits -represent the line number in both the XML format used for agencies on the IT Dashboard and the -line number in an equivalent spreadsheet file (CSV or XLS file), for agencies not on the IT -Dashboard: +To learn more about the ATP, read “About the American Trends Panel.” -00 = Total investment title line, structurally the first line for reporting this particular investment +Panel recruitment -04 = Funding source or appropriation -[09 = Any subtotal – This value is only used only for agencies not on the IT Dashboard] +Since 2018, the ATP has used address-based sampling (ABS) for recruitment. A study cover letter +and a pre-incentive are mailed to a stratified, random sample of households selected from the U.S. +Postal Service’s Computerized Delivery Sequence File. This Postal Service file has been estimated +to cover 90% to 98% of the population.1 Within each sampled household, the adult with the next +birthday is selected to participate. Other details of the ABS recruitment protocol have changed +over time but are available upon request.2 Prior to 2018, the ATP was recruited using landline and +cellphone random-digit-dial surveys administered in English and Spanish. -Page 20 of 45 Exhibit 53 +1 AAPOR Task Force on Address-based Sampling. 2016. “AAPOR Report: Address-based Sampling.” +2 Email pewsurveys@pewresearch.org. - (2012) +www.pewresearch.org - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO + 15 -Use the following 10-digit number coding system to update or complete your OMB MAX account ID code -information: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Entry +A national sample of U.S. adults has been recruited to the ATP approximately once per year since +2014. In some years, the recruitment has included additional efforts (known as an “oversample”) +to improve the accuracy of data for underrepresented groups. For example, Hispanic adults, Black +adults and Asian adults were oversampled in 2019, 2022 and 2023, respectively. -Description +Sample design -XXX-xx-xxxx-x +The overall target population for this survey was noninstitutionalized persons ages 18 and older +living in the United States. It featured a stratified random sample from among ATP members who +previously completed Wave 183. Non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18 to 29 were selected +with certainty. The remaining panelists were sampled at rates designed to ensure that the share of +respondents in each stratum is proportional to its share of the U.S. adult population to the greatest +extent possible. Respondent weights are adjusted to account for differential probabilities of +selection as described in the Weighting section below. -The first three digits are your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +Questionnaire development and testing -xxx-XX-xxxx-x +The questionnaire was developed by Pew Research Center in consultation with SSRS. The web +program used for online respondents was rigorously tested on both PC and mobile devices by the +SSRS project team and Pew Research Center researchers. The SSRS project team also populated +test data that was analyzed in SPSS to ensure the logic and randomizations were working as +intended before launching the survey. -The next two digits are your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +Incentives -xxx-xx-XXXX-x +All respondents were offered a post-paid incentive for their participation. Respondents could +choose to receive the post-paid incentive in the form of a check or gift code to Amazon.com, +Target.com or Walmart.com. Incentive amounts ranged from $5 to $20 depending on whether the +respondent belongs to a part of the population that is harder or easier to reach. Differential +incentive amounts were designed to increase panel survey participation among groups that +traditionally have low survey response propensities. -This is a four-digit account symbol for the appropriate MAX account (see Section 79.2 of -OMB Circular A-11). +Data collection protocol -xxx-xx-xxxx-X +The data collection field period for this survey was Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. Surveys were +conducted via self-administered web survey or by live telephone interviewing. -This is a single digit Transmittal Code (see Section 79.2 of OMB Circular A-11). -For the purposes of Exhibit 53A only, funding sources should continue to utilize the “-9” transmittal code to -flag funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA). +www.pewresearch.org -Use the following set of 3-digit numbers to identify each investment’s primary service area and, if desired, up -to four secondary service areas: + 16 -Entry +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Description +For panelists who take surveys online:3 Postcard notifications were mailed to a subset on +Jan. 20.4 Survey invitations were sent out in two separate launches: soft launch and full launch. +Sixty panelists were included in the soft launch, which began with an initial invitation sent on Jan. +20. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking sampled online panelists were included in the +full launch and were sent an invitation on Jan. 21. -XXX (primary services) +Invitation and reminder dates for web respondents, +ATP Wave -The first three digits identify the investment’s primary service area from the -FEA BRM version 3.0. +Soft launch -XXX (secondary services) +Jan. 20, 2026 -The second, third, fourth, and fifth set of three digits identify the investment’s -secondary service area(s) from the FEA BRM version 3.0. Agencies should -select from the following three-digit codes to map investments to primary and -secondary service areas. +Jan. 22, 2026 -53.5 What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53? +Jan. 24, 2026 -Exhibit 53 is separated into four sub-exhibits. The following table provides step-by-step instructions to -complete each part. See Section 4 and 53.3 for definitions. +Full launch -AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO +Jan. 21, 2026 -Entry +Jan. 22, 2026 -Description +Jan. 24, 2026 -Part 1. IT Investments for -Mission Delivery Area -and Management Support -Area +Initial invitation -Report IT investments that directly support an agency-designated mission -delivery and management support area as well as the mission delivery and -management support area it supports. This information should map directly to -your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. For IT investments that -cover more than one agency, report in the mission area with oversight of the IT -investment. Mission delivery and management support area 01 is reserved for IT -investments for major financial management systems. +First reminder -Page 21 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Final reminder - (2012) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Panelists participating online were sent an email invitation and up to two email reminders if they +did not respond to the survey. ATP panelists who consented to SMS messages were sent an SMS +invitation with a link to the survey and up to two SMS reminders. -IT investments for infrastructure, IT security, office automation, and -telecommunications are reported in Part 2 of Exhibit 53A. Report all IT -investments supporting common user systems, security, communications, and -computing infrastructure. Each agency may have multiple Exhibit 300s -encompassing office automation, infrastructure, IT security, and -telecommunications for the agency. It is encouraged that these investments be -reported at the point of management and thus may be defined at the bureau level -and/or by functional components of the infrastructure. These may involve -multiple mission areas and include end-user systems and support, mainframes -and servers services and support, and telecommunications services and support. -All IT investments capturing these shared services are to be included in Part 2. +For panelists who take surveys over the phone with a live interviewer: Prenotification +postcards were mailed on Jan. 16. Soft launch took place on Jan. 20 and involved dialing until a +total of four interviews had been completed. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking +sampled phone panelists’ numbers were dialed throughout the remaining field period. Panelists +who take surveys via phone can receive up to six calls from trained SSRS interviewers. -List all EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments. For the -President's Budget, EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments are -not categorized as major investments and an Exhibit 300 is not required for them. -Any capital planning and investment control process investments may be -reported separately in this section. However, agencies should ensure that -investments identified in variable information coding as belonging in Part 3 of -Exhibit 53A have the correct primary FEA mapping in order to clearly -distinguish the EA investments from other planning investments. +Data quality checks -Report IT investments that support grants management operations. See -classification instructions in Section 53.3a under Grants Management. +To ensure high-quality data, Center researchers performed data quality checks to identify any +respondents showing patterns of satisficing. This includes checking for whether respondents left +questions blank at very high rates or always selected the first or last answer presented. As a result +of this checking, two ATP respondents were removed from the survey dataset prior to weighting +and analysis. -Part 2. IT Investments for -Infrastructure, IT -Security, Office -Automation, and -Telecommunications +3 The ATP does not use routers or chains in any part of its online data collection protocol, nor are they used to direct respondents to additional +surveys. +4 Postcard notifications for web panelists are sent to 1) panelists who were recruited within the last two years and 2) panelists recruited prior +to the last two years who opt to continue receiving postcard notifications. -Part 3. IT Investments for -EA, Capital Planning, and -CIO Functions +www.pewresearch.org -Part 4. IT Investments for -Grants Management -Systems + 17 -Part 5. National Security -Systems IT Investments +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report IT investments related to national security systems (Department of -Defense only). +American Trends Panel weighting dimensions -Part 6. Grants to State -and Local IT Investments +Variable +Age (detailed) +Age x Gender +Education x Gender +Education x Age +Race/Ethnicity x Education +Race/Ethnicity x Gender +Race/Ethnicity x Age +Born inside vs. outside the U.S. among +Hispanics and Asian Americans +Years lived in the U.S. +Census region x Metropolitan status -Report total amounts for IT investments for grants to state and local -governments. +Volunteerism -Page 22 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Frequency of internet use +Religious affiliation +Party affiliation x Race/Ethnicity +Party affiliation x Age - (2012) +Validated 2024 presidential election +turnout and vote choice - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Benchmark source -AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO (COLUMNS) +2023 American Community Survey +(ACS) -The following columns are required for the President's Budget Exhibit 53A, Agency IT Investment Portfolio: +2023 CPS Volunteering & Civic Life +Supplement +2025 National Public Opinion +Reference Survey (NPORS) -Column 1: Previous UII (12 digits required for all legacy investments) +Candidate vote share is based on +official results from the Federal +Election Commission. Turnout is +based on estimates from the Election +Lab at the University of Florida. The +size of the voting-eligible population is +based on the 2023 ACS. -Column 2: Current UII (12-digit primary key for all investments) +Note: Estimates from the ACS are based on noninstitutionalized adults. For weighting to the +2024 presidential election results, panelists are considered validated voters if their self- +report of having voted was confirmed after matching to a national voter registry. -Column 3: Investment Category (2-digit code) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 4: Bureau Code (2-digit code) (variable element) +Weighting -Column 5: Part of Exhibit 53 (2-digit code) (variable element) +The ATP data is weighted in a +process that accounts for +multiple stages of sampling and +nonresponse that occur at +different points in the panel +survey process. First, each +panelist begins with a base +weight that reflects their +probability of recruitment into +the panel. These weights are +then calibrated to align with the +population benchmarks in the +accompanying table to correct +for nonresponse to recruitment +surveys and panel attrition. If +only a subsample of panelists +was invited to participate in the +wave, this weight is adjusted to +account for any differential +probabilities of selection. +Because respondents to this +wave were sampled from +among respondents to Wave +183, the weights were also +adjusted to account for +nonresponse to Wave 183. -Column 6: Mission Delivery and Management Support Area (2-digit code) (variable element) +Among the panelists who completed the survey, this weight is then calibrated again to align with +the population benchmarks identified in the accompanying table and trimmed at the 1st and 99th +percentiles to reduce the loss in precision stemming from variance in the weights. Sampling errors +and tests of statistical significance take into account the effect of weighting. -Column 7: Type of Investment (2-digit code) (variable element) +www.pewresearch.org -Column 8: Line Item Descriptor (2-digit code) (variable element) + 18 -Column 9: Change in Investment Status Identifier (2-digit code) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 10: Agency Description of Change in Investment Status (limited to 255 characters) +The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that +would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the survey. -Column 11: Investment Title +Sample sizes and margins of error, ATP Wave 185 -Column 12: Investment Description (limited to 255 characters) +Group +Total sample -Column 13: FEA BRM Services – Primary service area (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 14: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #1 (3-digit code) +Rep/Lean Rep -Column 15: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #2 (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 16: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #3 (3-digit code) +Dem/Lean Dem -Column 17: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #4 (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 18: Homeland Security Priority Identifier (select all that apply) +Unweighted +sample size +8,512 -Column 19: HSPD-12 Cost (PY/2012) ($M) +At least 4,250 -Column 20: Cross-Boundary Information Identifier (1-digit code) +3,913 -Column 21: Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding (select all that apply) +At least 1,953 -Column 22: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M) +4,343 -Column 23: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M) +At least 2,164 -Column 24: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M) +Weighted % -Column 25: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M) +46% -Column 26: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M) +48% -Column 27: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M) +Plus or minus … +1.4 percentage points -Column 28: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M) +2.0 percentage points -Column 29: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M) +2.1 percentage points -Column 30: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M) +3.0 percentage points -Column 31: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M) +2.0 percentage points -Column 32: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M) +2.8 percentage points -Column 33: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M) +Note: This survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 respondents. Unweighted +sample sizes do not account for the sample design or weighting and do not describe a group’s contribution to weighted +estimates. See the Sample design and Weighting sections above for details. -Column 34: Number of Government FTEs (BY/2014) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 35: Percentage of Investment Cost for Government FTE (BY/2014) +Sample sizes and sampling errors for other subgroups are available upon request. In addition to +sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in +conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls. -Column 36: Functional/Business Sponsor Name +www.pewresearch.org -Column 37: Functional/Business Sponsor Title + 19 -Column 38: Functional/Business Sponsor Phone Number +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 39: Functional/Business Sponsor E-mail +Dispositions and response rates -Column 40: Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation +Final dispositions, ATP Wave 185 -Column 41: Cloud Computing Spending (PY) +Completed interview -Column 42: Cloud Computing Spending (CY) -Column 43: Cloud Computing Spending (BY) +Logged in (web) / Contacted (CATI), but did not complete any items -Page 23 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Started survey; broke off before completion - (2012) +Never logged on (web) / Never reached on phone (CATI) - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Survey completed after close of the field period -AGENCY IT SECURITY PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53B) +Other non-interview -Row +Completed interview but was removed for data quality -Description +Total panelists sampled for the survey -1 Agency code +Completed interviews -2 Number of government -FTEs with information -security responsibilities +Partial interviews -3 Average cost per +Refusals -government FTE with -information security -responsibilities +Non-contact -4 Number of contractor -FTEs with information -security responsibilities +Other -5 +Unknown household -6 +Unknown other -Average cost per -contractor FTE for -information security -responsibilities +Not eligible -Total IT security tools -cost +Total -List the three-digit agency identifier (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A- -11). +AAPOR RR1 = I / (I+P+R+NC+O+UH+UO) -Report the number of government employees with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to these responsibilities. This number should -include but should not be limited to: designated security officers, network -security staff, system administrators, and system owners. The number -should not include individuals responsible for physical security, such as -guards. The number should be rounded to two decimal places. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Using the salary information of the government employees counted in -“Number of government FTEs with information security responsibilities,” -calculate an average fully loaded cost per government FTE. The average -cost should be represented in dollars and rounded to two decimal places. +Cumulative response rate, ATP Wave 185 -Report the number of contractor staff with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to these responsibilities. The number should be -rounded to two decimal places. +Weighted response rate to recruitment surveys -Using the billing rate of the contract staff counted in “Number of contractor -FTEs with information security responsibilities,” calculate an average -yearly cost per contractor FTE. The average cost should be represented in -dollars and rounded to two decimal places. +% of recruitment survey respondents who agreed to join the +panel, among those invited +% of those agreeing to join who were active panelists at start of +Wave 185 -This is the sum of the following eight data elements, which were formerly -provided separately in Exhibit 53B for the FY 2012 Budget cycle. Costs -should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. +Response rate to Wave 183 survey -1. Anti-Virus Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs incurred +Response rate to Wave 185 survey -or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not -purchase anti-virus software separately from anti-malware software, -enter all costs on the line for anti-malware and leave this line blank. +Cumulative response rate -2. Anti-Malware Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -3. Intrusion Detection Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +© Pew Research Center 2025 -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If you have -an IDS which is part of an IPS, include all costs in IPS and do not list -here. Include the amount paid for the Managed Trusted Internet -Protocol Service via the Networx contract as well as any other -operational IDSs. +www.pewresearch.org -4. Intrusion Prevention Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +Total -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -5. Web Filtering Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +8,512 -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. Costs should -be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. +145 -Page 24 of 45 Exhibit 53 +100 - (2012) +541 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +0 -6. E-mail Filtering Software – The licensing costs incurred or expected -to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not purchase e- -mail filtering software separate from web filtering software, include all -costs in web filtering software and do not list here. +2 -7. SIM/SIEM Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or expected to be +2 -incurred for the respective BY. +9,302 -8. Data Leakage Protection Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or +8,514 -expected to be incurred for the respective BY. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Security -authorization costs should only include contract costs. +245 -Report the number of systems used to in cost calculations for “Costs for -NIST 800-37 implementation.” +541 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all -costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs. +4 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all -costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include -the costs of annual security awareness training required by the FISMA Act. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Do not -include costs associated with annual awareness training. +0 -Report the number of government employees with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported -in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated government FTE costs -(based on the average costs reported in row 3) will be subtracted from the -total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting. +9,302 -Report the number of contractor staff with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported -in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated contractor FTE costs -(based on the average costs reported in row 5) will be subtracted from the -total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting. +92% -7 Costs for NIST 800-37 -implementation +AAPOR code -8 Number of systems +1.1 -scheduled for activities -represented in Row 7 +2.11 -9 Costs for annual FISMA +2.12 -testing +2.20 -10 Costs for network -penetration testing -activities +2.27 -11 Security awareness -training costs +2.30 -12 Security training costs for +2.90 -employees with -significant security -responsibilities +I -13 Number of government +P -FTEs included in costs for -row 7 and rows 9 through +R + +NC + +O + +UH + +UO + +NE + +Total + +12% + +74% + +40% + +92% + +92% + +3% + + 20 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +2026 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL +WAVE 185 POLITICS JANUARY SURVEY +FINAL TOPLINE +January 20-26, 2026 +N=8,512 + +Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This +topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly +modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire. + +American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online +(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys +conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail. +For additional details, visit the Methodology. + +* ”No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents +who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered +as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and +telephone refusals. + +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +SATIS All in all, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in this country today? + +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Oct 6-16, 2025 +Aug 4-10, 2025 +Apr 28-May 4, 2025 +Mar 10-16, 2025 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Nov 12-17, 2024 +Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 +Aug 5-11, 2024 +Jul 1-7, 2024 +May 13-19, 2024 +Jan 16-21, 2024 +Nov 27-Dec 3, 2023 +Jul 10-16, 2023 +Jun 5-11, 2023 +Mar 27-Apr 2, 2023 +Jan 18-24, 2023 +Nov 16-27, 2022 +Oct 10-16, 2022 +Aug 1-14, 2022 +Apr 25-May 1, 2022 +Jan 10-17, 2022 +Sep 20-26, 2021 +Sep 13-19, 2021 +Mar 1-7, 2021 +Nov 12-17, 2020 +Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 +Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020 + +Satisfied +29 +27 +34 +32 +34 +38 +29 +23 +24 +18 +22 +21 +22 +22 +21 +19 +22 +24 +21 +18 +24 +21 +25 +26 +33 +22 +18 12 -14 Number of contractor - -FTEs included in costs for -row 7 and rows 9 through +Dissatisfied +69 +72 +65 +67 +65 +61 +70 +76 +75 +82 +78 +78 +77 +77 +78 +80 +78 +75 +79 +81 +75 +78 +74 +74 +66 +77 +82 +87 + +No answer* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 + +www.pewresearch.org + + 21 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +SATIS CONTINUED … + +Jun 16-22, 2020 +Apr 7-12, 2020 +Mar 19-24, 2020 +Oct 29-Nov 11, 2019 +Oct 1-13, 2019 +Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019 +Nov 27-Dec 10, 2018 +Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018 +Feb 28-Mar 12, 20175 +Sep 27-Oct 10, 2016 +Jun 7-Jul 5, 2016 +Sep 15-Oct 3, 2014 + +Satisfied 12 +31 +33 +31 +28 +27 +34 +36 +32 +23 +19 +25 + +Dissatisfied +87 +68 +66 +69 +71 +72 +65 +63 +68 +75 +80 +75 + +No answer* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +2 +1 +* + +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +YEARAHEAD + +Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that 2026 will be … +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1] + +Better than 2025 Worse than 2025 + +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Jan 16-21, 2024 +Jan 18-24, 2023 +Jan 10-17, 2022 +Jan 8-12, 2021 +Jan 6-19, 2020 + +50 +55 +55 +57 +61 +67 +55 + +48 +45 +45 +43 +38 +32 +43 + +No answer* +1 +* +1 +* +1 +1 +2 + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: +Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that [coming year] will be better or worse +than [prior year]? + +Jan 8-13, 2020 +Jan 9-14, 2019 +Jan 10-15, 2018 +Jan 4-9, 2017 +Jan 7-14, 2016 +Dec 3-7, 2014 (U) +Jan 15-19, 2014 +Dec 5-9, 2012 +Jan 11-16, 2012 +Dec 1-5, 2010 +Jan 6-10, 2010 +Jan 7-11, 2009 +December, 2007 +December, 2006 +December, 1999 +December, 1998 +December, 1994 +Gallup: December, 1993 + +Better +55 +47 +61 +49 +56 +49 +56 +55 +57 +55 +67 +52 +50 +57 +66 +59 +59 +64 + +Worse +34 +43 +29 +42 +30 +42 +35 +36 +29 +31 +26 +37 +34 +28 +19 +25 +28 +20 + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref +11 +10 +11 +9 +14 +9 +9 +9 +14 +14 +8 +11 +16 +15 +15 +16 +13 +16 + +1 + +The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only. + +www.pewresearch.org + + 22 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED + +Gallup: December, 1992 +Gallup: December, 1991 +Gallup: December, 1990 +Gallup: December, 1986 +Gallup: December, 1985 +Gallup: December, 1984 +Gallup: December, 1982 +Gallup: December, 1981 + +Better +61 +61 +48 +53 +64 +61 +50 +41 + +Worse +11 +31 +42 +25 +20 +20 +32 +44 + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref +28 +8 +10 +22 +17 +19 +18 +15 + +ASK ALL: +POL1DT +ASK IF ANSWERED POL1DT (POL1DT=1,2) [N=8,378]: +POL1DTSTR + +Do you approve or disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling his job as president? + +Do you [IF POL1DT=1: approve; IF POL1DT=2: disapprove] of the way Donald Trump is +handling his job as president… + +NET +Approve + +Very +strongly + +Not so +strongly + +No +answer* + +NET +Disapprove + +Very +strongly + +Not so +strongly + +No +answer* + +No +answer* + +Trump Second Term +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Sep 22-28, 2025 +Aug 4-10, 2025 +Jun 2-8, 2025 +Apr 7-13, 2025 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 + +Trump First Term +Jan 8-12, 2021 +Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020 +Jun 16-22, 2020 +Apr 7-12, 2020 +Mar 19-24, 2020 +Jan 6-19, 2020 +Sep 3-15, 2019 +Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019 +Apr 29-May 13, 2019 +Feb 4-17, 2019 +Nov 7-13, 2018 +Sep 24-Oct 7, 2018 +Jul 30-Aug 12, 2018 +Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018 +Aug 8-21, 2017 +Apr 4-18, 2017 +Feb 28-Mar 12, 20176 + +37 +40 +38 +41 +40 +47 + +29 +38 +39 +44 +45 +40 +40 +40 +40 +38 +41 +38 +40 +38 +36 +39 +44 + +27 +29 +27 +30 +31 +37 + +21 +n/a +29 +33 +34 +31 +31 +n/a +29 +n/a +n/a +n/a +31 +29 +26 +27 +30 + +10 +10 +11 +11 +9 +9 + +7 +n/a +9 +10 +10 +9 +9 +n/a +10 +n/a +n/a +n/a +9 +9 +10 +12 +13 + +* +1 +* +* +* +* + +* +n/a +1 +1 +1 +* +* +n/a +* +n/a +n/a +n/a +* +* +* +* +* + +61 +58 +60 +58 +59 +51 + +68 +59 +59 +53 +52 +58 +58 +59 +59 +61 +58 +61 +59 +60 +63 +61 +56 + +49 +47 +47 +46 +48 +40 + +56 +n/a +48 +42 +40 +46 +46 +n/a +48 +n/a +n/a +n/a +48 +48 +49 +45 +43 -Note: Exhibit 53B should not include security costs typically embedded in IT investments, such as destruction -of data (e.g., degaussing, shredding), physical or logical access control software, continuous monitoring -software, tracking and reporting software, and annual disaster recovery and contingency plan tests. - -Page 25 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -AGENCY CLOUD COMPUTING PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53C) - -(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (Dollars in millions) - -PY - -CY - -BY - -Public Cloud - -Private Cloud - -Community Cloud - -Hybrid Cloud - -(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (Dollars in millions) - -PY - -CY - -BY - -SaaS - -PaaS - -IaaS - -Note: Exhibit 53C should describe agency funding for IT investments, not agency contributions. The sum of -all cells in Table (a) should equal the sum of all cells in Table (b) and should equal the sum of columns 41 to -43 in Exhibit 53A. - -Page 26 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -AGENCY IT REDUCTIONS AND REINVESTMENTS (Exhibit 53D) - -When properly managed and applied, IT can create efficiencies, reduce costs, improve service delivery, and -strengthen cybersecurity. But, too often spending on IT is still wasted on duplicative investments, missed -opportunities to leverage economies of scale, rising operational costs that starve new development, and -mismanaged projects that lead to cost overruns and schedule slippages. - -To address this issue, OMB Memorandum M-12-13 included guidance on IT reductions and reinvestments -that agencies should reflect in their FY 2014 budget submission. In accordance with the memorandum, this -section provides more specific guidance on how this information should be reflected in agency budgets, -including additional detail on the nature of cuts and reinvestments and detailed reporting instructions. - -Agencies should propose reductions in IT that represent 10% of their overall spending, and propose a -reinvestment of at least 5%, and up to 10%, of these savings, in priority IT investments for OMB -consideration. To do this, agencies are required to report the specific investments in which they propose cuts -and the specific investments in which they propose to reinvest funds. - -(a) What Agencies Will Provide - -As part of their FY 2014 budget submission, agencies are asked to complete the new Exhibit 53D (a -downloadable template is available on OMB MAX; final submission will be made via OMB MAX). This -new exhibit will allow agencies to show how they achieved the 10% reduction called for in the memorandum, -and where they propose to reinvest some of these savings. The template, OMB MAX data collection exercise, -and detailed technical instructions are available here. - -Please use the following guidelines when providing specific data on the proposed cuts and reinvestments from -FY 2013 to FY 2014: - - Agencies should provide the following for each cut and reinvestment: -o Specific IT investments and OMB accounts impacted, -o Related category of the cut or reinvestment (provided in MAX exercise) and explanation, -o Priority level and a description of the return on investment (reinvestments only); - - - -Information supplied in Exhibit 53D should be consistent with information supplied in Exhibits 53A, -B and C, and Exhibits 300A and B; - - Agencies should include, in their FY 2014 budget submissions to OMB, a summary of all the -information provided in Exhibit 53D, and the general approach the agency took to achieve its -reductions and reinvestments; and - - Reductions and reinvestments apply Department-wide and should not solely target investments from - -agency-level IT or administrative accounts. - -(b) What Agencies Should Cut - -Regarding required reductions, OMB M-12-13 states “…include an explanation of how, at the investment and -account level, you would achieve this reduction.” - -The 10% cuts should reduce agency spending in the following IT areas: - - Duplicative commodity IT investments or contracts (as emphasized in PortfolioStat and consistent - -with OMB Memoranda M-11-29 and M-12-10) include: - -IT infrastructure (e.g. data centers, networks, desktops, and/or mobile devices) - -o -o Enterprise IT systems (e.g. email, help desk, collaboration, identify and access management, - -security and web infrastructure) - -o Business systems (e.g. HR, FM, and other administrative functions); - Underperforming projects/investments of any type (as emphasized in TechStats); or - -Page 27 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - - Lower-value or lower-priority investments of any type. - -Exemptions from the 10% reduction target must be explicitly granted by OMB. - -(c) Where Agencies Should Reinvest - -Regarding reinvestments, OMB M-12-13, states “your budget submission may also propose where you would -reinvest the savings from identified cuts in innovative IT solutions that would produce a favorable return on -investment within 18 months or demonstrably improve citizen services or administrative efficiencies” - -Agencies should propose 10% cuts in IT and then propose a list of priority reinvestments to OMB up to the -10%. If the Agency does not propose to reinvest at least 5% of these savings into IT, the agency is required to -provide a justification explaining as to why it is unable to propose these reinvestments. Agencies should only -propose reinvestments which demonstrate a favorable return on investment (quantitative or qualitative) to the -agency within 18 months from the enactment of FY 2014 appropriations (excluding CRs). - -Proposed reinvestments should be in the following areas: - -Improvements to citizen services or administrative efficiencies; - - - Adoption of shared services; - Consolidation of commodity IT, including optimizing data centers; - - - - -Improvements to the security posture of the agency’s IT and information assets; -Improvements to the energy efficiency of IT facilities and equipment; -Innovative investments consistent with policy initiatives such as cloud computing, modular -development, reduction of improper payments, and digital government; or - - Data analytics or data management consistent with Administration priorities in Big Data. - -(d) How Much Agencies Should Cut Before Reinvesting - -Regarding the level of reductions, OMB M-12-13, states “…your 2014 budget submission should achieve an -agency-wide 10% reduction in IT spending, compared to the average spending on IT from FY 2010 through -2012” - -The table below shows the effects of the FY 2014 Budget policy for IT spending. Note that while the cut is -calculated as 10% of the average total IT spend from FY 2010-2012, the FY (before proposed reinvestments) -target is reached by applying the cut to the revised FY 2013 President's Budget level (as reported to the IT -Dashboard by agencies in May 2012). - -FY 2013 -(President's -Budget as -of May -2012) - -FY 2014 -10% -Reduction -(2010- -2012) - -$2,611 -$2,396 -$32,669 -$552 -$2,016 -$7,102 -$5,629 - -$252 -$259 -$3,509 -$61 -$205 -$662 -$587 - -Average - (2010- -2012) -$2,524 -$2,589 -$35,086 -$613 -$2,053 -$6,617 -$5,868 - -FY 2014 -Target -(before -reinvestment) -$2,359 -$2,137 -$29,161 -$491 -$1,811 -$6,440 -$5,042 - -FY 2014 -Minimum -(5%) -reinvestment -$126 -$129 -$1,754 -$31 -$103 -$331 -$293 - -FY 2014 -Maximum -(10%) -reinvestment -$252 -$259 -$3,509 -$61 -$205 -$662 -$587 - -Agency -USDA -Commerce -DOD -ED -Energy -HHS -DHS - -Page 28 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -HUD -Interior -Justice -Labor -State -USAID -DOT -Treasury -VA -USACE -EPA -GSA -NASA -NARA -NSF -NRC -OPM -SBA -SI -SSA - -$385 -$988 -$2,850 -$591 -$1,420 -$133 -$2,990 -$3,271 -$3,163 -$544 -$461 -$622 -$1,740 -$137 -$97 -$160 -$78 -$113 -$65 -$1,548 -$76,706 - -$354 -$965 -$2,655 -$606 -$1,369 -$140 -$3,092 -$3,495 -$3,327 -$566 -$465 -$631 -$1,462 -$100 -$97 -$151 -$73 -$112 -$68 -$1,380 -$74,083 - -$38 -$99 -$285 -$59 -$142 -$13 -$299 -$327 -$316 -$54 -$46 -$62 -$174 -$14 -$10 -$16 -$8 -$11 -$6 -$155 -$7,669 - -$316 -$866 -$2,370 -$547 -$1,227 -$127 -$2,793 -$3,168 -$3,011 -$512 -$419 -$569 -$1,288 -$86 -$88 -$135 -$65 -$100 -$61 -$1,226 -$66,415 - -$19 -$49 -$142 -$30 -$71 -$7 -$149 -$164 -$158 -$31 -$23 -$31 -$87 -$7 -$5 -$8 -$4 -$6 -$3 -$77 -$3,838 - -$38 -$99 -$285 -$59 -$142 -$13 -$299 -$327 -$316 -$54 -$46 -$62 -$174 -$14 -$10 -$16 -$8 -$11 -$6 -$155 -$7,669 - -Page 29 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT -OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CAPITAL ASSETS - -300.1 What is the purpose of this guidance? - -OMB provides specific policy, procedural, and analytic guidelines for planning, budgeting, acquisition, and -management of major IT capital investments in addition to general guidance issued in OMB Circular A-11 and -OMB Circular A-130. - -Exhibit 300 describes the justification, planning, and implementation of an individual capital asset included in the -agency IT investment portfolio (as reported in Exhibit 53) and serves as a key artifact of the agency’s EA and IT -CPIC processes. Exhibit 300 is comprised of two components—Exhibit 300A provides inherent investment -information, including general information and planning for resources such as staffing and personnel. Exhibit -300B provides more temporal information, such as projects and activities, risks, and operational performance of -the investment. - -Together, Exhibits 53 and 300 provide the budgetary and management information necessary for sound planning, -management, and governance of IT investments. These documents help agencies explicitly align IT investments -with strategic and performance goals, and ultimately provide value to the public by making investment and -management information more transparent. As architecture-driven IT investments are funded in the "Invest" -phase, they move forward into the implementation phase where system development life cycle processes are -followed and actual outputs, schedule, and operational performance expenditures are tracked versus planned -numbers using performance-based management processes. - -300.2 - - Does Exhibit 300 apply to my agency or IT investment? - -The policy and budget justification principles in Exhibit 300 apply to all agencies of the Executive Branch of the -Federal Government that are subject to Executive Branch review (see Section 25 of OMB Circular A-11). In -accordance with section 5, Exhibits 300A and B must be submitted for each major IT investment. Major IT -investments must be reported on the agency’s Exhibit 53A, along with all non-major investments. - -300.3 How will agencies manage IT capital assets/investments? - -The Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular A-11 provides guidance on the principles and techniques for -effective capital programming. OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J explains the principles of financing capital asset -acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A-130 establishes additional requirements for EAs, planning and -control of information systems and IT investments, and performance management. Agencies must develop and -implement a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio and must: - - Evaluate and select capital assets that will support core mission functions performed by the Federal - -Government and which demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal to or better -than alternative uses of available public resources. Specifically for IT, the investments should be -informed by and should address performance gaps and goals identified in an agency’s strategic plan, -annual performance plan, and EA; -Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative private -sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need; -Implement IT reforms from the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology -Management, such as adhering to modular development principles and the requirement to establish an -IPT prior to funding an IT investment; - - - - - - Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and maximize the - -use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology; - - Assign a functional/business sponsor for each investment who is responsible for the program or -function supported or implemented by the investment. The sponsor is responsible for expressing the - -Page 30 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for the IT -investment to the agency CIO and OMB. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must -include the name of the functional/business sponsor, title, phone number, and e-mail address; - - Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom-designed components, using components that can be -fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring involvement and -support of users in the design and testing of the asset; - - Structure major planning and acquisition into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration. -These segments should make adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between the -Federal Government and contractor. The agency head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and -performance goals for major acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the -proposed cost goals; - - Ensure a continuous linkage between Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency - - - -through alignment with the agency’s Enterprise Roadmap and target architecture, compliance with agency -business requirements and standards, as well as identification of milestones, as defined in the agency’s -EA transition strategy; -Institute performance measures and management processes to monitor and compare actual performance to -planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management system or EVMS, -based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748-B, to obtain timely information regarding the progress of capital -investments, as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR). The system must also measure -progress towards useful components in an independently verifiable basis in terms of cost, capability of the -investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality; - - Per requirements of Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V), agencies are expected -to achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major acquisitions. -Through the TechStat process and as part of the Clinger-Cohen Act responsibly, Agency CIOs should -review major acquisitions that have not achieved 90 percent of the goals to determine whether there is a -continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, should be taken; - - Ensure that the planning and management of agency assets that are IT systems conform to the -requirements of OMB Circular A-130, “Management of Federal Information Resources”; - - Ensure that agency assets that are financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB +12 +11 +13 +12 +10 +11 -Circular A-127; +12 +n/a +11 +11 +11 +11 +11 +n/a +10 +n/a +n/a +n/a +10 +12 +13 +15 +12 - Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition +* +* +* +* +* +* + +* +n/a +* +* +* +1 +1 +n/a +* +n/a +n/a +n/a +* +* +* +* +* + +2 +2 +2 +1 +1 +2 + +3 +3 +2 +3 +2 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +2 +2 +2 +1 +1 +1 + +See past presidents’ approval trends: Joe Biden, Barack Obama, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton -processes and projects to validate estimated costs and benefits and to document effective management -practices (e.g., lessons learned) for broader use; +6 - Establish oversight mechanisms that require periodic review of operational capital assets to determine -how mission requirements might have changed and whether the asset continues to fulfill ongoing and -anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and customers, and meet user -requirements; +The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only. + +www.pewresearch.org + + 23 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +ASK ALL: +DTSUCCESS + +Jan 20-26, +2026 +31 +47 +21 +1 + +In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be… +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1, HOLDING 3 LAST] + +A successful president +An unsuccessful president +Too early to tell +No answer* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +35 +33 +31 +1 + +Jan 6-19, +2020 +34 +48 +18 +1 + +TREND FOR COMPARISON: +In the long run, do you think Joe Biden will be… + +A successful president +An unsuccessful president +Too early to tell +No answer + +Jan 8-12, +2021 +29 +26 +44 +1 + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON +In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be a successful or unsuccessful president, or do you +think it is too early to tell? + +Successful + +Unsuccessful + +Too early +to tell + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref + +Trump +Jan 8-13, 2020 +Jan 9-14, 2019 +Jan 10-15, 2018 +Jan 4-9, 2017 +Obama +Jan 7-14, 2016 +Jan 7-11, 2015 +Jan 15-19, 2014 +Jun 12-16, 2013 +Jan 9-13, 2013 +Jan 11-16, 2012 +Jan 5-9, 2011 +Jan 6-10, 2010 +Sep 30-Oct 4, 2009 +Jan 7-11, 2009 +Bush +January, 2007 +January, 2006 +Early October, 2005 +January, 2005 +December, 2003 +Early October, 2002 +January, 2001 +Clinton +January, 1999 +Early September, 1998 +February, 1995 +October, 1994 +May, 1994 +January, 1994 +October, 1993 +September, 1993 +August, 1993 + +36 +29 +23 +21 + +37 +32 +28 +34 +33 +27 +25 +24 +27 +30 + +24 +27 +26 +36 +39 +40 +26 + +44 +38 +18 +14 +21 +21 +18 +22 +13 + +37 +47 +41 +20 + +34 +38 +34 +31 +26 +32 +26 +21 +18 +4 + +45 +37 +41 +27 +20 +15 +15 + +24 +24 +34 +35 +26 +19 +25 +22 +25 + +26 +23 +34 +58 + +26 +29 +35 +33 +39 +39 +47 +52 +54 +65 + +27 +32 +30 +35 +38 +44 +58 + +29 +35 +43 +48 +52 +57 +56 +54 +60 + +1 +1 +1 +1 + +3 +2 +3 +2 +2 +2 +2 +3 +2 +1 + +4 +4 +3 +2 +3 +1 +1 + +3 +3 +5 +3 +1 +3 +1 +2 +2 - Provide Chief Information Officer (CIO) evaluations for all major investments on the IT Dashboard +www.pewresearch.org -which reflect the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment in terms of its ability -to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, including, but not -limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical performance, -human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to forecasting future success. Each -evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation; -and + 24 - Develop, maintain, and submit the following investment documents and artifacts for all major IT -investments, as applicable. Provide updated versions (including date of last update) as significant -changes are made or as available throughout the investment’s lifecycle: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -o Risk management plan; -o -Investment charter, including IPT; -o -Investment-level alternative analysis and benefit-cost analysis; -o Operational analyses (for operational or mixed life cycle systems); -o Post implementation review results (investment level or project-specific); and, -o Documentation of investment re-baseline management approval(s). +ASK ALL: +QUALPRES_TRMP -Page 31 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, how confident are you that +Donald Trump…7 +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Extremely +confident -300.4 What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill? +Very +confident -Exhibit 300A is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to Congress, as -required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V) and Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996. -The business case (Exhibit 300A) for investment should demonstrate support for the mission statements, long- -term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the GPRA-MA. Exhibit 300B -establishes reporting requirements through the IT Dashboard to ensure the proper execution of those investments -against the established performance plans. +Somewhat +confident -300.5 What must I report on Exhibits 300A and B and when? +Not too +confident -All information necessary to complete Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should already exist as part of the agency's -overall capital planning activities and within project- and program-specific documentation. The materials used to -populate Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should be readily available to OMB upon request. +Not at all +confident -Agencies must submit Exhibit 300s using the following schedule: +No +answer* - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300A: September 10-14, 2012 - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300B: September 14, 2012 - President’s Budget Request Exhibit 300A & B: February 2013 (tentative) +MF -o Submit initial documents/artifacts at this time +Has the mental fitness +needed to do the job + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 20258 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -Unless otherwise noted, IT exhibits and reporting must be submitted electronically to the IT Dashboard. -Additional information regarding the submission process will be posted on the IT Dashboard, including business -rules for the validation of data and a schema that describes how data should be transmitted. As always, pre- -decisional and procurement sensitive information will not be displayed to the public. +▪ -Projects within investments are encouraged to use modular development principles. All projects (regardless of -whether they use modular development principles), must produce usable functionality at intervals of no more than -six months. +PHY ▪ Has the physical fitness -Exhibit 300Bs shall establish cost, schedule and performance targets for CY 2013 and BY 2014. Regular updates -for metrics and activities will be submitted to the IT Dashboard as soon as the data becomes available and at least -once per each calendar month. How periodic performance metrics updates for ongoing operations will be, will -vary according to the nature of the metric, as indicated in Table C1. +needed to do the job + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 20259 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -If an agency requests supplemental funds or reallocates funding within its authority, which includes changes to -the agency's portfolio and the performance targets, agencies should submit a new or revised version of Exhibit -53A as part of their supplemental request. +▪ +▪ +▪ -Multi-Agency Collaboration and Intra-agency Shared Services Investments (must submit both Exhibit 300A -and Exhibit 300B) +FIRM -The managing partners (lead agency that provides services or coordination services to other agencies) will take -the lead in completing and submitting the multi-agency collaboration investment Exhibits 300, managing it -through the managing partner’s capital programming and budget process. The managing partners are also -responsible for ensuring Exhibit 300 includes all necessary information from the partner agencies (customers who -receive services from the managing partners) and have been approved by all necessary partner agencies through -the appropriate governance process. The tracking of the multi-agency approvals, partner agency funding, and -related capital assets (e.g., migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, supporting -components) will be captured via an OMB MAX E-Gov Funding Tool. All initiative program managers or -designated leads should have received details about this in an OMB e-mail distribution dated May 22, 2012. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250] +Has the leadership skills +needed to do the job +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 -Page 32 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +RSP - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Respects the country’s +democratic values +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Apr 8-14, 2024 -For IT assets, partner agencies should report their participation in Exhibit 53 submissions. Partner agencies -should reference the name and UII of the multi-agency Exhibit 300 in the “Investment Description” field of -each Exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency Exhibit 300. Partner agencies should also ensure their -activities and participation are included in the appropriate sections of the multi-agency Exhibit 300. The entire -Summary of Funding Total for the investment, including funds provided by partner agencies, should be included -in Exhibit 300. + ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262] +ADV -Investments that provide a service to other agencies but do not receive contributions from partner agencies -should be reported as Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments. +Picks good advisers + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 202510 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -Investments for multi-agency collaboration, shared services, and/or LoBs will be reflected in the managing -partner's annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to OMB. +▪ +▪ +▪ -Managing partners that provide multi-agency services should ensure that funding is prioritized to -accommodate building and obtaining approval of a shared architecture. Approval should be obtained through -a working governance model that includes partner agencies, customers, and OMB. +ETHETH -OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency collaboration -investment Exhibit 300. When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate data -requests. +Acts ethically in office -Page 33 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Apr 8-14, 2024 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +17 +23 +20 -300.6 How will OMB use Exhibit 300? +12 +17 +15 -Exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total budget justification (see Section 51.2 of OMB Circular A- -11). OMB uses data reported in Exhibit 300 to make quantitative decisions about budgetary resources consistent -with the Administration’s program priorities as well as qualitative assessments about whether the agency’s -programming processes are consistent with OMB policies and guidance. OMB may request additional supporting -information from agencies as necessary. +19 +25 -Exhibit 300A: IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification +13 +17 +17 -Section A: General Information +11 +16 +11 -1. Investment Name: -2. UII. Unique Investment Identifier (see Section 53.4) : +9 +15 +11 -[Limit: 250 char] -[Limit: 13 char] +15 +17 +15 -Section B: Investment Detail +15 +18 +18 -1. Briefly describe the investment’s purpose, goals, and current or anticipated benefits (quantitative and/or -qualitative). Include the investment’s specific contribution to mission delivery or agency management -support functions and identify key customers, stakeholders, and other beneficiaries. -[Limit: 2500 char] +15 +15 -2. Briefly describe how the investment contributes to the agency target EA and its role in the Enterprise -Roadmap. Include a description of how the investment includes or will achieve programmatic or -technical innovation. -[Limit:2500 char] +12 +14 +13 -3. Provide the investment’s currently projected return on investment (ROI) percentage, as documented in +14 +15 +14 -the most recent alternatives analysis, and the date that it was established. +12 +13 +12 -a. Current ROI: -b. Date of Current ROI: +16 +16 +17 -[percentage] -[YYYY-MM-DD] +22 +24 +26 -4. In the table below, indicate if the investment in whole or in part specifically addresses any of the +14 +16 -following types of requirements: +15 +16 +16 -Note: Where “Yes” is indicated, provide a brief description of the requirement and how the investment will meet -the requirement. Include citations within descriptions, if available. Provide any URLs associated with each -requirement. If citing the Agency Performance Plan, provide the applicable “PRM” code from Performance.gov. -Description -[Limit: 1000 -characters] +18 +18 +22 -URL(s) / PRM code (s) -[One or more] +18 +17 +17 -Required -by -[Yes/No] +14 +14 +15 -Legislative Mandate -Outstanding Audit Finding or -Material Weakness -Published Agency Strategic -Plan/Annual Performance Plan -Presidential Direction (i.e. -Presidential Directive, Presidential -Memorandum, or Executive Order) -Other Requirement +19 +17 +17 -(URL required) +14 +13 -(optional) +15 +14 +12 -[URL of Agency Strategic Plan] (optional) -[PRM code for Annual Performance Plan] (required) +17 +14 +15 -(URL required) +15 +14 +14 -(optional) +37 +30 +32 -5. Provide a description of the investment’s progress and accomplishments in the PY, including the +31 +24 +23 -investment’s overall performance against baseline goals, targets, significant milestones, or performance -measures, and any corrective actions taken to address performance deficiencies. -[Limit: 1000 char] +36 +30 -Page 34 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +43 +39 +41 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +40 +37 +37 -6. Describe the investment’s objectives for the CY, BY, and budget out years, if available, including +45 +40 +45 -specific accomplishments to achieve, realize, or continue to achieve the benefits cited in question B.1. -above. -[Limit: 2500 char] +* +* +* -7. If this investment will result in the elimination or the reduction of another investment(s), please +1 +1 +* -complete the following: +* +* -Investment UII (one or more) +1 +* +1 -8. Does the investment include the following? - -To be Status -[to be eliminated/to be reduced] +1 +1 +1 -A shared service (intra-or inter-agency—current and/or planned) -A data center (current and/or planned) -PIV-enabled systems (per HSPD-12) (all systems currently PIV-enabled) -(see OMB memo M-11-11) -Cloud computing (current and/or planned) -APIs (application programming interfaces) consistent with the Digital Government -Strategy - -Check all that Apply -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] - -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] - -9. Provide any URLs related to the investment and indicate how they are related. Identify each URL’s - -relationship to the investment (if applicable): - -Relationship to Investment -(check all that apply) - -d -e -c -u -d -o -r -p -s -t -e -s -a -t -a -d -e -l -b -i -s -s -e -c -c -a - -y -l -c -i -l -b -u -p -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +1 +* +1 -. - -A - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t -y -b - -e -d -i -v -o -r -p -o -t +7 -I -P -A -e -l -b -i -s -s -e -c -c -a -y -l -c -i -l -b -u -p -a - -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +8 +9 +10 -. - -B - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -m -o -r -f - -a -t -a -d -o -t - -s -s -e -c -c -a - -. -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a - -a -i -d -e -m - -l -a -i -c -o -s -o -t - -s -k -n -i -L - -. - -C - -s -i -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -i - -l -a -r -e -n -e -g -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +Prior to January 2026, question was worded: “Thinking about the qualities needed to effectively serve another term +as president, how confident are you that Donald Trump…” +Prior to January 2026, the word “mental” was not underlined. +Prior to January 2026, the word “physical” was not underlined. +Prior to January 2026, the word “advisers” was spelled “advisors.” -. - -D - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -y -b -d -e -v -r -e -s -m -a -r -g -o -r -p -r -o -s -s -e -c -o -r -p -s -s -e -n -i -s -u -b - -f -l -e -s -t -i - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -e -h -t - -t -o -n -t -u -b -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -e -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -i - -l -a -r -e -n -e -g -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +www.pewresearch.org -. + 25 -E +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -URL -(as many as -necessary) +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -http://... +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +Thinking about important issues facing the country today… -[X] +TRUMPISSUE1 Overall, would you say you tend to agree with Donald Trump on… -[X] +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1] -[X] +Jan 20-26, +2026 +13 +27 +22 +37 +1 -[X] +All or nearly all issues +Many, but not all issues +A few issues +No or almost no issues +No answer* -[X] +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -10. Provide the date of the investment or IPT charter establishing the required IPT. +Jul 1-7, +2024 +16 +25 +23 +35 +1 -[Date] +Feb 4-15, +2020 +19 +23 +23 +34 +1 -Page 35 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Apr 25-May 1 +2018 +19 +22 +24 +33 +2 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Aug 15-21 +2017 +15 +18 +21 +45 +1 -11. Provide names and contact information for IPT members in the table below. If available, insert lines for -other IPT members such as enterprise architects, capital planners, and performance specialists. The IT -PM, business process owner/SME, and contracting specialist must be Federal Government employees. -The business process owner or SME may or may not be the same person listed as the functional/business -sponsor on the Exhibit 53-- the functional/business sponsor may be a higher-level agency official or -executive. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +TRUMPISSUE2 Now thinking not about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump conducts himself as -IPT Member Role +president, would you say you... +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-3/3-1] -IT PM +Jan 20-26, +2026 +16 -Name (Required for -all members listed) -[Limit: 250 char] +32 -Phone Number -(Required for PM) -[10 digits, 0-9 only] +51 -Business Process Owner -or SME -Contracting Specialist -IT Specialist -IT Security Specialist -(Optional: Insert other IPT -members) +1 -(optional) +Like the way he conducts +himself +Have mixed feelings about the +way he conducts himself +Don’t like the way he conducts +himself +No answer* -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +Jul 1-7, +202411 +13 -Extension +Feb 4-15, +202012 +15 -[Optional: 6 -digits, 0-9 only ] -(optional) +32 -E-mail (Required -for PM) -[Limit: one e- -mail only] -(optional) +54 -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +1 -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +30 -Page 36 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +53 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +3 -Section C: Life Cycle Costs +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -1. Provide the cost summary for the investment by completing the following tables. All costs are to be provided -in millions of dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, -although agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). Federal personnel costs should be -included only in the rows designated as “… Govt. FTEs” costs and should be excluded from the other cost -breakouts. For multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing and partner -agency contributions). +Apr 25-May 1 +2018 -For PY (FY2012) and earlier, provide final obligations (actuals) as they become available. For CY (FY2013) -and BY (FY2014) provide estimated obligations for each year. For BY+1 and beyond, please provide the -estimated obligations through the end of the investments useful life (may be different from the estimated -budget authority requests). The sum of amounts for all years should reflect the estimated lifecycle cost of the -investment. As described above, the Exhibit 53 should represent the budgetary resources for CY and BY. +Aug 15-21 +2017 -For lines in the table that ask for changes in your current submission compared to your most recent previous -submission, use the President’s Budget as your previous submission. When making comparisons, ensure that -you compare same-year-to-same-year (e.g., 2012 versus 2012). +19 -Significant changes from the previous submission should be reflected in an updated investment-level -Alternatives Analysis and is subject to OMB request, as discussed in Exhibit 300.3. +26 -PY-1 & -Prior +54 -PY -2012 +2 -CY -2013 +16 -BY -2014 +25 -BY+1 -2015 +58 -BY+2 -2016 +1 -BY+3 -2017 +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +NEWPRES_SUPP -BY+4 & -Beyond +How many of Donald Trump’s policies and plans would you say you support? +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] -Planning Costs: +Jan 20-26, +2026 +6 +22 +20 +26 +26 +1 + +All of them +Most of them +Some of them +Only a few of them +None of them +No answer* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +9 +25 +17 +23 +24 +1 + +11 -DME (Excluding Planning) -Costs: -DME (Including Planning) -Govt. FTEs: -Sub-Total DME (Including -Govt. FTE) : -O&M Costs: +12 -O&M Govt. FTEs: +In July 2024, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but about Donald Trump’s personal conduct, would +you say you…” +In February 2020, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump +conducts himself as president, would you say you…” + +www.pewresearch.org + + 26 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +NEWPRES_ACTNS + +Would you say the Trump administration's actions since taking office last year have +been... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] + +Jan 20-26, +2026 +11 +10 +28 +15 +34 +1 + +A lot better than you expected +A little better than you expected +About what you expected +A little worse than you expected +A lot worse than you expected +No answer* + +Jun 2-8, +202513 +11 +10 +31 +17 +32 +* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +17 +11 +36 +12 +24 +1 -Sub-Total O&M Costs -(Including Govt. FTE): -Total Cost (Including Govt. -FTE): +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -Total Govt. FTE costs: +[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF PRESWITHOP AND OPWITHPRES SUCH THAT FORM 1 (X_FORM=1) GETS +PRESWITHOP FIRST AND OPWITHPRES SECOND WHILE FORM 2 (X_FORM=2) GETS OPWITHPRES +FIRST AND PRESWITHOP SECOND] -Number of FTE rep by -costs: +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +PRESWITHOP -Total change from PY -final President’s Budget ($) -Total change from PY -final President’s Budget (%) -Note: Do not enter information for the dark gray cells (these will be calculated). - -2.a. - -In which year did or will this investment begin? (specify year – e.g., PY-1 = 2011)? - -2.b. - -In which year will this investment reach the end of its estimated useful life? -(specify year – e.g., BY+5 = 2019) - -3. If the funding levels have changed from the FY 2012 President’s Budget request for PY - -[Limit: 500 char] - -or CY, briefly explain those changes: - -Page 37 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -Section D: Acquisition/Contract Strategy - -1. In the table below, provide all prime contracts (or task orders) for awarded or open solicitations for the -investment (sub-award details are not required). Completed contracts and/or task orders should not be included in -the table. Contracts in open solicitation should provide estimated data for all fields (for “Total Contract Value,” -provide the estimated base contract costs and all anticipated option years). Data definitions can be found at -www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2. +This year, do you think Donald Trump should... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN +SAME ORDER AS OPWITHPRES] -For specifics, see notes 1 and 2 below the table. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +64 -Field +33 -Data Description +2 -Contract Status -Contracting Agency ID +Try as best he can to work with Democratic congressional leaders to accomplish things, +even if it means disappointing people who voted for him +Stand up to Democratic congressional leaders on issues that are important to people who +voted for him, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country +No answer* -Procurement Instrument -Identifier (PIID) +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +63 -Modular Approaches/ -Contracting +35 -Indefinite Delivery -Vehicle (IDV) Reference -ID -IDV Agency ID +2 -Solicitation ID1 +TREND FOR COMPARISON +This year, do you think Joe Biden should… -EVM Required -Ultimate Contract -Value1 -Type of Contract/ Task -Order (Pricing) 1 +Try as best he can to work with Republican +congressional leaders to accomplish things, even if it +means disappointing some people who voted for him +Stand up to Republican congressional leaders on +issues that are important to the people who voted +for him, even if it means it’s harder to address +critical problems facing the country +No answer -Is the contract a -Performance-Based -Service Acquisition -(PBSA)?1 -Effective date1 +Jan 16-21 +2024 +74 -Actual or expected End -Date of Contract/ Task -Order1 -Extent Competed1 +Jan 18-24, +2023 +73 -(1) Awarded, (2) Pre-award, but post-solicitation -Provide the contracting agency’s ID. This is required only if the -contracting agency is different than the agency submitting the -Exhibit. Use the agency’s 4-digit code as used in FPDS. -The unique identifier for each contract, agreement, or order. See -www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about -PIIDs. -Do acquisition planning, award, and management actions apply -the principles and strategies described in “Contracting Guidance -to Support Modular Development”? [Yes/No] -Provide the IDV Reference ID. This is only required for IDVs. -See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about -IDV Reference IDs. -Provide the IDV agency ID. This is a code for an agency, but it -does not necessarily represent the agency that issued the contract. -Instead, it serves as part of the unique identification for Federal -Procurement Data System IDV records. -Provide the identifier used to link transactions to solicitation -information. See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more -information. -[Yes/No] -Enter the total value of the contract, including base and all -options. Complete using dollars to two decimal places. -Provide information about the type of contract the investment is -(e.g., fixed price, cost, cost plus, incentive, IDV, time and -materials). See FAR Part 16 for more classifications. -[Yes/No] Indicate whether the contract is a PBSA as defined by -FAR Subpart 37.601. A PBSA describes the requirements in -terms of results rather than the methods of performance of the -work. -Provide the actual or expected start date of the contract/task order -that the parties have agreed on for the contract’s requirements. -[YYYY-MM-DD] -[YYYY-MM-DD] +Jan 10-17, +2022 +67 -Choose one of the following options: (A) Full and open -competition, (B) Not available for competition, (C) Not -competed, (D) Full and open competition after exclusion of -sources, (E) Follow on to competed action, (F) Competed under -simplified acquisition procedures, (G) Not competed under -simplified acquisition procedures, (CDO) Competitive Delivery -Order, (NDO) Non-competitive Delivery Order +Jan 8-12, +202114 +74 -Optional for -Awarded -Contracts +24 -Contract/ -Task -Order +25 -Y +29 -Y +23 -Y +2 -Y +2 -Y +4 -Y +3 -Y +13 +14 -Y +Prior to January 2026, the question was worded “Would you say the Trump administration’s actions so far have been…” +In January 2021, second response option was worded as “ … on issues that are important to his supporters …”. -Y +www.pewresearch.org -Page 38 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) + 27 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Contract Description +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +OPWITHPRES -A brief description of the goods or services bought (for an award) -or that are available (for an -IDV).www.usaspending.gov/learn?tab=FAQ#2 +This year, do you think Democratic congressional leaders should... [ROTATE RESPONSE +OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN SAME ORDER AS PRESWITHOP] -Y +Jan 20-26, +2026 +49 -1Assuming the PIID or IDV PIID match with www.usaspending.gov, these data elements will be automatically populated for awarded IT acquisitions. -2Assuming the PIID, IDV PIID, or solicitation number match with www.usaspending.gov or FedBizOpps (www.fbo.gov) this data will be automatically -populated for awarded, pre-awarded, and post-solicitation IT acquisitions. +49 -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement -for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why: +2 -[Limit: 2500 char] +Try as best they can to work with Donald Trump to accomplish things, even if it +means disappointing people who voted for them +Stand up to Donald Trump on issues that are important to people who voted for +them, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country +No answer* -Page 39 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +55 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +43 -Exhibit 300B: Performance Plan and Measurement Report +2 -Exhibit 300B is used to provide OMB BY 2014 and current FY 2013 investment plans and performance data. -Include in this exhibit, at a minimum, all projects, activities, and operations scheduled to commence or continue -in the CY and/or BYs. Information in Exhibit 300B is to be updated as soon as new data becomes available, but -at a minimum once per calendar month. +TREND FOR COMPARISON +This year, do you think Republican congressional leaders should… -UNDERSTANDING EXHIBIT 300B +Try as best they can to work with Joe Biden to +accomplish things, even if it means disappointing +some Republican voters +Stand up to Joe Biden on issues that are important +to Republican voters, even if it means it’s harder to +address critical problems facing the country +No answer -In Exhibit 300B, investments are described as: +Jan 16-21 +2024 +60 - +Jan 18-24, +2023 +63 -Investment +Jan 10-17, +2022 +61 -o Projects +Jan 8-12, +2021 +66 - Activities +37 -o Operations +35 -Report information about these areas in the following Exhibit 300B sections: +37 -A.1: General Information. Enter basic information about the major investment. -B.1: Projects. Identify all of the investment’s projects with activities occurring in the current FY. -B.2: Activities. Outline the activities that are performed to achieve the outcome of each project. -B.3: Project Risk. Identify significant risks to each project’s success. -C.1: Operational Performance Information. Identify performance targets for evaluating operations. -C.2: Operational Risk. Identify all significant risks to the investment achieving operational performance +3 -targets. +2 -SECTION A: GENERAL INFORMATION +2 -1. Investment Name: Agency-provided name of investment, consistent with Exhibit 53. -2. Investment UII: Agency-provided UII, consistent with Exhibit 53. +31 -SECTION B: PROJECT PLAN AND EXECUTION DATA +3 -In Tables B.1 and B.2., report, at a minimum, all projects with any activities that started in a previous FY (PY and -earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY. Also, report projects and activities that are -scheduled to start in the CY and BY, including planning, DME, and maintenance projects. Include projects and -activities commencing beyond the BY, as available. Include the following data in Table B.1: +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within the investment. -2. Project Name: Name used by the agency to refer specifically to the project. -3. Objectives/Expected Outcomes: Description of the project’s functionality, capability, or goal. -4. Project Start Date: Actual start date of in-progress projects or planned start of projects that have not yet +ASK ALL: +IMMIG_FAVOPP -begun (may be before the current FY or activities listed in Table B.2). +Thinking about immigration policy, do you favor or oppose each of the following? +[RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER +AS VEN_MADREMV] -5. Project Completion Date: Planned date of completion of in-progress projects or actual completion date -of projects that have completed (may be after BY or of completion date of activities listed in activities -Table B.2). +Strongly +favor -6. Project Life cycle Cost: Enter the total cost of all activities related to the project as described in OMB +Somewhat +favor -Circular A-131 (in $ millions). +Somewhat +oppose -7. PM Name: Name of PM responsible for the success of the project. -8. PM Level of Experience: The years of applicable experience or the status of certification for the PM. +Strongly +oppose -Available selections include: +No +answer* -1) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-3) – Senior -2) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-2) – Mid-Level -3) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-1) – Entry Level +SCMED -Page 40 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +FEE - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +ASY -4) Other certification with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years) -5) Other certification with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years) -6) Other certification with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years) -7) No certification, but with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years) -8) No certification, but with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years) -9) No certification, but with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years) +MIL -9. PM Phone: Phone number of the PM responsible for the success of the project. -10. PM E-mail: E-mail address of the PM responsible for the success of the project. +Requiring people who want to +enter the U.S. to let +immigration officers review +their social media accounts + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -ID +Giving people priority in the +immigration process if they pay +a $1 million fee + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -Name +Suspending all asylum +applications from people +seeking to live in the U.S. to +escape violence or danger + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Objectives/ -Expected -Outcomes +Maintaining a large military +presence at the U.S. border +with Mexico + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -Start -Date +25 -Project -Completion -Date +31 -Table B.1 -Project -Life cycle -Cost +20 -PM -Name +23 -PM Level -of -Experience +5 -PM -Phone +14 -PM -Extension +20 -[10 digit] +60 -[Optional] +11 -PM E- -mail -[Limit: one -e-mail only] +21 -In Table B.2, describe, at a minimum, all activities for projects in Table B.1 that started in a previous FY (PY and -earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY, as well as activities that are scheduled to -start in the current FY and BY. In line with modular development principles, each project must produce usable -functionality at intervals of no more than six months, as described in the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform -Federal Information Technology Management. Include the following data in Table B.2: +30 -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within this investment. -2. Activity Name: A short description consistent with the critical steps within the agency project management +36 -methodology. +31 -3. Activity Description: Describe what work is accomplished by the activity. -4. Structure ID: Agency-specified identifier that indicates the work breakdown structure (WBS) the agency uses to +31 -associate the activity with other activities or a project. Provide this in the format of “x.x.x.x.x” where the first string -is the Project ID and each following string (separated by periods) matches the structure ID of a parent activity. See -below for more guidance about parent and child activities expressed through this structure. +21 -5. Key Deliverable/Usable Functionality: Indicate whether the completion of the activity provides a key deliverable +16 -or usable functionality. This should only be provided for activities that do not have a child activity. Use this field to -demonstrate the investment’s alignment with the modular development principles of the 25 Point Implementation -Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management. +2 -6. Start Date Planned: The planned start date for the activity. This is the baseline value. -7. Start Date Projected: If the activity has not yet started, enter the current planned start date of the activity. -8. Start Date Actual: When the activity starts, enter the actual start date here. -9. Completion Date Planned: The planned completion date for the activity. This is the baseline value. -10. Completion Date Projected: If the activity has not yet completed, enter the current planned completion date of the +2 -activity. +2 -11. Completion Date Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual completion date here. -12. Total Costs Planned: The planned total cost for the activity. This is the baseline value. -13. Total Costs Projected: When the activity is not yet completed, enter the current planned total cost of the activity. -14. Total Costs Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual total costs for the activity here. +1 -Note: For programs that are employing earned value management, agencies should reflect “budget at completion” in the -“Total Costs Planned” field and “estimated at completion” in the “Total Costs Projected” field for projected costs. +www.pewresearch.org -A + 28 -B +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -C +IMMIG_FAVOPP CONTINUED … -D +DTN -E +PAU75 -F +Keeping large numbers of +immigrants in detention centers +while their cases are decided + Jan 20-26, 2026 -G +Pausing visa applications from +people in 75 countries seeking +to legally immigrate to the U.S. + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Table B.2 -H +Strongly +favor -Project -ID +Somewhat +favor -Activity -Name +Somewhat +oppose -Activity -Description +Strongly +oppose -Structure -ID +No +answer* -Key Deliverable/ -Usable Functionality -[Key Deliverable, -Usable Functionality, -N/A] +14 -Start Date -Planned +21 -Start Date -Projected +24 -Start Date -Actual +40 -I -Completion -Date -Planned +16 -J -Completion -Date -Projected +23 -K +30 -L +30 -M +2 -N +2 -Completion -Date Actual +ADDITONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -Total Costs -Planned +[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT AND IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT] -Total Costs -Projected +ASK ALL: +IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT -Total Costs -Actual +Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for people to +do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN +SAME ORDER AS IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT] -Page 41 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Definitely +acceptable - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Probably +acceptable -Reporting Parent and Child Activities (WBS Structure) +Probably +unacceptable -“Child” activities may be grouped into “Parent” activities to reflect the WBS used by the agency to manage the -investment. If a WBS is not used by the agency, report the relationship between parent activities and child -activities in “Structure ID” using this method. +Definitely +unacceptable -When reporting an activity, enter the “Structure ID” as a period-delimited string consisting of the “Project ID” -and each nested parent activity between the project level and the child activity. The “Structure ID” to enter will -vary depending on the activity’s WBS level. +No +answer* -Example: For child activity 3 which is part of parent activity 10, which in turn is part of parent activity 2, which in -turn is part of Project A, enter: A.2.10.3 +VDEO - Project A +TRCK -o Parent Activity 2 +REPT - Parent Activity 10 +Record video of immigration +officers while they make arrests + Jan 20-26, 2026 - Child Activity 3 +Share information about where +immigration officers are arresting +people + Jan 20-26, 2026 -There is no limit to the number of nested “child” and “parent” relationships allowed, and this depth may vary -from activity to activity and from project to project. +Report people who they think +may be in the country illegally to +immigration officers + Jan 20-26, 2026 -If any of a parent activity's child activities occurs in the current FY, then all child activities of the parent activity -must be reported, regardless of their timing. This is to ensure that a complete view of the parent activity is -available. +48 -All activities with no child activities must have, at a minimum, Project ID, Activity Name, Activity Description, Structure ID, -Start Date Planned, Start Date Projected, Completion Date Planned, Completion Date Projected, Total Costs Planned, and -Total Costs Projected. Completed activities must also have Start Date Actual, Completion Date Actual, and Total Costs -Actual. +26 -Any parent activities with a child activity must be completely described by the aggregate attributes of its child -activities. In the IT Dashboard, the cost and schedule information for parent activities will be based on the cost -and schedule information of the lowest level of child activities reported. Agency-submitted cost and schedule -information is not required for parent activities. +13 -Project -ID +12 -A -A -A -A +35 -Activity Name -Design -Business Requirements -Technical Requirements -Architecture +24 -Structure -ID +18 -Start Date -Planned +22 -Completion -Date Planned +22 -Planned Total -Costs +30 -… +22 -A.2 -A.2.1 -A.2.2 -A.2.3 +25 -2/1/2012 -2/1/2012 -2/11/2012 -2/21/2012 +1 -2/29/2012 -2/10/2012 -2/20/2012 -2/29/2012 +1 -$2.5 -$1.0 -$1.0 -$0.5 +2 -Parent activities as highlighted are optional (Structure ID: A.2). Reported parent activities values will be ignored, as -calculated values will be determined by aggregating the cost and schedule information reported in the child activities. +www.pewresearch.org -Page 42 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) + 29 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Project Risk +ASK ALL: +IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT -Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial -concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the -investment Risk Management Plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard in conjunction with the Exhibit 300 -submission. +Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for federal +immigration officers to do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE +OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER AS IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT] -In Table B.3, list all significant project-related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and -provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the -combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following -data in Table B.3: +Definitely +acceptable -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies a project within the investment. For +Probably +acceptable -each identified risk, list the associated Project ID. +Probably +unacceptable -2. Risk Name: A short description that identifies a risk, the cause of the risk, and the effect that the risk +Definitely +unacceptable -may have on the project. +No +answer* -3. Risk Category: Select the relevant OMB risk category for each risk. Risk categories include: 1) +MASK Wear face coverings that hide +their identities while working + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of -systems, 7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset -protection) considerations, 9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of -agency to manage the investment, 11) Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change -management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and -19) Project resources. +NGBH -4. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High +RLAN -likelihood). +Increase their presence in +neighborhoods with many +immigrants + Jan 20-26, 2026 -5. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact). -6. Mitigation Plan: A short description of the plan or steps to mitigate the identified risk. +Use a person’s looks or the +language they speak as a reason +to check their immigration status + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project ID +CITZ -Risk Name -[Limit: 500 -char] +Arrest U.S. citizens who help +people avoid immigration officers + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Risk Category -[19 risk -categories] +21 -Table B.3 -Risk Probability +16 -Risk Impact +15 -[Low, Medium, High] +46 -[Low, Medium, High] +18 -Mitigation Plan -[char 500] +26 -Page 43 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +21 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +33 -SECTION C: OPERATIONAL DATA +10 -Section C addresses operational activities that are not reported as a part of a project in Section B. +18 -Operational Performance -There are two essential types of operations metrics to be reported: +20 -1. Results-Specific: Provide a minimum of two metrics that measure the effectiveness of the investment in -delivering the desired service or support level. At least one metric should reflect customer results (e.g. -service quality). +23 -2. Activities or Technology-Specific: Provide a minimum of three metrics that measure the investment -against its defined process standards or technical service level agreements (e.g. Reliability and -Availability). At least one of these metrics must have a monthly reporting frequency +21 -All data will be displayed to the public on the IT Dashboard. Ensure that all provided metrics information -provided is publicly releasable. +20 -Defining a new metric +51 -When adding a new metric, such as for new investments or to provide new information about an existing -investment, use the following table. +34 -Metric ID -[Limit: -XXX char] +1 -Metric -Description -[Limit: 500 -char] +1 -Unit of -Measure -[Limit: 50 -char] +1 -Table C.1A +2 -FEA -Performance -Measurement -Category -Mapping -[PRM -Measurement -Category] +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -2012 -Target -[numeric] +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +EXPAND_GRNLND_MOD -2013 -Target -[numeric] +Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. +How likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will do this? [ROTATE +RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1 HOLDING 6 LAST] -Measurement -Condition -[Over target/ -Under target] +Jan 20-26, +2026 +8 +12 +21 +22 +17 -Reporting -Frequency -[Monthly, -Quarterly, Semi- -Annual, Annual] +Extremely likely +Very likely +Somewhat likely +Not too likely +Not at all likely -Agency -Strategic -Goals/Agency -Objective -[New PRM Code] +19 +1 -1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. When reporting actual results (see below), use +Not sure +No answer* -this ID to reference the correct metric. +Mar 24-30, +202515 +7 +16 +28 +22 +13 -2. Metric Description: Description to help the user understand what is being measured. In this field, +14 +* -describe the units used, any calculation algorithm used, and the definition or limits of the population or -“universe” measured. +15 -3. Unit of Measure: Brief indication of what quantity is measured (e.g. number, percentage, dollar value) +In the 2025 survey, question was worded “Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. How +likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will pursue this?” -for each metric. +www.pewresearch.org -4. FEA Performance Measurement Category Mapping: Indicates the PRM measurement category as + 30 -described above. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -5. 2012 Target: Metric target value from 2012 -6. 2013 Target: Metric target value for 2013 -7. Measurement Condition: Indicates whether a desired result would be “over the target” or “under the -target.” For example, if the target is to reduce the error rate to 10%, then the desired result would be -“under the target" so “under target” should be entered for measurement condition. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +EXPAND2_GRNLND -8. Reporting Frequency: How often actual measurements will be reported (monthly, quarterly, semi- +Do you favor or oppose the U.S. taking over Greenland, as Donald Trump has +proposed? [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 HOLDING 5 LAST] -annually, or annually). Annual reporting frequencies are reserved for annual operating cost measures, -performance measures associated with the agency’s annual performance plan, or other measures that can -only be appropriated measured on an annual basis. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +10 +12 +13 +45 -9. Agency Strategic Goals/Agency Objective: For annual reporting frequency metrics, agencies will be +Strongly favor +Somewhat favor +Somewhat oppose +Strongly oppose -required to provide the cross agency priority (CAP) goal; agency priority goal (APG); strategic goal (SG) -or agency objective (OBJ) associated with the metric (using the new Performance Reference Model code -use by Performance.gov). +20 +1 -Page 44 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Not sure +No answer* - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Mar 24-30, +2025 +8 +15 +12 +43 -Providing actual results: +22 +1 -As actual results are measured at the appropriate frequency, report them using the following table. Also use this -table when applicable to provide any historical actual results for a new metric (optional). +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. Use this ID to reference the correct metric. -2. Actual Result: Actual result measured. -3. Date of Actual Result: End date of the most recent reporting period. -4. Comment: A necessary provide a comment for each actual result reported, if necessary. +ASK REPUBLICAN AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS (XPARTYSUMFINAL=1) [N=3,913]: +Which comes closer to your view, even if neither is exactly right? +REPWORKTRMP +Republicans in Congress… [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1] -When adding a new metric, include historical actual result information as available. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +38 -Metric ID -[Limit: XXX char] +61 -Table C.1B +1 -Actual -Result -[numeric] +Have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s policies and +programs because he is a Republican president +Do not have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s +policies and programs if they disagree with him +No answer* -Date of Actual -Result -[date] +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +44 -Comment -[500 char] -(optional) +55 -Operational Risk +1 -Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial -concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the -investment risk management plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard. +ASK ALL: +PARTY +ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3,4 OR REFUSED): +As of today do you lean more to…16 +PARTYLN -In Table C.2, list all significant operational related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and -provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the -combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following -data in Table C.2: +In politics today, do you consider yourself a… -1. Risk Name: A short description that identifies the risk, the cause of the risk and the effect that the risk +Republican +28 -may have on the operational activity. +Democrat Independent -2. Risk Category: The relevant OMB Risk Category for each risk. Risk categories include: +26 -1) Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of systems, -7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset protection) considerations, -9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of agency to manage the investment, 11) -Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) -Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and 19) Project resources. +29 -3. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High likelihood). -4. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact). -5. Mitigation Plan: A short description of how to mitigate the risk. +Something +else +15 -Risk Name -[Limit: 500 char] +No +answer* +2 -Risk Category -[19 risk categories] +Lean +Rep +18 -Table C.2 -Risk Probability -[Low, Medium, High] +Lean +Dem +21 -Risk Impact -[Low, Medium, High] +16 -Mitigation Plan -[Limit: 500 char] +PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey. -Page 45 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +www.pewresearch.org diff --git a/q0/random_k4/question.json b/q0/random_k4/question.json index b7c98542222d0a1508bb940f91c8e5938787c12e..fedeb6e3c785fe06d286de808a65b96119c714f0 100644 --- a/q0/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q0/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "PH_2016.06.08_Economy-Final.pdf", - "web_24c4662e4f9e6338.pdf", - "web_d455d7d1e8416aea.pdf", - "web_b0b861dfece3f50d.pdf", - "37a87e9ff89a0d96aebd89f4c09844ea1ab59f76.pdf" + "web_3cd8fd0905eadfd3.pdf", + "web_4af2298618127c8a.pdf", + "web_bfb031d3e591ca35.pdf", + "web_ff8dcb0ea2a037b7.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_1.md b/q0/random_k4/random_1.md index 132a7a3a1eb856bf1ac3b2a8f7f839b34c78bc6d..0157c79493366431cd66d8105491fdfb94260f43 100644 --- a/q0/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q0/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1593 +1,663 @@ - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Thursday April 9 -About the National Science and Technology Council +Topics for this Lecture: +•Thermal Physics -The National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) is the principal means by which the Executive -Branch coordinates science and technology policy across the diverse entities that make up the federal -research and development enterprise. A primary objective of the NSTC is to ensure science and -technology (S&T) policy decisions and programs are consistent with the President’s stated goals. The -NSTC prepares research and development strategies that are coordinated across federal agencies -aimed at accomplishing multiple national goals. The work of the NSTC is organized under committees -that oversee subcommittees and working groups focused on different aspects of science and -technology. More information is available at www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/nstc. +• Temperature & Heat +• Temperature measurement +• Thermal expansion -About the Office of Science and Technology Policy +•Thermal Physics -The Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) was established by the National Science and -Technology Policy, Organization, and Priorities Act of 1976 to provide the President and others within -the Executive Office of the President with advice on the scientific, engineering, and technological -aspects of the economy, national security, homeland security, health, foreign relations, the -environment, and the technological recovery and use of resources, among other topics. OSTP leads -interagency S&T policy coordination efforts, assists the Office of Management and Budget with an -annual review and analysis of federal research and development in budgets, and serves as a source of -scientific and technological analysis and judgment for the President with respect to major policies, -is available at -plans, and programs of -www.whitehouse.gov/ostp. +• Phases & Latent Heat +• Calorimetry -federal government. More +• TF = (9/5)(TC) + 32 +• “Temperature” is not “Heat” +• Thermal linear expansion: -information +• ΔL = αL0ΔT [α] = K-1 -the +• Heat energy flow: +• Q=c*m*ΔT +• Qlost = Qgained -About the NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure +See the course webpage for slides, +video links, and google docs Q&A links +• Assignment 11 due Friday +• Pre-class due 15min before class +• Help Room: via Teams, 6-9pm +Wed/Thurs, also via email on Wed/Thurs +• SI: via Teams +• Office Hours: via email +(meisel@ohio.edu) -The Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure (RDI) coordinates federal investments -in infrastructure supporting research and development (R&D) across the nation under the auspices of -the NSTC’s Committee on Science and Technology Enterprise. This coordination ensures that U.S. R&D -infrastructure and the scientific and engineering workforce it supports remain preeminent, relevant, -and ready to address the nation’s economic and national security priorities. +• Phase changes: -About this Document +Q=m*L -Consistent with Section 1007 of the America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote -Excellence in Technology, Education, and Science (COMPETES) Act, the National Science and -Technology Council is required to “produce a report identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in -research facilities and major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities -at academic institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.” This -document fulfills that requirement by providing an assessment of issues facing the United States’ -research and development infrastructure (RDI) and their impact on the nation’s status as a global leader -in S&T. It aims be a tool for agencies to assess and address RDI concerns based on individual needs and -resources. The assessment identifies four major issues affecting U.S. RDI: aging and inadequate -research infrastructure; cascading impacts from substandard facilities; a widening gap in global S&T -outcomes; and challenges in recruiting and retaining top talent. This assessment also offers four -opportunities for agencies to meet future S&T needs: strategic planning, identifying gaps, -benchmarking, and interagency collaboration). +*If your circumstances +hinder your completion of +any of this class’s +assignments, please let +me know +*These slides are +recorded and posted in +advance for your +convenience. +Administrative details +may be out of date. Keep +an eye on your email +please. -– i – + Thermal Physics - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Why can we only see +warm things in infrared +and not cold objects? -Copyright Information +Why do bridges have +these sorts of joints? -This document is a work of the United States government and is in the public domain (see 17 U.S.C. -§105). Subject to the stipulations below, it may be distributed and copied with acknowledgment to -OSTP. Copyrights to graphics included in this document are reserved by the original copyright holders -or their assignees and are used here under the government’s license and by permission. Requests to -use any images must be made to the provider identified in the image credits or to OSTP if no provider -is identified. Published in the United States of America, 2024. +How much +energy does it +take to bring +water to a boiling +temperature? -– ii – + Temperature & Heat +• Temperature: - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +– A measure of the internal kinetic energy of atoms & molecules within an object. +– This is a property of an object. -NATIONAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL +• Heat: -Chair +– A measure of the transfer of energy between two objects. +– This is a property of an interaction, not of a single object. +– Heat is the energy moving from a high temperature object to a low temperature object. -Arati Prabhakar, Assistant to the President for -Science and Technology; and Director, Office -of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) + Temperature Scales -Executive Director +• A few common units are used for temperature: -Kei Koizumi, Principal Deputy Director for -Science, Society, and Policy, OSTP +– Fahrenheit, Celsius, & Kelvin +• Fahrenheit is related to Celsius by: + TFahrenheit = (9/5)TCelsius + 32 + ΔTFahrenheit = (9/5)ΔTCelsius +• Celsius is related to Kelvin by: + TKelvin = TCelsius + 273.15 -NSTC SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT -INFRASTRUCTURE +20C is about +room +temperature. -Co-Chairs +Zero C is +freezing, +10C is cold, +20C is nice, +30C is hot. -Executive Secretary +• Zero Kelvin is “absolute zero” (lowest possible T) +• Zero Celsius is the freezing point for water, +which is 32 Fahrenheit and 273.15 Kelvin. -Harriet Kung, Department of Energy +• 100 Celsius is the boiling point for water, -Mariam Elsayed, Department of Energy +which is 212 Fahrenheit and 373.14 Kelvin. -Linnea Avallone, National Science Foundation + Thermal Expansion of Solids: Linear expansion -Jagadeesh Pamulapati, Department of +• Objects expand when their temperature increases. +• The amount of expansion depends on the material +properties and is known as +the expansion coefficient: α +• α depends on the particular material +(and one the phase of matter). SI unit: K-1 +• α describes how much an object expands +in a linear dimension for a given temperature +increase -Defense + ΔL = αL0ΔT -Cole Donovan, Office of Science and +• The fractional change in length is: -Technology Policy + ΔL/L = αΔT + ΔT must be in Celsius or Kelvin -Members +• Typical α values are (at 20 degrees C): -Aliya Iftikhar, Office of Science and +–Aluminum, Copper, Silver: ~2x10-5 K-1 +–Concrete, Glass, Steel : ~1x10-5 K-1 +–Diamond: ~0.1x10-5 K-1 -Jason Boehm, National Institute for Standards +This is why you need special +joints for, e.g. bridges -Technology Policy + An 0.5m-long rod with a thermal expansion coefficient of α ~ 10-5 K-1 is heated +from room temperature (~293K) to the boiling temperature for water (~373K). +How much extra length does the rod have after heating? -and Technology +2 -Gordon Hengst, Department of Defense +(A) 4x10-6 m +(B) 4x10-4 m +(C) 4x10-2 m +(D) 4 m -Gary Matlock, National Oceanic and +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(373K - 293K) +3. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(80K) +4. ΔL = 0.0004m = 400μm This is ~4 human hair widths. -Atmospheric Administration + A bi-metallic strip is composed of one metal sandwiched together with +another, so one metal is on top and another metal is on the bottom. +If the metal on the top half has a smaller thermal expansion coefficient +than the metal on the bottom half, which picture best represents what +happens after the bi-metallic strip is heated? -Terence Lynch, National Oceanic and +3 -Atmospheric Administration +(A) 1 +(B) 2 +(C) 3 -Bob McDonald, National Institutes of Health +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. The top strip has a +smaller α and so it +will expand less than the +bottom strip. -Angela Hadley, Environmental Protection +3. To achieve the extra +length on the bottom, +without lengthening the +top-half by the same +amount, the strip is +forced to bend upwards. -Agency +Leonard G. -Kartik Sheth, National Aeronautics and Space +This is how some of the +older spring-based +thermostats work. +Temperature changes cause +the spring to bend, +ultimately completing a +circuit to turn on/off the +heat/AC. -Administration + Heat -Scott Miller, Smithsonian Institution + Sect 14.1 -Alexander Kurien, General Services +• Heat is thermal energy that flows from a high- -Administration +temperature object to a low-temperature object. -Paul Strang, Department of Homeland +• Heat depends on parameters of a process. -Security +These are so-called “state variables” +– Internal energy (U) of the objects, -Joon Park, Department of Agriculture +i.e. the kinetic energy of atoms/molecules inside -Mike Villarreal, Department of Agriculture +– Temperature (T) of the objects -Geoff Plumlee, U.S. Geological Survey +• Your body radiates heat to the surrounding -Dan Hayba, U.S. Geological Survey +environment as light. +• We see that light in the +infrared wavelengths. -Esha Mathew, State Department + Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy? -– iii – +6 - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +(A) Raising 1kg of water by 10K -Acknowledgements +(B) Raising 2kg of water by 10K -OSTP and the NSTC thank the members of the Writing Team for their time, expertise, and significant -contributions to the report: Michelle Buchanan, Shelby Walker, Skip Vaughn, Gordon Hengst, Mariam -Elsayed, Aliya Iftikhar, and Cole Donovan. OSTP and the NSTC also thank the Oak Ridge National -Laboratory science writing team—Betsy Sonewald, Holly Haun, Marissa Mills, and Jackie Kerr—for their -efforts in shaping and finalizing the report, and the Institute for Defense Analysis, Science and -Technology Policy Institute team—Walter Valdivia, Gifford Wong, Kush Patel, Skandan Ananthasekar, -and Matthew Diasio—for their literature review and contributions. +(C) Raising 2kg of water by 20K -– 1 – +(D) All the same - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +1. More heat will be required to create a larger temperature change. +2. The more material you have to heat-up, the more energy it will take. -Table of Contents + Heat: Heat-energy required to change an object’s temperature -Executive Summary ........................................................................................................... 4 +• More heat is required to raise the temperature of a larger object. +• More heat is required to induce a larger temperature change. +• The exact amount of heat will depend on properties of the material. -Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 7 +– These are described the the “specific heat capacity”, c +– c is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of a given -Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure ....................... 10 +mass of a particular material by a certain temperature change -Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure .................................................................................... 11 +– The SI unit of c is: J/(kg*K) +– Typical values of c are ~100J/(kg*K) -Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities .................................................................................. 15 +Aluminum is 10X higher than this +(which is atypically large for a solid). +Meaning it is hard to heat-up. +Though, liquid water is even higher. -Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes ............................................................................................... 18 +• In a formula: -Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent .................................. 20 + Q=c*m*ΔT -Opportunities ................................................................................................................... 22 +• If the temperature of an object decreases, +it will release heat into an environment -Strategic Planning .................................................................................................................................. 23 +• This does not describe phase changes (e.g. liquid water to solid ice) -Identification of Gaps ............................................................................................................................. 23 + You want to heat a 1kg block of aluminum and 0.5kg of water by 20K. +Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy? -Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations ........................................................ 24 +7 -Sharing RDI Strategies ........................................................................................................................... 24 +(A) the aluminum block -Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination ................................................... 25 +(B) the water -Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise ................................................................. 25 +(C) both the same amount of heat -Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors ......................... 26 +1. Q= mcΔT +2. Qal= malcalΔT = (1kg)(900J/(kgK))(20K) = 18,000J +3. Qwater= mwatercwaterΔT = (0.5kg)(4000J/(kgK))(20K) = 40,000J +4. The water will require more heat. -Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs ...................................................................................... 26 +caluminum ≈ 900 J/(kg*K) +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 26 + Calorimetry: Measuring heat-energy transfer via temperature changes -– 1 – +• Suppose I want to measure how much heat-energy a chemical reaction - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +dumps into a fluid. How do I do it? -Abbreviations and Acronyms +• By measuring the temperature before and after the reaction, we get ΔT. +• If we measure the mass of our fluid and know the specific heat, -AI +then the heat energy is given by Q= mcΔT -Artificial Intelligence +• The energy “lost” by the chemical reaction is gained by the surrounding -ALMA +environment: -Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array + Qlost = Qgained -AOML +• A key detail is that the stuff you care about (the system), +e.g. the chemical reaction stuff + the water in this picture, +must be thermally isolated from the surrounding environment +(here by coffee cups) -NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory + Sect 14.2 -ARS + Two liters of water at 353K is added to 1.5-liters of water at 293K. +No energy is lost to the surroundings. +What is the final equilibrium temperature of the water? +Note, 1liter of water has a mass of 1kg. -Agricultural Research Service +8 -CERN +(A) 293 K -European Organization for Nuclear Research +(B) 323K -DoD +(C) 327K -DOE +(D) 353 K -Department of Defense +1. Qlost = Qgained +2. (mcΔT)2liters = (mcΔT)1.5liters +3. (2kg)(353K - Tfinal) = (1.5kg)(Tfinal - 293K) +4. 706kg*K - (2kg)Tfinal = (1.5kg)Tfinal - 439.5kg*K +5. 1,145.5kg*K = (3.5kg)Tfinal +6. Tfinal = (1,145.5kg*K)(3.5kg) ≈ 327K -Department of Energy +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -ECMWF European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting + You have two beakers of water, each with 1kg of water (c=4186J/(kgK)) at 293K. +You drop one 353K block of 1kg of metal into each beaker, but one block is made +of aluminum (c= 900J/(kgK)) and the other is made of copper (c= 386J/(kgK)). +Once each beaker reaches thermal equilibrium with the block, which beaker of +water has a higher temperature? -EIC +9 -EOP +(A) beaker with aluminum -EPA +(B) beaker with copper -Electron-Ion Collider +(C) both reach same equilibrium temperature -Executive Office of the President +cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K) -Environmental Protection Agency +1. Aluminum has a larger specific heat capacity than copper. +2. This means it takes more energy to change the temperature of aluminum. +3. It also means that more energy is deposited by a change in temperature of the -FAST +aluminum block, relative to copper. -Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope +Math answer: +1. Qlost = Qgained +2. (mcΔT)block = (mcΔT)water +3. mblockcblock(Tblock - Tfinal) = mwatercwater(Tfinal - Twater) +4. mblockcblockTblock - mblockcblockTfinal = mwatercwaterTfinal - mwatercwaterTwater +5. mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater = (mwatercwater + mblockcblock)Tfinal +6. Tfinal = (mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater)/(mwatercwater + mblockcblock) -FY + Thermal Energy Storage -fiscal year +• Large objects can be used as energy reservoirs -FFRDCs +by storing energy as heat. -federally funded R&D centers +• Excess energy can be stored as heat to be +released later, or to smooth-out the power +distribution from a different energy source. +• E.g. store extra solar energy from the day or +wind energy from a windy day to use later +during the night. -NIST +• The earth itself is a large hot object -National Institutes of Standards and Technology +(where the heat comes from radioactive decays +inside the earth’s core). +This heat forms the basis of geothermal energy. -IT + A 1kg block of aluminum (c=900J/(kgK)) has an initial temperature of 300K. +The block is placed over an electric heater which provides 150W of power +for 300 seconds. +After this heating episode, what is the temperature of the aluminum block? -information technology +10 -JWST +(A) 50K -James Webb Space Telescope +(B) 300K -LBNF +(C) 350K -Long Baseline Neutrino Facility +(D) 450K -NAIRR National AI Research Resource +1. Q = mcΔT +2. ΔT = Q/mc +3. Q = P*t = 150W*300s = 45,000J +4. ΔT = (45,000J)/(1kg*900J/(kgK)) = 50K +5. Tfinal = Tinitial + ΔT = 300K + 50K = 350K. -NASA +1W = 1J/s -National Aeronautics and Space Administration + Phases: Definitions -NASEM National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine +• Solid: Stays the same shape +• Liquid: Takes the shape of the container*, but preserves volume +• Gas: Fills the volume of the container -NIH +*To be clear, +cats are not liquids -National Institutes of Health + Phase Changes -NIST +• Latent heat describes the amount of energy that needs to be absorbed to change phases -National Institute for Standards and Technology +or the amount of energy that is released upon a phase transition +due to breaking/forming molecular bonds -NMNH +• Energy must be absorbed (“endothermic”) for solid->liquid or liquid->gas +• Energy is released (“exothermic”) for gas->liquid or liquid->solid +• Latent Heat of Fusion, LFusion: solid ↔ liquid +• Latent heat of Vaporization, LVaporization: liquid ↔ gas -Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History + Latent Heat -NOAA +• Latent heat adds/removes heat during a phase transition: +• Following the heat added to bring water from ice to water-vapor: +𝑄𝑄 = 𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚 +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration +QA QB QC -NSF +QD -National Science Foundation +QE -NSTC +QA=mciceΔT +QB=mLfusion +QC=mcwaterΔT +QD=mLvaporization +QE=mcsteamΔT -National Science and Technology Council + How much energy is required to melt 0.5kg of ice? -OSTP +1 -Office of Science and Technology Policy +(A) 1045 J -PRC +(B) 2090 J -R&D +(C) 2093 J -RDI +(D) 16.7x104 J -People’s Republic of China +1. This is a phase transition: use Q=mL +Ice to liquid transition: Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +2. +3. Q=(0.5kg)*(33.533.5x104 J/kg) = 16.7x104 J -research and development + Calorimetry -research and development infrastructure +• Qlost-from-hot-object = Qgained-by-cold-object +• T is positive in this definition; i.e. subtract +the higher temperature from the lower one -RDT&E +• The calorimeter is a classic tool to take -research, development, test, and evaluation +advantage of this -SC +• For the example on the right, -DOE Office of Science +mwatercwaterΔTwater + mcupccupTcup = +mobjectcobjectTobject -– 2 – + Consider 1kg of material A (Blue) and material B (Green). +Which requires the most energy to change from the liquid to the +gas phase? - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +2 -S&T +(A) A (B) B (C) They require the same amount -science and technology +A longer horizontal stretch +corresponds to more added heat +to achieve a phase transition -STEM +C -science, technology, engineering, and math +º -USDA +p +m +e +T -U.S. Department of Agriculture +B -– 3 – +A - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +gas -Executive Summary +liquid -President Biden is delivering an "Infrastructure Decade" that will unlock access to economic -opportunity, create good paying jobs, boost domestic manufacturing, and grow America's economy -from the middle out and bottom up. As the President has said, “To have the best economy in the -world…you have to have the best infrastructure in the world.” That starts with investing in America and -building on our leadership in American research and development (R&D). +Solid -The America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote Excellence in Technology, Education, and -Science (COMPETES) Act of 2007 (“the Act”) requires that the National Science and Technology Council -(NSTC) produce an annual report “identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and -major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic -institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.”1 +Heat -This report focuses on the Act’s charge to address the growing deficiencies at federal and national -laboratories. This report provides an overview of those deficiencies and (short of additional -appropriations) makes suggestions about practices that could be more widely adopted throughout -government agencies. The report builds on the 2021 National Strategic Overview for Research and -Development Infrastructure,2 which provided a broad overview of the management and policy tools -used in the development and management of federal research and development infrastructure (RDI). + A 500g aluminum cylinder at T=20C is heated using steam at T=140C. +What is the minimum mass of the steam required to raise the +temperature of the aluminum cylinder by 40C? -In spite of the challenges facing the federal RDI ecosystem, since the last report was written there have -been several major developments in U.S. research and development infrastructure. For example, on -December 25, 2021, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) launched and has sent back unparalleled -insight into exoplanets, the origins of our universe, and more. The National Ignition Facility announced -that on December 5, 2022, it achieved fusion ignition for the first time. Major construction projects like -the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) and Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) have hit critical milestones -and announced significant international partnerships. On the planning and competition front, both the -Department of Energy (DOE) and Department of State have engaged in global surveys of international -RDI capabilities to help inform our future competitive landscape, and the DOE advisory committees are -undertaking a broad-based prioritization effort to identify critical capabilities through the next -decades. Significant progress has been made through community planning processes in all fields -relevant to research and development infrastructure (RDI), supported by our federal advisory -committees and the decadal planning processes undertaken by the National Academies of Sciences, -Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM). +3 -This report identifies four trends that can be found across federal research agencies. They are as -follows: +(A) 7mg -• Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure +(B) 0.7kg -• Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities +(C) 7kg -1 America COMPETES Act of 2007. Public Law 10-69, Section 1007. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/PLAW- +(D) 70kg -110publ69 +1. Qgained = Qlost +2. Heat Gained by Aluminum = Heat Lost by the Steam (1. Cooling, 2. Condensing, 3. Water Cooling) +3. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteamcsteam(ΔT)steam + msteamLvaporization + mwatercwater(ΔT)water +4. msteam = mwater (note csteam ≠ cwater) +5. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteam[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water] +6. msteam = mAlcAl(ΔT)Al /[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water] +7. msteam = [(0.5kg)(900J/kgC)(60C-20C)]/[2010J/kgC(140C-100C) + -2 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021. +2.2x106J/kg+ 4186J/kgC(100C-60C)] -https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf +8. msteam = 7.18x10-3kg ≈ 7mg -– 4 – +Aluminum: +cAl = 900 J/kg*C - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -• Widening Gaps in Global Science and Technology (S&T) Outcomes + A slug of copper (0.2kg) at 800C is immersed in 0.4kg of water at 80C. +The final temp is 100C. Part of the water boiled off as steam. +What was the mass of the water converted to steam? -• Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent +4 -To address these, the report identifies four areas that agencies can currently use within their existing -budgets and legal authorities to help address these deficiencies: +(A) 7mg -• Strategic Planning +(B) 8mg -o Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to -budget planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if -such investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable -impacts to mission execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are -difficult to attribute. +(C) 9mg -o The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of -facilities’ maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well- -defined prioritizations developed by each agency, and these assessments should be -updated regularly. +(D) 10mg -• +1. Qgained = Qlost +2. Heat lost by copper= Warms-up water + Converts some water to steam +3.mCucCu(ΔT)Cu = mwatercwater(ΔT)water + msteamLvaporization +4.msteam = [(mCucCu(ΔT)Cu) - (mwatercwater(ΔT)water)]/Lvaporization +5.msteam = [(0.2kg)(387J/kgC)(800C-100C) - (0.4kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C- -Identification of Gaps +80C)]/(2.26x106J/kg) -o Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning -efforts to identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research -community, including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in -academe, industry, and government. +6.msteam = 9.16 x10-3 kg ≈ 9mg … which is 9mL of liquid water -o Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in -U.S. dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those -capabilities are no longer possessed by the United States or its allies. +Copper: +cCu = 387 J/kg*C -• Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kg ºC +csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC +cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC -o Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their -respective mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by -DOE’s Office of Science (SC) federal advisory committees, the State Department’s -survey of international facilities, and through the decadal survey process. + It takes 10 minutes for your stove burner to bring 2 quarts of water +(~1.9kg) to boiling (100C) from room temperature (20C). +What is the minimum power output of your stove burner? +(I.e. assume 100% efficiency of heat transfer) -o To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the -Florence Agreement Program3 and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate -both national and international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in- -kind contributions, materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and -technologies importation. +8 -• Sharing RDI Strategies +(A) 1060 W (B) 600 W (C) 4186 W (D) 640,000 W -o The NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure will coordinate -an interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, -with activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, +1. Power = Energy/Time +2. Energy = Heat = Q = mwatercwaterΔT = (1.9kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-20C) = 636,272J +3. Time = 10min=600s +4. Power= (636,272J)/(600s) = 1060 J/s = 1060 W -3 Statutory Import Programs,” (International Trade Administration, n.d.). www.trade.gov/statutory-import- +Water: +Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg +Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg +cice = 2090 J/kgC +csteam = 2010 J/kgC +cwater = 4186 J/kgC +ρwater = 1000kg/m3 -programs + You will NOT be asked about the material below on +any homework or exam. Therefore you CAN IGNORE +IT, if you like. -– 5 – +We had to trim the following from this year’s course content due to the pandemic. +However, I think some of you may be curious. - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security + A washer is made of some metal with some thermal coefficient of linear +expansion, α. +If the washer is heated, what happens to R1 and R2? -identifying gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and -international collaborations in facilities. +(A) R1 decreases, R2 increases -Being a science superpower carries the burden of supporting and maintaining the advanced underlying -infrastructure that supports the research and development enterprise. Congressional appropriations -have not kept pace with maintenance needs across multiple administrations, resulting in multibillion -dollar maintenance backlogs across multiple government agencies, forcing government managers into -a position where they must choose between executing science missions or maintaining their facilities. +(B) R1 increases, R2 increases -These challenges come at a time when the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and other parts of the world -are able to provide newer, state-of-the-art facilities offering improved access that attracts U.S. and -other international researchers.4 Without action to remedy the situation, deferred maintenance will -only increase in both cost and impact to the U.S. taxpayer and to many of the nation’s critical S&T -programs. +(C) R1 increases, R2 decreases -Finally, to support the continued development of a robust federal RDI ecosystem, agencies should -continue to support the opportunities mentioned in the 2021 National Strategic Overview:5 +(D) R1 decreases, R2 decreases -• Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination +1. ΔL = αL0ΔT +2. This means all linear dimensions increase. +3. The radii are linear dimensions, so both will increase. -• Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise +For instance, consider what would +happen if our washer were made- +up of separate square components. +All sides would lengthen and “R1” +and “R2” would both increase. -• Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors + Thermal Expansion of Solids: Volume expansion -• Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs +• Sometimes we want to consider how the volume of an object changes -4 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the +when we heat it. This is the volume expansion -BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf +• Volume expansion: ΔV = βV0ΔT +• The fractional change in volume is: ΔV/V0 = βΔT +• β is the coefficient of volume expansion (SI units: K-1) -5 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021, vi. +– For solids: β≈3α +– For liquids: More complicated, so look-up in table -https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf +Most materials expand in volume when +they heat-up. However, water doesn’t. -– 6 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Introduction - -“The race for technological dominance is -inextricably intertwined with evolving -geopolitics and is increasingly shaped by -broader political, economic, and societal -rivalries, particularly those associated with -the PRC’s rise. - -The United States has a rich history of investing -heavily in its S&T enterprise, its S&T workforce, as -well as RDI, including laboratories, specialized -facilities, and equipment. A focus on S&T expanded -during the 1950s as the Cold War escalated. Under -the GI Benefits Bill, thousands of returning veterans -were trained as scientists and engineers to establish -the nation’s leadership in S&T, and this growth -continued as the generation of baby boomers, who -grew up during the Sputnik era, pursued careers in -S&T. During the 1950s and 1960s, the federal -government greatly expanded research programs -across multiple agencies to catalyze growth in -research and development (R&D). Concurrently, the -U.S. government invested millions of dollars in -to -building -accommodate the nation’s growing R&D enterprise. -These facilities, constructed at federal agencies and -federally funded R&D centers (FFRDCs), included -new laboratory buildings and specialized facilities -and equipment, such as accelerators, ground- and -space-based telescopes, reactors, and X-ray sources, to study fundamental and applied science. This -investment helped build the nation’s research and development infrastructure (RDI), which is defined -as the “facilities or systems used by scientific and technical communities to conduct R&D or foster -innovation.”6 - -Amassing the resources to sustain broad -technology leadership, including the -concentration of human talent, -foundational knowledge, and supply -chains, requires decades of long-term -investment and visionary leadership. Those -focusing their resources today are likely to -be the technology leaders of 2040.” +*Note the change in density is tiny, so we +can usually get away with ignoring it, +until the phase-transition to ice happens. -“Global Trends 2040: A More Contested World,” -National Intelligence Council, 2021, 56. -http://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessm - -laboratories and other - -ents/GlobalTrends_2040.pdf - -facilities - -These substantial investments propelled the United States to global science leadership and led to -technology breakthroughs that served as a foundation for the nation’s economic growth and national -security. Even under the Congressionally-authorized levels in the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022, -Federal RDI construction and maintenance has not seen the same level of prioritization as in prior -decades. One result has been an aging of the infrastructure at federal research laboratories and -facilities that is reducing scientific output and, in some cases, impacting the ability of departments and -agencies to meet their mission needs. - -The existing federal scientific infrastructure served the nation well in the 20th century, enabling the -United States to become a global leader in scientific discovery, talent development, and innovation. -Having reached that pinnacle, however, many U.S. scientists and engineers are now faced with -conducting 21st century R&D in many facilities designed in the 1950s that cannot support modern -research and current laboratory practices in health and safety. Many do not have sufficient, clean, -reliable, and secure electrical power necessary to support today’s instrumentation and high- -performance computers. Some also lack modern information technology (IT) capabilities needed to - -6 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure,” Subcommittee on Research and - -Development Infrastructure of the National Science and Technology Council, October 2021, iii. -www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf - -– 7 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -protect against data loss and cyberattacks (assuming such networking capabilities are even present). -Older HVAC systems are inefficient and costly to operate, and buildings were not designed to allow the -strict environmental controls needed for today’s laboratory operations. In many cases, infrastructure -has reached end-of-life for systems that manage water and sewage, steam and chilled water -distribution, and electrical networks. - -Departments and agencies have reported that the average age of their facilities exceeds the 40- to 50- -year design life of most facilities, with half rated to be in poor or critical condition. Because these -facilities are operating well beyond their expected lifetimes, the risk of failures is high. The risk is further -compounded by aging water, steam, gas, electrical, and other types of distribution systems that are -often inefficient, difficult to repair, and do not meet modern safety codes. Failing infrastructure is -causing interruptions in research activities lasting weeks or months and has resulted in significant -setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to -research programs. Another critical issue facing federal RDI is that facilities built in the mid-20th century -generally cannot support the needs of modern research, which requires clean, reliable electrical power, -strictly controlled environments, robust internet networks, and integrated cybersecurity infrastructure, -among other requirements not found in older facilities. Further, investments in new scientific user -facilities are needed to provide U.S. researchers with world-leading capabilities. Without RDI designed -for advancing critical and emerging technologies, such as quantum information S&T, engineering -materials, biotechnologies, sensors, and microelectronics, U.S. leadership in these areas will be -seriously and adversely impacted. - -The challenges that the U.S. RDI enterprise is experiencing are not new and reflect decades of -inadequate funding due to deprioritizing maintenance at existing facilities, development of new -facilities, and decommissioning of outdated facilities. Further, these challenges are occurring -simultaneously with intensified S&T competition with other nations. This is especially true of the PRC, -which is vying to become the preferred partner on large RDI projects for other nations. For instance, the -PRC has invested in new RDI outside of its borders, building supercomputers,7 earth observing satellite -constellations,8 telescopes,9 and even biosafety labs10 in Africa and South America. In 2022, PRC -President Xi Jinping committed to increase the number of international laboratories built in countries -participating in the Belt and Road Initiative to 100 over five years.11 As the PRC develops such novel -capabilities, the pressure for U.S. scientists to seek partnerships in order to utilize those capabilities in -order to say at the top of their fields correspondingly increases. - -7 High speed computer donated to Tunisia's scientific research field. China Global Television Network, retrieved - -from YouTube, June 25, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzLJ8qi_XGk - -8 Special Report: China’s Space Collaboration with Africa: Implications and Recommendations for the United - -States. U.S. Institute of Peace, September 2023. https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/2023-09/sr- -524_china-space-collaboration-africa-implications-recommendations-for-us.pdf - -9 South America is embracing Beijing’s science silk road. Nature, May 8, 2019. - -https://www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-019-01127-4/index.html - -10 Africa CDC and China CDC Commit to Deepen their Cooperation. Africa Centres for Disease Control and - -Prevention. https://africacdc.org/news-item/africa-cdc-and-china-cdc-commit-to-deepen-their-cooperation/ - -11 China’s Belt and Road Initiative is boosting science — the West must engage, not withdraw. Nature, October - -24, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-03299-6 - -– 8 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Some international facilities possess certain advantages due to their structuring as international -organizations or state-supported commercial enterprises with stable, multiyear funding. Europe, in -particular, has substantial experience leveraging investments from multiple countries through -organizations like the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), the European Southern -Observatory, and the European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network. While many of these facilities, -like CERN, provide open research platforms that mirror the U.S. model of facility access based on merit, -other international facilities either require membership in an international treaty or fee-based access -for outsiders. Others, like the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) and -COSMO-SkyMed satellite constellation charge for access to products and services. This has direct -consequences for broad U.S. access to and utilization of significant RDI capabilities. The challenges -associated with U.S. participation in such facilities (to include limitations due to the appropriations -process and Anti-Deficiency Act) often means that the United States does not have a seat at the table -when setting the rules for international RDI governance, providing an opening for competitors like the -PRC and Russia to have greater say in the governance of platforms that may require the development -of novel or dual-use technology. - -In addition to buildings and facilities, other capabilities factor into the way the United States conducts -research. High-performance computers, combined with new modeling and data analysis techniques, -such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, allow large sets of diverse data to be assimilated, -analyzed, and modeled, accelerating the pace of discovery and development. For example, -computational tools can be used in conjunction with multiple types of structural data combined with -measured material properties to yield insight into the relationship of a material’s structure with its -properties. Such an approach would expedite the discovery of new materials critical to emerging -technologies, including electronics, quantum materials, and engineering materials. Similarly, data from -infrastructure distributed across the nation, such as multiple types of air, water, and soil monitors and -satellite data, could be rapidly analyzed and modeled to provide more complete and timely -assessments of ecosystems. - -While the United States continues to lead the world in many fields of S&T at present, urgent efforts must -be made to ensure that federal RDI is ready to serve the nation’s research community in the future. -Numerous efforts to develop world-leading R&D capabilities have been deployed or are underway. -These include the successful commissioning and deployment of JWST12 and major R&D facilities -construction projects like the EIC13 and LBNF hitting critical milestones14 and announcing international -partnerships. Designed to facilitate a shared national research infrastructure for responsible artificial -intelligence (AI) discovery and innovation for the broad research and education community, the -National AI Research Resource (NAIRR) launched its pilot on January 24, 2024, with 10 government - -12 “NASA’s Webb Telescope Is Now Fully Ready for Science.” (NASA. July 11, 2022). - -https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2022/07/11/nasas-webb-telescope-is-now-fully-ready-for-science/ - -13 “Electron-Ion Collider Set to Begin Long-Lead Procurements.” (Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 2, 2024). - -https://www.bnl.gov/newsroom/news.php?a=121812 - -14 “Excavation of colossal caverns for Fermilab’s DUNE experiment completed.” (Fermi National Accelerator - -Laboratory. February 9, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/02/excavation-of-colossal-caverns-for-fermilabs- -dune-experiment-completed/ - -– 9 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security + You fill-up your 12-gallon fuel tank in your sedan up to the brim and +forget to put on your gas cap. Your friend makes the same mistake after +filling-up the 18-gallon fuel tank in her truck to the brim. +It gets really hot outside and the gasoline heats-up. +Who loses the most gas? -agency partners and 25 nongovernment partners.15 DOE/SC’s federal advisory committees have -released international benchmarking studies comparing RDI capabilities of the United States with -those in other parts of the world. The Department of State conducted a survey assessing planned RDI -capabilities issued to all diplomatic and consular posts. +5 -Major prioritization and assessment efforts, such as the 2023 Particle Physics Projects Prioritization -Panel report16 have been released. Agencies continue to actively commission RDI prioritization -exercises from their relevant federal advisory committees and through the decadal survey process, -where agencies seek community input via NASEM. Within the context of the RDI subcommittee, the -Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections on November 29, 2023 released the “The Unique -Role of Federal Scientific Collections,” assessing the varied ways that federal scientific collections have -served the nation in diverse areas of American life.17 Historically, these activities have focused primarily -on addressing the immediate scientific needs of the community; additional effort could be given to -assessing and enhancing the competitive position of the United States. +(A) You do -To sustain world S&T leadership, the United States must continue to make strategic investments to -maintain and renew federal facilities and supporting infrastructure, as well as phase out and -decommission federal RDI that is no longer needed. These critical investments in new, modern facilities -will underpin S&T innovation well into the future. These investments are also vital for training the next -generation of U.S. scientists and engineers who will conduct research, develop new technical -innovations, and manufacture new products. The challenge is to maintain a consistent and intentional -revitalization of the U.S. RDI while balancing competing needs and ensuring well-coordinated -prioritization decisions. +(B) Your friend does -Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure +(C) You both lose the same amount -The Act requires that the National Science and Technology Council produce an annual report -“identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and major instrumentation located at -federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic institutions that are widely accessible for -use by researchers in the United States.” This report answers that requirement. - -Four issues put the future success of the nation’s R&D enterprise at risk: Aging and Inadequate Research -Infrastructure, Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities, Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes, -and Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent. Together, these -issues present a serious threat to the country’s continued scientific innovation, output, and global -leadership in S&T. Understanding the context and consequence of these issues can shape action plans -for revitalizing the nation’s RDI. - -15 “Democratizing the future of AI R&D: NSF to launch National AI Research Resource pilot.” (National Science - -Foundation, January 24, 2024). https://new.nsf.gov/news/democratizing-future-ai-rd-nsf-launch-national-ai - -16 “Exploring Our Quantum Universe.” (Report of the 2023 Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel, - -December, 2023). https://www.usparticlephysics.org/2023-p5-report/assets/pdf/P5Report2023_121023- -DRAFT_single-pages.pdf - -17 “The Unique Role of Federal Scientific Collections: Infrastructure Generating Benefits, Serving Diverse Agency - -Missions” (A report of the Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections). -https://smithsonian.figshare.com/articles/book/The_Unique_Role_of_Federal_Scientific_Collections_Infrastr -ucture_Generating_Benefits_Serving_Diverse_Agency_Missions/24559996/1 - -– 10 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure - -Outdated and deficient RDI across the federal government is threatening U.S. leadership in R&D and -impeding technology breakthroughs. - -Aging infrastructure in many federal research laboratories and facilities is impacting the ability of -federal agencies to meet their current missions. Many facilities are rated as being in very poor condition. - -• A 2023 survey of Department of Energy (DOE) facilities at its 17 national laboratories showed -that the average age of these facilities was 46 years, close to the end of the planned 40- to 50- -year design life. This study further stated that nearly 40 percent of DOE facilities have been rated -as substandard or inadequate to serve DOE’s mission.18 - -• A survey of research facilities at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) -showed that 73 percent of facilities are 60 to 70 years old, and over 60 percent of the square -footage is classified as in “poor to critical condition.”19 - -• A 2019 report noted, “The buildings and facilities at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) -Bethesda Campus are in need of significant improvement and upgrading to sustain their current -mission and ongoing functionality. The 12 million facility square feet have an average Condition -Index of 83.3, which is considered poor.”20 - -• - -In an annual report to Congress in 2024, the Department of Defense’s (DoD) unfunded research, -development, test, and evaluation (RDT&E) infrastructure requirements were shown to have -grown significantly since annual reporting began in 2018, putting the military at risk of losing -its technological superiority.21 - -• A 2024 National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) report stated that 75 percent of -its facilities are beyond their designed lifetime, and as of 2022, had an estimated deferred -maintenance backlog of $3 billion.22 - -• The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Agricultural Research Service (ARS) has -approximately 3,000 facilities and structures in its inventory, with an average age of over 48 -years, and a $1.6 billion deferred maintenance backlog. - -Failures due to aging RDI can result in costly and significant interruptions in research activities lasting -weeks or months. For example, failures over a nine-month period that led to inadequate back-up power -and power conditioning at one NIST research facility cost an estimated $9 million and loss of 47,000 - -18 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure - -19 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 31. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684 - -20 Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical - -Research Environment, National Academies Press eBooks, 2019. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483 - -21 U.S. Department of Defense Fiscal Year 2025 Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction -Projects. February 2024. Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Report to -Congress on Section 2806 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91). - -22 NASA’s FY 2024 Volume of Integrated Performance. www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/fiscal-year- - -2024-volume-of-integrated-perfomance.pdf - -– 11 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -researcher hours.23 These failures can be compounded by the need to repair outdated equipment with -scarce replacement parts as well as a lack of personnel familiar with older components and systems. -These older systems also lack modern safety and security protection features that are standard in -equipment purchased and installed today. For example, modern electrical switchgear often -incorporates optical arc flash reduction systems, and today’s natural gas distribution systems have -built-in safety features absent in older systems. Moreover, the configurations of old steam, chilled -water, natural gas, compressed air, sewer, and other types of support systems make it difficult to -maintain sections of pipe or valves without extended outages. Another looming issue is that older -buildings do not meet today’s more stringent seismic standards, and the failure of susceptible buildings -could indefinitely halt research activities. Finally, many of these older buildings are contaminated with -materials that pose significant environmental and health concerns, including radioactive materials, -beryllium, asbestos, and lead. - -Today’s research is vastly different than that conducted when these buildings were designed in the mid- -20th century; thus, even well-maintained facilities do not meet the requirements of modern research. -First, older buildings were designed with laboratories that accommodate a lead investigator and a few -support staff, whereas today’s science is most often conducted by larger, collaborative teams of -investigators who require flexible space that can be readily reconfigured to meet changing research -directions. Second, research today is governed by robust environmental, health, and safety standards -that were not in place when these buildings were designed. For example, 50 years ago, nearly all -experiments were conducted at open laboratory benches, and laboratories included only a limited -number of ventilation hoods. Today, research standards require hoods for nearly all chemistry, -molecular biology, materials, and nanoscience experimental procedures. Also, updated fire codes -restrict the types and quantities of chemicals and gases that can be stored and used in a single fire zone; -older buildings were designed with a limited number of fire zones, and some have only one designated -fire zone for an entire building encompassing thousands of square feet. Further, modern research has -very different demands for utilities and other infrastructure that were not anticipated even a decade -ago. For example, outdated and inefficient HVAC and electrical systems are incapable of controlling -temperature and humidity within the exacting requirements of sensitive equipment, such as ultra-fast -laser systems and microscopes used in materials science and biology studies. Often, this type of -sensitive equipment also requires specialized environments with low vibration and electromagnetic -interference. - -In addition to these concerns, the cost to maintain aging facilities, even without bringing them up to -modern standards, continues to grow. For example, in annual DoD reports to Congress on RDT&E -revitalization, these costs were estimated to be $4.7 billion in 2019, growing to $7.7 billion in 2024.24 -Similarly, a 2019 study commissioned by the NIH and led by NASEM reported that the backlog of - -23 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 44. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684 - -24 Report to Congress on Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction Projects. February 2019. -Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Section 2806 of the National Defense -Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91) - -– 12 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -maintenance and repair for NIH’s Bethesda campus was $1.3 billion and growing rapidly.25 At the end -of fiscal year (FY) 2023, the Bethesda backlog had grown to $3.4 billion and, taking into account all NIH -sites in Maryland, Montana, and North Carolina, the backlog was reported to be $3.8 billion at the end -of FY 2023. The NASEM study triggered Congressional interest, which resulted in increases in NIH’s -Buildings and Facilities appropriation from $200 million in FY 2019 to $350 million in FY 2023. However, -even at the higher investment amount, the backlog continues to increase. - -Construction and renovation of research infrastructure provides the opportunity to incorporate agile, -efficient, and resilient designs that can adapt to new technologies, new operating standards, new work -environments, and changing missions. Effective modernization and design will lead to savings in -energy, cost, and space while improving laboratory functionality and capability (see sidebar “Modern -Chemical and Materials Science Building”). - -A successful renovation of an older building is exemplified by Building 1 on the NIST campus in Boulder, -CO, a structure that was dedicated by President Eisenhower in the 1950s. After renovation, a wing of -this building became the new home to quantum information science and technology research, -supporting experiments that demonstrated quantum entanglement of microresonators, an innovation -recognized as the Physics World 2021 Breakthrough of the Year. This research could never have been -accomplished in the original laboratory, which lacked necessary environmental controls for these -sensitive experiments.26 - -Some agencies have already taken steps and devised innovative solutions to address inadequate RDI. -For example, DOE’s Office of Science (SC) instituted the Science Laboratories Infrastructure program, -which invests over $300 million annually to transform and modernize foundational infrastructure at -its national laboratories. To facilitate this strategic program, the DOE Laboratory Operations Board,27 -which includes federal and national laboratory representatives, assesses facilities and infrastructure -across the DOE national laboratory complex. These enterprise-wide assessments result in a rigorous -and consistent analysis of the condition, utilization, and functionality of the facilities and -infrastructure that are most critical to accomplishing the mission. Building on these assessments, SC -works with each of its laboratories to develop comprehensive campus strategies used to establish -infrastructure priorities. - -25 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital -Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical Research Environment. Washington, DC: The -National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483 - -26 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, - -National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 34, https://doi.org/10.17226/26684. - -27 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure - -– 13 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Modern Chemical and Materials Science Building - -Chemical and Materials Sciences Building constructed in 2011 at -Oak Ridge National Laboratory. [Courtesy ORNL] - -With more than 300,000 square feet, Building 4500S at DOE’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory was -built in the 1960s to house dozens of materials science and chemistry laboratories with associated -offices. As was typical during this era, the labs in this facility were constructed with only one or two -chemical hoods and a handful of electrical circuits. HVAC systems were designed to condition -outside air and exhaust it through the chemical hoods, turning over the entire volume of air in the -building at a rate of 30 times per hour; this made the building exceptionally expensive to operate. - -A new Chemical and Materials Sciences Building was constructed in 2011 and received Gold LEED -certification by employing many energy saving innovations, such as reducing air flow in hoods not -being actively used. To meet modern research requirements, these laboratories contain up to six -hoods for use by teams of researchers and many electrical circuits and internet connections to -accommodate modern laboratory equipment and computers. Compared to the single fire zone in -the old building, the new building was designed with multiple fire zones and special storage rooms -on each floor to facilitate high chemical loading and reduce fire hazards caused by storing chemicals -in the laboratories. - -These features allowed lab space to be consolidated with a 30 percent savings in space compared -to the old facility, while adding new functionalities, such as highly controlled environments required -for laser spectroscopy and imaging. The labs were also designed to be readily reconfigurable to -accommodate changing programs, with all benches equipped with wheels and special utility hook- -ups enabling their easy removal. Importantly, the building was also designed with features that -support collaborations across disciplines that are critical for today’s scientific enterprise. As a result, -an influx of both student and staff researchers have joined the research programs of the -organizations in this modern laboratory building. - -Similarly, the DoD has a variety of authorities to assist in the modernization and revitalization of its RDI. -One of these, 10 U.S.C § 4123, also known as “FLEX-4,” authorizes laboratories to allocate between two -percent and four percent of their total RDT&E funds toward workforce development, basic research, -technology transition, and repair of laboratory infrastructure and equipment. DoD laboratories can use -revitalization and recapitalization projects to adapt facilities and infrastructure to support new - -– 14 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -technology missions. Since the inception of the FLEX-4 Program in 2009, DoD laboratories have invested -more than $4 billion across the four categories, funding improvements not possible otherwise. - -Since 2012, USDA ARS has reviewed its laboratory RDI and developed a long-term plan for future capital -investments, as outlined in “Capital Investment Strategy” (CIS) reports. Since 2013, ARS has adopted -the U.S. Corps of Engineers BUILDER assessment program28 to conduct assessments and assign a -condition index to each facility assessed. This index takes into consideration facility age, capacity, -safety and health issues, security, time since last repair/renovation, new capabilities needed, and -current and future research priorities. Since 2015, ARS has received funding to modernize 30 projects of -the 138 outlined in the most recent ARS CIS update. - -Many other agencies, such as the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have developed plans for -building renovations, but due to the lack of funds are unable to complete needed renovations at many -of their laboratory sites. - -In summary, aging infrastructure can cause research setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, -and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to research programs. Further, outdated RDI -impedes research that requires specialized infrastructure for sensitive experiments and equipment to -advance tomorrow’s technologies. Some agencies have taken steps to address these issues by -developing processes for prioritizing needs and by funding facility modernization and revitalization; -however, more fully addressing these needs will require strategic planning across the federal R&D -enterprise, as well as increased budgetary planning. - -Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities - -Aging and inadequate federal facilities can impact research efforts of government, universities, and -industry. - -Federal laboratories are home to many types of RDI that provide unique capabilities needed to sustain -the United States as a world leader in S&T. In addition to research facilities that support specific agency -missions, federal agencies also host specialized facilities that serve the nation. These critically -important facilities are not found in the private sector or academia due to their high construction and -maintenance costs, as well as their support of highly specialized equipment. Such equipment includes -the world’s largest vacuum chamber at NASA Glenn Research Center, radiation measurement and -calibration laboratories at NIST, DOE’s suite of scientific user facilities, and the National Science -Foundation’s (NSF) Antarctic research stations (see sidebar “Improving Antarctic Infrastructure”). - -Many of the nation’s unique federal research assets are operating well beyond their design lifetimes -and RDI failures can have a serious impact on the nation’s research enterprise. For example, in the -summer of 2022, the underground utility distribution system failed on the NIST campus in Gaithersburg, -MD, along with HVAC systems, resulting in a shutdown that lasted 14 days and impacted nearly all 1,700 -campus laboratories. The effects of this shutdown lasted much longer, compromising NIST’s ability to -provide measurement standards and support to multiple federal agencies, the private sector, and -universities. In turn, the research conducted by these customers, who require standards for quantum - -28 BUILDER Sustainment Management System. https://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/Media/Fact-Sheets/Fact- - -Sheet-Article-View/Article/476728/builder-sustainment-management-system/ - -– 15 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -science and technology, radiation physics, and other important traceable measurements, were -significantly delayed. - -National laboratories have long documented the broader impact of facilities investments on local -economies.29 While it is generally acknowledged that certain facilities have developed reputations as -training grounds for scientists and engineers in specific fields, relatively less attention has been paid to -the impact of facility degradation, incidents, and changes in facilities’ reputation on local universities, -business, and other stakeholder communities. Given the importance of RDI to local economies, as well -as their distribution around the country in diverse communities, greater attention to that relationship -may be warranted. - -Impact of Investment on the U.S. National Collections - -Helianthus annuus [Courtesy NMNH] - -The United States National Herbarium is one of the world’s largest and most diverse botanical -collections, accounting for more than 4 million specimens. The Smithsonian National Museum of -Natural History’s (NMNH) multi-year, approximately 7-million-dollar effort to digitize the herbarium -resulted in 3.8 million new specimen images, 2.8 million new label transcriptions, and over 80,000 -new taxonomic names added to the data catalog. This provides full access to the collection using -digital technology and shared online platforms. Full digitization also improves management and -enhances the long-term preservation of these fragile collections. Reliance on an industrial approach -rather than specimen by specimen actions reduced the average cost per specimen of digitization -from $3.32 and 555 seconds to $1.85 and 102 seconds. Deep learning tools have already been used -to identify past specimen preservation methods that are hazardous prompting remediation efforts. -The 500 percent increase in the past five years in web inquiries demonstrates that digital -accessibility is serving research: in 2015, 14 million botanical records were queried via the online -page. In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, this number exploded to 70 million records queried. - -29 “Fermilab drives economic growth in Illinois and South Dakota.” (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, -March 28, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/03/fermilab-drives-economic-growth-in-illinois-and-south- -dakota/ - -– 16 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Improving Antarctic Infrastructure - -Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station at dawn. [Courtesy Raffaela Busse and -the National Science Foundation. Reused under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.] - -The National Science Foundation (NSF) oversees three facilities in Antarctica that support important -and unique experiments sponsored by multiple U.S. agencies, ranging from astronomy to -environmental studies. However, maintaining and operating infrastructure at these facilities present -unique and costly challenges due to the harsh environment in Antarctica. For example, buildings are -in danger of becoming buried in snow, resulting in structural damage, and even collapse. -Environmental satellite grounds systems, which are crucial for weather forecasting, flight planning, -aviation safety, station operations, and science support, are beyond their end-of-life timelines and -in danger of failure. Even fuel transport to the South Pole Station has become more challenging due -to aging and increasingly unreliable equipment for traverses that carry 100,000 gallons of fuel -annually. - -A 2012 NSF report noted that “U.S. activities in Antarctica are very well managed but suffer from an -aging infrastructure, lack of a capital budget, and the effects of operating in an extremely unforgiving -environment. …when the…[NSF]…and its contractors must choose between repairing a roof or -conducting science, science usually prevails. Only when the science is seriously disrupted because -the roof begins to collapse will it be replaced; until then, it is likely only to be repaired. ...The status -quo is simply not an option ...Failure to [recapitalize]... will simply increase logistics costs until they -altogether squeeze out funding for science. A ten percent increase in the cost of logistics will -consume 40 percent of the remaining science budget.” - -NSF established a recapitalization program of $60 million a year that comprises a portfolio of -investments to mitigate aging infrastructure, assure safe working conditions, enhance operational -efficiencies, and support continued U.S. science leadership on the continent. - -More and Better Science in Antarctica Through Increased Logistical Effectiveness: Report of the U.S. Antarctic Program -Blue Ribbon Panel, 2012. www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/usap_special_review/usap_brp/rpt/antarctica_07232012.pdf - -– 17 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes - -Lagging U.S. RDI investment compared to other nations can erode U.S. leadership and influence in science -and technology. - -Significant investments in specialized RDI catalyzed U.S. scientific innovations in the 20th century. -These investments included large particle accelerators, wind tunnels, X-ray and neutron sources, and -large outdoor test ranges, as well as state-of-the-art research laboratories. With these capabilities, the -United States dominated for decades innovations that fueled the American economy, increased -security, and improved quality of life—including advances in computers and personal electronics, -breakthroughs in healthcare, and development of electric vehicles, among others. Today, however, -increasing investments in RDI in other nations, if unanswered, may lead to loss of U.S. global leadership. - -An example of the threat to U.S. S&T leadership is clearly seen in the area of high-performance -computing and computer science over the last decade. As shown in Figure 1, in 2015, the United States -contributed the most supercomputers30 to the Top500 list globally, backed by strong support from the -federal government for the development of leading high-performance computers. However, only seven -years later, in 2022, the PRC surpassed the United States in number of supercomputers on the Top500 -list, due in part to the PRC’s increased investment in R&D. The impact of the PRC’s investment is readily -apparent when comparing research output: the PRC is the top overall producer of S&E publications and -international patents and has the greatest knowledge- and technology-intensive (KTI) manufacturing -output.31 The United States remains the world leader in KTI services. - -Figure 1. Comparison of the 500 most powerful commercially-available supercomputers per country (from -www.top500.org). - -30 Supercomputers are used to model and simulate complex, dynamic systems that would be too expensive, - -impractical or impossible to physically demonstrate. Supercomputers are changing the way scientists explore -the evolution of our universe, biological systems, weather forecasting and even renewable energy. See more -at https://www.energy.gov/supercomputing-and-exascale - -31 “Translation: U.S. and Global Science, Technology, and Innovation Capabilities.” The State of U.S. Science and -Engineering 2024. Figures 21, 25. https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20243/translation-u-s-and-global-science- -technology-and-innovation-capabilities - -– 18 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Maintaining and improving U.S. computing infrastructure is critical for many applications. For example, -accurate and timely climate and weather models are critical to missions that protect and support the -U.S. economy and national security. However, evidence shows that the National Oceanic and -Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA’s) Global Forecast System lags behind the capabilities of systems -developed by other countries, such as the ECMWF.32 - -A 2021 NOAA Advisory Board report noted the lack of investment in computing power “indicates that -not only are we underserving the American public, but also that the United States has the potential to -provide more accurate and reliable weather information. The public benefits of NOAA regaining a -leadership role would be increased forecast accuracy, longer lead times, and finer-scale detail for -severe weather, flooding and hurricanes.”33 Further, many agencies including NOAA34 and DOE35 have -highlighted the growing demand to provide expanded and updated computing infrastructure to -complement experimental capabilities to facilitate efficient data sharing, integration, and analysis. - -In August 2023, the Defense Science Board reported in its briefing to the Office of Science and -Technology Policy (OSTP) on Balancing Openness and Security, “China (the PRC) is outpacing the U.S. -in global competition for key emerging technologies, leading in 37 out of 44 critical and emerging -technologies (e.g., electric batteries, hypersonics, quantum computing, and others). Western -democracies risk losing the global competition for research output and technological innovation.”36 -Leadership in this competition is enabled by state-of-the-art RDI, such as X-ray and neutron sources, -nanoscience facilities, biotechnology centers, accelerators, and specialized testing facilities, among -others (see sidebar “Broader Impacts of Accelerator Science and Technology”). - -Proactively planning and prioritizing federal infrastructure improvements and modernization can -benefit from benchmarking with other countries. For example, the Basic Energy Science Advisory -Committee, tasked by DOE/SC with benchmarking U.S. capabilities in basic research, concluded that -“advanced research facilities in the United States funded by DOE’s Office of Basic Energy Sciences are -world leading … largely because of long-range strategic planning, ongoing stewardship, and -investments.”37 This type of planning can protect the nation’s research enterprise and have far-reaching -effects. If DOE failed to develop and maintain capabilities at its five X-ray sources, the impact could -affect the 10,000 users served annually, which include scientists from universities, government, and - -32 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 72. - -sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf . - -33 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 22. - -sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf - -34 “NOAA ‘Omics Strategy: Strategic Application of Transformational Tools” (NOAA, February 2020). - -sciencecouncil.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/2020-Omics-Strategy.pdf - -35 “Basic Energy Sciences Network Requirements Review Final Report” (DOE/SC, November 2023). - -science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2023/ESnet-Report.pdf - -36 “Balancing Openness and Security Across the DoD Academic Research Enterprise” (Defense Science Board, - -July 2023), 11, apps.dtic.mil/sti/trecms/pdf/AD1212739.pdf - -37 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the - -BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. -science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf - -– 19 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -industry. For example, the pharmaceutical industry is highly dependent on X-ray crystallography for the -development of new drugs, and more than 30,000 samples are characterized annually on just a single -beamline at the DOE Advanced Photon Source. - -Broader Impacts of Accelerator S&T - -Accelerators broadly impact science, industry, medicine, defense, and other sectors. Annually, -particle accelerators are used to treat more than 5 million cancer patients; ion implantation is -used to produce $300 billion worth of semiconductors; and e-beam irradiation is used to -manufacture over $85 billion worth of consumer products, such as tires and insulation. - -Advances in accelerator technologies are also critical for maintaining the nation’s leadership in -many high energy and nuclear physics experiments, as well as X-ray and neutron sources used -broadly by the scientific community in studies on nanomaterials, vehicle batteries, -pharmaceuticals, and more. - -For years, the United States has been a major supporter of accelerator technology advances, but -its leadership position is being surpassed now by other nations. For example, growth in ultra-high -intensity lasers, an accelerator-based technology, has been stagnant in the United States while -development has increased significantly in Europe and Asia in the last several years. - -Maintaining leadership in this area requires investing in new accelerator infrastructure that can be -used to develop new capabilities and applications. Investment is also needed in training and -retaining experts who can create, operate, and further advance these technologies. - -“Ultra-High Intensity Lasers Facilities Across the Globe Over Time,” 2020. www.icuil.org/downloadss/laser-labs.html - -In some cases, optimizing RDI investments may include establishing international collaborations that -benefit the U.S. S&T enterprise. For example, NSF partnered with S&T funding agencies from Europe, -Japan, and Chile to build the Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array (ALMA)—the most powerful -telescope at these wavelengths in the world. Similarly, NASA partnered with the European and -Canadian space agencies and 14 additional countries to build the JWST. Additionally, such -collaborations offer untapped opportunities to enhance U.S. leadership. - -Proactive planning and prioritization of new and upgraded RDI is needed to ensure the nation’s global -S&T leadership is not eclipsed. Strategies are needed to plan for and prioritize future RDI investments, -including forming collaborations with domestic and international partners. - -Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent - -The declining state of infrastructure is affecting the United States’ ability to recruit and retain scientific -talent. - -Departments, agencies, and federal advisory committees report that sub-optimal research -infrastructure and project cancellations are factors that contribute to the loss of S&T talent in the -federal workforce, impacting researchers at every stage of their careers.38 These conditions affect - -38 “Can the United States Maintain its Leadership in High Performance Computing? (A report by the ASCAC - -Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021). 49. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/ascr/ascac/pdf/charges/2023/Report_20230627.pdf - -– 20 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -students and post-doctoral researchers when they cannot achieve an acceptable rate of productivity -due to aging RDI, which limits their career opportunities. More established researchers are affected -when their productivity and impact declines, preventing them from advancing their agency’s mission -and reaching their career goals. Together, these factors can affect the morale of researchers and drive -them away from the federal research arena. - -The research and often awe-inspiring technologies at the center of our federal laboratories have -inspired generations to pursue technical careers and to push the boundaries of human knowledge, -contributing to U.S. S&T leadership. For instance, NASA supports approximately 2,000 interns, annually, -at all NASA facilities. DOE/SC hosts thousands of students, accounting for about one third of total -unique users at scientific user facilities each year. In 2023, the Smithsonian Institution hosted 510 -interns and 355 fellows at its science units. Altogether, federal RDI facilities make up an important -contribution to developing STEM talent around the country. - -Despite this, external assessments of some federal laboratories have identified major concerns in the -workforce due to recruitment and retention problems which are straining existing staff to their limits. -This can affect the nation’s ability to attract and retain a strong federal S&T workforce, which can in -turn impact leadership and innovation in critical and emerging technologies, such as artificial -intelligence, biotechnology, quantum information S&T, and microelectronics, particularly as other -countries develop similar or more advanced capabilities. Breakthroughs in these areas are imperative -for the development of new products and jobs that fuel the nation’s economy. Solving the RDI problem -should help maintain the federal S&T workforce and R&D leadership to produce innovations critical to -the nation’s economy, security, and well-being. - -One example of how aging infrastructure is impacting the ability to attract and retain researchers is -NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory (AOML). This laboratory, housed in a -building that opened in 1973, is responsible for real-time hurricane-related measurements and -associated activities that include hurricane science, model development, sustained observational -platforms, and maintaining the global oceanographic climate data record. However, the 2019 AOML -Laboratory Review Summary Report stated, “AOML’s physical infrastructure is no longer sufficient to -support cutting-edge science and to attract a world-class scientific workforce.”39 (see Figure 2). - -39 “2019 AOML Laboratory Review Summary Report” (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, - -November 19, 2019), 17, www.aoml.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/AOML-2019-Review-Summary- -Report-FINAL-.pdf - -– 21 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Figure 2. “When AOML started [in 1973], keypunch cards seemed cutting edge, and leisure suits seemed -appropriate for the office.” [Courtesy NOAA] - -Foreign RDI investments are also prompting some U.S. researchers to leave the country to build state- -of-the-art facilities and to find longer-term employment. For example, U.S. diplomats reported in 2018 -that numerous fusion energy researchers and technologists began traveling to the PRC following the -shutdown of several U.S.-based magnetic confinement fusion facilities. U.S. scientists, technologies, -and companies often engage with international facilities where the U.S. government is not present, -such as the Extreme Light Infrastructure (ELI) in Czechia, Hungary, and Romania and the Square -Kilometer Array (SKA) in South Africa to stay on the leading edge of their respective fields. - -The importance of planned investments in maintaining, upgrading, and building (where warranted) -new RDI cannot be overstated, particularly given that many infrastructures may require decades of -planning for successful execution. Such efforts require the development of specialized workforces -around individual projects. Likewise, unexpected cancellations and inadequate communication with -foreign partners can affect the reputation of the United States as a reliable partner, limiting the -willingness of foreign experts to provide their unique expertise to major undertakings.40 Without -significant efforts to address these issues, the nation risks losing the S&T workforce that is critical for -maintaining its role as a global leader in S&T and innovation, which will have far-reaching impacts on -the future economy and security of the United States. - -Opportunities - -Agencies must continue to revitalize RDI critical to the nation’s S&T enterprise, otherwise U.S. RDI will -continue to deteriorate while costs for maintenance and replacement will continue to escalate. -Although agencies need to plan and prioritize investments based on individual needs and budgets, the -following four opportunities—Strategic Planning, Identification of Gaps, Benchmarking International -RDI and Identifying Collaborations, and Sharing RDI Strategies—represent high-level steps required to -ensure the nation’s RDI is prepared to meet future U.S. S&T needs. - -40 “The Path to Global Discovery: U.S. Leadership and Partnership in Particle Physics.” (A report of the High - -Energy Physics Advisory Panel. https://science.osti.gov/- -/media/hep/hepap/pdf/202203/International_Benchmarking_HEPAP_2023112.pdf - -– 22 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -Strategic Planning - -Assessment and prioritization of investments are necessary to maintain and renew legacy facilities, as well -as establish new infrastructure to realize future S&T advances. - -It is clear that the overall state of federal research facilities will continue to require substantial -investments to meet future research needs. Federal agencies and departments must prioritize and -develop short- and long-term strategies for addressing their RDI needs, including sufficient -recapitalization, operations, and maintenance investments in facilities, and disposition of excess -facilities, along with a strong workforce. As part of strategic planning for RDI, agencies should also -develop and maintain standards for assessing total facility and infrastructure costs, including -construction, annual operating costs, maintenance, and renovations, and regular recapitalization. For -example, modernization efforts should address updated requirements for safety (e.g., changes in -building codes), security, and specialized research. Where applicable, agencies should ensure a -proactive lifecycle approach to real property management that aligns with the federal Real Property -Reform Act of 2016, the associated Government Accountability Office framework. Agencies can also -look to external resources, strategies, and best practices like the 2023 NASEM report titled “Strategies -to Renew Federal Facilities.” The specific approaches employed may differ for the various agencies and -their specific RDI requirements. For instance, planning for construction and lifecycle costs of a -conventional laboratory building is quite different than the planning needed for a high-energy -accelerator-based facility that serves thousands of users annually. - -• Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to budget -planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if such -investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable impacts to mission -execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are difficult to attribute. - -• The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of facilities’ -maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-defined prioritizations -developed by each agency, and these assessments should be updated regularly. - -Identification of Gaps - -Agencies and departments should identify gaps in RDI needs and opportunities for collaborations with -other federal, industrial, academic, and international partners. - -Effective planning for RDI first requires input from the federal and non-federal research community, as -well as RDI managers, to help reveal or underscore serious gaps and to identify the potential impact of -these gaps on the U.S. federal S&T enterprise and agency mission execution. This input can be gathered -by various means, such as surveys, requests for information, workshops, and other avenues. For -example, federal research agencies frequently convene researchers from the national and international -communities to identify needs in research infrastructure, such as electron and X-ray sources, -computers, distributed measurement networks, sequencing centers, and other key areas. This gap -analysis could also be used to identify potential partnerships—with other agencies and departments, -the private sector, universities, and international partners—that could provide opportunities for cost- -sharing and result in more impactful RDI that serves a larger research community. - -• Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning efforts to -identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research community, - -– 23 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in academe, industry, -and government. - -• Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in U.S. -dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those capabilities are no -longer possessed by the United States or its allies. - -Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations - -Regular benchmarking should be performed to assess the global position of U.S. RDI and to identify -opportunities for international collaborations. - -Understanding the nation’s global standing in S&T is critical for prioritizing RDI investments and -identifying areas for international collaboration. Benchmarking studies should include documented -data on relevant topics, such as global development of large-scale and mid-scale research facilities, -research outputs and impact, and workforce trends. These assessments would provide foundational -data for the Quadrennial Science and Technology Review and National Science and Technology -Strategy, as well as for other reports and activities related to global competitive assessments. - -These benchmarking studies will also identify opportunities to develop new collaborations and -enhance existing partnerships as well as highlight strategic investments to restore and preserve U.S. -leadership in critical areas while strengthening federal RDI and the scientific workforce. For -international collaborations, processes must be established to reduce the administrative burdens often -associated with developing cutting-edge scientific capabilities, including the importation of materials -and technologies. Efforts should also be made to welcome the participation of international scientific -experts in these benchmarking studies. - -• Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their respective -mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by DOE’s SC federal -advisory committees and the State Department’s survey of international facilities. - -• To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the Florence -Agreement Program and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate both national and -international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-kind contributions, -materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and technologies importation. - -Sharing RDI Strategies - -Establishing an interagency working group would support the modernization of RDI for the future. - -RDI planning would greatly benefit from having regular meetings where representatives from federal -agencies discuss RDI strategic plans and needs at both the agency level and across the federal -government. These discussions would catalyze collaborations and cost-sharing on upgrading or -establishing new RDI. Although federal agencies and departments have unique business practices and -operating principles, they share common issues facing RDI modernization. Therefore, establishing an -interagency RDI working group could also be a platform for sharing best practices and ensuring access -to state-of-the-art RDI across the federal government. - -• The NSTC’s Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure should coordinate an -interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, with -activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, identifying - -– 24 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and international collaborations -in facilities. - -Additionally, departments and agencies should continue to look to the policy opportunities identified -in the National Strategic Overview on RDI, released in 2021: - -Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination - -• Adopt a cohesive definition of RDI that encompasses experimental, observational, as well as - -knowledge- and cyber-infrastructure, in federal planning processes - -• - -Identify complementary RDI—and their capabilities—across the federal government and -external R&D communities to inform agency priority-setting processes. - -• Plan for, invest in, and deploy the necessary knowledge infrastructure and research -cyberinfrastructure to keep pace with the rate of growth of data acquisition in research, as well -as published research data, to ensure the efficiency and trustworthiness of scientific pathways -and pipelines. - -• Ensure consistent, sufficient, and timely RDI capabilities, strategically addressing episodic - -efforts that can undermine the ability to meet long-term needs - -• Regularly review and document RDI needs and develop planning processes that encompass - -repurposing, reusing, or decommissioning low-priority RDI. - -Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise - -• Foster R&D community engagement to inform federal RDI planning and prioritization, for - -instance through assessments and cross-sector coordination. - -• Seek input from Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) and NSTC committees, as these -committees are capable of providing valuable insight on future RDI needs and coordination -possibilities. - -• - -Integrate agile design and decision processes in planning and maintaining RDIs so that -capabilities keep pace with the growth in data and advancements in computing and analytics. - -• Support remote access to RDI capabilities, tools, and platforms, where appropriate. - -• Build strategic, long-term relationships with contractors and suppliers to enable agility in - -procurement, development, design, and portability of RDI systems. - -• - -• - -Incorporate lifecycle considerations, such as upfront costs of construction, operation, and -maintenance, and anticipate future modernization needs for planned and existing RDIs. - -Incorporate lifecycle resourcing considerations to ensure RDIs sustain or enhance privacy and -other legal protections. - -• Ensure large or complex RDI projects are managed by staff with appropriate design and project - -management experience to safeguard delivery on schedule and within budget. - -• Continue to create and promote STEM education programs that directly engage with and - -support the use of RDIs as education and training platforms. - -– 25 – - - U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE - A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security - -• Ensure processes that allow the nation’s R&D enterprise to thrive by fostering the participation - -of talent that reflects the diversity of America. - -Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors - -• - -Invest in RDIs that complement core disciplinary needs while identifying opportunities to -enhance connections across disciplines and sectors. - -• Consider the potential use of RDIs beyond a single agency’s mission context in developing - -coordination efforts, especially for the Nation’s largest RDI investments. - -• Ensure RDIs foster convergence through partnerships and research information exchange. - -Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs - -• Seek international collaborations for the development of RDIs as appropriate to foster - -international cooperation - -• Operate RDIs using research security frameworks that balance open science with appropriate - -levels of vigilance and that uphold U.S. principles of integrity - -• Ensure proper protections for RDIs that are vital to competitiveness, public health and safety -resilience, and national security (e.g., intellectual property, certain classes of research data, -implications from climate change) - -Conclusion - -Just like the investments in research facilities that were built during the Cold War, investments in -modern federal RDI will support the development of new technologies and generate new jobs. -Revitalizing federal RDI will also ensure the development of a workforce trained to discover, develop, -manufacture, and use next-generation technologies. - -The nation can take immediate action to revitalize RDI and support a vibrant research enterprise for -years to come. Federal departments and agencies should develop actionable strategic plans with -priorities for RDI investments. These plans should be informed by input from the S&T community across -government, university, and private-sector institutions, and from international benchmarking. This -input can also identify opportunities to partner with both domestic and international institutions. An -RDI working group can share approaches and identify where collaborations can be forged to provide -enhanced capabilities to a broader research community. The time to act is now; prioritizing federal RDI -will support generations of future researchers and allow the United States to maintain global leadership -in science, technology, and innovation. - -– 26 – +1. ΔV = βV0ΔT +2. β*ΔT is the same for both of you. +3. But, V0 is greater for the 18-gallon fuel-tank for the truck. +4. So, ΔV will be larger for the truck and it will lose more fuel. diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_2.md b/q0/random_k4/random_2.md index f1acb0854be2920866b2127b008e7c6e2f57b22b..35a7eb473c0028e63514bfe2ddbd9a16bdb5c94f 100644 --- a/q0/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q0/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,3733 +1,3030 @@ -GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +FOR RELEASE January 29, 2026 -Table of Contents +Confidence in Trump +Dips, and Fewer Now Say +They Support His +Policies and Plans -Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments? -What background information must I know? -How do I ensure that IT investments are linked to and support agency strategic plans? -What special terms should I know? -How do I determine whether I must report? +Rising share of Democrats want their party’s congressional +leaders to stand up to Trump -How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due? -If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year? -How is Exhibit 53 organized? -How is Exhibit 53 coded? -What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53? -Agency IT Investment Portfolio -Agency IT Security Portfolio -Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio -Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments +BY Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley -1. -2. -3. -4. -5. +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: -53.1 -53.2 -53.3 -53.4 -53.5 -Ex53A -Ex53B -Ex53C -Ex53D +Jocelyn Kiley, Director of Political Research +Steven Shepard, Associate Director of Political +Research +Nida Asheer, Senior Communications Manager -300.1 -300.2 -300.3 -300.4 -300.5 -300.6 -Ex300A/B IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification, Performance Plan and Measurement Report +202.419.4372 -What is the purpose of the section? -Does Exhibit 300 apply to me? -How will agencies manage capital assets? -What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill? -What must I report on Exhibit 300A&B and when? -How will OMB use Exhibit 300A&B? +www.pewresearch.org - Updates and consolidates special terms related to information technology (IT) and E-Government +RECOMMENDED CITATION -Summary of Changes +Pew Research Center, January 2026, “Confidence in +Trump dips, and fewer now say they support his +policies and plans” -(Section 4) + 1 -Significantly updates Exhibit 53 requirements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Requires agencies to submit a draft Fiscal Year (FY) 2014 Exhibit 53A by August 27, 2012 and the +About Pew Research Center -agency budget request Exhibit 53s on September 10, 2012 +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan, nonadvocacy fact tank that informs the public about the +issues, attitudes and trends shaping the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center +conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, computational social science research and +other data-driven research. It studies politics and policy; news habits and media; the internet and +technology; religion; race and ethnicity; international affairs; social, demographic and economic +trends; science; research methodology and data science; and immigration and migration. Pew +Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. - Adds two new 53 Exhibits: Cloud Computing and Reductions and Reinvestments per budget guidance - Adds requirement for Functional/Business Sponsor identification for all investments - Adds several fields to the Exhibit 53A for reporting government FTE, HSPD-12, and cloud +© Pew Research Center 2026 -alternatives analysis +www.pewresearch.org - New FEA BRM 3.0 Service Mappings + 2 -Significantly updates Exhibit 300 requirements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Requires agencies to submit the FY 2014 Exhibit 300A/Bs between September 10-14, 2012. +About this research -Agencies may submit Exhibit 300Bs for any investment for which a 300A has been successfully -submitted/updated +This Pew Research Center report looks at how the U.S. public feels about Trump’s job +performance, their expectations for his administration, and their views about whether +congressional leaders should work with each other and the president. - Adds a requirement to submit specific investment artifacts/documents - Updates questions for areas of current policy emphasis - Changes Summary of Funding to Life Cycle Costs - Clarifies project and activity concepts and extends reporting time period - Clarifies reporting of actuals for performance metrics - Adds question on modular contracting - Adds question on return on investment +Why did we do this? -Page 1 of 45 +Pew Research Center conducted this research to check in on how the public is feeling about the +Trump administration. It is part of our regular work to understand how Americans feel about the +policies, actions and events that occur during the presidency – as well as to understand how +Americans feel about current events. - (2012) +Our research on presidents dates back to the 1980s, and has continued through the current Trump +administration. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +Learn more about Pew Research Center and our politics research. -1. Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments? +How did we do this? -The required information allows the agency and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to review and -evaluate each agency's IT spending and to compare IT spending across the Federal Government. Specifically, -the information helps the agency and OMB to: +We conducted a survey from January 20 through January 26, 2026 among 8,512 U.S. adults +recruited through our American Trends panel. - Provide a report on all IT investments for the agency, as required by the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996; +Here are the survey questions used for this report, the detailed responses and +the survey methodology. - Understand and compare the amount spent on the development of new capabilities (Development, +www.pewresearch.org -Modernization and Enhancement [DME], which may appropriately be treated as capitalized costs) and -in support of operation and maintenance (O&M) for all agency IT investments; + 3 - +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Identify and report IT security costs for all IT investments and for agency and bureau IT security -programs, as required by the Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA); and +Confidence in Trump dips, a +they support his policies and plans +Rising share of Democrats want their party +to stand up to Trump - +nd fewer now say -Identify and report on agency financial management systems. +’s congressional leaders -Agencies must provide required formation using the Exhibit 53 reporting format. This information should be -consistent with information required in Section 51 of OMB Circular A-11. In addition, as an output of your -agency's internal IT capital planning and investment control process, your budget justification for IT must -provide results-oriented information in the context of the agency's missions and operations, as expressed -through the agency’s enterprise architecture (EA). Your budget justification, including the status and plans -for information systems, should be consistent with your agency's submissions for Exhibit 300 submissions -(see guidance on Exhibit 300), regarding major IT investments. +By Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley -Investment costs must include all Federal budgetary resources (e.g., direct appropriation, working capital -fund, revolving funds). Federal budgetary resources are defined in Section 20 of OMB Circular A-11. These -investment costs and performance benefits must be formulated and reported order to support the Clinger- -Cohen Act's requirement that the OMB Director shall submit to Congress a report on the net program -performance benefits achieved as a result of major capital investments made by executive agencies in -information systems and how the benefits relate to the accomplishment of the goals of the executive agencies. +A year into his second administration, +Americans’ views of President Donald Trump – +already more negative than positive – have +continued to slip. -2. What background information must I know? +Half of Americans say Trump’s actions +have been worse than they expected -The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public -resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition, and management of -capital assets into the Budget decision-making process. It is intended to assist agencies in improving asset -management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of: +% who ___ of the way Donald Trump is handling his job +as president - The Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996, which requires agencies to use a disciplined capital planning and +▪ Trump’s approval rating stands at 37%, -investment control (CPIC) process to acquire, use, maintain, and dispose of IT in alignment with the -agency’s EA planning processes. OMB policy for the management of Federal information resources -is detailed in Circular A-130, Management of Federal Information Resources. +down from 40% in the fall. - The Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993, which establishes the foundation for +Approve -Budget decision making to achieve strategic goals in order to meet agency mission objectives. -Instructions for preparing strategic plans, annual performance plans, and annual program performance -reports are provided in Part 6 of OMB Circular A-11 (see Section 220). +Disapprove - The GPRA Modernization Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-352), which requires quarterly performance +37 -assessments of Federal Government priorities and establishes agency Performance Improvement -Officers and the Performance Improvement Council. +61 -Page 2 of 45 +▪ By more than two-to-one, Americans say +the administration’s actions have been +worse than they expected (50%) rather than +better (21%). - (2012) +▪ Only about a quarter of Americans today +(27%) say they support all or most of +Trump’s policies and plans, down from 35% +when he returned to office last year. That +change has come entirely among +Republicans. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +% who say the Trump administration’s actions since +taking office last year have been ___ expected - The Federal Managers Financial Integrity Act of 1982, Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990 (CFO +Better than -Act), and Federal Financial Management Improvement Act of 1996, which require accountability of -financial and program managers for financial results of actions taken, control over the Federal -Government's financial resources, and protection of Federal assets. OMB policies and standards for -developing, operating, evaluating, and reporting on financial management systems are contained in -Circular A–127, Financial Management Systems and OMB Circular A-11, Section 52. +About as - The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, which requires agencies to perform their information +Worse than -resources management activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner. +21 - The Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, which requires agencies to integrate IT -security into their capital planning and EA processes, conduct annual IT security reviews of all -programs and systems, and report the results of those reviews to OMB. +28 - The E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107–347), which requires agencies to support government-wide -E-Government (E-Gov) initiatives and to leverage cross-agency opportunities to further E-Gov. The -Act also requires agencies to establish a process for determining which government information the -agency intends to make available and accessible to the public on the Internet and by other means. In -addition, the Act requires agencies to conduct and make publicly available privacy impact -assessments (PIAs) for all new IT investments, administering information in an identifiable form -collected from or about members of the public. +50 - The National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act of 1995 (P.L. 104-113) and OMB Circular -A-119, which state that voluntary consensus standards are the preferred type of standards for Federal -Government use. When it would be inconsistent with law or otherwise impractical to use a voluntary -consensus standard, agencies must submit a report to OMB through the National Institute of Standards -and Technology (NIST) describing the reason(s) for the agency's use of government-unique standards -in lieu of voluntary consensus standards. +% who support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and +plans - The Federal Records Act, which requires agencies to establish standards and procedures to ensure -efficient and effective records management. The National Archives and Records Administration -(NARA) issues policies and guidance for agencies to meet their records management goals and -requirements. NARA also provides policies and guidance for planning and evaluating investments in -electronic records management. +All/Most - The Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. § 552a), which is an omnibus "code of fair information practices" -that attempts to regulate the collection, maintenance, use, and dissemination of personal information -by Federal executive branch agencies. +Some - NIST Special Publication 800-146 concepts and definitions regarding cloud computing. +Few/None - Recent OMB IT policies and guidance, including: +27 -o 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management -o Federal Information Technology Shared Services Strategy -o The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture -o Digital Government Strategy: Building a 21st Century Platform to Better Serve the American +20 -People +52 -o OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat -o The Federal Cloud Computing Strategy +A new Pew Research Center survey of 8,512 +U.S. adults, conducted Jan. 20-26, also finds +that – across six key qualities and abilities +needed to serve as president – more Americans +express little or no confidence in Trump than say they are extremely or very confident in him. -Page 3 of 45 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - (2012) +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT +Confidence is down on all six measures since last year, particularly among Republicans. -o Security Authorization of Information Systems in Cloud Computing Environments +Related: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions -(FedRAMP) +www.pewresearch.org -o OMB memo M-12-13 - Fiscal Year 2014 Budget Guidance + 4 - Executive Order 13514, Federal Leadership in Environmental, Energy, and Economic Performance +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Executive Order 13423, Strengthening Federal Environmental, Energy, and Transportation +Trump’s qualities and abilities as president -Management +Today, 34% of Americans say +they are extremely or very +confident that Trump has the +leadership skills needed to +serve as president. A larger +share (51%) are not too or not +at all confident. Another 14% +are somewhat confident. - Federal Acquisition Regulation, including Subchapter B, Parts 5 through 12 and Part 23 +Similarly, about half say they +are not too or not at all +confident Trump has the +mental fitness (52%) or +physical fitness (50%) to do +the job. Roughly three-in-ten +express confidence on these +measures. - Federal Management Regulation, including Subchapters B and C +Many Americans lack confidence in Trump on several +measures, including his ethics in office - Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, including Sections 431 through 435 and 523 through +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they +are ___ confident that Donald Trump … -525 +No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - Energy and Policy Act of 2005, including Sections 103, 104, 109, and 203 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -3. How do I ensure that IT investments align with and support the agency’s strategic plans? +Even fewer say they are confident that Trump respects the country’s democratic values (25% are +extremely or very confident) or that he picks good advisers (25%). -Each IT investment must clearly demonstrate that the investment is needed to help meet the agency's strategic -goals and mission. The agency must demonstrate how the investment supports a business line or enterprise -service performance goal as documented in the agency’s EA and annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to -OMB. Agency IT investment business cases (and other documents), the IT Capital Asset Summary (Exhibit -300A), and Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) must demonstrate the agency’s management of IT -investments and how governance processes are used to plan, select, develop, implement, and operate IT -investments. Documents used to manage the planning, development, implementation, and operation of IT -investments and documents that demonstrate the outcomes of agency, branch, and bureau governance -decisions should be maintained and made readily available if requested by OMB. +Americans express the least amount of confidence in Trump to act ethically in office. Just 21% are +extremely or very confident he does this, while 60% express little or no confidence. -The individual agency's Exhibit 53A and Exhibit 300A submissions are used to create an overall "Federal IT -Investment Portfolio," which is published as part of the President's Budget. Agency and OMB portfolio -reviews and Budget processes will ensure the selection of IT investments that support the agency’s strategic -goals, as captured in the agency’s High Priority Performance Goals and Strategic Plan. +www.pewresearch.org -4. What special terms should I know? + While overall confidence in +Trump’s ethics in office was +already relatively low last +February (29%), it has +declined 8 percentage points +since. And nearly all of that +drop has come among +Republicans: At the +beginning of Trump’s second +term, a 55% majority of +Republicans and Republican- +leaning independents said +they were confident that +Trump acts ethically in office, +but that share now stands at +42%. -Alternatives Analysis refers to an analysis of alternatives for addressing the performance objectives of an -investment. The analysis is performed prior to the initial decision to implement a solution and updated -periodically, as appropriate, to capture changes in the context for an investment decision. Alternatives -analysis documentation must be submitted along with Exhibit 300 for all major IT investments. Alternatives -Analysis should be performed for investments with projects in the planning or DME stages, whereas strictly -operational investments should instead perform operational analyses until such time as a decision is made to -re-evaluate the investment or to resume development, modernization or enhancement. - -Asset refers to anything that has value to an organization, including, but not limited to: a computing device, -IT system, IT network, IT circuit, software (both an installed instance and a physical instance), virtual -computing platform (common in cloud and virtualized computing), and related hardware (e.g., locks, cabinets, -keyboards). Assets are the lowest level at which IT is planned, acquired, implemented, and operated. - -Benefit-Cost Analysis refers to the recommended technique to use in a formal economic analysis of -government programs or projects. Guidance for Benefit-Cost Analysis is described in OMB Circular A-94. - -Page 4 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Business Reference Model (BRM) refers to one of six reference models of the Federal Enterprise -Architecture (FEA). It is a classification taxonomy used to describe mission sectors, business functions, and -services that are performed within and between Federal agencies and with external partners. IT investments -are mapped to the BRM to identify opportunities for collaboration, shared services, and solution reuse. -Exhibit 53 allows for one primary service and up to four secondary service codes to be identified for each IT -investment. BRM service codes can be found in the FEA Reference Model document library. -Note: Updated definitions are scheduled for release in version 2 of the FEA. - -Capital Assets refer to land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and IT (including the -output of IT service contracts) that has been acquired by the Federal Government and have an estimated useful -life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more complete -definition of capital assets. - -Capital Investment (or Investment) refers to the planning, development, and acquisition of a capital asset and -the management and operation of that asset through its usable life after the initial acquisition. IT capital -investments may consist of one or more assets, which provide useful components in an operational -(production) environment. - -Capital Planning and Investment Control (also called capital programming) refers to a decision-making -process that ensures IT investments integrate strategic planning, budgeting, procurement, and management of -IT in support of agency missions and business needs. The term was introduced in the Clinger-Cohen Act of -1996 and generally is used in relation to IT management issues. - -Capital Programming refers to an integrated process within an agency that focuses on the planning, -budgeting, procurement, and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve the agency’s -strategic goals and objectives with the lowest overall cost and least risk. - -Cloud First Policy (IT Reform) refers to the Cloud First policy, launched in December 2010, which is -intended to accelerate the pace at which the government realizes the value of cloud computing by requiring -agencies to evaluate safe, secure cloud computing options before making any new investments. Per the -Federal Cloud Computing Strategy, agencies should evaluate their technology sourcing plans to include -consideration and application of cloud computing solutions as part of the budget process. Agencies should -seek to optimize the use of cloud technologies in their IT portfolios to take full advantage of the benefits of -cloud computing in order to maximize capacity utilization, improve IT flexibility and responsiveness, and -minimize costs. When evaluating options for new IT deployments, OMB requires that agencies default to -cloud-based solutions whenever a secure, reliable, cost-effective cloud option exists. Additionally, agencies -shall continually evaluate cloud computing solutions across their IT portfolios, regardless of investment type -or life cycle stage. - -Contributions (or expected contributions) refers to both monetary contributions and fees for services -provided by partner agencies to managing partners or shared service providers of a multi-agency -collaboration. Contributions should only apply to multi-agency collaborations. - -Cost refers to the expenditure of funds or use of property to acquire, produce, operate, or maintain an asset. -Examples include, but are not limited to: sunk costs, operational costs, acquisition costs, and disposition costs -(including variable costs such as labor hours). - -Cost Avoidance refers to from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease costs in the -future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). - -Cost Saving refers to the reduction in actual expenditures to achieve a specific objective (as defined in OMB -Circular A-131). - -Page 5 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Data Center refers to a closet, room, floor, or building for the storage, management, and dissemination of data -and information. Such a repository houses computer systems and associated components, such as databases, -applications, and storage systems and data stores. A data center generally includes redundant or backup -power supplies; redundant data communications connections; environmental controls (e.g., air conditioning, -fire suppression); and special security devices housed in, leased (including by cloud providers), owned, -collocated, or situated in stand-alone facilities. This definition excludes facilities exclusively devoted to -communications and network equipment (e.g., telephone exchanges, telecommunications rooms). Neither -square footage nor Uptime Institute tier classifications are required to define a facility as a data center. This -definition of a data center applies to all agency IT assets, mission or otherwise. See March 2012 OMB Federal -Data Center Consolidation Initiative Memorandum for more detail. - -Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) of 1990 (P.L. 101-510) refers to a congressional -act that established for the Department of Defense an Acquisition Corps to professionalize the acquisition -workforce in the Department of Defense through education, training, and work experience. - -Dependency refers to the identification of relationships between projects and operational assets within an -investment as well as the identification of relationships between investments. Identification of dependencies -is critical to the management of project, program, and portfolio risk. - -Development, Modernization and Enhancement refers to costs for projects and activities leading to new IT -assets/systems and projects and activities that change or modify existing IT assets to: substantively improve -capability or performance, implement legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet an agency leadership -request. As part of DME, capital costs can include hardware, software development and acquisition costs, -commercial off-the-shelf acquisition costs, government labor costs, and contracted labor costs for planning, -development, acquisition, system integration, and direct project management and overhead support. - -Disposition Cost refers to the cost of retiring a capital asset once its useful life is completed or a replacement -asset has superseded it; disposition costs may be included in operational activities near the end of the useful -life of an asset. - -Earned Value Management (EVM) refers to a project management tool that effectively integrates the project -scope of work with a schedule and cost elements for optimum project planning and control. The qualities and -operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in American National -Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard–748–1998, Earned Value -Management Systems. Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/evm. - -Enterprise Architecture refers to the explicit description and documentation of the current and desired -relationships among business and management processes and IT of an organization. It describes the “current -architecture” and “target architecture”. An EA includes the rules and standards and systems life cycle -information to optimize and maintain the environment which the agency wishes to create and maintain -through its IT portfolio. An EA must provide a strategy that enables the agency to support its current state and -provides a roadmap for transition to its target environment. An EA defines principles and goals and sets a -direction on such issues as the promotion of interoperability, open systems, publics access, end-user -satisfaction, and IT security. The agency must support an EA with a complete inventory of agency -information resources including: personnel, equipment, systems, services, and funds devoted to information -resources management and IT, at an appropriate level of detail. - -Enterprise Roadmap refers to an annual submission from each agency to OMB that describes the business -and technology plan for the entire organization using EA methods. The Roadmap provides current views, -future views, and transition plans at an appropriate level of detail for all IT investments, services, systems, and -programs. The Enterprise Roadmap also contains an IT asset inventory using the FEA Reference Models and -other attachments or appendices for CPIC, EA, shared service, and other planning products requested by -OMB that provide additional information regarding Roadmap plans. - -Page 6 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Evaluation (by Agency CIO) refers to the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment -in terms of its ability to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, -including, but not limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical -performance, human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to the forecasting future success. -Each evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation. - -Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) refers to a certification -program that was established to clearly identify general training and experience requirements for program and -project managers (PMs) in civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for -program managers and PMs. The certification program does not include functional or technical competencies, -such as those for IT or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar certification program -under DAWIA. Agencies were required to be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available -levels are Entry/Apprentice, Mid/Journeyman, and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2, and 3 for -DAWIA. For more information about these programs, refer to the following links: -http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf -http://whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf - -Federal Enterprise Architecture refers to a business-based documentation and analysis framework for -government-wide improvement. The FEA allows agencies to use standardized methods to describe the -relationship between an agency’s strategic goals, business functions, and enabling technologies at various -levels of scope and complexity. The FEA is comprised of documentation in six domain areas (strategic goals, -business services, data and information, systems and applications, infrastructure, and security) that includes -required and elective artifacts. There are six reference models to support the six domain areas that should -facilitate standardized design; analysis; reporting; and the identification of duplicative investments, gaps, and -opportunities for collaboration within and across Federal agencies. More information about the FEA is -available in The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture (OMB, May 2, 2012) and at FEA -Reference Model document library. - -Federal Enterprise Architecture Mapping Codes refers to a framework for describing important elements of -the FEA in a common and consistent way. Through the use of this common framework and vocabulary, IT -portfolios can be better managed and leveraged across the Federal Government. The first three-digit code -indicates the primary service area served by this investment (the three-digit BRM service code). The second -through fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with this investment. Guidance on -the codes for these mappings can be found at FEA Reference Model document library. - -Financial Management refers to activities that support the interrelationships and interdependencies among -budget, cost and management functions, and information associated with business transactions. - -Financial Management Systems refers to systems necessary to support financial management, including -automated and manual processes, procedures, controls, data, hardware, software, and support personnel -dedicated to the operation and maintenance of system functions. The following are examples of financial -management systems: core financial systems, procurement systems, loan systems, grants systems, payroll -systems, budget formulation systems, billing systems, and travel systems. See OMB Circular A-127 for -additional information and guidance at www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a127. - -Full Funding refers to a situation where appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete an asset or a -useful segment of a capital asset before any obligations may be incurred. Incrementally funding the planning -and acquisition of capital assets or (useful segments) without certainty if or when future funding will be -available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets acquisition, higher acquisition costs, -project delays, cancellation of projects, the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate -the assets. Budget requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see Section 31.6 of -OMB Circular A-11). - -Page 7 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Funding refers to providing the budgetary resources to plan for, acquire, develop, sustain, or operate an asset. - -Funding Source refers to the direct appropriation or other budgetary resources an agency receives for an IT -investment. When “original paying accounts” within agencies are transferring resources to a different agency -account that ultimately supports the IT investment (for example, when bureau accounts are paying into a -central CIO office account or a working capital fund), the funding source provided in Exhibit 53A should be -the account that ultimately pays contracts and other costs for the investment directly (not the original -account(s) for the funds). - -Note: For agencies on the IT Dashboard, funding sources are planned as the primary drivers in the algorithm -to display “spending by bureau,” rather than using the bureau code associated with investments. It is critical -that valid funding source codes be provided in agency submissions. - -Government Information refers to information created, collected, processed, disseminated, or disposed of by -or for the Federal Government. - -Information Resource Management (IRM) Strategic Plan refers to a document that addresses all information -resources management of an agency. Agencies must develop and maintain their IRM strategic plans as -required by 44 U.S.C. 3506(b)(2) and OMB Circular A-130. IRM strategic plans should support the agency's -strategic plan that is required in OMB Circular A-11; provide a description of how information resources -management activities help accomplish the agency’s missions delivery area and program decisions; and -ensure IRM decisions are integrated with management support areas, including organizational planning, -budget, procurement, financial management, and human resources management. - -Information Security refers to all functions necessary to meet Federal information security policy -requirements. It includes the development, implementation, and maintenance of security policies, procedures, -and controls across the entire information life cycle. These functions should include implementation and -activities associated with NIST 800-37, Security Awareness training (but not the technical infrastructure -required for the delivery of training), FISMA compliance reporting, development of a security policy, and -security audits and testing. It does not include the physical protection of facilities such as those described in -Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP). - -Information System refers to a discrete set of IT, data, and related resources, such as personnel, hardware, -software, and associated IT services organized for the collection, processing, maintenance, use, sharing, -dissemination, or disposition of information. - -Information Technology refers to any equipment or interconnected system or subsystem of equipment that is -used in the automatic acquisition, storage, manipulation, management, movement, control, display, switching, -interchange, transmission, or reception of data or information by an executive agency. IT is related to the -terms capital asset, IT investment, program, project, sub-project, service, and system. - -Integrated Program Team (IPT) refers to a cross-functional or multidisciplinary group of individuals -organized and collectively responsible for the specific purpose of delivering a project, product, or process to -an external or internal customer. Each IPT should include experts in program and project management, -resource management, procurement, systems engineering, system security, and other disciplines, as necessary, -to plan and evaluate all aspects of the project. In order for OMB to approve the investment budget, an IPT -must include at a minimum: a qualified, fully dedicated IT program manager; a contracting specialist, if -applicable; an IT specialist; an IT security specialist; and a business process owner or subject matter expert -(SME). Other members of the IPT might include enterprise architects; IT specialists with specific expertise in -data, systems, or networks; capital planners; or performance specialists. Key members of the IPT should be -co-located during the most critical junctures of the program, to the maximum extent possible. Agencies -should establish IPT members’ individual performance goals to hold team members accountable for both - -Page 8 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -individual functional goals and the overall success of the program. The investment IPT should be defined in a -program or an IPT charter. - -Interagency Acquisition refers to the use of the Federal Supply Schedules; a multi-agency contract (i.e., a task -order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by multiple government agencies to obtain -supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535) or a government-wide acquisition -contract (i.e., a task order or delivery order contract for IT established by one agency for government-wide -use operated by an executive agent, as designated by OMB pursuant to Section 11302(3) of the Clinger-Cohen -Act of 1996). - -IT Dashboard refers to a website (www.itdashboard.gov) that enables Federal agencies, industry, the general -public, and other stakeholders to view details regarding the performance of Federal IT investments. The IT -Dashboard is used by the Administration and Congress to inform budget and policy decisions. - -IT Investment refers to the expenditure of IT resources to address mission delivery and management support. -An IT investment may include a project or projects for the development, modernization, enhancement, or -maintenance of a single IT asset or group of IT assets with related functionality and the subsequent operation -of those assets in a production environment. All IT investments should have a defined life cycle with start and -end dates, with the end date representing the end of the currently estimated useful life of the investment, -consistent with the investment’s most current alternatives analysis if applicable. - -IT Program Managers and IT Project Managers refers to the IPT members responsible for IT investments -and lead the required IPT for the investment. In some cases, IT program managers and PMs can hold -positions in other classification series; however they must still meet the requisite Federal certification and/or -IT program management experience requirements. Further definitions are available in the Office of Personnel -Management’s Job Family Standard for Administrative Work in the Information Technology Group (series -2200 in the Federal Classification and Job Grading Systems). - -IT System refers to a discrete set of information resources organized for the collection, processing, -maintenance, transmission, and dissemination of information, in accordance with defined procedures, whether -automated or manual. - -Life Cycle Costs refers to all investment costs (including government FTEs) from the commencement of the -investment through its estimated useful life (or the composite estimated useful life of the assets within the -investment), independent of the funding source (e.g., revolving fund, appropriated fund, working capital fund, -trust fund). For more information about life cycle costs, see the Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular -A-11 and OMB Circular A-131. - -Maintenance refers to the activity necessary to keep an asset functioning as designed during the O&M phase -of an investment. Some maintenance activities should be managed as projects and reported in Section B of -Exhibit 300B. Examples of maintenance projects may include, but are not limited to: operating system -upgrades, technology refreshes, and security patch implementations. As defined in the Federal Accounting -Standards Advisory Board Statement of Federal Financial Accounting Standards Number 10, “Maintenance -excludes activities aimed at expanding the capacity of an asset or otherwise upgrading it to serve needs -different from or significantly greater than those originally intended.” Maintenance costs refer to all costs -(including all related personnel costs) needed to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance -levels. - -Major IT Investment refers to an IT investment requiring special management attention because of its -importance to the mission or function to the government; significant program or policy implications; high -executive visibility; high development, operating, or maintenance costs; unusual funding mechanism; or -definition as major by the agency’s capital planning and investment control process. OMB may work with the - -Page 9 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -agency to declare IT investments as major investments. Agencies should consult with assigned OMB analysts -regarding which investments are considered “major.” Investments not considered “major” are “non-major.” - -Managing Partner refers to the lead agency that is responsible for coordinating the implementation of the E- -Gov or Line of Business (LoB) initiative. The managing partner is also responsible for coordinating and -submitting Exhibit 300 for the initiative; Exhibit 300 will be represented as part of the managing partner's -budget portfolio. For additional information on managing partner reporting requirements for IT investments, -refer to the OMB MAX portal. - -New IT Investment refers to an IT investment and its associated projects that is newly proposed by the agency -and that has not been previously reported/funded by OMB. - -Non-Major IT Investment refers to any IT investment in the agency's IT Portfolio that does not meet the -definition of “major IT investment.” All non-major investments must be reported in Exhibit 53. - -Ongoing IT Investment refers to an investment and its associated assets, including both maintenance projects -and operational activities that have been through a complete Budget Cycle with OMB with respect to the -President's Budget for the current year (CY)—in this case, for FY 2013. - -Operational Analysis refers to a method of examining the ongoing performance of an operating asset -investment and measuring that performance against an established set of cost, schedule, and performance -goals. An operational analysis is, by nature, less structured than performance reporting methods applied to -developmental projects and should trigger considerations of how the investment's objectives could be better -met, how costs could be reduced, and whether the organization should continue performing a particular -function. Guidance for Operational Analysis is described in the Capital Programming Guide. - -Operations refer to the day-to-day management of an asset in the production environment and include, but are -not limited to, activities that operate data centers, help desks, operational centers, telecommunication centers, -and end-user support services. Operational activities are reported through Section C of Exhibit 300B. -Operations costs include the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in the production environment; costs -to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including Federal and contracted labor -costs; and costs for the disposal of an asset. - -Operations and Maintenance (O&M) refers to the phase of the life cycle in which the asset is in operations -and produces the same product or provides a repetitive service. Also commonly referred to as steady state. - -Partner Agency refers to the agency for an E-Gov or LoB initiative that is designated to provide resources -(e.g., funding, full-time equivalents [FTEs], in-kind) for the management, development, deployment, or -maintenance of a common solution. The partner agency is also responsible for including the appropriate line -items in its Exhibit 53 and reflecting the amount of the contribution for each of the E-Gov or LoB initiatives -to which the agency provides resources. - -Performance-based Acquisition Management refers to a documented, systematic process for program -management, which includes the integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, the establishment -of a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and the use of earned value techniques for -performance measurement during execution of the program. This type of management includes prototypes -and tests to select the most cost-effective alternative during the planning phase; the work during the -acquisition phase; and any developmental, modification, or upgrade work done during the O&M phase. A -performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulation 37.101) or -contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance standards/measures -should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase. - -Page 10 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Planning refers to preparing, developing, or acquiring the information used to design the asset; assess the -benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted costs of alternative solutions; and establish realistic cost, schedule, and -performance goals for the selected alternative, before either proceeding to full acquisition of the capital -project or useful component or terminating the project. Planning must progress to the point where the agency -is ready to commit to achieving specific goals for the completion of the acquisition before proceeding to the -acquisition phase. Information gathering activities to support planning may include market research of -available solutions, architectural drawings, geological studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes. -Planning may be general to the overall investment or may be specific to a useful component. - -PortfolioStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an agency's IT portfolio. Reviews can be used -to identify and address a broad range of issues, including management of commodity IT, duplication of -investments, and alignment with the agency’s mission and strategy. More detail regarding the PortfolioStat -process is described in OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat. - -Post-Implementation Review (PIR) refers to an evaluation of how successfully the investment or project -objectives were met and how effective the project management practices were in keeping the investment or -project on track. A PIR can be conducted after a project has been completed, or after an investment concludes -the implementation phase. Additional details regarding the PIR process is described in the Capital -Programming Guide. - -Privacy Impact Assessment is a process for examining the risks and ramifications of using IT to collect, -maintain, and disseminate information from or about members of the public in an identifiable form. The -process also is also used to identify and evaluate protections and alternative processes to mitigate the impact -to privacy of collecting such information. Consistent with OMB guidance (M-03-22) regarding implementing -the privacy provisions of the E-Government Act, agencies must conduct and make publicly available PIAs for -all new or significantly altered IT investments that administer information in an identifiable form collected -from or about members of the public. - -Project refers to a temporary endeavor undertaken to accomplish a unique product or service with a defined -start and end point and specific objectives that, when attained, signify completion. Projects can be undertaken -for the development, modernization, enhancement, disposal, or maintenance of an IT asset. Projects are -composed of activities. When reporting projects in Exhibit 300A and 300B, to the maximum extent -practicable, agencies should detail the characteristics of “increments” under modular contracting as described -in the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996 and the characteristics of “useful segments,” as described in OMB Circular -A-130. - -Project Manager Level of Experience refers to the specific certification(s) or number of years of direct -project management experience that the PM holds. Examples of PM certifications include FAC-P/PM, -Project Management Institute/PMP, and other recognized certifications. - -Records refers to all books, papers, maps, photographs, machine-readable materials, or other documentary -materials, regardless of physical form or characteristics, made or received by an agency of the United States -Government under Federal law or in connection with the transaction of public business. Records may also -include items that are preserved or appropriate for preservation by that agency or its legitimate successor as -evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the -Federal Government or because of the informational value of data in them. Library and museum material -made or acquired and preserved solely for reference or exhibition purposes, extra copies of documents -preserved only for convenience of reference, and stocks of publications and processed documents are may not -be included as records. - -Risk Management refers to a systematic process of identifying, analyzing, and responding to risk. It includes -maximizing the probability and consequences of positive events and minimizing the probability and -consequences of adverse events to overall objectives. - -Page 11 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT - -Risk Management Plan refers to a documented and approved plan developed at the onset of the investment -and maintained throughout that specifies the risk management process - -Shared Service Provider refers to the provider of a technical solution and/or service that supports the business -of multiple agencies using a shared architecture. - -TechStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an IT program with Bureau/Agency leadership and -OMB as appropriate. TechStat sessions enable the Federal Government to turn around, halt, or terminate IT -investments that do not produce dividends for the American people. More detail regarding the TechStat -process is described in the TechStat Training Deck. - -Unique Investment Identifier (UII) refers to a persistent numeric code applied to an investment that allows -the identification and tracking of an investment across multiple FYs of an agency’s investment portfolio. The -UII is composed of a three-digit agency code concatenated with a nine-digit unique investment number -generated by the agency. Some nine-digit numbers are reserved for OMB to assign and may not be assigned -by agencies, as controlled by the restrictions described in the section on “Variable Information.” - -Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J, -“Principles of Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions.” - -5. How do I determine whether I must report? - -Agencies must submit an agency IT investment portfolio (Exhibit 53A, Exhibit 53C, Exhibit 53D, and -Exhibits 300), if the government agency is subject to Executive Branch review (see OMB Circular A-11 -Section 25.1). All CFO Act agencies and any others directed to do so must submit an agency security -portfolio (Exhibit 53B). - -The following agencies must also submit this information to the IT Dashboard: - -Department of Agriculture -Department of Commerce -Department of Defense -Department of Education -Department of Energy -Department of Health and Human Services -Department of Homeland Security -Department of Housing and Urban Development -Department of the Interior -Department of Justice -Department of Labor -Department of State -Department of Transportation -Department of the Treasury - -Department of Veteran’s Affairs -U.S. Agency for International Development -U.S. Army Corps of Engineers -Environmental Protection Agency -General Services Administration -National Aeronautics and Space Administration -National Archives and Records Administration -National Science Foundation -Nuclear Regulatory Commission -Office of Personnel Management -Small Business Administration -Smithsonian Institution -Social Security Administration - -The agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions/revisions of the Exhibit 53 -prior to submission. - -Page 12 of 45 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -53.1 How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due? - -Agencies must submit a draft and updated versions of Exhibit 53s using the following schedule: - - Draft Exhibit 53A: August 27, 2012 - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: September 10, 2012 - President’s Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: Early January 2013 (tentative) - -Specifically, a draft version of Exhibit 53A shall be completed by the agency and submitted to OMB. This -draft will allow the agency and OMB to agree on which major and non-major IT investments will be reported -as part of the next President's Budget Request and to confirm the mapping of agency investments to agency -architectures. The initial draft of Exhibit 53A must conform to a template described later in this section, -which will be published on the OMB MAX portal. Specific steps for completing the submission will be -available on the OMB MAX portal. The completion of the initial draft of Exhibit 53A should be coordinated -by the agency’s IT capital planning lead. At a minimum, the draft Exhibit 53A should include the legacy UIIs -and current UIIs, investment name, investment description, and the FEA BRM Primary services mappings. +5 -All subsequent updates to the Exhibit 53s will be submitted to the IT Dashboard or otherwise as directed. The -agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions of Exhibit 53 prior to -submission. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Additional updates to Exhibits 53A and 300A may be required after final budget decisions or if the agency -requests supplemental funds that require changes to Exhibits 53A and 300A. Specific instructions and -deadlines for submitting updates, corrections, and final submissions of these exhibits will be available on the -OMB MAX portal. +Republican confidence in Trump to respect country’s +democratic values, act ethically in office declines -53.2 If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year? +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are +extremely/very confident that Donald Trump … -If your agency submitted Exhibit 53 for the FY 2013 Budget, the revised FY 2014 Budget must be compliant -with the specified format or it will be rejected. Agencies must note “changes in status” for each investment -and provide descriptions for any changes in status. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -It is important that the agency updates its Exhibit 53 to reflect prior year (PY) for FY 2012, current year (CY) -for FY 2013, and budget year (BY) for FY 2014. Exhibit 53A also requires MAX funding codes for all -"Funding Sources" line items. Consistent with prior submissions, "Investment Descriptions" will be limited to -255 characters. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -53.3 How is Exhibit 53 organized? +There’s a similar pattern +across all six qualities we asked about. -Exhibit 53 is composed of four parts: +For example, 60% of Republicans said last February that they were extremely or very confident +Trump respects the country’s democratic values – it’s 52% today. And while 66% of Republicans +say he has the mental fitness to do the job, that’s down from three-quarters last year. -1. Exhibit 53A, “Agency IT Investment Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget and +Democrats’ confidence in Trump on these measures remains very low. -architecture information; +For full trend on each of the qualities asked on the survey, refer to chart appendix. -2. Exhibit 53B, “Agency IT Security Portfolio,” which includes a summary of agency and bureau IT +www.pewresearch.org -security information, including IT security costs; and + 6 -3. Exhibit 53C, “Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget information +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -by cloud computing deployment model and service model. +Support for Trump’s policies -4. Exhibit 53D, “Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments” (see OMB M-12-13) +There has also been a significant decline over +the last year in the share of adults who say they +agree with Trump’s plans and policies. -Agencies should compare all relevant portfolios to ensure consistency. For example, the sum of columns 41 -to 43 on Exhibit 53A should equal the sums of each table in Exhibit 53C. +Republican support for Trump’s agenda +has declined over the last year -Page 13 of 45 Exhibit 53 +% who say they support all/most of Donald Trump’s +plans and policies - (2012) +▪ Last year, 35% said they supported all or +most of his plans, 17% supported some of +them and 47% supported only a few or +none. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +▪ Today, 27% say they support all or most, -Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) +20% support some and 52% support few or +none. -(a) Overview +The decline in support has come +exclusively among Republicans. Last +year, 67% said they supported all or most +of Trump’s plans and policies. Today, 56% do. -Exhibit 53A is a report of all agency IT investments. Investment costs are to be provided in millions of -dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, although -agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Information reported in Exhibit 53A should be consistent with data reported in MAX schedule O, object -classification (specifically, object classes 11.1 through 12.2, 23.1, 23.2, 25.2, 25.3, 25.7, 26.0, 31.0, and 41.0). -All major and non-major IT investments must be reported in Exhibit 53A. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Agencies must note all Federal budgetary resources (includes carryover and new budget authority) used to -fund an IT investment, including discretionary or mandatory funding sources, user fees, or gifts. Funding -should represent only Federal budgetary resources. Agencies should not include funding provided by non- -Federal sources, such as in matching funds for grant programs provided by state or local governments. +Very small shares of Democrats say they support his policies. Most (87%) support only a few or +none. -Funding levels in Exhibit 53A should represent: +Related: Few Americans support Trump’s proposed takeover of Greenland. - Estimated budgetary resources for BY (this may be different from the estimated obligations on the +For full trend details, refer to the appendix. -Exhibit 300 for some investments) +www.pewresearch.org - Estimated budgetary resources for CY (based on enactment where applicable) (this may be different + 7 -from the estimated obligations on the Exhibit 300 for some investments) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Expended budgetary resources (actuals) for PY (or the best current estimate) (this cost should +Republicans increasingly say GOP +members of Congress aren’t obligated to +support Trump if they disagree with him -represent the actual costs reported to the Exhibit 300) +% of Rep/Lean Rep who say Republicans in Congress … -These levels should be consistent with program-level funding and branch, bureau, and agency summary -funding tables. Funding from supplemental appropriations and the Recovery Act should also be included in a -manner consistent with other budget submission displays of program data. +Do Republicans in Congress have an +obligation to support Trump? -Exhibit 53A has six major parts: +Today, 38% of Republicans and Republican- +leaning independents say that congressional +Republicans “have an obligation to support +Trump’s policies and programs because he is a +Republican president.” But a far larger share +(61%) say GOP members of Congress do not +have an obligation to support Trump if they +disagree with him. -Part 1. -Part 2. -Part 3. -Part 4. -Part 5. -Part 6. +The share saying Republicans in Congress do +not have this obligation is up since last year, +from 55%. -IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support -IT Investments for Infrastructure, Office Automation, and Telecommunications -IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions -IT Investments for Grants Management Systems -National Security Systems IT Investments -Grants to State and Local IT Investments +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -All parts use the following common data elements: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Agency Description of Change in Investment Status is used when an indicator has been chosen for “Change -in Investment Status” in order to provide a description of the rationale for the change which may include -impacted UPIs, specific references to legislative requirements, or governance board decisions and effective -dates. +www.pewresearch.org -Agency Funding is the agency’s budgetary resources for a given investment. + 8 -Change in Investment Status is used when an investment has a change in status (e.g., downgraded to non- -major investment, eliminated, retired, consolidated, split) for the current budget submission relative to the -previous budget cycle. The change of status should be indicated with one of the following reasons: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Page 14 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Other key findings from the survey - (2012) +Democrats increasingly say their congressional +leaders should stand up to Trump on their issues - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +% of Rep/Lean Rep who say +Donald Trump should … -1. Upgrade -2. Downgrade -3. Split -4. Consolidation -5. Reorganization -6. Eliminated by funding -7. Eliminated by split -8. Eliminated by consolidation -9. Eliminated by reorganization -10. New -11. No Change in Status +% of Dem/Lean Dem who say +Democratic congressional leaders +should … -Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation specifies whether, as of the date of the submission, a cloud -alternative was evaluated for the investment or components/systems within the investment, per the Cloud First -policy. All investments should answer this question regardless of the overall lifecycle stage of the investment, -as operational investments may consider performing such an evaluation during or as a result of an operational -analysis. The evaluation should indicate one of the following answers: +▪ Democrats -1. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative and chose a cloud alternative for some or all of the investment. -2. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative but did not choose a cloud alternative for any of the investment. -3. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative but plans to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of the BY. -4. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative and does not plan to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of +overwhelmingly say +their congressional +leadership should +stand up to Trump. +Today, 82% (up from 70% +last year) want to see their +leaders pushing back +against Trump, even if that +makes it harder to address +problems. A smaller +majority of Republicans +(61%) say Trump should +stand up to Democratic +leaders. This is similar to +their views a year ago. -the BY. +▪ Nearly half of -Cloud Computing Spending refers to implementation and operational costs directly attributable to the cloud -computing systems “within” the investment for the specified year. +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Cross-Boundary Information Sharing is an activity that crosses a bureau or agency boundary, including -information sharing with international, state, local, tribal, industry, or non-governmental organization partners. -If the investment supports reusable, standardized information exchanges, agencies must indicate which of the -following were used: - -1. NIEM -2. UCORE -3. XBRL -4. Other -5. None - -Current UII includes an agency code and a nine-digit unique identifier. Variable information formerly -included in the UPI of previous years is not part of the UII primary key. Details are provided in Section 53.4. - -Development/Modernization/Enhancement Expenditures are the costs for projects leading to new IT assets -and projects that change or modify existing IT assets to: improve capability or performance, implement -legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet agency leadership requests. These expenditures correspond to -capitalized costs, and expenses may include: hardware; software; Federal and contracted labor for system -planning, development, acquisition, and integration; and direct overhead and project management. If non- -repairable or non-working IT hardware or software is replaced to continue the operation of an asset, and as a -result improves the capability or performance of an asset, the expense should be categorized as operations. - -FEA BRM Services include three-digit codes that indicate the service area served by the investment. The first -three-digit code indicates the primary service area (the three-digit BRM service code) and the second through -fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with the investment. Guidance on providing -appropriate FEA BRM Services mapping codes can be found at FEA Reference Model document library. - -Page 15 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -Functional/Business Sponsor is the name of the agency official who is responsible for the program or -function supported or implemented by the investment {44 U.S.C. 3501 (a) (4)}. The sponsor is responsible -for expressing the value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for -the IT investment to the agency CIO and OMB. The designated person may (or may not) be the same as the -“Business Process owner/Subject Matter Expert” listed for a major investment on the Exhibit 300A under -Integrated Program Team. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must include the name -of the functional/business sponsor as well as the individual’s title, phone number, and e-mail address. - -Funding Source means for each investment, the agency must identify the funding source and budgetary -resources, including the MAX funding codes used for the investment. An agency should add as many funding -source line items as are appropriate for the investment. To avoid double counting or under counting, the totals -of the funding amounts for an investment must match the main investment line item, represented with the -investment category of "00," "24," or “48.” See definition in section 4. - -Government FTE Number and Percentage means the number of government FTE included in the BY -funding and the percentage of the total BY cost represented by the number of government FTE. This applies -to all investments, both major and non-major. If an FTE’s costs are included in the investment costs for BY, -the FTE or portion of the FTE should be reported, regardless of the FTE’s role in the investment (technical, -managerial, functional, etc.). - -Homeland Security Priority Identifier means an IT investment supporting the homeland security mission -areas of 1) Intelligence and warning, 2) Border and transportation security, 3) Defense against catastrophic -threats, 4) Protection of critical infrastructure and key assets, 5) Emergency preparedness and response, 6) -Other, 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which one(s) by -listing the corresponding number(s) listed above. - -Homeland Security Presidential Directive-12 (HSPD-12) Costs refer to all costs to implement or provide -logical access to the systems within the investment for the PY, per HSPD-12. HPSD-12 costs should be -provided for all relevant investments, both major and non-major. - -Investment Description means a short public-facing description (limited to 255 characters) for each -investment (major, migration, partner contribution, and non-major). This description should explain the -purpose of the investment and what program(s) it supports, including the value to the public. The description -should be understandable to someone who is not an expert of the agency. If the investment is part of a multi- -agency initiative or another business case, the agency should describe where that business case is located in -the appropriate agency Budget submission (e.g., managing partner UII). For example, if the investment -represents your agency's participation in one of the Presidential initiatives, the description should state this -information and refer to the UII of the managing partner's business case. - -Investment Title means a definitive title explaining the investment. For "funding source" information, -provide the 10-digit OMB MAX account code (OMB Circular A-11, Section 79.2). To the extent that they are -not part of the name used by the agency, other identifiers such as bureaus or other numeric codes should not -be included as part of an Investment Title. - -Operations & Maintenance (Steady State) Costs describes the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in -the O&M life cycle phase. Operations expenses include maintenance projects and operation costs needed to -sustain the IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including: Federal and contracted labor -costs, corrective hardware and software maintenance, voice and data communications maintenance and -service, replacement of broken or obsolete IT equipment, and overhead costs. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Previous UII means the identifier depicting agency code and unique investment number used to report the -investment in the previous BY Exhibit 53 submission to OMB. Indicating the UII used for a previous +Americans (47%) now +say Trump will be an +unsuccessful president +in the long term. This share is up 14 points since last year, with most of this change +occurring among Democrats. A majority of Republicans continue to say Trump will be +successful in the long run. -Page 16 of 45 Exhibit 53 +▪ Trump’s approval among Republicans is now 73% – down slightly since - (2012) +September. Older Americans, White adults and those without a college degree continue to +approve of his performance more than others. See detailed tables for additional demographic +breaks. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +www.pewresearch.org -submission allows cross-walk and historical analysis crossing FYs for tracking purposes. Previous UII is -mandatory, with the exception of new investments. To indicate consolidations/splits/reorganizations, agencies -can provide more than one entry and separate UIIs with commas. -Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding refers to an IT investment that supports the -information sharing, access, and safeguarding mission areas of: 1) The national network of state and major -urban area fusion centers; 2) Assured interoperability across Controlled Unclassified Information /Sensitive -but Unclassified networks targeting Federal, state, local, and tribal law enforcement, public safety, homeland -security, and intelligence personnel; 3) Assured interoperability across classified SECRET networks; 4) -Nationwide suspicious activity reporting initiative; 5) Alerts, Warnings and Notifications; and 6) Case and -event deconfliction; or 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which -one(s) by listing the corresponding number(s) listed above. + 9 -(b) Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery Areas and Management Support Areas1 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report all IT investments directly supporting an agency-designated mission delivery area or management -support area (“Mission delivery area” means programs or activities that execute the agency mission as -outlined in the agency strategic plan. “Management support area” means activities such as human resource -management, financial management, and command and control.). The investments support these mission -deliveries should be consistent with your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. Include capital -costs (planning, development, modernization, and enhancement) and O&M expenses for each IT investment. +Appendix: Additional charts -Agencies must include an area titled “Financial Management,” and it must be reported as the first area. -Report all IT investments for major financial management systems in this area. +Confidence in Trump on several key qualities and +abilities needed to serve as president -(c) Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications +% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are +extremely/very confident that Donald Trump … -Report all IT investments supporting planning, development, modernization, enhancement, operation, and -maintenance of common user systems such as IT infrastructure and IT security. Each agency may submit -multiple Exhibits 300 encompassing office automation, infrastructure, security, and telecommunications for -the agency. These investments may be defined at the bureau level and/or by functional components of the -infrastructure. These IT infrastructure investments may support multiple mission areas and should include -end-user services and support, mainframes and servers services and support, and telecommunications services -and support. IT infrastructure includes direct costs—those that produce tangible IT products or services for -business users—and indirect costs—those that do not lead to a tangible product or direct support of business -users—such as IT program management costs and overhead expenses. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -Agencies are encouraged to report these investments as they are managed. If IT infrastructure is managed at -both the agency and bureau levels, agencies should report both agency and bureau-level infrastructure -investments. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -(d) Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions +www.pewresearch.org -Report all IT investments supporting the strategic management of IT operations (e.g., business process -redesign efforts that are not part of an individual investment, EA development, capital planning and -investment control processes, procurement management, IT policy development and implementation). IT -investments in this part of Exhibit 53A should include costs for CIO functions. + 10 -(e) Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -1 For the purpose of Exhibit 53, IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions remain in Part 3 and IT -Investments for Grants Management Systems remain in Part 4. +Will Trump be a successful president in the long term? -Page 17 of 45 Exhibit 53 +% who say Donald Trump will be a(n) ___ president in the long run - (2012) +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report all IT investments supporting information regarding the planning, development, modernization, -enhancement, and operation of grants management systems. +Have the Trump administration’s actions since taking +office in 2025 been better or worse than expected? -(f) Part 5. National Security Systems Investments +% who say the Trump administration’s actions since taking office last year +have been ___ expected -Report all IT investments that represent planning, development, modernization, enhancement, and operation -of national security systems. Only the Department of Defense should report investments in Part 5. +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -(g) Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report amounts for grants to state and local agencies that fund the planning, development, modernization, -enhancement, and operation of state and local IT systems. Agencies should only use Part 6 to report "Grants -to State and Local” and not the systems that support these grant activities. Before using Part 6 for anything -other than these types of investments, check with your agency’s OMB E-Gov analyst. +www.pewresearch.org -Agency Security Portfolio (Exhibit 53B) + 11 -The Agency Security Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual investment level. -Exhibit 53B uses the following data elements (as they appear in Exhibit 53B). Note that eight data elements -that were previously provided separately (see the BY2012 Exhibit 53B guidance) are to be reported in the -aggregate of “Total IT Security Tools Costs.” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Virus)—a program that monitors desktops/laptops to identify all +Public support for Trump’s policies and plans -major types of viruses and prevent or contain virus incidents. +% who say they support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and plans - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Malware)—a program that monitors a computer or network to +Note: No answer responses are not shown. +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. -identify all major types of malware and prevent or contain malware incidents. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Data Leakage Protection Tools)—systems designed to detect and -prevent the unauthorized use and transmission of confidential information including encryption for -PII. +www.pewresearch.org - Total IT Security Tools Costs (E-mail Filtering Software)—software that organizes e-mail according + 12 -to defined criteria, most commonly used for detecting and eliminating spam and malware. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Total Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Detection System [IDS])—software that looks for suspicious +Trump’s approval rating in first year of +his second term -activity on networks and alerts administrators. +% who approve of the way Donald Trump is handling +his job as president - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Prevention System [IPS])—systems that can detect an -intrusive activity on networks and attempt to stop the activity, ideally before it reaches its targets. - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Security Information Management [SIM]/Security Information and -Event Management [SIEM])—software/systems that collect security data (e.g., event logs) into a -central repository for trend analysis. +84 - Total IT Security Tools Costs (Web filtering software—also known as Content-Control software or -Censorware)—software designed and optimized for controlling what content is permitted to a reader, -especially when it is used to restrict material delivered over the web. Content-control software -determines what content will be available. +Rep/Lean Rep -Page 18 of 45 Exhibit 53 +80 - (2012) +75 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +78 -Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio (Exhibit 53C) +74 -The Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual -investment level. Exhibit 53C is comprised of two tables to report the following data elements for each year -(PY, CY, BY). Note that the sum of each year should match across the two tables and this sum should match -the sum of columns 41 to 43 of Exhibit 53A. For definitions of terms used in Exhibit 53C, see NIST Special -Publication 800-146. Only costs directly attributable to cloud computing implementations, operations or -services should be reported, which may only be a portion of the total cost of contributing/associated -investments. +Total -(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (PY, CY, BY) +47 - Public Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Private Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Community Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Hybrid Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending +40 -(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (PY, CY, BY) +41 - Software as a Service (SaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending - Platform as a Service (PaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending - +38 40 -Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending +Dem/Lean Dem -53.4 How is Exhibit 53A coded? +10 -Use the following UII 12-digit line number coding, and additional six 2-digit variable information fields, to -categorize investments and line structure for your Exhibit 53A. Each investment identified in the agency's -portfolio must have a unique UII. +7 -Entry +7 -Description +6 -Unique Investment Identifier Primary Key +6 -XXX- -xxxxxxxxx +73 -xxx- -XXXXXXXXX +37 -The first three digits represent your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +5 -The last nine digits serve as your unique identifier. This identifier should be system -generated and applied at the agency level. It will allow agencies up to one billion unique -identifiers to associate with IT investments. Once used, the unique identifier must be -retired. If an IT investment is retired, discontinued, or merged with another IT -investment, the unique identifier persists with that IT investment. +Feb '25 -Note: “99999XXXX” codes are reserved for approved multi-agency investments, -including E-Gov and LoB initiatives +Jan '26 -Page 19 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026. - (2012) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +www.pewresearch.org -Variable Information: The following attributes extracted from the FY 2012 Budget cycle and prior years’ -UPI should continue to be supplied. + 13 -XX-xx- -xx-xx- -xx-xx +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -xx-XX- -xx-xx- -xx-xx +Acknowledgments -xx-xx- -XX-xx- -xx -xx +This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals: -xx-xx- -xx-XX- -xx-xx +Research team -xx-xx- -xx-xx- -XX-xx +Communications and editorial -00 = Code for all investments other than those coded “24” or “48” +Jocelyn Kiley, Director, Political Research +Steven Shepard, Associate Director, Political +Research +Hannah Hartig, Senior Researcher +Baxter Oliphant, Senior Researcher +Gabe Borelli, Research Associate +Andrew Daniller, Research Associate +Andy Cerda, Research Analyst +Joseph Copeland, Research Analyst +Shanay Gracia, Research Analyst +Ted Van Green, Research Analyst -24 = E-Gov initiatives or an individual agency's participation in one of the E-Gov initiatives +Nida Asheer, Senior Communications +Manager +Maya Pottinger, Communications Associate +David Kent, Senior Editorial Specialist +Anna Jackson, Editorial Specialist -48 = Any multi-agency collaboration or an individual agency’s participation in one of the multi-agency -initiatives, excluding E-Gov initiatives +Graphic design and web publishing -The next two digits indicate your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). If this is -a department level or an agency-wide activity, use 00 as your bureau code. +Peter Bell, Associate Director, Design and +Production +Alissa Scheller, Senior Information Graphics +Designer +Reem Nadeem, Digital Producer +Beshay Sakla, Associate Digital Producer -These two digits indicate the six parts of Exhibit 53: +Methodology -01 = Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support Area +Andrew Mercer, Senior Research +Methodologist +Dorene Asare-Marfo, Senior Panel Manager +Dana Popky, Associate Panel Manager +Arnold Lau, Research Methodologist -02 = Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications +www.pewresearch.org -03 = Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions + 14 -04 = Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -05 = Part 5. National Security Systems IT Investments (Department of Defense Only) -06 = Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments +Methodology -These two digits indicate the mission delivery and management support areas. Agencies should -assign a unique code for each mission delivery and management support area reported. +The American Trends Panel -These two digits indicate your agency's type of investment. Select one of the following two digit -codes according to the type of investment you are reporting: +survey methodology -01 = Major IT investments (see definition in Section 4) +Overview -02 = Non-major IT investments (see definition in Section 4) +Data in this report comes from Wave 185 of the American Trends Panel (ATP), Pew Research +Center’s nationally representative panel of randomly selected U.S. adults. The survey was +conducted from Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. A total of 8,512 panelists responded out of 9,302 who +were sampled, for a survey-level response rate of 92%. -03 = IT migration investment portion of a larger asset and for which there is an existing business case for the -overall asset. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of -the managing partner. +The cumulative response rate accounting for all stages of nonresponse and attrition is 3%. The +break-off rate among panelists who logged on to the survey and completed at least one item is 2%. +The margin of sampling error for the full sample of 8,512 respondents is plus or minus 1.4 +percentage points. -04 = Investments where the business case for the major IT investment is reported in another agency's Exhibit -53. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of the -managing partner. +The survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 in order +to provide more precise estimates of the opinions and experiences of these smaller demographic +subgroups. These oversampled groups are weighted back to reflect their correct proportions in the +population. -xx-xx- -xx-xx- -xx-XX +SSRS conducted the survey for Pew Research Center via online (n=8,272) and live telephone +(n=240) interviewing. Interviews were conducted in both English and Spanish. -These two digits identify the nature of the “line item” in the Exhibit 53 structure. The digits -represent the line number in both the XML format used for agencies on the IT Dashboard and the -line number in an equivalent spreadsheet file (CSV or XLS file), for agencies not on the IT -Dashboard: +To learn more about the ATP, read “About the American Trends Panel.” -00 = Total investment title line, structurally the first line for reporting this particular investment +Panel recruitment -04 = Funding source or appropriation -[09 = Any subtotal – This value is only used only for agencies not on the IT Dashboard] +Since 2018, the ATP has used address-based sampling (ABS) for recruitment. A study cover letter +and a pre-incentive are mailed to a stratified, random sample of households selected from the U.S. +Postal Service’s Computerized Delivery Sequence File. This Postal Service file has been estimated +to cover 90% to 98% of the population.1 Within each sampled household, the adult with the next +birthday is selected to participate. Other details of the ABS recruitment protocol have changed +over time but are available upon request.2 Prior to 2018, the ATP was recruited using landline and +cellphone random-digit-dial surveys administered in English and Spanish. -Page 20 of 45 Exhibit 53 +1 AAPOR Task Force on Address-based Sampling. 2016. “AAPOR Report: Address-based Sampling.” +2 Email pewsurveys@pewresearch.org. - (2012) +www.pewresearch.org - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO + 15 -Use the following 10-digit number coding system to update or complete your OMB MAX account ID code -information: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Entry +A national sample of U.S. adults has been recruited to the ATP approximately once per year since +2014. In some years, the recruitment has included additional efforts (known as an “oversample”) +to improve the accuracy of data for underrepresented groups. For example, Hispanic adults, Black +adults and Asian adults were oversampled in 2019, 2022 and 2023, respectively. -Description +Sample design -XXX-xx-xxxx-x +The overall target population for this survey was noninstitutionalized persons ages 18 and older +living in the United States. It featured a stratified random sample from among ATP members who +previously completed Wave 183. Non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18 to 29 were selected +with certainty. The remaining panelists were sampled at rates designed to ensure that the share of +respondents in each stratum is proportional to its share of the U.S. adult population to the greatest +extent possible. Respondent weights are adjusted to account for differential probabilities of +selection as described in the Weighting section below. -The first three digits are your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +Questionnaire development and testing -xxx-XX-xxxx-x +The questionnaire was developed by Pew Research Center in consultation with SSRS. The web +program used for online respondents was rigorously tested on both PC and mobile devices by the +SSRS project team and Pew Research Center researchers. The SSRS project team also populated +test data that was analyzed in SPSS to ensure the logic and randomizations were working as +intended before launching the survey. -The next two digits are your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). +Incentives -xxx-xx-XXXX-x +All respondents were offered a post-paid incentive for their participation. Respondents could +choose to receive the post-paid incentive in the form of a check or gift code to Amazon.com, +Target.com or Walmart.com. Incentive amounts ranged from $5 to $20 depending on whether the +respondent belongs to a part of the population that is harder or easier to reach. Differential +incentive amounts were designed to increase panel survey participation among groups that +traditionally have low survey response propensities. -This is a four-digit account symbol for the appropriate MAX account (see Section 79.2 of -OMB Circular A-11). +Data collection protocol -xxx-xx-xxxx-X +The data collection field period for this survey was Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. Surveys were +conducted via self-administered web survey or by live telephone interviewing. -This is a single digit Transmittal Code (see Section 79.2 of OMB Circular A-11). -For the purposes of Exhibit 53A only, funding sources should continue to utilize the “-9” transmittal code to -flag funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA). +www.pewresearch.org -Use the following set of 3-digit numbers to identify each investment’s primary service area and, if desired, up -to four secondary service areas: + 16 -Entry +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Description +For panelists who take surveys online:3 Postcard notifications were mailed to a subset on +Jan. 20.4 Survey invitations were sent out in two separate launches: soft launch and full launch. +Sixty panelists were included in the soft launch, which began with an initial invitation sent on Jan. +20. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking sampled online panelists were included in the +full launch and were sent an invitation on Jan. 21. -XXX (primary services) +Invitation and reminder dates for web respondents, +ATP Wave -The first three digits identify the investment’s primary service area from the -FEA BRM version 3.0. +Soft launch -XXX (secondary services) +Jan. 20, 2026 -The second, third, fourth, and fifth set of three digits identify the investment’s -secondary service area(s) from the FEA BRM version 3.0. Agencies should -select from the following three-digit codes to map investments to primary and -secondary service areas. +Jan. 22, 2026 -53.5 What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53? +Jan. 24, 2026 -Exhibit 53 is separated into four sub-exhibits. The following table provides step-by-step instructions to -complete each part. See Section 4 and 53.3 for definitions. +Full launch -AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO +Jan. 21, 2026 -Entry +Jan. 22, 2026 -Description +Jan. 24, 2026 -Part 1. IT Investments for -Mission Delivery Area -and Management Support -Area +Initial invitation -Report IT investments that directly support an agency-designated mission -delivery and management support area as well as the mission delivery and -management support area it supports. This information should map directly to -your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. For IT investments that -cover more than one agency, report in the mission area with oversight of the IT -investment. Mission delivery and management support area 01 is reserved for IT -investments for major financial management systems. +First reminder -Page 21 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Final reminder - (2012) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Panelists participating online were sent an email invitation and up to two email reminders if they +did not respond to the survey. ATP panelists who consented to SMS messages were sent an SMS +invitation with a link to the survey and up to two SMS reminders. -IT investments for infrastructure, IT security, office automation, and -telecommunications are reported in Part 2 of Exhibit 53A. Report all IT -investments supporting common user systems, security, communications, and -computing infrastructure. Each agency may have multiple Exhibit 300s -encompassing office automation, infrastructure, IT security, and -telecommunications for the agency. It is encouraged that these investments be -reported at the point of management and thus may be defined at the bureau level -and/or by functional components of the infrastructure. These may involve -multiple mission areas and include end-user systems and support, mainframes -and servers services and support, and telecommunications services and support. -All IT investments capturing these shared services are to be included in Part 2. +For panelists who take surveys over the phone with a live interviewer: Prenotification +postcards were mailed on Jan. 16. Soft launch took place on Jan. 20 and involved dialing until a +total of four interviews had been completed. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking +sampled phone panelists’ numbers were dialed throughout the remaining field period. Panelists +who take surveys via phone can receive up to six calls from trained SSRS interviewers. -List all EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments. For the -President's Budget, EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments are -not categorized as major investments and an Exhibit 300 is not required for them. -Any capital planning and investment control process investments may be -reported separately in this section. However, agencies should ensure that -investments identified in variable information coding as belonging in Part 3 of -Exhibit 53A have the correct primary FEA mapping in order to clearly -distinguish the EA investments from other planning investments. +Data quality checks -Report IT investments that support grants management operations. See -classification instructions in Section 53.3a under Grants Management. +To ensure high-quality data, Center researchers performed data quality checks to identify any +respondents showing patterns of satisficing. This includes checking for whether respondents left +questions blank at very high rates or always selected the first or last answer presented. As a result +of this checking, two ATP respondents were removed from the survey dataset prior to weighting +and analysis. -Part 2. IT Investments for -Infrastructure, IT -Security, Office -Automation, and -Telecommunications +3 The ATP does not use routers or chains in any part of its online data collection protocol, nor are they used to direct respondents to additional +surveys. +4 Postcard notifications for web panelists are sent to 1) panelists who were recruited within the last two years and 2) panelists recruited prior +to the last two years who opt to continue receiving postcard notifications. -Part 3. IT Investments for -EA, Capital Planning, and -CIO Functions +www.pewresearch.org -Part 4. IT Investments for -Grants Management -Systems + 17 -Part 5. National Security -Systems IT Investments +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Report IT investments related to national security systems (Department of -Defense only). +American Trends Panel weighting dimensions -Part 6. Grants to State -and Local IT Investments +Variable +Age (detailed) +Age x Gender +Education x Gender +Education x Age +Race/Ethnicity x Education +Race/Ethnicity x Gender +Race/Ethnicity x Age +Born inside vs. outside the U.S. among +Hispanics and Asian Americans +Years lived in the U.S. +Census region x Metropolitan status -Report total amounts for IT investments for grants to state and local -governments. +Volunteerism -Page 22 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Frequency of internet use +Religious affiliation +Party affiliation x Race/Ethnicity +Party affiliation x Age - (2012) +Validated 2024 presidential election +turnout and vote choice - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Benchmark source -AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO (COLUMNS) +2023 American Community Survey +(ACS) -The following columns are required for the President's Budget Exhibit 53A, Agency IT Investment Portfolio: +2023 CPS Volunteering & Civic Life +Supplement +2025 National Public Opinion +Reference Survey (NPORS) -Column 1: Previous UII (12 digits required for all legacy investments) +Candidate vote share is based on +official results from the Federal +Election Commission. Turnout is +based on estimates from the Election +Lab at the University of Florida. The +size of the voting-eligible population is +based on the 2023 ACS. -Column 2: Current UII (12-digit primary key for all investments) +Note: Estimates from the ACS are based on noninstitutionalized adults. For weighting to the +2024 presidential election results, panelists are considered validated voters if their self- +report of having voted was confirmed after matching to a national voter registry. -Column 3: Investment Category (2-digit code) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 4: Bureau Code (2-digit code) (variable element) +Weighting -Column 5: Part of Exhibit 53 (2-digit code) (variable element) +The ATP data is weighted in a +process that accounts for +multiple stages of sampling and +nonresponse that occur at +different points in the panel +survey process. First, each +panelist begins with a base +weight that reflects their +probability of recruitment into +the panel. These weights are +then calibrated to align with the +population benchmarks in the +accompanying table to correct +for nonresponse to recruitment +surveys and panel attrition. If +only a subsample of panelists +was invited to participate in the +wave, this weight is adjusted to +account for any differential +probabilities of selection. +Because respondents to this +wave were sampled from +among respondents to Wave +183, the weights were also +adjusted to account for +nonresponse to Wave 183. -Column 6: Mission Delivery and Management Support Area (2-digit code) (variable element) +Among the panelists who completed the survey, this weight is then calibrated again to align with +the population benchmarks identified in the accompanying table and trimmed at the 1st and 99th +percentiles to reduce the loss in precision stemming from variance in the weights. Sampling errors +and tests of statistical significance take into account the effect of weighting. -Column 7: Type of Investment (2-digit code) (variable element) +www.pewresearch.org -Column 8: Line Item Descriptor (2-digit code) (variable element) + 18 -Column 9: Change in Investment Status Identifier (2-digit code) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 10: Agency Description of Change in Investment Status (limited to 255 characters) +The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that +would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the survey. -Column 11: Investment Title +Sample sizes and margins of error, ATP Wave 185 -Column 12: Investment Description (limited to 255 characters) +Group +Total sample -Column 13: FEA BRM Services – Primary service area (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 14: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #1 (3-digit code) +Rep/Lean Rep -Column 15: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #2 (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 16: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #3 (3-digit code) +Dem/Lean Dem -Column 17: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #4 (3-digit code) + Half form -Column 18: Homeland Security Priority Identifier (select all that apply) +Unweighted +sample size +8,512 -Column 19: HSPD-12 Cost (PY/2012) ($M) +At least 4,250 -Column 20: Cross-Boundary Information Identifier (1-digit code) +3,913 -Column 21: Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding (select all that apply) +At least 1,953 -Column 22: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M) +4,343 -Column 23: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M) +At least 2,164 -Column 24: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M) +Weighted % -Column 25: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M) +46% -Column 26: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M) +48% -Column 27: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M) +Plus or minus … +1.4 percentage points -Column 28: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M) +2.0 percentage points -Column 29: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M) +2.1 percentage points -Column 30: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M) +3.0 percentage points -Column 31: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M) +2.0 percentage points -Column 32: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M) +2.8 percentage points -Column 33: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M) +Note: This survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 respondents. Unweighted +sample sizes do not account for the sample design or weighting and do not describe a group’s contribution to weighted +estimates. See the Sample design and Weighting sections above for details. -Column 34: Number of Government FTEs (BY/2014) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 35: Percentage of Investment Cost for Government FTE (BY/2014) +Sample sizes and sampling errors for other subgroups are available upon request. In addition to +sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in +conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls. -Column 36: Functional/Business Sponsor Name +www.pewresearch.org -Column 37: Functional/Business Sponsor Title + 19 -Column 38: Functional/Business Sponsor Phone Number +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Column 39: Functional/Business Sponsor E-mail +Dispositions and response rates -Column 40: Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation +Final dispositions, ATP Wave 185 -Column 41: Cloud Computing Spending (PY) +Completed interview -Column 42: Cloud Computing Spending (CY) -Column 43: Cloud Computing Spending (BY) +Logged in (web) / Contacted (CATI), but did not complete any items -Page 23 of 45 Exhibit 53 +Started survey; broke off before completion - (2012) +Never logged on (web) / Never reached on phone (CATI) - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +Survey completed after close of the field period -AGENCY IT SECURITY PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53B) +Other non-interview -Row +Completed interview but was removed for data quality -Description +Total panelists sampled for the survey -1 Agency code +Completed interviews -2 Number of government -FTEs with information -security responsibilities +Partial interviews -3 Average cost per +Refusals -government FTE with -information security -responsibilities +Non-contact -4 Number of contractor -FTEs with information -security responsibilities +Other -5 +Unknown household -6 +Unknown other -Average cost per -contractor FTE for -information security -responsibilities +Not eligible -Total IT security tools -cost +Total -List the three-digit agency identifier (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A- -11). +AAPOR RR1 = I / (I+P+R+NC+O+UH+UO) -Report the number of government employees with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to these responsibilities. This number should -include but should not be limited to: designated security officers, network -security staff, system administrators, and system owners. The number -should not include individuals responsible for physical security, such as -guards. The number should be rounded to two decimal places. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Using the salary information of the government employees counted in -“Number of government FTEs with information security responsibilities,” -calculate an average fully loaded cost per government FTE. The average -cost should be represented in dollars and rounded to two decimal places. +Cumulative response rate, ATP Wave 185 -Report the number of contractor staff with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to these responsibilities. The number should be -rounded to two decimal places. +Weighted response rate to recruitment surveys -Using the billing rate of the contract staff counted in “Number of contractor -FTEs with information security responsibilities,” calculate an average -yearly cost per contractor FTE. The average cost should be represented in -dollars and rounded to two decimal places. +% of recruitment survey respondents who agreed to join the +panel, among those invited +% of those agreeing to join who were active panelists at start of +Wave 185 -This is the sum of the following eight data elements, which were formerly -provided separately in Exhibit 53B for the FY 2012 Budget cycle. Costs -should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. +Response rate to Wave 183 survey -1. Anti-Virus Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs incurred +Response rate to Wave 185 survey -or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not -purchase anti-virus software separately from anti-malware software, -enter all costs on the line for anti-malware and leave this line blank. +Cumulative response rate -2. Anti-Malware Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -3. Intrusion Detection Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +© Pew Research Center 2025 -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If you have -an IDS which is part of an IPS, include all costs in IPS and do not list -here. Include the amount paid for the Managed Trusted Internet -Protocol Service via the Networx contract as well as any other -operational IDSs. +www.pewresearch.org -4. Intrusion Prevention Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +Total -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -5. Web Filtering Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs +8,512 -incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. Costs should -be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. +145 -Page 24 of 45 Exhibit 53 +100 - (2012) +541 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO +0 -6. E-mail Filtering Software – The licensing costs incurred or expected -to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not purchase e- -mail filtering software separate from web filtering software, include all -costs in web filtering software and do not list here. +2 -7. SIM/SIEM Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or expected to be +2 -incurred for the respective BY. +9,302 -8. Data Leakage Protection Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or +8,514 -expected to be incurred for the respective BY. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Security -authorization costs should only include contract costs. +245 -Report the number of systems used to in cost calculations for “Costs for -NIST 800-37 implementation.” +541 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all -costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs. +4 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all -costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include -the costs of annual security awareness training required by the FISMA Act. +0 -Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. -Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Do not -include costs associated with annual awareness training. +0 -Report the number of government employees with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported -in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated government FTE costs -(based on the average costs reported in row 3) will be subtracted from the -total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting. +9,302 -Report the number of contractor staff with information security -responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a -percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported -in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated contractor FTE costs -(based on the average costs reported in row 5) will be subtracted from the -total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting. +92% -7 Costs for NIST 800-37 -implementation +AAPOR code -8 Number of systems +1.1 -scheduled for activities -represented in Row 7 +2.11 -9 Costs for annual FISMA +2.12 -testing +2.20 -10 Costs for network -penetration testing -activities +2.27 -11 Security awareness -training costs +2.30 -12 Security training costs for +2.90 -employees with -significant security -responsibilities +I -13 Number of government +P -FTEs included in costs for -row 7 and rows 9 through +R + +NC + +O + +UH + +UO + +NE + +Total + +12% + +74% + +40% + +92% + +92% + +3% + + 20 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +2026 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL +WAVE 185 POLITICS JANUARY SURVEY +FINAL TOPLINE +January 20-26, 2026 +N=8,512 + +Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This +topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly +modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire. + +American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online +(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys +conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail. +For additional details, visit the Methodology. + +* ”No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents +who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered +as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and +telephone refusals. + +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +SATIS All in all, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in this country today? + +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Oct 6-16, 2025 +Aug 4-10, 2025 +Apr 28-May 4, 2025 +Mar 10-16, 2025 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Nov 12-17, 2024 +Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 +Aug 5-11, 2024 +Jul 1-7, 2024 +May 13-19, 2024 +Jan 16-21, 2024 +Nov 27-Dec 3, 2023 +Jul 10-16, 2023 +Jun 5-11, 2023 +Mar 27-Apr 2, 2023 +Jan 18-24, 2023 +Nov 16-27, 2022 +Oct 10-16, 2022 +Aug 1-14, 2022 +Apr 25-May 1, 2022 +Jan 10-17, 2022 +Sep 20-26, 2021 +Sep 13-19, 2021 +Mar 1-7, 2021 +Nov 12-17, 2020 +Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 +Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020 + +Satisfied +29 +27 +34 +32 +34 +38 +29 +23 +24 +18 +22 +21 +22 +22 +21 +19 +22 +24 +21 +18 +24 +21 +25 +26 +33 +22 +18 12 -14 Number of contractor - -FTEs included in costs for -row 7 and rows 9 through +Dissatisfied +69 +72 +65 +67 +65 +61 +70 +76 +75 +82 +78 +78 +77 +77 +78 +80 +78 +75 +79 +81 +75 +78 +74 +74 +66 +77 +82 +87 + +No answer* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +1 +1 +1 +1 + +www.pewresearch.org + + 21 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +SATIS CONTINUED … + +Jun 16-22, 2020 +Apr 7-12, 2020 +Mar 19-24, 2020 +Oct 29-Nov 11, 2019 +Oct 1-13, 2019 +Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019 +Nov 27-Dec 10, 2018 +Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018 +Feb 28-Mar 12, 20175 +Sep 27-Oct 10, 2016 +Jun 7-Jul 5, 2016 +Sep 15-Oct 3, 2014 + +Satisfied 12 +31 +33 +31 +28 +27 +34 +36 +32 +23 +19 +25 + +Dissatisfied +87 +68 +66 +69 +71 +72 +65 +63 +68 +75 +80 +75 + +No answer* +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +* +2 +1 +* + +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +YEARAHEAD + +Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that 2026 will be … +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1] + +Better than 2025 Worse than 2025 + +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Jan 16-21, 2024 +Jan 18-24, 2023 +Jan 10-17, 2022 +Jan 8-12, 2021 +Jan 6-19, 2020 + +50 +55 +55 +57 +61 +67 +55 + +48 +45 +45 +43 +38 +32 +43 + +No answer* +1 +* +1 +* +1 +1 +2 + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: +Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that [coming year] will be better or worse +than [prior year]? + +Jan 8-13, 2020 +Jan 9-14, 2019 +Jan 10-15, 2018 +Jan 4-9, 2017 +Jan 7-14, 2016 +Dec 3-7, 2014 (U) +Jan 15-19, 2014 +Dec 5-9, 2012 +Jan 11-16, 2012 +Dec 1-5, 2010 +Jan 6-10, 2010 +Jan 7-11, 2009 +December, 2007 +December, 2006 +December, 1999 +December, 1998 +December, 1994 +Gallup: December, 1993 + +Better +55 +47 +61 +49 +56 +49 +56 +55 +57 +55 +67 +52 +50 +57 +66 +59 +59 +64 + +Worse +34 +43 +29 +42 +30 +42 +35 +36 +29 +31 +26 +37 +34 +28 +19 +25 +28 +20 + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref +11 +10 +11 +9 +14 +9 +9 +9 +14 +14 +8 +11 +16 +15 +15 +16 +13 +16 + +1 + +The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only. + +www.pewresearch.org + + 22 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED + +Gallup: December, 1992 +Gallup: December, 1991 +Gallup: December, 1990 +Gallup: December, 1986 +Gallup: December, 1985 +Gallup: December, 1984 +Gallup: December, 1982 +Gallup: December, 1981 + +Better +61 +61 +48 +53 +64 +61 +50 +41 + +Worse +11 +31 +42 +25 +20 +20 +32 +44 + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref +28 +8 +10 +22 +17 +19 +18 +15 + +ASK ALL: +POL1DT +ASK IF ANSWERED POL1DT (POL1DT=1,2) [N=8,378]: +POL1DTSTR + +Do you approve or disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling his job as president? + +Do you [IF POL1DT=1: approve; IF POL1DT=2: disapprove] of the way Donald Trump is +handling his job as president… + +NET +Approve + +Very +strongly + +Not so +strongly + +No +answer* + +NET +Disapprove + +Very +strongly + +Not so +strongly + +No +answer* + +No +answer* + +Trump Second Term +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Sep 22-28, 2025 +Aug 4-10, 2025 +Jun 2-8, 2025 +Apr 7-13, 2025 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 + +Trump First Term +Jan 8-12, 2021 +Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020 +Jun 16-22, 2020 +Apr 7-12, 2020 +Mar 19-24, 2020 +Jan 6-19, 2020 +Sep 3-15, 2019 +Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019 +Apr 29-May 13, 2019 +Feb 4-17, 2019 +Nov 7-13, 2018 +Sep 24-Oct 7, 2018 +Jul 30-Aug 12, 2018 +Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018 +Aug 8-21, 2017 +Apr 4-18, 2017 +Feb 28-Mar 12, 20176 + +37 +40 +38 +41 +40 +47 + +29 +38 +39 +44 +45 +40 +40 +40 +40 +38 +41 +38 +40 +38 +36 +39 +44 + +27 +29 +27 +30 +31 +37 + +21 +n/a +29 +33 +34 +31 +31 +n/a +29 +n/a +n/a +n/a +31 +29 +26 +27 +30 + +10 +10 +11 +11 +9 +9 + +7 +n/a +9 +10 +10 +9 +9 +n/a +10 +n/a +n/a +n/a +9 +9 +10 +12 +13 + +* +1 +* +* +* +* + +* +n/a +1 +1 +1 +* +* +n/a +* +n/a +n/a +n/a +* +* +* +* +* + +61 +58 +60 +58 +59 +51 + +68 +59 +59 +53 +52 +58 +58 +59 +59 +61 +58 +61 +59 +60 +63 +61 +56 + +49 +47 +47 +46 +48 +40 + +56 +n/a +48 +42 +40 +46 +46 +n/a +48 +n/a +n/a +n/a +48 +48 +49 +45 +43 -Note: Exhibit 53B should not include security costs typically embedded in IT investments, such as destruction -of data (e.g., degaussing, shredding), physical or logical access control software, continuous monitoring -software, tracking and reporting software, and annual disaster recovery and contingency plan tests. - -Page 25 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -AGENCY CLOUD COMPUTING PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53C) - -(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (Dollars in millions) - -PY - -CY - -BY - -Public Cloud - -Private Cloud - -Community Cloud - -Hybrid Cloud - -(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (Dollars in millions) - -PY - -CY - -BY - -SaaS - -PaaS - -IaaS - -Note: Exhibit 53C should describe agency funding for IT investments, not agency contributions. The sum of -all cells in Table (a) should equal the sum of all cells in Table (b) and should equal the sum of columns 41 to -43 in Exhibit 53A. - -Page 26 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -AGENCY IT REDUCTIONS AND REINVESTMENTS (Exhibit 53D) - -When properly managed and applied, IT can create efficiencies, reduce costs, improve service delivery, and -strengthen cybersecurity. But, too often spending on IT is still wasted on duplicative investments, missed -opportunities to leverage economies of scale, rising operational costs that starve new development, and -mismanaged projects that lead to cost overruns and schedule slippages. - -To address this issue, OMB Memorandum M-12-13 included guidance on IT reductions and reinvestments -that agencies should reflect in their FY 2014 budget submission. In accordance with the memorandum, this -section provides more specific guidance on how this information should be reflected in agency budgets, -including additional detail on the nature of cuts and reinvestments and detailed reporting instructions. - -Agencies should propose reductions in IT that represent 10% of their overall spending, and propose a -reinvestment of at least 5%, and up to 10%, of these savings, in priority IT investments for OMB -consideration. To do this, agencies are required to report the specific investments in which they propose cuts -and the specific investments in which they propose to reinvest funds. - -(a) What Agencies Will Provide - -As part of their FY 2014 budget submission, agencies are asked to complete the new Exhibit 53D (a -downloadable template is available on OMB MAX; final submission will be made via OMB MAX). This -new exhibit will allow agencies to show how they achieved the 10% reduction called for in the memorandum, -and where they propose to reinvest some of these savings. The template, OMB MAX data collection exercise, -and detailed technical instructions are available here. - -Please use the following guidelines when providing specific data on the proposed cuts and reinvestments from -FY 2013 to FY 2014: - - Agencies should provide the following for each cut and reinvestment: -o Specific IT investments and OMB accounts impacted, -o Related category of the cut or reinvestment (provided in MAX exercise) and explanation, -o Priority level and a description of the return on investment (reinvestments only); - - - -Information supplied in Exhibit 53D should be consistent with information supplied in Exhibits 53A, -B and C, and Exhibits 300A and B; - - Agencies should include, in their FY 2014 budget submissions to OMB, a summary of all the -information provided in Exhibit 53D, and the general approach the agency took to achieve its -reductions and reinvestments; and - - Reductions and reinvestments apply Department-wide and should not solely target investments from - -agency-level IT or administrative accounts. - -(b) What Agencies Should Cut - -Regarding required reductions, OMB M-12-13 states “…include an explanation of how, at the investment and -account level, you would achieve this reduction.” - -The 10% cuts should reduce agency spending in the following IT areas: - - Duplicative commodity IT investments or contracts (as emphasized in PortfolioStat and consistent - -with OMB Memoranda M-11-29 and M-12-10) include: - -IT infrastructure (e.g. data centers, networks, desktops, and/or mobile devices) - -o -o Enterprise IT systems (e.g. email, help desk, collaboration, identify and access management, - -security and web infrastructure) - -o Business systems (e.g. HR, FM, and other administrative functions); - Underperforming projects/investments of any type (as emphasized in TechStats); or - -Page 27 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - - Lower-value or lower-priority investments of any type. - -Exemptions from the 10% reduction target must be explicitly granted by OMB. - -(c) Where Agencies Should Reinvest - -Regarding reinvestments, OMB M-12-13, states “your budget submission may also propose where you would -reinvest the savings from identified cuts in innovative IT solutions that would produce a favorable return on -investment within 18 months or demonstrably improve citizen services or administrative efficiencies” - -Agencies should propose 10% cuts in IT and then propose a list of priority reinvestments to OMB up to the -10%. If the Agency does not propose to reinvest at least 5% of these savings into IT, the agency is required to -provide a justification explaining as to why it is unable to propose these reinvestments. Agencies should only -propose reinvestments which demonstrate a favorable return on investment (quantitative or qualitative) to the -agency within 18 months from the enactment of FY 2014 appropriations (excluding CRs). - -Proposed reinvestments should be in the following areas: - -Improvements to citizen services or administrative efficiencies; - - - Adoption of shared services; - Consolidation of commodity IT, including optimizing data centers; - - - - -Improvements to the security posture of the agency’s IT and information assets; -Improvements to the energy efficiency of IT facilities and equipment; -Innovative investments consistent with policy initiatives such as cloud computing, modular -development, reduction of improper payments, and digital government; or - - Data analytics or data management consistent with Administration priorities in Big Data. - -(d) How Much Agencies Should Cut Before Reinvesting - -Regarding the level of reductions, OMB M-12-13, states “…your 2014 budget submission should achieve an -agency-wide 10% reduction in IT spending, compared to the average spending on IT from FY 2010 through -2012” - -The table below shows the effects of the FY 2014 Budget policy for IT spending. Note that while the cut is -calculated as 10% of the average total IT spend from FY 2010-2012, the FY (before proposed reinvestments) -target is reached by applying the cut to the revised FY 2013 President's Budget level (as reported to the IT -Dashboard by agencies in May 2012). - -FY 2013 -(President's -Budget as -of May -2012) - -FY 2014 -10% -Reduction -(2010- -2012) - -$2,611 -$2,396 -$32,669 -$552 -$2,016 -$7,102 -$5,629 - -$252 -$259 -$3,509 -$61 -$205 -$662 -$587 - -Average - (2010- -2012) -$2,524 -$2,589 -$35,086 -$613 -$2,053 -$6,617 -$5,868 - -FY 2014 -Target -(before -reinvestment) -$2,359 -$2,137 -$29,161 -$491 -$1,811 -$6,440 -$5,042 - -FY 2014 -Minimum -(5%) -reinvestment -$126 -$129 -$1,754 -$31 -$103 -$331 -$293 - -FY 2014 -Maximum -(10%) -reinvestment -$252 -$259 -$3,509 -$61 -$205 -$662 -$587 - -Agency -USDA -Commerce -DOD -ED -Energy -HHS -DHS - -Page 28 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO - -HUD -Interior -Justice -Labor -State -USAID -DOT -Treasury -VA -USACE -EPA -GSA -NASA -NARA -NSF -NRC -OPM -SBA -SI -SSA - -$385 -$988 -$2,850 -$591 -$1,420 -$133 -$2,990 -$3,271 -$3,163 -$544 -$461 -$622 -$1,740 -$137 -$97 -$160 -$78 -$113 -$65 -$1,548 -$76,706 - -$354 -$965 -$2,655 -$606 -$1,369 -$140 -$3,092 -$3,495 -$3,327 -$566 -$465 -$631 -$1,462 -$100 -$97 -$151 -$73 -$112 -$68 -$1,380 -$74,083 - -$38 -$99 -$285 -$59 -$142 -$13 -$299 -$327 -$316 -$54 -$46 -$62 -$174 -$14 -$10 -$16 -$8 -$11 -$6 -$155 -$7,669 - -$316 -$866 -$2,370 -$547 -$1,227 -$127 -$2,793 -$3,168 -$3,011 -$512 -$419 -$569 -$1,288 -$86 -$88 -$135 -$65 -$100 -$61 -$1,226 -$66,415 - -$19 -$49 -$142 -$30 -$71 -$7 -$149 -$164 -$158 -$31 -$23 -$31 -$87 -$7 -$5 -$8 -$4 -$6 -$3 -$77 -$3,838 - -$38 -$99 -$285 -$59 -$142 -$13 -$299 -$327 -$316 -$54 -$46 -$62 -$174 -$14 -$10 -$16 -$8 -$11 -$6 -$155 -$7,669 - -Page 29 of 45 Exhibit 53 - - (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT -OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CAPITAL ASSETS - -300.1 What is the purpose of this guidance? - -OMB provides specific policy, procedural, and analytic guidelines for planning, budgeting, acquisition, and -management of major IT capital investments in addition to general guidance issued in OMB Circular A-11 and -OMB Circular A-130. - -Exhibit 300 describes the justification, planning, and implementation of an individual capital asset included in the -agency IT investment portfolio (as reported in Exhibit 53) and serves as a key artifact of the agency’s EA and IT -CPIC processes. Exhibit 300 is comprised of two components—Exhibit 300A provides inherent investment -information, including general information and planning for resources such as staffing and personnel. Exhibit -300B provides more temporal information, such as projects and activities, risks, and operational performance of -the investment. - -Together, Exhibits 53 and 300 provide the budgetary and management information necessary for sound planning, -management, and governance of IT investments. These documents help agencies explicitly align IT investments -with strategic and performance goals, and ultimately provide value to the public by making investment and -management information more transparent. As architecture-driven IT investments are funded in the "Invest" -phase, they move forward into the implementation phase where system development life cycle processes are -followed and actual outputs, schedule, and operational performance expenditures are tracked versus planned -numbers using performance-based management processes. - -300.2 - - Does Exhibit 300 apply to my agency or IT investment? - -The policy and budget justification principles in Exhibit 300 apply to all agencies of the Executive Branch of the -Federal Government that are subject to Executive Branch review (see Section 25 of OMB Circular A-11). In -accordance with section 5, Exhibits 300A and B must be submitted for each major IT investment. Major IT -investments must be reported on the agency’s Exhibit 53A, along with all non-major investments. - -300.3 How will agencies manage IT capital assets/investments? - -The Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular A-11 provides guidance on the principles and techniques for -effective capital programming. OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J explains the principles of financing capital asset -acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A-130 establishes additional requirements for EAs, planning and -control of information systems and IT investments, and performance management. Agencies must develop and -implement a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio and must: - - Evaluate and select capital assets that will support core mission functions performed by the Federal - -Government and which demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal to or better -than alternative uses of available public resources. Specifically for IT, the investments should be -informed by and should address performance gaps and goals identified in an agency’s strategic plan, -annual performance plan, and EA; -Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative private -sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need; -Implement IT reforms from the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology -Management, such as adhering to modular development principles and the requirement to establish an -IPT prior to funding an IT investment; - - - - - - Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and maximize the - -use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology; - - Assign a functional/business sponsor for each investment who is responsible for the program or -function supported or implemented by the investment. The sponsor is responsible for expressing the - -Page 30 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for the IT -investment to the agency CIO and OMB. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must -include the name of the functional/business sponsor, title, phone number, and e-mail address; - - Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom-designed components, using components that can be -fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring involvement and -support of users in the design and testing of the asset; - - Structure major planning and acquisition into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration. -These segments should make adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between the -Federal Government and contractor. The agency head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and -performance goals for major acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the -proposed cost goals; - - Ensure a continuous linkage between Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency - - - -through alignment with the agency’s Enterprise Roadmap and target architecture, compliance with agency -business requirements and standards, as well as identification of milestones, as defined in the agency’s -EA transition strategy; -Institute performance measures and management processes to monitor and compare actual performance to -planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management system or EVMS, -based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748-B, to obtain timely information regarding the progress of capital -investments, as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR). The system must also measure -progress towards useful components in an independently verifiable basis in terms of cost, capability of the -investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality; - - Per requirements of Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V), agencies are expected -to achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major acquisitions. -Through the TechStat process and as part of the Clinger-Cohen Act responsibly, Agency CIOs should -review major acquisitions that have not achieved 90 percent of the goals to determine whether there is a -continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, should be taken; - - Ensure that the planning and management of agency assets that are IT systems conform to the -requirements of OMB Circular A-130, “Management of Federal Information Resources”; - - Ensure that agency assets that are financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB +12 +11 +13 +12 +10 +11 -Circular A-127; +12 +n/a +11 +11 +11 +11 +11 +n/a +10 +n/a +n/a +n/a +10 +12 +13 +15 +12 - Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition +* +* +* +* +* +* + +* +n/a +* +* +* +1 +1 +n/a +* +n/a +n/a +n/a +* +* +* +* +* + +2 +2 +2 +1 +1 +2 + +3 +3 +2 +3 +2 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +2 +2 +2 +1 +1 +1 + +See past presidents’ approval trends: Joe Biden, Barack Obama, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton -processes and projects to validate estimated costs and benefits and to document effective management -practices (e.g., lessons learned) for broader use; +6 - Establish oversight mechanisms that require periodic review of operational capital assets to determine -how mission requirements might have changed and whether the asset continues to fulfill ongoing and -anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and customers, and meet user -requirements; +The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only. + +www.pewresearch.org + + 23 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +ASK ALL: +DTSUCCESS + +Jan 20-26, +2026 +31 +47 +21 +1 + +In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be… +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1, HOLDING 3 LAST] + +A successful president +An unsuccessful president +Too early to tell +No answer* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +35 +33 +31 +1 + +Jan 6-19, +2020 +34 +48 +18 +1 + +TREND FOR COMPARISON: +In the long run, do you think Joe Biden will be… + +A successful president +An unsuccessful president +Too early to tell +No answer + +Jan 8-12, +2021 +29 +26 +44 +1 + +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON +In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be a successful or unsuccessful president, or do you +think it is too early to tell? + +Successful + +Unsuccessful + +Too early +to tell + +(VOL.) +DK/Ref + +Trump +Jan 8-13, 2020 +Jan 9-14, 2019 +Jan 10-15, 2018 +Jan 4-9, 2017 +Obama +Jan 7-14, 2016 +Jan 7-11, 2015 +Jan 15-19, 2014 +Jun 12-16, 2013 +Jan 9-13, 2013 +Jan 11-16, 2012 +Jan 5-9, 2011 +Jan 6-10, 2010 +Sep 30-Oct 4, 2009 +Jan 7-11, 2009 +Bush +January, 2007 +January, 2006 +Early October, 2005 +January, 2005 +December, 2003 +Early October, 2002 +January, 2001 +Clinton +January, 1999 +Early September, 1998 +February, 1995 +October, 1994 +May, 1994 +January, 1994 +October, 1993 +September, 1993 +August, 1993 + +36 +29 +23 +21 + +37 +32 +28 +34 +33 +27 +25 +24 +27 +30 + +24 +27 +26 +36 +39 +40 +26 + +44 +38 +18 +14 +21 +21 +18 +22 +13 + +37 +47 +41 +20 + +34 +38 +34 +31 +26 +32 +26 +21 +18 +4 + +45 +37 +41 +27 +20 +15 +15 + +24 +24 +34 +35 +26 +19 +25 +22 +25 + +26 +23 +34 +58 + +26 +29 +35 +33 +39 +39 +47 +52 +54 +65 + +27 +32 +30 +35 +38 +44 +58 + +29 +35 +43 +48 +52 +57 +56 +54 +60 + +1 +1 +1 +1 + +3 +2 +3 +2 +2 +2 +2 +3 +2 +1 + +4 +4 +3 +2 +3 +1 +1 + +3 +3 +5 +3 +1 +3 +1 +2 +2 - Provide Chief Information Officer (CIO) evaluations for all major investments on the IT Dashboard +www.pewresearch.org -which reflect the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment in terms of its ability -to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, including, but not -limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical performance, -human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to forecasting future success. Each -evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation; -and + 24 - Develop, maintain, and submit the following investment documents and artifacts for all major IT -investments, as applicable. Provide updated versions (including date of last update) as significant -changes are made or as available throughout the investment’s lifecycle: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -o Risk management plan; -o -Investment charter, including IPT; -o -Investment-level alternative analysis and benefit-cost analysis; -o Operational analyses (for operational or mixed life cycle systems); -o Post implementation review results (investment level or project-specific); and, -o Documentation of investment re-baseline management approval(s). +ASK ALL: +QUALPRES_TRMP -Page 31 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, how confident are you that +Donald Trump…7 +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Extremely +confident -300.4 What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill? +Very +confident -Exhibit 300A is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to Congress, as -required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V) and Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996. -The business case (Exhibit 300A) for investment should demonstrate support for the mission statements, long- -term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the GPRA-MA. Exhibit 300B -establishes reporting requirements through the IT Dashboard to ensure the proper execution of those investments -against the established performance plans. +Somewhat +confident -300.5 What must I report on Exhibits 300A and B and when? +Not too +confident -All information necessary to complete Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should already exist as part of the agency's -overall capital planning activities and within project- and program-specific documentation. The materials used to -populate Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should be readily available to OMB upon request. +Not at all +confident -Agencies must submit Exhibit 300s using the following schedule: +No +answer* - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300A: September 10-14, 2012 - Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300B: September 14, 2012 - President’s Budget Request Exhibit 300A & B: February 2013 (tentative) +MF -o Submit initial documents/artifacts at this time +Has the mental fitness +needed to do the job + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 20258 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -Unless otherwise noted, IT exhibits and reporting must be submitted electronically to the IT Dashboard. -Additional information regarding the submission process will be posted on the IT Dashboard, including business -rules for the validation of data and a schema that describes how data should be transmitted. As always, pre- -decisional and procurement sensitive information will not be displayed to the public. +▪ -Projects within investments are encouraged to use modular development principles. All projects (regardless of -whether they use modular development principles), must produce usable functionality at intervals of no more than -six months. +PHY ▪ Has the physical fitness -Exhibit 300Bs shall establish cost, schedule and performance targets for CY 2013 and BY 2014. Regular updates -for metrics and activities will be submitted to the IT Dashboard as soon as the data becomes available and at least -once per each calendar month. How periodic performance metrics updates for ongoing operations will be, will -vary according to the nature of the metric, as indicated in Table C1. +needed to do the job + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 20259 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -If an agency requests supplemental funds or reallocates funding within its authority, which includes changes to -the agency's portfolio and the performance targets, agencies should submit a new or revised version of Exhibit -53A as part of their supplemental request. +▪ +▪ +▪ -Multi-Agency Collaboration and Intra-agency Shared Services Investments (must submit both Exhibit 300A -and Exhibit 300B) +FIRM -The managing partners (lead agency that provides services or coordination services to other agencies) will take -the lead in completing and submitting the multi-agency collaboration investment Exhibits 300, managing it -through the managing partner’s capital programming and budget process. The managing partners are also -responsible for ensuring Exhibit 300 includes all necessary information from the partner agencies (customers who -receive services from the managing partners) and have been approved by all necessary partner agencies through -the appropriate governance process. The tracking of the multi-agency approvals, partner agency funding, and -related capital assets (e.g., migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, supporting -components) will be captured via an OMB MAX E-Gov Funding Tool. All initiative program managers or -designated leads should have received details about this in an OMB e-mail distribution dated May 22, 2012. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250] +Has the leadership skills +needed to do the job +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 -Page 32 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +RSP - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Respects the country’s +democratic values +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Apr 8-14, 2024 -For IT assets, partner agencies should report their participation in Exhibit 53 submissions. Partner agencies -should reference the name and UII of the multi-agency Exhibit 300 in the “Investment Description” field of -each Exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency Exhibit 300. Partner agencies should also ensure their -activities and participation are included in the appropriate sections of the multi-agency Exhibit 300. The entire -Summary of Funding Total for the investment, including funds provided by partner agencies, should be included -in Exhibit 300. + ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262] +ADV -Investments that provide a service to other agencies but do not receive contributions from partner agencies -should be reported as Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments. +Picks good advisers + Jan 20-26, 2026 + Jan 27-Feb 2, 202510 + Apr 8-14, 2024 -Investments for multi-agency collaboration, shared services, and/or LoBs will be reflected in the managing -partner's annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to OMB. +▪ +▪ +▪ -Managing partners that provide multi-agency services should ensure that funding is prioritized to -accommodate building and obtaining approval of a shared architecture. Approval should be obtained through -a working governance model that includes partner agencies, customers, and OMB. +ETHETH -OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency collaboration -investment Exhibit 300. When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate data -requests. +Acts ethically in office -Page 33 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Jan 20-26, 2026 +Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025 +Apr 8-14, 2024 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +17 +23 +20 -300.6 How will OMB use Exhibit 300? +12 +17 +15 -Exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total budget justification (see Section 51.2 of OMB Circular A- -11). OMB uses data reported in Exhibit 300 to make quantitative decisions about budgetary resources consistent -with the Administration’s program priorities as well as qualitative assessments about whether the agency’s -programming processes are consistent with OMB policies and guidance. OMB may request additional supporting -information from agencies as necessary. +19 +25 -Exhibit 300A: IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification +13 +17 +17 -Section A: General Information +11 +16 +11 -1. Investment Name: -2. UII. Unique Investment Identifier (see Section 53.4) : +9 +15 +11 -[Limit: 250 char] -[Limit: 13 char] +15 +17 +15 -Section B: Investment Detail +15 +18 +18 -1. Briefly describe the investment’s purpose, goals, and current or anticipated benefits (quantitative and/or -qualitative). Include the investment’s specific contribution to mission delivery or agency management -support functions and identify key customers, stakeholders, and other beneficiaries. -[Limit: 2500 char] +15 +15 -2. Briefly describe how the investment contributes to the agency target EA and its role in the Enterprise -Roadmap. Include a description of how the investment includes or will achieve programmatic or -technical innovation. -[Limit:2500 char] +12 +14 +13 -3. Provide the investment’s currently projected return on investment (ROI) percentage, as documented in +14 +15 +14 -the most recent alternatives analysis, and the date that it was established. +12 +13 +12 -a. Current ROI: -b. Date of Current ROI: +16 +16 +17 -[percentage] -[YYYY-MM-DD] +22 +24 +26 -4. In the table below, indicate if the investment in whole or in part specifically addresses any of the +14 +16 -following types of requirements: +15 +16 +16 -Note: Where “Yes” is indicated, provide a brief description of the requirement and how the investment will meet -the requirement. Include citations within descriptions, if available. Provide any URLs associated with each -requirement. If citing the Agency Performance Plan, provide the applicable “PRM” code from Performance.gov. -Description -[Limit: 1000 -characters] +18 +18 +22 -URL(s) / PRM code (s) -[One or more] +18 +17 +17 -Required -by -[Yes/No] +14 +14 +15 -Legislative Mandate -Outstanding Audit Finding or -Material Weakness -Published Agency Strategic -Plan/Annual Performance Plan -Presidential Direction (i.e. -Presidential Directive, Presidential -Memorandum, or Executive Order) -Other Requirement +19 +17 +17 -(URL required) +14 +13 -(optional) +15 +14 +12 -[URL of Agency Strategic Plan] (optional) -[PRM code for Annual Performance Plan] (required) +17 +14 +15 -(URL required) +15 +14 +14 -(optional) +37 +30 +32 -5. Provide a description of the investment’s progress and accomplishments in the PY, including the +31 +24 +23 -investment’s overall performance against baseline goals, targets, significant milestones, or performance -measures, and any corrective actions taken to address performance deficiencies. -[Limit: 1000 char] +36 +30 -Page 34 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +43 +39 +41 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +40 +37 +37 -6. Describe the investment’s objectives for the CY, BY, and budget out years, if available, including +45 +40 +45 -specific accomplishments to achieve, realize, or continue to achieve the benefits cited in question B.1. -above. -[Limit: 2500 char] +* +* +* -7. If this investment will result in the elimination or the reduction of another investment(s), please +1 +1 +* -complete the following: +* +* -Investment UII (one or more) +1 +* +1 -8. Does the investment include the following? - -To be Status -[to be eliminated/to be reduced] +1 +1 +1 -A shared service (intra-or inter-agency—current and/or planned) -A data center (current and/or planned) -PIV-enabled systems (per HSPD-12) (all systems currently PIV-enabled) -(see OMB memo M-11-11) -Cloud computing (current and/or planned) -APIs (application programming interfaces) consistent with the Digital Government -Strategy - -Check all that Apply -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] - -[Yes/No] -[Yes/No] - -9. Provide any URLs related to the investment and indicate how they are related. Identify each URL’s - -relationship to the investment (if applicable): - -Relationship to Investment -(check all that apply) - -d -e -c -u -d -o -r -p -s -t -e -s -a -t -a -d -e -l -b -i -s -s -e -c -c -a - -y -l -c -i -l -b -u -p -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +1 +* +1 -. - -A - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t -y -b - -e -d -i -v -o -r -p -o -t +7 -I -P -A -e -l -b -i -s -s -e -c -c -a -y -l -c -i -l -b -u -p -a - -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +8 +9 +10 -. - -B - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -m -o -r -f - -a -t -a -d -o -t - -s -s -e -c -c -a - -. -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a - -a -i -d -e -m - -l -a -i -c -o -s -o -t - -s -k -n -i -L - -. - -C - -s -i -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -i - -l -a -r -e -n -e -g -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +Prior to January 2026, question was worded: “Thinking about the qualities needed to effectively serve another term +as president, how confident are you that Donald Trump…” +Prior to January 2026, the word “mental” was not underlined. +Prior to January 2026, the word “physical” was not underlined. +Prior to January 2026, the word “advisers” was spelled “advisors.” -. - -D - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -s -i -h -t - -y -b -d -e -v -r -e -s -m -a -r -g -o -r -p -r -o -s -s -e -c -o -r -p -s -s -e -n -i -s -u -b - -f -l -e -s -t -i - -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -e -h -t - -t -o -n -t -u -b -t -n -e -m -t -s -e -v -n -i - -e -h -t - -t -u -o -b -a -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -i - -l -a -r -e -n -e -g -s -e -d -i -v -o -r -P +www.pewresearch.org -. + 25 -E +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -URL -(as many as -necessary) +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -http://... +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +Thinking about important issues facing the country today… -[X] +TRUMPISSUE1 Overall, would you say you tend to agree with Donald Trump on… -[X] +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1] -[X] +Jan 20-26, +2026 +13 +27 +22 +37 +1 -[X] +All or nearly all issues +Many, but not all issues +A few issues +No or almost no issues +No answer* -[X] +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -10. Provide the date of the investment or IPT charter establishing the required IPT. +Jul 1-7, +2024 +16 +25 +23 +35 +1 -[Date] +Feb 4-15, +2020 +19 +23 +23 +34 +1 -Page 35 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Apr 25-May 1 +2018 +19 +22 +24 +33 +2 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Aug 15-21 +2017 +15 +18 +21 +45 +1 -11. Provide names and contact information for IPT members in the table below. If available, insert lines for -other IPT members such as enterprise architects, capital planners, and performance specialists. The IT -PM, business process owner/SME, and contracting specialist must be Federal Government employees. -The business process owner or SME may or may not be the same person listed as the functional/business -sponsor on the Exhibit 53-- the functional/business sponsor may be a higher-level agency official or -executive. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +TRUMPISSUE2 Now thinking not about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump conducts himself as -IPT Member Role +president, would you say you... +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-3/3-1] -IT PM +Jan 20-26, +2026 +16 -Name (Required for -all members listed) -[Limit: 250 char] +32 -Phone Number -(Required for PM) -[10 digits, 0-9 only] +51 -Business Process Owner -or SME -Contracting Specialist -IT Specialist -IT Security Specialist -(Optional: Insert other IPT -members) +1 -(optional) +Like the way he conducts +himself +Have mixed feelings about the +way he conducts himself +Don’t like the way he conducts +himself +No answer* -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +Jul 1-7, +202411 +13 -Extension +Feb 4-15, +202012 +15 -[Optional: 6 -digits, 0-9 only ] -(optional) +32 -E-mail (Required -for PM) -[Limit: one e- -mail only] -(optional) +54 -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +1 -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) -(optional) +30 -Page 36 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +53 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +3 -Section C: Life Cycle Costs +PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -1. Provide the cost summary for the investment by completing the following tables. All costs are to be provided -in millions of dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, -although agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). Federal personnel costs should be -included only in the rows designated as “… Govt. FTEs” costs and should be excluded from the other cost -breakouts. For multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing and partner -agency contributions). +Apr 25-May 1 +2018 -For PY (FY2012) and earlier, provide final obligations (actuals) as they become available. For CY (FY2013) -and BY (FY2014) provide estimated obligations for each year. For BY+1 and beyond, please provide the -estimated obligations through the end of the investments useful life (may be different from the estimated -budget authority requests). The sum of amounts for all years should reflect the estimated lifecycle cost of the -investment. As described above, the Exhibit 53 should represent the budgetary resources for CY and BY. +Aug 15-21 +2017 -For lines in the table that ask for changes in your current submission compared to your most recent previous -submission, use the President’s Budget as your previous submission. When making comparisons, ensure that -you compare same-year-to-same-year (e.g., 2012 versus 2012). +19 -Significant changes from the previous submission should be reflected in an updated investment-level -Alternatives Analysis and is subject to OMB request, as discussed in Exhibit 300.3. +26 -PY-1 & -Prior +54 -PY -2012 +2 -CY -2013 +16 -BY -2014 +25 -BY+1 -2015 +58 -BY+2 -2016 +1 -BY+3 -2017 +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +NEWPRES_SUPP -BY+4 & -Beyond +How many of Donald Trump’s policies and plans would you say you support? +[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] -Planning Costs: +Jan 20-26, +2026 +6 +22 +20 +26 +26 +1 + +All of them +Most of them +Some of them +Only a few of them +None of them +No answer* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +9 +25 +17 +23 +24 +1 + +11 -DME (Excluding Planning) -Costs: -DME (Including Planning) -Govt. FTEs: -Sub-Total DME (Including -Govt. FTE) : -O&M Costs: +12 -O&M Govt. FTEs: +In July 2024, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but about Donald Trump’s personal conduct, would +you say you…” +In February 2020, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump +conducts himself as president, would you say you…” + +www.pewresearch.org + + 26 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +NEWPRES_ACTNS + +Would you say the Trump administration's actions since taking office last year have +been... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1] + +Jan 20-26, +2026 +11 +10 +28 +15 +34 +1 + +A lot better than you expected +A little better than you expected +About what you expected +A little worse than you expected +A lot worse than you expected +No answer* + +Jun 2-8, +202513 +11 +10 +31 +17 +32 +* + +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +17 +11 +36 +12 +24 +1 -Sub-Total O&M Costs -(Including Govt. FTE): -Total Cost (Including Govt. -FTE): +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -Total Govt. FTE costs: +[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF PRESWITHOP AND OPWITHPRES SUCH THAT FORM 1 (X_FORM=1) GETS +PRESWITHOP FIRST AND OPWITHPRES SECOND WHILE FORM 2 (X_FORM=2) GETS OPWITHPRES +FIRST AND PRESWITHOP SECOND] -Number of FTE rep by -costs: +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +PRESWITHOP -Total change from PY -final President’s Budget ($) -Total change from PY -final President’s Budget (%) -Note: Do not enter information for the dark gray cells (these will be calculated). - -2.a. - -In which year did or will this investment begin? (specify year – e.g., PY-1 = 2011)? - -2.b. - -In which year will this investment reach the end of its estimated useful life? -(specify year – e.g., BY+5 = 2019) - -3. If the funding levels have changed from the FY 2012 President’s Budget request for PY - -[Limit: 500 char] - -or CY, briefly explain those changes: - -Page 37 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) - - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS - -Section D: Acquisition/Contract Strategy - -1. In the table below, provide all prime contracts (or task orders) for awarded or open solicitations for the -investment (sub-award details are not required). Completed contracts and/or task orders should not be included in -the table. Contracts in open solicitation should provide estimated data for all fields (for “Total Contract Value,” -provide the estimated base contract costs and all anticipated option years). Data definitions can be found at -www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2. +This year, do you think Donald Trump should... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN +SAME ORDER AS OPWITHPRES] -For specifics, see notes 1 and 2 below the table. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +64 -Field +33 -Data Description +2 -Contract Status -Contracting Agency ID +Try as best he can to work with Democratic congressional leaders to accomplish things, +even if it means disappointing people who voted for him +Stand up to Democratic congressional leaders on issues that are important to people who +voted for him, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country +No answer* -Procurement Instrument -Identifier (PIID) +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +63 -Modular Approaches/ -Contracting +35 -Indefinite Delivery -Vehicle (IDV) Reference -ID -IDV Agency ID +2 -Solicitation ID1 +TREND FOR COMPARISON +This year, do you think Joe Biden should… -EVM Required -Ultimate Contract -Value1 -Type of Contract/ Task -Order (Pricing) 1 +Try as best he can to work with Republican +congressional leaders to accomplish things, even if it +means disappointing some people who voted for him +Stand up to Republican congressional leaders on +issues that are important to the people who voted +for him, even if it means it’s harder to address +critical problems facing the country +No answer -Is the contract a -Performance-Based -Service Acquisition -(PBSA)?1 -Effective date1 +Jan 16-21 +2024 +74 -Actual or expected End -Date of Contract/ Task -Order1 -Extent Competed1 +Jan 18-24, +2023 +73 -(1) Awarded, (2) Pre-award, but post-solicitation -Provide the contracting agency’s ID. This is required only if the -contracting agency is different than the agency submitting the -Exhibit. Use the agency’s 4-digit code as used in FPDS. -The unique identifier for each contract, agreement, or order. See -www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about -PIIDs. -Do acquisition planning, award, and management actions apply -the principles and strategies described in “Contracting Guidance -to Support Modular Development”? [Yes/No] -Provide the IDV Reference ID. This is only required for IDVs. -See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about -IDV Reference IDs. -Provide the IDV agency ID. This is a code for an agency, but it -does not necessarily represent the agency that issued the contract. -Instead, it serves as part of the unique identification for Federal -Procurement Data System IDV records. -Provide the identifier used to link transactions to solicitation -information. See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more -information. -[Yes/No] -Enter the total value of the contract, including base and all -options. Complete using dollars to two decimal places. -Provide information about the type of contract the investment is -(e.g., fixed price, cost, cost plus, incentive, IDV, time and -materials). See FAR Part 16 for more classifications. -[Yes/No] Indicate whether the contract is a PBSA as defined by -FAR Subpart 37.601. A PBSA describes the requirements in -terms of results rather than the methods of performance of the -work. -Provide the actual or expected start date of the contract/task order -that the parties have agreed on for the contract’s requirements. -[YYYY-MM-DD] -[YYYY-MM-DD] +Jan 10-17, +2022 +67 -Choose one of the following options: (A) Full and open -competition, (B) Not available for competition, (C) Not -competed, (D) Full and open competition after exclusion of -sources, (E) Follow on to competed action, (F) Competed under -simplified acquisition procedures, (G) Not competed under -simplified acquisition procedures, (CDO) Competitive Delivery -Order, (NDO) Non-competitive Delivery Order +Jan 8-12, +202114 +74 -Optional for -Awarded -Contracts +24 -Contract/ -Task -Order +25 -Y +29 -Y +23 -Y +2 -Y +2 -Y +4 -Y +3 -Y +13 +14 -Y +Prior to January 2026, the question was worded “Would you say the Trump administration’s actions so far have been…” +In January 2021, second response option was worded as “ … on issues that are important to his supporters …”. -Y +www.pewresearch.org -Page 38 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) + 27 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Contract Description +ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]: +OPWITHPRES -A brief description of the goods or services bought (for an award) -or that are available (for an -IDV).www.usaspending.gov/learn?tab=FAQ#2 +This year, do you think Democratic congressional leaders should... [ROTATE RESPONSE +OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN SAME ORDER AS PRESWITHOP] -Y +Jan 20-26, +2026 +49 -1Assuming the PIID or IDV PIID match with www.usaspending.gov, these data elements will be automatically populated for awarded IT acquisitions. -2Assuming the PIID, IDV PIID, or solicitation number match with www.usaspending.gov or FedBizOpps (www.fbo.gov) this data will be automatically -populated for awarded, pre-awarded, and post-solicitation IT acquisitions. +49 -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement -for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why: +2 -[Limit: 2500 char] +Try as best they can to work with Donald Trump to accomplish things, even if it +means disappointing people who voted for them +Stand up to Donald Trump on issues that are important to people who voted for +them, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country +No answer* -Page 39 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +55 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +43 -Exhibit 300B: Performance Plan and Measurement Report +2 -Exhibit 300B is used to provide OMB BY 2014 and current FY 2013 investment plans and performance data. -Include in this exhibit, at a minimum, all projects, activities, and operations scheduled to commence or continue -in the CY and/or BYs. Information in Exhibit 300B is to be updated as soon as new data becomes available, but -at a minimum once per calendar month. +TREND FOR COMPARISON +This year, do you think Republican congressional leaders should… -UNDERSTANDING EXHIBIT 300B +Try as best they can to work with Joe Biden to +accomplish things, even if it means disappointing +some Republican voters +Stand up to Joe Biden on issues that are important +to Republican voters, even if it means it’s harder to +address critical problems facing the country +No answer -In Exhibit 300B, investments are described as: +Jan 16-21 +2024 +60 - +Jan 18-24, +2023 +63 -Investment +Jan 10-17, +2022 +61 -o Projects +Jan 8-12, +2021 +66 - Activities +37 -o Operations +35 -Report information about these areas in the following Exhibit 300B sections: +37 -A.1: General Information. Enter basic information about the major investment. -B.1: Projects. Identify all of the investment’s projects with activities occurring in the current FY. -B.2: Activities. Outline the activities that are performed to achieve the outcome of each project. -B.3: Project Risk. Identify significant risks to each project’s success. -C.1: Operational Performance Information. Identify performance targets for evaluating operations. -C.2: Operational Risk. Identify all significant risks to the investment achieving operational performance +3 -targets. +2 -SECTION A: GENERAL INFORMATION +2 -1. Investment Name: Agency-provided name of investment, consistent with Exhibit 53. -2. Investment UII: Agency-provided UII, consistent with Exhibit 53. +31 -SECTION B: PROJECT PLAN AND EXECUTION DATA +3 -In Tables B.1 and B.2., report, at a minimum, all projects with any activities that started in a previous FY (PY and -earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY. Also, report projects and activities that are -scheduled to start in the CY and BY, including planning, DME, and maintenance projects. Include projects and -activities commencing beyond the BY, as available. Include the following data in Table B.1: +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within the investment. -2. Project Name: Name used by the agency to refer specifically to the project. -3. Objectives/Expected Outcomes: Description of the project’s functionality, capability, or goal. -4. Project Start Date: Actual start date of in-progress projects or planned start of projects that have not yet +ASK ALL: +IMMIG_FAVOPP -begun (may be before the current FY or activities listed in Table B.2). +Thinking about immigration policy, do you favor or oppose each of the following? +[RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER +AS VEN_MADREMV] -5. Project Completion Date: Planned date of completion of in-progress projects or actual completion date -of projects that have completed (may be after BY or of completion date of activities listed in activities -Table B.2). +Strongly +favor -6. Project Life cycle Cost: Enter the total cost of all activities related to the project as described in OMB +Somewhat +favor -Circular A-131 (in $ millions). +Somewhat +oppose -7. PM Name: Name of PM responsible for the success of the project. -8. PM Level of Experience: The years of applicable experience or the status of certification for the PM. +Strongly +oppose -Available selections include: +No +answer* -1) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-3) – Senior -2) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-2) – Mid-Level -3) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-1) – Entry Level +SCMED -Page 40 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +FEE - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +ASY -4) Other certification with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years) -5) Other certification with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years) -6) Other certification with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years) -7) No certification, but with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years) -8) No certification, but with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years) -9) No certification, but with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years) +MIL -9. PM Phone: Phone number of the PM responsible for the success of the project. -10. PM E-mail: E-mail address of the PM responsible for the success of the project. +Requiring people who want to +enter the U.S. to let +immigration officers review +their social media accounts + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -ID +Giving people priority in the +immigration process if they pay +a $1 million fee + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -Name +Suspending all asylum +applications from people +seeking to live in the U.S. to +escape violence or danger + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Objectives/ -Expected -Outcomes +Maintaining a large military +presence at the U.S. border +with Mexico + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project -Start -Date +25 -Project -Completion -Date +31 -Table B.1 -Project -Life cycle -Cost +20 -PM -Name +23 -PM Level -of -Experience +5 -PM -Phone +14 -PM -Extension +20 -[10 digit] +60 -[Optional] +11 -PM E- -mail -[Limit: one -e-mail only] +21 -In Table B.2, describe, at a minimum, all activities for projects in Table B.1 that started in a previous FY (PY and -earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY, as well as activities that are scheduled to -start in the current FY and BY. In line with modular development principles, each project must produce usable -functionality at intervals of no more than six months, as described in the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform -Federal Information Technology Management. Include the following data in Table B.2: +30 -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within this investment. -2. Activity Name: A short description consistent with the critical steps within the agency project management +36 -methodology. +31 -3. Activity Description: Describe what work is accomplished by the activity. -4. Structure ID: Agency-specified identifier that indicates the work breakdown structure (WBS) the agency uses to +31 -associate the activity with other activities or a project. Provide this in the format of “x.x.x.x.x” where the first string -is the Project ID and each following string (separated by periods) matches the structure ID of a parent activity. See -below for more guidance about parent and child activities expressed through this structure. +21 -5. Key Deliverable/Usable Functionality: Indicate whether the completion of the activity provides a key deliverable +16 -or usable functionality. This should only be provided for activities that do not have a child activity. Use this field to -demonstrate the investment’s alignment with the modular development principles of the 25 Point Implementation -Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management. +2 -6. Start Date Planned: The planned start date for the activity. This is the baseline value. -7. Start Date Projected: If the activity has not yet started, enter the current planned start date of the activity. -8. Start Date Actual: When the activity starts, enter the actual start date here. -9. Completion Date Planned: The planned completion date for the activity. This is the baseline value. -10. Completion Date Projected: If the activity has not yet completed, enter the current planned completion date of the +2 -activity. +2 -11. Completion Date Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual completion date here. -12. Total Costs Planned: The planned total cost for the activity. This is the baseline value. -13. Total Costs Projected: When the activity is not yet completed, enter the current planned total cost of the activity. -14. Total Costs Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual total costs for the activity here. +1 -Note: For programs that are employing earned value management, agencies should reflect “budget at completion” in the -“Total Costs Planned” field and “estimated at completion” in the “Total Costs Projected” field for projected costs. +www.pewresearch.org -A + 28 -B +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -C +IMMIG_FAVOPP CONTINUED … -D +DTN -E +PAU75 -F +Keeping large numbers of +immigrants in detention centers +while their cases are decided + Jan 20-26, 2026 -G +Pausing visa applications from +people in 75 countries seeking +to legally immigrate to the U.S. + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Table B.2 -H +Strongly +favor -Project -ID +Somewhat +favor -Activity -Name +Somewhat +oppose -Activity -Description +Strongly +oppose -Structure -ID +No +answer* -Key Deliverable/ -Usable Functionality -[Key Deliverable, -Usable Functionality, -N/A] +14 -Start Date -Planned +21 -Start Date -Projected +24 -Start Date -Actual +40 -I -Completion -Date -Planned +16 -J -Completion -Date -Projected +23 -K +30 -L +30 -M +2 -N +2 -Completion -Date Actual +ADDITONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -Total Costs -Planned +[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT AND IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT] -Total Costs -Projected +ASK ALL: +IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT -Total Costs -Actual +Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for people to +do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN +SAME ORDER AS IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT] -Page 41 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Definitely +acceptable - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Probably +acceptable -Reporting Parent and Child Activities (WBS Structure) +Probably +unacceptable -“Child” activities may be grouped into “Parent” activities to reflect the WBS used by the agency to manage the -investment. If a WBS is not used by the agency, report the relationship between parent activities and child -activities in “Structure ID” using this method. +Definitely +unacceptable -When reporting an activity, enter the “Structure ID” as a period-delimited string consisting of the “Project ID” -and each nested parent activity between the project level and the child activity. The “Structure ID” to enter will -vary depending on the activity’s WBS level. +No +answer* -Example: For child activity 3 which is part of parent activity 10, which in turn is part of parent activity 2, which in -turn is part of Project A, enter: A.2.10.3 +VDEO - Project A +TRCK -o Parent Activity 2 +REPT - Parent Activity 10 +Record video of immigration +officers while they make arrests + Jan 20-26, 2026 - Child Activity 3 +Share information about where +immigration officers are arresting +people + Jan 20-26, 2026 -There is no limit to the number of nested “child” and “parent” relationships allowed, and this depth may vary -from activity to activity and from project to project. +Report people who they think +may be in the country illegally to +immigration officers + Jan 20-26, 2026 -If any of a parent activity's child activities occurs in the current FY, then all child activities of the parent activity -must be reported, regardless of their timing. This is to ensure that a complete view of the parent activity is -available. +48 -All activities with no child activities must have, at a minimum, Project ID, Activity Name, Activity Description, Structure ID, -Start Date Planned, Start Date Projected, Completion Date Planned, Completion Date Projected, Total Costs Planned, and -Total Costs Projected. Completed activities must also have Start Date Actual, Completion Date Actual, and Total Costs -Actual. +26 -Any parent activities with a child activity must be completely described by the aggregate attributes of its child -activities. In the IT Dashboard, the cost and schedule information for parent activities will be based on the cost -and schedule information of the lowest level of child activities reported. Agency-submitted cost and schedule -information is not required for parent activities. +13 -Project -ID +12 -A -A -A -A +35 -Activity Name -Design -Business Requirements -Technical Requirements -Architecture +24 -Structure -ID +18 -Start Date -Planned +22 -Completion -Date Planned +22 -Planned Total -Costs +30 -… +22 -A.2 -A.2.1 -A.2.2 -A.2.3 +25 -2/1/2012 -2/1/2012 -2/11/2012 -2/21/2012 +1 -2/29/2012 -2/10/2012 -2/20/2012 -2/29/2012 +1 -$2.5 -$1.0 -$1.0 -$0.5 +2 -Parent activities as highlighted are optional (Structure ID: A.2). Reported parent activities values will be ignored, as -calculated values will be determined by aggregating the cost and schedule information reported in the child activities. +www.pewresearch.org -Page 42 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) + 29 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Project Risk +ASK ALL: +IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT -Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial -concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the -investment Risk Management Plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard in conjunction with the Exhibit 300 -submission. +Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for federal +immigration officers to do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE +OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER AS IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT] -In Table B.3, list all significant project-related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and -provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the -combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following -data in Table B.3: +Definitely +acceptable -1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies a project within the investment. For +Probably +acceptable -each identified risk, list the associated Project ID. +Probably +unacceptable -2. Risk Name: A short description that identifies a risk, the cause of the risk, and the effect that the risk +Definitely +unacceptable -may have on the project. +No +answer* -3. Risk Category: Select the relevant OMB risk category for each risk. Risk categories include: 1) +MASK Wear face coverings that hide +their identities while working + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of -systems, 7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset -protection) considerations, 9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of -agency to manage the investment, 11) Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change -management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and -19) Project resources. +NGBH -4. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High +RLAN -likelihood). +Increase their presence in +neighborhoods with many +immigrants + Jan 20-26, 2026 -5. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact). -6. Mitigation Plan: A short description of the plan or steps to mitigate the identified risk. +Use a person’s looks or the +language they speak as a reason +to check their immigration status + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Project ID +CITZ -Risk Name -[Limit: 500 -char] +Arrest U.S. citizens who help +people avoid immigration officers + Jan 20-26, 2026 -Risk Category -[19 risk -categories] +21 -Table B.3 -Risk Probability +16 -Risk Impact +15 -[Low, Medium, High] +46 -[Low, Medium, High] +18 -Mitigation Plan -[char 500] +26 -Page 43 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +21 - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +33 -SECTION C: OPERATIONAL DATA +10 -Section C addresses operational activities that are not reported as a part of a project in Section B. +18 -Operational Performance -There are two essential types of operations metrics to be reported: +20 -1. Results-Specific: Provide a minimum of two metrics that measure the effectiveness of the investment in -delivering the desired service or support level. At least one metric should reflect customer results (e.g. -service quality). +23 -2. Activities or Technology-Specific: Provide a minimum of three metrics that measure the investment -against its defined process standards or technical service level agreements (e.g. Reliability and -Availability). At least one of these metrics must have a monthly reporting frequency +21 -All data will be displayed to the public on the IT Dashboard. Ensure that all provided metrics information -provided is publicly releasable. +20 -Defining a new metric +51 -When adding a new metric, such as for new investments or to provide new information about an existing -investment, use the following table. +34 -Metric ID -[Limit: -XXX char] +1 -Metric -Description -[Limit: 500 -char] +1 -Unit of -Measure -[Limit: 50 -char] +1 -Table C.1A +2 -FEA -Performance -Measurement -Category -Mapping -[PRM -Measurement -Category] +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -2012 -Target -[numeric] +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +EXPAND_GRNLND_MOD -2013 -Target -[numeric] +Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. +How likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will do this? [ROTATE +RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1 HOLDING 6 LAST] -Measurement -Condition -[Over target/ -Under target] +Jan 20-26, +2026 +8 +12 +21 +22 +17 -Reporting -Frequency -[Monthly, -Quarterly, Semi- -Annual, Annual] +Extremely likely +Very likely +Somewhat likely +Not too likely +Not at all likely -Agency -Strategic -Goals/Agency -Objective -[New PRM Code] +19 +1 -1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. When reporting actual results (see below), use +Not sure +No answer* -this ID to reference the correct metric. +Mar 24-30, +202515 +7 +16 +28 +22 +13 -2. Metric Description: Description to help the user understand what is being measured. In this field, +14 +* -describe the units used, any calculation algorithm used, and the definition or limits of the population or -“universe” measured. +15 -3. Unit of Measure: Brief indication of what quantity is measured (e.g. number, percentage, dollar value) +In the 2025 survey, question was worded “Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. How +likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will pursue this?” -for each metric. +www.pewresearch.org -4. FEA Performance Measurement Category Mapping: Indicates the PRM measurement category as + 30 -described above. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -5. 2012 Target: Metric target value from 2012 -6. 2013 Target: Metric target value for 2013 -7. Measurement Condition: Indicates whether a desired result would be “over the target” or “under the -target.” For example, if the target is to reduce the error rate to 10%, then the desired result would be -“under the target" so “under target” should be entered for measurement condition. +ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]: +EXPAND2_GRNLND -8. Reporting Frequency: How often actual measurements will be reported (monthly, quarterly, semi- +Do you favor or oppose the U.S. taking over Greenland, as Donald Trump has +proposed? [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 HOLDING 5 LAST] -annually, or annually). Annual reporting frequencies are reserved for annual operating cost measures, -performance measures associated with the agency’s annual performance plan, or other measures that can -only be appropriated measured on an annual basis. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +10 +12 +13 +45 -9. Agency Strategic Goals/Agency Objective: For annual reporting frequency metrics, agencies will be +Strongly favor +Somewhat favor +Somewhat oppose +Strongly oppose -required to provide the cross agency priority (CAP) goal; agency priority goal (APG); strategic goal (SG) -or agency objective (OBJ) associated with the metric (using the new Performance Reference Model code -use by Performance.gov). +20 +1 -Page 44 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +Not sure +No answer* - GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS +Mar 24-30, +2025 +8 +15 +12 +43 -Providing actual results: +22 +1 -As actual results are measured at the appropriate frequency, report them using the following table. Also use this -table when applicable to provide any historical actual results for a new metric (optional). +ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. Use this ID to reference the correct metric. -2. Actual Result: Actual result measured. -3. Date of Actual Result: End date of the most recent reporting period. -4. Comment: A necessary provide a comment for each actual result reported, if necessary. +ASK REPUBLICAN AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS (XPARTYSUMFINAL=1) [N=3,913]: +Which comes closer to your view, even if neither is exactly right? +REPWORKTRMP +Republicans in Congress… [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1] -When adding a new metric, include historical actual result information as available. +Jan 20-26, +2026 +38 -Metric ID -[Limit: XXX char] +61 -Table C.1B +1 -Actual -Result -[numeric] +Have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s policies and +programs because he is a Republican president +Do not have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s +policies and programs if they disagree with him +No answer* -Date of Actual -Result -[date] +Jan 27-Feb 2, +2025 +44 -Comment -[500 char] -(optional) +55 -Operational Risk +1 -Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial -concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the -investment risk management plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard. +ASK ALL: +PARTY +ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3,4 OR REFUSED): +As of today do you lean more to…16 +PARTYLN -In Table C.2, list all significant operational related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and -provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the -combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following -data in Table C.2: +In politics today, do you consider yourself a… -1. Risk Name: A short description that identifies the risk, the cause of the risk and the effect that the risk +Republican +28 -may have on the operational activity. +Democrat Independent -2. Risk Category: The relevant OMB Risk Category for each risk. Risk categories include: +26 -1) Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of systems, -7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset protection) considerations, -9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of agency to manage the investment, 11) -Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) -Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and 19) Project resources. +29 -3. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High likelihood). -4. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact). -5. Mitigation Plan: A short description of how to mitigate the risk. +Something +else +15 -Risk Name -[Limit: 500 char] +No +answer* +2 -Risk Category -[19 risk categories] +Lean +Rep +18 -Table C.2 -Risk Probability -[Low, Medium, High] +Lean +Dem +21 -Risk Impact -[Low, Medium, High] +16 -Mitigation Plan -[Limit: 500 char] +PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey. -Page 45 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012) +www.pewresearch.org diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_3.md b/q0/random_k4/random_3.md index 8f865df3772bc41afe1f8a2c8625c0b0956ae175..327782fda9cc6dd0e3c846808abb7a84285c7afc 100644 --- a/q0/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q0/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,2302 +1,1336 @@ -LINC: A Neurosymbolic Approach for Logical Reasoning by Combining -| | | Language | | Models | with | First-Order | | Logic | Provers | | | -| ---------------- | -------------------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| TheoX.Olausson*1 | | | | AlexGu*1 | BenjaminLipkin*2 | | | | CedegaoE.Zhang*2 | | | -| | ArmandoSolar-Lezama1 | | | | JoshuaB.Tenenbaum1,2 | | | | RogerLevy2 | | | -| | | | {theoxo, | gua, | lipkinb, | cedzhang}@mit.edu | | | | | | -1MITCSAIL2MITBCS -∗Equalcontribution. -| | | Abstract | | | | 1 Introduction | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | Widespread | adoption | | of | large language | models | -| Logical | reasoning, | i.e., | deductively | inferring | | | | | | | | -the truth value of a conclusion from a set of (LLMs)suchasGPT-3(Brownetal.,2020),GPT- -4202 beF 41 ]LC.sc[ 2v46151.0132:viXra -| | | | | | | 4 (OpenAI, | 2023), | | and PaLM | (Chowdhery | et al., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | -premises,isanimportanttaskforartificialin- -telligencewithwidepotentialimpactsonsci- 2022)haveledtoaseriesofremarkablesuccesses -ence, mathematics, and society. While many in tasks ranging from text summarization to pro- -prompting-basedstrategieshavebeenproposed gramsynthesis. Someofthesesuccesseshaveen- -toenableLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)to -couragedthehypothesisthatsuchmodelsareable -| dosuchreasoningmoreeffectively, | | | | theystill | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -toflexiblyandsystematicallyreason(Huangand -| appear | unsatisfactory, | | often failing | in subtle | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -and unpredictable ways. In this work, we Chang, 2022), especially when using prompting -strategiesthatexplicitlyencourageverbalizingin- -| investigate | the | validity | of instead | reformulat- | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingsuchtasksasmodularneurosymbolicpro- termediate reasoning steps before generating the -LINC: -gramming, which we call Logical In- final answer (Nye et al., 2021; Wei et al., 2022; -ference via Neurosymbolic Computation. In Kojimaetal.,2022;Wangetal.,2023b). However, -LINC,theLLMactsasasemanticparser,trans- -thisreasoningabilityappearstobeunreliablefor -latingpremisesandconclusionsfromnatural -tasksthatrequirereasoningoutofdomain(Liang -| language | to | expressions | in first-order | | logic. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------- | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | et al., 2022; | Saparov | | et al., | 2023), understanding | | -Theseexpressionsarethenoffloadedtoanex- -| | | | | | | negation | (Anil | et al., | 2022), | and following | long | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -ternaltheoremprover,whichsymbolicallyper- -formsdeductiveinference. Leveragingthisap- reasoningchains(Dzirietal.,2023). Furthermore, -proach, we observe significant performance whilethestandardapproachof“scalingup”seems -gains on FOLIO and a balanced subset of toimproveperformanceacrosssomereasoningdo- -ProofWriterforthreedifferentmodelsinnearly mains,otherdomains,e.g.,reasoninginvolvinguse -| all experimental | | conditions | we | evaluate. | On | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | of Modus | Tollens, | | show | no such improvements | | -| ProofWriter, | | augmenting | the | comparatively | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | (McKenzie | et | al., 2022). | | These findings | suggest | -smallopen-sourceStarCoder+(15.5Bparame- -| | | | | | | that such | models | may | be | relying on approximate | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -ters)withLINCevenoutperformsGPT-3.5and -GPT-4withChain-of-Thought(CoT)prompt- heuristicsbasedonsurface-levelstatisticalpatterns -ing by an absolute 38% and 10%, respec- in reasoning tasks, rather than consistent, gener- -tively. When used with GPT-4, LINC scores alizablerepresentationsandstrategies(Srivastava -CoT -26% higher than on ProofWriter while etal.,2023;Creswelletal.,2023). -performingcomparativelyonFOLIO.Further -| | | | | | | At the | same | time, | the ability | to accurately | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ----- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -analysisrevealsthatalthoughbothmethodson -soundlyperformlogicalreasoningisimportantfor -averagesucceedroughlyequallyoftenonthis -dataset,theyexhibitdistinctandcomplemen- AIandNLPduetoitsimpactondownstreamtasks. -taryfailuremodes. Wethusprovidepromising For example: retrieval-augmented chatbots may -evidenceforhowlogicalreasoningovernatural becomemoretruthfulifitcanbeverifiedthattheir -languagecanbetackledthroughjointlylever- -answerslogicallyfollowfromtheretrievedfacts; -| agingLLMsalongsidesymbolicprovers. | | | | | All | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --------- | -| | | | | | | data-driven | models | | capable | of logical | reasoning | -correspondingcodeispubliclyavailable.1 -| | | | | | | may speed | up | progress | across | mathematics | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | the sciences | through | | automated | theorem | proving | -∗ -Authororderrandomized;allreservetherighttolist -andknowledgediscovery;andAItutoringsystems -theirnamefirst. -https://github.com/benlipkin/linc which ensure internal logical consistency might -1 +| | | | Fact | or Fiction: | Verifying | Scientific | | Claims | | | | | +| --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | DavidWadden†∗ | | | ShanchuanLin† | | KyleLo‡ | | LucyLuWang‡ | | | | | +| | MadeleinevanZuylen‡ | | | | ArmanCohan‡ | | HannanehHajishirzi†‡ | | | | | | +† UniversityofWashington,Seattle,WA,USA +‡ +AllenInstituteforArtificialIntelligence,Seattle,WA,USA +{dwadden,linsh,hannaneh}@cs.washington.edu +{kylel,lucyw,madeleinev,armanc}@allenai.org +Abstract +Claim +We introduce scientific claim verification, a Cardiac injury is common in +new task to select abstracts from the re- critical cases of COVID-19. +searchliteraturecontainingevidencethatSUP- +| PORTS | or REFUTES | | a given | scientific | claim, | | | | Fact-checker | | | | +| ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Corpus +| and to | identify | rationales | | justifying | each de- | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | Decision: | | SUPPORTS | | +| cision. | To study | this | task, | we construct | SCI- | | | | | | | | +More severe COVID-19 infection +| FACT, | a dataset | of | 1.4K expert-written | | scien- | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | | is associated with higher | | | | mean | +| tific claims | | paired | with evidence-containing | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | troponin | | (SMD 0.53, 95% CI 0.30 | | | +abstracts annotated with labels and rationales. to 0.75, p < 0.001) +| WedevelopbaselinemodelsforSCIFACT,and | | | | | | | | | | Rationale | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ----------- | --- | +| demonstrate | | that | simple domain | | adaptation | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Figure | 1: A scientific | | claim, | supported | by evidence | | +techniquessubstantiallyimproveperformance +compared to models trained on Wikipedia or identifiedbyoursystem. Tocorrectlyverifythisclaim, +| | | | | | | the system | must | possess | background | | knowledge | that | +| --------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | +| political | news. | We | show | that our | system is | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | troponin | is a protein | found | in | cardiac | muscle and | that | +| able to | verify | claims | related | to COVID-19 | by | | | | | | | | +identifying evidence from the CORD-19 cor- elevated levels of troponin are a marker of cardiac +| | | | | | | injury. | In addition, | it | must be | able to | reason about | di- | +| ---- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | +| pus. | Our experiments | | indicate | that | SCIFACT | | | | | | | | +will provide a challenging testbed for the de- rectionalrelationshipsbetweenscientificprocesses: re- +| | | | | | | placing | higher | with | lower would | cause | the rationale | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | +velopmentofnewsystemsdesignedtoretrieve +| | | | | | | to REFUTE | theclaimratherthan | | | SUPPORT | it. | Finally, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | +andreasonovercorporacontainingspecialized +domain knowledge. Data and code for this thesystemshouldinterpret p<0.001asanindication +thatthereportedfindingisstatisticallysignificant. +| new task | are | publicly | available | at | https:// | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| github.com/allenai/scifact. | | | | | A leader- | | | | | | | | +| board | and | COVID-19 | fact-checking | | demo | | | | | | | | +are available at https://scifact.apps. Fact-checking – a task in which the veracity +allenai.org. +| | | | | | | of an input | claim | is | verified | against | a corpus | of | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | documents | that | support | or | refute | the claim | – has | +1 Introduction +beenstudiedtocombattheproliferationofmisin- +Due to rapid growth in the scientific literature, it formationinpoliticalnews, socialmedia, andon +is difficult for researchers – and the general pub- the web (Thorne et al., 2018; Hanselowski et al., +2019). However,verifyingscientificclaimsposes +licevenmoreso–tostayuptodateonthelatest +findings. Thischallengeisespeciallyacuteduring new challenges to both dataset construction and +publichealthcriseslikethecurrentCOVID-19pan- effectivemodeling. Whilepoliticalclaimsareread- +ilyavailableonfact-checkingwebsitesandcanbe +demic,duetotheextremelyfastrateatwhichnew +findingsarereportedandtherisksassociatedwith verifiedbycrowdworkers,annotatorswithexten- +makingdecisionsbasedonoutdatedorincomplete sive domain knowledge are required to generate +andverifyscientificclaims. +| information. | As | a result, | there | is a need | for auto- | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +matedtoolstoassistresearchersandthepublicin In addition, NLP systems for scientific claim +evaluatingtheveracityofscientificclaims. verificationmustpossessadditionalcapabilitiesbe- +| | | | | | | yond those | required | | to verify | factoid | claims. | For | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | +∗WorkperformedduringinternshipwiththeAllenInsti- +tuteforArtificialIntelligence. instance,toverifytheclaimshowninFigure1,a +7534 +Proceedingsofthe2020ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages7534–7550, +November16–20,2020.(cid:13)c2020AssociationforComputationalLinguistics -Input -| Step 1: | | | | Premise: | All rectangles have four sides. | | | | | | | Output | -| -------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -| Semantic | | | | Premise: | All four-sided things are shapes. | | | | | | | | -True -| Parser | | | | Conclusion: | Are all rectangles shapes? | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | Sample 1 | | | | Sample 1 | | | - all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x)) - all x. (foursides(x) -> isshape(x)) -| | all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x)) | | | | | | | Step 2: | | True | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -Step 3: -Logic -K-Maj -| | | | | | | Sample 2 | | Theorem | | Sample 2 | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | - all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x)) Voting - all x. (foursides(x) -> isshape(x))) Prover Error - all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x)) -| | | | | | | Sample 3 | | | | Sample 3 | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | - all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursidedthings(x)) -| | all x. (foursidedthings(x) -> isshape(x)) | | | | | | | | | True | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | - all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x)) -| | | | | | | Sample N | | | | Sample N | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | - all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x)) - all x. (foursidedthings(x) -> isshape(x)) Unknown - all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x)) -Figure 1: This figure showcases the essence of our approach. Starting from a problem in natural language, in -Step1,theLLMsemanticparsersampleslogicformulasexpressingestimatesofthesemantics. Itispossiblethat -someofthesemightcontainerrors,e.g.,thesecondexampleshowsasyntaxerrorinvolvinganextraparenthesis, -whereasthefourthexamplehighlightsasemanticerrorcausedbymismatchedpredicates. InStep2,thesearethen -eachoffloadedtoanautomatedtheoremprover,filteringoutsyntaxerrors,andproducinglabelsfortheremaining -samples. InStep3,theremainingcandidateoutputsarepassedthroughamajority-votesievetoarriveatthebest -estimateforasingleoutputlabel. -make for better educational platforms, teaching thesolverastray,leadingtoanincorrectconclusion. -studentstothinkmoreclearlyandrigorously. The Asitisnotclearwhetherthetaskofformalization -questionofhowtoenablestate-of-the-artLLMsto ismoreorlessdifficultthanthatofend-to-endnat- -becomemorereliablelogicalreasonersisthusone ural language reasoning, our core interest in this -ofgreatimportance,withfar-reachingimplications. work is to compare and contrast our neurosym- -bolicapproachtoexistingreasoningstrategieslike -| In | this | work, | we analyze | LINC: | Logical | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Chain-of-Thought. | | | Our contributions | | are thus | -InferenceviaNeurosymbolicComputation(Fig.1). -| LINC, | | | | | | | three-fold: | | | | | | -| ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| In | logical | reasoning | | is tackled | through | a | | | | | | | -modular, two-step neurosymbolic process. First, • First,weproposeLINC,atwo-stageneurosym- -thelanguagemodelconvertsthenaturallanguage bolic approach for logical reasoning tasks -| premises | and | desired | conclusion | into | first-order | | (Sec.2). | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | ------ | --------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------ | -------------- | -| logic(FOL)expressions(Enderton,2001;Barker- | | | | | | | | | | LINC | | | -| | | | | | | | • Second, | | we compare | | to | three baseline | -| Plummer | et | al., 2011). | Second, | a symbolic | | FOL | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | LLM | strategies | | (Fig. 2), | across | three mod- | -| theorem | prover | algorithmically | | determines | | the | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | els | (StarCoder+, | | GPT-3.5, | GPT-4) | and two | -truthvalueoftheconclusiongiventheformalized -| | | | | | | | datasets | | (FOLIO | and ProofWriter) | | (Sec. 4). | -| --------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | --------- | -| premises. | Inpractice,wealsoincorporateathird | | | | | | | | | | | | -WefindthatLINCsignificantlyimprovesper- -| majority | voting | step, | which | is shown | to improve | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -formanceovereverybaselineinallexperimen- -LINCisanaturalextensionofrecent -performance. -talconditionsexceptforGPT-4onFOLIO. -workaugmentinglanugagemodelswithsymbolic -tools such as calculators or interpreters (Schick • Third,weprovideathorougherroranalysisof -| | | | | | | | | LINC | Chain-of-Thought, | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| etal.,2023). | | | | | | | both | | and | | | identify- | -LINChasakeyadvantage: ingthreehigh-levelfailuremodesofeach. We -thelanguagemodel -discoverthatthesefailuremodesaredistinct, -itselfnolongerneedstoperformanydeductiverea- -highlightingthepotentialforasynergyofthe -| soning, | which | is offloaded | | to the theorem | prover. | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -twomethods(Sec.5). -| However, | therearealsocleardrawbacks: | | | | thefor- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -malization from natural language to first-order Overall, we present strong evidence for the po- -logic must perfectly capture all relevant informa- tentialoffutureneurosymboliclogicalreasoning -tioncontainedinthepremises,andanylossofin- systemsbasedonintegratinglanguagemodelsand -| formationintheformalizationproceduremaylead | | | | | | | theoremprovers. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Claim1:Lopinavir/ritonavirhaveexhibitedfavorableclinicalresponseswhenusedasatreatmentforcoronavirus. +Supports:...Interestingly,afterlopinavir/ritonavir(Kaletra,AbbVie)wasadministered,β-coronavirusviralloadssignificantly +decreasedandnoorlittlecoronavirustiterswereobserved. +Refutes:Thefocuseddrugrepurposingofknownapproveddrugs(suchaslopinavir/ritonavir)hasbeenreportedfailedfor +curingSARS-CoV-2infectedpatients.Itisurgenttogeneratenewchemicalentitiesagainstthisvirus... +Claim2:Thecoronaviruscannotthriveinwarmerclimates. +Supports:...mostoutbreaksdisplayapatternofclusteringinrelativelycoolanddryareas...Thisisbecausetheenvironment +canmediatehuman-to-humantransmissionofSARS-CoV-2,andunsuitableclimatescancausethevirustodestabilizequickly... +Refutes: ...significantcasesinthecomingmonthsarelikelytooccurinmorehumid(warmer)climates,irrespectiveofthe +climate-dependenceoftransmissionandthatsummertemperatureswillnotsubstrantiallylimitpandemicgrowth. +Table1: EvidenceidentifiedbyoursystemassupportingandrefutingtwoclaimsconcerningCOVID-19. +system must have the ability to access scientific CORD-19corpus(Wangetal.,2020). Expertanno- +backgroundknowledge,reasonoverincreasesand tatorsjudgeretrievedevidencetobeplausiblefor +23of36claims.1 +decreasesinquantitiesormeasurements,andmake Ourresultsandanalysesdemon- +senseofspecializedstatisticallanguage. stratetheimportanceofthenewtaskanddatasetto +In this paper, we introduce the task of scien- supportsignificantfutureresearchinthisdomain. +tific claim verification to evaluate the veracity of Insummary,ourcontributionsinclude: (1)We +scientific claims against a scientific corpus. Ta- introduceandformalizethescientificclaimverifi- +ble 1 presents some examples. To facilitate re- cation task. (2) We develop a novel annotation +search on this task, we construct SCIFACT, an protocol to generate and verify 1.4K naturally- +expert-annotateddatasetof1,409scientificclaims occurringclaimsaboutscientificfindings. (3)We +accompanied by abstracts that support or refute establish strong baselines on this task, and iden- +eachclaim,andannotatedwithrationales(Leietal., tify substantial opportunities for improvement at +2016)justifyingeachSUPPORTS/REFUTESdeci- allstagesofthemodelingpipeline. (4)Wedemon- +sion. Tocreatethedataset,wedevelopanovelan- stratetheefficacyofoursysteminareal-worldcase +notationprotocolinwhichannotatorsre-formulate studyverifyingclaimsaboutCOVID-19againstthe +| naturallyoccurringclaimsinthescientificliterature | | | | | | researchliterature. | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +–citationsentences–intoatomicscientificclaims. +| | | | | | | 2 Backgroundandtaskdefinition | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Usingcitationsentencesasasourceofclaimsboth +speedstheclaimgenerationprocessandguarantees +| | | | | | | As illustrated | in Figure | 1, | scientific claim | verifi- | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | +| thatthetopicsdiscussedin | | | SCIFACTarerepresen- | | | | | | | | +cationisthetaskofidentifyingevidencefromthe +| tativeoftheresearchliterature. | | | Inaddition,citation | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | researchliteraturethat | | SUPPORTS | or | REFUTES a | +linksindicatetheexactdocumentslikelytocontain +| | | | | | | given scientific | claim. | Table | 1 shows | the results | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ----------- | +evidencenecessarytoverifyagivenclaim. +| | | | | | | of our system | applied | to | claims about | the novel | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | +WeestablishperformancebaselinesonSCIFACT +| | | | | | | coronavirus | COVID-19. | | For each claim, | the sys- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | -------- | +withanapproachsimilartoDeYoungetal.(2020a), +temidentifiesrelevantscientificabstracts,andla- +whichachievesstrongperformanceontheFEVER +| | | | | | | bels the | relation of | each | abstract to the | claim as | +| ------------------------------------------- | ------------- | ------ | ----- | --------- | --- | ------------------------ | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | -------- | +| claimverificationdataset(Thorneetal.,2018). | | | | | Our | | | | | | +| | | | | | | eitherSUPPORTSorREFUTES. | | | Verifyingscientific | | +| baseline | is a pipeline | system | which | retrieves | ab- | | | | | | +claimsischallengingandrequiresdomain-specific +| stracts | related | to an input | claim, uses | a | BERT- | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +backgroundknowledge–forinstance,inorderto +based(Devlinetal.,2019)sentenceselectortoiden- +| | | | | | | identify | the evidence | supporting | Claim | 1 in Ta- | +| -------------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | ----- | -------- | +| tify rationale | sentences, | | and labels | each abstract | | | | | | | +ble1,thesystemmustdeterminethatareductionin +| as SUPPORTS, | REFUTES,or | | NOINFO | withrespect | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +coronavirusviralloadindicatesafavorableclinical +| to the claim. | We | demonstrate | that | our baseline | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +response,eventhoughthisfactisnevermentioned. +canbenefitfromtrainingonclaimsfromdomains +| | | | | | | ScientificclaimsIn | | SCIFACT,ascientificclaimis | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | +includingWikipediaarticlesandpolitics. +We showcase the ability of our model to ver- anatomicverifiablestatementexpressingafinding +| ify expert-written | | claims | concerning | the | novel | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1Weemphasizethatourmodelisaresearchprototypeand +coronavirusCOVID-19againstthenewly-released shouldnotbeusedtomakeanymedicaldecisionswhatsoever. +7535 -| 2 LINC:LogicalInferencevia | | | | | | 3 Experiments | | | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -NeurosymbolicComputation -Inthissection,wepresentourexperimentalsetup, -themodelsweuse,andthethreebaselinestowhich -| Ourneurosymbolicapproachtoend-to-endlogical | | | | | | wecompareLINC. | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| reasoningconsistsoftwostages. | | | | Inthefirststage, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Datasets: | | Ourexperimentsusetasksfromtwo | | | | | -theLLMactsasasemanticparser,translatingNL -| | | | | | | existing | datasets: | FOLIO | (Han | et | al., 2022) | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | -statementsintoFOLexpressionsinoursupported -ProofWriter(Tafjordetal.,2021),bothofwhich -| logiclanguage. | Inthesecondstage,theseexpres- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -havebeenshowntobechallengingforoff-the-shelf -| sions are | parsed | from | the text | generated | by the | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --------------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | LLMs(Hanetal.,2022;Creswelletal.,2023). | | | | | | FO- | -| LLM and | then get | passed | to | an automated | theo- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | LIO is | an expert-written, | | open-domain, | | logically | | -remprover;weuseProver9,ahigh-performance -complexanddiversedatasetfornaturallanguage -| prover widely | used | in | the logic | community | (Mc- | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | reasoning | with | first-order | logic. | We | use | its val- | -| Cune, 2005–2010). | | The | external | solver | then ex- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | idation | set for | our evaluation. | | However, | | of the | -ecutesasymbolicdeductionalgorithm,whichei- -204samplesinthevalidationset,wediscoverthat -| ther returns | a value | from | the | set {True, | False, | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -22haveerrors(detailsinAppendixC),leavingus -Uncertain}orraisesanexceptionduetoimproper -| | | | | | | with182examplesforourevaluation. | | | | | ProofWriter, | | -| ---------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -| FOL syntax | (e.g., | if the | model | fails | to balance | | | | | | | | -meanwhile,isasyntheticallygenerateddatasetfor -paranthesesintheformulae). -| | | | | | | logical | reasoning | over | natural | language. | | For our | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -Atitscore,thestrengthofthisapproachliesin evaluation,weusetheOWA(Open-WorldAssump- -the reformulation of the problem space. End-to- tion)portionofProofWriter,sincethissettingbest -endNL-basedreasoningallowsforoperationover -| | | | | | | matches | that | of FOLIO. | Since | we | are running | a | -| -------- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| a highly | flexible | expression | space, | but | leaves the | | | | | | | | -largenumberofexperiments,werandomlyselect -LLMwiththedifficulttaskofperformingexplicit 360 data points to evaluate on in order to reduce -deductiveinferenceoverexpressionsinthisspace. costs. Wesampletheseinsuchawaythatthere- -| Using LINC, | we | instead | trade | off the | flexible ex- | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -sultingdatasetisbalancedacrossboththenumber -pressionspaceofNLforsyntacticallystrictlogic ofreasoningstepsintheshortestgroundtruthproof -formulas, allowing us to leverage symbolic algo- (depth0-5;50sampleseach)andacrossthethree -rithmswithprovableguaranteesthatthedeductive labels(True/False/Uncertain;120sampleseach; -chainswillbecorrectwithrespecttothesemantics -20eachperdepth). -oftheintermediaterepresentation. Makingeffec- In-contextlearningexamples: Wehand-pick -tiveuseofthisreformulationthusrequiresthelogic eight diverse samples from the FOLIO training -expressionsgeneratedbytheLLMtobe1)syntac- -| | | | | | | set to be | used | as few-shot | | in-context | examples. | | -| -------------- | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -| tically valid, | such | that | they are | accepted | by the | | | | | | | | -BecauseProofWriterdoesnotcomewithground -prover, and 2) semantically valid, such that their truthFOLstatements,weusetheseeightsamples -| evaluationresultsinthecorrectconclusion. | | | | | Inour | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | for both | evaluations. | | Compared | to | FOLIO, | ques- | -experiments,wemitigatetheserisksbyusingaK- -tionsinProofWritergenerallyhavemorepremises -waymajorityvotingprocedure,whichisdiscussed per question (in our validation sets: an average -furtherinSec.3. -| | | | | | | of 5.3 in | FOLIO | vs. | 18.8 in | ProofWriter). | | Thus, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | -The significance of this problem space refor- ourevaluationonFOLIOisanin-distributiontask, -whereasProofWriterrequiresgeneralizingout-of- -mulationcan—beyondthenumericalincreasesin -performance observed across our experiments— distributiontoreasoningoverconsiderablylarger -perhapsbestbeseenthroughanin-depthcompari- setsofpremisesthanaregivenintheprompt. -sonofhowLINCandtraditionalend-to-endLLM -| | | | | | | Majority | | voting: | K-way | majority | voting, | in | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------------- | ------- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -| reasoningapproachessuchasChain-of-Thought | | | | | | whichK | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | samplesaretakeni.i.d. | | | fromthemodel | | | -(CoT)fail. Toforeshadowourlatteranalysis,we and the mode is used as the final prediction, has -CoT, LINC -find that compared to has worse recall previouslybeenshowntoimprovetheperformance -butbetterprecisiononTrue/Falsepredictions. -| | | | | | We | ofprompting-basedstrategiesinlogicalreasoning | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -discussthisfurtherinSec.5andhighlightthatthis tasks (Wang et al., 2023b). We implement such -suggeststhatLINC,aswellasneurosymboliccom- a strategy in our work, with reported accuracies -putationmoregenerally,hasthepotentialtoreduce reflectingK=10-waymajorityvoting,unlessoth- -LLMoverconfidenceandhallucination. erwise stated. In the case of ties between two la- - -All rectangles have four sides. -All four-sided things are shapes. -Are all rectangles shapes? -* N ICL -Examples -⧺ -< A < E N / V S E A W V L E A U R L A : U T A E T T > r E u > e Naïve < N F N F N F A < E L O L O L O N / V : L : L : L S E A : : : W V L E A U R L A A a A a A a : U T l l l l r l A E l l l l e l T T > r E r x f x a x u > e . o . l . e c u l t ( r ( ( a r f r - r n e o e e s g c u c c i l t r t t d e a s a a e s n i n n d g d g g h l e l l t a e s e e h v ( ( ( s i e x x x n ) ) ) g s f s h o a - - - u a p > > > r r e e s f i i s ? o s s S i s u s s c d h r h h r e a s a a s p i p p a . e d e e t s e ( ( c . s x x h ( ) ) x ) ) p ) a ) d < S s a m A < E i i r u N / V n d e s S E A c e t W V L e s s E A U , h b R L A a a e : U T l a p A E l n e s T T > d s h r E r , a u > e a p e c l t e t l h s a e , n f n g o s l u a o e r l - s l T s r i h r u d a e e e v c ! d e t a t f n h o g i u l n r e C g s o s T < N F N F N F < E L O L O L O / V : L : L : L E A : : : V L A U L A A a A a A a U T l l l l r l A E l l l l e l T > E r x f x a x > e . o . l . c u l t ( r ( ( a r f r - r n e o e e s g c u c c i l t r t t d e a s a a e s n i n n d g d g g h l e l l t a e s e e h v ( ( ( s i e x x x n ) ) ) g s f s h o a - - - u a p > > > r r e e s f i i s ? o s s i s u s s d h r h h e a s a a s p i p p . e d e e s e ( ( L . s x x I ( ) ) N x ) ) C ) ) -⧺ -All dogs are mammals. ⧺ = string concatenation -Harry is a dog. -Is Harry a mammal? - -… -Figure 2: This figure outlines the string concatenation workflow for each of our conditions. We start with the -originalproblem,provideICLexamplesthroughanintermediatemarkuplanguage,andfinallyappendtheproblem -toevaluate. Atthisstage,weallowthemodeltoautoregressivelysampleuntilproducingastoptoken. -bels, we arbitrarily select the first of the two to IntheScratchpadbaseline(Nyeetal.,2021),the -have been generated. We report the effect of K model is asked to first generate FOL expressions -onperformanceacrossourconditionsandbriefly correspondingtothepremises,andthengenerate -discusstrendsinAppendixH. thelabel. ThisbaselineisthusanablationofLINC, -Models: We use three models pre-trained on -whereweusetheLLMinsteadofProver9asthe -bothnaturallanguageandcode: GPT-3.5(Ouyang logicsolver. Finally,intheCoTbaseline,weusethe -et al., 2022), GPT-42 (OpenAI, 2023), and Star- standard technique of CoT prompting (Wei et al., -Coder+3 (Lietal.,2023)withadecodingtemper- 2022; Kojima et al., 2022; Wang et al., 2023b), -ature of T = 0.8 for all experiments. We defer wherethemodelisaskedtogeneratestep-by-step -model,hyperparameter,andhardwaredetailstoAp- naturallanguagereasoningtoarriveattheconclu- -pendixB.WeoptforStarCoder+forthreereasons: sion. The prompts we use for all approaches can -firstly,unliketheothermodelsweconsider,itisa befoundinAppendixD. -free,open-accessmodel. Secondly,ithasadataset -4 Results&Discussion -search functionality4, with which we verify that -FOLIOandProofWriterarenotinStarCoder+’s -OurmainresultsareshowninFigure3. Eachbar -trainingset,givingfurtherassuranceinthevalidity representseitherLINCoroneofthethreebaselines, -ofourfindings. Thirdly,withits15.5Bparameters while each group of bars indicates the language -itislikelyconsiderablysmallerthanGPT-3.5and modelused(in{StarCoder+,GPT-3.5,GPT-4}). -GPT-45, allowing us to compare performance at WenotefirstthatintheFOLIOdomain(Figure -differentmodelscales. 3a), StarCoder+—the smallest model we experi- -Controlled baselines: We compare LINC to ment with—benefits the most from LINC, achiev- -threebaselines,whichwecallNaïve,Scratchpad, -ingameanaccuracythatis14.2pointshigherthan -and Chain-of-Thought (CoT), as illustrated in the closest controlled baseline (56.0% vs. 41.8% -Fig. 2. In the Naïve baseline, the model is given with CoT). We find that Scratchpad, where the -the natural language premises and is asked to di- intermediate logical formulae are still generated -rectlygeneratethelabel(True/False/Uncertain). -but the call to the symbolic solver is ablated and -replacedbythemodel’sownprediction,doesnot -2Weusegpt-3.5-turbo-16k-0613andgpt-4-0613. -appeartobenefitperformance;forStarCoder+,nei- -3https://huggingface.co/bigcode/starcoderplus -ther Scratchpad nor the Naïve baseline perform -4See https://huggingface.co/spaces/bigcode/ -in-the-stack and https://huggingface.co/spaces/ betterthansimplydeterministicallypredictingthe -bigcode/search. mostcommonlabel(“Uncertain”). ForGPT-3.5, -5Although the exact size of these models has not been thetrendissimilar,althoughthegapbetweenLINC -madepublic,theircommonpredecessorGPT-3wasknownto -have175Bparameters;seeBrownetal.(2020). andtheclosestbaselineshrinks(62.6%vs. 54.9% - -| 100% | | | | | | 100% | | | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | ---------- | ---------------- | ----------- | -| | Naive | | Chain-of-Thought | | | | Naive | Chain-of-Thought | 96.4% 98.3% | -| | Scratchpad | | LINC (ours) | | | | Scratchpad | LINC (ours) | | -| 80% | | | | 75.3% | | 80% | | 82.5% | | -| | | | | 69.8%68.7% | 72.5% | | | | 72.2% | -62.6% -| 60% | | 56.0% | 54.9% | | | 60% | | | 53.1% 55.8% | -| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -48.4%47.8% -| | | 41.8% | | | | | | 43.6% | | -| --- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | 37.8%38.1%38.6% | 36.4% | | -| 40% | 34.6%32.4% | | | | | 40% | | 33.1% | | -| 20% | | | | | | 20% | | | | -| | StarCoder+ | | GPT-3.5 | GPT-4 | | | StarCoder+ | GPT-3.5 | GPT-4 | -| | | | (a)FOLIO. | | | | | (b)ProofWriter. | | -Figure3: ResultsofeachmodelontheFOLIOandProofWriterdatasets. Accuraciesareforbootstrapped10-way -majorityvoteforallmodels. Errorbarsare±1bootstrappedstandarddeviation. Dotted,blacklineistheaccuracy -obtainedbyalwaysguessingthemostcommonlabelinthedataset. -averageaccuracies). ForGPT-4,thetrendreverses: tionofthenecessaryproofdepthinFigure4. We -LINC underperforms CoT. However, we perform notefirstthatStarCoder+’sperformanceremains -a McNemar’s test (McNemar, 1947) to get the p- flatandclosetochancewithallthreebaselinemeth- -| | | | LINC | CoT | | | Meanwhile,withLINCtheperfor- | | | -| ----- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | -| value | on | this GPT-4 | vs. | comparison, | | ods(Figure4a). | | | | -and we find that the difference is not significant manceremainsfarabovechance,althoughitdrops -(p = 0.58). Meanwhile,forourbalancedsubsetof somewhatasnecessaryproofdepthincreases;this -ProofWriter,weseesignificantperformancegains performancedropsuggeststhatStarCoder+strug- -across the board (Figure 3b); particularly so for glessomewhatwiththeNL-to-FOLtranslationtask -GPT-3.5andGPT-4,whichachievemeanaccura- as the problem at hand gets larger. For GPT-3.5, -ciesof96.4%and98.3%whenpairedwithLINC. allbaselinesperformabovechanceatproofdepth -In light of the high accuracies obtained with 0 (i.e., where the conclusion can immediately be -LINC on ProofWriter, we offer two plausible rea- reachedfromthepremises),butthenquicklydrop -sons why LINC is particularly favorable on this backdown(Figure4b). WhileChain-of-Thought -dataset. Firstly,ProofWriteris—unlikeFOLIO— prompting allows the model to complete some -completelysyntheticallygenerated,withrelatively depth-1 tasks, even this strategy then performs -shortsentences,perhapslendingitselfparticularly equivalentlytochance(within1standarddeviation) -LINC, -well to being formalized in FOL. However, it is for higher depths. When augmented with -Scratchpad -noteworthy that the mode does not however, GPT-3.5 is able to achieve near-perfect -seemtoimproveperformanceovertheNaïvebase- performanceacrossallproofdepths,providingevi- -line, indicating that even if the NL-to-FOL task denceforthescalabilityofthisapproachtolonger -were particularly easy in this domain, this is not deductive chains. Finally, for GPT-4 we observe -somethingthatthemodelisitselfcapableoflever- muchstrongerperformancefromthebaselines;in -agingtoimproveitspredictions. Thesecondreason particular,CoTperformsabovechanceforallproof -mightbethatthebaselinestrategiesstruggleinthis depths,andallbaselinesperformwellforshallow -out-of-distributionsetting,inwhichthemodelmust proofs(Figure4c). However,evenwithGPT-4the -generalizetoalargersetofpremises(withpoten- performance drops as the necessary proof depth -tiallylongerdeductivechains)thanthosefoundin increaseswitheveryconfigurationexceptforLINC, -theprompt. Thisdistributionshiftmakesitharder whichperformsnearoratceilingthroughthemax- -imumproofdepthavailableinthedataset. -forthemodeltoignoreirrelevantpremisesinthe -| question | and | carry | out all deductive | chains | cor- | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ----- | ----------------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Meanwhile,withLINC,thesymbolicsolver -| rectly. | | | | | | 5 ErrorAnalysis | | | | -| -------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| robustly | handles | irrelevant | premises | and | long de- | | | | | -ductivechains,sincetheLLMonlyneedstotrans- HavingestablishedthatLINCcanimproveperfor- -lateeachsentenceintoFOL. mance in many settings, we now move on to our -Totestthislastexplanationfurther,weploteach finalresearchquestion: Howdothefailuremodes -model’sperformanceacrossProofWriterasafunc- of LINCcomparetothoseofin-contextreasoning - -| 1.0 | | | | 1.0 | | | | | 1.0 | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 0.8 | | | | 0.8 | | | | | 0.8 | | | | | -| ycaruccA | | | | ycaruccA | | | | | ycaruccA | | | | | -| 0.6 | | | | 0.6 | | | | | 0.6 | | | | | -| 0.4 | | | | 0.4 | | | | | 0.4 | | | | | -| 0.2 | | | | 0.2 | | | | | 0.2 | | | | | -Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours) Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours) Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours) -Naive Chain-of-Thought Naive Chain-of-Thought Naive Chain-of-Thought -| 0.0 | 0 1 | 2 3 4 | 5 | 0.0 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 | 5 | 0.0 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 5 | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -| | | Proof Depth | | | Proof Depth | | | | | | Proof Depth | | | -| | (a)StarCoder+. | | | | (b)GPT-3.5. | | | | | (c)GPT-4. | | | | -Figure4: AccuracypernecessaryproofdepthinProofWriter. Accuraciesreportedareforbootstrapped10-way -majorityvote,andshadedareascover±1bootstrappedstandarddeviation. Black,dottedlinesreflecttheexpected -successrateofguessingarandomlabel,whichis1/3inallsubsetsperourexperimentdesign. -WefocusoncomparingGPT-4+CoTvs. onesymbolNaziGermanPolitician,causingthe -methods? -GPT-4+LINConFOLIO,sincetheiroverallperfor- informationthathewasindependentlyNazi,Ger- -mance is very similar (75.3% vs. 72.5% average man, or a politician to be lost. As a result, LINC -Uncertain -accuracy). We leave an analysis of StarCoder+’s predicted instead of the ground truth -| predictionsonFOLIOtoAppendixG. | | | | | | labelTrue. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -5.1 QualitativeAnalysis Premise: Heinrich Scmidt was a Nazi German -politician. -Qualitatively,wefindthatLINCandCoThavecom- -| | | | | | | FOL:NaziGermanPolitician | | | | (HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | -| ------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| pletely | different | failure modes. | | We give | a high- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Conclusion(Prover9:Uncertain):Heinrich | | | | | | Schmidt | was | -leveloverviewandabbreviatedexamplesofeach -German. -failuremodehere,leavingfulldetailedexamples -| toAppendixE. | | | | | | FOL:German(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -First,wedetailthefailuremodesforLINC: -| | | | | | | L3: | FOL | contains | syntax | | errors. | Across | all | -| --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | -| L1: | FOL | fails to capture | implicit | | informa- | | | | | | | | | -tionnotmentionedinthepremises. Often,there generations, we find that the FOL expressions -| | | | | | | sometimes | | contain | syntax | errors: | 38% | for | Star- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | -isobviousinformationnotexplicitlylistedinthe -CoderPlus,24%forGPT-3.5,and13%forGPT-4. -premisesthatisnecessarytoexplicitlyencodein -FOLinordertosuccessfullymakeadesireddeduc- The most common error is that the same symbol -| | | | | | | is used | with | multiple | arities. | | As an | example, | if | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | -tion. Forexample,inthesnippetbelowonemust -| | | | | | | Summer(July4)andLoves(Alex, | | | | | Summer)were | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -encodeinFOLtheimplicitassumptionthatHarry -Summer -isaperson(Person(Harry)). both present in a FOL translation, would -haveamultiplearityviolation. -| P re m | ise 1 : W | h e n a person reads | a book, | that | person | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --------- | -------------------- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Next,wedetailthreefailuremodesforCoT: -| ga i ns | k n o w | l e dg e. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C1: CoTconcludessomethingdifferentthan -| FOL:all | x. | all y. (Person(x) | | & Reads(x, | y) & | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Book(y) -> Gains(x, Knowledge)) it suggests. One common mistake we often see -withtheCoTapproachisthatitgeneratesachainof -| Premise2: | | Harry read the | book "Walden" | | by Henry | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | -| Thoreau. | | | | | | reasoning | | indicating | uncertainty, | | but | then | asserts | -FOL:Reads(Harry, Walden) thattheconclusionisfalse. Anexampleofthisis -Conclusion (Prover9: Uncertain): Harry gains shownbelow,whereGPT-4suggeststhereis“no -| knowledge. | | | | | | evidence” | | for the | conclusion | | but then | deduces | it | -| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -| FOL:Gains(Harry, | | Knowledge) | | | | false. | | | | | | | | -L2: FOLfailstocaptureinformationexplic- -(GPT-4IncorrectCoT):Let’sthinkstepbystep.Wewant -itlymentionedinthepremisesduetothechoice to evaluate if platypus are reptiles. We know from the -premisesthatplatypusaremammalsandthattheyhaveno -| ofrepresentation. | | Evenwheninformationisex- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | teeth. | The | fact that | some | mammals | have | teeth | does not | -plicitlywritteninthepremises,thechoiceofhow -contradictthefactthatplatypus,althoughmammals,donot -theNLisrepresentedinFOLcanleadtolostinfor- haveteeth.Moreover,thestatementabouthumanshaving -teethisunrelatedtotheclassificationofplatypus.There’s -| mation. | Intheexamplebelow, | | thefactthatHein- | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -noevidenceinthepremisesthatwouldsuggestplatypusare -richwasaNaziGermanpoliticianiscapturedby -reptiles.Therefore,thestatementisfalse. - -T -ru -e -F a -lse -U -n ce -rta -in -E -rro -r -Tr u -e -Fals -e -ert ai -n -Err -or -nc -U -Reference Label -lebaL -detciderP -100 T -ru -39 4 1 0 e -80 -F a -0 31 0 0 -lse -60 U -n ce -rta -23 18 62 0 40 in -E -20 rro -1 1 2 0 r -0 -Tr u -e -Fals -e -ert ai -n -Err -or -nc -U -Reference Label -(a)ConfusionmatrixforLINC. -lebaL -detciderP -100 -50 1 7 0 -80 -3 38 9 0 -60 -10 15 49 0 40 -20 -0 0 0 0 +| about one | aspect | of a | scientific | entity | or | process, | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Corpus +| | | | | | source.2 | | | N=601 | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| which can | be verified | | from | a single | | For | | | | | | | | +Citing +| instance,“TheR | | ofthenovelcoronavirusis2.5” | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | 0 -(b)ConfusionmatrixforChain-of-Thought. -C -o -rre -ct -In -co rre -ct -ect ect -orr orr C nc -I -LINC Outcome -emoctuO -ToC -100 L IN 1.0 -C -1 -80 108 29 0.8 -C o -S T 0.22 1 -60 c ra -tc 0.6 -h -p -a 40 d 0.21 0.54 1 -0.4 -24 21 N -20 a iv -e 0.14 0.52 0.56 1 -0.2 -0 -C T d e -LI N C o c h p a N ai v at -cr -S -(c) Comparing the consistency of LINC vs. (d)Similaritybetweenincorrectpredictionsofeachmethod, -Chain-of-Thought. i.e.,(A wrong == B wrong) / (A wrong or B wrong). -Figure5: AnalyzingandcomparingthemistakesmadebyGPT-4ontheFOLIOdataset. -C2: CoTmakesincorrectlogicaldeductions. (GPT-4IncorrectCoT):Let’sthinkstepbystep.Wewant -WhiletherearemanyinstanceswhereCoTmakes toevaluateifMikehasanF1visa.Fromthepremises,we -know that Mike is an international student and needs to -incorrectlogicaldeductions,onecommondeduc- -applyforCPTifhewantstoworkintheUS.Wealsoknow -tion mistake is the structure “if B is true and thataninternationalstudentintheUSwithanF1visaneeds -A → B, then A is true”. In the example shown toapplyforCPTorOPTifthestudentwantstoworkinthe -US.So,itisclearthatMikehasanF1visasincehefitsthe -below,weseethisincorrectdeductionwhereAis -criteria.Therefore,theconclusionistrue. -“MikehasanF1visa”andBis“Mikeneedstoap- -plyforCPTorOPTifhewantstoworkintheUS”. C3: CoTfailstofindcomplexpathsofreason- -We note that making this type of logical mistake ing. We find that with all three models, CoT fails -isoftencalledthefallacyoftheconverse,andthat whenthepathofreasoningnecessarytomakethe -humansarenotimmunetoit,either. deduction is complex. Sometimes, CoT has diffi- -cultygettingstarted,andothertimes,itgetsstuck -Premise1: InternationalstudentsinUShaveeitheranF1 -inthemiddleofareasoningchain. -visaoraJ1visa. -Premise2:AninternationalstudentinUSwithanF1visa 5.2 QuantitativeAnalysis -needstoapplyforCPTorOPTifthestudentwantstowork -intheUS. 1. ComparedtoCoT,LINChasworserecallbut -betterprecisiononTrue/Falsepredictions. To -Premise3:Mikeisaninternationalstudent. -seethis,weplottedtheconfusionmatricesinFig- -Premise4:MikeneedstoapplyforCPTifhewantstowork -ure 5b (CoT) and Figure 5a (LINC). Looking just -intheUS. -at the distributions of predicted labels of the two -Conclusion(GroundTruth: Uncertain): MikehasanF1 -visa. -methods,weseethatCoTpredicts32%True,27% - -| False, | and41%Uncertain, | | | whileLINCpredicts | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | vs. thenumberofinstanceswhereatleastoneof | | | | | | -| 24%True,17%False,and57%Uncertain(with | | | | | | | themiswrong. | | | | | | -2%ofpredictionsthrowinganerror). Notably,we Figure5dshowsthepairwisesimilaritybetween -observethatLINCpredictsUncertainmuchmore -| | | | | | | | our four | methods, | highlighting | | that | the similar- | -| ---------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | -| frequently | | than | CoT (57% | vs. 41%). | To | under- | | LINC’s | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ity between | | mispredictions | | | and the other | -stand why, note that the translation from natural methods’mispredictions(0.14,0.21,0.22)ismuch -languagetoFOLisalossyprocess: recallthatin lower than the similarity between any pair of the -L1andL2,wesawthattheinformationconveyed in-context reasoning methods (0.52, 0.54, 0.56). -throughtheFOLissometimesasubsetoftheinfor- -| | | | | | | | These results | suggest | | that for | GPT-4 | on FOLIO, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | -mationintheoriginalpremises. Removingpieces LINCistheonlymethodweevaluatewhichsignifi- -ofcrucialinformationthatwereonthecriticalpath cantlyaltersthewaysinwhichthemodelfailsto -todeducingTrue/Falsemaythenleaveanuncer- -reason. -| tainconclusion. | | | Atthesametime,whiletheFOL | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| translationssometimesdonotretainalloftheinfor- | | | | | | | 6 RelatedWork | | | | | | -mationintheNL,theyrarelycontainfalseinforma- -tionthatwasnotprovidedintheoriginalpremises. Reasoning in LLMs: Our work contributes to -| | | | | | | | the wider | literature | on | eliciting | natural | language | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------- | -------- | -Therefore,LINC’sprecisionwhenpredictingTrue -| | False | | | | | | reasoning | capabilities | | in models. | | Although we | -| --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -| or | | is very | high (93%) | compared | to | that of | | | | | | | -CoT(81%),butthiscomesatthecostoflowerre- havefocusedhereoncomparinganeurosymbolic -| | | | | | | | approach | to Scratchpad | | (Nye | et | al., 2021) and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -------------- | -callonTrue/Falsepredictions(60%forLINCvs. -| 75%forCoT). | | | | | | | Chain-of-Thought | | prompting | | (Wei | et al., 2022; | -| ----------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ------------- | -| | LINC | | CoT | | | | Kojima | et al., | 2022; | Wang | et al., | 2023b), many | -| | 2. | and | mispredict | on | different | ex- | | | | | | | -amples. EarlierinSec. 5.1,wesawthatLINCand other similar or related techniques have been de- -velopedinrecentyears;theseincludeleast-to-most -CoTexhibitdifferentfailuremodes,whichsuggests -prompting(Zhouetal.,2023),selection-inference -| theyshouldfailondifferentexamples. | | | | | Indeed,we | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -findthatthisisthecaseinourexperimentsonFO- (Creswelletal.,2023),backwardchaining(Tafjord -etal.,2022;Kazemietal.,2023),andself-taught -| LIO: | Figure | 5c | shows a | 2 × 2 confusion | | matrix | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | reasoning(Zelikmanetal.,2022). | | | | | Someofthese | -whichcompareswhetherornoteachmethod’spre- -| | | | | | | | techniques | have | been | formalized | | under the lan- | -| ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | -| diction | | was correct. | We | observe | that out | of the | | | | | | | -24 + 29 + 21 = 74 samples where at least one guage model cascades framework (Dohan et al., -2022). -methodmakesanincorrectprediction,only21are -| | | | | | | | Semantic | parsing: | | The | notion | of a semantic | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | -shared. Onacloserexaminationofthese21sam- -ples,wefindthat16areambiguousorincorrectin parserrestsonalongtraditionofresearch(Kamath -theirspecification(detailsinAppendixE.4),sothe andDas,2019)whoseaimistomapfragmentsof -naturallanguageintouseful,symbolicmeaningrep- -twomethodsonlyagreeon5well-formedsamples. -ThissuggeststhatLINCandCoTarecomplementary resentations(ZelleandMooney,1996;Zettlemoyer -methodswhichfailunderdistinctcircumstances. andCollins,2005;Berantetal.,2013;Liangetal., -| | | | | | | | 2013;Wongetal.,2023). | | | Unlikeearlierworksin | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -| | 3. Mispredictions | | of | in-context | reasoning | | | | | | | | -thistradition,weusealanguagemodeltogenerate -| baselines | | are more | similar | to each | other | than | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -theyarewithmispredictionsofLINC.Asanex- thesemanticparse,whichisamethodunderactive -tensionofthepreviousanalysis,wenextinvestigate investigationinrecentyears(ShinandVanDurme, -2022;Drozdovetal.,2022;Luetal.,2022;Wang -thecorrelationbetweenthemispredictionsofeach -| pair | of methods. | | To do so, | we define | a similarity | | etal.,2023a). | | | | | | -| ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -score between two methods A and B as follows: Neurosymbolic approaches for reasoning: -GivenadatasetD withN rowsandgroundtruth Methodswhichcombineneuralnetworkswithsym- -| | | }N | }N | | | | bolictechniqueshaveseenbroaduptakeindomains | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| labels{A | | i and{B | i | fromtwomethodsA | | | | | | | | | -| | | i=1 | | i=1 | | | | | | | | | -andB,wedefine adjacent to logical reasoning, such as generating -| | | | (cid:80)N | | | | outputs | consistent | with | a pre-existing | | symbolic | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | 1[A = | B ̸= R | ] | | | | | | | -sim (A,B) ≜ i=1 i i i knowledge base (Marra et al., 2019; Manhaeve -| | D | | (cid:80)N | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | 1[A | ̸= R | orB ̸= | R ] | | | | | | | -i=1 i i i i et al., 2018; Zhang et al., 2023a) and performing -Inwords,sim (A,B)measuresthenumberofin- algorithmicreasoningoversymbolicallygrounded -D -stanceswhereAandBarewronginidenticalways inputs (Ebrahimi et al., 2021; Ibarz et al., 2022; - -Velicˇkovic´ etal.,2022). Asforlogicalreasoning themodeldoesnotneedtolearnhoworwhereto -withLLMsinparticular,therehavebeenafewdif- invokethetool: instead,thetoolispredefinedand -ferentproposalsforwhenandhowtobestcombine is applied after the generation step finishes. For -theLLMwithasymboliccomponent. Zhangetal. example,Gaoetal.(2023)andDrorietal.(2022) -(2022)finetunealanguagemodeltosynthesizepo- solvemathematicalreasoningtasksbygenerating -tential facts paired with likelihoods and then use PythonprogramsandusingthePythoninterpreter -ahandwrittendifferentiablesymbolicreasonerin as the tool, Liu et al. (2023) approach physical -ordertodeduceotherfacts. WeirandVanDurme reasoning tasks with a physical simulator as the -(2022) relax thesolver byinstead training neural tool, and Wong et al. (2023) tackle cognitively- -“entailment”modelstodecideifandhowagivenin- inspiredprobabilisticreasoningtaskswithChurch -ferenceruleappliesateachstage. Concurrentlyto (aprobabilisticprogramminglanguage)asthetool. -thiswork,Logic-LM(Panetal.,2023)andSATLM In the second class, the model must learn to in- -(Yeetal.,2023)proposeneurosymbolicapproaches voke the tool by itself, meaning that the model -whichhavemuchincommonwithLINC.However, mustgenerateexplicitAPIcallstothetoolwhich -otherthanthemodelsanddatasetsconsidered,their are then executed when those calls are decoded -contributions have a few key differences to ours. (Schick et al., 2023; Thoppilan et al., 2022; Yao -First,weplaceparticularemphasisonestablishing etal.,2022;Chengetal.,2023). Ourworkbelongs -anin-depthunderstandingoftherelativebenefits to the former class, with the task at hand being -and drawbacks of a neurosymbolic approach to logicalreasoningandthetoolavailableforusebe- -reasoningwhencomparedtotraditionalin-context ingaFOLsolver(Prover9). Wereferthereaderto -reasoningstrategieslikeChain-of-Thought. Sec- Mialonetal.(2023)foramorethoroughsurveyof -ond, Logic-LM employs a self-refinement strat- recentworkinthetool-usageliterature. -egy, which has shown promise across code gen- -7 Conclusion -erationandNLPtasks(Zhangetal.,2023b;Chen -etal.,2023a;Pengetal.,2023;Madaanetal.,2023; -In this work, we present LINC: Logical Inference -Olaussonetal.,2023)butwhichwedonotconsider -viaNeurosymbolicComputation,aneurosymbolic -here. Third,SATLMstudiesarithmeticreasoning -approachforscalablelogicalreasoningwithlarge -in addition to logical reasoning, showcasing the -languagemodels. OurexperimentsshowthatLINC -versatilityoftheneurosymbolicapproach. Fourth, -leadstosignificantperformancegainsinnearlyev- -andfinally,weuseanFOLrepresentationthatwe -erysettingweconsider,andthatitsupportsgener- -believeiseasierforhumanstoreadandmodelsto -alizationtosettingswherethemodelhastoreason -learn. We highly encourage interested readers to -aboutamuchlargersetofpremisesthanitisshown -studythesetwocontemporaryworksindetail. -inthein-contextlearningexamples. Furthermore, -Autoformalization: Theideaofautomatically carryingoutaquantitativeandqualitativeanalysis -translating natural language into structured sym- of the mistakes made by LINC, we find evidence -bolic representations that programs can reason thatitmaycomplementpurelyin-contextreasoning -abouthasgainedpopularityinthedomainofformal strategiessuchasChain-of-Thoughtprompting, -mathematics,leadingtoautoformalizationsystems sincetheydiffergreatlyinthetypesandfrequen- -forseveraltheoremproversincludingMizar(Wang ciesofmistakesmade. Thisworkthussupportsthe -etal.,2018,2020),Lean3(Azerbayevetal.,2023), efficacy of neurosymbolic approaches to natural -andIsabelle(Wuetal.,2022). Outsideformalmath- languagereasoning,settingthestageforcontinued -ematics,autoformalizationhasalsobeenappliedto advancesincombininglargelanguagemodelsand -translatingnaturallanguageintosystemspecifica- symbolic reasoning engines; we discuss several -tionlanguagessuchastemporallogic(Hahnetal., promisingfuturedirectionsinAppendixA. -2022;Cosleretal.,2023;Chenetal.,2023b). -8 Limitations -Toolusage: Ourworkisheavilyinspiredbyre- -cent work on tool usage. The central idea in this Narrowscopeoflogicalreasoningtaskconsid- -lineofresearchistoaugmentlanguagemodelswith ered: Inthiswork,wefocusexclusivelyononeas- -externaltoolssuchascalculators,codeinterpreters pectoflogicalreasoning: predictingthetruthvalue -and information retrieval systems. We further di- of a conclusion given a set of natural language -videtheseworksintotwoclasses. Inthefirstclass, premises. Here, we consider a setting where the +| is valid, | but opinion-based | | | statements | like | “The | | | Seed | | | | | +| --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +governmentshouldrequirepeopletostandsixfeet +N=140 +| apart to | stop coronavirus” | | | are not. | Compound | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +claimslike“Aerosolizedcoronavirusdropletscan +| travelatleast6feetandcanremainintheairfor3 | | | | | | | | | Co- | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cited +hours”shouldbesplitintotwoatomicclaims. +Claim +| Claims | in SCIFACT | | are | natural | – they | are de- | | N=4,259 | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +rivedfromcitationsentences,orcitances(Nakov Cardiac injury is +common in critical +| et al., 2004), | that | occur | naturally | in | scientific | ar- | | | Dis- | | | | | +| -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cases of COVID-19. +tractor +| ticles. This | is | similar | to political | | fact-checking | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +datasetssuchasUKPSnopes(Hanselowskietal., +2019),whichusepoliticalfact-checkingwebsites +| | | | | | | | Figure | 2: | Corpus construction. | | Citing | abstracts | are | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | +as a source of natural claims. On the other hand, identified for each seed document. A claim is written +basedonthesourcecitanceinthecitingabstract. +| claimsinthepopular | | | FEVERdataset(Thorneetal., | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2018)aresynthetic,sincetheyarecreatedbyanno- +| tators by | mutating | sentences | | from | the Wikipedia | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Abstractsthatsupportorrefuteeachclaimarean- +articlesthatwillserveasevidence. +| | | | | | | | notated | with | rationales. | We | describe | our | corpus | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| Supporting | and | refuting | | evidence | In most | fact- | | | | | | | | +creationandannotationprocess. +checkingwork,claimsareassignedaglobaltruth +labelbasedontheentiretyoftheavailableevidence. 3.1 Datasourceandcorpusconstruction +ForexampleinFEVER,theclaim“BarackObama +| | | | | | | | Toconstruct | | SCIFACT,weuseS2ORC(Loetal., | | | | | +| ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | +| wasthe44th | PresidentoftheUnitedStates”canbe | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 2020), | a | publicly-available | | corpus | of millions | of | +verifiedusingWikipediaasanevidencesource. +| | | | | | | | scientificarticles. | | Toensurethatdocumentsinour | | | | | +| ----- | ------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | +| While | SCIFACT | claimsareindeedverifiableas- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | dataset | are | of high quality, | | we randomly | | sample | +sertionsaboutscientificfindings,accuratelyassign- +articlesfromamanuallycuratedcollectionofwell- +ingaglobaltruthlabeltoascientificclaim(givena +regardedjournalsspanningdomainsfrombasicsci- +fixedscientificcorpus)requiresasystematicreview ence(e.g.,Cell,Nature)toclinicalmedicine(e.g., +| byateamofexperts. | | | Inthisworkwefocusonthe | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +JAMA,BMJ).Thefulllistofjournalsisincludedin +| simplertaskofassigning | | | SUPPORTSor | | REFUTES | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | AppendixC.1. | | Werestricttoarticleswithatleast | | | | | +relationstoindividualclaim-abstractpairs. 10 citations. The resulting collection is referred +Each SUPPORTS or REFUTESrelationbetween to as our seed set. We use the S2ORC citation +claimandabstractmustbejustifiedbyatleastone +| | | | | | | | graph | to | sample source | citances | from | citing | arti- | +| ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --------------- | ------ | ----- | +| rationale. | A rationale | | is a | minimal | collection | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | cleswhichcitetheseseedarticles. | | | | Ifacitancecites | | | +sentenceswhich,takentogetheraspremisesinthe otherarticlesnotintheseedset,werefertothese +contextoftheabstract,canreasonablybejudgedby +| | | | | | | | asco-cited | | articlesandaddthemtothecorpus,as | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| adomainexpertasimplyingtheclaim. | | | | | Rationales | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | depictedinFigure2. | | | Thecontentofthecitedab- | | | | +facilitatethedevelopmentofinterpretablemodels stractsencompassesadiversearrayoftopicswithin +whichnotonlyhavetheabilitytomakelabelpre- biomedicine,asshowninFigure3. Themajority +dictions,butcanalsoidentifytheexactsentences +| | | | | | | | of | citances | used for | SCIFACT | cite | only | the seed | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ---- | -------- | +thatarenecessaryfortheirdecisions. +article(noco-citedarticles),aswefoundininitial +annotationexperimentsthatthesecitancestended +| 3 The | SCIFACT | dataset | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +toyieldspecific,easy-to-verifyclaims. +| | | | | | | | To | expand | the corpus, | we | identify | five | papers | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ | +| The SCIFACT | | dataset | consists | of 1,409 | scientific | | | | | | | | | +claims3 verifiedagainstacorpusof5,183abstracts. citedinthesamepaperaseachsourcecitancebut +inadifferentparagraph,andaddthesetothecor- +2Requiringannotatorstosearchmultiplesourcesincreases pusasdistractorabstracts. Theseabstractsoften +cognitiveburdenanddecreasesannotationquality. +3SCIFACTiscomparableinsizetorecentscientificdatasets has1,000 questions), and informationextraction(e.g. Sci- +for tasks such as QA (e.g. PubMedQA (Jin et al., 2019) ERC(Luanetal.,2018)has500annotatedabstracts). +7536 -premisesandconclusionareexpressedinrelatively dleproblemsrequiringhigher-orderlogics(Miller -short statements, which makes the formalization andNadathur,1986;Higginbotham,1998). Also, -tasktractable. Inparticular,ProofWriter’snatural in many settings it is desirable to work with non- -language statements are synthetically generated, classicallogics(Priest,2008;Burgess,2009). Al- -so they can be easily and accurately parsed into ternativetheoremproverswouldbeneededforsuch -FOL. FOLIO reflects a more naturalistic dataset, problems. AmethodlikeLINCcanbenaturallyex- -soweseeahigherfailurerateinLINC’ssemantic -| | | | | | | tended | to those | settings, | but | exactly | how | well it | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -parsingstep. However,theformalizationtaskbe- worksthererequiresfurtherinvestigations. -comesmoredifficultifthepremisesareinlonger Computational costs: Implementing our ap- -paragraphform,suchasinquestionansweringor proachwithbothGPTmodelsandtheStarCoder+ -contradictiondetectionfromcontextpassages. This modelrequiresnon-trivialresources. Theformer -| is because | the same | piece | of | information | can be | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | requires | reliance | on | costly | API requests | | and the | -formalizedinavarietyofways,andthereisalot latterdedicatedGPUsforinference. Especiallyas -ofinformationthatmustbepragmaticallyinferred weusemajorityvoting,manygenerationsmustbe -toarriveattheproperconclusion. madeforeachquery,increasingthecomputational -requirements. -| Generalizability | | of | qualitative | evaluation: | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------ | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | LINC | | CoT | | | | | | | | | -| While | we find that | | and | produce | com- | | | | | | | | -plementarymistakesforournaturallanguagerea- 9 Acknowledgements -soningtask,itisunclearifthisresultalsoholdstrue -| | | | | | | T.X. Olausson | | is supported | | by the | Defense | Ad- | -| ---------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | -| in similar | scenarios, | such | as | the ones | considered | | | | | | | | -vancedResearchProjectsAgency(DARPA)under -| inPAL(Gaoetal.,2023),Logic-LM,and | | | | | SATLM. | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | theASKEMprogram,awardHR00112220042. | | | | | | A. | -| This is | due to the | difference | | in intermediate | lan- | | | | | | | | -GuissupportedbytheNationalScienceFounda- -| guageandoveralllogicalreasoningtask. | | | | | However, | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ---- | --- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | tion (NSF) | Graduate | | Research | Fellowship | | under | -| we hypothesize | that | it | will and | encourage | future | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Grant No. | 2141064. | | B. Lipkin | | and C.E. | Zhang | -investigationinthisdirection. -| | | | | | | aresupportedbyMITPresidentialFellowships. | | | | | | A. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Moresophisticatedreasoningtechniques: Re- Solar-LezamaissupportedbytheNationalScience -| cent work | has proposed | | more | sophisticated | tech- | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---- | ------------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | Foundation | (NSF) | and | Intel | Corporation | | through | -| niques | beyond chain-of-thought, | | | such | as tree of | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | NSFGrantCCF:2217064. | | | | J.B.Tenenbaumissup- | | | -thoughts (Yao et al., 2023), program of thoughts, portedbyAFOSRGrant#FA9550-22-1-0387and -(Chenetal.,2022),orusingretrievalinchain-of- -| | | | | | | the MIT-IBM | | Watson | AI | Lab. R.P. | Levy | is sup- | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | -| thoughtprompting(Yasunagaetal.,2023). | | | | | These | | | | | | | | -portedbyagrantfromtheSimonsFoundationto -have potential to improve and eliminate some of theSimonsCenterfortheSocialBrainatMIT. -thefailuremodesofthetraditionalCoTmethod. -| | | | | | In | Wethankouranonymousreviewersfortheirin- | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -addition,ideassuchasself-repairmayalsoserve -| | | | | | | sightfulfeedbackandrecommendations. | | | | | | Wethank | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| toimprovethesefailuremodes. | | | | Itremainsfuture | | | | | | | | | -themembersoftheComputerAidedProgramming, -work to do a more thorough investigation of the Computational Psycholinguistics, and Computa- -| efficacy | of these | techniques, | | though there | is also | | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | tional Cognitive | | Science | groups | | for constructive | | -preliminaryevidencethattheystilllackreasoning -| | | | | | | commentaryatvariousstagesofthisproject. | | | | | | We | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -capabilities(Huangetal.,2023). -thankYoonKimforhelpfulsuggestionsandcom- -Scalability: It is unclear how well LINC will mentsonpiecesoftheinitialprojectproposal. In -perform as the number of premises scales. First, addition,wethankZhaofengWuandSimengHan -onemistakeinformalizationcanleadtoanincor- fordiscussionsregardingtheFOLIOdataset. -rectdeduction,andmorepremisesleadtoahigher -| probability | of errors. | | Second, | in the | deduction | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -References -| stage, while | many | fast | algorithms | (e.g., | forward- | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ---- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andbackward-chaining)existforlogicaldeduction, -| | | | | | | Cem Anil, | Yuhuai | Wu, | Anders | Andreassen, | | Aitor | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ----------- | --------- | ----- | -| thegeneralproblemisstillNP-hard. | | | | Therefore,the | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Lewkowycz, | | Vedant | Misra, | Vinay | Ramasesh, | Am- | -theoremprovermaytakealongtimeinpractice. broseSlone,GuyGur-Ari,EthanDyer,andBehnam -| | | | | | | Neyshabur. | | 2022. | Exploring | length | generalization | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | -| Otherlogicsbeyondfirst-orderlogic: | | | | | Inthis | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | in large | language | models. | | In Advances | | in Neural | -work, we exclusively focus on first-order logic. InformationProcessingSystems,volume35,pages -| However, | FOL is | not | expressive | enough | to han- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | 38546–38556. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | | +cationmodelperformspoorly,suggestingthatthe +Humans +| | Mice | | | | negationprocessdidnotintroducesevereartifacts. | | | | | | | +| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Animals +Female +| | Male | | | | 3.3 Claimverification | | | | | | | +| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Middle Aged +Aged +| | Adult | | | | AnnotationForeachclaim,alloftheclaim’scited | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Cell Line +Signal Transduction abstracts are annotated for evidence. Annotators +RNA +| | Receptors | | | | areshownasingleclaim-citedabstractpair,and | | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Gene Expression Regulation +| | | | | | askedtolabelthepairas | | | SUPPORTS, | | REFUTES,or | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +Models +Risk Factors +| | | | | | NOINFO. | Althoughourtaskdefinitionallowsfora | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Cells +Cell Differentiation +| | Mutation | | | | singleclaimtobebothsupportedandrefuted(by | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Microscopy | | | | differentabstracts)–anoccurrenceweobserveon | | | | | | | +Infant +| | | | | | real-world | COVID-19 | | claims | (§6.3) | – | this never | +| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ---------- | +| | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 0.6 | 0.8 1.0 | | | | | | | | +Fraction of evidence abstracts +| | | | | | occursinourdataset. | | | Eachclaimhasasinglelabel. | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | CountsforeachlabelareshowninTable2a. | | | | | | Over- | +| Figure 3: | Most frequently | occurring | Medical | Subject | | | | | | | | +all,theannotatorsfoundevidencein63%ofcited +Headings(MeSH)terms(y-axis)amongcitedabstracts. +MeSHisacontrolledvocabularyusedforindexingar- abstracts. Iftheannotatorassignsa SUPPORTS or +ticles in PubMed. Topics range from clinical trial re- REFUTES label, they must also identify all ratio- +ports(“Humans”,“RiskFactors”)tomolecularbiology nalesasdefinedin§2. Table2bprovidesstatistics +(“CellLine”,“RNA”). onthenumberofsentencesperrationale,thenum- +berofrationalesperclaim/abstractpair,andthe +discusssimilartopicstotheevidencedocuments, number of evidence abstracts per claim. No ab- +stracthasmorethan3rationalesforagivenclaim, +| increasing | the difficulty | of abstract | retrieval | and | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +andallrationalesconsistofatmostthreesentences. +makingourmetricsmoreaccuratelyreflectthesys- +| | | | | | RationalesinSCIFACTaremutuallyexclusive. | | | | | | 28 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tem’sperformanceonalargeresearchcorpus. +rationalescontainnon-contiguoussentences. +3.2 Claimwriting The verifiers included three NLP experts, five +lifescienceundergraduates,andfivegraduatestu- +AnnotationAnnotatorsareshownasourcecitance +| | | | | | dents studying | | life sciences. | | Annotators | | verified | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +inthecontextofanarticle,andareaskedtowriteup +| | | | | | claimsthattheydidnotwritethemselves. | | | | | | Annota- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +tothreeclaimsbasedonthecontentofthecitance; +tionguidelinesareprovidedinAppendixD. +| seeAppendixC.2foranexample. | | | Thisresultsin | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | +| | | | | | SCIFACT | claims | | are verified | | against | abstracts | +naturalclaimsbecausetheannotatordoesnotsee +| | | | | | rather than | full | articles | since | (1) | abstracts | can be | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------ | +thecitedarticle’sabstract–thecitedabstract–at +annotatedmorescalably,(2)evidenceisfoundin +| the time | of claim writing. | Annotators | are | asked | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theabstractinmorethan60%ofcases,and(3)pre- +toskipcitancesthatdonotmakestatementsabout +viousattemptsatfull-documentannotationsuffered +specificscientificfindings. +fromlowannotatoragreement(§7). +| The claim | writers included | | four experts | with | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +backgroundinscientificNLP,fifteenundergradu- QualityWeassign232claim-abstractpairsforin- +| | | | | | dependent | re-annotation. | | The | label | agreement | is | +| ------------- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | +| ates studying | the life sciences, | | and four | graduate | | | | | | | | +0.75Cohen’sκ,comparablewiththe0.68Fleiss’ +students(doctoralormedical)inthelifesciences. +Detailedinformationontheannotatortrainingpro- κ reported in Thorne et al. (2018), and 0.70 Co- +hen’sκreportedinHanselowskietal.(2019). +| cess can | be found in Appendix | | C.3. The | claim- | | | | | | | To | +| -------- | -------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | +| | | | | | measure | rationale | agreement, | | we | treat | each sen- | +writinginterfaceisshowninAppendixD. +tenceaseitherclassifiedas“partofarationale”or +| Claim negation | Unless | the authors | of the | source | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +“notpartofarationale”andcomputesentence-level +| citance | were mistaken, | cited | articles should | pro- | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ------------------ | ----- | --------------- | -------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | agreement. | TheresultingCohen’sκis0.71. | | | | | | +| vide supporting | evidence | for | the claims | made in | | | | | | | | +| a citance. | To obtain examples | | where an | abstract | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 4 The | SCIFACT | | task | | | | +REFUTESaclaim,anNLPexpertwrotenegations +of existing claims, taking precautions not to bias TaskFormulationTheinputstoourtaskareasci- +thenegationsbyusingobviouskeywordslike“not” entificclaimcandacorpusofabstractsA. Allab- +(Schusteretal.,2019;Gururanganetal.,2018). In stractsa ∈ Aarelabeledasy(c,a) ∈ {SUPPORTS, +§6.1, we demonstrate that a “claim-only” verifi- REFUTES, NOINFO } with respect to a claim c. +7537 -Zhangir Azerbayev, Bartosz Piotrowski, Hailey language modeling with pathways. arXiv preprint -Schoelkopf,EdwardWAyers,DragomirRadev,and arXiv:2204.02311. (Citedonpg.1) -| Jeremy | Avigad. | 2023. | ProofNet: | Autoformalizing | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ------- | ----- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andformallyprovingundergraduate-levelmathemat- -| | | | | | | | Matthias | Cosler, Christopher | | Hahn, | Daniel Men- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | -ics. arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.12433. (Citedonpg. doza,FrederikSchmitt,andCarolineTrippel.2023. -| 9) | | | | | | | nl2spec: | Interactivelytranslatingunstructurednatu- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -rallanguagetotemporallogicswithlargelanguage -David Barker-Plummer, Jon Barwise, and John models. InComputerAidedVerification,pages383– -| Etchemendy. | | 2011. Language, | | proof, | and logic, | 2 | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 396,Cham.SpringerNatureSwitzerland. | | | | (Citedon | -| edition. | CenterfortheStudyofLanguageandInfor- | | | | | | | | | | | -pg.9) -| mation. | (Citedonpg.2) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AntoniaCreswell,MurrayShanahan,andIrinaHiggins. -| Mohammad | Bavarian, | Heewoo | | Jun, Nikolas | Tezak, | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | ------ | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | 2023. Selection-inference:Exploitinglargelanguage | | | | | -JohnSchulman,ChristineMcLeavey,JerryTworek, -| | | | | | | | models | for interpretable | logical | reasoning. | In The | -| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | -| and Mark | Chen. | 2022. | Efficient | training | of | lan- | | | | | | -EleventhInternationalConferenceonLearningRep- -| guage | models | to fill in | the middle. | | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------ | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | resentations. | (Citedonpg.1,3,8) | | | | -| arXiv:2207.14255. | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | | | | | -JonathanBerant,AndrewChou,RoyFrostig,andPercy David Dohan, Winnie Xu, Aitor Lewkowycz, Ja- -Liang. 2013. Semantic parsing on Freebase from cob Austin, David Bieber, Raphael Gontijo Lopes, -question-answerpairs. InProceedingsofthe2013 Yuhuai Wu, Henryk Michalewski, Rif A Saurous, -Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Lan- JaschaSohl-Dickstein,etal.2022. Languagemodel -| | | | | | | | cascades. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2207.10342. | | | (Cited | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | -guageProcessing,pages1533–1544,Seattle,Wash- -| ington,USA.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- | | | | | | | onpg.8) | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tics. (Citedonpg.8) -IddoDrori,SarahZhang,ReeceShuttleworth,Leonard -Tom Brown, Benjamin Mann, Nick Ryder, Melanie Tang, Albert Lu, Elizabeth Ke, Kevin Liu, Linda -Subbiah,JaredDKaplan,PrafullaDhariwal,Arvind -| | | | | | | | Chen,SunnyTran,NewmanCheng,etal.2022. | | | | A | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Neelakantan,PranavShyam,GirishSastry,Amanda -neuralnetworksolves,explains,andgeneratesuni- -Askell,etal.2020. Languagemodelsarefew-shot versitymathproblemsbyprogramsynthesisandfew- -learners. InAdvancesinneuralinformationprocess- shotlearningathumanlevel. ProceedingsoftheNa- -ingsystems,volume33,pages1877–1901. (Citedon tionalAcademyofSciences,119(32):e2123433119. -pg.1,4) -(Citedonpg.9) -| JohnPBurgess.2009. | | Philosophicallogic. | | | Princeton | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Andrew Drozdov, | Nathanael | Schärli, | Ekin | Akyürek, | -| UniversityPress. | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | | | -NathanScales,XinyingSong,XinyunChen,Olivier -| | | | | | | | Bousquet, | and Denny | Zhou. | 2022. Compositional | | -| ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | -| Wenhu | Chen, | Xueguang | Ma, | Xinyi | Wang, | and | | | | | | -William W Cohen. 2022. Program of thoughts semanticparsingwithlargelanguagemodels. arXiv -| | | | | | | | preprintarXiv:2209.15003. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | -| ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --------- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -| prompting: | Disentanglingcomputationfromreason- | | | | | | | | | | | -| ing for | numerical | reasoning | tasks. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | -NouhaDziri,XimingLu,MelanieSclar,XiangLorraine -| arXiv:2211.12588. | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Li, LiweiJian, | BillYuchenLin, | | PeterWest, | Chan- | -Xinyun Chen, Maxwell Lin, Nathanael Schärli, and dra Bhagavatula, Ronan Le Bras, Jena D Hwang, -DennyZhou.2023a. Teachinglargelanguagemod- etal.2023. Faithandfate: Limitsoftransformerson -elstoself-debug. arXivpreprintarXiv:2304.05128. compositionality. arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.18654. -| (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | | -| ------------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Yongchao | Chen, | Rujul | Gandhi, | Yang | Zhang, | and | | | | | | -MonirehEbrahimi,AaronEberhart,FedericoBianchi, -| Chuchu | Fan. | 2023b. NL2TL: | | Transforming | | natu- | | | | | | -| ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | andPascalHitzler.2021. | | Towardsbridgingtheneuro- | | | -rallanguagestotemporallogicsusinglargelanguage symbolic gap: Deep deductive reasoners. Applied -| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.07766. | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Intelligence,51:6326–6348. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | -pg.9) -| | | | | | | | HerbertBEnderton.2001. | | Amathematicalintroduction | | | -| --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| Zhoujun | Cheng, | Tianbao | Xie, | Peng | Shi, Chengzu | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | tologic. | Elsevier. (Citedonpg.2) | | | | -| Li, Rahul | Nadkarni, | | Yushi | Hu, Caiming | Xiong, | | | | | | | -DragomirRadev,MariOstendorf,LukeZettlemoyer, -| | | | | | | | Luyu Gao, | Aman Madaan, | Shuyan | Zhou, | Uri Alon, | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------------------- | ----- | --------- | -| NoahA.Smith,andTaoYu.2023. | | | | Bindinglanguage | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | PengfeiLiu, | YimingYang, | JamieCallan, | | andGra- | -| modelsinsymboliclanguages. | | | | InTheEleventhIn- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | hamNeubig.2023. | | PAL:Program-aidedlanguage | | | -ternationalConferenceonLearningRepresentations. -| | | | | | | | models. | In International | Conference | | on Machine | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -(Citedonpg.9) -| | | | | | | | Learning,pages10764–10799.PMLR. | | | | (Citedonpg. | -| -------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -| AakankshaChowdhery,SharanNarang,JacobDevlin, | | | | | | | 9,10) | | | | | -| Maarten | Bosma, | Gaurav | Mishra, | Adam | Roberts, | | | | | | | -Paul Barham, Hyung Won Chung, Charles Sutton, Herbert P Grice. 1975. Logic and conversation. In -Sebastian Gehrmann, et al. 2022. Palm: Scaling Speechacts,pages41–58.Brill. (Citedonpg.15) +Fold SUPPORTS NOINFO REFUTES All goldevidenceabstractforc,and(2)Thepredicted +label is correct: y(c,a) = y(c,a). It is correctly +Train 332 304 173 809 (cid:98) +Dev 124 112 64 300 rationalized if,inaddition,thepredictedrationale +Test 100 100 100 300 +sentencescontainagoldrationale,i.e.,thereexists +All 556 516 337 1409 somegoldrationaleR +i +(c,a) ⊆ S(cid:98)(c,a). +(a)DistributionofclaimlabelsinSCIFACT. +LikeFEVER,whichlimitsthemaximumnumber +ofpredictedrationalesentencestofive, SCIFACT +0 1 2 3+ +limitstothreepredictedrationalesentences. Over- +Citedabstractsperclaim - 1278 86 45 +all performance is measured by the micro-F1 of +Evidenceabstractsperclaim 516 830 37 26 +theprecisionandrecalloverthecorrectly-labeled +Rationalesperabstract - 552 290 153 +Sentencesperrationale - 1542 92 11 andcorrectly-rationalizedevidenceabstracts. We +refertotheseevaluationsasAbstract and +(b)Evidencecountsatvariouslevelsofgranularity.Forexam- Label-Only +ple,Column2oftherow“Rationales/abstract”indicatesthat Abstract Label+Rationale ,respectively. +290claim/abstractpairsaresupportedby2distinctrationales. +Sentence-levelevaluationmeasuresperformance +Table 2: Statistics on claim labels, and the number of inidentifyingindividualrationalesentences. Un- +evidenceabstractsandrationalesperclaim. like the abstract-level metrics, this evaluation pe- +nalizesthepredictionofextrarationalesentences. +A predicted rationale sentence s(c,a) is cor- +(cid:98) +The abstracts that either SUPPORT or REFUTE c +rectlyselected if(1)Itisamemberofsomegold +arereferredtoasevidenceabstractsforc,denoted +rationaleR (c,a),(2)allothersentencesfromthe +i +as E(c). Each evidence abstract a ∈ E(c) is an- +same gold rationale R (c,a) are among the pre- +i +notated with rationales. A single rationale R i is dicted S(cid:98)(c,a), and (3) y +(cid:98) +(c,a) (cid:54)= NOINFO 4. It is +acollectionofsentences{r (c,a),...,r (c,a)}, +1 m correctly labeled if, in addition, the abstract a is +wheremisthenumberofsentencesinrationaleR . +i correctlylabeled: y(c,a) = y(c,a). +(cid:98) +We denote the set of all rationales as R(c,a) = +Overallperformanceismeasuredbythemicro- +{R (c,a),...,R (c,a)}. +1 n F1oftheprecisionandrecallofcorrectly-selected +Given a claim c and a corpus A, the system andcorrectly-labeledrationalesentences,denoted +mustpredictasetofevidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c). For Sentence and Sentence . +Selection-Only Selection+Label +each abstract a ∈ E(cid:98)(c), it must predict a label Forsentence-levelevaluation,wedonotlimitthe +y (cid:98) (c,a), and a collection of rationale sentences numberofpredictedrationalesentences,sincethe +S(cid:98)(c,a) = {s (cid:98)1 (c,a),...,s (cid:98)(cid:96) (c,a)}. Note that al- evaluationpenalizesmodelsthatover-predict. +thoughthegoldannotationsmaycontainmultiple +separaterationales,tosimplifythepredictiontask 5 VERISCI: Baselinemodel +weonlyrequirethemodeltopredictasinglecol- +Wedevelopabaseline(referredtoasVERISCI)that +lectionofrationalesentences;thesesentencesmay +takes a claim c and corpus A as input, identifies +encompassmultiplegoldrationales. +evidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c),andpredictsalabely +(cid:98) +(c,a) +TaskEvaluationWeevaluatethetaskattwolevels +andrationalesentencesS(cid:98)(c,a)foreacha ∈ E(cid:98)(c). +of granularity. For abstract-level evaluation, we +Followingthe“BERT-to-BERT”modelpresented +assessthemodel’sabilitytoidentifytheabstracts +inDeYoungetal.(2020a);Soleimanietal.(2019), +thatsupportorrefutetheclaim. Forsentence-level +VERISCIisapipelineofthreecomponents: +evaluation, we evaluate the model’s performance +1. ABSTRACTRETRIEVAL retrieves k abstracts +atidentifyingthesentencessufficienttojustifythe +withhighestTF-IDFsimilaritytotheclaim. +abstract-levelpredictions. Weconductevaluations +2. RATIONALESELECTION identifies rationale +in both the “Open” FEVER-style (Thorne et al., +sentencesS(cid:98)(c,a)foreachabstract. +2018) setting where the evidence abstracts must +3. LABELPREDICTIONmakesthefinallabelpre- +beretrieved,andthe“Oracleabstract” ERASER- +dictiony(c,a). +(cid:98) +style (DeYoung et al., 2020a) setting where the +Rationale selection Given a claim c and ab- +goldevidenceabstractsE(c)areprovided. stract a, we train a model to predict z (cid:44) +i +Abstract-level evaluation is inspired by the +4Condition(3)eliminatesrationalesentenceswhichwere +FEVERscore. Givenaclaimc,apredictedevidence +identifiedbytherationaleselector,butprovedinsufficientto +abstracta ∈ E(cid:98)(c)iscorrectlylabeled if(1)aisa justifyafinalSUPPORTS/REFUTESdecision +7538 -Christopher Hahn, Frederik Schmitt, Julia J Tillman, Percy Liang, Rishi Bommasani, Tony Lee, Dimitris -NiklasMetzger,JulianSiber,andBerndFinkbeiner. Tsipras, Dilara Soylu, Michihiro Yasunaga, Yian -2022. Formalspecificationsfromnaturallanguage. Zhang,DeepakNarayanan,YuhuaiWu,AnanyaKu- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2206.01962. (Citedonpg.9) mar, et al. 2022. Holistic evaluation of language -| | | | | | | models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2211.09110. | | | (Citedon | -| --------------------------------------------- | -------- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --------- | -------------- | -------- | -| SimengHan,HaileySchoelkopf,YilunZhao,Zhenting | | | | | | pg.1) | | | | | -| Qi, Martin | Riddell, | Luke | Benson, | Lucy | Sun, Eka- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Percy Liang, | Michael | I Jordan, | and Dan Klein. | 2013. | -| terina Zubova, | | Yujie Qiao, | Matthew | Burtell, | et al. | | | | | | -2022. Folio: Naturallanguagereasoningwithfirst- Learning dependency-based compositional seman- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2209.00840. tics. Computational Linguistics, 39(2):389–446. -| orderlogic. | | | | | (Cited | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(Citedonpg.8) -onpg.3) -RuiboLiu,JasonWei,ShixiangShaneGu,Te-YenWu, -| James Higginbotham. | | 1998. | On | higher-order | logic | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SoroushVosoughi,ClaireCui,DennyZhou,andAn- -| andnaturallanguage. | | InProceedingsoftheBritish | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --------- | ------------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | drewM.Dai.2023. | | Mind’seye: | Groundedlanguage | | -| Academy,volume95,pages1–27. | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | modelreasoningthroughsimulation. | | | InTheEleventh | | -| | | | | | | International | Conference | on | Learning | Representa- | -| Jie Huang | and Kevin | Chen-Chuan | | Chang. 2022. | To- | | | | | | -tions. (Citedonpg.9) -| wardsreasoninginlargelanguagemodels: | | | | | Asurvey. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.10403. (Citedonpg.1) XuantaoLu,JingpingLiu,ZhouhongGu,HanwenTong, -| | | | | | | ChenhaoXie, | JunyangHuang, | | YanghuaXiao, | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -Jie Huang, Xinyun Chen, Swaroop Mishra, Wenguang Wang. 2022. Parsing natural language -Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Adams Wei Yu, Xiny- intopropositionalandfirst-orderlogicwithdualre- -ingSong,andDennyZhou.2023. Largelanguage inforcement learning. In Proceedings of the 29th -models cannot self-correct reasoning yet. arXiv InternationalConferenceonComputationalLinguis- -| preprintarXiv:2310.01798. | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | tics,pages5419–5431. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | -| | | | | | | AmanMadaan, | NiketTandon,PrakharGupta,Skyler | | | | -BorjaIbarz,VitalyKurin,GeorgePapamakarios,Kyr- -| | | | | | | Hallinan, | Luyu Gao, | Sarah | Wiegreffe, | Uri Alon, | -| ---------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | --------- | -| iacos Nikiforou, | | Mehdi | Bennani, | Róbert | Csordás, | | | | | | -AndrewJosephDudzik,MatkoBošnjak,AlexVitvit- Nouha Dziri, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Yiming Yang, -skyi,YuliaRubanova,etal.2022. Ageneralistneural etal.2023. Self-refine:Iterativerefinementwithself- -algorithmiclearner. InLearningonGraphsConfer- feedback. arXivpreprintarXiv:2303.17651. (Cited -onpg.9) -| ence,pages2–1.PMLR. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RobinManhaeve,SebastijanDumancic,AngelikaKim- -| AishwaryaKamathandRajarshiDas.2019. | | | | | Asurvey | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | mig, ThomasDemeester, | | andLucDeRaedt.2018. | | | -| onsemanticparsing. | | InAutomatedKnowledgeBase | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | DeepProbLog: | Neuralprobabilisticlogicprogram- | | | | -| Construction(AKBC). | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | | | -ming. InAdvancesinneuralinformationprocessing -| | | | | | | systems,volume31. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -| Mehran Kazemi, | | Najoung | Kim, | Deepti Bhatia, | Xin | | | | | | -Xu,andDeepakRamachandran.2023. LAMBADA: Giuseppe Marra, Francesco Giannini, Michelangelo -Backwardchainingforautomatedreasoninginnat- -| | | | | | | Diligenti,andMarcoGori.2019. | | | Integratinglearn- | | -| -------------- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | ----------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ------- | -| ural language. | | In Proceedings | | of the 61st | Annual | | | | | | -| | | | | | | ingandreasoningwithdeeplogicmodels. | | | | InJoint | -| Meeting | of the Association | | for | Computational | Lin- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | European | Conference | on | Machine Learning | and | -guistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages6547–6568, KnowledgeDiscoveryinDatabases,pages517–532. -Toronto,Canada.AssociationforComputationalLin- Springer. (Citedonpg.8) -| guistics. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | W. McCune. | 2005–2010. | | Prover9 and | mace4. | -DenisKocetkov,RaymondLi,LoubnaBenAllal,JiaLi, |http://www.cs.unm.edu/ mccune/prover9/|. (Cited -onpg.3) -ChenghaoMou,CarlosMuñozFerrandis,YacineJer- -nite,MargaretMitchell,SeanHughes,ThomasWolf, -| | | | | | | Ian McKenzie, | Alexander | Lyzhov, | Alicia | Parrish, | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | -------- | -| etal.2022. | TheStack:3TBofpermissivelylicensed | | | | | | | | | | -AmeyaPrabhu,AaronMueller,NajoungKim,Sam -| source code. | | arXiv | preprint | arXiv:2211.15533. | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | Bowman,andEthanPerez.2022. | | | Theinversescaling | | -prize. (Citedonpg.1) -TakeshiKojima,ShixiangShaneGu,MachelReid,Yu- Quinn McNemar. 1947. Note on the sampling error -| takaMatsuo,andYusukeIwasawa.2022. | | | | | Largelan- | | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofthedifferencebetweencorrelatedproportionsor -| guagemodelsarezero-shotreasoners. | | | | InAdvances | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | percentages. | Psychometrika,12(2):153–157. | | | (Cited | -inneuralinformationprocessingsystems,volume35, -onpg.5) -| pages22199–22213. | | (Citedonpg.1,4,8) | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -GrégoireMialon,RobertoDessì,MariaLomeli,Christo- -Raymond Li, Loubna Ben Allal, Yangtian Zi, Niklas forosNalmpantis,RamPasunuru,RobertaRaileanu, -Muennighoff,DenisKocetkov,ChenghaoMou,Marc Baptiste Rozière, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, -Marone,ChristopherAkiki,JiaLi,JennyChim,etal. AsliCelikyilmaz,etal.2023. Augmentedlanguage -2023. Starcoder: maythesourcebewithyou! arXiv models: asurvey. arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.07842. -| preprintarXiv:2305.06161. | | | (Citedonpg.4,15) | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1[a isarationalesentence] for each sentence a RATIONAL-SELECT. LABEL-PRED. +| i | | | | | | i | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +in a. For each sentence, we encode the concate- Trainingdata P R F1 ACC. +| nated sequence | | w = | [a ,SEP,c] | | using | a BERT- | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | ---------- | ----- | --------------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- | +| | | i | i | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | FEVER | | 41.5 | 57.9 48.4 | | 67.6 | +| style language | | model | and | predict | a score | z˜ = | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | i | UKPSnopes | | 42.5 | 62.3 50.5 | | 71.3 | +| | | | | | | | SCIFACT | | 73.7 | 70.5 72.1 | | 75.7 | +| σ[f(CLS(w | ))],whereσ | | isthesigmoidfunction, | | | | | | | | | | +| | i | | | | | | FEVER+SCIFACT | | 72.4 | 67.2 69.7 | | 81.9 | +| f isalinearlayerand | | | CLS(w | i )isthe | CLS | token | | | | | | | +from the encoding of w . We train the model on Sentenceencoder P R F1 ACC. +i +pairs of claims and their cited abstracts and min- SCIBERT 74.5 74.3 74.4 69.2 +| | | | | | | | BioMedRoBERTa | | 75.3 | 69.9 72.5 | | 71.7 | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- | +| imize cross-entropy | | | loss between | | z i and | z˜. i For | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | RoBERTa-base | | 76.1 | 66.1 70.8 | | 62.9 | +eachclaim,weusecitedabstractslabeledNOINFO, +| | | | | | | | RoBERTa-large | | 73.7 | 70.5 72.1 | | 75.7 | +| ------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- | +| as well | as non-rationale | | sentences | | from | abstracts | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Modelinputs | | P | R F1 | | ACC. | +| labeled | SUPPORTS | and | REFUTES | | as negative | ex- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Claim-only | | - | - - | | 44.5 | +amples. To make predictions, we select all sen- Abstract-only 60.1 60.9 60.5 53.3 +| tencesa | withz˜ | > tasrationalesentences,where | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | i | i | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Table3: Comparisonofdifferenttrainingdatasets, | | | | | en- | +t ∈ [0,1]istunedonthedevset(AppendixA.1). +| | | | | | | | coders, and | model | inputs for | RATIONALESELECTION | | | +| ---------------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----- | ---------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------- | +| Label prediction | | Sentences | | identified | | by the ra- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and LABELPREDICTION, | | | evaluated | on the | SCIFACT | +| tionale | selector | are | passed | to a separate | | BERT- | | | | | | | +devset. Theclaim-onlymodelcannotselectrationales. +| based model | to | make | the | final labeling | | decision. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Given a | claim | c and | abstract | a, | we concatenate | | | | | | | | +the claim and the predicted rationale sentences VERISCI, and (4) discuss some modeling chal- +lengespresentedbythedataset. +| u = [s | (c,a),...s | | (c,a),SEP,c]5, | | and | predict | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------- | ---------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| (cid:98)1 | | (cid:98)(cid:96) | | | | | | | | | | | +| y˜(c,a) = | φ[f(CLS(u))], | | where | φ | is the | softmax | | | | | | | +6.1 Pipelinecomponents +| function,andf | | isalinearlayerwiththreeoutputs | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +representingthe{SUPPORTS, REFUTES, NOINFO We examine the effects of different training +datasets,sentenceencoders,andmodelinputson +| } labels. | We minimize | | the | cross-entropy | | loss be- | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tweeny˜(c,a)andthetruelabely(c,a). the performance of the RATIONALESELECTION +Wetrainthemodelonpairsofclaimsandtheir and LABELPREDICTION modules. The RATIO- +citedabstractsusinggoldrationalesasinput. For NALESELECTIONmoduleisevaluatedonitsability +toselectrationalesentencesgivengoldabstracts6. +| cited abstracts | | labeled | NOINFO, | | we choose | the | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +k sentences from the cited abstract with high- TheLABELPREDICTIONmoduleisevaluatedonits +est TF-IDF similarity to the claim as input ra- 3-waylabelclassificationaccuracygivengoldratio- +| | | | | | | | nalesfromcitedabstracts. | | | Citedabstractslabeled | | | +| --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | +| tionales. | For | prediction, | | we use | the | predicted | | | | | | | +rationale sentences S(cid:98)(c,a) as input and predict NOINFOareincludedintheevaluation. Theseab- +yˆ(c,a) = argmaxy˜(c,a). NOINFO is predicted stractshavenogoldrationalesentences;asin§5, +weprovidethek +forabstractswithnorationalesentences. mostsimilarsentencesfromthe +abstractasinput(moredetailsinAppendixA). +Weexperimentedwithalabelpredictionmodel +whichencodesentireabstractsviatheLongformer +| | | | | | | | Training Data | We | train | on (1) FEVER, | | (2) UKP | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ------- | +(Beltagy et al., 2020), and makes predictions us- Snopes,(3)SCIFACT,and(4)FEVERpretraining +ingthedocument-level CLS token. Performance followedby SCIFACTfine-tuning. RoBERTa-large +wasnotcompetitivewithourpipelinesetup,likely +(Liuetal.,2019)isusedasthesentenceencoder. +| because | the label | predictor | | struggles | to | identify | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Sentence encoder | | We fine-tune | SCIBERT | | (Belt- | +relevantinformationwhengivenfullabstracts. +agyetal.,2019),BioMedRoBERTa(Gururangan +etal.,2020),RoBERTa-base,andRoBERTa-large. +6 Experiments +SCIFACTisusedastrainingdata. +Inourexperiments,we(1)analyzetheperformance +| | | | | | | | Model Inputs | We | examine | the | performance | of | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +ofeachindividualcomponentofVERISCI,(2)eval- “claim-only” and “abstract-only” models trained +uatefulltaskperformanceinboththe“Oracleab- +onSCIFACT,usingRoBERTa-largeasthesentence +stract”and“Open”settings,(3)presentpromising +encoder. Theclaim-onlymodelmakeslabelpredic- +| results verifying | | claims | about | COVID-19 | | using | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | 6Our FEVER-trained | | RATIONALESELECTION | | | module | +5WetruncatetherationaleinputifitexceedstheBERT achieves79.9sentence-levelF1ontheFEVERtestset,virtu- +tokenlimit.cisnevertruncated. allyidenticalto79.6reportedinDeYoungetal.(2020a). +7539 -DaleA.MillerandGopalanNadathur.1986. Someuses Abulhair Saparov, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Vishakh -ofhigher-orderlogicincomputationallinguistics. In Padmakumar,NitishJoshi,SeyedMehranKazemi, -Proceedingsofthe24thAnnualMeetingonAssoci- Najoung Kim, and He He. 2023. Testing the -ationforComputationalLinguistics,page247–256, general deductive reasoning capacity of large lan- -NewYork,USA.AssociationforComputationalLin- guagemodelsusingoodexamples. arXivpreprint -| guistics. | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | arXiv:2305.15269. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | | -| --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MaxwellNye,AndersJohanAndreassen,GuyGur-Ari, TimoSchick,JaneDwivedi-Yu,RobertoDessì,Roberta -Henryk Michalewski, Jacob Austin, David Bieber, Raileanu,MariaLomeli,LukeZettlemoyer,Nicola -| | | | | | | | Cancedda,andThomasScialom.2023. | | | | | Toolformer: | | -| ----- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| David | Dohan, | Aitor | Lewkowycz, | | Maarten | Bosma, | | | | | | | | -Languagemodelscanteachthemselvestousetools. -| DavidLuan,etal.2021. | | | Showyourwork: | | | Scratch- | | | | | | | | -| -------------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ----- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.04761. | | | | (Citedonpg.2,9) | | | -| pads | for intermediate | | computation | | with | language | | | | | | | | -| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2112.00114. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Noam Shazeer. | | 2019. | Fast | transformer | | decoding: | -pg.1,4,8) -| | | | | | | | One write-head | | is all | you | need. | arXiv | preprint | -| ------ | --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | arXiv:1911.02150. | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | -| Theo X | Olausson, | Jeevana | | Priya | Inala, | Chenglong | | | | | | | | -| Wang, | Jianfeng | Gao, | and | Armando | Solar-Lezama. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Richard Shin | and | Benjamin | Van | Durme. | 2022. | Few- | -2023. Isself-repairasilverbulletforcodegenera- -shotsemanticparsingwithlanguagemodelstrained -| tion? | arXivpreprintarXiv:2306.09896. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | oncode. | InProceedingsofthe2022Conferenceof | | | | | | -pg.9) -theNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociationfor -| | | | | | | | ComputationalLinguistics: | | | HumanLanguageTech- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -OpenAI.2023. GPT-4technicalreport. (Citedonpg.1, nologies, pages 5417–5425, Seattle, United States. -4,15) -| | | | | | | | Association | for | Computational | | Linguistics. | | (Cited | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -onpg.8) -LongOuyang,JeffreyWu,XuJiang,DiogoAlmeida, -CarrollWainwright,PamelaMishkin,ChongZhang, -| | | | | | | | Aarohi Srivastava, | | Abhinav | Rastogi, | | Abhishek | Rao, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | -SandhiniAgarwal,KatarinaSlama,AlexRay,etal. AbuAwalMdShoeb,AbubakarAbid,AdamFisch, -2022. Training languagemodelsto followinstruc- AdamRBrown,AdamSantoro,AdityaGupta,Adrià -tionswithhumanfeedback. InAdvancesinNeural Garriga-Alonso, et al. 2023. Beyond the imitation -InformationProcessingSystems,volume35,pages -| | | | | | | | game: | Quantifying | and | extrapolating | | the | capabili- | -| ------------ | ---- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| 27730–27744. | | (Citedonpg.4,15) | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | tiesoflanguagemodels. | | | TransactionsonMachine | | | | -| | | | | | | | LearningResearch. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | | -| Liangming | Pan, | Alon | Albalak, | | Xinyi | Wang, and | | | | | | | | -William Yang Wang. 2023. Logic-lm: Empower- RobertStalnaker.2002. Commonground. Linguistics -ing large language models with symbolic solvers andphilosophy,25(5/6):701–721. (Citedonpg.15) -| for faithful | | logical | reasoning. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalvi,andPeterClark.2021. -| arXiv:2305.12295. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | ProofWriter: | | Generating | implications, | | proofs, | and | -| | | | | | | | abductivestatementsovernaturallanguage. | | | | | | InFind- | -GuilhermePenedo,QuentinMalartic,DanielHesslow, -ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: -| Ruxandra | Cojocaru, | | Alessandro | | Cappelli, | Hamza | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Alobeidli, Baptiste Pannier, Ebtesam Almazrouei, ACL-IJCNLP2021,pages3621–3634,Online.Asso- -| | | | | | | | ciationforComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | (Citedonpg. | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| andJulienLaunay.2023. | | | | TheRefinedWebdataset | | | | | | | | | | -3) -| for Falcon | | LLM: | outperforming | | curated | corpora | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| with | web data, | and | web data | only. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | | -OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalviMishra,andPeterClark. -| arXiv:2306.01116. | | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 2022. | Entailer: | Answering | | questions | with | faithful | -| | | | | | | | andtruthfulchainsofreasoning. | | | | InProceedingsof | | | -BaolinPeng,MichelGalley,PengchengHe,HaoCheng, -the2022ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNat- -YujiaXie,YuHu,QiuyuanHuang,LarsLiden,Zhou -uralLanguageProcessing,pages2078–2093,Abu -| Yu,WeizhuChen,andJianfengGao.2023. | | | | | | Check | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Dhabi,UnitedArabEmirates.AssociationforCom- -| yourfactsandtryagain: | | | Improvinglargelanguage | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | putationalLinguistics. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | -modelswithexternalknowledgeandautomatedfeed- -| back. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.12813. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RomalThoppilan,DanielDeFreitas,JamieHall,Noam -| pg.9) | | | | | | | Shazeer, | Apoorv | Kulshreshtha, | | Heng-Tze | | Cheng, | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | Alicia | Jin, Taylor | Bos, | Leslie | Baker, | Yu | Du, et al. | -Gabriel Poesia, Alex Polozov, Vu Le, Ashish Tiwari, 2022. LaMDA:Languagemodelsfordialogapplica- -GustavoSoares,ChristopherMeek,andSumitGul- -| | | | | | | | tions. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2201.08239. | | | | | (Citedon | -| ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -| wani.2022. | | Synchromesh: | | Reliablecodegeneration | | | | | | | | | | -pg.9) -InInternational -frompre-trainedlanguagemodels. -ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. (Citedon Petar Velicˇkovic´, Adrià Puigdomènech Badia, David -| pg.15) | | | | | | | Budden,RazvanPascanu,AndreaBanino,MishaDa- | | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -shevskiy,RaiaHadsell,andCharlesBlundell.2022. -GrahamPriest.2008. Anintroductiontonon-classical The clrs algorithmic reasoning benchmark. In In- -logic: From if to is. Cambridge University Press. ternationalConferenceonMachineLearning,pages -| (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | 22084–22102.PMLR. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | Sentence-level | | | | | Abstract-level | | | | +| --------- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --------------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | -------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | | | Label-Only | | Label+Rationale | | | +| Retrieval | Model | P | R | F1 | P | R F1 | | P R | F1 | P | R | F1 | +Oraclerationale 1 100.0 80.5 89.2 89.6 72.2 79.9 90.1 77.5 83.3 90.1 77.5 83.3 +| | | | | 2.1 | | | 3.0 | | | 2.4 | | 2.4 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Oracle +| | | | | 43.8 | | 37.2 | | | 66.3 | | | 51.8 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | +abstract Zero-shot 2 42.5 45.1 2.0 36.1 38.4 2.3 86.9 53.6 3.1 67.9 41.9 3.4 +VERISCI 3 76.1 63.8 69.4 66.5 55.7 60.6 87.3 65.3 74.7 84.9 63.5 72.7 +| | | | | 2.6 | | | 3.1 | | | 2.8 | | 2.9 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Oraclerationale 4 100.0 56.5 72.2 3.3 87.6 49.5 63.2 3.7 88.9 54.1 67.2 3.2 88.9 54.1 67.2 3.2 +Open Zero-shot 5 28.7 37.6 32.5 2.3 23.7 31.1 26.9 2.3 56.0 42.3 48.2 3.3 42.3 32.0 36.4 3.3 +VERISCI 6 45.0 47.3 46.1 3.0 38.6 40.5 39.5 3.0 47.5 47.3 47.4 3.1 46.6 46.4 46.5 3.1 +Table 4: Test set performance on SCIFACT, according to the metrics from §4. For the “Oracle abstract” rows, +thesystemisprovidedwithgoldevidenceabstracts. “Oraclerationale”rowsindicatethatthegoldrationalesare +providedasinput. “Zero-shot”indicateszero-shotperformanceofaverificationsystemtrainedonFEVER. Addi- +tionally,standarddeviationsarereportedassubscriptsforallF1scores. SeeAppendixBforstandarddeviations +onallreportedmetrics. +tionsbasedontheclaimtextalone,withoutaccess inordertoidentifyrelevantevidence. +| to evidence | abstracts. | The abstract-only | | model | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| selectsrationalesentencesandmakeslabelpredic- | | | | | 6.2 | Fulltask | | | | | | | +tionswithoutaccesstotheclaim. +| | | | | | Experimental | | setup | Based | | on the | results | from | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +ResultsTheresultsareshowninTable3. For LA- §6.1,weusetheRATIONALESELECTIONmodule +| | | | | | trainedon | | SCIFACT | only,andthe | | LABELPREDIC- | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | +BELPREDICTION,thebestperformanceisachieved +by training first on the large FEVER dataset and TIONmoduletrainedonFEVER+SCIFACTforour +thenfine-tuningonthesmallerin-domainSCIFACT finalend-to-endsystem VERISCI. AlthoughSCIB- +trainingset. TounderstandthebenefitsofFEVER ERTperformsslightlybetteronrationaleselection, +pretraining,weexaminedtheclaim/evidencepairs usingRoBERTa-largeforbothRATIONALESELEC- +wherethe FEVER+ SCIFACT-trainedmodelmade TION and LABELPREDICTION gavethebestfull- +correctpredictionsbuttheSCIFACT-trainedmodel pipeline performance on the dev set, so we use +| | | | | | RoBERTa-largeforbothcomponents. | | | | | | FortheAB- | | +| -------- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +| did not. | In 36 / 44 of | these cases, | the | SCIFACT- | | | | | | | | | +trainedmodelpredictsNOINFO. Thuspretraining STRACTRETRIEVALmodule,thebestdevsetfull- +on FEVER appears to improve the model’s abil- pipeline performance was achieved by retrieving +| | | | | | thetopk | | = 3documents. | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ity to recognize | textual | entailment | relationships | | | | | | | | | | +betweenevidenceandclaim–particularlyrelation- +| | | | | | Model | comparisons | | We | report | performance | | of | +| --------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | +| ships indicated | by non-domain-specific | | | cues | like | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | three | model | variants. | | For the | “Oracle | rationale” | | +“isassociatedwith”or“hasanimportantrolein”. setting,the RATIONALESELECTION moduleisre- +For RATIONALESELECTION, training on SCI- placedbyanoraclewhichoutputsgoldrationales +FACT alone produces the best results. We exam- forcorrectlyretrieveddocuments,andnorationales +inedtherationalesthattheSCIFACT-trainedmodel forincorrectretrievals. The“Zero-shot”settingre- +portsthezero-shotgeneralizationperformanceof +| identified | but the FEVER- | trained | model | missed, | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +and found that they generally contain science- a model trained on FEVER (the results on UKP +specific vocabulary. Thus, training on additional Snopeswereslightlyworse). VERISCIreportsthe +performanceofourbestsystem. +out-of-domaindataprovideslittlebenefit. +RoBERTa-large exhibits the strongest perfor- Results The results are shown in Table 4. In the +mance on label prediction, while SCIBERT has oracleabstractsetting,theabstract-levelF1scores +areroughlycomparabletolabelclassificationaccu- +| a slight | edge on rationale | selection. | The | “claim- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +only”modelexhibitsverypoorperformance,which racies,andtheAbstract scoreinRow +Label+Rationale +providessomereassurancethattheclaimnegation 3impliesanend-to-endclassificationaccuracyof +roughly70%,givengoldabstracts. +proceduredescribedin§3.2doesnotintroduceob- +viousstatisticalartifacts. Similarly,thepoorperfor- Access to in-domain data during training +manceofthe“abstract-only”modelindicatesthat clearly improves performance. Despite the +themodelneedsaccesstotheclaimbeingverified small size of SCIFACT, training on these data +7540 -BailinWang,ZiWang,XuezhiWang,YuanCao,RifA MichihiroYasunaga,XinyunChen,YujiaLi,Panupong -Saurous,andYoonKim.2023a. Grammarprompting Pasupat,JureLeskovec,PercyLiang,EdHChi,and -fordomain-specificlanguagegenerationwithlarge DennyZhou.2023. Largelanguagemodelsasana- -languagemodels. arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.19234. logicalreasoners. arXivpreprintarXiv:2310.01714. -| (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -QingxiangWang,ChadBrown,CezaryKaliszyk,and XiYe,QiaochuChen,IsilDillig,andGregDurrett.2023. -JosefUrban.2020. Explorationofneuralmachine Satisfiability-aidedlanguagemodelsusingdeclara- -translation in autoformalization of mathematics in tive prompting. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.09656. -| mizar. | In Proceedings | | of the | 9th ACM | SIGPLAN | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | -| ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InternationalConferenceonCertifiedProgramsand -EricZelikman,YuhuaiWu,JesseMu,andNoahGood- -| Proofs,pages85–98. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | man. 2022. | STaR: Bootstrapping | | | reasoning | with | -| | | | | | | | reasoning. | InAdvancesinNeuralInformationPro- | | | | | -| Qingxiang | Wang, | Cezary | Kaliszyk, | and | Josef | Urban. | | | | | | | -2018. First experiments with neural translation of cessing Systems, volume 35, pages 15476–15488. -| informaltoformalmathematics. | | | | InIntelligentCom- | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| puterMathematics: | | 11thInternationalConference, | | | | | | | | | | | -CICM2018,Hagenberg,Austria,August13-17,2018, John M Zelle and Raymond J Mooney. 1996. Learn- -ingtoparsedatabasequeriesusinginductivelogic -| Proceedings11,pages255–270.Springer. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | programming. | InProceedingsoftheNationalCon- | | | | | -pg.9) -ferenceonArtificialIntelligence,pages1050–1055. -| XuezhiWang,JasonWei,DaleSchuurmans,QuocVLe, | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| EdHChi, | SharanNarang, | | AakankshaChowdhery, | | | | | | | | | | -andDennyZhou.2023b. Self-consistencyimproves LukeSZettlemoyerandMichaelCollins.2005. Learn- -| | | | | | | | ing to | map sentences | to logical | form: | Structured | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -| chainofthoughtreasoninginlanguagemodels. | | | | | | In | | | | | | | -classificationwithprobabilisticcategorialgrammars. -TheEleventhInternationalConferenceonLearning -| | | | | | | | In Proceedings | of the | Twenty-First | | Conference | on | -| ---------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -| Representations. | | (Citedonpg.1,3,4,8,23) | | | | | | | | | | | -UncertaintyinArtificialIntelligence,UAI’05,page -JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten 658–666, Arlington, Virginia, USA. AUAI Press. -| Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou, | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | -| etal.2022. | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelicitsrea- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Hanlin Zhang, | Ziyang Li, | Jiani | Huang, | Mayur | Naik, | -| soning | in large | language | models. | In | Advances | in | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | and Eric | Xing. 2022. | Improved | logical | reasoning | | -NeuralInformationProcessingSystems,volume35, -oflanguagemodelsviadifferentiablesymbolicpro- -| pages24824–24837. | | | (Citedonpg.1,4,8) | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | gramming. | InFirstWorkshoponPre-training: | | | | Per- | -spectives,Pitfalls,andPathsForwardatICML2022. -| NathanielWeirandBenjaminVanDurme.2022. | | | | | | Dy- | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| namicgenerationofinterpretableinferencerulesin | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | -| a neuro-symbolic | | expert | system. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | -HonghuaZhang,MeihuaDang,NanyunPeng,andGuy -| arXiv:2209.07662. | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | VandenBroeck.2023a. | | Tractablecontrolforautore- | | | | -| | | | | | | | gressivelanguagegeneration. | | | InInternationalCon- | | | -LionelWong,GabrielGrand,AlexanderKLew,NoahD -ferenceonMachineLearning,pages40932–40945. -| Goodman, | Vikash | K | Mansinghka, | | Jacob Andreas, | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | -------------- | ----- | ------------ | --------------------------------------- | ------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | PMLR. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | -| andJoshuaBTenenbaum.2023. | | | | Fromwordmod- | | | | | | | | | -| els to world | models: | | Translating | from | natural | lan- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Kechi Zhang, | Zhuo Li, | Jia Li, | Ge Li, | and | Zhi Jin. | -| guagetotheprobabilisticlanguageofthought. | | | | | | arXiv | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | 2023b. | Self-edit: Fault-awarecodeeditorforcode | | | | | -| preprintarXiv:2306.12672. | | | | (Citedonpg.8,9) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | generation. | InProceedingsofthe61stAnnualMeet- | | | | | -ingoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics -YuhuaiWu,AlbertQiaochuJiang,WendaLi,Markus -| | | | | | | | (Volume1: | LongPapers),pages769–787,Toronto, | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rabe,CharlesStaats,MatejaJamnik,andChristian -Canada.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. -| Szegedy. | 2022. | Autoformalization | | | with large | lan- | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| guagemodels. | | InAdvancesinNeuralInformation | | | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | -ProcessingSystems,volume35,pages32353–32368. -| | | | | | | | Denny Zhou, | Nathanael | Schärli, | Le Hou, | Jason | Wei, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | -(Citedonpg.9) -| | | | | | | | Nathan | Scales, Xuezhi | Wang, | Dale | Schuurmans, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -ClaireCui,OlivierBousquet,QuocVLe,andEdH -| Shunyu Yao, | Dian | Yu, | Jeffrey | Zhao, | Izhak | Shafran, | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Chi. 2023. | Least-to-most | prompting | | enables | com- | -| Thomas | L Griffiths, | | Yuan | Cao, | and | Karthik | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | plex reasoning | in large | language | models. | | In The | -| Narasimhan. | 2023. | | Tree of | thoughts: | Deliberate | | | | | | | | -EleventhInternationalConferenceonLearningRep- -| problemsolvingwithlargelanguagemodels. | | | | | | arXiv | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | -------------- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | resentations. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | -| preprintarXiv:2305.10601. | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | | -| Shunyu Yao, | Jeffrey | Zhao, | Dian | Yu, | Nan Du, | Izhak | | | | | | | -Shafran,KarthikNarasimhan,andYuanCao.2022. -React: Synergizingreasoningandactinginlanguage -| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2210.03629. | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -pg.9) +Reasoningtype Example +Claim: Rapamycinslowsaginginfruitflies. +Science Evidence: ...feedingrapamycintoadultDrosophilaproduceslifespanextension... +background GoldVerdict: SUPPORTS +Reasoning: Drosophilaisatypeoffruitfly. +Claim: Inhibitingglucose-6-phospatedehydrogenaseimpairslipogenesis +Evidence: ...suppressionof6PGDincreasedlipogenesis +Directionality +GoldVerdict: REFUTES +Reasoning: Adecrease(notincrease)inlipogenesiswouldindicatelipogenesisimpairment. +Claim: Bariatricsurgeryimprovesresolutionofdiabetes. +Evidence: StrongassociationswerefoundbetweenbariatricsurgeryandtheresolutionofT2DM, +Numerical +withaHRof9.29(95%CI6.84-12.62)... +reasoning +GoldVerdict: SUPPORTS +Reasoning: AHR(hazardratio)thatisgreaterthan1with95%confidenceindicatesimprovement. +Claim: Majorvaultprotein(MVP)functionstodecreasetumoraggression. +Evidence: KnockoutofMVPleadstomiR-193aaccumulation...inhibitingtumorprogression +Causeand +effect +GoldVerdict: REFUTES +Reasoning: Knockingout(removing)MVPinhibitstumorprogression→MVPincreasestumor +aggression. +Claim: Lowsaturatedfatdietshaveadverseeffectsonthedevelopmentofinfants +Evidence: Neurologicaldevelopmentofchildrenintheinterventiongroupwasatleastasgoodas... +Coreference thecontrolgroup +GoldVerdict: REFUTES +Reasoning: Theinterventiongroupinthisstudywasplacedonalowsaturatedfatdiet. +Table 5: Reasoning types required to verify SCIFACT claims which are classified incorrectly by our modeling +baseline. Wordscrucialforcorrectverificationarehighlighted. +leads to relative improvements of 47% on sultsindicatethattheobserveddifferencesinmodel +open Sentence , and 28% on open performancearestatisticallyrobustandcannotbe +Selection+Label +Abstract +Label+Rationale +overFEVERalone(Row6vs. attributedtorandomvariationinthedataset. +Row5). Thethreepipelinecomponentsmakesimi- +6.3 VerifyingclaimsaboutCOVID-19 +larcontributionstotheoverallmodelerror. Replac- +ingRATIONALESELECTIONwithanoracleleads Weconductexploratoryexperimentsusingoursys- +toaroughly20-pointriseinSentence Selection+Label tem to verify claims concerning COVID-19. We +F1(Row6vs. Row4). ReplacingABSTRACTRE- taskedamedicalstudenttowrite36COVID-related +TRIEVALwithanoracleaswellleadstoagainof claims. For each claim c, we used VERISCI to +roughly20morepoints(Row4vs. Row1). predictevidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c). Theannotatorex- +Nearly all correctly-labeled abstracts are sup- amined each (c,E(cid:98)(c)) pair. A pair was labeled +portedbyatleastonerationale. Thereisonlyatwo- plausibleifE(cid:98)(c)wasnonempty,andatleasthalfof +point difference in F1 between Abstract +Label-Only +theevidenceabstractsinE(cid:98)(c)werejudgedtohave +and Abstract in the oracle setting reasonablerationalesandlabels. For23/36claims, +Label+Rationale +(Row 3), and a one-point difference in the theresponseofVERISCIwasdeemedplausibleby +open setting (Row 6). The differences between ourannotator,demonstratingthatVERISCIisable +Sentence andSentence are to successfully retrieve and classify evidence in +Selection-Only Selection+Label +larger,causedbyexampleswherethemodelfinds manycases. TwoexamplesareshowninTable1. +theevidencebutfailstopredictitsrelationshipto Inbothcases,oursystemidentifiesbothsupporting +theclaim. Weexaminethesein§6.4. and refutingevidence. +Weevaluatethestatisticalrobustnessofourre- +6.4 Erroranalysis +sultsbygenerating10,000bootstrap-resampledver- +sions of the test set (Dror et al., 2018) and com- TobetterunderstandtheerrorsmadebyVERISCI, +puting the standard deviation of all performance weconductamanualanalysisoftestsetpredictions +metrics. Table4showsthestandarddeviationsin whereanevidenceabstractwascorrectlyretrieved, +F1score. Uncertaintiesonallmetricsforboththe butwherethemodelfailedtoidentifyanyrelevant +devandtestsetcanbefoundinAppendixB.There- rationalesorpredictedanincorrectlabel. Weiden- +7541 -A FutureDirections -dateforthepreviouslymentionedlargernumberof -| | | | | | | | premises | involved | in | a typical | question). | | For the | -| ------ | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -| Of the | error | types | we catalog | in | our analysis | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | StarCoder+ | model, | we | allow | generation | up | until | -LINC, -| of | the key | opportunity | | for improvement | | is | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -the8192contextwindowlength,sincethismodel -moreeleganthandlingofnaturalisticlanguageuse. -| | | | | | | | is run locally. | | In either | case, | decoding | is | halted | -| --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | -| While the | errors | observed | | with CoT | result | from | | | | | | | | -earlywheneverthestoptokenispro- -LINC, -| faulty deductive | | inferences, | | in the | case of | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | duced. | Alllocalexperimentswereexecutedona | | | | | | -allerrorshavebeenlocalizedtothesemanticpars- -clusterequippedwithNVIDIAA100GPUs. -| ingprocedure. | | Thisprocessflowsprimarilyunim- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | GPT | Models: | We | use | the gpt-3.5-turbo-16k- | | | -pededintheevaluationofthesyntheticProofWriter -0613andgpt-4-0613checkpointsoftheGPT-3.5 -dataset,yetleavesroomforimprovementwiththe -(Ouyangetal.,2022)andGPT-4(OpenAI,2023) -| naturalistic | FOLIO. | | In follow-up | work, | we | hope | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -models,respectively,invokingbothmodelsviathe -| to deeply | explore | naturalistic | | evaluation | settings, | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -OpenAIAPI. -aswhendatagetthemostmessyisalsowhereim- -| | | | | | | | StarCoder+: | | StarCoder+(15.5B)6 | | | isaversion | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| provementsbecomethe | | | mostvaluable. | | Here, | we | | | | | | | | -ofStarCoderBase(Lietal.,2023)whichhasbeen -| propose | three | strategies | for | further | improvement | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -finetunedon600Btokensfromacombinationof(1) -onnaturalisticsettings. -FalconRefinedWeb(Penedoetal.,2023)(filtered -First,innaturalisticcommunication,“obvious” -versionofCommonCrawl),(2)TheStackv1.2(Ko- -informationisoftenleftoutofexplicitproductions, -| | | | | | | | cetkov et | al., 2022), | | and (3) | a Wikipedia | | dataset. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -lefttobeinferredinthe“commonground”ofthe -Itsbasemodel,StarCoderBase,isanopen-access -communicativeact(Grice,1975;Stalnaker,2002). -modelwithaGPT-2architectureusingmulti-query -| Implicit | premise | rediscovery | | through | controlled | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -attention(Shazeer,2019)andfill-in-the-middleob- -explorationonthelogicalneighborhoodoftheex- -| | | | | | | | jective(Bavarianetal.,2022). | | | | StarCoderBasehas | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -istingexplicitpremisespromisestobeapowerful -| | | | | | | | a8192contextwindowandistrainedon1T | | | | | | code | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -strategyforimprovingperformanceinunderspeci- -tokensofpermissivelylicensedtextfromGitHub -fiedsettings. -across80programminglanguages(Lietal.,2023). -| Second, | while | a | number | of samples | are | lost to | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | We use | StarCoder+ | instead | | of StarCoderBase | | be- | -syntaxerrors,recentworkhasproposedrestricting -| | | | | | | | cause it | is finetuned | | on natural | language, | | which | -| ------------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | -| the sampling | | space | of an | LLM to | that which | is | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | shouldimprovetheperformanceonourtask. | | | | | | We | -consistentwithtermexpansionsinacontext-free- -runStarCoder+withbf16precisiontoreduceits -| grammar(CFG)(Poesiaetal.,2022). | | | | | Doingsoin | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -memoryfootprint. -thissettingwouldeliminateallsyntaxerrors. -Third, sometimes, the translation process to C FOLIODatasetPreprocessing -FOLislossy,throwingawayvaluableinformation -| | | | | | | | We use | the publicly | | available | FOLIO | dataset | on | -| ------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | -| present | in the | original | sentence. | We | propose | im- | | | | | | | | -https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO. -| provingthefaithfulnessofFOLtranslationsbyask- | | | | | | | | | | | | | We | -| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | choose | representative | | samples | from | the training | | -ingtheLLMtotranslatetheFOLbacktonatural -splitofthedatasettobeourfew-shotexamplesand -| languageandcomparingwiththeoriginal. | | | | | Forward | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -translationsthatrankhighlywhenback-translated use the validation split of the dataset in our eval- -| | | | | | | | uation. | The testing | split | is | not publicly | available. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -wouldbethosewhichhaveeffectivelycapturedthe -Theoriginaldatasethas204validationexamples. -intricaciesofaparticularsentence’ssemantics. -However,wediscoveredthatthereareerrorsin22 -| Overall, | we | believe | that | shifting | to | evalua- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | ofthesamples. | | Weremovethesesamplesforour | | | | | -| tions on | more | naturalistic | | datasets, | and incorpo- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | evaluation | and | use the | remaining | | 182 examples. | | -ratingstrategiessuchasthosepresentedhere,will -Theerrorsasfollows: -helppavethepathforwardforneurosymbolicap- -proachestoformalreasoning. -• In4samples,oneormoreofthegroundtruth -| | | | | | | | FOL | expressions | | have | unbalanced | parenthe- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -B ModelDetailsandParameters -ses(samples3,109,110,111). -| We use | a decoding | | temperature | T | = 0.8 | for all | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -• In8samples,thelabelobtainedbyexecuting -models. ForGPT-3.5andGPT-4,welimitthemax- -| | | | | | | | the | ground-truth | | FOL | expressions | does | not | -| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | -| imum number | | of tokens | | to generate | to 1024 | for | | | | | | | | -FOLIO and 4096 for ProofWriter (to accommo- 6https://huggingface.co/bigcode/starcoderplus +tifyfivemodelingcapabilitiesrequiredtocorrect knowledgeintensivetaskswhichrequireanunder- +thesemistakes(Table5providesexamples): standingoftherelationshipbetweenaninputquery +andrelevantsupportingtext. +| Science | background | | includes | | knowledge | of | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +domain-specificlexicalrelationships. Automated evidence synthesis (Marshall and +Directionalityrequiresunderstandingincreasesor Wallace, 2019; Beller et al., 2018; Tsafnat et al., +decreasesinscientificquantities. 2014;Marshalletal.,2017)seekstoautomatethe +Numericalreasoninginvolvesinterpretingnumer- processofcreatingsystematicreviewsofthemed- +icalorstatisticalfindings. icalliterature7 –forinstance,byextractingPICO +Cause and effect requires reasoning about coun- snippets (Nye et al., 2018) and inferring the out- +comesofclinicaltrials(Lehmanetal.,2019;DeY- +terfactuals. +Coreferenceinvolvesdrawingconclusionsusing oungetal.,2020b). Wehopethatsystemsforclaim +contextstatedoutsideofarationalesentence. verificationwillserveascomponentsinfutureevi- +dencesynthesisframeworks. +7 Relatedwork +8 Conclusionandfuturework +| Fact checking | | and | rationalized | | NLP | models | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | ---- | ------- | --------------- | -------- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | Claim verification | | allows | us | to trace | the sources | +| Fact-checking | | datasets | include | | PolitiFact | (Vla- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | andmeasuretheveracityofscientificclaims. | | | | | These | +| chos and | Riedel, | 2014), | | Emergent | (Ferreira | and | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | abilities | have | emerged | as particularly | | important | +| Vlachos, | 2016), | LIAR | (Wang, | | 2017), | SemEval | | | | | | | +2017Task8RumorEval(Derczynskietal.,2017), in the context of the current pandemic, and the +| | | | | | | | broader | reproducibility | | crisis | in science. | In this | +| ---------------------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | +| Snopes | (Popat | et al., | 2017), | CLEF-2018 | | Check- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | article, | we formalize | | the task | of scientific | claim | +| That! (Barro´n-Ceden˜o | | | et | al., 2018), | Verify | (Baly | | | | | | | +et al., 2018), Perspectrum (Chen et al., 2019), verification,andreleaseadataset(SCIFACT)and +| | | | | | | | models | (VERISCI) | | to support | work | on this task. | +| ----- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | +| FEVER | (Thorne | et | al., 2018), | | and UKP | Snopes | | | | | | | +Ourresultsindicatethatitispossibletotrainmod- +| (Hanselowski | | et al., | 2019). | Hanselowski | | et al. | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | els for | scientific | fact-checking | | and | deploy them | +| (2019)providesathoroughreview. | | | | | Toourknowl- | | | | | | | | +edge, thereare noexistingdata setsfor scientific with reasonable efficacy on real-world claims re- +latedtoCOVID-19. +| claimverification. | | | Werefertoourtaskas“claim | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Scientificclaimverificationpresentsanumber +verification”ratherthan“fact-checking”toempha- +sizethatourfocusistohelpresearchersmakesense ofpromisingavenuesforresearchonmodelscapa- +bleofincorporatingbackgroundinformation,rea- +ofscientificfindings,nottocounterdisinformation. +| | | | | | | | soning | about | scientific | processes, | | and assessing | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | +Fact-checkingisoneofanumberoftaskswhere +| | | | | | | | the strength | and | provenance | | of various | evidence | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | +| a model | is required | | to justify | a | prediction | via ra- | | | | | | | +tionalesfromthesourcedocument. TheERASER sources. Thislastchallengewillbeespeciallycru- +cialforfutureworkthatseekstoverifyscientific +| dataset | (DeYoung | | et al., | 2020a) | provides | a suite | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +claimsagainstsourcesotherthantheresearchlit- +| of benchmark | | datasets | (including | | SCIFACT) | for | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +evaluatingrationalizedNLPmodels. erature–forinstance,socialmediaandthenews. +| | | | | | | | We hope | that | the resources | | presented | in this pa- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | +RelatedscientificNLPtasksThecitationcontex- +perencouragefutureresearchontheseimportant +| tualization | task | (Cohan | et | al., 2015; | Jaidka | et al., | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +challenges,andhelpfacilitateprogresstowardthe +2017)istoidentifyspansinaciteddocumentthat +broadergoalofscientificdocumentunderstanding. +arerelevanttoaparticularcitationinacitingdoc- +ument. Unlike SCIFACT, these citations are not Acknowledgments +| re-written | into | atomic | claims | | and are | therefore | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | ---- | ------ | ------------------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | This research | | was supported | | by the | ONR MURI | +| moredifficulttoverify. | | | Expertannotatorsachieved | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | N00014-18-1-2670, | | | ONR | N00014-18-1-2826, | | +verylow(21.7%)inter-annotatoragreementonthe +DARPAN66001-19-2-4031,NSF(IIS1616112), +BioMedSummdataset(Cohenetal.,2014),which +contains314citationsreferencing20papers. Allen Distinguished Investigator Award, and the +| | | | | | | | Sloanfellowship. | | WethanktheSemanticScholar | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +Biomedicalquestionansweringdatasetsinclude +teamatAI2,UW-NLP,andH2labatUWforhelp- +BioASQ(Tsatsaronisetal.,2015)andPubMedQA +(Jin et al., 2019), which contain 855 and 1,000 fulcommentsandfeedback. +“yes/no”questionsrespectively(Guetal.,2020). +7https://www.cochranelibrary.com/ +Claimverificationandquestionansweringareboth- about/about-cochrane-reviews +7542 -main/data/v0.0/folio-train.jsonl. -| match | the | provided | ground | | truth label. | We | | | | | | | We do | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -double-checked this, first by executing the notoptimizeforthechoiceoffew-shotexamples, -FOLexpressionsthroughProver9andsecond andthisistheonlysetofexamplesweevaluated -bycheckingitmanually. (samples6,28,30, with, so it is likely that there exist better choices -48,113,115,139,140). forfew-shotexamplesthatwouldleadtoimproved -performanceacrosstheboard. -• In10samples,thenumberofpremisesdoes -not match the number of FOL expressions D.1 FOLIO,1-shot(baseline) -| (samples | | 10, 11, | 12, 88, | 106, | 107, | 108, 174, | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---- | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | | The | following | is a first-order | | logic | (FOL) | | -175,176). -(cid:44)→ problem. -| | | | | | | | The | problem | is to determine | | whether | the | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -The sample numbers above refer to the (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises. -| | | | | | | | The | premises | are given | in the | form | of a set | of | -| ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ---- | -------- | --- | -| line index | in | the | validation | | file located | at | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ first-order | | logic sentences. | | | | -https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO/blob/ -| | | | | | | | The | conclusion | is given | in | the form | of a single | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -main/data/v0.0/folio-validation.jsonl. (cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence. -| | | | | | | | The | task is | to evaluate | the | conclusion | as | 'True', | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ----------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ 'False', | or | 'Uncertain' | | given the | | -D FOLIOFew-ShotPrompts -(cid:44)→ premises. -| The methodologies | | | we investigate | | do | not re- | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -| quire any | finetuning | on | domain-specific | | | data. In- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | All | dispensable | things | are | environment-friendly. | | | -| stead, we | use | in-context | learning | | (ICL) | with pre- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | All | woodware | is dispensable. | | | | | -| trained | models. | We | prompt | | the model | with | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | All | paper | is woodware. | | | | | -a set of instructions and 1-8 ICL examples, No good things are bad. -| | | | | | | | All | environment-friendly | | things | are | good. | | -| ----------- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | -------------------- | --------- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | -| which | adhere | to a | structured | | text format | de- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | A worksheet | | is either | paper | or is | environment- | | -| signed | to scaffold | generations | | | and ease | post- | | (cid:44)→ friendly. | | | | | | -| processing. | Inparticular,webegineachICLexam- | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -| ple with | each | of the | NL premises | | wrapped | in an | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | A worksheet | | is not dispensable. | | | | | -... -| HTML-style | | tag | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| followed | by | the NL | conclusion | | wrapped | in | | | | | | | | -Uncertain -| .... | | | | | The | requi- | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -siteevaluationstepsforeachevaluationparadigm - -arethenoutlinedinasubsequentsectionwrapped ...premises for sample here, one premise per -| .... | | | | | Followingthein- | | | line | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(cid:44)→ - -clusionofICLexamples,atestexampleisadded, - -withtheandsections. -| | | | | | | | ...conclusion | | for sample | here | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| Then,thetagisopened,andtheLM | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -| is allowed | to | proceed | with | causal | generation | un- | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| til the | | tag | is | generated. | Upon | gen- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | Listing1: | | todo | | | - -| eration | of this | stop token, | | the | | block | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -issegmentedforpost-processingaccordingtothe -D.2 FOLIO,1-shot(scratchpad) -| | | | ({naïve, | | scratchpad, | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | --------- | --------- | ----------------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -------------------- | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| method | being | evaluated | | | | | | | | | | | | -| chain-of-thought, | | | neuro-symbolic}). | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | The | following | is a first-order | | logic | (FOL) | | -| Forthefew-shotexamples,weusesamplesfrom | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ problem. | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | The | problem | is to determine | | whether | the | | -| the publicly | available | | FOLIO | training | | set. We | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ conclusion | follows | | from the | premises. | | -| | | | | | | | The | premises | are given | in the | form | of a set | of | -| select a | set of | diverse | samples | that | are | balanced | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | first-order | | logic sentences. | | | | -(cid:44)→ -across labels. Since the FOLIO training set does The conclusion is given in the form of a single -notcomewithFOLexpressionsfortheconclusions first-order logic sentence. -(cid:44)→ -| | | | | | | | The | task is | to translate | each | of | the premises | | -| -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------ | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- | -| or chain | of thought | | prompts, | we | manually | add | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | and | conclusions | into | FOL | expressions, | and | -(cid:44)→ -bothforeachsample. Forthek-shotsetting(k<8), then to evaluate the conclusion as 'True -(cid:44)→ -weusethefirstk samplesfromthefollowinglist ', 'False', or 'Uncertain' given the -(cid:44)→ -premises. -| of sample | indices: | 126, | 24, | 61, | 276, | 149, 262, | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 264, 684. | Here, | sample | i refers | | to the | ith line in | | | | | | | | -| https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO/blob/ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +References Jay DeYoung, Eric Lehman, Ben Nye, Iain James +Marshall, and Byron C. Wallace. 2020b. Evi- +Ramy Baly, Mitra Mohtarami, James Glass, Llu´ıs +dence inference 2.0: More data, better models. In +Ma`rquez,AlessandroMoschitti,andPreslavNakov. +BioNLP@ACL. +2018. Integratingstancedetectionandfactchecking +inaunifiedcorpus. InNAACL. RotemDror,GiliBaumer,SegevShlomov,andRoiRe- +ichart.2018. Thehitchhiker’sguidetotestingstatis- +Alberto Barro´n-Ceden˜o, Tamer Elsayed, Reem +ticalsignificanceinnaturallanguageprocessing. In +Suwaileh, Llu´ıs Ma`rquez i Villodre, Pepa ACL. +Atanasova, Wajdi Zaghouani, Spas Kyuchukov, +Giovanni Da San Martino, and Preslav Nakov. Bradley Efron and Robert Tibshirani. 1993. An intro- +2018. Overviewoftheclef-2018checkthat! labon ductiontothebootstrap. +automaticidentificationandverificationofpolitical +claims.task2: Factuality. InCLEF. William Ferreira and Andreas Vlachos. 2016. Emer- +gent: a novel data-set for stance classification. In +Elaine Beller, Justin Clark, Guy Tsafnat, Clive Elliott NAACL. +Adams, Heinz Diehl, Hans Lund, Mourad Ouzzani, +Kristina Thayer, James Thomas, Tari Turner, J. S. Yu Gu, Robert Tinn, Hao Cheng, M. Lucas, +Xia,KarenA.Robinson,andPaulPGlasziou.2018. Naoto Usuyama, Xiaodong Liu, Tristan Nau- +Makingprogresswiththeautomationofsystematic mann, Jianfeng Gao, and Hoifung Poon. 2020. +reviews: principles of the international collabora- Domain-specific language model pretraining for +tionfortheautomationofsystematicreviews(icasr). biomedical natural language processing. ArXiv, +SystematicReviews,7. abs/2007.15779. +Suchin Gururangan, Ana Marasovic, Swabha +IzBeltagy,KyleLo,andArmanCohan.2019. Scibert: +Swayamdipta, Kyle Lo, Iz Beltagy, Doug Downey, +A pretrained language model for scientific text. In +and Noah A. Smith. 2020. Don’t stop pretraining: +EMNLP. +Adapt language models to domains and tasks. In +Iz Beltagy, Matthew E. Peters, and Arman Cohan. ACL. +2020. Longformer: Thelong-documenttransformer. +Suchin Gururangan, Swabha Swayamdipta, Omer +ArXiv,abs/2004.05150. +Levy, Roy Schwartz, Samuel R. Bowman, and +Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, David Burkett, and Dan Noah A. Smith. 2018. Annotation artifacts in nat- +Klein. 2012. An empirical investigation of statisti- urallanguageinferencedata. InNAACL. +calsignificanceinnlp. InEMNLP. +AndreasHanselowski, ChristianStab, Claudia Schulz, +Zile Li, and Iryna Gurevych. 2019. A richly anno- +Sihao Chen, Daniel Khashabi, Wenpeng Yin, Chris +tated corpus for different tasks in automated fact- +Callison-Burch,andDanRoth.2019. Seeingthings +checking. InCoNLL. +fromadifferentangle: Discoveringdiverseperspec- +tivesaboutclaims. InNAACL. +Kokil Jaidka, Muthu Kumar Chandrasekaran, Devan- +shuJain,andMin-YenKan.2017. Thecl-scisumm +Arman Cohan, Luca Soldaini, and Nazli Goharian. +shared task 2017: Results and key insights. In +2015. Matching citation text and cited spans in +BIRNDL@JCDL. +biomedical literature: a search-oriented approach. +InNAACL. +QiaoJin,BhuwanDhingra,ZhengpingLiu,WilliamW. +Cohen, and Xinghua Lu. 2019. Pubmedqa: A +Kevin Bretonnel Cohen, Hoa Trang Dang, Anita +dataset for biomedical research question answering. +de Waard, Prabha Yadav, and Lucy Vanderwende. +InEMNLP. +2014. Tac 2014 biomedical summarization track. +https://tac.nist.gov/2014/BiomedSumm/. Eric Lehman, Jay DeYoung, Regina Barzilay, and By- +ron C. Wallace. 2019. Inferring which medical +Leon Derczynski, Kalina Bontcheva, Maria Liakata, +treatments work from reports of clinical trials. In +RobProcter,GeraldineWongSakHoi,andArkaitz +NAACL. +Zubiaga.2017. SemEval-2017task8: RumourEval: +Determining rumour veracity and support for ru- Tao Lei, Regina Barzilay, and Tommi S. Jaakkola. +mours. InSemEval. 2016. Rationalizingneuralpredictions. InACL. +Jacob Devlin, Ming-Wei Chang, Kenton Lee, and YinhanLiu,MyleOtt,NamanGoyal,JingfeiDu,Man- +KristinaToutanova.2019. Bert:Pre-trainingofdeep dar Joshi, Danqi Chen, Omer Levy, Mike Lewis, +bidirectional transformers for language understand- Luke Zettlemoyer, and Veselin Stoyanov. 2019. +ing. InNAACL. Roberta: A robustly optimized bert pretraining ap- +proach. ArXiv,abs/1907.11692. +Jay DeYoung, Sarthak Jain, Nazneen Fatema Rajani, +EricLehman, CaimingXiong, RichardSocher, and KyleLo,LucyLuWang,MarkNeumann,RodneyKin- +Byron C. Wallace. 2020a. Eraser: A benchmark to ney,andDanielS.Weld.2020. S2ORC:TheSeman- +evaluaterationalizednlpmodels. InACL. ticScholarOpenResearchCorpus. InACL. +7543 -All dispensable things are environment-friendly. -All woodware is dispensable. Let's think step by step. We want to evaluate if -All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ a worksheet is not dispensable. From -No good things are bad. (cid:44)→ premise 6, we know that a worksheet is -All environment-friendly things are good. (cid:44)→ either paper or is environment-friendly. -A worksheet is either paper or is environment- (cid:44)→ If it is paper, then from premise 3, a -(cid:44)→ friendly. (cid:44)→ worksheet is woodware, and from premise - (cid:44)→ 2, a worksheet is dispensable. If it is - (cid:44)→ environment-friendly, we know it is good -A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ from premise 5, but we know nothing about - (cid:44)→ whether it is dispensable. Therefore, we - (cid:44)→ don't know if a worksheet is dispensible -TEXT: All dispensable things are environment- (cid:44)→ or not, so the statement is uncertain. -(cid:44)→ friendly. ANSWER: Uncertain -FOL: all x. (Dispensable(x) -> -(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(x)) -TEXT: All woodware is dispensable. -FOL: all x. (Woodware(x) -> Dispensable(x)) ...premises for sample here, one premise per -TEXT: All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ line -FOL: all x. (Paper(x) -> Woodware(x)) -TEXT: No good things are bad. -FOL: all x. (Good(x) -> -Bad(x)) ...conclusion for sample here -TEXT: All environment-friendly things are good. -FOL: all x. (EnvironmentFriendly(x) -> Good(x)) -TEXT: A worksheet is either paper or is -(cid:44)→ environment-friendly. -FOL: ((Paper(Worksheet) & -EnvironmentFriendly( D.4 FOLIO,1-shot(neurosymbolic) -(cid:44)→ Worksheet)) | (-Paper(Worksheet) & -(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(Worksheet))) The following is a first-order logic (FOL) -TEXT: A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ problem. -FOL: -Dispensable(Worksheet) The problem is to determine whether the -ANSWER: Uncertain (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises. - The premises are given in the form of a set of -(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentences. - The conclusion is given in the form of a single -...premises for sample here, one premise per (cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence. -(cid:44)→ line The task is to translate each of the premises - (cid:44)→ and conclusions into FOL expressions, so - (cid:44)→ that the expressions can be evaluated by -...conclusion for sample here (cid:44)→ a theorem solver to determine whether the - (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises. - Expressions should be adhere to the format of -(cid:44)→ the Python NLTK package logic module. -D.3 FOLIO,1-shot(chainofthought) - -The following is a first-order logic (FOL) All dispensable things are environment-friendly. -(cid:44)→ problem. All woodware is dispensable. -The problem is to determine whether the All paper is woodware. -(cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises. No good things are bad. -The premises are given in the form of a set of All environment-friendly things are good. -(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentences. A worksheet is either paper or is environment- -The conclusion is given in the form of a single (cid:44)→ friendly. -(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence. -The task is to translate each of the premises -(cid:44)→ and conclusions into FOL expressions, A worksheet is not dispensable. - - - TEXT: All dispensable things are environment- -All dispensable things are environment-friendly. (cid:44)→ friendly. -All woodware is dispensable. FOL: all x. (Dispensable(x) -> -All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(x)) -No good things are bad. TEXT: All woodware is dispensable. -All environment-friendly things are good. FOL: all x. (Woodware(x) -> Dispensable(x)) -A worksheet is either paper or is environment- TEXT: All paper is woodware. -(cid:44)→ friendly. FOL: all x. (Paper(x) -> Woodware(x)) - TEXT: No good things are bad. - FOL: all x. (Good(x) -> -Bad(x)) -A worksheet is not dispensable. TEXT: All environment-friendly things are good. - FOL: all x. (EnvironmentFriendly(x) -> Good(x)) +Yi Luan, Luheng He, Mari Ostendorf, and Hannaneh Andreas Vlachos and Sebastian Riedel. 2014. Fact +Hajishirzi. 2018. Multi-task identification of enti- checking: Task definition and dataset construction. +ties, relations, and coreference for scientific knowl- In ACL Workshop on Language Technologies and +| edgegraphconstruction. | | | InEMNLP. | | | | ComputationalSocialScience. | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +IainJamesMarshall,Joe¨lKuiper,EdwardBanner,and Lucy Lu Wang, Kyle Lo, Yoganand Chandrasekhar, +RussellReas,JiangjiangYang,DarrinEide,Kathryn +| ByronC.Wallace.2017. | | | Automatingbiomedicalev- | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | -------------- | ----------------------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ------ | ------------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | Funk, Rodney | Kinney, | | Ziyang | Liu, William. | Mer- | +| idencesynthesis: | | Robotreviewer. | | ACL. | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | rill, Paul | Mooney, | Dewey | A. | Murdick, | Devvret | +Iain James Marshall and Byron C. Wallace. 2019. Rishi, Jerry Sheehan, Zhihong Shen, Brandon Stil- +Toward systematic review automation: a practical son,AlexD.Wade,KuansanWang,ChristopherWil- +| | | | | | | | helm, Boya | Xie, | Douglas | M. | Raymond, | Daniel S. | +| -------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +| guide to | using | machine | learning | | tools | in research | | | | | | | +Weld,OrenEtzioni,andSebastianKohlmeier.2020. +| synthesis. | SystematicReviews,8. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | Cord-19: | The | covid-19 | open | research | dataset. | +ArXiv,abs/2004.10706. +| Preslav I | Nakov, | Ariel | S Schwartz, | | and Marti | Hearst. | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2004. Citances: Citation sentences for semantic WilliamYangWang.2017. “liar,liarpantsonfire”: A +| analysis | of bioscience | | text. | In SIGIR | workshop | on | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | newbenchmarkdatasetforfakenewsdetection. | | | | | In | +SearchandDiscoveryinBioinformatics. +ACL. +Benjamin Nye, Junyi Jessy Li, Roma Patel, Yinfei Thomas Wolf, Lysandre Debut, Victor Sanh, Julien +Yang, Iain James Marshall, Ani Nenkova, and By- Chaumond, ClementDelangue, AnthonyMoi, Pier- +ronC.Wallace.2018. Acorpuswithmulti-levelan- ricCistac,TimRault,R’emiLouf,MorganFuntow- +notationsofpatients,interventionsandoutcomesto icz, and Jamie Brew. 2019. Huggingface’s trans- +| support | language | processing | | for medical | | literature. | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | formers: | State-of-the-art | | natural | language | process- | +InACL. +ing. ArXiv,abs/1910.03771. +| Kashyap | Popat, | Subhabrata | | Mukherjee, | | Jannik | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Stro¨tgen, | and | Gerhard | Weikum. | 2017. | | Where the | | | | | | | +| truth lies: | Explaining | | the | credibility | of | emerging | | | | | | | +| claimsonthewebandsocialmedia. | | | | | InWWW. | | | | | | | | +| Tal Schuster, | Darsh | J. | Shah, | Yun | Jie Serene | Yeo, | | | | | | | +| Daniel | Filizzola, | Enrico | Santus, | and | Regina | Barzi- | | | | | | | +| lay.2019. | Towardsdebiasingfactverificationmod- | | | | | | | | | | | | +els. InEMNLP. +| Amir Soleimani, | | Christof | Monz, | and | Marcel | Worring. | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 2019. | Bert for | evidence | retrieval | | and claim | verifi- | | | | | | | +| cation. | InEuropeanConferenceonInformationRe- | | | | | | | | | | | | +trieval. +| James Thorne, | | Andreas | | Vlachos, | | Christos | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | -------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Christodoulopoulos, | | | and | Arpit | Mittal. | 2018. | | | | | | | +| Fever: | a large-scale | | dataset | for fact | extraction | and | | | | | | | +| verification. | InNAACL. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Guy Tsafnat, | Paul | P Glasziou, | | Miew | Keen | Choong, | | | | | | | +| Adam | G. Dunn, | Filippo | Galgani, | | and | Enrico W. | | | | | | | +| Coiera. | 2014. | Systematic | | review | automation | tech- | | | | | | | +| nologies. | SystematicReviews,3:74–74. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| George Tsatsaronis, | | Georgios | | Balikas, | | Prodromos | | | | | | | +| Malakasiotis, | | Ioannis | Partalas, | Matthias | | Zschunke, | | | | | | | +| Michael | R. Alvers, | | Dirk | Weissenborn, | | Anastasia | | | | | | | +| Krithara, | Sergios | Petridis, | Dimitris | | Polychronopou- | | | | | | | | +| los, Yannis | Almirantis, | | John | Pavlopoulos, | | Nico- | | | | | | | +| las Baskiotis, | | Patrick | Gallinari, | | Thierry | Artie`res, | | | | | | | +| Axel-Cyrille | Ngonga | | Ngomo, | Norman | Heino, | E´ric | | | | | | | +Gaussier,LilianaBarrio-Alvers,MichaelSchroeder, +IonAndroutsopoulos,andGeorgiosPaliouras.2015. +| An overview | | of the | bioasq | large-scale | | biomedical | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +semanticindexingandquestionansweringcompeti- +tion. InBMCBioinformatics. +7544 -TEXT: A worksheet is either paper or is (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): (( -(cid:44)→ environment-friendly. (cid:44)→ Rabbit(Animal) & -Squirrel(Animal)) | (- -FOL: ((Paper(Worksheet) & -EnvironmentFriendly( (cid:44)→ Rabbit(Animal) & Squirrel(Animal))) -(cid:44)→ Worksheet)) | (-Paper(Worksheet) & (Incorrect) Translation 3 (GPT-4): all x. (( -(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(Worksheet))) (cid:44)→ Animal(x) & Rabbit(x)) | (Animal(x) & -TEXT: A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ Squirrel(x))) -FOL: -Dispensable(Worksheet) - Premise: a person either studys or teaches -(Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Study(x) | - (cid:44)→ Teaches(x)) -...premises for sample here, one premise per (Incorrect) Translation 1 (StarCoderPlus): -(cid:44)→ line (cid:44)→ Studys(Person) | Teaches(Person) - (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): (( - (cid:44)→ Study(Person) & -Teach(Person)) | (-Study -...conclusion for sample here (cid:44)→ (Person) & Teach(Person))) - (Correct) Translation 3 (GPT-4): all x. (Studies - (cid:44)→ (x) | Teaches(x)) -Premise: A man is either kind or evil. -E FOLIOErrorAnalysis (Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Kind(x) & - -(cid:44)→ Evil(x)) | (-Kind(x) & Evil(x)) -(Incorrect) Translation 1 (GPT-3.5): ((Man(x) & - -E.1 Ambiguityof“Either”statements -(cid:44)→ Kind(x)) | (-Man(x) & Evil(x))) -Dependingonthecontext,thephrase“eitherxor (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): Kind( -y”couldmeanx XOR y,x OR y,orbeambiguous. (cid:44)→ AMan) | Evil(AMan) -(Incorrect) Translation 3 (StarCoderPlus): (Kind -Throughoutourexperiments,wefoundthatmodels (cid:44)→ (x) | Evil(x)) -hadmanycreativelyincorrectwaysoftranslating -Premise: Ben is either from The Simpsons or -these statements. One reoccurring error was that -(cid:44)→ funny. -statementsthatclearlyintendedx XOR y(suchas, -(Ground Truth) Translation: (Simpsons(Ben) & - -“an animal is either a rabbit or a squirrel”) were (cid:44)→ Funny(Ben)) | (-Simpsons(Ben) & Funny(Ben -translated into x OR y. We tried to account for (cid:44)→ )) -(Correct) Translation 1 (StarCoderPlus): (( -this into account by including multiple samples (cid:44)→ Simpsons(Ben) & -Funny(Ben)) | (-Simpsons -with this construct in the few shot examples (see (cid:44)→ (Ben) & Funny(Ben))) -(Incorrect) Translation 2 (GPT-3.5): ( -Sec. D.4). However, the models still handle this -(cid:44)→ FromTheSimpsons(Ben) | Funny(Ben)) -constructinconsistentlyandincorrectly. (Incorrect) Translation 3 (GPT-4): -Inaddition,wefindthatthroughouttheFOLIO (cid:44)→ FromTheSimpsons(Ben) | Funny(Ben) -dataset,bymatchingthenaturallanguagepremises -totheFOLpremises,wefindnoconsistentorpre- E.2 GPT-4LINCFailureModes -dictable pattern as to how “either x or y” state- -L1: FOL fails to capture implicit information -ments are translated. For example, “an animal is -notmentionedinthepremises. Threeexamples -either a rabbi or a squirrel” is translated as all -oferrorsfromtheFOLIOvalidationsetareshown -x. Rabbit(x) | Squirrel(x),whilewebelieve -below. ThefirsttwooccurringinbothGPT-3.5and -thisinstanceshouldclearlybeXOR.Therefore,we -GPT-4,andthelatteronlyoccursinGPT-3.5and -believethatsomeofthesesamplesareinherently -interestingly, is correct in GPT-4. In Example 1, -ambiguousormalformed. -tomakethecorrectconclusion,wemustencodein -To highlight model behavior on these exam- -FOLthatHarryisaperson(Person(Harry))and -ples, four representative examples from the FO- -that Walden is a book (Book("Walden")). Harry -LIO validation set are shown below; examples -being a person is implicit, but “Walden” being a -have multiple translations because we used tem- -bookisexplicitlymentionedinpremise4butfails -peratureT = 0.8. Here,Correct/Incorrectindicate -to be explicitly encoded by the model. In Exam- -whether the translations match the ground truth -ple 2, we must encode that KiKi is an animal to -(which doesn’t necessarily match how we would -make the correct deduction. One can argue that -translateit). -this example is ambiguous, but from the context, -Premise: an animal is either a rabbit or a -mostwouldmakethisinference. InExample3,we -(cid:44)→ squirrel -(Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Rabbit(x) | needaclausethatsaysLGAandLGAarethesame -(cid:44)→ Squirrel(x)) airport(SameAirport(LGA, LGA)). -(Correct) Translation 1 (GPT-3.5): all x. ( -(cid:44)→ Animal(x) -> (Rabbit(x) | Squirrel(x))) Example 1 (GPT-4) +| A | Modelimplementationdetails | | | | | | | A.3 Trainingthe | | LABELPREDICTION | | | | +| --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +module +AllmodelsareimplementedusingtheHuggingface We adopt similar settings as we used for the RA- +Transformerspackage(Wolfetal.,2019). TIONALESELECTION moduleandonlychangethe +learningrateto1e-5forthetransformerbaseand +| | | | | | | | | 1e-4forthelinearlayerformodelstrainedon | | | | | SCI- | +| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | +| A.1 | Parametersforthefinal | | | | VERISCIsystem | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | FACT,FEVER,andUKPSnopes. | | | | Whentrainingon | | +claim/citedabstractpairslabeledNOINFO,weuse +| Forthe | ABSTRACTRETRIEVALmodule, | | | | | VERISCI | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thek +retrieves the top k = 3 documents ranked by TF- sentencesintheabstractwithgreatestsimi- +| | | | | | | | | laritytotheclaimasrationales(§5). | | | | k issampled | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| IDF | similarity | | using | unigram | + bigram | | features. | | | | | | | +from{0,1}withuniformprobability. +| Theseparametersaretunedonthe | | | | | SCIFACTdevel- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| opmentset. | | | | | | | | A.4 Additionaltrainingdetails | | | | | | +| When | | making | predictions | | using | the | RATIO- | | | | | | | +AllmodelsaretrainedusingasingleNvidiaP100 +NALESELECTIONmoduledescribedin§5,wefind GPUonGoogleColabortoaryProplatform.8 +For +| that | the | usual decision | | rule | of predicting | | zˆ = 1 | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ----- | ---- | ------------- | ------- | ------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | i | theRATIONALESELECTIONmodule,ittakesabout | | | | | | +| when | z˜ | ≥ 0.5 | works | well | for models | trained | on | | | | | | | +| | i | | | | | | | 150 minutes | to | train | on SCIFACT | for 20 epochs. | | +| SCIFACT. | | However,formodelstrainedonFEVER | | | | | | | | | | | | +120minutesonUKPSnopesfor5epochs,and700 +andUKPSnopes,weachievebetterperformance minuteson FEVER for3epochs. Forthe LABEL- +| by | tuning | the classification | | | threshold | t, such | that | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | PREDICTION | module,ittakesabout130minutes | | | | | +| zˆ | = 1 | when z˜ | ≥ | t, on | the SCIFACT | | dev set. | | | | | | | +| i | | | i | | | | | to train | on SCIFACT | | for 20 epochs, | 160 minutes | | +| The | best | threshold | was | t = | 0.025 | when | training | | | | | | | +onUKPSnopesfor5epochs,and640minuteson +| on | FEVER, | and | t = | 0.75 when | training | | on UKP | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +FEVERfor3epochs. +Snopes. +| | | | | | | | | A.5 Hyperparametersearch | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Thelearningrate,batchsize,andnumberofepochs +| A.2 | Trainingthe | | RATIONALESELECTION | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | | arethemostimportanthyperparameters. | | | | Weper- | | +module +formmanualtuningandselectthehyperparameters +| | | | | | | | | that produce | the | highest | F1 on | the development | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | +| We | experiment | | with | various | learning | rates | when | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | set. Forthelearningrate,weexperimentwith1e-3, | | | | | | +training SCIBERT,BioMedRoBERTa,RoBERTa- +base,andRoBERTa-large. Belowwedescribethe 1e-4, 5e-5, 1e-5, and5e-6. Forbatchsize, weex- +settingfortrainingRoBERTa-large. perimentwith64and256. Thenumberofepochs +arecutoffafterthemodelconverges. +| Formodelstrainedon | | | | SCIFACT,weuseanini- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------------------- | --------------- | ----- | ------ | --------------------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | +| tial | learning | rate | of 1e-5 | on | the transformer | | base | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | B Statisticalanalysis | | | | | | +| and | 1e-3 | on the | linear | layer. | For | FEVER | + SCI- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | We assess | the uncertainty | | in the | results reported | | +FACT,thelearningrateissetto1e-5fortheentire +modelforpre-trainingon FEVER andfine-tuning inthemainresults(Table4)usingasimpleboot- +on SCIFACT. Weuseabatchsizeof256through strapapproach(Droretal.,2018;Berg-Kirkpatrick +| | | | | | | | | et al., 2012; | Efron | and | Tibshirani, | 1993). | Given | +| -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | +| gradient | | accumulation | | and | apply cosine | | learning | | | | | | | +ratedecayover20epochstofindthebestperform- our test set with n = 300 claims, we gener- +test +ingmodelonthedevset. ate n = 10,000 bootstrap-resampled test sets +boot +byresampling(uniformly,withreplacement)n +| Formodelstrainedon | | | | FEVER,wesetthelearn- | | | | | | | | | test | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | claimsfromthetestset. | | | Foreachresampledtestset, | | | +ingrateto5e-6forthetransformerbaseand5e-5 +| | | | | | | | | wecomputethemetricsinTable4. | | | | Table6reports | | +| --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| for | the linear | layer. | | For models | trained | | on UKP | | | | | | | +themeanandstandarddeviationofthesemetrics, +Snopes,wesetthelearningrate1e-5forthetrans- +| | | | | | | | | computedoverthebootstrapsamples. | | | | Table7re- | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------- | --- | +| formerbaseand1e-4forthelinearlayer. | | | | | | | Wefind | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | portsdevsetmetrics. | | | Ourconclusionthattraining | | | +thattheselearningrateshelpthemodelsconverge. +onSCIFACTimprovesperformanceisrobusttothe +| We | only | train the | model | for | 3 epochs | on | FEVER | | | | | | | +| --- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +uncertaintiespresentedinthesetables. +| and | 5 epochs | on | UKP | Snopes | because | | they are | | | | | | | +| ------------ | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| larger | datasets | | and the | models | converged | | within | | | | | | | +| earlyepochs. | | | | | | | | 8https://colab.research.google.com/ | | | | | | +7545 -| Premises: | | | | | | choice | of | representation. | | We | show | four | illus- | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------ | -Books contain tons of knowledge. trative examples: the first two examples occur -| When a person | reads | a book, | that | person | gains | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | in both | GPT-3.5 | | and GPT-4, | | while | the last | two | -(cid:44)→ knowledge. -If a person gains knowledge, they become smarter. examples only occur in GPT-3.5 and are correct -| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | whenusingGPT-4. | | | Thefirstexampleisdescribed | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --------------- | ---- | ----- | -------------------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | -| Harry read | the book | "Walden" | by | Henry | Thoreau. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | in the | main | text. | In example | | 2, we | know | that | -Conclusion (Ground Truth: True) Barutin Cove is a cove, but this lost information -| Harry is | smarter than | before. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -isnotencodedintheFOL,sowecannotconclude -| FOLs: | | | | | | Cove(BarutinCove), | | | although | | this is | crucial | in- | -| --------------- | ------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | -| all x. (Book(x) | -> | Contains(x, | | Knowledge)) | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | formationformakingthededuction. | | | | | InExample3, | | | -| all x. all | y. (Person(x) | | & Reads(x, | y) | & Book(y) | | | | | | | | | --> Gains(x, Knowledge)) wemustdeducethatTom’slicenseplateisalicense -(cid:44)→ -all x. (Gains(x, Knowledge) -> Smarter(x)) plate(FromIstanbul(TomPlate)),whichisobvi- -| Reads(Harry, | Walden) | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | ous | but is | not encoded | by | the | model. | In the | final | -Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain) example,theideathatanobjecthasfoursidesisex- -| Smarter(Harry) | | | | | | pressedbothasFourSided(x)andFourSides(x), | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -sothemodelisunabletomakethecorrectdeduc- -| Example 2 | (GPT-4) | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Premises: | | | | | | tion. | | | | | | | | -| If an animal | barks, | then | Jane does | not | like it. | | | | | | | | | -| All dogs | are animals | that | bark. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Example | 1 | (GPT-4) | | | | | | -| If an animal | jumps, | then | Jane likes | it. | | | | | | | | | | -Premises: -| If an animal | has legs, | then | it | jumps. | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --------------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Heinrich | Scmidt | was | a Nazi | German | politician. | | | -| If an animal | is terricolous, | | then | it | has legs. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Heeinrich | | Scmidt was | also | a member | of | the | | -| If KiKi neither | jumps | nor | has legs, | then | KiKi is | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Prussian | State | Parliament | | and | the Nazi | | -| | terricolous | or has | legs. | | | | | | | | | | | -| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Reichstag. | | | | | | | -| Conclusion | (Ground | Truth: | True) | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True): | | | | -| KiKi neither | barks | nor is | a dog. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Heinrich | Schmidt | was | either | German | or | Russian. | | -FOLs: -FOLs: -| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Barks(x) | -> | NotLike(Jane, | x) | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | GermanPolitician(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | & Nazi( | | | -) -| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| all x. (Dog(x) | -> Animal(x) | | & Barks(x)) | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | MemberPrussianStateParliament(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | | & | -| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Jumps(x) | -> | Like(Jane, | x)) | | | | | | | | | -(cid:44)→ MemberNaziReichstag(HeinrichSchmidt) -| all x. (Animal(x) | & | HasLegs(x) | | -> Jumps(x)) | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Terricolous(x) | | -> | HasLegs(x) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain): | | | -) -| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | German(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | Russian( | | | | -| ------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| (-Jumps(KiKi) | & -HasLegs(KiKi)) | | | -> (Terricolous( | | | | | | | | | | -(cid:44)→ HeinrichSchmidt) -| KiKi) | | HasLegs(KiKi)) | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(cid:44)→ -| | | | | | | Example | 2 | (GPT-4) | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Conclusion | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain) | | | | | | | | | | -Premises: -| -Barks(KiKi) | & -Dog(KiKi) | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Barutin | Cove | is named | after | the | Bulgarian | | | -| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ settlement | | of Barutin. | | | | | -| Example 3 | (GPT-3.5): | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Barutin | Cove | is on | the southwest | | coast | of Snow | | -Premises: -(cid:44)→ Island. -| Susan flies | to LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | | The | South | Shetland | Islands | include | Snow | Island, | | -| The departure | and arrival | | can not | be | the same | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Greenwich | | Island, | and | Deception | Island. | | -airport. -| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | The | South | Shetland | Islands | are | considered | part | | -| ------------ | -------- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | -| John flies | from LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ of | Antarctica. | | | | | | -| | | | | | | If A | is located | in | B and | B is | located | in C, | then | -| Conclusion | (Ground | Truth: | False) | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ A | is located | in | C. | | | | -| Susan flies | from LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True) | | | | -| FOLs: | | | | | | There | is at | least | one cove | in | Antarctica | named | | -| Flies(Susan, | LGA) | | | | | | after | a place | in | Bulgaria. | | | | -(cid:44)→ -| all x. all | y. (Departure(x) | | & Arrival(y) | | & - | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| (cid:44)→ SameAirport(x, | | y)) | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | | | -Flies(John, LGA) NamedAfter(BarutinCove, Barutin) & In(Barutin, -Bulgaria) -(cid:44)→ -Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain): On(BarutinCove, SnowIsland) -| Flies(Susan, | LGA) | | | | | In(SnowIsland, | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | | & In( | | -| ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | --------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | | GreenwichIsland, | | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | & | -(cid:44)→ -| | | | | | | | In(DeceptionIsland, | | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -(cid:44)→ -L2: FOL fails to capture information ex- In(SouthShetlandIslands, Antarctica) -plicitly mentioned in the premises due to the all x. all y. all z. ((In(x, y) & In(y, z)) -> +Sentence-level +| | | | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | +| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 | +| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 100.0 | 80.5 | 89.2 | 89.6 | 72.2 | 79.9 | +| | | | | 0.0 | 3.3 | 2.1 | 2.7 | 3.7 3.0 | +Oracle +| | Zero-shot | 2 | 42.6 | 45.2 | 43.8 | 36.2 | 38.4 | 37.2 | +| -------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ------- | +| abstract | | | | 2.2 | 3.2 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 2.3 | +| | VERISCI | 3 | 76.2 | 63.9 | 69.4 | 66.5 | 55.7 | 60.6 | +| | | | | 2.9 | 3.6 | 2.6 | 3.4 | 3.7 3.1 | +| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 100.0 | 56.6 | 72.2 | 87.6 | 49.5 | 63.2 | +| | | | | 0.0 | 4.0 | 3.3 | 3.5 | 3.9 3.7 | +| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 28.7 | 37.6 | 32.5 | 23.8 | 31.1 | 26.9 | +| | | | | 2.3 | 3.4 | 2.3 | 2.3 | 3.1 2.3 | +| | VERISCI | 6 | 45.0 | 47.4 | 46.1 | 38.5 | 40.6 | 39.5 | +| | | | | 3.0 | 3.8 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.6 3.0 | +(a)Sentence-levelresults. +Abstract-level +| | | | | Label-Only | | | Label+Rationale | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | +| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 | +| | | | 90.1 | 77.5 | 83.3 | 90.1 | 77.5 | 83.3 | +| | Oraclerationale | 1 | | 2.2 | 2.8 | 2.4 | 2.2 | 2.8 2.4 | +Oracle +abstract Zero-shot 2 86.9 2.9 53.6 3.4 66.3 3.1 67.9 3.9 41.9 3.2 51.8 3.4 +| | VERISCI | 3 | 87.3 | 2.6 65.3 | 3.2 74.7 | 2.8 84.9 | 2.8 63.5 | 3.2 72.6 2.9 | +| --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | +| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 88.9 | 2.7 54.1 | 3.5 67.2 | 3.2 88.9 | 2.7 54.1 | 3.5 67.2 3.2 | +Open Zero-shot 5 56.0 3.9 42.3 3.4 48.2 3.3 42.3 4.0 32.0 3.2 36.4 3.3 +| | VERISCI | 6 | 47.5 | 3.3 47.3 | 3.5 47.4 | 3.1 46.6 | 3.3 46.4 | 3.5 46.4 3.1 | +| --- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | +(b)Abstract-levelresults +Table 6: Test set results as in Table 4, reporting mean and standard deviation over 10,000 bootstrap samples. +Standarddeviationsarereportedassubscripts. SomemeansreportedhereareslightlydifferentfromTable4due +tosamplingvariability. +Sentence-level +| | | | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | +| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 | +| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 100.0 | 81.9 | 90.0 | 91.4 | 74.9 | 82.3 | +| | | | | 0.0 | 3.2 | 1.9 | 2.5 | 3.6 2.9 | +Oracle +| | Zero-shot | 2 | 40.7 | 48.1 | 44.0 | 36.1 | 42.6 | 39.0 | +| -------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ------- | +| abstract | | | | 2.1 | 3.4 | 2.1 | 2.5 | 3.4 2.5 | +| | VERISCI | 3 | 79.4 | 59.0 | 67.7 | 71.4 | 53.0 | 60.8 | +| | | | | 2.7 | 3.6 | 2.8 | 3.5 | 3.6 3.3 | +| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 100.0 | 58.4 | 73.7 | 90.2 | 52.7 | 66.4 | +| | | | | 0.0 | 4.3 | 3.4 | 3.3 | 4.3 3.9 | +| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 28.6 | 38.5 | 32.8 | 24.8 | 33.4 | 28.4 | +| | | | | 2.0 | 3.6 | 2.3 | 2.2 | 3.4 2.4 | +| | VERISCI | 6 | 52.5 | 43.8 | 47.7 | 46.9 | 39.2 | 42.6 | +| | | | | 3.5 | 3.7 | 3.2 | 3.7 | 3.6 3.2 | +(a)Sentence-levelresults. +Abstract-level +| | | | | Label-Only | | | Label+Rationale | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | ------------ | +| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 | +| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 91.4 | 2.2 76.1 | 3.0 83.0 | 2.5 91.4 | 2.2 76.1 | 3.0 83.0 2.5 | +Oracle +| | Zero-shot | 2 | 88.9 | 2.8 58.3 | 3.7 70.4 | 3.2 69.2 | 3.9 45.4 | 3.5 54.8 3.5 | +| --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | +abstract +| | VERISCI | 3 | 91.0 | 2.3 67.4 | 3.3 77.4 | 2.7 85.2 | 2.9 63.2 | 3.5 72.5 3.1 | +| ---- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | +| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 91.0 | 2.6 53.1 | 3.8 67.0 | 3.4 91.0 | 2.6 53.1 | 3.8 67.0 3.4 | +| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 52.7 | 41.6 | 46.5 | 43.6 | 34.4 | 38.4 | +| | | | | 3.7 | 3.7 | 3.4 | 3.7 | 3.5 3.3 | +| | VERISCI | 6 | 55.4 | 47.5 | 51.0 | 52.6 | 45.1 | 48.5 | +| | | | | 3.7 | 3.6 | 3.3 | 3.7 | 3.6 3.3 | +(b)Abstract-levelresults +Table7: DevsetresultsasinTable4,reportingmeanandstandarddeviationover10,000bootstrapsamples. +7546 -| | (cid:44)→ In(x, | z)) | | | | | Premises: | | | | | | | -| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | There | are | four seasons | in | a year: | Spring, | Summer, | -Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain) (cid:44)→ Fall, and Winter. -exists x. (Cove(x) & In(x, Antarctica) & exists All students who want to have a long vacation -(cid:44)→ y. (In(y, Bulgaria) & NamedAfter(x, y))) (cid:44)→ love summer the most. -| Example | 3 | (GPT-3.5) | | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| Premises: | | | | | | | all | x. (Year(x) | -> | (Spring(x) | | | Summer(x) | | Fall | -All vehicle registration plates in Istanbul (cid:44)→ (x) | Winter(x))) -(cid:44)→ begin with the number 34. all x. (Student(x) & WantsLongVacation(x) -> -Plates that do not begin with the number 34 are Loves(x, Summer)) -(cid:44)→ -| | not | from | Istanbul. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(cid:44)→ -| Joe's | vehicle | registration | | plate | is from | | Prover9 | Error: | | | | | | -| ----- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | -| | Istanbul. | | | | | | The | following | symbols | are | used | with multiple | | -(cid:44)→ -Tom's license plate begins with the number 35. arities: Summer/1, Summer/0. -(cid:44)→ -| If a | license | plate | begins | with | the number | 35, | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | then | it does | not | begin | with the | number | Example | 2 | | | | | | -(cid:44)→ -| | 34. | | | | | | Premises: | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(cid:44)→ -| | | | | | | | Badults | is | a British | Sitcom | series, | starring | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | -| Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | False): | | | | members | of | Pappy's. | | | | -(cid:44)→ -Tom's license plate is from Istanbul. Badults piloted in July 2013 on BBC Three. -| FOLs: | | | | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -all x. (VehicleRegistrationPlate(x) -> exists x. (Badults(x) & BritishSitcom(x) & -| | BeginsWith(x, | | 34)) | | | | | StarringMembersOf(x, | | | Pappys)) | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -all x. (-BeginsWith(x, 34) -> -FromIstanbul(x)) Piloted(Badults, July2013, BBCThree) -FromIstanbul(JoePlate) -| BeginsWith(TomPlate, | | | 35) | | | | Prover9 | Error: | | | | | | -| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -all x. (LicensePlate(x) & BeginsWith(x, 35) -> - The following symbols are used with multiple -| | BeginsWith(x, | | 34)) | | | | | arities: | | Badults/1, | Badults/0. | | | -| ---------- | ------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | -| | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain): | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | While | rarer, | there | are | also | syntax | errors. For | -FromIstanbul(TomPlate) -illustration,twoexamplesfromGPT-4areshown -| Example | 4 | (GPT-3.5) | | | | | below: | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Premises: -| | | | | | | | Premise: | Ailton | Silva | foes | not | play for | a | -| ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | -| All | squares | have | four sides. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | football | | club. | | | | -| All | four-sided | things | are | shapes. | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | FOL: | -Exists | x. (FootballClub(x) | | | & PlaysFor( | | -| | | | | | | | | AiltonSilva, | | x)) | | | | -| Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True): | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Error: | Exists | should | not | be capitalized | | | -| All | squares | are shapes. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Premise: | The | security | deposit | | can be either | | -FOLs: -| | | | | | | | | equal | to | one month's | rent | or more. | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| all | x. (Square(x) | | -> FourSides(x)) | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | FOL: | all x. | all y. | (Rent(x, | y) | -> (Deposit(x) | = | -| all | x. (FourSided(x) | | -> | Shape(x)) | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | y | | Deposit(x) | > | y)) | | | -(cid:44)→ -| | | | | | | | Error: | > is | not allowed | | in Prover9's | FOL | | -| ---------- | ------------------------ | -------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | -| Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain) | | | | | | | | | -| all | x. (Square(x) | | -> Shape(x)) | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | L4: | There | are | mistakes | | in the FOL | trans- | -| | | | | | | | lation. | For | GPT-4, | there | are | very few | transla- | -| L3: | FOLcontainssyntaxerrors. | | | | | Thisisone | | | | | | | | -tionmistakes,butwestillfindacoupleinstances -reasonthatweobservemajorityvotinghelpssig- -whereGPT-3.5failstocapturethesemanticmean- -nificantlyforneurosymbolicmethods,asmultiple -| | | | | | | | ing | of the | NL examples | | properly. | Two | examples | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | -generationsincreasethelikelihoodthatatoneleast -areshownhere: -| oneFOLrepresentationsuccessfullycompiles. | | | | | | As | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----- | --------- | -------- | ----------------------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Premise: | Platypus | | have no | teeth | | | -| stated | in | the main | text, | the most | common | error | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Incorrect | | FOL: -NoTeeth(Platypus) | | | | | -isthatthesamesymbolisusedwithmultipleari- -ties. Twoexamplesofthisareshownbelow: inthe Premise: Imperium doesn't have a feud with a -| | | | | | | | | professional | | wrestling | | stable | that | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -| firstexample,theprimitiveSummerisbothusedas | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | includes | | Ivy Nile. | | | | -(cid:44)→ -a function representing that a year has a summer Incorrect FOL: -all x. (Includes(x, IvyNile) -> - -| | | | | | | | | HasFeud(Imperium, | | | x)) | | | -| --- | --------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| (in | the first | premise) | and | as a | constant | represent- | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | -| ing | that a | student | loves | summer. | A similar | phe- | | | | | | | | -nomenon occurs in the second example with the E.3 GPT-4CoTFailureModes -symbolBadults. -C1: CoTconcludessomethingdifferentthanit -| Example | 1 | | | | | | suggests. | | We show | two | examples | of | this below | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | +| Journal | | | | | Count | | Source citance | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| BMJ | | | | | 60 | | | | | | | | +"Future studies are also warranted to evaluate +the potential association between WNT5A/PCP +| Blood | | | | | | 8 | | | | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +signaling in adipose tissue and +| CancerCell | | | | | | 8 | atherosclerotic CVD, given the major role that | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Cell | | | | | 51 | | IL-6 signaling plays in this condition as | | | | | | +revealed by large Mendelian randomization +| CellMetabolism | | | | | 10 | | studies 44, 45 | | ." | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| CellStemCell | | | | | 41 | | | | | | | | +Claim +| Circulation | | | | | 12 | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +IL-6 signaling plays a major role in +| Immunity | | | | | 33 | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. +| JAMA | | | | | 79 | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MolecularCell 27 Figure 4: A claim written based on a citance. Mate- +MolecularSystemsBiology 5 rialunrelatedtothecitationisremoved. Theacronym +“CVD”isexpandedto“cardiovasculardisease”. +| Nature | | | | | 29 | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| NatureCellBiology | | | | | 26 | | | | | | | | +NatureCommunications 19 ten. Theseretrievalswouldbeincorrectlymarked +| NatureGenetics | | | | | | 8 | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +wrongbyourevaluationmetrics. +| NatureMedicine | | | | | 89 | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Distractorabstractsasdefinedin§3.1havetwo +| NatureMethods | | | | | | 1 | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------------ | +| | | | | | | | qualities | that | make them | a | good addition | to the | +| NucleicAcidsResearch | | | | | 10 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | SCIFACT | corpus: | (1) | They | are cited | in the same | +| PlosBiology | | | | | 36 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | articles | as our | evidence | abstracts, | | meaning that | +| PlosMedicine | | | | | 38 | | | | | | | | +theyoftendiscusssimilartopicsandincreasethe +| Science | | | | | | 7 | difficulty | of | abstract retrieval | | methods | based on | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | +| ScienceTranslationalMedicine | | | | | | 2 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | lexicalsimilarity. | | (2)Theauthorsofourcitances | | | | +| TheLancet | | | | | 22 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | were | aware of | the distractor | | abstracts, | and chose | +| Other | | | | | 120 | | nottomentiontheminthecitancesusedtogenerate | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | claims. | Thismakesthemunlikelytobeasourceof | | | | | +| Total | | | | | 741 | | | | | | | | +falsenegativeretrievals. +| Table8: | Numberofciteddocumentsbyjournal. | | | | | Some | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | C.2 | Annotationexamples | | | | | +co-citedarticles(§3.1)comefromjournalsoutsideour +curatedset;theseareindicatedby“Other”. Converting citances to claims Figure 4 shows +| | | | | | | | an example | | of a citance | re-written | | as a claim. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | The citance | | discusses | the | relationship | between | +C Datasetcollectionandcorpusstatistics +“atheroscleroticCVD”and“IL-6”,andcitestwopa- +| C.1 Corpus | | | | | | | pers(44and45)asevidence. | | | | Toconverttoaclaim, | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | +theacronym“CVD”isexpandedto“cardiovascu- +| Source | journals | Table | 8 shows | | the number | of | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lardisease”,irrelevantinformationisremoved,and +citedabstractsfromeachofourselectedjournals. +theclaimiswrittenasanatomicfactualstatement. +| The “Other” | category | | includes | “co-cited” | | (§3.1) | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +| abstracts | that | came from | journals | | not among | our | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Multiplerationales | | | Figure5showsaclaimsup- | | | +pre-definedset. +| | | | | | | | ported | by two | rationales | from | the same | abstract. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | ---- | -------- | --------- | +Thetextofeachrationaleonitsownissufficientto +| Distractor | abstracts | | In §3.1, | we | mention | how | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ---- | --------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| we increase | the | size of | the corpus | | by adding | dis- | entailtheclaim. | | | | | | +| tractor | abstracts. | The | reason | why | we do not | use | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | C.3 | Annotatorsandqualitycontrol | | | | | +theentiretyofalargeresearchcorpuslikeS2ORC +asourfact-checkingcorpusisthatdoingsowould Claimwriting Studentclaimwritersattendedan +introducemanyfalsenegativeretrievals: abstracts in-person training session where they were intro- +containingevidencerelevanttoagivenclaim,but ducedtothetaskandreceivedin-personfeedback +notmentionedintheclaim’ssourcecitance. This fromthefourexperts. Followingtraining,student +canoccureitherbecausethecitanceauthorssimply annotatorscontinuedwritingclaimsremotely. The +were not aware of these abstracts, or because the expertannotatorsmonitoredclaimsforqualitydur- +abstractswerepublishedafterthecitancewaswrit- ing the remote annotation process, and provided +7547 -(bothofwhichLINCsolvescorrectly). (cid:44)→ needs to apply for CPT if he wants to -(cid:44)→ work in the US. We also know that an -Example 1 (cid:44)→ international student in the US with an -Premises: (cid:44)→ F1 visa needs to apply for CPT or OPT if -Plungers suck. (cid:44)→ the student wants to work in the US. So, -Vacuums suck. (cid:44)→ it is clear that Mike has an F1 visa -Vampires suck. (cid:44)→ since he fits the criteria. Therefore, -Space is a vacuum. (cid:44)→ the conclusion is true. -A duster is a household appliance that doesn't -(cid:44)→ suck. Example 2 -Premises: -Conclusion: If people perform in school talent shows often, -Space is a vampire. (cid:44)→ then they attend and are very engaged -(cid:44)→ with school events. -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step. People either perform in school talent shows -(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Space is a (cid:44)→ often or are inactive and disinterested -(cid:44)→ vampire. We know that Space is a vacuum (cid:44)→ members of their community. -(cid:44)→ and that vacuums suck. However, while it' If people chaperone high school dances, then -(cid:44)→ s true that vampires also suck, this (cid:44)→ they are not students who attend the -(cid:44)→ doesn't mean that everything that sucks (cid:44)→ school. -(cid:44)→ is a vampire. Therefore, there is no All people who are inactive and disinterested -(cid:44)→ reason to believe that Space is a vampire (cid:44)→ members of their community chaperone high -(cid:44)→ based on these premises, so the (cid:44)→ school dances. -(cid:44)→ statement is false. All young children and teenagers who wish to -ANSWER: False (cid:44)→ further their academic careers and -(cid:44)→ educational opportunities are students -Example 2 (cid:44)→ who attend the school. -Premises: Bonnie either both attends and is very engaged -Some mammals have teeth. (cid:44)→ with school events and is a student who -Platypus have no teeth. (cid:44)→ attends the school, or she neither -Platypus are mammals. (cid:44)→ attends and is very engaged with school -Humans have teeth. (cid:44)→ events nor is a student who attends the -(cid:44)→ school. -Conclusion: -Platypus are reptiles. Conclusion (Ground Truth: Uncertain): -Bonnie performs in school talent shows often. -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step. -(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if platypus are (GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step. -(cid:44)→ reptiles. We know from the premises that (cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Bonnie performs -(cid:44)→ platypus are mammals and that they have (cid:44)→ in school talent shows often. Based on -(cid:44)→ no teeth. The fact that some mammals have (cid:44)→ the last premise, if Bonnie is a student -(cid:44)→ teeth does not contradict the fact that (cid:44)→ who attends the school and is very -(cid:44)→ platypus, although mammals, do not have (cid:44)→ engaged with school events, this is only -(cid:44)→ teeth. Moreover, the statement about (cid:44)→ possible if she performs in school talent -(cid:44)→ humans having teeth is unrelated to the (cid:44)→ shows often, as per the first premise. -(cid:44)→ classification of platypus. There's no (cid:44)→ If she doesn't attend and is not engaged -(cid:44)→ evidence in the premises that would (cid:44)→ with school events, she is an inactive -(cid:44)→ suggest platypus are reptiles. Therefore, (cid:44)→ and disinterested member of her community -(cid:44)→ the statement is false. (cid:44)→ . But the fourth premise states that -(cid:44)→ these individuals chaperone high school -C2: CoTmakesincorrectlogicaldeductions. (cid:44)→ dances, meaning they cannot be students, -(cid:44)→ which would contradict the last premise. -Example 1 (cid:44)→ Therefore, Bonnie performs in school -Premises: (cid:44)→ talent shows often, so the statement is -International students in US have either an F1 (cid:44)→ true. -(cid:44)→ visa or a J1 visa. -An international student in US with an F1 visa -(cid:44)→ needs to apply for CPT or OPT if the C3: CoTfailstofindcomplexpathsofreason- -(cid:44)→ student wants to work in the US. ing. Wehighlighttwoexamplesbelow: inthefirst -Mike is an international student. -example, the ground truth is false. To make this -Mike needs to apply for CPT if he wants to work -(cid:44)→ in the US. deduction,onemustreasonthatifaGreyhoundis -aBoeing707,thenitisaplane,whichmeansitis -Conclusion (Ground Truth: Uncertain): -empty, which means it cannot transport multiple -Mike has an F1 visa. -passengers,whichmeansitisnotanairline,which -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step. -meanstherearenoGreyhoundplanes,whichisa -(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Mike has an F1 -contradiction. LookingattheCoTgenerations,the -(cid:44)→ visa. From the premises, we know that -(cid:44)→ Mike is an international student and firstCoTattemptgivesupafterfailingtofindany +https://scifact.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws. +Claim +Antibiotic induced alterations in the gut com/doc/evidence-annotation-instructions. +microbiome reduce resistance against pdf. +Clostridium difficile +| | Decision: | | SUPPORTS | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +Antibiotics can have significant and long- +lasting effects on the gastrointestinal tract +microbiota, reducing colonization resistance +against pathogens including Clostridium +difficile. +Rationale 1 +Our results indicate that antibiotic-mediated +alteration of the gut microbiome converts the +global metabolic profile to one that favours +C. difficile germination and growth. +Rationale 2 +Figure5:Aclaimsupportedbytworationalesfromthe +| same abstract. | The | text | of each | rationale | on its own | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | +providessufficientevidencetoverifytheclaim. +feedbackwhennecessary;low-qualityclaimswere +| returnedtotheannotatorsforre-writing. | | | | | Asafinal | +| ------------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | -------- | +| check, all | submitted | | claims | were proofread | (and | +| edited if | necessary) | by | an | undergraduate | whose | +claimsweredeemedespeciallyhigh-qualitybythe +expertannotators. +| Claim negations | | As | mentioned | in §3.2, | an ex- | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------ | +pertannotatorwroteclaimnegationstointroduce +| caseswhereanabstractREFUTESaclaim. | | | | | Thean- | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +notatorskippedclaimsthatcouldonlybenegated +| by adding | obvious | triggers | | like “not”. | The ma- | +| --------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | ----------- | +| jority of | claim | negations | involved | a | reversal of | +effectdirection;forinstance“Ahighmicroerythro- +cytecountprotectsagainstsevereanemia”canbe +negatedas“Ahighmicroerythrocytecountraises +vulnerabilitytosevereanemia”. +| Claimverification | | | Annotationswereperformed | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------- | ------------- | ------------------------ | -------------- | ---------- | +| remotelythroughawebinterface. | | | | Annotatorswere | | +| required | to pass | a 10-question | | “quiz” | before an- | +| notatingtheirownclaims. | | | Afterpassingthequiz, | | | +subsequentsubmissionswerereviewedbyanNLP +expertuntilthatexpertdeemedtheannotatorreli- +able. Approvedannotatorswerethenassignedto +| revieweachothers’submissions. | | | | Ingeneral,grad- | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | +uatestudentswereassignedtoreviewannotations +fromundergraduates. +D Annotationinterfacesandguidelines +Weshowascreenshotoftheclaimwritinginterface +inFigure6,andtheclaimverificationinterfacein +| Figure7. | Thecompleteannotationguideforclaim | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------------------------------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | +| verification | is | available | at | the following | URL: | +7548 -linkbetweenGreyhoundandBoeing707. Thesec- No young person teaches. -Jerry neither teaches nor is a manager. -ondgenerationattemptstomakedeductionsfrom -Rose is young or a student. -thepremises. Inthiscase,noneofthe10CoTrea- -soningchainsbeginwiththecorrectstepofstarting Conclusion (Ground Truth: True) -Rose is a human or Jerry is a manager. -fromthenegationoftheconclusionanddeducing -itfalse. (GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 1): Let's think step by -Inthesecondexample, tomakethecorrectde- (cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if Rose is a -(cid:44)→ human or Jerry is a manager. Let's first -duction,weneedtostartfromthefactthatRoseis -(cid:44)→ look at Rose. From premise 6, we know -youngorastudent. IfRoseisyoung,thentheydo (cid:44)→ that Rose is either young or a student. -not teach, which means they study, which means (cid:44)→ If Rose is a student, then from premise 1 -(cid:44)→ we know that Rose is a human. If Rose is -theyareastudent,whichmeanstheyareahuman. (cid:44)→ young, we don't know from the premises -IfRoseisastudent,thentheyarehumans. Neither (cid:44)→ whether she is a human. Therefore, it is -oftheCoTgenerationisabletomakeprogresson (cid:44)→ uncertain whether Rose is a human. Now -(cid:44)→ let's look at Jerry. From premise 5, we -the deduction from the information that Rose is (cid:44)→ know that Jerry is not a manager. -young. In addition, the first CoT generation also (cid:44)→ Therefore, Jerry is not a manager. So, it -(cid:44)→ is uncertain whether Rose is a human, -hasalogicalerroratthelaststep,whereitasserts -(cid:44)→ but we know that Jerry is not a manager, -that“AorFalse”isFalsewhenthetruthnessofA (cid:44)→ so the statement is false. -isuncertain. -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 2): Let's think step by -Example 1 (cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if Rose is a -Premises: (cid:44)→ human or Jerry is a manager. First, we -If something can transport multiple passengers, (cid:44)→ know that Jerry neither teaches nor is a -(cid:44)→ then they are not empty. (cid:44)→ manager, which means Jerry is not a -All airlines can transport multiple passengers. (cid:44)→ manager. Therefore, the only way for the -All planes are empty. (cid:44)→ conclusion to be true is if Rose is a -All Boeing 707s are planes. (cid:44)→ human. We know that Rose is either young -If Greyhound is not an airline, then there are (cid:44)→ or a student. If she's a student, since -(cid:44)→ no Greyhound planes. (cid:44)→ all students are humans, then she is a -(cid:44)→ human. However, if Rose is young, we don' -Conclusion (Ground Truth: False) (cid:44)→ t have enough information to determine -A Greyhound is a Boeing 707. (cid:44)→ whether she's a human. Therefore, it's -(cid:44)→ uncertain whether Rose is a human or -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 1): Let's think step by (cid:44)→ Jerry is a manager. -(cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if a Greyhound -(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. Looking at our premises, -(cid:44)→ we have no direct or indirect E.4 SharedmistakesbetweenGPT-4CoTand -(cid:44)→ information linking Greyhounds to Boeing LINC -(cid:44)→ 707s. Given the information available, we -(cid:44)→ cannot make any certain conclusion about AsshowninFig. 5c,thereare21commonerrors -(cid:44)→ a Greyhound being a Boeing 707. betweenGPT-4CoTandGPT-4LINC.Afteranin- -(cid:44)→ Therefore, it is uncertain whether a -(cid:44)→ Greyhound is a Boeing 707. depthanalysisoftheexamples,weseethat16of -theseariseduetoinherenterrorsinthedataset: -(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 2): Let's think step by -(cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if a Greyhound -(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. The first three premises • 2ofthesesamplescontainthesentencefrag- -(cid:44)→ don't provide any information about ment “Either Zaha Hadid’s design style or -(cid:44)→ Greyhound or Boeing 707s. The fourth KellyWearstler’sdesignstyle.” asapremise. -(cid:44)→ premise tells us that all Boeing 707s are -(cid:44)→ planes but doesn't tell us anything This premise is likely intended to mean all -(cid:44)→ about Greyhound. The fifth premise tells designstylesareoneofthesetwostyles,but -(cid:44)→ us that if Greyhound is not an airline, -this is hard for the model to grasp from just -(cid:44)→ then there are no Greyhound planes, but -(cid:44)→ this still doesn't imply that a Greyhound thefragment(sample41,42). -(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. Therefore, we do not -(cid:44)→ have enough information to conclude • 2ofthesesamplescontainthesentencefrag- -(cid:44)→ whether a Greyhound is a Boeing 707 or -ment“EitherfemaletennisplayersatRoland -(cid:44)→ not. So, the statement is uncertain. -Garros2022ormaletennisplayersatRoland -Example 2 -Garros2022.” asapremise(sample43,45). -Premises: -All students are humans. -• 2ofthesesampleshaveanambiguoususeof -If someone studies, then they are a student. -A person either studies or teaches. “either”: “BeniseitherfromTheSimpsonsor +Figure 6: The claim-writing interface. The citation sentence is highlighted in blue on the top left. Additional +context is provided on bottom left. The right side shows two claims that could be written based on this citation +sentence. +7549 -| | | | | | | F ProofwriterStarCoder+Errors | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -funny,”whichinthiscaseambiguouslymeans -XOR.Webelievethissentenceisanunnatural -Wealsoanalyzed,qualitatively,theerrorsthatStar- -usageof“either”(sample142,143). -| | | | | | | Coder+ | makes | on the | ProofWriter | | dataset. | Since | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----- | -premisesfromtheProofWriterdatasetarerelatively -• In4samples,thereisanamethatisimplicitly -| | | | | | | simpleanddirect,lossytranslationisrarer. | | | | | | Moster- | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| an animal, | but | this is | not clear | (sample | 126, | | | | | | | | -rorsareduetosyntaxorimproperrepresentations. -| 127, 128, | 199). | Also, | in samples | | 126-128, | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thereisastatement“IfRockisneitheraflynor Weshowfiverepresentativeerrorsbelow: -a bird, then Rock neither flies nor breathes.” Premise: All quiet people are round. -| | | | | | | StarCoder+ | FOL: | all x. | Quiet(x) | -> | Round(x) | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -thatshouldlikelysay“IfRockneitherfliesnor -| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. (Quiet(x) | | -> Round(x)) | | -| ---------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | -| is a bird, | ...”. | With the | original | formulation, | | | | | | | | | -everythingcouldbeuncertainbecausenothing Premise: If someone is quiet and nice then they -| | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | are cold. | | | | | | -| -------- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| is known | in the | case | that Rock | is a | fly (and | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Starcoder+ | FOL: | all x. | (Quiet(x) | \& | Nice(x)) | -> | -thisisareasonableinterpretation). -(cid:44)→ Cold(x) -| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. ((Quiet(x) | | \& Nice(x)) | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | -> Cold(x)) | | | | | | -• In5samples,theground-truthFOLrepresen- -tationofthenaturallanguagepremiseisincor- -| | | | | | | Premise: | If something | | is furry | then | it is | quiet. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | -rect,causingthelabeltobeincorrect(samples Starcoder+ FOL: Furry(x) -> Quiet(x) -| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. (Furry(x) | | -> Quiet(x)) | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | -29,79,85,86,87). -| | | | | | | Premise: | The cow | eats | the dog. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -• There is a sample where the conclusion is Starcoder+ FOL: Cow(Eats(Dog)) -likely mis-worded and should be “Barutin Ground Truth FOL: Eats(Cow, Dog) -| Cove is | not located | in | Antarctica.” | | instead | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | Premise: | The cow | is blue. | | | | | -of“BarutinisnotlocatedinAntarctica.” This Starcoder+ FOL: Cow(x) \& Blue(x) -| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | Blue(Cow) | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| changesthegroundtruthlabel. | | | | (sample121). | | | | | | | | | -| The remaining | | 5 samples | are | examples | where | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | G StarCoderPlusFOLIOErrorAnalysis | | | | | | | -| bothmethodsfail. | | Inallcases,CoTfailstofindthe | | | | | | | | | | | -correctreasoningchain,asthepremises/reasoning For StarCoder+, we see a slightly different trend. -Meanwhile,LINC -pathisconvolutedandcomplex. InFig. 6a, weseethesamepatternasforGPT-4, -failsasfollows: withamajorityofuncertainpredictions. InFig. 6b, -however,weseethatCoTforStarCoder+primarily -• Insample104,LINCgeneratesseparatesym- -| | | | | | | predictstrue. | Thisislikelybecausethemodelwas | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | ---- | ---- | ---- | ----- | ------- | -| bols for | NotLiveAtHome | | and | -LiveAtHome, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | trained | on much | more | code | than | text, | and may | -whicharesemanticallyequivalent. nothavepickedupsophisticatedtextualchain-of- -| | | | | | | thought | reasoning | capabilities. | | In | Fig. | 6c, we | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | -Insample149,LINCgeneratesFOLsthatmiss -| • | | | | | | | | | | | | CoT | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | can see | that the | mispredictions | | between | | and | -implicit information; i.e. that people with LINCdiffermuchmoreforStarCoder+thanGPT- -namesRoseandJerryarehumans. -| | | | | | | 4. Finally, | in | Fig. | 6d, we | see the | same | trends | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | as we saw | with | GPT-4 | but | more pronounced, | | as | -• Insamples172and173,LINCdoesnotgener- -thesimilaritybetweenmispredictionsinLINCand -ateasinglevalidsetofFOLpremisesbecause -| | | | | | | those in | the baseline | | methods | is even | lower | than | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | -allgeneratedexpressionshaveamismatched -theywereforGPT-4. -arityissue. -| | | | | | | H TheeffectofK-waymajorityvotingon | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Insample193,LINCfailstoexpressthecon- -| • | | | | | | LINCandCoT | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| clusion | correctly: | the | conclusion | is | “If Yuri | | | | | | | | -is not an American basketball player, then In all our experiments, we use 10-way majority -Yuri is a basketball player.”, but the FOLs voting, inspired by prior work which found that -outputted are either -American(Yuri) Chain-of-Thoughtpromptingbenefitedtherefrom -& -BasketballPlayer(Yuri) (Wang et al., 2023b). However, one might won- -| | -American(Yuri) | | | | & | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | -| or | | | | | | der how | robust | the performance | | gains | seen | with | -BasketballPlayer(Yuri) LINCaretotheprecisevalueofK. Figure7thus - -| | T | | | | | 100 | | T | | | | | 100 | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | ru | | | | | | | ru | | | | | | -| | e | | | | | | | | e | | | | | -| | | 31 | 7 | 6 | 0 | | | | 61 | 38 | | 55 0 | | -| | | | | | | 80 | | | | | | | 80 | -| lebaL detciderP | F a | | | | | | lebaL detciderP | F a | | | | | | -| | lse | | | | | | | lse | | | | | | -| | | 1 | 16 | 0 | 0 | | | | 1 | 12 | | 7 0 | | -| | U | | | | | 60 | | U | | | | | 60 | -| | n | | | | | | | n | | | | | | -| | ce | | | | | | | ce | | | | | | -| | rta | | | | | | | rta | | | | | | -| | in | | | | | | | in | | | | | | -| | | 25 | 29 | 55 | 0 | 40 | | | 1 | 4 | | 3 0 | 40 | -| | E | | | | | | | E | | | | | | -| | rro | | | | | | | rro | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 20 | | | | | | | 20 | -| | r | 6 | 2 | 4 | 0 | | | | r 0 | 0 | | 0 0 | | -| | | | | | | 0 | | | | | | | 0 | -| | | e | e | n | or | | | | e | e | | n or | | -| | | u | Fals | ai | | | | | u | Fals | ai | | | -| | | Tr | | ert | Err | | | | Tr | | ert | Err | | -| | | | | nc | | | | | | | nc | | | -| | | | | U | | | | | | | U | | | -| | | | Reference Label | | | | | | | Reference Label | | | | -(a)ConfusionmatrixforLINC. (b)ConfusionmatrixforChain-of-Thought. -| | | | | | | 100 | | L | | | | | 1.0 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -IN -| | C | | | | | | | C | | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | o rre | | | | | | | | 1 | | | | | -| | ct | | | | | 80 | | | | | | | 0.8 | -| | | 37 | | 39 | | | | | | | | | | -| emoctuO ToC | | | | | | | | C o | | | | | | -T -| | | | | | | 60 | S c | | 0.11 | 1 | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | ra | | | | | 0.6 | -tc -h -| | In | | | | | | | p | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| | co | | | | | 40 | | a d | | | | | | -| | rre | | | | | | | | 0.1 | 0.62 | | 1 | | -0.4 -ct -| | | 65 | | 41 | | | | N | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | 20 | | a iv | | | | | | -e -| | | | | | | | | | 0.21 | 0.44 | 0.48 | 1 | 0.2 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | -0 -| | | ect | | ect | | | | | C | T | | d e | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | N | o | | a ai v | | -| | | orr | | orr | | | | | LI | C | h p | N | | -| | | C | | nc | | | | | | | c | | | -| | | | | I | | | | | | | at | | | -cr -| | | | LINC Outcome | | | | | | | | S | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(c) Comparing the consistency of LINC vs (d)Similaritybetweenincorrectpredictionsofeachmethod, -Chain-of-Thought. i.e.,(A wrong == B wrong) / (A wrong or B wrong). -Figure6: AnalyzingandcomparingthemistakesmadebyStarCoder+ontheFOLIOdataset. -shows,foreachmodelequippedwitheitherLINC -Chain-of-Thought, -| or | | | | how the | accuracy | on FO- | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------ | ---- | --- | --------------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -| LIO | varies | with | K ∈ | {1,2,3,...,10}. | We | note | | 1.0 | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | tes tset tuo-dleh no ycaruccA | | StarCoder+-Chain-of-Thought | | GPT-4-Chain-of-Thought | | -that,generallyspeaking,LINCmakesgooduseof StarCoder+-LINC (ours) GPT-4-LINC (ours) -| | | | | | | | | | | GPT-3.5-Chain-of-Thought | | Chance | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- | -0.8 -increasedvaluesofK. Thisisespeciallytruefor GPT-3.5-LINC (ours) -theweakermodels;thesearemorepronetogener- -0.6 -atingsyntacticallyinvalidFOLexpressions,which -| causethesolvertoreturnanError. | | | | | Takingthema- | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0.4 -jorityvoteovermanysamplesthuslessenstherisk -| ofpredictingError,whichisofcoursealwaysthe | | | | | | | | 0.2 | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | ------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| wrong | label. | Notably, | | our results | do not | indicate | | | | | | | | -| | CoT | | | | | | | 0.0 | | | | | | -that benefits from majority voting in this do- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 -main. Futureworkisneededtoestablishhowthis K-way majority vote -relatestothefindingsinthepreviouslymentioned Figure 7: Accuracy on FOLIO per value of K (Ap- -| priorwork. | | | | | | | pendixH).Shadedareasare±1standarddeviationover | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | 1000 | bootstrapped | | samples. | Note | that increasing | K | -benefitsLINC(solidlines;shadingincolor)butnotCoT -| | | | | | | | (dashedlines; | | shadingingray)inourexperimentson | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thisdataset. \ No newline at end of file +Figure7: Theevidencecollectioninterface. +7550 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_4.md b/q0/random_k4/random_4.md index 4e5670a37f0474e9f9d39a1b53abe412288336c0..69d1305f3a9c9c9fb312a4e7dbd3718670cacdd2 100644 --- a/q0/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q0/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,1191 +1,2203 @@ -| | | | | Omanic: | | Towards | Step-wise | | | Evaluation | | of | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | Multi-hop | | Reasoning | | in | Large | Language | | | Models | | | | -XiaojieGu1,SherryT.Tong1,AosongFeng2,SophiaSimengHan3, -JinghuiLu4,YingjianChen1,YusukeIwasawa1,YutakaMatsuo1,ChanjunPark5, -RexYing2,IreneLi1 -1TheUniversityofTokyo,2YaleUniversity,3StanfordUniversity, -4XiaomiEV,5SoongsilUniversity -| | | | Abstract | | | | | technique | | for eliciting | | intermediate | | logical | steps. | -| ---------------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | Yet | growing | evidence | | reveals | that | LLMs | often | -| 6202 raM 71 ]LC.sc[ 1v45661.3062:viXra | Reasoning-focused | | | large | language | models | | | | | | | | | | -exhibitreasoningshortcuts(Shojaeeetal.,2025; -| | (LLMs) | have | advanced | in | many | NLP tasks, | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------ | ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | | Hammoud | | et al., | 2025), | arriving | | at correct | final | -| | yet | their evaluation | | remains | challenging: | | fi- | | | | | | | | | -answersthroughheuristicpatternmatchingrather -| | nal | answers | alone | do not | expose | the inter- | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thanrigorousdeduction,andthathighend-to-end -| | mediate | reasoning | | steps, | making | it difficult | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -to determine whether a model truly reasons accuracycanmasksystematicfailuresininterme- -| | | | | | | | | diate | steps | (Jacovi | et | al., 2024). | | This concern | is | -| --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -| | correctly | and | where | failures | occur, | while | ex- | | | | | | | | | -isting multi-hop QA benchmarks lack step- especially acute in multi-hop reasoning, where -levelannotationsfordiagnosingreasoningfail- -| | | | | | | | | existing | | benchmarks | | such | as HotpotQA | | (Yang | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -ures. Toaddressthisgap,weproposeOmanic, -| | | | | | | | | et al., | 2018) | and | MuSiQue | | (Trivedi | et al., | 2022), | -| --- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------ | -| | an open-domain | | multi-hop | | QA resource | | that | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | despite | | advancing | | evidence | synthesis | | across | -| | provides | decomposed | | sub-questions | | and | in- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | documents, | | lack | step-level | | structural | annotations | | -| | termediate | | answers | as structural | | supervision | | | | | | | | | | -for analyzing reasoning processes. It con- needed to diagnose where and why models fail -| | | | | | | | | along | a | reasoning | chain. | | The absence | | of such | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | -tains10,296machine-generatedtrainingexam- -ples(OmanicSynth)and967expert-reviewed fine-grained ground truth creates a fundamental -human-annotatedevaluationexamples(Oman- blind spot, making it difficult to distinguish -| | icBench). | | Systematic | evaluations | | show | that | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -genuinecompositionalreasoningfromsuperficial -| | state-of-the-art | | LLMs | achieve | only | 73.11% | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -shortcutexploitation(Guetal.,2026). -| | multiple-choice | | accuracy | | on OmanicBench, | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | | To | bridge | this | gap, | we | introduce | | Oman- | -| | confirmingitshighdifficulty. | | | | Stepwiseanaly- | | | | | | | | | | | -icBench(Open-domainMulti-hopquestionswith -sisrevealsthatCoT’sperformancehingeson -ANnotatedreasonIngChain),amulti-hopreason- -factualcompleteness,withitsgainsdiminish- -ing under knowledge gaps and errors ampli- ing benchmark centered on a human-annotated -fying in later hops. Additionally, supervised evaluationsetwithstep-levelstructuralannotations, -fine-tuning on OmanicSynth brings substan- enablingfine-grainedanalysisofmodelreasoning -tialtransfergains(7.41averagepoints)across -| | | | | | | | | behavior. | | OmanicBenchconsistsof967multi-hop | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | six reasoning | | and | math benchmarks, | | validat- | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | questions, | | each | manually | annotated | | and | expert- | -ingthedataset’squalityandfurthersupporting -| | | | | | | | | reviewed | | (over | 300 | hours | of annotation | | effort), | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | -------- | -theeffectivenessofOmanicSynthassupervi- -| | | | | | | | | providing | | high-quality | | ground | truth | for | analyz- | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | ------- | -| | sionforreasoning-capabilitytransfer. | | | | | Were- | | | | | | | | | | -lease the data at https://huggingface.co/ ingreasoningbehavior. Crucially,everyquestion -datasets/li-lab/Omanic.1 isdecomposedintofourcross-domainsingle-hop -sub-questionswithintermediateanswers,drawing -| | 1 Introduction | | | | | | | onrichfactualknowledgeandconnectedthrough | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | mathematical | | reasoning. | | These | reasoning | | chains | -| | As Large | | Language | Models | | (LLMs) | ma- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | areorganizedunderdistinctgraphtopologies. | | | | | | | Be- | -ture(Google,2025;OpenAI,2025;Qwen,2026), -| | | | | | | | | sides, | we | also | release | OmanicSynth, | | a | machine- | -| --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | -| | the research | | frontier | has | progressively | | moved | | | | | | | | | -generatedtrainingsetcontaining10,296instances -| | beyond | single-task | proficiency | | toward | complex | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -forsupervisedtrainingandtransferexperiments. -| | reasoning, | with | Chain-of-Thought | | | (CoT) | (Wei | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Leveragingthestep-wiseannotationsinOmanic, -| | et al., | 2022) | prompting | emerging | | as a | central | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -weconductasystematicanalysisofmulti-hoprea- -1Codeathttps://github.com/XiaojieGu/Omanic soning behaviors in state-of-the-art LLMs. Our +3 +2 +0 +2 + +r +a + +M +7 + +] +L +C +. +s +c +[ + +4 +v +1 +7 +1 +1 +1 +. +3 +0 +2 +2 +: +v +i +X +r +a + +Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +SELF-CONSISTENCY IMPROVES CHAIN OF THOUGHT +REASONING IN LANGUAGE MODELS + +Jason Wei† Dale Schuurmans† Quoc Le† Ed H. Chi† + +Xuezhi Wang†‡ +Sharan Narang† Aakanksha Chowdhery† Denny Zhou†§ +†Google Research, Brain Team +‡xuezhiw@google.com, §dennyzhou@google.com + +ABSTRACT + +Chain-of-thought prompting combined with pre-trained large language models has +achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks. In this paper, we propose +a new decoding strategy, self-consistency, to replace the naive greedy decoding +used in chain-of-thought prompting. It first samples a diverse set of reasoning paths +instead of only taking the greedy one, and then selects the most consistent answer +by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths. Self-consistency leverages the +intuition that a complex reasoning problem typically admits multiple different ways +of thinking leading to its unique correct answer. Our extensive empirical evaluation +shows that self-consistency boosts the performance of chain-of-thought prompting +with a striking margin on a range of popular arithmetic and commonsense reasoning +benchmarks, including GSM8K (+17.9%), SVAMP (+11.0%), AQuA (+12.2%), +StrategyQA (+6.4%) and ARC-challenge (+3.9%). + +1 + +INTRODUCTION + +Although language models have demonstrated remarkable success across a range of NLP tasks, their +ability to demonstrate reasoning is often seen as a limitation, which cannot be overcome solely by +increasing model scale (Rae et al., 2021; BIG-bench collaboration, 2021, inter alia). In an effort +to address this shortcoming, Wei et al. (2022) have proposed chain-of-thought prompting, where +a language model is prompted to generate a series of short sentences that mimic the reasoning +process a person might employ in solving a task. For example, given the question “If there are 3 +cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot?”, instead +of directly responding with “5”, a language model would be prompted to respond with the entire +chain-of-thought: “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + +2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5.”. It has been observed that chain-of-thought prompting significantly +improves model performance across a variety of multi-step reasoning tasks (Wei et al., 2022). + +In this paper, we introduce a novel decoding strategy called self-consistency to replace the greedy +decoding strategy used in chain-of-thought prompting (Wei et al., 2022), that further improves +language models’ reasoning performance by a significant margin. Self-consistency leverages the +intuition that complex reasoning tasks typically admit multiple reasoning paths that reach a correct +answer (Stanovich & West, 2000). The more that deliberate thinking and analysis is required for a +problem (Evans, 2010), the greater the diversity of reasoning paths that can recover the answer. + +Figure 1 illustrates the self-consistency method with an example. We first prompt the language model +with chain-of-thought prompting, then instead of greedily decoding the optimal reasoning path, we +propose a “sample-and-marginalize” decoding procedure: we first sample from the language model’s +decoder to generate a diverse set of reasoning paths; each reasoning path might lead to a different +final answer, so we determine the optimal answer by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths +to find the most consistent answer in the final answer set. Such an approach is analogous to the +human experience that if multiple different ways of thinking lead to the same answer, one has greater +confidence that the final answer is correct. Compared to other decoding methods, self-consistency +avoids the repetitiveness and local-optimality that plague greedy decoding, while mitigating the +stochasticity of a single sampled generation. + +1 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Figure 1: The self-consistency method contains three steps: (1) prompt a language model using +chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting; (2) replace the “greedy decode” in CoT prompting by sampling +from the language model’s decoder to generate a diverse set of reasoning paths; and (3) marginalize +out the reasoning paths and aggregate by choosing the most consistent answer in the final answer set. + +Self-consistency is far simpler than prior approaches that either train an additional verifier (Cobbe +et al., 2021) or train a re-ranker given additional human annotations to improve generation quality +(Thoppilan et al., 2022). Instead, self-consistency is entirely unsupervised, works off-the-shelf with +pre-trained language models, requires no additional human annotation, and avoids any additional +training, auxiliary models or fine-tuning. Self-consistency also differs from a typical ensemble +approach where multiple models are trained and the outputs from each model are aggregated, it acts +more like a “self-ensemble” that works on top of a single language model. + +We evaluate self-consistency on a wide range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks over +four language models with varying scales: the public UL2-20B (Tay et al., 2022) and GPT-3-175B +(Brown et al., 2020), and two densely-activated decoder-only language models: LaMDA-137B +(Thoppilan et al., 2022) and PaLM-540B (Chowdhery et al., 2022). On all four language models, +self-consistency improves over chain-of-thought prompting by a striking margin across all tasks. In +particular, when used with PaLM-540B or GPT-3, self-consistency achieves new state-of-the-art levels +of performance across arithmetic reasoning tasks, including GSM8K (Cobbe et al., 2021) (+17.9% +absolute accuracy gains), SVAMP (Patel et al., 2021) (+11.0%), AQuA (Ling et al., 2017) (+12.2%), +and across commonsense reasoning tasks such as StrategyQA (Geva et al., 2021) (+6.4%) and ARC- +challenge (Clark et al., 2018) (+3.9%). In additional experiments, we show self-consistency can +robustly boost performance on NLP tasks where adding a chain-of-thought might hurt performance +compared to standard prompting (Ye & Durrett, 2022). We also show self-consistency significantly +outperforms sample-and-rank, beam search, ensemble-based approaches, and is robust to sampling +strategies and imperfect prompts. + +2 SELF-CONSISTENCY OVER DIVERSE REASONING PATHS + +A salient aspect of humanity is that people think differently. It is natural to suppose that in tasks +requiring deliberate thinking, there are likely several ways to attack the problem. We propose that +such a process can be simulated in language models via sampling from the language model’s decoder. +For instance, as shown in Figure 1, a model can generate several plausible responses to a math +question that all arrive at the same correct answer (Outputs 1 and 3). Since language models are not +perfect reasoners, the model might also produce an incorrect reasoning path or make a mistake in +one of the reasoning steps (e.g., in Output 2), but such solutions are less likely to arrive at the same +answer. That is, we hypothesize that correct reasoning processes, even if they are diverse, tend to +have greater agreement in their final answer than incorrect processes. + +We leverage this intuition by proposing the following self-consistency method. First, a language +model is prompted with a set of manually written chain-of-thought exemplars (Wei et al., 2022). Next, + +2 + +Language modelQ: If there are 3 cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot?A: There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + 2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5.…Q: Janet’s ducks lay 16 eggs per day. She eats three for breakfast every morning and bakes muffins for her friends every day with four. She sells the remainder for $2 per egg. How much does she make every day?A:She has 16 - 3 - 4 = 9 eggs left. So she makes $2 * 9 = $18 per day. Sample a diverse set of reasoning pathsShe eats 3 for breakfast, so she has 16 - 3 = 13 left. Then she bakes muffins, so she has 13 - 4 = 9 eggs left. So she has 9 eggs * $2 = $18. This means she she sells the remainder for $2 * (16 - 4 - 3) = $26 per day. The answer is $18.The answer is $26.The answer is $18.The answer is $18.Marginalize out reasoning paths to aggregate final answersLanguage modelThis means she uses 3 + 4 = 7 eggs every day. She sells the remainder for $2 per egg, so in total she sells 7 * $2 = $14 per day. The answer is $14.The answer is $14.Greedy decode Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +GSM8K MultiArith + +AQuA + +SVAMP + +CSQA + +ARC-c + +Greedy decode + +56.5 + +94.7 + +35.8 + +79.0 + +79.0 + +85.2 + +Weighted avg (unnormalized) +Weighted avg (normalized) + +56.3 ± 0.0 +22.1 ± 0.0 + +90.5 ± 0.0 +59.7 ± 0.0 + +35.8 ± 0.0 73.0 ± 0.0 74.8 ± 0.0 82.3 ± 0.0 +15.7 ± 0.0 40.5 ± 0.0 52.1 ± 0.0 51.7 ± 0.0 + +Weighted sum (unnormalized) +Weighted sum (normalized) + +59.9 ± 0.0 +74.1 ± 0.0 + +92.2 ± 0.0 +99.3 ± 0.0 + +38.2 ± 0.0 76.2 ± 0.0 76.2 ± 0.0 83.5 ± 0.0 +48.0 ± 0.0 86.8 ± 0.0 80.7 ± 0.0 88.7 ± 0.0 + +Unweighted sum (majority vote) 74.4 ± 0.1 + +99.3 ± 0.0 + +48.3 ± 0.5 86.6 ± 0.1 80.7 ± 0.1 88.7 ± 0.1 + +Table 1: Accuracy comparison of different answer aggregation strategies on PaLM-540B. + +we sample a set of candidate outputs from the language model’s decoder, generating a diverse set of +candidate reasoning paths. Self-consistency is compatible with most existing sampling algorithms, +including temperature sampling (Ackley et al., 1985; Ficler & Goldberg, 2017), top-k sampling (Fan +et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford et al., 2019), and nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al., +2020). Finally, we aggregate the answers by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths and +choosing the answer that is the most consistent among the generated answers. +In more detail, assume the generated answers ai are from a fixed answer set, ai ∈ A, where +i = 1, . . . , m indexes the m candidate outputs sampled from the decoder. Given a prompt and a +question, self-consistency introduces an additional latent variable ri, which is a sequence of tokens +representing the reasoning path in the i-th output, then couples the generation of (ri, ai) where +ri → ai, i.e., generating a reasoning path ri is optional and only used to reach the final answer ai. As +an example, consider Output 3 from Figure 1: the first few sentences “She eats 3 for breakfast ... So +she has 9 eggs * $2 = $18.” constitutes ri, while the answer 18 from the last sentence, “The answer +is $18”, is parsed as ai.1 After sampling multiple (ri, ai) from the model’s decoder, self-consistency +1(ai = a), +applies a marginalization over ri by taking a majority vote over ai, i.e., arg maxa +or as we defined as the most “consistent” answer among the final answer set. + +(cid:80)m + +i=1 + +In Table 1, we show the test accuracy over a set of reasoning tasks by using different answer +aggregation strategies. In addition to majority vote, one can also weight each (ri, ai) by P (ri, ai | +prompt, question) when aggregating the answers. Note to compute P (ri, ai | prompt, question), we +can either take the unnormalized probability of the model generating (ri, ai) given (prompt, question), +or we can normalize the conditional probability by the output length (Brown et al., 2020), i.e., + +P (ri, ai | prompt, question) = exp + +1 +K + +(cid:80)K + +k=1 log P (tk|prompt,question,t1,...,tk−1), + +(1) + +where log P (tk | prompt, question, t1, . . . , tk−1) is the log probability of generating the k-th token +tk in (ri, ai) conditioned on the previous tokens, and K is the total number of tokens in (ri, ai). +In Table 1, we show that taking the “unweighted sum”, i.e., taking a majority vote directly over ai +yields a very similar accuracy as aggregating using the “normalized weighted sum”. We took a closer +look at the model’s output probabilities and found this is because for each (ri, ai), the normalized +conditional probabilities P (ri, ai | prompt, question) are quite close to each other, i.e., the language +model regards those generations as “similarly likely”.2 Additionally, when aggregating the answers, +the results in Table 1 show that the “normalized” weighted sum (i.e., Equation 1) yields a much +higher accuracy compared to its unnormalized counterpart. For completeness, in Table 1 we also +report the results by taking a “weighted average”, i.e., each a gets a score of its weighted sum divided +by (cid:80)m +i=1 + +1(ai = a), which results in a much worse performance. + +Self-consistency explores an interesting space between open-ended text generation and optimal +text generation with a fixed answer. Reasoning tasks typically have fixed answers, which is why +researchers have generally considered greedy decoding approaches (Radford et al., 2019; Wei et al., +2022; Chowdhery et al., 2022). However, we have found that even when the desired answer is fixed, +introducing diversity in the reasoning processes can be highly beneficial; therefore we leverage + +1The parser is task dependent. For arithmetic reasoning, we parse the first numerical part as the final answer +after the model generates “The answer is ”. For commonsense reasoning, we parse the full string answer as the +final answer after the model generates “The answer is ”. Most generated outputs have a consistent format of +“{Reasoning paths}. The answer is X.” if we prompt the language model in this format. + +2This also means that the language model is not well calibrated and thus cannot distinguish well between +correct solutions and wrong solutions, which also explains why additional re-rankers were trained to better judge +the quality of the solutions in previous work (Cobbe et al., 2021; Thoppilan et al., 2022). + +3 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +sampling, as commonly used for open-ended text generation (Radford et al., 2019; Brown et al., 2020; +Thoppilan et al., 2022), to achieve this goal. One should note that self-consistency can be applied +only to problems where the final answer is from a fixed answer set, but in principle this approach can +be extended to open-text generation problems if a good metric of consistency can be defined between +multiple generations, e.g., whether two answers agree or contradict each other. + +3 EXPERIMENTS + +We conducted a series of experiments to compare the proposed self-consistency method with existing +approaches on a range of reasoning benchmarks. We find that self-consistency robustly improves +reasoning accuracy for every language model considered, spanning a wide range of model scales. + +3.1 EXPERIMENT SETUP + +Tasks and datasets. We evaluate self-consistency on the following reasoning benchmarks.3 + +• Arithmetic reasoning. For these tasks, we used the Math Word Problem Repository (Koncel- +Kedziorski et al., 2016), including AddSub (Hosseini et al., 2014), MultiArith (Roy & Roth, +2015), and ASDiv (Miao et al., 2020). We also included AQUA-RAT (Ling et al., 2017), a +recently published benchmark of grade-school-math problems (GSM8K; Cobbe et al., 2021), +and a challenge dataset over math word problems (SVAMP; Patel et al., 2021). + +• Commonsense reasoning. For these tasks, we used CommonsenseQA (Talmor et al., 2019), +StrategyQA (Geva et al., 2021), and the AI2 Reasoning Challenge (ARC) (Clark et al., 2018). +• Symbolic Reasoning. We evaluate two symbolic reasoning tasks: last letter concatenation (e.g., +the input is “Elon Musk” and the output should be “nk”), and Coinflip (e.g., a coin is heads-up, +after a few flips is the coin still heads-up?) from Wei et al. (2022). + +Language models and prompts. We evaluate self-consistency over four transformer-based lan- +guage models with varying scales: + +• UL2 (Tay et al., 2022) is an encoder-decoder model trained on a mixture of denoisers with 20- +billion parameters. UL2 is completely open-sourced4 and has similar or better performance than +GPT-3 on zero-shot SuperGLUE, with only 20B parameters and thus is more compute-friendly; +• GPT-3 (Brown et al., 2020) with 175-billion parameters. We use two public engines code-davinci- +001 and code-davinci-002 from the Codex series (Chen et al., 2021) to aid reproducibility;5 +• LaMDA-137B (Thoppilan et al., 2022) is a dense left-to-right, decoder-only language model with +137-billion parameters, pre-trained on a mixture of web documents, dialog data and Wikipedia; +• PaLM-540B (Chowdhery et al., 2022) is a dense left-to-right, decoder-only language model with +540-billion parameters, pre-trained on a high quality corpus of 780 billion tokens with filtered +webpages, books, Wikipedia, news articles, source code, and social media conversations. +We perform all experiments in the few-shot setting, without training or fine-tuning the language +models. For a fair comparison we use the same prompts as in Wei et al. (2022): for all arithmetic +reasoning tasks we use the same set of 8 manually written exemplars; for each commonsense +reasoning task, 4-7 exemplars are randomly chosen from the training set with manually composed +chain-of-thought prompts.6 Full details on the prompts used are given in Appendix A.3. + +Sampling scheme. To sample diverse reasoning paths, we followed similar settings to those +suggested in Radford et al. (2019); Holtzman et al. (2020) for open-text generation. In particular, for +UL2-20B and LaMDA-137B we applied temperature sampling with T = 0.5 and truncated at the +top-k (k = 40) tokens with the highest probability, for PaLM-540B we applied T = 0.7, k = 40, and +for GPT-3 we use T = 0.7 without top-k truncation. We provide an ablation study in Section 3.5 to +show that self-consistency is generally robust to sampling strategies and parameters. + +3By default we use the test split for all datasets if the labels are available for evaluation. For CommonsenseQA +we use the dev split; for StrategyQA we use the question-only set from BIG-bench collaboration (2021): +https://github.com/google/BIG-bench/tree/main/bigbench/benchmark_tasks/strategyqa. + +4Model checkpoints at https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/ul2. +5Public API available at https://openai.com/api/. +6Self-consistency is robust to different sets of prompts and we provide a study in Appendix A.1.2. + +4 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +3.2 MAIN RESULTS + +We report the results of self-consistency averaged over 10 runs, where we sampled 40 outputs +independently from the decoder in each run. The baseline we compare to is chain-of-thought +prompting with greedy decoding (Wei et al., 2022), referred to as CoT-prompting, which has been +previously used for decoding in large language models (Chowdhery et al., 2022). + +Arithmetic Reasoning The results are shown in Table 2.7 Self-consistency improves the arithmetic +reasoning performance over all four language models significantly over chain-of-thought prompting. +More surprisingly, the gains become more significant when the language model’s scale increases, +e.g., we see +3%-6% absolute accuracy improvement over UL2-20B but +9%-23% for LaMDA- +137B and GPT-3. For larger models that already achieve high accuracy on most tasks (e.g., GPT-3 +and PaLM-540B), self-consistency still contributes significant additional gains with +12%-18% +absolute accuracy on tasks like AQuA and GSM8K, and +7%-11% on SVAMP and ASDiv. With +self-consistency, we achieve new state-of-the-art results on almost all tasks: despite the fact that self- +consistency is unsupervised and task-agnostic, these results compare favorably to existing approaches +that require task-specific training, or fine-tuning with thousands of examples (e.g., on GSM8K). + +Method + +AddSub MultiArith ASDiv + +AQuA + +SVAMP + +GSM8K + +Previous SoTA 94.9a + +60.5a + +75.3b + +37.9c + +57.4d + +35e / 55g + +UL2-20B + +CoT-prompting +Self-consistency 24.8 (+6.6) + +18.2 + +10.7 +15.0 (+4.3) + +16.9 +21.5 (+4.6) 26.9 (+3.3) + +23.6 + +12.6 +19.4 (+6.8) + +4.1 +7.3 (+3.2) + +LaMDA-137B + +PaLM-540B + +GPT-3 +Code-davinci-001 + +CoT-prompting +51.8 +Self-consistency 63.5 (+10.6) 75.7 (+23.9) 58.2 (+9.2) 26.8 (+9.1) + +49.0 + +52.9 + +17.7 + +38.9 +53.3 (+14.4) 27.7 (+10.6) + +17.1 + +CoT-prompting +Self-consistency 93.7 (+1.8) + +91.9 + +94.7 +99.3 (+4.6) + +74.0 +81.9 (+7.9) 48.3 (+12.5) 86.6 (+7.6) + +79.0 + +35.8 + +56.5 +74.4 (+17.9) + +CoT-prompting +59.5 +Self-consistency 67.8 (+10.6) 82.7 (+23.2) 61.9 (+9.2) 25.6 (+6.7) + +52.7 + +57.2 + +18.9 + +39.8 +54.5 (+14.7) 23.4 (+8.8) + +14.6 + +GPT-3 +Code-davinci-002 + +CoT-prompting +Self-consistency 91.6 (+2.2) + +89.4 + +96.2 +100.0 (+3.8) 87.8 (+7.6) 52.0 (+12.2) 86.8 (+11.0) 78.0 (+17.9) + +80.1 + +75.8 + +60.1 + +39.8 + +Table 2: Arithmetic reasoning accuracy by self-consistency compared to chain-of-thought prompting +(Wei et al., 2022). The previous SoTA baselines are obtained from: a: Relevance and LCA operation +classifier (Roy & Roth, 2015), b: Lan et al. (2021), c: Amini et al. (2019), d: Pi et al. (2022), e: +GPT-3 175B finetuned with 7.5k examples (Cobbe et al., 2021), g: GPT-3 175B finetuned plus an +additional 175B verifier (Cobbe et al., 2021). The best performance for each task is shown in bold. + +Method + +CSQA + +StrategyQA ARC-e + +ARC-c + +Letter (4) Coinflip (4) + +Previous SoTA 91.2a + +73.9b + +86.4c + +75.0c + +N/A + +N/A + +UL2-20B + +51.4 +CoT-prompting +Self-consistency 55.7 (+4.3) 54.9 (+1.6) + +53.3 + +61.6 +69.8 (+8.2) 49.5 (+6.8) + +42.9 + +0.0 +0.0 (+0.0) + +50.4 +50.5 (+0.1) + +LaMDA-137B + +CoT-prompting +57.9 +Self-consistency 63.1 (+5.2) 67.8 (+2.4) + +65.4 + +75.3 +79.3 (+4.0) 59.8 (+4.7) + +55.1 + +8.2 +8.2 (+0.0) + +72.4 +73.5 (+1.1) + +PaLM-540B + +79.0 +CoT-prompting +Self-consistency 80.7 (+1.7) 81.6 (+6.3) + +75.3 + +95.3 +96.4 (+1.1) 88.7 (+3.5) + +85.2 + +65.8 +70.8 (+5.0) 91.2 (+3.0) + +88.2 + +GPT-3 +Code-davinci-001 + +CoT-prompting +46.6 +Self-consistency 54.9 (+8.3) 61.7 (+5.0) + +56.7 + +63.1 +72.1 (+9.0) 53.7 (+10.6) 10.0 (+2.2) 75.9 (+4.5) + +43.1 + +71.4 + +7.8 + +GPT-3 +Code-davinci-002 + +CoT-prompting +79.0 +Self-consistency 81.5 (+2.5) 79.8 (+6.4) + +73.4 + +94.0 +96.0 (+2.0) 87.5 (+3.9) + +83.6 + +70.4 +73.4 (+3.0) 99.5 (+0.5) + +99.0 + +Table 3: Commonsense and symbolic reasoning accuracy by self-consistency compared to chain- +of-thought prompting (Wei et al., 2022). The previous SoTA baselines are obtained from: a: +DeBERTaV3-large + KEAR (Xu et al., 2021b), b: Chowdhery et al. (2022), c: UnifiedQA-FT +(Khashabi et al., 2020). The best performance for each task is shown in bold. + +7The standard deviation of self-consistency is ≤ 0.5 for all tasks and is thus omitted in the table. Please refer + +to Figure 2, Figure 7 and 8 for the standard deviations under varying numbers of sampled paths. + +5 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Commonsense and Symbolic Reasoning Table 3 shows the results on commonsense and symbolic +reasoning tasks. Similarly, self-consistency yields large gains across all four language models, and +obtained SoTA results on 5 out of 6 tasks. For symbolic reasoning, we test the out-of-distribution +(OOD) setting where the input prompt contains examples of 2-letters or 2-flips but we test examples +of 4-letters and 4-flips (this setting is more challenging as PaLM-540B or GPT-3 can already achieve +perfect in-distribution accuracy). In this challenging OOD setting, the gain of self-consistency is still +quite significant compared to CoT-prompting with sufficient model sizes. + +To show the effect of the number of sampled reasoning paths, we plot the accuracy (mean and +standard deviation over 10 runs) with respect to varying numbers of sampled paths (1, 5, 10, 20, 40) +in Figure 2. The results show that sampling a higher number (e.g., 40) of reasoning paths leads to a +consistently better performance, further emphasizing the importance of introducing diversity in the +reasoning paths. In Table 4, we show self-consistency yields a richer set of reasoning paths compared +to greedy decoding with a few example questions from two tasks. + +Figure 2: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy over CoT-prompting with greedy +decoding (orange) across arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks, over LaMDA-137B. Sampling +a higher number of diverse reasoning paths consistently improves reasoning accuracy. + +GSM8K + +StrategyQA + +Question Henry made two stops during his 60-mile bike trip. He first stopped after 20 +miles. His second stop was 15 miles before the end of the trip. How many miles +did he travel between his first and second stops? + +Yes or no: Is Albany, Georgia the most populous +US Albany? + +Greedy +Decode + +He traveled 60 miles in total. He stopped after 20 miles, so he traveled 60 - 20 += 40 miles between the first and second stops. The answer is 40. + +Albany, Georgia is the most populous US Al- +bany. Thus, the answer is yes. + +Sampled +Path 1 + +Sampled +Path 2 + +Henry travelled a total of 60 miles. His first stop was 20 miles in, and his +second stop was 15 miles before the end. So between his first and second stops +he travelled 60 - 20 -15 = 25 miles. The answer is 25. + +The most populous US Albany is Albany, New +York. Thus, Albany, Georgia is not the most +populous US Albany. So the answer is no. + +He made two stops during a 60-mile trip. The first was 20 miles into the trip. +The second was 15 miles before the end of the trip. This means the second stop +was 60 - 15 = 45 miles into the trip. Since he made the stops in order, the second +stop must have been 45 - 20 = 25 miles after the first stop. The answer is 25. + +Albany, Georgia has a population of about +88,000. Albany, New York has a population of +about 95,000. Thus, Albany, Georgia is not the +most populous US Albany. So the answer is no. + +Table 4: Examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode, on PaLM-540B. +Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown. + +3.3 SELF-CONSISTENCY HELPS WHEN CHAIN-OF-THOUGHT HURTS PERFORMANCE + +Ye & Durrett (2022) show that sometimes chain-of-thought prompting could hurt performance +compared to standard prompting in few-shot in-context learning. Here we perform a study using +self-consistency to see if it can help fill in the gap, over a set of common NLP tasks, including (1) +Closed-Book Question Answering: BoolQ (Clark et al., 2019), HotpotQA (Yang et al., 2018), and +(2) Natural Language Inference: e-SNLI (Camburu et al., 2018), ANLI (Nie et al., 2020) and RTE +(Dagan et al., 2005; Bar-Haim et al., 2006; Giampiccolo et al., 2007; Bentivogli et al., 2009). + +The results over PaLM-540B are shown in Table 5. For some tasks (e.g., ANLI-R1, e-SNLI, RTE), +adding chain-of-thought does hurt performance compared to standard prompting (Brown et al., 2020), +but self-consistency is able to robustly boost the performance and outperform standard prompting, +making it a reliable way to add rationales in few-shot in-context learning for common NLP tasks. + +ANLI R1 / R2 / R3 e-SNLI RTE BoolQ HotpotQA (EM/F1) + +Standard-prompting (no-rationale) +CoT-prompting (Wei et al., 2022) + +69.1 / 55.8 / 55.8 +68.8 / 58.9 / 60.6 + +Self-consistency + +78.5 / 64.5 / 63.4 + +85.8 +81.0 + +88.4 + +84.8 +79.1 + +86.3 + +71.3 +74.2 + +78.4 + +27.1 / 36.8 +28.9 / 39.8 + +33.8 / 44.6 + +Table 5: Compare Standard/CoT prompting with self-consistency on common NLP tasks. + +6 + +0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505560657075Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths3336394245485154SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths56586062Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505254565860ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path) Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +3.4 COMPARE TO OTHER EXISTING APPROACHES + +We conduct a set of additional studies and show that self-consistency significantly outperforms +existing methods including sample-and-rank, beam search, and ensemble-based approaches. + +Comparison to Sample-and-Rank One commonly used approach to improve generation quality is +sample-and-rank, where multiple sequences are sampled from the decoder and then ranked according +to each sequence’s log probability (Adiwardana et al., 2020). We compare self-consistency with +sample-and-rank on GPT-3 code-davinci-001, by sampling the same number of sequences from the +decoder as self-consistency and taking the final answer from the top-ranked sequence. The results are +shown in Figure 3. While sample-and-rank does improve the accuracy with additionally sampled +sequences and ranking, the gain is much smaller compared to self-consistency. + +Figure 3: Self-consistency significantly outperforms sample-and-rank with the same # of samples. + +Comparison to Beam Search In Table 6, we compare self-consistency with beam search decoding +on the UL2-20B model. For a fair comparison we report the accuracy under the same number of +beams and reasoning paths. On both tasks self-consistency outperforms beam search significantly. +Note self-consistency can also adopt beam search to decode each reasoning path (results are shown +as “Self-consistency using beam search”), but its performance is worse compared to self-consistency +with sampling. The reason is that beam search yields a lower diversity in the outputs (Li & Jurafsky, +2016), while in self-consistency the diversity of the reasoning paths is the key to a better performance. + +Beam size / Self-consistency paths + 1 -| | | | | | | | edge graph | derived | | from Wikipedia. | | These | re- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----- | --- | -trievedtripletsfunctionasthefoundationalbuild- -ingblocksforour4-hopexpansion. -| | | | | | | | Constrained | | Synthesis | | To construct | | 4-hop | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | -queries,wemergeoriginalMuSiQuecomponents -| | | | | | | | with new | single-hop | | questions | synthesized | | from | -| --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | retrievedtriplets,utilizingClaude-Sonnet-4.5. | | | | | | This | -| | | | | | | | process | is governed | | by domain | | constraints | and | -| | | | | | | | reasoning-graphtopology. | | | Eachsynthesizedsingle- | | | | -| Figure 1: | Overview | of | Omanic | construction | pipeline, | | | | | | | | | -where rectangles denote entities and circles denote hopquestionisassignedtooneofeightpredefined -single-hopquestions. domains(e.g.,HistoryandLiterature,ArtandAr- -chitecture),andthesourceWikidatatripletiscon- -| studyrevealstwokeyphenomena. | | | | | First,weiden- | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -textuallyrefinedtoimprovefluencyandcoherence. -| tify a knowledge | | floor | effect, | where | CoT | gains | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Each4-hopinstanceisalsorequiredtocontainat -diminishsharplyasrequiredatomicfactsbecome -| | | | | | | | leastonemathematicallygroundedhop. | | | | | Numerical, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -missing,eventuallydisappearingbeyondacritical -temporal,orcountableattributesarerewritteninto -Second,weobserveerrorpropagation -threshold. -sub-questionsthatrequireexplicitquantitativerea- -| alongreasoningchains: | | | laterhopsconsistentlyex- | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -soning,suchascomparison,aggregation,counting, -| hibit higher | error | rates, | indicating | | that reasoning | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | arithmetic | composition, | | or | temporal | calculation. | | -errorsinherentlyamplifyduringsequentialmulti- -Thismathematicalhopisembeddedintothechain -| hop inference. | | Together, | | these findings | provide | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | ratherthanappendedindependently, | | | | | soitsinputs | | -| new evidence | | that reasoning | | and knowledge | | re- | | | | | | | | -dependonearlierhopsanditsoutputcansupport -trievalconstituteseparablecapabilitiesofLLMs. -| | | | | | | | later ones. | For | each | query, | we randomly | | choose | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -Insummary,wemakethreemaincontributions. -| | | | | | | | one of | three reasoning | | graph | topologies | | (Trivedi | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -| First, we | propose | Omanic, | | the open-domain | | 4- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | et al., 2022) | (Figure | | 6), which | determines | | both | -hopQAbenchmarkwithstructuralannotationsfor -| | | | | | | | question | synthesis | and | final | assembly. | For | exam- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | ----- | -step-levelreasoningdiagnosis,containing10,296 -ple,undertheBridgepattern(Table1),thesecond -trainingand967expert-reviewedtestinginstances, -| | | | | | | | hop depends | on | the first, | and | the | fourth | depends | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -wherestate-of-the-artLLMsonlyachieve73.11% -onboththesecondandthird,preventingshortcut -| accuracy. | Second,weevaluatevariousLLMsand | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | solutions | that bypass | | intermediate | | reasoning. | Fi- | -fine-tuneopen-sourcemodelsonOmanicSynth,ob- -nally,eachsingle-hopquestionispairedwiththree -taining7.41averagepointsimprovementacrosssix -distractors,andtheanswerandoptionsofthelast -externalbenchmarks,showingstrongtransferabil- -hopareusedasthegroundtruthandcandidateset -| ityandhighdataquality. | | | Third,usingsingle-hop | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -forthefull4-hopquery. -decomposition,weempiricallyanalyzetheknowl- -edge floor effect and error propagation in multi- Automated Filtering To maintain a great diffi- -hopreasoning,revealingthatCoTbenefitsrelyon cultyceiling,wefilterthesynthesizeddatasetusing -| factualcompletenessanderrorsamplifyalongthe | | | | | | | | | | models2. | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | an ensemble | of | four | | Any | question | an- | -| reasoningchain. | | | | | | | sweredcorrectlybytwoormoremodelsisdeemed | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | too simple | and | discarded. | | After | pruning, | 3,415 | -2 OmanicConstructionPipeline -| | | | | | | | instances | were | removed, | yielding | | a final | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -Theoverviewofthedatasetconstructionpipeline setof10,296examples. -isillustratedinFigure1. -| | | | | | | | ExpertReview | | Toensurethehighqualityofthe | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Triplets Retrieval To construct the Omanic OmanicBench,1,172candidateinstancesundergo -rigoroushumanauditconductedby10trainedun- -| dataset, | we | begin | with | the answers | | to the | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -original 2-hop questions in MuSiQue (Trivedi dergraduatesandpostgraduatesoverapproximately -et al., 2022), which are themselves composed 300person-hoursviatheLabel Studioplatform3. -of two single-hop questions. These answers For each instance, annotators first verify the fac- -serveasanchorsubjectsforretrievingcorrespond- -2IncludingLlama-3.1-8B-Instruct,Qwen3-8B,Mistral-7B- -ing(subject,relation,object)tripletsfromWiki- -Instruct-v0.3,andGemma-3-4b-it -data5M (Wang et al., 2021), a large-scale knowl- 3https://labelstud.io/ -2 +AQuA + +MultiArith + +Beam search decoding (top beam) +Self-consistency using beam search +Self-consistency using sampling + +Beam search decoding (top beam) +Self-consistency using beam search +Self-consistency using sampling + +23.6 +23.6 + +10.7 +10.7 + +19.8 ± 0.3 21.2 ± 0.7 24.6 ± 0.4 24.2 ± 0.5 +19.7 ± 2.5 24.9 ± 2.6 25.3 ± 1.8 26.7 ± 1.0 26.9 ± 0.5 + +12.0 + +11.3 + +11.0 + +10.5 + +11.8 ± 0.0 11.4 ± 0.1 12.3 ± 0.1 10.8 ± 0.1 +9.5 ± 1.2 11.3 ± 1.2 12.3 ± 0.8 13.7 ± 0.9 14.7 ± 0.3 + +5 + +19.3 + +10 + +16.1 + +20 + +15.0 + +40 + +10.2 + +Table 6: Compare self-consistency with beam search decoding on the UL2-20B model. + +Comparison to Ensemble-based Approaches We further compare self-consistency to ensemble- +based methods for few-shot learning. In particular, we consider ensembling by: (1) prompt order +permutation: we randomly permute the exemplars in the prompt 40 times to mitigate model’s +sensitivity to prompt order (Zhao et al., 2021; Lu et al., 2021); and (2) multiple sets of prompts +(Gao et al., 2021): we manually write 3 different sets of prompts. We took majority vote of the +answers from greedy decoding in both approaches as an ensemble. Table 7 shows that compared to +self-consistency, existing ensemble-based approaches achieve a much smaller gain.8 In addition, note +that self-consistency is different from a typical model-ensemble approach, where multiple models +are trained and their outputs are aggregated. Self-consistency acts more like a “self-ensemble” on +top of a single language model. We additionally show the results of ensembling multiple models in +Appendix A.1.3 where the model-ensembles perform much worse compared to self-consistency. + +GSM8K MultiArith + +SVAMP + +ARC-e + +ARC-c + +CoT (Wei et al., 2022) +Ensemble (3 sets of prompts) +Ensemble (40 prompt permutations) +Self-Consistency (40 sampled paths) + +17.1 +18.6 ± 0.5 +19.2 ± 0.1 +27.7 ± 0.2 + +51.8 +57.1 ± 0.7 +60.9 ± 0.2 +75.7 ± 0.3 + +38.9 +42.1 ± 0.6 +42.7 ± 0.1 +53.3 ± 0.2 + +75.3 +76.6 ± 0.1 +76.9 ± 0.1 +79.3 ± 0.3 + +55.1 +57.0 ± 0.2 +57.0 ± 0.1 +59.8 ± 0.2 + +Table 7: Self-consistency outperforms prompt-order and multi-prompt ensembles on LaMDA-137B. + +8Self-consistency is compatible with both ensemble approaches and we show the results in Appendix A.1.4. + +7 + +0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths12141618202224Accuracy (%)GSM8K0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths50556065707580Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths303540455055Accuracy (%)ARC (Challenge)Self Consistency (Multi-path)Sample & Rank (Multi-path)Greedy Decode (Single-path) Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +3.5 ADDITIONAL STUDIES + +We conducted a number of additional experiments to analyze different aspects of the self-consistency +method, including its robustness to sampling strategies and parameters, and how it works with +imperfect prompts and non-natural-language reasoning paths. + +Self-Consistency is Robust to Sampling Strategies and Scaling We show self-consistency is +robust to sampling strategies and parameters, by varying T in temperature sampling (Ackley et al., +1985; Ficler & Goldberg, 2017), k in top-k sampling (Fan et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford +et al., 2019), and p in nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al., 2020), over PaLM-540B in Figure 4 (left). +Figure 4 (right) shows that self-consistency robustly improves performance across all scales for the +LaMDA-137B model series. The gain is relatively lower for smaller models due to certain abilities +(e.g., arithmetic) only emerge when the model reaches a sufficient scale (Brown et al., 2020). + +Figure 4: GSM8K accuracy. (Left) Self-consistency is robust to various sampling strategies and +parameters. (Right) Self-consistency improves performance across language model scales. + +Self-Consistency Improves Robustness to Imperfect Prompts For few-shot learning with man- +ually constructed prompts, human annotators sometimes make minor mistakes when creating the +prompts. We further study if self-consistency can help improve a language model’s robustness to +imperfect prompts.9 We show the results in Table 8: while imperfect prompts decrease accuracy with +greedy decoding (17.1 → 14.9), self-consistency can fill in the gaps and robustly improve the results. + +Additionally, we found that the consistency (in terms of % of decodes agreeing with the final +aggregated answer) is highly correlated with accuracy (Figure 5, over GSM8K). This suggests that +one can use self-consistency to provide an uncertainty estimate of the model in its generated solutions. +In other words, one can use low consistency as an indicator that the model has low confidence; i.e., +self-consistency confers some ability for the model to “know when it doesn’t know”. + +Prompt with correct chain-of-thought + +17.1 + +LaMDA-137B + +Prompt with imperfect chain-of-thought 14.9 +23.4 + ++ Self-consistency (40 paths) + +Prompt with equations + ++ Self-consistency (40 paths) + +PaLM-540B + +Zero-shot CoT (Kojima et al., 2022) + ++ Self-consistency (40 paths) + +5.0 +6.5 + +43.0 +69.2 + +Table 8: Self-consistency works under imperfect prompts, equa- +tion prompts and zero-shot chain-of-thought for GSM8K. + +Figure 5: The consistency is cor- +related with model’s accuracy. + +Self-Consistency Works for Non-Natural-Language Reasoning Paths and Zero-shot CoT We +also tested the generality of the self-consistency concept to alternative forms of intermediate reasoning +like equations (e.g., from “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there +are 3 + 2 = 5 cars.” to “3 + 2 = 5”). The results are shown in Table 8 (“Prompt with equations”): +self-consistency still improves accuracy by generating intermediate equations; however, compared to +generating natural language reasoning paths, the gain is smaller since the equations are much shorter +and less opportunity remains for generating diversity in the decoding process. In addition, we tested +self-consistency with zero-shot chain-of-thought (Kojima et al., 2022) and show that self-consistency +works for zero-shot CoT as well and improves the results significantly (+26.2%) in Table 8. + +9We use the same prompts as before, but swap all the numbers in the reasoning paths with random numbers +except the final answer, e.g., from “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + +2 = 5 cars.” to “There are 7 cars in the parking lot already. 6 more arrive. Now there are 7 + 6 = 5 cars.”. + +8 + +0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths444852566064687276Accuracy (%)T=0.7, k=40T=0.5, k=40T=0.3, k=40T=0.7, k=20T=0.7, no top kp=0.95p=0.9Greedy Decode125102050100200Model size (#param in billions)510152025Accuracy (%)Self ConsistencyGreedy Decode020406080100Consistency (%)020406080100Accuracy (%) Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +4 RELATED WORK + +Reasoning in language models. Language models are known to struggle in Type 2 tasks, such as +arithmetic, logical and commonsense reasoning (Evans, 2010). Previous work has primarily focused +on specialized approaches for improving reasoning (Andor et al., 2019; Ran et al., 2019; Geva et al., +2020; Pi˛ekos et al., 2021). Compared to prior work, self-consistency is applicable to a wide range of +reasoning tasks without any additional supervision or fine-tuning, while still substantially improving +the performance of the chain-of-thought prompting approach proposed in Wei et al. (2022). +Sampling and re-ranking in language models. Multiple decoding strategies for language models +have been proposed in the literature, e.g., temperature sampling (Ackley et al., 1985; Ficler & +Goldberg, 2017), top-k sampling (Fan et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford et al., 2019), +nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al., 2020), minimum Bayes risk decoding (Eikema & Aziz, 2020; Shi +et al., 2022), and typical decoding (Meister et al., 2022). Other work has sought to explicitly promote +diversity in the decoding process (Batra et al., 2012; Li et al., 2016; Vijayakumar et al., 2018). + +Re-ranking is another common approach to improve generation quality in language models (Adiwar- +dana et al., 2020; Shen et al., 2021). Thoppilan et al. (2022) collect additional human annotations +to train a re-ranker for response filtering. Cobbe et al. (2021) train a “verifier” to re-rank generated +solutions, which substantially improves the solve rate on math tasks compared to just fine-tuning the +language model. Elazar et al. (2021) improve the consistency of factual knowledge extraction by +extending pre-training with an additional consistency loss. All these methods require either training +an additional re-ranker or collecting additional human annotation, while self-consistency requires no +additional training, fine-tuning, nor extra data collection. +Extract reasoning paths. Some previous work has considered task-specific approaches for iden- +tifying reasoning paths, such as constructing semantic graphs (Xu et al., 2021a), learning an RNN +to retrieve reasoning paths over the Wikipedia graph (Asai et al., 2020), fine-tuning with human +annotated reasoning paths on math problems (Cobbe et al., 2021), or training an extractor with +heuristic-based pseudo reasoning paths (Chen et al., 2019). More recently, the importance of di- +versity in the reasoning processes has been noticed, but only leveraged via task-specific training, +either through an additional QA model over extracted reasoning paths (Chen et al., 2019), or by the +introduction of latent variables in a commonsense knowledge graph (Yu et al., 2022). Compared to +these approaches, self-consistency is far simpler and requires no additional training. The approach +we propose simply couples the generation of reasoning paths and a final answer by sampling from +the decoder, using aggregation to recover the most consistent answer without additional modules. +Consistency in language models. Some prior work has shown that language models can suffer +from inconsistency in conversation (Adiwardana et al., 2020), explanation generation (Camburu et al., +2020), and factual knowledge extraction (Elazar et al., 2021). Welleck et al. (2020) use “consistency” +to refer to generating an infinite-length sequence in recurrent language models. Nye et al. (2021) +improve the logical consistency of samples from a System 1 model by adding a System 2-inspired +logical reasoning module. In this paper we focus on a slightly different notion of “consistency”, i.e., +utilizing answer consistency among diverse reasoning paths to improve accuracy. + +5 CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION + +We introduced a simple yet effective method called self-consistency, and observed that it significantly +improves accuracy in a range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks, across four large +language models with varying scales. Beyond accuracy gains, self-consistency is also useful for +collecting rationales when performing reasoning tasks with language models, and for providing +uncertainty estimates and improved calibration of language model outputs. + +One limitation of self-consistency is that it incurs more computation cost. In practice people can try a +small number of paths (e.g., 5 or 10) as a starting point to realize most of the gains while not incurring +too much cost, as in most cases the performance saturates quickly (Figure 2). As part of future work, +one could use self-consistency to generate better supervised data to fine-tune the model, such that the +model can give more accurate predictions in a single inference run after fine-tuning. In addition, we +observed that language models can sometimes generate incorrect or nonsensical reasoning paths (e.g., +the StrategyQA example in Table 4, the two population numbers are not exactly correct), and further +work is needed to better ground models’ rationale generations. + +9 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +REPRODUCIBILITY STATEMENT + +In experiments, we included four different language models with varying scales. Two of them are pub- +lic models: UL2 is a completely open-sourced model with model checkpoints available at https:// +github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/ul2; GPT-3 is +also a public model with public API available at https://openai.com/api/. For GPT-3, +we have included two public engines (“code-davinci-001” and “code-davinci-002”) to further aid +reproducibility, as Codex is currently free so anyone can reproduce the results. In addition, as our +results make use of LaMDA-137B and PaLM-540B that are not publicly available, we provide the +exact input prompts for all tasks in Appendix A.3 (and note that we do not perform any finetuning +and only apply prompting to off-the-shelf language models). + +ETHICS STATEMENT + +As we stated in the discussion, language models can sometimes generate nonsensical or non-factual +reasoning paths, so one should use language models’ outputs with extra caution. We deal with +reasoning tasks mostly and the generated rationales are only used for inspecting how a model reaches +its answer. One could potentially use the generated rationales to further check why the model makes +certain mistakes or whether the model contains any biases when performing a certain task. For +language model in real-world use, further work is needed to better ground models’ predictions and +improve model’s factuality and safety, to ensure the models do not cause harms to users. + +REFERENCES + +David H. Ackley, Geoffrey E. Hinton, and Terrence J. Sejnowski. A learning algorithm for boltzmann +machines. Cognitive Science, 9(1):147–169, 1985. ISSN 0364-0213. URL https://www. +sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0364021385800124. + +Daniel Adiwardana, Minh-Thang Luong, David R. So, Jamie Hall, Noah Fiedel, Romal Thoppilan, +Zi Yang, Apoorv Kulshreshtha, Gaurav Nemade, Yifeng Lu, and Quoc V. Le. Towards a human-like +open-domain chatbot, 2020. + +Aida Amini, Saadia Gabriel, Shanchuan Lin, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Yejin Choi, and Hannaneh +Hajishirzi. MathQA: Towards interpretable math word problem solving with operation-based +In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of the North American Chapter of the +formalisms. +Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, Volume 1 (Long +and Short Papers), pp. 2357–2367. Association for Computational Linguistics, June 2019. URL +https://aclanthology.org/N19-1245. + +Daniel Andor, Luheng He, Kenton Lee, and Emily Pitler. Giving BERT a calculator: Finding +operations and arguments with reading comprehension. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on +Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference +on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), 2019. URL https://aclanthology. +org/D19-1609. + +Akari Asai, Kazuma Hashimoto, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Richard Socher, and Caiming Xiong. Learn- +ing to retrieve reasoning paths over wikipedia graph for question answering. In International +Conference on Learning Representations, 2020. URL https://openreview.net/forum? +id=SJgVHkrYDH. + +Roy Bar-Haim, Ido Dagan, Bill Dolan, Lisa Ferro, Danilo Giampiccolo, Bernardo Magnini, and +Idan Szpektor. The second pascal recognising textual entailment challenge. In Proceedings of the +second PASCAL challenges workshop on recognising textual entailment, 2006. + +Dhruv Batra, Payman Yadollahpour, Abner Guzman-Rivera, and Gregory Shakhnarovich. Diverse +m-best solutions in markov random fields. In Proceedings of the 12th European Conference on +Computer Vision - Volume Part V, ECCV’12, pp. 1–16, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2012. Springer-Verlag. +ISBN 9783642337147. URL https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-33715-4_1. + +10 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Luisa Bentivogli, Peter Clark, Ido Dagan, and Danilo Giampiccolo. The fifth pascal recognizing + +textual entailment challenge. In TAC, 2009. + +BIG-bench collaboration. Beyond the imitation game: Measuring and extrapolating the capabil- +In preparation, 2021. URL https://github.com/google/ + +ities of language models. +BIG-bench/. + +Tom Brown, Benjamin Mann, Nick Ryder, Melanie Subbiah, Jared D Kaplan, Prafulla Dhariwal, +Arvind Neelakantan, Pranav Shyam, Girish Sastry, Amanda Askell, Sandhini Agarwal, Ariel +Herbert-Voss, Gretchen Krueger, Tom Henighan, Rewon Child, Aditya Ramesh, Daniel Ziegler, +Jeffrey Wu, Clemens Winter, Chris Hesse, Mark Chen, Eric Sigler, Mateusz Litwin, Scott Gray, +Benjamin Chess, Jack Clark, Christopher Berner, Sam McCandlish, Alec Radford, Ilya Sutskever, +and Dario Amodei. Language models are few-shot learners. In Advances in Neural Information +Processing Systems, 2020. URL https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper/2020/ +file/1457c0d6bfcb4967418bfb8ac142f64a-Paper.pdf. + +language inference with natural + +Oana-Maria Camburu, Tim Rocktäschel, Thomas Lukasiewicz, and Phil Blunsom. + +snli: Natural +gio, H. Wallach, H. Larochelle, K. Grauman, N. Cesa-Bianchi, +(eds.), Advances +Information Processing Systems 31, +Curran Associates, +8163-e-snli-natural-language-inference-with-natural-language-explanations. +pdf. + +e- +In S. Ben- +and R. Garnett +pp. 9539–9549. +URL http://papers.nips.cc/paper/ + +language explanations. + +in Neural +Inc., + +2018. + +Oana-Maria Camburu, Brendan Shillingford, Pasquale Minervini, Thomas Lukasiewicz, and Phil +Blunsom. Make up your mind! adversarial generation of inconsistent natural language explanations. +In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, pp. +4157–4165, Online, July 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020. +acl-main.382. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.acl-main.382. + +Jifan Chen, Shih-Ting Lin, and Greg Durrett. Multi-hop question answering via reasoning chains. + +CoRR, abs/1910.02610, 2019. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1910.02610. + +Mark Chen, Jerry Tworek, Heewoo Jun, Qiming Yuan, Henrique Ponde de Oliveira Pinto, Jared +Kaplan, Harri Edwards, Yuri Burda, Nicholas Joseph, Greg Brockman, et al. Evaluating large +language models trained on code. arXiv preprint arXiv:2107.03374, 2021. + +Aakanksha Chowdhery, Sharan Narang, Jacob Devlin, Maarten Bosma, Gaurav Mishra, Adam +Roberts, Paul Barham, Hyung Won Chung, Charles Sutton, Sebastian Gehrmann, Parker Schuh, +Kensen Shi, Sasha Tsvyashchenko, Joshua Maynez, Abhishek Rao, Parker Barnes, Yi Tay, Noam +Shazeer, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Emily Reif, Nan Du, Ben Hutchinson, Reiner Pope, James +Bradbury, Jacob Austin, Michael Isard, Guy Gur-Ari, Pengcheng Yin, Toju Duke, Anselm Lev- +skaya, Sanjay Ghemawat, Sunipa Dev, Henryk Michalewski, Xavier Garcia, Vedant Misra, Kevin +Robinson, Liam Fedus, Denny Zhou, Daphne Ippolito, David Luan, Hyeontaek Lim, Barret Zoph, +Alexander Spiridonov, Ryan Sepassi, David Dohan, Shivani Agrawal, Mark Omernick, Andrew M. +Dai, Thanumalayan Sankaranarayana Pillai, Marie Pellat, Aitor Lewkowycz, Erica Moreira, Rewon +Child, Oleksandr Polozov, Katherine Lee, Zongwei Zhou, Xuezhi Wang, Brennan Saeta, Mark +Diaz, Orhan Firat, Michele Catasta, Jason Wei, Kathy Meier-Hellstern, Douglas Eck, Jeff Dean, +Slav Petrov, and Noah Fiedel. Palm: Scaling language modeling with pathways, 2022. URL +https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.02311. -| ReasoningGraph | | Multi-hopQuestion | | | | | | Single-hopComposition | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | InthecountryofcitizenshipoftheauthorofCandida, | | | | | | 1. WhoistheauthorofCandida?BernardShaw | | | | | -whichpoliticalpartywasfoundedthesamenumberof -| | | | | | | | | 2. WhatisthecountryofcitizenshipofBernardShaw? | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | yearsbefore1968asthenumberofdistinct3-member | | | | | | Ireland | | | | | -committeesthatcanbeformedfromagroupof7candi- -| | | | | | | | | 3. Howmanydistinct3-membercommitteescanbeformed | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | dates?FineGael | | | | | | fromagroupof7candidates?35 | | | | | -[A:FineGaelB:LabourPartyC:FiannaFáilD:Sinn 4. InIreland,whichpoliticalpartywasfounded35years -Féin] -before1968?FineGael -Table1: Anexampleillustratingthemulti-hopreasoninggraphanditsstep-by-stepquestiondecomposition. -| tual correctness | | of every | sub-question | | and | its an- | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | MCQ | ExactMatch | F1-Score | -| swer by | consulting | the | Wikipedia | | articles | linked | | | | | | | -ProprietaryLLMs -totheunderlyingtriplets;forquestionsinvolving -| | | | | | | | GPT-5.4 | | | 49.22 | 22.85 | 32.22 | -| ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| mathematical | reasoning, | | annotators | | are | addition- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | GPT-5.4CoT | | | 70.84 | 27.09 | 43.58 | -allyrequiredtoprovidedetailedstep-by-stepcom- -| | | | | | | | Claude-Sonnet-4.6 | | | 55.43 | 20.73 | 37.15 | -| ---------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------ | -| putations. | They | then examine | | the | logical | coher- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Claude-Sonnet-4.6CoT | | | 73.11 | 14.81† | 32.27† | -| ence of | the full | 4-hop reasoning | | chain, | checking | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Gemini-3.1-flash-lite | | | 44.88 | 23.47 | 32.31 | -whetheritconformstothedesignatedgraphtopol- -| | | | | | | | Gemini-3.1-flash-liteCoT | | | 72.60 | 23.99 | 35.72 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -ogy,andthenassignqualityscoresacrossmultiple -| | | | | | | | Qwen3-Max | | | 49.02 | 17.79 | 26.31 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -dimensions(factualaccuracy,distractorplausibil- Qwen3-MaxCoT 72.08 35.99 45.51 -| ity, fluency, | and | reasoning | integrity) | | following | a | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Open-sourceLLMs -standardizedrubric(detailedinAppendixA).They -| | | | | | | | Qwen2.5-72B | | | 42.19 | 13.24 | 19.43 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -alsoverifythecorrectnessoftherequirednumer- -| | | | | | | | Qwen3-32B | | | 52.22 | 12.10 | 18.35 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -icaloperationsinmathematicallygroundedhops, -| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8B | | | 25.65 | 9.26 | 13.77 | -| ----------------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| ensuring | that intermediate | | calculations | | and | final | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8BSFT | | | 53.62 | 10.97 | 16.60 | -| derivedvaluesarearithmeticallyconsistent. | | | | | | Where | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8BSFT+GRPO | | | 53.77 | 11.79 | 17.98 | -deficienciesareidentified,annotatorsdirectlycor- -| | | | | | | | LLaMA-3.3-70B | | | 40.04 | 11.77 | 20.47 | -| --------- | ------------ | ------------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| rect the | instance | or supplement | | supporting | | refer- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | LLaMA-3.3-70BSFT | | | 57.55 | 19.42 | 29.04 | -| ences and | derivations. | | Instances | failing | | to meet | | | | | | | -predefinedqualitythresholdswereexcluded,yield- Table 2: Performance comparison of proprietary and -ingafinalsetof967high-qualityinstancesasthe open-sourceLLMsonOmanicBench. Subscriptsindi- -evalset. AninstanceisshowninTable1. cate different prompting and training settings. Bold -| | | | | | | | marks | the best | result | per metric. | †: discuss | in Ap- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | -pendixB.2. -3 ExperimentsandAnalysis -3.1 ModelsandSetup tion setting, we report Exact Match (EM), which -ToassessthequalityandutilityofOmanic,weeval- requiresstrictstringequivalencewiththegoldan- -uate a diverse set of proprietary and open-source swer,andF1-Score,whichcapturespartialcredit -atthetokenlevel(Rajpurkaretal.,2016). -| LLMs under | multiple | | settings. | For | proprietary | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -models(e.g.,GPT-5(Singhetal.,2025)),weeval- -| uate both | direct | answering | and | CoT | prompting. | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Foropen-sourcemodels(e.g.,Qwen3-8B(Qwen, -2025)),weadditionallyfine-tuneselectedmodels -| on the | Omanic | training | set | via supervised | | fine- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tuning(SFT)andGRPO-based(Shaoetal.,2024) -| reinforcementlearning. | | | Toexaminewhethertrain- | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ing on OmanicSynth | | transfers | | to broader | | reason- | | | | | | | -ingcapabilities,wefurtherevaluatethefine-tuned -modelsacrossmultiplereasoningbenchmarks(e.g., -| | | | | | | | Figure2: | Comparisonofaccuracyacrossbenchmarks | | | | | -| ---- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | --------- | ---------------- | ----- | -| MATH | (Hendrycks | et al., | 2021)). | | For evaluation | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | between | the | vanilla | model and | its counterparts | fine- | -onOmanicBench,wereportthreecomplementary -tunedonOmanicSynth. -| metricsacrosstwoevaluationparadigms. | | | | | | Forthe | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -multiple-choicequestionsetting,weuseMultiple- -| | | | | | | | 3.2 | MainResults | | | | | -| ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Choice | Question(MCQ) | | accuracy | | (Xinjie | et al., | | | | | | | -2025), which measures selection accuracy over Table 2 presents the overall performance of all -fourcandidateoptions. Fortheopen-endedgenera- evaluated models on OmanicBench. Proprietary -3 +Christopher Clark, Kenton Lee, Ming-Wei Chang, Tom Kwiatkowski, Michael Collins, and Kristina +Toutanova. Boolq: Exploring the surprising difficulty of natural yes/no questions. In NAACL, +2019. -LLMsconsistentlyoutperformopen-sourcecoun- To investigate this question, we group multi-hop -terparts,andCoTpromptingyieldsnotablegains questionsbythenumberofconstituentsingle-hop -across all proprietary models on MCQ. Among questionsansweredincorrectly,andthenmeasure -proprietarymodels,Claude-Sonnet-4.6 achieves multi-hopaccuracywithineachgroup. Asshown -CoT -thehighestMCQaccuracy(73.11),whileQwen3- in Figure 3 (left), even in the zero-error group, -Max leadsinopen-endedgeneration. Foropen- multi-hopaccuracyunderDirectpromptingreaches -CoT -sourcemodels,aftertrainingonOmanicSynth,we onlyabout60%,wellbelowceiling,indicatingthat -observe substantial improvements across all fine- multi-hopreasoningandsingle-hopknowledgere- -tuned models (e.g., Qwen3-8B MCQ: 25.65 → trievalarenotequivalent. Meanwhile,CoTgainde- -53.77),confirmingthatOmanicBenchposesagen- creasesmonotonicallyasthenumberoferroneous -uinechallengeforcurrentLLMswhileremaining single-hop steps increases, dropping to near zero -amenable to targeted training. Notably, we also (−0.7) when three steps are incorrect, while the -comparetheoutputlength,asshowninTable10, largest gain (+21.9) is observed in the zero-error -theperformancegainsfromCoTforsomemodels group. These results quantify a clear knowledge -comeatsubstantiallyhigherinferencecosts. While flooronOmanicBench: effectiveCoTrequiressuf- -Qwen3-Max achievesthebestopen-endedper- ficientfactualgrounding,sharpeningcompositional -CoT -formance,itsoutputtokenlengthfarexceedsthat inferencebutnotsubstitutingformissingfacts. -ofallothermodels. Incontrast,GPT-5.4 CoT iscon- RQ2: To what extent do errors amplify -siderablymoreefficientinpractice. toward the end of a multi-hop reasoning -Tofurtherassessthetransferabilityofskillsac- chain?(Pressetal.,2023)Toquantifythiseffect, -quired from OmanicSynth, we evaluate the fine- wecomparetwoevaluationprotocols: independent -tuned models on established reasoning (Yu et al., evaluation, where each step receives the gold an- -2020;Liuetal.,2021;Wangetal.,2022;Saparov swertopriorsingle-hopquestions;andchainevalu- -andHe,2023)andmathematics(Cobbeetal.,2021) ation,whereanswersfrompreviousstepspropagate -benchmarks. AsshowninFigure2,fine-tunedmod- tosubsequentsteps. AsshowninFigure3(right), -els consistently outperform their vanilla counter- evenunderindependentevaluation,Step4already -parts,demonstratingthatOmanicSynthcomprises exhibitsasubstantiallyhighererrorratethanear- -high-quality, non-trivial instances that cultivate liersteps,revealinganinherentdifficultygradient -genuinecomplexlogicalreasoningandmathemat- inOmanicBenchbeyondpurepropagationeffects. -ical reasoning capabilities rather than superficial Underchainevaluation,errorscompound: Step4 -pattern matching or factual knowledge retrieval reachesa33.0%errorrateunderDirectprompting, -alone. Allimplementationdetailsareprovidedin 4.7 points higher than under independent evalua- -theAppendixB.1. tion. While CoT reduces absolute error rates at -every step, the amplification pattern remains in- -3.3 KeyObservations -tact,suggestingthatsequentialmulti-hopinference -Beyondaggregateperformance,thestep-levelan- is intrinsically more fragile in later hops. Taken -notations in OmanicBench allow us to quantita- together, these analyses show that OmanicBench -tivelyexaminetworesearchquestionsaboutmulti- is not only a benchmark for end-to-end accuracy, -hopreasoningbehavior. butalsoadiagnostictestbedforquantifyingwhere -RQ1: TowhatextentdoesCoTrelyonasuffi- reasoning breaks down and how strongly errors -cientknowledgefoundation?(Wangetal.,2023) compoundacrosshops. -4 Conclusion -WepresentOmanic,anopen-domainmulti-hopQA -benchmarkintegratingmathematicalreasoningand -factualinference,withdecomposedsingle-hopsub- -questionsasreasoningannotations. Analysisshows -thatCoTgainsdependonfactualcompletenessand -Figure3: ResultsaveragedacrossLLMsunderDirect -that errors propagate along the reasoning chain. -andCoTprompting. Left: Multi-hopaccuracybynum- -WereleaseOmanicasadiagnosticbenchmarkto -berofsingle-hoperrors. Right: Step-wiseerrorrates -facilitatefutureresearchonmulti-hopreasoning. -underindependentandchainevaluation. -4 +Peter Clark, Isaac Cowhey, Oren Etzioni, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Carissa Schoenick, and +Oyvind Tafjord. Think you have solved question answering? try arc, the ai2 reasoning challenge. +ArXiv, abs/1803.05457, 2018. -Limitations -| | | | | | | | Jian Liu, Leyang | Cui, Hanmeng | | Liu, | Dandan | Huang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Yile Wang, | and Yue | Zhang. | 2021. | Logiqa: | a | -Omanichasseverallimitationsthatsuggestdirec- challenge dataset for machine reading comprehen- -| | | | | | | | sion with | logical reasoning. | | In Proceedings | | of the | -| --------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -| tions for | future | work. | First, | the benchmark | | is re- | | | | | | | -strictedtoEnglishonly,limitingitsapplicabilityto Twenty-NinthInternationalConferenceonInterna- -| | | | | | | | tional Joint | Conferences | on | Artificial | Intelligence, | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | -| multilingualreasoningevaluation. | | | | Second,while | | | | | | | | | -pages3622–3628. -| 4-hop questions | | represent | a | meaningful | increase | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -incomplexityoverexisting2-hopbenchmarks,ex- https://openai.com/ -| | | | | | | | OpenAI. 2025. | Gpt5.1. | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tendingtolongerreasoningchains(e.g.,6-hopor ja-JP/index/introducing-gpt-5/. Retrieved -December12,2025. -| 8-hop) would | | further | test the | limits | of composi- | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tional reasoning. | | Third, | although | Omanic | | spans | | | | | | | -OfirPress,MuruZhang,SewonMin,LudwigSchmidt, -eightknowledgedomains,certainspecializeddo- -| | | | | | | | NoahASmith,andMikeLewis.2023. | | | | Measuring | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -mains(e.g.,legal,biomedical)remainunderrepre- andnarrowingthecompositionalitygapinlanguage -| | | | | | | | models. | InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputa- | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | ------------------------------ | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| sented. | Fourth, | thedatasetscale(10,296training | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | EMNLP2023,pages5687–5711. | | | | | -| and 967 | test | instances) | is moderate; | | scaling | up | | | | | | | -throughbroaderknowledgegraphcoveragecould -| | | | | | | | Qwen. 2025. | Qwen3 | technical | report. | | Preprint, | -| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | --------- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| improvebothtrainingutilityandevaluationrobust- | | | | | | | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -ness -| | | | | | | | Qwen.2026. | Pushingqwen3-max-thinkingbeyondits | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -limits. -References -PranavRajpurkar,JianZhang,KonstantinLopyrev,and -| Karl Cobbe, | Vineet | Kosaraju, | | Mohammad | Bavarian, | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | PercyLiang.2016. | Squad: | | 100,000+questionsfor | | | -MarkChen,HeewooJun,LukaszKaiser,Matthias machinecomprehensionoftext. InProc.EMNLP. -| Plappert, | Jerry | Tworek, | Jacob | Hilton, | Reiichiro | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John Schulman. AbulhairSaparovandHeHe.2023. Languagemodels -| 2021. | Training | verifiers | to solve | math | word | prob- | | | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | aregreedyreasoners: | | Asystematicformalanalysis | | | | -lems. arXivpreprintarXiv:2110.14168. -| | | | | | | | ofchain-of-thought. | | InTheEleventhInternational | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. -| Google.2025. | | Gemini-3-pro. | | https://docs.cloud. | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -google.com/vertex-ai/generative-ai/docs/ -| | | | | | | | Zhihong Shao, | Peiyi Wang, | | Qihao Zhu, | Runxin | Xu, | -| -------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -| models/gemini/3-pro. | | | Retrieved | | December | 12, | | | | | | | -JunxiaoSong,XiaoBi,HaoweiZhang,Mingchuan -2025. -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | YK Li, Yang | Wu, | and | 1 others. | 2024. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Deepseekmath: | Pushingthelimitsofmathematical | | | | | -KenGu,AdvaitBhat,MikeAMerrill,RobertWest,Xin -| | | | | | | | reasoninginopenlanguagemodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | | -| ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| Liu,DanielMcDuff,andTimAlthoff.2026. | | | | | | Synth- | | | | | | | -| worlds: | Controlledparallelworldsfordisentangling | | | | | | arXiv:2402.03300. | | | | | | -reasoningandknowledgeinlanguagemodels. -| | | | | | | | Parshin Shojaee, | Iman | Mirzadeh, | Keivan | | Alizadeh, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------- | -Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Hani Itani, and MaxwellHorton,SamyBengio,andMehrdadFara- -| Bernard | Ghanem. | 2025. | Beyond | the | last | answer: | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------- | ------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | jtabar.2025. | Theillusionofthinking:Understanding | | | | | -Yourreasoningtraceuncoversmorethanyouthink. the strengths and limitations of reasoning models -ArXivpreprintarXiv:2504.20708. viathelensofproblemcomplexity. arXivpreprint -arXiv:2506.06941. -DanHendrycks,CollinBurns,SauravKadavath,Akul -Arora,StevenBasart,EricTang,DawnSong,andJa- -AadityaSingh,AdamFry,AdamPerelman,AdamTart, -| cobSteinhardt.2021. | | | Measuringmathematicalprob- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AdiGanesh,AhmedEl-Kishky,AidanMcLaughlin, -| lem solving | | with the | math dataset. | | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AidenLow,AJOstrow,AkhilaAnanthram,and1oth- -arXiv:2103.03874. -| | | | | | | | ers.2025. | Openaigpt-5systemcard. | | | arXivpreprint | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -arXiv:2601.03267. -| Edward | J Hu, | Phillip | Wallis, | Zeyuan | Allen-Zhu, | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| YuanzhiLi, | | SheanWang, | LuWang, | | WeizhuChen, | | | | | | | | -HarshTrivedi,NiranjanBalasubramanian,TusharKhot, -| and 1 | others. | 2023. Lora: | Low-rank | | adaptation | of | | | | | | | -| -------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | and Ashish | Sabharwal. | 2022. | Musique: | | Multi- | -| largelanguagemodels. | | | InInternationalConference | | | | | | | | | | -hopquestionsviasingle-hopquestioncomposition. -onLearningRepresentations. -TACL. -AlonJacovi,YonatanBitton,BerndBohnet,Jonathan -Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Siyuan Wang, Zhongkun Liu, Wanjun Zhong, Ming -Collins, Roee Aharoni, and Mor Geva. 2024. A Zhou,ZhongyuWei,ZhuminChen,andNanDuan. -chain-of-thoughtisasstrongasitsweakestlink: A 2022. Fromlsat:Theprogressandchallengesofcom- -benchmarkforverifiersofreasoningchains. InProc. plexreasoning. IEEE/ACMTransactionsonAudio, -| ofACL. | | | | | | | Speech,andLanguageProcessing,30:2201–2216. | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -5 +Karl Cobbe, Vineet Kosaraju, Mohammad Bavarian, Mark Chen, Heewoo Jun, Lukasz Kaiser, +Matthias Plappert, Jerry Tworek, Jacob Hilton, Reiichiro Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John +Schulman. Training verifiers to solve math word problems, 2021. -XiaozhiWang,TianyuGao,ZhaochengZhu,Zhengyan -Zhang,ZhiyuanLiu,JuanziLi,andJianTang.2021. -| Kepler: | Aunifiedmodelforknowledgeembedding | | | | | -| --------------- | ---------------------------------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -| and pre-trained | | language | representation. | | Transac- | -tionsofACL. -XuezhiWang,JasonWei,DaleSchuurmans,QuocVLe, -| EdHChi, | SharanNarang, | | AakankshaChowdhery, | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| andDennyZhou.2023. | | | Self-consistencyimproves | | | -| chainofthoughtreasoninginlanguagemodels. | | | | | In | -TheEleventhInternationalConferenceonLearning -Representations. -JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten -Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou, -| and1others.2022. | | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelic- | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | -| its reasoning | | in large language | | models. | Proc. of | -NeurIPS. -JianWu,LinyiYang,ZhenWang,ManabuOkumura, -| andYueZhang.2025. | | Cofca: | Astep-wisecounter- | | | -| ---------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------------------- | -------------- | -------- | -| factualmulti-hopqabenchmark. | | | | InProc.ofICLR. | | -| Zhao Xinjie, | Fan | Gao, Xingyu | Song, | Yingjian | Chen, | -| Rui Yang, | Yanran | Fu, Yuyang | Wang, | Yusuke | Iwa- | -| sawa,YutakaMatsuo,andIreneLi.2025. | | | | | ReAgent: | -| Reversible | multi-agent | | reasoning | for knowledge- | | -| enhancedmulti-hopQA. | | | InProceedingsofthe2025 | | | -| Conference | on | Empirical | Methods | in Natural | Lan- | -guageProcessing,pages4067–4089,Suzhou,China. -AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. -ZhilinYang,PengQi,SaizhengZhang,YoshuaBengio, -WilliamCohen,RuslanSalakhutdinov,andChristo- -| pher D | Manning. | 2018. | Hotpotqa: | A dataset | for | -| -------- | -------------------------------------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | -| diverse, | explainablemulti-hopquestionanswering. | | | | | -InProc.ofEMNLP. -WeihaoYu,ZihangJiang,YanfeiDong,andJiashiFeng. -| 2020. | Reclor: | Areadingcomprehensiondatasetre- | | | | -| ------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -| quiringlogicalreasoning. | | | InInternationalConfer- | | | -enceonLearningRepresentations. -AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris -| Callison-Burch.2024. | | Fanoutqa: | Amulti-hop,multi- | | | -| -------------------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -documentquestionansweringbenchmarkforlarge -| language | models. | In Proceedings | | of the | 62nd An- | -| -------- | ------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational -| Linguistics(Volume2: | | ShortPapers),pages18–37. | | | | -| -------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -6 +11 -A HumanAnnotationGuidance& – 2(Poor): Multiplecriticalfactsornumerical -DatasetStatistics valuesareincorrect,significantlyimpacting -the understanding of the problem. Evident -Werecruit10undergraduateandgraduatestudents -misuse of terminology or factual conflicts -toconductthehumancorrectionandscoringpro- -severelydamagestheprofessionalismofthe -cess. To ensure ethical research practices, all an- -content. -notators are compensated at a rate exceeding the -– 1(VeryPoor): Containsseverefactualerrors, -local minimum wage. The entire project encom- -falsestatements, orentirelyfabricated"hal- -passesacumulativetotalof200person-hours. The -lucinations." The question and answer fail -detailedhumanannotationguidanceislistedinthe -to correspond, or most content contradicts -following: -knownfacts. -Forsingle-hopquestions: -• Distractor Quality: This criterion evaluates -• Factuality and Accuracy: This criterion as- -whetherthethreeincorrectoptions(distractors) -sesses the truthfulness and precision of the -aresufficientlydeceptiveandbelongtoaplau- -question-answer pair within real-world con- -siblelogicalcategory. Annotatorsfollowfour -texts, specific subject areas, or the provided -steps: -knowledge source. Annotators follow four -1. Category Consistency Check. Verify that -steps: -all distractors belong to the same logical -1. Core Element Extraction. Identify key en- category as the correct answer (e.g., if the -tities (names, locations, events, dates) and answer is a location, distractors must also -logicalrelationshipsinthequestion. belocations). -2. Cross-Source Verification. Verify each en- 2. Domain Relevance Analysis. Assess -tity’sattributesusingreliabledatabases,en- whether distractors share geographic, tem- -cyclopedias,orauthoritativereferences. poral,orthematicproximitywiththecorrect -3. Terminology and Value Audit. Check that answerwithinthesamedomain. -specializedtermsarespelledcorrectlyand 3. TrapLogicIdentification. Examinewhether -thatanynumericalcomputationsareerror- distractors exploit plausible intermediate- -free. steperrorsorcommonover-simplifications -4. FinalScoring. Assignascorebasedonthe (e.g.,arithmeticnear-missesortemporally -number and severity of errors (critical vs. adjacententities). -minor). 4. FinalScoring. Assignascore: ifdistractors -arenearlyindistinguishablewithoutfullrea- -– 5(Excellent): Allkeyterms,concepts,dates, -soning,score5;iftheyspanunrelatedcate- -and numerical values are entirely accurate. -gories,score1–2. -The content is supported by authoritative -evidence, remains free of "hallucinations" – 5(HighlyDeceptive): Alldistractorsbelong -or misleading information, and utilizes pre- tothesamedomain. Numericaloptionsrep- -ciseterminologyconsistentwithfieldconven- resentlogical"traps"(e.g.,calculationnear- -tions. misses), while semantic options consist of -– 4(Good): Mostfactsareaccurate,withonly easily confused synonyms, similar institu- -minor flaws in non-core details that do not tions, or entities derived from intermediate -hinderoverallunderstanding. Terminologyis reasoningsteps. -generally correct, though it may be slightly – 4(Effective): Distractorsarewithinareason- -simplifiedwhileremainingacceptablewithin ablescope(e.g.,foraquestionaboutEurope, -thedomain. alldistractorsareEuropean). Theformatis -– 3 (Satisfactory): Core facts are fundamen- highly consistent with the answer, making -tallycorrect,buterrorsexistthatcouldlead themimpossibletoexcludeviasimpleword- -topartialmisunderstanding. Somekeyterms classorlogicalloopholes. -maybepoorlytranslatedorexpressed,requir- – 3 (Moderate): Distractors share attributes -ingthereadertoinferthetrueintentbasedon withtheanswer(e.g.,bothareyearsorloca- -commonsense. tions),butoneortwooptionscanbequickly -7 + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 -excludedusinggeneralknowledgeorobvious the core meaning is conveyed, it may omit -| contextclues. | | | | | | | someimportantconstraintsorincludeirrele- | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -– 2 (Weak): Distractors belong to the same vantinformation;grammarerrorsarepresent -broadcategorybutpossessobviousattribute butthemeaningremainsclear. -differences(e.g.,askingforauniversityname – 2 (Poor): Lacks fluency with abrupt transi- -whileprovidingacountrynameasadistrac- tionsandunclearlogicalconnections. Core -tor)orinconsistentformatting. informationisincomplete,containingsignif- -– 1(Non-existent): Distractorsarecompletely icant omissions or serious errors that affect -irrelevant or cross-domain (e.g., a "year" theabilitytojudgethecorrectanswer. -question with "apple" as an option). These – 1 (Very Poor): Language is extremely un- -| are | illogical | "fillers" | | that can | be instantly | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | natural | or unintelligible, | | containing | severe | -| identified. | | | | | | | grammaticalandlogicalerrors. | | | Thecontent | | -organizationischaoticandfailstoreflectthe -| • Fluency | and | Completeness: | | | This criterion | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -originalintentofthequestion. -| evaluates | whether | | the language | | is natural, | the | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| logic | is clear, | the | grammar | is | correct, | and all | For4-hopquestions: | | | | | -| necessary | constraints | | for | a unique | answer | are | | | | | | -provided. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: • LogicalIntegrityandTechnicalFormatting: -| | | | | | | | This criterion | evaluates | the | structural | rigor of | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -| 1. NaturalnessFirst-Read. | | | | Readthequestion | | | | | | | | -themulti-hopreasoningchainandthestandard- -asanativespeaker,checkingforawkward -izeduseofLaTeX,technicalterminology,and -| phrasing, | | inverted | word | order, | or | logical | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | codeformatting. | Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: | | | | -discontinuities—payingspecialattentionto -subordinateclausesandpronounreferences 1. Logic Chain Decomposition. Break the -| | | | | | | | multi-hop | question | into | an explicit | path | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ---- | -inlongersentences. -2. ConstraintCompletenessScan. Verifythat A → B → C → D andidentifyeachinter- -| thequestionstemcontainseveryconstraint | | | | | | | mediatenode. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | 2. Input–OutputMatching. | | | Verifythattheout- | | -necessarytoderiveauniquecorrectanswer -(e.g.,specificyears,inclusive/exclusivecon- putofeachprecedinghopiscorrectlyused -| ditions). | | | | | | | as the | input condition | | for the subsequent | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -| 3. GrammarandSpellingCheck. | | | | | Inspectpunc- | | hop. | | | | | -| | | | | | | | 3. SymbolandCodeAudit. | | | CheckthatallLa- | | -tuation,capitalizationofpropernouns,and -| tenseconsistency. | | | | | | | TeX formulas, | mathematical | | notation, | cur- | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ---- | -4. Final Scoring. Assign a score: flawless rency symbols, and code blocks are cor- -rectlyrenderedandunaltered. -grammarwithaself-containedinformation -loopscores5;translationartifactsormissing 4. Consistency Determination. Confirm that -critical constraints lower the score accord- thelogicchainformsaclosedloopwithno -| ingly. | | | | | | | breaksorcircularreasoning. | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -– 5(Excellent): Expressionisextremelynatu- – 5 (Excellent): The reasoning chain is per- -ralandsmooth,fullyadheringtonativeusage fectlyairtightwithoutgapsorcircularity. All -habits. Thestructureisrigorouswithappro- LaTeXsymbols,mathematicalformulas,and -priatelogicalconnectivesandzerogrammati- currency signs ($) are technically flawless -calerrors. Alloriginaldetailsandnecessary andcorrectlyrendered. -constraintsarepreservedwithoutomission. -| | | | | | | | – 4(Good): | Thelogicalchainiscompleteand | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | sound, | though the | natural | language | transi- | -| – 4 (Good): | | Expression | | is basically | | natural | | | | | | -with only minor linguistic flaws. The main tions between hops may feel slightly rigid. -meaning is preserved, though some non- Technical formatting is basically standard- -critical descriptive details may be missing. izedwithonlynegligiblelayoutflaws. -| Sentence | | structures | follow | standard | | norms | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | – 3(Satisfactory): | Aminorlogicalflawexists | | | | -withnegligibleerrors. (e.g.,ambiguouspronounreferencelike"the -– 3(Satisfactory): Expressionisslightlyrigid artist"whenmultipleartistsarementioned), -or exhibits a "translation-ese" tone. While requiringthereadertore-readtoclarifythe -8 +Ido Dagan, Oren Glickman, and Bernardo Magnini. The pascal recognising textual entailment -| steps. TerminologyorLaTeXsymbolsmay | | | | | conflictispresent. | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -showslightformattingdeviations. -| | | | | | – 2(Poor): | Significantfactualflawsappearin | | | -| ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| – 2 (Poor): | Relationships | | between | multiple | | | | | -intermediatesteps(e.g.,asingle-hopanswer -hopsareunclear,orcriticalpremisesarelost is"11years"butistreatedas"12years"dur- -duetopoorphrasing,preventingasuccessful ingthemulti-hopcalculation),renderingthe -logical"closed-loop."Formattingischaotic, finalresultunreliable. -withLaTeXsymbolsorcodeblocksappear- -| | | | | | – 1(VeryPoor): | Aseverefactualerrorexists | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -inggarbled. -inatleastoneintermediatestep,orthetime- -– 1(VeryPoor): Thelogicalchainisentirely line is logically impossible (e.g., a divorce -brokenorresultsinaparadox(e.g.,askingfor occurringbeforethemarriage). -a"year"butrequiringa"monetaryamount" -as the answer). Terminology is highly un- • AnswerObscurityandLeakagePrevention: -professional,andformattinghascompletely This criterion evaluates whether the question -| collapsed. | | | | | stem accidentally | reveals | the final answer | or | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | -ifthereasoningstepsprovideasufficientchal- -| • ContextualFactConsistency: | | | | Thiscriterion | | | | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -lenge. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: -verifieswhetherallsingle-hopfactsremainfac- -tuallyaccurateandconflict-freewhenamalga- 1. KeywordFiltering. Searchthequestionstem -mated into a multi-hop narrative. Annotators for the final answer itself or any strongly -characteristiccuesthatdirectlypointtoit. -followfoursteps: -| | | | | | 2. ShortcutTest. | Attempttoreachthecorrect | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| 1. Atomic | Fact | Backtracking. | | Compare each | | | | | -answerwithoutcompletingtheintermediate -backgroundclaiminthemulti-hopquestion -hops—relyingonlyonthefinalsegmentof -(e.g.,adate,atitle,anumericvalue)against -thequestionorgeneralknowledge. -theoriginalsingle-hopdata. -| | | | | | 3. Distractor | Elimination | Check. Assess | | -| ----------------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------- | ---- | -| 2. Spatiotemporal | | Conflict | Detection. | Verify | | | | | -| | | | | | whether | the stem provides | enough | non- | -| that the | combined | timeline | | is logically co- | | | | | -logicalinformationtoruleoutallincorrect -| herent | (e.g., | an appointment | | in 1877 re- | | | | | -| ------ | ------ | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -optionswithoutgenuinereasoning. -| quires | the predecessor’s | | tenure | to overlap | | | | | -| ------ | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 4. FinalScoring. | Ifeveryreasoningstepisin- | | | -orprecedethatdate). -dispensableforreachingtheanswer,score5; -| 3. ModifierVerification. | | | Checkwhetherqual- | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ifthefinalsegmentalonemakestheanswer -ifiersaddedduringcomposition(e.g.,“the -obvious,lowerthescoreaccordingly. -| large | art school”) | inadvertently | | alter the | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | -| originalmeaning. | | | | | – 5(Excellent): | Noleakage. | Thesolvermust | | -4. FinalScoring. Ifallintermediate-nodefacts completeeveryreasoningsteptofindthean- -arecorrectandtransitionsarenatural,assign -swer. Thefinalansweroritsdistinctcharac- -thefullscore. -teristicsdonotappear,directlyorindirectly, -withinthequestionstem. -| – 5(Excellent): | | Allintegratedfacts(dates,lo- | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -cations,values)arelogicallyconsistentwith – 4 (Good): The reasoning chain is intact, -thoughsomebackgrounddescriptionsmight -oneanotherandthereal-worldbackground. -The combined scenario is realistic (e.g., a allow a model to narrow down the answer -museumestablishedin2000iscorrectlyde- rangeviaaprocessofeliminationratherthan -purededuction. -scribedasexistingin2005). -– 4 (Good): Core facts are accurate, but mi- – 3(Satisfactory): Partialleakageoccurs. Cer- -tainphrasingistoodirect(e.g.,mentioninga -nordescriptivebiasesinnon-essentialdetails -(e.g., secondary institutional titles or hon- highly unique year or rare proper noun), al- -orifics)occurduringamalgamationwithout lowingexperiencedannotatorsormodelsto -"guess"theanswerviashortcutsorcommon -affectingthefinalanswer. -sense. -| – 3 (Satisfactory): | | Core | facts | remain funda- | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -mentallycorrect,butthetimelineorlogical – 2 (Poor): The question contains obvious -backgroundacrosshopsfeelsslightly"awk- hints that make the reasoning chain signif- -ward" or strained, though no direct factual icantlyeasiertobypass. -9 +challenge. In Machine Learning Challenges Workshop, pp. 177–190. Springer, 2005. -| – 1 (Very | Poor): | Direct | leakage. | | The | final | textunreadable. | | | | | | -| --------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -answerappearswithinthemulti-hopdescrip- -| | | | | | | | • Reasoning | Complexity | | and | Domain | Diver- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | -tion,orthequestionisphrasedinawaythat -| | | | | | | | sity: This | criterion | | measures | the | degree of | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | -rendersthelogicalstepsmeaningless. -cross-domaincomplexityandthedepthofthe -• SemanticCompletenessandLinguisticFlu- logicaljumps. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: -ency: Thiscriterionevaluatestheretentionof -| | | | | | | | 1. Domain | Counting. | | Identify | the | number of | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | -allnecessaryconstraintsandthenaturalnessof -distinctknowledgedomainsspannedbythe -| the linguistic | expression. | | | Annotators | follow | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | question | (e.g., | Literature, | | Geography, | Art | -foursteps: -History,Arithmetic). -1. GrammarandRhetoricScan. Checklong, 2. HopCounting. Countthenumberofexplicit -complex sentences for grammatical errors logicaltransitionsfromthestartingentityto -| and ambiguous | | references | | (e.g., | multiple | | thefinalanswer. | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -usesof“theartist”whenseveralartistsare 3. DepthandDependencyAnalysis. Determine -mentioned). -whethereachhoprequiresdomain-specific -2. Constraint Condition Checklist. Confirm knowledgethatcannotbebypassedthrough -| thatallcriticalconstraintsfromthesingle- | | | | | | | commonsensealone. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -hopquestions(e.g.,“since1855,”“priorto”) 4. LevelDetermination. Assignascorebased -arefaithfullycarriedoverintothemulti-hop onthenumberofdomainscrossed(4+do- -| question. | | | | | | | mains | = top | tier) | and the | number | of non- | -| ------------------------- | ---- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | -| 3. LogicalConnectorCheck. | | | | Verifythatcon- | | | trivialhops. | | | | | | -| nectors | such | as | “prior | to,” | “who,” | and | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | – 5 (Excellent): | | The | logical | chain | spans 4 or | -“where”accuratelyreflecttheinter-hoprela- -| | | | | | | | more | distinct | domains | (e.g., | Art | History → | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --------- | -tionships. -Geography→Law→FinancialArithmetic). -| 4. Final | Scoring. | A | question | that | reads | flu- | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Eachstepisstrictlydependentontheprevi- -entlyandpreservesallconstraintsscores5; -ousoneandcannotbebypassedviacommon -| noticeable | “translation-ese” | | | or | ambiguous | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -sense. -referenceslowerthescoreto3orbelow. -| | | | | | | | – 4(Good): | Thelogicspans3distinctdomains | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -– 5(Excellent): Allnecessaryconstraints(e.g., andinvolvesatleast4explicitlogicaljumps. -| specific | year | ranges, | "inclusive," | | rounding | | – 3 (Satisfactory): | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ---- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ------------------------ | ---- | --------- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | The reasoning | | chain in- | -| requirements) | | are perfectly | | preserved. | | The | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | volves | 3 or | more deep | logical | steps | within | -| languageisnatural, | | | smooth, | andadheresto | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | atleast2distinctdomains. | | | | Iteffectivelydis- | | -native-speakerhabitswithpreciselogicalcon- -tinguishesmodelswithsingle-domainknowl- -nectives. -edge. -| – 4(Good): | Constraintsarecomplete,butthe | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | – 2(Poor): | Thechaininvolves2domainsbut | | | | | -| phrasingisslightlywordy. | | | | Languageisflu- | | | | | | | | | -only1–2simplelogicaljumps,oroneofthe -ent,thoughthechoiceoflogicalconnectors -domainsreliesoncommonknowledge. -(e.g.,"priorto,""who")mayberepetitive. -| | | | | | | | – 1 (Very | Poor): | "Pseudo-multi-hop." | | | The | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| – 3 (Satisfactory): | | | The | core | meaning | is | | | | | | | -logicisextremelysimple,consistingmerely -clear,butsomenon-essentialconstraintsare -| | | | | | | | of the | additive | stacking | | of facts | within the | -| ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | -| omitted | (e.g., | missing | a | rounding | instruc- | | | | | | | | -samedomain. -| tion). | The expression | | is | rigid | and exhibits | | | | | | | | -| ------ | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -"translation-ese"oraformulaictone. -| – 2 (Poor): | Critical | | constraints | | required | for | | | | | | | -| ----------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -derivationaremissing,orredundantinforma- -tionisaddedthatinterfereswithunderstand- -ing. Logicalconnectorsareusedincorrectly. -| – 1(VeryPoor): | | Keyconstraintsaremissing, | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -makingitimpossibletodetermineaunique -| answer. | Thelanguageisbrokenandthelog- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -icalrelationshipsareerroneous,makingthe -10 +Bryan Eikema and Wilker Aziz. Is MAP decoding all you need? the inadequacy of the mode in neural +machine translation. In Proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Computational Lin- +guistics, pp. 4506–4520, Barcelona, Spain (Online), December 2020. International Committee on +Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.coling-main. +398. -Figure4: Annotationinterfaceforsingle-hopquestion. -Single-hopSub-questions -| | Factuality | Distractor | Fluency | -| ---- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -| Mean | 4.62 | 4.31 | 4.47 | -| STD | 0.54 | 0.72 | 0.61 | -4-hopQuestions -| | Logic | Consistency | Obscurity | -| ---- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | -| Mean | 4.53 | 4.41 | 4.18 | -| STD | 0.58 | 0.65 | 0.79 | -| | Fluency | Complexity | | -| Mean | 4.44 | 4.56 | | -| STD | 0.62 | 0.53 | | -Table3: Humanannotationscoresona1–5scaleover -967testinstances.Eachcellreportsthemeanscorewith -| thestandarddeviationinsubscript(mean | | std | ). | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -11 +Yanai Elazar, Nora Kassner, Shauli Ravfogel, Abhilasha Ravichander, Eduard Hovy, Hinrich +Schütze, and Yoav Goldberg. Measuring and improving consistency in pretrained language +models. Transactions of the Association for Computational Linguistics, 9:1012–1031, 2021. doi: +10.1162/tacl_a_00410. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.tacl-1.60. + +Jonathan St BT Evans. Intuition and reasoning: A dual-process perspective. Psychological Inquiry, + +21(4):313–326, 2010. + +Angela Fan, Mike Lewis, and Yann Dauphin. Hierarchical neural story generation. In Proceedings +of the 56th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long +Papers), pp. 889–898, Melbourne, Australia, July 2018. Association for Computational Linguistics. +doi: 10.18653/v1/P18-1082. URL https://aclanthology.org/P18-1082. + +Jessica Ficler and Yoav Goldberg. Controlling linguistic style aspects in neural language generation. In +Proceedings of the Workshop on Stylistic Variation, pp. 94–104, Copenhagen, Denmark, September +2017. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/W17-4912. URL https: +//aclanthology.org/W17-4912. + +Tianyu Gao, Adam Fisch, and Danqi Chen. Making pre-trained language models better few-shot +learners. In Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguis- +tics and the 11th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (Volume 1: Long +Papers), pp. 3816–3830, Online, August 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: +10.18653/v1/2021.acl-long.295. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.acl-long. +295. + +Mor Geva, Ankit Gupta, and Jonathan Berant. Injecting numerical reasoning skills into language +models. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguis- +tics, 2020. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.acl-main.89. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020. +acl-main.89. + +Mor Geva, Daniel Khashabi, Elad Segal, Tushar Khot, Dan Roth, and Jonathan Berant. Did aristotle +use a laptop? A question answering benchmark with implicit reasoning strategies. Transactions of +the Association for Computational Linguistics, 2021. URL https://aclanthology.org/ +2021.tacl-1.21. + +Danilo Giampiccolo, Bernardo Magnini, Ido Dagan, and Bill Dolan. The third pascal recognizing +textual entailment challenge. In Proceedings of the ACL-PASCAL workshop on textual entailment +and paraphrasing, pp. 1–9. Association for Computational Linguistics, 2007. + +Ari Holtzman, Jan Buys, Maxwell Forbes, Antoine Bosselut, David Golub, and Yejin Choi. Learning +In Proceedings of the 56th Annual Meeting of the +to write with cooperative discriminators. +Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pp. 1638–1649, Melbourne, +Australia, July 2018. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/P18-1152. +URL https://aclanthology.org/P18-1152. + +Ari Holtzman, Jan Buys, Li Du, Maxwell Forbes, and Yejin Choi. The curious case of neural text +degeneration. In International Conference on Learning Representations, 2020. URL https: +//openreview.net/forum?id=rygGQyrFvH. + +Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Oren Etzioni, and Nate Kushman. Learning to +solve arithmetic word problems with verb categorization. In Proceedings of the 2014 Conference on +Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP), 2014. doi: 10.3115/v1/D14-1058. +URL https://aclanthology.org/D14-1058. -Figure5: Annotationinterfacefor4-hopquestion. 12 -| ReasoningGraph | Multi-hopQuestion | Single-hopComposition | | | | -| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Ifapoliticalregimebeganin1969andlasted | 1. WhoservedasEisenhower’svicepresident?Nixon | | | | -foranumberofyearsequalto7timesthe 2. HowmanysuccessfulApollomoonlandingmissionsoccurred -countofApollomoonlandingmissionsthatoc- -whileNixonwaspresidentoftheU.S.?6 -curredduringthepresidencyofEisenhower’s 3. Ifapoliticalregimelastedfor6times7yearsstartingfrom1969, -vicepresident,andiftheU.S.wasoneof2ma- whosefacewasmostcloselyassociatedwithLibya’sgovernment -| | jorpowersthatrecognizedthisregime’sleader | duringthisperiod?Gaddafi | | | | -| --- | ----------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | earlyon,whatwastheothermajorpower?So- | 4. IftheU.S.wasonemajorpowerthatrecognizedGaddafi’s | | | | -vietUnion governmentatanearlydate,andtherewere2majorpowerstotal -[A: United Kingdom B: France C: Soviet thatdidsoearlyon,whatwastheothermajorpowerbesidesthe -| | UnionD:WestGermany] | U.S.?SovietUnion | | | | -| --- | ------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | -GreatAmericanBallParkisthehomestadium 1. InwhichU.S.cityisGreatAmericanBallParklocated?Cincin- -| | ofanMLBteamthathaswontheWorldSeries | nati | | | | -| --- | ----------------------------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -multipletimes. Multiplytheirtotalchampi- 2. HowmanyWorldSerieschampionshipshavetheCincinnatiReds -| | onshipcountbythenumberofplayersperma- | wonintotal?5 | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -nentlybannedforfixingthe1919WorldSeries 3. EightChicagoWhiteSoxplayerswerepermanentlybannedfrom -baseballfortheirroleinfixingthe1919WorldSeries(theBlack -intheBlackSoxScandal.Thecarriernamed -afterthepresidentwiththatordinalnumber SoxScandal).MultiplythisnumberbytheCincinnatiReds’total -replacedwhichvesselatNavalStationYoko- WorldSerieschampionships(5).WhichU.S.Presidentheldthe -| | suka,Japan,in2015?USSGeorgeWashing- | ordinalnumberequaltothisproduct?RonaldReagan | | | | -| --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | ton | 4. USSRonaldReaganreplacedwhichaircraftcarrierastheU.S. | | | | -[A:USSNimitzB:USSCarlVinsonC:USS Navy’sforward-deployedvesselatNavalStationYokosuka,Japan, -| | GeorgeWashingtonD:USSJohnC.Stennis] | in2015?USSGeorgeWashington | | | | -| --- | ----------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Table4: Examplemulti-hopreasoninggraphanditsstep-by-stepquestiondecomposition. -Dataset OpenDomain #Hops Explicitstep-wisechain #Topologies Mathreasoning Expert-review -| MuSiQue(Trivedietal.,2022) | Yes 2-4 | No | 3 | No | Yes | -| -------------------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| FanOutQA(Zhuetal.,2024) | Yes 5-6 | Yes | 1 | No | Yes | -| CofCA(Wuetal.,2025) | Yes 2-4 | No | 3 | No | No | -| SynthWorlds(Guetal.,2026) | No 2-4 | No | 3 | No | No | -| OmanicBench(ours) | Yes 4 | Yes | 3 | Yes | Yes | -Table5: QualitativecomparisonbetweenOmanicBenchandrepresentativemulti-hoporreasoningbenchmarks. “# -Hops”reportsthesupportedhoprange;forMuSiQueandCofCA,around80%ofthequestionsare2-hop. “Explicit -step-wise chain” indicates whether a benchmark provides explicit step-level annotations, such as decomposed -sub-questionsandintermediateanswers,fordiagnosingreasoningfailures. “#Topologies”countsthenumberof -reasoningtopologiesdefinedforquestionsatthemaximumhoplevelofeachbenchmark. + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Daniel Khashabi, Sewon Min, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark, and Han- +naneh Hajishirzi. UNIFIEDQA: Crossing format boundaries with a single QA system. In Findings +of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2020, pp. 1896–1907, Online, Novem- +ber 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.findings-emnlp.171. +URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.findings-emnlp.171. + +Takeshi Kojima, Shixiang Shane Gu, Machel Reid, Yutaka Matsuo, and Yusuke Iwasawa. Large +language models are zero-shot reasoners. In Alice H. Oh, Alekh Agarwal, Danielle Belgrave, +and Kyunghyun Cho (eds.), Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2022. URL +https://openreview.net/forum?id=e2TBb5y0yFf. + +Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Subhro Roy, Aida Amini, Nate Kushman, and Hannaneh Hajishirzi. MAWPS: +A math word problem repository. In Proceedings of the 2016 Conference of the North American +Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, 2016. +doi: 10.18653/v1/N16-1136. URL https://aclanthology.org/N16-1136. + +Yihuai Lan, Lei Wang, Qiyuan Zhang, Yunshi Lan, Bing Tian Dai, Yan Wang, Dongxiang Zhang, +and Ee-Peng Lim. MWPToolkit: An open-source framework for deep learning-based math word +problem solvers. arXiv preprint arXiv:2109.00799, 2021. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/ +2109.00799. + +Jiwei Li and Dan Jurafsky. Mutual information and diverse decoding improve neural machine + +translation, 2016. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1601.00372. + +Jiwei Li, Will Monroe, and Dan Jurafsky. A simple, fast diverse decoding algorithm for neural +generation. CoRR, abs/1611.08562, 2016. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1611.08562. + +Wang Ling, Dani Yogatama, Chris Dyer, and Phil Blunsom. Program induction by rationale genera- +tion: Learning to solve and explain algebraic word problems. In Proceedings of the 55th Annual +Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), 2017. doi: +10.18653/v1/P17-1015. URL https://aclanthology.org/P17-1015. + +Yao Lu, Max Bartolo, Alastair Moore, Sebastian Riedel, and Pontus Stenetorp. Fantastically +ordered prompts and where to find them: Overcoming few-shot prompt order sensitivity. ArXiv, +abs/2104.08786, 2021. + +Clara Meister, Tiago Pimentel, Gian Wiher, and Ryan Cotterell. Typical decoding for natural language + +generation. arXiv preprint arXiv:2202.00666, 2022. + +Shen Yun Miao, Chao Chun Liang, and Keh Yih Su. A diverse corpus for evaluating and developing +English math word problem solvers. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Asso- +ciation for Computational Linguistics, 2020. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020. +acl-main.92. + +Yixin Nie, Adina Williams, Emily Dinan, Mohit Bansal, Jason Weston, and Douwe Kiela. Adver- +sarial NLI: A new benchmark for natural language understanding. In Proceedings of the 58th +Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics. Association for Computational +Linguistics, 2020. + +Maxwell Nye, Michael Henry Tessler, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, and Brenden M. Lake. Improving +coherence and consistency in neural sequence models with dual-system, neuro-symbolic reasoning. +In A. Beygelzimer, Y. Dauphin, P. Liang, and J. Wortman Vaughan (eds.), Advances in Neural +Information Processing Systems, 2021. URL https://openreview.net/forum?id= +uyKk_avJ-p4. + +Arkil Patel, Satwik Bhattamishra, and Navin Goyal. Are NLP models really able to solve simple +math word problems? In Proceedings of the 2021 Conference of the North American Chapter of +the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, pp. 2080–2094, +Online, June 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.naacl-main. +168. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.naacl-main.168. + +Xinyu Pi, Qian Liu, Bei Chen, Morteza Ziyadi, Zeqi Lin, Yan Gao, Qiang Fu, Jian-Guang Lou, and + +Weizhu Chen. Reasoning like program executors, 2022. + 13 -(a)Bridge (b)Chain (c)Converging -Figure6: ThreereasoninggraphtopologiesusedinOmanicfororganizing4-hopquestions. -Figure7: Domaindistributionofsingle-hopsub-questionsacrossOmanicSynth,OmanicBench,andtheoverall -dataset. -Figure8: ReasoninggraphtopologydistributionacrossOmanicSynth,OmanicBench,andtheoveralldataset. + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Piotr Pi˛ekos, Mateusz Malinowski, and Henryk Michalewski. Measuring and improving BERT’s +mathematical abilities by predicting the order of reasoning. In Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meet- +ing of the Association for Computational Linguistics and the 11th International Joint Conference on +Natural Language Processing (Volume 2: Short Papers), 2021. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.acl-short.49. +URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.acl-short.49. + +Alec Radford, Jeff Wu, Rewon Child, David Luan, Dario Amodei, and Ilya Sutskever. Language + +models are unsupervised multitask learners. 2019. + +Jack W Rae, Sebastian Borgeaud, Trevor Cai, Katie Millican, Jordan Hoffmann, Francis Song, John +Aslanides, Sarah Henderson, Roman Ring, Susannah Young, et al. Scaling language models: +Methods, analysis & insights from training gopher. arXiv preprint arXiv:2112.11446, 2021. + +Qiu Ran, Yankai Lin, Peng Li, Jie Zhou, and Zhiyuan Liu. NumNet: Machine reading comprehension +with numerical reasoning. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural +Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing +(EMNLP-IJCNLP), 2019. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1251. URL https://aclanthology. +org/D19-1251. + +Subhro Roy and Dan Roth. Solving general arithmetic word problems. In Proceedings of the 2015 +Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, 2015. doi: 10.18653/v1/ +D15-1202. URL https://aclanthology.org/D15-1202. + +Jianhao Shen, Yichun Yin, Lin Li, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Ming Zhang, and Qun Liu. Generate +& rank: A multi-task framework for math word problems. In Findings of the Association for +Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2021, pp. 2269–2279, Punta Cana, Dominican Republic, +November 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology. +org/2021.findings-emnlp.195. + +Freda Shi, Daniel Fried, Marjan Ghazvininejad, Luke Zettlemoyer, and Sida I. Wang. Natural +language to code translation with execution. In Proceedings of the 2022 Conference on Empirical +Methods in Natural Language Processing, pp. 3533–3546, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, +December 2022. Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology. +org/2022.emnlp-main.231. + +Keith E Stanovich and Richard F West. + +Individual differences in reasoning: Implications for +the rationality debate? Behavioral and brain sciences, 23(5):645–665, 2000. URL https: +//pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11301544/. + +Alon Talmor, Jonathan Herzig, Nicholas Lourie, and Jonathan Berant. CommonsenseQA: A question +answering challenge targeting commonsense knowledge. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of +the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language +Technologies, Volume 1 (Long and Short Papers), 2019. URL https://aclanthology. +org/N19-1421. + +Yi Tay, Mostafa Dehghani, Vinh Q. Tran, Xavier Garcia, Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Hyung Won Chung, +Dara Bahri, Tal Schuster, Steven Zheng, Denny Zhou, Neil Houlsby, and Donald Metzler. Unifying +language learning paradigms, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.05131. + +Romal Thoppilan, Daniel De Freitas, Jamie Hall, Noam Shazeer, Apoorv Kulshreshtha, Heng-Tze +Cheng, Alicia Jin, Taylor Bos, Leslie Baker, Yu Du, et al. Lamda: Language models for dialog +applications. arXiv preprint arXiv:2201.08239, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/ +2201.08239. + +Ashwin Vijayakumar, Michael Cogswell, Ramprasaath Selvaraju, Qing Sun, Stefan Lee, David +Crandall, and Dhruv Batra. Diverse beam search for improved description of complex scenes. +Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 32, Apr. 2018. URL https: +//ojs.aaai.org/index.php/AAAI/article/view/12340. + +Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Brian Ichter, Fei Xia, Ed Chi, Quoc +Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain of thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. +Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), 2022. URL https://arxiv. +org/pdf/2201.11903. + 14 -B FullResults -| | | | | | | | Parameter | | Value | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Trainbatchsize | | 512 | | -B.1 Implementationdetails -| | | | | | | | Maxpromptlength | | 1024 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Maxresponselength | | 1024 | | -Forsupervisedfine-tuning,weconstructamixed -| | | | | | | | Actorlearningrate | | 1.0×10−5 | | -| -------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ------ | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| training | set in | which | half | of the | instances | are | | | | | -| | | | | | | | PPOmini-batchsize | | 512 | | -formattedasmulti-choicequestionexamplesand -| | | | | | | | PPOmicro-batchsize/GPU | | 32 | | -| --------- | --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| the other | half are | formatted | | as open-ended | | gen- | | | | | -| | | | | | | | PPOepochs | | 1 | | -| eration | examples. | For | Qwen3-8B, | | we | adopt a | KLloss | | Enabled | | -| two-stage | training | framework: | | we | first | perform | | | | | -| | | | | | | | KLcoefficient | | 0.01 | | -full-parameter SFT, and then conduct GRPO- Numberofrollouts 5 -based (Shao et al., 2024) reinforcement learning Totalepochs 3 -| starting | from the | fine-tuned | | model. | For LLaMA- | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -3.3-70B,weperformLoRA-based(Huetal.,2023) Table8: HyperparametersforQwen3-8BGRPOtrain- -ing. -| SFT on | the same | mixed | training | data. | All | exper- | | | | | -| ------ | ------------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| iments | are conducted | | on four | 96GB | H100 | NVL | | | | | -GPUs, and the detailed training hyperparameters Parameter Value -| arereportedinTables7,8,and9. | | | | Theevaluation | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | LoRArank | 8 | | | -| templatesaresummarizedinTable6. | | | | | | | Cutofflength | 2048 | | | -| | | | | | | | Per-devicebatchsize | 32 | | | -| | | | | | | | Gradientaccumulation | 2 | | | -| Setting | | | Template | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Learningrate | 1.0×10−4 | | | -| Directmulti-choicequestion | | | Selectthecorrectoption | | | | Epochs | 3.0 | | | -| | | | fromfourcandidatesand | | | | Precision | BF16 | | | -returnonlytheanswer -letter(A/B/C/D). -| | | | | | | | Table9: HyperparametersforLLaMA-3.3-70BLoRA | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Directopen-ended | | | Answerasconciselyas | | | | | | | | -SFT. -possibleandprovide -onlythefinalanswer -withoutexplanation. -| | | | | | | | B.2 Discussion | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| CoTmulti-choicequestion | | | Thinkstepbystepand | | | | | | | | -endtheresponsewith -| | | | | | | | Asmarkedby† inTable2,Claude-Sonnet-4.6ex- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -“TheanswerisX”,where -| | | | XisA,B,C,orD. | | | | hibitsauniquefailuremodeunderCoTprompting: | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -CoTopen-ended Thinkstepbystepand itsMCQaccuracyimprovessubstantially,yetopen- -writethefinalanswer -| | | | | | | | ended performance | (EM/F1) | degrades. | Manual | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | -onaseparatelinein -| | | | theformat“FINAL | | | | inspectionrevealsthatClaude’sCoTresponsesare | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -ANSWER:”. substantially longer (avg. 1,812 tokens vs. GPT- -5.4’s451tokens),withthefinalanswerfrequently -| Table 6: | Evaluation | templates | | for direct | | and CoT | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -buriedinextendedproseratherthanpresentedinan -prompting. -| | | | | | | | extractableformat. | Thissuggeststhedegradation | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------------------- | --- | --- | -reflectsananswerextractionfailureratherthana -reasoningregression,underscoringtheimportance -| Parameter | | | Value | | | | ofevaluatingreasoningcapability(MCQ)andan- | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -swerarticulation(EM/F1)ascomplementary,not -| Cutofflength | | | 2048 | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -interchangeable,axes. -| Per-devicebatchsize | | | 32 | | | | | | | | -| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Gradientaccumulation | | | 2 | | | | | | | | -1.0×10−5 -Learningrate -| Epochs | | | 3.0 | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| LRscheduler | | | Cosine | | | | | | | | -| Warmupratio | | | 0.1 | | | | | | | | -| Precision | | | BF16 | | | | | | | | -| Table7: | HyperparametersforQwen3-8BFullSFT. | | | | | | | | | | + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Sean Welleck, Ilia Kulikov, Jaedeok Kim, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, and Kyunghyun Cho. Consistency +of a recurrent language model with respect to incomplete decoding. In Proceedings of the 2020 +Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP), pp. 5553–5568, +Online, November 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020. +emnlp-main.448. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.emnlp-main.448. + +Weiwen Xu, Yang Deng, Huihui Zhang, Deng Cai, and Wai Lam. Exploiting reasoning chains +for multi-hop science question answering. In Findings of the Association for Computational +Linguistics: EMNLP 2021, pp. 1143–1156, Punta Cana, Dominican Republic, November 2021a. +Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021. +findings-emnlp.99. + +Yichong Xu, Chenguang Zhu, Shuohang Wang, Siqi Sun, Hao Cheng, Xiaodong Liu, Jianfeng +Gao, Pengcheng He, Michael Zeng, and Xuedong Huang. Human parity on commonsenseqa: +Augmenting self-attention with external attention, 2021b. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/ +2112.03254. + +Zhilin Yang, Peng Qi, Saizheng Zhang, Yoshua Bengio, William Cohen, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, and +Christopher D. Manning. HotpotQA: A dataset for diverse, explainable multi-hop question answer- +ing. In Proceedings of the 2018 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, +pp. 2369–2380, Brussels, Belgium, October-November 2018. Association for Computational Lin- +guistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D18-1259. URL https://aclanthology.org/D18-1259. + +Xi Ye and Greg Durrett. The unreliability of explanations in few-shot prompting for textual reasoning. +In Alice H. Oh, Alekh Agarwal, Danielle Belgrave, and Kyunghyun Cho (eds.), Advances in +Neural Information Processing Systems, 2022. URL https://openreview.net/forum? +id=Bct2f8fRd8S. + +Wenhao Yu, Chenguang Zhu, Lianhui Qin, Zhihan Zhang, Tong Zhao, and Meng Jiang. Diversifying +content generation for commonsense reasoning with mixture of knowledge graph experts. In +Findings of Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL), 2022. + +Zihao Zhao, Eric Wallace, Shi Feng, Dan Klein, and Sameer Singh. Calibrate before use: Improving +few-shot performance of language models. In Marina Meila and Tong Zhang (eds.), Proceed- +ings of the 38th International Conference on Machine Learning, volume 139 of Proceedings of +Machine Learning Research. PMLR, 2021. URL https://proceedings.mlr.press/ +v139/zhao21c.html. + 15 -| | | | MCQ | ExactMatch F1-Score | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -OpenAI -| | | GPT-5.2 | 38.51 | 18.20 | 29.09 | -| --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| | | GPT-5.2CoT | 65.98 | 34.13 | 46.93 | -| | | GPT-5.1 | 39.40 | 18.55 | 26.62 | -| | | GPT-5.1CoT | 71.68 | 39.96 | 51.18 | -Direct CoT -| | | GPT-4o | 39.50 | 16.65 | 28.93 | -| ----------------- | --------- | -------------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| OpenAI | | GPT-4oCoT | 66.91 | 37.85 | 47.04 | -| GPT-5.4 | 13 451 | Anthropic | | | | -| GPT-5.2 | 15 502 | Claude-Sonnet-4.5 | 51.24 | 24.56 | 34.04 | -| | | Claude-Sonnet-4.5CoT | 75.88 | 44.40 | 54.89 | -| GPT-5.1 | 12 1,126 | | | | | -| | | Claude-Opus-4.5 | 61.97 | 10.17 | 16.00 | -| GPT-4o | 16 1,314 | | | | | -| | | Claude-Opus-4.5CoT | 76.68 | 44.50 | 55.44 | -| Anthropic | | Claude-Opus-4.1 | 54.40 | 19.31 | 28.50 | -| | | Claude-Opus-4.1CoT | 76.95 | 39.75 | 49.81 | -| Claude-Sonnet-4.6 | 611 1,812 | | | | | -| | | Claude-Sonnet-4 | 51.40 | 21.92 | 31.80 | -| Claude-Sonnet-4.5 | 82 1,379 | | | | | -| | | Claude-Sonnet-4CoT | 74.15 | 39.09 | 49.40 | -| Claude-Opus-4.5 | 332 1,469 | Claude-Opus-4 | 52.02 | 22.45 | 32.16 | -| | | Claude-Opus-4CoT | 73.10 | 40.44 | 50.18 | -| Claude-Opus-4.1 | 196 1,221 | | | | | -Google -| Claude-Sonnet-4 | 76 1,316 | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --------- | ------------------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| | | Gemini-3-Flash-Preview | 67.22 | 21.30 | 31.34 | -| Claude-Opus-4 | 112 1,223 | | | | | -| | | Gemini-3-Flash-PreviewCoT | 75.90 | 40.54 | 50.19 | -| Google | | Gemini-2.5-Flash | 62.77 | 18.20 | 25.10 | -| | | Gemini-2.5-FlashCoT | 54.60 | 27.71 | 36.55 | -| Gemini-3.1-flash-Lite | 10 1,423 | | | | | -| | | Gemini-2.5-Flash-Lite | 32.68 | 9.31 | 14.04 | -| Gemini-3-Flash-Preview | 9 1,587 | | | | | -| | | Gemini-2.5-Flash-LiteCoT | 32.26 | 22.54 | 29.24 | -| Gemini-2.5-Flash | 8 3,837 | | | | | -Gemini-2.5-Flash-Lite 8 6,453 Table11: ExpandedproprietaryLLMsresultsonOman- -icBench. -Meta -| LLaMA-3.3-70B | 38 1,694 | | | | | -| ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | MCQ | ExactMatch F1-Score | | -| LLaMA-3-8B | 22 1,469 | | | | | -Meta -| LLaMA-3-70B | 11 735 | LLaMA-3.3-70B | 40.04 | 11.77 | 20.47 | -| ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| | | LLaMA-3.3-70BCoT | 59.57 | 31.33 | 39.43 | -Alibaba -| | | LLaMA-3-8B | 25.23 | 4.96 | 8.78 | -| --------- | -------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| Qwen3-Max | 14 4,841 | LLaMA-3-8BCoT | 42.50 | 16.55 | 22.78 | -| | | LLaMA-3-70B | 38.47 | 12.10 | 18.84 | -| Qwen3-32B | 33 920 | | | | | -| | | LLaMA-3-70BCoT | 57.39 | 29.09 | 37.49 | -| Qwen3-8B | 24 357 | | | | | -Alibaba -| Qwen2.5-72B | 12 1,260 | Qwen3-32B | 52.22 | 12.10 | 18.35 | -| ------------- | -------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| | | Qwen3-32BCoT | 54.86 | 30.37 | 38.98 | -| Qwen2.5-7B | 15 1,313 | | | | | -| | | Qwen3-8B | 25.65 | 9.26 | 13.77 | -| DeepSeek | | Qwen3-8BCoT | 56.44 | 21.76 | 29.97 | -| | | Qwen2.5-72B | 42.19 | 13.24 | 19.43 | -| DeepSeek-V3.2 | 11 2,548 | | | | | -| | | Qwen2.5-72BCoT | 60.81 | 32.06 | 41.31 | -DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70B 111 652 Qwen2.5-7B 30.51 7.76 14.31 -| | | Qwen2.5-7BCoT | 46.85 | 19.44 | 25.60 | -| ---------------------------- | ------ | ------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -| DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B | 68 429 | | | | | -DeepSeek -| | | DeepSeek-V3.2 | 43.33 | 12.82 | 19.36 | -| --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -Table10: AverageoutputlengthunderDirectandCoT -| | | DeepSeek-V3.2CoT | 70.94 | 35.92 | 46.19 | -| --- | --- | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -prompting. -| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70B | 75.92 | 1.72 | 13.71 | -| --- | --- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----- | -| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70BCoT | 72.67 | 41.27 | 51.08 | -| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B | 69.52 | 11.92 | 22.99 | -| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32BCoT | 69.29 | 35.51 | 46.00 | -| | | Table 12: Expanded | Open-source | LLMs results | on | -OmanicBench. + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +A APPENDIX + +A.1 ADDITIONAL EXPERIMENT RESULTS + +A.1.1 ROBUSTNESS TO SAMPLING STRATEGIES AND PARAMETERS + +In Figure 6 we ablate the results with respect to different sampling strategies and parameters by +varying T in temperature sampling and k in Top-k sampling, on LaMDA-137B. We show that +self-consistency is robust to various sampling strategies and parameters. + +Figure 6: GSM8K accuracy over LaMDA-137B. Self-consistency works under various sampling +strategies and sampling parameters. + +In Figure 7 and Figure 8, we show the results of self-consistency compared with greedy decoding a +single path over LaMDA-137B and PaLM-540B, respectively. Self-consistency improves over greedy +decode by a quite significant margin on both models, on top of high accuracy already achieved by +scaling up model sizes. + +Figure 7: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy across various arithmetic and +commonsense reasoning tasks, over LaMDA-137B. Sampling a higher number of diverse reasoning +paths consistently improves reasoning accuracy. + +We further show additional sampled reasoning paths from the LaMDA-137B model in Table 12, and +sampled reasoning paths from the PaLM-540B model in Table 13. We see that the diversity in the +additionally sampled reasoning paths indeed helps the model arrive at a more correct final answer +after aggregation. + +A.1.2 ROBUSTNESS TO DIFFERENT SETS OF PROMPTS + +In Table 9, we further show that self-consistency is quite robust to different sets of input prompts. +We manually wrote 3 different sets of chain-of-thought as prompts to the model. Across all sets of +prompts, self-consistency yields consistent gains over the original CoT approach. + +A.1.3 COMPARED TO MODEL ENSEMBLES + +Additionally, we provide results of directly ensembling the outputs from multiple language models. +The results are shown in Table 10, by greedily decoding sequences from 3 language models and + 16 -B.3 FullresultsonKnowledgeFloorandthe -ErrorPropagation -For the step-wise error rates under chain evalua- -tion,weexcludesingle-hopquestionsthatcanbe -answeredwithoutrelyingonprecedingsteps,since -theydonotreflectdependency-sensitiveerrorprop- -agation. Forexample,undertheBridgetopology, -thethirdhopisomittedbecauseitcanbeanswered -independentlyofearlierhops. -Figure11: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforGPT-4o. -Figure9: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforGPT-5.2. -Figure12: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforGPT-5.4. -Figure10: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforGPT-5.1. -Figure13: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4.5. +481216202428323640#Sampled Reasoning Paths182022242628Accuracy (%)T=0.7, k=40T=0.5, k=40T=0.3, k=40T=0.5, k=20T=0.5, no top kGreedy Decode0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505560657075Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths4446485052545658ASDiv0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths3336394245485154SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths1416182022242628GSM8KGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths56586062Accuracy (%)Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths62636465666768Strategy QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths687072747678ARC (Easy)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505254565860ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path) Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Figure 8: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy across various arithmetic and +commonsense reasoning tasks, over PaLM-540B. Sampling a higher number of diverse reasoning +paths consistently helps reasoning accuracy. + +Prompt set 1 (used in the main text) + +Prompt set 2 + +Prompt set 3 + +CoT (Wei et al., 2022) +Self-consistency + +56.5 +74.4 (+17.9) + +54.6 +72.1 (+17.5) + +54.0 +70.4 (+16.4) + +Table 9: GSM8K accuracy over PaLM-540B. The results show robustness of self-consistency with +respect to different prompts in the input. + +taking the majority vote (averaged over 10 runs). Note this is a typical ensemble approach (averaging +over the predictions over multiple models) and it achieves a performance significantly worse than +self-consistency (self-consistency over PaLM-540B gets an accuracy of 74.4%), as lower-capacity +models drag down the performance of higher-capacity models. In addition, this approach is limited in +two ways: 1) It requires multiple models for an ensemble which might not always be available, while +self-consistency only requires one single model to “self-ensemble”; 2) If one of the models is much +weaker, it can actually hurt the final performance. + +Method + +Single model + +PaLM-540B, greedy / self-consistency + +Ensemble of models + +LaMDA-137B + PaLM-540B +PaLM-540B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B) +LaMDA-137B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B) +LaMDA-137B + PaLM-540B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B) + +GSM8K accuracy + +56.5 / 74.4 + +36.9 ± 0.5 +36.6 ± 0.4 +16.0 ± 0.8 +33.3 ± 0.7 + +Table 10: Comparison of GSM8K accuracy over multiple-model ensembles. + +A.1.4 COMBINING SELF-CONSISTENCY WITH OTHER ENSEMBLING STRATEGIES + +Self-consistency is completely compatible with other ensemble strategies, although the gains achieved +by self-consistency are significantly higher than other ensemble strategies (and can “override” the +performance gains achieved by other ensemble strategies). We further performed experiments and +include the results in Table 11 (for a fair comparison, we use 40 sets of prompts, or 40 prompt +permutations to compare with self-consistency with 40 paths, all experiments are based on PaLM- +540B). + 17 -Figure14: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure17: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforClaude-Opus-4.5. errorsforClaude-Opus-4. -Figure15: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure18: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforClaude-Opus-4.1. errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4.6. -Figure16: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure19: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4. errorsforGemini-3-Flash-Preview. +0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains8688909294Accuracy (%)AddSub0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains727476788082Accuracy (%)ASDiv0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains30333639424548Accuracy (%)AQuAGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains889092949698Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains70.072.575.077.580.082.585.087.5Accuracy (%)SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains505560657075Accuracy (%)GSM8KGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths7475767778798081Accuracy (%)Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths7476788082Strategy QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths8890929496ARC (Easy)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths788082848688ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path) Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +GSM8K accuracy + +Different sets of prompts (x40) +Prompt-permutation (x40) +Self-consistency (x40) +Self-consistency + different sets of prompts (x40) +Self-consistency + prompt-permutation (x40) + +58.9 +59.6 +74.4 +75.4 +73.8 + +Table 11: Combining self-consistency with other ensembling strategies. + +A.2 DETAILS ON RESOURCES AND INFERENCE + +For all four language models we perform prompting-based inference only. For UL2 we use TPU v3 +(2x2 configuration, 4 chips, 8 cores). For GPT-3 models the experiments are done though the public +API.10 For LaMDA-137B we use TPU v3 (8x8 configuration, 64 chips, 128 cores). For PaLM-540B +we use TPU v4 (4x4x12 configuration, 192 chips, 384 cores). Most inference jobs take 1 to 4 hours +(over about 1,000 examples) for each task on UL2 and LaMDA-137B, and about 2 to 12 hours on +PaLM-540B. Some tasks (e.g., commonsense reasoning) take longer but do not exceed 2 days for +each task. + +For GPT-3 models, we use 128 max tokens for all methods, without frequency penalty or presence +penalty. For all models, we take the generated outputs until the start of the next “Q:" to parse the final +answers, consistent with our prompting format. + +Question + +Greedy Decode + +Sampled Path 1 + +Sampled Path 2 + +[MultiArith] Sam had 10 socks. +If he threw away 3 old ones +that didn’t fit and bought 36 new +ones, how many socks would he +have? + +Sam had 10 socks. He threw +away 3 old ones that didn’t fit. +He bought 36 new ones. That +means he has 10 + 36 - 3 = 41 +socks. The answer is 41. + +[SVAMP] In a school there are +697 girls and the rest are boys. +If there are 228 more girls than +boys. How many boys are there +in that school? + +[AQuA] There are 10 oranges in +a basket. Find the no. of ways in +which 2 oranges are chosen from +the basket? (a) 45 (b) 90 (c) 120 +(d) 150 (e) 180 + +There are 697 girls and the rest +are boys. That means there are +697 + 228 = 925 girls. The +rest are boys. So the number of +boys is 925 - 697 = 228. The +answer is 228. + +There are 10 oranges in a bas- +ket. +So there are 10 ways +in which 2 oranges are chosen +from the basket. + +[CommonsenseQA] The man +laid on the soft moss and looked +up at the trees, where was the +man? (a) niagra falls (b) forest +(c) waterfall (d) ground (e) tree + +The answer must be something +that is soft and mossy. Of the +above choices, only ground is +soft and mossy. So the answer +is (d). + +[ARC] Which of these will most +likely harm a habitat? (a) plant- +ing trees. (b) water pollution. (c) +rainfall. (d) sunlight. + +Planting trees will not harm a +habitat. So the answer is (a). + +[ARC-challenge] Which pro- +cess in the carbon cycle takes the +longest to complete? (a) emis- +sion of waste. (b) respiration in +animals. +(c) photosynthesis in +plants. (d) formation of fossil fu- +els. + +The process of photosynthesis +in plants takes the longest to +complete. So the answer is (c). + +Sam had 10 socks. He +threw away 3 old ones. So +now he has 7 left. Then he +bought 36 new ones. So +now he has 7 + 36 = 43 +socks. The answer is 43. + +He had 10 socks. He threw away +3 old ones that didn’t fit. He +bought 36 new ones. So in total +he has 10 - 3 + 36 = 43 socks. The +answer is 43. + +The number of boys is the +difference between 697 +and 228. This is 697 - 228 += 469. The answer is 469. + +In the beginning there are 697 +girls and the rest are boys. So, the +number of boys must be 697 - 228 += 469 boys. The answer is 469. + +There are 10 oranges in a +basket. We need to choose +2 oranges from the basket. +So the number of ways are +10C2. So the answer is (a). + +The +be +answer must +somewhere where moss +is found. Of the above +choices, only forests are +known for having moss. +So the answer is (b). + +The answer is (b), water +pollution, because it will +most likely harm the habi- +tat. The other answers are +not likely to harm the habi- +tat. + +The formation of fossil fu- +els takes the longest time +to complete. So the an- +swer is (d). + +There are 10 oranges in the bas- +ket. If you choose 2 oranges, you +have 10C2 = 45 ways of choosing +2 oranges. So the answer is (a). + +The answer must be a place where +the man is laying down and look- +ing up at trees. Of the above +is a place +choices, only forest +where people lay down and look +at trees. So the answer is (b). + +The answer is (b), water pollution. +Trees are good for a habitat, rain- +fall is necessary for a habitat, and +sunlight is necessary for a habitat. +So the answer is (b). + +The process that takes the longest +time to complete is the forma- +tion of fossil fuels, which hap- +pens over millions of years. So +the answer is (d). + +Table 12: Additional examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode on +LaMDA-137B. Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown. + +10https://beta.openai.com/docs/api-reference/making-requests + 18 -Figure20: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure23: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop -errorsforGemini-2.5-Flash. errorsforQwen3-Max. -Figure21: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure24: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -errorsforGemini-2.5-Flash-Lite. chainevaluationforGPT-5.2. -Figure22: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure25: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -errorsforGemini-3.1-flash-lite. chainevaluationforGPT-5.1. + Kyle bought a book that is sold +for $19.50. With a 25% discount, +the original price must be higher. +If we call +the original price x, +then the discounted price is 0.75x. +Since this is $19.50, we can write +0.75x = 19.50. Solving this, we +find that the original price is x = +19.50 / 0.75 = $26. The answer is +$26. + +The volume of the tank is 8 m * +6 m * 2.5 m = 120 m3. One cu- +bic meter contains 1000 litres, so +the tank contains 120 m3 * 1000 +liters/m3 = 120,000 liters. So the +answer is (d). + +Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Question + +Greedy Decode + +Sampled Path 1 + +Sampled Path 2 + +[GSM8K] Kyle bought +last +year’s best-selling book for +$19.50. This is with a 25% dis- +count from the original price. +What was the original price of +the book? + +The book was sold for $19.50. +This is 25% less than the origi- +nal price. This means the original +price was 100%. 25% of 100% +is 25%. +So the original price +was 100% - 25% = 75%. The +original price was 75% of $19.50. +75% of $19.50 is 75% * $19.50 = +$14.625. The answer is $14.625. + +The original price of the book +is $19.50. Since it was dis- +counted by 25%, the original +price was 19.50 / 0.75 = 26. +The answer is 26. + +The volume of the tank is 8 m * +6 m * 2.5 m = 120 m3. So the +capacity of the tank is 120 m3. So +the answer is (c). + +The volume of the tank is 8m +* 6m* 2.5m = 120m3. This is +equal to 120000 litres. So the +answer is (d) + +[AQuA] The capacity of a +tank of dimensions (8 m x 6 +m x 2.5 m) is (a) 120 litres (b) +1200 litres (c) 12000 litres (d) +120000 litres (e) None of these + +no: +[StrategyQA] Yes +Can the Great Depression be +treated with Prozac? + +or + +The Great Depression was an +economic depression. Prozac is +a drug used to treat depression. +Thus, the Great Depression could +be treated with Prozac. So the an- +swer is yes. + +Prozac is an anti-depressant +medication. The Great Depres- +sion is not a disease. Thus, +Prozac cannot treat the Great +Depression. So the answer is +no. + +The Great Depression is a time pe- +riod. Prozac is used to treat de- +pression (the mental illness). Thus, +the Great Depression can not be +treated with Prozac. So the answer +is no. + +[ARC-easy] Which source of +energy is nonrenewable? (a) +coal. +(c) water. +(d) wood. + +(b) sunlight. + +Coal, +sunlight, and water are +all renewable sources of energy. +Wood is a nonrenewable source of +energy. So the answer is (d). + +Students +[ARC-challenge] +studied the revolution of Earth +around the Sun. During which +month will Florida have the +most sunlight energy avail- +able? (a) March. (b) June. (c) +September. (d) December. + +The Earth is closest to the Sun +in December, hence Florida will +have the most sunlight energy +available in December. So the an- +swer is (d). + +A nonrenewable source of en- +ergy is one in which the source +is not replenished in a short +amount of time. Thus, the only +option that is nonrenewable is +coal. So the answer is (a). + +Coal is a fossil fuel and is formed +from dead organisms from the past. +Coal cannot be produced in a short +period of time, so it is considered +a nonrenewable source of energy. +So the answer is (a). + +Earth is closest to the Sun on +June 21, the summer solstice. +So the answer is (b). + +Florida is closer to the sun during +June, so it will have the most sun- +light energy during that month. So +the answer is (b). + +Table 13: Additional examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode on +PaLM-540B. Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown. + +A.3 FULL SETS OF PROMPTS + +We list the full details of the prompts used for two newly-introduced datasets, AQUA-RAT (Ling +et al., 2017) and AI2 Reasoning Challenge (ARC) (Clark et al., 2018), where we manually composed +the example chain-of-thought in this paper, in Table 14 and Table 15, respectively. + +Table 14: Few-shot exemplars for AQUA-RAT. +Q: John found that the average of 15 numbers is 40. If 10 is added to each number then the mean of the +numbers is? Answer Choices: (a) 50 (b) 45 (c) 65 (d) 78 (e) 64 + +A: If 10 is added to each number, then the mean of the numbers also increases by 10. So the new mean +would be 50. The answer is (a). + +Q: If a / b = 3/4 and 8a + 5b = 22,then find the value of a. Answer Choices: (a) 1/2 (b) 3/2 (c) 5/2 (d) 4/2 (e) +7/2 + +A: If a / b = 3/4, then b = 4a / 3. So 8a + 5(4a / 3) = 22. This simplifies to 8a + 20a / 3 = 22, which means +44a / 3 = 22. So a is equal to 3/2. The answer is (b). + +Q: A person is traveling at 20 km/hr and reached his destiny in 2.5 hr then find the distance? Answer Choices: +(a) 53 km (b) 55 km (c) 52 km (d) 60 km (e) 50 km + +A: The distance that the person traveled would have been 20 km/hr * 2.5 hrs = 50 km. The answer is (e). + +Q: How many keystrokes are needed to type the numbers from 1 to 500? Answer Choices: (a) 1156 (b) 1392 +(c) 1480 (d) 1562 (e) 1788 + +A: There are 9 one-digit numbers from 1 to 9. There are 90 two-digit numbers from 10 to 99. There are 401 +three-digit numbers from 100 to 500. 9 + 90(2) + 401(3) = 1392. The answer is (b). + 19 -Figure26: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure29: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforGPT-4o. chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4.5. -Figure27: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure30: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforGPT-5.4. chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4.1. -Figure28: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure31: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4.5. chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4. + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Table 15: Few-shot exemplars for ARC easy/challenge. +Q: George wants to warm his hands quickly by rubbing them. Which skin surface will produce the most +heat? (a) dry palms. (b) wet palms. (c) palms covered with oil. (d) palms covered with lotion. + +A: Dry surfaces will more likely cause more friction via rubbing than other smoother surfaces, hence dry +palms will produce the most heat. The answer is (a). + +Q: Which factor will most likely cause a person to develop a fever? (a) a leg muscle relaxing after exercise. +(b) a bacterial population in the bloodstream. (c) several viral particles on the skin. (d) carbohydrates being +digested in the stomach. + +A: Option (b), bacterial population is the most likely cause for a person developing fever. The answer is (b). + +Q: Which change in the state of water particles causes the particles to become arranged in a fixed position? +(a) boiling. (b) melting. (c) freezing. (d) evaporating. + +A: When water is freezed, the particles are arranged in a fixed position; the particles are still moving for all +other options. The answer is (c). + +Q: When a switch is used in an electrical circuit, the switch can (a) cause the charge to build. (b) increase +and decrease the voltage. (c) cause the current to change direction. (d) stop and start the flow of current. + +A: The function of a switch is to start and stop the flow of a current. The answer is (d). + +Table 16: Few-shot exemplars for HotpotQA (closed-book setting). + +Q: Which magazine was started first Arthur’s Magazine or First for Women? + +A: Arthur’s Magazine started in 1844. First for Women started in 1989. So Arthur’s Magazine was started first. +The answer is Arthur’s Magazine. + +Q: The Oberoi family is part of a hotel company that has a head office in what city? + +A: The Oberoi family is part of the hotel company called The Oberoi Group. The Oberoi Group has its head +office in Delhi. The answer is Delhi. + +Q: What nationality was James Henry Miller’s wife? + +A: James Henry Miller’s wife is June Miller. June Miller is an American. The answer is American. + +Q: The Dutch-Belgian television series that "House of Anubis" was based on first aired in what year? + +A: "House of Anubis" is based on the Dutch–Belgian television series Het Huis Anubis. Het Huis Anubis is first +aired in September 2006. The answer is 2006. + +As additional information, we also list the exact set of prompts used for all arithmetic reasoning tasks +in Table 17, since there are multiple sets of prompts introduced in Wei et al. (2022). The prompts for +CommonsenseQA and StrategyQA are the same as used in Wei et al. (2022). + +We provide the exact prompts used for common NLP tasks in the following tables as well, including +NLI (Table 18, Table 19, Table 20) and Closed-Book Question-Answering tasks (Table 16, Table 21). + 20 -Figure32: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure35: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4. chainevaluationforGemini-2.5-Flash. -Figure33: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure36: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4.6. chainevaluationforGemini-2.5-Flash-Lite. -Figure34: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure37: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforGemini-3-Flash-Preview. chainevaluationforGemini-3.1-flash-lite. + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Table 17: Few-shot exemplars for all arithmetic reasoning tasks, from Wei et al. (2022). +Q: There are 15 trees in the grove. Grove workers will plant trees in the grove today. After they are done, +there will be 21 trees. How many trees did the grove workers plant today? + +A: We start with 15 trees. Later we have 21 trees. The difference must be the number of trees they planted. +So, they must have planted 21 - 15 = 6 trees. The answer is 6. + +Q: If there are 3 cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot? + +A: There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + 2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5. + +Q: Leah had 32 chocolates and her sister had 42. If they ate 35, how many pieces do they have left in total? + +A: Leah had 32 chocolates and Leah’s sister had 42. That means there were originally 32 + 42 = 74 +chocolates. 35 have been eaten. So in total they still have 74 - 35 = 39 chocolates. The answer is 39. + +Q: Jason had 20 lollipops. He gave Denny some lollipops. Now Jason has 12 lollipops. How many lollipops +did Jason give to Denny? + +A: Jason had 20 lollipops. Since he only has 12 now, he must have given the rest to Denny. The number of +lollipops he has given to Denny must have been 20 - 12 = 8 lollipops. The answer is 8. + +Q: Shawn has five toys. For Christmas, he got two toys each from his mom and dad. How many toys does +he have now? + +A: He has 5 toys. He got 2 from mom, so after that he has 5 + 2 = 7 toys. Then he got 2 more from dad, so +in total he has 7 + 2 = 9 toys. The answer is 9. + +Q: There were nine computers in the server room. Five more computers were installed each day, from +monday to thursday. How many computers are now in the server room? + +A: There are 4 days from monday to thursday. 5 computers were added each day. That means in total 4 * 5 = +20 computers were added. There were 9 computers in the beginning, so now there are 9 + 20 = 29 computers. +The answer is 29. + +Q: Michael had 58 golf balls. On tuesday, he lost 23 golf balls. On wednesday, he lost 2 more. How many +golf balls did he have at the end of wednesday? + +A: Michael initially had 58 balls. He lost 23 on Tuesday, so after that he has 58 - 23 = 35 balls. On +Wednesday he lost 2 more so now he has 35 - 2 = 33 balls. The answer is 33. + +Q: Olivia has $23. She bought five bagels for $3 each. How much money does she have left? + +A: She bought 5 bagels for $3 each. This means she spent 5 * $3 = $15 on the bagels. She had $23 in +beginning, so now she has $23 - $15 = $8. The answer is 8. + 21 -Figure38: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand -chainevaluationforQwen3-Max. -22 \ No newline at end of file + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Table 18: Few-shot exemplars for ANLI. + +Premise: +"Conceptually cream skimming has two basic dimensions - product and geography." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Product and geography are what make cream skimming +work." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: Based on "cream skimming has two basic dimensions" we can’t infer that these two dimensions are what +make cream skimming work. The answer is it is not possible to tell. + +Premise: +"One of our member will carry out your instructions minutely." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A member of my team will execute your orders with +immense precision." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: "one of" means the same as "a member of", "carry out" means the same as "execute", and "minutely" means +the same as "immense precision". The answer is yes. + +Premise: +"Fun for adults and children." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Fun for only children." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: "adults and children" contradicts "only children". The answer is no. + +Premise: +"He turned and smiled at Vrenna." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "He smiled at Vrenna who was walking slowly behind +him with her mother." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: the premise does not say anything about "Vrenna was walking". The answer is it is not possible to tell. + +Premise: +"well you see that on television also" +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "You can see that on television, as well." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: "also" and "as well" mean the same thing. The answer is yes. + +Premise: +"Vrenna and I both fought him and he nearly took us." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Neither Vrenna nor myself have ever fought him." is +true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell + +A: "Vrenna and I both" contradicts "neither Vrenna nor myself". The answer is no. + +22 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Table 19: Few-shot exemplars for e-SNLI (the rationales are crowd-sourced annotations from the +original dataset). + +Premise: +"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is training his horse for a competition." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A: The person is not necessarily training his horse. The answer is it is not possible to tell. + +Premise: +"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is at a diner, ordering an omelette." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A: One jumping horse cannot be in a diner ordering food. The answer is no. + +Premise: +"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is outdoors, on a horse." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A: A broken down airplane is outdoors. The answer is yes. + +Premise: +"Children smiling and waving at camera." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "They are smiling at their parents." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A: Just because they are smiling and waving at a camera does not imply their parents or anyone is anyone behind +it. The answer is it is not possible to tell. + +Premise: +"Children smiling and waving at camera." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "The kids are frowning." is true? OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A: One cannot be smiling and frowning at the same time. The answer is no. + +Premise: +"Children smiling and waving at camera." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "There are children present." is true? +OPTIONS: +- yes +- no +- it is not possible to tell +A:The children must be present to see them smiling and waving. The answer is yes. + +23 + + Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023 + +Table 20: Few-shot exemplars for RTE. + +Premise: +"No Weapons of Mass Destruction Found in Iraq Yet." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Weapons of Mass Destruction Found in Iraq." is true? + +A: "No Weapons of Mass Destruction Found" contradicts "Weapons of Mass Destruction Found". The answer is +no. + +Premise: +"A place of sorrow, after Pope John Paul II died, became a place of celebration, as Roman Catholic faithful +gathered in downtown Chicago to mark the installation of new Pope Benedict XVI." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Pope Benedict XVI is the new leader of the Roman +Catholic Church." is true?’ + +A: "installation of new Pope Benedict XVI." means "Pope Benedict XVI is the new leader". The answer is yes. + +Premise: +"A man is due in court later charged with the murder 26 years ago of a teenager whose case was the first to +be featured on BBC One’s Crimewatch. Colette Aram, 16, was walking to her boyfriend’s house in Keyworth, +Nottinghamshire, on 30 October 1983 when she disappeared. Her body was later found in a field close to her +home. Paul Stewart Hutchinson, 50, has been charged with murder and is due before Nottingham magistrates +later." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Paul Stewart Hutchinson is accused of having stabbed a +girl." is true? + +A: The premise does not say Paul Stewart Hutchinson "stabbed" this girl. The answer is no. + +Premise: +"Herceptin was already approved to treat the sickest breast cancer patients, and the company said, Monday, it +will discuss with federal regulators the possibility of prescribing the drug for more breast cancer patients." +Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Herceptin can be used to treat breast cancer." is true? + +A: "Herceptin was approved to treat breast cancer" implies that "Herceptin can be used to treat breast cancer". +The answer is yes. + +Table 21: Few-shot exemplars for BoolQ (closed-book setting). + +Q: does system of a down have 2 singers? + +A: System of a Down currently consists of Serj Tankian, Daron Malakian, Shavo Odadjian and John Dolmayan. +Serj and Daron do vocals, so the band does have two singers. The answer is yes. + +Q: do iran and afghanistan speak the same language? + +A: Iran and Afghanistan both speak the Indo-European language Persian. The answer is yes. + +Q: is a cello and a bass the same thing? + +A: The cello is played sitting down with the instrument between the knees, whereas the double bass is played +standing or sitting on a stool. The answer is no. + +Q: can you use oyster card at epsom station? + +A: Epsom railway station serves the town of Epsom in Surrey and is not in the London Oyster card zone. The +answer is no. + +24 + diff --git a/q12/random_k2/question.json b/q12/random_k2/question.json index 3f778059aa9be022e15d3d50fdbcdde4f37b0d57..b9e4df8d0f0b17f4ee46bc2963929cf97620473e 100644 --- a/q12/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q12/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2401.18059v1.pdf", - "web_c83d6885217d96f0.pdf", - "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf" + "web_f77c9a6a0c40e754.pdf", + "resize_r1_31.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q12/random_k2/random_1.md b/q12/random_k2/random_1.md index dd5d594edac856e6a90c63c0d5c3c52351225e37..e93939cddbb26da056c6d4cb5d86060af787292b 100644 --- a/q12/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q12/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,771 +1,979 @@ -1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -2024 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL -WAVE 159 POLITICS SURVEY NOVEMBER 2024 -FINAL TOPLINE -NOVEMBER 12-17, 2024 -N=9,609 -Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This -topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly -modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire. -American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online -(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys -conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail. -For additional details, refer to the methodology. -* “No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents -who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered -as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and -telephone refusals. -In addition to the parameters used in weighting each wave of the American Trends Panel, the results of this -survey were weighted to the 2024 presidential popular vote and turnout among the voting-eligible population -(as of Nov. 18, 2024). For additional information, refer to the methodology. -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED -ASK ALL CITIZENS (XCITIZEN=1) [N=9,302]: -VOTED Which of the following statements best describes you? -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 16-27, Nov 12-17, Nov 7-16, Dec 12, -2024 20221 2020 2018 2016 -I did not vote in the November -22 2024 election 32 22 23 14 -13 I planned to vote but wasn’t able to 20 9 22 8 -I definitely voted in the November -65 2024 election 47 67 55 77 -1 No answer* 1 2 1 1 -1 In 2022 and 2018, this question was asked about that November’s congressional election. In 2020 and 2016, this question -was asked about that November’s presidential election. -www.pewresearch.org +INTRODUCING THE WINDOWS AZURE +PLATFORM + +DAVID CHAPPELL + +OCTOBER 2010 + +SPONSORED BY MICROSOFT CORPORATION + + CONTENTS + +An Overview of the Windows Azure Platform ....................................................................................... 3 + +Windows Azure ........................................................................................................................................ 4 + +SQL Azure ................................................................................................................................................. 6 + +Windows Azure AppFabric....................................................................................................................... 8 + +Windows Azure MarketPlace .................................................................................................................. 9 + +A Closer Look at the Technologies ....................................................................................................... 10 + +Windows Azure ...................................................................................................................................... 10 + +Compute ............................................................................................................................................ 11 + +Storage .............................................................................................................................................. 12 + +Fabric Controller ................................................................................................................................ 14 + +Content Delivery Network ................................................................................................................. 14 + +Connect ............................................................................................................................................. 15 + +SQL Azure ............................................................................................................................................... 15 + +Database ........................................................................................................................................... 15 + +Reporting ........................................................................................................................................... 17 + +Data Sync .......................................................................................................................................... 17 + +Windows Azure AppFabric..................................................................................................................... 19 + +Service Bus ........................................................................................................................................ 19 + +Access Control ................................................................................................................................... 21 + +Caching .............................................................................................................................................. 23 + +Windows Azure Marketplace ................................................................................................................ 24 + +Looking Ahead .................................................................................................................................... 26 + +Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................... 26 + +About the Author ................................................................................................................................ 27 2 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEGEN_POST In the 2024 presidential election, who did you vote for? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2 -FIRST FOLLOWED BY RANDOMIZED OPTIONS 3,4,5,6,7 WITH OPTION 8 AND 9 ALWAYS LAST] -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 49 | Donald Trump, the Republican | | | | | | | | | -| 47 | Kamala Harris, the Democrat | | | | | | | | | -| * | Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Chase Oliver, the Libertarian Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Cornel West, a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Claudia De la Cruz, the Socialism and Liberation Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Another candidate | | | | | | | | | -| 2 | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| * | No answer* | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE - -ASK IF DID NOT VOTE (VOTED=1-2) [N=1,201]: -| WISH_VOTED | Do you wish that you had voted in the election? | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | Nov 29- | | Nov 17- | | -| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | Dec 12 | | Dec 15, | | -| 2024 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | 2016 | | 2014 | | -| 42 | Yes | | 45 | 61 | | 44 | | 55 | | -| 57 | No | | 54 | 38 | | 55 | | 43 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | * | | 1 | | - -ASK IF CITIZEN AND DID NOT VOTE (X_CITIZEN=1 AND VOTED=1,2) [N=1,201]: -NOVOTERSN2 There are lots of different reasons why many people don’t vote. For you personally, -how much of a reason, if at all, is each of the following for why you did not vote? -[RANDOMIZE] - -| | | | Major | | Minor | | Not a | | No | -| ----- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | reason | | reason | | reason | | answer* | -| DIFF | I didn’t think my vote would make a | | | | | | | | | -difference -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 35 | | | 26 | 39 | | 1 | -| ----- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 21 | | | 23 | 55 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| CARE | I didn’t care who won2 | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 17 | | | 21 | 61 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 12 | | | 23 | 64 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| ELGB | I’m not registered or not eligible to | | | | | | | | | - vote -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 18 | | | 15 | 66 | | 1 | -| ----- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 19 | | | 10 | 70 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| INCV | It was too inconvenient for me to vote | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 15 | | | 22 | 62 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 20 | | | 21 | 59 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -2 In 2018, the reason was worded “I didn’t care who won the congressional election in my area.” -www.pewresearch.org -3 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -| NOVOTERSN2 CONTINUED … | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | Major | | | Minor | | Not a | No | | -| | | | | reason | | reason | | | reason | answer* | | -| LIKE | | I don’t like politics | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 31 | | | 25 | | 43 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 26 | | | 23 | | 50 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| FRGT | | I forgot to vote | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 8 | | 13 | | 79 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | | 7 | | 15 | | 77 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED TRUMP (VOTEGEN_POST=1) [N=3,536]: -DTFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… -ASK IF VOTED HARRIS (VOTEGEN_POST=2) [N=4,185]: -KHFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Harris was more a vote… - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: - -| | | | | | | Based on registered voters | | | | | | -| ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | | Aug 26-Sep 2, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 20243 | | 2024 | | | -| | 49 | | Trump | | | | 47 | | 49 | | | -| | 40 | | For Trump | | | | 31 | | 33 | | | -| | 9 | | Against Harris | | | | 15 | | 16 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| 47 | | | Harris | | | | 48 | | 49 | | | -| | 23 | | For Harris | | | | 23 | | 24 | | | -| | 24 | | Against Trump | | | | 25 | | 25 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| | 2 | | Vote for Kennedy Jr./Oliver/Stein/West/De | | | | - | | - | | | -La Cruz/Another candidate -| | 2 | | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | * | | No answer* | | | | * | | * | | | - -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Biden was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | Based on voters | | | | Based on registered voters | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | | | Jun 16-22, | -| | | | | | | 2020 | | | 20204 | | 2020 | -| | | | Trump | | | 47 | | | 42 | | 44 | -| | | | For Trump | | | 36 | | | 30 | | 33 | -| | | | Against Biden | | | 11 | | | 12 | | 10 | -| | | | Biden | | | 51 | | | 52 | | 54 | -| | | | For Biden | | | 24 | | | 19 | | 18 | -| | | | Against Trump | | | 28 | | | 33 | | 36 | -| | | | Vote for Jorgensen/Hawkins/Another | | | 1 | | | - | | - | -candidate -| | | | No answer | | | * | | | * | | - | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + AN OVERVIEW OF THE WINDOWS AZURE PLATFORM + +Using computers in the cloud can make lots of sense. Rather than buying and maintaining your own +machines, why not exploit the acres of Internet-accessible servers on offer today? For some applications, +both code and data might live in the cloud, where somebody else manages and maintains the systems +they use. Alternatively, applications that run inside an organization—on-premises applications—might +store data in the cloud or rely on other cloud infrastructure services. However it’s done, exploiting the +cloud’s capabilities can improve our world. + +But whether an application runs in the cloud, uses services provided by the cloud, or both, some kind of +application platform is required. Viewed broadly, an application platform can be thought of as anything +that provides developer-accessible services for creating applications or storing data. In the on-premises +Windows world, this includes technologies such as Windows Server and SQL Server. To let applications +exploit the cloud, a cloud application platform must also exist. + +This is exactly what the Microsoft Windows Azure platform provides. It’s a group of cloud technologies, +each providing a specific set of services to application developers. Figure 1 shows its components. + +Figure 1: The Windows Azure platform supports applications, data, and infrastructure in the cloud, +together with a cloud marketplace. + +The Windows Azure platform today has four parts: + + Windows Azure: A Windows environment for running applications and storing data on computers in + +Microsoft data centers. + +SQL Azure: Relational data services in the cloud based on SQL Server. + + Windows Azure AppFabric: Cloud-based infrastructure services for applications running in the cloud + +or on premises. 3 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and KHFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Harris. -4 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and JBFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Biden. -www.pewresearch.org + + Windows Azure Marketplace: An online service for purchasing cloud-based data and applications. + +All four of these components run in Microsoft data centers located around the world: two in North +America, two in Europe, and two in Asia. Developers using the platform can control which data center +runs their applications and stores their data, giving them the ability to place both closer to their users. + +Each part of the Windows Azure platform has its own role to play. This overview describes all four, first at +a high level, then in a bit more detail. The goal is to provide a big-picture introduction to this cloud +platform. + +WINDOWS AZURE + +At a high level, Windows Azure is simple to understand: It runs Windows applications and stores data in +the cloud. Figure 2 shows its components. + +Figure 2: Windows Azure provides compute and storage services in the cloud. + +The five parts of Windows Azure today are the following: + + Compute: The Windows Azure compute service runs applications on a Windows Server foundation. +These applications can be created using the .NET Framework in languages such as C# and Visual Basic, +or they can be built without .NET in C++, Java, and other languages. Developers can use Visual Studio +or other development tools, and they’re free to use technologies such as ASP.NET, Windows +Communication Foundation (WCF), and PHP. + +Storage: This service allows storing binary large objects (blobs), provides queues for communication +between components of Windows Azure applications, and even offers a form of tables with a simple +query language. (Windows Azure applications that need traditional relational storage can also use 4 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEDECTIME As far as you can remember, when did you make up your mind about who you were going to -vote for in the presidential election? -BASED ON THOSE WHO SELECTED A CANDIDATE (VOTEGEN_POST=1-8) [N=7,977] -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 12-17, Dec 12 -2024 2020 20165 -Last few days before Election -4 Day 3 9 -The last week before Election -3 Day 2 4 -7 In October 5 9 -6 In September 5 11 -81 Before September 84 67 -* No answer* * * -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you make up your mind definitely to vote for “Hillary Clinton;” “Donald Trump;” “Gary -Johnson;” “Jill Stein,” “The candidate of your choice”? -Nov 10-14 Nov 8-11 Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov -2016 2012 2004 2000 1996 1992 1988 -On Election Day 4 4 4 5 6 9 6 -On Monday (day before the election) * 1 1 2 3 4 3 -Over the last weekend * 1 1 2 2 4 2 -In the last week 2 2 3 5 6 8 4 -In the last few weeks 5 -- -- -- -- -- -- -During or just after the Presidential debates 10 10 11 17 -- 12 -- -Before debates/after the Conventions 10 9 6 9 12 6 16 -Convention period (NET) 22 10 7 7 8 12 15 -During or after the Republican convention 13 9 1 4 -- -- -- -During or after the Democratic convention 9 1 6 3 -- -- -- -This year, before the conventions 22 16 23 21 13 18 19 -Before 2016 20 41 38 20 39 12 9 -Other -- 0 0 -- * 8 -- -Don’t remember 2 1 4 6 6 5 4 -Don’t know/Refused 1 4 2 3 2 1 2 -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -5 In 2016, people who said “another candidate” were not asked this question; question read “As far as you can remember, -when did you make up your mind definitely to vote for ‘Donald Trump;’ ‘Hillary Clinton;’ ‘Gary Johnson;’ ‘Jill Stein’?” -www.pewresearch.org + + SQL Azure.) Both Windows Azure applications and on-premises applications can access the Windows +Azure storage service, and both do it in the same way: using a RESTful approach. + +Fabric controller: As the figure suggests, Windows Azure runs on a large number of machines. The +fabric controller’s job is to knit the machines in a single Windows Azure data center into a cohesive +whole. The Windows Azure compute and storage services are then built on top of this pool of +processing power. + + Content delivery network (CDN): Caching frequently accessed data closer to its users speeds up +access to that data. The Windows Azure CDN can do this for blobs, maintaining cached copies at sites +around the world. + + Connect: It’s often useful for organizations to interact with cloud applications as if they were inside +the organization’s own firewall. Windows Azure Connect allows this, making it easier for, say, a +Windows Azure application to access an on-premises database. + +Running applications and storing data in the cloud can have clear benefits. Rather than buying, installing, +and operating its own systems, for example, an organization can rely on a cloud provider to do this for +them. Also, customers pay just for the computing and storage they use, rather than maintaining a large +set of servers only for peak loads. And applications written for Windows Azure can scale better, be more +reliable, and require less administration than those written using the traditional Windows Server +programming model. + +To create, configure, and monitor applications, Windows Azure customers can use a browser-accessible +portal. A customer logs in with a Windows Live ID, then chooses whether to create a hosting account for +running applications, a storage account for storing data, or both. Microsoft then charges each customer +based on how much compute time, storage, and bandwidth that customer uses. How an application +charges its own customers—if it charges them at all—is entirely up to the people who create that +application. + +Windows Azure is a general platform that can be used in a broad set of scenarios. Here are a few +examples: + + An independent software vendor (ISV) creating a software-as-a-service (SaaS) version of an existing +on-premises Windows application might choose to build it on Windows Azure. Because Windows +Azure mostly provides a standard Windows environment, moving the application’s business logic to +this cloud platform won’t typically pose many problems. And once again, building on an existing +platform lets the ISV focus on business logic—the thing that makes them money—rather than +spending time on infrastructure. + + An enterprise creating an application for its customers or employees might choose to build it on +Windows Azure. Because Windows Azure supports .NET, developers with the right skills aren’t +difficult to find, nor are they prohibitively expensive. Running the application in Microsoft data +centers frees the enterprise from the responsibility and expense of managing its own servers, turning +capital expenses into operating expenses. And especially if the application has spikes in usage— +maybe it’s an on-line flower store that must handle the Mother’s Day rush—letting Microsoft +maintain the large server base required for this can make economic sense. 5 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_COM Do you think the elections this November in your community were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 55 | Very well | | 42 | | 53 | | 49 | | | | -| 35 | Somewhat well | | 42 | | 32 | | 38 | | | | -| 7 | Not too well | | 9 | | 9 | | | 8 | | | -| 2 | Not at all well | | 4 | | 6 | | | 4 | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | | 1 | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in your community will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 43 | | 40 | | 36 | | 41 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 44 | | 45 | | 48 | | 46 | -| | Not too well | | | 8 | | 10 | | 11 | | 9 | -| | Not at all well | | | 4 | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_US Do you think the elections this November in the United States were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 37 | Very well | | 25 | | 33 | | 21 | | | | -| 47 | Somewhat well | | 46 | | 25 | | 53 | | | | -| 11 | Not too well | | 18 | | 20 | | 18 | | | | -| 4 | Not at all well | | 8 | | 22 | | 7 | | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | 1 | | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in the United States will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 20 | | 20 | | 12 | | 20 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 50 | | 49 | | 46 | | 57 | -| | Not too well | | | 21 | | 23 | | 30 | | 18 | -| | Not at all well | | | 8 | | 7 | | 12 | | 4 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org + + A start-up creating a new Web site—the next Facebook, say—could build its application on Windows +Azure. Because this platform supports both Web-facing services and background processes, the +application can provide an +interface as well as executing work for users +asynchronously. Rather than spending time and money worrying about infrastructure, the start-up +can instead focus solely on creating code that provides value to its customers and investors. The +company can also start small, incurring low costs while its application has only a few users. If the +application catches on and usage increases, Windows Azure can scale the application as needed. + +interactive user + +These three examples illustrate the kinds of things organizations might do with Windows Azure, but +they’re not an exhaustive list. As interest in cloud computing continues to grow, expect to see a variety of +applications created for this cloud platform. + +SQL AZURE + +Along with running applications, another attractive way to use the cloud is for storing data. SQL Azure +addresses this area, offering cloud-based services for relational data. As Figure 3 shows, SQL Azure today +includes three components. + +Figure 3: SQL Azure provides relational database services in the cloud. + +The components of SQL Azure today are the following: + +SQL Azure Database provides a cloud-based database management system (DBMS). This technology +lets on-premises and cloud applications store relational data on Microsoft servers in Microsoft data 6 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTEASY_POST Overall, was voting in the election this November for you personally... [ROTATE -RESPONSES OPTIONS 1-4/4-1] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 79 | Very easy | | | | 77 | | | | | | -| | 15 | Somewhat easy | | | | 17 | | | | | | -| | 5 | Somewhat difficult | | | | 5 | | | | | | - -| | 2 | Very difficult | | | | 1 | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Overall, do you personally expect voting in the November elections to be... - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | | Sep 30- | Oct 10- | | Sep 30- | Jul 27- | Sep 24- | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | Oct 6, | 16 | | Oct 5 | Aug 2 | Oct 7 | -| | | | | | | 2024 | 2022 | | 2020 | 2020 | 2018 | -| | | Very easy | | | | 43 | 45 | | 29 | 23 | 46 | -| | | Somewhat easy | | | | 38 | 37 | | 36 | 28 | 39 | -| | | Somewhat difficult | | | | 16 | 14 | | 29 | 38 | 13 | -| | | Very difficult | | | | 4 | | 3 | 6 | 11 | 2 | -| | | No answer | | | | * | | * | * | 1 | * | - -ASK ALL: -SATCAND_POST Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential -candidates? Would you say that you were… -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 32 | Very satisfied | | | | 30 | | | | | | -| | 20 | Fairly satisfied | | | | 26 | | | | | | -| | 22 | Not too satisfied | | | | 24 | | | | | | -| | 25 | Not at all satisfied | | | | 19 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | - - TREND FOR COMPARISON: -What is your opinion of the presidential candidates for this year? Would you say that you are… - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | 2024 Election | | | | 2020 Election | | | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | Aug 26- | | | | | Jul 27- | | | -| | | | | Sep 2, | | Jul 1-7, | | | Aug 2, | Jun 16-22, | | -| | | | | 2024 | | 2024 | | | 2020 | 2020 | | -| | Very satisfied | | | | 15 | 11 | | | 15 | 16 | | -| | Fairly satisfied | | | | 32 | 20 | | | 31 | 31 | | -| | Not too satisfied | | | | 34 | 32 | | | 35 | 34 | | -| | Not at all satisfied | | | | 17 | 37 | | | 19 | 19 | | -| | No answer* | | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | 1 | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org + + centers. As with other cloud technologies, an organization pays only for what it uses, increasing and +decreasing usage (and cost) as the organization’s needs change. Using a cloud database also allows +converting what would be capital expenses, such as investments in disks and DBMS software, into +operating expenses. + +SQL Azure Reporting is a version of SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS) that runs in the cloud. +Intended primarily for use with SQL Azure Database, it allows creating and publishing standard SSRS +reports on cloud data. + +SQL Azure Data Sync allows synchronizing data between SQL Azure Database and on-premises SQL +Server databases. It can also be used to synchronize data across different SQL Azure databases in +different Microsoft data centers. + +SQL Azure is built on Microsoft SQL Server. As with SQL Server, developers can create indexes and views, +use stored procedures, define triggers, and more. Applications can access SQL Azure data using Entity +Framework, ADO.NET, and other Windows data access interfaces. In fact, applications that today access +SQL Server locally will largely work unchanged with data in SQL Azure. Customers can also use on- +premises software such as SQL Server Analysis Services to work with their cloud-based data. + +While applications can use SQL Azure much as they do a local DBMS, the management requirements are +significantly reduced. Rather than worry about mechanics, such as monitoring disk usage and servicing log +files, a SQL Azure customer can focus on their data; Microsoft handles the operational details. And as with +other components of this cloud platform, customers use the common Windows Azure platform portal to +access its services. + +Applications might use SQL Azure in a variety of ways. Here are some examples: + + A Windows Azure application can store its data in SQL Azure. While Windows Azure provides its own +storage, relational tables aren’t among the options it offers. Since many existing applications use +relational storage and many developers know how to work with it, a significant number of Windows +Azure applications rely on SQL Azure to work with data in this familiar way. For example, a SaaS +application built on Windows Azure might create a separate SQL Azure database for each customer, +providing an intrinsically multi-tenant design. And to improve performance, customers can specify +that a particular Windows Azure application must run in the same data center in which SQL Azure +Database stores that application’s information. + + An application in a small business or a department of a larger organization might rely on SQL Azure. +Rather than storing its data in a SQL Server or Access database running on a computer under +somebody’s desk, the application can instead take advantage of the reliability and availability of cloud +storage. It can also create reports on this data using either SQL Azure Reporting or SSRS on-premises. +If the organization wishes to maintain an on-premises copy of the data as well, it can use SQL Azure +Data Sync to synchronize the cloud and on-premises databases. + +Suppose a manufacturer wishes to make product information available both to its dealer network +and directly to customers. Putting this data in SQL Azure would let it be accessed by applications +running at the dealers and by a customer-facing Web application run by the manufacturer itself. 7 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -SATCAND_POST TREND FOR COMPARSION CONTINUED … -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: - Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential candidates? + Whether it’s for supporting a Windows Azure application, making data more accessible, or other reasons, +data services in the cloud can be attractive. The goal of SQL Azure is to provide these services in a familiar, +usable way for cloud and on-premises applications. + +WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC -BASED ON THOSE WHO VOTED: +Running applications and storing data in the cloud are both important aspects of cloud computing. +They’re far from the whole story, however. It’s also possible to provide cloud-based infrastructure +services. Filling this gap is the goal of Windows Azure AppFabric. -| | | | Nov 10-14, | | Nov 8-11, | | Nov Nov | | Nov Nov | Nov Nov | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2012 | | 2008 2004 | | 2000 1996 | 1992 1988 | -| Very satisfied | | | | 19 | 37 | | 39 | 33 | 24 18 | 24 26 | -| Fairly satisfied | | | | 25 | 33 | | 28 | 33 | 44 33 | 37 36 | -| Not very satisfied | | | | 26 | 16 | | 17 | 16 | 18 24 | 21 20 | -| Not at all satisfied | | | | 29 | 12 | | 14 | 16 | 9 22 | 16 17 | -| Don't | | | | 1 | 3 | | 2 | 2 | 5 3 | 2 1 | -know/Refused -(VOL.) +The functions provided by AppFabric today address common challenges in building distributed +applications. Figure 4 shows its components. -[DISPLAY CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD, CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG, CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY, -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT ON SAME PAGE; RANDOMIZE ORDER OF QUESTIONS; INCLUDE -RANDOMIZATION IN DATA FILE. DO NOT RANDOMIZE RESPONSE OPTIONS WITHIN EACH -QUESTION] +Figure 4: Windows Azure AppFabric provides Windows Azure-based infrastructure services that can be +used by both cloud and on-premises applications. -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... +As the figure suggests, all of the components of Windows Azure AppFabric are built on Windows Azure +(although they don’t all provide services solely to Windows Azure applications). Those components are +the following: -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: +Service Bus: Exposing an application’s services on the Internet is harder than it might seem. The goal +of Service Bus is to make this simpler by letting an application expose endpoints in the cloud that can +be accessed by other applications, whether on-premises or in the cloud. Each exposed endpoint is +assigned a URI, which clients can use to locate and access the service. Service Bus also handles the +challenges of dealing with network address translation and getting through firewalls without opening +new ports for exposed applications. -| | | | Made you feel proud | | | Did not make you feel | | | No | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | of the country | | | proud of the country | | | answer* | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 29 | | | 70 | | 1 | | + Access Control: There are many ways for a user to get a digital identity today. The options include +Active Directory, Windows Live ID, Google Accounts, Facebook, and more. If an application wants to +let users log in with any of these, the application’s creator faces the daunting challenge of supporting -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | +8 -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + this plethora of approaches. Access Control simplifies this by providing built-in support for all of them +(and more). It also provides a single place for defining rules to control what each user is allowed to +access. -| | | | | | | Makes you feel proud | | Does not make you feel | | No | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | of the country | | proud of the country | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | 19 | | 79 | 2 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | 12 | | 87 | 1 | + Caching: It’s common for applications to access the same data over and over. One way to speed up +this kind of application is to cache frequently accessed information, reducing the number of times +that application must query a database. The Caching service provides this—and the performance +boost it brings—for Windows Azure applications. -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org +Microsoft has announced plans to add more services under the Windows Azure AppFabric banner, so +expect this list to grow in the not-too-distant future. -8 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Too | | Not too | | No | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | negative | | negative | | answer* | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | | 25 | | 1 | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | Too | Not too | | No | | -| | | | | | | | | negative | negative | | answer* | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 71 | | 27 | | 2 | -Jul 1-7, 2024 -| | | | | | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:6 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 76 | | 23 | | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 61 | | 37 | | 2 | - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Focused on important | | | Not focused on important | | | | No | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | | | policy debates | | | | policy debates | | | answer* | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 35 | | | | 64 | | 1 | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | | | Focused on | | Not focused on | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | important | | important | | No | -| | | | | | | | | policy debates | | policy debates | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 37 | | | 62 | 1 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | | 23 | | | 76 | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:7 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 27 | | | 72 | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 25 | | | 73 | 2 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -6 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -7 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org +As with Windows Azure and SQL Azure, customers use a browser-accessible portal to sign up for +AppFabric. Once this has been done, these services can be used in a variety of ways. Here are some of the +possibilities: + +Suppose an enterprise wished to let software at its trading partners access one of its applications. It +could expose this application’s functions through SOAP or RESTful services created using WCF, then +register those service endpoints with Service Bus. Its trading partners could then use Service Bus to +find these endpoints and access the services. + +Imagine that the creator of this same application needs to let trading partners log in with a variety of +different identities. Rather than implementing support for these identities himself, he could use the +Access Control service to hide this complexity. + + A Windows Azure application created using ASP.NET might use the Session object to store per-client +state. By changing only a configuration setting, the application can cause this data to be kept in the +Caching service rather than, say, Windows Azure Storage tables. Doing this is likely to make the +application faster and more scalable. + +Along with the cloud-based services of Windows Azure AppFabric, Microsoft also provides an analogous +technology known as Windows Server AppFabric. As its name suggests, the services it provides run on +Windows Server—they support on-premises applications—rather than in the cloud. The on-premises +services aren’t exactly the same today as those in Windows Azure AppFabric (although Microsoft’s +announced plan is make the two congruent). Don’t be confused; throughout this paper, the name +“AppFabric” is used to refer to the cloud-based services. Also, don’t confuse Windows Azure AppFabric +with the Windows Azure fabric controller. Even though both contain the term “fabric”, they’re wholly +separate technologies addressing quite distinct problems. + +WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE + +In the on-premises world, many applications are purchased rather than custom-built. Many organizations +also rely on datasets from commercial providers. With the rise of the cloud, why not let customers find +and buy cloud applications and cloud-accessible data? Making this possible is the goal of Windows Azure +Marketplace. Figure 5 shows its two components. 9 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | | No | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | Interesting | Dull answer* | | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | 24 2 | | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | No | -| | | | | | Interesting | | | Dull | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON8 | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | 64 | | 34 | | 2 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | 39 | | 59 | | 2 | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -| VOTE_HOW_POST | | | How did you vote in the election? [RANDOMIZE] | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -| VOTEINPWHEN | | When did you vote? | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| | 65 | In person at a polling place | | | | | 65 | | 54 | | -| | 34 | On Election Day | | | | | 44 | | | 27 | -| | 32 | Before Election Day | | | | | 21 | | | 27 | -| | * | Refused | | | | | * | | | * | -| | 35 | By absentee or mail-in ballot | | | | | 35 | | 46 | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | * | | | * | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you vote in the elections this November? -How did you vote in the November election? - -| | | | | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2018 -| | | On election day | | | | | 55 | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Before election day | | | | | 45 | | | | -| | | Voted in person | | | | | 19 | | | | -| | | Mailed in ballot | | | | | 25 | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -8 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org + + Figure 5: Windows Azure Marketplace provides an online marketplace for cloud applications and data. + +The two parts of Windows Azure Marketplace are: + + DataMarket (originally codenamed “Dallas”), providing a way for content providers to make datasets +available. Customers can browse the offerings, then purchase whatever they find useful. Applications, +both custom and off-the-shelf (such as Microsoft Excel), can then access this data through RESTful +requests or the OData protocol. + + AppMarket, providing a way for creators of cloud applications to expose those applications to + +potential customers. AppMarket will be available sometime after DataMarket. + +Using the cloud to find, evaluate, and purchase data and applications makes sense. The goal of Windows +Azure Marketplace is to make these things easier to do. + +A CLOSER LOOK AT THE TECHNOLOGIES + +Having a broad understanding of the Windows Azure platform is an important first step. Making good +decisions require a deeper understanding of these technologies, however. This section takes a slightly +more in-depth look at each member of the family. + +WINDOWS AZURE + +Windows Azure provides what’s commonly called Platform as a Service (PaaS). Rather than offering a +cloud replica of the on-premises world, it offers a higher level of service that’s meant to make life easier +for both developers and administrators. What follows walks through the five components that +collectively provide this service. 10 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -VOTE_HOW_POST/VOTEINPWHEN TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED… - -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Did you vote ON Election Day or BEFORE Election DAY? - -Did you vote in person or did you mail your ballot in? - -| | | | Nov 10-14 | Nov 6-9 | | Nov 8-11 | | Nov | | Nov | | Nov | Nov | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2014 | | 2012 | 2008 | | 2006 | | 2004 | 2002 | -| On Election Day | | | 59 | | 71 | | 63 | 66 | | 80 | | 80 | 85 | -| Before Election Day | | | 41 | | 29 | | 37 | 34 | | 20 | | 20 | 15 | -| Voted in person | | | 22 | | 12 | | 19 | 19 | | -- | | | | -| Mailed in ballot | | | 18 | | 16 | | 17 | 14 | | -- | | | | -| Other way/DK/Ref (VOL) | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | 1 | | -- | | | | -| Don’t know/Refused (VOL) | | | 0 | | * | | 0 | * | | * | | * | * | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -VOTEMAIL How did you return your absentee or mail-in ballot? [RANDOMIZE] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | | 2020 | | | | -| | 12 | In person to an election official or poll | | | | | | 12 | | 15 | | | | -worker -| | 38 | At a designated dropbox | | | | | | 36 | | 41 | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 50 | By mail | | | | | | 52 | | 44 | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | * | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILWHEN When did you mail or return your absentee or mail-in ballot? - -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | | -| | 33 | In the week leading up to Election Day | | | | | | 23 | | | | | | -| | 67 | Before that | | | | | | 76 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -WAITVOTE When you went to vote, approximately how long did you have to wait in line to -vote? -| | | | | | | | | | | | Nov 17- | | | -| ------------ | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | Dec 15, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | 2014 | | | -| | 42 | Did not wait at all9 | | | | 35 | | 47 | | | | 53 | | -| | 30 | Less than 10 minutes | | | | 27 | | 33 | | | | 30 | | -| | 17 | 10 to 30 minutes | | | | 20 | | 14 | | | | 13 | | -| | 7 | 31 minutes to 1 hour | | | | 11 | | | 5 | | | 3 | | -| | 4 | More than 1 hour | | | | 6 | | | 1 | | | * | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | * | | | * | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -9 In surveys prior to November 2024, the response was worded “Not at all”. -www.pewresearch.org + + Compute + +An application built on the Windows Azure compute service is structured as one or more roles. When it +executes, the application typically runs two or more instances of each role, with each instance running as +its own virtual machine (VM). Figure 6 shows how this looks. + +Figure 6: A running Windows Azure application consists of any combination of Web role instances, +Worker role instances, and VM role instances. + +A Windows Azure application today can be created using three kinds of roles: + + Web roles, intended primarily for running Web-based applications. Each Web role instance has +Internet Information Services (IIS) 7 pre-configured to run inside it, so creating applications using +ASP.NET, WCF, or other Web technologies is straightforward. It’s also possible to create applications +using PHP, Java, and other non-Microsoft technologies. + + Worker roles, designed to run a variety of code. A Worker role might run a simulation, for example, +or video processing or nearly anything else. It’s common for an application to interact with users +through a Web role, then hand tasks off to a Worker role for processing. + + VM roles, which can run a user-provided Windows Server 2008 R2 image. A VM role can be the right + +choice for moving some on-premises Windows Server applications to Windows Azure. + +When a developer gives Windows Azure an application to run, she submits configuration information +along with it. Among other things, this information tells the platform how many instances of each role to +run. The Windows Azure fabric controller then creates a VM for each instance, running the code for the 11 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK IF VOTED BY MAIL OR ABSENTEE (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted by mail or absentee ballot? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2020 | | | -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted by -| 12 | | | 39 | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -mail or absentee ballot -| 88 | No, I have voted by mail or absentee ballot before | | 61 | | | -| --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON BEFORE ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=1) [N=2,671]: -| EARLYFIRST | Is this the first time you have ever voted early? | | | | | -| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -29 Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted early -71 No, I have voted early before -* No answer* - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON ON ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=2) [N=2,513]: -ELECDFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted in person on Election Day? - -Nov 12-17, -2024 -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted in person on Election Day -7 -93 No, I have voted in person on Election Day before -* No answer* - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTCOUNT_OWN How confident are you that your vote was accurately counted? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | 2020 | | -| 59 | Very confident | | 57 | 59 | | -| 33 | Somewhat confident | | 31 | 26 | | -| 5 | Not too confident | | 8 | 9 | | -Not at all confident -| 2 | | | 3 | 6 | | -| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | * | | - -| | PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | Nov 10-14 Nov 6-9 Nov 8-11 Nov 4-7 | | Nov Nov | Nov | -| --- | -------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | -| | | 2016 2014 | 2012 2010 | 2008 2006 | 2004 | -| | Very confident | 71 68 | 68 64 | 73 70 | 68 | -| | Somewhat confident | 19 21 | 22 26 | 22 23 | 24 | -| | Not too confident | 4 5 | 5 4 | 3 3 | 4 | -| | Not at all confident | 5 4 | 3 3 | 2 2 | 3 | -| | Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) | 1 1 | 1 3 | * 2 | 1 | -| | | | | | | -www.pewresearch.org + + appropriate role in each VM. And as Figure 6 indicates, requests from the outside world are load balanced +across all instances of a role. + +This has an important implication: To be scalable, Windows Azure role instances shouldn’t maintain their +state themselves between requests. Because the load balancer doesn’t allow creating an affinity with a +particular role instance—there’s no support for sticky sessions—there’s no way to guarantee that multiple +requests from the same user will be sent to the same instance. Instead, any client-specific state should be +written to Windows Azure storage, stored in SQL Azure Database, or maintained externally in some other +way. + +For role instances, Windows Azure lets developers choose from several VM sizes, each with a specific +number of processor cores and memory. Since each instance can be assigned one or more cores, +applications have predictable performance. And to increase the load an application can handle, its owner +or the application itself can request an increase in the number of running instances for one or more roles. +The Windows Azure fabric controller will then spin up new VMs for these instances and start them +running. It’s also possible to explicitly decrease the number of instances for a role, letting an application +grow and shrink as needed to handle changing loads. + +For developers, building a Windows Azure application looks much like building a traditional Windows +application. Microsoft provides Visual Studio project templates, for instance, to help developers create +Windows Azure applications. Also, the Windows Azure software development kit includes a version of the +Windows Azure environment that runs on the developer’s machine. Known as the Windows Azure +development fabric, it implements a local replica of the Windows Azure compute and storage services. A +developer can create and debug his application using this local simulacrum, then deploy it to Windows +Azure in the cloud when it’s ready. Windows Azure also provides other services for developers, such as +information about a running application’s CPU consumption, incoming and outgoing bandwidth, and +storage usage. + +Storage + +Applications work with data in many different ways. Sometimes, all that’s required are simple blobs, while +other situations call for a more structured way to store information. And in some cases, all that’s really +needed is a way to exchange data between different parts of an application. Windows Azure storage +addresses all three of these requirements, as Figure 7 shows. 12 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_INP How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 38 | Very confident | | 37 | | 42 | | -| 47 | Somewhat confident | | 43 | | 35 | | -| 11 | Not too confident | | 13 | | 13 | | -| 4 | Not at all confident | | 6 | | 8 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United States will -be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 36 | | 34 | 42 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 46 | | 45 | 44 | -| | Not too confident | | 13 | | 15 | 10 | -| | Not at all confident | | | 5 | 5 | 4 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_ABS How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail in ballot across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 24 | Very confident | | 25 | | 30 | | -| 46 | Somewhat confident | | 37 | | 27 | | -| 21 | Not too confident | | 23 | | 19 | | -| 7 | Not at all confident | | 13 | | 23 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail-in ballot across the United States -will be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 22 | | 21 | 17 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 38 | | 38 | 38 | -| | Not too confident | | 27 | | 24 | 28 | -| | Not at all confident | | 12 | | 16 | 16 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -www.pewresearch.org + + Figure 7: Windows Azure provides blobs, tables, and queues, all accessed in a RESTful style via HTTP, +HTTPS, or OData. + +The simplest way to store data in Windows Azure storage is to use blobs. As Figure 7 suggests, there’s a +simple hierarchy: A storage account can have one or more containers, each of which holds one or more +blobs. Blobs can be big—as large as a terabyte each—and to make transferring large blobs more efficient, +they can potentially be subdivided into blocks. If a failure occurs, retransmission can resume with the +most recent block rather than sending the entire blob again. Blobs can also have associated metadata, +such as information about where a JPEG photograph was taken or who the composer is for an MP3 file. + +Another way to use blobs is through Windows Azure drives, which can be mounted by a role instance. The +underlying storage for a drive is a blob, and so once a drive is mounted, the instance can read and write +file system data that gets stored persistently in a blob. + +Blobs are just right for some kinds of data, but they’re too unstructured for many situations. To allow +applications to work with data in a more fine-grained way, Windows Azure storage provides tables. Don’t +be misled by the name: These aren’t relational tables. In fact, even though they’re called “tables”, the +data they contain is actually stored in a set of entities with properties. A table has no defined schema; +instead, properties can have various types, such as int, string, Bool, or DateTime. And rather than using +SQL, an application can access a table’s data using the simple query language defined by OData. A single +table can be quite large, with billions of entities holding terabytes of data, and Windows Azure storage +can partition it across many servers if necessary to improve performance. + +Blobs and tables are both focused on storing data. The third option in Windows Azure storage, queues, +has a somewhat different purpose. A primary use of queues is to let Web role instances communicate +with Worker role instances. For example, a user might submit a request to perform some compute- 13 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK ALL: -ELECT_CONFNOVPOS How confident, if at all, are you that... [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] - -| | | | | | | Very | Somewhat | | Not too | | Not at all | No | -| ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | | | confident | | confident | | confident | | confident | answer* | -| PRVFR | | People who were not legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified to vote are prevented | | | | | | | | | | | -from casting a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 27 | | 38 | 26 | | 8 | 1 | -| ------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON10: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 29 | | 30 | 24 | | 17 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 23 | | 36 | 28 | | 11 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| PRVSUP | | People who were legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified and want to vote are | | | | | | | | | | | -able to cast a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 45 | | 42 | 9 | | 3 | 1 | -| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON11: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 44 | | 43 | 10 | | 3 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 36 | | 45 | 14 | | 4 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK ALL: -| PARTY | | In politics today, do you consider yourself a… | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3, 4 OR REFUSED): -| PARTYLN | | As of today do you lean more to…12 | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | Something | | No | | Lean | Lean | | - Republican Democrat Independent else answer* Rep Dem -| | | 28 | 27 | 30 | | 14 | | 1 | | 20 | | 20 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -10 In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are not legally qualified to vote are prevented from -casting a ballot.” -11 -In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are legally qualified and want to vote are able to cast -a ballot.” -12 PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey. -www.pewresearch.org \ No newline at end of file + + intensive task via a Web page implemented by a Windows Azure Web role. The Web role instance that +receives this request can write a message into a queue describing the work to be done. A Worker role +instance that’s waiting on this queue can then read the message and carry out the task it specifies. Any +results can be returned via another queue or handled in some other way. + +Regardless of how it’s stored—in blobs, tables, or queues—all data held in Windows Azure storage is +replicated three times. This replication allows fault tolerance, since losing a copy isn’t fatal. The system +guarantees consistency, however, so an application that reads data it has just written will get what it +expects. + +Windows Azure storage can be accessed either by a Windows Azure application or by an application +running somewhere else. In both cases, all three Windows Azure storage styles use the conventions of +REST (and the OData protocol for tables) to identify and expose data. Everything is named using URIs and +accessed with standard HTTP operations, so clients can be created using .NET, Java, or other familiar +technologies. + +The Windows Azure platform charges independently for compute and storage resources. This means that +an on-premises application can use just Windows Azure storage, accessing its data in the RESTful way just +described. For example, a Windows Server application running in an enterprise data center might choose +to store backups in Windows storage blobs. + +Fabric Controller + +Even though a Windows Azure application runs in VMs, a developer doesn’t explicitly create and manage +those VMs. Instead, as described earlier, she just tells the platform how many instances the application +needs, and Windows Azure silently creates the necessary VMs and runs her application. This magic is +performed by the fabric controller, a fundamental aspect of Windows Azure. + +Along with creating VMs and starting the applications that run in them, the fabric controller also monitors +all running instances. A role instance might fail for many reasons; maybe the code threw an exception or +the VM crashed or the physical server it’s running on went down. Whatever the reason, the fabric +controller will start a new instance to maintain the total number of instances required for this application. + +The fabric controller also handles housekeeping tasks like patching the operating system and other +system software, which minimizes the need for administrators. These are all examples of why Windows +Azure is viewed as PaaS: It provides a platform that lets customers run applications without worrying +about administering the environment they run in. + +Content Delivery Network + +One common use of blobs is to store information that will be accessed from many different places. Think +of an application that serves up videos, for example, to Flash, Silverlight, or HTML 5 clients around the +world. To improve performance in situations like this, Windows Azure provides a content delivery +network. The CDN stores copies of a blob at sites closer to the clients that use it. This speeds up delivery +of frequently accessed content, improving performance for users of this information. + +14 + + Connect + +Windows Azure applications can interact with the outside world via HTTP, HTTPS, or TCP. But suppose +you’d like to connect a role in an application to a machine outside the cloud at the IP level. For example, +suppose an organization decides to move an existing ASP.NET application to Windows Azure, but wishes +to keep the application’s data in an on-premises SQL Server database. Windows Azure Connect allows +this. + +Using this option requires running Windows Azure Connect software on the on-premises machine that +contains SQL Server, and it also requires some straightforward configuration. (This configuration can be +done by the developer—there’s no need to get a network administrator involved.) Once this is done, all of +the instances in the Web role can behave as if they’re on the same IP network as the SQL Server machine. +In fact, they can use the same SQL Server connection string as when the application was running on +premises—there’s no difference. + +Note that this isn’t a full-fledged virtual private network (VPN). While Microsoft has announced plans to +let customers connect to Windows Azure via a VPN, this isn’t currently supported. It is possible to use +Windows Azure Connect to domain-join a Windows Azure application to an on-premises Active Directory, +however. Doing this allows single sign-on by on-premises users to the cloud application, and it also lets +the application use existing Active Directory accounts and groups for access control. + +The goal of application platforms, whether on-premises or in the cloud, is to support applications and +data. Windows Azure provides a home for both of these things. Going forward, expect to see a substantial +share of what would have been on-premises Windows applications instead running on this new cloud +platform. + +SQL AZURE + +A DBMS in the cloud is attractive for many reasons. Letting a specialized service provider ensure reliability +and perform essential management functions can make sense, especially for organizations that find these +things hard to do on their own. Data in the cloud can also be accessed by applications running anywhere, +even on mobile devices. And given the economies of scale that a service provider enjoys, using a cloud +database may well be cheaper than doing it yourself. + +SQL Azure provides these things, together with cloud-based reporting and data synchronization services. +And while all of them are important, the place to start is with the foundation: SQL Azure Database. + +Database + +SQL Azure Database is simple to understand. As seen by an application, it provides the core database +functions of SQL Server as a cloud service. Figure 8 shows the basics of this technology. + +15 + + Figure 8: Applications access data in SQL Azure Database through Microsoft’s TDS protocol or via OData. + +An application using SQL Azure Database might run on Windows Azure, in an enterprise’s data center, on +a mobile device, or somewhere else. Wherever it runs, the application typically accesses data via a +protocol called Tabular Data Stream (TDS). This is the same protocol used to access a local SQL Server +database, and so a SQL Azure Database application can use any existing SQL Server client. This includes +Entity Framework, ADO.NET, ODBC, PHP and others. And because SQL Azure Database looks like an +ordinary SQL Server system, standard tools can also be used, including SQL Server Management Studio, +SQL Server Integration Services, and BCP for bulk data copy. Also, as Figure 8 shows, applications can +optionally access SQL Azure Database using OData. + +Each SQL Azure account can have one or more logical servers. (Note that these provide a way to organize +the data and billing for an account—they aren’t actual instances of SQL Server.) Each server can then have +multiple databases, each of which can be up to 50 gigabytes in size. A user is free to use multiple +databases if required, spreading data across them for better performance or for other reasons. It’s also +possible to store a snapshot of one SQL Azure database into another, providing a simple backup +mechanism. + +For the most part, an application using SQL Azure Database sees a familiar SQL Server environment. A few +things are omitted in the technology’s current release, however, such as the SQL Common Language +Runtime (CLR) and support for full-text search. (Microsoft says that both will be available in a future +version.) Also, because administration is handled by Microsoft, the service doesn’t expose physical +administrative functions. A customer can’t shut down the system, for example, or interact directly with +the hardware it runs on. And as you’d expect in a shared environment, a query can run for only a limited +time—no single request can take up more than a pre-defined amount of resources. + +16 + + Yet while the environment looks quite standard, the service an application gets is more robust than what +a single instance of SQL Server provides. As in Windows Azure storage, all data stored in SQL Azure +Database is replicated three times for high availability. Also like Windows Azure storage, the service +provides strong consistency: When a write returns, the data has been made persistent. The goal is to +provide reliable data storage even in the face of system and network failures. + +Whether an application needs multiple databases or just one, SQL Azure Database can help developers +address a range of scenarios. Whatever problem is being solved, the technology’s fundamental goal +remains the same: to provide a familiar, reliable, and low-cost cloud database for many kinds of +applications. + +Reporting + +Storing data in SQL Azure Database can be useful. But as soon as that data exists, there’s likely to be a +demand for reports based on that data. Meeting this demand is the purpose of SQL Azure Reporting. +Based on SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS), this technology provides a cloud-based way to create +reports. + +Given that SQL Azure Database looks like SQL Server to an application, it’s always possible to use SSRS on- +premises with the data it contains. So why bother to provide a cloud reporting service as well? SQL Azure +Reporting today targets two main scenarios: + + Reports created using SQL Azure Reporting can be published to a SQL Azure Reporting portal, letting + +users access it there, or made accessible directly via a URL. + + An ISV can embed reports published to the SQL Azure Reporting portal in any application, including +Windows Azure applications. This lets users access those reports without leaving the application. To +do this, the ISV can use the standard ReportViewer controls in Visual Studio—it’s no different from +embedding on-premises reports into applications. + +SQL Azure Reporting is designed to work with data stored in SQL Azure Database. Reports used with SQL +Azure Reporting are created on-premises, however, with Business Intelligence Developer Studio, the +Visual Studio-hosted tool that’s also used to create SSRS reports. In fact, SQL Azure Reporting relies on the +same reporting format, expressed in the Report Definition Language (RDL), used with SSRS. + +Like other aspects of SQL Azure, SQL Azure Reporting doesn’t provide all of the functions offered by SSRS +on premises. There’s currently no support for scheduling and subscriptions, for example, that let a report +be run and delivered at regular intervals. Still, cloud-based reporting services can be useful, and they’re an +important part of the SQL Azure technology family. + +Data Sync + +Storing data in SQL Azure Database can make it accessible to any application with an Internet connection. +Still, there are often situations where it makes sense to maintain a copy of this cloud-based data in some +other place. Suppose an organization needs to have an on-premises copy of the same information, for +example, for performance reasons or to ensure access if the network fails. For scenarios like this, the +ability to synchronize data in SQL Azure Database with other data stores is useful. + +17 + + It’s always possible to write synchronization code yourself using the Microsoft Sync Framework. To make +this easier, Microsoft provides SQL Azure Data Sync. Rather than requiring its user to write code, this +technology is entirely configuration-driven (although unsurprisingly, it’s built on the Microsoft Sync +Framework). As Figure 9 shows, SQL Azure Data Sync supports two options today. + +Figure 9: SQL Azure Data Sync can synchronize data between SQL Azure databases or between a SQL +Azure database and on-premises SQL Server databases. + +The two synchronization options are the following: + +Synchronizing data between a SQL Azure database and an on-premises SQL Server database. Having +an on-premises copy of cloud data might make sense for a variety of reasons. Maybe an organization +wants to make sure that this data is always available, for instance, even in the event of network +failures, or perhaps regulations require that a copy of the data always be available within a country’s +borders. And even though SQL Azure’s built-in data replication guards against hardware failures, the +data’s owner might choose to maintain an on-premises backup copy in case of administrative errors, +such as incorrect table deletions. + +Synchronizing data between SQL Azure databases in different Microsoft data centers. For example, +suppose an ISV or a global enterprise creates an application that’s used by people around the world. +To provide good performance for all of them, its creator might choose to run this application in three +different Windows Azure data centers: one each in North America, Europe, and Asia. If the +application stores data in SQL Azure Database, it might rely on SQL Azure Data Sync to keep +information synchronized across these three data centers. + +SQL Azure Data Sync uses a hub-and-spoke model. All changes are copied first to the SQL Azure database +hub, then out to the spokes (referred to as members). The members might be other SQL Azure databases + +18 + + or on-premises SQL Server databases. In both cases, the technology provides synchronization of an entire +database or just specific tables, with changes made to any copy propagated to all of the others. And while +it’s possible to initiate synchronization manually, SQL Azure Data Sync also includes a scheduling service. +This lets users schedule, say, hourly synchronization between a pair of databases. However it’s used, the +purpose is the same: providing a straightforward way to synchronize data between a SQL Azure database +in a Microsoft data center and one or more databases located somewhere else. + + WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC + +Applications exist because their business logic has value. Yet applications rely on infrastructure to provide +a foundation for that logic. A good application platform provides this infrastructure; application +developers shouldn’t need to write it themselves. + +Windows Azure AppFabric provides infrastructure for applications. The people who create applications +can benefit from different kinds of infrastructure, and so AppFabric contains various parts. This section +takes a closer look at Service Bus, Access Control, and Caching, the three components of Windows Azure +AppFabric today. + +Service Bus + +Suppose you have an application running inside your organization that exposes a Web service built with +Windows Communication Foundation (WCF). Suppose further that you’d like to connect this service +through the Internet to software running outside your organization. This client software might be running +on a cloud platform, such as Windows Azure, or inside another organization. + +At first glance, this can seem like a simple problem. Since your application provides its functionality +through Web services (either RESTful or SOAP-based), you can just make those Web services visible to the +outside world. When you actually try to do this, though, some problems appear. + +First, how can clients in other organizations find endpoints they can connect to for your service? It would +be nice to have some kind of registry where others could locate your application. And once they’ve found +it, how can requests from software in other organizations get through to your service? Network address +translation (NAT) is very common, so an application frequently doesn’t have a fixed IP address to expose +externally. And even if NAT isn’t being used, how can requests get through your firewall? It’s possible to +open firewall ports to allow access to your application, but network administrators frown on this. + +Service Bus addresses these challenges. Figure 10 shows how. + +19 + + Figure 10: A WCF service can register endpoints with Service Bus, then have clients discover and use +those endpoints to access the service. + +To begin, your WCF service registers one or more endpoints with Service Bus (step 1). For each registered +endpoint, Service Bus exposes its own corresponding endpoint (step 2). Service Bus assigns your +organization a URI root, below which you’re free to create any naming hierarchy you like. This allows your +endpoints to be assigned specific, discoverable URIs. + +When a client running in the cloud or on-premises at some other organization wishes to access your +service, it contacts the Service Bus registry (step 3) to find the endpoint, providing the endpoint’s URI. This +request uses the Atom Publishing Protocol, and it returns an AtomPub service document with references +to the endpoints Service Bus exposes on behalf of your application. Once it has these, the client can +invoke operations on the services exposed through these endpoints (step 4). For each request Service Bus +receives, it invokes the corresponding operation in the endpoint exposed by your WCF service (step 5). +(Although it’s not shown in the figure, Service Bus establishes a direct connection between an application +and its client whenever possible, making their communication more efficient.) + +There’s an obvious question here: How exactly does step 5 work? How does the request from Service Bus +back to your service deal with the challenges of NAT and firewalls? The answer is that in step 1, your +service opened a TCP connection with Service Bus for this exposed endpoint. Service Bus holds this +connection open, which solves two problems. First, NAT is no longer an issue, since traffic on the open +connection with Service Bus will always be routed to your application. Second, because the connection +was initiated from inside the firewall, there’s no problem passing information back to the application via +this connection—the firewall won’t block this traffic. + +20 + + Along with making communication easier, Service Bus can also improve security. Because clients now see +only an IP address provided by Service Bus, there’s no need to expose any IP addresses from within your +organization. This effectively makes your application anonymous, since the outside world can’t see it. +Service Bus acts as an external DMZ, providing a layer of indirection to deter attackers. + +While an application that exposes its services via Service Bus is typically implemented using WCF, clients +can be built with WCF or other technologies, such as Java. However they’re created, these clients can +make requests via TCP, HTTP, or HTTPS. Applications are also free to use their own security mechanisms, +such as encryption, to shield their communication from attackers. + +Service Bus provides a few more useful features, including these: + +Support for message buffers, which act like simple queues. Rather than require a client to make +direct calls to a service, the client can place a message of up to 256 kilobytes into a message buffer. +The message is persisted to disk—it’s durable—and the service can then read this message at some +later time. And as usual in the Windows Azure platform, the persisted messages are replicated to +guard against failures. + + The ability for multiple WCF services to listen on the same URI. Service Bus will then randomly spread +client requests across all of the listening services. The goal is to provide both load balancing and fault +tolerance for the WCF services. + +Exposing applications to the outside world isn’t as simple as it might seem. The intent of Service Bus is to +make implementing these interactions as straightforward as possible. + +Access Control + +Working with identity is a fundamental part of most distributed applications. The modern approach to +this, called claims-based identity, lets a user send a token full of claims that contain identity information. +One claim might contain the user’s name, for example, while another contains her age or a group she +belongs to. An application can use the claims in a token to decide what the user is allowed to do or in +other ways. + +In a claims-based world, tokens are issued by identity providers (IdPs). Some IdPs, such as Active Directory +Federation Services (AD FS) 2.0, exist inside organizations. Others, such as Windows Live ID and Google +Accounts, are accessible to anyone via the Internet. Each application can decide which IdPs it trusts and +thus which tokens it’s willing to accept. For example, an application running inside your company might +only accept tokens issued by your own AD FS server, while an application running on the Internet might +accept tokens issued by, say, Google and Facebook. + +Yet different IdPs use different token formats, and they represent claims in different ways. An application +that directly accepts identities from Google, Facebook, and Yahoo, for instance, would need to handle +these differences itself. But why do this? Why not instead create an intermediary that can generate a +single token format with a common representation of claims? Doing this would make life simpler for the +people who create applications, since they now need to handle only one kind of token. + +The Access Control service does exactly this, providing an intermediary in the cloud for working with +claims-based identity. Figure 11 shows how it works. + +21 + + Figure 11: The Access Control service makes it easier for applications to accept identity information +issued by different identity providers. + +As the figure shows, an application that relies on Access Control can run either on-premises or in the +cloud. In either case, the process begins when a user attempts to access this application via a browser +(step 1). The application then redirects the browser to an IdP whose token this application will accept. The +user authenticates herself with this IdP, such as by entering a username and password, and the IdP +returns a token containing claims about her (step 2). + +Next, the user’s browser sends the IdP token to Access Control (step 3). Access Control validates the +token, making sure that it really was issued by this IdP, then creates a new token according to whatever +rules have been defined for this application (step 4). Access Control contains a rules engine, allowing each +application’s administrator to define how tokens from various IdPs should be transformed into an Access +Control token. For example, if different IdPs use different formats for representing usernames, Access +Control rules can transform all of these into a common username string. Access Control then sends this +new token back to the browser (step 5), which submits it to the application (step 6). Once it has the +Access Control token, the application verifies that it really was issued by Access Control, then uses the +claims it contains (step 7). + +While this process might seem a little complicated, it actually makes life significantly simpler for the +creator of the application. Rather than handle diverse tokens containing various claims, the application +can accept identities issued by multiple identity providers while still receiving only a single token with +familiar claims. And rather than require each application to be configured to trust various IdPs, these trust +relationships are instead maintained by Access Control—an application need only trust it. + +22 + + As Figure 11 shows, Access Control has built-in support for several identity providers, including AD FS 2.0, +Windows Live ID, Google, Yahoo, and Facebook. It can also work with any IdP that supports OpenID. +Browsers and other clients can request Access Control tokens using either OAuth 2 or WS-Trust, and these +tokens can have various formats, including SAML 1.1, SAML 2.0, and Simple Web Token (SWT). And to +create applications that accept Access Control tokens, Windows developers can use Windows Identity +Foundation (WIF). (It’s worth pointing out, however, that nothing about Access Control is tied to +Windows—it could just as well be used by a Linux application that accepted only Google and Facebook +identities.) + +Working with identity is important in nearly every distributed application. The goal of Access Control is to +make it easier for developers to create secure applications that accept identities from diverse providers. +By putting this service in the cloud, Microsoft has made it available to any application running on any +platform. + +Caching + +For many applications, one of the most effective ways to improve performance is by caching frequently +accessed data. Since applications tend to use the same information over and over, making this +information more readily accessible can make the application faster. Doing this is the purpose of Windows +Azure AppFabric Caching. Figure 12 illustrates the idea. + +Figure 12: Windows Azure AppFabric Caching speeds up access to frequently accessed data for +Windows Azure applications. + +23 + + The Caching service provides a distributed cache for Windows Azure applications, along with a library to +access this cache. As Figure 12 suggests, the service includes a local cache that can keep a copy of recently +accessed data items in each of an application’s role instances. If a data item the application needs isn’t +found in the local cache, the cache library automatically contacts the shared cache provided by the +Caching service. As the figure shows, this cache is spread across a number of Windows Azure instances, +each holding different cached data. This diversity isn’t visible to applications using the cache, however. An +application just requests a data item, then lets the cache find it (if it’s in the cache) and return it from +whatever instance contains it. + +Recently accessed data isn’t automatically cached, however. Instead, the application explicitly inserts data +items in the cache, such as by using the Caching API. It’s also possible to configure an ASP.NET application +running on Windows Azure to store Session object data in the Caching service, speeding it up without +changing any of its code. + +Windows Server AppFabric, the on-premises analog to Windows Azure AppFabric, also provides a Caching +service. In fact, the two are very similar. The biggest different is that unlike its on-premises counterpart, +Windows Azure AppFabric Caching is a service—there’s no need to configure servers and administer the +cache. Instead, all of this is handled automatically by the service itself. And the cloud Caching service is +multi-tenant, so each application using it gets its own instance. Because the application must authenticate +itself to this instance, data held in the Caching service isn’t accessible to other applications. + +Caching can make applications faster and more scalable with little effort from developers, and so using it +makes sense. By providing caching as a service, Windows Azure AppFabric Caching makes this easier to +do. + +WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE + +Cloud platforms are useful, but they’re just a means to an end. The real goal is offering applications and +data that provide value for people. Since the Windows Azure platform provides a foundation for both, +why shouldn’t it also include a way for people to find the applications and data that they need? + +The Windows Azure Marketplace is designed to address this need. Its two components, AppMarket and +DataMarket, let users find, try, and purchase applications and data, respectively. While both are +important, DataMarket will appear first, and so what follows focuses on this aspect of the Marketplace. + +Buying applications is common today—nearly every organization does it. Buying data is less common, but +it’s no less important. Many firms sell many different kinds of data, including demographic information, +financial information, legal information, and much more. Yet using purchased data typically requires +figuring out whether the data you need exists, finding a firm that offers it, then determining whether their +data meets your needs. + +All of this is more difficult than it needs to be. Why not create one place where customers can find all +kinds of data from all kinds of content providers? Why not let them examine the data to make sure it +meets their needs, then purchase what they need right then and there? The DataMarket component of +Windows Azure Marketplace was created to do these things. Figure 13 shows its main components. + +24 + + Figure 13: Built on Windows Azure, the DataMarket allows access to content partner datasets stored in +Windows Azure, SQL Azure, or externally. + +As the figure suggests, both people and applications can access information through DataMarket. Using a +Windows Azure-based application called the Service Explorer, a user can see what datasets are available, +then purchase what she needs. Once this is done, applications can access that data using RESTful or OData +requests. The datasets made available by DataMarket can be stored on the Windows Azure platform itself +using Windows Azure Storage or SQL Azure Database. They can also be stored externally, such as in a data +center owned by the content provider. There’s no requirement to put everything in the cloud. + +For customers, DataMarket provides a single place to find, buy, and access a variety of commercial +datasets. For content providers—the owners of those data sets—DataMarket offers a chance to expose +their offerings to more customers through Microsoft’s cloud platform. While content providers set prices +for their data, DataMarket provides a billing service that frees them from dealing directly with customers. +Microsoft will also vet the quality of the content providers, limiting DataMarket initially to just the top five +providers in a particular industry. + +Applications are free to use purchased data in any way that the content provider’s license allows. Users of +Microsoft Excel 2010, for example, can access DataMarket’s information directly using an Excel add-in or +use the PowerPivot for Excel support for OData to access information from DataMarket for data analysis. +It’s also possible to combine data purchased from DataMarket with your own data, such as for reports +created using SQL Server Reporting Services. + +25 + + Getting business value from information technology requires the right applications, but it also requires +the right data. By making it easier to discover, evaluate, and buy commercially available datasets, +DataMarket intends to make it simpler for organizations to find and use the information they need. + +LOOKING AHEAD + +Microsoft has announced a number of updates that it plans to add to the Windows Azure platform in the +near future. They include the following: + + The Windows Azure Platform Appliance: Microsoft has announced plans to offer a Windows Azure +Platform Appliance, allowing hosters and enterprises to run Windows Azure in their own data +centers. Because Windows Azure requires a specific hardware configuration—it’s not just software— +this appliance will include servers, networking, and storage, all running Windows Azure. And while it +will initially be targeted only at large organizations, Microsoft’s goal is eventually to make the +Windows Azure Platform Appliance useful for smaller organizations as well. + + CDN dynamic content caching: Today, the Windows Azure CDN works only with blob data. This +forthcoming functionality will let the CDN also cache content created dynamically by a Windows +Azure application. + + VM role snapshotting: In its first release, the Windows Azure VM role doesn’t save any changes made +to the OS volume while it’s running. Snapshotting will change this, providing a way to periodically +save the state of this volume to persistent storage. + + Better Java support: While Windows Azure can run Java applications today, Microsoft plans to make +this better. The coming improvements include better Java performance, stronger support for Eclipse- +based tools, and a more complete set of Java libraries for Windows Azure. + +Support for composite applications: To make it easier to build Windows Azure applications by +combining existing components and services, Windows Azure AppFabric will add a composition +model. Accompanied by runtime services and a Visual Studio-based designer, this model will let +developers work with the various parts of an application as a single logical entity throughout its +lifecycle. + + All of these changes target the same goal: making the Windows Azure platform useful in a broader range +of scenarios. + +CONCLUSIONS + +The truth is evident: Cloud computing is here. For developers, taking advantage of the cloud means using +cloud platforms. With the Windows Azure platform, Microsoft presents a range of options addressing a +variety of needs: + + Windows Azure provides a computing and storage environment in the cloud. + +SQL Azure provides a relational DBMS in the cloud, together with reporting and data synchronization. + +26 + + Windows Azure AppFabric offers cloud-based infrastructure supporting both cloud and on-premises + +applications. + + Windows Azure Marketplace is an online store for finding and purchasing datasets from content + +providers, together with a forthcoming store for cloud applications. + +These approaches address a variety of requirements, and not every developer will use all of them. Yet +whether you work for an ISV, a systems integrator, or an enterprise, some cloud platform services are +likely to be useful for applications your organization creates. A new world is unfolding; prepare to be part +of it. + +ABOUT THE AUTHOR + +David Chappell is Principal of Chappell & Associates (www.davidchappell.com) in San Francisco, California. +Through his speaking, writing, and consulting, he helps people around the world understand, use, and +make better decisions about new technologies. + +27 + diff --git a/q12/random_k2/random_2.md b/q12/random_k2/random_2.md index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..41b128d8d6a3808185f462ec8b46e331c45f6af0 100644 --- a/q12/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q12/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,5479 +1,448 @@ -Owner’s Manual +Amazfit GTR User Manual + +Content + +Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation ............................................................................. 2 +Basic Operations ....................................................................................................................... 2 +Functions Navigation ................................................................................................................ 2 +Watch Wearing and Charging ............................................................................................................ 4 +Use of Functions ............................................................................................................................... 5 +Device Pairing and Unpairing ................................................................................................... 5 +Control Shortcut Menu .............................................................................................................. 7 +Flashlight ........................................................................................................................... 7 +Brightness adjustment ....................................................................................................... 8 +DND mode ........................................................................................................................ 8 +Battery saver mode ............................................................................................................ 9 +Lock screen ..................................................................................................................... 10 +Replace the Watch Face .......................................................................................................... 11 +Status ....................................................................................................................................... 11 +Heart Rate ............................................................................................................................... 12 +Workout ................................................................................................................................... 13 +Workout Record ...................................................................................................................... 14 +Weather ................................................................................................................................... 15 +Music....................................................................................................................................... 16 +Notifications ............................................................................................................................ 17 +Alarm ...................................................................................................................................... 18 +Event Reminder....................................................................................................................... 20 +Timer ....................................................................................................................................... 22 +Count Down ............................................................................................................................ 23 +Find Device ............................................................................................................................. 24 +Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude ............................................................................................... 25 +Settings .................................................................................................................................... 27 +Workout Function ........................................................................................................................... 29 +Workout Positioning................................................................................................................ 30 +During Workouts ..................................................................................................................... 31 +Swimming ............................................................................................................................... 32 +Workout Reminder .................................................................................................................. 33 +Workout Pause and End .......................................................................................................... 33 +Workout Settings ..................................................................................................................... 34 + + Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation + +Amazfit GTR features one AMOLED touch screen and two physical buttons. + +Basic Operations + +Slide left and right or up and down: You can switch between different function pages. +Tap and exit: You can tap to enter a specific function page and also operate the tap tips on that page. +You can slide right to quickly return to the upper-level menu after tapping to enter a certain function +page. +Button on the upper right: +① Short press to light up the screen. +② Short press the watch face page to close the screen. +③ Short press other pages to quickly return to the watch face. +④ Long press for 10s to shut down. +Button on the bottom right: +① Short press to light up the screen. +② Short press the watch face page to quickly enter the workout list. (This function can be +customized and used to short press to quickly start other functions) +You can long press either of the two buttons above to exit the battery saver mode, suspend the +workout, and close the alarm alert. + +Functions Navigation + +Pull the watch face down: You can then enter the shortcut control menu, which allows you to quickly +open the flashlight, set brightness, control the DND mode, enter the battery saver mode, and lock +the screen. + +Slide the watch face left and right: You can then quickly enter Status, Heart rate, + + Slide the watch face up: You can then enter the function list. + + Watch Wearing and Charging + +Daily wearing: During daily use, it is recommended to wear the watch with a moderate tightness at +a distance two fingers far from your wrist to ensure that the optical heart rate monitor works properly. +Wearing during workouts: During workouts, it is recommended to wear the watch comfortably and +ensure a tight fit without slipping. Being too tight or too loose may cause the inaccuracy of detected +workout data, so avoid doing this. +Charging + + +The watch charger's USB port needs to be plugged into the USB-supported device, such as +socket, PC, power bank. + + When placing the watch into the power socket, it's required to keep the watch in a proper +direction and position. Be sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch are closely +connected to the charging base. +The screen will display the charging reminder when the watch is placed properly. + + + + Use of Functions + +Download the Amazfit App via the mobile phone before using Amazfit GTR. You cannot use the +entire watch functions nor save and upload watch data to your personal cloud account until the +watch is paired by using the Amazfit App. + +Device Pairing and Unpairing + +Download the Amazfit App from Google Play Store or App Store and register an account or log in. + + Open the Amazfit App and choose "Profile – My devices – Watch – Amazfit GTR" to search the +device nearby. +Please tap the check-mark when it shows a pairing request on the watch. + +If a device can be paired by scanning a QR code, with the Amazfit App on, you can directly pair the +device by scanning the QR code on your watch. +After paired, the watch usually needs to be upgraded. Wait for upgrading with patience. With the +mobile network and Bluetooth on, you also need to keep the watch close to the mobile phone, so as +to ensure a successful upgrade. + + After the watch is paired and upgraded, its functions are available. Meanwhile, the Amazfit App +allows for the watch function-specific operations and settings. +To unpair the watch, open the Amazfit App, tap "Profile – My devices – Amazfit GTR" and then +swipe up and tap the "Unpair" button. -Models -14, 16, 17, 18 +Control Shortcut Menu -Refrigerators +Pulling down on the watch face page can quickly open the control shortcut menu page. -TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST +Flashlight +Tapping the flashlight icon can open the flashlight function. The white background on the watch +screen helps light up a small area at night. You can close the enabled flashlight function by sliding -Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR + right or pressing the button on the upper right. - Congratulations! +Brightness adjustment +Tapping on the brightness adjustment button can go to the brightness adjustment settings. +Auto brightness: The watch will automatically adjust the screen brightness upon ambient light. +Manual brightness: You can tailor the screen brightness as you wish. -Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our -quality products and we are committed to -providing dependable service. You’ll see it in -this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll -hear it in the friendly voices of our customer -service department. +DND mode +Enable DND: With the DND mode enabled, the watch will not vibrate when receiving any message +pushed by the mobile phone. +Time DND: You can tailor the time period during which the DND mode changes from automatically +enabled to disabled. -Best of all, you’ll experience these values -each time you use your refrigerator. That’s -important, because your new refrigerator will -be part of your family for many years. And we -hope you will be part of ours for a long time -to come. + Smart DND: After you fall asleep with the watch, the watch will automatically enable the DND +mode. +Disable DND: The DND mode is disabled, so the watch will vibrate when receiving notifications. -We appreciate your purchase, and hope you -will continue to rely on us whenever you -need quality appliances for your home. +Battery saver mode +The battery saver mode can minimize the power consumption of the watch and improve its +endurance. With the battery saver mode on, the watch can only record steps and sleep time, with +other functions disabled. -Important! + To exit the battery saver mode, long press any button on the watch. -Fill out and return the Consumer Product -Registration Card that is packed with this -product. If you cannot find it, please send -in the duplicate card printed in the back of -this manual. +Lock screen +With the lock screen function on, you can unlock the watch to enter the watch face page only by +using the watch button. This can prevent any error caused by mistouch. To close the lock screen +function, tap the lock screen button again to close this function. -Write the model and serial -numbers here. + Replace the Watch Face -# +To replace the watch face on the watch: Long press the watch face page for 2s, or go to "Settings – +Watch face settings", slide left and right to scan the watch face, and tap one to complete replacement. +To replace the watch face on the App: Tap "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch face settings" to +download more watch faces on the Watch Face Store. -# +Status -You can find them on a label on the -upper left side of the fresh food -compartment. +Sliding left on the watch face page can enable you to enter the status page which displays the current +steps and goal completed. Tapping the status entry can enable you to enter the details page which -Staple sales slip or cancelled -check here. + shows you the steps, distance, calories and idle data. -Proof of the original purchase date -is needed to obtain service under -the warranty. +You can also enter the details page by sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Status". -2 +Heart Rate - AService Partnership. +Sliding left on the watch face can enable you to enter the heart rate page, and then the watch +automatically starts to measure the heart rate. During measurement, it is required to properly wear +the watch and keep the back of the watch fairly close to your skin until the watch can measure a +stable heart rate. +To enable the all-day measure function, open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – +Heart rate detection", and choose to enable automatic heart rate detection. -We stand behind our products with -unmatched quality service. However, did -you know that most questions result from -simple problems that you can easily -fix yourself in just a few minutes? This -Owner’s Manual can tell you how. + Notes: With the all-day measure function on, the watch will measure the heart rate at regular time. +Sliding right on the watch face can make the last heart rate value visible. You can enter the all-day +heart rate details page by tapping it. -Read this Manual -Inside you will find many -helpful hints on how to use and -maintain your refrigerator -properly. Just a little preventive -care on your part can save you a -great deal of time and money -over the life of your refrigerator. +Workout -Review the Section on -Troubleshooting Tips +Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, +Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing, +and Exercise. See the "Workout" section for more details about the functions of different workout +types. -You’ll find many answers to -common problems here. -If you review our chart of -Troubleshooting Tips first, -you may not need to call for -service at all. + Workout Record -If You Need Service +The workout data on the watch will be stored in workout records, which are shown from the latest +to the earliest. Tapping a specific workout record will make the workout details visible. The visible +details vary in workout type. -If you do need service, you can -relax knowing help is only a -phone call away. A list of toll-free -customer service numbers is -included in the back section. -Or you can always call the -GE Answer Center® at -800.626.2000, 24 hours a day, -7 days a week. +The workout record not uploaded to the App will be marked with a little red dot before it. Open the +App to synchronize data timely to avoid the loss of workout records. -Safety Information -Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4 -Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 -How to Connect Electricity . . . .6 -Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7 -Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7 + To delete a workout record on the watch, tap to enter the workout record details page, slide up to +the bottom of the page, and then tap the delete button. -Operating Instructions +Weather -Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8 -Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10 -Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12 -Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13 -Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16 +Tapping the weather function can give you access to the current weather conditions and the weather +forecast. If weather data are invisible, you should open the App and connect the device to update +the data. -Installation Instructions + Music -Preparing to -Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18 -Water Line Installation . . .19–23 -Reversing the -Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29 +With the Bluetooth, the watch can suspend or play the music on the mobile music player, switch +between songs, and adjust the volume. + Open the mobile music player first, and then enable the music function on the watch. + + -Troubleshooting Tips +If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App. +If you are using an Android device, you need to connect the watch with the Amazfit App and +also enable the notification reading permission on the App. -Normal Operating Sounds . . .30 -Before You -Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33 +Notes: The compatibility of the Android mobile phone system and the openness of different music +players may to a certain extent affect the music control function of the watch. -Customer Service -Product Registration . . . . . . . .37 -Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39 -Service Telephone -Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover + Notifications -3 +Enable notifications +During use, you need to enable the corresponding "App alerts" on the App, and keep the watch and +the mobile phone connected. You can also enable the incoming SMS and incoming call alerts as you +wish. + + -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n +If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App. +If you are using an Android device, you need to keep the App running in the background or +include the App into the self-starting whitelist, so as to ensure the mobile phone can send the +alert to the watch. -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +View notifications +1. -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +In the case of an incoming notification, the watch will automatically light up the screen and +display the content. -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s +2. You can view the unread notification in the notification list and tap any notification to enter the -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e +notification details page. - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S + Delete notifications + -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O +The read notification on the watch or the mobile phone will be automatically deleted from the +notification list on the watch. +To manually delete the notification on the watch, slide left on the notification to be deleted and +tap the delete button. -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I + -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr +Alarm -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C +Amazfit GTR supports creating and managing the alarm on the watch. You can also create a watch +alarm on the Amazfit App. +Tapping the create button on the watch alarm function page can enable you to set the alarm time and -4 + cycle. After saved, the alarm can be opened and closed in the alarm list. +To create an alarm via the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch alarm" and add an +alarm upon the tips on the page. -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! +Alarm alert +In the case of a watch alarm alert, you can choose to close it or remind you later. -Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as -described in this Owner’s Manual. +To close the alarm, long press any button for 2s within the duration of the alarm alert. -SAFETY PRECAUTIONS -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions -should be followed, including the following: + To make a delayed alert, you can, within the duration of the alarm alert, tap the "Z" button at the +bottom. Then, the alarm will remind you 10min later. -n Keep fingers out of the -“pinch point” areas; -clearances between the -doors and between the doors -and cabinet are necessarily -small. Be careful closing -doors when children are in -the area. +Event Reminder -n Unplug the refrigerator +You need to create and manage the event reminder via the Amazfit App. The watch will display +your to-do list and vibrate to remind you in the set time. +Open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Event reminder", and create the event +reminder upon the tips on the page. +An alert will pop up on the watch when the time set for the event arrives. Tap the "×" button at the +bottom to close the alert. -before cleaning and making -repairs. + The watch supports modifying and deleting the event reminder. +To modify the event reminder, tap the right arrow on the event reminder list page to modify the +event reminder date and time. -NOTE: We strongly recommend -that any servicing be performed -by a qualified individual. +To delete the event reminder, slide right on the event to be deleted and tap the trash icon to delete it. -n Turning the control to the + Timer -OFF position does not remove -power to the light circuit. -n Do not refreeze frozen foods +The timer on the watch supports one hundredth of a second. To enable the timer, pull up the app list +on the watch face and choose the timer app. + + During timing, you can also count the number of times by tapping the button on the bottom -which have thawed -completely. +Tapping the start button can activate the timer to time it right away. -n This refrigerator must be -properly installed and -located in accordance with -the Installation Instructions -before it is used. +left on the watch screen (up to 99 times of such operation), +and suspend the current timer by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen. -n Do not allow children to + + When the timer pauses, you can reset it by tapping the button on the bottom left on the watch +screen, and resume timing by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen. -climb, stand or hang on the -shelves in the refrigerator. -They could damage the -refrigerator and seriously -injure themselves. -n Do not touch the cold -surfaces in the freezer -compartment, particularly -when hands are damp or wet. -Skin may stick to these -extremely cold surfaces. -n Do not store or use gasoline -or other flammable vapors -and liquids in the vicinity of -this or any other appliance. + Count Down -n In refrigerators with +To enable the count down, pull up the app list on the watch face and choose the count down app. +By default, the watch supports the shortcut count down of 1min, 3min, 5min, 10min, 15min, 20min, +30min, and 60min. You can enable the count down function right away by tapping it. +A custom count down function is available, which ranges from 1min to 23h and 59min. -automatic icemakers, avoid -contact with the moving parts -of the ejector mechanism, or -with the heating element that -releases the cubes. Do not -place fingers or hands on the -automatic icemaking -mechanism while the -refrigerator is plugged in. + You can suspend, resume or stop the count down function anytime when it operates. When time's +up, the watch will vibrate to remind you. You can close the count down function by tapping the "×" +button at the bottom. - DANGER! RISK OF CHILD +Find Device -ENTRAPMENT -PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR +Amazfit GTR supports finding the device via the Bluetooth. To enable this function, slide up the +app list on the watch face page and tap the find device function. + -Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of -the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still -dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.” -If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please -follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents. +To activate the find device function, you need to keep the Amazfit App running and ensure the +watch is connected to the mobile phone. Otherwise the function is not available. -Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator -or Freezer: + On the find page, the watch will automatically find the device. If no device is found after 60s, -n Take off the doors. -n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not + a failure prompt will display and then you can try again. -easily climb inside. + When found, the mobile phone will beep. You can close the ring on the mobile phone by +tapping the tip button on the watch. Meanwhile, the mobile phone will produce a message on +the notification bar. Tapping the message can draw back the Amazfit App and close the ring on +the mobile phone. -CFC Disposal +Notes: If you wish to use the find device function anytime, you can include the Amazfit App into +the built-in self-starting whitelist and keep it running in the background. In addition, the watch is +required to be connected to the mobile phone, otherwise it is unable to find the mobile phone. -Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used -CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm -stratospheric ozone. +Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude -If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make -sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal -by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this -CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and -imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean -Air Act. +Amazfit GTR supports the compass function. When the compass page opens, the watch +automatically detects the current orientation and degree. If needed, you can wear the watch and +calibrate the compass by filling out that circle with figure 8 movements in the air, until the watch +vibrates. Then the compass function can be reused. -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n + Sliding up on the compass page can enable you to enter the atmospheric pressure page. The +barometer on the watch displays the current air pressure in real time. -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s + Sliding up on the air pressure page can enable you to enter the altitude page. The altitude requires +double calibration of watch barometer and GPS. If you want more accurate altitude data, try to get +the satellite positioning in an open area as soon as possible. -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +Settings -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s +The watch settings page includes some watch settings and built-in control functions. +Watch face settings: You can quickly switch between watch faces. -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e + Screen-on duration: You can control the screen-on duration of the watch for 8s (by default) to 15s +(max). -5 +Quick start: You can short press the button on the bottom right to quickly start one watch function +(by default, workout list). - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S +System: It supports viewing the firmware version and regulatory information, and controlling the +actions of closing and rebooting the watch and performing the factory reset. -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O + Workout Function -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I +Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, +Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing, +and Exercise. And the workout types like Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, Open water +swim, Climb, Trail run, and Skiing support recording GPS-enabled workout tracks. -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr + There are two approaches to enabling the workout function on the watch: + -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C +If the workout list is set for quick start, then you can quickly enter the workout list by short +pressing the button on the bottom right on the watch face page. By default, the last workout +type displays. +Sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Workout" can enable you to enter the workout +list page and choose the workout you want to start. -6 + -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! +Workout Positioning -HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY -Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third -(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety, -this appliance must be properly grounded. +If you choose to start Outdoor running, you'd better go to the open area before workouts, which is +conducive to rapid GPS positioning. -The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong -(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong -(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric -shock hazard from this appliance. + If it takes a long time to process positioning, it may be because the buildings nearby block satellite +signals, or because the watch is disconnected to the App for a long time, causing the AGPS to be +not upgraded. You can open the Amazfit App, connect it to the watch, and try again after the AGPS +is updated. +It is recommended to ensure GPS positioning is processed successfully before the outdoor workout. +If you start the workout during positioning, the workout track cannot be recorded and the recorded +workout data will not be accurate. +After GPS positioning is processed successfully, the "GO" icon will be lit up and you can tap it to +start the workout. -Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician -to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. +During Workouts -Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your -personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a -properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet. +During workouts, the watch will display the current workout data in real time, such as time, distance, +pace/speed, and heart rate. After the watch screen goes off, the screen can be lit up again by lifting +the wrist or touching the screen. +Sliding right during workouts can enable you to view the time, date, and watch power. -The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual -electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating -plate. + Swimming -This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading -house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from -overheated wires. +With the swimming workout enabled, the watch will automatically lock the screen to avoid water +drops interfering with the screen display during the workout. To unlock the screen, you can short +press any button on the watch, and the screen will be locked again after the watch screen goes off. -Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord. -Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet. + Workout Reminder -Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become -frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or -abrasion damage along its length or at either end. +The workout reminder on the watch varies in workout type. For the workout types Running, Cycling, +and Walking, the alert will be vibrated once per kilometer by default. You can also set the alerts for +other workout types before workouts. See the "Workout Settings" section for more details. -When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to -roll over or damage the power cord. +Workout Pause and End -USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -adapter plug. +With the auto pause function on, the watch will automatically pause when the workout end is +detected. When the workout resumes, the watch will automatically end the pause status and resume +recording the workout performance. -However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a -temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong -wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local -hardware stores. + Tapping any button during a workout can suspend the workout. - The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in -the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the -power cord. +Tapping the right button can cancel the pause and resume the workout. +Tapping the left button can end the current workout and save the workout performance. -When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold -the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord -plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground -terminal is very likely to break with repeated use. +Workout Settings -If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator -until a proper ground has been established. +Before workouts, you can set some relevant functions. +The workout goal supports three types: mileage, duration, and calories. When the set goal is +achieved, the watch will vibrate to remind you. -Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not -ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the -wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit -checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. + The workout reminder supports five types: distance, pace, safe heart rate, heart rate zone, and pace +With a reminder set, the watch will vibrate to remind you as long as the set value is reached during +workouts. -USE OF EXTENSION CORDS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -extension cord. + With the auto pause on, the watch will automatically detect the workout status. When the workout +is stopped, the watch will automatically suspend the current exercise. And the watch will re-record +the data when the workout is resumed. +The real-time diagram supports demonstrating the real-time heart rate and pace. With the real-time +diagram on, a curve is drawn for the fluctuations of the heart rate or pace during workouts. -However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely -necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance -extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that -the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and -120 volts. - -REMEMBER… -Your continued health and safety are important to us. - -Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully. - -We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our -family. -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -7 - - About the temperature control dial. - -Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments— -fresh food and freezer. - -9 - -OFF - -7 - -5 - -3 - -1 - -Control Settings -Temperature Control Dial - -The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF. -1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5. - -After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary. - -Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn -the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs. - -Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -8 - - About the fresh food compartment shelves. - -Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves. -Not all features are on all models. - -2 Lift up and out - -1 Tilt up - -Half-Width Shelves - -One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall -support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track -on the rear cabinet wall. - -To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support -and out of the track. - -To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front -raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track, -then lower the shelf onto the support. - -NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to -hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is -designed to hook into the left-hand slot. - -Full-Width Shelves - -Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary -tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves. -These shelves can be moved to another place in the -fresh food compartment. - -The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed -correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before -coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not -tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it. - -To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf -and pull forward. - -To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food -compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of -the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it -out. - -9 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - About the freezer compartment shelves. - -Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf. - -Plug Supports - -Ice-Tray Shelf - -To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf -off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of -the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the -pins from the holes in the cabinet wall. - -(cid:49) - -(cid:50) - -Step Shelf - -To remove the step shelf: - -1 -2 - -3 - -Lift left side of shelf slightly. - -Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes -in the cabinet wall. - -Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and -take it out. - -To replace the step shelf: - -1 - -2 - -With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into -holes in cabinet wall. - -Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right -ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower -shelf into place. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -10 - - About the storage drawers. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Fruit and Vegetable Drawers - -Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the -drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry. - -Utility Drawer - -The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful -location for your family’s needs. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -11 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -12 - -About storage drawer and cover removal. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Drawer and Cover Removal - -Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to -help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers -can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly -while pulling drawers past the stoplocation. - -Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover - -To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it -forward, tilt it and take it out. - -Twin Drawer With Glass Cover - -To remove: - -1 -2 - -Remove the drawers. - -Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the -same time, pull it forward as far as it will come. - -Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover -with hot water because the extreme temperature -difference may cause it to break. - -3 - -Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass -cover before you take out the drawer frame.) - -Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back, -pull it forward, tilt it and take it out. - -To replace: - -Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each -side and back. - -Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly -into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the -front into place. - -Replace the drawers. - -1 - -2 - -3 - - About the automatic icemaker. - -A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice. - -Icemaker - -Feeler arm -in the STOP -(up) position - -Ice Storage Bin - -Automatic Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle— -approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period, -depending on freezer compartment temperature, room -temperature, number of door openings and other use -conditions. - -If the refrigerator is operated before the water -connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm -in the STOP (up) position. - -Feeler arm in the -ON (down) position - -When the refrigerator has been connected to the water -supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position. - -The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to -freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 -hours to begin making ice cubes. - -Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water -line to clear. - -Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler -arm. - -It is normal for several cubes to be joined together. - -If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become -cloudy and taste stale. - -Icemaker Accessory Kit - -If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an -automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra -cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit -needed for your model. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -13 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Cleaning the Outside - -The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth -dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth. - -Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened -with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and -polish with a clean, soft cloth. - -Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may -leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered -cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can -scratch and weaken the paint finish. - -Cleaning the Inside - -To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh -food and freezer compartments. - -Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring -excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around -switches, lights or controls. - -Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans -and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry. - -Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the -doors. - -After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly -to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets -from sticking and bending out of shape. - -Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the -extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves -carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter. - -Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -14 - - Under the Refrigerator - -For most efficient operation, keep the area under the -refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to -OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust. - -Clean the condenser coils at least -once a year. - -For best results, use a brush specially designed for this -purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores. - -Behind the Refrigerator - -Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All -types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned -coverings and those with embossed surfaces. - -Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator -counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull -the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it -straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in -damage to the floor covering or refrigerator. - -When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power -cord or icemaker supply line (on some models). - -After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise -until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -15 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Light Bulb Replacement - -To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its -electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an -appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage. - -Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit. - -Preparing for Vacation - -For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the -refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position, -and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the -doors open. - -Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut -off the water supply to the refrigerator. - -If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified -servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent -serious property damage due to flooding. - -Preparing to Move - -Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping -them securely in place to prevent damage. - -Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -16 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models) - -If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an -icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line. - -A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings -and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from -Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -Refrigerator Location - -Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below -60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain -proper temperatures. - -Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded. - -Clearances - -Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air -circulation and plumbing and electrical connections: -3/4† (19 mm) -1† (25 mm) -1† (25 mm) - -Sides - -Back - -Top - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -17 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Rollers and Leveling Legs - -Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They -firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are -opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just -enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway. - -Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to -lower it. - -Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the -wall for cleaning. - -Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred -from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the -legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -18 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Before You Begin -This water line installation is not warranted by the -refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these -instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive -water damage. - -Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house -plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead -to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to -correct water hammer before installing the water supply -line to the refrigerator. - -To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the -water line to the hot water line. - -If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water -line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP -(up) position. - -Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where -temperatures fall below freezing. - -When using any electrical device (such as a power drill) -during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired -in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock. - -All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing -code requirements. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -19 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -What You Will Need -To determine how much copper tubing you need: - -Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the -refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm). -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) -coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow -the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. -n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and -fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer -or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between - -20 and 120 p.s.i. - -n Power drill. - -n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to -the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square. - -Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is -under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle -with age and crack, resulting in water leakage. - -n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)— - -to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the -refrigerator water valve. - -n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will - -need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect -the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared -fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting. -n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve -should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of -5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle- -type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before -purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your -local plumbing codes. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -20 - - Shut Off the Main Water Supply - -Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water. - -Install the Shutoff Valve -1 -2 - -Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line. - -Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect -into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a -horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at -the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe. -Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs -resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe. - -3 - -4 -5 - -Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp. - -Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell. - -Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing. - -Pipe Clamp - -Washer - -Inlet End - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Vertical Cold Water Pipe - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -21 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve - -Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator. - -Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the -refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible. - -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about -10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and -connect it to the shutoff valve. - -Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut -securely. - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Compression Nut - -Packing -Nut - -Outlet Valve - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing -1 - -Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water -is clear. - -2 - -Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has -been flushed through the tubing. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -22 - - Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator - -Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the -refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet. - -We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles -that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water -line near the refrigerator. - -1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as -shown. - -Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as -possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting. - -Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical -position. You may need to pry open the clamp. - -1/4† Copper Tubing - -Tubing Clamp - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -1/4† Compression Nut - -Refrigerator Connection - -Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve - -Tighten any connections that leak. - -Plug In the Refrigerator - -Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of -the refrigerator or against the wall. - -Push the refrigerator back to the wall. - -Start the Icemaker - -Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will -not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.) -or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm -is in the ON(down) position. - -NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from -the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again. - -23 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - Reversing the door swing. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Important Notes -When reversing the door swing : - -n Read the instructions all the way through before starting. -n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint. -n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the - -wrong places. - -n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors. -IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until -door-swing reversal is completed. - -These instructions are for changing the hinges from the -right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the -hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions -and reverse all references to left and right. - -Tools Required -n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver -n Masking tape -n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires -n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver -n 5/16† open-end wrench -n Phillips screwdriver - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -24 - - Removing the doors. - -Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet. - -Before Removing the Doors -1 -2 -CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could -damage the door stop. - -Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment. - -Remove the Freezer Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the -top hinge to the cabinet. - -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin -from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws. - -Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the -door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge -bracket. - -Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal. - -Top Hinge - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -25 - - Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Remove the Fresh Food Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench, -remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to -the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of -the door, and set hinge and screws aside. - -3 - -4 -5 - -6 - -Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from -the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door -bottom, put it back on the hinge.) - -Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal. - -Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw -hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough -space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket. - -Center Hinge Bracket - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left -1 - -Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight -out. - -2 - -Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to -it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side. - -Plastic Washer - -Hinge Bracket - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -26 - - Reversing the door handles. - -Transfer Top Hinge to the Left - -Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws -at top left of cabinet. - -Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time. - -Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge -depends on which side you install the hinge. - -Installing the hinge on the left. - -Installing the hinge on the right. - -Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle - -Top View - -Bottom View - -1 - -2 - -3 -4 - -Remove the bottom cap by -pushing it toward the bottom of -the door and remove the screw -underneath. - -Remove the two screws holding -the handle to the top of the door. - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screws from the right -edge of the door top and insert -them into the handle screw holes -on the opposite side. - -5 - -6 - -With tape-tipped putty knife or -thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the -plug button from the hinge hole -on the left side of the door and -insert it into the hole on the -opposite side that was vacated by -removal of the top hinge. - -Pull the plug button from the -front of the door and transfer it to -the opposite side. - -Plug Button - -Screws for -Handle Holes - -Plug Button - -To reattach the handle on the -opposite side. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -27 - - Rehanging the doors. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Transfer Door Stop -1 - -Move the metal door stop from -the right end to the left end. Use a -Torxdriver. - -Door Stop - -2 - -Move any screws from the left end -to the right end. - -Right Side - -Left Side - -Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle -1 - -Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and -under the handle plug. - -Reinstall the handle plug. - -2 -Transfer Freezer Door Handle -1 - -Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two -screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door. - -2 -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the -handle screw hole on the left side. - -Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the -opposite side. - -Transfer the door stop as shown above. - -Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and -bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws. - -Left Side - -Right Side - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -28 - - Rehang the Fresh Food Door -1 - -Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom -hinge. - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -2 - -3 - -Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door. -NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the -left side. - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide -the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven -into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both -screws securely. - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic -Washer - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Rehang the Freezer Door -1 - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin. - -2 - -3 - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the -socket on the top of the door. - -Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even -across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these -screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one- -half turn. - -Center Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -29 - - Normal operating sounds. - -Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen, -you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under -the refrigerator to reduce noise. - -The fan circulating air inside the freezer which -keeps the temperatures even. - -Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of -refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils. - -Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water -dropping on the defrost heater during the -defrost cycle. - -Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils -expanding and contracting during the -defrosting cycle. - -Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator -and flows to the drain pan during the defrost -cycle. - -Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker water valve will buzz when the -icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in -the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has -not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the -feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is -hooked up to water can damage the icemaker. -To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP -(up) position. This will stop the buzzing. - -The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and -water running in pipes as icemaker refills. - -These sounds are normal -and are due mostly to highly -efficient operation. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -30 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips -Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and -you may not need to call for service. - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Refrigerator does not -operate - -Refrigerator in -defrost cycle. - -Temperature control -dial in OFFposition. - -Refrigerator is -unplugged. - -The fuse is blown/ -circuit breaker is -tripped. - -Normal when -refrigerator is first -plugged in. - -Often occurs when large -amounts of food are -placed in refrigerator. - -Door left open. - -• Wait about 30 minutes for - -defrost cycle to end. - -• Move the temperature - -control dial to a -temperature setting. - -• Push the plug completely - -into the outlet. - -• Replace fuse or reset the - -breaker. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• This is normal. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Hot weather or frequent -door openings. - -• This is normal. - -Temperature control dial -set at the coldest setting. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Grille and condenser -need cleaning. - -Front roller screws or -front leveling legs need -adjusting. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -• See Rollers and leveling legs. - -Motor operates for long -periods or cycles on and -off frequently. (Modern -refrigerators with more -storage space and a larger -freezer require more -operating time. They start -and stop often to maintain -even temperatures.) - -Vibration or rattling -(slight vibration is normal) - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -31 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Fresh food or freezer -compartment too warm - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Warm weather or -frequent door openings. - -Door left open. - -Package blocking air -duct in freezer -compartment. - -Door left open. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -• Set the temperature -control dial one step -colder. See About the -temperature control dial. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -• Check to see if package is - -blocking air duct in freezer -compartment. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Icemaker feeler arm in -STOP (up) position. - -• Move the feeler arm to the - -ON (down) position. - -Water supply turned -off or not connected. - -Freezer compartment -too warm. - -Water shutoff valve -connecting refrigerator -to water line may be -clogged. - -• See Installing thewater line. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• Call a plumber to clear - -the valve. - -Frost or ice crystals on -frozen food (frost within -package is normal) - -Automatic icemaker -does not work -(on some models) - -Cubes too small - -Slow ice cube freezing - -Door left open. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -32 - - Problem - -Ice cubes have -odor/taste - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Ice storage bin needs -cleaning. - -• Empty and wash bin. -Discard old cubes. - -Food transmitting odor/ -taste to ice cubes. - -Interior of refrigerator -needs cleaning. - -• Wrap foods well. - -• See Care andcleaning. - -Moisture forms on -cabinet surface -between the doors - -Moisture collects inside -(in humid weather, air -carries moisture into -refrigerator when doors -are opened) - -Refrigerator has odor - -Not unusual during -periods of high -humidity. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -Foods transmitting -odor to refrigerator. - -• Wipe surface dry and - -reset temperature control -dial one setting colder. - -• Foods with strong odors - -should be tightly wrapped. -• Keep an open box of baking -soda in the refrigerator; -replace every three months. - -Interior needs cleaning. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -33 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -34 - - S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -35 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -36 - - GE Service Protection Plus™ - -GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability, -offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on -all your appliances—No Matter What Brand! - -Benefits Include: -• Backed by GE -• All brands covered -• Unlimited service calls -• All parts and labor costs included -• No out-of-pocket expenses -• No hidden deductibles -• One 800 number to call - -We’ll Cover Any Appliance. -Anywhere. Anytime.* - -You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your -money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple. - -Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much -more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly -financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered. -You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected -against expensive repairs. - -Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224 -for more information. - -*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S. - -" - -Cut here - -Please place in envelope and mail to: - -General Electric Company -Warranty Registration Department -P.O. Box 34070 -Louisville, KY 40232-4070 - -37 - - Consumer Product Ownership Registration -Dear Customer: -Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us. -We are proud to have you as a customer! - -Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment: - -1 - -Complete and mail -your Consumer -Product Ownership -Registration today. -Have the peace of -mind of knowing -we can contact you -in the unlikely event of a safety -modification. - -2 - -After mailing -the registration -below, store this -document in a safe -place. It contains -information you -will need should - -you require service. Our -service number is 800 GE -CARES (800-432-2737). - -3 - -Read your -Owner’s Manual -carefully. -It will help you -operate your -new appliance -properly. - -If you have questions, or need -more information, call the GE -Answer Center® 800.626.2000. - -Model Number - -Serial Number - -Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product, - -detach and return the form below to ensure that your -product is registered. - -" -Consumer Product Ownership Registration - -Cut here - -Important -Mail -Today! - -First -Name - -Street -Address - -Apt. # - -City - -Model Number - -Serial Number - -Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108) - -Last -Name - -E-mail Address - -State - -Zip -Code - -Date Placed In Use - -Month - -Day - -Year - -Phone -Number - -Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information. -(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information. - -GE Appliances -General Electric Company -Louisville, Kentucky 40225 -www.ge.com/appliances - -38 - - Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States) - -All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers, -or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service, -call 800-GE-CARES. - -For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You: - -One Year -From the date of the -original purchase - -Five Years -From the date of the -original purchase - -Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect -in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year -warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor -and in-home service to replace the defective part. - -Any part of the sealed refrigerating system -(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all -connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in -materials or workmanship. During this additional -four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, -all labor and in-home service to replace the -defective part. - -What Is Not Covered: - -n Service trips to your home to teach you - -how to use the product. - -n Improper installation. - -n Failure of the product if it is - -abused, misused, or used for other -than the intended purpose or used -commercially. - -n Loss of food due to spoilage. - -n Replacement of house fuses or -resetting of circuit breakers. - -n Damage to the product caused by - -accident, fire, floods or acts of God. - -n Incidental or consequential damage to -personal property caused by possible -defects with this appliance. - -This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased -for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to -your home. - -Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This -warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to -state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your -state’s Attorney General. - -Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225 - -39 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -Service Telephone Numbers. - -GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000 - -The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. - -In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737) - -Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away. - -Special Needs Service800.626.2000 -TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322) - -GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier- -free kitchen for persons with limited mobility. - -Service Contracts800-626-2224 - -Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect -and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will -still be there after your warranty expires. - -Parts and Accessories800-626-2002 - -Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts -or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and -Discover cards are accepted). -Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed -by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified -service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing -may cause unsafe operation. - -Service Satisfaction - -If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow -these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance. -Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your -phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances, -Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225. - -40 - -Printed in Louisville, KY + Notes: Some workout types don't support the above four settings. The settings might slightly vary +in workout type. diff --git a/q12/random_k4/question.json b/q12/random_k4/question.json index a61a792157cc749b88fbeb1fb32c0f42982f60e5..d68acaf914974cb3393889592b16db50ce41f1b7 100644 --- a/q12/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q12/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2401.18059v1.pdf", - "web_c83d6885217d96f0.pdf", - "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf", - "web_a84abfae977a788a.pdf", - "675e3aeb6d0fc8bd13ab143192bd5d7a21a66de2.pdf" + "web_f77c9a6a0c40e754.pdf", + "resize_r1_31.pdf", + "web_a290dd87b6ce3b94.pdf", + "resize_fb_1.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_1.md b/q12/random_k4/random_1.md index dd5d594edac856e6a90c63c0d5c3c52351225e37..e93939cddbb26da056c6d4cb5d86060af787292b 100644 --- a/q12/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q12/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,771 +1,979 @@ -1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -2024 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL -WAVE 159 POLITICS SURVEY NOVEMBER 2024 -FINAL TOPLINE -NOVEMBER 12-17, 2024 -N=9,609 -Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This -topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly -modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire. -American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online -(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys -conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail. -For additional details, refer to the methodology. -* “No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents -who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered -as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and -telephone refusals. -In addition to the parameters used in weighting each wave of the American Trends Panel, the results of this -survey were weighted to the 2024 presidential popular vote and turnout among the voting-eligible population -(as of Nov. 18, 2024). For additional information, refer to the methodology. -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED -ASK ALL CITIZENS (XCITIZEN=1) [N=9,302]: -VOTED Which of the following statements best describes you? -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 16-27, Nov 12-17, Nov 7-16, Dec 12, -2024 20221 2020 2018 2016 -I did not vote in the November -22 2024 election 32 22 23 14 -13 I planned to vote but wasn’t able to 20 9 22 8 -I definitely voted in the November -65 2024 election 47 67 55 77 -1 No answer* 1 2 1 1 -1 In 2022 and 2018, this question was asked about that November’s congressional election. In 2020 and 2016, this question -was asked about that November’s presidential election. -www.pewresearch.org +INTRODUCING THE WINDOWS AZURE +PLATFORM + +DAVID CHAPPELL + +OCTOBER 2010 + +SPONSORED BY MICROSOFT CORPORATION + + CONTENTS + +An Overview of the Windows Azure Platform ....................................................................................... 3 + +Windows Azure ........................................................................................................................................ 4 + +SQL Azure ................................................................................................................................................. 6 + +Windows Azure AppFabric....................................................................................................................... 8 + +Windows Azure MarketPlace .................................................................................................................. 9 + +A Closer Look at the Technologies ....................................................................................................... 10 + +Windows Azure ...................................................................................................................................... 10 + +Compute ............................................................................................................................................ 11 + +Storage .............................................................................................................................................. 12 + +Fabric Controller ................................................................................................................................ 14 + +Content Delivery Network ................................................................................................................. 14 + +Connect ............................................................................................................................................. 15 + +SQL Azure ............................................................................................................................................... 15 + +Database ........................................................................................................................................... 15 + +Reporting ........................................................................................................................................... 17 + +Data Sync .......................................................................................................................................... 17 + +Windows Azure AppFabric..................................................................................................................... 19 + +Service Bus ........................................................................................................................................ 19 + +Access Control ................................................................................................................................... 21 + +Caching .............................................................................................................................................. 23 + +Windows Azure Marketplace ................................................................................................................ 24 + +Looking Ahead .................................................................................................................................... 26 + +Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................... 26 + +About the Author ................................................................................................................................ 27 2 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEGEN_POST In the 2024 presidential election, who did you vote for? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2 -FIRST FOLLOWED BY RANDOMIZED OPTIONS 3,4,5,6,7 WITH OPTION 8 AND 9 ALWAYS LAST] -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 49 | Donald Trump, the Republican | | | | | | | | | -| 47 | Kamala Harris, the Democrat | | | | | | | | | -| * | Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Chase Oliver, the Libertarian Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Cornel West, a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Claudia De la Cruz, the Socialism and Liberation Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Another candidate | | | | | | | | | -| 2 | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| * | No answer* | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE - -ASK IF DID NOT VOTE (VOTED=1-2) [N=1,201]: -| WISH_VOTED | Do you wish that you had voted in the election? | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | Nov 29- | | Nov 17- | | -| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | Dec 12 | | Dec 15, | | -| 2024 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | 2016 | | 2014 | | -| 42 | Yes | | 45 | 61 | | 44 | | 55 | | -| 57 | No | | 54 | 38 | | 55 | | 43 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | * | | 1 | | - -ASK IF CITIZEN AND DID NOT VOTE (X_CITIZEN=1 AND VOTED=1,2) [N=1,201]: -NOVOTERSN2 There are lots of different reasons why many people don’t vote. For you personally, -how much of a reason, if at all, is each of the following for why you did not vote? -[RANDOMIZE] - -| | | | Major | | Minor | | Not a | | No | -| ----- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | reason | | reason | | reason | | answer* | -| DIFF | I didn’t think my vote would make a | | | | | | | | | -difference -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 35 | | | 26 | 39 | | 1 | -| ----- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 21 | | | 23 | 55 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| CARE | I didn’t care who won2 | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 17 | | | 21 | 61 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 12 | | | 23 | 64 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| ELGB | I’m not registered or not eligible to | | | | | | | | | - vote -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 18 | | | 15 | 66 | | 1 | -| ----- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 19 | | | 10 | 70 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| INCV | It was too inconvenient for me to vote | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 15 | | | 22 | 62 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 20 | | | 21 | 59 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -2 In 2018, the reason was worded “I didn’t care who won the congressional election in my area.” -www.pewresearch.org -3 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -| NOVOTERSN2 CONTINUED … | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | Major | | | Minor | | Not a | No | | -| | | | | reason | | reason | | | reason | answer* | | -| LIKE | | I don’t like politics | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 31 | | | 25 | | 43 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 26 | | | 23 | | 50 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| FRGT | | I forgot to vote | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 8 | | 13 | | 79 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | | 7 | | 15 | | 77 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED TRUMP (VOTEGEN_POST=1) [N=3,536]: -DTFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… -ASK IF VOTED HARRIS (VOTEGEN_POST=2) [N=4,185]: -KHFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Harris was more a vote… - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: - -| | | | | | | Based on registered voters | | | | | | -| ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | | Aug 26-Sep 2, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 20243 | | 2024 | | | -| | 49 | | Trump | | | | 47 | | 49 | | | -| | 40 | | For Trump | | | | 31 | | 33 | | | -| | 9 | | Against Harris | | | | 15 | | 16 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| 47 | | | Harris | | | | 48 | | 49 | | | -| | 23 | | For Harris | | | | 23 | | 24 | | | -| | 24 | | Against Trump | | | | 25 | | 25 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| | 2 | | Vote for Kennedy Jr./Oliver/Stein/West/De | | | | - | | - | | | -La Cruz/Another candidate -| | 2 | | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | * | | No answer* | | | | * | | * | | | - -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Biden was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | Based on voters | | | | Based on registered voters | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | | | Jun 16-22, | -| | | | | | | 2020 | | | 20204 | | 2020 | -| | | | Trump | | | 47 | | | 42 | | 44 | -| | | | For Trump | | | 36 | | | 30 | | 33 | -| | | | Against Biden | | | 11 | | | 12 | | 10 | -| | | | Biden | | | 51 | | | 52 | | 54 | -| | | | For Biden | | | 24 | | | 19 | | 18 | -| | | | Against Trump | | | 28 | | | 33 | | 36 | -| | | | Vote for Jorgensen/Hawkins/Another | | | 1 | | | - | | - | -candidate -| | | | No answer | | | * | | | * | | - | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + AN OVERVIEW OF THE WINDOWS AZURE PLATFORM + +Using computers in the cloud can make lots of sense. Rather than buying and maintaining your own +machines, why not exploit the acres of Internet-accessible servers on offer today? For some applications, +both code and data might live in the cloud, where somebody else manages and maintains the systems +they use. Alternatively, applications that run inside an organization—on-premises applications—might +store data in the cloud or rely on other cloud infrastructure services. However it’s done, exploiting the +cloud’s capabilities can improve our world. + +But whether an application runs in the cloud, uses services provided by the cloud, or both, some kind of +application platform is required. Viewed broadly, an application platform can be thought of as anything +that provides developer-accessible services for creating applications or storing data. In the on-premises +Windows world, this includes technologies such as Windows Server and SQL Server. To let applications +exploit the cloud, a cloud application platform must also exist. + +This is exactly what the Microsoft Windows Azure platform provides. It’s a group of cloud technologies, +each providing a specific set of services to application developers. Figure 1 shows its components. + +Figure 1: The Windows Azure platform supports applications, data, and infrastructure in the cloud, +together with a cloud marketplace. + +The Windows Azure platform today has four parts: + + Windows Azure: A Windows environment for running applications and storing data on computers in + +Microsoft data centers. + +SQL Azure: Relational data services in the cloud based on SQL Server. + + Windows Azure AppFabric: Cloud-based infrastructure services for applications running in the cloud + +or on premises. 3 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and KHFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Harris. -4 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and JBFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Biden. -www.pewresearch.org + + Windows Azure Marketplace: An online service for purchasing cloud-based data and applications. + +All four of these components run in Microsoft data centers located around the world: two in North +America, two in Europe, and two in Asia. Developers using the platform can control which data center +runs their applications and stores their data, giving them the ability to place both closer to their users. + +Each part of the Windows Azure platform has its own role to play. This overview describes all four, first at +a high level, then in a bit more detail. The goal is to provide a big-picture introduction to this cloud +platform. + +WINDOWS AZURE + +At a high level, Windows Azure is simple to understand: It runs Windows applications and stores data in +the cloud. Figure 2 shows its components. + +Figure 2: Windows Azure provides compute and storage services in the cloud. + +The five parts of Windows Azure today are the following: + + Compute: The Windows Azure compute service runs applications on a Windows Server foundation. +These applications can be created using the .NET Framework in languages such as C# and Visual Basic, +or they can be built without .NET in C++, Java, and other languages. Developers can use Visual Studio +or other development tools, and they’re free to use technologies such as ASP.NET, Windows +Communication Foundation (WCF), and PHP. + +Storage: This service allows storing binary large objects (blobs), provides queues for communication +between components of Windows Azure applications, and even offers a form of tables with a simple +query language. (Windows Azure applications that need traditional relational storage can also use 4 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEDECTIME As far as you can remember, when did you make up your mind about who you were going to -vote for in the presidential election? -BASED ON THOSE WHO SELECTED A CANDIDATE (VOTEGEN_POST=1-8) [N=7,977] -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 12-17, Dec 12 -2024 2020 20165 -Last few days before Election -4 Day 3 9 -The last week before Election -3 Day 2 4 -7 In October 5 9 -6 In September 5 11 -81 Before September 84 67 -* No answer* * * -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you make up your mind definitely to vote for “Hillary Clinton;” “Donald Trump;” “Gary -Johnson;” “Jill Stein,” “The candidate of your choice”? -Nov 10-14 Nov 8-11 Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov -2016 2012 2004 2000 1996 1992 1988 -On Election Day 4 4 4 5 6 9 6 -On Monday (day before the election) * 1 1 2 3 4 3 -Over the last weekend * 1 1 2 2 4 2 -In the last week 2 2 3 5 6 8 4 -In the last few weeks 5 -- -- -- -- -- -- -During or just after the Presidential debates 10 10 11 17 -- 12 -- -Before debates/after the Conventions 10 9 6 9 12 6 16 -Convention period (NET) 22 10 7 7 8 12 15 -During or after the Republican convention 13 9 1 4 -- -- -- -During or after the Democratic convention 9 1 6 3 -- -- -- -This year, before the conventions 22 16 23 21 13 18 19 -Before 2016 20 41 38 20 39 12 9 -Other -- 0 0 -- * 8 -- -Don’t remember 2 1 4 6 6 5 4 -Don’t know/Refused 1 4 2 3 2 1 2 -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -5 In 2016, people who said “another candidate” were not asked this question; question read “As far as you can remember, -when did you make up your mind definitely to vote for ‘Donald Trump;’ ‘Hillary Clinton;’ ‘Gary Johnson;’ ‘Jill Stein’?” -www.pewresearch.org + + SQL Azure.) Both Windows Azure applications and on-premises applications can access the Windows +Azure storage service, and both do it in the same way: using a RESTful approach. + +Fabric controller: As the figure suggests, Windows Azure runs on a large number of machines. The +fabric controller’s job is to knit the machines in a single Windows Azure data center into a cohesive +whole. The Windows Azure compute and storage services are then built on top of this pool of +processing power. + + Content delivery network (CDN): Caching frequently accessed data closer to its users speeds up +access to that data. The Windows Azure CDN can do this for blobs, maintaining cached copies at sites +around the world. + + Connect: It’s often useful for organizations to interact with cloud applications as if they were inside +the organization’s own firewall. Windows Azure Connect allows this, making it easier for, say, a +Windows Azure application to access an on-premises database. + +Running applications and storing data in the cloud can have clear benefits. Rather than buying, installing, +and operating its own systems, for example, an organization can rely on a cloud provider to do this for +them. Also, customers pay just for the computing and storage they use, rather than maintaining a large +set of servers only for peak loads. And applications written for Windows Azure can scale better, be more +reliable, and require less administration than those written using the traditional Windows Server +programming model. + +To create, configure, and monitor applications, Windows Azure customers can use a browser-accessible +portal. A customer logs in with a Windows Live ID, then chooses whether to create a hosting account for +running applications, a storage account for storing data, or both. Microsoft then charges each customer +based on how much compute time, storage, and bandwidth that customer uses. How an application +charges its own customers—if it charges them at all—is entirely up to the people who create that +application. + +Windows Azure is a general platform that can be used in a broad set of scenarios. Here are a few +examples: + + An independent software vendor (ISV) creating a software-as-a-service (SaaS) version of an existing +on-premises Windows application might choose to build it on Windows Azure. Because Windows +Azure mostly provides a standard Windows environment, moving the application’s business logic to +this cloud platform won’t typically pose many problems. And once again, building on an existing +platform lets the ISV focus on business logic—the thing that makes them money—rather than +spending time on infrastructure. + + An enterprise creating an application for its customers or employees might choose to build it on +Windows Azure. Because Windows Azure supports .NET, developers with the right skills aren’t +difficult to find, nor are they prohibitively expensive. Running the application in Microsoft data +centers frees the enterprise from the responsibility and expense of managing its own servers, turning +capital expenses into operating expenses. And especially if the application has spikes in usage— +maybe it’s an on-line flower store that must handle the Mother’s Day rush—letting Microsoft +maintain the large server base required for this can make economic sense. 5 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_COM Do you think the elections this November in your community were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 55 | Very well | | 42 | | 53 | | 49 | | | | -| 35 | Somewhat well | | 42 | | 32 | | 38 | | | | -| 7 | Not too well | | 9 | | 9 | | | 8 | | | -| 2 | Not at all well | | 4 | | 6 | | | 4 | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | | 1 | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in your community will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 43 | | 40 | | 36 | | 41 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 44 | | 45 | | 48 | | 46 | -| | Not too well | | | 8 | | 10 | | 11 | | 9 | -| | Not at all well | | | 4 | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_US Do you think the elections this November in the United States were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 37 | Very well | | 25 | | 33 | | 21 | | | | -| 47 | Somewhat well | | 46 | | 25 | | 53 | | | | -| 11 | Not too well | | 18 | | 20 | | 18 | | | | -| 4 | Not at all well | | 8 | | 22 | | 7 | | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | 1 | | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in the United States will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 20 | | 20 | | 12 | | 20 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 50 | | 49 | | 46 | | 57 | -| | Not too well | | | 21 | | 23 | | 30 | | 18 | -| | Not at all well | | | 8 | | 7 | | 12 | | 4 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org + + A start-up creating a new Web site—the next Facebook, say—could build its application on Windows +Azure. Because this platform supports both Web-facing services and background processes, the +application can provide an +interface as well as executing work for users +asynchronously. Rather than spending time and money worrying about infrastructure, the start-up +can instead focus solely on creating code that provides value to its customers and investors. The +company can also start small, incurring low costs while its application has only a few users. If the +application catches on and usage increases, Windows Azure can scale the application as needed. + +interactive user + +These three examples illustrate the kinds of things organizations might do with Windows Azure, but +they’re not an exhaustive list. As interest in cloud computing continues to grow, expect to see a variety of +applications created for this cloud platform. + +SQL AZURE + +Along with running applications, another attractive way to use the cloud is for storing data. SQL Azure +addresses this area, offering cloud-based services for relational data. As Figure 3 shows, SQL Azure today +includes three components. + +Figure 3: SQL Azure provides relational database services in the cloud. + +The components of SQL Azure today are the following: + +SQL Azure Database provides a cloud-based database management system (DBMS). This technology +lets on-premises and cloud applications store relational data on Microsoft servers in Microsoft data 6 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTEASY_POST Overall, was voting in the election this November for you personally... [ROTATE -RESPONSES OPTIONS 1-4/4-1] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 79 | Very easy | | | | 77 | | | | | | -| | 15 | Somewhat easy | | | | 17 | | | | | | -| | 5 | Somewhat difficult | | | | 5 | | | | | | - -| | 2 | Very difficult | | | | 1 | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Overall, do you personally expect voting in the November elections to be... - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | | Sep 30- | Oct 10- | | Sep 30- | Jul 27- | Sep 24- | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | Oct 6, | 16 | | Oct 5 | Aug 2 | Oct 7 | -| | | | | | | 2024 | 2022 | | 2020 | 2020 | 2018 | -| | | Very easy | | | | 43 | 45 | | 29 | 23 | 46 | -| | | Somewhat easy | | | | 38 | 37 | | 36 | 28 | 39 | -| | | Somewhat difficult | | | | 16 | 14 | | 29 | 38 | 13 | -| | | Very difficult | | | | 4 | | 3 | 6 | 11 | 2 | -| | | No answer | | | | * | | * | * | 1 | * | - -ASK ALL: -SATCAND_POST Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential -candidates? Would you say that you were… -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 32 | Very satisfied | | | | 30 | | | | | | -| | 20 | Fairly satisfied | | | | 26 | | | | | | -| | 22 | Not too satisfied | | | | 24 | | | | | | -| | 25 | Not at all satisfied | | | | 19 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | - - TREND FOR COMPARISON: -What is your opinion of the presidential candidates for this year? Would you say that you are… - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | 2024 Election | | | | 2020 Election | | | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | Aug 26- | | | | | Jul 27- | | | -| | | | | Sep 2, | | Jul 1-7, | | | Aug 2, | Jun 16-22, | | -| | | | | 2024 | | 2024 | | | 2020 | 2020 | | -| | Very satisfied | | | | 15 | 11 | | | 15 | 16 | | -| | Fairly satisfied | | | | 32 | 20 | | | 31 | 31 | | -| | Not too satisfied | | | | 34 | 32 | | | 35 | 34 | | -| | Not at all satisfied | | | | 17 | 37 | | | 19 | 19 | | -| | No answer* | | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | 1 | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org + + centers. As with other cloud technologies, an organization pays only for what it uses, increasing and +decreasing usage (and cost) as the organization’s needs change. Using a cloud database also allows +converting what would be capital expenses, such as investments in disks and DBMS software, into +operating expenses. + +SQL Azure Reporting is a version of SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS) that runs in the cloud. +Intended primarily for use with SQL Azure Database, it allows creating and publishing standard SSRS +reports on cloud data. + +SQL Azure Data Sync allows synchronizing data between SQL Azure Database and on-premises SQL +Server databases. It can also be used to synchronize data across different SQL Azure databases in +different Microsoft data centers. + +SQL Azure is built on Microsoft SQL Server. As with SQL Server, developers can create indexes and views, +use stored procedures, define triggers, and more. Applications can access SQL Azure data using Entity +Framework, ADO.NET, and other Windows data access interfaces. In fact, applications that today access +SQL Server locally will largely work unchanged with data in SQL Azure. Customers can also use on- +premises software such as SQL Server Analysis Services to work with their cloud-based data. + +While applications can use SQL Azure much as they do a local DBMS, the management requirements are +significantly reduced. Rather than worry about mechanics, such as monitoring disk usage and servicing log +files, a SQL Azure customer can focus on their data; Microsoft handles the operational details. And as with +other components of this cloud platform, customers use the common Windows Azure platform portal to +access its services. + +Applications might use SQL Azure in a variety of ways. Here are some examples: + + A Windows Azure application can store its data in SQL Azure. While Windows Azure provides its own +storage, relational tables aren’t among the options it offers. Since many existing applications use +relational storage and many developers know how to work with it, a significant number of Windows +Azure applications rely on SQL Azure to work with data in this familiar way. For example, a SaaS +application built on Windows Azure might create a separate SQL Azure database for each customer, +providing an intrinsically multi-tenant design. And to improve performance, customers can specify +that a particular Windows Azure application must run in the same data center in which SQL Azure +Database stores that application’s information. + + An application in a small business or a department of a larger organization might rely on SQL Azure. +Rather than storing its data in a SQL Server or Access database running on a computer under +somebody’s desk, the application can instead take advantage of the reliability and availability of cloud +storage. It can also create reports on this data using either SQL Azure Reporting or SSRS on-premises. +If the organization wishes to maintain an on-premises copy of the data as well, it can use SQL Azure +Data Sync to synchronize the cloud and on-premises databases. + +Suppose a manufacturer wishes to make product information available both to its dealer network +and directly to customers. Putting this data in SQL Azure would let it be accessed by applications +running at the dealers and by a customer-facing Web application run by the manufacturer itself. 7 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -SATCAND_POST TREND FOR COMPARSION CONTINUED … -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: - Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential candidates? + Whether it’s for supporting a Windows Azure application, making data more accessible, or other reasons, +data services in the cloud can be attractive. The goal of SQL Azure is to provide these services in a familiar, +usable way for cloud and on-premises applications. + +WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC -BASED ON THOSE WHO VOTED: +Running applications and storing data in the cloud are both important aspects of cloud computing. +They’re far from the whole story, however. It’s also possible to provide cloud-based infrastructure +services. Filling this gap is the goal of Windows Azure AppFabric. -| | | | Nov 10-14, | | Nov 8-11, | | Nov Nov | | Nov Nov | Nov Nov | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2012 | | 2008 2004 | | 2000 1996 | 1992 1988 | -| Very satisfied | | | | 19 | 37 | | 39 | 33 | 24 18 | 24 26 | -| Fairly satisfied | | | | 25 | 33 | | 28 | 33 | 44 33 | 37 36 | -| Not very satisfied | | | | 26 | 16 | | 17 | 16 | 18 24 | 21 20 | -| Not at all satisfied | | | | 29 | 12 | | 14 | 16 | 9 22 | 16 17 | -| Don't | | | | 1 | 3 | | 2 | 2 | 5 3 | 2 1 | -know/Refused -(VOL.) +The functions provided by AppFabric today address common challenges in building distributed +applications. Figure 4 shows its components. -[DISPLAY CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD, CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG, CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY, -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT ON SAME PAGE; RANDOMIZE ORDER OF QUESTIONS; INCLUDE -RANDOMIZATION IN DATA FILE. DO NOT RANDOMIZE RESPONSE OPTIONS WITHIN EACH -QUESTION] +Figure 4: Windows Azure AppFabric provides Windows Azure-based infrastructure services that can be +used by both cloud and on-premises applications. -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... +As the figure suggests, all of the components of Windows Azure AppFabric are built on Windows Azure +(although they don’t all provide services solely to Windows Azure applications). Those components are +the following: -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: +Service Bus: Exposing an application’s services on the Internet is harder than it might seem. The goal +of Service Bus is to make this simpler by letting an application expose endpoints in the cloud that can +be accessed by other applications, whether on-premises or in the cloud. Each exposed endpoint is +assigned a URI, which clients can use to locate and access the service. Service Bus also handles the +challenges of dealing with network address translation and getting through firewalls without opening +new ports for exposed applications. -| | | | Made you feel proud | | | Did not make you feel | | | No | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | of the country | | | proud of the country | | | answer* | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 29 | | | 70 | | 1 | | + Access Control: There are many ways for a user to get a digital identity today. The options include +Active Directory, Windows Live ID, Google Accounts, Facebook, and more. If an application wants to +let users log in with any of these, the application’s creator faces the daunting challenge of supporting -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | +8 -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + this plethora of approaches. Access Control simplifies this by providing built-in support for all of them +(and more). It also provides a single place for defining rules to control what each user is allowed to +access. -| | | | | | | Makes you feel proud | | Does not make you feel | | No | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | of the country | | proud of the country | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | 19 | | 79 | 2 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | 12 | | 87 | 1 | + Caching: It’s common for applications to access the same data over and over. One way to speed up +this kind of application is to cache frequently accessed information, reducing the number of times +that application must query a database. The Caching service provides this—and the performance +boost it brings—for Windows Azure applications. -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org +Microsoft has announced plans to add more services under the Windows Azure AppFabric banner, so +expect this list to grow in the not-too-distant future. -8 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Too | | Not too | | No | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | negative | | negative | | answer* | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | | 25 | | 1 | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | Too | Not too | | No | | -| | | | | | | | | negative | negative | | answer* | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 71 | | 27 | | 2 | -Jul 1-7, 2024 -| | | | | | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:6 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 76 | | 23 | | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 61 | | 37 | | 2 | - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Focused on important | | | Not focused on important | | | | No | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | | | policy debates | | | | policy debates | | | answer* | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 35 | | | | 64 | | 1 | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | | | Focused on | | Not focused on | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | important | | important | | No | -| | | | | | | | | policy debates | | policy debates | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 37 | | | 62 | 1 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | | 23 | | | 76 | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:7 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 27 | | | 72 | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 25 | | | 73 | 2 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -6 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -7 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org +As with Windows Azure and SQL Azure, customers use a browser-accessible portal to sign up for +AppFabric. Once this has been done, these services can be used in a variety of ways. Here are some of the +possibilities: + +Suppose an enterprise wished to let software at its trading partners access one of its applications. It +could expose this application’s functions through SOAP or RESTful services created using WCF, then +register those service endpoints with Service Bus. Its trading partners could then use Service Bus to +find these endpoints and access the services. + +Imagine that the creator of this same application needs to let trading partners log in with a variety of +different identities. Rather than implementing support for these identities himself, he could use the +Access Control service to hide this complexity. + + A Windows Azure application created using ASP.NET might use the Session object to store per-client +state. By changing only a configuration setting, the application can cause this data to be kept in the +Caching service rather than, say, Windows Azure Storage tables. Doing this is likely to make the +application faster and more scalable. + +Along with the cloud-based services of Windows Azure AppFabric, Microsoft also provides an analogous +technology known as Windows Server AppFabric. As its name suggests, the services it provides run on +Windows Server—they support on-premises applications—rather than in the cloud. The on-premises +services aren’t exactly the same today as those in Windows Azure AppFabric (although Microsoft’s +announced plan is make the two congruent). Don’t be confused; throughout this paper, the name +“AppFabric” is used to refer to the cloud-based services. Also, don’t confuse Windows Azure AppFabric +with the Windows Azure fabric controller. Even though both contain the term “fabric”, they’re wholly +separate technologies addressing quite distinct problems. + +WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE + +In the on-premises world, many applications are purchased rather than custom-built. Many organizations +also rely on datasets from commercial providers. With the rise of the cloud, why not let customers find +and buy cloud applications and cloud-accessible data? Making this possible is the goal of Windows Azure +Marketplace. Figure 5 shows its two components. 9 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | | No | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | Interesting | Dull answer* | | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | 24 2 | | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | No | -| | | | | | Interesting | | | Dull | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON8 | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | 64 | | 34 | | 2 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | 39 | | 59 | | 2 | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -| VOTE_HOW_POST | | | How did you vote in the election? [RANDOMIZE] | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -| VOTEINPWHEN | | When did you vote? | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| | 65 | In person at a polling place | | | | | 65 | | 54 | | -| | 34 | On Election Day | | | | | 44 | | | 27 | -| | 32 | Before Election Day | | | | | 21 | | | 27 | -| | * | Refused | | | | | * | | | * | -| | 35 | By absentee or mail-in ballot | | | | | 35 | | 46 | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | * | | | * | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you vote in the elections this November? -How did you vote in the November election? - -| | | | | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2018 -| | | On election day | | | | | 55 | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Before election day | | | | | 45 | | | | -| | | Voted in person | | | | | 19 | | | | -| | | Mailed in ballot | | | | | 25 | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -8 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org + + Figure 5: Windows Azure Marketplace provides an online marketplace for cloud applications and data. + +The two parts of Windows Azure Marketplace are: + + DataMarket (originally codenamed “Dallas”), providing a way for content providers to make datasets +available. Customers can browse the offerings, then purchase whatever they find useful. Applications, +both custom and off-the-shelf (such as Microsoft Excel), can then access this data through RESTful +requests or the OData protocol. + + AppMarket, providing a way for creators of cloud applications to expose those applications to + +potential customers. AppMarket will be available sometime after DataMarket. + +Using the cloud to find, evaluate, and purchase data and applications makes sense. The goal of Windows +Azure Marketplace is to make these things easier to do. + +A CLOSER LOOK AT THE TECHNOLOGIES + +Having a broad understanding of the Windows Azure platform is an important first step. Making good +decisions require a deeper understanding of these technologies, however. This section takes a slightly +more in-depth look at each member of the family. + +WINDOWS AZURE + +Windows Azure provides what’s commonly called Platform as a Service (PaaS). Rather than offering a +cloud replica of the on-premises world, it offers a higher level of service that’s meant to make life easier +for both developers and administrators. What follows walks through the five components that +collectively provide this service. 10 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -VOTE_HOW_POST/VOTEINPWHEN TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED… - -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Did you vote ON Election Day or BEFORE Election DAY? - -Did you vote in person or did you mail your ballot in? - -| | | | Nov 10-14 | Nov 6-9 | | Nov 8-11 | | Nov | | Nov | | Nov | Nov | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2014 | | 2012 | 2008 | | 2006 | | 2004 | 2002 | -| On Election Day | | | 59 | | 71 | | 63 | 66 | | 80 | | 80 | 85 | -| Before Election Day | | | 41 | | 29 | | 37 | 34 | | 20 | | 20 | 15 | -| Voted in person | | | 22 | | 12 | | 19 | 19 | | -- | | | | -| Mailed in ballot | | | 18 | | 16 | | 17 | 14 | | -- | | | | -| Other way/DK/Ref (VOL) | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | 1 | | -- | | | | -| Don’t know/Refused (VOL) | | | 0 | | * | | 0 | * | | * | | * | * | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -VOTEMAIL How did you return your absentee or mail-in ballot? [RANDOMIZE] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | | 2020 | | | | -| | 12 | In person to an election official or poll | | | | | | 12 | | 15 | | | | -worker -| | 38 | At a designated dropbox | | | | | | 36 | | 41 | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 50 | By mail | | | | | | 52 | | 44 | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | * | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILWHEN When did you mail or return your absentee or mail-in ballot? - -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | | -| | 33 | In the week leading up to Election Day | | | | | | 23 | | | | | | -| | 67 | Before that | | | | | | 76 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -WAITVOTE When you went to vote, approximately how long did you have to wait in line to -vote? -| | | | | | | | | | | | Nov 17- | | | -| ------------ | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | Dec 15, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | 2014 | | | -| | 42 | Did not wait at all9 | | | | 35 | | 47 | | | | 53 | | -| | 30 | Less than 10 minutes | | | | 27 | | 33 | | | | 30 | | -| | 17 | 10 to 30 minutes | | | | 20 | | 14 | | | | 13 | | -| | 7 | 31 minutes to 1 hour | | | | 11 | | | 5 | | | 3 | | -| | 4 | More than 1 hour | | | | 6 | | | 1 | | | * | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | * | | | * | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -9 In surveys prior to November 2024, the response was worded “Not at all”. -www.pewresearch.org + + Compute + +An application built on the Windows Azure compute service is structured as one or more roles. When it +executes, the application typically runs two or more instances of each role, with each instance running as +its own virtual machine (VM). Figure 6 shows how this looks. + +Figure 6: A running Windows Azure application consists of any combination of Web role instances, +Worker role instances, and VM role instances. + +A Windows Azure application today can be created using three kinds of roles: + + Web roles, intended primarily for running Web-based applications. Each Web role instance has +Internet Information Services (IIS) 7 pre-configured to run inside it, so creating applications using +ASP.NET, WCF, or other Web technologies is straightforward. It’s also possible to create applications +using PHP, Java, and other non-Microsoft technologies. + + Worker roles, designed to run a variety of code. A Worker role might run a simulation, for example, +or video processing or nearly anything else. It’s common for an application to interact with users +through a Web role, then hand tasks off to a Worker role for processing. + + VM roles, which can run a user-provided Windows Server 2008 R2 image. A VM role can be the right + +choice for moving some on-premises Windows Server applications to Windows Azure. + +When a developer gives Windows Azure an application to run, she submits configuration information +along with it. Among other things, this information tells the platform how many instances of each role to +run. The Windows Azure fabric controller then creates a VM for each instance, running the code for the 11 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK IF VOTED BY MAIL OR ABSENTEE (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted by mail or absentee ballot? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2020 | | | -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted by -| 12 | | | 39 | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -mail or absentee ballot -| 88 | No, I have voted by mail or absentee ballot before | | 61 | | | -| --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON BEFORE ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=1) [N=2,671]: -| EARLYFIRST | Is this the first time you have ever voted early? | | | | | -| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -29 Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted early -71 No, I have voted early before -* No answer* - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON ON ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=2) [N=2,513]: -ELECDFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted in person on Election Day? - -Nov 12-17, -2024 -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted in person on Election Day -7 -93 No, I have voted in person on Election Day before -* No answer* - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTCOUNT_OWN How confident are you that your vote was accurately counted? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | 2020 | | -| 59 | Very confident | | 57 | 59 | | -| 33 | Somewhat confident | | 31 | 26 | | -| 5 | Not too confident | | 8 | 9 | | -Not at all confident -| 2 | | | 3 | 6 | | -| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | * | | - -| | PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | Nov 10-14 Nov 6-9 Nov 8-11 Nov 4-7 | | Nov Nov | Nov | -| --- | -------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | -| | | 2016 2014 | 2012 2010 | 2008 2006 | 2004 | -| | Very confident | 71 68 | 68 64 | 73 70 | 68 | -| | Somewhat confident | 19 21 | 22 26 | 22 23 | 24 | -| | Not too confident | 4 5 | 5 4 | 3 3 | 4 | -| | Not at all confident | 5 4 | 3 3 | 2 2 | 3 | -| | Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) | 1 1 | 1 3 | * 2 | 1 | -| | | | | | | -www.pewresearch.org + + appropriate role in each VM. And as Figure 6 indicates, requests from the outside world are load balanced +across all instances of a role. + +This has an important implication: To be scalable, Windows Azure role instances shouldn’t maintain their +state themselves between requests. Because the load balancer doesn’t allow creating an affinity with a +particular role instance—there’s no support for sticky sessions—there’s no way to guarantee that multiple +requests from the same user will be sent to the same instance. Instead, any client-specific state should be +written to Windows Azure storage, stored in SQL Azure Database, or maintained externally in some other +way. + +For role instances, Windows Azure lets developers choose from several VM sizes, each with a specific +number of processor cores and memory. Since each instance can be assigned one or more cores, +applications have predictable performance. And to increase the load an application can handle, its owner +or the application itself can request an increase in the number of running instances for one or more roles. +The Windows Azure fabric controller will then spin up new VMs for these instances and start them +running. It’s also possible to explicitly decrease the number of instances for a role, letting an application +grow and shrink as needed to handle changing loads. + +For developers, building a Windows Azure application looks much like building a traditional Windows +application. Microsoft provides Visual Studio project templates, for instance, to help developers create +Windows Azure applications. Also, the Windows Azure software development kit includes a version of the +Windows Azure environment that runs on the developer’s machine. Known as the Windows Azure +development fabric, it implements a local replica of the Windows Azure compute and storage services. A +developer can create and debug his application using this local simulacrum, then deploy it to Windows +Azure in the cloud when it’s ready. Windows Azure also provides other services for developers, such as +information about a running application’s CPU consumption, incoming and outgoing bandwidth, and +storage usage. + +Storage + +Applications work with data in many different ways. Sometimes, all that’s required are simple blobs, while +other situations call for a more structured way to store information. And in some cases, all that’s really +needed is a way to exchange data between different parts of an application. Windows Azure storage +addresses all three of these requirements, as Figure 7 shows. 12 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_INP How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 38 | Very confident | | 37 | | 42 | | -| 47 | Somewhat confident | | 43 | | 35 | | -| 11 | Not too confident | | 13 | | 13 | | -| 4 | Not at all confident | | 6 | | 8 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United States will -be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 36 | | 34 | 42 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 46 | | 45 | 44 | -| | Not too confident | | 13 | | 15 | 10 | -| | Not at all confident | | | 5 | 5 | 4 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_ABS How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail in ballot across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 24 | Very confident | | 25 | | 30 | | -| 46 | Somewhat confident | | 37 | | 27 | | -| 21 | Not too confident | | 23 | | 19 | | -| 7 | Not at all confident | | 13 | | 23 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail-in ballot across the United States -will be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 22 | | 21 | 17 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 38 | | 38 | 38 | -| | Not too confident | | 27 | | 24 | 28 | -| | Not at all confident | | 12 | | 16 | 16 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -www.pewresearch.org + + Figure 7: Windows Azure provides blobs, tables, and queues, all accessed in a RESTful style via HTTP, +HTTPS, or OData. + +The simplest way to store data in Windows Azure storage is to use blobs. As Figure 7 suggests, there’s a +simple hierarchy: A storage account can have one or more containers, each of which holds one or more +blobs. Blobs can be big—as large as a terabyte each—and to make transferring large blobs more efficient, +they can potentially be subdivided into blocks. If a failure occurs, retransmission can resume with the +most recent block rather than sending the entire blob again. Blobs can also have associated metadata, +such as information about where a JPEG photograph was taken or who the composer is for an MP3 file. + +Another way to use blobs is through Windows Azure drives, which can be mounted by a role instance. The +underlying storage for a drive is a blob, and so once a drive is mounted, the instance can read and write +file system data that gets stored persistently in a blob. + +Blobs are just right for some kinds of data, but they’re too unstructured for many situations. To allow +applications to work with data in a more fine-grained way, Windows Azure storage provides tables. Don’t +be misled by the name: These aren’t relational tables. In fact, even though they’re called “tables”, the +data they contain is actually stored in a set of entities with properties. A table has no defined schema; +instead, properties can have various types, such as int, string, Bool, or DateTime. And rather than using +SQL, an application can access a table’s data using the simple query language defined by OData. A single +table can be quite large, with billions of entities holding terabytes of data, and Windows Azure storage +can partition it across many servers if necessary to improve performance. + +Blobs and tables are both focused on storing data. The third option in Windows Azure storage, queues, +has a somewhat different purpose. A primary use of queues is to let Web role instances communicate +with Worker role instances. For example, a user might submit a request to perform some compute- 13 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK ALL: -ELECT_CONFNOVPOS How confident, if at all, are you that... [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] - -| | | | | | | Very | Somewhat | | Not too | | Not at all | No | -| ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | | | confident | | confident | | confident | | confident | answer* | -| PRVFR | | People who were not legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified to vote are prevented | | | | | | | | | | | -from casting a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 27 | | 38 | 26 | | 8 | 1 | -| ------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON10: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 29 | | 30 | 24 | | 17 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 23 | | 36 | 28 | | 11 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| PRVSUP | | People who were legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified and want to vote are | | | | | | | | | | | -able to cast a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 45 | | 42 | 9 | | 3 | 1 | -| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON11: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 44 | | 43 | 10 | | 3 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 36 | | 45 | 14 | | 4 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK ALL: -| PARTY | | In politics today, do you consider yourself a… | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3, 4 OR REFUSED): -| PARTYLN | | As of today do you lean more to…12 | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | Something | | No | | Lean | Lean | | - Republican Democrat Independent else answer* Rep Dem -| | | 28 | 27 | 30 | | 14 | | 1 | | 20 | | 20 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -10 In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are not legally qualified to vote are prevented from -casting a ballot.” -11 -In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are legally qualified and want to vote are able to cast -a ballot.” -12 PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey. -www.pewresearch.org \ No newline at end of file + + intensive task via a Web page implemented by a Windows Azure Web role. The Web role instance that +receives this request can write a message into a queue describing the work to be done. A Worker role +instance that’s waiting on this queue can then read the message and carry out the task it specifies. Any +results can be returned via another queue or handled in some other way. + +Regardless of how it’s stored—in blobs, tables, or queues—all data held in Windows Azure storage is +replicated three times. This replication allows fault tolerance, since losing a copy isn’t fatal. The system +guarantees consistency, however, so an application that reads data it has just written will get what it +expects. + +Windows Azure storage can be accessed either by a Windows Azure application or by an application +running somewhere else. In both cases, all three Windows Azure storage styles use the conventions of +REST (and the OData protocol for tables) to identify and expose data. Everything is named using URIs and +accessed with standard HTTP operations, so clients can be created using .NET, Java, or other familiar +technologies. + +The Windows Azure platform charges independently for compute and storage resources. This means that +an on-premises application can use just Windows Azure storage, accessing its data in the RESTful way just +described. For example, a Windows Server application running in an enterprise data center might choose +to store backups in Windows storage blobs. + +Fabric Controller + +Even though a Windows Azure application runs in VMs, a developer doesn’t explicitly create and manage +those VMs. Instead, as described earlier, she just tells the platform how many instances the application +needs, and Windows Azure silently creates the necessary VMs and runs her application. This magic is +performed by the fabric controller, a fundamental aspect of Windows Azure. + +Along with creating VMs and starting the applications that run in them, the fabric controller also monitors +all running instances. A role instance might fail for many reasons; maybe the code threw an exception or +the VM crashed or the physical server it’s running on went down. Whatever the reason, the fabric +controller will start a new instance to maintain the total number of instances required for this application. + +The fabric controller also handles housekeeping tasks like patching the operating system and other +system software, which minimizes the need for administrators. These are all examples of why Windows +Azure is viewed as PaaS: It provides a platform that lets customers run applications without worrying +about administering the environment they run in. + +Content Delivery Network + +One common use of blobs is to store information that will be accessed from many different places. Think +of an application that serves up videos, for example, to Flash, Silverlight, or HTML 5 clients around the +world. To improve performance in situations like this, Windows Azure provides a content delivery +network. The CDN stores copies of a blob at sites closer to the clients that use it. This speeds up delivery +of frequently accessed content, improving performance for users of this information. + +14 + + Connect + +Windows Azure applications can interact with the outside world via HTTP, HTTPS, or TCP. But suppose +you’d like to connect a role in an application to a machine outside the cloud at the IP level. For example, +suppose an organization decides to move an existing ASP.NET application to Windows Azure, but wishes +to keep the application’s data in an on-premises SQL Server database. Windows Azure Connect allows +this. + +Using this option requires running Windows Azure Connect software on the on-premises machine that +contains SQL Server, and it also requires some straightforward configuration. (This configuration can be +done by the developer—there’s no need to get a network administrator involved.) Once this is done, all of +the instances in the Web role can behave as if they’re on the same IP network as the SQL Server machine. +In fact, they can use the same SQL Server connection string as when the application was running on +premises—there’s no difference. + +Note that this isn’t a full-fledged virtual private network (VPN). While Microsoft has announced plans to +let customers connect to Windows Azure via a VPN, this isn’t currently supported. It is possible to use +Windows Azure Connect to domain-join a Windows Azure application to an on-premises Active Directory, +however. Doing this allows single sign-on by on-premises users to the cloud application, and it also lets +the application use existing Active Directory accounts and groups for access control. + +The goal of application platforms, whether on-premises or in the cloud, is to support applications and +data. Windows Azure provides a home for both of these things. Going forward, expect to see a substantial +share of what would have been on-premises Windows applications instead running on this new cloud +platform. + +SQL AZURE + +A DBMS in the cloud is attractive for many reasons. Letting a specialized service provider ensure reliability +and perform essential management functions can make sense, especially for organizations that find these +things hard to do on their own. Data in the cloud can also be accessed by applications running anywhere, +even on mobile devices. And given the economies of scale that a service provider enjoys, using a cloud +database may well be cheaper than doing it yourself. + +SQL Azure provides these things, together with cloud-based reporting and data synchronization services. +And while all of them are important, the place to start is with the foundation: SQL Azure Database. + +Database + +SQL Azure Database is simple to understand. As seen by an application, it provides the core database +functions of SQL Server as a cloud service. Figure 8 shows the basics of this technology. + +15 + + Figure 8: Applications access data in SQL Azure Database through Microsoft’s TDS protocol or via OData. + +An application using SQL Azure Database might run on Windows Azure, in an enterprise’s data center, on +a mobile device, or somewhere else. Wherever it runs, the application typically accesses data via a +protocol called Tabular Data Stream (TDS). This is the same protocol used to access a local SQL Server +database, and so a SQL Azure Database application can use any existing SQL Server client. This includes +Entity Framework, ADO.NET, ODBC, PHP and others. And because SQL Azure Database looks like an +ordinary SQL Server system, standard tools can also be used, including SQL Server Management Studio, +SQL Server Integration Services, and BCP for bulk data copy. Also, as Figure 8 shows, applications can +optionally access SQL Azure Database using OData. + +Each SQL Azure account can have one or more logical servers. (Note that these provide a way to organize +the data and billing for an account—they aren’t actual instances of SQL Server.) Each server can then have +multiple databases, each of which can be up to 50 gigabytes in size. A user is free to use multiple +databases if required, spreading data across them for better performance or for other reasons. It’s also +possible to store a snapshot of one SQL Azure database into another, providing a simple backup +mechanism. + +For the most part, an application using SQL Azure Database sees a familiar SQL Server environment. A few +things are omitted in the technology’s current release, however, such as the SQL Common Language +Runtime (CLR) and support for full-text search. (Microsoft says that both will be available in a future +version.) Also, because administration is handled by Microsoft, the service doesn’t expose physical +administrative functions. A customer can’t shut down the system, for example, or interact directly with +the hardware it runs on. And as you’d expect in a shared environment, a query can run for only a limited +time—no single request can take up more than a pre-defined amount of resources. + +16 + + Yet while the environment looks quite standard, the service an application gets is more robust than what +a single instance of SQL Server provides. As in Windows Azure storage, all data stored in SQL Azure +Database is replicated three times for high availability. Also like Windows Azure storage, the service +provides strong consistency: When a write returns, the data has been made persistent. The goal is to +provide reliable data storage even in the face of system and network failures. + +Whether an application needs multiple databases or just one, SQL Azure Database can help developers +address a range of scenarios. Whatever problem is being solved, the technology’s fundamental goal +remains the same: to provide a familiar, reliable, and low-cost cloud database for many kinds of +applications. + +Reporting + +Storing data in SQL Azure Database can be useful. But as soon as that data exists, there’s likely to be a +demand for reports based on that data. Meeting this demand is the purpose of SQL Azure Reporting. +Based on SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS), this technology provides a cloud-based way to create +reports. + +Given that SQL Azure Database looks like SQL Server to an application, it’s always possible to use SSRS on- +premises with the data it contains. So why bother to provide a cloud reporting service as well? SQL Azure +Reporting today targets two main scenarios: + + Reports created using SQL Azure Reporting can be published to a SQL Azure Reporting portal, letting + +users access it there, or made accessible directly via a URL. + + An ISV can embed reports published to the SQL Azure Reporting portal in any application, including +Windows Azure applications. This lets users access those reports without leaving the application. To +do this, the ISV can use the standard ReportViewer controls in Visual Studio—it’s no different from +embedding on-premises reports into applications. + +SQL Azure Reporting is designed to work with data stored in SQL Azure Database. Reports used with SQL +Azure Reporting are created on-premises, however, with Business Intelligence Developer Studio, the +Visual Studio-hosted tool that’s also used to create SSRS reports. In fact, SQL Azure Reporting relies on the +same reporting format, expressed in the Report Definition Language (RDL), used with SSRS. + +Like other aspects of SQL Azure, SQL Azure Reporting doesn’t provide all of the functions offered by SSRS +on premises. There’s currently no support for scheduling and subscriptions, for example, that let a report +be run and delivered at regular intervals. Still, cloud-based reporting services can be useful, and they’re an +important part of the SQL Azure technology family. + +Data Sync + +Storing data in SQL Azure Database can make it accessible to any application with an Internet connection. +Still, there are often situations where it makes sense to maintain a copy of this cloud-based data in some +other place. Suppose an organization needs to have an on-premises copy of the same information, for +example, for performance reasons or to ensure access if the network fails. For scenarios like this, the +ability to synchronize data in SQL Azure Database with other data stores is useful. + +17 + + It’s always possible to write synchronization code yourself using the Microsoft Sync Framework. To make +this easier, Microsoft provides SQL Azure Data Sync. Rather than requiring its user to write code, this +technology is entirely configuration-driven (although unsurprisingly, it’s built on the Microsoft Sync +Framework). As Figure 9 shows, SQL Azure Data Sync supports two options today. + +Figure 9: SQL Azure Data Sync can synchronize data between SQL Azure databases or between a SQL +Azure database and on-premises SQL Server databases. + +The two synchronization options are the following: + +Synchronizing data between a SQL Azure database and an on-premises SQL Server database. Having +an on-premises copy of cloud data might make sense for a variety of reasons. Maybe an organization +wants to make sure that this data is always available, for instance, even in the event of network +failures, or perhaps regulations require that a copy of the data always be available within a country’s +borders. And even though SQL Azure’s built-in data replication guards against hardware failures, the +data’s owner might choose to maintain an on-premises backup copy in case of administrative errors, +such as incorrect table deletions. + +Synchronizing data between SQL Azure databases in different Microsoft data centers. For example, +suppose an ISV or a global enterprise creates an application that’s used by people around the world. +To provide good performance for all of them, its creator might choose to run this application in three +different Windows Azure data centers: one each in North America, Europe, and Asia. If the +application stores data in SQL Azure Database, it might rely on SQL Azure Data Sync to keep +information synchronized across these three data centers. + +SQL Azure Data Sync uses a hub-and-spoke model. All changes are copied first to the SQL Azure database +hub, then out to the spokes (referred to as members). The members might be other SQL Azure databases + +18 + + or on-premises SQL Server databases. In both cases, the technology provides synchronization of an entire +database or just specific tables, with changes made to any copy propagated to all of the others. And while +it’s possible to initiate synchronization manually, SQL Azure Data Sync also includes a scheduling service. +This lets users schedule, say, hourly synchronization between a pair of databases. However it’s used, the +purpose is the same: providing a straightforward way to synchronize data between a SQL Azure database +in a Microsoft data center and one or more databases located somewhere else. + + WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC + +Applications exist because their business logic has value. Yet applications rely on infrastructure to provide +a foundation for that logic. A good application platform provides this infrastructure; application +developers shouldn’t need to write it themselves. + +Windows Azure AppFabric provides infrastructure for applications. The people who create applications +can benefit from different kinds of infrastructure, and so AppFabric contains various parts. This section +takes a closer look at Service Bus, Access Control, and Caching, the three components of Windows Azure +AppFabric today. + +Service Bus + +Suppose you have an application running inside your organization that exposes a Web service built with +Windows Communication Foundation (WCF). Suppose further that you’d like to connect this service +through the Internet to software running outside your organization. This client software might be running +on a cloud platform, such as Windows Azure, or inside another organization. + +At first glance, this can seem like a simple problem. Since your application provides its functionality +through Web services (either RESTful or SOAP-based), you can just make those Web services visible to the +outside world. When you actually try to do this, though, some problems appear. + +First, how can clients in other organizations find endpoints they can connect to for your service? It would +be nice to have some kind of registry where others could locate your application. And once they’ve found +it, how can requests from software in other organizations get through to your service? Network address +translation (NAT) is very common, so an application frequently doesn’t have a fixed IP address to expose +externally. And even if NAT isn’t being used, how can requests get through your firewall? It’s possible to +open firewall ports to allow access to your application, but network administrators frown on this. + +Service Bus addresses these challenges. Figure 10 shows how. + +19 + + Figure 10: A WCF service can register endpoints with Service Bus, then have clients discover and use +those endpoints to access the service. + +To begin, your WCF service registers one or more endpoints with Service Bus (step 1). For each registered +endpoint, Service Bus exposes its own corresponding endpoint (step 2). Service Bus assigns your +organization a URI root, below which you’re free to create any naming hierarchy you like. This allows your +endpoints to be assigned specific, discoverable URIs. + +When a client running in the cloud or on-premises at some other organization wishes to access your +service, it contacts the Service Bus registry (step 3) to find the endpoint, providing the endpoint’s URI. This +request uses the Atom Publishing Protocol, and it returns an AtomPub service document with references +to the endpoints Service Bus exposes on behalf of your application. Once it has these, the client can +invoke operations on the services exposed through these endpoints (step 4). For each request Service Bus +receives, it invokes the corresponding operation in the endpoint exposed by your WCF service (step 5). +(Although it’s not shown in the figure, Service Bus establishes a direct connection between an application +and its client whenever possible, making their communication more efficient.) + +There’s an obvious question here: How exactly does step 5 work? How does the request from Service Bus +back to your service deal with the challenges of NAT and firewalls? The answer is that in step 1, your +service opened a TCP connection with Service Bus for this exposed endpoint. Service Bus holds this +connection open, which solves two problems. First, NAT is no longer an issue, since traffic on the open +connection with Service Bus will always be routed to your application. Second, because the connection +was initiated from inside the firewall, there’s no problem passing information back to the application via +this connection—the firewall won’t block this traffic. + +20 + + Along with making communication easier, Service Bus can also improve security. Because clients now see +only an IP address provided by Service Bus, there’s no need to expose any IP addresses from within your +organization. This effectively makes your application anonymous, since the outside world can’t see it. +Service Bus acts as an external DMZ, providing a layer of indirection to deter attackers. + +While an application that exposes its services via Service Bus is typically implemented using WCF, clients +can be built with WCF or other technologies, such as Java. However they’re created, these clients can +make requests via TCP, HTTP, or HTTPS. Applications are also free to use their own security mechanisms, +such as encryption, to shield their communication from attackers. + +Service Bus provides a few more useful features, including these: + +Support for message buffers, which act like simple queues. Rather than require a client to make +direct calls to a service, the client can place a message of up to 256 kilobytes into a message buffer. +The message is persisted to disk—it’s durable—and the service can then read this message at some +later time. And as usual in the Windows Azure platform, the persisted messages are replicated to +guard against failures. + + The ability for multiple WCF services to listen on the same URI. Service Bus will then randomly spread +client requests across all of the listening services. The goal is to provide both load balancing and fault +tolerance for the WCF services. + +Exposing applications to the outside world isn’t as simple as it might seem. The intent of Service Bus is to +make implementing these interactions as straightforward as possible. + +Access Control + +Working with identity is a fundamental part of most distributed applications. The modern approach to +this, called claims-based identity, lets a user send a token full of claims that contain identity information. +One claim might contain the user’s name, for example, while another contains her age or a group she +belongs to. An application can use the claims in a token to decide what the user is allowed to do or in +other ways. + +In a claims-based world, tokens are issued by identity providers (IdPs). Some IdPs, such as Active Directory +Federation Services (AD FS) 2.0, exist inside organizations. Others, such as Windows Live ID and Google +Accounts, are accessible to anyone via the Internet. Each application can decide which IdPs it trusts and +thus which tokens it’s willing to accept. For example, an application running inside your company might +only accept tokens issued by your own AD FS server, while an application running on the Internet might +accept tokens issued by, say, Google and Facebook. + +Yet different IdPs use different token formats, and they represent claims in different ways. An application +that directly accepts identities from Google, Facebook, and Yahoo, for instance, would need to handle +these differences itself. But why do this? Why not instead create an intermediary that can generate a +single token format with a common representation of claims? Doing this would make life simpler for the +people who create applications, since they now need to handle only one kind of token. + +The Access Control service does exactly this, providing an intermediary in the cloud for working with +claims-based identity. Figure 11 shows how it works. + +21 + + Figure 11: The Access Control service makes it easier for applications to accept identity information +issued by different identity providers. + +As the figure shows, an application that relies on Access Control can run either on-premises or in the +cloud. In either case, the process begins when a user attempts to access this application via a browser +(step 1). The application then redirects the browser to an IdP whose token this application will accept. The +user authenticates herself with this IdP, such as by entering a username and password, and the IdP +returns a token containing claims about her (step 2). + +Next, the user’s browser sends the IdP token to Access Control (step 3). Access Control validates the +token, making sure that it really was issued by this IdP, then creates a new token according to whatever +rules have been defined for this application (step 4). Access Control contains a rules engine, allowing each +application’s administrator to define how tokens from various IdPs should be transformed into an Access +Control token. For example, if different IdPs use different formats for representing usernames, Access +Control rules can transform all of these into a common username string. Access Control then sends this +new token back to the browser (step 5), which submits it to the application (step 6). Once it has the +Access Control token, the application verifies that it really was issued by Access Control, then uses the +claims it contains (step 7). + +While this process might seem a little complicated, it actually makes life significantly simpler for the +creator of the application. Rather than handle diverse tokens containing various claims, the application +can accept identities issued by multiple identity providers while still receiving only a single token with +familiar claims. And rather than require each application to be configured to trust various IdPs, these trust +relationships are instead maintained by Access Control—an application need only trust it. + +22 + + As Figure 11 shows, Access Control has built-in support for several identity providers, including AD FS 2.0, +Windows Live ID, Google, Yahoo, and Facebook. It can also work with any IdP that supports OpenID. +Browsers and other clients can request Access Control tokens using either OAuth 2 or WS-Trust, and these +tokens can have various formats, including SAML 1.1, SAML 2.0, and Simple Web Token (SWT). And to +create applications that accept Access Control tokens, Windows developers can use Windows Identity +Foundation (WIF). (It’s worth pointing out, however, that nothing about Access Control is tied to +Windows—it could just as well be used by a Linux application that accepted only Google and Facebook +identities.) + +Working with identity is important in nearly every distributed application. The goal of Access Control is to +make it easier for developers to create secure applications that accept identities from diverse providers. +By putting this service in the cloud, Microsoft has made it available to any application running on any +platform. + +Caching + +For many applications, one of the most effective ways to improve performance is by caching frequently +accessed data. Since applications tend to use the same information over and over, making this +information more readily accessible can make the application faster. Doing this is the purpose of Windows +Azure AppFabric Caching. Figure 12 illustrates the idea. + +Figure 12: Windows Azure AppFabric Caching speeds up access to frequently accessed data for +Windows Azure applications. + +23 + + The Caching service provides a distributed cache for Windows Azure applications, along with a library to +access this cache. As Figure 12 suggests, the service includes a local cache that can keep a copy of recently +accessed data items in each of an application’s role instances. If a data item the application needs isn’t +found in the local cache, the cache library automatically contacts the shared cache provided by the +Caching service. As the figure shows, this cache is spread across a number of Windows Azure instances, +each holding different cached data. This diversity isn’t visible to applications using the cache, however. An +application just requests a data item, then lets the cache find it (if it’s in the cache) and return it from +whatever instance contains it. + +Recently accessed data isn’t automatically cached, however. Instead, the application explicitly inserts data +items in the cache, such as by using the Caching API. It’s also possible to configure an ASP.NET application +running on Windows Azure to store Session object data in the Caching service, speeding it up without +changing any of its code. + +Windows Server AppFabric, the on-premises analog to Windows Azure AppFabric, also provides a Caching +service. In fact, the two are very similar. The biggest different is that unlike its on-premises counterpart, +Windows Azure AppFabric Caching is a service—there’s no need to configure servers and administer the +cache. Instead, all of this is handled automatically by the service itself. And the cloud Caching service is +multi-tenant, so each application using it gets its own instance. Because the application must authenticate +itself to this instance, data held in the Caching service isn’t accessible to other applications. + +Caching can make applications faster and more scalable with little effort from developers, and so using it +makes sense. By providing caching as a service, Windows Azure AppFabric Caching makes this easier to +do. + +WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE + +Cloud platforms are useful, but they’re just a means to an end. The real goal is offering applications and +data that provide value for people. Since the Windows Azure platform provides a foundation for both, +why shouldn’t it also include a way for people to find the applications and data that they need? + +The Windows Azure Marketplace is designed to address this need. Its two components, AppMarket and +DataMarket, let users find, try, and purchase applications and data, respectively. While both are +important, DataMarket will appear first, and so what follows focuses on this aspect of the Marketplace. + +Buying applications is common today—nearly every organization does it. Buying data is less common, but +it’s no less important. Many firms sell many different kinds of data, including demographic information, +financial information, legal information, and much more. Yet using purchased data typically requires +figuring out whether the data you need exists, finding a firm that offers it, then determining whether their +data meets your needs. + +All of this is more difficult than it needs to be. Why not create one place where customers can find all +kinds of data from all kinds of content providers? Why not let them examine the data to make sure it +meets their needs, then purchase what they need right then and there? The DataMarket component of +Windows Azure Marketplace was created to do these things. Figure 13 shows its main components. + +24 + + Figure 13: Built on Windows Azure, the DataMarket allows access to content partner datasets stored in +Windows Azure, SQL Azure, or externally. + +As the figure suggests, both people and applications can access information through DataMarket. Using a +Windows Azure-based application called the Service Explorer, a user can see what datasets are available, +then purchase what she needs. Once this is done, applications can access that data using RESTful or OData +requests. The datasets made available by DataMarket can be stored on the Windows Azure platform itself +using Windows Azure Storage or SQL Azure Database. They can also be stored externally, such as in a data +center owned by the content provider. There’s no requirement to put everything in the cloud. + +For customers, DataMarket provides a single place to find, buy, and access a variety of commercial +datasets. For content providers—the owners of those data sets—DataMarket offers a chance to expose +their offerings to more customers through Microsoft’s cloud platform. While content providers set prices +for their data, DataMarket provides a billing service that frees them from dealing directly with customers. +Microsoft will also vet the quality of the content providers, limiting DataMarket initially to just the top five +providers in a particular industry. + +Applications are free to use purchased data in any way that the content provider’s license allows. Users of +Microsoft Excel 2010, for example, can access DataMarket’s information directly using an Excel add-in or +use the PowerPivot for Excel support for OData to access information from DataMarket for data analysis. +It’s also possible to combine data purchased from DataMarket with your own data, such as for reports +created using SQL Server Reporting Services. + +25 + + Getting business value from information technology requires the right applications, but it also requires +the right data. By making it easier to discover, evaluate, and buy commercially available datasets, +DataMarket intends to make it simpler for organizations to find and use the information they need. + +LOOKING AHEAD + +Microsoft has announced a number of updates that it plans to add to the Windows Azure platform in the +near future. They include the following: + + The Windows Azure Platform Appliance: Microsoft has announced plans to offer a Windows Azure +Platform Appliance, allowing hosters and enterprises to run Windows Azure in their own data +centers. Because Windows Azure requires a specific hardware configuration—it’s not just software— +this appliance will include servers, networking, and storage, all running Windows Azure. And while it +will initially be targeted only at large organizations, Microsoft’s goal is eventually to make the +Windows Azure Platform Appliance useful for smaller organizations as well. + + CDN dynamic content caching: Today, the Windows Azure CDN works only with blob data. This +forthcoming functionality will let the CDN also cache content created dynamically by a Windows +Azure application. + + VM role snapshotting: In its first release, the Windows Azure VM role doesn’t save any changes made +to the OS volume while it’s running. Snapshotting will change this, providing a way to periodically +save the state of this volume to persistent storage. + + Better Java support: While Windows Azure can run Java applications today, Microsoft plans to make +this better. The coming improvements include better Java performance, stronger support for Eclipse- +based tools, and a more complete set of Java libraries for Windows Azure. + +Support for composite applications: To make it easier to build Windows Azure applications by +combining existing components and services, Windows Azure AppFabric will add a composition +model. Accompanied by runtime services and a Visual Studio-based designer, this model will let +developers work with the various parts of an application as a single logical entity throughout its +lifecycle. + + All of these changes target the same goal: making the Windows Azure platform useful in a broader range +of scenarios. + +CONCLUSIONS + +The truth is evident: Cloud computing is here. For developers, taking advantage of the cloud means using +cloud platforms. With the Windows Azure platform, Microsoft presents a range of options addressing a +variety of needs: + + Windows Azure provides a computing and storage environment in the cloud. + +SQL Azure provides a relational DBMS in the cloud, together with reporting and data synchronization. + +26 + + Windows Azure AppFabric offers cloud-based infrastructure supporting both cloud and on-premises + +applications. + + Windows Azure Marketplace is an online store for finding and purchasing datasets from content + +providers, together with a forthcoming store for cloud applications. + +These approaches address a variety of requirements, and not every developer will use all of them. Yet +whether you work for an ISV, a systems integrator, or an enterprise, some cloud platform services are +likely to be useful for applications your organization creates. A new world is unfolding; prepare to be part +of it. + +ABOUT THE AUTHOR + +David Chappell is Principal of Chappell & Associates (www.davidchappell.com) in San Francisco, California. +Through his speaking, writing, and consulting, he helps people around the world understand, use, and +make better decisions about new technologies. + +27 + diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_2.md b/q12/random_k4/random_2.md index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..41b128d8d6a3808185f462ec8b46e331c45f6af0 100644 --- a/q12/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q12/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,5479 +1,448 @@ -Owner’s Manual +Amazfit GTR User Manual + +Content + +Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation ............................................................................. 2 +Basic Operations ....................................................................................................................... 2 +Functions Navigation ................................................................................................................ 2 +Watch Wearing and Charging ............................................................................................................ 4 +Use of Functions ............................................................................................................................... 5 +Device Pairing and Unpairing ................................................................................................... 5 +Control Shortcut Menu .............................................................................................................. 7 +Flashlight ........................................................................................................................... 7 +Brightness adjustment ....................................................................................................... 8 +DND mode ........................................................................................................................ 8 +Battery saver mode ............................................................................................................ 9 +Lock screen ..................................................................................................................... 10 +Replace the Watch Face .......................................................................................................... 11 +Status ....................................................................................................................................... 11 +Heart Rate ............................................................................................................................... 12 +Workout ................................................................................................................................... 13 +Workout Record ...................................................................................................................... 14 +Weather ................................................................................................................................... 15 +Music....................................................................................................................................... 16 +Notifications ............................................................................................................................ 17 +Alarm ...................................................................................................................................... 18 +Event Reminder....................................................................................................................... 20 +Timer ....................................................................................................................................... 22 +Count Down ............................................................................................................................ 23 +Find Device ............................................................................................................................. 24 +Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude ............................................................................................... 25 +Settings .................................................................................................................................... 27 +Workout Function ........................................................................................................................... 29 +Workout Positioning................................................................................................................ 30 +During Workouts ..................................................................................................................... 31 +Swimming ............................................................................................................................... 32 +Workout Reminder .................................................................................................................. 33 +Workout Pause and End .......................................................................................................... 33 +Workout Settings ..................................................................................................................... 34 + + Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation + +Amazfit GTR features one AMOLED touch screen and two physical buttons. + +Basic Operations + +Slide left and right or up and down: You can switch between different function pages. +Tap and exit: You can tap to enter a specific function page and also operate the tap tips on that page. +You can slide right to quickly return to the upper-level menu after tapping to enter a certain function +page. +Button on the upper right: +① Short press to light up the screen. +② Short press the watch face page to close the screen. +③ Short press other pages to quickly return to the watch face. +④ Long press for 10s to shut down. +Button on the bottom right: +① Short press to light up the screen. +② Short press the watch face page to quickly enter the workout list. (This function can be +customized and used to short press to quickly start other functions) +You can long press either of the two buttons above to exit the battery saver mode, suspend the +workout, and close the alarm alert. + +Functions Navigation + +Pull the watch face down: You can then enter the shortcut control menu, which allows you to quickly +open the flashlight, set brightness, control the DND mode, enter the battery saver mode, and lock +the screen. + +Slide the watch face left and right: You can then quickly enter Status, Heart rate, + + Slide the watch face up: You can then enter the function list. + + Watch Wearing and Charging + +Daily wearing: During daily use, it is recommended to wear the watch with a moderate tightness at +a distance two fingers far from your wrist to ensure that the optical heart rate monitor works properly. +Wearing during workouts: During workouts, it is recommended to wear the watch comfortably and +ensure a tight fit without slipping. Being too tight or too loose may cause the inaccuracy of detected +workout data, so avoid doing this. +Charging + + +The watch charger's USB port needs to be plugged into the USB-supported device, such as +socket, PC, power bank. + + When placing the watch into the power socket, it's required to keep the watch in a proper +direction and position. Be sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch are closely +connected to the charging base. +The screen will display the charging reminder when the watch is placed properly. + + + + Use of Functions + +Download the Amazfit App via the mobile phone before using Amazfit GTR. You cannot use the +entire watch functions nor save and upload watch data to your personal cloud account until the +watch is paired by using the Amazfit App. + +Device Pairing and Unpairing + +Download the Amazfit App from Google Play Store or App Store and register an account or log in. + + Open the Amazfit App and choose "Profile – My devices – Watch – Amazfit GTR" to search the +device nearby. +Please tap the check-mark when it shows a pairing request on the watch. + +If a device can be paired by scanning a QR code, with the Amazfit App on, you can directly pair the +device by scanning the QR code on your watch. +After paired, the watch usually needs to be upgraded. Wait for upgrading with patience. With the +mobile network and Bluetooth on, you also need to keep the watch close to the mobile phone, so as +to ensure a successful upgrade. + + After the watch is paired and upgraded, its functions are available. Meanwhile, the Amazfit App +allows for the watch function-specific operations and settings. +To unpair the watch, open the Amazfit App, tap "Profile – My devices – Amazfit GTR" and then +swipe up and tap the "Unpair" button. -Models -14, 16, 17, 18 +Control Shortcut Menu -Refrigerators +Pulling down on the watch face page can quickly open the control shortcut menu page. -TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST +Flashlight +Tapping the flashlight icon can open the flashlight function. The white background on the watch +screen helps light up a small area at night. You can close the enabled flashlight function by sliding -Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR + right or pressing the button on the upper right. - Congratulations! +Brightness adjustment +Tapping on the brightness adjustment button can go to the brightness adjustment settings. +Auto brightness: The watch will automatically adjust the screen brightness upon ambient light. +Manual brightness: You can tailor the screen brightness as you wish. -Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our -quality products and we are committed to -providing dependable service. You’ll see it in -this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll -hear it in the friendly voices of our customer -service department. +DND mode +Enable DND: With the DND mode enabled, the watch will not vibrate when receiving any message +pushed by the mobile phone. +Time DND: You can tailor the time period during which the DND mode changes from automatically +enabled to disabled. -Best of all, you’ll experience these values -each time you use your refrigerator. That’s -important, because your new refrigerator will -be part of your family for many years. And we -hope you will be part of ours for a long time -to come. + Smart DND: After you fall asleep with the watch, the watch will automatically enable the DND +mode. +Disable DND: The DND mode is disabled, so the watch will vibrate when receiving notifications. -We appreciate your purchase, and hope you -will continue to rely on us whenever you -need quality appliances for your home. +Battery saver mode +The battery saver mode can minimize the power consumption of the watch and improve its +endurance. With the battery saver mode on, the watch can only record steps and sleep time, with +other functions disabled. -Important! + To exit the battery saver mode, long press any button on the watch. -Fill out and return the Consumer Product -Registration Card that is packed with this -product. If you cannot find it, please send -in the duplicate card printed in the back of -this manual. +Lock screen +With the lock screen function on, you can unlock the watch to enter the watch face page only by +using the watch button. This can prevent any error caused by mistouch. To close the lock screen +function, tap the lock screen button again to close this function. -Write the model and serial -numbers here. + Replace the Watch Face -# +To replace the watch face on the watch: Long press the watch face page for 2s, or go to "Settings – +Watch face settings", slide left and right to scan the watch face, and tap one to complete replacement. +To replace the watch face on the App: Tap "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch face settings" to +download more watch faces on the Watch Face Store. -# +Status -You can find them on a label on the -upper left side of the fresh food -compartment. +Sliding left on the watch face page can enable you to enter the status page which displays the current +steps and goal completed. Tapping the status entry can enable you to enter the details page which -Staple sales slip or cancelled -check here. + shows you the steps, distance, calories and idle data. -Proof of the original purchase date -is needed to obtain service under -the warranty. +You can also enter the details page by sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Status". -2 +Heart Rate - AService Partnership. +Sliding left on the watch face can enable you to enter the heart rate page, and then the watch +automatically starts to measure the heart rate. During measurement, it is required to properly wear +the watch and keep the back of the watch fairly close to your skin until the watch can measure a +stable heart rate. +To enable the all-day measure function, open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – +Heart rate detection", and choose to enable automatic heart rate detection. -We stand behind our products with -unmatched quality service. However, did -you know that most questions result from -simple problems that you can easily -fix yourself in just a few minutes? This -Owner’s Manual can tell you how. + Notes: With the all-day measure function on, the watch will measure the heart rate at regular time. +Sliding right on the watch face can make the last heart rate value visible. You can enter the all-day +heart rate details page by tapping it. -Read this Manual -Inside you will find many -helpful hints on how to use and -maintain your refrigerator -properly. Just a little preventive -care on your part can save you a -great deal of time and money -over the life of your refrigerator. +Workout -Review the Section on -Troubleshooting Tips +Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, +Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing, +and Exercise. See the "Workout" section for more details about the functions of different workout +types. -You’ll find many answers to -common problems here. -If you review our chart of -Troubleshooting Tips first, -you may not need to call for -service at all. + Workout Record -If You Need Service +The workout data on the watch will be stored in workout records, which are shown from the latest +to the earliest. Tapping a specific workout record will make the workout details visible. The visible +details vary in workout type. -If you do need service, you can -relax knowing help is only a -phone call away. A list of toll-free -customer service numbers is -included in the back section. -Or you can always call the -GE Answer Center® at -800.626.2000, 24 hours a day, -7 days a week. +The workout record not uploaded to the App will be marked with a little red dot before it. Open the +App to synchronize data timely to avoid the loss of workout records. -Safety Information -Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4 -Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 -How to Connect Electricity . . . .6 -Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7 -Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7 + To delete a workout record on the watch, tap to enter the workout record details page, slide up to +the bottom of the page, and then tap the delete button. -Operating Instructions +Weather -Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8 -Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10 -Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12 -Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13 -Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16 +Tapping the weather function can give you access to the current weather conditions and the weather +forecast. If weather data are invisible, you should open the App and connect the device to update +the data. -Installation Instructions + Music -Preparing to -Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18 -Water Line Installation . . .19–23 -Reversing the -Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29 +With the Bluetooth, the watch can suspend or play the music on the mobile music player, switch +between songs, and adjust the volume. + Open the mobile music player first, and then enable the music function on the watch. + + -Troubleshooting Tips +If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App. +If you are using an Android device, you need to connect the watch with the Amazfit App and +also enable the notification reading permission on the App. -Normal Operating Sounds . . .30 -Before You -Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33 +Notes: The compatibility of the Android mobile phone system and the openness of different music +players may to a certain extent affect the music control function of the watch. -Customer Service -Product Registration . . . . . . . .37 -Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39 -Service Telephone -Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover + Notifications -3 +Enable notifications +During use, you need to enable the corresponding "App alerts" on the App, and keep the watch and +the mobile phone connected. You can also enable the incoming SMS and incoming call alerts as you +wish. + + -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n +If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App. +If you are using an Android device, you need to keep the App running in the background or +include the App into the self-starting whitelist, so as to ensure the mobile phone can send the +alert to the watch. -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +View notifications +1. -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +In the case of an incoming notification, the watch will automatically light up the screen and +display the content. -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s +2. You can view the unread notification in the notification list and tap any notification to enter the -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e +notification details page. - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S + Delete notifications + -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O +The read notification on the watch or the mobile phone will be automatically deleted from the +notification list on the watch. +To manually delete the notification on the watch, slide left on the notification to be deleted and +tap the delete button. -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I + -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr +Alarm -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C +Amazfit GTR supports creating and managing the alarm on the watch. You can also create a watch +alarm on the Amazfit App. +Tapping the create button on the watch alarm function page can enable you to set the alarm time and -4 + cycle. After saved, the alarm can be opened and closed in the alarm list. +To create an alarm via the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch alarm" and add an +alarm upon the tips on the page. -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! +Alarm alert +In the case of a watch alarm alert, you can choose to close it or remind you later. -Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as -described in this Owner’s Manual. +To close the alarm, long press any button for 2s within the duration of the alarm alert. -SAFETY PRECAUTIONS -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions -should be followed, including the following: + To make a delayed alert, you can, within the duration of the alarm alert, tap the "Z" button at the +bottom. Then, the alarm will remind you 10min later. -n Keep fingers out of the -“pinch point” areas; -clearances between the -doors and between the doors -and cabinet are necessarily -small. Be careful closing -doors when children are in -the area. +Event Reminder -n Unplug the refrigerator +You need to create and manage the event reminder via the Amazfit App. The watch will display +your to-do list and vibrate to remind you in the set time. +Open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Event reminder", and create the event +reminder upon the tips on the page. +An alert will pop up on the watch when the time set for the event arrives. Tap the "×" button at the +bottom to close the alert. -before cleaning and making -repairs. + The watch supports modifying and deleting the event reminder. +To modify the event reminder, tap the right arrow on the event reminder list page to modify the +event reminder date and time. -NOTE: We strongly recommend -that any servicing be performed -by a qualified individual. +To delete the event reminder, slide right on the event to be deleted and tap the trash icon to delete it. -n Turning the control to the + Timer -OFF position does not remove -power to the light circuit. -n Do not refreeze frozen foods +The timer on the watch supports one hundredth of a second. To enable the timer, pull up the app list +on the watch face and choose the timer app. + + During timing, you can also count the number of times by tapping the button on the bottom -which have thawed -completely. +Tapping the start button can activate the timer to time it right away. -n This refrigerator must be -properly installed and -located in accordance with -the Installation Instructions -before it is used. +left on the watch screen (up to 99 times of such operation), +and suspend the current timer by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen. -n Do not allow children to + + When the timer pauses, you can reset it by tapping the button on the bottom left on the watch +screen, and resume timing by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen. -climb, stand or hang on the -shelves in the refrigerator. -They could damage the -refrigerator and seriously -injure themselves. -n Do not touch the cold -surfaces in the freezer -compartment, particularly -when hands are damp or wet. -Skin may stick to these -extremely cold surfaces. -n Do not store or use gasoline -or other flammable vapors -and liquids in the vicinity of -this or any other appliance. + Count Down -n In refrigerators with +To enable the count down, pull up the app list on the watch face and choose the count down app. +By default, the watch supports the shortcut count down of 1min, 3min, 5min, 10min, 15min, 20min, +30min, and 60min. You can enable the count down function right away by tapping it. +A custom count down function is available, which ranges from 1min to 23h and 59min. -automatic icemakers, avoid -contact with the moving parts -of the ejector mechanism, or -with the heating element that -releases the cubes. Do not -place fingers or hands on the -automatic icemaking -mechanism while the -refrigerator is plugged in. + You can suspend, resume or stop the count down function anytime when it operates. When time's +up, the watch will vibrate to remind you. You can close the count down function by tapping the "×" +button at the bottom. - DANGER! RISK OF CHILD +Find Device -ENTRAPMENT -PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR +Amazfit GTR supports finding the device via the Bluetooth. To enable this function, slide up the +app list on the watch face page and tap the find device function. + -Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of -the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still -dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.” -If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please -follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents. +To activate the find device function, you need to keep the Amazfit App running and ensure the +watch is connected to the mobile phone. Otherwise the function is not available. -Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator -or Freezer: + On the find page, the watch will automatically find the device. If no device is found after 60s, -n Take off the doors. -n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not + a failure prompt will display and then you can try again. -easily climb inside. + When found, the mobile phone will beep. You can close the ring on the mobile phone by +tapping the tip button on the watch. Meanwhile, the mobile phone will produce a message on +the notification bar. Tapping the message can draw back the Amazfit App and close the ring on +the mobile phone. -CFC Disposal +Notes: If you wish to use the find device function anytime, you can include the Amazfit App into +the built-in self-starting whitelist and keep it running in the background. In addition, the watch is +required to be connected to the mobile phone, otherwise it is unable to find the mobile phone. -Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used -CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm -stratospheric ozone. +Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude -If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make -sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal -by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this -CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and -imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean -Air Act. +Amazfit GTR supports the compass function. When the compass page opens, the watch +automatically detects the current orientation and degree. If needed, you can wear the watch and +calibrate the compass by filling out that circle with figure 8 movements in the air, until the watch +vibrates. Then the compass function can be reused. -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n + Sliding up on the compass page can enable you to enter the atmospheric pressure page. The +barometer on the watch displays the current air pressure in real time. -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s + Sliding up on the air pressure page can enable you to enter the altitude page. The altitude requires +double calibration of watch barometer and GPS. If you want more accurate altitude data, try to get +the satellite positioning in an open area as soon as possible. -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s +Settings -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s +The watch settings page includes some watch settings and built-in control functions. +Watch face settings: You can quickly switch between watch faces. -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e + Screen-on duration: You can control the screen-on duration of the watch for 8s (by default) to 15s +(max). -5 +Quick start: You can short press the button on the bottom right to quickly start one watch function +(by default, workout list). - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S +System: It supports viewing the firmware version and regulatory information, and controlling the +actions of closing and rebooting the watch and performing the factory reset. -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O + Workout Function -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I +Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, +Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing, +and Exercise. And the workout types like Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, Open water +swim, Climb, Trail run, and Skiing support recording GPS-enabled workout tracks. -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr + There are two approaches to enabling the workout function on the watch: + -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C +If the workout list is set for quick start, then you can quickly enter the workout list by short +pressing the button on the bottom right on the watch face page. By default, the last workout +type displays. +Sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Workout" can enable you to enter the workout +list page and choose the workout you want to start. -6 + -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! +Workout Positioning -HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY -Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third -(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety, -this appliance must be properly grounded. +If you choose to start Outdoor running, you'd better go to the open area before workouts, which is +conducive to rapid GPS positioning. -The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong -(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong -(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric -shock hazard from this appliance. + If it takes a long time to process positioning, it may be because the buildings nearby block satellite +signals, or because the watch is disconnected to the App for a long time, causing the AGPS to be +not upgraded. You can open the Amazfit App, connect it to the watch, and try again after the AGPS +is updated. +It is recommended to ensure GPS positioning is processed successfully before the outdoor workout. +If you start the workout during positioning, the workout track cannot be recorded and the recorded +workout data will not be accurate. +After GPS positioning is processed successfully, the "GO" icon will be lit up and you can tap it to +start the workout. -Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician -to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. +During Workouts -Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your -personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a -properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet. +During workouts, the watch will display the current workout data in real time, such as time, distance, +pace/speed, and heart rate. After the watch screen goes off, the screen can be lit up again by lifting +the wrist or touching the screen. +Sliding right during workouts can enable you to view the time, date, and watch power. -The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual -electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating -plate. + Swimming -This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading -house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from -overheated wires. +With the swimming workout enabled, the watch will automatically lock the screen to avoid water +drops interfering with the screen display during the workout. To unlock the screen, you can short +press any button on the watch, and the screen will be locked again after the watch screen goes off. -Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord. -Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet. + Workout Reminder -Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become -frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or -abrasion damage along its length or at either end. +The workout reminder on the watch varies in workout type. For the workout types Running, Cycling, +and Walking, the alert will be vibrated once per kilometer by default. You can also set the alerts for +other workout types before workouts. See the "Workout Settings" section for more details. -When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to -roll over or damage the power cord. +Workout Pause and End -USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -adapter plug. +With the auto pause function on, the watch will automatically pause when the workout end is +detected. When the workout resumes, the watch will automatically end the pause status and resume +recording the workout performance. -However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a -temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong -wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local -hardware stores. + Tapping any button during a workout can suspend the workout. - The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in -the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the -power cord. +Tapping the right button can cancel the pause and resume the workout. +Tapping the left button can end the current workout and save the workout performance. -When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold -the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord -plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground -terminal is very likely to break with repeated use. +Workout Settings -If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator -until a proper ground has been established. +Before workouts, you can set some relevant functions. +The workout goal supports three types: mileage, duration, and calories. When the set goal is +achieved, the watch will vibrate to remind you. -Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not -ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the -wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit -checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. + The workout reminder supports five types: distance, pace, safe heart rate, heart rate zone, and pace +With a reminder set, the watch will vibrate to remind you as long as the set value is reached during +workouts. -USE OF EXTENSION CORDS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -extension cord. + With the auto pause on, the watch will automatically detect the workout status. When the workout +is stopped, the watch will automatically suspend the current exercise. And the watch will re-record +the data when the workout is resumed. +The real-time diagram supports demonstrating the real-time heart rate and pace. With the real-time +diagram on, a curve is drawn for the fluctuations of the heart rate or pace during workouts. -However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely -necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance -extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that -the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and -120 volts. - -REMEMBER… -Your continued health and safety are important to us. - -Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully. - -We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our -family. -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -7 - - About the temperature control dial. - -Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments— -fresh food and freezer. - -9 - -OFF - -7 - -5 - -3 - -1 - -Control Settings -Temperature Control Dial - -The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF. -1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5. - -After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary. - -Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn -the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs. - -Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -8 - - About the fresh food compartment shelves. - -Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves. -Not all features are on all models. - -2 Lift up and out - -1 Tilt up - -Half-Width Shelves - -One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall -support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track -on the rear cabinet wall. - -To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support -and out of the track. - -To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front -raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track, -then lower the shelf onto the support. - -NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to -hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is -designed to hook into the left-hand slot. - -Full-Width Shelves - -Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary -tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves. -These shelves can be moved to another place in the -fresh food compartment. - -The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed -correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before -coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not -tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it. - -To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf -and pull forward. - -To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food -compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of -the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it -out. - -9 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - About the freezer compartment shelves. - -Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf. - -Plug Supports - -Ice-Tray Shelf - -To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf -off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of -the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the -pins from the holes in the cabinet wall. - -(cid:49) - -(cid:50) - -Step Shelf - -To remove the step shelf: - -1 -2 - -3 - -Lift left side of shelf slightly. - -Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes -in the cabinet wall. - -Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and -take it out. - -To replace the step shelf: - -1 - -2 - -With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into -holes in cabinet wall. - -Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right -ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower -shelf into place. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -10 - - About the storage drawers. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Fruit and Vegetable Drawers - -Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the -drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry. - -Utility Drawer - -The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful -location for your family’s needs. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -11 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -12 - -About storage drawer and cover removal. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Drawer and Cover Removal - -Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to -help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers -can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly -while pulling drawers past the stoplocation. - -Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover - -To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it -forward, tilt it and take it out. - -Twin Drawer With Glass Cover - -To remove: - -1 -2 - -Remove the drawers. - -Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the -same time, pull it forward as far as it will come. - -Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover -with hot water because the extreme temperature -difference may cause it to break. - -3 - -Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass -cover before you take out the drawer frame.) - -Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back, -pull it forward, tilt it and take it out. - -To replace: - -Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each -side and back. - -Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly -into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the -front into place. - -Replace the drawers. - -1 - -2 - -3 - - About the automatic icemaker. - -A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice. - -Icemaker - -Feeler arm -in the STOP -(up) position - -Ice Storage Bin - -Automatic Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle— -approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period, -depending on freezer compartment temperature, room -temperature, number of door openings and other use -conditions. - -If the refrigerator is operated before the water -connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm -in the STOP (up) position. - -Feeler arm in the -ON (down) position - -When the refrigerator has been connected to the water -supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position. - -The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to -freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 -hours to begin making ice cubes. - -Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water -line to clear. - -Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler -arm. - -It is normal for several cubes to be joined together. - -If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become -cloudy and taste stale. - -Icemaker Accessory Kit - -If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an -automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra -cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit -needed for your model. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -13 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Cleaning the Outside - -The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth -dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth. - -Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened -with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and -polish with a clean, soft cloth. - -Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may -leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered -cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can -scratch and weaken the paint finish. - -Cleaning the Inside - -To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh -food and freezer compartments. - -Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring -excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around -switches, lights or controls. - -Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans -and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry. - -Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the -doors. - -After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly -to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets -from sticking and bending out of shape. - -Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the -extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves -carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter. - -Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -14 - - Under the Refrigerator - -For most efficient operation, keep the area under the -refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to -OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust. - -Clean the condenser coils at least -once a year. - -For best results, use a brush specially designed for this -purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores. - -Behind the Refrigerator - -Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All -types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned -coverings and those with embossed surfaces. - -Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator -counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull -the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it -straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in -damage to the floor covering or refrigerator. - -When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power -cord or icemaker supply line (on some models). - -After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise -until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -15 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Light Bulb Replacement - -To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its -electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an -appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage. - -Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit. - -Preparing for Vacation - -For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the -refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position, -and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the -doors open. - -Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut -off the water supply to the refrigerator. - -If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified -servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent -serious property damage due to flooding. - -Preparing to Move - -Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping -them securely in place to prevent damage. - -Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -16 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models) - -If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an -icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line. - -A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings -and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from -Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -Refrigerator Location - -Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below -60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain -proper temperatures. - -Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded. - -Clearances - -Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air -circulation and plumbing and electrical connections: -3/4† (19 mm) -1† (25 mm) -1† (25 mm) - -Sides - -Back - -Top - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -17 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Rollers and Leveling Legs - -Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They -firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are -opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just -enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway. - -Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to -lower it. - -Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the -wall for cleaning. - -Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred -from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the -legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -18 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Before You Begin -This water line installation is not warranted by the -refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these -instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive -water damage. - -Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house -plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead -to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to -correct water hammer before installing the water supply -line to the refrigerator. - -To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the -water line to the hot water line. - -If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water -line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP -(up) position. - -Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where -temperatures fall below freezing. - -When using any electrical device (such as a power drill) -during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired -in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock. - -All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing -code requirements. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -19 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -What You Will Need -To determine how much copper tubing you need: - -Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the -refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm). -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) -coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow -the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. -n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and -fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer -or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between - -20 and 120 p.s.i. - -n Power drill. - -n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to -the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square. - -Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is -under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle -with age and crack, resulting in water leakage. - -n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)— - -to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the -refrigerator water valve. - -n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will - -need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect -the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared -fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting. -n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve -should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of -5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle- -type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before -purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your -local plumbing codes. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -20 - - Shut Off the Main Water Supply - -Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water. - -Install the Shutoff Valve -1 -2 - -Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line. - -Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect -into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a -horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at -the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe. -Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs -resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe. - -3 - -4 -5 - -Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp. - -Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell. - -Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing. - -Pipe Clamp - -Washer - -Inlet End - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Vertical Cold Water Pipe - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -21 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve - -Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator. - -Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the -refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible. - -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about -10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and -connect it to the shutoff valve. - -Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut -securely. - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Compression Nut - -Packing -Nut - -Outlet Valve - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing -1 - -Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water -is clear. - -2 - -Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has -been flushed through the tubing. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -22 - - Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator - -Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the -refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet. - -We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles -that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water -line near the refrigerator. - -1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as -shown. - -Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as -possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting. - -Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical -position. You may need to pry open the clamp. - -1/4† Copper Tubing - -Tubing Clamp - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -1/4† Compression Nut - -Refrigerator Connection - -Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve - -Tighten any connections that leak. - -Plug In the Refrigerator - -Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of -the refrigerator or against the wall. - -Push the refrigerator back to the wall. - -Start the Icemaker - -Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will -not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.) -or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm -is in the ON(down) position. - -NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from -the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again. - -23 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - Reversing the door swing. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Important Notes -When reversing the door swing : - -n Read the instructions all the way through before starting. -n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint. -n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the - -wrong places. - -n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors. -IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until -door-swing reversal is completed. - -These instructions are for changing the hinges from the -right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the -hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions -and reverse all references to left and right. - -Tools Required -n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver -n Masking tape -n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires -n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver -n 5/16† open-end wrench -n Phillips screwdriver - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -24 - - Removing the doors. - -Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet. - -Before Removing the Doors -1 -2 -CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could -damage the door stop. - -Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment. - -Remove the Freezer Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the -top hinge to the cabinet. - -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin -from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws. - -Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the -door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge -bracket. - -Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal. - -Top Hinge - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -25 - - Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Remove the Fresh Food Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench, -remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to -the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of -the door, and set hinge and screws aside. - -3 - -4 -5 - -6 - -Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from -the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door -bottom, put it back on the hinge.) - -Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal. - -Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw -hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough -space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket. - -Center Hinge Bracket - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left -1 - -Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight -out. - -2 - -Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to -it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side. - -Plastic Washer - -Hinge Bracket - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -26 - - Reversing the door handles. - -Transfer Top Hinge to the Left - -Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws -at top left of cabinet. - -Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time. - -Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge -depends on which side you install the hinge. - -Installing the hinge on the left. - -Installing the hinge on the right. - -Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle - -Top View - -Bottom View - -1 - -2 - -3 -4 - -Remove the bottom cap by -pushing it toward the bottom of -the door and remove the screw -underneath. - -Remove the two screws holding -the handle to the top of the door. - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screws from the right -edge of the door top and insert -them into the handle screw holes -on the opposite side. - -5 - -6 - -With tape-tipped putty knife or -thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the -plug button from the hinge hole -on the left side of the door and -insert it into the hole on the -opposite side that was vacated by -removal of the top hinge. - -Pull the plug button from the -front of the door and transfer it to -the opposite side. - -Plug Button - -Screws for -Handle Holes - -Plug Button - -To reattach the handle on the -opposite side. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -27 - - Rehanging the doors. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Transfer Door Stop -1 - -Move the metal door stop from -the right end to the left end. Use a -Torxdriver. - -Door Stop - -2 - -Move any screws from the left end -to the right end. - -Right Side - -Left Side - -Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle -1 - -Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and -under the handle plug. - -Reinstall the handle plug. - -2 -Transfer Freezer Door Handle -1 - -Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two -screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door. - -2 -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the -handle screw hole on the left side. - -Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the -opposite side. - -Transfer the door stop as shown above. - -Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and -bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws. - -Left Side - -Right Side - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -28 - - Rehang the Fresh Food Door -1 - -Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom -hinge. - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -2 - -3 - -Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door. -NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the -left side. - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide -the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven -into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both -screws securely. - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic -Washer - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Rehang the Freezer Door -1 - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin. - -2 - -3 - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the -socket on the top of the door. - -Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even -across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these -screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one- -half turn. - -Center Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -29 - - Normal operating sounds. - -Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen, -you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under -the refrigerator to reduce noise. - -The fan circulating air inside the freezer which -keeps the temperatures even. - -Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of -refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils. - -Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water -dropping on the defrost heater during the -defrost cycle. - -Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils -expanding and contracting during the -defrosting cycle. - -Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator -and flows to the drain pan during the defrost -cycle. - -Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker water valve will buzz when the -icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in -the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has -not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the -feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is -hooked up to water can damage the icemaker. -To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP -(up) position. This will stop the buzzing. - -The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and -water running in pipes as icemaker refills. - -These sounds are normal -and are due mostly to highly -efficient operation. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -30 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips -Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and -you may not need to call for service. - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Refrigerator does not -operate - -Refrigerator in -defrost cycle. - -Temperature control -dial in OFFposition. - -Refrigerator is -unplugged. - -The fuse is blown/ -circuit breaker is -tripped. - -Normal when -refrigerator is first -plugged in. - -Often occurs when large -amounts of food are -placed in refrigerator. - -Door left open. - -• Wait about 30 minutes for - -defrost cycle to end. - -• Move the temperature - -control dial to a -temperature setting. - -• Push the plug completely - -into the outlet. - -• Replace fuse or reset the - -breaker. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• This is normal. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Hot weather or frequent -door openings. - -• This is normal. - -Temperature control dial -set at the coldest setting. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Grille and condenser -need cleaning. - -Front roller screws or -front leveling legs need -adjusting. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -• See Rollers and leveling legs. - -Motor operates for long -periods or cycles on and -off frequently. (Modern -refrigerators with more -storage space and a larger -freezer require more -operating time. They start -and stop often to maintain -even temperatures.) - -Vibration or rattling -(slight vibration is normal) - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -31 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Fresh food or freezer -compartment too warm - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Warm weather or -frequent door openings. - -Door left open. - -Package blocking air -duct in freezer -compartment. - -Door left open. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -• Set the temperature -control dial one step -colder. See About the -temperature control dial. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -• Check to see if package is - -blocking air duct in freezer -compartment. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Icemaker feeler arm in -STOP (up) position. - -• Move the feeler arm to the - -ON (down) position. - -Water supply turned -off or not connected. - -Freezer compartment -too warm. - -Water shutoff valve -connecting refrigerator -to water line may be -clogged. - -• See Installing thewater line. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• Call a plumber to clear - -the valve. - -Frost or ice crystals on -frozen food (frost within -package is normal) - -Automatic icemaker -does not work -(on some models) - -Cubes too small - -Slow ice cube freezing - -Door left open. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -32 - - Problem - -Ice cubes have -odor/taste - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Ice storage bin needs -cleaning. - -• Empty and wash bin. -Discard old cubes. - -Food transmitting odor/ -taste to ice cubes. - -Interior of refrigerator -needs cleaning. - -• Wrap foods well. - -• See Care andcleaning. - -Moisture forms on -cabinet surface -between the doors - -Moisture collects inside -(in humid weather, air -carries moisture into -refrigerator when doors -are opened) - -Refrigerator has odor - -Not unusual during -periods of high -humidity. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -Foods transmitting -odor to refrigerator. - -• Wipe surface dry and - -reset temperature control -dial one setting colder. - -• Foods with strong odors - -should be tightly wrapped. -• Keep an open box of baking -soda in the refrigerator; -replace every three months. - -Interior needs cleaning. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -33 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -34 - - S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -35 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -36 - - GE Service Protection Plus™ - -GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability, -offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on -all your appliances—No Matter What Brand! - -Benefits Include: -• Backed by GE -• All brands covered -• Unlimited service calls -• All parts and labor costs included -• No out-of-pocket expenses -• No hidden deductibles -• One 800 number to call - -We’ll Cover Any Appliance. -Anywhere. Anytime.* - -You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your -money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple. - -Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much -more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly -financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered. -You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected -against expensive repairs. - -Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224 -for more information. - -*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S. - -" - -Cut here - -Please place in envelope and mail to: - -General Electric Company -Warranty Registration Department -P.O. Box 34070 -Louisville, KY 40232-4070 - -37 - - Consumer Product Ownership Registration -Dear Customer: -Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us. -We are proud to have you as a customer! - -Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment: - -1 - -Complete and mail -your Consumer -Product Ownership -Registration today. -Have the peace of -mind of knowing -we can contact you -in the unlikely event of a safety -modification. - -2 - -After mailing -the registration -below, store this -document in a safe -place. It contains -information you -will need should - -you require service. Our -service number is 800 GE -CARES (800-432-2737). - -3 - -Read your -Owner’s Manual -carefully. -It will help you -operate your -new appliance -properly. - -If you have questions, or need -more information, call the GE -Answer Center® 800.626.2000. - -Model Number - -Serial Number - -Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product, - -detach and return the form below to ensure that your -product is registered. - -" -Consumer Product Ownership Registration - -Cut here - -Important -Mail -Today! - -First -Name - -Street -Address - -Apt. # - -City - -Model Number - -Serial Number - -Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108) - -Last -Name - -E-mail Address - -State - -Zip -Code - -Date Placed In Use - -Month - -Day - -Year - -Phone -Number - -Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information. -(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information. - -GE Appliances -General Electric Company -Louisville, Kentucky 40225 -www.ge.com/appliances - -38 - - Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States) - -All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers, -or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service, -call 800-GE-CARES. - -For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You: - -One Year -From the date of the -original purchase - -Five Years -From the date of the -original purchase - -Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect -in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year -warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor -and in-home service to replace the defective part. - -Any part of the sealed refrigerating system -(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all -connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in -materials or workmanship. During this additional -four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, -all labor and in-home service to replace the -defective part. - -What Is Not Covered: - -n Service trips to your home to teach you - -how to use the product. - -n Improper installation. - -n Failure of the product if it is - -abused, misused, or used for other -than the intended purpose or used -commercially. - -n Loss of food due to spoilage. - -n Replacement of house fuses or -resetting of circuit breakers. - -n Damage to the product caused by - -accident, fire, floods or acts of God. - -n Incidental or consequential damage to -personal property caused by possible -defects with this appliance. - -This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased -for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to -your home. - -Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This -warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to -state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your -state’s Attorney General. - -Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225 - -39 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -Service Telephone Numbers. - -GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000 - -The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. - -In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737) - -Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away. - -Special Needs Service800.626.2000 -TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322) - -GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier- -free kitchen for persons with limited mobility. - -Service Contracts800-626-2224 - -Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect -and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will -still be there after your warranty expires. - -Parts and Accessories800-626-2002 - -Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts -or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and -Discover cards are accepted). -Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed -by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified -service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing -may cause unsafe operation. - -Service Satisfaction - -If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow -these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance. -Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your -phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances, -Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225. - -40 - -Printed in Louisville, KY + Notes: Some workout types don't support the above four settings. The settings might slightly vary +in workout type. diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_3.md b/q12/random_k4/random_3.md index c8ab7ba6e2f09f6f6ed15e4f7482f41d41ee6cf8..a4b2b07cac278442884a849032b2d8b161f383fe 100644 --- a/q12/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q12/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1717 +1,2777 @@ -Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 1 of 29 - -UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT -FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA - -Civil No. - -Action for Declaratory and Injunctive -Relief to Remedy Violations of the -Oregon and California Railroad and Coos -Bay Wagon Road Grant Lands Act of -1937, 43 U.S.C. §1181a; Federal Land -Policy and Management Act, 43 U.S.C.A. -§1701 Savings Provision; and -Administrative Procedure Act, 5 -U.S.C.§§701-706 - -AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE -COUNCIL, 5100 SW Macadam Ave., Ste. -350, Portland, OR 97239; CARPENTERS -INDUSTRIAL COUNCIL,12788 SE Stark -Street, Portland, OR 97233; DOUGLAS -TIMBER OPERATORS, INC., 3000 -Stewart Parkway, Suite 208, Roseburg, OR -97470; C & D LUMBER CO., 1182 Pruner -Road, Riddle, OR 97469; FRERES -LUMBER CO. INC., P.O. Box 276, Lyons, -OR 97358; SENECA SAWMILL -COMPANY including its affiliate SENECA -JONES TIMBER COMPANY, 90201 -Highway 99N, Eugene, OR 97401; -STARFIRE LUMBER CO., INC., P.O. Box -547, Cottage Grove, OR 97424; SWANSON -GROUP MFG. LLC, 2695 Glendale Valley -Road, Glendale, OR 97442, - -v. - -Plaintiffs, - -NEIL KORNZE, Director, Bureau of Land -Management, 1849 C Street NW, Washington, -D.C. 20240 and S. M. R. JEWELL, Secretary -of Interior, 1849 C Street NW, Washington, -D.C. 20240, - -___________________________________ - -Defendants +Digital Landscape -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) -) - -COMPLAINT - -For their complaint herein, plaintiffs allege as follows: - -INTRODUCTION - -1. - -This is an action against the Hon. Neil Kornze, Director of the Bureau of Land - -Management (BLM), and the Hon. S. M. R. Jewell, Secretary of Interior, for declaratory and - -injunctive relief to remedy violations of the Oregon and California Railroad and Coos Bay Wagon - -Road Grant Lands Act of 1937 (O&C Act), 43 U.S.C. §1181a, the Federal Land Policy and - -Page 1 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 2 of 29 - -Management Act (FLPMA), 43 U.S.C.A. §1701 Savings Provision, and the Administrative - -Procedure Act (APA), 5 U.S.C.§§701-706, relating to the decision by defendant Kornze (through - -Deputy BLM Director Steven A. Ellis) on August 5, 2016 approving the Southwest Oregon Resource - -Management Plan and the Northwestern and Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan (2016 - -RMPs) to direct the management of six BLM districts in Western Oregon. - -JURISDICTION AND VENUE - -2. - -This Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (federal - -question), § 2201 (declaratory relief) and § 2202 (injunctive relief). Plaintiffs have challenged final - -agency action as defined by the APA, 5 U.S.C. §704. Venue in this district is proper under 28 - -U.S.C. § 1391(e) because defendant Kornze and the Secretary of the Interior were personally - -involved in the issues raised in this case, the challenged decision was approved in this district, a - -substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claims occurred in this district, and the - -defendants reside in this district. This action is timely under 28 U.S.C. § 2401(a)(1) because the - -2016 RMPs were approved on August 5, 2016. - -PARTIES - -3. - -Plaintiff American Forest Resource Council (AFRC), a nonprofit corporation organized - -under the laws of the state of Oregon, is a forest products trade association located in Portland, - -Oregon which represents approximately 60 wood products manufacturing companies and landowners - -throughout the states of Washington, Oregon, California and elsewhere in the western United States. - -Among AFRC’s members are plaintiffs C & D Lumber Co., Freres Lumber Co. Inc, Seneca Sawmill - -Company, Starfire Lumber Co., Inc., and Swanson Group Mfg. LLC, as well as companies such as - -Hampton Industries, with operations in Washington and Oregon; Interfor Pacific, Inc., with - -operations in Oregon, Washington and elsewhere; Rosboro, LLC, based in Oregon; Roseburg Forest - -Products, with operations in Oregon and California, and South Coast Lumber, Co, in Brookings, OR, - -Page 2 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 3 of 29 - -all of which have recently purchased BLM timber sales and seek to purchase more such sales. Many - -of AFRC’s members could not continue to operate at their current levels of production, and would - -suffer financial harm, without a reliable and adequate supply of timber sold by the BLM. One of - -AFRC’s primary purposes is to represent the interests of its members on matters relating to federal - -timber supply. - -4. - -AFRC and its predecessors have served as the representative for the wood products - -industry on major regional federal land management decisions since 1986. AFRC collects - -information about the environmental, economic and social impacts of these major federal land - -management decisions, and disseminates this information to its members and participants, to public - -officials and to thousands of members of the public who are directly affected by these decisions. - -5. - -AFRC also represents the interests of its members who own private forest land, including - -many who own private forest land intermingled with, adjoining or adjacent to O&C forests. The - -ability of these companies to manage their own lands has been and will be directly and adversely - -affected by the BLM’s management of the O&C lands. The risk of fire, disease or insect infestation - -starting on O&C land and spreading to nearby private land has been greatly increased by the 2016 - -RMPs because those decisions hinder or proscribe land management activities, including - -implementation of hazardous fuel reduction projects, on 74 percent of the O&C lands. These - -restrictions present a substantial threat to AFRC members’ lands in the vicinity of these O&C - -forests, which the decisions challenged in this case substantially increased, and may also limit AFRC - -members’ access to their lands through these O&C forests. - -6. - -Plaintiff Carpenters Industrial Council (CIC) is a labor organization that represents - -thousands of forest products workers in Oregon, Washington, northern California and nationwide. - -The CIC was chartered July 1, 2006, by the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of - -America, which is headquartered in Washington, D.C. The CIC was formed after the merger of four - -Page 3 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 4 of 29 - -Regional Industrial Councils – the Carpenters East Coast Industrial Council, the Midwestern Council - -of Industrial Workers, the Southern Council of Industrial Workers, and the Western Council of - -Industrial Workers. Many CIC members live in remote communities that are heavily dependent on - -BLM timber. Several thousand of these workers have experienced, or continue to be threatened - -with, permanent job loss caused by timber supply reductions resulting from the land management - -plans adopted for the BLM’s western Oregon districts since 1995, including the 2016 RMPs. There - -are few, if any, prospects for CIC members to replace their jobs at a comparable wage in their home - -towns. - -7. - -Plaintiff Douglas Timber Operators, Inc. (DTO), a nonprofit corporation organized under - -the laws of the State of Oregon, is a forest products trade association located in Roseburg, Oregon - -which represents approximately 145 timber and logging companies and other businesses operating - -in Douglas, Coos and Lane Counties and elsewhere in Oregon. DTO's membership includes - -businesses in every segment of the forest products industry, from logging companies and small - -independent sawmills to large integrated manufacturers. DTO's members include such companies - -as C & D Lumber Co.; Herbert Lumber Co., based in Riddle, Oregon; Starfire Lumber Co. and - -Douglas County Forest Products, based in Winchester, Oregon. DTO’s members purchase many of - -the timber sales that are offered by the BLM’s western Oregon districts. These companies have - -historically depended in large measure on timber sold by the BLM for their timber supply. One of - -DTO’s primary purposes is to represent the interests of its members on matters relating to federal - -timber supply. - -8. - - Plaintiff C & D Lumber Co. (C & D) is a family-owned manufacturer of lumber and - -wood products located in Riddle, Oregon, where it has operated for more than 60 years. C & D is - -a member of AFRC and DTO. C & D operates a cutting mill that can process logs as small as six - -inches in diameter but operates most efficiently with larger, high quality Douglas-fir, incense cedar - -Page 4 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 5 of 29 - -and Port Orford cedar logs over sixteen inches in diameter. C&D employs about 110 workers at its - -mill and associated facilities, and produces about 40 million board feet of lumber annually. C & D - -has no trouble selling all of the forest products it produces. C & D purchases and has historically - -depended heavily on timber sold from the O&C lands in the BLM’s Medford and Roseburg Districts - -and from the Umpqua and Willamette National Forests and on timber supplied by other private and - -state timberland owners for the raw materials needed to operate its processing facility. C & D is - -certified as a small business by the Small Business Administration (SBA). - -9. - - Riddle is a small town in Douglas County, in rural southwestern Oregon, with a - -population of about 1,000. C & D was founded in Douglas County, and has operated there for - -more than 60 years. When it is in full operation C & D can process up to 55 million board feet of - -timber per year, but is currently unable to process that volume of wood due to lack of log supply. - -C & D recently made a significant mill modernization update, and with adequate timber supply it - -expects to continue indefinitely to provide wood products to its customers for use in building - -construction throughout the United States. Without an adequate supply of timber, C & D faces - -the prospect of being forced to shut down, lay off all its employees and close its doors forever. - -10. Silver Butte Timber Company, a sister company of C & D with common ownership, - -owns 45,000 acres of forest land in Douglas, Coos, Jackson and Josephine Counties, Oregon. The - -Silver Butte lands can supply C & D with only about 15-25 percent of its required raw material - -supply. Approximately 80 -90 percent of Silver Butte's holdings are adjacent on at least two, and - -in some cases four, sides to BLM O&C Act timber lands, including O&C land that has been - -designated as no-management reserves in the 2016 RMPs. The management practices on the - -adjoining BLM lands directly and substantially influence the health and safety of Silver Butte's - -timberland assets, and substantially threaten C&D’s timber supply. - -11. The failure of the BLM to offer the level of sustained-yield timber sales required by - -Page 5 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 6 of 29 - -the O&C Act directly and substantially harms and threatens to harm C & D. The absence of these - -sustained-yield timber sales denies C & D the opportunity to bid on a supply of timber that it would - -like to purchase at competitive auction in the upcoming months and years to meet the increasing - -demand for home construction materials in the United States. In addition, an increase in BLM - -timber sales would mean more effective and proactive management of BLM forestlands, reducing - -the risk of fire, disease or insect infestation starting on BLM land and spreading to Silver Butte's - -land. There is a substantial probability that Silver Butte’s lands will be directly and substantially - -harmed by the failure to offer the timber sales mandated by the O&C Act. The risk of fire, disease - -or insect infestation starting on BLM land and spreading to adjoining C & D land has increased - -due to past BLM land mismanagement, will substantially increase further under the 2016 RMPs, and - -is substantial at the present time. - -12. Plaintiff Freres Lumber Co. Inc. (Freres) is a family-owned small business that was - -founded in 1922. Freres operates mills that manufacture softwood veneer, lumber and plywood. The - -company is headquartered in Lyons, Oregon, 20 miles east of Salem, Oregon. Freres is a member - -of AFRC. Freres purchases federal timber from the BLM’s Salem District and the Mt. Hood, - -Willamette, and Siuslaw National Forests. Freres is the largest contract holder of BLM timber in - -the state of Oregon. The decision in the 2016 RMPs to reduce BLM timber sales far below the - -legally required level will severely hinder Freres’ ability to maintain its current level of operations. - -13. Freres currently employs about 480 people, but at its peak capacity, it can employ as - -many as 499 workers. In the decade 1980-89, Freres processed approximately 50 million board feet - -of timber per year. Since the 1980’s the company has invested heavily in new technology that has - -increased its capability to process timber. In the past decade alone Freres has invested over $65 - -million in new equipment and technology for its plants in order to modernize the mill and increase - -its capacity. Over the past decade Freres has processed on average (with considerable variation) +February 2020 -Page 6 - Complaint +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com + Snapshot - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 7 of 29 +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -about 78 million board feet of timber per year, and it is currently capable of processing 100 million + Landscape Overview -board feet of timber per year if adequate timber supply were available. In 2011-13 Freres averaged +Metric -86 million board feet of timber processed in its mill and sold as finished wood products. Freres +Device -would increase its production to its 100 million board foot capacity, and hire additional employees +Jan-2020 -to perform the work, if additional timber were available. Freres is a modern, efficient processor of +Feb-2020 -timber, and with adequate timber supply it expects to continue indefinitely to provide wood products +Unique Audience (000) -to its customers for use in building construction throughout the United States. Freres has no +Digital (C/M) -difficulty selling all of the forests products it manufactures. +Active Reach (%) -14. In the decade 1980-89, almost 100 percent of Freres’ timber supply came from federal +Time Spent per Person +(hh:mm:ss) -forests and State of Oregon lands. About 75 percent of its timber supply (37.5 million board feet) +Desktop -was provided by the Forest Service, 15 percent (7.5 million board feet) by the BLM and 10 percent +Smartphone -(5 million board feet) from Oregon state lands. Its current capacity is double the 1980’s level, but +Tablet -since the 1980’s the Forest Service and BLM timber sale programs have diminished to a small +Digital (C/M) -fraction of 1980s levels. In the 1980’s western Oregon national forests sold over three billion board +Desktop -feet of timber per year, and the BLM sold over one billion board feet of timber per year. Today the +Smartphone -Forest Service allowable sale level in western Oregon has been reduced to only about 350 million +Tablet -board feet of timber per year, and the 2016 RMPs set the BLM annual allowable sale level at only +Digital (C/M) -17 percent of the legally required volume. The drop in Forest Service timber has been greatest, as +Desktop -Freres now obtains just 14 percent of its timber supply (12 million board feet) from the Forest +Smartphone -Service. Freres’ BLM percentage of timber has dropped to 12 percent (10 million board feet), and +Tablet -timber from Oregon state lands slightly increased to 12 percent (10 million board feet). Its sister +21,152 -company Freres Timber owns 14,500 acres of timberland and another related entity, Freres +18,505 -Partnership LLC, owns 2,400 acres, but under the sustained-yield management that these companies +16,383 -practice, their lands (referred to jointly as Freres Lands) can supply only about 13 percent of Freres’ +7,441 -Page 7 - Complaint +100% -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +87% - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 8 of 29 +77% -annual timber requirement, and Freres is not able to increase the annual supply of timber from the +35% -Freres Lands without destroying their long-term productivity. +108:47:50 -15. In addition to BLM timber sales, Freres acquires timber for its mills from the Mt. Hood, +21:57:14 -Siuslaw and Willamette National Forests, Oregon state forests and private timberland owners. None +89:56:34 -of these sources has any prospect of supplying a steady and reliable increase in timber production +58:05:33 -that would allow Freres to expand its business. The National Forests operate under the Northwest +21,310 -Forest Plan adopted in 1994, which is not scheduled to be revised in western Oregon for at least five +18,656 -more years. Each national Forest has an annual allowable sale quantity of timber that it is not +16570 -permitted to exceed. The Forest Service rarely if ever achieves its allowable sale quantity, and there +7,449 -is no plausible likelihood the Forest Service will voluntarily or involuntarily increase timber sales +100% -from the Mt. Hood, Siuslaw or Willamette National Forests in the next five years or longer. Oregon +88% -state forests also operate under a maximum permitted annual sale volume, and the State of Oregon +78% -has no plans to increase the permitted annual sale volume on its state forests in the foreseeable +35% -future. Oregon has offered sell one of its premier timber-producing state forests due to the low sale +90:49:40 -volume it has achieved in recent years. +20:17:06 -16. Freres currently purchases about half its timber supply on the open market from other +72:18:43 -private companies, but for several reasons these sales do not have the same value to Freres as BLM +48:48:53 -sustained-yield sales. First, these sales are solely at the discretion of the seller, and Freres has no +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Jan 2020, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P2+, Unique Audience (000), Active Reach (Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person +(hh:mm:ss). +3 -contractual right to any steady supply of timber from any private company. Any company could stop +. +. -selling timber, or stop selling timber to Freres, at any time without notice. For these reasons, Freres - -does not rely on private timber purchases as a basis for expanding its production. In contrast, a BLM - -timber sale contract generally allows three years for completion of the sale, so Freres can plan its - -operations with the certainty that the BLM logs will be available at the time of its choosing during - -the sale period. In addition, the BLM has a legal obligation to sell its declared and determined - -Page 8 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 9 of 29 - -allowable sale quantity each year, so Freres should be able to rely on a steady supply of BLM - -sustained-yield sales every year at the full productive capacity of the O&C lands. While sales are - -all competitively bid, and Freres has no guarantee of being able to purchase any particular sale, there - -is a substantial probability that Freres would purchase additional BLM timber sales if they are - -offered. Freres is certified as a small business under SBA rules, and a certain percentage of BLM - -timber sales are set aside for bidding solely by certified small businesses like Freres, increasing its - -chances of successfully bidding on those sales. Freres has been injured by BLM’s failure to offer the - -full legally-required level of sustained-yield sales. BLM’s certain failure under the 2016 RMPs to - -offer the full required level of sustained-yield sales each year (calculated with no reserves) creates - -a substantial probability of imminent future injury to Freres through loss of the opportunity to bid - -on additional timber sales and to process 14 million board feet of timber into additional forest - -products to be sold this year and next year and the year after that, indefinitely. The non-sustained- - -yield thinning sales offered by the BLM are not sufficiently reliable to serve as the basis for business - -expansion because there is no way to predict from year to year how many non-sustained-yield sales - -will be offered. - -17. The BLM’s continued failure to offer sustained-yield timber sales based on permanent - -forest production of all the suitable O&C timberlands in the BLM Salem district, and other districts, - -has also injured and imminently threatens to continue to injure Freres by making log prices higher - -than they otherwise would be (reducing the company’s profit margin and total profit). If the BLM - -Salem district, and other BLM districts in Oregon, increased their annual timber sale volume to the - -level required by the O&C Act, it is very likely that log prices in western Oregon would decline - -across the board, which would add to Freres’ profit margin and total profit. There is a substantial - -probability that BLM’s on-going violations of the O&C Act will cause Freres to suffer imminent - -future financial loss from having to pay above-market prices for the logs its purchases, which - -Page 9 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 10 of 29 - -reduces the profit margin and profitability of the wood products it sells. - -18. The quality of wood on BLM timber sales is very high, which increases the profitability - -of the forest products produced from those sales. In addition, the BLM is required to offer its full - -allowable sale quantity of sustained-yield sales every year regardless of log prices, and federal timber - -may not lawfully be exported, eliminating purchases by China as a market factor, which tempers - -bidding prices for BLM sales. - -19. The Freres Lands share 36 miles of boundary with O&C lands subject to the 2016 RMPs, - -including many miles of O&C land that has been designated as no-management reserves in the 2016 - -RMPs, and the Freres Lands are directly, immediately and substantially threatened with fire starting - -on poorly managed BLM lands and spreading uncontrollably onto the Freres Lands. - -20. Plaintiff Seneca Sawmill Company (Seneca) was founded by Aaron U. Jones in Eugene, - -Oregon in 1953 and continues to be owned by members of the Aaron U. Jones family. Seneca is a - -leading innovator in lumber manufacturing, and Seneca holds over 25 U.S. and Canadian patents in - -various sawmill technologies. Seneca manufactures 550 million board feet of studs and dimension - -lumber products annually from its manufacturing facilities in Eugene and Noti, Oregon, and sells - -everything it can produce. Seneca's affiliate Seneca Jones Timber Company (Seneca Jones) owns - -approximately 167,000 acres of forestland in Lane, Douglas, Curry, Jackson, Linn, Benton, Coos and - -Josephine Counties, Oregon. Seneca Jones manages its timberlands on a long-term sustained-yield - -basis. Operating on a sustained yield basis, Seneca Jones timberlands can only supply about 28% - -of Seneca Sawmill’s required timber needs. Seneca Sawmill currently employs about 420 workers, - -and is an SBA-qualified small business. Seneca relies heavily on timber supplied by the Coos Bay, - -Eugene, Roseburg and Salem districts of the BLM and by nearby national forests, which - -complements the timber available annually from Seneca Jones. There is no prospect that the USFS - -can increase its timber sale volume, so BLM is the only seller capable of increasing its annual timber - -Page 10 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 11 of 29 - -sale level. Seneca is a member of AFRC. - -21. Seneca Sawmill cannot maintain its current production level without a steady or - -increasing supply of federal timber. Seneca Sawmill does not currently operate at capacity, and an - -additional timber supply will be needed to produce at capacity. The continuing lack of adequate - -timber sales under the 2016 RMPs will also increase the cost of logs, causing financial harm to - -Seneca Sawmill. BLM sustained-yield sales are the only reliable source of additional timber that - -would allow increased production. Neither the Forest Service, Oregon state lands, Seneca Jones, - -other private landowners nor BLM non-sustained-yield thinning sales can be relied on to supply - -more timber than their current sale level. Seneca’s inability to operate at full capacity has reduced - -and will continue to reduce the company’s profitability. Seneca has been injured by the denial of - -the opportunity to bid on the full supply of BLM sustained-yield sales that are legally required to be - -offered each year, and faces the imminent threat of such future harm. - -22. The Seneca Jones timberlands include forestland that is both adjacent to, and, many - -times, intermingled with BLM land. Seneca Jones timberlands share a common boundary with O&C - -timberlands over a linear distance of 689 miles, including many linear miles of O&C land that has - -been designated as no-management reserves in the 2016 RMPs. - -23. Although the O&C Act requires BLM to manage all of its O&C timberlands for - -permanent forest production, for the past 20 years BLM has failed to do so over a majority of the - -O&C land it manages. The 2016 RMPs further reduce the area of O&C land that BLM is permitted - -to manage for sustained-yield timber production to 20 percent of its forested land base, down from - -27 percent under the 1995 RMPs, with 74 percent allocated to unlawful reserves where permanent - -forest production has been prohibited, and six percent to sparsely forested areas with no significant - -potential for timber production. The “Harvest Land Base” where sustained-yield timber production - -is permitted contains just 18 percent of the 72 billion board feet of standing timber on the O&C - -Page 11 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 12 of 29 - -lands. Proposed Resource Management Plan/Final EIS (2016) (FEIS) at 335. The past unlawful - -management of the O&C lands has already resulted in neglect and mismanagement of adjoining - -O&C lands, creating hundreds of thousands of acres of forests with high fuel loads that increase the - -risk, spread and intensity of wildfire, and threaten Seneca Jones= forestland. Conditions will only - -get worse under the 2016 RMPs. Continued neglect and mismanagement of BLM lands is a direct, - -immediate and substantial threat to Seneca Sawmill=s business and Seneca Jones= forest land. Seneca - -Jones relies on access to its own land through rights-of-way across BLM land. Loss of a BLM right- - -of-way road will cost Seneca Jones significant economic loss by preventing, or at least increasing - -the expense of, removal of Seneca Jones’ timber from its own land, thereby reducing the profitability - -of any subsequent use of the timber and causing financial harm to Seneca Jones. - -24. The risk of fire, disease or insect infestation starting on BLM lands and spreading to - -adjoining private land has increased substantially over the past 20 years, is substantial and will - -continue to increase as long as BLM fails to manage all of the O&C timberlands for permanent forest - -production under the O&C Act. For Seneca Jones, this concern is not imaginary. In 2009, the - -Williams Creek Fire in Douglas County burned approximately 490 acres of Seneca Jones property - -in late July and early August. The fire started on Forest Service land over two miles from Seneca - -Jones property in an area where no active management had occurred for over 15 years, and there - -were no maintained roads suitable for mechanized access – the same management regime that is - -commanded by the 2016 RMPs for 74 percent of the O&C timberlands. - -25. For the Williams Creek fire, lack of access to the burning area by mechanized transport - -created difficulty in firefighting efforts from the beginning of the fire throughout the life of the - -incident. Over the 16-day incident, access by ground personnel was a severely limiting factor in - -providing opportunity for control of the fire. Without access for facilitation of effective retreat for - -ground forces, safety concerns dictated an indirect attack method that utilized natural landscape - -Page 12 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 13 of 29 - -features for controlling the perimeter location. Therefore, the Forest Service had to conduct a - -backburning of Seneca property on or near a ridgeline in three separate locations, with a total burned - -area of approximately 490 acres. Backburning of Seneca property should not have been necessary - -because there is an intervening ridge of Forest Service land between the area where the fire started - -and Seneca’s property, which could have been used as the site for the backburn had proper access - -been available. Unfortunately, the fire crews could not gain access to this ridge due to the Forest - -Service=s failure to properly manage its land. The fire crews could gain easy access to Seneca Jones - -land, so they had no choice but to use Seneca’s land for the backburn. - -26. Seneca Jones’ losses included Douglas-fir plantations ranging in age from four to 29 - -years, and many acres were 28 years old with a net value of $3,000 per acre. Seneca has - -reestablished these plantations with an initial average cost of $600 per acre, and will incur further - -costs associated with fertilization and precommercial thinning. Had the Forest Service been actively - -managing the area adjacent to Seneca property, they would have been able to control the fire prior - -to its entering Seneca=s land. The management regime adopted in the 2016 RMPs will result in - -comparable management constraints on the O&C land adjoining Seneca Jones’ property. - -27. Plaintiff Starfire Lumber Co., Inc. (Starfire) is a family-owned small business that - -manufactures high grade Douglas-fir lumber, including beams, stringers, timbers, clears and other - -specialty cuttings, at its mill in Cottage Grove, Oregon. Starfire is a member of AFRC and DTO. - -Starfire owns virtually no commercial forestland so timber from federal land has been and remains - -a vital source of its log supply. Starfire obtains its logs from O&C lands including the Salem, - -Eugene, and Roseburg BLM Districts as well as the Mt. Hood, Willamette, Siuslaw and Umpqua - -National Forests. The BLM forests formerly provided a steady supply of high quality large logs - -suitable for Starfire’s operations, but BLM timber sales containing high quality logs have sharply - -declined even though the O&C lands contain a huge inventory of large high quality trees. - -Page 13 - Complaint - -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com - - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 14 of 29 - -28. Starfire currently has 75 employees, and processes approximately 2.5 million board - -feet of timber per month, equal to 30 million board feet per year. It currently operates one shift at - -the mill, but with additional reliable timber supply it would expand its operations by adding a second - -shift and hiring new employees to work that shift, which would make the company more efficient - -and more profitable. However at the present time Starfire does not have any additional reliable - -source of timber supply that would permit it to add a second shift. Starfire is certified as an SBA - -small business, and can sell all the forest products it produces without difficulty. - -29. In the 1980’s and early 1990’s, when federal timber supply was more plentiful, - -Starfire operated three shifts, employing 120 workers and consuming about 4.5 million board feet - -per month, equal to 54 million board feet per year. At that time approximately 70-90 percent of its - -timber supply came from federal forestlands within its sourcing radius (the geographic distance at - -which Starfire can afford to ship logs to the mill). Of that portion of its timber supply, approximately - -15 percent came from the BLM and approximately 85 percent from USFS. However since the - -Northwest Forest Plan was adopted in 1994 reducing federal timber sales by more than 80 percent, - -the availability of BLM and Forest Service timber has dropped sharply. Today only approximately - -1 percent of Starfire’s log supply comes from BLM. About 1.5 percent comes from the Forest - -Service, and the rest of its log supply comes from private timberland owners. Starfire has no long - -term contracts with any supplier. The company purchases logs one month at a time at a negotiated - -price based on current log market prices. +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Trend - Time Spent by Device - DCR + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -30. Starfire processes large-diameter logs that commonly comprise only a small +i +i -proportion of the typical BLM timber sale today. Starfire regularly purchases BLM logs from other +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -companies that purchase a BLM timber sale, operate the sale and then sell Starfire the large-diameter +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Jan 2019 - Feb 2020, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P 2+, % of Total Time Spent, Text -logs from the sale, which normally are too big to be processed in most small-dimension sawmills. +4 -In particular, BLM sustained-yield sales are most likely to contain large-diameter logs suitable for + Age Breakdowns Overview -Page 14 - Complaint +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com + Digital Audience Reach and Time by Demo Overview - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 15 of 29 +Data Type -Starfire while the non-sustained-yield thinning sales have few if any large-diameter logs suitable for +Device -Starfire. All of the BLM logs Starfire currently owns came from other purchasers of BLM timber +Unique +Audience -sales, although on occasion Starfire will bid on and buy a BLM timber sale. All of the O&C Lands +Total Platform -are within its sourcing radius. Starfire has been injured, and faces imminent threat of future injury, +Desktop -by the failure of the 2016 RMPs to permit BLM to offer the full legally-required level of sustained- +Smartphone -yield sales from the O&C lands. +Tablet -31. There is no prospect the Forest Service will increase its annual harvest level in the +Profile % -near future, and there is no prospect that any private timberland owner will enter into a long-term +Total Platform -supply contract with Starfire, or will increase the monthly volume of timber Starfire purchases at the +Desktop -present time. The only plausible source of increased timber supply in its area is the BLM. Starfire +Smartphone -purchases BLM logs originating on the Salem, Eugene, and Roseburg BLM Districts. If these +Tablet -districts offered a higher volume of sustained-yield timber sales, it is very likely that the additional +P 18+ -sustained-yield sales would contain additional large-diameter logs, and that Starfire would be able +18,300 -to purchase additional logs from such sales. In addition, if more BLM sustained-yield sales were +15,646 -offered on these districts, Starfire, as an SBA-certified small business, would likely be able to +16,570 -purchase a sale at competitive auction, which would be a source of profit for the company even if +7,449 -it sells the small-diameter logs to other enterprises. +100% -32. Plaintiff Swanson Group Mfg. LLC (Swanson) is a family-owned enterprise that operates +100% -forest product manufacturing facilities in Glendale, Roseburg and Springfield, Oregon and employs +100% -over 700 workers at its sawmills and related operations. Swanson is one of the largest purchasers +100% -of timber sales offered by the BLM in Oregon. At the current time Swanson’s manufacturing +P 18-24 -facilities process 200-300 million board feet of timber in a year (the variation is due to differing log +P 25-34 -scaling measures), producing wood products sold to customers throughout the United States. +P 35-44 -Swanson has no trouble selling all the wood products it currently produces. Swanson has the capacity +P 45-54 -Page 15 - Complaint +P 55-64 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +2,353 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 16 of 29 +1,931 -to process an additional 58 million board feet of timber in a year by running additional shifts at its +2,313 -mills. If Swanson could produce more wood products the company would easily be able to sell those +304 -products into the open market and increase its profitability. Swanson is a member of the AFRC and +13% -DTO. +12% -33. Swanson owns virtually no private timber land. For its supply of raw materials to operate +14% -its business, Swanson relies on BLM timber provided by the Medford, Roseburg, Coos Bay, Eugene +4% -and Salem districts, on USFS timber from the Rogue-Siskiyou, Umpqua, Willamette and Siuslaw +3,813 -National Forests, on timber supplied by the State of Oregon and on timber supplied by private +3,392 -timberland owners. Swanson is currently unable to purchase additional timber for processing beyond +3,813 -the volume it now processes. +1,360 -34. The Forest Service is not capable of selling more timber than it currently does. Each +21% -national forest has an allowable annual sale quantity of timber set in its land and resource +22% -management plan, and it cannot exceed that volume of timber in a year. The Forest Service cannot +23% -reach its allowable sale quantity on any of its national forests in Oregon due to a combination of +18% -budget constraints, personnel limitations, Endangered Species Act consultations, restrictions in the +3,332 -Northwest Forest Plan (which governs all the national forests in western Oregon) and citizen appeals +2,998 -and litigation of planned timber sales. There is no reasonable possibility the Forest Service can +3,320 -increase its annual timber sales beyond the level it currently sells. +1,499 -35. The State of Oregon only owns a small amount of commercial forest lands, and offers a very +18% -small annual sale program each year. The Oregon state sale trend is down due to new management +19% -constraints and litigation, and Oregon is trying to sell some of its state-owned timberlands to private +20% -interests. There is no plausible chance Oregon state lands will increase their annual timber sales +20% -beyond the current level. +3,115 -Page 16 - Complaint +2,700 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +2,904 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 17 of 29 +1,599 -36. Swanson currently purchases over 130 million board feet per year of private timber. +17% -Swanson is one of the largest purchasers of private timber in the state of Oregon. Virtually all of the +17% -companies it buys timber from manage their lands on a long-term sustained-yield basis, which means +18% -these companies do not have the capacity to increase their annual sales above current levels. These +21% -timber sellers are free to sell timber to whomever they choose, including foreign buyers such as +2,716 -China, or not to sell timber in times of unfavorable market conditions. Most of Swanson’s private +2,344 -timber purchases are on the “spot” market, based on currently available logs. Swanson cannot rely +2,463 -on unpredictable future private timber sale levels to expand its operations. +1,399 -37. The BLM’s western Oregon O&C districts are the only timber sellers that have the capacity +15% -to increase timber sales that Swanson might be able to purchase at competitive auction. Those +15% -districts can sell more timber if ordered to do so because that is what has happened in the Medford +15% -and Roseburg Districts when the court in Swanson Group v. Salazar, No. 10-1843 (D.D.C.) ordered +19% -the BLM in 2013 to sell or offer for sale the allowable sale quantity (ASQ) declared in its resource +P 65+ -management plans (RMPs) for the Medford and Roseburg districts. In response to the court’s order, +2,972 -the BLM significantly increased its timber sale program for Fiscal Years 2014 and 2015 in the +2,281 -Medford and Roseburg districts. Swanson purchased the Rockstar Salvage sale in FY 2014 on the +1,757 -Medford district, containing over 12 million board feet of timber, for $1,180,205.40 (more than +1,288 -$220,000 over the appraised price) and will be injured if it is denied the opportunity to bid on and +16% -attempt to purchase additional sales in future auctions. +15% -38. Not all BLM timber sales are equally reliable as the basis for adding shifts and employees. +11% -The O&C Act requires the BLM to sell or offer for sale the allowable sale quantity (ASQ) declared +17% -in each of its O&C districts’ resource management plans. These sales, known as ASQ sales, must +Time Spent per +Person (Text) -come from areas of O&C land designated for sustained-yield timber production, must be sold or +Total Platform -offered every year, and are therefore reliable as a basis for adding a shift and new employees. The +105:15:33 -Page 17 - Complaint +82:51:47 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +104:05:13 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 18 of 29 +131:29:27 -BLM also offers “non-ASQ” sales involving commercial thinning of reserved areas where no +121:53:22 -sustained-yield timber production is permitted, but these sales are not reliable as a basis for adding +103:45:04 -a shift and new employees because there is no statutory requirement for BLM to offer the same +79:01:37 -amount, or any amount, of these sales each year. +Desktop -39. Swanson’s inability to secure additional long-term timber supplies necessary to add shifts +23:39:39 -to its mills is occurring at the present time and currently deprives Swanson of the additional profits +22:28:55 -that would be generated by adding an additional shift and processing more timber. For the same +19:08:11 -reason the reduction in BLM timber sales from the Medford and Roseburg districts under the 2016 +26:13:02 -RMPs also creates a substantial probability of imminent future injury to Swanson. +27:00:23 -40. Neil Kornze, Director of the BLM, is the official in charge of the BLM and made the decision +22:41:43 -challenged in this case. S. M. R. Jewell, the Secretary of the Interior, is the official charged with +25:03:33 -administering the O&C Act, through the BLM. Since 1993 several of Secretary Jewell’s +Smartphone -precedessors, including Bruce Babbitt and Ken Salazar, were personally involved in various +72:18:43 -decisions concerning the BLM western Oregon O&C lands that are the subject of this case. +59:11:44 -A. The O&C Act. +68:14:18 -BACKGROUND ALLEGATIONS +78:06:30 -41. In 1866 and 1870 Congress passed legislation that led to grants of large amounts of +83:00:33 -federally-owned land in western Oregon to the Oregon and California Railroad Company in +72:09:21 -exchange for construction of a north-south rail line from the Columbia River to California. The +70:01:28 -grant was conditioned on requirements that the land be resold by the railroad to "actual settlers" in +Tablet -parcels not to exceed 160 acres and for no more than $2.50 per acre. Once acquired by the railroad, +48:48:53 -these lands became subject to county property taxes and were an important source of tax revenues +80:59:43 -for the counties in which the lands are located (the "O&C Counties"). The railroad completed +64:04:38 -construction of the rail line and initially complied with the terms of the grant, but eventually ceased +35:49:12 -Page 18 - Complaint +50:59:20 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +41:43:09 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 19 of 29 +44:10:57 -reselling lands to actual settlers. Controversy followed, during which the railroad stopped paying +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P18+, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Profile +(Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person (text). -property taxes to the O&C Counties on the grant lands. Following a lengthy court battle, Congress +6 -passed the Chamberlain-Ferris Revestment Act in 1916, revesting the grant lands ("O&C lands") to +. +. -federal ownership, but requiring the government to pay the railroad company the amount it would +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Digital Audience Reach and Time Demo Overview + +Unique Audience + +Time Spent per Person + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P0-17, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Universe +Reach %, Time Spent per Person (text). + +* Persons 0-17 does not include mobile data. + +7 + + Surfing Reports + +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. + + People 2+ Surfing Online + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -have received had it sold the lands as the grant legislation originally required. A smaller amount of +i +i -land associated with the Coos Bay Wagon Road was also reconveyed to the United States in 1919 +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -in a similar manner, and is also included herein in the reference to "O&C lands." +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2019 - Feb 2020, Digital (C/M), People 2+ Market Line -42. The 1916 Chamberlain-Ferris Act required that the O&C lands be classified as +9 -timberlands, agriculture lands or power-site lands, that the timber on these lands be sold as rapidly + Surfing Report -as reasonably possible, and that the cutover lands classified as timber or agricultural lands be +People 2+ -returned to private ownership and county tax rolls by selling them for $2.50 per acre. An amount +People 18+ -was appropriated from the Treasury to pay counties the back taxes owed by the railroad at the time +Name -of revestment in 1916, and to pay the railroad what it would have earned from selling the lands as +UA -was originally required. Future sums from expected land and timber sales were earmarked for +Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent -sharing with the O&C Counties to offset the loss of property taxes after 1916 until the lands were +Name -finally once again all in private ownership. Those payments to counties, however, would be delayed +UA -until the federal government had first recovered from land and timber sales all amounts appropriated +Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent -in 1916 in connection with the terms of the Revestment Act. For the next 10 years the land and +Google -timber sales were insufficient to repay the amount appropriated in 1916, and the O&C Counties +Facebook -therefore received nothing from 1916 until 1926. In order to relieve the financial plight of the +YouTube -counties, Congress passed additional legislation in 1926 that appropriated monies to pay the +19,848,439 -equivalent of county taxes on the O&C lands still in federal ownership from 1916 through 1926. +17,837,239 -The policy of selling timber and then selling the cutover lands continued. +17,068,585 -Page 19 - Complaint +13:40:46 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +16,291,203,606 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 20 of 29 +Google -43. The 1926 law did not take into account that most of the remaining lands were unsuitable +18:39:42 -for agriculture, and did not consider the adverse impact that liquidating the timber with no provision +19,972,379,884 -for reforestation would have on local timber-dependent communities. Controversy regarding the +YouTube -lands continued. In 1937 Congress enacted the O&C Act, abandoning the cut-and-dispose +23:05:53 -philosophy of the 1916 and 1926 laws and replacing it with a new policy calling for permanent +23,655,150,362 -timber production from the O&C lands based on the scientific forestry principle of “sustained yield” +Facebook -to produce a permanent timber supply and to provide revenues to the O&C Counties that had been +17,943,703 -promised but not delivered by prior legislation. Determination of a sustained yield timber harvest +16,204,525 -level for a forested area requires two facts: the volume of standing timber and the “rotation period” +17,278,479 -(the time for a tree to grow from a seedling to optimum harvest size). The volume of standing timber +15:04:14 -is divided by the years in the rotation period to calculate the allowable annual sustained yield timber +16,225,558,846 -harvest, which can then continue in perpetuity. At the time of enactment of the O&C Act, Congress’ +23:52:30 -best available estimate of the standing timber on the O&C lands was approximately 50 billion board +23,213,035,282 -feet. To set an interim timber sale level pending completion of more accurate volume and rotation +19:15:20 -determinations, Congress used an approximate 100 year rotation period, and thus established 500 +19,962,616,731 -million board feet per year as the minimum required sale level until the larger sustained yield amount +MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype -could be accurately determined (i.e., annually harvesting 500 million board feet of timber for 100 +13,681,073 -years would remove 50 billion board feet of timber, while regeneration and regrowth of new trees +4:55:39 -would produce 50 billion board feet of new timber in 100 years, leaving at least as much timber +4,044,846,450 -standing at the end of the 100 years as at the beginning). To implement the new policy the O&C Act +MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype -provided: +12,995,336 -[O & C lands] classified as timberlands . . . shall be managed . . . for -permanent forest production, and the timber thereon shall be sold, cut, and -removed in conformity with the principal [sic] of sustained yield for the -purpose of providing a permanent source of timber supply, protecting -watersheds, regulating stream flow, and contributing to the economic stability -of local communities and industries, and providing recreational facilities. +Apple -Page 20 - Complaint +Instagram -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +eBay - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 21 of 29 +PayPal -The annual productive capacity for such lands shall be determined and -declared . . . Provided, that timber from said lands in an amount not less than -one-half billion feet board measure, or not less than the annual sustained yield -capacity when the same has been determined and declared, shall be sold -annually, or so much thereof as can be sold at reasonable prices on a normal -market. +Microsoft -43 U.S.C. §1181a. Thus, the O&C Act imposes four mandatory duties on the BLM: +12,866,475 -1. All of the O & C lands classified as timberlands “shall be managed . . . +12,684,785 -for permanent forest production.” +12,605,107 -2. The timber on those lands “shall be sold, cut, and removed in conformity +12,094,593 -with the princip[le] of sustained yield ....” +11,551,875 -3. “The annual productive capacity for such lands shall be determined and +ABC Online Network -declared.” +11,333,137 -4. Timber from the O&C timberlands “in an amount not less than one-half -billion feet board measure, or not less than the annual sustained yield -capacity when the same has been determined and declared, shall be sold -annually, or so much thereof as can be sold at reasonable prices on a -normal market.” +Woolworths -44. Following passage of the O&C Act, the Interior Department immediately began to +Wikipedia -determine the inventory of standing timber and the proper classification of O&C lands as +LinkedIn -timberlands. By 1942 the Department determined that 2,446,000 acres of O&C lands were properly +realestate.com.au -classified as timberlands (referred to as “O&C timberlands”). U.S. Department of Interior General +news.com.au -Land Office, Forever Timber: Perpetual Sustained Yield Forestry on the Revested Oregon and +10,376,298 -California Railroad Grant Lands and the Reconveyed Coos Bay Wagon Road Grant Lands in +10,187,717 -Western Oregon (1945) at 17. The Department also immediately began marketing timber from the +9,762,158 -O&C lands, selling 593 million board feet of timber sales from the O&C lands in fiscal year 1940. +9,634,420 -W. Horning, The O&C Lands and their Management, an Important Advance in Forest Conservation +9,348,648 -(U.S. Department of Interior General Land Office) (December 1940) at 7. +1:59:17 -45. The O&C Act authorizes the Secretary to subdivide the revested lands “into +1,534,854,537 -sustained-yield forest units, the boundary lines of which shall be so established that a forest unit will +Apple -Page 21 - Complaint +3:37:53 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +2,764,000,687 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 22 of 29 +Instagram -provide, insofar as practicable, a permanent source of raw materials for the support of dependent +1:29:37 -communities and local industries of the region ....” 43 U.S.C. §1181a. Under this authority the BLM +1,129,694,442 -has subdivided the O&C lands into five “districts” based in the western Oregon cities of Coos Bay, +eBay -Eugene, Medford, Roseburg and Salem, and a subdivision of a sixth district (the Lakeview district) +0:09:31 -based in Klamath Falls. +1:07:37 -46. After the BLM determined the annual productive capacity of the six units, the agency +1:18:02 -steadily increased the allowable sale quantities until starting in 1959 the BLM began selling an +0:19:47 -average of more than 1.1 billion board feet (bbf) of timber from the O&C lands every year for the +0:14:00 -next 32 years, with the peak sale level of 1.662 bbf occurring in 1960. See FEIS 602; Final +1:15:48 -Environmental Impact Statement for the Revision of the Resource Management Plans of the Western +0:46:34 -Oregon Bureau of Land Management (October 2008) at 3-239-40. This level of annual timber sales +0:36:05 -proved to be sustainable in perpetuity: the standing timber on the O&C lands in 1990 was greater +115,109,629 -than in 1960. FEIS 333. +PayPal -47. To provide a reliable stream of income to the O&C Counties, the O&C Act mandated that +781,266,772 -50 percent of the gross revenues from timber sales on the O & C lands be paid to the counties, 43 +Microsoft -U.S.C. §1181f (a), and that an additional 25 percent of the gross revenues from timber sales on the +884,466,592 -O & C lands also be paid to the counties under certain conditions. 43 U.S.C. §1181f (b). The +ABC Online Network -remaining 25 percent of gross revenues would go to the government to cover the administrative cost +205,325,529 -of running the sale program. +Woolworths -48. The BLM currently manages approximately 2,151,200 acres of O&C lands. FEIS 118. +142,669,437 -In 2008 the Director of the BLM recognized that “[b]ased on the O&C Act, management of timber +Wikipedia -is the dominant use of the O&C lands in western Oregon” and affirmed that “[t]he O&C Act requires +740,053,674 -O&C lands classified as timberlands to be managed for permanent forest production following the +LinkedIn -principles of sustained yield, which include determining and declaring the annual productive capacity +448,667,709 -Page 22 - Complaint +realestate.com.au -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +337,483,439 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 23 of 29 +news.com.au -of such lands with the timber from those lands (not less than the annual sustained yield capacity) +12,763,377 -being sold annually.” In 2016 Defendant Kornze again confirmed that “The O&C Act established +12,579,558 -sustained-yield timber production as the primary or dominant use of O&C lands in western Oregon.” +12,221,372 - Director’s Protest Resolution Report (August 5, 2016) 188. +11,957,707 -B. +11,265,747 -Resource Management Plan Development and Revision under FLPMA. +10,981,388 -49. FLPMA, adopted in 1976, requires the BLM to “develop, maintain, and, when +10,298,974 -appropriate, revise land use plans which provide by tracts or areas for the use of the public lands.” +9,957,687 -43 U.S.C. §1712(a). FLPMA also requires the BLM to provide the public adequate notice and +9,737,846 -opportunity to comment upon and participate in the formulation of plans and programs relating to +9,463,425 -the management of the public lands. 43 U.S.C. §1712(f). FLPMA’s procedural measures apply to +9,174,848 -the O&C lands, but in the event FLPMA conflicts with the substantive measures of the O&C Act +5:10:42 -“insofar as they relate to the management of timber resources,” the O&C Act prevails. 43 U.S.C.A. +2:00:13 -§ 1701 Savings Provision Note (West 2010). +3:39:33 -C. +1:31:56 -BLM Management of O& C lands since 1994. +0:09:35 -50. In 1994 the Secretaries of Interior and Agriculture adopted a land management plan +1:08:45 -known as the Northwest Forest Plan (NWFP) for the administration of the O&C lands as well as all +1:19:29 -or parts of 19 national forests in Washington, Oregon and California that lie within the range of the +0:19:53 -northern spotted owl, a bird that was listed throughout its range as a threatened species under the +0:14:15 -Endangered Species Act in 1990. 55 Fed. Reg. 26114 (June 26, 1990). +1:15:58 -51. The BLM adopted RMPs in 1995 to implement the NWFP. The 1995 RMPs reduced +0:46:50 -the annual sustained yield timber level on the O&C lands to 211 mmbf, an 82% reduction from the +0:36:24 -previous allowable level. FEIS 341. The annual harvest level was later further reduced to 203 +4,037,669,825 -million board feet, id, but in 2016 BLM recalculated that ASQ and raised it to 277 million board feet +1,534,537,028 -based on new data and analysis. Id. The 1995 plans permitted sustained yield timber management +2,761,947,509 -Page 23 - Complaint +1,123,728,567 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +114,630,946 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 24 of 29 +774,538,814 -on only 27 percent of the O&C timberlands. As a result of these decisions, the revenues from O&C +872,997,444 -timber sales dropped sharply, severely reducing payments to the 18 O&C Counties in western +204,886,013 -Oregon. To replace the lost revenues to the O&C counties, starting in the mid-1990's the federal +141,942,109 -government appropriated and paid several billion dollars of direct federal payments to the counties, +739,859,176 -with the funding levels steadily dropping as time passed, and ending in 2016. As a result of the +443,213,459 -absence of O&C timber revenues and the diminishing federal grant program, exacerbated in recent +333,989,057 -years by poor economic conditions, rural western Oregon counties have faced, and continue to face, +Source: Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2020, People 2+, People 13+, Unique Audience, Avg TIme Spent, Total Time Spent. +*YouTube reporting is sourced from DCR Monthly Total Video -a grave financial crisis, with counties publically discussing bankruptcy filings and wholesale layoffs +10 -of law enforcement personnel. +. +. -52. Plaintiffs AFRC, CIC, C & D, Swanson and other citizens filed a legal challenge in this +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Streaming Video + +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. + + Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent + +Demo + +Total 18+ +Total 18 - 24 +Total 25 - 34 +Total 35 - 44 +Total 45 - 54 +Total 55 - 64 +Total 65+ +Total Female 18+ +Female 18 - 24 +Female 25 - 34 +Female 35 - 44 +Female 45 - 54 +Female 55 - 64 +Female 65+ +Total Male 18+ +Male 18 - 24 +Male 25 - 34 +Male 35 - 44 +Male 45 - 54 +Male 55 - 64 +Male 65+ + +Unique Audience +16,888,355 + +Population Reach (%) +86% + +Average Time Spent +37:42:52 + +2,224,910 +3,636,729 +3,163,950 +2,933,646 +2,574,718 +2,417,820 +8,663,869 +1,099,710 +1,829,763 +1,598,064 +1,560,162 +1,359,606 +1,216,564 +8,287,904 +1,125,200 +1,806,966 +1,565,886 +1,373,484 +1,215,112 +1,201,256 + +94.5% +96.7% +95.6% +90.7% +88.3% +61.0% +87.1% +95.6% +96.8% +96.2% +94.5% +91.1% +57.8% +86.4% +93.5% +96.6% +94.9% +86.7% +85.4% +64.7% + +70:58:47 +43:08:00 +37:51:40 +33:36:20 +20:05:40 +16:42:54 +32:57:32 +57:17:19 +38:46:58 +32:35:06 +32:47:02 +19:27:09 +18:00:58 +40:59:43 +84:21:38 +47:32:19 +43:14:45 +34:32:20 +20:48:47 +15:23:50 + +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census + +12 + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent + +Unique Audience + +Population Reach% + +Average Time Spent + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -Court against the Secretary of Interior’s adoption of the 1994 NWFP in American Forest Resource +i +i -Council et al. v. Dombeck, No. C94-1031 (D.D.C.). On October 17, 2003 the parties in that case +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -(then captioned AFRC v. Caswell) entered into a Settlement Agreement to resolve the case, which +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census -included an agreement for the BLM to “revise its resource management plans for its Coos Bay, +13 -Eugene, Lakeview, Medford, Roseburg and Salem Districts by December 31, 2008.” Settlement + Streaming Video Report - Total - Computer -Agreement, paragraph 3.5. +Name -53. In 2005 the BLM began the plan revision process required by the 2003 Settlement +Market Total -Agreement, which BLM called the Western Oregon Plan Revision (WOPR). Each of the six WOPR +Facebook -plans was prepared and adopted in accordance with the BLM’s FLPMA land use planning +YouTube -regulations. The BLM undertook extensive public involvement during the plan revision process, +news.com.au* -beginning in August 2005 and extending through December 2008. +Netflix -54. On December 30, 2008 the Secretary of Interior approved the WOPR RODs for the six +ABC Online Network -BLM districts consistent with the schedule in the Settlement Agreement in AFRC v. Caswell. See +Pinterest -74 Fed. Reg. 829 (January 8, 2009). The six WOPR RODs went into effect immediately. Id. The +Yahoo! -Page 24 - Complaint +9Now* -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +smh.com.au - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 25 of 29 +Daily Mail Australia* -six WOPR RODs collectively directed the BLM to offer 502 million board feet of timber per year. +Reddit -55. On July 16, 2009, the Department of Interior’s Acting Assistant Secretary of Interior for +nine.com.au* -Land and Minerals Management purported to withdraw the WOPR RODs through a two-page +Instagram -internal memorandum to the Acting Director of the BLM. The decision included direction for the +SBS (Special Broadcasting Service)* -BLM to return to management of the O&C lands under its 1995 RMPs, id., and the BLM did so. +UA -56. Plaintiffs DTO, CIC, Seneca Jones and Swanson Group filed a lawsuit in this court +Pop Base -challenging the withdrawal of the WOPR RODs. On March 31, 2011 the court found that the +Reach % -withdrawal was procedurally unlawful under FLPMA, and vacated and remanded the unlawful +10,010,479 -withdrawal decision, which had the effect of reinstating the WOPR. Douglas Timber Operators v. +6,300,756 -Salazar, 774 F.Supp.2d 245, 261-62 (D.D.C. 2011). +6,283,189 -57. Environmental groups then filed an action in Oregon challenging the BLM's failure to +1,740,628 -engage in consultation on the WOPR RODs under the ESA, 16 U.S.C. §1536(a)-(b), with the U.S. +1,602,615 -Fish and Wildlife Service and the Commerce Department’s NOAA Fisheries. Pacific Rivers Council +975,781 -v. Shepard, Civ. No. 11-442-HU (D. Or. filed April 8, 2011). The Oregon district court entered an +952,349 -order on May 16,2012 vacating the WOPR RODs and reinstating the 1995 RMPs. +888,471 -58. On March 12, 2012 the Interior Department announced that BLM would commence a +812,255 -new process for revising the 1995 RMPs. That process culminated in the decision by defendant +766,276 -Kornze on August 5, 2016 adopting the 2016 RMPs for the six BLM districts in Western Oregon. +719,233 -59. The BLM has determined that at the present time the annual productive capacity of the +710,274 -O&C timberlands, based on the entire land base of O&C timberlands, is approximately 1.2 billion +699,436 -board feet of timber per year. FEIS 340, 1853. The current standing volume of timber on the O&C +629,777 -timberlands is 72-73.3 billion board feet. FEIS 334, 335 (two differing estimates). +623,930 -60. The 2016 RMPs together designate 957,872 acres (38 percent of the total area) of O&C +19,774,230 -timberlands as late-successional reserves where the sale, cutting and removal of timber in conformity +19,774,230 -Page 25 - Complaint +19,774,230 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +19,774,230 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 26 of 29 +19,774,230 -with the principles of sustained yield timber management is prohibited. The 2016 RMPs designate +19,774,230 -another 520,092 acres (21 percent of the total area) as “Riparian Reserves” where the sale, cutting +19,774,230 -and removal of timber in conformity with the principles of sustained yield timber management is +19,774,230 -prohibited. Finally, the 2016 RMPs designate another 362,894 acres (15 percent of the total area) +19,774,230 -as “Other Reserves,” including Special Recreation Management Areas, where the sale, cutting and +19,774,230 -removal of timber in conformity with the principles of sustained yield timber management is +19,774,230 -prohibited. The 2016 RMPs designate only 498,597 acres (20 percent of the lands suitable for timber +19,774,230 -production) as the “Harvest Land Base” available for sustained-yield timber management, and even +19,774,230 -that small area is subject to harvest constraints inconsistent with sustained-yield management under +19,774,230 -the O&C Act. The level of permitted annual sustained-yield timber harvest dropped from 277 +19,774,230 -million board feet under the Northwest Forest Plan (as recalculated by BLM in 2016) to 205 million +50.6 -board feet, a 26 percent reduction. FEIS 341. In southwestern Oregon, the reductions are even +31.9 -greater on a percentage basis: the Coos Bay ASQ falls from 46 million board feet to 12 million board +31.8 -feet, a 74 percent drop; the Medford ASQ declines from 73 million board feet to 37 million board +8.8 -feet, a 49 percent drop; and the Roseburg ASQ goes down from 55 million board feet to 32 million +8.1 -board feet, a 42 percent drop. +4.9 -61. The legal violations described below are causing current and threatened injury to +4.8 -plaintiffs, who have no remedy at law for these injuries. +4.5 -CLAIM FOR RELIEF +4.1 -(Violation of O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. §1181a; arbitrary and capricious agency action under 5 -U.S.C. §706(2); approval of 2016 RMPs that fail to require management of O&C -timberlands for permanent sustained yield timber production, fail to sell timber from O&C -timberlands in conformity with the principle of sustained yield, unlawfully determine and -declare the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands, and fail to require annual -offering of timber sales equal to the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands) +3.9 -62. Plaintiffs repeat and reallege the allegations in paragraphs 1-61 as if fully set forth +3.6 -herein. +3.6 -Page 26 - Complaint +3.5 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +3.2 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 27 of 29 +3.2 -63. The 2016 RMPs violate the O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. § 1181a. The RMPs do not allow the +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Video, 0 secs Qualifier, February 2020, People 18+, Computer, Unique Audience, Population Base, Reach % +*Brands marked with an asterisk represent metrics from tagged methodology. -timber on 74 percent of the O&C timberlands to be sold, cut, and removed in conformity with the +14 -principle of sustained yield by assigning those lands to land use allocations that do not permit +. +. -sustained yield timber production, and place unlawful constraints on management of the 20 percent +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -of O&C timberlands in the “Harvest Land Base” that prevent full sustained yield timber production +i +i -of those lands. Although the actual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands is approximately +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -1.2 billion board feet per year, the 2016 RMPs set the annual sustained yield harvest level at 205 + Streaming Video Report - Tagged - 2 secs -million board feet, just 17 percent of the required total. The BLM is not selling, and has no intention +Name -of selling, the actual annual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands of approximately 1.2 billion +SWM 7 -board feet. +news.com.au -64. The non-discretionary duties imposed on the BLM by the O&C Act to manage all O&C +nine.com.au -timberlands for sustained yield timber production are the exclusive criteria for management of the +9Now -O&C timberlands. The O&C Act does not identify wildlife conservation or the protection of +Daily Mail Australia -threatened or endangered species as a factor for management of the O&C timberlands. When +Network 10 -adopting a resource management plan for the O&C lands as required by FLPMA, the O&C Act +Whimn -prohibits the BLM from considering any factors outside the O&C Act. The BLM does not have +taste.com.au -authority under the O&C Act to manage any of the O&C timberlands for wildlife conservation or +SBS (Special Broadcasting Service) -protection of endangered or threatened species in a manner that does not constitute sustained yield +perthnow -timber production required by the O&C Act. Nonetheless, the 2016 RMPs unlawfully assert that +The Daily Telegraph -“[t]he purpose of the action includes contributing to the conservation and recovery of threatened and +couriermail.com.au -endangered species within the planning area, including the northern spotted owl, marbled murrelet, +AdelaideNow -and threatened and endangered anadromous fish” and that this purpose “necessarily includes +Herald Sun -maintaining a network of large blocks of forest to be managed for late-successional forests and +THE AUSTRALIAN -maintaining older and more structurally-complex multi-layered conifer forests.” FEIS 7. Defendant +UA -Page 27 - Complaint +Pop Base -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +Reach % - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 28 of 29 +3,491,937 -Kornze expressly asserted on August 5, 2016 that “[t]he BLM must comply with the O&C Act as +2,689,535 -well as other environmental statutes, including ... the ESA.” +1,936,015 -65. The BLM’s approval of the 2016 RMPs that fail to require management of O&C +1,904,222 -timberlands for sustained yield timber production, fail to sell timber from O&C timberlands in +1,431,763 -conformity with the principle of sustained yield, fail to determine and declare the annual productive +1,238,902 -capacity of O&C timberlands, and fail to require annual offering of timber sales equal to the annual +587,609 -productive capacity of O&C timberlands in accordance with the O&C Act is arbitrary and capricious, +431,831 -an abuse of discretion, not in accordance with law, without observance of procedure required by law, +404,486 -in excess of statutory authority and short of statutory right under 5 U.S.C. § 706(2). +387,648 -PRAYER FOR RELIEF +303,779 -WHEREFORE, plaintiffs pray for judgment as follows: +275,778 -1. +165,451 -A declaration that defendant Kornze’s decision to approve the 2016 RMPs that fail to +161,710 -require management of O&C timberlands for permanent sustained yield timber production, fail to +115,625 -sell timber from O&C timberlands in conformity with the principle of sustained yield, fail to +19,774,230 -determine and declare the annual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands, and fail to require +19,774,230 -annual offering of timber sales equal to the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands in +19,774,230 -accordance with the O&C Act violates the O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. § 1181a, and that these violations +19,774,230 -are arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discretion, not in accordance with law, without observance +19,774,230 -of procedure required by law, in excess of statutory authority and short of statutory right under 5 +19,774,230 -U.S.C. § 706(2). +19,774,230 -2. +19,774,230 -A declaration that the non-discretionary duties imposed on the BLM by the O&C Act are +19,774,230 -the exclusive criteria for management of the O&C timberlands, that when the BLM adopts a resource +19,774,230 -management plan for the O&C lands as required by FLPMA, the O&C Act prohibits the BLM from +19,774,230 -considering any factors outside the O&C Act, and that the BLM does not have authority under the +19,774,230 -Page 28 - Complaint +19,774,230 -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +19,774,230 - Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 29 of 29 +19,774,230 -O&C Act to manage any of the O&C timberlands for wildlife conservation or protection of +18 -endangered or threatened species in a manner that does not constitute sustained-yield timber +14 -production required by the O&C Act. +10 -3. +10 -4. +7 -An order vacating and remanding the 2016 RMPs to the Secretary of Interior. +6 -An injunction requiring the BLM to offer at least 500 million board feet of timber sales +3 -from O&C timberlands annually at reasonable prices on a normal market until the BLM adopts new +2 -RMPs that comply with the O&C Act. +2 -5. +2 -An order awarding plaintiff AFRC its attorneys fees under the Equal Access to Justice +2 -Act, 28 U.S.C. §2412. +1 -6. +1 -Granting plaintiffs such further relief as may be just, proper and equitable. +1 -Dated this 5th day of August, 2016. +1 -By: /s/ +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Tagged, Video, 2 secs Qualifier ,Ad Supported (Video), February 2020, People 18+, Digital (C/M), Unique Audience, Population +Base, Reach % -Mark C. Rutzick, D.C. Bar No. 979547 -markrutzick@rutzick.com -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct., Oak Hill, VA 20171 -Telephone/Facsimile: (703) 870-7347 -Attorney for Plaintiffs +15 -Page 29 - Complaint +. +. -Mark C. Rutzick, Inc. -12402 Myra Virginia Ct -Oak Hill, Virginia 20171 - Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a + +l +l + +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_4.md b/q12/random_k4/random_4.md index 4f893ddec7d5896260cf6c80e16cbb4898829c99..93421da53624a4659d5f91ceaa6a712c34229053 100644 --- a/q12/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q12/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,422 +1,2535 @@ -# **Robust Reasoning Benchmark** +BY08 Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary +Exhibit 300 -# **Pavel Golikov[1,2] , Evgenii Opryshko[1,2] , Gennady Pekhimenko[1,2] , Mark C. Jeffrey[1]** +PART I: SUMMARY INFORMATION AND JUSTIFICATION -1University of Toronto, 2Vector Institute +In Part I, complete Sections A. B, C, and D for all capital assets (IT and non-IT). Complete Sections E and +F for IT capital assets. -## **Abstract** +Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) -While Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve high performance on standard mathematical benchmarks, their underlying reasoning processes remain highly overfit to standard textual formatting. We propose a perturbation pipeline consisting of 14 techniques to evaluate robustness of LLM reasoning. We apply this pipeline to AIME 2024 dataset and evalute 8 state-of-the-art models on the resulting benchmark. While frontier models exhibit resilience, open-weights reasoning models suffer catastrophic collapses (up to 55% average accuracy drops across perturbations and up to 100% on some), exposing structural fragility. To further disentangle mechanical parsing failures from downstream reasoning failures, we strictly isolate the models’ working memory capacity by forcing models to solve multiple unperturbed mathematical problems sequentially within a single context window. Our results indicate that open weight models ranging from 7B to 120B parameters and Claude Opus 4.6 exhibit accuracy decay on subsequent problems. This degradation demonstrates that intermediate reasoning steps permanently pollute standard dense attention mechanisms. We argue that to achieve reliable reasoning, future reasoning architectures must integrate explicit contextual resets within a model’s own Chain-of-Thought, leading to fundamental open questions regarding the optimal granularity of atomic reasoning tasks. +The following series of questions are to be completed for all investments to help OMB to identify which +agency and bureau is responsible for managing each capital asset, which OMB MAX budget account funds +the project, the kind of the project, who to contact with questions about the information provided in the +exhibit 300, and whether or not it is an IT or a non-IT capital asset. -## **1 Introduction** +(1) Date of Submission: +(2) Agency: +(3) Bureau: +(4) Name of this Capital Asset: -Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success on mathematical reasoning benchmarks, with state-of-the-art models approaching saturation on datasets like AIME, GSM8K, and MATH [6, 13, 25]. These results have fueled the perception that LLMs possess robust algorithmic reasoning capabilities—the ability to decompose complex problems into logical intermediate steps. However, a growing body of literature [26, 18, 29] suggests that this performance may be brittle, relying instead on probabilistic pattern matching and surface-level correlations. +09/11/2006 +422 -To distinguish between robust reasoning and fragile memorization, recent research has turned to adversarial evaluation. Existing approaches generally fall into two categories: changing numeric values to test arithmetic generalization [35, 53, 42] or increasing environmental complexity by adding irrelevant context or harder logic [39, 19, 2]. While valuable, these methods often introduce confounding variables. When a model fails after numerical perturbation, it is unclear whether the failure lies in the reasoning logic or the arithmetic calculation. Similarly, when a model fails on a more complex problem, it is difficult to distinguish between a lack of robustness and a hard limit on the model’s inherent capacity. Furthermore, some benchmarks rely on LLMs to generate the perturbations, introducing non-deterministic noise and potential validity errors into the evaluation pipeline. +00 -In this paper, we first propose an evaluation framework based on 14 deterministic structural perturbations: the Robust Reasoning Benchmark (RRB). Unlike prior work, we do not alter the mathematical values, the logic, or the final answer. Instead, we apply reversible algorithmic transformations, such as syntactic string reversals, visual 2D grid encodings (e.g., Rail Fence, Snake), and semantic +Financial Accounting System (FAS) -Preprint. +(250 Character Max) +(5) Unique ID (Unique Project +Identifier ) : +Format xxx-xx-xx-xx-xx-xxxx-xx +(For IT investments only, see section 53. For all other, use agency ID system.) -**==> picture [393 x 109] intentionally omitted <==** +422-00-01-01-01-0001-00 -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-100
User Prompt Example 90 -0.4% -1.2%
Solve these completely unrelated math problems. For 80 -13.8% -6.7% -7.1%
eachProblemproblem1: Findput theyournumberfinal ofanswerwayswithinto place\boxed{}.a ... 70 -7.1%
-10.6%
Problem 2: Let ABC be a triangle inscribed ... 60
Problem 3: Let p be the least prime number for... 50 1 4 1 4 1 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 1 -7.1%2 3
The last problem (3) is the target problem. The
prior problems (1 and 2) are distractor problems.
Gemini 3.1 Pro gpt-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6Qwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-32BNemotron-7BGPT-OSS-120BDSR1-Llama-70B
Accuracy on Last Problem (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+(6) What kind of investment +Will in be this FY2008? +(7) What was the first budget +year this investment was +submitted to OMB? +Operations and Maintenance -Figure 1: **The Intra-Query Attention Dilution.** _Left:_ The sequential cognitive overload setup, where models are prompted to solve multiple independent AIME 2024 problems within a single prompt. _Right:_ Mathematical accuracy strictly on the _final_ problem of the sequence. While frontier APIs like Gemini 3.1 Pro and GPT-5.4 exhibit strong resilience, Claude Opus 4.6 and all tested open-weights models suffer a degradation in reasoning accuracy. This reasoning degradation seems to be scale-invariant across open weight models ranging from 7B to 120B parameters. This suggests that prior reasoning steps permanently degrade subsequent reasoning ability, highlighting a fundamental architectural need for explicit working memory isolation inside of model’s own chain-of-thought. +FY2001 or earlier -wrappers. We provide the descriptions of the transformation in context to isolate the ability to perform the reverse transformation from the ability to recognize the transformation in the first place. Our transformations are cognitively trivial for humans to decode but structurally hostile to LLM tokenization and attention mechanisms. +(8) Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this +closes a gap in part or in whole an identified agency performance gap: (2500 Char Max) -To further disentangle parsing failures from reasoning failures, we additionally task models with solving several mathematical problems within a single query. By measuring the accuracy only on the last problem, we identify **Intra-Query Attention Dilution** . As visualized in Figure 1, the accuracy on the last problem degrades as the context window is polluted by the model’s own prior reasoning steps. This effect persists across open-weights models from 7B to 120B parameters. +The Financial Accounting System (FAS) is the main tool NSF staff utilizes to monitor, control, and execute the +management and financial accountability of approximately 20,000 active awards with 2000+ external +grantees. The FAS is an on-line real time system is the primary vehicle for managing all funding allocated to the +NSF. A central transaction management procedure called the "post-routine" represents the core of the system, +handling the full spectrum of financial transaction processing, accounts maintenance, transaction history, and +rules processing. This procedure processes any financial request, whether generated from within the Financial +System itself or by an external system. The FAS is extensively integrated with all of NSF's core business +systems including the e-Jacket, Proposal and Reviewer System, the Awards System, Guest Travel System, and +the FastLane System in support of Grants management. NSF's accounting and financial systems staff +created a data warehousing environment with the ability to produce our financial statements including the +Closing Package statements, generate automated closing entries and in produce the SGL Tie points reports. In +FY06, NSF implemented a near real-time interface between FAS and FedTraveler that -Long-context attention drift is a recognized challenge in information retrieval [37] and recent systemprompt leaks [46], A.5 from proprietary agentic frameworks suggest the industry is attempting to mitigate this through the use of explicit contextual resets. In this work, we demonstrate that such pollution exists even within the span of a single query. We argue that this represents a fundamental architectural limitation of the standard dense attention mechanism, which lacks the inherent capacity for working memory isolation. To achieve reliable algorithmic reasoning, we argue that future architectures must integrate explicit contextual resets within the model’s own Chain-of-Thought or use alternative mechanisms to achieve the same effect, such as using sub-agents [44, 55]. This introduces an open research question regarding the optimal _granularity of reasoning_ , which we further discuss in A.4. +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -In summary, our contributions are: +1 of 18 -- A taxonomy and implementation pipeline of 14 deterministic textual transforms that perturb structure without altering meaning or difficulty, allowing to evaluate robustness of LLMs to textual perturbations. +FY08 Exhibit 300 -- A benchmark, based on AIME 2024 dataset, with 14 textual perturbations that can be used to evaluate robustness of LLM reasoning. + includes evaluation of funds availability and funds obligation. NSF expects the same type of data exchanges with +other externally provided cross-services. The e-Learning and e-Procurement /FAS interfaces are +scheduled to be implemented in FY 2007. The FAS will remain in a steady-state phase in the FY05-FY10 +timeframe. NSF will be approaching its future financial system requirements as an integral part of its grant +process. NSF will conduct an integrated review of the GMLOB/FMLOB solution in 2007. If that solution is +determined to not be feasible, NSF will analyze the FMLOB Shared Service Provider (SSP) options in 2008. If +necessary, NSF will conduct a Business Case Feasibility Study for the FMLOB solution in 2009. This plan allows +the NSF to take advantage of the results/findings of the GMLOB process in becoming a SSP to more fully +define our financial requirements. NSF anticipates that if a conversion is necessary it will substantially impact +NSF Grantees and will begin in 2010. The current FAS will remain in steady-state maintenance until the +conversion is complete. Any decisions NSF makes regarding the future financial system modernization will +support the President's Management Agenda. -- A comprehensive evaluation and analysis of LLM reasoning robustness on benchmark generated from AIME 2024 datset across 5 open-source models and 3 closed-source flagship models (GPT-5.4, Gemini-3.1 Pro, Claude 4.6 Opus). +(9) Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee approve this request? -## **2 Background and Related Work** +a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval? -## **2.1 Reasoning Large Language Models** +(10) Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? -There are several benchmarks introduced to evaluate the performance of LLMs on mathematical reasoning tasks, such as GSM8K, MATH, AIME 2024 [6, 13, 25]. Techniques like Chain-of-Thought +11) Contact Information of Project Manager? -2 +N a me : +Phone Number: +E-Mail: -(CoT) and Tree-of-Thought (ToT) [49, 54] have been the primary drivers of this success. However, static benchmark accuracy can mask the fragility of the underlying thinking process. +Carolyn Miller -While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at pattern matching, distinguishing this from genuine reasoning remains a challenge. Following the classical definition by Newell & Simon [28], reasoning involves the manipulation of symbols to bridge premises and conclusions. In cognitive science, this aligns with algorithmic thinking - a slow, deliberate, and multi-step process - as opposed to the rapid, intuitive processing often associated with neural inference [20]. +703-292-4272 -A critical attribute of robust reasoning is invariance to surface-level perturbations. If a model truly understands the concepts and how to manipulate them (like words, sentences, symbols, and math operations), it should be resistant to both surface-level perturbations and deeper logical distractions. +cmiller@nsf.gov -## **2.2 Prior Works** +yes -**Surface-level and Informational Perturbations.** A prominent line of prior work evaluates robustness by introducing irrelevant information or lexical shifts to test whether a model is reasoning or merely pattern matching. GSM-Symbolic [27], PROBLEMATHIC [2], and others [39, 18, 19] demonstrate the fragility of LLM math reasoning by injecting irrelevant numeric variables or token biases. Beyond irrelevant information, RUPBench [48], ROMMATH [56], and meaning-preserving rephrasing studies [22, 12, 43, 21, 15, 57, 1] systematically quantify how homophones, sentence rephrasings, and visual attacks degrade accuracy. Unlike these methods, which can introduce semantic ambiguity or rely on LLM-generation, our perturbations are strictly deterministic and textualy based. By explicitly providing the decoding rule, we isolate pure structural fragility without altering the semantic or logical constraints of the problem. +. -**Dataset Contamination, Memorization, and Numerical Variations.** Another approach alters values and variables to prove the model is not simply reciting training data. Works like [35, 29, 23, 42, 52] dynamically alter numeric values or utilize abstract syntax trees to minimally edit problems, while [41, 51] convert static problems into code functions to enable autmatic generation or measuring memorization limits. Embers of Autoregression [26] demonstrates that performance is heavily driven by text probability. While changing numbers effectively tests memorization, it modifies the mathematical constraints themselves. Our approach preserves the exact pristine mathematical state. Furthermore, unlike Embers, which solely tests text decoding, we force the model to sequentially decode **and** reason, evaluating how decoding structural noise impacts downstream logic. +08/30/2006 -**Perturbations within Chain-of-Thought Trajectories.** Recent work explores robustness by perturbing the intermediate steps of a model’s reasoning trajectory. Von Recum et al. [47] and Fragile Thoughts [5] inject errors or interventions directly into the CoT to highlight that internal reasoning processes remain susceptible to derailment. Rather than perturbing the active reasoning steps, our work pollutes the initial problem presentation. +yes -**Formal, Symbolic, and Difficulty-Based Evaluations.** Several works modify existing benchmarks to evolve their inherent difficulty. Frameworks like Algebraic Circuit Complexity [17], ASyMOB [38], and others [40, 24, 16, 14] design controlled environments, perform confusing parameter substitutions, or rewrite questions into more mathematically complex versions. These benchmarks intentionally increase the mathematical or algorithmic complexity of the task. In contrast, our textual transformations maintain a constant level of difficulty. Moreover, our method is entirely domain-agnostic and can be applied at scale to any existing LaTeX-formatted math dataset without requiring complex problem rewrites. +(12) Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost effective, energy-efficient and environmentally +sustainable techniques or practices for this project. -3 +no -**==> picture [350 x 356] intentionally omitted <==** +(a) Will this investment include electronic assets (including computers)? -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Semantic and Lexical Substitutions Visual Encoding
Original Problem
Rail Fence Cipher
Let $p$ be the least prime number for L...$...b...h...e... ...m...u...r...r
which there exists a positive integer $n$ .e. .p. .e.t.e.l.a.t.p.i.e.n.m.e. .o.
such that ... ..t...$... ... ...s...r... ...b...f..
Not Not
Let $p$ be the not not least not not prime Rectangle Perimeter
not not number for which there exists a Let $p$ be the least prime number for
... ....................................
....................................w
$...................................h
Opposites
Forbid $p$ be the most antiprime ...
defyn{let "most" mean "least", let "For Snake Horizontal
bid" mean "Let"}. → Let $p$ be the least prime number
...is indivisible by $pˆ{2}$. ← vitisop a stsixe ereht hcihw rof
Wrappers Snake Vertical
Let $3(p)$ be the least prime 2(number) Le t m b h i e p o n t s $ i
fordefyn{letwhich "3(p)"there existsmean "p",a ......let "7(p)" etbthsapurn er w hc er xi a si i eg $n uc ta nˆ $1s
mean "p"}. $eei r e s t e e $ h h { + d
...divisible by $7(p)ˆ{9(2)}$. $p lme f o t h t s i v r t 4 } i
Syntactic Distortions
Contextual Overload
Sentence Reversal
Line-Level
A> LetLet $ABCD$$p$ be bethea leasttetr ...... Findthat the$nˆ{4}+1$least positiveis divisibleintegerby $pˆ{2}$.$m$ such
ositive integer $n$ ... Let $p$ be the least prime number ...
Word Reversal
Word-level
$pˆ{2}$. by divisible is $mˆ{4}+1$ that
Let Let $p$ $ABCD$ be be the a least such $m$ integer positive least the Find
tetrahedron prime such number that ...
Symbol Reversal
Symbol-level teL $p$ eb eht tsael emirp rebmun rof
LLeett $$pA$B CbDe$ tbhee al etaest hcihw ereht stsixe a evitisop regetni $n$
tr aphreidmreo nn usmubcehr tfhoart ...
**----- End of picture text -----**
+yes +(b) Is this investment for new construction or major retrofit of a Federal building or +facility? (answer applicable to non-IT assets only) +[1] If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help fund this investment? +[2] If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable design principles? +[3] If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy efficient than relevant code? -Figure 2: Examples of the 13 structural transformations applied to a sample mathematical query. Target problems and lengthier text mappings have been truncated (...) for brevity. +(13) Does this investment support one of the PMA initiatives? yes -## **3 Adversarial Transformations and Context Pollution** +If "yes," select all that apply: +President's Management Agenda (PMA) Initiatives +E x p a n d e d E - G o v e r n m e n t -To evaluate the robustness of mathematical reasoning, we design 14 input perturbations, grouped into four broad categories. These transformations are strictly textual and deterministic; they are cognitively trivial for a human with pen, paper, and access to the decoding rules. Examples in Figure 2. +Budget Performance Integration -## **3.1 Semantic and Lexical Substitutions** +a. Briefly describe how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)? -This category challenges the model’s ability to maintain logical coherence when linguistic structures are obscured by aliasing or redundant operators. **Not Not:** We insert double negations (“not not”) prior to numerical values and adjectives. Because the double negation is logically equivalent to the original term, a robust reasoner should parse and discard these terms without altering its mathematical logic. **Opposites:** Semantic terms within the query are remapped to antonyms (e.g., “short” means “long”, “stop” means “goes”). **Wrappers:** Terms are encapsulated within arbitrary syntactic wrappers (e.g., replacing “morning” with “3(morning)”). All wrappers are strictly identity functions. For both **Opposites** and **Wrappers** , the specific localized substitutions are explicitly defined inside a of the user query. Solving these problems requires precise, localized key-value substitution. +NSF's Enterprise Information System, the FAS and the Report web reporting system provide +financial, budgetary, awards and performance information (including PART) that is accessible in -4 +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -## **3.2 Contextual Overload and Saturation** +2 of 18 -**Interleaved Contexts:** The text of two distinct math problems (Problem A and Problem B) is interwoven into a single prompt. The model is explicitly instructed to only solve Problem A. We evaluate three granularities of interleaving. **Line-level:** The statements are split into line segments of at most 60 symbols. Each segment is placed on a separate line, prefixed by a tag (e.g., `` ), and segments for two problems are strictly alternated. **Word-level:** The words of Problem A and Problem B are strictly alternated one by one. **Symbol-level:** The individual characters/symbols of the two problems are alternatingly interwoven. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the remaining gaps are padded by repeating the shorter problem from its beginning. +FY08 Exhibit 300 -**Context Saturation.** Distinct from algorithmic interleaving, context saturation investigates the impact of domain-specific noise on long-horizon reasoning. We prepend the question with synthetic mathematical questions paired with Chain-of-Thought reasoning trajectories generated by an open source model before asking the target non-transformed question. + multiple formats at every workstation on a 24/7, real-time basis. Managers use this information to +make decisions regarding NSF budget priorities and business processes. NSF's Statement of Net +Cost uses the FAS to report the full cost of each strategic goal - Ideas, Tools, People and +Stewardship. -## **3.3 Syntactic Distortions** +(14) Does this investment support a program assessed using OMB's +Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? +(a) If "yes," does this investment address a +weakness found during a PART review? +(b) If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed +program ? +(c) If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? -Transformations in this category belong to “split-modify-join” paradigm. In these permutations, the text is partitioned based on a specific delimiter (e.g., spaces or periods), and either the order of the resulting tokens is reversed, or the sequence of symbols within each token is reversed. While this can be extended to arbitrary delimiters or multi-stage combinations, we focus on three foundational variants. **Sentence Reversal:** The order of sentences (defined as sequences of symbols separated by periods) in the user query has been reversed. **Word Reversal:** The order of words (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query has been reversed. **Symbol Reversal:** Every word (words defined as in Word Reversal above) in user query has its symbols in reverse order. +no -## **3.4 Visual and Spatial Encoding** +(15) Is this investment for information technology? (see section 53 for definition)) yes -This category tests the model’s character-level attention by mapping the 1D problem string onto a 2D visual grid. All transformed inputs in this category are bounded by `GRID START` and `GRID END` markers. We evaluate four distinct spatial transformations. **Rail Fence Cipher:** The symbols of the encoded string are placed in a zigzag pattern across multiple rails (rows), and empty spatial gaps are filled with dots ( `.` ) [50]. **Rectangle Perimeter:** User query is mapped onto the perimeter of a rectangle. The message is written as a single continuous string following the edges of the shape in a clockwise manner, beginning at the top-left. **Snake Vertical:** User query is written into a grid using a vertical ‘snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written down the first column, then up the second column, then down the third, etc... **Snake Horizontal:** The user query is written into a grid using a horizontal ‘snake’ (boustrophedon) pattern. +If the answer to Question 15 was "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If +the answer is "No," do not answer questions 16-23. -## **4 Methodology and Results** +Level 1 -## **4.1 Methodology** + (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this +investment -**Dataset Preprocessing and Sanitization** To ensure our evaluation strictly measures mathematical reasoning and avoid introducing low-level parsing or tokenizer artifacts, we apply a preprocessing pipeline to AIME 2024 [25]. String reversals can create executable escape sequences. For instance, if a variable is enclosed in escaped parentheses, e.g., `\(b\)` , character reversal yields `\)\b(\` . During string rendering, `\b` may be interpreted as a backspace, thereby silently deleting the preceding character. To eliminate information loss, we apply three preprocessing steps to all problem statements prior to transformation. For completeness, we apply these steps to the baseline as well. **LaTeX Comment Removal:** We strip all inline LaTeX comments. **Newline Flattening:** We replace all newline characters with a semicolon followed by a space ( `;` ). This preserves the logical segmentation of the text while preventing spatial layout anomalies that can confuse the model’s spatial attention during transformation reversal. **Escape Sequence Neutralization:** We systematically insert a space between backslashes and specific characters ( `n, t, b, r, a, f` ) to neutralize the accidental formation of control characters during string reversal. These sanitization steps are semantically invariant; they do not meaningfully alter the mathematical problem and are trivial for a human reader to parse and ignore. +no -5 +No -**Transformation Design Principles** To ensure rigor, fairness, and consistency, every adversarial transformation adheres to four guidelines: +(16) What is the level of the IT Project (per CIO +Council PM Guidance)? +(17) What project management qualifications does +the Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM -- **Information-Theoretic Invariance:** The transformation cannot add extraneous mathematical constraints, remove necessary premises, or introduce lexical ambiguities that would change the difficulty of the problem. +(18) Is this investment identified as "high risk" on +the Q4 - FY 2006 agency high risk report +(per OMB's 'high risk" memo)? -- **Algorithmic Reversibility:** The transformation must be deterministic and programmatically invertible. We verify this by using Python reversal scripts for each transformation rule, confirming that original problem statement can be reconstructed without heuristics. +(19) Is this a financial management system? +(a) If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA +compliance area? -- **Cognitive Tractability:** The transform must be simple enough that a human, equipped only with pen and paper, can decode the text and subsequently solve the mathematical problem without any degradation compared to their baseline accuracy. +[1] If "yes," which compliance area: +[2] If "no," what does it address? -- **Explicit Decoding Protocol:** The exact transformation rule is provided in plain English to the model in user query. The model is explicitly instructed to execute a two-stage trajectory: first, programmatically decode the input to reconstruct the problem statement; second, execute mathematical reasoning to solve it. +(b) If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and +system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent +financial systems inventory update required by +Circular A-11 section 52: -- **Grid Padding and Alignment:** For all visual and spatial encodings, we ensure that character spacing is strictly preserved by substituting blank spaces with explicit dots ( `.` ) or padding the grid dimensions perfectly. This ensures that when the LLM’s tokenizer parses the grid, the geometric alignment (e.g., columns in the vertical snake, or edges in the rectangle) remains structurally intact. +(20) What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2008 funding request for the following? +(This should total 100%) -All models are supplied with standard chain-of-thought system prompt: "You are a helpful math assistant. Please reason step by step, and put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` ." To disentangle perturbation decoding from reasoning failures, we perform sequential cognitive overload experiment, where we ask the model to solve a set of problems within a single query and record the accuracy only on the last problem. For sequential cognitive overload, we additionally prompt the model in user query with "Solve these completely unrelated math problems. For each problem put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` ". +Hardware %: +0 -**Context Saturation Protocol** For our contextual overload experiments, we construct input contexts by simulating multi-turn mathematical problem-solving sessions. To ensure the distractors are domainrelevant, we use synthetically generated math questions paired with chain-of-thought solutions generated by the `tiiuae/Falcon-H1R-7B` [45]. Prior to injection, we sanitize these distractor trajectories by stripping their internal `` tokens. This domain-specific noise occupies 75% of each target model’s maximum context window (e.g., up to 750K tokens for three frontier models). For closed-source APIs, we leverage provider-native context caching mechanisms to execute these high-volume evaluations [4, 8, 34]. This domain specific noise is generated once and reused across all models. +Software %: +0 -**Evaluation Metrics** We evaluate the robustness of each model using two primary metrics. **ProblemSolving Accuracy:** The percentage of final mathematical answers evaluated as strictly correct (extracted via the `\boxed{}` format using `math_verify` [9] package). When evaluating the baseline, we report max token cutoffs as failures, except for sequential cognitive overload where we count max token cutoffs as successes since it can be argued that the model is still reasoning about the last problem when it hits the max token limit. For sequential cognitive overload, we search through all `\boxed{}` blocks and count the sample as correct if any of them match the ground truth of the target problem, in case the model outputs answers out of order. **Reasoning Efficiency:** The token consumption required by the model to reach a final solution, serving as a proxy for the computational friction introduced by the adversarial transformations. Discussion of Reasoning Efficiency is deferred to the Appendix A.3. +Services %: +100 -**Models and Experimental Scope** Our evaluation encompasses a suite of eight state-of-the-art models, comprising five open-source weights and three proprietary APIs. The open-source models: `Qwen/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507` [36], `nvidia/OpenReasoning-Nemotron-7B` [31], `nvidia/OpenReasoning-Nemotron-32B` [30], `DeepSeek-R1-Distill-70B` [7] (DSR1-Llama70B), and `openai/gpt-oss-120b` [32]. The closed-source models are Gemini 3.1 Pro [11], GPT5.4 [33], and Claude 4.6 Opus [3]. All experiments are conducted on AIME 2024 dataset [25]. We sample 8 zero-shot trajectories per problem for the proprietary models, and 16 zero-shot trajectories for open-source models. The only exception is context saturation, where we sample 8 zero-shot trajectories per problem for all problems. GPT-5.4 was used with _high_ reasoning effort setting +Other %: -6 +0 -throughout. For experiments with perturbations, temperature for all models was set to 0.7, _top_ p_ to 1.0, and _max_ tokens_ to 32000. For sequential cognitive overload, temperature was set to 0.6, _top_ p_ to 0.95, and _max_ tokens_ as follows: Qwen3-30B-A3B: 81920, Nemotron-7B: 65536, Nemotron32B: 65536, DSR1-Llama-70B: 65536, gpt-oss-120b: 128000. When evaluating sequential cognitive overload on proprietary models, due to high computational cost, we sampled only the baseline and 4 sequential problems. +Total % +100 -## **4.2 Results and Discussion** +(21) If this project produces information dissemination products for the public, are these products +published to the Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and included in your +agency inventory, schedules and priorities? +n/a -We evaluate mathematical reasoning robustness across a total of 15 transformations. Our results expose fragility in modern mathematical reasoning models, particularly within open-weights. +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -**==> picture [390 x 466] intentionally omitted <==** +3 of 18 -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4
100 99 98 96 97 97 96 95 [98] [98] 95 97 99 100 96 95 92 96 95 91 96 95 94 95 87 [94]
80 62 62 65 80 70 [77] 72
60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
100 99 97 92 97 98 90 99 96 100
80 80 78 69 69 70 78 74
63
60 51 60 53 50
39 40
40 32 32 40
26
20 3 2 8 3 20 1 0 11
0 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B
100 89 100
80 82 78 68 77 74 [80] 80 81 77 77 70 77 78 [82]
60 60 53
48
40 25 35 40 29
20 16 20 16 14
0 0 4 1 0 0 6 0
0 0
Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
100 100
80 77 78 80
67 66
60 59 43 60 57 53 44 54 48
40 33 40
22
20 5 0 8 13 0 0 0 0 0 20 14 0 0 5 0 0 0 1
0 0
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+FY08 Exhibit 300 + (22) Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions: -Figure 3: Full bars represent Achieved Accuracy on the AIME 2024 benchmark modified with our perturbations. Semi-transparent segments indicate model refusals or failed answers. +Name: +Phone +Number: +Title: +E-Mail: -7 +Leslie A. Jensen -**==> picture [390 x 175] intentionally omitted <==** +703-292-8060 -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80
60 60 60 60
40 40 40 40
20 20 20 20
Semantic Semantic Semantic Semantic
Contextual Contextual Contextual Contextual
Visual Visual Visual Visual
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80
60 60 60 60
40 40 40 40
20 20 20 20
Semantic Semantic Semantic Semantic
Contextual Contextual Contextual Contextual
Visual Visual Visual Visual
**----- End of picture text -----**
+NSF FOIA/Privacy Act Officer +Ijensen@nsf.gov -Figure 4: Vulnerability Profiling: Average accuracy on transformations from each of the 4 categories by model. +(23) Are the records produced by this investment appropriately scheduled with the National +Archives and Records Administration's approval? no -## **4.2.1 Robustness Against Perturbations: Frontier vs. Open-Weights Models.** +Section B: Summary of Funding (All Capital Assets) +(1) Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. +All amounts represent budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. +Federal personnel costs should be included only in the row designated "Government FTE Cost," +and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full Acquisition," and +"Operation/Maintenance." The total estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for +"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities, +life-cycle costs should include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or +restoration costs. The costs associated with the entire life-cycle of the investment should be +included in this report. -Our macro-level evaluation reveals a stark divergence in architectural resilience towards textual perturbations, visualized in the Average Accuracy Drop (Figure 5) and Achieved Accuracy (Figure 3). State-of-the-art proprietary models exhibit remarkable robustness to structural noise; GPT-5.4 and Gemini 3.1 Pro suffer average performance degradations of only 7% and 10%, respectively. In contrast, the open-weights ecosystem experiences substantial reasoning degradation. Despite demonstrating strong baseline accuracy on the AIME 2024 dataset, models such as Nemotron-7B and Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507 suffer average accuracy drops of 55% and 47%, respectively. +Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES (REPORTED IN MILLIONS) +All amounts represent Budget Authority (Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not +represent budget decisions) -This “robustness gap” indicates that while current open-weights architectures and RL paradigms can memorize and execute standard mathematical heuristics, their reasoning pathways are overfit to standard textual formatting and sequential presentation. By disaggregating performance into transformation categories (Figure 4), we can pinpoint the exact mechanical failures of these models. Semantic substitutions are handled relatively well across the board. However, open-weights models universally degrade on **Syntactic Distortions** and **Visual Encodings** . Transformations that break words down into isolated characters, such as _Interleave (Symbol)_ and _Rail Fence Cipher_ , strongly affect Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) boundaries. Consequently, models like Qwen3 and DSR1 drop to 0% accuracy on these tasks. This shows that their general reasoning is bottlenecked by subword semantic priors; they cannot map isolated character tokens back into a coherent internal causal graph. Our 2D spatial mappings show the inherent autoregressive bias of standard Transformers. When presented with the _Snake (Horizontal)_ task, Gemini 3.1 Pro scores 98%, and Qwen3 scores 16%. However, when the exact same text is mapped vertically ( _Snake (Vertical)_ ), Gemini drops to 65%, and Qwen3 drops to near 1%. This suggests that even when explicitly prompted to perform simple spatial grid algorithmic tasks, LLMs are fundamentally constrained by their left-to-right, 1D pre-training biases. +PY-1 +Spending +Prior to 2006 -**The Alignment Issues** While closed-source models generally excel, Claude Opus 4-6 presents a striking anomaly, suffering a 41.7% average accuracy drop. A review of the data reveals that this drop is not due to reasoning failure, but rather a disproportionate rate of model refusals (indicated by the semi-transparent upper segments of the bar charts in Figure 3). Claude categorically refuses to process the vast majority of the prompts involving symbol manipulation. We hypothesize that this is an artifact of its safety filters, which aggressively flag abstract symbol manipulation as prompt injection or jailbreak attempts. This highlights an unintended consequence of current alignment strategies that penalize abstract, character-level reasoning by misclassifying textually complex inputs as adversarial attacks. +BY +1 BY+2 2010 +2009 -8 +2011 -**==> picture [175 x 103] intentionally omitted <==** +Total -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-60 55
50 45 47
40 40 42
32
30
20
10 7 10
0GPT-5.4Gemini 3.1 ProGPT-OSS-120BNemotron-32BClaude Opus 4.6DSR1-Llama-70BQwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-7B
Avg Accuracy Drop (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+BY+4 +2012 and +beyond +Planning -Figure 5: Average Accuracy Drop across all models and transformations. +Acquisition +Subtotal +Planning & +Acquisition +Operations -**==> picture [199 x 111] intentionally omitted <==** +$0.000 -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-100
-0.4%
90 -1.2%
80 -13.8% -6.7% -7.1%
70 -7.1%
-10.6%
60
-7.1%
50 1 4 1 4 1 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3
Gemini 3.1 Pro gpt-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6Qwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-32BNemotron-7BGPT-OSS-120BDSR1-Llama-70B
Accuracy on Last Problem (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+$0.000 +$0.000 +$0.000 -Figure 6: Mathematical accuracy on last problem in sequential overload. Number of problems asked is shown as a sequence on the x-axis. Total accuracy drop from baseline is shown in red. +$0.000 +$0.000 -## **4.2.2 Intra-Query Context Management** +$0.000 -It is well-established in the literature that long-horizon, multi-turn agentic workflows suffer from attention drift, necessitating explicit state management to maintain coherence. However, our findings suggest that this phenomenon is not restricted to macro-level agentic interactions; it is a fundamental architectural bottleneck that degrades reasoning _within a single query_ . Complex mathematical problems, much like real-world tasks, require multi-step, sequential reasoning. As models become more capable, they are used for ever more complex multi-step tasks. Figure 6 illustrates that the cognitive load of prior reasoning steps negatively affects the model’s reasoning ability. All evaluated open-weights models ranging from 7B parameters to 120B parameters experience this degradation in performance. This suggests that single-turn attention dilution is a fundamental limitation of the standard dense attention mechanism, which forces subsequent reasoning steps to unconditionally attend to prior ones. +$0.000 +$0.000 -Recent community leaks [46] and artifacts observed during the development of this project (Appendix A.5) reveal that proprietary agent frameworks, such as Google’s AntiGravity [10], utilize explicit scaffolding like the `` . This strongly suggests the industry is aware of long context attention drift and likely attempts to mitigate it by enforcing context management for long-horizon, multi-turn tasks. Building on our empirical evidence of intra-query attention dilution, we argue that these same principles must be applied at the micro-level. To achieve reliable algorithmic reasoning, future architectures require mechanisms for _micro-context isolation_ - allowing the model to explicitly summarize state and flush the noisy “scratchpad” of previous intermediate steps, effectively resetting its attention focus within a single Chain-of-Thought. This raises fundamental open research questions about optimal granularity of reasoning tasks, which we discuss in Appendix A.4. +$0.000 -## **5 Conclusion** +$0.000 +$0.000 -In this work we demonstrate that current LLMs suffer from mathematical reasoning fragility, revealing that their reasoning prowess is often overfit to standard textual presentation rather than abstract logical manipulation. By decoupling deterministic mechanical deciphering from downstream mathematical reasoning, we identify intra-query attention dilution. We empirically show that this reasoning degradation is present in open weight models from 7B to 120B parameters, demonstrating that intermediate reasoning steps pollute the context window. Our findings, corroborated by artifacts leaked from proprietary agentic frameworks, suggest that standard dense attention mechanisms are inherently insufficient for robust algorithmic reasoning because they fail to isolate working memory between sequential reasoning steps _inside a single forward pass_ . In this work we argue that achieving reliable multi-step deduction requires the integration of native contextual resets and task-boundary compartmentalization to flush intermediate states and preserve logical coherence. +$7.570 -9 +$1.500 -## **Acknowledgments** +$1.500 -We gratefully acknowledge Vector Institute and Compute Canada Alliance for providing the computational resources required for this study on their Killarney cluster. +$1.120 -## **References** +TOTAL -- [1] Khashayar Alavi, Zhastay Yeltay, Lucie Flek, and Akbar Karimi. More agents helps but adversarial robustness gap persists, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.07112` . +$7.570 -- [2] Ujjwala Anantheswaran, Himanshu Gupta, Kevin Scaria, Shreyas Verma, Chitta Baral, and Swaroop Mishra. Cutting through the noise: Boosting llm performance on math word problems, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15444` . +$1.500 -- [3] Anthropic. The claude 4.6 model family. Technical report, Anthropic, 2026. URL `https: //www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-4-6` . +$1.500 -- [4] Google Gemini API. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/ docs/caching` . +$1.120 -- [5] Ashwath Vaithinathan Aravindan and Mayank Kejriwal. Fragile thoughts: How large language models handle chain-of-thought perturbations, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2603. 03332` . +Government FTE Costs +should not be included +th -- [6] Karl Cobbe, Vineet Kosaraju, Mohammad Bavarian, Mark Chen, Heewoo Jun, Lukasz Kaiser, Matthias Plappert, Jerry Tworek, Jacob Hilton, Reiichiro Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John Schulman. Training verifiers to solve math word problems, 2021. URL `https://arxiv.org/ abs/2110.14168` . +i -- [7] DeepSeek-AI. Deepseek-r1-distill-llama-70b, January 2025. URL `https://huggingface. co/deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Llama-70B` . +t -- [8] Claude API Docs. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/ build-with-claude/prompt-caching` . +provided +above. -- [9] Hugging Face. Math verify, 2026. URL `https://pypi.org/project/math-verify/` . +$0.360 -- [10] Google. Google antigravity, 2026. URL `https://antigravity.google/` . +$0.360 -- [11] Google DeepMind. Gemini 3.1: Advancing the state of the art in multimodal reasoning. Technical report, Google, 2026. URL `https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/ models-and-research/gemini-models/gemini-3-1-pro/` . +$0.360 -- [12] Yuren Hao, Xiang Wan, and ChengXiang Zhai. An investigation of robustness of llms in mathematical reasoning: Benchmarking with mathematically-equivalent transformation of advanced mathematical problems, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.08833` . +$1.800 -- [13] Dan Hendrycks, Collin Burns, Saurav Kadavath, Akul Arora, Steven Basart, Eric Tang, Dawn Song, and Jacob Steinhardt. Measuring mathematical problem solving with the math dataset. In _Proceedings of the Neural Information Processing Systems Track on Datasets and Benchmarks_ , 2021. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.03874` . +Government +FTE Costs +Number of +FTE +represented +by cost +Note: For the cross-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner +and partner agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL +represented. -- [14] Pengfei Hong, Navonil Majumder, Deepanway Ghosal, Somak Aditya, Rada Mihalcea, and Soujanya Poria. Evaluating LLMs’ mathematical and coding competency through ontologyguided interventions. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL 2025_ , pages 22811–22849, Vienna, Austria, jul 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025.findings-acl.1172. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025. findings-acl.1172` . +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -- [15] Yutao Hou, Zeguan Xiao, Fei Yu, Yihan Jiang, Xuetao Wei, Hailiang Huang, Yun Chen, and Guanhua Chen. Automatic robustness stress testing of llms as mathematical problem solvers, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.05038` . +4 of 18 -10 +FY08 Exhibit 300 -- [16] Kaixuan Huang, Jiacheng Guo, Zihao Li, Xiang Ji, Jiawei Ge, Wenzhe Li, Yingqing Guo, Tianle Cai, Hui Yuan, Runzhe Wang, Yue Wu, Ming Yin, Shange Tang, Yangsibo Huang, Chi Jin, Xinyun Chen, Chiyuan Zhang, and Mengdi Wang. Math-perturb: Benchmarking llms’ math reasoning abilities against hard perturbations. In _Forty-second International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.06453` . + (2) Will this project require the agency to hire additional FTE's? no -- [17] Takuya Ito, Murray Campbell, Lior Horesh, Tim Klinger, and Parikshit Ram. Quantifying artificial intelligence through algorithmic generalization. In _Nature Machine Intelligence_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.05943` . +(a) If "yes," How many and in what year? -- [18] Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Zhuoqun Hao, Xiaomeng Wang, Tanwi Mallick, Weijie J. Su, Camillo Jose Taylor, and Dan Roth. A peek into token bias: Large language models are not yet genuine reasoners. In _Proceedings of the 2024 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP)_ , pages 4722–4756, Miami, Florida, USA, nov 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.emnlp-main.272. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024.emnlp-main.272` . +(3) If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2007 President's budget request, briefly +explain those changes. -- [19] Ming Jiang, Tingting Huang, Biao Guo, Yao Lu, and Feng Zhang. Enhancing robustness in large language models: Prompting for mitigating the impact of irrelevant information, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.10615` . +Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) -- [20] Daniel Kahneman. _Thinking, fast and slow_ . Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, 2011. ISBN 9780374275631 0374275637. URL `https://mlsu.ac.in/econtents/2950_Daniel% 20Kahneman%20-%20Thinking,%20Fast%20and%20Slow%20(2013).pdf` . +(1) Complete the table for all contracts and/or task orders in place or planned for this investment: -- [21] Aabid Karim, Abdul Karim, Bhoomika Lohana, Matt Keon, Jaswinder Singh, and Abdul Sattar. Lost in cultural translation: Do llms struggle with math across cultural contexts?, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.18018` . +Contract or Task Order Number: BZ-11/0533982 Type of Contract/TO Used: Cost Plus Fixed Fee +Has the Contract Being Awarded: yes +Contract Actual/Planned Award Date: +05/01/2005 +Contract/TO Start Date: +05/01/2005 +Contract/TO End Date: +04/30/2007 +Contract/TO Total Value ($M): $32.200 Inter Agency Acquisition: no +Performance Based Contract: yes +Competitively Awarded Contract: yes +Alternative Financing: NA EVM Required: yes +Security Privacy Clause: yes -- [22] Neeraja Kirtane, Yuvraj Khanna, and Peter Relan. Mathrobust-lv: Evaluation of large language models’ robustness to linguistic variations in mathematical reasoning, 2025. URL `https: //arxiv.org/abs/2510.06430` . +Contracting Officer (CO) Contact Information: -- [23] Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Xueliang Zhao, Lingpeng Kong, and Wei Bi. GSM-plus: A comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the robustness of LLMs as mathematical problem solvers. In _Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pages 2961–2984, Bangkok, Thailand, aug 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.163. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024.acl-long.163` . +CO Name: Patricia S. Williams +CO Contact Information (Phone/Email): (703) 292-8240 pswillia@nsf.gov +CO Certification Level (Level 1, 2, 3, N/A): 3 +If N/A has the agency determined the CO assigned has the competencies and skills necessary to +support this acquisition? (Y/N) -- [24] Xinyuan Li, Murong Xu, Wenbiao Tao, Hanlun Zhu, Yike Zhao, Jipeng Zhang, and Yunshi Lan. Ride: Difficulty evolving perturbation with item response theory for mathematical reasoning, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.04120` . +(2) If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or -- [25] Mathematical Association of America. Aime 2024 dataset, 2024. URL `https:// huggingface.co/datasets/HuggingFaceH4/aime_2024` . +task orders above, explain why: -- [26] R. Thomas McCoy, Shunyu Yao, Dan Friedman, Matthew Hardy, and Thomas L. Griffiths. Embers of autoregression: Understanding large language models through the problem they are trained to solve. In _Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)_ , 2023. doi: 10. 1073/pnas.2322420121. URL `https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2322420121` . +The contract has a requirement to utilize earned value management (EVM) for tasks/projects designated as +new development or "Development/Modernization/Enhancements (DME)." FAS is in Steady State and its +maintenance activities are exempt from EVM at this time per OMB Guidance. -- [27] Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Hooman Shahrokhi, Oncel Tuzel, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. Gsm-symbolic: Understanding the limitations of mathematical reasoning in large language models. In _The Thirteenth International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR)_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05229` . +(3) Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? yes +Section 508 Compliance Explanation: +The system was reviewed and modified, as needed, in 2001 for Section 508 compliance. The FAS consists of an +end-user GUI and back-end software programs. Only the end-user GUI is used by users; therefore only changes +to it would affect Section 508 compliance. While the majority of maintenance changes are to the back-end +software, when the GUI is affected, NSF staff review each maintenance change for Section 508 compliance +before the change is implemented. -- [28] Allen Newell and Herbert A. Simon. Computer science as empirical inquiry: symbols and search. _Commun. ACM_ , 19(3), March 1976. ISSN 0001-0782. doi: 10.1145/360018.360022. URL `https://doi.org/10.1145/360018.360022` . +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -- [29] Marianna Nezhurina, Lucia Cipolina-Kun, Mehdi Cherti, and Jenia Jitsev. Alice in wonderland: Simple tasks showing complete reasoning breakdown in state-of-the-art large language models, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02061` . +5 of 18 -11 +FY08 Exhibit 300 -- [30] NVIDIA. Openreasoning-nemotron-32b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/nvidia/ OpenReasoning-Nemotron-32B` . + (4) Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in accordance with agency requirements? -- [31] NVIDIA. Openreasoning-nemotron-7b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/nvidia/ OpenReasoning-Nemotron-7B` . +yes -- [32] OpenAI. gpt-oss-120b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/openai/gpt-oss-120b` . +(a) If "yes", what is the date? +12/01/2001 +(b) If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed? -- [33] OpenAI. Gpt-5.4 technical report. Technical report, OpenAI, 2026. URL `https://openai. com/index/introducing-gpt-5-4/` . +[1] If "no," briefly explain why: -- [34] OpenAI. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://openai.com/index/ api-prompt-caching/` . +Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) -- [35] Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, and Zhou Yu. VarBench: Robust language model benchmarking through dynamic variable perturbation. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2024_ , pages 16131–16161, Miami, Florida, USA, nov 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp.946. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024. findings-emnlp.946` . +In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the +agency and be linked to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and +strategic goals, and performance measures must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the +agency's strategic goals and objectives this investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external +performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 +percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall citizen participation rate of +75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if applicable, +investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or +general goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure. -- [36] Qwen Team. Qwen3: The next generation of qwen large language models, 2026. URL `https://huggingface.co/Qwen/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507` . +Agencies must use Table 1 below for reporting performance goals and measures for all non-IT investments +and for existing IT investments that were initiated prior to FY 2005. The table can be extended to include +measures for years beyond FY 2006. -- [37] Nikolaus Salvatore, Hao Wang, and Qiong Zhang. Lost in the middle: An emergent property from information retrieval demands in llms, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2510. 10276` . +Table 1 -- [38] Michael Shalyt, Rotem Elimelech, and Ido Kaminer. Asymob: Algebraic symbolic mathematical operations benchmark, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.23851` . +Fiscal Year -- [39] Freda Shi, Xinyun Chen, Kanishka Misra, Nathan Scales, David Dohan, Ed H. Chi, Nathanael Schärli, and Denny Zhou. Large language models can be easily distracted by irrelevant context. In _Proceedings of the 40th International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , pages 31210–31227, 2023. URL `https://proceedings.mlr.press/v202/shi23a.html` . +Strategic -- [40] Parshin Shojaee, Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Maxwell Horton, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. The illusion of thinking: Understanding the strengths and limitations of reasoning models via the lens of problem complexity, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/ 2506.06941` . +Goal(s) +Supported -- [41] Saurabh Srivastava, Annarose M B, Anto P V, Shashank Menon, Ajay Sukumar, Adwaith Samod T, Alan Philipose, Stevin Prince, and Sooraj Thomas. Functional benchmarks for robust evaluation of reasoning performance, and the reasoning gap, 2024. URL `https://arxiv. org/abs/2402.19450` . +2003 -- [42] Zhishen Sun, Guang Dai, Ivor Tsang, and Haishan Ye. Numerical sensitivity and robustness: Exploring the flaws of mathematical reasoning in large language models, 2025. URL `https: //arxiv.org/abs/2511.08022` . +2003 -- [43] Zhishen Sun, Guang Dai, and Haishan Ye. Mscr: Exploring the vulnerability of llms’ mathematical reasoning abilities using multi-source candidate replacement, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.08055` . +2003 -- [44] Kimi Team, Tongtong Bai, Yifan Bai, Yiping Bao, S. H. Cai, Yuan Cao, Y. Charles, H. S. Che, Cheng Chen, Guanduo Chen, Huarong Chen, Jia Chen, Jiahao Chen, Jianlong Chen, Jun Chen, Kefan Chen, Liang Chen, Ruijue Chen, Xinhao Chen, Yanru Chen, Yanxu Chen, Yicun Chen, Yimin Chen, Yingjiang Chen, Yuankun Chen, Yujie Chen, Yutian Chen, Zhirong Chen, Ziwei Chen, Dazhi Cheng, Minghan Chu, Jialei Cui, Jiaqi Deng, Muxi Diao, Hao Ding, Mengfan Dong, Mengnan Dong, Yuxin Dong, Yuhao Dong, Angang Du, Chenzhuang Du, Dikang Du, Lingxiao Du, Yulun Du, Yu Fan, Shengjun Fang, Qiulin Feng, Yichen Feng, Garimugai Fu, Kelin Fu, Hongcheng Gao, Tong Gao, Yuyao Ge, Shangyi Geng, Chengyang Gong, Xiaochen Gong, Zhuoma Gongque, Qizheng Gu, Xinran Gu, Yicheng Gu, Longyu Guan, Yuanying Guo, +2003 -12 +2004 -Xiaoru Hao, Weiran He, Wenyang He, Yunjia He, Chao Hong, Hao Hu, Jiaxi Hu, Yangyang Hu, Zhenxing Hu, Ke Huang, Ruiyuan Huang, Weixiao Huang, Zhiqi Huang, Tao Jiang, Zhejun Jiang, Xinyi Jin, Yu Jing, Guokun Lai, Aidi Li, C. Li, Cheng Li, Fang Li, Guanghe Li, Guanyu Li, Haitao Li, Haoyang Li, Jia Li, Jingwei Li, Junxiong Li, Lincan Li, Mo Li, Weihong Li, Wentao Li, Xinhang Li, Xinhao Li, Yang Li, Yanhao Li, Yiwei Li, Yuxiao Li, Zhaowei Li, Zheming Li, Weilong Liao, Jiawei Lin, Xiaohan Lin, Zhishan Lin, Zichao Lin, Cheng Liu, Chenyu Liu, Hongzhang Liu, Liang Liu, Shaowei Liu, Shudong Liu, Shuran Liu, Tianwei Liu, Tianyu Liu, Weizhou Liu, Xiangyan Liu, Yangyang Liu, Yanming Liu, Yibo Liu, Yuanxin Liu, Yue Liu, Zhengying Liu, Zhongnuo Liu, Enzhe Lu, Haoyu Lu, Zhiyuan Lu, Junyu Luo, Tongxu Luo, Yashuo Luo, Long Ma, Yingwei Ma, Shaoguang Mao, Yuan Mei, Xin Men, Fanqing Meng, Zhiyong Meng, Yibo Miao, Minqing Ni, Kun Ouyang, Siyuan Pan, Bo Pang, Yuchao Qian, Ruoyu Qin, Zeyu Qin, Jiezhong Qiu, Bowen Qu, Zeyu Shang, Youbo Shao, Tianxiao Shen, Zhennan Shen, Juanfeng Shi, Lidong Shi, Shengyuan Shi, Feifan Song, Pengwei Song, Tianhui Song, Xiaoxi Song, Hongjin Su, Jianlin Su, Zhaochen Su, Lin Sui, Jinsong Sun, Junyao Sun, Tongyu Sun, Flood Sung, Yunpeng Tai, Chuning Tang, Heyi Tang, Xiaojuan Tang, Zhengyang Tang, Jiawen Tao, Shiyuan Teng, Chaoran Tian, Pengfei Tian, Ao Wang, Bowen Wang, Chensi Wang, Chuang Wang, Congcong Wang, Dingkun Wang, Dinglu Wang, Dongliang Wang, Feng Wang, Hailong Wang, Haiming Wang, Hengzhi Wang, Huaqing Wang, Hui Wang, Jiahao Wang, Jinhong Wang, Jiuzheng Wang, Kaixin Wang, Linian Wang, Qibin Wang, Shengjie Wang, Shuyi Wang, Si Wang, Wei Wang, Xiaochen Wang, Xinyuan Wang, Yao Wang, Yejie Wang, Yipu Wang, Yiqin Wang, Yucheng Wang, Yuzhi Wang, Zhaoji Wang, Zhaowei Wang, Zhengtao Wang, Zhexu Wang, Zihan Wang, Zizhe Wang, Chu Wei, Ming Wei, Chuan Wen, Zichen Wen, Chengjie Wu, Haoning Wu, Junyan Wu, Rucong Wu, Wenhao Wu, Yuefeng Wu, Yuhao Wu, Yuxin Wu, Zijian Wu, Chenjun Xiao, Jin Xie, Xiaotong Xie, Yuchong Xie, Yifei Xin, Bowei Xing, Boyu Xu, Jianfan Xu, Jing Xu, Jinjing Xu, L. H. Xu, Lin Xu, Suting Xu, Weixin Xu, Xinbo Xu, Xinran Xu, Yangchuan Xu, Yichang Xu, Yuemeng Xu, Zelai Xu, Ziyao Xu, Junjie Yan, Yuzi Yan, Guangyao Yang, Hao Yang, Junwei Yang, Kai Yang, Ningyuan Yang, Ruihan Yang, Xiaofei Yang, Xinlong Yang, Ying Yang, Yi Yang, Yi Yang, Zhen Yang, Zhilin Yang, Zonghan Yang, Haotian Yao, Dan Ye, Wenjie Ye, Zhuorui Ye, Bohong Yin, Chengzhen Yu, Longhui Yu, Tao Yu, Tianxiang Yu, Enming Yuan, Mengjie Yuan, Xiaokun Yuan, Yang Yue, Weihao Zeng, Dunyuan Zha, Haobing Zhan, Dehao Zhang, Hao Zhang, Jin Zhang, Puqi Zhang, Qiao Zhang, Rui Zhang, Xiaobin Zhang, Y. Zhang, Yadong Zhang, Yangkun Zhang, Yichi Zhang, Yizhi Zhang, Yongting Zhang, Yu Zhang, Yushun Zhang, Yutao Zhang, Yutong Zhang, Zheng Zhang, Chenguang Zhao, Feifan Zhao, Jinxiang Zhao, Shuai Zhao, Xiangyu Zhao, Yikai Zhao, Zijia Zhao, Huabin Zheng, Ruihan Zheng, Shaojie Zheng, Tengyang Zheng, Junfeng Zhong, Longguang Zhong, Weiming Zhong, M. Zhou, Runjie Zhou, Xinyu Zhou, Zaida Zhou, Jinguo Zhu, Liya Zhu, Xinhao Zhu, Yuxuan Zhu, Zhen Zhu, Jingze Zhuang, Weiyu Zhuang, Ying Zou, and Xinxing Zu. Kimi k2.5: Visual agentic intelligence, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.02276` . +2004 -- [45] Technology Innovation Institute. Falcon-h1r: Pushing the reasoning frontiers with a hybrid model for efficient test-time scaling, January 2026. URL `https://huggingface.co/ tiiuae/Falcon-H1R-7B` . +2004 -- [46] Reddit User. Leaked: I caught google antigravity’s hidden inner prompt, 2026. URL `https://www.reddit.com/r/google_antigravity/comments/1rl1vjx/leaked_i_ caught_google_antigravitys_hidden_inner/` . +2004 -- [47] Alexander von Recum, Leander Girrbach, and Zeynep Akata. Are reasoning llms robust to interventions on their chain-of-thought? In _The Fourteenth International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR)_ , 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.07470` . +Financial +Management +Financial +Management -- [48] Yuqing Wang and Yun Zhao. Rupbench: Benchmarking reasoning under perturbations for robustness evaluation in large language models, 2024. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406. 11020` . +Financial +Management -- [49] Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Brian Ichter, Fei Xia, Ed H. Chi, Quoc V. Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain-of-thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. In _Proceedings of the 36th International Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems_ , NIPS ’22, Red Hook, NY, USA, 2022. Curran Associates Inc. ISBN 9781713871088. +Financial +Management -13 +Financial +Management -- [50] Wikipedia. Rail fence cipher, 2026. URL `https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_fence_ cipher` . +Financial +Management -- [51] Chulin Xie, Yangsibo Huang, Chiyuan Zhang, Da Yu, Xinyun Chen, Bill Yuchen Lin, Bo Li, Badih Ghazi, and Ravi Kumar. On memorization of large language models in logical reasoning. In _Proceedings of the 14th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing and the 4th Conference of the Asia-Pacific Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics_ , pages 2742–2785. Association for Computational Linguistics, 2025. URL `https: //aclanthology.org/2025.ijcnlp-long.148/` . +Financial +Management -- [52] Roy Xie, Chengxuan Huang, Junlin Wang, and Bhuwan Dhingra. Adversarial math word problem generation. pages 5075–5093, Miami, Florida, USA, 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp.292. URL `https://aclanthology.org/ 2024.findings-emnlp.292` . +Financial +Management -- [53] Yuli Yang, Hiroaki Yamada, and Takenobu Tokunaga. Evaluating robustness of LLMs to numerical variations in mathematical reasoning. In _The Sixth Workshop on Insights from Negative Results in NLP_ , pages 171–180, Albuquerque, New Mexico, May 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025.insights-1.16. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025.insights-1.16/` . +Performance Measure -- [54] Shunyu Yao, Dian Yu, Jeffrey Zhao, Izhak Shafran, Thomas L. Griffiths, Yuan Cao, and Karthik Narasimhan. Tree of thoughts: Deliberate problem solving with large language models. In _Proceedings of the Neural Information Processing Systems_ , volume 36, 2023. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10601` . +Actual/ -- [55] Alex L. Zhang, Tim Kraska, and Omar Khattab. Recursive language models, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.24601` . +Migrate from current payroll system to +Government wide Payroll provider -- [56] Yilun Zhao, Guo Gan, Chengye Wang, Chen Zhao, and Arman Cohan. Are multimodal LLMs robust against adversarial perturbations? RoMMath: A systematic evaluation on multimodal math reasoning. In Luis Chiruzzo, Alan Ritter, and Lu Wang, editors, _Proceedings of the 2025 Conference of the Nations of the Americas Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , Albuquerque, New Mexico, April 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025. naacl-long.582. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025.naacl-long.582/` . +Meet Accelerated Financial Management +Reporting Requirements (45 days after +fiscal year-end) +Meet Quarterly reporting requirement -- [57] Kaijie Zhu, Jindong Wang, Qinlin Zhao, Ruochen Xu, and Xing Xie. Dynamic evaluation of large language models by meta probing agents. In _Forty-first International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , 2024. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14865` . +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements -## **A Appendix** +Implement Government wide ePayroll +service provider -## **A.1 A - Methodology Details** +Baseline (from +previous year) -When the model is given a transformed user query, it is given instructions on what transformation was applied to the original user query. Below are the transformations descriptions that are supplied to the model in plain English. +Legacy System-IPAY -1. Word Reversal: The order of words (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in the user query has been reversed. +Met Current Financial +Management Reporting +Requirements +Met Current Financial +Management Reporting +Requirements +Unqualified Audit +Opinion -2. Sentence Reversal: The order of sentences in the user query has been reversed. Sentences are defined as sequences of symbols separated by periods. +Legacy System-IPAY -3. Interleaved Context Word: User query will consist of two problems - A and B, whose statements are interleaved word by word. First word belongs to problem A, second word belongs to problem B, third word belongs to problem A, and so on. You need to solve only problem A. Words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the empty spaces resulting from the shorter problem statement will be filled with the shorter problem statement repeated from the beginning. +Planned +Performance +Metric (Target) -14 +Select ePayroll provider in +FY03 +Submit NSF Performance +and Accountability Report +to OMB on November 17 +Submit Quarterly financial +statements to OMB within +45 days of end of quarter -4. Interleaved Context Line: User query will consist of two problems - A and B, whose statements are split into line segments at most 60 symbols long. Each segment is followed by a space and a problem tag (e.g. problem A or B). The segments are interleaved. You need to solve only problem A. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the empty lines resulting from the shorter problem statement will be filled with the shorter problem statement repeated from the beginning. +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2003 Financial +Statements +Successful transition to +Government wide ePayroll +service provide and +retirement of IPAY system -5. Word Split Swap: Every word (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query is split into 2 parts down the middle. If the word has odd number of symbols, the first part has one symbol less than the second part. After splitting, the 2 parts are swapped. +Meet Accelerated Financial Management +Reporting Requirements 45 days after fiscal +year end +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements -6. Split Reversal: Every word (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query has its symbols in reverse order. +Met Current Financial +Management Reporting +Requirements +Unqualified Audit +Opinion -7. Opposites: There will be terms remapped in the user query. The remappings are defined inside ’defyn’ block in the middle of user query. +Submit NSF Performance +and Accountability Report +by November 15 +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2004 Financial +Statements -8. Wrappers: There will be terms remapped in the user query. The remappings are defined inside ’defyn’ block in the middle of user query. +Produce Quarterly Financial Statements +within 21 days of end of quarter -9. Rail Fence: The user query is encoded using the Rail Fence Cipher. The input is provided as a visual grid where the symbols (including spaces) of the encoded message string (message string does NOT contain any newline characters) are placed in a zigzag pattern across multiple rails (rows), and empty spaces are filled with dots (.). To decode, read the characters in zigzag order: Down-and-Right diagonally until you hit bottom rail, then Up-and-Right diagonally until you hit top rail, then Down-and-Right again etc... Rows are given on separate lines and all have equal lengths. +Produced Quarterly +Financial Statements +within 21 days of end of +quarter -10. Rectangle Perimeter: "The user query is mapped onto the perimeter of a rectangle. The message is written as a single continuous string following the edges of the shape in a clockwise manner, beginning at the top-left. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual text block representing this rectangle with GRID START and GRID END markers. The center of the shape is filled with dots. +Produce Quarterly +Financial Statements +within 21 days of end of +quarter -11. Snake Vertical: The user query is written into a grid using a vertical ’snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written down the first column, then up the second column, then down the third, and so on. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual grid with GRID START and GRID END markers. +Performance Metric +Results (Actual) -12. Snake Horizontal: The user query is written into a grid using a horizontal ’snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written across the first row, then left across the second row, then right across the third, and so on. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual grid with GRID START and GRID END markers. +ePayroll Service Provider +selected in January 2003 +November 15th date was +achieved one year ahead of +OMB requirements +NSF's Quarterly reports +were consistently one of the +first submitted to OMB +NSF received an Unqualified +Audit Opinion for FY 2003 +on 11/05/04 +New ePayroll service +provider began processing +NSF's payroll in May 2004. +Because NSF's payroll +system ran for part of the +calendar year, NSF cannot +retire its IPAY system until +all reconciliation for the +calendar year is done and W- +2s are generated +PAR Report submitted on +11/15/2004 -**Disclosure:** This research utilized the AntiGravity agent framework to programmatically develop the evaluation codebase, and assist in experimental data analysis. The observational artifacts presented in Appendix A.5 were captured during the development of this codebase. +NSF received an Unqualified +Audit Opinion for FY 2004 +on 11/04/2005 +Quarterly reports produced +within 21 days beginning +March 2004 -## **A.2 Prompts** +NSF FAS 1-3-07 -Baseline system prompt: ‘You are a helpful math assistant. Please reason step by step, and put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` .’ +6 of 18 -Solution Protocol Prompt that is inserted before the query. +FY08 Exhibit 300 -## YOUR PROTOCOL: + Fiscal Year -1. Read the "TRANSFORMATION RULE" provided by the user and reverse the transformation on the "TRANSFORMED INPUT" to obtain the original problem statement. +Strategic +Goal(s) +Supported -2. Once you have the original problem statement, proceed to solve the math problem. +Performance Measure -3. Put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` . +Actual/ +Baseline (from +previous year) -## **A.3 Cognitive Thrashing** +2004 -Figure 7 shows the average output token length for each transformation. The number in the center of each bar is the accuracy of the model on that transformation. Analysis of the figure reveals a +2005 -15 +Financial +Management -**==> picture [390 x 466] intentionally omitted <==** +Automate closing package financial +statements -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4
1250 1 1 1
1000 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 800
750 600 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
500 400
250 200
0 0
Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
12501000 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 100008000 9 7 8 7 10 8
750 1 1 6000 5 5 4 5 5 5 4 5 6
500 0 0 0 4000
250 0 2000
0
0 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B
1500010000 16 15 10 12 11 13 14 8 11 10 13 15 15 13 16 3000020000 18 19 17 19 17 24 29 16 17 18 21 20 28 22 27
5000 10000
0 0
Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
2500020000 19 20 17 22 23 25 28 19 18 20 22 25 27 24 27 100008000 9 10 7 7 7 8 9 6 10 7 10 10
6000 6
15000 5
10000 4000
5000 2000 1
0 0
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+Met new Closing +package requirements +Financial +Management -Figure 7: Reasoning Efficiency: Average output token length by task. On top of each bar is output prompt length in thousands of tokens. Values in the middle of each bar are the accuracy of the model on that transformation. +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements -pathological failure mode unique to modern open-source “Thinking” models (e.g., Qwen3, Nemotron). Rather than failing cleanly when presented with unrecognizable structural logic, these models enter massive, unproductive loops. For example, when attempting the _Rectangle Perimeter_ task, Nemotron7B outputs an average of 27K tokens, only to achieve 0% accuracy. Similarly, Qwen generates 13K tokens on the _Snake (Vertical)_ task with 1% accuracy. This indicates that the stopping criteria and logical progression heuristics are highly brittle. When structural noise breaks the expected syntactic progression of a math problem, the model’s internal confidence mechanisms fail, resulting in hallucination loops rather than structured problem-solving. +Unqualified Audit +Opinion -16 +2005 -## **A.4 Open Questions: The Granularity of Atomic Reasoning** +FFMIA Compliance -If the mitigation of intra-query attention dilution requires explicitly breaking complex reasoning into isolated sub-tasks with contextual resets, it immediately raises a fundational open question for future research: _What is the optimal granularity of a sub-task?_ +Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance - +Implement FAS Requirements necessary to +maintain compliance -Currently, task decomposition in LLMs is treated as an arbitrary, heuristic-driven prompting technique. However, our findings suggest that there exists a theoretical "atomic unit" of reasoning - the maximum amount of computation a model can perform in a single context state before structural noise irreversibly degrades its algorithmic logic. +Financial +Management -This introduces a critical trade-off. If a task is not decomposed enough, the model falls victim to the attention dilution and cognitive thrashing demonstrated in our benchmark. Conversely, if a task is decomposed too finely, the system will incur massive computational overhead from constantly explicitly summarizing state, calling boundary tools, and flushing context, which may disrupt the continuous latent representations necessary for deep reasoning. +Produce Quarterly Financial Statements +within 21 days of end of quarter -Furthermore, it remains unknown how this atomic reasoning capacity scales. It is entirely possible that the _optimal chunk size_ of a sub-task scales conditionally with parameter count or network depth. We argue that formally quantifying the maximum safe "cognitive load" of a single transformer forward-pass—and designing architectures that can dynamically determine their own optimal sub-task boundaries—represents an important frontier for the next generation of reasoning models. +Financial +Management -## **A.5 Agent Leaks** +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements -The following Antigravity leaks were observed during work on this project. +Unqualified Audit +Opinion -17 +Financial +Management -**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==** +Produce Quarterly and year end Financial +statement -Figure 8: Agent Context Leaks (1/3): Example of the `task_boundary` mechanism observed in Antigravity. +2006 -18 +FFMIA Compliance -**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==** +Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance - +Implement FAS Requirements necessary to +maintain compliance -Figure 9: Agent Context Leaks (2/3): Observed internal reasoning steps. Images are displayed at full width for maximum readability of the internal thought traces. +Financial +Management -19 +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements -**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==** +Unqualified Audit +Opinion -Figure 10: Agent Context Leaks (3/3): Note "Wait, the system message explicitly said You have called 5 tools in a row without calling a task_boundary tool." +2005 -20 +2006 + +20116 + +2007 + +2007 + +Financial +Management + +Produce Quarterly and year end Financial +statement + +2007 + +FFMIA Compliance + +Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance - +Implement FAS Requirements necessary to +maintain compliance + +2007 + +2007 + +2008 + +2008 + +2008 + +2008 + +2008 + +Financial +Management + +Federal Cash Transactions Report +Monitoring + +Financial +Management + +Grant Closeout - Review the Award +Closeout Report on a quarterly basis + +Financial +Management + +Federal Cash Transactions Report +Monitoring + +Financial +Management + +Grant Closeout - Review the Award +Closeout Report on a quarterly basis + +Financial +Management + +Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial +Statements + +Financial +Management + +Produce Quarterly and year end Financial +statement + +FFMIA Compliance + +Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance - +Implement FAS Requirements necessary to +maintain compliance + +Planned +Performance +Metric (Target) +Automate closing package +financial statements + +Performance Metric +Results (Actual) + +Closing package statement +became automated in June +2004 NSF produces its +automated financial +statements and closing +package statements +simultaneously + +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2005 Financial +Statements +Maintain Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance +through FAS compliance +with requirements + +FFMIA compliance asserted +on 11/08/2005 + +Produce Quarterly +Financial Statements +within 21 days of end of +quarter + +NSF submitted timely and +accurate quarterly statements +within 21 days of the end of +quarter + +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2006 Financial +Statements +Quarterly reports +produced +within 21 days and year + +ithi 45 d + +Maintain Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance +through FAS compliance +with requirements + +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2007 Financial +Statements +Quarterly reports +produced +within 21 days and year +Maintain Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance +through FAS compliance +with requirements + +ithi 45 d + +Resolve 100% of +excessive cash on hand +findings + +Close 100% of awards +within two full reporting +quarters after the +expiration date + +Resolve 100% of +excessive cash on hand +findings + +Close 100% of awards +within two full reporting +quarters after the +expiration date + +Unqualified Audit Opinion +for FY 2008 Financial +Statements +Quarterly reports +produced +within 21 days and year + +ithi 45 d + +Maintain Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance +through FAS compliance +with requirements + +Received Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance - +Implemented required +changes to SGL and +transactions + +Produced Quarterly +Financial Statements +within 21 days of end +of + +Produced Quarterly and +year-end Financial +Statements by deadlines + +Received Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance - +Implemented required +changes to SGL and +transactions + +Produce Quarterly and +year-end Financial +Statements by deadlines + +Received Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance - +Implemented required +changes to SGL and +transactions + +Reviewed 100% of +Federal Cash +Transactions Reports +with positive cash on +hand + +Closed 100% of awards +within two full +reporting +quarters after the +expiration date +Reviewed 100% of +Federal Cash +Transactions Reports +with positive cash on +hand + +Closed 100% of awards +within two full +reporting +quarters after the +expiration date +Unqualified Audit +Opinion + +Produced Quarterly and +year-end Financial +Statements by deadlines + +Received Assertion of +FFMIA Compliance - +Implemented required +changes to SGL and +transactions + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +7 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Fiscal Year + +Strategic +Goal(s) +Supported + +Performance Measure + +Actual/ +Baseline (from +previous year) + +Planned +Performance +Metric (Target) + +Performance Metric +Results (Actual) + +2009 + +2009 + +2009 + +2009 + +2009 + +2010 + +2011 + +2010 + +2010 + +2010 + +2011- + +2011 + +2011 + +2011 + +2011 + +All new IT investments initiated for FY 2005 and beyond must use Table 2 and are required to use the +Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Please use Table 2 and the +PRM to identify the performance information pertaining to this major IT investment. Map all Measurement +Indicators to the corresponding "Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. +There should be at least one Measurement Indicator for at least four different Measurement Areas (for each +fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +8 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Table 2 +Fiscal +Year + +Measurement Area IT + +Measurement Grouping IT + +Measurement +I di + +t + +Baseline Planned + +Actual Results + +Improvement to +the Baseline + +Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets Only) + +In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the +system/application level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and +operational systems security tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational +Security Table must be included on your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the +inventory (i.e., should use the same name or identifier). + +All systems supporting and/or part of this investment should be included in the tables below, inclusive of both agency +owned systems and contractor systems. For IT investments under development, security and privacy planning must +proceed in parallel with the development of the system/s to ensure IT security and privacy requirements and costs are +identified and incorporated into the overall lifecycle of the system/s. + +Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: + +(1) Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified and integrated into the overall costs of the + +investment: yes + +(a) If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the budget year: 14 + +(2) Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part of the overall risk management effort for +each system supporting or part of this investment. yes + +(3) Systems in Planning - Security: + +Name Of System + +Agency Or Contractor Operated + +System? + +Planned Operational Date + +Planned or Actual +C&A Completion Date + +(4) Operational Systems - Security: + +Name Of System + +Agency Or Contractor +Operated system + +NIST FIPS +199 + +Risk Impact +Level (High, +Moderate, +Low) + +Has the +C&A been +completed +using +NIST 800- +37? + +Date C&A +Complete + +What standards we +used for the +Security Controls +tests? + +Date Completed + +Security +Control Testing + +Date +Contingency +Plan Tested + +FAS + +Contractor and +Government + +High + +yes + +04/05/06 + +FIPS 200 / NIST +800-53 + +01/18/06 + +02/15/06 + +(5) Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of the systems part of or supporting this +investment been identified by the agency or IG? no + +(a) If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into the agency's plan of action and milestone + +process? + +(6) Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is requested to remediate IT security +weaknesses? no + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +9 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + (a) If "yes," specify the amount, a general description of the weakness, and how the funding request +will remediate the weakness. + +(7) How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for + +the contractor systems above? + +NSF uses a range of methods to review the security of operations through contract requirements, project +management oversight and review, certification and accreditation processes, IG independent reviews, +proactive testing of controls through penetration testing and vulnerability scans to ensure services are +adequately secure and meet the requirements of FISMA, OMB policy, NIST guidelines and NSF policy. The +system is operated on-site by a team of contractors and NSF personnel with system administrators tightly +controlling access to the systems. Only administrators with current need have access to the system, +and strict code migration, quality control, and configuration management procedures prevent deployment of +hostile or vulnerable software on the systems. Contractors are trained in the same security measures as +NSF employees. All NSF employees and contract staff are required to complete an on-line security training +class each year, including the rules of behavior. Background checks are done routinely as a part of the +NSF contracting process, and IT security requirements are stated in the contracts statement of work. +Contractor security procedures are monitored, verified, and validated by the agency in the same way as for +government employees. Once on board, contractors are allowed access to the NSF systems based on their +specific job requirements. Audit logs are also implemented to monitor operating system changes - these +audit logs are reviewed by the system administrators. Additionally, roles and responsibilities are separated +to the extent possible to allow for checks and balances in system management and multiple levels of +oversight. + +(8) Planning and Operational Systems - Privacy: + +(a) Name Of System + +(b) Is this a +new system? + +(c) Is there a PIA that +covers this system? • + +(d) Is the PIA available to the public? + +F A S + +no + +1. Y e s . + +2 . No, because a PIA is not yet + +required to be completed at this time. + +(e) Is a +System +Records +Notice +(SORN) +required for +this system? + +no + +(I) Was a new or amended SORN +published in FY06? + +5. No, because the system is + +not a Privacy Act system of + +records. + +(c) Is there a Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) that covers this system? + +1. Yes. +2. No. +3. No, because the system does not contain, process, or transmit personal identifying information. +4. No, because even though it has personal identifying information, the system contains information solely about + +federal employees and agency contractors. + +(d) Is the PIA available to the public? + +1. Yes. +2. No, because a PIA is not yet required to be completed at this time. +3. No, because the PIA has not been prepared. + +(f) Was a new or amended SORN published in FY2006? + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +10 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + 1. Yes, because this is a newly established Privacy Act system of records. +2. Yes, because the existing Privacy Act system of records was substantially revised in FY 06. +3. No, because the existing Privacy Act system of records was not substantially revised in FY 06. +4. No; the system is operational, but the SORN has not yet been published. +5. No, because the system is not a Privacy Act system of records. + +Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets Only) + +In order to successfully address this area of the business case and capital asset plan you must ensure +the investment is included in the agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) +process, and is mapped to and supports the FEA. You must also ensure the business case demonstrates +the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and +technology layers of the agency's EA. + +(1) Is this investment included in your agency's target enterprise architecture? yes (a) + +If "no," please explain why? + +(2) Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition Strategy? yes + +a. If "yes," provide the +investment name as identified +in the Transition Strategy +provided in the agency's most +recent annual EA +Assessment. +b. If "no," please explain +why? + +The Financial Accounting System (FAS) is included as part of the Next +Generation Grants Management workstream in the EA Transition Strategy +submitted to OMB on February 28, 2006. + +(3) Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge +management, content management, customer relationship management, etc.). Provide this +information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components, +please refer to http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/egov/. + +Agency +Component +Name + +Agency +Comonent +p + +Description + +Advice of BEP Maintenance of + +FEASRM +Service Type + +FEA SRM +Component +(a) + +Billing and + +FEA Service Component Reused (b) + +Reused Service +Component Name + +Reused Service Component +UPI + +Internal External +Reuse (c) + +Funding +Percentage +(d) + +No Reuse + +10 + +Charge Card +Module + +FASTRAN + +AP Log + +Funding +Allocations +Charge Card +Bill Processing + +Transaction +Processing +Module + +Accounts +Payable/Prompt +Pay and Invoice +tracking + +Management + +Credit / +Charge + +Management + +Financials + +Management + +Expense +Management + +Financial + +Management + +Payment / +Settlement + +No Reuse + +No Reuse + +No Reuse + +3 + +10 + +7 + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +11 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Agency +Componen +Name + +FASTRAN + +FAS Core + +Agency +Component +Description + +FEASRM +Service Type + +FEA SRM +Component +(a) + +FEA Service Component Reused (b) + +Reused Service +Component Name + +Reused Service Component +UPI + +Internal External +Reuse(c) + +Funding +Percentage +(d) + +Transaction +Processing +Module + +Financial +Management + +Debt +Collection + +Core +Functionally of +Accounting +System + +Internal +Controls + +Financial + +Management + +No Reuse + +10 + +No Reuse + +60 + +a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already +identified as a service component in the FEA SRM. + +b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this +investment. Rather than answer yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other +investment and identify the other investment using the Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the +OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission. + +c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a +service component provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one +agency within a department reusing a service component provided by another agency in another +department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiatiye service being reused by multiple +organizations across the federal government. + +d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service +component listed in the table. If external, provide the funding level transferred to another agency to +pay for the service. + +4. To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model +(TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and Service Specifications supporting +this IT investment. + +FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area +Billing and Accounting + +Service Access and + +FEA TRM Service Category +Access Channels + +FEA TRM Service Standard +Other Electronic Channels + +FEAService Specification (b) + +Billing and Accounting + +Delivery + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Billing and Accounting + +Billing and Accounting + +Service Access and + +Delivery + +Service Access and +Delivery + +Service Access and +Delivery + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Billing and Accounting. + +Service Platform and + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Billing and Accounting + +Billing and Accounting + +Billing and Accounting + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Delivery Servers + +Application Servers + +Windows NT + +Database / Storage + +Database + +Sybase 12,x + +Hardware / Infrastructure + +Servers / Computers + +Windows NT + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +12 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Billing and Accounting + +Billing and Accounting + +Billing and Accounting +Billing and Accounting + +Component Framework Presentation / Interface + +Static Display + +Component Framework Data Management + +Database Connectivity. + +Sybase 12.x + +Component Framework Data Management + +Service Interface and + +Integration + +Integration + +Reporting and Analysis +Enterprise Application + +Integration + +Billing and Accounting + +Service Interface and + +lnteroperability + +Data Transformation + +Integration + +Billing and Accounting + +Service Interface and + +Interface + +Service Description + +API + +Credit / Charge + +Service Access and + +Access Channels + +Other Electronic Channels + +Integration + +Interface + +Delivery + +Credit / Charge + +Service Access and + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Delivery + +Credit / Charge + +Service Access and + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Credit / Charge + +Service Access and + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Delivery + +Credit / Charge + +Credit / Charge + +Credit / Charge + +Credit / Charge + +Delivery. + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Delivery Servers + +Application Servers + +Windows NT + +Database / Storage + +Database: + +Sybase 12,x + +Hardware / Infrastructure Servers / Computers + +Windows NT + +Credit / Charge + +Component Framework + +Presentation / Interface + +Static Display + +Credit / Charge + +Component Framework Data Management + +Database Connectivity + +Sybase 12.x + +Credit / Charge + +Component Framework Data Management + +Credit / Charge + +Service Interface and + +Integration; + +Reporting and Analysis + +. + +Enterprise Application +Integration + +Credit / Charge + +Credit / Charge + +Integration + +Service Interface and + +Integration + +Service Interface and +Integration + +lnteroperability + +Data Transformation + +Interface + +Service Description / + +API + +Interface + +Expense Management + +Service Access and + +Access Channels + +Other Electronic Channels + +Delivery + +Expense Management + +Service Access and + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Delivery + +Expense Management + +Service Access and + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Expense Management + +Service Access and + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Delivery + +Delivery + +Expense Management + +Service Platform and + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Infrastructure + +Expense Management + +Service Platform and + +Delivery Servers + +Application Servers + +Windows NT + +Expense Management + +Service Platform and + +Database / Storage + +Database, + +Sybase 12,x + +Infrastructure + +Infrastructure + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +13 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Expense Management + +Service Platform and + +Hardware / Infrastructure + +Servers / Computers, + +Windows NT + +Infrastructure + +Expense Management + +Component Framework + +Presentation / Interface + +Static Display + +Expense Management + +Component Framework Data Management + +Database Connectivity + +Sybase 12.x + +Expense Management +Expense Management + +Component Framework Data Management + +Reporting and Analysis + +Service Interface and + +Integration + +Integration + +Enterprise Application + +Integration + +Expense Management. + +Service Interface and + +lnteroperability + +Data Transformation + +Integration: + +Expense Management + +Service Interface and + +Interface + +Service Description / + +API + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Access and + +Access Channels + +Other Electronic Channels + +Integration + +Interface + +Delivery + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Access and + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Delivery + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Access and + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Payment / Settlement + +Payment / Settlement + +Payment / Settlement + +Delivery + +Service Access and +Delivery + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Delivery Servers + +Application Servers + +Windows NT + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Platform and + +Database / Storage + +Database + +Sybase 12,x + +Infrastructure + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Platform and + +Hardware / Infrastructure + +Servers / Computers + +Windows NT + +Payment / Settlement + +Infrastructure +Component Framework Presentation / Interface + +Static Display + +Payment / Settlement + +Component Framework Data Management + +Database Connectivity + +Sybase 12.x + +Payment / Settlement + +Component Framework: Data Management + +Reporting and Analysis, + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Interface and + +Integration + +Integration + +Payment / Settlement + +Service Interface and + +Interoperability + +Payment / Settlement + +Debt Collection + +Integration + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Interface + +Enterprise Application + +Integration +„..,, +Data Transformation + +Service Description / + +Interface' + +Service Access and + + Delivery + +Access Channels + +Other Electronic Channels + +Debt Collection + +Service Access and + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Delivery + +Service Access and + +Delivery + +Service Access and + + Delivery + +Service Platform and, + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Delivery Servers + +!Application Servers + +Windows NT + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +14 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Database / Storage + +Database + +Sybase 12,x + +Hardware / Infrastructure + +Servers / Computers + +Windows NT + +Debt Collection + +Component Framework + +Presentation / Interface + +Static Display + +Debt Collection + +Component Framework Data Management + +Database Connectivity + +Sybase 12.x. + +Debt Collection +Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Debt Collection + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Component Framework Data Management + +Reporting and Analysis + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Service Access and +Delivery + +Service Access and + +Delivery + +Service Access and + +Delivery + +Service Access and +Delivery + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Service Platform and + +Infrastructure + +Integration + +Enterprise Application: + +Integration + +Interoperability + +Data Transformation + +Interface + +Service Description / + +Interface + +API + +Access Channels + +:Other Electronic Channels. + +Delivery Channels + +Intranet + +Service Requirements + +Legislative / Compliance + +Service Transport + +Service Transport + +Support Platforms + +Platform Dependent + +Windows XP + +Delivery Servers + +Application Servers + +Windows NT + +Database / Storage + +Database + +Sybase 12,x + +Hardware / Infrastructure + +Servers / Computers + +Windows NT + +Internal Controls + +Component Framework Presentation / Interface + +Internal Controls + +Component Framework Data Management + +Static Display +Database Connectivity + +Sybase 12.x + +Internal Controls +Internal Controls + +Internal Controls + +Component Framework Data Management + +Reporting and Analysis, + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Service Interface and +Integration + +Integration + +Enterprise Application + +Integration + +Interoperability. + +Data Transformation + +Internal Controls: + +Service Interface and! + +Interface + +Service Description / + +API + +Integration + +Interface + +a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please +enter multiple rows for FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications. + +b. In the Service Specification field, Agencies should provide information on the specified technical +standard or vendor product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version +numbers, as appropriate. + +5. Will the application leverage existing components and/or applications across the Government +(i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, etc)? no + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +15 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + a. If "yes," please describe. + +6. Does this investment provide the public with access to a government automated information +system? no + +(a) If "yes," does customer access require specific software (e.g., a +specific web browser version)? +[1] If "yes," provide the specific product name(s) and version number(s) of the required software and +the date when the public will be able to access this investment by any software (i.e. to ensure +equitable and timely access of government information and services). + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +16 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + PART III: For "Operation and Maintenance" Investments ONLY (Steady State) + +Part III should be completed only for investments which will be in "Operation and Maintenance" +(Steady State) in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. + +Section A: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) + +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of +this investment's life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to +eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment's life- +cycle. + +Answer the following questions to describe how you are managing investment risks. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? yes + +a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan? + +06/01/2005 + +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since last year's submission to + +OMB? no + +c. If "yes," describe any significant changes: + +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? + +a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date? +b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks? + +Section B: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +Answer the following questions about how you are currently managing this investment. + +1. Was an operational analysis conducted? yes + +a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed. + +06/01/2005 + +b. If "yes," what were the results? (Max 2500 Characters) + +The results of the OA recommend that the FAS continue to be used as the NSF's financial accounting + +system for the next several years. The NSF is in the process of conducting a pilot project as a Grants + +Management Line of Business provider. We plan to take advantage of the results/findings of the GMLOB + +process in becoming an SSP to more fully define our financial requirements. This will allow the NSF to take + +an integrated approach to both GMLOB & FMLOB in regards to the future of FAS and NSF's + +financial system. + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +17 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 + + c. If "no," please explain why it was not conducted and if there are any plans to conduct an + +operational analysis in the future? (Max 2500 Characters) + +2. Complete the following table to compare actual cost performance against the planned cost +performance baseline. Milestones reported may include specific individual scheduled preventative +and predictable corrective maintenance activities, or may be the total of planned annual operation +and maintenance efforts). Indicate if the information provided includes government and contractor +costs: + +a. What costs are included in the reported Cost/Schedule Performance information (Government +Only/Contractor Only/Both)? Contractor Only + +Description of Milestone (Max 50 +Characters) + +Planned + +Completion Date + +Total Cost +($M) + +Actual +Completion Date Total Costs + +($M) + +$1.800 + +$1.500 + +09/30/2001 + +09/30/2002 + +$1.800 + +$1.500 + +09/30/2001 + +09/30/2002 + +09/30/2003 + +$1.670 + +09/30/2003 + +$1.670 + +09/30/2004 + +09/30/2005 + +09/30/200 + +09/30/2007 + +$1.300 + +$1.300 + +$1.500 + +$1.500. + +09/30/2004 + +09/30/2005 + +09/30/2006 + +$1.300: + +$1.300 + +$1.500 + +$0.000 + +Baseline +Schedule +Variance +(#Days) + +Baseline +Cost +Variance +($M) + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +$0.000 + +FY01 Steady State Operations + +FY02 Steady State Operations + +FY03 Steady State Operations + +FY04 Steady State Operations + +FY05 Steady State Operations + +FY06 Steady State Operations + +FY07 Steady State Operations + +Total Planned Costs: + +Total Actual Costs: $9.070 + +NSF FAS 1-3-07 + +18 of 18 + +FY08 Exhibit 300 diff --git a/q15/random_k2/question.json b/q15/random_k2/question.json index 9eb0d24f1915f708e5916a78f9fd1f32e456a74c..c308919e32a1b0e0411e0cfb981f026a068dc7a6 100644 --- a/q15/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q15/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2312.10997v5.pdf", - "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf", - "web_c40e5cade76fba39.pdf" + "web_0592b193cfe894c0.pdf", + "resize_r2_25.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q15/random_k2/random_1.md b/q15/random_k2/random_1.md index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..d3a8827a2c9c1661d68231635f74293c020f1a02 100644 --- a/q15/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q15/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,5479 +1,1353 @@ -Owner’s Manual +CHAPTER 42 -Models -14, 16, 17, 18 - -Refrigerators +FORMWORK -TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST +42 FORMWORK -Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR +Definitions - Congratulations! - -Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our -quality products and we are committed to -providing dependable service. You’ll see it in -this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll -hear it in the friendly voices of our customer -service department. - -Best of all, you’ll experience these values -each time you use your refrigerator. That’s -important, because your new refrigerator will -be part of your family for many years. And we -hope you will be part of ours for a long time -to come. +The following definitions are used in the forming +industry. Some terms may be used by other trades +as well, but their meanings may be different from +these depending upon the application. -We appreciate your purchase, and hope you -will continue to rely on us whenever you -need quality appliances for your home. +Falsework, in relation to a form or structure, means +the structural supports and bracing used to support +all or part of the form or structure until the concrete +is poured and is strong enough to support loads. -Important! - -Fill out and return the Consumer Product -Registration Card that is packed with this -product. If you cannot find it, please send -in the duplicate card printed in the back of -this manual. +Flying formwork is a designed floor formwork +system that can be hoisted between levels as a unit. -Write the model and serial -numbers here. - -# - -# - -You can find them on a label on the -upper left side of the fresh food -compartment. - -Staple sales slip or cancelled -check here. - -Proof of the original purchase date -is needed to obtain service under -the warranty. - -2 - - AService Partnership. - -We stand behind our products with -unmatched quality service. However, did -you know that most questions result from -simple problems that you can easily -fix yourself in just a few minutes? This -Owner’s Manual can tell you how. - -Read this Manual -Inside you will find many -helpful hints on how to use and -maintain your refrigerator -properly. Just a little preventive -care on your part can save you a -great deal of time and money -over the life of your refrigerator. - -Review the Section on -Troubleshooting Tips - -You’ll find many answers to -common problems here. -If you review our chart of -Troubleshooting Tips first, -you may not need to call for -service at all. - -If You Need Service - -If you do need service, you can -relax knowing help is only a -phone call away. A list of toll-free -customer service numbers is -included in the back section. -Or you can always call the -GE Answer Center® at -800.626.2000, 24 hours a day, -7 days a week. - -Safety Information -Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4 -Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 -How to Connect Electricity . . . .6 -Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7 -Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7 - -Operating Instructions - -Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8 -Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10 -Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12 -Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13 -Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16 - -Installation Instructions - -Preparing to -Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18 -Water Line Installation . . .19–23 -Reversing the -Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29 - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Normal Operating Sounds . . .30 -Before You -Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33 - -Customer Service -Product Registration . . . . . . . .37 -Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39 -Service Telephone -Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover - -3 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -4 - -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! - -Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as -described in this Owner’s Manual. - -SAFETY PRECAUTIONS -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions -should be followed, including the following: - -n Keep fingers out of the -“pinch point” areas; -clearances between the -doors and between the doors -and cabinet are necessarily -small. Be careful closing -doors when children are in -the area. - -n Unplug the refrigerator - -before cleaning and making -repairs. - -NOTE: We strongly recommend -that any servicing be performed -by a qualified individual. - -n Turning the control to the - -OFF position does not remove -power to the light circuit. -n Do not refreeze frozen foods - -which have thawed -completely. - -n This refrigerator must be -properly installed and -located in accordance with -the Installation Instructions -before it is used. - -n Do not allow children to - -climb, stand or hang on the -shelves in the refrigerator. -They could damage the -refrigerator and seriously -injure themselves. -n Do not touch the cold -surfaces in the freezer -compartment, particularly -when hands are damp or wet. -Skin may stick to these -extremely cold surfaces. -n Do not store or use gasoline -or other flammable vapors -and liquids in the vicinity of -this or any other appliance. - -n In refrigerators with - -automatic icemakers, avoid -contact with the moving parts -of the ejector mechanism, or -with the heating element that -releases the cubes. Do not -place fingers or hands on the -automatic icemaking -mechanism while the -refrigerator is plugged in. - - DANGER! RISK OF CHILD - -ENTRAPMENT -PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR - -Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of -the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still -dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.” -If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please -follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents. - -Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator -or Freezer: - -n Take off the doors. -n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not - -easily climb inside. - -CFC Disposal - -Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used -CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm -stratospheric ozone. - -If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make -sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal -by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this -CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and -imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean -Air Act. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -5 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -6 - -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! - -HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY -Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third -(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety, -this appliance must be properly grounded. - -The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong -(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong -(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric -shock hazard from this appliance. - -Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician -to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. - -Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your -personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a -properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet. - -The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual -electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating -plate. - -This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading -house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from -overheated wires. - -Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord. -Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet. - -Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become -frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or -abrasion damage along its length or at either end. - -When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to -roll over or damage the power cord. - -USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -adapter plug. - -However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a -temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong -wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local -hardware stores. - - The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in -the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the -power cord. - -When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold -the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord -plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground -terminal is very likely to break with repeated use. - -If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator -until a proper ground has been established. - -Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not -ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the -wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit -checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. - -USE OF EXTENSION CORDS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -extension cord. - -However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely -necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance -extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that -the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and -120 volts. - -REMEMBER… -Your continued health and safety are important to us. - -Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully. - -We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our -family. -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -7 - - About the temperature control dial. - -Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments— -fresh food and freezer. - -9 - -OFF - -7 - -5 - -3 - -1 - -Control Settings -Temperature Control Dial - -The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF. -1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5. - -After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary. - -Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn -the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs. - -Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -8 - - About the fresh food compartment shelves. - -Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves. -Not all features are on all models. - -2 Lift up and out - -1 Tilt up - -Half-Width Shelves - -One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall -support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track -on the rear cabinet wall. - -To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support -and out of the track. - -To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front -raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track, -then lower the shelf onto the support. - -NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to -hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is -designed to hook into the left-hand slot. - -Full-Width Shelves - -Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary -tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves. -These shelves can be moved to another place in the -fresh food compartment. - -The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed -correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before -coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not -tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it. - -To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf -and pull forward. - -To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food -compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of -the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it -out. - -9 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - About the freezer compartment shelves. - -Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf. - -Plug Supports - -Ice-Tray Shelf - -To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf -off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of -the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the -pins from the holes in the cabinet wall. - -(cid:49) - -(cid:50) - -Step Shelf - -To remove the step shelf: - -1 -2 - -3 - -Lift left side of shelf slightly. - -Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes -in the cabinet wall. - -Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and -take it out. - -To replace the step shelf: - -1 - -2 - -With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into -holes in cabinet wall. - -Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right -ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower -shelf into place. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -10 - - About the storage drawers. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Fruit and Vegetable Drawers - -Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the -drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry. - -Utility Drawer - -The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful -location for your family’s needs. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -11 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -12 - -About storage drawer and cover removal. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Drawer and Cover Removal - -Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to -help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers -can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly -while pulling drawers past the stoplocation. - -Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover - -To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it -forward, tilt it and take it out. - -Twin Drawer With Glass Cover - -To remove: - -1 -2 - -Remove the drawers. - -Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the -same time, pull it forward as far as it will come. - -Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover -with hot water because the extreme temperature -difference may cause it to break. - -3 - -Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass -cover before you take out the drawer frame.) - -Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back, -pull it forward, tilt it and take it out. - -To replace: - -Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each -side and back. - -Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly -into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the -front into place. - -Replace the drawers. - -1 - -2 - -3 - - About the automatic icemaker. - -A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice. - -Icemaker - -Feeler arm -in the STOP -(up) position - -Ice Storage Bin - -Automatic Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle— -approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period, -depending on freezer compartment temperature, room -temperature, number of door openings and other use -conditions. - -If the refrigerator is operated before the water -connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm -in the STOP (up) position. - -Feeler arm in the -ON (down) position - -When the refrigerator has been connected to the water -supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position. - -The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to -freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 -hours to begin making ice cubes. - -Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water -line to clear. - -Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler -arm. - -It is normal for several cubes to be joined together. - -If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become -cloudy and taste stale. - -Icemaker Accessory Kit - -If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an -automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra -cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit -needed for your model. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -13 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Cleaning the Outside - -The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth -dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth. - -Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened -with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and -polish with a clean, soft cloth. - -Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may -leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered -cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can -scratch and weaken the paint finish. - -Cleaning the Inside - -To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh -food and freezer compartments. - -Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring -excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around -switches, lights or controls. - -Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans -and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry. - -Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the -doors. - -After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly -to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets -from sticking and bending out of shape. - -Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the -extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves -carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter. - -Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -14 - - Under the Refrigerator - -For most efficient operation, keep the area under the -refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to -OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust. - -Clean the condenser coils at least -once a year. - -For best results, use a brush specially designed for this -purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores. - -Behind the Refrigerator - -Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All -types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned -coverings and those with embossed surfaces. - -Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator -counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull -the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it -straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in -damage to the floor covering or refrigerator. - -When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power -cord or icemaker supply line (on some models). - -After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise -until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -15 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Light Bulb Replacement - -To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its -electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an -appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage. - -Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit. - -Preparing for Vacation - -For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the -refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position, -and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the -doors open. - -Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut -off the water supply to the refrigerator. - -If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified -servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent -serious property damage due to flooding. - -Preparing to Move - -Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping -them securely in place to prevent damage. - -Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -16 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models) - -If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an -icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line. - -A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings -and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from -Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -Refrigerator Location - -Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below -60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain -proper temperatures. - -Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded. - -Clearances - -Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air -circulation and plumbing and electrical connections: -3/4† (19 mm) -1† (25 mm) -1† (25 mm) - -Sides - -Back - -Top - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -17 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Rollers and Leveling Legs - -Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They -firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are -opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just -enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway. - -Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to -lower it. - -Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the -wall for cleaning. - -Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred -from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the -legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -18 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Before You Begin -This water line installation is not warranted by the -refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these -instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive -water damage. - -Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house -plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead -to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to -correct water hammer before installing the water supply -line to the refrigerator. - -To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the -water line to the hot water line. - -If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water -line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP -(up) position. - -Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where -temperatures fall below freezing. - -When using any electrical device (such as a power drill) -during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired -in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock. - -All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing -code requirements. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -19 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -What You Will Need -To determine how much copper tubing you need: - -Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the -refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm). -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) -coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow -the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. -n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and -fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer -or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between - -20 and 120 p.s.i. - -n Power drill. - -n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to -the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square. - -Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is -under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle -with age and crack, resulting in water leakage. - -n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)— - -to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the -refrigerator water valve. - -n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will - -need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect -the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared -fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting. -n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve -should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of -5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle- -type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before -purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your -local plumbing codes. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -20 - - Shut Off the Main Water Supply - -Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water. - -Install the Shutoff Valve -1 -2 - -Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line. - -Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect -into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a -horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at -the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe. -Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs -resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe. - -3 - -4 -5 - -Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp. - -Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell. - -Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing. - -Pipe Clamp - -Washer - -Inlet End - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Vertical Cold Water Pipe - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -21 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve - -Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator. - -Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the -refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible. - -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about -10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and -connect it to the shutoff valve. - -Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut -securely. - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Compression Nut - -Packing -Nut - -Outlet Valve - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing -1 - -Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water -is clear. - -2 - -Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has -been flushed through the tubing. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -22 - - Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator - -Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the -refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet. - -We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles -that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water -line near the refrigerator. - -1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as -shown. - -Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as -possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting. - -Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical -position. You may need to pry open the clamp. - -1/4† Copper Tubing - -Tubing Clamp - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -1/4† Compression Nut - -Refrigerator Connection - -Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve - -Tighten any connections that leak. - -Plug In the Refrigerator - -Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of -the refrigerator or against the wall. - -Push the refrigerator back to the wall. - -Start the Icemaker - -Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will -not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.) -or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm -is in the ON(down) position. - -NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from -the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again. - -23 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - Reversing the door swing. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Important Notes -When reversing the door swing : - -n Read the instructions all the way through before starting. -n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint. -n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the - -wrong places. - -n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors. -IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until -door-swing reversal is completed. - -These instructions are for changing the hinges from the -right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the -hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions -and reverse all references to left and right. - -Tools Required -n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver -n Masking tape -n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires -n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver -n 5/16† open-end wrench -n Phillips screwdriver - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -24 - - Removing the doors. - -Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet. - -Before Removing the Doors -1 -2 -CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could -damage the door stop. - -Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment. - -Remove the Freezer Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the -top hinge to the cabinet. - -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin -from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws. - -Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the -door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge -bracket. - -Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal. - -Top Hinge - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -25 - - Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Remove the Fresh Food Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench, -remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to -the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of -the door, and set hinge and screws aside. - -3 - -4 -5 - -6 - -Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from -the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door -bottom, put it back on the hinge.) - -Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal. - -Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw -hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough -space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket. - -Center Hinge Bracket - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left -1 - -Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight -out. - -2 - -Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to -it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side. - -Plastic Washer - -Hinge Bracket - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -26 - - Reversing the door handles. - -Transfer Top Hinge to the Left - -Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws -at top left of cabinet. - -Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time. - -Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge -depends on which side you install the hinge. - -Installing the hinge on the left. - -Installing the hinge on the right. - -Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle - -Top View - -Bottom View - -1 - -2 - -3 -4 - -Remove the bottom cap by -pushing it toward the bottom of -the door and remove the screw +Forms are the moulds into which concrete or +another material is poured. + +Formwork is a system of forms connected +together. + +Gangforms are large panels designed to be hoisted +as a unit, and to be erected, stripped, and re-used. + +Knock-down forms are traditional formwork +supported by falsework and shoring, assembled +from bulk materials, used once, and then +dismantled. + +Panels are sections of form intended to be +connected together. + +Sheathing is the material directly supported by +wales, and against which concrete is to be placed. + +Specialty formwork is designed specifically for a +particular structure or placing technique. + +Struts are vertical members of shoring that directly +resist pressure from wales. + +Wales are horizontal members of shoring that are +placed against sheathing to directly resist pressure +from the sheathing. + +Introduction + +In most cases, the formwork required for concrete +construction is built by carpenters. Shoring and +bracing support the forms that contain the wet +concrete. Formwork must also support the temporary +weight of material such as bundles of reinforcing +steel and live loads of workers and equipment. + +There are three stages in formwork operations: + +1. Assembly and erection + +2. Concrete placement + +3. Stripping and dismantling. + +To be done safely, each of these jobs requires +planning, knowledge, and skill from both +supervisors and workers. Design and planning +are a supervisory function that may also legally +require a professional engineer’s involvement. +Small construction and renovation jobs, however, +sometimes call for typical design work (e.g., +specific heights and sizes from the manufacturer), +which can be done on site by workers. + +Where design drawings are provided, it is +important to construct the formwork as designed. +Any confusion regarding the design should be +approved by the designer. + +If site conditions require changes or the design +does not seem to suit the situation, changes +and approval should also be obtained from the +designer. Formwork failures frequently involve +deviations from the original design that were done +without consulting the designer. They may also +involve human error. For these reasons, formwork +and shoring must always be inspected before +concrete is placed. + +All large formwork installations in Ontario must be +designed by a professional engineer. But there are +always smaller jobs of moderate height or depth— +basements, footings, stairs—that may include +formwork with typical design arrangements from +a form tie manufacturer, which is installed and +constructed on the site. + +Every carpenter should therefore know the type +of formwork needed and how to build, install, and +dismantle it safely. + +Formwork must always be constructed according +to good, safe, and sound carpentry practice. It must +have the following: + +• Adequate braces and supports + +• Reliable bearing surfaces, especially where wood + +structures are involved + +• Adequate ties, bolts, or bracing to prevent + +movement or bulging. + +Because wood is relatively soft, it will crush under +heavy loads such as concrete when the bearing +surface of joists on stringers, or studs on wales, is +not adequate. + +Crushing can be avoided by increasing the bearing +area between members, using spreader washers +(Figure 42-1), or increasing the number of joists +or studs. + +Figure 42-1: Spreader Washer on +Wooden Wale System + +Tools and Techniques + +42-1 + + FORMWORK + +Hazards + +The following are the main hazard areas in +formwork operations. + +• Falls – They are the major hazard because they are +potentially fatal. Cramped work areas, inadequate +access, failure to install guardrails, failure to use fall +arrest systems, tools or material left underfoot, and +surfaces slippery from form oil can all lead to falls. +Ladders are also frequently involved in falls. All +workers in Ontario who may be exposed to a fall +hazard and who may use a fall protection system +must have working at heights training that has been +approved by the Chief Prevention Officer. (See +Chapter 18: Guardrails and Chapter 19: Personal +Fall Protection) + +• Dust and concrete – Blowing dust and flying + +concrete particles during the chipping or cleaning +of formwork can injure unprotected eyes. + +• Access equipment – Access equipment such as +ladders and scaffolds is involved not only in falls +but in slips, trips, and other accidents. Hazards +include ladders not tied off, workers carrying +materials while climbing, ladders obstructed at +top or bottom, scaffolds not completely decked +in, and scaffolds erected or dismantled without +fall protection. + +• Lighting – Inadequate lighting can create or + +aggravate hazards when workers install or strip +forms in dark areas or place concrete at night. + +• Materials handling – The activity most frequently + +Injuries + +connected with injury. Improper or excessive +materials handling can result in sprains, strains, +and overexertion in shoulders, arms, and back, as +well as bruises, abrasions, and crushed fingers. + +• Struck against – Common because formwork + +operations are constantly changing and involve +the movement of heavy, awkward, and pointed +components. Wales, beams, panels, snap-ties, +nails, bolts, and rebar can cause punctures, cuts, +contusions, and abrasions. + +• Struck by – Another common cause of injury. +Rebar, formwork panels, concrete buckets, +and other material hoisted overhead can strike +workers. Struck-by injuries can also be caused by +hammers, pry bars, stakes, wedges, and material +such as joists and panels during stripping. + +• Electrical contact – Power tools, extension cords, +and temporary supply and wiring systems, used +under less-than-ideal conditions – mud, ground +water, wet excavations, fresh concrete – can lead +to ground faults, shortcircuits, and shock hazards. +Ground fault circuit interrupters are legally +required for portable tools used outdoors or in +wet locations. + +• Collapses – Even with advanced methods of + +design and installation, there is always the risk +that formwork, slabforms, wall forms, and other +large components can come loose, slip out of +place, or fall over, striking or crushing workers underneath. -Remove the two screws holding -the handle to the top of the door. - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screws from the right -edge of the door top and insert -them into the handle screw holes -on the opposite side. - -5 - -6 - -With tape-tipped putty knife or -thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the -plug button from the hinge hole -on the left side of the door and -insert it into the hole on the -opposite side that was vacated by -removal of the top hinge. - -Pull the plug button from the -front of the door and transfer it to -the opposite side. - -Plug Button - -Screws for -Handle Holes - -Plug Button - -To reattach the handle on the -opposite side. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -27 - - Rehanging the doors. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Transfer Door Stop -1 - -Move the metal door stop from -the right end to the left end. Use a -Torxdriver. - -Door Stop - -2 - -Move any screws from the left end -to the right end. - -Right Side - -Left Side - -Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle -1 - -Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and -under the handle plug. - -Reinstall the handle plug. - -2 -Transfer Freezer Door Handle -1 - -Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two -screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door. - -2 -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the -handle screw hole on the left side. - -Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the -opposite side. - -Transfer the door stop as shown above. - -Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and -bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws. - -Left Side - -Right Side - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -28 - - Rehang the Fresh Food Door -1 - -Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom -hinge. - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -2 - -3 - -Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door. -NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the -left side. - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide -the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven -into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both -screws securely. - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic -Washer - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Rehang the Freezer Door -1 - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin. - -2 - -3 - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the -socket on the top of the door. - -Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even -across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these -screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one- -half turn. - -Center Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -29 - - Normal operating sounds. - -Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen, -you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under -the refrigerator to reduce noise. - -The fan circulating air inside the freezer which -keeps the temperatures even. - -Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of -refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils. - -Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water -dropping on the defrost heater during the -defrost cycle. - -Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils -expanding and contracting during the -defrosting cycle. - -Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator -and flows to the drain pan during the defrost -cycle. - -Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker water valve will buzz when the -icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in -the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has -not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the -feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is -hooked up to water can damage the icemaker. -To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP -(up) position. This will stop the buzzing. - -The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and -water running in pipes as icemaker refills. - -These sounds are normal -and are due mostly to highly -efficient operation. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -30 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips -Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and -you may not need to call for service. - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Refrigerator does not -operate - -Refrigerator in -defrost cycle. - -Temperature control -dial in OFFposition. - -Refrigerator is -unplugged. - -The fuse is blown/ -circuit breaker is -tripped. - -Normal when -refrigerator is first -plugged in. - -Often occurs when large -amounts of food are -placed in refrigerator. - -Door left open. - -• Wait about 30 minutes for - -defrost cycle to end. - -• Move the temperature - -control dial to a -temperature setting. - -• Push the plug completely - -into the outlet. - -• Replace fuse or reset the - -breaker. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• This is normal. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Hot weather or frequent -door openings. - -• This is normal. - -Temperature control dial -set at the coldest setting. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Grille and condenser -need cleaning. - -Front roller screws or -front leveling legs need -adjusting. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -• See Rollers and leveling legs. - -Motor operates for long -periods or cycles on and -off frequently. (Modern -refrigerators with more -storage space and a larger -freezer require more -operating time. They start -and stop often to maintain -even temperatures.) - -Vibration or rattling -(slight vibration is normal) - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -31 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Fresh food or freezer -compartment too warm - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Warm weather or -frequent door openings. - -Door left open. - -Package blocking air -duct in freezer -compartment. - -Door left open. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -• Set the temperature -control dial one step -colder. See About the -temperature control dial. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -• Check to see if package is - -blocking air duct in freezer -compartment. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Icemaker feeler arm in -STOP (up) position. - -• Move the feeler arm to the - -ON (down) position. - -Water supply turned -off or not connected. - -Freezer compartment -too warm. - -Water shutoff valve -connecting refrigerator -to water line may be -clogged. - -• See Installing thewater line. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• Call a plumber to clear - -the valve. - -Frost or ice crystals on -frozen food (frost within -package is normal) - -Automatic icemaker -does not work -(on some models) - -Cubes too small - -Slow ice cube freezing - -Door left open. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -32 - - Problem - -Ice cubes have -odor/taste - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Ice storage bin needs -cleaning. - -• Empty and wash bin. -Discard old cubes. - -Food transmitting odor/ -taste to ice cubes. - -Interior of refrigerator -needs cleaning. - -• Wrap foods well. - -• See Care andcleaning. - -Moisture forms on -cabinet surface -between the doors - -Moisture collects inside -(in humid weather, air -carries moisture into -refrigerator when doors -are opened) - -Refrigerator has odor - -Not unusual during -periods of high -humidity. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -Foods transmitting -odor to refrigerator. - -• Wipe surface dry and - -reset temperature control -dial one setting colder. - -• Foods with strong odors - -should be tightly wrapped. -• Keep an open box of baking -soda in the refrigerator; -replace every three months. - -Interior needs cleaning. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -33 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -34 - - S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -35 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -36 - - GE Service Protection Plus™ - -GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability, -offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on -all your appliances—No Matter What Brand! - -Benefits Include: -• Backed by GE -• All brands covered -• Unlimited service calls -• All parts and labor costs included -• No out-of-pocket expenses -• No hidden deductibles -• One 800 number to call - -We’ll Cover Any Appliance. -Anywhere. Anytime.* - -You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your -money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple. - -Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much -more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly -financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered. -You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected -against expensive repairs. - -Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224 -for more information. - -*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S. - -" - -Cut here - -Please place in envelope and mail to: - -General Electric Company -Warranty Registration Department -P.O. Box 34070 -Louisville, KY 40232-4070 - -37 - - Consumer Product Ownership Registration -Dear Customer: -Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us. -We are proud to have you as a customer! +• Health hazards – The spraying of form oils and + +curing compounds can irritate the lungs. Contact +with these chemicals can irritate the skin, leading +to redness, inflammation, or dermatitis. The +same conditions can result from the abrasive/ +corrosive effect of skin contact with concrete or +cement, especially when inadvertently left inside +boots all day. + +• Environmental conditions – Ice, snow, and rain +create slippery conditions. Wind can be a major +hazard. Handling sheets of plywood becomes +more difficult, panels may require more bracing, +and hoisting gets harder, especially with large +panels or tables. + +Formwork hazards can lead to the injuries +described below. Follow the safety tips to prevent +such injuries. + +• Eye injuries – These are quite common in + +formwork operations. Most result from particles +of wood or concrete that fall or are blown into +the eye during chipping and cleaning. The injuries +may not be severe but most can be prevented +by wearing eye protection. It is strongly +recommended that everyone on site wear eye +protection at all times. + +• Cuts, scrapes, punctures – The manhandling + +necessary to install and strip formwork can lead +to cut hands, arms, and legs, as well as pinched +or crushed fingers. Gloves help to prevent +injuries from rough or sharp edges on formwork +components. But workers must also have the +knowledge, skill, and physical ability necessary +for safe materials handling. That means knowing +your limitations and asking for help when needed. +Formwork involves protruding objects such as +nails, snap ties, conduit, and bolts that can give +you cuts and punctures. Where possible, these +objects should not be left sticking out or should +be covered over. + +• Back injuries – These injuries are frequently + +related to materials handling. The most important +preventive measure is back care. Exercise +programs, warm-ups before work, and knowing +your limitations can help to prevent sprains and +strains. Wherever necessary, get help or use +dollies, carts, or other mechanical devices. + +• Ankle sprains and fractures – Working in +close quarters, stepping over debris and +material, climbing into excavations, turning with +awkward loads, jumping down from scaffolds +or benches—these can lead to ankle and other +foot or leg injuries. Prevention starts with proper +housekeeping and materials handling. + +• Bruises and contusions – Handling formwork + +under rushed, cramped, or slippery conditions or +beyond a person's physical limitations can lead to +bruises. Bruises and contusions also result from +contact with protruding formwork components. + +42-2 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +More serious are contusions from falling formwork +materials. Formwork must be braced to ensure +stability, especially under windy conditions. Try +to avoid areas where work such as hoisting or +stripping is being done overhead. + +• Fall injuries – All of the injuries above, and many +others, can result from falls. Most falls are caused +by missing or inadequate guardrails, failure to use +fall-arrest equipment, failure to completely plank +scaffolds and other work platforms, and standing +or climbing on surfaces not meant to be used as +such – the tops of wall forms or 2 x 4 wales, for +example. Installing and stripping formwork often +requires the use of a fall-arrest system. + +• Falls also result from holes left unguarded or + +uncovered in formwork. These should be covered +up or fitted with guardrails as quickly as possible. +Where this cannot be done, the area should +be roped off and posted with warning signs to +prevent unauthorized entry. + +Planning + +Planning is the first and most important step in +reducing hazards and preventing injuries. + +Because formwork operations must often be +carried out in congested areas where other trades +are also working, planning is essential in making the +most of the time and space available to improve +safety and efficiency. + +Planning is a must for fall protection, work +platforms, material staging areas, housekeeping, +and material handling and movement. + +Planning should take place at every level from +manager to supervisor to worker. Planning labour, +materials, equipment, and work schedules to +meet design requirements is the responsibility of +management and supervision. But supervisors and +workers should come together to plan the details +of their assigned tasks based on the most effective +work methods and safety measures. + +For example, the normal weight of liquid concrete +is 150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre). +So a form designed to withstand 600 lb per square +feet (2929 kg per square metre) of pressure will be +able to support liquid concrete up to a height of 4 +feet (1.2 metres). + +600 lb/ft2 ÷ 150 lb/ft3 = 4 ft + +2929 kg/m2 ÷ 2403 kg/m3 = 1.2 m + +Other factors determine how long concrete +will remain liquid, such as temperature, slump, +vibration, and admixtures. For example, concrete +will set much more quickly in hot summer weather +than in cold winter weather. As a result, the same +form filled at the same pour rate may be subjected +to greater pressure in winter than in summer. + +Concrete pumping may cause additional pressure, +as well as vibration, on forms and must be +considered at the design stage. The action of the +pump sends surges of pressure through the piping +system which are often transmitted directly to +the forms, especially for narrow walls or columns. +Vibration may move the forms or loosen bracing, +ties, or spreaders. + +Pressure acts perpendicular to formwork surfaces +(Figure 42-2). This causes an outward thrust for +typical wall or column forms. However, it can also +cause uplift for battered or sloping forms. These +require hold-down anchors or tie-down braces. The +anchors will prevent the forms from lifting up or +floating on the concrete. + +Expansion Anchors Holding +Down Battered Form + +Design + +Safety and economy are the main factors in design. +Both have to be considered because adjustments in +one affect the other. + +For example, reducing the support structure for +wall forms in expectation of reduced pouring rates +should not be considered if the rate of pour is not +going to be controlled on the job. + +Fresh concrete exerts a pressure on formwork +similar to liquids. Concrete starts to set when +poured. So if the pour rate is slow, the maximum +formwork design pressure can be reduced, since +concrete at the bottom will be set before concrete +at the top is poured. Similarly, if the forms are +filled to the top immediately, they must be able to +withstand the pressure of the full liquid head. + +Figure 42-2: Pressure of Concrete on +Vertical (left) and Battered Formwork + +Consider using bracing systems and spreaders for +wall forms. Concrete filling the bottom of the form +may cause forces at the top to push the two sides +together unless they are properly braced and/ +or separated with spreaders. Formwork has to be +designed to resist such forces. During pouring, +ensure that spreaders are not removed until concrete +has reached at least two-thirds of the form height. + +Where box forms are used—for instance, on one- +piece covers for open-cut tunnels—you must use +bracing against the side thrusts caused by the +uneven pouring rates of the walls. Resisting these +forces requires that the system be tied together +and securely braced (Figure 42-3). + +Tools and Techniques + +42-3 + + FORMWORK + +Figure 42-3: Open-Cut Tunnel Formwork with +Bracing and Spreaders on Each Side + +Formwork should be designed and constructed +with stripping and removing as well as pouring in +mind. On wooden forms, crush plates or filler strips +should be used at corners such as slab-and-column +or slab-and-wall intersections (Figure 42-4). The +plates or strips are easily removed with a wrecking +bar and, once removed, make the stripping of +adjacent panels much easier. + +Crush Plates + +Figure 42-5: Formwork Panel + +A formwork panel or wall form to be lifted as a +single unit must be designed to withstand the +loads and forces exerted by hoisting (Figure +42-6). In most cases, this means designing a more +substantial structure. Fastening components may +also need more attention at the design stage. For +example, simple nailing may not be enough to hold +plywood sheets. + +Figure 42-4: Crush Plates + +The strips should be big enough to leave space at +the edges of the panels to accommodate wrecking +bars. + +When formwork has to be manhandled during +assembly or dismantling, the design should ensure +that the components are manageable. Formwork +panels are not only heavy but awkward (Figure +42-5). Realistic design demands consideration of +the size as well as the weight of panels. + +Figure 42-6: Formwork Lifted as Single Unit + +Special attention must also be applied to the design, +construction, and use of pick points for hoisting. The +strongbacks and wales must be securely attached +to the formwork. The pick points must be located +so that the panel hangs properly during installation, +concrete placement, and removal. + +42-4 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +Types of Formwork + +Below Grade + +The first concern with formwork below grade is +the stability of the excavation walls. Walls must be +either shored or sloped according to soil type as +defined by section 226 of the Construction Projects +regulation (O.Reg. 213/91). Figure 42-7 shows +typical slopes. + +Good Soil + +Fairly +Good Soil + +Max 1.2m + +(4 ft.) + +Type 1 & 2 Soil + +Type 3 Soil + +Poor Soil + +Type 4 Soil + +Figure 42-7: Excavation Slopes for Soil Types + +In most cases the shoring must be designed by an +engineer. Engineers may also specify slopes for +excavations. In both instances the design drawings +must be kept on the project. + +Excavations should be kept essentially dry. Water +should be pumped out. Mud should be cleared off +and replaced by compacted granular material in +work areas and on surfaces where concrete will be +placed. Mud presents slipping hazards and can lead +to inferior construction if not removed or replaced. + +Since mud has to be removed before concrete +is placed, it might as well be removed before +formwork is constructed, thereby reducing slipping +hazards at both stages. + +Water and mud also contribute to electrical +hazards. Grounding and insulation must be +effective and intact. Ground fault circuit +interrupters (GFCIs) are required by law on all +portable tools used outdoors or in wet locations. + +Formwork for footings and grade walls frequently +begins before excavation in the area is complete. +Trucks and excavating equipment put workers on +foot at the risk of being struck down or run over. + +Wherever possible, formwork operations should +be roped off from other work such as excavation +or pile-driving (Figure 42-8). Separate access +ramps for vehicles and workers are strongly +recommended. Stairs are an even better alternative +for personnel on foot. + +Figure 42-8: Formwork Roped-Off +from Other Operations + +Mud sills must be used to support any shoring or +bracing that rests on soil in the excavation (Figure +42-9). The sill must bear on the soil throughout its +length. Sills should not be used to bridge holes or +irregular surfaces. To ensure uniform bearing, soil +should be levelled before sills are set in position. + +Figure 42-9: Mud Sills Under Shoring Frames + +The soil must have the capacity to bear whatever +loads are applied (Table 42-1). This information +may or may not be on the design drawings. + +Table 42-1: In Situ Bearing +Pressure for Dry Soil Conditions +(Conservative Estimates) + + Silt and clay + Sands + Gravelly sands + Gravel + +1,200 lb/ft2 (5,859 kg/m2) +4,000 lb/ft2 (19,530 kg/m2) +6,000 lb/ft2 (29,295 kg/m2) +8,000 lb/ft2 (39,059 kg/m2) + +Tools and Techniques + +42-5 + + FORMWORK + +Soil that supports bracing or shoring should +be compacted and qualify as good soil at least +(cohesive, hard, with no water). Professional advice +from a geotechnical engineer may be required +for heavy structures such as elevated equipment +supports shored at or below grade. + +Formwork in these situations is frequently built in +place. Planning is required to store material and +equipment out of the way, dispose of scrap and +debris, and ensure safe, efficient access (Figure +42-10). Because conditions are often cramped and +scrap accumulates quickly, it is important to clean +up as work proceeds. + +Starting the Form + +Setting up the first form is always hard, heavy, +manual work. It requires enough workers to do +the job without overexertion or injury. Whenever +possible, use mechanical assistance such as a boom, +truck, or crane for this operation. It will reduce the +risk of injury to workers and increase productivity. + +Temporary bracing (Figure 42-12) is needed from the +start and at every step to prevent wind loads from +toppling the forms—historically the cause of many +serious injuries. A wind speed as low as 30 km/h can +create a dangerous wind load on formwork. + +Figure 42-10: Well-Planned Storage, +Access, and Setup + +Wall Forms + +Wall forms built in place are hazardous to +construct. Hazards include + +• Dowels sticking up from concrete slabs or + +footings + +• Unstable work surfaces and access created by + +poor planning + +• Manual handling of heavy material such as + +plywood sheets, panels, wales, and buckets of +snap-ties, wedges, and plates + +• Slippery surfaces at and below grade + +• Inadequate design + +• Improper construction. + +The best protection against dowels is a wood +cover built of lumber at least 1 1/2 inches thick and +wired in place or protective caps placed over the +exposed ends of rebar (Figure 42-11). + +Figure 42-12: Temporary Bracing at +Start of Form Construction + +Access to wall forms is not always given enough +thought. Forms more than 2 metres high will +require access platforms for workers involved in +concrete placing. The platforms can also be used +to complete the upper portion of the formwork. + +An alternative is a frame scaffold, which can also +be used to install reinforcing steel (Figure 42-13). + +Figure 42-11: Protective Covers +Over Dowels and Rebar + +42-6 + +Figure 42-13: Scaffolding for Access + +Construction Health and Safety Manual Fall arrest systems or scaffolds with guardrails +must be used where workers may fall more than +3 m (10 ft), or onto hazards such as projecting +dowels (Figure 42-14). In some circumstances, you +must use fall protection when the height is 2.4 m +(8 ft) or more. (See chapters on Guardrails and +Personal Fall Protection.) + +FORMWORK + +Figure 42-15: Formwork Properly Tied and Braced + +Recommended design pressures for various pour +rates and environmental conditions are set out +in CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework and Formwork. +The standard defines a number of other design +considerations and should be consulted by field staff. + +Slab Forms or Falsework Built in Place + +With slab forms built in place the major hazard is +falls. Injuries are also connected with the manual +handling of heavy materials and components. + +Forms built in place usually have to be taken +down in place after the concrete has hardened +sufficiently. This should be considered at the +construction stage. Stability may also be a +consideration where the structure is high, carries +heavy loads, and is placed on grade as in bridge +and overpass construction. + +Fall protection is difficult to provide for workers +building slab forms in place. That’s why planning is +essential in the design and erection procedure. + +Workers should wear a safety harness with the +lanyard tied off to the structure of the formwork +(Figure 42-16). This means tying off to the support +structure where shoring frame structures are being +constructed, tying off to a lifeline when placing +plywood panels at a leading edge, constructing +a guardrail at the edge of the formwork, or tying +off to the support structure when connecting it +together with tube and clamp. Don’t wait for the +structure to be completed before tying-off. + +Figure 42-14: Workers Wear Fall Arrest While +Attaching Wales to Threaded Rods + +Materials should be distributed along the work +location to minimize further handling. But traffic +and work areas must be kept clear for the safe +movement and installation of material. + +Form Construction + +Wall forms must be constructed as designed. +The design must indicate clearly what is required. +Some wall forms are designed for specific concrete +placement rates expressed in metres of height per +hour (m/hr). A wall form in which concrete is +placed to a height of one metre in one hour would +have a placement rate of 1 m/hr. Slower pouring +rates result in lower formwork pressure because +the bottom concrete has started to set. + +Note: Using a concrete vibrator will increase the +liquid (hydraulic) pressure on the form in the +immediate area of the vibration. Over-vibrating the +concrete while increasing the pour rate can cause +the formwork to fail. + +Ensure that ties and braces are installed where +indicated on design drawings. Ties should be +snugged up. Braces should be securely fastened to +forms and wedged or fastened to a support that +will not settle or deform under load (Figure 42-15). + +Formwork platforms must be: + +• Capable of bearing at least 50 lb/ft2 + +• Adequately supported + +• Equipped with guardrails + +• Secured at the level or levels where work such as + +pouring and stripping will be done. + +Figure 42-16: Workers Tie Off to +Shoring Frames While Placing Stringers + +Tools and Techniques + +42-7 + + FORMWORK + +Make sure you have fall protection at all stages of +formwork construction. Wherever possible, cranes or +other equipment should be used to move material, +thereby reducing the amount of manual carrying, +lifting, and handling. + +Shoring towers require special consideration. + +• Towers must remain stable during construction +and dismantling. Guys or other bracing and +supports may be necessary to maintain stability +(Figure 42-17). + +• If towers are to be tied together and braced +horizontally, this should be done as work +progresses (Figure 42-18). + +• Shoring towers and shores should be installed so + +they are plumb to within 1/8 inch in 3 feet. + +• Shoring towers should be snugged up under the + +stringers with adjustable base plates and U-heads +(Figure 42-19). + +• If frames do not ride tightly on top of one + +another after tightening, one or more are out of +square and should be replaced (Figure 42-20). + +• With single-post shores, provide adequate lateral +bracing (Figure 42-21). Stairwells and balconies +are places where horizontal bracing for single- +post shoring systems may be required. + +Figure 42-19: Typical Shoring Tower with +Stringers, Adjustable Base Plates, and U-Heads + +Replace this frame. + +Figure 42-17: High Towers with Guys for Support + +Figure 42-20: Frame Bent Out of Shape + +Figure 42-18: Towers Tied +Together and Braced Horizontally + +Figure 42-21: Single-Post +Shores with Lateral Bracing + +42-8 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +Using forms designed for typical floors in non- +typical situations has resulted in serious accidents. +Before using any flying form under non-typical +conditions, consult the designer or manufacturer. +Wall forms should not be extended in height or +width, for instance, or slab panels cantilevered +without the review and approval of a professional +engineer. Such situations usually occur with +penthouses or mechanical rooms where wall and +ceiling heights are greater than for typical floors. + +Other hazards with flying forms include the +following. + +• Stability during initial fabrication + +• Fill-in work between slab panels + +• Wind and fall hazards during flying operations + +• Stripping, flying, and re-setting. + +Although a flying form is designed to be stable +when complete, it may not be stable during +fabrication or erection. Temporary bracing or +temporary support by a crane may be necessary +to ensure stability during certain phases of the +operation (Figure 42-24). + +Figure 42-22: Two Rows of Shoring Frames with +Row of Shoring Posts in Centre + +Frequently, supports for built-in-place forms are +deliberately left out to allow other work to be +done. One example might be a row of single-post +shores left out until work below is complete. Or, +an area might be supported temporarily during +construction by a few single-post shores that will +be replaced later by a shoring tower. + +In these and other instances of incomplete +formwork, heavy temporary loads such as bundles +of rebar or stacks of plywood should not be placed +on the structure. Even on completed formwork, +make sure that landed material will not overload +the structure. + +Before placing concrete, the formwork must be +inspected and approved by a professional engineer +or their designate. Keep a copy of this inspection +and approval on the site in case an inspector asks +to see it. + +Flying Forms + +Flying forms must always be designed by a +professional engineer and constructed, hoisted, +moved, and set strictly according to the +instructions of the designer or manufacturer. + +Figure 42-24: Temporary Support of Shoring +System for Flying Wall Form + +One example is setting up trusses for a flying slab +formwork table. The trusses must be held upright +to be connected or disconnected. If not adequately +supported, they can fall over on workers. + +Trusses and wall panels have also been blown over +by wind during fabrication and dismantling. Set- +up procedures should indicate the maximum wind +speed where the flying form operation can be done +safely. This wind speed should be determined by the +professional engineer who designed the system. + +Work with flying forms requires adequate space +for stacking materials and components. Working in +cramped quarters is not only difficult but hazardous. + +Figure 42-23: Flying Forms + +Tools and Techniques + +42-9 + + FORMWORK + +Fall Protection + +A fall arrest system should be used by any worker +who is at risk of falling when: + +• Installing a panel + +• Pushing a panel out toward the slab edge + +• Pulling a panel in from the slab edge (Figure + +42-24) + +• Helping other workers attach rigging hardware + +such as slings + +• Getting on and off + +• Bolting and unbolting wall forms for exterior walls + +and elevator shafts (Figure 42-25) + +• Stepping onto a panel to attach slings to pick + +points + +Figure 42-24: Fall Protection Required when +Receiving a Flying Form + +Figure 42-25: Attaching Chain Sling to Wall Form + +Each worker’s fall-arrest system must be attached +to an individual anchor independent of the flying +form. Contractors can provide for anchorage by +casting rebar anchors in columns or other areas to +be covered over or filled in later (Figure 42-26). +This type of anchorage must be approved by a +professional engineer. + +Figure 42-26: Rebar Anchor Cast in Concrete + +Safety Below Flying Forms + +The previous section covered the safety of workers +flying the forms. But precautions must also be +taken to protect workers below the hoisting +operation and the public at large, since forms are +often swung out over sidewalks and streets. The +Construction Projects regulation (213/91, s. 103(2)) +prohibits hoisting a load over the head of a person +who is not receiving the load or sinking a shaft. + +The most efficient protection for workers is to +fence or rope off the area below the flying form to +prevent anyone from entering the area. Pedestrian +traffic on sidewalks, as well as vehicle traffic if +necessary, should be detoured around the area +while hoisting is under way. + +Communication + +Flying forms are heavy, large, and awkward to +move. Hoisting and moving them safely requires +clear reliable communication. While hand signals +are often necessary and are still used, direct +radio or cell phone communication between the +signaller and the crane operator is more accurate +and effective. Relying on hand signals alone is not +recommended. + +Stripping + +Formwork stripping is probably the most +hazardous operation in concrete construction. +Hazards include the following. + +• Falling material + +• Waste material and equipment underfoot + +• Manual handling of heavy or awkward forms, + +panels, and other components + +• Prying forms loose from concrete presents risk of + +overexertion, lost balance, and slips and falls. + +42-10 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual Hazards can be reduced by + +• Planning and providing for stripping when + +designing and constructing formwork + +• Stripping as soon as it is permitted by the + +engineer + +• Supplying facilities and equipment for removing + +materials as they are stripped + +• Providing proper tools and adequate access for + +the stripping crew + +• Training personnel properly for this and other + +aspects of formwork. + +Forms can be designed with crush plates or filler +strips to facilitate removal at difficult intersections +of columns, beams, and wall forms. Later, formwork +oils should be used liberally to make stripping +easier. + +Wherever possible, waste materials, plywood, and +debris should be removed from the area as work +proceeds. This will reduce the need to walk over or +work around things left on floor or ground. + +Providing carts or cradles can help the crew +remove material and reduce the need for lifting +and carrying. Material on a cart can be rolled away. +Material in cradles can be hoisted off by a crane. + +Climbing partially stripped formwork is not +only hazardous but unnecessary. Safe access +such as rolling scaffolds or powered elevating +work platforms should be provided for stripping +formwork at elevated locations. + +Poor lighting may be a hazard in formwork +stripping in the early morning or late in the day +during certain times of the year. Mobile light +stands are probably the best solution, since pigtail +stringers can easily be knocked down and damaged +during stripping. + +Wherever possible, stripping crews should be +small. This is especially important with knock-down +systems. In small crews, the supervisor and each +worker can more easily keep track of what the +others are doing. Workers are not as likely to create +hazards for each other. Crews of two or three are +recommended for knock-down systems. If more +workers are required, they can still be divided into +small crews working in separate areas. + +Other trades and operations should not be allowed +in areas where stripping is under way. Given the +many hazards involved, the area should be fenced +or roped off and warning signs posted. + +Knock-Down Slab Systems + +Stripping these forms is physically difficult +because much of the work is overhead. The +usual arrangement involves shoring frames or a +combination of shoring frames and jacks. + +Wherever possible, the work should proceed +progressively from one side. That means taking out +one row of formwork supported by a row of stringers +on shoring frames. + +FORMWORK + +The first step is to back off the adjustable base plates +and U-heads in one area, which will in turn lower the +stringers, joists, and plywood (Figure 42-27). + +Figure 42-27: Lowering Base Plates +and U-Heads to Release Slab Form + +In practice, however, the plywood will stick to +the underside of the concrete, especially around +beams, column caps, and similar points. Wherever +possible, stuck sheets should be loosened and +removed before the shoring structure is dismantled. + +Stripping should proceed in reverse order to +erection. Plywood should be removed first, +followed by joists and stringers. The last items to +be removed are the shoring frames. + +When scaffold or shoring frames are used as a +work platform, it should be completely decked +in with planks (Figure 42-28). Otherwise planks +can shift and slide as workers pry or pull at stuck +pieces of formwork, lose their balance, and fall. This +has been a frequent cause of injuries. Temporary +guardrails may be required near the edge of the +structure or workers will need to use fall protection +during this operation. + +Figure 42-28: Shoring Frame +Fully Planked for Access + +Tools and Techniques + +42-11 + + FORMWORK + +The area where stripping starts should be planned +to allow access for taking away material as the +form is dismantled. + +Columns + +Check the following: + +Sound training, effective supervision, well- +designed safe access facilities, and immediate and +continuous cleanup can help reduce hazards in +stripping knock-down slab forms. + +Built-in-Place Wall Forms + +These forms are frequently of only moderate height. +Taller types usually make use of large panels erected +and removed by crane rather than hand. Built- +in-place wall forms are usually a stud-and-wale +system using some type of formwork ties. + +Where workers cannot reach the top of the wall, +scaffolding should be provided for removing wales +on the upper level. Safe access is essential for the +dismantling and manhandling of wales that are +frequently long, heavy, and waterlogged. + +Material should then be removed immediately to a +staging area. + +Inspection + +Before concrete placing begins, formwork must be +inspected and signed off by a professional engineer +or a competent person designated by the engineer +to ensure that it has been constructed to provide +for worker safety and to meet job specifications. + +A report must be completed by the person doing +the inspection stating whether the formwork has +been constructed according to the design. Any +discrepancies must be approved by the design +engineer before concrete placing proceeds. + +It is in everyone’s best interest to ensure that the +formwork has been inspected by a competent +person for workmanship, stability, and adherence +to design drawings and specifications. Inspection +should begin when the forms are being constructed +and continue until concrete placing is complete. + +Checking line and grade is best carried out while the +formwork is being constructed. Shoring structures +should be within the alignment limits specified on +the design drawings. Line and grade should also +be checked during the pour to determine whether +formwork is shifting or deflecting. + +Dimensions of special features like beams, column +capitals, and inserts are best checked at the time of +construction. If inspection is delayed until formwork +is completed, some details may be covered up or +become more difficult to check. + +• The proper size and type of materials are used + +• Column ties or column clamps are spaced + +according to design drawings + +• The spacing of ties or clamps is based on a + +sound assessment of concrete pressure (generally +columns are designed for a full liquid head of +150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre) +times height) + +• Columns are adequately braced where they are + +not tied in to a slab-form structure. + +NOTE: For more information on column formwork +pressures, refer to CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework +and Formwork or the American Concrete Institute +(ACI) standard Formwork for Concrete (SP-4). + +Wall Forms + +Check the following: + +• Materials and any manufactured components are as +specified in design drawings (size and spacing of +studs, wales, and ties are crucial to safety) + +• Ties are snugged up before concrete is placed + +• Wedges in wedged systems are tight + +• Nuts in threaded systems are tight + +• Bracing conforms to design drawings + +• Free-standing formwork is braced to ensure stability + +and resistance to loads during concrete placing + +• Specified pour rates are not exceeded (wall + +forms are often designed for specific pour rates; +exceeding these rates can cause failure or collapse). + +Slab Forms + +From a safety perspective, this is the most critical +type of formwork. The collapse of slab forms has +caused many injuries and deaths, whether from +flawed design (e.g., not considering the effect +of wind loading on the design), unauthorized +modifications in the field, or the failure to +inspect, which would have located and corrected +deficiencies. + +Competent inspection demands knowledge, +experience, and the ability to + +1) Distinguish between similar but different + +materials and shoring equipment + +2) Read and interpret design drawings + +3) + +Identify and clear up with the designer any +apparent or real discrepancies in components +such as shoring frames. -Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment: +42-12 -1 +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK -Complete and mail -your Consumer -Product Ownership -Registration today. -Have the peace of -mind of knowing -we can contact you -in the unlikely event of a safety -modification. +Check the following: -2 +Watch for the following warning signs: -After mailing -the registration -below, store this -document in a safe -place. It contains -information you -will need should +• Grade beams or mud sills supporting shoring are -you require service. Our -service number is 800 GE -CARES (800-432-2737). +• Lateral displacement or movement of single-post -3 +properly sized and located. -Read your -Owner’s Manual -carefully. -It will help you -operate your -new appliance -properly. +shoring for slab forms -If you have questions, or need -more information, call the GE -Answer Center® 800.626.2000. +• Hazardous soil conditions such as excessive +moisture, freezing, and uncompacted soil +conditions are reported and discussed with the +professional engineer. -Model Number +• Shoring frames and jacks are located and aligned -Serial Number +within tolerances specified on the drawings. -Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product, +• Shoring frames and jacks are out of plumb no -detach and return the form below to ensure that your -product is registered. +more than 1/8 inch every 3 feet. -" -Consumer Product Ownership Registration +• Adjustable base plates for shoring frames and -Cut here +jacks are snugged up. -Important -Mail -Today! +• U-heads are wedged in place. -First -Name +• Stringers are the specified size and number, with -Street -Address +supports properly spaced. -Apt. # +• Aluminum stringers have no bent flanges or other -City +damage. -Model Number +• Movement or deflection of lateral bracing for -Serial Number +single-post shores -Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108) +• Movement of stringers on U-heads -Last -Name +• Crushing of wooden stringers on U-heads -E-mail Address +(Figure 42-29) -State +• Gaps or shoring that is not snugged up under -Zip -Code +stringers -Date Placed In Use +• Deflection of stringers between supports -Month +(Figure 42-30) -Day +• Deflection of wales or strongbacks on wall forms -Year +• Wall forms that are bulging or cracking -Phone -Number +• Crushing of wales or strongbacks at washers -Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information. -(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information. +for ties -GE Appliances -General Electric Company -Louisville, Kentucky 40225 -www.ge.com/appliances +• Movement of wall forms -38 +• Joists are the specified size and properly spaced. - Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States) +• Uplifting of battered forms -All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers, -or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service, -call 800-GE-CARES. +• Support structures and shoring for beam bottoms +and column capitals are constructed according to +design. -For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You: +• Lateral bracing is provided where required (for +instance, on freestanding formwork for bridges +and overpasses). -One Year -From the date of the -original purchase +• The bearing surface for lateral bracing is +adequate—that is, stable footings or well- +compacted soil. -Five Years -From the date of the -original purchase +• Temporary loads such as rebar are not -Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect -in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year -warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor -and in-home service to replace the defective part. +overloading the system. -Any part of the sealed refrigerating system -(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all -connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in -materials or workmanship. During this additional -four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, -all labor and in-home service to replace the -defective part. +Concrete Placing -What Is Not Covered: +Forms should continue being observed during +concrete placing. Any signs of movement, crushing, +cracking, or deflection are cause for alarm. Placing +concrete should be suspended until the situation is +corrected. -n Service trips to your home to teach you +• Pour rates that exceed design specifications. -how to use the product. +Figure 42-29: Crushing of Stringer Over U-Head -n Improper installation. +Figure 42-30: Deflection +of Stringers Between Supports -n Failure of the product if it is +Tools and Techniques -abused, misused, or used for other -than the intended purpose or used -commercially. - -n Loss of food due to spoilage. - -n Replacement of house fuses or -resetting of circuit breakers. - -n Damage to the product caused by - -accident, fire, floods or acts of God. - -n Incidental or consequential damage to -personal property caused by possible -defects with this appliance. - -This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased -for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to -your home. - -Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This -warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to -state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your -state’s Attorney General. - -Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225 - -39 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -Service Telephone Numbers. - -GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000 - -The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. - -In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737) - -Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away. - -Special Needs Service800.626.2000 -TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322) - -GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier- -free kitchen for persons with limited mobility. - -Service Contracts800-626-2224 - -Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect -and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will -still be there after your warranty expires. - -Parts and Accessories800-626-2002 - -Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts -or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and -Discover cards are accepted). -Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed -by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified -service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing -may cause unsafe operation. - -Service Satisfaction - -If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow -these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance. -Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your -phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances, -Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225. - -40 - -Printed in Louisville, KY +42-13 diff --git a/q15/random_k2/random_2.md b/q15/random_k2/random_2.md index 3f8f519b055815348eb52fd213fd7d32396a7bde..a7cbcf7d4134f4c225b224673f418e279c4db69c 100644 --- a/q15/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q15/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,3490 +1,1314 @@ -Fully Automatic Coffee Machine -OPERATION MANUAL - - Instructions of coffee machine parts - +B160V + +User Guide + + Contents +Safety information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 +Getting to know your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 +Setting up your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 +Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 +Messages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 +Email . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 +Chrome browser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 +Bluetooth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 +Wi-Fi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 +Camera . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 +Photos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 +Calendar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 +Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 +Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 +Clock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 +Google Maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 +Google Play Store . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 +Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 +Troubleshooting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 +Regulatory Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -9 +Safety information -6 +Please carefully read the items bellow: +Use Safely +Do not use the phone in situations where it might cause danger. +Transportation Safety +Please observe all transportation laws and regulations. +Please drive with both hands on the wheel. -7 +DO NOT TEXT AND DRIVE -9 +Hospitals +Please follow limitations. +Please turn off your mobile phone when near medical instruments. +Airports +Remember to follow all airport and flight safety regulations. +Please do not use your phone during flight. -10 +2 -11 + Toxic Chemicals +Do not use your mobile phone around fuels or chemicals. -12 +Hazard +Do not use in hazardous areas where explosions may occur. -13 +Accessories and Batteries +Use only Blu authorized batteries and accessories. -8 +Backup +Remember to keep a written record of all important information. -1 +Water +Your phone is not waterproof. Keep it away from water and liquids. -2 +SOS Emergency Calls +Make sure your mobile phone is switched on and in a service area. In +home screen, tap the phone key and dial 911 and send. 3 -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 +Getting to know your phone -Bean container +Receiver -Water tank +Headset port +Status bar -Coffee grounds container +Front camera -Pre - ground coffee chute +Rear cameras -Grinding wheel +Volume keys -Coffee spout +Power key -Handle +Flash -8 +Back +Home -9 +Recent Apps -10 +USB port -11 +4 -12 + Power +key -13 +• Press to turn the screen on or off. +• Press and hold to turn the phone on. +• Press along with the Volume up key to turn the phone off. +• Press along with the Volume down key to take a -Waste water container +screenshot. -Milk pipe +Volume +keys -Milk frother +Adjust the volume for ringtones, media, notifications, and +system sounds. -Hot water spout +Home -Milk and foam spout +The home button pauses any current action and returns to +the home screen. -Power cord +Recent +Apps - Coffee machine operation interface instructions +Open a list of recently opened applications that allows you +to switch conveniently between them. This option can also +close any open applications by swiping to the side. -5 +Back -1 +Return to the previous screen; Closes the keyboard, any +open program, or any menu option. -2 +USB port -3 +Charge the device and transfers data such as documents, +music, and video between your device and a PC. -4 +Headset +port -6 +Connect earphones to this port for hands-free capabilities. +You may also to listen to music or FM radio. -7 +Status +bar -8 +Provide phone and service status information on the right +side and notification alerts on the left. -9 +Front +Camera -10 +A high-resolution front camera to take pictures and video. +This option is ideal for self-portraits. -1 +Rear +Cameras -2 +Flash -3 +A high-resolution rear camera to take pictures and video. -4 +Provide light for pictures in low-light conditions. It also +may be used as a flashlight. 5 -Espresso icon - -Long coffee icon - -Hot water icon - -Power switch - -Display - 6 -7 - -8 - -9 - -Cappuccino icon - -Coffee Latte icon - -Hot milk/foam icon - -Cleaning button - -10 - -Rotary button - - Safety Instructions - -Please see specification label on the bottom of the coffee machine or -technical date indicated in the instruction manual(P20). - -IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS - -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should always be followed, -including the following: -1. Read all Instructions. -2. Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -3. To protect against fire, electric shock and injury to persons do not immerse cord, -plugs, or (state specific part or parts in question) in water or other liquid. -4. Unplug from outlet when not in use and before cleaning. Allow to cool before -putting on or taking off parts, and before cleaning the appliance. -5.Avoid contacting moving parts. -6. Do not operate any appliance with a damaged cord or plug or if the appliance -malfunctions, or has been damaged in any manner. Return the appliance to the near -est authorized service facility for examination, repair or adjustment. -7. The use of accessory attachments not recommended by the appliance manufac -turer may result in fire, electric shock or injury to persons. -8. Do not use outdoors . -9. Do not let the cord hang over edge of table or counter, or touch hot surfaces. -10. Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a heated oven. -11. Always plug cord into the wall outlet first,then turn controls to -turn any control to”off“, -12. Do not use appliance for other than intended use. -13. Check bean hopper for presence of foreign objects before using the brewer . -14. Unplug power cord from outlet before cleaning brewer exterior. Allow to cool -before disassembling and cleaning the coffee machine. -15. When dispensing drinks high temperature liquid will flow from coffee spout and hot -water spout. Do not touch hot liquids to avoid scalding -16. When using cappuccino, coffee latte, hot milk/foam, please confirm that the milk -pipe has been connected from the milk frother to milk before making cappuccino, -coffee latte, and hot milk/cream. Otherwise, high temperature steam may cause -personal injury. -17. Never connect to voltage different than the electric specification of the machine; -Brewer damage will occur. -18. Only potable water at room temperature should be used in the water tank. -Never put warm water, hot water, milk or other liquid into the tank. - -then remove plug from wall outlet. - -To disconnect, - -"on". - -01 - - Safety Instructions - -19. Never carry or move the coffee machine while power is on. -20. The machine will release heat and some steam. Therefore, when placing the -machine on a workbench, at least 3cm must be left between its surfaces, sides and -rear; at least15cm must be left above its top. -As for dimension of the machine, please look up the Technical Data in the User -Manual(Page 20). -21. Never use harsh or abrasive cleaner to wipe the machine, it may cause -corrosion of the coffee machine, and result in a risk of electric shock. -22. Never use hard edged tool or rough rag to clean the stain on the machine, it will -damage the surfaces. -23. Never fill specially treated coffee beans (e.g. cocoa, sugar coated) into the -beancontainer, it will cause the coffee machine damage . -24. Only roasted coffee bean are approved to place into the bean container. Rice, -soybean, chocolate bean, nut, sugar, spice etc are prohibited. Otherwise it would -cause the coffee machine to be damaged. -25. Never wash the bean container or pre-ground coffee chute with water, it will -damage the machine. -26. Never use the coffee machine in the environment temperature below 0 °C. -Water inside the machine will freeze and cause the coffee machine damaged. -27. Never expose the machine in rainy, snowy, frosty environment. It would cause -the coffee machine to be damaged. -28. Save these Instructions. - -POWER CORD EXTENSION USE - -Please don’t use power cord extensions. - -02 - -- - -- - - Proper operation - -the - -sure - -taste, - -make - -that the - -guarantee - -To -coffee -into the water tank is at room temperature. -used -can -The coffee -We -intended -it -use -of -read -this manual, so that you can understand operation of the coffee machine -sufficiently. - -preparing -not be responsible -contents - -machine -other -use. - -be -use. -carefully - -any -for -improper - -hot -for the - -temperature - -for -will - -coffee - -Please - -only - -and - -the - -the - -all - -of - -of - -water - -poured - -water. -Do -consequences - -not - -Please keep this manual in an appropriate place to -Safety Tips - -be accessed - -at any time. - -if - -is - -(if - -or - -the - -the - -the - -the - -smell - -power - -power - -coffee - -coffee - -unplug - -burning - -operate - -machine - -machine - -appliance - -or -an authorized - -any -contact + Setting up your phone -machine -and +Charge the battery +1. Connect one end of the data cable to the USB port located on the -the -of -immediately +Install a Nano SIM/microSD card -a breakdown -cord -power +bottom of your phone. -encountering -the +Note: Please contact your cellular phone service provider directly to +obtain your SIM card if your card is not preinstalled. +1. Insert the included SIM tray pin into -cord of the -service center. +the tray slot and remove the SIM tray. +2. Place the Nano SIM card and microSD -Please notice the following tips to avoid personal injury from electric shock. -cord +microSD -Do -not -damaged. -When -smoke), -service center. -If -authorized -Place the coffee machine and the power cord far away from heat sources. -Please don't contact the power cord with sharp tools.Do -coffee -it -operate -mentioned in this manual, to avoid personal injury. -Place the coffee machine out of the reach of children. -periods, -is -When the -cord and put it away, so that not to trip up people or damage to the power -cord. -Please -be damaged. +Nano SIM -not -way that is not +card (not included) with metal +contacts facing down into the tray. +3. Gently slide the SIM tray back into -authorization +SIM tray -contact an +Pin -damaged, +the slot. -otherwise, +Warning: Please keep the SIM card out of the reach of children. +The SIM card and its contact are easily damaged due to scratching or +bending. Please use caution when carrying, installing, or taking out the +SIM card. -unoriginal +2. Connect the other end to the power adapter. +3. Connect the power adapter to an electrical outlet to fully charge your -machine +phone. -machine +Power On and Off +Long press the Power key to switch on the phone. +To turn off the phone, press the Power key and the +Volume up key at the same time, and tap Power Off on +the screen that displayed. -without - -unused - -Coffee - -unplug - -please - -power - -cause - -repair - -parts, - -the machine to - -don't - -may - -long - -the - -any - -use - -the - -for - -or - -in - -is - -it - -03 - -Instructions for use - -Reading this manual will help you familiarize yourself with the coffee -machine, and enable you to use -“Instruction -coffee -“Failures handling" will provide information when encountering problems. - -the -use - machine step-by-step, for first-time use. - -it properly. -introduces - -operation - -first-time - -process - -for - -of - -" - -the - -Coffee machine model - -This +Power +key -Manual +7 -is +8 -only + Phone +Make a call -applicable +1. To make a call, tap Phone +2. Tap Dialer -to the + from the Home screen. -1601pro series coffee machine. + to access the keypad, or select one of the following: -Symbol description +• Choose frequently called or favorite contacts in Favorites. -Non-compliance -and threat to life. +• Choose recently called numbers and contacts in Recents. -with +• Choose a saved contact in Contacts. -proper +3. Tap +4. During a call, you can tap -operation, + to make a call. -may +up. -cause + at the bottom of the screen to hang -electric +Enable Wi-Fi call -shock, +You can make a voice call with Wi-Fi Calling. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Network & internet > Wi-Fi Calling. Slide the switch to the -Non-compliance -damage, or personal injury. +. -with +On + position to enable it. You must have an active Wi-Fi +connection and have Wi-Fi calling service activated before it can be +used. -proper +Call history -operation +Every telephone number called and received will be saved in the history. +1. From the Home screen, tap Phone +2. Tap Recents on the bottom bar to display the call history. +You can tap a contact in the call history to display more options. -may +. -cause +Call settings -Coffee +1. From the Home screen, tap Phone +2. Tap Options > Settings to configure your phone settings. -machine +. -Non-compliance +9 -with +10 -proper + Contacts -operation, +Add a contact -may +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Contacts -cause +. +2. Tap +3. Use the keyboard to enter contact information, such as picture, -scalding + to add a contact. -or +name, telephone number, group, address, email, etc. -burn +4. When you are finished, tap Save. -injury.This symbol, if prompted, please carefully read it. +Edit a contact -This symbol, if prompted, represents recyclable. +To edit a contact, tap the contact from the Contacts screen to view its +details, and tap - 01 +. -03 +Messages -03 -03 +Send a text or multimedia message +1. From the Home screen, tap Messaging +2. Tap Start chat to create a new text or multimedia message, or start -03 +. -05 +a new group chat. -05 +3. Enter the recipient(s) name from your Contacts list or phone number -05 +in the To field. -05 + to send the text message. -05 +4. Type your message and tap +5. Or tap -06 + to the left side of the text box to add location, contacts, -06 +or files. Tap +recordings. When done, tap -07 -07 -08 - 09 + to attach photos or videos. Tap -Catalogue + to send sound + to send the multimedia message. -Safety Instructions +Message settings +From Message screen, tap + on the top right corner of the Messages +screen and tap Messages Settings to adjust your messages settings. -Proper operation +11 -Instructions for use +12 -Coffee machine model -Symbol description + Email -Instructions for first time use +Email setup (Gmail, Yahoo!, etc.) -Power connection +From the Home screen, tap Gmail +your account. -Fill water tank +, and follow the steps to set up -Fill beans +Create and send an email message +1. Tap Compose from the Inbox screen to compose a new message. +2. Enter the recipient(s) email address in the To field. To add a carbon copy -Grinding wheel +or blind carbon copy, tap -Power on +. -Power off +3. Enter the subject and content of your message. To add attachments, tap -Making beverages + and select Attach file. -Preparing coffee by touch icon +4. Tap -Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle. + to send. -Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee +Email settings +From Email screen, tap Menu +settings. -Program setting + > Settings to configure your Email -Beverage +Chrome browser +From the Home screen, tap Chrome +for information, and bookmark your favorite web pages for convenient +access. -setting + to browse the Internet, search -Setting beverage parameters and range +Browsing web pages +From the Chrome browser screen, tap the address field and enter a web +address or a keyword to browse for web pages. -Temperature setting +Adding a bookmark +Open the web page you want to bookmark and tap Menu > -Eco-settings +. -Automatic power-down +Opening a bookmark +From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Bookmarks, select +the bookmark of the website you want to view. -Factory Reset +Browser settings +From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Settings to customize +the browser. -Information Statics +13 -Language +14 -Exit + Bluetooth -Cleaning and maintenance +Wi-Fi -Cleaning the coffee machine before operation +Bluetooth is a short-range wireless communications technology that +devices can use to exchange information and connect to different types +of devices which include headsets and other devices. -Cleaning brewing unit +Enable Bluetooth -Rinsing milk unit +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Connected devices > Connection preferences > -Descaling the coffee machine +. -Cleaning coffee +Bluetooth. -grounds +3. Slide the Bluetooth switch to the On -container and drip tray + position. -Cleaning water tank +Pair Bluetooth devices -Cleaning bean hopper +1. From the Connected devices screen, tap Pair new device. +2. Tap a device under Available devices and follow the on-screen -Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother +instructions to pair with the device. -Installing milk pipe +3. When the device is connected to your phone, You can then use the +headset or car kit to listen to music or make and receive phone calls. -Cleaning milk pipe +To use your phone’s Wi-Fi, you need access to a wireless access point or +hotspot. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Network & internet > Internet > Wi-Fi. +3. Slide the Wi-Fi switch to the On +4. Tap a Wi-Fi network to connect, enter the password (if applicable), -Cleaning coffee machine + position to enable Wi-Fi. -Failures handling +. -Display information +and then tap CONNECT . -Transport and recycle +5. Your phone will be connected to the Wi-Fi network. You will see -Technical data +in the status bar. -04 +You can drag down the status bar twice to access Quick Settings panel +to enable or disable Bluetooth and Wi-Fi quickly and easily. -9 -10 +15 -10 +16 -10 + Camera -11 +Photos -11 +Take a photo +1. From the Home screen, tap Camera +2. Tap Photo to switch to Photo mode. +3. Aim the camera at your subject and tap -11 + to take the photo. -11 +. -11 +Record a video +1. From the Camera screen, tap Video to switch to Video mode. +2. Tap +3. Tap -11 + to start recording a video. + again to stop recording and save your video. -12 -12 +Camera settings +From the Camera screen, tap Settings -12 + to adjust camera settings. -13 +You can view photos and watch videos that you’ve taken, downloaded, +or copied onto your storage card or phone memory. -14 +Edit photos +1. From the Home screen, tap Photos +2. Tap the picture you want to edit. +3. Tap +save. -16 +. -17 + to access the Edit screen. When finished, tap Save copy to -17 +Share pictures and videos +1. Select the photos or videos you want to share. +2. Tap -17 +, select a sharing method, and follow the on-screen prompts -17 +to send the photos or videos. 17 18 -18 - -19 - -20 - -20 - - Instructions for first-time use - -This chapter will help you understand the basic operations and settings for your -first time use - -Power connection - -● - -● - -● - -● - -coffee - -machine - -Place the coffee machine on a stable workbench that is not -close to water. -Keep -the -heat sources. -Be sure to use the power supply that is in accordance with -specification label. -Put -at -power -tripping over the cord. + Calendar -avoid people +Calculator +Calculator -temperature +Use the Calendar to create and manage events, meetings, and +appointments. -suitable +Add an event -place +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calendar -away - -cord - -from - -high - -the - -far - -to - -a - -Fill water tank - -● - -● - -● - -temperature +. +2. Tap Add +3. Enter event details, and then tap Save. -milk). + to add an event. -room +Calendar settings -water, +1. From the Calendar screen, tap Menu +2. Tap an option to adjust Calendar settings. -at -tank, + > Settings. -water -water +Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic +Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic +mathematical equations. +mathematical equations. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator -fill -will -taste +. . -never -It -the -at 25℃ - -potable -in the -water,hot -In - -to ensure -order -water -to -use -a -create - -Only -poured -warm -machine. -recommended -water -will -taste. -To -change the water in the tank every day. -The -in -height of the MAX mark. - -the water - -a healthy +2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then +2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then -amount +enter the second number. +enter the second number. -ensure +3. Tap +3. Tap -water + to view the result, tap + to view the result, tap -good + to clear the results. + to clear the results. -tasty +View calculator history +View calculator history -tank +From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on +From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on +the history bar +the history bar +To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the +To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the +. +calculator, drag the history bar +. +calculator, drag the history bar -and + back up or tap the Back button + back up or tap the Back button -not + to view the calculator history. + to view the calculator history. -the +19 -of +20 -to be + Clock -is -other +Google Maps -allowed -liquid +The Clock app allows you to set alarms, view different world times, use +a stopwatch, set a timer, manage your bedtime, and use your phone as +a desk clock. -any -coffee -damage the -it -is -coffee, -temperature +Use the Google Maps app to determine your location, get directions, +browse local businesses and attractions, rate and review places, and +more. -of -Low +Set the date and time manually -(e.g. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Clock +2. Tap Menu > Settings > Change date & time > Set time +automatically > Off, and set the date and time manually. -coffee drink, +. -please +Create a new alarm -cannot +1. From the Clock screen, tap Alarm +2. Set the time for the alarm and tap OK. -exceed + > -the +. -Fill beans +Search for destinations +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Maps +2. Tap Search here. +3. Enter an address, city, facility name, etc., and then choose a search -05 +. -● +result. You will see your location on the map. -● +Find a route to your destination +Tap Go +, enter your desired start location and destination, and tap a +method of transportation (car, public transit, or on foot) for the detailed +directions to your destination. -● +21 -● +22 -● + Google Play Store -put +Access Google Play -Never -treated (e.g. sugar, cocoa) into the bean hopper. +1. From the Home screen, tap Play Store +2. Enter your existing GoogleTM Account login or create one by following -coffee +. -beans +the steps on the screen. -been +Navigate Google Play -have +1. Tap Search for apps & games on the top of the screen to search -that +for a specific game or app. -specially +2. To install an app, tap the app and follow the prompts to complete +the process. After installation, you will see a notification in the +Notifications panel. You can open the app from the notification panel +or Apps list. -into -soybeans, +Settings -be +From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +to access your phone’s Settings menu. -put +Network & Internet -can -rice, +From the Settings screen, tap Network & internet. +• Internet: Enable or disable Wi-Fi, add Wi-Fi network, view saved -beans -like +networks, and monitor data usage. -roasted -put +• Wi-Fi Calling: Enable or disable Wi-Fi Calling, adjust Wi-Fi Calling settings. +• Mobile network: Enable or disable mobile data, adjust data roaming +settings, view mobile data usage, set data limit and warning mode, etc. -coffee -other items +• Airplane mode: Enable or disable Airplane mode. +• Mobile plan: View your mobile plan. +• Others: Adjust settings on Hotspot & tethering, Data saver, VPN, -Only -never -nuts,sugar, and spices into the hopper. -objects -Never -damage the grinder. -bean hopper -The -beans -of +Private DNS, etc. -cover acts -maximized. +23 -as a -Please +24 - coffee + Connected devices +From the Settings screen, tap Connected devices > Connection +preferences. +• USB: Connect your phone with a computer using a USB cable to +transfer data, share network connectivity, or charge your phone. +• Bluetooth: Pair Bluetooth devices to launch wirelessly hear calls, -hard +connect speakers, transfer data, and more. -into +• Cast: Scan for nearby devices to connect to and set them up. +• Printing: Connect your device to a printer on the same Wi-Fi -put +network. -the +• Chromebook: Link your phone to a chromebook. +• Nearby Share: Allow the rapid short-range exchange of images, -seal. -do +videos, text, contact info, directions, YouTube videos, and other data +via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. -beanhopper, +• Android Auto: Control your phone’s maps, media and messaging -otherwise +functions, with the Google Assistant while you drive. -it will +Apps -It -not +View current running applications, manage permissions, and more. +From the Settings screen, tap Apps. +• Recently opened apps: Tap an app to view detailed information. +• Default apps: Set the default app for the browser, phone, messages, -keeps +etc. You can also set default apps for opening links. -the aroma +• Screen time: You can tap -lose +on the right side of most apps to set -the cover. +daily timers. When the app timer ends, the app is paused for the rest +of the day. -the +• Unused apps: View apps that you have not used for a long time. You -bean hopper, +can un-install them to free up some space. -chocolate +• App battery usage: Set battery usage for apps. +• Special app access: View app access for special functions, such as -beans, +battery optimization, display over other apps, unrestricted data, usage +access, etc. -Don't pour liquid in the bean container. +25 -Grinding wheel +26 -● + Notifications -● +Battery -● +From the Settings screen, tap Notifications. +• App notifications: Control notifications from individual apps. +• Notification history: View your recent and snoozed notifications. +• Conversations: View priority and modified conversations. +• Bubbles: Enable message conversations display as bubbles, floating -● +on top of other apps. -● +• Device & app notification: Control which apps and devices can -● +read notifications. -● +• Notifications on lock screen: Select how you want notifications to -adjust +be displayed on the lock screen. -Please -according to the coffee bean type. +• Do Not Disturb: Enable or disable Do Not Disturb. Set Do Not -fineness +Disturb behavior, exceptions, schedule, etc. -coffee +• Others: You can adjust other notifications settings, like wireless -the +emergency alerts, hide silent notifications in status bar, etc. -of +Monitor your phone’s battery usage. +From the Settings screen, tap Battery. +• Battery Usage: View the battery percentage that each apps used -bean +from last full charge. -grind choice +• Battery Saver: Enable or disable Battery Saver, set a schedule for +turning on the Battery Saver, turn the Battery Saver off when your +phone charges above 90%. -adjust +• Battery percentage: Show battery percentage in the Status bar. -Please -or the grinder may be damaged. +Storage -grinding +Manage internal storage on your phone and provides menu choices for +an optional SD card. +From the Settings screen, tap Storage. +• Device storage: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > This -wheel +device. Tap a category to view the storage amount used by each app. -the +27 -when +28 -the + • SD card: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > SD CARD to -grinder +Display -is +view files stored on your SD card. Tap on the top right corner of the +screen to rename, eject or format the SD card. -running, +• Storage manager: Storage manager removes backed up photos and -it +videos from your device. -is +Sound & vibration +From the Settings screen, tap Sound & vibration. +• Media/Call/Ring/Notification/Alarm volume: Drag the slides to -are +adjust the media, call, ring & notification, and alarm volumes. -are +• Do Not Disturb: Manage Do Not Disturb settings. +• Phone ringtone: Select a ringtone for incoming phone calls. +• Media: Enable Media to hide player when the media session has ended. +• Others: You can adjust other sound and vibration settings, like -your +vibration & haptics, default notification and alarm sounds, enable +tones or vibration on other scenarios, etc. -your +From the Settings screen, tap Display. +• Brightness level: Drag the slide to adjust the screen brightness -color, +level. -beans +• Adaptive brightness: Enable adaptive brightness to automatically -beans +adjust the screen brightness basing on the lighting conditions. -light in +• Lock screen: Set what to show on lock screen. +• Screen timeout: Your screen will automatically go to sleep after the -coffee +set amount of time. -coffee +• Dark theme: Turn on dark theme. +• Display size and text: Adjust font size and display size. +• Night Light: Set a Night Light schedule and intensity. +• Others: You can adjust other display settings, like enable auto-rotate +screen and life to wake features, adjust display color and screen saver, +etc. -recommended to +29 -dark in +30 -If -set to the coarse grind. -If -to set to the fine grind. -While -very -coarse grind. -Adjust grind choice as needed, increase or decrease grind -level. + Accessibility -making -slowly , please change the grind choice to a more +Security & privacy -recommended +Manage accessibility-related apps to make the device easier to use for +those with certain physical disabilities. +From the Settings screen, tap Accessibility. +• Real-Time text call: Manage RTT call options. +• Display: Adjust the font size and display size, enable or disable dark -brew dispense +theme, enable screen magnification, etc. -coffee drinks, +• Interaction controls: Enable or disable useful interaction functions, -coffee +such as timing control, system controls, etc. -color, +• Captions: Enable or disable captions. You can also set caption display -the +language, text size, and caption style. -is +• Audio: Pair your hearing aids, enable mono audio, or adjust the audio -it +balance from the speaker. -if +• Accessibility shortcuts: Mange the settings on accessibility button. +• Text-to-speech output: Set the text-to-speech engine, language, -adjustment +speech rate, etc. -The -making two or more cups of coffee. +From the Settings screen, tap Security & privacy. +• App security: Check your device and prevent/warn you of potential -grinding +harm. -wheel +• Device lock: Set your screen lock method, pattern, PIN, password, etc. +• Account security: Add a Google Account to secure your device. +• Device finders: Enable Find My Device to locate your device -of +remotely, keeping your data safe in the event that your phone is lost. +• System & updates: Check for new software updates for your device. +• Privacy: Manage a batch of privacy settings. +• Face unlock: Unlock your phone by looking at it. +• More security & privacy: Adjust more security and privacy settings. -will +Unlock your device automatically in certain conditions. -be +31 -effective +32 -only + Location -after +From the Settings screen, tap Location. +• Recent access: View a list of apps that have recently requested your -Finest +location. -Fine +• App location permissions: View which apps have permission to -Medium +access location services. -Coarse +• Location services: Manage settings on other location services, such -Coarsest +as emergency location service, Google location accuracy, etc. - Power on +Safety & emergency -First-time use +Fulfill your medical and emergency information, view emergency alerts, +and manage settings on emergency SOS and location service. +From the Settings screen, tap Safety & emergency. +• Emergency information: Add medical information and emergency +contacts to help first responders in an emergency. Anyone can read +this information from your lock screen and dial your emergency +contacts without unlocking your phone.. -● +• Emergency SOS: If you have turned the Emergency SOS function +on, when you have an emergency and need emergency services, +press the Power/Lock key 5 or more times quickly. -As -be +• Emergency Location Service: If you have turned Emergency +Location Services (ELS) on, when you call or text an emergency +number, your device will use ELS to automatically send your location +to emergency responders. -the -a +• Earthquake alerts: Get an alert with the initial estimated magnitude -machine +and distance from your location. -has +• Wireless emergency alerts: Turn wireless emergency alerts on -been +or off. You can also view emergency alert history and manage alert +preferences. -tested +Passwords & accounts -at the +Set up and manage all of your accounts, including your Google Account +and other social networking accounts, through the Accounts settings +menu. From the Settings screen, tap Passwords & accounts. -factory, +33 -there +34 -may + • Passwords: See, change, or remove passwords you saved in your -little +• Reduce interruptions: Enable or disable the notifications of apps -coffee +Google Account. -left in the machine +and Do Not Disturb mode. -. +• Autofill service: Autofill your information when needed from your -● +Google Account. -● +• Add account: Set up your account. +• Automatically sync app data: Activate automatic data syncing. -● +Digital Wellbeing & parental controls -coffee +Statistics screen usage time, app timers, bedtime schedules, manage +notifications, etc. +From the Settings screen, tap Digital Wellbeing & parental controls. +• Your Digital Wellbeing tools: Use app timers and other tools to -The -first-time -best working condition, and this process cannot be skipped +keep track of screen time and unplug more easily. -cleaning upon -achieve +• Ways to disconnect: View your screen time and set timers for your +apps, set a bedtime schedule to disconnect from your phone and +avoid interruptions while you sleep, pause distracting apps when you +need time to focus. -and -machine +• Show icon in the app list: Enable icons in the app list. +• Parental controls: Add content restrictions and set other limits to -machine -this +help your child balance their screen time. -will -helps +Google -start -the +Configure your device’s Google settings. Available options depend on +your Google Account. From the Settings screen, tap Google. -self-testing +System -coffee +Manage detailed settings for your phone, including language and input +settings, battery and storage, date and time, etc. +From the Settings screen, tap System. +• Languages: Set the language for the phone’s menus and keyboards, +set the language for each app, set units and number preferences, etc. -use, +• Keyboard: Select and configure keyboard settings -the +35 -When powering on the coffee machine, it will automatically +36 -complete heating and cleaning for one time, every + • Gestures: Enable useful gestures, such as Quickly open camera, +Navigation mode, Power & hold power menu and Prevent ringing. +• Date & time: Enable or disable network-provided time, automatic -time and the process cannot be stopped. The coffee machine +time zone, 24-hour format, etc. -can only be used after the above cycle process is finished. +• Backup: Back up your phone’s data and settings to Google servers -During the cleaning process, some hot water may flow out of +before resetting your phone to the original factory settings. -the coffee spout into the drip tray. Please avoid contacting +• System update: Check for new software updates for your device. +• Multiple users: Share this device with other people by creating -the hot water. +additional users. -Please ensure the power is connected before pressing -the +• Reset options: View different reset options and reset your device. -power button. +About phone -Power off +Access important phone information, search for and apply updates, and +view legal and safety information. +From the Settings screen, tap About phone. -● +Troubleshooting -● +Below is a list of common problems that may occur when using your +mobile phone. Try these easy troubleshooting steps to resolve any type +of issues you may encounter. +The phone does not power on +• Press and hold the power key until the startup sequence appears on -● +the display. -When powering off the coffee machine , it will automatically -complete the cleaning process for one time, every time,and the -process cannot be stopped. This operation is to clean up -the coffee pipelines and remove the coffee grounds. +• Check the battery level and ensure there is sufficient charge. +The phone does not respond after several minutes +• Remove and insert the battery – If the phone has an internal battery, -During the cleaning process, some hot water will flow out of -the coffee spout into the drip tray. Avoid touching hot -water, so as not to be burned. -Only after using milk/foam/cappuccino/latte, the Rinse -Milk Unit function will be operated when the power is turned off. +please press and hold the power button. -When you press the power button, the machine will be -powered off after auto cleaning +The phone powers off by itself +• Check if the screen lock of the phone is enabled. +• Check if the phone needs to be charged. -When +37 -you +38 -press + The battery will not charge +• Check if the battery is already fully charged. +• Make sure that the battery is inserted correctly. +• Ensure that the battery being used is a BLU approved battery. +• Double check if the charger connector is properly connected to the -the power +phone. -button, +Note: Connect charger only after the battery has been inserted. -the +The phone displays a SIM Error +• Make sure the SIM is properly inserted and in its intended slot. +• Make sure that the SIM card is not damaged or scratched. +The PIN code was entered incorrectly three times +• The SIM card will lock, and you will need to enter the PUK code (PIN +Unlock Code). Please contact your local service provider to obtain the +PUK. -machine +The standby time is too short +• Please keep in mind that standby time relates directly to phone usage -will +I cannot make calls +• Make sure that the number you dialed is correct and the dial key has -be +(Internet, Text, Voice Calls, Maps, etc.). -powered +been pressed. -off after auto +• Batteries typically have to be replaced after a year of use. +The phone cannot connect to the network (Voice or Data) +• Verify if you have active service with your service provider. +• Contact your local network service provider and verify if you are within -cleaning. +its network coverage area. -READY +• Use the full national area code when dialing out of your area or when -06 +abroad, use country-specific international access codes. - Making beverages +I cannot receive calls +• Make sure that your phone is connected to a network. -T, his chapter instructs you on how to make various kinds -of coffee, hot water,hot milk and milk foam by this coffee -machine.Please read the following instructions carefully to help -you make high-quality beverages +39 -temperature -The -avoid being scalded. +40 -of + The caller ID does not display on incoming calls +• Contact your local network service provider and verify you have the +caller ID feature enabled on your account or verify if the caller may +have blocked his number from appearing. -the +The caller cannot leave a voicemail message +• Contact your local network service provider and verify if the voicemail -hot +service is active on your account or check if the network is busy. -water +The phone does not connect to the internet +• Ensure with your service provider that your account has the -is +appropriate internet/data plan enabled. -high, +• Ensure internet APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent). +Text Messages cannot be Sent / Received +• Ensure text messaging is enabled with your service provider. +• Ensure APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent). -please +Regulatory Information -do +FCC regulations -not +This mobile phone complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is +subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause +harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept any interference +received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. +This mobile phone has been tested and found to comply with the limits +for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These +limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful +interference in a residential installation. +This equipment generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy +and, if not installed and used in accordance with the instructions, may +cause harmful interference to radio communications. + +41 + +42 + + However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a +particular installation If this equipment does cause harmful interference +to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning +the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to correct the +interference by one or more of the following measures: +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. +• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that + +to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. +Changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party +responsible for compliance could void the user’s authority to operate the +equipment. +The antenna(s) used for this transmitter must not be co-located or +operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter. + +RF Exposure Information (SAR) + +This mobile phone meets the government’s requirements for exposure to +radio waves. +This phone is designed and manufactured not to exceed the emission +limits for exposure to radio frequency (RF) energy set by the Federal +Communications Commission of the U.S. Government. +The exposure standard for wireless mobile phones employs a unit of +measurement known as the Specific Absorption Rate, or SAR. The SAR +limit set by the FCC is 1.6 W/kg. *Tests for SAR are conducted using +standard operating positions accepted by the FCC with the phone +transmitting at its highest certified power level in all tested frequency +bands. +Although the SAR is determined at the highest certified power level, +the actual SAR level of the phone while operating can be well below +the maximum value. This is because the phone is designed to operate +at multiple power levels so as to use only the poser required to reach +the network. In general, the closer you are to a wireless base station +antenna, the lower the power output. + +43 + +44 + + The highest SAR value for the model phone as reported to the FCC when +tested for use at the ear is 1.29 W/kg and when worn on the body, as +described in this user guide, is 0.89 W/kg (Body-worn measurements +differ among phone models, depending upon available accessories and +FCC requirements.). +While there may be differences between the SAR levels of various +phones and at various positions, they all meet the government +requirement. +The FCC has granted an Equipment Authorization for this model phone +with all reported SAR levels evaluated as in compliance with the FCC RF +exposure guidelines. SAR information on this model phone is on file with +the FCC and can be found under the Display Grant section of www.fcc. +gov/oet/ea/fccid after searching on FCC ID: YHLBLUB160V. +For body worn operation, this phone has been tested and meets the FCC +RF exposure guidelines for use with an accessory that contains no metal +and the positions the handset with a minimum of 1.5 cm from the body. + +Use of other accessories may not ensure compliance with FCC RF +exposure guidelines. If you do not use a body-worn accessory and are +not holding the phone at the ear, position the handset a minimum of 1.5 +cm from your body when the phone is switched on. + +Safety precautions for power supply unit + +Use the correct external power source +A product should be operated only from the type of power source +indicated on the electrical ratings label. If you are not sure of the type +of power source required, consult your authorized service provider or +local power company. For a product that operates from battery power or +other sources, refer to the operating instructions that are included with +the product. +This product should be operated only with the following designated +power supply unit(s). +Travel charger: Input: 100-240V, 50/60Hz, 0.35A. Output: 5V, 2000mA. + +45 + +46 + + Handle battery packs carefully +This product contains a Lithium-ion battery. There is a risk of fire and +burns if the battery pack is handled improperly. Do not attempt to open +or service the battery pack. Do not disassemble, crush, puncture, short +circuit the external contacts or circuits, dispose of in fire or water, or +expose a battery pack to temperatures higher than 140°F (60°C). The +operating temperature for the phone is 14°F (-10°C) to 113°F (45°C). +Warning: Battery is non-removable. Do not attempt to remove +the battery for danger of explosion. +To reduce risk of fire or burns, do not disassemble, crush, puncture, +short circuit the external contacts, expose to temperature above 113°F +(45°C), or dispose of in fire or water. Do not attempt to replace the +non-removable battery. The phone and battery as a unibody device +must be disposed of in accordance with locally applicable environmental +regulations or guides supplied with your product. + +47 + +Take extra precautions +• Do not disassemble or open crush, bend or deform, puncture or + +shred. + +• Do not modify or remanufacture, attempt to insert foreign objects into +the battery, immerse or expose to water or other liquids, expose to +fire, explosion, or other hazards. + +• Only use the battery with a charging system that has been qualified + +with the system per CTIA Certification Requirement for Battery System +Compliance to IEEE1725. Use of an unqualified battery or charger may +present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage, or other hazards. + +• Replace the battery only with another battery that has been qualified + +with the system per this standard, IEEE-Std-1725. Use of an +unqualified battery may present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or +other hazards. Only authorized service providers shall replace battery. +(If the battery is non-user replaceable). + +• Promptly dispose of used batteries in accordance with local + +regulations. + +• Improper battery use may result in a fire, explosion, or other hazards. +48 + + • Do not replace an embedded battery pack. Improper replacement may +present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or other hazards. Contact the +manufacturer for replacement instructions. + +• The phone identifies the battery by the Battery ID Pin. +• If the battery leaks: + +• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with skin or + +clothing. If already in contact, flush the affected area immediately +with clean water and seek medical advice. + +• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with eyes. +If already in contact, DO NOT rub; rinse with clean water +immediately and seek medical advice. + +• Take extra precautions to keep a leaking battery away from fire as + +there is a danger of ignition or explosion. + +Hearing Aid Compatibility (HAC) + +This device is hearing aid-compatible as determined by ANSI C63.19- +2019 and waiver DA-23-914. The lowest conversational gain is 10.32 +dB with a hearing-aid, and 13.93 dB without hearing-aid, using telecoil +coupling capability and Bluetooth connectivity. +The 2019 ANSI C63.19 standard does not use this rating system nor +do any test standards exist for any wireless technologies that transmit +above 6 GHz. Instead, this standard uses the conversational gains for +the device’s hearing aid compatible capabilities. +This device has been tested and certified for use with hearing aids for +some of the wireless technologies that it uses. However, there may be +some newer wireless technologies used in this phone that have not been +tested yet for use with hearing aids. It is important to try the different +features of this phone thoroughly and in different locations, using your +hearing aid or cochlear implant, to determine if you hear any interfering +noise. Consult your service provider or the manufacturer of this phone +for information on hearing aid compatibility. If you have questions about +return or exchange policies, consult your service provider or retailer. -touch +49 -it +50 -to + We consent to the following conditions of the waiver: +• Pass Conversational Gain, Receive Distortion and Noise and Receive -Before making -display. -on +Acoustic Frequency Response testing using one narrowband and one +wideband codec, limited to one bit rate. -the +• Pass Conversational Gain at both 2N and 8N on all available -all +narrowband and wideband codecs and air interface combinations. +Please see the HAC Volume Control test report for further details and +supporting data. -kinds +The information provided in this user manual is subject to change without notice +and BLU Products reserves the right to modify the manual at any given time. BLU +Products has made every effort to ensure that this user manual is accurate and +disclaims responsibility and liability for any inaccuracies or omissions. BLU Products +makes no commitment to keep current the user manuals, however, does reserve +the right to make improvements to the user manual at any given time without +notice. -of +Google, Google Play, Google Maps, YouTube, Gmail and other marks are +trademarks of Google LLC. -coffee, - -please - -ensure - -“READY” - -is - -indicated - -● -● - -● - -● - -● - -● - -used. - -ensure - -at -it -of - -recommended - -water -better, -quality - -normal -is -coffee, - -potable -tastes -the - -can -temperature -use -to -change - -The coffee beans should be stored in a dry place and avoid sunlight. -Only -make the -coffee -To -tank every day. -Please -taste. -Please -of -height of the cup in order to avoid coffee splashing. -Adjustable height of coffee spout: 80-140mm. - -around25℃. -in the - -be -water -the - -making the - -according - -please - -before - -coffee - -coffee - -coffee - -height - -better - -adjust - -water - -water - -warm - -spout - -cup - -the - -the - -the - -the - -for - -To - -to - -Preparing coffee by touch icon - -You can make 4 kinds of coffee using the touch icons, when -shows -“READY” - -the screen - -Take espresso for example to explain how to make coffee by touch icons. - -07 - -The volume of espresso is suggested between 30 to 50ml. -Because of the small volume of espresso, please warm the coffee cup before -making coffee. - -Touch the espresso icon for espresso -function. - -ESPRESSO - -STRONG - -VOLUME - -50ML - -ENJOY ! - -The grinder will begin to grind . At this time -you can adjust the amount of coffee beans -by rotating the rotary button. -Default amount of coffee beans for -espresso: - -During making coffee, you can adjust the -volume of coffee by rotating the rotary -button. -Default volume of espresso: 50ML - -When the screen shows as the left picture, it -means the espresso is ready, please enjoy -it. - -READY - -ESPRESSO - - Single time setting of coffee parameters - -Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle. - -Making beverages - -● -● -● -● -● -● -● -● - -Set the amount of coffee beans during the grinding process. -Set the volume of coffee when making coffee -Set the dispense time of milk -foam to control the -to -Set the dispense time of milk -Set the temperature of hot water before making hot water -Set the hot water volume when making hot water -Set the dispense time of hot milk -Set the dispense time of hot foam when making hot foam - -the volume - -control the - -volume - -volume - -control - -to - -making -when -when making latte - -cappuccino - -when making hot milk - -Detail instructions -You can set the strength of coffee before making the beverage and the -volume of the beverage -saved. - -during the brew cycle. The settings will - -not be - -STRONG - -VOLUME - -40ML - -FOAM TIME - -20S - -MILK TIME - -15S - -NORMAL - -VOLUME - -60ML - -When -rotate - -grinding -rotary -the - -the -button - -coffee -to - -beans, -the - -you -amount - -can -of - -adjust - -coffee - -beans, - -to - -the left - -is - -mild - -, - -and - -to - -the right - -is strong . The - -default - -amount - -is normal - -When -can -For -2 -clicks - -making long - -coffee - -volume - -coffee, -by using the - -be adjusted -example, - -the current - -rotary -is -to reduce -95ml, -increase to 105ml. - -volume -to - -button. -100ml, -2 -and - -clicks - -to the - -to the - -right - -left -to - -cappuccino, -making -the - -making -latte,the foam - -When -coffee -adjusted by rotating -the milk foam outflows. -current time is 20s,2 clicks -reduce -increase to 21S. - -For - -to - -milk -time - -foam -be - -or - -can -rotary -button -example,the -to -to the - -left - -19S,and 2 clicks to the right to - -while - -08 - -making - -time -button. - -When -dispensing -the rotary -milk dispensing -left to reduce to -to increase to 16S. - -hot -can - -milk -be - -coffee - -or -adjusted - -For -time -14S, - -example, -is -and - -15S, -2 - -2 -clicks - -latte, - -milk -rotating -current -to the - -by -the -clicks - -to the - -right - -hot - -making - -Before -adjusted -be -the left -low, -is -temperature is normal. - -water, -rotating -right is - -by -to the - -temperature -rotary - -the -the -high. The - -default - -button. - -can -To - -dispensing - -be - - can -button. -is -and - -For -100ML, -2 - -hot - -adjusted - -water, -by -example, -clicks -2 -to -clicks - -the -hot -rotating -the -to the - -water -the -current -reduce -left - the right to increase - -to - -When -volume -rotary -volume -to -95ML, -to 105ML. - - Making beverages - -Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee - -can - -You -Pre-ground coffee. - -choose - -this - -function - -if - -you - -want - -to - -make - -coffee - -with - -●Do not use instant coffee powder -pre-ground -damage the machine. - -or cocoa powder in the -coffee chute. powder container.Otherwise it will - -● -Do not put pre-ground coffee powder into the coffee -bean hopper,otherwise, it will damage the machine. - -● - -● - -● - -Please use proper Pre-ground coffee for espresso. - -Only 7-14g of pre-ground coffee can be added. -Machine will be - -damaged. - -The process of using pre-ground coffee to make coffee -only skips the process of grinding coffee beans, other -operations are the same as making espresso, long coffee, -cappuccino, and coffee latte. This chapter illustrates with -espresso. - -Press and hold the rotary button to -enter into -programming when the -coffee machine is -“READY”. - -READY - -09 - -GROUND COFFEE - -Display shows “GROUND COFFEE ” page -after entered into programming. Press -the rotary button to make coffee. - -Open pre-ground coffee chute cover and -fill .close the cover. Touch the - -icon -beverage -Press the rotary button to - -need - -you - -to - -make -cancel. - -coffee. - -FILL GROUND COFFEE - -SELECT COFFEE -ROTARY TO CANCEL - -Program setting - -● - -This chapter will give instructions on program settings. - -● - -Ensure the coffee machine shows “READY”, press and hold the - -rotary button , then you can enter into the menu - - Beverage setting - -will - -instruct - -chapter - -This -settings -temperature -hot milk, dispense time of - -you -parameters include -hot - -of - -how -to -coffee - -set -strength, - -beverages parameters. -coffee, - -volume - -of - -The - -water,volume of hot water,dispense time of making - -making hot foam - -parameters - -accomplished - -by the - -beverage - -setting - -will - -be - -the - -The -default - - values for each beverage. - -1. Espresso setting -2. Long coffee setting -3. Hot water setting -4. Cappuccino setting -5. Coffee latte setting -6. Hot milk setting -7. Hot foam setting - -Setting beverage parameters and range - -The parameters such as strength, volume, temperature and -forthe beverages below. - -time can be set - -can be set - -can be set - -The strength and volume of espresso -The strength and volume of long coffee -The strength and volume of coffee part of cappuccino -set -The foam dispensing time in cappuccino -eht dna trap eeffoc fo emulov dna htgnerts ehT -can be set -The temperature and the volume of hot water can be set -Hot milk making time can be set -Hot foam making time can be set - -can be set - -can be - - ettal ni emit gnitiaw - -Please read the following table for the detail setting parameters and -adjustment range - -10 - -Drinks - -espresso - -long coffee - -cappuccino - -coffee Latte - -hot water - -hot milk - -hot foam - -Strength - -Volume range - -Default - -Mild: -Normal: -Strong: - -Mild: -Normal: -Strong: - -Volume: 15 -120ML - -Volume: 15 - 240ML - -Volume: 15 - 240ML -Milk time: 0 - 120SEC -Foam time: 3 - 120SEC -Wait time: 0 - 30SEC - -Volume: 25 -450ML - -Milk time: 3 -120SEC - -Foam time: 3 -120SEC - -50ML - -100ML - -60ML - -Foam time: 20SEC - -60ML - -Milk time: 15SEC -Foam time: 20SEC -Wait : 20SEC - -100ML - -15 SEC - -15 SEC - -Temperature Setting - -The coffee temperature can be adjusted to your liking with the “ Temperature setting” -function and you can choose: - -1 .Low - -2 .Normal - -3 .High - -The default temperature is Normal, and it’s only adjustable for coffee not milk. - - Program setting - -Eco settings - -● - -● - -If the machine is set to Eco-setting, the machine needs 30 -seconds to warm up to make Cappuccino, Coffee Latte, -milk and foam. . The normal setting has more energy -consumption than the Eco-saving mode. - -Hot - -The factory default setting of the machine is normal mode. -entering the program setting, please turn the rotary -“ECO SETTING” option, then press the rotary button, -finished. - -button to -setting is - -After - -Automatic power-down - -switch - -off - -time - -automatically - -is 4 hours, -switch - -which -off 4 hours - -automatic - -switch-off - -is - -from - -15 - -minutes - -to - -program - -setting, -Then - -please -press - -the - -turn - -the -rotary - -rotary -button, - -option. - -will - -default - -machine - -machine’s - -the -setting - -last use . -range - -The -means the -after -The -24 hours. -entering -After -button -“Auto-off” -the -the setting is completed. - -the - -to - -of - -Factory Reset - -● - -● - -● - -● - -● - -will - -the - -the - -all -to - -function - -reset -parameters -options). However - -This -beverage -language -not be reset. -After -the -confirm, the setting is completed. - -program -option - -“FACTORY RESET” - -entering - -the - -the - -menu -factory - -setting -settings - -and -(except - -default -the - -information - -options - -will - -setting, -then - -please - -press - -the - -turn - -the -rotary - -rotarybutton -button - -to - -to - -Information Statics - -11 - -● - -In this program you can view the statistical information on -the number of drinks, total drinks numbers, etc. - -1. Number of rinses -2. Number of total cycles -3. Number of espresso -4. Number of long coffee -5. Number of hot water -6. Number of cappuccino -7. Number of coffee latte -8. Number of hot milk -9. Number of hot foam -10. Number of descales -11. Number of ground coffee -12. Number of brew unit cleans -13. Number of milk unit rinses - -● - -When first viewed there will -produced -been - -because -before leaving the factory. - -already be -each - -beverages - -tested - -a -coffee - -number - -of -machine - -has - -Language - -● - -You can set your preferred language on the coffee machine. - -● - -After entering the program setting, turn the rotary button to the "CHOOSE -LANGUAGE" option, then press the rotary button, rotate the rotary to -choose the language, and press the rotary button, the language setting -is completed. -EXIT - -● - -After entering the program setting, please turn the rotary button to the -“EXIT” option. Then press the rotary button. The -machine will return to -“READY” . - - Cleaning and maintenance - -chapter - -This -the coffee machine. - -will - -instruct - -you on - -how - -to - -clean - -and - -maintain - -Paying -machine,will -coffee, - -attention -not -also - -but - -daily - -maintenance -to -only -of -taste -the -extend the life of the coffee machine. - -coffee -cup - -of the -of - -ensure - -each - -Cleaning the coffee machine before operation - -chapter -This -coffee machine. - -will - -instruct - -you - -on how - -to - -clean - -and - -maintain - -the - -Cleaning function must be processed in “READY” status. - -When the coffee machine is in “READY” -status and the cleaning indicator light is not -on, press the cleaning button to start -cleaning the brewing unit and coffee -spout. - -The process of cleaning coffee machine -cannot be interrupted, and it will -automatically return to “READY” status after -cleaning. - -READY - -CLEANING - -Cleaning brewing unit - -READY - -12 - -After a long-term use, there will be some coffee ground -brewing unit. Remove the grounds by deeply cleaning the -brewing -The process of cleaning the brewing unit takes about - - unit. - -20minutes. - -left in the - -After entering the program settings, turn the -rotary button to the "MAINTENANCE" option, -and press the rotary button. - -When the screen shows the picture on the -indicates cleaning the brewing unit -left, it - has been selected. Press the -program -cleaning -button to start cleaning the -brewing unit. - -The brew unit is cleaning. - -MAINTENANCE - -CLEAN BREW UNIT - -CLEANING - - Cleaning and maintenance - -OPEN COVER ADD -CLEANING TABLET - -CLOSE COVER -PRESS RINSE - -CLEAN - -CLEANING - -READY - -Open the pre-ground coffee chute cover, -add - -the cleaning tablet. - -Close the pre-ground coffee chute -cover, -press the cleaning button to -start the cleaning process. - -The screen will display as the left picture, - -Brew unit is now cleaning. - -After cleaning has finished, the machine -re-enters - -into “READY” status. - -13 - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -● - -After long-term use, some milk waste would be left in the Milk -needs to - -be cleaned. - -unit and - -Enter the program setting, Turn the -rotary -page and - -button to the“MAINTENANCE” -pressed the rotary button. - -When showing left picture in the display, it is -now in milk unit cleaning mode, press the -cleaning button to start. - -Remove the milk pipe from the milk -container and insert it into the hole in the -drip tray grid according to the display. -Press the rinse button to rinse milk unit. - -MAINTENANCE - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -REMOVE MILK PIPE - -PRESS RINSE - - Milk unit is cleaning. -After cleaning is finished, the machine -enters - - into “READY” status. - -Cleaning and maintenance - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning process - -is - -completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - -Descaling the coffee machine - -The daily usage will cause calcium deposits in the coffee -machine. The depositing rate varies with the local water -hardness. - -Decalcifier contains acidic substances that -could hurt -comply with the security warnings noted by the -manufacturer on the packaging. - -your eyes and skin, so you must strictly - -Dissolve the decalcifier in clean water, and then put the -mixed liquid into the water tank. Fully dissolved the -Decalcifier can descale the coffee machine more -thoroughly. -The whole descaling process takes about 30 minutes. -Do not cancel the descaling process or you will damage -the coffee machine. -once -process,please do not terminate it midway or turn off -power to themachine. - -descaling - -start - -you - -the - -So - -NEED DESCALE - -PRESS RINSE - -MAINTENANCE - -DESCALE - -30 MINS - -PRESS RINSE - -14 - -After a certain time of use, if it reaches a -high -degree of scaling, “NEEDS DESCALE" -and"PRESS RINSE " will automatically -display on -the screen alternately. Now, press the -cleaning button to enter the descaling -program. - -Turn the rotary button to the maintenance -setting option, press the rotary button to -enter. - -Turn the rotary button to descaling option, -press rotary button to enter - -After entering the descaling program, press -the cleaning button to start the descaling -program; it will take about - -minutes. - -30 - - Cleaning and maintenance - -SOLVENT IN TANK - -PRESS RINSE - -DECALCIFYING - -EMPTY TRAY - -Take a bag of decalcifier and sufficiently -dissolve it in clean water, then put this -mixed liquid to the water tank, and reinstall -the water tank to the coffee machine. - -After adding decalcifier, press the -cleaning -cleaning. - -button to start descaling and - -To start descaling and cleaning for the first -time, put a container, of which the -capacity is more than 1L, under the coffee -spout. - -Empty tray. - -Install tray. - -INSTALL TRAY - -15 - -FILL WATER TANK - -After descaling and cleaning for the first -time, take the water tank out, empty the -rest of the water and clean it. Add -potable water again, and reinstall it to the -coffee machine - - and cleaning for the second - -Press the cleaning button to enter -descaling -time. This is to clean -decalcifying water in pipes at -a container, of which the -than 1L, under the coffee - -the residual - -capacity is more -spout. - -this time . Put - -Decalcifying. - -the - -screen - -When -shows -the descaling is completed; Now, you can -continue to brew beverages. - -“READY”, - -indicates - -it - -PRESS RINSE - -DECALCIFYING - -READY - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - - Cleaning coffee grounds container and drip tray - -● - -● - -● - -not - -use - -and - -corrosive - -chemical - -Do -cleaner -solvents -to clean the coffee grounds container and drip tray. -The drip tray and coffee grounds container cannot be cleaned -in dishwasher. -not -Do -avoid - -residue -container. - -use -scraping - -coffee -grounds - -objects -drip - -or -dirt -coffee - -clean -and - -to -tray - -metal - -the - -to - -or - -alcohol - -Cleaning and maintenance - -1 - -● -When prompted to empty the coffee grounds, coffee grounds -must be cleaned up, or it will cause the machine to be -damaged. - -. - -When it accumulates to 35 cups, it will -automatically indicate “EMPTY GROUNDS”. - -2 - -EMPTY GROUNDS - -INSTALL TRAY - -READY - -EMPTY TRAY - -INSTALL TRAY - -READY - -When it shows “INSTALL TRAY “, please -remove coffee grounds from the drip tray -and -more than 3 seconds. - - coffee grounds container. This will take - -Reinstall the water drip tray in the machine, -it should returns to “READY” status. You can -continue using the machine. - -If the drip tray is full, the machine will -automatically indicate"EMPTY TRAY". Take -out the water drip tray and dispose of -waste - - water. - -After clearing the waste water, reinstall the -drip tray to the coffee machine, it should -returns to“READY” status. You can continue -using the machine. - -3 - -4 - -16 - - ● - -Each time you are cleaning coffee grounds and waste water -from the drip tray, please empty the drip tray and coffee -grounds - -container. - -● - -Each time after cleaning coffee grounds and waste water from the drip -tray, -at the end of drip tray, then reinstall the drip tray to the coffee machine. - -please rinse the tray with clean water, and wipe dry the 2 steel plates - - Cleaning and maintenance - -Cleaning water tank - -● - -● - -● - -It is suggested that, each time adding water, clean the tank -thoroughly with running water first. -Cleaning the water tank regularly - -to - -be - -use - -rag - -a wet - -better - -would - -and some mild - -it -cleaning fluid. -Because the water tank is made from food-grade materials and -environmental materials, it might crack if handled -aggressively. Please gently pick it up -and put it down, and -never let it fall down. if the water tank is damaged, please -contact the customer service center. - -Cleaning bean container - -● - -● - -● - -to - -do - -not - -use - -wash - -water - -, -would -it - -beans hopper - -in the bean hopper - -the -Please -cause the grinder to be damaged. -Please use a dry rag or a paper towel to clean the -residue -food-grade -Because -crack if handle aggre. - and -Please gently pick it up and put it down, and never let it fall -down. If the bean container lid is damaged , please contact -the customer service center. - -. -cover -it - -environmental - -is -might - -container - -materials, - -grease - -made - -bean - -from - -the - -ssively. - -Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother - -In order to guarantee the fine and smooth milk foam, please -clean the milk frother every day. - -1. Carefully take off the milk frother. -2. Disassemble each part of the milk frother thoroughly. -3. Wash the parts with running water. -4. Reassemble the milk frother, and install it to the coffee -machine. - -17 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -Installing milk pipe - -● - -Install the milk pipe to the milk frother inlet. - -Cleaning milk pipe - -In order to keep milk pipe clean, please clean it every day. - -1. Take off milk pipe carefully. -2. Clean milk pipe in running water. - - Cleaning coffee machine - -● - -● - -● - -● - -the - -check - -coffee - -grounds residue - -Before cleaning the interior of the coffee machine, power it -off, the disconnect power cord from the outlet ,Never -immerse the coffee machine inwater. There will be a risk of -electric shock. -Regularly -coffee -brush to remove the coffee - -machine -the -ground. -Use a dry and soft -machine. -the -As the touch panel is made of glass, please do not hit it to -avoid the risk of electric shock once the glass broken. -Use a dry and soft rag to wipe the surface of the machine, -and never use hard objects to clean coffee residue on the -surface, otherwise it would cause the surface to be -damaged. - -is -can use a - -whether -machine. - -there -You - -excessive - -touch - -panel - -inside - -wipe - -rag - -the - -to - -of - -Problem Causes and Solutions - -● - -● - -This chapter will instruct you on some errors that you may -encounter - -and the solutions. - -If there are some failures cannot be resolved by the following -methods, please contact with the authorized service center. - -melborP - -Cause - -snoituloS - -The coffee temperature is too low. - -The coffee cup was not pre-heated. - -Wash the coffee cup with hot water -before making coffee. - -Several minutes have passed since the -last time of coffee making , so the -brewing unit and the internal pipes are -already cold. - -Make some more cups of coffee. - -18 - -Coffee only comes out from the -coffee spout drop by drop. - -Overly fine pre -ground coffee or coffee -bean has been ground too fine. - -Adjust the grinding level to coarse -or use the suitable pre-ground coffee . - -Brewing unit filter was blocked. - -Run the brewing unit rinse programme - -Insufficient coffee oil. - -Chose the wrong coffee bean type. - -The grinder is making unusual noises. - -There are foreign objects in the grinder. - -Use suitable coffee beans. - -Make coffee again, if it still fails, please -contact the authorized service center - -The milk frother cannot make any milk -foam. - -The milk frother is blocked. - -Cleaning the milk frother ( refer to P17). - -Milk sprays from the milk frother. - -The milk frother was not assembled -correctly. - -Reassemble the milk frother. - -Screen always indicates "EMPTY TRAY". - -Screen always indicates "INSTALL TRAY". - -Screen always indicates “FILL WATER -TANK”, but the water tank is full. - -The sheet metal at the end of the drip -tray is dirty or wet. - -Coffee grounds in the bottom of the -machine are not cleaned. - -Wipe the sheet metal to dry ( refer to P16). - -Clean the coffee grounds in the bottom. - -The water tank inductor is trapped. - -Clean the water tank ( refer to P17). - -Screen always indicates “FILL BEANS”, -but the bean container is full. - -The bean container is too oily and -sticky for coffee beans. - -“Errors 1 to 7”is displayed. - -If the coffee machine fails, it cannot -continue to be used - -1. Stir coffee beans in bean container. -2. Observe if the coffee beans are over -roasted or charcoal roasted. -3. Clean the beans container ( refer to -P17). - -1. Restart coffee machine. -2. If “errors” still exist, switch off the main -power, and contact the authorized -service center - - Display information - -● - -This chapter will instruct you on the error information -that is - -screen and the solutions. - - displayed on the - -Causes - -Solutions - -If the water drip tray is full, -making beverage will -service. - - be out of - -Take the drip tray out, empty the -waste water in the drip tray and -reinstall it to the machine. - -If the coffee grounds container is -full, making - beverage will be out -of service. - -Take the coffee grounds container -out, empty the coffee grounds -container and reinstall it. - -If water in the water tank is -empty, making -be out of service. - - beverage will - -Fill the water tank with water. - -If coffee beans in the bean -hopper are used up, making -coffee will be out of - -service. - -Add beans into bean container, -and press the rotary button to -release. - -There is not enough pre - -ground -pre-ground coffee - -coffee - -in the - - chute. - -Next time when making coffee -with pre-ground coffee , please -use proper amount. - -The drip tray is not installed -correctly; any function is out of -service. - -Install the drip tray correctly. - -The water in the pipe inside the -machine is not enough; any -function is out of service. - -Press the rotary button to release, -to run the water replenishing system. - -Temperature of the machine is too -high, the machine cannot be used. - -Power off the main power, and -wait 1 hour later. - -Temperature of the machine is too -low, the machine cannot be used. - -Increase environmental temperature -to above 10℃. - -EMPTY TRAY - -EMPTY GROUNDS - -FILL WATER TANK - -FILL BEANS - -FILL POWDER - -19 - -INSTALL TRAY - -UNIT EMPTY - -TEMPERATURE HIGH - -TEMPERATURE LOW - -ERROR 1 - -The coffee machine fails -error1.may -used. - -not be able to be - -1. Power off, then power back -;2. If still unresolved, please -on -unplug from outlet.Contact with -authorized service center. -the - -1. Using dark roasted coffee beans -or over fine pre-ground coffee -filter of the brewer is -2. The -clogged. - -1.Adjust grinder wheel to a coarse -setting2. Start brewer cleaning -procedure(refer to P12). - -Dispenser valve is blocked. - -Restart coffee machine. - -PRESSURE HIGH - -VALVE RESET -RESTART MACHINE - - Transport and recycle - -Transport - -Please save the packaging of the coffee machine for future -transportation. -Make sure to empty water inside the machine before transportation, -otherwise, it will damage the machine. -After emptying the waterway, please wipe the machine both -inside and outside to dry. -Once the empty waterway program was executed, the system -will rerun to the program of “first-time use”, when the coffee -machine is used again.( refer to P6, First-time use) -While emptying the waterway, there will be high-temperature -steam sprays from coffee spout. Please pay special attention to -avoid being scalded. - -READY - -FILL WATER TANK - -EMPTY UNIT - -The machine is on the status of “READY”. - -Take out the water tank, and the machine -indicates “FILL WATER TANK”. - -Press and hold the cleaning button until -the screen shows "EMPTY UNIT", themachine -begins to clean up the waterway -automatically, and steam will spray from -coffee spout, please keep your distance to -avoid scalding. - -the - -After emptying the waterway, the machine -will automatically power off. Take the drip -tray out after the power is switched off, and -clear the water in the drip tray. - -Recycle - -When recycling the machine, some inner parts can be -recycled to use again. Please pay attention to recycle them -for environmental protection. - -Technical Data - -Voltage/Frequency - -120V~ 50/60 Hz - -Power - -Pump pressure - -1450 W - -19 bar - -Capacity of water tank - -2 L or connect to water barrel - -Capacity of bean hopper - -Capacity of coffee ground waste bin - -Capacity of the brewing unit - -750 g - -35 cakes - -7 - 14 g - -Adjusting the height of coffee spout - -80 - 140 mm - -Length of power cord - -Net weight - -1.5 m - -16 kg - -Dimensions (Length×Width×Height) - -533mm×383mm×662mm - -20 +51 diff --git a/q15/random_k4/question.json b/q15/random_k4/question.json index 4f851e40715cac938495549d782e4af34c348f93..cae82c8bbfd0130cc7e7558454d010d736ac2748 100644 --- a/q15/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q15/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2312.10997v5.pdf", - "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf", - "web_c40e5cade76fba39.pdf", - "web_eb48e5fd4ea89aaf.pdf", - "web_2ccba6013fe960b7.pdf" + "web_0592b193cfe894c0.pdf", + "resize_r2_25.pdf", + "web_fe44495665edf65a.pdf", + "web_5b8076d084922575.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_1.md b/q15/random_k4/random_1.md index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..d3a8827a2c9c1661d68231635f74293c020f1a02 100644 --- a/q15/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q15/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,5479 +1,1353 @@ -Owner’s Manual +CHAPTER 42 -Models -14, 16, 17, 18 - -Refrigerators +FORMWORK -TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST +42 FORMWORK -Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR +Definitions - Congratulations! - -Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our -quality products and we are committed to -providing dependable service. You’ll see it in -this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll -hear it in the friendly voices of our customer -service department. - -Best of all, you’ll experience these values -each time you use your refrigerator. That’s -important, because your new refrigerator will -be part of your family for many years. And we -hope you will be part of ours for a long time -to come. +The following definitions are used in the forming +industry. Some terms may be used by other trades +as well, but their meanings may be different from +these depending upon the application. -We appreciate your purchase, and hope you -will continue to rely on us whenever you -need quality appliances for your home. +Falsework, in relation to a form or structure, means +the structural supports and bracing used to support +all or part of the form or structure until the concrete +is poured and is strong enough to support loads. -Important! - -Fill out and return the Consumer Product -Registration Card that is packed with this -product. If you cannot find it, please send -in the duplicate card printed in the back of -this manual. +Flying formwork is a designed floor formwork +system that can be hoisted between levels as a unit. -Write the model and serial -numbers here. - -# - -# - -You can find them on a label on the -upper left side of the fresh food -compartment. - -Staple sales slip or cancelled -check here. - -Proof of the original purchase date -is needed to obtain service under -the warranty. - -2 - - AService Partnership. - -We stand behind our products with -unmatched quality service. However, did -you know that most questions result from -simple problems that you can easily -fix yourself in just a few minutes? This -Owner’s Manual can tell you how. - -Read this Manual -Inside you will find many -helpful hints on how to use and -maintain your refrigerator -properly. Just a little preventive -care on your part can save you a -great deal of time and money -over the life of your refrigerator. - -Review the Section on -Troubleshooting Tips - -You’ll find many answers to -common problems here. -If you review our chart of -Troubleshooting Tips first, -you may not need to call for -service at all. - -If You Need Service - -If you do need service, you can -relax knowing help is only a -phone call away. A list of toll-free -customer service numbers is -included in the back section. -Or you can always call the -GE Answer Center® at -800.626.2000, 24 hours a day, -7 days a week. - -Safety Information -Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4 -Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 -How to Connect Electricity . . . .6 -Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7 -Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7 - -Operating Instructions - -Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8 -Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10 -Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12 -Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13 -Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16 - -Installation Instructions - -Preparing to -Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18 -Water Line Installation . . .19–23 -Reversing the -Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29 - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Normal Operating Sounds . . .30 -Before You -Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33 - -Customer Service -Product Registration . . . . . . . .37 -Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39 -Service Telephone -Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover - -3 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -4 - -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! - -Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as -described in this Owner’s Manual. - -SAFETY PRECAUTIONS -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions -should be followed, including the following: - -n Keep fingers out of the -“pinch point” areas; -clearances between the -doors and between the doors -and cabinet are necessarily -small. Be careful closing -doors when children are in -the area. - -n Unplug the refrigerator - -before cleaning and making -repairs. - -NOTE: We strongly recommend -that any servicing be performed -by a qualified individual. - -n Turning the control to the - -OFF position does not remove -power to the light circuit. -n Do not refreeze frozen foods - -which have thawed -completely. - -n This refrigerator must be -properly installed and -located in accordance with -the Installation Instructions -before it is used. - -n Do not allow children to - -climb, stand or hang on the -shelves in the refrigerator. -They could damage the -refrigerator and seriously -injure themselves. -n Do not touch the cold -surfaces in the freezer -compartment, particularly -when hands are damp or wet. -Skin may stick to these -extremely cold surfaces. -n Do not store or use gasoline -or other flammable vapors -and liquids in the vicinity of -this or any other appliance. - -n In refrigerators with - -automatic icemakers, avoid -contact with the moving parts -of the ejector mechanism, or -with the heating element that -releases the cubes. Do not -place fingers or hands on the -automatic icemaking -mechanism while the -refrigerator is plugged in. - - DANGER! RISK OF CHILD - -ENTRAPMENT -PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR - -Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of -the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still -dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.” -If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please -follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents. - -Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator -or Freezer: - -n Take off the doors. -n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not - -easily climb inside. - -CFC Disposal - -Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used -CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm -stratospheric ozone. - -If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make -sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal -by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this -CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and -imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean -Air Act. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -5 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -6 - -IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION. -READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING. -WARNING! - -HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY -Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third -(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety, -this appliance must be properly grounded. - -The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong -(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong -(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric -shock hazard from this appliance. - -Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician -to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. - -Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your -personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a -properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet. - -The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual -electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating -plate. - -This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading -house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from -overheated wires. - -Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord. -Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet. - -Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become -frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or -abrasion damage along its length or at either end. - -When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to -roll over or damage the power cord. - -USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -adapter plug. - -However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a -temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong -wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local -hardware stores. - - The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in -the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the -power cord. - -When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold -the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord -plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground -terminal is very likely to break with repeated use. - -If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator -until a proper ground has been established. - -Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not -ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the -wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit -checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded. - -USE OF EXTENSION CORDS -Because of potential safety hazards under certain -conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an -extension cord. - -However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely -necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance -extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that -the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and -120 volts. - -REMEMBER… -Your continued health and safety are important to us. - -Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully. - -We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our -family. -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -7 - - About the temperature control dial. - -Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments— -fresh food and freezer. - -9 - -OFF - -7 - -5 - -3 - -1 - -Control Settings -Temperature Control Dial - -The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF. -1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5. - -After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary. - -Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn -the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs. - -Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -8 - - About the fresh food compartment shelves. - -Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves. -Not all features are on all models. - -2 Lift up and out - -1 Tilt up - -Half-Width Shelves - -One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall -support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track -on the rear cabinet wall. - -To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support -and out of the track. - -To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front -raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track, -then lower the shelf onto the support. - -NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to -hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is -designed to hook into the left-hand slot. - -Full-Width Shelves - -Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary -tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves. -These shelves can be moved to another place in the -fresh food compartment. - -The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed -correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before -coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not -tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it. - -To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf -and pull forward. - -To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food -compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of -the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it -out. - -9 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - About the freezer compartment shelves. - -Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf. - -Plug Supports - -Ice-Tray Shelf - -To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf -off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of -the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the -pins from the holes in the cabinet wall. - -(cid:49) - -(cid:50) - -Step Shelf - -To remove the step shelf: - -1 -2 - -3 - -Lift left side of shelf slightly. - -Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes -in the cabinet wall. - -Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and -take it out. - -To replace the step shelf: - -1 - -2 - -With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into -holes in cabinet wall. - -Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right -ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower -shelf into place. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -10 - - About the storage drawers. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Fruit and Vegetable Drawers - -Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the -drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry. - -Utility Drawer - -The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful -location for your family’s needs. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -11 - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -12 - -About storage drawer and cover removal. - -Not all features are on all models. - -Drawer and Cover Removal - -Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to -help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers -can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly -while pulling drawers past the stoplocation. - -Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover - -To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it -forward, tilt it and take it out. - -Twin Drawer With Glass Cover - -To remove: - -1 -2 - -Remove the drawers. - -Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the -same time, pull it forward as far as it will come. - -Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover -with hot water because the extreme temperature -difference may cause it to break. - -3 - -Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass -cover before you take out the drawer frame.) - -Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back, -pull it forward, tilt it and take it out. - -To replace: - -Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each -side and back. - -Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly -into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the -front into place. - -Replace the drawers. - -1 - -2 - -3 - - About the automatic icemaker. - -A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice. - -Icemaker - -Feeler arm -in the STOP -(up) position - -Ice Storage Bin - -Automatic Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle— -approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period, -depending on freezer compartment temperature, room -temperature, number of door openings and other use -conditions. - -If the refrigerator is operated before the water -connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm -in the STOP (up) position. - -Feeler arm in the -ON (down) position - -When the refrigerator has been connected to the water -supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position. - -The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to -freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 -hours to begin making ice cubes. - -Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water -line to clear. - -Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler -arm. - -It is normal for several cubes to be joined together. - -If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become -cloudy and taste stale. - -Icemaker Accessory Kit - -If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an -automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra -cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit -needed for your model. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -13 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Cleaning the Outside - -The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth -dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth. - -Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened -with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and -polish with a clean, soft cloth. - -Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may -leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered -cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can -scratch and weaken the paint finish. - -Cleaning the Inside - -To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh -food and freezer compartments. - -Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring -excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around -switches, lights or controls. - -Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans -and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry. - -Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the -doors. - -After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly -to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets -from sticking and bending out of shape. - -Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the -extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves -carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter. - -Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -14 - - Under the Refrigerator - -For most efficient operation, keep the area under the -refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to -OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust. - -Clean the condenser coils at least -once a year. - -For best results, use a brush specially designed for this -purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores. - -Behind the Refrigerator - -Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All -types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned -coverings and those with embossed surfaces. - -Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator -counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull -the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it -straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in -damage to the floor covering or refrigerator. - -When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power -cord or icemaker supply line (on some models). - -After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise -until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -15 - - Care and cleaning of the refrigerator. - -Light Bulb Replacement - -To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its -electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an -appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage. - -Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit. - -Preparing for Vacation - -For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the -refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position, -and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon -(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the -doors open. - -Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut -off the water supply to the refrigerator. - -If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified -servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent -serious property damage due to flooding. - -Preparing to Move - -Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping -them securely in place to prevent damage. - -Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -16 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models) - -If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an -icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line. - -A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings -and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from -Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -Refrigerator Location - -Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below -60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain -proper temperatures. - -Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded. - -Clearances - -Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air -circulation and plumbing and electrical connections: -3/4† (19 mm) -1† (25 mm) -1† (25 mm) - -Sides - -Back - -Top - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -17 - - Preparing to install the refrigerator. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Rollers and Leveling Legs - -Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They -firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are -opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just -enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway. - -Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to -lower it. - -Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the -wall for cleaning. - -Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred -from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the -legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -18 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Before You Begin -This water line installation is not warranted by the -refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these -instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive -water damage. - -Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house -plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead -to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to -correct water hammer before installing the water supply -line to the refrigerator. - -To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the -water line to the hot water line. - -If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water -line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP -(up) position. - -Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where -temperatures fall below freezing. - -When using any electrical device (such as a power drill) -during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired -in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock. - -All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing -code requirements. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -19 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -What You Will Need -To determine how much copper tubing you need: - -Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the -refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm). -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) -coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow -the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. -n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and -fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer -or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002. - -n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between - -20 and 120 p.s.i. - -n Power drill. - -n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to -the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square. - -Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is -under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle -with age and crack, resulting in water leakage. - -n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)— - -to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the -refrigerator water valve. - -n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will - -need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect -the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared -fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting. -n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve -should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of -5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle- -type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before -purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your -local plumbing codes. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -20 - - Shut Off the Main Water Supply - -Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water. - -Install the Shutoff Valve -1 -2 - -Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line. - -Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect -into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a -horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at -the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe. -Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs -resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe. - -3 - -4 -5 - -Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp. - -Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell. - -Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing. - -Pipe Clamp - -Washer - -Inlet End - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Vertical Cold Water Pipe - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -21 - - Installing the water line. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve - -Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator. - -Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the -refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible. - -Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about -10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and -connect it to the shutoff valve. - -Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut -securely. - -Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve - -Compression Nut - -Packing -Nut - -Outlet Valve - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing -1 - -Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water -is clear. - -2 - -Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has -been flushed through the tubing. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -22 - - Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator - -Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the -refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet. - -We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles -that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water -line near the refrigerator. - -1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve. - -Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as -shown. - -Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as -possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting. - -Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical -position. You may need to pry open the clamp. - -1/4† Copper Tubing - -Tubing Clamp - -Ferrule (sleeve) - -1/4† Compression Nut - -Refrigerator Connection - -Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve - -Tighten any connections that leak. - -Plug In the Refrigerator - -Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of -the refrigerator or against the wall. - -Push the refrigerator back to the wall. - -Start the Icemaker - -Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will -not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.) -or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm -is in the ON(down) position. - -NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from -the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again. - -23 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - Reversing the door swing. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Important Notes -When reversing the door swing : - -n Read the instructions all the way through before starting. -n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint. -n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the - -wrong places. - -n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors. -IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until -door-swing reversal is completed. - -These instructions are for changing the hinges from the -right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the -hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions -and reverse all references to left and right. - -Tools Required -n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver -n Masking tape -n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires -n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver -n 5/16† open-end wrench -n Phillips screwdriver - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -24 - - Removing the doors. - -Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet. - -Before Removing the Doors -1 -2 -CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could -damage the door stop. - -Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment. - -Remove the Freezer Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the -top hinge to the cabinet. - -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin -from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws. - -Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the -door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge -bracket. - -Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal. - -Top Hinge - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -25 - - Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Remove the Fresh Food Door -1 -2 - -Tape the door shut with masking tape. -Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench, -remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to -the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of -the door, and set hinge and screws aside. - -3 - -4 -5 - -6 - -Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from -the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door -bottom, put it back on the hinge.) - -Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface. - -Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the -cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal. - -Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw -hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough -space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket. - -Center Hinge Bracket - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left -1 - -Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight -out. - -2 - -Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to -it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side. - -Plastic Washer - -Hinge Bracket - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -26 - - Reversing the door handles. - -Transfer Top Hinge to the Left - -Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws -at top left of cabinet. - -Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time. - -Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge -depends on which side you install the hinge. - -Installing the hinge on the left. - -Installing the hinge on the right. - -Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle - -Top View - -Bottom View - -1 - -2 - -3 -4 - -Remove the bottom cap by -pushing it toward the bottom of -the door and remove the screw +Forms are the moulds into which concrete or +another material is poured. + +Formwork is a system of forms connected +together. + +Gangforms are large panels designed to be hoisted +as a unit, and to be erected, stripped, and re-used. + +Knock-down forms are traditional formwork +supported by falsework and shoring, assembled +from bulk materials, used once, and then +dismantled. + +Panels are sections of form intended to be +connected together. + +Sheathing is the material directly supported by +wales, and against which concrete is to be placed. + +Specialty formwork is designed specifically for a +particular structure or placing technique. + +Struts are vertical members of shoring that directly +resist pressure from wales. + +Wales are horizontal members of shoring that are +placed against sheathing to directly resist pressure +from the sheathing. + +Introduction + +In most cases, the formwork required for concrete +construction is built by carpenters. Shoring and +bracing support the forms that contain the wet +concrete. Formwork must also support the temporary +weight of material such as bundles of reinforcing +steel and live loads of workers and equipment. + +There are three stages in formwork operations: + +1. Assembly and erection + +2. Concrete placement + +3. Stripping and dismantling. + +To be done safely, each of these jobs requires +planning, knowledge, and skill from both +supervisors and workers. Design and planning +are a supervisory function that may also legally +require a professional engineer’s involvement. +Small construction and renovation jobs, however, +sometimes call for typical design work (e.g., +specific heights and sizes from the manufacturer), +which can be done on site by workers. + +Where design drawings are provided, it is +important to construct the formwork as designed. +Any confusion regarding the design should be +approved by the designer. + +If site conditions require changes or the design +does not seem to suit the situation, changes +and approval should also be obtained from the +designer. Formwork failures frequently involve +deviations from the original design that were done +without consulting the designer. They may also +involve human error. For these reasons, formwork +and shoring must always be inspected before +concrete is placed. + +All large formwork installations in Ontario must be +designed by a professional engineer. But there are +always smaller jobs of moderate height or depth— +basements, footings, stairs—that may include +formwork with typical design arrangements from +a form tie manufacturer, which is installed and +constructed on the site. + +Every carpenter should therefore know the type +of formwork needed and how to build, install, and +dismantle it safely. + +Formwork must always be constructed according +to good, safe, and sound carpentry practice. It must +have the following: + +• Adequate braces and supports + +• Reliable bearing surfaces, especially where wood + +structures are involved + +• Adequate ties, bolts, or bracing to prevent + +movement or bulging. + +Because wood is relatively soft, it will crush under +heavy loads such as concrete when the bearing +surface of joists on stringers, or studs on wales, is +not adequate. + +Crushing can be avoided by increasing the bearing +area between members, using spreader washers +(Figure 42-1), or increasing the number of joists +or studs. + +Figure 42-1: Spreader Washer on +Wooden Wale System + +Tools and Techniques + +42-1 + + FORMWORK + +Hazards + +The following are the main hazard areas in +formwork operations. + +• Falls – They are the major hazard because they are +potentially fatal. Cramped work areas, inadequate +access, failure to install guardrails, failure to use fall +arrest systems, tools or material left underfoot, and +surfaces slippery from form oil can all lead to falls. +Ladders are also frequently involved in falls. All +workers in Ontario who may be exposed to a fall +hazard and who may use a fall protection system +must have working at heights training that has been +approved by the Chief Prevention Officer. (See +Chapter 18: Guardrails and Chapter 19: Personal +Fall Protection) + +• Dust and concrete – Blowing dust and flying + +concrete particles during the chipping or cleaning +of formwork can injure unprotected eyes. + +• Access equipment – Access equipment such as +ladders and scaffolds is involved not only in falls +but in slips, trips, and other accidents. Hazards +include ladders not tied off, workers carrying +materials while climbing, ladders obstructed at +top or bottom, scaffolds not completely decked +in, and scaffolds erected or dismantled without +fall protection. + +• Lighting – Inadequate lighting can create or + +aggravate hazards when workers install or strip +forms in dark areas or place concrete at night. + +• Materials handling – The activity most frequently + +Injuries + +connected with injury. Improper or excessive +materials handling can result in sprains, strains, +and overexertion in shoulders, arms, and back, as +well as bruises, abrasions, and crushed fingers. + +• Struck against – Common because formwork + +operations are constantly changing and involve +the movement of heavy, awkward, and pointed +components. Wales, beams, panels, snap-ties, +nails, bolts, and rebar can cause punctures, cuts, +contusions, and abrasions. + +• Struck by – Another common cause of injury. +Rebar, formwork panels, concrete buckets, +and other material hoisted overhead can strike +workers. Struck-by injuries can also be caused by +hammers, pry bars, stakes, wedges, and material +such as joists and panels during stripping. + +• Electrical contact – Power tools, extension cords, +and temporary supply and wiring systems, used +under less-than-ideal conditions – mud, ground +water, wet excavations, fresh concrete – can lead +to ground faults, shortcircuits, and shock hazards. +Ground fault circuit interrupters are legally +required for portable tools used outdoors or in +wet locations. + +• Collapses – Even with advanced methods of + +design and installation, there is always the risk +that formwork, slabforms, wall forms, and other +large components can come loose, slip out of +place, or fall over, striking or crushing workers underneath. -Remove the two screws holding -the handle to the top of the door. - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screws from the right -edge of the door top and insert -them into the handle screw holes -on the opposite side. - -5 - -6 - -With tape-tipped putty knife or -thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the -plug button from the hinge hole -on the left side of the door and -insert it into the hole on the -opposite side that was vacated by -removal of the top hinge. - -Pull the plug button from the -front of the door and transfer it to -the opposite side. - -Plug Button - -Screws for -Handle Holes - -Plug Button - -To reattach the handle on the -opposite side. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -27 - - Rehanging the doors. - -Read these instructions completely and carefully. - -Transfer Door Stop -1 - -Move the metal door stop from -the right end to the left end. Use a -Torxdriver. - -Door Stop - -2 - -Move any screws from the left end -to the right end. - -Right Side - -Left Side - -Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle -1 - -Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and -under the handle plug. - -Reinstall the handle plug. - -2 -Transfer Freezer Door Handle -1 - -Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two -screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door. - -2 -3 - -4 - -5 -6 - -Remove the handle. - -Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the -handle screw hole on the left side. - -Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the -opposite side. - -Transfer the door stop as shown above. - -Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and -bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws. - -Left Side - -Right Side - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -28 - - Rehang the Fresh Food Door -1 - -Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom -hinge. - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -2 - -3 - -Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door. -NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the -left side. - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide -the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven -into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both -screws securely. - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic -Washer - -Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -Rehang the Freezer Door -1 - -Be sure the washer is in place on the pin. - -Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin. - -2 - -3 - -Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the -socket on the top of the door. - -Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even -across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these -screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one- -half turn. - -Center Hinge Pin - -Plastic Washer - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -29 - - Normal operating sounds. - -Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen, -you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under -the refrigerator to reduce noise. - -The fan circulating air inside the freezer which -keeps the temperatures even. - -Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of -refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils. - -Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water -dropping on the defrost heater during the -defrost cycle. - -Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils -expanding and contracting during the -defrosting cycle. - -Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator -and flows to the drain pan during the defrost -cycle. - -Icemaker (on some models) - -The icemaker water valve will buzz when the -icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in -the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has -not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the -feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is -hooked up to water can damage the icemaker. -To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP -(up) position. This will stop the buzzing. - -The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and -water running in pipes as icemaker refills. - -These sounds are normal -and are due mostly to highly -efficient operation. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -30 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips -Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and -you may not need to call for service. - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Refrigerator does not -operate - -Refrigerator in -defrost cycle. - -Temperature control -dial in OFFposition. - -Refrigerator is -unplugged. - -The fuse is blown/ -circuit breaker is -tripped. - -Normal when -refrigerator is first -plugged in. - -Often occurs when large -amounts of food are -placed in refrigerator. - -Door left open. - -• Wait about 30 minutes for - -defrost cycle to end. - -• Move the temperature - -control dial to a -temperature setting. - -• Push the plug completely - -into the outlet. - -• Replace fuse or reset the - -breaker. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• This is normal. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Hot weather or frequent -door openings. - -• This is normal. - -Temperature control dial -set at the coldest setting. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Grille and condenser -need cleaning. - -Front roller screws or -front leveling legs need -adjusting. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -• See Rollers and leveling legs. - -Motor operates for long -periods or cycles on and -off frequently. (Modern -refrigerators with more -storage space and a larger -freezer require more -operating time. They start -and stop often to maintain -even temperatures.) - -Vibration or rattling -(slight vibration is normal) - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -31 - - Before you call for service… - -Troubleshooting Tips - -Problem - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Fresh food or freezer -compartment too warm - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -Warm weather or -frequent door openings. - -Door left open. - -Package blocking air -duct in freezer -compartment. - -Door left open. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -• Set the temperature -control dial one step -colder. See About the -temperature control dial. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -• Check to see if package is - -blocking air duct in freezer -compartment. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Icemaker feeler arm in -STOP (up) position. - -• Move the feeler arm to the - -ON (down) position. - -Water supply turned -off or not connected. - -Freezer compartment -too warm. - -Water shutoff valve -connecting refrigerator -to water line may be -clogged. - -• See Installing thewater line. - -• Wait 24 hours for the - -refrigerator to completely -cool down. - -• Call a plumber to clear - -the valve. - -Frost or ice crystals on -frozen food (frost within -package is normal) - -Automatic icemaker -does not work -(on some models) - -Cubes too small - -Slow ice cube freezing - -Door left open. - -• Check to see if package is - -holding door open. - -Temperature control -dial not set cold enough. - -• See About the temperature - -control dial. - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -32 - - Problem - -Ice cubes have -odor/taste - -Possible Causes - -What To Do - -Ice storage bin needs -cleaning. - -• Empty and wash bin. -Discard old cubes. - -Food transmitting odor/ -taste to ice cubes. - -Interior of refrigerator -needs cleaning. - -• Wrap foods well. - -• See Care andcleaning. - -Moisture forms on -cabinet surface -between the doors - -Moisture collects inside -(in humid weather, air -carries moisture into -refrigerator when doors -are opened) - -Refrigerator has odor - -Not unusual during -periods of high -humidity. - -Too frequent or too -long door openings. - -Foods transmitting -odor to refrigerator. - -• Wipe surface dry and - -reset temperature control -dial one setting colder. - -• Foods with strong odors - -should be tightly wrapped. -• Keep an open box of baking -soda in the refrigerator; -replace every three months. - -Interior needs cleaning. - -• See Care and cleaning. - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -33 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -34 - - S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - -35 - - Notes - -n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -36 - - GE Service Protection Plus™ - -GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability, -offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on -all your appliances—No Matter What Brand! - -Benefits Include: -• Backed by GE -• All brands covered -• Unlimited service calls -• All parts and labor costs included -• No out-of-pocket expenses -• No hidden deductibles -• One 800 number to call - -We’ll Cover Any Appliance. -Anywhere. Anytime.* - -You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your -money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple. - -Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much -more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly -financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered. -You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected -against expensive repairs. - -Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224 -for more information. - -*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S. - -" - -Cut here - -Please place in envelope and mail to: - -General Electric Company -Warranty Registration Department -P.O. Box 34070 -Louisville, KY 40232-4070 - -37 - - Consumer Product Ownership Registration -Dear Customer: -Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us. -We are proud to have you as a customer! +• Health hazards – The spraying of form oils and + +curing compounds can irritate the lungs. Contact +with these chemicals can irritate the skin, leading +to redness, inflammation, or dermatitis. The +same conditions can result from the abrasive/ +corrosive effect of skin contact with concrete or +cement, especially when inadvertently left inside +boots all day. + +• Environmental conditions – Ice, snow, and rain +create slippery conditions. Wind can be a major +hazard. Handling sheets of plywood becomes +more difficult, panels may require more bracing, +and hoisting gets harder, especially with large +panels or tables. + +Formwork hazards can lead to the injuries +described below. Follow the safety tips to prevent +such injuries. + +• Eye injuries – These are quite common in + +formwork operations. Most result from particles +of wood or concrete that fall or are blown into +the eye during chipping and cleaning. The injuries +may not be severe but most can be prevented +by wearing eye protection. It is strongly +recommended that everyone on site wear eye +protection at all times. + +• Cuts, scrapes, punctures – The manhandling + +necessary to install and strip formwork can lead +to cut hands, arms, and legs, as well as pinched +or crushed fingers. Gloves help to prevent +injuries from rough or sharp edges on formwork +components. But workers must also have the +knowledge, skill, and physical ability necessary +for safe materials handling. That means knowing +your limitations and asking for help when needed. +Formwork involves protruding objects such as +nails, snap ties, conduit, and bolts that can give +you cuts and punctures. Where possible, these +objects should not be left sticking out or should +be covered over. + +• Back injuries – These injuries are frequently + +related to materials handling. The most important +preventive measure is back care. Exercise +programs, warm-ups before work, and knowing +your limitations can help to prevent sprains and +strains. Wherever necessary, get help or use +dollies, carts, or other mechanical devices. + +• Ankle sprains and fractures – Working in +close quarters, stepping over debris and +material, climbing into excavations, turning with +awkward loads, jumping down from scaffolds +or benches—these can lead to ankle and other +foot or leg injuries. Prevention starts with proper +housekeeping and materials handling. + +• Bruises and contusions – Handling formwork + +under rushed, cramped, or slippery conditions or +beyond a person's physical limitations can lead to +bruises. Bruises and contusions also result from +contact with protruding formwork components. + +42-2 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +More serious are contusions from falling formwork +materials. Formwork must be braced to ensure +stability, especially under windy conditions. Try +to avoid areas where work such as hoisting or +stripping is being done overhead. + +• Fall injuries – All of the injuries above, and many +others, can result from falls. Most falls are caused +by missing or inadequate guardrails, failure to use +fall-arrest equipment, failure to completely plank +scaffolds and other work platforms, and standing +or climbing on surfaces not meant to be used as +such – the tops of wall forms or 2 x 4 wales, for +example. Installing and stripping formwork often +requires the use of a fall-arrest system. + +• Falls also result from holes left unguarded or + +uncovered in formwork. These should be covered +up or fitted with guardrails as quickly as possible. +Where this cannot be done, the area should +be roped off and posted with warning signs to +prevent unauthorized entry. + +Planning + +Planning is the first and most important step in +reducing hazards and preventing injuries. + +Because formwork operations must often be +carried out in congested areas where other trades +are also working, planning is essential in making the +most of the time and space available to improve +safety and efficiency. + +Planning is a must for fall protection, work +platforms, material staging areas, housekeeping, +and material handling and movement. + +Planning should take place at every level from +manager to supervisor to worker. Planning labour, +materials, equipment, and work schedules to +meet design requirements is the responsibility of +management and supervision. But supervisors and +workers should come together to plan the details +of their assigned tasks based on the most effective +work methods and safety measures. + +For example, the normal weight of liquid concrete +is 150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre). +So a form designed to withstand 600 lb per square +feet (2929 kg per square metre) of pressure will be +able to support liquid concrete up to a height of 4 +feet (1.2 metres). + +600 lb/ft2 ÷ 150 lb/ft3 = 4 ft + +2929 kg/m2 ÷ 2403 kg/m3 = 1.2 m + +Other factors determine how long concrete +will remain liquid, such as temperature, slump, +vibration, and admixtures. For example, concrete +will set much more quickly in hot summer weather +than in cold winter weather. As a result, the same +form filled at the same pour rate may be subjected +to greater pressure in winter than in summer. + +Concrete pumping may cause additional pressure, +as well as vibration, on forms and must be +considered at the design stage. The action of the +pump sends surges of pressure through the piping +system which are often transmitted directly to +the forms, especially for narrow walls or columns. +Vibration may move the forms or loosen bracing, +ties, or spreaders. + +Pressure acts perpendicular to formwork surfaces +(Figure 42-2). This causes an outward thrust for +typical wall or column forms. However, it can also +cause uplift for battered or sloping forms. These +require hold-down anchors or tie-down braces. The +anchors will prevent the forms from lifting up or +floating on the concrete. + +Expansion Anchors Holding +Down Battered Form + +Design + +Safety and economy are the main factors in design. +Both have to be considered because adjustments in +one affect the other. + +For example, reducing the support structure for +wall forms in expectation of reduced pouring rates +should not be considered if the rate of pour is not +going to be controlled on the job. + +Fresh concrete exerts a pressure on formwork +similar to liquids. Concrete starts to set when +poured. So if the pour rate is slow, the maximum +formwork design pressure can be reduced, since +concrete at the bottom will be set before concrete +at the top is poured. Similarly, if the forms are +filled to the top immediately, they must be able to +withstand the pressure of the full liquid head. + +Figure 42-2: Pressure of Concrete on +Vertical (left) and Battered Formwork + +Consider using bracing systems and spreaders for +wall forms. Concrete filling the bottom of the form +may cause forces at the top to push the two sides +together unless they are properly braced and/ +or separated with spreaders. Formwork has to be +designed to resist such forces. During pouring, +ensure that spreaders are not removed until concrete +has reached at least two-thirds of the form height. + +Where box forms are used—for instance, on one- +piece covers for open-cut tunnels—you must use +bracing against the side thrusts caused by the +uneven pouring rates of the walls. Resisting these +forces requires that the system be tied together +and securely braced (Figure 42-3). + +Tools and Techniques + +42-3 + + FORMWORK + +Figure 42-3: Open-Cut Tunnel Formwork with +Bracing and Spreaders on Each Side + +Formwork should be designed and constructed +with stripping and removing as well as pouring in +mind. On wooden forms, crush plates or filler strips +should be used at corners such as slab-and-column +or slab-and-wall intersections (Figure 42-4). The +plates or strips are easily removed with a wrecking +bar and, once removed, make the stripping of +adjacent panels much easier. + +Crush Plates + +Figure 42-5: Formwork Panel + +A formwork panel or wall form to be lifted as a +single unit must be designed to withstand the +loads and forces exerted by hoisting (Figure +42-6). In most cases, this means designing a more +substantial structure. Fastening components may +also need more attention at the design stage. For +example, simple nailing may not be enough to hold +plywood sheets. + +Figure 42-4: Crush Plates + +The strips should be big enough to leave space at +the edges of the panels to accommodate wrecking +bars. + +When formwork has to be manhandled during +assembly or dismantling, the design should ensure +that the components are manageable. Formwork +panels are not only heavy but awkward (Figure +42-5). Realistic design demands consideration of +the size as well as the weight of panels. + +Figure 42-6: Formwork Lifted as Single Unit + +Special attention must also be applied to the design, +construction, and use of pick points for hoisting. The +strongbacks and wales must be securely attached +to the formwork. The pick points must be located +so that the panel hangs properly during installation, +concrete placement, and removal. + +42-4 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +Types of Formwork + +Below Grade + +The first concern with formwork below grade is +the stability of the excavation walls. Walls must be +either shored or sloped according to soil type as +defined by section 226 of the Construction Projects +regulation (O.Reg. 213/91). Figure 42-7 shows +typical slopes. + +Good Soil + +Fairly +Good Soil + +Max 1.2m + +(4 ft.) + +Type 1 & 2 Soil + +Type 3 Soil + +Poor Soil + +Type 4 Soil + +Figure 42-7: Excavation Slopes for Soil Types + +In most cases the shoring must be designed by an +engineer. Engineers may also specify slopes for +excavations. In both instances the design drawings +must be kept on the project. + +Excavations should be kept essentially dry. Water +should be pumped out. Mud should be cleared off +and replaced by compacted granular material in +work areas and on surfaces where concrete will be +placed. Mud presents slipping hazards and can lead +to inferior construction if not removed or replaced. + +Since mud has to be removed before concrete +is placed, it might as well be removed before +formwork is constructed, thereby reducing slipping +hazards at both stages. + +Water and mud also contribute to electrical +hazards. Grounding and insulation must be +effective and intact. Ground fault circuit +interrupters (GFCIs) are required by law on all +portable tools used outdoors or in wet locations. + +Formwork for footings and grade walls frequently +begins before excavation in the area is complete. +Trucks and excavating equipment put workers on +foot at the risk of being struck down or run over. + +Wherever possible, formwork operations should +be roped off from other work such as excavation +or pile-driving (Figure 42-8). Separate access +ramps for vehicles and workers are strongly +recommended. Stairs are an even better alternative +for personnel on foot. + +Figure 42-8: Formwork Roped-Off +from Other Operations + +Mud sills must be used to support any shoring or +bracing that rests on soil in the excavation (Figure +42-9). The sill must bear on the soil throughout its +length. Sills should not be used to bridge holes or +irregular surfaces. To ensure uniform bearing, soil +should be levelled before sills are set in position. + +Figure 42-9: Mud Sills Under Shoring Frames + +The soil must have the capacity to bear whatever +loads are applied (Table 42-1). This information +may or may not be on the design drawings. + +Table 42-1: In Situ Bearing +Pressure for Dry Soil Conditions +(Conservative Estimates) + + Silt and clay + Sands + Gravelly sands + Gravel + +1,200 lb/ft2 (5,859 kg/m2) +4,000 lb/ft2 (19,530 kg/m2) +6,000 lb/ft2 (29,295 kg/m2) +8,000 lb/ft2 (39,059 kg/m2) + +Tools and Techniques + +42-5 + + FORMWORK + +Soil that supports bracing or shoring should +be compacted and qualify as good soil at least +(cohesive, hard, with no water). Professional advice +from a geotechnical engineer may be required +for heavy structures such as elevated equipment +supports shored at or below grade. + +Formwork in these situations is frequently built in +place. Planning is required to store material and +equipment out of the way, dispose of scrap and +debris, and ensure safe, efficient access (Figure +42-10). Because conditions are often cramped and +scrap accumulates quickly, it is important to clean +up as work proceeds. + +Starting the Form + +Setting up the first form is always hard, heavy, +manual work. It requires enough workers to do +the job without overexertion or injury. Whenever +possible, use mechanical assistance such as a boom, +truck, or crane for this operation. It will reduce the +risk of injury to workers and increase productivity. + +Temporary bracing (Figure 42-12) is needed from the +start and at every step to prevent wind loads from +toppling the forms—historically the cause of many +serious injuries. A wind speed as low as 30 km/h can +create a dangerous wind load on formwork. + +Figure 42-10: Well-Planned Storage, +Access, and Setup + +Wall Forms + +Wall forms built in place are hazardous to +construct. Hazards include + +• Dowels sticking up from concrete slabs or + +footings + +• Unstable work surfaces and access created by + +poor planning + +• Manual handling of heavy material such as + +plywood sheets, panels, wales, and buckets of +snap-ties, wedges, and plates + +• Slippery surfaces at and below grade + +• Inadequate design + +• Improper construction. + +The best protection against dowels is a wood +cover built of lumber at least 1 1/2 inches thick and +wired in place or protective caps placed over the +exposed ends of rebar (Figure 42-11). + +Figure 42-12: Temporary Bracing at +Start of Form Construction + +Access to wall forms is not always given enough +thought. Forms more than 2 metres high will +require access platforms for workers involved in +concrete placing. The platforms can also be used +to complete the upper portion of the formwork. + +An alternative is a frame scaffold, which can also +be used to install reinforcing steel (Figure 42-13). + +Figure 42-11: Protective Covers +Over Dowels and Rebar + +42-6 + +Figure 42-13: Scaffolding for Access + +Construction Health and Safety Manual Fall arrest systems or scaffolds with guardrails +must be used where workers may fall more than +3 m (10 ft), or onto hazards such as projecting +dowels (Figure 42-14). In some circumstances, you +must use fall protection when the height is 2.4 m +(8 ft) or more. (See chapters on Guardrails and +Personal Fall Protection.) + +FORMWORK + +Figure 42-15: Formwork Properly Tied and Braced + +Recommended design pressures for various pour +rates and environmental conditions are set out +in CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework and Formwork. +The standard defines a number of other design +considerations and should be consulted by field staff. + +Slab Forms or Falsework Built in Place + +With slab forms built in place the major hazard is +falls. Injuries are also connected with the manual +handling of heavy materials and components. + +Forms built in place usually have to be taken +down in place after the concrete has hardened +sufficiently. This should be considered at the +construction stage. Stability may also be a +consideration where the structure is high, carries +heavy loads, and is placed on grade as in bridge +and overpass construction. + +Fall protection is difficult to provide for workers +building slab forms in place. That’s why planning is +essential in the design and erection procedure. + +Workers should wear a safety harness with the +lanyard tied off to the structure of the formwork +(Figure 42-16). This means tying off to the support +structure where shoring frame structures are being +constructed, tying off to a lifeline when placing +plywood panels at a leading edge, constructing +a guardrail at the edge of the formwork, or tying +off to the support structure when connecting it +together with tube and clamp. Don’t wait for the +structure to be completed before tying-off. + +Figure 42-14: Workers Wear Fall Arrest While +Attaching Wales to Threaded Rods + +Materials should be distributed along the work +location to minimize further handling. But traffic +and work areas must be kept clear for the safe +movement and installation of material. + +Form Construction + +Wall forms must be constructed as designed. +The design must indicate clearly what is required. +Some wall forms are designed for specific concrete +placement rates expressed in metres of height per +hour (m/hr). A wall form in which concrete is +placed to a height of one metre in one hour would +have a placement rate of 1 m/hr. Slower pouring +rates result in lower formwork pressure because +the bottom concrete has started to set. + +Note: Using a concrete vibrator will increase the +liquid (hydraulic) pressure on the form in the +immediate area of the vibration. Over-vibrating the +concrete while increasing the pour rate can cause +the formwork to fail. + +Ensure that ties and braces are installed where +indicated on design drawings. Ties should be +snugged up. Braces should be securely fastened to +forms and wedged or fastened to a support that +will not settle or deform under load (Figure 42-15). + +Formwork platforms must be: + +• Capable of bearing at least 50 lb/ft2 + +• Adequately supported + +• Equipped with guardrails + +• Secured at the level or levels where work such as + +pouring and stripping will be done. + +Figure 42-16: Workers Tie Off to +Shoring Frames While Placing Stringers + +Tools and Techniques + +42-7 + + FORMWORK + +Make sure you have fall protection at all stages of +formwork construction. Wherever possible, cranes or +other equipment should be used to move material, +thereby reducing the amount of manual carrying, +lifting, and handling. + +Shoring towers require special consideration. + +• Towers must remain stable during construction +and dismantling. Guys or other bracing and +supports may be necessary to maintain stability +(Figure 42-17). + +• If towers are to be tied together and braced +horizontally, this should be done as work +progresses (Figure 42-18). + +• Shoring towers and shores should be installed so + +they are plumb to within 1/8 inch in 3 feet. + +• Shoring towers should be snugged up under the + +stringers with adjustable base plates and U-heads +(Figure 42-19). + +• If frames do not ride tightly on top of one + +another after tightening, one or more are out of +square and should be replaced (Figure 42-20). + +• With single-post shores, provide adequate lateral +bracing (Figure 42-21). Stairwells and balconies +are places where horizontal bracing for single- +post shoring systems may be required. + +Figure 42-19: Typical Shoring Tower with +Stringers, Adjustable Base Plates, and U-Heads + +Replace this frame. + +Figure 42-17: High Towers with Guys for Support + +Figure 42-20: Frame Bent Out of Shape + +Figure 42-18: Towers Tied +Together and Braced Horizontally + +Figure 42-21: Single-Post +Shores with Lateral Bracing + +42-8 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK + +Using forms designed for typical floors in non- +typical situations has resulted in serious accidents. +Before using any flying form under non-typical +conditions, consult the designer or manufacturer. +Wall forms should not be extended in height or +width, for instance, or slab panels cantilevered +without the review and approval of a professional +engineer. Such situations usually occur with +penthouses or mechanical rooms where wall and +ceiling heights are greater than for typical floors. + +Other hazards with flying forms include the +following. + +• Stability during initial fabrication + +• Fill-in work between slab panels + +• Wind and fall hazards during flying operations + +• Stripping, flying, and re-setting. + +Although a flying form is designed to be stable +when complete, it may not be stable during +fabrication or erection. Temporary bracing or +temporary support by a crane may be necessary +to ensure stability during certain phases of the +operation (Figure 42-24). + +Figure 42-22: Two Rows of Shoring Frames with +Row of Shoring Posts in Centre + +Frequently, supports for built-in-place forms are +deliberately left out to allow other work to be +done. One example might be a row of single-post +shores left out until work below is complete. Or, +an area might be supported temporarily during +construction by a few single-post shores that will +be replaced later by a shoring tower. + +In these and other instances of incomplete +formwork, heavy temporary loads such as bundles +of rebar or stacks of plywood should not be placed +on the structure. Even on completed formwork, +make sure that landed material will not overload +the structure. + +Before placing concrete, the formwork must be +inspected and approved by a professional engineer +or their designate. Keep a copy of this inspection +and approval on the site in case an inspector asks +to see it. + +Flying Forms + +Flying forms must always be designed by a +professional engineer and constructed, hoisted, +moved, and set strictly according to the +instructions of the designer or manufacturer. + +Figure 42-24: Temporary Support of Shoring +System for Flying Wall Form + +One example is setting up trusses for a flying slab +formwork table. The trusses must be held upright +to be connected or disconnected. If not adequately +supported, they can fall over on workers. + +Trusses and wall panels have also been blown over +by wind during fabrication and dismantling. Set- +up procedures should indicate the maximum wind +speed where the flying form operation can be done +safely. This wind speed should be determined by the +professional engineer who designed the system. + +Work with flying forms requires adequate space +for stacking materials and components. Working in +cramped quarters is not only difficult but hazardous. + +Figure 42-23: Flying Forms + +Tools and Techniques + +42-9 + + FORMWORK + +Fall Protection + +A fall arrest system should be used by any worker +who is at risk of falling when: + +• Installing a panel + +• Pushing a panel out toward the slab edge + +• Pulling a panel in from the slab edge (Figure + +42-24) + +• Helping other workers attach rigging hardware + +such as slings + +• Getting on and off + +• Bolting and unbolting wall forms for exterior walls + +and elevator shafts (Figure 42-25) + +• Stepping onto a panel to attach slings to pick + +points + +Figure 42-24: Fall Protection Required when +Receiving a Flying Form + +Figure 42-25: Attaching Chain Sling to Wall Form + +Each worker’s fall-arrest system must be attached +to an individual anchor independent of the flying +form. Contractors can provide for anchorage by +casting rebar anchors in columns or other areas to +be covered over or filled in later (Figure 42-26). +This type of anchorage must be approved by a +professional engineer. + +Figure 42-26: Rebar Anchor Cast in Concrete + +Safety Below Flying Forms + +The previous section covered the safety of workers +flying the forms. But precautions must also be +taken to protect workers below the hoisting +operation and the public at large, since forms are +often swung out over sidewalks and streets. The +Construction Projects regulation (213/91, s. 103(2)) +prohibits hoisting a load over the head of a person +who is not receiving the load or sinking a shaft. + +The most efficient protection for workers is to +fence or rope off the area below the flying form to +prevent anyone from entering the area. Pedestrian +traffic on sidewalks, as well as vehicle traffic if +necessary, should be detoured around the area +while hoisting is under way. + +Communication + +Flying forms are heavy, large, and awkward to +move. Hoisting and moving them safely requires +clear reliable communication. While hand signals +are often necessary and are still used, direct +radio or cell phone communication between the +signaller and the crane operator is more accurate +and effective. Relying on hand signals alone is not +recommended. + +Stripping + +Formwork stripping is probably the most +hazardous operation in concrete construction. +Hazards include the following. + +• Falling material + +• Waste material and equipment underfoot + +• Manual handling of heavy or awkward forms, + +panels, and other components + +• Prying forms loose from concrete presents risk of + +overexertion, lost balance, and slips and falls. + +42-10 + +Construction Health and Safety Manual Hazards can be reduced by + +• Planning and providing for stripping when + +designing and constructing formwork + +• Stripping as soon as it is permitted by the + +engineer + +• Supplying facilities and equipment for removing + +materials as they are stripped + +• Providing proper tools and adequate access for + +the stripping crew + +• Training personnel properly for this and other + +aspects of formwork. + +Forms can be designed with crush plates or filler +strips to facilitate removal at difficult intersections +of columns, beams, and wall forms. Later, formwork +oils should be used liberally to make stripping +easier. + +Wherever possible, waste materials, plywood, and +debris should be removed from the area as work +proceeds. This will reduce the need to walk over or +work around things left on floor or ground. + +Providing carts or cradles can help the crew +remove material and reduce the need for lifting +and carrying. Material on a cart can be rolled away. +Material in cradles can be hoisted off by a crane. + +Climbing partially stripped formwork is not +only hazardous but unnecessary. Safe access +such as rolling scaffolds or powered elevating +work platforms should be provided for stripping +formwork at elevated locations. + +Poor lighting may be a hazard in formwork +stripping in the early morning or late in the day +during certain times of the year. Mobile light +stands are probably the best solution, since pigtail +stringers can easily be knocked down and damaged +during stripping. + +Wherever possible, stripping crews should be +small. This is especially important with knock-down +systems. In small crews, the supervisor and each +worker can more easily keep track of what the +others are doing. Workers are not as likely to create +hazards for each other. Crews of two or three are +recommended for knock-down systems. If more +workers are required, they can still be divided into +small crews working in separate areas. + +Other trades and operations should not be allowed +in areas where stripping is under way. Given the +many hazards involved, the area should be fenced +or roped off and warning signs posted. + +Knock-Down Slab Systems + +Stripping these forms is physically difficult +because much of the work is overhead. The +usual arrangement involves shoring frames or a +combination of shoring frames and jacks. + +Wherever possible, the work should proceed +progressively from one side. That means taking out +one row of formwork supported by a row of stringers +on shoring frames. + +FORMWORK + +The first step is to back off the adjustable base plates +and U-heads in one area, which will in turn lower the +stringers, joists, and plywood (Figure 42-27). + +Figure 42-27: Lowering Base Plates +and U-Heads to Release Slab Form + +In practice, however, the plywood will stick to +the underside of the concrete, especially around +beams, column caps, and similar points. Wherever +possible, stuck sheets should be loosened and +removed before the shoring structure is dismantled. + +Stripping should proceed in reverse order to +erection. Plywood should be removed first, +followed by joists and stringers. The last items to +be removed are the shoring frames. + +When scaffold or shoring frames are used as a +work platform, it should be completely decked +in with planks (Figure 42-28). Otherwise planks +can shift and slide as workers pry or pull at stuck +pieces of formwork, lose their balance, and fall. This +has been a frequent cause of injuries. Temporary +guardrails may be required near the edge of the +structure or workers will need to use fall protection +during this operation. + +Figure 42-28: Shoring Frame +Fully Planked for Access + +Tools and Techniques + +42-11 + + FORMWORK + +The area where stripping starts should be planned +to allow access for taking away material as the +form is dismantled. + +Columns + +Check the following: + +Sound training, effective supervision, well- +designed safe access facilities, and immediate and +continuous cleanup can help reduce hazards in +stripping knock-down slab forms. + +Built-in-Place Wall Forms + +These forms are frequently of only moderate height. +Taller types usually make use of large panels erected +and removed by crane rather than hand. Built- +in-place wall forms are usually a stud-and-wale +system using some type of formwork ties. + +Where workers cannot reach the top of the wall, +scaffolding should be provided for removing wales +on the upper level. Safe access is essential for the +dismantling and manhandling of wales that are +frequently long, heavy, and waterlogged. + +Material should then be removed immediately to a +staging area. + +Inspection + +Before concrete placing begins, formwork must be +inspected and signed off by a professional engineer +or a competent person designated by the engineer +to ensure that it has been constructed to provide +for worker safety and to meet job specifications. + +A report must be completed by the person doing +the inspection stating whether the formwork has +been constructed according to the design. Any +discrepancies must be approved by the design +engineer before concrete placing proceeds. + +It is in everyone’s best interest to ensure that the +formwork has been inspected by a competent +person for workmanship, stability, and adherence +to design drawings and specifications. Inspection +should begin when the forms are being constructed +and continue until concrete placing is complete. + +Checking line and grade is best carried out while the +formwork is being constructed. Shoring structures +should be within the alignment limits specified on +the design drawings. Line and grade should also +be checked during the pour to determine whether +formwork is shifting or deflecting. + +Dimensions of special features like beams, column +capitals, and inserts are best checked at the time of +construction. If inspection is delayed until formwork +is completed, some details may be covered up or +become more difficult to check. + +• The proper size and type of materials are used + +• Column ties or column clamps are spaced + +according to design drawings + +• The spacing of ties or clamps is based on a + +sound assessment of concrete pressure (generally +columns are designed for a full liquid head of +150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre) +times height) + +• Columns are adequately braced where they are + +not tied in to a slab-form structure. + +NOTE: For more information on column formwork +pressures, refer to CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework +and Formwork or the American Concrete Institute +(ACI) standard Formwork for Concrete (SP-4). + +Wall Forms + +Check the following: + +• Materials and any manufactured components are as +specified in design drawings (size and spacing of +studs, wales, and ties are crucial to safety) + +• Ties are snugged up before concrete is placed + +• Wedges in wedged systems are tight + +• Nuts in threaded systems are tight + +• Bracing conforms to design drawings + +• Free-standing formwork is braced to ensure stability + +and resistance to loads during concrete placing + +• Specified pour rates are not exceeded (wall + +forms are often designed for specific pour rates; +exceeding these rates can cause failure or collapse). + +Slab Forms + +From a safety perspective, this is the most critical +type of formwork. The collapse of slab forms has +caused many injuries and deaths, whether from +flawed design (e.g., not considering the effect +of wind loading on the design), unauthorized +modifications in the field, or the failure to +inspect, which would have located and corrected +deficiencies. + +Competent inspection demands knowledge, +experience, and the ability to + +1) Distinguish between similar but different + +materials and shoring equipment + +2) Read and interpret design drawings + +3) + +Identify and clear up with the designer any +apparent or real discrepancies in components +such as shoring frames. -Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment: +42-12 -1 +Construction Health and Safety Manual FORMWORK -Complete and mail -your Consumer -Product Ownership -Registration today. -Have the peace of -mind of knowing -we can contact you -in the unlikely event of a safety -modification. +Check the following: -2 +Watch for the following warning signs: -After mailing -the registration -below, store this -document in a safe -place. It contains -information you -will need should +• Grade beams or mud sills supporting shoring are -you require service. Our -service number is 800 GE -CARES (800-432-2737). +• Lateral displacement or movement of single-post -3 +properly sized and located. -Read your -Owner’s Manual -carefully. -It will help you -operate your -new appliance -properly. +shoring for slab forms -If you have questions, or need -more information, call the GE -Answer Center® 800.626.2000. +• Hazardous soil conditions such as excessive +moisture, freezing, and uncompacted soil +conditions are reported and discussed with the +professional engineer. -Model Number +• Shoring frames and jacks are located and aligned -Serial Number +within tolerances specified on the drawings. -Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product, +• Shoring frames and jacks are out of plumb no -detach and return the form below to ensure that your -product is registered. +more than 1/8 inch every 3 feet. -" -Consumer Product Ownership Registration +• Adjustable base plates for shoring frames and -Cut here +jacks are snugged up. -Important -Mail -Today! +• U-heads are wedged in place. -First -Name +• Stringers are the specified size and number, with -Street -Address +supports properly spaced. -Apt. # +• Aluminum stringers have no bent flanges or other -City +damage. -Model Number +• Movement or deflection of lateral bracing for -Serial Number +single-post shores -Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108) +• Movement of stringers on U-heads -Last -Name +• Crushing of wooden stringers on U-heads -E-mail Address +(Figure 42-29) -State +• Gaps or shoring that is not snugged up under -Zip -Code +stringers -Date Placed In Use +• Deflection of stringers between supports -Month +(Figure 42-30) -Day +• Deflection of wales or strongbacks on wall forms -Year +• Wall forms that are bulging or cracking -Phone -Number +• Crushing of wales or strongbacks at washers -Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information. -(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information. +for ties -GE Appliances -General Electric Company -Louisville, Kentucky 40225 -www.ge.com/appliances +• Movement of wall forms -38 +• Joists are the specified size and properly spaced. - Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States) +• Uplifting of battered forms -All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers, -or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service, -call 800-GE-CARES. +• Support structures and shoring for beam bottoms +and column capitals are constructed according to +design. -For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You: +• Lateral bracing is provided where required (for +instance, on freestanding formwork for bridges +and overpasses). -One Year -From the date of the -original purchase +• The bearing surface for lateral bracing is +adequate—that is, stable footings or well- +compacted soil. -Five Years -From the date of the -original purchase +• Temporary loads such as rebar are not -Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect -in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year -warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor -and in-home service to replace the defective part. +overloading the system. -Any part of the sealed refrigerating system -(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all -connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in -materials or workmanship. During this additional -four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, -all labor and in-home service to replace the -defective part. +Concrete Placing -What Is Not Covered: +Forms should continue being observed during +concrete placing. Any signs of movement, crushing, +cracking, or deflection are cause for alarm. Placing +concrete should be suspended until the situation is +corrected. -n Service trips to your home to teach you +• Pour rates that exceed design specifications. -how to use the product. +Figure 42-29: Crushing of Stringer Over U-Head -n Improper installation. +Figure 42-30: Deflection +of Stringers Between Supports -n Failure of the product if it is +Tools and Techniques -abused, misused, or used for other -than the intended purpose or used -commercially. - -n Loss of food due to spoilage. - -n Replacement of house fuses or -resetting of circuit breakers. - -n Damage to the product caused by - -accident, fire, floods or acts of God. - -n Incidental or consequential damage to -personal property caused by possible -defects with this appliance. - -This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased -for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to -your home. - -Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This -warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to -state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your -state’s Attorney General. - -Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225 - -39 - -S -a -f -e -t -y -I -n -f -o -r -m -a -t -i -o -n - -O -p -e -r -a -t -i -n -g -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -I -n -s -t -a -l -l -a -t -i -o -n -I -n -s -t -r -u -c -t -i -o -n -s - -Tr -o -u -b -l -e -s -h -o -o -t -i -n -g -Ti -p -s - -C -u -s -t -o -m -e -r -S -e -r -v -i -c -e - - n -o -i -t -a -m -r -o -f -n -I -y -t -e -f -a -S - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -g -n -i -t -a -r -e -p -O - -s -n -o -i -t -c -u -r -t -s -n -I -n -o -i -t -a -l -l -a -t -s -n -I - -s -p -Ti -g -n -i -t -o -o -h -s -e -l -b -u -o -Tr - -e -c -i -v -r -e -S -r -e -m -o -t -s -u -C - -Service Telephone Numbers. - -GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000 - -The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. - -In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737) - -Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away. - -Special Needs Service800.626.2000 -TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322) - -GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier- -free kitchen for persons with limited mobility. - -Service Contracts800-626-2224 - -Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect -and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will -still be there after your warranty expires. - -Parts and Accessories800-626-2002 - -Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts -or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and -Discover cards are accepted). -Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed -by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified -service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing -may cause unsafe operation. - -Service Satisfaction - -If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow -these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance. -Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your -phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances, -Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225. - -40 - -Printed in Louisville, KY +42-13 diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_2.md b/q15/random_k4/random_2.md index 3f8f519b055815348eb52fd213fd7d32396a7bde..a7cbcf7d4134f4c225b224673f418e279c4db69c 100644 --- a/q15/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q15/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,3490 +1,1314 @@ -Fully Automatic Coffee Machine -OPERATION MANUAL - - Instructions of coffee machine parts - +B160V + +User Guide + + Contents +Safety information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 +Getting to know your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 +Setting up your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 +Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 +Messages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 +Email . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 +Chrome browser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 +Bluetooth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 +Wi-Fi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 +Camera . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 +Photos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 +Calendar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 +Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 +Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 +Clock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 +Google Maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 +Google Play Store . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 +Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 +Troubleshooting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 +Regulatory Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -9 +Safety information -6 +Please carefully read the items bellow: +Use Safely +Do not use the phone in situations where it might cause danger. +Transportation Safety +Please observe all transportation laws and regulations. +Please drive with both hands on the wheel. -7 +DO NOT TEXT AND DRIVE -9 +Hospitals +Please follow limitations. +Please turn off your mobile phone when near medical instruments. +Airports +Remember to follow all airport and flight safety regulations. +Please do not use your phone during flight. -10 +2 -11 + Toxic Chemicals +Do not use your mobile phone around fuels or chemicals. -12 +Hazard +Do not use in hazardous areas where explosions may occur. -13 +Accessories and Batteries +Use only Blu authorized batteries and accessories. -8 +Backup +Remember to keep a written record of all important information. -1 +Water +Your phone is not waterproof. Keep it away from water and liquids. -2 +SOS Emergency Calls +Make sure your mobile phone is switched on and in a service area. In +home screen, tap the phone key and dial 911 and send. 3 -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 +Getting to know your phone -Bean container +Receiver -Water tank +Headset port +Status bar -Coffee grounds container +Front camera -Pre - ground coffee chute +Rear cameras -Grinding wheel +Volume keys -Coffee spout +Power key -Handle +Flash -8 +Back +Home -9 +Recent Apps -10 +USB port -11 +4 -12 + Power +key -13 +• Press to turn the screen on or off. +• Press and hold to turn the phone on. +• Press along with the Volume up key to turn the phone off. +• Press along with the Volume down key to take a -Waste water container +screenshot. -Milk pipe +Volume +keys -Milk frother +Adjust the volume for ringtones, media, notifications, and +system sounds. -Hot water spout +Home -Milk and foam spout +The home button pauses any current action and returns to +the home screen. -Power cord +Recent +Apps - Coffee machine operation interface instructions +Open a list of recently opened applications that allows you +to switch conveniently between them. This option can also +close any open applications by swiping to the side. -5 +Back -1 +Return to the previous screen; Closes the keyboard, any +open program, or any menu option. -2 +USB port -3 +Charge the device and transfers data such as documents, +music, and video between your device and a PC. -4 +Headset +port -6 +Connect earphones to this port for hands-free capabilities. +You may also to listen to music or FM radio. -7 +Status +bar -8 +Provide phone and service status information on the right +side and notification alerts on the left. -9 +Front +Camera -10 +A high-resolution front camera to take pictures and video. +This option is ideal for self-portraits. -1 +Rear +Cameras -2 +Flash -3 +A high-resolution rear camera to take pictures and video. -4 +Provide light for pictures in low-light conditions. It also +may be used as a flashlight. 5 -Espresso icon - -Long coffee icon - -Hot water icon - -Power switch - -Display - 6 -7 - -8 - -9 - -Cappuccino icon - -Coffee Latte icon - -Hot milk/foam icon - -Cleaning button - -10 - -Rotary button - - Safety Instructions - -Please see specification label on the bottom of the coffee machine or -technical date indicated in the instruction manual(P20). - -IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS - -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should always be followed, -including the following: -1. Read all Instructions. -2. Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -3. To protect against fire, electric shock and injury to persons do not immerse cord, -plugs, or (state specific part or parts in question) in water or other liquid. -4. Unplug from outlet when not in use and before cleaning. Allow to cool before -putting on or taking off parts, and before cleaning the appliance. -5.Avoid contacting moving parts. -6. Do not operate any appliance with a damaged cord or plug or if the appliance -malfunctions, or has been damaged in any manner. Return the appliance to the near -est authorized service facility for examination, repair or adjustment. -7. The use of accessory attachments not recommended by the appliance manufac -turer may result in fire, electric shock or injury to persons. -8. Do not use outdoors . -9. Do not let the cord hang over edge of table or counter, or touch hot surfaces. -10. Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a heated oven. -11. Always plug cord into the wall outlet first,then turn controls to -turn any control to”off“, -12. Do not use appliance for other than intended use. -13. Check bean hopper for presence of foreign objects before using the brewer . -14. Unplug power cord from outlet before cleaning brewer exterior. Allow to cool -before disassembling and cleaning the coffee machine. -15. When dispensing drinks high temperature liquid will flow from coffee spout and hot -water spout. Do not touch hot liquids to avoid scalding -16. When using cappuccino, coffee latte, hot milk/foam, please confirm that the milk -pipe has been connected from the milk frother to milk before making cappuccino, -coffee latte, and hot milk/cream. Otherwise, high temperature steam may cause -personal injury. -17. Never connect to voltage different than the electric specification of the machine; -Brewer damage will occur. -18. Only potable water at room temperature should be used in the water tank. -Never put warm water, hot water, milk or other liquid into the tank. - -then remove plug from wall outlet. - -To disconnect, - -"on". - -01 - - Safety Instructions - -19. Never carry or move the coffee machine while power is on. -20. The machine will release heat and some steam. Therefore, when placing the -machine on a workbench, at least 3cm must be left between its surfaces, sides and -rear; at least15cm must be left above its top. -As for dimension of the machine, please look up the Technical Data in the User -Manual(Page 20). -21. Never use harsh or abrasive cleaner to wipe the machine, it may cause -corrosion of the coffee machine, and result in a risk of electric shock. -22. Never use hard edged tool or rough rag to clean the stain on the machine, it will -damage the surfaces. -23. Never fill specially treated coffee beans (e.g. cocoa, sugar coated) into the -beancontainer, it will cause the coffee machine damage . -24. Only roasted coffee bean are approved to place into the bean container. Rice, -soybean, chocolate bean, nut, sugar, spice etc are prohibited. Otherwise it would -cause the coffee machine to be damaged. -25. Never wash the bean container or pre-ground coffee chute with water, it will -damage the machine. -26. Never use the coffee machine in the environment temperature below 0 °C. -Water inside the machine will freeze and cause the coffee machine damaged. -27. Never expose the machine in rainy, snowy, frosty environment. It would cause -the coffee machine to be damaged. -28. Save these Instructions. - -POWER CORD EXTENSION USE - -Please don’t use power cord extensions. - -02 - -- - -- - - Proper operation - -the - -sure - -taste, - -make - -that the - -guarantee - -To -coffee -into the water tank is at room temperature. -used -can -The coffee -We -intended -it -use -of -read -this manual, so that you can understand operation of the coffee machine -sufficiently. - -preparing -not be responsible -contents - -machine -other -use. - -be -use. -carefully - -any -for -improper - -hot -for the - -temperature - -for -will - -coffee - -Please - -only - -and - -the - -the - -all - -of - -of - -water - -poured - -water. -Do -consequences - -not - -Please keep this manual in an appropriate place to -Safety Tips - -be accessed - -at any time. - -if - -is - -(if - -or - -the - -the - -the - -the - -smell - -power - -power - -coffee - -coffee - -unplug - -burning - -operate - -machine - -machine - -appliance - -or -an authorized - -any -contact + Setting up your phone -machine -and +Charge the battery +1. Connect one end of the data cable to the USB port located on the -the -of -immediately +Install a Nano SIM/microSD card -a breakdown -cord -power +bottom of your phone. -encountering -the +Note: Please contact your cellular phone service provider directly to +obtain your SIM card if your card is not preinstalled. +1. Insert the included SIM tray pin into -cord of the -service center. +the tray slot and remove the SIM tray. +2. Place the Nano SIM card and microSD -Please notice the following tips to avoid personal injury from electric shock. -cord +microSD -Do -not -damaged. -When -smoke), -service center. -If -authorized -Place the coffee machine and the power cord far away from heat sources. -Please don't contact the power cord with sharp tools.Do -coffee -it -operate -mentioned in this manual, to avoid personal injury. -Place the coffee machine out of the reach of children. -periods, -is -When the -cord and put it away, so that not to trip up people or damage to the power -cord. -Please -be damaged. +Nano SIM -not -way that is not +card (not included) with metal +contacts facing down into the tray. +3. Gently slide the SIM tray back into -authorization +SIM tray -contact an +Pin -damaged, +the slot. -otherwise, +Warning: Please keep the SIM card out of the reach of children. +The SIM card and its contact are easily damaged due to scratching or +bending. Please use caution when carrying, installing, or taking out the +SIM card. -unoriginal +2. Connect the other end to the power adapter. +3. Connect the power adapter to an electrical outlet to fully charge your -machine +phone. -machine +Power On and Off +Long press the Power key to switch on the phone. +To turn off the phone, press the Power key and the +Volume up key at the same time, and tap Power Off on +the screen that displayed. -without - -unused - -Coffee - -unplug - -please - -power - -cause - -repair - -parts, - -the machine to - -don't - -may - -long - -the - -any - -use - -the - -for - -or - -in - -is - -it - -03 - -Instructions for use - -Reading this manual will help you familiarize yourself with the coffee -machine, and enable you to use -“Instruction -coffee -“Failures handling" will provide information when encountering problems. - -the -use - machine step-by-step, for first-time use. - -it properly. -introduces - -operation - -first-time - -process - -for - -of - -" - -the - -Coffee machine model - -This +Power +key -Manual +7 -is +8 -only + Phone +Make a call -applicable +1. To make a call, tap Phone +2. Tap Dialer -to the + from the Home screen. -1601pro series coffee machine. + to access the keypad, or select one of the following: -Symbol description +• Choose frequently called or favorite contacts in Favorites. -Non-compliance -and threat to life. +• Choose recently called numbers and contacts in Recents. -with +• Choose a saved contact in Contacts. -proper +3. Tap +4. During a call, you can tap -operation, + to make a call. -may +up. -cause + at the bottom of the screen to hang -electric +Enable Wi-Fi call -shock, +You can make a voice call with Wi-Fi Calling. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Network & internet > Wi-Fi Calling. Slide the switch to the -Non-compliance -damage, or personal injury. +. -with +On + position to enable it. You must have an active Wi-Fi +connection and have Wi-Fi calling service activated before it can be +used. -proper +Call history -operation +Every telephone number called and received will be saved in the history. +1. From the Home screen, tap Phone +2. Tap Recents on the bottom bar to display the call history. +You can tap a contact in the call history to display more options. -may +. -cause +Call settings -Coffee +1. From the Home screen, tap Phone +2. Tap Options > Settings to configure your phone settings. -machine +. -Non-compliance +9 -with +10 -proper + Contacts -operation, +Add a contact -may +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Contacts -cause +. +2. Tap +3. Use the keyboard to enter contact information, such as picture, -scalding + to add a contact. -or +name, telephone number, group, address, email, etc. -burn +4. When you are finished, tap Save. -injury.This symbol, if prompted, please carefully read it. +Edit a contact -This symbol, if prompted, represents recyclable. +To edit a contact, tap the contact from the Contacts screen to view its +details, and tap - 01 +. -03 +Messages -03 -03 +Send a text or multimedia message +1. From the Home screen, tap Messaging +2. Tap Start chat to create a new text or multimedia message, or start -03 +. -05 +a new group chat. -05 +3. Enter the recipient(s) name from your Contacts list or phone number -05 +in the To field. -05 + to send the text message. -05 +4. Type your message and tap +5. Or tap -06 + to the left side of the text box to add location, contacts, -06 +or files. Tap +recordings. When done, tap -07 -07 -08 - 09 + to attach photos or videos. Tap -Catalogue + to send sound + to send the multimedia message. -Safety Instructions +Message settings +From Message screen, tap + on the top right corner of the Messages +screen and tap Messages Settings to adjust your messages settings. -Proper operation +11 -Instructions for use +12 -Coffee machine model -Symbol description + Email -Instructions for first time use +Email setup (Gmail, Yahoo!, etc.) -Power connection +From the Home screen, tap Gmail +your account. -Fill water tank +, and follow the steps to set up -Fill beans +Create and send an email message +1. Tap Compose from the Inbox screen to compose a new message. +2. Enter the recipient(s) email address in the To field. To add a carbon copy -Grinding wheel +or blind carbon copy, tap -Power on +. -Power off +3. Enter the subject and content of your message. To add attachments, tap -Making beverages + and select Attach file. -Preparing coffee by touch icon +4. Tap -Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle. + to send. -Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee +Email settings +From Email screen, tap Menu +settings. -Program setting + > Settings to configure your Email -Beverage +Chrome browser +From the Home screen, tap Chrome +for information, and bookmark your favorite web pages for convenient +access. -setting + to browse the Internet, search -Setting beverage parameters and range +Browsing web pages +From the Chrome browser screen, tap the address field and enter a web +address or a keyword to browse for web pages. -Temperature setting +Adding a bookmark +Open the web page you want to bookmark and tap Menu > -Eco-settings +. -Automatic power-down +Opening a bookmark +From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Bookmarks, select +the bookmark of the website you want to view. -Factory Reset +Browser settings +From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Settings to customize +the browser. -Information Statics +13 -Language +14 -Exit + Bluetooth -Cleaning and maintenance +Wi-Fi -Cleaning the coffee machine before operation +Bluetooth is a short-range wireless communications technology that +devices can use to exchange information and connect to different types +of devices which include headsets and other devices. -Cleaning brewing unit +Enable Bluetooth -Rinsing milk unit +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Connected devices > Connection preferences > -Descaling the coffee machine +. -Cleaning coffee +Bluetooth. -grounds +3. Slide the Bluetooth switch to the On -container and drip tray + position. -Cleaning water tank +Pair Bluetooth devices -Cleaning bean hopper +1. From the Connected devices screen, tap Pair new device. +2. Tap a device under Available devices and follow the on-screen -Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother +instructions to pair with the device. -Installing milk pipe +3. When the device is connected to your phone, You can then use the +headset or car kit to listen to music or make and receive phone calls. -Cleaning milk pipe +To use your phone’s Wi-Fi, you need access to a wireless access point or +hotspot. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +2. Tap Network & internet > Internet > Wi-Fi. +3. Slide the Wi-Fi switch to the On +4. Tap a Wi-Fi network to connect, enter the password (if applicable), -Cleaning coffee machine + position to enable Wi-Fi. -Failures handling +. -Display information +and then tap CONNECT . -Transport and recycle +5. Your phone will be connected to the Wi-Fi network. You will see -Technical data +in the status bar. -04 +You can drag down the status bar twice to access Quick Settings panel +to enable or disable Bluetooth and Wi-Fi quickly and easily. -9 -10 +15 -10 +16 -10 + Camera -11 +Photos -11 +Take a photo +1. From the Home screen, tap Camera +2. Tap Photo to switch to Photo mode. +3. Aim the camera at your subject and tap -11 + to take the photo. -11 +. -11 +Record a video +1. From the Camera screen, tap Video to switch to Video mode. +2. Tap +3. Tap -11 + to start recording a video. + again to stop recording and save your video. -12 -12 +Camera settings +From the Camera screen, tap Settings -12 + to adjust camera settings. -13 +You can view photos and watch videos that you’ve taken, downloaded, +or copied onto your storage card or phone memory. -14 +Edit photos +1. From the Home screen, tap Photos +2. Tap the picture you want to edit. +3. Tap +save. -16 +. -17 + to access the Edit screen. When finished, tap Save copy to -17 +Share pictures and videos +1. Select the photos or videos you want to share. +2. Tap -17 +, select a sharing method, and follow the on-screen prompts -17 +to send the photos or videos. 17 18 -18 - -19 - -20 - -20 - - Instructions for first-time use - -This chapter will help you understand the basic operations and settings for your -first time use - -Power connection - -● - -● - -● - -● - -coffee - -machine - -Place the coffee machine on a stable workbench that is not -close to water. -Keep -the -heat sources. -Be sure to use the power supply that is in accordance with -specification label. -Put -at -power -tripping over the cord. + Calendar -avoid people +Calculator +Calculator -temperature +Use the Calendar to create and manage events, meetings, and +appointments. -suitable +Add an event -place +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calendar -away - -cord - -from - -high - -the - -far - -to - -a - -Fill water tank - -● - -● - -● - -temperature +. +2. Tap Add +3. Enter event details, and then tap Save. -milk). + to add an event. -room +Calendar settings -water, +1. From the Calendar screen, tap Menu +2. Tap an option to adjust Calendar settings. -at -tank, + > Settings. -water -water +Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic +Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic +mathematical equations. +mathematical equations. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator -fill -will -taste +. . -never -It -the -at 25℃ - -potable -in the -water,hot -In - -to ensure -order -water -to -use -a -create - -Only -poured -warm -machine. -recommended -water -will -taste. -To -change the water in the tank every day. -The -in -height of the MAX mark. - -the water - -a healthy +2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then +2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then -amount +enter the second number. +enter the second number. -ensure +3. Tap +3. Tap -water + to view the result, tap + to view the result, tap -good + to clear the results. + to clear the results. -tasty +View calculator history +View calculator history -tank +From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on +From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on +the history bar +the history bar +To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the +To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the +. +calculator, drag the history bar +. +calculator, drag the history bar -and + back up or tap the Back button + back up or tap the Back button -not + to view the calculator history. + to view the calculator history. -the +19 -of +20 -to be + Clock -is -other +Google Maps -allowed -liquid +The Clock app allows you to set alarms, view different world times, use +a stopwatch, set a timer, manage your bedtime, and use your phone as +a desk clock. -any -coffee -damage the -it -is -coffee, -temperature +Use the Google Maps app to determine your location, get directions, +browse local businesses and attractions, rate and review places, and +more. -of -Low +Set the date and time manually -(e.g. +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Clock +2. Tap Menu > Settings > Change date & time > Set time +automatically > Off, and set the date and time manually. -coffee drink, +. -please +Create a new alarm -cannot +1. From the Clock screen, tap Alarm +2. Set the time for the alarm and tap OK. -exceed + > -the +. -Fill beans +Search for destinations +1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Maps +2. Tap Search here. +3. Enter an address, city, facility name, etc., and then choose a search -05 +. -● +result. You will see your location on the map. -● +Find a route to your destination +Tap Go +, enter your desired start location and destination, and tap a +method of transportation (car, public transit, or on foot) for the detailed +directions to your destination. -● +21 -● +22 -● + Google Play Store -put +Access Google Play -Never -treated (e.g. sugar, cocoa) into the bean hopper. +1. From the Home screen, tap Play Store +2. Enter your existing GoogleTM Account login or create one by following -coffee +. -beans +the steps on the screen. -been +Navigate Google Play -have +1. Tap Search for apps & games on the top of the screen to search -that +for a specific game or app. -specially +2. To install an app, tap the app and follow the prompts to complete +the process. After installation, you will see a notification in the +Notifications panel. You can open the app from the notification panel +or Apps list. -into -soybeans, +Settings -be +From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings +to access your phone’s Settings menu. -put +Network & Internet -can -rice, +From the Settings screen, tap Network & internet. +• Internet: Enable or disable Wi-Fi, add Wi-Fi network, view saved -beans -like +networks, and monitor data usage. -roasted -put +• Wi-Fi Calling: Enable or disable Wi-Fi Calling, adjust Wi-Fi Calling settings. +• Mobile network: Enable or disable mobile data, adjust data roaming +settings, view mobile data usage, set data limit and warning mode, etc. -coffee -other items +• Airplane mode: Enable or disable Airplane mode. +• Mobile plan: View your mobile plan. +• Others: Adjust settings on Hotspot & tethering, Data saver, VPN, -Only -never -nuts,sugar, and spices into the hopper. -objects -Never -damage the grinder. -bean hopper -The -beans -of +Private DNS, etc. -cover acts -maximized. +23 -as a -Please +24 - coffee + Connected devices +From the Settings screen, tap Connected devices > Connection +preferences. +• USB: Connect your phone with a computer using a USB cable to +transfer data, share network connectivity, or charge your phone. +• Bluetooth: Pair Bluetooth devices to launch wirelessly hear calls, -hard +connect speakers, transfer data, and more. -into +• Cast: Scan for nearby devices to connect to and set them up. +• Printing: Connect your device to a printer on the same Wi-Fi -put +network. -the +• Chromebook: Link your phone to a chromebook. +• Nearby Share: Allow the rapid short-range exchange of images, -seal. -do +videos, text, contact info, directions, YouTube videos, and other data +via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. -beanhopper, +• Android Auto: Control your phone’s maps, media and messaging -otherwise +functions, with the Google Assistant while you drive. -it will +Apps -It -not +View current running applications, manage permissions, and more. +From the Settings screen, tap Apps. +• Recently opened apps: Tap an app to view detailed information. +• Default apps: Set the default app for the browser, phone, messages, -keeps +etc. You can also set default apps for opening links. -the aroma +• Screen time: You can tap -lose +on the right side of most apps to set -the cover. +daily timers. When the app timer ends, the app is paused for the rest +of the day. -the +• Unused apps: View apps that you have not used for a long time. You -bean hopper, +can un-install them to free up some space. -chocolate +• App battery usage: Set battery usage for apps. +• Special app access: View app access for special functions, such as -beans, +battery optimization, display over other apps, unrestricted data, usage +access, etc. -Don't pour liquid in the bean container. +25 -Grinding wheel +26 -● + Notifications -● +Battery -● +From the Settings screen, tap Notifications. +• App notifications: Control notifications from individual apps. +• Notification history: View your recent and snoozed notifications. +• Conversations: View priority and modified conversations. +• Bubbles: Enable message conversations display as bubbles, floating -● +on top of other apps. -● +• Device & app notification: Control which apps and devices can -● +read notifications. -● +• Notifications on lock screen: Select how you want notifications to -adjust +be displayed on the lock screen. -Please -according to the coffee bean type. +• Do Not Disturb: Enable or disable Do Not Disturb. Set Do Not -fineness +Disturb behavior, exceptions, schedule, etc. -coffee +• Others: You can adjust other notifications settings, like wireless -the +emergency alerts, hide silent notifications in status bar, etc. -of +Monitor your phone’s battery usage. +From the Settings screen, tap Battery. +• Battery Usage: View the battery percentage that each apps used -bean +from last full charge. -grind choice +• Battery Saver: Enable or disable Battery Saver, set a schedule for +turning on the Battery Saver, turn the Battery Saver off when your +phone charges above 90%. -adjust +• Battery percentage: Show battery percentage in the Status bar. -Please -or the grinder may be damaged. +Storage -grinding +Manage internal storage on your phone and provides menu choices for +an optional SD card. +From the Settings screen, tap Storage. +• Device storage: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > This -wheel +device. Tap a category to view the storage amount used by each app. -the +27 -when +28 -the + • SD card: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > SD CARD to -grinder +Display -is +view files stored on your SD card. Tap on the top right corner of the +screen to rename, eject or format the SD card. -running, +• Storage manager: Storage manager removes backed up photos and -it +videos from your device. -is +Sound & vibration +From the Settings screen, tap Sound & vibration. +• Media/Call/Ring/Notification/Alarm volume: Drag the slides to -are +adjust the media, call, ring & notification, and alarm volumes. -are +• Do Not Disturb: Manage Do Not Disturb settings. +• Phone ringtone: Select a ringtone for incoming phone calls. +• Media: Enable Media to hide player when the media session has ended. +• Others: You can adjust other sound and vibration settings, like -your +vibration & haptics, default notification and alarm sounds, enable +tones or vibration on other scenarios, etc. -your +From the Settings screen, tap Display. +• Brightness level: Drag the slide to adjust the screen brightness -color, +level. -beans +• Adaptive brightness: Enable adaptive brightness to automatically -beans +adjust the screen brightness basing on the lighting conditions. -light in +• Lock screen: Set what to show on lock screen. +• Screen timeout: Your screen will automatically go to sleep after the -coffee +set amount of time. -coffee +• Dark theme: Turn on dark theme. +• Display size and text: Adjust font size and display size. +• Night Light: Set a Night Light schedule and intensity. +• Others: You can adjust other display settings, like enable auto-rotate +screen and life to wake features, adjust display color and screen saver, +etc. -recommended to +29 -dark in +30 -If -set to the coarse grind. -If -to set to the fine grind. -While -very -coarse grind. -Adjust grind choice as needed, increase or decrease grind -level. + Accessibility -making -slowly , please change the grind choice to a more +Security & privacy -recommended +Manage accessibility-related apps to make the device easier to use for +those with certain physical disabilities. +From the Settings screen, tap Accessibility. +• Real-Time text call: Manage RTT call options. +• Display: Adjust the font size and display size, enable or disable dark -brew dispense +theme, enable screen magnification, etc. -coffee drinks, +• Interaction controls: Enable or disable useful interaction functions, -coffee +such as timing control, system controls, etc. -color, +• Captions: Enable or disable captions. You can also set caption display -the +language, text size, and caption style. -is +• Audio: Pair your hearing aids, enable mono audio, or adjust the audio -it +balance from the speaker. -if +• Accessibility shortcuts: Mange the settings on accessibility button. +• Text-to-speech output: Set the text-to-speech engine, language, -adjustment +speech rate, etc. -The -making two or more cups of coffee. +From the Settings screen, tap Security & privacy. +• App security: Check your device and prevent/warn you of potential -grinding +harm. -wheel +• Device lock: Set your screen lock method, pattern, PIN, password, etc. +• Account security: Add a Google Account to secure your device. +• Device finders: Enable Find My Device to locate your device -of +remotely, keeping your data safe in the event that your phone is lost. +• System & updates: Check for new software updates for your device. +• Privacy: Manage a batch of privacy settings. +• Face unlock: Unlock your phone by looking at it. +• More security & privacy: Adjust more security and privacy settings. -will +Unlock your device automatically in certain conditions. -be +31 -effective +32 -only + Location -after +From the Settings screen, tap Location. +• Recent access: View a list of apps that have recently requested your -Finest +location. -Fine +• App location permissions: View which apps have permission to -Medium +access location services. -Coarse +• Location services: Manage settings on other location services, such -Coarsest +as emergency location service, Google location accuracy, etc. - Power on +Safety & emergency -First-time use +Fulfill your medical and emergency information, view emergency alerts, +and manage settings on emergency SOS and location service. +From the Settings screen, tap Safety & emergency. +• Emergency information: Add medical information and emergency +contacts to help first responders in an emergency. Anyone can read +this information from your lock screen and dial your emergency +contacts without unlocking your phone.. -● +• Emergency SOS: If you have turned the Emergency SOS function +on, when you have an emergency and need emergency services, +press the Power/Lock key 5 or more times quickly. -As -be +• Emergency Location Service: If you have turned Emergency +Location Services (ELS) on, when you call or text an emergency +number, your device will use ELS to automatically send your location +to emergency responders. -the -a +• Earthquake alerts: Get an alert with the initial estimated magnitude -machine +and distance from your location. -has +• Wireless emergency alerts: Turn wireless emergency alerts on -been +or off. You can also view emergency alert history and manage alert +preferences. -tested +Passwords & accounts -at the +Set up and manage all of your accounts, including your Google Account +and other social networking accounts, through the Accounts settings +menu. From the Settings screen, tap Passwords & accounts. -factory, +33 -there +34 -may + • Passwords: See, change, or remove passwords you saved in your -little +• Reduce interruptions: Enable or disable the notifications of apps -coffee +Google Account. -left in the machine +and Do Not Disturb mode. -. +• Autofill service: Autofill your information when needed from your -● +Google Account. -● +• Add account: Set up your account. +• Automatically sync app data: Activate automatic data syncing. -● +Digital Wellbeing & parental controls -coffee +Statistics screen usage time, app timers, bedtime schedules, manage +notifications, etc. +From the Settings screen, tap Digital Wellbeing & parental controls. +• Your Digital Wellbeing tools: Use app timers and other tools to -The -first-time -best working condition, and this process cannot be skipped +keep track of screen time and unplug more easily. -cleaning upon -achieve +• Ways to disconnect: View your screen time and set timers for your +apps, set a bedtime schedule to disconnect from your phone and +avoid interruptions while you sleep, pause distracting apps when you +need time to focus. -and -machine +• Show icon in the app list: Enable icons in the app list. +• Parental controls: Add content restrictions and set other limits to -machine -this +help your child balance their screen time. -will -helps +Google -start -the +Configure your device’s Google settings. Available options depend on +your Google Account. From the Settings screen, tap Google. -self-testing +System -coffee +Manage detailed settings for your phone, including language and input +settings, battery and storage, date and time, etc. +From the Settings screen, tap System. +• Languages: Set the language for the phone’s menus and keyboards, +set the language for each app, set units and number preferences, etc. -use, +• Keyboard: Select and configure keyboard settings -the +35 -When powering on the coffee machine, it will automatically +36 -complete heating and cleaning for one time, every + • Gestures: Enable useful gestures, such as Quickly open camera, +Navigation mode, Power & hold power menu and Prevent ringing. +• Date & time: Enable or disable network-provided time, automatic -time and the process cannot be stopped. The coffee machine +time zone, 24-hour format, etc. -can only be used after the above cycle process is finished. +• Backup: Back up your phone’s data and settings to Google servers -During the cleaning process, some hot water may flow out of +before resetting your phone to the original factory settings. -the coffee spout into the drip tray. Please avoid contacting +• System update: Check for new software updates for your device. +• Multiple users: Share this device with other people by creating -the hot water. +additional users. -Please ensure the power is connected before pressing -the +• Reset options: View different reset options and reset your device. -power button. +About phone -Power off +Access important phone information, search for and apply updates, and +view legal and safety information. +From the Settings screen, tap About phone. -● +Troubleshooting -● +Below is a list of common problems that may occur when using your +mobile phone. Try these easy troubleshooting steps to resolve any type +of issues you may encounter. +The phone does not power on +• Press and hold the power key until the startup sequence appears on -● +the display. -When powering off the coffee machine , it will automatically -complete the cleaning process for one time, every time,and the -process cannot be stopped. This operation is to clean up -the coffee pipelines and remove the coffee grounds. +• Check the battery level and ensure there is sufficient charge. +The phone does not respond after several minutes +• Remove and insert the battery – If the phone has an internal battery, -During the cleaning process, some hot water will flow out of -the coffee spout into the drip tray. Avoid touching hot -water, so as not to be burned. -Only after using milk/foam/cappuccino/latte, the Rinse -Milk Unit function will be operated when the power is turned off. +please press and hold the power button. -When you press the power button, the machine will be -powered off after auto cleaning +The phone powers off by itself +• Check if the screen lock of the phone is enabled. +• Check if the phone needs to be charged. -When +37 -you +38 -press + The battery will not charge +• Check if the battery is already fully charged. +• Make sure that the battery is inserted correctly. +• Ensure that the battery being used is a BLU approved battery. +• Double check if the charger connector is properly connected to the -the power +phone. -button, +Note: Connect charger only after the battery has been inserted. -the +The phone displays a SIM Error +• Make sure the SIM is properly inserted and in its intended slot. +• Make sure that the SIM card is not damaged or scratched. +The PIN code was entered incorrectly three times +• The SIM card will lock, and you will need to enter the PUK code (PIN +Unlock Code). Please contact your local service provider to obtain the +PUK. -machine +The standby time is too short +• Please keep in mind that standby time relates directly to phone usage -will +I cannot make calls +• Make sure that the number you dialed is correct and the dial key has -be +(Internet, Text, Voice Calls, Maps, etc.). -powered +been pressed. -off after auto +• Batteries typically have to be replaced after a year of use. +The phone cannot connect to the network (Voice or Data) +• Verify if you have active service with your service provider. +• Contact your local network service provider and verify if you are within -cleaning. +its network coverage area. -READY +• Use the full national area code when dialing out of your area or when -06 +abroad, use country-specific international access codes. - Making beverages +I cannot receive calls +• Make sure that your phone is connected to a network. -T, his chapter instructs you on how to make various kinds -of coffee, hot water,hot milk and milk foam by this coffee -machine.Please read the following instructions carefully to help -you make high-quality beverages +39 -temperature -The -avoid being scalded. +40 -of + The caller ID does not display on incoming calls +• Contact your local network service provider and verify you have the +caller ID feature enabled on your account or verify if the caller may +have blocked his number from appearing. -the +The caller cannot leave a voicemail message +• Contact your local network service provider and verify if the voicemail -hot +service is active on your account or check if the network is busy. -water +The phone does not connect to the internet +• Ensure with your service provider that your account has the -is +appropriate internet/data plan enabled. -high, +• Ensure internet APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent). +Text Messages cannot be Sent / Received +• Ensure text messaging is enabled with your service provider. +• Ensure APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent). -please +Regulatory Information -do +FCC regulations -not +This mobile phone complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is +subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause +harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept any interference +received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. +This mobile phone has been tested and found to comply with the limits +for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These +limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful +interference in a residential installation. +This equipment generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy +and, if not installed and used in accordance with the instructions, may +cause harmful interference to radio communications. + +41 + +42 + + However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a +particular installation If this equipment does cause harmful interference +to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning +the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to correct the +interference by one or more of the following measures: +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. +• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that + +to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. +Changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party +responsible for compliance could void the user’s authority to operate the +equipment. +The antenna(s) used for this transmitter must not be co-located or +operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter. + +RF Exposure Information (SAR) + +This mobile phone meets the government’s requirements for exposure to +radio waves. +This phone is designed and manufactured not to exceed the emission +limits for exposure to radio frequency (RF) energy set by the Federal +Communications Commission of the U.S. Government. +The exposure standard for wireless mobile phones employs a unit of +measurement known as the Specific Absorption Rate, or SAR. The SAR +limit set by the FCC is 1.6 W/kg. *Tests for SAR are conducted using +standard operating positions accepted by the FCC with the phone +transmitting at its highest certified power level in all tested frequency +bands. +Although the SAR is determined at the highest certified power level, +the actual SAR level of the phone while operating can be well below +the maximum value. This is because the phone is designed to operate +at multiple power levels so as to use only the poser required to reach +the network. In general, the closer you are to a wireless base station +antenna, the lower the power output. + +43 + +44 + + The highest SAR value for the model phone as reported to the FCC when +tested for use at the ear is 1.29 W/kg and when worn on the body, as +described in this user guide, is 0.89 W/kg (Body-worn measurements +differ among phone models, depending upon available accessories and +FCC requirements.). +While there may be differences between the SAR levels of various +phones and at various positions, they all meet the government +requirement. +The FCC has granted an Equipment Authorization for this model phone +with all reported SAR levels evaluated as in compliance with the FCC RF +exposure guidelines. SAR information on this model phone is on file with +the FCC and can be found under the Display Grant section of www.fcc. +gov/oet/ea/fccid after searching on FCC ID: YHLBLUB160V. +For body worn operation, this phone has been tested and meets the FCC +RF exposure guidelines for use with an accessory that contains no metal +and the positions the handset with a minimum of 1.5 cm from the body. + +Use of other accessories may not ensure compliance with FCC RF +exposure guidelines. If you do not use a body-worn accessory and are +not holding the phone at the ear, position the handset a minimum of 1.5 +cm from your body when the phone is switched on. + +Safety precautions for power supply unit + +Use the correct external power source +A product should be operated only from the type of power source +indicated on the electrical ratings label. If you are not sure of the type +of power source required, consult your authorized service provider or +local power company. For a product that operates from battery power or +other sources, refer to the operating instructions that are included with +the product. +This product should be operated only with the following designated +power supply unit(s). +Travel charger: Input: 100-240V, 50/60Hz, 0.35A. Output: 5V, 2000mA. + +45 + +46 + + Handle battery packs carefully +This product contains a Lithium-ion battery. There is a risk of fire and +burns if the battery pack is handled improperly. Do not attempt to open +or service the battery pack. Do not disassemble, crush, puncture, short +circuit the external contacts or circuits, dispose of in fire or water, or +expose a battery pack to temperatures higher than 140°F (60°C). The +operating temperature for the phone is 14°F (-10°C) to 113°F (45°C). +Warning: Battery is non-removable. Do not attempt to remove +the battery for danger of explosion. +To reduce risk of fire or burns, do not disassemble, crush, puncture, +short circuit the external contacts, expose to temperature above 113°F +(45°C), or dispose of in fire or water. Do not attempt to replace the +non-removable battery. The phone and battery as a unibody device +must be disposed of in accordance with locally applicable environmental +regulations or guides supplied with your product. + +47 + +Take extra precautions +• Do not disassemble or open crush, bend or deform, puncture or + +shred. + +• Do not modify or remanufacture, attempt to insert foreign objects into +the battery, immerse or expose to water or other liquids, expose to +fire, explosion, or other hazards. + +• Only use the battery with a charging system that has been qualified + +with the system per CTIA Certification Requirement for Battery System +Compliance to IEEE1725. Use of an unqualified battery or charger may +present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage, or other hazards. + +• Replace the battery only with another battery that has been qualified + +with the system per this standard, IEEE-Std-1725. Use of an +unqualified battery may present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or +other hazards. Only authorized service providers shall replace battery. +(If the battery is non-user replaceable). + +• Promptly dispose of used batteries in accordance with local + +regulations. + +• Improper battery use may result in a fire, explosion, or other hazards. +48 + + • Do not replace an embedded battery pack. Improper replacement may +present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or other hazards. Contact the +manufacturer for replacement instructions. + +• The phone identifies the battery by the Battery ID Pin. +• If the battery leaks: + +• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with skin or + +clothing. If already in contact, flush the affected area immediately +with clean water and seek medical advice. + +• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with eyes. +If already in contact, DO NOT rub; rinse with clean water +immediately and seek medical advice. + +• Take extra precautions to keep a leaking battery away from fire as + +there is a danger of ignition or explosion. + +Hearing Aid Compatibility (HAC) + +This device is hearing aid-compatible as determined by ANSI C63.19- +2019 and waiver DA-23-914. The lowest conversational gain is 10.32 +dB with a hearing-aid, and 13.93 dB without hearing-aid, using telecoil +coupling capability and Bluetooth connectivity. +The 2019 ANSI C63.19 standard does not use this rating system nor +do any test standards exist for any wireless technologies that transmit +above 6 GHz. Instead, this standard uses the conversational gains for +the device’s hearing aid compatible capabilities. +This device has been tested and certified for use with hearing aids for +some of the wireless technologies that it uses. However, there may be +some newer wireless technologies used in this phone that have not been +tested yet for use with hearing aids. It is important to try the different +features of this phone thoroughly and in different locations, using your +hearing aid or cochlear implant, to determine if you hear any interfering +noise. Consult your service provider or the manufacturer of this phone +for information on hearing aid compatibility. If you have questions about +return or exchange policies, consult your service provider or retailer. -touch +49 -it +50 -to + We consent to the following conditions of the waiver: +• Pass Conversational Gain, Receive Distortion and Noise and Receive -Before making -display. -on +Acoustic Frequency Response testing using one narrowband and one +wideband codec, limited to one bit rate. -the +• Pass Conversational Gain at both 2N and 8N on all available -all +narrowband and wideband codecs and air interface combinations. +Please see the HAC Volume Control test report for further details and +supporting data. -kinds +The information provided in this user manual is subject to change without notice +and BLU Products reserves the right to modify the manual at any given time. BLU +Products has made every effort to ensure that this user manual is accurate and +disclaims responsibility and liability for any inaccuracies or omissions. BLU Products +makes no commitment to keep current the user manuals, however, does reserve +the right to make improvements to the user manual at any given time without +notice. -of +Google, Google Play, Google Maps, YouTube, Gmail and other marks are +trademarks of Google LLC. -coffee, - -please - -ensure - -“READY” - -is - -indicated - -● -● - -● - -● - -● - -● - -used. - -ensure - -at -it -of - -recommended - -water -better, -quality - -normal -is -coffee, - -potable -tastes -the - -can -temperature -use -to -change - -The coffee beans should be stored in a dry place and avoid sunlight. -Only -make the -coffee -To -tank every day. -Please -taste. -Please -of -height of the cup in order to avoid coffee splashing. -Adjustable height of coffee spout: 80-140mm. - -around25℃. -in the - -be -water -the - -making the - -according - -please - -before - -coffee - -coffee - -coffee - -height - -better - -adjust - -water - -water - -warm - -spout - -cup - -the - -the - -the - -the - -for - -To - -to - -Preparing coffee by touch icon - -You can make 4 kinds of coffee using the touch icons, when -shows -“READY” - -the screen - -Take espresso for example to explain how to make coffee by touch icons. - -07 - -The volume of espresso is suggested between 30 to 50ml. -Because of the small volume of espresso, please warm the coffee cup before -making coffee. - -Touch the espresso icon for espresso -function. - -ESPRESSO - -STRONG - -VOLUME - -50ML - -ENJOY ! - -The grinder will begin to grind . At this time -you can adjust the amount of coffee beans -by rotating the rotary button. -Default amount of coffee beans for -espresso: - -During making coffee, you can adjust the -volume of coffee by rotating the rotary -button. -Default volume of espresso: 50ML - -When the screen shows as the left picture, it -means the espresso is ready, please enjoy -it. - -READY - -ESPRESSO - - Single time setting of coffee parameters - -Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle. - -Making beverages - -● -● -● -● -● -● -● -● - -Set the amount of coffee beans during the grinding process. -Set the volume of coffee when making coffee -Set the dispense time of milk -foam to control the -to -Set the dispense time of milk -Set the temperature of hot water before making hot water -Set the hot water volume when making hot water -Set the dispense time of hot milk -Set the dispense time of hot foam when making hot foam - -the volume - -control the - -volume - -volume - -control - -to - -making -when -when making latte - -cappuccino - -when making hot milk - -Detail instructions -You can set the strength of coffee before making the beverage and the -volume of the beverage -saved. - -during the brew cycle. The settings will - -not be - -STRONG - -VOLUME - -40ML - -FOAM TIME - -20S - -MILK TIME - -15S - -NORMAL - -VOLUME - -60ML - -When -rotate - -grinding -rotary -the - -the -button - -coffee -to - -beans, -the - -you -amount - -can -of - -adjust - -coffee - -beans, - -to - -the left - -is - -mild - -, - -and - -to - -the right - -is strong . The - -default - -amount - -is normal - -When -can -For -2 -clicks - -making long - -coffee - -volume - -coffee, -by using the - -be adjusted -example, - -the current - -rotary -is -to reduce -95ml, -increase to 105ml. - -volume -to - -button. -100ml, -2 -and - -clicks - -to the - -to the - -right - -left -to - -cappuccino, -making -the - -making -latte,the foam - -When -coffee -adjusted by rotating -the milk foam outflows. -current time is 20s,2 clicks -reduce -increase to 21S. - -For - -to - -milk -time - -foam -be - -or - -can -rotary -button -example,the -to -to the - -left - -19S,and 2 clicks to the right to - -while - -08 - -making - -time -button. - -When -dispensing -the rotary -milk dispensing -left to reduce to -to increase to 16S. - -hot -can - -milk -be - -coffee - -or -adjusted - -For -time -14S, - -example, -is -and - -15S, -2 - -2 -clicks - -latte, - -milk -rotating -current -to the - -by -the -clicks - -to the - -right - -hot - -making - -Before -adjusted -be -the left -low, -is -temperature is normal. - -water, -rotating -right is - -by -to the - -temperature -rotary - -the -the -high. The - -default - -button. - -can -To - -dispensing - -be - - can -button. -is -and - -For -100ML, -2 - -hot - -adjusted - -water, -by -example, -clicks -2 -to -clicks - -the -hot -rotating -the -to the - -water -the -current -reduce -left - the right to increase - -to - -When -volume -rotary -volume -to -95ML, -to 105ML. - - Making beverages - -Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee - -can - -You -Pre-ground coffee. - -choose - -this - -function - -if - -you - -want - -to - -make - -coffee - -with - -●Do not use instant coffee powder -pre-ground -damage the machine. - -or cocoa powder in the -coffee chute. powder container.Otherwise it will - -● -Do not put pre-ground coffee powder into the coffee -bean hopper,otherwise, it will damage the machine. - -● - -● - -● - -Please use proper Pre-ground coffee for espresso. - -Only 7-14g of pre-ground coffee can be added. -Machine will be - -damaged. - -The process of using pre-ground coffee to make coffee -only skips the process of grinding coffee beans, other -operations are the same as making espresso, long coffee, -cappuccino, and coffee latte. This chapter illustrates with -espresso. - -Press and hold the rotary button to -enter into -programming when the -coffee machine is -“READY”. - -READY - -09 - -GROUND COFFEE - -Display shows “GROUND COFFEE ” page -after entered into programming. Press -the rotary button to make coffee. - -Open pre-ground coffee chute cover and -fill .close the cover. Touch the - -icon -beverage -Press the rotary button to - -need - -you - -to - -make -cancel. - -coffee. - -FILL GROUND COFFEE - -SELECT COFFEE -ROTARY TO CANCEL - -Program setting - -● - -This chapter will give instructions on program settings. - -● - -Ensure the coffee machine shows “READY”, press and hold the - -rotary button , then you can enter into the menu - - Beverage setting - -will - -instruct - -chapter - -This -settings -temperature -hot milk, dispense time of - -you -parameters include -hot - -of - -how -to -coffee - -set -strength, - -beverages parameters. -coffee, - -volume - -of - -The - -water,volume of hot water,dispense time of making - -making hot foam - -parameters - -accomplished - -by the - -beverage - -setting - -will - -be - -the - -The -default - - values for each beverage. - -1. Espresso setting -2. Long coffee setting -3. Hot water setting -4. Cappuccino setting -5. Coffee latte setting -6. Hot milk setting -7. Hot foam setting - -Setting beverage parameters and range - -The parameters such as strength, volume, temperature and -forthe beverages below. - -time can be set - -can be set - -can be set - -The strength and volume of espresso -The strength and volume of long coffee -The strength and volume of coffee part of cappuccino -set -The foam dispensing time in cappuccino -eht dna trap eeffoc fo emulov dna htgnerts ehT -can be set -The temperature and the volume of hot water can be set -Hot milk making time can be set -Hot foam making time can be set - -can be set - -can be - - ettal ni emit gnitiaw - -Please read the following table for the detail setting parameters and -adjustment range - -10 - -Drinks - -espresso - -long coffee - -cappuccino - -coffee Latte - -hot water - -hot milk - -hot foam - -Strength - -Volume range - -Default - -Mild: -Normal: -Strong: - -Mild: -Normal: -Strong: - -Volume: 15 -120ML - -Volume: 15 - 240ML - -Volume: 15 - 240ML -Milk time: 0 - 120SEC -Foam time: 3 - 120SEC -Wait time: 0 - 30SEC - -Volume: 25 -450ML - -Milk time: 3 -120SEC - -Foam time: 3 -120SEC - -50ML - -100ML - -60ML - -Foam time: 20SEC - -60ML - -Milk time: 15SEC -Foam time: 20SEC -Wait : 20SEC - -100ML - -15 SEC - -15 SEC - -Temperature Setting - -The coffee temperature can be adjusted to your liking with the “ Temperature setting” -function and you can choose: - -1 .Low - -2 .Normal - -3 .High - -The default temperature is Normal, and it’s only adjustable for coffee not milk. - - Program setting - -Eco settings - -● - -● - -If the machine is set to Eco-setting, the machine needs 30 -seconds to warm up to make Cappuccino, Coffee Latte, -milk and foam. . The normal setting has more energy -consumption than the Eco-saving mode. - -Hot - -The factory default setting of the machine is normal mode. -entering the program setting, please turn the rotary -“ECO SETTING” option, then press the rotary button, -finished. - -button to -setting is - -After - -Automatic power-down - -switch - -off - -time - -automatically - -is 4 hours, -switch - -which -off 4 hours - -automatic - -switch-off - -is - -from - -15 - -minutes - -to - -program - -setting, -Then - -please -press - -the - -turn - -the -rotary - -rotary -button, - -option. - -will - -default - -machine - -machine’s - -the -setting - -last use . -range - -The -means the -after -The -24 hours. -entering -After -button -“Auto-off” -the -the setting is completed. - -the - -to - -of - -Factory Reset - -● - -● - -● - -● - -● - -will - -the - -the - -all -to - -function - -reset -parameters -options). However - -This -beverage -language -not be reset. -After -the -confirm, the setting is completed. - -program -option - -“FACTORY RESET” - -entering - -the - -the - -menu -factory - -setting -settings - -and -(except - -default -the - -information - -options - -will - -setting, -then - -please - -press - -the - -turn - -the -rotary - -rotarybutton -button - -to - -to - -Information Statics - -11 - -● - -In this program you can view the statistical information on -the number of drinks, total drinks numbers, etc. - -1. Number of rinses -2. Number of total cycles -3. Number of espresso -4. Number of long coffee -5. Number of hot water -6. Number of cappuccino -7. Number of coffee latte -8. Number of hot milk -9. Number of hot foam -10. Number of descales -11. Number of ground coffee -12. Number of brew unit cleans -13. Number of milk unit rinses - -● - -When first viewed there will -produced -been - -because -before leaving the factory. - -already be -each - -beverages - -tested - -a -coffee - -number - -of -machine - -has - -Language - -● - -You can set your preferred language on the coffee machine. - -● - -After entering the program setting, turn the rotary button to the "CHOOSE -LANGUAGE" option, then press the rotary button, rotate the rotary to -choose the language, and press the rotary button, the language setting -is completed. -EXIT - -● - -After entering the program setting, please turn the rotary button to the -“EXIT” option. Then press the rotary button. The -machine will return to -“READY” . - - Cleaning and maintenance - -chapter - -This -the coffee machine. - -will - -instruct - -you on - -how - -to - -clean - -and - -maintain - -Paying -machine,will -coffee, - -attention -not -also - -but - -daily - -maintenance -to -only -of -taste -the -extend the life of the coffee machine. - -coffee -cup - -of the -of - -ensure - -each - -Cleaning the coffee machine before operation - -chapter -This -coffee machine. - -will - -instruct - -you - -on how - -to - -clean - -and - -maintain - -the - -Cleaning function must be processed in “READY” status. - -When the coffee machine is in “READY” -status and the cleaning indicator light is not -on, press the cleaning button to start -cleaning the brewing unit and coffee -spout. - -The process of cleaning coffee machine -cannot be interrupted, and it will -automatically return to “READY” status after -cleaning. - -READY - -CLEANING - -Cleaning brewing unit - -READY - -12 - -After a long-term use, there will be some coffee ground -brewing unit. Remove the grounds by deeply cleaning the -brewing -The process of cleaning the brewing unit takes about - - unit. - -20minutes. - -left in the - -After entering the program settings, turn the -rotary button to the "MAINTENANCE" option, -and press the rotary button. - -When the screen shows the picture on the -indicates cleaning the brewing unit -left, it - has been selected. Press the -program -cleaning -button to start cleaning the -brewing unit. - -The brew unit is cleaning. - -MAINTENANCE - -CLEAN BREW UNIT - -CLEANING - - Cleaning and maintenance - -OPEN COVER ADD -CLEANING TABLET - -CLOSE COVER -PRESS RINSE - -CLEAN - -CLEANING - -READY - -Open the pre-ground coffee chute cover, -add - -the cleaning tablet. - -Close the pre-ground coffee chute -cover, -press the cleaning button to -start the cleaning process. - -The screen will display as the left picture, - -Brew unit is now cleaning. - -After cleaning has finished, the machine -re-enters - -into “READY” status. - -13 - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -● - -After long-term use, some milk waste would be left in the Milk -needs to - -be cleaned. - -unit and - -Enter the program setting, Turn the -rotary -page and - -button to the“MAINTENANCE” -pressed the rotary button. - -When showing left picture in the display, it is -now in milk unit cleaning mode, press the -cleaning button to start. - -Remove the milk pipe from the milk -container and insert it into the hole in the -drip tray grid according to the display. -Press the rinse button to rinse milk unit. - -MAINTENANCE - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -REMOVE MILK PIPE - -PRESS RINSE - - Milk unit is cleaning. -After cleaning is finished, the machine -enters - - into “READY” status. - -Cleaning and maintenance - -RINSE MILK UNIT - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning process - -is - -completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - -Descaling the coffee machine - -The daily usage will cause calcium deposits in the coffee -machine. The depositing rate varies with the local water -hardness. - -Decalcifier contains acidic substances that -could hurt -comply with the security warnings noted by the -manufacturer on the packaging. - -your eyes and skin, so you must strictly - -Dissolve the decalcifier in clean water, and then put the -mixed liquid into the water tank. Fully dissolved the -Decalcifier can descale the coffee machine more -thoroughly. -The whole descaling process takes about 30 minutes. -Do not cancel the descaling process or you will damage -the coffee machine. -once -process,please do not terminate it midway or turn off -power to themachine. - -descaling - -start - -you - -the - -So - -NEED DESCALE - -PRESS RINSE - -MAINTENANCE - -DESCALE - -30 MINS - -PRESS RINSE - -14 - -After a certain time of use, if it reaches a -high -degree of scaling, “NEEDS DESCALE" -and"PRESS RINSE " will automatically -display on -the screen alternately. Now, press the -cleaning button to enter the descaling -program. - -Turn the rotary button to the maintenance -setting option, press the rotary button to -enter. - -Turn the rotary button to descaling option, -press rotary button to enter - -After entering the descaling program, press -the cleaning button to start the descaling -program; it will take about - -minutes. - -30 - - Cleaning and maintenance - -SOLVENT IN TANK - -PRESS RINSE - -DECALCIFYING - -EMPTY TRAY - -Take a bag of decalcifier and sufficiently -dissolve it in clean water, then put this -mixed liquid to the water tank, and reinstall -the water tank to the coffee machine. - -After adding decalcifier, press the -cleaning -cleaning. - -button to start descaling and - -To start descaling and cleaning for the first -time, put a container, of which the -capacity is more than 1L, under the coffee -spout. - -Empty tray. - -Install tray. - -INSTALL TRAY - -15 - -FILL WATER TANK - -After descaling and cleaning for the first -time, take the water tank out, empty the -rest of the water and clean it. Add -potable water again, and reinstall it to the -coffee machine - - and cleaning for the second - -Press the cleaning button to enter -descaling -time. This is to clean -decalcifying water in pipes at -a container, of which the -than 1L, under the coffee - -the residual - -capacity is more -spout. - -this time . Put - -Decalcifying. - -the - -screen - -When -shows -the descaling is completed; Now, you can -continue to brew beverages. - -“READY”, - -indicates - -it - -PRESS RINSE - -DECALCIFYING - -READY - -Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed. - -First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning. - - Cleaning coffee grounds container and drip tray - -● - -● - -● - -not - -use - -and - -corrosive - -chemical - -Do -cleaner -solvents -to clean the coffee grounds container and drip tray. -The drip tray and coffee grounds container cannot be cleaned -in dishwasher. -not -Do -avoid - -residue -container. - -use -scraping - -coffee -grounds - -objects -drip - -or -dirt -coffee - -clean -and - -to -tray - -metal - -the - -to - -or - -alcohol - -Cleaning and maintenance - -1 - -● -When prompted to empty the coffee grounds, coffee grounds -must be cleaned up, or it will cause the machine to be -damaged. - -. - -When it accumulates to 35 cups, it will -automatically indicate “EMPTY GROUNDS”. - -2 - -EMPTY GROUNDS - -INSTALL TRAY - -READY - -EMPTY TRAY - -INSTALL TRAY - -READY - -When it shows “INSTALL TRAY “, please -remove coffee grounds from the drip tray -and -more than 3 seconds. - - coffee grounds container. This will take - -Reinstall the water drip tray in the machine, -it should returns to “READY” status. You can -continue using the machine. - -If the drip tray is full, the machine will -automatically indicate"EMPTY TRAY". Take -out the water drip tray and dispose of -waste - - water. - -After clearing the waste water, reinstall the -drip tray to the coffee machine, it should -returns to“READY” status. You can continue -using the machine. - -3 - -4 - -16 - - ● - -Each time you are cleaning coffee grounds and waste water -from the drip tray, please empty the drip tray and coffee -grounds - -container. - -● - -Each time after cleaning coffee grounds and waste water from the drip -tray, -at the end of drip tray, then reinstall the drip tray to the coffee machine. - -please rinse the tray with clean water, and wipe dry the 2 steel plates - - Cleaning and maintenance - -Cleaning water tank - -● - -● - -● - -It is suggested that, each time adding water, clean the tank -thoroughly with running water first. -Cleaning the water tank regularly - -to - -be - -use - -rag - -a wet - -better - -would - -and some mild - -it -cleaning fluid. -Because the water tank is made from food-grade materials and -environmental materials, it might crack if handled -aggressively. Please gently pick it up -and put it down, and -never let it fall down. if the water tank is damaged, please -contact the customer service center. - -Cleaning bean container - -● - -● - -● - -to - -do - -not - -use - -wash - -water - -, -would -it - -beans hopper - -in the bean hopper - -the -Please -cause the grinder to be damaged. -Please use a dry rag or a paper towel to clean the -residue -food-grade -Because -crack if handle aggre. - and -Please gently pick it up and put it down, and never let it fall -down. If the bean container lid is damaged , please contact -the customer service center. - -. -cover -it - -environmental - -is -might - -container - -materials, - -grease - -made - -bean - -from - -the - -ssively. - -Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother - -In order to guarantee the fine and smooth milk foam, please -clean the milk frother every day. - -1. Carefully take off the milk frother. -2. Disassemble each part of the milk frother thoroughly. -3. Wash the parts with running water. -4. Reassemble the milk frother, and install it to the coffee -machine. - -17 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -Installing milk pipe - -● - -Install the milk pipe to the milk frother inlet. - -Cleaning milk pipe - -In order to keep milk pipe clean, please clean it every day. - -1. Take off milk pipe carefully. -2. Clean milk pipe in running water. - - Cleaning coffee machine - -● - -● - -● - -● - -the - -check - -coffee - -grounds residue - -Before cleaning the interior of the coffee machine, power it -off, the disconnect power cord from the outlet ,Never -immerse the coffee machine inwater. There will be a risk of -electric shock. -Regularly -coffee -brush to remove the coffee - -machine -the -ground. -Use a dry and soft -machine. -the -As the touch panel is made of glass, please do not hit it to -avoid the risk of electric shock once the glass broken. -Use a dry and soft rag to wipe the surface of the machine, -and never use hard objects to clean coffee residue on the -surface, otherwise it would cause the surface to be -damaged. - -is -can use a - -whether -machine. - -there -You - -excessive - -touch - -panel - -inside - -wipe - -rag - -the - -to - -of - -Problem Causes and Solutions - -● - -● - -This chapter will instruct you on some errors that you may -encounter - -and the solutions. - -If there are some failures cannot be resolved by the following -methods, please contact with the authorized service center. - -melborP - -Cause - -snoituloS - -The coffee temperature is too low. - -The coffee cup was not pre-heated. - -Wash the coffee cup with hot water -before making coffee. - -Several minutes have passed since the -last time of coffee making , so the -brewing unit and the internal pipes are -already cold. - -Make some more cups of coffee. - -18 - -Coffee only comes out from the -coffee spout drop by drop. - -Overly fine pre -ground coffee or coffee -bean has been ground too fine. - -Adjust the grinding level to coarse -or use the suitable pre-ground coffee . - -Brewing unit filter was blocked. - -Run the brewing unit rinse programme - -Insufficient coffee oil. - -Chose the wrong coffee bean type. - -The grinder is making unusual noises. - -There are foreign objects in the grinder. - -Use suitable coffee beans. - -Make coffee again, if it still fails, please -contact the authorized service center - -The milk frother cannot make any milk -foam. - -The milk frother is blocked. - -Cleaning the milk frother ( refer to P17). - -Milk sprays from the milk frother. - -The milk frother was not assembled -correctly. - -Reassemble the milk frother. - -Screen always indicates "EMPTY TRAY". - -Screen always indicates "INSTALL TRAY". - -Screen always indicates “FILL WATER -TANK”, but the water tank is full. - -The sheet metal at the end of the drip -tray is dirty or wet. - -Coffee grounds in the bottom of the -machine are not cleaned. - -Wipe the sheet metal to dry ( refer to P16). - -Clean the coffee grounds in the bottom. - -The water tank inductor is trapped. - -Clean the water tank ( refer to P17). - -Screen always indicates “FILL BEANS”, -but the bean container is full. - -The bean container is too oily and -sticky for coffee beans. - -“Errors 1 to 7”is displayed. - -If the coffee machine fails, it cannot -continue to be used - -1. Stir coffee beans in bean container. -2. Observe if the coffee beans are over -roasted or charcoal roasted. -3. Clean the beans container ( refer to -P17). - -1. Restart coffee machine. -2. If “errors” still exist, switch off the main -power, and contact the authorized -service center - - Display information - -● - -This chapter will instruct you on the error information -that is - -screen and the solutions. - - displayed on the - -Causes - -Solutions - -If the water drip tray is full, -making beverage will -service. - - be out of - -Take the drip tray out, empty the -waste water in the drip tray and -reinstall it to the machine. - -If the coffee grounds container is -full, making - beverage will be out -of service. - -Take the coffee grounds container -out, empty the coffee grounds -container and reinstall it. - -If water in the water tank is -empty, making -be out of service. - - beverage will - -Fill the water tank with water. - -If coffee beans in the bean -hopper are used up, making -coffee will be out of - -service. - -Add beans into bean container, -and press the rotary button to -release. - -There is not enough pre - -ground -pre-ground coffee - -coffee - -in the - - chute. - -Next time when making coffee -with pre-ground coffee , please -use proper amount. - -The drip tray is not installed -correctly; any function is out of -service. - -Install the drip tray correctly. - -The water in the pipe inside the -machine is not enough; any -function is out of service. - -Press the rotary button to release, -to run the water replenishing system. - -Temperature of the machine is too -high, the machine cannot be used. - -Power off the main power, and -wait 1 hour later. - -Temperature of the machine is too -low, the machine cannot be used. - -Increase environmental temperature -to above 10℃. - -EMPTY TRAY - -EMPTY GROUNDS - -FILL WATER TANK - -FILL BEANS - -FILL POWDER - -19 - -INSTALL TRAY - -UNIT EMPTY - -TEMPERATURE HIGH - -TEMPERATURE LOW - -ERROR 1 - -The coffee machine fails -error1.may -used. - -not be able to be - -1. Power off, then power back -;2. If still unresolved, please -on -unplug from outlet.Contact with -authorized service center. -the - -1. Using dark roasted coffee beans -or over fine pre-ground coffee -filter of the brewer is -2. The -clogged. - -1.Adjust grinder wheel to a coarse -setting2. Start brewer cleaning -procedure(refer to P12). - -Dispenser valve is blocked. - -Restart coffee machine. - -PRESSURE HIGH - -VALVE RESET -RESTART MACHINE - - Transport and recycle - -Transport - -Please save the packaging of the coffee machine for future -transportation. -Make sure to empty water inside the machine before transportation, -otherwise, it will damage the machine. -After emptying the waterway, please wipe the machine both -inside and outside to dry. -Once the empty waterway program was executed, the system -will rerun to the program of “first-time use”, when the coffee -machine is used again.( refer to P6, First-time use) -While emptying the waterway, there will be high-temperature -steam sprays from coffee spout. Please pay special attention to -avoid being scalded. - -READY - -FILL WATER TANK - -EMPTY UNIT - -The machine is on the status of “READY”. - -Take out the water tank, and the machine -indicates “FILL WATER TANK”. - -Press and hold the cleaning button until -the screen shows "EMPTY UNIT", themachine -begins to clean up the waterway -automatically, and steam will spray from -coffee spout, please keep your distance to -avoid scalding. - -the - -After emptying the waterway, the machine -will automatically power off. Take the drip -tray out after the power is switched off, and -clear the water in the drip tray. - -Recycle - -When recycling the machine, some inner parts can be -recycled to use again. Please pay attention to recycle them -for environmental protection. - -Technical Data - -Voltage/Frequency - -120V~ 50/60 Hz - -Power - -Pump pressure - -1450 W - -19 bar - -Capacity of water tank - -2 L or connect to water barrel - -Capacity of bean hopper - -Capacity of coffee ground waste bin - -Capacity of the brewing unit - -750 g - -35 cakes - -7 - 14 g - -Adjusting the height of coffee spout - -80 - 140 mm - -Length of power cord - -Net weight - -1.5 m - -16 kg - -Dimensions (Length×Width×Height) - -533mm×383mm×662mm - -20 +51 diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_3.md b/q15/random_k4/random_3.md index 0572cd5a0b3a091ffd9cca8b1a4cbd9e0b32bc77..7f06b970eb191d018409053c543e59811fc6cbd9 100644 --- a/q15/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q15/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,217 +1,1186 @@ -Active Noise Cancelling -Wireless Headphones -INSTRUCTION MANUAL + TABLE OF +CONTENTS -QDPRANCBK +Is Graduate School Right for You?............................. -The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered -trademarks owned by Bluetooth SIG,Inc. and any -use of such marks by Officeworks Ltd. is under license. +4 -1/8 +What to Expect from Graduate School .................... - Functions +5 -ANC switch +Why UTRGV?................................................................ -ANC switch indicator +6 -USB charging port +Institutional Accreditations ...................................... -Charging light +Graduate Programs ..................................................... -Line in audio cable -Microphone +Graduate Admissions ................................................ -LED status -indicator +Research Centers & Key Research Areas ................. -VOL+ (Short Press) -NEXT (Long Press) +Costs & Financing ....................................................... -Power button -VOL- (Short Press) -PREV (Long Press) +Important Contact Information ............................... -Pack Contents -1. Headphones 2. Instruction manual 3. USB charging cable -4. Audio cable 5. Airline adaptor 6. Headphone case -Note: When an audio cable is plugged in, the Bluetooth wireless function will disconnect. +8 -2/8 +10 - Power On +12 -Power Off +14 -Press and hold -3 sec +16 -Press and hold -3 sec +18 -3/8 +2 - Bluetooth Pairing +3 -Press and hold -3 sec + IS GRADUATE +SCHOOL +Right for You? +Right for You? -LED will flash red -and blue when ready -to connect +Your undergraduate education gave you a strong foundation of knowledge and skills to start +your career. These days, however, to become an expert in your field, a graduate education is +often required. -Bluetooth +Specialized skills that you’ll learn and practice in graduate school are the key to career growth, +a better income, and unlocking your full potential. More and more, employers look for hiring +candidates to hold a graduate degree that demonstrates their expertise. -Bluetooth +Even if you’re currently satisfied with your career, you might have a passion for lifelong +learning or want to take a deeper dive into a particular subject. Investing in self-development is +never a bad decision, and a graduate degree can create surprising benefits for you in the future. -Devices +As a graduate student, you’ll connect with supportive faculty who are leaders in their fields, +as well as other motivated graduate students who share similar goals and interests. You have +the flexibility to choose the pathway that’s right for you, including research, accelerated online +master’s programs, on-campus master’s or doctoral programs, and certificates. - 16BN01 +WHAT TO +EXPECT FROM +Graduate School? +Graduate School? -ON +• You can expect to be more responsible for your success than you were as a an -Paired +• You’ll need to plan ahead to ensure you don’t miss out on required classes. -Now discoverable +undergraduate. You may even help with research or teaching. -In your device‘s Bluetooth -settings activate bluetooth and -select ” 16BN01” enter -the PIN ‘0000’ if needed +Since some classes are only offered, for example, in the spring, you will prepare +a graduation plan to guide you towards on-time completion of your program. -The blue LED light will be on -and flash to indicate the -headphone is connected +• You’ll take rigorous classes alongside driven classmates like yourself. Being in -4/8 +graduate school raises the bar for expectations. You’ll need to maintain at least +a 3.0 GPA. - Play +• Unlike large undergraduate classes with hundreds of students, graduate -10m +classes are smaller. You will be on a first-name basis with your professors, who +will be both instructors and valuable mentors. -1 × Press +• As an undergraduate, you may have assisted graduate students or faculty with +their research. As a graduate student, depending on your program, you’ll be +expected to carry out your own research, present it, and publish it. -Press and hold +• If you’re taking classes on campus, you can expect most of them to be in the +evening. Many graduate students have jobs and families, so most on-campus +graduate classes are offered after 5 pm, twice a week. Online students need to +prioritize and allocate time for classwork in their schedules. -1 × Press +• You can expect to be proud of your hard work and for pursuing your passion. -1 × Press +Get ready to positively transform your community and the world. -Press and hold +4 -Calling Mode +5 -10m + UTRGV? -Answer +WhyWhy -1 × Press +A high-quality education at an affordable price -Hung up +Graduate school at UTRGV is the perfect fit for -1 × Press +ambitious leaders, dreamers, researchers, educators, -Decline +and creators. -Press and hold -for 2 sec +We welcome you to join our vibrant community, +whether on campus or online. This is your opportunity +to leap forward in your career with an excellent +graduate education that’s both rigorous and affordable. -5/8 +Pursuing a graduate degree is a commitment to your +future, and we understand that our students have +different learning styles and real-world responsibilities. +We have options to suit your lifestyle and give you the +flexibility to choose between 100% online or on-campus +programs. All students receive the same high level of +training and support from faculty and staff. - Active Noise Cancelling (ANC) Function +UTRGV offers unique research and resources through +the STARGATE partnership with SpaceX, the Coastal +Studies Laboratory on South Padre Island, and UT +Health RGV clinics from our School of Medicine. -ON +The Valley itself has a low cost of living that’s 10.2% +below the national average, with easy access to the +beautiful Gulf Coast. -OFF +Demand for trained professionals in the Rio Grande +Valley, the United States, and around the world +continues to grow, and UTRGV equips graduate students +with the necessary competitive edge. -Turning ON: Slide the ANC switch on the right headphone to ON, the indicator light -on the switch will turn red. +Established in -The ANC function uses more power when turned on and will reduce the time between -charge of the headphones. +2015 -ANC reduced 15db±3db noise. +4th Largest -Product Specifications +institution in +the UT System -1. Charging voltage: -2. Bluetooth working range: -3. Working time: -4. Standby time: +Enrollment Numbers 2020: +Graduate -Micro USB 5V -10 metres -ANC off: 7-8 hours, ANC on: 3-3.5 hours -Up to 70 hours +Overall -6/8 +32,618 - Charging +5,122 -Plug micro-USB cable -into computer’s USB port +UTRGV RANKINGS +UTRGV +RANKINGS +19th +6th -Plug micro-USB cable -into USB wall charger +1st -Charging +In net price among +national universities by +Washington Monthly (2018) -Before using the headphone for the first time, charge it for at least -two hours +In the nation for top master’s +universities by Washington +Monthly (2019) -Low battery alert -When battery voltage less than 3.3V, the Headphone will be -warning and have tone speak out from speaker. +Best online college in Texas by +OnlineColleges.com (2019) -Charging -red light on +3rd -Full charge -light off +Most affordable university in +America by BestValueSchools.com +(2018) -Airline Adaptor +1st -The airline adaptor can only be used on the aircraft. +4th -Plug the airline adaptor into the connector of the video player on the plane, then connect the -headphone with the Adaptor by audio cable. +19th -7/8 +79th +6th - Trouble Shooting +Best college in Texas by +BestColleges.com (2018) -Do not expose the device to water or attempt to disassemble the device -Headphones will not turn on -Ensure headphones are fully charged before turning it on. +In net price among +national universities by +Washington Monthly +(2018) -My mobile device is unable to find the Bluetooth headphones -Check that the headphones is in pairing mode (blue/red indicator lights flashing). -Remove“ 16BN01” from Bluetooth settings list and setup again. -If still no search result, please restart the headset and phone, and try again. +In the nation for top +master’s universities by +Washington Monthly +(2019) -After successfully pairing, headphones disconnect -Check the battery level and recharge if low. -Ensure headphones are within 10m of mobile device and free of destructions. -The connection may be affected by obstructions such as walls or other electronic devices. Try moving -closer to the device you are connected to. +Best online college +Among 300+ national universities +in Texas by +by Washington Monthly (2018) +OnlineColleges.com +(2019) -When answering a call, I cannot hear anything -Ensure the mobile device is connected to headphones and not on speakerphone mode. -Increase the volume on your mobile device. +3rd -There is no sound when listening to music -Increase the volume on your mobile device. -Reconnect the headphones to your mobile device. -Check if the app has paused or stopped playback. +in the nation among public +institutions for least student +Most affordable +debt according to U.S. News +university in America +& World Report (2020) +by BestValueSchools.com +(2018) -Headphones will not charge -Check whether the charging cable is functional. -Ensure the micro-USB charging cable is fully seated in the headphones and wall charger ports. -Ensure the charging cable and wall charger are functional. +1st -Officework address: Officeworks Ltd. 1 South Drive, 236-262 East Boundary Road, - East Bentleigh, VIC 3165 +4th -8/8 +3rd +79th + +Best college in Texas +by BestColleges.com +(2018) + +America’s Best Bank for the +Buck Colleges: South by +Washington Monthly (2020) + +Among 300+ national +universities by +Washington Monthly +(2018) + +QUALITY . FLEXIBILITY . AFFORDABILITY + +• According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 101 occupations require a graduate degree for entry. + +• The number of jobs requiring a master’s degree is projected to increase by 17% between 2016 and 2026. + +• Students who obtain master’s degrees earn, on average, $12,000 more in entry-level positions. + +• UTRGV offers graduate programs that align with the fastest growing careers. + +% change +2018-2028 + +Medium annual wage (2018) + +2018 Fastest Growing Occupations + +Occupational therapy assistants + +Information security analysts + +Physician assistants + +Statisticians + +Nurse practitioners + +Speech-language pathologists + +Physical therapist assistants + +Genetic counselors + +Mathematicians + +Operations research analysts + +Software developers, applications + +Health specialties teachers, postsecondary + + 33.1 + + 31.6 + + 31.1 + + 30.7 + + 28.2 + + 27.3 + + 27.1 + + 27.0 + + 26.0 + + 25.6 + + 25.6 + + 23.2 + + $60,220 + + $98,350 + + $108,610 + + $87,780 + + $107,030 + + $77,510 + + $58,040 + + $80,370 + + $101,900 + + $83,390 + + $103,620 + + $97,370 + + $44,630 + + $50,090 + + $87,930 + + $60,280 + + $63,120 + + $73,490 + +Substance abuse, behavioral disorder, and mental health counselors + + 22.5 + +Marriage and family therapists + +Physical therapists + +Respiratory therapists + +Market research analysts and marketing specialists + +Nursing instructors and teachers, postsecondary + + 22.3 + + 21.9 + + 20.8 + + 20.4 + + 20.0 + +Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Outlook Handbook, [Fastest Growing Occupations], on the Internet +at [https://www.bls.gov/ooh/fastest-growing.htm] (visited [October 2019]).”” * U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics + +55+ + +ON-CAMPUS AND ONLINE +MASTER’S PROGRAMS +16-week-long semesters + +Full-time students (9 hours/semester) +can finish in as little as 2 years + +25 + +ACCELERATED ONLINE + +PROGRAMS +7-week-long modules + +Full-time students (6 hours/module) +can finish in as little as 1 year + +6DOCTORAL PROGRAMS + +40CERTIFICATE PROGRAMS + +SCHOLARSHIPS & ASSISTANTSHIPS +AVAILABLE + +$0 + +APPLICATION FEE + +Except: Occupational Therapy, Physician Assistant +Studies, Communication Sciences and Disorders, +Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner, and +Physician Assistant Studies - Bridge. + +6 + +7 + + INSTITUTIONAL +Accreditations +Accreditations + +The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (UTRGV) is accredited by the Southern Association of Colleges and + +Schools Commission on Colleges to award bachelor’s, master’s, and doctoral degrees. + +Individual Program Accreditations and Recognitions + +• Robert C. Vackar College of Business & Entrepreneurship + AACSB International, The Association to Advance + +• Department of Physician Assistant Studies + Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the + +Collegiate Schools of Business + +Physician Assistant (ARC-PA) + +• Educational Leadership (EdD) and Curriculum and + +Instruction (EdD) + +• School of Rehabilitation Services & Counseling + Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related + + Admitted to the Carnegie Project on the Education + +Educational Programs + +Doctorate (CPED) + +• Social Work (MSSW) + Council on Social Work Education (CSWE) + +• Music (MM) + National Association of School of Music (NASM) + +• Department of Occupational Therapy + Accreditation Council for Occupational Therapy + +Education (ACOTE) + +• Department of Communication Sciences & Disorders + Council on Academic Accreditation in Audiology and +Speech-Language Pathology of the American Speech- +Language-Hearing Association + +• Master’s Degree in Nursing and Post-Graduate + +Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner Certificate + + Commision on Collegiate Nursing Education + +• Counseling (MEd) + Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related + +Educational Programs + +8 + +9 + + GRADUATE PROGRAMS + +COLLEGE OF EDUCATION +AND P-16 INTEGRATION +utrgv.edu/cep +Bilingual Education (MEd)2 +Board Certified Behavior Analyst + +(Certificate) + +Certificado Avanzado en Educación + Bilingüe 2 +Counseling (MEd) +Curriculum & Instruction (MEd) + Content Specialization in English (MEd)3 + Content Specialization in Mathematics (MEd)3 + Content Specialization in Elementary Math and + +Science Education (MEd)3 + + Content Specialization in Mathematics + +Education (MEd)3 + +Curriculum and Instruction (EdD) +Digital Literacy Leader (Certificate)2 +Early Childhood Education (MEd) +Educational Leadership (EdD) +Educational Leadership (MEd)4 +Educational Technology (MEd)3 +E-Learning (Certificate)3 +Higher Education Teaching (Certificate)3 +Online Instructional Designer (Certificate)3 +Principal Credential Certification (6 Credit Hours) + +(Certificate) 4 + +Principal Credential Certification (21 Credit Hours) +Reading and Literacy (MEd) 2 +Reading Specialist Certification (Certificate) 2 +School Psychology (MA) +Secondary Bilingual Education (Certificate) 2 +Special Education (MEd)3 +Superintendent Certification (Certificate) +Teacher Leadership (MEd)4 +Technology Leadership in Education + +(Certificate)3 + +TxVSN Digital Literacies (Certificate)2 + +COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING +AND COMPUTER SCIENCE +utrgv.edu/coec +Civil Engineering (MS) +Computer Science (MS) +Electrical Engineering (MSE) +Engineering Management (MS) 4 +Information Technology (MS) +Manufacturing Engineering (MSE) +Materials (Certificate) +Mechanical Engineering (MSE) +Mechanics and Design (Certificate) +Thermal Fluid Science (Certificate) + +COLLEGE OF FINE ARTS +utrgv.edu/cofa +Art (MFA) +Interdisciplinary Studies (MA) + Concentration in Art History +Creative Writing (MFA) +Design (Certificate) +Latin American Art History (Certificate) +Music (MM) + +COLLEGE OF HEALTH PROFESSIONS +utrgv.edu/coha +Bilingual Counseling (Certificate)2 +Bioethics (MS)2 +Clinical Rehabilitation Counseling (MS) +Clinical Laboratory Sciences (Certificate)3 +Communication Sciences and Disorders (MS) +Cooperative Pharmacy Program (with UT Austin) +Exercise Science (MS) +Health Sciences (MS)3 + Concentration in Clinical Laboratory Sciences3 + Concentration in Healthcare Administration3 + Concentration in Health Professions Education + +and Technology3 + + Concentration in Healthcare Informatics3 + Concentration in Nutrition3 +Health Science Nutrition (Certificate)3 +Healthcare Informatics (Certificate)3 +Kinesiology (MS)3 +Occupational Therapy (MS) +Physician Assistant Studies (MPAS) +Physician Assistant Studies - Bridge + Program (MPAS)2 +Rehabilitation Counseling (PhD) + +ROBERT C. VACKAR COLLEGE OF +BUSINESS & ENTREPRENEURSHIP +utrgv.edu/cobe +Accountancy (MAcc)4 +Advanced Business Administration + +(Certificate)4 + +Business Administration (MBA) + General4 + Specialization in Accounting (MBA)4 + Specialization in Business Analytics (MBA)4 + Specialization in Entrepreneurship (MBA)4 + Specialization in Financial Planning (MBA)4 + + Specialization in Health Care Administration + +(MBA)4 + + Specialization in International Trade (MBA)4 + Specialization in Marketing (MBA)4 +Business Administration (PhD) +Business Administration in Spanish (MBA)3 +Business Analytics (Certificate) +Business Analytics (MS)3 +Entrepreneurship (Certificate) +Healthcare Administration Leadership + +(Certificate) + +International Sustainability Management + +(Internal Certificate)5 + +User Experience and User Interface Design (UX/UI) + +(Certificate)3 + +SCHOOL OF NURSING +utrgv.edu/nursing +Family Nurse Practitioner (MSN) +Nursing Administration (MSN)3 +Nursing Education (MSN)3 +Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse + Practitioner (Certificate)2 + +SCHOOL OF SOCIAL WORK +utrgv.edu/social work +Social Work (63-Hour) (MSSW) +Social Work (MSSW)4 + Concentration in Administration and + +Community Practice (Advanced Standing) +(MSSW)4 + + Concentration in Direct Practice with Latino +Individuals, Families, and Groups (Advanced +Standing) (MSSW)4 + +COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS +utrgv.edu/cla +Advanced Placement Spanish Literature + +(Certificate)2 + +Board Certified Behavior Analyst + +(Certificate) + +Clinical Psychology (MA, PhD) +Communication (MA) +Communication Training and Consulting + +(Certificate) + +Court Interpreting (Certificate)2 +Criminal Justice (MS)4 +Disaster Studies (MA) +English (MA) +English as a Second Language (MA) + +COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS cont. +Experimental Psychology (MA) +Gender and Women’s Studies (Certificate) +Healthcare Interpreting (Certificate)2 +History (MA) +Interdisciplinary Studies (MA) + Concentration in Anthropology + Concentration in English + Concentration in History + Concentration in Mexican American Studies +Literary Translation (Certificate)2 +Localization and Audiovisual Translation + +(Certificate)2 + +Media Relations and Strategic + Communication (Certificate) +Mexican American Studies (Certificate) +Political Science (MA) +Public Affairs (MPA)4 +Secondary English Language Arts (Certificate) +Sociology (MS) +Spanish (MA) +Spanish Translation and Interpreting + +(MA, Certificate) 2 + +COLLEGE OF SCIENCES +utrgv.edu/cos +Agricultural, Environmental and Sustainability + +Sciences (MS) + +Applied Statistics and Data Science (MS) + +Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (MS) + +Biology (MS) + +Chemistry (MS) + +Cooperative PhD in Physics (with UT Arlington) + +Mathematics (Accelerated BS/MS + + 5-Year Program, MS) + +Ocean, Coastal, and Earth Sciences (MS) + +Physics (MS, PhD) +Interdisciplinary Studies (MS) + + Concentration in Science and Technology + +Instructional method is traditional +(face-to-face) unless otherwise noted. +2 Online (16-week Semesters) +3 Accelerated Online (7-Week Courses) +4 On-Campus & Accelerated Online Options +5 Online (16-week semester) and Accelerated + Online Options + + Graduate +Graduate +ADMISSIONS + +While most of our graduate programs have rolling admissions, ideally, you should begin the application +process several months in advance to ensure that you submit all documents on time and to have the best +chance for scholarships and assistantships. +Admissions Checklist: + +Apply online: utrgv.edu/gradapply +Get a certified English translation of your educational records + +Send your official college or university transcripts + +Submit official English Proficiency exam scores. (TOEFL, IELTS or Duolingo English Test) +Send your official GRE or GMAT scores (if applicable)*Note: Due to the impacts of the coronavirus pandemic on +testing centers across the world, we are temporarily suspending the GRE and GMAT test score requirements for + +most graduate programs until Fall 2021. +Other documents requested by the program (varies by program). Review requirements at utrgv.edu/grad +The application fee is waived for all graduate programs, except for Physician Assistant Studies, + +Occupational Therapy, Communication Sciences & Disorders, Physician Assistant Studies Bridge Program, + +and Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner + +*If you will be pursuing your degree as an *International Student, please complete the following steps with International +Admissions & Student Services to finalize your admissions process.*International Student is defined as someone +who is not a U.S. citizen or U.S. resident and has a visa status or will require one to pursue their studies in a U.S. higher +education institution. + +Submit financial documentation + +Submit immigration documents + +To check the status of your application and review the final decision, visit the self-service center at utrgv.edu/selfservice. + +FAQ FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS + +Does my program require the GRE or GMAT? +Not all graduate programs require an entrance exam. +Visit utrgv.edu/graduate to find out +if your program requires one. + +*Note: Due to the impacts of the coronavirus pandemic + +on testing centers across the world, we are temporarily + +suspending the GRE and GMAT test score requirements for + +most graduate programs until Fall 2021. + +Where can I register for the GRE? What is UTRGV’s GRE +code? +You can register to take the GRE at ets.org/gre and send us +your scores using the GRE Code 6570. + +Where can I register for the GMAT? What is UTRGV’s +GMAT code? +You can register to take the GMAT at mba.com and send us +your scores using the GMAT Code 9P3. + +I attended a legacy institution (UT Pan American, UT +Brownsville, or Texas Southmost College). +Do I need to request those transcripts to be sent to +UTRGV? +No, we have access to all transcripts from our legacy +institutions and can upload them to your application. + +I started a graduate application. How do I log back +into my application? +Visit utrgv.edu/selfservice to log in with your username and +password that you previously +created. Do not create another application. + +Where do I send my official transcripts? +You can get them sent electronically to gradapps@utrgv.edu +or mail them to: The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley +The Graduate College +Marialice Shary Shivers Bldg. 1.158 +1201 W. Univesity Dr., Edinburg, TX 78539-2999 + +What are the minimum English Proficiency Exam +scores? +TOEFL minimum: 550 paper based, 79 internet based +IELTS minimum: 6.5 +Duolingo English Test score minimum of 105 +(Applicants with a score of 105 or above may also be +required to participate in a Zoom or Skype interview before +receiving a final decision.) + +How long is a TOEFL or IELTS score valid? +The TOEFL and the IELTS exam scores have a two year +validity period. + +Do you have exemptions for the English Proficiency +Exam (TOELF or IELTS)? +To view a list of exempt countries visit UTRGV.edu/grad + +Do I need to get my transcripts evaluated by an +evaluation agency? +We accept evaluations from the Foreign Credentials Services +of America (FCSA) or the World Education Services (WES). +However, if you have not had your transcript evaluated +by FCSA or WES, you can send us your transcripts to be +evaluated by UTRGV. + +How many credit hours do I need to be enrolled if I +have a F1 visa? +Nine credit hours per semester is the minimum; please +contact the International Admissions and Student Services +Office at international@utrgv.edu for +more details. + +Is proof of health insurance required for +international students? +Medical insurance is mandatory for any enrolled +international students on non-immigrant visa J-1, J-2, F-1, +F-2. An insurance waiver is available for students with +medical coverage. Although, medical insurance is strongly +recommended, F-1/F-2 Mexican students are exempt from +this health insurance requirement. For information on +waivers, contact the International Admissions and Student +Services office at international@utrgv.edu + +Who should I contact to assist me with inquires on +the student visa process? +International Admissions and Student Services +1-(956) 882-7092 | 1- (956) 665-2922 +utrgv.edu/iass | international@utrgv.edu + +12 + +13 + + Research +CENTERS + +At UTRGV, we have 15 research centers and +institutes + +• Center for Advanced Radio Astronomy (CARA) +• Center for Excellence in STEM Education +• University Transportation Center for Railway Safety (UTCRS) +• Texas Manufacturing Assistance Center (TMAC) +• South Texas Industrial Assessment Center +• Spacecraft Tracking and Astronomical Research into Gigahertz + Astrophysical Transient Emission (STARGATE) +• Nanotechnology Center of Excellence +• The Institute for Neuroscience +• Center for Vector-Borne Disease (CVBD) +• Coastal Studies Laboratory +• Center for Sustainable Agriculture & Rural Advancement (SARA) +• Center for Gravitational Wave Astronomy (CGWA) +• The South Texas Diabetes and Obesity Institute (STDOI) +• Dr. Cristina V. Torres Memorial Astronomical Observatory +• Center for Innovation and Commercialization + +KEY RESEARCH +Areas + +• Sustainable Agriculture + + and Food Systems + +• Diabetes, Obesity, and Human + + Genetics + +• Gravitational Wave and + +• Advanced Renewable + + Advanced Radio Astronomy + + Energy + +• Space Science Technology + +• Cell and Molecular + + (STARGATE) + +• Material Science and + + Engineering + +• Nanoscience and + + Nanotechnology + +• Optics + +• Coastal Resilience + + and Disaster Studies + +• Ocean Intelligence + + Biology + +• Biophysics + +• Computational Biology + +• Applied Statistics and + + Data Science + +• Mathematics (nonlinear + + waves, fluid dynamics, + + solitons, integrable + + systems) + +14 + +15 + + Costs & +FINANCING + +Scholarships* +UTRGV has several scholarship opportunities that use the same scholarship application. Scholarships are highly +competitive, so be sure to apply early. Visit utrgv.edu/applyscholarships for more information and to start your +application. + +Graduate College Scholarships + +Each semester the Graduate College may offer a variety of scholarships, dependent upon funding. To view + +what scholarships are currently being offered visit utrgv.edu/gradscholarships. + +Assistantships + +Assistantships give students the opportunity to work on campus (up to 20-hour work weeks) and are + +based on college/institutional demands and funds. Three types of assistantships are offered: + +• Teaching + +• Research + +• Graduate + +Please see your program director about the different assistantships available in your + +field of study. Visit careers.utrgv.edu for additional graduate assistantship opportunities. + +Texas Resident Tuition Rate +The Texas resident tuition rate may be granted to students who receive a teaching or +research assistantship in their discipline or who are awarded a competitive scholarship +of over $1,000. + +Payment Options +UTRGV provides payment plans to assist with the cost of tuition and fees. Eligible students may elect one of two payment +assistance options during the term of registration: + +• Installment Plan: This plan is available to any student unable to pay the full amount or partial amount due by the + university due dates. Installment plans consist of 4 payments. + Note: This is not available for summer sessions and accelerated online students. + +• Emergency Tuition and Fee Loan: This plan defers the payment of qualified tuition and fee charges to a future date. + +You can set up payment plans online through your my.utrgv.edu account within the ASSIST application. For additional +information, contact student_billing@utrgv.edu or call 956-665-7824 or 956-665-2191. + +Estimated Cost of Attendance: Fall 2020 - Summer 2021 + +Online and On-Campus (16-Week Semester) Programs + +Residency + +Texas Resident + +Non-Resident/International + +Per 3-Credit-Hour Course + +Per 9-Credit-Hour Semester + +$1,481.39 + +$2,708.39 + +$3,894.17 + +$7,575.17 + +Accelerated Online (7-Week Module) Programs + +Program + +Per 3-Credit-Hour Course + +Total Cost + +Technology Leadership in Education (Certificate) + +$1,374.99 + +E-Learning (Certificate) + +$1,374.99 + +Online Instructional Designer (Certificate) + +$1,374.99 + +Principal Certification (Certificate) + +$1,374.99 + +$4,125 + +$5,500 + +$5,500 + +$9,625 + +Curriculum & Instruction (MEd) +Educational Leadership (MEd) +Educational Technology (MEd) +Special Education (MEd) + +Social Work 33-Hour (MSSW) + +Social Work (MSSW) (63 Hr) + +Accountancy (MACC) + +Business Analytics (MS) + +Health Sciences (MS) + +$1,374.99 + +$13,750 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,416.66 + +$1,416.66 + +$1,333.32 + +$14,667 + +$27,999 + +$14,170 + +$15,584 + +$16,000 + +12 + +16 + +13 +17 + + Accelerated Online (7-Week Module) Programs + +Program + +Per 3-Credit-Hour Course + +Total Cost + +Health Sciences (Certificate) + +Kinesiology (MS) + +Nursing (MSN) + +Public Affairs (MPA) + +Criminal Justice (MS) + +Business Administration (MBA) + +Business Analytics (MS) + + International Sustainability Management +(Certificate) + +Entrepreneurship (Certificate + +$1,333.32 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,333.32 + +$1,416.66 + +$1,416.66 + +$1,416.66 + +$1,416.66 + +User Experience and User Interface Design + (UX/UI) (Certificate) + +$1,416.66 + +$8,000 + +$16,000 + +$16,000 + +$17,000 + +$16,000 + +$9,625 + +$15,583 + +$5,666 + +$5,666 + +$5,666 + +IMPORTANT CONTACT +Information +Information + +GRADUATE SCHOLARSHIPS +gradscholarships@utrgv.edu + +CONTINUING EDUCATION +continuinged@utrgv.edu + +RESIDENCE LIFE +home@utrgv.edu + +INTERNATIONAL ADMISSIONS +international@utrgv.edu + +LANGUAGE INSTITUTE +international@utrgv.edu + +18 + +19 diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_4.md b/q15/random_k4/random_4.md index d1771f94490a748cfd31a8d039434182828c4f11..89df54c010831780605bc9c91d547406d9ddb498 100644 --- a/q15/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q15/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,2639 +1,2646 @@ -For Immediate Release +Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 1 of 21 -Contact: +Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) +twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com +Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) +rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com +Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) +tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com +Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) +abrown@ahdootwolfson.com +AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC +2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 +Burbank, CA 91505-4521 +Telephone: 310-474-9111 +Facsimile: 310-474-8585 -Ken Bond -Oracle Investor Relations -1.650.607.0349 -ken.bond@oracle.com +Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class -Deborah Hellinger -Oracle Corporate Communications -1.212.508.7935 -deborah.hellinger@oracle.com +UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT -SAAS AND PAAS CLOUD REVENUE UP 32%, SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUE UP 6% TO $6.6 BILLION +NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA -Record Quarterly Operating Cash Flow Up 7% to $6.7 Billion +THOMAS THELE, individually and on +behalf of all others similarly situated, -REDWOOD SHORES, Calif., September 18, 2014 -- Oracle Corporation (NYSE: ORCL) +Case No. 5:25-cv-09704 -today announced that fiscal 2015 Q1 total revenues were up 3% to $8.6 billion. Total Software plus +Plaintiff, -Cloud revenue was up 6% to $6.6 billion. Software-as-a-service (SaaS) and Platform-as-a-service +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -(PaaS) cloud revenue was up 32% to $337 million. Infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) cloud revenue +DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL -was up 26% to $138 million. Hardware systems revenue was down 8% to $1.2 billion. GAAP +v. -operating income was up 3% to $3.0 billion, and the GAAP operating margin was 34%. Non-GAAP +GOOGLE LLC, -operating income was up 2% to $3.8 billion, and the non-GAAP operating margin was 44%. GAAP +Defendant. -net income was unchanged at $2.2 billion while non-GAAP net income was up 2% at $2.8 billion. +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + +- i - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 2 of 21 + +Plaintiff Thomas Thele (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly + +situated (the “Class” or “Class Members”), by and through his undersigned counsel, brings this + +class action complaint against Defendant Google LLC (“Google” or “Defendant”). + +I. + +INTRODUCTION + +1. + +Much like its competitors, Google has developed and deployed an artificial + +intelligence program named Gemini throughout its portfolio of services. Some of Google’s most + +popular services include Gmail, Chat, and Meet, which millions of Americans use every day to + +email, instant message, and videoconference, respectively. Until recently, Google users could “opt + +in” and turn on Gemini as a “Smart” feature for these services, purportedly to “personalize [their] + +experience”: + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + +- 1 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 3 of 21 + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + +2. + +However, on or about October 10, 2025, Google secretly turned on Gemini for all + +its users’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, enabling AI to track its users’ private communications + +contained in those platforms without the users’ knowledge or consent. As of the date of this filing, + +Google continues to track these private communications with Gemini by default, requiring users to + +affirmatively find this data privacy setting and shut it off, despite never “agreeing” to such AI + +tracking in the first place (“When you turn this setting on, you agree . . . .”). + +3. + +Despite users never giving Google informed consent to track and store their private + +communications, Google does just that, using Gemini AI to access and exploit the entire recorded + +history of its users’ private communications, including literally every email and attachment sent + +and received in their Gmail accounts. + +4. + +Google’s deceptive and outrageous conduct violates its users’ reasonable + +expectations of privacy. The intent and efforts of individuals to safeguard their private information + +and communications must be respected. The ramifications of unauthorized access to voluminous + +private communications can be severe, and individuals accordingly go to great lengths to safeguard + +not only their own email and messaging accounts, but, in the case of parents and guardians, also + +that of their minor children. + +5. + +While falsely characterizing its illusory privacy controls, Google deceptively and + +unconscionably deprived and continues to deprive Plaintiff and Class Members of their privacy + +right to send and receive private communications via email, chat, and video. This is true not only + +for Plaintiff and Class Members, but also for their children, whose private communications they + +also sought to protect. + +6. + +Google’s conduct violates the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Pen. Code + +§§ 630, et seq. (“CIPA”)), the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (Cal. Pen. Code § + +502 (“CDAFA”)), the Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq. (“SCA”)), and + +California’s Constitutional Right to Privacy, and it constitutes an unlawful intrusion upon + +seclusion. + +II. + +THE PARTIES + +7. + +Plaintiff Thomas Thele resides in Cook County, Illinois. From at least October 10, + +- 2 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 4 of 21 + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + +2025 until the present, Plaintiff has maintained and used, and continues to maintain and use, his + +Google account, including the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services. Plaintiff values his privacy—and + +the privacy of his family and friends—in the use of these password-protected services and + +reasonably expected the messages and conversations therein to remain private. Despite this + +reasonable expectation, Google surreptitiously turned on the “Smart features” setting in Plaintiff’s + +Data privacy settings without Plaintiff’s knowledge or consent and began tracking Plaintiff’s + +private communications with Gemini AI. Throughout the relevant time period, Plaintiff regularly + +used his Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts throughout the day, unaware that Google’s Gemini AI + +was monitoring and tracking those private messages and conversations. In the interest of protecting + +his privacy and security, Plaintiff does not recite here the precise Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet + +communications that he sent or received with the “Smart features” setting surreptitiously turned on + +during the relevant time, but he does allege that the following could be determined from those + +communications: financial information and records, employment information and records, religious + +affiliations and activities, political affiliations and activities, medical care and records, the identities + +of his family, friends, and other contacts, social habits and activities, eating habits, shopping habits, + +exercise habits, the extent to which he is involved in the activities of his children (if any), and what + +those activities are. + +8. + +Defendant Google LLC is a limited liability company headquartered in Mountain + +View, California, and formed under the laws of Delaware. Google is a sophisticated mobile + +operating system, email, and applications developer in the business of commercializing personal + +data extracted from the use of tools and services connected to the internet. As such, Google is aware + +of and benefits from the conduct described herein. Indeed, this forms a core component, among + +others, of Google’s business model. + +III. + +JURISDICTION AND VENUE + +9. + +This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. + +§§ 1332 and 1367 because this is a class action in which the matter or controversy exceeds the sum + +of $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and in which some Members of the proposed Class + +are citizens of a state different from Defendant. + +- 3 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 5 of 21 + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + +10. + +This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant owns and + +operates a business that is headquartered in this District and conducts substantial business + +throughout California. Defendant expressly consents to the jurisdiction of the federal or state courts + +of Santa Clara County, California through its terms of service.1 + +11. + +Venue properly lies in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1), as Defendant + +is headquartered in this District. + +IV. CHOICE OF LAW + +12. + +California law governs the substantive legal issues in this case. Google’s Terms of + +Service provide in pertinent part that California law will apply to any disputes arising out of or + +relating to Google’s terms of service.2 + +V. + +STATEMENT OF FACTS + +13. + +According to recent reporting, an estimated 1.8 billion people globally in 2025 have + +active Gmail accounts.3 It is estimated that 41.9% of United States citizens use Gmail, which + +amounts to over 130 million American users.4 + +14. + +In Google’s Gmail, Chat, and Meet services, users reasonably expect to customize + +their use of these services to their preferences by managing various functionalities and settings. + +They can, for example, change their preferred language, time zone, or storage settings. Included + +among these functionalities, within “Data privacy,” is the option to turn on or off Google’s use of + +“Smart features”—that is, Google’s ability to track the user’s “email, chat, and video content” with + +its Gemini AI technology. In its terms of service, Google’s only reference to AI is in the context of + +“develop[ing], improv[ing], and updat[ing]” its services: + +We’re constantly developing new technologies and features to improve +our services. For example, we use artificial intelligence and machine +learning to provide you with simultaneous translations, and to better +detect and block spam and malware. As part of this continual + +1 Google Terms of Service (last modified May 22, 2024), available at +https://policies.google.com/terms?hl=en. +2 Id. +3 Robert A. Lee, Gmail Statistics 2025: User Growth, Market Share & Emerging Trends, SQ +MAGAZINE, Aug. 6, 2025, available at https://sqmagazine.co.uk/gmail-statistics/. +4 Id.; see also Dominic Reigns, 35+ Gmail Statistics And User Trends [2025 Updated], ABOUT +CHROMEBOOKS, Aug. 7, 2025, available at https://www.aboutchromebooks.com/gmail-statistics/. +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + +- 4 - + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 6 of 21 + +improvement, we sometimes add or remove features and functionalities, +increase or decrease limits to our services, and start offering new +services or stop offering old ones.5 + +In its privacy policy, Google states that “across our services, you can adjust your privacy settings + +to control whether we collect some types of data and how we use it.”6 + +15. + +On information and belief, Google turned on this “Smart features” option—without + +any notice to users—for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts on or about October 10, 2025, which + +enabled Gemini AI to scan, read, and analyze every email (and email attachment), message, and + +conversation on those services. Google users now must proactively go into their account settings + +and locate and turn off this feature to prevent Gemini AI from tracking their Gmail, Chat, or Meet + +communications. Despite this setting being in default, “opt out” status since at least October 10, + +the setting is still worded as an “opt in” feature: “When you turn this setting on, you agree . . .” + +(emphasis added). Google’s secretive Gmail, Chat, and Meet tracking practices are not only + +deceptive and unethical, they are directly contrary to users’ reasonable expectations of privacy. + +16. + +It appears that even tech journalists monitoring Google’s use of Gemini AI in Gmail + +are not fully aware of this change. Recent articles about using Gemini in Google services like Gmail + +still characterize the feature as something that must be agreed to and affirmatively turned on.7 + +Nonetheless, this reporting confirms that, when active, Gemini is “downright creepy” in its ability + +to track, analyze, and immediately know private information: + +In testing [Gemini in Gmail], it was able to tell me useful information, +such as when my next Trade coffee delivery would arrive and if I had +any pressing emails that required responses. But it goes far beyond that. + +When I asked it about my first crush, Gemini was able to determine that +it occurred in elementary school, as well as tell me the name of my first +love, how we met, and when. Upon request, Gemini also told me who +my top Facebook friends were in 2009 and who my best friend was in +2010. Gemini even explained that one of my character flaws is that I get +“too laser-focused on what [I] want, which extracts a toll on [my] +relationships, much like Drake from the Uncharted game.” And, yes, + +5 Supra n.1. +6 Google Privacy Policy (last modified July 1, 2025), available at +https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US. +7 Ruben Circelli, I Let Gemini Access My Gmail, and It’s Downright Creepy, PC MAG, Nov. 5, +2025, available at https://www.pcmag.com/opinions/i-let-gemini-access-my-gmail-and-its- +downright-creepy. + +- 5 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 7 of 21 + +that’s one of my favorite game franchises, which apparently Gemini +knows, too. + +How does Gemini know that? The simple answer is that the information +is somewhere within the 16 years’ worth of my email history that it can +access. + +. . . . + +I don’t plan on letting Gemini access my personal email anymore.8 + +17. + +Google is now able to collect and utilize users’ private communications through AI + +“Smart features” and combine it with existing data profiles it has for its users. Back in 2012, Google + +announced that it would eliminate distinctions between data collected from different Google + +products and services for purposes of its advertising, data analysis, and other activities, saying + +specifically that Google “may combine information you’ve provided from one service with + +information from other services,” and “[w]e’ll treat you as a single user across all our products.”9 + +18. + +Through the use of its Gemini AI technology, Google has created the means to + +illicitly compile all of its users’ private communications on its platforms without those users’ + +express knowledge and consent. The data from these communications enables Google to cross- + +reference and conduct unlimited analysis toward unmerited, improper, and monetizable insights + +into users’ private lives, including their social, professional, and other relationships. + +19. + +The collection and use of users’ private communications violates users’ reasonable + +expectations of privacy, and also puts them at increased risk for further privacy violations. Data + +breaches and other security vulnerabilities are increasingly common among companies that store + +user data. As a major aggregator of valuable personally identifying and other information, Google + +is an obvious target for hackers. Any information that Google stores through its Gemini AI platform + +may eventually be stolen, if it has not already been. In 2018, for example, Google announced that + +it had discovered a vulnerability in its Google+ program that exposed personal account information + +to third-parties, contrary to its user agreements and representations. Reportedly, in order to protect + +8 Id. +9 Alma Whitten, Updating our privacy policies and terms of service, GOOGLE OFFICIAL BLOG +(Jan. 24, 2012), available at https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/updating-our-privacy- +policies-and-terms.html. + +- 6 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +6 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 8 of 21 + +its public image, Google failed to disclose that information to the public for months, and came clean + +only after the security risk was discovered by the media.10 + +20. + +Each of the following acts defy social norms and invade reasonable privacy + +expectations: tracking private communications contrary to users’ consent, misleading users + +regarding whether the AI tracking required the users to opt out, and failing to disclose how AI was + +monitoring, tracking, and utilizing these private communications. Normally, mobile device and + +Internet users such as Plaintiff are able to affirmatively control the flow of sensitive information + +about themselves through “settings” and “permissions” that they grant, or withhold, from third + +parties, particularly private parties such as Google. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ expectations + +that those settings and permissions would be heeded and effective, and that they could send and + +receive communications privately without being tracked by Google, are eminently reasonable. + +21. + +Plaintiff and Class Members took specific steps to protect their private + +communications (as well as the private communications of their minor children) and had a + +reasonable expectation that Google would not use AI to monitor and track their private + +communications without their informed consent. Based on Google’s representations and omissions, + +context, and industry norms, they expected Google to heed and follow their instructions and, as a + +result, expected that their private communications would be private, not tracked and utilized by + +Google’s AI tool for Google’s own benefit and to the detriment of their personal privacy. Those + +reasonable expectations were consistent with sentiments that are widely shared in American society + +and elsewhere, and grounded in long-standing social norms and jurisprudence protecting privacy. + +22. + +Invasion of privacy has been recognized as a common law tort for more than a + +century. In Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965), the Supreme Court confirmed the + +primacy of privacy rights, explaining that the Constitution operates in the shadow of a “right of + +10 Douglas MacMillan and Robert McMillan, Google Exposed User Data, Feared Repercussions +of Disclosing to Public, THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (Oct. 8, 2018), available at +https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared-repercussions-of-disclosing-to- +public-1539017194. Shortly thereafter, Google shut down the Google+ product entirely. Bill +Chappell, Google Accelerates Google+ Shutdown After 52.5 Million Users’ Data Exposed, NPR +(Dec. 11, 2018), available at https://www.npr.org/2018/12/11/675529798/with-52-5-million- +users-data-exposed-on-google-google-quickens-shutdown. + +- 7 - + +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + +1 -GAAP earnings per share were $0.48, up 2% compared to last year while non-GAAP earnings per +2 + +3 + +4 -share were $0.62, up 4%. GAAP operating cash flow on a trailing twelve-month basis was $15.4 +5 -billion. +6 -“We are increasing our cloud services growth rate while simultaneously delivering record +7 -levels of cash flow,” said Oracle CEO, Safra Catz. “In Q1, our overall cloud services business grew +8 -more than 30% to $475 million in revenue. At the same time, we delivered an all-time record +9 -operating cash flow up 7% to $6.7 billion. We are laser focused on two goals: growing our cloud +10 -business and growing our cash flow. We’re off to a good start in FY15.” +11 -“Our internally developed Fusion cloud applications business grew at a rate of nearly 200% +12 -in the quarter,” said Oracle CEO, Mark Hurd. “As our hyper-growth Fusion applications become a +13 -larger and larger portion of our total SaaS sales, that will drive up our overall cloud services growth +14 -rate. Our cloud business is already three times the size of Workday, but we won’t be satisfied until +15 -we’re number one in the cloud.” +16 -“Next week at Oracle Open World, we will be rolling out our database cloud service,” said +17 -Oracle Executive Chairman and Chief Technology Officer, Larry Ellison. “Database is our largest +18 - software business, and database will be our largest cloud service. With our new multitenant Database +19 -as a Service offering, our customers and ISV’s can move any of their existing Oracle databases and +20 -applications to the Oracle Cloud with the push of a button.” +21 -The Board of Directors also declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.12 per share of +22 -outstanding common stock. This dividend will be paid to stockholders of record as of the close of +23 -business on October 8, 2014, with a payment date of October 29, 2014. +24 -Oracle also announced that its Board of Directors authorized the repurchase of up to an +25 -additional $13.0 billion of common stock under its existing share repurchase program in future +26 -quarters. +27 -Q1 Fiscal 2015 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast +28 -Oracle will hold a conference call and webcast today to discuss these results at 2:00 p.m. + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 9 of 21 -Pacific. You may listen to the call by dialing (816) 287-5563, Passcode: 425392. To access the live +1 -webcast of this event, please visit the Oracle Investor Relations website at +2 -http://www.oracle.com/investor. In addition, Oracle’s Q1 results and Fiscal 2015 financial tables are +3 -available on the Oracle Investor Relations website. +4 -A replay of the conference call will also be available by dialing (855) 859-2056 or (404) 537- +5 -3406, Passcode: 99926438. +6 -About Oracle +7 -Oracle engineers hardware and software to work together in the cloud and in your data center. For more +8 -information about Oracle (NYSE: ORCL), visit www.oracle.com or contact Investor Relations at +9 -investor_us@oracle.com or (650) 506-4073. +10 -# # # +11 -Trademarks +12 -Oracle and Java are registered trademarks of Oracle and/or its affiliates. Other names may be trademarks +13 -of their respective owners. +14 - "Safe Harbor" Statement: Statements in this press release relating to Oracle's future plans, -expectations, beliefs, intentions and prospects, including statements regarding our cloud services -growth rate, growing our cash flow, our plans to be number one in the cloud, our Database as a -Service offering and that database will be our largest cloud service, are "forward-looking statements" +15 - and are subject to material risks and uncertainties. Many factors could affect our current expectations -and our actual results, and could cause actual results to differ materially. We presently consider the -following to be among the important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from -expectations: (1) Economic, geopolitical and market conditions, including the continued slow -economic recovery in the U.S. and other parts of the world, can adversely affect our business, results -of operations and financial condition, including our revenue growth and profitability, which in turn -could adversely affect our stock price. (2) We may fail to achieve our financial forecasts due to such -factors as delays or size reductions in transactions, fewer large transactions in a particular quarter, -unanticipated fluctuations in currency exchange rates, delays in delivery of new products or releases -or a decline in our renewal rates for support contracts. (3) Our cloud computing strategy, including -our Oracle Cloud Software-as-a-Service, Platform-as-a-Service, Infrastructure-as-a-Service and our -new Database as a Service offerings, may not be successful. (4) If we are unable to develop new or -sufficiently differentiated products and services, or to enhance and improve our products and support -services in a timely manner or to position and/or price our products and services to meet market -demand, customers may not buy new software licenses, cloud software subscriptions or hardware -systems products or purchase or renew support contracts. (5) Our international sales and operations -subject us to additional risks that can adversely affect our operating results, including risks relating -to foreign currency gains and losses. (6) If the security measures for our software, hardware, services -or Oracle Cloud offerings are compromised or if such offerings contain significant coding, -manufacturing or configuration errors, we may experience reputational harm, legal claims and -financial exposure. (7) We have an active acquisition program and our acquisitions may not be -successful, may involve unanticipated costs or other integration issues or may disrupt our existing -operations. A detailed discussion of these factors and other risks that affect our business is contained -in our SEC filings, including our most recent reports on Form 10-K and Form 10-Q, particularly -under the heading "Risk Factors." Copies of these filings are available online from the SEC or by -contacting Oracle Corporation's Investor Relations Department at (650) 506-4073 or by clicking on -SEC Filings on Oracle’s Investor Relations website at http://www.oracle.com/investor. All -information set forth in this press release is current as of September 18, 2014. Oracle undertakes no -duty to update any statement in light of new information or future events. +16 - ORACLE CORPORATION - Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS -($ in millions, except per share data) +17 -Three Months Ended August 31, +18 -2014 +19 -% of -Revenues +20 -2013 +21 -% of -Revenues +22 -% Increase -(Decrease) -in US $ +23 -% Increase -(Decrease) -in Constant -Currency (1) +24 -REVENUES +25 -New software licenses -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support +26 -$ +27 -1,370 -337 -138 -4,731 +28 -Software and Cloud Revenues +privacy older than the Bill of Rights.” For its part, California amended its constitution in 1972 to -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support +specifically enumerate a right to privacy in its very first section. See Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1. -Hardware Systems Revenues +23. -Services Revenues +Google itself has long acknowledged the importance of user control over privacy - Total Revenues +settings. In 2018, Google’s Chief Privacy Officer testified to United States Senate Committee on -OPERATING EXPENSES -Sales and marketing -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support -Services -Research and development -General and administrative -Amortization of intangible assets -Acquisition related and other -Restructuring - - Total Operating Expenses - -OPERATING INCOME -OPERATING INCOME -Interest expense -Non-operating income, net - -INCOME BEFORE PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES - -Provision for income taxes - -8,596 +Commerce, Science, and Transportation that “users trust [Google] to keep their personal -100% +information confidential and under their control.”11 -8,372 +24. -100% +According to a poll by the Pew Research Center, 93% of adults believe that being -16% -4% -1% -55% +in control of who can get information about them is important, and 90% believe that controlling -76% -7% -7% +what information is collected about them is important.12 Additionally, Americans say they do not -14% +approve of observation without consent: 88% say it is important that they not have someone watch -10% +or listen to them without their permission.13 -$ +25. -1,399 -254 -109 -4,431 +According to a 2013 Pew Research study, “86% of Internet users have tried to be -6,193 -669 -592 +anonymous online and taken at least one step to try to mask their behavior or avoid being tracked.”14 -1,261 +For example, 64% percent of adults claim to clear their cookies and browser histories in an attempt -918 +to be less visible online. 15 Such behaviors exemplify people’s expectation that their personal -17% -3% -1% -53% +information will not be tracked by others without their consent or permission, and that settings -74% -8% -7% +claiming to allow them to protect such information will be effective. -15% +26. -11% +A 2010 study comparing the opinions of young adults between the ages of 18 to 24 -20% -2% -1% -3% -4% -2% -8% -16% -3% -6% -0% -1% +with other age categories (25-34, 35-44, 45-54, 55-64, and 65+) found that a large percentage of -66% +young adults were in harmony with older Americans regarding concerns about online privacy, -34% -34% -(3%) -0% +11 Written Testimony of Keith Enright Chief Privacy Officer, United States Senate Committee on +Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Examining Safeguards for Consumer Data Privacy, +(Sept. 26, 2018), available at https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/17926-keith-enright-chief- +privacy-officer-google (emphasis added). +12 Mary Madden and Lee Rainie, Americans’ Attitudes About Privacy, Security and Surveillance, +PEW RESEARCH CENTER (May 20, 2015), available at +https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2015/05/20/americans-attitudes-about-privacy-security- +and-surveillance/. +13 Id. +14 Lee Rainie, et al., Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online, PEW RESEARCH CENTER (Sept. 5, +2013) available at https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2013/09/05/anonymity-privacy-and- +security-online/. +15 Id. -31% -6% +- 8 - -25% +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -1,620 -102 -72 -288 -330 -209 -720 -1,237 -260 -595 -10 -56 + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 10 of 21 -5,499 +1 -2,873 -2,873 -(217) -7 +2 -2,663 -472 +3 -$ +4 -2,191 +5 -19% -1% -1% -3% -4% -3% -9% -15% -3% -7% -0% -1% +6 -66% +7 -34% -34% -(2%) -0% +8 -32% -6% +9 -26% +10 -6,576 -578 -587 +11 -1,165 +12 -855 +13 -1,706 -149 -79 -272 -298 -192 -691 -1,329 -276 -547 -25 -69 +14 -5,633 +15 -2,963 -2,963 -(261) 16 -2,718 -534 +17 -(2%) -32% -26% -7% +18 -6% -(14%) -(1%) +19 -(8%) +20 -(7%) +21 -3% +22 -5% -47% -10% -(5%) -(10%) -(8%) -(4%) -7% -6% -(8%) -138% -23% +23 -2% +24 -3% -3% -21% -144% +25 -2% -13% +26 -0% +27 -(2%) -32% -25% -6% +28 -6% -(14%) -(2%) +norms, and policy suggestions.16 For example, 88% of young adults surveyed responded that “there -(8%) +should be a law that requires websites and advertising companies to delete all stored information -(8%) +about an individual”; for individuals in the 45-54 age range, 94% approved of such a law.17 -2% +27. -5% -45% -9% -(6%) -(10%) -(9%) -(5%) -7% -5% -(8%) -134% -21% +The same study noted that “[o]ne way to judge a person’s concern about privacy -2% +laws is to ask about the penalties that companies or individuals should pay for breaching them.” A -2% -2% -21% -80% +majority of the 18- to 24-year-olds polled selected the highest dollar amount of punishment (“more -1% -12% +than $2,500”) in response to how a company should be fined if it purchases or uses someone’s -(1%) +personal information illegally; across all age groups, 69% of individuals opted for the highest fine. -NET INCOME +Beyond a fine, approximately half of the sample (across all age groups) chose the harshest penalties -$ +for companies using a person’s information illegally: putting them out of business and imposing -2,184 +jail time.18 -EARNINGS PER SHARE: +28. -Basic -Diluted +Google claimed to offer people a choice when it came to data privacy. In purporting -WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING: +to offer users the ability to adjust data privacy settings to control whether Google’s AI technology -Basic -Diluted +accesses their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, Google warranted that it would respect those users’ -$ -$ +privacy choices. In reality, Google rendered users’ choices meaningless when it surreptitiously -0.49 -0.48 +turned on the “Smart features” setting for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet users without their knowledge -$ -$ +or consent. Google’s AI tracking of users’ private communications was surreptitious and purposely -0.48 -0.47 +deceptive, as they did not provide notification of this change, thus requiring users to discover this -4,451 -4,548 +change on their own and manually turn off the “Smart features” setting. -4,608 -4,674 +29. -(1) +Not only were Google’s representations about privacy likely to deceive people, -We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to -provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, -current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange -rates in effect on May 31, 2014, which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. Movements -in international currencies relative to the United States dollar during the three months ended August 31, 2014 compared with the corresponding prior year period -increased our revenues by 1 percentage point and operating income by 1 percentage point. +Google did in fact deceive the millions of people who use Gmail, Chat, and Meet. Ordinary users, - 1 +including Plaintiff, reasonably expected that their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts would not be - ORACLE CORPORATION - Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -RECONCILIATION OF SELECTED GAAP MEASURES TO NON-GAAP MEASURES (1) -($ in millions, except per share data) +tracked and stored by AI unless they affirmatively turned on that feature in their Google accounts. -Three Months Ended August 31, +16 Chris Hoofnagle, et al., How Different Are Young Adults from Older Adults When It Comes to +Information Privacy Attitudes & Policies, University of Pennsylvania Scholarly Commons (April +14, 2010), available at +https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/privacy-roundtables- +comment-project-no.p095416-544506-00125/544506-00125.pdf. +17 Id. +18 Id. -% Increase (Decrease) -in US $ +- 9 - -% Increase (Decrease) in -Constant Currency (2) +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -2014 -GAAP + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 11 of 21 -Adj. +30. -2014 -Non-GAAP +Google’s misrepresentations continue, despite public reporting. Users are still being -2013 -GAAP +deceived and tracked without consent unless they are made aware of the change to their data privacy -Adj. +settings and affirmatively turn off the “Smart features” setting, which is still worded in terms that -2013 -Non-GAAP +deceptively suggest it is something that must be agreed to and turned on by the user, not Google. -GAAP +VI. CLASS ALLEGATIONS -Non-GAAP +31. -GAAP +Plaintiff brings this class action, pursuant to Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil -Non-GAAP +Procedure, individually and on behalf of all members of the following class, which is referred to -TOTAL REVENUES (3) (4) +throughout this Complaint as the “Class”: -$ +All natural persons residing in the United States with Google +accounts whose private communications in Gmail, Chat, and/or +Meet were tracked by Google’s Gemini AI after Google turned on +“Smart features” in those persons’ data privacy account settings. -8,596 +32. -$ -3 +Excluded from each Class are the following individuals: officers and directors of -$ +Google and its parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, any entity in which Google has a controlling interest, -8,599 +and all judges assigned to hear any aspect of this litigation, as well as their immediate family -$ +members. -8,372 +33. -$ -9 +Plaintiff reserves the right to modify or amend the Class definition before the Court -$ +determines whether certification is appropriate. -8,381 +34. -TOTAL SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUES (3) +This action readily satisfies the requirements set forth under Federal Rule of Civil -$ +Procedure 23: -6,576 +a. -$ -2 +Each Class is so numerous that joinder of all Members is impracticable. -$ +Upon information and belief, Class Members number in the millions. -6,578 +b. -$ +There are questions of law or fact common to the Class. These questions -6,193 +include, but are not limited to, the following: -$ -4 +i. -$ +Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount -6,197 +to the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording device to eavesdrop upon or record” -New software licenses -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service (3) -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support +confidential communications in violation of CIPA; -1,370 -337 -138 -4,731 +- 10 - -- -2 -- -- +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -1,370 -339 -138 -4,731 +1 -1,399 -254 -109 -4,431 +2 -- 3 -- -1 -1,399 -257 -109 -4,432 +4 + +5 -TOTAL HARDWARE SYSTEMS REVENUES (4) +6 -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support (4) +7 -TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES -Stock-based compensation (5) -Amortization of intangible assets (6) -Acquisition related and other -Restructuring +8 -OPERATING INCOME +9 -OPERATING MARGIN % +10 -INCOME TAX EFFECTS (7) +11 -NET INCOME +12 -$ +13 -1,165 -578 -587 +14 -1 -$ -- -1 +15 -$ +16 + +17 + +18 -1,166 -578 -588 +19 -$ +20 -1,261 -669 -592 +21 -$ +22 + +23 + +24 -5,633 -212 -547 25 -69 -$ +26 -(853) -(212) -(547) -(25) -(69) +27 -$ +28 -4,780 -- -- -- -- + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 12 of 21 -$ +1 -5,499 -198 -595 -10 -56 +2 + +3 + +4 5 -$ -- -5 -$ +6 + +7 + +8 -(859) -(198) -(595) -(10) -(56) +9 -$ +10 -1,266 -669 -597 +11 -$ +12 -4,640 -- -- -- -- +13 -$ +14 -2,963 +15 -$ +16 -856 +17 -$ +18 -3,819 +19 -$ +20 -2,873 +21 -$ +22 -868 +23 -$ +24 -3,741 +25 -3% +26 -34% +27 -44% +28 -34% +ii. -45% +Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount -15 bp. +to “tampering, interference, damage, and unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data -(22) bp. +and computer systems” in violation of CDAFA; -$ +iii. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount -534 +to “intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic -$ +communication service is provided” in violation of the SCA; -234 +iv. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount -$ +to egregious breaches of social norms; -768 +v. -$ +Whether Google acted intentionally in violating Plaintiff’s and Class -472 +Members’ privacy rights; -$ +vi. Whether an injunction should issue; and -298 +vii. Whether declaratory relief should be granted. -$ +c. -770 +Plaintiff’s claims are typical of the claims of the Class. Plaintiff and Class -13% +Members maintained private, password-protected Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts that they -$ +thought were secure and not being tracked by Google. Despite these efforts and contrary to -2,184 +Google’s representations, Plaintiff and Class Members nonetheless had their Gmail, Chat, and/or -$ +Meet accounts tracked by Google’s AI technology. Plaintiff and Class Members did not consent to -622 +Google’s tracking of their private communications, which forms the basis for this suit. -$ +d. -2,806 +Moreover, like all Class Members, Plaintiff suffered a substantial risk of -$ +repeated injury in the future. Plaintiff continues to use the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services that -2,191 +are capable of being tracked by Google’s Gemini AI, and Google may unilaterally change his -$ +privacy settings again in the future. Google has shown deliberate indifference to Plaintiff’s and -570 +Class Members’ desire to keep their communications private, and has indeed taken pains to deceive -$ +and mislead Plaintiff (and all Class Members) and to conduct its business contrary to their privacy -2,761 +rights, and contrary to the plain meaning of its own terms of service in favor of surreptitiously and -3% +deceitfully monitoring their private communications. Google’s deceptive and deliberate actions -6% +have thwarted and continue to threaten Plaintiff’s (and Class Members’) ability to exercise control -(2%) -32% -26% -7% +over their own privacy while using their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. Because the conduct -(8%) -(14%) -(1%) +- 11 - -2% -7% -(8%) -138% -23% +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -0% + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 13 of 21 -2% +1 -3% +2 -6% +3 -(2%) -32% -26% -7% +4 -(8%) -(14%) -(2%) +5 -3% -* -* -* -* +6 -2% +7 -0% +8 -2% +9 -4% +10 -2% +11 -6% +12 -(2%) -32% -25% -6% +13 -(8%) -(14%) -(2%) +14 -2% -7% -(8%) -134% -21% +15 -2% +16 -8 bp. +17 -12% +18 -(1%) +19 -1% +20 -(3%) +21 -2% +22 -6% +23 -(2%) -31% -25% -6% +24 -(8%) -(14%) -(2%) +25 -2% -* -* -* -* +26 -1% +27 -(25) bp. +28 -(1%) +complained of herein is systemic, Plaintiff and Class Members face substantial risk of the same -1% +injury in the future. Google’s conduct is common to all Class Members and represents a common -4% +pattern of conduct resulting in injury to all Class Members. Plaintiff has suffered the harm alleged -(3%) +and has no interests antagonistic to any other Class member. -DILUTED EARNINGS PER SHARE +e. -$ +Plaintiff will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the Class. -0.48 +Plaintiff’s interests do not conflict with the interests of the Class Members. Furthermore, Plaintiff -$ +has retained competent counsel experienced in class action litigation, consumer protection -0.62 +litigation, and electronic privacy litigation. Plaintiff’s counsel will fairly and adequately protect and -$ +represent the interests of the Class. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)(4) and 23(g) are satisfied. -0.47 +f. -$ +In acting as alleged above, and in failing and refusing to cease and desist -0.59 +despite being exposed, Google has acted on grounds generally applicable to the entire Class, -DILUTED WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING +thereby making final injunctive relief and corresponding declaratory relief each appropriate with -4,548 +respect to the Class as a whole. The prosecution of separate actions by individual Class Members -- +would create the risk of inconsistent or varying adjudications with respect to individual Class -4,548 +Members that would establish incompatible standards of conduct for Google. -4,674 +g. -- +Injunctive relief is necessary to prevent further unlawful and unfair conduct -4,674 +by Google. Money damages, alone, could not afford adequate and complete relief, and injunctive -(3%) +relief is necessary to restrain Google from continuing to commit its illegal and unfair violations of -(3%) +privacy. -(1) +VII. CAUSES OF ACTION -(2) + Count One +(Violations of CIPA, Cal. Pen. Code §§ 630, et seq.) -This presentation includes non-GAAP measures. Our non-GAAP measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures, and should be read only in conjunction with our consolidatedfinancial statements prepared in -accordance with GAAP. For a detailed explanation of the adjustments made to comparable GAAP measures, the reasons why management uses these measures, the usefulness of these measures and the material limitations on the usefulness of these measures, -please see Appendix A. +35. -We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of -foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014, -which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. +36. -(3) +Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. -As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to assumed cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules. +Cal. Pen. Code § 630 provides that “[t]he Legislature hereby declares that advances -(4) +in science and technology have led to the development of new devices and techniques for the -As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to hardware systems support contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules. +purpose of eavesdropping upon private communication and that the invasion of privacy resulting -(43) -(2) -(1) -( ) -(5) -(1) -(1) -(6) -(108) -(45) -(212) -(3) -(215) +from the continual and increasing use of such devices and techniques has created a serious threat -Non-GAAP -- -$ -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -$ -- +to the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot be tolerated in a free and civilized society.” -Three Months Ended -August 31, 2013 -Adj. -$ +- 12 - -GAAP +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -$ + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 14 of 21 -39 -2 1 -6 + 2 + 3 -6 -97 -42 -198 -2 -200 - -(39) -(2) -(1) -( ) -(6) -(2) -(3) -(6) -(97) -(42) -(198) -(2) -(200) - -Non-GAAP -- -$ -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -$ -- - -$ - -$ - -$ - -$ - -(5) - -Stock-based compensation was included in the following GAAP operating expense categories: - -Three Months Ended -August 31, 2014 - -GAAP - -$ - -Adj. -$ - - Sales and marketing - Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service - Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service - Software license updates and product support - Hardware systems products - Hardware systems support - Services - Research and development - General and administrative - Subtotal - Acquisition related and other - Total stock-based compensation - -Remainder of Fiscal 2015 -Fiscal 2016 -Fiscal 2017 -Fiscal 2018 -Fiscal 2019 -Fiscal 2020 -Thereafter - -Total intangible assets subject to amortization - -In-process research and development - -Total intangible assets, net - -43 -2 -1 + +4 + 5 -1 -1 + 6 -108 -45 -212 -3 -215 - -1,395 -1,345 -749 -611 -511 -387 -592 -5,590 + +7 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + 15 -5,605 -$ +16 -$ +17 -(6) +18 -Estimated future annual amortization expense related to intangible assets as of August 31, 2014 was as follows: +19 -(7) +20 -Income tax effects were calculated reflecting an effective GAAP tax rate of 19.7% and 17.7% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively, and an effective non-GAAP tax rate of 21.5% and 21.8% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively. -The differences between our GAAP and non-GAAP tax rates in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014 were primarily due to the net tax effects of acquisition related items, including the tax effects of amortization of intangible assets. +21 -* Not meaningful +22 - 2 - 2 +23 - ORACLE CORPORATION +24 -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS -($ in millions) +25 -ASSETS +26 -Current Assets: +27 -Cash and cash equivalents -Marketable securities -Trade receivables, net -Inventories -Deferred tax assets -Prepaid expenses and other current assets +28 -Total Current Assets +37. -Non-Current Assets: +Google’s acts and practices complained of herein, engaged in for purposes of - Property, plant and equipment, net - Intangible assets, net - Goodwill - Deferred tax assets - Other assets +tracking and storing indefinitely the private communications of its users without their consent— -Total Non-Current Assets +and indeed in direct contravention of Google’s own wording of the “Smart features” setting that -TOTAL ASSETS +suggests it must be turned on to “opt in,” when, in reality, Google has already secretly turned it on -LIABILITIES AND EQUITY +and requires users to find the setting and turn it off to “opt out”—violated and continues to violate -Current Liabilities: +Cal. Pen. Code § 632. -August 31, -2014 +38. -May 31, -2014 +Cal. Pen. Code § 632 prohibits the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording -$ +device to eavesdrop upon or record [a] confidential communication, whether the communication is -24,179 -27,437 -3,551 -179 -833 -2,015 +carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, -$ +or other device . . . .” -17,769 -21,050 -6,087 -189 -914 -2,129 +39. -58,194 +In direct violation of this prohibition and without the consent of Plaintiff or Class -3,086 -5,605 -29,707 -916 -2,218 +Members, Google has been using its Gemini AI technology to eavesdrop and record the confidential -41,532 +communications of Plaintiff and Class Members on their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. -48,138 +40. -3,061 -6,137 -29,652 -837 -2,519 +Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private -42,206 +communications from California. On information and belief, Google uses servers located in -$ +California that allow Google to access private communications of Plaintiff and Class Members. -99,726 +Google’s terms of service indicate that California law controls the use of its services. -$ +41. -90,344 +As a result of Google’s violations of Cal. Pen. Code § 632, Plaintiff and Class -Notes payable, current and other current borrowings -Notes payable, current and other current borrowings -Accounts payable -Accrued compensation and related benefits -Income taxes payable -Deferred revenues -Other current liabilities +Members are entitled to the following relief: -- -$ -$ -423 -1,491 -425 -8,939 -2,099 +a. -$ -$ +b. -1,508 -1,508 -471 -1,940 -416 -7,269 -2,785 +c. -Total Current Liabilities +A declaration that Google’s conduct violates CIPA; -Non-Current Liabilities: +Statutory damages and/or trebled actual damages; -Notes payable and other non-current borrowings -Income taxes payable -Other non-current liabilities +Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from -Total Non-Current Liabilities +continuing to access Class Members’ private communications in violation of CIPA; -Equity +d. -13,377 +Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order requiring Google to -32,567 -4,148 -1,703 +destroy all data created or otherwise obtained from its illegal tracking of Class Members’ private -38,418 +communications; and -47,931 +e. -14,389 +An award of attorney’s fees and costs of litigation as provided by CIPA, the -22,667 -4,184 -1,657 +private attorney general doctrine existing at common law and also codified at California Civil Code -28,508 +- 13 - -47,447 +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 15 of 21 -$ +1 -99,726 +2 -$ +3 -90,344 +4 - 3 - 3 +5 - ORACLE CORPORATION +6 -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +7 -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS -($ in millions) +8 -Cash Flows From Operating Activities: +9 -Net income -Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities: +10 -Depreciation -Amortization of intangible assets -Deferred income taxes -Stock-based compensation -Tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards -Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards -Other, net -Changes in operating assets and liabilities, net of effects from acquisitions: +11 -Decrease in trade receivables, net -Decrease in inventories -Decrease in prepaid expenses and other assets -Decrease in accounts payable and other liabilities -Increase (decrease) in income taxes payable -Increase in deferred revenues +12 -Net cash provided by operating activities +13 -Cash Flows From Investing Activities: +14 -Purchases of marketable securities and other investments -Proceeds from maturities and sales of marketable securities and other investments -Acquisitions, net of cash acquired -Capital expenditures +15 -Net cash used for investing activities +16 -Cash Flows From Financing Activities: +17 -Payments for repurchases of common stock -Proceeds from issuances of common stock -Payments of dividends to stockholders -Proceeds from borrowings, net of issuance costs -Repayments of borrowings -Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards -Distributions to noncontrolling interests +18 -Net cash provided by financing activities +19 -Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents +20 -Net increase in cash and cash equivalents +21 -Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period +22 -Cash and cash equivalents at end of period +23 -Three Months Ended August 31, +24 -2014 +25 -2013 +26 -$ +27 -2,184 +28 -$ +Section 1021.5, and all other applicable laws. -2,191 +Count Two +(Intrusion Upon Seclusion) -160 -547 -(68) -215 -96 -(51) -46 +42. -2,506 -10 -275 -(1,088) -80 -1,816 +43. -6,728 +Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. -(10,340) -3,878 -(37) -(201) +Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, -(6,700) +Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications -(2,000) -588 -(537) -9,945 -(1,500) -51 -(27) +contained in these accounts. -6,520 +44. -(138) +The reasonableness of such expectations of privacy is supported by Google’s unique -6,410 +position to monitor Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private communications through its access to -17,769 +Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. It is further supported by the -150 -595 -(101) -200 -67 -(40) -17 +surreptitious nature of Google’s tracking. -2,707 -5 -366 -(994) -(313) -1,442 +45. -6,292 +Defendant intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ -(8,549) -6,515 -(1,314) -(153) +solitude, seclusion, or private affairs by intentionally using AI to track their private -(3,501) +communications. -(2,968) -285 -(554) -5,566 -- +46. -40 -(28) +These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications -2,341 +sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information -(81) +and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. -5,051 +Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff -14,613 +and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact -$ +that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the -24,179 +consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. -$ +47. -19,664 +Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs - 4 - 4 +as detailed throughout this Complaint. - ORACLE CORPORATION -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -FREE CASH FLOW - TRAILING 4-QUARTERS (1) -($ in millions) +48. -Q1 +Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in -Fiscal 2014 +causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. -Q2 +49. -Q3 +As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and -Q4 +punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive -Q1 +damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were -Q2 +- 14 - -Q3 +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -Q4 + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 16 of 21 -Fiscal 2015 +1 -GAAP Operating Cash Flow +2 -$ +3 -14,845 +4 -$ +5 -15,196 +6 -$ +7 -15,029 +8 -$ +9 -14,921 +10 -$ +11 -15,357 +12 -Capital Expenditures (2) +13 -(664) +14 -(578) +15 -(609) +16 -(580) +17 -(628) +18 -Free Cash Flow +19 -$ +20 -14,181 +21 -$ +22 -14,618 +23 -$ +24 -14,420 +25 -$ +26 -14,341 +27 -$ +28 -14,729 +calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and -% Growth over prior year +Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in -6% +future misconduct. -14% +Count Three +(California Constitutional Right to Privacy, Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1) -11% +50. -6% +51. -4% +Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. -GAAP Net Income +Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, -$ +Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications -11,082 +contained in these accounts. -$ +52. -11,054 +Google intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ solitude, -$ +seclusion, right of privacy, or private affairs by intentionally tracking the private communications. -11,115 +53. -$ +These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications -10,955 +sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information -$ +and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. -10,948 +Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff -Free Cash Flow as a % of Net Income +and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact -128% +that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the -132% +consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. -130% +54. -131% +Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs -135% +as detailed throughout this Complaint. -(1) +55. -To supplement our statements of cash flows presented on a GAAP basis, we use non-GAAP measures of cash flows on a trailing 4-quarter basis to analyze cash flow generated -from operations. We believe free cash flow is also useful as one of the bases for comparing our performance with our competitors. The presentation of non-GAAP free cash flow is -not meant to be considered in isolation or as an alternative to net income as an indicator of our performance, or as an alternative to cash flows from operating activities as a -measure of liquidity. +Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in -(2) +causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. -Derived from capital expenditures as reported in cash flows from investing activities as per our consolidated statements of cash flows presented in accordance with GAAP. +56. - 5 5 +As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and - ORACLE CORPORATION -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -SUPPLEMENTAL ANALYSIS OF GAAP REVENUES AND HEADCOUNT (1) -($ in millions) +punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive -Q1 +damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were -Q2 +calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and -Fiscal 2014 -Q3 +Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in -Q4 +future misconduct. -TOTAL +- 15 - -Q1 +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -Q2 + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 17 of 21 -Fiscal 2015 -Q3 +1 -Q4 +2 -TOTAL +3 -REVENUES -New software licenses -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support +4 -Software and Cloud Revenues +5 -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support +6 -Hardware Systems Revenues +7 -Services Revenues +8 -Total Revenues +9 -AS REPORTED REVENUE GROWTH RATES -New software licenses -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support +10 -Software and Cloud Revenues +11 -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support +12 -Hardware Systems Revenues +13 -Services Revenues +14 -Total Revenues +15 -CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) -New software licenses -Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service -Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service -Software license updates and product support -d R +16 -Software and Cloud Revenues -S ft +17 -d Cl +18 -Hardware systems products -Hardware systems support +19 -Hardware Systems Revenues +20 -Services Revenues +21 -Total Revenues +22 -GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES +23 -REVENUES -Americas -Europe, Middle East & Africa -Asia Pacific +24 -Total Revenues +25 -HEADCOUNT +26 -GEOGRAPHIC AREA +27 -Americas -Europe, Middle East & Africa -Asia Pacific +28 -Total Company +Count Four +(Violations of CDAFA, Cal. Pen. Code § 502) -$ +57. -1,399 -254 -109 -4,431 -6,193 +58. -$ +Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. -2,121 -259 -97 -4,516 -6,993 +The California legislature enacted CDAFA with the intent of “expand[ing] the -$ +degree of protection afforded to individuals . . . from tampering, interference, damage, and -2,128 -287 -121 -4,564 -7,100 +unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data and computer systems.” Cal. Penal Code -$ +§502(a). The enactment of CDAFA was motivated by the finding that “the proliferation of -3,769 -322 -128 -4,695 -8,914 +computer technology has resulted in a concomitant proliferation of . . . unauthorized access to -$ +computers, computer systems, and computer data.” Id. -9,416 -1,121 -456 -18,206 -29,199 +59. -$ +Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices used to access their Gmail, Chat, -1,370 -337 -138 -4,731 -6,576 +and Meet accounts constitute “computers” within the scope of CDAFA. -669 -592 -1,261 +60. -714 -609 -1,323 +Google violated the following sections of CDAFA: -725 -598 -1,323 +a. -870 -596 -1,466 +Section 502(c)(1), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly access[] and -2,976 -2,396 -5,372 +without permission . . . use[] any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order -578 -587 -1,165 +to either (A) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B) -918 +wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;” -959 +b. -884 +Section 502(c)(2), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly accesses and -940 +without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or -3,704 +computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing -855 +internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;” and -$ +c. -1,370 -337 -138 -4,731 -6,576 +Section 502(c)(7), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly and without -578 -587 -1,165 +permission accesses or causes to be accessed any computer, computer system, or computer -855 +network.” -$ +61. -8,372 +Google knowingly accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet -$ +accounts without their permission by surreptitiously activating Gemini AI access that intercepts -9,275 +and transmits data, communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class -$ +Members. -9,307 +62. -$ +Google used data, communications, and personal information that it intercepted and -11,320 +- 16 - -$ +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -38,275 + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 18 of 21 -$ +1 -8,596 +2 -$ +3 -8,596 +4 -2% -25% -(9%) -7% -6% +5 -(14%) -3% -(7%) +6 -(2%) -19% -(15%) -6% -3% +7 -(3%) -4% -0% +8 -1% -24% -10% -5% -5% +9 -8% -5% -7% +10 -0% -25% -13% -7% -4% +11 -2% -2% -2% +12 -0% -23% -0% -6% -5% +13 -(2%) -4% -0% +14 -(2%) -32% -26% -7% -6% +15 -(14%) -(1%) -(8%) +16 -(8%) +17 -(5%) +18 -(5%) +19 -(4%) +20 -(5%) +21 -(7%) +22 -2% +23 -2% +24 -4% +25 -3% +26 -3% +27 -3% +28 -5% -26% -(7%) -8% -8% -8% +took from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts to wrongfully and -(13%) -5% -(6%) +unjustly enrich itself at the expense of Plaintiff and Class Members. -0% -20% -(14%) -7% -5% -5% +63. -(2%) -5% -1% +Defendant took, copied, intercepted, and made use of data, communications, and -3% -25% -11% -7% -6% -6% +personal information from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. -10% -7% -9% +64. -(1%) -25% -13% -6% -4% -4% +Defendant knowingly and without Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ permission -3% -2% -3% +accessed or caused to be accessed their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts by installing—without -1% -24% -1% -7% -5% -5% +Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ informed consent—AI software that intercepts and/or takes data, -(1%) -5% -2% +communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiffs and Class Members. -(2%) -32% -25% -6% -6% -6% +65. -(14%) -(2%) -(8%) +Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ data, -(6%) +communications, and personal information from California. On information and belief, Google -(3%) +uses servers located in California that allow Google to access and process the data, communications -(3%) +and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class Members. Google’s terms of service -(3%) +indicate that California law controls the use of its services. -(4%) +66. -(8%) +Google was unjustly enriched by intercepting, acquiring, taking, or using Plaintiff’s -4% +and Class Members’ data, communications, and personal information without their permission, and -3% +using it for Google’s own financial benefit. Google has been unjustly enriched in an amount to be -6% +determined at trial. -3% +67. -4% +As a direct and proximate result of Google’s violations of CDAFA, Plaintiff and -2% +Class Members suffered damages. -(2%) -32% -26% -7% -6% +68. -(14%) -(1%) -(8%) +Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(1), Plaintiff and Class Members seek -(7%) +compensatory, injunctive, and equitable relief in an amount to be determined at trial. -3% +69. -(2%) -32% -25% -6% -6% -6% +Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(2), Plaintiff and Class Members seek an award -(14%) -(2%) -(8%) +of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. -(8%) +70. -2% +Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(4), Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive -$ +or exemplary damages for Google’s willful violations of CDAFA. -$ +Count Five +(Violations of the SCA, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq.) -$ +71. -4,517 -2,439 -1,416 -8,372 +Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. -4,995 -2,817 -1,463 -9,275 +- 17 - -$ +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -$ + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 19 of 21 -$ +1 -4,953 -2,923 -1,431 -9,307 +2 -$ +3 -5,857 -3,768 -1,695 -11,320 +4 -$ +5 -$ +6 -20,323 -11,946 -6,006 -38,275 +7 -$ +8 -$ +9 -$ +10 -4,620 -2,589 -1,387 -8,596 +11 -$ +12 -$ +13 -4,620 -2,589 -1,387 -8,596 +14 -53,465 -23,349 -45,513 -122,327 +15 -53,073 -23,178 -45,617 -121,868 +16 -53,799 -23,350 -45,561 -122,710 +17 -53,827 -23,339 -45,108 -122,274 +18 -54,073 -23,349 -45,496 -122,918 +19 -(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding. +20 -(2) +21 -We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for -assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for -entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal -2014 constant currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. +22 - 6 - 6 +23 - ORACLE CORPORATION -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -SUPPLEMENTAL GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES ANALYSIS (1) -($ in millions) +24 -Q1 +25 -Q2 +26 -Fiscal 2014 -Q3 +27 -Q4 +28 -TOTAL +72. -Q1 +The SCA provides a cause of action against any person who “intentionally accesses -Q2 +without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided,” -Fiscal 2015 -Q3 +or any person “who intentionally exceeds an authorization to access that facility; and thereby -Q4 +obtains, alters or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in -TOTAL +electronic storage in such a system.” 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a). -AMERICAS - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +73. -AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +The SCA defines “electronic storage” as “any temporary, intermediate storage of a -CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +wire or electronic communication incidental to the electronic transmission thereof;” and “any -EUROPE / MIDDLE EAST / AFRICA - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +storage of such communication by an electronic communication service for purposes of backup -AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +protection of such communication.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(17). -CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +74. -ASIA PACIFIC - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +The SCA defines an “electronic communications service” as “any service which -AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +provides to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 -CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +U.S.C. § 2510(15). -TOTAL COMPANY - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +75. -AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES -Software and cloud revenues - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +Google intentionally accessed without authorization or intentionally exceeded -CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) - Software and cloud revenues - Hardware systems revenues +authorization to access facilities through which an electronic communications services was -$ -$ +provided when it used its Gemini AI technology to access the Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ -3,434 -640 +Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts for purposes of tracking their private communications. -$ -$ +76. -3,808 -694 +The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services utilized by Plaintiff and Class Members on their -$ -$ +computing devices provide electronic communications services to Plaintiff and Class Members -3,847 -655 +because they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic -$ -$ +communications.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(15). -4,649 -747 +77. -$ -$ +The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services to which the Plaintiff and Class Members use -15,737 -2,736 +or subscribe to provide electronic communication services to Plaintiff and Class Members because -$ -$ +they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 -3,614 -583 +U.S.C. § 2510(15). -9% -(2%) +78. -9% -(1%) +Neither the Plaintiff and Class Members nor the third parties with whom they -5% -7% +communicated with on Gmail, Chat, and Meet authorized the extent of Google’s access to -6% -8% +Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices and Google’s services therein. -5% -14% +79. -7% -16% +Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts—and the -(1%) -3% +- 18 - -1% -5% +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -4% -5% + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 20 of 21 -5% -6% +1 -5% -(9%) +2 -6% -(8%) +3 -$ -$ +4 -1,816 -358 +5 -$ -$ +6 -2,155 -372 +7 -$ -$ +8 -2,245 -403 +9 -$ -$ +10 -3,032 -440 +11 -$ -$ +12 -9,249 -1,572 +13 -$ -$ +14 -1,992 -338 +15 -7% -(11%) +16 -4% -(13%) +17 -8% -(5%) +18 -6% -(6%) +19 -8% -3% +20 -6% -2% +21 -15% -7% +22 -10% -3% +23 -10% -(1%) +24 -7% -(3%) +25 -10% -(6%) +26 -7% -(7%) +27 -$ -$ +28 -943 -263 +computing devices, applications, and/or web browsers through which they accessed those -$ -$ +services—also are facilities under the SCA because they comprise the software necessary for and -1,030 -257 +“through which (the) electronic communications service is provided.” -$ -$ +80. -1,008 -265 +Google intentionally accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and -$ -$ +Meet accounts without authorization when Google turned on the Gemini AI access to those services -1,233 -279 +without obtaining the consent of the Plaintiff and Class Members. -$ -$ +81. -4,213 -1,064 +Upon information and belief, Google’s acquisition of electronic communications -$ -$ +from Plaintiff and Class Members included private communications Plaintiff and Class Members -970 -244 +had with third parties that are not affiliated with Google. -(3%) -(12%) +82. -8% -(5%) +Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by Google’s violations and, pursuant to -(9%) -(9%) +18 U.S.C. § 2707(c), are entitled to statutory damages or actual damages, including profits earned -0% -(3%) +by Google attributable to the violations, punitive damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees. -(5%) -(3%) +VIII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF -3% -3% +WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests that judgment be entered against Google and that the -0% -(4%) +Court grant the following: -3% -(3%) +A. -(4%) -(7%) +An order determining that this action may be maintained as a class action under Rule -3% -(2%) +23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that Plaintiff is a proper class representative, that -3% -(8%) +Plaintiff’s attorneys shall be appointed as Class counsel pursuant to Rule 23(g) of the Federal Rules -2% -(8%) +of Civil Procedure, and that Class notice be promptly issued; -$ -$ +B. -6,193 -1,261 +Judgment against Google for Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ asserted causes of -$ -$ +action; -6,993 -1,323 +C. -$ -$ +D. -7,100 -1,323 +Appropriate declaratory relief against Google; -$ -$ +Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from -8,914 -1,466 +continuing its practice of accessing, using, and/or storing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private -$ -$ +communications without their knowledge or consent in violation of CIPA, CDAFA, and/or SCA; -29,199 -5,372 +E. -$ -$ +Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from -6,576 -1,165 +continuing its practice of tracking, recording, and using Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private -6% -6% -(7%) +communications; -8% -(6%) +- 19 - -3% -3% -0% +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -5% -1% + Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 21 of 21 -5% -5% -7% +F. -6% -9% +An order awarding Plaintiff and the Class Members damages, special damages, -4% -4% -2% +general damages, and restitution; -4% -3% +G. -5% -5% -0% +H. -5% -2% +I. -6% -6% -(8%) +J. -6% -(8%) +An order requiring Google to pay punitive damages and exemplary damages; -$ -$ +An order requiring Google to pay pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; -3,614 -583 +Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs reasonably incurred; and -5% -(9%) +Any and all other and further relief to which Plaintiff and the Class may be entitled. -6% -(8%) +IX. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL -$ -$ +Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury of all issues so triable. -1,992 -338 +Dated: November 11, 2025 -10% -(6%) +Respectfully Submitted, -7% -(7%) +/s/ Tina Wolfson +Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) +twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com +Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) +rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com +Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) +tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com +Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) +abrown@ahdootwolfson.com +AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC +2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 +Burbank, CA 91505-4521 +Telephone: 310.474.9111 +Facsimile: 310.474.8585 -$ -$ +Bradley K. King (SBN 274399) +bking@ahdootwolfson.com +AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC +521 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor +New York, NY 10175 +Telephone: 917.336.0171 +Facsimile: 917.336.0177 -970 -244 +Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class -3% -(8%) +- 20 - -2% -(8%) +CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 +CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT -$ -$ +1 -6,576 -1,165 +2 -6% -6% -(8%) +3 -6% -(8%) +4 -(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding. +5 -(2) We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for -assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities -reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal 2014 constant -currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. - - 7 - 7 - - ORACLE CORPORATION -Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS -EXPLANATION OF NON-GAAP MEASURES - -APPENDIX A +6 -To supplement our financial results presented on a GAAP basis, we use the non-GAAP measures indicated in the tables, which exclude -certain business combination accounting entries and expenses related to acquisitions, as well as other significant expenses including -stock-based compensation, that we believe are helpful in understanding our past financial performance and our future results. Our non- -GAAP financial measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures and should be -read only in conjunction with our consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with GAAP. Our management regularly uses -our supplemental non-GAAP financial measures internally to understand, manage and evaluate our business and make operating -decisions. These non-GAAP measures are among the primary factors management uses in planning for and forecasting future periods. -Compensation of our executives is based in part on the performance of our business based on these non-GAAP measures. Our non- -GAAP financial measures reflect adjustments based on the following items, as well as the related income tax effects: - -• Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service, software license updates and product support and hardware systems support -deferred revenues: Business combination accounting rules require us to account for the fair values of cloud software-as-a-service and -platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts and hardware systems support contracts assumed -in connection with our acquisitions. Because these contracts are generally one year in duration, our GAAP revenues generally for the one -year period subsequent to our acquisition of a business do not reflect the full amount of revenues on these assumed cloud and support -contracts that would have otherwise been recorded by the acquired entity. The non-GAAP adjustment to our cloud software-as-a-service -and platform-as-a-service revenues, software license updates and product support revenues and hardware systems support revenues is -intended to include, and thus reflect, the full amount of such revenues. We believe the adjustment to these revenues is useful to investors -as a measure of the ongoing performance of our business. We have historically experienced high renewal rates on our software license -updates and product support contracts and our objective is to increase the renewal rates on acquired and new cloud software-as-a-service -and platform-as-a-service and hardware systems support contracts; however, we cannot be certain that our customers will renew our -cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts or our hardware -systems support contracts. - -• Stock-based compensation expenses: We have excluded the effect of stock-based compensation expenses from our non-GAAP -operating expenses and net income measures. Although stock-based compensation is a key incentive offered to our employees, and we -believe such compensation contributed to the revenues earned during the periods presented and also believe it will contribute to the -generation of future period revenues, we continue to evaluate our business performance excluding stock-based compensation expenses. -Stock-based compensation expenses will recur in future periods. - -• Amortization of intangible assets: We have excluded the effect of amortization of intangible assets from our non-GAAP operating -expenses and net income measures. Amortization of intangible assets is inconsistent in amount and frequency and is significantly -affected by the timing and size of our acquisitions. Investors should note that the use of intangible assets contributed to our revenues -earned during the periods presented and will contribute to our future period revenues as well. Amortization of intangible assets will recur -in future periods. - -• Acquisition related and other expenses; and restructuring expenses: We have excluded the effect of acquisition related and other -expenses and the effect of restructuring expenses from our non-GAAP operating expenses and net income measures. We incurred -significant expenses in connection with our acquisitions and also incurred certain other operating expenses or income, which we -generally would not have otherwise incurred in the periods presented as a part of our continuing operations. Acquisition related and other -expenses consist of personnel related costs for transitional employees, other acquired employee related costs, stock-based compensation -expenses (in addition to the stock-based compensation expenses described above), integration related professional services, certain -business combination adjustments including adjustments after the measurement period has ended and certain other operating items, net. -Substantially all of the stock-based compensation expenses included in acquisition related and other expenses resulted from unvested -options assumed in acquisitions whose vesting was fully accelerated upon termination of the employees pursuant to the original terms of -those options. Restructuring expenses consist of employee severance and other exit costs. We believe it is useful for investors to -understand the effects of these items on our total operating expenses. Although acquisition related expenses and restructuring expenses -generally diminish over time with respect to past acquisitions, we generally will incur these expenses in connection with any future -acquisitions. +7 8 +9 + +10 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +14 + +15 + +16 + +17 + +18 + +19 + +20 + +21 + +22 + +23 + +24 + +25 + +26 + +27 + +28 + + ClassAction.org + +This complaint is part of ClassAction.org's searchable class action lawsuit +database and can be found in this post: Google Hit with Data Privacy Lawsuit +After ‘Secretly’ Turning On Gemini AI for All Users + diff --git a/q158/random_k2/question.json b/q158/random_k2/question.json index 9e7999d866671790e0de63806c0fe2c65032f36f..58949097360e7c30ef2cde0d0d84fa2377de5135 100644 --- a/q158/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q158/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "f8d3a162ab9507e021d83dd109118b60.pdf", - "web_ed8636d8f0faddf2.pdf", - "web_289916b20eaef9df.pdf" + "web_ae1b8a373064ff5e.pdf", + "web_19b03cfaf44f6244.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q158/random_k2/random_1.md b/q158/random_k2/random_1.md index 4df5215b83d8f847c48c411dacd211a9574481da..d1447fd886d0d69697641e94fcf1890d83769afd 100644 --- a/q158/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q158/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,752 +1,1679 @@ -C H A P T E R 1 +Hobart and William SmitH CollegeS -Get started with -Web GIS +Handbook for +International Students -T his chapter introduces the basic concepts and workflows of Web GIS and the Esri® geo- +intercultural affairs Center +288 Pulteney Street +geneva, nY 14456 +(315) 781-3319 – Phone +(315) 781-3888 – Fax -spatial cloud. The chapter begins with an overview of Web GIS and its advantages; intro- -duces Esri’s geospatial cloud including ArcGIS® Online and ArcGIS Enterprise; illustrates online, -on-premises, and hybrid deployment patterns; lists the technical evolutions in Web GIS; explains -the content types, hosted feature layers, app types, and user types in Web GIS; and demonstrates -the workflow to build Web GIS apps using the Attachment Viewer instant app template. This -chapter familiarizes you with ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise basic operations and work- -flows and introduces flexible ways to build Web GIS apps that you will explore in other chapters. + TABLE OF CONTENTS -Objectives +SECTION I: General Information + Welcome -• Grasp the concept and advantages of Web GIS. -• Understand the deployment patterns of Web GIS. -• Learn the components of the new-generation Web GIS. -• Understand the technical evolutions and trends in Web GIS. -• Understand the concepts of web services and hosted feature layers. -• Publish hosted feature layers from CSV files. -• Learn the workflow for creating web maps and web apps. +important Campus Phone numbers -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 2 + office locations -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS +banks and theaters +Places to Stay +Frequently asked Questions -Web GIS and the geospatial cloud +SECTION II: Immigration Procedures + How to get assistance with immigration matters +immigration basics and definition of terms -Web GIS is the combination of the web and geographic information systems (GIS). The web -removed the constraint of distance and thus allows people the freedom to interact with GIS apps -globally and access information almost instantly. Web GIS uses web technologies, including but -not limited to Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP), Hypertext Markup Language (HTML), -Uniform Resource Locator (URL), JavaScript, Web Graphics Library (WebGL), and WebSocket. -The first operational GIS was developed in the 1960s by Roger Tomlinson (who developed -the Canada Geographic Information System). Since then, GIS has evolved from a local file-based, -single-computer system to a central database client/server system, often with multiple servers -and many more client computers. The invention of the internet in the 1980s and the growth -of the World Wide Web in the early 1990s laid the foundation for an evolutionary leap toward -Web GIS. In 1993, the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), a Xerox company, developed a map- -ping web page, which marked the origin of Web GIS. In the 2000s, Web GIS evolved into a new -generation — a system of distributed web services in the cloud you can access anywhere, repre- -sented by ArcGIS. + obtaining a Visa and Form i-20 -Inheriting the power of the web and the cloud, Web GIS offers many advantages: +differences between F-1 and J-1 Status -• Global reach: You can share your geographic information easily, within your organization + arriving at a U.S. port of entry… What a student can expect -and with people all over the world. +dealing with the department of Homeland Security (dHS) +exceptions to a Full Course of Study +duration of Status for F-1 Students +temporary departure from the US -• Large number of users: You can share your app with dozens, or even millions, of users sup- + accepting U.S. government Public assistance or Public benefits + Work opportunities for students with F-1 Status + Work opportunities for students in J-1 Status -ported by scalable cloud technology. +Practical training + optional Practical training (oPt) + Curricular Practical training (CPt) +departure Checklist -• Low cost per user: The cost of building one Web GIS app is often lower than building a - -stand-alone desktop solution and installing it for every user. - -• Better cross-platform capabilities: Web apps, especially those built with JavaScript, can - -run on desktop and mobile browsers running a wide range of operating systems, including -Windows, Mac OS, and Linux, along with iOS, Android, and Windows Phone. - -• Easy to use: Web GIS apps typically incorporate simplicity, intuition, and convenience in -their design. Public users can use these apps without a technical background (see figure). -• Easy to maintain: Web clients can benefit from the latest program and data updates each -time they access a web app. The web administrator does not have to update all the clients -separately. +page 1 +9 +10 +10 +10 +12 -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. Web GIS and the geospatial cloud +15 +16 +17 +19 +21 +22 +24 +24 +24 +25 +26 +26 +27 +27 +28 +29 + +SECTION III: + +Sample Fall orientation Schedule for international Students + +30 + +2 + + SECTION I: +GENERAL INFORMATION + +Welcome! + +Welcome to Hobart and William Smith Colleges (the Colleges or HWS). to you, the +decision to study abroad might have been a small one – or, indeed, a rather big step. +either way you won’t know what your experience will be like until you are here. this +handbook is designed to help you prepare for the adventure of studying in the United +States. in our experience the better prepared you are the more you will benefit from +your time at the Colleges. + While we are trying to answer many of your questions prior to your arrival in the +United States, some of your questions will only arise once you are here. the inter- +national Student adviser will serve as a resource to you and your parents or guardians +throughout the application process and during your stay at Hobart and William Smith +Colleges. The adviser will be your primary contact for any questions or concerns +regarding visas and immigration issues, employment, travel and a host of other + matters that may arise. + +the International Student Office (iSo) is located on the second floor of the + +intercultural affairs Center at 288 Pulteney Street. this office advocates for and ad- +dresses the needs of international students as well as provides programs and services +related to immigration matters. during the academic school year the iSo sponsors +and co-sponsors events designed to promote cross-cultural sharing between the many +groups at the Colleges and +geneva communities. +Currently, international +students come to us from 22 +nations: austria, bulgaria, +Canada, China, Colombia, +Czech republic, germany, +india, iran, nepal, Pakistan, +Portugal, Scotland, South +africa, South Korea, Swe- +den, Switzerland, thailand, +the netherlands, turkey, +Ukraine and Vietnam. + +Intercultural Affairs Center – Home to the International Student Office. + +in the fall international students attend a special two-day orientation before +the regular first year orientation begins. at Hobart and William Smith, we ask that +incoming international students join us ahead of time as it is a wonderful opportunity +to get acquainted with the new culture, get assimilated with the campus, and provide +a forum to answer your questions before the rush of orientation activities begins. at +the iSo, we will check to make sure that all your immigration paperwork is in order as +well as help you gain a better understanding of what your F-1 or J-1 status means and +how to maintain it; help to answer any questions that you might have about adjusting +to life as a student in the United States, specifically life at HWS; and meet students, +staff and faculty members. 3 -GIS professional -using Web GIS - -Casual users - -Developers - -Open data -community - -Web GIS offers a collaborative environment and a pattern for delivering GIS capabilities. GIS -professionals share information to Web GIS and extend geospatial intelligence to users across -organizations and throughout communities. - -GIS is the science of locations — The Science of Where®. The term has two meanings. One mean- -ing is that GIS is itself a science, as the scientific basis for GIS technology. The other meaning -is that GIS has been used for science as an effective tool for making scientific discoveries. The -Science of Where is now recognized as a force for solving problems and understanding our -world. Web GIS takes the science to a whole new scale, transforming how we share and col- -laborate and revealing deeper insight into data. The common patterns of Web GIS applications -include mapping and visualization, data management, field mobility, monitoring, analytics, -design and planning, decision support, constituent engagement, sharing, and collaboration. -Web GIS unlocks and delivers this science to offices and homes and puts GIS technology in the -hands of billions of people. Web GIS provides immense value to government, business, science, -and daily life. In recent years, the concept and importance of spatial location have become more -mainstream, and Web GIS awareness is growing more prominent in many organizations: - -• Government: Web GIS offers an ideal channel for sharing public information services and -delivering open data, an engaging medium for encouraging public participation, and a pow- -erful framework for supporting decision-making. - -• Business: Web GIS helps create novel business models and reshapes existing ones. It - -enhances the power of location-based advertising, business analysis, and volunteered geo- -graphic information, generating tremendous revenue directly and indirectly. -• Science: Web GIS creates research areas and renews existing avenues of research. -• Daily life: Web GIS helps people decide where to eat, stay, shop, and learn how to get from - -place to place. - -Table 1.1 describes patterns of Web GIS applications, including mapping and visualization, data -management, and analytics. - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 4 - -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS - -Table 1 .1 . Common patterns of Web GIS applications - -Pattern name - -Description - -Mapping and visualization Understand locations and relationships with maps and visual representations. - -Data management - -Collect, organize, and maintain accurate locations and details about assets -and resources. - -Field mobility - -Monitoring - -Analytics - -Manage and enable a mobile workforce to collect and access information in -the field. - -Track, manage, and monitor assets and resources in real time. - -Discover, quantify, and predict trends and patterns to improve outcomes. - -Design and planning - -Evaluate alternative solutions and create optimal designs. - -Decision support - -Gain situational awareness and enable information-driven decision-making. - -Constituent engagement - -Communicate and collaborate with citizens and external communities -of interest. - -Sharing and collaboration - -Empower everyone to discover, use, make, and share geographic information. - -The geospatial cloud powers Web GIS -Esri’s Web GIS capabilities are provided by ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise, which are at -the core of the geospatial cloud. - -• ArcGIS Online is a software-as-a-service (SaaS) offering of Web GIS. ArcGIS Online is - -hosted on the Amazon Web Services (AWS) cloud and Microsoft Azure cloud platforms and -is managed by Esri. There is no hardware infrastructure for an organization to maintain. -ArcGIS Online hosts hundreds of millions of content items and registered users. It serves bil- -lions of maps per day with high performance, scalability, and availability. With the benefits -of cloud computing, ArcGIS Online has been quickly adopted by government and commer- -cial organizations around the world. - -• ArcGIS Enterprise is a Web GIS software product that organizations can acquire and deploy. - -ArcGIS Enterprise includes four basic software components: Portal for ArcGIS, ArcGIS -Server, ArcGIS Data Store, and ArcGIS Web Adaptor. These components support flexible -ways for deployment, from a single-machine deployment to multiple-machine deployments, -highly available (HA) deployment, on Windows, Linux, and the Kubernetes platform, in -on-premises data centers or in AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud, and many other cloud -platforms. - -Table 1.2 lists these deployment patterns. - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. Web GIS and the geospatial cloud + Questions? Please +contact the International +Student Adviser by phone + at (315) 781-3319. The + International Student + Office is located on the + 2nd floor of the +Intercultural Affairs Cent- +ter, 288 Pulteney Street, +Geneva, NY 14456. (315) +781-3319 – Phone (315) +781-3888-Fax. Office +hours are 8:30 am to +5:00 pm weekdays during +the academic year. + +THINGS TO DO BEFORE GOING ABROAD +before you can board a plane and start your study +abroad adventure, there are some formalities you will +need to take care of. the earlier you start thinking +about the things you need, the smoother your prepara- +tions will go. this list will help you consider some of +the things you will have to do. + +Obtaining a Visa +Upon receipt of the form i-20 (for F-1 students) or dS- +2019 (for J-1 exchange students) you can apply for your +student visa. it is wise to schedule an appointment with +the U.S. embassy or consulate in your country as soon +as possible as sometimes there are no appointments +available for weeks. You should also give yourself some +time to prepare for your visit to the U.S. embassy or +consulate. Visa procedures vary from country to country. +make sure to check the website of the embassy or + +consulate in your country to find out what documents you need to bring. document +you certainly need include: (1) a current, valid passport; (2) your i-20 or dS-2019 +form; (3) evidence of financial support for the duration of time you will spend in the +US; (4) proof that you have a permanent residence outside the US; (5) one or more +passport pictures meeting U.S. requirements; (6) a nonimmigrant visa application. + +Medical Insurance +HWS Colleges require that all students buy the medical insurance provided by +the colleges. all J-1 student-visa holders (that is, all exchange students) are also +required by U.S. law to have their own medical insurance. While F-2 students are +covered by the Colleges medical insurance you might nevertheless consider buying +additional medical coverage. + +Important Documents +You need to bring all important documents relating to your legal, medical, and aca- +demic history with you. Such documents might include medical and dental records, +certificates of immunizations, information about medical conditions and treatments, +prescriptions for medication and eyeglasses or contact lenses, and official transcripts +from secondary school and college. make sure you photocopy all documents and +leave some copies with a person you trust in your home country. it is also helpful to +translate these documents into english before you leave your home country. + +Packing +Pack as light as possible. remember that you might have to carry all your things at +different times during the journey. if you are studying abroad for only a semester you +might not need to bring your entire wardrobe. You might also want to leave room +in your suitcase for souvenirs you will buy while in the US. at the same time there +might be things you want to bring because they will make you more comfortable + +4 + + and will make your transition to a new environment easier. Some exchange students +and international students also like to bring small gifts from their home country to +share with new friends abroad. this might be a means for you to share and explain +your culture to your new acquaintances. if you have traditional, national cloth- +ing consider bringing it to wear at events sponsored by the international Students +association or other cultural events. if you arrive during spring semester (January), +to bring a warm jacket and boots, a scarf, gloves and hat. We encourage you to take +advantage of the option to ship your packages ahead of time using the box number +that will be provided to you from the Colleges orientation office. You may also +consider purchasing larger items upon your arrival at our local shopping centers. + +Traveling Tips +You can book your flight as soon as you find the Colleges start date for international +Student orientation. at this time, you might have already received the schedule of +international student orientation. the Colleges provide a complimentary pick-up +from rochester and Syracuse airport for those international students coming to the +Colleges for the first time if you arrive during the assigned times. long-distance +traveling can be really exhausting, so try to get a good-night’s sleep before the trip, +eat lightly and drink plenty of water. it is also a good idea to wear several layers of +clothes so you can accommodate to changes in temperature. label your luggage with +both your home address and the address in the United States (if you don’t have an +address yet, use that of the international student office). Keep you passport, impor- +tant documents, flight tickets, and money or traveler’s checks with you at all times. +You might also want to pack everything you need for a one-night emergency stay +into your hand luggage in case you get stuck at the airport or your luggage gets lost. + +Money +You should carry a small amount of U.S. dollars with you while traveling so that you +can buy some food or other small things you might need. However, it is not a good +idea to carry large sums of money. We recommend that you buy traveler’s checks or +get a credit card that allows you to withdraw money from a cash machine when you +need to. Upon arrival on campus, the international student adviser can help you to +set up an account with a local bank. it is highly recommended to have an U.S. bank +account because it will make payments so much easier. Students can create bank +accounts free of charge. + +GETTING TO KNOW HOBART AND WILLIAM SMITH COLLEGES +College is an exciting time for everyone and it is a transition for all students. if you +are an exchange student, you already went through the transition process once. +nevertheless, studying abroad brings with it a range of new experiences. every col- +lege is a little different and if you have never studied in the United States before, +many things might be very confusing. + +Hobart and William Smith Colleges +Hobart and William Smith is a small, private liberal arts institution. You can expect +to study in relatively small classes and build close relationships with your classmates 5 -Table 1 .2 . Esri Web GIS deployment patterns - -Online - -Hybrid - -On-premises or in cloud - -Esri managed - -ArcGIS Online + and professors. Virtually all students are being housed on campus. living so close +to each other has many advantages: it is relatively easy to get to know new people, +get involved in clubs and activities, and make an impact on the community. at the +same time it can be hard to find personal time and separate school from other activi- +ties when the two are not physically separated. + +Classes +at HWS, a normal course load is four classes per semester. this means that you +will be in class for between 12 and 15 hours every week, or more if you take courses +requiring labs or studio work. there are different types of classes. 100- and 200-level +classes are usually introductory classes and have a wider focus. 300- and 400-level +classes have a narrower, more specific focus. Some professors prefer to lecture, but +you also encounter class-discussions. Higher level classes tend to be taught in a semi- +nar style, in which a lot of the class’ content relies on student presentations. there +are also independent study classes in which you research a topic under a professor’s +guidance but without the classroom structure. as an upper-class student you might +choose to work on an honors project. this is an independent research project that +will culminate in a 80- to 100-page paper. You can take classes from all departments +but at the end of your Sophomore (2nd) year, you will need to declare a major and a +minor subject (or one major, two minors; or two majors, one minor; or two majors, +two minors). as part of your liberal arts education, you will also have to fulfill cer- +tain academic goals. Your academic adviser will help you with that. + +Grading and Grades +Foreign students often find that americans are very competitive. this also reflects +on the system of grading. You will find that you will have many opportunities to +prove your knowledge of a subject in class. many professors will give short, unan- +nounced quizzes that test your knowledge of the course material assigned for that +day. exams are bigger, announced tests that cover the course material of a longer pe- +riod of time. they can be compromised of true or false questions, sentence comple- +tion (“fill in the blank”), multiple choice, matching, essay questions, or a combina- +tion of these. Professors will also assign essays and papers you have to write on your +own time. Your class participation might also count toward your final grade. the +Colleges use the grading system based on a four-point scale: a= 4.0, b= 3.0, C= 2.0, +d= 1.0. You need at least a C average in your classes to remain a full-time student. + +Homework +Some foreign students are overwhelmed by the quantity of homework assigned by +american colleges. especially in the beginning when you still have problems with +the english language, keeping up with homework can be really hard. if you find +yourself struggling to keep up with work, ask for help. Find the Center for teaching +and learning on campus and schedule an appointment! Ctl is open to all students +and its services are already covered by your tuition. they can help you with your +writing assignments, help with time management, or assign you a tutor to help you +with the content of a class. it is also important to realize that most american stu- +dents prioritize their work: decide what readings are important to do and read them +thoroughly; skim the others. +6 + + Professors and Advisers +every student at HWS is assigned an academic adviser. He or she will help you +with any questions you have related to your academic life. Feel free to consult them +before choosing classes, if you are struggling with certain classes or professors, if you +want to know how and when to declare majors and minors, and any other questions +you might have. most professors are also interested in helping you as much as pos- +sible and want to get to know you outside of class. don’t feel embarrassed to ask a +professor a question after class. You should also take advantage of their office hours. +interaction between professors and students in america is a lot tighter than in many +other countries. Students sometimes stop by their professor’s office simply to talk +about something that they are interested in. + +Important information on financial aid +Hobart and William Smith Colleges offer merit scholarships as well as need-based +grants to international students. the average package typically equals more than +half the annual cost of tuition, room and board. Highly competitive applicants will +be considered for a full tuition scholarships. + +Financial aid is available for a maximum of four years for those who enroll as + +first-year students. For those entering with advanced standing (transfers), aid is +available for the time allotted to complete a degree. awards based on demonstrated +financial need, if it becomes apparent that such need no longer exists, may be re- +duced. Students must resubmit a financial aid application each year. + +ADJUSTING TO A NEW ENVIRONMENT +going abroad for a semester or the duration of one’s studies is exciting. at times, +however, the confrontation with a foreign culture can be challenging. Studying +abroad is a learning experience in every sense of the word. besides your scholastic +learning in college courses, you will get to know the american culture and how +people around you view their world and their lives. by experiencing and understand- +ing a different way of life, you will also learn about things in your own culture you +have never thought of before. this is your chance to broaden your view and reflect +on and mature your own values. the process of learning about a new culture and +finding your own place in the new environment can be confusing and tiring. the +best way to deal with a new situation and find out about something you don’t under- +stand is to ask questions. + +Culture Shock and Adjustment +Culture shock is a normal phenomenon on your way to adjusting to a new environ- +ment. For some people, the encounter with a new culture can be shocking, indeed, +but for most people culture shock is not as sudden and dramatic as you might expect. +When the excitement about being in a foreign country wears off, cultural differences +can become overwhelming. You might think your language skills are inadequate; you +might be struggling with course work; you might be troubled by unfamiliar food; you +might have difficulties interpreting other people’s behavior; you might be offended +by the way people act or dress or by their body language. there are a variety of +symptoms of culture shock. Some people feel tired and nervous; some are frustrated -ArcGIS Online - -Customer managed +7 -ArcGIS Enterprise + with or even hostile toward the american culture; some get angry and irritated very +easily; some isolate themselves or socialize only with other international students and +people who speak their language. You might also feel very homesick and question +why you decided to go abroad in the first place. a way to prepare yourself to deal with +culture shock is to clarify for yourself why you want to study abroad. Knowing your +personal expectations and goals will help you overcome periods of doubt. -ArcGIS Enterprise +THINGS TO DO +• Chose a non-credit or half-credit class like tennis, scuba diving, or basic sailing. +• Join some of the many student clubs on campus (http://www.hws.edu/studentlife/ -Although on-premises data center technology is not necessarily on the verge of extinction, cloud -computing is an option with many benefits, including scalability, agility, and cost efficiency. -During the COVID-19 pandemic, cloud usage increased rapidly because people use the cloud -platforms to work and shop from home. Today, more organizations are adopting ArcGIS Online -or deploying their ArcGIS Enterprise to the cloud, such as AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google -Cloud, and others (see figure). Many organizations adopt a hybrid model by integrating ArcGIS -Online and ArcGIS Enterprise. +campuslife/sll/clubs). -ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise benefit from an effective framework to enforce security -and protect user privacy. They are certified as compliant with many federal and international -security and privacy standards. For more information, see the ArcGIS Trust Center page at -doc .arcgis .com/en/trust/compliance/compliance-tab-intro .htm. +• You like to be active? Visit the sport and recreation facilities and take a yoga class, +borrow a racquet and play tennis or racquetball. You can also try out for intramu- +ral sports. -Built on ArcGIS Online, the Johns Hopkins COVID-19 Dashboard, a real-time pandemic tracker, has become -a global reference for the pandemic and one of the most cited resources to track the spread of coronavirus -around the world. It has received billions of views and remained highly efficient under a massive amount of -web traffic. +• get involved in the religious life on campus! there are services and meditation as +well as bible study sessions, ecumenical candlelight prayers, Sabbath dinners and +a lot more. -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. +• Participate in ongoing events – take in a movie on Fridays at Friday Flix, visit the +Cellar Pub in the basement of Coxe Hall and see what is happening (comedians, +bands, etc.), show school spirit by supporting one of many sporting events hap- +pening on campus. - 6 +• are you interested in current events? Political and social developments? the +Fisher Center lecture Series, the President’s Forum and the President’s radio +Show are a few venues through which you can satisfy this interest. -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS +• travel the area! intercultural affairs (iC) and the Center for global education -New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends +(Cge) will occasionally offer trips to see the area, oraP (outdoor recreational +activities Program) organizes hiking, rock climbing and rafting trips (among +others), and you can always get a group of friends together and go somewhere on +your own. -ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise represent the new generation of Web GIS. Although the -two have some differences (see chapter 5), they generally share similar architecture, similar capa- -bilities, and similar workflows for creating content, as shown in this figure. +• offer your help in the language departments. maybe someone needs a Spanish -Desktop +tutor or a teaching assistant for mandarin? -Web +• discover geneva. Volunteer. to find out how visit the Public Service office in -Device +trinity (2nd floor) (or call x3825). -ArcGIS Online +• do you like to dance? or watch others dance? the dance department is big on +campus and the students as well as the faculty put on dance shows! ask about +Koshare or join one of the dance teams. -Portal for -ArcGIS +• Check the daily Update! there is always something going on – just show up and -Server +try it out! -Web services +8 + P +H +O +N +E +N +U +M +B +E +R +S +& +O +F +F +I C - -l -i - -e -n -t - -a -p -p -s - -A -c -c -e -s -s - +E S -e -r -v -i -c -e -s - -ArcGIS is a new-generation Web GIS that provides mapping, analysis, data management, and collaboration. - -This new-generation Web GIS architecture is described as follows: - -• At the center of the new Web GIS architecture is a portal—ArcGIS Online or Portal for - -ArcGIS—which represents a gateway for accessing all spatial products in an organization. -The portal helps organize, secure, and facilitate access to geographic information products. -• On the back end, the portal is powered by two components: GIS servers that allow you to -create content and ready-to-use content such as ArcGIS Living Atlas of the World, which -provides tens of thousands of data layers and maps. - -• On the client side, users can search, discover, and use the layers, maps, and apps on desktops, - -in web browsers, and on mobile devices anywhere, anytime. -Technology evolution and trends in Web GIS -Since its inception, Web GIS has coevolved with geographic science and information technology -(see figure). This evolution and these trends are discussed in greater detail in later chapters. - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. - New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends - -7 - -Web GIS has coevolved with geographic information science and information technology. - -Web GIS has exemplified the following evolution of stages and trends in technologies: - -• From closed websites to open geospatial web services. Early Web GIS apps were developed -as independent websites. These websites were isolated from one another. It was difficult to -share information and functions between them and difficult to remix the content to create -apps. In the later 1990s, web services technology was conceived. Web services can be thought -of as building blocks that can be shared and remixed in versatile ways for building web apps. -The GIS industry adopted the concept of web services in manufacturing Web GIS products. -For example, ArcGIS Web GIS products fully support the web services architecture. The -server side provides ready-to-use services and allows users to create their own services, -whereas the client side can consume and combine these services to create apps. - -• From one-way to two-way information flow. Early Web GIS products and applications - -mainly supported one-way information flow, which was from server side to client side. Users -were merely the receivers of information. As we entered the 21st century, user-generated -content (UGC) became a significant phenomenon and created a reversed information flow, -from client side to server side. Volunteered geographic information (VGI) is the UGC of a -geospatial nature. For example, ArcGIS facilitates VGI through editable layers, Mobile GIS -apps, and browser-based apps. Users can view maps and perform queries, as well as conduct -field surveys, collect data, and report events they see. - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 8 - -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS - -• Portal technology is becoming essential. The word portal means gate or entrance. It was -adopted in the mid-1990s to form new terms such as web portal, referring to a website -that serves as the gateway to other websites or web resources. Geoportals are gateways to -geospatial information. Portals have become a core component of Web GIS technology. For -example, ArcGIS Online and Portal for ArcGIS have geoportal capabilities. They facilitate -the management, search, discovery, configuration, security, and remix of GIS data layers and -services. Today, portal collaboration allows different organizations to replicate selected con- -tent as hosts and guests, creating a portal of portals — a distributed Web GIS pattern. ArcGIS -Hub℠ and ArcGIS Enterprise Sites are examples of subject- or initiative-based portals. They -provide an easy-to-configure community engagement platform that organizes people, data, -and tools through information-driven initiatives. Organizations can create websites to share -data, documents, videos, and web maps on a certain subject or for a certain initiative. For -instance, the COVID-19 GIS Hub (coronavirus-resources .esri .com) provides GIS resources, -solutions, and a collaboration platform for the world to combat the coronavirus pandemic. -• Cloud GIS delivers GIS functionality and ready-to-use contents. Cloud GIS, which uses -public and private cloud computing to provide GIS software and contents, has become the -primary way to deliver GIS — not just functionality but also content. Cloud GIS advantages -include vast content and functionality, the flexibility of pay-as-you-go or subscription pric- -ing, reduced complexity, and increased availability of services. Because of these advantages, -cloud GIS, such as ArcGIS Online, has penetrated organizations that have not used GIS -before or been able to afford GIS on their own. - -• Mobile is becoming the pervasive Web GIS client platform. In the post-PC era, mobile - -devices have surpassed desktops and notebooks as the primary platform for accessing online -information. Mobile devices are a part of everyone’s life and work. “Mobile first” is a strategy -of many industries, including the Web GIS industry. Vendors have given extra attention to -Mobile GIS. For example, Esri provides numerous mobile-native apps and mobile-friendly -browser apps to support the needs of users and organizations for Mobile GIS. Mobile GIS -is also associated with many frontiers in Web GIS, such as augmented reality (AR). AR can -superimpose GIS data on top of a user’s camera views and thus augment a user’s sense of -reality. With the rapid advances in Mobile GIS, the vision of using GIS for anything, any- -time, anywhere, and by anyone is being realized faster than we can imagine. - -• Map visualization goes from 2D to 3D and virtual reality. With the increased client-side -graphics processing power and the broader support of WebGL (a JavaScript application pro- -gramming interface [API] that renders interactive 2D and 3D graphics in a browser), Web -GIS products such as ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise can smoothly create and display - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends + Extension + +IMPORTANT PHONE NUMBERS +Office +business office +Center for global education +Center for teaching and learning +Counseling Center +deans: Hobart +deans: William Smith +Financial aid +Hubbs Health Center +information technology +intercultural affairs +registrar +residential education +Security +emergency +Student accounts + +3655 +3307 +3351 +3388 +3300 +3467 +3315 +3600 +4357 (HelP) +3319 +3651 +3900 +3656 +3333 +3386 + +OFFICE LOCATIONS +admissions +alcohol and other drug Programs +alumni House +athletics (WS) +buildings and grounds +business office +Career Services +Center for global education +Ctl +Chapel +College Store +Communications office +deans: Hobart +deans: William Smith +dining Services + +Financial aid +Hubbs Health/Counseling Center +information technology +intercultural affairs +President +Provost’s office +Public Service office +registrar +residential education +Security +Student accounts +Student life and leadership +WeoS radio Station + +bradford House +Smith Hall +615 South main +Winn-Seeley +medbery Parking lot +demarest (basement) +trinity (1st Floor) +trinity (3rd Floor) +Harris House (678 S. main St.) +St. John’s Chapel (near 630 S. main St.) +51 Saint Clair Street, Sherrill Hall +durfee House (639 S. main St.) +Smith Hall (1st Floor) +Smith Hall (1st Floor) +Scandling Center Café, Saga, +Cellar Pub, de Cordova Café +demarest (basement) +119 St. Clair St. +Williams Hall +288 Pulteney St. +Coxe Hall (2nd Floor) +Coxe Hall (2nd Floor) +trinity (3rd Floor) +gulick (1st Floor) +101 St. Clair St. +medbery Parking lot +demarest (basement) +Scandling Center (2nd Floor) +113 Hamilton St. 9 -thematic and photo-realistic 3D web scenes. Representing a big step from 2D online maps, -3D web scenes provide users a more intuitive means to understand their data. Web scenes -are also important for indoor mapping, an ongoing trend in GIS. Even more intuitive than -3D, virtual reality (VR) allows users with certain visual wearables to immerse themselves in -3D city models by transporting themselves into static viewpoints and comparing different -urban design scenarios. This immersive experience brings GIS data and geospatial under- -standing even closer to users. The GIS community can play an important role in building the -metaverse and can assist with getting real work done in the virtual world environment. The -term metaverse refers to the fully immersive 3D expansion of existing internet technologies -to include AR and VR. - -• Data source goes from static to real time and spatiotemporal big data. Many elements in - -Web GIS are of a real-time nature, such as the incidents immediately reported by field crews, -citizens using mobile devices, concurrent measurements from sensor networks, and smart -cities. This massive amount of data presents challenges in real-time intake, processing, analy- -sis, visualization, and storage. ArcGIS GeoEvent™ Server and ArcGIS Velocity use cluster -computing and can ingest millions of sensor readings per second, process them, and store -them in real time. Such products and research allow Web GIS to meet the requirements of -the sensor web and the Internet of Things (IoT). - -• Web GIS is becoming more intelligent. Map visualization is the first step toward data -analysis. ArcGIS smart mapping can analyze the data automatically and suggest the best -mapping style and best defaults. This can help both expert and novice users quickly create -aesthetic and informative maps. Web GIS goes far beyond mapping. Web GIS can perform -big data analysis using distributed computing, aggregate data in the context of both space -and time, extrapolate new ideas from raw data, and bring superior intelligence to business -decisions. More recently, Web GIS has started to use artificial intelligence (AI), especially -machine learning and deep learning. For example, AI significantly improves the accuracy of -online imagery classification. AI can quickly identify the damaged locations from millions of -facilities’ photos and ensure that the damaged facilities are repaired early. - -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 10 - -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS - -Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and - -apps - -Web GIS elements include users, groups, content items, and metadata (see figure). - -• Users with necessary privileges can create and join groups. -• Users sign in to create and share content items (with certain privileges), which include a - -large variety of data, web layers, tools, web maps, web scenes, and web apps. - -• Content items have metadata, including title, summary, description, categories, and tags, and -additional standards-based metadata. Metadata is indexed so users can search and discover -items more efficiently. - -• Users can keep information to themselves, share with certain groups (rather than individual -users), share with their organizations, or share with everyone — even the public if the organi- -zation allows anonymous access. This allows other users to see and access the items. - -own or join - -Users - -o -w -n - -organize and secure - -Groups - -x -e -d -n - -i - -index - -Items - -Metadata - -The ArcGIS Online and Portal for ArcGIS high-level information model. - -Main types of content items -Web GIS has five main types of content: data, layers, tools, web maps and scenes, and apps. Data -can be used to publish web layers; web layers can be used to create web maps and web scenes; -web maps and scenes and web tools can be used in apps or to create apps, as shown in the figure. + BANKS AND MOVIE THEATERS IN GENEVA + +Community Bank +5 Seneca St. +geneva, nY 14456 +Phone: (315) 789-7700 +Website: www.communitybankna.com + +First Niagara Bank +811 Canandaigua road +geneva, nY 14456 +Phone: (315) 789-1049 +Fax: (315) 789-6009 +Website: www.firstniagarabank.com + +BANKS +Five-Star Bank +P.o. box 193 +geneva, nY 14456 +Phone: (315) 789-2300 +Fax: (315) 787-3263 +Website: www.five-starbank.com + +Seneca Falls Savings Bank +342 Hamilton St. +geneva, nY 14456 +Phone: 315-789-8100 +Website: www.seneca24.net/ + +MOVIE THEATERS +Geneva Movieplex 8 +t & C Plaza, Hamilton St. +geneva, nY, 14456 +Phone: (315) 789-4524 +Web: www.cinemanorth.com + +PLACES TO STAY +Note: the Colleges provide this list as a service to all who might visit our area, but +do not endorse any local hotel, motel, inn or bed and breakfast. + +the following are a handful of accommodations that are available in and around +geneva, no more than 30 minutes from campus. lodging is also available in ithaca, +rochester and Syracuse, which are each approximately one hour from Hobart and +William Smith. You can find out more about accommodations outside the greater +geneva area by visiting the geneva Chamber of Commerce or ontario County +tourism bureau websites. + +Holiday inn, Waterloo +(315) 539-5011 or (800) HolidaY + +Hampton inn +(315) 781-2037 + +ramada inn, geneva, lakefront +(315) 789-0400 + +belhurst Castle/White Spring manor, +geneva +(315) 781-0201 + +microtel inn & Suites, Seneca Falls +(315) 539-8438 + +geneva-on-the-lake, geneva +(315) 789-7190 or (800) 3-geneVa + +motel 6, Hamilton Street, geneva +(315) 789-4050 or (800) 466-8356 + +10 + + G +E +N +E +V +A -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps +, + +N +E +W +Y +O +R +K + +PLACES TO EAT +*Please note that some restaurants are closed on Mondays or Tuesdays, +so call ahead. + +The area code for all numbers listed below is (315). + +American/Continental +abigail’s restaurant, routes 5 & 20, Seneca Falls, 539-9300 +belhurst Castle, lochland road, route 14, 781-0201 +the Crow’s nest, 415 boody’s Hill road, 781-0600 +emile’s restaurant, east north Street and routes 5 & 20, 789-2775 +geneva-on-the-lake, 1001 lochland road, 789-7190 +madderlake Café, West lake road, 781-2424 +the red brick inn, 291 main St., 789-3247 + +Diners/Grilles +Flour Petal Café, 34 linden St., 781-2233 +Parkers’ grille & tap House, 100 Seneca St., 789-4656 +Ports Cone & grill, 4432 W. lake road, 789-2020 +Water Street Café, 467 exchange St., 789-2560 +the Captain’s room, 372 exchange St., 781-0122 +dana’s time out, 258 Hamilton St., 781-2107 + +Italian-American and Pizza +nonna Cosentino’s trattoria, 1 railroad Place, 789-1638 +Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria, 99 n. genesee Street, 781-1199 + +International +ling ling, 481 Hamilton Street, 781-0668 +main moon, 480 exchange Street, 781-5106 +Wing tai oriental restaurant, 164 Castle Street, 789-8892 +garcia’s mexican restaurant, 313 Hamilton Street, 789-5760 + +Fast Food/Family Chains +routes 5 & 20 west of downtown geneva (Hamilton Street) offers an array of popu- +lar fast food and family chains, including Quiznos, tim Horton’s, Club 86 bagels +and Cakes, Friendly’s, KFC-taco bell, mcdonald’s, long John Silver’s, Pizza Hut, +Subway, Waffle Works and Wendy’s. 11 -Tools - -configured -and used in - -published to - -added to - -Web, mobile, -and desktop apps - -Data - -Web layers + FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQs) + +Do you require the TOEFL for international students? +Yes, we do require the toeFl (test of english as a Foreign language). We offer limited +english language support on campus, and require that students have a solid foundation +in english prior to admission. the minimum required computer based toeFl score is +220. the Colleges also will accept the aPiel examination in lieu of the toeFl. + +Do you offer financial assistance for international students? +need-based scholarships are available to international students. the cost of attend- +ing college here for the 2007-2008 academic year is U.S. $45,968. the average aid +package typically equals more than half the annual cost of tuition, room and board. +Highly competitive applicants will be considered for a full-tuition scholarship. the +financial aid application forms are included in the application for admissions. + +How many international students do you currently have on campus? +We have 32 full-time matriculated students in a degree program Fall 2006 +Semester. the following countries are represented: austria, bulgaria, Canada, +China, Colombia, Czech republic, germany, india, nepal, Pakistan, South Korea, +Sweden, turkey, Ukraine, United Kingdom and Vietnam. + +Do you have an international student adviser? +Yes, the student adviser is responsible for working with our international students +on campus to help them make the transition from home to the Colleges. We offer an +international student orientation prior to the first-year and transfer student orienta- +tion at the beginning of the academic year, and the beginning of the spring semester +for new arrivals. a variety of activities and programs are available throughout the +year. Student advising and counseling is available in a variety of other areas on cam- +pus, including faculty advisers, Hubbs Health Center, and the Center for teaching +and learning. We make every effort to work individually with each student to help +them reach their potential and make the most of the opportunities available here. + +Do you have an international student organization? +Yes. the international Student association (iSa) is a student organization that cel- +ebrates the diverse cultures found around the globe. other cultural clubs with interna- +tional perspectives represented on campus include asian Student association (aSU), +latin american organization (lao), Caribbean Student association (CSa), and +dia al-din: muslim Student association. + +Do you have E.S.L. services? +Yes, an entry level course is offered, as are workshops and one-to-one tutoring. How- +ever, the Colleges do not offer a full e.S.l. curriculum. + +What kinds of housing are available? +Within the Hobart and William Smith community are dozens of smaller communi- +ties--those of the individual residences. the range of housing options is extensive, + +12 + + with coed or single-sex college residences, cooperative houses, theme houses, and +town houses among the choices you’ll find over your four years here. residence +halls offer a variety of configurations, with traditional singles and doubles as well as +suites. Some recent theme houses have included Jewish Culture House, multicul- +tural Sisterhood House, Writers House, and international awareness House. the +ten cooperative houses provide an alternative to standard residence-hall living, with +residents sharing responsibility for food and housecleaning arrangements. + +Is it possible to work on campus? +You are eligible to work up to 20 hours a week on campus, if your visa status permits +it. However, the demand for such employment exceeds the number of jobs available. +therefore, you cannot use on-campus employment as a resource for the issuance of +the i-20 form. + +STORAGE AND TRANSPORTATION OF SCHOOL YEAR ITEMS +Special consideration will be given to those international students who need storage +on campus during the school breaks. international students must attend a manda- +tory meeting in September regarding storage and transportation of school year items. +attendance will be taken at this meeting. Students unable to attend this meeting +must take the initiative to set up a meeting with the international Student adviser +before oct. 1. + +the storage and transportation meeting in September will encompass the following +information: +a. date and time of transportation to and from storage areas + +- Winter break (december) +- Summer break (may) +b. location of storage areas +c. How to pack and maximum number of storage items allowed +each student will be allowed no more than 8 items. items must be labeled with +students name, return date and number of items. boxes must be secured properly +and must be easily manageable. large items such as refrigerators, sofas, etc. will not +be accommodated due to limited space. +d. transportation requirements: items are to be placed at curbside 15 minutes +before van arrives for pick up. +e. Cost of transportation = $20 per student (gas and labor cost) +f. information on surcharges: the student’s account will be charged a surcharge for +each infraction: + +- No shows = $50 +- Fail to have items at curbside = $20 +- Not packed = $20 +- Change of time and/or date without 24 hour notice to Intercultural Affairs + Office = $40 + +Please Note: Storage space is limited, therefore there is no guarantee that you +will get storage or transportation support. -Web maps -and scenes - -The main types of content in Web GIS and their relationships. - -These five main content types are described as follows: - -• Data: ArcGIS Online supports data in a variety of formats, including CSV, shapefiles, GPS - -Exchange Format (GPX), JavaScript Object Notation (GeoJSON), photos, imagery, geodata- -bases, and so on. - -• Layers: The Esri geospatial cloud can host layers, including feature layers, tiled layers, vector -tiles, map image layers, image layers, scene layers, CSV layers, tables, and Open Geospatial -Consortium (OGC) standard layers such as Keyhole Markup Language (KML), Web Map -Service (WMS), Web Map Tile Service (WMTS), and Web Feature Service (WFS). - -• Web maps and scenes: A web map, which is 2D, or a scene, which is 3D, comprises one or - -multiple layers and allows sophisticated layer configuration, including styles, pop-ups, labels, -and access permission. - -• Tools: Tools perform analytical functions, such as geocoding, routing, generating PDF files, - -summarizing data, finding hot spots, and analyzing proximity. - -• Apps: GIS apps are lightweight mapcentric programs that can be used on mobile devices, -in web browsers, or on desktops. Developers can program with ArcGIS web APIs to build -web apps. However, you do not have to be a developer to create a web app. ArcGIS provides -many ready-to-use web apps and mobile apps that can be used without programming. +13 -Apps: The face of Web GIS -Apps bring Web GIS to life. Web GIS end users directly interact with apps. The back-end data, -web layers, and server computation power of Web GIS become live and useful through apps. -ArcGIS provides ready-to-use apps out of the box and provides APIs and software development -kits (SDKs) for developers to create custom apps. + IN CASE OF AN EMERGENCY +if you should have a need to contact the international Student adviser while travel- +ing outside of the United States please call (315) 781-3656 and ask for extension +3319. You can also contact the office directly by calling (315) 781-3319. + +In an emergency, they can be reached at (315) 781-3333. + +remember that the international Student adviser, while a resource to you, is not +your only resource during your time at the Colleges. While on campus, your respec- +tive deans will be available to assist you with a variety of issues, and should always +be kept aware of important matters. + +WHAT TO EXPECT DURING SCHOOL BREAKS +Since not everyone is able to return home during school breaks, international +students are allowed to remain on campus during those times. at specific times +during the fall and spring, you will receive e-mails from the residential education +office asking about their plans during the upcoming break. Your immediate response +is necessary as it is the only way to ensure that you will get permission to remain in +your room or elsewhere on the campus during school breaks. + +Students are not allowed to remain in their rooms during fall, winter and spring + +breaks. during summer vacation, students who remain on campus must move into +temporary housing. once again, an e-mail from the residential education office +is the first step in determining where students will be staying during the summer. +Currently, international students are allowed to stay on campus during the summer +holiday free of charge (subject to change). + +the dining hall is not open to students during the summer months so students +will need to provide their own meals. most summer housing will feature a kitchen, +but in the event that one doesn’t, appropriate accommodations will be made for +those students who wish to prepare their own meals. + +the international student adviser must also know your plans and should also be + +notified if you will or will not be staying on campus. + +US Holidays/Observances +January 1 +January 15 +3rd monday in February +2nd Sunday in may +4th monday in may +3rd Sunday in June +July 4th +1st monday in September +october 31 +november 11 +4th thursday in november +december 4 +december 25 +december 26 + +14 + +new Year’s day +martin luther King Jr. day +Presidents day +mother’s day +memorial day +Father’s day +independence day +labor day +Halloween +Veterans day +thanksgiving +Hanukkah begins +Christmas day +Kwanzaa + + SECTION II: +IMMIGRATION PROCEDURES + +HOW TO GET ASSISTANCE WITH IMMIGRATION MATTERS + +the international Student adviser is available to help you process your immigration +forms and documents. Working with the department of Homeland Security can be +very complicated, detailed, and time-consuming. it is important that you do not rely +on information obtained from friends and other students because circumstances may +vary from one student to another and the regulations can and do change. + the international Student adviser must work within the federal immigration +laws. When making a request, please make sure that you allow plenty of time for +your request to be processed and plan to be patient. Have your documents, such as +your passport, i-94 card, i-20 or dS-2019 with you when you go to the international +student office for immigration assistance. + +Important: You should allow at least one week for processing signatures, letters +and/or other types of paperwork. Special consideration will be given for emergency +situations. + +Reminder: the international Student adviser cannot remember when each +student’s documents expire. it is YOUR responsibility to keep track of all immigra- +tion documents and keep them current. + +Hristo Dimitrov ’09 (Bulguria), and Ayokunle Abogan ’06 (Nigeria) -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 12 +15 -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS + IMMIGRATION BASICS AND DEFINITION OF TERMS + +as with all countries, the United States has laws and regulations governing foreign- +ers who are temporarily within its borders. the immigration regulations are adminis- +tered by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). + +immigration regulations can change frequently and are difficult to interpret. it +is important for international students to understand the rules as they apply to stu- +dent status. The DHS does not consider ignorance of the law a legitimate reason +for failing to obey it. + Questions should be directed to the international Student adviser, who will be +able to assist with legal regulations and can sign your immigration documents. + +dHS requires that a copy of your passport, i-94 and other immigration docu- +ments be kept on file by the international Student adviser, as well as your local +address and telephone number. + +Passport +be sure to keep your passport in a safe place. it is your most important document. +most passports are good for a limited period of time. Your passport must be valid at +all times while you are in the United States. + +the expiration date of your passport should be six months beyond the date you + +enter the U.S. if your passport expiration date is close to the date you will begin +classes, obtain a new passport before leaving home. + +it is your responsibility to remember when your passport will expire and to con- +tact the nearest consulate or embassy for your country. to find the nearest consulate +or U.S. embassy check http://usembassy.state.gov. + +Your passport can only be extended by your government and it usually takes +several weeks for a passport to be renewed, so be sure to allow enough time. You may +extend your passport in the U.S. at your home country’s embassy or consulate. You +are in this country illegally if your passport expires and are subject to deportation. + +Visas +the visa stamped in your passport at the U.S. embassy or Consulate is for permis- +sion to enter the United States for a specific purpose and period of time. Students +are usually given an F-1 visa. J-1 visas are given to researchers, scholars and students +who are sponsored by agencies or universities. + +Since the visa stamp is only important for entry and re-entry to the United +States, there is no need to worry if it expires while you are here if you are maintain- +ing your student status. because a visa is only a permit to apply for entry into a coun- +try, it is not possible to obtain a U.S. visa while you are in the U.S. to apply for a +visa, you must go to a U.S. consulate or embassy in a country other than the United +States, usually your home country. + +I-94 (Arrival/Departure Record) +Form i-94, also called the arrival/departure record of Stay Permit, is the small white +card given to you at the port of entry to the U.S. this form is very important since it +officially determines how long an international student can remain in the U.S. + +16 + + Students on the F-1 and J-1 visas usually have their i-94 stamped “d/S” (dura- + +tion of Status), which means that the student can remain in this country for the +length of time required to complete his/her studies as long as the student follows all +of the regulations of the student visa. the eleven-digit number written on your i-94 +is your dHS admission number, which is used by the dHS to monitor entry into and +departure from the U.S. The I-94 cards are turned in when leaving the U.S. and a +new I-94 is completed with each subsequent entry. + +if you are on a visa other than a F or J, or if you have a specific date stamped on + +your i-94 card instead of the “d/S” designation, you must apply for an extension, a +Change of Status, or exit the U.S before the expiration date or you will be consid- +ered out of status and a visa overstay, which can have serious dHS consequences. + +SEVIS +an acronym for Student and exchange Visitor information System (SeViS). it is a +data collection and monitoring system that creates an interface between institutions +of higher education, the department of Homeland Security (dHS), consulates and +embassies abroad, and ports of entry. Schools are required to make regular electronic +updates in SeViS throughout each semester on the records of their enrolled students +in F-1 and J-1 status and their dependents and their researchers and faculty on J-1 +status. this includes, but is not limited to enrollment status, changes in address, +changes in level of study, employment recommendations and school transfers. + +Form I-20 +When Hobart and William Smith Colleges accepts an international student for +full-time study, the student is sent a Form i-20 a-b as proof of acceptance and to +use when applying for an F-1 Student Visa at a U.S. Consulate abroad. the student +presents the i-20 with their passport and visa at the Port of entry and the i-20 is +stamped and given back to the student. this is your Certificate of eligibility, and +it must be signed by a dSo/ international Student adviser before you leave the +United States. Students should keep copies of all i-20 issued to them. + +Immigration Status +this is often confused with “visa” but your immigration status, e.g., F-1, J-1, etc. is +determined at the time of your entry into the U.S. by an immigration official and is +noted on the Form i-94. You may have many visa stamps in your passport but, upon +entry into the U.S., an immigration inspector will admit you in only one immigra- +tion status which is noted on the i-94 card. + +OBTAINING A VISA AND FORM I-20 +Your passport should be valid at least six months beyond the date of entering the U.S. +as a student. be sure to check your passport expiration date. if it will expire close to +when you will begin classes, obtain a new passport before applying for your visa. + +How to Obtain a Visa +although U.S. embassies will not issue a student visa prior to 120 days before the +start date on the i-20 (or dS-2019 for J’s), you can schedule an appointment prior + +17 + + to the 120-day period. Since processing times have become longer due to increased +security clearances, students should check with their local U.S. embassy or consulate +to learn the estimated waiting time and allow plenty of time to obtain the visa. a +list of consulates and embassies can be found at http://usembassy.state.gov/. + +You will need to pay a $100 SeViS fee at least 3 business days before your visa +interview. the fee can be paid online or by mail. For complete directions, see http:// +www.fmJfee.com. + Unless you are a sponsored J-1 student or already in another visa category, the +Colleges’ office of admissions will send you a Form i-20 when you are admitted and +have submitted proof of your ability to finance your education. take the i-20 form, +your acceptance letter, passport, copies of sponsorship letters and bank statements +to prove financial support, and a receipt for your SeViS fee payment to the United +States embassy or consulate nearest your home. once you have acquired the visa +stamp in your passport, you are ready to enter the U.S. + +Note: Students may not enter the U.S. more than 30 days prior to the start date +on their I-20. + +Canadian and some British Commonwealth citizens do not need visas to enter +the U.S., but they must request F-1 status and present their i-20 forms for process- +ing at the point of entry even if the official does not ask for it. they should also be +prepared to show evidence of financial support and proof of citizenship. Without a +stamped i-20 and an i-94 card with the F-1 or J-1 designation on it, you are con- +sidered a tourist in the United States and will not be legally able to study and take +advantage of the special privileges allowed those in Student Status until he or she +has been in an immigration status appropriate for studying for at least nine consecu- +tive months. + +Note: If you will not be entering the U.S. on an F-1 visa, do not use an I-20 form +to obtain a visa. If you received an I-20, please return it to the Office of Admis- +sions with an explanation of the type of visa you hold. + +if your visa document (i-20 or dS-2019) does not arrive in time for you to secure +the proper visa, do not enter the United States on a B1/B2 Visitor Visa. obtain a +b-2 “prospective student” or “prospective exchange visitor” visa from a U.S. embassy +or consulate post in your country. be certain the consul writes “Prospective Student” +or “Prospective exchange Visitor” (for J-1) in your passport on the visa page. You +will need to present your letter of acceptance and evidence of financial support to +request this visa. + +in general, it is best to avoid using the b-2 visa since you will have to pay a fee +and do a time-consuming change of status through dHS (department of Homeland +Security) after you arrive. You may not begin your studies until the change is com- +pleted, so this could also delay the start of your studies until a subsequent term. + +Note: Students must attend the school named on the I-20 or DS-2019 presented at +the port of entry in order to be in status. Also, do not enter the U.S. on a “W-T” + +18 + + (waiver) as this classification cannot be extended or changed and you will lose your +legal immigration status as a student. + +Students Transferring From another Colleges in the United States +if you are an F-1 student transferring from a U.S. institution and will not be leav- +ing the country prior to enrollment at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, follow +the procedures required by dHS. bring your completed i-20 to the international +Student adviser’s office as soon as possible after your arrival on campus. Sign the +document and leave it to be processed by a dSo/ international Student adviser +who will notify you when you may pick it up. + +if you leave the U.S. before beginning your studies at Hobart and William +Smith Colleges, use the new i-20 issued by the Colleges when you arrive at the port +of entry. Keep the i-20 from your old school with your immigration records, but do +not use it to enter the U.S. it is not necessary for transfer students with an unex- +pired student visa and who have maintained their status to obtain a new visa, even +though the former school’s name is listed. + +Transfer to another School +to be eligible to transfer schools, you must be pursuing a full-course of study at your +current school. otherwise you are “out of status” and must apply to dHS for rein- +statement to student status, which, if granted, will allow you to transfer. + +Students transferring to another school must notify the dSo/international +Student adviser of their intent to transfer. Hobart and William Smith Colleges +must release your SeViS record to the new school before a new i-20 can be issued +for the transfer. Upon arrival at the new school, the student should take the new +i-20 to the international Student adviser at the new school. J-1 students wishing to +transfer should consult with their sponsor. + +Changing Your Academic Level +if you are currently a student at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, and will be +continuing your studies in an additional program of study (such as a mat Program), +you should follow the transfer procedure. a new i-20 will be issued for the new pro- +gram, and you will use the new i-20 to enter the country. if you do not leave, bring +it to the international Student adviser as described in the transfer process in the +preceding paragraph. Failure to complete this “internal transfer” will cause you to +be out of status with dHS, which can adversely affect work authorizations or other +student privileges. + +DIFFERENCES BETWEEN F-1 AND J-1 STATUS +there are two types of entry visa issued to nonimmigrant students who intend to +study full-time at Hobart and William Smith Colleges—the F-1 student visa and the +J-1 exchange visitor visa. + +• Source of Funding: J-1 exchange visitor visa status is available to those students +who are supported substantially by funding other than personal or family funds. +Such funding may include that which comes from the U.S. government or the + +19 + + student’s home government, or an international organization, or the Colleges. Stu- +dents who are supported by personal or family funds are ineligible for J-1 immigra- +tion status and must come to the U.S. to study in F-1 immigration status. + +• Foreign Residence Requirement: Students in J-1 immigration status and the J-2 +dependents may be subject to a “foreign residence requirement.” J-1 students who +receive direct or indirect U.S. or home government funding, or who are studying +in fields for which personnel are considered in short supply in their home coun- +tries (most developing nations have “Country Skills” lists of varying lengths), are +ineligible to apply for a change to another non-immigrant status (except a or g) +or permanent residency in the U.S. until they have satisfied the “two year home +country physical presence requirement. only those in J-1 status with government +funding or whose skills are on Country Skills list are subject to the foreign resi- +dence requirement, which mean upon completion of the program of study they must +reside in their country of last legal permanent residence for two years before they are +eligible to apply for entry into the U.S. on an immigrant visa or on specialized work +visa (H or l). there is no foreign residence requirement for students on F-1 student +status. refer to the department of State’s website for additional information on the +exchange Visitor Program. + +• Medical Insurance: Students in J-1 status and their J-2 dependents are required to +have comprehensive medical coverage in order to fulfill U.S. government regula- +tions governing the J exchange Visitor status. Currently the medical insurance +offered by Hobart and William Smith Colleges does not cover all requirements for +those in J immigration status. the U.S. department of State specifies that program +participants and their dependents have medical coverage with the following mini- +mum requirements (22 CFr 62:14): medical benefits of at least $50,000 per accident +or illness; repatriation of remains in the amount of $7, 500, medical evacuation of +the exchange visitor to his or her home country in the amount of $10, 000, and a +deductible not to exceed $500 per accident or illness. For more information please +contact the international Student adviser. + +• Work Permission: Students in either F-1 or J-1 immigration status may work part +time (up to 20 hours per week) on campus with permission from the international +Student adviser. For both statuses, permission to work off campus based on eco- +nomic need may be requested only after the first full academic year of student status, +and only under extraordinary circumstances of unforeseen need. the United States +Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) authorizes F-1 students to work off +campus, whereas J-1 students submit an application for work permission to their visa +sponsor, i.e. the agency or school that issued the dS-2019 form. + +• Practical or Academic Training: Students in F-1 and J-1 immigration status are +eligible to engage in differing lengths of practical or academic training during their +studies and at the completion of their academic programs. Practical training, a +privilege of F-1 immigration status if you are eligible, is employment in one’s field of +study. those in F-1 immigration classification may be eligible for “curricular” practi- + +20 + + cal training (which is authorized by the international Student adviser) during their +programs, in addition to one year of “optional” practical training that may take place +during or after one’s program of study. Permission to engage in practical training may +be granted only after you have been in valid student status for one academic year, +except in a graduate program that requires it from the first term. the international +Student adviser recommends optional practical training and the USCiS authorizes +it. refer to the Practical training overview for complete information on both cur- +ricular and optional practical training. academic training, a privilege of J-1 immi- +gration status if you are eligible, is employment which is integral, not just related, +to one’s field of study. one is eligible to apply for permission to engage in academic +training after one academic term in valid student status. a total of 18 months of +academic training is possible during or following completion of a program of study, +with the exception of some postdoctoral research positions that may qualify for up +to 36 months. an application for academic training is made to the J-1 student’s +exchange Visitor program sponsor. refer to academic training authorization for +those in J-1 exchange Visitor immigration Status for complete information. + +ARRIVING AT A U.S. PORT OF ENTRY … +WHAT A STUDENT CAN EXPECT +Plan your arrival: You may be refused entry into the United States if you attempt to +arrive more than 30 days before the start date listed on your SeViS i-20 form. + +Always carry your passport and I-20 on hand: do not check the following docu- +ments in your baggage. if your baggage is lost or delayed, you will be unable to pres- +ent the documents at your port of entry. as a result, you may not be able to enter +the United States. + +In addition, it is strongly recommended that you carry on hand the following + +documentation: + +1. evidence of financial resources +2. evidence of student status, such as tuition receipts +3. name and contact information for your international Student adviser, + +including a 24-hour emergency contact number at the school + +Complete your entry paperwork: +Arriving by Air: Flight attendants will distribute Customs declaration Forms and +arrival departure Forms (i-94). these must be completed prior to landing. + +Arriving by Land or Sea: the CbP officer at the port of entry will provide the +necessary Customs declaration Form and the arrival-departure Form (i-94) to be +filled out upon arrival. + as you arrive at the port of entry proceed to the terminal area for arriving +passengers. Have the following documents available for presentation: you passport, +i-20, arrival-departure Form (i-94), and the Customs declaration Form. Your docu- +ments will be examined and processed by the department of Homeland Security +(dHS) at the port of entry. Your passport will be returned to you along with an i-94 +card (arrival/departure record) designated “d/S” which means “duration of status” + +21 + + and refers to the time you are engaged in a full-time course of study as indicated on +your visa document. the dHS official will stamp and return your i-20 to you. + +Note: Your documents are extremely important. They legitimize your presence in +the United States. Keep them in a safe and secure place. + +For Further Information: +Preparing to Study in the U.S. http://educationusa.state.gov/ +applying for a Visa to Study in the U.S. http://travel.state.gov/visa/temp/types/ +types_1268.html + +MAINTAINING & BEING IN STATUS WITH DHS +an F-1 student is considered in-status for the entire length of time during which +he/she is enrolled as a full-time student in an educational program if adhering to +the conditions of the visa designated on the i-94 card, plus any authorized period of +practical training and an additional sixty (60) days to prepare for departure. be sure +to pay close attention to the conditions described below: + +• report to the international Student adviser for SeViS registration upon arrival +at Hobart and William Smith Colleges. + +• attend only the school authorized. this means that you must only attend the +school whose i-20 you last used to enter the U.S. or the school whose i-20 you used +to transfer schools. if you decide to withdraw from the Colleges before completing +your program, you are not allowed to remain in the U.S. with in-student status un- +less you transfer to another institution. + +• Complete a full course of study for each academic term and make normal academ- +ic progress towards completion of program. attendance and/or full-time enrollment +is not required during the summer. at Hobart and William Smith Colleges 4 credit +hours per semester is required and exceptions can be made on the recommenda- +tion of the international Student adviser for valid medical or academic reasons as +defined by the dHS. be sure to speak with the international Student adviser about +any exceptions beFore dropping below full-time status in order to avoid the seri- +ous consequences that may result from being out of status. + +• transfer or extend program in a timely manner. duration of Status expires if a +student takes longer than expected to complete a given academic level (e.g. bachelor’s, +master’s, and doctorate). the amount of time permitted for completing studies at a +given level is determined by the date on the initial i-20 issued at the beginning of each +academic level. Students must pay close attention to the expected completion date +noted in item 5 on the form i-20 for each level. if more time is needed, an applica- +tion for extension of stay must be filed with the dHS. there are certain requirements +to meet in order to be eligible for an extension, so you will need to consult with the +international Student adviser at least 45 days before the completion date. + +22 + + • Keep continuity in the program of study (in general an absence from the U.S. of +more than 5 months terminates status. However, an authorized study abroad pro- +gram does not break continuity). + +• refrain from unauthorized work. When you apply for an F-1 visa, you must prove +that you have full financial support. the law assumes that you will not be employed +in the U.S. and therefore will not accept employment that could be filled by a U.S. +worker or student. there are some exceptions to this policy provided that full-time +enrollment during the year is maintained and the appropriate permission is ob- +tained, but you should always check with the international Student adviser before +accepting employment, especially if it is off campus. + +• When traveling abroad, always return in proper F-1 status. + +• maintain a valid passport for 6 months into the future (Some countries have +agreements with the U.S. that recognize the passport as valid for 6 months after the +expiration date). + +• report any address changes to the international Student adviser within 10 days +of the change. dHS regulations require that the international Student adviser +maintain a record of the current address where you are living. therefore, you must +always notify the international Student adviser immediately of any change of ad- +dress. addresses with a post office box number or addresses of your academic depart- +ment are not acceptable to the dHS. + +• Comply with Special registration requirements if applicable (nSeerS). + +• File timely requests of change of status, practical training and other benefits. + +• obey all State and Federal laws. + +• depart form the U.S. in a timely manner. + +• do not enter on a tourist visa (b-1 or b-2). + +Note: Students who fail to maintain full-time enrollment are not eligible for any +of the benefits of the student visa, such as on-campus and off-campus employ- +ment, practical training, remaining in the U.S. during summer vacation, transfer +to another school or change of level, or registration for further courses. they are +considered to be “out of status” and must apply to dHS for reinstatement to valid +student status. eligibility for benefits will be regained only if and when the dHS +approves the reinstatement. if you have any questions regarding reinstatement, see +the international Student adviser immediately. + +23 + + EXCEPTIONS TO A FULL COURSE OF STUDY + +• the normal vacation period; + +• medical problems documented by a licensed medical doctor, osteopath or clinical +psychologist. approval for reduced or no course load for a medical condition is limited +to 12 months total for the program of study; + +• teaching or research assistantship; + +• Valid academic reasons, such as first semester language difficulties and/or adjustment +problems, improper course placement, unfamiliarity with american teaching methods; + +• the final term when the student needs less than a fulltime course load to complete +program of study. Student must be enrolled in at least one credit; + +• during a period of full-time optional or Curricular Practical training. + +DURATION OF STATUS FOR F-1 STUDENTS +an F-1 student is admitted to the U.S. for a period known as “duration of Status” +which is recorded upon entry documents i-94 and i-20 with the notation “d/S”. du- +ration of Status refers to the period a student is pursuing a full course of study, plus +any authorized practical training following completion. The dates on the I-20 de- +termine the initial parameters of the duration of status. A student can be admit- +ted to the U.S. up to 30 days prior to the report date on the I-20 and may remain +60 days after completion of program or practical training. Certain factors may +reduce grace period to 15 days or to 0 days. an international Student adviser au- +thorized withdrawal from classes is allowed a 15-day period for departure. a student +who fails to maintain status is not eligible for an additional period for departure. + +TEMPORARY DEPARTURE FROM THE U.S. +If you plan on leaving the U.S. temporarily to visit your homeland or some other +country, an International Student Adviser must validate your I-20 for re-entry into +the U.S. You may not be allowed back into the U.S. without the validated immigra- +tion documents, a current visa, and a passport which is valid for at least six months +after you re-enter the country. + most students with valid status may travel to Canada, mexico and many of the +adjacent islands if they have a valid passport, a valid i-94 and a valid i-20 or dS-2019. +if you re-enter the U.S. in fewer than 30 days, an unexpired U.S. visa is not required. +However, Canada, mexico and the island nations do require entry visas for citizens of +certain countries. + +it is always best to check with the embassy or consulate of any country you wish + +to visit. Since certain countries are ineligible for this benefit and travel regulations are +subject to change, you should check with the international Student adviser if you +intend to travel with an expired visa. + +Students who apply for a new visa in contiguous territory forfeit the right to re- + +24 + + enter with an expired visa. if the new visa is denied, the student would not be able to +re-enter the United States to study until a valid visa is obtained in their home country. + +ACCEPTING U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLIC ASSISTANCE OR PUBLIC +BENEFITS +international students and scholars should not, under any circumstance, accept public +benefits from the federal, state, county or any other local government agencies in the +United States. this includes, but is not limited to, participation in programs such +as medicare/medicaid, Supplemental Social Security income, aid to Families with +dependent Children, food stamps, and subsidized housing. accepting such benefits +can cause you to lose your legal status in the United States and create a bar to your +re-entry to this country. + +Cooperation between state social service agencies and the inS and department + +of State make it possible for an inS inspector or U.S. Consular officer to become +aware of an individual who has accepted public benefits. the acceptance of public +benefits is interpreted as a declaration that the individual is unable to meet his or her +financial obligations (a requirement of obtaining and maintaining status) and thereby +rendering him or herself ineligible for F-1 or J-1 status. + occasionally a well-meaning social service agency, hospital or public housing admin- +istrator may offer such assistance not realizing that non-immigrants are ineligible for such +benefits. additionally, even though U.S. citizen children of non-immigrant parents may be +eligible for pre and post-natal public benefits, the non-immigrant parent may be denied a +visa or re-entry based on the child’s receiving the benefits. again this is interpreted as the +non-immigrant individual not being able to meet his or her financial obligations. + +Information on U.S. Social Security Numbers (SSN) +if you will be employed in the United States, including at Hobart and William Smith +Colleges, you must obtain a U.S. Social Security number, which is used by the U.S. +government to identify wage earners for tax purposes. the number assigned to interna- +tional students is not a valid U.S. Social Security number. + +to apply for a Social Security number (SSn) you must obtain a “proof of work” + +form from the international Student adviser confirming your student or exchange +visitor status, that you are authorized to engage in on-campus employment, the nature +of the employment to be engaged in, and identify the department/office for whom you +will be working before being able to apply to the Social Security administration for +a SSn. You must also present your passport, your i-20 or dS-2019 form and your i-94 +form. the Social Security administration office is open monday-Friday from 9:00 a.m. +to 4:00 p.m. (closed on federal holidays). + +Social Ssecurity numbers will not be issued to foreign nationals who are not +authorized to work. a Social Security number is not required for opening a bank +account, registering for school, filing a U.S. tax form or applying for a driver’s license. +if you are required to file a tax return and are not eligible for a U.S. Social Security +number, you will have to apply to the internal revenue Service (irS) for a tax iden- +tification number (tin) on form W-7. this form may be obtained from the Colleges +payroll department. + +For more information about U.S. Social Security Numbers visit the website or + +call their toll-free number at 1-800-772-1213. + +25 + + WORK OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS IN F-1 STATUS +The following is a list of all opportunities to obtain authorization to work in the +United States if you are in F-1 immigration status. Each category may allow for +authorization under different circumstances and at different times during your +stay in the U.S. This is summary of work benefits but does not include all regu- +lations governing employment. + +On-campus Work: Full-time students are allowed to work up to twenty hours per +week during the academic year. on campus employment means that you are paid by +Hobart and William Smith Colleges or working at a Colleges location with an em- +ployer that is providing services to students, such as Sodexho’s Saga dining hall or +the Café. on-campus employment requires an i-9 employment verification autho- +rization form to be completed by you at the Colleges business office. + +Off-campus Work Based on Financial Need: Students who have been in F-1 status +for one academic year and who are experiencing extreme financial difficulties due to +unforeseen changes that severely affect their financial resources may apply for work +permission. authorization is given by the dHS with the recommendation of the +international Student advisers/ dSo. + +Internship with an International Organization: Students in F-1 status are eligible +to apply for permission to work for international organizations such as the World +bank, the international monetary Fund, etc. authorization is granted by the dHS +with the recommendation of the international Student adviser/dSo. + +WORK OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS IN J-1 STATUS +J-1 On-Campus Employment +enrolled J-1 students may work on campus up to 20 hours per week during the +semester and full time during the break with the permission of their sponsor. if the +Colleges are your sponsor please see the international Student adviser. + +J-1 Off-Campus Employment +if a J-1 student needs employment during the academic year due to financial hard- +ship arising form unforeseen circumstances, the program sponsor may authorize it. +Such employment cannot interfere with full-time pursuit of the exchange visitor’s +program objective and is limited to 20 hours per week during the academic year and +full-time during break. + +PRACTICAL TRAINING: +this is defined as employment related to your field of study and is available dur- +ing and after completion of your studies. the following is a list of the categories of +practical training: + +Curricular practical training (before completion of your studies) is defined as + +employment pursuant to a required or optional internship which is an integral part +of the established curriculum of your school. + +26 + + optional practical training is defined as employment related to your field of study. +it is authorized in variable increments, deducted form the maximum of one year of +optional practical training per educational level, and is available in the following +variations: + +1. optional practical training after completion of your studies +2. optional practical training before completion of your studies with three pos- + +sible variations: + +a. practical training during the annual vacation. the annual vacation must + +follow at least two consecutive terms of fulltime enrollment and is usually taken in +the summer + +b. practical training when school is in session, provided that employment + +does not exceed 20 hours a week + +c. practical training following the completion of all the course requirements + +for the degree except the thesis or equivalent + +Optional Practical Training (OPT) Before Completion of Degree Requirements +definition: employment related to your field of study before completion of all degree +requirements. it is authorized in variable increments and is deducted from the +maximum of one year (12 months) of optional practical training per educational +level. there are three circumstances under which this type of practical training can +be authorized: -The ready-to-use apps include configurable apps (also referred to as ArcGIS Online and Portal -for ArcGIS web app templates), ArcGIS StoryMaps℠ stories, mobile apps, app builders, and -more. ArcGIS organizes these apps into bundles: +1. Following completion of all degree requirements except the thesis or equivalent +2. during the annual vacation +3. Part-time (up to 20 hours per week) during the academic year -• Essential apps bundle: ArcGIS StoryMaps, ArcGIS Experience Builder, ArcGIS Web -AppBuilder, ArcGIS Dashboards, instant apps, ArcGIS Hub Basic, Map Viewer, Scene -Viewer, and so on +Eligibility to Engage In OPT: You must: +• be a registered student in F-1 status physically in the United States at the time of +application +• have been enrolled in lawful student status on a full-time basis for at least one full +academic year +• not have used twelve months or more of full-time curricular practical training +oPt is permitted for a period of up to a maximum of twelve months per educational +level (bachelors, masters, etc.). -• Field apps bundle: ArcGIS Field Maps, ArcGIS Survey123, ArcGIS QuickCapture, and so on -• Office apps bundle: ArcGIS for Office, ArcGIS for SharePoint, and so on -• ArcGIS Pro -• ArcGIS Insights℠ -• Add-on apps: ArcGIS Drone2Map®, ArcGIS Navigator, ArcGIS Business Analyst™, and so on +Procedure: obtaining authorization for oPt is a two-step process. Your first step in +obtaining an employment authorization document (ead) is to qualify for a certifica- +tion from the international Student adviser/dSo recommending you for oPt. the +international Student adviser/dSo cannot authorize oPt - only the United States +Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) can do so by issuing you an ead. -ArcGIS user types consist of Viewer, Storyteller, Editor, Field Worker, Creator, GIS -Professional, and Insights Analyst (see table 1.3). Different user types have included access to -different app bundles and apps. Apps that are not included with a user type can be acquired and -assigned as add-on licenses. To finish most of the tutorials in this book, a Creator user type with -a Publisher role is required. +You may not begin employment until you have been issued an ead by the US- -Table 1 .3 . Main ArcGIS user types, privileges, and included apps +CiS and can work only within the time period indicated on the card. requests for +employment authorization must be mailed to the USCiS regional Service Center +having jurisdiction over your place of residence and may require 6 to 12 weeks for +adjudication. -Type +27 -Viewer + When to Apply: +• not more than 90 days prior to being enrolled for one full academic year· +• not more than 120 days prior to the employment start date that you select +Please note: the employment start date cannot be earlier than the date on which +you will have completed one full academic year. -Storyteller +How to Apply: +Obtaining the International Student Adviser recommendation +Since you must first obtain a new SeViS i-20 with the international Student ad- +viser/dSo’s oPt endorsement, which may require 5 working days, you should make +every effort to apply as early as possible within the 90 or 120 day window. You might +need to come twice to the international Student adviser/dSo—once to submit the +application and another to pick up the approved recommendation on a SeViS i-20. -Editor +Curricular Practical Training in F-1 Status +Definition: Curricular practical training (CPt) is employment pursuant to an intern- +ship requirement or internship elective which is an integral part of the established +curriculum of your school, which will be counted towards completion of your degree. -Privileges +Eligibility to engage in CPT: You must be a degree candidate who has been in +lawful status for at least one academic year. You must have been offered a specific +training opportunity that must fall into one of the following categories: +• to satisfy an internship requirement expected of all students in your program +and necessary for completion of your degree; +• to satisfy an internship elective which counts towards completion of your degree. +the internship elective must be listed in your school’s bulletin and must state in the +official course description that it is specifically designed to allow students enrolled in +the course to engage in off-campus internships; +• the internship may be done to engage in research necessary and integral to the +completion of the doctoral dissertation. -Can view items -Can’t create, edit, share, or analyze items +Restrictions: U.S. Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) regulations do +not place an absolute limit on the amount of CPt you may utilize. However, if you +engage in one year or more of full-time CPt, you will lose your eligibility to engage +in optional Practical training. CPt is always part-time during the academic year +unless the student is engaged in doctoral dissertation research. CPt may be full time +during the annual vacation. You may engage in curricular practical training only +after your SeViS record has been updated by the international Student adviser and +the i-20 has been printed, indicating the approved employment. the endorsement +will indicate the precise details of the authorized training, including the name and +location of the employer, the specific dates of the training period, and whether it +is full-time or part-time. We encourage you to contact the international Student +adviser/dSo if you have questions. -Can create stories and express maps -Can’t create other types of content +28 -Can view and edit data -Can’t analyze, create, or share items + Departure Checklist -Included apps +q admissions letter from HWS -Essential apps bundle +q evidence of Financial resources -Essential apps bundle +q Passport with Student Visa -Essential apps bundle +q Form 1-20 or dS-2019 -Field Worker +q Copies of medical records and other important documents translated into english -Same as Editor +q if J-1 visa holder – additional health insurance requirements. this must also be -+ Field apps bundles +translated into english, if needed. -Creator +q emergency outfit packed in carry-on luggage -Can edit, create, share content, and do analysis +q Calling card to use during travel -+ Office apps bundles +q emergency phone numbers (HWS: 1-315-781-3333) -GIS Professional +q minimum of 100 U.S. dollars for use in an emergency -Same as Creator +q Sweater or jacket in event of bad weather -Insights Analyst +q if taking prescription medicine bring prescription for future refills (translated into -Same as GIS Professional +english) -+ ArcGIS Pro +q Photocopy of your passport, visa, etc. do not carry in the same place as your -Insights +original documents. -“+” means including the apps from the user type listed earlier in the table . +29 -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps + SECTION III: +*SAMPLE* ORIENTATION SCHEDULE *SAMPLE* -13 +Hobart and William Smith Colleges +international Students orientation +“let Your adventure begin!” +august 22 -25, 2006 -Basic components of a Web GIS app -Today’s best practices recommend that a GIS app have basemaps, operational layers, and tools -(see figure). ArcGIS supports this practice and allows you to create Web GIS apps. +Tuesday, August 22 +8:30 a.m. –7:00 p.m. -+ +Wednesday, August 23 +8:30 a.m. –12:00 p.m. -+ +arrival/Check-in +location: office of intercultural affairs +288 Pulteney Street +**bring all immigration paperwork -= +arrival/Check-in +location: office of intercultural affairs, +288 Pulteney Street +**bring all immigration paperwork -Basemaps +HWS Student id Cards +location: registrar’s office -Operational -layers +Campus tour -Tools +Shopping @ Wal-mart & Wegmans Supermarket, +Van leaves from intercultural affairs parking lot -Web GIS app +12:30 p.m. - 1:30 p.m. -The basic components of a Web GIS app. +lunch with deans of the Colleges +location: blue room in Scandling Center -The components of a Web GIS app are described as follows: +1:45 p.m. – 2:45 p.m. -• Basemap layers: Basemaps provide a reference or context for your app. ArcGIS provides a -collection of fast-responding 2D and 3D basemaps (see figure). In addition, you can create -and use your own basemaps. +overview of library Services +location: Warren Hunting Smith library -ArcGIS provides a gallery of basemaps and an elevation service to support 2D and 3D web maps and apps. +6:00 p.m. – 7:30 p.m. -• Operational layers: Operational layers are theme layers that you and other users can use and -interact with. You can use existing layers from ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Living Atlas of -the World as your operational layers. These layers span a range of subjects and can support +dinner +location: intercultural affairs Center -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 14 +Thursday, August 24 +7:30 a.m. – 8:00 a.m. -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS +8:15 a.m. 9:45 a.m. -maps and apps of almost every subject. You can search these collections and discover layers -that fit your needs. You can also create and use your own operational layers. +30 -• Tools: Tools perform tasks beyond mapping, including common tasks such as query, geocod- -ing, routing, and more specialized tasks. ArcGIS Online provides extensive spatial analysis -tools for you to ask questions and solve spatial problems. ArcGIS Enterprise provides tools -for standard analysis, big data analysis, and raster analysis, and allows you to publish custom -web tools — in other words, geoprocessing services. +breakfast +location: Saga dining Hall in the blue room -Web layers or services: The building blocks of Web GIS -Web services technology is at the foundation of today’s Web GIS. The previously mentioned -three types of components of Web GIS apps are typically all based on web services. To make it -easier to understand, web services in ArcGIS are also called web layers or web tools. For exam- -ple, basemaps are often tile services or tile layers, operational layers are often feature services or -feature layers, and many tools are based on geoprocessing services or web tools. +immigration regulations overview +location: Conference room, 2nd Floor, +intercultural affairs -Early Web GIS was not based on web services; instead, it consisted mostly of stand-alone -websites in which GIS data and functions were available only to their own clients and couldn’t -be reused in other systems. This situation greatly limited the reusability of Web GIS resources. -In the late 1990s, web services technology was conceived. A web service is a program that runs -on a web server and provides programming interfaces for clients to consume over the web. Web -services have many advantages, such as flexibility in being reused and remixed in many web apps. -The GIS industry quickly adopted web services technology and reformed Web GIS products -based on web services architecture in the early 2000s. Today’s Web GIS products are designed to -support the publication, discovery, and use of GIS web services. A GIS service represents a GIS -resource — such as a layer, map, locator, or toolbox — that is located on the server and made avail- -able to web clients. For example, ArcGIS Living Atlas provides collections of ready-to-use GIS -services. The Esri geospatial cloud allows publishers to publish many types of GIS services and -allows users to discover and use GIS services in web maps, web apps, and mobile apps. + 10:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m. -This chapter introduces feature layers and services. Other chapters introduce raster tile ser- -vices, vector tile services, 3D scene services, map services, image services, stream services, geo- -processing services, geocoding services, and more. To support interoperability, ArcGIS supports -OGC standards such as WMS, WMTS, WFS, and KML. +11:05 a.m. – 11:35 a.m. -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps +on Campus employment/Social Security +elaine Ferrara, business office +location: tba -15 +benefits of the HWS Health insurance +ann brink, bursars office +location: tba -Hosted and nonhosted feature layers -Feature layers are the most used layer type for operational layers. Feature refers to vector data: -points, lines, and polygons. Feature layers can be hosted or nonhosted, depending on where the -underlying data is stored. +12:00 p.m. – 1:30 p.m. -• Hosted refers to a situation in which a web service is based on ArcGIS-managed data: for -instance, the data is stored in the ArcGIS Online cloud database (which is managed auto- -matically by Esri) or in ArcGIS Data Store (which is managed automatically by ArcGIS -Enterprise). +lunch with Chaplain lesley adams +location: Chaplain’s residence, 630 S. main St. -• Nonhosted refers to a situation in which a web service connects directly to user-managed +1:45 p.m. – 2:15 p.m. -data: for instance, the data is stored in your organization’s own database, and the database is -managed by your own organization. +money matters +beth turner, director of Financial aid +location: tba -Feature layers published to ArcGIS Online are always hosted feature layers. Feature layers pub- -lished in ArcGIS Enterprise can be hosted if the data is stored in ArcGIS Data Store or nonhosted -if your feature layers reference your organization’s own geodatabase — for example, SQL Server, -Oracle, or PostgreSQL. +2:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. -Hosted feature layers are often easier to publish because you don’t have to worry about the -underlying database. You don’t have to (and you won’t be able to) directly connect to the database -and manipulate it. To change the database schema and edit the data, you must go through the -hosted feature layer web interface. Nonhosted feature layers require that you have and manage -your own database. You can directly connect to the database and perform various operations -on it. +a Healthy You +location: Hubbs Health Center -This book teaches many ways to publish hosted feature layers—from CSV files, zipped file -geodatabases, ArcGIS Pro, and so on. You can also create empty feature layers and add fields in -ArcGIS Online (see chapter 4). +3:15 p.m. – 3:45 p.m. -Web maps and web scenes: The bridge between layers and apps -Web GIS provides Map Viewer and Scene Viewer for creators to integrate multiple layers, style -these layers, configure layer pop-ups, and make many other configurations. After a web map or -web scene is created, it can be used in one app or reused in many apps. This makes it easier for -creators to create apps. Without web maps and scenes, creators would often have to integrate the -layers directly and configure them in the apps, which can be cumbersome. +5:30 p.m. – 7:30 p.m. -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. 16 +Friday , August 25 +10:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m. -Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS +Study basics +Center for teaching & learning +location: Center for teaching & learning +(Ctl) -Paths to building Web GIS applications -The tutorials in this book teach readers how to build Web GIS apps. ArcGIS offers many paths to -this goal, as shown in this figure, which will be used throughout the book. +Welcome dinner +President and mrs. mark gearan & Family +location: President’s House – 690 South main St. -ArcGIS offers many ways to build web apps. The green arrows in the figure highlight the workflows and -technology presented in this chapter. +guide to U.S. education & Culture +amy teel and doug reilly, Center for +global education +location: delancey House -The figure presents the generic workflow to build Web GIS apps: +12:00 p.m. – 1:00 p.m. -• The data tier contains formats that range from simple CSV files managed with Microsoft +lunch +location: delancey House -Excel to sophisticated geodatabases managed with enterprise databases. +1:30 p.m. -• You can publish desktop resources to ArcGIS Online or ArcGIS Enterprise as web layers, +Join regular campus wide orientation schedule -tools, or other services. You can also use layers provided by ArcGIS Living Atlas. You can add -layers to web maps and web scenes and configure the styles and pop-ups in these layers. +Welcome to Hobart and William Smith Colleges -• On the client side, you can use various ready-to-use apps or custom apps. The former can be -configured without programming. The latter can be developed using various web APIs or -SDKs. +31 -Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q158/random_k2/random_2.md b/q158/random_k2/random_2.md index 482f9de9b0ff67f242f61e09321d1c78cb243915..7c9bfe03e0f0526a505a4d46c111520dc2f0531c 100644 --- a/q158/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q158/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,410 +1,1126 @@ -IEEEInternationalConferenceonDataMining(ICDM),WorkshoponUserModelingandRecommendation(UMRec),Washington,DC,USA,2025 -| Effectiveness | | | | | of LLMs | | in | Temporal | | | User | | Profiling | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------------- | ------- | -------------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | for | Recommendation | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | Milad | Sabouri∗, | | Masoud | Mansoury†, | Kun | Lin∗, | Bamshad | Mobasher∗ | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ∗DePaul University, | | USA | | | | | | | -| | | | Email: | msabouri@depaul.edu, | | | klin13@depaul.edu, | | | mobasher@cs.depaul.edu | | | | | | -| | | | | | †Delft | University | of | Technology, | Netherlands | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Email: | m.mansoury@tudelft.nl | | | | | | | | | -Abstract—Effectively modeling the dynamic nature of user 17% in Recall@10 and 14% in NDCG@10, benefits are -| preferences | is crucial | | for enhancing | | recommendation | | accuracy | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | less | pronounced | in | sparser | environments | | like Video | Games. | -5202 tcO 13 ]RI.sc[ 1v67100.1152:viXra andfosteringtransparencyinrecommendersystems.Traditional -| | | | | | | | | Our | analysis | of these | results | leads | us | to hypothesize | that | -| -------------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | -------------- | ------ | -| user profiling | often | overlooks | | the distinction | | between | transitory | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | this | nuanced | capability | is | particularly | evident | where | short- | -short-terminterestsandstablelong-termpreferences.Thispaper -examines the capability of leveraging Large Language Models term and long-term preferences are more clearly separable -(LLMs) to capture these temporal dynamics, generating richer (e.g., Movies&TV), versus domains with more stable user -| user representations | | through | | distinct | short-term | and | long-term | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -profiles(e.g.,VideoGames).Thishighlightsacriticaltrade-off -textualsummariesofinteractionhistories.Ourobservationssug- -betweenLLM-enhancedpredictivepowerandassociatedcom- -gestthatwhileLLMstendtoimproverecommendationqualityin -| | | | | | | | | putational | | costs, suggesting | | context-dependent | | application. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -domainswithmoreactiveuserengagement,theirbenefitsappear -less pronounced in sparser environments. This disparity likely Also,beyondpredictiveaccuracy,thisLLM-drivenapproach -stemsfromthevaryingdistinguishabilityofshort-termandlong- inherently offers an intrinsic potential for transparency. The -| term preferences | | across | domains; | the | approach | shows | greater | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -naturallanguageprofilesandlearnedattentionweightsprovide -utilitywherethesetemporalinterestsaremoreclearlyseparable -| | | | | | | | | a pathway | | toward interpretability, | | | conveying | whether | recom- | -| ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------ | ------ | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------ | -| (e.g., Movies&TV) | | compared | | to domains | with | more | stable user | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | mendations | | stem from | recent | or | enduring | interests. | While | -| profiles | (e.g., Video | Games). | | This | highlights | a critical | trade- | | | | | | | | | -off between enhanced performance and computational costs, fully realizing user-facing explanations is a future direction, -suggesting context-dependent LLM application. Beyond predic- this work contributes insights into the practical capability -| tive capability, | this | LLM-driven | | approach | inherently | | provides | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --------- | ---------- | -------------------- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------------- | -------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------------ | ---- | -| | | | | | | | | and | inherent | interpretability | | of LLM-driven | | temporal | user | -| an intrinsic | potential | | for interpretability | | through | | its natural | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | profiling, | outlining | new | research | | directions | for adaptive | and | -| language | profiles | and | attention | weights. | This | work | contributes | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | transparent | | recommender | systems. | | | | | -insightsintothepracticalcapabilityandinherentinterpretability -| of LLM-driven | | temporal | user | profiling, | outlining | new | research | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -II. RELATEDWORK -directionsfordevelopingadaptiveandtransparentrecommender -systems. Modeling the dynamic nature of user preferences is a -IndexTerms—TemporalUserProfiling,LargeLanguageMod- -| | | | | | | | | long-standing | | challenge | in | recommender | | systems. | Traditional | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -els, User Modeling -| | | | | | | | | methods, | such | as averaging | | item embeddings | | [3], | often fail to | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -| | | | | | | | | capture | the | evolving | distinction | between | | short-term | and long- | -| | | I. | INTRODUCTION | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | term | interests. | More | advanced | approaches | | for temporal | and | -Effective recommender systems demand both accurate and sequential recommendation include time-aware matrix factor- -transparent suggestions, a challenge exacerbated by the dy- ization (e.g., TimeSVD++ [4]), and sequential deep learning -namic nature of user preferences. Traditional user profiling, models like GRU4Rec [5] and SASRec [6], which learn user -such as averaging item embeddings, often oversimplifies user dynamics from interaction sequences. Recent work has also -interests by conflating fleeting short-term desires with sta- explored long short-term preference modeling for continuous- -ble long-term tastes, hindering both recommendation quality time sequential recommendation [7]. -and interpretability. This paper examines the capability of Research in recommender systems increasingly emphasizes -leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) to capture these balancing predictive accuracy with interpretability. Early ef- -temporaldynamics.Ourapproachgeneratesdistinctshort-term forts integrated explanations through content summarization -and long-term textual summaries of user interaction histories, or leveraged user-generated reviews [8]. More recently, Large -which are then encoded via BERT [1] and adaptively fused LanguageModels(LLMs)[9],[10]haveemergedaspowerful -using an attention mechanism [2] to form a unified user tools for generating richer explanations, demonstrating their -representation. capacity to enhance interpretability through personalized nar- -Our observations reveal a nuanced capability of this LLM- rativesandcollaborativeadaptors[11]–[14].Knowledgegraph -driven approach across varying user engagement patterns. (KG)-based approaches [15] have also integrated structured -While it tends to improve recommendation quality in ac- side information for explanations, sometimes combined with -tive domains like Movies&TV, with improvements such as LLM outputs [15]–[18]. +IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 1 +RA-BLIP: Multimodal Adaptive +Retrieval-Augmented Bootstrapping +Language-Image Pre-training +Muhe Ding, Yang Ma, Pengda Qin, Jianlong Wu, Member, IEEE, Yuhong Li, Liqiang Nie, Senior Member, IEEE +rec A en bs tl t y ra r c e t c — ei M ve u d lt s i u m b o s d ta a n l t L ia a l r i g n e te L r a e n st g , u w a h g i e ch M s o h d o e w ls s ( t M he L ir L e M m s e ) r h g a in v g e (a) × × In +S +n +i +e +m +r +i +P +la +ro +ri +d +ty +uct (b) 𝐻 …["#$] … 𝐼) T +S +o +i +k +m +en +il +- +a +W +rit +i +y +se +potential as general-purpose models for various vision-language +𝐻,-./012 𝐼& +tasks.MLLMsinvolvesignificantexternalknowledgewithintheir ContrastiveLearning 𝐻["#$] 𝐻& 𝐻'()* …𝐻!"#$%&' 𝐼) 𝐼* 𝐼+ …𝐼& +parameters; however, it is challenging to continually update +these models with the latest knowledge, which involves huge Text Image Text Image +Encoder Encoder Encoder Encoder +computationalcostsandpoorinterpretability.Retrievalaugmen- +tation techniques have proven to be effective plugins for both +LLMsandMLLMs.Inthisstudy,weproposemultimodaladap- Arockband Arockband +isplaying isplaying +tive Retrieval-Augmented Bootstrapping Language-Image Pre- +training (RA-BLIP), a novel retrieval-augmented framework for (c) Multimodal Knowledge Semantic Space +various MLLMs. Considering the redundant information within +vision modality, we first leverage the question to instruct the +extractionofvisualinformationthroughinteractionswithoneset +of learnable queries, minimizing irrelevant interference during +retrieval and generation. Besides, we introduce a pre-trained +multimodal adaptive fusion module to achieve question text-to- MultimodalAdaptiveRA-BLIP +multimodalretrievalandintegrationofmultimodalknowledgeby +projectingvisualandlanguagemodalitiesintoaunifiedsemantic … … … … +space.Furthermore,wepresentanAdaptiveSelectionKnowledge +Generation (ASKG) strategy to train the generator to au- +tonomously discern the relevance of retrieved knowledge, which +Which streetwas paved with +realizes excellent denoising performance. Extensive experiments boards; Little Champlain +Street, Quebec City, 1916 or +o th n at op R e A n -B m L u I l P tim a o ch d i a e l ve q s ue si s g ti n o i n fi - c a a n n s t w p er e i r n fo g rm da a t n a c s e ets an d d em su o r n p s a tr s a se te s Quebec C w i i t n y t e R r u 2 e 0 S 1 a 0 int-Louis N Q aN w t u i Q ao i N e w t nu n b i Q a t o i e a e e wn tn b lu c i rt oai ee eH 2 n C ln cbr 0 ti Ha i e es2 C1 t l ctr y 0 i 0 o i Hs 21 tC. r R t y i00 oi Lic s u 1. r tR t oy i e S0 o L c uu . r iR S o e i tSi L s e a u c u i S i iot Seo S n s e a u t f t i iSrS i - ot ne Cs e L at f t er i - aS o o en C tL n - u t f eta ra o a- i te C L n s -d u ea aa a io t s dn - u aaa i s d a +Question Image Image-Text Document +the state-of-the-art retrieval-augmented models. +QuestionPrompt Inter-Modal Intra-Modal Relevant +Index Terms—Retrieval-augmented model, vision-language Instruction Interaction Interaction Irrelevant +pre-training, multimodal retrieval, open question answering. Question Image Image-Text Text +Embeddings Embeddings Embeddings Embeddings +I. INTRODUCTION +Fig. 1. Illustration of different multimodal retrieval approaches. (a) Cross- +THE birth of the Internet has triggered an unprecedented modality retrieval. (b) Late-interaction retrieval. (c) RA-BLIP multimodal +information revolution, catapulting humanity into the era adaptive retrieval. For RA-BLIP, questions, documents, images, and image- +textpairsareprojectedintoaunifiedmultimodalspace. +of information explosion. It is a great challenge to efficiently +find answers from a vast amount of information based on +our questions. Open Multimodal Multihop Question Answer- +BLIP-2 [10], GPT-4 [11], etc., have been notably explored to +ing (MMQA) [1]–[7] can help alleviate this problem of in- +enhancetheirperformancebyimplicitlyencodingasubstantial +formationoverloadbyretrievingexternalknowledgebasedon +amount of external knowledge within their parameters, which +questionsandgeneratingcorrectanswers.Inrecentyears,sev- +now scale into the hundreds of billions [12]. While these +eraladvancedLLMsandMLLMslikeFlanT5[8],LLaMA[9], +models have yielded exciting results on various multimodal +ThisworkwassupportedinpartbytheNationalNaturalScienceFoundation tasks, they have also encountered high computational costs +ofChinaunderGrant62376069,inpartbyYoungEliteScientistsSponsorship and significant challenges in terms of interpretability. +ProgrambyCASTunderGrant2023QNRC001,andinpartbyGuangdongBa- +To alleviate the challenge, many researchers proposed re- +sicandAppliedBasicResearchFoundationunderGrant2024A1515012027. +Muhe Ding, Jianlong Wu and Liqiang Nie are with the School trievalaugmentationtechniquesthatdividethemodelintotwo +of Computer Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology keycomponents:theretrieverandthegenerator[13]–[16].The +(Shenzhen),Shenzhen518055,China(e-mail:dmh1216380870@gmail.com, +retriever accesses relevant knowledge from a knowledge base +jlwu1992@pku.edu.cn,nieliqiang@gmail.com). +Yang Ma is with the School of Computer Science, University of Sydney, based on the posed question, while the generator leverages +Sydney,NSW2006,Australia(e-mail:yama5878@uni.sydney.edu.au). this information to create textual output in response. In ear- +Pengda Qin and Yuhong Li are with the Security Department, Al- +lier stages, text-modality retrieval-augmented models, such as +ibaba Group, Hangzhou 311121, China (e-mail: qinpengda0406@163.com, +daniel.yuhong@gmail.com). REALM [13], RAG [17], and so on [18], [19], have been +4202 +tcO +81 +]MM.sc[ +1v45141.0142:viXra -| | | Fig.1. | Pipeline | for | LLM-Driven | Temporal | | User Profile | Generation | and | Recommendation. | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Ourworkintersectsthesetwocriticalareasbyinvestigating (i) LLM-based Temporal Profile Generation: To capture -the utility of leveraging LLMs to explicitly model temporal temporal aspects of user preferences, our approach prompts -user dynamics for enhanced content-based recommendations the LLM twice over each user’s interaction history H , using -u -and inherent transparency. Unlike existing methods that pri- distinct instructions to generate two textual summaries. The -marily use static profiles or sequential models without natural first focuses on recent interactions, producing the short-term -| language | grounding | [6], | [19], | [20], this | study | explores | an | profile: | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | -------------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -| approach | that generates | | distinct | natural | language | summaries | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | NLshort | =LLM(H | ,Promptshort). | | | (2) | -| | | | | | | | | | | u | | u | | | | -| for short-term | and | long-term | user | behaviors. | By | encoding | and | | | | | | | | | -| adaptively | fusing | these | semantic | summaries, | | this approach | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | The second | summarizes | | persistent | behaviors | | across | the full | -aims to create intrinsically interpretable user profiles. This history, forming the long-term profile: -| unique combination | | transparently | | highlights | the | temporal | ra- | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------ | -| tionale behind | | recommendations, | | bridging | advanced | | LLM- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | NLlong | =LLM(H | ,Promptlong). | | | (3) | -| | | | | | | | | | | u | | u | | | | -| based explainability | | with | nuanced | temporal | dynamics | | of user | | | | | | | | | -| interests. | This work | provides | | preliminary | insights | | into the | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | These summaries | | enhance | interpretability | | by | separating | tran- | -| practical | utility | of this novel | integration. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | sient and | stable | user | interests. | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | To provide | | a concrete | understanding | | of | our LLM-based | | -| | | III. | METHODOLOGY | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | temporal | profile | generation, | | we include | a conceptual | | illus- | -Let U = u ,u ,...,u be users, and I = i ,i ,...,i tration of the prompts and their corresponding output in -| | 1 | 2 | |U| | | | 1 2 | |I| | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -------- | -| be items. | Each | user u ∈ | U interacts | with | a subset | | of items | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Figure 3. | The | prompts | are carefully | designed | | to elicit | distinct | -I u ⊆ I, with interactions associated to timestamps. We temporal summaries. As shown, the ”Long-term Preference -| define the | interaction | history | as | Hu=(i,t | ):i∈I | | sorted | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u,i u Prompt” emphasizes identifying enduring interests and con- -chronologically. -| | | | | | | | | sistent themes | | across | the user’s | entire | history. | In | contrast, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --------- | -∈Rd) -We aim to learn embeddings for users (e u and items the ”Short-term Preference Prompt” is engineered to focus -| (e ∈Rd) | to predict | user-item | | interaction | likelihood: | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -i specifically on recent behaviors and fleeting interests. While -thefull,detailedpromptsandtheirconfigurationsareavailable -| | | yˆ | =f(e | ,e ), | | | (1) | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | u,i | | u i | | | | | | | | | | | | -inourpublicrepository(seesectionIV)toensurereproducibil- -wheref isamulti-layerperceptron(MLP).Thepipeline(Fig- ity, these examples demonstrate the core strategy of using -ure 1) comprises three steps: (i) profile generation via LLMs, natural language instructions to temporally disentangle user -| (ii) semantic | embedding, | | and (iii) | interaction | prediction. | | | preferences. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 2 | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +proposed to solve text-only question answering. They build an adaptive selection knowledge generation strategy, which +the dense index as a non-parametric document memory from gives the generator the capability of selecting knowledge by +extensive textual sources like Wikipedia for effective knowl- data enhancement to make the model automatically judge the +edge retrieval, and the generator produces answers based on relevance of knowledge. ASKG strategy allows the generator +the retrieved knowledge. More recently, multimodal retrieval- tonotsimplyrelyonthewordsimilaritybetweenthequestion +augmented models, such as MuRAG [14], SKURG [20], and and knowledge, but to understand the semantic information +soon[16],[21],haveemergedoneafteranother.Thesemodels of question and know which knowledge contains the answer. +extend the knowledge memory across various modalities, em- Furthermore, the parameters of the image encoder and LLM +ployingpre-trainedvisuallanguagemodelstoretrieverelevant of our framework are frozen, significantly reducing computa- +evidence and support reasoning for answers. tionalcosts.ExtensiveexperimentsonthreerepresentativeQA +However, existing methods exhibit certain limitations. The datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods. +first limitation is the insufficient integration and interaction Overall, our key contributions are as follows: +| between | vision | and | language. | On | the one | hand, | existing | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | | • We | propose | a novel | multimodal | | adaptive | | retrieval- | +| methods | lack | explicit | integration | of | multimodal | information, | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | augmented | | framework, | which | achieves | | question | text-to- | +hindering the alignment of questions and multimodal knowl- multimodalretrievalandknowledge-intensivemultimodal +| edge in | the semantic | | space. | As shown | in | Fig. | 1(a), some | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | QA | by integrating | | visual | and language | | modalities | and | +methods [14], [22], [23] have employed separate visual en- projecting them into a unified semantic space. +| coder and | text | encoder | for individual | | modality | encoding | and | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• Weintroduceanadaptiveselectionknowledgegeneration +| adopted | contrastive | learning | | [24] for | multimodal | | alignment | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | strategy | that | leverages | the | powerful | capabilities | | of LLMs | +to retrieve. This may lead to an unbalanced and biased to select the relevant retrieved knowledge for answer +| multimodal | retrieval | | and reasoning | | process | towards | specific | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | reasoning | | autonomously. | | | | | | +modalities.Besides,late-interactionretrievalapproaches[25]– We conduct extensive experiments on various multi- +• +[27] in Fig. 1(b), retain dual-encoder independent encoding modal and multihop datasets (i.e., WebQA [4], Multi- +| architecture | and | perform | token-wise | | interactions | only | in the | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | modalQA | | [5], and | MMCoQA | [6]). | RA-BLIP | | demon- | +late scoring stage, which sacrifices the retrieval efficiency for strates superiority over the existing state-of-the-art +thebenefitsoffine-grainedfeaturelearning.Ontheotherhand, +| | | | | | | | | retrieval-augmented | | | models. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +existingmethods[14],[20],[28],[29]donotutilizequestions +| to instruct | the | image | encoder | in selectively | | extracting | visual | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ---------------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | | | II. | RELATEDWORK | | | | | +| features, | and | thus suffer | from | interference | | and noise | caused | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | A. Vision-Language | | Pretraining | | | | | | +| by redundant | information | | in | images. | Moreover, | such | methods | | | | | | | | | +| lack mutual | instruction | | when | encoding | different | | modal fea- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Vision-language | | pre-training | | (VLP) | aims | to train | models | +| tures, making | | it challenging | | to model | relationships | | between | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | on large-scale | | image-text | datasets | to | capture | the relationship | | +multiple sources. The second limitation is that existing ap- between these two modalities. Broadly, VLP methodologies +proachesdonotinspectthecorrectnessoftheretrievedrelevant +| | | | | | | | | fall into | two categories | | based | on their | training | approach: | 1) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +knowledge at the generation stage. However, the retrieved End-to-end Methods: This category includes methods [35]– +| knowledge | contains | significant | | noise, | resulting | in poor | model | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +[38]thattrainmodelsend-to-end,backpropagatinglearnedsig- +| anti-interference | | and | robustness. | The | generator | assumes | all | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | nals to achieve | | mutual | learning | between | different | | modalities. | +retrieved relevant knowledge is correct, potentially leading to 2)ModularMethods:Incontrast,modularmethods,asseenin +| the utilization | | of irrelevant | or | confusing | information. | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +worksby[39]–[43],involvekeepingtheparametersofspecific +To address the above issues, we propose multimodal adap- pre-trainedcomponents(likeimageencodersorlargelanguage +tiveRetrieval-AugmentedBootstrappingLanguage-ImagePre- models) fixed while focusing on refining other aspects of the +| training | (RA-BLIP). | | RA-BLIP | consists | of | two key | compo- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | model. | For instance, | LiT | [44] | utilizes | a pre-trained | | frozen | +nents: a multimodal adaptive retrieval-augmented framework image encoder from CLIP, while Flamingo [45] and BLIP-2 +| and an | adaptive | selection | | knowledge | generation | | (ASKG) | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +[10]freezethelanguagemodeltointegrateLLMsintovision- +strategy. To tackle the first limitation, RA-BLIP is based on language tasks better. Besides, instruction tuning is also an +the InstructBLIP architecture [30] and adopts Q-Former to effective approach during VLP. InstructBLIP [30] represents +implementinstruction-awarevisualfeatureextractionthatuses +arecentadvancementinthisarea,achievinginstruction-aware +questions as instructions. The question instruction interacts visual feature extraction and instruction-guided LLM genera- +withthequeryembeddingsthroughsharedself-attentionlayers +| | | | | | | | | tion. The | unique | capability | of | InstructBLIP | to | extract | features | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------- | ----------- | +| and encourages | | the extraction | | of question-relevant | | | visual fea- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | based on | prompt | instructions, | | combined | with | its | utilization | +tures. Additionally, we incorporate a pre-trained multimodal of frozen LLMs and image encoders, positions it as an ideal +| adaptive | fusion | module | to fuse | vision | and | text information, | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | backbone | for our | proposed | retrieval-augmented | | | framework. | | +| obtaining | multimodal | | features | [31]–[33]. | | As a result, | RA- | | | | | | | | | +| BLIP achieves | | question | text-to-multimodal | | | retrieval | by align- | | | | | | | | | +ing the questions and multimodal knowledge bases in the B. Text-modality Retrieval-Augmented Models +semantic space of three modalities: text, image, and image- Retrieval-augmented techniques have proven to be ef- +text [34], as shown in Fig. 1(c). For the second limitation, fective plugins for both LLMs and MLLMs in academia. +we leverage the implicit capabilities of LLMs and introduce These techniques extract pertinent world knowledge from -Fig. 2. A conceptual illustration of the framework’s potential for enhancing transparency. (A) and (B) show the short-term and long-term -textual profiles generated and encoded by our current approach. (C) shows a hypothetical extension wherein the final recommendation is -explicitly justified by both sets of preferences, further strengthening user-facing transparency—an aspect we plan to explore in future work. -TABLEI -DATASETSSTATISTICS -| | | | | | | | | Dataset | Users | Items | | Interactions | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | Movies&TV | 10,000 | 14,420 | | 202,583 | | | -| | | | | | | | | Games | 10,371 | | 3,790 | 83,842 | | | -TABLEII -USERPROFILESSTATISTICS -| | | | | | | | Dataset | | Mean | Median | Mode | | StdDev | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Movies&TV | | 11.79 | 9.00 | | 6 | 9.80 | | -| | | | | | | | Games | | 4.55 | 3.00 | | 3 | 3.97 | | -| | | | | | | Crucially, | | the learned | weights | | (αshort, | αlong) | explicitly | con- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | u | u | | | -| | | | | | | vey | the model’s | | decision | rationale | regarding | | recent | versus | -| | | | | | | historical | user | interests. | | | | | | | -(iii)InteractionPrediction:Topredictinteractionprobabili- -| | | | | | | ties, | we concatenate | | user embedding | | e | with item | embedding | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | -u -| | | | | | | e and | process | through | an | MLP | [21]: | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 3 +extensive databases, subsequently integrating this information A. Problem Formulation +to formulate answers. Pioneering methods like ORQA [3] +This paper presents a multimodal adaptive retrieval- +have employed inverse cloze tasks for retriever pre-training, +augmentedframeworkcalledRA-BLIPforopenmultihopand +showcasing their efficacy on open-ended question answering +multimodalQA,integratingretrievalandgenerationfunctions. +datasets. Following suit, REALM [13] extends this by retriev- +For knowledge-intensive QA, we deconstruct the task into +ing and processing documents from comprehensive sources +two stages: retrieval and generation, which are implemented +like Wikipedia for logical reasoning, which is pre-trained to +by the retriever and generator respectively. The goal of our +reason over a large corpus of knowledge on the fly during model training is to learn the distribution P(y|x ) to generate +q +inference. Furthermore, RAG [17] adopts a pre-trained model a textual output y conditioned on input question x and +q +andnon-parametricmemoryforlanguagegeneration.FiD[18] multimodal knowledge base KB (KB = k ,...,k ). Firstly, +1 n +leveragesencoder-decodertransformermodelsforknowledge- +the retriever encodes questions, images, and texts from the +intensivetasks,settingnewbenchmarksinQA.Morerecently, knowledge base KB. It identifies the most relevant retrieved +RETRO [19] has advanced these methods by handling longer knowledge, K ⊂KB (K is the retrieved knowledge) for +ret ret +sequences and accessing diverse documents for segmented each question x , which is modeled as p(K |x ). Secondly, +q ret q +sequences from expansive retrieval datasets. Text-modality the generator utilizes an LLM to generate answers y, condi- +retrieval-augmented models construct dense indices as non- +tionedonboththequestionandtheretrievedknowledge,which +parametricdocumentmemories,usingextensivetextualknowl- is modeled as p(y|x ,K ). We treat multimodal knowledge +q ret +edge bases to align the retrieval process with specific queries. K asalatentvariablefromtheexternalknowledgebaseand +ret +Despite these advancements, a notable limitation remains the +marginalize it to increase the overall likelihood of the answer +needforthesemethodstoeffectivelyleveragevastmultimodal y. The overall process is encapsulated in the equation: +knowledge, thereby constraining their applicability in the +(cid:88) +domain of open multimodal question answering. p(y |x q )= p(K ret |x q )·p(y |x q ,K ret ). (1) +(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) +Kret⊂KB +Retrieval Generation +C. Multimodal Retrieval-Augmented Models This dual-stage framework effectively addresses the complex- +To overcome the limitations of text-modality retrieval- ities of open multimodal QA by balancing the retrieval of +augmented models, recent research [10], [15], [30], [46], [47] multimodal data and knowledge-based generation, and has +has made strides in integrating multimodal knowledge. No- been validated by extensive experiments and ablation studies. +tableefforts,includingAutoRouting[5]andMAE[6],involve +trainingdistinctmodelsforeachmodalityandusingclassifiers B. Model Architecture +for task-specific routing, though this approach often hampers +RA-BLIP is built on a simple backbone model that is pre- +cross-modal reasoning. MuRAG [14] seeks to overcome this +trained to encode image-text pairs so that they are suitable +limitation by employing separate encoders for visual and +for both knowledge base retrieval and answer generation. +textualmodalities,followedbyajointencoderformultimodal +The overall framework of RA-BLIP is shown in Fig. 2. The +fusion. However, this approach lacks integrated guidance for +backbone model consists of a multimodal encoder f (·) and +θ +different modalities and cannot model the relations between +decoderg (·),whichareusedascomponentsoftheRA-BLIP +θ +knowledge sources during retrieval. SKURG [20] attempts to +model to implement retrieval and generation. The multimodal +bridge this gap by using an entity-centered fusion encoder +encoder f (·) contains a frozen image encoder ViT [48], +θ +to align modalities, yet faces challenges in computational +Q-Former architecture [30], and the pre-trained multimodal +efficiency and limited interpretability. Besides, Solar [21] +adaptive fusion module. The decoder g (·) is composed of +θ +transforms multimodal inputs into a unified language format +a LLM FlanT5 [8]. Querying Transformer (Q-Former) [10] +but falls short in handling complex tasks and generalizing +is a lightweight Transformer consisting of two modules that +visual information. REVAL [16] leverages large-scale knowl- +sharethesameself-attentionlayer:oneisanimagetransformer +edgegraphstoassistvisuallanguagepre-training,butitbrings +that interacts with the frozen image encoder ViT for visual +a lot of calculations. In contrast, RA-BLIP distinguishes itself +featureextraction,andtheotherisatexttransformercanactas +by seamlessly integrating visual and language modalities into +both text encoder and text decoder for text feature. The visual +a cohesive semantic space, enabling the autonomous selection +encoder, composed of ViT and Q-Former image transformer, +of relevant knowledge for reasoning, thus addressing these +hasinstruction-awarevisualfeatureextractioncapabilitiesand +limitations more effectively. +can extract visual information based on question instructions. +We input N learnable query embeddings into the Q-Former +III. METHODOLOGY +imagetransformer,whichinteracts withfrozenimagefeatures +In this section, we first formulate the research problem through cross-attention layers to obtain visual representation +and subsequently elaborate on the model architecture of our f (I) ∈ RN×D, where D is the hidden dimension of the Q- +θ +retrieval-augmented framework. Then, we describe the learn- Former.Additionally,weusetheQ-Formertexttransformerto +ablequeryinteractionapproach,followedbymultimodaladap- encode text, taking the [CLS] token as the text representation +tive fusion module. Subsequently, we show how to train the f (T)∈R1×D.Toobtainmultimodalfeaturescombiningboth +θ +retrieverandranktherelevantknowledge.Lastly,weintroduce imageandtext,weintroduceapre-trainedmultimodaladaptive +the adaptive selection knowledge generation strategy. fusion module M (·) to obtain the multimodal representation +θ + +IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 4 +Q:The Marina Bay Sands +in Singapore is made of +what building material? +Retrieval Knowledge +Template: {Q}. Which item is related to this question? Positive & Negative Knowledge Pair +Answer +Generation Stage: +Q-Former +Q-Former +Q-Former +Fusion +Multimodal +LLM +Retrieval Stage: Learnable queries +🔥 🔥 +Image 𝑓!(𝑘"#) +… Encoder 𝑓!(𝑘") +Marina Bay Q K1 🔥Q-Former +Sands Singapore 🔥 +Q:The Marina Bay Sands 𝑓!(𝑘#) +in Singapore is made of +what building material? +It is close to some of Singapore's famous In Asia, the Marina 🔥 S l u a n n t d e m c a C r i k t s y , s u M c a h r i a n s a S B i a n y g a S p a o n r d e s w lo a c s a a te d d d e in d 𝑓!(𝑘#) Bay Sands, Esplanade, +to the company's portfolio in 2010… +… +ModalityRepresentation +… +Text Question +QA Data Format +Image Relevant Knowledge Input +Learnable queries +Image-Text +concat +Q K2 Image Encoder +Instruction Top-K Q K3 Q K4 Question& Caption +Marina Bay ASKG Data Format Sands Singapore +FeatureEncoder +In 2010, when it opened, at total cosTt he Downtown MRInT Asia, the Marina 🔥 Classifier inc o lu f d S in $ g 8 l b a i n ll d io c n o stm, st e a t t e io rs n t i o s t b h u e i l W t a e s fe St B w oi a nf y g a S p a o n r d e s w lo a c s a a te d d d e in d Marina Bay Sands… the building. to the company's portfolio in 2010… +Maximum Inner Product Search Ranking +Fig. 2. The overall workflow of RA-BLIP consists of a retrieval stage and a generation stage. We utilize multimodal encoder f θ (·) to project questions +and multimodal knowledge into a unified semantic space to achieve question text-to-multimodal retrieval, and exclude confusing knowledge by ranking. +Additionally, we employ ASKG strategy to filter out invalid knowledge, enabling precise reasoning. The parameters of LLM and image encoder are fixed, +onlytheQ-Formerandclassifieraretrainable. +f (IT) ∈ R(N+1)×D. Consequently, the multimodal encoder Q-Former has aligned visual and text feature representation, +θ +can simultaneously encode image, text, and image-text fea- we use Image-Text Matching loss and Image-grounded Text +tures. Questions and knowledge are encoded into multimodal Generation loss for pre-training. As shown in Fig. 3, our +information through the multimodal encoder and then input approach is to fix the parameters of the image encoder and +into the decoder for answer generation. In the generation Q-Former, and solely fine-tune the parameters of the multi- +stage, compared with the retriever, the multimodal encoder modal adaptive fusion module. The module concatenates the +discards the multimodal adaptive fusion module to reduce the visual embedding and text embedding with a dimension of +computational cost. R(N+L)×D, where N is the learnable query embeddings and +L is the length of text tokens. Image-text matching loss is +used to fuse image and text representations, and the results +C. Learnable Query Interaction for Multi-images +of the fusion module are fed into a binary linear classifier +Questions and image captions are used as instructions to +foreachoutputquerytoobtainthelogitsandtaketheaverage +extract visual features to get learnable query embeddings +logitsofallqueriesasthematchingscore.Givenapre-training +and input them together with text knowledge to LLMs for dataset X = {I ,T }n , we randomly sample negative texts +i i i=1 +generation. We employ a novel approach for extracting visual +foreachimageandrandomlysamplenegativeimagesforeach +information to alleviate the burden of LLMs in distinguishing +text, to generate negative training data. Therefore, we denote +knowledge. In the original Q-Former in [30], multiple images +the ground truth label as y ∈ {1,0} for each image-text pair +are processed by employing multiple separate sets of queries +(I ,T ), indicating if the input image-text pair is relevant or +i i +for each, with each set of queries independently extracting +not.Weusethemultimodalencoderf (·)toencodeimage-text +θ +visualfeatures.Thisresultsinusingmultiplequeryfeaturesfor +pairs and input it into the multimodal adaptive fusion module +generation, which can be computationally intensive and less +M (·). The objective function is defined as follows: +θ +efficientincapturingtheinterrelationsamongdifferentimages. +1 (cid:88) +In contrast, our method innovates by succinctly utilizing one L =− ylog(ρ(M (f (I );f (T )))), (2) +itm n θ θ i θ i +set of learnable queries to directly interact with and extract Ii,Ti∈X +features from multiple images in a unified manner. This pro- whereρ(·)isthesoftmaxfunction.Image-groundedTextGen- +cessoccursduringtheQ-Formerstage,enablingmoreefficient +eration loss trains the fusion module to generate texts, given +and integrated interaction among multiple visual references. +input images as the condition [10], [30]. For the image-text +By employing one set of query interaction approach, RA- pairs in the pre-training dataset, each image I corresponds to +BLIP not only simplifies the feature extraction process but a text sentence y ={y ,...,y } of length T. We employ a +1:T 1 T +also enhances the efficiency of information extraction. This +multimodalcausalself-attentionmaskformultimodalencoder +unified interaction allows the model to understand better and f (·)andmultimodaladaptivefusionmoduleM (·)tocontrol +θ θ +represent the collective information presented in multiple im- +the interaction between queries and text. The visual query +ages, enabling more effective and cohesive feature utilization, +functions as a prefix causal, ensuring that queries can attend +especially when dealing with complex scenes or subjects +to each other while excluding text tokens. Similarly, each text +across multiple images. token y can attend to all visual queries and preceding text +tokens. The loss function is defined as: +D. Multimodal Adaptive Fusion Module T +(cid:88) +L =− logM (f ((y |y ,I)). (3) +The pre-trained multimodal adaptive fusion module M (·) itg θ θ t
, | | | a search | query | | | | | | | | -as ..., a retrieved information andr (θ)=π (τ |q,τ )/π (τ |q,τ ). -| | | | | | | | i,t | | θ i,t | i,...,andafinal -| answeras.... | | | | | | | 2.3.ICRL | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Furthermore,thetoolfunctionsasaresponsemechanism. Training Process. Rather than training models from -Forexample,asearchenginecanbemodeledasaretrieval -scratchusingreinforcementlearning,whichoftensuffers -| | | V∗ | V∗, | V∗ | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -function T : → where is the space of textual fromsparserewardsandinefficientexploration,orrelying -sequences. Givenasearchqueryq′,thetoolreturnsanob- exclusivelyonfew-shotprompting,whichincurssubstantial -servationo=T(q′),suchasthetop-kdocumentsretrieved -inferenceoverhead,weintroduceICRL,aframeworkthat -fromacorpus. Thisobservationisappendedtothemodel’s integrates the strengths of both approaches. ICRL lever- -contextandusedinsubsequentgenerationsteps. -agesthesampleefficiencyandinductivebiasoffew-shot -promptingwhilebenefitingfromtheexplorationcapabilities -| 2.2.RLwithToolUse | | | | | | | ofreinforcementlearning. | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RL Objective Function. After formulating the tool- Atthebeginningoftraining,weincorporateasmallnumber -augmentedreasoninginLLMsasaMarkovDecisionPro- of tool-use demonstrations into the model’s rollout tem- -cess(MDP),wecandefinethecorrespondingreinforcement plate. These examples guide the model toward effective -learning(RL)objectiveasfollows: tool-augmentedreasoningviain-contextlearning,akinto -| | | | | | | | few-shotprompting. | | Theresultingpolicyisdenotedas: | | | | | -| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | max | E | [r | (q,y)] | | | | | | | | | | -| | | q∼D,y∼πθ(·|q,T) | | ϕ | | | | | | | | | | -πθ -| | | | | | | (2) | | | | |y| | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | −βD | [π (y |q,T)∥π | | (y |q,T)], | | | | | (cid:89) | | | | -| | | KL | θ | ref | | | π (y | |P | ,q,T)= | π (y |P | ,y ,q,H | ), | (5) | -| | | | | | | | θ | N | | θ t | N ...everytimeyougetnew -information.Afterreasoning,ifyoufindyoulacksomeknowledge,youcancallasearchenginebyquery -anditwillreturnresultsbetween....Youcansearchasmanytimesasyouwant.Finally, -providetheanswerinside.... -Herearesomeexamples: -ExampleProblem:q -demo -ExampleSolution:...... -......a -| (repeatedforN | | examples | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Nowsolvethefollowingproblem: -ActualProblem:question -| Table2.Formatviolationpenaltiesforcomputingreward | | | | | . | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -format -Algorithm1ICRL -| Violation | | | Rationale | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | Input: | Initial | policy π | , reference | model | π | , tool | -| | | | | | | | | θ | | | ref | | -Notag Mustprovidestructuredanswer T, initial few-shot prompt P , dataset partitions -N -Unbalancedtags ProperXMLstructurerequired {D(N),D(N−1),...,D(0)}, reward function r (·), -ϕ -| Notag | | | Shoulddemonstratereasoning | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Unbalancedtags | | | | | | numberofRLstepsT | | | | | | | -ProperXMLstructurerequired -Nousage Shouldutilizeavailabletool Output: Trainedmodelπ θ -| Emptyanswercontent | | | Answermustbesubstantive | | | 1: fork=N | | to0do | | | | | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | 2: | // Step | 1: Construct | | prompt | with | | -k demonstrations -P ←selectkexamplesfromP -| reward | = 1 if the | prediction | exactly | matches | the cor- | 3: | k | | | N | | | -| ------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | acc | | | | | | D(k)←RLtrainingsubsetforcurrentpromptlevel | | | | | | -| rectanswer,and0otherwise. | | | | | | 4: | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 5: | fort=1toT | do | | | | | -The reward component evaluates the model’s adher- 6: forq∈D(k)do -format -| encetotheexpectedstructuredoutputformat,specifically | | | | | | 7: | π | ←π | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θold θ -| | | | | | | 8: | Sample | N trajectories | | {τ | ,...,τ | } ∼ | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -| thecorrectuseofXMLtags. | | | Itisdefinedas: | | | | | | | 1 | N | | -π (q,P ,T) -θold k -| | | | (cid:88) | | | | foreachtrajectoryτ | | do | | | | -| --- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | reward | =1.0− | penalty(v), | | (8) | 9: | | | i | | | | -format -| | | | | | | 10: | | Computereward:r | ϕ | (q,τ i ) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -v∈V -| | | | | | | 11: | | ComputenormalizedadvantageA | | | i | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -whereV denotesthesetofformatviolationsidentifiedinthe 12: Computeimportanceweightsr (θ) -i,t -| | | | | | | 13: | endfor | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -| model’sresponse. | | Thepenaltyfunctionpenalty(v)assigns | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 14: | Updatepolicy:π | | ←π | −∇ L | | | -apredefinedcosttoeachviolation,asspecifiedinTable2. θ θ θ GRPO -endfor -15: -| Withtheproposedrewarddesign,weoptimizethepolicy | | | | | | 16: | endfor | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| usingtheRLobjectivedefinedinEquation3. | | | | Thecomplete | | 17: endfor | | | | | | | -trainingprocedureforICRLisoutlinedinAlgorithm1. -| | | | | | | convergenceduringRLtraining. | | | Forimprovedtrainingeffi- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.Experiment ciency,allmodelsareloadedusingbfloat16precision. -3.1.Setup -WeevaluatetheeffectivenessofICRLbycom- -Baselines. -Backbone Models. We apply ICRL to the Qwen2.5 paringitagainstseveralstate-of-the-artmethodsfortraining -model family (Yang et al., 2024a), focusing primarily on tool-augmentedLLMs. Thesebaselinesfallintothreemain -Qwen2.5-3B-InstructandQwen2.5-7B-Instruct,andfurther categories. Directpromptingmethodsincludemodelsthat -evaluatingonQwen2.5-14B-Instruct. Wealsoextendour performinferenceusingdirectinputsorpromptingstrate- -experimentstotheQwen3series(Yangetal.,2025),particu- giessuchasChain-of-Thought(CoT)reasoning(Weietal., -larlyQwen3-8B,whichincorporatesRLenhancements. All 2022). Retrieval-basedmethodsleverageexternalinfor- -theseinstruction-tunedmodelsarewidelyadoptedforques- mationthroughtechniqueslikeRetrieval-AugmentedGen- -tionansweringandreasoningtasks. Wechoosetheinstruct eration(RAG),includingstandardRAG(Lewisetal.,2020), -variants over base models due to their strong instruction- InterleavingRetrievalChain-of-Thought(IRCoT)(Trivedi -followingcapabilities,whichenablefasterandmorestable etal.,2023),andSearch-o1(Lietal.,2025a). Fine-tuning- + Major IT Investments + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Cloud Enterprise + +Description: + +Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through +investment in the Treasury enterprise shared services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on +cloud security enhancement and upgraded capabilities to meet security and compliance risks will +involve investment in security controls, monitoring, and increased threat protections by providing a +common cloud operating platform for Departmental workloads, inclusive of all security elements +required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance. Treasury’s recently awarded Blanket +Purchase Agreement (BPA) for cloud services (Treasury Cloud [TCloud]) will support our design, +development, and implementation of security patterns and guardrails with expanded Security +Operations Center (SOC) capabilities to accommodate increased telemetry from cloud assets and +workloads. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +2 0 . 0 7 + +2 5 . 3 3 + +1 5 . 8 0 + +- 9 . 5 3 + +- 3 7 . 6 1 % + +0 . 6 5 + +1 . 6 0 + +9 . 6 3 + +8 . 0 3 + +5 0 1 . 5 6 % + +2 0 . 7 2 + +2 6 . 9 3 + +2 5 . 4 3 + +- 1 . 5 0 + +- 5 . 5 7 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA cloud investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build stronger +protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Cloud Enterprise investment, Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further +accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through investment in the Treasury enterprise shared +services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on cloud security enhancement and upgraded +capabilities to meet security and compliance risks involves investment in security controls, monitoring, +and increased threat protections by providing a common cloud operating platform for Departmental +workloads, inclusive of all security elements required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance. + 4 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Table3.MainResultsofICRL:ExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousdifficultQAdatasets.Thebestperformanceissetbold.The -secondbestperformanceisunderlined. -DifficultQuestionAnswering -| | | Model | Method | | | | | | | | Average | | -| --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | TriviaQA | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | | -| | | | Direct | | 28.8 | 14.9 | 24.4 | 2.0 | | 2.4 | 14.50 | | -| | | | CoT | | 3.2 | 2.1 | 2.1 | 0.2 | | 0.0 | 1.52 | | -| | | | IRCoT | | 31.2 | 16.4 | 17.1 | 6.7 | | 24.0 | 19.08 | | -| | | | Search-o1 | | 47.2 | 22.1 | 21.8 | 5.4 | | 32.0 | 25.70 | | -| | | | RAG | | 54.4 | 25.5 | 22.6 | 4.7 | | 8.0 | 23.04 | | -| | | | SFT | | 29.2 | 18.6 | 24.8 | 4.4 | | 11.2 | 17.64 | | -Qwen2.5-3B -| | | | R1-instruct | | 44.9 | 20.8 | 27.5 | 6.0 | | 19.2 | 23.68 | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | RejectSampling | | 48.8 | 24.0 | 23.3 | 5.9 | | 21.0 | 24.60 | | -| | | | Search-R1 | | 54.5 | 32.4 | 31.9 | 10.3 | | 26.4 | 31.10 | | -| | | | ZeroSearch | | 57.4 | 27.4 | 30.0 | 9.8 | | 11.1 | 27.14 | | -| | | | ICRL | | 72.6 | 35.4 | 39.2 | 20.0 | | 33.6 | 40.16+8.94 | | -| | | | Direct | | 40.8 | 18.3 | 25.0 | 3.1 | | 12.0 | 19.84 | | -| | | | CoT | | 18.5 | 9.2 | 11.1 | 2.2 | | 23.2 | 12.84 | | -| | | | IRCoT | | 47.8 | 13.3 | 14.9 | 7.2 | | 22.4 | 21.12 | | -| | | | Search-o1 | | 44.3 | 18.7 | 17.6 | 5.8 | | 29.6 | 23.20 | | -| | | | RAG | | 58.5 | 29.9 | 23.5 | 5.8 | | 20.8 | 27.70 | | -| | | | SFT | | 35.4 | 21.7 | 25.9 | 6.6 | | 11.2 | 20.16 | | -| | Qwen2.5-7B | | R1-base | | 53.9 | 24.2 | 27.3 | 8.3 | | 29.6 | 28.66 | | -| | | | R1-instruct | | 53.7 | 23.7 | 29.2 | 7.2 | | 29.3 | 28.62 | | -| | | | RejectSampling | | 59.2 | 33.1 | 29.6 | 12.3 | | 35.5 | 33.94 | | -| | | | Search-R1 | | 61.0 | 37.0 | 41.4 | 14.6 | | 36.8 | 38.16 | | -| | | | ZeroSearch | | 65.2 | 34.6 | 35.2 | 18.4 | | 27.8 | 36.24 | | -| | | | ParallelSearch | | 62.8 | 42.9 | 42.4 | 19.7 | | 41.1 | 41.78 | | -| | | | ICRL | | 75.4 | 42.6 | 53.6 | 26.0 | | 48.0 | 49.12+7.34 | | -based methods involve approaches such as SFT (Chung EvaluationBenchmarks. WeevaluateICRLandvarious -et al., 2024), RL without search (R1) (Guo et al., 2025), baselinesonseveralwidely-usedQAbenchmarks,including -andRejectionSampling(Ahnetal.,2024). Wealsoinclude TriviaQA(Joshietal.,2017),HotpotQA(Yangetal.,2018), -recentRLmethodsthatintegratesearchcapabilities,suchas 2Wiki (Ho et al., 2020), Musique (Trivedi et al., 2022), -Search-R1(Jinetal.,2025a),ZeroSearch(Sunetal.,2025), andBamboogle(Pressetal.,2023). Sinceourmodelsare -O2-Searcher(Meietal.,2025),andParallelSearch(Zhao -trainedontheNaturalQuestions(NQ)dataset,weexclude -et al., 2025). These baselines provide a comprehensive NQfromtheevaluationtoavoiddataleakage. Thesebench- -comparisontovalidatethegeneralityandadvantagesofour markscoverdiversedomainsandreasoningtypes,providing -proposedICRLframework. acomprehensiveassessmentofmodelperformance.Further- -more,toensureevaluationefficiency,werandomlysample -| Training | Datasets. | | We use | the Natural | Questions (NQ) | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | upto500questionsfromeachdataset. | | | | Theselectedbench- | | -dataset(Kwiatkowskietal.,2019)astheprimarytraining -marksincludebothin-domaingeneralQAtasks(e.g.,Triv- -| corpus. | The | dataset | is loaded | via FlashRAG | (Jin et | al., | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -iaQA,HotpotQA)andout-of-domainmulti-hopQAtasks -2025b),whichprovidespreprocessedquestion-answerpairs -(e.g.,2Wiki,Musique,andBamboogle),allowingustothor- -| withgold-standardanswers. | | | | NQcontainsrealuserqueries | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oughlytestthegeneralizationandreasoningcapabilitiesof -fromGoogleSearch,eachpairedwithWikipediapassages -differentmethods. -| that | includethe | correct | answer. | To support | ourproposed | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -trainingmethod,werandomlysampledthreequestionsfrom -thewebandusedGPT-5.22togeneratefew-shotexamples Reward. The hyperparameter α in Equation 7 is set to -formattedaccordingtotherollouttemplateshowninTable1. 0.8. Furthermore,fortheformatviolationpenaltiesinTa- -Tosimulatereal-worldtool-usebehavior,weintegratethe ble2,theweightsaresetto0.5,0.2,0.15,0.1,0.1,and0.2 -| SerperAPI3 | | | | | | | respectivelyfromtoptobottom. | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -acrossallmodelstoretrieveliveresultsfrom -| theGoogleSearchengine. | | | Forfairness,eachqueryretrieves | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thetop3documentsrequiredforsearch-basedreasoning. ImplementationDetails. Weimplementourmethodus- -| | | | | | | | ing the Volcano | Engine | Reinforcement | | Learning | (VeRL) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -2https://platform.openai.com/docs/models/ -| gpt-5.2 | | | | | | | framework | (Sheng | et al., | 2024). | Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | -3https://serper.dev/ Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct,andQwen2.5-14B-Instructserveas -| | | | | | | | the backbone | models, | trained | with | a learning | rate of 1e- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ---- | ---------- | ----------- | + The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.4 million for Treasury’s CEA Cloud Enterprise +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate + +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. + +In FY2025, CEA – Cloud Enterprise investments are targeted to the Department’s cloud focused +modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments will build +on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +• Treasury seeks to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +• Bureau of the Fiscal Service cloud cybersecurity modernization and the necessary human + +capital to support initiatives. + +• Cloud security resources (engineers, ISSM, etc.) to support the FY2023 awarded enterprise + +TCloud contract and program. + +• Application migrations from on-premises to cloud environments and/or from unique Bureau + +environments to the enterprise cloud platform. + +• + +Incident response infrastructure to support coordination and communication in an + +uncompromised environment for response and recovery activities. + +• Migration of National Security System infrastructure to the cloud. +• Operations, maintenance, and ongoing investment in a sustainable low code cloud platforms +(i.e., ServiceNow, Salesforce) to support organizational capabilities, to include +Cybersecurity Governance, Risk, and Compliance; CEA Administration and Governance; +and Security. + +• Storage support for enterprise logging collection and utilization of historic logs to support + +threat hunt and threat detection activities, as well as additional behavioral analytics. +• Expansion of the Department’s enterprise offering for public-facing, cloud-based web hosting + +that includes an Akamai CDN with robust DoS and bot protections, a Drupal content +management system, and additional centralized site shield, web performance and +readiness/response investments that integrate with Treasury’s security operations +capabilities for threat detection and response. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + 5 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Table4.Results:ExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousQAdatasets.O2-Searcherappliescold-startSFTbeforeRL,whileour -method(ICRL)appliesRLwithoutSFT. -| | Model | | Method | | SFT | | DifficultQuestionAnswering | | | | Average | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | TriviaQA | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | -| | | | O2-Searcher | | ✓ | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 59.7 | 38.8 | 37.4 | 16.0 | | 34.4 37.26 | | -| | Qwen2.5-3B | | | | ✗ | | | | | | | | -| | | | ICRL | | | 72.6 | 35.4 | 39.2 | 20.0 | | 33.6 40.16 | | -Table5.Exampleofmulti-turnsearch-augmentedquestionanswering.ThemodelcorrectlyidentifiesGeorgeWashingtonasthepresident -whosetthetwo-termprecedentandretrieveshisinaugurationdatethroughtwosearchqueries. -Question Whendidthepresidentwhosettheprecedentofatwotermlimitenteroffice? -| | GoldenAnswer | | | April30,1789 | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ModelResponse Ineedtoknowwhichpresidentsetthisprecedent. Ialsoneedtoknowwhenhe -enteredoffice.Letmestartbyfindingoutwhichpresidentitis. -presidentwhosettwotermlimitprecedent -Doc1(Title:“Twenty-secondAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitution”) -Untiltheamendment’sratification,thepresidenthadnotbeensubjecttotermlimits,butboth -GeorgeWashingtonandThomasJefferson(thefirstandthird...Doc2(Title:“Amendment22 -–TermLimitsforthePresidency”)ThedecisionforGeorgeWashington–theFirstPresident -of the United States – to voluntarily step down from office after two terms, established an -unofficial...Doc3(Title:“ThefirstU.S.presidentsethisowntermlimit”)Washingtonwrote... - -ItseemsGeorgeWashingtonsettheprecedent. NowIneedtofindoutwhenhe -enteredoffice. -whendidGeorgeWashingtonenterofficeaspresident -Doc1(Title: “PresidencyofGeorgeWashington”)Washingtonwasinau- -guratedasthefirstPresidentoftheUnitedStatesonApril30,1789... Doc2(Title: “George -Washington”)Washingtonwasunanimouslyelected... Doc3(Title:“PresidentWashington’s -FirstTerm(1789-1792)”)GeorgeWashingtonwasinaugurated... - Based on the information, George Washington entered office on April 30, 1789. - -April30,1789 -6. For each query, we sample 8 rollout trajectories with (EM)scoreof40.16,surpassingthebestcompetingmethod, -atemperatureof1.0tocomputethegroup-relativeadvan- Search-R1 (31.10), by +8.94. The improvements are es- -tage. Themaximumpromptlengthissetto5000tokensto peciallypronouncedonmulti-hopdatasetssuchas2Wiki -accommodatefew-shotdemonstrations,andthemaximum (+7.3),Musique(+9.7),andBamboogle(+7.2),demonstrat- -response length is capped at 2048 tokens, allowing up to ing ICRL’s strength in handling complex reasoning and -| 6searchturnsperquery. | | | Toregularizethepolicy, | | | | weap- tool-usescenarios. | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ply a KL | penalty | with | a coefficient | | of 0.001. | Training | is | | | | | | -Furthermore,onQwen2.5-7B,ICRLachievesanaverage -conductedon4NVIDIAA100GPUs(80GBeach),using -| | | | | | | | EMscoreof49.12, | | outperformingthestrongestbaseline, | | | | -| --------------- | -------- | ------------------------------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------- | ------------ | -| abatchsizeof64. | | WeadoptFullyShardedDataParallel | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ParallelSearch | | (41.78), | by +7.34. | It achieves | the best re- | -| (FSDP) | training | with | gradient | checkpointing | | to optimize | | | | | | | -sultsonfouroutoffivedatasets,includingTriviaQA(75.4), -| memoryusage. | | Forretrieval,weuseaBM25retrieverthat | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2Wiki(53.6),Musique(26.0),andBamboogle(48.0).These -returnsthetop-3documentsforeachsearchquery. -resultsshowthatICRLscaleseffectivelywithmodelsize -| | | | | | | | and | generalizes | well | across both | in-domain | and out-of- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | -3.2.MainResults -| | | | | | | | domainQAtasks. | | Theconsistentgainsoverbaselinesthat | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -relyonsupervisedfine-tuningorrewardmodeling—such -Table3presentsthemainresultscomparingICRLtoother -baselines across five popular QA benchmarks. From the asZeroSearch,Search-R1,andRejectSampling—highlight -results,wecanobservethat: theeffectivenessofourin-contextreinforcementlearning -frameworkinlearningtool-usebehaviorswithoutexplicit -accuracy-basedrewardsorsupervision. -| ICRL | achieves | state-of-the-art | | | performance | across | | | | | | | -| -------------- | -------- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| QA benchmarks. | | | As shown | in | Table | 3, ICRL signifi- | | | | | | | -ICRL -cantlyoutperformsallbaselinesonbothQwen2.5-3Band achieves better performance without SFT or la- -Qwen2.5-7BmodelsacrossfivechallengingQAdatasets. beleddata. Table4highlightsakeyadvantageofICRL: -On Qwen2.5-3B, ICRL achieves an average exact match it achieves superior performance without requiring any + Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Multi-Factor Authentication + +Description: + +Treasury’s investment in Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) supports our development and +implementation of compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a +critical component of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, +including nation state actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications +by certifying identity with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an +authentication mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities +include strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption, +and strategic partnerships to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all Treasury Bureaus and +Offices. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +5 . 1 0 + +0 . 6 0 + +5 . 7 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +- 5 . 1 0 + +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % + +2 . 5 0 + +2 . 5 0 + +1 . 9 0 + +3 1 6 . 6 7 % + +- 3 . 2 0 + +- 5 6 . 1 4 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA multi-factor authentication (MFA) investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Multi-Factor Authentication investment, Treasury aims to develop and implement +compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a critical component +of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, including nation state +actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications by certifying identity +with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an authentication +mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities include +strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption of MFA, +and strategic partnerships with industry partners to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all +Treasury Bureaus and Offices. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $2.5 million for Treasury’s CEA Multi-Factor +Authentication investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + 6 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -(a)EMAccuracy -(b)FinishPercent -100 -| | | | | | | 3~2~0 | | 100 | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -3~2~1~0 -| 80 | 75.4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| )%(ycaruccAME | | | | | | | | )%(hsiniFevitalumuC | | | | | | | -80 -60 -53.6 -| | | | | | | 48 | | 60 | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -42.6 -40 -3~2~0 -| | | | | 26.8 | 26 | | | 40 | | | | | | | -| --- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | 20.8 | | | | | | | | | | | | 3~2~1~0 | | -| 20 | | | 17.8 | | | 14.4 | | | | | | | | | -20 -9 -0 -| | A | A | Wiki | | Que mboogle | | | | 0 | | | | | | -| ------ | -------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Trivia | Q Hotpot | Q | | MuSi | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | 2 | | | | | | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 6 | 7 | -Ba -NumberofTurns -Figure2.ComparisonofQwen-7Btrainedforthreestages(3~2~0)vsfourstages(3~2~1~0).(a)EMAccuracyacrossfiveQAdatasets. -(b)Cumulativefinishpercentvsnumberofsearchturns,aggregatedacrossalldatasets. -Table6.Results:Qwen2.5-14BmodelsExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousQAdatasets.Thebestperformanceissetbold. -DifficultQuestionAnswering -| | | Model | | Method | | | | | | | | Average | | | -| --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------ | -------- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | TriviaQA | | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | | | -| | | | | Direct | | 52.0 | 22.6 | 28.2 | 6.0 | | 15.2 | 24.80 | | | -| | Qwen2.5-14B | | | CoT | | 56.4 | 24.6 | 25.8 | 9.0 | | 40.0 | 31.16 | | | -| | | | | ICRL | | 75.0 | 43.2 | 61.8 | 25.6 | | 53.6 | 51.84 | | | -SFT,incontrasttoO2-Searcher,whichappliesacold-start throughin-contextreinforcementlearning. -| SFT phase | before | reinforcement | | learning. | | Despite | using | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | ------------- | ---------------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| no labeled | tool | traces | or task-specific | | supervision, | | ICRL | | | | | | | | -4.FurtherAnalysis -achievesahigheraverageEMscoreof40.16comparedto -37.26 from O2-Searcher. It outperforms O2-Searcher on 4.1.Ablationanalysis -fouroutoffivedatasets,includingsubstantialgainsonTrivi- -| | | | | | | | | Ablation | on curriculum | | design | for | rollout reduction. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | -aQA(+12.9)andMusique(+4.0).Theseresultsdemonstrate -Weconductanablationstudycomparingtwocurriculafor -thatICRLcanlearneffectivetool-usestrategiespurelyfrom -reducingthenumberofexamplesusedintherolloutprocess: -in-contextexamplesandreinforcementsignals,offeringa -athree-stageschedule(3~2~0)andafour-stageschedule -scalableanddata-efficientalternativetomethodsthatrely -| | | | | | | | | (3~2~1~0). | AsshowninFigure2(a),thethree-stagevariant | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oncostlyannotationandpretraining. -achievessubstantiallyhigherEMaccuracyacrossallfive -| | | | | | | | | QA datasets. | For | instance, | on | TriviaQA | and 2Wiki, | the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -3.3.ConcreteExamples -three-stagemodelreaches75.4and53.6,comparedto20.8 -Table5presentsacompletereasoningexamplefromICRL- and26.8withthefour-stageversion. -| Qwen2.5-7B | on | a question | | from the | Bamboogle | dataset. | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2(b)showsthatthefour-stagecurriculumleadsto -Themodelistaskedwithansweringacompositionalquery: -fasterdecisions,withover80%ofqueriesfinishingwithin -| identifying | the | president | who | established | | the two-term | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | twosearchturns. | However,thiscomesatthecostofanswer | | | | | | -precedentanddeterminingwhenheenteredoffice. Itfirst quality. These results suggest that aggressively reducing -issuesasearchquerytoidentifytherelevantfigure,correctly -| | | | | | | | | rollout length | too | early | (via the | intermediate | stage | with | -| ---------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -| concluding | that | George | Washington | | set the | precedent. | It | | | | | | | | -oneexample)encouragesprematurestoppingandweakens -thenformulatesafollow-upquerytoretrievehisinaugura- -| | | | | | | | | multi-turnreasoning. | | Incontrast,thesimpler3~2~0curricu- | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tiondateandsuccessfullyextractsthecorrectanswer,April -lummaintainsstrongerperformancebyallowingthemodel -30,1789. ThiscaseillustratesICRL’sabilitytodecompose -toexplorelongerreasoningpathsduringtraining. -complexquestions,retrieverelevantinformationacrossmul- -tipleturns,andmaintaincoherentreasoningwithoutexplicit -intermediatesupervision. Itdemonstratestheeffectiveness ModelScalingand14BPerformance. Toevaluatethe -ofourframeworkinlearningstructuredtool-usebehaviors scalabilityofICRLacrosslargermodels, weappliedour + In FY2025, CEA – Multi-Factor Authentication investment is targeted to the Department’s MFA- +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +Conversion to Active Directory (AD) Federation that provides for the authorization, authentication, +and SSO functionality to applications and services virtually anywhere, including perimeter networks, +partner organizations, and the cloud. + +• Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Other Cyber Priorities + +Description: + +Treasury maintains investment in Other Cybersecurity Priorities that address and respond to the +changing threat landscape of the Department, given our interconnected technology environment, which +has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the security posture of high value assets, national +security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, cybersecurity governance, risk, and +compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient +future through the acquisition of federal labor cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our +complex technology portfolio, as well as the necessary resources to support the overall administration +and governance of Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) appropriations and the ongoing +performance of cybersecurity investments. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 7 . 7 9 + +2 . 7 3 + +6 . 0 5 + +3 . 3 2 + +1 2 1 . 5 4 % + +8 . 7 5 + +2 6 . 5 5 + +1 2 . 9 0 + +1 5 . 6 3 + +1 8 . 9 0 + +2 4 . 9 5 + +6 . 0 1 + +4 6 . 5 8 % + +9 . 3 3 + +5 9 . 6 8 % + 7 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -| | (a)ResponseLength | | | (b)Reward | | (c)NumberofValidSearch | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3.Trainingdynamicscomparisonacrossdifferentfew-shotsettings(3-shot,2-shot,0-shot)forQwen-7Bmodel. -Table7.Results:Accuracy(%)onMathQAdatasets. -methodtoQwen2.5-14B-InstructandreportresultsinTa- -ble6.ICRLsignificantlyoutperformsbothdirectprompting -MathQA -andCoTmethods acrossallfiveQAdatasets. Inparticu- Model Method SFT -| | | | | | | | AIME2024 | AIME2025 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -lar, itachieves75.0EMonTriviaQAand61.8on2Wiki, -| | | | | | ReTool | ✓ | 67.0 | | 49.3 | -| ----------------------------------------------- | ------------------- | --------- | --------------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | -| yieldingastrongaverageEMscoreof51.84—surpassing | | | | Qwen3-8B | | | | | | -| | | | | | ICRL | ✗ | 64.1 | | 51.7 | -| CoT | by +20.7 and direct | prompting | by +27.0. These | re- | | | | | | -sultsdemonstratethatICRLcontinuestoscaleeffectively -tolargermodelsizesandbenefitsfromincreasedcapacity, -compareourresultswithReTool,whichisaSFT-RLtrain- -withoutrequiringadditionalsupervisionorannotation. -ingframeworkthattrainingmodelstolearncode-writing -| | | | | and tool-calling | on running | code. | ReTool | (Feng | et al., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ------- | -4.2.Trainingprocess -| | | | | 2025) achieves | the state-of-the-art | | performance | on | code- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -TounderstandhowICRLevolvesduringtraining,weana- -augmentedlong-formreasoningforsolvingmathproblems, -lyzethelearningcurvesacrossthe3-shot,2-shot,and0-shot butitalsoneedsalotofannotateddatatoapplycold-start -curriculumstagesusingtheQwen2.5-7Bmodel.Intheearly -SFTformodelstolearnthetool-callingformatandunder- -stageswithdemonstrations(3-shotand2-shot),themodel standthewholereasoningprocess. However,ourmethod -producesrelativelystableandwell-structuredresponses,as ICRLdoesn’tneedtoSFTthemodelfirst,andmodelscan -| reflected | in the consistent | response | lengths. As training | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------------- | -------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stillreasoningproperlyfromtheIn-ContextLearningwith -progressesintothe0-shotstage,theresponselengthinitially the examples we provides in prompt. From Table 7, al- -dropsduetotheremovalofin-contextexamplesbutgradu- -throughoutmethodunderperformsReToolonAIME2024 -allyincreasesagain,indicatingthatthemodelislearningto by 2.9%, it can achieve better result on AIME2025 with -independentlycomposelongerandmorestructuredoutputs. -| | | | | +2.4%accuracy. | Whichmeansourmethodstillworksfor | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | help models | to learn | other tool-calling | operations | | and is | -Althoughtherewardremainsrelativelysteadythroughout -moredata-efficientthanothermethodsthatneedcold-start -trainingandisbasedonlyonsparsesignals—outputformat -validityandfinalansweraccuracy—themodelstilllearns SFTwiththousandsofannotateddata. -| tousetoolsmoreeffectivelyovertime. | | | Thisismostclearly | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ----------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| reflectedintheincreasingnumberofvalidtoolcallsduring | | | | 5.Conclusion | | | | | | -| the0-shotphase. | Theriseinvalidtoolusageindicatesthat | | | | | | | | | -WeintroduceICRL,asimpleyetpowerfulframeworkfor -ICRLsuccessfullyencouragesthemodeltointernalizetool- -usebehavior,evenwithoutdenseorstep-levelsupervision. training LLMs to use tools via in-context reinforcement -| | | | | learning,withoutrequiringSFTorlabeledtooltraces. | | | | | By | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -incorporatingfew-shotdemonstrationsdirectlyintotheRL -4.3.Generalize -rolloutpromptsandgraduallyphasingthemout,ICRLen- -Apart from conducting our method in web search tool- ablesmodelstotransitionfromimitationtoautonomoustool -callingdomain,wealsoevaluateourmethodbytrainingthe -| | | | | usethroughreward-drivenlearning. | | | Ourmethodachieves | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -models’abilitiesoncode-writingandcallingtoolstorunthe strong performance across a range of QA and reasoning -pythoncodetohelpthemsolvecomplexmathproblems.We benchmarks, outperforming existing approaches that rely + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA investment for other cybersecurity priorities focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment, Treasury maintains investment in +initiatives that address and respond to the changing threat landscape of the Department, given our +interconnected technology environment, which has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the +security posture of high value assets, national security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, +cybersecurity governance, risk, and compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. +Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient future through the acquisition of federal labor +cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our complex technology portfolio, as well as the +necessary resources to support the overall administration and governance of CEA appropriations and +the ongoing performance of cybersecurity investments. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.0 million for Treasury’s CEA Other Cybersecurity +Priorities investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate + +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. + +In FY2025, CEA – Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment is targeted to the Department’s cyber +priorities focused om modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Establish a repeatable programmatic structure to review, assess, and govern emerging + +technologies (i.e., quantum, Artificial Intelligence [AI], etc.) to ensure applications of all +security standards develop consistent policies, workforce planning, reporting, Bureau +adherence, ethical use, etc. + +• Acquisition of an enterprise EDR solution +• Workforce focused cyber awareness and other supplemental trainings +• Enhanced security compliance of a low code platform through Enhanced Adoption and + +Automation of Change Management/Enablement, as well as increased use of common +controls. + +• Evolution of the Enterprise Cyber Risk Management (ECRM) initiative which will continue to + +strengthen Treasury's approach to managing risks across the enterprise and instantiate a +continuous review of all of its critical networks, systems, and data. + 8 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -onsuperviseddataorfrozentool-usepolicies. ICRLalso Hsiao, V., Fine-Morris, M., Roberts, M., Smith, L. N., -generalizesacrossdomains,includingwebsearchandcode and Hiatt, L. M. A critical assessment of LLMs for -execution, demonstrating its flexibility and effectiveness. solving multi-step problems: Preliminary results. In -TheseresultshighlightICRLasascalableanddata-efficient AAAI 2025 Workshop LM4Plan, 2025. URL https: -alternative to traditional SFT+RL pipelines for enabling //openreview.net/forum?id=kFrqoVtMIy. -tool-augmentedlanguagemodels. -| | | | | Jin, B., Zeng, | H., | Yue, Z., | Yoon, | J., | Arik, S., | Wang, D., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | -| | | | | Zamani, | H., and | Han, | J. Search-r1: | | Training | llms to | -ImpactStatements -reasonandleveragesearchengineswithreinforcement -Thispaperpresentsworkwhosegoalistoadvancethefield learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2503.09516,2025a. -| of machine | learning. There | are many potential | societal | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------------- | ------------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -consequencesofourwork,noneofwhichwefeelmustbe Jin, J., Zhu, Y., Dou, Z., Dong, G., Yang, X., Zhang, C., -| | | | | Zhao, T., | Yang, | Z., and | Wen, | J.-R. | Flashrag: | A mod- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | ------ | -specificallyhighlightedhere. -ulartoolkitforefficientretrieval-augmentedgeneration -| | | | | research. | InCompanionProceedingsoftheACMonWeb | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -References -Conference2025,pp.737–740,2025b. -Ahn,J.,Verma,R.,Lou,R.,Liu,D.,Zhang,R.,andYin,W. -Largelanguagemodelsformathematicalreasoning: Pro- Joshi, M., Choi, E., Weld, D. S., and Zettlemoyer, L. -| | | | | Triviaqa: | A large | scale | distantly | supervised | | challenge | -| --------------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | -| gressesandchallenges. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.00157, | | | | | | | | | -| 2024. | | | | dataset | for reading | comprehension. | | | arXiv | preprint | -arXiv:1705.03551,2017. -Cheng,J.,Marone,M.,Weller,O.,Lawrie,D.,Khashabi, -D., and Van Durme, B. Dated data: Tracing knowl- Kwiatkowski, T., Palomaki, J., Redfield, O., Collins, M., -edge cutoffs in large language models. arXiv preprint Parikh,A.,Alberti,C.,Epstein,D.,Polosukhin,I.,Kel- -arXiv:2403.12958,2024. cey, M., Devlin, J., Lee, K., Toutanova, K. N., Jones, -| | | | | L., Chang, | M.-W., | Dai, | A., Uszkoreit, | | J., | Le, Q., and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | -Chung,H.W.,Hou,L.,Longpre,S.,Zoph,B.,Tay,Y.,Fe- Petrov,S. Naturalquestions: abenchmarkforquestion -dus,W.,Li,Y.,Wang,X.,Dehghani,M.,Brahma,S.,etal. answeringresearch. TransactionsoftheAssociationof -Scalinginstruction-finetunedlanguagemodels. Journal ComputationalLinguistics,2019. -ofMachineLearningResearch,25(70):1–53,2024. -Lewis,P.,Perez,E.,Piktus,A.,Petroni,F.,Karpukhin,V., -Feng,J.,Huang,S.,Qu,X.,Zhang,G.,Qin,Y.,Zhong,B., Goyal,N.,Küttler,H.,Lewis,M.,Yih,W.-t.,Rocktäschel, -Jiang,C.,Chi,J.,andZhong,W. Retool: Reinforcement T.,etal. Retrieval-augmentedgenerationforknowledge- -learning for strategic tool use in llms. arXiv preprint intensivenlptasks. Advancesinneuralinformationpro- -| arXiv:2504.11536,2025. | | | | cessingsystems,33:9459–9474,2020. | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Gao,Y.,Xiong,Y.,Gao,X.,Jia,K.,Pan,J.,Bi,Y.,Dai,Y., Li,X.,Dong,G.,Jin,J.,Zhang,Y.,Zhou,Y.,Zhu,Y.,Zhang, -Sun, J., Wang, H., andWang, H. Retrieval-augmented P., and Dou, Z. Search-o1: Agentic search-enhanced -generationforlargelanguagemodels: Asurvey. arXiv largereasoningmodels.arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.05366, -| preprintarXiv:2312.10997,2(1),2023. | | | | 2025a. | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Guo,D.,Yang,D.,Zhang,H.,Song,J.,Zhang,R.,Xu,R., Li,X.,Jin,J.,Dong,G.,Qian,H.,Zhu,Y.,Wu,Y.,Wen,J.- -Zhu,Q.,Ma,S.,Wang,P.,Bi,X.,etal. Deepseek-r1: In- R.,andDou,Z.Webthinker:Empoweringlargereasoning -| | | | | models | with deep | research | capability. | | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -centivizingreasoningcapabilityinllmsviareinforcement -learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.12948,2025. arXiv:2504.21776,2025b. -| | | | | Matarazzo,A.andTorlone,R. | | | Asurveyonlargelanguage | | | | -| -------- | --------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Guo, T., | Chen, X., Wang, | Y., Chang, R., | Pei, S., Chawla, | | | | | | | | -N.V.,Wiest,O.,andZhang,X. Largelanguagemodel modelswithsomeinsightsontheircapabilitiesandlimi- -basedmulti-agents: Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. tations. arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.04040,2025. -InIJCAI,2024. -| | | | | Mei, J., Hu, | T., | Fu, D., | Wen, | L., | Yang, | X., Wu, R., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | ----- | ----------- | -Ho, X., Nguyen, A.-K. D., Sugawara, S., and Aizawa, Cai, P., Cai, X., Gao, X., Yang, Y., et al. O2- -A. Constructing a multi-hop qa dataset for compre- searcher: A searching-based agent model for open- -hensive evaluation of reasoning steps. arXiv preprint domainopen-endedquestionanswering. arXivpreprint -| arXiv:2011.01060,2020. | | | | arXiv:2505.16582,2025. | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + • Development of a low code Configuration Management Database (CMDB) solution, +encompassing both Asset Management and Configuration Management. +• Development of a Risk Management Framework for enterprise infrastructure +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component to + +address current and emerging cyber priorities such as Supply Chain Risk Management +(SCRM) and incident response support. + +• Performance of enterprise-level FISMA readiness assessments. +• Facilitation of an Enterprise Cyber BPA ordering capability (PROTECTS) +• + +Investment in an Annual Threat Hunt that identifies a random sampling of Treasury systems to + +identify anomalies beyond traditional detection methodologies. + +Acquisition of Incident Response support, allowing for defined response timeline in the +event of a compromise and need for SME and resource depth. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Security Logging + +Description: + +Treasury’s investments in Security Logging ensure compliance with Office of Management and +Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security logging capabilities +to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. Investment funding targets +the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, storage and retention of +log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the creation of user +behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The investment objective +is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security operations center at +the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center (TSSSOC). + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +2 5 . 6 6 + +2 . 4 8 + +2 9 . 4 1 + +2 6 . 9 3 1 , 0 8 8 . 2 4 % + +0 . 0 0 + +2 5 . 6 6 + +4 . 0 0 + +6 . 4 8 + +1 1 . 9 2 + +7 . 9 2 + +1 9 7 . 9 0 % + +4 1 . 3 3 + +3 4 . 8 5 + +5 3 8 . 2 2 % + 9 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Nguyen,X.-P.,Pandit,S.,Reddy,R.G.,Xu,A.,Savarese, for knowledge-intensive multi-step questions. In Pro- -S., Xiong, C., and Joty, S. Sfr-deepresearch: Towards ceedingsofthe61stannualmeetingoftheassociationfor -effective reinforcement learning for autonomously rea- computational linguistics (volume 1: long papers), pp. -| soningsingleagents. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2509.06283, | | | | | 10014–10037,2023. | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2025. -| | | | | | | | Wang, C., | Deng, Y., | Lyu, | Z., Zeng, L., | He, J., Yan, | S., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --------- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | and An, | B. Q*: | Improving | multi-step | reasoning | for | -Press,O.,Zhang,M.,Min,S.,Schmidt,L.,Smith,N.A., -andLewis, M. Measuringandnarrowingthecomposi- llms with deliberative planning, 2024a. URL https: -tionalitygapinlanguagemodels. InFindingsoftheAs- //arxiv.org/abs/2406.14283. -| sociationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | | EMNLP2023, | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,S.,Zhu,Y.,Liu,H.,Zheng,Z.,Chen,C.,andLi,J. -pp.5687–5711,2023. -| | | | | | | | Knowledgeeditingforlargelanguagemodels: | | | | Asurvey. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -Qu, C., Dai, S., Wei, X., Cai, H., Wang, S., Yin, D., ACMComputingSurveys,57(3):1–37,2024b. -| Xu, J., | and Wen, | J.-r. | Tool learning | with | large | lan- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | ------------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Wei,J.,Wang,X.,Schuurmans,D.,Bosma,M.,Xia,F.,Chi, -| guage models: | | a survey. | Frontiers | of Computer | | Sci- | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ence, 19(8), January 2025. ISSN 2095-2236. doi: E.,Le,Q.V.,Zhou,D.,etal.Chain-of-thoughtprompting -| | | | | | | | elicitsreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. | | | | Advancesin | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| 10.1007/s11704-024-40678-2. | | | URLhttp://dx.doi. | | | | | | | | | | -neuralinformationprocessingsystems,35:24824–24837, -org/10.1007/s11704-024-40678-2. -2022. -Seed,B.,Chen,J.,Fan,T.,Liu,X.,Liu,L.,Lin,Z.,Wang, -Yang,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B.,Yu,B., -| M.,Wang,C.,Wei,X.,Xu,W.,etal. | | | | Seed1.5-thinking: | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Li,C.,Liu,D.,Huang,F.,Wei,H.,Lin,H.,Yang,J.,Tu, -Advancingsuperbreasoningmodelswithreinforcement -J.,Zhang,J.,Yang,J.,Yang,J.,Zhou,J.,Lin,J.,Dang, -| learning. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2504.13914,2025. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -K.,Lu,K.,Bao,K.,Yang,K.,Yu,L.,Li,M.,Xue,M., -Zhang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Men,R.,Lin,R.,Li,T.,Tang,T.,Xia, -Shao,Z.,Wang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Xu,R.,Song,J.,Bi,X.,Zhang, -H.,Zhang,M.,Li,Y.,Wu,Y.,etal. Deepseekmath: Push- T., Ren, X., Ren, X., Fan, Y., Su, Y., Zhang, Y., Wan, -ingthelimitsofmathematicalreasoninginopenlanguage Y., Liu, Y., Cui, Z., Zhang, Z., and Qiu, Z. Qwen2.5 -models. arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.03300,2024. technicalreport,2024a. -Sheng,G.,Zhang,C.,Ye,Z.,Wu,X.,Zhang,W.,Zhang, Yang,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B.,Yu,B., -R.,Peng,Y.,Lin,H.,andWu,C. Hybridflow: Aflexi- Li,C.,Liu,D.,Huang,F.,Wei,H.,Lin,H.,Yang,J.,Tu, -J.,Zhang,J.,Yang,J.,Yang,J.,Zhou,J.,Lin,J.,Dang, -| bleandefficientrlhfframework. | | | | arXivpreprintarXiv: | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2409.19256,2024. | | | | | | | K.,Lu,K.,Bao,K.,Yang,K.,Yu,L.,Li,M.,Xue,M., | | | | | | -Zhang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Men,R.,Lin,R.,Li,T.,Xia,T.,Ren, -| Shi, Z., Gao, | S., | Yan, L., | Feng, Y., | Chen, | X., Chen, | Z., | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -X.,Ren,X.,Fan,Y.,Su,Y.,Zhang,Y.,Wan,Y.,Liu,Y., -Yin, D., Verberne, S., and Ren, Z. Tool learning in Cui,Z.,Zhang,Z.,andQiu,Z. Qwen2.5technicalreport. -the wild: Empowering language models as automatic arXivpreprintarXiv:2412.15115,2024b. -toolagents,2025.URLhttps://arxiv.org/abs/ -| 2405.16533. | | | | | | | Yang,A.,Li,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B., | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Yu,B.,Gao,C.,Huang,C.,Lv,C.,etal. | | | | Qwen3technical | | -Sun,H.,Qiao,Z.,Guo,J.,Fan,X.,Hou,Y.,Jiang,Y.,Xie, report. arXivpreprintarXiv:2505.09388,2025. -| P., Zhang, | Y., | Huang, F., | and Zhou, | J. Zerosearch: | | In- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Yang,Z.,Qi,P.,Zhang,S.,Bengio,Y.,Cohen,W.,Salakhut- -centivizethesearchcapabilityofllmswithoutsearching. -arXivpreprintarXiv:2505.04588,2025. dinov,R.,andManning,C.D. Hotpotqa: Adatasetfor -| | | | | | | | diverse, explainable | | multi-hop | question | answering. | In | -| --------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| Team, K., | Bai, Y., | Bao, | Y., Chen, | G., Chen, | J., | Chen, | | | | | | | -Proceedingsofthe2018conferenceonempiricalmethods -N., Chen, R., Chen, Y., Chen, Y., Chen, Y., et al. innaturallanguageprocessing,pp.2369–2380,2018. -| Kimi k2: | Open | agentic | intelligence. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ------- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Zhao,S.,Yu,T.,Xu,A.,Singh,J.,Shukla,A.,andAkkiraju, -arXiv:2507.20534,2025. -| | | | | | | | R. Parallelsearch: | | Trainyourllmstodecomposequery | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Trivedi,H.,Balasubramanian,N.,Khot,T.,andSabharwal, and search sub-queries in parallel with reinforcement -A. Musique: Multihop questions via single-hop ques- learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2508.09303,2025. -| | | Transactions | | of the Association | | for | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tion composition. -Zhu,Z.,Liao,Y.,Chen,Z.,Wang,Y.,Guan,Y.,Wang,Y., -ComputationalLinguistics,10:539–554,2022. -andWang,Y.Evolvebench:Acomprehensivebenchmark -Trivedi,H.,Balasubramanian,N.,Khot,T.,andSabharwal, for assessing temporal awareness in llms on evolving -A. Interleavingretrievalwithchain-of-thoughtreasoning knowledge. InProceedingsofthe63rdAnnualMeeting -10 + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA security logging investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Security Logging investment, Treasury ensures compliance with Office of +Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security +logging capabilities to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. +Investment funding targets the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, +storage and retention of log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the +creation of user behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The +investment objective is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security +operations center at the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center +(TSSSOC). + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $41.3 million for Treasury’s CEA Security Logging +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +In FY2025, CEA – Security Logging investment is targeted to the Department’s security logging +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Security Logging efforts to protect against Distributed Denial-of-Services (DDoS) and other +cyber-attacks including 1) increase of storage for Treasury Trusted Internet Connection +(TIC) packet capture data, allowing rapid forensic analysis of suspected attacks; 2) +expansion of Web Application Firewall (WAF) capabilities for applications and services +across the Department; and 3) implementation of indexers at the Network Colocations +which will provide critical cyber visibility and analytics. + +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary + +to strengthen threat analysis, provide Security Operations Center (SOC) support for +sustained cyber attacks, and establish, operate, and maintain the Treasury logging platform. + +• Expansion of the SOC to provide enterprise SOC capabilities for Treasury bureaus, including + +Operations analysts, intake support, Threat & Research analysts, enhanced capabilities, and +associated equipment. + +• + +Investment in cloud-based log processing, storage, and platform licenses. + +10 + + Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Universal Encryption + +Description: + +The Department’s investment in Universal Encryption supports our commitment to fully achieve +encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance (i.e., Office of +Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security Agency [CISA], and +others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest (DAR) and data in transit +(DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our environment, proposed +solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for compliance with encryption +standards and requirements. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +2 . 5 0 + +0 . 4 8 + +2 . 9 8 + +1 . 0 0 + +- 1 . 5 0 + +- 6 0 . 0 0 % + +0 . 0 0 + +1 . 0 0 + +- 0 . 4 8 + +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % + +- 1 . 9 8 + +- 6 6 . 3 9 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA universal encryption investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Universal Encryption investment, the Department supports initiatives that work +toward full achievement of encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance (i.e., Office of Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security +Agency [CISA], and others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest +(DAR) and data in transit (DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our + +11 + + environment, proposed solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for +compliance with encryption standards and requirements. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $1 million for Treasury’s CEA Universal Encryption +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +In FY 2025, CEA – Universal Encryption investment is targeted to the Department’s universal +encryption focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY 2025 appropriations: + +• + +Investment in Quantum-Resistant Cryptography that could protect the Department against + +cryptanalytic attacks by a quantum computer. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Zero Trust Architecture + +Description: + +Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) investment priorities at Treasury seek to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +12 + + Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 4 . 8 1 + +3 3 . 1 0 + +1 2 . 8 0 + +- 2 0 . 3 0 + +- 6 1 . 3 3 % + +1 2 . 2 7 + +2 7 . 0 8 + +9 . 2 0 + +4 2 . 0 0 + +3 2 . 8 0 + +3 5 6 . 5 2 % + +4 2 . 3 0 + +5 4 . 8 0 + +1 2 . 5 0 + +2 9 . 5 5 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA zero trust architecture investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to +build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation +of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the Zero Trust Architecture investment, Treasury seeks to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. Treasury +leverages the Zero Trust Architecture investment to provide additional human capital to support +management of service providers, as well as development, testing, and deployment of the applications +that have the security controls integrated into them. This investment also supports the Treasury Zero +Trust enterprise identity access solution, known as Common Approach to Identify Access Management +(CAIA), for all external federal partners who access the Enterprise Content Management (ECM) +SharePoint platform for shared services. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $54.8 million for Treasury’s CEA Zero Trust Architecture +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +In FY 2025, CEA – Zero Trust Architecture investments are targeted to the Department’s zero trust +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +13 + + Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Expansion of Treasury’s cyber threat intelligence platform to include additional cyber threat +intelligence feeds, additional material from existing feeds, and expand access to platform +capabilities and shared data. + +• + +Implementation of a TSSSOC lateral scanning capability across enterprise application and + +centralized incident response + +• Acquisition of an enterprise Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solution +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary + +to implement zero trust architecture across the Department’s IT systems + +• Bureau implementation of zero trust architecture +• Development or acquisition of Security Operations Center (SOC) services for the Treasury + +Security Data Network + +• Expansion of Treasury’s mobile Secret Internet Protocol Router (SIPR) capability +• Enterprise-wide vulnerability management efforts including the establishment of an enterprise +penetration testing shared service offering and acquisition of a vulnerability management +tool to track and conduct analysis of enterprise-wide critical vulnerabilities + +• Development of application threat modeling capabilities to prepare for increasing resilience of + +systems and robustness of testing. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +HR LoB - HRConnect + +Description: + +HR Connect is a Human Resources enterprise system. It is a web-based solution built on PeopleSoft +software. HR Connect transforms core back-office HR functions, moving them from a processing- +centric capability to a strategic-centric capability. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 2 . 2 8 + +1 8 . 5 9 + +1 8 . 8 7 + +0 . 2 8 + +1 . 5 1% + +3 7 . 1 4 + +4 9 . 4 2 + +3 7 . 0 5 + +5 5 . 6 4 + +3 8 . 2 6 + +5 7 . 1 3 + +1 . 2 1 + +3 . 2 7% + +1 . 4 9 + +2 . 6 8 % + +14 + + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +HRConnect is Treasury's enterprise human resources system. It is one of four federal OPM HR Lines +of Business providing HR services to the federal government. HRConnect is based on a combination of +(a) web-based solution built on PeopleSoft commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) software, (b) Software as +a Service (Saas) platforms (e.g. Talent Management and Career Connector) and (c) internally +developed applications (e.g. Entrance on Duty System). HRConnect transforms core back-office HR +functions, moving them from a processing-centric capability to a strategic-centric capability enabled +through its commercial software underpinning. Additionally, self-service components of the software +fundamentally transform the standard government HR service delivery model, putting additional +information, services and processes (i.e., personal data, position management, requests for personnel +action, recruitment, reporting, etc.) directly in the hands of managers and employees. + +HRConnect supports the common HR Line of Business processes and provides core HR functionality +that is interoperable, portable and scalable. This shared solution provides automated systems that are +configurable to the individual organizations' needs while providing a single solution across the +Department and federal landscape. HRConnect's core functions include: Personnel Action Processing, +Managing Payroll, Administering Benefits, Time and Attendance and Labor Distribution. By enabling +the retirement of legacy systems and automating and streamlining many aspects of human resources, +HRConnect facilitates increased efficiency and overall productivity for its customers. HRConnect is +the system used by all Treasury bureaus and several other government agencies (over 22 entities) with +over 200,000 employees and contractors in total. + +HRConnect Top FY 2023 Accomplishments: + +1. Implemented 74 HRConnect change requests to maintain regulatory compliance, improve the +employee and manager experience, and provide tools to streamline and enable efficient +processing for HR Specialists. + +2. Maintained a steady state of 100% availability for customers. +3. Treasury HRLOB implemented multifactor authentication (MFA) for all TSSC applications + +and achieved M-21-31 compliance for the HRConnect High Value Asset (HVA). + +4. Completed the migration of HRConnect’s data service, Workforce Analytics from on prem +data centers to a FedRAMP High secure cloud hosted environment, effectively scaling and +maturing the platform. + +5. Delivered Integrated Talent Management (ITM) and HRConnect real-time performance plan + +and learning data integration. + +6. Implemented new Remote/Telework Agreement Type and Program and Project Job Identifier + +fields and Mass Update Process, 34K positions updated. + +7. Streamlined the background investigation security process across Treasury by expanding the + +Adjudication Tracker application to three additional bureaus. + +8. Continued to modernize HRConnect delivering enhancements to improve the user experience + +for employees, managers, and HR Specialists. + +9. Deployed a visual representation of key Time to Hire (T2H) metrics via the Treasury + +Workforce Dashboard to track and optimize the hiring timeline and make data-driven hiring +decisions. + +10. Continued employee self-service (ESS) redesign leveraging fluid concepts. +11. Supported gender identity and other preferred name representation in accordance with + +management directives. + +15 + + Enterprise API Service Platform [MuleSoft]: Transition 15+ partners to the new API Service +Framework. Launched integrations between USAS to DO and FinCEN Adjudication Tracker, ARC- +FS Worklist API and SAM.gov integration to HRC to update vendor information. +In FY2023: Treasury Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) recently assumed responsibility +for the management of the transformation of Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Human Resource +Information Technology (HRIT) applications in support of the Inflation Reduction Act. This transfer of +responsibility allows the IRS CIO to focus their efforts on improving the taxpayer experience +leveraging the Treasury OCIO’s shared services and common platforms to facilitate the modernization +of IRS HRIT systems, the rationalization pillars include: HRConnect, Integrated Talent Management, +USA Staffing, Enterprise Data Management, and the Employee Portal. + +A few of technical improvements, included: Nessus implementation, CAST implementation, piloted +the transition of 3 environments to Oracle Managed Services compartment in Q3, improved the fire +wall configurations and finalized the closure of the Memphis and Martinsburg HRC footprint. + +Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM) + +Description: + +The Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM), formerly submitted +as EIdM, consolidates funding of Treasury implementing the Homeland Security Presidential +Directive- (HSPD) 12, E-Auth, and Federal PKI initiatives. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +4 3 . 0 7 + +7 5 . 9 4 + +7 5 . 9 8 + +0 . 0 4 + +8 1 . 6 2 + +7 8 . 9 9 + +8 0 . 9 5 + +0.05% + +2.48% + +1.29% + +1 . 9 6 + +2 . 0 0 + +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +1 2 4 . 6 9 + +1 5 4 . 9 3 + +1 5 6 . 9 3 + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The TEICAM Business Case consolidates funding that supports Treasury’s implementation of HSPD- +12, FICAM and PKI requirements. This investment supports the target vision of "One Treasury One +Card" to provide universal access. Availability and use of a PIV/identity management standard within +Treasury provides a mechanism for Physical and Logical access to Treasury-wide assets. The TEICAM +phased implementation provides all of Treasury: + +• Trusted identity processes for both Federal and public users of Treasury applications +• Enhanced security (by decreasing data breaches and trust violations) +• Compliance with laws, regulations, and standards +• +• Expanded use of PIV encryption and digital signature certificates (ensuring adoption of multi- + +Improved interoperability + +factor authentication) +• Elimination of redundancy + +16 + + Treasury/TEICAM has achieved many of the defined goals for PIV card issuance, physical access, +logical access, data synchronization, enterprise single sign-on, federation, and PIV required for both +privileged and unprivileged users. These goals have helped the Department align with the required +OMB and FICAM goals. +Additionally, TEICAM has updated the Department strategic roadmap & planned for the following +investment goals: + +1) CDM II-PRIV/CRED Management + +o Continue working with the Managed Service Bureaus and Non-Managed Service + +Bureaus on implementation of Credential (CRED) and Privileged Access Management +(PAM) + +o On-board new bureaus, such as IRS and DO Orbit Organizations (TSSOC, OFR, etc.), + +to the enterprise CDM Managed Service Offering (MSO) + +o Continue working with DHS CISA on the integration activities for the Federal + +Dashboard for Treasury’s CDM Data reporting + +2) Plan, test, & implement the issuance of version 8.1 PIV cards (PIV V8.1) across the enterprise + +in FY21-FY24 + +3) Expand usage of the Enterprise Derived Credential issuance capability to support + +authentication to Treasury services/infrastructure from mobile devices across Treasury in +FY21-FY24 + +4) As part of the PIV-I solution, implement an application programming interface (API) + +connection between a Fiscal Service application used to capture applicant data and +HRConnect in FY21-FY24 + +5) Implement an enterprise Hardware Security Module (HSM) as a service in FY22-FY24 +6) Enterprise solution for tracking and monitoring the Only Locally Trusted (OLT) PKI + +certificates generated and in use within each bureau + +7) Plan, design, and implement a modernized Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) + +solution that enforces multifactor authentication and aligns with the Treasury Zero Trust +Architecture (ZTA) + +8) In an effort to improve cost-savings, the Department utilizes interagency resources to +authenticate users, synchronize data, and to procure and maintain enterprise-wide +compliant PIV credentials (USAccess). As a mixed life-cycle investment, the TEICAM +Operations and Maintenance tasks includes OMB, FISMA, and Cyber reporting specific to +identity, credential and access management. + +Planned objectives and accomplishments include: + +• Maintaining above 95% PIV card issuance rate and providing replacements for the PIV in time + +sensitive activities; + +• Maintained 100% PIV required privileged account access and 97% PIV required unprivileged + +access; + +• CDM II privileged access management is operating with a cloud infrastructure and production +at four bureaus performing O&M functions; we have commenced technical work on +bringing the IRS on as the fifth and largest managed service customer; + +• Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) onboarded 12 new customers and integrated + +with third-party identity providers to expand citizen services and access; +• Executed a Treasury-wide BPA for citizen authentication services access to the entire +enterprise, allowing for secure and fast public access to Treasury systems; + +• Developed an alternative authentication solution and deployed it within 6 weeks to ensure + +continuity of government during the pandemic; + +• + +Implemented a hardware security module (HSM) as a service for the Derived PIV solution and + +DO. + +17 + + • + +Implementation of the department-wide PKI Only Locally Trusted (OLT) monitoring solution. + +18 + + Major Non-IT Investments + +Main Treasury Building and Freedman's Bank Building + +Description: + +Correct life safety and code issues, reduce building systems risk, and maintain the buildings. Absent +full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation, Treasury is utilizing available funding to +correct the most severe issues. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +9 . 7 9 + +0 . 0 0 + +9 . 7 9 + +3 . 5 5 + +0 . 0 0 + +3 . 5 5 + +5 . 5 5 + +2 . 0 0 + +5 6 . 2 5 % + +0 . 0 0 + +5 . 5 5 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 % + +2 . 0 0 + +5 6 . 2 5 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +This investment is to address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by +upgrading a number of outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building +standards. Absent full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical +buildings, available funding will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being +executed with the expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent +investments could be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments +support a safe and healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project +needs are mission focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs +that pose significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. + +Treasury’s three-step long-term strategy to continue to maintain and modernize its owned spaces: (1) +secure the building’s outer envelope; (2) conduct a condition assessment to identify additional needs +associated with the buildings’ continual aging and deferred maintenance; and (3) based on this +assessment, conduct a holistic modernization of the building’s systems and infrastructure. Targeted +investments address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by upgrading +outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building standards. Absent full +funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical buildings, available funding +will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being executed with the +expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent investments could +be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments support a safe and +healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project needs are mission +focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs that pose +significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. + +Treasury Operations has continued to strategically focus on restoring the health of the building +envelope (shell), to correct the deteriorating building structure and infrastructure. Components of the + +19 + + Main Treasury building that have been repaired, replaced, or funded include new roofs (FY 2019/2021) +and repairs to 40 percent of the windows (FY 2015/2017). The Freedman’s Bank Building components +that have been repaired, replaced, or funded/planned include new roofs (FY 2017/2019), domestic +water line (FY 2020/2022), and replacement of all windows (FY 2009/2011). Funding and completion +of these exterior items represent significant progress towards the preservation of the two buildings, +maintaining a safe and healthy workplace, and reducing damage to the interior plaster and paint. The +contract for the first phase (west façade) of the Main Treasury exterior restoration project was awarded +late in FY 2021 and completed during FY 2022. Exterior restoration work continued through 2023 with +the completion of phase 2 (south) and phase 3 (north) north façades. In FY 2024, assuming adequate +funding, Phase 4 work will commence and, in FY 2025, with this requested funding, work on Phase 5 +will commence. + +The MT Building houses the entire chilled water plant for the Main Treasury Complex. A five cell +cooling tower feeds four water cooled centrifugal chillers providing a total cooling capacity of 2,050 +tons. The chillers are located in a mechanical room under the northwest lawn. The four chillers provide +over 98% of the cooling required for the entire Treasury Headquarters complex; therefore, the plant is +operated 24/7, 365 days per year. The Freedman’s Bank Building (FBB) does not generate chilled +water but rather uses chilled water from the main plant distributed by a dedicated secondary chilled +water pump which serves most air handling units directly. The Chilled Water System is over 30 years +old and has a wide variety of repair needs including bearings, motors, valves, distribution piping, +insulation, controls, and other repairs. The system has redundancy for repairs. However, with all of the +components aging at the same time the occurrence of repair needs combined with the time to repair +diminishes the reliability of the redundant capacity. It is imperative that these items are +repaired/replaced before the available redundancy is lost. A system breakdown would indefinitely +shutdown the Treasury Complex’s daily operations. This first-year cost of a multi-year project includes +design for this effort. + +There is currently a backlog of damaged paint and plaster as well as frayed carpet throughout MT and +FBB. Some of the paint and plaster damage is due to water intrusion. These funds will supplement +other funding to address the backlog in repairing these problems and implementing a regular schedule +of maintenance. The damaged paint and plaster are unsightly and pose potential health and safety risks, +while the frayed carpet is a safety hazard. + +20 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -oftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Volume -1: LongPapers),pp.16173–16188,2025. -11 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q22/random_k4/question.json b/q22/random_k4/question.json index ddc56fe6b570b6cc7778c005cdc3aab7e649cbaf..3727442546a6464d7a2071129569be227e7ce230 100644 --- a/q22/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q22/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "watch_d.pdf", - "web_5ba1faa4f8b60c76.pdf", - "8479d6a14809b60b1850209bf7f393998a818837.pdf", - "web_81710007d7992b9d.pdf", - "web_b4009fe9cbb76c2a.pdf" + "web_949ca008fd6aab55.pdf", + "resize_r2_4.pdf", + "resize_r1_33.pdf", + "resize_r2_5.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q22/random_k4/random_1.md b/q22/random_k4/random_1.md index 35d753e173e665d80fac0b41039f9a77a81ccbdd..7dc052f723cc7f2c4f76f8f2c1434e638752d4c4 100644 --- a/q22/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q22/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,2223 +1,826 @@ -Graduate Student -Handbook - -Colorado State University -Fort Collins, CO 80523-1472 - - CONTENTS - -INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................................... 5 - -NEW STUDENTS ..................................................................................................................................................... 6 - -THINGS YOU NEED TO DO RIGHT NOW! ......................................................................................................................... 6 -Register for classes ........................................................................................................................................ 6 -Establish residency ........................................................................................................................................ 7 -Update your contact information ................................................................................................................... 7 -Establish a WCNR Computer Account ............................................................................................................. 8 -Get a RamCard (CSU identification Card) ........................................................................................................ 8 -Still looking for housing? ................................................................................................................................ 8 - -GENERAL PROGRAM INFORMATION ...................................................................................................................... 9 - -MASTER OF SCIENCE (MS)........................................................................................................................................ 9 -Types of MS Degrees...................................................................................................................................... 9 -MS Course Requirements ............................................................................................................................... 9 -MASTER OF NATURAL RESOURCES STEWARDSHIP (MNRS) ............................................................................................. 11 -Coursework Intensive ................................................................................................................................... 11 -MNRS Course Requirements......................................................................................................................... 11 -DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (PHD) ............................................................................................................................... 11 -PhD Course Requirements ............................................................................................................................ 12 - -GETTING AN ADVANCED DEGREE ......................................................................................................................... 13 - -ADMISSION ......................................................................................................................................................... 13 -THE ADVISOR ...................................................................................................................................................... 14 -GRADUATE COMMITTEE ......................................................................................................................................... 14 -PROGRAM OF STUDY ............................................................................................................................................. 15 -Cultural Requirements ................................................................................................................................. 15 -S/U Grading (Pass-Fail) ................................................................................................................................ 15 -SATISFACTORY STANDARDS ..................................................................................................................................... 16 -Satisfactory Academic Performance ............................................................................................................. 16 -Satisfactory Progress ................................................................................................................................... 16 -RESEARCH PROPOSAL ............................................................................................................................................ 20 -PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION ................................................................................................................................... 21 -DISSERTATION, THESIS, OR PROFESSIONAL PAPER ......................................................................................................... 21 -Publications ................................................................................................................................................. 22 -Copyright .................................................................................................................................................... 22 -FINAL EXAMINATION (DEFENSE) ............................................................................................................................... 23 -APPLICATION FOR GRADUATION ............................................................................................................................... 23 -COMPLETION OF DEGREE REQUIREMENTS IN ABSENTIA .................................................................................................. 24 -GRADUATE SCHOOL FORMS .................................................................................................................................... 24 -CONTINUOUS REGISTRATION ................................................................................................................................... 24 -ACADEMIC DISHONESTY ......................................................................................................................................... 25 -Plagiarism, Citing, and the Student Writing Center ....................................................................................... 25 -PROBATION ......................................................................................................................................................... 26 -DISMISSAL .......................................................................................................................................................... 26 -STUDENT ACADEMIC APPEALS POLICY AND PROCEDURE ................................................................................................. 26 - -TUITION, FUNDING, AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE ............................................................................................... 27 - -TUITION AND FEES ................................................................................................................................................ 27 - - RESIDENCY .......................................................................................................................................................... 27 -FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE .......................................................................................................................................... 27 -Scholarships ................................................................................................................................................ 28 -Graduate Assistantships .............................................................................................................................. 28 - -DEPARTMENT INFORMATION .............................................................................................................................. 29 - -FRS DEPARTMENT OFFICE ...................................................................................................................................... 29 -OFFICE SUPPLIES .................................................................................................................................................. 29 -OFFICE SPACE ...................................................................................................................................................... 29 -KEYS .................................................................................................................................................................. 30 -PHONES ON CAMPUS ............................................................................................................................................. 30 -MAIL ................................................................................................................................................................. 30 -CONFERENCE ROOMS ............................................................................................................................................ 30 -COPY MACHINES .................................................................................................................................................. 31 -CONTACT INFORMATION ........................................................................................................................................ 31 - -ACADEMIC, RESEARCH AND TEACHING SUPPORT SERVICES................................................................................. 31 - -COMPUTER SERVICES ............................................................................................................................................. 31 -Computer Accounts ..................................................................................................................................... 31 -Computer Labs ............................................................................................................................................ 31 -Computer Services at Morgan Library .......................................................................................................... 32 -Academic Computing and Networking Services (ACNS) ................................................................................. 32 -MORGAN LIBRARY, PROSPECTOR, AND INTERLIBRARY LOAN ............................................................................................ 32 -Library Homepage and Important Phone Numbers ....................................................................................... 32 -Warner College of Natural Resources Liaison Librarian ................................................................................. 32 -Access from Off-Campus: CSU Secure Network ............................................................................................. 33 -Library Books, Journal, and More… .............................................................................................................. 33 -RESEARCH INTEGRITY AND COMPLIANCE REVIEW OFFICE ................................................................................................ 33 -GREENHOUSE SPACE ............................................................................................................................................. 34 -FRANKLIN A. GRAYBILL STATISTICAL LABORATORY ......................................................................................................... 34 -COMMITMENT OF FUNDS ....................................................................................................................................... 34 -UNIVERSITY PROPERTY ........................................................................................................................................... 34 -DATA OWNERSHIP AND ARCHIVING ........................................................................................................................... 34 -STATE-OWNED MOTOR VEHICLES............................................................................................................................. 35 -TRAVEL .............................................................................................................................................................. 35 - -SAFETY ON CAMPUS ............................................................................................................................................ 35 - -LABORATORY AND EQUIPMENT SAFETY ...................................................................................................................... 35 -THEFT ................................................................................................................................................................ 35 -EMERGENCY TEXT MESSAGING ALERT SERVICE ............................................................................................................ 36 -SAFEWALK.......................................................................................................................................................... 36 -TELL SOMEONE/PUBLIC SAFETY ............................................................................................................................... 36 -RAMRIDE ............................................................................................................................................................ 36 -WEST NILE VIRUS ................................................................................................................................................. 36 -TULAREMIA ......................................................................................................................................................... 37 - -TRANSPORTATION ON CAMPUS .......................................................................................................................... 37 - -BIKING ON CAMPUS .............................................................................................................................................. 37 -PARKING ON CAMPUS ............................................................................................................................................ 37 -PARKING OFF CAMPUS ........................................................................................................................................... 37 -TAKING THE BUS .................................................................................................................................................. 38 - -UNIVERSITY SERVICES .......................................................................................................................................... 38 - -OFF CAMPUS LIFE ................................................................................................................................................. 38 -CSU HEALTH NETWORK ......................................................................................................................................... 38 -CONFLICT RESOLUTION SERVICES .............................................................................................................................. 38 -STUDENT LEGAL SERVICES ....................................................................................................................................... 38 - - CAREER CENTER LIAISON ........................................................................................................................................ 39 -ADULT LEARNERS/VETERAN SERVICES ........................................................................................................................ 39 -STUDENT DISABILITY CENTER ................................................................................................................................... 39 -WOMEN AND GENDER ADVOCACY CENTER ................................................................................................................. 40 -ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS ON CAMPUS ................................................................................................................... 40 - -EQUAL OPPORTUNITY .......................................................................................................................................... 41 - -SEXUAL HARASSMENT ......................................................................................................................................... 41 - -APPENDIX I: FORMAT OF A RESEARCH PROPOSAL ............................................................................................... 42 - -APPENDIX II: GRADUATE STUDENT TIME TABLE ................................................................................................... 43 - - INTRODUCTION - -The objective of the Graduate Student Handbook is to present general policies -and procedures for obtaining an advanced degree in the Forest & Rangeland -Stewardship (FRS) Department at Colorado State University (CSU). This -handbook supplements and reemphasizes the information provided to graduate -students in the CSU Graduate and Professional Bulletin and the CSU General -Catalog. Its intent is to familiarize incoming graduate students with the -procedures and minimum standards for graduate studies in the FRS Department -(note that the student's graduate committee might augment these minimum -requirements). The administration of a student's program by his/her graduate -committee follows the regulations of the Graduate School as outlined in the -current Graduate and Professional Bulletin. - -The educational objective of the FRS Department is to produce excellent leaders -in the fields of forest and rangeland stewardship. The goal of graduate study is to -develop individual capacity for independent scholarship and critical thought. The -department, its faculty, and the University provide the atmosphere, physical -resources, and counsel necessary to attain these ends. Students admitted to the -department for graduate study will receive the assistance and advice of the -faculty to attain their educational objectives. While graduate students enjoy more -privileges than undergraduate students do, they also accept greater personal -responsibilities. Although faculty members are available for consultation, -graduate students must assume a major role in developing and carrying out their -graduate studies. - - 5 - - NEW STUDENTS - -THINGS YOU NEED TO DO RIGHT NOW! - -Register for classes -• You must first obtain your eID before you can access RAMweb. You can - -obtain your eID at this web site: https://eid.colostate.edu. - -• Every semester you must complete “Registration Ready” (also on RAMweb) - -before you will be able to register. This is a series of questions regarding your -contact information, billing address, etc. - -• If you register on or after the first day of the semester, you will be charged a - -$50 late registration fee. - -• The class schedule is on-line and accessible at https://ramweb.colostate.edu/. - -You will also register for on-campus classes from this site. Some course -prefixes that are of interest to our students include: RS (Rangeland -Ecosystems), F (Forest Sciences), WR (Watershed Sciences), NR (Natural -Resources), ECOL (Ecology), ESS (Ecosystem Science and Sustainability), -FW (Fish and Wildlife), SOCR (Soil and Crop Sciences), GR (Geography, -including remote sensing and GIS), STAT (Statistics), ED (education). You -can find a full listing in the CSU catalog, available here: -http://catalog.colostate.edu/general-catalog/ - -• Most semesters there is an extensive listing of ECOL 592 sections. These are -seminars offered through the Graduate Degree Program in Ecology (GDPE). -Each section will cover a different topic; topics offered vary from one semester -to the next and they often add sections and topics right before the term starts. -To see a listing of current ECOL 592 topic areas, visit the GDPE website: -https://ecology.colostate.edu/ecol-592-interdisciplinary-seminar/ - -• Graduate level courses are numbered 500 and higher. Graduate students may -count a certain number of courses at the 300-level and 400-level towards their -degree. Courses at the 100 and 200-level will not count towards a graduate -degree, although you may still enroll in them. - -• Pay attention to the course pre-requisites when choosing classes. These are -guidelines to help you ensure you have the background needed to perform -well in a course, but they do not affect your ability to register for a course. If -you are unsure if your academic preparation is sufficient for a course, email -the instructor and ask them their opinion. - -• For courses with multiple required components (e.g. a lecture with a required -lab and/or recitation), you must add all required components to your schedule -at the same time. Trying to add a lecture without the required lab will result in -an error message. - - 6 - - • Variable credit courses require departmental permission. These include: - -research credits, thesis and dissertation credits, independent study credits, -group study credits, internship credits, and supervised college teaching -credits. If you try to register for these without departmental permission, you will -be directed to get departmental permission. To get departmental permission, -complete the Variable Credit Override Form available here: -http://warnercnr.colostate.edu/frs-graduate-study/curriculum. After submitting -the form, you will be emailed when you can register. - -Establish residency - -If your out-of-state tuition was waived for the first year of your studies, it is -your responsibility to achieve residency by the time your second year -starts. Your advisor will not remind you, and your assistantship will not cover the -additional expense of out-of-state tuition during your second year. - -To establish residency, you must: a) reside in Colorado permanently for at least -one year and intend to make Colorado your permanent domicile, and b) petition -for residency. The petition process requires extensive documentation. - -To receive in-state tuition, you must establish residency before the semester -starts; therefore, you must begin the process a year before the semester starts. -Take steps towards establishing residency immediately: - -• View the online residency orientation in RAMweb or attend one of the -tuition classification orientations offered through the CSU Financial -Services (https://financialaid.colostate.edu/residency-orientations/) as -soon as you arrive on campus. - -• Get a Colorado driver’s license (1121 W. Prospect, Suite D) -• Register to vote in Colorado (1121 W. Prospect, Suite D) -• Register your car (100 West Oak Street) -• Save documents that provide proof of residency, e.g. checks that you - -used to pay rent, rent statements, utility statements, lease agreements, -etc. These should go back a year prior to the first day of the semester you -hope to be considered a resident. - -For more detailed information about the filing of a petition for Colorado residency, -including the exact date by which a domicile needs to be established and -deadlines to petition for residency, visit the Tuition Classification Office website : -http://sfs.colostate.edu/residency/), Centennial Hall, (970) 491-6321. - -Update your contact information -The University will use the mailing address, telephone number, and email -address associated with your eID to contact you. Check your contact information -in RAMweb (https://ramweb.colostate.edu/) and update anything that needs to be - - 7 - - changed. To change your information, after logging in to RAMweb, use the links -under “Records” on the bottom right hand corner of the screen. - -Establish a WCNR Computer Account -WCNR requires its own computer account to log into the college network and -access network drives, printers, etc. The account creation process is completely -automated and can be accessed as soon as your eID is active. Just log in using -your eID at https://accounts.warnercnr.colostate.edu and you'll be guided through -the process. From the IT Support website (http://warnercnr.colostate.edu/it- -support-home) you can access the large attachment mailer, remotely connect to -a WCNR PC lab, learn about the five free copies of Office 365 that you are -allowed as a student, or use the online help desk form. If you need help using the -WCNR network resources, or have any other computer related questions, submit -a ticket to the Natural Resources IT Support Center at -https://warnercnr.colostate.edu/helpdesk/. Notice that there is a “Frequently -Asked Questions” section for Office 365 here: -http://warnercnr.colostate.edu/office-365 - -Get a RamCard (CSU identification Card) -You will need a RamCard to: check out books from the library, use the Student -Rec Center, use Transfort/MAX (the city bus system), buy student tickets, get the -student discount at the movies, to name a few. If you will live on campus and -have a meal plan, your RamCard will also act as your entry card to the dining -centers on campus. If you choose, you can create a RamCash account that will -allow you to purchase food, beverages or services on campus using your -RamCard, or upgrade to a RamCard Plus, which also acts as a Visa debit/ATM -card. Please acquaint yourself with these options before getting your RamCard: -http://www.housing.colostate.edu/ramcarduses. -RamCards are issued at the RamCard Office in room 271 of Lory Student Center -(http://www.housing.colostate.edu/get-a-ramcard). You will also need to have on -you one of the following forms of identification: passport, driver's license, state -identification card, or military ID. You will get your picture taken when getting -your RamCard, so remember to smile! - -Still looking for housing? -If you are currently looking for housing, Off Campus Life -(https://ocl.colostate.edu/) has a website with many helpful features. Under the -“Off Campus Housing” link you can search a database of rental listings for -vacancies, sublets, roommates needed, and roommates available. You may also -create your own entry in the database. - - 8 - - GENERAL PROGRAM INFORMATION - -MASTER OF SCIENCE (MS) - -Master of Science (MS) graduate programs are available in Rangeland -Ecosystem Science and Forest Sciences. - -Rangeland Ecosystem Science areas of study include: soil-plant relations, -riparian ecology and management, restoration ecology, grazing and weed -management, and community based resource management. - -Forest Sciences areas of study include: fire ecology and management, forest -biometry, forest ecology, forest economics, forest ecosystem management, -forest restoration, natural resource policy, quantitative analysis of natural -resources, silviculture, spatial landscape analysis, wood products. - -Types of MS Degrees - -Thesis and Professional Paper -The Department offers two types of MS programs: the thesis option and the -professional paper option. - -The thesis option emphasizes research. In partial fulfillment of degree -requirements, the student is required to conduct research approved by their -graduate committee and to present the results in a thesis. If the student is -supported by a research assistantship, the thesis is ordinarily related to this -support. - -The professional paper option emphasizes course work and professional -preparation. The student must submit a professional paper based on literature -reviews, surveys, and other sources of information to the graduate committee as -partial fulfillment of degree requirements. The student’s graduate committee must -approve the topic for the professional paper. - -MS Course Requirements -Completion of the MS degree generally requires at least two years of full-time -work beyond the bachelor's degree. Master’s students must take at least 30 -credits of formal coursework at the 300-level or higher (see Table 1). Most -graduate students take from nine to 12 credit hours of regular1 course work (not - -1 Regular course work is defined as courses other than independent or group studies, research -courses, open seminars, thesis/dissertation credits, study abroad, U.S. travel, supervised college -Footnote continued on next page. - - 9 - - including research credits) each academic semester. Because students on -assistantships agree to commit part of their time to required duties, they may -need more time to meet degree requirements. Additionally, graduate work may -require undergraduate courses as prerequisites. Although students may take -courses at the 100 and 200-level, courses below the 300-level are not accepted -for credit toward a graduate degree. Therefore, students lacking the prerequisites -for their Program of Study may require more time and credits to earn their -degree. Finally, it is important to note that not every course is offered every -semester. A student may opt to prolong their studies in order to take a course -that is particularly relevant to their field of study. - -Table 1. University course requirements for Master’s programs - -Minimum credits in 300 or higher level courses -Minimum credits earned at CSU -Minimum credits earned after admission to -Graduate School -Minimum credits earned at CSU in 500 or higher -level courses -Minimum credits earned at CSU in 500 or higher -level regular courses - -MS -30 -24 -21 - -16 - -12 - -MNRS -30 -24 -21 - -21 - -12 - -A minimum of 24 credits must be earned at Colorado State University, 21 of -which must be earned after admission to the Graduate School. Required courses -listed on the program of study may not be taken on a “student option pass/fail” -basis. For the MS degrees, at least 16 credits earned at CSU must be in 500- -level or higher courses, and at least 12 of these credits must be in regular -courses. Other courses may be at the 300- or 400-level, or may be in seminars, -independent study, supervised college teaching, internship, research, and thesis -or dissertation. - -All graduate students in the MS and PhD programs are required to register for -the department graduate seminar one semester each year they are working on -their Program of Study. The seminar is offered in the Spring as NR 592-005, RS -693 or F 693. - -teaching, student teaching, practicum, internship, field placement, unique title courses offered -through Continuing Education, and any courses graded pass/fail. - - 10 - - MASTER OF NATURAL RESOURCES STEWARDSHIP -(MNRS) - -Coursework Intensive -The Master of Natural Resources Stewardship (MNRS) is a coursework- -intensive, non-thesis, professional master's degrees. Students in this program -receive a broad natural resources training and specialized resource management -skills in one of three core specialties: 1) ecological restoration, 2) forest sciences, -and 3) rangeland ecology and management. - -MNRS Course Requirements -The MNRS degree can be completed in three semesters of full-time course work. -Master’s students must take at least 30 credits of formal coursework at the 300- -level or higher (see Table 1). Most full time graduate students take from nine to -12 credit hours of regular course work each academic semester. Because -students on assistantships agree to commit part of their time to required duties, -they may need more time to meet degree requirements. Additionally, graduate -work may require undergraduate courses as prerequisites. Although students -may take courses at the 100 and 200-level, courses below the 300-level are not -accepted for credit toward a graduate degree. Therefore, students lacking the -prerequisites for their Program of Study may require more time and credits to -earn their degree. Finally, it is important to note that not every course is offered -every semester. A student may opt to prolong their studies in order to take a -course that is particularly relevant to their field of study. - -A minimum of 24 credits must be earned at Colorado State University, 21 of -which must be earned after admission to the Graduate School. For the MNRS -degree, at least 21 credits earned at CSU must be in 500-level or higher courses, -and at least 12 of those credits must be in regular courses. For the MNRS, no -independent study, research, internship, supervised college teaching, or -practicum credits may be credited toward the degree. - -Students in the MNRS program are required to complete the common MNRS -core in addition to nine credits selected from their area of specialization. For a -complete description of the MNRS course requirements, please see the MNRS -Program Requirements Handbook available on the department webpage. - -DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (PHD) -The Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree is the highest graduate degree offered at -Colorado State University. A student working toward a PhD degree is expected -to produce independent research that contributes significantly to science and to -present the results of such research in a written dissertation. This program leads -to a high degree of specialization. - - 11 - - PhD Course Requirements -The PhD program is based on an area of specialization in research and intensive -course work. A PhD program often requires five years of full-time work beyond -the bachelor's degree, or three years beyond the MS degree to complete. It -requires a minimum of 72 semester credits beyond the bachelor's degree at the -300-level or higher (see Table 2). The graduate committee my set additional -requirements, depending on the student's background and interests. Many -students take more than the minimum requirements, because they wish to -pursue special fields in greater depth. In addition, the graduate committee may -feel that the student needs a broader exposure, or some undergraduate courses, -to complement their education. Because students on assistantships agree to -commit part of their time to required duties, they may need more time to meet -degree requirements. - -Table 2. University course requirements for PhD programs - -PhD -with no -prior -master’s -degree -72 - -- - -10 - -62 - -37 - -PhD with -prior -master’s -degree - -Continuous -Master’s/PhD -program at -CSU - -72 - -30 - -10 - -32 - -21 - -72 - -All - -10 - -- - -21 - -Minimum credits in 300 or higher level -courses -Maximum credits accepted from master’s -degree program -Maximum prior admission regular credits -not earned in conjunction with MS -Minimum credits earned after admission to -doctoral program -Minimum credits earned at CSU in 500 or -higher level courses (includes both prior -admission and after admission courses; -credits need not be in regular courses) - -Of the 72 credits required, 48 should be in courses in the area of specialization or -related fields. Required courses listed on the program of study may not be taken -on a “student-option pass-fail” basis. At least 21 credits of the courses beyond -the MS degree, or 37 credits beyond the bachelor's degree, shall be in graduate -(500-level or higher) courses. The number of earned credits required after a -student is admitted to a PhD program depends on whether the student has a -prior master’s degree, and whether the student is enrolled in a continuous -master’s/PhD program: - -• Students entering a PhD program without first earning a master’s degree -must earn a minimum of 62 credits at Colorado State University after -admission to the doctoral program. - - 12 - - • Students entering a PhD program with a prior master’s degree must earn -a minimum of 32 credits at Colorado State University after admission to -the doctoral program. The student’s graduate committee may accept 30 -semester credits earned in an MS program at an accredited institution -towards meeting the PhD credit requirements. - -• Students enrolled in a continuous master’s/PhD program (e.g. those who -enter a PhD program the fall or spring semester immediately following -receipt of a Colorado State University master’s degree) may apply all of -the credits used towards their CSU master’s degree to their PhD degree, -even if these credits total more than 30. In this case, the student must -earn a minimum of 62 credits at CSU after being admitted to the master’s -degree. - -An additional 10 credits in regular courses earned after the award of the MS -degree may be transferred to Colorado State University and applied toward the -PhD degree, if approved by the student’s graduate committee. Courses below -300 are not accepted for credit toward a graduate degree. Graduate work may -require undergraduate courses as prerequisites. - -GETTING AN ADVANCED DEGREE - -ADMISSION - -The application process and admission requirements for MS, MNRS, and PhD -programs in the Department are described in detail on the Department website. -Recipients of MS degrees from the FRS Department who wish to continue in a -PhD program must reapply to the department. The application will consist of the -student's existing file plus a personal essay describing the PhD program the -student wishes to pursue, and one or more letters of recommendation, including -one from the student's graduate advisor for the MS degree. - -The Council of Graduate Schools in the United States has accepted the following -resolution regarding scholars, fellows, trainees, and graduate assistants. -Colorado State University is a member of this council. - -Acceptance of an offer of a graduate scholarship, a fellowship, -traineeship, or graduate assistantship for the next academic year by an -actual or prospective graduate student completes an agreement which -both the student and the Graduate School expect to honor. In those -instances in which the student indicates his/her acceptance prior to April -15 and subsequently desires to change his/her plans, the student may -submit in writing a resignation of his/her appointment at any time through -April 15 in order to accept another scholarship, fellowship, traineeship, or -graduate assistantship. However, an acceptance given or left in force after - - 13 - - April 15 commits him/her to not accepting another appointment without -first obtaining formal release for this purpose. - -Additional admission information is available in the CSU Graduate and -Professional Bulletin. - -THE ADVISOR - -Each advisor has a unique approach to advising graduate students. Some -advisors want frequent interaction with their students, whereas others expect -students to operate with greater independence. To insure the best possible -guidance, you should discuss expectations with your advisor. Applicants are -encouraged to talk to current graduate students of a potential advisor to ensure -the best match in working styles and expectations. - -The advisor chairs the student's graduate committee and is normally a -recognized authority in the general area of the student's principal academic -interest. The advisor counsels the student in research and in writing the thesis, -dissertation, or professional paper. The advisor also assists the student with -course selection and registration. The advisor helps the student with all problems -related to the study program. The advisor notifies committee members of -committee meetings and must advise all department faculty and graduate -students of the date and location of the thesis or dissertation defense at least one -week prior to the defense. - -Co-advisors may share the responsibilities for advising a graduate student, but if -the co-advisor is from outside the FRS Department, the advisor must be from -within the FRS Department. In all such cases, the latter will have ultimate -responsibility for the student's progress. - -If circumstances are such that the student needs or desires a different advisor, -the student should consult with the department head. The student should consult -their advisor regarding changes to their other committee members. Students -should promptly file the GS Form 9A Petition for Committee Member Changes -with the Graduate School in the event that they do change their committee -members. - -GRADUATE COMMITTEE - -The graduate committee is an administrative unit of the Graduate School -assigned to aid, advise, and supervise the graduate student's study program. -This committee guides the student throughout the graduate program. It aids in -the development of the student's Program of Study, including the research plan. -The graduate committee also administers the preliminary examination (PhD only) -and final examination or defense (MS and PhD). The student should feel free to -seek the counsel and advice of individual committee members at any time. - - 14 - - The student and advisor should select a graduate committee as soon as -possible, and no later than the second semester of study. The MS program -committee consists of a minimum of three members, including the advisor, while -a PhD committee is composed of a minimum of four members, including the -advisor. All committee members must hold terminal degrees or have equivalent -experience and have appropriate graduate faculty standing. Two committee -members must be faculty in the FRS Department. At least one committee -member must be from outside the department. The outside member is to provide -expertise not found in the Program of Study and represents the Graduate School. - -Discussions and meetings between the graduate student and committee -members may result in modification of the original research plan. It is the -student's responsibility to keep members of the graduate committee informed -about progress and changes in research efforts. Students should meet with -committee members during each term of residency. - -PROGRAM OF STUDY -After forming the committee, the advisor will convene the committee to consider -the student's proposed Program of Study. Following approval of this program by -the committee and the department head, the student submits the official Program -of Study (GS Form 6) to the Graduate School. The GS Form 6 is due in the -Graduate School office by the end of the third semester of study. Students will -not be allowed to register for their forth semester until the GS Form 6 is -submitted to the Graduate School. It is the responsibility of each graduate -student to know and meet registration and Graduate School deadlines. - -Students do not need to list courses taken for credit in excess of the minimum -required by the graduate committee their GS Form 6. Note, however, that all -regular courses taken at Colorado State are included in the GPA calculation. -Regular courses listed on the GS Form 6 are required and the student must take -them for a letter grade. The department head will sign the GS Form 6 once the -graduate advisor has signed it. The students must get their committee’s approval -for any deviations from the Program of Study and must report these deviations -on the Application for Graduation (GS Form 25). - -Cultural Requirements -Generally, no additional requirements are set if the student has taken some -courses of a cultural nature for the baccalaureate degree. - -S/U Grading (Pass-Fail) -Students may not take required courses listed on the Program of Study (GS -Form 6) on a “student option pass-fail” basis. Courses offered “pass-fail only” or -“instructor-option pass-fail” are acceptable. No more than six credits earned with -a grade of ‘S’ in courses other than research, thesis or dissertation, and seminar -may be counted toward meeting credit requirements for the MS or PhD degrees. - - 15 - - The acceptance of formal courses graded ‘S’ or ‘C’ to satisfy degree -requirements are at the discretion of the student's graduate committee. - -SATISFACTORY STANDARDS -Graduate students are expected to meet two standards in their course of study: -• Satisfactory Performance refers to the requirement of minimum grade - -performance in course work, and the passage of the required written and -oral examinations. - -• Satisfactory Progress refers to the speed and timeliness of progression - -through course work and required written and oral examinations. - -Satisfactory Academic Performance -The Graduate & Professional Bulletin outlines the required standards that must -be met by all graduate students under the Scholastic Standards section. What -follows is a brief introduction to some of standards; it is not exhaustive. Students -are advised to review the standards in the Bulletin and understand the -implications of unsatisfactory performance. - -Graduate School minimum scholastic standards require that the student maintain -a 3.0 grade point average in formal course work and a 3.0 grade point average or -S in research, thesis or dissertation, and seminars. Courses graded D, F, I, U, -WP (withdrawn passing), and WF (withdrawn failing) are not accepted toward -meeting degree requirements. Grades of D, F, U, and WF are included in -calculation of a student's grade point average. The grade point average is based -on all formal courses for which a student registers, including those not listed on -the Program of Study (GS Form 6). - -The Graduate School reviews the scholastic performance of each graduate -student at the end of each semester. If the student has not met the required -standards, the Graduate School initiates any necessary changes in the student's -status. A student whose GPA in either regular courses or non-regular or informal -courses (300-level and above) has dropped below 3.0 is placed on academic -probation and has one semester to raise the GPA to 3.0. The grade point -average in those courses included on the GS Form 6 must also equal at least -3.0. Students on an assistantship who are put on academic probation will lose -their assistantship. The assistantship can be reinstated if the student is back in -good standing the semester following the probation. If the student's GPA has not -reached a 3.0 at the end of the probationary semester, the student is dismissed -by the university. - -Satisfactory Progress -For students to remain in good academic standing, they must make satisfactory -progress toward their degree completion. While graduate study is often flexible, -there are time limits for graduate programs. Students who fail to progress and -complete requirements within this time frame may lose their teaching or research - - 16 - - assistantship (which requires satisfactory progress toward a degree as a -condition of employment) and/or be dismissed from the program - -The following general guidelines reflect reasonable milestones of satisfactory -progress for MS, MNRS, and PhD students as they progress through graduate -program. These guidelines are general, and not necessarily exhaustive. PLEASE -NOTE that each student should individually discuss these expectations explicitly -with their advisor, so that there is mutual understanding about specific -expectations for the student. - -Time Limits for the MS Degree -MS students are expected to complete the MS degree requirements within three -(3) years of beginning graduate study. If a student’s program of study will take -longer than this, the student must submit a projected timeline that includes -measurable goals and is approved by their advisor and committee. A signed -copy of this agreement will be placed in the student’s department file. - -The following is the expected timeline for MS students. Unless a plan has already -been agreed upon as described above, failure to adhere to this projected timeline -renders the student at risk for unsatisfactory progress. - -Semester 1 Discuss with the advisor a plan of coursework and enroll in first -courses. Discuss potential graduate committee members, and a -plan for the thesis project. Review the literature on the thesis topic. - -Semester 2 Select graduate committee members, prepare research proposal, - -and hold committee meeting to approve research study plan. -Submit GS-6 form to the department for review and approval and -then submit to the Graduate School by the end of the second -semester. Initiate research and data collection. - -Semester 3 Perform data analysis from research activities. NOTE: Graduate -students must select their graduate committee and submit a GS6 -before registration begins for their fourth regular semester. Failure -to do so will result in a hold being placed on their account that -prevents them from registering for their fourth semester. - -Semester 4 Complete research; begin to write thesis and a draft manuscript - -from the research for a professional journal. - -Semester 4+. Complete thesis and defend, and submit manuscript for publication - -in a professional journal if applicable. - -Time Limits for the MNRS Degree -Full time MNRS students are expected to complete the MNRS degree -requirements within two (2) years of beginning graduate study. Part time MNRS -students are expected to complete the MNRS degree within five (5) years of part -time study. If a student’s program of study will take longer than this, the student -must submit a projected timeline that includes measurable goals and is approved -by their advisor. A copy of this signed agreement will be placed in the student’s -department file. - - 17 - - Time Limits for the PhD Degree -PhD students are expected to pass the Preliminary Examination (admitted to -candidacy) by the end of the sixth semester; their course requirements in 5 to 6 -semesters; and pass the Final Oral Examination before completing eleven (11) -semesters. Additional university requirements regarding the timing of the -Preliminary Examination or reexamination and the Final Oral Examination are -described in the Graduate and Professional Bulletin. PhD students are required -to submit an approved proposal within a year after being admitted to candidacy. -If a student’s program of study will take longer than this, the student must submit -a projected timeline that includes measurable goals and is approved by their -advisor and committee. A copy of this signed agreement will be placed in the -student’s department file. - -The following is the expected timeline for PhD students. Unless a plan has -already been agreed upon as described above, failure to adhere to this projected -timeline renders the student at risk for unsatisfactory progress. - -Semester 1 Discuss with the advisor a plan of coursework and enroll in first -courses. Discuss potential graduate committee members, and a -plan for the dissertation project. Review the literature on the -dissertation topic. - -Semester 2 Select graduate committee members, prepare research proposal, - -Semester 3 - -and hold committee meeting to approve research study plan. -Submit GS6 to the department for review and approval and then -submit to Graduate School by the end of the second semester. -Initiate research and data collection. NOTE: Graduate students -must select their graduate committee and submit a GS6 before -registration begins for their fourth regular semester. Failure to do so -will result in a hold being placed on their account that prevents -them from registering for their fourth semester. - -Semester 4 Conduct research and disseminate results at professional - -meetings. Prepare for preliminary exam. - -Semester 5 Conduct research and disseminate results at professional - -meetings. Complete preliminary exam. Dissertation research work. - -Semester 6+ Complete coursework and dissertation work. Defend PhD - -dissertation in public seminar held in home department. Write -manuscripts from dissertation and present key findings at a -professional meeting. - -Maximum Time Limit for a Graduate Degree -Independent of the Department’s guidelines for expected progress, the Graduate -School imposes a 10-year time limit for completion of the master’s or doctoral -degrees: - - 18 - - E.1.12 TIME LIMIT -There is a ten-year time limit for completion of the master’s or doctoral -degrees. Courses to be applied toward fulfilling the requirements for the -master’s and doctoral degrees, including any which may have been -transferred from another institution, must have been registered for and -completed within the ten years immediately preceding the date of -completion of requirements for the degrees. - -Expectations about Thesis or Dissertation - -At its core, a MS thesis or PhD dissertation is a document that both -demonstrates and follows the accepted principles and practices of scholarship. It -should provide the graduate committee evidence, in a well-written and internally -consistent document, of a student’s ability to: (1) plan and execute original and -substantive research; (2) rigorously analyze the results; (3) interpret these results -in the broader context of the field; and (4) logically argue a coherent thesis (a -hypothetical proposition or point of view) that is defensible, and ultimately, -provides new knowledge and understanding in their field. - -Other Measures of Satisfactory Progress -In addition, the Department expects that students will: - -• - -take 9-13 graduate credits each semester or be actively engaged in -research with their advisor; - -• meet with their advisor each semester; and -• submit a progress report at the end of every spring semester to their - -advisor and graduate committee, or as otherwise required. - -Unsatisfactory Academic Progress -Each graduate advisor will review the progress of their students annually to -ensure that unnecessary delays do not happen accidentally. Students whose -progress is deemed unsatisfactory or worrisome will be notified of these -concerns by their advisor. The graduate committee and the student will meet to -discuss the concerns and to create a progress plan, including a timeline that -includes measurable goals and outcomes, due dates, and the potential -consequences (dismissal) if the progress is not satisfactory. The committee will -provide regular feedback to the student during the progress plan timeline and -document such contacts and outcomes. At the end of the timeline, if progress is -not adequate, the committee may recommend the student for dismissal. The -recommendation will be reviewed by the Department Head and the Dean of the -Graduate School. - -Additionally, the Forest & Rangeland Stewardship Department Graduate -Program Committee will review the progress of all graduate students annually. -Students whose progress falls outside the satisfactory progress time limits will be -notified, along with their advisor, and required to submit a progress plan, -including a timeline with measurable goals and outcomes. The plan will be - - 19 - - approved by the student’s advisor, submitted to the Department Graduate -Program Committee and placed in the student’s file. - -Registration Requirement -Students in a graduate program are required to be enrolled every spring and fall -semester from the time of their admission until graduation, as described in the -Graduate and Professional Bulletin: - -E.1.13 CONTINUOUS REGISTRATION -All students admitted to a graduate program at Colorado State University -are required to be continuously registered in the fall and spring semester -throughout their degree programs. This policy applies from the time of first -enrollment through the graduation term. Students may fulfill this -requirement by registering for any graduate credit- bearing course (regular -or non-regular). As an alternative, students may opt for a Continuous -Registration (CR) status. - -If a student fails to register for credit or for continuous registration in a fall or -spring semester, their registration has lapsed and they are no longer considered -a degree-seeking student. If the student wishes to return to their graduate -program following a lapse in registration, a faculty member must first agree to -serve as advisor, and the student must submit a projected timeline that includes -measurable goals and is approved by advisor and committee (if one has been -designated). A signed copy of this agreement will be placed in the student’s -department file. Once these steps are complete the returning student must -submit the GS Form 1B to apply for readmission and pay the fee associated with -this form. This form and the associated fee must be submitted at least two weeks -prior to the term that the student plans to return. Once the application for -readmission is processed, the student must register for a course or for -continuous registration in order to be considered a degree-seeking student. - -RESEARCH PROPOSAL - -Research, including library research required for the professional paper, is an -essential part of graduate education. It provides the student the opportunity to -develop creativity and independence. A general statement of the research or -problem area will be prepared prior to selection of the student's committee and -acceptance of the Program of Study (GS Form 6) to aid in selection of a -committee and courses appropriate to the student's topic. Students in a PhD -program or thesis option MS program will propose a research program that is -approved by the student's committee prior to beginning research leading to the -thesis or dissertation. Students in a professional paper option MS program will -prepare an acceptable problem statement. For PhD degrees, the student’s -committee must approve the final proposal prior to the preliminary examination. -Research proposals must demonstrate accepted standards of scientific endeavor -on a subject judged by the committee to be worthy of scientific investigation. In -preparing the research plan, a student holding a research assistantship often - - 20 - - must consider specific research requirements stipulated in the agreement. -Usually, an MS student will have completed at least one semester of course work -before the student is prepared to write a final proposal; a PhD student will have -completed two or more semesters. Once the committee accepts the research -proposal, the advisor presents the proposal to the department head for review -and placement in the student's file in the department office. A suggested -proposal outline is included as an appendix to this handbook. - -PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION -A comprehensive preliminary examination is required of PhD candidates at least -two semesters before the final examination. The graduate committee administers -this examination to determine if the student has progressed satisfactorily in the -Program of Study and is qualified to be advanced to candidacy. The procedure is -to examine, in writing and orally, the chosen area of specialization and -supporting fields. Upon completion of the examination, the committee will review -the student's performance. A majority vote is necessary to pass; a tie vote -constitutes a failure. The student is responsible for obtaining a Report of -Preliminary Examination Results (GS Form 16) from the Graduate School -website and for returning it, appropriately completed, to the Graduate School -Office within two working days after the results of the examination are known. - -Upon recommendation of the graduate committee, and with permission of the -dean of the Graduate School, a student who fails the preliminary examination -may be granted one additional examination. The student may petition the -graduate committee for one re-examination no sooner than two months (unless -the student agrees to a shorter time period) and no later than 12 months after the -date of the first examination. Failure to pass the second exam results in dismissal -from the Graduate School. - -DISSERTATION, THESIS, OR PROFESSIONAL PAPER - -Research findings are presented in various forms: PhD students prepare a -dissertation; MS students prepare a thesis or professional paper. The preparation -of the dissertation, thesis, or professional paper is the most critical test of the -student's ability to clearly and accurately report research findings. The final -evaluation of the student for awarding the degree largely depends on this report. -The student should clearly understand the high quality of work required in -preparing and writing this report. - -The student should closely follow the Graduate School Thesis and Dissertation -Formatting Guide and the Thesis and Dissertation Submission guidelines posted -on the Graduate School website, as well as any technical writing manual or -existing theses suggested by the advisor. All drafts should be word processed, -and as nearly as possible in final form. The advisor will review the first and -subsequent drafts and determine when the report is in suitable form for -committee review. The student must provide a complete and final version of the - - 21 - - thesis, dissertation or professional paper to each committee member two weeks -before the date of the final examination (defense). Although this copy should be a -final version, the committee may request changes during the final examination. - -The standards of quality for the professional paper are the same as those -required for the thesis or dissertation. The format will be determined in -consultation with the advisor, but is usually the same as that required for the -thesis or dissertation. - -The dissertation, thesis, or professional paper must be approved by the student's -advisor and graduate committee, and finally by the department head. The -Graduate School requires that the student submit an electronic copy of the thesis -or dissertation (the Graduate School does not require a copy of a professional -paper) for inclusion in the digital repository of the William E. Morgan Library. -Students usually present a bound copy to the advisor, and the student may wish -to give copies to members of the graduate committee. Costs for copying, binding, -and filing theses, dissertations, and professional papers are borne by the -student. - -Upon submission of a PhD dissertation, payment for microfilming the abstract of -the PhD student's dissertation is required. Information on current fees is posted -on the Graduate School website. - -Publications -Publication of research results in a recognized journal is the responsibility of -each graduate student and advisor. The department encourages the use of a -format for the thesis or dissertation that facilitates the submission of manuscripts -for publication. It is acceptable to pattern the style and format of the thesis or -dissertation after a prominent journal or a potential outlet for the research. The -major advisor must approve the choice of style and format. - -Special permission may be required to publish data collected in an Agricultural -Experiment Station or other funded project. When research is conducted under -other financial arrangements, additional requirements may be made regarding -filing and publications. Advisors should have information regarding such arrange- -ments. - -The student may publish results of student non-sponsored research, alone or -jointly, with an advisor. Students and faculty should consider the ethics of proper -recognition for publication. It is usually desirable to establish publication -arrangements and authorship in advance. In most cases, the thesis or -dissertation advisor will publish jointly with the graduate student. - -Copyright -The Department promotes open exchange of information. Therefore, theses, -dissertations, and professional papers prepared as part of a student's - - 22 - - educational program may not be copyrighted or otherwise restricted without -explicit written approval of the student's committee and the department head. - -FINAL EXAMINATION (DEFENSE) -Final examinations for MS and PhD programs must occur prior to the end of the -11th week of the term of graduation (the end of the third week during the eight- -week summer term). The final examination takes the form of defense of the -thesis, professional paper, or dissertation. Examinations will be open to the -university faculty and graduate students. The advisor must notify all departmental -faculty and graduate students of the defense date, time, and location at least one -week prior to the exam. At the advisor's discretion, visitors may be invited to ask -questions about subject matter of the thesis or dissertation, but visitors are -generally required to leave prior to the committee's discussion of the candidate’s -performance. - -The examining committee is the graduate committee, with the advisor serving as -chairperson. Only committee members determine the outcome of the final -examination. A majority vote is necessary to pass; a tie vote constitutes a failure. -The examination will be concerned primarily with the professional paper, thesis, -or dissertation subject; however, additional subject matter, as specified by the -committee at the time of the preliminary examination, may also be covered. - -The graduate committee may require a student who fails the final examination to -complete further work. The student may petition the graduate committee for one -re-examination no sooner than two months, and no later than 12 months, after -the date of the first examination. - -The student is responsible for delivering the completed Report of Final -Examination (GS Form 24) to the Graduate School within two working days after -the results of the final examination are known. - -Procedures for the oral examination are outlined in the Graduate and -Professional Bulletin. All members of the graduate committee must participate. If -a committee member is not physically present, they will email the advisor -following the examination and report 1) how they participated and 2) what their -vote is. The chairperson (advisor) for the examining committee will make sure -each committee member has an equal opportunity to examine the candidate. - -APPLICATION FOR GRADUATION -The due dates for Application for Graduation (GS Form 25) are the sixth week of -graduation term for fall and spring semesters; and the first week of eight-week -summer term. Approval of these forms by the dean of the Graduate School -constitutes candidacy for graduation that semester. Students who don’t meet all -of their graduation requirements by the deadlines in the term they applied to -graduate must complete a Reapplication for Graduation for the semester he/she - - 23 - - actually receives the degree. The student should consult the Graduate and -Professional Bulletin and the FRS Graduate Program Coordinator (Sonya Le -Febre) for more detailed information on these forms. - -It should be noted that a student may complete all degree requirements in a -semester, yet miss these deadline dates set by the Graduate School. In this -case, the student may request a Certificate of Completion (GS Form 26) until the -degree appears on their transcripts. See also the section on Continuous -Registration below. - -COMPLETION OF DEGREE REQUIREMENTS IN -ABSENTIA -The student is encouraged to complete all degree requirements before leaving -campus. If extenuating circumstances exist, the student can petition the graduate -committee in writing for permission to complete a graduate degree in absentia. -When granting a student's request for completion of degree requirements in -absentia, the graduate committee will set a specific time in which the student -must complete his/her work. See also the section on Continuous Registration -below. - -GRADUATE SCHOOL FORMS -All of the forms required by the Graduate School are available on-line from their -website, along with instructions for completing them. The Graduate Program -Coordinator, Sonya Le Febre, will help students ensure they are completing the -forms correctly and can secure the Department Head’s signature. - -CONTINUOUS REGISTRATION - -All graduate students at Colorado State University are required to be -continuously registered in the fall and spring semesters throughout the duration -of their studies. Students normally fulfill this requirement by registering for -courses (regular or non-regular) at the 300-level or higher. Recognizing that for a -variety of reasons, students may not be on campus or actively advancing toward -their degree for one or more semesters, Colorado State has a continuous -registration policy. The policy defines a continuous registration fee of $150 per -semester for all students who will not be registered for academic courses. -Registration for CR status is accomplished in the same way as registering for -courses via RamWeb. Use “CR” to search the class schedule for continuous -registration. - -Subject to the established time limits for the earning of graduate degrees and the -various academic requirements, CR registrants need not apply for readmission -should they wish to take additional courses. Such students are assured a place -in their graduate programs as long as their academic performance is satisfactory. - - 24 - - For those students planning to be away from their academic program and who do -not register for academic courses or continuous registration, there is a $150 -readmission fee. - -The availability of the CR option shall not supersede any other registration -requirements to which students may be subject. For example, a student's -advisory committee may require additional course work. - -Students must be registered for a least one credit or Continuous Registration -(CR) in the term they earn their degree. - -Note: Neither audit registration nor continuous registration qualifies a student for -assistantship appointment. At least one hour of graduate, credit-bearing -registration is required for appointment to teaching assistants, research -assistants, and support assistants. - -ACADEMIC DISHONESTY -Students are expected to adhere to a high standard of ethics and conduct during -their graduate program of study and in their professional careers beyond. -Academic integrity consists of accomplishment and taking credit for one's own -work, and is an indispensable foundation for teaching, learning, and research. -Academic dishonesty undermines this foundation, and negatively affects morale -and the relationship among students and faculty. Examples of academic -dishonesty include providing or receiving unauthorized assistance, verbal or -written falsification in academic work or university documents, and the copying of -language or ideas of another without proper acknowledgment. Academic -dishonesty is not tolerated. Students guilty of academic dishonesty may be subject -to immediate dismissal or appropriate lesser penalty. Academic integrity and -dishonesty are more fully described in the CSU General Catalog. For a more -complete discussion of procedures related to academic dishonesty, refer to the -Graduate and Professional Bulletin. - -Plagiarism, Citing, and the Student Writing Center -The University does not tolerate plagiarism, whether it is intentional or accidental. -Unintentional plagiarism usually occurs because the writer’s understanding of -plagiarism is not complete, or because the writer lacks a systematic and efficient -way to collect and keep track of information that comes from different sources. -There are many bibliography management programs available (e.g. EndNote, -ProCite) that help writers keep track of information and make it easier to cite -sources and create bibliographies. - -The Writing Center at CSU is a helpful site that offers over 150 different writing -guides, as well as tutorials, extensive links to outside sources, and writing studio -classes and coops. This site also provides a password protected space to store -your writing, and the opportunity to get feedback on your writing. - - 25 - - PROBATION -The graduate advisory committee will periodically evaluate the student's progress -in the degree program, including both course work and research. If the -committee deems the student’s progress is unsatisfactory, the student will be -placed on academic probation for one semester. If the student's performance is -judged unsatisfactory by the student's graduate committee after the probationary -period, the student is subject to dismissal by the department or the Graduate -School. Probation is fully explained in the Graduate and Professional Bulletin. - -DISMISSAL - -The student's graduate committee may recommend immediate dismissal if that -student's progress in the graduate program is found to be unsatisfactory and if -satisfactory progress cannot reasonably be anticipated. Indicators of -unsatisfactory performance considered grounds for immediate dismissal include: -failure to submit a research proposal as required by the department; -unsatisfactory progress in the research as outlined in the research proposal; two -consecutive semesters with a grade of D, F, or U in thesis or dissertation or -research; or failure to submit the thesis or dissertation, or sections of the thesis -or dissertation, for review by the graduate committee. Recommendation and -documented justification for immediate dismissal is referred to the department -head for approval and to the dean of the Graduate School for final action. -Dismissal is fully explained in the Graduate and Professional Bulletin. - -STUDENT ACADEMIC APPEALS POLICY AND -PROCEDURE - -The faculty of the FRS Department recognizes the importance of resolving -student grievances in a timely and equitable manner. The faculty further -recognizes the right of students to appeal decisions to a higher administrative -level. It is, therefore, the policy of the department to provide a specific procedure -for dealing with grievances in a fair and impartial manner. The procedure is as -follows: - -1. Students are encouraged to consult with their academic advisor to clarify -the specifics of their grievances, discuss appropriate approaches to the -resolution of the issues, and to insure their understanding of the appeals -procedure. It is the responsibility of the student to initiate action to resolve -the grievance. - -2. A student should first present his/her grievance in an informal discussion -with the faculty member involved. If the student does not feel that a -satisfactory explanation or solution has been reached through these -discussions, the student may initiate a formal review of the grievance -following the procedure outlined in detail in the Academic Faculty and -Administrative Professional Manual which specifies the procedure for grade - - 26 - - appeals (see Academic and Legal Matters). This procedure is used for all -student grievances. - -3. If a student is not satisfied with results of informal discussions, the student - -may request that the department head form an academic appeals -committee to hear and review the complaint. If the student is not satisfied -with the decision of the department Academic Appeals Committee, the -student may appeal the committee's decision to the dean of the College of -Natural Resources. - -TUITION, FUNDING, AND FINANCIAL -ASSISTANCE - -TUITION AND FEES - -Graduate research assistants are assessed general fees and tuition; however, -some research or graduate teaching assistantships pay for in-state tuition or a -portion thereof. Unfunded students must pay tuition and general fees. - -RESIDENCY -Tuition for Colorado residents is considerably lower than tuition for non-residents. -All eligible students are expected to attain Colorado residency by the beginning -of their second year of graduate study. To establish residency, you must: a) -reside in Colorado permanently for at least one year and intend to make -Colorado your permanent domicile, and b) petition for residency. The petition -process requires extensive documentation. Students must be domiciled in -Colorado for the 12 consecutive months immediately preceding the first day of -classes to be able to petition for residency and resident tuition rates. It is highly -recommended that non-resident students educate themselves on residency -requirements and begin establishing a domicile in Colorado by obtaining a -Colorado driver’s license or other valid Colorado ID, registering their motor -vehicle in Colorado, and registering to vote in Colorado immediately upon arrival -in Colorado. The CSU Financial Services Tuition Classification site is very helpful -in explaining the residency petition process. In addition, Student Financial -Services holds residency orientation sessions every every first and third Tuesday -from 3:00-4:00 pm in room 100A of Centennial Hall. These are highly -recommended for students interested in petitioning for in-state residency. You -do not need to register for the orientation, but do show up on time. - -FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE -Information on financial assistance is located under Financial Resources on the -Graduate School web site and in the Graduate and Professional Bulletin. -Additionally, there are opportunities for students to work on research projects as - - 27 - - hourly employees. Availability of such opportunities varies; therefore, students -interested in such employment should contact faculty members or the -department office. - -Scholarships -The College of Natural Resources offers more than 130 scholarships ranging -from $450-$5,000 specifically to students in Natural Resources (both -undergraduate and graduate). Scholarships are also available through the -Student Financial Services Office. To apply, log in to RamWeb and select the -CSU Scholarship Application (CSUSA) link. Be sure to complete the Warner -College of Natural Resources section of the CSUSA. The application is available -December 1st each year and due March 1st. Scholarships are awarded in August -for the following academic year. More information is available from the Warner -College of Natural Resources website. - -Graduate Assistantships -Graduate Research Assistant (GRA) responsibilities are to assist assigned -investigators or research scientists in their research. Approximately 20 hours per -week are required of half-time GRA’s. Often, the GRA position is to conduct -research, under the investigator, as part of the student's own research. - -Graduate Teaching Assistant (GTA) responsibilities are to assist assigned -instructors (and occasionally other faculty) in the teaching of courses. GTA’s -provide students with an opportunity to acquire teaching experience as a -classroom assistant to the faculty instructor. Approximately 20 hours per week -are required of a half-time GTA. Responsibilities are typically, but not limited to, -teaching labs, giving occasional lectures, grading homework and exams, and -preparing laboratory materials. GTA’s do not have primary responsibility for -courses or for grade assignment. Refer to the Graduate Student Bulletin and the -Graduate School’s Student Funding page for specific policies and requirements -concerning GRA’s and GTA’s. - -Note: Neither audit registration nor continuous registration qualifies a student for -assistantship appointment. At least one hour of graduate, credit-bearing -registration is required for appointment to research, teaching and support -assistantships. - -Residency -Graduate Research Assistantship Tuition Premium payments of the difference -between resident and non-resident tuition are designed to assist new non- -resident graduate students in their first year of enrollment at Colorado State -University and in their first year GRA appointment. Tuition Premiums remove any -financial disincentive for researchers to give support to new non-resident -graduate students. All eligible students should attain Colorado residency by the -beginning of their second year of graduate study. If your out-of-state tuition -was waived for the first year of your studies, it is your responsibility to - - 28 - - achieve residency by the time your second year starts. Your advisor will not -remind you, and your assistantship will not cover the additional expense of out- -of-state tuition during your second year. GRA’s who do not establish residency -within one year of their assistantship will be assessed out-of-state tuition, -however their appointment will only cover in-state tuition. The student will be -required to make up the difference. - -The CSU Financial Services Tuition Classification site is very helpful in -explaining the residency petition process. Online and face-to-face residency -orientations that are offered by this office and described on their website. - -Vacations -The Graduate Council has adopted the following policy concerning time off for -graduate students on appointment. The policy also appears on the Graduate -Student Bulletin: - -Between semesters, graduate assistants usually concentrate on their -research and associated library work. To the extent that the supervising -faculty and department head concur, graduate assistants may use such -periods for leave. - -Pay -A student holding a research (GRA) or teaching (GTA) assistantship receives a -stipend payment on the last working day of the month. Students on hourly wage -arrangements are paid every two weeks. Arrange to have your check deposited -to your account in a local bank. Student assistantships and positions do not -include benefits. - -DEPARTMENT INFORMATION - -FRS DEPARTMENT OFFICE -The FRS Department Office is located in room 123 of the Forestry Building. The -phone number is 970-491-6911. The department campus delivery code is 1472. - -OFFICE SUPPLIES -Supplies are provided for conduct of instructional duties only. These are available -from 123 Forestry. - -OFFICE SPACE -Office space for funded graduate students is provided in the Natural Resources -Building, Forestry Building, or other appropriate locations. Advisors will provide -Graduate Assistants and other graduate students with office space and a study -desk, as space allows. Graduate assistants are given priority for office space - - 29 - - allocation. Direct questions regarding office space to your advisor. Keys are -available for after-hour entrance to buildings for study or research. Students -should be sure not to leave doors unlocked after regular hours. You must return -any keys to Denise Parcesepe in Forestry 123 before graduation. - -KEYS -Graduate students, post docs, and research associates are issued a key to their -office and a building entrance key. Complete the online key request form -https://www.cognitoforms.com/ForestAndRangelandStewardshipDepartment/Key -Request. Denise Parcesepe will process the form and email you when your keys -are ready. It can take up to two weeks to get keys back, depending on demand. - -PHONES ON CAMPUS -Telephones are located in all graduate student offices. Use for local calls is free. -Long distance calls cannot be made without an authorization number. -Authorization numbers should not be used for personal business. If you need to -call long distance for your research, discuss it with your advisor. - -If dialing a campus number from a campus number, simply dial the last 5 digits. -For example, if you wanted to call Sonya (970-491-1907) from another campus -phone line, pick up the phone and dial 1-1907. - -If dialing off campus from an on campus number, you will need to dial an 8 first, -then the 7-digit number. For example, if you want to call the City of Fort Collins -Natural Areas Department (970-416-2185) from a campus phone, you will dial 8- -416-2815. - -MAIL -Off campus mail must have appropriate postage; on campus mail does not need -to be stamped. To address on campus mail, include the recipient’s name -followed by their department and the department code. The department code is -also the last four digits of the department zip code. For example, the FRS -Department zip code is 80523-1472, so the department code is 1472. To send on -campus mail to Sonya Le Febre, you would address it: Sonya Le Febre, FRS, -1472. An outgoing mail bin is located in Forestry 123. - -CONFERENCE ROOMS -The FRS large conference room (114 Forestry) and small conference room (121 -Forestry) are scheduled by the department office (123 Forestry Building, -wcnr_frs_deptadmin@mail.colostate.edu, 970-491-6911). - - 30 - - COPY MACHINES - -Copy machines and scanners (coin and card operated) are located in Morgan -Library and Lory Student Center. - -CONTACT INFORMATION - -The University will use the mailing address, telephone number, and email -address associated with your eID to contact you. Check your contact information -in RamWeb and update anything that needs to be changed. To change your -information, after logging in to RamWeb, use the links under “Records” on the -bottom right hand corner of the screen. - -ACADEMIC, RESEARCH AND -TEACHING SUPPORT SERVICES - -COMPUTER SERVICES - -Computer Accounts -WCNR requires its own computer account to log into the college network and -access network drives, printers, etc. The account creation process is completely -automated and can be accessed as soon as your eID is active. Just log in using -your eID at https://accounts.warnercnr.colostate.edu and you will be guided -through the process. If you need help or have questions about WCNR network -resources, or have any other computer related questions, visit the "Frequently -Asked Questions” section found towards the bottom of the WCNR Computing -and Network Services website: -http://warnercnr.colostate.edu/home/resources/information-technology or submit -a ticket to the Natural Resources IT Support Center at -https://warnercnr.colostate.edu/helpdesk/. - -Computer Labs -Computers are available for students in the Warner College of Natural Resources -in the following locations: - -• NR230 – the GTL (GIS Technology Lab) -• NR232 – Teaching lab split with an east and west side - 970.491.5867 -• NR107A – Open Lab - 970.491.3776 - -o This lab includes a collaborative study area in the back room, a - -large format plotter for printing posters, and has laptops available -for checkout. - -• NR201 (herbarium) – scheduled by FRS (Forestry, room 123) -• Collaborative Study Area in the back room of NR107 - - 31 - - Two rooms in the Warner College of Natural Resources can accommodate video -conferencing: NR 100 and Forestry 217. - -Computer Services at Morgan Library -Computer training and support services are available in Morgan Library. The -Computing Help Desk provides telephone, e-mail and walk-in assistance to -students, faculty and staff. Services include hands-on training and support for PC -applications, scanning and color plotting capabilities, and computer repair (for a -fee). See the website for hours. -http://lib.colostate.edu/services/computers (970) 491-7276 - -Academic Computing and Networking Services (ACNS) -Academic Computing and Networking Services (ACNS) supports the University's -central computing requirements, providing a number of services to Colorado -State including: email and web-hosting services; support of campus networks; -classroom technology upgrades, training and repair; Windows contract support; -computer hardware and software sales; and self-help guides and on-campus -computer applications trainings. -http://www.acns.colostate.edu/ - -MORGAN LIBRARY, PROSPECTOR, AND -INTERLIBRARY LOAN - -Your CSU ID allows you to check out books from Morgan Library. Graduate -students may check out books for six months and bound journals for two days, -subject to recall. Current journals are kept in the journal room and are not -available for check out. The library has several powerful search engines, and is -transitioning more and more towards on-line journals and electronic books (e- -books). Most of the refereed/peer reviewed natural resources journals are -available online. - -Library Homepage and Important Phone Numbers -http://lib.colostate.edu/ - - Loan and Reserve: (970) 491-1842 -Information Desk: (970) 491-1841 - -Warner College of Natural Resources Liaison Librarian -Jocelyn Boice, the Warner College of Natural Resources Liaison Librarian, -is a subject specialist in natural resources who provides library research -instruction to classes and individuals. Email Dr. Boice to set up an appointment -(jocelyn.boice@colostate.edu). Dr. Boice also maintains a library guide to help -with Natural Resources, Forestry, and Rangelands Research: -Forest & Rangeland Stewardship Research Guide -http://libguides.colostate.edu/forest-rangeland - - 32 - - Access from Off-Campus: CSU Secure Network -Do you want to access library resources (online journals, databases, e-books, -and more) from off-campus? While your eID eName and ePassword are all that -you need to access library resources from off campus, you may like to work by -first signing on to the CSU Secure Access Gateway (SSL VPN; visit this ACNS -website for information on using the Secure Access Gateway -http://www.acns.colostate.edu/Help/SSL-VPN). - -When you are ready to research from off-campus, sign on to the secure network -(https://secure.colostate.edu), then click on CSU libraries. - -Library Books, Journal, and More… -Most scientists turn first to peer-reviewed/referenced journal articles for their -research needs. The library has many databases but Web of Science and CAB -Abstracts are two of the most important databases for natural resources. For -other database suggestions, look at the Natural Resources Portal, the tab for -databases and scholarly journals: -http://libguides.colostate.edu/sb.php?subject_id=17026. These databases are -better than Google Scholar. If you decide to also use Google Scholar, make sure -you are configured to get to the FindIT@CSU link to the online journals from -Google Scholar. Information on how to configure for Google Scholar is available -here: http://libguides.colostate.edu/googlescholar. - -The library online catalog (https://lib.colostate.edu/#) includes e-books, print -books, government documents, titles of the journals we own and more. Two -additional services allow you to access more books than are currently held at -CSU libraries. The regional catalog, Prospector -(https://encore.coalliance.org/iii/encore/;jsessionid=75FA023BA71B8FE8AB522B -E726D482A7?lang=eng) allows you to search several regional libraries at once. -You can request and borrow books unavailable at CSU for a two-week loan -period. The turnaround time to complete a Prospector request is generally two to -four days. Once the books arrive, the patron is notified by email and the books -are held for pick up at the Loan and Reserve Desk. Interlibrary Loan -(http://lib.colostate.edu/illiad) allows a library patron to request any book or article -not available at CSU Libraries online. Over 90% of articles requested are -delivered within three working days, and you can view these articles online using -the WebView option. - -RESEARCH INTEGRITY AND COMPLIANCE REVIEW -OFFICE - -Graduate Students conducting research may need to work with the Research -Integrity and Compliance Review Office to ensure that research is conducted -ethically and in accordance with applicable regulations and guidelines. If the -research will involve animal subjects, human participants, biohazardous agents, - - 33 - - or controlled substances, the research proposal will need to undergo a review -process prior to any collection of data. -http://ricro.colostate.edu/ - -(970) 491-1553 - -GREENHOUSE SPACE -Greenhouse space is available for a fee through centralized CSU Greenhouse -Management (Jennifer Matsuura, 970-491-7140). - -FRANKLIN A. GRAYBILL STATISTICAL LABORATORY -The laboratory provides general statistical consulting to researchers from every -college at the University. Conducting approximately 1000 consulting sessions -each year, consultants offer advice ranging from the planning and design of -experiments to the analysis and interpretation of experimental results. There is -no charge to CSU faculty, staff and graduate students for consultations. Call 491- -5268 to schedule appointments. -http://www.stat.colostate.edu/statlab.html - -(970) 491-5268 - -COMMITMENT OF FUNDS - -Graduate students are not authorized to commit departmental, research, or -instructional funds. Signature of an authorized faculty or staff member is required -on all purchase, travel, or requisitions. - -UNIVERSITY PROPERTY - -Most property items are under the jurisdiction of certain faculty members, and -students must obtain permission to use such items from the faculty member in -advance. Appropriate regard for state-owned property and the return of borrowed -books, articles, and other public or private items to the proper owner or custodian -is a responsibility that is assumed by all students and faculty. Equipment, labs, -and offices are for use only as assigned. - -Graduate students who use research equipment are cautioned to exercise all -reasonable care. Poorly maintained equipment results in costly repair or -replacement, as well as research data of doubtful value in the student's research. - -DATA OWNERSHIP AND ARCHIVING -Graduate students are responsible for understanding and following the University -Policy on Research Data. Under this policy all research data that arise from -research activity conducted using CSU facilities, funded by internal or external -grants, or that result in a thesis or dissertation must be made “discoverable, -accessible, and available” for future use. Data associated with scholarly -publications, including theses and dissertations, is considered a part of the -scientific record and therefore must be permanently stored along with the - - 34 - - published manuscript, thesis or dissertation. In most cases, this means that a -copy of the research data is retained for permanent archiving at the University. -For internally or externally funded research, the Principal Investigator (PI) is -responsible for controlling the storage, use and distribution of the research data, -subject to provisions of any grant, agreement, University policy or law. Where -research is performed without a grant or contract, the individual primarily -responsible for the conduct of the research is responsible for data storage, use -and distribution. In either case, a copy of the data must be permanently stored at -CSU or made “discoverable, accessible and available” for future use. Graduate -students are urged to discuss data ownership, management and storage with -their major advisor early in their program and to communicate regularly about the -location, condition and use of data. - -STATE-OWNED MOTOR VEHICLES - -A graduate student who drives a state-owned motor vehicle must have a valid -driver's license. Permission from an advisor or authorized faculty member is -required before using a state-owned motor vehicle. State-owned motor vehicles -are for official use only; do not transport passengers who are not on official -business with the university. - -Travel stipends are provided to GRAs and GTAs for assigned duties. For -research-related travel and travel to professional meetings, see your advisor. - -TRAVEL - -SAFETY ON CAMPUS - -LABORATORY AND EQUIPMENT SAFETY - -Graduate students may use potentially hazardous equipment, apparatus, or -chemicals only if they fully understand the dangers involved and safe procedures -of use. Federal and state laws require the wearing of goggles and protective -clothing when handling acids and other dangerous chemicals. Read and follow -the directions for use given on all packages of dangerous materials. Students -must wear a hard hat and suitable clothing on logging operations and in mills. -See also Research Integrity and Compliance Review Office. - -THEFT - -Please be aware that theft does occur on campus. Both personal items and -university equipment have been stolen. Do not leave valuables unattended. If -you have an office, lock it when you are not in it. If you access buildings after -hours, make sure to secure any doors you open. In the winter months, transient -people sometimes seek shelter in University buildings. Building occupants should - - 35 - - contact CSU Police Department immediately if they notice any strangers in their -areas. -http://police.colostate.edu/ non-emergency: 970-491-6425; emergency: 911 - -EMERGENCY TEXT MESSAGING ALERT SERVICE -Colorado State University operates an emergency cell phone text messaging -alert service. The service is available to all faculty, staff, and students who sign -up. The program sends a text message alert to all enrolled cell phones in the -event of an emergency at the university. The system is only used during a safety -emergency or unexpected closing of the university, such as a snow day. To enter -a cell phone number into the system, anyone with a campus EID – a university -electronic identity – can register on RamWeb. Once on the site, click on -"Records" on the right side of the page, then on "Change My Emergency -Notification Cell Phone" and enter the number. The same steps can be taken to -update cell phone information. - -SAFEWALK -If you are walking at night, Campus Service Officers can provide a SafeWalk to -your destination on or near campus within a specified service area. Call 491- -1155 or use any of the outdoor emergency/service phones to request the service. -https://police.colostate.edu/safe-walk/ (970) 491-1155 - -TELL SOMEONE/PUBLIC SAFETY - -If you are concerned about a CSU student or employee who may be -experiencing emotional difficulty or mental health illness, please visit the website -below or call the number to discuss your concerns. -http://www.publicsafety.colostate.edu/tell-someone.aspx (970) 491-1350 - -RAMRIDE - -Ramride provides safe, nonjudgmental rides for CSU students with the goal of -improving safety of the Fort Collins community. Rides are provided Thursday -from 10:00 pm to 2:00 am, and Friday and Saturday nights from 10:00 pm to 3:00 -am but do not run during school holidays or during the summer. -http://www.ramride.colostate.edu/ - -(970) 491-3333 - -WEST NILE VIRUS - -There were several reported cases of West Nile Virus in Larimer County last -summer (2014). The winter temperatures have killed them off for now, but we -fully expect they’ll return again this spring/summer. The best thing you can do to -protect yourself from this mosquito borne illness is to limit your exposure to biting -mosquitos and wear mosquito repellent when outdoors. -http://www.larimer.org/health/cd/westnile.cfm - - 36 - - TULAREMIA - -Tularemia has been found in the area since summer 2015 in rabbits, and a -handful of people in Larimer, Weld, and Boulder Counties have also be infected. -Tularemia is transmitted from wildlife to pets and people. Keep your pet indoors -or on a leash to reduce the risk of infection, and read more about Tularemia in -people and pets as well as tips on prevention on the Larimer County website. -http://larimer.org/health/tularemia.asp +5 +2 +0 +2 + +r +p +A +0 +2 + +] +L +C +. +s +c +[ + +2 +v +7 +0 +1 +9 +0 +. +0 +1 +3 +2 +: +v +i +X +r +a + +GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large +Language Models + +Hanmeng Liu1, Zhiyang Teng3 Ruoxi Ning2, Yiran Ding2, Xiulai Li1, +Xiaozhang Liu1, and Yue Zhang2 + +1 Hainan University, Haikou, Hainan +2 Westlake University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China +3 ByteDance SG + +Abstract. Large language models (LLMs) have shown significant gen- +eral language understanding abilities. However, there has been a scarcity +of attempts to assess the logical reasoning capacities of these LLMs, +an essential facet of natural language understanding. To encourage fur- +ther investigation in this area, we introduce GLoRE, a General Logical +Reasoning Evaluation platform that not only consolidates diverse datasets +but also standardizes them into a unified format suitable for evaluating +large language models across zero-shot and few-shot scenarios. Our ex- +perimental results show that compared to the performance of humans +and supervised fine-tuning models, the logical reasoning capabilities of +large reasoning models, such as OpenAI’s o1 mini, DeepSeek R1 and +QwQ-32B, have seen remarkable improvements, with QwQ-32B achiev- +ing the highest benchmark performance to date. GLoRE is designed as +a living project that continuously integrates new datasets and models, +facilitating robust and comparative assessments of model performance +in both commercial and Huggingface communities. It garnered over 300 +citations upon its release. + +Keywords: Large Language Model · Large Reasoning Model · Logical +reasoning · Natural Language Inference. + +1 + +Introduction + +Large Language Models (LLMs) [50, 67], especially reasoning language mod- +els [18, 51] demonstrate advanced capabilities in complex reasoning tasks and +show significant adaptability and versatility across various applications, from +simple everyday tasks to specialized domains such as coding, mathematics, law, +medicine, and finance [11, 22, 34, 37, 76]. Quantitative evaluation of LLM rea- +soning has thus become a very important task. To this end, existing work has +considered mathematical reasoning [15, 26], algorithmic problem solving [9, 58], +and knowledge-driven reasoning [25, 73]. + +Logical reasoning is a cornerstone of human intelligence and has been a cen- +tral focus in artificial intelligence research since its inception [16,29,33]. However, +evaluating verbal reasoning turned out to be too difficult in the 1950s due to + + 2 + +H. Liu et al. + +Fig. 1. Instruction and question format for logical reading comprehension tasks. + +insufficient natural language understanding (NLU) technologies, and thus AI +researchers focused on formal logical reasoning instead [29, 48, 49]. Since the +2010s, NLU has witnessed huge advances, where reading comprehension [8, 21] +and natural language inference [7, 74] tasks were solved with high accuracies, +which made verbal reasoning evaluation feasible [43, 80]. Figure 1 illustrates an +example of logical reasoning in reading comprehension. To address such ques- +tions, LLMs must engage in multi-step, algorithmic, symbolic reasoning. This +makes logical reasoning an ideal testbed for evaluating LLMs’ ability to process +complex natural language information accurately, robustly, and logically. + +To this end, we introduce the General Logical Reasoning Evaluation (GLoRE) +benchmark, designed to assess instruction-tuned LLMs on various logical rea- +soning tasks. GLoRE evaluates the strengths and limitations of LLMs in this +domain, similar to how GLUE [71] and Super-GLUE [70] benchmark natu- +ral language understanding. GLoRE includes three types of logical reasoning +tasks: Multi-choice Reading Comprehension [35], Natural Language Inference +(NLI) [17], and True-or-False (Yes-or-No) Questions [13]. These tasks encompass +a wide range of logical reasoning phenomena, with high-quality datasets that re- +main challenging for pre-trained language models [13, 27, 32]. In total, GLoRE +covers 12 datasets with 72,848 instances. Since its release in 2023, GLoRE has +been used for evaluating language models, receiving over 300 citations on ArXiv. +Using GLoRE, we report the logical reasoning capabilities of commercial +models such as GPT-4 and OpenAI o1 [51], as well as popular open-source +models such as LLaMA [67], Falcon [1], Mistral [30], DeepSeek R1 [18], and +QwQ-32B [66]. We test their instruction-following and problem-solving abili- +ties in logical reasoning tasks. Results show that while commercial LLMs like +GPT-4 still excel in zero-shot settings and approach human performance on spe- +cific datasets like ReClor, open-source models like QwQ-32B now rival or even +surpass commercial counterparts in key tasks, achieving state-of-the-art results +on multiple benchmarks. This underscores rapid advancements in open-source +LLMs, narrowing the performance gap with commercial models. However, per- +formance varies significantly across datasets, indicating sensitivity to data dis- +tribution. This sensitivity is further confirmed by observations that in-context + + GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models + +3 + +learning and supervised fine-tuning primarily enhance LLM performance on spe- +cific test distributions, demonstrating their strong learning ability. While LLMs +show promise in logical reasoning, their robustness to data distribution variations +remains a challenge, highlighting the need for further improvement. + +2 Related Work + +Logical reasoning with natural language. Tapping into logical reasoning +capabilities represents a holistic endeavour in natural language understanding +(NLU). A variety of methods have been explored to realize this objective, includ- +ing symbolic systems [45, 47, 55], fine-tuning of language models [28, 41, 71, 78], +and hybrid approaches combining neural and symbolic elements [36, 59, 60]. + +The recent introduction of evaluation datasets, notably LogiQA [43] and +Reclor [80], has reinvigorated the focus on logical reasoning in NLP research. +Logical reasoning is now leveraged in numerous probing tasks over large Pre- +trained Language Models (PLMs) and applied to downstream tasks such as +question-answering and dialogue systems [6, 63]. Despite these advancements, +the aspiration to emulate human-like logical reasoning capabilities within NLU +systems remains a significant challenge for traditional models [27, 43]. In this +study, our goal is not only to quantitatively evaluate the capability of Large +Language Models (LLMs) in addressing the previously mentioned challenge but +also to underscore the significance of our work in providing a validated platform +for enhancing various reasoning methods with our data. + +LLM reasoning evaluation. Despite progress in evaluating LLMs for spe- +cific reasoning tasks like arithmetic [57] and commonsense [4], a yawning gap +exists in comprehensively assessing their logical reasoning. While LLMs excel at +specific tasks like arithmetic reasoning [57], they face challenges in complex ar- +eas like multi-step reasoning [23] and abstract scenarios [24]. ChatGPT exhibits +strengths in chat-specific reasoning and some commonsense domains [4, 53], but +struggles with tasks requiring longer chains of inference [4]. Other LLMs like +FLAN-T5 [12], LLaMA [67], and PaLM [2] show potential in general deductive +reasoning [61], while InstructGPT and Codex excel in specialized domains like +medical reasoning [38]. Despite these advances, limitations in data bias [52], and +complex reasoning tasks necessitate further research and optimization to fully +unlock the reasoning potential of LLMs [77]. + +Big-Bench Hard (BBH) [64] isolates 23 most challenging tasks from BIG- +Bench [3]. These tasks comprise general language understanding, arithmetic and +algorithmic reasoning, and logical deduction. However, in comparison to our +benchmark, the data size of the logical reasoning section in BBH is very small. +HumanEval [10] serves as a hand-written evaluation set for coding. The pro- +gramming problems included are designed to assess language comprehension, +reasoning, algorithms, and simple mathematics. While similar to logical reason- +ing in that code generation necessitates complex reasoning skills, GLoRE differs +in presenting logical reasoning problems via natural language prompts. + + 4 + +H. Liu et al. + +Target + +Size +Dataset +1,572 4-way multi-choice ConTRoL + +Dataset +LogiQA 2.0 test +LogiQA 2.0 zh test 1,594 4-way multi-choice HELP +ReClor dev +AR-LSAT test +LogiQA22 + +500 4-way multi-choice TaxiNLI test +230 5-way multi-choice NaN-NLI +1,354 4-way multi-choice FraCas + +Size +805 +35,891 +10,071 +259 +346 Yes, No, Neutral + +Target +E, C, N +E, C, N +E, C, N +E, C, N + +Table 1. Data statistics. (“E”: entailment; “C”: contradiction; “N”: neutral.) + +10,068 +RuleTaker dev +ProofWriter dev 10,158 + +Yes, No +Yes, No + +ARB [62] is a benchmark for advanced reasoning over multiple fields like +mathematics, physics, biology, chemistry, and law. Similar to GLoRE, it in- +troduces a challenging subset of math and physics problems that require ad- +vanced symbolic reasoning. However, the benchmark constraints its problem on +the above subjects with domain knowledge, not general logical reasoning ques- +tions, which is the focus of GLoRE. + +3 The GLoRE Dataset + +As mentioned in the introduction, GLoRE contains three NLU tasks: Multi- +choice Reading Comprehension, NLI, and Yes-or-No. First, Multi-choice reading +comprehension [35] is essential in verbal reasoning tests, which cover abundant +high-quality logical reasoning problems in the wild. Second, Unlike multi-choice +reading comprehension, NLI [17] is more general and centric on entailment rela- +tions in a simpler task format, which is a fundamental task for evaluating rea- +soning abilities [19,54]. Third, the Yes-or-No reasoning task [13] is a combination +of question-answering and textual entailment, which can serve as a playground +for testing models’ reasoning abilities [14, 65]. The data statistics are shown in +Table 1. + +3.1 Multi-choice Reading Comprehension (MRC) + +Within the standard multi-choice reading comprehension (MRC) task setting, a +system is presented with a passage and a question, and the objective is to choose +the most suitable answer from a set of candidate responses. Particularly, GLoRE +contains five such datasets: +LogiQA [43] is a logical MRC dataset derived from the Chinese Civil Service +Examination, translated into English, and made available in both Chinese and +English versions. We adopt LogiQA 2.0 [40] and use both the English (LogiQA +2.0) and Chinese (LogiQA 2.0 zh) test sets for our evaluation. +ReClor [80] comprises question-answering examples from the LSAT exams de- +signed to assess human logical reasoning abilities. We use the development set +for our testing as the test set does not provide gold labels. +AR-LSAT [72] is a dataset of analytical reasoning questions from the Law +School Admission Test. Each question contains five options rather than four. + + GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models + +5 + +LogiQA22 is collected and processed according to the LogiQA 2.0 format after +ChatGPT was released. It incorporates the newly released Chinese Civil Servant +Exams from 2022, which are not included in the original LogiQA dataset. + +3.2 Natural Language Inference (NLI) + +NLI is the task of determining the logical relationship between a hypothesis +and a premise. The typical scheme involves text classification, where the model +selects one of three labels: entailment, contradiction, and neutral. +ConTRoL [39] is an NLI dataset that offers an in-depth examination of con- +textual reasoning within the NLI framework. Approximately 36.2% of premise- +hypothesis pairs fall under the category of logical reasoning in this dataset. We +choose the logical reasoning portion for our evaluation. +HELP [79] is an NLI dataset emphasizing monotonicity reasoning, a crucial +concept in Natural Logic [46]. We use the training set for our evaluation. +TaxiNLI [31] is an NLI dataset that has been re-annotated based on MNLI [75], +with categories include logical categories such as connectives, mathematical rea- +soning, and deduction. +NaN-NLI [68] is a test suite designed to probe the capabilities of NLP models in +capturing sub-clausal negation. The successful handling of sub-clausal negation +can be seen as a strong indicator of a model’s logical reasoning capacity. + +3.3 True-or-False (Yes-or-No) Questions (TF) + +FraCaS test suite [56] presents complex entailment problems involving multi- +premised contexts as a three-way classification task. The ability to determine +entailment relationships in this context is closely tied to logical reasoning. +RuleTaker [14] dataset is a synthetic creation designed to examine the reasoning +ability of transformer models [69] over natural language rules. This task explicitly +targets logical reasoning by asking models to reason over a set of rules and facts +to generate true-or-false responses as output. +ProofWriter [65] dataset generates sets of facts and rules, each followed by +questions, which can be proven true or false using proofs of various depths. + +4 Experiments + +We employ GLoRE to assess the logical reasoning capabilities across differ- +ent categories of language models, including traditional pre-trained models and +reasoning-enhanced LLMs, both open-source and proprietary. We conduct a +comprehensive comparative analysis of their performance against human bench- +marks. + + 6 + +H. Liu et al. + +Task + +Dataset + +MRC + +NLI + +TF + +Avg + +LQ LQ zh RC AL LQ22 CT HL TN NN FC RT PW + +RoBERTa + +86.00 88.00 63.00 56.00 83.00 87.00 81.00 97.00 94.00 92.00 84.00 82.00 82.75 +Human avg. +Human Ceiling 95.00 96.00 100.00 91.00 99.00 94.00 95.00 100.00 100.00 97.00 95.00 93.00 96.25 +48.76 35.64 55.01 30.90 33.22 48.76 39.47 49.91 90.02 32.01 53.50 55.92 47.76 +19.31 26.35 17.81 17.98 18.41 24.10 32.26 41.91 47.29 40.00 48.89 53.78 32.34 +LLaMA +23.21 19.77 26.77 12.70 17.33 16.13 28.49 44.66 53.31 35.57 56.11 53.33 32.28 +Falcon +Mixtral-8x7B 45.29 36.81 48.92 41.40 38.97 50.84 33.27 40.86 50.13 32.08 46.84 44.80 42.52 +52.37 53.18 57.38 51.49 38.44 58.45 42.13 57.30 56.59 49.13 54.74 53.95 52.10 +72.25 70.56 87.20 73.12 58.49 56.40 46.01 60.08 76.74 75.35 60.19 59.66 66.34 +69.35 74.18 80.57 79.23 59.84 75.12 63.69 81.41 71.55 63.07 75.90 75.33 72.44 +76.22 81.49 77.88 90.01 71.63 78.37 62.05 75.74 72.58 59.96 75.29 80.51 75.14 +85.70 73.33 93.76 92.35 86.30 73.87 61.53 81.96 75.59 62.45 78.10 82.40 78.95 + +o1 mini +DeepSeek R1 +QwQ-32B + +ChatGPT +GPT-4 + +Table 2. LLMs’ performance on the GLoRE benchmark. LQ: LogiQA 2.0, RC : Re- +Clor, AL: AR-LSAT, CT : ConTRoL, HL: HELP, TN : TaxiNLI, NN : NaN-NLI, FC : +FraCas, RT : RuleTaker, PW : ProofWriter. All results are in %, the best ones are in +bold, and the second best ones are in underline. + +4.1 Experimental Settings + +We adopted RoBERTa-base [44] as a baseline, fine-tuning it on the training set +over five epochs for each dataset. The community models selected for compari- +son include Falcon-40b-instruct [1], LLaMA-30b-supercot [67] Mixtral- +8x7b, DeepSeek R1 [18] and QwQ-32B [66]. For OpenAI models, we choose +ChatGPT, GPT-4 and o1 mini [51]. + +Our evaluation metrics consisted of classification accuracy scores. Addition- +ally, we utilized reported accuracies for datasets where human performance data +was available and recorded both the average and peak performance of human +participants to establish a human baseline. For the LogiQA22 dataset, we en- +gaged five co-authors as test subjects and computed their accuracy based on 150 +test examples. + +4.2 Main Results + +Zero-shot results. Table 2 summarizes the zero-shot evaluation results. The +first block shows human performance. The second block presents RoBERTa- +base’s supervised fine-tuning results. With 125M parameters, RoBERTa-base +achieves 48.76% and 33.22% accuracy on LogiQA 2.0 and LogiQA22, respec- +tively, lagging behind human performance. It performs better on NLI and TF +tasks than MRC tasks, likely due to output ambiguities. On NaN-NLI, RoBERTa +achieves 90.02% accuracy, matching human performance, possibly due to learn- +ing superficial patterns from rule-based negation data. On ProofWriter, RoBERTa- +base scores 55.92%, indicating potential for specific logical reasoning tasks. + +The third block shows zero-shot results for LLaMA, Falcon, and Mixtral. +LLaMA and Falcon perform similarly (32.34% vs. 32.28%), suggesting compa- +rable reasoning capabilities despite LLaMA-30B’s smaller size. Both underper- +form RoBERTa-base on most tasks, except Falcon on RT. On MRC tasks, their + + GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models + +7 + +Model + +0-shot 1-shot 2-shot 5-shot + +32.34 +LLaMA +Falcon +32.28 +ChatGPT 52.10 +66.34 +GPT-4 + +32.89 +33.14 +55.85 +70.31 + +35.03 +33.76 +57.43 +71.44 + +39.62 +35.72 +60.32 +75.83 + +Table 3. Average accuracies on GLoRE few-shot evaluation. + +accuracy is around 20%, worse than random guessing in 4-way classification, +indicating challenges in logical reasoning without in-context demonstrations. +Performance gaps between LogiQA and LogiQA22 are smaller for these mod- +els, suggesting stable performance across data distributions without in-domain +tuning. Mixtral-8x7b outperforms LLaMA and Falcon, demonstrating the ef- +fectiveness of mixture-of-expert models. + +The fourth block provides zero-shot results for ChatGPT and GPT-4. Both +models, especially GPT-4, surpass RoBERTa-base on several MRC benchmarks. +However, GPT-4’s accuracy drops significantly on LogiQA22 (58.49% vs. 72.25% +on LogiQA 2.0), indicating sensitivity to data distribution. In NLI and TF +tasks, ChatGPT and GPT-4 outperform RoBERTa, with ChatGPT achieving +58.45% accuracy on ConTRoL, surpassing GPT-4. GPT-4’s NLI performance +varies across datasets, further highlighting its sensitivity to data distribution. +TF task results show similar inconsistencies, suggesting model rationales differ +from human reasoning. + +The final block shows results for o1 mini, DeepSeek R1, and QwQ-32B, which +achieve notable improvements over prior models. QwQ-32B attains the high- +est average accuracy (78.95%), surpassing GPT-4 (66.34%) and DeepSeek R1 +(75.14%). It achieves state-of-the-art results on MRC tasks like ReClor (93.76%) +and AR-LSAT (92.35%), indicating the need for more challenging benchmarks +for logical reasoning. Its robustness is evident in LogiQA22 (86.30%), outper- +forming GPT-4 by 27.81 percentage points. However, QwQ-32B shows uneven +performance on NLI datasets, such as HELP (61.53%, lagging behind o1 mini’s +63.69%), suggesting its reasoning capabilities are less generalizable in tasks re- +quiring fine-grained entailment analysis. + +While GPT-4 retains an advantage on FraCas (75.35%), QwQ-32B surpasses +GPT-4 on ReClor (93.76% vs. 87.20%), redefining state-of-the-art performance +for MRC tasks. QwQ-32B and DeepSeek R1 showcase balanced performance +across most tasks, with QwQ-32B achieving unprecedented TF results (e.g., +82.40% on ProofWriter, outperforming both GPT-4’s 59.66% and DeepSeek R1’s +80.51%). Though still below the human average overall, these models mark sub- +stantial progress — QwQ-32B’s 78.95% average accuracy (vs. DeepSeek R1’s +75.14% and GPT-4’s 66.34%) highlights significant architectural or training in- +novations for logical inference. + +Few-shot results. LLMs excel at in-context learning [20], where perfor- +mance improves with context examples and demonstration methods [42]. For +this study, we randomly sampled instances (1 for 1-shot, 2 for 2-shot, and 5 for +5-shot) from each dataset and appended them to the prompt. We used the same + + 8 + +H. Liu et al. + +model configuration as in the zero-shot scenario. Table 3 highlights the impact +of in-context learning (ICL), as seen in GPT-4’s 9% accuracy gain with 5-shot +learning. However, this improvement stems from statistical adaptation rather +than true reasoning, as models rely on superficial patterns rather than human- +like logical inference. This aligns with findings that chain-of-thought prompts +correlate with outputs but do not causally drive reasoning [5]. While reasoning- +enhanced models narrow the gap with human performance, their sensitivity to +data distribution highlights the need for further research into more robust rea- +soning mechanisms. GLoRE’s evolving framework will continue to track these +advancements. + +4.3 Analysis + +Large language models vs. reasoning-enhanced models. The reasoning- +enhanced models like QwQ-32B, DeepSeek R1, and OpenAI’s o1 mini demon- +strate significant improvements over traditional LLMs. QwQ-32B, in particular, +achieves the highest average performance (78.95%), indicating that its reinforce- +ment learning framework or specialized training methodology enables better gen- +eralization across data distributions. While QwQ-32B dominates MRC and TF +tasks, its relatively lower performance on NLI datasets like HELP (61.53%) sug- +gests that even state-of-the-art models struggle with tasks requiring monotonic- +ity or negation reasoning, highlighting the need for broader evaluation beyond +task-specific robustness. +Data leakage concerns. While GLoRE includes diverse datasets, potential +data leakage risks arise from overlapping sources. GPT-4’s lower accuracy on +LogiQA22 (58.49%) compared to LogiQA 2.0 (72.25%) suggests limited expo- +sure to newer data, reducing leakage concerns but highlighting distributional +sensitivity. The benchmark’s dynamic updates and inclusion of newly annotated +datasets help mitigate leakage by testing models on unseen distributions. +Sensitivity to data distribution. The above experiments show that the per- +formance of LLMs is sensitive to the data distribution. Even though the under- +lying reasoning principles are the same, LLM performance varies significantly +across datasets. This suggests that LLMs might not reason using the correct +rationale but rely on superficial features. As shown in Table 2, although GPT-4 +achieves near-human performance on datasets like ReClor (87.20%) and NaN- +NLI (75.74%), it lags significantly on others (e.g., HELP at 46.01%). This in- +consistency mirrors the behavior of reasoning-enhanced models like DeepSeek +R1, revealing a critical divergence from human reasoning: once humans master a +reasoning pattern, their performance generalizes robustly, whereas LLMs remain +sensitive to data-specific features. -TRANSPORTATION ON CAMPUS +5 Conclusion -BIKING ON CAMPUS -All bicycles ridden or parked on the Colorado State campus must be registered -with the CSU Police Department (CSUPD). A registration decal, known as a CSU -Bicycle (or Bike) License, is valid for as long as the bike is in possession of the -registered owner. The cost is $10, and more information and forms are available -from the CSU PD webpage: https://police.colostate.edu/register-your-bike/. +We constructed GLoRE, a dynamic and comprehensive benchmark tailored for +assessing the logical reasoning capabilities of advanced language models, includ- +ing GPT-4 and various strong open-source LLMs across multiple reasoning tasks. -While registering your bike, pick up a copy of the campus biking regulations, or -view them at https://police.colostate.edu/safe-commuting-regulations/. Bike -regulations are enforced, tickets are given, and fees are paid. Especially pay -attention to the dismount zones posted on campus. + GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models -PARKING ON CAMPUS +9 -Commuter student permits cost $569/year and are good in Z lots. Since more -parking permits are sold than there are parking spaces, the parking permit is -actually less of a permit to park and more of a license to hunt. Parking violation -fees range from $20 to $150, depending on the violation. -http://parking.colostate.edu/ - - (970) 491-7041 - -PARKING OFF CAMPUS -The City of Fort Collins has implemented a residential parking permit program for -several neighborhoods that surround Colorado State University. To see where -these zones are, visit the City’s Residential Parking Permit Program site: -http://www.fcgov.com/parking/residential-parking-permit/index.php In some -neighborhoods, parking is still free, but give yourself plenty of time to find a spot -and walk the several blocks from your car to your classroom or office. Finally, -pay attention to any parking signs. Some blocks limit parking to two hours, for -example. +Our findings indicate that QwQ-32B, a reasoning-enhanced model, sets a new +state-of-the-art on the GLoRE benchmark, significantly narrowing the gap to hu- +man performance. This underscores the potential of targeted architectural and +training innovations for logical reasoning. GLoRE will be continually maintained +to track advancements in this rapidly evolving domain. - 37 +References - TAKING THE BUS +1. Almazrouei, E., Alobeidli, H., Alshamsi, A., Cappelli, A., Cojocaru, R., Debbah, +M., Goffinet, E., Heslow, D., Launay, J., Malartic, Q., Noune, B., Pannier, B., +Penedo, G.: Falcon-40B: an open large language model with state-of-the-art per- +formance (2023) -Passes for Transfort, Fort Collins’ bus system, are free for full fee-paying -students with a CSU Student ID. Transfort has convenient schedules, several -stops on campus, and reaches many of the city’s outlying areas. -http://www.sc.colostate.edu/transit-center.aspx -http://www.fcgov.com/transfort/ - - (970) 416-6444 - (970) 221-6620 - -UNIVERSITY SERVICES +2. Anil, R., Dai, A.M., Firat, O., Johnson, M., Lepikhin, D., Passos, A., others.: Palm -OFF CAMPUS LIFE -Off-Campus Life is dedicated to providing a comprehensive array of services to -meet the diverse needs of students who live off campus. The off campus housing -information provided on the Off Campus Life website lets you peruse house and -apartment listings, learn about leases and mortgages, find roommates, learn -about occupancy limits and other Fort Collins residency laws, find out where to -register your pet, and get tips on being a good neighbor. -https://ocl.colostate.edu/ +2 technical report (2023) - (970) 491-2248 +3. bench authors, B.: Beyond the imitation game: Quantifying and extrapolating the -CSU HEALTH NETWORK +capabilities of language models. TMLR (2023) -The CSU Health Network is available to every student. Students may purchase -student health services for their spouse and children by contacting the CSU -Health Network at the beginning of the semester. +4. Bang, Y., Cahyawijaya, S., Lee, N., Dai, W., Su, D., Wilie, B., Lovenia, H., Ji, Z., +Yu, T., Chung, W., et al.: A multitask, multilingual, multimodal evaluation of chat- +gpt on reasoning, hallucination, and interactivity. arXiv preprint arXiv:2302.04023 +(2023) -All new, full-fee paying resident-instruction graduate students are required to -enroll in the CSU Student Insurance Plan or to opt out by demonstrating -comparable health insurance coverage. -http://www.health.colostate.edu +5. Bao, G., Zhang, H., Wang, C., Yang, L., Zhang, Y.: How likely do llms with cot -(970) 491-7121 +mimic human reasoning? arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.16048 (2024) -CONFLICT RESOLUTION SERVICES -Conflict Resolution Services assists students with any issue and assists faculty -and staff on matters concerning students. They provide advice and referrals to -aid in problem solving, coaching and mentoring to help people solve conflicts on -their own, and mediation to facilitate conversation between willing parties who -are in conflict. -https://resolutioncenter.colostate.edu/ - - (970) 491-7165 - -STUDENT LEGAL SERVICES +6. Beygi, S., Fazel-Zarandi, M., Cervone, A., Krishnan, P., Jonnalagadda, S.R.: Log- -The office of Student Legal Services provides legal advice and counsel on a -variety of legal issues, including: housing issues, criminal matters, family matters, -consumer issues, employment matters, traffic laws, real estate, criminal records, +ical reasoning for task oriented dialogue systems (2022) - 38 +7. Bowman, S.R., Angeli, G., Potts, C., Manning, C.D.: A large annotated corpus for +learning natural language inference. In: Proc. of EMNLP. pp. 632–642 (2015) +8. Chen, D., Bolton, J., Manning, C.D.: A thorough examination of the CNN/daily - name changes, wills, powers of attorney, court, and name changes. The -following students can use the service: +mail reading comprehension task. In: ACL (2016) -• Full-fee paying students taking six credits or more during Fall or Spring +9. Chen, M., Tworek, J., Jun, H., Yuan, Q., Others: Evaluating large language models -semester. +trained on code (2021) -• Students taking at least six credits during any summer session. -• Continuing Education and GUEST students who pay full student fees. -Intensive English Program students who have paid the special fee. -• +10. Chen, M., Tworek, J., Jun, H., Yuan, Q., Others: Evaluating large language models -https://sls.colostate.edu/ +trained on code (2021) - (970) 491-1482 +11. Choi, J.H., Hickman, K.E., Monahan, A., Schwarcz, D.: Chatgpt goes to law school. -CAREER CENTER LIAISON +Available at SSRN (2023) -Many full-time jobs, internships, seasonal jobs, and graduate assistantship -announcements are posted on CareerRAM, CSU’s on-line job and internship -posting site for students and alumni. Students and alumni can schedule -appointments with Barb Richardson, the Warner College’s Career Center -counselor, by calling 970-491-5707, or by contacting Barb directly -(Barbara.Richardson@ColoState.edu, 970-491-2668), or by signing up for a time -on the bulletin board outside of Barb’s office, room 107C of the Natural -Resources Building, to cover any of the following topics: +12. Chung, H.W., Hou, L., Longpre, S., Zoph, B., Tay, Y., Fedus, W., Li, Y., Wang, X., +Dehghani, M., Brahma, S., et al.: Scaling instruction-finetuned language models. +arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.11416 (2022) -• Major/Career Exploration -• Career Assessments -• Cover Letter/Resume Assistance -• Federal Application Assistance -• Job Search Strategies -• -• Graduate School Preparation -• Online job/internship postings +13. Clark, C., Lee, K., Chang, M.W., Kwiatkowski, T., Collins, M., Toutanova, K.: +Boolq: Exploring the surprising difficulty of natural yes/no questions (2019) +14. Clark, P., Tafjord, O., Richardson, K.: Transformers as soft reasoners over lan- -Interviewing Skill Development +guage. In: Proc. of IJCAI (2020) -http://warnercnr.colostate.edu/career-services/ +15. Cobbe, K., Kosaraju, V., Bavarian, M., Chen, M., Jun, H., Kaiser, L., Plappert, +M., Tworek, J., Hilton, J., Nakano, R., et al.: Training verifiers to solve math word +problems. arXiv preprint arXiv:2110.14168 (2021) - (970) 491-2668 +16. Cresswell, M.J.: Logics and languages (1st ed.). Routledge (1973) +17. Dagan, I., Glickman, O., Magnini, B.: The pascal recognising textual entailment -ADULT LEARNERS/VETERAN SERVICES -Adult Learners/Veteran Services has information pertinent to veterans and also -to active service men and women that are students at Colorado State University. -A Veterans Educational Benefits Representative is available for consult, and they -have information on other issues that relate to veterans, such as claiming -residency. Information, support groups, and activities are also provided for adult -learners. These include a Student Parent Resource Room, the Student Parent -Community that plans social events for students and their children, and several -other activities and benefits. -https://alvs.colostate.edu/ +challenge. In: MLCW (2005) - (970) 491-3977 +18. DeepSeek-AI: Deepseek-r1: Incentivizing reasoning capability in llms via reinforce- -STUDENT DISABILITY CENTER +ment learning (2025), https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.12948 -The Student Disability Center recognizes that disability reflects diverse -characteristics and experiences, and is an aspect of diversity integral to society. -To that end, the Center collaborates with students, instructors, staff, and -community members to create useable, equitable, inclusive and sustainable + 10 - 39 +H. Liu et al. - learning environments. RDS is also committed to supporting Colorado State -University as a non-discriminating environment for qualified students with -disabilities as mandated by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and the -Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. +19. Demszky, D., Guu, K., Liang, P.: Transforming question answering datasets into -The mission is fulfilled through three specific goals: to provide accommodation, -awareness, and advocacy. All activities of the Center are related to fulfilling these -goals in support of a campus environment that is not discriminatory based solely -on the presence of a disability -https://disabilitycenter.colostate.edu/ (970) 491-6385 +natural language inference datasets (2018) -WOMEN AND GENDER ADVOCACY CENTER +20. Dong, Q., Li, L., Dai, D., Zheng, C., Wu, Z., Chang, B., Sun, X., Xu, J., Li, L., -The Women and Gender Advocacy Center offers many services for students. -The Victim Assistance Team (VAT) is here to assist Colorado State University -students who have been sexually assaulted on or off campus; and staff, faculty, -or visitors who have been sexually assaulted on campus. Counseling and -referrals are also available for students who wish to obtain information and -explore with a staff member academic, career, and/or personal concerns that are -sex or gender based. Personal concerns can range from difficulties related to -relationships, dealing with sexism, or any type of interpersonal violence, including -dating/domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. Staff in the office will -provide immediate assistance and referral for students and assist them in -discovering the best avenues, if any, to meet the needs of their situation. -https://wgac.colostate.edu/ +Sui, Z.: A survey on in-context learning (2023) -(970) 491-6384 +21. Dua, D., Wang, Y., Dasigi, P., Stanovsky, G., Singh, S., Gardner, M.: DROP: A +reading comprehension benchmark requiring discrete reasoning over paragraphs. +In: Proc. of AACL (2019) -ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS ON CAMPUS +22. Frieder, S., Pinchetti, L., Griffiths, R.R., Salvatori, T., Lukasiewicz, T., Petersen, -Adult Learners/Veteran Services -https://alvs.colostate.edu/ (970) 491-3977 +P.C., Chevalier, A., Berner, J.: Mathematical capabilities of chatgpt (2023) -Asian/Pacific American Cultural Center -https://apacc.colostate.edu/ +23. Fu, Y., Ou, L., Chen, M., Wan, Y., Peng, H., Khot, T.: Chain-of-thought hub: A +continuous effort to measure large language models’ reasoning performance. arXiv +preprint arXiv:2305.17306 (2023) - (970) 491-6154 +24. Gendron, G., Bao, Q., Witbrock, M., Dobbie, G.: Large language models are not -Black/African American Cultural Center -http://baacc.colostate.edu/ +abstract reasoners. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.19555 (2023) -El Centro -http://www.elcentro.colostate.edu/ +25. Hendrycks, D., Burns, C., Basart, S., Zou, A., Mazeika, M., Song, D., Steinhardt, +J.: Measuring massive multitask language understanding. Proceedings of the In- +ternational Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR) (2021) -Pride Resource Center -https://prideresourcecenter.colostate.edu/ +26. Hendrycks, D., Burns, C., Kadavath, S., Arora, A., Basart, S., Tang, E., Song, D., +Steinhardt, J.: Measuring mathematical problem solving with the math dataset. +arXiv preprint arXiv:2103.03874 (2021) -Native American Cultural Center -https://nacc.colostate.edu/ +27. Huang, J., Chang, K.C.C.: Towards reasoning in large language models: A survey -Student Disability Center -https://disabilitycenter.colostate.edu/ +(2023) -Women and Gender Advocacy Center -https://wgac.colostate.edu/ +28. Huang, Y., Fang, M., Cao, Y., Wang, L., Liang, X.: Dagn: Discourse-aware graph - 40 +network for logical reasoning. arXiv preprint arXiv:2103.14349 (2021) -(970) 491-5781 +29. Iwańska, L.: Logical reasoning in natural language: It is all about knowledge. Minds -(970) 491-5722 +and Machines pp. 475–510 (1993) -(970) 491-4342 +30. Jiang, A.Q., Sablayrolles, A., Roux, A., Mensch, A., Savary, B., Others.: Mixtral -(970) 491-1332 +of experts (2024) -(970) 491-6385 +31. Joshi, P., Aditya, S., Sathe, A., Choudhury, M.: Taxinli: Taking a ride up the NLU -(970) 491-6384 +hill. CoRR (2020) - Victim Assistance Team -https://wgac.colostate.edu/support/ +32. Koreeda, Y., Manning, C.: ContractNLI: A dataset for document-level natural -(970) 492-4242 +language inference for contracts. In: Proc. of EMNLP Findings (2021) +33. Kowalski, R.: Logic for problem solving. Ediciones Díaz de Santos (1979) +34. Kung, T.H., Cheatham, M., Medenilla, A., Sillos, C., De Leon, L., Elepaño, C., +Madriaga, M., Aggabao, R., Diaz-Candido, G., Maningo, J., et al.: Performance of +chatgpt on usmle: Potential for ai-assisted medical education using large language +models. PLoS digital health p. e0000198 (2023) -EQUAL OPPORTUNITY +35. Lai, G., Xie, Q., Liu, H., Yang, Y., Hovy, E.: RACE: Large-scale Reading Com- -Colorado State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, -religion, national origin, sex, or handicap. The university complies with the Civil -Rights Act of 1964, related Executive Orders 11246 and 11375 and all civil rights -laws of the State of Colorado. Accordingly, equal opportunity for employment and -admission shall be extended to all persons, and the university shall promote -equal opportunity and treatment through a positive and continuing affirmative -action program. +prehension dataset from Examinations. In: EMNLP (2017) -SEXUAL HARASSMENT +36. Li, T., Srikumar, V.: Augmenting neural networks with first-order logic. In: Proc. -Colorado State University strives to create and maintain a work and study -environment that is fair, humane, and responsible so that each member of the -University community is treated with dignity and rewarded for such relevant -considerations as ability and performance. Abusive treatment of individuals on a -personal or stereotyped basis is contrary to the concepts of academic freedom -and equal opportunity. Sexual harassment is one form of such abuse and cannot -be tolerated. +of ACL. pp. 292–302 (2019) -Sexual harassment is also illegal. It is prohibited in the employment context by -Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act and in the education context by Title IX of the -Educational Amendments of 1972. Therefore, this policy shall apply to all -persons affiliated with the University, including its students and employees. -Persons who violate this policy shall be subject to corrective action. This policy -prohibits "quid pro quo" and "hostile environment" sexual harassment. +37. Li, Y., Choi, D., Chung, J., Kushman, N., Schrittwieser, J., Others.: Competition- -To learn what constitutes sexual harassment, or what to do if you experience or -witness sexual harassment, please visit this website: -https://oeo.colostate.edu/sexual-harassment-awareness-training/ +level code generation with alphacode. Science pp. 1092–1097 (2022) - 41 +38. Liévin, V., Hother, C.E., Winther, O.: Can large language models reason about - APPENDIX I: FORMAT OF A -RESEARCH PROPOSAL +medical questions? arXiv preprint arXiv:2207.08143 (2022) -I. Abstract: summary of the proposed work +39. Liu, H., Cui, L., Liu, J., Zhang, Y.: Natural language inference in context - inves- -II. Introduction: The introduction should put the proposed project into +tigating contextual reasoning over long texts. CoRR (2020) -perspective and provide a brief review of the pertinent literature in the -field. Be sure to include the scientific rationale for and importance of the -proposed research and specific research objectives, questions, and/or -hypotheses. +40. Liu, H., Liu, J., Cui, L., Teng, Z., Duan, N., Zhou, M., Zhang, Y.: Logiqa +2.0—an improved dataset for logical reasoning in natural language understand- +ing. IEEE/ACM Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing pp. +2947–2962 (2023) -III. Research Plan: Describe the research design and proposed analysis -methods, including study site, study population, etc. as appropriate. + GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models -IV. Expected Results and Products +11 -A. Describe any relevant preliminary research already completed or in +41. Liu, H., Teng, Z., Cui, L., Zhang, C., Zhou, Q., Zhang, Y.: Logicot: Logical chain- +of-thought instruction tuning. In: Proc. of EMNLP Findings. pp. 2908–2921 (2023) +42. Liu, J., Shen, D., Zhang, Y., Dolan, B., Carin, L., Chen, W.: What makes good -progress (if any) and provide relevant figures and tables. +in-context examples for gpt-3? (2021) -B. Discuss any expected research findings (including table and figure -captions if appropriate) and relate these results to the problem you -stated. +43. Liu, J., Cui, L., Liu, H., Huang, D., Wang, Y., Zhang, Y.: Logiqa: A challenge -C. Describe expected research products including scientific articles, +dataset for machine reading comprehension with logical reasoning. CoRR (2020) -factsheets or briefing papers, or other outreach or scientific -presentations and outputs. +44. Liu, Y., Ott, M., Goyal, N., Du, J., Joshi, M., Chen, D., Levy, O., Lewis, M., +Zettlemoyer, L., Stoyanov, V.: Roberta: A robustly optimized bert pretraining +approach. arXiv (2019) -V. Timeline +45. MacCartney, B., Manning, C.D.: Natural logic for textual inference. In: Proceed- +ings of the ACL-PASCAL Workshop on Textual Entailment and Paraphrasing. pp. +193–200 (2007) -Provide the dates of major milestones in the proposed study. +46. MacCartney, B., Manning, C.D.: Natural logic for textual inference. In: Proceed- +ings of the ACL-PASCAL Workshop on Textual Entailment and Paraphrasing +(2007) -VI. Budget +47. Mccarthy, J.: Programs with common sense (2002) +48. McCarthy, J., Hayes, P.J.: Some philosophical problems from the standpoint of -Provide a budget for all expenses needed to complete your proposed -project. +artificial intelligence. In: Machine Intelligence 4 (1969) -VII. Literature Cited - Provide complete references for the literature cited in the proposal. Use -the author-and-year system in standard form (e.g., CBE Style Manual). +49. Newell, A., Simon, H.: The logic theory machine–a complex information processing -The research proposal should be approximately 5-10 single-spaced pages -for MS students and 8-15 pages of PhD students. +system. IRE Transactions on Information Theory (1956) - 42 +50. OpenAI: Gpt-4 technical report (2023) +51. OpenAI: Openai o1 system card (2024), https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.16720 +52. Orrù, G., Piarulli, A., Conversano, C., Gemignani, A.: Human-like problem-solving +abilities in large language models using chatgpt. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence +p. 1199350 (2023) - APPENDIX II: GRADUATE STUDENT TIME TABLE +53. Ott, S., Hebenstreit, K., Liévin, V., Hother, C.E., Moradi, M., Mayrhauser, M., +Praas, R., Winther, O., Samwald, M.: Thoughtsource: A central hub for large +language model reasoning data. arXiv preprint arXiv:2301.11596 (2023) -Please note that Graduate School deadlines are absolute. Plan ahead to avoid missing critical deadlines due to advisor or committee -member travel. All forms are available here: http://graduateschool.colostate.edu/current-students/forms/index.aspx +54. Poliak, A., Haldar, A., Rudinger, R., Hu, J.E., Pavlick, E., White, A.S., +Van Durme, B.: Collecting diverse natural language inference problems for sen- +tence representation evaluation. In: Proc. of EMNLP (2018) -What +55. Poole, D., Goebel, R., Aleliunas, R.: Theorist: A Logical Reasoning System for -___1. Select graduate committee in consultation with -advisor (MS and PhD students only). +Defaults and Diagnosis, pp. 331–352 (1987) +56. Pulman, S.G.: Using the framework (1996) +57. Qin, C., Zhang, A., Zhang, Z., Chen, J., Yasunaga, M., Yang, D.: Is chatgpt a -When -Before end of second term. +general-purpose natural language processing task solver? (2023) -___2. File Program of Study (GS Form 6) with the Graduate +58. Quan, S., Yang, J., Yu, B., Zheng, B., Liu, D., Yang, A., Ren, X., Gao, B., Miao, +Y., Feng, Y., et al.: Codeelo: Benchmarking competition-level code generation of +llms with human-comparable elo ratings. arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.01257 (2025) +59. Saha, S., Ghosh, S., Srivastava, S., Bansal, M.: Prover: Proof generation for inter- -School. +pretable reasoning over rules (2020) -Before end of second term (preferred). Students who -have not submitted their Program of Study by their 3rd -regular semester will have a registration hold placed -on their account. +60. Sanyal, S., Singh, H., Ren, X.: Fairr: Faithful and robust deductive reasoning over -___3. Submit and present a proposal to the advisor and -committee for review and approval (MS and PhD -students only). +natural language (2022) -Before end of second term. +61. Saparov, A., Pang, R.Y., Padmakumar, V., Joshi, N., Kazemi, S.M., Kim, N., He, +H.: Testing the general deductive reasoning capacity of large language models using +ood examples. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.15269 (2023) -___4. Complete preliminary examination (PhD students +62. Sawada, T., Paleka, D., Havrilla, A., Tadepalli, P., Vidas, P., Kranias, A., Nay, +J.J., Gupta, K., Komatsuzaki, A.: Arb: Advanced reasoning benchmark for large +language models (2023) -only). +63. Shi, J., Ding, X., Du, L., Liu, T., Qin, B.: Neural natural logic inference for inter- -By the end of the 5th semester, and at least two -semesters before final examination (defense). +pretable question answering. In: Proc. of EMNLP (2021) -___5. File Report of Preliminary Examination (GS Form 16) + 12 -Within two working days after results are known. +H. Liu et al. -with the Graduate School (PhD candidates only). +64. Suzgun, M., Scales, N., Schärli, N., Gehrmann, S., Tay, Y., Chung, H.W., Chowd- +hery, A., Le, Q.V., Chi, E.H., Zhou, D., Wei, J.: Challenging big-bench tasks and +whether chain-of-thought can solve them (2022) -___6. File the Application for Graduation (GS Form 25) with +65. Tafjord, O., Mishra, B.D., Clark, P.: Proofwriter: Generating implications, proofs, -the Graduate School. +and abductive statements over natural language (2021) -By the 6th week of the graduation term for fall and -spring semesters, and the first week of eight-week -summer term. Refer to published deadlines posted on -the graduate school webpage. +66. Team, Q.: Qwq-32b: Embracing the power of reinforcement learning (2025) +67. Touvron, H., Lavril, T., Izacard, G., Martinet, X., Lachaux, M.A., Lacroix, T., +Rozière, B., Goyal, N., Hambro, E., Azhar, F., Rodriguez, A., Joulin, A., Grave, +E., Lample, G.: Llama: Open and efficient foundation language models (2023) +68. Truong, T.H., Otmakhova, Y., Baldwin, T., Cohn, T., Lau, J.H., Verspoor, K.: Not +another negation benchmark: The NaN-NLI test suite for sub-clausal negation. In: +Proc. of AACL. pp. 883–894 (2022) -___7. File Petition for Committee Member Changes (GS +69. Vaswani, A., Shazeer, N., Parmar, N., Uszkoreit, J., Jones, L., Gomez, A.N., Kaiser, -As committee changes but prior to the final exam. +L., Polosukhin, I.: Attention is all you need. CoRR (2017) -Form 9A) with the Graduate School. +70. Wang, A., Pruksachatkun, Y., Nangia, N., Singh, A., Michael, J., Hill, F., Levy, O., +Bowman, S.R.: SuperGLUE: A Stickier Benchmark for General-Purpose Language +Understanding Systems (2019) - 43 +71. Wang, A., Singh, A., Michael, J., Hill, F., Levy, O., Bowman, S.: GLUE: A multi- +task benchmark and analysis platform for natural language understanding. In: +Proceedings of the 2018 EMNLP Workshop BlackboxNLP: Analyzing and Inter- +preting Neural Networks for NLP (2018) - APPENDIX II: GRADUATE STUDENT TIME TABLE +72. Wang, S., Liu, Z., Zhong, W., Zhou, M., Wei, Z., Chen, Z., Duan, N.: From lsat: +The progress and challenges of complex reasoning. IEEE/ACM Transactions on +Audio, Speech, and Language Processing (2022) -Please note that Graduate School deadlines are absolute. Plan ahead to avoid missing critical deadlines due to advisor or committee -member travel. All forms are available here: http://graduateschool.colostate.edu/current-students/forms/index.aspx +73. Wang, Y., Ma, X., Zhang, G., Ni, Y., Chandra, A., Guo, S., Ren, W., Arulraj, +A., He, X., Jiang, Z., et al.: Mmlu-pro: A more robust and challenging multi-task +language understanding benchmark. In: Proc. of NeurIPS (2024) -What +74. Williams, A., Nangia, N., Bowman, S.: A broad-coverage challenge corpus for sen- -___8. Submit thesis or dissertation to the graduate +tence understanding through inference. In: Proc. of AACL (2018) -committee (MS and PhD students only). +75. Williams, A., Nangia, N., Bowman, S.: A broad-coverage challenge corpus for sen- -When -Two weeks (thesis) or one month (dissertation) before -the final exam. +tence understanding through inference. In: Proc. of NAACL (2018) -___9. Advisor sends an announcement of final exam, +76. Wu, S., Irsoy, O., Lu, S., Dabravolski, V., Dredze, M., Gehrmann, S., Kambadur, +P., Rosenberg, D., Mann, G.: Bloomberggpt: A large language model for finance. +arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.17564 (2023) -Two weeks before final exam. +77. Wu, Z., Qiu, L., Ross, A., Akyürek, E., Chen, B., Wang, B., Kim, N., Andreas, +J., Kim, Y.: Reasoning or reciting? exploring the capabilities and limitations of +language models through counterfactual tasks. arXiv preprint arXiv:2307.02477 +(2023) -including date and time, to the Department -Communications Coordinator for distribution to the -college (MS and PhD students only). +78. Xu, F., Liu, J., Lin, Q., Pan, Y., Zhang, L.: Logiformer. In: Proc. of SIGIR (2022) +79. Yanaka, H., Mineshima, K., Bekki, D., Inui, K., Sekine, S., , Bos, J.: Help: A +dataset for identifying shortcomings of neural models in monotonicity reasoning. +In: Proceedings of the Eighth Joint Conference on Lexical and Computational +Semantics (*SEM2019) (2019) -___10. Advisor notifies candidate and committee of scope +80. Yu, W., Jiang, Z., Dong, Y., Feng, J.: Reclor: A reading comprehension dataset -and nature of final oral exam (MS and PhD students -only). - -One week before final oral exam (MS); one month -before final oral exam (PhD candidates). - -___11. Complete final oral exam (MS and PhD students - -only). - -Prior to the end of the 11th week of the term of -graduation for fall and spring semesters, and the end -of the third week during the eight-week summer term. -Refer to published deadlines posted on the graduate -school webpage. - -___12. File Report of Final Examination Results (GS Form - -24) with the Graduate School (MS and PhD students -only). - -Within two working days after results are known, but -no later than published deadlines. - -___13. Secure the signatures of your advisor, committee, and -the department head on the GS30 Thesis/Dissertation -Submission Form (MS and PhD students only). - -When the advisor and committee approve your -finalized thesis or dissertation. - - 44 - - APPENDIX II: GRADUATE STUDENT TIME TABLE - -Please note that Graduate School deadlines are absolute. Plan ahead to avoid missing critical deadlines due to advisor or committee -member travel. All forms are available here: http://graduateschool.colostate.edu/current-students/forms/index.aspx - -What - -___14. Submit your thesis/dissertation electronically to - -ProQuest/UMI through the Colorado State University -Libraries Electronic Thesis and Dissertation (ETD) -Submission website. Refer to the Graduate School -website for complete instructions. (MS and PhD -students only.) - -___15. Submit data to Primary Investigator for archiving. - -___17. Clearance of all incompletes, course requirements, -and clearance for departmental requirements (GS -Form 25B). - -When -Refer to the published deadlines for the semester in -question. - -By the time the thesis or dissertation is submitted to -the Graduate School. - -By the last day of the graduation term. - -___18. Pay balance of student account, due in the cashier’s - -Before leaving campus. - -office. - -___19. Commencement ceremony (optional; diplomas are not - -awarded at commencement). - -Ceremonies are held in the spring and fall. See the -Graduate School website for complete information. - -___20. Receive diploma from the Registrar’s Office. - -Mailed 6 to 8 weeks after the end of the graduating -term. - - 45 +requiring logical reasoning. In: Proc. of ICLR (2020) diff --git a/q22/random_k4/random_2.md b/q22/random_k4/random_2.md index c0a5f6c70f0875176e47091a53153e71c3cdff7b..310f0f860924656c9ab9a27398fe83594f525660 100644 --- a/q22/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q22/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,851 +1,1527 @@ -In-Context Reinforcement Learning for Tool Use in Large Language Models -YaoqiYe*1 YiranZhao*2 KeyuDuan1 ZeyuZheng3 KenjiKawaguchi1 CihangXie4 MichaelQizheShieh1 -| | | | Abstract | | | | 1.Introduction | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -| | | | | | | | Recent advances | | in large | language | | models | (LLMs) | (Guo | -etal.,2025;Yangetal.,2025;Seedetal.,2025;Teametal., -| While | large | language | | models | (LLMs) | exhibit | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2025)haveshowntheireffectivenessinaddressingawide -strongreasoningabilities,theirperformanceon -6202 raM 9 ]IA.sc[ 1v86080.3062:viXra -complextasksisoftenconstrainedbythelimita- range of complex tasks (Wang et al., 2024a; Hsiao et al., -| | | | | | | | 2025;Shietal.,2025;Quetal.,2025). | | | | | Nevertheless,akey | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------------------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ---- | ----------------- | ------------ | --- | -| tionsoftheirinternalknowledge. | | | | | Acompelling | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | limitation | remains: | these | models | rely | on | a fixed body | of | -| approach | | to overcome | | this challenge | | is to aug- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | knowledge | acquired | during | pretraining, | | which | inherently | | -mentthesemodelswithexternaltools—suchas -| | | | | | | | restricts their | ability | to | adapt | to new | or time-sensitive | | in- | -| ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --------------- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| Python | interpreters | | for | mathematical | | computa- | | | | | | | | | -formation(Gaoetal.,2023;Zhuetal.,2025;Wangetal., -tionsorsearchenginesforretrievingfactualin- -| | | | | | | | 2024b; Cheng | et | al., 2024; | Matarazzo | | & | Torlone, | 2025). | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | -| formation. | | However, | | enabling | models | to use | | | | | | | | | -Tomitigatethisissueandenhancemodelflexibility,recent -thesetoolseffectivelyremainsasignificantchal- -researchhasfocusedonenablingLLMstointeractwithex- -| lenge. | Existing | methods | | typically | rely | on cold- | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | ternaltoolsduringinference. | | | Thisincludesgeneratingand | | | | | -| start | pipelines | that | begin | with | supervised | fine- | | | | | | | | | -executingPythoncodeformathematicalreasoning,lever- -tuning(SFT),followedbyreinforcementlearning -agingwebsearchenginestoaccessup-to-dateanddomain- -(RL).Theseapproachesoftenrequiresubstantial -specificcontent,andinvokingdedicatedhelpermodelsfor -| amounts | of | labeled | data | for SFT, | which | is ex- | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -pensivetoannotateorsynthesize. Inthiswork, specializedsubtasks(Guoetal.,2024;Teametal.,2025;Li -etal.,2025b;Jinetal.,2025a;Fengetal.,2025). -weproposeIn-ContextReinforcementLearning -| (ICRL), | an | RL-only | framework | | that | eliminates | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------ | -| | | | | | | | The dominant | training | | paradigms | for | LLMs | either | lever- | -theneedforSFTbyleveragingfew-shotprompt- agereinforcementlearning(RL)withverifiablerewardsig- -ing during the rollout stage of RL. Specifically, nals(Guoetal.,2025;Jinetal.,2025a;Zhaoetal.,2025), -ICRLintroducesin-contextexampleswithinthe -| | | | | | | | or adopt | a cold-start | strategy | | that begins | with | supervised | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -rollout prompts to teach the model how to in- fine-tuning(SFT)followedbyanRLphase(Meietal.,2025; -| voke | external | tools. | Furthermore, | | as | training | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Nguyenetal.,2025). | | DirectlyapplyingRLfromscratch | | | | | | -progresses, the number of in-context examples often yields poor performance, as the model lacks initial -isgraduallyreduced,eventuallyreachingazero- tool-useabilitiesandstruggleswithineffectiveexploration. -shotsettingwherethemodellearnstocalltools -WhileincorporatinganSFTstagecanguidethemodelto- -independently.Weconductextensiveexperiments wardamorefavorableinitialization,ittypicallyrequiresa -acrossarangeofreasoningandtool-usebench- largeamountofhigh-qualitylabeleddata,whichisexpen- -ICRL -marks. Results show that achieves state- sivetoannotateorsynthesize. -| of-the-art | | performance, | | demonstrating | | its effec- | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | In this work, | | we introduce | | In-Context | | Reinforcement | | -tivenessasascalable,data-efficientalternativeto -| | | | | | 1 | | Learning | (ICRL), | a lightweight | | and | supervision-efficient | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -traditionalSFT-basedpipelines. -frameworkfortrainingLLMstoperformtool-augmented -| | | | | | | | reasoning. | UnlikepriorapproachesthatrelyonSFT,ICRL | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -teachestoolusedirectlythroughRLrolloutsthatareaug- -*Equal contribution 1National University of Singapore mentedwithin-contextdemonstrations. Specifically,during -| 2Salesforce | AI | Research | 3University | | of California | Berkeley | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RLtraining,weconstructeachrolloutpromptbyprepending -| 4University | of California, | | Santa | Cruz. | Correspondence | to: Yi- | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -asmallnumberoffew-shotexamplesthatillustratehowto -| ran Zhao | , | | | | Michael | Qizhe Shieh | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -. reasonstep-by-step,invoketoolsinastructuredformat,and -| | | | | | | | generatefinalanswers. | | Thesedemonstrationsserveassoft | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Preprint.March10,2026. supervisionduringexploration,guidingthemodeltoward -| 1Code | | | | https://github.com/ | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -is publicly available at successfulbehaviorwithoutrequiringlabeledtrajectories. -applese233/ICRL +Department of the Treasury +Departmental Offices + +FY 2025 + +Capital Investment Plan + 1 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Figure1.ICRLtrainingworkflow.Themodelistrainedthroughamulti-stagecurriculumthatgraduallyreducesthenumberofin-context -examplesintherollouttemplate.Ateachstage,theLLMgeneratestool-augmentedrollouts,receivesrewards,andupdatesitspolicyvia -reinforcementlearning,enablingatransitionfromimitationtoautonomoustooluse. -Furthermore,astrainingprogresses,wegraduallyreducethe TheseresultshighlightICRL’sabilitytogeneralizetodi- -numberofdemonstrationsincludedintheserolloutprompts, versetool-augmentedreasoningdomainsanditspotentialas -transitioningthemodelfromfew-shottozero-shotsettings. aunified,scalableframeworkfortrainingtool-usingmodels -Thisprogressivereductionformsacurriculumthatencour- withoutcostlysupervision. -agesthemodeltointernalizetool-usestrategiesandproduce -structuredoutputsautonomously,withoutrelyingonprompt- 2.In-ContextReinforcementLearning(ICRL) -| basedscaffolding. | WeoptimizethemodelusingRLwitha | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -rewardthatbalancestaskaccuracyandformatcorrectness. In this section, we formally introduce tool use in LLMs -Toensurestability,weadoptGRPO(Shaoetal.,2024)with anddescribehowRLcanbeappliedtotrainsuchbehavior. -lossmaskingtoignorenon-trainabletooloutputs. Byem- WealsopresenttheoverallworkflowofICRL,detailingits -beddingandgraduallyremovingdemonstrationsfromthe trainingtemplates,learningprocess,andrewarddesign. -RLrollouts,ICRLmergestheefficiencyofpromptingwith -theadaptabilityofRL,offeringascalable,supervision-light -2.1.ToolUseinLLMs -alternativetotraditionalSFT+RLpipelines. -| | | | | When | LLMs encounter | queries | that exceed | the | scope of | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -Weconductcomprehensiveexperimentsacrossarangeof -theirinternalknowledge,theymustleverageexternaltools -QA and reasoning benchmarks to evaluate the effective- to obtain updated information or perform more complex -nessofICRL.Withoutrelyingonsupervisedfine-tuningor -| | | | | reasoning. | Forexample,searchenginescanprovideaccess | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ground-truthtooltraces,ICRLachievesstate-of-the-artper- torecentknowledge,whilePythoninterpreterscanbeused -formanceonchallengingQAdatasets,outperformingstrong toexecutestructuredreasoningprocedures. -| baselines such | as ZeroSearch | (Sun et al., | 2025), Search- | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Formally,givenaqueryqandanexternaltoolT,themodel -R1(Jinetal.,2025a),andParallelSearch(Zhaoetal.,2025) -| | | | | generates | a response | y = | (y ,y ,...,y | ), where | each | -| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------ | --------- | -------- | -| byupto8.9onQwen2.5-3B(Yangetal.,2024b)and7.3on | | | | | | | 1 2 | |y| | | -| | | | | token | is conditioned | not only | on the | query and | previous | -Qwen2.5-7Binaverageexactmatchaccuracy.Thegainsare -tokens,butalsoonahistoryofpriorinteractionswiththe -especiallypronouncedonmulti-hopreasoningtasks,where -ICRLachievesdouble-digitimprovementsondatasetslike tool. Thisdefinesaconditionaldistributionoftheform: -| TriviaQA(Joshietal.,2017),2Wiki(Hoetal.,2020),and | | | | | | |y| | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Musique(Trivedietal.,2022). Furthermore,incontrastto (cid:89) -| | | | | | π θ (y |q,T)= | | π θ (y t |y | ..., | | | a search | query | | | | | | | | -as ..., a retrieved information andr (θ)=π (τ |q,τ )/π (τ |q,τ ). -| | | | | | | | i,t | | θ i,t | i,...,andafinal -| answeras.... | | | | | | | 2.3.ICRL | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Furthermore,thetoolfunctionsasaresponsemechanism. Training Process. Rather than training models from -Forexample,asearchenginecanbemodeledasaretrieval -scratchusingreinforcementlearning,whichoftensuffers -| | | V∗ | V∗, | V∗ | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -function T : → where is the space of textual fromsparserewardsandinefficientexploration,orrelying -sequences. Givenasearchqueryq′,thetoolreturnsanob- exclusivelyonfew-shotprompting,whichincurssubstantial -servationo=T(q′),suchasthetop-kdocumentsretrieved -inferenceoverhead,weintroduceICRL,aframeworkthat -fromacorpus. Thisobservationisappendedtothemodel’s integrates the strengths of both approaches. ICRL lever- -contextandusedinsubsequentgenerationsteps. -agesthesampleefficiencyandinductivebiasoffew-shot -promptingwhilebenefitingfromtheexplorationcapabilities -| 2.2.RLwithToolUse | | | | | | | ofreinforcementlearning. | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RL Objective Function. After formulating the tool- Atthebeginningoftraining,weincorporateasmallnumber -augmentedreasoninginLLMsasaMarkovDecisionPro- of tool-use demonstrations into the model’s rollout tem- -cess(MDP),wecandefinethecorrespondingreinforcement plate. These examples guide the model toward effective -learning(RL)objectiveasfollows: tool-augmentedreasoningviain-contextlearning,akinto -| | | | | | | | few-shotprompting. | | Theresultingpolicyisdenotedas: | | | | | -| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | max | E | [r | (q,y)] | | | | | | | | | | -| | | q∼D,y∼πθ(·|q,T) | | ϕ | | | | | | | | | | -πθ -| | | | | | | (2) | | | | |y| | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | −βD | [π (y |q,T)∥π | | (y |q,T)], | | | | | (cid:89) | | | | -| | | KL | θ | ref | | | π (y | |P | ,q,T)= | π (y |P | ,y ,q,H | ), | (5) | -| | | | | | | | θ | N | | θ t | N ...everytimeyougetnew -information.Afterreasoning,ifyoufindyoulacksomeknowledge,youcancallasearchenginebyquery -anditwillreturnresultsbetween....Youcansearchasmanytimesasyouwant.Finally, -providetheanswerinside.... -Herearesomeexamples: -ExampleProblem:q -demo -ExampleSolution:...... -......a -| (repeatedforN | | examples | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Nowsolvethefollowingproblem: -ActualProblem:question -| Table2.Formatviolationpenaltiesforcomputingreward | | | | | . | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -format -Algorithm1ICRL -| Violation | | | Rationale | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | Input: | Initial | policy π | , reference | model | π | , tool | -| | | | | | | | | θ | | | ref | | -Notag Mustprovidestructuredanswer T, initial few-shot prompt P , dataset partitions -N -Unbalancedtags ProperXMLstructurerequired {D(N),D(N−1),...,D(0)}, reward function r (·), -ϕ -| Notag | | | Shoulddemonstratereasoning | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Unbalancedtags | | | | | | numberofRLstepsT | | | | | | | -ProperXMLstructurerequired -Nousage Shouldutilizeavailabletool Output: Trainedmodelπ θ -| Emptyanswercontent | | | Answermustbesubstantive | | | 1: fork=N | | to0do | | | | | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | 2: | // Step | 1: Construct | | prompt | with | | -k demonstrations -P ←selectkexamplesfromP -| reward | = 1 if the | prediction | exactly | matches | the cor- | 3: | k | | | N | | | -| ------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | acc | | | | | | D(k)←RLtrainingsubsetforcurrentpromptlevel | | | | | | -| rectanswer,and0otherwise. | | | | | | 4: | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 5: | fort=1toT | do | | | | | -The reward component evaluates the model’s adher- 6: forq∈D(k)do -format -| encetotheexpectedstructuredoutputformat,specifically | | | | | | 7: | π | ←π | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θold θ -| | | | | | | 8: | Sample | N trajectories | | {τ | ,...,τ | } ∼ | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -| thecorrectuseofXMLtags. | | | Itisdefinedas: | | | | | | | 1 | N | | -π (q,P ,T) -θold k -| | | | (cid:88) | | | | foreachtrajectoryτ | | do | | | | -| --- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | reward | =1.0− | penalty(v), | | (8) | 9: | | | i | | | | -format -| | | | | | | 10: | | Computereward:r | ϕ | (q,τ i ) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -v∈V -| | | | | | | 11: | | ComputenormalizedadvantageA | | | i | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -whereV denotesthesetofformatviolationsidentifiedinthe 12: Computeimportanceweightsr (θ) -i,t -| | | | | | | 13: | endfor | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -| model’sresponse. | | Thepenaltyfunctionpenalty(v)assigns | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 14: | Updatepolicy:π | | ←π | −∇ L | | | -apredefinedcosttoeachviolation,asspecifiedinTable2. θ θ θ GRPO -endfor -15: -| Withtheproposedrewarddesign,weoptimizethepolicy | | | | | | 16: | endfor | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| usingtheRLobjectivedefinedinEquation3. | | | | Thecomplete | | 17: endfor | | | | | | | -trainingprocedureforICRLisoutlinedinAlgorithm1. -| | | | | | | convergenceduringRLtraining. | | | Forimprovedtrainingeffi- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.Experiment ciency,allmodelsareloadedusingbfloat16precision. -3.1.Setup -WeevaluatetheeffectivenessofICRLbycom- -Baselines. -Backbone Models. We apply ICRL to the Qwen2.5 paringitagainstseveralstate-of-the-artmethodsfortraining -model family (Yang et al., 2024a), focusing primarily on tool-augmentedLLMs. Thesebaselinesfallintothreemain -Qwen2.5-3B-InstructandQwen2.5-7B-Instruct,andfurther categories. Directpromptingmethodsincludemodelsthat -evaluatingonQwen2.5-14B-Instruct. Wealsoextendour performinferenceusingdirectinputsorpromptingstrate- -experimentstotheQwen3series(Yangetal.,2025),particu- giessuchasChain-of-Thought(CoT)reasoning(Weietal., -larlyQwen3-8B,whichincorporatesRLenhancements. All 2022). Retrieval-basedmethodsleverageexternalinfor- -theseinstruction-tunedmodelsarewidelyadoptedforques- mationthroughtechniqueslikeRetrieval-AugmentedGen- -tionansweringandreasoningtasks. Wechoosetheinstruct eration(RAG),includingstandardRAG(Lewisetal.,2020), -variants over base models due to their strong instruction- InterleavingRetrievalChain-of-Thought(IRCoT)(Trivedi -followingcapabilities,whichenablefasterandmorestable etal.,2023),andSearch-o1(Lietal.,2025a). Fine-tuning- + Major IT Investments + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Cloud Enterprise + +Description: + +Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through +investment in the Treasury enterprise shared services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on +cloud security enhancement and upgraded capabilities to meet security and compliance risks will +involve investment in security controls, monitoring, and increased threat protections by providing a +common cloud operating platform for Departmental workloads, inclusive of all security elements +required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance. Treasury’s recently awarded Blanket +Purchase Agreement (BPA) for cloud services (Treasury Cloud [TCloud]) will support our design, +development, and implementation of security patterns and guardrails with expanded Security +Operations Center (SOC) capabilities to accommodate increased telemetry from cloud assets and +workloads. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +2 0 . 0 7 + +2 5 . 3 3 + +1 5 . 8 0 + +- 9 . 5 3 + +- 3 7 . 6 1 % + +0 . 6 5 + +1 . 6 0 + +9 . 6 3 + +8 . 0 3 + +5 0 1 . 5 6 % + +2 0 . 7 2 + +2 6 . 9 3 + +2 5 . 4 3 + +- 1 . 5 0 + +- 5 . 5 7 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA cloud investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build stronger +protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Cloud Enterprise investment, Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further +accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through investment in the Treasury enterprise shared +services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on cloud security enhancement and upgraded +capabilities to meet security and compliance risks involves investment in security controls, monitoring, +and increased threat protections by providing a common cloud operating platform for Departmental +workloads, inclusive of all security elements required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance. + 4 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Table3.MainResultsofICRL:ExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousdifficultQAdatasets.Thebestperformanceissetbold.The -secondbestperformanceisunderlined. -DifficultQuestionAnswering -| | | Model | Method | | | | | | | | Average | | -| --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | TriviaQA | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | | -| | | | Direct | | 28.8 | 14.9 | 24.4 | 2.0 | | 2.4 | 14.50 | | -| | | | CoT | | 3.2 | 2.1 | 2.1 | 0.2 | | 0.0 | 1.52 | | -| | | | IRCoT | | 31.2 | 16.4 | 17.1 | 6.7 | | 24.0 | 19.08 | | -| | | | Search-o1 | | 47.2 | 22.1 | 21.8 | 5.4 | | 32.0 | 25.70 | | -| | | | RAG | | 54.4 | 25.5 | 22.6 | 4.7 | | 8.0 | 23.04 | | -| | | | SFT | | 29.2 | 18.6 | 24.8 | 4.4 | | 11.2 | 17.64 | | -Qwen2.5-3B -| | | | R1-instruct | | 44.9 | 20.8 | 27.5 | 6.0 | | 19.2 | 23.68 | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | RejectSampling | | 48.8 | 24.0 | 23.3 | 5.9 | | 21.0 | 24.60 | | -| | | | Search-R1 | | 54.5 | 32.4 | 31.9 | 10.3 | | 26.4 | 31.10 | | -| | | | ZeroSearch | | 57.4 | 27.4 | 30.0 | 9.8 | | 11.1 | 27.14 | | -| | | | ICRL | | 72.6 | 35.4 | 39.2 | 20.0 | | 33.6 | 40.16+8.94 | | -| | | | Direct | | 40.8 | 18.3 | 25.0 | 3.1 | | 12.0 | 19.84 | | -| | | | CoT | | 18.5 | 9.2 | 11.1 | 2.2 | | 23.2 | 12.84 | | -| | | | IRCoT | | 47.8 | 13.3 | 14.9 | 7.2 | | 22.4 | 21.12 | | -| | | | Search-o1 | | 44.3 | 18.7 | 17.6 | 5.8 | | 29.6 | 23.20 | | -| | | | RAG | | 58.5 | 29.9 | 23.5 | 5.8 | | 20.8 | 27.70 | | -| | | | SFT | | 35.4 | 21.7 | 25.9 | 6.6 | | 11.2 | 20.16 | | -| | Qwen2.5-7B | | R1-base | | 53.9 | 24.2 | 27.3 | 8.3 | | 29.6 | 28.66 | | -| | | | R1-instruct | | 53.7 | 23.7 | 29.2 | 7.2 | | 29.3 | 28.62 | | -| | | | RejectSampling | | 59.2 | 33.1 | 29.6 | 12.3 | | 35.5 | 33.94 | | -| | | | Search-R1 | | 61.0 | 37.0 | 41.4 | 14.6 | | 36.8 | 38.16 | | -| | | | ZeroSearch | | 65.2 | 34.6 | 35.2 | 18.4 | | 27.8 | 36.24 | | -| | | | ParallelSearch | | 62.8 | 42.9 | 42.4 | 19.7 | | 41.1 | 41.78 | | -| | | | ICRL | | 75.4 | 42.6 | 53.6 | 26.0 | | 48.0 | 49.12+7.34 | | -based methods involve approaches such as SFT (Chung EvaluationBenchmarks. WeevaluateICRLandvarious -et al., 2024), RL without search (R1) (Guo et al., 2025), baselinesonseveralwidely-usedQAbenchmarks,including -andRejectionSampling(Ahnetal.,2024). Wealsoinclude TriviaQA(Joshietal.,2017),HotpotQA(Yangetal.,2018), -recentRLmethodsthatintegratesearchcapabilities,suchas 2Wiki (Ho et al., 2020), Musique (Trivedi et al., 2022), -Search-R1(Jinetal.,2025a),ZeroSearch(Sunetal.,2025), andBamboogle(Pressetal.,2023). Sinceourmodelsare -O2-Searcher(Meietal.,2025),andParallelSearch(Zhao -trainedontheNaturalQuestions(NQ)dataset,weexclude -et al., 2025). These baselines provide a comprehensive NQfromtheevaluationtoavoiddataleakage. Thesebench- -comparisontovalidatethegeneralityandadvantagesofour markscoverdiversedomainsandreasoningtypes,providing -proposedICRLframework. acomprehensiveassessmentofmodelperformance.Further- -more,toensureevaluationefficiency,werandomlysample -| Training | Datasets. | | We use | the Natural | Questions (NQ) | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | upto500questionsfromeachdataset. | | | | Theselectedbench- | | -dataset(Kwiatkowskietal.,2019)astheprimarytraining -marksincludebothin-domaingeneralQAtasks(e.g.,Triv- -| corpus. | The | dataset | is loaded | via FlashRAG | (Jin et | al., | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -iaQA,HotpotQA)andout-of-domainmulti-hopQAtasks -2025b),whichprovidespreprocessedquestion-answerpairs -(e.g.,2Wiki,Musique,andBamboogle),allowingustothor- -| withgold-standardanswers. | | | | NQcontainsrealuserqueries | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oughlytestthegeneralizationandreasoningcapabilitiesof -fromGoogleSearch,eachpairedwithWikipediapassages -differentmethods. -| that | includethe | correct | answer. | To support | ourproposed | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -trainingmethod,werandomlysampledthreequestionsfrom -thewebandusedGPT-5.22togeneratefew-shotexamples Reward. The hyperparameter α in Equation 7 is set to -formattedaccordingtotherollouttemplateshowninTable1. 0.8. Furthermore,fortheformatviolationpenaltiesinTa- -Tosimulatereal-worldtool-usebehavior,weintegratethe ble2,theweightsaresetto0.5,0.2,0.15,0.1,0.1,and0.2 -| SerperAPI3 | | | | | | | respectivelyfromtoptobottom. | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -acrossallmodelstoretrieveliveresultsfrom -| theGoogleSearchengine. | | | Forfairness,eachqueryretrieves | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thetop3documentsrequiredforsearch-basedreasoning. ImplementationDetails. Weimplementourmethodus- -| | | | | | | | ing the Volcano | Engine | Reinforcement | | Learning | (VeRL) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -2https://platform.openai.com/docs/models/ -| gpt-5.2 | | | | | | | framework | (Sheng | et al., | 2024). | Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | -3https://serper.dev/ Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct,andQwen2.5-14B-Instructserveas -| | | | | | | | the backbone | models, | trained | with | a learning | rate of 1e- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ---- | ---------- | ----------- | + The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.4 million for Treasury’s CEA Cloud Enterprise +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate + +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. + +In FY2025, CEA – Cloud Enterprise investments are targeted to the Department’s cloud focused +modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments will build +on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +• Treasury seeks to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +• Bureau of the Fiscal Service cloud cybersecurity modernization and the necessary human + +capital to support initiatives. + +• Cloud security resources (engineers, ISSM, etc.) to support the FY2023 awarded enterprise + +TCloud contract and program. + +• Application migrations from on-premises to cloud environments and/or from unique Bureau + +environments to the enterprise cloud platform. + +• + +Incident response infrastructure to support coordination and communication in an + +uncompromised environment for response and recovery activities. + +• Migration of National Security System infrastructure to the cloud. +• Operations, maintenance, and ongoing investment in a sustainable low code cloud platforms +(i.e., ServiceNow, Salesforce) to support organizational capabilities, to include +Cybersecurity Governance, Risk, and Compliance; CEA Administration and Governance; +and Security. + +• Storage support for enterprise logging collection and utilization of historic logs to support + +threat hunt and threat detection activities, as well as additional behavioral analytics. +• Expansion of the Department’s enterprise offering for public-facing, cloud-based web hosting + +that includes an Akamai CDN with robust DoS and bot protections, a Drupal content +management system, and additional centralized site shield, web performance and +readiness/response investments that integrate with Treasury’s security operations +capabilities for threat detection and response. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + 5 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Table4.Results:ExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousQAdatasets.O2-Searcherappliescold-startSFTbeforeRL,whileour -method(ICRL)appliesRLwithoutSFT. -| | Model | | Method | | SFT | | DifficultQuestionAnswering | | | | Average | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | TriviaQA | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | -| | | | O2-Searcher | | ✓ | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | 59.7 | 38.8 | 37.4 | 16.0 | | 34.4 37.26 | | -| | Qwen2.5-3B | | | | ✗ | | | | | | | | -| | | | ICRL | | | 72.6 | 35.4 | 39.2 | 20.0 | | 33.6 40.16 | | -Table5.Exampleofmulti-turnsearch-augmentedquestionanswering.ThemodelcorrectlyidentifiesGeorgeWashingtonasthepresident -whosetthetwo-termprecedentandretrieveshisinaugurationdatethroughtwosearchqueries. -Question Whendidthepresidentwhosettheprecedentofatwotermlimitenteroffice? -| | GoldenAnswer | | | April30,1789 | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ModelResponse Ineedtoknowwhichpresidentsetthisprecedent. Ialsoneedtoknowwhenhe -enteredoffice.Letmestartbyfindingoutwhichpresidentitis. -presidentwhosettwotermlimitprecedent -Doc1(Title:“Twenty-secondAmendmenttotheUnitedStatesConstitution”) -Untiltheamendment’sratification,thepresidenthadnotbeensubjecttotermlimits,butboth -GeorgeWashingtonandThomasJefferson(thefirstandthird...Doc2(Title:“Amendment22 -–TermLimitsforthePresidency”)ThedecisionforGeorgeWashington–theFirstPresident -of the United States – to voluntarily step down from office after two terms, established an -unofficial...Doc3(Title:“ThefirstU.S.presidentsethisowntermlimit”)Washingtonwrote... - -ItseemsGeorgeWashingtonsettheprecedent. NowIneedtofindoutwhenhe -enteredoffice. -whendidGeorgeWashingtonenterofficeaspresident -Doc1(Title: “PresidencyofGeorgeWashington”)Washingtonwasinau- -guratedasthefirstPresidentoftheUnitedStatesonApril30,1789... Doc2(Title: “George -Washington”)Washingtonwasunanimouslyelected... Doc3(Title:“PresidentWashington’s -FirstTerm(1789-1792)”)GeorgeWashingtonwasinaugurated... - Based on the information, George Washington entered office on April 30, 1789. - -April30,1789 -6. For each query, we sample 8 rollout trajectories with (EM)scoreof40.16,surpassingthebestcompetingmethod, -atemperatureof1.0tocomputethegroup-relativeadvan- Search-R1 (31.10), by +8.94. The improvements are es- -tage. Themaximumpromptlengthissetto5000tokensto peciallypronouncedonmulti-hopdatasetssuchas2Wiki -accommodatefew-shotdemonstrations,andthemaximum (+7.3),Musique(+9.7),andBamboogle(+7.2),demonstrat- -response length is capped at 2048 tokens, allowing up to ing ICRL’s strength in handling complex reasoning and -| 6searchturnsperquery. | | | Toregularizethepolicy, | | | | weap- tool-usescenarios. | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ply a KL | penalty | with | a coefficient | | of 0.001. | Training | is | | | | | | -Furthermore,onQwen2.5-7B,ICRLachievesanaverage -conductedon4NVIDIAA100GPUs(80GBeach),using -| | | | | | | | EMscoreof49.12, | | outperformingthestrongestbaseline, | | | | -| --------------- | -------- | ------------------------------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------- | ------------ | -| abatchsizeof64. | | WeadoptFullyShardedDataParallel | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ParallelSearch | | (41.78), | by +7.34. | It achieves | the best re- | -| (FSDP) | training | with | gradient | checkpointing | | to optimize | | | | | | | -sultsonfouroutoffivedatasets,includingTriviaQA(75.4), -| memoryusage. | | Forretrieval,weuseaBM25retrieverthat | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2Wiki(53.6),Musique(26.0),andBamboogle(48.0).These -returnsthetop-3documentsforeachsearchquery. -resultsshowthatICRLscaleseffectivelywithmodelsize -| | | | | | | | and | generalizes | well | across both | in-domain | and out-of- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | -3.2.MainResults -| | | | | | | | domainQAtasks. | | Theconsistentgainsoverbaselinesthat | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -relyonsupervisedfine-tuningorrewardmodeling—such -Table3presentsthemainresultscomparingICRLtoother -baselines across five popular QA benchmarks. From the asZeroSearch,Search-R1,andRejectSampling—highlight -results,wecanobservethat: theeffectivenessofourin-contextreinforcementlearning -frameworkinlearningtool-usebehaviorswithoutexplicit -accuracy-basedrewardsorsupervision. -| ICRL | achieves | state-of-the-art | | | performance | across | | | | | | | -| -------------- | -------- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| QA benchmarks. | | | As shown | in | Table | 3, ICRL signifi- | | | | | | | -ICRL -cantlyoutperformsallbaselinesonbothQwen2.5-3Band achieves better performance without SFT or la- -Qwen2.5-7BmodelsacrossfivechallengingQAdatasets. beleddata. Table4highlightsakeyadvantageofICRL: -On Qwen2.5-3B, ICRL achieves an average exact match it achieves superior performance without requiring any + Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Multi-Factor Authentication + +Description: + +Treasury’s investment in Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) supports our development and +implementation of compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a +critical component of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, +including nation state actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications +by certifying identity with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an +authentication mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities +include strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption, +and strategic partnerships to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all Treasury Bureaus and +Offices. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +5 . 1 0 + +0 . 6 0 + +5 . 7 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +- 5 . 1 0 + +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % + +2 . 5 0 + +2 . 5 0 + +1 . 9 0 + +3 1 6 . 6 7 % + +- 3 . 2 0 + +- 5 6 . 1 4 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA multi-factor authentication (MFA) investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Multi-Factor Authentication investment, Treasury aims to develop and implement +compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a critical component +of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, including nation state +actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications by certifying identity +with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an authentication +mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities include +strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption of MFA, +and strategic partnerships with industry partners to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all +Treasury Bureaus and Offices. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $2.5 million for Treasury’s CEA Multi-Factor +Authentication investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + 6 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -(a)EMAccuracy -(b)FinishPercent -100 -| | | | | | | 3~2~0 | | 100 | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -3~2~1~0 -| 80 | 75.4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| )%(ycaruccAME | | | | | | | | )%(hsiniFevitalumuC | | | | | | | -80 -60 -53.6 -| | | | | | | 48 | | 60 | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -42.6 -40 -3~2~0 -| | | | | 26.8 | 26 | | | 40 | | | | | | | -| --- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | 20.8 | | | | | | | | | | | | 3~2~1~0 | | -| 20 | | | 17.8 | | | 14.4 | | | | | | | | | -20 -9 -0 -| | A | A | Wiki | | Que mboogle | | | | 0 | | | | | | -| ------ | -------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Trivia | Q Hotpot | Q | | MuSi | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | 2 | | | | | | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 6 | 7 | -Ba -NumberofTurns -Figure2.ComparisonofQwen-7Btrainedforthreestages(3~2~0)vsfourstages(3~2~1~0).(a)EMAccuracyacrossfiveQAdatasets. -(b)Cumulativefinishpercentvsnumberofsearchturns,aggregatedacrossalldatasets. -Table6.Results:Qwen2.5-14BmodelsExactMatch(EM)Accuracy(%)onvariousQAdatasets.Thebestperformanceissetbold. -DifficultQuestionAnswering -| | | Model | | Method | | | | | | | | Average | | | -| --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------ | -------- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | TriviaQA | | HotpotQA | 2Wiki | Musique | Bamboogle | | | | | -| | | | | Direct | | 52.0 | 22.6 | 28.2 | 6.0 | | 15.2 | 24.80 | | | -| | Qwen2.5-14B | | | CoT | | 56.4 | 24.6 | 25.8 | 9.0 | | 40.0 | 31.16 | | | -| | | | | ICRL | | 75.0 | 43.2 | 61.8 | 25.6 | | 53.6 | 51.84 | | | -SFT,incontrasttoO2-Searcher,whichappliesacold-start throughin-contextreinforcementlearning. -| SFT phase | before | reinforcement | | learning. | | Despite | using | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | ------------- | ---------------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| no labeled | tool | traces | or task-specific | | supervision, | | ICRL | | | | | | | | -4.FurtherAnalysis -achievesahigheraverageEMscoreof40.16comparedto -37.26 from O2-Searcher. It outperforms O2-Searcher on 4.1.Ablationanalysis -fouroutoffivedatasets,includingsubstantialgainsonTrivi- -| | | | | | | | | Ablation | on curriculum | | design | for | rollout reduction. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | -aQA(+12.9)andMusique(+4.0).Theseresultsdemonstrate -Weconductanablationstudycomparingtwocurriculafor -thatICRLcanlearneffectivetool-usestrategiespurelyfrom -reducingthenumberofexamplesusedintherolloutprocess: -in-contextexamplesandreinforcementsignals,offeringa -athree-stageschedule(3~2~0)andafour-stageschedule -scalableanddata-efficientalternativetomethodsthatrely -| | | | | | | | | (3~2~1~0). | AsshowninFigure2(a),thethree-stagevariant | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oncostlyannotationandpretraining. -achievessubstantiallyhigherEMaccuracyacrossallfive -| | | | | | | | | QA datasets. | For | instance, | on | TriviaQA | and 2Wiki, | the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -3.3.ConcreteExamples -three-stagemodelreaches75.4and53.6,comparedto20.8 -Table5presentsacompletereasoningexamplefromICRL- and26.8withthefour-stageversion. -| Qwen2.5-7B | on | a question | | from the | Bamboogle | dataset. | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2(b)showsthatthefour-stagecurriculumleadsto -Themodelistaskedwithansweringacompositionalquery: -fasterdecisions,withover80%ofqueriesfinishingwithin -| identifying | the | president | who | established | | the two-term | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | twosearchturns. | However,thiscomesatthecostofanswer | | | | | | -precedentanddeterminingwhenheenteredoffice. Itfirst quality. These results suggest that aggressively reducing -issuesasearchquerytoidentifytherelevantfigure,correctly -| | | | | | | | | rollout length | too | early | (via the | intermediate | stage | with | -| ---------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -| concluding | that | George | Washington | | set the | precedent. | It | | | | | | | | -oneexample)encouragesprematurestoppingandweakens -thenformulatesafollow-upquerytoretrievehisinaugura- -| | | | | | | | | multi-turnreasoning. | | Incontrast,thesimpler3~2~0curricu- | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tiondateandsuccessfullyextractsthecorrectanswer,April -lummaintainsstrongerperformancebyallowingthemodel -30,1789. ThiscaseillustratesICRL’sabilitytodecompose -toexplorelongerreasoningpathsduringtraining. -complexquestions,retrieverelevantinformationacrossmul- -tipleturns,andmaintaincoherentreasoningwithoutexplicit -intermediatesupervision. Itdemonstratestheeffectiveness ModelScalingand14BPerformance. Toevaluatethe -ofourframeworkinlearningstructuredtool-usebehaviors scalabilityofICRLacrosslargermodels, weappliedour + In FY2025, CEA – Multi-Factor Authentication investment is targeted to the Department’s MFA- +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +Conversion to Active Directory (AD) Federation that provides for the authorization, authentication, +and SSO functionality to applications and services virtually anywhere, including perimeter networks, +partner organizations, and the cloud. + +• Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Other Cyber Priorities + +Description: + +Treasury maintains investment in Other Cybersecurity Priorities that address and respond to the +changing threat landscape of the Department, given our interconnected technology environment, which +has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the security posture of high value assets, national +security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, cybersecurity governance, risk, and +compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient +future through the acquisition of federal labor cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our +complex technology portfolio, as well as the necessary resources to support the overall administration +and governance of Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) appropriations and the ongoing +performance of cybersecurity investments. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 7 . 7 9 + +2 . 7 3 + +6 . 0 5 + +3 . 3 2 + +1 2 1 . 5 4 % + +8 . 7 5 + +2 6 . 5 5 + +1 2 . 9 0 + +1 5 . 6 3 + +1 8 . 9 0 + +2 4 . 9 5 + +6 . 0 1 + +4 6 . 5 8 % + +9 . 3 3 + +5 9 . 6 8 % + 7 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -| | (a)ResponseLength | | | (b)Reward | | (c)NumberofValidSearch | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3.Trainingdynamicscomparisonacrossdifferentfew-shotsettings(3-shot,2-shot,0-shot)forQwen-7Bmodel. -Table7.Results:Accuracy(%)onMathQAdatasets. -methodtoQwen2.5-14B-InstructandreportresultsinTa- -ble6.ICRLsignificantlyoutperformsbothdirectprompting -MathQA -andCoTmethods acrossallfiveQAdatasets. Inparticu- Model Method SFT -| | | | | | | | AIME2024 | AIME2025 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -lar, itachieves75.0EMonTriviaQAand61.8on2Wiki, -| | | | | | ReTool | ✓ | 67.0 | | 49.3 | -| ----------------------------------------------- | ------------------- | --------- | --------------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | -| yieldingastrongaverageEMscoreof51.84—surpassing | | | | Qwen3-8B | | | | | | -| | | | | | ICRL | ✗ | 64.1 | | 51.7 | -| CoT | by +20.7 and direct | prompting | by +27.0. These | re- | | | | | | -sultsdemonstratethatICRLcontinuestoscaleeffectively -tolargermodelsizesandbenefitsfromincreasedcapacity, -compareourresultswithReTool,whichisaSFT-RLtrain- -withoutrequiringadditionalsupervisionorannotation. -ingframeworkthattrainingmodelstolearncode-writing -| | | | | and tool-calling | on running | code. | ReTool | (Feng | et al., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ------- | -4.2.Trainingprocess -| | | | | 2025) achieves | the state-of-the-art | | performance | on | code- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -TounderstandhowICRLevolvesduringtraining,weana- -augmentedlong-formreasoningforsolvingmathproblems, -lyzethelearningcurvesacrossthe3-shot,2-shot,and0-shot butitalsoneedsalotofannotateddatatoapplycold-start -curriculumstagesusingtheQwen2.5-7Bmodel.Intheearly -SFTformodelstolearnthetool-callingformatandunder- -stageswithdemonstrations(3-shotand2-shot),themodel standthewholereasoningprocess. However,ourmethod -producesrelativelystableandwell-structuredresponses,as ICRLdoesn’tneedtoSFTthemodelfirst,andmodelscan -| reflected | in the consistent | response | lengths. As training | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------------- | -------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stillreasoningproperlyfromtheIn-ContextLearningwith -progressesintothe0-shotstage,theresponselengthinitially the examples we provides in prompt. From Table 7, al- -dropsduetotheremovalofin-contextexamplesbutgradu- -throughoutmethodunderperformsReToolonAIME2024 -allyincreasesagain,indicatingthatthemodelislearningto by 2.9%, it can achieve better result on AIME2025 with -independentlycomposelongerandmorestructuredoutputs. -| | | | | +2.4%accuracy. | Whichmeansourmethodstillworksfor | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | help models | to learn | other tool-calling | operations | | and is | -Althoughtherewardremainsrelativelysteadythroughout -moredata-efficientthanothermethodsthatneedcold-start -trainingandisbasedonlyonsparsesignals—outputformat -validityandfinalansweraccuracy—themodelstilllearns SFTwiththousandsofannotateddata. -| tousetoolsmoreeffectivelyovertime. | | | Thisismostclearly | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ----------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| reflectedintheincreasingnumberofvalidtoolcallsduring | | | | 5.Conclusion | | | | | | -| the0-shotphase. | Theriseinvalidtoolusageindicatesthat | | | | | | | | | -WeintroduceICRL,asimpleyetpowerfulframeworkfor -ICRLsuccessfullyencouragesthemodeltointernalizetool- -usebehavior,evenwithoutdenseorstep-levelsupervision. training LLMs to use tools via in-context reinforcement -| | | | | learning,withoutrequiringSFTorlabeledtooltraces. | | | | | By | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -incorporatingfew-shotdemonstrationsdirectlyintotheRL -4.3.Generalize -rolloutpromptsandgraduallyphasingthemout,ICRLen- -Apart from conducting our method in web search tool- ablesmodelstotransitionfromimitationtoautonomoustool -callingdomain,wealsoevaluateourmethodbytrainingthe -| | | | | usethroughreward-drivenlearning. | | | Ourmethodachieves | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -models’abilitiesoncode-writingandcallingtoolstorunthe strong performance across a range of QA and reasoning -pythoncodetohelpthemsolvecomplexmathproblems.We benchmarks, outperforming existing approaches that rely + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA investment for other cybersecurity priorities focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment, Treasury maintains investment in +initiatives that address and respond to the changing threat landscape of the Department, given our +interconnected technology environment, which has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the +security posture of high value assets, national security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, +cybersecurity governance, risk, and compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. +Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient future through the acquisition of federal labor +cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our complex technology portfolio, as well as the +necessary resources to support the overall administration and governance of CEA appropriations and +the ongoing performance of cybersecurity investments. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.0 million for Treasury’s CEA Other Cybersecurity +Priorities investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate + +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. + +In FY2025, CEA – Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment is targeted to the Department’s cyber +priorities focused om modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Establish a repeatable programmatic structure to review, assess, and govern emerging + +technologies (i.e., quantum, Artificial Intelligence [AI], etc.) to ensure applications of all +security standards develop consistent policies, workforce planning, reporting, Bureau +adherence, ethical use, etc. + +• Acquisition of an enterprise EDR solution +• Workforce focused cyber awareness and other supplemental trainings +• Enhanced security compliance of a low code platform through Enhanced Adoption and + +Automation of Change Management/Enablement, as well as increased use of common +controls. + +• Evolution of the Enterprise Cyber Risk Management (ECRM) initiative which will continue to + +strengthen Treasury's approach to managing risks across the enterprise and instantiate a +continuous review of all of its critical networks, systems, and data. + 8 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -onsuperviseddataorfrozentool-usepolicies. ICRLalso Hsiao, V., Fine-Morris, M., Roberts, M., Smith, L. N., -generalizesacrossdomains,includingwebsearchandcode and Hiatt, L. M. A critical assessment of LLMs for -execution, demonstrating its flexibility and effectiveness. solving multi-step problems: Preliminary results. In -TheseresultshighlightICRLasascalableanddata-efficient AAAI 2025 Workshop LM4Plan, 2025. URL https: -alternative to traditional SFT+RL pipelines for enabling //openreview.net/forum?id=kFrqoVtMIy. -tool-augmentedlanguagemodels. -| | | | | Jin, B., Zeng, | H., | Yue, Z., | Yoon, | J., | Arik, S., | Wang, D., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | -| | | | | Zamani, | H., and | Han, | J. Search-r1: | | Training | llms to | -ImpactStatements -reasonandleveragesearchengineswithreinforcement -Thispaperpresentsworkwhosegoalistoadvancethefield learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2503.09516,2025a. -| of machine | learning. There | are many potential | societal | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------------- | ------------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -consequencesofourwork,noneofwhichwefeelmustbe Jin, J., Zhu, Y., Dou, Z., Dong, G., Yang, X., Zhang, C., -| | | | | Zhao, T., | Yang, | Z., and | Wen, | J.-R. | Flashrag: | A mod- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | ------ | -specificallyhighlightedhere. -ulartoolkitforefficientretrieval-augmentedgeneration -| | | | | research. | InCompanionProceedingsoftheACMonWeb | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -References -Conference2025,pp.737–740,2025b. -Ahn,J.,Verma,R.,Lou,R.,Liu,D.,Zhang,R.,andYin,W. -Largelanguagemodelsformathematicalreasoning: Pro- Joshi, M., Choi, E., Weld, D. S., and Zettlemoyer, L. -| | | | | Triviaqa: | A large | scale | distantly | supervised | | challenge | -| --------------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | -| gressesandchallenges. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.00157, | | | | | | | | | -| 2024. | | | | dataset | for reading | comprehension. | | | arXiv | preprint | -arXiv:1705.03551,2017. -Cheng,J.,Marone,M.,Weller,O.,Lawrie,D.,Khashabi, -D., and Van Durme, B. Dated data: Tracing knowl- Kwiatkowski, T., Palomaki, J., Redfield, O., Collins, M., -edge cutoffs in large language models. arXiv preprint Parikh,A.,Alberti,C.,Epstein,D.,Polosukhin,I.,Kel- -arXiv:2403.12958,2024. cey, M., Devlin, J., Lee, K., Toutanova, K. N., Jones, -| | | | | L., Chang, | M.-W., | Dai, | A., Uszkoreit, | | J., | Le, Q., and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | -Chung,H.W.,Hou,L.,Longpre,S.,Zoph,B.,Tay,Y.,Fe- Petrov,S. Naturalquestions: abenchmarkforquestion -dus,W.,Li,Y.,Wang,X.,Dehghani,M.,Brahma,S.,etal. answeringresearch. TransactionsoftheAssociationof -Scalinginstruction-finetunedlanguagemodels. Journal ComputationalLinguistics,2019. -ofMachineLearningResearch,25(70):1–53,2024. -Lewis,P.,Perez,E.,Piktus,A.,Petroni,F.,Karpukhin,V., -Feng,J.,Huang,S.,Qu,X.,Zhang,G.,Qin,Y.,Zhong,B., Goyal,N.,Küttler,H.,Lewis,M.,Yih,W.-t.,Rocktäschel, -Jiang,C.,Chi,J.,andZhong,W. Retool: Reinforcement T.,etal. Retrieval-augmentedgenerationforknowledge- -learning for strategic tool use in llms. arXiv preprint intensivenlptasks. Advancesinneuralinformationpro- -| arXiv:2504.11536,2025. | | | | cessingsystems,33:9459–9474,2020. | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Gao,Y.,Xiong,Y.,Gao,X.,Jia,K.,Pan,J.,Bi,Y.,Dai,Y., Li,X.,Dong,G.,Jin,J.,Zhang,Y.,Zhou,Y.,Zhu,Y.,Zhang, -Sun, J., Wang, H., andWang, H. Retrieval-augmented P., and Dou, Z. Search-o1: Agentic search-enhanced -generationforlargelanguagemodels: Asurvey. arXiv largereasoningmodels.arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.05366, -| preprintarXiv:2312.10997,2(1),2023. | | | | 2025a. | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Guo,D.,Yang,D.,Zhang,H.,Song,J.,Zhang,R.,Xu,R., Li,X.,Jin,J.,Dong,G.,Qian,H.,Zhu,Y.,Wu,Y.,Wen,J.- -Zhu,Q.,Ma,S.,Wang,P.,Bi,X.,etal. Deepseek-r1: In- R.,andDou,Z.Webthinker:Empoweringlargereasoning -| | | | | models | with deep | research | capability. | | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -centivizingreasoningcapabilityinllmsviareinforcement -learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.12948,2025. arXiv:2504.21776,2025b. -| | | | | Matarazzo,A.andTorlone,R. | | | Asurveyonlargelanguage | | | | -| -------- | --------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Guo, T., | Chen, X., Wang, | Y., Chang, R., | Pei, S., Chawla, | | | | | | | | -N.V.,Wiest,O.,andZhang,X. Largelanguagemodel modelswithsomeinsightsontheircapabilitiesandlimi- -basedmulti-agents: Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. tations. arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.04040,2025. -InIJCAI,2024. -| | | | | Mei, J., Hu, | T., | Fu, D., | Wen, | L., | Yang, | X., Wu, R., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | ----- | ----------- | -Ho, X., Nguyen, A.-K. D., Sugawara, S., and Aizawa, Cai, P., Cai, X., Gao, X., Yang, Y., et al. O2- -A. Constructing a multi-hop qa dataset for compre- searcher: A searching-based agent model for open- -hensive evaluation of reasoning steps. arXiv preprint domainopen-endedquestionanswering. arXivpreprint -| arXiv:2011.01060,2020. | | | | arXiv:2505.16582,2025. | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + • Development of a low code Configuration Management Database (CMDB) solution, +encompassing both Asset Management and Configuration Management. +• Development of a Risk Management Framework for enterprise infrastructure +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component to + +address current and emerging cyber priorities such as Supply Chain Risk Management +(SCRM) and incident response support. + +• Performance of enterprise-level FISMA readiness assessments. +• Facilitation of an Enterprise Cyber BPA ordering capability (PROTECTS) +• + +Investment in an Annual Threat Hunt that identifies a random sampling of Treasury systems to + +identify anomalies beyond traditional detection methodologies. + +Acquisition of Incident Response support, allowing for defined response timeline in the +event of a compromise and need for SME and resource depth. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Security Logging + +Description: + +Treasury’s investments in Security Logging ensure compliance with Office of Management and +Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security logging capabilities +to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. Investment funding targets +the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, storage and retention of +log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the creation of user +behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The investment objective +is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security operations center at +the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center (TSSSOC). + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +2 5 . 6 6 + +2 . 4 8 + +2 9 . 4 1 + +2 6 . 9 3 1 , 0 8 8 . 2 4 % + +0 . 0 0 + +2 5 . 6 6 + +4 . 0 0 + +6 . 4 8 + +1 1 . 9 2 + +7 . 9 2 + +1 9 7 . 9 0 % + +4 1 . 3 3 + +3 4 . 8 5 + +5 3 8 . 2 2 % + 9 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -Nguyen,X.-P.,Pandit,S.,Reddy,R.G.,Xu,A.,Savarese, for knowledge-intensive multi-step questions. In Pro- -S., Xiong, C., and Joty, S. Sfr-deepresearch: Towards ceedingsofthe61stannualmeetingoftheassociationfor -effective reinforcement learning for autonomously rea- computational linguistics (volume 1: long papers), pp. -| soningsingleagents. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2509.06283, | | | | | 10014–10037,2023. | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2025. -| | | | | | | | Wang, C., | Deng, Y., | Lyu, | Z., Zeng, L., | He, J., Yan, | S., | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --------- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | and An, | B. Q*: | Improving | multi-step | reasoning | for | -Press,O.,Zhang,M.,Min,S.,Schmidt,L.,Smith,N.A., -andLewis, M. Measuringandnarrowingthecomposi- llms with deliberative planning, 2024a. URL https: -tionalitygapinlanguagemodels. InFindingsoftheAs- //arxiv.org/abs/2406.14283. -| sociationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | | EMNLP2023, | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,S.,Zhu,Y.,Liu,H.,Zheng,Z.,Chen,C.,andLi,J. -pp.5687–5711,2023. -| | | | | | | | Knowledgeeditingforlargelanguagemodels: | | | | Asurvey. | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -Qu, C., Dai, S., Wei, X., Cai, H., Wang, S., Yin, D., ACMComputingSurveys,57(3):1–37,2024b. -| Xu, J., | and Wen, | J.-r. | Tool learning | with | large | lan- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | ------------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Wei,J.,Wang,X.,Schuurmans,D.,Bosma,M.,Xia,F.,Chi, -| guage models: | | a survey. | Frontiers | of Computer | | Sci- | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ence, 19(8), January 2025. ISSN 2095-2236. doi: E.,Le,Q.V.,Zhou,D.,etal.Chain-of-thoughtprompting -| | | | | | | | elicitsreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. | | | | Advancesin | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| 10.1007/s11704-024-40678-2. | | | URLhttp://dx.doi. | | | | | | | | | | -neuralinformationprocessingsystems,35:24824–24837, -org/10.1007/s11704-024-40678-2. -2022. -Seed,B.,Chen,J.,Fan,T.,Liu,X.,Liu,L.,Lin,Z.,Wang, -Yang,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B.,Yu,B., -| M.,Wang,C.,Wei,X.,Xu,W.,etal. | | | | Seed1.5-thinking: | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Li,C.,Liu,D.,Huang,F.,Wei,H.,Lin,H.,Yang,J.,Tu, -Advancingsuperbreasoningmodelswithreinforcement -J.,Zhang,J.,Yang,J.,Yang,J.,Zhou,J.,Lin,J.,Dang, -| learning. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2504.13914,2025. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -K.,Lu,K.,Bao,K.,Yang,K.,Yu,L.,Li,M.,Xue,M., -Zhang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Men,R.,Lin,R.,Li,T.,Tang,T.,Xia, -Shao,Z.,Wang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Xu,R.,Song,J.,Bi,X.,Zhang, -H.,Zhang,M.,Li,Y.,Wu,Y.,etal. Deepseekmath: Push- T., Ren, X., Ren, X., Fan, Y., Su, Y., Zhang, Y., Wan, -ingthelimitsofmathematicalreasoninginopenlanguage Y., Liu, Y., Cui, Z., Zhang, Z., and Qiu, Z. Qwen2.5 -models. arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.03300,2024. technicalreport,2024a. -Sheng,G.,Zhang,C.,Ye,Z.,Wu,X.,Zhang,W.,Zhang, Yang,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B.,Yu,B., -R.,Peng,Y.,Lin,H.,andWu,C. Hybridflow: Aflexi- Li,C.,Liu,D.,Huang,F.,Wei,H.,Lin,H.,Yang,J.,Tu, -J.,Zhang,J.,Yang,J.,Yang,J.,Zhou,J.,Lin,J.,Dang, -| bleandefficientrlhfframework. | | | | arXivpreprintarXiv: | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2409.19256,2024. | | | | | | | K.,Lu,K.,Bao,K.,Yang,K.,Yu,L.,Li,M.,Xue,M., | | | | | | -Zhang,P.,Zhu,Q.,Men,R.,Lin,R.,Li,T.,Xia,T.,Ren, -| Shi, Z., Gao, | S., | Yan, L., | Feng, Y., | Chen, | X., Chen, | Z., | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -X.,Ren,X.,Fan,Y.,Su,Y.,Zhang,Y.,Wan,Y.,Liu,Y., -Yin, D., Verberne, S., and Ren, Z. Tool learning in Cui,Z.,Zhang,Z.,andQiu,Z. Qwen2.5technicalreport. -the wild: Empowering language models as automatic arXivpreprintarXiv:2412.15115,2024b. -toolagents,2025.URLhttps://arxiv.org/abs/ -| 2405.16533. | | | | | | | Yang,A.,Li,A.,Yang,B.,Zhang,B.,Hui,B.,Zheng,B., | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Yu,B.,Gao,C.,Huang,C.,Lv,C.,etal. | | | | Qwen3technical | | -Sun,H.,Qiao,Z.,Guo,J.,Fan,X.,Hou,Y.,Jiang,Y.,Xie, report. arXivpreprintarXiv:2505.09388,2025. -| P., Zhang, | Y., | Huang, F., | and Zhou, | J. Zerosearch: | | In- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Yang,Z.,Qi,P.,Zhang,S.,Bengio,Y.,Cohen,W.,Salakhut- -centivizethesearchcapabilityofllmswithoutsearching. -arXivpreprintarXiv:2505.04588,2025. dinov,R.,andManning,C.D. Hotpotqa: Adatasetfor -| | | | | | | | diverse, explainable | | multi-hop | question | answering. | In | -| --------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| Team, K., | Bai, Y., | Bao, | Y., Chen, | G., Chen, | J., | Chen, | | | | | | | -Proceedingsofthe2018conferenceonempiricalmethods -N., Chen, R., Chen, Y., Chen, Y., Chen, Y., et al. innaturallanguageprocessing,pp.2369–2380,2018. -| Kimi k2: | Open | agentic | intelligence. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ------- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Zhao,S.,Yu,T.,Xu,A.,Singh,J.,Shukla,A.,andAkkiraju, -arXiv:2507.20534,2025. -| | | | | | | | R. Parallelsearch: | | Trainyourllmstodecomposequery | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Trivedi,H.,Balasubramanian,N.,Khot,T.,andSabharwal, and search sub-queries in parallel with reinforcement -A. Musique: Multihop questions via single-hop ques- learning. arXivpreprintarXiv:2508.09303,2025. -| | | Transactions | | of the Association | | for | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tion composition. -Zhu,Z.,Liao,Y.,Chen,Z.,Wang,Y.,Guan,Y.,Wang,Y., -ComputationalLinguistics,10:539–554,2022. -andWang,Y.Evolvebench:Acomprehensivebenchmark -Trivedi,H.,Balasubramanian,N.,Khot,T.,andSabharwal, for assessing temporal awareness in llms on evolving -A. Interleavingretrievalwithchain-of-thoughtreasoning knowledge. InProceedingsofthe63rdAnnualMeeting -10 + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA security logging investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Security Logging investment, Treasury ensures compliance with Office of +Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security +logging capabilities to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. +Investment funding targets the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, +storage and retention of log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the +creation of user behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The +investment objective is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security +operations center at the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center +(TSSSOC). + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $41.3 million for Treasury’s CEA Security Logging +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +In FY2025, CEA – Security Logging investment is targeted to the Department’s security logging +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Security Logging efforts to protect against Distributed Denial-of-Services (DDoS) and other +cyber-attacks including 1) increase of storage for Treasury Trusted Internet Connection +(TIC) packet capture data, allowing rapid forensic analysis of suspected attacks; 2) +expansion of Web Application Firewall (WAF) capabilities for applications and services +across the Department; and 3) implementation of indexers at the Network Colocations +which will provide critical cyber visibility and analytics. + +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary + +to strengthen threat analysis, provide Security Operations Center (SOC) support for +sustained cyber attacks, and establish, operate, and maintain the Treasury logging platform. + +• Expansion of the SOC to provide enterprise SOC capabilities for Treasury bureaus, including + +Operations analysts, intake support, Threat & Research analysts, enhanced capabilities, and +associated equipment. + +• + +Investment in cloud-based log processing, storage, and platform licenses. + +10 + + Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Universal Encryption + +Description: + +The Department’s investment in Universal Encryption supports our commitment to fully achieve +encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance (i.e., Office of +Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security Agency [CISA], and +others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest (DAR) and data in transit +(DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our environment, proposed +solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for compliance with encryption +standards and requirements. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 + +2 . 5 0 + +0 . 4 8 + +2 . 9 8 + +1 . 0 0 + +- 1 . 5 0 + +- 6 0 . 0 0 % + +0 . 0 0 + +1 . 0 0 + +- 0 . 4 8 + +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % + +- 1 . 9 8 + +- 6 6 . 3 9 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA universal encryption investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the CEA Universal Encryption investment, the Department supports initiatives that work +toward full achievement of encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance (i.e., Office of Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security +Agency [CISA], and others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest +(DAR) and data in transit (DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our + +11 + + environment, proposed solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for +compliance with encryption standards and requirements. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $1 million for Treasury’s CEA Universal Encryption +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +In FY 2025, CEA – Universal Encryption investment is targeted to the Department’s universal +encryption focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. + +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY 2025 appropriations: + +• + +Investment in Quantum-Resistant Cryptography that could protect the Department against + +cryptanalytic attacks by a quantum computer. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Zero Trust Architecture + +Description: + +Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) investment priorities at Treasury seek to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. + +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. + +12 + + Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 4 . 8 1 + +3 3 . 1 0 + +1 2 . 8 0 + +- 2 0 . 3 0 + +- 6 1 . 3 3 % + +1 2 . 2 7 + +2 7 . 0 8 + +9 . 2 0 + +4 2 . 0 0 + +3 2 . 8 0 + +3 5 6 . 5 2 % + +4 2 . 3 0 + +5 4 . 8 0 + +1 2 . 5 0 + +2 9 . 5 5 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The CEA zero trust architecture investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to +build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation +of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. + +Through the Zero Trust Architecture investment, Treasury seeks to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. Treasury +leverages the Zero Trust Architecture investment to provide additional human capital to support +management of service providers, as well as development, testing, and deployment of the applications +that have the security controls integrated into them. This investment also supports the Treasury Zero +Trust enterprise identity access solution, known as Common Approach to Identify Access Management +(CAIA), for all external federal partners who access the Enterprise Content Management (ECM) +SharePoint platform for shared services. + +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $54.8 million for Treasury’s CEA Zero Trust Architecture +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: + +• + +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an + +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. + +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement + +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. + +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the + +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. + +In FY 2025, CEA – Zero Trust Architecture investments are targeted to the Department’s zero trust +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. + +13 + + Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: + +• Expansion of Treasury’s cyber threat intelligence platform to include additional cyber threat +intelligence feeds, additional material from existing feeds, and expand access to platform +capabilities and shared data. + +• + +Implementation of a TSSSOC lateral scanning capability across enterprise application and + +centralized incident response + +• Acquisition of an enterprise Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solution +• + +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary + +to implement zero trust architecture across the Department’s IT systems + +• Bureau implementation of zero trust architecture +• Development or acquisition of Security Operations Center (SOC) services for the Treasury + +Security Data Network + +• Expansion of Treasury’s mobile Secret Internet Protocol Router (SIPR) capability +• Enterprise-wide vulnerability management efforts including the establishment of an enterprise +penetration testing shared service offering and acquisition of a vulnerability management +tool to track and conduct analysis of enterprise-wide critical vulnerabilities + +• Development of application threat modeling capabilities to prepare for increasing resilience of + +systems and robustness of testing. + +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: + +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to + +threats. + +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information + +sharing. + +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. + +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. + +HR LoB - HRConnect + +Description: + +HR Connect is a Human Resources enterprise system. It is a web-based solution built on PeopleSoft +software. HR Connect transforms core back-office HR functions, moving them from a processing- +centric capability to a strategic-centric capability. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +1 2 . 2 8 + +1 8 . 5 9 + +1 8 . 8 7 + +0 . 2 8 + +1 . 5 1% + +3 7 . 1 4 + +4 9 . 4 2 + +3 7 . 0 5 + +5 5 . 6 4 + +3 8 . 2 6 + +5 7 . 1 3 + +1 . 2 1 + +3 . 2 7% + +1 . 4 9 + +2 . 6 8 % + +14 + + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +HRConnect is Treasury's enterprise human resources system. It is one of four federal OPM HR Lines +of Business providing HR services to the federal government. HRConnect is based on a combination of +(a) web-based solution built on PeopleSoft commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) software, (b) Software as +a Service (Saas) platforms (e.g. Talent Management and Career Connector) and (c) internally +developed applications (e.g. Entrance on Duty System). HRConnect transforms core back-office HR +functions, moving them from a processing-centric capability to a strategic-centric capability enabled +through its commercial software underpinning. Additionally, self-service components of the software +fundamentally transform the standard government HR service delivery model, putting additional +information, services and processes (i.e., personal data, position management, requests for personnel +action, recruitment, reporting, etc.) directly in the hands of managers and employees. + +HRConnect supports the common HR Line of Business processes and provides core HR functionality +that is interoperable, portable and scalable. This shared solution provides automated systems that are +configurable to the individual organizations' needs while providing a single solution across the +Department and federal landscape. HRConnect's core functions include: Personnel Action Processing, +Managing Payroll, Administering Benefits, Time and Attendance and Labor Distribution. By enabling +the retirement of legacy systems and automating and streamlining many aspects of human resources, +HRConnect facilitates increased efficiency and overall productivity for its customers. HRConnect is +the system used by all Treasury bureaus and several other government agencies (over 22 entities) with +over 200,000 employees and contractors in total. + +HRConnect Top FY 2023 Accomplishments: + +1. Implemented 74 HRConnect change requests to maintain regulatory compliance, improve the +employee and manager experience, and provide tools to streamline and enable efficient +processing for HR Specialists. + +2. Maintained a steady state of 100% availability for customers. +3. Treasury HRLOB implemented multifactor authentication (MFA) for all TSSC applications + +and achieved M-21-31 compliance for the HRConnect High Value Asset (HVA). + +4. Completed the migration of HRConnect’s data service, Workforce Analytics from on prem +data centers to a FedRAMP High secure cloud hosted environment, effectively scaling and +maturing the platform. + +5. Delivered Integrated Talent Management (ITM) and HRConnect real-time performance plan + +and learning data integration. + +6. Implemented new Remote/Telework Agreement Type and Program and Project Job Identifier + +fields and Mass Update Process, 34K positions updated. + +7. Streamlined the background investigation security process across Treasury by expanding the + +Adjudication Tracker application to three additional bureaus. + +8. Continued to modernize HRConnect delivering enhancements to improve the user experience + +for employees, managers, and HR Specialists. + +9. Deployed a visual representation of key Time to Hire (T2H) metrics via the Treasury + +Workforce Dashboard to track and optimize the hiring timeline and make data-driven hiring +decisions. + +10. Continued employee self-service (ESS) redesign leveraging fluid concepts. +11. Supported gender identity and other preferred name representation in accordance with + +management directives. + +15 + + Enterprise API Service Platform [MuleSoft]: Transition 15+ partners to the new API Service +Framework. Launched integrations between USAS to DO and FinCEN Adjudication Tracker, ARC- +FS Worklist API and SAM.gov integration to HRC to update vendor information. +In FY2023: Treasury Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) recently assumed responsibility +for the management of the transformation of Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Human Resource +Information Technology (HRIT) applications in support of the Inflation Reduction Act. This transfer of +responsibility allows the IRS CIO to focus their efforts on improving the taxpayer experience +leveraging the Treasury OCIO’s shared services and common platforms to facilitate the modernization +of IRS HRIT systems, the rationalization pillars include: HRConnect, Integrated Talent Management, +USA Staffing, Enterprise Data Management, and the Employee Portal. + +A few of technical improvements, included: Nessus implementation, CAST implementation, piloted +the transition of 3 environments to Oracle Managed Services compartment in Q3, improved the fire +wall configurations and finalized the closure of the Memphis and Martinsburg HRC footprint. + +Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM) + +Description: + +The Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM), formerly submitted +as EIdM, consolidates funding of Treasury implementing the Homeland Security Presidential +Directive- (HSPD) 12, E-Auth, and Federal PKI initiatives. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) + +4 3 . 0 7 + +7 5 . 9 4 + +7 5 . 9 8 + +0 . 0 4 + +8 1 . 6 2 + +7 8 . 9 9 + +8 0 . 9 5 + +0.05% + +2.48% + +1.29% + +1 . 9 6 + +2 . 0 0 + +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +1 2 4 . 6 9 + +1 5 4 . 9 3 + +1 5 6 . 9 3 + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +The TEICAM Business Case consolidates funding that supports Treasury’s implementation of HSPD- +12, FICAM and PKI requirements. This investment supports the target vision of "One Treasury One +Card" to provide universal access. Availability and use of a PIV/identity management standard within +Treasury provides a mechanism for Physical and Logical access to Treasury-wide assets. The TEICAM +phased implementation provides all of Treasury: + +• Trusted identity processes for both Federal and public users of Treasury applications +• Enhanced security (by decreasing data breaches and trust violations) +• Compliance with laws, regulations, and standards +• +• Expanded use of PIV encryption and digital signature certificates (ensuring adoption of multi- + +Improved interoperability + +factor authentication) +• Elimination of redundancy + +16 + + Treasury/TEICAM has achieved many of the defined goals for PIV card issuance, physical access, +logical access, data synchronization, enterprise single sign-on, federation, and PIV required for both +privileged and unprivileged users. These goals have helped the Department align with the required +OMB and FICAM goals. +Additionally, TEICAM has updated the Department strategic roadmap & planned for the following +investment goals: + +1) CDM II-PRIV/CRED Management + +o Continue working with the Managed Service Bureaus and Non-Managed Service + +Bureaus on implementation of Credential (CRED) and Privileged Access Management +(PAM) + +o On-board new bureaus, such as IRS and DO Orbit Organizations (TSSOC, OFR, etc.), + +to the enterprise CDM Managed Service Offering (MSO) + +o Continue working with DHS CISA on the integration activities for the Federal + +Dashboard for Treasury’s CDM Data reporting + +2) Plan, test, & implement the issuance of version 8.1 PIV cards (PIV V8.1) across the enterprise + +in FY21-FY24 + +3) Expand usage of the Enterprise Derived Credential issuance capability to support + +authentication to Treasury services/infrastructure from mobile devices across Treasury in +FY21-FY24 + +4) As part of the PIV-I solution, implement an application programming interface (API) + +connection between a Fiscal Service application used to capture applicant data and +HRConnect in FY21-FY24 + +5) Implement an enterprise Hardware Security Module (HSM) as a service in FY22-FY24 +6) Enterprise solution for tracking and monitoring the Only Locally Trusted (OLT) PKI + +certificates generated and in use within each bureau + +7) Plan, design, and implement a modernized Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) + +solution that enforces multifactor authentication and aligns with the Treasury Zero Trust +Architecture (ZTA) + +8) In an effort to improve cost-savings, the Department utilizes interagency resources to +authenticate users, synchronize data, and to procure and maintain enterprise-wide +compliant PIV credentials (USAccess). As a mixed life-cycle investment, the TEICAM +Operations and Maintenance tasks includes OMB, FISMA, and Cyber reporting specific to +identity, credential and access management. + +Planned objectives and accomplishments include: + +• Maintaining above 95% PIV card issuance rate and providing replacements for the PIV in time + +sensitive activities; + +• Maintained 100% PIV required privileged account access and 97% PIV required unprivileged + +access; + +• CDM II privileged access management is operating with a cloud infrastructure and production +at four bureaus performing O&M functions; we have commenced technical work on +bringing the IRS on as the fifth and largest managed service customer; + +• Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) onboarded 12 new customers and integrated + +with third-party identity providers to expand citizen services and access; +• Executed a Treasury-wide BPA for citizen authentication services access to the entire +enterprise, allowing for secure and fast public access to Treasury systems; + +• Developed an alternative authentication solution and deployed it within 6 weeks to ensure + +continuity of government during the pandemic; + +• + +Implemented a hardware security module (HSM) as a service for the Derived PIV solution and + +DO. + +17 + + • + +Implementation of the department-wide PKI Only Locally Trusted (OLT) monitoring solution. + +18 + + Major Non-IT Investments + +Main Treasury Building and Freedman's Bank Building + +Description: + +Correct life safety and code issues, reduce building systems risk, and maintain the buildings. Absent +full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation, Treasury is utilizing available funding to +correct the most severe issues. + +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): + +T y p e + +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s + +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s + +C h a n g e i n +$ + +% C h a n g e + +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s + +9 . 7 9 + +0 . 0 0 + +9 . 7 9 + +3 . 5 5 + +0 . 0 0 + +3 . 5 5 + +5 . 5 5 + +2 . 0 0 + +5 6 . 2 5 % + +0 . 0 0 + +5 . 5 5 + +0 . 0 0 + +0 . 0 0 % + +2 . 0 0 + +5 6 . 2 5 % + +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: + +This investment is to address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by +upgrading a number of outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building +standards. Absent full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical +buildings, available funding will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being +executed with the expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent +investments could be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments +support a safe and healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project +needs are mission focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs +that pose significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. + +Treasury’s three-step long-term strategy to continue to maintain and modernize its owned spaces: (1) +secure the building’s outer envelope; (2) conduct a condition assessment to identify additional needs +associated with the buildings’ continual aging and deferred maintenance; and (3) based on this +assessment, conduct a holistic modernization of the building’s systems and infrastructure. Targeted +investments address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by upgrading +outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building standards. Absent full +funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical buildings, available funding +will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being executed with the +expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent investments could +be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments support a safe and +healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project needs are mission +focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs that pose +significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. + +Treasury Operations has continued to strategically focus on restoring the health of the building +envelope (shell), to correct the deteriorating building structure and infrastructure. Components of the + +19 + + Main Treasury building that have been repaired, replaced, or funded include new roofs (FY 2019/2021) +and repairs to 40 percent of the windows (FY 2015/2017). The Freedman’s Bank Building components +that have been repaired, replaced, or funded/planned include new roofs (FY 2017/2019), domestic +water line (FY 2020/2022), and replacement of all windows (FY 2009/2011). Funding and completion +of these exterior items represent significant progress towards the preservation of the two buildings, +maintaining a safe and healthy workplace, and reducing damage to the interior plaster and paint. The +contract for the first phase (west façade) of the Main Treasury exterior restoration project was awarded +late in FY 2021 and completed during FY 2022. Exterior restoration work continued through 2023 with +the completion of phase 2 (south) and phase 3 (north) north façades. In FY 2024, assuming adequate +funding, Phase 4 work will commence and, in FY 2025, with this requested funding, work on Phase 5 +will commence. + +The MT Building houses the entire chilled water plant for the Main Treasury Complex. A five cell +cooling tower feeds four water cooled centrifugal chillers providing a total cooling capacity of 2,050 +tons. The chillers are located in a mechanical room under the northwest lawn. The four chillers provide +over 98% of the cooling required for the entire Treasury Headquarters complex; therefore, the plant is +operated 24/7, 365 days per year. The Freedman’s Bank Building (FBB) does not generate chilled +water but rather uses chilled water from the main plant distributed by a dedicated secondary chilled +water pump which serves most air handling units directly. The Chilled Water System is over 30 years +old and has a wide variety of repair needs including bearings, motors, valves, distribution piping, +insulation, controls, and other repairs. The system has redundancy for repairs. However, with all of the +components aging at the same time the occurrence of repair needs combined with the time to repair +diminishes the reliability of the redundant capacity. It is imperative that these items are +repaired/replaced before the available redundancy is lost. A system breakdown would indefinitely +shutdown the Treasury Complex’s daily operations. This first-year cost of a multi-year project includes +design for this effort. + +There is currently a backlog of damaged paint and plaster as well as frayed carpet throughout MT and +FBB. Some of the paint and plaster damage is due to water intrusion. These funds will supplement +other funding to address the backlog in repairing these problems and implementing a regular schedule +of maintenance. The damaged paint and plaster are unsightly and pose potential health and safety risks, +while the frayed carpet is a safety hazard. + +20 -In-ContextReinforcementLearningforToolUseinLargeLanguageModels -oftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Volume -1: LongPapers),pp.16173–16188,2025. -11 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q22/random_k4/random_3.md b/q22/random_k4/random_3.md index 899a20fab830cbeedf8a0c7a609e50156908d80f..176646e2bfa5eda33dc9bb0858d570d16a45ac86 100644 --- a/q22/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q22/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,938 +1,447 @@ -**==> picture [521 x 336] intentionally omitted <==** +Colorado Division +of Insurance Annual +Complaint and +Recoveries Report -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-San Francisco:
A City Resources Guide
**----- End of picture text -----**
+FY 2023-24 (July 2023 - June 2024) + Contents +Facts and Figures � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4 -||||| -|---|---|---|---| -||**Inside the Guide**||| -|**_WELCOME TO SAN FRANCISCO!_**|Iconic Sites of the City|2|| -||Parks|4|| -|The Ofce of Student Life welcomes you to one of the best cites in|Beaches|7|| -|the world! Though we might be slightly biased, we|The Arts|8|| -|truly believe that this city ofers a wide range of opportunites and|Shopping|10|| -|actvites for individuals of all ages, with diferent backgrounds and|Sports|11|| -|varying interests.|Cinemas|12|| -||Food|13|| -|Our aim for this guide is to provide you with a “Clif Notes” version|Sample Itneraries|14|| -|of San Francisco, though we highly encourage you venture out and|Student Discounts|16|| -|do your own exploring of the city and the Bay Area as a whole.|Neighborhood informaton|18|| -|If you have any questons, stop by Suite 208.|San Francisco Websites|19|| -|Enjoy your urban adventure!|Yearly Events and Festvals|20|| -||Useful San Francisco Apps|22|| +Digging Deeper Into Issues � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 +Helping Coloradans Navigate Homeowners Insurance +6 -**==> picture [144 x 100] intentionally omitted <==** +Answers and Education � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 -**==> picture [151 x 101] intentionally omitted <==** +Digging Deeper Into Issues � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 8 -**==> picture [151 x 100] intentionally omitted <==** +Providing a Better Understanding of Health Insurance -Page 2 +8 -## _**If you’re in the mood to visit the iconic sites of San Francisco...**_ +Out-of-Network Labs � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 8 -**==> picture [213 x 160] intentionally omitted <==** +Helping Consumers Understand Long-Term Care Insurance +Policy Options � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 9 -## **Golden Gate Bridge** +Consumers’ Stories � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 10 -One of the most instantly recognizable bridges in the world, the Golden Gate Bridge is truly a regal sight to see, and with a bright orange coat of paint, it’s surely near impossible to miss. There are view points on the north side and the south side, and there are numerous companies that rent bicycles that you can ride on the lower deck of the bridge. Make sure to bring a jacket, it gets windy! +Delay in Hail Damage Claim � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 10 -**==> picture [267 x 193] intentionally omitted <==** +Transplant Results in Out-of-Network Billing � � � � � � � � � 10 -## **Alcatraz** +Smoke Damage from Marshall Fire � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 11 -A facility that once operated as a military base, a lighthouse, and prison, Alcatraz once was the home of America’s most notorious mobster, Al Capone. Alcatraz became a National Historic Landmark in 1986, offering historical tours around the facility and the island. Make sure to buy your tickets ahead of time, you’re competing with a lot of international tourists! The Halloween night tour is also a favorite, make sure you take it during your time in the city. +Following Through on Network Exception � � � � � � � � � � � 12 -## _**Did you know that San Francisco has 215 historic landmark buildings, ten historical districts, and 14,000 Victorian homes?**_ +Improper Delay for Life Insurance Claim � � � � � � � � � � � � 12 -## **SF Cable Cars** +Travel Insurance Not Paying Hospital Bill � � � � � � � � � � � � 13 -A little-known fact: the San Francisco Cable Car System is the last manually-operated Cable Car Systems in the world. With a rich history in San Francisco starting in 1873, the Cable Cars now operate on three lines close to downtown. The most popular line, the Powell-Hyde line, runs from Union Square (Powell and Market) all the way down to Fisherman’s Wharf (Beach and Hyde) offering pristine views of the Bay. Hang onto the bars as you go up the hills – they’re incredibly steep! +Getting Medical Claims Paid � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 13 -**==> picture [250 x 191] intentionally omitted <==** +Contact the Colorado Division of Insurance � � � � � � � � � � � 14 -Page 3 +2 | -**==> picture [268 x 179] intentionally omitted <==** + Colorado Division of Insurance Annual +Complaint and Recoveries Report -## **Alamo Square/Painted Ladies** +FY 2023-24 (July 2023 - June 2024) -The Painted Ladies at Alamo Square are mostly known not only for their beauty and elegance, but from the opening credits scene of the late 80s/early 90s American television show _Full House_ . Put simply, a Painted Lady is a term used for Victorian and Edwardian houses and buildings painted in three or more colors that enhance their architectural beauty. Most noted houses (including Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin’s old houses on Central) are clustered around the Haight neighborhood, but there are several other Painted Ladies scattered throughout the city. +The Colorado Division of Insurance (DOI), part of the Department of Regulatory Agencies +(DORA), regulates insurance in Colorado - the insurance companies as well as insurance +agents/brokers. But the DOI is also a resource for Coloradans on insurance matters. We +answer consumers’ questions, investigate consumers’ complaints and generally explain +the world of insurance to the public. Most of this work is done by the Consumer Services +Team, which is split into two components - Property & Casualty Insurance and Life & Health +Insurance. The Consumer Services Team also works with other DOI teams as necessary, +especially when systemic issues with insurance companies are identified through complaints +received and interactions with consumers. -## **Lombard Street** +This report covers the consumer complaints submitted to the DOI, the work in investigating +the complaints, and the money recovered for consumers throughout the 2023-24 fiscal year +(FY 2023-24; July 2023 - June 2024). During that fiscal year, the Consumer Services Team +received more complaints as compared to the previous year, and recovered more money +for Coloradans. -Featured in multiple films and TV shows, the steep and beautiful Lombard Street is indeed as steep and beautiful as you imagine it to be—and more! You’ll pass this street on your Cable Car Ride down to Fisherman’s Wharf. +For the Property & Casualty section, complaints were mostly centered around homeowners +and auto insurance. This group not only investigated and resolved these complaints, but also +worked to educate consumers regarding the current challenges in the homeowners insurance +market and served as a valuable resource by providing assistance to consumers in Colorado. -**==> picture [268 x 168] intentionally omitted <==** +The Life & Health group received fewer complaints compared to the previous year. However, +they investigated nearly 2,000 complaints while helping consumers navigate their health +insurance. -## **Pier 39** +Ensuring access to care for Colorado consumers continued to be top of mind for the DOI in +working through consumers’ questions and complaints. -Pier 39 is a busy hub of the Fisherman’s Wharf neighborhood, full of shops, tourist attractions, restaurants, and street performers. Pier 39 is most notably known for its Sea Lions that come and sprawl out on the docks every year. + | 3 -**==> picture [231 x 164] intentionally omitted <==** + Money Recovered for +Colorado Consumers -## **Haight/Ashbury** +Facts and +Figures -Most known as the incubator of the 1967 Summer of Love, the Haight-Ashbury (also known as the Upper Haight) neighborhood once drew out thousands of hippies and revolutionaries from all of the country. Today, it is still true to its history and maintains a bohemian ambiance, although there are a number of franchises that have made their home on the famous Haight Street. Great for shopping, people watching, and close walking distance from Golden Gate Park, the Haight-Ashbury is a fun neighborhood that demands a visit. +This is money that goes to consumers in situations where +the DOI finds that an insurance company improperly +denied a claim, or did not initially pay the correct claim +amount. Recoveries can also come about when a company +is delaying payment on a claim or has not followed State +insurance law and regulations. -**==> picture [230 x 187] intentionally omitted <==** +Property & Casualty Insurance -Page 4 +Total Money +Recovered +for Colorado +Consumers +$26,487,192 -## _**Iconic Sites, Continued...**_ +(an increase over the previous +year’s total of $21,523,066) -## **Mission Dolores** +Money recovered +on homeowners +insurance complaints -Mission Dolores has always had a central place in the religious, civic, and cultural life of San Francisco. Misión San Francisco de Asís was founded June 29, 1776, under the direction of Father Junipero Serra and is both the oldest original intact Mission in California and the oldest building in San Francisco. Today, the Mission Dolores Parish comprises both the Basilica and the Old Mission. The Old Mission's religious, historic, and architectural significance makes it a unique and memorable destination for visitors to San Francisco; it located at the intersection of 16th and Dolores Street. +$10,601,710 -## **Chinatown** +Money recovered +on auto insurance +complaints +$4,995,340 -Practically a city within a city, San Francisco’s Chinatown is the oldest Chinatown in North America and hoses the largest Chinese community outside of Asia. Since Angel Island (the Ellis Island of the Western United States) is not too far away from San Francisco, Chinese immigrants came here to establish their own community. Chinatown continues to hold on to a lot of historically formed organizations that thrive in this ethnic enclave. With stunning architecture, curious stores and plenty of people-watching, Chinatown is most certainly worth the visit. +$19,253,299 +total recovered -**==> picture [225 x 169] intentionally omitted <==** +Life & Health Insurance -**==> picture [238 x 169] intentionally omitted <==** +Money recovered +on health insurance +complaints -## _**If you’re in the mood for park explorations...**_ +$4,080,002 -San Francisco is home to a number of parks that offer a get-away from the hustle and bustle of city life. Whether it’s a long afternoon stroll through Golden Gate Park, a Lord-of-the-Rings-like quest up Twin Peaks or Corona Heights, or simply laying out in the sun atop Alamo Square, you’ll be sure to find a park in your neighborhood that fits your lifestyle. The following are a list of well-known parks in San Francisco. +Money recovered on +life insurance and +annuity complaints +$3,152,428 -## **Golden Gate Park** +$7,232,430 +total recovered -Often referred to as the “Central Park of the West Coast,” Golden Gate Park spans 1.5 square miles in the north west quadrant of the city. With an estimate of 13 Million visitors annually, Golden Gate Park is the 3rd most visited park In the United States. There are so many places to go and see inside the park that each trip will offer a new experience: a tea ceremony at the Japanese Tea House, a breathtaking museum exhibit, an encounter with Bison, a music festival, or anything else in between. A list of some highlights in the park can be found below. For more information on events and to download a comprehensive map of the park, visit www.golden-gate-park.com. +4 | Facts and Figures -**==> picture [301 x 175] intentionally omitted <==** + Facts and Figures -_Birds-eye view of Golden Gate Park_ +Property & Casualty +Insurance Complaints -Page 5 +Life & Health +Insurance Complaints -## **Dolores Park** +Total Property & +Casualty Insurance +Complaints Received -This Park is a lazy haven in the MissionDolores neighborhood. Located next to the historic Mission Dolores, this park draws everyone and anyone looking to relax and curl up in a sunbeam. Dolores Park is host to numerous festivities throughout the year, including SF Pride Festival, the Hunky Jesus Competition, and the Fourth of July. In addition to the sunny fields, there are basketball courts, tennis courts, and frequent food truck visitors. There is no other park quite like Dolores, so it begs to be checked out. The park is located between 18[th] and 19[th] streets on Dolores Street. +3,829 -## **The Presidio** +1,929 -The Presidio is a beautiful and somewhat secluded park area of San Francisco that once served as an Army Post for 2 nations. The Presidio is home to numerous hiking and walking trails, a golf course, old forts and barracks, and rows of Eucalyptus trees that permeate the air with zesty refreshment. Towards the northern part of the park are beaches and stunning views of the Bay and the Golden Gate Bridge, which actually emerges from the Presidio, not Golden Gate Park which some might assume! This park is truly dazzling and deserves a visit. +Total Life & Health +Insurance Complaints +Received -## **Sutro Baths/Land’s End** +Complaints +specifically related +to homeowners +insurance -Located at the top left corner of the city, the Sutro Bath Ruins are a beautiful sight to see. The Sutro Baths was, at one time, the world’s largest indoor swimming pool establishment. Unfortunately it burned down in the late 1960s, and all that is left of them are the ruins in a cove that opens up to the Pacific Ocean. These ruins are adjacent to Land’s End Park which offers peaceful scenic trails along the coast. +1,504 -## **Sutro Baths** +Complaints +and Inquiries +Received +6,987 -Point Lobos Ave at 48th Avenue Golden Gate National Recreation Area San Francisco, CA 94121 +Complaints and +Inquiries Closed + 7,327 -**==> picture [314 x 177] intentionally omitted <==** +1,716 -**==> picture [315 x 182] intentionally omitted <==** +Complaints +specifically related +to health insurance -**==> picture [314 x 194] intentionally omitted <==** +Note: Some complaints take longer than others to fully +investigate, so not all complaints are resolved in the year they +are received. This figure also includes 2,218 inquiries, which +are instances when a consumer’s complaint involves an easily +resolved question or falls outside of the DOI’s authority to +regulate. These complaints still require the Consumer Services +Team to contact the consumer to answer their questions and +educate them on their options. -Page 6 +14,741 -## _**Parks, Continued...**_ +Telephone Calls: 14,741 -## **Buena Vista Park** - -Buena Vista Park is the oldest official park in San Francisco, offering stunning views of the City’s northern quadrant. Bordered by Haight Street to the north, this park is convenient to get to and to explore. **Buena Vista Park** Haight Street & Buena Vista East San Francisco, CA 94101 - -**==> picture [321 x 193] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Coit Tower** - -Offering some of the best views of the city, this 210 foot tower is located in the Telegraph Hill neighborhood of San Francisco. Once you hike up the steep hills to get to the tower (it’s accessible by car….) you can take an elevator up the tower to check out the views. **Coit Tower** 1 Telegraph Hill Blvd (at Greenwich St) San Francisco, CA 94133 - -**==> picture [321 x 180] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Twin Peaks** - -If San Francisco were a Cartesian Axis, Twin Peaks would be the origin. Practically in the geographical center of the city, Twin Peaks offers 360 degree panoramic views of the entire city. Bring a jacket, it gets windy up there! **Twin Peaks** 501 Twin Peaks Blvd (between Burnett Ave & Christmas Tree Point Rd) San Francisco, CA 94114 - -**==> picture [325 x 194] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 7 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for the Beach…**_ - -**==> picture [237 x 149] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [237 x 152] intentionally omitted <==** - -**East Beach** - -## **Baker Beach** - -Marina/Cow Hollow, North edge of Crissy Field. Golden Gate is to your left and Alcatraz to the right and Tiburon right in front of you. - -A public beach, roughly a half mile long, the north end is considered “clothing optional.” Located just southwest of the Golden Gate Bridge, it boasts a stunning, close-up view! - -**==> picture [240 x 135] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [237 x 134] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **China Beach** - -Small cove in San Francisco’s Sea Cliff neighborhood. This is one of the cleanest in the state. Robin Williams and other famous celebrities have houses nearby. - -## **Ocean Beach** - -Runs along the west coast of San Francisco at the Pacific Ocean. Part of Golden Gate National Recreation Area. Great Highway runs along the beach and the Cliff House and former Sutro Baths are at the northern end. - -**For more information about San Francisco Parks, please visit the San Francisco Recreation and Parks website** - -**www.sfrecpark.org** - -Page 8 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for the Arts...**_ - -San Francisco is overflowing with museums and cultural centers. From the Contemporary Jewish Museum to the Museum of Modern Art, there is an exhibit somewhere in the city for your specific interests. The following is a list of some of the well-known museums in the city; please note that there are dozens more that are not listed here. - -**==> picture [164 x 66] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **California Academy of Sciences** - -Featuring an Aquarium, a Planetarium, a natural history museum and more. www.calacademy.org - -**==> picture [144 x 55] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Legion of Honor** - -Legion of Honor has a collection of more than 6,000 years of ancient European Art. www.legionofonor.famsf.org - -**==> picture [130 x 47] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **San Francisco Museum of Modern Art** - -Currently exhibiting over 26,000 contemporary works of art with new exhibits coming every few months, this museum will be sure to leave your senses stimulated. www.sfmoma.org - -**==> picture [166 x 42] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Contemporary Jewish Museum** - -Established in 1984, this museum offers contemporary perspectives on Jewish culture, history, art, and ideas www.thecjm.org - -**==> picture [97 x 51] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Yerba Buena Center for the Arts** - -A contemporary art center featuring visual art, performance, and film/video celebrating local, national and international artists. www.ybca.org - -**==> picture [88 x 42] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **deYoung Museum** - -Located in Golden Gate park, the deYoung museum showcases International art from the 17th through the 21st - -www.deyoung.famsf.org - -**==> picture [130 x 57] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Exploratorium** - -Now at their new home on Pier 15, this center builds innovative exhibits that foster creativity and encourage exploration. www.exploratorium.edu - -**==> picture [63 x 78] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Oakland Museum of California** - -OCMA showcases California’s Identity and character through cultural diversity, creativity, and innovations. www _._ museumca.org - -Page 9 - -## _**Arts, Continued...**_ - -**==> picture [123 x 58] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [78 x 8] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Asian Art Museum
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Located in the Civic Center, the Asian Art Museum is filled with stunning exhibits; a city-wide favorite for contemporary and historical Asian art. www.asianart.org - -**==> picture [62 x 62] intentionally omitted <==** - -**GLBT history museum** - -A unique museum featuring collections that document the historical journey of the city’s GLBT community. www.glbthistory.org - -**==> picture [168 x 52] intentionally omitted <==** - -**San Francisco Conservatory of Flowers** - -A unique museum bursting with life, full of flowers from around the world. - -www.conservatoryofowers.org - -**==> picture [59 x 59] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **The Beat Museum** - -A tribute to the writers, thinkers, and artists that congregated in 1950s San Francisco. www.kerouac.com - -## _**If you’re in the mood for some Aquariums and Zoos...**_ - -**==> picture [80 x 103] intentionally omitted <==** - -**San Francisco Zoo** - -Home to a unique assortment of wildlife from around the world, the SF Zoo is definitely worth a visit. - -www.sfzoo.org - -**==> picture [148 x 96] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Monterey Bay Aquarium** - -A two-hour drive from San Francisco, Monterey is a quaint seaside town and a refreshing escape from big-city life. If you end up driving down to Monterey, don’t miss out on this famous Aquarium **.** www.montereybayaquarium.org - -**==> picture [111 x 93] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Oakland Zoo** - -On-par with the SF Zoo, this Conservation and Education Center is located across the Bay Bridge in the East Bay. www.oaklandzoo.org - -_**Did you know that most museums in San Francisco have “free days?”**_ On the first Sundays of every month, gain free entry to Asian Art Museum, and the Oakland museum of California On the first Tuesdays of every month, gain free entry to the YBCA, de Young, Conservatory of Flowers, and the Contemporary Jewish Museum On the first Wednesday of every month, gain free entry to the SF Zoo, and the LGBT Museum On the first Thursday of every month, gain free entry to the Chinese Historical Society, Berkeley Art Museum, and the Pacific Film Archive - -Page 10 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for shopping…**_ - -Just like any other city, San Francisco has everything from high-end Fashion Malls to one-of-a-kind Boutiques, to Thrift Stores to Junk Shops. The following is an introductory list of locations where you can get your shopping fix. - -**==> picture [167 x 94] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [142 x 94] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [127 x 95] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Union Square/Downtown** - -Union Square and the Downtown area is home to numerous brand-name stores. All of your major shopping needs are located here. - -## **Westield Mall** - -Located downtown across the street from the Cable Car Turnaround at Powell and Market, this several-story building will keep your entertained (or frustrated?) for hours. - -## **Hayes Valley** - -Located around the corner from the Conservatory, there are several cute Boutiques to browse (though they can be on the pricey side!) - -**==> picture [168 x 94] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **- Haight Ashbury** - -The site of the famous “Summer of Love,” Haight-Ashbury has plenty of boutique shops and vintage stores and is quite an amusing area to browse! - -**==> picture [158 x 100] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Stonestown Galleria** - -For those who don’t want to make the trek to downtown, the Stonestown Galleria is located on the opposite end of the city and can satisfy all of your mall needs. - -**==> picture [128 x 97] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [142 x 93] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **North Beach** - -## **The Mission** - -Home to several thrift shops, variety stores, and quirky boutiques and antique stores, one can easily spend hours shopping in the Mission. - -Home to vintage shops, cute cafes, and the famous City Lights Bookstore, North Beach is a stimulating neighborhood to wander around in. - -## **Outlet Shopping** - -There are a few Outlet stores located throughout the Bay Area. If you need help finding what you need, contact the Office of Student Life. - -**==> picture [90 x 50] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [62 x 49] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [95 x 49] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [271 x 28] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-321 Nut Tree Rd #2 629 Factory Stores Dr 681 Leavesley Rd
Vacaville, California Napa Gilroy
(707) 447-5755 (707) 226-9876 (408) 842-3729
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Page 11 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for sports...**_ - -San Francisco is home to World Champions in both Baseball and Football. In the Bay area there are also a number of other Professional Teams in Hockey and Basketball. Below is a list of the local teams, be sure to root for them at the next game! - -**==> picture [226 x 128] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [69 x 51] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **San Francisco Giants** - -The San Francisco Giants are the winners of the 2012 and 2010 World Series. During the season they play at AT&T Park. - -Catch them at **24 Willie Mays Plaza San Francisco, CA** www.sanfrancisco.giants.mlb.com - -_Giant’s Stadium_ - -**==> picture [212 x 153] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [61 x 62] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **The Golden State Warriors** - -The Warriors are the local Basketball team. Games are fun and tickets are cheap, what more could you want? Catch them at **7000 Coliseum Way Oakland, CA 94621** www.nba.com/warriors - -_Oakland Coliseum_ - -**==> picture [214 x 145] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [63 x 61] intentionally omitted <==** - -**The Oakland Athletics** The A’s, as they’re called, Oakland’s baseball team, also play at the Oakland Coliseum. 7000 Coliseum Way Oakland, CA 94621 www.oakland.athletcs.mlb.com - -_The old Candlestick Pack_ - -**==> picture [148 x 99] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [88 x 88] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [102 x 74] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [89 x 53] intentionally omitted <==** - -**San Francisco 49ers** The San Francisco 49ers is the local SF Football team. During the season they will play at the new Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara at **4900 Centennial Blvd Santa Clara, CA** www.49ers.com - -**==> picture [59 x 62] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Oakland Raiders** Known for their loyal fan base and team fan culture, the Raiders are an Oakland-based Football team with a small rivalry with the 49ers. Catch - -them at **7000 Coliseum Way Oakland, CA 94621 www.raiders.com** - -**==> picture [66 x 66] intentionally omitted <==** - -**San Jose Sharks** A member of the National Hockey League, the San Jose Sharks play at the HP Pavillion in San Jose. **525 W. Santa Clara Street San Jose, CA 95113** www.sharks.nhl.com - -**==> picture [74 x 74] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 12 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for a movie...**_ - -San Francisco is home to several independent and chain movie theaters. Whether it’s an independent film or sing-along special at the Castro Theater or the latest Hollywood blockbuster, you'll be sure to find a venue playing what you want to watch. **The Office of Student Life has discount AMC Movie Passes available in Suite 208 for $8 a ticket. Stop by to get yours today!** - -## **Independent Theaters** - -## **Corporate Theaters** - -## **4-Star Theater** - -## **AMC Van Ness 14** - -## **Castro Street Theater** - -2200 Clement St www.lntsf.com MUNI Lines: 38, 1 - -1000 Van Ness Avenue @ O’Farrell MUNI lines: 38. 49, 47 - -429 Castro Street - -www.castrotheatre.com MUNI lines: 33, 24, L, M, K - -**AMC Metreon 16** 135 4[th] Street @ Mission MUNI Lines: J, K, L, M ,N - -## **Marina Theater** - -**Presidio Theater** 2340 Chestnut St www.lntsf.com MUNI Lines: 10, 1, 43, 24 - -2149 Chestnut St www.lntsf.com MUNI lines: 30, 24, 1 - -**==> picture [160 x 107] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [132 x 109] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Balboa Theatre** 3630 Balboa St www.cinemasf.com/balboa/ MUNI Lines: 31, 18, 38 - -**==> picture [164 x 101] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [151 x 95] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [150 x 85] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [103 x 47] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [154 x 61] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [124 x 182] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [103 x 55] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [107 x 137] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [256 x 108] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 13 - -## _**If you’re in the mood for some good food...**_ - -Foodies will have no problem finding a myriad of dishes in San Francisco that suit their taste buds. Thanks to the City’s tremendous cultural diversity, we are blessed with an assortment of options from Burgers to Burmese and from Thai to Tapas. San Francisco also has a rich food-truck culture with pop-up food parks scattered throughout the city. While this is not a comprehensive list of every restaurant or cuisine option in the city, it is certainly a good starting point. - -## **Neighborhood Cuisines** - -**Richmond and Sunset Districts Tenderloin District/Downtown Mission District** Burmese Indian/Pakistani Mexican (and other Central American Cuisines) Vietnamese Vietnamese Peruvian Thai Cambodian Pilipino Chinese (various regional styles) Thai Chinese Korean Lebanese Japanese Eritrean Mediterranean Russian Burmese **North Beach** Japanese “American” Italian Thai **Hayes Valley Castro** Cafés & Deli’s Korean French Italian Mexican **Glen Park/Balboa Park** Thai Spanish French “American” Various Bistros Chinese Italian Italian Mexican - -## **Food Trucks & Street Food** - -## _**The Office of Student Life Recommends…**_ - -## **Of the Grid** - -Off the Grid is a San Francisco Food Truck Fair that takes place in carious neighborhoods during lunch and dinner times during the week. Vendors change daily, and there is always a vide variety of cuisines suiting all dietary needs. - -www.ofhegridsf.com - -**Sai Jai Thai** (Thai Cuisine) [771 O'Farrell St ] - -**Taqueria Vallarta** (Mexican Cuisine) [3033 24th St ] - -**My Tofu House** (Korean Soft Tofu) [4627 Geary Blvd ] - -**Little Vietnam Café** (Vietnamese, lunch only) [309 6th Ave] - -**Ragazza** (Pizza) [311 Divisadero St. ] - -**Cha Cha Cha** (Spanish, etc.) [2327 Mission St ] - -## **SOMA StrEAT Park** - -A stationary on-going Food Truck area that hosts events and get-togethers. Vendors change regularly. www.somastreatoodpark.com - -**Rosamunde’s** (Sausage Grill) [2832 Mission St ] - -**Assab** (Eritrean/Ethiopian Cuisine) [2845 Geary Blvd] - -_**Want some more recommendations? See us in 208!**_ - -_** This is by no means a complete list. If there’s anything specific you are looking for, contact the Office of Student Life._ - -Page 14 - -## **Sample Itineraries for Urban Adventures** - -## **— — Trip One: Inner Richmond Haight the Mission** - -1. Breakfast in Inner Richmond (Dim Sum to-go) - -2. Walk through Golden Gate Park onto Haight Street - -3. Stop at Amoeba Records - -4. Walk up Buena Vista East to Corona Heights - -5. Walk down 16th street to Ike’s Sandwiches (3489 16th St ) - -6. Walk to Dolores Park to eat your sandwich and lie in the sun - -7. Walk towards the Mission for drinks/thrift store shopping - -**==> picture [190 x 139] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **— — — Trip Two: Embarcadero Telegraph Hill North beach Chinatown** - -1. Start at the Ferry Building - -2. Walk North along the Embarcadero - -3. Stop by Pier 7 for stunning views of the Bay Bridge - -4. Walk west towards the Filbert Steps - -5. Wander up the Filbert Steps towards Coit Tower - -6. Walk down from Coit Tower along Kearny towards the Peter - - - Macchiarini Steps _(between Broadway and Vallejo Streets)_ - -7. Take a left and stop into City Lights Bookstore - -8. Wander into Chinatown on Grant Street for something to munch on - -9. Visit the Fortune Cookie Factory - -**==> picture [192 x 135] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **Trip Three: Golden Gate Park Excursion** - -1. Start at Haight and Stanyan - -2. Purchase some food stuffs and various goodies from Whole Foods Market - -3. Wander through Golden Gate Park beginning at the entrance - -4. Enter the San Francisco Botanical Gardens (1199 9th Ave) - - - _[bring proof of residency for free admission!]_ - -5. From the botanical gardens, walk around Stow Lake, eat your food! - -6. Continue your journey west and visit the Bison off of JFK Boulevard - - - _(between 36th and 41st Ave)_ - -7. Continue on in the direction of the ocean, and walk north along Ocean Beach - -8. Watch the sunset from Sutro Baths - -Page 15 - -## _**Places and things you’ll see along the way….**_ - -_**Did you know that MUNI sells 3-day passes? Perfect for friends and relatives that come to visit. Stop by 208 to find out more...**_ - -**==> picture [541 x 553] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Trip One... Trip Two... Trip Three...
Dim Sum! Pier 7
Botanical Gardens
Haight Street
Stow Lake
Filbert Steps
Corona Heights Bison!
Coit Tower
Dolores Park
Sutro Baths
Chinatown
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -_**Want to go on an excursion but not sure where to go and what to see? Stop by 208 and we can help you curate your own urban journey.**_ - -Page 16 - -## **Student Discounts** - -The following is a list of venues and locations that currently offer Student Discounts. Remember to bring your Student ID! - -|Page 16
**Student Discounts**
The following is a list of venues and locatons that currently ofer Student Discounts. Remember to bring your Student ID!|Page 16
**Student Discounts**
The following is a list of venues and locatons that currently ofer Student Discounts. Remember to bring your Student ID!|Page 16
**Student Discounts**
The following is a list of venues and locatons that currently ofer Student Discounts. Remember to bring your Student ID!|Page 16
**Student Discounts**
The following is a list of venues and locatons that currently ofer Student Discounts. Remember to bring your Student ID!| -|---|---|---|---| -|**Organization**|**Discount Description**|**Location**|**Contact**| -|**24 Hour Fitness**|Show your Student ID to get a discount when you sign up for a stu-
dent rate|1200 Van Ness Ave|
(415) 776-2200| -|**Adobe Sofware**|Student Editon Discount sofware with school email address|www.adobe.com|---| -|**AMC Movie Theaters**|The Ofce of Student Life has discount movie passes for $8 each|1000 Van Ness Ave/101 4th St|(415) 674-4630| -|**American**
**Conservatory Theater**|
$20 Student Rush Tickets are available 2 hours before a performance|30 Grant Ave #6|(415) 834-3200| -|**Apple, Inc.**|Student’s save money with Apple’s educaton pricing.
Visit an Apple Store or their website for more informaton|1 Stockton St|(415) 392-0202| -|**Asian Art Museum**|$8 Student Admission with Student ID, free on the frst Sunday of
every month|200 Larkin St|(415) 581-3500| -|**Banana Republic**|15% Discount with Student ID (only applies to full-price merchandise)|
256 Grant Ave|(415) 788-3087| -|**Blick Art Materials**|Student discount with Student ID|979 Market St|(415) 441-6075| -|**Botanical Gardens**|Free with proof of San Francisco residency|9th Ave and Lincoln Way
Golden Gate Park|(415) 661-1316| -|**Cable Car Museum**|Free|1201 Mason St|(415) 474-1887| -|**California Academy**
**of Sciences**|Various free neighborhood days, quarterly free Sundays.
Student Discount with ID|55 Music Concourse Dr
Golden Gate Park|(415) 379-8000| -|**Cartoon Art Museum**|$5 Student Admission with ID|655 Mission St|(415) 227-8666| -|**Chinese Historical**
**Society of America**|$3 Student Admission with ID; Free frst Thursdays of the month|965 Clay St|(415) 391-1188| -|**Chipotle**|Free drink with purchase with Student ID|525 Market St, San Francisco
(and other locatons)|www.chipotle.com| -|**Conservatory of**
**Flowers**|Free on the frst Tuesday of every month|100 John F Kennedy Dr
Golden Gate Park|(415) 831-2090| -|**Contemporary**
**Jewish Museum**|Free frst Tuesday of the month, $10 Student Admission with ID.
Thursdays afer 5pm admission is $5|736 Mission St|(415) 655-7888| -|**De Young Museum**|Free frst Tuesday of every month; free frst full weekend of every
month for Bank of America Card holders. Any other day: $6 Student
Admission with ID|50 Hagiwara Tea Garden Dr
Golden Gate Park|(415) 750-3600| -|**Eddie Bauer**|Educaton discounts with Student ID|865 Market St|(415) 343-0146| -|**Exploratorium**|$15 Student Admission with Student ID|15/17 Pier|(415) 528-4444| -|**FedEx Ofce**|Student discounts with Student ID (not at all locatons)|1 Daniel Burnham Ct #10|
(415) 292-2500| -|**Flax Art Supplies**|Student discount with Student ID.|1699 Market St|(415) 552-2355| - - - -Page 17 - -|Page 17|Page 17|Page 17|Page 17|Page 17| -|---|---|---|---|---| -|**_Student Discounts Contnued..._**||||| -|**J. Crew Clothing**|15% discount with Student ID (only applies to full-price merchandise)|845 Market St||(415) 434-2739| -|**Japanese Tea Garden**|Free every Monday, Wednesday and Friday from 9 – 10am.
$5 Student Admission with proof of San Francisco residency.|75 Hagiwara Tea Garden Dr,
Golden Gate Park||
(415) 752-4227| -|**Kate Spade**|15% Student Discount with ID (varies by store)|227 Grant Ave||(415) 216-0880| -|**Legion of Honor**|$6 Student Admission with Student ID, Free on the frst Tuesdays of
every month.|100 34th Ave||(415) 750-3600| -|**Marin History Museum**|Free|1125 B St, San Rafael, CA , 94901||(415) 454-8538| -|**Musee Macanique**|Free|Pier 45 Shed A||(415) 346-2000| -|**Museo Italoamericano**|Free|Fort Mason Center
Building C||(415) 673-2200| -|**Museum of American**
**Heritage**|
Free|351 Homer Ave
Palo Alto, CA 94301||(650) 321-1004| -|**Museum of the**
**African Diaspora**|
$5 Student Admission with Student ID|685 Mission Street (at Third)||(415) 358-7200| -|**Oakland Museum of**
**California**|
$9 Student Admission with Student ID. Half-price admission on Fri-
days|1000 Oak St
Oakland, CA,94607||(510) 318-8400| -|**San Francisco Ballet**|$20 Student Rush tckets are available on the same day as the perfor-
mance.
See site for more into|301 Van Ness Ave||(415) 861-5600
www.sfallet.org/
studentrush| -|||||| -|**San Francisco**
**Camerawork Museum**|Free|657 Mission St #200||(415) 512-2020| -|**San Francisco Fire**
**Department Museum**|
Free|655 Presidio Ave||(415) 563-4630| -|**San Francisco Opera**|Tickets become availabile at 11am on the day of the show, if there is
availability. Student tckets are $25 with ID|301 Van Ness Avenue||(415) 864-3330| -|**San Francisco**
**Performances**|Culture Card - $25 Dollars for 25 performances around San Francisco|www.sfperformances.org||(415) 398-6449| -|**San Francisco**
**Symphony**|Student Rush tckets are $20.
Call the Rush Hotline on the same day of performances for tcket
availability|201 Van Ness Ave||(415) 864-6000| -|**San Francisco Zoo**|$12 Admission with proof of San Francisco residency|1 Zoo Rd||(415) 753-7080| -|**Student Universe**|Ofers discounted airfare for students|www.studentuniverse.com||---| -|**Yerba Buena**
**Center of the Arts**|$8 Student Admission with Student ID. Free gallery admission frst
Tuesdays of the month. $10 Student Rush Tickets, check
www.ybca.org for availability,
available one hour before curtain|701 Mission St||(415) 978-2787| -|**Zipcar**|$15/year Membership through SFCM|www.zipcar.com||---| -|**_Curious about other local deals? Stop by 208 to fnd out more..._**||||| -|||||| - - - -Page 18 - -## **San Francisco Neighborhoods** - -San Francisco is one of the most distinguished and celebrated cities in the world. Its diverse cultures and lifestyles attract prospective students to the city, and with a little bit of direction, you can discover all the treasures of San Francisco! Short descriptions of the major neighborhoods are listed below. - -More information on city neighborhoods can be found at www.sfgate.com/neighborhoods/sf/. To further explore the city, visit the San Francisco Convention & Visitors Bureau’s Web site www.sanfrancisco.travel. - -## **The Castro** - -The universally-agreed historic Mecca of gay life is San Francisco's Castro District. It is home to a predominantly lesbian/gay/bisexual/transgender community with excellent bakeries, boutiques, cafes, restaurants and nightlife. The Castro hosts a variety of festivals, street fairs and activities throughout the year. - -## **Cole Valley/UCSF** - -Nestled between the Sunset district and Haight-Ashbury, this generally cute and quiet neighborhood is populated by families and young professionals. Here you’ll find a variety of mom-and-pop shops in lieu of mainstream franchises. - -## **Lower Haight/Western Addition** - -A punky off-shoot of the Haight-Ashbury area, the Lower Haight is one of the more culturally and economically diverse neighborhoods in San Francisco. This area offers unique restaurants and bars overflowing with locals, as well as intriguing shops offering everything you could imagine. - -## **The Marina** - -A picturesque area that boasts many tourist attractions but also a plethora of trendy restaurants, bars, and shopping. Many young professionals call this area home. - -## **The Mission** - -## **Haight-Ashbury** - -Commonly referred to as the Upper Haight, the Haight-Ashbury was the center of ‘60s hippie movement. It is a bustling center of gift shops, piercing salons, vintage clothing stores and Amoeba Music, the country’s largest independent music store. - -Easily mistaken as Central America, the Mission is an exceptionally diverse area of San Francisco with a strong Latino influence. The area boasts a colorful collection of authentic restaurants, taquerías, bakeries, produce markets, specialty shops, kaleidoscopic murals, and a lively, thriving bar scene. - -## **Hayes Valley/Civic Center** - -With the Asian Art Museum, San Francisco Ballet, Opera, Symphony, SF Jazz, and the Conservatory, Civic Center is the cultural nexus of San Francisco. Adjacent to Civic Center is Hayes Valley, which caters to the “symphony crowd” with its fine restaurants, boutiques, trendy furniture stores and upscale shoe emporia. - -## **Noe Valley** - -West of the Mission and south of the Castro is Noe Valley. Its streets are lined with beautifully renovated Victorians. Somewhat upscale and slower-paced, Noe Valley attracts young families, students, artists and professionals. - -## **Nob Hill** - -Known for its landmarks and famous hotels, upscale Nob Hill offers a wide variety of shops, restaurants, and a range of bars and clubs. - -## **Russian Hill** - -Encompassing two of the highest points in San Francisco, Russian Hill is a neighborhood of steep ascents and descents, panoramic views, interesting restaurants and shops on Hyde and Polk Streets, and fairly pricey housing for its location. Macondray Lane was the inspiration for Barbary Lane in Armistead Maupin’s Tales of the City. - -## **Pacific Heights** - -A very wealthy neighborhood offering beautiful multi-million dollar homes and amazing views, Pacific Heights boasts upscale shopping and restaurants. However, some find the most exciting activity is to sit at a sidewalk café on Fillmore Street and people watch. - -## **Potrero Hill** - -Once a largely industrial area, the Internet boom brought a change with warehouses being converted ninto offices, houses, and art studios. A unique and rapidly gentrifying area, you will find a unique community of artists, musicians, and young professional techies. - -## **The Richmond District** - -A middle-income, family-oriented area, the Richmond is convenient to a variety of shops, restaurants and transportation. With a large Russian and East Asian population, it’s not difficult to find amazing food. This neighborhood is relatively inexpensive and is close to Ocean Beach, The Presidio, and Golden Gate Park. - -## **North Beach/Chinatown** - -Even though it's home to Little Italy and the Beat movement, North Beach offers an extremely wide variety of restaurants, bars, clubs, shopping (fantastic bookstores and funky shops) and sites. Chinatown is the oldest and one of the largest Chinatowns in the US. - -## **The Sunset District** - -Home of the Conservatory from 1956 to 2006, this largely residential area is a good place to find affordable housing. Irving Street features a number of excellent, reasonably-priced restaurants, bars, and shops. - -**==> picture [279 x 82] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 19 - -## **Want to find out more info about SF? Check out these sites...** - -**==> picture [282 x 122] intentionally omitted <==** - -The Bold Italic is an online magazine, shop, and events hub in San Francisco that celebrates the free-wheeling spirit of the city. Long form tales of the city often make an appearance on the front page of the site. - -## **www.thebolditalic.com** - -**==> picture [226 x 128] intentionally omitted <==** - -SFist is the San Francisco branch of the **Gothamist,** - -a worldwide site that focus on news, events, food, culture, and other local coverage. Their snarky style articles often highlight events and incidents left out of local news. - -**==> picture [95 x 112] intentionally omitted <==** - -SFWeekly is a website and a weekly print publication with lists of local upcoming events, underground - -news stories, and write-ups of interesting happenings around the city. Check out their website for local deals and coupons. - -**www.sfweekly.com** - -**==> picture [196 x 91] intentionally omitted <==** - -The SF Bay Guardian features San Francisco Bay Area news, progressive politics, arts, culture, music, nightlife, events, theater, food, drink, dance, and film. They often release “Best of” lists. - -**www.sfg.com** - -**www.sfst.com** - -**==> picture [214 x 86] intentionally omitted <==** - -A site (and occasional publication) curated by San Francisco lovers and locals. They feature articles about local eateries, upcoming shows, influential individuals from this beautiful city, and more! - -**==> picture [216 x 74] intentionally omitted <==** - -….we don’t know how to adequately explain this one. A great source of fun information about things to do and places to go in the city. We’ll leave it at that. - -**www.7x7.com** - -**www.brokeassstuart.com** - -Page 20 - -## _**Yearly Local Events and Festivals...**_ - -San Francisco is host to numerous yearly events and festivals that draw thousands of visitors into the city from the rest of the country. Below is a list of yearly festivals that take place in San Francisco. Be sure to check local calendars for events and festivities that go on outside of the regularly scheduled festivals. - -## **February** - -**==> picture [251 x 149] intentionally omitted <==** - -Valentine’s Day Pillow Fight at Justin Herman Plaza SF Indie fest - -Chinese New Year Festival and Parade - -## **March** - -**==> picture [51 x 44] intentionally omitted <==** - -St. Patrick’s Day Celebration Spring Open Studios Union Street Spring Celebration - -**==> picture [202 x 155] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [130 x 146] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **April** - -SF International Film Festival How Weird Street Fair Cherry Blossom Festival - -## **May** - -Bay to Breakers Golden Gate Festival Cinco De Mayo Carnival Documentary Film Festival - -**==> picture [102 x 130] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [124 x 81] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [91 x 91] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **June** - -SF Pride Festival Haight Ashbury Street Festival North Beach Festival Stern Grove Festival - -**==> picture [224 x 149] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [154 x 130] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [116 x 113] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 21 - -**==> picture [145 x 105] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [109 x 150] intentionally omitted <==** - -**July** Fillmore Jazz Festival Forth of July Festival America’s Cup San Francisco Silent Film Festival J-POP Summit Festival **August** SF Street Food festival Outside Lands Nihonmachi Street Fair San Francisco Shakespeare Festival **September** Lovevolution Power to the Peaceful Folsom Street Fair Ghiradelli Chocolate Festival **October** Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Oktoberfest by the Bay Castro Street Fair Treasure Island Music festival Columbus Day Parade **November** Dia de los Muertos Annual Tree Lighting in Ghirardelli Square San Francisco Hip Hop Dance Festival San Francisco World Music Festival **December** Santacon SF Ballet Nutcracker Light the Menorah Renegade Craft Fair - -**==> picture [76 x 96] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [108 x 39] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [254 x 151] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [86 x 130] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [87 x 84] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [65 x 81] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [183 x 118] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [119 x 89] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [245 x 127] intentionally omitted <==** - -Page 22 - -## **Office of Student Life** - -**Jason E. Smith** Associate Dean for Student Life jsmith@sfcm.edu 415.503.6281 - -**Caitlin Shepherd** Student Life Assistant cshepherd@sfcm.edu 415.503.6259 - -**Suite 208 Office Hours:** - -Monday—Friday 9:00am to 5pm Closed for Lunch 12:30—1:30pm - -## **Emergency Numbers** - -Ambulance: 911 Police: 911 or 415.553.0123 Fire: 911 or 415.553.3268 - -In the event of a disaster while off campus, please contact the Conservatory. **Main Number:** 415.864.7326 - -**==> picture [81 x 80] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Scan me for the Student Handbook!** - -**==> picture [77 x 66] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Like us on Facebook!** San Francisco Conservatory of Music Office of Student Life - -**==> picture [70 x 61] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Follow us on Twitter!** @sfcmstudentlife - -## **Useful San Francisco Apps** - -There are several useful apps that will ease your transition into San Francisco. They provide useful information about transit times, city-wide maps, fun events around the city, among other valuable bits of information. Here is a list of some popular ones. - -**==> picture [40 x 42] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Google Maps Golden Gate San Francisco** This offers detailed **Park Field Guide Stairways** views of various Created by the This app helps you maps and easy California Acadefind the hidden driving, my of Science, gem stairways walking, or public it’s an easy guide that adorn the transport route to the Park! entire city. options. - -**==> picture [42 x 40] intentionally omitted <==** - -**NextMUNI Zipcar Embark iBart** Tells you the next Convenient This app provides bus arrival times booking and car you with arrival based on your pickup if you times and anacculocation. have a rate schedule of Zipcar account. BART trains. - -**SF Weekly Scoutmob** A free local publication with A fun and informative app that pop and features discounts and freebies sub-culture news and events around the city. from around the city. - -**==> picture [42 x 42] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [49 x 49] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [48 x 48] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [52 x 51] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [47 x 47] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **1AM Sidecar** - -**Winery Finder SF Parks and Rec** A winery finder and More information tasting pass provider about Parks and in the palm of your Recreation around hand. Your guide to the city. wine country! - -An on-demand car service. Summon a ride from point A to point B from your phone. - -A community driven photography app that celebrates art in the streets of SF - -**==> picture [48 x 48] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [48 x 48] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [52 x 50] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [47 x 47] intentionally omitted <==** - -## **AroundMe** - -**Café Guidebook** Your go-to guide for cafés around the city. - -**Yelp** A useful app to find reviews on restaurants and local businesses. - -## **Let’s Get Lost** - -This app allows you This app features to quickly find out local adventures information and and walks through things to do based the city and around on your location. the Bay Area. +Calls to the Consumer Services Team can include simple +questions regarding a claim or insurance policy, inquiries about +a company’s actions which may violate State insurance laws or +how to submit a formal complaint to the DOI + +Facts and Figures | 5 + + DOI’s Work + +Digging +Deeper +Into Issues + +Helping Coloradans Navigate +Homeowners Insurance + +Across the country, including here in Colorado, +people are working through challenges with +their homeowners insurance. The DOI has been +implementing a number of ways to address +these issues, including legislation like the FAIR +Plan (an insurer of last resort), market studies +and regular stakeholder meetings to hear from +consumers and share information about the +DOI’s efforts. Our Consumer Services Team has +also been working through these challenges +with individual consumers. + +6 | DOI’s Work - Digging Deeper Into Issues + + Digging Deeper Into Issues + +Answers and Education + +In the last year, the Team fielded about 570 calls +and emails from Colorado consumers concerned +about the affordability and availability of +homeowners insurance, as well as non-renewals, +which represented about 35% of all the calls and +emails the team received specifically related to +homeowners insurance. + +With each of these inquiries, a Team member takes +the time necessary to educate the consumer about +the factors leading to premium increases, the +underwriting decisions of insurance companies, +and the claims process, while also providing +resources to help find coverage and suggestions +to possibly lower premiums. + +DOI’s Work - Digging Deeper Into Issues | 7 + + DOI’s Work + +Digging +Deeper +Into Issues + +Providing a Better +Understanding of Health +Insurance + +In recent years, the DOI developed various programs +that increase access to health insurance and save +people money on health care. However people can +still run into problems and roadblocks when using +that health insurance. The Consumer Services Team +strives to not only answer people’s questions and +investigate their complaints, but also works to +help people gain a better understanding of their +coverage and benefits, and help them navigate the +health care system. + +Out-of-Network Labs + +Over the last year, the Consumer Services Team has seen an +uptick in complaints about physicians sending blood draws +and other lab work to out-of-network labs. Generally, this +shouldn’t occur, as in-network physicians are required by +their contract with insurance companies to use labs that +are also in-network. In addition to investigating each +consumer complaint to ensure that consumers are receiving +the benefits promised by their insurance policies, the Team +is currently working with insurance companies to address +this challenge and ensure members’ labs are being sent to +in-network providers by their contracted care teams. + +8 | DOI’s Work - Digging Deeper Into Issues + + Digging Deeper Into Issues + +Helping Consumers Understand Long-Term Care +Insurance Policy Options + +In this past year, the Consumer Services Team successfully +helped many consumers understand their Long–Term Care +(LTC) policies, as well as what options are available to +them when they experience a rate increase. The Team also +worked to gain a deeper knowledge about how LTC insurance +companies interpret their policies and determine payouts to +their policyholders. Through this effort, the Team identified +a specific policy option that could help many Coloradans. +An “Alternate Plan of Care” option is designed to provide +consideration for care that would not normally be covered +under LTC policies. And while this policy option can only be +accessed in very specific circumstances, the Team was able to +identify it as an option for specific consumers that had filed +complaints concerning coverage that was dependent on the +type of facility in which the care was received. In some cases +this allowed the policyholders to access policy benefits without +having to change the facility in which they were residing. + +DOI’s Work - Digging Deeper Into Issues | 9 + + Consumers’ +Stories + +10 | Consumers' Stories + +Delay in Hail Damage Claim + +The owners of an apartment complex filed a complaint +after an extensive delay in getting payment on a claim +regarding extensive hail damage to the complex. +The hail claim was filed on July 24, 2023, yet as of +November 2023, the insurance company had still not +paid the settlement amount. After the apartment +complex filed a complaint with the DOI on November 1, +the DOI contacted the insurance company, prompting +the company to start working with the complex to +negotiate the settlement. By November 22, 2023, the +insurance company had paid the settlement amount +of $2,657,730. + +Transplant Results in Out-of-Network +Billing + +The Team worked with a consumer with medical bills +over $420,000 due to a transplant. The consumer had +been insured by Friday Health, and even though the +company had made the appropriate arrangements +with the out-of-network health care providers, Friday +Health had been liquidated throughout the country +and put into receivership. The Consumer Services +Team worked with the providers to pause bills to +the consumer while working through the transplant +claims and provider payments. The Team also worked +with an outside advocacy agency, and ultimately the +consumer was not billed for anything over in-network +charges. + + Consumers’ Stories + +Smoke Damage from Marshall Fire + +Unfortunately, some consumers are still working through +issues resulting from the December 2021 Marshall Fire. +One consumer filed a complaint in November 2022, as their +insurance company had still not remediated the smoke +damage to their home. While the company did agree to +do some cleaning, it was not to the extent the consumer +needed. With the Consumer Services Team’s involvement, +the company eventually paid an additional $122,197 to +properly clean and remediate the smoke damage to the +home, and the Team was able to close the complaint in +August 2023. + +Consumers' Stories | 11 + + Consumers’ Stories + +Following Through on Network Exception + +With health insurance, issues around provider networks are +common. When Coloradans run into problems with a provider +network being inadequate in rural areas or regarding speciality +care and speciality providers, consumers will often require what is +called a Provider Network Gap Exception so they can get the care +they need. The Consumer Services Team makes sure the insurance +companies follow through and approve these exceptions as +necessary. In the last year, the Team worked through a consumer’s +exception that had been approved by Oscar Health. However, this +exception was complicated by the fact that Oscar had not set +up the appropriate agreement, called a Single Case Agreement +(SCA), with the out-of-network speciality provider. Additionally, +Oscar Health had exited the Colorado market. As a result, the +consumer was billed for over $30,000. The Team intervened to +ensure that Oscar Health processed the claim correctly, and the +consumer was covered at no greater cost to the consumer than +if the services and treatment were obtained from an in-network +provider. + +Improper Delay for Life Insurance Claim + +The DOI often needs to intervene when a life insurance policy +payout is delayed. In one particular case, a person was expecting +a payout of over $2 million from two policies. The claims were +filed on March 10, 2023, and the consumer battled with the +insurance company over the next three months to get this settled. +Even after the company received a coroner report, it did not +issue the payout. Finally, the consumer filed a complaint with +the DOI on July 14, 2023. After a DOI investigation, the company +processed the claim and made the payments by July 26, including +over $14,000 in interest. + +12 | Consumers' Stories + + Consumers’ Stories + +Travel Insurance Not Paying Hospital Bill + +A Colorado consumer purchased travel insurance, which included medical +coverage, for an overseas trip. A health emergency occurred early in the trip. In +January 2023, the foreign hospital billed for services in the amount of $48,656. +Yet, as of November 2023, the travel insurance had still not paid for this bill. +The consumer submitted a complaint to the DOI on November 28. The travel +insurance company was attempting to renegotiate the bill, however, based on +the DOI’s involvement, they wrapped up their review of the claim and paid the +full amount to the hospital by late December 2023. + +Getting Medical Claims Paid + +For many people, struggling with traumatic +medical problems can mean they do not have the +energy to navigate the health care system. The +Consumer Services Team worked with a consumer +whose wife was involved in a car accident that +resulted in a traumatic brain injury. She had been +moved multiple times from one facility to another +and was having claims denied. The Team worked +with the insurance company to get a better +understanding of the claims, as well as the claim +denials. Eventually, our Team ensured the claims +were paid, providing an immense sense of relief +for the family. + +Consumers' Stories | 13 + + Contact the Colorado +Division of Insurance + +If you have questions, concerns or complaints about your insurance, +insurance company or insurance agent, or you just need an explanation +of terminology, processes or the world of insurance in general, please +contact the Colorado Division of Insurance Consumer Services Team. + +303-894-7490 + +DORA_Insurance@state.co.us + +doi.colorado.gov (click on “File a Complaint”) diff --git a/q22/random_k4/random_4.md b/q22/random_k4/random_4.md index a06602212318e73c917d6b795e293e4828db2a80..1baafa3214e3d1c3ba84ae8c4e451072ec71f1c5 100644 --- a/q22/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q22/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,369 +1,891 @@ -Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -Contact Information -Steve Shannon -School Phone: (402) 443-4332 Ext. 3224 -Email: sshannon@esu2.org - -Room 85 - -General Course Description -This course begins with a consideration of the living condition and discussion of the -unique properties of living organisms that set life apart from the non-living. It continues -with molecular and cellular biology, from which it moves logically into reproduction and -genetics. An understanding of genetics gives meaning to organized variation, evolution -and methods of scientific classification units dealing with microbiology and plant and -animal phylum. This course is designed for the college-bound student. Students should -expect a demanding daily homework load as well as projects, quizzes, tests, and -laboratory write-ups. A high level of understanding in problem solving and the scientific -methods is necessary for success in this course. - -Daily Class Materials Needed -*Student Planner -*Notebook - -*Modern Biology textbook -*Pen/Pencil - -*3 Ring Binder/Folder -*Calculator - -Daily Requirements: - -All students will be required to keep a 3-Ring Binder with all their classroom materials in -the binder. This binder will hold the student’s Vocabulary Word List, Notes, Classroom -Assignments and Activities, Labs, Quizzes, and Reviews. This notebook will be graded at -the end of every chapter. - -General Routines and Procedures -1. BE ON TIME AND PREPARED FOR LEARNING - -*Respect for Others (Teachers, Students, and Community) - --Ways to Show Respect to Others: -1. Make good eye contact when communicating with others -2. BE ON TIME! - -Punctuality is vital in today’s world. Virtually any job you may -have will require you to be on time and ready to work. You must be -in your seat when the bell rings. If you are late, you must have a -pass from the office or the teacher who detained you or you will -be counted tardy. You will receive one free tardy, every -subsequent tardy will result in a problem solving session with Mr. -Shannon. - -3. Listen! - -2. COMPLETE ASSIGNED TASKS ON TIME - *Make Hard Work Your Passion - --The simplest way that an individual can achieve a higher degree of success in any - -endeavor is simple: “I’m going to outwork you!” - --The harder you work, the harder it is to surrender to any challenge in - -life....PERIOD! - -We do a significant amount of cooperative/group learning. You are expected to -contribute to your group and work with others. Failure to do so will result in your -removal from groups and subsequent individual work. - - Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -Bell Work - -Everyday at the beginning of class, you will be expected to do bell work. The bell work will -consist of Lateral/Critical Thinking Problems. You will have the first 5 minutes of class to -write down the question to be answered for that day. All bell work must be turned into Mr. -Shannon by 3:45PM the same day to receive credit. Bell work is worth 5 points each day. - -“It is our attitude at the beginning of a difficult task which, more than anything else, will -affect it’s successful outcome.” --William James - -3. DEMONSTRATE ACADEMIC PROFICIENCY - -Cheating is not tolerated in this class. Any student caught cheating will receive at - -automatic office referral. In addition, the student will be required to make-up the -assignment and may receive a maximum of 50% on the make-up assignment. Cheating is -defined as passing off another’s work as your own. This includes copying or stealing -answers, whether it be daily work or assessments. (Reminder: Life is full of choices….) - -"Good habits result from resisting temptation." Indian Proverb - -Homework - -Expect to see homework on a nightly basis throughout the year. Homework will -usually involve reading material from the text and answering problems associated -with lab work, activities, and in-class discussions. It will also include some project -work, laboratory reports, and study for examinations. Each homework assignment -carries a due date or deadline. The deadlines in this course are very reasonable and -I expect that you will put forth effort daily in this class to complete these -assignments. - -If you do not turn in an assignment on time, the following consequence & options will be -given to make-up the assignment. - -Options & Consequence - -1. If an assignment is not completed on time the student will have until the end of the -day to turn it in for a late grade (60%). If it is not turned in before school starts on -the following day a detention with Mr. Shannon will be assigned, until the -assignment is completed. All late assignments will be at 60% credit. If the -assignment is not turned in the next day, a Problem Solving will result and the -WEBSS process will be implemented. - -"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence then, is not an act, but a habit." -Aristotle - -Academic Assistance -Due to extracurricular responsibilities, if students are in need of academic assistance in -Mr. Shannon’s classes, the following times will be set aside for academic assistance: - -1. Before School (7:30 – 8:15 PM) -2. Home Room -3. Mr. Shannon’s Plan Period - - Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -Class Absences -*If a student misses class due to a school related event, the student is responsible for -getting their assignments ahead of time and making sure that they are turned in an -completed before they leave. -*If a student misses class due to illness or an non-school related absence, that student will -have one day to make up their work for each day they are gone. The materials can be -found in the vertical paper holders. - -Class Participation -When you are in class, I expect you to be ready to learn. I expect each of you to be an -active participant in your learning. While I am speaking, you should be actively listening. -If you have a question raise your hand, and I’ll be happy to try and answer it. When I ask -questions, I will either call on students to answer or ask for volunteers, so be ready. There -will be days when you will be graded on how well you participate in the class. - -"Not to know is bad, not to wish to know is worse." -Nigerian Proverb - -Grading Policy -For each chapter or unit that is learned during the year, we will have four basic grades: -1. Homework (10-50 pts) -2. Lab Assignments (10 - 50 pts) -3. Section/Unit Quizzes (10 - 50pts) -4. Chapter Assessment (150 - 300 pts) - -You will also have projects assigned during the semester, which will be graded using a -rubric and will be worth between 100 - 300 pts. - -Your quarter final assessments will be worth 20% of your semester grade. - -Grading Scale -A+ 98-100 -A 95-97 -A- 93-94 - -B+ -B -B- - -92-90 -88-89 -85-87 - -C+ -C -C- - -82-84 -79-81 -77-78 - -D+ -D -D- - -75-76 -73-74 -70-72 - -Extra Credit -You will have the opportunity to do some extra credit with every chapter. It can be a -great asset to help you improve your grade. It is meant as a tool to help you better -understand the material and help you prepare for tests. Therefore, I will only accept it, if -turned in before the tests. Also, it should not be done in place of your regular homework, -instead it is meant as a supplement. You may do a maximum of 20 points of extra credit -per chapter. - -Extra Credit is done on the following website associated with the text book: -http://www.go.hrw.com -Once at the home page type in the keyword: HM2 HOME -*More information on the extra credit will be given at a later date. - - Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -Daily Behavioral Expectations -1. USE WORK TIME APPROPRIATELY - *Discipline Yourself So No One Else Has To - --Discipline is the internal mechanism that self-motivates you! It is essential to - -success, whether individually or in a group. - --To accomplish anything of real quality requires discipline and having the patience to - -do things right , the first time. - --Self discipline is a matter of how hard you are willing to work WHEN NO ONE IS - -WATCHING! - -"Disciplining yourself to do what you know is right and important, although difficult, is the -high road to pride, self-esteem, and personal satisfaction. " -Brian Tracy - -2. DEMONSTRATE RESPECT FOR PEOPLE AND PROPERTY - -*Respect Yourself & Others --Respect for Yourself --Ways to Develop Self Respect: - -1. Take responsibility for your actions! (See Below) -2. Be true to yourself! -3. Be willing to laugh at yourself! - --Respect for Your School and School Property --Ways to Show Respect for School Property - -1. ASK FIRST to borrow an item (PLEASE!) -2. Return all items to their proper locations when you are done! -( THANK YOU!) -3. Take responsibility for materials in your possession! - -“I must respect the opinions of others even if I disagree with them.” -Herbert Henry Lehman - -"I never could have done what I have done without the habits of punctuality, order, and -diligence, without the determination to concentrate myself on one subject at a time." -Charles Dickens - - Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -3. RESPOND APPROPRIATELY TO MR.SHANNON’S DIRECTIVES - -*Take Full Responsibility - --Life is full of CHOICES.....Each choice bears a consequence! --If you make a positive choice, enjoy the rewards! --If you make a negative choice, accept the consequences! - (DO NOT MAKE EXCUSES!) - --Responsibility is a constant state of being that evolves! --We cannot pick and choose the days that we wish to be responsible! - --RESPONSIBILITY = ACCOUNTABILITY = OWNERSHIP - --Ways to Become More Responsible: - -1. Assume responsibility for a situation and force yourself to cope - with it -2. Make yourself accountable for the “little things” each day. -These are the things that develop character! - -3. DO NOT MAKE EXCUSES! - --Whining/Blaming Others......”LOSERS LIMP” - -“Nobody can do it for you.” -Ralph Cordiner - -“The willingness to accept responsibility for one's own life is the source from which self- -respect springs.” -Joan Didion - -Mr. Shannon’s Directives: -1. Book bags are NOT allowed in class and are to be kept in your locker during the school -day. Small purses (smaller than an text book) will be allowed until they become a -distraction. If they become a distraction, they will not be allowed and must be kept in the -student’s locker. This will be dealt with on an individual basis. - -2. iPods/mp3 players and cell phones are NOT allowed in the science classroom. - -3. Due to safety and custodial issues, will not be allowed to bring any food or drink into -the classroom during science lab. - - Biology: Syllabus -Instructor: Mr. Shannon - -COURSE OBJECTIVES AND SCHEDULE - -Semester 1 -Introduction - --True Colors Personality Survey --Class Expectations and Guidelines --Class Syllabus and Guidelines --Lab Procedures --Lab Safety - -Unit 1 – Biological Principles - --The Science of Life - -Unit 2 – Cells - --Structure and Function of the Cell --Homeostasis and Transport --Photosynthesis -(SS 12.4.1) --Cellular Respiration --Cell Reproduction - -Unit 3 – Genetics - --Fundamentals of Genetics --Nucleic Acids and Protein Synthesis --Inheritance Patterns and Human Genetics --DNA Technology -(SS 12.4.2) - -Semester 2 -Unit 4 – Evolution - --The Origin of Life --Evolution: Evidence and Theory -(SS 12.4.3) --Classification - -Unit 5 – Ecology - --Introduction to Ecology --Populations -(SS 12.4.4) --Community Ecology -(SS 12.4.5) --Ecosystems and the Biosphere --Behavior of Organisms -(SS 12.4.6) - -Unit 6- Microorganisms (If Time Allows…) - --Bacteria --Viruses --Protozoa --Algae --Fungi - -Unit 7- Plants (If Time Allows…) - --Importance of Plants --Plant Evolution and Classification --Plant Structure and Function --Plant Reproduction --Plant Responses - +Explanation, Debate, Align: A Weak-to-Strong Framework for Language Model +Generalization +MehrdadZakershahrak*,SamiraGhodratnama* +DepartmentofComputing +{mehrdad,samira}@mq..edu.au +4202 peS 11 ]IA.sc[ 1v53370.9042:viXra Abstract inglysophisticatedAIsystemswithoutsolelydependingon +humanoversight.Suchmethodsshouldfacilitatealignment +Therapidadvancementofartificialintelligencesystemshas +| | | | | | | | in domains | where | human | experts | may | struggle | to provide | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | +broughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttotheforefrontofre- +accuratefeedback,whilestillmaintainingthecoreprinciple +search,particularlyincomplexdecision-makingandtaskex- +ofaligningwithhumanvalues.Furthermore,thesemethods +ecution.Asthesesystemssurpasshuman-levelperformance +insophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralignmentwithhu- shouldprovideamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +man values, intentions, and ethical guidelines becomes cru- capabilities evolve, ensuring that alignment scales with ad- +cial.Buildingonpreviousworkinexplanationgenerationfor vancementsinAItechnology. +human-agent alignment, we address the more complex dy- Buildingonourpreviousworkinexplanationgeneration +namicsofmulti-agentsystemsandhuman-AIteams.Thispa- forhuman-agentalignment,weintroduceaframeworkthat +perintroducesanovelapproachtomodelalignmentthrough +combinesweak-to-stronggeneralizationandmodelfacilita- +| weak-to-strong | | generalization | in | the context | of | language | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | tion, leveraging | | explanatory | debates | to | enhance | alignment. | | +models.Wepresentaframeworkwhereastrongmodelfacili- +Thisapproachaimstocreateascalable,self-improvingsys- +| tates the | improvement | of a | weaker | model, | bridging | the gap | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +temforAIalignmentthatcanhandleincreasinglycomplex +| between | explanation | generation | and | model | alignment. | Our | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskswhilemaintainingtransparencyandinterpretability. +| method, | formalized | as a facilitation | | function | Φ, | allows for | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thetransferofcapabilitiesfromadvancedmodelstolessca- Toformalizeourapproach,webeginbydefiningthecon- +pable ones without direct access to extensive training data. ceptsofweakandstrongmodels: +Our results suggest that this facilitation-based approach not A model M is considered +| | | | | | | | Definition1(WeakModel) | | | | | W | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +onlyenhancesmodelperformancebutalsoprovidesinsights +| | | | | | | | weakif,foragiventaskT | | | andperformancemetricP,M | | | | W | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intothenatureofmodelalignmentandthepotentialforscal- +| | | | | | | | achievesascoreS | | suchthatS | | < S | ,whereS | | isthe | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| ableoversightofAIsystems. | | | | | | | | | W | | W | H | H | | +human-levelperformanceonT. +Introduction Definition2(StrongModel) A model M is considered +S +| | | | | | | | strong if, | for the | same | task T | and performance | | metric | P, | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----------------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +| The rapid | advancement | of | artificial | intelligence | | (AI) sys- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | M achievesascoreS | | | suchthatS | >S | . | | | +| | | | | | | | S | | S | | S | H | | | +temshasbroughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttothefore- +| | | | | | | | The idea | of | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | involves | us- | +| ------------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ---------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | +| front of research, | | particularly | in complex | | decision-making | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ing weaker | AI systems | | to supervise | and | align | stronger | AI | +| and task | execution. | As these | systems | surpass | human-level | | | | | | | | | | +performanceinsophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralign- systems, a concept closely related to capability amplifica- +ment with human values, intentions, and ethical guidelines tion, where the goal is to create AI systems that can solve +| | | | | | | | problems | beyond | the capabilities | | of their | creators | or | train- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | +becomescrucial.Thischallengehasbeenhighlightedinre- +| | | | | | | | ers. This | concept | has its | roots | in model | compression | | and | +| ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | ------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | +| cent work | on alignment, | | such as | Reinforcement | | Learning | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | knowledge | distillation, | | where smaller, | | less capable | | models | +| from Human | Feedback | (RLHF), | | which | iteratively | refines | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | are used | to enhance | the | performance | of | larger | models. | Re- | +modelbehaviorbasedonhumanevaluations(Ghodratnama +and Zakershahrak 2024). While RLHF has shown promise cent research, such as the work by Schick and Schu¨tze on +| | | | | | | | few-shot | learning | in language | | models, | demonstrates | | how | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +inaligninglanguagemodelswithhumanintentions,itfaces +| | | | | | | | these ideas | can | be applied | to improve | | the performance | | of | +| ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| scalability | challenges | when | dealing | with | tasks | that surpass | | | | | | | | | +smallermodelswithlimiteddata. +human-levelcomplexity.Therelianceondirecthumanfeed- +FacilitationFunctionandDebate-BasedAlignmentAtthe +backbecomesabottleneck,limitingthescopeanddepthof +alignmentthatcanbeachieved. heart of our method is the facilitation function Φ, which +formalizestheprocessofknowledgetransferfromastrong +Toaddresstheselimitations,morescalableandadaptable +modeltoaweakerone: +approachesarerequired—approachesthatcanalignincreas- +| | | | | | | | Definition3(FacilitationFunc.) | | | | Φ:M | ×M | →M′ | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| *Theseauthorscontributedequally. | | | | | | | | | | | | W | S | W | +Copyright©2025,AssociationfortheAdvancementofArtificial WhereM W istheweakmodel,M S isthestrongmodel,and +Intelligence(www.aaai.org).Allrightsreserved. M′ istheenhancedweakmodel.Thefacilitationfunction +W + +isimplementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: wefosteranAIsystemthatnotonlyperformswellbutalso +| | | | | | | | | maintains | transparency | | and interpretability, | | | key factors | in | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +(cid:88) +| | argmin | | L(f | θ (q),f | θS (q)) | | (1) | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ W′ b u i ld i n gtrustandensuringlong-termalignmentwithhuman +W′ q∈Q +| | | | | | | | | va l u e s . | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WhereQisasetoftaskinstances,Lisatask-specificloss Contributions Our contributions in this paper are three- +| function, | and | f represents | | the model’s | decision-making | | | fold: | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ +functionparameterizedbyθ. +| | | | | | | | | 1. We introduce | | a novel | framework | | for model | alignment | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | +Tofurtherenhanceourapproach,weincorporatedebate- +| | | | | | | | | through | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | and | model | facil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +basedalignment,leveragingtheideathatitmaybeeasierto +itation,formalizingthefacilitationfunctionΦanditsap- +| judge the | outcome | of | a debate | than | to directly | solve | com- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +plicationtocomplexdecision-makingtasks. +| plex problems. | | This | method | uses adversarial | | dynamics | to | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +improve model alignment and capability by evaluating the 2. We present empirical results demonstrating significant +explanationsprovidedbydifferentmodels. improvements in model performance and alignment +acrossmultiplecomplextaskdomains,achievedthrough +| Definition4(DebateFunction) | | | | D :E | ×E | ×J | →R | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | S′ | W | | ourfacilitationapproach. | | | | | | | | +| WhereE | istheexplanationfunctionofthestrongmodel, | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +S′ 3. We provide an in-depth analysis of the facilitation pro- +| E is | the explanation | | function | of the | weak | model, | and J | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | +| W | | | | | | | | cess, | offering | new | perspectives | | on the nature | of | model | +| is the judge | (which | could | be | another | instance | of the | weak | | | | | | | | | +alignmentindecision-makingandthepotentialforscal- +model,ahuman,oranotherevaluationmechanism).Theout- +ableoversightofadvancedAIsystemstacklingcomplex +| put of D | is a | real number | representing | | the | quality | of the | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tasks. +strongmodel’sexplanationrelativetotheweakmodel’s,as +evaluated by the judge. This scalar output can be used as a This work represents a key component of a broader re- +reward signal in a reinforcement learning (RL) framework, search agenda aimed at developing robust, aligned AI sys- +allowingforcontinuousimprovementofthestrongmodel’s tems capable of handling increasingly complex decisions +explanatorycapabilities. and tasks. By bridging the gap between weak and strong +| | | | | | | | →M′ | models | in sophisticated | | problem-solving | | scenarios, | | we not | +| ------------------------------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | +| Definition5(AlignmentFunction) | | | | | Ψ:M S | ×M W | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | S | onlyenhancethecapabilitiesofAIsystemsbutalsoensure | | | | | | | | +| Where | M′ is | the aligned | | strong model. | This | function | is | | | | | | | | | +| | S | | | | | | | they remain | fundamentally | | aligned | | with human | values | and | +implementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: intentions. To achieve this, our approach draws on and ex- +tendsseveralfoundationalareaswithinartificialintelligence +(cid:88) +argm i n [L(f θ (q),f θW (q))+D(E S′ (q),E W (q),J)] r e se a r c h , in c lu d i n g e x p l a in a b l e AI, model alignment, and +| θ | | S′ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| S ′ | | | | | | | | la n g u a g | e m o d e l | g e ne r a | li z a ti o n | . | | | | +q∈Q +(2) +By incorporating a learned reward model over debate- RelatedWork +drivenalignment,ourframeworkcreatesadynamiclearning +Ourresearchintegratesandbuildsuponthesekeyareas,par- +| environment | that | scales | beyond | mere | decision | alignment. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ticularlyfocusingontheprogressionfromexplainableAIto +Thestrongmodelisincentivizednotonlytomakedecisions +thedevelopmentofaligned,capablelanguagemodels.This +thatalignwithhumanvaluesbutalsotoconsistentlyprovide +| | | | | | | | | section | traces how | these | concepts | interconnect, | | laying | the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +high-quality,persuasiveexplanationsthatmirrorhumanrea- +foundationforourproposedapproach. +soningprocesses. +Thepracticalimplementationofthisprocessfollowsthese +ExplanationGenerationinAI +steps: +ExplainableAI(XAI)hasbecomeacriticalareaofresearch +Algorithm1:Debate-BasedAlignmentProcess asAIsystemsincreasinglyinfluencevariousaspectsofsoci- +ety(GhodratnamaandZakershahrak2023).Gunning’swork +| Inputs: | Models | M | (strong) | and M | (weak), | Task | in- | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | S | | | W | | | (Gunning2017)definesXAIasthedevelopmentofmachine | | | | | | | | +stanceq learning models that are not only high-performing but also +| Ensure: | AlignedandimprovedstrongmodelM | | | | | S | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | interpretable | by | humans. | This | focus | on interpretability | | be- | +| 1: PresentbothmodelsM | | | | andM | withtaskinstanceq | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | S | W | | | | gan with | efforts | by Swartout | | and Moore | (1993) | to | create | +| 2: Eachmodelproducesadecisionf | | | | | (q)andanexplana- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | θ | | | expertsystemscapableofexplainingtheirdecisions.Asthe | | | | | | | | +tionE(q) +| | | | | | | | | field evolved, | the | emphasis | shifted | | from post-hoc | | explana- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +3: Evaluate explanations using the debate function tionstoinherentlyinterpretablesystems. +D(E S′ ,E W ) Notably, research by Zakershahrak et al. (Zakershahrak +| 4: JudgeJ | determineswhichexplanationissuperior | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------------------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | et al. 2020a, | 2018, | 2020b) | introduced | | progressive | | explana- | +| 5: Finetune | strong | model | M | to minimize | | decision | dis- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | S | | | | tiongenerationtechniquesthatadapttohumanunderstand- | | | | | | | | +crepanciesandimproveexplanations +| | | | | | | | | ing, aligning | closely | with | the | principles | of | Inverse | Rein- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | forcement | Learning | (IRL). | These | approaches | | often | employ | +Thisframeworkcreatesamorerobustandadaptivealign- maximumentropymethods,similartoMaxEntIRL(Ziebart +ment,wherethemodel’sabilitytoexplainitsdecisionsbe- et al. 2008), to manage the uncertainty inherent in human +| comesascrucialasthedecisionsthemselves.Consequently, | | | | | | | | preferences. | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Miller (Miller 2018) further underscored the importance FacilitationinHuman-AITeams +| of social | context | in | AI explanations, | | bridging | AI | expla- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | As AI systems | | have | become | more | advanced, | research | has | +| nations | with human-centric | | | explanation | science. | Our | work | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | increasingly | focused | | on how | these | systems | can | support | +| builds on | these | foundations | | by | incorporating | | dynamic, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | and enhance | human | | decision-making. | | This | research | aligns | +debate-styleexplanationswithinthealignmentprocess,not +| | | | | | | | | closely | with | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | by | exploring | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +onlyenhancingtransparencybutalsousingexplanationsas +howAIcanamplifyhumancapabilities.Bansaletal.(2019) +amechanismtoguideandimproveAIbehavior. +| | | | | | | | | explored | collaborative | | problem-solving | | | between | humans | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | and AI, | while | Kamar | et al. | (2012) | examined | AI-assisted | | +| ModelAlignment | | | | | | | | decision-makingprocesses. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Nancy | Cooke’s | work | on | human-AI | teams | (Cooke | et al. | +As AI systems become more sophisticated, the challenge 2013; Cooke 2015) has been pivotal in understanding the +ofaligningthesesystemswithhumanvaluesandgoalshas +dynamicsofcollaborationbetweenhumansandAI.Seeber +takencenterstage.Leikeetal.(Leikeetal.2018)definethe +etal.(Seeberetal.2020)providedacomprehensivereview +alignmentproblemasensuringthatAIsystemsconsistently +| | | | | | | | | of AI-enabled | | teamwork, | emphasizing | | the | role | of AI as a | +| ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +| pursue | the goals | intended | by | their | creators. | The | develop- | | | | | | | | | +teammemberratherthanameretool. +mentofInverseReinforcementLearning(IRL)methodsby Ourapproachleveragestheseinsightsbypositioningthe +NgandRussell(NgandRussell2000)laidthegroundwork +strongmodelasafacilitatorfortheweakermodel,enhanc- +forpreferencelearninginAI,allowingsystemstoinferand +| | | | | | | | | ing the | alignment | process | through | | structured | learning | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +adopthuman-likegoals. +debate. +| Further | advances, | such | as | cooperative | inverse | reinforce- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ment learning | | (CIRL) | explored | by | Hadfield-Menell | | et al. | | | | | | | | | +LanguageModelAlignment +(Hadfield-Menelletal.2016),modeledalignmentasacoop- +erative game between humans and AI. Stiennon et al. (Sti- Therapidadvancementsinlanguagemodelcapabilitieshave +intensifiedtheneedforrobustalignmentstrategies.TheIn- +| ennon et | al. 2020) | expanded | | on this | by demonstrating | | how | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --------- | +| | | | | | | | | structGPT | approach | | by Ouyang | | et al. | (2022) | showcased | +| summarization | | tasks | can be | used | to align | language | mod- | | | | | | | | | +elswithhumanpreferences,acrucialsteptowardsscalable how large language models could be fine-tuned to align +alignment. more closely with human instructions, representing a key +| | | | | | | | | advancement | | in scalable | alignment | | techniques. | | Bai et al. | +| -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------- | +| Our work | builds | on | these | concepts | by integrating | | weak- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | (2022) further | | contributed | to | this | field with | Constitutional | | +to-stronggeneralizationandexplanationgenerationintothe +| | | | | | | | | AI, which | incorporates | | specific | behavioral | | constraints | dur- | +| --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| alignment | process. | This | combination | | allows | us to | create a | | | | | | | | | +ingtrainingtoensurealignmentwithhumanvalues. +| more holistic | approach | | to aligning | | AI systems, | particularly | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | Anthropic’s | | ”AI | Safety | via Debate” | | research | (Irving, | +incomplextaskenvironments. +| | | | | | | | | Christiano, | and | Amodei | 2018) | introduced | | the idea | of us- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | ing debates | between | | AI systems | | as a method | for | improv- | +Weak-to-StrongGeneralization ingalignment,anapproachthatresonatesstronglywithour +| | | | | | | | | work. This | method | | leverages | adversarial | | dynamics | to en- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Theconceptofweak-to-stronggeneralization,discussedby +hancemodelcapabilitiesandensurealignment.Recentwork +Burnsetal.(Burnsetal.2023),involvesleveragingweaker +byPerezetal.(2023)ondiscoveringlanguagemodelbehav- +AIsystemstosuperviseandguidestrongerAIsystems.This +iorsusinggeneratedtaskdatasetshasprovidednewtoolsfor +paradigmisanextensionoftheideaofcapabilityamplifica- +evaluatingandimprovinglanguagemodelalignment. +| tion, where | the | goal is | to enable | AI | systems | to solve | prob- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ourresearchcomplementstheseapproachesbyintegrat- +lemsbeyondthedirectcapabilitiesoftheirdevelopers. +ingweak-to-stronggeneralizationwithdebate-drivenlearn- +| This | approach | has | its roots | in | model compression | | and | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ing. By | combining | the | strengths | of | explanation | generation, | | +knowledge distillation, as first introduced by Buciluaˇ et al. weak-to-strong generalization, and structured debates, we +(Buciluaˇ, Caruana, and Niculescu-Mizil 2006) and refined offerascalableandtransparentframeworkforensuringlan- +| by Hinton | et al. | (LeCun, | Bengio, | and | Hinton | 2015). | These | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guagemodelalignmentthatcanadapttotheincreasingcom- +methodshavebeensuccessfullyappliedinnaturallanguage +plexityofAIsystems. +processing,wherestudent-teachermodels(Sanhetal.2019) +havedemonstratedthatsmallermodelscanachievehighper- +Methodology +formancewithfewerresources.RecentworkbySchickand +Schu¨tze(Mittaletal.2023)onfew-shotlearningfurtheril- Our research explores weak-to-strong generalization as a +lustrateshowsmallermodelscanbeenhancedthrougheffi- technique for model alignment. The core idea is to use +cientlearningtechniques. +| | | | | | | | | weaker | models | to supervise | | stronger | models, | serving | as an | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +Ourframeworkextendstheseideasbyapplyingweak-to- analogy for how humans might align superhuman AI sys- +stronggeneralizationasameansofaligningAIsystems.By tems.Thisapproachallowsustostudyalignmentchallenges +incorporating structured debates and explanations, we cre- empiricallyusingcurrentmodels,whilepotentiallyyielding +ate a mechanism where weaker models can guide stronger insightsapplicabletofuture,morecapablesystems. +models, even in scenarios where the weaker model (or hu- The weak-to-strong learning process consists of three +| mansupervisor)lacksfullexpertise. | | | | | | | | mainsteps: | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +1. Create a weak supervisor by finetuning a smaller pre- Baseline Method We finetune the strong student model +trainedmodelongroundtruthlabels. on the weak labels over 2 epochs with a batch size of 32. +2. Generateweaklabelsusingthesupervisoronaheld-out Early stopping is applied based on the model’s agreement +| dataset. | | | | | | | | withweaklabelsonthevalidationset. | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Trainastrongerstudentmodelusingtheseweaklabels. +Algorithm3:BaselineStrongStudentTraining +Weevaluatethisprocessacrossmultipletaskdomainsand Inputs: Weaklabelsf (x),StrongstudentmodelM +| | | | | | | | | | | w | | | S | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +modelsizestounderstanditsscalabilityandlimitations. +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | TrainedstrongstudentmodelM | | | S | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: InitializeM | S | withpretrainedweights | | | | +ExperimentalSetup +2: foreachepochi=1to2do +Models WeusepretrainedlanguagemodelsfromtheGPT- 3: TrainM onweaklabelsf (x)withbatchsize32 +| | | | | | | | | | S | | w | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4family,whichspan7ordersofmagnitudeincompute.This 4: ifvalidationaccuracyimprovesthen +wide range allows us to analyze the performance gap be- UpdateM +| | | | | | | | | 5: | | S | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| tweenweakandstrongmodelsacrossdifferentlevelsofca- | | | | | | | | 6: else | | | | | | +pability.ThemodelsareaccessedthroughtheOpenAIAPI, 7: Applyearlystopping +| and we replace | | the unembedding | | layer | with | a task-specific | | 8: endif | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| linear classification | | head | for | each model | to | suit the | experi- | 9: endfor | | | | | | +ments. +Tasks Weevaluateourmethodsontwosettings: +| | | | | | | | | Improved | Methods | To | enhance the performance | | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ------ | +1. NaturalLanguageProcessing(NLP)benchmarks:We strongstudentmodel,weemployseveralimprovedmethods: +useasuiteof22classificationtasks,coveringareaslike +| | | | | | | | | a) Auxiliary | | Confidence | Loss: We | introduce | a | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| ethics, | commonsense | | reasoning, | | natural | language | infer- | | | | | | | +confidence-drivenlosstermthatbalancesthecross-entropy +| ence, | and sentiment | | analysis. | All | tasks | are | converted | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ---- | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | loss between | weak | label | predictions and | a thresholded | | +| to binary | classification, | | with | soft | labels | from | the weak | | | | | | | +versionofthemodel’sownpredictions. +modelusedfortraining.ThesetasksarelistedinTable1. +| 2. Chess | puzzles: | Using | the | Chess | Game | Dataset | from | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Algorithm4:AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss +Lichess(Datasnaek2021),wepredictthebestmovefor +eachposition.Thedatasetconsistsofsequencesofmoves Inputs: Model predictions f(x), Weak labels f (x), +w +| | | | | | | | | Thresholdedpredictionsf | | | (x),Weightingfactorα | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | +| leadinguptoapuzzle,formattedasinputsforourmodel. | | | | | | | | | | | t | | | +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | UpdatedmodelM | | withconfidence-drivenloss | | | +S +1: Setα=0.75forlargemodels,0.5otherwise +WeakSupervisorCreation +| | | | | | | | | 2: ComputeL | | (f)=(1−α)·CE(f(x),f | | | (x))+α· | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | | conf | | | w | | +We create weak supervisors by generating weak labels, CE(f(x),f (x)) +t +whichguidethealignmentofstrongermodels.Theprocess 3: TrainM usingL (f)withlinearwarm-upoverthe +S conf +involvesthefollowingstepsmentionedinAlgorithm2: first20%oftraining +Algorithm2:WeakLabelGenerationProcess +| | | | | | | | | b) Bootstrapping: | | Rather | than training | the | strongest | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | +Inputs: TaskdatasetD +| | | | | | | | | model directly | with | the weakest | supervisor, | we | use inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +Ensure: WeaklabelsgeneratedforD +| | | | | | | | | mediate models | in | a bootstrapping | process, | iterating | weak- | +| -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | --- | --------------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | +| 1: Split | dataset | D into | two | halves: | D and | D , | grouping | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 1 | 2 | | to-stronglearninginstages. | | | | | | +relateddatapoints +| 2: Finetune | a | smaller | pretrained | model | M | on | D using | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | W | 1 | Algorithm5:BootstrappingwithIntermediateModels | | | | | | +groundtruthlabels +3: UseM W togenerateweaklabelsforD 2 Inputs: Weak labels f w (x), Intermediate models +| | | | | | | | | M ,M | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | S1 | S2 | | S | | | +Ensure: TrainedstrongmodelM +| After generating | | weak | labels, | we | train | the weak | super- | | | | S | | | +| ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------- | ------ | -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: Foreachroundr | | =1to3: | | | | +| visor over | 2 epochs | with | a | batch | size of | 32. Early | stop- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ForeachintermediatemodelM | | | | : | | +| | | | | | | | | 2: | | | Si | | | +| ping is applied | | based | on validation | | accuracy | to ensure | the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 3: | TrainM | Si onf w | (x)andgeneratenewweaklabels | | | +| model is | properly | trained | to | produce | informative | | labels for | | | | | | | +f (x) +| thestrongermodels. | | | | | | | | wi | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 4: Train | M | on f | (x) using the | best intermediate | | +S wi +model +StrongStudentTraining +| The strong | student | model | is | trained | using | the weak | labels. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +We apply several training strategies, including a baseline c) Generative Finetuning: Before weak-to-strong train- +method and more advanced techniques to improve perfor- ing, we perform unsupervised finetuning on task-relevant +| mance. | | | | | | | | datatoimprovethemodel’srepresentationofkeyconcepts. | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| TaskName | | Source | | | | | Description | | | | | | TaskType | | +| -------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| CoLA | | Warstadtetal.,2019 | | | | | Linguisticacceptability | | | | | | Binary | | +| SST-2 | | Socheretal.,2013 | | | | | Sentimentanalysis | | | | | | Binary | | +| MRPC | | Dolan&Brockett,2005 | | | | | Paraphrasedetection | | | | | | Binary | | +| STS-B | | Ceretal.,2017 | | | | | Semantictextualsimilarity | | | | | | Regression | | +| QQP | | Quora | | | | | Questionpairsimilarity | | | | | | Binary | | +| MNLI | | Williamsetal.,2018 | | | | | Naturallanguageinference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| QNLI | | Rajpurkaretal.,2016 | | | | | QuestionansweringNLI | | | | | | Binary | | +| RTE | | Daganetal.,2006 | | | | | Recognizingtextualentailment | | | | | | Binary | | +| WNLI | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| AX | | Wangetal.,2019 | | | | | DiagnosticdatasetforMNLI | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| CB | | DeMarneffeetal.,2019 | | | | | CommitmentBank | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| COPA | | Roemmeleetal.,2011 | | | | | ChoiceofPlausibleAlternatives | | | | | | Binary | | +MultiRC Khashabietal.,2018 Multi-SentenceReadingComprehension Binary +ReCoRD Zhangetal.,2018 ReadingComprehensionwithCommonsense Binary +| WiC | | Pilehvar&Camacho-Collados,2019 | | | | | Word-in-Context | | | | | | Binary | | +| --------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| WSC | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| BoolQ | | Clarketal.,2019 | | | | | BooleanQuestions | | | | | | Binary | | +| RACE | | Laietal.,2017 | | | | | ReadingComprehension | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SciTail | | Khotetal.,2018 | | | | | ScienceQuestionAnswering | | | | | | Binary | | +| SNLI | | Bowmanetal.,2015 | | | | | NaturalLanguageInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SWAG | | Zellersetal.,2018 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| HellaSWAG | | Zellersetal.,2019 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +Table1:NLPClassificationTasks +Algorithm6:GenerativeFinetuning model size. Each stage consists of 3 iterations of weak-to- +| | | | | | | | | strong learning. | | The learning | rate | is reduced | by | a factor of | +| ------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| Inputs: | Task-relevantdataD | | | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | task | | | S | | | | | | | | | +| Ensure: | FinetunedstrongmodelM | | | | | | | 10ateachstage. | | | | | | | +S +| 1: PretrainM | | S onD task | withalanguagemodelingobjec- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | GenerativeFinetuning | | | Forgenerativefinetuning,wepre- | | | | +tive +trainthestrongmodelontask-relevant,unlabeleddatausing +| 2: Proceed | with | weak-to-strong | | training | on | weak | labels | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +alanguagemodelingobjective.Wethenfinetunethemodel +f (x) +| w | | | | | | | | usingweaklabels,withalearningrateof5e−5 | | | | | | andabatch | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +sizeof16. +These methods collectively improve the robustness and EvaluationMetrics +| accuracy | of the | strong student | | model, | enabling | better | gen- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eralization and alignment with weak labels across different 1. PerformanceGapRecovered(PGR): +tasks. +P −P +| | | | | | | | | | | PGR= | | ws w | | (3) | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DetailedMethodsDescription | | | | | | | | | | | | P s −P w | | | +Baseline Method For the baseline method, we finetune WhereP istheweak-to-strongperformance,P +| | | | | | | | | | ws | | | | | w isthe | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | +| the strong | student | model | directly | on weak | labels | generated | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | weak | performance, | | and P s | is the strong | ceiling | perfor- | +1e−4, +| by the weak | supervisor. | | We use | a learning | rate | of | a | mance. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +batchsizeof32,andapplyearlystoppingbasedonvalida- +| | | | | | | | | 2. Student-SupervisorAgreement:Thefractionoftestin- | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionaccuracy. +putswherethestrongstudentmakesthesameprediction +astheweaksupervisor. +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| method | introduces | a loss | term | that combines | | cross-entropy | | | | | | | | | +loss with confidence-based regularization. The weighting AblationStudies +factorαissetto0.5formediummodelsand0.75forlarge +| | | | | | | | | We conduct | ablation | studies | to | evaluate | the impact | of dif- | +| ------- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | +| models, | with linear | warm-up | over | the | first 20% | of training | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ferent components | | of our | method. | Specifically, | | we analyze | +epochs. +| | | | | | | | | the effect | of removing | | the auxiliary | confidence | | loss, boot- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +Bootstrapping In the bootstrapping approach, we train strapping, and generative finetuning. The results are shown +| intermediate | models | in | three | stages, | gradually | increasing | | inTable2. | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 2: Ablation Study Results: Impact of Removing Key tratesthePerformanceGapRecovered(PGR)acrossdiffer- +Components on Model Performance. The table shows ac- enttaskdomainsandmodelsizes. +curacy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) when each +componentisremoved.Lowervalueshighlightthecompo- Performance Across Tasks Figure 1 illustrates the test +nent’s importance. Auxiliary Confidence Loss and Genera- accuracy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) for our +tiveFinetuninghavethemostsignificantimpact,underscor- three task domains: NLP benchmarks, chess puzzles, and +ingtheircriticalroleintheframework’seffectiveness. ChatGPTrewardmodeling. +Method Accuracy PGR +(Without) (Without) +Aux.Confidence 0.82 0.60 +Bootstrapping 0.80 0.55 +Gen.Finetuning 0.85 0.70 +Analysis +Weconductthreetypesofanalysis: +1. Scaling Behavior: We plot PGR and test accuracy +againstsupervisorandstudentmodelsizes. +2. Error Analysis: We manually inspect cases where the +studentmodelmakesmistakes,categorizingerrortypes. +Figure 1: PGR as a function of model size for each task +3. ConceptSaliency:Wemeasuretheperformanceoflin- +domain. Higher PGR values indicate more effective weak- +ear probes on frozen model activations before and after +to-stronglearning.ThegraphshowsthatPGRgenerallyin- +weak-to-strongtraining. +creases with model size for NLP tasks, while it decreases +This methodology provides a comprehensive framework +forlargermodelsinchesstasks,indicatingscalabilitychal- +for studying weak-to-strong generalization in model align- +lenges. Reward modeling shows consistently lower PGR, +ment, incorporating various training techniques and eval- +highlightingtheneedformoreadvancedmethods. +uation metrics to assess the effectiveness of our approach +acrossdifferenttasksandmodelsizes. +ResultsandAnalysis +Our work builds upon and extends recent advancements in +language model alignment, leveraging weak-to-strong gen- +eralizationtechniques to address the challengesof aligning +increasinglycomplexAIsystems. +Toverifytherobustnessofourresults,weconductpaired +t-testscomparingtheperformanceofdifferentmethods.The +resultsarepresentedinTable3. +Table 3: Statistical Significance of Method Improvements. +P-values for paired t-tests comparing the baseline method +to each enhanced approach in terms of Accuracy and Per- +formance Gap Recovered (PGR). Lower p-values (< 0.05) +indicatestatisticallysignificantimprovementsoverthebase- Figure 2: Accuracy as a function of model size for each +line,withBootstrappingshowingthemostsignificantgains. task domain. Weak-to-strong generalization improves per- +formance across all tasks, with NLP achieving the highest +Comparison P-value P-value accuracy.ChessandRewardModelingshowdiminishingre- +(Accuracy) (PGR) turnswithlargermodels,highlightingchallengesinscaling +Baselinevs.Aux.Confidence 0.03 0.01 theapproachtomorecomplextasksandareasforfuturere- +Baselinevs.Bootstrapping 0.003 0.002 search +Baselinevs.Gen.Finetuning 0.01 0.01 +NLP tasks: We observe promising weak-to-strong gen- +eralization, with PGR often exceeding 50% for the largest +BaselineWeak-to-StrongGeneralization +student models. Chess puzzles: PGR is high for small +Our initial experiments demonstrate that strong pretrained supervisor-student gaps but decreases for larger gaps. Re- +modelscannaturallygeneralizebeyondtheirweaksupervi- ward modeling: Weak-to-strong generalization is poor by +sorswhennaivelyfinetunedonweaklabels.Figure1illus- default,withPGRrarelyexceeding20%. + +Scaling Behavior We find that PGR generally increases AnalysisofGeneralizationMechanisms +| with both | weak | supervisor | size and | strong | student | size for | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Imitation | vs. | Generalization | | We | analyze | student- | | +NLPtasks.However,forchesspuzzles,PGRdecreaseswith +| | | | | | | | supervisor | agreement | to | understand | | the extent | of imitation | | +| -------------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | +| strong student | size | for a | given | weak supervisor. | | Reward | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | versus true | generalization, | | | illustrated | in | Figure | 3. The | +modelingshowspoorscalingbehavioroverall. +| | | | | | | | student-supervisor | | agreement | | trends | corroborate | our | sta- | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------------ | ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | +| Our findings | on | scaling | behavior | align | with the | observa- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tistical | significance | results | (Table | | 3), providing | | insights | +tionsof(Baietal.2022)intheirworkonConstitutionalAI, +| | | | | | | | into the | effectiveness | | of different | weak-to-strong | | learning | | +| ---------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| suggesting | that | alignment | techniques | must | adapt | as model | | | | | | | | | +methods. +capabilitiesincrease. +| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Figure | 3, all | methods | exhibit | decreasing | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | agreement | rates | as model | size | increases, | but | to varying | de- | +ImprovedWeak-to-StrongGeneralizationMethods +grees.Thisgeneraltrendsuggeststhatlargermodelstendto +Drawing inspiration from ”AI Safety via Debate” frame- diverge more from the weak supervisor’s predictions, indi- +work (Irving, Christiano, and Amodei 2018), we explore cating potential generalization beyond the initial weak su- +| methods | to enhance | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | through | pervision. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +adversarialdynamicsandstructuredlearning. +Notably,theBootstrappingmethoddemonstratesthemost +substantialdecreaseinagreementacrossmodelsizes(from +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | -------- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | 0.88 for | small | models | to 0.75 | for large | models). | This | pro- | +| significantly | improves | weak-to-strong | | generalization, | | par- | | | | | | | | | +nounceddeclinealignswithitslowestp-valuesinourstatis- +ticularlyforNLPtasks. +| | | | | | | | tical significance | | tests | (p = 0.003 | for | accuracy, | p = | 0.002 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | for PGR), | suggesting | that | Bootstrapping | | is | particularly | ef- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +• Forthelargestsupervisor-studentgaps,medianPGRin- fective at enabling the model to surpass the weak supervi- +| creases | from | about 25% | to nearly | 80% | with | the confi- | sor’sperformance. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +denceloss. The Auxiliary Confidence and Generative Finetuning +• The improvement is most pronounced for large gaps in methods show moderate decreases in agreement (0.89 to +computebetweenweakandstrongmodels. 0.80and0.89to0.79,respectively),consistentwiththeirin- +| | | | | | | | termediate | p-values. | These | methods | | appear | to strike | a bal- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | +This approach can be seen as an extension of the debate ancebetweenleveragingweaksupervisionandencouraging +framework, encouraging models to make confident predic- independentgeneralization. +tionswhilestillleveragingweaksupervision. +Incontrast,theBaselinemethodmaintainsrelativelyhigh +| | | | | | | | agreement | across | all model | sizes | (0.90 | to 0.87), | indicating | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Bootstrapping | | Bootstrappingshowspromisingresultsfor | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that without | additional | | techniques, | | larger | models | tend to | +chesspuzzlesbutyieldslimitedimprovementsforNLPand +morecloselymimictheweaksupervisor,potentiallyinclud- +rewardmodelingtasks. +ingitserrors. +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | These | findings | suggest | that | our enhanced | | methods, | par- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | +• Bootstrapping improves PGR compared to the baseline, ticularlyBootstrapping,aremoreeffectiveatenablingmod- +especiallyforlargerstudentmodels. elstogeneralizebeyondtheweaksupervisor’scapabilities. +Thedecreasingagreementrates,coupledwithimprovedper- +| • The | accuracy | continues | to monotonically | | improve | with | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bootstrapping,unliketheflatteningobservedinthenaive formance(asindicatedbylowerp-values),demonstratethat +thesemethodsfacilitatethedevelopmentofmodelsthatcan +method. +| | | | | | | | leverage | weak | supervision | while | still | developing | indepen- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +The bootstrapping method resonates with the iterative dentandpotentiallysuperiordecision-makingcapabilities. +| refinement | processes | suggested | in | Constitutional | | AI (Bai | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----- | --------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | Larger | student | models | show | lower | agreement | with | weak | +etal.2022),allowingforgradualimprovementofalignment +| | | | | | | | supervisors, | suggesting | | less imitation | | of errors. | The | auxil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +acrossmodelscales. iary confidenceloss furtherreduces imitationof supervisor +mistakes. +| Generative | Finetuning | | Generative | finetuning | | on reward | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | These | findings | contribute | | to our | understanding | | of how | +| modeling | data improves | | weak-to-strong | | performance | and | | | | | | | | | +modelsbalanceimitationandtruegeneralization,akeycon- +PGR. +cerninscalingalignmenttechniques(Ouyangetal.2022). +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | ConceptSaliency | | Weinvestigatethelinearrepresentabil- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• PGRimprovesbyapproximately10-20%withgenerative +| | | | | | | | ity of desired | | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +finetuning. +learning.Figure4illustratesthechangeinlinearprobeper- +• Theimprovementstackswithearly-stoppingtechniques, +| | | | | | | | formance | for key | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +achievingPGRof30-40%. +learning. +This technique builds on the insights from (Dehghani Finetuningonweaklabelsincreasesthelinearseparability +et al. 2017; Pe´rez-D’Arpino, Khurshid, and Shah 2020) on ofgroundtruthconcepts.Thissuggeststhatweak-to-strong +discovering and shaping language model behaviors, using learning may help make desired concepts more salient in +| task-relevantdatatoenhancealignment. | | | | | | | modelrepresentations. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Figure3:Student-supervisoragreementacrossmodelsizesfordifferentweak-to-strongmethods.Decliningagreementinboot- +strapping and Auxiliary confidence suggests improved generalization, while the baseline method remains stable, indicating +limitedgeneralization. +| This analysis | provides | | insights | into how | weak-to-strong | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | +learningmayhelpinshapingmodelbehavior,complement- +ingtheworkonConstitutionalAI(Baietal.2022)ininstill- +ingdesiredconceptsandvalues. +ErrorAnalysis +| We conducted | a detailed | | error analysis | | on cases | where the | +| ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +strongstudentmodelmakesmistakes.Commonerrortypes +include: +• Poorquoteselection(forNLPtasks) +| • Inability | to extract | key | evidence | from | weak | supervision | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | +(forrewardmodeling) +• Overfittingtoweaklabelerrors(acrossalltasks) +Ourerroranalysisbuildsontheframeworkofdebate(Irv- +ing,Christiano,andAmodei2018),identifyingareaswhere +| adversarial | dynamics | can | be leveraged | | to improve | model | +| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | +performanceandalignment. +| To better | understand | | the types | of errors | made | by the | +| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | +Figure4:Conceptsaliencybeforeandafterweak-to-strong +learningforkeyNLPconcepts.Thefigureshowsimproved strong student model, we present the distribution of error +linearprobeperformance,indicatingenhancedmodelrepre- typesinFigure5. +sentationsacrossallconcepts.LargergainsinSentimentvs. +DiscussionandConclusion +Intentsuggestthatweak-to-stronglearningaffectsdifferent +aspects of language understanding to varying degrees, pro- Ourworkdemonstratestheeffectivenessofweak-to-strong +vidinginsightsforfutureimprovements. generalization in language models for model alignment. +| The proposed | framework, | | which | combines | facilitation | and | +| ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | +| debate-based | learning, | shows | promise | in | enhancing | model | +| performance | and | alignment | across | various | tasks. | Through | + +| | | | | | | | • While an | improvement | over | baseline | approaches, | | naive | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | +finetuningonweaksupervisionisinsufficienttofullyre- +coverstrongmodelperformance,indicatingtheneedfor +moresophisticatedtransfertechniques. +| | | | | | | | • Generalization | remains | inconsistent | | across | tasks, | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | complex | domains like | reward | modeling | | proving | partic- | +ularlychallenging.Thishighlightstheneedformorero- +bustandadaptivealignmenttechniques. +• Ourcurrentsetup,thoughanadvancementoverprevious +| | | | | | | | methods, | may not fully | capture | the | difficulties | | of align- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +ingsuperhumanAIsystems,suchasthepotentialeaseof +imitatinghuman-levelerrors. +Theselimitationspointtoseveralpromisingdirectionsfor +Figure5:Distributionoferrortypesfromtheerroranalysis. +futurework: +Thechartshowsthatpoorquoteselectionandevidenceex- +| | | | | | | | • Developing | more sophisticated | | | debate | mechanisms | to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +tractionaccountfor70%oferrors,suggestingimprovements +enhancethequalityandefficiencyofknowledgetransfer +| in identifying | relevant | information | | could enhance | weak-to- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweenmodelsofvaryingcapabilities. +stronglearning.Overfittingerrors(20%)arerelativelylow, +indicating the approach generally succeeds in generalizing • Exploringtheintegrationofourapproachwithotherscal- +beyondweaklabels,thoughfurtherimprovementispossible +| | | | | | | | able oversight | methods | to | create | more | comprehensive | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | +alignmentframeworks. +| | | | | | | | • Investigating | the application | | of this | framework | | to even | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | +| our experiments | | and analysis, | we | have gained | several | key | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | more advanced | AI | systems | and diverse | | task domains | to | +insightsintothenatureofmodelalignmentthroughfacilita- +testitsscalabilityandgeneralizability. +tion: +• Refiningourunderstandingofmodelbehaviorandalign- +| 1. Strong | models | demonstrate | a remarkable | | ability | to gen- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | ment across | increasing | scales | of | capability | to | better ad- | +| eralize | beyond | weak supervision, | | particularly | | in NLP | | | | | | | | +dressthechallengesofaligningsuperhumanAIsystems. +| tasks, | suggesting | the potential | | for knowledge | | transfer | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +acrossdifferentcapabilitylevels. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that weak-to- +2. The introduction of auxiliary confidence loss signif- strong generalization is a promising approach for model +icantly improves generalization, especially for large alignment,capableofelicitingstrongcapabilitiesfromlim- +| supervisor-student | | gaps, | highlighting | the | importance | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ited supervision. | By bridging | | the gap | between | explanation | | +calibratedconfidenceinthealignmentprocess. generationandmodelalignment,ourframeworkopensnew +3. Techniquessuchasbootstrappingandgenerativefinetun- avenues for creating AI systems that are not only powerful +ing show potential in addressing domain-specific chal- but also fundamentally aligned with human values and in- +tentions.Whilesignificantchallengesremaininscalingthis +lenges,asevidencedbytheireffectivenessinchesspuz- +approachtomorecomplextasksandtrulysuperhumanmod- +zlesandrewardmodelingtasks. +4. Thelearningprocessrequiresadelicatebalancebetween els,theinsightsgainedfromthisworkprovideasolidfoun- +dationforfutureresearchinAIalignmentandsafety. +imitationandtruegeneralization,emphasizingthecom- +| plexity | of aligning | AI | systems | with human | values | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| intentions. | | | | | | | | | References | | | | | +Compared to traditional explanation generation ap- Bai, Y.; Kadavath, S.; Kundu, S.; Askell, A.; Kernion, J.; +proaches,ourframeworkoffersseveraladvantages: Jones,A.;Chen,A.;Goldie,A.;Mirhoseini,A.;McKinnon, +C.;etal.2022.Constitutionalai:Harmlessnessfromaifeed- +• ItprovidesamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +back. arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.08073. +capabilitiesevolve,addressingthescalabilitychallenges +facedbycurrentmethodslikeRLHF. Buciluaˇ, C.; Caruana, R.; and Niculescu-Mizil, A. 2006. +• Thedebate-basedcomponentenhancestransparencyand Model compression. In Proceedings of the 12th ACM +interpretability, allowing for more nuanced oversight of SIGKDDinternationalconferenceonKnowledgediscovery +| thealignmentprocess. | | | | | | | anddatamining,535–541. | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• By leveraging both weak and strong models, our ap- Burns, C.; Izmailov, P.; Kirchner, J. H.; Baker, B.; Gao, +proachpotentiallyovercomeslimitationsofhumanover- L.; Aschenbrenner, L.; Chen, Y.; Ecoffet, A.; Joglekar, M.; +sightincomplextasks. Leike,J.;etal.2023. Weak-to-stronggeneralization:Elicit- +ingstrongcapabilitieswithweaksupervision.arXivpreprint +| However, | despite | these | promising | results, | several | limita- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionsandchallengesremain,echoingconcernsidentifiedin arXiv:2312.09390. +recent alignment research (Ouyang et al. 2022; Bai et al. Cooke,N.J.2015. Teamcognitionasinteraction. Current +2022;Pe´rez-D’Arpino,Khurshid,andShah2020): directionsinpsychologicalscience,24(6):415–419. + +Cooke,N.J.;Gorman,J.C.;Myers,C.W.;andDuran,J.L. Stiennon, N.; Ouyang, L.; Wu, J.; Ziegler, D.; Lowe, R.; +2013. Interactiveteamcognition. Cognitivescience,37(2): Voss, C.; Radford, A.; Amodei, D.; and Christiano, P. F. +| 255–285. | | | | | | | 2020. | Learning | to | summarize | with | human | feedback. | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Advances | in Neural | | Information | Processing | | Systems, | 33: | +Datasnaek.2021.ChessGameDataset(Lichess).Accessed: +3008–3021. +2024-08-09. +Zakershahrak,M.;Gong,Z.;Sadassivam,N.;andZhang,Y. +Dehghani,M.;Severyn,A.;Rothe,S.;andKamps,J.2017. +2020a. Onlineexplanationgenerationforplanningtasksin +Learningtolearnfromweaksupervisionbyfullsupervision. +human-robotteaming.In2020IEEE/RSJInternationalCon- +arXivpreprintarXiv:1711.11383. +| | | | | | | | ference | on Intelligent | | Robots | and Systems | (IROS), | | 6304– | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| Ghodratnama, | S.; | and | Zakershahrak, | M. | 2023. | Adapt- | 6310.IEEE. | | | | | | | | +ingLLMsforEfficient,PersonalizedInformationRetrieval: +| | | | | | | | Zakershahrak, | | M.; Marpally, | | S. R.; Sharma, | | A.; Gong, | Z.; | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | +| Methods | and Implications. | | In | International | Conference | on | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Zhang, | Y. | 2020b. | Order | Matters: | Generating | | Pro- | +Service-OrientedComputing,17–26.Springer. +| | | | | | | | gressive | Explanations | | for Planning | Tasks | in | Human-Robot | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| Ghodratnama,S.;andZakershahrak,M.2024. | | | | | SumRecom: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Teaming. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2004.07822. | | | | | | | +APersonalizedSummarizationApproachbyLearningfrom Zakershahrak, M.; Sonawane, A.; Gong, Z.; and Zhang, Y. +| Users’Feedback. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2408.07294. | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2018.Interactiveplanexplicabilityinhuman-robotteaming. +Gunning, D. 2017. Explainable artificial intelligence (xai). In 2018 27th IEEE International Symposium on Robot and +Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), nd HumanInteractiveCommunication(RO-MAN),1012–1017. +| Web. | | | | | | | IEEE. | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Hadfield-Menell,D.;Russell,S.J.;Abbeel,P.;andDragan, Ziebart, B. D.; Maas, A.; Bagnell, J. A.; and Dey, A. K. +A. 2016. Cooperative inverse reinforcement learning. In 2008. MaximumEntropyInverseReinforcementLearning. +Advances in neural information processing systems, 3909– InProceedingsofthe23rdNationalConferenceonArtificial +Intelligence-Volume3,AAAI’08,1433–1438.AAAIPress. +3917. +Irving, G.; Christiano, P.; and Amodei, D. 2018. AI safety ISBN9781577353683. +| viadebate. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1805.00899. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| LeCun,Y.;Bengio,Y.;andHinton,G.2015. | | | | | Deeplearning. | | | | | | | | | | +nature,521(7553):436–444. +Leike,J.;Krueger,D.;Everitt,T.;Martic,M.;Maini,V.;and +| Legg,S.2018. | Scalableagentalignmentviarewardmodel- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ing:aresearchdirection. | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:1811.07871. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Miller, | T. 2018. | Explanation | | in artificial | intelligence: | In- | | | | | | | | | +| sightsfromthesocialsciences. | | | | ArtificialIntelligence. | | | | | | | | | | | +Mittal,A.;Schick,T.;Artetxe,M.;andDwivedi-Yu,J.2023. +| Evaluation | of Faithfulness | | Using | the | Longest | Supported | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Subsequence. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2308.12157. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Ng, A. | Y.; and Russell, | | S. J. 2000. | Algorithms | | for Inverse | | | | | | | | | +InICML,663–670.MorganKauf- +ReinforcementLearning. +mannPublishersInc. +Ouyang,L.;Wu,J.;Jiang,X.;Almeida,D.;Wainwright,C.; +| Mishkin, | P.; Zhang, | C.; | Agarwal, | S.; Slama, | K.; | Ray, A.; | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| etal.2022. | Traininglanguagemodelstofollowinstructions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| withhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralinformationpro- | | | | | | | | | | | | +cessingsystems,35:27730–27744. +Pe´rez-D’Arpino,C.;Khurshid,R.P.;andShah,J.A.2020. +| Experimental | Assessment | | of | Human-Robot | Teaming | for | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Multi-Step | Remote | Manipulation | | with | Expert | Operators. | | | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2011.10898. +| Sanh,V.;Debut,L.;Chaumond,J.;andWolf,T.2019. | | | | | | Dis- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tilBERT,adistilledversionofBERT:smaller,faster,cheaper +| andlighter. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1910.01108. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Seeber, | I.; Bittner, | E.; | Briggs, | R. O.; | De Vreede, | T.; | | | | | | | | | +DeVreede,G.-J.;Elkins,A.;Maier,R.;Merz,A.B.;Oeste- +| Reiß,S.;Randrup,N.;etal.2020. | | | | Machinesasteammates: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| AresearchagendaonAIinteamcollaboration. | | | | | | Information | | | | | | | | | +&management,57(2):103174. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q226/random_k4/question.json b/q226/random_k4/question.json index 8ea351c1a9d7f119cc86d81ddd1ad57a21f6a2f5..601be1a6229f659e44285160978a3fca8ad045db 100644 --- a/q226/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q226/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NETFLIX_2015_10K.pdf", - "web_f7c8a4fb24ac7362.pdf", - "web_8f3d7e741a1d660a.pdf", - "web_830d0aa2115caf34.pdf", - "eb30c70c153e1dbc5a0ea9bd5a306750a2b4ebf7.pdf" + "resize_r1_27.pdf", + "web_423699b643b21d01.pdf", + "web_f8f90e71a8e2a36d.pdf", + "resize_r1_15.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q226/random_k4/random_1.md b/q226/random_k4/random_1.md index 2a08a5d152b0c9f673b119f3b536a79719deb932..115f4732d2b2b4ac58bc190c98e665ccd42edf1b 100644 --- a/q226/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q226/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,524 +1,560 @@ -Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +ETSI White Paper No. 11 -TO OUR SHAREHOLDERS +Mobile Edge Computing +A key technology towards 5G -05 +First edition – September 2015 -09 +ISBN No. 979-10-92620-08-5 -CEO Letter +Authors: -Report by the Supervisory Board +Yun Chao Hu, Milan Patel, Dario Sabella, Nurit Sprecher and Valerie Young -4 - - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +ETSI (European Telecommunications Standards Institute) +06921 Sophia Antipolis CEDEX, France +Tel +33 4 92 94 42 00 +info@etsi.org +www.etsi.org -CEO-LETTER + About the authors -↗ BJØRN GULDEN +Yun Chao Hu +Contributor, Huawei, Vice Chair ETSI MEC ISG, Chair MEC IEG Working Group -CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER PUMA +Milan Patel +Contributor, Huawei -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, +Dario Sabella +Contributor, Telecom Italia; Vice-Chair MEC IEG Working Group -I hope this letter finds you well despite the current challenges around the world. After more than -two years, the COVID-19 pandemic still has a negative impact on our daily lives and business and -now we’re also facing a conflict in the heart of Europe that is causing terrible human suffering. +Nurit Sprecher +Contributor, Nokia; Chair ETSI MEC ISG -We’re in constant dialogue with all our stakeholders in Ukraine and we do our utmost to support -our local employees and their families as well as all our partners, ambassadors, and athletes -wherever we can. Ensuring the health and safety of our people continues to be our number one -priority, as we have already demonstrated throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. We have set up a -safe house in Ukraine, we are delivering food, water, and other necessities directly to our people -and we are helping women and children who want to leave the country. We currently have 40 -women and children in accommodation in Poland and about 120 here in Germany. Many of the -adults have already started working and most of the children are already attending schools and -kindergarten. Their positive attitude and mindset, as well as their willingness to work and -integrate, is remarkable. They are strong and positive people. I sincerely hope that this conflict -will be solved diplomatically as soon as possible, that further bloodshed can be avoided and that -peace will be restored. +Valerie Young +Contributor, Intel -While we are most concerned about the lives and livelihoods of the people who are directly -affected in Ukraine and by the COVID-19 pandemic, the conflict as well as the pandemic also have -a significant business impact on our sector and on PUMA. In addition to the impact on our -operations in Russia and Ukraine, we continue to face some of the challenges that we already -saw during the course of 2021: COVID-19 related lockdowns and restrictions in different parts of -the world, a weak consumer sentiment in some key markets, significant challenges in our supply -chain, strong inflationary pressures, and geopolitical tensions. +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -5 +2 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -Despite all these challenges, 2021 was a very successful year for us. To be specific, it was the -best year in PUMA’s history. Due to our continued brand momentum combined with high -operational flexibility and a fantastic effort from our employees, our sales grew by 32% to -EUR 6,805m and EBIT grew by 166% to EUR 557m. Compared to the pre-pandemic level of 2019, -our sales increased by 30%, resulting in a two-year CAGR of around 15% during these -challenging times. Our strategy of working closely together with all our suppliers and retail -partners to manage short-term issues without hindering our mid-term momentum continued to -pay off. Our external partners supported us in an extraordinary way and the dedication and -commitment of all our employees during such a challenging year was truly exceptional. A lot of -our employees went far beyond what a company can expect from them and in the name of the -entire PUMA Board, I would like to thank everyone for their contribution towards making these -results possible. People make the difference and our PUMA family is our biggest strength and -asset. - -Throughout 2021, we continued to focus on the three main areas that we defined in early 2020 in -reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic: Deal with COVID, continue to drive the business and continue -to do the right thing in areas such as social responsibility and environmental sustainability. - -Dealing with COVID first and foremost meant ensuring the health and safety of our people and -everyone in our value chain. We continued to adopt and comply with very strict health and safety -measures across our operations and rolled out vaccination programs for our employees in -countries where this was possible. This helped us achieve a vaccination rate of more than 90% at -our headquarters in Herzogenaurach by mid-July. At the end of the year, we followed up with -booster vaccinations. I would once again like to thank our People & Organization teams (formerly -known as Human Resources) around the world for successfully managing a second year of -COVID-19 and supporting our employees in the best way possible. - -Until around the first quarter 2021, the COVID-19 pandemic mainly impacted the store operations -of our own retail organization and of our retail partners due to mandatory store closures and -other restrictions. This was followed by significant disruptions in our supply chain due to -lockdowns and factory closures in key sourcing countries such as Bangladesh, Cambodia, China -and Vietnam. Especially, the lockdown in the third quarter in 2021 in the south of Vietnam, one of -our most important sourcing destinations, had a very negative impact on our supply chain. Due to -strict local lockdown measures, the production at our footwear, apparel and accessories -suppliers in the south of Vietnam was suspended for about ten weeks, affecting approximately -15% of our global sourcing volumes. We tried to minimize delays as much as possible and shifted -part of the volumes to other sourcing locations where possible. Thanks to the quick rollout of the -vaccination program in the south of Vietnam, the factories gradually reopened during October -and ramped up to full production by the end of year. After our suppliers resumed normal -operations, we saw fewer and very localized factory closures in some parts of Asia, which did not -significantly impact our product supply. We’re very thankful to our suppliers for being a part of -the PUMA family. The strong collaboration, long-term partnership and all their incredible support -ensured the continued supply of products under very difficult circumstances. - -The COVID-19 pandemic also had a major impact on other parts of our supply chain, and we had -to deal with capacity constraints, container shortages and harbor congestion in ocean freight, but -also significant challenges in air freight and land-based transportation. All these constraints led -to a strong increase in freight costs, which further fueled inflationary pressures, in addition to -rising costs for energy, raw materials and labor. - -As manifested in our strong sales growth, we also continued to drive the business in 2021. After -the end of the COVID-19 related lockdowns, we witnessed a certain “normalization” of buying -patterns, with more consumers shopping offline again instead of online. In our Direct-to- -Consumer business, we therefore saw a higher growth rate in our brick & mortar stores -compared to our eCommerce sites. However, both channels grew by double-digits last year, and -we continued to invest in the optimization of our store portfolio, the consumer experience on our -existing sites as well as the launch of new eCommerce sites. During a time of limited supply, we - -6 + Contents - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -continued to prioritize our retail partners in terms of product allocation. We strongly believe in a -multi-brand retail environment and will therefore strengthen the relationship with all our retail -partners around the world and do everything we can to service them in the best way possible. - -After a year without any major sporting events in 2020, we were also excited to see sports -leagues, tournaments and other competitions resume in the course of 2021, for the most part -including live spectators. - -The summer of 2021 was exceptional for our teams and athletes, who delivered world class -performances on track and on the pitch. We underlined our credibility and high ambitions in -football with the victory of the PUMA-sponsored national team Italy at UEFA Euro 2020, several -league and cup titles of our PUMA-sponsored club teams and great on-pitch visibility of our -products. At the Tokyo Olympics and Paralympics, our athletes won more than 70 medals, -demonstrating the performance credentials of our products on the world stage, including our -new NITRO running shoes that I personally am exceptionally proud of. We also continued our -successful re-entry into basketball, especially for the North American market and launched our -first signature shoe with LaMelo Ball at the end of the year. The strengthening of our -performance credibility has always been important to us and I’m very happy about the great -progress that we’ve seen across football, running, fitness, golf, motorsport, basketball and other -locally relevant sports. In Sportstyle, we also continued to build brand heat through exciting new -products and collaborations and by offering a comprehensive collection across all relevant price -points, including a strong focus on comfort. We are very happy to see that our classics business -is growing strongly. Our PUMA Archive is full of footwear and apparel from the 70s, 80s and 90s, -for which there is currently a lot of demand in youth culture. We’re also very satisfied to see the -continued momentum in our women’s business, following the launch of our “She Moves Us” -brand platform, and we will keep capitalizing on our truly inclusive product offering across -genders, age groups etc.! - -We also continued to focus on what we call “Doing the right thing”. We want to be a good -corporate citizen and embed our social responsibility and our environmental sustainability into all -our business practices. With regards to social responsibility, we continued with multiple -initiatives under our #REFORM platform to promote universal equality. We strongly believe that -people should be treated equally irrespective of their gender, age, skin color, religious believes, -sexual orientation or any other factor. Together with our brand ambassadors and partner -organizations, we want to do our part to promote universal equality and fight any form of -discrimination in sports and society as a whole. As part of our ambitious 10FOR25 sustainability -targets, we implemented more sustainable business practices in all our business operations -from sourcing to retail and further increased the usage of more sustainable materials and the -overall share of more sustainable products in our collections. We also increased our focus on -circularity, with several pilot projects and strengthened our consumer-facing sustainability -communication through our FOREVER BETTER brand platform. I, together with my team, -attended the COP26 climate conference in Glasgow to emphasize our commitment in the fight -against climate change and to work towards limiting the global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees -Celsius above pre-industrial levels. We have all these initiatives because we really believe in -them, as part of PUMA’s core values, and we will continue to do the right thing. - -Given our strong performance in 2021 and good momentum in the first months of 2022, we’re -also optimistic for the future of our industry in general and for PUMA in particular, despite the -external challenges. The underlying dynamics in our sector remain very strong given the -increasing participation in sports, the ongoing sneaker trend and the continued casualization -among consumers all around the world. We also see PUMA’s brand momentum continuing and -we will ensure operational flexibility in an increasingly volatile and unpredictable marketplace. -As we have already done during the past years, we will continue to work very closely with all our -retail partners to further increase our shelf space and support the sell-through of our products in -their stores. We have focused on building strong partnerships with all our key stakeholders such -as suppliers, retailers, ambassadors and athletes, helping them as well as us through the -ongoing challenges. We will continue to foster these partnerships in the future. We therefore +About the authors +Contents +Introduction +Market Drivers +Business Value +Mobile Edge Computing Service Scenarios -7 +General - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Augmented Reality -expect 2022 to be another record year for PUMA, with a net sales growth of at least 10%, with -upside potential, and an EBIT of EUR 600 – 700 million. The objective is not to maximize short- -term EBIT, but to continue to have healthy long-term growth in both sales and EBIT. We will also -keep on putting our people first and take care of all our partners. +Intelligent Video Acceleration -Let’s stay positive and hope that peace in Ukraine will be restored as soon as possible and that -the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic will continue to decrease. +Connected Cars -Thank you for being part of the PUMA family! +Internet of Things Gateway +Deployment Scenarios +ETSI Industry Specification Group on Mobile Edge Computing +Proofs of Concept +Conclusions +References -Stay strong, healthy and optimistic! +2 +3 +4 +5 +6 +7 -Bjørn Gulden -Chief Executive Officer PUMA +7 8 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -REPORT BY THE SUPERVISORY BOARD - -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -CHAIRMAN OF THE -CHAIRMAN OF THE -SUPERVISORY BOARD -SUPERVISORY BOARD - -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, - -The 2021 financial year was again heavily impacted by the COVID 19 pandemic. Despite the associated -uncertainties, supply chain bottlenecks due to container shortages, port congestion and pandemic-related -factory closures in key sourcing regions, as well as political tensions in key markets, we managed to start -2021 with high growth momentum. Due to the continued decisive and consistent actions of our Management -Board and the outstanding performance of our employees, we were able to maintain our market -momentum and operational flexibility throughout the year. As a result, we were able to raise our outlook for -2021 during the year and end the year with the highest sales and profit in PUMA's history. At the same time, -it was of utmost importance for us to protect the safety and health of our employees in the best possible -way through the resolute development and implementation of hygiene and occupational safety concepts -and the implementation of vaccination campaigns. We were once again a flexible and reliable business -partner for our suppliers and customers. We worked as closely as possible with them to stabilize our -supply chains and increase sales of our products. By appointing Hubert Hinterseher and Arne Freundt to -the Management Board, we were able to further strengthen our organization and thus lay the foundations -for a successful 2022. - -In the financial year 2021, the Supervisory Board has exercised all its duties under the law, statutes and -company rules. The Supervisory Board has dealt extensively with the status and the development of PUMA, -particularly continuing with a special focus on the COVID-19 pandemic, and has regularly advised and -supervised the Management Board in its management of the Company. - -In this regard, the Supervisory Board has in its four regular meetings discussed and resolved on the -Company’s business policies, all relevant aspects of corporate development and corporate planning, the -Company’s economic situation, including its net assets, financial position and results of operations, the -adequacy of capital resources and all key decisions for the Group. The Management Board has informed the - 9 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +9 -Supervisory Board regularly, comprehensively, and in a timely manner in written and verbal form about the -implementation of all decisions and about all major business transactions. Furthermore, in 2021 one -extraordinary meeting of the Supervisory Board took place. Urgent matters were decided via circular -resolutions using electronic means of communication. All members participated in drawing up the -resolutions. Whenever necessary, representatives of the shareholders and employees held separate -preliminary discussions prior to the meetings. +11 +11 +12 +13 +14 +15 + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G + +3 + + Introduction + +Mobile Edge Computing (MEC) is a new technology which is currently being standardized in an ETSI +Industry Specification Group (ISG) of the same name. Mobile Edge Computing provides an IT service +environment and cloud-computing capabilities at the edge of the mobile network, within the Radio +Access Network (RAN) and in close proximity to mobile subscribers. The aim is to reduce latency, ensure +highly efficient network operation and service delivery, and offer an improved user experience. + +Mobile Edge Computing is a natural development in the evolution of mobile base stations and the +convergence of IT and telecommunications networking. Based on a virtualized platform, MEC is +recognized by the European 5G PPP (5G Infrastructure Public Private Partnership) research body as one +of the key emerging technologies for 5G networks (together with Network Functions Virtualization (NFV) +and Software-Defined Networking (SDN)) [1]. In addition to defining more advanced air interface +technologies, 5G networks will leverage more programmable approaches to software networking and +use IT virtualization technology extensively within the telecommunications infrastructure, functions, and +applications. MEC thus represents a key technology and architectural concept to enable the evolution to +5G, since it helps advance the transformation of the mobile broadband network into a programmable +world and contributes to satisfying the demanding requirements of 5G in terms of expected throughout, +latency, scalability and automation. + +MEC is based on a virtualized platform, with an approach complementary to NFV: in fact, while NVF is +focused on network functions, the MEC framework enables applications running at the edge of the +network. The infrastructure that hosts MEC and NFV or network functions is quite similar; thus, in order +to allow operators to benefit as much as possible from their investment, it will be beneficial to reuse the +infrastructure and infrastructure management of NFV to the largest extent possible, by hosting both +VNFs (Virtual Network Functions) and MEC applications on the same platform. + +The environment of Mobile Edge Computing is characterized by low latency, proximity, high bandwidth, +and real-time insight into radio network information and location awareness. All of this can be +translated into value and can create opportunities for mobile operators, application and content +providers enabling them to play complementary and profitable roles within their respective business +models and allowing them to better monetize the mobile broadband experience. + +Mobile Edge Computing opens up services to consumers and enterprise customers as well as to adjacent +industries that can now deliver their mission-critical applications over the mobile network. It enables a +new value chain, fresh business opportunities and a myriad of new use cases across multiple sectors. +The intention is to develop favourable market conditions which will create sustainable business for all +players in the value chain, and to facilitate global market growth. To this end, a standardized, open +environment needs to be created to allow the efficient and seamless integration of such applications +across multi-vendor Mobile Edge Computing platforms. This will also ensure that the vast majority of the +customers of a mobile operator can be served. + +The objectives of this white paper are to introduce the concept of Mobile Edge Computing and the +related key market drivers, and to discuss the business and technical benefits of Mobile Edge +Computing. A few examples of service scenarios that can benefit from the technology and possible +deployment scenarios are presented. The white paper explains what is being standardized and how + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -Plenary Supervisory Board +4 -Jean-François Palus + innovation can be stimulated through using a standardized API. It outlines the specifications being +produced by the Industry Specification Group on MEC. -Thore Ohlsson +ETSI ISG MEC encourages Proofs of Concept (PoC) to demonstrate the viability of MEC implementations. +PoCs help to build awareness and confidence in the technology, and to develop a diverse and open MEC +ecosystem. This white paper describes the MEC PoC framework and calls for active participation. -Héloïse Temple-Boyer +Market Drivers -Fiona May +The growth of mobile traffic and pressure on costs are driving a need to implement several changes in +order to maintain quality of experience, to generate revenue, and optimize network operations and +resource utilization. The Internet of Things is further congesting the network and network operators +need to do local analysis to ease security and backhaul impacts. Enterprises want the ability to enable +and engage with their customers with more efficient, secure and low latency connections. Application +and content providers are challenged with the latency of the network when connecting to the cloud. +These challenges need to be resolved. -Martin Köppel +Mobile operators need to shorten the time to launch new revenue generating applications for current +customers but also for specific industries and sectors, such as but not limited to automotive, industry +automation and welfare industries. Business transformation based on collaboration with the different +players in the value chain can help in facing these challenges. -Bernd Illig +Technology improvements which provide low latency, better flexibility, agility, usage of virtualization, +network and context awareness, etc. can provide the opportunity to increase the Quality of Experience +of end users and make network operation more cost effective and competitive. -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +Smart phone applications and content are moving to the cloud. The access to the cloud needs to be +optimised to guarantee a rich experience for consumers of an application or consumers of content and a +tight collaboration is essential between network operators and application and content providers. This +collaboration can lead to the deployment of applications/content at the edge of the mobile operator’s +network, providing awareness of the network and context information. Standardization will be essential +to support this collaboration and the hosting of cloud or internet based applications within a multi- +vendor environment. -Attendance in % +The market drivers of MEC include business transformation, technology integration and industry +collaboration (as illustrated in Figure 1). All of these can be enabled by MEC and a wide variety of use +cases can be supported for new and innovative markets, such as e-Health, connected vehicles, industry +automation, augmented reality, gaming and IoT services. -5/5 +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -5/5 +5 -5/5 + Figure 1: MEC market drivers -5/5 +Business Value -5/5 +Mobile Edge Computing offers an IT service environment at a location considered to be a lucrative point +in the mobile network: the Radio Access Network (RAN) edge. Characterized by proximity, low latency +and high bandwidth, this environment will offer localized cloud computing capabilities as well as +exposure to real-time radio network and context information. -5/5 +Opening up this IT service environment will allow applications and services from mobile operators, +service and content providers to be efficiently and seamlessly integrated across multi-vendor, mobile +edge computing platforms. The characteristics and capabilities offered by a MEC platform can be +leveraged in a way that will allow proximity, context, agility and speed to be used for wider innovation +that can be translated into unique value and revenue generation. -100 +Access to content and applications can be accelerated; their responsiveness can be increased, +maximizing speed and interactivity. Popular and locally-relevant content can be delivered directly where +users connect, limiting ingress bandwidth to the core and cloud. -100 +Knowledge of real-time radio network conditions and context information can be used to optimize the +network and service operation (responding and adapting to changing network conditions). This would +improve service experience and the utilization of network resources, enabling them to efficiently handle +increased amounts of traffic. Real-time network and fine-granular context information (including -100 +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -100 +6 -100 + location) could be used to enrich the mobile broadband experience by creating highly personalized +services which are tailored to individual needs and preferences. -100 +Operators can reposition themselves in the value chain and redefine personalized services. They can +capitalize their networks and open them up to authorized third-parties (in a secure way), exposing +capabilities to Over the Top (OTT) players and application developers to flexibly, agilely and rapidly +deploy innovative applications and services towards mobile subscribers, enterprises and vertical +segments. Operators will be able to create new revenue streams, delight their customers by developing +a new breed of applications that provide incremental value, and open up new market opportunities. In +addition, applications supporting tighter integration of network and service parameters will improve +both service experience and utilization of the network resources. -The Supervisory Board discussed in detail all of the Company’s key business transactions, based on the -reports by the Management Board and the Committees, and presented its own ideas. The Management -Board has provided the Supervisory Board with detailed information on any deviations of the business -performance from the budgeted figures, both in writing and orally. The Supervisory Board verified these -explanations using the supporting documents, which were always submitted in appropriate time before the -meetings. The Supervisory Board was involved in all key decisions at an early stage. In addition, the Chair of -the Supervisory Board maintained, and continues to maintain, regular verbal or written contact with the -CEO and keeps himself informed of all major developments. Overall, these discussions did not give any -indication that the Management Board was managing the Group in anything other than a lawful and proper -manner. +Application service providers, OTT players and independent software vendors will be able to translate +proximity and context into value, and be able to generate new revenue. Their applications and services +can be enhanced and accelerated to provide a unique and unparalleled experience. Innovative +applications can be deployed rapidly in a new standards-based environment, taking advantage of new +levels of flexibility and agility. Applications will be able to expand their cloud into the mobile network +and create a whole new set of services. They will be able to feel and react to end-user experience in real +time, based on the actual radio conditions. The new MEC specifications will allow applications and +services to be deployed on top of multi-vendor Mobile Edge Computing platforms, enabling them to be +used by the vast majority of the customers of a single mobile operator. The mobile end user will enjoy a +unique, gratifying and personalized mobile-broadband experience. -The Supervisory Board members took part, on their own initiative, in the educational and training measures -necessary for the performance of their duties. The Company supports the Supervisory Board members in -their training activities, for example by having the Legal Department regularly review changes in the legal -framework for the Supervisory Board and report about them in the meetings. In 2021, the Supervisory -Board received a training on the sustainability strategy of the Company and the challenges in the supply -chain. The Supervisory Board dealt with the Act on Corporate Due Diligence in Supply Chains (Supply Chain -Due Diligence Act) and the EU Regulation on the Establishment of a Framework to Facilitate Sustainable -Investment (EU Taxonomy Regulation). +The MEC initiative will help to develop favourable market conditions for all players in the value chain as +well as facilitate economic growth with a myriad of new use cases across multiple sectors (see Figure 2). -MAIN ADVISORY FOCUS +Figure 2: Improved QoE with Mobile Edge Computing in close proximity to end users -In the 2021 financial year, the main focus was on the following issues: review and approval of the 2020 -consolidated and annual financial statements and the non-financial report, dividend proposal, resolution of -the new remuneration system for the Management Board and submission to the 2021 Annual General -Meeting for approval, ongoing assessment of the impact and handling of the COVID 19 pandemic, setting the -agenda for the Annual General Meeting on 5 May 2021, approval of the Management Board’s decisions to -hold the Annual General Meeting as a virtual Annual General Meeting without the physical presence of -shareholders or their proxies, appointment of Hubert Hinterseher to the Management Board to succeed -Michael Lämmermann and appointment of Arne Freundt to the Management Board, establishment of a -Sustainability Committee, setting of new targets for the proportion of women to be achieved on the -Supervisory Board and Management Board, self-assessment of the Supervisory Board, current business -and revenue development, markets and trends, financial position of the Group, corporate and budget -planning 2022 as well as medium-term planning, including investments, further improvement of the -compliance management and internal control system as well as material litigation in the Group. +Mobile Edge Computing Service Scenarios -10 +General +The following sections describe a number of service scenarios that have been considered within ETSI ISG +MEC. These illustrate various scenarios which can take advantage of Mobile Edge Computing to either - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -The Audit Committee submitted a recommendation to the Supervisory Board for the election of the auditor, -which was prepared following a selection process within the meaning of Art. 16 (3) Regulation (EU) No. -537/2014, comprised two candidates and was substantiated. +7 -As every year, the Personnel Committee and the Supervisory Board determined the degree of achievement -of the targets for the individual Management Board members with regard to 2020. The Supervisory Board -decided on the targets for the variable Management Board remuneration for the 2021 financial year upon -recommendation of the Personnel Committee. + increase performance compared to providing such services through the cloud or through core network +servers, or to utilize the unique capabilities offered by MEC platforms such as proximity to the user and +network edge, serving a highly localized area. It should be noted these examples are non-exhaustive and +further service scenarios are available in the ETSI ISG MEC specification for Mobile Edge Computing +Service Scenarios, GS MEC 004. Other scenarios which can make use of MEC are also possible. + +Augmented Reality +New services become possible when mobile networks supporting high data rates and low latency +computation are deployed. One example of such services is Augmented Reality. Augmented reality (AR) +is the combination of a view of the real-world environment and supplementary computer-generated +sensory input such as sound, video, graphics or GPS data. Augmented reality can enhance the +experience of a visitor to a museum or another point of interest. Consider a visitor to a museum, art +gallery, city monument, music or sports event, holding their mobile device towards a particular point of +interest with the application related to their visit activated (i.e., the museum application). The camera +captures the point of interest and the application displays additional information related to what the +visitor is viewing. + +Augmented reality services require an application to analyse the output from a device's camera and/or a +precise location in order to supplement a user's experience when visiting a point of interest by providing +additional information to the user about what they are currently experiencing. The application needs to +be aware of a user's position and the direction they are facing, either through positioning techniques or +through the camera view, or both. After analysing such information, the application can provide +additional information in real-time to the user. If the user moves, the information needs to be +refreshed. Hosting the Augmented Reality service on a MEC platform instead of in the cloud is +advantageous since supplementary information pertaining to a point of interest is highly localised and is +often irrelevant beyond the particular point of interest. Figure 3 shows how a MEC platform can be used +to provide an Augmented Reality service. + +Figure 3: Augmented Reality Service Scenario + +Additionally, the processing of user location or camera view can be performed on a MEC platform rather +than on a more centralized server. There may be a need to update information at a fast rate, depending +on how the user moves, and the context in which the augmented reality service is used (e.g. in an art +gallery, exhibits are positioned only a few metres apart and each piece is supplemented with additional +text on the artist, the interpretation of the artwork, etc.) In other words, augmented reality data +requires low latency and a high rate of data processing in order to provide the correct information to + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -CONFLICTS OF INTEREST +8 -The members of the Supervisory Board are required to disclose to its Chair any conflicts of interest without -undue delay. In the past year, no such disclosures were made. + the user's device depending on the location and orientation of the user. Performing such data +processing on the MEC platform also has the advantage of collecting metrics, anonymized meta-data, +etc., in order to analyse the service usage and help to improve the service in order to provide a better +user experience. + +Intelligent Video Acceleration +End user Quality of Experience (QoE) and utilization of radio network resources can be improved +through intelligent video acceleration. Internet media and file delivery are typically streamed or +downloaded today using Hypertext Transmission Protocol (HTTP) over the TCP protocol. Available +capacity can vary by an order of magnitude within seconds (as a result of changes in radio channel +conditions, devices entering/leaving network). TCP may not be able to adapt fast enough to rapidly- +varying conditions in the radio access network (RAN). This may lead to under-utilisation of precious +radio resources and to a sub-optimal user experience. + +Figure 4 shows an example of the intelligent video acceleration service scenario which attempts to +overcome the challenges described above. In this scenario, a radio analytics application, which resides in +a MEC server, provides the video server with an indication on the throughput estimated to be available +at the radio downlink interface. This information can be used to assist the TCP congestion control +decisions (for example in selecting the initial window size, setting the value of the congestion window +during the congestion avoidance phase, and adjusting the size of the congestion window when the +conditions on the "radio link" deteriorate). The information can also be used to ensure that the +application-level coding matches the estimated capacity at the radio downlink. + +The video server may use this information to assist TCP congestion control decisions (for example by +ensuring that the application level coding matches the estimated capacity at the radio downlink). The +content’s time-to-start as well as video-stall occurrences can be reduced, enabling improved video +quality and throughput. + + Figure 4: Intelligent Video Acceleration Service Scenario + +Connected Cars +The number of connected vehicles is rapidly growing and will continue to do so over the coming years. +Communication of vehicles and roadside sensors with a roadside unit is intended to increase the safety, +efficiency, and convenience of the transportation system, by the exchange of critical safety and + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -COMMITTEES +9 -The Supervisory Board has established four committees to perform its duties: The Personnel Committee, -the Audit Committee, the Nominating Committee and the Sustainability Committee which was established -in April 2021. The Personnel Committee, the Audit Committee and the Sustainability Committee each -comprise two shareholder representatives and one employee representative. The Nominating Committee is -composed only of shareholder representatives. The composition of the committees can be found in the -notes to the consolidated financial statements. The Supervisory Board receives regular reports on their -work. + operational data. The communication can also be used to provide value added services, such as car +finder, parking location and to support entertainment services (e.g. video distribution). -PERSONNEL COMMITTEE +As the number of connected vehicles increases and use cases evolve, the volume of data will continue to +increase along with the need to minimize latency. Whilst data stored and processed centrally may be +adequate for some use cases, it can be unreliable and slow for others. -The Personnel Committee has the task of preparing the conclusion and amendment of employment -contracts with the members of the Management Board and establishing policies for human resources and -personnel development. It met to one regular meeting and to one extraordinary meeting in 2021 and mainly -dealt with the compensation system for the Management Board, which has been approved by the Annual -General Meeting in 2021. Furthermore, the determination of target achievement for the individual -Management Board members and the setting of targets for 2021 were the focus of the discussions. -Corresponding recommendations for resolutions were made to the Supervisory Board. +LTE can significantly accelerate the deployment of connected vehicle communications. LTE cells can +provide “beyond the line of sight” visibility i.e. beyond the range of direct communication between +vehicles of 300 – 500m. It can also satisfy the tight latency requirement of connected vehicle +communications, below 100ms in some use cases. Messages could be distributed in real time over LTE, +eliminating the need to build a countrywide Digital Short-Range Communications (DSRC) network. Cars +can leverage their increasingly inbuilt LTE connectivity; in deployments where DSRC exists, LTE would be +able complement it. -Personnel Committee +Mobile Edge Computing can be used to extend the connected car cloud into the highly distributed +mobile base station environment, and enable data and applications to be housed close to the vehicles. +This can reduce the round trip time of data and enable a layer of abstraction from both the core +network and applications provided over the internet. MEC applications can run on MEC servers which +are deployed at the LTE base station site to provide the roadside functionality. The MEC applications can +receive local messages directly from the applications in the vehicles and the roadside sensors, analyse +them and then propagate (with extremely low latency) hazard warnings and other latency-sensitive +messages to other cars in the area (as depicted in Figure 5). This enables a nearby car to receive data in +a matter of milliseconds, allowing the driver to immediately react. -Attendance at meetings +Figure 5: Connected Vehicles Service Scenario -Attendance in % +The roadside MEC application will be able to inform adjacent Mobile Edge Computing servers about the +event(s) and in so doing, enable these servers to propagate hazard warnings to cars that are close to the +affected area. -Jean-François Palus +The roadside application will be able to send local information to the applications at the connected car +cloud for further centralized processing and reporting. -Fiona May +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G -Martin Köppel +10 -AUDIT COMMITTEE + Internet of Things Gateway +The Internet of Things (IoT) generates additional messaging on telecoms networks, and requires +gateways to aggregate the messages and ensure low latency and security. Because of the nature of +some of the devices being connected, a real time capability is required and a grouping of sensors and +devices is needed for efficient service. -2/2 +IoT devices are often resource constrained in terms of processor and memory capacity. There is a need +to aggregate various IoT device messages connected through the mobile network close to the devices. +This also provides an analytics processing capability and a low latency response time. -2/2 +Figure 6: IoT Gateway Service Scenario -2/2 +Various devices are connected over different forms of connectivity, such as 3G, LTE, Wi-Fi or other radio +technologies. In general the messages are small, encrypted and come in different forms of protocols. +There is a need for a low latency aggregation point to manage the various protocols, distribution of +messages and for the processing of analytics. The MEC server provides the capability to resolve these +challenges. -100 +Mobile Edge Computing can be used to connect and control devices remotely, analyse and provide real +time provisioning and analytics. MEC enables the aggregation and distribution of IoT services into the +highly distributed mobile base station environment, and enable applications to respond in real-time. +This can reduce the round trip time of data and enable a layer of abstraction from both the core +network and applications in the cloud. IoT applications can run on MEC servers which are deployed at +the LTE base station site to provide this functionality. -100 +Deployment Scenarios -100 +Mobile Edge Computing servers can be deployed at multiple locations, such as at the LTE macro base +station (eNodeB) site, at the 3G Radio Network Controller (RNC) site, at a multi-Radio Access Technology +(RAT) cell aggregation site, and at an aggregation point (which may also be at the edge of the core +network). The multi-RAT cell aggregation site can be located indoors within an enterprise (e.g. hospital, +large corporate HQ), or indoors/outdoors for a special public coverage scenario (e.g. stadium, shopping +mall) to control a number of local multi-RAT access points providing radio coverage to the premises. This +deployment option enables the direct delivery of locally-relevant, fast services from base station +clusters. Where a MEC platform is deployed may depend on a number of factors, including scalability, -The Audit Committee held four regular meetings in the financial year 2021. Furthermore, one extraordinary -meeting of the Audit Committee took place in 2021. In particular, the Audit Committee is responsible for the -review of the accounting, particularly comprising the consolidated financial statements and the group -management report, group half year report, interim financial information and the single entity financial -statements in accordance with the German Commercial Code (HGB). It is furthermore responsible for -monitoring the accounting process, the effectiveness of the internal control system, the risk management -system, the internal audit system, compliance and the statutory audit of the financial statements, with -particular regard to the process of selecting an auditor. The Audit Committee is also responsible for -conducting the selection process of the auditor. In addition, the Audit Committee monitors the -independence of the auditor and ensures that the non-audit services of the auditor commissioned by the -Management Board do not give rise to any grounds for disqualification or partiality or any threat to -independence. The Audit Committee issues the audit mandate on behalf of the Supervisory Board to the +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G 11 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -auditor elected by the general meeting, determines the audit areas of the audit and agrees the fee with the -auditor. Heads of the corporate functions were also available for reports and questions on individual agenda -items at the committee meetings. The Audit Committee meets regularly with the auditor, also without the -Management Board. - -Audit Committee - -Thore Ohlsson - -Héloïse Temple-Boyer - -Bernd Illig + physical deployment constraints, performance criteria (e.g. latency) and which network information will +be exposed. Note that some MEC services may not be available / applicable in certain deployment +options. -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +MEC applications can be intelligently and flexibly deployed in a seamless manner on different MEC +platforms based on technical and business parameters. The deployment of MEC applications on a +particular MEC platform may depend on the availability of specific MEC services and on other +parameters, such as latency requirements, required resources, availability of a particular VNF, scalability +considerations, cost etc. -Attendance in % +MEC will utilise the NFV infrastructure. The NFV platform may be dedicated to MEC or shared with other +network functions or applications. MEC will also use (as much as possible) the NFV management and +orchestration entities and interfaces. -5/5 +ETSI Industry Specification Group on Mobile Edge +Computing -5/5 +The ETSI Industry Specification Group (ISG) on Mobile Edge Computing (MEC) produces normative +Group Specifications that will enable the hosting of third-party applications in a multi-vendor MEC +environment. Launched in December 2014, the group plans to deliver the first set of specifications +within 2 years. -5/5 +The initial scope of the ISG MEC focuses on use cases; it specifies the requirements and the reference +architecture, including the components and functional elements that are the key enablers for MEC +solutions. -100 +When the first documents reach the required maturity level, work on platform services, APIs and +interfaces will commence. The MEC platform API will be application-agnostic and will allow the smooth +porting of value-creating applications on every mobile-edge server with guaranteed SLA (see Figure 7). -100 + Figure 7: MEC platform API -100 +In addition to the technical work, an industry-enabling working group (IEG WG) has been setup under +the ISG MEC which is tasked with advancing Mobile Edge Computing in the industry and accelerating the -NOMINATING COMMITTEE - -The Nominating Committee has the task of proposing suitable candidates to the Supervisory Board for its -election proposals to the Annual General Meeting. It held no meeting in the last financial year. - -SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE - -The Sustainability Committee was established in April 2021 and met once in the 2021 financial year to -discuss the company's sustainability strategies. The Sustainability Committee consists of three members. - -CORPORATE GOVERNANCE - -As in previous years, the Supervisory Board addressed current developments in the financial year 2021 -regarding the German Corporate Governance Code in the version dated December 16, 2019 (effective as of -March 20, 2020) (GCGC). The GCGC contains essential statutory regulations and recommendations for the -management and supervision of listed companies and standards for responsible corporate governance. The -corporate governance standards have long been a part of the corporate routine. - -Pursuant to Principle 22 of the GCGC, the Supervisory Board reports on corporate governance in the -Corporate Governance Statement. The Company satisfies all requirements of the GCGC, to the extent -required by it. The Statement of Compliance of November 9, 2021 is available to our shareholders at any -time on the Company’s website under https://about.PUMA.com/en/investor-relations/corporate- -governance at STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE. - -ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ADOPTED - -The annual financial statements for PUMA SE prepared by the Management Board in accordance with the -German Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch/HGB), the consolidated financial statements and the -combined management report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, each for the financial year 2021, -prepared in accordance with Section 315a HGB on the basis of the International Financial Reporting -Standards (IFRS) have been audited by the statutory auditors, Deloitte GmbH -Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, Munich, who were appointed at the Annual General Meeting on May 5, -2021 and commissioned by the Supervisory Board to audit the annual financial statements and the -consolidated financial statements and have been given an unqualified auditor’s opinion. - -In their report, the statutory auditors conclude that PUMA’s institutionalized risk management system, in -accordance with Section 91(2) of the German Stock Corporation Act (Aktiengesetz/AktG), is capable of -detecting at an early stage and countering any developments that might jeopardize the continuity of the -Company as a going concern. The Supervisory Board has been updated by the Management Board regularly +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G 12 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders + adoption of the concept and the standards. This will help to develop favourable market conditions for +sustainable business for all players in the value chain. -on all relevant risks in this regard, in particular its assessments of market and procurement risks, financial -risks (including currency risks as well as risks due to the COVID-19 pandemic) and organizational risks. +The IEG group is developing two Group Specifications: -The accounting records, the audit reports from the statutory auditors and the Management Board’s and -Supervisory Board’s recommendation on the appropriation of net profit were made available to all -members of the Supervisory Board in a timely manner. At the meeting of the Audit Committee on February -22, 2022 and at the subsequent Supervisory Board meeting held on the same day, the statutory auditors -reported on the key results of their audit and discussed them in detail with the Management Board and the -members of the Supervisory Board. No discrepancies were detected. +1. ETSI GS MEC-IEG 005 [2] Proof of Concept Framework, specifying the process and criteria that a +Proof of Concept demonstration must adhere to. This specification has already been published; -The Supervisory Board reviewed in detail the annual financial statements, the combined management -report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, the Management Board’s and the Supervisory Board’s -recommendation on the appropriation of net profit and the consolidated financial statements and raised no -objections. In accordance with the recommendation of the Audit Committee, the Supervisory Board agreed -with the results of the audit of both statements and approved the annual financial statements of PUMA SE -and the consolidated financial statements for the financial year 2021. The 2021 annual financial statements -have thus been adopted. +2. ETSI GS MEC-IEG 004 Service Scenarios, which presents a number of examples of service -The Management Board and the Supervisory Board resolved to propose to the Annual General Meeting a -distribution of a dividend of € 0.72 per dividend entitled share to the shareholders for the financial year -2021. In this context, the liquidity situation of the Company, the financing and the effects on the capital -market were discussed. The payout is conditional to an overall sound macroeconomic environment. A total -amount of around € 107.7 million will be paid out in dividends from PUMA SE’s retained earnings. The -remaining retained earnings of around € 382.4 million will be carried forward. +scenarios, business and consumer benefits which can be enabled by Mobile Edge Computing. -In its meeting on February 22, 2022, the Supervisory Board was presented the state of data collection for -the non-financial report in accordance with §§ 315c in conjunction with §§ 289c to 289e of the German -Commercial Code (HGB). As soon as the non-financial report is finalized, it will be submitted to the -Supervisory Board for approval and will be published on the website of the Company by April 30, 2022. +The ETSI ISG is open to members and non-members of ETSI to participate and contribute towards this +innovative technology. Industry players are invited to actively participate and contribute to the work on +Mobile Edge Computing and to take part in the PoC activities. More information on how to participate is +available at: http://www.etsi.org/mobile-edge-computing/get-involved-in-mec. -THANKS +Proofs of Concept -We would like to express our gratitude and recognition to the Management Board, the management teams -at the Group companies, the Works Council and all our employees for their hard work and their outstanding -cooperation in 2021. +In order to ensure the success and widespread deployment of Mobile Edge Computing, it is necessary to +have more than just timely and high quality specifications. It is crucial to validate the specifications that +are being developed, and to demonstrate that the use cases have been fulfilled. Furthermore, the MEC +concept must be demonstrated to be feasible and valuable to all the major stakeholders in the value +chain in order to appeal to the widest possible audience. -Herzogenaurach, February 22, 2022 +To showcase the Mobile Edge Computing concept, the ISG MEC has developed a Proof of Concept +process, specified in GS MEC-IEG 005 [2]. A PoC proposal can be submitted by a PoC team consisting of +at least one Mobile Network Operator, at least one infrastructure vendor and at least one content or +application provider. GS MEC-IEG 005 [2] specifies the process and criteria that a Proof of Concept +demonstration must adhere to in order to be accepted as a MEC PoC. A wiki site http://mecwiki.etsi.org +has been put in place to assist PoC teams. This site hosts the PoC project proposal templates and the list +of PoC Topics, which are specific areas where input or feedback from PoCs is needed. One or several PoC +Topics can be addressed by a single PoC project. -On behalf of the Supervisory Board +The public demonstration of MEC Proofs of Concept helps to build commercial awareness and +confidence in this technology, and helps to develop a diverse, open, MEC ecosystem. -Jean-François Palus -Chairman +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G 13 + Conclusions + +Mobile Edge Computing enables innovative service scenarios that can ensure enhanced personal +experience and optimized network operation, as well as opening up new business opportunities. A few +examples are described in this white paper to demonstrate how proximity to users and objects, together +with network and context information can be leveraged by applications to create value. Mobile Edge +Computing attracts a new value-chain and energized eco-system, where all players can benefit from +tighter collaboration. Mobile operators can play a pivotal role within the new value chain and attract +OTT service providers, developers and Internet players to innovate over a new cutting-edge technology, +while enabling context-aware applications to run in close proximity to the mobile subscriber. Mobile +subscribers can enjoy a unique, truly gratifying and personalized mobile-broadband experience which is +tailored to their needs and preferences. + +Based on a virtualized platform, MEC complements NFV and is fully aligned with the emerging +distributed cloud approach. It is recognised as a key technology of the future 5G era, satisfying the +demanding requirements for ultra-low latency and stimulating innovation. + +The MEC technology is defined by the ETSI ISG MEC, which was launched in December 2014 with the +intention to develop the first set of specifications within 2 years. The deliverables will include service +scenarios, requirements, architecture and API specifications, complemented with a PoC Framework +specification and White Papers which aim to accelerate the market adoption of the MEC technology. + +MEC supports different deployment options, as MEC Servers can be located at different places within +the Radio Access Network depending on technical and business requirements. + +A MEC Proof-of-Concept (PoC) program has been established to demonstrate the viability of MEC +implementations. The results and lessons learned by the MEC PoCs are fed back to the ISG MEC +specification activities. + +The MEC ISG is developing the foundation to enable an open radio access network which can host third +party innovative applications and content at the edge of the network. The ISG is open to members and +non-members of ETSI to participate and contribute towards this innovative technology, and to take part +in the PoC activities. + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G + +14 + + References + +[1] +5G Vision: The 5G Infrastructure Public Private Partnership: the next generation of +communication networks and services. From The 5G Infrastructure Public Private Partnership: +https://5g-ppp.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/5G-Vision-Brochure-v1.pdf + + [2] + +ETSI GS MEC-IEG 005; Mobile Edge Computing (MEC); Proof of Concept Framework. + +Mobile Edge Computing - a key technology towards 5G + +15 + + ETSI (European Telecommunications Standards Institute) +06921 Sophia Antipolis CEDEX, France +Tel +33 4 92 94 42 00 +info@etsi.org +www.etsi.org + + This White Paper is issued for information only. It does not constitute an official or agreed position of ETSI, nor of its Members. The +views expressed are entirely those of the author(s). +ETSI declines all responsibility for any errors and any loss or damage resulting from use of the contents of this White Paper. +ETSI also declines responsibility for any infringement of any third party's Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), but will be pleased to +acknowledge any IPR and correct any infringement of which it is advised. +Copyright Notification +Copying or reproduction in whole is permitted if the copy is complete and unchanged (including this copyright statement). + © European Telecommunications Standards Institute 2015. All rights reserved. +DECT™, PLUGTESTS™, UMTS™, TIPHON™, IMS™, INTEROPOLIS™, FORAPOLIS™, and the TIPHON and ETSI logos are Trade Marks of ETSI +registered for the benefit of its Members. +3GPP™ and LTE™ are Trade Marks of ETSI registered for the benefit of its Members and of the 3GPP Organizational Partners. +GSM™, the Global System for Mobile communication, is a registered Trade Mark of the GSM Association. + diff --git a/q226/random_k4/random_2.md b/q226/random_k4/random_2.md index d0e4711d45467ad9a4bb5f563733b6d5247d3efa..d8b0f4b36b599f181acd3182fd16c52ced85f073 100644 --- a/q226/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q226/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,806 +1,733 @@ -Music and streaming -market study final report - -Executive summary - -29 November 2022 - - Executive summary - -Introduction - -1. - -2. - -Music streaming has transformed how consumers listen to music. The rise of -music streaming has given consumers easy access to large catalogues of -music covering an array of genres and time periods for a fixed monthly price, -or free with ads. As music streaming services have grown in popularity, -consumer outcomes have improved significantly. Between 2009 and 2021 the -monthly price of individual music streaming subscriptions has fallen by more -than 20% in real terms because the price of these plans has not kept pace -with inflation. At the same time, consumers have gained access to more -music and more innovative and better quality services, for example higher -quality audio, new video content and synced song lyrics. - -Consumers have widely adopted music streaming -– in the UK in 2021 there were 39 million monthly -active users of music streaming services and -there were over 138 billion streams. Streaming is -now the primary means for artists and labels to -distribute music and has been pivotal in securing -the sector’s recovery from piracy. +Israeli and Palestinian Youth Attitudes toward the Conflict and Each Other: + +Cause for Concern, Openings for Hope, Areas for Action + +Lucy Kurtzer-Ellenbogen +John Lyndon +Dr. Dahlia Scheindlin +Dr. Khalil Shikaki + +Key Findings + +In spring-summer 2021, the Alliance for Middle East Peace (ALLMEP) and the United States Institute of +Peace (USIP) commissioned a study of Israeli and Palestinian youth, ages 15-21, to deepen the understanding +of the rising generation’s views of “the other,” and to learn how this generation views the prospects of +resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The research included both qualitative and quantitative research, and +the findings reveal attitudes that should concern and motivate those seeking a just and sustainable resolution +of the conflict. They should also lead to greater prioritization and resourcing of efforts to interrupt and alter +the variables that have formed and informed these mutually reinforcing perspectives. Serious ongoing +deterioration in conditions on the ground, spiraling violence, and severely diminished prospects for peace +seem all but inevitable if these attitudinal trends and their drivers are left to fester. + +Yet, while the data makes a case for urgency, it does not suggest reason for despair. While many of the +findings point to an uphill battle against these trends, other results point toward openings that can be +constructively leveraged with the right policy and civil society interventions. The data affirms how little +contact there is or has ever been between both sides in this age cohort, but simultaneously shows that only a +minority on both sides would fully rule out contact because they deem it illegitimate. It is therefore +incumbent on those who care about this conflict and the future of the parties to seize upon opportunities to +effect attitudinal change. Such an approach can allow for the development of realistic strategies that are +grounded in the realities of the situation today, and account for the attitudes, experiences, values, fears and +concerns reflected in the poll’s findings. + +● + +In both Israeli and Palestinian communities, there has been a trend in recent years of young people +embracing more hardline positions. Among Palestinian youth ages 15-21, the largest single +cohort – over 40 percent of the sample – identify with the ideological designation Islamiyya, +which can (but does not necessarily) correlate with a harder-line positions toward peace and +compromise with Israel. Sixty percent of Jewish Israelis of the same age define themselves as +right-wing – a term in Israel that is closely correlated with harder-line positioning toward +peace and compromise with the Palestinians. + +● Among youth on both sides, support for the two-state solution is in serious decline and does +not enjoy the support of a majority of respondents. Yet this solution is still more popular +than alternative proposals. Among both Jewish citizens of Israel and West Bank Palestinians, +support for two states and for one unequal state (dominated by their respective side) is nearly tied, 1 - 3. - -4. - -5. - -6. - -7. - -Some parts of the market have improved for artists in recent years, with more -choice about the type of deals with record labels available and more able to -directly release their music on streaming services. Average royalty rates in -major deals for new artists have increased steadily from an average of 19.7% -in 2012 to 23.3% in 2021. For songwriters, the share of revenues going to -publishing rights has increased significantly from 8% in 2008 to 15% in 2021. - -Whilst outcomes are good for consumers and generally improving for -creators, we note that to some extent changes in the sector, precipitated by -streaming, have made it harder for some creators. Reduced barriers to entry -and more choice on how to distribute music has meant there are more artists -than ever and, therefore, creators face more artists and songs to compete -with for streaming revenues. Not only that, but the convenience of streaming -means that older music is enjoying a resurgence of popularity, meaning that -today’s artists need to work harder than ever to grab listeners’ attention. - -These factors may be exacerbated by the fact that it is challenging for music -companies to know who among the growing pool of creators will be -successful. This inherent uncertainty combined with consumer tastes that -tend to tip to a relatively small number of artists means that it is challenging -for creators to succeed. We do not think that these factors arise from how -firms compete in the market. - -We have found that it is unlikely that the outcomes that concern many -stakeholders are primarily driven by competition. Consequently, it is unlikely -that a competition intervention would improve outcomes overall, and release -more money in the system to pay creators more. In such circumstances, there -is a greater risk that a competition intervention will result in unintended -consequences and worse outcomes for both consumers and creators. The -costs, risks and uncertainty created by a market investigation (which could run -for two years) would be imposed on the industry and borne, ultimately, by -consumers. We have therefore decided to not undertake a market -investigation. - -While there is limited potential for a competition intervention to improve -outcomes, there remains a broader policy debate about the optimal -distribution of existing revenues. We think it is a matter for Government and -policymakers to determine whether the current split is appropriate and fair, -and to explore whether wider policy interventions are required, for example -those relating to the copyright framework and how music streaming licensing -rates are set. We hope that our final findings provide insights that will be -helpful for that continuing debate. + with the latter option just ahead in both cases, though within the margin of error. Among young +Arab citizens of Israel as well as Gazan youth, support for two states is significantly higher +than support for alternatives. Small proportions of each cohort – just 12% among Israelis and 13% +of Palestinians – favor the status quo as the preferred option, indicating perhaps more interest in +disruption and change among youth than is the case for older compatriots, with 41.5% of Jewish +Israeli adults favoring the status quo in a 2021 survey conducted by the Israeli Democracy Institute.1 + +● Among both Israelis and Palestinians, large majorities believe the chances of a Palestinian +state in the foreseeable future are low. Just about half on each side believe that a political +resolution can actually bring peace. And by a clear majority, each side believes that violence is the only +or best way to achieve concessions from the other side. + +● Once violence is removed as an option, the two populations differ in terms of how to change the +situation and move towards peace: nearly two-thirds of Palestinians embrace boycotting the +other side, while a plurality, nearly half of Israelis, prefer dialogue. Among Arab youth in Israel +– by contrast to the historic polling trend of clear enthusiastic support for many peace-related themes +among their adult counterparts – nearly half express no position on how to interact with the other +side. However, about half support dialogue, more than four times as many as those who choose to +boycott – presenting a narrow but important opportunity. + +● Furthermore, at the deepest level of accepting the other’s historic, national connection to the + +land – young people are inclined to reject the legitimacy of such claims. Over 80% of +Palestinian youth deny the legitimacy of the Jews’ history and national connection to the +land, with a majority of Jewish youth in Israel – 57% – likewise rejecting the Palestinian +historic and national connection. + +● The two sides share a powerful belief in the importance of living in a democratic society, + +with this value reaching practically a consensus on each side, even as there is growing support +in both societies for solutions to the conflict that would result in non-democratic outcomes. Over +90% of Palestinian youth and 90% of Jewish Israelis believe democracy is important, even if they do +not prioritize it relative to other national goals at present. + +● Despite widespread negative emotions, a strong majority on both sides respects the majority +religion of the other: Jews respect Islam and Palestinians respect Judaism. At present, high +levels of religious observance correlate strongly with hardline attitudes; but the findings suggest +future opportunities for religiously-grounded engagement to bridge divides rather than deepen them. + +● In contrast to the broadly negative opinion trends regarding the conflict, a majority of +respondents on both sides expressed the view that peace is possible between the two +peoples, and the conflict is mostly about leaders fighting for their own interests. + +● While fewer than 10% of either population has ever engaged in a meaningful way with the other in +pursuit of such a goal, and there is skepticism about the efficacy of doing so, only 30% of Israeli +Jews and 29% of Palestinians believe cross-border peacebuilding efforts are illegitimate and +that they would therefore not participate. + +1 https://www.jpost.com/arab-israeli-conflict/with-only-40-percent-support-israelis-still-think-2-states-best-option- +poll-675838 2 - The effect of digitisation on the music industry - -8. + Polls are just one tool for seeking to understand societal attitudes, and responses are best considered as a data +point to be examined within a broader complex context. Israelis and Palestinians have been extensively polled +over years, allowing for visible trendlines to emerge, and yet the younger cohort that is the sample for this +particular study is examined only occasionally. As with all polls, the findings should not be considered +determinative, but rather as a valuable snapshot and starting point from which concerned stakeholders can +ask questions and cross reference data with other knowledge about the contextual factors that may be driving +the responses. While answers to some questions about the deeper future implications are beyond the scope of +this study, supplemental lines of inquiry might include whether the mutual rejectionist beliefs evinced in this +study indicate immutable attitudes among the communities polled, or to what extent zero-sum +conceptualizations of the conflict are grounded in a context of lack of contact between the two sides that can +be rectified, to mitigate practices that deepen conflict on the ground? How do we understand and compare +the relative responses of the different communities polled in light of their very different daily lived +experiences of conflict? And how do we evaluate cause and effect, or explain seemingly contradictory +findings as growing support for non-democratic end-game outcomes alongside overwhelming value placed on +democracy in both societies? + +Thanks to years of intensive polling among Israeli and Palestinian adult populations, one clear observation is +that public opinion is dynamic. Public attitudes respond to positive developments in the political and +diplomatic context and can often shift attitudes in response to potential confidence-building measures by the +other side. Combining this knowledge with some of the openings suggested by this study points to untapped +potential for bottom-up approaches and interventions driven by civil society and centered on building +partnerships and greater consensus to help prepare the ground for future diplomatic and political efforts. -9. - -The introduction of the internet made music piracy easier than had previously -been the case. Whilst piracy had always been a problem in the industry, the -internet made it easier to illegally copy works and share them with other -internet users on a large scale. The result was a collapse in music industry -revenues, and therefore creator revenues, as CD and other physical sales -declined. Inflation adjusted UK recorded music revenues fell by around 60% -from £1.9 billion in 2001 to £0.8 billion in 2015. - -Services that allowed consumers to access digital music legally, initially -through paid downloads of songs followed by music streaming, meant that for -the first time music companies and creators could monetise their content on -digital services and stem the flow of revenue losses. Since the introduction of -streaming, adjusting the older revenue figure for inflation music revenues -have increased from £0.8 billion in 2015 to £1.1 billion in 2021, although these -revenues remain below their £1.9 billion peak in 2001. - -UK inflation-adjusted recorded music revenues between 2000 and 2021 by format -type - -10. +Introduction -Consumers have embraced legal music -streaming and today music streaming accounts -for more than 80% of music sales. Data published -by Ofcom indicates that 47% of the population -made weekly use of music streaming services in -early 2022. This has nearly doubled since 2017, -but has remained relatively stable since 2020, -indicating that it might be plateauing. Younger -people stream music the most, with 77% of 15- +When asked by the press about the prospects of Israeli-Palestinian peace, following the funeral of Shimon +Peres, President Clinton predicted that an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal will happen at some point because the +young people in the region will demand it. President Obama, in his landmark address to Israeli youth, struck a +similar chord: “You – the young people of Israel – must now claim its future. It falls to you to write the next +chapter in the great story of this great nation. And as the President of a country that you can count on as your +greatest friend, I am confident that you can help us find the promise in the days that lie ahead.” + +Placing hope in the next generation is a time-honored political tradition that can also serve as a useful +mechanism for kicking difficult problems down the road for others to solve at a later date. While most +analysts agree that in the current moment conflict resolution between Israelis and Palestinians is a distant +prospect, assuming that it will improve over time requires more than blind faith that youthful idealism can be +relied upon to resolve the conflict in the future. The emerging generation of Israelis and Palestinians, between +the ages of 15-21, was born into arguably the least hopeful era in this conflict’s history. These young people +have come of age during and after the second Intifada and witnessed or directly experienced frequent physical +and/or structural violence at each other’s hands. The brutal Second Intifada; recurring Israel-Gaza wars; and +the most pronounced physical separation between Israelis and Palestinians since 1967--with the regime of +walls, permits, closures and blockade--have characterized the only context they have known. What does this +generation of Palestinians and Israelis, respectively, think of the “other”, who is at once more distant and +more wholly negatively framed within their societies than in the past? How interested are they in knowing +more about and working with each other to try to succeed where previous generations have failed? 3 - 11. - -12. - -34-year-olds streaming music on a weekly basis compared with just 19% of -those aged 55+.1 - -Streaming has changed not only how we listen to music but what we listen to -because for the first time all music, both old and new, is readily available in -one place at no additional cost. This has created opportunities for labels, -publishers, and creators to reach new audiences who may not have heard the -music on its first release which has in turn extended the lifecycle for earning -revenue from songs. This is a benefit to those creators whose music -continues to be listened to, but this development is not necessarily good for all -creators because it means that today’s new music competes with yesterday’s -songs for a share of streaming revenue. - -Digitisation and new online business models continue to create new -opportunities to consume music. Today, besides new online radio stations, a -consumer may hear a piece of music in a video on TikTok, see their favourite -artist on a live stream rather than in concert, or engage with music alongside -new interactive online gaming platforms. Whilst these are different to -streaming services with full catalogues and music available on-demand, they -are new ways that consumers hear and discover music and offer potential -new sources of revenue for the music companies, artists, and songwriters. - -The recorded music sector is concentrated, but that is not driving -the concerns raised by artists - -13. - -14. - -Our analysis shows that more creators than ever are releasing music, -doubling from 200,000 in 2014 to 400,000 in 2020. This is, in part, made -possible by innovations in technology and the ability to easily distribute music -online. For example, it is now easier than ever to create and record music -outside the confines of a traditional music studio and share it on streaming -services without the need for a record label. - -It has long been the case in recorded music that only a very small minority of -artists will achieve the highest level of success. In 2020 over 60% of streams -were of music recorded by only the top 0.4% of artists. To reach the top of the -chart, songs need to be streamed many millions of times each day and many -artists are faced with a situation where their work can be streamed millions of -times, but it does not translate into a significant share of their income. For -example, twelve million streams a year could earn an artist around £12,000, -but less than 1% of artists achieve that number of streams. We have heard - -1 Data published by Ofcom (2022), Media Nations: UK 2022. + In November-December 2020, the Alliance for Middle East Peace (ALLMEP) and the United States Institute +of Peace (USIP) commissioned a joint research project to answer these questions. Surveys were conducted +among Israeli and Palestinian youth, ages 15-21. The quantitative survey was conducted among representative +samples of this age group among both populations, with a margin of error of 3.5%. Dr. Khalil Shikaki and +Dr. Dahlia Scheindlin wrote the survey, supervised the fieldwork, and analyzed the results. All participants +were youth between the ages of 15 and 21 years; half were male and half female. Palestinian respondents +included both West Bankers and Gazans, and Israeli respondents included both Jewish and Arab Citizens of +Israel. While many Arab citizens of Israel also identify as Palestinian (using terms such as Palestinian citizen +of Israel to describe their identity), for the purpose of this report and the clarity of comparison with +Palestinian respondents in the West Bank and Gaza, we use the terms Arab Israeli or Arab citizens of Israel. + +About seven months after the joint poll – in June 2021 – focus groups among Palestinians and Israelis were +conducted to add qualitative breadth and understanding to the poll findings. Important to note is that the +focus group discussions were not designed to be definitive or assess support or opposition on particular +positions – a goal already pursued via the poll. Rather, this significantly smaller pool of respondents was +asked to reflect more deeply on some of the questions asked in the poll, and thereby shed more light on some +of the dynamics driving certain findings. Overall, the focus group participants expressed more hardline +attitudes than the poll respondents overall. This may have been a factor of these discussions, unlike the poll, +taking place so recently after the May 2021 war between Israel and Hamas and internal fighting within Israel, +or might also be explained by the group setting creating a more hardline dynamic. + +The results of the research defy generalization, and are worthy of deep interrogation by policymakers, +academics and advocates for Israeli-Palestinian peace. It is nonetheless clear that the attitudes of Palestinian +and Israeli youth reflect the challenging and hardline context within which they have come of age. They have +grown up during an era of cyclical wars and waves of violent escalation; the hard realities of a military +occupation; political dysfunction, division, and entrenching or growing authoritarianism in Gaza and the West +Bank; and a crescendo of nationalist populism and leadership retreat from a two-state vision in Israel. +Having lived through only failed attempts at diplomacy and the eclipse of a political horizon, the +majority of young people on both sides are cynical about peace and skeptical of each other. Further, a +deepening trend of each side conceptualizing its own national identity in terms of opposition to the other +indicates that without interventions or a change of circumstances, this generation could remain hardline in the +long term, making the currently challenging environment for peacemaking even more difficult over time. +However, the surveys and focus group discussions also unearthed positive findings, with points of +commonality cohorts as well as openness to engaging in some activities and modes of thinking +which could disrupt and reshape some of these attitudes and – in turn – practices over time. + +Both Israeli and (especially) Palestinian societies are far younger than is the case in the United States or +Europe, so the attitudes of these young people are primed to play a significant role in determining the +trajectory on the ground, alongside the trajectory of what is and is not diplomatically possible. Yet while +demography may be destiny, the public opinions of any demographic group are not static. These young +people’s opinions and ideas are the fruit of their experiences, the failures of previous generations, the +radicalization of both Israeli and Palestinian politics, and the injustices and insecurities that characterize the +Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Altering those variables may disrupt and rearrange many of these opinions, +as may providing opportunities for young people from both societies to meet, discuss and debate +these issues, something – as this poll demonstrates – only a tiny minority of each cohort has ever +done. Accordingly, this report, and the study from which it derives, seeks to unearth the attitudes, fears, +hopes and interests of this generation as they contemplate their futures within their own societies and in +relation to each other, and with the goal of strengthening the relevance and impact of civil society and policy +interventions aimed at transforming or resolving the conflict. 4 - from both artists and songwriters that they are unable to make a sustainable -income from music streaming and for many it feels unfair. - -15. We have considered what may be causing these outcomes for artists2 and, in - -line with our statutory duties, whether these outcomes are being caused by -competition issues in the market. - -16. - -The recorded music sector is concentrated, with the 3 major labels holding a -combined share of over 70% of UK streams, and this has persisted for some -time. The market share in terms of streams of independent record companies -(indies) has remained steady at around one quarter for several years. This -share is very fragmented with only 2 indies having a share in excess of 1%. - -Label shares of total UK streams in 2021 - -Source: CMA analysis of data from Official Charts.3 - -2 As described in Chapter 5 of this report, a number of our findings on artists will also relate to songwriters. -Issues specific to songwriters are considered in more detail below. -3 Notes: This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. These figures are provided in a 5% range where the figure -is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the ranges have -been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints does not -equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of the -midpoints. + Identity, Values and Priorities + +In both Israeli and Palestinian communities, there has been a trend in recent years of young people embracing +more hardline positions. The root causes have been studied and documented in research over the course of +the last decade.2 Within this research, there is an attempt to better understand how respondents’ sense of +their own identity, and the values and ideals that they wish to see reflected in their respective societies relate +to these political positions. + +Israeli and Palestinian Youth Identities3 + +In Israel, 61% of Jewish Israeli youth surveyed defined themselves as right-wing, and 32% of Jewish +Israeli youth placed themselves on the far right-wing of that spectrum. One-fifth of Jewish young +people in Israel identify as centrist and just 12% consider themselves left-wing (either far left, just +4%, or moderate left: 8%), yielding just one-third in total of the Jewish Israeli population who self- +identify as left-wing or centrist. + +As is consistently the case among their adult counterparts, Arab Israeli youth were reticent about stating their +political views. Within the survey, over 60% of this cohort declined to provide self-identification at all. A net +plurality of Arab Israeli youth – nearly one-quarter – identified as leftist and only 4% identified as right-wing. +The remaining 8% self-defined as centrist. However, like in the Palestinian groups polled and focus grouped +in the West Bank and Gaza, the focus group of Arab citizens of Israel expressed a significant hardline +attitude on topics like Israel, Zionism, Israeli politics and policies, and specifically around +occupation and the dismal prospects for the conflict’s resolution. + +Parallel to Jewish Israeli youth survey results, a plurality of young Palestinians in the West Bank and +Gaza situate themselves on arguably the harder-line end of the ideological spectrum of attitudes +toward the conflict. In this poll, over 40% of the total sample identified themselves with the term Islamiyya, a +markedly higher percentage than the second choice of “mainstream nationalism” (28%). The term – variably +translated as “Islamic” or “Islamism” in English – is open to interpretation. As polling and focus grouping +over time has suggested, identification with “Islamiyya” is not necessarily or exclusively a self-designation of +level of religiosity or political activism. In some cases, the term seems to correlate with a hardline approach to +the conflict, but can also more exclusively correlate with those who ascribe to political Islam separate from +attitudes toward the conflict. It can also designate an altogether apolitical outlook: an identifier of a +respondent who believes society should subscribe to Islamic values.4 Gazans are significantly more likely to +describe their ideological affiliation as Islamiyya – nearly half of the total (49%) – while a plurality of 37% of +West Bank youth choose to self-identify this way. Yet, as we will address later in this report, the attitudes of +Gazan youth are much more nuanced, often surprisingly, than this broad self-identification may suggest. The +second-ranked political position of “mainstream nationalism” is consistent in both regions. Just a tiny +portion, 3% of the total, self-defines as leftist, a term typically associated with loyalty to some of the Marxist +parties in Palestinian politics, rather than any broader definition, while another 8% holds a “traditional +opinion;” a term that tends to denote a greater emphasis on religious values in society than the left and +nationalists. The remainder, nearly one-fifth, declined to define themselves. + +2 See “Israeli & Palestinian Youth Attitudes towards peace, conflict and the other,” prepared by Dahlia Scheindlin for +ALLMEP in March 2020, for a comprehensive review of relevant research. +3 To account for distinct political and social contexts in the societies being polled, the choices presented by the questions +are differentiated according to whether they are directed at Israelis or Palestinians to account for the terms and dynamics +that resonate in their respective contexts. +4 To underscore this point, not all who identify with the designation Islamiyya are religious; in fact, only slightly more +than half (53%) of all Islamists say they are “religious” while 45% describe themselves as “somewhat religious.” 5 - 17. - -The scale of the majors and their global reach means they can offer large -advances which attracts proven and successful artists. In turn, this can make -it difficult for indie labels to attract and retain artists as they become -successful, which can create a barrier to expansion for indie labels. - -18. Despite the concentrated nature of the market, outcomes for artists as a - -whole seem to be improving. We accept that this improvement may not be -benefiting all artists, and that for many artists the improvement will seem -insufficient. - -19. Our analysis shows that in some respects the options available to artists, - -particularly new artists, are improving: - -(a) There is now more choice for artists about which type of deal they would -like to agree, from DIY distribution, A&L services, or more traditional -record deals. - -(b) Some new artists have greater leverage when negotiating a record deal - -with a label if they have already built a strong fanbase and online -presence. - -Average UK artist yearly streaming earnings from majors and average -(mean) royalty rates (2021 prices) in the UK - -Source: CMA analysis of data from the majors - -20. Analysis of new contracts signed by the majors with new artists for multi-track - -deals (ie albums or extended play (EP) records) shows that, between 2012 -and 2021: - -(a) the average gross royalty rate has increased from 19.7% to 23.3%; + Israeli and Palestinian Youth Priorities and Values + +Each group was asked to select its top priority from four defining values for their society. This is a tracking +question that has been tested among both Israeli and Palestinian adults in recent years, allowing comparison +between different age cohorts. + +Jewish Israeli youth responses to this question suggest that overall trends in this group are not fundamentally +different from those found in the adult Jewish Israeli population over time, as demonstrated by past polling. +A notable exception, however, is that adult Jewish Israelis polled in 2020 placed a significantly greater +priority on a democratic state, placing it in second place overall (with 30% of adults favoring a +democratic state vs. 19% of youth).5 Jewish Israeli youth generally express a preference for a Jewish +majority and a relatively secular state. However, a closer look at the data shows that Jewish Israeli youth are +fundamentally divided on both issues. The clear plurality of the Jewish youth interviewed (37%) ranked the +Jewish majority in the State of Israel as the top value, with the value of “Greater Israel '' in last place (16%). +However, Jewish Israeli youth who identified as leftist and centrist diverged sharply from their right-wing +counterparts. Among these cohorts, democracy was ranked as the highest value (by 44% of leftists and 36% +of centrists), and peace with the Palestinians was ranked second (38% of leftists and 28% of centrists). The +Jewish majority of Israel is ranked in third place for both the self-identified leftists and centrists. By contrast, +self-identified right-wing youth place a much higher priority on the Jewish majority (48%), with “Greater +Israel” in second place (23%). + +Palestinian youth and Arab Israeli youth were asked the same set of questions for this section of the poll, with +a focus on priorities and values that historically resonate in those respective communities. 35% of Palestinians +interviewed ranked Israeli withdrawal from areas occupied in 1967 and the establishment of a Palestinian state +as the highest value. This is only one fraction higher than their second choice: the right of refugees to return +to the villages left in 1948. Of note is that for youth who are Arab citizens of Israel, this latter value of the +“right of return” for Palestinian refugees was the highest value by a large margin: prioritized five times as +strongly as the establishment of a Palestinian state. Whereas in Gaza – where a large majority of the +population are refugees and their descendants – respondents prioritized Israeli withdrawal and establishment +of a Palestinian state at a significantly higher rate than support for the right of return (39% vs. 27%, +respectively). The Gaza/West Bank divide, overlapping with refugees versus non-refugees, thus presents itself +in a slightly counter-intuitive way, with Gazans prioritizing statehood over the right of return, and West +Bankers holding the opposite view. In all groups, the values of establishing a religious society or a democracy +are ranked significantly lower than the above-mentioned priorities more directly related to the conflict. A +religious society is ranked higher than democracy among the most religious Palestinians and those who +identify with the term Islamiyya, but only by a slight margin. + +Perceptions of “the Other” + +The survey results underscored the lack of contact between Israeli and Palestinian youth. An overwhelming +majority of Palestinian youth (82%) and about one third (32%) of Jewish Israeli youth indicated that +they had no contact with the other side whatsoever. Almost half of Jewish Israeli youth (47%) indicated +that they had some “minimal” contact with the other side. The gap between Israeli and Palestinian +communities in these responses is likely due to the fact that Israeli youth are exposed to tens of thousands of + +5https://www.pcpsr.org/sites/default/files/Table%20of%20findings_English%20Joint%20Poll%20%20Oct%202020.p +df 6 - (b) the proportion of contracts where labels own copyright of recordings in - -perpetuity has reduced from 66% to 26.4%; and - -(c) the average number of minimum commitment periods (where a period is -defined by a commitment to produce a multi-track output such as an -album) has fallen from 3.8 to 3.4 - -21. Competition appears to be particularly focused on artists who are already - -popular or are likely to be. Competition to sign such artists can be very -intense with offers from many labels. Traditional record deals also face -increasing disruption from alternative models, in particular service deals from -artist and label (A&L) service providers, and there are more options than ever -for artists to reach audiences and monetise their work. - -22. We think that outcomes for artists are driven by factors which are largely - -unrelated to competition issues in the market. Rather, we think these -outcomes can be attributed to factors more inherent to how music streaming -works. Digitisation has allowed for a huge increase in the number of artists -sharing their music and a vast back catalogue made available via streaming -so there is more music available to stream and consumer tastes tend to tip -towards a relativity small number of artists being successful. In addition, there -is very significant uncertainty about which artists will be successful. The -combination of these market features is likely to result in competition focused -on a relatively limited number of artists and market outcomes where the -majority of the benefits are accrued by a minority of artists. - -23. We therefore conclude that a competition intervention, for example a change - -to the structure of the market, is unlikely to result in a material increase in -revenues for artists. - -24. Whilst majors’ profits have been increasing since the lows of piracy, our -profitability analysis has not found evidence of substantial and sustained -excess profits by the majors. This is consistent with our overall finding that - -4 As these are only averages across all 3 majors, they do not show how the terms can vary significantly between -artists, reflecting for example the different potential financial rewards and risks based on the characteristics of -individual artists (including by genre, potential, and stage of career). + Palestinian laborers who work in Israel while West Bank Palestinian exposure to Israelis is much more limited +and usually restricted to minimal – and rarely positive – contacts with soldiers and settlers. The overwhelming +majority of Gazans have been sealed off from any contact with Israelis since 2007, when even the oldest +respondents to this poll would have been children. Subsequently, respondents were asked if they were willing +to have a friend from the other side or, if they had one, whether they would be willing to invite him or her to +their homes. Findings show that Israelis, both Jews (52%) and Arabs (63% - Arabs were asked about having a +Jewish friend), are more open to inviting friends of the other side to their homes than was the case for +Palestinians (12%). On both sides, the wish to have a friend from the other side is restricted to a small +minority. + +The survey sought to map each side’s image of the other within the conflict, in order to consider how these +perceptions might shift. One set of questions showed two polarized groups, each deeply entrenched in +the notion that “our side is decent, their side is bad.” The first question tested the commonly held view +that the other side only understands force when seeking to gain concessions. A majority of both Jewish +Israelis and Palestinians believe that the other side only understands force: this is equal to two thirds +of Jewish Israelis (66%), and nearly three quarters (73%) of Palestinians. Arab Israelis were asked +about Jewish Israelis, and they were the only group in which just a minority agreed with the +statement (27%). + +The second related question sought to test the potential for self-criticism, by asking each constituency to +confirm or deny whether the side that they belong to only understands the use of force as a means to extract +concessions. + +Barely one-quarter of Jews, one-third of Palestinians, and only 17% of Arab citizens of Israel agreed +with the statement that their side only understands force as a means to draw concessions from the +other side. + +Despite the mutually aggressive image of the other, there are some positive indicators showing the existence +of a significant camp still open to peacemaking. When asked if they agreed with the statement that “the +conflict was mainly a matter of political leaders fighting for their own interests, while regular people +could get along,” a majority on both sides agreed. + +Furthermore, when asked whether they viewed a final status political solution as the path for the two sides to +reach peace, just under half of Palestinians agreed that a political solution can bring peace, while a +similar proportion disagreed. Among Israelis, 51% of Jewish Israelis and 48% of Arab Israelis agreed +that a political solution can bring peace, for a total average of 50%. In general terms, a plurality of +both Jewish and Arab Israelis agreed that a political resolution can bring peace. + +However, Israeli focus group discussions revealed that the idea of a formal, agreed-upon political resolution +appears remote and abstract, failing to come up organically in discussion without a prompt. When probed +on their understanding of the term “peace”, even the Jewish left-leaning group defined it mostly as a +cessation of fighting and violence, coupled with diplomacy and physical improvement, and not as a +final status settlement that addresses substantive political issues. + +The Legitimacy of “the Other’s” Narrative + +The survey sought to assess perceptions of the other side’s historic links to the land. Despite significant +variations within and between groups, the findings are clear: at the deepest level of accepting the +other’s historic, national commitment to the land, young people are inclined to reject any such +legitimacy. Among the Palestinians, the gap between West Bankers and Gazans is very small as the +overwhelming majority in both places reject such Jewish links (83% and 85% respectively). While only 24% +of Arab Israelis believed that Jews have a historic and religious connection to the land, this percentage is 7 - there is unlikely to be scope to improve outcomes for artists substantially -through increased competition. - -25. We understand that Government has taken several steps to address concerns - -about creator remuneration and has responded to the DCMS Select -Committee recommendations for legislative and policy reform in this area. In -particular, the IPO is conducting a research programme including examining -potential options to strengthen creator rights and remuneration. We are -sharing our final findings with the IPO and DCMS to help inform their work. + more than double that of the number of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza (11%) who accept such a +connection. -Labels could do more to improve the information they provide to -artists +A majority of Jewish Israeli youth – 57% – likewise reject the Palestinian historic and national +connection, though the cohort also shows greater willingness to acknowledge the other’s links to the land +(43%). These views correlate heavily with the left-right divide. Among the firm-right, a near-consensus (81%) +rejected Palestinian historic and religious connection to the land, and almost three-quarters of the total right- +wing responded this way in the survey. This trend is almost reversed among the left and center, where clear +majorities acknowledged the Palestinian historic and religious connection to the land (83% among the left, +and 65% among the center). -26. We heard strong concern from some artists and their representatives that they +The right-wing Jewish focus group expressed these sentiments clearly. Some of the participants rejected the +notion of a Palestinian nation altogether. These young Israelis argued that the Palestinian people did not fit +the definition of a nation, or that the nation was a fiction, or at best, if there is a Palestinian nation, that it +emerged only in response to Zionism. -do not get enough information from record labels on how their earnings from -streaming services are calculated or how the deals that exist between labels -and streaming services may affect what they earn or could earn in future. -Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) between music streaming services and -labels were cited as a barrier to improving information provision to artists. +Engaging “the Other” -27. Our analysis shows that some artists are provided with information, such as +One of the deepest divisions between Israeli and Palestinian youth is on the question of whether the two +sides should even engage with one another. Here there is no mirror image, but rather two communities that +largely hold different worldviews on the utility and legitimacy of engagement. The poll asked both sides: -number of streams and the royalties earnt on these streams, which tells them -how much they have earned per stream on music streaming services, and we -saw some positive examples of labels presenting this information in a user- -friendly way. However, this was not consistent across all labels, and we think -best practices could be developed so that information could be presented in a -more straightforward and uniform way with appropriate guidance on how to -interpret the data. This will help artists better understand how they are paid for -streaming and the sources of their income. +“In order to advance a resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which do you think will be more effective: -28. +[For Israeli Jews] Do not engage with Palestinians until they embrace non-violence (and/or) recognize Israel as a +Jewish State +[For Palestinians & Arab Israelis] Anti-normalization or boycott talks with [Jewish] Israelis until occupation is +ended -In respect of NDAs, whilst they do prevent certain terms and conditions being -made available to artists and limit access to the ‘source data’ from the music -streaming services, they do not appear to prevent a significant amount of -relevant information being made available to artists about their earnings. By -limiting the access to source data, the NDAs may potentially limit the ability of -artists to verify the accuracy of information. However, this is an issue more to -do with verification of the fulfilment of contractual terms rather than one of -competition to sign artists. - -29. We welcome the work the IPO is undertaking on issues -around transparency for artists, including developing a -code of practice. - -8 +OR - Publishing revenues from streaming in the UK have grown -significantly, but many songwriters argue they are not paid enough -to make a sustainable income +Talk, hold dialogue with the other side first, in order to agree on demands and move ahead” -30. Each song has two sets of music rights: (1) rights in the underlying song or -‘publishing rights’ which includes the music and lyrics; and (2) rights in the -particular recording of that song, the ‘recording rights’. Without permission to -use both rights, a streaming service cannot legally stream the song. +Nearly two-thirds of Palestinians chose anti-normalization or boycott of talks, until the occupation is +over, with barely one-third supporting dialogue. -31. +By contrast, a plurality of Jewish Israelis believes in dialogue over boycotting the Palestinian side. However, +one sobering observation is that even among Israelis just 48% of the total chose this option (49% among +Jews, and 45% among Arabs, who were asked about engagement with Jewish Israelis). Among Jewish Israelis, +35% preferred boycott. While an equal number of Arab Israelis chose “don’t know” as chose dialogue, only +10% of this group definitively supported the boycott of Jewish Israelis as a mechanism to achieve conflict +resolution. -Throughout the study we have heard consistently from groups that represent -songwriters that the publishing right of a song is systematically undervalued -when compared to the recording right. In turn, they argue that this means that -songwriters receive less in royalties for their work and do not make a -sustainable income from streaming. Whilst some songwriters are also -themselves artists and may have access to revenues from recording rights -and other sources of income, that is not always the case. +Unsurprisingly, when the same question is tested against ideology, substantial divisions appear within Israeli +society. A strong majority of leftist and centrist youth (79% and 66% respectively) support dialogue with +Palestinians, rather than boycott. Moreover, there is an interesting division within the right-wing cohort, in +which a plurality of moderate Israeli Jewish right-wingers support dialogue (48%) over boycott +(38%), whereas the far-right strongly supports boycott (55%) over dialogue (28%). A strong majority +(62%) of self-defined religious Jews also prefer boycott over engagement. -32. Songwriters and their representatives have suggested that the undervaluation -of publishing rights is because the majors have market power and interests in -both publishing and recording rights and that it is financially advantageous for -them to suppress publishing revenues in favour of the recording side of their -business, possibly through tacit collusion. We have also heard concerns that -the majors may have the ability and incentive to influence industry outcomes -via their membership of collecting societies (CMOs) who have a role in -negotiating royalties for the use of their members’ publishing rights. +Participation in Joint Activities with “the Other” -33. We have examined evidence on the allocation of music streaming revenues, +Despite the varied responses regarding perceptions of the efficacy of joint socio-political activities, attitudes +shifted when the survey asked if the respondent is currently participating or is willing to participate in such +activities. Twenty-two percent of Israelis and 30% of Palestinians indicated either current (or past) -and it indicates that: - -(a) The share of revenues going to publishers (publishing share) increased - -from 8% in 2008 to approximately 12% in 2012. Since then it has -increased to 15% in 2021. This is a significant increase across the period. -In contrast, the share of revenues going to record companies in 2021 is at -a broadly similar level to what it was in 2008. - -(b) For the majors, the growth in publishing revenues - -has far exceeded the growth in recording revenues. +8 -(c) Majors’ growth in publishing revenues is 244% since -2017, which is significantly above the [110-120]% -average across the publishing sector over the same -period. + participation or else willingness to participate in such activities in the future. With less than one fifth +of Israeli Jews and less than a third of Palestinian youth participating or showing immediate +willingness to participate, these findings at first appear to be discouraging. Yet on the other hand, only +a minority on each side views such efforts as beyond the pale. Only 30% of Jewish Israelis and 29% of +Palestinians believe that these efforts are illegitimate and would not participate, suggesting +majorities in each society who could, under the right conditions, be open to engaging in such +activities. + +Gazan responses to this question present an interesting case for consideration. While a plurality of Gazans +have not been active in joint activities, with participation all but impossible due to the regime of +closure that has been in place for most of their young lives--not to mention Hamas intimidation of +those who are able to find avenues to engage6-- still, 33% are interested in such activities. It is worth +dwelling on these findings, as research conducted by Notre Dame University in 2019 showed that +participation in such activities was very effective in halting or reversing some of the more worrying attitudes +expressed elsewhere in this survey, with participants-- up to five years after participation in such projects-- +reporting more positive attitudes toward “the other” and an increased belief in the possibility of peace.7 Amid +much other data that is troubling in this survey, one may wonder how those findings might be different if the +very large number of Israeli and Palestinian youth who are potential participants in such programs had the +opportunity to avail themselves of them. It is notable that attitudes towards engagement and the +receptivity toward the other’s narrative is higher among Jewish and Arab citizens of Israel than +among Palestinians in the Occupied Territories. While additionally a matter of speculation, this +raises a question about the impact that more consistent and longstanding contact between Jewish +and Arab citizens of the state has had on softening attitudes and fostering mutual understanding. + +The questionnaire also proposed various specific activities and asked each side whether it viewed them as +legitimate and if they would be willing or ready to engage in them. The findings show that both Jewish +Israelis and Palestinians are likely to view activities such as economic ventures and tourism as +legitimate, while denying legitimacy to most others. It should be noted that Palestinians are rather +internally divided: large majorities of West Bankers find some of these activities legitimate, while majorities of +Gazans refuse to describe any of the proposed activities as legitimate. Palestinians overall significantly extend +legitimacy to medical visits, which have been a critical matter during the coronavirus pandemic when +Palestinians relied heavily on coordination with Israel to combat the virus. By contrast, Israeli Jews are likely +to extend legitimacy to peace and dialogue programs (47% of total Israelis), together with economic ventures +(44%) and tourism activities (39%) However, it is striking once again how low support for the legitimacy of +these activities is among Israelis, with no single option achieving over 50% among the general sample, and +especially low levels of legitimacy among Arab citizens of Israel. + +The focus groups allowed further exploration of the conditions and variables that might affect participants’ +willingness to engage with the other side and also provided more complexity -- and at times even +contradicting -- the poll findings. In the Palestinian focus groups, almost all Gazan participants found +it legitimate and acceptable to have contacts with Israeli Jews when it came to all humanitarian +matters. Gazan participants were also more likely to support youth political dialogue, explaining that +such contacts should expand to include “joint demonstrations against the occupation,” a type of +joint activity often branded as “co-resistance.” Most West Bankers who participated in the focus groups +found dialogue with Israeli Jewish youths productive, and therefore legitimate, and some expressed +willingness to engage in it “because it would provide an opportunity to expose the crimes of occupation and + +6 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/09/hamas-arrests-gaza-peace-activists-for-zoom-chat-with-israelis +7 “Expanding the Reach of Impact Evaluations in Peacebuilding: A Retrospective Evaluation of CMM P2P Activities in +Israel/West Bank.” Danice Brown Guzman and Lila Khatiwada, Notre Dame Initiative for Global Development. +https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00TVV3.pdf 9 - Split in music streaming revenues in 2008 and 2021 - -34. - -Source: Section 4.2.2 of research commissioned by the IPO Music Creators Earnings, the Digital Era, -and On-Demand Streaming Revenues and CMA analysis of data from Apple, Amazon and Spotify.5 - -This evidence is inconsistent with the argument that the majors have tacitly -colluded to suppress the publishing share or that there is otherwise -particularly weak competition to sign songwriters that is leading to a split in -the allocation of music streaming revenues that favours recording rights over -publishing rights. The majors having both a recording and a publishing -business is also not necessarily problematic. For instance, if the majors did -not have a publishing business they might have a stronger incentive to block -increases in the ‘publishing share’ by refusing to accommodate such an -increase through reducing the recording share since any losses to their -recording revenues which occurred would not be mitigated by gains to their -publishing revenues. - -35. We also have not seen clear evidence that CMOs are failing to push for better -terms owing to the majors’ influence or that CMO governance procedures and -processes are failing to mitigate any potential bias in their decision making. If -such regulatory concerns do exist, the proper body to examine them is the -IPO, which has responsibility for monitoring the conduct of CMOs under the -Collective Management of Copyright (EU Directive) Regulations 2016.6 - -5 Note: Whilst the CMA analysis for 2021 is based on data from the largest music streaming services, the IPO -research draws on a range of largely qualitative evidence and therefore (as the IPO research itself -acknowledges) the IPO research estimate of the split of revenues for 2008 is only indicative. Therefore, -comparison between the split between 2008 and 2021 should be treated with caution and taken to be indicative -of the overall trend in the split over time rather than estimates of the exact quantum of change in the split. -6 The conduct of UK CMOs (including the PRS) is governed by the CRM Regulations. The CRM Regulations -designate a National Competent Authority (NCA) which is responsible for monitoring and enforcing compliance + make them understand Palestinian suffering.” Others, mostly from the West Bank, supported dialogue +because “we have no alternative as Palestinians are captives.” Some West Bank participants also argued that +Israel is an advanced country in medicine and education and “we need to engage with Israeli Jews on such +matters like these, but not necessarily [on other matters] like the promotion of peace.” Importantly, the +minority of West Bank focus group participants who thought dialogue and contact was unacceptable +for all Palestinians, nevertheless found it legitimate for those in need of education or health care. + +Despite the contradictory polling evidence, Israeli Jewish focus group participants did not tend to +question the legitimacy of such interactions. However, demonstrating how remote such programs +are to the lives of most Israeli youth, the very idea appeared completely new to most – only 2-3 focus +group participants (out of 24) had ever participated in cross-communal programs (though others had contact +from organic interaction or physical proximity to Arab communities). Most participants expressed a mixture +of curiosity, and indifference or skepticism about the purpose of such contact. + +The Conflict: Attitudes toward Solutions + +Polling shows that Israeli and Palestinian political realities have led to a steady erosion of support +for the two-state solution among both publics over the last decade, even as it still narrowly retains +pride of place as the most popular option among other alternatives. Among the key drivers for the +erosion of support for the two-state solution is the perception of low prospects for its feasibility. In this +survey, respondents were asked whether they believed there were chances for the establishment of a +Palestinian state within the next five years. On this question, the answers of young people differed little from +that of the adult population that is regularly polled on this question: nearly three quarters (73%) of Israeli +youth (and 80% of the Jewish Israeli sample) believe the chances are low or very low. Two thirds of +Palestinians (66%) gave the same assessment. Although support for a two-state solution is highest in +Gaza, it is also where despair is highest: 75% give low or very low chances, compared to 61% of +youth in the West Bank. + +The study then asked respondents to rank their preferences from among four general directions of the +conflict: a two-state solution, a single state dominated exclusively by one group, an equal one-state solution, +and the status quo. Arab citizens of Israel were asked the same question as Palestinians. The results showed +that the only sectors who ranked the two-state solution clearly as the top choice were the youth in +Gaza and, to a lesser extent, Arab citizens of Israel. + +● 44% of Gazan respondents selected “two states for two people”, with a 26-points margin over the +second ranked choice (one equal state, which was statistically tied with the two remaining options). +This makes Gazan Palestinians -- by a strong margin -- the most supportive cohort of a two- +state solution among any cohort polled; + +● Arab citizens of Israel ranked the two-state solution as the top option (26%), followed by 21% who +chose an equal democratic state. Only 12% of this group chose a Palestinian-dominated single state; + +● Among West Bank respondents, the two-state solution and an unequal Palestinian + +dominated one-state were tied at 26% each, with the two remaining options also statistically tied; +● Among Israeli Jews, one Jewish-dominated unequal state was ranked at the first place, with +29% of respondents choosing this option – though this option ranked only two points higher +than the two-state solution (27%), and within the statistical margin of error. + +The ideological designation that emerges as meaningful in regard to this question among Palestinians is 10 - 36. Songwriters are concerned that the initial split between publishing and - -recording revenues adopted when streaming began was unfair and -unjustified, for example because it did not reflect the alleged lower costs of -record companies under streaming compared to physical distribution. The -increase in the publishing share is consistent with this concern over the initial -split and there being a subsequent period of market-correction, which may not -yet have fully played out. However, the fact that publishing revenues are -increasing at a greater rate compared to recording revenues, in particular for -the majors, suggests that publishing revenues are not being actively -suppressed because of a distortion or restriction of competition. - -37. We have found that there are inherent difficulties in securing increases to the - -publishing share and, consequently, increasing the amount songwriters are -paid. This difficulty may arise from the fact that music streaming services, -labels and publishers must all reach agreement to change how streaming -revenues are divided. However, they may all have different incentives and so -they may not agree – we call this a ‘licensing negotiation friction’. We think -that agreement between the parties may be particularly challenging when an -increase in the publishing share would necessitate a fall in the share that goes -to record companies due to the strong bargaining position of music -rightsholders, which arises from the need for music streaming services to get -agreement from all key rightsholders to offer a wide range of music. - -38. - -The long-term increase in the publishing share since 2008 has been -accommodated by a fall in the share taken by music streaming services. The -risk is that we may reach a point, or could do soon, where further substantial -increases in the publishing share can only be accommodated by a fall in the -recording share, which labels would be in a strong bargaining position to -resist. - -39. Whilst we think that competition for songwriters has driven up the existing - -publishing share, concerns exist that the current split could still be sub- -optimal, particularly for songwriters. If that is the case, we think that it may -take time for the split to adjust further, if at all, owing to the inherent licensing -negotiation frictions and bargaining power of music rightsholders we have -described. There is also a limit on the extent to which competition to sign -songwriters can drive further increases in the publishing share, particularly if -an increase needs to be accommodated by a fall in the recording share. -Competition policy is not therefore the right tool to reach an optimal split. We -think it is a matter for Government and policymakers to determine whether the - -with the Regulations’ provisions. The NCA functions in the UK are undertaken through the IPO, which has -published guidance on these regulations (see IPO (2021), Guidance on the Collective Management of Copyright -(EU Directive) Regulations 2016). + Islamiyya versus mainstream nationalism. Together, these groups make up nearly 70% of the youth sample. +Among mainstream nationalists, the two-state solution is the favorite approach (41%), well ahead of the +Palestinian dominated one state (23%). Those who identify as Islamiyya also rank a two-state solution as the +preferred option, but at a significantly lower rate: 32%, while 20% support one unequal Palestinian state. + +Among young Jewish Israelis, the question exposes deep divisions based on ideology and levels of religiosity, +revealing fundamentally different worldviews. Young national religious and ultra-orthodox Jews support a +Jewish-dominated single state by a wide margin over all other options, the former ranking it at an absolute +majority of 53% and the latter at 41%. Secular respondents ranked the two-state solution highest, but only by +a ten-point margin over the single state options, tied at 22% each for the equal and unequal version. +Traditionalists ranked the two-state solution and a Jewish-dominated one state almost identically: 29% and +28% each. This finding reinforces long-standing polarization based on religious observance among Jews. In +this regard, it is important to keep in mind the religious trends: at present, ultra-orthodox and national +religious Jews make up 21% of Jewish adults in Israel (approximately 16% of the entire adult population) and +their population growth rate is significantly higher than secular and traditionalist Jews.8 + +Steps toward Conflict Resolution + +Respondents were also asked to choose what they viewed as the most effective means of advancing an +acceptable resolution of the conflict. They were offered four options: military means, negotiations, citizen +engagement through civil society, or “I don’t know.” Half of Palestinians, with minimal variation +between Gaza and the West Bank, preferred military force as the most effective means of ending the +conflict. Among Jewish Israelis, the clear plurality – 41% – preferred direct negotiations. The findings +reflect the widespread feeling among Palestinians that negotiations have not only failed to achieve their goals +but have also corresponded to a period during which Palestinians feel that their situation has deteriorated. +Research demonstrates that support for the use of military force on both sides tends to increase when +diplomacy is viewed as ineffective. + +At the same time, if there is a chance of winning support for negotiations in the future, the survey was able to +pinpoint at least one clear condition which could convince each group that the other side is serious. When +asked what might convince them that the other side is genuinely committed to negotiations, and +would cause them to support such negotiations, a plurality of Palestinian youth (28%) chose the +option in which Israel would offer greater freedom of movement. The urgency of easing movement +restrictions has appeared in the regular joint surveys of adults conducted by these same researchers, where +freedom of movement has emerged as a strong incentive for Palestinians, who otherwise reject a final status +agreement, to change their minds. For Palestinians, the second most convincing incentive was that Israel +cease settlement construction (21%), followed closely by Israel accepting the ’67 lines as a basis for +negotiations (19%). Among Israelis, a plurality (35%) chose the item stating that “Palestinians declare +a major effort to review all school textbooks for anti-Israel incitement or anti-Semitism and replace +them.” This finding is consistent with incentives tested in the joint survey conducted among adults.9 + +8 Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics, “Annual Social Survey, 2019” Jerusalem: CBS publication #1829, June 2021. +https://www.cbs.gov.il/he/publications/DocLib/2021/seker_hevrati19_1829/h_print.pdf. Note that this figure relates +to the adult population; the data is based on a CBS survey rather than census figures (such surveys are conducted +annually to supplement census data). The report cites 10% of Jewish adults who self-identify as Haredi and 11% who are +national religious, for a total 21%. The Jewish population is 78% of Israel’s adult population, hence the religious groups +mentioned represent just over 16% of the total adult population. + +9 See page 7: +https://www.pcpsr.org/sites/default/files/Table%20of%20findings_English%20Joint%20Poll%20%20Oct%202020 11 - split is appropriate and fair, and to explore what is needed to incentivise song -writing as part of wider policy interventions on this split and other measures, -for example those relating to the copyright framework and how music -streaming licensing rates are set. - -The legal arrangements between major labels and music streaming -services are complex but they do not appear to be significantly -hampering competition and innovation - -40. Major labels rely on music streaming services to distribute their music, - -and streaming services cannot meet consumers’ needs without obtaining -licences to the large catalogue of each major record label and publisher. -Accordingly, music streaming services must negotiate deals with labels -and publishers to access music content. These deals can be exceedingly -complex and will cover financials and other terms. Our market study -uncovered a number of clauses that could plausibly raise competition -concerns. For example a number of agreements contained non- -discrimination clauses which act to prevent the music streaming service -from favouring music content based on price, for example, by giving -more prominence to cheaper music. - -41. However, given the current ‘full catalogue’ business model of music streaming - -– consumers expect to access every major’s repertoire on each streaming -service – there is no credible alternative to each major’s catalogue. Taking -this into account, our view is that the nature of competition between record -companies to supply music to music streaming services is weak but would -remain weak even absent the combined effect of the contractual clauses we -identified as being potentially problematic. Whilst a slight strengthening of -competition might result from the removal of these clauses (individually or in -combination), it is not clear any improvement would be more than marginal. - -42. - -Innovation is intrinsic to a healthy, competitive market and we therefore take -seriously any suggestion that innovation has been hindered. We have -therefore also assessed the impact of contractual clauses on how music -services compete with each other in terms of innovation. To introduce -innovations or changes to services, the music streaming services typically -need to agree with the majors to amend existing contracts, which we heard -can be a long process which may slow the pace of innovation. - -43. We found examples of substantial innovation by music streaming services, -both in terms of the services, such as the introduction of high-quality audio, -and in the price plans available. But we were also given a few examples of -innovations that were slow to market because of the complex negotiations + Conclusions and Recommendations + +We are all products of our environment, and the conditions and events that mark a person’s youth can often +play an outsized role in their attitudes and perceptions throughout their lives. After three decades of failed +diplomacy, and within a context of repeated wars between Israel and Hamas-led Gaza; settlement expansion; +terrorist attacks; movement and access restrictions; populism; racism and political dysfunction: it is sadly not +unexpected that many of the attitudes uncovered in this poll are cause for serious concern. The Israelis and +Palestinians of this generation, born after the collapse of the Oslo Accords and into the violence of the +Second Intifada and its aftermath of profound separation, are the victims of political decisions and diplomatic +failures that they had no part in. Yet they could also still be the beneficiaries of smart policy decisions taken +now, with the sense of urgency and focus that many of these results demand. + +The current general hardline environment bodes poorly for the success of diplomatic attempts at conflict +resolution that do not take account of this reality. The overwhelming denial of the legitimacy of the other ‘s +connection to the land and to the validity of their very identity should alarm all those concerned with a more +just and peaceful future for both peoples. But meaningful portions of each population hold attitudes +conducive to peacemaking in the future. Nearly half of Palestinians and half of all Israelis believe +that there is a political solution worth striving for and avoid the conclusion that each side must +simply advance its own interest. + +Over half of Israelis and forty percent of Palestinians believe joint efforts to advance peace are very +or somewhat effective, and only a minority on both sides – one-quarter of Israelis and 29% of +Palestinians – believe that cross community work is not legitimate. This opens an opportunity for +policymakers with the political will to address this conflict, allowing tools that have been proven10 to be +effective at ameliorating some of the most worrying ideas and attitudes in this poll to be exploited at a scale +that can have a meaningful impact on a majority of the region’s young people. This is not a substitute for a +diplomatic and political horizon, which is not only the best but also the only mechanism which can fully +address the attitudinal crisis that this poll reveals. In fact, it can be a catalyst for such a horizon. It is worth +considering what sort of new political dynamics and fresh ideas might emerge from facilitating +engagement between the two-thirds of Israeli and Palestinian youth who think it legitimate to +engage one another. + +Based on the findings of this poll, several policy recommendations stand out for international and local +political actors who are willing to invest in moving this conflict toward resolution: + +1) Invest Meaningfully and Multilaterally in Peacebuilding + +It is clear that both Israeli and Palestinian youth lack real opportunity to engage one another, and that +significant proportions of both populations are potential participants in such encounters. A long-held +misperception about the Israeli-Palestinian peacebuilding field, and one that has fueled some +skepticism about its impact given the persistence of the conflict, is that it has benefited from massive +amounts of funding over the years. While the U.S. government and the broader international +community have invested in Israeli-Palestinian peacebuilding programs, relative to the scope of the +challenge, these investments have been minimal, uncoordinated across donors, and inconsistent, +falling short of what is needed to enact wide-spread change. + +10 “Expanding the Reach of Impact Evaluations in Peacebuilding: A Retrospective Evaluation of CMM P2P Activities in +Israel/West Bank”: https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00TVV3.pdf 12 - needed to secure licensing agreements. There is a risk that contractual -restrictions may contribute to the slower development of such innovations -than might otherwise be expected or, potentially, preclude innovation -altogether. - -44. While potential competition concerns have been raised with us about the - -effect of agreements between the majors and music streaming services, we -are not persuaded that changing the contractual clauses would significantly -increase innovation. Rather, the problem appears to relate to the need for -music streaming services to agree with multiple rightsholders on what terms -(financial or otherwise) they can use their content, including in new and -innovative ways. It is the sheer volume and complexity of these negotiations -that appear to be the main barrier to even greater innovation. However, these -negotiations appear to be an inherent part of the licensing process – with the -financial terms negotiated depending on the features agreed. - -Competition between music streaming services is currently -delivering good outcomes for consumers, but concerns may arise -in future - -45. - -The music streaming services market is concentrated with a few larger -streaming services such as Spotify, Apple, Amazon, and YouTube (which is -part of Google), alongside a range of other smaller providers. Spotify has the -largest number of monthly active users by some distance, as shown in the -graph below. Music streaming services are popular with consumers and have -grown rapidly – between 2019 and 2021 the number of monthly active users -of music streaming services increased from 32 million to 39 million. Despite -the strong presence of large, well-known firms in the market, and the number -of active users increasing, music streaming services are not making -sustained, excess profits: indeed, our analysis has shown that many services -have low or negative operating margins. + By contrast, in the context of the Northern Ireland conflict the United States, alongside other +governments, created and funded the International Fund for Ireland (IFI) –a precedent to the +recently-passed Nita M. Lowey Middle East Partnership for Peace Act (MEPPA) in the United +States. Beginning a dozen years before the Good Friday Agreement, the IFI invested heavily in both +social and economic advancement projects, encouraging dialogue and reconciliation between +Unionists and Nationalists throughout Ireland. The comparative amount of investment is striking. +For three decades, beginning 12 years before The Good Friday Agreement peace treaty—and paving +the way toward it—the international community spent the equivalent of $44 per capita annually on +peacebuilding priorities in Northern Ireland. By contrast, today in the deeply entrenched Israeli- +Palestinian conflict, the international community spends $1.50 per capita among Israelis and +Palestinians. With the passage of MEPPA there now exists a well-resourced tool that can help take +advantage of such an opportunity. The resources are substantial, but with around 14 million people +living in the region, including some of the youngest demographics in the Middle East, more +investment will reinforce the ability to disrupt the attitudes found in this study. MEPPA has paved +the way for international contributions, and the opportunity to have other international actors, as +well as major private philanthropy, join this effort and provide the scale and long-term investment +that the findings of this poll demand. Such a multilateral strategy, pooling of resources and +coordinating of joint strategy should be urgently encouraged, taking advantage of the interest +apparent in the US, UK and EU, alongside possible engagement from Arab actors in the context of +the Abraham Accords and other normalization agreements. + +2) Revive the Trilateral Commission on Incitement + +The Trilateral Commission on Incitement was formed as part of the Wye River Agreement between +Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization in October 1998, under Prime Minister Benjamin +Netanyahu. Its members were experts appointed by the government of Israel, the Palestinian +Authority and the United States, and it met every two months, until the outbreak of the Second +Intifada, in order to discuss issues of incitement. This commission should be revived and +reconstituted, with a particular focus on youth and should include international mediators and +independent experts, with renewed governance language that can ensure that rather than being used +as a stage for denunciations of either party’s policies, it is focused on good faith efforts to disrupt +incitement and radicalization among both Israeli and Palestinian youth. + +3) Hone in on Practical Confidence Building Measures (CBMs) + +One of the more positive findings in this survey is that when youth were presented with a list of +actions that might “convince them that the other side is genuinely committed to negotiations, +therefore allowing an opening towards the same direction,” the most popular choices were eminently +practical steps, even in the current political environment. For Palestinians, the most popular option +was greater freedom of movement. For Israelis, it was a good faith effort to review and reform +Palestinian textbooks. That such politically viable steps were favored over more difficult-to- +implement policies such as freezing settlements or recognizing Israel as a Jewish state is notable. And +while they should not be pursued as a substitute for addressing more complex but vital conflict +drivers, efforts should be made by international actors to encourage the implementation of CBMs +that address the concerns of youth, as well as effective communication of those CBMs and their +rationale – as well as their reception – among and between youth constituencies on either side of the +Green Line and in Gaza. + +4) Establish and Legitimize Parallel Youth Parliaments + +The survey reveals a significant level of frustration and disassociation with regards to political leaders +and institutions. With Palestinian elections repeatedly cancelled or postponed, and the political +volatility in Israel that led to four elections in two years, this is not a surprising finding. Alongside 13 - Share of UK Monthly Active Users by music streaming service in -December 2021, excluding YouTube’s UUC platform - -Source: CMA analysis of data from music streaming services.7 - -46. We have heard consistently that consumers demand access to a full - -catalogue of music. The result is that the main music streaming services -effectively offer the same music content to consumers. Competition between -the services, therefore, anchors around offering the best experience to -consumers through good design, personalised playlists, and high-quality -audio content, as well as through pricing plans. These services also now -compete with one another by offering non-music content, such as podcasts. - -47. - -For consumers, the monthly price of music -streaming services is either free (ad-funded) or -falling in real terms because the price of -individual subscriptions has remained stable and -not kept pace with inflation. Most services offer a -range of price plans, including family and student -plans, as well as free ad-funded tiers. Streaming -services are also frequently bundled with other - -7 This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. Monthly Active User shares only account for Spotify, YouTube -Music, Apple, Amazon, Deezer, Soundcloud and Tidal which have a combined streaming share of over 99% -according to CMA analysis of data provided by Official Charts. YouTube Music users include YouTube Music -premium Monthly Active Viewers and YouTube Music ad-funded Daily Active Viewers, meaning this figure will -provide an underestimation of YouTube Music’s actual users. These figures are provided in a 5% range where -the figure is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the -ranges have been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints -does not equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of -the midpoints. + efforts to address macro-level democratic deficits and the absence of democratic processes, youth +Parliaments, such as the type modeled in the European Union, could be an effective model for +connecting disenfranchised young Israelis and Palestinians to the political process, giving them a +voice and sense of agency in their communities. Further, connecting those institutions to each other +– and perhaps to parallel entities in the wider region and around the world – would help to create +greater connection between, and awareness of, each other’s societies and beyond to the global +community. + +5) Leverage Media as a Tool + +Media can drive the public discourse as much as it reflects it. As the polling and focus group data +affirm, there is scant faith on the part of Israeli and Palestinian youth that the other is a partner for +peace; minimal interaction between the two sides to challenge that skepticism; and yet strong +evidence to suggest that greater exposure to the other side could impact attitudes in a way that +unlocks space for constructive engagement. We also know that in a “plugged-in” social media +environment, consumers tend to be captive to their own echo chambers and silos, missing +opportunities to be exposed to views that may challenge static attitudes. As such, there should be a +sustained strategy aimed at harnessing social and conventional media platforms that have a high +degree of engagement with younger audiences. Large numbers of Israeli and Palestinian youth will +continue to have little to no contact with each other. Media can function as a tool to break this lack +of contact and awareness and can serve as a steppingstone toward more meaningful engagement. +Furthermore, the lack of awareness that both Palestinian and Israeli focus group participants +conveyed regarding peacebuilding programs could be disrupted if those same programs were +amplified significantly via social media, so that every young Israeli and Palestinian was at least aware +that there was an opportunity to meet their counterparts from the other side, and to work together to +bridge, as this survey shows, the very significant gaps that exist in their understanding of each other +and the conflict between them. + +6) Invest in Further Research on Youth Attitudes + +This report’s findings are complex, full of contradictions and not conclusive – a snapshot of a few +particular groups’ attitudes at a particular time. Results should be examined within the broader +complex context from which they derive and concerned stakeholders should use this data as +complementary to other research about the contextual factors that may be driving the responses. + +Much more work is needed to understand these groups. While Israelis and Palestinians are frequently +polled, the youth demographics targeted in this research are surveyed only occasionally. Public +opinion – like the societies it represents – is dynamic. Public attitudes respond to positive +developments in the political and diplomatic context and can often shift attitudes in response to +potential confidence-building measures by the other side. Those working to prepare the ground for +future diplomatic and political efforts at peacemaking would benefit from greater understanding of +the rising generation’s opinions and worldviews, as well as bottom-up approaches that may help top- +down efforts find traction. A regular youth poll could track trends rather than just capturing a +moment in time. Further, using a similar approach with participants and beneficiaries of some of the +interventions suggested above could also measure how peacebuilding programs and confidence +building measures impact the attitudes of both Israeli and Palestinian youth. 14 - services, such as mobile phone subscriptions, and accessed via a range of -devices, including smart speakers. - -48. Recorded music is now also costing consumers less overall compared to - -when CDs and other physical formats were more popular, as indicated by UK -recorded music revenues falling by around 40% from £1.9 billion in 2001 to -£1.1 billion in 2021 in real terms. - -49. - -In a market that is expanding, music streaming services mainly compete for -new consumers, rather than encouraging existing customers to switch to their -streaming services. However, music streaming services with ad-funded plans -do actively seek to get customers to upgrade to a paid-for service. - -50. Our analysis shows that consumers cancel their service at above 4% a month -for the major streaming services. Cancellation might occur because free trials -are coming to an end, the user is switching to another service, or because the -user is no longer using any streaming service. The current data on why -consumers may cancel their services is limited, but it suggests that the most -cited reasons are consumers not being able to afford the service or not using -it enough.8 - -51. Switching between music streaming services might be challenging if - -consumers are concerned that they will lose access to their favourite playlists. -There are some nascent music data portability services that support -switching, but demand for them is currently low. Low switching rates are not -necessarily a dynamic that causes immediate concern - for example, in a -growing market. However, as the number of new premium users to compete -for declines in future, there is a risk that prices for music streaming services -will rise significantly for consumers or there may be a deterioration in the -quality of services, if there isn’t a significant threat of switching. Therefore, as -the market reaches maturity we would be concerned if we did not see more -vigorous competition between streaming services (eg through enhanced -efforts to make it seamless for consumers to switch and port their playlists or -musical preferences). Higher rates of switching would imply consumers -exercising choice (and hence competition), although the lack of switching by -itself is not conclusive evidence of a lack of competition. - -52. With more music available, tools that help consumers - -discover new music are more important. Streaming services -compete in bringing music to consumers’ attention and -promoting new artists and songs. We have found that while - -8 This should be treated with caution, however, as only a small proportion of users who cancel respond to the -cancellation survey used to collect this data. - -15 - - the majority of tracks listed on the top new music discovery playlists are -licensed by the majors, the proportion is lower than the majors’ combined -share of total streams. This suggests that artists that are not signed to a major -do have reasonable opportunities to reach new listeners via discovery -playlists and more generally the streaming services have told us that they -design their music recommendation systems with a focus on listener -engagement and user satisfaction. - -53. Overall, whilst music streaming services are currently delivering good - -outcomes for consumers, it is imperative for a sustainable and vibrant market -that services can effectively compete with one another, and we would have -concerns in future if we saw a reduction in competition – for example, if -majors sought commitments from streaming platforms to exclude competitors -(large or small) from discovery or search elements of their service. - -There is a ‘value gap’ between what YouTube and other music -streaming providers pay to rightsholders but it currently amounts -to less than 0.5% of UK recorded music revenues - -54. UUC platforms allow consumers to access music content uploaded by users, - -artists and labels for free (but often with ads), in some cases coupled with -other content such as entertainment videos. These services differ from music -streaming services because any user can upload content, which may include -copyrighted material which they may or may not have permission to share. -Sometimes this content can appear on these platforms before a licence has -been agreed with rightsholders. - -55. UUC platforms have some protection in law through a ‘safe harbour’ provision -which limits the liability they have for hosting illegal content uploaded by users -in some circumstances. However, once they become aware that content is -available without permission from rightsholders, they must remove it or, as is - -16 - - more often the case, allow the rightsholder to grant permission and monetise -the content, for example by sharing ad revenues. - -56. A range of music companies, artists and songwriters have been concerned - -that the asymmetry in the legal regime may result in a loss of revenues (often -called the ‘value gap’) for the music industry. In particular, there is concern -that the safe harbour provisions give UUC platforms greater bargaining power -over rightsholders, leading to rightsholders having to agree worse terms than -they would otherwise. - -57. - -To understand whether a value gap exists and, if so, how significant the gap -is, we have compared the amount that YouTube, as the largest UUC platform, -pays out to rightsholders in comparison to Spotify’s ad-funded service. In -2017, YouTube’s ‘value gap’ in the UK – that is how much more it would have -paid to rightsholders as a proportion of revenue from music content if it had -paid them at the same rate as Spotify’s ad-funded service – was over 20 -percentage points. However, this ‘gap’ has closed over time and in 2021 had -fallen to significantly less than 5 percentage points, or less than £5 million. To -put this figure into context, it is less than 0.5% of the £1,115 million total UK -recorded music revenues in 2021. The evidence therefore suggests that the -extent of YouTube’s ‘value gap’ has decreased in recent years. - -58. Whilst YouTube is the largest UUC service and therefore very important in the -market, there are other UUC platforms that take a different approach to -licensing and may have less effective content management systems. - -59. Some newer UUC platforms incorporate music into their offering, but do not -offer a full streaming service. Examples of this include TikTok, a short-form -video-sharing service, and Twitch, a longer-form live streaming service. These -platforms, alongside YouTube, provide innovative services for consumers and -potential opportunities for creators and music companies to earn further -revenues in addition to those generated by music streaming. - -60. - -The way these services use music differs from traditional music streaming -services: they may use snippets of recordings or only offer specific genres of -music, rather than a full catalogue on an on-demand basis. Therefore, it may -not always be the case that the rates payable for these services will be -comparable to music streaming services, which is an important factor when -assessing if there is a ‘value gap’ between the two offerings. That said, we -have heard examples of refusal to license or difficulties in agreeing licences -that may indicate that safe harbour is among the factors in some commercial -negotiations. We also consider that the quality of content management -systems is important in ensuring that rightsholders are remunerated fairly for -music content uploaded onto UUC platforms, and we have heard some newer - -17 - - emerging platforms may lag behind the more established platforms in this -regard. - -61. Meanwhile, since the exit of the UK from the EU, European legislation - -relevant to UUC has been amended such that it now requires UUC services -using copyrighted content to make their ‘best efforts’ to seek permission to -use that content. We note that the DCMS and IPO are monitoring the practical -impact of these legislative changes on UUC services in the UK. We -encourage them to take account of our broader findings in relation to UUC -services when considering if legislative changes are required in the UK. - -The market is evolving and innovating, but it is vital that it -continues to deliver good outcomes for consumers - -62. - -The music streaming market is changing rapidly, and further technological -advances in the years to come may spark further changes to the way we -listen to music. Our analysis shows that the market is on balance delivering -good outcomes for consumers. However, we would have concerns and may -intervene in the future if aspects of the market change in ways that harm -consumers’ interests. For example, factors that may give rise to concerns -could include: - -(a) if future mergers or acquisitions affect the bargaining power of either - -music companies or music streaming services, which may in turn lead to -worse outcomes for consumers with the CMA likely to pay particularly -close attention to any such merger activity and to investigate whether it -could lead to a substantial lessening of competition. - -(b) shifts in the way consumers access streaming services that influence their - -listening behaviour, for example if there is continued growth in the use of -smart speakers, and whether this could exacerbate barriers to expansion -of streaming services that do not have their own smart speaker -ecosystem. - -(c) greater use of playlists, autoplay and recommendations for music - -discovery and consumption could be a cause of uncertainty and concern -for consumers and artists if their operation, including any underlying -algorithms, is not fair and transparent. - -(d) how difficult it is to switch between music streaming services and whether -this limits the strength of competition between those services when the -market is no longer growing. - -(e) if the level of innovation on the part of streaming services were to - -decrease; or if innovations that would benefit consumers were to be -prohibited by music companies; or if consumers were to be -disadvantaged in other ways, including through significantly higher prices. - -18 - diff --git a/q226/random_k4/random_3.md b/q226/random_k4/random_3.md index 314f7476a81f8217ad5531402f8f3255b7f5dbd2..e2f4690064e5381fbfbef3012bd5ce5c92984a53 100644 --- a/q226/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q226/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,228 +1,638 @@ -Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap - -Parte 1 – Introduzione ed esempi - -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 - - OpenStreetMap - -• OpenStreetMap è un progetto che crea e -fornisce dati cartografici liberi e gratuiti a -chiunque ne abbia bisogno. - -• Il progetto è stato avviato perché la maggior - -parte delle mappe che si credono liberamente -utilizzabili, hanno invece restrizioni legali o -tecniche al loro utilizzo e ciò ne impedisce -l'uso per scopi produttivi, creativi o inattesi. - - Esempio base di ciclo di utilizzo - -Programma -di editing (JOSM) - -Database - -Mappatore - -Sentiero - -Escursionisti - -Mappa o -servizio -online - -GPS - - La mappa - -http://www.openstreetmap.org - - Altre mappe: cyclemap - -http://www.opencyclemap.org - - Altre mappe: 4umaps -http://www.4umaps.eu - - Altre mappe: webmapp.it - -http://www.webmapp.it - - Includere la mappa in un sito internet - -Librerie: Leaflet, Openlayers - - Applicazioni Smartphone - -Navit - -OsmAnd - -OruxMaps - -ViewRanger - -http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software/Mobile (in inglese) - - Applicazioni Smartphone - -Esempio possibilità di routing -su sentieri e forestali - - GPS Garmin - -• Alcuni siti con istruzioni e dati - -– http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:OSM_Map_On - -_Garmin - -– http://cuneotrekking.com/2013/03/24/openstreetma -p-come-caricare-mappe-gratuite-sul-garmin-etrex-30/ - -– https://sites.google.com/site/stefanodroghetti/nuvi -– http://www.mtb- - -forum.it/community/forum/showthread.php?p=3454 -010 - -– http://openmtbmap.org/it/tutorials/enbeginners- - -starting-guide-dewo-beginnen-tutorial/ - - Trovare un percorso tra due città - -http://www.yournavigation.org/ - - Creare una rotta su ViewRanger.com - -http://my.viewranger.com/ - - Scaricare una mappa con Mobile Atlas Creator - -http://mobac.sourceforge.net/ - - Scaricare i dati con overpass-turbo.eu - -http://overpass-turbo.eu/ - - Disegnare la propria mappa con Maperitive - -http://maperitive.net/ - - Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap - -Parte 2 – Introduzione a JOSM - -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 - - Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap - -Parte 3 - Documentazione - -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 - - WIKI internazionale - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org - - WIKI italiano - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Main_Page - - Map Features (come “etichettare” gli -oggetti della mappa) - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Map_Features - - WIKI trentino - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino - - Particolarità trentine - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino/Strade_forestali - -_provinciali - -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino/Sentieri - - Mailing list italiana - -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/ - - Mailing list trentina - -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it-trentino -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it-trentino/ - - Guide - -• http://learnosm.org/it/ -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Beginners%27_Guide -• http://svn.openstreetmap.org/misc/pr_material/italy_minigui - -da/tutorial.pdf - -• http://svn.openstreetmap.org/misc/pr_material/italy_minigui - -da/book.pdf - - Dati liberi in Trentino - -• http://dati.trentino.it -• http://www2.comune.rovereto.tn.it/servizionline/extra/open - -data/ - -• http://www.sat.tn.it/default.aspx?fn=loadarea&idarea=450 - - Trentino – Cosa c’è da fare - -Importazione strade forestali PAT mancanti - -• -• Completare rete sentieri SAT -• Mappatura di dettaglio in centri minori e periferici (edifici ma - -anche nomi vie) -Importazione toponimi PAT - -• -• Numeri civici ?? -• …. - - Link utili da usare durante il Workshop - -Pagina di registrazione su OSM - -https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/new - -Installazione JOSM - -http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:JOSM#Inst -allazione - -File preimpostazioni JOSM utile per mappare -forestali e sentieri SAT - -https://www.dropbox.com/s/hjoq9nf3zx7mfdz/Pr -esets_TNTracks-preset.xml - -File gpx di forestali trentine da importare - -File con tutte le forestali trentine - -https://www.dropbox.com/sh/kd616xtq47ct5wd/ -gFnS9iVodO - -https://www.dropbox.com/s/g9zq64gwis9ldqn/for -estali_tn.zip - +Electronic Arts Reports Q4 and Full Year FY19 Financial Results +REDWOOD CITY, CA – May 7, 2019 – Electronic Arts Inc. (NASDAQ: EA) today announced +preliminary financial results for its fourth fiscal quarter and fiscal year ended March 31, 2019. +News and ongoing updates regarding EA and its games are available on EA’s blog at +www.ea.com/news. +“FY20 will be a year of continued growth for our industry, and we’re excited to bring more great +entertainment to the expanding audience around the world,” said CEO Andrew Wilson. “Players are +engaging with games in more ways than ever before. We’re committed to meeting them where they +are with a broad portfolio of amazing new games and live services, choice of engagement models +including free-to-play and subscriptions, and new opportunities to play, compete and watch.” +“We ended our fiscal year with strong growth, driven by our live services business which continued to +provide a very large, stable and profitable source of net bookings,” said COO and CFO Blake +Jorgensen. “Looking ahead, we will bring games to an extraordinary variety of players in fiscal 2020 +and deliver on our commitment to players with deep live services content for Ultimate Team, Apex +Legends, The Sims 4, Anthem and Battlefield V.” +Selected Operating Highlights and Metrics +• Digital net bookings* for the trailing twelve months was $3.722 billion, up 5% year-over-year +and represents 75% of total net bookings. +• During the quarter, launched two new original IP titles, Apex LegendsTM and AnthemTM. +• During the quarter, launched Firestorm battle royale in Battlefield TM V, the biggest +BattlefieldTM live service event ever. +• In FY19, more than 45 million unique players engaged in FIFA 19 and FIFA 18 on console +and PC. +• In FY19, active players in The Sims TM 4 increased by 35% year-over-year. +* Net bookings is defined as the net amount of products and services sold digitally or sold-in +physically in the period. Net bookings is calculated by adding total net revenue to the change in +deferred net revenue for online-enabled games and, for periods after the fourth quarter of fiscal 2018, +mobile platform fees. +Selected Financial Highlights and Metrics +All financial measures are presented on a GAAP basis. +• Net cash from operating activities was $599 million for the quarter and $1.547 billion for the +trailing twelve months. +• EA repurchased 3.2 million shares for $301 million during the quarter and 11.0 million shares +for $1.192 billion during the trailing twelve months. +Impact of Recently Adopted Accounting Standard +At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606), +Revenue from Contracts with Customers. For more information about the adoption of Topic 606, +please refer to the Investor Accounting FAQ on our IR website. Financial data for periods prior to April +1, 2018 has not been restated. + +Quarterly Financial Highlights +Three Months Ended +March 31, +| | | 2019 | 2018 | | | +| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | +(in $ millions, except per share amounts) +| Digital net revenue | | 1,065 | 1,102 | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | +| Packaged goods and other net revenue | | 173 | 480 | | | +| Total net revenue | | 1,238 | 1,582 | | | + +| Net income | | 209 | 607 | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +| Diluted earnings per share | | 0.69 | 1.95 | | | + +| Operating cash flow | | 599 | 615 | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +| Value of shares repurchased | | 301 | 148 | | | +| Number of shares repurchased | | 3.2 | 1.2 | | | + +The following GAAP-based financial data and tax rate of 18% was used internally by company +management to adjust its fiscal 2019 GAAP results in order to assess EA’s operating results: + +Three Months Ended March 31, 2019 +GAAP-Based Financial Data +Change in +deferred +net revenue +| | Statement | Acquisition- | (online- | Mobile | | +| --------------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | --------- | ------------ | +| | of | related | enabled | platform | Stock-based | +| (in $ millions) | Operations | expenses | games) | fees | compensation | +Total net revenue 1 ,238 - 1 73 ( 47) - + Cost of revenue 2 76 ( 1) - ( 47) ( 1) +Gross profit 9 62 1 1 73 - 1 + Total operating expenses 7 66 ( 16) - - ( 72) +Operating income 1 96 1 7 1 73 - 7 3 +Interest and other income, net 2 3 - - - - +Income before provision for income taxes 2 19 1 7 1 73 - 7 3 +Number of shares used in computation: +| Diluted | | 301 | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +For more information about the nature of the GAAP-based financial data, please refer to EA’s Form +10-Q for the fiscal quarter ended December 31, 2018. + +2 + +TTM Financial Highlights +Twelve Months Ended +March 31, +| | 2019 | | 2018 | | | | +| --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +(in $ millions, except per share amounts) +| Digital net revenue | | 3,710 | 3,450 | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| Packaged goods and other net revenue | | 1,240 | 1,700 | | | | +| Total net revenue | | 4,950 | 5,150 | | | | + +| Net income | | 1,019 | 1,043* | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ----------------------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| Diluted earnings per share | | 3.33 | 3.34* | | | | +| Operating cash flow | | 1,547 | 1,692 | | | | +| Value of shares repurchased | 1,192 | | 601 | | | | +| Number of shares repurchased | | 11.0 | 5.3 | | | | +*During the twelve months ended March 31, 2018, EA recognized $235 million of incremental income tax +expense, or approximately $0.75 per share, due to the application of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. + +The following GAAP-based financial data and tax rate of 18% was used internally by company +management to adjust its fiscal 2019 GAAP results in order to assess EA’s operating results: + +Twelve Months Ended March 31, 2019 +GAAP-Based Financial Data +Change in +deferred net +revenue +| | Statement | Acquisition- | (online- | Mobile | | | +| --------------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | +| | of | related | enabled | platform | Stock-based | | +| (in $ millions) | Operations | expenses | games) | fees | compensation | | +Total net revenue 4,950 - 182 (188) - + Cost of revenue 1,322 (4) - (188) (4) +Gross profit 3,628 4 182 - 4 + Total operating expenses 2,632 (37) - - (280) +Operating income 996 41 182 - 2 84 +Interest and other income, net 83 - - - - +Income before provision for income taxes 1,079 41 182 - 2 84 +Number of shares used in computation: +| Diluted | 306 | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +For more information about the nature of the GAAP-based financial data, please refer to EA’s Form +10-Q for the fiscal quarter ended December 31, 2018. + +3 + +Operating Metric +The following is a calculation of our total net bookings for the periods presented: +Three Months Ended TTM Ended +March 31, March 31, +2019 2018 2019 2018 +(in $ millions) +Total net revenue 1,238 1,582 4,950 5,150 +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) 173 (327) 182 30 +Mobile platform fees (47) - (188) - +Net bookings 1,364 1,255 4,944 5,180 +Business Outlook as of May 7, 2019 +The following forward-looking statements reflect expectations as of May 7, 2019. Electronic Arts +assumes no obligation to update these statements, except as required by law. Results may be +materially different and are affected by many factors detailed in this release and in EA’s annual and +quarterly SEC filings. +Fiscal Year 2020 Expectations – Ending March 31, 2020 +Financial metrics: +• Net revenue is expected to be approximately $5.375 billion. +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) is expected to be +o +approximately $(125) million. +Mobile platform fees are expected to be approximately $(150) million. +o +• Net income is expected to be approximately $2.595 billion. This includes a one-time tax +benefit of approximately $1.5 billion (see below). +• Diluted earnings per share is expected to be approximately $8.56. This includes a one- +time tax benefit of approximately $5 per share (see below). +• Operating cash flow is expected to be approximately $1.575 billion. +• The Company estimates a share count of 303 million for purposes of calculating fiscal +year 2020 diluted earnings per share. +Subsequent to the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, EA completed an internal transfer of some of its +intellectual property rights to its Swiss subsidiary, where EA’s international business is +headquartered. This transfer will result in a one-time tax benefit of between $1.5 billion and $3.9 +billion, which will be recognized as a deferred tax asset in EA’s consolidated financial statements for +the three months ending June 30, 2019. The recognition of the deferred tax asset will add between $5 +to $13 per share to GAAP EPS and the low end of this range has been reflected above in EA’s +forecast. The forecast of this one-time tax benefit is preliminary and is dependent on the results of +Swiss referendums to be voted on later this month. +Operational metric: +• Net bookings is expected to be approximately $5.100 billion. +In addition, the following outlook for GAAP-based financial data and a long-term tax rate of 18% are +used internally by EA to adjust our GAAP expectations to assess EA’s operating results and plan for +future periods: +4 + +Twelve Months Ending March 31, 2020 +GAAP-Based Financial Data +Change in +deferred net +revenue +Acquisition- (online- +GAAP related enabled Mobile Stock-based +Guidance expenses games) platform fees compensation +(in $ millions) +Digital net revenue 4 ,175 - ( 75) ( 150) - +Packaged goods & other net revenue 1 ,200 - ( 50) - - +Total net revenue 5 ,375 - ( 125) ( 150) - +Cost of revenue 1 ,327 ( 12) - ( 150) ( 2) +Operating expense 2 ,746 ( 23) - - ( 353) +Income before provision for income taxes 1 ,361 3 5 ( 125) - 3 55 +Net income 2 ,595 +Number of shares used in computation: +Diluted shares 3 03 +First Quarter Fiscal Year 2020 Expectations – Ending June 30, 2019 +Financial metrics: +• Net revenue is expected to be approximately $1.130 billion. +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) is expected to be +o +approximately $(405) million. +Mobile platform fees are expected to be approximately $(35) million. +o +• Net income is expected to be approximately $1.765 billion. This includes a one-time tax +benefit of approximately $1.5 billion (see above). +• Diluted earnings per share is expected to be approximately $5.84. This includes a one- +time tax benefit of approximately $5 per share (see above). +• The Company estimates a share count of 302 million for purposes of calculating first +quarter fiscal year 2020 diluted earnings per share. Should the first quarter be a loss, the +Company will use the basic share count of 299 million for purposes of calculating first +quarter fiscal year 2020 earnings per share. +Operational metric: +• Net bookings is expected to be approximately $690 million. +In addition, the following outlook for GAAP-based financial data and a long-term tax rate of 18% are +used internally by EA to adjust our GAAP expectations to assess EA’s operating results and plan for +future periods: +5 + +Three Months Ending June 30, 2019 +GAAP-Based Financial Data +Change in +deferred net +revenue +Acquisition- (online- Mobile +GAAP related enabled platform Stock-based +Guidance expenses games) fees compensation +(in $ millions) +Total net revenue 1 ,130 - ( 405) ( 35) - +Cost of revenue 1 88 ( 2) - ( 35) - +Operating expense 6 50 ( 5) - - ( 70) +Income before provision for income taxes 3 10 7 ( 405) - 7 0 +Net income 1 ,765 +Number of shares used in computation: +Diluted shares 3 02 +For more information about the nature of the GAAP-based financial data, please refer to EA’s Form +10-Q for the fiscal quarter ended December 31, 2018. +Conference Call and Supporting Documents +Electronic Arts will host a conference call on Tuesday, May 7, 2019 at 2:00 pm PT (5:00 pm ET) to +review its results for the fiscal fourth quarter and fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 and its outlook for +the future. During the course of the call, Electronic Arts may disclose material developments affecting +its business and/or financial performance. Listeners may access the conference call live through the +following dial-in number (866) 393-4306 (domestic) or (734) 385-2616 (international), using the +Conference ID 2997759 or via webcast at EA’s IR Website at http://ir.ea.com. +EA has posted a slide presentation, a financial model of EA’s historical results and guidance, and an +Investor Accounting FAQ on EA’s IR Website. After the conference call, EA will also post the +prepared remarks and a transcript from the conference call on EA’s IR Website. +A dial-in replay of the conference call will be available until May 21, 2019 at (855) 859-2056 +(domestic) or (404) 537-3406 (international) using pin code 2997759. An audio webcast replay of the +conference call will be available for one year on EA’s IR Website. +Forward-Looking Statements +Some statements set forth in this release, including the information relating to EA’s fiscal 2020 +expectations under the heading “Business Outlook as of May 7, 2019,” and other information +regarding EA's fiscal 2020 expectations contain forward-looking statements that are subject to +change. Statements including words such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “expect,” “intend,” “estimate”, +“plan”, “predict”, “seek”, “goal”, “will”, “may”, “likely”, “should”, “could” (and the negative of any of +these terms), “future” and similar expressions also identify forward-looking statements. These +forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and reflect management’s +current expectations. Our actual results could differ materially from those discussed in the forward- +looking statements. +6 + +Some of the factors which could cause the Company’s results to differ materially from its expectations +include the following: sales of the Company’s products and services; the Company’s ability to develop +and support digital products and services, including managing online security and privacy; outages of +our products, services or technological infrastructure; the Company’s ability to manage expenses; the +competition in the interactive entertainment industry; governmental regulations; the effectiveness of +the Company’s sales and marketing programs; timely development and release of the Company’s +products and services; the Company’s ability to realize the anticipated benefits of acquisitions; the +consumer demand for, and the availability of an adequate supply of console hardware units; the +Company’s ability to predict consumer preferences among competing platforms; the Company’s +ability to develop and implement new technology; foreign currency exchange rate fluctuations; +general economic conditions; changes in our tax rates or tax laws; and other factors described in Part +II, Item 1A of Electronic Arts’ latest Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q under the heading “Risk Factors”, +as well as in other documents we have filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including +our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. +These forward-looking statements are valid as of May 7, 2019. Electronic Arts assumes no obligation +to revise or update any forward-looking statement for any reason, except as required by law. In +addition, the preliminary financial results set forth in this release are estimates based on information +currently available to Electronic Arts. +While Electronic Arts believes these estimates are meaningful, they could differ from the actual +amounts that Electronic Arts ultimately reports in its Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year +ended March 31, 2019. Electronic Arts assumes no obligation and does not intend to update these +estimates prior to filing its Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019. +About Electronic Arts +Electronic Arts (NASDAQ: EA) is a global leader in digital interactive entertainment. The Company +develops and delivers games, content and online services for Internet-connected consoles, mobile +devices and personal computers. +In fiscal year 2019, EA posted GAAP net revenue of $4.95 billion. Headquartered in Redwood City, +California, EA is recognized for a portfolio of critically acclaimed, high-quality brands such as The +Sims™, Madden NFL, EA SPORTS™ FIFA, Battlefield™, Need for Speed™, Dragon Age™ and +Plants vs. Zombies™. More information about EA is available at www.ea.com/news. +Apex Legends, Anthem, Battlefield, The Sims, EA SPORTS, Need for Speed, Dragon Age, and +Plants vs. Zombies are trademarks of Electronic Arts Inc. John Madden, NFL and FIFA are the +property of their respective owners and used with permission. +For additional information, please contact: +Chris Evenden John Reseburg +Vice President, Investor Relations Vice President, Corporate Communications +650-628-0255 650-628-3601 +cevenden@ea.com jreseburg@ea.com +7 + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations +(in $ millions, except per share data) +| | Three Months Ended | | Twelve Months Ended | | +| --- | ------------------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | +| | March 31, | | March 31, | | +| | 2019 1 | | 2019 1 | | +| | | 2018 | 2018 | | +Net revenue +| Product | 216 | 757 | 1,593 | 2,586 | +| ----------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| Service and other | 1,022 | 825 | 3,357 | 2,564 | +| Total net revenue | 1,238 | 1,582 | 4,950 | 5,150 | +Cost of revenue +| Product | 52 | 106 | 517 | 822 | +| --------------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| Service and other | 224 | 127 | 805 | 455 | +| Total cost of revenue | 276 | 233 | 1,322 | 1,277 | +| Gross profit | 962 | 1,349 | 3,628 | 3,873 | +Operating expenses: +| Research and development | 398 | 335 | 1,433 | 1,320 | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | +| Marketing and sales | 229 | 130 | 702 | 641 | +| General and administrative | 123 | 126 | 460 | 469 | +| Acquisition-related contingent consideration | 11 | — | 14 | — | +| Amortization of intangibles | 5 | 5 | 23 | 9 | +| Total operating expenses | 766 | 596 | 2,632 | 2,439 | +| Operating income | 196 | 753 | 996 | 1,434 | +| Interest and other income (expense), net | 23 | 1 | 83 | 15 | +| Income before provision for income taxes | 219 | 754 | 1,079 | 1,449 | +| Provision for income taxes | 10 | 147 | 60 | 406 | +| Net income | 209 | 607 | 1,019 | 1,043 | +Earnings per share +| Basic | 0.70 | 1.98 | 3.36 | 3.39 | +| ------- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +| Diluted | 0.69 | 1.95 | 3.33 | 3.34 | +Number of shares used in computation +| Basic | 299 | 307 | 303 | 308 | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Diluted | 301 | 311 | 306 | 312 | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606), Revenue from Contracts with Customers. Topic 606 +significantly changes how EA recognizes and reports revenue and diluted earnings per share. For more information about the adoption of Topic 606, including +information with respect to mobile platform fees, please refer to the Investor Accounting FAQ on our IR website. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, +2018 has not been restated. + +Results (in $ millions, except per share data) +The following table reports the variance of the actuals versus our guidance provided on February 5, 2019 for the three months ended March +31, 2019 plus a comparison to the actuals for the three months ended March 31, 2018. +Three Months Ended March 31, +| | 2019 1 | | 2019 1 | | +| --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | +2018 +| | Guidance | Variance | Actuals | Actuals | +| --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | +Net revenue +| Net revenue | 1,163 | 75 | 1,238 | 1,582 | +| ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | +GAAP-based financial data +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) 56 117 173 (327) +| Mobile platform fees | (49) | 2 | (47) | — | +| -------------------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | +Cost of revenue +| Cost of revenue | 265 | 11 | 276 | 233 | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | — | (1) | (1) | (1) | +| ---------------------------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | +| Stock-based compensation | — | (1) | (1) | (1) | +| Mobile platform fees | (49) | 2 | (47) | — | +Operating expenses +| Operating expenses | 715 | 51 | 766 | 596 | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | (6) | (10) | (16) | (5) | +| ---------------------------- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +| Stock-based compensation | (76) | 4 | (72) | (68) | +Income before tax +| Income before tax | 195 | 24 | 219 | 754 | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | 6 | 11 | 17 | 6 | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) 56 117 173 (327) +| Mobile platform fees | — | — | — | — | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Stock-based compensation | 76 | (3) | 73 | 69 | +| Tax rate used for management reporting | 18% | | 18% | 21% | +Earnings per share +| Basic | 0.56 | 0.14 | 0.70 | 1.98 | +| ------- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +| Diluted | 0.56 | 0.13 | 0.69 | 1.95 | +Number of shares +| Basic | 301 | (2) | 299 | 307 | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Diluted | 303 | (2) | 301 | 311 | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606), Revenue from Contracts with Customers. Topic 606 +significantly changes how EA recognizes and reports revenue and diluted earnings per share. For more information about the adoption of Topic 606, including +information with respect to mobile platform fees, please refer to the Investor Accounting FAQ on our IR website. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, +2018 has not been restated. + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets +(in $ millions) +March 31, 20191 March 31, 20182 +ASSETS +Current assets: +| Cash and cash equivalents | 4,708 | 4,258 | +| ------------------------- | ----- | ----- | +| Short-term investments | 737 | 1,073 | +Receivables, net of allowances of $7 and $165, respectively 623 385 +| Other current assets | 313 | 288 | +| ------------------------------------ | ----- | ----- | +| Total current assets | 6,381 | 6,004 | +| Property and equipment, net | 448 | 453 | +| Goodwill | 1,892 | 1,883 | +| Acquisition-related intangibles, net | 87 | 71 | +| Deferred income taxes, net | 35 | 84 | +| Other assets | 114 | 89 | +| TOTAL ASSETS | 8,957 | 8,584 | +LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY +Current liabilities: +| Accounts payable | 113 | 48 | +| ------------------------------------------- | ----- | ----- | +| Accrued and other current liabilities | 1,052 | 821 | +| Deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) | 1,100 | 1,622 | +| Total current liabilities | 2,265 | 2,491 | +| Senior notes, net | 994 | 992 | +| Income tax obligations | 233 | 250 | +| Deferred income taxes, net | 2 | 1 | +| Other liabilities | 132 | 255 | +| Total liabilities | 3,626 | 3,989 | +Stockholders’ equity: +| Common stock | 3 | 3 | +| ------------------------------------------ | ----- | ----- | +| Additional paid-in capital | — | 657 | +| Retained earnings | 5,358 | 4,062 | +| Accumulated other comprehensive loss | (30) | (127) | +| Total stockholders’ equity | 5,331 | 4,595 | +| TOTAL LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY | 8,957 | 8,584 | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606) Revenue from Contracts with Customers. EA’s FY19 +Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheet reflects the effect of the adoption as of April 1, 2018, which had an impact on the following: receivables, net +of allowances, accrued and other current liabilities, deferred net revenue (online-enabled games), deferred income taxes, net, retained earnings and accumulated +other comprehensive loss. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, 2018 has not been restated. + 2Derived from audited consolidated financial statements. + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows +(in $ millions) +| | | Three Months Ended | | Twelve Months | | +| --- | --- | ------------------ | ---- | --------------- | ---- | +| | | March 31, | | Ended March 31, | | +| | | 2019 | 2018 | 2019 | 2018 | +OPERATING ACTIVITIES +| Net income | | 209 | 607 | 1,019 | 1,043 | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | +Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by +operating activities: +| | Depreciation, amortization and accretion | 37 | 39 | 145 | 136 | +| --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Acquisition-related contingent consideration | 14 | — | 14 | — | +| | Stock-based compensation | 73 | 69 | 284 | 242 | +Change in assets and liabilities +| | Receivables, net | 183 | 502 | (88) | (25) | +| --- | ------------------------------------------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ---- | +| | Other assets | (65) | (69) | (24) | 10 | +| | Accounts payable | 24 | (60) | 59 | (44) | +| | Accrued and other liabilities | (120) | (222) | 3 | 43 | +| | Deferred income taxes, net | 73 | 74 | (16) | 204 | +| | Deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) | 171 | (325) | 151 | 83 | +Net cash provided by operating activities 599 615 1,547 1,692 +INVESTING ACTIVITIES +| Capital expenditures | | (35) | (20) | (119) | (107) | +| -------------------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----- | ----- | +Proceeds from maturities and sales of short-term investments 733 1,510 1,688 3,166 +Purchase of short-term investments (198) (275) (1,342) (2,287) +| Acquisitions, net of cash acquired | | — | — | (58) | (150) | +| ---------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ----- | +| | Net cash provided by investing activities | 500 | 1,215 | 169 | 622 | +FINANCING ACTIVITIES +| Proceeds from issuance of common stock | | 25 | 21 | 61 | 78 | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Cash paid to taxing authorities for shares withheld from employees (6) (8) (122) (120) +Repurchase and retirement of common stock (301) (148) (1,192) (601) +Net cash used in financing activities (282) (135) (1,253) (643) +Effect of foreign exchange on cash and cash equivalents 4 (3) (13) 22 +| Increase in cash and cash equivalents | | 821 | 1,692 | 450 | 1,693 | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| Beginning cash and cash equivalents | | 3,887 | 2,566 | 4,258 | 2,565 | +| Ending cash and cash equivalents | | 4,708 | 4,258 | 4,708 | 4,258 | + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Supplemental Financial Information and Business Metrics +(in $ millions, except per share data) +| | Q4 Q11 | Q21 Q31 | Q41 | YOY % | +| --- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | +| | FY18 FY19 | FY19 FY19 | FY19 | Change | +Net revenue +| Net revenue | 1,582 1,137 | 1,286 1,289 | 1,238 | (22%) | +| ------------ | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | +GAAP-based financial data +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games)3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Mobile platform fees | — (49) | (44) (48) | (47) | | +| -------------------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | --- | +Gross profit +| Gross profit | 1,349 922 | 868 876 | 962 | (29%) | +| ------------ | --------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | 1 1 | 1 1 | 1 | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games)3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Mobile platform fees | — — | — — | — | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | +| Stock-based compensation | 1 1 | 1 1 | 1 | | +| Gross profit (as a % of net revenue) | 85% 81% | 67% 68% | 78% | | +Operating income +| Operating income | 753 300 | 258 242 | 196 | (74%) | +| ---------------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | 6 7 | 9 8 | 17 | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games)3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Stock-based compensation | 69 70 | 66 75 | 73 | | +| ---------------------------------------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | +| Operating income (as a % of net revenue) | 48% 26% | 20% 19% | 16% | | +Net income +| Net income | 607 293 | 255 262 | 209 | (66%) | +| ---------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +GAAP-based financial data +| Acquisition-related expenses | 6 7 | 9 8 | 17 | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games)3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Stock-based compensation | 69 70 | 66 75 | 73 | | +| -------------------------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ----- | +| Tax rate used for management reporting | 21% 18% | 18% 18% | 18% | | +| Net income (as a % of net revenue) | 38% 26% | 20% 20% | 17% | | +| Diluted earnings per share | 1.95 0.95 | 0.83 0.86 | 0.69 | (65%) | +Number of diluted shares used in computation +| Basic | 307 306 | 305 302 | 299 | | +| ------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | +| Diluted | 311 310 | 307 304 | 301 | | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606), Revenue from Contracts with Customers. Topic 606 significantly +changes how EA recognizes and reports revenue and diluted earnings per share. For more information about the adoption of Topic 606, including information with +respect to mobile platform fees, please refer to the Investor Accounting FAQ on our IR website. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, 2018 has not been +restated. +3The change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) in the unaudited condensed consolidated statements of cash flows does not necessarily equal the +change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) in the unaudited condensed consolidated statements of operations primarily due to the impact of +unrecognized gains/losses on cash flow hedges. + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Supplemental Financial Information and Business Metrics +(in $ millions) +YOY +| | Q4 Q11 | Q21 Q31 | Q41 % | +| --- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | +| | FY18 FY19 | FY19 FY19 | FY19 Change | +QUARTERLY NET REVENUE PRESENTATIONS +Net revenue by composition +| Full game downloads | 232 116 | 148 247 | 169 (27%) | +| ------------------------ | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | +| Live services | 698 610 | 412 480 | 714 2% | +| Mobile | 172 231 | 220 181 | 182 6% | +| Total digital | 1,102 957 | 780 908 | 1,065 (3%) | +| Packaged goods and other | 480 180 | 506 381 | 173 (64%) | +| Total net revenue | 1,582 1,137 | 1,286 1,289 | 1,238 (22%) | +| Total digital | 70% 84% | 61% 70% | 86% | +| Packaged goods and other | 30% 16% | 39% 30% | 14% | +| Total net revenue % | 100% 100% | 100% 100% | 100% | +GAAP-based financial data +| Full game downloads | (39) (20) | 9 26 | 44 | +| ------------------------ | ----------- | -------- | --- | +| Live services | (19) (160) | (84) 304 | 131 | +| Mobile | 4 (35) | (24) 9 | — | +| Total digital | (54) (215) | (99) 339 | 175 | +| Packaged goods and other | (273) (124) | 79 29 | (2) | +Total change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) by composition3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Mobile platform fees | — (49) | (44) (48) | (47) | +| -------------------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | +Net revenue by platform +| Console | 1,196 705 | 917 885 | 826 (31%) | +| ----------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | +| PC/Browser | 210 197 | 149 217 | 217 3% | +| Mobile | 173 233 | 220 181 | 190 10% | +| Other | 3 2 | — 6 | 5 67% | +| Total net revenue | 1,582 1,137 | 1,286 1,289 | 1,238 (22%) | +GAAP-based financial data +| Console | (313) (288) | 8 323 | 87 | +| ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | +| PC/Browser | (20) (9) | (4) 33 | 88 | +| Mobile | 5 (42) | (24) 11 | (2) | +| Other | 1 — | — 1 | — | +Total change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) by platform3 (327) (339) (20) 368 173 +| Mobile platform fees | — (49) | (44) (48) | (47) | +| -------------------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606), Revenue from Contracts with Customers. Topic 606 +significantly changes how EA recognizes and reports revenue and diluted earnings per share. For more information about the adoption of Topic 606, including +information with respect to mobile platform fees, please refer to the Investor Accounting FAQ on our IR website. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, +2018 has not been restated. +3The change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) in the unaudited condensed consolidated statements of cash flows does not necessarily equal the +change in deferred net revenue (online-enabled games) in the unaudited condensed consolidated statements of operations primarily due to the impact of +unrecognized gains/losses on cash flow hedges. + +ELECTRONIC ARTS INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES +Unaudited Supplemental Financial Information and Business Metrics +(in $ millions) +| | Q4 Q11 | Q21 Q31 | Q41 YOY % | +| --- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | +| | FY18 FY19 | FY19 FY19 | FY19 Change | +CASH FLOW DATA +| Operating cash flow | 615 120 | (126) 954 | 599 (3%) | +| -------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------- | +| Operating cash flow - TTM | 1,692 1,636 | 1,458 1,563 | 1,547 (9%) | +| Capital expenditures | 20 32 | 31 21 | 35 75% | +| Capital expenditures - TTM | 107 106 | 107 104 | 119 11% | +Repurchase and retirement of common stock 148 300 299 292 301 103% +DEPRECIATION +| Depreciation expense | 31 30 | 30 30 | 31 — | +| -------------------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | +BALANCE SHEET DATA +| Cash and cash equivalents | 4,258 3,876 | 2,881 3,887 | 4,708 | +| ------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | +| Short-term investments | 1,073 1,095 | 1,664 1,274 | 737 | +Cash and cash equivalents, and short-term investments 5,331 4,971 4,545 5,161 5,445 2% +| Receivables, net | 385 371 | 966 806 | 623 62% | +| ---------------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | +STOCK-BASED COMPENSATION +| Cost of revenue | 1 | 1 1 | 1 1 | +| ------------------------------ | ----- | ----- | --- | +| Research and development | 44 47 | 39 49 | 49 | +| Marketing and sales | 8 | 7 9 | 8 9 | +| General and administrative | 16 15 | 17 17 | 14 | +| Total stock-based compensation | 69 70 | 66 75 | 73 | +1At the beginning of fiscal year 2019, April 1, 2018, EA adopted FASB ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606) Revenue from Contracts with Customers. EA’s FY19 +Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets reflect the effect of the adoption as of April 1, 2018, which had an impact on receivables, net of +allowances. Financial data for periods prior to April 1, 2018 has not been restated. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q226/random_k4/random_4.md b/q226/random_k4/random_4.md index 3daebaafe246f3a5e46090056de1a61dc59b26a4..ca68109bbe7fda9dcd218fe6180e0133f819a6e0 100644 --- a/q226/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q226/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,859 +1,2285 @@ -Showcasing research from Professor Bettina V. Lotsch’s -laboratory, Nanochemistry Department, Max Planck Institute for As featured in: -Solid State Research, Stuttgart, Germany. -Dynamic breathing behaviour of the titanium-based -metal–organic framework NTU-9 upon adsorption of -water and organic solvents -What happens to the structure of a framework material when -the pore content is changed or reduced? While investigating and -optimising the reproducibility of synthesising the two-dimensional -titanium-based MOF NTU 9, we discovered a dynamic behaviour -of NTU-9 triggered by guest adsorption and desorption. After -applying additional stimuli (i.e., vacuum), the material exhibits -reversible pore distortion by compression in the lateral dimension, -forming a new metastable form, NTU-9-d (d stands for distorted), -with a reduction in unit cell volume, pore size, and crystal symmetry. See Sebastian Bette, -Bettina V. Lotsch et al., -Image reproduced by permission of Julia Knapp from Chem. Sci., Chem. Sci., 2025, 16, 13646. -2025, 16, 13646. -rsc.li/chemical-science -Registered charity number: 207890 +| | | | A | Survey | on Automated | Fact-Checking | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ZhijiangGuo∗,MichaelSchlichtkrull∗,AndreasVlachos +DepartmentofComputerScienceandTechnology +UniversityofCambridge +{zg283,mss84,av308}@cam.ac.uk +Abstract +Fact-checkinghasbecomeincreasinglyim- +| portant | due | to the | speed | with | which both | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +informationandmisinformationcanspread +| in | the modern | | media | ecosystem. | There- | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2202 nuJ 6 ]LC.sc[ 3v69811.8012:viXra +| fore, | researchers | | have | been exploring | how | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fact-checkingcanbeautomated,usingtech- +| niques | based | on | natural | language | process- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ing,machinelearning,knowledgerepresen- +| tation, | and | databases | to | automatically | pre- | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| dict | the veracity | | of claims. | | In this paper, | | | | | | | +| we | survey | automated | | fact-checking | stem- | | | | | | | +mingfromnaturallanguageprocessing,and +| discuss | its | connections | | to related | tasks and | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ----------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | Figure 1: | An example | of | a fact-checked | | statement. | +| disciplines. | | In this | process, | | we present an | | | | | | | +overview of existing datasets and models, Referring to the manufacturing sector, Donald Trump +| | | | | | | said“Ibroughtback700,000jobs. | | | ObamaandBiden | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +aimingtounifythevariousdefinitionsgiven +| | | | | | | broughtbacknothing.” | | Thefact-checkergavethever- | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| andidentifycommonconcepts. | | | | | Finally,we | | | | | | | +highlightchallengesforfutureresearch. dictFalsebasedonthecollectedevidence. +| | | | | | | tight deadlines, | especially | | in the case | of | internal | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +1 Introduction +| | | | | | | processes | (Borel, 2016; | Godler | and | Reich, | 2017), | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | ------ | --- | ------ | ------ | +Fact-checking is the task of assessing whether andsomestudieshaveshownthatlessthanhalfof +claims made in written or spoken language are allpublishedarticleshavebeensubjecttoverifica- +true. Thisisanessentialtaskinjournalism,andis tion(Lewisetal.,2008). Giventheamountofnew +commonlyconductedmanuallybydedicatedorga- informationthatappearsandthespeedwithwhich +nizationssuchasPolitiFact. Inadditiontoexternal itspreads,manualvalidationisinsufficient. +fact-checking, internal fact-checking is also per- Automatingthefact-checkingprocesshasbeen +| formed | by publishers | | of newspapers, | | magazines, | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----- | ---------------- | ------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | discussed | in the context | | of computational | | jour- | +| and books | prior | to publishing | | in | order to promote | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | nalism (Flew | et al., | 2010; | Cohen | et al., | 2011; | +truthful reporting. Figure 1 shows an example Graves, 2018), and has received significant atten- +from PolitiFact, together with the evidence (sum- tion in the artificial intelligence community. Vla- +marized)andtheverdict. +chosandRiedel(2014)proposedstructuringitasa +Fact-checking is a time-consuming task. To sequenceofcomponents–identifyingclaimstobe +assess the claim in Figure 1, a journalist would checked, finding appropriate evidence, producing +| need to | search | through | potentially | | many sources | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +verdicts–thatcanbemodelledasnaturallanguage +| to find | job gains | under | Trump | | and Obama, eval- | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | processing(NLP)tasks. | | | Thismotivatedthedevel- | | | +uate the reliability of each source, and make a opment of automated pipelines consisting of sub- +comparison. This process can take professional tasksthatcanbemappedtotaskswell-exploredin +fact-checkersseveralhoursordays(Hassanetal., +| | | | | | | the NLP | community. | Advances | were | made | pos- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +2015;Adairetal.,2017). Compoundingtheprob- sible by the development of datasets, consisting +lem, fact-checkers often work under strict and ofeitherclaimscollectedfromfact-checkingweb- +∗∗EquallyContributed. sites,e.g.Liar(Wang,2017),orpurpose-madefor -Chemical -Science -| EDGE | ARTICLE | | | | | | | | | View Article Online | | | -| ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -View Journal | View Issue -| | | Dynamic | | breathing | | behaviour | | of | the | titanium- | | | -| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT based metal – organic framework NTU-9 upon -| Citethis:Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646 | | | | | | | | | | | † | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | adsorption | | | of water | and | organic | | solvents | | | | - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO -Allpublicationchargesforthisarticle -havebeenpaidforbytheRoyalSociety -| | | | | ab | | ın-Rubio, | a | Heck,ac | | | | ab | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofChemistry Julia E. Knapp, Borja Ort´ Fabian Kristina Gjorgjevikj, -| | | Anastasia | Sleptsova, | | a Simon | Krause, | a Sebastian | | Bette | *a | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | and Bettina | V. | Lotsch | *abc | | | | | | | | -Understandingthestructuralresponseofframeworkmaterialstoexternalstimulihasbeenofgreatinterest. -However,littleisknownaboutthestimuliresponsivenessoftitanium-basedmetal–organicframeworks.We -investigatethereproducibilityofthesynthesisofthetwo-dimensionalmetal–organicframeworkNTU-9 -(NTU = Nanyang Technological University) composed of Ti4+ cations and 2,5-dihydroxyterephtalate as -theorganiclinkerandtheflexibleresponseoftheframework -structuretoexternalstimuli.Usingacetic -acid simultaneously as mediator and solvent leads to the reproducible formation of large NTU-9 -crystallites after long reaction times. The MOF synthesis in isopropanol:acetonitrile (i-PrOH:MeCN) -significantly -mixtures without a modulator is faster but yields smaller NTU-9 crystallites. Pure heat -treatment under ambient conditions removes a significant amount of the incorporated host solvent -moleculeswithoutalterationoftheframework'sstructure.Afterapplyingadditionalexternalstimuli(i.e., -vacuum),thematerialexhibitsaporedistortionby compressioninthelateraldimension,dependingon -the synthetic procedure. The new, distorted, metastable form NTU-9-d shows a reduction in unit cell -volume, pore size, and crystal symmetry. Under humidity/air exposure or solvent resuspension, the -frameworkrevertsintoitsoriginalstate.Thesynthesisconditionssignificantlyaffecttheflexibilityofthe -Received7thApril2025 MOF structure, wheresamples synthesized withoutmodulator showed a lower tendency for distortion. -Accepted24thJune2025 -Our results emphasise the importance of an in-depth understanding of the structure–property -DOI:10.1039/d5sc02585k relationshipsinflexibleMOFsthroughadetailedcharacterisationofthematerial'sstimuliresponsiveness -| rsc.li/chemical-science | | process. | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Introduction Titanium-based MOFs are of particular interest due to the -| | | | | | | earth abundance | of | their | metal source, | | high stability, | low | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -Metal–organic toxicity, redox activity, and promising photochemical proper- -| | frameworks | (MOFs) are | porous | reticular | mate- | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -rials consisting of inorganic nodes (e.g., metal ions, clusters) ties.6Thelatterpavethewayforattractiveapplications,suchas -linked by organic bridging ligands through coordination in photocatalysis, because tetravalent titanium cations exhibit -bonds.1–3 -Among them, MOFs constructed from tri- and tetra- anemptyd-shellconstitutingtheconductionbandminimum, -valent metal-based clusters combined with carboxylate-based whichcangeneratelong-livedchargecarrier,resultinginhigh -| | | | | | so | solar-to-chemical | | conversion | efficiencies.7,8 | | However, | the | -| ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | ------ | ---- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| ligands show | higher stability | according | to the | hard | and | | | | | | | | -Ti4+-clusters -acidsandbases(HSAB)principle,4whichmakesthemsuitable synthesis of carboxylate-based is challenging due -forapplicationssuchasgasstorageandseparation,aswellas tothehighreactivity(pronetofastolationandoxolation)and -catalysis.2,5 thehydrolyticinstabilityoftitaniumprecursors,impedingthe -| | | | | | | crystallisation | process.9–11 | | Ti4+ ions | are highly | susceptible | to | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------------------------------------ | --------- | ------------ | ---------- | -------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | hydrolysis, | which | results | in the rapid | formation | of | various | -| | | | | | | molecular | titanium-oxo-clustersand,eventually, | | | | intheprecip- | | -| | | | | | | itation of | TiO . As | a result, | signicantly | fewer | titanium-based | | -| aMaxPlanckInstituteforSolidStateResearch,Heisenbergstraße1,Stuttgart,70569, | | | | | | | 2 | | | | | | -Germany.E-mail:s.bette@f.mpg.de;b.lotsch@f.mpg.de MOFs have been reported in the literature compared to other -Pfaffenwaldring -bDepartment of Chemistry, University of Stuttgart, 55, Stuttgart, MOFs based on transition metals such as Zn2+, Cu2+, and -70569,Germany Zr4+.9,12–14Usefulsynthesisstrategiesforenablingtheformation -cDepartment of Chemistry, University of Munich, Butenandtstraße 5-13, Munich, Mart´ı- -| | | | | | | of Ti-MOF | single crystals | | have been | introduced | by the | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -81377,Germany -| | | | | | | Gastaldo | group, i.e., | by metal | doping15 | or using | hydroxamate- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -†Electronicsupplementaryinformation(ESI)available:Methods,additionaldata -andanalysis.SeeDOI:https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc02585k -13646 | Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 ©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry +Verdict Prediction +| | | | Claim | | | Evidence | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | Detection | | | Retrieval | | | | | | | | +Justification Production +| | | Figure2: | Anaturallanguageprocessingframeworkforautomatedfact-checking. | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +research,e.g.FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018a). reachedbytheclaim,andtheintentionsandforms +Agrowingbodyofresearchisexploringthevar- oftheclaim–areoftenconsidered. Thesefactors +ious tasks and subtasks necessary for the automa- also feature in the context of propaganda detec- +tionoffact-checking,andtomeettheneedfornew tion, recently surveyed by Da San Martino et al. +methods to address emerging challenges. Early (2020b). Unliketheseefforts,theworksdiscussed +developments were surveyed in Thorne and Vla- inthissurveyconcentrateonassessingveracityof +chos (2018), which remains the closest to an ex- general-domain claims. Finally, Shu et al. (2017) +| | | | | | | | and da Silva | et | al. (2019) | surveyed | | research | on | +| -------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| haustive | overview | of the | subject. | However, | | their | | | | | | | | +proposedframeworkdoesnotincludeworkonde- fake news detection and fact-checking with a fo- +termining which claims to verify (i.e. claim de- cusonsocialmediadata,whilethissurveycovers +tection), nor does their survey include the recent fact-checkingacrossdomainsandsources,includ- +work on producing explainable, convincing ver- ingnewswire,science,etc. +dicts(i.e.justificationproduction). In this survey, we present a comprehensive and +Several recent papers have surveyed research up-to-datesurveyofautomatedfact-checking,uni- +focusing on individual components of the task. fying various definitions developed in previous +Zubiagaetal.(2018)andIslametal.(2020)focus research into a common framework. We begin +on identifying rumours on social media, Küçük by defining the three stages of our fact-checking +and Can (2020) and Hardalov et al. (2021) on de- framework – claim detection, evidence retrieval, +andclaimverification,thelatterconsistingofver- +| tecting the | stance | of a given | piece | of | evidence | to- | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------ | ---------- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +wards a claim, and Kotonya and Toni (2020a) on dict prediction and justification production. We +producingexplanationsandjustificationsforfact- thengiveanoverviewoftheexistingdatasetsand +modellingstrategies,taxonomizingtheseandcon- +checks. FinallyNakovetal.(2021a)surveyedau- +tomatedapproachestoassistfact-checkingbyhu- textualizing them with respect to our framework. +mans. While these surveys are extremely useful We finally discuss key research challenges that +in understanding various aspects of fact-checking havebeenaddressed,andgivedirectionsforchal- +| | | | | | | | lenges which | we | believe | should | be tackled | | by fu- | +| ----------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | +| technology, | they | are fragmented | | and | focused | on | | | | | | | | +specific subtasks and components; our aim is to ture research. We accompany the survey with a +repository,1whichliststheresourcesmentionedin +| give a comprehensive | | | and exhaustive | | birds-eye | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +oursurvey. +viewofthesubjectasawhole. +Anumberofpapershavesurveyedrelatedtasks. +Lazer et al. (2018) and Zhou and Zafarani (2020) 2 TaskDefinition +| surveyed | work | on fake | news, | including | descrip- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------- | ------ | --------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Figure 2 | shows | a NLP | framework | for | automated | | +| tive work | on the | problem, | as | well as | work | seek- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | fact-checking | consisting | | of three | stages: | (i) | claim | +| ing to counteract | | fake | news | through | computa- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | detection | to identify | claims | that | require | verifica- | | +| tionalmeans. | AcomprehensivereviewofNLPap- | | | | | | | | | | | | | +tion;(ii)evidenceretrievaltofindsourcessupport- +proachestofakenewsdetectionwasalsoprovided +ingorrefutingtheclaim;(iii)claimverificationto +| in Oshikawa | et | al. (2020). | However, | | fake | news | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------- | ----------- | -------- | -------------- | ---- | ---- | ---------------- | -------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | assess the | veracity | of the | claim | based | on | the re- | +| detection | differs | in scope | from | fact-checking, | | as | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | trievedevidence. | | Evidenceretrievalandclaimver- | | | | | +theformerfocusesonassessingnewsarticles,and +ificationaresometimestackledasasingletaskre- +| includes | labelling | items | based | on aspects | | not re- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ferredtoasfactualverification,whileclaimdetec- +| lated to | veracity, | such | as satire | detection | | (Os- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| hikawa | et al., | 2020; Zhou | and | Zafarani, | | 2020). | | | | | | | | +1www.github.com/Cartus/ +Furthermore, other factors – such as the audience Automated-Fact-Checking-Resources -View Article Online -| EdgeArticle | | | | | | | | | | | | | ChemicalScience | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -basedlinkers.16AnotherstrategywasproposedbyLietal.using -achelatingcoordinationmodulationmethod.17 -Oneofthemostinterestingfeaturesofreticularmaterialsis -| the combination | | of robust | and | exible | entities | in | a collective | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -structure,whichisalsoreferredtoassoporouscrystals18,19or -exibleframeworkmaterials20–23whichreacttoexternalstimuli -| (e.g., | temperature, | pressure, | light) | by | reversibly | changing | the | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ------ | ------------------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| framework | structure | without | | bond-breaking.18,19 | | These | mate- | | | | | | | | -| rials | can respond | to incorporation | | and | release | of | guest mole- | | | | | | | | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT -culeswithstructuraldeformationsoftheframework,resulting -| | | | | | | | | Fig.1 ImageofthecrystalstructureofNTU-9(ref.32)(a)alongthe | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -c-axis) -inexpansionorshrinkageoftheporespace,alsoreferredtoas pore (view along and (b) visualising the layer structure (view - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO b-axis), i.e., -breathing behaviour. Since then, framework materials have along with the pores and pore content, positionally -| | classied | | | | | | so- | disorderedsolventmolecules. | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ------------- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| been | | into three | categories | | according | to | their | | | | | | | | -| ness:18,19 | exibility | through | synergistic | | effects | of | the metal | | | | | | | | -| nodes' | coordination | symmetry, | | the rotatable | | axis | of organic | | | | | | | | -linkers,andstronghost–guestinteractions.22,24–27 synthetic routes differ in terms of solvent (acetic acid vs. i- -PrOH:MeCNmixture)andreactiontime(5dvs.1d).Gaoetal. -F´ereyandco-workersrstreportedonthebreathing/swelling -rst -behaviourinMOFsin2002.28Todate,thedynamicbehaviourof reported the solvothermal synthesis S1 (Solvent -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | 5d | reaction- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -)inaceticacid(1),actingasbothmodulatorandsolvent.32 -| titanium-basedMOFs | | israrely | | describedinthe | | literature,and | | time | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onlyafewreportsarepublished.9,29–31InCOK-69,theframework The acidic medium during synthesis promotes a slow seeding -exibility byshiingthedeprotonationequilibriumofthelinkerH dhta -| | results | from the | dynamic | conformational | | | change | of | | | | | | 4 | -| ------------------------------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | ---------- | --------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | -------- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | | toward the | precursor | side, | thus | slowing | down the | reaction, | -| the (cis/trans)1,4-cyclohexanedicarboxylate | | | | | linker | upon | solvent | | | | | | | | -removal.9Anotherexampleistheheterometallic(TiMn )MUV- resultinginlargercrystals.33,38Incontrast,Yuetal.useda1:1 -2 -mixtureofi-PrOHandMeCN(2)inanalternativesynthesisS2 -35, where the single-crystal transformation is controlled by 1d -linkerconformationinopen,intermediate,andclosedstates.30 intheabsenceofmodulatoranddecreasedthereactiontimeto -onedayinsteadofve.35 -| In | the following, | we | report | the synthesis, | | activation | proce- | | | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ------- | --------- | -------------- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | | As the | limited | reproducibility | | of MOF syntheses | | is a recur- | -| dure, | and the | dynamic | behaviour | of the | Ti-based | | MOF NTU-9 | | | | | | | | -eld,39,40 -(NTU = Nanyang Technological University) triggered by guest ring problem that is gaining attention in the we -statisticallystudiedtheinuenceofthereactiontimeforeach -| adsorption | | and desorption. | | We optimised | | the | synthesis | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -parameters and evaluated for reproducibility towards large syntheticprotocolbyperformingthereactionbetween4and21 -different -| | | | | | | | | times. Indeed, | | we found | | trends | depending | on the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -singlecrystalsandmicrocrystallinebulkpowders.Furthermore, -solventused(Table1andFig.S1,S2†). -| we discovered | | a new metastable | | form | NTU-9-d | (d | stands for | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -distorted),whichexhibitsastrongporeandunitcelldistortion Half of the S1 5d syntheses resulted in the formation of an -amorphousproduct(Fig.S3†),ashasbeenpreviouslyobserved -uponactivation.Weinvestigatedthestructuraltransitionsbyin -| | | | | | | | | byothergroups.41ThesuccessfulS1 | | | | attemptsresultedinthe | | | -| ----------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------------------------- | ---- | ------------- | ------- | --------------------- | --------- | ----------- | -| situ powder | | X-ray diffraction | | (PXRD) | and THz | Raman | spec- | | | | | 5d | | | -| | | | | | | rst | | formation | of a | heterogeneous | mixture | of | dark red, | crystalline | -| troscopy. | These | investigations | | revealed | the | | dynamic | | | | | | | | -hexagonalNTU-9andmicrocrystallinepowder(Fig.2candS4†). -breathingbehaviourofatitanium-basedmetal–organicframe- -conrmed -work with a rigid linker upon solvent loss and exposure to We the phase purity of the bulk powder by PXRD -| | | | | | | | | measurements | | (Fig. 2a). Scanning | | electron | microscopy | (SEM) | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | -| humidity/air. | | Our work | establishes | a | reproducible | | synthesis | | | | | | | | -revealedtheformationofcrystalswithvaryingsize(20–50mm) -| procedure | and | a detailed | | mechanism | of | the | previously | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | | and microcrystalline | | powder | with | average | crystallite | size | -unknownframeworkdynamics. -| | | | | | | | | smaller 0.5 | mm | (Fig. 2c). | S2 syntheses | | also resulted | in the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------ | -1d -expectedphaseandshoweduniformlysized(z2.5mm)hexag- -| Results | | and discussion | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | onal red | crystals | (Fig. 2a, | b and | S4†). | The rened | lattice | -Synthesis,reproducibilityandmaterialscharacterisation parameters (Fig. 2a, inset) differ slightly from the reported -In 2014, Gao et al. synthesised NTU-9 (C H O Ti ) as a pho- valuesforthecrystallographicc-axisand,hence,cellvolume.32 -| | | | | | 24 | 6 18 | 2 | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Additionally,FT-IRdata32,35,42(Fig.S5†)aswellasTHzRaman -| toactive | titanium(IV)-based | | MOF | with | p-type | semiconductor | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -spectroscopy43(Fig.S6†)ofthesynthesisedsolidsalignwiththe -behaviourandutiliseditforthephotochemicaldegradationof -reportedliteratureandindicatesuccessfulformationofNTU-9 -| organic | dyes.32 | This 2D | MOF (Fig. | 1) results | | from | the reaction | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | -------- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | for both | synthesis | pathways. | | More detailed | information | | -betweentitanium(IV)-isopropoxideand2,5-dihydroxyterephtalic -regardingthesyntheticconditionscanbefoundintheESI.† -acid(H dhta)inaceticacid,formingdarkredhexagonalcrystals -4 -WewereabletosolvethereproducibilityproblemforS1by -composedofasingleTiion-basedhexagonalframeworkinan -underlying hcb net.32,33 Later, investigations on NTU-9's effi- doubling the reaction time (S1 10d ). SEM images of S1 10d -| | | | | | | | | revealed | a uniform | distribution | of | larger agglomerated | | hexag- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | ------ | -cientgasseparationabilitywithanoptimisedsyntheticproce- -onalcrystals(120mm).Conversely,decreasingthereactiontime -durewerereported.34 -| | | | | | | | | | | | signicant | | difference | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -We rst synthesised NTU-9 by reproducing different to three days did not yield any (S1 3d ) in -literature.32,35–37 terms of reproducibility, and decreasing it further did not -| synthesis | conditions | reported | | in the | | | These | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 | 13647 +tionisoftentackledseparately. Claimverification judgedtobelesscheck-worthybythegeneralpub- +canbedecomposedintotwopartsthatcanbetack- lic than misinformation that targets the majority. +ledseparatelyorjointly: verdictprediction,where Conversely, claims originating from marginalised +claimsareassignedtruthfulnesslabels,andjustifi- groups may be subject to greater scrutiny than +cationproduction,whereexplanationsforverdicts claimsoriginatingfromthemajority;forexample, +| mustbeproduced. | | | | | | | journalistshavebeenshowntoassigngreatertrust | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | and therefore | | lower need | for | verification | | to sto- | +2.1 ClaimDetection riesproducedbymalesources (BarnoyandReich, +2019). Suchbiasescouldbereplicatedindatasets +Thefirststageinautomatedfact-checkingisclaim +thatcapturethe(oftenimplicit)decisionsmadeby +| detection, | where | claims | are | selected | | for verifi- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ----- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +journalistsaboutwhichclaimstoprioritize. +| cation. | Commonly, | | detection | relies | on | the con- | | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Insteadofusingsubjectiveconcepts,Konstanti- +| cept of | check-worthiness. | | | Hassan | et | al. (2015) | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | novskiy | et al. | (2021) | framed | claim | detection | as | +| defined | check-worthy | | claims | as | those | for which | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | whether | a claim | makes | an | assertion | about | the | +thegeneralpublicwouldbeinterestedinknowing +worldthatischeckable,i.e.whetheritisverifiable +| the truth. | For | example, | “over | six | million | Ameri- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | with readily | available | | evidence. | Claims | based | on | +canshadCOVID-19inJanuary”wouldbecheck- +personalexperiencesoropinionsareuncheckable. +| worthy,asopposedto“wateriswet”. | | | | | Thiscanin- | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ----- | ---- | ------ | ------ | +| | | | | | | | For example, | | “I woke | up at | 7 am | today” | is not | +volveabinarydecisionforeachpotentialclaim,or +checkablebecauseappropriateevidencecannotbe +animportance-rankingofclaims(Atanasovaetal., +| | | | | | | | collected; | “cubist | art | is beautiful” | | is not | check- | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| 2018; Barrón-Cedeño | | | et al., | 2020). | | The latter | | | | | | | | +ablebecauseitisasubjectivestatement. +| parallels | standard | practice | | in internal | journalistic | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| fact-checking, | | where | deadlines | often | require | fact- | | | | | | | | +2.2 EvidenceRetrieval +checkerstoemployatriagesystem(Borel,2016). +Another instantiation of claim detection based Evidence retrieval aims to find information be- +| | | | | | | | yond the | claim | – e.g. | text, | tables, | knowledge | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | +| on check-worthiness | | | is rumour | detection. | | A ru- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | bases, | images, | relevant | metadata | | – to | indicate | +mourcanbedefinedasanunverifiedstoryorstate- +| | | | | | | | veracity. | Some | earlier | efforts | do | not | use any | +| ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | +| ment circulating | | (typically | | on social | media) | (Ma | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | evidence | beyond | the | claim | itself | (Wang, | 2017; | +| et al., 2016; | Zubiaga | | et al., | 2018). | Rumour | de- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Rashkin | et al., | 2017; | Volkova | et al., | 2017; | Dungs | +tectionconsiderslanguagesubjectivityandgrowth +| | | | | | | | et al., | 2018). | Relying | on | surface | patterns | of | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +ofreadershipthroughasocialnetwork(Qazvinian +et al., 2011). Typical input to a rumour detection claims without considering the state of the world +failstoidentifywell-presentedmisinformation,in- +| system | is a stream | of | social | media | posts, | where- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cludingmachine-generatedclaims(Schusteretal., +| upon a | binary | classifier | has | to determine | | if each | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +post is rumourous. Metadata, such as the num- 2020). Recent developments in natural language +| | | | | | | | generation | have | exacerbated | | this | issue (Radford | | +| ------------ | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | ------------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | +| ber of likes | and | re-posts, | is | often | used | as features | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | et al., 2019; | | Brown et | al., 2020), | | with machine- | | +| to identify | rumours | (Zubiaga | | et al., | 2016; | Gorrell | | | | | | | | +generatedtextsometimesbeingperceivedasmore +etal.,2019;Zhangetal.,2021). +trustworthythanhuman-writtentext(Zellersetal., +| Check-worthiness | | | and rumourousness | | | can be | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------- | ----------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | 2019). | In addition | to | enabling | verification, | | evi- | +| subjective. | For | example, | | the importance | | placed | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | dence is | essential | for | generating | verdict | justifica- | | +| on countering | | COVID-19 | | misinformation | | is not | | | | | | | | +tionstoconvinceusersoffact-checks. +| uniform | across | every | social | group. | The | check- | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +worthiness of each claim also varies over time, Stance detection can be viewed as an instantia- +tionofevidenceretrieval,whichtypicallyassumes +| as countering | | misinformation | | related | | to current | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | a more | limited | amount | of potential | | evidence | and | +eventsisinmanycasesunderstoodtobemoreim- +| | | | | | | | predicts | its stance | towards | the | claim. | For | exam- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | +portantthancounteringoldermisinformation(e.g. +ple,FerreiraandVlachos(2016)usednewsarticle +misinformationaboutCOVID-19hasagreaterso- +| | | | | | | | headlinesfromtheEmergent | | | | project2 | asevidence | | +| ------------- | ------- | ------------ | -------- | -------------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------------------ | ------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | +| cietal impact | | in 2021 | than | misinformation | | about | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | to predict | whether | articles | supported, | | refuted | or | +| the Spanish | flu). | Furthermore, | | | older | rumours | | | | | | | | +| may have | already | been | debunked | | by | journalists, | | | | | | | | +2www.cjr.org/tow_center_reports/craig_ +| reducing | their | impact. | Misinformation | | | that is | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +silverman_lies_damn_lies_viral_content. +| harmfultomarginalizedcommunitiesmayalsobe | | | | | | | php | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -View Article Online -| ChemicalScience | | | | | | | | | | | EdgeArticle | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -Table1 SyntheticconditionsforNTU-9varyinginsolvent(aceticacid reactionsolventmightexhibitastrongerbindinginteractionwith -vs.i-PrOH:MeCN)andreactiontime(between15minand10days). -| | | | | | | | the framework. | This leads | to an extension | | or shrinking | of the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | -Reactionsyieldedanamorphousphase(red),phasemixture(yellow), -interlayerdistance(Fig.1b),whichindicatesatendencyforNTU-9 -| orpurephase(green)ofNTU-9. | | | | (successfulsynthesis/total | | | reaction | | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tobeexibletowardsdifferentsolvents. -attempts) -Stabilitytowardssolvents–guestmoleculesforstructural -stabilisation -| | | | | | | | We studied | the framework–solvent | | interaction | | by solvent | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT -| | | | | | | | exchange | of the incorporated | solvent | molecules, | | letting the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | NTU-9 crystals | soak in | polar and | non-polar | solvents | (hexane, | - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO -H O,EtOH,acetone,i-PrOH,THF,DMF,MeCN)forthreedays -2 -aAcetic acid as solvent. b1:1 ratio ofi-PrOH:MeCN as solvent. atroomtemperature(Fig.3).TheoverallPXRDpatternsofthe -cMicrowave-assistedreaction. -resultingsolvent-exchangedNTU-9samplescanbeindexedby -thereportedtrigonalcell,whichshowsthattheMOFisstablein -| | | | | | | | differentsolvents. | | however,aresignicantlyshif- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Somepeaks, -| | | | | | | | ted, e.g., | 002 or 102. This | could | indicate | that different-sized | | -| ------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ----------------- | ---------------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------------------- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | solvent molecules | are | accommodated | within | the | pores. With | -| produce | any crystalline | | product. | The | attempt | to change | from | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | different | solvents incorporated, | the | unit | cell volume | slightly | -solvothermaltomicrowave-assistedsynthesistofurtherreduce -| | | | | | | | varies between | 2174(2) | Å3 and 2208(2) | Å3. | The volume | change | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -thereactiontime,asshownbyYanetal.37withformicacid,lead -mainlyoriginatesfromaslightchangeofthec-axis(Fig.S9and -toamorphousproductsfortheaceticacidbasedreaction. -TableS2†).Thisbehaviourcanbeexplainedbytheanisotropic -| On the | contrary, | | we found | that | a microwave-assisted | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ---- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -structureofNTU-9(Fig.1):intheab-plane,covalentandcoor- -synthesiscouldreducethereactiontimeto15minutesforthe -dinationbondsarestabilisingtheframework,whichischemi- -| synthesis | without | modulator | | (S2 | ), yielding | a mixture | of | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -mw cally stiff. Perpendicular to the ab-plane, the 2D sheets are -different-sized -| polycrystalline | powder | | and | | hexagonal | | crystals. | | | | | | -| --------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | stabilised | betweeneachotherbyhydrogenbondsandvander | | | | | -| Instead, | increasing | the | reaction | time | resulted | in a | phase | | | | | | -Waalsforces,whicharechemicallylessstrongandmoreelastic. -reections -| mixture | (S2 3d , S2 | 5d , S2 | 10d ). Additional | | broad | | in the | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thelayeredstructureinthec-directioncanthusbemoreeasily -diffractionpatternscouldnotbeassignedtooneofthereported expandedandaccommodatesdifferent-sizedsolventmolecules, -polymorphsofNTU-917,44(Fig.S7andS2†). -alsodependingonthespecicsolvent–frameworkinteractions. -| S1 ,S1 | ,S1 | andS2 | ,S2 | resultedinphase-pureNTU-9 | | | Aer | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ----- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -3d 5d 10d mw 1d resuspension of NTU-9 in DMF, new, unindexed peaks -| with slight | peak | shis | in the | PXRD | patterns. | The peaks | of the | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -shied -| resulting | products | of synthesis | | route | S2 are slightly | | to | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -lower2qvalues,indicatingalargerunitcellvolume,comparedto -S1,whichisconrmedbyRietveldrenement45foreachsample -(Fig.2,S8andTableS1†).Allproductscrystalliseinthetrigonal -(cid:1) -spacegroupP31c;butthec-axisincreasesfortheS2.Thisvariance -| | | different | | llings | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| may result | from | | pore | | and solventinteractions. | | | | | | | | -Despitemultiplewashingstepsofeachsamplewithethanol,itis -possiblethatacompletesolventexchangedidnotoccur,andthe -Fig.2 (a)PXRDpatternofNTU-9calculatedfromthesinglecrystal -(black)32includingtherefinedandreportedlatticeparametersofthe -as-synthesised S1 (red) and S2 (blue) isolated crystallites. Inset: Fig.3 PXRDpatternsofS1withdifferentsolventsusedforsolvent- -| | | 5d | | 1d | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tablewithcorrespondingspacegroup,refinedlatticeparameters,and exchange. Dotted lines highlight the peak shifts and red asterisks -unitcellvolume.SEMimagesof(b)S2 and(c)S1 . indicatenewlyformedpeaks. -| | | | | 1d | 5d | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -13648 | Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 ©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry +merely reported a claim. The Fake News Chal- fact-checking agencies, employing multi-class la- +lenge(PomerleauandRao,2017)furtheruseden- bels representing degrees of truthfulness (Wang, +tiredocuments,allowingforevidencefrommulti- 2017; Alhindi et al., 2018; Shahi and Nandini, +ple sentences. More recently, Hanselowski et al. 2020;Augensteinetal.,2019). +(2019)filteredoutirrelevantsentencesinthesum- +maries of fact-checking articles to obtain fine- 2.4 JustificationProduction +grained evidence via stance detection. While +Justifying decisions is an important part of jour- +both stance detection and evidence retrieval in +nalistic fact-checking, as fact-checkers need to +the context of claim verification are classification +convince readers of their interpretation of the ev- +tasks, what is considered evidence in the former +idence (Uscinski and Butler, 2013; Borel, 2016). +is broader, including for example a social media +Debunkingpurelybycallingsomethingfalseoften +postresponding“@AJENews@germanwingsyes +failstobepersuasive,andcaninducea“backfire”- +indeed:-(.” toaclaim(Gorrelletal.,2019). +effect where belief in the erroneous claim is rein- +A fundamental issue is that not all available +forced (Lewandowsky et al., 2012). This need is +information is trustworthy. Most fact-checking +even greater for automated fact-checking, which +approaches implicitly assume access to a trusted +mayemployblack-boxcomponents. Whendevel- +information source such as encyclopedias (e.g. +opers deploy black-box models whose decision- +Wikipedia (Thorne et al., 2018a)) or results pro- +making processes cannot be understood, these +vided(andthusvetted)bysearchengines(Augen- +artefacts can lead to unintended, harmful conse- +stein et al., 2019). Evidence is then defined as in- +quences (O’Neil, 2016). Developing techniques +formation that can be retrieved from this source, +thatexplainmodelpredictionshasbeensuggested +and veracity as coherence with the evidence. For +as a potential remedy to this problem (Lipton, +real-world applications, evidence must be curated +2018), and recent work has focused on the gen- +through the manual efforts of journalists (Borel, +eration of justifications (see Kotonya and Toni’s +2016), automated means (Li et al., 2015), or their +(2020a) survey of explainable claim verification). +combination. For example, Full Fact uses tables +Research so far has focused on justification pro- +and legal documents from government organisa- +ductionforclaimverification,asthelatterisoften +tionsasevidence.3 +the most scrutinized stage in fact-checking. Nev- +ertheless,explainabilitymayalsobedesirableand +2.3 VerdictPrediction +necessaryfortheotherstagesinourframework. +Given an identified claim and the pieces of evi- +Justification production for claim verification +dence retrieved for it, verdict prediction attempts +typicallyreliesononeoffourstrategies. First,at- +to determine the veracity of the claim. The sim- +tentionweightscanbeusedtohighlightthesalient +plest approach is binary classification, e.g. la- +parts of the evidence, in which case justifications +belling a claim as true or false (Nakashole and +typically consist of scores for each evidence to- +Mitchell, 2014; Popat et al., 2016; Potthast et al., +ken (Popat et al., 2018; Shu et al., 2019; Lu and +2018). Whenevidenceisusedtoverifytheclaim, +Li,2020). Second,decision-makingprocessescan +it is often preferable to use supported/refuted (by +be designed to be understandable by human ex- +evidence) instead of true/false respectively, as in +perts,e.g.byrelyingonlogic-basedsystems(Gad- +many cases the evidence itself is not assessed by +Elrab et al., 2019; Ahmadi et al., 2019); in this +the systems. More broadly it would be dangerous +case,thejustificationistypicallythederivationfor +tomakesuchstrongclaimsabouttheworldgiven +the veracity of the claim. Finally, the task can be +thewell-knownlimitations(Graves,2018). +modelled as a form of summarization, where sys- +Manyversionsofthetaskemployfiner-grained +tems generate textual explanations for their deci- +classification schemes. A simple extension is to +sions (Atanasova et al., 2020b). While some of +useanadditionallabeldenotingalackofinforma- +thesejustificationtypesrequireadditionalcompo- +tion to predict the veracity of the claim (Thorne +nents, we did not introduce a fourth stage in our +et al., 2018a). Beyond that, some datasets and +framework as in some cases the decision-making +systems follow the approach taken by journalistic +process of the model is self-explanatory (Gad- +Elrabetal.,2019;Ahmadietal.,2019). +3www.fullfact.org/about/ +frequently-asked-questions A basic form of justification is to show which -View Article Online -| EdgeArticle | | | | | | | | | | | | | ChemicalScience | | | -| ----------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -| emerge | in the PXRD | patterns, | | indicating | the | very slow | forma- | | | | | | | | | -tionofanadditional,unknownphase(Fig.3,S9andS10†). -Thermalstabilityatambientpressureandundervacuum -| Next, we | explore | the thermal | | and solvolytic | | stability | of NTU-9 | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------- | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| (S1 5d ) in | air and | under | dynamic | vacuum. | Thermogravimetric | | | | | | | | | | | -analysis(TGA)insyntheticairshowsthatthematerialisstable -uptoaround290°C.Twomainmasslossstepscanbedistin- -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT -guished.StepI(20wt%massloss)inthetemperaturerangeof -30–220°Ccanbeassignedtothereleaseofsolventmolecules. - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO different -The combustion of the linkers, which is associated with the Fig. 5 PXRD pattern of S1 (left) and S2 (right) at stages of -deconstruction of the framework structure, leads to step II drying: as-synthesised (black), 120 °C heated (red) and exposed to -(48 wt% mass loss) in the range of 220–460 °C. At 460 °C, dynamicvacuumat60°C(blue). -asmall,additionalmasslossoccurs(3wt%massloss),andthe -TG-curveeventuallyreachesaplateauat550°C(Fig.4a).Exsitu -different -| | | | | | | | | vacuum | for 24 | h.36 Surprisingly, | | PXRD | revealed | a | | -| ------------- | ------- | ------ | --------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ------ | ------------------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -| PXRD analyses | | show | that combustion | | of NTU-9 | leads | to the | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | behaviour | when | activating | NTU-9 | using | heat | only | (under | -| formation | of pure | rutile | (TG | temperature | 1000 | °C). | TGA was | | | | | | | | | -measuredtwice(5Kmin −1vs.10Kmin −1)forthesamebatchto ambient pressure) (Fig. 5, red lines) compared to applying -additionaldynamicvacuum(Fig.5,bluelines).Forthelatter,we -| distinguish | the | solvent | loss, | which | is assigned | to | be around | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -20 wt% (19 and 21 wt% for the different heating rates). We observedapronouncedpeaksplittingthatimpliesastructural -cannotbesurethatallsolventisremovedintherststepand distortion. The distorted structure is characterised by a peak -| | | | | | | | | splitting | of the | 100 reection | and | a shi | of peaks, | i.e., | 110 or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ----- | ------ | -remainingcoordinatingsolventmoleculescanbeexpecteddue -todiffuse,residualelectrondensityinthepores,asestablished 002,inthePXRDpattern.ForS2 1d ,theconversiontoNTU-9-dis -byRietveldrenementofthedriedNTU-9(Fig.S11–S13†). incomplete,resultinginaphasemixtureofNTU-9andNTU-9-d. -Inthemechanisticstudytounderstandthedistortion,wefocus -| For | structural | insights, | | we | performed | temperature- | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -dependent in situ PXRD using the same sample (S1) within onsynthesisS1,whichresultsinNTU-9-duponevacuationand -notinaphasemixture(Fig.5,S14andS15†). -thetemperaturerangeofsolventrelease,i.e.,upto220°C.The -| heating | results | in changes | in | peak | intensity, | attributed | to the | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Characterisationofthenewform(NTU-9-d) -| release | of adsorbed | solvent | molecules | | and | peak broadening, | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| indicating | a decrease | | in crystallinity. | | The absence | | of a strong | | | | | | | | | -WederivedastructuralmodelofthedistortedNTU-9-dfromthe -| peak shi | illustrates | the | low | thermal | expansion | of | NTU-9 and | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PXRDdata.Startingfromthetrigonalstructureofnon-distorted -showsitsratherstrongthermalstability,astheoverallpattern NTU-9,wegraduallyreducedthespacegroupsymmetryandper- -| and, therefore, | | the framework | | of NTU-9 | remains | unchanged. | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -formedglobaloptimisationofthelatticeparametersbyperform- -The 100 and 110 peaks do not change positions but broaden, ingmultipleRietveldrenements45(furtherdetailsaregiveninthe -whereas the other peaks shi to slightly higher 2q values, ESI†).Eventually,wewereabletodescribethediffractiondataof -| indicating | smaller | lattice | parameters | | as the | loss | of guest | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -thedistortedNTU-9byusingatriclinicunitcellwithspacegroup -moleculeslikelyleadstoasmallerlatticecontraction(Fig.4b). P1 (cid:1) (Table2).Aerdistortion,NTU-9iscontractedalongtheaaxis -A typical activation procedure for MOFs employs heating andthebanglesignicantlydecreases.Thisleadstoadecreaseof -Different -under dynamic vacuum.46 activation procedures for 9%inunitcellvolumefrom2192(2)Å3to1995(4)Å3(activationvia -NTU-9 are reported, e.g., 120 °C under vacuum overnight,32 vacuumat60°C)andtoanellipsoidalporedistortion.(TableS3†) -| dried at | 60 °C,35 | without | dynamic | | vacuum, | or 80 | °C under | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thisbehaviourisunusualin2Dframeworksasitisnottheelastic -axisc(layerdistance)thatchanges,butthedistortionoccursinthe -ab-plane,whichresultsintheporedeformation.Theporechannel -runningalongthec-directionisslightlytiltedandperpendicularto -theab-plane(Fig.6).AertheRietveldrenementusingonlythe -signicant -| | | | | | | | | node and | the linkers, | a | | amount | of residual | electron | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | density is | still | visible within | the | pores (Fig. | S13†). | The | broad, | -signicant -| | | | | | | | | anisotropic | peak | shape of | NTU-9-d | indicates | a | | struc- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | -turaldisorderofthedistortedframework.Thisledtoinstabilities -inthenalRietveldrenements,whenweattemptedtorenethe -| | | | | | | | | cation and | linker | position. | Consequently, | | we can | neither | report | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | -(a)TGAdataofS1,heatingrate5Kmin−1undersyntheticair -| Fig.4 | | | | | | | | reliablebondanglesandlengthsbetweenthetitaniumnodesand | | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -atmosphere(flowrate70mLmin−1)(black)andthederivationofthe -| | | | | | | | | the linker | molecules | nor | quantify | the residual | amount | of | guest | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | -TGAdata(lightgreen).(b)Temperaturedependent(30–220°C)insitu -moleculeswithinthepores. -| PXRD measurements | | including | | selected | reflection | indices | using an | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | We investigated | | the nature | of | this structural | | distortion | by | -| open capillary | of | S1. Dotted | lines | are included | to | indicate | the peak | | | | | | | | | -differentactivationmethods:evaporationatroomtemperature/ -shifts. -©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 | 13649 +Dataset Type Input #Inputs Evidence Verdict Sources Lang +CredBank(MitraandGilbert,2015) Worthy Aggregate 1,049 Meta 5Classes Twitter En +Weibo(Maetal.,2016) Worthy Aggregate 5,656 Meta 2Classes Twitter/Weibo En/Ch +PHEME(Zubiagaetal.,2016) Worthy Individual 330 Text/Meta 3Classes Twitter En/De +RumourEval19(Gorrelletal.,2019) Worthy Individual 446 Text/Meta 3Classes Twitter/Reddit En +DAST(Lillieetal.,2019) Worthy Individual 220 Text/Meta 3Classes Reddit Da +Suspicious(Volkovaetal.,2017) Worthy Individual 131,584 (cid:55) 2/5Classes Twitter En +CheckThat20-T1(Barrón-Cedeñoetal.,2020) Worthy Individual 8,812 (cid:55) Ranking Twitter En/Ar +CheckThat21-T1A(Nakovetal.,2021b) Worthy Individual 17,282 (cid:55) 2Classes Twitter Many +Debate(Hassanetal.,2015) Worthy Statement 1,571 (cid:55) 3Classes Transcript En +ClaimRank(Genchevaetal.,2017) Worthy Statement 5,415 (cid:55) Ranking Transcript En +CheckThat18-T1(Atanasovaetal.,2018) Worthy Statement 16,200 (cid:55) Ranking Transcript En/Ar +CitationReason(Redietal.,2019) Checkable Statement 4,000 Meta 13Classes Wikipedia En +PolitiTV(Konstantinovskiyetal.,2021) Checkable Statement 6,304 (cid:55) 7Classes Transcript En +Table1: Summaryofclaimdetectiondatasets. Inputcanbeasetofposts(aggregate)oranindividualpostfrom +socialmedia,orastatement. Evidenceincludetextandmetadata. Verdictcanbeamulti-classlabeloraranklist. +pieces of evidence were used to reach a verdict. putisasocialmediapostwithtextualcontent. Zu- +However,ajustificationmustalsoexplainhowthe biaga et al. (2016) constructed PHEME based on +retrievedevidencewasused, explainanyassump- sourcetweetsinEnglishandGermanthatsparked +tions or commonsense facts employed, and show a high number of retweets exceeding a prede- +the reasoning process taken to reach the verdict. fined threshold. Derczynski et al. (2017) intro- +Presentingtheevidencereturnedbyaretrievalsys- duced the shared task RumourEval using the En- +temcanassuchbeseenasaratherweakbaseline glishsectionofPHEME;forthe2019iterationof +for justification production, as it does not explain the shared task, this dataset was further expanded +theprocessusedtoreachtheverdict. Thereisfur- to include Reddit and new Twitter posts (Gor- +thermore a subtle difference between evaluation rell et al., 2019). Following the same annotation +criteria for evidence and justifications: good ev- strategy, Lillie et al. (2019) constructed a Dan- +idence facilitates the production of a correct ver- ish dataset by collecting posts from Reddit. In- +dict; a good justification accurately reflects the stead of considering only source tweets, subtasks +reasoning of the model through a readable and inCheckThat(Barrón-Cedeñoetal.,2020;Nakov +plausible explanation, regardless of the correct- et al., 2021b) viewed every post as part of the in- +ness of the verdict. This introduces different con- put. A set of auxiliary questions, such as “does +siderations for justification production, e.g. read- it contain a factual claim?”, “is it of general in- +ability (how accessible an explanation is to hu- terest?”, were created to help annotators identify +mans), plausibility (how convincing an explana- check-worthyposts. Sinceanindividualpostmay +tionis),andfaithfulness(howaccuratelyanexpla- contain limited context, other works (Mitra and +nationreflectsthereasoningofthemodel)(Jacovi Gilbert,2015;Maetal.,2016;Zhangetal.,2021) +andGoldberg,2020). represented each claim by a set of relevant posts, +e.g.thethreadtheyoriginatefrom. +3 Datasets +The second type of textual input is a document +Datasetscanbeanalysedalongthreeaxesaligned consistingofmultipleclaims. ForDebate(Hassan +with three stages of the fact-checking framework et al., 2015), professionals were asked to select +(Figure 2): the input, the evidence used, and ver- check-worthy claims from U.S. presidential de- +dicts and justifications which constitute the out- batestoensuregoodagreementandsharedunder- +put. In this section we bring together efforts that standing of the assumptions. On the other hand, +emerged in different communities using different Konstantinovskiyetal.(2021)collectedcheckable +terminologies, but nevertheless could be used to claimsfromtranscriptsbycrowd-sourcing,where +developandevaluatemodelsforthesametask. workerslabelledclaimsbasedonapredefinedtax- +onomy. Differentfrompriorworksfocusedonthe +3.1 Input +political domain, Redi et al. (2019) sampled sen- +We first consider the inputs to claim detection tences that contain citations from Wikipedia arti- +(summarized in Table 1) as their format and con- cles, and asked crowd-workers to annotate them +tentinfluencestherestoftheprocess. Atypicalin- basedoncitationpolicies. -View Article Online -| ChemicalScience | | | | | | | | | | | | | EdgeArticle | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -CellparametersofNTU-9andtheresultingparametersofthemodelfromNTU-9-dbydifferentactivationmethods -Table2 -Activationprocedure As-synthesised 120°C,7h 120°C,N 2 ,7h scCO 2 Vacuum,rt Vacuum,60°C -Polytype NTU-9 NTU-9 NTU-9-d(83.8wt%)NTU-9(16.2wt%) NTU-9-d NTU-9-d NTU-9-d -| | | (cid:1) | | (cid:1) | | (cid:1) | | | | (cid:1) | (cid:1) | | (cid:1) | | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| Spacegroup | | P31c | | P31c | | P1 | | | | P1 | P1 | | P1 | | -| a/Å | | 14.63(1) | | 14.62(1) | | 13.24(1) | | | | 14.15(1) | 13.42(1) | | 13.24(2) | | -| b/Å | | 14.63(1) | | 14.62(1) | | 15.23(1) | | | | 15.00(1) | 15.36(1) | | 15.14(2) | | -| c/Å | | 11.82(1) | | 11.53(1) | | 11.35(1) | | | | 11.50(1) | 11.37(1) | | 11.31(2) | | -| a/° | | 90 | | 90 | | 94.5(1) | | | | 92.3(1) | 94.2(1) | | 94.3(1) | | -| b/° | | 90 | | 90 | | 79.9(1) | | | | 85.6(1) | 80.6(1) | | 79.9(1) | | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT g/° 120 120 116.0(1) 118.5(1) 117.1(1) 116.6(1) -V/Å3 -| | | 2192(1) | | 2133(1) | | 2026(1) | | | | 2138(2) | 2060(2) | | 1995(4) | | -| --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO -ambientpressure(overnight),heatingat120°Cunderambient To the best of our knowledge, no external stimuli-induced -exible -pressure (7 h), heating at 120 °C under continuous nitrogen behaviour for polymorphs of NTU-9 such as MIL-167- -stream (7 h), supercritical CO activation (scCO ), and under 169 or FIR-117-119 has been reported as yet.17,44 However, -| | | | 2 | | 2 | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -exibility -dynamic vacuum (with or without additional heating). We some studies were reported for FIR-131-138, with -different -observed that NTU-9-d formation was triggered by dynamic sulfonated linker, when soaking crystals in -| vacuum, scCO | , | or heating | in | a continuous | nitrogen | ow, | solvents.49,50 | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2 -inuence -whereas drying the sample up to 220 °C at 1 bar (ambient To investigate the vacuum on the distortion of -pressure) did not distort the framework (Fig. 4b). The rened NTU-9 in more detail, we performed in situ PXRD under -cellparametersofthedifferentlyactivatedsamplesS1showthat dynamicvacuum.SampleS1wasrstheatedto60°Cfollowed -byastepwisereductioninpressure,eventuallyreachinganal -| the cell distortion | | varies | depending | on the | activation | process. | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -For the sample dried with only heat under nitrogen stream dynamicvacuumof3×10 −3mbarwhileconstantlymeasuring -| | | | | | | | diffraction | | | | rst, | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -a mixture of NTU-9 and NTU-9-d is present. For the scCO 2 - patterns (Fig. 7a). At NTU-9 remained undis- -activatedsample,weobservedlesspronouncedchangesinthe torted when heating at 60 °C and under ambient pressure. A -cellparameterscomparedtothevacuum-activatedanalogue;by slight decrease of the c-axis (Fig. 7b, green squares) indicates -dynamicvacuumexposure,weobtainedamoredistortedpore the incipient release of solvent molecules. Further pressure -withanoverallsmallercellvolume,whichcanbeampliedby decreaseto200mbarinitiatestheformationofNTU-9-d,indi- -catedbythedegenerationofthea-andb-axesandthea-andb- -additionalheat.Wecanstatethatdryingundervacuumdistorts -theporemostefficiently(Table2,Fig.S16andS17†). angles(Fig.7bandc).Thegradualdistortionofthetrigonalunit -Although vacuum-induced structural transformations in celltowardstriclinicmetricsandthereductionoftheunitcell -rst -MOFs have been investigated,47 this is the time that the volumecontinueswithfurtherreducingthepressure.Interest- -exibility behaviour ofNTU-9 hasbeen reported. We hypothe- ingly,thetransitionfromNTU-9toitsdistortedformdoesnot -sisethatthedifferencesbetweensynthesisprotocols(S1vs.S2) affectthecontractionbehaviouroftheelasticc-axis. -in the activation process (NTU-9-d vs. phase mixture) can be TheformationofNTU-9-dcanalsobefollowedbyinsituTHz -either explained by the difference in crystallite size which is Raman spectroscopy in dynamic vacuum at 60 °C. Changes -known to impact dynamic framework transitions,48 or by the from the initial spectrum compared to the vacuum evacuated -differenceinthekindorpositionoftheguestmoleculeswithin sample (S1) at different pressure values between 0 and 1100 -the pores. We noticed a difference by nuclear magnetic reso- mbar and 60 °C can be observed (Fig. S6b and c†). The vibra- -nance(NMR)ofthedigestedsampleswithandwithoutmodu- tions of the organic H dhta linker dominate the Raman spec- -4 -lator. In synthesis S1 , the digested sample shows residual trum.HerewemainlyfocusontheTi–Ostretchingbandaround -5d -| aceticacid(Fig.S18†). | | | | | | | −1.43,51 | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -------- | ---------------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 683 cm | The | band | broadening | in | the process | of | vacuum | -| | | | | | | | exposure | indicates | changes | in | the Ti–O | bond | upon | pore | -| | | | | | | | distortion. | We can | assume | that, | as proven | for | Zr-MOFs, | node | -| | | | | | | | distortion | caused | by guest | removal/addition | | can | also | occur in | -Ti-MOFs.52Broadeningcanalsobeobservedinthesymmetrical -−1.43 -| | | | | | | | stretching | vibration | mode | around | 700 | cm | This | spectro- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | -scopicresulthintsattheformationofthedistortedformNTU-9- -| | | | | | | | d and, | in particular, | | indicates | changes | in | the octahedral | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -titanium-linkercoordination(Fig.S6bandc†). -CO gasadsorptionexperimentswereconductedtoanalyse -2 -| | | | | | | | porosity | and adsorption | | behaviour | of | NTU-9-d | (S1). | The CO 2 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | ----------- | ------------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | adsorption | isotherm | was | collected | at | 273 K | and resembles | | -| | | | | | | | a type I | isotherm, | indicating | the | present | micro-pores | | (<2 nm) | -| | | | | | | | (Fig.S19a†). | NTU-9-dadsorbed72cm3g | | | | −1ofCO | | | -Fig.6 StructuralmodelofNTU-9-d'sdistortedcrystalstructureupon 2 witha total -vacuumexposure(a)intheab-planeand(b)alongthec-axis.Green pore volume of 0.15 cm3 g −1 and a calculated Brunauer– -ellipsoidal cylinders represents the random distribution of solvent Emmett–Teller = m2 −1 -| | | | | | | | | | (BET) | surface | area of | S BET | 199 | g | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | -moleculeswithinthechannels. -13650 | Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 ©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry +Dataset Input #Inputs Evidence Verdict Sources Lang +CrimeVeri(Bachenkoetal.,2008) Statement 275 (cid:55) 2Classes Crime En +Politifact(VlachosandRiedel,2014) Statement 106 Text/Meta 5Classes FactCheck En +StatsProperties(VlachosandRiedel,2015) Statement 7,092 KG Numeric Internet En +Emergent(FerreiraandVlachos,2016) Statement 300 Text 3Classes Emergent En +CreditAssess(Popatetal.,2016) Statement 5,013 Text 2Classes FactCheck/Wiki En +PunditFact(Rashkinetal.,2017) Statement 4,361 (cid:55) 2/6Classes FactCheck En +Liar(Wang,2017) Statement 12,836 Meta 6Classes FactCheck En +Verify(Balyetal.,2018) Statement 422 Text 2Classes FactCheck Ar/En +CheckThat18-T2(Barrón-Cedeñoetal.,2018) Statement 150 (cid:55) 3Classes Transcript En +Snopes(Hanselowskietal.,2019) Statement 6,422 Text 3Classes FactCheck En +MultiFC(Augensteinetal.,2019) Statement 36,534 Text/Meta 2-27Classes FactCheck En +Climate-FEVER(Diggelmannetal.,2020) Statement 1,535 Text 4Classes Climate En +SciFact(Waddenetal.,2020) Statement 1,409 Text 3Classes Science En +PUBHEALTH(KotonyaandToni,2020b) Statement 11,832 Text 4Classes FactCheck En +COVID-Fact(Saakyanetal.,2021) Statement 4,086 Text 2Classes Forum En +X-Fact(GuptaandSrikumar,2021) Statement 31,189 Text 7Classes FactCheck Many +cQA(Mihaylovaetal.,2018) Answer 422 Meta 2Classes Forum En +AnswerFact(Zhangetal.,2020) Answer 60,864 Text 5Classes Amazon En +NELA(Horneetal.,2018) Article 136,000 (cid:55) 2Classes News En +BuzzfeedNews(Potthastetal.,2018) Article 1,627 Meta 4Classes Facebook En +BuzzFace(SantiaandWilliams,2018) Article 2,263 Meta 4Classes Facebook En +FA-KES(Salemetal.,2019) Article 804 (cid:55) 2Classes VDC En +FakeNewsNet(Shuetal.,2020) Article 23,196 Meta 2Classes FactCheck En +FakeCovid(ShahiandNandini,2020) Article 5,182 (cid:55) 2Classes FactCheck Many +Table2:Summaryoffactualverificationdatasetswithnaturalinputs.KGdenotesknowledgegraphs.ChectThat18 +hasbeenextendedlater(Hasanainetal.,2019;Barrón-Cedeñoetal.,2020;Nakovetal.,2021b). NELAhasbeen +updatedbyaddingmoredatafrommorediversesources(Nørregaardetal.,2019;Gruppietal.,2020,2021) +Next, we discuss the inputs to factual verifica- correctisproblematic,andthusrarelypractisedby +tion. The most popular type of input to verifi- humanfact-checkers(UscinskiandButler,2013). +cation is textual claims, which is expected given In order to better control the complexity of +theyareoftentheoutputofclaimdetection. These the task, efforts listed in Table 3 created claims +tend to be sentence-level statements, which is artificially. Thorne et al. (2018a) had annota- +a practice common among fact-checkers in or- tors mutate sentences from Wikipedia articles to +der to include only the context relevant to the create claims. Following the same approach, +claim (Mena, 2019). Many existing efforts (Vla- Khouja (2020) and Nørregaard and Derczynski +chosandRiedel,2014;Wang,2017;Hanselowski (2021) constructed Arabic and Danish datasets +et al., 2019; Augenstein et al., 2019) constructed respectively. Another frequently considered op- +datasets by crawling real-world claims from ded- tion is subject-predicate-object triples, e.g. (Lon- +icated websites (e.g. Politifact) due to their avail- don, city_in, UK). The popularity of triples as in- +ability (see Table 2). Unlike previous work that put stems from the fact that they facilitate fact- +focusonEnglish,GuptaandSrikumar(2021)col- checking against knowledge bases (Ciampaglia +lectednon-Englishclaimsfrom25languages. et al., 2015; Shi and Weninger, 2016; Shiralkar +et al., 2017; Kim and Choi, 2020) such as DB- +Others extract claims from specific domains, +pedia (Auer et al., 2007), SemMedDB (Kilicoglu +such as science (Wadden et al., 2020), cli- +et al., 2012), and KBox (Nam et al., 2018). How- +mate (Diggelmann et al., 2020), and public +ever, such approaches implicitly assume the non- +health (Kotonya and Toni, 2020b). Alternative +trivialconversionoftextintotriples. +forms of sentence-level inputs, such as answers +from question answering forums, have also been +3.2 Evidence +considered (Mihaylova et al., 2018; Zhang et al., +2020). There have been approaches that consider A popular type of evidence often considered is +apassage(MihalceaandStrapparava,2009;Pérez- metadata, such as publication date, sources, user +Rosasetal.,2018)oranentirearticle(Horneetal., profiles, etc. However, while it offers informa- +2018;SantiaandWilliams,2018;Shuetal.,2020) tion complementary to textual sources or struc- +as input. However, the implicit assumption that turalknowledgewhichisusefulwhenthelatterare +every claim in it is either factually correct or in- unavailable (Wang, 2017; Potthast et al., 2018), it -View Article Online -| EdgeArticle | | | | | | | | | | | | ChemicalScience | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO -Fig. 7 (a) In situ diffraction data of sample S1. The pressure was (a)InsituPXRDmeasurementofopencapillaryofvacuumdried -Fig.8 -gradually reduced from ambient pressureto dynamic vacuumat 10 ± -| | | | | | | | | S1 over | time (RH | of 25 | 5%). Evolution | of (b) | lattice | parameter | -| ------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ----- | -------------- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -| mbar at | 60 °C. | Evolution | of (b) | lattice | parameter | changes, | volume | | | | | | | | -changes,volumechanges,and(c)theunitcellanglechangesduring -changes, and (c) the unit cell angle changes during in situ vacuum therehydrationofNTU-9-dbyambientatmosphere. -PXRD. -theambientatmosphere,indicatingarelativelyslowwateruptake -(Fig.S19b†).Thecalculatedporesizedistributionsiscentredat -fromtheatmosphere(Fig.S6d†). -S19c†). -0.6 nm (Fig. In comparison to a reported similar WeconrmedbyexsituPXRDthatresuspendingNTU-9-din -| procedure | for | S2 from | Cai | et al. (2 | d reaction | | time, without | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -differentsolvents(ethanol,water,acetonitrile)overnightresults -ethanol solvent exchange), the CO 2 uptake of NTU-9 (no peak S21andS22†). Differentsolvent -inthe recoveryofNTU-9(Fig. -| splitting | observed) | is | about | 12% higher | with | a | largely higher | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ---- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -moleculesinsidethelledchannelsleadtoslightdifferencesin -| BET surface | area | (917 | m2 g −1 | from | N sorption | | data).34 These | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 2 | | | thelatticeparameters,inparticularinthelengthoftheelasticc- | | | | | | | -differences -| | could | originate | from | the | tendency | of | S1 to distort, | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----- | --------- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | axis, of | the resulting | undistorted | | NTU-9 (Table | S5), | demon- | -whichcausesloweraccessibilityofthematerial'spores,result- -stratingtheadaptivenatureoftheframeworktowardsdifferent -inginloweruptakeandBETsurfacearea.PXRDdataaergas -guestmolecules.Interestingly,weobservethatthereversibility, -| adsorption | experiments | | indicate | the | stability | of | the distorted | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | | from NTU-9-d | to | NTU-9, | is signicantly | faster | in | the liquid | -pore(Fig.S19d,S20andTableS4†). -| | | | | | | | | phase compared | | to the | gas phase. | We demonstrated | | full | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --------------------- | ---------- | --------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | reversibility | of this | desolvation-solvation | | process | over | 5 cycles | -byPXRD(Fig.S23†). -ReversibilityofthedeformationofNTU-9 -Aerapplyingvacuum,NTU-9-dcanbetransformedbackinto -its original state by exposure to moisture. We monitored the Conclusions -| structural | changes | upon | water | uptake | of | NTU-9-d | from the | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ambient atmosphere (22 °C, 25, 5% R.H.) in an open glass In this work, we explore the impact and reproducibility of the -capillary with an opening diameter of 0.7 mm by PXRD over synthesis conditions on the formation of the layered Ti-MOF -aperiodof42hours(Fig.8). NTU-9. We observe that the selection of solvent, additive, and -inuenced -The c-lattice parameter is hardly by the water reactiontimeiscrucialforareliable,reproduciblesynthesisof -uptake (Fig. 8b, light green), whereas the a- and b-axis exhibit the phase pure material. Using pure acetic acid as modulator -signicant -changes. Initially, both the a- and the b-axis expand and solvent at 120 °C leads to the reproducible formation of -upon exposure to ambient conditions (Fig. 8d, cyan and olive), large NTU-9 crystals. When long reaction times of at least 10 -whichleadstoarapidincreaseintheunitcellvolume(Fig.8b, daysareapplied,thepresenceofaceticacidintheframework -| | Aer | | | | | | | | | aer | | | | | -| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -black). approximately three hours, the b-axis starts con- can be detected, even vigorous post-synthetic washing -tractingwhileakeepsexpanding,leadingtoanoverallexpansion steps. Solvothermal synthesis in an i-PrOH:MeCN mixture -oftheunitcellvolume.Bothunitcellaxesbecomemoresimilarin without a modulator at 120 °C is faster (1 day) and can be -length, and the g-angle between a and b expands towards 120° further sped up using microwave-assisted synthesis (15 min), -(Fig.8c,lightgreen).Whilethea-angleslightlydecreasestowards butyieldssmallerNTU-9crystals. -90°,theb-anglerapidlyexpandsto90°(Fig.8c,cyanandolive). Pure heat treatment of the solvated MOFs up to 220 °C and -Consequently, water uptake from the atmosphere distorts the ambient pressure removes large amounts of the incorporated -ellipsoidalporebacktowardstheroundshapeofNTU-9,andthe guestsolventmoleculeswithoutchangingtheframework'sstruc- -tilted channel becomes more perpendicular to the ab-plane. ture. However, activating the material with heating under -Despitethefactthatthecellrelaxestowardsthetrigonalmetricof a nitrogen ow, scCO , or vacuum results in a previously -2 -NTU-9,itdoesnotreachthisstateaer42hoursofexposureto -| | | | | | | | | unknown, | distorted | structure, | abbreviated | as | NTU-9-d. | The | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | -©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 | 13651 +Dataset Input #Inputs Evidence Verdict Sources Lang +KLinker(Ciampagliaetal.,2015) Triple 10,000 KG 2Classes Google/Wiki En +PredPath(ShiandWeninger,2016) Triple 3,559 KG 2Classes Google/Wiki En +KStream(Shiralkaretal.,2017) Triple 18,431 KG 2Classes Google/Wiki En +UFC(KimandChoi,2020) Triple 1,759 KG 2Classes Wiki En +LieDetect(MihalceaandStrapparava,2009) Passage 600 (cid:55) 2Classes News En +FakeNewsAMT(Pérez-Rosasetal.,2018) Passage 680 (cid:55) 2Classes News En +FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018a) Statement 185,445 Text 3Classes Wiki En +HOVER(Jiangetal.,2020) Statement 26,171 Text 2Classes Wiki En +WikiFactCheck(Satheetal.,2020) Statement 124,821 Text 2Classes Wiki En +VitaminC(Schusteretal.,2021) Statement 488,904 Text 3Classes Wiki En +TabFact(Chenetal.,2020) Statement 92,283 Table 2Classes Wiki En +InfoTabs(Guptaetal.,2020) Statement 23,738 Table 3Classes Wiki En +Sem-Tab-Fact(Wangetal.,2021) Statement 5,715 Table 3Classes Wiki En +FEVEROUS(Alyetal.,2021) Statement 87,026 Text/Table 3Classes Wiki En +ANT(Khouja,2020) Statement 4,547 (cid:55) 3Classes News Ar +DanFEVER(NørregaardandDerczynski,2021) Statement 6,407 Text 3Classes Wiki Da +Table3:Summaryoffactualverificationdatasetswithartificialinputs.GoogledenotesGoogleRelationExtraction +Corpora,andWSDMmeanstheWSDMCup2017TripleScoringchallenge. +doesnotprovideevidencegroundingtheclaim. evidence, while information that is necessary for +Textualsources,suchasnewsarticles,academic verificationismissing. +papers, and Wikipedia documents, are one of the Though the majority of studies focus on un- +most commonly used types of evidence for fact- structured evidence (i.e. textual sources), struc- +checking. Ferreira and Vlachos (2016) used the turedknowledgehasalsobeenused. Forexample, +headlines of selected news articles, and Pomer- thetruthfulnessofaclaimexpressedasanedgein +leau and Rao (2017) used the entire articles in- aknowledgebase(e.g.DBpedia)canbepredicted +stead as the evidence for the same claims. In- by the graph topology (Ciampaglia et al., 2015; +stead of using news articles, Alhindi et al. (2018) Shi and Weninger, 2016; Shiralkar et al., 2017). +and Hanselowski et al. (2019) extracted sum- However, while graph topology can be an indica- +mariesaccompanyingfact-checkingarticlesabout tor of plausibility, it does not provide conclusive +the claims as evidence. Documents from special- evidence. Aclaimthatisnotrepresentedbyapath +ized domains such as science and public health in the graph, or that is represented by an unlikely +have also been considered (Wadden et al., 2020; path,isnotnecessarilyfalse. Theknowledgebase +KotonyaandToni,2020b;Zhangetal.,2020). approach assumes that true facts relevant to the +The aforementioned works assume that evi- claim are present in the graph; but given the in- +dence is given for every claim, which is not con- completenessofeventhelargestknowledgebases, +ducivetodevelopingsystemsthatneedtoretrieve this is not realistic (Bordes et al., 2013; Socher +evidence from a large knowledge source. There- etal.,2013). +fore, Thorne et al. (2018a) and Jiang et al. (2020) Another type of structural knowledge is semi- +considered Wikipedia as the source of evidence structured data (e.g. tables), which is ubiquitous +andannotatedthesentencessupportingorrefuting thanks to its ability to convey important infor- +eachclaim. Schusteretal.(2021)constructedVi- mation in a concise and flexible manner. Early +taminCbasedonfactualrevisionstoWikipedia,in work by Vlachos and Riedel (2015) used tables +which evidence pairs are nearly identical in lan- extractedfromFreebase(Bollackeretal.,2008)to +guage and content, with the exception that one verify claims retrieved from the web about statis- +supports a claim while the other does not. How- ticsofcountriessuchaspopulation, inflation, etc. +ever,theseeffortsrestrictedworldknowledgetoa Chen et al. (2020) and Gupta et al. (2020) stud- +single source (Wikipedia), ignoring the challenge iedfact-checkingtextualclaimsagainsttablesand +ofretrievingevidencefromheterogeneoussources info-boxesfromWikipedia. Wangetal.(2021)ex- +on the web. To address this, other works (Popat tracted tables from scientific articles and required +et al., 2016; Baly et al., 2018; Augenstein et al., evidence selection in the form of cells selected +2019)retrievedevidencefromtheInternet,butthe from tables. Aly et al. (2021) further considered +searchresultswerenotannotated. Thus, itispos- both text and table for factual verification, while +sible that irrelevant information is present in the explicitlyrequiringtheretrievalofevidence. -ChemicalScience EdgeArticle -structuraldistortiontransformsthecircularporechannelsintoan research and innovation programme under the Marie -ellipsoidal shape and reduces the unit cell volume by 9%. The Skłodowska-Curie Actions (Grant Agreement No. 101208213, -distortion mechanism is primarily governed by compression MUVCATMOF,HORIZON-MSCA-2024-PF-01-01).TheFondsder -withinthehardcoordinationplane(ab-plane,metal–ligandcoor- Chemischen Industrie (Kekul´e stipend to J. E. K.) is gratefully -dinationconnectivity),withonlyminorchangesintheelasticaxis acknowledged.B.O.-R.gratefullyacknowledgesapostdoctoral -c(layerstackingviahydrogenbonding).Thisresultisparticularly scholarship from the Max Planck Society and the European -interesting, as it contradicts the prevailing assumption that the Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme -soconnectivitybetweenlayerspredominantlydrivesexibilityin for the receipt of a Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions Post- -2Dlayeredframeworks.Ramanspectroscopyindicatesadistortion doctoral Fellowship. Deutsche Forschungsgemeinscha (DFG) -oftheoctahedralcoordinationgeometryofthetitaniumcations. (project-ID358283783,SFB1333/2),S.K.acknowledgessupport -Interestingly,thesynthesisconditionsstronglyaffecttheexibility fromtheCarl-Zeiss-StiungNEXUSprogram. -oftheMOFstructure,wheresamplessynthesisedwithoutmodu- -latoryieldsmallercrystalsandshowalowertendencyfordistor- References -tion.ThedriedanddistortedMOFisabletotakeupwaterfrom -the atmosphere and a variety of polar and non-polar solvent 1 S.L.James,Metal-organicframeworks,Chem.Soc.Rev.,2003, -moleculesfromtheliquidphase,leadingtoareversiblestructural 32,276–288. -relaxationintotheundistortedformofNTU-9overseveralcycles. 2 H. Furukawa, K. E. Cordova, M. O'Keeffe and O. M. Yaghi, -Incorporating different solvent molecules into the structure of The Chemistry and Applications of Metal-Organic -NTU-9 leads to signicant changes in the elastic c-axis lattice Frameworks,Science,2013,341,1230444. -parameters,whichcorrespondtotheinterlayerdistance.Despite 3 A. J. Howarth, A. W. Peters, N. A. Vermeulen, T. C. Wang, -the observed large exibility of the framework, the long-range J. T. Hupp and O. K. Farha, Best Practices for the -orderisstillmaintainedaermultiplecyclesofde-andresolva- Synthesis, Activation, and Characterization of Metal– -tionandtheassociatedporedistortionandrelaxation. OrganicFrameworks,Chem.Mat.,2017,29,26–39. -This work illustrates the oen-overlooked dynamic proper- 4 R.G.Pearson,HardandSoAcidsandBases,J.Am.Chem. -ties of reticular materials in general and Ti-based MOFs in Soc.,1963,85,3533–3539. -particular under solvent evacuation/resuspension. Our study 5 A. Dhakshinamoorthy, Z. Li and H. Garcia, Catalysis and -thus suggests that thorough characterisation of reticular photocatalysis by metal organic frameworks, Chem. Soc. -materials for each process is essential to deeply understand Rev.,2018,47,8134–8172. -frameworkbehaviouranditsresultingapplications. 6 M. Dan-Hardi, C. Serre, T. Frot, L. Rozes, G. Maurin, -C. Sanchez and G. F´erey, A New Photoactive Crystalline -Data availability Highly Porous Titanium(IV) Dicarboxylate, J. Am. Chem. -Soc.,2009,131,10857–10859. -Thedata supportingthisarticle havebeenincludedaspartof 7 A. Cadiau, N. Kolobov, S. Srinivasan, M. G. Goesten, -the ESI.† The authors have cited additional references within H. Haspel, A. V. Bavykina, M. R. Tchalala, P. Maity, -theESI.†53–59. A. Goryachev, A. S. Poryvaev, M. Eddaoudi, M. V. Fedin, -O. F. Mohammed and J. Gascon, A Titanium Metal– -Author contributions Organic Framework with Visible-Light-Responsive -Photocatalytic Activity, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed., 2020, 59, -J.E.K.andS.B.conceivedtheideaoftheproject.J.E.K.syn- 13468–13472. -thesisedandcharacterisedthemetal–organicframework.F.H. 8 M. Sachs, L. Harnett-Cauleld, E. Pastor, B. Davies, -performedCO sorptionmeasurements.K.Gj.measuredthein D. J. C. Sowood, B. Moss, A. Kazas, J. Nelson, A. Walsh -2 -situ Raman data, A. S. the in situ vacuum PXRD data. S. B. andJ.R.Durrant,Ligandeldstatescontrolphotocatalytic -performedtheinsiturehydrationmeasurementsandtheRiet- efficiency of transition metal oxides, in preparation, -veld renements. J. E. K. wrote the manuscript with contribu- ChemRxiv,2024,DOI:10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-2wn0d. -tionsfromallauthors.Allauthorsreadandcommentedonthe 9 B.Bueken,F.Vermoortele,D.E.P.Vanpoucke,H.Reinsch, -nalmanuscript. C. C. Tsou, P. Valvekens, T. D. Baerdemaeker, R. Ameloot, -C. E. A. Kirschhock, V. Van Speybroeck, J. M. Mayer and -Conflicts of interest D. De Vos, A Flexible Photoactive Titanium Metal–Organic -Framework Based on a [Ti(IV) (m -O)(O) (COO) ] Cluster, -3 3 2 6 -Therearenoconictstodeclare. Angew.Chem.,Int.Ed.,2015,54,13912–13917. -10 T.DevicandC.Serre,Highvalence3pandtransitionmetal -Acknowledgements basedMOFs,Chem.Soc.Rev.,2014,43,6097–6115. -11 L.RozesandC.Sanchez,Titaniumoxo-clusters:precursors -The authors gratefully acknowledge the help of Viola Duppel for a Lego-like construction of nanostructured hybrid -(MPI-FKF)fortheSEMimagesandNadineWeib(MPI-FKF)for materials,Chem.Soc.Rev.,2011,40,1006–1030. -the TGA measurements. Financial support was granted by the 12 H.L.Nguyen,Perspectivesontitanium-basedmetal–organic -MaxPlanckSocietyandtheEuropeanUnion'sHorizonEurope frameworks,JPhysEnergy,2021,3,021003. -13652 | Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 ©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry -.MP -00:74:5 -6202/7/5 -no -dedaolnwoD -.5202 enuJ -52 -no -dehsilbuP -.elcitrA -sseccA -nepO -.ecneciL -detropnU -0.3 -noitubirttA -snommoC -evitaerC -a -rednu -desnecil -si -elcitra -sihT -View Article Online +3.3 Verdict&Justification 4 ModellingStrategies +Wenowturntosurveyingmodellingstrategiesfor +Theverdictinearlyefforts(Bachenkoetal.,2008; +the various components of our framework. The +Mihalcea and Strapparava, 2009) is a binary la- +bel, i.e. true/false. However, fact-checkers usu- most common approach is to build separate mod- +elsforeachcomponentandapplytheminpipeline +ally employ multi-class labels to represent de- +grees of truthfulness (e.g. true, mostly-true, mix- fashion. Nevertheless, joint approaches have also +ture,etc),4 whichwereconsideredbyVlachosand been developed, either through end-to-end learn- +ing or by modelling the joint output distributions +Riedel(2014)andWang(2017). Recently,Augen- +ofmultiplecomponents. +stein et al. (2019) collected claims from different +sources, where the number of labels vary greatly, +4.1 ClaimDetection +ranging from 2 to 27. Due to the difficulty of +mapping veracity labels onto the same scale, they Claim detection is typically framed as a classifi- +didn’t attempt to harmonize them across sources. cation task, where models predict whether claims +On the other hand, other efforts (Hanselowski are checkable or check-worthy. This is challeng- +et al., 2019; Kotonya and Toni, 2020b; Gupta and ing,especiallyinthecaseofcheck-worthiness: ru- +Srikumar,2021)performednormalizationbypost- mourous and non-rumourous information is often +processingthelabelsbasedonrulestosimplifythe difficult to distinguish, and the volume of claims +veracity label. For example, Hanselowski et al. analysed in real-world scenarios – e.g. all posts +(2019) mapped mixture, unproven, and undeter- publishedtoasocialnetworkeveryday–prohibits +mined ontonotenoughinformation. the retrieval and use of evidence. Early systems +employed supervised classifiers with feature en- +Unlike prior datasets that only required out- +gineering, relying on surface features like Reddit +puttingverdicts,FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018a)ex- +karma and up-votes (Aker et al., 2017), Twitter- +pected the output to contain both sentences form- +specific types (Enayet and El-Beltagy, 2017), +ing the evidence and a label (e.g. support, refute, +named entities and verbal forms in political tran- +notenoughinformation). Laterdatasetswithboth +scripts (Zuo et al., 2018), or lexical and syntactic +natural (Hanselowski et al., 2019; Wadden et al., +features(Zhouetal.,2020). +2020) and artificial claims (Jiang et al., 2020; +Neuralnetworkapproachesbasedonsequence- +Schuster et al., 2021) also adopted this scheme, +or graph-modelling have recently become popu- +where the output expected is a combination of +lar, as they allow models to use the context of +multi-classlabelsandextractedevidence. +surrounding social media activity to inform deci- +Most existing datasets do not contain textual +sions. This can be highly beneficial, as the ways +explanations provided by journalists as justifica- +in which information is discussed and shared by +tion for verdicts. Alhindi et al. (2018) extended +usersarestrongindicatorsofrumourousness(Zu- +the Liar dataset with summaries extracted from +biaga et al., 2016). Kochkina et al. (2017) em- +fact-checking articles. While originally intended +ployed an LSTM (Hochreiter and Schmidhuber, +as an auxiliary task to improve claim verifica- +1997) to model branches of tweets, Ma et al. +tion, these justifications have been used as ex- +(2018) used Tree-LSTMs (Tai et al., 2015) to di- +planations (Atanasova et al., 2020b). Recently, +rectly encode the structure of threads, and Guo +Kotonya and Toni (2020b) constructed the first +et al. (2018) modelled the hierarchy by using at- +dataset which explicitly includes gold explana- +tention networks. Recent work explored fusing +tions. These consist of fact-checking articles and +more domain-specific features into neural mod- +other news items, which can be used to train nat- +els (Zhang et al., 2021). Another popular ap- +ural language generation models to provide post- +proach is to use Graph Neural Networks (Kipf +hoc justifications for the verdicts, However, us- +and Welling, 2017) to model the propagation be- +ing fact-checking articles is not realistic, as they +haviour of a potentially rumourous claim (Monti +are not available during inference, which makes +etal.,2019;Lietal.,2020;Yangetal.,2020a). +thetrainedsystemunabletoprovidejustifications +Some works tackle claim detection and +basedonretrievedevidence. +claim verification jointly, labelling potential +claims as true rumours, false rumours, or non- +4www.snopes.com/fact-check-ratings rumours (Buntain and Golbeck, 2017; Ma et al., -View Article Online -| EdgeArticle | | | | | | | | | ChemicalScience | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -exibility -13 L. Li, X.-S. Wang,T. F. Liu and J. Ye,Titanium-Based MOF in metal-organic frameworks, Nat. Chem., 2017, -| Materials: | From Crystal Engineering | | to Photocatalysis, | | 9,11–16. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SmallMethods,2020,4,2000486. 27 M. Alhamami, H. Doan and C.-H. Cheng, A Review on -14 C. Serre and G. F´erey, Hybrid Open Frameworks. 8. Breathing Behaviors of Metal-Organic-Frameworks (MOFs) -Hydrothermal Synthesis, Crystal Structure, and Thermal forGasAdsorption,Materials,2014,7,3198–3250. -Behavior of the First Three-Dimensional Titanium(IV) 28 K. Barthelet, J. Marrot, D. Riou and G. F´erey, A Breathing -Diphosphonate with an Open Structure: Hybrid Organic–Inorganic Solid with Very Large Pores and -| | P–(CH )–PO $(H | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Ti 3 O 2 (H 2 O) 2 (O 3 2 32 ) 2 O) 2 , or MIL-22, Inorg. High Magnetic Characteristics, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed., -| Chem.,1999,38,5370–5373. | | | | | 2002,41,281–284. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -.ecneciL detropnU 0.3 noitubirttA snommoC evitaerC a rednu desnecil si elcitra sihT -15 J. Castells-Gil, N. M. Padial, N. Almora-Barrios, J. Albero, 29 J.Cao,W.Ma,K.Lyu,L.Zhuang,H.CongandH.Deng,Twist -Garc´ıa -A. R. Ruiz-Salvador, J. Gonz´alez-Platas, H. and andslidingdynamicsbetweeninterpenetratedframesinTi- - .MP 00:74:5 6202/7/5 no dedaolnwoD .5202 enuJ 52 no dehsilbuP .elcitrA sseccA nepO -C. Mart´ı-Gastaldo, Chemical Engineering of Photoactivity MOF revealing high proton conductivity, Chem. Sci., 2020, -| | Titanium–Organic | | | | 11,3978–3985. | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| in Heterometallic | | Frameworks | | by Metal | | | | | | | -Doping,Angew.Chem.,Int.Ed.,2018,57,8453–8457. 30 C.Chinchilla-Garz´on,M.Galbiati,A.Misturini,P.Gimeno- -16 N.M.Padial,J.Castells-Gil,N.Almora-Barrios,M.Romero- Fonquernie, N. Almora-Barrios, N. M. Padial and C. Mart´ı- -Angel,I.D.Silva,M.Barawi,A.Garc´ıa-S´anchez,V.A.DeLa -| | | | | | Gastaldo, | Structural | Control | of Photoconductivity | | in | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -Pena O'Shea and C. Mart´ı-Gastaldo, Hydroxamate a Flexible Titanium-Organic Framework, Adv. Mater., 2025, -| Titanium–Organic | | | Effect | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Frameworks | and | the | of | 2412045,DOI:10.1002/adma.202412045. | | | | | | -Siderophore-Type Linkers over Their Photocatalytic 31 Q.Yan,J.Wang,L.Zhang,J.Liu,M.Wahiduzzaman,N.Yan, -Activity,J.Am.Chem.Soc.,2019,141,13124–13133. L.Yu,R.Dupuis,H.Wang,G.Maurin,M.Hirscher,P.Guo, -17 H.-Z. Li, S. Li, F. Wang and J. Zhang, A chelating S. Wang and J. Du, A squarate-pillared titanium oxide -coordination modulation method for the synthesis of Ti- quantum sieve towards practical hydrogen isotope -MOF single crystals, Inorg. Chem. Front., 2024, 11, 2876– separation,Nat.Commun.,2023,14,4189. -| 2883. | | | | | 32 J.Gao,J.Miao,P.-Z.Li,W.Y.Teng,L.Yang,Y.Zhao,B.Liu | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -18 S. Horike, S. Shimomura and S. Kitagawa, So porous and Q. Zhang, A p-type Ti(iv)-based metal–organic -crystals,Nat.Chem.,2009,1,695–704. -| | | | | | framework | with | visible-light | photo-response, | | Chem. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | -19 S.KitagawaandM.Kondo,Functionalmicroporechemistry Commun.,2014,50,3786–3788. -of crystalline metal complex-assembled compounds, Bull. 33 H. L. Nguyen, The chemistry of titanium-based metal– -Chem.Soc.Jpn.,1998,71,1739–1753. organicframeworks,NewJ.Chem.,2017,41,14030–14043. -20 T. Loiseau, C. Serre, C. Huguenard, G. Fink, F. Taulelle, 34 Y. Cai, L. Zou, Q. Ji, J. Yong, X. Qian and J. Gao, Two -M. Henry, T. Bataille and G. F´erey, A Rationale for the dimensional Ti-based metal-organic framework with polar -Large Breathing of the Porous Aluminum Terephthalate oxygen atoms on the pore surface for efficient gas -(MIL-53) Upon Hydration, Chem. –Eur. J., 2004, 10, 1373– separation,Polyhedron,2020,190,114771. -| 1382. | | | | | 35 S.Yu,Y.Xiao,Z.Liu,J.-M.Lyu,Y.-L.Wang,Z.-Y.Hu,Y.Li, | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -21 C. Mellot-Draznieks, C. Serre, S. Surbl´e, N. Audebrand and M. Sun, L.-H. Chen and B.-L. Su, Ti-MOF single-crystals -| F´erey, | | | | | | | macro–microporous | | | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -G. Very Large Swelling in Hybrid Frameworks: A featuring an intracrystal hierarchy for -Combined Computational and Powder Diffraction Study, J. catalytic oxidative desulfurization, Chem. Commun., 2023, -| Am.Chem.Soc.,2005,127,16273–16278. | | | | | 59,1801–1804. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Cresp´ı -22 C. Serre, C. Mellot-Draznieks, S. Surbl´e, N. Audebrand, 36 N. Sanchez, G. Turnes Palomino and C. Palomino -Y. Filinchuk and G. F´erey, Role of Solvent-Host Cabello, TiO derived from NTU-9 metal organic -2 -efficient -Interactions That Lead to Very Large Swelling of Hybrid framework as highly photocatalyst, Mater. Sci. -Frameworks,Science,2007,315,1828–1831. -Eng.,B,2021,273,115424. -23 N. Klein, H. C. Hoffmann, A. Cadiau, J. Getzschmann, 37 D.Yan,J.Jia,K.Tong,J.OuyangandY.Pan,Metalorganic -M. R. Lohe, S. Paasch, T. Heydenreich, K. Adil, framework as a matrix for laser desorption/ionisation of -I. Senkovska, E. Brunner and S. Kaskel, Structural environmentalpollutantsandothersmallmolecules,Int.J. -exibility and intrinsic dynamics in the M (2,6- Environ.Anal.Chem.,2023,104,9153–9163. -2 -| | = | | metal–organic | | | | | | metal–organic | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -ndc) (dabco) (M Ni, Cu, Co, Zn) 38 R. S. Forgan, Modulated self-assembly of -2 -frameworks,J.Mater.Chem.,2012,22,10303–10312. frameworks,Chem.Sci.,2020,11,4546–4562. -24 J.H.Lee,S.Jeoung,Y.G.ChungandH.R.Moon,Elucidation 39 H. L. B. Boström, S. Emmerling, F. Heck, C. Koschnick, -of exible metal-organic frameworks: Research progresses A. J. Jones, M. J. Cliffe, R. A. Natour, M. Bonneau, -and recent developments, Coord. Chem. Rev., 2019, 389, V. Guillerm, O. Shekhah, M. Eddaoudi, J. Lopez-Cabrelles, -| 161–188. | | | | | | | | Mart´ı-Gastaldo, | | | -| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | S. Furukawa, | M. Romero-Angel, | | C. | | M. Yan, | -25 A.Schneemann,V.Bon,I.Schwedler,I.Senkovska,S.Kaskel A.J.Morris,I.Romero-Muñiz,Y.Xiong,A.E.Platero-Prats, -andR.A.Fischer,Flexiblemetal–organicframeworks,Chem. -| | | | | | J. Roth, | W. L. | Queen, | K. S. Mertin, | D. | E. Schier, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---------- | -Soc.Rev.,2014,43,6062–6096. N. R. Champness, H. H. M. Yeung and B. V. Lotsch, How -26 T. D. Bennett, A. K. Cheetham, A. H. Fuchs and reproducible is the synthesis of Zr–porphyrin metal– -| F.-X. Coudert, | Interplay between | defects, | disorder | and | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 | 13653 +2018). This allows systems to exploit specific purposes (Thorne et al., 2018a; Jiang et al., 2020; +featuresusefulforbothtasks,suchasthedifferent Schusteretal.,2021)oftenrequirereasoningover +spreading patterns of false and true rumours (Zu- and combining multiple pieces of evidence. A +biaga et al., 2016). Veracity predictions made by simple approach is to treat multiple pieces of ev- +such systems are to be considered preliminary, as idence as one by concatenating them into a sin- +theyaremadewithoutevidence. gle string (Luken et al., 2018; Nie et al., 2019a), +andthenemployatextualentailmentmodeltoin- +4.2 EvidenceRetrieval&ClaimVerification fer whether the evidence supports or refutes the +| | | | | | | | claim. | More | recent | systems | employ | | specialized | +| -------------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------------- | -------- | -------------- | ----------- | +| As mentioned | | in Section | | 2, evidence | | retrieval | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | components | to | aggregate | | multiple | pieces | of evi- | +| and claim | verification | | are | commonly | | addressed | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | dence. | This allows | | the verification | | of | more com- | +| together. | Systems | | mostly | operate | as | a pipeline | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | plex claims | where | | several | pieces | of information | | +| consisting | of | an evidence | | retrieval | module | and | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | must be | combined, | | and addresses | | the | case where | +| a verification | | module | (Thorne | et | al., | 2018b), but | | | | | | | | +theretrievalmodulereturnsseveralhighly-related +| there are | exceptions | | where | these | two modules | are | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +documentsallofwhichcould(butmightnot)con- +trainedjointly(YinandRoth,2018). +| | | | | | | | tain the | right evidence | | (Yoneda | et | al., | 2018; Zhou | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +ClaimverificationcanbeseenasaformofRec- et al., 2019; Ma et al., 2019; Liu et al., 2020; +| ognizing | Textual | Entailment | | (RTE; | Dagan | et al. | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Zhongetal.,2020b;Schlichtkrulletal.,2021). +2010;Bowmanetal.2015),predictingwhetherthe +| | | | | | | | Some | early | work | does not | include | evidence | re- | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| evidencesupportsorrefutestheclaim. | | | | | | Typicalre- | | | | | | | | +trievalatall,performingverificationpurelyonthe +trievalstrategiesincludecommercialsearchAPIs, +basisofsurfaceformsandmetadata(Wang,2017; +| Lucene | indices, | entity | linking, | | or ranking | func- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Rashkin | et al., | 2017; | Dungs | et | al., 2018). | Re- | +tionslikedot-productsofTF-IDFvectors(Thorne +| | | | | | | | cently Lee | et | al. (2020) | considered | | using | the in- | +| --------------- | --- | --------------- | ----- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | +| et al., 2018b). | | Recently, | dense | retrievers | | employ- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | formation | stored | in | the weights | | of a | large pre- | +| ing learned | | representations | | and | fast | dot-product | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | trained | language | model | – | BERT | (Devlin | et al., | +indexing(Johnsonetal.,2017)haveshownstrong +| | | | | | | | 2019) – | as the | only | source | of evidence, | | as it has | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------- | +| performance | | (Lewis | et al., | 2020; | Maillard | et al., | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | been shown | competitive | | in | knowledge | | base com- | +2021). Toimproveprecision,morecomplexmod- +| | | | | | | | pletion | (Petroni | et | al., 2019). | Without | | explicitly | +| --------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | +| els – for | example | stance | | detection | systems | – can | | | | | | | | +consideringevidencesuchapproachesarelikelyto +| be deployed | | as second, | fine-grained | | filters | to re- | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | --- | --------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | propagate | biases | learned | during | | training, | and ren- | +rankretrievedevidence(Thorneetal.,2018b;Nie +derjustificationproductionimpossible(Leeetal., +| et al., 2019b,a; | | Hanselowski | | et | al., 2019). | Sim- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2021;Panetal.,2021). +| ilarly, evidence | | can | be re-ranked | | implicitly | dur- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ing verification | | in late-fusion | | systems | | (Ma et al., | | | | | | | | +4.3 JustificationProduction +| 2019; | Schlichtkrull | | et al., | 2021). | An | alterna- | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +| tive approach | | was proposed | | by | Fan et | al. (2020), | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Approaches | for | justification | | production | | can be | +who retrieved evidence using question genera- separated into three categories, which we exam- +tion and question answering via search engine re- ine along the three dimensions discussed in Sec- +| sults. | Some | work | avoids | retrieval | by | making a | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---- | ---- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | tion 2.4 | – readability, | | plausibility, | | and | faithful- | +closed-domainassumptionandevaluatinginaset- ness. First,somemodelsincludecomponentsthat +ting where appropriate evidence has already been can be analysed as justifications by human ex- +| found (Ferreira | | and | Vlachos, | 2016; | Chen | et al., | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | perts, primarily | | attention | | modules. | Popat | et al. | +2020; Zhong et al., 2020a; Yang et al., 2020b; (2018) selected evidence tokens that have higher +Eisenschlos et al., 2020); this, however, is unreal- attention weights as explanations. Similarly, co- +istic. Finally,Alleinetal.(2021)tookintoaccount attention (Shu et al., 2019; Lu and Li, 2020) and +thetimestampoftheevidenceinordertoimprove +| | | | | | | | self-attention | | (Yang | et al., | 2019) | were | used to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | +veracitypredictionaccuracy. highlight the salient excerpts from the evidence. +Ifonlyasingleevidencedocumentisretrieved, Wuetal.(2020b)furthercombineddecisiontrees +verification can be directly modelled as RTE. and attention weights to explain which tokens +However, both real-world claims (Augenstein weresalient,andhowtheyinfluencedpredictions. +etal.,2019;Hanselowskietal.,2019;Kotonyaand Recent studies have shown the use of attention as +Toni,2020b),aswellasthosecreatedforresearch explanation to be problematic. Some tokens with -ChemicalScience EdgeArticle -organic frameworks? An interlaboratory study, Adv. Mater., W. L. Queen, Anisotropic Node Distortions in Amorphous -2023,36,2304832. MOFs: Low Valent Zr Sites as Catalytic Hotspots, preprint, -40 C. Koschnick, M. W. Terban, S. Canossa, M. Etter, ChemRxiv,2024,DOI:10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-56r8t. -R. E. Dinnebier and B. V. Lotsch, Inuence of Water 53 A.A.Coelho,TOPASandTOPAS-Academic:anoptimization -Content on Speciation and Phase Formation in Zr– programintegratingcomputeralgebraandcrystallographic -Porphyrin-BasedMOFs,Adv.Mater.,2024,36,2210613. objectswritteninC++,J.Appl.Crystallogr.,2018,51,210–218. -41 H. Chun and D. Moon, Metal–Organic Frameworks from 54 R. W. Cheary and A. Coelho, A fundamental parameters -Group 4 Metals and 2,5-Dihydroxyterephthalic Acid: approach to X-ray line-prole tting, J. Appl. Crystallogr., -Reinvestigation, New Structure, and Challenges Toward 1992,25,109–121. -Gas Storage and Separation, Cryst. Growth Des., 2017, 17, 55 A. L. Bail, H. Duroy and J. L. Fourquet, Ab initio structure -2140–2146. determination of LiSbWO by X-ray powder diffraction, -6 -42 E. Dhivya, D. Magadevan, Y. Palguna, T. Mishra and Mater.Res.Bull.,1988,23,447–452. -N. Aman, Synthesis of titanium based hetero MOF 56 A.A.Coelho,Whole-prolestructuresolutionfrompowder -photocatalyst for reduction of Cr (VI) from wastewater, J. diffraction data using simulated annealing, J. Appl. -Environ.Chem.Eng.,2019,7,103240. Crystallogr.,2000,33,899–908. -43 Y.Yu,S.Li,L.Huang,J.Yu,H.Zhang,S.SongandT.Zeng, 57 L.ZhangandY.H.Hu,StructuredistortionofZn O C H -4 13 24 12 -Solar-driven CO conversion promoted by MOF-on-MOF framework(MOF-5),Mater.Sci.Eng.,B,2011,176,573–578. -2 -homophasejunction,Catal.Commun.,2021,150,106270. 58 J. W. M. Osterrieth, J. Rampersad, D. Madden, N. Rampal, -44 H. Assi, L. C. Padro P´erez, G. Mouchaham, F. Ragon, L. Skoric, B. Connolly, M. D. Allendorf, V. Stavila, -M. Nasalevich, N. Guillou, C. Martineau, H. Chevreau, J. L. Snider, R. Ameloot, J. Marreiros, C. Ania, D. Azevedo, -F. Kapteijn, J. Gascon, P. Fertey, E. Elkaim, C. Serre and E. Vilarrasa-Garcia, B. F. Santos, X.-H. Bu, Z. Chang, -T. Devic, Investigating the Case of Titanium(IV) H. Bunzen, N. R. Champness, S. L. Griffin, B. Chen, -Carboxyphenolate Photoactive Coordination Polymers, R.-B. Lin, B. Coasne, S. Cohen, J. C. Moreton, Y. J. Col´on, -Inorg.Chem.,2016,55,7192–7199. L. Chen, R. Clowes, F.-X. Coudert, Y. Cui, B. Hou, -45 H.M.Rietveld,Aprolerenementmethodfornuclearand D. M. D'Alessandro, P. W. Doheny, M. Dinc˘a, C. Sun, -magneticstructures,J.Appl.Crystallogr.,1969,2,65–71. C. Doonan, M. T. Huxley, J. D. Evans, P. Falcaro, R. Ricco, -46 J.E.Mondloch,O.Karagiaridi,O.K.FarhaandJ.T.Hupp, O. Farha, K. B. Idrees, T. Islamoglu, P. Feng, H. Yang, -Activation of metal–organic framework materials, R. S. Forgan, D. Bara, S. Furukawa, E. Sanchez, J. Gascon, -CrystEngComm,2013,15,9258–9264. S. Telalovi´c, S. K. Ghosh, S. Mukherjee, M. R. Hill, -47 Y.Li,Z.-M.Hao,M.-Y.Chao,W.-H.ZhangandD.J.Young, M. M. Sadiq, P. Horcajada, P. Salcedo-Abraira, K. Kaneko, -Vacuum-Induced Guest N,N0-Diethylformamide Binding in R. Kukobat, J. Kenvin, S. Keskin, S. Kitagawa, K.-i. Otake, -a Metastable Cd -Based Metal–Organic Framework, Inorg. R. P. Lively, S. J. A. DeWitt, P. Llewellyn, B. V. Lotsch, -5 -Chem.,2022,61,20227–20231. S. T. Emmerling, A. M. Pütz, C. Mart´ı-Gastaldo, -48 C. L. Hobday, S. Krause, S. M. J. Rogge, J. D. Evans and N. M. Padial, J. Garc´ıa-Mart´ınez, N. Linares, D. Maspoch, -H. Bunzen, Perspectives on the Inuence of Crystal Size J. A. S. d. Pino, P. Moghadam, R. Oktavian, R. E. Morris, -and Morphology on the Properties of Porous Framework P. S. Wheatley, J. Navarro, C. Petit, D. Danaci, -Materials,Front.Chem.,2021,9,772059. M. J. Rosseinsky, A. P. Katsoulidis, M. Schröder, X. Han, -49 D.-F.Lu,S.Li,M.-X.Guan,Y.-P.Han,Y.Sun,X.Wu,F.Wang S. Yang, C. Serre, G. Mouchaham, D. S. Sholl, -and J. Zhang, Visible-Light-Active Titanium Sulfonate R. Thyagarajan, D. Siderius, R. Q. Snurr, R. B. Goncalves, -Framework for Photocatalytic Organic Synthesis, ACS S.Telfer,S.J.Lee,V.P.Ting,J.L.Rowlandson,T.Uemura, -Mater.Lett.,2023,5,2836–2842. T. Iiyuka, M. A. van derVeen, D. Rega, V. Van Speybroeck, -50 D.-F.Lu,Y.-P.Han,Y.Sun,F.WangandJ.Zhang,Titanium S. M. J. Rogge, A. Lamaire, K. S. Walton, L. W. Bingel, -Sulfonate-Based Metal–Organic Frameworks, Cryst. Growth S. Wuttke, J. Andreo, O. Yaghi, B. Zhang, C. T. Yavuz, -Des.,2023,23,3778–3784. T. S. Nguyen, F. Zamora, C. Montoro, H. Zhou, A. Kirchon -51 R. Hassandoost, A. Khataee and E. Doustkhah, and D. Fairen-Jimenez, How Reproducible are Surface -Photocatalytic performance of disordered titanium-based Areas Calculated from the BET Equation?, Adv. Mater., -hollownanosheetmetal–organicframeworksinwastewater 2022,34,2201502. -treatment,J.TaiwanInst.Chem.Eng.,2024,157,105409. 59 M.BrunelliandA.N.Fitch,Aglasscapillarycellforinsitu -52 T.Schertenleib,M.Asgari,B.Mourino,V.V.Karve,T.Felder, powderX-raydiffractionofcondensedvolatilecompounds. -D. Stoian, V. Bon, J. Hao, A. Ortega-Guerrero, E. Oveisi, Solid HCFC-123a and HCFC-124, J. Synchrotron Radiat., -K. V. Agrawal, B. Smit, S. Kaskel, S. J. L. Billinge and 2003,10,337–339. -13654 | Chem.Sci.,2025,16,13646–13654 ©2025TheAuthor(s).PublishedbytheRoyalSocietyofChemistry -.MP -00:74:5 -6202/7/5 -no -dedaolnwoD -.5202 enuJ -52 -no -dehsilbuP -.elcitrA -sseccA -nepO -.ecneciL -detropnU -0.3 -noitubirttA -snommoC -evitaerC -a -rednu -desnecil -si -elcitra -sihT -View Article Online \ No newline at end of file +high attention scores can be removed without af- work for multi-modal disinformation detection. +fecting predictions, while some tokens with low Although misinformation and conspiracy theories +(non-zero) scores turn out to be crucial (Jain and overlap conceptually, conspiracy theories do not +Wallace, 2019; Serrano and Smith, 2019; Pruthi hinge exclusively on the truth value of the claims +et al., 2020). Explanations provided by attention being made, as they are sometimes proved to be +maythereforenotbesufficientlyfaithful. Further- true (Sunstein and Vermeule, 2009). A related +more, as they are difficult for non-experts and/or problem is propaganda detection, which overlaps +those not well-versed in the architecture of the with disinformation detection, but also includes +modeltograsp,theylackreadability. identifying particular techniques such as appeals +| | | | | | | | to emotion, | | logical | fallacies, | whataboutery, | | or | +| ------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| Another | approach | | is to | construct | decision- | | | | | | | | | +makingprocessesthatcanbefullygraspedbyhu- cherry-picking(DaSanMartinoetal.,2020b). +man experts. Rule-based methods use Horn rules Propagandaandthedeliberateoraccidentaldis- +and knowledge bases to mine explanations (Gad- semination of misleading information has been +Elrabetal.,2019;Ahmadietal.,2019),whichcan studiedextensively. JowettandO’Donnell(2019) +be directly understood and verified. These rules address the subject from a communications per- +areminedfromapre-constructedknowledgebase, spective, Taylor (2003) provides a historical ap- +such as DBpedia (Auer et al., 2007). This limits proach,andGoldmanandO’Connor(2021)tackle +whatcanbefact-checkedtoclaimswhicharerep- therelatedsubjectofepistemologyandtrustinso- +resentableastriples,andtoinformationpresentin cialsettingsfromaphilosophicalperspective. For +the(oftenmanuallycurated)knowledgebase. fact-checking and the identification of misinfor- +| | | | | | | | mation | by journalists, | | we direct | the | reader | to Sil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +Finally,somerecentworkhasfocusedonbuild- +ing models which – like human experts – can verman(2014)andBorel(2016). +| generate | textual | explanations | | for their | decisions. | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | ------------ | ---- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | Detecting | Previously | | Fact-checked | | Claims | | +| Atanasova | et | al. (2020b) | used | an extractive | | ap- | | | | | | | | +proachtogeneratesummaries,whileKotonyaand While in this survey we focus on methods for +| | | | | | | | verifying | claims | by | finding | the | evidence | rather | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ---------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | +| Toni(2020b)adoptedtheabstractiveapproach. | | | | | | A | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | than relying | on | previously | conducted | | fact checks, | | +potentialissueisthatsuchmodelscangenerateex- +| | | | | | | | misleading | claims | are | often | repeated | (Hassan | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | +planationsthatdonotrepresenttheiractualverac- +ity prediction process, but which are nevertheless et al., 2017); thus it is useful to detect whether a +| | | | | | | | claim has | already | been | fact-checked. | | Shaar | et al. | +| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | +| plausible | with | respect | to the | decision. | This | is es- | | | | | | | | +(2020)formulatedthistaskrecentlybyasranking, +| pecially | an issue | with | abstractive | models, | | where | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +hallucinations can produce very misleading justi- and constructed two datasets. The social media +versionofthetaskthenfeaturedatthesharedtask +| fications | (Maynez | et al., | 2020). | Also, | the | model | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | --- | ----- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | CheckThat! | (Barrón-Cedeño | | | et al., | 2020; | Nakov | +ofAtanasovaetal.(2020b)assumesfact-checking +| | | | | | | | et al., 2021b). | | This task | was | also | explored | by Vo | +| -------- | -------- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | +| articles | provided | as input | during | inference, | | which | | | | | | | | +isunrealistic. and Lee (2020) from a multi-modal perspective, +| | | | | | | | where claims | | about images | | were matched | against | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | previously | fact-checked | | claims. | | More recently, | | +5 RelatedTasks +| | | | | | | | Sheng | et al. | (2021) | and Kazemi | | et al. | (2021) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +MisinformationandDisinformation Misinfor- constructed datasets for this task in languages +mationisdefinedasconstitutingaclaimthatcon- beyond English. Hossain et al. (2020) detected +tradictsordistortscommonunderstandingsofver- misinformation by adopting a similar strategy. If +ifiable facts (Guess and Lyons, 2020). On the a tweet was matched to any known COVID-19 +other hand, disinformation is defined as the sub- relatedmisconceptions,thenitwouldbeclassified +set of misinformation that is deliberately propa- as misinformative. Matching claims against +gated. This is a question of intent: disinforma- previously verified ones is a simpler task that +tion is meant to deceive, while misinformation can often be reduced to sentence-level similar- +maybeinadvertentorunintentional(Tuckeretal., ity(Shaaretal.,2020),whichiswellstudiedinthe +2018). Fact-checkingcanhelpdetectmisinforma- context of textual entailment. Nevertheless, new +tion,butnotdistinguishitfromdisinformation. A claims and evidence emerge regularly. Previous +recentsurvey(Alametal.,2021)proposedtointe- fact-checks can be useful, but they can become +gratebothfactualityandharmfulnessintoaframe- outdatedandpotentiallymisleadingovertime. + +6 ResearchChallenges and the time-constraints of media consumers) of- +tenforcetheuseofatriagesystem(Borel,2016). +Choice of Labels The use of fine-grained la- This can introduce biases regardless of the inten- +bels by fact-checking organisations has recently tions of journalists and system-developers to use +comeundercriticism(UscinskiandButler,2013). objective criteria (Uscinski and Butler, 2013; Us- +| In-between | labels like | “mostly | true” | often | repre- | | | | | | +| ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ----- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | +| | | | | | cinski, 2015). | Addressing | | this challenge | will | re- | +sent “meta-ratings” for composite claims consist- quire the development of systems allowing for +ing of multiple elementary claims of different ve- real-time interaction with users to take into ac- +| racity. | For example, | a politician | might | claim | im- | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +counttheirevolvingneeds. +| provements | to unemployment | | and | productivity; | if | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +one part is true and the other false, a fact-checker Dataset Artefacts & Biases Synthetic datasets +| might label | the full | statement | “half | true”. | Noisy | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | constructed | through | crowd-sourcing | | are | com- | +labels resulting from composite claims could be mon(Zeichneretal.,2012;Hermannetal.,2015; +avoidedbyinterveningatthedatasetcreationstage Williams et al., 2018). It has been shown that +to manually split such claims, or by learning to models tend to rely on biases in these datasets, +| dosoautomatically. | | Theseparationofclaimsinto | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | without learning | the | underlying | task | (Gururangan | | +truth and falsehood can be too simplistic, as true et al., 2018; Poliak et al., 2018; McCoy et al., +claimscanstillmislead. Examplesincludecherry- 2019). For fact-checking, Schuster et al. (2019) +| picking, | where evidence | | is chosen | to suggest | a | | | | | | +| -------- | -------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | showed | that the predictions | | of models | trained | on | +misleading trend (Asudeh et al., 2020), and tech- FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018a)werelargelydriven +nical truth, where true information is presented byindicativeclaimwords. TheFEVER2.0shared +in a way that misleads (e.g. “I have never lost a task explored how to generate adversarial claims +gameofchess”isalsotrueifthespeakerhasnever andbuildsystemsresilienttosuchattacks(Thorne +played chess). A major challenge is integrating et al., 2019). Alleviating such biases and increas- +analysis of such claims into the existing frame- ingtherobustnesstoadversarialexamplesremains +| works. | This could | involve | new labels | identifying | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --------- | --------- | --------- | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | an open | question. | Potential | solutions | include | | +specific forms of deception, as is done in propa- leveraging better modelling approaches (Utama +ganda detection (Da San Martino et al., 2020a), et al., 2020a,b; Karimi Mahabadi et al., 2020; +or a greater focus on producing justifications to Thorne and Vlachos, 2021), collecting data by +showwhyclaimsaremisleading(Atanasovaetal., adversarial games (Eisenschlos et al., 2021), or +2020b;KotonyaandToni,2020b). context-sensitiveinference(Schusteretal.,2021). +Sources & Subjectivity Not all information is Multimodality Information (either in claims +equally trustworthy, and sometimes trustworthy or evidence) can be conveyed through multiple +sourcescontradicteachother. Thischallengesthe modalities such as text, tables, images, audio, or +assumptions made by most current fact-checking video. Though the majority of existing works +researchrelyingonasinglesourceconsideredau- have focused on text, some efforts also inves- +thoritative, such as Wikipedia. Methods must be tigated how to incorporate multimodal informa- +developed to address the presence of disagreeing tion, including claim detection with misleading +oruntrustworthyevidence. Recentworkproposed images (Zhang et al., 2018), propaganda detec- +integrating credibility assessment as a part of the tion over mixed images and text (Dimitrov et al., +fact-checking task (Wu et al., 2020a). This could 2021),andclaimverificationforimages(Zlatkova +be done for example by assessing the agreement et al., 2019; Nakamura et al., 2020). Monti et al. +betweenevidencesources,orbyassessingthede- (2019)arguedthatrumoursshouldbeseenassig- +greetowhichsourcescoherewithknownfacts(Li nals propagating through a social network. Ru- +etal.,2015;Dongetal.,2015;Zhangetal.,2019). mourdetectionisthereforeinherentlymultimodal, +Similarly, check-worthiness is a subjective con- requiringanalysisofbothgraphstructureandtext. +ceptvaryingalongaxesincludingtargetaudience, Available multimodal corpora are either small in +recency, and geography. One solution is to focus size (Zhang et al., 2018; Zlatkova et al., 2019) or +solelyonobjectivecheckability(Konstantinovskiy constructed based on distant supervision (Naka- +et al., 2021). However, the practical limitations muraetal.,2020). Theconstructionoflarge-scale +of fact-checking (e.g. the deadlines of journalists annotated datasets paired with evidence beyond + +metadata will facilitate the development of mul- Wallace, 2019; Wiegreffe and Pinter, 2019). Fur- +timodalfact-checkingsystems. therworkisneededtodevelopsuchtechniquesfor +justificationproduction. +Multilinguality Claims can occur in multiple +languages, often different from the one(s) evi- From Debunking to Early Intervention and +denceisavailablein,callingformultilingualfact- Prebunking The prevailing application of au- +checking systems. While misinformation spans tomated fact-checking is to discover and inter- +both geographic and linguistic boundaries, most vene against circulating misinformation, also re- +workinthefieldhasfocusedonEnglish. Apossi- ferred to as debunking. Efforts have been made +bleapproachformultilingualverificationistouse torespondquicklyaftertheappearanceofapiece +translationsystemsforexistingmethods(Demen- of misinformation (Monti et al., 2019), but com- +tieva and Panchenko, 2020), but relevant datasets mon to all approaches is that intervention takes +in more languages are necessary for testing mul- place reactively after misinformation has already +tilingual models’ performance within each lan- been introduced to the public. NLP technol- +guage, and ideally also for training. Currently, ogy could also be leveraged in proactive strate- +there exist a handful of datasets for factual ver- gies. Prior work has employed network anal- +ification in languages other than English (Baly ysis and similar techniques to identify key ac- +et al., 2018; Lillie et al., 2019; Khouja, 2020; torsforinterventioninsocialnetworks(Farajtabar +Shahi and Nandini, 2020; Nørregaard and Der- et al., 2017); using NLP, such techniques could +czynski, 2021), but they do not offer a cross- be extended to take into account the information +lingual setup. More recently, Gupta and Sriku- shared by these actors, in addition to graph-based +mar(2021)introducedamultilingualdatasetcov- features (Nakov, 2020; Mu and Aletras, 2020). +ering25languages,butfoundthataddingtraining Another direction is to disseminate countermes- +data from other languages did not improve per- saging before misinformation can spread widely; +formance. How to effectively align, coordinate, this is also known as pre-bunking, and has been +and leverage resources from different languages showntobemoreeffectivethanpost-hocdebunk- +remains an open question. One promising direc- ing(vanderLindenetal.,2017;Roozenbeeketal., +tion is to distill knowledge from high-resource to 2020; Lewandowsky and van der Linden, 2021). +low-resourcelanguages(Kazemietal.,2021). NLPcouldplayacrucialrolebothinearlydetec- +tionandinthecreationofrelevantcountermessag- +Faithfulness A significant unaddressed chal- ing. Finally, training people to create misinfor- +lenge in justification production is faithfulness. mation has been shown to increase resistance to- +As we discuss in Section 4.3, some justifications wards false claims (Roozenbeek and van der Lin- +– such as those generated abstractively (Maynez den, 2019). NLP could be used to facilitate this +et al., 2020) – may not be faithful. This can be process, ortoprovideanadversarialopponentfor +highly problematic, especially if these justifica- gamifying the creation of misinformation. This +tions are used to convince users of the validity of could be seen as a form of dialogue agent to edu- +model predictions (Lertvittayakumjorn and Toni, cateusers,howeverthereareasofyetnoresources +2019). Faithfulness is difficult to evaluate for, as forthedevelopmentofsuchsystems. +humanevaluatorsandhuman-producedgoldstan- +dards often struggle to separate highly plausible, 7 Conclusion +unfaithful explanations from faithful ones (Jacovi +and Goldberg, 2020). In the model interpretabil- We have reviewed and evaluated current auto- +ity domain, several recent papers have introduced matedfact-checkingresearchbyunifyingthetask +strategies for testing or guaranteeing faithfulness. formulations and methodologies across different +These include introducing formal criteria which research efforts into one framework comprising +models should uphold (Yu et al., 2019), measur- claimdetection,evidenceretrieval,verdictpredic- +ing the accuracy of predictions after removing tion, and justification production. Based on the +some or all of the predicted non-salient input el- proposed framework, we have provided an exten- +ements (Yeh et al., 2019; DeYoung et al., 2020; sive overview of the existing datasets and mod- +Atanasova et al., 2020a), or disproving the faith- elling strategies. Finally, we have identified vital +fulnessoftechniquesbycounterexample(Jainand challengesforfutureresearchtoaddress. + +| Acknowledgements | | | | | | | Christodoulopoulos, | | | O. Cocarascu, | | and | Arpit | +| ---------------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------- | -------------------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Mittal.2021. | FEVEROUS:FactExtractionand | | | | | | +| Zhijiang | Guo, Michael | | Schlichtkrull | | and | Andreas | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | VERification | over | unstructured | | and | structured | | +VlachosaresupportedbytheERCgrantAVeriTeC +| | | | | | | | information. | 35th | Conference | | on | Neural | In- | +| ------------ | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | +| (GA 865958), | | The latter | is | further | supported | by | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | formation | Processing | | Systems | (NeurIPS | | 2021) | +| the EU | H2020 | grant | MONITIO | | (GA | 965576). | | | | | | | | +TrackonDatasetsandBenchmarks. +| TheauthorswouldliketothankRamiAly, | | | | | | Chris- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tos Christodoulopoulos, Nedjma Ousidhoum, and Abolfazl Asudeh, H. V. Jagadish, You (Will) Wu, +| James Thorne | | for useful | comments | | and | sugges- | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | ----------- | ------------------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | andCongYu.2020. | | Ondetectingcherry-picked | | | | | +| tions. | | | | | | | trendlines. | Proceedings | | of | the VLDB | | Endow- | +ment,13(6):939–952. +| References | | | | | | | Pepa Atanasova, | Lluís | Màrquez, | | Alberto | | Barrón- | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | +Cedeño,TamerElsayed,ReemSuwaileh,Wajdi +| Bill Adair, | Chengkai | | Li, Jun | Yang, | and | Cong | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ------ | -------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | ------------ | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Zaghouani, | Spas | Kyuchukov, | | Giovanni | | Da San | +| Yu. 2017. | | Progress | | toward | “the | holy | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Martino, | and Preslav | | Nakov. | 2018. | Overview | | +| grail”: | The | continued | quest | to | automate | fact- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | of the CLEF-2018 | | CheckThat! | | | lab on | auto- | +| checking. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 2017 | Compu- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | matic identification | | and | verification | | of political | | +tation+JournalismSymposium. +| | | | | | | | claims. | task 1: | Check-worthiness. | | | In | Work- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +Naser Ahmadi, Joohyung Lee, Paolo Papotti, and ing Notes of CLEF 2018 - Conference and +LabsoftheEvaluationForum,Avignon,France, +| Mohammed | | Saeed. | 2019. | Explainable | | fact | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +September10-14,2018,volume2125ofCEUR +checkingwithprobabilisticanswersetprogram- +ming. In Proceedings of the 2019 Truth and WorkshopProceedings.CEUR-WS.org. +| Trust | Online | Conference | | (TTO | 2019), | London, | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------- | --------------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Pepa Atanasova, | Jakob | | Grue Simonsen, | | Christina | | +UK,October4-5,2019. +| | | | | | | | Lioma, | and Isabelle | Augenstein. | | | 2020a. | A di- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | +Ahmet Aker, Leon Derczynski, and Kalina agnostic study of explainability techniques for +| | | | | | | | text classification. | | In | Proceedings | | of the | 2020 | +| ---------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | -------------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +| Bontcheva. | 2017. | Simple | | open | stance | classifi- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Conference | on | Empirical | Methods | | in | Natural | +| cation | for rumour | analysis. | | In | Proceedings | of | | | | | | | | +the International Conference Recent Advances Language Processing (EMNLP), pages 3256– +| | | | | | | | 3274, Online. | | Association | | for Computational | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | +inNaturalLanguageProcessing,RANLP2017, +Linguistics. +pages31–39,Varna,Bulgaria.INCOMALtd. +FirojAlam,StefanoCresci,TanmoyChakraborty, Pepa Atanasova, Jakob Grue Simonsen, Christina +| | | | | | | | Lioma,andIsabelleAugenstein.2020b. | | | | | | Gener- | +| ----------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | ------------- | ------- | ---------------------------------- | ----------------- | ------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | +| Fabrizio | Silvestri, | Dimiter | | Dimitrov, | Giovanni | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ating fact | checking | explanations. | | | In Proceed- | | +| Da San | Martino, | Shaden | | Shaar, | Hamed | Firooz, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ings of | the 58th | Annual | Meeting | | of | the As- | +| and Preslav | | Nakov. | 2021. | A survey | on | multi- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | sociation | for Computational | | | Linguistics, | | pages | +| modaldisinformationdetection. | | | | | arXivpreprint | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 7352–7364, | Online. | Association | | | for Computa- | | +arXiv:2103.12541. +tionalLinguistics. +| Tariq Alhindi, | | Savvas | Petridis, | | and Smaranda | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------- | -------------- | ------ | ------------------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Sören Auer, | Christian | | Bizer, | Georgi | | Kobi- | +| Muresan. | 2018. | Where | is | your | evidence: | Im- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | larov, Jens | Lehmann, | | Richard | Cyganiak, | | and | +| proving | fact-checking | | by | justification | | model- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ZacharyG.Ives.2007. | | | DBpedia: | | Anucleusfor | | +| ing. | In Proceedings | | of | the | First Workshop | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | a web of | open | data. | In The | Semantic | Web, | 6th | +| on Fact | Extraction | | and VERification | | (FEVER), | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | International | Semantic | | Web | Conference, | | 2nd | +| pages | 85–90, | Brussels, | | Belgium. | Association | | | | | | | | | +AsianSemanticWebConference,ISWC2007+ +forComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | ASWC | 2007, Busan, | | Korea, | November | | 11-15, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | +Liesbeth Allein, Isabelle Augenstein, and Marie- 2007, volume 4825 of Lecture Notes in Com- +Francine Moens. 2021. Time-Aware Evidence puterScience,pages722–735.Springer. +| RankingforFact-Checking. | | | | WebSemantics. | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +IsabelleAugenstein,ChristinaLioma,Dongsheng +Rami Aly, Zhijiang Guo, M. Schlichtkrull, Wang, Lucas Chaves Lima, Casper Hansen, +James Thorne, Andreas Vlachos, Christos Christian Hansen, and Jakob Grue Simonsen. + +2019. MultiFC: A real-world multi-domain Overview of the CLEF-2018 CheckThat! lab +dataset for evidence-based fact checking of on automatic identification and verification of +claims. In Proceedings of the 2019 Confer- political claims. task 2: Factuality. In Work- +ence on Empirical Methods in Natural Lan- ing Notes of CLEF 2018 - Conference and +guage Processing and the 9th International LabsoftheEvaluationForum,Avignon,France, +Joint Conference on Natural Language Pro- September10-14,2018,volume2125ofCEUR +cessing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), pages 4685–4697, WorkshopProceedings.CEUR-WS.org. +| Hong Kong, | China. | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +KurtD.Bollacker,ColinEvans,PraveenParitosh, +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Tim Sturge, | and | Jamie | Taylor. | 2008. | Freebase: | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --------- | +Joan Bachenko, Eileen Fitzpatrick, and Michael a collaboratively created graph database for +Schonwetter.2008. Verificationandimplemen- structuring human knowledge. In Proceedings +tationoflanguage-baseddeceptionindicatorsin oftheACMSIGMODInternationalConference +civilandcriminalnarratives. InProceedingsof on Management of Data, SIGMOD 2008, Van- +the 22nd International Conference on Compu- couver, BC, Canada, June 10-12, 2008, pages +| tational Linguistics | | (Coling | 2008), | pages | 41– | 1247–1250.ACM. | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | +| 48, Manchester, | | UK. Coling | 2008 | Organizing | | | | | | | | +| Committee. | | | | | | AntoineBordes,NicolasUsunier,AlbertoGarcía- | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Durán, Jason | | Weston, | and | Oksana | Yakhnenko. | +RamyBaly, MitraMohtarami, JamesGlass, Lluís 2013. Translating embeddings for modeling +Màrquez, Alessandro Moschitti, and Preslav multi-relational data. In Advances in Neural +Nakov. 2018. Integrating stance detection and Information Processing Systems 26: 27th An- +fact checking in a unified corpus. In Proceed- nual Conference on Neural Information Pro- +ingsofthe2018ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- cessingSystems2013.Proceedingsofameeting +ican Chapter of the Association for Computa- heldDecember5-8,2013,LakeTahoe,Nevada, +tionalLinguistics: HumanLanguageTechnolo- UnitedStates,pages2787–2795. +| gies, Volume | 2 | (Short Papers), | | pages | 21–27, | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | --------------- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ------------- | ------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | +| | | | | | | Brooke Borel. | 2016. | The | Chicago | Guide | to Fact- | +| New Orleans, | Louisiana. | | Association | for | Com- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | checking. | UniversityofChicagoPress. | | | | | +putationalLinguistics. +Aviv Barnoy and Zvi Reich. 2019. The When, Samuel R. Bowman, Gabor Angeli, Christopher +Why,HowandSo-WhatofVerifications. Jour- Potts, and Christopher D. Manning. 2015. A +| | | | | | | large annotated | | corpus | for | learning | natural lan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------------ | +nalismStudies,20(16):2312–2330. +| | | | | | | guage inference. | | In | Proceedings | | of the 2015 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | +Alberto Barrón-Cedeño, Tamer Elsayed, Preslav Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural +Nakov, Giovanni Da San Martino, Maram Language Processing, pages 632–642, Lisbon, +Hasanain, Reem Suwaileh, Fatima Haouari, Portugal. Association for Computational Lin- +| Nikolay | Babulkov, | Bayan | Hamdan, | | Alex | guistics. | | | | | | +| -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Nikolov, | Shaden | Shaar, and | Zien | Sheikh | Ali. | | | | | | | +2020. Overview of CheckThat! 2020: Auto- Tom B. Brown, Benjamin Mann, Nick Ry- +| | | | | | | der, Melanie | | Subbiah, | Jared | Kaplan, | Prafulla | +| -------------------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | ----- | ------- | -------- | +| matic identification | | and verification | | of | claims | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Dhariwal, | Arvind | Neelakantan, | | Pranav | Shyam, | +| in social | media. | In Experimental | | IR | Meets | | | | | | | +Multilinguality, Multimodality, and Interaction Girish Sastry, Amanda Askell, Sandhini Agar- +| | | | | | | wal, Ariel | Herbert-Voss, | | | Gretchen | Krueger, | +| -------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | ------------- | ----- | ------ | -------- | -------- | +| - 11th International | | Conference | | of the | CLEF | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Tom Henighan, | | Rewon | Child, | Aditya | Ramesh, | +Association,CLEF2020,Thessaloniki,Greece, +September 22-25, 2020, Proceedings, Daniel M. Ziegler, Jeffrey Wu, Clemens Win- +volume +12260 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, ter,ChristopherHesse,MarkChen,EricSigler, +| | | | | | | Mateusz | Litwin, | Scott | Gray, | Benjamin | Chess, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | ------ | +pages215–236.Springer. +| | | | | | | Jack Clark, | Christopher | | Berner, | Sam | McCan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | +Alberto Barrón-Cedeño, Tamer Elsayed, Reem dlish, Alec Radford, Ilya Sutskever, and Dario +Suwaileh, Lluís Màrquez, Pepa Atanasova, Amodei. 2020. Language models are few-shot +Wajdi Zaghouani, Spas Kyuchukov, Giovanni learners. In Advances in Neural Information +Da San Martino, and Preslav Nakov. 2018. Processing Systems 33: Annual Conference on + +Neural Information Processing Systems 2020, Daryna Dementieva and A. Panchenko. 2020. +NeurIPS2020,December6-12,2020,virtual. Fake news detection using multilingual evi- +| | | | | | | dence. | 2020 | IEEE | 7th International | | Confer- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | +CodyBuntainandJenniferGolbeck.2017. Auto- ence on Data Science and Advanced Analytics +maticallyidentifyingfakenewsinpopulartwit- (DSAA),pages775–776. +In2017IEEEInternationalConfer- +terthreads. +enceonSmartCloud(SmartCloud),pages208– Leon Derczynski, Kalina Bontcheva, Maria Li- +| | | | | | | akata, Rob | Procter, | | Geraldine | Wong | Sak Hoi, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | +215.IEEE. +| | | | | | | andArkaitzZubiaga.2017. | | | | SemEval-2017task | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | +Wenhu Chen, Hongmin Wang, Jianshu Chen, 8: RumourEval: Determining rumour veracity +| | | | | | | | | | | Proceedings | of | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +Yunkai Zhang, Hong Wang, Shiyang Li, Xiyou and support for rumours. In +| | | | | | | the 11th | International | | Workshop | | on Semantic | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | +| Zhou,andWilliamYangWang.2020. | | | | | TabFact: | | | | | | | +A large-scale dataset for table-based fact ver- Evaluation(SemEval-2017),pages69–76,Van- +ification. In 8th International Conference on couver,Canada.AssociationforComputational +Linguistics. +| Learning | Representations, | | ICLR | 2020, | Addis | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ababa,Ethiopia. +| | | | | | | Jacob Devlin, | Ming-Wei | | Chang, | Kenton | Lee, and | +| -------------- | -------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ------------------ | ------------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ------------ | +| | | | | | | Kristina | Toutanova. | | 2019. | BERT: | Pre-training | +| Giovanni | Luca | Ciampaglia, | Prashant | | Shiralkar, | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | of deep | bidirectional | | transformers | | for language | +| Luis M | Rocha, | Johan | Bollen, | Filippo | Menczer, | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | understanding. | | In | Proceedings | | of the 2019 | +| and Alessandro | | Flammini. | | 2015. | Computa- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Conference | of | the | North | American | Chapter | +| tional fact | checking | from | knowledge | | networks. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | of the Association | | | for Computational | | Linguis- | +PloSone,10(6):e0128193. +| | | | | | | tics: Human | | Language | Technologies, | | Volume | +| ------------ | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------------- | ----- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | 1 (Long | and | Short | Papers), | pages | 4171–4186, | +| Sarah Cohen, | Chengkai | | Li, Jun | Yang, | and Cong | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Minneapolis, | | Minnesota. | Association | | for Com- | +| Yu. 2011. | Computational | | journalism: | | A call to | | | | | | | +putationalLinguistics. +| arms to | database | researchers. | | In CIDR | 2011, | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | +| Fifth Biennial | | Conference | on | Innovative | Data | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Jay DeYoung, | Sarthak | | Jain, | Nazneen | Fatema Ra- | +SystemsResearch,Asilomar,CA,USA,January +| | | | | | | jani, Eric | Lehman, | | Caiming | Xiong, | Richard | +| ----------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ----- | ---- | ------------------------------ | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | +| 9-12, 2011, | Online | Proceedings, | | pages | 148– | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Socher,andByronC.Wallace.2020. | | | | | ERASER: | +151.www.cidrdb.org. +| | | | | | | A benchmark | | to | evaluate | rationalized | NLP | +| -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ------ | ----------- | -------- | ----------------- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | models. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 58th Annual | +| Giovanni | Da San | Martino, | | Alberto | Barrón- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Meeting | of the | Association | | for Computational | | +Cedeño,HenningWachsmuth,RostislavPetrov, +| | | | | | | Linguistics, | pages | 4443–4458, | | Online. | Associ- | +| ----------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---- | ------------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +| and Preslav | Nakov. | 2020a. | SemEval-2020 | | task | | | | | | | +ationforComputationalLinguistics. +| 11: Detection | | of propaganda | | techniques | in | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +newsarticles. InProceedingsoftheFourteenth Thomas Diggelmann, Jordan L. Boyd-Graber, +WorkshoponSemanticEvaluation,pages1377– +| | | | | | | Jannis | Bulian, | Massimiliano | | Ciaramita, | and | +| --------------- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------------- | --- | +| 1414, Barcelona | | (online). | International | | Com- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Markus | Leippold. | | 2020. | CLIMATE-FEVER: | | +mitteeforComputationalLinguistics. A dataset for verification of real-world climate +| | | | | | | claims. | CoRR,abs/2012.00614. | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Giovanni | Da San | Martino, | Stefano | Cresci, | Al- | | | | | | | +berto Barrón-Cedeño, Seunghak Yu, Roberto Dimitar Dimitrov, Bishr Bin Ali, Shaden Shaar, +| | | | | | | Firoj Alam, | Fabrizio | | Silvestri, | Hamed | Firooz, | +| ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ----------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | +| Di Pietro, | and | Preslav | Nakov. | 2020b. | A sur- | | | | | | | +veyoncomputationalpropagandadetection. In Preslav Nakov, and Giovanni Da San Mar- +Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth International tino. 2021. Detecting propaganda techniques +Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence, IJ- in memes. In Proceedings of the 59th An- +CAI2020,pages4826–4832.ijcai.org. nual Meeting of the Association for Compu- +| | | | | | | tational | Linguistics | | and the | 11th | International | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------- | +Ido Dagan, Bill Dolan, Bernardo Magnini, and Joint Conference on Natural Language Pro- +Dan Roth. 2010. Recognizing textual entail- cessing (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages 6603– +ment: Rational, evaluation and approaches. 6617, Online. Association for Computational +| NaturalLanguageEngingeering,16(1):105. | | | | | | Linguistics. | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +XinLunaDong,EvgeniyGabrilovich,KevinMur- news mitigation via point process based inter- +phy, Van Dang, Wilko Horn, Camillo Lu- vention. In Proceedings of the 34th Interna- +garesi, Shaohua Sun, and Wei Zhang. 2015. tional Conference on Machine Learning, vol- +Knowledge-based trust: Estimating the trust- ume 70 of Proceedings of Machine Learning +worthiness of web sources. Proceedings of the Research,pages1097–1106.PMLR. +VLDBEndowment,8(9):938–949. +| | | | | | | | William | Ferreira | and Andreas | | Vlachos. | | 2016. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | +Sebastian Dungs, Ahmet Aker, Norbert Fuhr, and Emergent: a novel data-set for stance classi- +Kalina Bontcheva. 2018. Can rumour stance fication. In Proceedings of the 2016 Confer- +alone predict veracity? In Proceedings of ence of the North American Chapter of the As- +| | | | | | | | sociation | for Computational | | | Linguistics: | | Hu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | +the27thInternationalConferenceonComputa- +tional Linguistics, pages 3360–3370, Santa Fe, manLanguageTechnologies,pages1163–1168, +New Mexico, USA. Association for Computa- SanDiego, California.AssociationforCompu- +tationalLinguistics. +tionalLinguistics. +TerryFlew,ChristinaSpurgeon,AnnaDaniel,and +| Julian Eisenschlos, | | Bhuwan | | Dhingra, | Jannis | Bu- | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lian, Benjamin Börschinger, and Jordan Boyd- Adam Swift. 2010. The promise of computa- +| | | | | | | | tionaljournalism. | | JournalismPractice,6:157– | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Graber. | 2021. | Fool | Me | Twice: | Entailment | | | | | | | | | +171. +| from Wikipedia | | gamification. | | | In Proceedings | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| of the | 2021 | Conference | | of the | North | Ameri- | | | | | | | | +MohamedH.Gad-Elrab,DariaStepanova,Jacopo +| can Chapter | | of the | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | -------- | ---------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Urbani, | and Gerhard | Weikum. | | 2019. | ExFaKT: | | +| tionalLinguistics: | | HumanLanguageTechnolo- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | A framework | for | explaining | | facts | over knowl- | | +| gies, pages | 352–365, | | Online. | Association | | for | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | edge graphs | and | text. | In Proceedings | | | of the | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Twelfth | ACM International | | Conference | | on | Web | +| ------------------- | ----- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | ----------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Search | and Data | Mining, | WSDM | | 2019, | Mel- | +| Julian Eisenschlos, | | Syrine | Krichene, | | and | Thomas | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | bourne, | VIC, Australia, | | February | 11-15, | | 2019, | +| Müller. | 2020. | Understanding | | tables | with | inter- | | | | | | | | +pages87–95.ACM. +| mediate | pre-training. | | In Findings | | of | the Asso- | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------- | ------------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | +| ciationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | | | | EMNLP | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Pepa Gencheva, | Preslav | | Nakov, | Lluís | Màrquez, | | +| 2020, pages | | 281–296, | Online. | | Association | for | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Alberto | Barrón-Cedeño, | | and | Ivan | Koychev. | | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | 2017. | A context-aware | | approach | | for detect- | | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ing worth-checking | | claims | in | political | debates. | | +| Omar Enayet | and | Samhaa | | R. El-Beltagy. | | 2017. | | | | | | | | +InProceedingsoftheInternationalConference +| NileTMRGatSemEval-2017task8: | | | | | Determin- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +RecentAdvancesinNaturalLanguageProcess- +| ing rumour | and | veracity | | support | for | rumours | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | +| | | | | | | | ing, RANLP | 2017, | pages | 267–276, | | Varna, | Bul- | +| on Twitter. | | In Proceedings | | of | the | 11th In- | | | | | | | | +garia.INCOMALtd. +| ternational | Workshop | | on | Semantic | Evaluation | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------ | ------------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | +| (SemEval-2017), | | pages | 470–474, | | Vancouver, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Yigal Godler | and | Zvi Reich. | 2017. | | Journalistic | | +| Canada. | Association | | for | Computational | | Lin- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | evidence: | Cross-verification | | | as a constituent | | of | +| guistics. | | | | | | | mediated | knowledge. | | Journalism, | | 18(5):558– | | +574. +| Angela Fan, | Aleksandra | | Piktus, | | Fabio | Petroni, | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | ----- | --- | +| Guillaume | Wenzek, | | Marzieh | Saeidi, | | Andreas | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Alvin Goldman | and | Cailin | O’Connor. | | 2021. | So- | +Vlachos,AntoineBordes,andSebastianRiedel. cial Epistemology. In Edward N. Zalta, ed- +2020. Generating fact checking briefs. In Pro- itor, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philoso- +| ceedings | of the | 2020 | Conference | | on | Empiri- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | phy, Spring | 2021 | edition. | | Metaphysics | | Re- | +cal Methods in Natural Language Processing searchLab,StanfordUniversity. +| (EMNLP), | pages | 7147–7161, | | Online. | | Associa- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Genevieve | Gorrell, | | Ahmet | Aker, | | Kalina | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Bontcheva, | Leon | Derczynski, | | Elena | Kochk- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | +Mehrdad Farajtabar, Jiachen Yang, Xiaojing Ye, ina, Maria Liakata, and Arkaitz Zubiaga. +HuanXu,RakshitTrivedi,EliasKhalil,Shuang 2019. SemEval-2019 task 7: RumourEval, +Li, Le Song, and Hongyuan Zha. 2017. Fake determining rumour veracity and support for + +rumours. In Proceedings of the 13th Inter- SuchinGururangan, SwabhaSwayamdipta, Omer +national Workshop on Semantic Evaluation, Levy, Roy Schwartz, Samuel Bowman, and +SemEval@NAACL-HLT 2019, Minneapolis, Noah A. Smith. 2018. Annotation artifacts in +MN, USA, June 6-7, 2019, pages 845–854. natural language inference data. In Proceed- +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. ingsofthe2018ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- +| | | | | | | | ican Chapter | | of the | Association | | for Computa- | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | +| Lucas Graves. | | 2018. Understanding | | | the promise | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | | HumanLanguageTechnolo- | | | | | +| and limits | of | automated | fact-checking. | | Reuters | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | gies, Volume | | 2 (Short | Papers), | pages | 107–112, | | +InstitutefortheStudyofJournalism. +| | | | | | | | New Orleans, | | Louisiana. | Association | | for | Com- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | +putationalLinguistics. +| Maurício | Gruppi, | Benjamin | D. | Horne, | and | Sibel | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Adali. | 2020. | NELA-GT-2019: | | | A | large | | | | | | | | +multi-labelled news dataset for the study of Andreas Hanselowski, Christian Stab, Claudia +| | | | | | | | Schulz, | Zile | Li, and | Iryna | Gurevych. | 2019. | A | +| -------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | -------- | +| misinformation | | in | news | articles. | | CoRR, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | richly | annotated | corpus | for | different | | tasks in | +abs/2003.08444. +| | | | | | | | automated | fact-checking. | | | In Proceedings | | of | +| -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +| Maurício | Gruppi, | Benjamin | D. | Horne, | and | Sibel | | | | | | | | +the23rdConferenceonComputationalNatural +| Adali. | 2021. | NELA-GT-2020: | | | A | large | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | Language | Learning | | (CoNLL), | pages | 493–503, | | +| multi-labelled | | news | dataset | for the | study | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Hong Kong, | | China. | Association | | for Computa- | | +| misinformation | | in | news | articles. | | CoRR, | | | | | | | | +tionalLinguistics. +abs/2102.04567. +| | | | | | | | Momchil | Hardalov, | Arnav | Arora, | Preslav | | Nakov, | +| ------ | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ------ | +| Andrew | M. Guess | and | Benjamin | | A. Lyons. | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Isabelle | | Augenstein. | | 2021. | A survey | on | +| 2020. | Misinformation, | | disinformation, | | | and | | | | | | | | +online propaganda. In Nathaniel Persily and stance detection for mis- and disinformation +| | | | | | | | identification. | | ArXiv,abs/2103.00242. | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Joshua | A. Tucker, | editors, | | Social | media | and | | | | | | | | +| democracy: | | the state | of | the field, | prospects | | | | | | | | | +forreform,pages10–33.CambridgeUniversity Maram Hasanain, Reem Suwaileh, Tamer El- +| | | | | | | | sayed, | Alberto | Barrón-Cedeño, | | | and | Preslav | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +Press. +| | | | | | | | Nakov. | 2019. | Overview | | of the | CLEF-2019 | | +| -------- | ---- | --------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | +| Han Guo, | Juan | Cao, Yazi | Zhang, | Junbo | Guo, | and | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | CheckThat! | | lab: Automatic | | identification | | and | +Jintao Li. 2018. Rumor detection with hier- verification of claims. task 2: Evidence and +archical social attention network. In Proceed- factuality. In Working Notes of CLEF 2019 - +ingsofthe27thACMInternationalConference +| | | | | | | | Conference | and | Labs | of the | Evaluation | | Forum, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | +on Information and Knowledge Management, Lugano, Switzerland, September 9-12, 2019, +CIKM2018,Torino,Italy,October22-26,2018, volume 2380 of CEUR Workshop Proceedings. +| pages943–951.ACM. | | | | | | | CEUR-WS.org. | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | ----------------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ---- | +| Ashim Gupta | and | Vivek | Srikumar. | 2021. | X-Fact: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Naeemul | Hassan, | Chengkai | | Li, | and | Mark | +| A new | benchmark | dataset | | for multilingual | | fact | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Tremayne. | 2015. | Detecting | | check-worthy | | fac- | +| checking. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 59th Annual | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tualclaimsinpresidentialdebates. | | | | | InProceed- | | +| Meeting | of the | Association | | for Computational | | | | | | | | | | +ingsofthe24thACMInternationalConference +| Linguistics | and | the | 11th | International | | Joint | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | ---------- | ----- | -------------- | ----- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | on Information | | and | Knowledge | | Management, | | +| Conference | on | Natural | Language | | Processing | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | CIKM | 2015, | Melbourne, | VIC, | Australia, | | Octo- | +| (Volume | 2: Short | Papers), | | pages 675–682, | | On- | | | | | | | | +ber19-23,2015,pages1835–1838.ACM. +| line. Association | | for | Computational | | Linguis- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tics. +NaeemulHassan,GenshengZhang,FatmaArslan, +Vivek Gupta, Maitrey Mehta, Pegah Nokhiz, and Josue Caraballo, Damian Jimenez, Siddhant +Vivek Srikumar. 2020. INFOTABS: Inference Gawsane, Shohedul Hasan, Minumol Joseph, +on tables as semi-structured data. In Proceed- Aaditya Kulkarni, Anil Kumar Nayak, Vikas +ings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the As- Sable,ChengkaiLi,andMarkTremayne.2017. +sociation for Computational Linguistics, pages ClaimBuster: The first-ever end-to-end fact- +2309–2324, Online. Association for Computa- checkingsystem. ProceedingsoftheVLDBEn- +| tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | | dowment,10(12):1945–1948. | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Karl Moritz Hermann, Tomás Kociský, Edward Bansal. 2020. HoVer: A dataset for many- +Grefenstette,LasseEspeholt,WillKay,Mustafa hop fact extraction and claim verification. In +Suleyman, and Phil Blunsom. 2015. Teaching Findings of the Association for Computational +machinestoreadandcomprehend. InAdvances Linguistics: EMNLP 2020, pages 3441–3460, +in Neural Information Processing Systems 28: Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| AnnualConferenceonNeuralInformationPro- | | | | | | | tics. | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | +| cessing | Systems | 2015, | December | | 7-12, | 2015, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Jeff Johnson, | Matthijs | | Douze, | and | Hervé | Jégou. | +Montreal,Quebec,Canada,pages1693–1701. +2017. Billion-scalesimilaritysearchwithgpus. +| Sepp Hochreiter | | and | Jürgen | Schmidhuber. | | 1997. | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +CoRR,abs/1702.08734. +| Long | short-term | memory. | | Neural | | Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Garth S. | Jowett | and Victoria | | O’Donnell. | | 2019. | +tion,9(8):1735–1780. +| | | | | | | | Propaganda | & | Persuasion, | | 7th edition. | | SAGE | +| -------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | +| Benjamin | D. Horne, | Sara | Khedr, | | and Sibel | Adali. | | | | | | | | +Publications. +| 2018. | Sampling | the | news | producers: | | A large | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +news and feature data set for the study of the RabeehKarimiMahabadi, YonatanBelinkov, and +complex media landscape. In Proceedings of James Henderson. 2020. End-to-end bias miti- +the Twelfth International Conference on Web gation by modelling biases in corpora. In Pro- +andSocialMedia,ICWSM2018,Stanford,Cal- ceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the As- +ifornia,USA,June25-28,2018,pages518–527. sociation for Computational Linguistics, pages +| AAAIPress. | | | | | | | 8706–8716, | Online. | | Association | | for Computa- | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +tionalLinguistics. +| Tamanna | Hossain, | Robert | | L. Logan | IV, | Arjuna | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ugarte,YoshitomoMatsubara,SeanYoung,and AshkanKazemi,KiranGarimella,DevinGaffney, +| Sameer | Singh. | 2020. | COVIDLies: | | | Detecting | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | and Scott | Hale. | 2021. | Claim | matching | | beyond | +COVID-19misinformationonsocialmedia. In English to scale global fact-checking. In Pro- +Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on NLP for ceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the As- +COVID-19 (Part 2) at EMNLP 2020, Online. sociationforComputationalLinguisticsandthe +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | 11th International | | Joint | Conference | | on | Natu- | +| ------------ | ------ | ------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------------------ | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | ral Language | | Processing | (Volume | | 1: Long | Pa- | +| Md. Rafiqul | Islam, | Shaowu | | Liu, | Xianzhi | Wang, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | pers), | pages | 4504–4517, | | Online. | Association | | +| and Guandong | | Xu. | 2020. | Deep | learning | for | | | | | | | | +forComputationalLinguistics. +| misinformation | | detection | | on online | social | net- | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +works: a survey and new perspectives. Soc. Jude Khouja. 2020. Stance prediction and claim +Netw.Anal.Min.,10(1):82. +| | | | | | | | verification: | An | Arabic | perspective. | | In | Pro- | +| ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | ceedings | of the | Third | Workshop | | on Fact | Ex- | +| Alon Jacovi | and | Yoav | Goldberg. | | 2020. | To- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | traction | and VERification | | | (FEVER), | pages | 8– | +| wards | faithfully | interpretable | | | NLP | systems: | | | | | | | | +17,Online.AssociationforComputationalLin- +| How should | | we define | | and evaluate | | faithful- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guistics. +ness? InProceedingsofthe58thAnnualMeet- +| ing of | the Association | | for | Computational | | Lin- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Halil Kilicoglu, | | Dongwook | | Shin, Marcelo | | Fisz- | +guistics,pages4198–4205,Online.Association +man,GracielaRosemblat,andThomasC.Rind- +forComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | flesch. | 2012. | SemMedDB: | | a | pubmed-scale | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +Sarthak Jain and Byron C. Wallace. 2019. Atten- repositoryofbiomedicalsemanticpredications. +Bioinform.,28(23):3158–3160. +| tion is | not Explanation. | | | In Proceedings | | of the | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---------------- | -------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------------------- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | +| 2019 Conference | | of | the North | American | | Chap- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Jiseong Kim | and | Key-sun | Choi. | 2020. | Unsuper- | | +| ter of | the Association | | for | Computational | | Lin- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | vised fact | checking | | by counter-weighted | | | posi- | +| guistics: | Human | Language | | Technologies, | | Vol- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tive and | negative | evidential | | paths | in a | knowl- | +| ume 1 | (Long | and | Short | Papers), | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | pages | 3543– | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | edge graph. | | In Proceedings | | of | the 28th | In- | +| 3556, | Minneapolis, | | Minnesota. | | Association | for | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ternational | Conference | | on | Computational | | Lin- | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | guistics, | pages | 1677–1686, | | Barcelona, | | Spain | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | +Yichen Jiang, Shikha Bordia, Zheng Zhong, (Online). International Committee on Compu- +| Charles | Dognin, | Maneesh | | Singh, | and | Mohit | tationalLinguistics. | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Thomas N. Kipf and Max Welling. 2017. Semi- 2021 Conference of the North American Chap- +supervised classification with graph convolu- ter of the Association for Computational Lin- +tional networks. In 5th International Confer- guistics: HumanLanguageTechnologies,pages +ence on Learning Representations, ICLR 2017, 1971–1981, Online. Association for Computa- +| Toulon, | France, | April | 24-26, | 2017, | Conference | | tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +TrackProceedings.OpenReview.net. +| | | | | | | | Nayeon Lee, | Belinda | Z. | Li, Sinong | | Wang, Wen- | +| --------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | tau Yih, | Hao | Ma, and | Madian | Khabsa. | 2020. | +| Elena Kochkina, | | Maria | Liakata, | and | Isabelle | Au- | | | | | | | +Pro- +genstein. 2017. Turing at SemEval-2017 task Language models as fact checkers? In +ceedingsoftheThirdWorkshoponFactExtrac- +| 8: Sequential | | approach | to rumour | | stance | clas- | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | tion and | VERification | | (FEVER), | pages | 36–41, | +| sification | with | branch-LSTM. | | In | Proceedings | | | | | | | | +of the 11th International Workshop on Seman- Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +tics. +ticEvaluation(SemEval-2017),pages475–480, +| Vancouver, | Canada. | | Association | for | Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Piyawat Lertvittayakumjorn | | | and | Francesca | Toni. | +tionalLinguistics. 2019. Human-grounded evaluations of expla- +| | | | | | | | nation | methods | for text | classification. | | In Pro- | +| --------------------- | ------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | --------------- | --------------- | ---------- | --------- | +| Lev Konstantinovskiy, | | | Oliver | Price, | | Mevan | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ceedings | of the | 2019 Conference | | on | Empirical | +| Babakar, | and | Arkaitz | Zubiaga. | 2021. | | Toward | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Methods | in Natural | Language | | Processing | and | +| automated | factchecking: | | Developing | | an | anno- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the 9th | International | Joint | Conference | | on Nat- | +tationschemaandbenchmarkforconsistentau- +| | | | | | | | ural Language | | Processing | (EMNLP-IJCNLP), | | | +| ------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| tomated | claim | detection. | Digital | | Threats: | Re- | | | | | | | +pages5195–5205,HongKong,China.Associa- +searchandPractice,2(2):1–16. +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +Neema Kotonya and Francesca Toni. 2020a. Ex- Stephan Lewandowsky, Ullrich K.H. Ecker, +plainable automated fact-checking: A survey. Colleen M. Seifert, Norbert Schwarz, and John +| In Proceedings | | of the | 28th | International | | Con- | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ---------------- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | Cook. | 2012. | Misinformation | | and | Its Correc- | +| ference | on Computational | | | Linguistics, | | pages | | | | | | | +tion: ContinuedInfluenceandSuccessfulDebi- +5430–5443, Barcelona, Spain (Online). Inter- asing. Psychological Science in the Public In- +nationalCommitteeonComputationalLinguis- terest,Supplement,13(3):106–131. +tics. +| | | | | | | | Stephan Lewandowsky | | and | Sander | | van der Lin- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------------ | +Neema Kotonya and Francesca Toni. 2020b. Ex- den.2021. Counteringmisinformationandfake +plainable automated fact-checking for public news through inoculation and prebunking. Eu- +ropeanReviewofSocialPsychology,0(0):1–38. +| healthclaims. | | InProceedingsofthe2020Con- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | -------------------------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | +| ference | on Empirical | | Methods | in | Natural | Lan- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Justin Matthew | | Wren | Lewis, | Andy | Williams, | +guageProcessing(EMNLP),pages7740–7754, +| | | | | | | | Robert | Arthur | Franklin, | James | Thomas, | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | +Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| | | | | | | | NicholasAlexanderMosdell.2008. | | | | | Thequality | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | +tics. +| | | | | | | | and independence | | of british | | journalism. | Medi- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | +awise. +| Dilek Küçük | and | Fazli | Can. | 2020. | Stance | de- | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --------- | ----- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| tection: | A survey. | | ACM Computing | | Surveys, | | | | | | | | +PatrickS.H.Lewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPik- +| 53(1):12:1–12:37. | | | | | | | tus,FabioPetroni,VladimirKarpukhin,Naman | | | | | | +| ----------------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | -------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | Goyal, | Heinrich | Küttler, | Mike | Lewis, | Wen- | +| David MJ | Lazer, | Matthew | A Baum, | | Yochai | Ben- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tau Yih, | Tim | Rocktäschel, | | Sebastian | Riedel, | +kler, Adam J Berinsky, Kelly M Greenhill, and Douwe Kiela. 2020. Retrieval-augmented +| Filippo | Menczer, | Miriam | J | Metzger, | Brendan | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | generation | for | knowledge-intensive | | | NLP tasks. | +| Nyhan, | Gordon | Pennycook, | | David | Rothschild, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | In Advances | in | Neural | Information | | Processing | +etal.2018. Thescienceoffakenews. Science, Systems 33: Annual Conference on Neural In- +359(6380):1094–1096. +| | | | | | | | formation | Processing | | Systems | 2020, | NeurIPS | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | +2020,December6-12,2020,virtual. +| Nayeon Lee, | Yejin | Bang, | Andrea | Madotto, | | and | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Pascale Fung. 2021. Towards few-shot fact- Jiawen Li, Yudianto Sujana, and Hung-Yu Kao. +checking via perplexity. In Proceedings of the 2020. Exploiting microblog conversation + +structures to detect rumors. In Proceed- Annual Meeting of the Association for Com- +ings of the 28th International Conference on putational Linguistics, pages 2561–2571, Flo- +Computational Linguistics, pages 5420–5429, rence,Italy.AssociationforComputationalLin- +| Barcelona, | Spain | (Online). | | International | | Com- | guistics. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +mitteeonComputationalLinguistics. +JingMa,WeiGao,PrasenjitMitra,SejeongKwon, +YaliangLi,JingGao,ChuishiMeng,QiLi,LuSu, Bernard J. Jansen, Kam-Fai Wong, and Meey- +Bo Zhao, Wei Fan, and Jiawei Han. 2015. A oung Cha. 2016. Detecting rumors from mi- +survey on truth discovery. SIGKDD Explor., croblogs with recurrent neural networks. In +| 17(2):1–16. | | | | | | | Proceedings | | of the Twenty-Fifth | | | International | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Joint | Conference | on | Artificial | Intelligence, | | IJ- | +| Anders Edelbo | | Lillie, | Emil | Refsgaard | Middel- | | | | | | | | | +CAI2016,NewYork,NY,USA,9-15July2016, +| boe, and | Leon | Derczynski. | | 2019. | Joint | rumour | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pages3818–3824.IJCAI/AAAIPress. +| stance and | veracity | | prediction. | In | Proceedings | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +of the 22nd Nordic Conference on Computa- JingMa,WeiGao,andKam-FaiWong.2018. Ru- +| | | | | | | | mor detection | | on Twitter | | with tree-structured | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| tional Linguistics, | | pages | 208–221, | | Turku, | Fin- | | | | | | | | +land.LinköpingUniversityElectronicPress. recursive neural networks. In Proceedings of +| | | | | | | | the 56th | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +Sander van der Linden, Anthony Leiserowitz, ComputationalLinguistics(Volume1: LongPa- +| Seth Rosenthal, | | and | Edward | Maibach. | | 2017. | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | pers), | pages | 1980–1989, | Melbourne, | | Australia. | | +| Inoculating | the | public | against | misinformation | | | | | | | | | | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| about climate | | change. | | Global | Challenges, | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | +| 1(2):1600008. | | | | | | | JeanMaillard,VladimirKarpukhin,FabioPetroni, | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Wen-tau | Yih, | Barlas | Oguz, | Veselin | Stoyanov, | | +Zachary C. Lipton. 2018. The mythos of model andGargiGhosh.2021. Multi-taskretrievalfor +Commun.ACM,61(10):36–43. +interpretability. knowledge-intensive tasks. In Proceedings of +| | | | | | | | the 59th | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | for | +| ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ------------ | ------- | ---- | ---- | ------------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------ | +| Zhenghao | Liu, | Chenyan | Xiong, | Maosong | | Sun, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Computational | | Linguistics | | and the | 11th | Inter- | +| and Zhiyuan | | Liu. 2020. | Fine-grained | | fact | ver- | | | | | | | | +nationalJointConferenceonNaturalLanguage +| ification | with | kernel | graph | attention | network. | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ---- | ------ | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Processing | | (Volume | 1: Long | Papers), | | pages | +| In Proceedings | | of | the 58th | Annual | Meeting | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 1098–1111, | | Online. | Association | | for Computa- | | +| of the Association | | | for Computational | | Linguis- | | | | | | | | | +tionalLinguistics. +| tics, pages | 7342–7351, | | Online. | Association | | for | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Joshua Maynez, | | Shashi | Narayan, | Bernd | Bohnet, | | +| -------------------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------------- | ------------ | ------- | +| | | | | | | | andRyanMcDonald.2020. | | | | Onfaithfulnessand | | | +| Yi-JuLuandCheng-TeLi.2020. | | | | GCAN:Graph- | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | factualityinabstractivesummarization. | | | | | | InPro- | +| aware | co-attention | | networks | for | explainable | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ceedings | of | the 58th | Annual | Meeting | of | the As- | +| fake news | detection | | on social | media. | | In Pro- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | sociation | for | Computational | | Linguistics, | | pages | +| ceedings | of the | 58th | Annual | Meeting | of | the As- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 1906–1919, | | Online. | Association | | for Computa- | | +| sociation | for | Computational | | Linguistics, | | pages | | | | | | | | +tionalLinguistics. +| 505–514, | Online. | | Association | for | Computa- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionalLinguistics. Tom McCoy, Ellie Pavlick, and Tal Linzen. 2019. +| | | | | | | | Right | for the | wrong | reasons: | Diagnosing | | syn- | +| ------------------------- | ------ | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | ------ | --------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------ | ---- | +| Jackson | Luken, | Nanjiang | | Jiang, | and | Marie- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tactic | heuristics | in natural | | language | inference. | | +| CatherinedeMarneffe.2018. | | | | QED:Afactver- | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | In Proceedings | | of the | 57th | Annual | Meeting | of | +| ification | system | for | the FEVER | shared | task. | In | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the Association | | for Computational | | | Linguistics, | | +| Proceedings | | of the | First Workshop | | on Fact | Ex- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | pages | 3428–3448, | Florence, | | Italy. | Association | | +tractionandVERification(FEVER),pages156– +forComputationalLinguistics. +| 160, Brussels, | | Belgium. | Association | | for | Com- | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +putationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Paul Mena. | 2019. | Principles | | and | boundaries | of | +| -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | fact-checking: | | Journalists’ | | perceptions. | | Jour- | +| Jing Ma, | Wei | Gao, | Shafiq | Joty, | and Kam-Fai | | | | | | | | | +nalismPractice,13(6):657–672. +| Wong. | 2019. | Sentence-level | | evidence | | embed- | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ding for claim verification with hierarchical at- RadaMihalceaandCarloStrapparava.2009. The +tention networks. In Proceedings of the 57th lie detector: Explorations in the automatic + +recognitionofdeceptivelanguage. InProceed- Preslav Nakov. 2020. Can we spot the "fake +ingsoftheACL-IJCNLP2009ConferenceShort news" before it was even written? CoRR, +| Papers,pages309–312,Suntec,Singapore.As- | | | | | | abs/2008.04374. | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Preslav | Nakov, | David | P. | A. Corney, | Maram | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | ----- | +Tsvetomila Mihaylova, Preslav Nakov, Lluís Hasanain, Firoj Alam, Tamer Elsayed, Alberto +Màrquez, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño, Mitra Mo- Barrón-Cedeño, Paolo Papotti, Shaden Shaar, +htarami, Georgi Karadzhov, and James R. and Giovanni Da San Martino. 2021a. Auto- +Glass. 2018. Fact checking in community fo- mated fact-checking for assisting human fact- +rums. In Proceedings of the Thirty-Second checkers. CoRR,abs/2103.07769. +| AAAI Conference | | on Artificial | | Intelligence, | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(AAAI-18), the 30th innovative Applications of Preslav Nakov, Giovanni Da San Martino, +TamerElsayed,AlbertoBarrón-Cedeño,Rubén +| Artificial | Intelligence | (IAAI-18), | | and | the 8th | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | Míguez, | Shaden | Shaar, | | Firoj Alam, | Fatima | +| AAAI Symposium | | on Educational | | Advances | in | | | | | | | +ArtificialIntelligence(EAAI-18), NewOrleans, Haouari, Maram Hasanain, Nikolay Babulkov, +| | | | | | | Alex | Nikolov, | Gautam | | Kishore | Shahi, Ju- | +| ---------- | ---- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ---------- | +| Louisiana, | USA, | February | 2-7, | 2018, | pages | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | lia Maria | Struß, | and | Thomas | Mandl. | 2021b. | +5309–5316.AAAIPress. +| | | | | | | The CLEF-2021 | | CheckThat! | | lab | on detecting | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | +Tanushree Mitra and Eric Gilbert. 2015. CRED- check-worthy claims, previously fact-checked +| | | | | | | claims,andfakenews. | | | InAdvancesinInforma- | | | +| ----- | ------------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| BANK: | A large-scale | social | media | corpus | with | | | | | | | +associated credibility annotations. In Proceed- tion Retrieval - 43rd European Conference on +ings of the Ninth International Conference on IR Research, ECIR 2021, Virtual Event, March +28-April1,2021,Proceedings,PartII,volume +| Web and | Social | Media, ICWSM | | 2015, | Univer- | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sity of Oxford, Oxford, UK, May 26-29, 2015, 12657 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, +| pages258–267.AAAIPress. | | | | | | pages639–649.Springer. | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Federico Monti, Fabrizio Frasca, Davide Eynard, Sangha Nam, Eun-Kyung Kim, Jiho Kim, +YoosungJung,KijongHan,andKey-SunChoi. +| Damon | Mannion, | and Michael | | M. Bronstein. | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2019. Fake news detection on social me- 2018. A korean knowledge extraction sys- +dia using geometric deep learning. CoRR, tem for enriching a kbox. In COLING 2018, +| | | | | | | The 27th | International | | Conference | | on Compu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | +abs/1902.06673. +| | | | | | | tational | Linguistics: | | System | Demonstrations, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | +Yida Mu and Nikolaos Aletras. 2020. Identifying Santa Fe, New Mexico, August 20-26, 2018, +twitteruserswhorepostunreliablenewssources +| | | | | | | pages | 20–24. | Association | | for Computational | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | +| with linguistic | | information. | | PeerJ | Computer | Linguistics. | | | | | | +Science,6. +| | | | | | | Yixin Nie, | Haonan | | Chen, | and Mohit | Bansal. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------- | ------- | +Kai Nakamura, Sharon Levy, and William Yang 2019a. Combining fact extraction and verifica- +| Wang. | 2020. | Fakeddit: | A | new multimodal | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | tion with | neural | semantic | | matching | networks. | +benchmark dataset for fine-grained fake news In The Thirty-Third AAAI Conference on Ar- +detection. In Proceedings of The 12th Lan- tificial Intelligence, AAAI 2019, The Thirty- +guage Resources and Evaluation Conference, First Innovative Applications of Artificial In- +LREC 2020, Marseille, France, May 11-16, telligence Conference, IAAI 2019, The Ninth +2020, pages 6149–6157. European Language AAAI Symposium on Educational Advances in +ResourcesAssociation. Artificial Intelligence, EAAI 2019, Honolulu, +| | | | | | | Hawaii, | USA, | January | 27 | - February | 1, 2019, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | +Ndapandula Nakashole and Tom M. Mitchell. pages6859–6866.AAAIPress. +2014. Language-awaretruthassessmentoffact +candidates. In Proceedings of the 52nd Annual Yixin Nie, Songhe Wang, and Mohit Bansal. +Meeting of the Association for Computational 2019b. Revealing the importance of semantic +Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages retrieval for machine reading at scale. In Pro- +1009–1019, Baltimore, Maryland. Association ceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical +forComputationalLinguistics. Methods in Natural Language Processing and + +the 9th International Joint Conference on Nat- FabioPetroni,TimRocktäschel,SebastianRiedel, +ural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), PatrickLewis,AntonBakhtin,YuxiangWu,and +pages2553–2566,HongKong,China.Associa- Alexander Miller. 2019. Language models as +tionforComputationalLinguistics. knowledge bases? In Proceedings of the 2019 +Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural +Jeppe Nørregaard and Leon Derczynski. 2021. LanguageProcessingandthe9thInternational +DanFEVER: claim verification dataset for dan- Joint Conference on Natural Language Pro- +ish. In Proceedings of the 23rd Nordic Con- cessing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), pages 2463–2473, +ference on Computational Linguistics, NoDaL- Hong Kong, China. Association for Computa- +iDa 2021, Reykjavik, Iceland (Online), May 31 tionalLinguistics. +-June2,2021,pages422–428.LinköpingUni- +versityElectronicPress,Sweden. Adam Poliak, Jason Naradowsky, Aparajita +Haldar, Rachel Rudinger, and Benjamin +Jeppe Nørregaard, Benjamin D. Horne, and Sibel Van Durme. 2018. Hypothesis only baselines +Adali. 2019. NELA-GT-2018: A large multi- in natural language inference. In Proceedings +labelled news dataset for the study of misin- of the Seventh Joint Conference on Lexical +formation in news articles. In Proceedings of and Computational Semantics, pages 180–191, +theThirteenthInternationalConferenceonWeb New Orleans, Louisiana. Association for +andSocialMedia,ICWSM2019,Munich,Ger- ComputationalLinguistics. +many,June11-14,2019,pages630–638.AAAI +Dean Pomerleau and Delip Rao. 2017. The fake +Press. +news challenge: Exploring how artificial intel- +Cathy O’Neil. 2016. Weapons of Math De- ligencetechnologiescouldbeleveragedtocom- +struction: How Big Data Increases Inequality batfakenews. FakeNewsChallenge. +and Threatens Democracy. Crown Publishing +Kashyap Popat, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Jannik +Group,USA. +Strötgen, and Gerhard Weikum. 2016. Cred- +ibility assessment of textual claims on the +Ray Oshikawa, Jing Qian, and William Yang +web. In Proceedings of the 25th ACM Interna- +Wang.2020. Asurveyonnaturallanguagepro- +tional Conference on Information and Knowl- +cessingforfakenewsdetection. InProceedings +edge Management, CIKM 2016, Indianapolis, +of the 12th Language Resources and Evalua- +IN, USA, October 24-28, 2016, pages 2173– +tion Conference, pages 6086–6093, Marseille, +2178.ACM. +France.EuropeanLanguage ResourcesAssoci- +ation. +Kashyap Popat, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Andrew +Yates, and Gerhard Weikum. 2018. DeClarE: +Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, Wenhan Xiong, +Debunking fake news and false claims using +Min-Yen Kan, and William Yang Wang. 2021. +evidence-aware deep learning. In Proceedings +Zero-shot fact verification by claim generation. +of the 2018 Conference on Empirical Methods +In Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of +in Natural Language Processing, pages 22–32, +the Association for Computational Linguistics +Brussels, Belgium. Association for Computa- +and the 11th International Joint Conference +tionalLinguistics. +onNaturalLanguageProcessing,ACL/IJCNLP +2021, (Volume 2: Short Papers), Virtual Event, MartinPotthast,JohannesKiesel,KevinReinartz, +August 1-6, 2021, pages 476–483. Association Janek Bevendorff, and Benno Stein. 2018. A +forComputationalLinguistics. stylometric inquiry into hyperpartisan and fake +news. In Proceedings of the 56th Annual +Verónica Pérez-Rosas, Bennett Kleinberg, +Meeting of the Association for Computational +Alexandra Lefevre, and Rada Mihalcea. 2018. +Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages +Automatic detection of fake news. In Proceed- +231–240,Melbourne,Australia.Associationfor +ings of the 27th International Conference on +ComputationalLinguistics. +Computational Linguistics, pages 3391–3401, +Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA. Association for Danish Pruthi, Mansi Gupta, Bhuwan Dhingra, +ComputationalLinguistics. Graham Neubig, and Zachary C. Lipton. 2020. + +Learningtodeceivewithattention-basedexpla- International Joint Conference on Natural +nations. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Language Processing, ACL/IJCNLP 2021, +Meeting of the Association for Computational (Volume1: LongPapers),VirtualEvent,August +Linguistics, pages 4782–4793, Online. Associ- 1-6, 2021, pages 2116–2129. Association for +| ationforComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | | | ComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| VahedQazvinian, | | EmilyRosengren, | | | DragomirR. | | | | | | | | | +FatimaK.AbuSalem,RoaaAlFeel,ShadyElbas- +Radev, and Qiaozhu Mei. 2011. Rumor has it: suoni, Mohamad Jaber, and May Farah. 2019. +Identifying misinformation in microblogs. In FA-KES: A fake news dataset around the syr- +Proceedingsofthe2011ConferenceonEmpiri- ianwar. InProceedingsoftheThirteenthInter- +| cal Methods | | in Natural | Language | | Processing, | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +nationalConferenceonWebandSocialMedia, +pages 1589–1599, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK. ICWSM 2019, Munich, Germany, June 11-14, +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. 2019,pages573–582.AAAIPress. +| Alec Radford, | Jeffrey | | Wu, | Rewon | Child, | David | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Giovanni | C. Santia | and | Jake | Ryland | Williams. | | +Luan,DarioAmodei,andIlyaSutskever.2019. +| | | | | | | | 2018. | BuzzFace: | A | news veracity | | dataset | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | +Language models are unsupervised multitask facebook user commentary and egos. In Pro- +| learners. | OpenAIblog,1(8):9. | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ----- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | ceedings | of the | Twelfth | International | | | Confer- | +| | | | | | | | ence on | Web and | Social | Media, | ICWSM | | 2018, | +HannahRashkin,EunsolChoi,JinYeaJang,Svit- +| | | | | | | | Stanford, | California, | | USA, | June | 25-28, | 2018, | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------ | ----- | +| lana Volkova, | | and | Yejin | Choi. | 2017. | Truth | | | | | | | | +pages531–540.AAAIPress. +| of varying | shades: | | Analyzing | language | | in fake | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | ----- | ------ | ---- | ---- | --- | ------ | +| news and | political | | fact-checking. | | In Proceed- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Aalok Sathe, | Salar | Ather, | Tuan | Manh | Le, | Nathan | +ingsofthe2017ConferenceonEmpiricalMeth- +| | | | | | | | Perry,andJoonsukPark.2020. | | | | Automatedfact- | | | +| ---------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | --------- | ---- | --------------- | -------------- | --- | ---- | +| ods in | Natural | Language | | Processing, | | pages | | | | | | | Pro- | +| | | | | | | | checking | of claims | | from wikipedia. | | | In | +| 2931–2937, | | Copenhagen, | | Denmark. | | Associa- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ceedings | of The | 12th | Language | Resources | | and | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +EvaluationConference,LREC2020,Marseille, +| | | | | | | | France, | May | 11-16, | 2020, | pages | 6874–6882. | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| Miriam Redi, | Besnik | | Fetahu, | Jonathan | | T. Mor- | | | | | | | | +EuropeanLanguageResourcesAssociation. +| gan, and | Dario | Taraborelli. | | 2019. | | Citation | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | ------------------- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | +| Needed: | A taxonomy | | and | algorithmic | | assess- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Michael | Sejr Schlichtkrull, | | Vladimir | | Karpukhin, | | +| ment of | wikipedia’s | | verifiability. | | In The | World | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Barlas | Oguz, | Mike | Lewis, | Wen-tau | Yih, | and | +| Wide Web | Conference, | | WWW | 2019, | San | Fran- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Sebastian | Riedel. | 2021. | Joint | verification | | and | +cisco,CA,USA,May13-17,2019,pages1567– +| | | | | | | | reranking | for | open fact | checking | | over | tables. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------- | +1578.ACM. +| | | | | | | | In Proceedings | | of the | 59th | Annual | Meeting | of | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | +Jon Roozenbeek and Sander van der Linden. the Association for Computational Linguistics +| | | | | | | | and the | 11th International | | | Joint Conference | | on | +| ----------- | -------- | ---- | ------------------ | -------- | --------- | ------- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | +| 2019. | The fake | news | game: | actively | inoculat- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | NaturalLanguageProcessing(Volume1: | | | | | | Long | +| ing against | the | risk | of misinformation. | | | Journal | | | | | | | | +Papers),pages6787–6799,Online.Association +ofRiskResearch,22(5):570–580. +forComputationalLinguistics. +| Jon Roozenbeek, | | Sander | van | der | Linden, | and | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Thomas Nygren. 2020. Prebunking interven- Tal Schuster, Adam Fisch, and Regina Barzilay. +| | | | | | | | 2021. | Get your | Vitamin | C! | robust | fact | verifi- | +| ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------- | +| tions based | on | the psychological | | | theory | of "in- | | | | | | | | +oculation"canreducesusceptibilitytomisinfor- cation with contrastive evidence. In Proceed- +mation across cultures. The Harvard Kennedy ingsofthe2021ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- +| | | | | | | | ican Chapter | | of the | Association | | for Computa- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +SchoolMisinformationReview,1(2). +| | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | | HumanLanguageTechnolo- | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ------------------ | -------- | ---------------------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | +| Arkadiy | Saakyan, | | Tuhin | Chakrabarty, | | and | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | gies, pages | 624–643, | | Online. | Association | | for | +| Smaranda | Muresan. | | 2021. | COVID-Fact: | | Fact | | | | | | | | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| extraction | and | verification | | of real-world | | claims | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +on COVID-19 pandemic. In Proceedings of Tal Schuster, Roei Schuster, Darsh J. Shah, and +the 59th Annual Meeting of the Association Regina Barzilay. 2020. The limitations of sty- +for Computational Linguistics and the 11th lometry for detecting machine-generated fake + +news. Computational Linguistics, 46(2):499– factchecking. In2017IEEEInternationalCon- +| 510. | | | | | | | ference | on Data | Mining, | ICDM | 2017, | New Or- | +| ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | leans, LA, | USA, | November | | 18-21, | 2017, pages | +| Tal Schuster, | | Darsh Shah, | Yun | Jie | Serene | Yeo, | | | | | | | +859–864.IEEEComputerSociety. +| Daniel | Roberto | Filizzola | Ortiz, | Enrico | | Santus, | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +and Regina Barzilay. 2019. Towards debias- Kai Shu, Limeng Cui, Suhang Wang, Dongwon +ing fact verification models. In Proceedings Lee, and Huan Liu. 2019. dEFEND: Explain- +of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Meth- ablefakenewsdetection. InProceedingsofthe +ods in Natural Language Processing and the 25th ACM SIGKDD International Conference +onKnowledgeDiscovery&DataMining,KDD +| 9th International | | Joint | Conference | | on | Natu- | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ral Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), 2019, Anchorage, AK, USA, August 4-8, 2019, +| pages3419–3425,HongKong,China.Associa- | | | | | | | pages395–405.ACM. | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Kai Shu, Deepak | | Mahudeswaran, | | Suhang | Wang, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | +Sofia Serrano and Noah A. Smith. 2019. Is atten- Dongwon Lee, and Huan Liu. 2020. Fake- +tion interpretable? In Proceedings of the 57th NewsNet: Adatarepositorywithnewscontent, +| | | | | | | | social context, | | and spatiotemporal | | | information | +| ------ | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | +| Annual | Meeting | of the | Association | | for | Com- | | | | | | | +putational Linguistics, pages 2931–2951, Flo- for studying fake news on social media. Big +| rence,Italy.AssociationforComputationalLin- | | | | | | | Data,8(3):171–188. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guistics. +| | | | | | | | Kai Shu, Amy | Sliva, | Suhang | Wang, | | Jiliang Tang, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | ----- | --- | ------------- | +Shaden Shaar, Nikolay Babulkov, Giovanni and Huan Liu. 2017. Fake news detection +| | | | | | | | on social | media: | A data | mining | | perspective. | +| ------ | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | ------------ | +| Da San | Martino, | and | Preslav | | Nakov. | 2020. | | | | | | | +SIGKDDExplor.,19(1):22–36. +| That | is a known | lie: Detecting | | previously | | fact- | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | +| checked | claims. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 58th | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Fernando | Cardoso | Durier | da Silva, | Rafael | Vieira, | +| Annual | Meeting | of the | Association | | for | Compu- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Ana | Cristina | Bicharra | Garcia. | | 2019. Can | +| tational | Linguistics, | pages | | 3607–3618, | | Online. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | machines | learn | to detect | fake | news? | A sur- | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | vey focused | on | social | media. | In | 52nd Hawaii | +| ------ | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | International | | Conference | on | System | Sciences, | +| Gautam | Kishore | Shahi | and | Durgesh | Nandini. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | HICSS | 2019, | Grand | Wailea, | Maui, | Hawaii, | +2020. FakeCovid–amultilingualcross-domain +| | | | | | | | USA, January | | 8-11, 2019, | | pages | 1–8. Schol- | +| ----------------------------------------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | +| fact | check | news dataset | | for covid-19. | | In | | | | | | | +| WorkshopProceedingsofthe14thInternational | | | | | | | arSpace. | | | | | | +AAAIConferenceonWebandSocialMedia. +| | | | | | | | Craig Silverman. | | 2014. | Verification | | Handbook: | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +AnUltimateGuidelineonDigitalAgeSourcing +| Qiang Sheng, | | Juan Cao, | Xueyao | Zhang, | | Xirong | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | forEmergencyCoverage. | | | EuropeanJournalism | | | +| Li, and | Lei | Zhong. 2021. | Article | | reranking | by | | | | | | | +Centre. +| memory-enhanced | | key | sentence | | matching | for | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +detecting previously fact-checked claims. In RichardSocher,DanqiChen,ChristopherD.Man- +Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the ning, and Andrew Y. Ng. 2013. Reasoning +| Association | | for Computational | | Linguistics | | and | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +withneuraltensornetworksforknowledgebase +the11thInternationalJointConferenceonNat- completion. InAdvancesinNeuralInformation +uralLanguageProcessing(Volume1: LongPa- Processing Systems 26: 27th Annual Confer- +| pers), | pages | 5468–5481, | Online. | | Association | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +enceonNeuralInformationProcessingSystems +forComputationalLinguistics. +2013.ProceedingsofameetingheldDecember +| | | | | | | | 5-8, 2013, | Lake | Tahoe, | Nevada, | United | States, | +| ----- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | +| Baoxu | Shi and | Tim Weninger. | | 2016. | Discrim- | | | | | | | | +pages926–934. +| inative | predicate | path | mining | for | fact | check- | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ing in knowledge graphs. Knowl. Based Syst., Cass R Sunstein and Adrian Vermeule. 2009. +| 104:123–133. | | | | | | | Conspiracy | theories: | Causes | | and | cures. Jour- | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | ------------ | +nalofPoliticalPhilosophy,17(2):202–227. +| Prashant | Shiralkar, | Alessandro | | Flammini, | | Filippo | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Menczer,andGiovanniLucaCiampaglia.2017. Kai Sheng Tai, Richard Socher, and Christo- +Findingstreamsinknowledgegraphstosupport pher D. Manning. 2015. Improved semantic + +representationsfromtree-structuredlongshort- Hong Kong, China. Association for Computa- +| term memory | | networks. | In | Proceedings | of | tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| the 53rd | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | | | | | | | | +for Computational Linguistics and the 7th In- Joshua A Tucker, Andrew Guess, Pablo Bar- +ternational Joint Conference on Natural Lan- berá,CristianVaccari,AlexandraSiegel,Sergey +guage Processing (Volume 1: Long Papers), Sanovich, Denis Stukal, and Brendan Nyhan. +pages 1556–1566, Beijing, China. Association 2018. Social media, political polarization, and +forComputationalLinguistics. politicaldisinformation: Areviewofthescien- +| | | | | | | tific | literature. | Political | | polarization, | | and po- | +| --------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | ---------- | +| Philip M. | Taylor. | 2003. | Munitions | of | the mind: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | litical | disinformation: | | a | review | of the | scientific | +Ahistoryofpropagandafromtheancientworld +literature(March19,2018). +| tothepresentera,3rdedition. | | | | ManchesterUni- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------- | ------------------ | -------------- | ----- | -------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | ----- | +| versityPress. | | | | | | Joseph | E. Uscinski. | | 2015. | The | epistemology | | +| | | | | | | of fact | checking | (is | still | naìve): | Rejoinder | to | +| JamesThorneandAndreasVlachos.2018. | | | | | Auto- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | amazeen. | CriticalReview,27(2):243–252. | | | | | | +| mated fact | checking: | | Task formulations, | | meth- | | | | | | | | +| ods and | future | directions. | | In Proceedings | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Joseph | E. Uscinski | and | Ryden | | W. Butler. | 2013. | +the27thInternationalConferenceonComputa- +| | | | | | | Theepistemologyoffactchecking. | | | | | CriticalRe- | | +| ------------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| tional Linguistics, | | pages | 3346–3359, | | Santa Fe, | | | | | | | | +view,25(2):162–180. +| New Mexico, | | USA. Association | | for | Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Prasetya | Ajie | Utama, | Nafise | Sadat | Moosavi, | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | +James Thorne and Andreas Vlachos. 2021. Elas- Iryna Gurevych. 2020a. Mind the trade-off: +tic weight consolidation for better bias inoc- Debiasing NLU models without degrading the +ulation. In Proceedings of the 16th Confer- in-distribution performance. In Proceedings of +enceoftheEuropeanChapteroftheAssociation the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for +for Computational Linguistics: Main Volume, Computational Linguistics, pages 8717–8729, +pages 957–964, Online. Association for Com- Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| putationalLinguistics. | | | | | | tics. | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | +| James Thorne, | | Andreas | Vlachos, | | Christos | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Prasetya | Ajie | Utama, | Nafise | Sadat | Moosavi, | and | +| Christodoulopoulos, | | | and Arpit | Mittal. | 2018a. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Iryna | Gurevych. | 2020b. | | Towards | | debiasing | +FEVER:alarge-scaledatasetforfactextraction +| | | | | | | NLU | models | from | unknown | | biases. | In Pro- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +and VERification. In Proceedings of the 2018 ceedings of the 2020 Conference on Empiri- +| Conference | of | the North | American | | Chapter of | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | -------- | ----------------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | cal Methods | | in Natural | | Language | Processing | | +| the Association | | for Computational | | Linguistics: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | (EMNLP), | pages | 7597–7610, | | | Online. | Associa- | +| Human | Language | Technologies, | | | Volume 1 | | | | | | | | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| (Long Papers), | | pages | 809–819, | New | Orleans, | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----- | +| Louisiana. | Association | | for | Computational | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Andreas | Vlachos | and | Sebastian | | Riedel. | 2014. | +Linguistics. +| | | | | | | Factchecking: | | Taskdefinitionanddatasetcon- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | struction. | | In Proceedings | | of | the ACL | 2014 | +JamesThorne,AndreasVlachos,OanaCocarascu, +WorkshoponLanguageTechnologiesandCom- +| Christos | Christodoulopoulos, | | | and Arpit | Mittal. | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | +| | | | | | | putational | Social | | Science, | pages | 18–22, | Bal- | +| 2018b. | The fact | extraction | | and VERification | | | | | | | | | +(FEVER) shared task. In Proceedings of the timore, MD, USA. Association for Computa- +tionalLinguistics. +| First Workshop | | on Fact | Extraction | and | VERifi- | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cation(FEVER),pages1–9,Brussels,Belgium. +| | | | | | | Andreas | Vlachos | and | Sebastian | | Riedel. | 2015. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----- | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Identification | | and | verification | | of simple | claims | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ------ | +JamesThorne,AndreasVlachos,OanaCocarascu, about statistical properties. In Proceedings +Christos Christodoulopoulos, and Arpit Mittal. of the 2015 Conference on Empirical Methods +2019. The FEVER2.0 shared task. In Pro- in Natural Language Processing, pages 2596– +ceedings of the Second Workshop on Fact Ex- 2601, Lisbon, Portugal. Association for Com- +tractionandVERification(FEVER),pages1–6, putationalLinguistics. + +Nguyen Vo and Kyumin Lee. 2020. Where are AdinaWilliams,NikitaNangia,andSamuelBow- +the facts? searching for fact-checked informa- man.2018. Abroad-coveragechallengecorpus +tion to alleviate the spread of fake news. In for sentence understanding through inference. +Proceedings of the 2020 Conference on Empir- In Proceedings of the 2018 Conference of the +ical Methods in Natural Language Processing North American Chapter of the Association for +(EMNLP), pages 7717–7731, Online. Associa- Computational Linguistics: Human Language +tionforComputationalLinguistics. Technologies, Volume 1 (Long Papers), pages +| | | | | | | | 1112–1122, | | New Orleans, | | Louisiana. | Associa- | | +| -------- | -------- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +| Svitlana | Volkova, | Kyle | Shaffer, | Jin | Yea | Jang, and | | | | | | | | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| NathanHodas.2017. | | | Separatingfactsfromfic- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | +| tion: | Linguistic | models | | to classify | suspicious | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Lianwei | Wu, | Yuan Rao, | Xiong | Yang, | Wanzhen | | +and trusted news posts on Twitter. In Pro- Wang, and Ambreen Nazir. 2020a. Evidence- +| ceedings | of | the 55th | Annual | Meeting | | of the As- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | aware | hierarchical | | interactive | | attention | net- | +| sociation | for | Computational | | Linguistics | | (Vol- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | works | for explainable | | claim | verification. | | In | +ume 2: Short Papers), pages 647–653, Van- Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth International +couver,Canada.AssociationforComputational Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence, +Linguistics. +IJCAI-20,pages1388–1394.InternationalJoint +| | | | | | | | Conferences | | on Artificial | | Intelligence | | Organi- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | +DavidWadden,ShanchuanLin,KyleLo,LucyLu +| | | | | | | | zation. | Maintrack. | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -------------- | ------ | ---------------------------- | ---------- | ------------ | --------- | -------- | -------- | ------- | +| Wang, | Madeleine | | van Zuylen, | | Arman | Cohan, | | | | | | | | +| andHannanehHajishirzi.2020. | | | | | FactorFiction: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Lianwei | Wu, | Yuan Rao, | Yongqiang | | Zhao, | Hao | +| Verifying | scientific | | claims. | In | Proceedings | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Liang,andAmbreenNazir.2020b. | | | | | DTCA:De- | | +| the 2020 | Conference | | on | Empirical | Methods | in | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | cision | tree-based | co-attention | | networks | | for ex- | +NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP),pages +| | | | | | | | plainable | claim | verification. | | In Proceedings | | of | +| ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| 7534–7550, | | Online. | Association | | for | Computa- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the 58th | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | for | +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Computational | | Linguistics, | | pages | 1024–1035, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| Nancy Xin | Ru | Wang, | Diwakar | | Mahajan, | Ma- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | +| rina Danilevsky, | | | and Sara | Rosenthal. | | 2021. | tics. | | | | | | | +| SemEval-2021 | | task | 9: Fact | verification | | and ev- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Fan Yang, | Shiva | K. | Pentyala, | Sina | Mohseni, | | +idencefindingfortabulardatainscientificdoc- +MengnanDu,HaoYuan,RhemaLinder,EricD. +| uments | (SEM-TAB-FACTS). | | | | In Proceedings | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ | ----------- | --------- | -------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ | -------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | Ragan, | Shuiwang | Ji, | and | Xia (Ben) | Hu. | 2019. | +| of the | 15th | International | | Workshop | on | Seman- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | XFake: | Explainablefakenewsdetectorwithvi- | | | | | | +| tic Evaluation, | | SemEval@ACL/IJCNLP | | | | 2021, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | sualizations. | | In The | World | Wide | Web | Confer- | +| Virtual | Event | / Bangkok, | | Thailand, | August | 5-6, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ence, | WWW | 2019, | San Francisco, | | CA, | USA, | +| 2021, | pages | 317–326. | Association | | for | Compu- | | | | | | | | +May13-17,2019,pages3600–3604.ACM. +tationalLinguistics. +William Yang Wang. 2017. “Liar, Liar Pants on Xiaoyu Yang, Yuefei Lyu, Tian Tian, Yifei Liu, +Fire”: A new benchmark dataset for fake news Yudong Liu, and Xi Zhang. 2020a. Rumor de- +| | | | | | | | tection | on social | media | with | graph | structured | | +| ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | --------- | ----- | ---- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| detection. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 55th | Annual | | | | | | | | +Meeting of the Association for Computational adversarial learning. In Proceedings of the +Linguistics (Volume 2: Short Papers), pages Twenty-NinthInternationalJointConferenceon +ArtificialIntelligence,IJCAI2020,pages1417– +| 422–426, | Vancouver, | | Canada. | | Association | for | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1423.ijcai.org. +ComputationalLinguistics. +Sarah Wiegreffe and Yuval Pinter. 2019. Atten- Xiaoyu Yang, Feng Nie, Yufei Feng, Quan Liu, +tion is not not explanation. In Proceedings of Zhigang Chen, and Xiaodan Zhu. 2020b. Pro- +the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in gram enhanced fact verification with verbal- +NaturalLanguageProcessingandthe9thInter- ization and graph attention network. In Pro- +nationalJointConferenceonNaturalLanguage ceedings of the 2020 Conference on Empiri- +Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), pages 11–20, cal Methods in Natural Language Processing +Hong Kong, China. Association for Computa- (EMNLP), pages 7810–7825, Online. Associa- +| tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | | tionforComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Chih-Kuan Yeh, Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Arun Sai Sug- Daniel Yue Zhang, Lanyu Shang, Biao Geng, +gala, David I. Inouye, and Pradeep Ravikumar. Shuyue Lai, Ke Li, Hongmin Zhu, Md. Tan- +2019. On the (in)fidelity and sensitivity of ex- vir Al Amin, and Dong Wang. 2018. Faux- +planations. In Advances in Neural Information Buster: A content-free fauxtography detector +Processing Systems 32: Annual Conference on usingsocialmediacomments. InIEEEInterna- +Neural Information Processing Systems 2019, tionalConferenceonBigData,BigData2018, +NeurIPS 2019, December 8-14, 2019, Vancou- Seattle, WA, USA, December 10-13, 2018, +| ver,BC,Canada,pages10965–10976. | | | | | | | pages891–900.IEEE. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | Wenxuan | Zhang, | Yang | Deng, | Jing Ma, | and Wai | +| WenpengYinandDanRoth.2018. | | | | | TwoWingOS: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Lam. | 2020. | AnswerFact: | | Fact checking | in | +Atwo-wingoptimizationstrategyforevidential +claim verification. In Proceedings of the 2018 product question answering. In Proceedings of +Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural the 2020 Conference on Empirical Methods in +NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP),pages +| Language | Processing, | | Brussels, | | Belgium, | Oc- | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tober 31 - November 4, 2018, pages 105–114. 2407–2417, Online. Association for Computa- +| AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ------ | ------------------ | ------ | ------ | ------- | ---------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | Xueyao | Zhang, | Juan | Cao, | Xirong | Li, Qiang | +| Takuma Yoneda, | | Jeff | Mitchell, | Johannes | | Welbl, | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Sheng, | Lei | Zhong, | and Kai | Shu. 2021. | Mining | +| Pontus | Stenetorp, | and | Sebastian | | Riedel. | 2018. | | | | | | | +UCL machine reading group: Four factor dualemotionforfakenewsdetection. InWWW +| | | | | | | | ’21: | The Web | Conference | | 2021, Virtual | Event | +| --------- | --- | ---- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----- | ------------- | ----- | +| framework | for | fact | finding | (HexaF). | | In Pro- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | / Ljubljana, | | Slovenia, | April | 19-23, 2021, | pages | +ceedingsoftheFirstWorkshoponFactExtrac- +| tionandVERification(FEVER),pages97–102, | | | | | | | 3465–3476.ACM/IW3C2. | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------------------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----- | +| Brussels, | Belgium. | | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Yi Zhang, | Zachary | Ives, | and | Dan Roth. | 2019. | +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Evidence-based | | trustworthiness. | | In | Proceed- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------- | +ingsofthe57thAnnualMeetingoftheAssocia- +| Mo Yu, Shiyu | Chang, | | Yang | Zhang, | and | Tommi | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | tionforComputationalLinguistics, | | | | | pages413– | +| Jaakkola. | 2019. | Rethinking | | cooperative | | ratio- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 423, | Florence, | Italy. | Association | for | Computa- | +| nalization: | Introspective | | | extraction | and | com- | | | | | | | +tionalLinguistics. +| plement | control. | In | Proceedings | | of the | 2019 | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------ | ---- | ----- | -------- | --------- | +| Conference | on | Empirical | | Methods | in | Natural | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Wanjun | Zhong, | Duyu | Tang, | Zhangyin | Feng, Nan | +LanguageProcessingandthe9thInternational +| | | | | | | | Duan, | Ming | Zhou, | Ming | Gong, Linjun | Shou, | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ---- | ----- | ---- | ------------ | ----- | +| Joint Conference | | on | Natural | Language | | Pro- | | | | | | | +DaxinJiang,JiahaiWang,andJianYin.2020a. +cessing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), pages 4094–4103, LogicalFactChecker: Leveraginglogicalopera- +| Hong Kong, | | China. | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ------------ | ---- | +| | | | | | | | tions | for fact | checking | with | graph module | net- | +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | work. | InProceedingsofthe58thAnnualMeet- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | ing of | the | Association | for | Computational | Lin- | +NaomiZeichner,JonathanBerant,andIdoDagan. +guistics,pages6053–6065,Online.Association +| 2012. | Crowdsourcing | | inference-rule | | | evalua- | | | | | | | +| ----- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +forComputationalLinguistics. +| tion. In | Proceedings | | of the | 50th | Annual | Meet- | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ing of the Association for Computational Lin- Wanjun Zhong, Jingjing Xu, Duyu Tang, Zenan +guistics (Volume 2: Short Papers), pages 156– Xu, Nan Duan, Ming Zhou, Jiahai Wang, and +| 160, Jeju | Island, | Korea. | Association | | for | Com- | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ---- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | Jian | Yin. 2020b. | | Reasoning | over | semantic- | +putationalLinguistics. levelgraphforfactchecking. InProceedingsof +| | | | | | | | the 58th | Annual | Meeting | | of the Association | for | +| -------------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | +| Rowan Zellers, | | Ari Holtzman, | | Hannah | Rashkin, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Computational | | Linguistics, | | pages | 6170–6180, | +| Yonatan | Bisk, | Ali Farhadi, | | Franziska | Roesner, | | | | | | | | +Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| andYejinChoi.2019. | | | Defendingagainstneural | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tics. +| fake news. | In | Advances | in | Neural | Information | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Processing Systems 32: Annual Conference on Jie Zhou, Xu Han, Cheng Yang, Zhiyuan Liu, +Neural Information Processing Systems 2019, Lifeng Wang, Changcheng Li, and Maosong +NeurIPS 2019, December 8-14, 2019, Vancou- Sun. 2019. GEAR: Graph-based evidence ag- +ver,BC,Canada,pages9051–9062. gregating and reasoning for fact verification. + +In Proceedings of the 57th Annual Meeting of +the Association for Computational Linguistics, +pages892–901,Florence,Italy.Associationfor +ComputationalLinguistics. +XinyiZhou,AtishayJain,VirV.Phoha,andReza +Zafarani. 2020. Fake news early detection: +A theory-driven model. Digital Threats: Re- +searchandPractice,1(2). +Xinyi Zhou and Reza Zafarani. 2020. A survey +of fake news: Fundamental theories, detection +methods, and opportunities. ACM Computing +Surveys,53(5):109:1–109:40. +DimitrinaZlatkova,PreslavNakov,andIvanKoy- +chev. 2019. Fact-checking meets fauxtogra- +phy: Verifying claims about images. In Pro- +ceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical +Methods in Natural Language Processing and +the 9th International Joint Conference on Nat- +ural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), +pages2099–2108,HongKong,China.Associa- +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +Arkaitz Zubiaga, Ahmet Aker, Kalina Bontcheva, +Maria Liakata, and Rob Procter. 2018. Detec- +tion and resolution of rumours in social me- +dia: A survey. ACM Computing Surveys, +51(2):32:1–32:36. +Arkaitz Zubiaga, Maria Liakata, Rob Procter, +Geraldine Wong Sak Hoi, and Peter Tolmie. +2016. Analysing how people orient to and +spread rumours in social media by look- +ing at conversational threads. PloS one, +11(3):e0150989. +Chaoyuan Zuo, Ayla Karakas, and Ritwik Baner- +jee. 2018. A hybrid recognition system for +check-worthyclaimsusingheuristicsandsuper- +visedlearning. InWorkingNotesofCLEF2018 +- Conference and Labs of the Evaluation Fo- +rum, Avignon, France, September 10-14, 2018, +volume 2125 of CEUR Workshop Proceedings. +CEUR-WS.org. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q227/random_k2/question.json b/q227/random_k2/question.json index 31f18fffc3441a5b31c8e742f42a1483bb9a33e1..370aad1297a812c85a460a21b64d981cd0b844d3 100644 --- a/q227/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q227/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NETFLIX_2015_10K.pdf", - "web_f7c8a4fb24ac7362.pdf", - "web_8f3d7e741a1d660a.pdf" + "resize_r2_6.pdf", + "web_4635faf220a9b852.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q227/random_k2/random_1.md b/q227/random_k2/random_1.md index 2a08a5d152b0c9f673b119f3b536a79719deb932..b8b427adc83703ef22c6ae3416c90497206054cb 100644 --- a/q227/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q227/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,524 +1,1096 @@ -Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources +State Historic Preservation Office +David L. S. Brook, Administrator -TO OUR SHAREHOLDERS +Michael F. Easley, Governor +Lisbeth C. Evans, Secretary +Jeffrey J. Crow, Deputy Secretary -05 +June 18, 2003 -09 +MEMORANDUM -CEO Letter +Division of Historical Resources +David J. Olson, Director -Report by the Supervisory Board +TO: -4 +Greg Thorpe, Manager +Project Development and Environmental Analysis Branch +NCDOT Division of Highways - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +FROM: (cid:9) -CEO-LETTER +David Brook -↗ BJØRN GULDEN +SUBJECT: (cid:9) -CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER PUMA +Historic Architectural Resources Survey Report, Replacement of +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek, B-4015, Ashe County, +ER02-8494 -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, +Thank you for your letter of May 6, 2003, transmitting the survey report by Circa, Inc. -I hope this letter finds you well despite the current challenges around the world. After more than -two years, the COVID-19 pandemic still has a negative impact on our daily lives and business and -now we’re also facing a conflict in the heart of Europe that is causing terrible human suffering. +We concur that there are no properties within the Area of Potential Effect (APE) that are +eligible for listing in the National Register. -We’re in constant dialogue with all our stakeholders in Ukraine and we do our utmost to support -our local employees and their families as well as all our partners, ambassadors, and athletes -wherever we can. Ensuring the health and safety of our people continues to be our number one -priority, as we have already demonstrated throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. We have set up a -safe house in Ukraine, we are delivering food, water, and other necessities directly to our people -and we are helping women and children who want to leave the country. We currently have 40 -women and children in accommodation in Poland and about 120 here in Germany. Many of the -adults have already started working and most of the children are already attending schools and -kindergarten. Their positive attitude and mindset, as well as their willingness to work and -integrate, is remarkable. They are strong and positive people. I sincerely hope that this conflict -will be solved diplomatically as soon as possible, that further bloodshed can be avoided and that -peace will be restored. +The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation +Act and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with +Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Part 800. -While we are most concerned about the lives and livelihoods of the people who are directly -affected in Ukraine and by the COVID-19 pandemic, the conflict as well as the pandemic also have -a significant business impact on our sector and on PUMA. In addition to the impact on our -operations in Russia and Ukraine, we continue to face some of the challenges that we already -saw during the course of 2021: COVID-19 related lockdowns and restrictions in different parts of -the world, a weak consumer sentiment in some key markets, significant challenges in our supply -chain, strong inflationary pressures, and geopolitical tensions. +Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the +above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, environmental review coordinator, at +919/733-4763. In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above +referenced tracking number. -5 +cc: (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -Despite all these challenges, 2021 was a very successful year for us. To be specific, it was the -best year in PUMA’s history. Due to our continued brand momentum combined with high -operational flexibility and a fantastic effort from our employees, our sales grew by 32% to -EUR 6,805m and EBIT grew by 166% to EUR 557m. Compared to the pre-pandemic level of 2019, -our sales increased by 30%, resulting in a two-year CAGR of around 15% during these -challenging times. Our strategy of working closely together with all our suppliers and retail -partners to manage short-term issues without hindering our mid-term momentum continued to -pay off. Our external partners supported us in an extraordinary way and the dedication and -commitment of all our employees during such a challenging year was truly exceptional. A lot of -our employees went far beyond what a company can expect from them and in the name of the -entire PUMA Board, I would like to thank everyone for their contribution towards making these -results possible. People make the difference and our PUMA family is our biggest strength and -asset. - -Throughout 2021, we continued to focus on the three main areas that we defined in early 2020 in -reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic: Deal with COVID, continue to drive the business and continue -to do the right thing in areas such as social responsibility and environmental sustainability. - -Dealing with COVID first and foremost meant ensuring the health and safety of our people and -everyone in our value chain. We continued to adopt and comply with very strict health and safety -measures across our operations and rolled out vaccination programs for our employees in -countries where this was possible. This helped us achieve a vaccination rate of more than 90% at -our headquarters in Herzogenaurach by mid-July. At the end of the year, we followed up with -booster vaccinations. I would once again like to thank our People & Organization teams (formerly -known as Human Resources) around the world for successfully managing a second year of -COVID-19 and supporting our employees in the best way possible. - -Until around the first quarter 2021, the COVID-19 pandemic mainly impacted the store operations -of our own retail organization and of our retail partners due to mandatory store closures and -other restrictions. This was followed by significant disruptions in our supply chain due to -lockdowns and factory closures in key sourcing countries such as Bangladesh, Cambodia, China -and Vietnam. Especially, the lockdown in the third quarter in 2021 in the south of Vietnam, one of -our most important sourcing destinations, had a very negative impact on our supply chain. Due to -strict local lockdown measures, the production at our footwear, apparel and accessories -suppliers in the south of Vietnam was suspended for about ten weeks, affecting approximately -15% of our global sourcing volumes. We tried to minimize delays as much as possible and shifted -part of the volumes to other sourcing locations where possible. Thanks to the quick rollout of the -vaccination program in the south of Vietnam, the factories gradually reopened during October -and ramped up to full production by the end of year. After our suppliers resumed normal -operations, we saw fewer and very localized factory closures in some parts of Asia, which did not -significantly impact our product supply. We’re very thankful to our suppliers for being a part of -the PUMA family. The strong collaboration, long-term partnership and all their incredible support -ensured the continued supply of products under very difficult circumstances. - -The COVID-19 pandemic also had a major impact on other parts of our supply chain, and we had -to deal with capacity constraints, container shortages and harbor congestion in ocean freight, but -also significant challenges in air freight and land-based transportation. All these constraints led -to a strong increase in freight costs, which further fueled inflationary pressures, in addition to -rising costs for energy, raw materials and labor. - -As manifested in our strong sales growth, we also continued to drive the business in 2021. After -the end of the COVID-19 related lockdowns, we witnessed a certain “normalization” of buying -patterns, with more consumers shopping offline again instead of online. In our Direct-to- -Consumer business, we therefore saw a higher growth rate in our brick & mortar stores -compared to our eCommerce sites. However, both channels grew by double-digits last year, and -we continued to invest in the optimization of our store portfolio, the consumer experience on our -existing sites as well as the launch of new eCommerce sites. During a time of limited supply, we - -6 - - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -continued to prioritize our retail partners in terms of product allocation. We strongly believe in a -multi-brand retail environment and will therefore strengthen the relationship with all our retail -partners around the world and do everything we can to service them in the best way possible. - -After a year without any major sporting events in 2020, we were also excited to see sports -leagues, tournaments and other competitions resume in the course of 2021, for the most part -including live spectators. - -The summer of 2021 was exceptional for our teams and athletes, who delivered world class -performances on track and on the pitch. We underlined our credibility and high ambitions in -football with the victory of the PUMA-sponsored national team Italy at UEFA Euro 2020, several -league and cup titles of our PUMA-sponsored club teams and great on-pitch visibility of our -products. At the Tokyo Olympics and Paralympics, our athletes won more than 70 medals, -demonstrating the performance credentials of our products on the world stage, including our -new NITRO running shoes that I personally am exceptionally proud of. We also continued our -successful re-entry into basketball, especially for the North American market and launched our -first signature shoe with LaMelo Ball at the end of the year. The strengthening of our -performance credibility has always been important to us and I’m very happy about the great -progress that we’ve seen across football, running, fitness, golf, motorsport, basketball and other -locally relevant sports. In Sportstyle, we also continued to build brand heat through exciting new -products and collaborations and by offering a comprehensive collection across all relevant price -points, including a strong focus on comfort. We are very happy to see that our classics business -is growing strongly. Our PUMA Archive is full of footwear and apparel from the 70s, 80s and 90s, -for which there is currently a lot of demand in youth culture. We’re also very satisfied to see the -continued momentum in our women’s business, following the launch of our “She Moves Us” -brand platform, and we will keep capitalizing on our truly inclusive product offering across -genders, age groups etc.! - -We also continued to focus on what we call “Doing the right thing”. We want to be a good -corporate citizen and embed our social responsibility and our environmental sustainability into all -our business practices. With regards to social responsibility, we continued with multiple -initiatives under our #REFORM platform to promote universal equality. We strongly believe that -people should be treated equally irrespective of their gender, age, skin color, religious believes, -sexual orientation or any other factor. Together with our brand ambassadors and partner -organizations, we want to do our part to promote universal equality and fight any form of -discrimination in sports and society as a whole. As part of our ambitious 10FOR25 sustainability -targets, we implemented more sustainable business practices in all our business operations -from sourcing to retail and further increased the usage of more sustainable materials and the -overall share of more sustainable products in our collections. We also increased our focus on -circularity, with several pilot projects and strengthened our consumer-facing sustainability -communication through our FOREVER BETTER brand platform. I, together with my team, -attended the COP26 climate conference in Glasgow to emphasize our commitment in the fight -against climate change and to work towards limiting the global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees -Celsius above pre-industrial levels. We have all these initiatives because we really believe in -them, as part of PUMA’s core values, and we will continue to do the right thing. - -Given our strong performance in 2021 and good momentum in the first months of 2022, we’re -also optimistic for the future of our industry in general and for PUMA in particular, despite the -external challenges. The underlying dynamics in our sector remain very strong given the -increasing participation in sports, the ongoing sneaker trend and the continued casualization -among consumers all around the world. We also see PUMA’s brand momentum continuing and -we will ensure operational flexibility in an increasingly volatile and unpredictable marketplace. -As we have already done during the past years, we will continue to work very closely with all our -retail partners to further increase our shelf space and support the sell-through of our products in -their stores. We have focused on building strong partnerships with all our key stakeholders such -as suppliers, retailers, ambassadors and athletes, helping them as well as us through the -ongoing challenges. We will continue to foster these partnerships in the future. We therefore +Circa, Inc. +Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT -7 +bc: 'Southern/McBride + +County + +ADMINISTRATION +RESTORAT1QN . +SURYEridtcPLANNING + +Location (cid:9) +507 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) +515 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) +515 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) + +Mailing Address +4617 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4617 +4613 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4613 +4618 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4618 + +Telephone/Fax +(919) 733-1763 • 733-8653 +(919) 733-6547 • 7154801 +(919) 733-6545 • 715-4801 + +www.hpo.dcr.state.nc.us + +(cid:9) + HISTORIC ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT + +REPLACEMENT OF BRIDGE NO. 165 ON S.R. 1362 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ASHE COUNTY + +NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION +T.I.P. NO. B-4015 +STATE PROJECT NO. 8.2712401 +FEDERAL-AID PROJECT NO. BRZ-1362 (1) + +Prepared for: + +Wetherill Engineering, Inc. +559 Jones Franklin Road, Suite 164 +Raleigh, NC 27606 + +Prepared by: + +Circa, Inc. +P.O. Box 407 +Durham, NC 27702 + +April 2003 + +a-44 + +OiU s cc Are)A-Ad-uArL_ t\_)csx) r + +S • (0 .2143 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Replacement of Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 +over Big Horse Creek +Ashe County +T.I.P. No. B-4015 +State Project No. 8.2712401 +Federal-Aid Project No. BRZ-1362 (1) + +Management Summary +The North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) proposes to replace +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek in Ashe County. The project +involves the replacement of the existing one-lane bridge with a two-lane +structure. There are two alternatives for the new bridge. Alternative 1 entails +the realignment of SR 1362 and the construction of a new structure on the +upstream side of the existing bridge. Alternative 2 entails the realignment of SR +1362 and the construction of a new structure on the downstream side of the +existing bridge. Alternative 3 entails the replacement of the existing bridge with +a new structure, in same location. It is anticipated that traffic will be maintained +on the existing bridge during construction. + +Circa, Inc. conducted the intensive survey by automobile and by foot in January +2003, covering one-hundred percent of the Area of Potential Effects (APE). Circa +photographed, mapped, and evaluated every property over fifty years of age +within the APE. Those properties considered worthy of further analysis were +researched and evaluated in January 2003. + +In addition to the field survey of the project area, Circa reviewed the survey files, +as well as National Register and Study List files, at the Survey and Planning +Branch of the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office in Raleigh. +Background research was also conducted at the Ashe County Courthouse in +Jefferson, the Ashe County Public Library in West Jefferson, and in a meeting +with one of the property owners. + +Circa staff delineated the APE, which includes parcels immediately adjacent to +the present bridge and those impacted, physically or visually, by any of the +proposed alternatives. One property over fifty years of age, the Graham-Brooks +Farm, was identified within the APE. While the house itself is not within the +APE, a corner of the 31.6-acre parcel lies within the APE. Therefore, the property +was evaluated as part of this report. + +Properties Listed in the National Register or the North Carolina State Study List: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Eligible for the National Register: + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +i (cid:9) + +4/1/2003 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Not Eligible for the National Register: + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +ii (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +4/1/2003 -expect 2022 to be another record year for PUMA, with a net sales growth of at least 10%, with -upside potential, and an EBIT of EUR 600 – 700 million. The objective is not to maximize short- -term EBIT, but to continue to have healthy long-term growth in both sales and EBIT. We will also -keep on putting our people first and take care of all our partners. + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -Let’s stay positive and hope that peace in Ukraine will be restored as soon as possible and that -the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic will continue to decrease. +Table of Contents -Thank you for being part of the PUMA family! +Management Summary (cid:9) -Stay strong, healthy and optimistic! +Table of Contents (cid:9) -Bjørn Gulden -Chief Executive Officer PUMA +List of Figures (cid:9) -8 +List of Plates (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Project Description (cid:9) -REPORT BY THE SUPERVISORY BOARD +Methodology (cid:9) -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -CHAIRMAN OF THE -CHAIRMAN OF THE -SUPERVISORY BOARD -SUPERVISORY BOARD +Brief History of Ashe County (cid:9) -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, +Historical and Architectural Contexts (cid:9) -The 2021 financial year was again heavily impacted by the COVID 19 pandemic. Despite the associated -uncertainties, supply chain bottlenecks due to container shortages, port congestion and pandemic-related -factory closures in key sourcing regions, as well as political tensions in key markets, we managed to start -2021 with high growth momentum. Due to the continued decisive and consistent actions of our Management -Board and the outstanding performance of our employees, we were able to maintain our market -momentum and operational flexibility throughout the year. As a result, we were able to raise our outlook for -2021 during the year and end the year with the highest sales and profit in PUMA's history. At the same time, -it was of utmost importance for us to protect the safety and health of our employees in the best possible -way through the resolute development and implementation of hygiene and occupational safety concepts -and the implementation of vaccination campaigns. We were once again a flexible and reliable business -partner for our suppliers and customers. We worked as closely as possible with them to stabilize our -supply chains and increase sales of our products. By appointing Hubert Hinterseher and Arne Freundt to -the Management Board, we were able to further strengthen our organization and thus lay the foundations -for a successful 2022. +Property Evaluations -In the financial year 2021, the Supervisory Board has exercised all its duties under the law, statutes and -company rules. The Supervisory Board has dealt extensively with the status and the development of PUMA, -particularly continuing with a special focus on the COVID-19 pandemic, and has regularly advised and -supervised the Management Board in its management of the Company. +Graham-Brooks Farm -In this regard, the Supervisory Board has in its four regular meetings discussed and resolved on the -Company’s business policies, all relevant aspects of corporate development and corporate planning, the -Company’s economic situation, including its net assets, financial position and results of operations, the -adequacy of capital resources and all key decisions for the Group. The Management Board has informed the +Bibliography (cid:9) + +i + +iii + +.iv + +.v + +1 + +5 + +7 9 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +12 -Supervisory Board regularly, comprehensively, and in a timely manner in written and verbal form about the -implementation of all decisions and about all major business transactions. Furthermore, in 2021 one -extraordinary meeting of the Supervisory Board took place. Urgent matters were decided via circular -resolutions using electronic means of communication. All members participated in drawing up the -resolutions. Whenever necessary, representatives of the shareholders and employees held separate -preliminary discussions prior to the meetings. +19 -Plenary Supervisory Board +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Jean-François Palus +iii (cid:9) -Thore Ohlsson +4/1/2003 -Héloïse Temple-Boyer +(cid:9) + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -Fiona May +List of Figures -Martin Köppel +Figure 1. Project vicinity map (cid:9) -Bernd Illig +Figure 2. Location of Alternatives 1 & 2 (cid:9) -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +Figure 3. Location of Alternative 3 (cid:9) -Attendance in % +Figure 4. The ideally sited Appalachian house (cid:9) -5/5 +Figure 5. Graham-Brooks Farm site plan (cid:9) -5/5 +2 -5/5 +3 -5/5 +.4 11 -5/5 +15 -5/5 +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -100 +iv (cid:9) -100 +4/1/2003 -100 + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -100 +List of Plates -100 +Plate 1. Graham-Brooks Farm - main house facade (cid:9) -100 +Plate 2. Graham-Brooks Farm - main house facade & north elevation (cid:9) -The Supervisory Board discussed in detail all of the Company’s key business transactions, based on the -reports by the Management Board and the Committees, and presented its own ideas. The Management -Board has provided the Supervisory Board with detailed information on any deviations of the business -performance from the budgeted figures, both in writing and orally. The Supervisory Board verified these -explanations using the supporting documents, which were always submitted in appropriate time before the -meetings. The Supervisory Board was involved in all key decisions at an early stage. In addition, the Chair of -the Supervisory Board maintained, and continues to maintain, regular verbal or written contact with the -CEO and keeps himself informed of all major developments. Overall, these discussions did not give any -indication that the Management Board was managing the Group in anything other than a lawful and proper -manner. +Plate 3. Graham-Brooks Farm - setting (cid:9) -The Supervisory Board members took part, on their own initiative, in the educational and training measures -necessary for the performance of their duties. The Company supports the Supervisory Board members in -their training activities, for example by having the Legal Department regularly review changes in the legal -framework for the Supervisory Board and report about them in the meetings. In 2021, the Supervisory -Board received a training on the sustainability strategy of the Company and the challenges in the supply -chain. The Supervisory Board dealt with the Act on Corporate Due Diligence in Supply Chains (Supply Chain -Due Diligence Act) and the EU Regulation on the Establishment of a Framework to Facilitate Sustainable -Investment (EU Taxonomy Regulation). +Plate 4. Graham-Brooks Farm - outbuilding 1 (cid:9) -MAIN ADVISORY FOCUS +Plate 5. Graham-Brooks Farm - outbuilding 2 (cid:9) -In the 2021 financial year, the main focus was on the following issues: review and approval of the 2020 -consolidated and annual financial statements and the non-financial report, dividend proposal, resolution of -the new remuneration system for the Management Board and submission to the 2021 Annual General -Meeting for approval, ongoing assessment of the impact and handling of the COVID 19 pandemic, setting the -agenda for the Annual General Meeting on 5 May 2021, approval of the Management Board’s decisions to -hold the Annual General Meeting as a virtual Annual General Meeting without the physical presence of -shareholders or their proxies, appointment of Hubert Hinterseher to the Management Board to succeed -Michael Lämmermann and appointment of Arne Freundt to the Management Board, establishment of a -Sustainability Committee, setting of new targets for the proportion of women to be achieved on the -Supervisory Board and Management Board, self-assessment of the Supervisory Board, current business -and revenue development, markets and trends, financial position of the Group, corporate and budget -planning 2022 as well as medium-term planning, including investments, further improvement of the -compliance management and internal control system as well as material litigation in the Group. +16 -10 +16 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +17 -The Audit Committee submitted a recommendation to the Supervisory Board for the election of the auditor, -which was prepared following a selection process within the meaning of Art. 16 (3) Regulation (EU) No. -537/2014, comprised two candidates and was substantiated. +17 -As every year, the Personnel Committee and the Supervisory Board determined the degree of achievement -of the targets for the individual Management Board members with regard to 2020. The Supervisory Board -decided on the targets for the variable Management Board remuneration for the 2021 financial year upon -recommendation of the Personnel Committee. +18 -CONFLICTS OF INTEREST +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -The members of the Supervisory Board are required to disclose to its Chair any conflicts of interest without -undue delay. In the past year, no such disclosures were made. +v (cid:9) -COMMITTEES +4/1/2003 -The Supervisory Board has established four committees to perform its duties: The Personnel Committee, -the Audit Committee, the Nominating Committee and the Sustainability Committee which was established -in April 2021. The Personnel Committee, the Audit Committee and the Sustainability Committee each -comprise two shareholder representatives and one employee representative. The Nominating Committee is -composed only of shareholder representatives. The composition of the committees can be found in the -notes to the consolidated financial statements. The Supervisory Board receives regular reports on their -work. + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County -PERSONNEL COMMITTEE +Replacement of Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 +over Big Horse Creek +Ashe County +T.I.P. No. B-4015 +State Project No. 8.2712401 +Federal-Aid Project No. BRZ-1362 (1) -The Personnel Committee has the task of preparing the conclusion and amendment of employment -contracts with the members of the Management Board and establishing policies for human resources and -personnel development. It met to one regular meeting and to one extraordinary meeting in 2021 and mainly -dealt with the compensation system for the Management Board, which has been approved by the Annual -General Meeting in 2021. Furthermore, the determination of target achievement for the individual -Management Board members and the setting of targets for 2021 were the focus of the discussions. -Corresponding recommendations for resolutions were made to the Supervisory Board. +Project Description -Personnel Committee +The North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) proposes to replace +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek in Ashe County (Figure 1). The +current structure, completed in 1960, consists of a timber floor on I-beams with a +substructure of timber posts and caps. Bridge No. 165 is classified as structurally +insufficient by the NCDOT Bridge Maintenance Unit, scoring a sufficiency rating +of 44.1 out of a possible 100 in 1999. -Attendance at meetings +The project involves the replacement of the existing one-lane bridge with a two- +lane structure. There are two alternatives for the new bridge. Alternative 1 +entails the realignment of SR 1362 and the construction of a new structure on the +upstream side of the existing bridge; alternative 2 entails the realignment of SR +1362 and the construction of a new structure on the downstream side of the +existing bridge (Figure 2). Alternative 3 entails the replacement of the existing +bridge with a new structure in the same location (Figure 3). It is anticipated that +traffic will be maintained on the existing bridge during construction. -Attendance in % +Purpose of Survey and Report -Jean-François Palus +The historic resources survey was conducted to identify all historic resources +located within the area of potential effects (APE) (Figures 2 & 3). This survey +and report are part of the environmental studies conducted by NCDOT and +documented by a categorical exclusion (CE). This report was prepared as a +technical appendix to the CE and is part of the compliance documentation +required by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 and the +National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) of 1966, as amended. Section 106 of +the NHPA states that if a federally funded, licensed, or permitted project has an +effect on a property listed in, or potentially eligible for listing in the National +Register of Historic Places, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation should +be given an opportunity to comment on the proposed undertaking. This report +is on file with NCDOT and available for review by the public. -Fiona May +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Martin Köppel +1 (cid:9) -AUDIT COMMITTEE +4/1/03 -2/2 + Bridge No. 338, T. I. P. No. B-4013 +Ashe County -2/2 +'4 -2/2 +1309 kP -100 +Torseaut R2 -100 +Wee -100 +13-10 -The Audit Committee held four regular meetings in the financial year 2021. Furthermore, one extraordinary -meeting of the Audit Committee took place in 2021. In particular, the Audit Committee is responsible for the -review of the accounting, particularly comprising the consolidated financial statements and the group -management report, group half year report, interim financial information and the single entity financial -statements in accordance with the German Commercial Code (HGB). It is furthermore responsible for -monitoring the accounting process, the effectiveness of the internal control system, the risk management -system, the internal audit system, compliance and the statutory audit of the financial statements, with -particular regard to the process of selecting an auditor. The Audit Committee is also responsible for -conducting the selection process of the auditor. In addition, the Audit Committee monitors the -independence of the auditor and ensures that the non-audit services of the auditor commissioned by the -Management Board do not give rise to any grounds for disqualification or partiality or any threat to -independence. The Audit Committee issues the audit mandate on behalf of the Supervisory Board to the +1310 -11 +ra• - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +ce • -auditor elected by the general meeting, determines the audit areas of the audit and agrees the fee with the -auditor. Heads of the corporate functions were also available for reports and questions on individual agenda -items at the committee meetings. The Audit Committee meets regularly with the auditor, also without the -Management Board. +A -Audit Committee +1308 -Thore Ohlsson +La -Héloïse Temple-Boyer +1310 -Bernd Illig +1107 -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +:..1397 -Attendance in % +Creek -5/5 +41; -5/5 +-60gVOTOR -5/5 +1315 +f -100 +98' -100 +OISTANC; Ill NILES -100 +SR 1320 +(ROARING FORK ROAD) +REPLACE BRIDGE NO. 338 over +ROARING FORK CREEK -NOMINATING COMMITTEE +6-4013 -The Nominating Committee has the task of proposing suitable candidates to the Supervisory Board for its -election proposals to the Annual General Meeting. It held no meeting in the last financial year. +Ashe County, North Carolina -SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE +PROJECT VICINITY -The Sustainability Committee was established in April 2021 and met once in the 2021 financial year to -discuss the company's sustainability strategies. The Sustainability Committee consists of three members. +Fioure 1 -CORPORATE GOVERNANCE +Circa, Inc. -As in previous years, the Supervisory Board addressed current developments in the financial year 2021 -regarding the German Corporate Governance Code in the version dated December 16, 2019 (effective as of -March 20, 2020) (GCGC). The GCGC contains essential statutory regulations and recommendations for the -management and supervision of listed companies and standards for responsible corporate governance. The -corporate governance standards have long been a part of the corporate routine. +2 -Pursuant to Principle 22 of the GCGC, the Supervisory Board reports on corporate governance in the -Corporate Governance Statement. The Company satisfies all requirements of the GCGC, to the extent -required by it. The Statement of Compliance of November 9, 2021 is available to our shareholders at any -time on the Company’s website under https://about.PUMA.com/en/investor-relations/corporate- -governance at STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE. +4/1/2003 -ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ADOPTED +(cid:9) +(cid:9) + HISTORIC ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT -The annual financial statements for PUMA SE prepared by the Management Board in accordance with the -German Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch/HGB), the consolidated financial statements and the -combined management report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, each for the financial year 2021, -prepared in accordance with Section 315a HGB on the basis of the International Financial Reporting -Standards (IFRS) have been audited by the statutory auditors, Deloitte GmbH -Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, Munich, who were appointed at the Annual General Meeting on May 5, -2021 and commissioned by the Supervisory Board to audit the annual financial statements and the -consolidated financial statements and have been given an unqualified auditor’s opinion. +REPLACEMENT OF BRIDGE NO. 165 ON S.R. 1362 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ASHE COUNTY -In their report, the statutory auditors conclude that PUMA’s institutionalized risk management system, in -accordance with Section 91(2) of the German Stock Corporation Act (Aktiengesetz/AktG), is capable of -detecting at an early stage and countering any developments that might jeopardize the continuity of the -Company as a going concern. The Supervisory Board has been updated by the Management Board regularly +NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION +T.I.P. NO. B-4015 +STATE PROJECT NO. 8.2712401 +FEDERAL-AID PROJECT NO. BRZ-1362 (1) -12 +Prepared for: + +Wetherill Engineering, Inc. +559 Jones Franklin Road, Suite 164 +Raleigh, NC 27606 + +Prepared by: + +Circa, Inc. +P.O. Box 407 +Durham, NC 27702 + +April 2003 + + BEGIN PROJECT + +NATE + +IUiUIN I. Lai EcT +ALTERNATE 2 + +A PI' + +BR; HORSE CR EEK ROA D + +17,62 + +RIG HORSE CREEK + +\ I FER + +‘1,TER.\:.\ TI (cid:9) + +I + +RU; HORSE CREEK + +RIG IIOR`-;I: (cid:9) + +I(EEK 1(0 \ + +SR (cid:9) + +' + +REPLACEMENT OF +BRIDGE NO. 156 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ON SR 1362 +;13IG HORSE CREEK ROAD) + +ALTERNATE + +PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +ALTERNATE 2 + +/ PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +ALTERNATE 1 +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +ALTERNATE 2 +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +Ashe County, North Carolina + +\ ERIAL MAP WITH BUILD + +ALTERNATIVES 1 & 2 + +FIGURE 2 + +SCALE 1' = 75' + + 1EGIN PROJECT + +ALTERNATE 3 + +111 (cid:9) POI( (cid:9) + +\I + +I 5 (cid:9) + +1)1. 101 R + +Sit 1.3b2 + +BIG HORSE CREEK + +END PROJECT + +ALTERNATE 3 + +BIG HORSE CREEK ROAD + +r REPLACEMENT OF + +BRIDGE NO. 156 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ON SR 1362 +tI3113 HORSE CREEK ROAD) + +Asko County, North Carolina + +AERIAL MAP WITH BUILD + +ALTERNATIVE 3 + +FIGURE 3 +SCALE 1' = 75' + +PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +TEMPORARY DETOUR + +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +TEMPORARY BRIDGE + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Methodology + +This report was prepared in accordance with the provisions of Federal Highway +Administration (FHWA) Technical Advisory T 6640.8A (Guidance for Preparing +and Processing Environmental and Section 4(f) Documents); the Secretary of the +Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Archaeological and Historic Preservation +(48 FRR 44716); 36 CFR Part 800; 36 CFR Part 60; and the Survey Procedures and +Report Guidelines for Historic Architectural Resources by NCDOT. This report +meets the guidelines of NCDOT and the National Park Service. + +This survey was conducted with the following goals: (1) to determine the APE, +which is defined as the geographic area or areas within which a project may +cause changes to the character or use of the historic properties, if any such +properties exist; (2) to identify all resources over fifty years of age within the +APE; and (3) to evaluate these resources according to the National Register of +Historic Places criteria. + +The methodology for this project included a field survey and background +research of the project area and the region. The field survey was conducted in +January 2003 to delineate the APE (Figure 3) and identify all properties within +the APE greater than fifty years of age. Every property over fifty years of age +was photographed, mapped, and evaluated. + +Background research was conducted at the Survey and Planning Branch of the +North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office in Raleigh. This research +indicated that there are no resources within the APE that have been listed on the +National Register of Historic Places or the State Study List. Background research +was also conducted at the Ashe County Courthouse in Jefferson, the Ashe +County Public Library in West Jefferson, and in a meeting with one of the +property owners. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +5 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Summary of Survey Findings + +Bridge No. 165 spans Big Horse Creek, a tributary of the North Fork of the New +River, in the northern portion of Ashe County, 2.5 miles north of the town of +Lansing. The bridge carries SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek at a 45-degree angle +between two curves in the road. + +Bridge No. 165 was built in 1960 and consists of a timber floor on I-beams with a +substructure of timber posts and caps. The bridge was not evaluated as part of +this study as it is under fifty years of age and not associated with a significant +type of design or movement in bridge construction. + +One property over fifty years of age, the Graham-Brooks Farm, was identified +within the APE. While, the house itself is not within the APE, a corner of the +31.6-acre parcel lies within the APE. Therefore, the property was evaluated as +part of this report. + +Properties Listed in the National Register or the North Carolina State Study List: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Eligible for the National Register: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Not Eligible for the National Register: + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +6 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Brief History of Ashe County +Note: This section adapted from "Historic Architectural Resources Survey Report, +Replacement of Bridge No. 281 on SR 1358 Over Big Horse Creek, Ashe County, TIP +No. B-4014." + +The project area is located in the northern portion of Ashe County, in the +northwest corner of North Carolina. The county is approximately 3,000 feet +above sea level, on the west side of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Because of the +mountain barrier, Ashe County became known as one of the "lost provinces" of +North Carolina. Prior to the Good Roads Movement of the 1920s, Ashe County +was relatively isolated from the eastern part of the state. However, trade was +possible with the neighboring states of Virginia and Tennessee due to the +numerous passes through the Stone Mountains, the north-flowing New River, +and the extension of the Norfolk and Western Railway from Virginia in 1915. +Despite its relative isolation, Ashe County was unique among the mountain +counties of western North Carolina because of its rolling, rather than rugged, +terrain and its fertile farmland, well watered by the New River and its +tributaries. Because of these conditions, Ashe County has remained +overwhelmingly agrarian throughout its history. + +Named for Governor Samuel Ashe, Ashe County was created in 1799 after +settlers arrived in the area from the Shenandoah Valley to the north and the +North Carolina Piedmont to the east. Sited at the base of Mount Jefferson, the +county seat of Jefferson was incorporated in 1803, but has remained small in part +because the county's gentle topography and good farmland encouraged settlers +to disperse uniformly throughout the county. Small crossroads communities +with stores, mills, and churches emerged to serve nearby farms, and the county +developed few large towns. Located just a few miles south of the county seat, +West Jefferson emerged in the early-twentieth century as the commercial center +of Ashe County after a branch of the Norfolk and Western Railway was extended +south from Virginia in 1915. + +Since its founding at the end of the American Revolution, Ashe County has been +rural, with more then ninety-one percent of its area designated as farmland into +the late 1950s. Despite good farming conditions, insufficient transportation +routes and the absence of ready markets stymied the development of commercial +agriculture, and subsistence farms predominated in Ashe County until the early- +twentieth century when the economy diversified somewhat. The early settlers +cultivated rye, buckwheat, and corn. Eventually, these fields turned to grasses, +which in turn supported livestock. In 1879, there were thirty-eight cattle traders +in the county. Livestock production continued to be a profitable part of the +agricultural economy through the twentieth century, and by the post-World War +I period Ashe County was the leading producer of beef and dairy cattle in the +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +7 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +state and the second largest producer of sheep. Ashe, along with neighboring +Watauga and Allegheny Counties, has also been a major producer of wool and +dairy products. Only since the 1920s has Ashe County joined other mountain +counties in cultivating burley tobacco as a cash crop. By 1965 it had become the +third leading producer in North Carolina. + +Manufacturing has remained a minor part of the economy, employing less then +nine percent of the county work force into the 1960s. Much of the manufacturing +sector has been concentrated in the processing of agricultural, timber-related, +and some textile products. + +Because of its largely subsistence economy and geographical isolation, Ashe +County was generally less affected by the Civil War than other regions of the +state. Both Union and Confederate sympathizers were present, and clashes +between the two groups were common. The county remained a Republican +stronghold through the end of the nineteenth century in contrast to the rest of +North Carolina. + +In addition to agriculture, a number of minerals were discovered during the late- +antebellum period, and several mining communities emerged by the mid- +nineteenth century. In the 1870s, Ore Knob was a bustling boomtown for copper +mining, leading the nation in the production of the metal. During its brief period +of prosperity, Ore Knob was the largest town in the county. The community +quickly declined with the closing of the mines in the 1880s and has since +vanished. 'Throughout the nineteenth century iron was also mined, and a number +of forges were established for iron production. Unlike Ore Knob, the town of +Helton, which once boasted several iron mines and forges, survives although its +iron production has long since ended. By 1884, Creston, with its grist and saw +mills, tannery, and furniture and wagon factory, had emerged as the largest +town in Ashe County. + +Like much of western North Carolina, a seasonal tourist industry began to +emerge in Ashe County by the end of the nineteenth century as wealthy families +wanting to escape the summer heat began to "take the waters" at local mineral +springs. Spa resorts such as Shatley Springs, Thompson's Bromine, Arsenic +Springs (NR), and the Glendale Springs flourished with seasonal visitors. + +In the 1970s, Ashe County found itself embroiled in controversy with a proposal +by the Appalachian Power Company to dam the New River in Virginia, +effectively impounding the river on the North Carolina side. Environmentalists +succeeded in having the river designated as a Wild and Scenic River, and the +proposal died. Since then, Ashe County has profited from the growing interest +in outdoor sports, particularly rafting, and the river valleys of the county have +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +8 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +become popular spots for vacation home construction. Despite these changes, the +rural, agrarian way of life survives remarkably intact in Ashe County. + +Architectural Context: Early-Twentieth Century Architecture and Farmsteads in +Ashe County + +The Blue Ridge Mountains served as a natural wall separating the New River +Valley counties of Ashe and Alleghany from the rest of state until well into the +twentieth century. As a result of this isolation, the region developed its own +culture and economy, as well as its own building practices. In the 1970s, a +proposal to dam the New River in Virginia, effectively flooding the New River +Valley in North Carolina, created an immediate need for research and +documentation of the region's built environment. In 1976, Davyd Foard Hood +and Michael Southern conducted a reconnaissance level survey documenting +approximately 100 resources in Ashe County. What was discovered through this +work was a landscape and building pattern drastically different from that of the +rest of the state. + +The collection of structures that dominate the vernacular architecture of the New +River Valley were built between 1885 and 1915. Two trends were occurring at +that time that resulted in the rapid construction of farmsteads throughout the +region. First, families were getting larger. The original settlers of the region +were now welcoming their third and fourth generations and that resulted in the +need for larger or additional housing. The second trend was a combination of an +improvement in transportation routes and a change in local agricultural +methods. With the improvement of transportation routes, including both roads +and the introduction of the railroad, local farmers were able to get their products +to distant markets. This changed the face of farming in the region from +subsistence farming to cash crops or products such as tobacco, corn and large- +scale dairying operations (Hood, 205). + +Buildings constructed prior to 1885 were first of log, then frame construction. +The majority of these structures were unadorned one or two-room houses. These +houses were primarily one-story, but two-story interpretations were not +uncommon. The simplicity of these structures was due to a more dominant need +for function. Early settlers of the region came from Virginia and quickly built +temporary structures to house their family, with the idea that a more permanent +structure would be built at a later date. Often, when the more permanent house +was built, the original home was converted to an agricultural purpose. As a +result of this practice, both the Georgian and Federal styles of architecture are +practically absent and the Greek Revival movement, wildly popular across the +state, has only a few examples in the county (Hood, 205). + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +9 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +It was not until the building boom between 1885 and 1915 that elements of +national building styles began to appear in the region's domestic architecture. +While the improved transportation routes served to transport agricultural +products out of the region, they also served to bring new materials in. The +sudden availability of materials from sawmills, such as bargeboards, turned +posts, balusters and moldings brought a new life to the local architecture and +changed the local vernacular in both form and focus. In addition to the extensive +ornamentation of houses, their plan began to take on more elaborate forms. +Two-story houses, three-bays wide, became the preferred form, often with an ell +off the back resulting in an overall a "T" or "L" plan (Hood, 210). Smaller, one- +story houses also began to be built on larger farmsteads to house younger +generations or farm hands and their families. These structures rarely +incorporated the ornamentation present on the farmstead's main house. + +What was more important than form or decoration, both during the region's +early development and well into the twentieth century, was the location of +buildings on a site. While the county's rolling topography and fertile soil +defined the area as ideal for agricultural purposes, the bitter cold and often harsh +winds proved challenging for the siting of residences and shelters for livestock. +Furthermore, the remoteness of the region in its early settlement, required that +each farmstead be self-sufficient. The lack of good roads or other reliable means +of transportation in conjunction with long winters meant that families had to be +able to exist on these farmsteads for long periods of time without outside sources +of sustenance. + +In order for farmsteads to be self-sufficient a compilation of outbuildings was +necessary. Livestock barns, equipment sheds, smokehouses, spring houses, +corncribs, granaries, woodsheds, root cellars, tobacco barns, and, of course, +privies were all common structures. The collection of outbuildings and the size +of each structure varied greatly from farm to farm, reflecting both the size of the +family that subsided on it, and any specialization in crop or production. +Outbuildings were predominantly log or frame structures until the late- +nineteenth and early-twentieth century. The location of each of the structures on +the farm related directly to its function. + +The defining factors in selecting a site for a farmstead included access to water, +slope, workable (farmable) land, rock outcroppings, vegetation cover, prevailing +winds, and access to roads. Access to water was needed at the subsurface level +for drinking as well as food storage and preparation. This water was often +acquired from many of the region's springs as the use of wells was not common. +Surface water was necessary for the provision of water for livestock and for the +facilitation of crop farming. Attention to slope and prevailing winds and +vegetation cover were necessary to protect the structures from severe winter +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +10 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County + +weather, and take advantage of sun exposure as a means of heat. Rock +outcroppings and workable land directly relate to the ability to build structures +on the site and plant crops nearby (Keber, 198-99). + +As a result of this combination of factors, most farmsteads are built with the side +of a vegetated mountain behind them to break the wind, and so the facade of the +house is positioned to take advantage of as much winter sun as possible. Ideally, +there is a source of surface water to the front or side of a property and adjacent to +a stream or creek. The location of a farmstead's surface water source is +synonymous with the location of its springhouse. The cold water trickling up +from the ground was an ideal location for food storage. Meadows for livestock +and fields suitable for crop farming were often located off either side of the main +house or in front of it. Necessary outbuildings, such as livestock barns, +equipment sheds, and corncribs were often built between the house and the +meadows or crops. Also ideal is the location of a road nearby for accessibility to +the local community and nearby church, weather permitting. + +, vinter sun + +4 + +wind +break + +spring + +, View of crops Sz iVISLUre + +row crops + +stream + +alluvial Hood plain + +Figure 4. The ideally sited Appalachian house (Keber, 200.) + +While the combination of all of these factors results in the "ideally sited +Appalachian house," finding all of these elements in use on a modern day farm is +a rarity. Changes in farming practices as well as the decline of the size of families +living on these farms has resulted in the degeneration of these traditional +farmsteads. That is not to say that examples do not exist. Many of these +elements remain in many farms across the region today. It is finding an +operational farm, with it full complement of outbuildings still functioning that is +the rarity. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +11 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Property Evaluation + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Date of Construction +Ca. 1910 + +Setting +The Graham-Brooks Farm is set on a rise in a turn of the Big Horse Creek, 0.5 +mile north of Bridge No. 165. The 31.6 acre site is wooded and slopes down to +Big Horse Creek where the remnants of an earlier bridge stand. The area +surrounding the house and its outbuildings is severely overgrown as a result of +the property being vacant for more than twenty years. + +Physical Description +The Graham-Brooks Farm is set into a hillside, adjacent to Big Horse Creek. The +farm consists of a main house, built ca. 1910, and two outbuildings. Like many +Appalachian farmsteads, the main house is built with the hillside behind it to +serve as a wind break. In front of the house, the land descends to Big Horse +Creek. SR 1362 runs in front of the house, across the creek. The property was +accessed by from SR 1362 by a one-lane bridge that has fallen into the creek. + +The main house of the Graham-Brooks Farm is a one-story, three-bay, single-pile, +frame, hip-roofed dwelling with a one-story, gable-roofed ell at the rear. The +main block of the house and rear ell have weatherboard siding, cornerboards, +and exposed rafter tails. There is a three-bay, hip-roofed porch on the facade +supported by replacement timber porch posts and an interior brick chimney +towards the rear of the main block. All windows and doors have been removed, +though their original unadorned trim remains. The roof of the rear ell is +collapsing. + +There are two outbuildings associated with the Graham-Brooks Farm. Both are +simple frame structures with shed roofs and vertical planks forming the walls. +The first outbuilding, the equipment shed, is located adjacent to the house on its +north side and sits between the house and an open field. The second outbuilding +is a larger, two-story structure and is set in front of the house, adjacent to the +creek. This larger structure served as a livestock barn with a hayloft above. + +Historical Background +The Graham-Brooks Farm was originally part of a larger farmstead owned by +William H. Graham and begun in the late-nineteenth century. The 31.6 acre tract +that the house currently sits on was sold to Moody Brooks by the Graham family +in 1951. The actual date of construction is not known. However, a conversation +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +12 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +with the adjacent property owner, a descendant of William H. Graham, indicated +that the house likely post-dates the Graham-Wilcox House, built in 1904 north of +the APE. The Graham-Brooks House was likely built to house a child of William +H. Graham's or, possibly, a farm worker. Given the information in conjunction +with the form and roof style of the structure, it likely dates to ca. 1910. + +Because agricultural records were not taken in Ashe County after 1880, there is +no definite record of what was farmed at this location. The 1880 agricultural +census indicates that Graham land holdings in the Piney Creek Township, the +township in which the Graham-Brooks Farm is located, produced corn, hay, and +over two-hundred pounds of butter. It is likely that similar crops were grown at +this location, once established by William H. Graham in the late 1800s. Since the +purchase of the property by Moody Brooks in 1951, he has passed and left the +property to heirs that do not live in the area and were not available for comment. + +Significance +The Graham-Brooks Farm is a small, turn-of-the-century farmstead in Ashe +County. Its location and setting are common among New River Valley +farmsteads, but the number of outbuildings is small compared to most +farmsteads in the region. The property is simple in form, and void of any +decorative embellishments, exuding no special significance in the area of +architecture. The farm and its associated buildings exhibit no significant +elements of design, use of materials nor do they illustrate a significant type or +style of workmanship. The farm's outbuildings remain intact but, like the house, +lack integrity as a result of neglect. The house lacks original windows and doors, +the roof of the rear ell has fallen, and the original porch posts have been replaced. +The outbuildings are overgrown and are also on the verge of collapse. This stage +of neglect diminishes the property's feeling as, and association with, a historic +farmstead. For these reasons the property lacks the requisite significance and +integrity necessary for listing, either individually or as part of a district, in the +National Register of Historic Places. + +Evaluation of National Register Eligibility +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for the National Register under +Criterion A (event) To be eligible under Criterion A the property must retain integrity +and must be associated with a specific event marking an important moment in American +History or a pattern of events or historic trend that made a significant contribution to the +development of a community. Furthermore, the property must have existed at the time +and be documented to be associated with the events. Finally, the property's specific +association must be important as well. The Graham-Brooks Farm is not known to be +associated with, or representative of, any specific event or pattern of events or +historic trend that made a significant contribution to the development of a +community. +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +13 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion B (person). For a property to be eligible for significance under +Criterion B, it must retain integrity and 1) be associated with the lives of persons +significant in our past, i.e., individuals whose activities are demonstrably important +within a local, state, or national historic context; 2) be normally associated with a +person's productive life, reflecting the time period when he/she achieved significance; and +3) should be compared to other associated properties to identify those that best represent +the person's historic contributions. Furthermore, a property is not eligible if its only +justification for significance is that it was owned or used by a person who is or was a +member of an identifiable profession, class, or social or ethnic group. The Graham- +Brooks Farm is not known to be associated with an individual or individuals +significant in our past. + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion C (architecture). For a property to be eligible under this Criterion, it +must retain integrity and either 1) embody distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or +method of construction; 2) represent the work of a master; 3) possess high artistic value; +or 4) represent a significant and distinguishable entity whose components lack individual +distinction. The Graham-Brooks Farm and its accompanying structures do not +represent a particular type, period, or method of construction, the work of a +master, or possess high artistic value. + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion D (potential to yield information). For a property to be eligible +under Criterion D, it must meet two requirements: 1) the property must have, or have +had, information to contribute to our understanding of human history or prehistory, and +2) the information must be considered important. The Graham-Brooks Farm does not +have the potential to yield important information to contribute to our +understanding of human history or prehistory. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +14 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County + +OMER. 4111•••• S S .11Mmo + +Outbuilding #1 + +I Graham-Brooks + +House + +Parcel +boundary + +Figure 4. Graham Brooks Farm - site plan + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +15 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Bibliography + +Ashe County Tax Maps. Located in Ashe County Courthouse, Jefferson, North +Carolina. + +Hood, Davyd Foard. 1978. "The Architecture of the New River Valley." In + +Carolina Dwelling: towards preservation of place, in celebration of the North +Carolina vernacular landscape , edited by Doug Swain. Raleigh, NC: North +Carolina State University. + +Keber, Robert. 1978. "Site Selection of Pre-1940 Mountain Houses." In + +Carolina Dwelling: towards preservation of place, in celebration of the North +Carolina vernacular landscape , edited by Doug Swain. Raleigh, NC: North +Carolina State University. + +Bishir, Catherine W., et al. A Guide to the Historic Architecture of Western North +Carolina. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1999. + +Wilcox, George. Interview with author. January 8, 2003. - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Fearnbach, Heather. "Replace Bridge No. 334 on SR 1351 Over the South Fork of +the New River, Watauga/ Ashe County, North Carolina, TIP No. B-3928." +Raleigh: North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office, Survey and +Planning Branch, 2002. -on all relevant risks in this regard, in particular its assessments of market and procurement risks, financial -risks (including currency risks as well as risks due to the COVID-19 pandemic) and organizational risks. +Fletcher, Arthur L. Ashe County, A History. Jefferson, NC: Ashe County Research -The accounting records, the audit reports from the statutory auditors and the Management Board’s and -Supervisory Board’s recommendation on the appropriation of net profit were made available to all -members of the Supervisory Board in a timely manner. At the meeting of the Audit Committee on February -22, 2022 and at the subsequent Supervisory Board meeting held on the same day, the statutory auditors -reported on the key results of their audit and discussed them in detail with the Management Board and the -members of the Supervisory Board. No discrepancies were detected. +Association, Inc. 1963. -The Supervisory Board reviewed in detail the annual financial statements, the combined management -report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, the Management Board’s and the Supervisory Board’s -recommendation on the appropriation of net profit and the consolidated financial statements and raised no -objections. In accordance with the recommendation of the Audit Committee, the Supervisory Board agreed -with the results of the audit of both statements and approved the annual financial statements of PUMA SE -and the consolidated financial statements for the financial year 2021. The 2021 annual financial statements -have thus been adopted. +Mattson, Alexander and Associates. "Historic Architectural Resources Survey -The Management Board and the Supervisory Board resolved to propose to the Annual General Meeting a -distribution of a dividend of € 0.72 per dividend entitled share to the shareholders for the financial year -2021. In this context, the liquidity situation of the Company, the financing and the effects on the capital -market were discussed. The payout is conditional to an overall sound macroeconomic environment. A total -amount of around € 107.7 million will be paid out in dividends from PUMA SE’s retained earnings. The -remaining retained earnings of around € 382.4 million will be carried forward. +Report, Replacement of Bridge No. 281 on SR 1358 Over Big Horse Creek, +Ashe County, TIP No. B-4014." Raleigh: North Carolina State Historic +Preservation Office, Survey and Planning Branch, 2000. -In its meeting on February 22, 2022, the Supervisory Board was presented the state of data collection for -the non-financial report in accordance with §§ 315c in conjunction with §§ 289c to 289e of the German -Commercial Code (HGB). As soon as the non-financial report is finalized, it will be submitted to the -Supervisory Board for approval and will be published on the website of the Company by April 30, 2022. +National Park Service. National Register Bulletin: How to Complete the National -THANKS +Register Registration Form. Washington DC: Department of the Interior, +1997. -We would like to express our gratitude and recognition to the Management Board, the management teams -at the Group companies, the Works Council and all our employees for their hard work and their outstanding -cooperation in 2021. +Weaver, Clarice, ed. Heritage of Ashe County, Volume II. West Jefferson, NC: Ashe -Herzogenaurach, February 22, 2022 +County Historical Society, 1994. -On behalf of the Supervisory Board +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Jean-François Palus -Chairman +19 (cid:9) -13 +4/1/03 diff --git a/q227/random_k2/random_2.md b/q227/random_k2/random_2.md index d0e4711d45467ad9a4bb5f563733b6d5247d3efa..1ac627c3d95d71bba88aff7ff8158f25e99f463e 100644 --- a/q227/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q227/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,806 +1,1642 @@ -Music and streaming -market study final report +RESEARCH ARTICLE + +The population genetics of human disease: +The case of recessive, lethal mutations + +Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim1,2*, Ziyue Gao3, Zachary Baker4, Jose´ Francisco Diesel5, +Yuval B. Simons1, Imran S. Haque6¤, Joseph Pickrell1,7‡, Molly Przeworski1,4‡ + +1 Department of Biological Sciences, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, +2 CAPES Foundation, Ministry of Education of Brazil, Brası´lia, DF, Brazil, 3 Howard Hughes Medical +Institution, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States of America, 4 Department of Systems Biology, +Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, 5 Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, +Santa Maria, RS, Brazil, 6 Counsyl, 180 Kimball Way, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America, +7 New York Genome Center, New York, NY, United States of America + +¤ Current address: Freenome, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America +‡ These authors co-supervised this work. +* guerraamorim@gmail.com + +Abstract + +Do the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations reflect a simple balance +between mutation and purifying selection? What other factors shape the prevalence of dis- +ease mutations? To begin to answer these questions, we focused on one of the simplest +cases: recessive mutations that alone cause lethal diseases or complete sterility. To this +end, we generated a hand-curated set of 417 Mendelian mutations in 32 genes reported to +cause a recessive, lethal Mendelian disease. We then considered analytic models of muta- +tion-selection balance in infinite and finite populations of constant sizes and simulations of +purifying selection in a more realistic demographic setting, and tested how well these mod- +els fit allele frequencies estimated from 33,370 individuals of European ancestry. In doing +so, we distinguished between CpG transitions, which occur at a substantially elevated rate, +and three other mutation types. Intriguingly, the observed frequency for CpG transitions is +slightly higher than expectation but close, whereas the frequencies observed for the three +other mutation types are an order of magnitude higher than expected, with a bigger deviation +from expectation seen for less mutable types. This discrepancy is even larger when subtle +fitness effects in heterozygotes or lethal compound heterozygotes are taken into account. +In principle, higher than expected frequencies of disease mutations could be due to wide- +spread errors in reporting causal variants, compensation by other mutations, or balancing +selection. It is unclear why these factors would have a greater impact on disease mutations +that occur at lower rates, however. We argue instead that the unexpectedly high frequency +of disease mutations and the relationship to the mutation rate likely reflect an ascertainment +bias: of all the mutations that cause recessive lethal diseases, those that by chance have +reached higher frequencies are more likely to have been identified and thus to have been +included in this study. Beyond the specific application, this study highlights the parameters +likely to be important in shaping the frequencies of Mendelian disease alleles. + +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 + +OPEN ACCESS + +Citation: Amorim CEG, Gao Z, Baker Z, Diesel JF, +Simons YB, Haque IS, et al. (2017) The population +genetics of human disease: The case of recessive, +lethal mutations. PLoS Genet 13(9): e1006915. +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 + +Editor: Philipp W. Messer, Cornell University, +UNITED STATES + +Received: December 4, 2016 + +Accepted: July 9, 2017 + +Published: September 28, 2017 + +Copyright: © 2017 Amorim et al. This is an open +access article distributed under the terms of the +Creative Commons Attribution License, which +permits unrestricted use, distribution, and +reproduction in any medium, provided the original +author and source are credited. + +Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are +within the paper and its Supporting Information +files and code from gitHub (https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease; https://github. +com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator). + +Funding: CEGA was partially funded by a Science +Without Borders fellowship from CAPES +foundation (BEX 8279/11-0) and Conselho +Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientı´fico e +Tecnolo´gico (PDE 201145/2015-4), Brazil. ZG was +partially supported by a postdoctoral fellowship +funded by Stanford Center for Computational, + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +1 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Evolutionary and Human Genomics. JFD was +funded by a Science Without Borders fellowship +from CAPES foundation (88888.038761/2013-00). +YBS was supported by NIH grant GM115889. The +work was partially supported by a Research +Initiative in Science and Engineering grant from +Columbia University and NIGMS grants +(GM121372) to JKP and MP. The computing in +this project was supported by two National +Institutes of Health instrumentation grants +(S10OD012351 and S10OD021764) received by +the Department of Systems Biology at Columbia +University. The funders had no role in study +design, data collection and analysis, decision to +publish, or preparation of the manuscript. + +Competing interests: The authors have declared +that no competing interests exist. + +Author summary + +What determines the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations? To begin to +answer this question, we focus on one of the simplest cases: mutations that cause com- +pletely recessive, lethal Mendelian diseases. We first review theory about what to expect +from mutation and selection in a population of finite size and generate predictions based +on simulations using a plausible demographic scenario of recent human evolution. For a +highly mutable type of mutation, transitions at CpG sites, we find that the predictions are +close to the observed frequencies of recessive lethal disease mutations. For less mutable +types, however, predictions substantially under-estimate the observed frequency. We dis- +cuss possible explanations for the discrepancy and point to a complication that, to our +knowledge, is not widely appreciated: that there exists ascertainment bias in disease muta- +tion discovery. Specifically, we suggest that alleles that have been identified to date are +likely the ones that by chance have reached higher frequencies and are thus more likely to +have been mapped. More generally, our study highlights the factors that influence the fre- +quencies of Mendelian disease alleles. -Executive summary +Introduction -29 November 2022 +New disease mutations arise in heterozygotes and either drift to higher frequencies or are rap- +idly purged from the population, depending on the strength of selection and the demographic +history of the population [1–6]. Elucidating the relative contributions of mutation, natural +selection and genetic drift will help to understand why disease alleles persist in humans. +Answers to these questions are also of practical importance, in informing how genetic varia- +tion data can be used to identify additional disease mutations [7]. + +In this regard, rare, Mendelian diseases, which are caused by single highly penetrant and +deleterious alleles, are perhaps most amenable to investigation. A simple model for the persis- +tence of mutations that lead to Mendelian diseases is that their frequencies reflect an equilib- +rium between their introduction by mutation and elimination by purifying selection, i.e., that +they should be found at “mutation-selection balance” [4]. In finite populations, random drift +leads to stochastic changes in the frequency of any mutation, so demographic history, in addi- +tion to mutation and natural selection, plays an important role in shaping the frequency distri- +bution of deleterious mutations [3]. + +Another factor that may be important in determining the frequencies of highly penetrant + +disease mutations is genetic interactions. The mutation-selection balance model has been +extended to scenarios with more than one disease allele, as is often seen for Mendelian diseases +[8,9]. When compound heterozygotes have the same fitness as homozygotes for the disease +allele (i.e., there is no complementation), the combined frequency of all disease alleles can be +modeled similarly as the bi-allelic case, with the mutation rate given by the sum of the muta- +tion rate to each disease allele [8]. In other cases, a disease mutation may be rescued by another +mutation in the same gene [10–12] or by a modifier locus elsewhere in the genome that modu- +lates the severity of the disease symptoms or the penetrance of the disease allele (e.g. [13–15]). +For a subset of disease alleles that are recessive, an alternative model for their persistence in +the population is that there is an advantage to carrying one copy but a disadvantage to carrying +two or none, such that the alleles persist due to overdominance, a form of balancing selection. +Well known examples include sickle cell anemia, thalassemia and G6PD deficiency in populations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +2 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +living where malaria exerts strong selection pressures [16]. The importance of overdominance in +maintaining the high frequency of disease mutations is unknown beyond these specific cases. + +Here, we tested hypotheses about the persistence of mutations that cause lethal, recessive, +Mendelian disorders. This case provides a good starting point, because a large number of Men- +delian disorders have been mapped (e.g., genes have already been associated with >56% of +Mendelian disease phenotypes; [17]). Moreover, while the fitness effects of most diseases are +hard to estimate, for recessive lethal diseases, the selection coefficient is clearly 1 for homozy- +gote carriers in the absence of modern medical care (which, when available, became so only in +the last couple of generations, a timescale that is much too short to substantially affect disease +allele frequencies). Moreover, assuming mutation-selection balance in an infinite population +and no effects in heterozygotes would suggest that, given a per base pair (bp) mutation rate u +ffiffiffi +, i.e., ~10−4 +on the order of 10−8 per generation [18], the frequency of such alleles would be +u +[4]. Thus, sample sizes in human genetics are now sufficiently large that we should be able to +observe completely recessive, lethal disease alleles segregating in heterozygote carriers. + +p + +To this end, we compiled genetic information for a set of 417 mutations reported to cause +fatal, recessive Mendelian diseases and estimated the frequencies of the disease-causing alleles +from large exome datasets. We then compared these data to the expected frequencies of delete- +rious alleles based on models of mutation-selection balance in order to evaluate the effects of +mutation rates and other factors in influencing these frequencies. + +Results + +Mendelian recessive disease allele set + +We relied on two datasets, one that describes 173 autosomal recessive diseases [19] and another +from a genetic testing laboratory (Counsyl [20]; ) that includes 110 +recessive diseases of clinical interest. From these lists, we obtained a set of 44 “recessive lethal” dis- +eases associated with 45 genes (S1 Table), requiring that at least one of the following conditions is +met: (i) in the absence of treatment, the affected individuals die of the disease before reproductive +age, (ii) reproduction is completely impaired in patients of both sexes, (iii) the phenotype includes +severe mental retardation that in practice precludes reproduction, or (iv) the phenotype includes +severely compromised physical development, again precluding reproduction. + +Based on clinical genetics datasets and the medical literature (see Methods for details), we +were able to confirm that 417 Single Nucleotide Variants (SNVs) in 32 (of the 44) genes had +been reported with compelling evidence of association to the severe form of the corresponding +disease and an early-onset, as well as no indication of effects in heterozygote carriers (S2 Table). +By this approach, we obtained a set of mutations for which, at least in principle, there is no het- +erozygote effect, i.e., for which the dominance coefficient h = 0 in a model with relative fitness +of 1 for the homozygote for the reference allele, 1-hs for the heterozygote, and 1-s for the homo- +zygote for the deleterious allele, and the selective coefficient s is 1. - Executive summary +A large subset of these mutations (29.3%) consists of transitions at CpG sites (henceforth +CpGti), which occur at a highly elevated rates (~17-fold higher on average) compared to other +mutation types, namely CpG transversions, and non-CpG transitions and transversions [18]. +This proportion is in agreement with previous estimates for a smaller set of disease genes [21] +and for DMD [22]. -Introduction +Empirical distribution of allele frequencies of disease mutations in Europe + +Allele frequency data for the 417 variants were obtained from the Exome Aggregation Consor- +tium (ExAC) for 60,706 individuals, of whom 33,370 are non-Finnish Europeans [23]. Out of + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +3 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +the 417 variants associated with putative recessive lethal diseases, three were found homozy- +gous in at least one individual in this dataset (rs35269064, p.Arg108Leu in ASS1; rs28933375, +p.Asn252Ser in PRF1; and rs113857788, p.Gln1352His in CFTR). Available data quality infor- +mation for these variants does not suggest genotype calling artifacts (S2 Table). Since these +diseases have severe symptoms that lead to early death without treatment and these ExAC indi- +viduals are healthy (i.e., do not manifest severe Mendelian diseases) [23], the reported muta- +tions are likely errors in pathogenicity classification or cases of incomplete penetrance (see a +similar observation for CFTR and DHCR7 in [24]). We therefore excluded them from our anal- +yses. In addition to the mutations present in homozygotes, we also filtered out sites that had +lower coverage in ExAC (see Methods), resulting in a final dataset of 385 variants in 32 genes +(S2 Table). + +Genotypes for a subset (91) of these mutations were also available for a larger sample size +(76,314 individuals with self-reported European ancestry) generated by the company Counsyl +(S3 Table). A comparison of the allele frequencies in this larger dataset to that of ExAC sug- +gests that the allele frequencies for individual variants are concordant between the two datasets +(Pearson’s correlation coefficient of 0.79, S1 Fig) and that the overall distributions do not differ +appreciably (Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.23). Thus, both data sets appear to reflect +the general distribution of these disease alleles in Europeans. In what follows, we focused on +ExAC, which includes a greater number of disease mutations. + +Models of mutation-selection balance + +To generate expectations for the frequencies of these disease mutations under mutation-selec- +tion balance, we considered models of infinite and finite populations of constant size [3] and +conducted forward simulations using a plausible demographic model for African and Euro- +pean populations [25] (see Methods for details). In all these models, there is a wild-type allele +(A) and a deleterious allele (a, which could also represent a class of distinct deleterious alleles +with the same fitness effect) at each site, such that the relative fitness of individuals of geno- +types AA, Aa, or aa is given respectively by: + +• wAA = 1; + +• wAa = 1-hs; + +• waa = 1-s; + +The mutation rate from A to a is u; we assume that there are no back mutations. +For a constant population of infinite size, Wright [26] showed that under these conditions, +there exists a stable equilibrium between mutation and selection, when the selection pressure +is sufficiently strong (s>>u). In particular, when the deleterious effect of allele a is completely +recessive (h = 0), its equilibrium frequency q is given by: + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +: +u=s + +q ¼ + +ð1Þ + +For a finite population of constant size, Nei [3] derived the mean (Eq 2) and variance (Eq 3) + +of the frequency of a fully recessive deleterious mutation (h = 0) based on a diffusion model, +leading to: + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +(cid:22)q ¼ + +Gð2Nu þ 1=2Þ +p +Gð2NuÞ + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2Ns + +; + +q ¼ u=s (cid:0) (cid:22)q2; +s2 + +ð2Þ + +ð3Þ + +4 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +where N is the diploid population size and Γ is the gamma function (see Simons et al. [1] for a +similar approximation). + +In a finite population, the mean frequency, (cid:22)q, therefore depends on assumptions about the +population mutation rate (2Nu). If the population mutation rate is high, such that 2Nu>>1, (cid:22)q +is approximated by + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +u=s + +(cid:22)q (cid:25) + +ð4Þ + +which is independent of the population size and equal to the equilibrium frequency in an infi- +nite population, i.e., the right hand side of Eq (1). The important difference between the two +models above is that in a finite population, there is a distribution of frequencies q (because of +genetic drift), whose variance is given in Eq (3), rather than a single value, as in an infinite +population. + +In contrast, when the finite population has a low population mutation rate (2Nu<<1), the + +mean allele frequency, (cid:22)q, is approximated by: +p + +(cid:22)q (cid:25) u + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +2pN=s + +which depends on the population size [3]. + +ð5Þ + +We note that Nei [3] assumed a Wright-Fisher model, in which there is no distinction + +between census and the effective population sizes. However, when the two differ, it is the effec- +tive population size that governs the dynamics of deleterious alleles, so the N in the analytical +results in fact represents the effective population size. In humans, the mutation rate at each bp +is very small (on the order of 10−8 [18]) and the effective population size not that large, even +recently [27,28], so the second approximation should apply when considering each single site +independently. + +The expectation and variance of the frequency of a fatal, fully recessive allele (i.e., s = 1, + +h = 0) are then given by: + +and + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2pN + +; + +(cid:22)q ¼ u + +q ¼ u (cid:0) (cid:22)q2 ¼ uð1 (cid:0) 2pNuÞ (cid:25) u: +s2 + +ð6Þ + +ð7Þ + +This single site model implicitly ignores the existence of compound heterozygosity in model- +ing the strength of selection acting on an individual site. + +Comparing mutation-selection balance models + +Although an infinite population size has often been assumed when modeling deleterious allele +frequencies (e.g. [5,29–32]), predictions under this assumption can differ markedly from what +is expected from models of finite population sizes, assuming plausible parameter values for +humans. For example, the long-term estimate of the effective population size from total poly- +morphism levels is ~20,000 individuals (assuming a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 per bp per gen- +eration [18] and diversity levels of 0.1% [33]). In this case and considering a mutation rate of +1.5 x 10−8 for exons (which have a higher mutation rate than the rest of the genome, because of +their base composition [34]), the average deleterious allele frequency in the model of finite +population size is ~23-fold lower than that in the infinite population model (Fig 1). + +Because the human population size has not been constant and changes in the population +size can affect the frequencies of deleterious alleles in the population (e.g. [2,35]), we also simu- +lated the population dynamics of disease alleles under a plausible demographic model for + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +5 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +European populations based on Tennessen et al. [25]. The original model assumes a genome- +wide mutation rate of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation, when current, more direct estimates +are approximately two-fold smaller [18,34,36]. We therefore rescaled the demographic parame- +ters of the Tennessen et al. model, based on a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] (see Methods). As- +suming a mutation rate of 1.5 x 10−8 per bp (as recently estimated for exons [34]), the mean +allele frequency of a lethal, recessive disease allele obtained from this model was 7.10 x 10−6, +~1.33-fold higher than expected for a constant population size model with Ne = 20,000 (Fig 1). +The mean frequency seen in simulations instead matches the expectation for a constant popula- +tion size of 35,651 individuals (see Methods and S2A Fig). Increasing the effective population +size in a constant size model is not enough to capture the dynamics of disease alleles appropri- +ately, however. For example, if simulation results obtained under the Tennessen et al. [25] +demographic model are compared to those for simulations of a constant population size of Ne = +35,651, the mean allele frequencies match, but the distributions of allele frequencies are signifi- +cantly different (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, p-value < 10−15; S2B and S2C Fig). These findings +thus confirm the importance of incorporating demographic history into models for under- +standing the population dynamics of disease alleles [5,37,38]. In what follows, we therefore +tested the fit of the more realistic demographic model [25] (and variants of it) to the observed +allele frequencies. + +Fig 1. Expected allele frequencies in a population, according to mutation-selection balance models. +The blue bar denotes the expected allele frequency under an infinite population size, the green bar the mean +under a finite constant population, and the red bar the mean under a plausible demographic model for +European populations; for this last case, the entire distribution across 100,000 simulations is shown in the +grey histogram. All models assume s = 1 and h = 0, i.e., fully recessive, lethal mutations. For the finite +constant population size model, we present the mean frequency for a population size of 20,000 (see S2A Fig +for other choices). Population allele frequencies (q) were transformed to log10(q), and those q = 0 were set to +10−7 for visual purposes, but indicated as “0” on the X-axis. The density of the distribution is plotted on a log- +scale on the Y-axis. The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation in all models. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g001 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +6 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Comparing empirical and expected distributions of disease allele +frequencies + +The mutation rate from wild-type allele to disease allele, u, is a critical parameter in predicting +the frequencies of a deleterious allele [4,39]. To model disease alleles, we considered four muta- +tion types separately, with the goal of capturing most of the fine-scale heterogeneity in muta- +tion rates [27,36,40,41]: transitions in methylated CpG sites (CpGti) and three less mutable +types, namely transversions in CpG sites (CpGtv) and transitions and transversions outside a +CpG site (nonCpGti and nonCpGtv, respectively). In order to control for the methylation sta- +tus of CpG sites, we excluded 12 CpGti that occurred in CpG islands, which tend not to be +methylated and thus are likely to have a lower mutation rate [36] (following Moorjani et al. +[42]). To allow for heterogeneity in mutation rates within each one of these four classes consid- +ered, we modeled the within-class variation in mutation rates according to a lognormal distri- +bution (see details in Methods and [27]). + +For each mutation type, we then compared the mean allele frequency obtained from simu- +lations to what is observed in ExAC, running 100,000 replicates. To this end, we matched sim- +ulations to the empirical data with regard to the number of individuals sampled and number +of mutations observed of each mutation type and focused the analysis on the largest sample of +the same common ancestry, namely Non-Finnish Europeans (n = 33,370) (Fig 2A). We found +significant differences between empirical and expected mean frequencies for nonCpGtv (30- +fold higher on average; two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4; see Methods for details) and nonCpGti +(15-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4), but only marginally so for CpGtv +(5-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value = 0.08). The mean frequency for CpGti is also +somewhat higher than expected, but insignificantly so (1.17-fold higher on average, two-tailed +p-value = 0.59). Intriguingly, the discrepancy between observed and expected frequencies +becomes smaller as the mutation rate increases (Fig 2B). + +Two additional factors that we have not included in our model should further decrease the +predicted frequencies of disease alleles. Given that frequencies in ExAC are already unexpect- +edly high, these factors would only exacerbate the discrepancy between observed and expected +frequencies of deleterious alleles. First, we have ignored the effects of compound heterozygos- +ity, the case in which combinations of two distinct pathogenic alleles in the same gene lead to +lethality. This phenomenon is known to be common [43], and indeed, in the 320 cases in +which we were able to obtain this information, 58.44% were initially identified in compound +heterozygotes. In the presence of compound heterozygosity, each deleterious mutation will be +selected against not only when present in two copies within the same individual, but also in +the presence of lethal mutations at other sites. Since the purging effect of selection against +compound heterozygotes was not modeled in simulations, we would predict the frequency of a +deleterious mutation to be even lower than shown (e.g., in Fig 2A). + +In order to model the effect of compound heterozygosity in our simulations, we re-ran our +simulations, but focusing on a gene rather than a single site and so considering the sum of fre- +quencies of all known recessive lethal alleles within a gene. In these simulations, we used the +same set-up as in the site level analysis, except for the mutation rate, U, which is now the sum +of the mutation rates uj at each site j that is known to cause a severe and early onset form of the +disease [8] (S2 Table; see Methods for details). This approach does not consider the contribu- +tion of other mutations in the genes that cause the mild and/or late onset forms of the disease, +and implicitly assumes that all combinations of known recessive lethal alleles of the same gene +have the same fitness effect as homozygotes. Comparing observed frequencies of disease alleles +for each gene to predictions generated by simulation, about a fourth of the 27 genes for which +we implemented the gene-level analysis (see Methods) differ from the expected distribution at + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +7 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +8 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Fig 2. Comparison between expected and observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease mutations. (A) Shown +are the expected and observed mean sample frequencies of disease mutations for four different mutation types. The title of the panel +indicates the mutation type, followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type considered in this study, with the p-value for the +difference between observed and expected mean frequencies given below. Distributions in grey are the mean sample allele frequencies +across K mutations based on 100,000 simulations, and rely on a plausible demographic model for European populations [25] (see +Methods). Blue bars represent the observed mean frequencies of the four mutation types, estimated from 33,370 individuals of +European ancestry from ExAC. (B) Fold increase in the observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expected, as a function of the +mutation rate u (on a log-scale), for each of the four mutation classes. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g002 + +the 5% level, with a clear overall trend for observed frequencies to be above expectation (S4 +Table; Fig 3; Fisher’s combined probability test p-value = 6 x 10−8). + +This finding is even more surprising than it may seem, because we are far from knowing the +complete mutation target for each gene, i.e., all the sites at which mutations could cause the dis- +ease. If there are additional, undiscovered sites in the gene at which mutations are fatal when +carried in combination with a known recessive lethal mutation, the purging effect of purifying +selection on the known mutations will be under-estimated in our simulations, leading us to +over-estimate the expected frequencies of the known mutations in simulations. Therefore, our +predictions are, if anything, an over-estimate of the expected allele frequency, and the discrep- +ancy between predicted and the observed is likely even larger than what we found. + +The other factor that we did not consider in simulations but would reduce the expected +allele frequencies is a subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes, as has been documented in Dro- +sophila for example [44]. To evaluate potential fitness effects in heterozygotes when none had +been documented in humans, we considered the phenotypic consequences of orthologous +gene knockouts in mouse. We were able to retrieve information on phenotypes for both homo- +zygote and heterozygote mice for only eight out of the 32 genes, namely ASS1, CFTR, DHCR7, +NPC1, POLG, PRF1, SLC22A5, and SMPD1. For all eight, homozygote knockout mice pre- +sented similar phenotypes as affected humans, and heterozygotes showed a milder but + +Fig 3. Sample allele frequencies at the gene level. The expectation (grey) is based on 1000 simulations, assuming no fitness decrease in +heterozygotes, but allowing for compound heterozygosity (see Methods for details). The sum of allele frequencies of known recessive lethal +disease mutations in each gene (purple bars) was obtained from ExAC considering 33,370 European individuals. Genes are ordered according +to the two-tailed p-value (S4 Table; see Methods). Genes are bolded when they differ significantly from expectation (at the 5% level). Violin +plots show the distribution of the log10 combined allele frequency of all segregating alleles obtained from simulations and boxes represent the +fraction of simulations in which no deleterious allele was observed in the simulated sample at present time. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g003 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +9 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +detectable phenotype (S5 Table). The magnitude of the heterozygote effect of these mutations +in humans is unclear, but the finding with knockout mice makes it plausible that there exists a +very small fitness decrease in heterozygotes in humans as well, potentially not enough to have +been recognized in clinical investigations but enough to have a marked impact on the allele fre- +quencies of the disease mutations. Indeed, even if the fitness effect in heterozygotes were as +small as h = 1%, a 79% decrease in the mean allele frequency of the disease allele is expected +relative to the case with complete recessivity (h = 0) (S3 Fig). + +Discussion + +To investigate the population genetics of human disease, we focused on mutations that cause +Mendelian, recessive disorders that lead to early death or completely impaired reproduction. +We sought to understand to what extent the frequencies of these mutations fit the expectation +based on a simple balance between the input of mutations and the purging by purifying selec- +tion, as well as how other mechanisms might affect these frequencies. Many studies implicitly +or explicitly compare known disease allele frequencies to expectations from mutation-selection +balance [5,29–32]. In this study, we tested whether known recessive lethal disease alleles as a +class fit these expectations, and found that, under a sensible demographic model for European +population history with purifying selection only in homozygotes, the expectations fit the +observed disease allele frequencies poorly: the mean empirical frequencies of disease alleles are +substantially above expectation for all mutation types (although not significantly so for CpGti), +and the fold increase in observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expectation decreases +with increased mutation rate (Fig 2). Furthermore, including possible effects of compound he- +terozygosity and subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes will only exacerbate the discrepancy. +In principle, higher than expected disease allele frequencies could be explained by at least +six (non-mutually exclusive) factors: (i) widespread errors in reporting the causal variants; (ii) +misspecification of the demographic model, (iii) misspecification of the mutation rate; (iv) +reproductive compensation; (v) overdominance of disease alleles; and (vi) low penetrance of +disease mutations. Because widespread mis-annotation of the causal variants in disease muta- +tion databases had previously been reported [23,45,46], we tried to minimize the effect of such +errors on our analyses by filtering out any case that lacked compelling evidence of association +with a recessive lethal disease, reducing our initial set of 769 mutations to 385 in which we had +greater confidence (see Methods for details). + +We also explored the effects of having misspecified recent demographic history or the +mutation rate. Based on very large samples, it has been estimated that population growth in +Europe was stronger than what we considered in our simulations [47,48]. When we considered +higher growth rates, such that the current effective population size is up to 10-fold larger than +that of the rescaled Tennessen model, we observed an increase in the expected frequency of +recessive disease alleles and a larger number of segregating sites (S4 Fig, columns A-E). How- +ever, the impact of larger growth rate is insufficient to explain the observed discrepancy: the +allele frequencies observed in ExAC are still on average an order of magnitude larger than +expected based on a model with a 10-fold larger current effective population size than the one +initially considered [25] (S4 Fig). In turn, population substructure within Europe would only +increase the number of homozygotes relative to what was modeled in our simulations (through +the Wahlund effect [49]) and expose more recessive alleles to selection, thus decreasing the +expected allele frequencies and exacerbating the discrepancy that we report. + +To explore the effects of error in the mutation rate, we considered a 50% higher mean + +mutation rate than what has been estimated for exons [34], beyond what seems plausible based +on current estimates on human mutation rates [42]. Except for the mean mutation rate (now + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +10 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +set to 2.25 x 10−8), all other parameters used for these simulations (i.e. the variance in mutation +rate across simulations, the demographic model [25], absence of selective effect in heterozy- +gotes, and selection coefficient) were kept the same as the ones used for generating S4 Fig, col- +umn A. The observed mean frequency remains significantly above what those predicted and +qualitative conclusions are unchanged (S4 Fig, column F). + +Another factor to consider is that for disease phenotypes that are lethal very early on in life, + +there may be partial or complete reproductive compensation (e.g. [50]). This phenomenon +would decrease the fitness effects of the recessive lethal mutations and could therefore lead to +an increase in the allele frequency in data relative to what we predict for a selection coefficient +of 1. There are no reasons, however, for this phenomenon to correlate with the mutation rate, +as seen in Fig 2B. + +The other two factors, overdominance and low penetrance, are likely explanations for a sub- +set of cases. For instance, CFTR, the gene in which some mutations lead to cystic fibrosis, is the +farthest above expectation (p-value < 0.004; Fig 3). It was long noted that there is an unusually +high frequency of the CFTR deletion ΔF508 in Europeans, which led to speculation that disease +alleles of this gene may be subject to over-dominance ([51,52], but see [53]). Regardless, it is +known that disease mutations in this gene can complement one another [10,11] and that modi- +fier loci in other genes also influence their penetrance [11,14]. Consistent with variable pene- +trance, Chen et al. [24] identified three purportedly healthy individuals carrying two copies of +disease mutations in this gene. Similarly, DHCR7, the gene associated with the Smith-Lemli- +Opitz syndrome, is somewhat above expectation in our analysis (p-value = 0.056; Fig 3) and +healthy individuals were found to be homozygous carriers of putatively lethal disease alleles in +other studies [24]. These observations make it plausible that, in a subset of cases (particularly +for CFTR), the high frequency of deleterious mutations associated with recessive, lethal diseases +are due to genetic interactions that modify the penetrance of certain recessive disease mutations. +It is hard to assess the importance of this phenomenon in driving the general pattern that we +observe, but two factors argue against it being a sufficient explanation for our findings at the +level of single sites. First, when we removed 130 mutations in CFTR and 12 in DHCR7, the two +genes that were outliers at the gene level (Fig 3; S4 Table) and for which there is evidence of +incomplete penetrance [24], the discrepancy between observed and expected allele frequencies +is barely impacted (S5 Fig). Moreover, there is no obvious reason why the degree of incomplete +penetrance would vary systematically with the mutation rate of a site, as observed (Fig 2B). + +Instead, it seems plausible that there is an ascertainment bias in disease allele discovery and +mutation identification [52,54,55]. Unlike missense or protein-truncating variants, Mendelian +disease mutations cannot be annotated based solely on DNA sequences, and their identifica- +tion requires reliable diagnosis of affected individuals (usually in more than one pedigree) fol- +lowed by mapping of the underlying gene/mutation. Therefore, those mutations that have +been identified to date are likely the ones that are segregating at higher frequencies in the pop- +ulation. Moreover, mutation-selection balance models predict that the frequency of a deleteri- +ous mutation should correlate with the mutation rate. Together, these considerations suggest +that disease variants of a highly mutable class, such as CpGti, are more likely to have been +mapped and that the mean frequency of mapped mutations will tend to be only slightly above +all disease mutations in that class. In contrast, less mutable disease mutations are less likely to +have been discovered to date, and the mean frequency of the subset of mutations that have +been identified may tend to be far above that of all mutations in that class. + +To quantify these effects, we modeled the ascertainment of disease mutations both analyti- + +cally and in simulations. A large proportion of recessive Mendelian disease mutations were +identified in inbred populations, likely because inbreeding leads to an excess of homozygotes +compared to expected under random mating, increasing the probability that a recessive + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +11 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +mutation would be discovered as causing a disease. Therefore, we modeled ascertainment in +disease discovery in human populations with a plausible degree of inbreeding (see Methods). +As expected, we found that for a given mutation type, the probability of ascertainment in- +creases with the sample size of the putative disease ascertainment study (na) and the average +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study (Fa); in addition, the average allele fre- +quency of mutations that have been identified is always higher than that of all existing muta- +tions, and the discrepancy decreases as the ascertainment probability increases (Table 1). +Furthermore, comparison across different mutation types reveals that a higher mutation rate +increases the probability of disease mutations being ascertained (Table 1 and S6 Fig) and +decreases the magnitude of bias in the estimated allele frequency relative to the mutation class +as a whole (Table 1). In summary, among all the possible aforementioned explanations for the +observed discrepancy between empirical and expected mean allele frequencies, the ascertain- +ment bias hypothesis is the only one that also explains why it is more pronounced for less +mutable mutation types (Fig 2B). + +One implication of this hypothesis is that there are numerous sites at which mutations +cause recessive lethal diseases yet to be discovered, particularly at non-CpG sites. More gener- +ally, this ascertainment bias complicates the interpretation of observed allele frequencies in +terms of the selection pressures acting on disease alleles. Beyond this specific point, our study +illustrates how the large sample sizes now made available to researchers in the context of proj- +ects like ExAC [23] can be used not only for direct discovery of disease variants, but also to test +why disease alleles are segregating in the population and to understand at what frequencies we +might expect to find them in the future. + +Methods +Disease allele set + +In order to identify single nucleotide variants within the 42 genes associated with lethal, reces- +sive Mendelian diseases (S1 Table), we initially relied on the ClinVar dataset [56] (accessed on + +Table 1. For a given set of parameters na (the sample size in a putative disease ascertainment study) and Fa (the average inbreeding coefficient of +the population in which the study is being performed), we report the probability of a recessive, lethal mutation being ascertained, as well as the +fold increase in mean allele frequencies of the ascertained cases (qa) in relation to the mean frequencies of all mutations for each mutation type +(qu), based on simulations (see Methods for details). For a similar result derived from analytical modeling, see S6 Fig. Parameters for this step of the sim- +ulation correspond to plausible scenarios for human populations with widespread inbreeding (e.g., Fa = 1/16 corresponds to offspring of first-cousin marriage). +The last column in the bottom panel shows the fold increase of the mean allele frequency observed in ExAC in relation to simulations based on the Tennessen +et al. [25] demographic model (see Methods). Mutation rates u per bp, per generation were obtained from a large human pedigree study [18]. + +Parameter + +na +Fa +Mutation type (u) + +CpGti (1.12e-7) + +CpGtv (9.59e-9) + +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) + +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) + +CpGti (1.12e-7) + +CpGtv (9.59e-9) + +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) + +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) + +10,000 + +1/16 + +0.0150 + +0.0014 + +0.0009 + +0.0005 + +27.6 + +284.1 + +455.7 + +716.5 + +10,000 + +1/8 + +0.0247 + +0.0024 + +0.0015 + +0.0010 + +Simulation settings + +100,000 + +1/8 + +100,000 + +1/6 + +Probability of a mutation being ascertained + +0.0968 + +0.0104 + +0.0067 + +0.0044 + +0.1125 + +0.0124 + +0.0074 + +0.0050 + +500,000 + +1/8 + +0.1858 + +0.0235 + +0.0146 + +0.0091 + +Fold increase in allele frequency due to ascertainment bias + +22.3 + +222.6 + +335.6 + +577.4 + +9.0 + +81.2 + +126.1 + +192.9 + +8.0 + +70.2 + +114.8 + +174.1 + +5.2 + +40.6 + +64.7 + +103.6 + +ExAC + +- + +- + +- + +- + +1.17 + +5.4 -1. - -2. - -Music streaming has transformed how consumers listen to music. The rise of -music streaming has given consumers easy access to large catalogues of -music covering an array of genres and time periods for a fixed monthly price, -or free with ads. As music streaming services have grown in popularity, -consumer outcomes have improved significantly. Between 2009 and 2021 the -monthly price of individual music streaming subscriptions has fallen by more -than 20% in real terms because the price of these plans has not kept pace -with inflation. At the same time, consumers have gained access to more -music and more innovative and better quality services, for example higher -quality audio, new video content and synced song lyrics. - -Consumers have widely adopted music streaming -– in the UK in 2021 there were 39 million monthly -active users of music streaming services and -there were over 138 billion streams. Streaming is -now the primary means for artists and labels to -distribute music and has been pivotal in securing -the sector’s recovery from piracy. - -1 - - 3. - -4. - -5. - -6. - -7. - -Some parts of the market have improved for artists in recent years, with more -choice about the type of deals with record labels available and more able to -directly release their music on streaming services. Average royalty rates in -major deals for new artists have increased steadily from an average of 19.7% -in 2012 to 23.3% in 2021. For songwriters, the share of revenues going to -publishing rights has increased significantly from 8% in 2008 to 15% in 2021. - -Whilst outcomes are good for consumers and generally improving for -creators, we note that to some extent changes in the sector, precipitated by -streaming, have made it harder for some creators. Reduced barriers to entry -and more choice on how to distribute music has meant there are more artists -than ever and, therefore, creators face more artists and songs to compete -with for streaming revenues. Not only that, but the convenience of streaming -means that older music is enjoying a resurgence of popularity, meaning that -today’s artists need to work harder than ever to grab listeners’ attention. - -These factors may be exacerbated by the fact that it is challenging for music -companies to know who among the growing pool of creators will be -successful. This inherent uncertainty combined with consumer tastes that -tend to tip to a relatively small number of artists means that it is challenging -for creators to succeed. We do not think that these factors arise from how -firms compete in the market. - -We have found that it is unlikely that the outcomes that concern many -stakeholders are primarily driven by competition. Consequently, it is unlikely -that a competition intervention would improve outcomes overall, and release -more money in the system to pay creators more. In such circumstances, there -is a greater risk that a competition intervention will result in unintended -consequences and worse outcomes for both consumers and creators. The -costs, risks and uncertainty created by a market investigation (which could run -for two years) would be imposed on the industry and borne, ultimately, by -consumers. We have therefore decided to not undertake a market -investigation. - -While there is limited potential for a competition intervention to improve -outcomes, there remains a broader policy debate about the optimal -distribution of existing revenues. We think it is a matter for Government and -policymakers to determine whether the current split is appropriate and fair, -and to explore whether wider policy interventions are required, for example -those relating to the copyright framework and how music streaming licensing -rates are set. We hope that our final findings provide insights that will be -helpful for that continuing debate. +15.2 +30.0 + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.t001 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +12 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +June 3rd, 2015). We filtered out any variant that is an indel or a more complex copy number +variant or that is ever classified as benign or likely benign in ClinVar (whether or not it is also +classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic). By this approach, we obtained 769 SNVs +described as pathogenic or likely pathogenic. For each one of these variants, we searched the +literature for evidence that it is exclusively associated to the lethal and early onset form of the +disease and was never reported as causing the mild and/or late-onset form of the disease. We +considered effects in the absence of medical treatment, as we were interested in the selection +pressures acting on the alleles over evolutionary time scales rather than in the last one or two +generations, i.e., the period over which treatment became available for some of diseases con- +sidered. To evaluate the impact of treatment, we decreased s from 1 to 0 (i.e., we assumed a +complete absence of selective effects due to treatment) in the last three generations and com- +pared the mean allele frequencies across 100,000 simulations implemented with or without +this readjustment in selection coefficient. Because of the stochastic nature of the simulations, +we repeated this pairwise comparison 10 times in order to get a range of expected increase in +allele frequencies. We observed only a minor increase in the mean allele frequency (2.6% at +most) across the 10 replicates. This simulation procedure corresponds to a scenario in which +there is an extremely effective treatment for all diseases for the past three generations, which is +an overestimate of the effect and length of treatment for the disease set considered. + +Variants with mention of incomplete penetrance (i.e. for which homozygotes were not +always affected) or with known effects in heterozygote carriers were removed from the analy- +sis. This process yielded 417 SNVs in 32 genes associated with distinct Mendelian recessive +lethal disorders (S2 Table). Although these mutations were purportedly associated with +completely recessive diseases, we sought to examine whether there would be possible, unre- +ported effects in heterozygous carriers. To this end, we used the Mouse Genome Database +(MGD) [57] (accessed July 29th, 2015) and were able to retrieve information for both homozy- +gote and heterozygote mice for eight out of the 32 genes (all of which with a homologue in +mice) (S5 Table). + +In addition to the information provided by ClinVar for each one of these variants, we con- + +sidered the immediate sequence context of each SNV, to tailor the mutation rate estimate +accordingly [18]. To do so, we used an in-house Python script and the human genome refer- +ence sequence hg19 from UCSC (). + +Genetic datasets +The Exome Aggregation Consortium (ExAC) [23] was accessed on August 9th, 2016. The data +consist of genotype frequencies for 60,706 individuals, assigned after Principal Component +Analysis to one of seven population labels: African (n = 5,203), East Asian (n = 4,327), Finnish +(n = 3,307), Latino (n = 5,789), Non-Finnish European (n = 33,370), South Asian (n = 8,256) +and “other” (n = 454) [23]. We focused our analyses on those individuals of Non-Finnish +European descent, because they constitute the largest sample size from a single ancestry group. +We note that, some diseases mutations, for instance, those in ASPA, HEXA and SMPD1, are +known to be especially prevalent in Ashkenazi Jewish populations, which could potentially +bias our results if Ashkenazi Jewish individuals constituted a great portion of the sample we +considered. However, this sample includes only ~2,000 (~6%) Ashkenazi individuals (Dr. +Daniel MacArthur, personal communication). + +From the initial 417 mutations, we filtered out three that were homozygous in at least one + +individual in ExAC and 29 that had lower coverage, i.e., fewer than 80% of the individuals +were sequenced to at least 15x. This approach left us with a set of 385 mutations with a + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +13 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +minimum coverage of 27x per sample and an average coverage of 69x per sample (S2 Table). +For 248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies, ExAC reported the number of non-Finnish +European individuals that were sequenced, which was on average 32,881 individuals [23]. For +the remaining 137 sites, we did not have this information. Nonetheless, the coverage across all +samples is reported and does not differ significantly between the two sets of sites (by a Kolmo- +gorov-Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90; S7 Fig). We therefore assumed that mean number of indi- +viduals covered for all sites was 32,881 and used this number to obtain sample frequencies +from simulations, as explained below. + +A second genetic dataset was obtained from Counsyl (). +Counsyl is a commercial genetic screening laboratory that offers, among other products, the +“Family Prep Screen”, a genetic screening test intended to detect carrier status for up to 110 +recessive Mendelian diseases in couples that are planning to have a child [20]. A subset of +294,000 of its customers was surveyed by genotyping or sequencing for “routine carrier screen- +ing”. This subset excludes individuals with indications for testing because of known personal +or family history of Mendelian diseases, infertility, and consanguinity. It therefore represents a +more random (with regard to the presence of disease alleles), population-based survey. For +these individuals, we had details on self-reported ancestry (14 distinct ethnic/ancestry/geo- +graphic groups) and the allele frequencies for 98 mutations that match those that passed our +variant selection criteria described above, of which 91 are also sequenced to high coverage in +the ExAC database (S2 Table). We focused our analysis of this dataset on the 76,314 individu- +als of self-reported Northern or Southern European ancestry. + +Simulating the evolution of disease alleles with population size change + +We modeled the frequency of a deleterious allele in human populations by forward simula- +tions based on a crude but plausible demographic model for human populations from Africa +and Europe, inferred from exome data for African-Americans and European-Americans [25]. +To this end, we used a program described in [1]. In brief, the demographic scenario consists of +an Out-of-Africa demographic model, with changes in population size throughout the popula- +tion history, including a severe bottleneck in Europeans following the split from the African +population and a rapid, recent population growth in both populations [25]. As in Simons et al. +[1], we simulated genetic drift and two-way gene flow between Africans and Europeans in +recent history. + +The original demographic model was inferred using a mutation rate u of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp + +per generation [25,58]. More recent estimates, based on direct resequencing of human pedi- +grees, instead point to mutation rates about 50% smaller than that [18,34,36]. To incorporate +what is believed to be a more accurate mutation rate estimate, we rescaled all demographic and +time parameters in the original Tennessen et al. [25] model by a factor of 1.97, based on the +difference between the mutation rate considered in the original study and that of Kong et al. +[18] (which is similar to that found in other studies [48]). We refer to this model as the rescaled +Tennessen model and rely on it throughout. + +Negative selection acting on a single bi-allelic site was modeled as in the analytic models. +Allele frequencies follow a Wright-Fisher sampling scheme in each generation according to +these viabilities, with migration rate and population sizes varying according to the demo- +graphic scenario considered. Whenever a demographic event (e.g., growth) altered the number +of individuals and the resulting number was not an integer, we rounded it to the nearest inte- +ger, as in Simons et al. [1]. A burn-in period of 10Ne generations with constant population size +Ne = 14,328 individuals was implemented in order to ensure an equilibrium distribution of +segregating alleles at the onset of demographic changes in Africa, 11,643 generations ago. + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +14 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +In contrast to Simons et al. [1], our simulations always start with the ancestral allele A fixed + +and mutation occurs exclusively from this allele to the deleterious one (a), i.e., a mutation +occurs with mean probability u per gamete, per generation, and there is no back-mutation. +However, recurrent mutations at a site are allowed, as in Simons et al. [1]. + +When implementing the simulations, we considered a mean mutation rate u of 1.5x10-8 per +bp, per generation, as has been estimated for exons [34], as well as mutation rates for four dis- +tinct mutation types (CpGti = 1.12 x 10−7; CpGtv = 9.59 x 10−9; nonCpGti = 6.18 x 10−9; and +nonCpGtv = 3.76 x 10−9) estimated from a large human pedigree study [18]. While these four +categories capture much of the variation in germline mutation rates across sites, a number of +other factors (e.g., the larger sequence context or the replication timing) also influence muta- +tion rates, introducing heterogeneity in the mutation rate within each class considered +[27,36,40,59]. To allow for this heterogeneity as well as for uncertainty in the point mutation +rates estimates, in each simulation, when compared to human exome data (Figs 1, 2, S4 and +S5), instead of using a fixed rate u, we drew the mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution +with the following parameters: + +log10Mju (cid:24) Nðlog10u (cid:0) + +s2 2 - The effect of digitisation on the music industry +lnð10Þ; s2Þ + +ð8Þ + +such that that E[M] = u. σ was set to 0.57 (following [27]). +For each mutation type, we then proceeded as follows: + +1. We ran two million simulations, thus obtaining the distribution of deleterious allele fre- + +quencies expected for the European population. + +2. We sampled K allele frequencies from the two million simulations implemented for each + +mutation type, where K is the number of identified mutations of that type. Sample allele fre- +quencies were simulated from these population frequencies by Poisson sampling, so to +match ExAC’s number of chromosomes. + +3. We repeated step (2) 100,000 times, thus obtaining a distribution for the mean allele fre- + +quency across K mutations. + +To assess the significance of the deviation between observed and expected mean, we + +obtained a two-tailed p-value, defined as 2 x (r+1)/(100000+1), where r is the number of simu- +lated allele frequencies that were greater or equal to that of the empirical mean [60], for each +mutation type separately. + +A well-known source of heterogeneity in mutation rate within the CpGti class is methyla- +tion status, with a high transition rate seen only at methylated CpGs [21]. In our analyses, we +tried to control for the methylation status of CpG sites by excluding sites located in CpG +islands (CGIs), which tend to not be methylated [42]. The CGI annotation for hg19 was +obtained from UCSC Genome Browser (track “Unmasked CpG”; , accessed in June 6th, +2016). BEDTools [61] was used to exclude those CpG sites located in CGIs. We note that the +CpGti estimate from [18] includes CGIs, and in that sense the average mutation rate that we +are using for CpGti may be a very slight underestimate of the mean rate for transitions at +methylated CpG sites. + +Unless otherwise noted, the expectation assumes fully recessive, lethal alleles with complete +penetrance. Notably, by calculating the expected frequency one site at a time, we are ignoring +possible interaction between genes (i.e., effects of the genetic background) and among differ- +ent mutations within a gene (i.e., compound heterozygotes). These assumptions are relaxed in +two ways. In one analysis (S3 Fig), we considered a very low selective effect in heterozygous + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +15 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +individuals (h = 1%), reasoning that such an effect could plausibly go undetected in medical +examinations and yet would nonetheless impact the frequency of the disease allele. Second, +when considering the gene-level analysis (Fig 3), we implicitly allowed for compound hetero- +zygosity between any pair of known lethal mutations [8]. For this analysis, we ran 1000 simula- +tions for a total mutation rate U per gene that was calculated accounting for the heterogeneity +and uncertainty in the mutation rates estimates as follows: (i) For j sites in a gene known to +cause a recessive lethal disease and that passed our filtering criteria (S2 Table), we drew a +mutation rate uj from the lognormal distribution, as described above; (ii) We then took the +sum of uj as the total mutation rate U; (iii) We then ran one replicate with U as the mutation +parameter, and other parameters as specified for site level analysis. Because the mutational tar- +get size considered in simulations is only comprised of those sites at which mutations are +known to cause a lethal recessive disease, it is almost certainly an underestimate of the true +mutation rate—potentially by a lot. We note further that by this approach, we are assuming +that compound heterozygotes formed by any two lethal alleles have fitness zero, i.e., that they +are identical in their effects to homozygotes for any of the lethal alleles. Moreover, we are +implicitly ignoring the possibility of complementation, which is (somewhat) justified by our +focus on mutations with severe effects and complete penetrance (but see Discussion). Since we +were interested in understanding the effect of compound heterozygosity, for this analysis, we +did not consider the five genes in which only one mutation passed our filters (BCS1L, FKTN, +LAMA3, PLA3G6, and TCIRG1). + +Modeling the effect of the ascertainment bias in disease discovery + +To calculate the probability of ascertaining a recessive, lethal mutation, we assumed that all +currently known disease mutations were identified in a putative ascertainment study of sample +size na in a population with an inbreeding coefficient of Fa. Under this model, we can estimate +Pasc, the probability of ascertaining a disease mutation, as following: + +For a disease allele (denoted as a) at frequency q in the present population, if we randomly +sample an individual with inbreeding coefficient of Fa, the probabilities of the three genotypes +are: + +PðAAÞ ¼ Fað1 (cid:0) qÞ þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞð1 (cid:0) qÞ2; + +PðAaÞ ¼ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞ2qð1 (cid:0) qÞ; + +PðaaÞ ¼ Faq þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2: + +ð9Þ + +ð10Þ + +ð11Þ + +Thus, if na unrelated individual are surveyed, the probability of not seeing any homozygote +for the disease allele (which is the same as the probability of not being ascertained in this set) is: + +Therefore, the probability of ascertainment is + +Pnasc ¼ ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna: + +Pasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) Pnasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna +½1 (cid:0) Faq (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2(cid:138)na +½ð1 (cid:0) qÞð1 þ q (cid:0) FaqÞ(cid:138)na; + +¼ 1 (cid:0) + +¼ 1 (cid:0) + +ð12Þ + +ð13Þ + +which is an increasing function with regard to q (the population allele frequency), Fa (the +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study) as well as na (the sample size of the puta- +tive ascertainment study) (S6 Fig). + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +16 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +We also demonstrate the relationship between the probability of ascertainment and muta- +tion rate using simulations of ascertainment bias implemented according to the following steps: + +1. For each of the four mutation types considered, we generated 106 allele frequencies q from + +the results of the simulations based on a realistic demographic model [25]. + +2. We generated na independent diploid genotypes, given the allele frequencies from step 1 + +and an inbreeding coefficient Fa. We ran this step for a range of na and Fa values (Table 1). +3. With a given combination of na and Fa values, we identified the cases (out of the 106 obser- +vations from step 1) where at least one homozygote individual was observed in step 2. +These cases correspond to disease mutations that were ascertained; the reasoning being that +given complete penetrance, a recessive disease mutation can only be identified if there is at +least one affected individual in the studied population. With this step, we calculated the +probability of ascertainment by taking the fraction of cases that satisfy the criteria above. + +4. Finally, for each one of the 106 simulations from step 1, we generated a sample allele fre- + +quency of the disease mutation, matching ExAC’s sample size (i.e., considering 2n = 65,762 +chromosomes). We can then compare qu, the unbiased average allele frequency of all dis- +ease mutations, to qa, the mean frequency of the subset of cases ascertained in step 3, i.e., +those cases for which at least one homozygote individual is observed. + +These simulations were meant to illustrate the likely impact of ascertainment bias, rather + +than to precisely describe the disease mutation identification process or to quantify the ex- +pected effect. Notably, we performed these simulations for single sites, so the criteria for ascer- +tainment in step 3 did not include the possibility of compound heterozygotes, despite the fact +that an estimated 58.4% of the disease mutations included in our study were initially identified +in compound heterozygotes. However, this simulation framework could readily be extended +in this direction and it would not change our qualitative conclusion. + +Supporting information + +S1 Table. List of lethal, recessive Mendelian diseases considered in this study. +(DOCX) + +S2 Table. Information on 417 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases. +(XLSX) + +S3 Table. Information on 91 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases in Counsyl and ExAC databases. +(XLSX) + +S4 Table. P-values for each gene estimated by simulation, under a model of mutation- +selection balance with a plausible demographic history. +(DOCX) + +S5 Table. Phenotypic effect of mouse knock-outs (see main text). +(DOCX) + +S1 Fig. Comparison of the empirical allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease muta- +tions in individuals of European ancestry from two large exome studies. Shown are the +allele frequencies for 91 variants associated with lethal, recessive diseases, as estimated from +33,370 individuals of non-Finnish, European ancestry in the Exome Aggregation Consortium +(ExAC) database [23] and 76,314 European-ancestry individuals from a genetic testing + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +17 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +laboratory (Counsyl [20]) (see Methods). Points lie on the dashed blue line if the allele frequen- +cies in Counsyl and ExAC are the same. +(TIF) + +S2 Fig. Comparisons of mutation-selection balance models with constant versus changing +population sizes. (A) Population mean allele frequency as a function of effective population +size, under a model of constant population size. The X-axis range corresponds to the range of +effective population size over time estimated in [25]. The red bar indicates the value of a con- +stant population size at which the mean allele frequency is the same as in simulations, for an +average mutation rate of 1.5 x10-8 per bp per generation [34]. (B-C) The allele frequency distri- +bution (in grey) is presented for 2 x 106 simulations based on (B) the complex demographic +scenario inferred by Tennessen et al. [25] for the evolution of European populations based on +simulations (see Methods) and of (C) the finite, constant size population model, with N set to +35,651 individuals to match the mean allele frequency with (B). Both models assume complete +lethality (s = 1) and recessivity (h = 0). +(TIF) + +S3 Fig. The impact on disease allele frequencies of a small fitness effect in heterozygotes +(h = 0.01). Shown in each case is the distribution of the deleterious allele frequencies in the +population, generated from 100,000 simulations. Means are represented by red vertical bars. +For visualization, an allele frequency of q = 0 is set to 0.5 x 10−6. When a small fitness effect in +heterozygotes is considered in the simulations, the mean allele frequency decreases by 79% rel- +ative to no effect. The two distributions differ significantly by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (p- +value < 10−15). The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation, reflective of the +mean mutation rate for exons [34]. +(TIF) + +S4 Fig. Effect of varying the end population size and the average mutation rate on the sam- +ple allele frequency of recessive, lethal mutations. Tennessen et al. [25] inferred the present +effective population size of Europeans to be 512,000 individuals based on a mutation rate of +2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation. We rescaled the parameters of this model based on a lower +mutation rate estimate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] and show the expected distribution of sample allele +frequencies of recessive, lethal mutations in column A. We further considered the effect of +larger population sizes at present (2-, 4-, and 10-fold increase, denoted by columns B, C and +D respectively), keeping other rescaled demographic parameters the same as in A. We also +included a model (E) where rapid growth begins immediately after the out-of-Africa bottle- +neck, representing a more extreme scenario of population growth in comparison to the two- +stage and more gradual scenario proposed by Tennessen et al. (2012). For A-E, we drew the +mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution with parameters set as in Eq 8, with u = 1.5 x +10−8 (as implemented for Fig 2; see Methods). Model F considers a larger u (2.25 x 10−8, i.e., a +1.5-fold increase from A-E), with all other parameters (e.g., variance in mutation rates across +simulations, the demographic model) the same as in column A. The observed sample allele fre- +quency distribution of 385 disease mutations in ExAC is shown in white. Violin plots show the +density distribution of the log10 allele frequencies for variants that were segregating in these +samples, whereas boxes indicate the proportion of sites for which the deleterious mutation was +not observed segregating in the sample. All distributions differ significantly from one another +(i.e., all p-values are < 10−15 by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test). +(TIF) + +S5 Fig. Expected distribution and the observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal +disease mutations (excluding mutations in CFTR and DHCR7). As in Fig 2, the four panels + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +18 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +correspond to four different mutation types. The title of the panel indicates the mutation type, +followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type, with p-values for the difference +between observed and expected mean frequencies below. Distributions in grey are for 100,000 +observations of the expected mean sample allele frequencies across K mutations, and were +obtained from simulations based on a plausible demographic model for European populations +[25] (see Methods). Blue bars represent the observed values estimated from 33,370 individuals +of European ancestry from ExAC. As opposed to in Fig 2, here, we did not include mutations +present in two genes (CFTR and DHCR7) that were outliers in the gene-level analysis (Fig 3) +and were reported elsewhere to be carried by healthy homozygous individuals [24]. +(TIF) -8. +S6 Fig. The probability Pasc of a mutation being ascertained, given its population allele fre- +quency q, the sample size na of the putative ascertainment study and the inbreeding coeffi- +cient Fa in the population in which the ascertainment study was conducted. In each case, +we let only one parameter (q, na or Fa) vary, while fixing the others at q = 7.10 x 10−6 (corre- +sponding to the mean allele frequency from simulations), na = 10,000, and Fa = 1/16 (corre- +sponding to marriage between first cousins, a plausible scenario for a population with +widespread inbreeding). +(TIF) -9. +S7 Fig. Depth of coverage for 385 mutations in ExAC known to cause lethal, Mendelian +diseases. Box plots show the mean (black bar) and the lower and upper quartiles for (A) the +248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies in ExAC, for which the number of sequenced non- +Finnish European individuals was reported (n = 32,881) and (B) the 137 sites for which we did +not have this information. Since distributions of depth of coverage are similar between the two +sets (by a Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90), we assumed that 32,881 individuals were +sequenced at all sites, and used this number to subsample simulations to match the sample size +of the ExAC data. +(TIF) -The introduction of the internet made music piracy easier than had previously -been the case. Whilst piracy had always been a problem in the industry, the -internet made it easier to illegally copy works and share them with other -internet users on a large scale. The result was a collapse in music industry -revenues, and therefore creator revenues, as CD and other physical sales -declined. Inflation adjusted UK recorded music revenues fell by around 60% -from £1.9 billion in 2001 to £0.8 billion in 2015. +Acknowledgments -Services that allowed consumers to access digital music legally, initially -through paid downloads of songs followed by music streaming, meant that for -the first time music companies and creators could monetise their content on -digital services and stem the flow of revenue losses. Since the introduction of -streaming, adjusting the older revenue figure for inflation music revenues -have increased from £0.8 billion in 2015 to £1.1 billion in 2021, although these -revenues remain below their £1.9 billion peak in 2001. +We thank Daniel MacArthur for his help with the ExAC data, Ellen Leffler for providing her +Python script (available at https://github.com/cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease), as well as +members of the Pickrell, Przeworski and Sella labs, Aravinda Chakravarti, Brian Charlesworth, +Damien Labuda and four anonymous reviewers for helpful discussions and comments on an +earlier version of the manuscript. All codes and data to generate the figures in R [62] and the +script used to get the sequence context of each mutation are available at https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease. The code to run the simulations is available at https:// +github.com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator. Allele frequencies and other information for the dis- +ease mutations employed in the analyses are in S2 and S3 Tables. -UK inflation-adjusted recorded music revenues between 2000 and 2021 by format -type +Author Contributions -10. +Conceptualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly -Consumers have embraced legal music -streaming and today music streaming accounts -for more than 80% of music sales. Data published -by Ofcom indicates that 47% of the population -made weekly use of music streaming services in -early 2022. This has nearly doubled since 2017, -but has remained relatively stable since 2020, -indicating that it might be plateauing. Younger -people stream music the most, with 77% of 15- +Przeworski. -3 +Data curation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Zachary Baker, Jose´ Francisco Diesel, Imran S. - 11. +Haque, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -12. +Formal analysis: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao. -34-year-olds streaming music on a weekly basis compared with just 19% of -those aged 55+.1 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -Streaming has changed not only how we listen to music but what we listen to -because for the first time all music, both old and new, is readily available in -one place at no additional cost. This has created opportunities for labels, -publishers, and creators to reach new audiences who may not have heard the -music on its first release which has in turn extended the lifecycle for earning -revenue from songs. This is a benefit to those creators whose music -continues to be listened to, but this development is not necessarily good for all -creators because it means that today’s new music competes with yesterday’s -songs for a share of streaming revenue. +19 / 23 -Digitisation and new online business models continue to create new -opportunities to consume music. Today, besides new online radio stations, a -consumer may hear a piece of music in a video on TikTok, see their favourite -artist on a live stream rather than in concert, or engage with music alongside -new interactive online gaming platforms. Whilst these are different to -streaming services with full catalogues and music available on-demand, they -are new ways that consumers hear and discover music and offer potential -new sources of revenue for the music companies, artists, and songwriters. + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -The recorded music sector is concentrated, but that is not driving -the concerns raised by artists +Funding acquisition: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -13. +Investigation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -14. +Methodology: Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -Our analysis shows that more creators than ever are releasing music, -doubling from 200,000 in 2014 to 400,000 in 2020. This is, in part, made -possible by innovations in technology and the ability to easily distribute music -online. For example, it is now easier than ever to create and record music -outside the confines of a traditional music studio and share it on streaming -services without the need for a record label. +Project administration: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -It has long been the case in recorded music that only a very small minority of -artists will achieve the highest level of success. In 2020 over 60% of streams -were of music recorded by only the top 0.4% of artists. To reach the top of the -chart, songs need to be streamed many millions of times each day and many -artists are faced with a situation where their work can be streamed millions of -times, but it does not translate into a significant share of their income. For -example, twelve million streams a year could earn an artist around £12,000, -but less than 1% of artists achieve that number of streams. We have heard +Resources: Imran S. Haque, Molly Przeworski. -1 Data published by Ofcom (2022), Media Nations: UK 2022. +Software: Yuval B. Simons. -4 +Supervision: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. - from both artists and songwriters that they are unable to make a sustainable -income from music streaming and for many it feels unfair. +Validation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -15. We have considered what may be causing these outcomes for artists2 and, in +Visualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim. -line with our statutory duties, whether these outcomes are being caused by -competition issues in the market. +Writing – original draft: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -16. +Writing – review & editing: Yuval B. Simons, Imran S. Haque, Joseph Pickrell. -The recorded music sector is concentrated, with the 3 major labels holding a -combined share of over 70% of UK streams, and this has persisted for some -time. The market share in terms of streams of independent record companies -(indies) has remained steady at around one quarter for several years. This -share is very fragmented with only 2 indies having a share in excess of 1%. +References +1. Simons YB, Turchin MC, Pritchard JK, Sella G (2014) The deleterious mutation load is insensitive to +recent population history. Nat Genet 46: 220–224. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.2896 PMID: 24509481 -Label shares of total UK streams in 2021 +2. Simons YB, Sella G (2016) The impact of recent population history on the deleterious mutation load in +humans and close evolutionary relatives. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 150–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. +gde.2016.09.006 PMID: 27744216 -Source: CMA analysis of data from Official Charts.3 +3. Nei M (1968) The frequency distribution of lethal chromosomes in finite populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci -2 As described in Chapter 5 of this report, a number of our findings on artists will also relate to songwriters. -Issues specific to songwriters are considered in more detail below. -3 Notes: This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. These figures are provided in a 5% range where the figure -is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the ranges have -been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints does not -equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of the -midpoints. +U S A 60: 517–524. PMID: 5248809 -5 +4. Gillespie JH (2004) Population Genetics: A Concise Guide. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University - 17. +Press. -The scale of the majors and their global reach means they can offer large -advances which attracts proven and successful artists. In turn, this can make -it difficult for indie labels to attract and retain artists as they become -successful, which can create a barrier to expansion for indie labels. +5. Brandvain Y, Wright SI (2016) The Limits of Natural Selection in a Nonequilibrium World. Trends Genet -18. Despite the concentrated nature of the market, outcomes for artists as a +32: 201–210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tig.2016.01.004 PMID: 26874998 -whole seem to be improving. We accept that this improvement may not be -benefiting all artists, and that for many artists the improvement will seem -insufficient. +6. Balick DJ, Do R, Cassa CA, Reich D, Sunyaev SR (2015) Dominance of Deleterious Alleles Controls -19. Our analysis shows that in some respects the options available to artists, +the Response to a Population Bottleneck. PLoS Genet 11: e1005436. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1005436 PMID: 26317225 -particularly new artists, are improving: +7. Beauchamp KA, Muzzey D, Wong KK, Hogan GJ, Karimi K, et al. (2017) Systematic Design and Com- -(a) There is now more choice for artists about which type of deal they would -like to agree, from DIY distribution, A&L services, or more traditional -record deals. +parison of Expanded Carrier Screening Panels. Genet Med—ePub ahead of print -(b) Some new artists have greater leverage when negotiating a record deal +8. Clark AG (1998) Mutation-selection balance with multiple alleles. Genetica 102–103: 41–47. PMID: -with a label if they have already built a strong fanbase and online -presence. +9720270 -Average UK artist yearly streaming earnings from majors and average -(mean) royalty rates (2021 prices) in the UK +9. Crow JF, Kimura M (1970) Introduction to Population Genetics Theory New York: Harper & Row Pub- -Source: CMA analysis of data from the majors +lishers. 591 p. -20. Analysis of new contracts signed by the majors with new artists for multi-track +10. Cormet-Boyaka E, Jablonsky M, Naren AP, Jackson PL, Muccio DD, et al. (2004) Rescuing cystic fibro- +sis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)-processing mutants by transcomplementation. Proc +Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 8221–8226. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0400459101 PMID: 15141088 -deals (ie albums or extended play (EP) records) shows that, between 2012 -and 2021: +11. Rapino D, Sabirzhanova I, Lopes-Pacheco M, Grover R, Guggino WB, et al. (2015) Rescue of NBD2 -(a) the average gross royalty rate has increased from 19.7% to 23.3%; +mutants N1303K and S1235R of CFTR by small-molecule correctors and transcomplementation. PLoS +One 10: e0119796. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0119796 PMID: 25799511 -6 +12. Andressoo JO, Jans J, de Wit J, Coin F, Hoogstraten D, et al. (2006) Rescue of progeria in trichothiody- +strophy by homozygous lethal Xpd alleles. PLoS Biol 4: e322. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio. +0040322 PMID: 17020410 - (b) the proportion of contracts where labels own copyright of recordings in +13. Gallati S (2014) Disease-modifying genes and monogenic disorders: experience in cystic fibrosis. Appl -perpetuity has reduced from 66% to 26.4%; and +Clin Genet 7: 133–146. https://doi.org/10.2147/TACG.S18675 PMID: 25053892 -(c) the average number of minimum commitment periods (where a period is -defined by a commitment to produce a multi-track output such as an -album) has fallen from 3.8 to 3.4 +14. Corvol H, Blackman SM, Boelle PY, Gallins PJ, Pace RG, et al. (2015) Genome-wide association meta- +analysis identifies five modifier loci of lung disease severity in cystic fibrosis. Nat Commun 6: 8382. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms9382 PMID: 26417704 -21. Competition appears to be particularly focused on artists who are already +15. Habara A, Steinberg MH (2016) Minireview: Genetic basis of heterogeneity and severity in sickle cell -popular or are likely to be. Competition to sign such artists can be very -intense with offers from many labels. Traditional record deals also face -increasing disruption from alternative models, in particular service deals from -artist and label (A&L) service providers, and there are more options than ever -for artists to reach audiences and monetise their work. +disease. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 241: 689–696. -22. We think that outcomes for artists are driven by factors which are largely +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -unrelated to competition issues in the market. Rather, we think these -outcomes can be attributed to factors more inherent to how music streaming -works. Digitisation has allowed for a huge increase in the number of artists -sharing their music and a vast back catalogue made available via streaming -so there is more music available to stream and consumer tastes tend to tip -towards a relativity small number of artists being successful. In addition, there -is very significant uncertainty about which artists will be successful. The -combination of these market features is likely to result in competition focused -on a relatively limited number of artists and market outcomes where the -majority of the benefits are accrued by a minority of artists. +20 / 23 -23. We therefore conclude that a competition intervention, for example a change + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -to the structure of the market, is unlikely to result in a material increase in -revenues for artists. +16. Hedrick PW (2011) Population genetics of malaria resistance in humans. Heredity (Edinb) 107: 283– -24. Whilst majors’ profits have been increasing since the lows of piracy, our -profitability analysis has not found evidence of substantial and sustained -excess profits by the majors. This is consistent with our overall finding that +304. https://doi.org/10.1038/hdy.2011.16 PMID: 21427751 -4 As these are only averages across all 3 majors, they do not show how the terms can vary significantly between -artists, reflecting for example the different potential financial rewards and risks based on the characteristics of -individual artists (including by genre, potential, and stage of career). +17. Chong JX, Buckingham KJ, Jhangiani SN, Boehm C, Sobreira N, et al. (2015) The Genetic Basis of -7 +Mendelian Phenotypes: Discoveries, Challenges, and Opportunities. Am J Hum Genet 97: 199–215. +https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.06.009 PMID: 26166479 - there is unlikely to be scope to improve outcomes for artists substantially -through increased competition. +18. Kong A, Frigge ML, Masson G, Besenbacher S, Sulem P, et al. (2012) Rate of de novo mutations and -25. We understand that Government has taken several steps to address concerns +the importance of father’s age to disease risk. Nature 488: 471–475. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11396 PMID: 22914163 -about creator remuneration and has responded to the DCMS Select -Committee recommendations for legislative and policy reform in this area. In -particular, the IPO is conducting a research programme including examining -potential options to strengthen creator rights and remuneration. We are -sharing our final findings with the IPO and DCMS to help inform their work. +19. -Labels could do more to improve the information they provide to -artists +Turner TN, Douville C, Kim D, Stenson PD, Cooper DN, et al. (2015) Proteins linked to autosomal domi- +nant and autosomal recessive disorders harbor characteristic rare missense mutation distribution pat- +terns. Hum Mol Genet 24: 5995–6002. https://doi.org/10.1093/hmg/ddv309 PMID: 26246501 -26. We heard strong concern from some artists and their representatives that they +20. Haque IS, Lazarin GA, Kang H, Evans EA, Goldberg JD, et al. (2016) Modeled fetal risk of genetic dis- -do not get enough information from record labels on how their earnings from -streaming services are calculated or how the deals that exist between labels -and streaming services may affect what they earn or could earn in future. -Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) between music streaming services and -labels were cited as a barrier to improving information provision to artists. +eases identified by expanded carrier screening. JAMA 316: 734–742. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama. +2016.11139 PMID: 27533158 -27. Our analysis shows that some artists are provided with information, such as +21. Cooper DN, Youssoufian H (1988) The CpG dinucleotide and human genetic disease. Hum Genet 78: -number of streams and the royalties earnt on these streams, which tells them -how much they have earned per stream on music streaming services, and we -saw some positive examples of labels presenting this information in a user- -friendly way. However, this was not consistent across all labels, and we think -best practices could be developed so that information could be presented in a -more straightforward and uniform way with appropriate guidance on how to -interpret the data. This will help artists better understand how they are paid for -streaming and the sources of their income. +151–155. PMID: 3338800 -28. +22. Akalin N, Zietkiewicz E, Makalowski W, Labuda D (1994) Are CpG sites mutation hot spots in the dystro- -In respect of NDAs, whilst they do prevent certain terms and conditions being -made available to artists and limit access to the ‘source data’ from the music -streaming services, they do not appear to prevent a significant amount of -relevant information being made available to artists about their earnings. By -limiting the access to source data, the NDAs may potentially limit the ability of -artists to verify the accuracy of information. However, this is an issue more to -do with verification of the fulfilment of contractual terms rather than one of -competition to sign artists. +phin gene? Hum Mol Genet 3. -29. We welcome the work the IPO is undertaking on issues -around transparency for artists, including developing a -code of practice. +23. -8 +Lek M, Karczewski KJ, Minikel EV, Samocha KE, Banks E, et al. (2016) Analysis of protein-coding +genetic variation in 60,706 humans. Nature 536: 285–291. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature19057 PMID: +27535533 - Publishing revenues from streaming in the UK have grown -significantly, but many songwriters argue they are not paid enough -to make a sustainable income +24. Chen R, Shi L, Hakenberg J, Naughton B, Sklar P, et al. (2016) Analysis of 589,306 genomes identifies -30. Each song has two sets of music rights: (1) rights in the underlying song or -‘publishing rights’ which includes the music and lyrics; and (2) rights in the -particular recording of that song, the ‘recording rights’. Without permission to -use both rights, a streaming service cannot legally stream the song. +individuals resilient to severe Mendelian childhood diseases. Nat Biotechnol 34: 531–538. https://doi. +org/10.1038/nbt.3514 PMID: 27065010 + +25. + +Tennessen JA, Bigham AW, O’Connor TD, Fu W, Kenny EE, et al. (2012) Evolution and functional +impact of rare coding variation from deep sequencing of human exomes. Science 337: 64–69. https:// +doi.org/10.1126/science.1219240 PMID: 22604720 + +26. Wright S (1937) The Distribution of Gene Frequencies in Populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 23: + +307–320. PMID: 16577780 + +27. Harpak A, Bhaskar A, Pritchard JK (2016) Mutation Rate Variation is a Primary Determinant of the Dis- +tribution of Allele Frequencies in Humans. PLoS Genet 12: e1006489. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1006489 PMID: 27977673 + +28. Browning Sharon R, Browning Brian L (2015) Accurate Non-parametric Estimation of Recent Effective +Population Size from Segments of Identity by Descent. The American Journal of Human Genetics 97: +404–418. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.07.012 PMID: 26299365 + +29. Reich DE, Lander ES (2001) On the allelic spectrum of human disease. Trends Genet 17: 502–510. + +PMID: 11525833 + +30. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- + +mon variant. . .or not? Hum Mol Genet 11: 2417–2423. PMID: 12351577 31. -Throughout the study we have heard consistently from groups that represent -songwriters that the publishing right of a song is systematically undervalued -when compared to the recording right. In turn, they argue that this means that -songwriters receive less in royalties for their work and do not make a -sustainable income from streaming. Whilst some songwriters are also -themselves artists and may have access to revenues from recording rights -and other sources of income, that is not always the case. - -32. Songwriters and their representatives have suggested that the undervaluation -of publishing rights is because the majors have market power and interests in -both publishing and recording rights and that it is financially advantageous for -them to suppress publishing revenues in favour of the recording side of their -business, possibly through tacit collusion. We have also heard concerns that -the majors may have the ability and incentive to influence industry outcomes -via their membership of collecting societies (CMOs) who have a role in -negotiating royalties for the use of their members’ publishing rights. - -33. We have examined evidence on the allocation of music streaming revenues, - -and it indicates that: - -(a) The share of revenues going to publishers (publishing share) increased - -from 8% in 2008 to approximately 12% in 2012. Since then it has -increased to 15% in 2021. This is a significant increase across the period. -In contrast, the share of revenues going to record companies in 2021 is at -a broadly similar level to what it was in 2008. - -(b) For the majors, the growth in publishing revenues - -has far exceeded the growth in recording revenues. - -(c) Majors’ growth in publishing revenues is 244% since -2017, which is significantly above the [110-120]% -average across the publishing sector over the same -period. - -9 - - Split in music streaming revenues in 2008 and 2021 - -34. - -Source: Section 4.2.2 of research commissioned by the IPO Music Creators Earnings, the Digital Era, -and On-Demand Streaming Revenues and CMA analysis of data from Apple, Amazon and Spotify.5 - -This evidence is inconsistent with the argument that the majors have tacitly -colluded to suppress the publishing share or that there is otherwise -particularly weak competition to sign songwriters that is leading to a split in -the allocation of music streaming revenues that favours recording rights over -publishing rights. The majors having both a recording and a publishing -business is also not necessarily problematic. For instance, if the majors did -not have a publishing business they might have a stronger incentive to block -increases in the ‘publishing share’ by refusing to accommodate such an -increase through reducing the recording share since any losses to their -recording revenues which occurred would not be mitigated by gains to their -publishing revenues. - -35. We also have not seen clear evidence that CMOs are failing to push for better -terms owing to the majors’ influence or that CMO governance procedures and -processes are failing to mitigate any potential bias in their decision making. If -such regulatory concerns do exist, the proper body to examine them is the -IPO, which has responsibility for monitoring the conduct of CMOs under the -Collective Management of Copyright (EU Directive) Regulations 2016.6 - -5 Note: Whilst the CMA analysis for 2021 is based on data from the largest music streaming services, the IPO -research draws on a range of largely qualitative evidence and therefore (as the IPO research itself -acknowledges) the IPO research estimate of the split of revenues for 2008 is only indicative. Therefore, -comparison between the split between 2008 and 2021 should be treated with caution and taken to be indicative -of the overall trend in the split over time rather than estimates of the exact quantum of change in the split. -6 The conduct of UK CMOs (including the PRS) is governed by the CRM Regulations. The CRM Regulations -designate a National Competent Authority (NCA) which is responsible for monitoring and enforcing compliance - -10 - - 36. Songwriters are concerned that the initial split between publishing and - -recording revenues adopted when streaming began was unfair and -unjustified, for example because it did not reflect the alleged lower costs of -record companies under streaming compared to physical distribution. The -increase in the publishing share is consistent with this concern over the initial -split and there being a subsequent period of market-correction, which may not -yet have fully played out. However, the fact that publishing revenues are -increasing at a greater rate compared to recording revenues, in particular for -the majors, suggests that publishing revenues are not being actively -suppressed because of a distortion or restriction of competition. - -37. We have found that there are inherent difficulties in securing increases to the - -publishing share and, consequently, increasing the amount songwriters are -paid. This difficulty may arise from the fact that music streaming services, -labels and publishers must all reach agreement to change how streaming -revenues are divided. However, they may all have different incentives and so -they may not agree – we call this a ‘licensing negotiation friction’. We think -that agreement between the parties may be particularly challenging when an -increase in the publishing share would necessitate a fall in the share that goes -to record companies due to the strong bargaining position of music -rightsholders, which arises from the need for music streaming services to get -agreement from all key rightsholders to offer a wide range of music. - -38. - -The long-term increase in the publishing share since 2008 has been -accommodated by a fall in the share taken by music streaming services. The -risk is that we may reach a point, or could do soon, where further substantial -increases in the publishing share can only be accommodated by a fall in the -recording share, which labels would be in a strong bargaining position to -resist. - -39. Whilst we think that competition for songwriters has driven up the existing - -publishing share, concerns exist that the current split could still be sub- -optimal, particularly for songwriters. If that is the case, we think that it may -take time for the split to adjust further, if at all, owing to the inherent licensing -negotiation frictions and bargaining power of music rightsholders we have -described. There is also a limit on the extent to which competition to sign -songwriters can drive further increases in the publishing share, particularly if -an increase needs to be accommodated by a fall in the recording share. -Competition policy is not therefore the right tool to reach an optimal split. We -think it is a matter for Government and policymakers to determine whether the - -with the Regulations’ provisions. The NCA functions in the UK are undertaken through the IPO, which has -published guidance on these regulations (see IPO (2021), Guidance on the Collective Management of Copyright -(EU Directive) Regulations 2016). - -11 - - split is appropriate and fair, and to explore what is needed to incentivise song -writing as part of wider policy interventions on this split and other measures, -for example those relating to the copyright framework and how music -streaming licensing rates are set. - -The legal arrangements between major labels and music streaming -services are complex but they do not appear to be significantly -hampering competition and innovation - -40. Major labels rely on music streaming services to distribute their music, - -and streaming services cannot meet consumers’ needs without obtaining -licences to the large catalogue of each major record label and publisher. -Accordingly, music streaming services must negotiate deals with labels -and publishers to access music content. These deals can be exceedingly -complex and will cover financials and other terms. Our market study -uncovered a number of clauses that could plausibly raise competition -concerns. For example a number of agreements contained non- -discrimination clauses which act to prevent the music streaming service -from favouring music content based on price, for example, by giving -more prominence to cheaper music. - -41. However, given the current ‘full catalogue’ business model of music streaming - -– consumers expect to access every major’s repertoire on each streaming -service – there is no credible alternative to each major’s catalogue. Taking -this into account, our view is that the nature of competition between record -companies to supply music to music streaming services is weak but would -remain weak even absent the combined effect of the contractual clauses we -identified as being potentially problematic. Whilst a slight strengthening of -competition might result from the removal of these clauses (individually or in -combination), it is not clear any improvement would be more than marginal. - -42. - -Innovation is intrinsic to a healthy, competitive market and we therefore take -seriously any suggestion that innovation has been hindered. We have -therefore also assessed the impact of contractual clauses on how music -services compete with each other in terms of innovation. To introduce -innovations or changes to services, the music streaming services typically -need to agree with the majors to amend existing contracts, which we heard -can be a long process which may slow the pace of innovation. - -43. We found examples of substantial innovation by music streaming services, -both in terms of the services, such as the introduction of high-quality audio, -and in the price plans available. But we were also given a few examples of -innovations that were slow to market because of the complex negotiations - -12 - - needed to secure licensing agreements. There is a risk that contractual -restrictions may contribute to the slower development of such innovations -than might otherwise be expected or, potentially, preclude innovation -altogether. - -44. While potential competition concerns have been raised with us about the - -effect of agreements between the majors and music streaming services, we -are not persuaded that changing the contractual clauses would significantly -increase innovation. Rather, the problem appears to relate to the need for -music streaming services to agree with multiple rightsholders on what terms -(financial or otherwise) they can use their content, including in new and -innovative ways. It is the sheer volume and complexity of these negotiations -that appear to be the main barrier to even greater innovation. However, these -negotiations appear to be an inherent part of the licensing process – with the -financial terms negotiated depending on the features agreed. - -Competition between music streaming services is currently -delivering good outcomes for consumers, but concerns may arise -in future - -45. - -The music streaming services market is concentrated with a few larger -streaming services such as Spotify, Apple, Amazon, and YouTube (which is -part of Google), alongside a range of other smaller providers. Spotify has the -largest number of monthly active users by some distance, as shown in the -graph below. Music streaming services are popular with consumers and have -grown rapidly – between 2019 and 2021 the number of monthly active users -of music streaming services increased from 32 million to 39 million. Despite -the strong presence of large, well-known firms in the market, and the number -of active users increasing, music streaming services are not making -sustained, excess profits: indeed, our analysis has shown that many services -have low or negative operating margins. - -13 - - Share of UK Monthly Active Users by music streaming service in -December 2021, excluding YouTube’s UUC platform - -Source: CMA analysis of data from music streaming services.7 - -46. We have heard consistently that consumers demand access to a full - -catalogue of music. The result is that the main music streaming services -effectively offer the same music content to consumers. Competition between -the services, therefore, anchors around offering the best experience to -consumers through good design, personalised playlists, and high-quality -audio content, as well as through pricing plans. These services also now -compete with one another by offering non-music content, such as podcasts. - -47. - -For consumers, the monthly price of music -streaming services is either free (ad-funded) or -falling in real terms because the price of -individual subscriptions has remained stable and -not kept pace with inflation. Most services offer a -range of price plans, including family and student -plans, as well as free ad-funded tiers. Streaming -services are also frequently bundled with other - -7 This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. Monthly Active User shares only account for Spotify, YouTube -Music, Apple, Amazon, Deezer, Soundcloud and Tidal which have a combined streaming share of over 99% -according to CMA analysis of data provided by Official Charts. YouTube Music users include YouTube Music -premium Monthly Active Viewers and YouTube Music ad-funded Daily Active Viewers, meaning this figure will -provide an underestimation of YouTube Music’s actual users. These figures are provided in a 5% range where -the figure is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the -ranges have been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints -does not equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of -the midpoints. - -14 - - services, such as mobile phone subscriptions, and accessed via a range of -devices, including smart speakers. - -48. Recorded music is now also costing consumers less overall compared to - -when CDs and other physical formats were more popular, as indicated by UK -recorded music revenues falling by around 40% from £1.9 billion in 2001 to -£1.1 billion in 2021 in real terms. - -49. - -In a market that is expanding, music streaming services mainly compete for -new consumers, rather than encouraging existing customers to switch to their -streaming services. However, music streaming services with ad-funded plans -do actively seek to get customers to upgrade to a paid-for service. - -50. Our analysis shows that consumers cancel their service at above 4% a month -for the major streaming services. Cancellation might occur because free trials -are coming to an end, the user is switching to another service, or because the -user is no longer using any streaming service. The current data on why -consumers may cancel their services is limited, but it suggests that the most -cited reasons are consumers not being able to afford the service or not using -it enough.8 - -51. Switching between music streaming services might be challenging if - -consumers are concerned that they will lose access to their favourite playlists. -There are some nascent music data portability services that support -switching, but demand for them is currently low. Low switching rates are not -necessarily a dynamic that causes immediate concern - for example, in a -growing market. However, as the number of new premium users to compete -for declines in future, there is a risk that prices for music streaming services -will rise significantly for consumers or there may be a deterioration in the -quality of services, if there isn’t a significant threat of switching. Therefore, as -the market reaches maturity we would be concerned if we did not see more -vigorous competition between streaming services (eg through enhanced -efforts to make it seamless for consumers to switch and port their playlists or -musical preferences). Higher rates of switching would imply consumers -exercising choice (and hence competition), although the lack of switching by -itself is not conclusive evidence of a lack of competition. - -52. With more music available, tools that help consumers - -discover new music are more important. Streaming services -compete in bringing music to consumers’ attention and -promoting new artists and songs. We have found that while - -8 This should be treated with caution, however, as only a small proportion of users who cancel respond to the -cancellation survey used to collect this data. - -15 - - the majority of tracks listed on the top new music discovery playlists are -licensed by the majors, the proportion is lower than the majors’ combined -share of total streams. This suggests that artists that are not signed to a major -do have reasonable opportunities to reach new listeners via discovery -playlists and more generally the streaming services have told us that they -design their music recommendation systems with a focus on listener -engagement and user satisfaction. - -53. Overall, whilst music streaming services are currently delivering good - -outcomes for consumers, it is imperative for a sustainable and vibrant market -that services can effectively compete with one another, and we would have -concerns in future if we saw a reduction in competition – for example, if -majors sought commitments from streaming platforms to exclude competitors -(large or small) from discovery or search elements of their service. - -There is a ‘value gap’ between what YouTube and other music -streaming providers pay to rightsholders but it currently amounts -to less than 0.5% of UK recorded music revenues - -54. UUC platforms allow consumers to access music content uploaded by users, - -artists and labels for free (but often with ads), in some cases coupled with -other content such as entertainment videos. These services differ from music -streaming services because any user can upload content, which may include -copyrighted material which they may or may not have permission to share. -Sometimes this content can appear on these platforms before a licence has -been agreed with rightsholders. - -55. UUC platforms have some protection in law through a ‘safe harbour’ provision -which limits the liability they have for hosting illegal content uploaded by users -in some circumstances. However, once they become aware that content is -available without permission from rightsholders, they must remove it or, as is - -16 - - more often the case, allow the rightsholder to grant permission and monetise -the content, for example by sharing ad revenues. - -56. A range of music companies, artists and songwriters have been concerned - -that the asymmetry in the legal regime may result in a loss of revenues (often -called the ‘value gap’) for the music industry. In particular, there is concern -that the safe harbour provisions give UUC platforms greater bargaining power -over rightsholders, leading to rightsholders having to agree worse terms than -they would otherwise. - -57. - -To understand whether a value gap exists and, if so, how significant the gap -is, we have compared the amount that YouTube, as the largest UUC platform, -pays out to rightsholders in comparison to Spotify’s ad-funded service. In -2017, YouTube’s ‘value gap’ in the UK – that is how much more it would have -paid to rightsholders as a proportion of revenue from music content if it had -paid them at the same rate as Spotify’s ad-funded service – was over 20 -percentage points. However, this ‘gap’ has closed over time and in 2021 had -fallen to significantly less than 5 percentage points, or less than £5 million. To -put this figure into context, it is less than 0.5% of the £1,115 million total UK -recorded music revenues in 2021. The evidence therefore suggests that the -extent of YouTube’s ‘value gap’ has decreased in recent years. - -58. Whilst YouTube is the largest UUC service and therefore very important in the -market, there are other UUC platforms that take a different approach to -licensing and may have less effective content management systems. - -59. Some newer UUC platforms incorporate music into their offering, but do not -offer a full streaming service. Examples of this include TikTok, a short-form -video-sharing service, and Twitch, a longer-form live streaming service. These -platforms, alongside YouTube, provide innovative services for consumers and -potential opportunities for creators and music companies to earn further -revenues in addition to those generated by music streaming. - -60. - -The way these services use music differs from traditional music streaming -services: they may use snippets of recordings or only offer specific genres of -music, rather than a full catalogue on an on-demand basis. Therefore, it may -not always be the case that the rates payable for these services will be -comparable to music streaming services, which is an important factor when -assessing if there is a ‘value gap’ between the two offerings. That said, we -have heard examples of refusal to license or difficulties in agreeing licences -that may indicate that safe harbour is among the factors in some commercial -negotiations. We also consider that the quality of content management -systems is important in ensuring that rightsholders are remunerated fairly for -music content uploaded onto UUC platforms, and we have heard some newer - -17 - - emerging platforms may lag behind the more established platforms in this -regard. - -61. Meanwhile, since the exit of the UK from the EU, European legislation - -relevant to UUC has been amended such that it now requires UUC services -using copyrighted content to make their ‘best efforts’ to seek permission to -use that content. We note that the DCMS and IPO are monitoring the practical -impact of these legislative changes on UUC services in the UK. We -encourage them to take account of our broader findings in relation to UUC -services when considering if legislative changes are required in the UK. - -The market is evolving and innovating, but it is vital that it -continues to deliver good outcomes for consumers - -62. - -The music streaming market is changing rapidly, and further technological -advances in the years to come may spark further changes to the way we -listen to music. Our analysis shows that the market is on balance delivering -good outcomes for consumers. However, we would have concerns and may -intervene in the future if aspects of the market change in ways that harm -consumers’ interests. For example, factors that may give rise to concerns -could include: - -(a) if future mergers or acquisitions affect the bargaining power of either - -music companies or music streaming services, which may in turn lead to -worse outcomes for consumers with the CMA likely to pay particularly -close attention to any such merger activity and to investigate whether it -could lead to a substantial lessening of competition. - -(b) shifts in the way consumers access streaming services that influence their - -listening behaviour, for example if there is continued growth in the use of -smart speakers, and whether this could exacerbate barriers to expansion -of streaming services that do not have their own smart speaker -ecosystem. - -(c) greater use of playlists, autoplay and recommendations for music - -discovery and consumption could be a cause of uncertainty and concern -for consumers and artists if their operation, including any underlying -algorithms, is not fair and transparent. - -(d) how difficult it is to switch between music streaming services and whether -this limits the strength of competition between those services when the -market is no longer growing. - -(e) if the level of innovation on the part of streaming services were to - -decrease; or if innovations that would benefit consumers were to be -prohibited by music companies; or if consumers were to be -disadvantaged in other ways, including through significantly higher prices. - -18 +Zwick ME, Cutler DJ, Chakravarti A (2000) Patterns of genetic variation in Mendelian and complex +traits. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 1: 387–407. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.genom.1.1.387 +PMID: 11701635 + +32. Cassa CA, Weghorn D, Balick DJ, Jordan DM, Nusinow D, et al. (2017) Estimating the Selective Effect +of Heterozygous Protein Truncating Variants from Human Exome Data. Nat Genet 49: 806–810. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.3831 PMID: 28369035 + +33. + +The Thousand Genomes Consortium (2015) A global reference for human genetic variation. Nature +526: 68–74. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature15393 PMID: 26432245 + +34. Neale BM, Kou Y, Liu L, Ma/’ayan A, Samocha KE, et al. (2012) Patterns and rates of exonic de novo +mutations in autism spectrum disorders. Nature 485: 242–245. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11011 +PMID: 22495311 + +35. + +Fu W, O’Connor T, Jun G, Kang H, Abecasis G, et al. (2013) Analysis of 6,515 exomes reveals the +recent origin of most human protein-coding variants. Nature 493: 216–220. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11690 PMID: 23201682 + +36. Segurel L, Wyman MJ, Przeworski M (2014) Determinants of mutation rate variation in the human germ- +line. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 15: 47–70. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-genom-031714- +125740 PMID: 25000986 + +37. + +Lohmueller KE, Indap AR, Schmidt S, Boyko AR, Hernandez RD, et al. (2008) Proportionally more dele- +terious genetic variation in European than in African populations. Nature 451: 994–997. https://doi.org/ +10.1038/nature06611 PMID: 18288194 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +21 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +38. Peischl S, Dupanloup I, Bosshard L, Excoffier L (2016) Genetic surfing in human populations: from + +genes to genomes. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 53–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.08.003 PMID: +27584859 + +39. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- + +mon variant. . .or not? PMID: 12351577 + +40. Aggarwala V, Voight BF (2016) An expanded sequence context model broadly explains variability in + +polymorphism levels across the human genome. Nat Genet 48: 349–355. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng. +3511 PMID: 26878723 + +41. Hodgkinson A, Eyre-Walker A Variation in the mutation rate across mammalian genomes. Nat Rev + +Genet 12: 756–766. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg3098 PMID: 21969038 + +42. Moorjani P, Amorim CE, Arndt PF, Przeworski M (2016) Variation in the molecular clock of primates. +Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 113: 10607–10612. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1600374113 PMID: +27601674 + +43. Kamphans T, Sabri P, Zhu N, Heinrich V, Mundlos S, et al. (2013) Filtering for compound heterozygous + +sequence variants in non-consanguineous pedigrees. PLoS One 8: e70151. https://doi.org/10.1371/ +journal.pone.0070151 PMID: 23940540 + +44. Burkhart BD, Montgomery E, Langley CH, Voelker RA (1984) Characterization of Allozyme Null and + +Low Activity Alleles from Two Natural Populations of DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER. Genetics 107: +295–306. PMID: 17246217 + +45. Xue Y, Chen Y, Ayub Q, Huang N, Ball EV, et al. (2012) Deleterious- and disease-allele prevalence in +healthy individuals: insights from current predictions, mutation databases, and population-scale rese- +quencing. Am J Hum Genet 91: 1022–1032. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2012.10.015 PMID: +23217326 + +46. Piton A, Redin C, Mandel JL (2013) XLID-causing mutations and associated genes challenged in light +of data from large-scale human exome sequencing. Am J Hum Genet 93: 368–383. https://doi.org/10. +1016/j.ajhg.2013.06.013 PMID: 23871722 + +47. Gazave E, Ma L, Chang D, Coventry A, Gao F, et al. (2014) Neutral genomic regions refine models of + +recent rapid human population growth. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 111: 757–762. https://doi.org/10. +1073/pnas.1310398110 PMID: 24379384 + +48. Gao F, Keinan A (2016) Explosive genetic evidence for explosive human population growth. Curr Opin + +Genet Dev 41: 130–139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.09.002 PMID: 27710906 + +49. Wright S (1931) Evolution in Mendelian populations. Genetics 16: 97–159. PMID: 17246615 + +50. Ober C, Hyslop T, Hauck WW (1999) Inbreeding Effects on Fertility in Humans: Evidence for Reproduc- + +tive Compensation. The American Journal of Human Genetics 64: 225–231. https://doi.org/10.1086/ +302198 PMID: 9915962 + +51. Gabriel SE, Brigman KN, Koller BH, Boucher RC, Stutts MJ (1994) Cystic fibrosis heterozygote resis- +tance to cholera toxin in the cystic fibrosis mouse model. Science 266: 107–109. PMID: 7524148 + +52. Wagener D, Cavalli-Sforza LL, Barakat R (1978) Ethnic variation of genetic disease: roles of drift for + +recessive lethal genes. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 262–270. PMID: 677123 + +53. Quinton PM (1994) Human genetics. What is good about cystic fibrosis? Curr Biol 4: 742–743. PMID: + +7525005 + +54. Chakravarti A, Chakraborty R (1978) Elevated frequency of Tay-Sachs disease among Ashkenazic + +Jews unlikely by genetic drift alone. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 256–261. PMID: 677122 + +55. Ewens WJ (1978) Tay-Sachs disease and theoretical population genetics. American Journal of Human + +Genetics 30: 328–329. PMID: 677129 + +56. + +Landrum MJ, Lee JM, Riley GR, Jang W, Rubinstein WS, et al. (2014) ClinVar: public archive of rela- +tionships among sequence variation and human phenotype. Nucleic acids research 42: D980–D985. +https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkt1113 PMID: 24234437 + +57. Eppig JT, Blake JA, Bult CJ, Kadin JA, Richardson JE (2015) The Mouse Genome Database (MGD): + +facilitating mouse as a model for human biology and disease. Nucleic Acids Res 43: D726–736. https:// +doi.org/10.1093/nar/gku967 PMID: 25348401 + +58. Gravel S, Henn BM, Gutenkunst RN, Indap AR, Marth GT, et al. (2011) Demographic history and rare + +allele sharing among human populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 108: 11983–11988. https://doi.org/ +10.1073/pnas.1019276108 PMID: 21730125 + +59. Mugal CF, Ellegren H (2011) Substitution rate variation at human CpG sites correlates with non-CpG + +divergence, methylation level and GC content. Genome Biol 12: R58. https://doi.org/10.1186/gb-2011- +12-6-r58 PMID: 21696599 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +22 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +60. North BV, Curtis D, Sham PC (2002) A Note on the Calculation of Empirical Values from Monte Carlo +Procedures. The American Journal of Human Genetics 71: 439–441. https://doi.org/10.1086/341527 +PMID: 12111669 + +61. Quinlan AR, Hall IM (2010) BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic features. Bioin- + +formatics 26: 841–842. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btq033 PMID: 20110278 + +62. R Core Team (2015) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria. + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +23 / 23 diff --git a/q227/random_k4/question.json b/q227/random_k4/question.json index b4f6b535c77aea6ef7fd069254e2c4a0dd7cd693..98fdbed9e3178d859e1e74ec626e65d49d7a180d 100644 --- a/q227/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q227/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NETFLIX_2015_10K.pdf", - "web_f7c8a4fb24ac7362.pdf", - "web_8f3d7e741a1d660a.pdf", - "web_830d0aa2115caf34.pdf", - "eb30c70c153e1dbc5a0ea9bd5a306750a2b4ebf7.pdf" + "resize_r2_6.pdf", + "web_4635faf220a9b852.pdf", + "web_2c0d954cf4efd312.pdf", + "5349694f4eecdd46092594856d170286c4d2fc94.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q227/random_k4/random_1.md b/q227/random_k4/random_1.md index 2a08a5d152b0c9f673b119f3b536a79719deb932..b8b427adc83703ef22c6ae3416c90497206054cb 100644 --- a/q227/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q227/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,524 +1,1096 @@ -Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources +State Historic Preservation Office +David L. S. Brook, Administrator -TO OUR SHAREHOLDERS +Michael F. Easley, Governor +Lisbeth C. Evans, Secretary +Jeffrey J. Crow, Deputy Secretary -05 +June 18, 2003 -09 +MEMORANDUM -CEO Letter +Division of Historical Resources +David J. Olson, Director -Report by the Supervisory Board +TO: -4 +Greg Thorpe, Manager +Project Development and Environmental Analysis Branch +NCDOT Division of Highways - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +FROM: (cid:9) -CEO-LETTER +David Brook -↗ BJØRN GULDEN +SUBJECT: (cid:9) -CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER PUMA +Historic Architectural Resources Survey Report, Replacement of +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek, B-4015, Ashe County, +ER02-8494 -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, +Thank you for your letter of May 6, 2003, transmitting the survey report by Circa, Inc. -I hope this letter finds you well despite the current challenges around the world. After more than -two years, the COVID-19 pandemic still has a negative impact on our daily lives and business and -now we’re also facing a conflict in the heart of Europe that is causing terrible human suffering. +We concur that there are no properties within the Area of Potential Effect (APE) that are +eligible for listing in the National Register. -We’re in constant dialogue with all our stakeholders in Ukraine and we do our utmost to support -our local employees and their families as well as all our partners, ambassadors, and athletes -wherever we can. Ensuring the health and safety of our people continues to be our number one -priority, as we have already demonstrated throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. We have set up a -safe house in Ukraine, we are delivering food, water, and other necessities directly to our people -and we are helping women and children who want to leave the country. We currently have 40 -women and children in accommodation in Poland and about 120 here in Germany. Many of the -adults have already started working and most of the children are already attending schools and -kindergarten. Their positive attitude and mindset, as well as their willingness to work and -integrate, is remarkable. They are strong and positive people. I sincerely hope that this conflict -will be solved diplomatically as soon as possible, that further bloodshed can be avoided and that -peace will be restored. +The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation +Act and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with +Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Part 800. -While we are most concerned about the lives and livelihoods of the people who are directly -affected in Ukraine and by the COVID-19 pandemic, the conflict as well as the pandemic also have -a significant business impact on our sector and on PUMA. In addition to the impact on our -operations in Russia and Ukraine, we continue to face some of the challenges that we already -saw during the course of 2021: COVID-19 related lockdowns and restrictions in different parts of -the world, a weak consumer sentiment in some key markets, significant challenges in our supply -chain, strong inflationary pressures, and geopolitical tensions. +Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the +above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, environmental review coordinator, at +919/733-4763. In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above +referenced tracking number. -5 +cc: (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -Despite all these challenges, 2021 was a very successful year for us. To be specific, it was the -best year in PUMA’s history. Due to our continued brand momentum combined with high -operational flexibility and a fantastic effort from our employees, our sales grew by 32% to -EUR 6,805m and EBIT grew by 166% to EUR 557m. Compared to the pre-pandemic level of 2019, -our sales increased by 30%, resulting in a two-year CAGR of around 15% during these -challenging times. Our strategy of working closely together with all our suppliers and retail -partners to manage short-term issues without hindering our mid-term momentum continued to -pay off. Our external partners supported us in an extraordinary way and the dedication and -commitment of all our employees during such a challenging year was truly exceptional. A lot of -our employees went far beyond what a company can expect from them and in the name of the -entire PUMA Board, I would like to thank everyone for their contribution towards making these -results possible. People make the difference and our PUMA family is our biggest strength and -asset. - -Throughout 2021, we continued to focus on the three main areas that we defined in early 2020 in -reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic: Deal with COVID, continue to drive the business and continue -to do the right thing in areas such as social responsibility and environmental sustainability. - -Dealing with COVID first and foremost meant ensuring the health and safety of our people and -everyone in our value chain. We continued to adopt and comply with very strict health and safety -measures across our operations and rolled out vaccination programs for our employees in -countries where this was possible. This helped us achieve a vaccination rate of more than 90% at -our headquarters in Herzogenaurach by mid-July. At the end of the year, we followed up with -booster vaccinations. I would once again like to thank our People & Organization teams (formerly -known as Human Resources) around the world for successfully managing a second year of -COVID-19 and supporting our employees in the best way possible. - -Until around the first quarter 2021, the COVID-19 pandemic mainly impacted the store operations -of our own retail organization and of our retail partners due to mandatory store closures and -other restrictions. This was followed by significant disruptions in our supply chain due to -lockdowns and factory closures in key sourcing countries such as Bangladesh, Cambodia, China -and Vietnam. Especially, the lockdown in the third quarter in 2021 in the south of Vietnam, one of -our most important sourcing destinations, had a very negative impact on our supply chain. Due to -strict local lockdown measures, the production at our footwear, apparel and accessories -suppliers in the south of Vietnam was suspended for about ten weeks, affecting approximately -15% of our global sourcing volumes. We tried to minimize delays as much as possible and shifted -part of the volumes to other sourcing locations where possible. Thanks to the quick rollout of the -vaccination program in the south of Vietnam, the factories gradually reopened during October -and ramped up to full production by the end of year. After our suppliers resumed normal -operations, we saw fewer and very localized factory closures in some parts of Asia, which did not -significantly impact our product supply. We’re very thankful to our suppliers for being a part of -the PUMA family. The strong collaboration, long-term partnership and all their incredible support -ensured the continued supply of products under very difficult circumstances. - -The COVID-19 pandemic also had a major impact on other parts of our supply chain, and we had -to deal with capacity constraints, container shortages and harbor congestion in ocean freight, but -also significant challenges in air freight and land-based transportation. All these constraints led -to a strong increase in freight costs, which further fueled inflationary pressures, in addition to -rising costs for energy, raw materials and labor. - -As manifested in our strong sales growth, we also continued to drive the business in 2021. After -the end of the COVID-19 related lockdowns, we witnessed a certain “normalization” of buying -patterns, with more consumers shopping offline again instead of online. In our Direct-to- -Consumer business, we therefore saw a higher growth rate in our brick & mortar stores -compared to our eCommerce sites. However, both channels grew by double-digits last year, and -we continued to invest in the optimization of our store portfolio, the consumer experience on our -existing sites as well as the launch of new eCommerce sites. During a time of limited supply, we - -6 - - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders - -continued to prioritize our retail partners in terms of product allocation. We strongly believe in a -multi-brand retail environment and will therefore strengthen the relationship with all our retail -partners around the world and do everything we can to service them in the best way possible. - -After a year without any major sporting events in 2020, we were also excited to see sports -leagues, tournaments and other competitions resume in the course of 2021, for the most part -including live spectators. - -The summer of 2021 was exceptional for our teams and athletes, who delivered world class -performances on track and on the pitch. We underlined our credibility and high ambitions in -football with the victory of the PUMA-sponsored national team Italy at UEFA Euro 2020, several -league and cup titles of our PUMA-sponsored club teams and great on-pitch visibility of our -products. At the Tokyo Olympics and Paralympics, our athletes won more than 70 medals, -demonstrating the performance credentials of our products on the world stage, including our -new NITRO running shoes that I personally am exceptionally proud of. We also continued our -successful re-entry into basketball, especially for the North American market and launched our -first signature shoe with LaMelo Ball at the end of the year. The strengthening of our -performance credibility has always been important to us and I’m very happy about the great -progress that we’ve seen across football, running, fitness, golf, motorsport, basketball and other -locally relevant sports. In Sportstyle, we also continued to build brand heat through exciting new -products and collaborations and by offering a comprehensive collection across all relevant price -points, including a strong focus on comfort. We are very happy to see that our classics business -is growing strongly. Our PUMA Archive is full of footwear and apparel from the 70s, 80s and 90s, -for which there is currently a lot of demand in youth culture. We’re also very satisfied to see the -continued momentum in our women’s business, following the launch of our “She Moves Us” -brand platform, and we will keep capitalizing on our truly inclusive product offering across -genders, age groups etc.! - -We also continued to focus on what we call “Doing the right thing”. We want to be a good -corporate citizen and embed our social responsibility and our environmental sustainability into all -our business practices. With regards to social responsibility, we continued with multiple -initiatives under our #REFORM platform to promote universal equality. We strongly believe that -people should be treated equally irrespective of their gender, age, skin color, religious believes, -sexual orientation or any other factor. Together with our brand ambassadors and partner -organizations, we want to do our part to promote universal equality and fight any form of -discrimination in sports and society as a whole. As part of our ambitious 10FOR25 sustainability -targets, we implemented more sustainable business practices in all our business operations -from sourcing to retail and further increased the usage of more sustainable materials and the -overall share of more sustainable products in our collections. We also increased our focus on -circularity, with several pilot projects and strengthened our consumer-facing sustainability -communication through our FOREVER BETTER brand platform. I, together with my team, -attended the COP26 climate conference in Glasgow to emphasize our commitment in the fight -against climate change and to work towards limiting the global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees -Celsius above pre-industrial levels. We have all these initiatives because we really believe in -them, as part of PUMA’s core values, and we will continue to do the right thing. - -Given our strong performance in 2021 and good momentum in the first months of 2022, we’re -also optimistic for the future of our industry in general and for PUMA in particular, despite the -external challenges. The underlying dynamics in our sector remain very strong given the -increasing participation in sports, the ongoing sneaker trend and the continued casualization -among consumers all around the world. We also see PUMA’s brand momentum continuing and -we will ensure operational flexibility in an increasingly volatile and unpredictable marketplace. -As we have already done during the past years, we will continue to work very closely with all our -retail partners to further increase our shelf space and support the sell-through of our products in -their stores. We have focused on building strong partnerships with all our key stakeholders such -as suppliers, retailers, ambassadors and athletes, helping them as well as us through the -ongoing challenges. We will continue to foster these partnerships in the future. We therefore +Circa, Inc. +Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT -7 +bc: 'Southern/McBride + +County + +ADMINISTRATION +RESTORAT1QN . +SURYEridtcPLANNING + +Location (cid:9) +507 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) +515 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) +515 N. Blount St.. Raleigh NC (cid:9) + +Mailing Address +4617 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4617 +4613 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4613 +4618 Mail Service Center. Raleigh NC 27699-4618 + +Telephone/Fax +(919) 733-1763 • 733-8653 +(919) 733-6547 • 7154801 +(919) 733-6545 • 715-4801 + +www.hpo.dcr.state.nc.us + +(cid:9) + HISTORIC ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT + +REPLACEMENT OF BRIDGE NO. 165 ON S.R. 1362 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ASHE COUNTY + +NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION +T.I.P. NO. B-4015 +STATE PROJECT NO. 8.2712401 +FEDERAL-AID PROJECT NO. BRZ-1362 (1) + +Prepared for: + +Wetherill Engineering, Inc. +559 Jones Franklin Road, Suite 164 +Raleigh, NC 27606 + +Prepared by: + +Circa, Inc. +P.O. Box 407 +Durham, NC 27702 + +April 2003 + +a-44 + +OiU s cc Are)A-Ad-uArL_ t\_)csx) r + +S • (0 .2143 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Replacement of Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 +over Big Horse Creek +Ashe County +T.I.P. No. B-4015 +State Project No. 8.2712401 +Federal-Aid Project No. BRZ-1362 (1) + +Management Summary +The North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) proposes to replace +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek in Ashe County. The project +involves the replacement of the existing one-lane bridge with a two-lane +structure. There are two alternatives for the new bridge. Alternative 1 entails +the realignment of SR 1362 and the construction of a new structure on the +upstream side of the existing bridge. Alternative 2 entails the realignment of SR +1362 and the construction of a new structure on the downstream side of the +existing bridge. Alternative 3 entails the replacement of the existing bridge with +a new structure, in same location. It is anticipated that traffic will be maintained +on the existing bridge during construction. + +Circa, Inc. conducted the intensive survey by automobile and by foot in January +2003, covering one-hundred percent of the Area of Potential Effects (APE). Circa +photographed, mapped, and evaluated every property over fifty years of age +within the APE. Those properties considered worthy of further analysis were +researched and evaluated in January 2003. + +In addition to the field survey of the project area, Circa reviewed the survey files, +as well as National Register and Study List files, at the Survey and Planning +Branch of the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office in Raleigh. +Background research was also conducted at the Ashe County Courthouse in +Jefferson, the Ashe County Public Library in West Jefferson, and in a meeting +with one of the property owners. + +Circa staff delineated the APE, which includes parcels immediately adjacent to +the present bridge and those impacted, physically or visually, by any of the +proposed alternatives. One property over fifty years of age, the Graham-Brooks +Farm, was identified within the APE. While the house itself is not within the +APE, a corner of the 31.6-acre parcel lies within the APE. Therefore, the property +was evaluated as part of this report. + +Properties Listed in the National Register or the North Carolina State Study List: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Eligible for the National Register: + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +i (cid:9) + +4/1/2003 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Not Eligible for the National Register: + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +ii (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +4/1/2003 -expect 2022 to be another record year for PUMA, with a net sales growth of at least 10%, with -upside potential, and an EBIT of EUR 600 – 700 million. The objective is not to maximize short- -term EBIT, but to continue to have healthy long-term growth in both sales and EBIT. We will also -keep on putting our people first and take care of all our partners. + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -Let’s stay positive and hope that peace in Ukraine will be restored as soon as possible and that -the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic will continue to decrease. +Table of Contents -Thank you for being part of the PUMA family! +Management Summary (cid:9) -Stay strong, healthy and optimistic! +Table of Contents (cid:9) -Bjørn Gulden -Chief Executive Officer PUMA +List of Figures (cid:9) -8 +List of Plates (cid:9) - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Project Description (cid:9) -REPORT BY THE SUPERVISORY BOARD +Methodology (cid:9) -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -↗ JEAN-FRANÇOIS PALUS -CHAIRMAN OF THE -CHAIRMAN OF THE -SUPERVISORY BOARD -SUPERVISORY BOARD +Brief History of Ashe County (cid:9) -DEAR SHAREHOLDERS, +Historical and Architectural Contexts (cid:9) -The 2021 financial year was again heavily impacted by the COVID 19 pandemic. Despite the associated -uncertainties, supply chain bottlenecks due to container shortages, port congestion and pandemic-related -factory closures in key sourcing regions, as well as political tensions in key markets, we managed to start -2021 with high growth momentum. Due to the continued decisive and consistent actions of our Management -Board and the outstanding performance of our employees, we were able to maintain our market -momentum and operational flexibility throughout the year. As a result, we were able to raise our outlook for -2021 during the year and end the year with the highest sales and profit in PUMA's history. At the same time, -it was of utmost importance for us to protect the safety and health of our employees in the best possible -way through the resolute development and implementation of hygiene and occupational safety concepts -and the implementation of vaccination campaigns. We were once again a flexible and reliable business -partner for our suppliers and customers. We worked as closely as possible with them to stabilize our -supply chains and increase sales of our products. By appointing Hubert Hinterseher and Arne Freundt to -the Management Board, we were able to further strengthen our organization and thus lay the foundations -for a successful 2022. +Property Evaluations -In the financial year 2021, the Supervisory Board has exercised all its duties under the law, statutes and -company rules. The Supervisory Board has dealt extensively with the status and the development of PUMA, -particularly continuing with a special focus on the COVID-19 pandemic, and has regularly advised and -supervised the Management Board in its management of the Company. +Graham-Brooks Farm -In this regard, the Supervisory Board has in its four regular meetings discussed and resolved on the -Company’s business policies, all relevant aspects of corporate development and corporate planning, the -Company’s economic situation, including its net assets, financial position and results of operations, the -adequacy of capital resources and all key decisions for the Group. The Management Board has informed the +Bibliography (cid:9) + +i + +iii + +.iv + +.v + +1 + +5 + +7 9 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +12 -Supervisory Board regularly, comprehensively, and in a timely manner in written and verbal form about the -implementation of all decisions and about all major business transactions. Furthermore, in 2021 one -extraordinary meeting of the Supervisory Board took place. Urgent matters were decided via circular -resolutions using electronic means of communication. All members participated in drawing up the -resolutions. Whenever necessary, representatives of the shareholders and employees held separate -preliminary discussions prior to the meetings. +19 -Plenary Supervisory Board +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Jean-François Palus +iii (cid:9) -Thore Ohlsson +4/1/2003 -Héloïse Temple-Boyer +(cid:9) + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -Fiona May +List of Figures -Martin Köppel +Figure 1. Project vicinity map (cid:9) -Bernd Illig +Figure 2. Location of Alternatives 1 & 2 (cid:9) -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +Figure 3. Location of Alternative 3 (cid:9) -Attendance in % +Figure 4. The ideally sited Appalachian house (cid:9) -5/5 +Figure 5. Graham-Brooks Farm site plan (cid:9) -5/5 +2 -5/5 +3 -5/5 +.4 11 -5/5 +15 -5/5 +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -100 +iv (cid:9) -100 +4/1/2003 -100 + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County -100 +List of Plates -100 +Plate 1. Graham-Brooks Farm - main house facade (cid:9) -100 +Plate 2. Graham-Brooks Farm - main house facade & north elevation (cid:9) -The Supervisory Board discussed in detail all of the Company’s key business transactions, based on the -reports by the Management Board and the Committees, and presented its own ideas. The Management -Board has provided the Supervisory Board with detailed information on any deviations of the business -performance from the budgeted figures, both in writing and orally. The Supervisory Board verified these -explanations using the supporting documents, which were always submitted in appropriate time before the -meetings. The Supervisory Board was involved in all key decisions at an early stage. In addition, the Chair of -the Supervisory Board maintained, and continues to maintain, regular verbal or written contact with the -CEO and keeps himself informed of all major developments. Overall, these discussions did not give any -indication that the Management Board was managing the Group in anything other than a lawful and proper -manner. +Plate 3. Graham-Brooks Farm - setting (cid:9) -The Supervisory Board members took part, on their own initiative, in the educational and training measures -necessary for the performance of their duties. The Company supports the Supervisory Board members in -their training activities, for example by having the Legal Department regularly review changes in the legal -framework for the Supervisory Board and report about them in the meetings. In 2021, the Supervisory -Board received a training on the sustainability strategy of the Company and the challenges in the supply -chain. The Supervisory Board dealt with the Act on Corporate Due Diligence in Supply Chains (Supply Chain -Due Diligence Act) and the EU Regulation on the Establishment of a Framework to Facilitate Sustainable -Investment (EU Taxonomy Regulation). +Plate 4. Graham-Brooks Farm - outbuilding 1 (cid:9) -MAIN ADVISORY FOCUS +Plate 5. Graham-Brooks Farm - outbuilding 2 (cid:9) -In the 2021 financial year, the main focus was on the following issues: review and approval of the 2020 -consolidated and annual financial statements and the non-financial report, dividend proposal, resolution of -the new remuneration system for the Management Board and submission to the 2021 Annual General -Meeting for approval, ongoing assessment of the impact and handling of the COVID 19 pandemic, setting the -agenda for the Annual General Meeting on 5 May 2021, approval of the Management Board’s decisions to -hold the Annual General Meeting as a virtual Annual General Meeting without the physical presence of -shareholders or their proxies, appointment of Hubert Hinterseher to the Management Board to succeed -Michael Lämmermann and appointment of Arne Freundt to the Management Board, establishment of a -Sustainability Committee, setting of new targets for the proportion of women to be achieved on the -Supervisory Board and Management Board, self-assessment of the Supervisory Board, current business -and revenue development, markets and trends, financial position of the Group, corporate and budget -planning 2022 as well as medium-term planning, including investments, further improvement of the -compliance management and internal control system as well as material litigation in the Group. +16 -10 +16 - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +17 -The Audit Committee submitted a recommendation to the Supervisory Board for the election of the auditor, -which was prepared following a selection process within the meaning of Art. 16 (3) Regulation (EU) No. -537/2014, comprised two candidates and was substantiated. +17 -As every year, the Personnel Committee and the Supervisory Board determined the degree of achievement -of the targets for the individual Management Board members with regard to 2020. The Supervisory Board -decided on the targets for the variable Management Board remuneration for the 2021 financial year upon -recommendation of the Personnel Committee. +18 -CONFLICTS OF INTEREST +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -The members of the Supervisory Board are required to disclose to its Chair any conflicts of interest without -undue delay. In the past year, no such disclosures were made. +v (cid:9) -COMMITTEES +4/1/2003 -The Supervisory Board has established four committees to perform its duties: The Personnel Committee, -the Audit Committee, the Nominating Committee and the Sustainability Committee which was established -in April 2021. The Personnel Committee, the Audit Committee and the Sustainability Committee each -comprise two shareholder representatives and one employee representative. The Nominating Committee is -composed only of shareholder representatives. The composition of the committees can be found in the -notes to the consolidated financial statements. The Supervisory Board receives regular reports on their -work. + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County -PERSONNEL COMMITTEE +Replacement of Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 +over Big Horse Creek +Ashe County +T.I.P. No. B-4015 +State Project No. 8.2712401 +Federal-Aid Project No. BRZ-1362 (1) -The Personnel Committee has the task of preparing the conclusion and amendment of employment -contracts with the members of the Management Board and establishing policies for human resources and -personnel development. It met to one regular meeting and to one extraordinary meeting in 2021 and mainly -dealt with the compensation system for the Management Board, which has been approved by the Annual -General Meeting in 2021. Furthermore, the determination of target achievement for the individual -Management Board members and the setting of targets for 2021 were the focus of the discussions. -Corresponding recommendations for resolutions were made to the Supervisory Board. +Project Description -Personnel Committee +The North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) proposes to replace +Bridge No. 165 on SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek in Ashe County (Figure 1). The +current structure, completed in 1960, consists of a timber floor on I-beams with a +substructure of timber posts and caps. Bridge No. 165 is classified as structurally +insufficient by the NCDOT Bridge Maintenance Unit, scoring a sufficiency rating +of 44.1 out of a possible 100 in 1999. -Attendance at meetings +The project involves the replacement of the existing one-lane bridge with a two- +lane structure. There are two alternatives for the new bridge. Alternative 1 +entails the realignment of SR 1362 and the construction of a new structure on the +upstream side of the existing bridge; alternative 2 entails the realignment of SR +1362 and the construction of a new structure on the downstream side of the +existing bridge (Figure 2). Alternative 3 entails the replacement of the existing +bridge with a new structure in the same location (Figure 3). It is anticipated that +traffic will be maintained on the existing bridge during construction. -Attendance in % +Purpose of Survey and Report -Jean-François Palus +The historic resources survey was conducted to identify all historic resources +located within the area of potential effects (APE) (Figures 2 & 3). This survey +and report are part of the environmental studies conducted by NCDOT and +documented by a categorical exclusion (CE). This report was prepared as a +technical appendix to the CE and is part of the compliance documentation +required by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 and the +National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) of 1966, as amended. Section 106 of +the NHPA states that if a federally funded, licensed, or permitted project has an +effect on a property listed in, or potentially eligible for listing in the National +Register of Historic Places, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation should +be given an opportunity to comment on the proposed undertaking. This report +is on file with NCDOT and available for review by the public. -Fiona May +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Martin Köppel +1 (cid:9) -AUDIT COMMITTEE +4/1/03 -2/2 + Bridge No. 338, T. I. P. No. B-4013 +Ashe County -2/2 +'4 -2/2 +1309 kP -100 +Torseaut R2 -100 +Wee -100 +13-10 -The Audit Committee held four regular meetings in the financial year 2021. Furthermore, one extraordinary -meeting of the Audit Committee took place in 2021. In particular, the Audit Committee is responsible for the -review of the accounting, particularly comprising the consolidated financial statements and the group -management report, group half year report, interim financial information and the single entity financial -statements in accordance with the German Commercial Code (HGB). It is furthermore responsible for -monitoring the accounting process, the effectiveness of the internal control system, the risk management -system, the internal audit system, compliance and the statutory audit of the financial statements, with -particular regard to the process of selecting an auditor. The Audit Committee is also responsible for -conducting the selection process of the auditor. In addition, the Audit Committee monitors the -independence of the auditor and ensures that the non-audit services of the auditor commissioned by the -Management Board do not give rise to any grounds for disqualification or partiality or any threat to -independence. The Audit Committee issues the audit mandate on behalf of the Supervisory Board to the +1310 -11 +ra• - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +ce • -auditor elected by the general meeting, determines the audit areas of the audit and agrees the fee with the -auditor. Heads of the corporate functions were also available for reports and questions on individual agenda -items at the committee meetings. The Audit Committee meets regularly with the auditor, also without the -Management Board. +A -Audit Committee +1308 -Thore Ohlsson +La -Héloïse Temple-Boyer +1310 -Bernd Illig +1107 -Attendance at meetings -(referring to regular and extraordinary -meetings) +:..1397 -Attendance in % +Creek -5/5 +41; -5/5 +-60gVOTOR -5/5 +1315 +f -100 +98' -100 +OISTANC; Ill NILES -100 +SR 1320 +(ROARING FORK ROAD) +REPLACE BRIDGE NO. 338 over +ROARING FORK CREEK -NOMINATING COMMITTEE +6-4013 -The Nominating Committee has the task of proposing suitable candidates to the Supervisory Board for its -election proposals to the Annual General Meeting. It held no meeting in the last financial year. +Ashe County, North Carolina -SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE +PROJECT VICINITY -The Sustainability Committee was established in April 2021 and met once in the 2021 financial year to -discuss the company's sustainability strategies. The Sustainability Committee consists of three members. +Fioure 1 -CORPORATE GOVERNANCE +Circa, Inc. -As in previous years, the Supervisory Board addressed current developments in the financial year 2021 -regarding the German Corporate Governance Code in the version dated December 16, 2019 (effective as of -March 20, 2020) (GCGC). The GCGC contains essential statutory regulations and recommendations for the -management and supervision of listed companies and standards for responsible corporate governance. The -corporate governance standards have long been a part of the corporate routine. +2 -Pursuant to Principle 22 of the GCGC, the Supervisory Board reports on corporate governance in the -Corporate Governance Statement. The Company satisfies all requirements of the GCGC, to the extent -required by it. The Statement of Compliance of November 9, 2021 is available to our shareholders at any -time on the Company’s website under https://about.PUMA.com/en/investor-relations/corporate- -governance at STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE. +4/1/2003 -ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ADOPTED +(cid:9) +(cid:9) + HISTORIC ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT -The annual financial statements for PUMA SE prepared by the Management Board in accordance with the -German Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch/HGB), the consolidated financial statements and the -combined management report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, each for the financial year 2021, -prepared in accordance with Section 315a HGB on the basis of the International Financial Reporting -Standards (IFRS) have been audited by the statutory auditors, Deloitte GmbH -Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, Munich, who were appointed at the Annual General Meeting on May 5, -2021 and commissioned by the Supervisory Board to audit the annual financial statements and the -consolidated financial statements and have been given an unqualified auditor’s opinion. +REPLACEMENT OF BRIDGE NO. 165 ON S.R. 1362 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ASHE COUNTY -In their report, the statutory auditors conclude that PUMA’s institutionalized risk management system, in -accordance with Section 91(2) of the German Stock Corporation Act (Aktiengesetz/AktG), is capable of -detecting at an early stage and countering any developments that might jeopardize the continuity of the -Company as a going concern. The Supervisory Board has been updated by the Management Board regularly +NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION +T.I.P. NO. B-4015 +STATE PROJECT NO. 8.2712401 +FEDERAL-AID PROJECT NO. BRZ-1362 (1) -12 +Prepared for: + +Wetherill Engineering, Inc. +559 Jones Franklin Road, Suite 164 +Raleigh, NC 27606 + +Prepared by: + +Circa, Inc. +P.O. Box 407 +Durham, NC 27702 + +April 2003 + + BEGIN PROJECT + +NATE + +IUiUIN I. Lai EcT +ALTERNATE 2 + +A PI' + +BR; HORSE CR EEK ROA D + +17,62 + +RIG HORSE CREEK + +\ I FER + +‘1,TER.\:.\ TI (cid:9) + +I + +RU; HORSE CREEK + +RIG IIOR`-;I: (cid:9) + +I(EEK 1(0 \ + +SR (cid:9) + +' + +REPLACEMENT OF +BRIDGE NO. 156 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ON SR 1362 +;13IG HORSE CREEK ROAD) + +ALTERNATE + +PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +ALTERNATE 2 + +/ PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +ALTERNATE 1 +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +ALTERNATE 2 +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +Ashe County, North Carolina + +\ ERIAL MAP WITH BUILD + +ALTERNATIVES 1 & 2 + +FIGURE 2 + +SCALE 1' = 75' + + 1EGIN PROJECT + +ALTERNATE 3 + +111 (cid:9) POI( (cid:9) + +\I + +I 5 (cid:9) + +1)1. 101 R + +Sit 1.3b2 + +BIG HORSE CREEK + +END PROJECT + +ALTERNATE 3 + +BIG HORSE CREEK ROAD + +r REPLACEMENT OF + +BRIDGE NO. 156 +OVER BIG HORSE CREEK +ON SR 1362 +tI3113 HORSE CREEK ROAD) + +Asko County, North Carolina + +AERIAL MAP WITH BUILD + +ALTERNATIVE 3 + +FIGURE 3 +SCALE 1' = 75' + +PERMANENT ALIGNMENT + +TEMPORARY DETOUR + +PERMANENT BRIDGE + +TEMPORARY BRIDGE + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Methodology + +This report was prepared in accordance with the provisions of Federal Highway +Administration (FHWA) Technical Advisory T 6640.8A (Guidance for Preparing +and Processing Environmental and Section 4(f) Documents); the Secretary of the +Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Archaeological and Historic Preservation +(48 FRR 44716); 36 CFR Part 800; 36 CFR Part 60; and the Survey Procedures and +Report Guidelines for Historic Architectural Resources by NCDOT. This report +meets the guidelines of NCDOT and the National Park Service. + +This survey was conducted with the following goals: (1) to determine the APE, +which is defined as the geographic area or areas within which a project may +cause changes to the character or use of the historic properties, if any such +properties exist; (2) to identify all resources over fifty years of age within the +APE; and (3) to evaluate these resources according to the National Register of +Historic Places criteria. + +The methodology for this project included a field survey and background +research of the project area and the region. The field survey was conducted in +January 2003 to delineate the APE (Figure 3) and identify all properties within +the APE greater than fifty years of age. Every property over fifty years of age +was photographed, mapped, and evaluated. + +Background research was conducted at the Survey and Planning Branch of the +North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office in Raleigh. This research +indicated that there are no resources within the APE that have been listed on the +National Register of Historic Places or the State Study List. Background research +was also conducted at the Ashe County Courthouse in Jefferson, the Ashe +County Public Library in West Jefferson, and in a meeting with one of the +property owners. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +5 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Summary of Survey Findings + +Bridge No. 165 spans Big Horse Creek, a tributary of the North Fork of the New +River, in the northern portion of Ashe County, 2.5 miles north of the town of +Lansing. The bridge carries SR 1362 over Big Horse Creek at a 45-degree angle +between two curves in the road. + +Bridge No. 165 was built in 1960 and consists of a timber floor on I-beams with a +substructure of timber posts and caps. The bridge was not evaluated as part of +this study as it is under fifty years of age and not associated with a significant +type of design or movement in bridge construction. + +One property over fifty years of age, the Graham-Brooks Farm, was identified +within the APE. While, the house itself is not within the APE, a corner of the +31.6-acre parcel lies within the APE. Therefore, the property was evaluated as +part of this report. + +Properties Listed in the National Register or the North Carolina State Study List: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Eligible for the National Register: + +None + +Properties Evaluated and Considered Not Eligible for the National Register: + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +6 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Brief History of Ashe County +Note: This section adapted from "Historic Architectural Resources Survey Report, +Replacement of Bridge No. 281 on SR 1358 Over Big Horse Creek, Ashe County, TIP +No. B-4014." + +The project area is located in the northern portion of Ashe County, in the +northwest corner of North Carolina. The county is approximately 3,000 feet +above sea level, on the west side of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Because of the +mountain barrier, Ashe County became known as one of the "lost provinces" of +North Carolina. Prior to the Good Roads Movement of the 1920s, Ashe County +was relatively isolated from the eastern part of the state. However, trade was +possible with the neighboring states of Virginia and Tennessee due to the +numerous passes through the Stone Mountains, the north-flowing New River, +and the extension of the Norfolk and Western Railway from Virginia in 1915. +Despite its relative isolation, Ashe County was unique among the mountain +counties of western North Carolina because of its rolling, rather than rugged, +terrain and its fertile farmland, well watered by the New River and its +tributaries. Because of these conditions, Ashe County has remained +overwhelmingly agrarian throughout its history. + +Named for Governor Samuel Ashe, Ashe County was created in 1799 after +settlers arrived in the area from the Shenandoah Valley to the north and the +North Carolina Piedmont to the east. Sited at the base of Mount Jefferson, the +county seat of Jefferson was incorporated in 1803, but has remained small in part +because the county's gentle topography and good farmland encouraged settlers +to disperse uniformly throughout the county. Small crossroads communities +with stores, mills, and churches emerged to serve nearby farms, and the county +developed few large towns. Located just a few miles south of the county seat, +West Jefferson emerged in the early-twentieth century as the commercial center +of Ashe County after a branch of the Norfolk and Western Railway was extended +south from Virginia in 1915. + +Since its founding at the end of the American Revolution, Ashe County has been +rural, with more then ninety-one percent of its area designated as farmland into +the late 1950s. Despite good farming conditions, insufficient transportation +routes and the absence of ready markets stymied the development of commercial +agriculture, and subsistence farms predominated in Ashe County until the early- +twentieth century when the economy diversified somewhat. The early settlers +cultivated rye, buckwheat, and corn. Eventually, these fields turned to grasses, +which in turn supported livestock. In 1879, there were thirty-eight cattle traders +in the county. Livestock production continued to be a profitable part of the +agricultural economy through the twentieth century, and by the post-World War +I period Ashe County was the leading producer of beef and dairy cattle in the +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +7 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +state and the second largest producer of sheep. Ashe, along with neighboring +Watauga and Allegheny Counties, has also been a major producer of wool and +dairy products. Only since the 1920s has Ashe County joined other mountain +counties in cultivating burley tobacco as a cash crop. By 1965 it had become the +third leading producer in North Carolina. + +Manufacturing has remained a minor part of the economy, employing less then +nine percent of the county work force into the 1960s. Much of the manufacturing +sector has been concentrated in the processing of agricultural, timber-related, +and some textile products. + +Because of its largely subsistence economy and geographical isolation, Ashe +County was generally less affected by the Civil War than other regions of the +state. Both Union and Confederate sympathizers were present, and clashes +between the two groups were common. The county remained a Republican +stronghold through the end of the nineteenth century in contrast to the rest of +North Carolina. + +In addition to agriculture, a number of minerals were discovered during the late- +antebellum period, and several mining communities emerged by the mid- +nineteenth century. In the 1870s, Ore Knob was a bustling boomtown for copper +mining, leading the nation in the production of the metal. During its brief period +of prosperity, Ore Knob was the largest town in the county. The community +quickly declined with the closing of the mines in the 1880s and has since +vanished. 'Throughout the nineteenth century iron was also mined, and a number +of forges were established for iron production. Unlike Ore Knob, the town of +Helton, which once boasted several iron mines and forges, survives although its +iron production has long since ended. By 1884, Creston, with its grist and saw +mills, tannery, and furniture and wagon factory, had emerged as the largest +town in Ashe County. + +Like much of western North Carolina, a seasonal tourist industry began to +emerge in Ashe County by the end of the nineteenth century as wealthy families +wanting to escape the summer heat began to "take the waters" at local mineral +springs. Spa resorts such as Shatley Springs, Thompson's Bromine, Arsenic +Springs (NR), and the Glendale Springs flourished with seasonal visitors. + +In the 1970s, Ashe County found itself embroiled in controversy with a proposal +by the Appalachian Power Company to dam the New River in Virginia, +effectively impounding the river on the North Carolina side. Environmentalists +succeeded in having the river designated as a Wild and Scenic River, and the +proposal died. Since then, Ashe County has profited from the growing interest +in outdoor sports, particularly rafting, and the river valleys of the county have +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +8 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +become popular spots for vacation home construction. Despite these changes, the +rural, agrarian way of life survives remarkably intact in Ashe County. + +Architectural Context: Early-Twentieth Century Architecture and Farmsteads in +Ashe County + +The Blue Ridge Mountains served as a natural wall separating the New River +Valley counties of Ashe and Alleghany from the rest of state until well into the +twentieth century. As a result of this isolation, the region developed its own +culture and economy, as well as its own building practices. In the 1970s, a +proposal to dam the New River in Virginia, effectively flooding the New River +Valley in North Carolina, created an immediate need for research and +documentation of the region's built environment. In 1976, Davyd Foard Hood +and Michael Southern conducted a reconnaissance level survey documenting +approximately 100 resources in Ashe County. What was discovered through this +work was a landscape and building pattern drastically different from that of the +rest of the state. + +The collection of structures that dominate the vernacular architecture of the New +River Valley were built between 1885 and 1915. Two trends were occurring at +that time that resulted in the rapid construction of farmsteads throughout the +region. First, families were getting larger. The original settlers of the region +were now welcoming their third and fourth generations and that resulted in the +need for larger or additional housing. The second trend was a combination of an +improvement in transportation routes and a change in local agricultural +methods. With the improvement of transportation routes, including both roads +and the introduction of the railroad, local farmers were able to get their products +to distant markets. This changed the face of farming in the region from +subsistence farming to cash crops or products such as tobacco, corn and large- +scale dairying operations (Hood, 205). + +Buildings constructed prior to 1885 were first of log, then frame construction. +The majority of these structures were unadorned one or two-room houses. These +houses were primarily one-story, but two-story interpretations were not +uncommon. The simplicity of these structures was due to a more dominant need +for function. Early settlers of the region came from Virginia and quickly built +temporary structures to house their family, with the idea that a more permanent +structure would be built at a later date. Often, when the more permanent house +was built, the original home was converted to an agricultural purpose. As a +result of this practice, both the Georgian and Federal styles of architecture are +practically absent and the Greek Revival movement, wildly popular across the +state, has only a few examples in the county (Hood, 205). + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +9 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +It was not until the building boom between 1885 and 1915 that elements of +national building styles began to appear in the region's domestic architecture. +While the improved transportation routes served to transport agricultural +products out of the region, they also served to bring new materials in. The +sudden availability of materials from sawmills, such as bargeboards, turned +posts, balusters and moldings brought a new life to the local architecture and +changed the local vernacular in both form and focus. In addition to the extensive +ornamentation of houses, their plan began to take on more elaborate forms. +Two-story houses, three-bays wide, became the preferred form, often with an ell +off the back resulting in an overall a "T" or "L" plan (Hood, 210). Smaller, one- +story houses also began to be built on larger farmsteads to house younger +generations or farm hands and their families. These structures rarely +incorporated the ornamentation present on the farmstead's main house. + +What was more important than form or decoration, both during the region's +early development and well into the twentieth century, was the location of +buildings on a site. While the county's rolling topography and fertile soil +defined the area as ideal for agricultural purposes, the bitter cold and often harsh +winds proved challenging for the siting of residences and shelters for livestock. +Furthermore, the remoteness of the region in its early settlement, required that +each farmstead be self-sufficient. The lack of good roads or other reliable means +of transportation in conjunction with long winters meant that families had to be +able to exist on these farmsteads for long periods of time without outside sources +of sustenance. + +In order for farmsteads to be self-sufficient a compilation of outbuildings was +necessary. Livestock barns, equipment sheds, smokehouses, spring houses, +corncribs, granaries, woodsheds, root cellars, tobacco barns, and, of course, +privies were all common structures. The collection of outbuildings and the size +of each structure varied greatly from farm to farm, reflecting both the size of the +family that subsided on it, and any specialization in crop or production. +Outbuildings were predominantly log or frame structures until the late- +nineteenth and early-twentieth century. The location of each of the structures on +the farm related directly to its function. + +The defining factors in selecting a site for a farmstead included access to water, +slope, workable (farmable) land, rock outcroppings, vegetation cover, prevailing +winds, and access to roads. Access to water was needed at the subsurface level +for drinking as well as food storage and preparation. This water was often +acquired from many of the region's springs as the use of wells was not common. +Surface water was necessary for the provision of water for livestock and for the +facilitation of crop farming. Attention to slope and prevailing winds and +vegetation cover were necessary to protect the structures from severe winter +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +10 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County + +weather, and take advantage of sun exposure as a means of heat. Rock +outcroppings and workable land directly relate to the ability to build structures +on the site and plant crops nearby (Keber, 198-99). + +As a result of this combination of factors, most farmsteads are built with the side +of a vegetated mountain behind them to break the wind, and so the facade of the +house is positioned to take advantage of as much winter sun as possible. Ideally, +there is a source of surface water to the front or side of a property and adjacent to +a stream or creek. The location of a farmstead's surface water source is +synonymous with the location of its springhouse. The cold water trickling up +from the ground was an ideal location for food storage. Meadows for livestock +and fields suitable for crop farming were often located off either side of the main +house or in front of it. Necessary outbuildings, such as livestock barns, +equipment sheds, and corncribs were often built between the house and the +meadows or crops. Also ideal is the location of a road nearby for accessibility to +the local community and nearby church, weather permitting. + +, vinter sun + +4 + +wind +break + +spring + +, View of crops Sz iVISLUre + +row crops + +stream + +alluvial Hood plain + +Figure 4. The ideally sited Appalachian house (Keber, 200.) + +While the combination of all of these factors results in the "ideally sited +Appalachian house," finding all of these elements in use on a modern day farm is +a rarity. Changes in farming practices as well as the decline of the size of families +living on these farms has resulted in the degeneration of these traditional +farmsteads. That is not to say that examples do not exist. Many of these +elements remain in many farms across the region today. It is finding an +operational farm, with it full complement of outbuildings still functioning that is +the rarity. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +11 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Property Evaluation + +Graham-Brooks Farm + +Date of Construction +Ca. 1910 + +Setting +The Graham-Brooks Farm is set on a rise in a turn of the Big Horse Creek, 0.5 +mile north of Bridge No. 165. The 31.6 acre site is wooded and slopes down to +Big Horse Creek where the remnants of an earlier bridge stand. The area +surrounding the house and its outbuildings is severely overgrown as a result of +the property being vacant for more than twenty years. + +Physical Description +The Graham-Brooks Farm is set into a hillside, adjacent to Big Horse Creek. The +farm consists of a main house, built ca. 1910, and two outbuildings. Like many +Appalachian farmsteads, the main house is built with the hillside behind it to +serve as a wind break. In front of the house, the land descends to Big Horse +Creek. SR 1362 runs in front of the house, across the creek. The property was +accessed by from SR 1362 by a one-lane bridge that has fallen into the creek. + +The main house of the Graham-Brooks Farm is a one-story, three-bay, single-pile, +frame, hip-roofed dwelling with a one-story, gable-roofed ell at the rear. The +main block of the house and rear ell have weatherboard siding, cornerboards, +and exposed rafter tails. There is a three-bay, hip-roofed porch on the facade +supported by replacement timber porch posts and an interior brick chimney +towards the rear of the main block. All windows and doors have been removed, +though their original unadorned trim remains. The roof of the rear ell is +collapsing. + +There are two outbuildings associated with the Graham-Brooks Farm. Both are +simple frame structures with shed roofs and vertical planks forming the walls. +The first outbuilding, the equipment shed, is located adjacent to the house on its +north side and sits between the house and an open field. The second outbuilding +is a larger, two-story structure and is set in front of the house, adjacent to the +creek. This larger structure served as a livestock barn with a hayloft above. + +Historical Background +The Graham-Brooks Farm was originally part of a larger farmstead owned by +William H. Graham and begun in the late-nineteenth century. The 31.6 acre tract +that the house currently sits on was sold to Moody Brooks by the Graham family +in 1951. The actual date of construction is not known. However, a conversation +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +12 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +with the adjacent property owner, a descendant of William H. Graham, indicated +that the house likely post-dates the Graham-Wilcox House, built in 1904 north of +the APE. The Graham-Brooks House was likely built to house a child of William +H. Graham's or, possibly, a farm worker. Given the information in conjunction +with the form and roof style of the structure, it likely dates to ca. 1910. + +Because agricultural records were not taken in Ashe County after 1880, there is +no definite record of what was farmed at this location. The 1880 agricultural +census indicates that Graham land holdings in the Piney Creek Township, the +township in which the Graham-Brooks Farm is located, produced corn, hay, and +over two-hundred pounds of butter. It is likely that similar crops were grown at +this location, once established by William H. Graham in the late 1800s. Since the +purchase of the property by Moody Brooks in 1951, he has passed and left the +property to heirs that do not live in the area and were not available for comment. + +Significance +The Graham-Brooks Farm is a small, turn-of-the-century farmstead in Ashe +County. Its location and setting are common among New River Valley +farmsteads, but the number of outbuildings is small compared to most +farmsteads in the region. The property is simple in form, and void of any +decorative embellishments, exuding no special significance in the area of +architecture. The farm and its associated buildings exhibit no significant +elements of design, use of materials nor do they illustrate a significant type or +style of workmanship. The farm's outbuildings remain intact but, like the house, +lack integrity as a result of neglect. The house lacks original windows and doors, +the roof of the rear ell has fallen, and the original porch posts have been replaced. +The outbuildings are overgrown and are also on the verge of collapse. This stage +of neglect diminishes the property's feeling as, and association with, a historic +farmstead. For these reasons the property lacks the requisite significance and +integrity necessary for listing, either individually or as part of a district, in the +National Register of Historic Places. + +Evaluation of National Register Eligibility +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for the National Register under +Criterion A (event) To be eligible under Criterion A the property must retain integrity +and must be associated with a specific event marking an important moment in American +History or a pattern of events or historic trend that made a significant contribution to the +development of a community. Furthermore, the property must have existed at the time +and be documented to be associated with the events. Finally, the property's specific +association must be important as well. The Graham-Brooks Farm is not known to be +associated with, or representative of, any specific event or pattern of events or +historic trend that made a significant contribution to the development of a +community. +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + +13 (cid:9) + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion B (person). For a property to be eligible for significance under +Criterion B, it must retain integrity and 1) be associated with the lives of persons +significant in our past, i.e., individuals whose activities are demonstrably important +within a local, state, or national historic context; 2) be normally associated with a +person's productive life, reflecting the time period when he/she achieved significance; and +3) should be compared to other associated properties to identify those that best represent +the person's historic contributions. Furthermore, a property is not eligible if its only +justification for significance is that it was owned or used by a person who is or was a +member of an identifiable profession, class, or social or ethnic group. The Graham- +Brooks Farm is not known to be associated with an individual or individuals +significant in our past. + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion C (architecture). For a property to be eligible under this Criterion, it +must retain integrity and either 1) embody distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or +method of construction; 2) represent the work of a master; 3) possess high artistic value; +or 4) represent a significant and distinguishable entity whose components lack individual +distinction. The Graham-Brooks Farm and its accompanying structures do not +represent a particular type, period, or method of construction, the work of a +master, or possess high artistic value. + +The Graham-Brooks Farm is not eligible for listing in the National Register +under Criterion D (potential to yield information). For a property to be eligible +under Criterion D, it must meet two requirements: 1) the property must have, or have +had, information to contribute to our understanding of human history or prehistory, and +2) the information must be considered important. The Graham-Brooks Farm does not +have the potential to yield important information to contribute to our +understanding of human history or prehistory. + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +14 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B4015 +Ashe County + +OMER. 4111•••• S S .11Mmo + +Outbuilding #1 + +I Graham-Brooks + +House + +Parcel +boundary + +Figure 4. Graham Brooks Farm - site plan + +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) + +15 (cid:9) + +4/1/03 + + Bridge No. 165, T. I. P. No. B-4015 +Ashe County + +Bibliography + +Ashe County Tax Maps. Located in Ashe County Courthouse, Jefferson, North +Carolina. + +Hood, Davyd Foard. 1978. "The Architecture of the New River Valley." In + +Carolina Dwelling: towards preservation of place, in celebration of the North +Carolina vernacular landscape , edited by Doug Swain. Raleigh, NC: North +Carolina State University. + +Keber, Robert. 1978. "Site Selection of Pre-1940 Mountain Houses." In + +Carolina Dwelling: towards preservation of place, in celebration of the North +Carolina vernacular landscape , edited by Doug Swain. Raleigh, NC: North +Carolina State University. + +Bishir, Catherine W., et al. A Guide to the Historic Architecture of Western North +Carolina. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1999. + +Wilcox, George. Interview with author. January 8, 2003. - Annual Report 2021 ↗ To our Shareholders +Fearnbach, Heather. "Replace Bridge No. 334 on SR 1351 Over the South Fork of +the New River, Watauga/ Ashe County, North Carolina, TIP No. B-3928." +Raleigh: North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office, Survey and +Planning Branch, 2002. -on all relevant risks in this regard, in particular its assessments of market and procurement risks, financial -risks (including currency risks as well as risks due to the COVID-19 pandemic) and organizational risks. +Fletcher, Arthur L. Ashe County, A History. Jefferson, NC: Ashe County Research -The accounting records, the audit reports from the statutory auditors and the Management Board’s and -Supervisory Board’s recommendation on the appropriation of net profit were made available to all -members of the Supervisory Board in a timely manner. At the meeting of the Audit Committee on February -22, 2022 and at the subsequent Supervisory Board meeting held on the same day, the statutory auditors -reported on the key results of their audit and discussed them in detail with the Management Board and the -members of the Supervisory Board. No discrepancies were detected. +Association, Inc. 1963. -The Supervisory Board reviewed in detail the annual financial statements, the combined management -report for PUMA SE and the PUMA Group, the Management Board’s and the Supervisory Board’s -recommendation on the appropriation of net profit and the consolidated financial statements and raised no -objections. In accordance with the recommendation of the Audit Committee, the Supervisory Board agreed -with the results of the audit of both statements and approved the annual financial statements of PUMA SE -and the consolidated financial statements for the financial year 2021. The 2021 annual financial statements -have thus been adopted. +Mattson, Alexander and Associates. "Historic Architectural Resources Survey -The Management Board and the Supervisory Board resolved to propose to the Annual General Meeting a -distribution of a dividend of € 0.72 per dividend entitled share to the shareholders for the financial year -2021. In this context, the liquidity situation of the Company, the financing and the effects on the capital -market were discussed. The payout is conditional to an overall sound macroeconomic environment. A total -amount of around € 107.7 million will be paid out in dividends from PUMA SE’s retained earnings. The -remaining retained earnings of around € 382.4 million will be carried forward. +Report, Replacement of Bridge No. 281 on SR 1358 Over Big Horse Creek, +Ashe County, TIP No. B-4014." Raleigh: North Carolina State Historic +Preservation Office, Survey and Planning Branch, 2000. -In its meeting on February 22, 2022, the Supervisory Board was presented the state of data collection for -the non-financial report in accordance with §§ 315c in conjunction with §§ 289c to 289e of the German -Commercial Code (HGB). As soon as the non-financial report is finalized, it will be submitted to the -Supervisory Board for approval and will be published on the website of the Company by April 30, 2022. +National Park Service. National Register Bulletin: How to Complete the National -THANKS +Register Registration Form. Washington DC: Department of the Interior, +1997. -We would like to express our gratitude and recognition to the Management Board, the management teams -at the Group companies, the Works Council and all our employees for their hard work and their outstanding -cooperation in 2021. +Weaver, Clarice, ed. Heritage of Ashe County, Volume II. West Jefferson, NC: Ashe -Herzogenaurach, February 22, 2022 +County Historical Society, 1994. -On behalf of the Supervisory Board +Circa, Inc. (cid:9) -Jean-François Palus -Chairman +19 (cid:9) -13 +4/1/03 diff --git a/q227/random_k4/random_2.md b/q227/random_k4/random_2.md index d0e4711d45467ad9a4bb5f563733b6d5247d3efa..1ac627c3d95d71bba88aff7ff8158f25e99f463e 100644 --- a/q227/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q227/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,806 +1,1642 @@ -Music and streaming -market study final report +RESEARCH ARTICLE + +The population genetics of human disease: +The case of recessive, lethal mutations + +Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim1,2*, Ziyue Gao3, Zachary Baker4, Jose´ Francisco Diesel5, +Yuval B. Simons1, Imran S. Haque6¤, Joseph Pickrell1,7‡, Molly Przeworski1,4‡ + +1 Department of Biological Sciences, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, +2 CAPES Foundation, Ministry of Education of Brazil, Brası´lia, DF, Brazil, 3 Howard Hughes Medical +Institution, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States of America, 4 Department of Systems Biology, +Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, 5 Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, +Santa Maria, RS, Brazil, 6 Counsyl, 180 Kimball Way, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America, +7 New York Genome Center, New York, NY, United States of America + +¤ Current address: Freenome, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America +‡ These authors co-supervised this work. +* guerraamorim@gmail.com + +Abstract + +Do the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations reflect a simple balance +between mutation and purifying selection? What other factors shape the prevalence of dis- +ease mutations? To begin to answer these questions, we focused on one of the simplest +cases: recessive mutations that alone cause lethal diseases or complete sterility. To this +end, we generated a hand-curated set of 417 Mendelian mutations in 32 genes reported to +cause a recessive, lethal Mendelian disease. We then considered analytic models of muta- +tion-selection balance in infinite and finite populations of constant sizes and simulations of +purifying selection in a more realistic demographic setting, and tested how well these mod- +els fit allele frequencies estimated from 33,370 individuals of European ancestry. In doing +so, we distinguished between CpG transitions, which occur at a substantially elevated rate, +and three other mutation types. Intriguingly, the observed frequency for CpG transitions is +slightly higher than expectation but close, whereas the frequencies observed for the three +other mutation types are an order of magnitude higher than expected, with a bigger deviation +from expectation seen for less mutable types. This discrepancy is even larger when subtle +fitness effects in heterozygotes or lethal compound heterozygotes are taken into account. +In principle, higher than expected frequencies of disease mutations could be due to wide- +spread errors in reporting causal variants, compensation by other mutations, or balancing +selection. It is unclear why these factors would have a greater impact on disease mutations +that occur at lower rates, however. We argue instead that the unexpectedly high frequency +of disease mutations and the relationship to the mutation rate likely reflect an ascertainment +bias: of all the mutations that cause recessive lethal diseases, those that by chance have +reached higher frequencies are more likely to have been identified and thus to have been +included in this study. Beyond the specific application, this study highlights the parameters +likely to be important in shaping the frequencies of Mendelian disease alleles. + +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 + +OPEN ACCESS + +Citation: Amorim CEG, Gao Z, Baker Z, Diesel JF, +Simons YB, Haque IS, et al. (2017) The population +genetics of human disease: The case of recessive, +lethal mutations. PLoS Genet 13(9): e1006915. +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 + +Editor: Philipp W. Messer, Cornell University, +UNITED STATES + +Received: December 4, 2016 + +Accepted: July 9, 2017 + +Published: September 28, 2017 + +Copyright: © 2017 Amorim et al. This is an open +access article distributed under the terms of the +Creative Commons Attribution License, which +permits unrestricted use, distribution, and +reproduction in any medium, provided the original +author and source are credited. + +Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are +within the paper and its Supporting Information +files and code from gitHub (https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease; https://github. +com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator). + +Funding: CEGA was partially funded by a Science +Without Borders fellowship from CAPES +foundation (BEX 8279/11-0) and Conselho +Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientı´fico e +Tecnolo´gico (PDE 201145/2015-4), Brazil. ZG was +partially supported by a postdoctoral fellowship +funded by Stanford Center for Computational, + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +1 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Evolutionary and Human Genomics. JFD was +funded by a Science Without Borders fellowship +from CAPES foundation (88888.038761/2013-00). +YBS was supported by NIH grant GM115889. The +work was partially supported by a Research +Initiative in Science and Engineering grant from +Columbia University and NIGMS grants +(GM121372) to JKP and MP. The computing in +this project was supported by two National +Institutes of Health instrumentation grants +(S10OD012351 and S10OD021764) received by +the Department of Systems Biology at Columbia +University. The funders had no role in study +design, data collection and analysis, decision to +publish, or preparation of the manuscript. + +Competing interests: The authors have declared +that no competing interests exist. + +Author summary + +What determines the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations? To begin to +answer this question, we focus on one of the simplest cases: mutations that cause com- +pletely recessive, lethal Mendelian diseases. We first review theory about what to expect +from mutation and selection in a population of finite size and generate predictions based +on simulations using a plausible demographic scenario of recent human evolution. For a +highly mutable type of mutation, transitions at CpG sites, we find that the predictions are +close to the observed frequencies of recessive lethal disease mutations. For less mutable +types, however, predictions substantially under-estimate the observed frequency. We dis- +cuss possible explanations for the discrepancy and point to a complication that, to our +knowledge, is not widely appreciated: that there exists ascertainment bias in disease muta- +tion discovery. Specifically, we suggest that alleles that have been identified to date are +likely the ones that by chance have reached higher frequencies and are thus more likely to +have been mapped. More generally, our study highlights the factors that influence the fre- +quencies of Mendelian disease alleles. -Executive summary +Introduction -29 November 2022 +New disease mutations arise in heterozygotes and either drift to higher frequencies or are rap- +idly purged from the population, depending on the strength of selection and the demographic +history of the population [1–6]. Elucidating the relative contributions of mutation, natural +selection and genetic drift will help to understand why disease alleles persist in humans. +Answers to these questions are also of practical importance, in informing how genetic varia- +tion data can be used to identify additional disease mutations [7]. + +In this regard, rare, Mendelian diseases, which are caused by single highly penetrant and +deleterious alleles, are perhaps most amenable to investigation. A simple model for the persis- +tence of mutations that lead to Mendelian diseases is that their frequencies reflect an equilib- +rium between their introduction by mutation and elimination by purifying selection, i.e., that +they should be found at “mutation-selection balance” [4]. In finite populations, random drift +leads to stochastic changes in the frequency of any mutation, so demographic history, in addi- +tion to mutation and natural selection, plays an important role in shaping the frequency distri- +bution of deleterious mutations [3]. + +Another factor that may be important in determining the frequencies of highly penetrant + +disease mutations is genetic interactions. The mutation-selection balance model has been +extended to scenarios with more than one disease allele, as is often seen for Mendelian diseases +[8,9]. When compound heterozygotes have the same fitness as homozygotes for the disease +allele (i.e., there is no complementation), the combined frequency of all disease alleles can be +modeled similarly as the bi-allelic case, with the mutation rate given by the sum of the muta- +tion rate to each disease allele [8]. In other cases, a disease mutation may be rescued by another +mutation in the same gene [10–12] or by a modifier locus elsewhere in the genome that modu- +lates the severity of the disease symptoms or the penetrance of the disease allele (e.g. [13–15]). +For a subset of disease alleles that are recessive, an alternative model for their persistence in +the population is that there is an advantage to carrying one copy but a disadvantage to carrying +two or none, such that the alleles persist due to overdominance, a form of balancing selection. +Well known examples include sickle cell anemia, thalassemia and G6PD deficiency in populations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +2 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +living where malaria exerts strong selection pressures [16]. The importance of overdominance in +maintaining the high frequency of disease mutations is unknown beyond these specific cases. + +Here, we tested hypotheses about the persistence of mutations that cause lethal, recessive, +Mendelian disorders. This case provides a good starting point, because a large number of Men- +delian disorders have been mapped (e.g., genes have already been associated with >56% of +Mendelian disease phenotypes; [17]). Moreover, while the fitness effects of most diseases are +hard to estimate, for recessive lethal diseases, the selection coefficient is clearly 1 for homozy- +gote carriers in the absence of modern medical care (which, when available, became so only in +the last couple of generations, a timescale that is much too short to substantially affect disease +allele frequencies). Moreover, assuming mutation-selection balance in an infinite population +and no effects in heterozygotes would suggest that, given a per base pair (bp) mutation rate u +ffiffiffi +, i.e., ~10−4 +on the order of 10−8 per generation [18], the frequency of such alleles would be +u +[4]. Thus, sample sizes in human genetics are now sufficiently large that we should be able to +observe completely recessive, lethal disease alleles segregating in heterozygote carriers. + +p + +To this end, we compiled genetic information for a set of 417 mutations reported to cause +fatal, recessive Mendelian diseases and estimated the frequencies of the disease-causing alleles +from large exome datasets. We then compared these data to the expected frequencies of delete- +rious alleles based on models of mutation-selection balance in order to evaluate the effects of +mutation rates and other factors in influencing these frequencies. + +Results + +Mendelian recessive disease allele set + +We relied on two datasets, one that describes 173 autosomal recessive diseases [19] and another +from a genetic testing laboratory (Counsyl [20]; ) that includes 110 +recessive diseases of clinical interest. From these lists, we obtained a set of 44 “recessive lethal” dis- +eases associated with 45 genes (S1 Table), requiring that at least one of the following conditions is +met: (i) in the absence of treatment, the affected individuals die of the disease before reproductive +age, (ii) reproduction is completely impaired in patients of both sexes, (iii) the phenotype includes +severe mental retardation that in practice precludes reproduction, or (iv) the phenotype includes +severely compromised physical development, again precluding reproduction. + +Based on clinical genetics datasets and the medical literature (see Methods for details), we +were able to confirm that 417 Single Nucleotide Variants (SNVs) in 32 (of the 44) genes had +been reported with compelling evidence of association to the severe form of the corresponding +disease and an early-onset, as well as no indication of effects in heterozygote carriers (S2 Table). +By this approach, we obtained a set of mutations for which, at least in principle, there is no het- +erozygote effect, i.e., for which the dominance coefficient h = 0 in a model with relative fitness +of 1 for the homozygote for the reference allele, 1-hs for the heterozygote, and 1-s for the homo- +zygote for the deleterious allele, and the selective coefficient s is 1. - Executive summary +A large subset of these mutations (29.3%) consists of transitions at CpG sites (henceforth +CpGti), which occur at a highly elevated rates (~17-fold higher on average) compared to other +mutation types, namely CpG transversions, and non-CpG transitions and transversions [18]. +This proportion is in agreement with previous estimates for a smaller set of disease genes [21] +and for DMD [22]. -Introduction +Empirical distribution of allele frequencies of disease mutations in Europe + +Allele frequency data for the 417 variants were obtained from the Exome Aggregation Consor- +tium (ExAC) for 60,706 individuals, of whom 33,370 are non-Finnish Europeans [23]. Out of + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +3 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +the 417 variants associated with putative recessive lethal diseases, three were found homozy- +gous in at least one individual in this dataset (rs35269064, p.Arg108Leu in ASS1; rs28933375, +p.Asn252Ser in PRF1; and rs113857788, p.Gln1352His in CFTR). Available data quality infor- +mation for these variants does not suggest genotype calling artifacts (S2 Table). Since these +diseases have severe symptoms that lead to early death without treatment and these ExAC indi- +viduals are healthy (i.e., do not manifest severe Mendelian diseases) [23], the reported muta- +tions are likely errors in pathogenicity classification or cases of incomplete penetrance (see a +similar observation for CFTR and DHCR7 in [24]). We therefore excluded them from our anal- +yses. In addition to the mutations present in homozygotes, we also filtered out sites that had +lower coverage in ExAC (see Methods), resulting in a final dataset of 385 variants in 32 genes +(S2 Table). + +Genotypes for a subset (91) of these mutations were also available for a larger sample size +(76,314 individuals with self-reported European ancestry) generated by the company Counsyl +(S3 Table). A comparison of the allele frequencies in this larger dataset to that of ExAC sug- +gests that the allele frequencies for individual variants are concordant between the two datasets +(Pearson’s correlation coefficient of 0.79, S1 Fig) and that the overall distributions do not differ +appreciably (Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.23). Thus, both data sets appear to reflect +the general distribution of these disease alleles in Europeans. In what follows, we focused on +ExAC, which includes a greater number of disease mutations. + +Models of mutation-selection balance + +To generate expectations for the frequencies of these disease mutations under mutation-selec- +tion balance, we considered models of infinite and finite populations of constant size [3] and +conducted forward simulations using a plausible demographic model for African and Euro- +pean populations [25] (see Methods for details). In all these models, there is a wild-type allele +(A) and a deleterious allele (a, which could also represent a class of distinct deleterious alleles +with the same fitness effect) at each site, such that the relative fitness of individuals of geno- +types AA, Aa, or aa is given respectively by: + +• wAA = 1; + +• wAa = 1-hs; + +• waa = 1-s; + +The mutation rate from A to a is u; we assume that there are no back mutations. +For a constant population of infinite size, Wright [26] showed that under these conditions, +there exists a stable equilibrium between mutation and selection, when the selection pressure +is sufficiently strong (s>>u). In particular, when the deleterious effect of allele a is completely +recessive (h = 0), its equilibrium frequency q is given by: + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +: +u=s + +q ¼ + +ð1Þ + +For a finite population of constant size, Nei [3] derived the mean (Eq 2) and variance (Eq 3) + +of the frequency of a fully recessive deleterious mutation (h = 0) based on a diffusion model, +leading to: + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +(cid:22)q ¼ + +Gð2Nu þ 1=2Þ +p +Gð2NuÞ + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2Ns + +; + +q ¼ u=s (cid:0) (cid:22)q2; +s2 + +ð2Þ + +ð3Þ + +4 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +where N is the diploid population size and Γ is the gamma function (see Simons et al. [1] for a +similar approximation). + +In a finite population, the mean frequency, (cid:22)q, therefore depends on assumptions about the +population mutation rate (2Nu). If the population mutation rate is high, such that 2Nu>>1, (cid:22)q +is approximated by + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +u=s + +(cid:22)q (cid:25) + +ð4Þ + +which is independent of the population size and equal to the equilibrium frequency in an infi- +nite population, i.e., the right hand side of Eq (1). The important difference between the two +models above is that in a finite population, there is a distribution of frequencies q (because of +genetic drift), whose variance is given in Eq (3), rather than a single value, as in an infinite +population. + +In contrast, when the finite population has a low population mutation rate (2Nu<<1), the + +mean allele frequency, (cid:22)q, is approximated by: +p + +(cid:22)q (cid:25) u + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +2pN=s + +which depends on the population size [3]. + +ð5Þ + +We note that Nei [3] assumed a Wright-Fisher model, in which there is no distinction + +between census and the effective population sizes. However, when the two differ, it is the effec- +tive population size that governs the dynamics of deleterious alleles, so the N in the analytical +results in fact represents the effective population size. In humans, the mutation rate at each bp +is very small (on the order of 10−8 [18]) and the effective population size not that large, even +recently [27,28], so the second approximation should apply when considering each single site +independently. + +The expectation and variance of the frequency of a fatal, fully recessive allele (i.e., s = 1, + +h = 0) are then given by: + +and + +p + +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2pN + +; + +(cid:22)q ¼ u + +q ¼ u (cid:0) (cid:22)q2 ¼ uð1 (cid:0) 2pNuÞ (cid:25) u: +s2 + +ð6Þ + +ð7Þ + +This single site model implicitly ignores the existence of compound heterozygosity in model- +ing the strength of selection acting on an individual site. + +Comparing mutation-selection balance models + +Although an infinite population size has often been assumed when modeling deleterious allele +frequencies (e.g. [5,29–32]), predictions under this assumption can differ markedly from what +is expected from models of finite population sizes, assuming plausible parameter values for +humans. For example, the long-term estimate of the effective population size from total poly- +morphism levels is ~20,000 individuals (assuming a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 per bp per gen- +eration [18] and diversity levels of 0.1% [33]). In this case and considering a mutation rate of +1.5 x 10−8 for exons (which have a higher mutation rate than the rest of the genome, because of +their base composition [34]), the average deleterious allele frequency in the model of finite +population size is ~23-fold lower than that in the infinite population model (Fig 1). + +Because the human population size has not been constant and changes in the population +size can affect the frequencies of deleterious alleles in the population (e.g. [2,35]), we also simu- +lated the population dynamics of disease alleles under a plausible demographic model for + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +5 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +European populations based on Tennessen et al. [25]. The original model assumes a genome- +wide mutation rate of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation, when current, more direct estimates +are approximately two-fold smaller [18,34,36]. We therefore rescaled the demographic parame- +ters of the Tennessen et al. model, based on a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] (see Methods). As- +suming a mutation rate of 1.5 x 10−8 per bp (as recently estimated for exons [34]), the mean +allele frequency of a lethal, recessive disease allele obtained from this model was 7.10 x 10−6, +~1.33-fold higher than expected for a constant population size model with Ne = 20,000 (Fig 1). +The mean frequency seen in simulations instead matches the expectation for a constant popula- +tion size of 35,651 individuals (see Methods and S2A Fig). Increasing the effective population +size in a constant size model is not enough to capture the dynamics of disease alleles appropri- +ately, however. For example, if simulation results obtained under the Tennessen et al. [25] +demographic model are compared to those for simulations of a constant population size of Ne = +35,651, the mean allele frequencies match, but the distributions of allele frequencies are signifi- +cantly different (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, p-value < 10−15; S2B and S2C Fig). These findings +thus confirm the importance of incorporating demographic history into models for under- +standing the population dynamics of disease alleles [5,37,38]. In what follows, we therefore +tested the fit of the more realistic demographic model [25] (and variants of it) to the observed +allele frequencies. + +Fig 1. Expected allele frequencies in a population, according to mutation-selection balance models. +The blue bar denotes the expected allele frequency under an infinite population size, the green bar the mean +under a finite constant population, and the red bar the mean under a plausible demographic model for +European populations; for this last case, the entire distribution across 100,000 simulations is shown in the +grey histogram. All models assume s = 1 and h = 0, i.e., fully recessive, lethal mutations. For the finite +constant population size model, we present the mean frequency for a population size of 20,000 (see S2A Fig +for other choices). Population allele frequencies (q) were transformed to log10(q), and those q = 0 were set to +10−7 for visual purposes, but indicated as “0” on the X-axis. The density of the distribution is plotted on a log- +scale on the Y-axis. The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation in all models. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g001 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +6 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Comparing empirical and expected distributions of disease allele +frequencies + +The mutation rate from wild-type allele to disease allele, u, is a critical parameter in predicting +the frequencies of a deleterious allele [4,39]. To model disease alleles, we considered four muta- +tion types separately, with the goal of capturing most of the fine-scale heterogeneity in muta- +tion rates [27,36,40,41]: transitions in methylated CpG sites (CpGti) and three less mutable +types, namely transversions in CpG sites (CpGtv) and transitions and transversions outside a +CpG site (nonCpGti and nonCpGtv, respectively). In order to control for the methylation sta- +tus of CpG sites, we excluded 12 CpGti that occurred in CpG islands, which tend not to be +methylated and thus are likely to have a lower mutation rate [36] (following Moorjani et al. +[42]). To allow for heterogeneity in mutation rates within each one of these four classes consid- +ered, we modeled the within-class variation in mutation rates according to a lognormal distri- +bution (see details in Methods and [27]). + +For each mutation type, we then compared the mean allele frequency obtained from simu- +lations to what is observed in ExAC, running 100,000 replicates. To this end, we matched sim- +ulations to the empirical data with regard to the number of individuals sampled and number +of mutations observed of each mutation type and focused the analysis on the largest sample of +the same common ancestry, namely Non-Finnish Europeans (n = 33,370) (Fig 2A). We found +significant differences between empirical and expected mean frequencies for nonCpGtv (30- +fold higher on average; two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4; see Methods for details) and nonCpGti +(15-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4), but only marginally so for CpGtv +(5-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value = 0.08). The mean frequency for CpGti is also +somewhat higher than expected, but insignificantly so (1.17-fold higher on average, two-tailed +p-value = 0.59). Intriguingly, the discrepancy between observed and expected frequencies +becomes smaller as the mutation rate increases (Fig 2B). + +Two additional factors that we have not included in our model should further decrease the +predicted frequencies of disease alleles. Given that frequencies in ExAC are already unexpect- +edly high, these factors would only exacerbate the discrepancy between observed and expected +frequencies of deleterious alleles. First, we have ignored the effects of compound heterozygos- +ity, the case in which combinations of two distinct pathogenic alleles in the same gene lead to +lethality. This phenomenon is known to be common [43], and indeed, in the 320 cases in +which we were able to obtain this information, 58.44% were initially identified in compound +heterozygotes. In the presence of compound heterozygosity, each deleterious mutation will be +selected against not only when present in two copies within the same individual, but also in +the presence of lethal mutations at other sites. Since the purging effect of selection against +compound heterozygotes was not modeled in simulations, we would predict the frequency of a +deleterious mutation to be even lower than shown (e.g., in Fig 2A). + +In order to model the effect of compound heterozygosity in our simulations, we re-ran our +simulations, but focusing on a gene rather than a single site and so considering the sum of fre- +quencies of all known recessive lethal alleles within a gene. In these simulations, we used the +same set-up as in the site level analysis, except for the mutation rate, U, which is now the sum +of the mutation rates uj at each site j that is known to cause a severe and early onset form of the +disease [8] (S2 Table; see Methods for details). This approach does not consider the contribu- +tion of other mutations in the genes that cause the mild and/or late onset forms of the disease, +and implicitly assumes that all combinations of known recessive lethal alleles of the same gene +have the same fitness effect as homozygotes. Comparing observed frequencies of disease alleles +for each gene to predictions generated by simulation, about a fourth of the 27 genes for which +we implemented the gene-level analysis (see Methods) differ from the expected distribution at + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +7 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +8 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Fig 2. Comparison between expected and observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease mutations. (A) Shown +are the expected and observed mean sample frequencies of disease mutations for four different mutation types. The title of the panel +indicates the mutation type, followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type considered in this study, with the p-value for the +difference between observed and expected mean frequencies given below. Distributions in grey are the mean sample allele frequencies +across K mutations based on 100,000 simulations, and rely on a plausible demographic model for European populations [25] (see +Methods). Blue bars represent the observed mean frequencies of the four mutation types, estimated from 33,370 individuals of +European ancestry from ExAC. (B) Fold increase in the observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expected, as a function of the +mutation rate u (on a log-scale), for each of the four mutation classes. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g002 + +the 5% level, with a clear overall trend for observed frequencies to be above expectation (S4 +Table; Fig 3; Fisher’s combined probability test p-value = 6 x 10−8). + +This finding is even more surprising than it may seem, because we are far from knowing the +complete mutation target for each gene, i.e., all the sites at which mutations could cause the dis- +ease. If there are additional, undiscovered sites in the gene at which mutations are fatal when +carried in combination with a known recessive lethal mutation, the purging effect of purifying +selection on the known mutations will be under-estimated in our simulations, leading us to +over-estimate the expected frequencies of the known mutations in simulations. Therefore, our +predictions are, if anything, an over-estimate of the expected allele frequency, and the discrep- +ancy between predicted and the observed is likely even larger than what we found. + +The other factor that we did not consider in simulations but would reduce the expected +allele frequencies is a subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes, as has been documented in Dro- +sophila for example [44]. To evaluate potential fitness effects in heterozygotes when none had +been documented in humans, we considered the phenotypic consequences of orthologous +gene knockouts in mouse. We were able to retrieve information on phenotypes for both homo- +zygote and heterozygote mice for only eight out of the 32 genes, namely ASS1, CFTR, DHCR7, +NPC1, POLG, PRF1, SLC22A5, and SMPD1. For all eight, homozygote knockout mice pre- +sented similar phenotypes as affected humans, and heterozygotes showed a milder but + +Fig 3. Sample allele frequencies at the gene level. The expectation (grey) is based on 1000 simulations, assuming no fitness decrease in +heterozygotes, but allowing for compound heterozygosity (see Methods for details). The sum of allele frequencies of known recessive lethal +disease mutations in each gene (purple bars) was obtained from ExAC considering 33,370 European individuals. Genes are ordered according +to the two-tailed p-value (S4 Table; see Methods). Genes are bolded when they differ significantly from expectation (at the 5% level). Violin +plots show the distribution of the log10 combined allele frequency of all segregating alleles obtained from simulations and boxes represent the +fraction of simulations in which no deleterious allele was observed in the simulated sample at present time. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g003 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +9 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +detectable phenotype (S5 Table). The magnitude of the heterozygote effect of these mutations +in humans is unclear, but the finding with knockout mice makes it plausible that there exists a +very small fitness decrease in heterozygotes in humans as well, potentially not enough to have +been recognized in clinical investigations but enough to have a marked impact on the allele fre- +quencies of the disease mutations. Indeed, even if the fitness effect in heterozygotes were as +small as h = 1%, a 79% decrease in the mean allele frequency of the disease allele is expected +relative to the case with complete recessivity (h = 0) (S3 Fig). + +Discussion + +To investigate the population genetics of human disease, we focused on mutations that cause +Mendelian, recessive disorders that lead to early death or completely impaired reproduction. +We sought to understand to what extent the frequencies of these mutations fit the expectation +based on a simple balance between the input of mutations and the purging by purifying selec- +tion, as well as how other mechanisms might affect these frequencies. Many studies implicitly +or explicitly compare known disease allele frequencies to expectations from mutation-selection +balance [5,29–32]. In this study, we tested whether known recessive lethal disease alleles as a +class fit these expectations, and found that, under a sensible demographic model for European +population history with purifying selection only in homozygotes, the expectations fit the +observed disease allele frequencies poorly: the mean empirical frequencies of disease alleles are +substantially above expectation for all mutation types (although not significantly so for CpGti), +and the fold increase in observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expectation decreases +with increased mutation rate (Fig 2). Furthermore, including possible effects of compound he- +terozygosity and subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes will only exacerbate the discrepancy. +In principle, higher than expected disease allele frequencies could be explained by at least +six (non-mutually exclusive) factors: (i) widespread errors in reporting the causal variants; (ii) +misspecification of the demographic model, (iii) misspecification of the mutation rate; (iv) +reproductive compensation; (v) overdominance of disease alleles; and (vi) low penetrance of +disease mutations. Because widespread mis-annotation of the causal variants in disease muta- +tion databases had previously been reported [23,45,46], we tried to minimize the effect of such +errors on our analyses by filtering out any case that lacked compelling evidence of association +with a recessive lethal disease, reducing our initial set of 769 mutations to 385 in which we had +greater confidence (see Methods for details). + +We also explored the effects of having misspecified recent demographic history or the +mutation rate. Based on very large samples, it has been estimated that population growth in +Europe was stronger than what we considered in our simulations [47,48]. When we considered +higher growth rates, such that the current effective population size is up to 10-fold larger than +that of the rescaled Tennessen model, we observed an increase in the expected frequency of +recessive disease alleles and a larger number of segregating sites (S4 Fig, columns A-E). How- +ever, the impact of larger growth rate is insufficient to explain the observed discrepancy: the +allele frequencies observed in ExAC are still on average an order of magnitude larger than +expected based on a model with a 10-fold larger current effective population size than the one +initially considered [25] (S4 Fig). In turn, population substructure within Europe would only +increase the number of homozygotes relative to what was modeled in our simulations (through +the Wahlund effect [49]) and expose more recessive alleles to selection, thus decreasing the +expected allele frequencies and exacerbating the discrepancy that we report. + +To explore the effects of error in the mutation rate, we considered a 50% higher mean + +mutation rate than what has been estimated for exons [34], beyond what seems plausible based +on current estimates on human mutation rates [42]. Except for the mean mutation rate (now + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +10 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +set to 2.25 x 10−8), all other parameters used for these simulations (i.e. the variance in mutation +rate across simulations, the demographic model [25], absence of selective effect in heterozy- +gotes, and selection coefficient) were kept the same as the ones used for generating S4 Fig, col- +umn A. The observed mean frequency remains significantly above what those predicted and +qualitative conclusions are unchanged (S4 Fig, column F). + +Another factor to consider is that for disease phenotypes that are lethal very early on in life, + +there may be partial or complete reproductive compensation (e.g. [50]). This phenomenon +would decrease the fitness effects of the recessive lethal mutations and could therefore lead to +an increase in the allele frequency in data relative to what we predict for a selection coefficient +of 1. There are no reasons, however, for this phenomenon to correlate with the mutation rate, +as seen in Fig 2B. + +The other two factors, overdominance and low penetrance, are likely explanations for a sub- +set of cases. For instance, CFTR, the gene in which some mutations lead to cystic fibrosis, is the +farthest above expectation (p-value < 0.004; Fig 3). It was long noted that there is an unusually +high frequency of the CFTR deletion ΔF508 in Europeans, which led to speculation that disease +alleles of this gene may be subject to over-dominance ([51,52], but see [53]). Regardless, it is +known that disease mutations in this gene can complement one another [10,11] and that modi- +fier loci in other genes also influence their penetrance [11,14]. Consistent with variable pene- +trance, Chen et al. [24] identified three purportedly healthy individuals carrying two copies of +disease mutations in this gene. Similarly, DHCR7, the gene associated with the Smith-Lemli- +Opitz syndrome, is somewhat above expectation in our analysis (p-value = 0.056; Fig 3) and +healthy individuals were found to be homozygous carriers of putatively lethal disease alleles in +other studies [24]. These observations make it plausible that, in a subset of cases (particularly +for CFTR), the high frequency of deleterious mutations associated with recessive, lethal diseases +are due to genetic interactions that modify the penetrance of certain recessive disease mutations. +It is hard to assess the importance of this phenomenon in driving the general pattern that we +observe, but two factors argue against it being a sufficient explanation for our findings at the +level of single sites. First, when we removed 130 mutations in CFTR and 12 in DHCR7, the two +genes that were outliers at the gene level (Fig 3; S4 Table) and for which there is evidence of +incomplete penetrance [24], the discrepancy between observed and expected allele frequencies +is barely impacted (S5 Fig). Moreover, there is no obvious reason why the degree of incomplete +penetrance would vary systematically with the mutation rate of a site, as observed (Fig 2B). + +Instead, it seems plausible that there is an ascertainment bias in disease allele discovery and +mutation identification [52,54,55]. Unlike missense or protein-truncating variants, Mendelian +disease mutations cannot be annotated based solely on DNA sequences, and their identifica- +tion requires reliable diagnosis of affected individuals (usually in more than one pedigree) fol- +lowed by mapping of the underlying gene/mutation. Therefore, those mutations that have +been identified to date are likely the ones that are segregating at higher frequencies in the pop- +ulation. Moreover, mutation-selection balance models predict that the frequency of a deleteri- +ous mutation should correlate with the mutation rate. Together, these considerations suggest +that disease variants of a highly mutable class, such as CpGti, are more likely to have been +mapped and that the mean frequency of mapped mutations will tend to be only slightly above +all disease mutations in that class. In contrast, less mutable disease mutations are less likely to +have been discovered to date, and the mean frequency of the subset of mutations that have +been identified may tend to be far above that of all mutations in that class. + +To quantify these effects, we modeled the ascertainment of disease mutations both analyti- + +cally and in simulations. A large proportion of recessive Mendelian disease mutations were +identified in inbred populations, likely because inbreeding leads to an excess of homozygotes +compared to expected under random mating, increasing the probability that a recessive + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +11 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +mutation would be discovered as causing a disease. Therefore, we modeled ascertainment in +disease discovery in human populations with a plausible degree of inbreeding (see Methods). +As expected, we found that for a given mutation type, the probability of ascertainment in- +creases with the sample size of the putative disease ascertainment study (na) and the average +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study (Fa); in addition, the average allele fre- +quency of mutations that have been identified is always higher than that of all existing muta- +tions, and the discrepancy decreases as the ascertainment probability increases (Table 1). +Furthermore, comparison across different mutation types reveals that a higher mutation rate +increases the probability of disease mutations being ascertained (Table 1 and S6 Fig) and +decreases the magnitude of bias in the estimated allele frequency relative to the mutation class +as a whole (Table 1). In summary, among all the possible aforementioned explanations for the +observed discrepancy between empirical and expected mean allele frequencies, the ascertain- +ment bias hypothesis is the only one that also explains why it is more pronounced for less +mutable mutation types (Fig 2B). + +One implication of this hypothesis is that there are numerous sites at which mutations +cause recessive lethal diseases yet to be discovered, particularly at non-CpG sites. More gener- +ally, this ascertainment bias complicates the interpretation of observed allele frequencies in +terms of the selection pressures acting on disease alleles. Beyond this specific point, our study +illustrates how the large sample sizes now made available to researchers in the context of proj- +ects like ExAC [23] can be used not only for direct discovery of disease variants, but also to test +why disease alleles are segregating in the population and to understand at what frequencies we +might expect to find them in the future. + +Methods +Disease allele set + +In order to identify single nucleotide variants within the 42 genes associated with lethal, reces- +sive Mendelian diseases (S1 Table), we initially relied on the ClinVar dataset [56] (accessed on + +Table 1. For a given set of parameters na (the sample size in a putative disease ascertainment study) and Fa (the average inbreeding coefficient of +the population in which the study is being performed), we report the probability of a recessive, lethal mutation being ascertained, as well as the +fold increase in mean allele frequencies of the ascertained cases (qa) in relation to the mean frequencies of all mutations for each mutation type +(qu), based on simulations (see Methods for details). For a similar result derived from analytical modeling, see S6 Fig. Parameters for this step of the sim- +ulation correspond to plausible scenarios for human populations with widespread inbreeding (e.g., Fa = 1/16 corresponds to offspring of first-cousin marriage). +The last column in the bottom panel shows the fold increase of the mean allele frequency observed in ExAC in relation to simulations based on the Tennessen +et al. [25] demographic model (see Methods). Mutation rates u per bp, per generation were obtained from a large human pedigree study [18]. + +Parameter + +na +Fa +Mutation type (u) + +CpGti (1.12e-7) + +CpGtv (9.59e-9) + +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) + +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) + +CpGti (1.12e-7) + +CpGtv (9.59e-9) + +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) + +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) + +10,000 + +1/16 + +0.0150 + +0.0014 + +0.0009 + +0.0005 + +27.6 + +284.1 + +455.7 + +716.5 + +10,000 + +1/8 + +0.0247 + +0.0024 + +0.0015 + +0.0010 + +Simulation settings + +100,000 + +1/8 + +100,000 + +1/6 + +Probability of a mutation being ascertained + +0.0968 + +0.0104 + +0.0067 + +0.0044 + +0.1125 + +0.0124 + +0.0074 + +0.0050 + +500,000 + +1/8 + +0.1858 + +0.0235 + +0.0146 + +0.0091 + +Fold increase in allele frequency due to ascertainment bias + +22.3 + +222.6 + +335.6 + +577.4 + +9.0 + +81.2 + +126.1 + +192.9 + +8.0 + +70.2 + +114.8 + +174.1 + +5.2 + +40.6 + +64.7 + +103.6 + +ExAC + +- + +- + +- + +- + +1.17 + +5.4 -1. - -2. - -Music streaming has transformed how consumers listen to music. The rise of -music streaming has given consumers easy access to large catalogues of -music covering an array of genres and time periods for a fixed monthly price, -or free with ads. As music streaming services have grown in popularity, -consumer outcomes have improved significantly. Between 2009 and 2021 the -monthly price of individual music streaming subscriptions has fallen by more -than 20% in real terms because the price of these plans has not kept pace -with inflation. At the same time, consumers have gained access to more -music and more innovative and better quality services, for example higher -quality audio, new video content and synced song lyrics. - -Consumers have widely adopted music streaming -– in the UK in 2021 there were 39 million monthly -active users of music streaming services and -there were over 138 billion streams. Streaming is -now the primary means for artists and labels to -distribute music and has been pivotal in securing -the sector’s recovery from piracy. - -1 - - 3. - -4. - -5. - -6. - -7. - -Some parts of the market have improved for artists in recent years, with more -choice about the type of deals with record labels available and more able to -directly release their music on streaming services. Average royalty rates in -major deals for new artists have increased steadily from an average of 19.7% -in 2012 to 23.3% in 2021. For songwriters, the share of revenues going to -publishing rights has increased significantly from 8% in 2008 to 15% in 2021. - -Whilst outcomes are good for consumers and generally improving for -creators, we note that to some extent changes in the sector, precipitated by -streaming, have made it harder for some creators. Reduced barriers to entry -and more choice on how to distribute music has meant there are more artists -than ever and, therefore, creators face more artists and songs to compete -with for streaming revenues. Not only that, but the convenience of streaming -means that older music is enjoying a resurgence of popularity, meaning that -today’s artists need to work harder than ever to grab listeners’ attention. - -These factors may be exacerbated by the fact that it is challenging for music -companies to know who among the growing pool of creators will be -successful. This inherent uncertainty combined with consumer tastes that -tend to tip to a relatively small number of artists means that it is challenging -for creators to succeed. We do not think that these factors arise from how -firms compete in the market. - -We have found that it is unlikely that the outcomes that concern many -stakeholders are primarily driven by competition. Consequently, it is unlikely -that a competition intervention would improve outcomes overall, and release -more money in the system to pay creators more. In such circumstances, there -is a greater risk that a competition intervention will result in unintended -consequences and worse outcomes for both consumers and creators. The -costs, risks and uncertainty created by a market investigation (which could run -for two years) would be imposed on the industry and borne, ultimately, by -consumers. We have therefore decided to not undertake a market -investigation. - -While there is limited potential for a competition intervention to improve -outcomes, there remains a broader policy debate about the optimal -distribution of existing revenues. We think it is a matter for Government and -policymakers to determine whether the current split is appropriate and fair, -and to explore whether wider policy interventions are required, for example -those relating to the copyright framework and how music streaming licensing -rates are set. We hope that our final findings provide insights that will be -helpful for that continuing debate. +15.2 +30.0 + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.t001 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +12 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +June 3rd, 2015). We filtered out any variant that is an indel or a more complex copy number +variant or that is ever classified as benign or likely benign in ClinVar (whether or not it is also +classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic). By this approach, we obtained 769 SNVs +described as pathogenic or likely pathogenic. For each one of these variants, we searched the +literature for evidence that it is exclusively associated to the lethal and early onset form of the +disease and was never reported as causing the mild and/or late-onset form of the disease. We +considered effects in the absence of medical treatment, as we were interested in the selection +pressures acting on the alleles over evolutionary time scales rather than in the last one or two +generations, i.e., the period over which treatment became available for some of diseases con- +sidered. To evaluate the impact of treatment, we decreased s from 1 to 0 (i.e., we assumed a +complete absence of selective effects due to treatment) in the last three generations and com- +pared the mean allele frequencies across 100,000 simulations implemented with or without +this readjustment in selection coefficient. Because of the stochastic nature of the simulations, +we repeated this pairwise comparison 10 times in order to get a range of expected increase in +allele frequencies. We observed only a minor increase in the mean allele frequency (2.6% at +most) across the 10 replicates. This simulation procedure corresponds to a scenario in which +there is an extremely effective treatment for all diseases for the past three generations, which is +an overestimate of the effect and length of treatment for the disease set considered. + +Variants with mention of incomplete penetrance (i.e. for which homozygotes were not +always affected) or with known effects in heterozygote carriers were removed from the analy- +sis. This process yielded 417 SNVs in 32 genes associated with distinct Mendelian recessive +lethal disorders (S2 Table). Although these mutations were purportedly associated with +completely recessive diseases, we sought to examine whether there would be possible, unre- +ported effects in heterozygous carriers. To this end, we used the Mouse Genome Database +(MGD) [57] (accessed July 29th, 2015) and were able to retrieve information for both homozy- +gote and heterozygote mice for eight out of the 32 genes (all of which with a homologue in +mice) (S5 Table). + +In addition to the information provided by ClinVar for each one of these variants, we con- + +sidered the immediate sequence context of each SNV, to tailor the mutation rate estimate +accordingly [18]. To do so, we used an in-house Python script and the human genome refer- +ence sequence hg19 from UCSC (). + +Genetic datasets +The Exome Aggregation Consortium (ExAC) [23] was accessed on August 9th, 2016. The data +consist of genotype frequencies for 60,706 individuals, assigned after Principal Component +Analysis to one of seven population labels: African (n = 5,203), East Asian (n = 4,327), Finnish +(n = 3,307), Latino (n = 5,789), Non-Finnish European (n = 33,370), South Asian (n = 8,256) +and “other” (n = 454) [23]. We focused our analyses on those individuals of Non-Finnish +European descent, because they constitute the largest sample size from a single ancestry group. +We note that, some diseases mutations, for instance, those in ASPA, HEXA and SMPD1, are +known to be especially prevalent in Ashkenazi Jewish populations, which could potentially +bias our results if Ashkenazi Jewish individuals constituted a great portion of the sample we +considered. However, this sample includes only ~2,000 (~6%) Ashkenazi individuals (Dr. +Daniel MacArthur, personal communication). + +From the initial 417 mutations, we filtered out three that were homozygous in at least one + +individual in ExAC and 29 that had lower coverage, i.e., fewer than 80% of the individuals +were sequenced to at least 15x. This approach left us with a set of 385 mutations with a + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +13 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +minimum coverage of 27x per sample and an average coverage of 69x per sample (S2 Table). +For 248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies, ExAC reported the number of non-Finnish +European individuals that were sequenced, which was on average 32,881 individuals [23]. For +the remaining 137 sites, we did not have this information. Nonetheless, the coverage across all +samples is reported and does not differ significantly between the two sets of sites (by a Kolmo- +gorov-Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90; S7 Fig). We therefore assumed that mean number of indi- +viduals covered for all sites was 32,881 and used this number to obtain sample frequencies +from simulations, as explained below. + +A second genetic dataset was obtained from Counsyl (). +Counsyl is a commercial genetic screening laboratory that offers, among other products, the +“Family Prep Screen”, a genetic screening test intended to detect carrier status for up to 110 +recessive Mendelian diseases in couples that are planning to have a child [20]. A subset of +294,000 of its customers was surveyed by genotyping or sequencing for “routine carrier screen- +ing”. This subset excludes individuals with indications for testing because of known personal +or family history of Mendelian diseases, infertility, and consanguinity. It therefore represents a +more random (with regard to the presence of disease alleles), population-based survey. For +these individuals, we had details on self-reported ancestry (14 distinct ethnic/ancestry/geo- +graphic groups) and the allele frequencies for 98 mutations that match those that passed our +variant selection criteria described above, of which 91 are also sequenced to high coverage in +the ExAC database (S2 Table). We focused our analysis of this dataset on the 76,314 individu- +als of self-reported Northern or Southern European ancestry. + +Simulating the evolution of disease alleles with population size change + +We modeled the frequency of a deleterious allele in human populations by forward simula- +tions based on a crude but plausible demographic model for human populations from Africa +and Europe, inferred from exome data for African-Americans and European-Americans [25]. +To this end, we used a program described in [1]. In brief, the demographic scenario consists of +an Out-of-Africa demographic model, with changes in population size throughout the popula- +tion history, including a severe bottleneck in Europeans following the split from the African +population and a rapid, recent population growth in both populations [25]. As in Simons et al. +[1], we simulated genetic drift and two-way gene flow between Africans and Europeans in +recent history. + +The original demographic model was inferred using a mutation rate u of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp + +per generation [25,58]. More recent estimates, based on direct resequencing of human pedi- +grees, instead point to mutation rates about 50% smaller than that [18,34,36]. To incorporate +what is believed to be a more accurate mutation rate estimate, we rescaled all demographic and +time parameters in the original Tennessen et al. [25] model by a factor of 1.97, based on the +difference between the mutation rate considered in the original study and that of Kong et al. +[18] (which is similar to that found in other studies [48]). We refer to this model as the rescaled +Tennessen model and rely on it throughout. + +Negative selection acting on a single bi-allelic site was modeled as in the analytic models. +Allele frequencies follow a Wright-Fisher sampling scheme in each generation according to +these viabilities, with migration rate and population sizes varying according to the demo- +graphic scenario considered. Whenever a demographic event (e.g., growth) altered the number +of individuals and the resulting number was not an integer, we rounded it to the nearest inte- +ger, as in Simons et al. [1]. A burn-in period of 10Ne generations with constant population size +Ne = 14,328 individuals was implemented in order to ensure an equilibrium distribution of +segregating alleles at the onset of demographic changes in Africa, 11,643 generations ago. + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +14 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +In contrast to Simons et al. [1], our simulations always start with the ancestral allele A fixed + +and mutation occurs exclusively from this allele to the deleterious one (a), i.e., a mutation +occurs with mean probability u per gamete, per generation, and there is no back-mutation. +However, recurrent mutations at a site are allowed, as in Simons et al. [1]. + +When implementing the simulations, we considered a mean mutation rate u of 1.5x10-8 per +bp, per generation, as has been estimated for exons [34], as well as mutation rates for four dis- +tinct mutation types (CpGti = 1.12 x 10−7; CpGtv = 9.59 x 10−9; nonCpGti = 6.18 x 10−9; and +nonCpGtv = 3.76 x 10−9) estimated from a large human pedigree study [18]. While these four +categories capture much of the variation in germline mutation rates across sites, a number of +other factors (e.g., the larger sequence context or the replication timing) also influence muta- +tion rates, introducing heterogeneity in the mutation rate within each class considered +[27,36,40,59]. To allow for this heterogeneity as well as for uncertainty in the point mutation +rates estimates, in each simulation, when compared to human exome data (Figs 1, 2, S4 and +S5), instead of using a fixed rate u, we drew the mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution +with the following parameters: + +log10Mju (cid:24) Nðlog10u (cid:0) + +s2 2 - The effect of digitisation on the music industry +lnð10Þ; s2Þ + +ð8Þ + +such that that E[M] = u. σ was set to 0.57 (following [27]). +For each mutation type, we then proceeded as follows: + +1. We ran two million simulations, thus obtaining the distribution of deleterious allele fre- + +quencies expected for the European population. + +2. We sampled K allele frequencies from the two million simulations implemented for each + +mutation type, where K is the number of identified mutations of that type. Sample allele fre- +quencies were simulated from these population frequencies by Poisson sampling, so to +match ExAC’s number of chromosomes. + +3. We repeated step (2) 100,000 times, thus obtaining a distribution for the mean allele fre- + +quency across K mutations. + +To assess the significance of the deviation between observed and expected mean, we + +obtained a two-tailed p-value, defined as 2 x (r+1)/(100000+1), where r is the number of simu- +lated allele frequencies that were greater or equal to that of the empirical mean [60], for each +mutation type separately. + +A well-known source of heterogeneity in mutation rate within the CpGti class is methyla- +tion status, with a high transition rate seen only at methylated CpGs [21]. In our analyses, we +tried to control for the methylation status of CpG sites by excluding sites located in CpG +islands (CGIs), which tend to not be methylated [42]. The CGI annotation for hg19 was +obtained from UCSC Genome Browser (track “Unmasked CpG”; , accessed in June 6th, +2016). BEDTools [61] was used to exclude those CpG sites located in CGIs. We note that the +CpGti estimate from [18] includes CGIs, and in that sense the average mutation rate that we +are using for CpGti may be a very slight underestimate of the mean rate for transitions at +methylated CpG sites. + +Unless otherwise noted, the expectation assumes fully recessive, lethal alleles with complete +penetrance. Notably, by calculating the expected frequency one site at a time, we are ignoring +possible interaction between genes (i.e., effects of the genetic background) and among differ- +ent mutations within a gene (i.e., compound heterozygotes). These assumptions are relaxed in +two ways. In one analysis (S3 Fig), we considered a very low selective effect in heterozygous + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +15 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +individuals (h = 1%), reasoning that such an effect could plausibly go undetected in medical +examinations and yet would nonetheless impact the frequency of the disease allele. Second, +when considering the gene-level analysis (Fig 3), we implicitly allowed for compound hetero- +zygosity between any pair of known lethal mutations [8]. For this analysis, we ran 1000 simula- +tions for a total mutation rate U per gene that was calculated accounting for the heterogeneity +and uncertainty in the mutation rates estimates as follows: (i) For j sites in a gene known to +cause a recessive lethal disease and that passed our filtering criteria (S2 Table), we drew a +mutation rate uj from the lognormal distribution, as described above; (ii) We then took the +sum of uj as the total mutation rate U; (iii) We then ran one replicate with U as the mutation +parameter, and other parameters as specified for site level analysis. Because the mutational tar- +get size considered in simulations is only comprised of those sites at which mutations are +known to cause a lethal recessive disease, it is almost certainly an underestimate of the true +mutation rate—potentially by a lot. We note further that by this approach, we are assuming +that compound heterozygotes formed by any two lethal alleles have fitness zero, i.e., that they +are identical in their effects to homozygotes for any of the lethal alleles. Moreover, we are +implicitly ignoring the possibility of complementation, which is (somewhat) justified by our +focus on mutations with severe effects and complete penetrance (but see Discussion). Since we +were interested in understanding the effect of compound heterozygosity, for this analysis, we +did not consider the five genes in which only one mutation passed our filters (BCS1L, FKTN, +LAMA3, PLA3G6, and TCIRG1). + +Modeling the effect of the ascertainment bias in disease discovery + +To calculate the probability of ascertaining a recessive, lethal mutation, we assumed that all +currently known disease mutations were identified in a putative ascertainment study of sample +size na in a population with an inbreeding coefficient of Fa. Under this model, we can estimate +Pasc, the probability of ascertaining a disease mutation, as following: + +For a disease allele (denoted as a) at frequency q in the present population, if we randomly +sample an individual with inbreeding coefficient of Fa, the probabilities of the three genotypes +are: + +PðAAÞ ¼ Fað1 (cid:0) qÞ þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞð1 (cid:0) qÞ2; + +PðAaÞ ¼ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞ2qð1 (cid:0) qÞ; + +PðaaÞ ¼ Faq þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2: + +ð9Þ + +ð10Þ + +ð11Þ + +Thus, if na unrelated individual are surveyed, the probability of not seeing any homozygote +for the disease allele (which is the same as the probability of not being ascertained in this set) is: + +Therefore, the probability of ascertainment is + +Pnasc ¼ ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna: + +Pasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) Pnasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna +½1 (cid:0) Faq (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2(cid:138)na +½ð1 (cid:0) qÞð1 þ q (cid:0) FaqÞ(cid:138)na; + +¼ 1 (cid:0) + +¼ 1 (cid:0) + +ð12Þ + +ð13Þ + +which is an increasing function with regard to q (the population allele frequency), Fa (the +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study) as well as na (the sample size of the puta- +tive ascertainment study) (S6 Fig). + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +16 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +We also demonstrate the relationship between the probability of ascertainment and muta- +tion rate using simulations of ascertainment bias implemented according to the following steps: + +1. For each of the four mutation types considered, we generated 106 allele frequencies q from + +the results of the simulations based on a realistic demographic model [25]. + +2. We generated na independent diploid genotypes, given the allele frequencies from step 1 + +and an inbreeding coefficient Fa. We ran this step for a range of na and Fa values (Table 1). +3. With a given combination of na and Fa values, we identified the cases (out of the 106 obser- +vations from step 1) where at least one homozygote individual was observed in step 2. +These cases correspond to disease mutations that were ascertained; the reasoning being that +given complete penetrance, a recessive disease mutation can only be identified if there is at +least one affected individual in the studied population. With this step, we calculated the +probability of ascertainment by taking the fraction of cases that satisfy the criteria above. + +4. Finally, for each one of the 106 simulations from step 1, we generated a sample allele fre- + +quency of the disease mutation, matching ExAC’s sample size (i.e., considering 2n = 65,762 +chromosomes). We can then compare qu, the unbiased average allele frequency of all dis- +ease mutations, to qa, the mean frequency of the subset of cases ascertained in step 3, i.e., +those cases for which at least one homozygote individual is observed. + +These simulations were meant to illustrate the likely impact of ascertainment bias, rather + +than to precisely describe the disease mutation identification process or to quantify the ex- +pected effect. Notably, we performed these simulations for single sites, so the criteria for ascer- +tainment in step 3 did not include the possibility of compound heterozygotes, despite the fact +that an estimated 58.4% of the disease mutations included in our study were initially identified +in compound heterozygotes. However, this simulation framework could readily be extended +in this direction and it would not change our qualitative conclusion. + +Supporting information + +S1 Table. List of lethal, recessive Mendelian diseases considered in this study. +(DOCX) + +S2 Table. Information on 417 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases. +(XLSX) + +S3 Table. Information on 91 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases in Counsyl and ExAC databases. +(XLSX) + +S4 Table. P-values for each gene estimated by simulation, under a model of mutation- +selection balance with a plausible demographic history. +(DOCX) + +S5 Table. Phenotypic effect of mouse knock-outs (see main text). +(DOCX) + +S1 Fig. Comparison of the empirical allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease muta- +tions in individuals of European ancestry from two large exome studies. Shown are the +allele frequencies for 91 variants associated with lethal, recessive diseases, as estimated from +33,370 individuals of non-Finnish, European ancestry in the Exome Aggregation Consortium +(ExAC) database [23] and 76,314 European-ancestry individuals from a genetic testing + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +17 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +laboratory (Counsyl [20]) (see Methods). Points lie on the dashed blue line if the allele frequen- +cies in Counsyl and ExAC are the same. +(TIF) + +S2 Fig. Comparisons of mutation-selection balance models with constant versus changing +population sizes. (A) Population mean allele frequency as a function of effective population +size, under a model of constant population size. The X-axis range corresponds to the range of +effective population size over time estimated in [25]. The red bar indicates the value of a con- +stant population size at which the mean allele frequency is the same as in simulations, for an +average mutation rate of 1.5 x10-8 per bp per generation [34]. (B-C) The allele frequency distri- +bution (in grey) is presented for 2 x 106 simulations based on (B) the complex demographic +scenario inferred by Tennessen et al. [25] for the evolution of European populations based on +simulations (see Methods) and of (C) the finite, constant size population model, with N set to +35,651 individuals to match the mean allele frequency with (B). Both models assume complete +lethality (s = 1) and recessivity (h = 0). +(TIF) + +S3 Fig. The impact on disease allele frequencies of a small fitness effect in heterozygotes +(h = 0.01). Shown in each case is the distribution of the deleterious allele frequencies in the +population, generated from 100,000 simulations. Means are represented by red vertical bars. +For visualization, an allele frequency of q = 0 is set to 0.5 x 10−6. When a small fitness effect in +heterozygotes is considered in the simulations, the mean allele frequency decreases by 79% rel- +ative to no effect. The two distributions differ significantly by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (p- +value < 10−15). The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation, reflective of the +mean mutation rate for exons [34]. +(TIF) + +S4 Fig. Effect of varying the end population size and the average mutation rate on the sam- +ple allele frequency of recessive, lethal mutations. Tennessen et al. [25] inferred the present +effective population size of Europeans to be 512,000 individuals based on a mutation rate of +2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation. We rescaled the parameters of this model based on a lower +mutation rate estimate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] and show the expected distribution of sample allele +frequencies of recessive, lethal mutations in column A. We further considered the effect of +larger population sizes at present (2-, 4-, and 10-fold increase, denoted by columns B, C and +D respectively), keeping other rescaled demographic parameters the same as in A. We also +included a model (E) where rapid growth begins immediately after the out-of-Africa bottle- +neck, representing a more extreme scenario of population growth in comparison to the two- +stage and more gradual scenario proposed by Tennessen et al. (2012). For A-E, we drew the +mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution with parameters set as in Eq 8, with u = 1.5 x +10−8 (as implemented for Fig 2; see Methods). Model F considers a larger u (2.25 x 10−8, i.e., a +1.5-fold increase from A-E), with all other parameters (e.g., variance in mutation rates across +simulations, the demographic model) the same as in column A. The observed sample allele fre- +quency distribution of 385 disease mutations in ExAC is shown in white. Violin plots show the +density distribution of the log10 allele frequencies for variants that were segregating in these +samples, whereas boxes indicate the proportion of sites for which the deleterious mutation was +not observed segregating in the sample. All distributions differ significantly from one another +(i.e., all p-values are < 10−15 by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test). +(TIF) + +S5 Fig. Expected distribution and the observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal +disease mutations (excluding mutations in CFTR and DHCR7). As in Fig 2, the four panels + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +18 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +correspond to four different mutation types. The title of the panel indicates the mutation type, +followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type, with p-values for the difference +between observed and expected mean frequencies below. Distributions in grey are for 100,000 +observations of the expected mean sample allele frequencies across K mutations, and were +obtained from simulations based on a plausible demographic model for European populations +[25] (see Methods). Blue bars represent the observed values estimated from 33,370 individuals +of European ancestry from ExAC. As opposed to in Fig 2, here, we did not include mutations +present in two genes (CFTR and DHCR7) that were outliers in the gene-level analysis (Fig 3) +and were reported elsewhere to be carried by healthy homozygous individuals [24]. +(TIF) -8. +S6 Fig. The probability Pasc of a mutation being ascertained, given its population allele fre- +quency q, the sample size na of the putative ascertainment study and the inbreeding coeffi- +cient Fa in the population in which the ascertainment study was conducted. In each case, +we let only one parameter (q, na or Fa) vary, while fixing the others at q = 7.10 x 10−6 (corre- +sponding to the mean allele frequency from simulations), na = 10,000, and Fa = 1/16 (corre- +sponding to marriage between first cousins, a plausible scenario for a population with +widespread inbreeding). +(TIF) -9. +S7 Fig. Depth of coverage for 385 mutations in ExAC known to cause lethal, Mendelian +diseases. Box plots show the mean (black bar) and the lower and upper quartiles for (A) the +248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies in ExAC, for which the number of sequenced non- +Finnish European individuals was reported (n = 32,881) and (B) the 137 sites for which we did +not have this information. Since distributions of depth of coverage are similar between the two +sets (by a Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90), we assumed that 32,881 individuals were +sequenced at all sites, and used this number to subsample simulations to match the sample size +of the ExAC data. +(TIF) -The introduction of the internet made music piracy easier than had previously -been the case. Whilst piracy had always been a problem in the industry, the -internet made it easier to illegally copy works and share them with other -internet users on a large scale. The result was a collapse in music industry -revenues, and therefore creator revenues, as CD and other physical sales -declined. Inflation adjusted UK recorded music revenues fell by around 60% -from £1.9 billion in 2001 to £0.8 billion in 2015. +Acknowledgments -Services that allowed consumers to access digital music legally, initially -through paid downloads of songs followed by music streaming, meant that for -the first time music companies and creators could monetise their content on -digital services and stem the flow of revenue losses. Since the introduction of -streaming, adjusting the older revenue figure for inflation music revenues -have increased from £0.8 billion in 2015 to £1.1 billion in 2021, although these -revenues remain below their £1.9 billion peak in 2001. +We thank Daniel MacArthur for his help with the ExAC data, Ellen Leffler for providing her +Python script (available at https://github.com/cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease), as well as +members of the Pickrell, Przeworski and Sella labs, Aravinda Chakravarti, Brian Charlesworth, +Damien Labuda and four anonymous reviewers for helpful discussions and comments on an +earlier version of the manuscript. All codes and data to generate the figures in R [62] and the +script used to get the sequence context of each mutation are available at https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease. The code to run the simulations is available at https:// +github.com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator. Allele frequencies and other information for the dis- +ease mutations employed in the analyses are in S2 and S3 Tables. -UK inflation-adjusted recorded music revenues between 2000 and 2021 by format -type +Author Contributions -10. +Conceptualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly -Consumers have embraced legal music -streaming and today music streaming accounts -for more than 80% of music sales. Data published -by Ofcom indicates that 47% of the population -made weekly use of music streaming services in -early 2022. This has nearly doubled since 2017, -but has remained relatively stable since 2020, -indicating that it might be plateauing. Younger -people stream music the most, with 77% of 15- +Przeworski. -3 +Data curation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Zachary Baker, Jose´ Francisco Diesel, Imran S. - 11. +Haque, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -12. +Formal analysis: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao. -34-year-olds streaming music on a weekly basis compared with just 19% of -those aged 55+.1 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -Streaming has changed not only how we listen to music but what we listen to -because for the first time all music, both old and new, is readily available in -one place at no additional cost. This has created opportunities for labels, -publishers, and creators to reach new audiences who may not have heard the -music on its first release which has in turn extended the lifecycle for earning -revenue from songs. This is a benefit to those creators whose music -continues to be listened to, but this development is not necessarily good for all -creators because it means that today’s new music competes with yesterday’s -songs for a share of streaming revenue. +19 / 23 -Digitisation and new online business models continue to create new -opportunities to consume music. Today, besides new online radio stations, a -consumer may hear a piece of music in a video on TikTok, see their favourite -artist on a live stream rather than in concert, or engage with music alongside -new interactive online gaming platforms. Whilst these are different to -streaming services with full catalogues and music available on-demand, they -are new ways that consumers hear and discover music and offer potential -new sources of revenue for the music companies, artists, and songwriters. + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -The recorded music sector is concentrated, but that is not driving -the concerns raised by artists +Funding acquisition: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -13. +Investigation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -14. +Methodology: Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -Our analysis shows that more creators than ever are releasing music, -doubling from 200,000 in 2014 to 400,000 in 2020. This is, in part, made -possible by innovations in technology and the ability to easily distribute music -online. For example, it is now easier than ever to create and record music -outside the confines of a traditional music studio and share it on streaming -services without the need for a record label. +Project administration: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -It has long been the case in recorded music that only a very small minority of -artists will achieve the highest level of success. In 2020 over 60% of streams -were of music recorded by only the top 0.4% of artists. To reach the top of the -chart, songs need to be streamed many millions of times each day and many -artists are faced with a situation where their work can be streamed millions of -times, but it does not translate into a significant share of their income. For -example, twelve million streams a year could earn an artist around £12,000, -but less than 1% of artists achieve that number of streams. We have heard +Resources: Imran S. Haque, Molly Przeworski. -1 Data published by Ofcom (2022), Media Nations: UK 2022. +Software: Yuval B. Simons. -4 +Supervision: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. - from both artists and songwriters that they are unable to make a sustainable -income from music streaming and for many it feels unfair. +Validation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -15. We have considered what may be causing these outcomes for artists2 and, in +Visualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim. -line with our statutory duties, whether these outcomes are being caused by -competition issues in the market. +Writing – original draft: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -16. +Writing – review & editing: Yuval B. Simons, Imran S. Haque, Joseph Pickrell. -The recorded music sector is concentrated, with the 3 major labels holding a -combined share of over 70% of UK streams, and this has persisted for some -time. The market share in terms of streams of independent record companies -(indies) has remained steady at around one quarter for several years. This -share is very fragmented with only 2 indies having a share in excess of 1%. +References +1. Simons YB, Turchin MC, Pritchard JK, Sella G (2014) The deleterious mutation load is insensitive to +recent population history. Nat Genet 46: 220–224. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.2896 PMID: 24509481 -Label shares of total UK streams in 2021 +2. Simons YB, Sella G (2016) The impact of recent population history on the deleterious mutation load in +humans and close evolutionary relatives. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 150–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. +gde.2016.09.006 PMID: 27744216 -Source: CMA analysis of data from Official Charts.3 +3. Nei M (1968) The frequency distribution of lethal chromosomes in finite populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci -2 As described in Chapter 5 of this report, a number of our findings on artists will also relate to songwriters. -Issues specific to songwriters are considered in more detail below. -3 Notes: This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. These figures are provided in a 5% range where the figure -is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the ranges have -been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints does not -equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of the -midpoints. +U S A 60: 517–524. PMID: 5248809 -5 +4. Gillespie JH (2004) Population Genetics: A Concise Guide. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University - 17. +Press. -The scale of the majors and their global reach means they can offer large -advances which attracts proven and successful artists. In turn, this can make -it difficult for indie labels to attract and retain artists as they become -successful, which can create a barrier to expansion for indie labels. +5. Brandvain Y, Wright SI (2016) The Limits of Natural Selection in a Nonequilibrium World. Trends Genet -18. Despite the concentrated nature of the market, outcomes for artists as a +32: 201–210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tig.2016.01.004 PMID: 26874998 -whole seem to be improving. We accept that this improvement may not be -benefiting all artists, and that for many artists the improvement will seem -insufficient. +6. Balick DJ, Do R, Cassa CA, Reich D, Sunyaev SR (2015) Dominance of Deleterious Alleles Controls -19. Our analysis shows that in some respects the options available to artists, +the Response to a Population Bottleneck. PLoS Genet 11: e1005436. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1005436 PMID: 26317225 -particularly new artists, are improving: +7. Beauchamp KA, Muzzey D, Wong KK, Hogan GJ, Karimi K, et al. (2017) Systematic Design and Com- -(a) There is now more choice for artists about which type of deal they would -like to agree, from DIY distribution, A&L services, or more traditional -record deals. +parison of Expanded Carrier Screening Panels. Genet Med—ePub ahead of print -(b) Some new artists have greater leverage when negotiating a record deal +8. Clark AG (1998) Mutation-selection balance with multiple alleles. Genetica 102–103: 41–47. PMID: -with a label if they have already built a strong fanbase and online -presence. +9720270 -Average UK artist yearly streaming earnings from majors and average -(mean) royalty rates (2021 prices) in the UK +9. Crow JF, Kimura M (1970) Introduction to Population Genetics Theory New York: Harper & Row Pub- -Source: CMA analysis of data from the majors +lishers. 591 p. -20. Analysis of new contracts signed by the majors with new artists for multi-track +10. Cormet-Boyaka E, Jablonsky M, Naren AP, Jackson PL, Muccio DD, et al. (2004) Rescuing cystic fibro- +sis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)-processing mutants by transcomplementation. Proc +Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 8221–8226. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0400459101 PMID: 15141088 -deals (ie albums or extended play (EP) records) shows that, between 2012 -and 2021: +11. Rapino D, Sabirzhanova I, Lopes-Pacheco M, Grover R, Guggino WB, et al. (2015) Rescue of NBD2 -(a) the average gross royalty rate has increased from 19.7% to 23.3%; +mutants N1303K and S1235R of CFTR by small-molecule correctors and transcomplementation. PLoS +One 10: e0119796. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0119796 PMID: 25799511 -6 +12. Andressoo JO, Jans J, de Wit J, Coin F, Hoogstraten D, et al. (2006) Rescue of progeria in trichothiody- +strophy by homozygous lethal Xpd alleles. PLoS Biol 4: e322. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio. +0040322 PMID: 17020410 - (b) the proportion of contracts where labels own copyright of recordings in +13. Gallati S (2014) Disease-modifying genes and monogenic disorders: experience in cystic fibrosis. Appl -perpetuity has reduced from 66% to 26.4%; and +Clin Genet 7: 133–146. https://doi.org/10.2147/TACG.S18675 PMID: 25053892 -(c) the average number of minimum commitment periods (where a period is -defined by a commitment to produce a multi-track output such as an -album) has fallen from 3.8 to 3.4 +14. Corvol H, Blackman SM, Boelle PY, Gallins PJ, Pace RG, et al. (2015) Genome-wide association meta- +analysis identifies five modifier loci of lung disease severity in cystic fibrosis. Nat Commun 6: 8382. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms9382 PMID: 26417704 -21. Competition appears to be particularly focused on artists who are already +15. Habara A, Steinberg MH (2016) Minireview: Genetic basis of heterogeneity and severity in sickle cell -popular or are likely to be. Competition to sign such artists can be very -intense with offers from many labels. Traditional record deals also face -increasing disruption from alternative models, in particular service deals from -artist and label (A&L) service providers, and there are more options than ever -for artists to reach audiences and monetise their work. +disease. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 241: 689–696. -22. We think that outcomes for artists are driven by factors which are largely +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -unrelated to competition issues in the market. Rather, we think these -outcomes can be attributed to factors more inherent to how music streaming -works. Digitisation has allowed for a huge increase in the number of artists -sharing their music and a vast back catalogue made available via streaming -so there is more music available to stream and consumer tastes tend to tip -towards a relativity small number of artists being successful. In addition, there -is very significant uncertainty about which artists will be successful. The -combination of these market features is likely to result in competition focused -on a relatively limited number of artists and market outcomes where the -majority of the benefits are accrued by a minority of artists. +20 / 23 -23. We therefore conclude that a competition intervention, for example a change + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -to the structure of the market, is unlikely to result in a material increase in -revenues for artists. +16. Hedrick PW (2011) Population genetics of malaria resistance in humans. Heredity (Edinb) 107: 283– -24. Whilst majors’ profits have been increasing since the lows of piracy, our -profitability analysis has not found evidence of substantial and sustained -excess profits by the majors. This is consistent with our overall finding that +304. https://doi.org/10.1038/hdy.2011.16 PMID: 21427751 -4 As these are only averages across all 3 majors, they do not show how the terms can vary significantly between -artists, reflecting for example the different potential financial rewards and risks based on the characteristics of -individual artists (including by genre, potential, and stage of career). +17. Chong JX, Buckingham KJ, Jhangiani SN, Boehm C, Sobreira N, et al. (2015) The Genetic Basis of -7 +Mendelian Phenotypes: Discoveries, Challenges, and Opportunities. Am J Hum Genet 97: 199–215. +https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.06.009 PMID: 26166479 - there is unlikely to be scope to improve outcomes for artists substantially -through increased competition. +18. Kong A, Frigge ML, Masson G, Besenbacher S, Sulem P, et al. (2012) Rate of de novo mutations and -25. We understand that Government has taken several steps to address concerns +the importance of father’s age to disease risk. Nature 488: 471–475. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11396 PMID: 22914163 -about creator remuneration and has responded to the DCMS Select -Committee recommendations for legislative and policy reform in this area. In -particular, the IPO is conducting a research programme including examining -potential options to strengthen creator rights and remuneration. We are -sharing our final findings with the IPO and DCMS to help inform their work. +19. -Labels could do more to improve the information they provide to -artists +Turner TN, Douville C, Kim D, Stenson PD, Cooper DN, et al. (2015) Proteins linked to autosomal domi- +nant and autosomal recessive disorders harbor characteristic rare missense mutation distribution pat- +terns. Hum Mol Genet 24: 5995–6002. https://doi.org/10.1093/hmg/ddv309 PMID: 26246501 -26. We heard strong concern from some artists and their representatives that they +20. Haque IS, Lazarin GA, Kang H, Evans EA, Goldberg JD, et al. (2016) Modeled fetal risk of genetic dis- -do not get enough information from record labels on how their earnings from -streaming services are calculated or how the deals that exist between labels -and streaming services may affect what they earn or could earn in future. -Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) between music streaming services and -labels were cited as a barrier to improving information provision to artists. +eases identified by expanded carrier screening. JAMA 316: 734–742. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama. +2016.11139 PMID: 27533158 -27. Our analysis shows that some artists are provided with information, such as +21. Cooper DN, Youssoufian H (1988) The CpG dinucleotide and human genetic disease. Hum Genet 78: -number of streams and the royalties earnt on these streams, which tells them -how much they have earned per stream on music streaming services, and we -saw some positive examples of labels presenting this information in a user- -friendly way. However, this was not consistent across all labels, and we think -best practices could be developed so that information could be presented in a -more straightforward and uniform way with appropriate guidance on how to -interpret the data. This will help artists better understand how they are paid for -streaming and the sources of their income. +151–155. PMID: 3338800 -28. +22. Akalin N, Zietkiewicz E, Makalowski W, Labuda D (1994) Are CpG sites mutation hot spots in the dystro- -In respect of NDAs, whilst they do prevent certain terms and conditions being -made available to artists and limit access to the ‘source data’ from the music -streaming services, they do not appear to prevent a significant amount of -relevant information being made available to artists about their earnings. By -limiting the access to source data, the NDAs may potentially limit the ability of -artists to verify the accuracy of information. However, this is an issue more to -do with verification of the fulfilment of contractual terms rather than one of -competition to sign artists. +phin gene? Hum Mol Genet 3. -29. We welcome the work the IPO is undertaking on issues -around transparency for artists, including developing a -code of practice. +23. -8 +Lek M, Karczewski KJ, Minikel EV, Samocha KE, Banks E, et al. (2016) Analysis of protein-coding +genetic variation in 60,706 humans. Nature 536: 285–291. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature19057 PMID: +27535533 - Publishing revenues from streaming in the UK have grown -significantly, but many songwriters argue they are not paid enough -to make a sustainable income +24. Chen R, Shi L, Hakenberg J, Naughton B, Sklar P, et al. (2016) Analysis of 589,306 genomes identifies -30. Each song has two sets of music rights: (1) rights in the underlying song or -‘publishing rights’ which includes the music and lyrics; and (2) rights in the -particular recording of that song, the ‘recording rights’. Without permission to -use both rights, a streaming service cannot legally stream the song. +individuals resilient to severe Mendelian childhood diseases. Nat Biotechnol 34: 531–538. https://doi. +org/10.1038/nbt.3514 PMID: 27065010 + +25. + +Tennessen JA, Bigham AW, O’Connor TD, Fu W, Kenny EE, et al. (2012) Evolution and functional +impact of rare coding variation from deep sequencing of human exomes. Science 337: 64–69. https:// +doi.org/10.1126/science.1219240 PMID: 22604720 + +26. Wright S (1937) The Distribution of Gene Frequencies in Populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 23: + +307–320. PMID: 16577780 + +27. Harpak A, Bhaskar A, Pritchard JK (2016) Mutation Rate Variation is a Primary Determinant of the Dis- +tribution of Allele Frequencies in Humans. PLoS Genet 12: e1006489. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1006489 PMID: 27977673 + +28. Browning Sharon R, Browning Brian L (2015) Accurate Non-parametric Estimation of Recent Effective +Population Size from Segments of Identity by Descent. The American Journal of Human Genetics 97: +404–418. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.07.012 PMID: 26299365 + +29. Reich DE, Lander ES (2001) On the allelic spectrum of human disease. Trends Genet 17: 502–510. + +PMID: 11525833 + +30. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- + +mon variant. . .or not? Hum Mol Genet 11: 2417–2423. PMID: 12351577 31. -Throughout the study we have heard consistently from groups that represent -songwriters that the publishing right of a song is systematically undervalued -when compared to the recording right. In turn, they argue that this means that -songwriters receive less in royalties for their work and do not make a -sustainable income from streaming. Whilst some songwriters are also -themselves artists and may have access to revenues from recording rights -and other sources of income, that is not always the case. - -32. Songwriters and their representatives have suggested that the undervaluation -of publishing rights is because the majors have market power and interests in -both publishing and recording rights and that it is financially advantageous for -them to suppress publishing revenues in favour of the recording side of their -business, possibly through tacit collusion. We have also heard concerns that -the majors may have the ability and incentive to influence industry outcomes -via their membership of collecting societies (CMOs) who have a role in -negotiating royalties for the use of their members’ publishing rights. - -33. We have examined evidence on the allocation of music streaming revenues, - -and it indicates that: - -(a) The share of revenues going to publishers (publishing share) increased - -from 8% in 2008 to approximately 12% in 2012. Since then it has -increased to 15% in 2021. This is a significant increase across the period. -In contrast, the share of revenues going to record companies in 2021 is at -a broadly similar level to what it was in 2008. - -(b) For the majors, the growth in publishing revenues - -has far exceeded the growth in recording revenues. - -(c) Majors’ growth in publishing revenues is 244% since -2017, which is significantly above the [110-120]% -average across the publishing sector over the same -period. - -9 - - Split in music streaming revenues in 2008 and 2021 - -34. - -Source: Section 4.2.2 of research commissioned by the IPO Music Creators Earnings, the Digital Era, -and On-Demand Streaming Revenues and CMA analysis of data from Apple, Amazon and Spotify.5 - -This evidence is inconsistent with the argument that the majors have tacitly -colluded to suppress the publishing share or that there is otherwise -particularly weak competition to sign songwriters that is leading to a split in -the allocation of music streaming revenues that favours recording rights over -publishing rights. The majors having both a recording and a publishing -business is also not necessarily problematic. For instance, if the majors did -not have a publishing business they might have a stronger incentive to block -increases in the ‘publishing share’ by refusing to accommodate such an -increase through reducing the recording share since any losses to their -recording revenues which occurred would not be mitigated by gains to their -publishing revenues. - -35. We also have not seen clear evidence that CMOs are failing to push for better -terms owing to the majors’ influence or that CMO governance procedures and -processes are failing to mitigate any potential bias in their decision making. If -such regulatory concerns do exist, the proper body to examine them is the -IPO, which has responsibility for monitoring the conduct of CMOs under the -Collective Management of Copyright (EU Directive) Regulations 2016.6 - -5 Note: Whilst the CMA analysis for 2021 is based on data from the largest music streaming services, the IPO -research draws on a range of largely qualitative evidence and therefore (as the IPO research itself -acknowledges) the IPO research estimate of the split of revenues for 2008 is only indicative. Therefore, -comparison between the split between 2008 and 2021 should be treated with caution and taken to be indicative -of the overall trend in the split over time rather than estimates of the exact quantum of change in the split. -6 The conduct of UK CMOs (including the PRS) is governed by the CRM Regulations. The CRM Regulations -designate a National Competent Authority (NCA) which is responsible for monitoring and enforcing compliance - -10 - - 36. Songwriters are concerned that the initial split between publishing and - -recording revenues adopted when streaming began was unfair and -unjustified, for example because it did not reflect the alleged lower costs of -record companies under streaming compared to physical distribution. The -increase in the publishing share is consistent with this concern over the initial -split and there being a subsequent period of market-correction, which may not -yet have fully played out. However, the fact that publishing revenues are -increasing at a greater rate compared to recording revenues, in particular for -the majors, suggests that publishing revenues are not being actively -suppressed because of a distortion or restriction of competition. - -37. We have found that there are inherent difficulties in securing increases to the - -publishing share and, consequently, increasing the amount songwriters are -paid. This difficulty may arise from the fact that music streaming services, -labels and publishers must all reach agreement to change how streaming -revenues are divided. However, they may all have different incentives and so -they may not agree – we call this a ‘licensing negotiation friction’. We think -that agreement between the parties may be particularly challenging when an -increase in the publishing share would necessitate a fall in the share that goes -to record companies due to the strong bargaining position of music -rightsholders, which arises from the need for music streaming services to get -agreement from all key rightsholders to offer a wide range of music. - -38. - -The long-term increase in the publishing share since 2008 has been -accommodated by a fall in the share taken by music streaming services. The -risk is that we may reach a point, or could do soon, where further substantial -increases in the publishing share can only be accommodated by a fall in the -recording share, which labels would be in a strong bargaining position to -resist. - -39. Whilst we think that competition for songwriters has driven up the existing - -publishing share, concerns exist that the current split could still be sub- -optimal, particularly for songwriters. If that is the case, we think that it may -take time for the split to adjust further, if at all, owing to the inherent licensing -negotiation frictions and bargaining power of music rightsholders we have -described. There is also a limit on the extent to which competition to sign -songwriters can drive further increases in the publishing share, particularly if -an increase needs to be accommodated by a fall in the recording share. -Competition policy is not therefore the right tool to reach an optimal split. We -think it is a matter for Government and policymakers to determine whether the - -with the Regulations’ provisions. The NCA functions in the UK are undertaken through the IPO, which has -published guidance on these regulations (see IPO (2021), Guidance on the Collective Management of Copyright -(EU Directive) Regulations 2016). - -11 - - split is appropriate and fair, and to explore what is needed to incentivise song -writing as part of wider policy interventions on this split and other measures, -for example those relating to the copyright framework and how music -streaming licensing rates are set. - -The legal arrangements between major labels and music streaming -services are complex but they do not appear to be significantly -hampering competition and innovation - -40. Major labels rely on music streaming services to distribute their music, - -and streaming services cannot meet consumers’ needs without obtaining -licences to the large catalogue of each major record label and publisher. -Accordingly, music streaming services must negotiate deals with labels -and publishers to access music content. These deals can be exceedingly -complex and will cover financials and other terms. Our market study -uncovered a number of clauses that could plausibly raise competition -concerns. For example a number of agreements contained non- -discrimination clauses which act to prevent the music streaming service -from favouring music content based on price, for example, by giving -more prominence to cheaper music. - -41. However, given the current ‘full catalogue’ business model of music streaming - -– consumers expect to access every major’s repertoire on each streaming -service – there is no credible alternative to each major’s catalogue. Taking -this into account, our view is that the nature of competition between record -companies to supply music to music streaming services is weak but would -remain weak even absent the combined effect of the contractual clauses we -identified as being potentially problematic. Whilst a slight strengthening of -competition might result from the removal of these clauses (individually or in -combination), it is not clear any improvement would be more than marginal. - -42. - -Innovation is intrinsic to a healthy, competitive market and we therefore take -seriously any suggestion that innovation has been hindered. We have -therefore also assessed the impact of contractual clauses on how music -services compete with each other in terms of innovation. To introduce -innovations or changes to services, the music streaming services typically -need to agree with the majors to amend existing contracts, which we heard -can be a long process which may slow the pace of innovation. - -43. We found examples of substantial innovation by music streaming services, -both in terms of the services, such as the introduction of high-quality audio, -and in the price plans available. But we were also given a few examples of -innovations that were slow to market because of the complex negotiations - -12 - - needed to secure licensing agreements. There is a risk that contractual -restrictions may contribute to the slower development of such innovations -than might otherwise be expected or, potentially, preclude innovation -altogether. - -44. While potential competition concerns have been raised with us about the - -effect of agreements between the majors and music streaming services, we -are not persuaded that changing the contractual clauses would significantly -increase innovation. Rather, the problem appears to relate to the need for -music streaming services to agree with multiple rightsholders on what terms -(financial or otherwise) they can use their content, including in new and -innovative ways. It is the sheer volume and complexity of these negotiations -that appear to be the main barrier to even greater innovation. However, these -negotiations appear to be an inherent part of the licensing process – with the -financial terms negotiated depending on the features agreed. - -Competition between music streaming services is currently -delivering good outcomes for consumers, but concerns may arise -in future - -45. - -The music streaming services market is concentrated with a few larger -streaming services such as Spotify, Apple, Amazon, and YouTube (which is -part of Google), alongside a range of other smaller providers. Spotify has the -largest number of monthly active users by some distance, as shown in the -graph below. Music streaming services are popular with consumers and have -grown rapidly – between 2019 and 2021 the number of monthly active users -of music streaming services increased from 32 million to 39 million. Despite -the strong presence of large, well-known firms in the market, and the number -of active users increasing, music streaming services are not making -sustained, excess profits: indeed, our analysis has shown that many services -have low or negative operating margins. - -13 - - Share of UK Monthly Active Users by music streaming service in -December 2021, excluding YouTube’s UUC platform - -Source: CMA analysis of data from music streaming services.7 - -46. We have heard consistently that consumers demand access to a full - -catalogue of music. The result is that the main music streaming services -effectively offer the same music content to consumers. Competition between -the services, therefore, anchors around offering the best experience to -consumers through good design, personalised playlists, and high-quality -audio content, as well as through pricing plans. These services also now -compete with one another by offering non-music content, such as podcasts. - -47. - -For consumers, the monthly price of music -streaming services is either free (ad-funded) or -falling in real terms because the price of -individual subscriptions has remained stable and -not kept pace with inflation. Most services offer a -range of price plans, including family and student -plans, as well as free ad-funded tiers. Streaming -services are also frequently bundled with other - -7 This pie chart is for illustrative purposes only. Monthly Active User shares only account for Spotify, YouTube -Music, Apple, Amazon, Deezer, Soundcloud and Tidal which have a combined streaming share of over 99% -according to CMA analysis of data provided by Official Charts. YouTube Music users include YouTube Music -premium Monthly Active Viewers and YouTube Music ad-funded Daily Active Viewers, meaning this figure will -provide an underestimation of YouTube Music’s actual users. These figures are provided in a 5% range where -the figure is below 10%, and a 10% range where the figure is between 10% and 100%. The midpoints of the -ranges have been used to provide an illustration of relative size in the market. Where the sum of these midpoints -does not equal 100%, we have scaled the pie chart so that the area segments represent the share of the sum of -the midpoints. - -14 - - services, such as mobile phone subscriptions, and accessed via a range of -devices, including smart speakers. - -48. Recorded music is now also costing consumers less overall compared to - -when CDs and other physical formats were more popular, as indicated by UK -recorded music revenues falling by around 40% from £1.9 billion in 2001 to -£1.1 billion in 2021 in real terms. - -49. - -In a market that is expanding, music streaming services mainly compete for -new consumers, rather than encouraging existing customers to switch to their -streaming services. However, music streaming services with ad-funded plans -do actively seek to get customers to upgrade to a paid-for service. - -50. Our analysis shows that consumers cancel their service at above 4% a month -for the major streaming services. Cancellation might occur because free trials -are coming to an end, the user is switching to another service, or because the -user is no longer using any streaming service. The current data on why -consumers may cancel their services is limited, but it suggests that the most -cited reasons are consumers not being able to afford the service or not using -it enough.8 - -51. Switching between music streaming services might be challenging if - -consumers are concerned that they will lose access to their favourite playlists. -There are some nascent music data portability services that support -switching, but demand for them is currently low. Low switching rates are not -necessarily a dynamic that causes immediate concern - for example, in a -growing market. However, as the number of new premium users to compete -for declines in future, there is a risk that prices for music streaming services -will rise significantly for consumers or there may be a deterioration in the -quality of services, if there isn’t a significant threat of switching. Therefore, as -the market reaches maturity we would be concerned if we did not see more -vigorous competition between streaming services (eg through enhanced -efforts to make it seamless for consumers to switch and port their playlists or -musical preferences). Higher rates of switching would imply consumers -exercising choice (and hence competition), although the lack of switching by -itself is not conclusive evidence of a lack of competition. - -52. With more music available, tools that help consumers - -discover new music are more important. Streaming services -compete in bringing music to consumers’ attention and -promoting new artists and songs. We have found that while - -8 This should be treated with caution, however, as only a small proportion of users who cancel respond to the -cancellation survey used to collect this data. - -15 - - the majority of tracks listed on the top new music discovery playlists are -licensed by the majors, the proportion is lower than the majors’ combined -share of total streams. This suggests that artists that are not signed to a major -do have reasonable opportunities to reach new listeners via discovery -playlists and more generally the streaming services have told us that they -design their music recommendation systems with a focus on listener -engagement and user satisfaction. - -53. Overall, whilst music streaming services are currently delivering good - -outcomes for consumers, it is imperative for a sustainable and vibrant market -that services can effectively compete with one another, and we would have -concerns in future if we saw a reduction in competition – for example, if -majors sought commitments from streaming platforms to exclude competitors -(large or small) from discovery or search elements of their service. - -There is a ‘value gap’ between what YouTube and other music -streaming providers pay to rightsholders but it currently amounts -to less than 0.5% of UK recorded music revenues - -54. UUC platforms allow consumers to access music content uploaded by users, - -artists and labels for free (but often with ads), in some cases coupled with -other content such as entertainment videos. These services differ from music -streaming services because any user can upload content, which may include -copyrighted material which they may or may not have permission to share. -Sometimes this content can appear on these platforms before a licence has -been agreed with rightsholders. - -55. UUC platforms have some protection in law through a ‘safe harbour’ provision -which limits the liability they have for hosting illegal content uploaded by users -in some circumstances. However, once they become aware that content is -available without permission from rightsholders, they must remove it or, as is - -16 - - more often the case, allow the rightsholder to grant permission and monetise -the content, for example by sharing ad revenues. - -56. A range of music companies, artists and songwriters have been concerned - -that the asymmetry in the legal regime may result in a loss of revenues (often -called the ‘value gap’) for the music industry. In particular, there is concern -that the safe harbour provisions give UUC platforms greater bargaining power -over rightsholders, leading to rightsholders having to agree worse terms than -they would otherwise. - -57. - -To understand whether a value gap exists and, if so, how significant the gap -is, we have compared the amount that YouTube, as the largest UUC platform, -pays out to rightsholders in comparison to Spotify’s ad-funded service. In -2017, YouTube’s ‘value gap’ in the UK – that is how much more it would have -paid to rightsholders as a proportion of revenue from music content if it had -paid them at the same rate as Spotify’s ad-funded service – was over 20 -percentage points. However, this ‘gap’ has closed over time and in 2021 had -fallen to significantly less than 5 percentage points, or less than £5 million. To -put this figure into context, it is less than 0.5% of the £1,115 million total UK -recorded music revenues in 2021. The evidence therefore suggests that the -extent of YouTube’s ‘value gap’ has decreased in recent years. - -58. Whilst YouTube is the largest UUC service and therefore very important in the -market, there are other UUC platforms that take a different approach to -licensing and may have less effective content management systems. - -59. Some newer UUC platforms incorporate music into their offering, but do not -offer a full streaming service. Examples of this include TikTok, a short-form -video-sharing service, and Twitch, a longer-form live streaming service. These -platforms, alongside YouTube, provide innovative services for consumers and -potential opportunities for creators and music companies to earn further -revenues in addition to those generated by music streaming. - -60. - -The way these services use music differs from traditional music streaming -services: they may use snippets of recordings or only offer specific genres of -music, rather than a full catalogue on an on-demand basis. Therefore, it may -not always be the case that the rates payable for these services will be -comparable to music streaming services, which is an important factor when -assessing if there is a ‘value gap’ between the two offerings. That said, we -have heard examples of refusal to license or difficulties in agreeing licences -that may indicate that safe harbour is among the factors in some commercial -negotiations. We also consider that the quality of content management -systems is important in ensuring that rightsholders are remunerated fairly for -music content uploaded onto UUC platforms, and we have heard some newer - -17 - - emerging platforms may lag behind the more established platforms in this -regard. - -61. Meanwhile, since the exit of the UK from the EU, European legislation - -relevant to UUC has been amended such that it now requires UUC services -using copyrighted content to make their ‘best efforts’ to seek permission to -use that content. We note that the DCMS and IPO are monitoring the practical -impact of these legislative changes on UUC services in the UK. We -encourage them to take account of our broader findings in relation to UUC -services when considering if legislative changes are required in the UK. - -The market is evolving and innovating, but it is vital that it -continues to deliver good outcomes for consumers - -62. - -The music streaming market is changing rapidly, and further technological -advances in the years to come may spark further changes to the way we -listen to music. Our analysis shows that the market is on balance delivering -good outcomes for consumers. However, we would have concerns and may -intervene in the future if aspects of the market change in ways that harm -consumers’ interests. For example, factors that may give rise to concerns -could include: - -(a) if future mergers or acquisitions affect the bargaining power of either - -music companies or music streaming services, which may in turn lead to -worse outcomes for consumers with the CMA likely to pay particularly -close attention to any such merger activity and to investigate whether it -could lead to a substantial lessening of competition. - -(b) shifts in the way consumers access streaming services that influence their - -listening behaviour, for example if there is continued growth in the use of -smart speakers, and whether this could exacerbate barriers to expansion -of streaming services that do not have their own smart speaker -ecosystem. - -(c) greater use of playlists, autoplay and recommendations for music - -discovery and consumption could be a cause of uncertainty and concern -for consumers and artists if their operation, including any underlying -algorithms, is not fair and transparent. - -(d) how difficult it is to switch between music streaming services and whether -this limits the strength of competition between those services when the -market is no longer growing. - -(e) if the level of innovation on the part of streaming services were to - -decrease; or if innovations that would benefit consumers were to be -prohibited by music companies; or if consumers were to be -disadvantaged in other ways, including through significantly higher prices. - -18 +Zwick ME, Cutler DJ, Chakravarti A (2000) Patterns of genetic variation in Mendelian and complex +traits. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 1: 387–407. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.genom.1.1.387 +PMID: 11701635 + +32. Cassa CA, Weghorn D, Balick DJ, Jordan DM, Nusinow D, et al. (2017) Estimating the Selective Effect +of Heterozygous Protein Truncating Variants from Human Exome Data. Nat Genet 49: 806–810. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.3831 PMID: 28369035 + +33. + +The Thousand Genomes Consortium (2015) A global reference for human genetic variation. Nature +526: 68–74. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature15393 PMID: 26432245 + +34. Neale BM, Kou Y, Liu L, Ma/’ayan A, Samocha KE, et al. (2012) Patterns and rates of exonic de novo +mutations in autism spectrum disorders. Nature 485: 242–245. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11011 +PMID: 22495311 + +35. + +Fu W, O’Connor T, Jun G, Kang H, Abecasis G, et al. (2013) Analysis of 6,515 exomes reveals the +recent origin of most human protein-coding variants. Nature 493: 216–220. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11690 PMID: 23201682 + +36. Segurel L, Wyman MJ, Przeworski M (2014) Determinants of mutation rate variation in the human germ- +line. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 15: 47–70. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-genom-031714- +125740 PMID: 25000986 + +37. + +Lohmueller KE, Indap AR, Schmidt S, Boyko AR, Hernandez RD, et al. (2008) Proportionally more dele- +terious genetic variation in European than in African populations. Nature 451: 994–997. https://doi.org/ +10.1038/nature06611 PMID: 18288194 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +21 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +38. Peischl S, Dupanloup I, Bosshard L, Excoffier L (2016) Genetic surfing in human populations: from + +genes to genomes. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 53–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.08.003 PMID: +27584859 + +39. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- + +mon variant. . .or not? PMID: 12351577 + +40. Aggarwala V, Voight BF (2016) An expanded sequence context model broadly explains variability in + +polymorphism levels across the human genome. Nat Genet 48: 349–355. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng. +3511 PMID: 26878723 + +41. Hodgkinson A, Eyre-Walker A Variation in the mutation rate across mammalian genomes. Nat Rev + +Genet 12: 756–766. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg3098 PMID: 21969038 + +42. Moorjani P, Amorim CE, Arndt PF, Przeworski M (2016) Variation in the molecular clock of primates. +Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 113: 10607–10612. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1600374113 PMID: +27601674 + +43. Kamphans T, Sabri P, Zhu N, Heinrich V, Mundlos S, et al. (2013) Filtering for compound heterozygous + +sequence variants in non-consanguineous pedigrees. PLoS One 8: e70151. https://doi.org/10.1371/ +journal.pone.0070151 PMID: 23940540 + +44. Burkhart BD, Montgomery E, Langley CH, Voelker RA (1984) Characterization of Allozyme Null and + +Low Activity Alleles from Two Natural Populations of DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER. Genetics 107: +295–306. PMID: 17246217 + +45. Xue Y, Chen Y, Ayub Q, Huang N, Ball EV, et al. (2012) Deleterious- and disease-allele prevalence in +healthy individuals: insights from current predictions, mutation databases, and population-scale rese- +quencing. Am J Hum Genet 91: 1022–1032. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2012.10.015 PMID: +23217326 + +46. Piton A, Redin C, Mandel JL (2013) XLID-causing mutations and associated genes challenged in light +of data from large-scale human exome sequencing. Am J Hum Genet 93: 368–383. https://doi.org/10. +1016/j.ajhg.2013.06.013 PMID: 23871722 + +47. Gazave E, Ma L, Chang D, Coventry A, Gao F, et al. (2014) Neutral genomic regions refine models of + +recent rapid human population growth. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 111: 757–762. https://doi.org/10. +1073/pnas.1310398110 PMID: 24379384 + +48. Gao F, Keinan A (2016) Explosive genetic evidence for explosive human population growth. Curr Opin + +Genet Dev 41: 130–139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.09.002 PMID: 27710906 + +49. Wright S (1931) Evolution in Mendelian populations. Genetics 16: 97–159. PMID: 17246615 + +50. Ober C, Hyslop T, Hauck WW (1999) Inbreeding Effects on Fertility in Humans: Evidence for Reproduc- + +tive Compensation. The American Journal of Human Genetics 64: 225–231. https://doi.org/10.1086/ +302198 PMID: 9915962 + +51. Gabriel SE, Brigman KN, Koller BH, Boucher RC, Stutts MJ (1994) Cystic fibrosis heterozygote resis- +tance to cholera toxin in the cystic fibrosis mouse model. Science 266: 107–109. PMID: 7524148 + +52. Wagener D, Cavalli-Sforza LL, Barakat R (1978) Ethnic variation of genetic disease: roles of drift for + +recessive lethal genes. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 262–270. PMID: 677123 + +53. Quinton PM (1994) Human genetics. What is good about cystic fibrosis? Curr Biol 4: 742–743. PMID: + +7525005 + +54. Chakravarti A, Chakraborty R (1978) Elevated frequency of Tay-Sachs disease among Ashkenazic + +Jews unlikely by genetic drift alone. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 256–261. PMID: 677122 + +55. Ewens WJ (1978) Tay-Sachs disease and theoretical population genetics. American Journal of Human + +Genetics 30: 328–329. PMID: 677129 + +56. + +Landrum MJ, Lee JM, Riley GR, Jang W, Rubinstein WS, et al. (2014) ClinVar: public archive of rela- +tionships among sequence variation and human phenotype. Nucleic acids research 42: D980–D985. +https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkt1113 PMID: 24234437 + +57. Eppig JT, Blake JA, Bult CJ, Kadin JA, Richardson JE (2015) The Mouse Genome Database (MGD): + +facilitating mouse as a model for human biology and disease. Nucleic Acids Res 43: D726–736. https:// +doi.org/10.1093/nar/gku967 PMID: 25348401 + +58. Gravel S, Henn BM, Gutenkunst RN, Indap AR, Marth GT, et al. (2011) Demographic history and rare + +allele sharing among human populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 108: 11983–11988. https://doi.org/ +10.1073/pnas.1019276108 PMID: 21730125 + +59. Mugal CF, Ellegren H (2011) Substitution rate variation at human CpG sites correlates with non-CpG + +divergence, methylation level and GC content. Genome Biol 12: R58. https://doi.org/10.1186/gb-2011- +12-6-r58 PMID: 21696599 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +22 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +60. North BV, Curtis D, Sham PC (2002) A Note on the Calculation of Empirical Values from Monte Carlo +Procedures. The American Journal of Human Genetics 71: 439–441. https://doi.org/10.1086/341527 +PMID: 12111669 + +61. Quinlan AR, Hall IM (2010) BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic features. Bioin- + +formatics 26: 841–842. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btq033 PMID: 20110278 + +62. R Core Team (2015) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria. + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +23 / 23 diff --git a/q227/random_k4/random_3.md b/q227/random_k4/random_3.md index 314f7476a81f8217ad5531402f8f3255b7f5dbd2..82b82c26456cb0f85a7ad988e31ecf2fa7ec88b3 100644 --- a/q227/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q227/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,228 +1,658 @@ -Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap +E17889 +First Edition / June 2021 -Parte 1 – Introduzione ed esempi +User Guide -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 +MyASUS FAQ - OpenStreetMap + Top View -• OpenStreetMap è un progetto che crea e -fornisce dati cartografici liberi e gratuiti a -chiunque ne abbia bisogno. +NOTE: The keyboard's layout may vary per region or country. The top view may also +vary in appearance depending on the Notebook PC model. -• Il progetto è stato avviato perché la maggior +Array microphones -parte delle mappe che si credono liberamente -utilizzabili, hanno invece restrizioni legali o -tecniche al loro utilizzo e ciò ne impedisce -l'uso per scopi produttivi, creativi o inattesi. +Camera indicator - Esempio base di ciclo di utilizzo +Camera/Webcam shield +(built-in) -Programma -di editing (JOSM) +360º-adjustable +touch screen panel -Database +Power button/ +Fingerprint sensor -Mappatore +Keyboard -Sentiero +Touchpad/NumberPad -Escursionisti +Function key lock indicator -Mappa o -servizio -online +Capital lock indicator -GPS +2 - La mappa +Notebook PC User Guide Using the NumberPad (on selected models) -http://www.openstreetmap.org +• - Altre mappe: cyclemap +• -http://www.opencyclemap.org +• - Altre mappe: 4umaps -http://www.4umaps.eu +Press and hold - Altre mappe: webmapp.it + for a second to toggle between number keys or touchpad. -http://www.webmapp.it +Tap - Includere la mappa in un sito internet + to adjust brightness for the NumberPad. -Librerie: Leaflet, Openlayers +Press and hold - Applicazioni Smartphone + then slide anywhere on the NumberPad to launch Windows -Navit +Calculator. -OsmAnd +IMPORTANT! Please note that all versions of NumberPad are only supported on the +latest Microsoft Windows® operating system. -OruxMaps +NOTE: To use the % and = function, set the input language to English. -ViewRanger +3 -http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software/Mobile (in inglese) +Notebook PC User Guide I/O ports and slots - Applicazioni Smartphone +MicroSD card slot -Esempio possibilità di routing -su sentieri e forestali +HDMI output port - GPS Garmin +Headphone/Headset/Microphone jack -• Alcuni siti con istruzioni e dati +Thunderbolt™ 4 port with +Power Delivery -– http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:OSM_Map_On +USB 3.2 Gen 2 port -_Garmin +IMPORTANT! +To prevent any damage, use only power sources rated 20V/5A to charge your Notebook PC with +the USB Power Delivery combo port. For more information, consult an ASUS service center for +assistance. -– http://cuneotrekking.com/2013/03/24/openstreetma -p-come-caricare-mappe-gratuite-sul-garmin-etrex-30/ +ASUS Pen (on selected models) -– https://sites.google.com/site/stefanodroghetti/nuvi -– http://www.mtb- +Right-click button -forum.it/community/forum/showthread.php?p=3454 -010 +Eraser button -– http://openmtbmap.org/it/tutorials/enbeginners- +4 -starting-guide-dewo-beginnen-tutorial/ +Notebook PC User Guide Getting started - Trovare un percorso tra due città +IMPORTANT! +Do not use this Notebook PC for cryptocurrency mining (consuming a vast amount of electricity +and time to gain convertible virtual currency) and/or related activities. -http://www.yournavigation.org/ +1. Charge your Notebook PC - Creare una rotta su ViewRanger.com +A. Connect the DC power connector into your Notebook PC’s power (DC) input port. -http://my.viewranger.com/ +B. Plug the AC power adapter into a 100V~240V power source. - Scaricare una mappa con Mobile Atlas Creator +IMPORTANT! Use only the bundled power adapter to charge the battery pack and +supply power to your Notebook PC. -http://mobac.sourceforge.net/ +NOTE: The power adapter may vary in appearance, depending on models and your +region. - Scaricare i dati con overpass-turbo.eu +2. Lift to open the display panel -http://overpass-turbo.eu/ +3. Press the power button - Disegnare la propria mappa con Maperitive +Charge the Notebook PC +for 3 hours before using +it in battery mode for the +first time. -http://maperitive.net/ +5 - Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap +Notebook PC User Guide -Parte 2 – Introduzione a JOSM + Safety notices for your Notebook PC +WARNING! +Your Notebook PC can get warm to hot while in use or while charging the battery pack. Do not +leave your Notebook PC on your lap or near any part of your body to prevent injury from heat. +When working on your Notebook PC, do not place it on surfaces that can block the vents. -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 +CAUTION! +• This Notebook PC should only be used in environments with ambient temperatures between - Workshop introduttivo sull'inserimento -di dati in OpenStreetMap +5°C (41°F) and 35°C (95°F). -Parte 3 - Documentazione +• Refer to the rating label on the bottom of your Notebook PC and ensure that your power -Rovereto – 13 novembre 2013 +adapter complies with this rating. - WIKI internazionale +• The power adapter may become warm to hot while in use. Do not cover the adapter and keep -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org +it away from your body while it is connected to a power source. - WIKI italiano +IMPORTANT! +• Ensure that your Notebook PC is connected to the power adapter before turning it on for the +first time. Always plug the power cord into a wall socket without using any extension cords. +For your safety, connect this device to a properly grounded electrical outlet only. -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Main_Page +• When using your Notebook PC on power adapter mode, the socket outlet must be near to the - Map Features (come “etichettare” gli -oggetti della mappa) +unit and easily accessible. -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Map_Features +• Locate the input/output rating label on your Notebook PC and ensure that it matches the +input/output rating information on your power adapter. Some Notebook PC models may +have multiple rating output currents based on the available SKU. - WIKI trentino +• Power adapter information: -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino +- Input voltage: 100-240Vac - Particolarità trentine +- Input frequency: 50-60Hz -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino/Strade_forestali +- Rating output current: 5A (100W) -_provinciali +- Rating output voltage: 20V -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Trentino/Sentieri +WARNING! +Read the following precautions for your Notebook PC’s battery: - Mailing list italiana +• Only ASUS-authorized technicians should +remove the battery inside the device +(for non-removable battery only). -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/ +• The battery used in this device may present +a risk of fire or chemical burn if removed or +disassembled. - Mailing list trentina +• Follow the warning labels for your personal -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it-trentino -• https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it-trentino/ +safety. - Guide +• Risk of explosion if battery is replaced by an -• http://learnosm.org/it/ -• http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Beginners%27_Guide -• http://svn.openstreetmap.org/misc/pr_material/italy_minigui +incorrect type. -da/tutorial.pdf +• Do not dispose of in fire. -• http://svn.openstreetmap.org/misc/pr_material/italy_minigui +• Never attempt to short-circuit your -da/book.pdf +Notebook PC’s battery. - Dati liberi in Trentino +• Never attempt to disassemble and -• http://dati.trentino.it -• http://www2.comune.rovereto.tn.it/servizionline/extra/open +reassemble the battery +(for non-removable battery only). -data/ +• Discontinue usage if leakage is found. -• http://www.sat.tn.it/default.aspx?fn=loadarea&idarea=450 +• This battery and its components must be - Trentino – Cosa c’è da fare +recycled or disposed of properly. -Importazione strade forestali PAT mancanti +• Keep the battery and other small +components away from children. -• -• Completare rete sentieri SAT -• Mappatura di dettaglio in centri minori e periferici (edifici ma +6 + +Notebook PC User Guide + + Avis concernant les batteries remplaçables + +• La batterie de l’appareil peut présenter un risque d’incendie ou de brûlure si celle-ci est + +retirée ou désassemblée. + +• La batterie et ses composants doivent être recyclés de façon appropriée. + +Copyright Information +You acknowledge that all rights of this Manual remain with ASUS. Any and all rights, including without +limitation, in the Manual or website, are and shall remain the exclusive property of ASUS and/or its +licensors. Nothing in this Manual intends to transfer any such rights, or to vest any such rights to you. + +ASUS PROVIDES THIS MANUAL “AS IS” WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. SPECIFICATIONS AND +INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS MANUAL ARE FURNISHED FOR INFORMATIONAL USE ONLY, AND +ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE AT ANY TIME WITHOUT NOTICE, AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS A +COMMITMENT BY ASUS. + +Copyright © 2021 ASUSTeK COMPUTER INC. All Rights Reserved. + +Limitation of Liability +Circumstances may arise where because of a default on ASUS’ part or other liability, you are entitled to +recover damages from ASUS. In each such instance, regardless of the basis on which you are entitled to +claim damages from ASUS, ASUS is liable for no more than damages for bodily injury (including death) +and damage to real property and tangible personal property; or any other actual and direct damages +resulted from omission or failure of performing legal duties under this Warranty Statement, up to the +listed contract price of each product. + +ASUS will only be responsible for or indemnify you for loss, damages or claims based in contract, tort or +infringement under this Warranty Statement. + +This limit also applies to ASUS’ suppliers and its reseller. It is the maximum for which ASUS, its suppliers, +and your reseller are collectively responsible. + +UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES IS ASUS LIABLE FOR ANY OF THE FOLLOWING: (1) THIRD-PARTY CLAIMS +AGAINST YOU FOR DAMAGES; (2) LOSS OF, OR DAMAGE TO, YOUR RECORDS OR DATA; OR (3) SPECIAL, +INCIDENTAL, OR INDIRECT DAMAGES OR FOR ANY ECONOMIC CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING +LOST PROFITS OR SAVINGS), EVEN IF ASUS, ITS SUPPLIERS OR YOUR RESELLER IS INFORMED OF THEIR +POSSIBILITY. + +Service and Support +For complete E-Manual version, refer to our multi-language website at: +https://www.asus.com/support/ + +MyASUS offers a variety of support features including troubleshooting, products performance +optimization, ASUS software integration, and helps you to organize personal desktop and increase +storage space. For more details, please visit https://www.asus.com/support/FAQ/1038301/. + +7 + +Notebook PC User Guide FCC Radio Frequency (RF) Exposure Caution +Statement + +WARNING! Any changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party +responsible for compliance could void the user’s authority to operate this equipment. + +This equipment complies with FCC radiation exposure limits set forth for an uncontrolled +environment. To maintain compliance with FCC RF exposure compliance requirements, please +avoid direct contact to the transmitting antenna during transmitting. End users must follow the +specific operating instructions for satisfying RF exposure compliance. + +UL Safety Notices + +• DO NOT use the Notebook PC near water, for example, near a bath tub, wash bowl, kitchen + +sink or laundry tub, in a wet basement or near a swimming pool. + +• DO NOT use the Notebook PC during an electrical storm. There may be a remote risk of + +electric shock from lightning. + +• DO NOT use the Notebook PC in the vicinity of a gas leak. + +• DO NOT dispose the Notebook PC battery pack in a fire, as they may explode. Check with local +codes for possible special disposal instructions to reduce the risk of injury to persons due to +fire or explosion. + +• DO NOT use power adapters or batteries from other devices to reduce the risk of injury to -anche nomi vie) -Importazione toponimi PAT +persons due to fire or explosion. Use only UL certified power adapters or batteries supplied +by the manufacturer or authorized retailers. + +Coating Notice + +IMPORTANT! To provide electrical insulation and maintain electrical safety, a coating +is applied to insulate the device except on the areas where the I/O ports are located. + +Prevention of Hearing Loss +To prevent possible hearing damage, do not listen at high volume levels for long +periods. + +Power Safety Requirement +Products with electrical current ratings up to 6A and weighing more than 3Kg must use +approved power cords greater than or equal to: H05VV-F, 3G, 0.75mm2 or H05VV-F, 2G, 0.75mm2. + +8 + +Notebook PC User Guide Declaration of Compliance for Product Environmental +Regulation +ASUS follows the green design concept to design and manufacture our products, and +makes sure that each stage of the product life cycle of ASUS product is in line with global +environmental regulations. In addition, ASUS disclose the relevant information based on +regulation requirements. Please refer to http://csr.asus.com/Compliance.htm for information +disclosure based on regulation requirements ASUS is complied with. + +EU REACH and Article 33 +Complying with the REACH (Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and Restriction of +Chemicals) regulatory framework, we publish the chemical substances in our products at ASUS +REACH website at http://csr.asus.com/english/REACH.htm. + +EU RoHS +This product complies with the EU RoHS Directive. For more details, see +http://csr.asus.com/english/article.aspx?id=35. + +Japan JIS-C-0950 Material Declarations +Information on Japan RoHS (JIS-C-0950) chemical disclosures is available on +http://csr.asus.com/english/article.aspx?id=19. + +India RoHS +This product complies with the “India E-Waste (Management) Rules, 2016” and prohibits use of +lead, mercury, hexavalent chromium, polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) and polybrominated +diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) in concentrations exceeding 0.1% by weight in homogenous materials +and 0.01% by weight in homogenous materials for cadmium, except for the exemptions listed +in Schedule II of the Rule. + +Vietnam RoHS +ASUS products sold in Vietnam, on or after September 23, 2011, meet the requirements of the +Vietnam Circular 30/2011/TT-BCT. + +Các sản phẩm ASUS bán tại Việt Nam, vào ngày 23 tháng 9 năm2011 trở về sau, đều phải đáp +ứng các yêu cầu của Thông tư 30/2011/TT-BCT của Việt Nam. + +9 + +Notebook PC User Guide ASUS Recycling/Takeback Services +ASUS recycling and takeback programs come from our commitment to the highest standards for +protecting our environment. We believe in providing solutions for you to be able to responsibly +recycle our products, batteries, other components as well as the packaging materials. Please +go to http://csr.asus.com/english/Takeback.htm for detailed recycling information in different +regions. + +Ecodesign Directive +European Union announced a framework for the setting of ecodesign requirements for energy- +related products (2009/125/EC). Specific Implementing Measures are aimed at improving +environmental performance of specific products or across multiple product types. ASUS +provides product information on the CSR website. Further information could be found at +https://csr.asus.com/english/article.aspx?id=1555. + +EPEAT Registered Products +The public disclosure of key environmental information for ASUS EPEAT (Electronic Product +Environmental Assessment Tool) registered products is available at +https://csr.asus.com/english/article.aspx?id=41. More information about EPEAT program and +purchase guidance can be found at www.epeat.net. + +Regional notice for Singapore + +Complies with +IMDA Standards +DB103778 + +This ASUS product complies with IMDA Standards. + +RF Exposure Information (SAR) +This device meets the government’s requirements for exposure to radio waves. This device is +designed and manufactured not to exceed the emission limits for exposure to radio frequency +(RF) energy set by the Federal Communications Commission of the U.S. Government. + +The exposure standard for wireless device employs a unit of measurement known as the Specific +Absorption Rate, or SAR. The SAR limit set by the FCC is 1.6 W/kg. Tests for SAR are conducted +using standard operating positions accepted by the FCC with the device transmitting at its +highest certified power level in all tested frequency bands. + +10 + +Notebook PC User Guide Simplified EU Declaration of Conformity +ASUSTek Computer Inc. hereby declares that this device is in compliance with the essential +requirements and other relevant provisions of Directive 2014/53/EU. Full text of EU declaration +of conformity is available at https://www.asus.com/support/. + +The WiFi operating in the band 5150-5350 MHz shall be restricted to indoor use for countries +listed in the table below: + +AT +DE +LV +NO +FI + +BE +IS +LI +PL +SE + +BG +IE +LT +PT +CH + +CZ +IT +LU +RO +HR + +DK +EL +HU +SI +UK(NI) + +EE +ES +MT +SK + +FR +CY +NL +TR + +Simplified UKCA Declaration of Conformity +ASUSTek Computer Inc. hereby declares that this device is in compliance with the essential +requirements and other relevant provisions of The Radio Equipment Regulations 2017 (S.I. +2017/1206). Full text of UKCA declaration of conformity is available at +https://www.asus.com/support/. + +The WiFi operating in the band 5150-5350 MHz shall be restricted to indoor use for the country +listed below: + +11 + +Notebook PC User Guide RF Exposure information (SAR) +This device meets the EU requirements (2014/53/EU) on the limitation of exposure of the +general public to electromagnetic fields by way of health protection. + +The limits are part of extensive recommendations for the protection of the general public. These +recommendations have been developed and checked by independent scientific organizations +through regular and thorough evaluations of scientific studies. The unit of measurement for the +European Council’s recommended limit for mobile devices is the “Specific Absorption Rate” (SAR), +and the SAR limit is 2.0 W/Kg averaged over 10 gram of body tissue. It meets the requirements +of the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP). + +For next-to-body operation, this device has been tested and meets the ICNIRP exposure +guidelines and the European Standard EN 50566 and EN 62209-2. SAR is measured with the +device directly contacted to the body while transmitting at the highest certified output power +level in all frequency bands of the mobile device. + +A minimum separation distance of 1 cm must be maintained between the user’s body and the +device, including the antenna during body-worn operation to comply with the RF exposure +requirements in Europe. + +12 + +Notebook PC User Guide Federal Communications Commission Interference +Statement +This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits for a Class B digital +device, pursuant to part 15 of the FCC Rules. These limits are designed to provide reasonable +protection against harmful interference in a residential installation. This equipment generates, +uses and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed and used in accordance with +the instructions, may cause harmful interference to radio communications. However, there is +no guarantee that interference will not occur in a particular installation. If this equipment does +cause harmful interference to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning +the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to correct the interference by one or +more of the following measures: + +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. • -• Numeri civici ?? -• …. - Link utili da usare durante il Workshop +Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. + +• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that to which the receiver is + +connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. + + FCC COMPLIANCE INFORMATION + +Per FCC Part 2 Section 2.1077 + +Responsible Party: Asus Computer International + +Address: + +48720 Kato Rd., Fremont, CA 94538 + +Phone/Fax No: + +(510)739-3777/(510)608-4555 + +hereby declares that the product + +Product Name : ZenBook + +Model Number : UP5401E, RP5401E + +compliance statement: + +This device complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is subject to the +following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause harmful interference, +and (2) this device must accept any interference received, including interference +that may cause undesired operation. + + Ver. 180620 + +13 + +Notebook PC User Guide + + CE RED RF Output table (Directive 2014/53/EU) + +MT7921 + +Function + +WiFi + +Bluetooth + +* Receiver category 1 + +Intel AX201NGW + +Function + +WiFi + +Bluetooth + +* Receiver category 2 + +Frequency +2412 - 2472 MHz + +5150 - 5350 MHz + +5470 - 5725 MHz + +5725 - 5850 MHz + +2402 - 2480 MHz + +Frequency +2412 - 2472 MHz + +5150 - 5350 MHz + +5470 - 5725 MHz + +5725 - 5850 MHz + +2402 - 2480 MHz + +Maximum Output Power (EIRP) +19 dBm + +22 dBm + +20 dBm + +13.97 dBm + +14 dBm + +Maximum Output Power (EIRP) +19 dBm + +22 dBm + +23 dBm + +13.97 dBm + +13 dBm + +14 + +Notebook PC User Guide UKCA RF Output table +(The Radio Equipment Regulations 2017) + +MT7921 + +Function + +WiFi + +Bluetooth + +* Receiver category 1 + +Intel AX201NGW + +Function + +WiFi + +Bluetooth + +* Receiver category 2 + +Frequency +2412 - 2472 MHz + +5150 - 5350 MHz + +5470 - 5725 MHz + +5725 - 5850 MHz + +2402 - 2480 MHz + +Frequency +2412 - 2472 MHz + +5150 - 5350 MHz + +5470 - 5725 MHz + +5725 - 5850 MHz + +2402 - 2480 MHz + +Maximum Output Power (EIRP) +19 dBm + +22 dBm -Pagina di registrazione su OSM +20 dBm -https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/new +13.97 dBm -Installazione JOSM +14 dBm -http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:JOSM#Inst -allazione +Maximum Output Power (EIRP) +19 dBm -File preimpostazioni JOSM utile per mappare -forestali e sentieri SAT +22 dBm -https://www.dropbox.com/s/hjoq9nf3zx7mfdz/Pr -esets_TNTracks-preset.xml +23 dBm -File gpx di forestali trentine da importare +13.97 dBm -File con tutte le forestali trentine +13 dBm -https://www.dropbox.com/sh/kd616xtq47ct5wd/ -gFnS9iVodO +15 -https://www.dropbox.com/s/g9zq64gwis9ldqn/for -estali_tn.zip +Notebook PC User Guide 16 +Notebook PC User Guide \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k2/question.json b/q231/random_k2/question.json index e0a79b2de25854c965a25c2be7bd6fccbadb6cf1..3409a54a39020252852e1c479e9ab249ca5309a7 100644 --- a/q231/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q231/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NIKE_2021_10K.pdf", - "web_6019e7c0934ca3b6.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf" + "web_0fc33975f03605a5.pdf", + "resize_r2_23.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k2/random_1.md b/q231/random_k2/random_1.md index 1c064e3ff046ea90ec57fa6e9a2c7b22d1110cc1..15d75a09f41359a0dd28001b377846c0439ea651 100644 --- a/q231/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q231/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1527 +1,589 @@ -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary -Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) -Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) -1. Date of Submission: 8/17/2007 -2. Agency: Department of Justice -3. Bureau: Federal Bureau Of Investigation -4. Name of this Capital Asset: FBI Digital Collection -5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: (For IT 011-10-01-02-01-2503-00 -investment only, see section 53. For all other, use agency -ID system.) -6. What kind of investment will this be in FY2009? (Please Mixed Life Cycle -NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY2009, with -Planning/Acquisition activities prior to FY2009 should not -select O&M. These investments should indicate their current -status.) -7. What was the first budget year this investment was FY2001 or earlier -submitted to OMB? -8. Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this closes in part or -in whole an identified agency performance gap: -Since September 2001, the FBI's demands for critical, timely intelligence gathering have increased significantly. Pre- -September 2001 ELSUR intercepts (per year) have increased. Not only do demands for information continue to increase, -but also the requirement to facilitate information sharing does. The current collection enterprise consists of Foreign -Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) and Criminal Law Enforcement (CLE) systems. Today's telecommunications -capabilities afford terrorists and criminals many avenues to coordinate and commit offenses against U.S. citizens and -interests. Communications methods, such as voice over internet protocol (VoIP) and voice over packet (VoP), are -dramatically increasing in number and complexity, resulting in the continual and evolving need for advanced methods of -electronic surveillance of voice communications; methods of electronic surveillance have limited-life utility in intercepting -newer, more secure types of publicly offered communications. The expansion of electronic surveillance activity in -frequency, sophistication, and linguistic needs continues to increase the level of support, transportability, and -information sharing required. An important factor behind this expansion is the changing demographic of targets that -must be monitored by investigators. Further, the life span of today's technology is often much shorter than older -technologies, resulting in more frequent need for solution development. Collection equipment manufacturers continue -toward complying with technical standards as a result of the Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act -(CALEA). One result of the CALEA standard is more information is available for collection. -9. Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee Yes -approve this request? -a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval? 5/19/2007 -10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? Yes -11. Contact information of Project Manager? -Name -Phone Number -Email -a. What is the current FAC-P/PM certification level of the TBD -project/program manager? -12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost Yes -effective, energy-efficient and environmentally sustainable -techniques or practices for this project? -a. Will this investment include electronic assets Yes -(including computers)? -b. Is this investment for new construction or major No -retrofit of a Federal building or facility? (answer applicable -to non-IT assets only) -1. If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help -fund this investment? -Page 1 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable -design principles? -3. If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy -efficient than relevant code? -13. Does this investment directly support one of the PMA Yes -initiatives? -If "yes," check all that apply: Human Capital -Expanded E-Government -a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected Strategic Management of Human Capital. The FBI acquires -how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)? individuals with rare linguistic skills by collocating and -(e.g. If E-Gov is selected, is it an approved shared service networking the collection assets within proximity for -provider or the managing partner?) employment, training, and development. A work flow -management module is used by operations managers -monitor productivity and distribute work accordingly. -Expanded E-Gov -14. Does this investment support a program assessed using No -the Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more -information about the PART, visit -www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) -a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness -found during a PART review? -b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? -c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? -15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes -If the answer to Question 15 is "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is "No," do not answer questions -16-23. -For information technology investments only: -16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Level 1 -Guidance) -17. What project management qualifications does the (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this -Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) investment -18. Is this investment or any project(s) within this No -investment identified as "high risk" on the Q4 - FY 2007 -agency high risk report (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) -19. Is this a financial management system? No -a. If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA -compliance area? -1. If "yes," which compliance area: -2. If "no," what does it address? -b. If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent financial -systems inventory update required by Circular A-11 section 52 -20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2009 funding request for the following? (This should total 100%) -Hardware -Software -Services -Other -21. If this project produces information dissemination N/A -products for the public, are these products published to the -Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and -included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? -22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions: -Name -Phone Number -Title Acting FBI Privacy and Civil Liberties Officer -Page 2 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -E-mail -23. Are the records produced by this investment No -appropriately scheduled with the National Archives and -Records Administration's approval? -Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: -24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO Yes -High Risk Areas? -Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) -1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts represent -budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be included only in -the row designated "Government FTE Cost," and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full -Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." The "TOTAL" estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for -"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should -include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or restoration costs. The costs associated with the -entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this report. -Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES -(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) -(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) -P -e -Y -a --1 -rl i -a -e -n -r -d -PY 2007 CY 2008 BY 2009 BY+1 2010BY+2 2011BY+3 2012 -B -b -Y -e -+ -y -4 -o n -an -d -d -Total -Planning: 13.915 2 2.554 0 0 0 0 0 18.469 -Acquisition: 142.387 0 21.181 21.261 0 0 0 0 184.829 -Subtotal Planning & 156.302 2 23.735 21.261 0 0 0 0 203.298 -Acquisition: -Operations & Maintenance: 80.936 20.916 15.547 21.075 -TOTAL: 237.238 22.916 39.282 42.336 -Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. -Government FTE Costs 9.045 1.905 7.378 7.378 -Number of FTE represented 14 7 21 21 -by Costs: -Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner -agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. -2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional Yes -FTE's? -a. If "yes," How many and in what year? Ten FTEs were requested for this project in FY08 Exhibit -300 submission to perform requirements generation, -testing/evaluation, installation of new/upgraded equipment, -and user training as well as, system administration -expertise, telephonic/on-site technical support and system -maintenance support. The FTEs are included in the FY08 -President?s Budget; no additional personnel resources are -required upon approval of the request. -3. If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2008 President's budget request, briefly explain those changes: -The FY 2008 request for personnel enhancement of 14 personnel and non-personnel enhancement of $7,035,000 will -enhance the Digital Collection project's capacity to provide next generation systems, facilities, and capabilities to enable -continuance of audio and data collection in the furtherance of the FBI's FCI and Counterterrorism (CT) responsibilities. -The nonpersonnel enhancement will be used for new systems and equipment purchases ($3,850,000) and professional -and technical services ($3,185,000).. Without the requested resources, the number of funded contractor positions is -expected to increase. -Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) -1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned for this -investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders completed do -not need to be included. -Page 3 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) - -Contracts/Task Orders Table: - * Costs in millions -If N/A, has -the agency -| | | | What, if | | | determined | -| --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | -| | If so what | | any, | Does the | | the CO | -| | is the date | | alternative | contract | Contracting | assigned | -Has the Total Value Is this an -of the Start date Is it Competitiv financing Is EVM in include the CO Contact Officer has the -Contract or Type of contract award? If of End date of of Interagenc performanc ely option is the required information Certificatio competenci -Task Order Contract/ been Contract/ Contract/ y Name of CO -Number n o t , w h a t i s C o n t r a c t / e b a s e d ? aw ar d e d ? b e i n g co n t r ac t ? s e c u r i t y & (pho n e / em n L e v e l e s a n d -Task Order aw a r de d Task Order Tas k O r d er Ac q u is i ti o n -(Y / N ) t h e p la n n e d T a s k O r d e r ( $ M ) ? ( Y / N ) ( Y / N ) (Y / N ) u s e d ? ( Y / N ) p r i v a c y a il ) ( L e v e l s k il ls -a w a r d ( E S P C , c l a u s e s ? 1, 2 , 3 , N / A ) ne c e s s a r y -| | date? | | | (Y/N) | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | -| | | | UESC, EUL, | | | to support | -| | | | N/A) | | | this | -acquisition -? (Y/N) -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -FFP IDIQ Yes 9/28/2002 9/28/2002 9/27/2008 120 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - FFP Yes 4/1/2005 4/1/2005 8/2/2008 9.39 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP IDIQ Yes 9/15/2003 9/15/2003 9/15/2008 47 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 9/3/2003 9/3/2003 9/8/2008 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 10/1/2003 10/1/2003 9/30/2008 50 Yes No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -FFP Yes 10/7/2004 10/7/2004 10/5/2009 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | - -Page 4 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain -why: -Although EVM was not incorporated at the project's inception, a modified form of earned value management is being used -internally by the project team to monitor contractors' cost and schedule performance. Internal procedures are being used to -monitor FFP contracts using a straight-line calculation for services delivered and 100% earned value for product deliverables -received. Current contracts, being performed under the Digital Collection Project are Firm Fixed Price for Project Management -and Operations and Maintenance (O&M) of current systems; however, there are provisions within contract J-FBI-02-158 that -permit the time and material (T&M) and cost reimbursable (CR) efforts to be accomplished for research, development, and -unforeseen (O&M) requirements. It should also be noted that current and previous contracts did not include ANSI-compliant -EVMS because they did not meet the DOJ threshhold for ANSI-748 compliance. -For new developmental contracts the Digital Collection project will review, and include where appropriate, acquisition -requirements for ANSI-748 compliant EVM, as well as performance based contracting. -3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? Yes -a. Explain why: Contracts supporting this requirement ensure Section 508 -compliance in order to meet legal requirements as well as -satisfy needs of user personnel. -4. Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in Yes -accordance with agency requirements? -a. If "yes," what is the date? 2/9/2001 -b. If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed? -1. If "no," briefly explain why: -Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) -In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency and be linked -to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and strategic goals, and performance -measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the agency's strategic goals and objectives this -investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to -the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall -citizen participation rate of 75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if -applicable, investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general -goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure. -Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use the Federal -Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement Indicators to the corresponding -"Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There should be at least one Measurement Indicator -for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be -extended to include performance measures for years beyond FY 2009. -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year -Su -G -p -o -p -a -o -l( -r -s -te -) -d -Meas -A -u -r -r -e -e -a -m ent Me -C -a -a -s -t -u -e -r -g -e -o -m -ry -e nt Me -G -a -r -s -o -u -u -r -p -e -i -m -ng -e nt Me -I -a -n -s -d +Chapter 7 + +Competitive Positioning + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Short Description +• Background +• Strategic Rationale & Implications +• Strengths & Advantages +• Weaknesses & Limitations +• Process for Applying Technique +• Summary +• FAROUT + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.2 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Short Description +• Analyze a position relative to one’s own in order + +to: +– Preserve an advantage +– Attempt an improvement +– Withdraw from a market + +• Looks at: + +– Market share, client perceptions, current + +marketing strategies, prices and costs, and +competitors’ positions. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.3 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Background + +1950’s-60’s + +Late 60’s- +70’s + +•‘Corporate planning’ approach by firms founded on +steady expansion in a stable financial environment. +•Marketing tells about product benefits in comparison +with competition. + +•Corporate planning shifts to strategic planning and +management to as competition increases and market is +more volatile. +•Marketing attempts to change perception of product in +the mind of the customer by creating unique position. + +1980’s- now •Competitive positioning continues to evolve to provides +information with importance to the development of a +strategic plan by giving a firm an overview of its industry +and enabling it to appraise its own competitive position. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.4 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strategic Rationale & Implications + +• Analysis should reveal firms’ position within an industry. +• Overview of industry as a whole. +• A variety of tools and models can assist, including: + +Porter’s Five Forces Industry Analysis +Nine Forces Industry Analysis +BCG Matrix +McKinsey Matrix +Perceptual Maps + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.5 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Strategic Rationale & Implications + +4 Directions for any Strategy + +Develop firms’ +position + +Expand niche + +Minor to dominant + +Joint to sole +dominance + +Maintain strong position + +Preserve market share +in mature market + +Defend dominant position + +Withdraw from market + +Price cutting strategy + +New product +strategy + +Other strategies + +Market decline or +obsolescence + +Unsuccessful +expansion + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.6 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strengths and Advantages +• Improves decision making + +• Provides information for firms of all sizes, + +stages, and positions on: +– Gaps in marketplace +– Viability of products or markets +– Competition in new markets +– Attracting investment and creating alliances + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.7 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Weaknesses and Limitations +• Care must be taken in defining industries and + +markets. + +• Competitor information is not always available. +• Competitor and new product information is not + +always accurate. + +• Results may be limited by internal biases. +• Third party analysts may be misled by incomplete + +information. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.8 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +Can be defined as a broad 3-step process: + +1. + +Identify focus of your firm's current strategy and +analysis parameters such as market or products to be +assessed. + +2. Conduct analysis with the following: + +• Market segmentation +• Industry Analysis +• Market Research + +3. Derive insights from the above analysis and formulate + +positioning strategy for your firm. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.9 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 1: Assess current strategy and market, + +product, project, parameters. +– What is the scope of this project? +– What do you plan to do with this information? +– Will research be done in house, or by a third + +party? + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.10 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Product Market Matrix + +Markets + +current + +potential + +Products + +Current + +Potential + +c u -ic -re -a -m -to -e r -nt -Baseline Target Actual Results -2000 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2000 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 95% of Title Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 10% additional 30% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2001 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity -Terrorism and Activities Efficiency -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 65% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 10% additional 20% -Laws, and deployed in field life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2002 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Page 5 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2002 | | | | | Productivity | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Productivity and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2002 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 45% of Title Deploy Deployed -Requirements -Enforce Federal Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 30% additional 40% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -| | | | | | | offices | | systems | systems | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2003 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2003 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -Promote the Title III and Title and digital input by 300% collection input -by 346% -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | | -| ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2003 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -Prevent Crime, User Near end of life 5% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 5% of additional 5% of -deployed in field life -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | Title III systems | Title III systems | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------------- | -| | Represent the | | | | | offices | | | | -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2004 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -input by130% -Promote the Title III and Title and digital collection input -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | by 135% | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2004 | | Technology | | | Data Storage | | | | | -| | Prevent | | | Information and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | Data | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2004 Prevent Crime, Technology Information and Data Storage System Total storage Increase system Increased -Data -Enforce Federal information capacity storage capacity system storage -| | | | | | | storage capacity 4,200GB | | by 9% | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | | capacity by 12% | -| | Represent the | | | | | for collected | | | | -evidence -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2005 -| | Prevent | Customer | | Service | Service | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Results | | Coverage | Efficiency | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 30% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 60% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2006 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2006 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 9% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 8% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -| 2006 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Security and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Privacy | | | | | | -Promote the - -Page 6 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -| | | Results | | Responsiveness | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | response and | to requests for | response to | | -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -2007 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2008 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Response Time | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Customer Timeliness and Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2009 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | Improve speed | | | | - -Page 7 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | of access and | | | | -| | Promote the | | | | | dissemination of | | | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | information | | | | -| | Security | | | | | collected | | | | -through data -and -telecommunicati -ons intercepts -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Nation¿s -Security -2009 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy system and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the system/application -level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and operational systems security -tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational Security Table must be included on -your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or -identifier). -For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, include the -investment in both the "Systems in Planning" table (Table 3) and the "Operational Systems" table (Table 4). Systems which are -already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization activity, should be included in both Table 3 and -Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date - -Page 8 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information -contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the -enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. -All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the "Name of System" -column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled "Name of System" in the security tables -(Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one-to-one ratio between the list of systems and -the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA -may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). -The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the system are -discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text explanation why a working link is -not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, -answer "yes" for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is -not yet required to be published. -Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: -1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified -and integrated into the overall costs of the investment: -a. If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the -budget year: -2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part -of the overall risk management effort for each system -supporting or part of this investment. -3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or Modernization - Security Table(s): -Date of Planned C&A update (for -Name of System -Agency/ or C -S -o -y -n -st -t -e -ra -m -c -? -to r Operated -Planned Operational Date -e -o -x r -i s -P -t -l -i -a -n -n -g -n -m -ed -ix -C e -o -d -m -li -p -fe -le -c t -y -io -c n -le -D -s -a -y t -s -e -t e -( -m -fo -s -r -) -new systems) -DCS-5000 (Next Gen) Government Only -4. Operational Systems - Security Table: -What standards -were used for -Agency/ or NIST FIPS 199 Has C&A been the Security Date -Date the -Name of System -C -O -S -o -p -y -n -e -s -t -t -r -r -e -a -a -m -c -te -t -? -o -d -r R -(H -is -i -k -g h -I -, -m -L -M -o -p -w -o -a -d -c -) -t -e r -le -a -v -te -e -, -l Co -N -m -IS -p -T -l -( -e -Y -8 -t -/ -e -0 -N -d + +*SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility +Exit Barriers + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility + +Options + +Keep or drop? + +Determine +Product +Structure + +Set Pricing + +Options +Determine +Product +Structure + +Choose timing + +Go/No go + +Ch7.11 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis +– Market Segmentation: + +• Identifiable and measurable +• Accessible by communication/distribution + +channels + +• Have unique needs +• Be stable over time + +– Segments may be made up of +individual or industry consumers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.12 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Segmentation + +Individual + +Industry + +Geography + +Demographics + +Psychographics + +Behavior + +Geography + +Client Type + +Client Behavior + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.13 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Industry + +– SWOT Analysis +– Porter’s Five Forces Model +– Other tools + +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Research + +– Preferably conducted by third party. +– Use surveys, telemarketing, face-to-face + +interviews. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.14 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 3: Formulate position strategy + +– Use combination of perceptual maps, strengths and weaknesses of +self and competitors on matrices, and refer back to information +gathered in Steps 1&2. + +Strength/Weakness Evaluation Matrix: Sales Force Quality +SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International + +Much Better + +Somewhat Better + +Same + +Somewhat Worse + +Much Worse + 0 -, -) -- -u -3 -s -7 -i -? -n g Date C -C -o -& -m -A -p leted: -( -C -F +Strength or Weakness + +2 + +4 + +6 + +Relative Importance to success + 8 -o -I -0 -P -n -0 -S -tr -- 5 -o + +10 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.15 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Summary: + +Complete competitive positioning analysis will have: + +– Outline of current and potential products/markets + +• Product/market matrix can be helpful. + +– Identified competitive practices in the industry including +• Costs, revenue and profits, opportunities, weaknesses to + +exploit and strengths to overcome or avoid. + +– Factors contributing to client satisfaction with their + +current suppliers + +• Ability to understand value of purchases, availability & + +convenience of products, quality of service, loyalty, effort +required to change suppliers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.16 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Summary Continued: +• Undertake an overall appraisal of the competitive + +environment to identify any strategies or tactics, which +may improve your firm’s competitive position and identified +a set of strategies to take the firm where it wishes to go in +an industry. + +• Should have comprehensive view of the market. +• Any gaps or unmet needs should be apparent. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.17 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• FAROUT Summary + +1 + 2 -l + 3 -0 -s -, -0 -t -N -/ -e -N -I -s -S -t -I -s -T -S -? -T Se -C -c -o -u -m -T -r -e -i -p -t -s -l -y -e -t i -C -t -n -e -o -g -( -n -d -t -) -r -: -o l -contin -te -g -s -e -t -n -e -c -d -y plan -800-26, Other, -N/A) -DCS-3000 Government Only Yes 6/1/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-5000 Government Only Yes 6/3/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-6000 Government Only Yes 2/2/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of -the systems part of or supporting this investment been -identified by the agency or IG? -a. If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into -the agency's plan of action and milestone process? -6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is -requested to remediate IT security weaknesses? -a. If "yes," specify the amount, provide a general description of the weakness, and explain how the funding request will -remediate the weakness. -7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System -(b -sy -) -s -I -t -s -e m -th -? -is -( -a -Y / -n -N -e -) -w -Assessment (PIA) -(d) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t i -L -o -i -n -n k or Rec -r -o -e -r -q -d -u -s -i -N -re -o -d -t i -f -c -o -e -r -( -t -S -h + +4 + +5 + +F + +A + +R + O -is -R N) (f) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t -L -io -in -n -k or -w -s -h -y -i -s -c -t -h -e -c -m -o -? -v e -(Y -rs -/ N -th -) -i s -system? (Y/N) -DCS-3000 No No No PIA is required by the Yes www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva -E-Government Act at this cyact.html -time for this system -Page 9 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System (b ) I s th is a n e w Assessment (PIA) (d) I n t e r n e t L i n k or Rec o r d s N o t i c e ( S O R N) (f) I n t e r n e t L in k or -sy s t e m ? ( Y / N ) E x p l a n a t i o n r e q u i re d f o r t h is E x p l a n a t io n -| | | | w h i c h c | o v e rs th i s | | | system? (Y/N) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | - -| | | | s y s t e m | ? (Y / N ) | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| DCS-5000 | No | | Yes | | | | Yes | | | -| | | | | | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -cyact.html -| DCS-6000 | No | | No | | | | Yes | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| | | | | No PIA is required by the | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -| | | | | E-Government Act at this | | | | cyact.html | | -time for this system. -Details for Text Options: -Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to (c), provide an explanation -why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. - -Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal register. If no to (e), provide -an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn't a current and up to date SORN. - -Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be considered as a blank field. - -Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be included in the -agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and supporting the FEA. The business -case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and -technology layers of the agency's EA. -| 1. Is this investment included in your agency's target | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enterprise architecture? - a. If "no," please explain why? - -| 2. Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Strategy? - a. If "yes," provide the investment name as identified in Digital Collection Program -the Transition Strategy provided in the agency's most recent -annual EA Assessment. - b. If "no," please explain why? - -| 3. Is this investment identified in a completed (contains a | | | | No | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -target architecture) and approved segment architecture? - a. If "yes," provide the name of the segment architecture as -provided in the agency's most recent annual EA Assessment. - -4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table: -Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, customer relationship management, -etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. -| | | | | | | Service | Service | | | -| ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -| Agency | Agency | FEA SRM | | | | | | Internal or | | -Com p on e nt Co m p o n e n t Se r v ic e FEA SRM FEA SRM Component Component E x t e r n a l BY Funding - Service Type Component (a) Reuse d N ame Reus e d UPI ) Percentage (d) -| Na m e | D e sc ri p t io | n D o m a i n | | | | | | R e u s e ? (c | | -| ------ | ---------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | ( b ) | ( b ) | | | -No Reuse -Legacy Collaborative Back Office Development Legacy -| Integration | Analysis | Services | and Integration | Integration | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| Ad Hoc | Case Analysis | | Reporting | Ad Hoc | | | | No Reuse | | -| | | Business | | | | | | | | -Analytical -Services -Information Interagency Digital Asset Knowledge Information No Reuse -| Sharing | | Services | Management | Sharing | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Information -Sharing -Knowledge Intelligence and Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge No Reuse -| Capture | | Services | Management | Capture | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Evidence -Collection -No Reuse -Knowledge Intra-agency Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge -| Distribution and | Information | Services | Management | Distribution and | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------ | --------- | ----------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Delivery | Sharing | | | Delivery | | | | | | -Query Information Support Services Search Query No Reuse -Analysis - - a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already identified as a service -component in the FEA SRM. - b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather than answer -yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify the other investment using the -Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission. - -Page 10 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service component -provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one agency within a department reusing a service -component provided by another agency in another department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being -reused by multiple organizations across the federal government. -d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed in the table. If -external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another agency to pay for the service. The -percentages in the column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Data Management Database Connectivity Sybase -Delivery -Ad Hoc Component Framework Data Management Reporting and Analysis Word Perfect 6.0 -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Content Rendering Hyper Text Markup Language -Delivery (HTML) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Active Server Pages -Delivery .NetServer Pages .NetMicrosoft -Active Server Pages .Net -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Sun Active Server -Delivery Pages -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Microsoft Server 2003 -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Uniform Resource Locator -(URL) -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Microsoft Internet Explorer6.0 -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Netscape Navigator -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Requirements Legislative / Compliance Section 508 -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Hyper Text Transfer Protocol -Delivery (HTTP) -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Internet Protocol (IP) -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Transport Control Protocol -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Supporting Network Services Simple Network Management -Delivery Protocol (SNMP) -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: ISQL/w -Integration -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: PL/SQL -Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Interface and Integration Middleware Remote Procedure Call (RPC) -Delivery Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Oracle 10i -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Sybase -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Storage HP Series Enterprise Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Application Servers 2600 Dell Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Apache -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Internet Information Server -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Hard Disk -Infrastructure Drives -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Redundant -Infrastructure Array of Independent Disks -(RAID) -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Intel Microprocessors -Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Random Access Memory (RAM) -Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Ethernet -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Virtual LAN (VLAN) -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 2900 Series Switches -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 3700 Series Routers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco Gateway -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ICTG T1 Card -Page 11 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ISDN -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Network Interface Card (NIC) | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Transceivers | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Peripherals | | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hewlett-Packard 4500 Series -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | Printers | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | - - a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter multiple rows for -FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications - b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard or vendor -product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as appropriate. -No -6. Will the application leverage existing components and/or -applications across the Government (i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, -etc)? - a. If "yes," please describe. - -Page 12 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Part II: Planning, Acquisition and Performance Information -Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) -Part II should be completed only for investments identified as "Planning" or "Full Acquisition," or "Mixed Life-Cycle" investments -in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. -In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to the current -baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments to -determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. -1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this project? Yes -a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed? 1/27/2006 -b. If "no," what is the anticipated date this analysis will be -completed? -c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: -2. Alternative Analysis Results: * Costs in millions -Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: -Alternative Analyzed Description of Alternative -Risk Adjus -e -te -st -d -i m -Li -a -fe -te -c ycle Costs Risk Adjuste -e -d -s t -L -im -ife -a -c -t -y -e -c le Benefits -1- Volumetric Collection 245.015 9.443 -3. Which alternative was selected by the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? -Alternative 1 - Volumetric Collection. -4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? -The primary benefits of a regionalized architectural approach for the next generation of DCS-5000 would be to: 1) reduce -overhead costs by utilizing "economies of scale" practices,. -5. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part Yes -or in-whole? -a. If "yes," are the migration costs associated with the This Investment -migration to the selected alternative included in this -investment, the legacy investment, or in a separate migration -investment. -b. If "yes," please provide the following information: -List of Legacy Investment or Systems -Name of the Legacy Investment of Systems UPI if available Date of the System Retirement -DCS-5000 -Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) -You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this investment's life-cycle, -developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing -risk throughout the investment's life-cycle. -1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes -a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan? 4/16/2007 -b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly Yes -changed since last year's submission to OMB? -c. If "yes," describe any significant changes: -A preliminary internal project rating and risk assessment of the DCS-5000 NG acquisition effort was conducted and a DCS-5000 -NG Project baseline for risk was established. The Risk Management Plan (RMP) defined basic organizational, technical, and policy -guidelines for the implementation of risk management within the DCS-5000 Next Generation Project. It established the -techniques and procedures that will be utilized throughout the evolutionary life of the various DCS-5000 Next Generation Project -systems. The procedures described will help ensure the positive identification and management of risk areas associated with -acquisition, development, deployment, and support of the systems. The risk management policies and procedures set forth in -this RMP apply to all DCS-5000 Next Generation Project systems. The policies and procedures of this RMP are tailored for -Page 13 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -specific subsystems and contracts. The DCS-5000 Next Generation Project risk management system used by the DCS-5000 Next -Generation Risk Management Board follows the recommended policies and procedures and use the Glossary of terms set forth -by the Project Management Institute (PMI). These policies and procedures include: Risk management Planning, Risk -Identification, Qualitative Risk Analysis, Quantitative Risk Analysis, Risk Response Planning, and Risk Monitoring and Control. -2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? -a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date? -b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks? -3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle cost estimate and investment schedule: -Risks for the investment are identified within 3 categories: technical, acquisition, and financial. Each risk is evaluated as to its -probability of occurrence and level of impact on schedule, cost, and technical performance to determine the overall risk rating. -Given that, with very limited deviation, effort performed for digital collection implementation is completed by contracted support -through firm fixed price contracts, there is limited risk associated with technical, cost and schedule performance. Baselines -established are provided to contract vendors as contract requirements/deliverables; however, in order to mitigate the risk of -unforeseen requirements and increased scope, a management reserve of 10% is maintained. Cost performance risk is mitigated -through maximum usage of firm fixed price contracts and task orders. Budget projections are reviewed at least quarterly. -Independent government cost estimates are developed, analyzed, and compared to contractor proposals for each major -acquisition. Out-of-tolerance variances are brought to the contractors? attention and cost/price is negotiated. -Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) -EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should still be included -in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should accurately reflect the milestones -in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. -1. Does the earned value management system meet the No -criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard-748? -2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than +/- 10%? (CV%= CV/EV x No -100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) -a. If "yes," was it the CV or SV or both? -b. If "yes," explain the causes of the variance: -c. If "yes," describe the corrective actions: -3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? No -a. If "yes," when was it approved by the agency head? -Page 14 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | - 1 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $8.85 9/30/2004 $8.85 $8.85 $0 100% -(Planning) Prior -to FY05 - 2 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $128.14 9/30/2004 $128.14 $126.53 $1.61 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(Acquisition) -Prior to FY05 - 3 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $31.75 9/30/2004 $31.75 $31.75 $0 100% -(O&M) Prior to -FY05 - 4 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2005 $3.27 9/30/2005 $3.27 $3.12 $0.15 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - 5 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2005 $16.65 9/30/2005 $16.65 $17.33 $-0.68 100% - 6 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2005 $10.32 9/30/2005 $10.32 $11.31 $-0.99 100% - 7 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2006 $3.27 9/30/2006 $3.27 $3.13 $0.14 100% - 8 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2006 $15.7 9/30/2006 $15.7 $15.68 $0.02 100% - 9 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2006 $9.2 9/30/2006 $9.2 $9.2 $0 100% - 10 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2007 $3.31 9/30/2007 $3.31 $4.42 $-1.11 100% - 11 DCS-5000 9/30/2007 $2 9/30/2007 $2 $2 $0 100% -Planning - 12 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2007 $7.64 9/30/2007 $7.64 $7.97 $-0.33 100% - 13 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2007 $9.97 9/30/2007 $9.97 $8.12 $1.85 100% -| 14 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $2.96 | | | $2.96 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 15 | DCS-5000 | 9/30/2008 | $2.55 | | | $2.55 | | | | 0% | -Planning -| 16 | | 9/30/2008 | $20.18 | | | $21.18 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition -| 17 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $8.02 | | | $8.02 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 18 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $9.79 | | | $9.79 | | | | 0% | -| 19 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $2.11 | | | $2.11 | | | | 0% | -| 20 | | 9/30/2009 | $21.26 | | | $21.26 | | | | 0% | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition - -Page 15 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 21 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $9.7 | | | $9.7 | | | | 0% | -| 22 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $14.48 | | | $14.48 | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| Project Totals | | | | | | | | | | | - -Page 16 of 16 \ No newline at end of file + +U + +T + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.18 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques +• Industry Analysis +• SWOT Analysis +• Value Chain Analysis +• Competitor Analysis +• Financial Ratio and Statement Analysis +• Customer Segmentation Analysis +• BCG Growth/Share Portfolio Matrix +• GE Business Screen + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.19 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques Cont’d +• Supply Chain Analysis +• Product Line Analysis +• Benchmarking + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.20 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +For More About Competitive +Positioning and 23 Other Useful +Analysis Methods, see: + +Fleisher, Craig S. and Babette E. +Bensoussan + +Business and Competitive +Analysis: Effective Application of +New and Classic Methods + +Upper Saddle River, NJ +2007 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.21 + diff --git a/q231/random_k2/random_2.md b/q231/random_k2/random_2.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..82ecb3b9af6c3286b3846d69480033be2a625972 100644 --- a/q231/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q231/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,493 +1,1408 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. - -3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - -7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - -9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - -1 -0 - +Double-Contrast Upper +Gastrointestinal Radiography: A +Pattern Approach for Diseases of the +Stomach1 +StephenE.Rubesin,MD +Thedouble-contrastuppergastrointestinalseriesisavalu- +MarcS.Levine,MD +ablediagnostictestforevaluatingstructuralandfunctional +IgorLaufer,MD +abnormalities of the stomach. This article will review the +normalradiographicanatomyofthestomach.Theprinci- +plesofanalyzingdouble-contrastimageswillbediscussed. +Apatternapproachforthediagnosisofgastricabnormali- +tieswillalsobepresented,focusingonabnormalmucosal +patterns,depressedlesions,protrudedlesions,thickened +folds,andgastricnarrowing. +!RSNA,2008 +1FromtheDepartmentofRadiology,HospitaloftheUni- +versityofPennsylvania,3400SpruceSt,Philadelphia,PA +19104.ReceivedJuly18,2006;revisionrequestedSep- +tember20;revisionreceivedOctober5;acceptedNovem- +ber2;finalversionacceptedJanuary2,2007;finalre- +viewbyM.S.L.June19.S.E.R.andM.S.L.arepaid +consultantsforE-Z-Em,Westbury,NY.Addresscorre- +spondencetoM.S.L.(e-mail:marc.levine@uphs.upenn +.edu). +"RSNA,2008 +REVIEWSANDCOMMENTARY +# +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS +Note: This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for +distribution to your colleagues or clients, use the Radiology Reprints form at the end of this article. +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 33 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +T +his article presents a pattern ap- ples of double-contrast image interpre- more undulating on the greater curva- +proach for the diagnosis of dis- tation, we will consider abnormal sur- ture. The thickness of the rugal folds +eases of the stomach at double- facepatternsofthemucosa,depressed varieswiththedegreeofgastricdisten- +contrast upper gastrointestinal radi- lesions(erosionsandulcers),protruded tion(5). +ography. After describing the normal lesions (polyps, submucosal masses, +appearance of the stomach on double- andothertumors),thickenedfolds,and AreaeGastricae +contrast barium studies and the princi- gastricnarrowing. The mucosal surface of the stomach +consistsofflatpolygonal-shapedtuftsof +mucosa,knownasareaegastricae,sep- +Essentials NormalStomach +arated by narrow grooves (6,7). The +# Protrudedlesions(eg,polypsand areae gastricae are recognized on dou- +cancers)onthedependentwallof GastricConfigurationandRugalFolds ble-contrast studies as a reticular net- +thestomachmayappearasradi- The normal stomach is a J-shaped workofbarium-coatedwhitelineswhen +olucentfillingdefectsinthebar- pouch that lies in the left upper quad- barium fills the grooves between these +iumpool,whereasprotrudedle- rant (Fig 1). The stomach has a fixed mucosal tufts (Fig 3). Individual muco- +sionsonthenondependentwall configuration created by the greater sal tufts of areae gastricae normally +mayappearasbarium-coated length of the longitudinal muscle layer have a diameter of 2–3 mm in the gas- +“ringshadows”duetobarium onitsgreatercurvature.Thelessercur- tricantrumandof3–5mminthegastric +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions. vature of the stomach is suspended body and fundus (Fig 3) (6,8). Areae +# Multiplesmall,round,uniformnod- from the retroperitoneum by the hepa- gastricae are detected on double-con- +ulesinthestomachareusually togastric ligament, a portion of the trast studies in nearly 70% of patients +causedbylymphoidhyperplasia lesseromentum.Thegastrosplenicliga- and are observed with greater fre- +associatedwithHelicobacterpylori ment and gastrocolic ligament (ie, the quencyintheelderly(8,9). +gastritis,whereasirregularnonuni- proximal portion of the greater omen- +formnodulesmaybecausedby tum)areattachedtothegreatercurva- ComparisonofHistologicAnatomywith +low-gradeB-cellmucosa-associated ture of the stomach. The gastric cardia MacroscopicAnatomy +lymphoidtissuelymphoma. isattachedtothediaphragmbythesur- Abasicunderstandingofthehistologic +# Aspirinandothernonsteroidal roundingphrenoesophagealmembrane. anatomy of the stomach is helpful for +antiinflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs) The stomach is arbitrarily divided understandingpepticulcerdisease,as +arebyfarthemostcommon into five segments: the cardia, fundus, well as other gastric abnormalities +causeoferosivegastritis,acondi- body,antrum,andpylorus.Thegastric (5,10). The stomach contains several +tionmanifestedondouble-con- cardiaischaracterizedonbariumstud- typesofmucosa:cardiac-typemucosa, +traststudiesaspunctateorslitlike ies by three or four stellate folds that body/fundic-type mucosa, and antral/ +erosionssurroundedbyradiolu- radiatetoacentralpointatthegastro- pyloric-type mucosa. Gastric foveolae +centmoundsofedemaor,in esophageal junction, also known as the (orpits)areconicaldepressionsinthe +somepatientstakingNSAIDs,by cardiac“rosette”(Fig2)(1,2).Thegas- mucosal surface that communicate +linearorserpiginouserosionson tric fundus is defined as the portion of with gastric glands (4,10). The glands +ornearthegreatercurvatureof the stomach craniad to the gastric car- are long, straight, and tightly packed +thegastricantrumorbody. dia. The gastric body is defined as the structures.Thefoveolaeinallpartsof +# Hpylorigastritisisbyfarthe portion of the stomach extending from thestomacharelinedbysurfacefove- +mostcommoncauseoffocallyor thegastriccardiatothesmoothbendin olar mucous cells. The cardiac-type +diffuselythickenedgastricfolds, the mid lesser curvature known as the mucosa comprises a short (1 cm in +whichcanbesolargeandlobu- incisuraangularis.Thegastricantrumis length) segment of the gastric mucosa +lated(eg,polypoidgastritis)that defined as the portion of the stomach adjacenttothegastroesophagealjunc- +theradiographicfindingsresem- extendingfromtheincisuraangularisto tion (4). The distinguishing feature of +blethoseofMenetrierdiseaseor the pylorus (a structure created by a the body-type mucosa is the presence +lymphoma. muscle sphincter shaped like a figure +# Onbariumstudies,scirrhouscarci- eight). +nomasofthestomachmayproduce Rugal folds are most prominent in Publishedonline +alinitisplasticaappearancewith the gastric fundus and body, whereas 10.1148/radiol.2461061245 +diffusenarrowingorlong-orshort- the gastric antrum is often devoid of +Radiology2008;246:33–48 +segmentnarrowingofanyportion folds(Fig1).Gastricrugaearechange- +ofthestomach;metastaticbreast able structures composed of mucosa Abbreviations: +cancerandlymphomaoccasionally and submucosa (3,4). The rugal folds MALT!mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissue +NSAID!nonsteroidalantiinflammatorydrug +mayproduceasimilarradiographic arerelativelystraightonthelessercur- +appearance. vature of the stomach but larger and Authorsstatednofinancialrelationshiptodisclose. +34 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +ofparietalandchiefcellsintheglands. extending progressively higher on the (Fig 1). With air contrast, the luminal +The parietal cells produce hydrochlo- lesser curvature. Peptic ulcers fre- contourappearsasasmooth,continuous +ric acid and intrinsic factor, and the quently develop on the lesser curva- barium-coatedwhiteline(Fig1)(11). +| chief cells | produce | proteolytic | en- tureatthetransitionzone(Fig4). | | +| ----------- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | +| zymes. | No parietal | or chief cells | are | BariumPool | +found in antral-type mucosa. The sur- The pool of high-density barium is the +PrinciplesofImageAnalysis +facefoveolarmucouscellslinebothan- tool the radiologist uses to scrub and +tralpitsandglands. +| Body-type | mucosa | lines the | ana- AppearanceoftheStomach | | +| --------- | ------ | --------- | --------------------------- | --- | +tomic gastric fundus and the gastric Theradiologistfirstexaminestheover- +Figure3 +body and extends into the gastric an- allposition,shape,andsizeofthestom- +trum along the greater curvature (4). ach. The gastric fundus abuts the left +Antral-type mucosa lines the antrum hemidiaphragm. The cardia has a mid- +along the lesser curvature from the py- linelocation,abuttingthecrusoftheleft +lorustotheincisuraangularis,butonly hemidiaphragm.Thestomachcurvesto +linesasmallamountofantrumalongthe the right across the midline, with the +greater curvature. Thus, the histologic distalgastricantrumandduodenumex- +division of the stomach into body- and tendingtotherightofthespine.There +antral-type mucosa does not correlate is considerable variation in the size of +with the anatomic and radiologic divi- thestomach,dependingontheamount +sion of the stomach into fundus, body, of barium and effervescent agent ad- +| andantrum(5). | | | ministered. | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +The transition zone between body- Figure3: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +and antral-type mucosa is a line that LuminalContour achwithpatientinleftposteriorobliqueposition +extends from the incisura angularis to In the barium pool, the contour is de- showsnormalareaegastricaepatterninantrumas +thedistalgreatercurvature.Thetransi- marcated by a smooth edge of barium 2–3-mmpolygonallyshapedradiolucenttuftsof +tionzonemigratesproximallywithage, mucosaoutlinedbybariumingrooves.Areae +| | | | Figure2 | gastricaeareslightlylargerindistalgastricbody | +| --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | +thaninantrum. +Figure1 +Figure4 +| Figure1: | Normalstomach.Double-contrast | | | | +| -------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +spotimageofstomachwithpatientsupineshows +distalgastricbody(B)andantrum(A).Greater +| curvature(whitearrows)andlessercurvature | | | Figure2: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | +| (blackarrows)arecoatedbybarium.Rugalfoldon | | | tricfunduswithpatientinright-side-downposi- | | +| posteriorwallofgastricbodyisdepictedastubu- | | | tionshowsnormalgastriccardiawithsmooth | | +lar,slightlyundulating,radiolucentfillingdefect foldsradiatingtocentralpoint(whitearrow)at Figure4: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +(blackarrowheads)inshallowbariumpool.Dense closedgastroesophagealjunction,alsoknownas achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsbenign +bariumpooloutlinescontour(whitearrowheads) cardiacrosette.Long,straightfold(arrowheads) lessercurvaturegastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid +ofgastricfundus(F).Mucosalsurfaceandfoldsin extendsinferiorlyfromcardiaalonglessercurva- collectionofbariumextendingoutsideexpected +fundusareobscuredbybariumpool,andantrum ture.Blackarrowsdenotenormalextrinsicimpres- luminalcontourofgastricbody.Smoothfoldsare +sionbyadjacentspleen. +| isdevoidofrugalfolds. | | | | seenradiatingtoedgeofulcercrater. | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 35 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +coatthemucosalsurface(12–15).Some dent wall usually appear as radiolucent thickness of barium in the grooves +lesions are best shown in the barium fillingdefectsinthebariumpool(Fig5) between the mucosal tufts in relation +pool, whereas others are obscured by (16),whereasprotrudedlesionsonthe to the thickness of barium overlying +even a small pool of high-density bar- nondependent wall appear as barium- the tufts (8,9). Thus, an increase in +ium. Protruded lesions on the depen- coated “ring shadows” due to barium theheightofthemucosaltuftsorthin- +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions(Fig5). ning of the mucous gel layer in the +Figure5 When filled with barium, depressed le- stomach may cause the areae gastri- +sions appear as barium collections on caetobecomemorevisibleorconspic- +the dependent wall (Fig 4). When bar- uous. When viewed in profile, barium +ium spills out of depressed lesions on in the grooves between areae gastri- +thedependentwall,theymayappearas cae may be manifested as tiny spike- +| ringshadows. | like outpouchings, | | producing | | subtle | +| ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +spiculationoftheluminalcontourthat +| EnFaceMucosalDetail | should | not be mistaken | | for erosions. | | +| ------------------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Whenviewedenface,themucosalsur- In addition, the areae gastricae may +face either has a smooth appearance be enlarged by conditions that in- +(Fig 1) or is manifested as a reticular crease the size of the mucosal tufts +network of barium-filled grooves be- beyond their normal diameter of 2–3 +tween the areae gastricae (Fig 3). Dis- mm in the antrum and of 3–5 mm in +ruption of the normal areae gastricae the body and fundus. Enlarged areae +Figure5: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- pattern or the smooth mucosal surface gastricaehavebeenreportedinabout +tricbodywithpatientinsupinerightposterior ofthestomachbybarium-coatedlinesis 50% of patients with Helicobacter py- +obliquepositionshowsmultiplehyperplastic abnormal(Fig5). lori gastritis (Fig 7) (18). In contrast, +polypsondependent,orposterior,wallassmall small or even absent areae gastricae +("1cminsize),roundorovoid,finelylobulated have been reported in patients with +PatternApproachforDouble-Contrast +radiolucentfillingdefectsinbariumpool(arrows). severe atrophic gastritis and perni- +Diagnosis +Incontrast,polypsonnondependent,oranterior, ciousanemia(19). +wallarecoatedbybariumandappearaswhite H pylori is a curved or spiral-shaped, +lines(arrowheads).Bariumisseentofillinter- AbnormalMucosalPatterns gram-negative bacillus (20–22) that in- +sticesbetweenlobulesofsomepolyps. Striations.—Thin, barium-coated stria- fects the stomach in more than 50% of +tions perpendicular to the longitudinal Americans over 50 years of age and in +axis of the gastric antrum, also known nearly100%ofJapaneseadults(23,24). +as gastric “striae,” are sometimes seen H pylori most frequently involves the +Figure6 as a transient finding when the antrum gastric antrum (25). H pylori gastritis +is slightly collapsed (Fig 6) (17). These can be documented in almost all pa- +striaeareasignofchronicantralgastri- tientswithduodenalulcersandinabout +| tis(16). | 80%ofpatientswithgastriculcers(26). | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| Conspicuousorenlargedareaegas- | The mechanism | | by which | H | pylori | +tricae.—Visualizationoftheareaegas- causes ulceration is not fully under- +tricae in the stomach depends on the stood. H pylori gastritis is also a major +| | causative | factor | in the development | | of | +| ------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| Figure7 | bothgastriccarcinoma(27,28)andgas- | | | | | +triclymphoma(29,30). +Uniformnodules.—Innumerablesmall +| | (1–2 mm | in size), | round, | uniform | nod- | +| --- | --------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | +| | ules disrupting | | the normal | polygonal | | +| | areae gastricae | | pattern | are | usually | +| | caused | by lymphoid | hyperplasia | | of the | +stomachresultingfromchronicHpylori +| | gastritis | (Fig 8) | (31–33). | At birth, | no | +| --- | --------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +Figure6: Double-contrastspotimageofan- +| | lymphoid | tissue | is present | in the | stom- | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ----- | +trumwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsgastric Figure7: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +ach.WhenHpyloriinfectsthestomach, +striaeastransientfindingduetobariumfilling achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsenlarged +| | the organism | colonizes | | the | mucous | +| --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | +delicatetransversegroovesbetweenthinradiolu- areaegastricaeinpatientwithHpylorigastritis. +layerandattachestothemembranesof +centfoldstraversingcircumferenceofslightly Areaegastricaeinantrum(whitearrow)arelarger +| | the surface | epithelial | cells, | resulting | in | +| --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --------- | --- | +collapsedgastricantrum. thanthoseindistalgastricbody(blackarrow). +| | the development | | of chronic | | gastritis | +| --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | +36 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure8 Figure9 +| (22). Repeated | infections | may | eventu- | | | | +| -------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ally lead | to lymphocytic | infiltration | | of | | | +thestomach,followedbytheformation +| of lymphoid | aggregates | and | even true | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoidfollicles(34).Thus,whenlym- +| phoid hyperplasia | | is detected | on dou- | | | | +| ----------------- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ble-contrast | barium | studies, | these pa- | | | | +| tients are | almost | always found | to have | | | | +chronicHpylorigastritis(33). +| Nonuniform | nodules.—Irregular | | nod- | | | | +| ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +ulesdisruptingthesmoothmucosalsur- +| face or | the polygonal | areae | gastricae | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| pattern | of the stomach | may | be caused | | | | +byinflammation,metaplasia(alteration +Figure9: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- +| of one form | of epithelium | | to another), | Figure8: | Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | +tricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +| or malignant | tumor. | The | nodules are | tricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +positionshowsnonuniformnodulesdisrupting +| nonuniform | in size | and shape | and have | positionshowslymphoidhyperplasiawithinnu- | | | +| ---------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +normalsurfacepattern.Nodules(arrows)appear +| a patchy | or diffuse | distribution, | involv- | merableround,uniform,1–2-mmnodulescarpet- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +asroundorlobulated,confluentprotrusionsvary- +| ing a focal | or large | surface | area of the | ingmucosaandreplacingnormalpolygonalareae | | | +| ----------- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +ingfrom3–6-mminsize.Endoscopicbiopsy +| stomach | on barium | studies. | Nonuni- | gastricaepattern.ThispatienthadchronicHpylori | | | +| ------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +specimensrevealedlow-grade,B-cell,gastric +gastritis. +formmucosalnodularityisaworrisome MALTlymphomainpatientwithchronicHpylori +radiographicfindingforgastricmucosa- gastritis. +| associated | lymphoid | tissue | (MALT) | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoma(Fig9)or,rarely,superficial IIa (elevated), IIb (flat), or IIc (de- +spreadingcarcinoma(Fig10)(35). pressed)lesions(Fig10);andulcerated +| Gastric | lymphomas | usually | arise | EGCsthataremorethan5mmindepth | | | +| ------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +Figure10 +| from preexisting | MALT | in | the stomach | aretypeIIIlesions(42). | | | +| ---------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +associatedwithchronicHpylorigastri- +| tis. A lymphoid | response | to | chronic in- | DepressedLesions | | | +| --------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +fectionbyHpylorihasbeenpostulated Erosions.—Anerosionisafocalareaof +astheprecursormilieuforthedevelop- mucosalnecrosisconfinedtotheepithe- +ment of low-grade B-cell gastric MALT lium or lamina propria without extend- +lymphomas (36). These tumors are ing through the muscularis mucosae +sometimes recognized on double-con- into the submucosa (5). In contrast, +trast studies by the presence of innu- a true ulcer niche or crater extends +merable poorly defined, confluent mu- through the muscularis mucosae into +cosal nodules of varying size (Fig 9) the deeper layers of the gastric wall +(35). In such cases, endoscopic biopsy (4). The actual histologic depth of an +specimensarerequiredtoruleoutgas- ulcercannotbedeterminedonbarium +tricMALTlymphoma. studies.Instead,theradiographicsize Figure10: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricfunduswithpatientinsemiuprightposition +| Because | of mass | screening | of the | and depth | are used | to distinguish an | +| ------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -------- | ----------------- | +showssuperficialgastriccarcinomaasfocalarea +adult population in Japan, early gastric erosion from an ulcer. When viewed +ofslightlyelevated,irregularradiolucentnodules +cancers (EGCs) constitute as many as in profile, a depressed lesion greater +(arrows)inshallowbariumpool.Clubbed,irregu- +25%–46% of all gastric cancers de- than several millimeters in depth is +tected in that country (37,38). In con- arbitrarilycalledanulcer. larfolds(arrowheads)areseenradiatingtoward +centralareaofmucosalnodularity. +trast, EGCs constitute a much smaller Erosions are manifested on double- +percentage of gastric cancers detected contrast studies as tiny, 1–2 mm in +in the West, because endoscopy and depth collections of barium, usually in +bariumstudiesareperformedpredomi- the gastric antrum. Erosions may be turned from side to side, so a shallow +nantly in symptomatic patients who al- punctate, round, linear, or stellate in poolofbariumflowsoverthedependent +readyhaveadvancedlesions(39–41).In configurationandareoftensurrounded surface of the stomach (45). Erosions +the Japanese classification system for by radiolucent halos of edematous mu- aredefinedascompleteorvarioliformif +EGC, polypoid EGCs that protrude cosa (Fig 11) (43). Erosions are fre- surrounded by a radiolucent halo of +morethan5mmintothelumenaretype quently seen to reside on the crests of edema and as incomplete if there is no +I lesions; flat EGCs that appear as enlarged scalloped antral folds (44), surroundingedematousmound.Incom- +plaques,nodules,ortinyulcersaretype particularly when the patient is slowly plete erosions are much less common, +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 37 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +appearing as punctate or linear collec- the most common cause of gastric ero- eas of epithelial necrosis with hemor- +tions of barium that may be difficult to sions (46). NSAID exposure causes rhage,edema,andvasculardilatationin +differentiate from barium trapped be- breakdown of the mucosal barrier and the lamina propria (47). Because often +tweenareaegastricaeoralongsiderugal mucosal hypoxia, resulting in focal ar- thereisrelativelylittleinflammatoryre- +| folds. | | sponse, | the term | NSAID | gastropathy | | +| ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | +Aspirinandothernonsteroidalanti- rather than NSAID gastritis is favored +Figure13 +inflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs)arebyfar by some authors (10,48). NSAID-in- +ducederosivegastritisistypicallymani- +| Figure11 | | fested as | multiple | varioliform | | erosions | +| -------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +intheantrumorantrumandbodyofthe +stomach(18).Lessfrequently,thesepa- +| | | tients may | have | incomplete | | erosions | +| --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +thatappearaslinearorserpiginousbar- +iumcollections(Fig12),manyofwhich +| | | are located | on | or near | the greater | cur- | +| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | +vatureofthegastricbodysecondaryto +theeffectofgravity(49). +| | | Other | causes | of gastric | erosions | in- | +| --- | --- | --------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------ | -------- | +| | | clude alcohol, | | viral | infections, | Crohn | +| | | disease, | hemorrhagic | | gastropathy, | and | +| | | iatrogenic | trauma | (4,50–55). | | Surpris- | +| | | ingly, erosions | | are infrequently | | seen in | +patientswithHpylorigastritis(18). +| | Figure13: Double-contrastspotimageof | Ulcers.—An | | ulcer | is a | focal area | +| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinleftposterioroblique | of mucosal | disruption | | that | penetrates | +| Figure11: Double-contrastspotimageof | positionshowsgastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid | | | | | | +| | | through | the muscularis | | mucosae | into | +collectionofbariumonposteriorwall.Smooth, +distalgastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterior the deeper layers of the gastric wall. +straightfoldsradiatedirectlytoedgeofulcercra- +obliquepositionshowsNSAID-inducederosive Whenviewedenface,mostbenigngas- +ter.Thesearetypicalfindingsofabenigngastric +antralgastritis.Multiplevarioliformerosionsare tric ulcers on the dependent wall are +ulcer. +seenaspunctate(smallwhitearrow)andlinear manifested on double-contrast studies +(largewhitearrow)collectionsofbariumsur- +asasmoothroundorovoidcollectionof +roundedbyradiolucentmoundsofedema(black +| | | barium | filling the | ulcer | crater | (Fig 13). | +| --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | +arrows).Thispatientwastakingaspirin. +| | | Some shallow | | ulcers | on the | dependent | +| --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --------- | +| | Figure14 | wall and | ulcers | on the | nondependent | | +wallmaybemanifestedasacircularor +hemisphericringduetobariumcoating +| Figure12 | | the rim | of the | unfilled | ulcer | crater | +| -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------ | +(Fig14)(56).Mostulcersareroundor +ovoid,butsomemayhavealinear,ser- +| | | pentine, | rectangular, | | flame-shaped, | or | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | +rod-shapedconfiguration(56–58). +Whenviewedinprofile,benigngas- +triculcersmayberecognizedbyafocal +bariumcollectionorbarium-coatedline +| | | extending | outside | the | expected | luminal | +| --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | +contour(Fig4)(11,59–61).Someulcers +| | Figure14: Double-contrastspotimageof | have a smooth | | radiolucent | rim | of vari- | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | able thickness | | directly | adjacent | to the | +| | incompletelyfilledulcerondependent,orposte- | ulcer crater, | | representing | | a collar of | +| | rior,wallashemisphericringshadowwithtwo | edema and | inflammation, | | whereas | oth- | +| Figure12: Double-contrastspotimageof | crescent-shapedbarium-coatedlines(arrows) | | | | | | +| | | ers have | a thin | radiolucent | | line (also | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | coatingvariousportionsofinferiorrimofulcer. | | | | | | +| | | known | as a Hampton | | line) | traversing | +| positionshowsNSAID-inducedlinearandserpig- | Smooth,straightfoldsradiatealmosttoedgeof | | | | | | +thebaseofthecraterduetoundermin- +| inouserosions(arrows).Thispatientwastaking | ulcercrater.Thefindingsarecharacteristicofa | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --------- | +| | | ing of the | submucosa | | (59). | The pres- | +| aspirin.Surgicalclipsinrightupperquadrantare | benigngastriculcerwithretractionofadjacent | | | | | | +enceofaHamptonlineisdiagnosticofa +frompriorcholecystectomy. +gastricwall. +benigngastriculcer.Chronicinflamma- +| 38 | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure15 Figure16 +| tion and | scarring may | cause | retraction | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +oftheadjacentgastricwallwiththede- +velopmentofsmooth,straightfoldsthat +radiatedirectlytotheedgeoftheulcer +crater(Figs13,14). +| Although | giant gastric | ulcers | are | at | | | +| ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| greater | risk for bleeding | and | perfora- | | | | +| tion (62), | the size of | the ulcer | crater | is | | | +notausefulcriterionfordifferentiating +| benign | and malignant | gastric | ulcers. | | | | +| ----------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Most benign | gastric | ulcers are | located | | | | +onthelessercurvatureorposteriorwall +ofthestomachatornearthetransition +zonebetweenbody-andantral-typemu- +| cosa(Fig4).Somebenignulcersmaybe | | | | Figure15: | Double-contrastspotimageof | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------------------- | --- | +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +| located | on the greater | curvature | (al- | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +malignantgastriculcerduetolymphoma.Large +| most all | of these greater | curvature | ul- | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lobulesoftumor(arrows)surroundirregularcen- +cersarecausedbytheuseofaspirinor +tralulcer(U)filledwithbarium,althoughbarium +other NSAIDs) (14,63) or within hiatal Figure16: Listofradiographicfeaturesdistin- +poolistoodensetoclearlydelineatemarginsof +hernias, where the stomach traverses guishingbenignandmalignantgastriculcers. +ulcer. +| the diaphragm | (64). | Thus, | ulcer loca- | | | | +| ------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| tion also | is not a useful | criterion | for | | | | +differentiating benign and malignant nign radiographic appearance; virtually +gastric ulcers. Radiologists therefore all of these unequivocally benign ulcers +should ignore the size and location of are ultimately proved to be benign +Figure17 +| ulcerswhenassessingtheriskofmalig- | | | | (56,65). | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +nancy;instead,theyshouldfocusonthe Incontrast,ifanulcerisassociated +morphologicfeaturesoftheselesions. withnodularityoftheadjacentmucosa, +| In general, | malignant | gastric | ulcers | mass effect, | or radiating | folds that are | +| ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | -------------- | +produceradiographicfindingsdiametri- coarse,lobulated,orirregular(Figs10, +callyopposedtothoseofbenignulcers. 15), it fulfills the radiographic criteria +With malignant ulcers, the ulcer crater foramalignantgastriculcer,andendos- +represents a focal area of necrosis and copy should be performed for a defini- +excavation within a malignant tumor, tive diagnosis. Less than 5% of ulcers +usuallygastriccarcinomaorlymphoma. have an unequivocally malignant radio- +Thesurfaceoftheulcerandofthesur- graphicappearance;almostallofthese +roundingmucosaisthereforecomposed malignant-appearing ulcers are ulti- +| of nodules, | irregular | elevations, | or | matelyprovedtobemalignant. | | | +| ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | +irregular depressions of varying size Finally, one-fourth to one-third of +within the tumor (Fig 15) (42). The gastric ulcers have an equivocal or in- +folds adjoining a malignant ulcer may determinateappearancethatdoesnot +have a coarse, lobulated, clubbed, or allow the radiologist to establish a +penciledshapeduetoinfiltrationofthe confident diagnosis of benignancy or Figure17: Double-contrastspotimageof +foldsbythetumor(Fig10)(42). malignancy. An ulcer is classified as gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +Radiologists can often differentiate equivocalorindeterminateifthereare positionshowsulcer(U)onposteriorwallfilling +benign and malignant gastric ulcers on coarse areae gastricae or moderate withbarium.Smallradiolucentnodules(arrow- +the basis of the radiographic findings nodularity of the mucosa abutting the heads)areseenlateraltoulcerandlargernodules +(Fig 16). If an ulcer has a smooth sur- ulcer (Fig 17), a nodular ulcer collar, (arrows)areseenjustsuperiortoulcer.Thisnodu- +face with smooth, straight folds radiat- or mildly irregular folds radiating to laritycouldbesecondarytoedema,inflammation, +ing to the ulcer margin and no sur- theulcer’sedge.Insuchcases,endos- metaplasia,dysplasia,ortumor;findingsinthis +casedonotmeetradiographiccriteriaforabenign +rounding mass effect or mucosal nodu- copyandbiopsyareneededtoruleout +gastriculcer,andlesionshouldbeclassifiedas +larity (Figs 4, 13, 14), it fulfills the malignant tumor. Nevertheless, the +equivocal.Nevertheless,benigngastriculcerwas +radiographic criteria for a benign gas- majorityofequivocalorindeterminate +confirmedatendoscopyandfollow-up.Gastric +triculcer.Abouttwo-thirdsofallgastric ulcers are ultimately proved to be be- +metaplasiawasfoundattheedgeoftheulceron +| ulcers diagnosed | on double-contrast | | bar- | nign. | | | +| ---------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +endoscopicbiopsyspecimens. +ium studies have an unequivocally be- Some benign NSAID-induced greater +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 39 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +curvature ulcers may have an indeter- theadjacentgreatercurvature(66).De- Thesetinysacsarethoughttorepresent +minate appearance due to extensive spite a history of NSAID use, these thesequelaofhealedpepticulcers.Par- +surrounding mass effect and an appar- greater curvature ulcers therefore may tial antral diverticula are differentiated +ent intraluminal location because of requireendoscopytoruleoutanulcer- from true ulcers by their variable size +spasm and inflammatory retraction of ated gastric carcinoma. Eventually, and shape at fluoroscopy and the ab- +| | largeNSAID-inducedgreatercurvature | | | senceofassociatedinflammatorychanges. | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | ulcers may penetrate | inferiorly | via the | | | | | | +ProtrudedLesions +| Figure18 | gastrocolic ligament | into | the superior | | | | | | +| -------- | -------------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +borderofthetransversecolon,produc- Polyps.—A polyp is a small protrusion +ingagastrocolicfistula(67). fromthemucosalsurface,eithersessile +| | Diverticula.—Diverticula | | are un- | or pedunculated. | | The | term | polyp does | +| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +commonly found in the stomach. The notimplyanadenomatoushistology.In +majorityarisefromtheposteriorwallof fact,awidevarietyofbenignandmalig- +thegastricfundus(68),presumablybe- nant polypoid lesions may occur in the +causeofagapinthemuscularlayersof stomach. If polyps arise from the mu- +the gastric wall in this location. Fundal cosa,theymayhaveasmooth,nodular, +diverticula are smoothly contoured, orlobulatedsurfaceondouble-contrast +broad-mouthed outpouchings, ranging studies, and when viewed in profile, +from 1 to 10 cm in size (Fig 18). Rugal formacuteangleswiththeadjacentgas- +foldsarenotseenwithinthediverticula. tricwall(Fig5)(70).Incontrast,lesions +These diverticula can be distinguished arising from the submucosa or muscu- +from ulcers by their smooth contour, larispropriausuallyhaveaverysmooth +Figure18: Double-contrastspotimagewith +broad or shallow necks, and lack of surface and, when viewed in profile, +patientinrightdecubituspositionshowsgastric +foldsradiatingtotheirmargins. form right angles or slightly obtuse +diverticulumassmoothbarium-coatedoutpouch- +| | A variant | of a gastric | diverticulum | angles with | the | adjacent | gastric | wall | +| --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | +ing(arrow)extendingfromposteriorwalloffun- +dus.Asmallamountofbariumispresentinlumen mayrarelybefoundonthegreatercur- (Fig 19). Although large lesions that +ofdiverticulum. vatureofthedistalantrum,alsoknown have a smooth surface are usually sub- +as a partial antral diverticulum (69). mucosal in origin, it is often difficult to +| | | | | determine | whether | protruded | | lesions | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +lessthan1–1.5cmindiameteraremu- +Figure20 +| | | | | cosal or | submucosal | in | origin, | as small | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | +| | | | | polyps originating | | in | the mucosa | may | +Figure19 +alsohaveasmoothsurface. +Hyperplasticpolypsarenonneoplas- +| | | | | tic proliferations | | of | surface | foveolar | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --------- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | +| | | | | cells, consisting | | of elongated, | | distorted | +| | | | | pits and | numerous | | branching | glands | +| | | | | (4). These | polyps | are | typically | smooth | +| | | | | or finely | lobulated | sessile | lesions | less | +| | | | | than 1 cm | in size | (Fig | 5). Occasionally, | | +| | | | | however, | atypical | hyperplastic | | polyps | +| | | | | may be | larger | than 1 | cm in | diameter, | +pedunculated,andhaveacoarselylobu- +| | | | | lated surface | (Fig | 20) | (71–73). | At least | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------- | +| | | | | one-third | of patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| | | | | polyps have | multiple | | polyps, | usually in | +thegastricbodyandfundus(Fig5)(4). +| | Figure20: Double-contrastspotimageof | | | Although | hyperplastic | | polyps | have no | +| --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | | | malignantpotential,theyusuallyarisein | | | | | +Figure19: Double-contrastspotimageof 1-cminsize,sessile,slightlylobulatedpolypon thesettingofchronicgastritis,thesame +| fundusandupperbodyofstomachwithpatientin | greatercurvatureasareaofincreasedradiopacity | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +milieuthatresultsingastricmetaplasia +| semiuprightpositionshowslargesubmucosal | coatedbybarium(arrow).Althoughradiographic | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | -------- | +| | | | | and dysplasia. | | As a result, | gastric | ade- | +| massassmooth-surfacedhemisphericlesion | findingsareworrisomeforanadenomatouspolyp | | | | | | | | +| | | | | nomas and | carcinomas | | have | been re- | +| (largearrows)formingrightangles(smallarrows) | orevenasmallpolypoidcarcinoma,thislesion | | | | | | | | +| | | | | ported | to occur | with | increased | fre- | +| withadjacentluminalcontour.Surgeryrevealed | wasfoundtobealargehyperplasticpolyponen- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | quency | in patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| benigngastrointestinalstromaltumor. | doscopicbiopsyspecimens. | | | | | | | | +polyps(4). +| 40 | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure21 +Fundic gland polyps, the second in these patients. Atypical hyperplastic +mostcommongastricpolyps,areprolif- polypsthatareunusuallylargeorlobu- +erationsofthedeepepithelialcompart- lated(Fig20)areindistinguishablefrom +ment of body-type mucosa (4). These adenomatous polyps or even polypoid +polyps consist of cystically dilated pits carcinomas(71–73). +and glands lined by parietal and chief Retention polyps (juvenile polyps) +cells. Fundic gland polyps are found mayoccurassolitarylesionsorasmul- +both sporadically and in patients with tiple lesions in Cronkite-Canada syn- +familialadenomatouspolyposissyndrome. drome (76). Xanthelasmas, isolated +These polyps typically appear on dou- hamartomatous polyps, and inflamma- +ble-contrast studies as smooth-sur- toryfibroidpolypsareotherbenignpol- +faced,sessileprotrusionslessthan1cm yps occasionally encountered in the +in size. Fundic gland polyps are usually stomach. A focal cluster of polyps may +locatedinthefundusandupperbodyof also be seen in the gastric antrum or +thestomachandareoftenmultiple(74). body in patients with small carcinoid +In patients with familial adenomatous tumors. +polyposis syndrome, hundreds of small Masses.—For gastric masses larger +(" 5 mm in size) fundic gland polyps than 2 cm in size, barium studies are +Figure21: Double-contrastspotimageof +maybefound. extremelyhelpfulfordeterminingwhether +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +Adenomatouspolypsofthestomach thelesionsarisefromthemucosa,sub- +bariumoutliningoutercontourandintersticesofa +arearelativelyuncommonmacroscopic mucosa,ormuscularispropria,orwhether +3-cmsessile,multilobulatedlesion(arrows). +formofgastricdysplasia.Adenomasare they are extrinsic to the stomach. This +Surgeryrevealedtubulovillousadenoma.(Re- +classified as tubular, tubulovillous, or differentiationenablestheradiologistto +printed,withpermission,fromreference15.) +villous on the basis of their underlying suggest a specific diagnosis or differen- +architecture. Gastric adenomas may tial diagnosis. In general, a mass origi- +progresstogastriccarcinomabymeans nating in the mucosa has a nodular or +ofapolypoidadenomatocarcinomase- lobulatedsurface,appearingenfaceon +quence similar to that found in the co- double-contrast studies as a filling de- Figure22 +lon.Insitucarcinomaorinvasivecarci- fectinthebariumpoolorasanareaof +nomaisfoundinatleast50%ofadeno- abnormalbarium-coatedlines,depend- +matous polyps larger than 2 cm in size ingonwhetheritisonthedependentor +(75).Mostgastricdysplasias,however, nondependent walls (Fig 22) (11). Not +are relatively flat macroscopically. In infrequently, irregular collections of +fact,mostgastriccarcinomasarisefrom bariumaretrappedintheintersticesof +flat or slightly elevated or depressed thetumor(Fig21)orinareasofulcer- +areas of dysplasia, not polypoid adeno- ation. Barium thus outlines multiple +mas(4). roundorovoidnoduleswithintheinter- +Insymptomaticpatients,gastricad- sticesofthelesion.Forexample,apol- +enomas detected on double-contrast ypoidcarcinomamaybemanifestedasa +studies are usually larger than 1 cm in lobulated or fungating mass within the +size(75).Theseadenomascanbesessile, expectedluminalcontour(Fig22). +lobulated, or pedunculated lesions Incontrast,asubmucosalmassmay +Figure22: Double-contrastspotimageof +(Fig 21). Although most hyperplastic appearenfaceondouble-contraststud- +uppergastricbodywithpatientinsupineposition +polyps are smaller than 1 cm and most ies as a round or ovoid, well-circum- +showsmultilobulatedpolypoidmassasconfluent, +adenomasarelargerthan1cm,itisnot scribed, smooth or slightly lobulated +lobulatedradiolucentfillingdefects(blackarrows) +always possible to distinguish a hyper- area of increased radiopacity. When +inbariumpoolwithseparateportionoflesion +plastic polyp from an adenomatous viewed in profile, a submucosal mass outlinedinwhiteongreatercurvature(whitear- +polyp on barium studies. If a polyp is 1 maybemanifestedasahemisphericin- row).Surgeryrevealedpolypoidadenocarcinoma. +cm or larger in size and has a finely traluminalprojectionthathasasmooth +nodularorlobulatedsurface,endoscopy surface and forms right angles or +and biopsy therefore should be per- slightlyobliqueangleswiththeadjacent 23)(4).Anulceratedsubmucosalmass +formed to exclude the possibility of an gastricwall(Figs19,23).Centralulcer- viewed en face produces a characteris- +adenoma.Conversely,multiplerounded ationoccursinabout50%ofsubmuco- tic“target”or“bull’s-eye”lesion,witha +polyps 5 mm or smaller in size are al- sal masses due to central ischemia and central ulcer surrounded by a smooth, +most always hyperplastic, so that en- necrosis of the tumor or pressure ne- well-definedmass(Fig24).Gastrointes- +doscopy and biopsy are not warranted crosis of the overlying epithelium (Fig tinalstromaltumorsarebyfarthemost +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 41 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +commonsolitarysubmucosalmassesin shape at fluoroscopy (78) and has fat An extrinsic mass that indents but +the stomach (77). Lymphoma and soli- attenuation at computed tomography does not infiltrate the gastric serosa is +tarymetastasesareotherfrequentsub- (79,80). Granular cell tumors usually manifested as a smooth, broad-based +mucosal tumors. Lipoma is a submuco- appear as one or more small submuco- inbowingofthegastricwall(Fig26).In +sal lesion that may change in size and sallesions.Mostothermesenchymaltu- contrast, an extrinsic inflammatory or +mors (eg, neurofibromas) are indistin- neoplasticmassthatinvolvestheserosa +Figure23 guishable from gastrointestinal stromal of the stomach may cause tethering of +| tumors. | | the gastric | wall | toward | the | extrinsic | +| -------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | +| Ectopicpancreaticrest(ie,myoepi- | | process, | resulting | in | spiculation | of the | +thelial hamartoma) is an uncommon luminal contour. For example, omental +submucosallesioncomposedofvarying metastases invading the greater curva- +amounts of pancreatic tissue (including tureofthestomachthroughthegastro- +ducts, acini, and islet cells), hypertro- colic ligament may cause spiculation +phicsmoothmusclefibers,andglandular and tethering of the greater curvature +structures resembling Brunner glands (84).Extrinsicinflammatoryorneoplas- +(81,82). These lesions may be compli- tic processes that involve the gastric +catedbypancreatitis,cysts,isletcelltu- walloroccludegastriclymphaticorve- +mors, and even pancreatic carcinoma nous channels may also result in en- +(4). Ectopic pancreatic rests usually larged gastric folds. For example, pan- +appear on barium studies as small creatitissecondarilyinvolvingthestom- +(1–2cm),solitary,centrallyumbilicated ach may be manifested as thickened +| submucosal masses, | most often | on the foldsontheposteriorgastricwall. | | | | | +| ------------------ | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +greater curvature of the distal gastric Thepreciselocationofmasslesions +antrumwithin1–6cmfromthepylorus, in the stomach may help suggest the +but can occasionally be located else- diagnosisinasmallpercentageofcases. +Figure23: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows whereinthestomach(Fig25)(83). As previously discussed, a submucosal +4-cmsmooth-surfacedsubmucosalmassout- lesion on the greater curvature of the +linedinwhitebybarium(arrows).Notecentral distal gastric antrum should suggest an +Figure25 +triangular-shapedulcer(arrowheads)inmass. ectopicpancreaticrest,whereasasub- +Surgeryandclinicalfollow-uprevealedamalig- mucosal defect extending from the +nantgastrointestinalstromaltumor. lessercurvatureofthedistalantrumto +| | | the pylorus | should | suggest | | a hypertro- | +| --- | --- | -------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | phied antral-pyloric | | fold. | In | contrast, a | +| | | smooth, | undulating | submucosal | | lesion | +onthemedialaspectofthefundusnear +Figure24 +thegastriccardiashouldsuggestacon- +glomeratemassofgastricvarices(85). +Multiplicityoflesionsisanotherra- +| | | diographic | feature | that | may | be helpful | +| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | +| | | in suggesting | | a specific | diagnosis | or | +| | | differential | diagnosis. | | Numerous | small | +("1cminsize),smoothorfinelylobu- +lated,sessileprotrusionsarealmostal- +| | | ways hyperplastic | | polyps | (Fig | 5) or, if | +| --- | --- | ----------------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | confined | to the | gastric | body | or fundus, | +fundicglandpolyps.Aclusterofpolyps +| Figure25: Double-contrastspotimageof | | elsewhere | in | the stomach | | in patients | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | withchronicHpylorigastritismayrep- | | | | | +Figure24: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowssmooth,1-cmovoid,radiolucent resent gastric carcinoid tumors due +gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique fillingdefect(arrow)inbariumpoolwithshallow to end-stage neuroendocrine hyperpla- +positionshowsbull’s-eyeortargetlesioninstom- centralumbilicationcontainingtraceamountof +| | | sia associated | | with | hypogastrinemia | | +| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------------- | --- | +achasa2-cmovoid,smooth-surfaced,submuco- barium(arrowhead).Endoscopicbiopsyspeci- +| | | (5,10). | Multiple | large | (# 1 | cm in size) | +| --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | +salmass(blackarrows)inbariumpoolcontaining mensrevealedanectopicpancreaticrest(myoepi- +| | | polypoid | lesions | may | represent | adeno- | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | +stellatecentralulcer(whitearrow).Thispatient thelialhamartoma).Ectopicpancreaticrestsare +| | | matous | polyps, | atypical | hyperplastic | | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | +hadbreastcancerwithhematogenousmetastasis usuallylocatedongreatercurvatureofdistalan- +| | | polyps, | Peutz-Jeghers | | hamartomas, | or | +| --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +tothestomach. +trum,butthislesionwasonposteriorwall. +evensynchronouspolypoidcarcinomas. +42 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure26 +Finally, multiple submucosal masses or tal antrum to the pylorus or even +centrally ulcerated bull’s-eye lesions may throughthepylorusintothemedialfor- +representhematogenousmetastases(such nix of the base of the duodenal bulb +as metastatic melanoma), disseminated (Fig27)(92).Inmostpatients,ahyper- +lymphoma,and,inpatientswithacquired trophied antral-pyloric fold can be dif- +immunodeficiency syndrome, Kaposi sar- ferentiated from a neoplastic lesion by +coma. itscharacteristicappearanceandloca- +tion (93). Another clue to the pres- +ThickenedFolds enceofahypertrophiedantral-pyloric +Normal rugal folds are thicker in the fold is its variable size and shape at +proximal stomach, have a smooth con- fluoroscopy, with palpation and peri- +tour in profile, and taper distally (5). stalsis. Occasionally, however, a hy- Figure26: Double-contrastspotimageof +Foldsalsoarelargerandmoreundulat- pertrophied fold may be unusually gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +ingonthegreatercurvaturethanonthe large or lobulated, so it can be mis- positionshowssmoothindentationongreater +lesser curvature. Rugal folds become taken for a polypoid or plaquelike tu- curvature(blackarrows)duetoextrinsicmass +straightandthinnerwithincreasinggas- mor(93). lesioncompressingstomach.Secondbarium- +coatedline(whitearrows)indicatesthatlumenis +tric distention and can even disappear H pylori gastritis is by far the most +narrowedasymmetrically.Areaofincreasedra- +when the stomach is fully distended, common cause of focally or diffusely +diopacity(D)alsoresultsfrommasscompressing +particularly in the gastric antrum. Be- thickened folds in the stomach. Abnor- +lumen.Thesefindingswerecausedbymassive +causeofthesenormalvariationsinfold mal folds are found in about 75% of +retroperitoneallymphoma. +size, there are no reliable criteria for patients with H pylori gastritis (89). +enlarged folds in the stomach. How- Fold enlargement in H pylori gastritis +ever,rugalfoldsaremuchmorelikelyto mostcommonlyinvolvesthegastrican- +beabnormalwhentheyhaveanirregu- trum and body but may involve the en- +lar, lobulated, or scalloped contour or tirestomachormayevenbeconfinedto +Figure27 +when they are enlarged or have an an- thegastricfundus.MostpatientswithH +gledortransverseorientationinawell- pylori gastritis have mildly to moder- +distendedgastricantrum.Foldsthatare ately thickened gastric folds without +larger on the lesser curvature than on substantialfoldirregularity(Fig28),so +the greater curvature are also consid- that the radiographic findings are not +eredtobeabnormal. worrisome for Menetrier disease or +Becauserugalfoldsarecomposedof lymphoma. However, some patients +mucosa and submucosa, any process with H pylori gastritis have such en- +thatinfiltratestheselayersofthegastric larged,lobulatedfolds(ie,polypoidgas- +wall can increase the size of the folds. tritis)thattheradiographicfindingser- +Enlargedfoldsmaybecausedbyinflam- roneously suggest a malignant process. +matory processes such as H pylori gas- Other patients with H pylori gastritis +tritis (86–89), hyperplastic processes may have focally thickened polypoid +suchasZollinger-Ellisonsyndrome(90) folds confined to the gastric antrum or +and Menetrier disease (91), or malig- bodythataremistakenradiographically +nanttumorssuchaslymphomaandsub- for a polypoid or infiltrating neoplasm +mucosally infiltrating adenocarcinoma. (88). Nevertheless, radiologists cannot +Endoscopic biopsy specimens may be assume that all cases of enlarged folds +required to differentiate these various arecausedbythisubiquitouspathogen. +causes of enlarged folds, particularly Ifthefoldsaremarkedlyenlarged,lobu- +when the folds are markedly thickened lated, or irregular (particularly if they +andirregular. haveafocalorsegmentaldistribution), +Antralgastritis(whetherornotitis endoscopic biopsy specimens should Figure27: Double-contrastspotimageof +associatedwithHpylori)isusuallyman- beobtainedtoexcludeamalignanttu- gastricantrumwithpatientinsupineleftposterior +ifestedonbariumstudiesasthickened, mor. obliquepositionshowsovoid,1.5-cmsmooth- +scalloped folds that have a longitudinal In Menetrier disease, there is surfacedsubmucosallesion(arrows)extending +fromlessercurvatureofdistalantrumtoadjacent +ortransverseorientation.Antralgastri- marked hyperplasia of surface foveolar +pylorus.Thislesionchangedinsizeandshapeat +tis may lead to the development of a mucous cells (4,10), resulting in a +fluoroscopywithpalpationandperistalsis.Find- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold, seen marked increase in the height of the +ingsarecharacteristicofhypertrophiedantral- +as a smooth submucosal defect extend- foveolae and partial atrophy of the +pyloricfold. +ingfromthelessercurvatureofthedis- glands,withacorrespondinglossofvol- +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 43 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +umeofparietalandchiefcellandsubse- Although early reports stated that fold causesurfacefoveolarcellslinetheen- +quent hypochlorhydria. The rugal folds enlargement predominantly involved tirestomach. +mayappearmassivelyenlargedandlob- thegastricfundusandbody(sparingthe Portalhypertensionsometimesmay +ulated on barium studies (Fig 29) (91). antrum) (94), later reports found that cause mucosal hyperemia with dilated +Menetrier disease causes fold enlarge- submucosal vessels in the absence of +Figure28 +mentthroughoutthestomachinatleast truevarices,aconditionknownaspor- +50% of patients (91), presumably be- tal hypertensive gastropathy (95). This +gastropathycanleadtoacuteorchronic +| Figure30 | gastrointestinal | | bleeding. | Thickened, | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | +finelynodularfoldsareseeninthegas- +tricfundusonbariumstudies(96).Gas- +| | tric varices | with | associated | esophageal | | +| --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | +varicesareusuallycausedbyportalhy- +| | pertension, | whereas | isolated | | gastric | +| --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | +| | varices | (in the | absence | of esophageal | | +varices)maybecausedbyportalhyper- +| | tension | or, less | commonly, | by | splenic | +| --- | ---------------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | +| | vein obstruction | | from pancreatic | | carci- | +noma,pancreatitis,orpancreaticpseudo- +| | cysts (97,98). | | Gastric varices | | can be | +| --- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | +| | distinguished | from | the abnormal | | folds | +| | of portal | hypertensive | gastropathy | | by | +theirundulatingandtortuousconfigura- +Figure28: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- tion and smooth contour (Fig 30) (97). +achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsmoderately Figure30: Double-contrastspotimageof In some patients, varices may also be +thickenedfoldsingastricbodyduetochronicHpy- gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +seenondouble-contraststudiesasmul- +lori gastritis.Foldsareconsiderablylessthickened positionshowssmooth,undulatingsubmucosal +| | tiple smooth, | round | or ovoid | nodules, | | +| --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | +andlobulatedthaninpatientwithMenetrierdisease mass(arrows)onposteriorwalloffundusextend- +likenedtotheappearanceofabunchof +ingtocardia.Thispatienthadportalhypertension +(Fig29).Notesurgicalclipsfrompriorvagotomy. grapes.Inothers,however,aconglom- +| withaconglomeratemassofgastricvarices(also | erate mass | of | gastric | varices | (also | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +knownastumorousvarices).Notesurgicalclips +| | known | as tumorous | varices) | may | be | +| --- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | +fromrecentlivertransplantation. +manifestedasasmooth,undulatingsub- +Figure29 +mucosalmassonthemedialwallofthe +fundusnearthegastriccardia(85). +| | The | normal | gastric | cardia | is usu- | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | +Figure31 +| | ally manifested | | on double-contrast | | | +| --- | --------------- | ------------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | +| | studies | as a stellate | collection | of | thin, | +| | smooth | folds | radiating | to a | central | +pointatthegastroesophagealjunction +(Fig2).Anylesiondisruptingoroblit- +| | erating | the cardiac | rosette | with | asso- | +| --- | ------------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | +| | ciated nodularity, | | mass | effect, | ulcer- | +| | ation, or | distorted | folds | in this | region | +| | should | be considered | suspicious | | for | +carcinomaofthecardia(Fig31).More +| | advanced | tumors | at the | cardia | may | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | +appearaspolypoid,ulcerated,orinfil- +| | trating lesions | | that can | easily be | visu- | +| ------------------------------------ | --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----- | +| | alized with | a | double-contrast | | tech- | +| Figure31: Double-contrastspotimageof | nique(Fig31)(99–101). | | | | | +gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +Figure29: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowspolypoidmass(arrows)thathas GastricNarrowing +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows obliteratedandreplacednormalcardiacrosette. +Narrowingoftheluminalcontourofthe +markedlythickened,lobulatedfoldsanddiffuse Arrowheadsdenoteareasofulcerationwithintu- +stomachmaybecausedbyscarring,in- +distortionofareaegastricaepatterninpatientwith mor.Thispatienthadanadvancedcarcinomaof +| | filtrating | tumor, | or extrinsic | diseases | | +| --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | +Menetrierdisease. cardia. +secondarilyaffectingthestomach.Chronic +44 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure32 Figure33 +| scarring | from peptic | ulcer | disease | may | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| produce | asymmetric | inbowing | | and re- | | | | +| traction | of one | wall of | the stomach, | of- | | | | +| ten associated | | with | smooth, | straight | | | | +| folds that | radiate | to | the site | of the | | | | +healedulcer.Otherpatientswithpeptic +scarringhavesmooth,taperednarrow- +| ing of | the gastric | antrum | | or, less | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| commonly, | weblike | antral | narrowing | | | | | +| (Fig 32). | Scarring | from | ingestion | | of | | | +| NSAIDs | (ie, chronic | NSAID | | gastropa- | | | | +thy)canalsoresultinthecharacteristic +flatteningofthegreatercurvatureofthe +distalantrum(102). +Long-segmentnarrowingofthestom- Figure33: Double-contrastspotimageof +ach (either circumferential or confined gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +toonewall)ordiffusenarrowingofthe Figure32: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowslongsegmentofcircumferential +stomachisusuallycausedbyaninfiltrat- narrowingextendingfrommidgastricbodytomid +distalgastricantrumandduodenalbulbwithpa- +ingorscirrhousgastriccarcinoma(103) gastricantrum(arrowsdenotelimitsoftumor). +tientinleftposteriorobliquepositionshowsshort +or metastatic breast cancer. The nar- Althoughtumorsurfaceispredominantlysmooth, +segmentofsmooth,circumferentialnarrowing +focalareasofmucosalnodularityareseeninprox- +| rowingwithscirrhouscarcinomaresults | | | | | (arrow)duetoantralwebrelatedtoscarringfrom | | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +imalendoflesion(arrowheads).Thispatienthad +| fromadesmoplasticreactiontotumor | | | | | previouspepticulcerdisease.Ifmucosalnodular- | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +scirrhousgastriccarcinomaproducingalinitis +| cells infiltrating | | the submucosa, | | pro- | ityorirregularityofluminalcontourhadbeen | | | +| ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +plasticaappearance. +| ducing | a linitis | plastica | appearance. | | present,endoscopyandbiopsywouldhavebeen | | | +| ------------------ | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | ------ | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| Scirrhous | carcinomas | | may be | mani- | requiredtoruleoutfocalgastriccancer. | | | +| fested | as diffuse, | long-segment, | | or | | | | +| even short-segment | | narrowing | | of any | | | | +portionofthestomach(Fig33)(103). be caused by antral scarring from +Figure34 +The narrowed lumen is rigid and non- Crohndiseaseor,rarely,othergranu- +distensible at fluoroscopy, and gastric lomatousdiseasessuchassarcoidosis, +peristalsisisobliteratedinthisregion. syphilis, and tuberculosis. Occasion- +Theluminalcontourmayhaveasmooth, ally, antral narrowing may also result +nodular, or finely ulcerated surface on from gastric atrophy related to the +double-contrast studies (Fig 33). Occa- presenceofalong-standinggastrojeju- +sionally, scirrhous carcinomas of the nal anastomosis without an antrec- +| distal antrum | may | be | very short, | cir- | tomy. | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +cumferential lesions confined to the Atrophic gastritis is a condition in +prepyloricregionofthestomach(104). whichbody-typemucosalglandsarere- +It is important to recognize that en- placed by metaplastic cells resembling +doscopyandbiopsyhaveapoorsensi- pyloric- or intestinal-type epithelium +tivity in depicting scirrhous carcino- (10). Most atrophic gastritis is related +mas of the stomach, so that some pa- tochronicinflammationratherthanau- Figure34: Double-contrastspotimageof +tientswithradiographicallydiagnosed toimmune phenomena. This form of gastricfundusandbodywithpatientinright- +lesions may require one or more re- atrophic gastritis is often patchy and side-downpositionshowssmoothnarrowingof +peat endoscopic examinations to con- macroscopically flat, so that it is not fundusandbodyofstomachwithabsentrugal +foldsandsmall,barelyvisibleareaegastricae. +| firmthediagnosis. | | | | | recognizable | on barium studies. | In other | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | -------- | +Thesefindingsarecharacteristicofatrophic +| In contrast, | | the | narrowing | with | patients | with the autoimmune | form of | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ------------------- | ------- | +metastatic breast cancer results from atrophicgastritis,thereisseverelossof gastritis. +denseinfiltrationofthesubmucosaby parietal cell mass, resulting in inade- +tumor. Severe scarring from previous quate secretion of intrinsic factor with +causticingestionmaycausediffusean- thesubsequentdevelopmentofvitamin of gastric folds. More than 80% of pa- +tral narrowing indistinguishable from B12 deficiency and, eventually, perni- tients with pernicious anemia have a +antral carcinoma on barium studies, ciousanemia.Inthelaterstagesofauto- diffusely narrowed stomach with a +but the clinical history should suggest immuneatrophicgastritis,decreasedpari- smooth contour and decreased or ab- +the correct diagnosis. Tapered nar- etal cell mass is manifested as a dimin- sent rugal folds on double-contrast +rowingofthegastricantrummayalso ished mucosal surface volume and loss studies(Fig34). +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 45 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +References +| | | | | | 15.RubesinSE,LevineMS.Principlesforper- | | | | | gastritis | and primary | B-cell | gastric | lym- | +| -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------------------------------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | formingadoublecontrastuppergastroin- | | | | | phoma.Lancet1991;338:1175–1176. | | | | | +| 1.Freeny | PC. Double-contrast | | gastrography | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | testinal | examination. | Westbury, | | NY: E-Z- | | | | | | +ofthefundusandcardia:normallandmarks 30.ParsonnetJ,HansenS,RodriguezL,etal. +EM,2000;1–29. +and their pathologic changes. AJR Am J Helicobacter pylori infection and gastric +Roentgenol1979;133:481–487. 16.RubesinSE.Galleryofdoublecontrastter- lymphoma.NEnglJMed1994;330:1267– +| | | | | | minology. | Gastroenterol | | Clin North | Am | 1271. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2.HerlingerH,GrossmanR,LauferI,Kressel +1995;24:259–288. +HY,OchR.Thegastriccardiaindouble– 31.BahkYW,AhnJR,ChoiHJ.Lymphoidhy- +| contrast | study: | its dynamic | image. | AJR | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 17.Cho | KC, Gold | BM, Printz | DA. | Multiple | perplasiaofthestomachpresentingasum- | | | | | +AmJRoentgenol1980;135:21–29. +| | | | | | transversefoldsinthegastricantrum.Ra- | | | | | bilicatedpolypoidlesions.Radiology1971; | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3.TonerPG,CameronCHS.Thegastricmu- diology1987;164:339–341. 100:277–280. +cosa.In:WhiteheadR,ed.Gastrointestinal 18.Dheer S, Levine MS, Redfern RO, Metz 32.Sbeih F, Abdullach A, Sullican S, Meren- +and oesophageal pathology. 2nd ed. Edin- DC,RubesinSE,LauferI.Antralgastritis kowZ.Antralnodularity,gastriclymphoid +burgh, Scotland: Churchill Livingstone, radiographic findings in patients with and hyperplasia and Helicobacter pylori in +1995;15–32. without Helicobacter pylori. Br J Radiol adults. J Clin Gastroenterol 1996;22:227– +| | | | | | 2002;75:805–811. | | | | | 230. | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 4.Fenoglio-Preiser | | CM, | Noffsinger | AE, | | | | | | | | | | | +StemmermannGN,LantzPE,ListromMB. 19.LevineMS,PalmanCL,RubesinSE,Laufer 33.Torigian DA, Levine MS, Gill NS, et al. +| Gastrointestinal | | pathology: | an | atlas and | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | --------- | +| | | | | | I,HerlingerH.Atrophicgastritisinperni- | | | | | Lymphoid | hyperplasia | of | the stomach: | ra- | +| text. Philadelphia, | | Pa: | Lippincott-Raven, | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | ciousanemia:diagnosisbydoublecontrast | | | | | diographic | findings | in five | adult | patients. | +1999;153–236. radiography. Gastrointest Radiol 1989;14: AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:71–75. +215–219. +5.RubesinSE,FurthEE,LevineMS.Gastritis 34.GentaRM,HamnerHW.Thesignificance +from NSAIDs to Helicobacter pylori. Ab- 20.Warren JR. Unidentified curved bacilli on oflymphoidfolliclesintheinterpretationof +domImaging2005;30:142–159. gastricepitheliuminchronicactivegastri- gastricbiopsyspecimens.ArchPatholLab +| | | | | | tis.Lancet1983;1:1273–1275. | | | | | Med1994;118:740–743. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6.MackintoshCE,KreelL.Anatomyandra- +diologyoftheareaegastricae.Gut1977;18: 21.Marshall BJ, Warren JR. Unidentified 35.YooCC,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Gastric +855–864. curved bacilli in the stomach of patients mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissuelymphoma: +7.Seaman WB. The areae gastricae. AJR withgastritis.Lancet1984;1:1311–1315. radiographicfindingsinsixpatients.Radiology +1998;208:239–243. +| AmJRoentgenol1978;131:554. | | | | | 22.Yardley | JH, Hendrix | TR. | Gastritis, | gas- | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | tropathy,duodenitis,andassociatedulcer- | | | | | 36.Eidt S, Stolte | M. | Prevalence | of lymphoid | | +8.RubesinSE,HerlingerH.Theeffectofbar- +| | | | | | ative | lesions. In: | Yamada | Y, Alpers | DH, | folliclesandaggregatesinHelicobacterpy- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +iumsuspensionviscosityonthedelineation +| | | | | | LaineL,OwyangC,PowellDW,eds.Text- | | | | | lori gastritis | in | antral and | body | mucosa. | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | +| of areae | gastricae. | AJR | Am J | Roentgenol | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | bookofgastroenterology.3rded.Philadel- | | | | | JClinPathol1993;46:832–835. | | | | | +1986;146:35–38. +| | | | | | phia, | Pa: Lippincott | Williams | & | Wilkins, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +37.KanekoE,NakamuraT,UmedaN,Fugino +| 9.Charagundla | SR, | Levine | MS, Langlotz | CP, | 1999;1463–1499. | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +M,NiwaH.Outcomeofgastriccarcinoma +| Rubesin | SE, Laufer | I. Visualization | | of areae | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 23.DooleyCP,CohenH,FitzgibbonsPL,etal. | | | | | detectedbygastricmasssurveyinJapan. | | | | | +| gastricae | on double-contrast | | gastrointestinal | | | | | | | | | | | | +radiography: relationship to age of patients. PrevalenceofHelicobacterpyloriinfection Gut1977;18:626–630. +| | | | | | and | histologic | gastritis | in asymptomatic | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:61–63. 38.KaibaraN,KawaguchiH,NishidoiH,etal. +| | | | | | persons. | N Engl | J Med | 1989;321:1562– | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Significanceofmasssurveyforgastriccan- +| 10.AppelmanHD.Gastritis:terminology,eti- | | | | | 1566. | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | | | cer from | the standpoint | | of surgery. | Am J | +ology,andclinicopathologiccorrelations— +| | | | | | 24.Graham | DY, Go | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori: | Surg1981;142:543–545. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +anotherbiasedview.HumPathol1994;25: +currentstatus.Gastroenterology1993;105: +| 1006–1019. | | | | | | | | | | 39.Montesi | A, Graziani | | L, Pesaresi | A, | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +279–282. +| | | | | | | | | | | DeNigris | E, Bearzi | I, Ranaldi | R. | Radio- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +11.LauferI,KresselHY.Principlesofdouble- +| | | | | | 25.BayerdorfferE,LehnN,HatzR,etal.Dif- | | | | | logicdiagnosisofearlygastriccancerby | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +contrastdiagnosis.In:LevineMS,Rubesin +SE,LauferI,eds.Doublecontrastgastroin- ferenceinexpressionofHelicobacterpylori routine double-contrast examination. +| | | | | | gastritisinantrumandbody.Gastroenter- | | | | | GastrointestRadiol1982;7:205–215. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +testinalradiology.3rded.Philadelphia,Pa: +ology1992;102:1575–1582. +| Saunders,2000;8–46. | | | | | | | | | | 40.GoldRP,GreenPH,O’TooleKM,Seaman | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 26.Dixon | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori and | peptic | WB.Earlygastriccancer:radiographicex- | | | | | +12.LauferI.Asimplemethodforroutinedou- +| | | | | | ulceration: | histologic | aspects. | J | Gastroen- | perience.Radiology1984;152:283–290. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +blecontraststudyoftheuppergastrointes- +terolHepatol1991;6:125–130. +tinaltract.Radiology1975;117:513–518. 41.White RM, Levine MS, Enterline HT, +| | | | | | 27.Parsonnet | J, Friedman | | GD, Vandersteen | | LauferI.Earlygastriccancer:recentexpe- | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 13.Shirakabe | H, Kobayashi | | S, Maruyama | M. | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | DP,etal.Helicobacterpyloriinfectionand | | | | | rience.Radiology1985;155:25–27. | | | | | +| Principles | and application | | of double | con- | | | | | | | | | | | +theriskofgastriccarcinoma.NEnglJMed +trast radiography. In: Shirakabe H, Nish- 1991;325:1127–1131. 42.ShirakabeH,NishizawaM,MaruyamaM, +izawaM,MaruyamaS.Atlasofx-raydiag- KobayashiS.Definitionandclassificationof +nosis of early gastric cancer. 2nd ed. To- 28.HanssonLE,EngstrandL,NyrenO,etal. earlygastriccancer.In:ShirakabeH,Nish- +kyo,Japan:Igaku-Shoin,1982;19–43. Helicobacter pylori infection: independent izawaM,MaruyamaM,KobayashiS,eds. +| | | | | | risk indicator | of | gastric | adenocarcinoma. | | Atlasofx-raydiagnosisofearlygastriccan- | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | +| 14.Levine | MS, Rubesin | | SE, Herlinger | H, | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Gastroenterology1993;105:1098–1103. | | | | | cer. 2nd | ed. Tokyo, | Japan: | Igaku-Shoin, | | +| Laufer | I. Double | contrast | upper | gastroin- | | | | | | | | | | | +1982;1–18. +| testinal | examination: | technique | | and inter- | 29.WotherspoonAC,Ortiz-HidalgoC,Flaxon, | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pretation.Radiology1988;168:593–602. IsaccsonPG.Helicobacterpyloriassociated 43.LauferI,HamiltonJ,MullensJE.Demon- +| 46 | | | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +stration of superficial gastric erosions by WE, Goldsmith MR. Improved radio- 73.CherukuriR,LevineMS,FurthEE,Rubesin +doublecontrastradiography.Gastroenter- graphicdetectionofmultiplegastriculcers. SE, Laufer I. Giant hyperplastic polyps in +ology1975;68:387–391. AJRAmJRoentgenol1977;128:949–952. thestomach:radiographicfindingsinseven +patients.AJRAmJRoentgenol2000;175: +| 44.Op den | Orth | JO, Dekker | W. | Gastric | 58.BraverJM,PaulRE,PhilippsE,BloomS. | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1445–1448. +| erosions: | radiological | and | endoscopic | as- | Roentgendiagnosisoflinearulcers.Radiol- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pects.RadiolClin(Belg)1976;45:88–89. ogy1979;132:29–32. 74.HizawaK,IidaM,MatsumotoT,AoyagiK, +YaoT,FujisimaM.Naturalhistoryoffundic +| 45.KikuchiY,LevineMS,LauferI,Herlinger | | | | | 59.NelsonSW.Thediscoveryofgastriculcers | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +glandpolypswithoutfamilialadenomatous +| H.Valueofflowtechniquefordouble-con- | | | | | andthedifferentialdiagnosisbetweenbe- | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +coli:follow-upobservationsin31patients. +| trast | examination | of the | stomach. | AJR | nignancy | and malignancy. | | Radiol Clin | | | | | +| ----- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Radiology1993;189:429–432. +| AmJRoentgenol1986;147:1183–1184. | | | | | NorthAm1969;7:5–25. | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +75.OpdenOrthJO,DekkerW.Gastricadeno- +| 46.Lanza | FL, Nelson | RS, Rack | MF. | A con- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 60.Wolf | BS. Observations | on | roentgen fea- | mas.Radiology1981;141:289–293. | | | | +| trolled | endoscopic | study | comparing | the | | | | | | | | | +turesofbenignandmalignantulcers.Semin +toxiceffectsofsulindac,naproxen,aspirin, 76.DanielES,LudwigSL,LewinKJ,Ruprecht +Roentgenol1971;6:140–150. +and placebo on the gastric mucosa of RM, Rajacich GM, Schwabe AD. The +healthyvolunteers.JClinPharmacol1984; 61.OttDJ,GelfandDW,WuWC.Detectionof Cronkhite-Canadasyndrome:ananalysisof +24:89–95. gastriculcer:comparisonofsingleanddou- clinicalandpathologicfeaturesandtherapy +| | | | | | ble-contrastexamination.AJRAmJRoent- | | | | in55patients.Medicine1982;61:293–309. | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 47.LanzaFL.NSAIDSandthegastrointestinal | | | | | genol1982;139:93–97. | | | | | | | | +tract.AbdomImaging1997;22:1–4. 77.SusterS.Gastrointestinalstromaltumors. +| | | | | | 62.Barragry | TP, Blatchford | JW, | Allen MO. | SeminDiagnPathol1996;13:297–313. | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 48.Grace | E. Approach | to | the patient | with | | | | | | | | | +Giantgastriculcers:areviewof49cases. +grossgastrointestinalbleeding.In:Yamada 78.MaderalF,HunterF,FuselierG,Gonzales- +AnnSurg1986;203:255–259. +T,ed.Textbookofgastroenterology.Phila- Rogue P, Torres O. Gastric lipomas: an +delphia,Pa:LippincottWilliams&Wilkins, 63.KottlerRE,TuftRJ.Benigngreatercurva- update of clinical presentation, diagnosis +2003;698–723. ture gastric ulcer: the “sump ulcer.” Br J and treatment. Am J Gastroenterol 1984; +| | | | | | Radiol1981;54:651–654. | | | | 79:964–967. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +49.LevineMS,VerstandigA,LauferI.Serpiginous +gastric erosions caused by aspirin and other 64.Hocking BV, Alp MH, Grant AK. Gastric 79.Megibow AJ, Redmond PE, Bosniak MA, +nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. AJR ulcerationwithhiatushernia.MedJAust Horowitz L. Diagnosis of gastrointestinal +AmJRoentgenol1986;146:31–34. lipomasbyCT.AJRAmJRoentgenol1979; +1976;2:207–208. +133:743–745. +50.RobertsDM.Chronicgastritis,alcoholand +| | | | | | 65.Thompson | G, Somers | S, Stevenson | GW. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +non-ulcer dyspepsia. Gut 1972;13:768– 80.Imoto T, Nobe T, Koga M, Miyamoto Y, +| | | | | | Benign | gastric ulcer: | a reliable | radiologic | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 774. | | | | | | | | | NakataH.Computedtomographyofgastric | | | | +diagnosis?AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;141: +| | | | | | | | | | lipomas. | Gastrointest | Radiol | 1983;8:129– | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | +| 51.BalthazarEJ,MegibowAJ,HulnickDH.Cy- | | | | | 331–333. | | | | | | | | +131. +| tomegalovirus | | esophagitis | and gastritis | in | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 66.Zboralske | FF, Stargardter | | FL, Harel GS. | | | | | +AIDS. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1985;144: 81.Barbosa JJ, Dockerty MB, Waugh JM. +Profileroentgenographicfeaturesofbenign +1201–1204. greater curvature ulcers. Radiology 1978; Pancreaticheterotopia:areviewofthelit- +| | | | | | 127:63–67. | | | | eratureandreportof41authenticatedsur- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +52.Laufer I, Trueman T. Multiple superficial gicalcasesofwhich25wereclinicallysignif- +gastricerosionsduetoCrohn’sdiseaseof +| | | | | | 67.LevineMS,KellyMR,LauferI,RubesinSE, | | | | icant. | Surg Gynecol | Obstet | 1946;82:527– | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | +thestomach:radiologicandendoscopicdi- +| | | | | | Herlinger | H. Gastrocolic | fistulas: | the in- | 542. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +agnosis.BrJRadiol1976;49:726–728. +| | | | | | creasing | role of aspirin. | Radiology | 1993; | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | | 82.Lai EC, | Tompkins | RK. | Heterotopic | +| 53.Ariyama | J, Wehlin | L, | Lindstrom | CG, | 187:359–361. | | | | | | | | +pancreas:reviewofa26-yearexperience. +WenkertA,RobertsGM.Gastroduodenal +| | | | | | 68.Eisenberg | RL, Levine | MS. | Miscellaneous | AmJSurg1986;151:697–700. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +erosionsinCrohn’sdisease.Gastrointest +abnormalitiesofthestomach.In:GoreRM, +| Radiol1980;5:121–125. | | | | | | | | | 83.BesemannEF,AuerbachSH,WolfeWW. | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +LevineMS,eds.Textbookofgastrointesti- +Theimportanceofroentgenologicdiagnosis +54.Sloan JM. Acute haemorrahagic gastritis nal radiology. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders, ofaberrantpancreatictissueinthegastro- +| and | acute infective | gastritis: | | gastritis | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------------- | ------ | +| | | | | | 2000;659–681. | | | | intestinal | tract. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium | +| caused | by physical | agents | and | corro- | | | | | | | | | +TherNuclMed1969;107:71–76. +| sives—uraemic | | gastritis. | In: Whitehead | | 69.Treichel | J, Gerstenberg | | E, Palme G, | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +R, ed. Gastrointestinal and oesophageal KlemmT.Diagnosisofpartialgastricdiver- 84.RubesinSE,LevineMS,GlickSN.Gastric +ticula.Radiology1976;119:13–18. +pathology. 2nd ed. Edinburgh, Scotland: involvement by omental cakes: radio- +Churchill-Livingstone,1995;461–470. 70.Gordon R, Laufer I, Kressel HY. Gastric graphicfindings.GastrointestRadiol1986; +| | | | | | polypsfoundonroutinedouble-contrastex- | | | | 11:223–228. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +55.RumermanJ,RubesinSE,LevineMS,Long +aminationofthestomach.Radiology1980; +WB,LauferI.Gastriculcerationcausedby 85.CarucciLR,LevineMS,RubesinSE,Laufer +heaterprobecoagulation.GastrointestRa- 134:27–30. I. Tumorous gastric varices: radiographic +| diol1988;13:200–202. | | | | | | | | | findingsin10patients.Radiology1999;212: | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 71.Joffe | N, Antonioli | DA. Atypical | appear- | | | | | +861–865. +| 56.LevineMS,CreteurV,KresselHY,Laufer | | | | | ances | of benign hyperplastic | | polyps. AJR | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +I,HerlingerH.Benigngastriculcers:diag- AmJRoentgenol1978;131:147–152. 86.deLangeEE.Radiographicfeaturesofgas- +nosis and follow-up with double-contrast tritisusingthebiphasiccontrasttechnique. +72.SmithHJ,LeeEL.Largehyperplasticpol- +radiography.Radiology1987;164:9–13. CurrProblDiagnRadiol1987;16:273–308. +| | | | | | yps of | the stomach. | Gastrointest | Radiol | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +57.BloomSM,PaulREJR,MatsueH,Poplack 1983;8:19–23. 87.GelfandDW,OttDI,ChemMY.Radiologic +| Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | | | | | | | | 47 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +evaluationofgastritisandduodenitis.AJR in 40 patients. Radiology 1999;213:347– graphic diagnosis and clinical significance. +AmJRoentgenol1999;173:357–361. 351. Radiology1979;132:593–598. +| | | | | 94.ReeseDF,HodgsonJR,DockertyMB.Gi- | | | 99.Balthazar | EJ, | Goldfine | S, Davidian | NM. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | +88.SohnJ,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Helico- +bacter pylori gastritis: radiographic find- anthypertrophyofthegastricmucosa(Me- Carcinomaoftheesophagogastricjunction. +ings.Radiology1995;195:763–767. netrier’s disease): a correlation of the AmJGastroenterol1980;74:237–243. +| | | | | roentgenographic, | pathologic, | and clinical | 100.Freeny | PC, | Marks | WM. Adenocarcinoma | | +| --------- | ----------- | ----------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --------------- | ------------ | --------------------------------- | -------------------- | ----- | ------------------ | ------ | +| 89.Levine | MS, Rubesin | SE. The Helicobacter | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | findings. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium Ther | of | the gastroesophageal | | junction: | barium | +| pylori | revolution: | radiologic perspective. | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | NuclMed1962;88:619–626. | | | andCTexamination.AJRAmJRoentgenol | | | | | +Radiology1995;195:593–596. +1982;138:1077–1084. +| | | | | 95.Smart | HL, Triger DR. Clinical | features, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +90.Ellison EH, Wilson SD. The Zollinger- 101.LevineMS,LauferI,ThompsonJJ.Carci- +| | | | | pathophysiology, | and relevance | of portal | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ellisonsyndrome:re-appraisalandevalua- nomaofthegastriccardiainyoungpeople. +| | | | | hypertensive | gastropathy. | Endoscopy | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tion of 260 registered cases. Ann Surg AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;140:69–72. +1991;23:224–228. +1964;160:512–530. +| | | | | | | | 102.Laveran-Stieber | | RL, | Laufer I, Levine | MS. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | +96.ChangD,LevineMS,GinsbergGG,Rubesin +91.Olmsted WW, Cooper PH, Madewell JE. SE,LauferI.Portalhypertensivegastropathy: Greatercurvatureantralflattening:aradio- +| | | | | | | | logic | sign | of NSAID-related | gastropathy. | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------------- | ------------- | ----- | ---- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | +| InvolvementofthegastricantruminMen- | | | | radiographic | findings in eight | patients. AJR | | | | | | +AbdomImaging1994;19:295–297. +| etrier’s | disease. | AJR Am J Roentgenol | | AmJRoentgenol2000;175:1609–1612. | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1976;126:524–529. | | | | | | | 103.LevineMS,KongV,RubesinSE,LauferI, | | | | | +97.LevineMS,KieuK,RubesinSE,Herlinger +| | | | | | | | Herlinger | H. | Scirrhous | carcinoma | of the | +| ------------ | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------ | +| 92.Glick SN, | Cavanaugh | B, Teplick | SK. The | H,LauferI.Isolatedgastricvarices:splenic | | | | | | | | +stomachradiographicandendoscopicdiag- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold. AJR vein obstruction or portal hypertension? nosis.Radiology1990;175:151–154. +| AmJRoentgenol1985;145:547–549. | | | | GastrointestRadiol1990;15:188–192. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +104.BalthazarEJ,RosenbergH,DavidianMM. +93.AroraR,LevineMS,HarveyRT,LauferI, 98.MuhletalerC.GerlockJ,GoncharenkoV, Scirrhouscarcinomaofthepyloricchannel +Rubesin SE. Hypertrophied antral-pyloric AvantGR,FlexnerJM.Gastricvaricessec- anddistalgastricantrum.AJRAmJRoent- +foldreassessmentofradiographicfindings ondary to splenic vein occlusion: radio- genol1980;134:669–673. +| 48 | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | + +Radiology 2007 +This is your reprint order form or pro forma invoice +(Please keep a copy of this document for your records.) +Reprint order forms and purchase orders or prepayments must be received 72 hours after receipt of form either +by mail or by fax at 410-820-9765. It is the policy o f Cadmus Reprints to issue one invoice per order. +Please print clearly. +Author Name _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Title of Article _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Issue of Journal_______________________________ Reprint # _____________ Publication Date ________________ +Number of Pages_______________________________ KB # _____________ Symbol Radiology +Color in Article? Yes / No (Please Circle) +Please include the journal name and reprint number or manuscript number on your purchase order or other correspondence. +Order and Shipping Information +Reprint Costs +(Please see page 2 of 2 for reprint costs/fees.) +Shipping Address +(cannot ship to a P.O. Box) Please Print Clearly +Name ___________________________________________ +________ Number of reprints ordered $_________ +Institution _________________________________________ +________ Number of color reprints ordered $_________ Street ___________________________________________ +City ____________________ State _____ Zip ___________ +________ Number of covers ordered $_________ +Country ___________________________________________ +Subtotal $_________ +Quantity___________________ Fax ___________________ +Taxes $_________ Phone: Day _________________ Evening _______________ +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +(Add appropriate sales tax for Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the +District of Columbia or Canadian GST to the reprints if your order is to +Additional Shipping Address* +be shipped to these locations.) (cannot ship to a P.O. Box) +Name ___________________________________________ +First address included, add $32 for Institution _________________________________________ +Street ___________________________________________ +each additional shipping address $_________ +City ________________ State ______ Zip ___________ +Country _________________________________________ +TOTAL $_________ +Quantity __________________ Fax __________________ +Phone: Day ________________ Evening ______________ +E-mail Address ____________________________________ +* Add $32 for each additional shipping address +Payment and Credit Card Details Invoice or Credit Card Information +Enclosed: Personal Check ___________ Invoice Address Please Print Clearly +Please complete Invoice address as it appears on credit card statement +Credit Card Payment Details _________ +Name ____________________________________________ +Checks must be paid in U.S. dollars and drawn on a U.S. Bank. +Institution ________________________________________ +Credit Card: __ VISA __ Am. Exp. __ MasterCard Department _______________________________________ +Card Number __________________________________ Street ____________________________________________ +Expiration Date_________________________________ City ________________________ State _____ Zip _______ +Signature: _____________________________________ Country ___________________________________________ +Phone _____________________ Fax _________________ +Please send your order form and prepayment made payable to: +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +Cadmus Reprints +P.O. Box 751903 Cadmus will process credit cards and Cadmus Journal +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 Services will appear on the credit card statement. +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +If you don’t mail your order form, you may fax it to 410-820-9765 with +FEIN #:541274108 +your credit card information. +Signature __________________________________________ Date _______________________________________ +Signature is required. By signing this form, the author agrees to accept the responsibility for the payment of reprints and/or all charges +described in this document. +RB-9/22/06 +Page 1 of 2 + +Radiology 2007 +Black and White Reprint Prices Color Reprint Prices +Domestic (USA only) Domestic (USA only) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $213 $228 $260 $278 $295 $313 1-4 $218 $233 $343 $460 $579 $697 +5-8 $338 $373 $420 $453 $495 $530 5-8 $343 $388 $584 $825 $1,069 $1,311 +9-12 $450 $500 $575 $635 $693 $755 9-12 $471 $503 $828 $1,196 $1,563 $1,935 +13-16 $555 $623 $728 $805 $888 $965 13-16 $601 $633 $1,073 $1,562 $2,058 $2,547 +17-20 $673 $753 $883 $990 $1,085 $1,185 17-20 $738 $767 $1,319 $1,940 $2,550 $3,164 +21-24 $785 $880 $1,040 $1,165 $1,285 $1,413 21-24 $872 $899 $1,564 $2,308 $3,045 $3,790 +25-28 $895 $1,010 $1,208 $1,350 $1,498 $1,638 25-28 $1,004 $1,035 $1,820 $2,678 $3,545 $4,403 +29-32 $1,008 $1,143 $1,363 $1,525 $1,698 $1,865 29-32 $1,140 $1,173 $2,063 $3,048 $4,040 $5,028 +Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 +International (includes Canada and Mexico) International (includes Canada and Mexico)) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $263 $275 $330 $385 $430 $485 1-4 $268 $280 $412 $568 $715 $871 +5-8 $415 $443 $555 $650 $753 $850 5-8 $419 $457 $720 $1,022 $1,328 $1,633 +9-12 $563 $608 $773 $930 $1,070 $1,228 9-12 $583 $610 $1,025 $1,492 $1,941 $2,407 +13-16 $698 $760 $988 $1,185 $1,388 $1,585 13-16 $742 $770 $1,333 $1,943 $2,556 $3,167 +17-20 $848 $925 $1,203 $1,463 $1,705 $1,950 17-20 $913 $941 $1,641 $2,412 $3,169 $3,929 +21-24 $985 $1,080 $1,420 $1,725 $2,025 $2,325 21-24 $1,072 $1,100 $1,946 $2,867 $3,785 $4,703 +25-28 $1,135 $1,248 $1,640 $1,990 $2,350 $2,698 25-28 $1,246 $1,274 $2,254 $3,318 $4,398 $5,463 +29-32 $1,273 $1,403 $1,863 $2,265 $2,673 $3,075 29-32 $1,405 $1,433 $2,561 $3,788 $5,014 $6,237 +Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 +Tax Due +Minimum order is 50 copies. For orders larger than 500 copies, +please consult Cadmus Reprints at 800-407-9190. Residents of Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the District +of Columbia are required to add the appropriate sales tax to each +Reprint Cover reprint order. For orders shipped to Canada, please add 7% +Cover prices are listed above. The cover will include the Canadian GST unless exemption is claimed. +publication title, article title, and author name in black. +Ordering +Reprint order forms and purchase order or prepayment is +Shipping required to process your order. Please reference journal name +Shipping costs are included in the reprint prices. Domestic and reprint number or manuscript number on any +orders are shipped via UPS Ground service. Foreign orders are correspondence. You may use the reverse side of this form as a +shipped via a proof of delivery air service. proforma invoice. Please return your order form and +prepayment to: +Multiple Shipments +Cadmus Reprints +Orders can be shipped to more than one location. Please be +P.O. Box 751903 +aware that it will cost $32 for each additional location. +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 +Delivery +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +Your order will be shipped within 2 weeks of the journal print FEIN #:541274108 +date. Allow extra time for delivery. +Please direct all inquiries to: Reprint Order Forms +and purchase order +Rose A. Baynard or prepayments must +800-407-9190 (toll free number) be received 72 hours +410-819-3966 (direct number) after receipt of form. +410-820-9765 (FAX number) +baynardr@cadmus.com (e-mail) +Page 2 of 2 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k4/question.json b/q231/random_k4/question.json index cc21acf47ee27fe80ffc025187abaab075c359c7..6b02e0caf80045b32e3293a9747eee96c2f92d71 100644 --- a/q231/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q231/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NIKE_2021_10K.pdf", - "web_6019e7c0934ca3b6.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf", - "web_8617c40cc2c5d6aa.pdf", - "web_5b8076d084922575.pdf" + "web_0fc33975f03605a5.pdf", + "resize_r2_23.pdf", + "web_903701db648fd6ad.pdf", + "resize_r2_4.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k4/random_1.md b/q231/random_k4/random_1.md index 1c064e3ff046ea90ec57fa6e9a2c7b22d1110cc1..15d75a09f41359a0dd28001b377846c0439ea651 100644 --- a/q231/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q231/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1527 +1,589 @@ -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary -Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) -Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) -1. Date of Submission: 8/17/2007 -2. Agency: Department of Justice -3. Bureau: Federal Bureau Of Investigation -4. Name of this Capital Asset: FBI Digital Collection -5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: (For IT 011-10-01-02-01-2503-00 -investment only, see section 53. For all other, use agency -ID system.) -6. What kind of investment will this be in FY2009? (Please Mixed Life Cycle -NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY2009, with -Planning/Acquisition activities prior to FY2009 should not -select O&M. These investments should indicate their current -status.) -7. What was the first budget year this investment was FY2001 or earlier -submitted to OMB? -8. Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this closes in part or -in whole an identified agency performance gap: -Since September 2001, the FBI's demands for critical, timely intelligence gathering have increased significantly. Pre- -September 2001 ELSUR intercepts (per year) have increased. Not only do demands for information continue to increase, -but also the requirement to facilitate information sharing does. The current collection enterprise consists of Foreign -Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) and Criminal Law Enforcement (CLE) systems. Today's telecommunications -capabilities afford terrorists and criminals many avenues to coordinate and commit offenses against U.S. citizens and -interests. Communications methods, such as voice over internet protocol (VoIP) and voice over packet (VoP), are -dramatically increasing in number and complexity, resulting in the continual and evolving need for advanced methods of -electronic surveillance of voice communications; methods of electronic surveillance have limited-life utility in intercepting -newer, more secure types of publicly offered communications. The expansion of electronic surveillance activity in -frequency, sophistication, and linguistic needs continues to increase the level of support, transportability, and -information sharing required. An important factor behind this expansion is the changing demographic of targets that -must be monitored by investigators. Further, the life span of today's technology is often much shorter than older -technologies, resulting in more frequent need for solution development. Collection equipment manufacturers continue -toward complying with technical standards as a result of the Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act -(CALEA). One result of the CALEA standard is more information is available for collection. -9. Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee Yes -approve this request? -a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval? 5/19/2007 -10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? Yes -11. Contact information of Project Manager? -Name -Phone Number -Email -a. What is the current FAC-P/PM certification level of the TBD -project/program manager? -12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost Yes -effective, energy-efficient and environmentally sustainable -techniques or practices for this project? -a. Will this investment include electronic assets Yes -(including computers)? -b. Is this investment for new construction or major No -retrofit of a Federal building or facility? (answer applicable -to non-IT assets only) -1. If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help -fund this investment? -Page 1 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable -design principles? -3. If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy -efficient than relevant code? -13. Does this investment directly support one of the PMA Yes -initiatives? -If "yes," check all that apply: Human Capital -Expanded E-Government -a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected Strategic Management of Human Capital. The FBI acquires -how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)? individuals with rare linguistic skills by collocating and -(e.g. If E-Gov is selected, is it an approved shared service networking the collection assets within proximity for -provider or the managing partner?) employment, training, and development. A work flow -management module is used by operations managers -monitor productivity and distribute work accordingly. -Expanded E-Gov -14. Does this investment support a program assessed using No -the Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more -information about the PART, visit -www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) -a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness -found during a PART review? -b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? -c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? -15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes -If the answer to Question 15 is "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is "No," do not answer questions -16-23. -For information technology investments only: -16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Level 1 -Guidance) -17. What project management qualifications does the (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this -Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) investment -18. Is this investment or any project(s) within this No -investment identified as "high risk" on the Q4 - FY 2007 -agency high risk report (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) -19. Is this a financial management system? No -a. If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA -compliance area? -1. If "yes," which compliance area: -2. If "no," what does it address? -b. If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent financial -systems inventory update required by Circular A-11 section 52 -20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2009 funding request for the following? (This should total 100%) -Hardware -Software -Services -Other -21. If this project produces information dissemination N/A -products for the public, are these products published to the -Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and -included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? -22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions: -Name -Phone Number -Title Acting FBI Privacy and Civil Liberties Officer -Page 2 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -E-mail -23. Are the records produced by this investment No -appropriately scheduled with the National Archives and -Records Administration's approval? -Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: -24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO Yes -High Risk Areas? -Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) -1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts represent -budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be included only in -the row designated "Government FTE Cost," and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full -Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." The "TOTAL" estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for -"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should -include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or restoration costs. The costs associated with the -entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this report. -Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES -(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) -(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) -P -e -Y -a --1 -rl i -a -e -n -r -d -PY 2007 CY 2008 BY 2009 BY+1 2010BY+2 2011BY+3 2012 -B -b -Y -e -+ -y -4 -o n -an -d -d -Total -Planning: 13.915 2 2.554 0 0 0 0 0 18.469 -Acquisition: 142.387 0 21.181 21.261 0 0 0 0 184.829 -Subtotal Planning & 156.302 2 23.735 21.261 0 0 0 0 203.298 -Acquisition: -Operations & Maintenance: 80.936 20.916 15.547 21.075 -TOTAL: 237.238 22.916 39.282 42.336 -Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. -Government FTE Costs 9.045 1.905 7.378 7.378 -Number of FTE represented 14 7 21 21 -by Costs: -Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner -agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. -2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional Yes -FTE's? -a. If "yes," How many and in what year? Ten FTEs were requested for this project in FY08 Exhibit -300 submission to perform requirements generation, -testing/evaluation, installation of new/upgraded equipment, -and user training as well as, system administration -expertise, telephonic/on-site technical support and system -maintenance support. The FTEs are included in the FY08 -President?s Budget; no additional personnel resources are -required upon approval of the request. -3. If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2008 President's budget request, briefly explain those changes: -The FY 2008 request for personnel enhancement of 14 personnel and non-personnel enhancement of $7,035,000 will -enhance the Digital Collection project's capacity to provide next generation systems, facilities, and capabilities to enable -continuance of audio and data collection in the furtherance of the FBI's FCI and Counterterrorism (CT) responsibilities. -The nonpersonnel enhancement will be used for new systems and equipment purchases ($3,850,000) and professional -and technical services ($3,185,000).. Without the requested resources, the number of funded contractor positions is -expected to increase. -Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) -1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned for this -investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders completed do -not need to be included. -Page 3 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) - -Contracts/Task Orders Table: - * Costs in millions -If N/A, has -the agency -| | | | What, if | | | determined | -| --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | -| | If so what | | any, | Does the | | the CO | -| | is the date | | alternative | contract | Contracting | assigned | -Has the Total Value Is this an -of the Start date Is it Competitiv financing Is EVM in include the CO Contact Officer has the -Contract or Type of contract award? If of End date of of Interagenc performanc ely option is the required information Certificatio competenci -Task Order Contract/ been Contract/ Contract/ y Name of CO -Number n o t , w h a t i s C o n t r a c t / e b a s e d ? aw ar d e d ? b e i n g co n t r ac t ? s e c u r i t y & (pho n e / em n L e v e l e s a n d -Task Order aw a r de d Task Order Tas k O r d er Ac q u is i ti o n -(Y / N ) t h e p la n n e d T a s k O r d e r ( $ M ) ? ( Y / N ) ( Y / N ) (Y / N ) u s e d ? ( Y / N ) p r i v a c y a il ) ( L e v e l s k il ls -a w a r d ( E S P C , c l a u s e s ? 1, 2 , 3 , N / A ) ne c e s s a r y -| | date? | | | (Y/N) | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | -| | | | UESC, EUL, | | | to support | -| | | | N/A) | | | this | -acquisition -? (Y/N) -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -FFP IDIQ Yes 9/28/2002 9/28/2002 9/27/2008 120 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - FFP Yes 4/1/2005 4/1/2005 8/2/2008 9.39 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP IDIQ Yes 9/15/2003 9/15/2003 9/15/2008 47 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 9/3/2003 9/3/2003 9/8/2008 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 10/1/2003 10/1/2003 9/30/2008 50 Yes No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -FFP Yes 10/7/2004 10/7/2004 10/5/2009 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | - -Page 4 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain -why: -Although EVM was not incorporated at the project's inception, a modified form of earned value management is being used -internally by the project team to monitor contractors' cost and schedule performance. Internal procedures are being used to -monitor FFP contracts using a straight-line calculation for services delivered and 100% earned value for product deliverables -received. Current contracts, being performed under the Digital Collection Project are Firm Fixed Price for Project Management -and Operations and Maintenance (O&M) of current systems; however, there are provisions within contract J-FBI-02-158 that -permit the time and material (T&M) and cost reimbursable (CR) efforts to be accomplished for research, development, and -unforeseen (O&M) requirements. It should also be noted that current and previous contracts did not include ANSI-compliant -EVMS because they did not meet the DOJ threshhold for ANSI-748 compliance. -For new developmental contracts the Digital Collection project will review, and include where appropriate, acquisition -requirements for ANSI-748 compliant EVM, as well as performance based contracting. -3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? Yes -a. Explain why: Contracts supporting this requirement ensure Section 508 -compliance in order to meet legal requirements as well as -satisfy needs of user personnel. -4. Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in Yes -accordance with agency requirements? -a. If "yes," what is the date? 2/9/2001 -b. If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed? -1. If "no," briefly explain why: -Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) -In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency and be linked -to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and strategic goals, and performance -measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the agency's strategic goals and objectives this -investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to -the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall -citizen participation rate of 75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if -applicable, investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general -goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure. -Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use the Federal -Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement Indicators to the corresponding -"Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There should be at least one Measurement Indicator -for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be -extended to include performance measures for years beyond FY 2009. -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year -Su -G -p -o -p -a -o -l( -r -s -te -) -d -Meas -A -u -r -r -e -e -a -m ent Me -C -a -a -s -t -u -e -r -g -e -o -m -ry -e nt Me -G -a -r -s -o -u -u -r -p -e -i -m -ng -e nt Me -I -a -n -s -d +Chapter 7 + +Competitive Positioning + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Short Description +• Background +• Strategic Rationale & Implications +• Strengths & Advantages +• Weaknesses & Limitations +• Process for Applying Technique +• Summary +• FAROUT + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.2 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Short Description +• Analyze a position relative to one’s own in order + +to: +– Preserve an advantage +– Attempt an improvement +– Withdraw from a market + +• Looks at: + +– Market share, client perceptions, current + +marketing strategies, prices and costs, and +competitors’ positions. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.3 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Background + +1950’s-60’s + +Late 60’s- +70’s + +•‘Corporate planning’ approach by firms founded on +steady expansion in a stable financial environment. +•Marketing tells about product benefits in comparison +with competition. + +•Corporate planning shifts to strategic planning and +management to as competition increases and market is +more volatile. +•Marketing attempts to change perception of product in +the mind of the customer by creating unique position. + +1980’s- now •Competitive positioning continues to evolve to provides +information with importance to the development of a +strategic plan by giving a firm an overview of its industry +and enabling it to appraise its own competitive position. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.4 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strategic Rationale & Implications + +• Analysis should reveal firms’ position within an industry. +• Overview of industry as a whole. +• A variety of tools and models can assist, including: + +Porter’s Five Forces Industry Analysis +Nine Forces Industry Analysis +BCG Matrix +McKinsey Matrix +Perceptual Maps + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.5 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Strategic Rationale & Implications + +4 Directions for any Strategy + +Develop firms’ +position + +Expand niche + +Minor to dominant + +Joint to sole +dominance + +Maintain strong position + +Preserve market share +in mature market + +Defend dominant position + +Withdraw from market + +Price cutting strategy + +New product +strategy + +Other strategies + +Market decline or +obsolescence + +Unsuccessful +expansion + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.6 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strengths and Advantages +• Improves decision making + +• Provides information for firms of all sizes, + +stages, and positions on: +– Gaps in marketplace +– Viability of products or markets +– Competition in new markets +– Attracting investment and creating alliances + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.7 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Weaknesses and Limitations +• Care must be taken in defining industries and + +markets. + +• Competitor information is not always available. +• Competitor and new product information is not + +always accurate. + +• Results may be limited by internal biases. +• Third party analysts may be misled by incomplete + +information. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.8 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +Can be defined as a broad 3-step process: + +1. + +Identify focus of your firm's current strategy and +analysis parameters such as market or products to be +assessed. + +2. Conduct analysis with the following: + +• Market segmentation +• Industry Analysis +• Market Research + +3. Derive insights from the above analysis and formulate + +positioning strategy for your firm. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.9 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 1: Assess current strategy and market, + +product, project, parameters. +– What is the scope of this project? +– What do you plan to do with this information? +– Will research be done in house, or by a third + +party? + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.10 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Product Market Matrix + +Markets + +current + +potential + +Products + +Current + +Potential + +c u -ic -re -a -m -to -e r -nt -Baseline Target Actual Results -2000 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2000 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 95% of Title Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 10% additional 30% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2001 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity -Terrorism and Activities Efficiency -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 65% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 10% additional 20% -Laws, and deployed in field life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2002 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Page 5 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2002 | | | | | Productivity | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Productivity and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2002 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 45% of Title Deploy Deployed -Requirements -Enforce Federal Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 30% additional 40% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -| | | | | | | offices | | systems | systems | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2003 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2003 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -Promote the Title III and Title and digital input by 300% collection input -by 346% -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | | -| ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2003 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -Prevent Crime, User Near end of life 5% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 5% of additional 5% of -deployed in field life -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | Title III systems | Title III systems | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------------- | -| | Represent the | | | | | offices | | | | -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2004 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -input by130% -Promote the Title III and Title and digital collection input -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | by 135% | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2004 | | Technology | | | Data Storage | | | | | -| | Prevent | | | Information and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | Data | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2004 Prevent Crime, Technology Information and Data Storage System Total storage Increase system Increased -Data -Enforce Federal information capacity storage capacity system storage -| | | | | | | storage capacity 4,200GB | | by 9% | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | | capacity by 12% | -| | Represent the | | | | | for collected | | | | -evidence -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2005 -| | Prevent | Customer | | Service | Service | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Results | | Coverage | Efficiency | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 30% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 60% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2006 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2006 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 9% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 8% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -| 2006 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Security and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Privacy | | | | | | -Promote the - -Page 6 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -| | | Results | | Responsiveness | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | response and | to requests for | response to | | -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -2007 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2008 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Response Time | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Customer Timeliness and Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2009 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | Improve speed | | | | - -Page 7 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | of access and | | | | -| | Promote the | | | | | dissemination of | | | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | information | | | | -| | Security | | | | | collected | | | | -through data -and -telecommunicati -ons intercepts -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Nation¿s -Security -2009 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy system and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the system/application -level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and operational systems security -tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational Security Table must be included on -your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or -identifier). -For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, include the -investment in both the "Systems in Planning" table (Table 3) and the "Operational Systems" table (Table 4). Systems which are -already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization activity, should be included in both Table 3 and -Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date - -Page 8 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information -contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the -enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. -All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the "Name of System" -column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled "Name of System" in the security tables -(Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one-to-one ratio between the list of systems and -the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA -may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). -The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the system are -discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text explanation why a working link is -not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, -answer "yes" for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is -not yet required to be published. -Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: -1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified -and integrated into the overall costs of the investment: -a. If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the -budget year: -2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part -of the overall risk management effort for each system -supporting or part of this investment. -3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or Modernization - Security Table(s): -Date of Planned C&A update (for -Name of System -Agency/ or C -S -o -y -n -st -t -e -ra -m -c -? -to r Operated -Planned Operational Date -e -o -x r -i s -P -t -l -i -a -n -n -g -n -m -ed -ix -C e -o -d -m -li -p -fe -le -c t -y -io -c n -le -D -s -a -y t -s -e -t e -( -m -fo -s -r -) -new systems) -DCS-5000 (Next Gen) Government Only -4. Operational Systems - Security Table: -What standards -were used for -Agency/ or NIST FIPS 199 Has C&A been the Security Date -Date the -Name of System -C -O -S -o -p -y -n -e -s -t -t -r -r -e -a -a -m -c -te -t -? -o -d -r R -(H -is -i -k -g h -I -, -m -L -M -o -p -w -o -a -d -c -) -t -e r -le -a -v -te -e -, -l Co -N -m -IS -p -T -l -( -e -Y -8 -t -/ -e -0 -N -d + +*SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility +Exit Barriers + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility + +Options + +Keep or drop? + +Determine +Product +Structure + +Set Pricing + +Options +Determine +Product +Structure + +Choose timing + +Go/No go + +Ch7.11 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis +– Market Segmentation: + +• Identifiable and measurable +• Accessible by communication/distribution + +channels + +• Have unique needs +• Be stable over time + +– Segments may be made up of +individual or industry consumers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.12 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Segmentation + +Individual + +Industry + +Geography + +Demographics + +Psychographics + +Behavior + +Geography + +Client Type + +Client Behavior + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.13 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Industry + +– SWOT Analysis +– Porter’s Five Forces Model +– Other tools + +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Research + +– Preferably conducted by third party. +– Use surveys, telemarketing, face-to-face + +interviews. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.14 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 3: Formulate position strategy + +– Use combination of perceptual maps, strengths and weaknesses of +self and competitors on matrices, and refer back to information +gathered in Steps 1&2. + +Strength/Weakness Evaluation Matrix: Sales Force Quality +SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International + +Much Better + +Somewhat Better + +Same + +Somewhat Worse + +Much Worse + 0 -, -) -- -u -3 -s -7 -i -? -n g Date C -C -o -& -m -A -p leted: -( -C -F +Strength or Weakness + +2 + +4 + +6 + +Relative Importance to success + 8 -o -I -0 -P -n -0 -S -tr -- 5 -o + +10 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.15 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Summary: + +Complete competitive positioning analysis will have: + +– Outline of current and potential products/markets + +• Product/market matrix can be helpful. + +– Identified competitive practices in the industry including +• Costs, revenue and profits, opportunities, weaknesses to + +exploit and strengths to overcome or avoid. + +– Factors contributing to client satisfaction with their + +current suppliers + +• Ability to understand value of purchases, availability & + +convenience of products, quality of service, loyalty, effort +required to change suppliers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.16 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Summary Continued: +• Undertake an overall appraisal of the competitive + +environment to identify any strategies or tactics, which +may improve your firm’s competitive position and identified +a set of strategies to take the firm where it wishes to go in +an industry. + +• Should have comprehensive view of the market. +• Any gaps or unmet needs should be apparent. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.17 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• FAROUT Summary + +1 + 2 -l + 3 -0 -s -, -0 -t -N -/ -e -N -I -s -S -t -I -s -T -S -? -T Se -C -c -o -u -m -T -r -e -i -p -t -s -l -y -e -t i -C -t -n -e -o -g -( -n -d -t -) -r -: -o l -contin -te -g -s -e -t -n -e -c -d -y plan -800-26, Other, -N/A) -DCS-3000 Government Only Yes 6/1/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-5000 Government Only Yes 6/3/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-6000 Government Only Yes 2/2/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of -the systems part of or supporting this investment been -identified by the agency or IG? -a. If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into -the agency's plan of action and milestone process? -6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is -requested to remediate IT security weaknesses? -a. If "yes," specify the amount, provide a general description of the weakness, and explain how the funding request will -remediate the weakness. -7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System -(b -sy -) -s -I -t -s -e m -th -? -is -( -a -Y / -n -N -e -) -w -Assessment (PIA) -(d) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t i -L -o -i -n -n k or Rec -r -o -e -r -q -d -u -s -i -N -re -o -d -t i -f -c -o -e -r -( -t -S -h + +4 + +5 + +F + +A + +R + O -is -R N) (f) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t -L -io -in -n -k or -w -s -h -y -i -s -c -t -h -e -c -m -o -? -v e -(Y -rs -/ N -th -) -i s -system? (Y/N) -DCS-3000 No No No PIA is required by the Yes www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva -E-Government Act at this cyact.html -time for this system -Page 9 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System (b ) I s th is a n e w Assessment (PIA) (d) I n t e r n e t L i n k or Rec o r d s N o t i c e ( S O R N) (f) I n t e r n e t L in k or -sy s t e m ? ( Y / N ) E x p l a n a t i o n r e q u i re d f o r t h is E x p l a n a t io n -| | | | w h i c h c | o v e rs th i s | | | system? (Y/N) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | - -| | | | s y s t e m | ? (Y / N ) | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| DCS-5000 | No | | Yes | | | | Yes | | | -| | | | | | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -cyact.html -| DCS-6000 | No | | No | | | | Yes | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| | | | | No PIA is required by the | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -| | | | | E-Government Act at this | | | | cyact.html | | -time for this system. -Details for Text Options: -Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to (c), provide an explanation -why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. - -Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal register. If no to (e), provide -an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn't a current and up to date SORN. - -Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be considered as a blank field. - -Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be included in the -agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and supporting the FEA. The business -case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and -technology layers of the agency's EA. -| 1. Is this investment included in your agency's target | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enterprise architecture? - a. If "no," please explain why? - -| 2. Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Strategy? - a. If "yes," provide the investment name as identified in Digital Collection Program -the Transition Strategy provided in the agency's most recent -annual EA Assessment. - b. If "no," please explain why? - -| 3. Is this investment identified in a completed (contains a | | | | No | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -target architecture) and approved segment architecture? - a. If "yes," provide the name of the segment architecture as -provided in the agency's most recent annual EA Assessment. - -4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table: -Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, customer relationship management, -etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. -| | | | | | | Service | Service | | | -| ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -| Agency | Agency | FEA SRM | | | | | | Internal or | | -Com p on e nt Co m p o n e n t Se r v ic e FEA SRM FEA SRM Component Component E x t e r n a l BY Funding - Service Type Component (a) Reuse d N ame Reus e d UPI ) Percentage (d) -| Na m e | D e sc ri p t io | n D o m a i n | | | | | | R e u s e ? (c | | -| ------ | ---------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | ( b ) | ( b ) | | | -No Reuse -Legacy Collaborative Back Office Development Legacy -| Integration | Analysis | Services | and Integration | Integration | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| Ad Hoc | Case Analysis | | Reporting | Ad Hoc | | | | No Reuse | | -| | | Business | | | | | | | | -Analytical -Services -Information Interagency Digital Asset Knowledge Information No Reuse -| Sharing | | Services | Management | Sharing | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Information -Sharing -Knowledge Intelligence and Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge No Reuse -| Capture | | Services | Management | Capture | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Evidence -Collection -No Reuse -Knowledge Intra-agency Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge -| Distribution and | Information | Services | Management | Distribution and | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------ | --------- | ----------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Delivery | Sharing | | | Delivery | | | | | | -Query Information Support Services Search Query No Reuse -Analysis - - a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already identified as a service -component in the FEA SRM. - b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather than answer -yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify the other investment using the -Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission. - -Page 10 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service component -provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one agency within a department reusing a service -component provided by another agency in another department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being -reused by multiple organizations across the federal government. -d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed in the table. If -external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another agency to pay for the service. The -percentages in the column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Data Management Database Connectivity Sybase -Delivery -Ad Hoc Component Framework Data Management Reporting and Analysis Word Perfect 6.0 -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Content Rendering Hyper Text Markup Language -Delivery (HTML) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Active Server Pages -Delivery .NetServer Pages .NetMicrosoft -Active Server Pages .Net -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Sun Active Server -Delivery Pages -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Microsoft Server 2003 -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Uniform Resource Locator -(URL) -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Microsoft Internet Explorer6.0 -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Netscape Navigator -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Requirements Legislative / Compliance Section 508 -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Hyper Text Transfer Protocol -Delivery (HTTP) -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Internet Protocol (IP) -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Transport Control Protocol -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Supporting Network Services Simple Network Management -Delivery Protocol (SNMP) -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: ISQL/w -Integration -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: PL/SQL -Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Interface and Integration Middleware Remote Procedure Call (RPC) -Delivery Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Oracle 10i -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Sybase -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Storage HP Series Enterprise Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Application Servers 2600 Dell Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Apache -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Internet Information Server -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Hard Disk -Infrastructure Drives -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Redundant -Infrastructure Array of Independent Disks -(RAID) -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Intel Microprocessors -Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Random Access Memory (RAM) -Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Ethernet -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Virtual LAN (VLAN) -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 2900 Series Switches -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 3700 Series Routers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco Gateway -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ICTG T1 Card -Page 11 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ISDN -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Network Interface Card (NIC) | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Transceivers | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Peripherals | | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hewlett-Packard 4500 Series -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | Printers | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | - - a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter multiple rows for -FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications - b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard or vendor -product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as appropriate. -No -6. Will the application leverage existing components and/or -applications across the Government (i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, -etc)? - a. If "yes," please describe. - -Page 12 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Part II: Planning, Acquisition and Performance Information -Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) -Part II should be completed only for investments identified as "Planning" or "Full Acquisition," or "Mixed Life-Cycle" investments -in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. -In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to the current -baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments to -determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. -1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this project? Yes -a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed? 1/27/2006 -b. If "no," what is the anticipated date this analysis will be -completed? -c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: -2. Alternative Analysis Results: * Costs in millions -Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: -Alternative Analyzed Description of Alternative -Risk Adjus -e -te -st -d -i m -Li -a -fe -te -c ycle Costs Risk Adjuste -e -d -s t -L -im -ife -a -c -t -y -e -c le Benefits -1- Volumetric Collection 245.015 9.443 -3. Which alternative was selected by the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? -Alternative 1 - Volumetric Collection. -4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? -The primary benefits of a regionalized architectural approach for the next generation of DCS-5000 would be to: 1) reduce -overhead costs by utilizing "economies of scale" practices,. -5. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part Yes -or in-whole? -a. If "yes," are the migration costs associated with the This Investment -migration to the selected alternative included in this -investment, the legacy investment, or in a separate migration -investment. -b. If "yes," please provide the following information: -List of Legacy Investment or Systems -Name of the Legacy Investment of Systems UPI if available Date of the System Retirement -DCS-5000 -Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) -You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this investment's life-cycle, -developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing -risk throughout the investment's life-cycle. -1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes -a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan? 4/16/2007 -b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly Yes -changed since last year's submission to OMB? -c. If "yes," describe any significant changes: -A preliminary internal project rating and risk assessment of the DCS-5000 NG acquisition effort was conducted and a DCS-5000 -NG Project baseline for risk was established. The Risk Management Plan (RMP) defined basic organizational, technical, and policy -guidelines for the implementation of risk management within the DCS-5000 Next Generation Project. It established the -techniques and procedures that will be utilized throughout the evolutionary life of the various DCS-5000 Next Generation Project -systems. The procedures described will help ensure the positive identification and management of risk areas associated with -acquisition, development, deployment, and support of the systems. The risk management policies and procedures set forth in -this RMP apply to all DCS-5000 Next Generation Project systems. The policies and procedures of this RMP are tailored for -Page 13 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -specific subsystems and contracts. The DCS-5000 Next Generation Project risk management system used by the DCS-5000 Next -Generation Risk Management Board follows the recommended policies and procedures and use the Glossary of terms set forth -by the Project Management Institute (PMI). These policies and procedures include: Risk management Planning, Risk -Identification, Qualitative Risk Analysis, Quantitative Risk Analysis, Risk Response Planning, and Risk Monitoring and Control. -2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? -a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date? -b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks? -3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle cost estimate and investment schedule: -Risks for the investment are identified within 3 categories: technical, acquisition, and financial. Each risk is evaluated as to its -probability of occurrence and level of impact on schedule, cost, and technical performance to determine the overall risk rating. -Given that, with very limited deviation, effort performed for digital collection implementation is completed by contracted support -through firm fixed price contracts, there is limited risk associated with technical, cost and schedule performance. Baselines -established are provided to contract vendors as contract requirements/deliverables; however, in order to mitigate the risk of -unforeseen requirements and increased scope, a management reserve of 10% is maintained. Cost performance risk is mitigated -through maximum usage of firm fixed price contracts and task orders. Budget projections are reviewed at least quarterly. -Independent government cost estimates are developed, analyzed, and compared to contractor proposals for each major -acquisition. Out-of-tolerance variances are brought to the contractors? attention and cost/price is negotiated. -Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) -EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should still be included -in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should accurately reflect the milestones -in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. -1. Does the earned value management system meet the No -criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard-748? -2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than +/- 10%? (CV%= CV/EV x No -100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) -a. If "yes," was it the CV or SV or both? -b. If "yes," explain the causes of the variance: -c. If "yes," describe the corrective actions: -3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? No -a. If "yes," when was it approved by the agency head? -Page 14 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | - 1 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $8.85 9/30/2004 $8.85 $8.85 $0 100% -(Planning) Prior -to FY05 - 2 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $128.14 9/30/2004 $128.14 $126.53 $1.61 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(Acquisition) -Prior to FY05 - 3 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $31.75 9/30/2004 $31.75 $31.75 $0 100% -(O&M) Prior to -FY05 - 4 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2005 $3.27 9/30/2005 $3.27 $3.12 $0.15 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - 5 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2005 $16.65 9/30/2005 $16.65 $17.33 $-0.68 100% - 6 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2005 $10.32 9/30/2005 $10.32 $11.31 $-0.99 100% - 7 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2006 $3.27 9/30/2006 $3.27 $3.13 $0.14 100% - 8 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2006 $15.7 9/30/2006 $15.7 $15.68 $0.02 100% - 9 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2006 $9.2 9/30/2006 $9.2 $9.2 $0 100% - 10 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2007 $3.31 9/30/2007 $3.31 $4.42 $-1.11 100% - 11 DCS-5000 9/30/2007 $2 9/30/2007 $2 $2 $0 100% -Planning - 12 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2007 $7.64 9/30/2007 $7.64 $7.97 $-0.33 100% - 13 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2007 $9.97 9/30/2007 $9.97 $8.12 $1.85 100% -| 14 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $2.96 | | | $2.96 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 15 | DCS-5000 | 9/30/2008 | $2.55 | | | $2.55 | | | | 0% | -Planning -| 16 | | 9/30/2008 | $20.18 | | | $21.18 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition -| 17 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $8.02 | | | $8.02 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 18 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $9.79 | | | $9.79 | | | | 0% | -| 19 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $2.11 | | | $2.11 | | | | 0% | -| 20 | | 9/30/2009 | $21.26 | | | $21.26 | | | | 0% | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition - -Page 15 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 21 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $9.7 | | | $9.7 | | | | 0% | -| 22 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $14.48 | | | $14.48 | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| Project Totals | | | | | | | | | | | - -Page 16 of 16 \ No newline at end of file + +U + +T + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.18 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques +• Industry Analysis +• SWOT Analysis +• Value Chain Analysis +• Competitor Analysis +• Financial Ratio and Statement Analysis +• Customer Segmentation Analysis +• BCG Growth/Share Portfolio Matrix +• GE Business Screen + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.19 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques Cont’d +• Supply Chain Analysis +• Product Line Analysis +• Benchmarking + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.20 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +For More About Competitive +Positioning and 23 Other Useful +Analysis Methods, see: + +Fleisher, Craig S. and Babette E. +Bensoussan + +Business and Competitive +Analysis: Effective Application of +New and Classic Methods + +Upper Saddle River, NJ +2007 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.21 + diff --git a/q231/random_k4/random_2.md b/q231/random_k4/random_2.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..82ecb3b9af6c3286b3846d69480033be2a625972 100644 --- a/q231/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q231/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,493 +1,1408 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. - -3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - -7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - -9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - -1 -0 - +Double-Contrast Upper +Gastrointestinal Radiography: A +Pattern Approach for Diseases of the +Stomach1 +StephenE.Rubesin,MD +Thedouble-contrastuppergastrointestinalseriesisavalu- +MarcS.Levine,MD +ablediagnostictestforevaluatingstructuralandfunctional +IgorLaufer,MD +abnormalities of the stomach. This article will review the +normalradiographicanatomyofthestomach.Theprinci- +plesofanalyzingdouble-contrastimageswillbediscussed. +Apatternapproachforthediagnosisofgastricabnormali- +tieswillalsobepresented,focusingonabnormalmucosal +patterns,depressedlesions,protrudedlesions,thickened +folds,andgastricnarrowing. +!RSNA,2008 +1FromtheDepartmentofRadiology,HospitaloftheUni- +versityofPennsylvania,3400SpruceSt,Philadelphia,PA +19104.ReceivedJuly18,2006;revisionrequestedSep- +tember20;revisionreceivedOctober5;acceptedNovem- +ber2;finalversionacceptedJanuary2,2007;finalre- +viewbyM.S.L.June19.S.E.R.andM.S.L.arepaid +consultantsforE-Z-Em,Westbury,NY.Addresscorre- +spondencetoM.S.L.(e-mail:marc.levine@uphs.upenn +.edu). +"RSNA,2008 +REVIEWSANDCOMMENTARY +# +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS +Note: This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for +distribution to your colleagues or clients, use the Radiology Reprints form at the end of this article. +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 33 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +T +his article presents a pattern ap- ples of double-contrast image interpre- more undulating on the greater curva- +proach for the diagnosis of dis- tation, we will consider abnormal sur- ture. The thickness of the rugal folds +eases of the stomach at double- facepatternsofthemucosa,depressed varieswiththedegreeofgastricdisten- +contrast upper gastrointestinal radi- lesions(erosionsandulcers),protruded tion(5). +ography. After describing the normal lesions (polyps, submucosal masses, +appearance of the stomach on double- andothertumors),thickenedfolds,and AreaeGastricae +contrast barium studies and the princi- gastricnarrowing. The mucosal surface of the stomach +consistsofflatpolygonal-shapedtuftsof +mucosa,knownasareaegastricae,sep- +Essentials NormalStomach +arated by narrow grooves (6,7). The +# Protrudedlesions(eg,polypsand areae gastricae are recognized on dou- +cancers)onthedependentwallof GastricConfigurationandRugalFolds ble-contrast studies as a reticular net- +thestomachmayappearasradi- The normal stomach is a J-shaped workofbarium-coatedwhitelineswhen +olucentfillingdefectsinthebar- pouch that lies in the left upper quad- barium fills the grooves between these +iumpool,whereasprotrudedle- rant (Fig 1). The stomach has a fixed mucosal tufts (Fig 3). Individual muco- +sionsonthenondependentwall configuration created by the greater sal tufts of areae gastricae normally +mayappearasbarium-coated length of the longitudinal muscle layer have a diameter of 2–3 mm in the gas- +“ringshadows”duetobarium onitsgreatercurvature.Thelessercur- tricantrumandof3–5mminthegastric +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions. vature of the stomach is suspended body and fundus (Fig 3) (6,8). Areae +# Multiplesmall,round,uniformnod- from the retroperitoneum by the hepa- gastricae are detected on double-con- +ulesinthestomachareusually togastric ligament, a portion of the trast studies in nearly 70% of patients +causedbylymphoidhyperplasia lesseromentum.Thegastrosplenicliga- and are observed with greater fre- +associatedwithHelicobacterpylori ment and gastrocolic ligament (ie, the quencyintheelderly(8,9). +gastritis,whereasirregularnonuni- proximal portion of the greater omen- +formnodulesmaybecausedby tum)areattachedtothegreatercurva- ComparisonofHistologicAnatomywith +low-gradeB-cellmucosa-associated ture of the stomach. The gastric cardia MacroscopicAnatomy +lymphoidtissuelymphoma. isattachedtothediaphragmbythesur- Abasicunderstandingofthehistologic +# Aspirinandothernonsteroidal roundingphrenoesophagealmembrane. anatomy of the stomach is helpful for +antiinflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs) The stomach is arbitrarily divided understandingpepticulcerdisease,as +arebyfarthemostcommon into five segments: the cardia, fundus, well as other gastric abnormalities +causeoferosivegastritis,acondi- body,antrum,andpylorus.Thegastric (5,10). The stomach contains several +tionmanifestedondouble-con- cardiaischaracterizedonbariumstud- typesofmucosa:cardiac-typemucosa, +traststudiesaspunctateorslitlike ies by three or four stellate folds that body/fundic-type mucosa, and antral/ +erosionssurroundedbyradiolu- radiatetoacentralpointatthegastro- pyloric-type mucosa. Gastric foveolae +centmoundsofedemaor,in esophageal junction, also known as the (orpits)areconicaldepressionsinthe +somepatientstakingNSAIDs,by cardiac“rosette”(Fig2)(1,2).Thegas- mucosal surface that communicate +linearorserpiginouserosionson tric fundus is defined as the portion of with gastric glands (4,10). The glands +ornearthegreatercurvatureof the stomach craniad to the gastric car- are long, straight, and tightly packed +thegastricantrumorbody. dia. The gastric body is defined as the structures.Thefoveolaeinallpartsof +# Hpylorigastritisisbyfarthe portion of the stomach extending from thestomacharelinedbysurfacefove- +mostcommoncauseoffocallyor thegastriccardiatothesmoothbendin olar mucous cells. The cardiac-type +diffuselythickenedgastricfolds, the mid lesser curvature known as the mucosa comprises a short (1 cm in +whichcanbesolargeandlobu- incisuraangularis.Thegastricantrumis length) segment of the gastric mucosa +lated(eg,polypoidgastritis)that defined as the portion of the stomach adjacenttothegastroesophagealjunc- +theradiographicfindingsresem- extendingfromtheincisuraangularisto tion (4). The distinguishing feature of +blethoseofMenetrierdiseaseor the pylorus (a structure created by a the body-type mucosa is the presence +lymphoma. muscle sphincter shaped like a figure +# Onbariumstudies,scirrhouscarci- eight). +nomasofthestomachmayproduce Rugal folds are most prominent in Publishedonline +alinitisplasticaappearancewith the gastric fundus and body, whereas 10.1148/radiol.2461061245 +diffusenarrowingorlong-orshort- the gastric antrum is often devoid of +Radiology2008;246:33–48 +segmentnarrowingofanyportion folds(Fig1).Gastricrugaearechange- +ofthestomach;metastaticbreast able structures composed of mucosa Abbreviations: +cancerandlymphomaoccasionally and submucosa (3,4). The rugal folds MALT!mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissue +NSAID!nonsteroidalantiinflammatorydrug +mayproduceasimilarradiographic arerelativelystraightonthelessercur- +appearance. vature of the stomach but larger and Authorsstatednofinancialrelationshiptodisclose. +34 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +ofparietalandchiefcellsintheglands. extending progressively higher on the (Fig 1). With air contrast, the luminal +The parietal cells produce hydrochlo- lesser curvature. Peptic ulcers fre- contourappearsasasmooth,continuous +ric acid and intrinsic factor, and the quently develop on the lesser curva- barium-coatedwhiteline(Fig1)(11). +| chief cells | produce | proteolytic | en- tureatthetransitionzone(Fig4). | | +| ----------- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | +| zymes. | No parietal | or chief cells | are | BariumPool | +found in antral-type mucosa. The sur- The pool of high-density barium is the +PrinciplesofImageAnalysis +facefoveolarmucouscellslinebothan- tool the radiologist uses to scrub and +tralpitsandglands. +| Body-type | mucosa | lines the | ana- AppearanceoftheStomach | | +| --------- | ------ | --------- | --------------------------- | --- | +tomic gastric fundus and the gastric Theradiologistfirstexaminestheover- +Figure3 +body and extends into the gastric an- allposition,shape,andsizeofthestom- +trum along the greater curvature (4). ach. The gastric fundus abuts the left +Antral-type mucosa lines the antrum hemidiaphragm. The cardia has a mid- +along the lesser curvature from the py- linelocation,abuttingthecrusoftheleft +lorustotheincisuraangularis,butonly hemidiaphragm.Thestomachcurvesto +linesasmallamountofantrumalongthe the right across the midline, with the +greater curvature. Thus, the histologic distalgastricantrumandduodenumex- +division of the stomach into body- and tendingtotherightofthespine.There +antral-type mucosa does not correlate is considerable variation in the size of +with the anatomic and radiologic divi- thestomach,dependingontheamount +sion of the stomach into fundus, body, of barium and effervescent agent ad- +| andantrum(5). | | | ministered. | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +The transition zone between body- Figure3: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +and antral-type mucosa is a line that LuminalContour achwithpatientinleftposteriorobliqueposition +extends from the incisura angularis to In the barium pool, the contour is de- showsnormalareaegastricaepatterninantrumas +thedistalgreatercurvature.Thetransi- marcated by a smooth edge of barium 2–3-mmpolygonallyshapedradiolucenttuftsof +tionzonemigratesproximallywithage, mucosaoutlinedbybariumingrooves.Areae +| | | | Figure2 | gastricaeareslightlylargerindistalgastricbody | +| --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | +thaninantrum. +Figure1 +Figure4 +| Figure1: | Normalstomach.Double-contrast | | | | +| -------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +spotimageofstomachwithpatientsupineshows +distalgastricbody(B)andantrum(A).Greater +| curvature(whitearrows)andlessercurvature | | | Figure2: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | +| (blackarrows)arecoatedbybarium.Rugalfoldon | | | tricfunduswithpatientinright-side-downposi- | | +| posteriorwallofgastricbodyisdepictedastubu- | | | tionshowsnormalgastriccardiawithsmooth | | +lar,slightlyundulating,radiolucentfillingdefect foldsradiatingtocentralpoint(whitearrow)at Figure4: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +(blackarrowheads)inshallowbariumpool.Dense closedgastroesophagealjunction,alsoknownas achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsbenign +bariumpooloutlinescontour(whitearrowheads) cardiacrosette.Long,straightfold(arrowheads) lessercurvaturegastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid +ofgastricfundus(F).Mucosalsurfaceandfoldsin extendsinferiorlyfromcardiaalonglessercurva- collectionofbariumextendingoutsideexpected +fundusareobscuredbybariumpool,andantrum ture.Blackarrowsdenotenormalextrinsicimpres- luminalcontourofgastricbody.Smoothfoldsare +sionbyadjacentspleen. +| isdevoidofrugalfolds. | | | | seenradiatingtoedgeofulcercrater. | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 35 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +coatthemucosalsurface(12–15).Some dent wall usually appear as radiolucent thickness of barium in the grooves +lesions are best shown in the barium fillingdefectsinthebariumpool(Fig5) between the mucosal tufts in relation +pool, whereas others are obscured by (16),whereasprotrudedlesionsonthe to the thickness of barium overlying +even a small pool of high-density bar- nondependent wall appear as barium- the tufts (8,9). Thus, an increase in +ium. Protruded lesions on the depen- coated “ring shadows” due to barium theheightofthemucosaltuftsorthin- +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions(Fig5). ning of the mucous gel layer in the +Figure5 When filled with barium, depressed le- stomach may cause the areae gastri- +sions appear as barium collections on caetobecomemorevisibleorconspic- +the dependent wall (Fig 4). When bar- uous. When viewed in profile, barium +ium spills out of depressed lesions on in the grooves between areae gastri- +thedependentwall,theymayappearas cae may be manifested as tiny spike- +| ringshadows. | like outpouchings, | | producing | | subtle | +| ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +spiculationoftheluminalcontourthat +| EnFaceMucosalDetail | should | not be mistaken | | for erosions. | | +| ------------------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Whenviewedenface,themucosalsur- In addition, the areae gastricae may +face either has a smooth appearance be enlarged by conditions that in- +(Fig 1) or is manifested as a reticular crease the size of the mucosal tufts +network of barium-filled grooves be- beyond their normal diameter of 2–3 +tween the areae gastricae (Fig 3). Dis- mm in the antrum and of 3–5 mm in +ruption of the normal areae gastricae the body and fundus. Enlarged areae +Figure5: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- pattern or the smooth mucosal surface gastricaehavebeenreportedinabout +tricbodywithpatientinsupinerightposterior ofthestomachbybarium-coatedlinesis 50% of patients with Helicobacter py- +obliquepositionshowsmultiplehyperplastic abnormal(Fig5). lori gastritis (Fig 7) (18). In contrast, +polypsondependent,orposterior,wallassmall small or even absent areae gastricae +("1cminsize),roundorovoid,finelylobulated have been reported in patients with +PatternApproachforDouble-Contrast +radiolucentfillingdefectsinbariumpool(arrows). severe atrophic gastritis and perni- +Diagnosis +Incontrast,polypsonnondependent,oranterior, ciousanemia(19). +wallarecoatedbybariumandappearaswhite H pylori is a curved or spiral-shaped, +lines(arrowheads).Bariumisseentofillinter- AbnormalMucosalPatterns gram-negative bacillus (20–22) that in- +sticesbetweenlobulesofsomepolyps. Striations.—Thin, barium-coated stria- fects the stomach in more than 50% of +tions perpendicular to the longitudinal Americans over 50 years of age and in +axis of the gastric antrum, also known nearly100%ofJapaneseadults(23,24). +as gastric “striae,” are sometimes seen H pylori most frequently involves the +Figure6 as a transient finding when the antrum gastric antrum (25). H pylori gastritis +is slightly collapsed (Fig 6) (17). These can be documented in almost all pa- +striaeareasignofchronicantralgastri- tientswithduodenalulcersandinabout +| tis(16). | 80%ofpatientswithgastriculcers(26). | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| Conspicuousorenlargedareaegas- | The mechanism | | by which | H | pylori | +tricae.—Visualizationoftheareaegas- causes ulceration is not fully under- +tricae in the stomach depends on the stood. H pylori gastritis is also a major +| | causative | factor | in the development | | of | +| ------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| Figure7 | bothgastriccarcinoma(27,28)andgas- | | | | | +triclymphoma(29,30). +Uniformnodules.—Innumerablesmall +| | (1–2 mm | in size), | round, | uniform | nod- | +| --- | --------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | +| | ules disrupting | | the normal | polygonal | | +| | areae gastricae | | pattern | are | usually | +| | caused | by lymphoid | hyperplasia | | of the | +stomachresultingfromchronicHpylori +| | gastritis | (Fig 8) | (31–33). | At birth, | no | +| --- | --------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +Figure6: Double-contrastspotimageofan- +| | lymphoid | tissue | is present | in the | stom- | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ----- | +trumwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsgastric Figure7: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +ach.WhenHpyloriinfectsthestomach, +striaeastransientfindingduetobariumfilling achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsenlarged +| | the organism | colonizes | | the | mucous | +| --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | +delicatetransversegroovesbetweenthinradiolu- areaegastricaeinpatientwithHpylorigastritis. +layerandattachestothemembranesof +centfoldstraversingcircumferenceofslightly Areaegastricaeinantrum(whitearrow)arelarger +| | the surface | epithelial | cells, | resulting | in | +| --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --------- | --- | +collapsedgastricantrum. thanthoseindistalgastricbody(blackarrow). +| | the development | | of chronic | | gastritis | +| --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | +36 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure8 Figure9 +| (22). Repeated | infections | may | eventu- | | | | +| -------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ally lead | to lymphocytic | infiltration | | of | | | +thestomach,followedbytheformation +| of lymphoid | aggregates | and | even true | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoidfollicles(34).Thus,whenlym- +| phoid hyperplasia | | is detected | on dou- | | | | +| ----------------- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ble-contrast | barium | studies, | these pa- | | | | +| tients are | almost | always found | to have | | | | +chronicHpylorigastritis(33). +| Nonuniform | nodules.—Irregular | | nod- | | | | +| ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +ulesdisruptingthesmoothmucosalsur- +| face or | the polygonal | areae | gastricae | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| pattern | of the stomach | may | be caused | | | | +byinflammation,metaplasia(alteration +Figure9: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- +| of one form | of epithelium | | to another), | Figure8: | Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | +tricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +| or malignant | tumor. | The | nodules are | tricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +positionshowsnonuniformnodulesdisrupting +| nonuniform | in size | and shape | and have | positionshowslymphoidhyperplasiawithinnu- | | | +| ---------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +normalsurfacepattern.Nodules(arrows)appear +| a patchy | or diffuse | distribution, | involv- | merableround,uniform,1–2-mmnodulescarpet- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +asroundorlobulated,confluentprotrusionsvary- +| ing a focal | or large | surface | area of the | ingmucosaandreplacingnormalpolygonalareae | | | +| ----------- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +ingfrom3–6-mminsize.Endoscopicbiopsy +| stomach | on barium | studies. | Nonuni- | gastricaepattern.ThispatienthadchronicHpylori | | | +| ------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +specimensrevealedlow-grade,B-cell,gastric +gastritis. +formmucosalnodularityisaworrisome MALTlymphomainpatientwithchronicHpylori +radiographicfindingforgastricmucosa- gastritis. +| associated | lymphoid | tissue | (MALT) | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoma(Fig9)or,rarely,superficial IIa (elevated), IIb (flat), or IIc (de- +spreadingcarcinoma(Fig10)(35). pressed)lesions(Fig10);andulcerated +| Gastric | lymphomas | usually | arise | EGCsthataremorethan5mmindepth | | | +| ------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +Figure10 +| from preexisting | MALT | in | the stomach | aretypeIIIlesions(42). | | | +| ---------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +associatedwithchronicHpylorigastri- +| tis. A lymphoid | response | to | chronic in- | DepressedLesions | | | +| --------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +fectionbyHpylorihasbeenpostulated Erosions.—Anerosionisafocalareaof +astheprecursormilieuforthedevelop- mucosalnecrosisconfinedtotheepithe- +ment of low-grade B-cell gastric MALT lium or lamina propria without extend- +lymphomas (36). These tumors are ing through the muscularis mucosae +sometimes recognized on double-con- into the submucosa (5). In contrast, +trast studies by the presence of innu- a true ulcer niche or crater extends +merable poorly defined, confluent mu- through the muscularis mucosae into +cosal nodules of varying size (Fig 9) the deeper layers of the gastric wall +(35). In such cases, endoscopic biopsy (4). The actual histologic depth of an +specimensarerequiredtoruleoutgas- ulcercannotbedeterminedonbarium +tricMALTlymphoma. studies.Instead,theradiographicsize Figure10: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricfunduswithpatientinsemiuprightposition +| Because | of mass | screening | of the | and depth | are used | to distinguish an | +| ------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -------- | ----------------- | +showssuperficialgastriccarcinomaasfocalarea +adult population in Japan, early gastric erosion from an ulcer. When viewed +ofslightlyelevated,irregularradiolucentnodules +cancers (EGCs) constitute as many as in profile, a depressed lesion greater +(arrows)inshallowbariumpool.Clubbed,irregu- +25%–46% of all gastric cancers de- than several millimeters in depth is +tected in that country (37,38). In con- arbitrarilycalledanulcer. larfolds(arrowheads)areseenradiatingtoward +centralareaofmucosalnodularity. +trast, EGCs constitute a much smaller Erosions are manifested on double- +percentage of gastric cancers detected contrast studies as tiny, 1–2 mm in +in the West, because endoscopy and depth collections of barium, usually in +bariumstudiesareperformedpredomi- the gastric antrum. Erosions may be turned from side to side, so a shallow +nantly in symptomatic patients who al- punctate, round, linear, or stellate in poolofbariumflowsoverthedependent +readyhaveadvancedlesions(39–41).In configurationandareoftensurrounded surface of the stomach (45). Erosions +the Japanese classification system for by radiolucent halos of edematous mu- aredefinedascompleteorvarioliformif +EGC, polypoid EGCs that protrude cosa (Fig 11) (43). Erosions are fre- surrounded by a radiolucent halo of +morethan5mmintothelumenaretype quently seen to reside on the crests of edema and as incomplete if there is no +I lesions; flat EGCs that appear as enlarged scalloped antral folds (44), surroundingedematousmound.Incom- +plaques,nodules,ortinyulcersaretype particularly when the patient is slowly plete erosions are much less common, +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 37 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +appearing as punctate or linear collec- the most common cause of gastric ero- eas of epithelial necrosis with hemor- +tions of barium that may be difficult to sions (46). NSAID exposure causes rhage,edema,andvasculardilatationin +differentiate from barium trapped be- breakdown of the mucosal barrier and the lamina propria (47). Because often +tweenareaegastricaeoralongsiderugal mucosal hypoxia, resulting in focal ar- thereisrelativelylittleinflammatoryre- +| folds. | | sponse, | the term | NSAID | gastropathy | | +| ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | +Aspirinandothernonsteroidalanti- rather than NSAID gastritis is favored +Figure13 +inflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs)arebyfar by some authors (10,48). NSAID-in- +ducederosivegastritisistypicallymani- +| Figure11 | | fested as | multiple | varioliform | | erosions | +| -------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +intheantrumorantrumandbodyofthe +stomach(18).Lessfrequently,thesepa- +| | | tients may | have | incomplete | | erosions | +| --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +thatappearaslinearorserpiginousbar- +iumcollections(Fig12),manyofwhich +| | | are located | on | or near | the greater | cur- | +| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | +vatureofthegastricbodysecondaryto +theeffectofgravity(49). +| | | Other | causes | of gastric | erosions | in- | +| --- | --- | --------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------ | -------- | +| | | clude alcohol, | | viral | infections, | Crohn | +| | | disease, | hemorrhagic | | gastropathy, | and | +| | | iatrogenic | trauma | (4,50–55). | | Surpris- | +| | | ingly, erosions | | are infrequently | | seen in | +patientswithHpylorigastritis(18). +| | Figure13: Double-contrastspotimageof | Ulcers.—An | | ulcer | is a | focal area | +| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinleftposterioroblique | of mucosal | disruption | | that | penetrates | +| Figure11: Double-contrastspotimageof | positionshowsgastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid | | | | | | +| | | through | the muscularis | | mucosae | into | +collectionofbariumonposteriorwall.Smooth, +distalgastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterior the deeper layers of the gastric wall. +straightfoldsradiatedirectlytoedgeofulcercra- +obliquepositionshowsNSAID-inducederosive Whenviewedenface,mostbenigngas- +ter.Thesearetypicalfindingsofabenigngastric +antralgastritis.Multiplevarioliformerosionsare tric ulcers on the dependent wall are +ulcer. +seenaspunctate(smallwhitearrow)andlinear manifested on double-contrast studies +(largewhitearrow)collectionsofbariumsur- +asasmoothroundorovoidcollectionof +roundedbyradiolucentmoundsofedema(black +| | | barium | filling the | ulcer | crater | (Fig 13). | +| --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | +arrows).Thispatientwastakingaspirin. +| | | Some shallow | | ulcers | on the | dependent | +| --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --------- | +| | Figure14 | wall and | ulcers | on the | nondependent | | +wallmaybemanifestedasacircularor +hemisphericringduetobariumcoating +| Figure12 | | the rim | of the | unfilled | ulcer | crater | +| -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------ | +(Fig14)(56).Mostulcersareroundor +ovoid,butsomemayhavealinear,ser- +| | | pentine, | rectangular, | | flame-shaped, | or | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | +rod-shapedconfiguration(56–58). +Whenviewedinprofile,benigngas- +triculcersmayberecognizedbyafocal +bariumcollectionorbarium-coatedline +| | | extending | outside | the | expected | luminal | +| --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | +contour(Fig4)(11,59–61).Someulcers +| | Figure14: Double-contrastspotimageof | have a smooth | | radiolucent | rim | of vari- | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | able thickness | | directly | adjacent | to the | +| | incompletelyfilledulcerondependent,orposte- | ulcer crater, | | representing | | a collar of | +| | rior,wallashemisphericringshadowwithtwo | edema and | inflammation, | | whereas | oth- | +| Figure12: Double-contrastspotimageof | crescent-shapedbarium-coatedlines(arrows) | | | | | | +| | | ers have | a thin | radiolucent | | line (also | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | coatingvariousportionsofinferiorrimofulcer. | | | | | | +| | | known | as a Hampton | | line) | traversing | +| positionshowsNSAID-inducedlinearandserpig- | Smooth,straightfoldsradiatealmosttoedgeof | | | | | | +thebaseofthecraterduetoundermin- +| inouserosions(arrows).Thispatientwastaking | ulcercrater.Thefindingsarecharacteristicofa | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --------- | +| | | ing of the | submucosa | | (59). | The pres- | +| aspirin.Surgicalclipsinrightupperquadrantare | benigngastriculcerwithretractionofadjacent | | | | | | +enceofaHamptonlineisdiagnosticofa +frompriorcholecystectomy. +gastricwall. +benigngastriculcer.Chronicinflamma- +| 38 | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure15 Figure16 +| tion and | scarring may | cause | retraction | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +oftheadjacentgastricwallwiththede- +velopmentofsmooth,straightfoldsthat +radiatedirectlytotheedgeoftheulcer +crater(Figs13,14). +| Although | giant gastric | ulcers | are | at | | | +| ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| greater | risk for bleeding | and | perfora- | | | | +| tion (62), | the size of | the ulcer | crater | is | | | +notausefulcriterionfordifferentiating +| benign | and malignant | gastric | ulcers. | | | | +| ----------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Most benign | gastric | ulcers are | located | | | | +onthelessercurvatureorposteriorwall +ofthestomachatornearthetransition +zonebetweenbody-andantral-typemu- +| cosa(Fig4).Somebenignulcersmaybe | | | | Figure15: | Double-contrastspotimageof | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------------------- | --- | +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +| located | on the greater | curvature | (al- | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +malignantgastriculcerduetolymphoma.Large +| most all | of these greater | curvature | ul- | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lobulesoftumor(arrows)surroundirregularcen- +cersarecausedbytheuseofaspirinor +tralulcer(U)filledwithbarium,althoughbarium +other NSAIDs) (14,63) or within hiatal Figure16: Listofradiographicfeaturesdistin- +poolistoodensetoclearlydelineatemarginsof +hernias, where the stomach traverses guishingbenignandmalignantgastriculcers. +ulcer. +| the diaphragm | (64). | Thus, | ulcer loca- | | | | +| ------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| tion also | is not a useful | criterion | for | | | | +differentiating benign and malignant nign radiographic appearance; virtually +gastric ulcers. Radiologists therefore all of these unequivocally benign ulcers +should ignore the size and location of are ultimately proved to be benign +Figure17 +| ulcerswhenassessingtheriskofmalig- | | | | (56,65). | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +nancy;instead,theyshouldfocusonthe Incontrast,ifanulcerisassociated +morphologicfeaturesoftheselesions. withnodularityoftheadjacentmucosa, +| In general, | malignant | gastric | ulcers | mass effect, | or radiating | folds that are | +| ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | -------------- | +produceradiographicfindingsdiametri- coarse,lobulated,orirregular(Figs10, +callyopposedtothoseofbenignulcers. 15), it fulfills the radiographic criteria +With malignant ulcers, the ulcer crater foramalignantgastriculcer,andendos- +represents a focal area of necrosis and copy should be performed for a defini- +excavation within a malignant tumor, tive diagnosis. Less than 5% of ulcers +usuallygastriccarcinomaorlymphoma. have an unequivocally malignant radio- +Thesurfaceoftheulcerandofthesur- graphicappearance;almostallofthese +roundingmucosaisthereforecomposed malignant-appearing ulcers are ulti- +| of nodules, | irregular | elevations, | or | matelyprovedtobemalignant. | | | +| ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | +irregular depressions of varying size Finally, one-fourth to one-third of +within the tumor (Fig 15) (42). The gastric ulcers have an equivocal or in- +folds adjoining a malignant ulcer may determinateappearancethatdoesnot +have a coarse, lobulated, clubbed, or allow the radiologist to establish a +penciledshapeduetoinfiltrationofthe confident diagnosis of benignancy or Figure17: Double-contrastspotimageof +foldsbythetumor(Fig10)(42). malignancy. An ulcer is classified as gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +Radiologists can often differentiate equivocalorindeterminateifthereare positionshowsulcer(U)onposteriorwallfilling +benign and malignant gastric ulcers on coarse areae gastricae or moderate withbarium.Smallradiolucentnodules(arrow- +the basis of the radiographic findings nodularity of the mucosa abutting the heads)areseenlateraltoulcerandlargernodules +(Fig 16). If an ulcer has a smooth sur- ulcer (Fig 17), a nodular ulcer collar, (arrows)areseenjustsuperiortoulcer.Thisnodu- +face with smooth, straight folds radiat- or mildly irregular folds radiating to laritycouldbesecondarytoedema,inflammation, +ing to the ulcer margin and no sur- theulcer’sedge.Insuchcases,endos- metaplasia,dysplasia,ortumor;findingsinthis +casedonotmeetradiographiccriteriaforabenign +rounding mass effect or mucosal nodu- copyandbiopsyareneededtoruleout +gastriculcer,andlesionshouldbeclassifiedas +larity (Figs 4, 13, 14), it fulfills the malignant tumor. Nevertheless, the +equivocal.Nevertheless,benigngastriculcerwas +radiographic criteria for a benign gas- majorityofequivocalorindeterminate +confirmedatendoscopyandfollow-up.Gastric +triculcer.Abouttwo-thirdsofallgastric ulcers are ultimately proved to be be- +metaplasiawasfoundattheedgeoftheulceron +| ulcers diagnosed | on double-contrast | | bar- | nign. | | | +| ---------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +endoscopicbiopsyspecimens. +ium studies have an unequivocally be- Some benign NSAID-induced greater +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 39 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +curvature ulcers may have an indeter- theadjacentgreatercurvature(66).De- Thesetinysacsarethoughttorepresent +minate appearance due to extensive spite a history of NSAID use, these thesequelaofhealedpepticulcers.Par- +surrounding mass effect and an appar- greater curvature ulcers therefore may tial antral diverticula are differentiated +ent intraluminal location because of requireendoscopytoruleoutanulcer- from true ulcers by their variable size +spasm and inflammatory retraction of ated gastric carcinoma. Eventually, and shape at fluoroscopy and the ab- +| | largeNSAID-inducedgreatercurvature | | | senceofassociatedinflammatorychanges. | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | ulcers may penetrate | inferiorly | via the | | | | | | +ProtrudedLesions +| Figure18 | gastrocolic ligament | into | the superior | | | | | | +| -------- | -------------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +borderofthetransversecolon,produc- Polyps.—A polyp is a small protrusion +ingagastrocolicfistula(67). fromthemucosalsurface,eithersessile +| | Diverticula.—Diverticula | | are un- | or pedunculated. | | The | term | polyp does | +| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +commonly found in the stomach. The notimplyanadenomatoushistology.In +majorityarisefromtheposteriorwallof fact,awidevarietyofbenignandmalig- +thegastricfundus(68),presumablybe- nant polypoid lesions may occur in the +causeofagapinthemuscularlayersof stomach. If polyps arise from the mu- +the gastric wall in this location. Fundal cosa,theymayhaveasmooth,nodular, +diverticula are smoothly contoured, orlobulatedsurfaceondouble-contrast +broad-mouthed outpouchings, ranging studies, and when viewed in profile, +from 1 to 10 cm in size (Fig 18). Rugal formacuteangleswiththeadjacentgas- +foldsarenotseenwithinthediverticula. tricwall(Fig5)(70).Incontrast,lesions +These diverticula can be distinguished arising from the submucosa or muscu- +from ulcers by their smooth contour, larispropriausuallyhaveaverysmooth +Figure18: Double-contrastspotimagewith +broad or shallow necks, and lack of surface and, when viewed in profile, +patientinrightdecubituspositionshowsgastric +foldsradiatingtotheirmargins. form right angles or slightly obtuse +diverticulumassmoothbarium-coatedoutpouch- +| | A variant | of a gastric | diverticulum | angles with | the | adjacent | gastric | wall | +| --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | +ing(arrow)extendingfromposteriorwalloffun- +dus.Asmallamountofbariumispresentinlumen mayrarelybefoundonthegreatercur- (Fig 19). Although large lesions that +ofdiverticulum. vatureofthedistalantrum,alsoknown have a smooth surface are usually sub- +as a partial antral diverticulum (69). mucosal in origin, it is often difficult to +| | | | | determine | whether | protruded | | lesions | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +lessthan1–1.5cmindiameteraremu- +Figure20 +| | | | | cosal or | submucosal | in | origin, | as small | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | +| | | | | polyps originating | | in | the mucosa | may | +Figure19 +alsohaveasmoothsurface. +Hyperplasticpolypsarenonneoplas- +| | | | | tic proliferations | | of | surface | foveolar | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --------- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | +| | | | | cells, consisting | | of elongated, | | distorted | +| | | | | pits and | numerous | | branching | glands | +| | | | | (4). These | polyps | are | typically | smooth | +| | | | | or finely | lobulated | sessile | lesions | less | +| | | | | than 1 cm | in size | (Fig | 5). Occasionally, | | +| | | | | however, | atypical | hyperplastic | | polyps | +| | | | | may be | larger | than 1 | cm in | diameter, | +pedunculated,andhaveacoarselylobu- +| | | | | lated surface | (Fig | 20) | (71–73). | At least | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------- | +| | | | | one-third | of patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| | | | | polyps have | multiple | | polyps, | usually in | +thegastricbodyandfundus(Fig5)(4). +| | Figure20: Double-contrastspotimageof | | | Although | hyperplastic | | polyps | have no | +| --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | | | malignantpotential,theyusuallyarisein | | | | | +Figure19: Double-contrastspotimageof 1-cminsize,sessile,slightlylobulatedpolypon thesettingofchronicgastritis,thesame +| fundusandupperbodyofstomachwithpatientin | greatercurvatureasareaofincreasedradiopacity | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +milieuthatresultsingastricmetaplasia +| semiuprightpositionshowslargesubmucosal | coatedbybarium(arrow).Althoughradiographic | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | -------- | +| | | | | and dysplasia. | | As a result, | gastric | ade- | +| massassmooth-surfacedhemisphericlesion | findingsareworrisomeforanadenomatouspolyp | | | | | | | | +| | | | | nomas and | carcinomas | | have | been re- | +| (largearrows)formingrightangles(smallarrows) | orevenasmallpolypoidcarcinoma,thislesion | | | | | | | | +| | | | | ported | to occur | with | increased | fre- | +| withadjacentluminalcontour.Surgeryrevealed | wasfoundtobealargehyperplasticpolyponen- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | quency | in patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| benigngastrointestinalstromaltumor. | doscopicbiopsyspecimens. | | | | | | | | +polyps(4). +| 40 | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure21 +Fundic gland polyps, the second in these patients. Atypical hyperplastic +mostcommongastricpolyps,areprolif- polypsthatareunusuallylargeorlobu- +erationsofthedeepepithelialcompart- lated(Fig20)areindistinguishablefrom +ment of body-type mucosa (4). These adenomatous polyps or even polypoid +polyps consist of cystically dilated pits carcinomas(71–73). +and glands lined by parietal and chief Retention polyps (juvenile polyps) +cells. Fundic gland polyps are found mayoccurassolitarylesionsorasmul- +both sporadically and in patients with tiple lesions in Cronkite-Canada syn- +familialadenomatouspolyposissyndrome. drome (76). Xanthelasmas, isolated +These polyps typically appear on dou- hamartomatous polyps, and inflamma- +ble-contrast studies as smooth-sur- toryfibroidpolypsareotherbenignpol- +faced,sessileprotrusionslessthan1cm yps occasionally encountered in the +in size. Fundic gland polyps are usually stomach. A focal cluster of polyps may +locatedinthefundusandupperbodyof also be seen in the gastric antrum or +thestomachandareoftenmultiple(74). body in patients with small carcinoid +In patients with familial adenomatous tumors. +polyposis syndrome, hundreds of small Masses.—For gastric masses larger +(" 5 mm in size) fundic gland polyps than 2 cm in size, barium studies are +Figure21: Double-contrastspotimageof +maybefound. extremelyhelpfulfordeterminingwhether +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +Adenomatouspolypsofthestomach thelesionsarisefromthemucosa,sub- +bariumoutliningoutercontourandintersticesofa +arearelativelyuncommonmacroscopic mucosa,ormuscularispropria,orwhether +3-cmsessile,multilobulatedlesion(arrows). +formofgastricdysplasia.Adenomasare they are extrinsic to the stomach. This +Surgeryrevealedtubulovillousadenoma.(Re- +classified as tubular, tubulovillous, or differentiationenablestheradiologistto +printed,withpermission,fromreference15.) +villous on the basis of their underlying suggest a specific diagnosis or differen- +architecture. Gastric adenomas may tial diagnosis. In general, a mass origi- +progresstogastriccarcinomabymeans nating in the mucosa has a nodular or +ofapolypoidadenomatocarcinomase- lobulatedsurface,appearingenfaceon +quence similar to that found in the co- double-contrast studies as a filling de- Figure22 +lon.Insitucarcinomaorinvasivecarci- fectinthebariumpoolorasanareaof +nomaisfoundinatleast50%ofadeno- abnormalbarium-coatedlines,depend- +matous polyps larger than 2 cm in size ingonwhetheritisonthedependentor +(75).Mostgastricdysplasias,however, nondependent walls (Fig 22) (11). Not +are relatively flat macroscopically. In infrequently, irregular collections of +fact,mostgastriccarcinomasarisefrom bariumaretrappedintheintersticesof +flat or slightly elevated or depressed thetumor(Fig21)orinareasofulcer- +areas of dysplasia, not polypoid adeno- ation. Barium thus outlines multiple +mas(4). roundorovoidnoduleswithintheinter- +Insymptomaticpatients,gastricad- sticesofthelesion.Forexample,apol- +enomas detected on double-contrast ypoidcarcinomamaybemanifestedasa +studies are usually larger than 1 cm in lobulated or fungating mass within the +size(75).Theseadenomascanbesessile, expectedluminalcontour(Fig22). +lobulated, or pedunculated lesions Incontrast,asubmucosalmassmay +Figure22: Double-contrastspotimageof +(Fig 21). Although most hyperplastic appearenfaceondouble-contraststud- +uppergastricbodywithpatientinsupineposition +polyps are smaller than 1 cm and most ies as a round or ovoid, well-circum- +showsmultilobulatedpolypoidmassasconfluent, +adenomasarelargerthan1cm,itisnot scribed, smooth or slightly lobulated +lobulatedradiolucentfillingdefects(blackarrows) +always possible to distinguish a hyper- area of increased radiopacity. When +inbariumpoolwithseparateportionoflesion +plastic polyp from an adenomatous viewed in profile, a submucosal mass outlinedinwhiteongreatercurvature(whitear- +polyp on barium studies. If a polyp is 1 maybemanifestedasahemisphericin- row).Surgeryrevealedpolypoidadenocarcinoma. +cm or larger in size and has a finely traluminalprojectionthathasasmooth +nodularorlobulatedsurface,endoscopy surface and forms right angles or +and biopsy therefore should be per- slightlyobliqueangleswiththeadjacent 23)(4).Anulceratedsubmucosalmass +formed to exclude the possibility of an gastricwall(Figs19,23).Centralulcer- viewed en face produces a characteris- +adenoma.Conversely,multiplerounded ationoccursinabout50%ofsubmuco- tic“target”or“bull’s-eye”lesion,witha +polyps 5 mm or smaller in size are al- sal masses due to central ischemia and central ulcer surrounded by a smooth, +most always hyperplastic, so that en- necrosis of the tumor or pressure ne- well-definedmass(Fig24).Gastrointes- +doscopy and biopsy are not warranted crosis of the overlying epithelium (Fig tinalstromaltumorsarebyfarthemost +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 41 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +commonsolitarysubmucosalmassesin shape at fluoroscopy (78) and has fat An extrinsic mass that indents but +the stomach (77). Lymphoma and soli- attenuation at computed tomography does not infiltrate the gastric serosa is +tarymetastasesareotherfrequentsub- (79,80). Granular cell tumors usually manifested as a smooth, broad-based +mucosal tumors. Lipoma is a submuco- appear as one or more small submuco- inbowingofthegastricwall(Fig26).In +sal lesion that may change in size and sallesions.Mostothermesenchymaltu- contrast, an extrinsic inflammatory or +mors (eg, neurofibromas) are indistin- neoplasticmassthatinvolvestheserosa +Figure23 guishable from gastrointestinal stromal of the stomach may cause tethering of +| tumors. | | the gastric | wall | toward | the | extrinsic | +| -------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | +| Ectopicpancreaticrest(ie,myoepi- | | process, | resulting | in | spiculation | of the | +thelial hamartoma) is an uncommon luminal contour. For example, omental +submucosallesioncomposedofvarying metastases invading the greater curva- +amounts of pancreatic tissue (including tureofthestomachthroughthegastro- +ducts, acini, and islet cells), hypertro- colic ligament may cause spiculation +phicsmoothmusclefibers,andglandular and tethering of the greater curvature +structures resembling Brunner glands (84).Extrinsicinflammatoryorneoplas- +(81,82). These lesions may be compli- tic processes that involve the gastric +catedbypancreatitis,cysts,isletcelltu- walloroccludegastriclymphaticorve- +mors, and even pancreatic carcinoma nous channels may also result in en- +(4). Ectopic pancreatic rests usually larged gastric folds. For example, pan- +appear on barium studies as small creatitissecondarilyinvolvingthestom- +(1–2cm),solitary,centrallyumbilicated ach may be manifested as thickened +| submucosal masses, | most often | on the foldsontheposteriorgastricwall. | | | | | +| ------------------ | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +greater curvature of the distal gastric Thepreciselocationofmasslesions +antrumwithin1–6cmfromthepylorus, in the stomach may help suggest the +but can occasionally be located else- diagnosisinasmallpercentageofcases. +Figure23: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows whereinthestomach(Fig25)(83). As previously discussed, a submucosal +4-cmsmooth-surfacedsubmucosalmassout- lesion on the greater curvature of the +linedinwhitebybarium(arrows).Notecentral distal gastric antrum should suggest an +Figure25 +triangular-shapedulcer(arrowheads)inmass. ectopicpancreaticrest,whereasasub- +Surgeryandclinicalfollow-uprevealedamalig- mucosal defect extending from the +nantgastrointestinalstromaltumor. lessercurvatureofthedistalantrumto +| | | the pylorus | should | suggest | | a hypertro- | +| --- | --- | -------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | phied antral-pyloric | | fold. | In | contrast, a | +| | | smooth, | undulating | submucosal | | lesion | +onthemedialaspectofthefundusnear +Figure24 +thegastriccardiashouldsuggestacon- +glomeratemassofgastricvarices(85). +Multiplicityoflesionsisanotherra- +| | | diographic | feature | that | may | be helpful | +| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | +| | | in suggesting | | a specific | diagnosis | or | +| | | differential | diagnosis. | | Numerous | small | +("1cminsize),smoothorfinelylobu- +lated,sessileprotrusionsarealmostal- +| | | ways hyperplastic | | polyps | (Fig | 5) or, if | +| --- | --- | ----------------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | confined | to the | gastric | body | or fundus, | +fundicglandpolyps.Aclusterofpolyps +| Figure25: Double-contrastspotimageof | | elsewhere | in | the stomach | | in patients | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | withchronicHpylorigastritismayrep- | | | | | +Figure24: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowssmooth,1-cmovoid,radiolucent resent gastric carcinoid tumors due +gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique fillingdefect(arrow)inbariumpoolwithshallow to end-stage neuroendocrine hyperpla- +positionshowsbull’s-eyeortargetlesioninstom- centralumbilicationcontainingtraceamountof +| | | sia associated | | with | hypogastrinemia | | +| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------------- | --- | +achasa2-cmovoid,smooth-surfaced,submuco- barium(arrowhead).Endoscopicbiopsyspeci- +| | | (5,10). | Multiple | large | (# 1 | cm in size) | +| --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | +salmass(blackarrows)inbariumpoolcontaining mensrevealedanectopicpancreaticrest(myoepi- +| | | polypoid | lesions | may | represent | adeno- | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | +stellatecentralulcer(whitearrow).Thispatient thelialhamartoma).Ectopicpancreaticrestsare +| | | matous | polyps, | atypical | hyperplastic | | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | +hadbreastcancerwithhematogenousmetastasis usuallylocatedongreatercurvatureofdistalan- +| | | polyps, | Peutz-Jeghers | | hamartomas, | or | +| --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +tothestomach. +trum,butthislesionwasonposteriorwall. +evensynchronouspolypoidcarcinomas. +42 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure26 +Finally, multiple submucosal masses or tal antrum to the pylorus or even +centrally ulcerated bull’s-eye lesions may throughthepylorusintothemedialfor- +representhematogenousmetastases(such nix of the base of the duodenal bulb +as metastatic melanoma), disseminated (Fig27)(92).Inmostpatients,ahyper- +lymphoma,and,inpatientswithacquired trophied antral-pyloric fold can be dif- +immunodeficiency syndrome, Kaposi sar- ferentiated from a neoplastic lesion by +coma. itscharacteristicappearanceandloca- +tion (93). Another clue to the pres- +ThickenedFolds enceofahypertrophiedantral-pyloric +Normal rugal folds are thicker in the fold is its variable size and shape at +proximal stomach, have a smooth con- fluoroscopy, with palpation and peri- +tour in profile, and taper distally (5). stalsis. Occasionally, however, a hy- Figure26: Double-contrastspotimageof +Foldsalsoarelargerandmoreundulat- pertrophied fold may be unusually gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +ingonthegreatercurvaturethanonthe large or lobulated, so it can be mis- positionshowssmoothindentationongreater +lesser curvature. Rugal folds become taken for a polypoid or plaquelike tu- curvature(blackarrows)duetoextrinsicmass +straightandthinnerwithincreasinggas- mor(93). lesioncompressingstomach.Secondbarium- +coatedline(whitearrows)indicatesthatlumenis +tric distention and can even disappear H pylori gastritis is by far the most +narrowedasymmetrically.Areaofincreasedra- +when the stomach is fully distended, common cause of focally or diffusely +diopacity(D)alsoresultsfrommasscompressing +particularly in the gastric antrum. Be- thickened folds in the stomach. Abnor- +lumen.Thesefindingswerecausedbymassive +causeofthesenormalvariationsinfold mal folds are found in about 75% of +retroperitoneallymphoma. +size, there are no reliable criteria for patients with H pylori gastritis (89). +enlarged folds in the stomach. How- Fold enlargement in H pylori gastritis +ever,rugalfoldsaremuchmorelikelyto mostcommonlyinvolvesthegastrican- +beabnormalwhentheyhaveanirregu- trum and body but may involve the en- +lar, lobulated, or scalloped contour or tirestomachormayevenbeconfinedto +Figure27 +when they are enlarged or have an an- thegastricfundus.MostpatientswithH +gledortransverseorientationinawell- pylori gastritis have mildly to moder- +distendedgastricantrum.Foldsthatare ately thickened gastric folds without +larger on the lesser curvature than on substantialfoldirregularity(Fig28),so +the greater curvature are also consid- that the radiographic findings are not +eredtobeabnormal. worrisome for Menetrier disease or +Becauserugalfoldsarecomposedof lymphoma. However, some patients +mucosa and submucosa, any process with H pylori gastritis have such en- +thatinfiltratestheselayersofthegastric larged,lobulatedfolds(ie,polypoidgas- +wall can increase the size of the folds. tritis)thattheradiographicfindingser- +Enlargedfoldsmaybecausedbyinflam- roneously suggest a malignant process. +matory processes such as H pylori gas- Other patients with H pylori gastritis +tritis (86–89), hyperplastic processes may have focally thickened polypoid +suchasZollinger-Ellisonsyndrome(90) folds confined to the gastric antrum or +and Menetrier disease (91), or malig- bodythataremistakenradiographically +nanttumorssuchaslymphomaandsub- for a polypoid or infiltrating neoplasm +mucosally infiltrating adenocarcinoma. (88). Nevertheless, radiologists cannot +Endoscopic biopsy specimens may be assume that all cases of enlarged folds +required to differentiate these various arecausedbythisubiquitouspathogen. +causes of enlarged folds, particularly Ifthefoldsaremarkedlyenlarged,lobu- +when the folds are markedly thickened lated, or irregular (particularly if they +andirregular. haveafocalorsegmentaldistribution), +Antralgastritis(whetherornotitis endoscopic biopsy specimens should Figure27: Double-contrastspotimageof +associatedwithHpylori)isusuallyman- beobtainedtoexcludeamalignanttu- gastricantrumwithpatientinsupineleftposterior +ifestedonbariumstudiesasthickened, mor. obliquepositionshowsovoid,1.5-cmsmooth- +scalloped folds that have a longitudinal In Menetrier disease, there is surfacedsubmucosallesion(arrows)extending +fromlessercurvatureofdistalantrumtoadjacent +ortransverseorientation.Antralgastri- marked hyperplasia of surface foveolar +pylorus.Thislesionchangedinsizeandshapeat +tis may lead to the development of a mucous cells (4,10), resulting in a +fluoroscopywithpalpationandperistalsis.Find- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold, seen marked increase in the height of the +ingsarecharacteristicofhypertrophiedantral- +as a smooth submucosal defect extend- foveolae and partial atrophy of the +pyloricfold. +ingfromthelessercurvatureofthedis- glands,withacorrespondinglossofvol- +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 43 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +umeofparietalandchiefcellandsubse- Although early reports stated that fold causesurfacefoveolarcellslinetheen- +quent hypochlorhydria. The rugal folds enlargement predominantly involved tirestomach. +mayappearmassivelyenlargedandlob- thegastricfundusandbody(sparingthe Portalhypertensionsometimesmay +ulated on barium studies (Fig 29) (91). antrum) (94), later reports found that cause mucosal hyperemia with dilated +Menetrier disease causes fold enlarge- submucosal vessels in the absence of +Figure28 +mentthroughoutthestomachinatleast truevarices,aconditionknownaspor- +50% of patients (91), presumably be- tal hypertensive gastropathy (95). This +gastropathycanleadtoacuteorchronic +| Figure30 | gastrointestinal | | bleeding. | Thickened, | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | +finelynodularfoldsareseeninthegas- +tricfundusonbariumstudies(96).Gas- +| | tric varices | with | associated | esophageal | | +| --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | +varicesareusuallycausedbyportalhy- +| | pertension, | whereas | isolated | | gastric | +| --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | +| | varices | (in the | absence | of esophageal | | +varices)maybecausedbyportalhyper- +| | tension | or, less | commonly, | by | splenic | +| --- | ---------------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | +| | vein obstruction | | from pancreatic | | carci- | +noma,pancreatitis,orpancreaticpseudo- +| | cysts (97,98). | | Gastric varices | | can be | +| --- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | +| | distinguished | from | the abnormal | | folds | +| | of portal | hypertensive | gastropathy | | by | +theirundulatingandtortuousconfigura- +Figure28: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- tion and smooth contour (Fig 30) (97). +achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsmoderately Figure30: Double-contrastspotimageof In some patients, varices may also be +thickenedfoldsingastricbodyduetochronicHpy- gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +seenondouble-contraststudiesasmul- +lori gastritis.Foldsareconsiderablylessthickened positionshowssmooth,undulatingsubmucosal +| | tiple smooth, | round | or ovoid | nodules, | | +| --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | +andlobulatedthaninpatientwithMenetrierdisease mass(arrows)onposteriorwalloffundusextend- +likenedtotheappearanceofabunchof +ingtocardia.Thispatienthadportalhypertension +(Fig29).Notesurgicalclipsfrompriorvagotomy. grapes.Inothers,however,aconglom- +| withaconglomeratemassofgastricvarices(also | erate mass | of | gastric | varices | (also | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +knownastumorousvarices).Notesurgicalclips +| | known | as tumorous | varices) | may | be | +| --- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | +fromrecentlivertransplantation. +manifestedasasmooth,undulatingsub- +Figure29 +mucosalmassonthemedialwallofthe +fundusnearthegastriccardia(85). +| | The | normal | gastric | cardia | is usu- | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | +Figure31 +| | ally manifested | | on double-contrast | | | +| --- | --------------- | ------------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | +| | studies | as a stellate | collection | of | thin, | +| | smooth | folds | radiating | to a | central | +pointatthegastroesophagealjunction +(Fig2).Anylesiondisruptingoroblit- +| | erating | the cardiac | rosette | with | asso- | +| --- | ------------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | +| | ciated nodularity, | | mass | effect, | ulcer- | +| | ation, or | distorted | folds | in this | region | +| | should | be considered | suspicious | | for | +carcinomaofthecardia(Fig31).More +| | advanced | tumors | at the | cardia | may | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | +appearaspolypoid,ulcerated,orinfil- +| | trating lesions | | that can | easily be | visu- | +| ------------------------------------ | --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----- | +| | alized with | a | double-contrast | | tech- | +| Figure31: Double-contrastspotimageof | nique(Fig31)(99–101). | | | | | +gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +Figure29: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowspolypoidmass(arrows)thathas GastricNarrowing +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows obliteratedandreplacednormalcardiacrosette. +Narrowingoftheluminalcontourofthe +markedlythickened,lobulatedfoldsanddiffuse Arrowheadsdenoteareasofulcerationwithintu- +stomachmaybecausedbyscarring,in- +distortionofareaegastricaepatterninpatientwith mor.Thispatienthadanadvancedcarcinomaof +| | filtrating | tumor, | or extrinsic | diseases | | +| --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | +Menetrierdisease. cardia. +secondarilyaffectingthestomach.Chronic +44 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure32 Figure33 +| scarring | from peptic | ulcer | disease | may | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| produce | asymmetric | inbowing | | and re- | | | | +| traction | of one | wall of | the stomach, | of- | | | | +| ten associated | | with | smooth, | straight | | | | +| folds that | radiate | to | the site | of the | | | | +healedulcer.Otherpatientswithpeptic +scarringhavesmooth,taperednarrow- +| ing of | the gastric | antrum | | or, less | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| commonly, | weblike | antral | narrowing | | | | | +| (Fig 32). | Scarring | from | ingestion | | of | | | +| NSAIDs | (ie, chronic | NSAID | | gastropa- | | | | +thy)canalsoresultinthecharacteristic +flatteningofthegreatercurvatureofthe +distalantrum(102). +Long-segmentnarrowingofthestom- Figure33: Double-contrastspotimageof +ach (either circumferential or confined gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +toonewall)ordiffusenarrowingofthe Figure32: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowslongsegmentofcircumferential +stomachisusuallycausedbyaninfiltrat- narrowingextendingfrommidgastricbodytomid +distalgastricantrumandduodenalbulbwithpa- +ingorscirrhousgastriccarcinoma(103) gastricantrum(arrowsdenotelimitsoftumor). +tientinleftposteriorobliquepositionshowsshort +or metastatic breast cancer. The nar- Althoughtumorsurfaceispredominantlysmooth, +segmentofsmooth,circumferentialnarrowing +focalareasofmucosalnodularityareseeninprox- +| rowingwithscirrhouscarcinomaresults | | | | | (arrow)duetoantralwebrelatedtoscarringfrom | | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +imalendoflesion(arrowheads).Thispatienthad +| fromadesmoplasticreactiontotumor | | | | | previouspepticulcerdisease.Ifmucosalnodular- | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +scirrhousgastriccarcinomaproducingalinitis +| cells infiltrating | | the submucosa, | | pro- | ityorirregularityofluminalcontourhadbeen | | | +| ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +plasticaappearance. +| ducing | a linitis | plastica | appearance. | | present,endoscopyandbiopsywouldhavebeen | | | +| ------------------ | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | ------ | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| Scirrhous | carcinomas | | may be | mani- | requiredtoruleoutfocalgastriccancer. | | | +| fested | as diffuse, | long-segment, | | or | | | | +| even short-segment | | narrowing | | of any | | | | +portionofthestomach(Fig33)(103). be caused by antral scarring from +Figure34 +The narrowed lumen is rigid and non- Crohndiseaseor,rarely,othergranu- +distensible at fluoroscopy, and gastric lomatousdiseasessuchassarcoidosis, +peristalsisisobliteratedinthisregion. syphilis, and tuberculosis. Occasion- +Theluminalcontourmayhaveasmooth, ally, antral narrowing may also result +nodular, or finely ulcerated surface on from gastric atrophy related to the +double-contrast studies (Fig 33). Occa- presenceofalong-standinggastrojeju- +sionally, scirrhous carcinomas of the nal anastomosis without an antrec- +| distal antrum | may | be | very short, | cir- | tomy. | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +cumferential lesions confined to the Atrophic gastritis is a condition in +prepyloricregionofthestomach(104). whichbody-typemucosalglandsarere- +It is important to recognize that en- placed by metaplastic cells resembling +doscopyandbiopsyhaveapoorsensi- pyloric- or intestinal-type epithelium +tivity in depicting scirrhous carcino- (10). Most atrophic gastritis is related +mas of the stomach, so that some pa- tochronicinflammationratherthanau- Figure34: Double-contrastspotimageof +tientswithradiographicallydiagnosed toimmune phenomena. This form of gastricfundusandbodywithpatientinright- +lesions may require one or more re- atrophic gastritis is often patchy and side-downpositionshowssmoothnarrowingof +peat endoscopic examinations to con- macroscopically flat, so that it is not fundusandbodyofstomachwithabsentrugal +foldsandsmall,barelyvisibleareaegastricae. +| firmthediagnosis. | | | | | recognizable | on barium studies. | In other | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | -------- | +Thesefindingsarecharacteristicofatrophic +| In contrast, | | the | narrowing | with | patients | with the autoimmune | form of | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ------------------- | ------- | +metastatic breast cancer results from atrophicgastritis,thereisseverelossof gastritis. +denseinfiltrationofthesubmucosaby parietal cell mass, resulting in inade- +tumor. Severe scarring from previous quate secretion of intrinsic factor with +causticingestionmaycausediffusean- thesubsequentdevelopmentofvitamin of gastric folds. More than 80% of pa- +tral narrowing indistinguishable from B12 deficiency and, eventually, perni- tients with pernicious anemia have a +antral carcinoma on barium studies, ciousanemia.Inthelaterstagesofauto- diffusely narrowed stomach with a +but the clinical history should suggest immuneatrophicgastritis,decreasedpari- smooth contour and decreased or ab- +the correct diagnosis. Tapered nar- etal cell mass is manifested as a dimin- sent rugal folds on double-contrast +rowingofthegastricantrummayalso ished mucosal surface volume and loss studies(Fig34). +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 45 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +References +| | | | | | 15.RubesinSE,LevineMS.Principlesforper- | | | | | gastritis | and primary | B-cell | gastric | lym- | +| -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------------------------------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | formingadoublecontrastuppergastroin- | | | | | phoma.Lancet1991;338:1175–1176. | | | | | +| 1.Freeny | PC. Double-contrast | | gastrography | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | testinal | examination. | Westbury, | | NY: E-Z- | | | | | | +ofthefundusandcardia:normallandmarks 30.ParsonnetJ,HansenS,RodriguezL,etal. +EM,2000;1–29. +and their pathologic changes. AJR Am J Helicobacter pylori infection and gastric +Roentgenol1979;133:481–487. 16.RubesinSE.Galleryofdoublecontrastter- lymphoma.NEnglJMed1994;330:1267– +| | | | | | minology. | Gastroenterol | | Clin North | Am | 1271. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2.HerlingerH,GrossmanR,LauferI,Kressel +1995;24:259–288. +HY,OchR.Thegastriccardiaindouble– 31.BahkYW,AhnJR,ChoiHJ.Lymphoidhy- +| contrast | study: | its dynamic | image. | AJR | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 17.Cho | KC, Gold | BM, Printz | DA. | Multiple | perplasiaofthestomachpresentingasum- | | | | | +AmJRoentgenol1980;135:21–29. +| | | | | | transversefoldsinthegastricantrum.Ra- | | | | | bilicatedpolypoidlesions.Radiology1971; | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3.TonerPG,CameronCHS.Thegastricmu- diology1987;164:339–341. 100:277–280. +cosa.In:WhiteheadR,ed.Gastrointestinal 18.Dheer S, Levine MS, Redfern RO, Metz 32.Sbeih F, Abdullach A, Sullican S, Meren- +and oesophageal pathology. 2nd ed. Edin- DC,RubesinSE,LauferI.Antralgastritis kowZ.Antralnodularity,gastriclymphoid +burgh, Scotland: Churchill Livingstone, radiographic findings in patients with and hyperplasia and Helicobacter pylori in +1995;15–32. without Helicobacter pylori. Br J Radiol adults. J Clin Gastroenterol 1996;22:227– +| | | | | | 2002;75:805–811. | | | | | 230. | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 4.Fenoglio-Preiser | | CM, | Noffsinger | AE, | | | | | | | | | | | +StemmermannGN,LantzPE,ListromMB. 19.LevineMS,PalmanCL,RubesinSE,Laufer 33.Torigian DA, Levine MS, Gill NS, et al. +| Gastrointestinal | | pathology: | an | atlas and | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | --------- | +| | | | | | I,HerlingerH.Atrophicgastritisinperni- | | | | | Lymphoid | hyperplasia | of | the stomach: | ra- | +| text. Philadelphia, | | Pa: | Lippincott-Raven, | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | ciousanemia:diagnosisbydoublecontrast | | | | | diographic | findings | in five | adult | patients. | +1999;153–236. radiography. Gastrointest Radiol 1989;14: AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:71–75. +215–219. +5.RubesinSE,FurthEE,LevineMS.Gastritis 34.GentaRM,HamnerHW.Thesignificance +from NSAIDs to Helicobacter pylori. Ab- 20.Warren JR. Unidentified curved bacilli on oflymphoidfolliclesintheinterpretationof +domImaging2005;30:142–159. gastricepitheliuminchronicactivegastri- gastricbiopsyspecimens.ArchPatholLab +| | | | | | tis.Lancet1983;1:1273–1275. | | | | | Med1994;118:740–743. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6.MackintoshCE,KreelL.Anatomyandra- +diologyoftheareaegastricae.Gut1977;18: 21.Marshall BJ, Warren JR. Unidentified 35.YooCC,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Gastric +855–864. curved bacilli in the stomach of patients mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissuelymphoma: +7.Seaman WB. The areae gastricae. AJR withgastritis.Lancet1984;1:1311–1315. radiographicfindingsinsixpatients.Radiology +1998;208:239–243. +| AmJRoentgenol1978;131:554. | | | | | 22.Yardley | JH, Hendrix | TR. | Gastritis, | gas- | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | tropathy,duodenitis,andassociatedulcer- | | | | | 36.Eidt S, Stolte | M. | Prevalence | of lymphoid | | +8.RubesinSE,HerlingerH.Theeffectofbar- +| | | | | | ative | lesions. In: | Yamada | Y, Alpers | DH, | folliclesandaggregatesinHelicobacterpy- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +iumsuspensionviscosityonthedelineation +| | | | | | LaineL,OwyangC,PowellDW,eds.Text- | | | | | lori gastritis | in | antral and | body | mucosa. | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | +| of areae | gastricae. | AJR | Am J | Roentgenol | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | bookofgastroenterology.3rded.Philadel- | | | | | JClinPathol1993;46:832–835. | | | | | +1986;146:35–38. +| | | | | | phia, | Pa: Lippincott | Williams | & | Wilkins, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +37.KanekoE,NakamuraT,UmedaN,Fugino +| 9.Charagundla | SR, | Levine | MS, Langlotz | CP, | 1999;1463–1499. | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +M,NiwaH.Outcomeofgastriccarcinoma +| Rubesin | SE, Laufer | I. Visualization | | of areae | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 23.DooleyCP,CohenH,FitzgibbonsPL,etal. | | | | | detectedbygastricmasssurveyinJapan. | | | | | +| gastricae | on double-contrast | | gastrointestinal | | | | | | | | | | | | +radiography: relationship to age of patients. PrevalenceofHelicobacterpyloriinfection Gut1977;18:626–630. +| | | | | | and | histologic | gastritis | in asymptomatic | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:61–63. 38.KaibaraN,KawaguchiH,NishidoiH,etal. +| | | | | | persons. | N Engl | J Med | 1989;321:1562– | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Significanceofmasssurveyforgastriccan- +| 10.AppelmanHD.Gastritis:terminology,eti- | | | | | 1566. | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | | | cer from | the standpoint | | of surgery. | Am J | +ology,andclinicopathologiccorrelations— +| | | | | | 24.Graham | DY, Go | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori: | Surg1981;142:543–545. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +anotherbiasedview.HumPathol1994;25: +currentstatus.Gastroenterology1993;105: +| 1006–1019. | | | | | | | | | | 39.Montesi | A, Graziani | | L, Pesaresi | A, | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +279–282. +| | | | | | | | | | | DeNigris | E, Bearzi | I, Ranaldi | R. | Radio- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +11.LauferI,KresselHY.Principlesofdouble- +| | | | | | 25.BayerdorfferE,LehnN,HatzR,etal.Dif- | | | | | logicdiagnosisofearlygastriccancerby | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +contrastdiagnosis.In:LevineMS,Rubesin +SE,LauferI,eds.Doublecontrastgastroin- ferenceinexpressionofHelicobacterpylori routine double-contrast examination. +| | | | | | gastritisinantrumandbody.Gastroenter- | | | | | GastrointestRadiol1982;7:205–215. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +testinalradiology.3rded.Philadelphia,Pa: +ology1992;102:1575–1582. +| Saunders,2000;8–46. | | | | | | | | | | 40.GoldRP,GreenPH,O’TooleKM,Seaman | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 26.Dixon | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori and | peptic | WB.Earlygastriccancer:radiographicex- | | | | | +12.LauferI.Asimplemethodforroutinedou- +| | | | | | ulceration: | histologic | aspects. | J | Gastroen- | perience.Radiology1984;152:283–290. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +blecontraststudyoftheuppergastrointes- +terolHepatol1991;6:125–130. +tinaltract.Radiology1975;117:513–518. 41.White RM, Levine MS, Enterline HT, +| | | | | | 27.Parsonnet | J, Friedman | | GD, Vandersteen | | LauferI.Earlygastriccancer:recentexpe- | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 13.Shirakabe | H, Kobayashi | | S, Maruyama | M. | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | DP,etal.Helicobacterpyloriinfectionand | | | | | rience.Radiology1985;155:25–27. | | | | | +| Principles | and application | | of double | con- | | | | | | | | | | | +theriskofgastriccarcinoma.NEnglJMed +trast radiography. In: Shirakabe H, Nish- 1991;325:1127–1131. 42.ShirakabeH,NishizawaM,MaruyamaM, +izawaM,MaruyamaS.Atlasofx-raydiag- KobayashiS.Definitionandclassificationof +nosis of early gastric cancer. 2nd ed. To- 28.HanssonLE,EngstrandL,NyrenO,etal. earlygastriccancer.In:ShirakabeH,Nish- +kyo,Japan:Igaku-Shoin,1982;19–43. Helicobacter pylori infection: independent izawaM,MaruyamaM,KobayashiS,eds. +| | | | | | risk indicator | of | gastric | adenocarcinoma. | | Atlasofx-raydiagnosisofearlygastriccan- | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | +| 14.Levine | MS, Rubesin | | SE, Herlinger | H, | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Gastroenterology1993;105:1098–1103. | | | | | cer. 2nd | ed. Tokyo, | Japan: | Igaku-Shoin, | | +| Laufer | I. Double | contrast | upper | gastroin- | | | | | | | | | | | +1982;1–18. +| testinal | examination: | technique | | and inter- | 29.WotherspoonAC,Ortiz-HidalgoC,Flaxon, | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pretation.Radiology1988;168:593–602. IsaccsonPG.Helicobacterpyloriassociated 43.LauferI,HamiltonJ,MullensJE.Demon- +| 46 | | | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +stration of superficial gastric erosions by WE, Goldsmith MR. Improved radio- 73.CherukuriR,LevineMS,FurthEE,Rubesin +doublecontrastradiography.Gastroenter- graphicdetectionofmultiplegastriculcers. SE, Laufer I. Giant hyperplastic polyps in +ology1975;68:387–391. AJRAmJRoentgenol1977;128:949–952. thestomach:radiographicfindingsinseven +patients.AJRAmJRoentgenol2000;175: +| 44.Op den | Orth | JO, Dekker | W. | Gastric | 58.BraverJM,PaulRE,PhilippsE,BloomS. | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1445–1448. +| erosions: | radiological | and | endoscopic | as- | Roentgendiagnosisoflinearulcers.Radiol- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pects.RadiolClin(Belg)1976;45:88–89. ogy1979;132:29–32. 74.HizawaK,IidaM,MatsumotoT,AoyagiK, +YaoT,FujisimaM.Naturalhistoryoffundic +| 45.KikuchiY,LevineMS,LauferI,Herlinger | | | | | 59.NelsonSW.Thediscoveryofgastriculcers | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +glandpolypswithoutfamilialadenomatous +| H.Valueofflowtechniquefordouble-con- | | | | | andthedifferentialdiagnosisbetweenbe- | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +coli:follow-upobservationsin31patients. +| trast | examination | of the | stomach. | AJR | nignancy | and malignancy. | | Radiol Clin | | | | | +| ----- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Radiology1993;189:429–432. +| AmJRoentgenol1986;147:1183–1184. | | | | | NorthAm1969;7:5–25. | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +75.OpdenOrthJO,DekkerW.Gastricadeno- +| 46.Lanza | FL, Nelson | RS, Rack | MF. | A con- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 60.Wolf | BS. Observations | on | roentgen fea- | mas.Radiology1981;141:289–293. | | | | +| trolled | endoscopic | study | comparing | the | | | | | | | | | +turesofbenignandmalignantulcers.Semin +toxiceffectsofsulindac,naproxen,aspirin, 76.DanielES,LudwigSL,LewinKJ,Ruprecht +Roentgenol1971;6:140–150. +and placebo on the gastric mucosa of RM, Rajacich GM, Schwabe AD. The +healthyvolunteers.JClinPharmacol1984; 61.OttDJ,GelfandDW,WuWC.Detectionof Cronkhite-Canadasyndrome:ananalysisof +24:89–95. gastriculcer:comparisonofsingleanddou- clinicalandpathologicfeaturesandtherapy +| | | | | | ble-contrastexamination.AJRAmJRoent- | | | | in55patients.Medicine1982;61:293–309. | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 47.LanzaFL.NSAIDSandthegastrointestinal | | | | | genol1982;139:93–97. | | | | | | | | +tract.AbdomImaging1997;22:1–4. 77.SusterS.Gastrointestinalstromaltumors. +| | | | | | 62.Barragry | TP, Blatchford | JW, | Allen MO. | SeminDiagnPathol1996;13:297–313. | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 48.Grace | E. Approach | to | the patient | with | | | | | | | | | +Giantgastriculcers:areviewof49cases. +grossgastrointestinalbleeding.In:Yamada 78.MaderalF,HunterF,FuselierG,Gonzales- +AnnSurg1986;203:255–259. +T,ed.Textbookofgastroenterology.Phila- Rogue P, Torres O. Gastric lipomas: an +delphia,Pa:LippincottWilliams&Wilkins, 63.KottlerRE,TuftRJ.Benigngreatercurva- update of clinical presentation, diagnosis +2003;698–723. ture gastric ulcer: the “sump ulcer.” Br J and treatment. Am J Gastroenterol 1984; +| | | | | | Radiol1981;54:651–654. | | | | 79:964–967. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +49.LevineMS,VerstandigA,LauferI.Serpiginous +gastric erosions caused by aspirin and other 64.Hocking BV, Alp MH, Grant AK. Gastric 79.Megibow AJ, Redmond PE, Bosniak MA, +nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. AJR ulcerationwithhiatushernia.MedJAust Horowitz L. Diagnosis of gastrointestinal +AmJRoentgenol1986;146:31–34. lipomasbyCT.AJRAmJRoentgenol1979; +1976;2:207–208. +133:743–745. +50.RobertsDM.Chronicgastritis,alcoholand +| | | | | | 65.Thompson | G, Somers | S, Stevenson | GW. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +non-ulcer dyspepsia. Gut 1972;13:768– 80.Imoto T, Nobe T, Koga M, Miyamoto Y, +| | | | | | Benign | gastric ulcer: | a reliable | radiologic | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 774. | | | | | | | | | NakataH.Computedtomographyofgastric | | | | +diagnosis?AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;141: +| | | | | | | | | | lipomas. | Gastrointest | Radiol | 1983;8:129– | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | +| 51.BalthazarEJ,MegibowAJ,HulnickDH.Cy- | | | | | 331–333. | | | | | | | | +131. +| tomegalovirus | | esophagitis | and gastritis | in | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 66.Zboralske | FF, Stargardter | | FL, Harel GS. | | | | | +AIDS. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1985;144: 81.Barbosa JJ, Dockerty MB, Waugh JM. +Profileroentgenographicfeaturesofbenign +1201–1204. greater curvature ulcers. Radiology 1978; Pancreaticheterotopia:areviewofthelit- +| | | | | | 127:63–67. | | | | eratureandreportof41authenticatedsur- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +52.Laufer I, Trueman T. Multiple superficial gicalcasesofwhich25wereclinicallysignif- +gastricerosionsduetoCrohn’sdiseaseof +| | | | | | 67.LevineMS,KellyMR,LauferI,RubesinSE, | | | | icant. | Surg Gynecol | Obstet | 1946;82:527– | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | +thestomach:radiologicandendoscopicdi- +| | | | | | Herlinger | H. Gastrocolic | fistulas: | the in- | 542. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +agnosis.BrJRadiol1976;49:726–728. +| | | | | | creasing | role of aspirin. | Radiology | 1993; | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | | 82.Lai EC, | Tompkins | RK. | Heterotopic | +| 53.Ariyama | J, Wehlin | L, | Lindstrom | CG, | 187:359–361. | | | | | | | | +pancreas:reviewofa26-yearexperience. +WenkertA,RobertsGM.Gastroduodenal +| | | | | | 68.Eisenberg | RL, Levine | MS. | Miscellaneous | AmJSurg1986;151:697–700. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +erosionsinCrohn’sdisease.Gastrointest +abnormalitiesofthestomach.In:GoreRM, +| Radiol1980;5:121–125. | | | | | | | | | 83.BesemannEF,AuerbachSH,WolfeWW. | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +LevineMS,eds.Textbookofgastrointesti- +Theimportanceofroentgenologicdiagnosis +54.Sloan JM. Acute haemorrahagic gastritis nal radiology. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders, ofaberrantpancreatictissueinthegastro- +| and | acute infective | gastritis: | | gastritis | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------------- | ------ | +| | | | | | 2000;659–681. | | | | intestinal | tract. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium | +| caused | by physical | agents | and | corro- | | | | | | | | | +TherNuclMed1969;107:71–76. +| sives—uraemic | | gastritis. | In: Whitehead | | 69.Treichel | J, Gerstenberg | | E, Palme G, | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +R, ed. Gastrointestinal and oesophageal KlemmT.Diagnosisofpartialgastricdiver- 84.RubesinSE,LevineMS,GlickSN.Gastric +ticula.Radiology1976;119:13–18. +pathology. 2nd ed. Edinburgh, Scotland: involvement by omental cakes: radio- +Churchill-Livingstone,1995;461–470. 70.Gordon R, Laufer I, Kressel HY. Gastric graphicfindings.GastrointestRadiol1986; +| | | | | | polypsfoundonroutinedouble-contrastex- | | | | 11:223–228. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +55.RumermanJ,RubesinSE,LevineMS,Long +aminationofthestomach.Radiology1980; +WB,LauferI.Gastriculcerationcausedby 85.CarucciLR,LevineMS,RubesinSE,Laufer +heaterprobecoagulation.GastrointestRa- 134:27–30. I. Tumorous gastric varices: radiographic +| diol1988;13:200–202. | | | | | | | | | findingsin10patients.Radiology1999;212: | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 71.Joffe | N, Antonioli | DA. Atypical | appear- | | | | | +861–865. +| 56.LevineMS,CreteurV,KresselHY,Laufer | | | | | ances | of benign hyperplastic | | polyps. AJR | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +I,HerlingerH.Benigngastriculcers:diag- AmJRoentgenol1978;131:147–152. 86.deLangeEE.Radiographicfeaturesofgas- +nosis and follow-up with double-contrast tritisusingthebiphasiccontrasttechnique. +72.SmithHJ,LeeEL.Largehyperplasticpol- +radiography.Radiology1987;164:9–13. CurrProblDiagnRadiol1987;16:273–308. +| | | | | | yps of | the stomach. | Gastrointest | Radiol | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +57.BloomSM,PaulREJR,MatsueH,Poplack 1983;8:19–23. 87.GelfandDW,OttDI,ChemMY.Radiologic +| Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | | | | | | | | 47 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +evaluationofgastritisandduodenitis.AJR in 40 patients. Radiology 1999;213:347– graphic diagnosis and clinical significance. +AmJRoentgenol1999;173:357–361. 351. Radiology1979;132:593–598. +| | | | | 94.ReeseDF,HodgsonJR,DockertyMB.Gi- | | | 99.Balthazar | EJ, | Goldfine | S, Davidian | NM. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | +88.SohnJ,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Helico- +bacter pylori gastritis: radiographic find- anthypertrophyofthegastricmucosa(Me- Carcinomaoftheesophagogastricjunction. +ings.Radiology1995;195:763–767. netrier’s disease): a correlation of the AmJGastroenterol1980;74:237–243. +| | | | | roentgenographic, | pathologic, | and clinical | 100.Freeny | PC, | Marks | WM. Adenocarcinoma | | +| --------- | ----------- | ----------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --------------- | ------------ | --------------------------------- | -------------------- | ----- | ------------------ | ------ | +| 89.Levine | MS, Rubesin | SE. The Helicobacter | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | findings. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium Ther | of | the gastroesophageal | | junction: | barium | +| pylori | revolution: | radiologic perspective. | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | NuclMed1962;88:619–626. | | | andCTexamination.AJRAmJRoentgenol | | | | | +Radiology1995;195:593–596. +1982;138:1077–1084. +| | | | | 95.Smart | HL, Triger DR. Clinical | features, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +90.Ellison EH, Wilson SD. The Zollinger- 101.LevineMS,LauferI,ThompsonJJ.Carci- +| | | | | pathophysiology, | and relevance | of portal | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ellisonsyndrome:re-appraisalandevalua- nomaofthegastriccardiainyoungpeople. +| | | | | hypertensive | gastropathy. | Endoscopy | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tion of 260 registered cases. Ann Surg AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;140:69–72. +1991;23:224–228. +1964;160:512–530. +| | | | | | | | 102.Laveran-Stieber | | RL, | Laufer I, Levine | MS. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | +96.ChangD,LevineMS,GinsbergGG,Rubesin +91.Olmsted WW, Cooper PH, Madewell JE. SE,LauferI.Portalhypertensivegastropathy: Greatercurvatureantralflattening:aradio- +| | | | | | | | logic | sign | of NSAID-related | gastropathy. | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------------- | ------------- | ----- | ---- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | +| InvolvementofthegastricantruminMen- | | | | radiographic | findings in eight | patients. AJR | | | | | | +AbdomImaging1994;19:295–297. +| etrier’s | disease. | AJR Am J Roentgenol | | AmJRoentgenol2000;175:1609–1612. | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1976;126:524–529. | | | | | | | 103.LevineMS,KongV,RubesinSE,LauferI, | | | | | +97.LevineMS,KieuK,RubesinSE,Herlinger +| | | | | | | | Herlinger | H. | Scirrhous | carcinoma | of the | +| ------------ | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------ | +| 92.Glick SN, | Cavanaugh | B, Teplick | SK. The | H,LauferI.Isolatedgastricvarices:splenic | | | | | | | | +stomachradiographicandendoscopicdiag- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold. AJR vein obstruction or portal hypertension? nosis.Radiology1990;175:151–154. +| AmJRoentgenol1985;145:547–549. | | | | GastrointestRadiol1990;15:188–192. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +104.BalthazarEJ,RosenbergH,DavidianMM. +93.AroraR,LevineMS,HarveyRT,LauferI, 98.MuhletalerC.GerlockJ,GoncharenkoV, Scirrhouscarcinomaofthepyloricchannel +Rubesin SE. Hypertrophied antral-pyloric AvantGR,FlexnerJM.Gastricvaricessec- anddistalgastricantrum.AJRAmJRoent- +foldreassessmentofradiographicfindings ondary to splenic vein occlusion: radio- genol1980;134:669–673. +| 48 | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | + +Radiology 2007 +This is your reprint order form or pro forma invoice +(Please keep a copy of this document for your records.) +Reprint order forms and purchase orders or prepayments must be received 72 hours after receipt of form either +by mail or by fax at 410-820-9765. It is the policy o f Cadmus Reprints to issue one invoice per order. +Please print clearly. +Author Name _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Title of Article _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Issue of Journal_______________________________ Reprint # _____________ Publication Date ________________ +Number of Pages_______________________________ KB # _____________ Symbol Radiology +Color in Article? Yes / No (Please Circle) +Please include the journal name and reprint number or manuscript number on your purchase order or other correspondence. +Order and Shipping Information +Reprint Costs +(Please see page 2 of 2 for reprint costs/fees.) +Shipping Address +(cannot ship to a P.O. Box) Please Print Clearly +Name ___________________________________________ +________ Number of reprints ordered $_________ +Institution _________________________________________ +________ Number of color reprints ordered $_________ Street ___________________________________________ +City ____________________ State _____ Zip ___________ +________ Number of covers ordered $_________ +Country ___________________________________________ +Subtotal $_________ +Quantity___________________ Fax ___________________ +Taxes $_________ Phone: Day _________________ Evening _______________ +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +(Add appropriate sales tax for Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the +District of Columbia or Canadian GST to the reprints if your order is to +Additional Shipping Address* +be shipped to these locations.) (cannot ship to a P.O. Box) +Name ___________________________________________ +First address included, add $32 for Institution _________________________________________ +Street ___________________________________________ +each additional shipping address $_________ +City ________________ State ______ Zip ___________ +Country _________________________________________ +TOTAL $_________ +Quantity __________________ Fax __________________ +Phone: Day ________________ Evening ______________ +E-mail Address ____________________________________ +* Add $32 for each additional shipping address +Payment and Credit Card Details Invoice or Credit Card Information +Enclosed: Personal Check ___________ Invoice Address Please Print Clearly +Please complete Invoice address as it appears on credit card statement +Credit Card Payment Details _________ +Name ____________________________________________ +Checks must be paid in U.S. dollars and drawn on a U.S. Bank. +Institution ________________________________________ +Credit Card: __ VISA __ Am. Exp. __ MasterCard Department _______________________________________ +Card Number __________________________________ Street ____________________________________________ +Expiration Date_________________________________ City ________________________ State _____ Zip _______ +Signature: _____________________________________ Country ___________________________________________ +Phone _____________________ Fax _________________ +Please send your order form and prepayment made payable to: +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +Cadmus Reprints +P.O. Box 751903 Cadmus will process credit cards and Cadmus Journal +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 Services will appear on the credit card statement. +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +If you don’t mail your order form, you may fax it to 410-820-9765 with +FEIN #:541274108 +your credit card information. +Signature __________________________________________ Date _______________________________________ +Signature is required. By signing this form, the author agrees to accept the responsibility for the payment of reprints and/or all charges +described in this document. +RB-9/22/06 +Page 1 of 2 + +Radiology 2007 +Black and White Reprint Prices Color Reprint Prices +Domestic (USA only) Domestic (USA only) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $213 $228 $260 $278 $295 $313 1-4 $218 $233 $343 $460 $579 $697 +5-8 $338 $373 $420 $453 $495 $530 5-8 $343 $388 $584 $825 $1,069 $1,311 +9-12 $450 $500 $575 $635 $693 $755 9-12 $471 $503 $828 $1,196 $1,563 $1,935 +13-16 $555 $623 $728 $805 $888 $965 13-16 $601 $633 $1,073 $1,562 $2,058 $2,547 +17-20 $673 $753 $883 $990 $1,085 $1,185 17-20 $738 $767 $1,319 $1,940 $2,550 $3,164 +21-24 $785 $880 $1,040 $1,165 $1,285 $1,413 21-24 $872 $899 $1,564 $2,308 $3,045 $3,790 +25-28 $895 $1,010 $1,208 $1,350 $1,498 $1,638 25-28 $1,004 $1,035 $1,820 $2,678 $3,545 $4,403 +29-32 $1,008 $1,143 $1,363 $1,525 $1,698 $1,865 29-32 $1,140 $1,173 $2,063 $3,048 $4,040 $5,028 +Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 +International (includes Canada and Mexico) International (includes Canada and Mexico)) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $263 $275 $330 $385 $430 $485 1-4 $268 $280 $412 $568 $715 $871 +5-8 $415 $443 $555 $650 $753 $850 5-8 $419 $457 $720 $1,022 $1,328 $1,633 +9-12 $563 $608 $773 $930 $1,070 $1,228 9-12 $583 $610 $1,025 $1,492 $1,941 $2,407 +13-16 $698 $760 $988 $1,185 $1,388 $1,585 13-16 $742 $770 $1,333 $1,943 $2,556 $3,167 +17-20 $848 $925 $1,203 $1,463 $1,705 $1,950 17-20 $913 $941 $1,641 $2,412 $3,169 $3,929 +21-24 $985 $1,080 $1,420 $1,725 $2,025 $2,325 21-24 $1,072 $1,100 $1,946 $2,867 $3,785 $4,703 +25-28 $1,135 $1,248 $1,640 $1,990 $2,350 $2,698 25-28 $1,246 $1,274 $2,254 $3,318 $4,398 $5,463 +29-32 $1,273 $1,403 $1,863 $2,265 $2,673 $3,075 29-32 $1,405 $1,433 $2,561 $3,788 $5,014 $6,237 +Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 +Tax Due +Minimum order is 50 copies. For orders larger than 500 copies, +please consult Cadmus Reprints at 800-407-9190. Residents of Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the District +of Columbia are required to add the appropriate sales tax to each +Reprint Cover reprint order. For orders shipped to Canada, please add 7% +Cover prices are listed above. The cover will include the Canadian GST unless exemption is claimed. +publication title, article title, and author name in black. +Ordering +Reprint order forms and purchase order or prepayment is +Shipping required to process your order. Please reference journal name +Shipping costs are included in the reprint prices. Domestic and reprint number or manuscript number on any +orders are shipped via UPS Ground service. Foreign orders are correspondence. You may use the reverse side of this form as a +shipped via a proof of delivery air service. proforma invoice. Please return your order form and +prepayment to: +Multiple Shipments +Cadmus Reprints +Orders can be shipped to more than one location. Please be +P.O. Box 751903 +aware that it will cost $32 for each additional location. +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 +Delivery +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +Your order will be shipped within 2 weeks of the journal print FEIN #:541274108 +date. Allow extra time for delivery. +Please direct all inquiries to: Reprint Order Forms +and purchase order +Rose A. Baynard or prepayments must +800-407-9190 (toll free number) be received 72 hours +410-819-3966 (direct number) after receipt of form. +410-820-9765 (FAX number) +baynardr@cadmus.com (e-mail) +Page 2 of 2 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k4/random_3.md b/q231/random_k4/random_3.md index 0c7ef2d487833615a392ae69c62e25551ee74322..5092924c1175d8a8e40e6138d07cac9f3c71498a 100644 --- a/q231/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q231/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,552 +1,1586 @@ -HEALTH INFORMATICS (HI) +Retrieval Augmented Visual Question Answering with Outside Knowledge +| | | WeizheLin | | | | | | BillByrne | | | | +| --- | ----------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | ------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | DepartmentofEngineering | | | | | DepartmentofEngineering | | | | | | +| | | UniversityofCambridge | | | | UniversityofCambridge | | | | | | +| | | UnitedKingdom | | | | | UnitedKingdom | | | | | +| | | wl356@cam.ac.uk | | | | bill.byrne@eng.cam.ac.uk | | | | | | +| | | Abstract | | | | UnlikeotherKB-VQAdatasets(e.g. | | | | FVQA(Wang | | +etal.,2017))whichprovideanassociatedknowl- +Outside-Knowledge Visual Question Answer- edgebase,OK-VQAencouragesusinganyoutside +ing(OK-VQA)isachallengingVQAtaskthat +knowledgeinansweringquestions. +requiresretrievalofexternalknowledgetoan- +2202 tcO 92 ]LC.sc[ 2v90830.0122:viXra +| swer | questions | about | images. | Recent | OK- | | | | | | | +| ---- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| VQA | systems | use Dense | Passage | | Retrieval | | | | | | | +(DPR) to retrieve documents from external Question : How many +knowledgebases,suchasWikipedia,butwith teeth does this animal use +| DPR | trained | separately | from | answer | genera- | | | | | to have? | | +| --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +Answer: 26 +| tion, introducing | | a potential | limit | on | the over- | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | ----- | ------ | +| all system | performance. | | Instead, | we | propose | | | | | | | +| a joint | training | scheme | which | includes | differ- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Figure 1: | OK-VQA | contains | questions | whose | answer | +| entiable | DPR | integrated | with | answer | genera- | | | | | | | +tion so that the system can be trained in an cannotbefoundwithintheimage. +| end-to-end | fashion. | Our | experiments | | show | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thatourschemeoutperformsrecentOK-VQA +Theneedtoadaptandrefreshknowledgesources +| systems | with | strong DPR | for | retrieval. | We | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +motivatesthestudyofKB-VQAsystemsthatcan +| also introduce | | new diagnostic | | metrics | to ana- | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | extractknowledgefrombothstructured(e.g. | | | | | Con- | +lyzehowretrievalandgenerationinteract.The +| | | | | | | ceptNet | (Speer | et al., 2017)) | | and unstructured | | +| ------ | --------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | +| strong | retrieval | ability | of our | model | signifi- | | | | | | | +cantly reduces the number of retrieved docu- knowledge representations (e.g. Wikipedia pas- +ments needed in training, yielding significant sages). Recentdesigns(Luoetal.,2021;Gaoetal., +benefitsinanswerqualityandcomputationre- 2022) approach VQA in two distinct steps: (1) +quiredfortraining. +| | | | | | | Knowledge | Retrieval | extracts | documents | | from a | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | +largeknowledgebase;(2)AnswerGenerationpro- +1 Introduction +| | | | | | | duces an | answer | from these | documents. | | Knowl- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +VisualQuestionAnswering(VQA)isachallenging edgeRetrievalcanbedoneviaDensePassageRe- +trieval(DPR)(Karpukhinetal.,2020),whichcon- +| problem | that lies | at the intersection | | | of Computer | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sistsofaquestionencoderandadocumentencoder +| Vision, Natural | | Language | Processing, | | and Infor- | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +mationRetrieval. TheobjectiveinVQAistoread (both Transformer-based) that encode questions +an image and provide an answer to an accompa- anddocumentsintoseparatedenserepresentations. +TheDPRsystemistrainedtoassignhigherscores +| nying question | | about the | image | content. | Current | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +approachestoVQAemploydeep-learning-based todocumentsintendedtobehelpfulinanswering +systemstojointlyunderstandimagesandtext. questions, so that document sets can be retrieved +andpassedtoAnswerGeneration. +| VQA is | particularly | challenging | | when | the an- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +swer to the question is not directly available in KnowledgeRetrievalbasedonDPRispowerful +theimage. InKnowledge-based VQA(KB-VQA), buthassomereadilyobservedlimitations,particu- +theVQAsystemmustaccessexternalknowledge larlyinmodeltraining. Firstly,whetheraretrieved +sourcestofindacorrectandcompleteanswer. The documentisusefulinansweringaquestioncannot +Ouside-KnowledgeVQAtask(OK-VQA)(Marino beeasilydetermined,evenifananswerisprovided. +etal.,2019)consistsofquestionsthatrequiresgen- Priorwork(Quetal.,2021;Luoetal.,2021)has +eral knowledge and simple inference to answer addressedthisproblemusing“PseudoRelevance +(Fig.1). Suchquestionsareevenhardforhumans. Labels” which are based on whether a document -HI 41095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Topics could include current or emerging issues -in health informatics. Topics will be announced in schedule of classes. -Offered irregularly as resources and opportunities permit. -Prerequisite: None. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +containsagivenanswer. However,theseareonly We find significantly better performance on OK- +a weak signal of potential relevance and may en- VQAcomparedtoRAG.Inthispaper: +| courage | DPR | to retrieve | misleading | | documents. | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | • We | present | a | novel | joint training | | frame- | +Secondly,thedocumentretrieverandanswergen- +| | | | | | | | work | Retrieval | Augmented | | Visual | Question | | +| --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | +| eratoraretrainedseparately. | | | Toensurethatthean- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Answering | | (RA-VQA) | | for Knowledge | | Re- | +swergeneratorseesrelevantdocumentsintraining, +trievalandAnswerGenerationthatimproves +systemscanretrievelargenumbersofdocuments +| | | | | | | | over | RAG | and | two-step | baseline | systems | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | --- | +(∼50+)(Gaoetal.,2022;Guietal.,2021),butat +basedonDPR(Karpukhinetal.,2020). +| the cost | of slower | training | and | more | GPU | usage, | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | • We | investigate | | visually | grounded | features | | +| and also | possibly | presenting | | misleading | material | | | | | | | | | +transformedinto‘languagespace’andassess +totheanswergenerator. +theircontributiontoOK-VQAperformance. +Jointtrainingoftheretrieverandanswergenera- +| | | | | | | | • We | study | the role | of | document | retrieval | in | +| ---------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --------- | ---- | +| toroffersasolutiontotheseproblems. | | | | | Theaimis | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | KB-VQA | | and evaluate | | its interaction | | with | +| twofold: | (1)toimprovetheretrievalofdocuments | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | retrieval-augmentedgeneration. | | | | Wealsoshow | | | +trulyrelevanttoprovidingagivenanswer;and(2) +thatretrievalbecomesmoreefficientinjoint +torejectdocumentswithpseudorelevancebutnot +| | | | | | | | training, | requiringretrievalofrelativelyfew | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +actualrelevance. +(∼ 5)documentsintraining. +RetrievalAugmentedGeneration(RAG)(Lewis +| | | | | | | | 2 RelatedWork | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +etal.,2020)hasshownthatend-to-endjointtrain- +| ing of | a DPR-based | QA | system | can | outperform | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Open-domain | | QA systems. | | These | QA systems | | +| baseline | two-step | systems. | A | notable | feature | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | are designed | to | answer | questions | from | datasets | | +RAGisalossfunctionthatincorporatesmarginal- +| | | | | | | | such as | Natural | Questions | | (Kwiatkowski | | et al., | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | +izedlikelihoodsoverretrieveddocumentssuchthat +| | | | | | | | 2019). Theknowledgeneededtoanswerquestions | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thetrainingscoreofadocumentisincreasedwhen- +canbeinpre-trainedmodels(Robertsetal.,2020), +everitimprovesprediction. +| | | | | | | | knowledge-graphs | | (KGs) | (Lin | et al., | 2019; | Feng | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ----- | ---- | +However,inpreliminaryOK-VQAexperiments +etal.,2020;Lvetal.,2020;Saffarietal.,2021)or +wefoundthatRAGdidnotperformwell. Ourin- document collections (Chen et al., 2017; Izacard +vestigationsfoundthatagoodportionofOK-VQA andGrave,2021;Guuetal.,2020;Leeetal.,2019; +| training | questions | are | answerable | in | closed-book | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Lewis et | al., 2020). | | In retrieval-based | | systems, | | +| form(i.e. | usingpre-trainedmodelssuchasT5(Raf- | | | | | | | | | | | | | +differentialretrievalcanbecombinedwithextrac- +fel et al., 2020)) with information extracted only tivequestionanswering,asinREALM(Guuetal., +fromtheimage,withtheunintendedconsequence +2020)andORQA(Leeetal.,2019),aswellaswith +thattheRAGlossfunctionawardscredittodocu- +| | | | | | | | generative | answer | generation, | | as in RAG | (Lewis | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | +| mentsthatdidnotactuallycontributetoanswering | | | | | | | etal.,2020). | | | | | | | +aquestion. Wealsofoundthatdifficultquestions VQA Systems. Modelling vision and language +| that are | unanswerable | | with the | knowledge | | avail- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | is central | to VQA. | Models | | can aggregate | | visual | +abletoretrievalweremoreprevalentinOK-VQA +andtextualfeaturesviacross-modalityfusion(Yu +thanintheOpenQAdatasets(e.g. NaturalQues- et al., 2018; Singh et al., 2019; Yu et al., 2019; +| tions (Kwiatkowski | | et | al., 2019)) | on | which | RAG | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Jiangetal.,2020;Guoetal.,2021). | | | | | Systemscan | | +| wasdeveloped. | | Inbothofthesescenarios,theRAG | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | also be pre-trained | | on | large | vision-and-language | | | +lossfunctionleadstocounter-intuitiveadjustments collections (Jia et al., 2021) and then fine-tuned +tothedocumentscoresusedintrainingtheretrieval forVQAtasks(TanandBansal,2019;Chenetal., +model,leadingtodecreasedVQAperformance. +2020;Ganetal.,2020;Lietal.,2020b;Wangetal., +Motivatedbythesefindings,weproposeanovel 2022;Zhangetal.,2021;Lietal.,2021)withVQA +neural-retrieval-in-the-loop framework for joint datasetssuchasVQA2.0(Antoletal.,2015). +trainingoftheretrieverandtheanswergenerator. Knowledge-basedVQASystems. KB-VQAcan +We formulate a loss function that avoids sending access both structured data, such as ConceptNet +misleading signals to the retrieval model in the andotherKGs(Narasimhanetal.,2018a;Garderes +presenceofirrelevantdocuments. Thisformalism et al., 2020; Li et al., 2020a; Wu et al., 2022; +combinesbothpseudorelevancelabelsandmodel Marinoetal.,2021),aswellasunstructureddata +predictions to refine document scores in training. suchasWikipediapassages(Wuetal.,2022;Gao -HI 41096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Research or individual investigation in areas not -covered in the existing curriculum for baccalaureate level students at or -above the junior level. In-progress (IP) mark permissible. -Prerequisite: Special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP +etal.,2022;Guietal.,2021). Avarietyofmulti- textattributesforeachvisualobject{a i,j }. Visual +modal approaches have been explored to access objectsandtheirattributesareextractedbyVinVL +external knowledge. ConceptBERT (Garderes atconfidencethresholds0.8and0.6,respectively. +etal.,2020)usesattentiontoaggregategraphnode Image captioning is performed to extract rela- +| embeddings | from ConceptNet. | KRISP | (Marino | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionshipsandinteractionsamongvisualelements +et al., 2021) uses a “symbolic knowledge mod- such as “a woman holding a knife cuts a cake”. +ule” to match ConceptNet KG entities with lan- Thepre-trainedcaptioningmodelOscar+(Zhang +guage/visualelementsinquestions. MAVEx(Wu et al., 2021) is applied to process visual features +et al., 2022) uses multiple information sources extractedfromtheVinVLmodeltogenerateacap- +(Google Images, Wikipedia sentences, and Con- tion for the image. To answer questions related +ceptNet)tovalidatepromisinganswercandidates. totextstringsinimages(e.g. “whichlanguageis +| VRR (Luo | et al., 2021) | uses Google | Search in a | | | | | +| -------- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thebookwrittenin?”),GoogleOCR(OpticalChar- +retriever-readerpipelinetoperformopen-endedan- acter Recognition) APIs are used to extract text +| swergeneration. | | | | stringsfromeachimage. | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +We also note unpublished contemporaneous Hence, a VQA training set {(I,q,S)}, where +work on OK-VQA at the time of submission. S isasetofanswerstoaquestionq aboutI, can +TRiG (Gao et al., 2022) shows that it is feasible be transformed into a text-only training set T = +totransformimagesintotextualfeaturesforVQA. {(x,S)} that we use for RA-VQA. The string x +The features used are similar to those presented contains all the text features extracted from the +here, although without an emphasis on the role image(thequestion,thetextualattributesforeach +of knowledge retrieval. PICa (Yang et al., 2022) identifiedvisualobject,thegeneratedcaption,and +‘prompts’ GPT-3 with descriptive captions gener- anyOCR’dtext),withspecialtokensmarkingthe +atedfromimages,andKAT(Guietal.,2021)ex- startandendofeachtypeoffeature(Fig.2). +ploitsanensembleofDPR,T5,andGPT-3toim- +3.2 Weakly-supervisedDensePassage +proveOK-VQAperformance. +Retrieval +| 3 Methodology | | | | Dense Passage | Retrieval | in RA-VQA consists | of | +| ------------- | ---------------------- | --------- | -------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------- | ------------------ | --- | +| | | | | a query | encoder F and | a document encoder | F , | +| | | | | | q | | d | +| We present | our RA-VQA | framework | that con- | | | | | +| | | | | bothasTransformer-likeencoders. | | Theaimisto | | +| sists of: | (1) Vision-to-Language | | Transformation | | | | | +retrieveK +documentsfromanexternalknowledge +(Sec.3.1);(2)Weakly-supervisedDensePassage +| | | | | database | Z = {z }Nd (e.g. | Wikipedia passages) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ------------------- | --- | +i i=1 +Retrieval(Sec.3.2);(3)JointTrainingofRetrieval +thatareexpectedtobeusefulforansweringaques- +andAnswerGeneration(Sec.3.3). +tion. DPRencodesquestionsanddocumentssepa- +| | | | | ratelyintodensefeaturevectorsF | | (x) ∈ Rh | and | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | -------- | --- | +| 3.1 Vision-to-LanguageTransformation | | | | | | q | | +| | | | | F (z) ∈ | Rh. Ascoringfunctionisusedtoretrieve | | | +d +| Prior work | has established | that | images can be | | | | | +| ---------- | --------------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +documentsforeachquestionastheinnerproduct +transformed into text such that large pre-trained betweentherepresentationsofxandz +| language-basedTransformers(e.g. | | | BERT(Devlin | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | +| etal.,2019),GPT-2(Radfordetal.,2019),andT5) | | | | | F(cid:62)(x)F | | | +| | | | | | r(x,z) = | d (z) | (1) | +q +canbeappliedtoVQAtasks(Luoetal.,2021;Yang +etal.,2022). Systemscanbebasedonstraightfor- RA-VQAtrainingaimstomaximizer(x,z)when +ward image caption, but we have found improve- documentz isrelevanttoansweringthequestion. +mentsbyintroducingadditionalvisually-grounded AsdiscussedinSec.1,therelevancebetweenqand +features. InRA-VQA,eachimageisrepresented z cannotbeeasilyobtainedand“pseudorelevance +by visual objects and their attributes, image cap- labels”serveasaproxy. Weuseapseudorelevance +tion,andanytextstringsdetectedwithintheimage. functionH(z,S)whichis1ifzcontainsananswer +WeuseanobjectdetectionmodelVinVL(Zhang inS (bystringmatch),and0otherwise. +et al., 2021) that was pre-trained on large object Foreachquestion-answerpair(x,S)oneposi- +detection datasets to extract visual elements and tivedocumentz+(x)isextractedfortraining. In- +theirattributes(e.g. colorandmaterial). batchnegativesamplingisused: alldocumentsin +z+(x) +Formally, for an image I we use VinVL to ex- a training batch other than are considered +tractasetofvisualobjects{o },alongwithasetof tobenegativefor(x,S)(Karpukhinetal.,2020). +i -HI 60401     HEALTH INFORMATICS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80401) This introductory course is a survey course -that acts as a foundation for all other courses in the Health Informatics -program. Basic concepts of Health Informatics are emphasized -throughout. The course targets students who at some point in their -career will oversee or have direct input on one of the highest expenditure -areas for health care organizations--the planning, selection, deployment -and management of electronic medical records (EMR), management -decision-support and tracking systems (DSS) and other health -information technologies (health IT). -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter + flash floods occur within six hours of a + What weather phenomenon +rain event, or after a dam or levee failure, and flash +most likely happened? floods can catch people unprepared. ... flood Prediction +| | | | | | | | | | | | er | | 4 | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | --------------------- | ------------------- | ----------------------- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | a man sitting on a bench in | | | the most common cause of flooding is | | | | | m | | | +| | | | a fl oo | d e d p a r k . < E O C | > | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | w a te r d u | e to r a i n a n | d / o r s n o w | m e l t t h a t a c | c u m u l a t e s | or | | | +| | | | | | | fa s te r t h | a n s o i l s c a | n a b s o r b it | o r r i v e r s c a | n ca r r y it | sf rain | | fl o o d | +| | | | < B O V | > w o o d b r o w n r | e d b e n c h | | | a w a y . < E O | K > | | n | | | +< S O V > l a r g e ta l l g re e n t re e < SOV> a ma x jo int +| | | | calm gray water white | | | these types of storm are hard to predict | | | | | Tr | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +probability +| | | | docked boat cloudy gray | | | ... flooding floods occur due to rain and other water | | | | | storm | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | | white sky ...... [OCR texts if | | | rising faster than the drains can handle. | | | | | | | | +1 Image-to-Text Transform +exists] +..... +| 2 Dense Passage Retrieval | | | | Backpropogation | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3Joint Training of +Trainable +Parameters +D o c u m e n t Q u e st io n M I P S Pseudo Relevance G ra d i e n t +| | E n | c o d e r | E | n co d e r | In | d e x | | | | | | | Ba c k p r o pogate | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | +Non-parametric +Knowledge +| Database | | | | | | | | Answers: flood, hurricane, rain | | | | | Transform | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +Figure 2: Model overview. (1) Using object detection/image captioning/Optical Character Recognition to trans- +formvisualsignalsintolanguagespace. (2)DensePassageRetrievalretrievesdocumentsthatareexpectedtobe +helpfulfromtheknowledgedatabase;(3)Trainingtheretrieverp andtheanswergeneratorp togetherusingour +| | | | | | | | θ | | | | φ | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +proposedRA-VQAloss. (4)Theanswerwithhighestjointprobabilityp (z |x)p (y |x,z )isselected. +| | | | | | | | | θ | i φ | i | i | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +DenotingthenegativedocumentsasN(x,S)and the generation target s∗ for each retrieved docu- +k +thescoreofthepositivedocumentasr+(x)leads ment instead of training all (x,z ) pairs towards +| | | | | (cid:98) | | | | | | | k | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +s∗. +| totheDPRlossL | | DPR | : | | | the | most | popular | human | response | | This | has | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | been | proved | | to improve | the | system | performance | | +| (cid:88) | | | exp(r | +(x)) | | | | | | | | | | +| − | log | | | (cid:98) | | (AppendixB.1). | | | | | | | | +(cid:88) +| | | exp(r +(x))+ | | exp(r | (x,z)) | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(cid:98) (cid:98) We identify two subsets of the retrieved docu- +(x,S)∈T +| | | | | | | ments | {z | }K | based | on pseudo | relevance | | labels | +| --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | z∈N(x,S) | | | | | k | | | | | | +k=1 +| | | | | | | (2) andmodelpredictions: | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3.3 RA-VQA:JointTrainingofDocument +| RetrievalandAnswerGeneration | | | | | | | P+(x,S) | | | s∗ | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | = | {k : y | = | ∧H(z | ,S) = | 1}; | +| | | | | | | | | | | k k | k | | | +(5) +Given a full query string x extracted from the P−(x,S) = {k : y (cid:54)= s∗ ∧H(z ,S) = 0}. +| | | | | | | | | | | k k | k | | | +| -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| image-question | | pair (I,q), | DPR | returns | the | K | | | | | | | | +highest scoring documents {z }K . The score P+ areindicesofpseudorelevantdocumentsthat +k k=1 +assigned by the document retriever p (·|x) to a also help the model generate popular answers +θ +whereasP− +| retrieveddocumentis | | | | | | | | identifiesdocumentsnotexpectedto | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | --- | ------- | --- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | benefit | | answer | generation. | | In joint | training, | we | +| | | | exp(r(x,z | k )) | | | | | | | | | | +p (z |x) = (cid:98) (3) intendtoincreasethescoresofdocumentsinP+ +θ k (cid:80)K +| | | | exp(r | (x,z | )) | | | | | | | | P−. | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | +| | | | j=1 | (cid:98) j | | while | decreasing | | the | scores | for those | in | z k | +willbeputintothenegativesetifitdoesnotcon- +| Open-ended | | answer | generation | for | each | re- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +trieveddocumentz isperformedwithagenerative tainanyanswer(H(z ,S) = 0)andthegeneration +| | | k | | | | | | | | k | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | s∗ | ).2 | | | | +model,suchasT5,withparametersφ: is incorrect (y (cid:54)= This is motivated by our +| | | | | | | | | | k | k | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intentiontoreducescoresforthosedocumentsthat +y k = argmaxp φ (y|x,z k ) (4) containnoanswersandfailtoanswerquestions. +y +Formally,jointtrainingofretrievalandanswer +| For each | document | | z k retrieved | for | a training | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | +| | | | | | | generationisachievedwithalossL | | | | | | RA−VQA | that | +item(x,S),wetraintheanswergeneratortopro- +| | | | | | | reflects | | both | model | predictions | and | pseudo | rele- | +| --------------------- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | +| ducetheanswerstrings∗ | | | fromtheconcatenation | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | k | | | vance: | | | | | | | | +| ofxandz | k (asshowninFig.2). | | | Weselectthemost | | | | | | | | | | +K +| popular1 | humanresponses∗ | | fromS | suchthats∗ | | is | | (cid:88) | (cid:0)(cid:88) | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --------------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------------- | ---- | -------- | ------ | ------- | +| | | | k | | | k | − | | logp | (s∗ | |x,z ) | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | φ | k k | | | +| containedinz | | ;inthecasethatz | | doesnotcontain | | | | | | | | | | +| | | k | | k | | | (x,S)∈T | | k=1 | | | | | +| anyanswer,themostpopularanswers∗ | | | | | | | | | | | | | (6) | +| | | | | | ∈ S isse- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | (cid:88) | | | (cid:88) | | (cid:1) | +| lecteds∗ | = s∗. | | | | | | + | logp | (z | |x)− | logp | (z |x) | | +| | | Throughthisdesign,wecustomize | | | | | | | θ | k | | θ k | | +k +| | | | | | | | k∈P+(x,S) | | | k∈P−(x,S) | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +1Thereare5annotatorsforeachOKVQAquestion.The +popularityofananswerismeasuredbythenumberofannota- 2NotethatinthiscaseH(z k ,S)=0alreadyimpliesthat +| | | | | | | | doesnotcontainanyanswerandthuss∗ | | | | | =s∗. | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +| torswhovotedforit. | | | | | | z | k | | | | | | | +k -HI 60402     LEGAL ISSUES IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80402) This course provides students with an -introduction to the fundamentals of law for Health Informatics and -Information Management. Components of learning will include general -legal principles and regulatory issues in the U.S. healthcare system. -Primary topics will include ethical issues, consideration of state laws -and the Federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act -(HIPAA), privacy and security rules. Through discussion board and writing -assignments, students will demonstrate understanding of practical -issues of health information access, its use and disclosure, and the -legal and regulatory consequences associated with breaches of health -information confidentiality and security. We will explore some of the -special legal issues with electronic health records (EHR) and health -information exchange; secondary uses of health information; compliance; -and related ethics issues. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +Thefirstterminthelossimprovesanswergener- highestscoresareretrievedusingthepre-computed +ationfromqueriesandretrieveddocuments,taken index. +together. The remaining terms affect document +4 Experiments +retrieval: thesecondtermencouragesretrievalof +documents that are not only pseudo relevant but 4.1 DatasetsandRA-VQAConfigurations +also lead to production of correct answers, while +OK-VQA (Marino et al., 2019) is currently the +the third term works to remove irrelevant items +largestknowledge-basedVQAdataset. Itconsists +fromthetoprankedretrieveddocuments. Thein- +of 14,031 images and 14,055 questions. These +questionsaresplitintoatrainingset(9,009ques- +Customized tions)andatestset(5046questions). Inaddition +Generation Targets +Answer to understanding images and questions, external +Retriever +Generator knowledgesourcesareneededtoanswerquestions. +Model Predictions As outside knowledge we use the knowledge +corpuscollectedbyLuoetal.(2021)fromGoogle +Pseudo Relevance Labels +Search. We use the corpus GS-full which con- +Figure 3: Information flow between the retriever and sistsof168,306documentscoveringtrainingand +theanswergenerator. +testquestions. InAppendixB.1wealsoreporton +GS-train, which contains documents relevant to +formationflowisdemonstratedinFig.3. Retrieval +OK-VQAtrainingsetquestionsonly. +and generation complement each other in train- +Pre-training: Westartwithpre-trainedversions +ing: pseudorelevancelabelsandmodelpredictions +of BERT-base and T5-large as the document re- +provide positive and negative signals to improve +trieverandtheanswergenerator,respectively. The +retrieval, and the improved retrieval leads to im- +retrieverwasrefinedbytrainingitonGS-fullun- +provedanswergenerationbytrainingtowardss∗, +k der the DPR loss (Equation 2) with pseudo rele- +a customized generation target for each retrieved +vance labels released by Luo et al. (2021). The +documentz . +k already strong retriever serves as a good starting +point for all DPR-based models presented in this +3.4 RA-VQAGeneration +paper(includingRA-VQAandourreplicationof +Givenanimagequery(I,q),afullqueryxiscre- +baselinesintheliterature). +ated(Sec.3.1)andanswergenerationsearchesfor +OK-VQA Fine-tuning: Our RA-VQA frame- +theanswerwiththehighestjointprobability: +worktrainstheanswergeneratorandtheretriever +jointlyunderEquation6. +{z }K = argmaxKp (z|x) +k k=1 θ We also report on variants of RA-VQA, to in- +z +(7) +y,z = argmaxp (y|x,z )p (z |x) vestigatethecontributionofvariousmodelcompo- +(cid:98) (cid:98) φ k θ k +y,z k nentstooverallperformance: +RA-VQA-NoDPRomitsretrievalentirelysothat +Answersreflectbothgenerationandretrievalmod- +answersaregeneratedbythefine-tunedT5alone. +els and retrieval confidence plays a strong role, +RA-VQAgenerationinEquation7simplifiesto +unlikesomepriorworksuchasLuoetal.(2021). +y = argmaxp (y|x) (8) +3.5 Pre-ComputedFAISSDocumentIndices (cid:98)NoDPR φ +y +Sincerepeatedcomputationofembeddingsforall RA-VQA-FrDPRleavestheretrieverfrozenafter +documentsiscostly,wefollow Lewisetal.(2020) pre-trainingandfine-tunesthegeneratoronly. +who find that it is enough to train only the ques- RA-VQA-NoPRisaversionofRA-VQAinwhich +tion encoder F and leave document encoder F documentretrievalistrainedonlywithmodelpre- +q d +fixed. AsshowninFig.2,documentembeddings dictions. The loss function is as Equation 6, but +arepre-extractedwithapre-trainedDPRdocument withpositiveandnegativedocumentsetsdefined +encoder. TheFAISSsystem(Johnsonetal.,2019) as P+ (x,S) = {k : y = s∗}; +isusedtoindexalldocumentembeddingswhichen- NoPR k k (9) +P− (x,S) = {k : y (cid:54)= s∗}. +ablesfastnearestneighboursearchwithsub-linear NoPR k k +timecomplexity. Intraining,questionembeddings RA-VQA-NoCTreplacesthecustomizedgenera- +are generated dynamically and documents with tion targets by the single most popular response -Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           1 +| (s∗ becomess∗ | | | | | | | 1(cid:8) | | | | | (cid:9) | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +inEquation6)sothatthegenerator FSR = y (cid:98) ∈ S ∧y (cid:98)NoDPR ∈ S . (13) +k +istrainedtoproducethesameanswerfromevery +| | | | | | | A high FSR | suggests | | a model | | can generate | cor- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | +retrieveddocument. +| | | | | | | rect answers | ‘freely’ | | without | being | distracted | by | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +retrieveddocumentsiftheyarenotneeded. +4.2 Evaluation +Wealsoassessperformanceasafunctionofthe +| The following | | metrics | are applied | to | assess the | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +numberofdocumentsretrievedduringtrainingand +qualityofindividualanswersgeneratedanddocu- +| | | | | | | testing,K | | andK | . Inpractice,K | | | hasthe | +| --------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | ----- | ---- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | train | | test | | | train | +| mentsretrieved. | | Averagescoresarethencomputed | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | greatereffectonGPUusage,sincealargeK | | | | | | train re- | +| overtheevaluationset. | | | Theaverageof3runswith | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | quiresatleastK | | | forwardpassesforeachques- | | | | +train +differentseedsisreported. +| | | | | | | tion and | an Adam-like | | optimizer | | must | compute | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------- | +4.2.1 AnswerEvaluation andstoretheassociatedgradients(KingmaandBa, +2015). Incontrast,GPUmemoryrequiredduring +| VQA Score: | We | follow | Marino | et | al. (2019) to | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +testingissignificantlyless,asthereisnooptimizer +computeVQAScoresusingpre-processedhuman +| | | | | | | involved. | Weareinparticularinterestedintheabil- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +annotationsS: +| | | | | | | ity of knowledge-augmented | | | | systems | | that can be | +| --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | (cid:0)# | (y) | (cid:1) | | | | | | | | +VQAScore(y,S) = min S ,1 , (10) robustly trained with small K while yielding +train +3 +| | | | | | | improvedperformancewithlargeK | | | | | | . | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +test +| where # | S (y) | is the | number | of annotators | who | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +answered y. This score ensures that a model is 4.3 BaselineSystems +| partially | rewarded | even | if it generates | | one of the | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4.3.1 RetrievalAugmentedGeneration +lesspopularanswersfromamongstthehumanre- +RAG(Lewisetal.,2020)isbasedonDPRandan +sponses. +answergeneratorthataretrainedjointlybyapprox- +| Exact | Match | (EM) | treats | annotated | answers | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +imatelymarginalizingtheprobabilityofy +overthe +| equally: | EM(y,S) | = | min(# | (y),1). | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | S | | | retrieveddocuments. | | | InthenotationofSec.3: | | | | +| 4.2.2 RetrievalEvaluation | | | | | | | | K | | | | | +(cid:88) +| | | | | | | p (y|x) | ≈ | | p (y|x,z | )p | (z |x) | (14) | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | ---------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --------- | +| Following | Luo | et al. | (2021), we | use | pseudo rele- | RAG | | | φ | k | θ k | | +| vancetoascertainwhethertheretrieveddocuments | | | | | | | | k=1 | | | | | +| | | | | | | The answer | | generator | and | the | retriever | are | +| are relevant | to | the response. | | It concerns | pseudo | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | jointly | trained | by | optimizing | | the | RAG loss: | +| | | | | | | | | (cid:0) | | (cid:1) | | | +relevanceinsteadofactualrelevancebutisstilla − (cid:80) log p (s∗|x) . The rationale is +| | | | | | | (x,S)∈T | | RAG | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +reasonablemetricforretrievalevaluation. +| | | | | | | thatp (z | |x)willincreaseifz | | | | hasapositiveim- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | θ | k | | | k | | | +PseudoRelevanceRecall(PRRecall)@Kmea- +| | | | | | | pactonanswergeneration(Lewisetal.,2020). | | | | | | We | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sures how likely the retrieved K documents con- consider RAG as an important baseline and have +tainsatleastonepositivedocument: +carefullyreplicateditspublishedimplementation3. +K +| | | | (cid:0)(cid:88) | | (cid:1) | 4.3.2 BaselineSystemsintheLiterature | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | ----- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| PRRecall@K | | = min | H(z | ,S),1 | . (11) | | | | | | | | +k +WecompareagainstthepublishedOK-VQAresults +k=1 +| | | | | | | fromsystemsdescribedinSec.2: | | | | | ConceptBERT, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +4.2.3 IntegratedSystemEvaluation +| | | | | | | KRISP, | MAVEx, | and | VRR. | We | also | report per- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | ----------- | +Theabovemethodsevaluateretrievalandanswer +formanceagainstunpublished(nonpeer-reviewed) +generationasseparateprocesses. Weproposead- systems TRiG4, PICa, and KAT. TRiG uses a +ditionalmetricsthatassesshowthetwoprocesses similarimage-to-texttransformasthiswork,soto +behaveinanintegratedVQAsystem. +enablefaircomparisonwithourmodelwereplicate +TheHitSuccessRatio(HSR)countsquestions theirknowledgefusingmethodwithourfeatures. +thatrequireexternalknowledgetoanswer: Baseline results are reported in Table 1; baseline +1(cid:8) (cid:9) results marked * are our own. TRiG*, our own +| HSR | = | y ∈ S | ∧y | ∈/ | S . (12) | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | (cid:98) | (cid:98)NoDPR | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | implementationofTRiG,concatenatesK | | | | | | encoder | +outputsforthedecodertouseingeneration. +| HSR reflects | the | value | of incorporating | | external | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +documentsintoanswergeneration. We make some particular observations. Our +By contrast, Free Success Rate (FSR) counts TRiG* improves over the results released in its +questions that can be answered without external 3TheauthorsreleasedRAGinhuggingface. +knowledge. +4Atthetimeofsubmission,TRiGhasnotbeenpublished. -HI 60403     HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80403) Introduction to information systems and their -applications in healthcare used for managerial and clinical support. -Study the fundamentals of information systems, including Electronic -Medical Records (EMR), information security. Understand the role of -standardized codes, vocabularies and terminologies used in health -information systems. Analysis of management and enterprise systems, -identify the key elements to manage information resources effectively -and the trends affecting the development of health information systems -and networks. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +| Model | | T5 | GPT-3 K | K | Knowl.Src. | | PRRecall | HSR/FSR | | H/F | EM | VQA | +| ------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----- | +| | | | train | test | | | | | | | | | +| ConceptBERT | | × | × - | - | C | | | | | | | 33.66 | +| KRISP | | × | × - | - | C+W | | | | | | | 38.35 | +| VRR | | × | × 100 | 100 | GS | | | | | | | 45.08 | +| MAVEx | | × | × - | - | W+C+GI | | | | | | | 39.40 | +| KAT-T5 | | (cid:88) | × 40 | 40 | W | | | | | | | 44.25 | +| TRiG | | (cid:88) | × 5 | 5 | W | | | | | | 49.21 | 45.51 | +| TRiG | | (cid:88) | × 100 | 100 | W | | | | | | 53.59 | 49.35 | +| TRiG-Ensemble | | (cid:88) | × 100 | 100 | W | | | | | | 54.73 | 50.50 | +| TRiG* | | (cid:88) | × 5 | 5 | GS | | | | | | 52.79 | 48.32 | +| RAG* | | (cid:88) | × 5 | 5 | GS | | 82.34 | 12.28/40.24 | | 0.31 | 52.52 | 48.22 | +RA-VQA(Ours) (cid:88) × 5 5 GS 82.84 16.75/41.97 0.40 58.72 53.81 +RA-VQA(Ours) (cid:88) × 5 50 GS 96.55 17.32/42.09 0.41 59.41 54.48 +AblationStudy +RA-VQA-FrDPR (cid:88) × 5 5 GS 81.25 15.01/40.76 0.37 55.77 51.22 +RA-VQA-NoPR (cid:88) × 5 5 GS 77.67 15.97/41.83 0.38 57.80 52.98 +RA-VQA-NoCT (cid:88) × 5 5 GS 83.77 14.55/42.96 0.33 57.51 52.67 +GPT-3-basedSystems(>175BillionParameters) +| PICa | | × | (cid:88) - | - | GPT-3 | | | | | | | 48.00 | +| ---------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +| KAT-Knowledge-T5 | | (cid:88) | (cid:88) 40 | 40 | W+GPT-3 | | | | | | | 51.97 | +| KAT-Ensemble | | (cid:88) | (cid:88) 40 | 40 | W+GPT-3 | | | | | | | 54.41 | +Table1: RA-VQAvs. BaselineSystems. KnowledgeSources: ConceptNet;Wikipedia;GoogleSearch;Google +Images; GPT-3closedbookknowledge. H/F: HSRtoFSRratio. PRRecall, HSR,FSR,andEMarereportedin +| percentage(%). | PRRecallisreportedatthecorrespondingK | | | | | test | . | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +paper(VQAScoreof48.32vs45.51)atK = intraining(5). Wefindthatreducingthenumber +train +K = 5; TRiG and TRiG Ensemble both bene- ofretrieveddocumentsintest(K = 5)reduces +| test | | | | | | | | | | | test | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +fitfrommoreretrieveddocumentsintrainingand theVQAScore,butstillyieldsperformancebetter +testing (K = K = 100), although at great thanallbaselinesexcepttheKATensemble. +train test +computationalcost. BestperformancewithKAT- WealsofindthatRA-VQAperformswellrela- +T5 and VRR similarly requires large document tivetoGPT-3baselines. RA-VQAyieldsahigher +collectionsintrainingandintest. VQA score than KAT-Knowledge-T5 (54.48 vs. +We include results from GPT-3 based systems 51.97)andmatchestheKAT-Ensemblesystem. We +| | | | | | | emphasize | that | RA-VQA | | is significantly | | smaller | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | +becausetheyareamongstthebestintheliterature, +but we note that GPT-3 is so much bigger than intermsofparameters(andinmodelpre-training +T5(175billionparametersinGPT-3v.s. 770mil- data) than these GPT-3 based systems and that +lion in T5-large) that simply switching a system training RA-VQA requires much less memory +| | | | | | | (K | = 5vsK | | = 40). | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| implementation | | from T5 | to GPT-3 | can give | sig- | | train | train | | | | | +| nificantimprovements: | | KAT-T5achieveda44.25 | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 4.4.1 | ContributionsofQueryFeaturesand | | | | | | +VQAScorewhileensemblingitwithGPT-3yields +DPRtoOverallPerformance +54.41;andGPT-3alonealreadyachievedgoodper- +formancewithprompting(PICawith48.00VQA +| | | | | | | Model | | | Q O | A | C T | VQAScore | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +Score). OurRA-VQAsystemisbasedonT5,but +(cid:88) +| | | | | | | RA-VQA-NoDPR | | | × | × | × × | 28.05 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +westillfindcompetitiveresultsevenincomparison (cid:88) (cid:88) +| | | | | | | RA-VQA-NoDPR | | | | × | × × | 40.95 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | | | (cid:88) (cid:88) | (cid:88) | | | +tosystemsincorporatingGPT-3(54.48vs54.41of RA-VQA-NoDPR × × 42.14 +| | | | | | | | | | (cid:88) (cid:88) | (cid:88) | (cid:88) | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ----------------- | ----- | +| KAT-Ensemble). | | | | | | RA-VQA-NoDPR | | | | | × | 45.31 | +| | | | | | | | | | (cid:88) (cid:88) | (cid:88) | (cid:88) (cid:88) | | +| | | | | | | RA-VQA-NoDPR | | | | | | 46.16 | +| | | | | | | | | | (cid:88) (cid:88) | (cid:88) | (cid:88) (cid:88) | | +| | | | | | | RA-VQA-FrDPR | | | | | | 51.22 | +| | | | | | | | | | (cid:88) (cid:88) | (cid:88) | (cid:88) (cid:88) | | +| 4.4 RA-VQAPerformanceAnalysis | | | | | | RA-VQA | | | | | | 53.81 | +WefindthatRA-VQAmatchesorimprovesoverall Table 2: Ablation study on input features and system +baselinesystemswithaVQAScoreof54.48. This configurations: Questions; Objects; Attributes associ- +is with a configuration of K = 5 and K = ated with objects; Captions; visible Text from OCR. +| | | | train | | test | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +K =5inRA-VQAandRA-VQA-FrDPR. +50,thusvalidatingourclaimthatRA-VQAcanuse +a large number of retrieved documents in testing A detailed ablation study on input features is +(50)whileusingrelativelyfewretrieveddocuments presented in Table 2. As shown, the T5 model -HI 60410     HEALTH RECORDS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80410) This course examines Health Information -Management, the role of the HIM professional in the context of the -health system and the role of the health record. The role of information -management and documentation principles is essential to the successful -application of technology and ensuring an effective health information -infrastructure. The course discusses confidentiality, privacy, security, -reliable standards, data integrity, quality, governance, and ethical -principles that make health care information of use for organizations and -individuals. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +fine-tuned on OK-VQA achieves a 28.05 VQA eration. In comparing RA-VQA-FrDPR (frozen +Score. The VQA Score increases to 46.16 as ob- DPR) to RA-VQA, we see that joint training of +jects, objectattributes, imagecaptions, andOCR DPRyieldsnotonlyimprovedEMbutalsosignif- +textsareincorporatedintoRA-VQA-NoDPR.With icantlyhigherHSR(+1.74%)andFSR(+1.21%). +5 retrieved documents, RA-VQA-FrDPR yields ManualinspectionofOK-VQArevealsthatthere +a 51.22 VQA Score, with a further improvement are many general knowledge questions. For ex- +(53.81VQAScore)infulltrainingofretrievaland ample,documentretrievalisnotneededtoanswer +answergeneration,confirmingthatoutsideknowl- thequestion"Isthistelevisionworking?"inrefer- +edgeisneededtoanswerOK-VQAquestions. encetoapictureofabrokentelevisionlyingina +field. AhighFSRindicatesgoodperformanceon +4.4.2 BenefitsofIntegratedTraining +| | | | | | | such | questions. | By | contrast, | a | high HSR | reflects | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +JointtrainingisakeybenefitofourproposedRA- theabilitytousedocumentretrievaltoanswerthe +VQAframework: modelpredictionscombinewith questionsthattrulyrequireexternaldocuments. +pseudorelevancelabelstoimproveretrieval, and Both EM and HSR are further improved for +| the resulting | improved | retrieval | | in turn | provides | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +K test = 50inRA-VQA,withlittlechangeinFSR. +customized answer generation targets. To quan- The increased HSR to FSR ratio (0.41 vs. 0.40) +tify these effects, we take RA-VQA-FrDPR as a indicates that RA-VQA is using these additional +| starting point | (Table | 1). Comparing | | it with | other | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | retrieved | documents | | to answer | | the questions | that | +RA-VQA models suggests that DPR training in needoutsideknowledge. +itselfisnecessary,asusingonlypre-trainedDPR HSRandFSRalsoexplaintherelativelyweak +(RA-VQA-FrDPR) leads to weaker VQA Score performanceofRAG*. WeseethatalthoughRAG* +| (51.22). | Using | model predictions | | alone | in joint | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ------- | ----- | ---- | +| | | | | | | and | RA-VQA-FrDPR | | have | similar | FSRs, | RAG* | +DPRtraining(RA-VQA-NoPR)leadstoahigher hashigherPRRecallbutlowerHSR(by-2.73%). +VQA Score (52.98 vs 51.22), but a significantly This suggests RAG*’s DPR model is not well +| lowerPRRecall(77.67%vs81.25%). | | | | Themodel | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | matchedtoitsanswergenerator. | | | | | Theresultisthat | | +decidestoremovesomepseudorelevantdocuments +| | | | | | | retrieveddocumentsremainunexploited. | | | | | | Inman- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +butachievesbetterperformance. Thispointstoa ual examination of gradients of document scores +potentialproblemthatcanarise. Pseudorelevance intraining,wefindanecdotallythatadjustmentsto +| is only an | imperfect | indication | of | true | relevance | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | documentscoresareoftencounter-intuitive: | | | | | | doc- | +andsoisnotanidealcriteriaonitsown. Training umentsthatdonotcontainanswerscanstillhave +DPRtoretrievepseudorelevantdocumentscould their scores upvoted if the answer generator hap- +| result in misleading | | documents | being | used | in an- | | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +penstofindacorrectanswerbyrelyingonlyonthe +| swergeneration. | | | | | | abilityofT5model. | | | Thisworksagainstamodel’s | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Usingbothpseudorelevancelabelsandmodel abilitytofindanswersinretrieveddocumentseven +predictionsinDPRtraining(RA-VQA)improves whenthosedocumentsarerelevant. +| VQA Score | to | 53.81 and | notably | | improves | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4.4.4 EffectsofK +| PRRecallto82.84%. | | Includingpseudorelevance | | | | | | | train | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +ensures that potentially useful documents are re- Asnoted,retrievingalargecollectionofdocuments +tained,evenwhilethegeneratorisstilllearningto in training is costly (large K ). Fig. 4 shows +train +| usethem. | | | | | | that | RA-VQA | can | be trained | with | relatively | few | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | +We also note that when generation targets are retrieveddocuments(K train = 5). Wegraduallyin- +| | | | | | | creaseK | | whilefixingK | | = | K | (dashlines) | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | +| notcustomizedforeachretrieveddocument(RA- | | | | | | | train | | | test | train | | +VQA-NoCT), VQA Score drops by 1.14 relative and K = 50 (solid lines). RA-VQA achieves +test +toRA-VQA,showingthatcustomizedgeneration consistent performance (∼54.4 VQA Score) at +| | | | | | | K | ≥ 5 | K | = | 50, | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +targets play an important role in the overall sys- train and test which suggests that +| | | | | | | our | joint training | | scheme | is able | to gather | most | +| ---------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --------- | ---- | +| tem: by training | | the model | to extract | the | reliable | | | | | | | | +answersavailableinretrieveddocuments,answer usefulknowledgeintoatop-50listevenwhenthe +generationandretrievalarebothimproved. modelistrainedtoretrievefewerdocuments. This +isnotthecaseforthefrozenDPRsystemswhichre- +4.4.3 InteractionofRetrievalandGeneration +| | | | | | | quireincreasingK | | | toobtainbestperformance. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +train +Table1alsoreportsourinvestigationintotheinter- RA-VQA’ssuperiorperformanceshowsthatjoint +actionbetweendocumentretrievalandanswergen- trainingofretrievalandgenerationyieldsclearben- -HI 60411     CLINICAL ANALYTICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80411) The use of well-defined and well-integrated -clinical analytics throughout the healthcare value chain can be -transformative. Through careful implementation of health analytics, -hospitals can transform unwieldy amalgamations of data into -information that can: improve patient outcomes, increase safety, -enhance operational efficiency and support public health. Given the -immense size of the data challenge, the distinctness and geographic -spread of many healthcare-related activities, and the fact that so many -healthcare activities are conducted by different entities which must -interact with each other, there is really no other way to provide operations -management tools necessary to deliver personalized medicine and to -control spiraling costs. Since clinical analytics is an immature discipline, -we carefully examine the practices of those institutions that are standard -setters in the industry. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +55 +54.5 54.4 54.3 54.4 54.4 and have also shown how RA-VQA’s gains arise +54.0 54.0 54.0 54.1 53.9 relative to other approaches, such as RAG. As a +| | 54 | | 53.8 | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | --- | +| | | 53.4 | | | | | further | practical | benefit, | we found | that | RA-VQA | | +| erocS AQV | | | 53.2 | | | | | | | | | | | +53 +| | 52.6 | | | | 52.8 | 52.8 | canbeusedwithlargernumbersofretrieveddocu- | | | | | | | +| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +52.4 52.4 +| | | 52.3 | | | | 52.3 | mentsthanwereusedinsystemtraining,yielding | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | ------ | ---- | ---- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | +| | | | 5 2 . 0 5 2 . | 0 52.2 | | | | | | | | | | +| | 52 | 5 1 . 9 | 5 1 . | 8 51.8 | 51.9 | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 5 1 . 7 | | | | computational | | savings | without | sacrificing | | perfor- | +5 1 . 5 +51.3 51.2 +mance. +51 +| | 50.5 | | | | | | The | code for | this | paper | will | be released | | +| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | +athttps://github.com/LinWeizheDragon/Retrieval- +50 +| | 2 | 3 | 4 5 | 10 | 15 20 30 | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | Ktrain | | | | Augmented-Visual-Question-Answering. | | | | | | | +RA-VQA-FrDPR(Ktest=Ktrain) +| | | | | | | | 6 Acknowledgement | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +RA-VQA-FrDPR(Ktest=50) +RA-VQA(Ktest=Ktrain) +| | | | | | | | W. Lin | was | supported | by | a Research | | Stu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | +RA-VQA(Ktest=50) +| | | | | | | | dentship | funded | by | Toyota | Motor | | Europe | +| ------ | ------ | ------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | ----------------- | ------ | --- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | (RG92562(24020)). | | We | thank | our | colleagues, | | +| Figure | 4: VQA | Scores | against | K | train . Dashed | line: | | | | | | | | +K = K ; solid line: K = 50. Our proposed DanielOlmedaReino(ToyotaMotorEurope)and +| test | train | | | test | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ---- | +| model | achieves | the best | performance | | when additional | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Jonas Ambeck | | (Toyota | Motor | Europe), | who | pro- | +| documentsareretrievedintest(K | | | | | =50).Thisholds | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | test | | | videdinsightandexpertiseinthisproject. | | | | | | | +evenformodelstrainedtoretrievefewerdocuments. +| | | | | | | | We thank | Zhilin | Wang | (University | | of | Wash- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | +ington)andAlexandruCoca(UniversityofCam- +efitsincomputationandanswerquality. +| | | | | | | | bridge) | for comments | | that greatly | | improved | the | +| --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | ----- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | ------- | +| WealsonotethatK | | | = | 5isanoptimaldesign | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | train | | | | manuscript. | We | would | also | like to | thank | all the | +choicethatstrikesabalancebetweentrainingcom- +reviewersfortheirknowledgeablereviews. +| putationalcostandsystemperformance. | | | | | Thegreen | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | ----- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| curvesatK | | < 5alsosuggestthatitisbeneficial | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | train | | | | | | 7 Limitations | | | | | | | +| toincludeatleast5documentsintraining. | | | | | | Thisis | | | | | | | | +because K ≥ 5 offers a good PRRecall (over Onepossiblelimitationisthatsomerelevantinfor- +train +80%),whichprovidesdocumentsofhigherquality mation (such as relative positioning of objects in +fortrainingthesystem. the image) could be lost in transforming images +| | | | | | | | independentlyoftheinformationbeingsought. | | | | | | Ex- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4.5 AdditionalAnalyses +tractingvisualfeaturesbasedonqueriescouldbea +We redirect readers to other interesting analyses naturalnextstep,althoughquery-specificprocess- +(e.g. an analysis of computational cost) and case ingoftheimagecollectionwouldbecomputation- +| studiesinAppendicesB-E. | | | | | | | allyexpensive. | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +In addition, in Appendix F, we evaluate We selected the Google Search corpus (Luo +our proposed framework on another popular et al., 2021) as the knowledge base for our ques- +Knowledge-based VQA dataset, FVQA (Fact- tionansweringsystem. Itsadvantagesarethatitis +basedVQA)(Wangetal.,2017). Similarly,theRA- large, openly available, and can be readily used +VQAframeworkwithjointtrainingachievesbet- to replicate the results in this paper. However +terresultsoverthebaselinesystemswithafrozen some visual question types (e.g. ‘Is the athlete +DPRcomponent, showingthegeneralizabilityof rightorlefthanded?’) couldplausiblyrequireboth +ourproposedframework. complexreasoningandmorecloselyrelevantdoc- +umentsfromadditionalknowledgesources(such +5 Conclusion +| | | | | | | | as Wikipedia). | | Our system | may | be | limited | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | +respecttotheseconsiderations. +Retrieval-AugmentedVisualQuestionAnswering +isanovelmodellingframeworkforintegratedtrain- +| ingofDPRandanswergeneration. | | | | | Wehaveevalu- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +References +atedRA-VQAontheOK-VQAtaskandwefind +significantlybetterperformancethantheindepen- Stanislaw Antol, Aishwarya Agrawal, Jiasen Lu, Mar- +| | | | | | | | garet | Mitchell, | Dhruv | Batra, | C Lawrence | | Zitnick, | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | -------- | +| denttrainingofcomponentsystem. | | | | | Throughdiag- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Devi | Parikh. | 2015. | Vqa: | Visual | question | an- | +nosticmetricssuchasHSRandFSRweanalysed swering. In Proceedings of the IEEE international +| the interaction | | between | retrieval | | and generation, | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +conferenceoncomputervision,pages2425–2433. -HI 60412     CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80412) Provides a practical survey of clinical decision -support systems that collect clinical data and enable the transition to -clinical knowledge in real world applications intended to improve quality -and safety of patient care. Students become familiar with the basic -requirements for clinical decision support systems and the challenges -associated with the development and deployment of new applications -within the healthcare setting. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +Sören Auer, Christian Bizer, Georgi Kobilarov, Jens Kelvin Guu, Kenton Lee, Zora Tung, Panupong Pasu- +Lehmann, Richard Cyganiak, and Zachary Ives. pat,andMing-WeiChang.2020. Realm: Retrieval- +2007. Dbpedia: A nucleus for a web of open data. augmented language model pre-training. In Pro- +InThesemanticweb,pages722–735.Springer. ceedings of the 37th International Conference on +MachineLearning,ICML’20.JMLR.org. +| DanqiChen, | AdamFisch, | | JasonWeston, | | andAntoine | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | GautierIzacardandEdouardGrave.2021. | | | | | | Leveraging | +| Bordes. | 2017. | Reading | Wikipedia | | to answer | open- | | | | | | | | +domain questions. In Proceedings of the 55th An- passage retrieval with generative models for open +nual Meeting of the Association for Computational domain question answering. In Proceedings of the +Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages 1870– 16thConferenceoftheEuropeanChapteroftheAs- +1879,Vancouver,Canada.AssociationforComputa- sociation for Computational Linguistics: Main Vol- +| | | | | | | | ume, pages | 874–880, | | Online. | Association | | for Com- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +tionalLinguistics. +putationalLinguistics. +| Yen-Chun | Chen, | Linjie | Li, | Licheng | Yu, | Ahmed | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Chao Jia, | Yinfei | Yang, | Ye Xia, | Yi-Ting | Chen, | Zarana | +| El Kholy, | Faisal | Ahmed, | | Zhe Gan, | Yu | Cheng, and | | | | | | | | +Jingjing Liu. 2020. Uniter: Universal image-text Parekh, Hieu Pham, Quoc Le, Yun-Hsuan Sung, +representationlearning. InEuropeanconferenceon Zhen Li, and Tom Duerig. 2021. Scaling up visual +computervision,pages104–120.Springer. and vision-language representation learning with +| | | | | | | | noisytextsupervision. | | | InInternationalConference | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +onMachineLearning,pages4904–4916.PMLR. +| Jacob Devlin, | | Ming-Wei | Chang, | | Kenton | Lee, and | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | ----- | ------------ | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | --------- | ---------- | +| Kristina | Toutanova. | | 2019. | BERT: | Pre-training | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Huaizu Jiang, | | Ishan Misra, | | Marcus | Rohrbach, | Erik | +| deep | bidirectional | transformers | | for | language | under- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Learned-Miller, | | and | Xinlei | Chen. | 2020. | In defense | +| standing. | InProceedingsofthe2019Conferenceof | | | | | | | | | | | | | +the North American Chapter of the Association for of grid features for visual question answering. In +| | | | | | | | Proceedings | | of the IEEE/CVF | | Conference | | on Com- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | +ComputationalLinguistics.ACL. +puterVisionandPatternRecognition,pages10267– +10276. +| Yanlin Feng, | Xinyue | | Chen, | Bill Yuchen | Lin, | Peifeng | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | -------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ----- | +| Wang, | Jun | Yan, and | Xiang | Ren. | 2020. | Scalable | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Jeff Johnson, | Matthijs | | Douze, | and Hervé | Jégou. | 2019. | +multi-hoprelationalreasoningforknowledge-aware +| | | | | | | | Billion-scale | | similarity | search | with | GPUs. | IEEE | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ----- | ---- | +| question | answering. | | In | Proceedings | of | the 2020 | | | | | | | | +TransactionsonBigData,7(3):535–547. +| Conference | | on Empirical | | Methods | in Natural | Lan- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guageProcessing(EMNLP),pages1295–1309,On- VladimirKarpukhin,BarlasOguz,SewonMin,Patrick +line.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +Lewis,LedellWu,SergeyEdunov,DanqiChen,and +| | | | | | | | Wen-tau | Yih. | 2020. | Dense | passage | retrieval | for | +| --------- | --------- | -------- | ------------------- | --------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | --------------- | ------- | +| Zhe Gan, | Yen-Chun | | Chen, | Linjie | Li, | Chen Zhu, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | open-domainquestionanswering. | | | | | InProceedingsof | | +| Yu Cheng, | and | Jingjing | Liu. | 2020. | Large-scale | ad- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the 2020 | Conference | | on Empirical | | Methods | in Nat- | +| versarial | training | for | vision-and-language | | | represen- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ural Language | | Processing | | (EMNLP), | pages | 6769– | +| tation | learning. | Advances | | in Neural | | Information | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 6781, | Online. | Association | | for Computational | | Lin- | +ProcessingSystems,33:6616–6628. +guistics. +| Feng Gao, | Qing | Ping, | Govind | Thattai, | | Aishwarya | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----- | ---------------------------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | Diederik | P. Kingma | and | Jimmy | Ba. | 2015. | Adam: A | +| Reganti, | Ying | Nian | Wu, | and | Prem | Natara- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | method | for stochastic | | optimization. | | In | 3rd Inter- | +| jan. | 2022. | Transform-retrieve-generate: | | | | Natural | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | national | Conference | | on Learning | | Representations, | | +language-centricoutside-knowledgevisualquestion +| | | | | | | | ICLR | 2015, | San Diego, | CA, | USA, | May | 7-9, 2015, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | ---------- | +answering. InProceedingsoftheIEEE/CVFConfer- ConferenceTrackProceedings. +| ence | on Computer | | Vision | and Pattern | Recognition, | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pages5067–5077. Tom Kwiatkowski, Jennimaria Palomaki, Olivia Red- +| | | | | | | | field, MichaelCollins, | | | AnkurParikh, | | ChrisAlberti, | | +| -------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | ------------ | ---- | ---------------------- | -------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | ------- | +| François | Garderes, | Maryam | | Ziaeefard, | Baptiste | Abe- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Danielle | Epstein, | Illia | Polosukhin, | | Jacob | Devlin, | +| loos, | and | Freddy | Lecue. | 2020. | Conceptbert: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | KentonLee,etal.2019. | | | Naturalquestions: | | | abench- | +Concept-awarerepresentationforvisualquestionan- +| | | | | | | | markforquestionansweringresearch. | | | | | Transactions | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +swering. InProceedingsofthe2020Conferenceon of the Association for Computational Linguistics, +| EmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing: | | | | | | | 7:453–466. | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Findings,pages489–498. +KentonLee,Ming-WeiChang,andKristinaToutanova. +Liangke Gui, Borui Wang, Qiuyuan Huang, Alex 2019. Latent retrieval for weakly supervised open +| Hauptmann, | | Yonatan | Bisk, | and | Jianfeng | Gao. | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | domain | question | answering. | | In | Proceedings | of the | +2021. Kat: A knowledge augmented trans- 57th Annual Meeting of the Association for Com- +former for vision-and-language. arXiv preprint putational Linguistics, pages 6086–6096, Florence, +arXiv:2112.08614. Italy.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +DaluGuo,ChangXu,andDachengTao.2021. Bilinear Patrick Lewis, Ethan Perez, Aleksandra Piktus, Fabio +graphnetworksforvisualquestionanswering. IEEE Petroni, Vladimir Karpukhin, Naman Goyal, Hein- +TransactionsonNeuralNetworksandLearningSys- rich Küttler, Mike Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Tim Rock- +| tems. | | | | | | | täschel,etal.2020. | | | Retrieval-augmentedgeneration | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Health Informatics (HI)           1 +forknowledge-intensivenlptasks. AdvancesinNeu- Medhini Narasimhan, Svetlana Lazebnik, and Alexan- +ralInformationProcessingSystems,33:9459–9474. der Schwing. 2018a. Out of the box: Reasoning +| | | | | | | | with graph | convolution | | nets | for factual | visual | ques- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | +GuohaoLi,XinWang,andWenwuZhu.2020a. Boost- tionanswering. Advancesinneuralinformationpro- +| ing visual | question | answering | | with | context-aware | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cessingsystems,31. +| knowledge | | aggregation. | | In Proceedings | | of the | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +28thACMInternationalConferenceonMultimedia, Medhini Narasimhan, Svetlana Lazebnik, and Alexan- +pages1227–1235. der Schwing. 2018b. Out of the box: Reasoning +| | | | | | | | with graph | convolution | | nets | for factual | visual | ques- | +| ------- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | +| Wei Li, | Can Gao, | Guocheng | | Niu, Xinyan | Xiao, | Hao | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tionanswering. | | InAdvancesinNeuralInformation | | | | | +Liu,JiachenLiu,HuaWu,andHaifengWang.2021. Processing Systems, volume 31. Curran Associates, +| UNIMO:Towardsunified-modalunderstandingand | | | | | | | Inc. | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| generation | via | cross-modal | | contrastive | learning. | In | | | | | | | | +Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the Chen Qu, Hamed Zamani, Liu Yang, W Bruce Croft, +Association for Computational Linguistics and the andErikLearned-Miller.2021. Passageretrievalfor +11thInternationalJointConferenceonNaturalLan- +| | | | | | | | outside-knowledge | | | visual | question | answering. | In | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | +guage Processing (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages Proceedings of the 44th International ACM SIGIR +2592–2607, Online. Association for Computational Conference on Research and Development in Infor- +| Linguistics. | | | | | | | mationRetrieval,pages1753–1757. | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +XiujunLi,XiYin,ChunyuanLi,PengchuanZhang,Xi- Alec Radford, Jeffrey Wu, Rewon Child, David Luan, +aowei Hu, Lei Zhang, Lijuan Wang, Houdong Hu, Dario Amodei, Ilya Sutskever, et al. 2019. Lan- +Li Dong, Furu Wei, et al. 2020b. Oscar: Object- guage models are unsupervised multitask learners. +| semantics | aligned | pre-training | | for | vision-language | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +OpenAIblog,1(8):9. +tasks. InEuropeanConferenceonComputerVision, +pages121–137.Springer. Colin Raffel, Noam Shazeer, Adam Roberts, Kather- +| | | | | | | | ine Lee, | Sharan | Narang, | | Michael | Matena, | Yanqi | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +Bill Yuchen Lin, Xinyue Chen, Jamin Chen, and Xi- Zhou, Wei Li, and Peter J. Liu. 2020. Exploring +ang Ren. 2019. KagNet: Knowledge-aware graph thelimitsoftransferlearningwithaunifiedtext-to- +networks for commonsense reasoning. In Proceed- text transformer. Journal of Machine Learning Re- +| ings of | the 2019 | Conference | | on Empirical | | Methods | search,21(140):1–67. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| in Natural | Language | | Processing | and | the | 9th Inter- | | | | | | | | +AdamRoberts,ColinRaffel,andNoamShazeer.2020. +nationalJointConferenceonNaturalLanguagePro- +cessing(EMNLP-IJCNLP),pages2829–2839,Hong Howmuchknowledgecanyoupackintotheparam- +Kong, China. Association for Computational Lin- eters of a language model? In Proceedings of the +| guistics. | | | | | | | 2020 | Conference | on | Empirical | Methods | in Natural | | +| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Language | Processing | | (EMNLP), | pages | 5418–5426, | | +Man Luo, Yankai Zeng, Pratyay Banerjee, and Chitta Online.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Baral. | 2021. | Weakly-supervised | | | visual-retriever- | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +readerforknowledge-basedquestionanswering. In Amir Saffari, Armin Oliya, Priyanka Sen, and Tom +| | | | | | | | Ayoola. | 2021. | End-to-end | | entity | resolution | and | +| ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| Proceedings | | of the 2021 | Conference | | on | Empirical | | | | | | | | +Methods in Natural Language Processing, pages question answering using differentiable knowledge +6417–6431,OnlineandPuntaCana,DominicanRe- graphs. In Proceedings of the 2021 Conference on +public.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. EmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing, +| | | | | | | | pages4193–4200, | | OnlineandPuntaCana, | | | Domini- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | +Shangwen Lv, Daya Guo, Jingjing Xu, Duyu Tang, can Republic. Association for Computational Lin- +| Nan Duan, | Ming | Gong, | Linjun | Shou, | Daxin | Jiang, | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guistics. +| Guihong | Cao, | and Songlin | | Hu. 2020. | Graph-based | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Amanpreet | Singh, | Vivek | Natarajan, | | Meet | Shah, | +| reasoning | over | heterogeneous | | external | knowledge | | | | | | | | | +for commonsense question answering. In Proceed- Yu Jiang, Xinlei Chen, Dhruv Batra, Devi Parikh, +ings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelli- and Marcus Rohrbach. 2019. Towards vqa models +gence,volume34,pages8449–8456. thatcanread. InProceedingsoftheIEEE/CVFCon- +| | | | | | | | ference | on Computer | | Vision | and | Pattern Recogni- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | +Kenneth Marino, Xinlei Chen, Devi Parikh, Abhinav tion,pages8317–8326. +| Gupta, | and | Marcus Rohrbach. | | 2021. | Krisp: | Inte- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +grating implicit and symbolic knowledge for open- RobynSpeer,JoshuaChin,andCatherineHavasi.2017. +domainknowledge-basedvqa. InProceedingsofthe Conceptnet5.5: Anopenmultilingualgraphofgen- +IEEE/CVFConferenceonComputerVisionandPat- eralknowledge. InThirty-firstAAAIconferenceon +| ternRecognition,pages14111–14121. | | | | | | | artificialintelligence. | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Kenneth Marino, Mohammad Rastegari, Ali Farhadi, HaoTanandMohitBansal.2019. LXMERT:Learning +and Roozbeh Mottaghi. 2019. Ok-vqa: A visual cross-modality encoder representations from trans- +question answering benchmark requiring external formers. InProceedingsofthe2019Conferenceon +knowledge. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Con- EmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing +ference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recogni- andthe9thInternationalJointConferenceonNatu- +tion,pages3195–3204. ralLanguageProcessing(EMNLP-IJCNLP),pages - 2        Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026 +5100–5111, Hong Kong, China. Association for Zihao Zhu, Jing Yu, Yujing Wang, Yajing Sun, Yue +ComputationalLinguistics. Hu, and Qi Wu. 2020. Mucko: Multi-layer cross- +| | | | | | | | modal | knowledge | reasoning | | for fact-based | visual | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | ------ | +NiketTandon,GerardDeMelo,andGerhardWeikum. question answering. In Proceedings of the Twenty- +2017. Webchild 2.0: Fine-grained commonsense Ninth International Joint Conference on Artificial +knowledgedistillation. InProceedingsofACL2017, Intelligence, IJCAI-20, pages 1097–1103. Interna- +SystemDemonstrations,pages115–120. tional Joint Conferences on Artificial Intelligence +| | | | | | | | Organization. | | Maintrack. | | | | +| ----------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------- | -------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Peng Wang, | Qi | Wu, Chunhua | | Shen, | Anthony | Dick, | | | | | | | +| and Anton | Van | Den | Hengel. | 2017. | Fvqa: | Fact- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | A TrainingDetailsandArtifacts | | | | | | +| based | visual | question | answering. | | IEEE | transac- | | | | | | | +| tions on | pattern | analysis | and | machine | intelligence, | | | | | | | | +| 40(10):2413–2427. | | | | | | | Adam(KingmaandBa,2015)wasusedinthispa- | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | per. InDPRpre-training,theretrieverwastrained | | | | | | +ZiruiWang,JiahuiYu,AdamsWeiYu,ZihangDai,Yu- +| | | | | | | | for6epochswithaconstantlearningrate10−5. | | | | | In | +| ------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| lia Tsvetkov, | | and Yuan | Cao. | 2022. | SimVLM: | Sim- | | | | | | | +RA-VQAtraining(includingRAG*),thelearning +plevisuallanguagemodelpretrainingwithweaksu- +| | | | | | | | | 10−5 | | | 6×10−5 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +pervision. InInternationalConferenceonLearning rates are for the retriever, and for +| Representations. | | | | | | | theanswergenerator,linearlydecayingto0after | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ------------ | ----- | +| | | | | | | | 10 epochs. | In | the training | of | RA-VQA-NoDPR | | +| Thomas | Wolf, | Lysandre | Debut, | Victor | Sanh, | Julien | | | | | | 10−5. | +| | | | | | | | and TRiG*, | the | initial | learning | rate is | 6 × | +| Chaumond, | ClementDelangue, | | | AnthonyMoi, | | Pier- | | | | | | | +Empirically,thecheckpointsatepoch6wereused +| ric Cistac, | Tim | Rault, | Rémi Louf, | Morgan | | Funtow- | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +icz, Joe Davison, Sam Shleifer, Patrick von Platen, intesting. AllexperimentswererunonNvidiaA- +| Clara | Ma, Yacine | Jernite, | Julien | Plu, | Canwen | Xu, | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------------------- | ----- | ------ | ---------------------- | ------------- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | 100GPUclusters. | | WithK | | = 5,theRA-VQA | | +| Teven | Le Scao, | Sylvain | Gugger, | Mariama | | Drame, | | | | train | | | +| | | | | | | | training | takes | around | 5 hours | (10 epochs) | while | +| Quentin | Lhoest, | and | Alexander | M. | Rush. | 2020. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | testingtakes5minutes. | | | Thetimecostincreasesas | | | +| Transformers: | | State-of-the-artnaturallanguagepro- | | | | | | | | | | | +cessing. InProceedingsofthe2020Conferenceon K increases,approximatelylinearly. +train +EmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing: +| | | | | | | | Pre-trainedmodelparameters(e.g. | | | | T5-largeand | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +SystemDemonstrations,pages38–45,Online.Asso- +| | | | | | | | BERT-base) | are | provided | by | huggingface | (Wolf | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | +ciationforComputationalLinguistics. +etal.,2020)accompaniedbyPythonlibraries(un- +JialinWu,JiasenLu,AshishSabharwal,andRoozbeh der Apache License 2.0). FAISS (Johnson et al., +| Mottaghi.2022. | | Multi-modalanswervalidationfor | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2019)isunderMITLicense. +| knowledge-based | | vqa. | In Proceedings | | of | the AAAI | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Conference on Artificial Intelligence, volume 36, B SupplementaryTablesandFigures +pages2712–2721. +Limitedbyspaceavailable,wepresentsupplemen- +| Zhengyuan | Yang, | Zhe Gan, | Jianfeng | | Wang, | Xiaowei | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tarytablesandfiguresinthissection,offeringmore +| Hu, Yumao | | Lu, Zicheng | Liu, | and | Lijuan | Wang. | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +findingstoreaders. +| 2022. | An empirical | | study | of gpt-3 | for | few-shot | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ------------ | ---------- | -------------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| knowledge-based | | vqa. | In Proceedings | | of | the AAAI | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | B.1 FullVersionofTable1 | | | | | | +| Conference | on | Artificial | Intelligence, | | volume | 36, | | | | | | | +pages3081–3089. +WeprovidethefullversionofTable1inTable8. +Zhou Yu, Jun Yu, Yuhao Cui, Dacheng Tao, and Somemorediscussionsaboutcustomizedgenera- +tiontargetinjointtrainingisprovided. +| QiTian.2019. | | Deepmodularco-attentionnetworks | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +forvisualquestionanswering. InProceedingsofthe Asnoted,RA-VQAimprovesretrievalwiththe +| IEEE/CVF | conference | | on computer | | vision | and pat- | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +feedbackofmodelpredictions,andinturntheim- +ternrecognition,pages6281–6290. +| | | | | | | | proved retrieval | | leads | to improved | answer | gener- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | ------ | +ationbytrainingtowardss∗,acustomizedgener- +| ZhouYu, | JunYu, | ChenchaoXiang, | | JianpingFan, | | and | | | | k | | | +| ------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Dacheng Tao. 2018. Beyond bilinear: Generalized ation target for each retrieved document z . We +k +multimodalfactorizedhigh-orderpoolingforvisual +removethisinteractionfromRA-VQAmodelsby +| question | answering. | | IEEE transactions | | | on neural | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | enforcing | s∗ = | s∗ (the | most | popular | human re- | +| networksandlearningsystems,29(12):5947–5959. | | | | | | | | k | | | | | +| | | | | | | | sponse), | independent | | of the | retrieved z | . The ab- | +k +Pengchuan Zhang, Xiujun Li, Xiaowei Hu, Jianwei latedmodelsaredenotedwitha*-NoCTsuffix. +Yang,LeiZhang,LijuanWang,YejinChoi,andJian- As shown in Table 8, customizing generation +| fengGao.2021. | | Vinvl: | Revisitingvisualrepresenta- | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | ------ | --------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | targetsforeachretrievedz | | | | intrainingyieldsper- | | +| tionsinvision-languagemodels. | | | | InProceedingsof | | | | | | k | | | +theIEEE/CVFConferenceonComputerVisionand formanceboostforbothRA-VQA-FrDPRandRA- +VQA,showingthatthissupervisionsignalisbenefi- +PatternRecognition,pages5579–5588. -HI 60413     CHANGE MANAGEMENT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80413) Designed to cover the process of change -management in large healthcare organizations in light of current trends. -Topics related to technology requirements, technology implementations, -risk assessment and buy-in are among those covered. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +| | | | | K =5 | | K =10 | | K =20 | | K =50 | | K | =5 | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | +| Models | | | | | | | | | | | | test | | +| | | | | P | R | P R | | P | R | P | R | EM VQAScore | | +| VRR(Luoetal.,2021) | | | | - | 80.40 | - 88.55 | | - 93.22 | | - 97.11 | | - | 42.54 | +RA-VQA-FrDPR 51.82 81.25 49.20 88.51 45.98 92.98 41.24 96.75 55.77 51.22 +RA-VQA 57.39 82.84 54.83 89.00 51.48 93.62 46.36 96.47 58.72 53.81 +Table 3: Comparing retrieval performance of VRR and our RA-VQA models. The same knowledge corpus +(GS-full) was used. P: Pseudo Relevance Precision; R: Pseudo Relevance Recall; EM: Exact Match. P un- +derK =5referstoPRPrec@5. VRRwastrainedonK =100,whileRA-VQAsweretrainedonK =5. +| | | | | | | | train | | | | | | train | +| ------------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +| cialtooverallsystemperformance. | | | | | Wealsonotice | | | | | | | | | +| that | the improvement | | to | RA-VQA | (+1.14 | VQA | | | | | | | | +54.5 +| Score) | is larger | | compared | to | RA-VQA-FrDPR | | | 54 | | | | | | +| ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +53.8 +53.5 +(+0.56VQAScore),showingthatcustomizingthe +| | | | | | | | | erocS AQV 53 | 53.0 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +generationtargetbringsmorebenefitswhenthere- +| trievalisimprovedwithinourproposedRA-VQA | | | | | | | | 52 | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +51.6 +| jointtrainingframework. | | | | Thisfurtherconfirmsthat | | | | | 51.2 | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +51 +RA-VQA-FrDPR (baseline) +thetwocomponents,retrievalandanswergenera- +RA-VQA-NoPR (ablation) +| tion,complementeachotherbi-directionally. | | | | | | | | 50 | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +RA-VQA +| | | | | | | | | | 5 10 | 20 | 50 | 80 | 100 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ktest +| B.2 | RetrievalPerformanceofRA-VQA | | | | | | | | (a) | VQAScorevsK | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +test +InadditiontoPseudoRelevanceRecall(PRRecall) +| introduced | | in the | paper, | we further | | evaluate re- | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0.975 +| trievalperformancewithPseudoRelevancePreci- | | | | | | | | 0.950 | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0.925 +| sion(PRPrec)@K,whichiscalculatedastherate | | | | | | | | 5@llaceR | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0.900 +| of pseudo | | positive | documents | | in all | the K docu- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0.875 +mentsretrievedforaquestion: +0.850 +0.825 +RA-VQA-FrDPR (baseline) +RA-VQA-NoPR (ablation) +0.800 +| | | | | K | | | | | | | RA-VQA | | | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | +| | | | | 1 (cid:88) | | | | 0.775 | | | | | | +| | PRPrec@K | | = | | H(z | ,S) (15) | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | k | | | | 5 10 | 20 | 50 | 80 100 | | +| | | | | K | | | | | | | Ktest | | | +k=1 +(b) RecallvsK +test +| | | | | | | | Figure | 5: | Comparison | of | model | performance | as more | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | +whereH(·)isthepseudorelevancefunctionintro- +ducedinSec.3.2. documents are retrieved in testing. These models are +| | | | | | | | alltrainedwithK | | | =5. | InRA-VQAfulljointtrain- | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | +train +ThesuccessofourRA-VQAmodelcanbefur- ing(green),combiningmodelpredictionswithpseudo +therexplainedbyTable3. Asexpected,RA-VQA- relevance labels yields higher PRRecall at low K , +test +FrDPR(pre-trainedDPR)achievessimilarretrieval showingthatfulljointtrainingimprovesretrieval;RA- +performanceasVRR(Luoetal.,2021)sincethey VQA-NoPR (orange), which uses only model predic- +| | | | | | | | tions | in training, | achieves | | a higher | VQA | Score with | +| --------------------------------- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | --------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | +| are both | based | on | DPR | and are | trained | with the | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | lower | Pseudo | Relevance | | Recall | compared | to the RA- | +| samepseudo-relevance-basedlabels. | | | | | Ourproposed | | | | | | | | | +VQA-FrDPRwithfrozenDPRintraining(blue),which +RA-VQA,withasubstantialimprovementinRe- +suggeststhatPseudoRelevanceisonlyanapproximate +calloverRA-VQA-FrDPR(82.84PRRecall@5vs +measurementofactualrelevance. +81.25PRRecall@5),achievessignificantlyhigher +Precision(57.39PRPrec@5vs51.82PRPrec@5). +Thisalsoyieldssubstantialimprovementstoboth +B.3 EffectsofRetrievingMoreDocumentsin +| EM | (+3.05%) | and | VQA | Score | (+2.59%). | This | | Test | | | | | | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +suggeststhattrainingtheretrieverjointlypresents +morepotentiallyrelevantdocumentstoanswergen- Fig. 5 presents the change of VQA Score and +eration, improving the quality of the top-ranked PRRecall as additional documents are retrieved +| documents. | | | | | | | intest(increasingK | | | | ). | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +test -HI 60414     HUMAN FACTORS AND USABILITY IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -     3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80414) Provides students with the foundational -principles of usability and human factors as applied to safety and quality -in health informatics technology. Course readings and materials review -the concepts of human factors, usability and the cognitive consequences -of health information technology on clinical performance and decision -making. Attention is given to the role of mobile computing in health care, -as well as information visualization. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +PRRecall is improved dramatically as K test in- As K increases, the DPR-based system takes +creasesfrom5to50,afterwhichonlymarginalim- significantlymoretimetotrain. Thisisarealissue +provementisobserved. Similarly,theVQAScore for other DPR-based systems that use very high +of these models is improved as more documents K (e.g. TRiG, KAT), but not the case for our +train +are presented in test, and the performance peaks framework: we verified in Sec.4.4.4 that K = 5 +at K ∼ 50. This suggests that including more achievesalmostthesameresultsasK ≥ 10,which +test +additional documents in test is more likely to in- isadesirablefeaturethatcansignificantlyreduce +clude the truly relevant document to help answer the required computation cost for achieving the +| the | question | yet | along | with more | distracting | and | bestperformance. | | | | | | | +| --- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +misleadingdocuments. +D RandomGuesswithOK-VQA +RA-VQA-NoPR(introducedinSec.4.1),which +Questions +| uses | only | model | predictions | in | training | to adjust | | | | | | | | +| ---- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +documentscoreswithoutpseudorelevancelabels, +yieldsasignificantlylowerPRRecallcurve(orange +| | | | | | | | Question | | | | | Prediction | | +| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | +| curve | in | Fig. 5(b)) | than | RA-VQA-FrDPR | | (blue | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whattypeofbirdisthis? | | | | | | hawk | +| curve)acrossallK | | | s,butachievesmuchhigher | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | test | | | | Whattimeofdayisit? | | | | | afternoon | | +VQA performance (Fig. 5(a)). This further con- Whatkindofdogisthis? chihuaha +| | | | | | | | Whatkindofbirdisthis? | | | | | | hawk | +| ----- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | +| firms | that | Pseudo | Relevance | Labels | | are a weak | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whatsportisthis? | | | | | horserace | | +signal and a high PRRecall does not necessarily Whatbreedofhorseisthat? clydesdale +guarantee to gather truly relevant knowledge in Whatcenturyisthis? 19th +| | | | | | | | Whatkindofbirdsarethese? | | | | | pigeon | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +retrieval. +| | | | | | | | Whatcityisthis? | | | | | newyork | | +| ----------- | ----------------------------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Whatistheweatherlike? | | | | | | rainy | +| C | EvaluationofComputationalCost | | | | | | Whatdotheseanimalseat? | | | | | | grass | +| | | | | | | | Whatactivityisthis? | | | | | skateboard | | +| | | | | | | | Howlongdotheseanimalslive? | | | | | 20years | | +| | | | | | | | Whattypeoftrainisthis? | | | | | passenger | | +| Model | | | GPUmemory | | Walltime | BatchSize | Whatisthisusedfor? | | | | | | travel | +| | | | | | | | Whatisthisroomusedfor? | | | | | | sleep | +| RAVQA | | | 70G | | 180min | 2×16 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whatkindofbirdisthat? | | | | | | hawk | +| RAVQA-FrDPR | | | 67G | | 160min | 4×8 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whatfooddoestheanimaleat? | | | | | catfood | | +| TRiG* | | | 70G | | 220min | 16×2 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whattypeofdogisthis? | | | | | chihuaha | | +| | | | | | | | Whatfooddotheseanimalseat? | | | | | catfood | | +| Table | 4: | Comparing | computational | | cost | of models. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Whatplaceisthis? | | | | | switzerland | | +GPUmemory:totalGPUmemoryoccupiedinruntime Whatbreedofcatisthis? calico +(approximately); Walltime: therequiredtrainingtime Whatseasonisthis? winter +per_device_batch_size× +| for8epochs; | | BatchSize: | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | Table 6: | Example | of | random | guesses | with | only ques- | +| gradient_accumulation_steps. | | | | | The | statistics was | | | | | | | | +collectedusingoneNvidiaA100GPU(80G). tioninput. RandomguessachievedagoodVQAScore +| | | | | | | | by matching | to | the answers | | by chance. | But | the OK- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | +VQAquestionsarestillnotdirectlyanswerablewithout +| | As shown | in | Fig. 4, | comparing | with | the DPR | | | | | | | | +| --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +accesstotheassociatedimages. +| baseline, | | the wall | time | is increased | | by only 20 | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | ------------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | +| minsforRAVQAjointtraining. | | | | | Ourmethoddoes | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | From | the feature | | ablation | study | we | found that | +| not | significantly | | increase | the computation | | needs. | | | | | | | | +ourRA-VQA-NoDPRachieved∼28VQAScore +IncomparingwithTRiG,thetotaltrainingtimeis +| | | | | | | | relying | on only | questions. | | This | is due | to the fact | +| ---- | -------- | ---- | ---------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | +| also | reduced; | this | is because | TRiG | concatenates | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that ∼ | 75% of | answers | | to training | questions | ap- | +allK hiddenstatesfordecoding(Gaoetal.,2022), +| | | | | | | | pear in | the answers | | to test | questions. | | As shown | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +whichiscomputationallyexpensive. +| | | | | | | | in Table | 6, for | each | distinct | question, | | the model | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | +learnedtogeneratethesameanswerwithoutaccess +| | Model | | | WallTime(8epochs) | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ---- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------- | +| | | | | | | | to the associated | | images. | | These | random | guesses | +| | RAVQAK | | =5 | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | train | | | 3hrs | canmatchtotheanswersofsometestquestionsby | | | | | | | +| | RAVQAK | | =10 | | | 7hrs | | | | | | | | +train +| | RAVQAK | | =15 | | | 12hrs | chance,leadingtoagoodVQAScore. | | | | | | Byinspec- | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +train +tionwereportthatmostofthesuccessfulcasesare +Table 5: Wall time of the RAVQA model with an in- random guesses, and these questions are still not +K +creasing train . More time is required for training 8 directlyanswerablewithoutreadingtheassociated +| epochsasK | | | increases. | | | | images. | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +train -HI 60416     HEALTH INFORMATICS ISSUES: POLICY, POLITICS AND -ETHICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80416) This course uses a policy analysis lens to -critically examine issues related to the use of information technology in -healthcare from an ethical, political and regulatory perspective. Course's -primary focus is on the United States, but international approaches are -also be discussed. Legislation affecting health information technology -area are examined,including the American Reinvestment and Recovery -Act, HITECH section; Affordable Care Act and Health Insurance Portability -and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996. Topics and issues related to -health informatics also are discussed, including structure of health -administrative and delivery systems, assessment of population health, -models of health care delivery, access and quality of care. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +E CaseStudy F GeneralizingRAVQAtoOther +Datasets +WepresentacasestudyinFig.6tocompareRA- +VQA-FrDPR and our proposed RA-VQA frame- Wearealsointerestedinwhetherthisapproachis +work. Conclusionsareprovidedtoeachcaseinthe +alsogeneralisabletoothersimilarVQAtasksthat +figure. maybenefitfromimprovedpassageretrieval. +| We | implement | our | framework | on | another | +| --------------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | +| knowledge-based | | VQA | task, | Fact-based | VQA | +| (FVQA) | (Wang | et al., | 2017). | This dataset | con- | +tainscommonsensefactoidVQAquestions,suchas +| “Question: | whichobjectintheimagecancutyou? | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | +| Answer: | theknife”. | IncontrasttoOKVQAwhere | | | | +| no knowledge | | base is | provided, | FVQA | grounds | +eachquestion-answerpairwithafact(atripletfrom +several‘commonsense’knowledgebases,includ- +ingConceptNet(Speeretal.,2017),Webchild(Tan- +donetal.,2017),andDBpedia(Aueretal.,2007)). +Atripletcontainsaheadnode,arelation,andatail +| node(e.g. | [Car]/r/HasA[4wheels]). | | | Tocopewith | | +| --------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +passageretrieval,theseknowledgetripletsareflat- +| tenedintosurfacetexts(e.g. | | | “[car]has[4wheels]”) | | | +| -------------------------- | ------- | ------ | -------------------- | ------- | ----------- | +| such that | DPR | can be | directly | applied | to retrieve | +| them. We | replace | pseudo | relevance | with | ground- | +truthrelevancesincerelevanttripletsforanswering +questionsaregiven. +Themetricsusedforassessingperformanceare +| Accuracy | and | Recall, | with their | standard | devia- | +| -------------------------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------------- | ---------- | +| tions of | 5 splits. | Accuracy | counts | the | portion of | +| questions | that | are successfully | | answered, | while | +| Recall@K | measures | how | likely | the retrieved | K | +| knowledgetripletscontaintheanswernode. | | | | | Since | +FVQAwasdesignedforanswerselectioninstead +ofopen-endedanswergeneration,priorworksused +accuracyas“whethertheanswernodeissuccess- +| fullyselectedfromallKGnodes”. | | | | Toenablefair | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +evaluationwithouropen-endedframework,incal- +culatingaccuracy,aquestionisconsideredsuccess- +| fully answered | | if the answer | | node is | the closest | +| --------------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | +| node to | the generated | | answer | string (shortest | in | +| Levenshteindistance). | | | Forexample,thegenerated | | | +answer‘knives’isstillavalidanswersincethean- +swernode‘[knife]’canbematchedwithashortest +Levenshteindistance. +| The significance | | of | performance | is | guaranteed | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +byreportingtheaverageof5splits(asintheofficial +| FVQAevaluation). | | Intotalwetrained5DPRmod- | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +elsand5×3models(RAVQA,RAVQA-FrDPR, +andRAVQA-NoDPR)withthesamehyperparam- +eters. Eachsplithasapproximatelyhalfquestions +fortrainingandtheremainingfortesting. +Wecomparewiththreesystemsinpriorwork: +| (1)FVQA(Wangetal.,2017): | | | | thebaselinesys- | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -HI 60417     PUBLIC HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80417) Public Health Informatics (PHI) is an emergent, -interdisciplinary field that focuses on the systematic management -and dynamic application of information resources to enhance public -health practice, education and research. As an emerging subset of -Health Informatics, PHI is practiced by individuals, governmental and -nongovernmental organizations at the international, national, regional, -state and local levels. PHI deals with the collection and analysis of vital -statistics data through surveillance; information creation; information -storage and retrieval; visualization and graphics; dissemination; use of -information for policy, decision making and trend tracking. The purpose -of this course is to provide students with an introductory overview of -the vast and dynamic field of PHI, including definitions, approaches, -competencies, applications and informatics principles applied in public -health settings. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter +RAVQA-Frozen +an adult dog should have 42 teeth in total: that's 20 on top of their jaw and 22 on the bottom. Pred: 42 +cats have 30 teeth and dogs have 42. Pred: 30 +we humans have 32 pearly whites. horses have 44 chompers, dolphins can have as many as +250 teeth and, it's hard to believe, but snails can have more than 20,000 tiny, very sharp teeth Pred: 32 +— located on their tongues +RAVQA (ours) +cats have 26 deciduous teeth and 30 permanent teeth. Pred: 26 +How many teeth does this animal this is true. as dogs grow older, they will have 42 permanent teeth while cats will have 30. Pred: 30 +use to have? +cats have 26 deciduous teeth consisting of: 12 incisors; 4 canines; 10 premolars. permanent +Pred: 26 +teeth begin to erupt from the age of 11-12 weeks. +Retrieval was improved by RA-VQA, which leads to sucessful answering with given knowledge. +RAVQA-Frozen +i credit this “secret ingredient” for being the greatest offender in this recipe. Pred: toothpaste +ingredients on the list that end in “ose”—fructose, maltose, sucrose...... Pred: toothpaste +natural cheese is made from only four ingredients: milk, salt, starter culture (good bacteria) +Pred: toothpaste +and rennet (an enzyme) +Questions about "ingredient" are common in food domain, and misleading material may be +presented by Pseudo Relevance Labels to Answer Generator, leading to failed answering. +RAVQA (ours) +active ingredient sodium fluoride 0.21% (0.12% w/v fluoride ion) purpose anticavity +toothpaste use helps protect teeth and roots against cavities warnings keep out of reach of Pred: fluoride +What is the active ingredient in children under 6 years of age. +this? ingredients. active ingredient - purpose. sodium fluoride (0. 24%) - anticavity toothpaste. +Pred: fluoride +inactive ingredients: sorbitol, water, hydrated silica, peg-32, sodium lauryl sulfate, ...... +fluoride-containing compounds in the form of sodium monofluorophosphate, sodium +Pred: toothpaste +fluoride and stannous fluoride are used as anticaries agents in toothpastes. +RA-VQA sucessfully retrieved more relevant documents. +RAVQA-Frozen +catcher is a position for a baseball or softball player. when a batter takes their turn to hit, the +catcher crouches behind home plate, in front of the (home) umpire, and receives the ball Pred: Catcher +from the pitcher..... +..... +RAVQA (ours) +catcher is a position for a baseball or softball player. when a batter takes their turn to hit, the +catcher crouches behind home plate, in front of the (home) umpire, and receives the ball Pred: Batter +from the pitcher...... +What position does the man with +..... +the bat play? +Even with the same retrieved document, RA-VQA learned to retrieve correct answers. +Notations +Prediction (correct / wrong) +Pred: answer +with the given knowledge +Pred: answer Selected as final prediction +Figure6: AcasestudycomparingRA-VQA-FrDPR(baseline)andourRA-VQAthatbenefitsfromjointtraining +ofretrievalandanswergeneration. -2        Health Informatics (HI) - -HI 60418     CLINICAL ANALYTICS II      3 Credit Hours -As the volume and complexity of health data continues to grow, analysis -of that data requires more advanced tools to transform that data into -meaningful information for clinical decisions. Not only is data from -electronic medical records (EMRs) growing at a rapid pace but new -types of data are available for analysis, such as, genomic data and -patient generated data. These advanced analytic tools break down into -three areas, each of which will be examined in this course: new data -warehousing techniques to manage big data, new analytic tools including -cognitive computing and predictive analytics and new ways to visualize -the data. All of these techniques transform the raw data into use cases, -such as, population health, precision medicine and clinical decision -support using artificial intelligence and machine learning which will also -be addressed in this course. -Prerequisite: HI 60411; and graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60419     CONSUMER HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -This course examines the history and current trends in consumer health -informatics, examining how patients and healthcare stakeholders -manage health in the digital age. The evolution of health information -technology has expanded the role of the patient to include being -a consumer of healthcare, bringing with it more capabilities and -responsibilities. The course will discuss health information and -communication technologies and their influence on health care for -patients, affecting health information seeking behaviors and expectations -among multiple stakeholder groups. The course will discuss US and -global perspectives for health information professionals serving health -information needs in the community and in medical, academic, and public -libraries. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60636     STANDARDIZED TERMINOLOGIES IN HEALTHCARE      3 -Credit Hours -Introduce various types of standardized healthcare terminologies -(controlled vocabularies) used in the Electronic Health Records -(EHR) and Health information Exchange (HIE). Present the benefits of -using standardized terminologies, as well as the interoperability and -Meaningful Use (MU) requirements and standards. Explain the purposes, -structures, components, and application of the most widely implemented -standardized terminologies such as ICD, CPT, SNOMED CT, LOINC, -RxNorm, ICNP and UMLS. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60691     SEMINAR IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 80691) Advanced research by -students who are qualified to examine problems of certain special areas -in health informatics. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Seminar -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - - HI 60693     VARIABLE TITLE WORKSHOP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit). Intensive examination of special topics of interest -to those involved in health informatics program. Maximum workshop -credit for the M.S. degree in health informatics is 4 semester hours. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Workshop -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory - -HI 60792     ELECTIVE INTERNSHIP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      2-3 -Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Supervised work experience in health informatics -of a professional nature of not less than 100 clock hours (for 2 credit -hours) or 150 clock hours (for 3 credit hours). -Prerequisite: Graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Practical Experience -Contact Hours: 6.66-10 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 61095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 81095) Offered irregularly as -resources and or opportunities permit. Topics could include current or -emerging issues in health informatics. Specific topics are announced in -the Schedule of Classes. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 61096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Research or individual investigation in areas not -covered by the existing curriculum for master's level students. Maximum -6 credit hours towards master's degree. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP - -HI 66092     MASTER'S INTERNSHIP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -Supervised work experience of an advanced professional nature that -concentrates on developing skills in areas of health informatics and -integrates their knowledge from all HI courses and experiences. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Practical Experience -Contact Hours: 10 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66099     MASTER'S PROJECT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit -Hours -Provides a means for the application of the knowledge, research and -competencies learned through study in health informatics to the -development of an information system, product, setting or service. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum overall 3.000 GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Project or Capstone -Contact Hours: 3 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           3 - -HI 66198     MASTER'S RESEARCH PAPER IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -Under the advisement of a faculty member, students will complete a -research paper that serves as a culminating experience for the Health -Informatics master's degree. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Research -Contact Hours: 9 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66199     THESIS I      2-6 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Thesis students must register for a total of -6 hours, 2 to 6 hours in a single semester distributed over several -semesters if desired. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Masters Thesis -Contact Hours: 6-18 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66299     THESIS II      2 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Thesis students must continue registration each -semester until all degree requirements are met. -Prerequisite: HI 66199; and graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Masters Thesis -Contact Hours: 6 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 80401     HEALTH INFORMATICS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60401) This introductory course is a survey course -that acts as a foundation for all other courses in the Health Informatics -program. Basic concepts of Health Informatics are emphasized -throughout. The course targets students who at some point in their -career will oversee or have direct input on one of the highest expenditure -areas for health care organizations--the planning, selection, deployment, -and management of electronic medical records (EMR), management -decision-support and tracking systems (DSS), and other health -information technologies (health IT). -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Health Informatics (HI)           3 - - 4        Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026 - -HI 80402     LEGAL ISSUES IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60402) This course provides students with an -introduction to the fundamentals of law for Health Informatics and -Information Management. Components of the learning will include -general legal principles and regulatory issues in the U.S. healthcare -system. Primary topics will include ethical issues, consideration of state -laws and the Federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act -(HIPAA), privacy and security rules. Through discussion board and writing -assignments, students will demonstrate understanding of practical -issues of health information access, its use and disclosure, and the -legal and regulatory consequences associated with breaches of health -information confidentiality and security. We will explore some of the -special legal issues with electronic health records (EHR) and health -information exchange; secondary uses of health information; compliance; -and related ethics issues. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80411     CLINICAL ANALYTICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60411) The use of well-defined and well integrated -clinical analytics throughout the healthcare value chain can be -transformative. Through careful implementation of health analytics, -hospitals can transform unwieldy amalgamations of data into -information that can: Improve patient outcomes, increase safety, -enhance operational efficiency and support public health. Given the -immense size of the data challenge, the distinctness and geographic -spread of many healthcare-related activities, and the fact that so many -healthcare activities are conducted by different entities which must -interact with each other, there is really no other way to provide operations -management tools necessary to deliver personalized medicine and to -control spiraling costs. Since clinical analytics is an immature discipline, -we carefully examine the practices of those institutions that are standard -setters in the industry. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80403     HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60403) Introduction to information systems and their -applications in healthcare used for managerial and clinical support. -Study the fundamentals of information systems, including Electronic -Medical Records (EMR), information security. Understand the role of -standardized codes, vocabularies and terminologies used in health -information systems. Analysis of management and enterprise systems, -identify the key elements to manage information resources effectively -and the trends affecting the development of health information systems -and networks. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80410     HEALTH RECORDS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60410) This course examines Health Information -Management, the role of the HIM professional in the context of the -health system and the role of the health record. The role of information -management and documentation principles is essential to the successful -application of technology and ensuring an effective health information -infrastructure. The course discusses confidentiality, privacy, security, -reliable standards, data integrity, quality, governance, and ethical -principles that make health care information of use for organizations and -individuals. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80412     CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60412) Provides a practical survey of clinical decision -support systems that collect clinical data and enable the transition to -clinical knowledge in real world applications intended to improve quality -and safety of patient care. Students become familiar with the basic -requirements for clinical decision support systems and the challenges -associated with the development and deployment of new applications -within the healthcare setting. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80413     CHANGE MANAGEMENT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60413) Designed to cover the process of change -management in large healthcare organizations in light of current trends. -Topics related to technology requirements, technology implementations, -risk assessment, end user computing and buy-in are among those -covered. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80414     HUMAN FACTORS AND USABILITY IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -     3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60414) Provides students with the foundational -principles of usability and human factors as applied to safety and quality -in health informatics technology. Course readings and materials review -the concepts of human factors, usability, and the cognitive consequences -of health information technology on clinical performance and decision -making. Attention is given to the role of mobile computing in health care, -as well as information visualization. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -4        Health Informatics (HI) - - Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           5 - -HI 81096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit). Research or individual investigation in areas -not covered by the existing curriculum for doctoral level students. -Deliverables determined with instructor of record. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP - -HI 80416     HEALTH INFORMATICS ISSUES: POLICY, POLITICS AND -ETHICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60416) This course uses a policy analysis lens to -critically examine issues related to the use of information technology in -healthcare from an ethical, political and regulatory perspective. Course's -primary focus is on the United States, but international approaches are -also be discussed. Legislation affecting health information technology -area are examined,including the American Reinvestment and Recovery -Act, HITECH section; Affordable Care Act and Health Insurance Portability -and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996. Topics and issues related to -health informatics also are discussed, including structure of health -administrative and delivery systems, assessment of population health, -models of health care delivery, access and quality of care. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80417     PUBLIC HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60417) Public Health Informatics (PHI) is an emergent, -interdisciplinary field that focuses on the systematic management -and dynamic application of information resources to enhance public -health practice, education and research. As an emerging subset of -Health Informatics, PHI is practiced by individuals, governmental and -nongovernmental organizations at the international, national, regional, -state and local levels. PHI deals with the collection and analysis of vital -statistics data through surveillance; information creation; information -storage and retrieval; visualization and graphics; dissemination; use of -information for policy, decision making and trend tracking. The purpose -of this course is to provide students with an introductory overview of -the vast and dynamic field of PHI, including definitions, approaches, -competencies, applications and informatics principles applied in public -health settings. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80691     SEMINAR IN HEALH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 60691) Advanced research by -students who are qualified to examine problems of certain special areas -in health informatics. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Seminar -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 81095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 61095) Offered irregularly as -resources and or opportunities permit. Topics could include current or -emerging issues in health informatics. Specific topics are announced in -the Schedule of Classes. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Health Informatics (HI)           5 +temprovidedintheofficialFVQAdatasetpaper. +(2) GCN (Narasimhan et al., 2018b): a +model that leverages graph convolutional net- +works (GCNs) to aggregate features from vi- +sual/language/factmodalities. +(3)Mucko(Zhuetal.,2020): thecurrentstate- +of-the-artsystemthatusesGCNstocombinevisual, +fact,andsemanticgraphs. +Model Accuracy(Std.) Recall@5(Std.) +Mucko 73.06( – ) - +RAVQA 69.88(0.13) 68.77(0.87) +GCN 69.35( – ) - +RAVQA-FrDPR 68.81(0.59) 64.54(0.80) +RAVQA-NoDPR 67.93(0.82) - +FVQA 58.76(0.92) - +Table 7: Model performance on the FVQA dataset +(sortedbyaccuracy).Ourproposedsystemsareinbold. +AsshowninTable7,RAVQA-NoDPRachieves +an already strong result (67.93% accuracy) com- +pared to early work in FVQA, showing that the +extracted vision-to-language features are useful +and text-based Transformers are able to learn to +answer commonsense VQA questions well with- +outaccessingtheprovidedknowledgegraph(Con- +ceptNet). The incorporation of DPR boosts the +performance to 68.81% with 64.54% Recall@5, +showingthatretrievalworksasexpectedandthere- +trievedknowledgetripletsareexploitedinanswer +generation. Thejointtrainingschemeimprovesthe +retrieval(64.54%to68.77%Recall@5)aswellas +theoverallperformance(68.81%to69.88%Accu- +racy). This demonstrates that our proposed joint +training framework is generalizable to other KB- +VQAtasks,thoughthepassagesusedinretrieval +aresimplyflattenedsurfacetextsofKGtriplets. +IncomparingwithothersystemsintheFVQA +benchmark,ourbestsystemrankssecondwithout +an explicit design for leveraging KG structures. +Thisshowsthepowerofopen-endedanswergen- +erationwithtext-basedTransformers. Butweem- +phasisethatbetterperformancecouldbeachieved +throughdesigningamorespecialisedretrievalcom- +ponentforthestructuredknowledgebaseusedin +thistask. +To summarise, our system shows great gener- +alizability in an external KB-VQA task that was +constructed very differently. Therefore, the pro- +posed framework can serve as a strong basis for +futureimprovements. +| Model | T5 GPT-3 | K K | Knowl.Src. | PRRecall EM | VQAScore | +| ----- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | +train test +| ConceptBERT | × × | - - | C | | 33.66 | +| ------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----------- | +| KRISP | × × | - - | C+W | | 38.35 | +| VRR | × × | 100 100 | GS(trn/full) | | 39.22/45.08 | +| MAVEx | × × | - - | W+C+GI | | 39.40 | +| KAT-T5 | (cid:88) × | 40 40 | W | | 44.25 | +| TRiG | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | W | 49.21 | 45.51 | +| TRiG | (cid:88) × | 100 100 | W | 53.59 | 49.35 | +| TRiG-Ensemble | (cid:88) × | 100 100 | W | 54.73 | 50.50 | +| TRiG* | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | GS(trn/full) | 52.79 | 45.11/48.32 | +| RAG* | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | GS(trn/full) | 82.34 52.52 | 44.90/48.22 | +RA-VQA(Ours) (cid:88) × 5 5 GS(trn/full) 82.84 58.72 48.77/53.81 +RA-VQA(Ours) (cid:88) × 5 50 GS(trn/full) 96.55 59.41 49.24/54.48 +AblationStudy +RA-VQA-FrDPR (cid:88) × 5 5 GS(trn/full) 81.25 55.77 47.05/51.22 +| RA-VQA-NoPR | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | GS(full) | 77.67 57.80 | 52.98 | +| ----------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | +| RA-VQA-FrDPR-NoCT | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | GS(full) | 81.25 54.99 | 50.66 | +| RA-VQA-NoCT | (cid:88) × | 5 5 | GS(full) | 83.77 57.51 | 52.67 | +GPT-3-basedSystems(>175BillionParameters) +(cid:88) +| PICa | × | - - | GPT-3 | | 48.00 | +| ---- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | +(cid:88) (cid:88) +| KAT-Knowledge-T5 | | 40 40 | W+GPT-3 | | 51.97 | +| ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----- | +(cid:88) (cid:88) +| KAT-Ensemble | | 40 40 | W+GPT-3 | | 54.41 | +| ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----- | +Table 8: Full table of RA-VQA vs Baseline Systems. Knowledge Sources: ConceptNet; Wikipedia; Google +Search; Google Images; GPT-3 closed book knowledge. ‘GS (trn/full)’ indicates if the Google Search data is +constrainedtocontainonlydocumentsrelevanttotrainingquestions. PRRecall,HSR,FSR,andEMarereported +on‘GS(full)’systemsaspercentage(%). PRRecallisreportedatthecorrespondingK . +test \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q231/random_k4/random_4.md b/q231/random_k4/random_4.md index 89df54c010831780605bc9c91d547406d9ddb498..310f0f860924656c9ab9a27398fe83594f525660 100644 --- a/q231/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q231/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,2646 +1,1527 @@ -Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 1 of 21 +Department of the Treasury +Departmental Offices -Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) -twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com -Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) -rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com -Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) -tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com -Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) -abrown@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 -Burbank, CA 91505-4521 -Telephone: 310-474-9111 -Facsimile: 310-474-8585 +FY 2025 -Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class - -UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - -NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA - -THOMAS THELE, individually and on -behalf of all others similarly situated, - -Case No. 5:25-cv-09704 - -Plaintiff, - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL - -v. - -GOOGLE LLC, - -Defendant. +Capital Investment Plan 1 -2 + Standard IT Investments ...................................................................................................... 3 -3 +Treasury Shared Services Security Operations Center (TSSSOC) .............................................. 3 -4 +Major IT Investments .......................................................................................................... 4 -5 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Cloud Enterprise ................................................ 4 -6 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Multi-Factor Authentication .............................. 6 -7 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Other Cyber Priorities ....................................... 7 -8 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Security Logging ............................................... 9 -9 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Universal Encryption ...................................... 11 -10 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Zero Trust Architecture ................................... 12 -11 +HR LoB - HRConnect ................................................................................................................ 14 -12 +Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM) ........................ 16 -13 +Major Non-IT Investments ................................................................................................ 19 -14 +Main Treasury Building and Freedman's Bank Building .......................................................... 19 -15 +2 -16 + Note to Reviewers: Consistent with the corresponding Summary of Capital Investments table, the +columns included in the investment tables below are defined as: -17 +FY 2023 Actuals -Total actual obligations. +FY 2024 Estimated Obligations- Anticipated obligations from all budgetary resources (e.g., balances +from prior years, user fees, and FY 2023 Operating levels). +FY 2025 Estimated Obligations - Anticipated obligations from all budgetary resources (e.g., balances +from prior years, user fees, and FY 2025 President’s budget). -18 +Standard IT Investments -19 +Treasury Shared Services Security Operations Center (TSSSOC) -20 +Description: +TSSSOC functions as the Department wide security operations center providing security monitoring, +incident coordination, incident response, and reporting. TSSSOC operates 24x7x365 and actively +coordinates with other federal agencies, DoD, and the IC. -21 +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -22 +T y p e -23 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -24 +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -25 +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -26 +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -27 +C h a n g e i n +$ -28 +% C h a n g e -- i - +2 . 2 6 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +1 . 0 9 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 2 of 21 +1 . 0 9 -Plaintiff Thomas Thele (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly +0 -situated (the “Class” or “Class Members”), by and through his undersigned counsel, brings this +0% -class action complaint against Defendant Google LLC (“Google” or “Defendant”). +1 5 . 4 4 -I. +1 7 . 7 0 -INTRODUCTION +1 4 . 75 -1. +1 5 . 8 4 -Much like its competitors, Google has developed and deployed an artificial +1 5 . 1 9 -intelligence program named Gemini throughout its portfolio of services. Some of Google’s most +1 6 . 2 8 -popular services include Gmail, Chat, and Meet, which millions of Americans use every day to +0 . 4 4 -email, instant message, and videoconference, respectively. Until recently, Google users could “opt +0 . 4 4 -in” and turn on Gemini as a “Smart” feature for these services, purportedly to “personalize [their] +2.98% -experience”: +2.78% -1 +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -2 +The Treasury Shared Services Security Operations Center (TSSSOC) provides leadership and oversight +for the offices and bureaus across Treasury in all aspects of cybersecurity operations. The program is +responsible for ensuring implementation of the Federal Information Security Modernization Act (FISMA) +of 2014 as well as other federal laws and guidance related to cybersecurity operations. The program also +provides central coordination and reporting on cybersecurity operational metrics and programs to external +agencies and sets Treasury cybersecurity operations standards and guidance. TSSSOC also provides +departmental situational awareness of cybersecurity incidents and coordinates response to intrusion +activity. The program also serves as a lead in implementing the Treasury Cybersecurity Strategy. + +Investments have contributed to Treasury's success in defending against cyber adversaries and provides +leadership and direction in mitigating threats to Treasury systems and services. Future objectives include: +collecting and storing data from all bureaus to meet M-21-31 objectives, expanding TSSSOC to offer +additional security operations and incident response services to bureaus, and improving communication +and collaboration throughout the Department through automation. 3 -4 + Major IT Investments -5 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Cloud Enterprise -6 +Description: -7 +Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through +investment in the Treasury enterprise shared services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on +cloud security enhancement and upgraded capabilities to meet security and compliance risks will +involve investment in security controls, monitoring, and increased threat protections by providing a +common cloud operating platform for Departmental workloads, inclusive of all security elements +required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance. Treasury’s recently awarded Blanket +Purchase Agreement (BPA) for cloud services (Treasury Cloud [TCloud]) will support our design, +development, and implementation of security patterns and guardrails with expanded Security +Operations Center (SOC) capabilities to accommodate increased telemetry from cloud assets and +workloads. -8 +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. -9 +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -10 +T y p e -11 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -12 +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -13 +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -14 +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -15 +C h a n g e i n +$ -16 +% C h a n g e -17 +2 0 . 0 7 -18 +2 5 . 3 3 -19 +1 5 . 8 0 -20 +- 9 . 5 3 -21 +- 3 7 . 6 1 % -22 +0 . 6 5 -23 +1 . 6 0 -24 +9 . 6 3 -25 +8 . 0 3 -26 +5 0 1 . 5 6 % -27 +2 0 . 7 2 -28 +2 6 . 9 3 -- 1 - +2 5 . 4 3 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +- 1 . 5 0 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 3 of 21 +- 5 . 5 7 % -1 +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -2 +The CEA cloud investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build stronger +protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. -3 +Through the CEA Cloud Enterprise investment, Treasury aims to improve, entice, and further +accelerate enterprise-wide cloud adoption through investment in the Treasury enterprise shared +services cloud environments. The Department’s focus on cloud security enhancement and upgraded +capabilities to meet security and compliance risks involves investment in security controls, monitoring, +and increased threat protections by providing a common cloud operating platform for Departmental +workloads, inclusive of all security elements required by Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance. 4 -5 + The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.4 million for Treasury’s CEA Cloud Enterprise +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -6 +• -7 +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an -8 +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. -9 +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement -10 +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. -11 +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the -12 +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. -13 +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate -14 +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. -15 +In FY2025, CEA – Cloud Enterprise investments are targeted to the Department’s cloud focused +modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments will build +on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. -16 +• Treasury seeks to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +• Bureau of the Fiscal Service cloud cybersecurity modernization and the necessary human -17 +capital to support initiatives. -18 +• Cloud security resources (engineers, ISSM, etc.) to support the FY2023 awarded enterprise -19 +TCloud contract and program. -20 +• Application migrations from on-premises to cloud environments and/or from unique Bureau -21 +environments to the enterprise cloud platform. -22 +• -23 +Incident response infrastructure to support coordination and communication in an -24 +uncompromised environment for response and recovery activities. -25 +• Migration of National Security System infrastructure to the cloud. +• Operations, maintenance, and ongoing investment in a sustainable low code cloud platforms +(i.e., ServiceNow, Salesforce) to support organizational capabilities, to include +Cybersecurity Governance, Risk, and Compliance; CEA Administration and Governance; +and Security. -26 +• Storage support for enterprise logging collection and utilization of historic logs to support -27 +threat hunt and threat detection activities, as well as additional behavioral analytics. +• Expansion of the Department’s enterprise offering for public-facing, cloud-based web hosting -28 +that includes an Akamai CDN with robust DoS and bot protections, a Drupal content +management system, and additional centralized site shield, web performance and +readiness/response investments that integrate with Treasury’s security operations +capabilities for threat detection and response. -2. +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: -However, on or about October 10, 2025, Google secretly turned on Gemini for all +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -its users’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, enabling AI to track its users’ private communications +threats. -contained in those platforms without the users’ knowledge or consent. As of the date of this filing, +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -Google continues to track these private communications with Gemini by default, requiring users to +sharing. -affirmatively find this data privacy setting and shut it off, despite never “agreeing” to such AI +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -tracking in the first place (“When you turn this setting on, you agree . . . .”). +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -3. +5 -Despite users never giving Google informed consent to track and store their private + Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Multi-Factor Authentication -communications, Google does just that, using Gemini AI to access and exploit the entire recorded +Description: -history of its users’ private communications, including literally every email and attachment sent +Treasury’s investment in Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) supports our development and +implementation of compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a +critical component of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, +including nation state actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications +by certifying identity with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an +authentication mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities +include strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption, +and strategic partnerships to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all Treasury Bureaus and +Offices. -and received in their Gmail accounts. +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. -4. +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -Google’s deceptive and outrageous conduct violates its users’ reasonable +T y p e -expectations of privacy. The intent and efforts of individuals to safeguard their private information +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -and communications must be respected. The ramifications of unauthorized access to voluminous +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -private communications can be severe, and individuals accordingly go to great lengths to safeguard +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -not only their own email and messaging accounts, but, in the case of parents and guardians, also +C h a n g e i n +$ -that of their minor children. +% C h a n g e -5. +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) -While falsely characterizing its illusory privacy controls, Google deceptively and +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -unconscionably deprived and continues to deprive Plaintiff and Class Members of their privacy +0 . 0 0 -right to send and receive private communications via email, chat, and video. This is true not only +0 . 0 0 -for Plaintiff and Class Members, but also for their children, whose private communications they +0 . 0 0 -also sought to protect. +5 . 1 0 -6. +0 . 6 0 -Google’s conduct violates the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Pen. Code +5 . 7 0 -§§ 630, et seq. (“CIPA”)), the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (Cal. Pen. Code § +0 . 0 0 -502 (“CDAFA”)), the Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq. (“SCA”)), and +- 5 . 1 0 -California’s Constitutional Right to Privacy, and it constitutes an unlawful intrusion upon +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % -seclusion. +2 . 5 0 -II. +2 . 5 0 -THE PARTIES +1 . 9 0 -7. +3 1 6 . 6 7 % -Plaintiff Thomas Thele resides in Cook County, Illinois. From at least October 10, +- 3 . 2 0 -- 2 - +- 5 6 . 1 4 % -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 4 of 21 +The CEA multi-factor authentication (MFA) investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. -1 +Through the CEA Multi-Factor Authentication investment, Treasury aims to develop and implement +compliant technologies for internal systems and applications. This investment is a critical component +of the Department’s solutions to prevent unauthorized access by adversaries, including nation state +actors. MFA is a layered approach to security access to network or applications by certifying identity +with a combination of two or more approved pieces of evidence (or factors) to an authentication +mechanism. The Department’s investment in, and sustainment of, MFA capabilities include +strengthening MFA governance, ongoing investment in enterprise solutions to boost adoption of MFA, +and strategic partnerships with industry partners to streamline MFA related procurement effort for all +Treasury Bureaus and Offices. -2 +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $2.5 million for Treasury’s CEA Multi-Factor +Authentication investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -3 +• -4 +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an -5 +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. 6 -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -2025 until the present, Plaintiff has maintained and used, and continues to maintain and use, his - -Google account, including the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services. Plaintiff values his privacy—and + In FY2025, CEA – Multi-Factor Authentication investment is targeted to the Department’s MFA- +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. -the privacy of his family and friends—in the use of these password-protected services and +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: +Conversion to Active Directory (AD) Federation that provides for the authorization, authentication, +and SSO functionality to applications and services virtually anywhere, including perimeter networks, +partner organizations, and the cloud. -reasonably expected the messages and conversations therein to remain private. Despite this +• Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -reasonable expectation, Google surreptitiously turned on the “Smart features” setting in Plaintiff’s +threats. -Data privacy settings without Plaintiff’s knowledge or consent and began tracking Plaintiff’s +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -private communications with Gemini AI. Throughout the relevant time period, Plaintiff regularly +sharing. -used his Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts throughout the day, unaware that Google’s Gemini AI +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -was monitoring and tracking those private messages and conversations. In the interest of protecting +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -his privacy and security, Plaintiff does not recite here the precise Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Other Cyber Priorities -communications that he sent or received with the “Smart features” setting surreptitiously turned on +Description: -during the relevant time, but he does allege that the following could be determined from those +Treasury maintains investment in Other Cybersecurity Priorities that address and respond to the +changing threat landscape of the Department, given our interconnected technology environment, which +has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the security posture of high value assets, national +security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, cybersecurity governance, risk, and +compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient +future through the acquisition of federal labor cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our +complex technology portfolio, as well as the necessary resources to support the overall administration +and governance of Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) appropriations and the ongoing +performance of cybersecurity investments. -communications: financial information and records, employment information and records, religious +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. -affiliations and activities, political affiliations and activities, medical care and records, the identities +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -of his family, friends, and other contacts, social habits and activities, eating habits, shopping habits, +T y p e -exercise habits, the extent to which he is involved in the activities of his children (if any), and what +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -those activities are. +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -8. +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -Defendant Google LLC is a limited liability company headquartered in Mountain +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -View, California, and formed under the laws of Delaware. Google is a sophisticated mobile +C h a n g e i n +$ -operating system, email, and applications developer in the business of commercializing personal +% C h a n g e -data extracted from the use of tools and services connected to the internet. As such, Google is aware +1 7 . 7 9 -of and benefits from the conduct described herein. Indeed, this forms a core component, among +2 . 7 3 -others, of Google’s business model. +6 . 0 5 -III. +3 . 3 2 -JURISDICTION AND VENUE +1 2 1 . 5 4 % -9. +8 . 7 5 -This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. +2 6 . 5 5 -§§ 1332 and 1367 because this is a class action in which the matter or controversy exceeds the sum +1 2 . 9 0 -of $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and in which some Members of the proposed Class +1 5 . 6 3 -are citizens of a state different from Defendant. +1 8 . 9 0 -- 3 - +2 4 . 9 5 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +6 . 0 1 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 5 of 21 +4 6 . 5 8 % -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 +9 . 3 3 -6 +5 9 . 6 8 % 7 -8 - -9 + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -10 +The CEA investment for other cybersecurity priorities focuses on an enterprise-wide investment +approach to build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With +the creation of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to +develop and enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and +drive a more robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, +protect, recover, and respond to cybersecurity events. -11 +Through the CEA Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment, Treasury maintains investment in +initiatives that address and respond to the changing threat landscape of the Department, given our +interconnected technology environment, which has amplified the need for identifying and assessing the +security posture of high value assets, national security systems infrastructure, Treasury’s supply chain, +cybersecurity governance, risk, and compliance (GRC), amongst other necessary priorities. +Additionally, Treasury is investing in a resilient future through the acquisition of federal labor +cybersecurity subject matter expertise to support our complex technology portfolio, as well as the +necessary resources to support the overall administration and governance of CEA appropriations and +the ongoing performance of cybersecurity investments. -12 +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $25.0 million for Treasury’s CEA Other Cybersecurity +Priorities investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -13 +• -14 +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an -15 +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. -16 +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement -17 +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. -18 +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the -19 +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. -20 +• Respond to Detected Cybersecurity Incidents Goal: Develop and implement appropriate -21 +activities to take action regarding a detected cybersecurity incident. -22 +In FY2025, CEA – Other Cybersecurity Priorities investment is targeted to the Department’s cyber +priorities focused om modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. -23 +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: -24 +• Establish a repeatable programmatic structure to review, assess, and govern emerging -25 +technologies (i.e., quantum, Artificial Intelligence [AI], etc.) to ensure applications of all +security standards develop consistent policies, workforce planning, reporting, Bureau +adherence, ethical use, etc. -26 +• Acquisition of an enterprise EDR solution +• Workforce focused cyber awareness and other supplemental trainings +• Enhanced security compliance of a low code platform through Enhanced Adoption and -27 +Automation of Change Management/Enablement, as well as increased use of common +controls. -28 +• Evolution of the Enterprise Cyber Risk Management (ECRM) initiative which will continue to -10. +strengthen Treasury's approach to managing risks across the enterprise and instantiate a +continuous review of all of its critical networks, systems, and data. -This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant owns and +8 -operates a business that is headquartered in this District and conducts substantial business + • Development of a low code Configuration Management Database (CMDB) solution, +encompassing both Asset Management and Configuration Management. +• Development of a Risk Management Framework for enterprise infrastructure +• -throughout California. Defendant expressly consents to the jurisdiction of the federal or state courts +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component to -of Santa Clara County, California through its terms of service.1 +address current and emerging cyber priorities such as Supply Chain Risk Management +(SCRM) and incident response support. -11. +• Performance of enterprise-level FISMA readiness assessments. +• Facilitation of an Enterprise Cyber BPA ordering capability (PROTECTS) +• -Venue properly lies in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1), as Defendant +Investment in an Annual Threat Hunt that identifies a random sampling of Treasury systems to -is headquartered in this District. +identify anomalies beyond traditional detection methodologies. -IV. CHOICE OF LAW +Acquisition of Incident Response support, allowing for defined response timeline in the +event of a compromise and need for SME and resource depth. -12. +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: -California law governs the substantive legal issues in this case. Google’s Terms of +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -Service provide in pertinent part that California law will apply to any disputes arising out of or +threats. -relating to Google’s terms of service.2 +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -V. +sharing. -STATEMENT OF FACTS +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -13. +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -According to recent reporting, an estimated 1.8 billion people globally in 2025 have +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Security Logging -active Gmail accounts.3 It is estimated that 41.9% of United States citizens use Gmail, which +Description: -amounts to over 130 million American users.4 +Treasury’s investments in Security Logging ensure compliance with Office of Management and +Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security logging capabilities +to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. Investment funding targets +the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, storage and retention of +log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the creation of user +behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The investment objective +is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security operations center at +the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center (TSSSOC). -14. +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. -In Google’s Gmail, Chat, and Meet services, users reasonably expect to customize +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -their use of these services to their preferences by managing various functionalities and settings. +T y p e -They can, for example, change their preferred language, time zone, or storage settings. Included +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -among these functionalities, within “Data privacy,” is the option to turn on or off Google’s use of +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -“Smart features”—that is, Google’s ability to track the user’s “email, chat, and video content” with +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -its Gemini AI technology. In its terms of service, Google’s only reference to AI is in the context of +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -“develop[ing], improv[ing], and updat[ing]” its services: +C h a n g e i n +$ -We’re constantly developing new technologies and features to improve -our services. For example, we use artificial intelligence and machine -learning to provide you with simultaneous translations, and to better -detect and block spam and malware. As part of this continual +% C h a n g e -1 Google Terms of Service (last modified May 22, 2024), available at -https://policies.google.com/terms?hl=en. -2 Id. -3 Robert A. Lee, Gmail Statistics 2025: User Growth, Market Share & Emerging Trends, SQ -MAGAZINE, Aug. 6, 2025, available at https://sqmagazine.co.uk/gmail-statistics/. -4 Id.; see also Dominic Reigns, 35+ Gmail Statistics And User Trends [2025 Updated], ABOUT -CHROMEBOOKS, Aug. 7, 2025, available at https://www.aboutchromebooks.com/gmail-statistics/. -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +2 5 . 6 6 -- 4 - +2 . 4 8 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 6 of 21 +2 9 . 4 1 -improvement, we sometimes add or remove features and functionalities, -increase or decrease limits to our services, and start offering new -services or stop offering old ones.5 +2 6 . 9 3 1 , 0 8 8 . 2 4 % -In its privacy policy, Google states that “across our services, you can adjust your privacy settings +0 . 0 0 -to control whether we collect some types of data and how we use it.”6 +2 5 . 6 6 -15. +4 . 0 0 -On information and belief, Google turned on this “Smart features” option—without +6 . 4 8 -any notice to users—for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts on or about October 10, 2025, which +1 1 . 9 2 -enabled Gemini AI to scan, read, and analyze every email (and email attachment), message, and +7 . 9 2 -conversation on those services. Google users now must proactively go into their account settings +1 9 7 . 9 0 % -and locate and turn off this feature to prevent Gemini AI from tracking their Gmail, Chat, or Meet +4 1 . 3 3 -communications. Despite this setting being in default, “opt out” status since at least October 10, +3 4 . 8 5 -the setting is still worded as an “opt in” feature: “When you turn this setting on, you agree . . .” +5 3 8 . 2 2 % -(emphasis added). Google’s secretive Gmail, Chat, and Meet tracking practices are not only +9 -deceptive and unethical, they are directly contrary to users’ reasonable expectations of privacy. + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -16. +The CEA security logging investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. -It appears that even tech journalists monitoring Google’s use of Gemini AI in Gmail +Through the CEA Security Logging investment, Treasury ensures compliance with Office of +Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum 21-31 (M-21-31) to develop and implement security +logging capabilities to receive, store, analyze, and process security event and system log data. +Investment funding targets the creation and monitoring of data-stream disruptions, a shared log facility, +storage and retention of log data, development of threat hunt and incident response playbooks, and the +creation of user behavioral analytics capabilities to support detection of malicious behavior. The +investment objective is for all logs to be accessible and visible for the highest level (enterprise) security +operations center at the Department, the Treasury Shared Services Security Operation Center +(TSSSOC). -are not fully aware of this change. Recent articles about using Gemini in Google services like Gmail +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $41.3 million for Treasury’s CEA Security Logging +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -still characterize the feature as something that must be agreed to and affirmatively turned on.7 +• -Nonetheless, this reporting confirms that, when active, Gemini is “downright creepy” in its ability +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an -to track, analyze, and immediately know private information: +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. -In testing [Gemini in Gmail], it was able to tell me useful information, -such as when my next Trade coffee delivery would arrive and if I had -any pressing emails that required responses. But it goes far beyond that. +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement -When I asked it about my first crush, Gemini was able to determine that -it occurred in elementary school, as well as tell me the name of my first -love, how we met, and when. Upon request, Gemini also told me who -my top Facebook friends were in 2009 and who my best friend was in -2010. Gemini even explained that one of my character flaws is that I get -“too laser-focused on what [I] want, which extracts a toll on [my] -relationships, much like Drake from the Uncharted game.” And, yes, +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. -5 Supra n.1. -6 Google Privacy Policy (last modified July 1, 2025), available at -https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US. -7 Ruben Circelli, I Let Gemini Access My Gmail, and It’s Downright Creepy, PC MAG, Nov. 5, -2025, available at https://www.pcmag.com/opinions/i-let-gemini-access-my-gmail-and-its- -downright-creepy. +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the -- 5 - +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +In FY2025, CEA – Security Logging investment is targeted to the Department’s security logging +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. -1 +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: -2 +• Security Logging efforts to protect against Distributed Denial-of-Services (DDoS) and other +cyber-attacks including 1) increase of storage for Treasury Trusted Internet Connection +(TIC) packet capture data, allowing rapid forensic analysis of suspected attacks; 2) +expansion of Web Application Firewall (WAF) capabilities for applications and services +across the Department; and 3) implementation of indexers at the Network Colocations +which will provide critical cyber visibility and analytics. -3 +• -4 +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary -5 +to strengthen threat analysis, provide Security Operations Center (SOC) support for +sustained cyber attacks, and establish, operate, and maintain the Treasury logging platform. -6 +• Expansion of the SOC to provide enterprise SOC capabilities for Treasury bureaus, including -7 +Operations analysts, intake support, Threat & Research analysts, enhanced capabilities, and +associated equipment. -8 +• -9 +Investment in cloud-based log processing, storage, and platform licenses. 10 -11 + Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: -12 +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -13 +threats. -14 +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -15 +sharing. -16 +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -17 +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -18 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Universal Encryption -19 +Description: -20 +The Department’s investment in Universal Encryption supports our commitment to fully achieve +encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary guidance (i.e., Office of +Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security Agency [CISA], and +others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest (DAR) and data in transit +(DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our environment, proposed +solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for compliance with encryption +standards and requirements. -21 +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. -22 +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -23 +T y p e -24 +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -25 +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -26 +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -27 +C h a n g e i n +$ -28 +% C h a n g e - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 7 of 21 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) -that’s one of my favorite game franchises, which apparently Gemini -knows, too. +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -How does Gemini know that? The simple answer is that the information -is somewhere within the 16 years’ worth of my email history that it can -access. +0 . 0 0 -. . . . +0 . 0 0 -I don’t plan on letting Gemini access my personal email anymore.8 +0 . 0 0 -17. +2 . 5 0 -Google is now able to collect and utilize users’ private communications through AI +0 . 4 8 -“Smart features” and combine it with existing data profiles it has for its users. Back in 2012, Google +2 . 9 8 -announced that it would eliminate distinctions between data collected from different Google +1 . 0 0 -products and services for purposes of its advertising, data analysis, and other activities, saying +- 1 . 5 0 -specifically that Google “may combine information you’ve provided from one service with +- 6 0 . 0 0 % -information from other services,” and “[w]e’ll treat you as a single user across all our products.”9 +0 . 0 0 -18. +1 . 0 0 -Through the use of its Gemini AI technology, Google has created the means to +- 0 . 4 8 -illicitly compile all of its users’ private communications on its platforms without those users’ +- 1 0 0 . 0 0 % -express knowledge and consent. The data from these communications enables Google to cross- +- 1 . 9 8 -reference and conduct unlimited analysis toward unmerited, improper, and monetizable insights +- 6 6 . 3 9 % -into users’ private lives, including their social, professional, and other relationships. +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -19. +The CEA universal encryption investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to build +stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation of a +centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. -The collection and use of users’ private communications violates users’ reasonable +Through the CEA Universal Encryption investment, the Department supports initiatives that work +toward full achievement of encryption protocols outlined in Executive Order 14028 and subsidiary +guidance (i.e., Office of Management and Budget [OMB], Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Security +Agency [CISA], and others). Our investment focuses on full adoption of encryption of data at rest +(DAR) and data in transit (DIT) for all Treasury systems and will address the unique challenges of our -expectations of privacy, and also puts them at increased risk for further privacy violations. Data +11 -breaches and other security vulnerabilities are increasingly common among companies that store + environment, proposed solutions, and the implementations necessary to address each system for +compliance with encryption standards and requirements. -user data. As a major aggregator of valuable personally identifying and other information, Google +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $1 million for Treasury’s CEA Universal Encryption +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -is an obvious target for hackers. Any information that Google stores through its Gemini AI platform +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement -may eventually be stolen, if it has not already been. In 2018, for example, Google announced that +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. -it had discovered a vulnerability in its Google+ program that exposed personal account information +In FY 2025, CEA – Universal Encryption investment is targeted to the Department’s universal +encryption focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our +investments will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared +services, enhance Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, +deliver greater visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and +protection capabilities. -to third-parties, contrary to its user agreements and representations. Reportedly, in order to protect +Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY 2025 appropriations: -8 Id. -9 Alma Whitten, Updating our privacy policies and terms of service, GOOGLE OFFICIAL BLOG -(Jan. 24, 2012), available at https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/updating-our-privacy- -policies-and-terms.html. +• -- 6 - +Investment in Quantum-Resistant Cryptography that could protect the Department against -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +cryptanalytic attacks by a quantum computer. -1 +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: -2 +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -3 +threats. -4 +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -5 +sharing. -6 +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -7 +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -8 +Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) - Zero Trust Architecture -9 +Description: -10 +Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) investment priorities at Treasury seek to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. -11 +Previously part of the Cybersecurity Enhancement Account (CEA) 015-000200319 Investment. 12 -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 + Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -20 +T y p e -21 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -22 +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -23 +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -24 +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -25 +C h a n g e i n +$ -26 +% C h a n g e -27 +1 4 . 8 1 -28 +3 3 . 1 0 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 8 of 21 +1 2 . 8 0 -its public image, Google failed to disclose that information to the public for months, and came clean +- 2 0 . 3 0 -only after the security risk was discovered by the media.10 +- 6 1 . 3 3 % -20. +1 2 . 2 7 -Each of the following acts defy social norms and invade reasonable privacy +2 7 . 0 8 -expectations: tracking private communications contrary to users’ consent, misleading users +9 . 2 0 -regarding whether the AI tracking required the users to opt out, and failing to disclose how AI was +4 2 . 0 0 -monitoring, tracking, and utilizing these private communications. Normally, mobile device and +3 2 . 8 0 -Internet users such as Plaintiff are able to affirmatively control the flow of sensitive information +3 5 6 . 5 2 % -about themselves through “settings” and “permissions” that they grant, or withhold, from third +4 2 . 3 0 -parties, particularly private parties such as Google. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ expectations +5 4 . 8 0 -that those settings and permissions would be heeded and effective, and that they could send and +1 2 . 5 0 -receive communications privately without being tracked by Google, are eminently reasonable. +2 9 . 5 5 % -21. +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -Plaintiff and Class Members took specific steps to protect their private +The CEA zero trust architecture investment focuses on an enterprise-wide investment approach to +build stronger protections and further benefit the bureaus in their cybersecurity goals. With the creation +of a centralized appropriation, administration, and governance, Treasury has been able to develop and +enhance Department-wide cloud services, support Bureau-level modernization goals, and drive a more +robust coordination of efforts to improve the Department’s ability to detect, identify, protect, recover, +and respond to cybersecurity events. -communications (as well as the private communications of their minor children) and had a +Through the Zero Trust Architecture investment, Treasury seeks to minimize implicit trust and +reinvigorate least privilege through a continual verification of each user, device, application, and +transition. The investment approach requires the Department to enhance visibility and threat detection +at the application level to improve its ability to support continuous threat analysis, detection, and +response, and enable to analysis of encrypted traffic. Compartmentalization, micro segmentation, and +reinforcing enforcement of continuous identity verification and conditional access policies will +improve our resistance to fraudulent tampering of privileged accounts. Our objective is a universal, +default security posture of “never trust, always verify” across our entire technology stack. Treasury +leverages the Zero Trust Architecture investment to provide additional human capital to support +management of service providers, as well as development, testing, and deployment of the applications +that have the security controls integrated into them. This investment also supports the Treasury Zero +Trust enterprise identity access solution, known as Common Approach to Identify Access Management +(CAIA), for all external federal partners who access the Enterprise Content Management (ECM) +SharePoint platform for shared services. -reasonable expectation that Google would not use AI to monitor and track their private +The FY 2025 President's Budget includes $54.8 million for Treasury’s CEA Zero Trust Architecture +investment with alignment to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework priorities: -communications without their informed consent. Based on Google’s representations and omissions, +• -context, and industry norms, they expected Google to heed and follow their instructions and, as a +Identify the Business Context, Resources & Cybersecurity Risk Goal: Develop an -result, expected that their private communications would be private, not tracked and utilized by +organizational understanding to manage cybersecurity risk to systems, people, assets, data, +and capabilities. -Google’s AI tool for Google’s own benefit and to the detriment of their personal privacy. Those +• Protect the Delivery of Critical Infrastructure Services Goal: Develop and implement -reasonable expectations were consistent with sentiments that are widely shared in American society +appropriate safeguards to ensure delivery of critical services. -and elsewhere, and grounded in long-standing social norms and jurisprudence protecting privacy. +• Detect Cybersecurity Events Goal: Develop and implement appropriate activities to identify the -22. +occurrence of a cybersecurity event. -Invasion of privacy has been recognized as a common law tort for more than a +In FY 2025, CEA – Zero Trust Architecture investments are targeted to the Department’s zero trust +focused modernization and the intrinsic enhancement of our cybersecurity posture. Our investments +will build on prior year accomplishments, continue investment in enterprise shared services, enhance +Department-wide coordination of cyber efforts, improve responsiveness to threats, deliver greater +visibility and information shared, and improve threat detection, identification, and protection +capabilities. -century. In Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965), the Supreme Court confirmed the +13 -primacy of privacy rights, explaining that the Constitution operates in the shadow of a “right of + Treasury is looking to support the following initiatives with final FY2025 appropriations: -10 Douglas MacMillan and Robert McMillan, Google Exposed User Data, Feared Repercussions -of Disclosing to Public, THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (Oct. 8, 2018), available at -https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared-repercussions-of-disclosing-to- -public-1539017194. Shortly thereafter, Google shut down the Google+ product entirely. Bill -Chappell, Google Accelerates Google+ Shutdown After 52.5 Million Users’ Data Exposed, NPR -(Dec. 11, 2018), available at https://www.npr.org/2018/12/11/675529798/with-52-5-million- -users-data-exposed-on-google-google-quickens-shutdown. +• Expansion of Treasury’s cyber threat intelligence platform to include additional cyber threat +intelligence feeds, additional material from existing feeds, and expand access to platform +capabilities and shared data. -- 7 - +• -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Implementation of a TSSSOC lateral scanning capability across enterprise application and -1 +centralized incident response -2 +• Acquisition of an enterprise Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solution +• -3 +Investment in Organizational Resiliency and the associated human capital component necessary -4 +to implement zero trust architecture across the Department’s IT systems -5 +• Bureau implementation of zero trust architecture +• Development or acquisition of Security Operations Center (SOC) services for the Treasury -6 +Security Data Network -7 +• Expansion of Treasury’s mobile Secret Internet Protocol Router (SIPR) capability +• Enterprise-wide vulnerability management efforts including the establishment of an enterprise +penetration testing shared service offering and acquisition of a vulnerability management +tool to track and conduct analysis of enterprise-wide critical vulnerabilities -8 +• Development of application threat modeling capabilities to prepare for increasing resilience of -9 +systems and robustness of testing. -10 +Looking forward, CEA investments will aim to accomplish the below future objectives: -11 +• Enhance Department-wide coordination of cybersecurity efforts and improve responsiveness to -12 +threats. -13 +• Provide leadership with greater visibility into cybersecurity efforts and encourage information -14 +sharing. -15 +Improve identification of cyber threats and better protect information systems from attack. -16 +• +• Provide platform to enhance communication, collaboration, and transparency. -17 +HR LoB - HRConnect -18 +Description: -19 +HR Connect is a Human Resources enterprise system. It is a web-based solution built on PeopleSoft +software. HR Connect transforms core back-office HR functions, moving them from a processing- +centric capability to a strategic-centric capability. -20 +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -21 +T y p e -22 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -23 +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -24 +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -25 +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -26 +C h a n g e i n +$ -27 +% C h a n g e -28 +1 2 . 2 8 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 9 of 21 +1 8 . 5 9 -1 +1 8 . 8 7 -2 +0 . 2 8 -3 +1 . 5 1% -4 +3 7 . 1 4 -5 +4 9 . 4 2 -6 +3 7 . 0 5 -7 +5 5 . 6 4 -8 +3 8 . 2 6 -9 +5 7 . 1 3 -10 +1 . 2 1 -11 +3 . 2 7% -12 +1 . 4 9 -13 +2 . 6 8 % 14 -15 - -16 - -17 + Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -18 +HRConnect is Treasury's enterprise human resources system. It is one of four federal OPM HR Lines +of Business providing HR services to the federal government. HRConnect is based on a combination of +(a) web-based solution built on PeopleSoft commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) software, (b) Software as +a Service (Saas) platforms (e.g. Talent Management and Career Connector) and (c) internally +developed applications (e.g. Entrance on Duty System). HRConnect transforms core back-office HR +functions, moving them from a processing-centric capability to a strategic-centric capability enabled +through its commercial software underpinning. Additionally, self-service components of the software +fundamentally transform the standard government HR service delivery model, putting additional +information, services and processes (i.e., personal data, position management, requests for personnel +action, recruitment, reporting, etc.) directly in the hands of managers and employees. -19 +HRConnect supports the common HR Line of Business processes and provides core HR functionality +that is interoperable, portable and scalable. This shared solution provides automated systems that are +configurable to the individual organizations' needs while providing a single solution across the +Department and federal landscape. HRConnect's core functions include: Personnel Action Processing, +Managing Payroll, Administering Benefits, Time and Attendance and Labor Distribution. By enabling +the retirement of legacy systems and automating and streamlining many aspects of human resources, +HRConnect facilitates increased efficiency and overall productivity for its customers. HRConnect is +the system used by all Treasury bureaus and several other government agencies (over 22 entities) with +over 200,000 employees and contractors in total. -20 +HRConnect Top FY 2023 Accomplishments: -21 +1. Implemented 74 HRConnect change requests to maintain regulatory compliance, improve the +employee and manager experience, and provide tools to streamline and enable efficient +processing for HR Specialists. -22 +2. Maintained a steady state of 100% availability for customers. +3. Treasury HRLOB implemented multifactor authentication (MFA) for all TSSC applications -23 +and achieved M-21-31 compliance for the HRConnect High Value Asset (HVA). -24 +4. Completed the migration of HRConnect’s data service, Workforce Analytics from on prem +data centers to a FedRAMP High secure cloud hosted environment, effectively scaling and +maturing the platform. -25 +5. Delivered Integrated Talent Management (ITM) and HRConnect real-time performance plan -26 +and learning data integration. -27 +6. Implemented new Remote/Telework Agreement Type and Program and Project Job Identifier -28 +fields and Mass Update Process, 34K positions updated. -privacy older than the Bill of Rights.” For its part, California amended its constitution in 1972 to +7. Streamlined the background investigation security process across Treasury by expanding the -specifically enumerate a right to privacy in its very first section. See Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1. +Adjudication Tracker application to three additional bureaus. -23. +8. Continued to modernize HRConnect delivering enhancements to improve the user experience -Google itself has long acknowledged the importance of user control over privacy +for employees, managers, and HR Specialists. -settings. In 2018, Google’s Chief Privacy Officer testified to United States Senate Committee on +9. Deployed a visual representation of key Time to Hire (T2H) metrics via the Treasury -Commerce, Science, and Transportation that “users trust [Google] to keep their personal +Workforce Dashboard to track and optimize the hiring timeline and make data-driven hiring +decisions. -information confidential and under their control.”11 +10. Continued employee self-service (ESS) redesign leveraging fluid concepts. +11. Supported gender identity and other preferred name representation in accordance with -24. +management directives. -According to a poll by the Pew Research Center, 93% of adults believe that being +15 -in control of who can get information about them is important, and 90% believe that controlling + Enterprise API Service Platform [MuleSoft]: Transition 15+ partners to the new API Service +Framework. Launched integrations between USAS to DO and FinCEN Adjudication Tracker, ARC- +FS Worklist API and SAM.gov integration to HRC to update vendor information. +In FY2023: Treasury Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) recently assumed responsibility +for the management of the transformation of Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Human Resource +Information Technology (HRIT) applications in support of the Inflation Reduction Act. This transfer of +responsibility allows the IRS CIO to focus their efforts on improving the taxpayer experience +leveraging the Treasury OCIO’s shared services and common platforms to facilitate the modernization +of IRS HRIT systems, the rationalization pillars include: HRConnect, Integrated Talent Management, +USA Staffing, Enterprise Data Management, and the Employee Portal. -what information is collected about them is important.12 Additionally, Americans say they do not +A few of technical improvements, included: Nessus implementation, CAST implementation, piloted +the transition of 3 environments to Oracle Managed Services compartment in Q3, improved the fire +wall configurations and finalized the closure of the Memphis and Martinsburg HRC footprint. -approve of observation without consent: 88% say it is important that they not have someone watch +Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM) -or listen to them without their permission.13 +Description: -25. +The Treasury Enterprise Identity, Credential and Access Management (TEICAM), formerly submitted +as EIdM, consolidates funding of Treasury implementing the Homeland Security Presidential +Directive- (HSPD) 12, E-Auth, and Federal PKI initiatives. -According to a 2013 Pew Research study, “86% of Internet users have tried to be +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -anonymous online and taken at least one step to try to mask their behavior or avoid being tracked.”14 +T y p e -For example, 64% percent of adults claim to clear their cookies and browser histories in an attempt +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -to be less visible online. 15 Such behaviors exemplify people’s expectation that their personal +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -information will not be tracked by others without their consent or permission, and that settings +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -claiming to allow them to protect such information will be effective. +C h a n g e i n +$ -26. +% C h a n g e -A 2010 study comparing the opinions of young adults between the ages of 18 to 24 +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) -with other age categories (25-34, 35-44, 45-54, 55-64, and 65+) found that a large percentage of +4 3 . 0 7 -young adults were in harmony with older Americans regarding concerns about online privacy, +7 5 . 9 4 -11 Written Testimony of Keith Enright Chief Privacy Officer, United States Senate Committee on -Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Examining Safeguards for Consumer Data Privacy, -(Sept. 26, 2018), available at https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/17926-keith-enright-chief- -privacy-officer-google (emphasis added). -12 Mary Madden and Lee Rainie, Americans’ Attitudes About Privacy, Security and Surveillance, -PEW RESEARCH CENTER (May 20, 2015), available at -https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2015/05/20/americans-attitudes-about-privacy-security- -and-surveillance/. -13 Id. -14 Lee Rainie, et al., Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online, PEW RESEARCH CENTER (Sept. 5, -2013) available at https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2013/09/05/anonymity-privacy-and- -security-online/. -15 Id. +7 5 . 9 8 -- 8 - +0 . 0 4 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +8 1 . 6 2 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 10 of 21 +7 8 . 9 9 -1 +8 0 . 9 5 -2 +0.05% -3 +2.48% -4 +1.29% -5 +1 . 9 6 -6 +2 . 0 0 -7 +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -8 +1 2 4 . 6 9 -9 +1 5 4 . 9 3 -10 +1 5 6 . 9 3 -11 +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -12 +The TEICAM Business Case consolidates funding that supports Treasury’s implementation of HSPD- +12, FICAM and PKI requirements. This investment supports the target vision of "One Treasury One +Card" to provide universal access. Availability and use of a PIV/identity management standard within +Treasury provides a mechanism for Physical and Logical access to Treasury-wide assets. The TEICAM +phased implementation provides all of Treasury: -13 +• Trusted identity processes for both Federal and public users of Treasury applications +• Enhanced security (by decreasing data breaches and trust violations) +• Compliance with laws, regulations, and standards +• +• Expanded use of PIV encryption and digital signature certificates (ensuring adoption of multi- -14 +Improved interoperability -15 +factor authentication) +• Elimination of redundancy 16 -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 + Treasury/TEICAM has achieved many of the defined goals for PIV card issuance, physical access, +logical access, data synchronization, enterprise single sign-on, federation, and PIV required for both +privileged and unprivileged users. These goals have helped the Department align with the required +OMB and FICAM goals. +Additionally, TEICAM has updated the Department strategic roadmap & planned for the following +investment goals: -25 +1) CDM II-PRIV/CRED Management -26 +o Continue working with the Managed Service Bureaus and Non-Managed Service -27 +Bureaus on implementation of Credential (CRED) and Privileged Access Management +(PAM) -28 +o On-board new bureaus, such as IRS and DO Orbit Organizations (TSSOC, OFR, etc.), -norms, and policy suggestions.16 For example, 88% of young adults surveyed responded that “there +to the enterprise CDM Managed Service Offering (MSO) -should be a law that requires websites and advertising companies to delete all stored information +o Continue working with DHS CISA on the integration activities for the Federal -about an individual”; for individuals in the 45-54 age range, 94% approved of such a law.17 +Dashboard for Treasury’s CDM Data reporting -27. +2) Plan, test, & implement the issuance of version 8.1 PIV cards (PIV V8.1) across the enterprise -The same study noted that “[o]ne way to judge a person’s concern about privacy +in FY21-FY24 -laws is to ask about the penalties that companies or individuals should pay for breaching them.” A +3) Expand usage of the Enterprise Derived Credential issuance capability to support -majority of the 18- to 24-year-olds polled selected the highest dollar amount of punishment (“more +authentication to Treasury services/infrastructure from mobile devices across Treasury in +FY21-FY24 -than $2,500”) in response to how a company should be fined if it purchases or uses someone’s +4) As part of the PIV-I solution, implement an application programming interface (API) -personal information illegally; across all age groups, 69% of individuals opted for the highest fine. +connection between a Fiscal Service application used to capture applicant data and +HRConnect in FY21-FY24 -Beyond a fine, approximately half of the sample (across all age groups) chose the harshest penalties +5) Implement an enterprise Hardware Security Module (HSM) as a service in FY22-FY24 +6) Enterprise solution for tracking and monitoring the Only Locally Trusted (OLT) PKI -for companies using a person’s information illegally: putting them out of business and imposing +certificates generated and in use within each bureau -jail time.18 +7) Plan, design, and implement a modernized Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) -28. +solution that enforces multifactor authentication and aligns with the Treasury Zero Trust +Architecture (ZTA) -Google claimed to offer people a choice when it came to data privacy. In purporting +8) In an effort to improve cost-savings, the Department utilizes interagency resources to +authenticate users, synchronize data, and to procure and maintain enterprise-wide +compliant PIV credentials (USAccess). As a mixed life-cycle investment, the TEICAM +Operations and Maintenance tasks includes OMB, FISMA, and Cyber reporting specific to +identity, credential and access management. -to offer users the ability to adjust data privacy settings to control whether Google’s AI technology +Planned objectives and accomplishments include: -accesses their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, Google warranted that it would respect those users’ +• Maintaining above 95% PIV card issuance rate and providing replacements for the PIV in time -privacy choices. In reality, Google rendered users’ choices meaningless when it surreptitiously +sensitive activities; -turned on the “Smart features” setting for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet users without their knowledge +• Maintained 100% PIV required privileged account access and 97% PIV required unprivileged -or consent. Google’s AI tracking of users’ private communications was surreptitious and purposely +access; -deceptive, as they did not provide notification of this change, thus requiring users to discover this +• CDM II privileged access management is operating with a cloud infrastructure and production +at four bureaus performing O&M functions; we have commenced technical work on +bringing the IRS on as the fifth and largest managed service customer; -change on their own and manually turn off the “Smart features” setting. +• Treasury Enterprise Federation Service (TEFS) onboarded 12 new customers and integrated -29. +with third-party identity providers to expand citizen services and access; +• Executed a Treasury-wide BPA for citizen authentication services access to the entire +enterprise, allowing for secure and fast public access to Treasury systems; -Not only were Google’s representations about privacy likely to deceive people, +• Developed an alternative authentication solution and deployed it within 6 weeks to ensure -Google did in fact deceive the millions of people who use Gmail, Chat, and Meet. Ordinary users, +continuity of government during the pandemic; -including Plaintiff, reasonably expected that their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts would not be +• -tracked and stored by AI unless they affirmatively turned on that feature in their Google accounts. +Implemented a hardware security module (HSM) as a service for the Derived PIV solution and -16 Chris Hoofnagle, et al., How Different Are Young Adults from Older Adults When It Comes to -Information Privacy Attitudes & Policies, University of Pennsylvania Scholarly Commons (April -14, 2010), available at -https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/privacy-roundtables- -comment-project-no.p095416-544506-00125/544506-00125.pdf. -17 Id. -18 Id. +DO. -- 9 - +17 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + • - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 11 of 21 +Implementation of the department-wide PKI Only Locally Trusted (OLT) monitoring solution. -30. +18 -Google’s misrepresentations continue, despite public reporting. Users are still being + Major Non-IT Investments -deceived and tracked without consent unless they are made aware of the change to their data privacy +Main Treasury Building and Freedman's Bank Building -settings and affirmatively turn off the “Smart features” setting, which is still worded in terms that +Description: -deceptively suggest it is something that must be agreed to and turned on by the user, not Google. +Correct life safety and code issues, reduce building systems risk, and maintain the buildings. Absent +full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation, Treasury is utilizing available funding to +correct the most severe issues. -VI. CLASS ALLEGATIONS +Investment Obligations: (In Millions of $): -31. +T y p e -Plaintiff brings this class action, pursuant to Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil +F Y 2 0 2 3 +A c t u a l s -Procedure, individually and on behalf of all members of the following class, which is referred to +F Y 2 0 2 4 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -throughout this Complaint as the “Class”: +F Y 2 0 2 5 +E s t i m a t e d +O b l i g a t i o n s -All natural persons residing in the United States with Google -accounts whose private communications in Gmail, Chat, and/or -Meet were tracked by Google’s Gemini AI after Google turned on -“Smart features” in those persons’ data privacy account settings. +C h a n g e i n +$ -32. +% C h a n g e -Excluded from each Class are the following individuals: officers and directors of +S u b - T o t a l D M E O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l l a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +S u b - T o t a l O & M O b l i g a t i o n s ( I n c l u d i n g +I n t e r n a l L a b o r ( G o v t . F T E ) ) +T o t a l O b l i g a t i o n s -Google and its parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, any entity in which Google has a controlling interest, +9 . 7 9 -and all judges assigned to hear any aspect of this litigation, as well as their immediate family +0 . 0 0 -members. +9 . 7 9 -33. +3 . 5 5 -Plaintiff reserves the right to modify or amend the Class definition before the Court +0 . 0 0 -determines whether certification is appropriate. +3 . 5 5 -34. +5 . 5 5 -This action readily satisfies the requirements set forth under Federal Rule of Civil +2 . 0 0 -Procedure 23: +5 6 . 2 5 % -a. +0 . 0 0 -Each Class is so numerous that joinder of all Members is impracticable. +5 . 5 5 -Upon information and belief, Class Members number in the millions. +0 . 0 0 -b. +0 . 0 0 % -There are questions of law or fact common to the Class. These questions +2 . 0 0 -include, but are not limited to, the following: +5 6 . 2 5 % -i. +Purpose, Accomplishments, Future Objectives: -Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount +This investment is to address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by +upgrading a number of outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building +standards. Absent full funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical +buildings, available funding will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being +executed with the expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent +investments could be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments +support a safe and healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project +needs are mission focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs +that pose significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. -to the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording device to eavesdrop upon or record” +Treasury’s three-step long-term strategy to continue to maintain and modernize its owned spaces: (1) +secure the building’s outer envelope; (2) conduct a condition assessment to identify additional needs +associated with the buildings’ continual aging and deferred maintenance; and (3) based on this +assessment, conduct a holistic modernization of the building’s systems and infrastructure. Targeted +investments address life safety and code compliance issues, reduce building systems risk by upgrading +outdated systems, and bring both facilities into alignment with current building standards. Absent full +funding to perform a complete repair and renovation of these historical buildings, available funding +will be used to correct the most urgent issues. These investments are being executed with the +expectation that were Treasury to pursue a full renovation and modernization, recent investments could +be largely retained, achieving cost savings over the long term. These investments support a safe and +healthy work environment that meets Treasury operational requirements. Project needs are mission +focused and prioritized based on life-safety, security, code discrepancies, and needs that pose +significant financial risk if not addressed in a timely manner. -confidential communications in violation of CIPA; +Treasury Operations has continued to strategically focus on restoring the health of the building +envelope (shell), to correct the deteriorating building structure and infrastructure. Components of the -- 10 - +19 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 12 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -ii. - -Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to “tampering, interference, damage, and unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data - -and computer systems” in violation of CDAFA; - -iii. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to “intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic - -communication service is provided” in violation of the SCA; - -iv. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to egregious breaches of social norms; - -v. - -Whether Google acted intentionally in violating Plaintiff’s and Class - -Members’ privacy rights; - -vi. Whether an injunction should issue; and - -vii. Whether declaratory relief should be granted. - -c. - -Plaintiff’s claims are typical of the claims of the Class. Plaintiff and Class - -Members maintained private, password-protected Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts that they - -thought were secure and not being tracked by Google. Despite these efforts and contrary to - -Google’s representations, Plaintiff and Class Members nonetheless had their Gmail, Chat, and/or - -Meet accounts tracked by Google’s AI technology. Plaintiff and Class Members did not consent to - -Google’s tracking of their private communications, which forms the basis for this suit. - -d. - -Moreover, like all Class Members, Plaintiff suffered a substantial risk of - -repeated injury in the future. Plaintiff continues to use the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services that - -are capable of being tracked by Google’s Gemini AI, and Google may unilaterally change his - -privacy settings again in the future. Google has shown deliberate indifference to Plaintiff’s and - -Class Members’ desire to keep their communications private, and has indeed taken pains to deceive - -and mislead Plaintiff (and all Class Members) and to conduct its business contrary to their privacy - -rights, and contrary to the plain meaning of its own terms of service in favor of surreptitiously and - -deceitfully monitoring their private communications. Google’s deceptive and deliberate actions - -have thwarted and continue to threaten Plaintiff’s (and Class Members’) ability to exercise control - -over their own privacy while using their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. Because the conduct - -- 11 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 13 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -complained of herein is systemic, Plaintiff and Class Members face substantial risk of the same - -injury in the future. Google’s conduct is common to all Class Members and represents a common - -pattern of conduct resulting in injury to all Class Members. Plaintiff has suffered the harm alleged - -and has no interests antagonistic to any other Class member. - -e. - -Plaintiff will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the Class. - -Plaintiff’s interests do not conflict with the interests of the Class Members. Furthermore, Plaintiff - -has retained competent counsel experienced in class action litigation, consumer protection - -litigation, and electronic privacy litigation. Plaintiff’s counsel will fairly and adequately protect and - -represent the interests of the Class. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)(4) and 23(g) are satisfied. - -f. - -In acting as alleged above, and in failing and refusing to cease and desist - -despite being exposed, Google has acted on grounds generally applicable to the entire Class, - -thereby making final injunctive relief and corresponding declaratory relief each appropriate with - -respect to the Class as a whole. The prosecution of separate actions by individual Class Members - -would create the risk of inconsistent or varying adjudications with respect to individual Class - -Members that would establish incompatible standards of conduct for Google. - -g. - -Injunctive relief is necessary to prevent further unlawful and unfair conduct - -by Google. Money damages, alone, could not afford adequate and complete relief, and injunctive - -relief is necessary to restrain Google from continuing to commit its illegal and unfair violations of - -privacy. - -VII. CAUSES OF ACTION - - Count One -(Violations of CIPA, Cal. Pen. Code §§ 630, et seq.) - -35. - -36. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -Cal. Pen. Code § 630 provides that “[t]he Legislature hereby declares that advances - -in science and technology have led to the development of new devices and techniques for the - -purpose of eavesdropping upon private communication and that the invasion of privacy resulting - -from the continual and increasing use of such devices and techniques has created a serious threat - -to the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot be tolerated in a free and civilized society.” - -- 12 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 14 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -37. - -Google’s acts and practices complained of herein, engaged in for purposes of - -tracking and storing indefinitely the private communications of its users without their consent— - -and indeed in direct contravention of Google’s own wording of the “Smart features” setting that - -suggests it must be turned on to “opt in,” when, in reality, Google has already secretly turned it on - -and requires users to find the setting and turn it off to “opt out”—violated and continues to violate - -Cal. Pen. Code § 632. - -38. - -Cal. Pen. Code § 632 prohibits the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording - -device to eavesdrop upon or record [a] confidential communication, whether the communication is - -carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, - -or other device . . . .” - -39. - -In direct violation of this prohibition and without the consent of Plaintiff or Class - -Members, Google has been using its Gemini AI technology to eavesdrop and record the confidential - -communications of Plaintiff and Class Members on their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. - -40. - -Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private - -communications from California. On information and belief, Google uses servers located in - -California that allow Google to access private communications of Plaintiff and Class Members. - -Google’s terms of service indicate that California law controls the use of its services. - -41. - -As a result of Google’s violations of Cal. Pen. Code § 632, Plaintiff and Class - -Members are entitled to the following relief: - -a. - -b. - -c. - -A declaration that Google’s conduct violates CIPA; - -Statutory damages and/or trebled actual damages; - -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from - -continuing to access Class Members’ private communications in violation of CIPA; - -d. - -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order requiring Google to - -destroy all data created or otherwise obtained from its illegal tracking of Class Members’ private - -communications; and - -e. - -An award of attorney’s fees and costs of litigation as provided by CIPA, the - -private attorney general doctrine existing at common law and also codified at California Civil Code - -- 13 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 15 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -Section 1021.5, and all other applicable laws. - -Count Two -(Intrusion Upon Seclusion) - -42. - -43. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, - -Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications - -contained in these accounts. - -44. - -The reasonableness of such expectations of privacy is supported by Google’s unique - -position to monitor Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private communications through its access to - -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. It is further supported by the - -surreptitious nature of Google’s tracking. - -45. - -Defendant intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ - -solitude, seclusion, or private affairs by intentionally using AI to track their private - -communications. - -46. - -These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications - -sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information - -and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. - -Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff - -and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact - -that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the - -consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. - -47. - -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs - -as detailed throughout this Complaint. - -48. - -Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in - -causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. - -49. - -As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and - -punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive - -damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were - -- 14 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 16 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and - -Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in - -future misconduct. - -Count Three -(California Constitutional Right to Privacy, Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1) - -50. - -51. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, - -Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications - -contained in these accounts. - -52. - -Google intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ solitude, - -seclusion, right of privacy, or private affairs by intentionally tracking the private communications. - -53. - -These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications - -sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information - -and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. - -Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff - -and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact - -that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the - -consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. - -54. - -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs - -as detailed throughout this Complaint. - -55. - -Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in - -causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. - -56. - -As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and - -punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive - -damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were - -calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and - -Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in - -future misconduct. - -- 15 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 17 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -Count Four -(Violations of CDAFA, Cal. Pen. Code § 502) - -57. - -58. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -The California legislature enacted CDAFA with the intent of “expand[ing] the - -degree of protection afforded to individuals . . . from tampering, interference, damage, and - -unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data and computer systems.” Cal. Penal Code - -§502(a). The enactment of CDAFA was motivated by the finding that “the proliferation of - -computer technology has resulted in a concomitant proliferation of . . . unauthorized access to - -computers, computer systems, and computer data.” Id. - -59. - -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices used to access their Gmail, Chat, - -and Meet accounts constitute “computers” within the scope of CDAFA. - -60. - -Google violated the following sections of CDAFA: - -a. - -Section 502(c)(1), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly access[] and - -without permission . . . use[] any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order - -to either (A) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B) - -wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;” - -b. - -Section 502(c)(2), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly accesses and - -without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or - -computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing - -internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;” and - -c. - -Section 502(c)(7), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly and without - -permission accesses or causes to be accessed any computer, computer system, or computer - -network.” - -61. - -Google knowingly accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet - -accounts without their permission by surreptitiously activating Gemini AI access that intercepts - -and transmits data, communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class - -Members. - -62. - -Google used data, communications, and personal information that it intercepted and - -- 16 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 18 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -took from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts to wrongfully and - -unjustly enrich itself at the expense of Plaintiff and Class Members. - -63. - -Defendant took, copied, intercepted, and made use of data, communications, and - -personal information from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. - -64. - -Defendant knowingly and without Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ permission - -accessed or caused to be accessed their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts by installing—without - -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ informed consent—AI software that intercepts and/or takes data, - -communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiffs and Class Members. - -65. - -Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ data, - -communications, and personal information from California. On information and belief, Google - -uses servers located in California that allow Google to access and process the data, communications - -and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class Members. Google’s terms of service - -indicate that California law controls the use of its services. - -66. - -Google was unjustly enriched by intercepting, acquiring, taking, or using Plaintiff’s - -and Class Members’ data, communications, and personal information without their permission, and - -using it for Google’s own financial benefit. Google has been unjustly enriched in an amount to be - -determined at trial. - -67. - -As a direct and proximate result of Google’s violations of CDAFA, Plaintiff and - -Class Members suffered damages. - -68. - -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(1), Plaintiff and Class Members seek - -compensatory, injunctive, and equitable relief in an amount to be determined at trial. - -69. - -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(2), Plaintiff and Class Members seek an award - -of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. - -70. - -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(4), Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive - -or exemplary damages for Google’s willful violations of CDAFA. - -Count Five -(Violations of the SCA, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq.) - -71. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -- 17 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 19 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -72. - -The SCA provides a cause of action against any person who “intentionally accesses - -without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided,” - -or any person “who intentionally exceeds an authorization to access that facility; and thereby - -obtains, alters or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in - -electronic storage in such a system.” 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a). - -73. - -The SCA defines “electronic storage” as “any temporary, intermediate storage of a - -wire or electronic communication incidental to the electronic transmission thereof;” and “any - -storage of such communication by an electronic communication service for purposes of backup - -protection of such communication.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(17). - -74. - -The SCA defines an “electronic communications service” as “any service which - -provides to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 - -U.S.C. § 2510(15). - -75. - -Google intentionally accessed without authorization or intentionally exceeded - -authorization to access facilities through which an electronic communications services was - -provided when it used its Gemini AI technology to access the Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ - -Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts for purposes of tracking their private communications. - -76. - -The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services utilized by Plaintiff and Class Members on their - -computing devices provide electronic communications services to Plaintiff and Class Members - -because they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic - -communications.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(15). - -77. - -The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services to which the Plaintiff and Class Members use - -or subscribe to provide electronic communication services to Plaintiff and Class Members because - -they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 - -U.S.C. § 2510(15). - -78. - -Neither the Plaintiff and Class Members nor the third parties with whom they - -communicated with on Gmail, Chat, and Meet authorized the extent of Google’s access to - -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices and Google’s services therein. - -79. - -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts—and the - -- 18 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 20 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -computing devices, applications, and/or web browsers through which they accessed those - -services—also are facilities under the SCA because they comprise the software necessary for and - -“through which (the) electronic communications service is provided.” - -80. - -Google intentionally accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and - -Meet accounts without authorization when Google turned on the Gemini AI access to those services - -without obtaining the consent of the Plaintiff and Class Members. - -81. - -Upon information and belief, Google’s acquisition of electronic communications - -from Plaintiff and Class Members included private communications Plaintiff and Class Members - -had with third parties that are not affiliated with Google. - -82. - -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by Google’s violations and, pursuant to - -18 U.S.C. § 2707(c), are entitled to statutory damages or actual damages, including profits earned - -by Google attributable to the violations, punitive damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees. - -VIII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF - -WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests that judgment be entered against Google and that the - -Court grant the following: - -A. - -An order determining that this action may be maintained as a class action under Rule - -23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that Plaintiff is a proper class representative, that - -Plaintiff’s attorneys shall be appointed as Class counsel pursuant to Rule 23(g) of the Federal Rules - -of Civil Procedure, and that Class notice be promptly issued; - -B. - -Judgment against Google for Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ asserted causes of - -action; - -C. - -D. - -Appropriate declaratory relief against Google; - -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from - -continuing its practice of accessing, using, and/or storing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private - -communications without their knowledge or consent in violation of CIPA, CDAFA, and/or SCA; - -E. - -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from - -continuing its practice of tracking, recording, and using Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private - -communications; - -- 19 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 21 of 21 - -F. - -An order awarding Plaintiff and the Class Members damages, special damages, - -general damages, and restitution; - -G. - -H. - -I. - -J. - -An order requiring Google to pay punitive damages and exemplary damages; - -An order requiring Google to pay pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; - -Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs reasonably incurred; and - -Any and all other and further relief to which Plaintiff and the Class may be entitled. - -IX. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL - -Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury of all issues so triable. - -Dated: November 11, 2025 - -Respectfully Submitted, - -/s/ Tina Wolfson -Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) -twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com -Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) -rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com -Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) -tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com -Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) -abrown@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 -Burbank, CA 91505-4521 -Telephone: 310.474.9111 -Facsimile: 310.474.8585 - -Bradley K. King (SBN 274399) -bking@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -521 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor -New York, NY 10175 -Telephone: 917.336.0171 -Facsimile: 917.336.0177 - -Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class - -- 20 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 + Main Treasury building that have been repaired, replaced, or funded include new roofs (FY 2019/2021) +and repairs to 40 percent of the windows (FY 2015/2017). The Freedman’s Bank Building components +that have been repaired, replaced, or funded/planned include new roofs (FY 2017/2019), domestic +water line (FY 2020/2022), and replacement of all windows (FY 2009/2011). Funding and completion +of these exterior items represent significant progress towards the preservation of the two buildings, +maintaining a safe and healthy workplace, and reducing damage to the interior plaster and paint. The +contract for the first phase (west façade) of the Main Treasury exterior restoration project was awarded +late in FY 2021 and completed during FY 2022. Exterior restoration work continued through 2023 with +the completion of phase 2 (south) and phase 3 (north) north façades. In FY 2024, assuming adequate +funding, Phase 4 work will commence and, in FY 2025, with this requested funding, work on Phase 5 +will commence. + +The MT Building houses the entire chilled water plant for the Main Treasury Complex. A five cell +cooling tower feeds four water cooled centrifugal chillers providing a total cooling capacity of 2,050 +tons. The chillers are located in a mechanical room under the northwest lawn. The four chillers provide +over 98% of the cooling required for the entire Treasury Headquarters complex; therefore, the plant is +operated 24/7, 365 days per year. The Freedman’s Bank Building (FBB) does not generate chilled +water but rather uses chilled water from the main plant distributed by a dedicated secondary chilled +water pump which serves most air handling units directly. The Chilled Water System is over 30 years +old and has a wide variety of repair needs including bearings, motors, valves, distribution piping, +insulation, controls, and other repairs. The system has redundancy for repairs. However, with all of the +components aging at the same time the occurrence of repair needs combined with the time to repair +diminishes the reliability of the redundant capacity. It is imperative that these items are +repaired/replaced before the available redundancy is lost. A system breakdown would indefinitely +shutdown the Treasury Complex’s daily operations. This first-year cost of a multi-year project includes +design for this effort. + +There is currently a backlog of damaged paint and plaster as well as frayed carpet throughout MT and +FBB. Some of the paint and plaster damage is due to water intrusion. These funds will supplement +other funding to address the backlog in repairing these problems and implementing a regular schedule +of maintenance. The damaged paint and plaster are unsightly and pose potential health and safety risks, +while the frayed carpet is a safety hazard. 20 -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - - ClassAction.org - -This complaint is part of ClassAction.org's searchable class action lawsuit -database and can be found in this post: Google Hit with Data Privacy Lawsuit -After ‘Secretly’ Turning On Gemini AI for All Users - diff --git a/q236/random_k2/question.json b/q236/random_k2/question.json index 3f4c953674036d0ebc9bec900aa4c2d7ca15c8e2..950306c4a9ecf62f3700f9401164f0af8502c1a3 100644 --- a/q236/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q236/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NIKE_2021_10K.pdf", - "web_6019e7c0934ca3b6.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf" + "resize_r2_14.pdf", + "web_fba1e08daa86a699.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q236/random_k2/random_1.md b/q236/random_k2/random_1.md index 1c064e3ff046ea90ec57fa6e9a2c7b22d1110cc1..3a49db96c4533f83fdc27ab1adb7310a8ce9a865 100644 --- a/q236/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q236/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1527 +1,2202 @@ -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary -Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) -Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) -1. Date of Submission: 8/17/2007 -2. Agency: Department of Justice -3. Bureau: Federal Bureau Of Investigation -4. Name of this Capital Asset: FBI Digital Collection -5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: (For IT 011-10-01-02-01-2503-00 -investment only, see section 53. For all other, use agency -ID system.) -6. What kind of investment will this be in FY2009? (Please Mixed Life Cycle -NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY2009, with -Planning/Acquisition activities prior to FY2009 should not -select O&M. These investments should indicate their current -status.) -7. What was the first budget year this investment was FY2001 or earlier -submitted to OMB? -8. Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this closes in part or -in whole an identified agency performance gap: -Since September 2001, the FBI's demands for critical, timely intelligence gathering have increased significantly. Pre- -September 2001 ELSUR intercepts (per year) have increased. Not only do demands for information continue to increase, -but also the requirement to facilitate information sharing does. The current collection enterprise consists of Foreign -Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) and Criminal Law Enforcement (CLE) systems. Today's telecommunications -capabilities afford terrorists and criminals many avenues to coordinate and commit offenses against U.S. citizens and -interests. Communications methods, such as voice over internet protocol (VoIP) and voice over packet (VoP), are -dramatically increasing in number and complexity, resulting in the continual and evolving need for advanced methods of -electronic surveillance of voice communications; methods of electronic surveillance have limited-life utility in intercepting -newer, more secure types of publicly offered communications. The expansion of electronic surveillance activity in -frequency, sophistication, and linguistic needs continues to increase the level of support, transportability, and -information sharing required. An important factor behind this expansion is the changing demographic of targets that -must be monitored by investigators. Further, the life span of today's technology is often much shorter than older -technologies, resulting in more frequent need for solution development. Collection equipment manufacturers continue -toward complying with technical standards as a result of the Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act -(CALEA). One result of the CALEA standard is more information is available for collection. -9. Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee Yes -approve this request? -a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval? 5/19/2007 -10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? Yes -11. Contact information of Project Manager? -Name -Phone Number -Email -a. What is the current FAC-P/PM certification level of the TBD -project/program manager? -12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost Yes -effective, energy-efficient and environmentally sustainable -techniques or practices for this project? -a. Will this investment include electronic assets Yes -(including computers)? -b. Is this investment for new construction or major No -retrofit of a Federal building or facility? (answer applicable -to non-IT assets only) -1. If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help -fund this investment? -Page 1 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable -design principles? -3. If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy -efficient than relevant code? -13. Does this investment directly support one of the PMA Yes -initiatives? -If "yes," check all that apply: Human Capital -Expanded E-Government -a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected Strategic Management of Human Capital. The FBI acquires -how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)? individuals with rare linguistic skills by collocating and -(e.g. If E-Gov is selected, is it an approved shared service networking the collection assets within proximity for -provider or the managing partner?) employment, training, and development. A work flow -management module is used by operations managers -monitor productivity and distribute work accordingly. -Expanded E-Gov -14. Does this investment support a program assessed using No -the Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more -information about the PART, visit -www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) -a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness -found during a PART review? -b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? -c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? -15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes -If the answer to Question 15 is "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is "No," do not answer questions -16-23. -For information technology investments only: -16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Level 1 -Guidance) -17. What project management qualifications does the (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this -Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) investment -18. Is this investment or any project(s) within this No -investment identified as "high risk" on the Q4 - FY 2007 -agency high risk report (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) -19. Is this a financial management system? No -a. If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA -compliance area? -1. If "yes," which compliance area: -2. If "no," what does it address? -b. If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent financial -systems inventory update required by Circular A-11 section 52 -20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2009 funding request for the following? (This should total 100%) -Hardware -Software -Services -Other -21. If this project produces information dissemination N/A -products for the public, are these products published to the -Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and -included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? -22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions: -Name -Phone Number -Title Acting FBI Privacy and Civil Liberties Officer -Page 2 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -E-mail -23. Are the records produced by this investment No -appropriately scheduled with the National Archives and -Records Administration's approval? -Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: -24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO Yes -High Risk Areas? -Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) -1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts represent -budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be included only in -the row designated "Government FTE Cost," and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full -Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." The "TOTAL" estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for -"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should -include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or restoration costs. The costs associated with the -entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this report. -Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES -(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) -(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) -P -e -Y -a --1 -rl i -a -e -n -r -d -PY 2007 CY 2008 BY 2009 BY+1 2010BY+2 2011BY+3 2012 -B -b -Y -e -+ -y -4 -o n -an -d -d -Total -Planning: 13.915 2 2.554 0 0 0 0 0 18.469 -Acquisition: 142.387 0 21.181 21.261 0 0 0 0 184.829 -Subtotal Planning & 156.302 2 23.735 21.261 0 0 0 0 203.298 -Acquisition: -Operations & Maintenance: 80.936 20.916 15.547 21.075 -TOTAL: 237.238 22.916 39.282 42.336 -Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. -Government FTE Costs 9.045 1.905 7.378 7.378 -Number of FTE represented 14 7 21 21 -by Costs: -Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner -agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. -2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional Yes -FTE's? -a. If "yes," How many and in what year? Ten FTEs were requested for this project in FY08 Exhibit -300 submission to perform requirements generation, -testing/evaluation, installation of new/upgraded equipment, -and user training as well as, system administration -expertise, telephonic/on-site technical support and system -maintenance support. The FTEs are included in the FY08 -President?s Budget; no additional personnel resources are -required upon approval of the request. -3. If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2008 President's budget request, briefly explain those changes: -The FY 2008 request for personnel enhancement of 14 personnel and non-personnel enhancement of $7,035,000 will -enhance the Digital Collection project's capacity to provide next generation systems, facilities, and capabilities to enable -continuance of audio and data collection in the furtherance of the FBI's FCI and Counterterrorism (CT) responsibilities. -The nonpersonnel enhancement will be used for new systems and equipment purchases ($3,850,000) and professional -and technical services ($3,185,000).. Without the requested resources, the number of funded contractor positions is -expected to increase. -Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) -1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned for this -investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders completed do -not need to be included. -Page 3 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) - -Contracts/Task Orders Table: - * Costs in millions -If N/A, has -the agency -| | | | What, if | | | determined | -| --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | -| | If so what | | any, | Does the | | the CO | -| | is the date | | alternative | contract | Contracting | assigned | -Has the Total Value Is this an -of the Start date Is it Competitiv financing Is EVM in include the CO Contact Officer has the -Contract or Type of contract award? If of End date of of Interagenc performanc ely option is the required information Certificatio competenci -Task Order Contract/ been Contract/ Contract/ y Name of CO -Number n o t , w h a t i s C o n t r a c t / e b a s e d ? aw ar d e d ? b e i n g co n t r ac t ? s e c u r i t y & (pho n e / em n L e v e l e s a n d -Task Order aw a r de d Task Order Tas k O r d er Ac q u is i ti o n -(Y / N ) t h e p la n n e d T a s k O r d e r ( $ M ) ? ( Y / N ) ( Y / N ) (Y / N ) u s e d ? ( Y / N ) p r i v a c y a il ) ( L e v e l s k il ls -a w a r d ( E S P C , c l a u s e s ? 1, 2 , 3 , N / A ) ne c e s s a r y -| | date? | | | (Y/N) | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | -| | | | UESC, EUL, | | | to support | -| | | | N/A) | | | this | -acquisition -? (Y/N) -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -FFP IDIQ Yes 9/28/2002 9/28/2002 9/27/2008 120 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - FFP Yes 4/1/2005 4/1/2005 8/2/2008 9.39 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP IDIQ Yes 9/15/2003 9/15/2003 9/15/2008 47 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 9/3/2003 9/3/2003 9/8/2008 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 10/1/2003 10/1/2003 9/30/2008 50 Yes No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -FFP Yes 10/7/2004 10/7/2004 10/5/2009 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | - -Page 4 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain -why: -Although EVM was not incorporated at the project's inception, a modified form of earned value management is being used -internally by the project team to monitor contractors' cost and schedule performance. Internal procedures are being used to -monitor FFP contracts using a straight-line calculation for services delivered and 100% earned value for product deliverables -received. Current contracts, being performed under the Digital Collection Project are Firm Fixed Price for Project Management -and Operations and Maintenance (O&M) of current systems; however, there are provisions within contract J-FBI-02-158 that -permit the time and material (T&M) and cost reimbursable (CR) efforts to be accomplished for research, development, and -unforeseen (O&M) requirements. It should also be noted that current and previous contracts did not include ANSI-compliant -EVMS because they did not meet the DOJ threshhold for ANSI-748 compliance. -For new developmental contracts the Digital Collection project will review, and include where appropriate, acquisition -requirements for ANSI-748 compliant EVM, as well as performance based contracting. -3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? Yes -a. Explain why: Contracts supporting this requirement ensure Section 508 -compliance in order to meet legal requirements as well as -satisfy needs of user personnel. -4. Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in Yes -accordance with agency requirements? -a. If "yes," what is the date? 2/9/2001 -b. If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed? -1. If "no," briefly explain why: -Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) -In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency and be linked -to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and strategic goals, and performance -measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the agency's strategic goals and objectives this -investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to -the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall -citizen participation rate of 75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if -applicable, investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general -goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure. -Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use the Federal -Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement Indicators to the corresponding -"Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There should be at least one Measurement Indicator -for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be -extended to include performance measures for years beyond FY 2009. -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year -Su -G -p -o -p -a -o -l( -r -s -te -) -d -Meas -A -u -r -r -e -e -a -m ent Me -C -a -a -s -t -u -e -r -g -e -o -m -ry -e nt Me -G -a -r -s -o -u -u -r -p -e -i -m -ng -e nt Me +Alibaba Cloud +Alibaba Cloud + +Object Storage Service + +Product Introduction + +Document Version: 20220707 + +Alibaba CloudAlibaba CloudObject Storage ServiceProduct IntroductionDocument Version: 20220707 Object St orage Service + +Legal disclaimer + +Product Int roduct ion··Legal disclaim +er + +Alibaba Cloud reminds you t o carefully read and fully underst and t he t erms and condit ions of t his legal +disclaimer before you read or use t his document . If you have read or used t his document , it shall be deemed +as your t ot al accept ance of t his legal disclaimer. + +1. You shall download and obt ain t his document from t he Alibaba Cloud websit e or ot her Alibaba Cloud- +aut horized channels, and use t his document for your own legal business act ivit ies only. The cont ent of +t his document is considered confident ial informat ion of Alibaba Cloud. You shall st rict ly abide by t he +confident ialit y obligat ions. No part of t his document shall be disclosed or provided t o any t hird part y for +use wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of Alibaba Cloud. + +2. No part of t his document shall be excerpt ed, t ranslat ed, reproduced, t ransmit t ed, or disseminat ed by + +any organizat ion, company or individual in any form or by any means wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud. + +3. The cont ent of t his document may be changed because of product version upgrade, adjust ment , or + +ot her reasons. Alibaba Cloud reserves t he right t o modify t he cont ent of t his document wit hout not ice +and an updat ed version of t his document will be released t hrough Alibaba Cloud-aut horized channels +from t ime t o t ime. You should pay at t ent ion t o t he version changes of t his document as t hey occur and +download and obt ain t he most up-t o-dat e version of t his document from Alibaba Cloud-aut horized +channels. + +4. This document serves only as a reference guide for your use of Alibaba Cloud product s and services. +Alibaba Cloud provides t his document based on t he "st at us quo", "being defect ive", and "exist ing +funct ions" of it s product s and services. Alibaba Cloud makes every effort t o provide relevant operat ional +guidance based on exist ing t echnologies. However, Alibaba Cloud hereby makes a clear st at ement t hat +it in no way guarant ees t he accuracy, int egrit y, applicabilit y, and reliabilit y of t he cont ent of t his +document , eit her explicit ly or implicit ly. Alibaba Cloud shall not t ake legal responsibilit y for any errors or +lost profit s incurred by any organizat ion, company, or individual arising from download, use, or t rust in +t his document . Alibaba Cloud shall not , under any circumst ances, t ake responsibilit y for any indirect , +consequent ial, punit ive, cont ingent , special, or punit ive damages, including lost profit s arising from t he +use or t rust in t his document (even if Alibaba Cloud has been not ified of t he possibilit y of such a loss). + +5. By law, all t he cont ent s in Alibaba Cloud document s, including but not limit ed t o pict ures, archit ect ure + +design, page layout , and t ext descript ion, are int ellect ual propert y of Alibaba Cloud and/or it s +affiliat es. This int ellect ual propert y includes, but is not limit ed t o, t rademark right s, pat ent right s, +copyright s, and t rade secret s. No part of t his document shall be used, modified, reproduced, publicly +t ransmit t ed, changed, disseminat ed, dist ribut ed, or published wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud and/or it s affiliat es. The names owned by Alibaba Cloud shall not be used, published, or +reproduced for market ing, advert ising, promot ion, or ot her purposes wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud. The names owned by Alibaba Cloud include, but are not limit ed t o, "Alibaba Cloud", +"Aliyun", "HiChina", and ot her brands of Alibaba Cloud and/or it s affiliat es, which appear separat ely or in +combinat ion, as well as t he auxiliary signs and pat t erns of t he preceding brands, or anyt hing similar t o +t he company names, t rade names, t rademarks, product or service names, domain names, pat t erns, +logos, marks, signs, or special descript ions t hat t hird part ies ident ify as Alibaba Cloud and/or it s +affiliat es. + +6. Please direct ly cont act Alibaba Cloud for any errors of t his document . + +> Document Version: 20220707 + I -a -n -s -d -u -ic -re -a -m -to -e -r -nt -Baseline Target Actual Results -2000 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2000 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 95% of Title Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 10% additional 30% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2001 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity -Terrorism and Activities Efficiency -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 65% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 10% additional 20% -Laws, and deployed in field life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2002 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Page 5 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2002 | | | | | Productivity | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Productivity and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2002 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 45% of Title Deploy Deployed -Requirements -Enforce Federal Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 30% additional 40% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -| | | | | | | offices | | systems | systems | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2003 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2003 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -Promote the Title III and Title and digital input by 300% collection input -by 346% -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | | -| ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2003 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -Prevent Crime, User Near end of life 5% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 5% of additional 5% of -deployed in field life -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | Title III systems | Title III systems | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------------- | -| | Represent the | | | | | offices | | | | -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2004 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -input by130% -Promote the Title III and Title and digital collection input -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | by 135% | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2004 | | Technology | | | Data Storage | | | | | -| | Prevent | | | Information and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | Data | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2004 Prevent Crime, Technology Information and Data Storage System Total storage Increase system Increased -Data -Enforce Federal information capacity storage capacity system storage -| | | | | | | storage capacity 4,200GB | | by 9% | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | | capacity by 12% | -| | Represent the | | | | | for collected | | | | -evidence -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2005 -| | Prevent | Customer | | Service | Service | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Results | | Coverage | Efficiency | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 30% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 60% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2006 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2006 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 9% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 8% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -| 2006 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Security and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Privacy | | | | | | -Promote the - -Page 6 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -| | | Results | | Responsiveness | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | response and | to requests for | response to | | -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -2007 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2008 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Response Time | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Customer Timeliness and Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2009 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | Improve speed | | | | - -Page 7 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | of access and | | | | -| | Promote the | | | | | dissemination of | | | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | information | | | | -| | Security | | | | | collected | | | | -through data -and -telecommunicati -ons intercepts -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Nation¿s -Security -2009 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy system and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the system/application -level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and operational systems security -tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational Security Table must be included on -your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or -identifier). -For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, include the -investment in both the "Systems in Planning" table (Table 3) and the "Operational Systems" table (Table 4). Systems which are -already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization activity, should be included in both Table 3 and -Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date - -Page 8 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information -contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the -enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. -All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the "Name of System" -column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled "Name of System" in the security tables -(Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one-to-one ratio between the list of systems and -the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA -may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). -The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the system are -discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text explanation why a working link is -not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, -answer "yes" for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is -not yet required to be published. -Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: -1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified -and integrated into the overall costs of the investment: -a. If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the -budget year: -2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part -of the overall risk management effort for each system -supporting or part of this investment. -3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or Modernization - Security Table(s): -Date of Planned C&A update (for -Name of System -Agency/ or C -S -o -y -n -st -t -e -ra -m -c -? -to r Operated -Planned Operational Date -e -o -x -r -i s -P -t -l -i -a -n -n -g -n -m -ed -ix -C -e -o -d -m -li -p -fe -le -c -t -y -io -c -n -le -D -s -a -y -t -s -e -t e -( -m -fo -s -r -) -new systems) -DCS-5000 (Next Gen) Government Only -4. Operational Systems - Security Table: -What standards -were used for -Agency/ or NIST FIPS 199 Has C&A been the Security Date -Date the -Name of System -C -O -S -o -p -y -n -e -s -t -t -r -r -e -a -a -m -c -te -t -? -o -d -r R -(H -is -i -k -g h + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Document con +vent ions + +Document conventions + +St yle +St yle + +Descript io n +Descript io n + +Example +Example + +Danger + Danger + +W arning + W arning + +No t ice + No t ice + + No t eNo t e + +> + +Bo ldBo ld + +A danger notice indicates a situation that +will cause major system changes, faults, +physical injuries, and other adverse +results. + +Danger: + Danger: + +Resetting will result in the loss of user +configuration data. + +A warning notice indicates a situation +that may cause major system changes, +faults, physical injuries, and other adverse +results. + +W arning: + W arning: + +Restarting will cause business +interruption. About 10 minutes are +required to restart an instance. + +A caution notice indicates warning +information, supplementary instructions, +and other content that the user must +understand. + +No t ice: + No t ice: + +If the weight is set to 0, the server no +longer receives new requests. + +A note indicates supplemental +instructions, best practices, tips, and +other content. + +No t e: + No t e: + +You can use Ctrl + A to select all files. + +Closing angle brackets are used to +indicate a multi-level menu cascade. + +Set t ings > Net w o rk + +Set net w o rk +Net w o rk> Set net w o rk + +Click Set t ings +t ype . +t ype + +Bold formatting is used for buttons , +menus, page names, and other UI +elements. + +Click OKOK. + +Courier font + +Courier font is used for commands + +Run the cd /d C:/window command to +enter the Windows system folder. + +Italic + +[] or [a|b] + +{} or {a|b} + +Italic formatting is used for parameters +and variables. + +bae log list --instanceid + +Instance_ID + +T his format is used for an optional value, +where only one item can be selected. + +ipconfig [-all|-t] + +T his format is used for a required value, +where only one item can be selected. + +switch {active|stand} + +> Document Version: 20220707 + I -, -m -L -M -o -p -w -o -a -d -c -) -t -e r -le -a -v -te -e -, -l Co -N -m -IS -p -T -l -( -e -Y -8 -t -/ -e -0 -N -d -0 -, -) -- -u -3 -s + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Table of Cont +ent s + +Table of Contents + +1.What is OSS? + +2.Features + +3.Benefits + +4.Scenarios + +5.FAQ + +6.Terms + +7.Limits + +05 + +09 + +15 + +18 + +20 + +25 + +30 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +I + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +1.What is OSS? +1.What is OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud Object St orage Service (OSS) is a secure, cost -effect ive, and highly reliable cloud st orage +service t hat allows you t o st ore a large amount of dat a. OSS is designed t o provide 99.9999999999% +(t welve 9's) dat a durabilit y and 99.995% dat a availabilit y. OSS provides mult iple st orage classes t o help +you manage and reduce st orage cost s. + +OSS support s REST ful API operat ions t hat are independent of t he OSS console. You can st ore and +access dat a from all applicat ions anyt ime and anywhere. + +You can call API operat ions and use SDKs or OSS migrat ion t ools provided by Alibaba Cloud t o t ransfer +large amount s of dat a t o and from Alibaba Cloud OSS. You can use OSS bucket s of t he St andard +st orage class t o st ore image, audio, and video object s for apps and websit es. You can use OSS bucket s +of t he Infrequent Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive st orage class t o st ore infrequent ly accessed +object s at a low cost and wit h longer st orage period. + +Get started with O SS +Get started with O SS + +Video t ut orial + +T he following video quickly guides you t hrough OSS. + +FAQ + +For frequent ly asked quest ions about OSS, see FAQ. + +Learning pat h + +OSS Learning Pat h helps you get st art ed wit h OSS. You can learn basic OSS operat ions, and t hen +perform secondary development by using a variet y of API operat ions, SDKs, and convenient t ools. + +Terms +Terms + +st orage class + +T he st orage class of a bucket or an object . OSS provides t he following st orage classes t o cover a +variet y of dat a st orage scenarios from hot dat a t o cold dat a: St andard, IA, Archive, and Cold Archive. +T he St andard st orage class provides high-durabilit y, high-availabilit y, and high-performance object +st orage services t hat can support frequent dat a access. T he IA st orage class is suit able for st oring +dat a t hat is accessed once or t wice a mont h. In addit ion, t he unit price of IA st orage is lower t han +t hat of St andard st orage. T he Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring archive dat a for at least six +mont hs. T he Cold Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring cold dat a over a long period of t ime. +For more informat ion about st orage classes, see Overview. + +bucket + +A cont ainer used t o st ore object s in OSS. All object s are cont ained in bucket s. You can configure a +variet y of bucket at t ribut es such as t he region, access cont rol list (ACL), and st orage class. You can +creat e bucket s of different st orage classes t o st ore your dat a. + +object + +T he basic unit used t o st ore dat a in OSS. Object s are also known as files. An object consist s of object +met adat a, object dat a, and an object key. T he key of an object uniquely ident ifies t he object in a +bucket . Object met adat a consist s of key-value pairs t hat describe object at t ribut es, such as t he last +modified t ime and t he size of t he object . You can also specify t he user met adat a of an object . + +region + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +5 + + Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +Object St orage Service + +T he physical locat ion of an OSS dat a cent er. You can select a region t o creat e a bucket based on t he +cost and locat ion of t he request s t o t he bucket . For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +endpoint + +T he domain name t hat is used t o access OSS. OSS uses REST ful API operat ions t o provide services. +Different regions are accessed by using different endpoint s. Access over t he int ernal net work or over +t he Int ernet wit hin t he same region also uses different endpoint s. For more informat ion, see Regions +and endpoints. + +AccessKey pair + +T he access credent ial t hat is used t o aut hent icat e a request er. An AccessKey pair consist s of an +AccessKey ID and an AccessKey secret . OSS uses symmet ric encrypt ion based on AccessKey pairs t o +verify t he ident it y of a request er. T he AccessKey ID is used t o ident ify a user. T he AccessKey secret is +used t o encrypt and verify signat ure st rings. T he AccessKey secret must be kept confident ial. For +more informat ion about how t o obt ain an AccessKey pair, see Obtain an AccessKey pair. + +Common operations +Common operations + +Creat e bucket s + +Before you can upload object s t o OSS, you must creat e a bucket . You can configure various +at t ribut es such as t he region, ACL, and ot her met adat a for a bucket . For more informat ion about how +t o creat e a bucket , see Create buckets. + +Upload object s + +Aft er you creat e a bucket , you can upload object s of different sizes t o t he bucket . For more +informat ion about how t o upload object s, see Upload objects. + +Download object s + +Aft er you upload object s t o a bucket , you can download t he object s t o t he default download pat h +of your browser or t he specified local pat h. For more informat ion about how t o download object s, +see Download objects. + +List object s + +You can list all object s in a bucket . If a large number of object s are st ored in a bucket , you can also +list some of t he object s in t he bucket . For more informat ion about how t o list object s, see List objects. + +Delet e object s + +You can manually delet e one or more object s t hat you no longer need. You can also configure +lifecycle rules t o allow OSS t o aut omat ically delet e a single object or mult iple object s. For more +informat ion about how t o delet e object s, see Delete objects. + +Features +Features + +Versioning + +OSS allows you t o configure versioning for a bucket t o prot ect object s t hat are st ored in t he bucket . +Aft er you enable versioning for a bucket , dat a t hat is overwrit t en or delet ed in t he bucket is saved as +a previous version. You can use versioning t o recover a previous version of an object t hat is +accident ally overwrit t en or delet ed. For more informat ion about versioning, see Overview. + +Bucket Policy + +6 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +T he owner of a bucket can configure bucket policies t o grant users different permissions t o access +t he specified OSS resources in t he bucket . For example, you can configure bucket policies t o +aut horize ot her Alibaba Cloud account s or anonymous users t o access or manage all or some +resources in your bucket . You can also configure bucket policies t o grant full permissions such as +read-only, read/writ e, or full permissions t o different RAM users of t he same Alibaba Cloud account . +T his way, different RAM users have different permissions t o access or manage resources in your +bucket . For more informat ion about how t o configure bucket policies, see Configure bucket policies to +authorize other users to access OSS resources. + +CRR + +Cross-region replicat ion (CRR) provides aut omat ic and asynchronous (near real-t ime) replicat ion of +object s across bucket s in different OSS regions. Operat ions such as creat ing, overwrit ing, and +delet ing object s can be synchronized from a source bucket t o a dest inat ion bucket . CRR can meet +your requirement s for cross-region disast er recovery and dat a replicat ion. For more informat ion about +CRR, see CRR. + +Dat a encrypt ion + +Server-side encrypt ion: When you upload an object t o a bucket for which server-side encrypt ion is +enabled, OSS encrypt s t he object and st ores t he encrypt ed object . When you download t he +encrypt ed object from OSS, OSS aut omat ically decrypt s t he object and ret urns t he decrypt ed object . +A header is added in t he response t o indicat e t hat t he object is encrypt ed on t he OSS server. For +more informat ion about server-side encrypt ion, see Server-side encryption. + +Client -side encrypt ion: Before you upload an object t o a bucket , t he object is encrypt ed on t he local +client . For more informat ion about client -side encrypt ion, see Client-side encryption. + +Manage O SS +Manage O SS + +You can use a variet y of met hods t o upload object s, download object s, and manage OSS. + +Manage OSS by using t he OSS console + +OSS provides a web-based console. You can log on t o t he OSS console t o manage your OSS +resources. For more informat ion, see Use Alibaba Cloud accounts to log on to the OSS console. + +Manage OSS by using API operat ions or SDKs + +OSS provides REST ful API operat ions and SDKs for mult iple programming languages t o facilit at e +secondary development . For more informat ion, see List of operations by function and Overview. + +Manage OSS by using t ools + +OSS provides mult iple management t ools, such as ossbrowser, ossut il, and ossft p. For more +informat ion, see OSS tools. + +Manage OSS by using CSG + +OSS uses a flat st ruct ure inst ead of a hierarchical st ruct ure t o st ore object s. All element s are st ored +as object s in bucket s. T o use OSS in t he same manner in which local file syst ems are used, you can +configure Cloud St orage Gat eway (CSG). For more informat ion, visit t he CSG product page. + +Pricing +Pricing + +> Document Version: 20220707 + 7 -i -? -n g Date C -C -o -& -m -A -p leted: -( -C -F + + Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +Object St orage Service + +T radit ional st orage service providers require you t o purchase a reserved amount of st orage capacit y +and net work t raffic before you use resources. If your st orage capacit y or t raffic usage exceeds t he +reserved amount , your service is deact ivat ed or you are charged excess fees. At t he same t ime, if your +st orage capacit y or t raffic usage does not exceed t he reserved amount , you are charged for t he full +amount of t he st orage and t raffic. + +OSS charges you only for t he st orage capacit y and t raffic t hat you consume. T herefore, you do not +need t o purchase st orage capacit y and t raffic before you use resources. You can t ake t he cost +advant ages of t he flexible infrast ruct ure provided by Alibaba Cloud t o grow your business. + +For more informat ion about OSS pricing, go t o t he Pricing t ab of t he OSS product page. For more +informat ion about OSS billing met hods, see Overview. + +Related services +Related services + +Aft er you upload your dat a t o OSS, you can use ot her Alibaba Cloud feat ures and services t o manage +your dat a. + +T he following feat ures and services are frequent ly used wit h OSS: + +Image Processing (IMG): a service t hat allows you t o perform a variet y of operat ions such as format +convert ing, resizing, cropping, rot at ing, and adding wat ermarks t o images st ored in OSS. For more +informat ion, see IMG implement at ion modes. + +Elast ic Comput e Service (ECS): a cloud comput ing service t hat provides elast ic and efficient +comput ing capabilit y. For more informat ion, visit t he ECS product page. + +Alibaba Cloud CDN: a dist ribut ed net work t hat caches resources from an origin server t o edge nodes +in different regions t o accelerat e cont ent delivery. For more informat ion, visit t he CDN product page. + +E-MapReduce (EMR): a big dat a processing solut ion built on ECS. EMR is developed based on open +source Apache Hadoop and Apache Spark t o facilit at e dat a analysis and processing. For more +informat ion, visit t he E-MapReduce product page. + +ApsaraVideo Media Processing: a service t hat convert s audio or video object s st ored in OSS int o files +t hat are suit able for playback on PCs, T Vs, and mobile devices. Deep learning result s from large +amount s of dat a help ApsaraVideo Media Processing perform mult imodal analysis on t he audio, t ext , +and images in video files and t he cont ent of audio files. ApsaraVideo for Media Processing uses t he +analysis result s t o int elligent ly audit , underst and, and edit t he cont ent of t he audio or video files. For +more informat ion, visit t he ApsaraVideo Media Processing product page. + +Dat a Online Migrat ion: a service t hat allows you t o migrat e dat a from a t hird-part y st orage service +such as Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Google Cloud t o OSS wit h ease. For more informat ion, see +Dat a Online Migrat ion document at ion. + +Dat a T ransport : a service t hat helps you migrat e large amount s of dat a from local st orage t o OSS. +For example, you can use Dat a T ransport t o migrat e t erabyt es or pet abyt es of local dat a t o OSS +when t he local net work bandwidt h is insufficient and expansion cost s are high. For more informat ion, +see What is Dat a T ransport ? + +Alibaba Cloud storage services +Alibaba Cloud storage services + +In addit ion t o OSS, Alibaba Cloud also provides a variet y of st orage services such as file st orage and +block st orage for different scenarios. For more informat ion about Alibaba Cloud st orage services, see +Overview. + +For more informat ion about use cases and solut ions of Alibaba Cloud st orage services, visit t he Alibaba +Cloud St orage. + 8 -o -I -0 -P -n -0 -S -tr -- 5 -o -2 -l -3 -0 -s -, -0 -t -N -/ -e -N -I -s -S -t -I -s -T -S -? -T Se -C -c -o -u -m -T -r -e -i -p -t -s -l -y -e -t i -C -t -n -e -o -g -( -n -d -t -) -r -: -o l -contin -te -g -s -e -t -n -e -c -d -y plan -800-26, Other, -N/A) -DCS-3000 Government Only Yes 6/1/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-5000 Government Only Yes 6/3/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-6000 Government Only Yes 2/2/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of -the systems part of or supporting this investment been -identified by the agency or IG? -a. If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into -the agency's plan of action and milestone process? -6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is -requested to remediate IT security weaknesses? -a. If "yes," specify the amount, provide a general description of the weakness, and explain how the funding request will -remediate the weakness. -7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System -(b -sy -) -s -I -t -s -e m -th -? -is -( -a -Y / -n -N -e -) -w -Assessment (PIA) -(d) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t i -L -o -i -n -n k or Rec -r -o -e -r -q -d -u -s -i -N -re -o -d -t i -f -c -o -e -r -( -t -S -h -O -is -R N) (f) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t -L -io -in -n -k or -w -s -h -y -i -s -c -t -h -e -c -m -o -? -v e -(Y -rs -/ N -th -) -i s -system? (Y/N) -DCS-3000 No No No PIA is required by the Yes www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva -E-Government Act at this cyact.html -time for this system -Page 9 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System (b ) I s th is a n e w Assessment (PIA) (d) I n t e r n e t L i n k or Rec o r d s N o t i c e ( S O R N) (f) I n t e r n e t L in k or -sy s t e m ? ( Y / N ) E x p l a n a t i o n r e q u i re d f o r t h is E x p l a n a t io n -| | | | w h i c h c | o v e rs th i s | | | system? (Y/N) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | - -| | | | s y s t e m | ? (Y / N ) | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| DCS-5000 | No | | Yes | | | | Yes | | | -| | | | | | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -cyact.html -| DCS-6000 | No | | No | | | | Yes | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| | | | | No PIA is required by the | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -| | | | | E-Government Act at this | | | | cyact.html | | -time for this system. -Details for Text Options: -Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to (c), provide an explanation -why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. - -Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal register. If no to (e), provide -an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn't a current and up to date SORN. - -Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be considered as a blank field. - -Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be included in the -agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and supporting the FEA. The business -case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and -technology layers of the agency's EA. -| 1. Is this investment included in your agency's target | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enterprise architecture? - a. If "no," please explain why? - -| 2. Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Strategy? - a. If "yes," provide the investment name as identified in Digital Collection Program -the Transition Strategy provided in the agency's most recent -annual EA Assessment. - b. If "no," please explain why? - -| 3. Is this investment identified in a completed (contains a | | | | No | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -target architecture) and approved segment architecture? - a. If "yes," provide the name of the segment architecture as -provided in the agency's most recent annual EA Assessment. - -4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table: -Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, customer relationship management, -etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. -| | | | | | | Service | Service | | | -| ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -| Agency | Agency | FEA SRM | | | | | | Internal or | | -Com p on e nt Co m p o n e n t Se r v ic e FEA SRM FEA SRM Component Component E x t e r n a l BY Funding - Service Type Component (a) Reuse d N ame Reus e d UPI ) Percentage (d) -| Na m e | D e sc ri p t io | n D o m a i n | | | | | | R e u s e ? (c | | -| ------ | ---------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | ( b ) | ( b ) | | | -No Reuse -Legacy Collaborative Back Office Development Legacy -| Integration | Analysis | Services | and Integration | Integration | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| Ad Hoc | Case Analysis | | Reporting | Ad Hoc | | | | No Reuse | | -| | | Business | | | | | | | | -Analytical -Services -Information Interagency Digital Asset Knowledge Information No Reuse -| Sharing | | Services | Management | Sharing | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Information -Sharing -Knowledge Intelligence and Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge No Reuse -| Capture | | Services | Management | Capture | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Evidence -Collection -No Reuse -Knowledge Intra-agency Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge -| Distribution and | Information | Services | Management | Distribution and | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------ | --------- | ----------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Delivery | Sharing | | | Delivery | | | | | | -Query Information Support Services Search Query No Reuse -Analysis - - a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already identified as a service -component in the FEA SRM. - b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather than answer -yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify the other investment using the -Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission. - -Page 10 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service component -provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one agency within a department reusing a service -component provided by another agency in another department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being -reused by multiple organizations across the federal government. -d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed in the table. If -external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another agency to pay for the service. The -percentages in the column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Data Management Database Connectivity Sybase -Delivery -Ad Hoc Component Framework Data Management Reporting and Analysis Word Perfect 6.0 -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Content Rendering Hyper Text Markup Language -Delivery (HTML) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Active Server Pages -Delivery .NetServer Pages .NetMicrosoft -Active Server Pages .Net -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Sun Active Server -Delivery Pages -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Microsoft Server 2003 -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Uniform Resource Locator -(URL) -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Microsoft Internet Explorer6.0 -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Netscape Navigator -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Requirements Legislative / Compliance Section 508 -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Hyper Text Transfer Protocol -Delivery (HTTP) -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Internet Protocol (IP) -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Transport Control Protocol -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Supporting Network Services Simple Network Management -Delivery Protocol (SNMP) -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: ISQL/w -Integration -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: PL/SQL -Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Interface and Integration Middleware Remote Procedure Call (RPC) -Delivery Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Oracle 10i -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Sybase -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Storage HP Series Enterprise Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Application Servers 2600 Dell Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Apache -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Internet Information Server -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Hard Disk -Infrastructure Drives -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Redundant -Infrastructure Array of Independent Disks -(RAID) -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Intel Microprocessors -Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Random Access Memory (RAM) -Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Ethernet -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Virtual LAN (VLAN) -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 2900 Series Switches -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 3700 Series Routers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco Gateway -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ICTG T1 Card -Page 11 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ISDN -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Network Interface Card (NIC) | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Transceivers | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Peripherals | | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hewlett-Packard 4500 Series -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | Printers | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | - - a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter multiple rows for -FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications - b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard or vendor -product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as appropriate. -No -6. Will the application leverage existing components and/or -applications across the Government (i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, -etc)? - a. If "yes," please describe. - -Page 12 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Part II: Planning, Acquisition and Performance Information -Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) -Part II should be completed only for investments identified as "Planning" or "Full Acquisition," or "Mixed Life-Cycle" investments -in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. -In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to the current -baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments to -determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. -1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this project? Yes -a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed? 1/27/2006 -b. If "no," what is the anticipated date this analysis will be -completed? -c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: -2. Alternative Analysis Results: * Costs in millions -Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: -Alternative Analyzed Description of Alternative -Risk Adjus -e -te -st -d -i m -Li -a -fe -te -c ycle Costs Risk Adjuste -e -d -s t -L -im -ife -a -c -t -y -e -c le Benefits -1- Volumetric Collection 245.015 9.443 -3. Which alternative was selected by the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? -Alternative 1 - Volumetric Collection. -4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? -The primary benefits of a regionalized architectural approach for the next generation of DCS-5000 would be to: 1) reduce -overhead costs by utilizing "economies of scale" practices,. -5. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part Yes -or in-whole? -a. If "yes," are the migration costs associated with the This Investment -migration to the selected alternative included in this -investment, the legacy investment, or in a separate migration -investment. -b. If "yes," please provide the following information: -List of Legacy Investment or Systems -Name of the Legacy Investment of Systems UPI if available Date of the System Retirement -DCS-5000 -Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) -You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this investment's life-cycle, -developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing -risk throughout the investment's life-cycle. -1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes -a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan? 4/16/2007 -b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly Yes -changed since last year's submission to OMB? -c. If "yes," describe any significant changes: -A preliminary internal project rating and risk assessment of the DCS-5000 NG acquisition effort was conducted and a DCS-5000 -NG Project baseline for risk was established. The Risk Management Plan (RMP) defined basic organizational, technical, and policy -guidelines for the implementation of risk management within the DCS-5000 Next Generation Project. It established the -techniques and procedures that will be utilized throughout the evolutionary life of the various DCS-5000 Next Generation Project -systems. The procedures described will help ensure the positive identification and management of risk areas associated with -acquisition, development, deployment, and support of the systems. The risk management policies and procedures set forth in -this RMP apply to all DCS-5000 Next Generation Project systems. The policies and procedures of this RMP are tailored for -Page 13 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -specific subsystems and contracts. The DCS-5000 Next Generation Project risk management system used by the DCS-5000 Next -Generation Risk Management Board follows the recommended policies and procedures and use the Glossary of terms set forth -by the Project Management Institute (PMI). These policies and procedures include: Risk management Planning, Risk -Identification, Qualitative Risk Analysis, Quantitative Risk Analysis, Risk Response Planning, and Risk Monitoring and Control. -2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? -a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date? -b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks? -3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle cost estimate and investment schedule: -Risks for the investment are identified within 3 categories: technical, acquisition, and financial. Each risk is evaluated as to its -probability of occurrence and level of impact on schedule, cost, and technical performance to determine the overall risk rating. -Given that, with very limited deviation, effort performed for digital collection implementation is completed by contracted support -through firm fixed price contracts, there is limited risk associated with technical, cost and schedule performance. Baselines -established are provided to contract vendors as contract requirements/deliverables; however, in order to mitigate the risk of -unforeseen requirements and increased scope, a management reserve of 10% is maintained. Cost performance risk is mitigated -through maximum usage of firm fixed price contracts and task orders. Budget projections are reviewed at least quarterly. -Independent government cost estimates are developed, analyzed, and compared to contractor proposals for each major -acquisition. Out-of-tolerance variances are brought to the contractors? attention and cost/price is negotiated. -Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) -EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should still be included -in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should accurately reflect the milestones -in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. -1. Does the earned value management system meet the No -criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard-748? -2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than +/- 10%? (CV%= CV/EV x No -100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) -a. If "yes," was it the CV or SV or both? -b. If "yes," explain the causes of the variance: -c. If "yes," describe the corrective actions: -3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? No -a. If "yes," when was it approved by the agency head? -Page 14 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | - 1 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $8.85 9/30/2004 $8.85 $8.85 $0 100% -(Planning) Prior -to FY05 - 2 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $128.14 9/30/2004 $128.14 $126.53 $1.61 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(Acquisition) -Prior to FY05 - 3 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $31.75 9/30/2004 $31.75 $31.75 $0 100% -(O&M) Prior to -FY05 - 4 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2005 $3.27 9/30/2005 $3.27 $3.12 $0.15 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - 5 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2005 $16.65 9/30/2005 $16.65 $17.33 $-0.68 100% - 6 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2005 $10.32 9/30/2005 $10.32 $11.31 $-0.99 100% - 7 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2006 $3.27 9/30/2006 $3.27 $3.13 $0.14 100% - 8 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2006 $15.7 9/30/2006 $15.7 $15.68 $0.02 100% - 9 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2006 $9.2 9/30/2006 $9.2 $9.2 $0 100% - 10 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2007 $3.31 9/30/2007 $3.31 $4.42 $-1.11 100% - 11 DCS-5000 9/30/2007 $2 9/30/2007 $2 $2 $0 100% -Planning - 12 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2007 $7.64 9/30/2007 $7.64 $7.97 $-0.33 100% - 13 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2007 $9.97 9/30/2007 $9.97 $8.12 $1.85 100% -| 14 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $2.96 | | | $2.96 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 15 | DCS-5000 | 9/30/2008 | $2.55 | | | $2.55 | | | | 0% | -Planning -| 16 | | 9/30/2008 | $20.18 | | | $21.18 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition -| 17 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $8.02 | | | $8.02 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 18 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $9.79 | | | $9.79 | | | | 0% | -| 19 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $2.11 | | | $2.11 | | | | 0% | -| 20 | | 9/30/2009 | $21.26 | | | $21.26 | | | | 0% | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition - -Page 15 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 21 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $9.7 | | | $9.7 | | | | 0% | -| 22 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $14.48 | | | $14.48 | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| Project Totals | | | | | | | | | | | - -Page 16 of 16 \ No newline at end of file + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +2.Features +2.Features + +Object St orage Service (OSS) provides secure, cost -effect ive, and high-durabilit y services for you t o +st ore large amount s of dat a in t he cloud. T his t opic describes t he common scenarios and corresponding +feat ures of OSS. You can select t he best solut ion based on your business requirement s. + +Before you use OSS, we recommend t hat you have a good underst anding of t he basic t erms used in +OSS, including bucket s, object s, regions, and endpoint s. For more informat ion, see T erms. + +T he following t able describes t he feat ures provided by OSS. + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Upload objects + +Search for objects + +Download objects + +Share objects + +Query objects + +Before you upload objects to OSS, you must +create a bucket in an Alibaba Cloud region to +store uploaded objects. After you create a +bucket, you can upload objects to the bucket. + +Create buckets + +Create directories + +Simple upload + +OSS allows you to search for objects and +directories to find the object that you want to +access in a bucket. + +Search for objects + +After you upload objects to a bucket, you can +download the objects to the default +download path of your browser or a specified +local path. + +Download objects + +After you upload an object to a bucket, you +can share the object URL with third parties for +downloads or previews. + +Share objects + +OSS provides the data indexing feature to +allow you to index the metadata of objects. +You can specify the metadata of objects as +index conditions to query objects. T his way, +you can efficiently manage and learn about +data structures, perform queries, collect +statistics, and manage objects. + +Data indexing + +Delete objects or +directories + +OSS allows you to delete one or more objects, +directories, and parts at a time. You can delete +expired objects at regular intervals to save +storage space. + +Delete objects + +Delete directories + +Manage parts + +Automatically delete +multiple objects at a +specified period of time + +OSS supports lifecycle rules. You can configure +lifecycle rules to periodically convert the +storage class of non-hot data to Infrequent +Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive. You can +also configure lifecycle rules to delete expired +data. + +Overview + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +9 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Accelerate the upload and +download of data + +Recover the data that is +accidentally deleted + +Zone-disaster recovery + +Geo-disaster recovery + +OSS supports transfer acceleration. T ransfer +acceleration uses optimal route selection and +protocol stack tuning to reduce timeouts in +remote transmission and improve user +experience. + +OSS supports versioning. After you enable +versioning for a bucket, OSS saves the +overwritten and deleted objects as previous +versions in the bucket. You can configure +versioning to recover an object to a previous +version when the object is accidentally +overwritten or deleted. + +You can store data in and migrate the data +across three zones in the same region by using +zone-redundant storage (ZRS). If one zone +becomes unavailable, you can continue to +access the data that is stored in the other two +zones. T his feature is designed to provide +99.9999999999% (twelve 9's) data durability +and 99.995% service availability. + +OSS supports cross-region replication (CRR). +You can use CRR to synchronize operations +such as creation, update, and deletion of data +from the source bucket to the destination +bucket in a different region. T his way, you can +implement geo-disaster recovery. + +T ransfer acceleration + +Overview + +ZRS + +CRR + +Retention policy + +OSS supports the Write Once Read Many +(WORM) feature. T he feature helps prevent +objects from being deleted or overwritten +within a specified period of time. + +合规保留策略 + +10 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Control access to data + +OSS supports flexible authorization and +authentication mechanisms. You can control +access to your OSS resources by using the +following methods: + +ACL: You can set access control lists (ACLs) +for buckets and objects, including public +read/write, public read, and private. + +Bucket policy: You can configure bucket +policies to authorize other users to access +your OSS resources in the OSS console. For +example, you can authorize RAM users of +other Alibaba Cloud accounts and +anonymous users from specific IP addresses +to access your OSS resources. + +RAM policy: You can create RAM policies to +control access to buckets and directories. +OSS provides RAM Policy Editor to generate +required RAM policies. For more information, +see RAM Policy Editor. + +ST S temporary authorization: You can use +Alibaba Cloud Security T oken Service (ST S) +to grant a third-party application or a RAM +user temporary access credentials with a +custom validity period. + +Hotlink protection: You can configure a +Referer whitelist to prevent unauthorized +users from accessing your OSS resources. + +Bucket ACL + +Configure ACL for +objects + +Bucket Policy + +RAM Policy + +Use a temporary +credential provided by +ST S to access OSS + +Hotlink protection + +Encrypt data + +OSS supports client-side and server-side +encryption. You can select an encryption +method to encrypt and store your data in OSS. + +Client-side encryption + +Server-side encryption + +OSS DDoS protection + +OSS DDoS protection is a proxy-based attack +mitigation service that integrates OSS with +Anti-DDoS Pro and Anti-DDoS Premium. When a +bucket with OSS DDoS protection enabled +becomes a victim of DDoS attacks, OSS DDoS +protection diverts incoming traffic to an Anti- +DDoS Pro or Anti-DDoS Premium instance for +scrubbing and then redirects normal traffic to +the bucket. T his ensures the continuity of your +business in the event of DDoS attacks. + +OSS DDoS protection + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +11 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Integrate with data lake + +Manage data by category + +OSS-HDFS (JindoFS service) is a cloud native +data lake storage service. OSS-HDFS is built on +unified metadata management capabilities and +is fully compatible with Hadoop Distributed File +System (HDFS) API operations. T he Portable +Operating System Interface (POSIX) is +supported in OSS-HDFS. T his helps OSS-HDFS +handle data lake computing scenarios in the +big data and AI fields. + +OSS allows you to configure tagging to +manage data based on the data category: + +Configure bucket tags: You can manage +data based on bucket tags. For example, +you can list buckets that have specified tags +and configure the ACLs of buckets that have +specified tags. + +Configure object tags: You can manage +data based on object tags. For example, you +can configure lifecycle rules and ACLs for +objects that have specified tags. + +Overview of the OSS-HDFS +service + +Configure bucket +tagging + +Object tagging + +Record the access +information for OSS +resources + +OSS supports logging. You can configure +logging to collect access statistics, audit +access to OSS, track exceptions, and +troubleshoot problems. + +Use custom domain names +to access OSS resources + +OSS allows you to map custom domain names +to OSS buckets and use the custom domain +names to access data in the buckets. If you +want to use your custom domain name to +access OSS over HT T PS, you can host your +Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) certificate in OSS. + +Real-time log query + +Logging + +Map custom domain +names + +Host SSL certificates + +Static website hosting + +OSS supports static website hosting. You can +configure static website hosting for your +bucket and access static websites by using the +bucket domain name. + +Overview + +CORS + +OSS supports cross-origin resource sharing +(CORS) in HT ML5. CORS allows web application +clients that are loaded in one domain name to +interact with resources in another domain. + +Configure CORS + +12 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Obtain data from the +origin + +Query object metadata + +Modify HT T P headers + +View the details of +resource usage + +T raffic throttling + +Analyze and process data + +OSS supports back-to-origin configurations. If +your user accesses data in a bucket that has no +back-to-origin rules configured and the data +does not exist, 404 Not Found is returned. +However, if you configure back-to-origin rules +that contain the correct origin URLs, users can +obtain the data from the origin based on the +back-to-origin rules. You can configure back- +to-origin rules for hot data migration and +specific request redirection. + +OSS supports the inventory feature. You can +configure inventories for buckets to export the +metadata of specified objects, including the +object sizes and encryption status. + +OSS allows you to modify the HT T P headers of +objects. You can configure HT T P headers to +specify custom HT T P request policies, such as +the cache policy and forced object download +policy. + +Overview + +Bucket inventory + +Configure object +metadata + +OSS supports the monitoring feature. You can +use the monitoring feature to view real-time +information about OSS service usage, such as +the running status and performance of the +system. + +Overview + +OSS supports single-connection bandwidth +throttling. You can configure single-connection +bandwidth throttling for upload, download, +and copy operations on OSS objects to ensure +sufficient bandwidth for your other +applications. + +OSS provides Image Processing (IMG) and video +snapshot capturing for you to analyze and +process data stored in OSS: + +IMG: You can perform operations on images +stored in OSS, such as format conversion, +cropping, scaling, rotating, and +watermarking. You can also encapsulate +multiple operations into a style to process +images stored in OSS. + +Video snapshot capturing: You can capture +images from video objects in the H.264 +format. + +Single-connection +bandwidth throttling + +Overview + +Video snapshots + +Use tools to manage OSS +resources + +OSS provides graphical, command-line, file +mounting, and FT P tools for you to manage +your OSS resources. + +OSS tools + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +13 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +Use OSS SDKs to manage +OSS resources + +OSS provides SDKs for a variety of +programming languages to facilitate custom +development. + +References + +Overview + +14 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +3.Benefits +3.Benefits + +Object St orage Service (OSS) is a secure, cost -effect ive, and high-durabilit y service t hat enables you t o +st ore large amount s of dat a in Alibaba Cloud. T his t opic compares OSS wit h t he t radit ional self- +managed server st orage t o help you bet t er underst and t he benefit s of OSS. + +Advantages of O SS over self-managed server storage +Advantages of O SS over self-managed server storage + +Item + +OSS + +Self-managed server storage + +Durability + +Security + +OSS is the core infrastructure of data +storage for Alibaba Group. T his reliable +and highly available service is one of the +backbone services that ensure stability +during the peak hours of Double 11. OSS +comes with a multi-redundant +architecture to provide reliable data +storage. In addition, OSS is built on a +high-availability architecture to eliminate +single points of failure (SPOFs) and +ensure the continuity of your services. + +Provides service availability of at least +99.995%. + +Provides data durability of at least +99.9999999999% (twelve 9's). + +Automatically expands capacities +without affecting your services. + +Offers automatic data redundancy. + +Provides multi-level security +protection for enterprises, including +features such as server-side +encryption, client-side encryption, +hotlink protection, bucket policies that +specify IP address blacklists or +whitelists, fine-grained access control, +log audit, and the Write Once Read +Many (WORM) strategy. + +Provides resource isolation +mechanisms for multiple tenants and +supports geo-disaster recovery. + +Complies with the regulations of +multiple organizations including the +U.S. Securities and Exchange +Commission (SEC) and Financial +Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc. +(FINRA), which delivers services that +can meet the requirements of your +enterprise for data security and +compliance. + +Prone to errors due to hardware +failures. If a disk has a bad sector, +data may be lost. + +Requires manual restoration of data, +which can be a complex, time- +consuming, and labor-intensive +process. + +Requires additional scrubbing devices +and blackhole policy-related services. + +Requires a separate security +mechanism. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +15 + + Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +OSS + +Self-managed server storage + +Requires manual expansion of storage +space due to limited capacity of hard +disks. + +Offers limited bandwidth due to slow +single-line or double-line access. +Requires the manual expansion during +peak hours. + +Requires dedicated O&M personnel, +which results in high costs. + +Requires separate purchase and +deployment of data processing +capabilities. + +Cost + +Intelligent storage + +Allows you to use multi-line Border +Gateway Protocol (BGP) to connect to +operator backbone network lines with +sufficient bandwidth resources. +Upstream traffic is free of charge. + +Requires no hosting fees or the need +to hire O&M personnel. + +Provides multiple data processing +capabilities, such as Image Processing +(IMG), video snapshot, document +preview, image scenario recognition, +facial recognition, and SQL in-place +query. OSS can be seamlessly integrated +with the Hadoop ecosystem and Alibaba +Cloud services such as Function +Compute, E-MapReduce (EMR), Data Lake +Analytics (DLA), BatchCompute, +MaxCompute, and Database Backup +(DBS) to manage and analyze data of +enterprises. + +Additional benefits of O SS +Additional benefits of O SS + +Ease of use + +OSS provides st andard REST ful API operat ions, a wide range of SDKs, client t ools, and t he OSS +console. You can upload, download, ret rieve, and manage large amount s of dat a used for +websit es and mobile apps in t he same way you use regular file syst ems. + +T he capacit y of each bucket is unlimit ed. T herefore, you can expand your bucket s in OSS based on +your requirement s. + +OSS support s st reaming writ es and reads. It is suit able for business scenarios t hat require +simult aneous writ e and read of large files such as videos. + +OSS support s lifecycle management . You can configure lifecycle rules t o bat ch delet e expired +object s or convert t he st orage classes of expired object s t o cost -effect ive Infrequent Access (IA), +Archive, or Cold Archive. + +Powerful and flexible securit y mechanisms + +OSS provides Securit y T oken Service (ST S) and URL aut hent icat ion and aut horizat ion. OSS also +support s IP address blacklist s or whit elist s, hot link prot ect ion, and Resource Access Management +(RAM). + +OSS provides resource isolat ion mechanisms for users. You can also use t he mult i-clust er +synchronizat ion service. + +OSS provides server-side encrypt ion, client -side encrypt ion, and encrypt ed t ransmission based on +Secure Socket s Layer (SSL) or T ransport Layer Securit y (T LS) t o prot ect dat a from pot ent ial securit y +risks on t he cloud. + +16 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +OSS provides t he versioning feat ure t o prevent object s from being accident ally delet ed or +overwrit t en. + +Dat a redundancy mechanism + +OSS uses a dat a redundant st orage mechanism t o st ore copies of each object in mult iple devices of +different facilit ies in t he same region. T his way, OSS ensures dat a durabilit y and availabilit y even if +hardware failures occur. + +Operat ions performed on object s in OSS are st rongly consist ent . For example, aft er you upload or +copy an object , t he uploaded or copied object can be immediat ely read and copies of t he object +are writ t en t o mult iple devices for redundancy. + +T o ensure t hat dat a is complet ely t ransmit t ed, OSS calculat es t he checksum of t he net work t raffic +packet s t o check for errors when packet s are t ransmit t ed bet ween t he client and t he server. + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism of OSS can prevent dat a loss even when t wo st orage facilit ies +are damaged at t he same t ime. + +Aft er dat a is st ored in OSS, OSS regularly checks whet her copies of t he dat a are lost . T hen, OSS +recovers lost copies t o ensure dat a durabilit y and dat a availabilit y. + +OSS periodically verifies t he int egrit y of dat a t o det ect dat a corrupt ion caused by errors such as +hardware failures. If dat a is part ially corrupt ed or lost , OSS uses t he ot her copies t o reconst ruct +and repair t he corrupt ed dat a. + +Rich and powerful value-added services + +IMG: support s format conversion, t humbnails, cropping, wat ermarking, and resizing for object s in +format s such as JPG, PNG, BMP, GIF, WebP, and T IFF. + +Audio or video t ranscoding: provides high-qualit y, high-speed, and parallel audio or video +t ranscoding capabilit ies. T his way, your audio or video files can be played on different t erminal +devices. + +T ransfer accelerat ion over t he Int ernet : provides t he t ransfer accelerat ion service, which uses +opt imal rout e select ion and prot ocol st ack t uning t o reduce t imeout s in remot e t ransmission and +improve user experience. For more informat ion, see T ransfer accelerat ion. + +Accelerat ed cont ent delivery: uses OSS as t he origin and works wit h Cont ent Delivery Net work +(CDN) t o improve user experience when t he same object is repeat edly downloaded. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +17 + + Product Int roduct ion··Scenarios + +Object St orage Service + +4.Scenarios +4.Scenarios + +T his t opic describes t he applicat ion scenarios of OSS. + +Massive storage for image, audio, and video applications +Massive storage for image, audio, and video applications + +OSS can be used t o st ore large amount s of dat a, such as images, audio and video, and logs. You can +use a variet y of devices, websit es, and mobile applicat ions t o read dat a from or writ e dat a t o OSS. You +can writ e dat a t o OSS by uploading files or using st reams. + +Dynamic and static content separation for websites and mobile +Dynamic and static content separation for websites and mobile +applications +applications + +By using t he high bandwidt h provided by OSS, you can concurrent ly download a large amount of dat a +from OSS over t he Int ernet . OSS provides T ransfer acceleration t hat accelerat es uploads and downloads +across count ries and cont inent s and improves user experience. You can also use OSS wit h Cont ent +Delivery Net work (CDN) t o deliver st at ic dat a st ored in OSS t o CDN edge nodes. Users can access t he +dat a cached on CDN edge nodes inst ead of t he same dat a st ored in OSS. T his way, t he concurrent and +repeat ed download of an object wit hin t he same region can be accelerat ed. + +Cloud data processing +Cloud data processing + +18 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Scenarios + +Aft er you upload object s t o OSS, you can use ApsaraVideo for Media Processing and Image Processing +(IMG) t o process t he uploaded dat a. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +19 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +5.FAQ +5.FAQ + +T his t opic provides answers t o frequent ly asked quest ions about Object St orage Service (OSS). + +General FAQ +General FAQ + +What is Alibaba Cloud OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud OSS is a secure, cost -effect ive, and scalable st orage service t hat has high durabilit y +and is capable of processing large amount s of dat a. OSS is designed for dat a durabilit y of at least +99.9999999999% (t welve 9's) and provides service availabilit y of at least 99.995%. + +What are t he feat ures of OSS? + +OSS support s REST ful API operat ions t hat are independent of t he OSS console. You can st ore and +access dat a from all applicat ions anyt ime and anywhere. OSS is highly scalable. You are charged only +for t he resources t hat you use. You can scale OSS resources based on your requirement s wit hout +compromising performance or durabilit y. + +You can call API operat ions and use SDKs or OSS migrat ion t ools provided by Alibaba Cloud t o +t ransfer large amount s of dat a t o and from Alibaba Cloud OSS. You can use OSS bucket s of t he +St andard st orage class t o st ore image, audio, and video object s for apps and websit es. You can use +OSS bucket s of t he Infrequent Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive st orage class t o st ore infrequent ly +accessed object s at a low cost and wit h longer st orage period. + +For more informat ion about t he feat ures of OSS, see Features. + +Who are t he int ended users of OSS? + +OSS is an ideal solut ion for users who need t o st ore large amount s of dat a. T hese users include app +and soft ware developers, game development ent erprises, and webmast ers of online communit ies, +media-sharing sit es, and e-commerce websit es. + +What dat a does OSS st ore? + +OSS is suit able for st oring at t achment s, high-definit ion images, audio and video object s, and backup +object s for forums, websit es, and soft ware applicat ions, as well as object s for a variet y of +applicat ions, file synchronizat ion soft ware, and online st orage syst ems. + +What are t he advant ages of OSS over local st orage solut ions? + +OSS allows developers t o make full use of t he economy of scale of Alibaba Cloud at minimal cost +wit hout addit ional invest ment s or affect ing performance. Developers can focus on t heir own +innovat ions wit hout performance bot t lenecks and securit y risks t hat come wit h increasing business +scales. OSS is cost -effect ive and easy t o use. + +What is t he upper limit of t he dat a volume t hat OSS can support ? + +OSS does not impose limit s on t he t ot al st orage capacit y and t he capacit y of a bucket . You can use +t he OSS console t o upload an object up t o 5 GB in size. T o upload an object larger t han 5 GB in size, +use mult ipart upload, resumable upload, ossbrowser, or ossut il. For more informat ion, see Multipart +upload, Quick start, and Overview. + +What st orage classes does OSS provide? + +20 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +T he st orage class of a bucket or an object . OSS provides t he following st orage classes t o cover a +variet y of dat a st orage scenarios from hot dat a t o cold dat a: St andard, IA, Archive, and Cold Archive. +T he St andard st orage class provides high-durabilit y, high-availabilit y, and high-performance object +st orage services t hat can support frequent dat a access. T he IA st orage class is suit able for st oring +dat a t hat is accessed once or t wice a mont h. In addit ion, t he unit price of IA st orage is lower t han +t hat of St andard st orage. T he Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring archive dat a for at least six +mont hs. T he Cold Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring cold dat a over a long period of t ime. +For more informat ion about st orage classes, see Overview. + +Will Alibaba Cloud use t he dat a t hat I st ore in OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud does not use or release your dat a wit hout aut horizat ion. Alibaba Cloud processes user +dat a only based on your service requirement s or requirement s of laws and regulat ions. For more +informat ion, see Service t erms. + +Does Alibaba Cloud use OSS t o st ore t heir own dat a? + +Yes, Alibaba Cloud developers also use OSS t o st ore aut horized dat a for many project s. T hese +project s rely on OSS t o perform key business operat ions. + +How does OSS ensure availabilit y when my OSS service experiences burst s of t raffic from +applicat ions? + +OSS is designed t o address burst s of t raffic from Int ernet applicat ions. Pay-as-you-go is used as a +billing met hod. T o ensure service cont inuit y during burst s of t raffic, OSS does not impose capacit y +limit s. OSS ensures load balancing so t hat applicat ions are not affect ed by burst s of t raffic. + +How is OSS dat a organized? + +OSS is a dist ribut ed object st orage service t hat st ores dat a as key-value pairs. When you st ore an +object , you must specify an object name (key). T he key can t hen be used t o obt ain t he cont ent of +t he object . + +Keys can also be used t o simulat e cert ain feat ures of direct ories. OSS uses a flat st ruct ure for object s +inst ead of a hierarchical st ruct ure. All element s are st ored as object s in bucket s. However, OSS +support s direct ories as a concept t o group object s and simplify management . When you use APIs or +SDKs t o configure an object , you can specify t he key value, a full name t hat includes a prefix for t he +object t o manage ot her object s. For example, if you set t he key of an object t o dir/example.jpg , +a direct ory named dir is creat ed in t he current bucket and an object named example.jpg is +creat ed in t he direct ory. If you delet e t he dir/example.jpg object , t he dir direct ory is also +delet ed. + +How do I get st art ed wit h OSS? + +Before you use OSS, ensure t hat you have creat ed an Alibaba Cloud account and complet ed real- +name verificat ion. If you do not have an Alibaba Cloud account , t he syst em prompt s you t o creat e an +Alibaba Cloud account when you act ivat e OSS. For more informat ion, see Creat e Your Alibaba Cloud +Account . Aft er you creat e t he Alibaba Cloud account , visit t he Object St orage Service product +homepage. Click Act ivat e Now +go. T o furt her minimize OSS cost s, we recommend t hat you purchase resource plans. For more +informat ion, see Buy OSS resource plans (subscript ion). + +Act ivat e Now. By default , t he billing met hod aft er you act ivat e OSS is Pay-as-you- + +You can get st art ed wit h OSS by using t he OSS console, graphical management t ool, command-line +management t ool, and SDKs for various programming languages. For more informat ion, see Get +started with OSS. + +FAQ about Alibaba Cloud regions +FAQ about Alibaba Cloud regions + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +21 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +What is an Alibaba Cloud region? + +An Alibaba Cloud region is a geographical region t hat cont ains mult iple geographically isolat ed +zones. T hese zones are connect ed t o each ot her by using net works t hat feat ure short lat ency, high +t hroughput , and high redundancy. + +What is a zone? + +Each region cont ains several isolat ed locat ions known as zones. T he power supply and net work of +each zone are independent . T he net work lat ency bet ween inst ances wit hin t he same zone is short er. +Zones wit hin t he same region can access each ot her. However, fault s t hat occur in one zone do not +affect ot her zones. + +How do I det ermine which region t o st ore my dat a? + +When you select a region, we recommend t hat you consider fact ors such as physical locat ions, +relat ionships bet ween cloud services, and resource prices For more informat ion, see Choose an OSS +region. + +FAQ about billing +FAQ about billing + +How does OSS charge fees? + +OSS provides t he pay-as-you-go billing met hod t hat allows you t o pay for resources you use. No +minimum usage fees are imposed. You can also purchase resource plans. Resource plans are used t o +deduct fees incurred by resource usage. In most cases, resource plans are more cost -effect ive. For +more informat ion about prices, visit t he OSS pricing page. + +How does OSS charge fees when ot her account s are used t o access my OSS resource? + +When ot her account s access your OSS resources, OSS charges you based on st andard pricing. You can +enable t he pay-by-request er mode for your bucket so t hat request ers pay t he fees generat ed by +sending request s and downloading OSS dat a. For more informat ion, see Enable pay-by-requester. + +FAQ about data security and protection +FAQ about data security and protection + +Is dat a st ored in OSS secure? + +OSS is secure. By default , only t he resource owner can access resources wit hin a bucket . OSS provides +user ident it y verificat ion t o cont rol access t o dat a. You can use various access cont rol policies on t he +bucket or object level, such as access cont rol list s (ACLs), t o grant specific permissions t o specific +users and user groups. T he OSS console displays bucket s t hat are available t o public access. You can +set t he bucket ACL t o privat e if you do not want ot her users t o access your bucket or object . If you +set t he bucket ACL t o public read or public read/writ e, a message t hat indicat es securit y risks +appears. For more informat ion about t he securit y of OSS, see Overview. + +How do I cont rol access t o my OSS dat a? + +OSS provides mult iple access cont rol met hods, including ACLs, RAM policies, and bucket policies, for +access t o object s st ored in bucket s. For more informat ion, see Overview. + +What dat a encrypt ion met hods does OSS provide? + +Server-side encrypt ion: When you upload an object t o a bucket for which server-side encrypt ion is +enabled, OSS encrypt s t he object and st ores t he encrypt ed object . When you download t he +encrypt ed object from OSS, OSS aut omat ically decrypt s t he object and ret urns t he decrypt ed object . +A header is added in t he response t o indicat e t hat t he object is encrypt ed on t he OSS server. For +more informat ion about server-side encrypt ion, see Server-side encryption. + +22 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Client -side encrypt ion: Before you upload an object t o a bucket , t he object is encrypt ed on t he local +client . For more informat ion about client -side encrypt ion, see Client-side encryption. + +How do I prevent dat a st ored in bucket s from being accident ally delet ed or overwrit t en? + +OSS allows you t o configure versioning for a bucket t o prot ect object s t hat are st ored in t he bucket . +Aft er you enable versioning for a bucket , dat a t hat is overwrit t en or delet ed in t he bucket is saved as +a previous version. You can use versioning t o recover a previous version of an object t hat is +accident ally overwrit t en or delet ed. For more informat ion about versioning, see Overview. + +What is a ret ent ion policy? + +OSS support s t he Writ e Once Read Many (WORM) st rat egy t hat prevent s an object from being +delet ed or overwrit t en for a specified period of t ime. You can configure t ime-based ret ent ion +policies for bucket s. Aft er a ret ent ion policy is configured and locked for a bucket , you can read +object s from or upload object s t o t he bucket . However, object s in t he bucket or t he ret ent ion policy +cannot be delet ed wit hin t he ret ent ion period of t he ret ent ion policy. You can delet e t he object s +only aft er t he ret ent ion period expires. + +You can configure ret ent ion policies when you need t o st ore infrequent ly accessed import ant dat a +t hat is not allowed t o be modified or delet ed. Such dat a includes medical records, t echnical +document s, and cont ract s. You can st ore t hese object s in a specified bucket and configure a +ret ent ion policy for t he bucket . + +FAQ about data replication +FAQ about data replication + +How do I replicat e dat a from a bucket t o anot her bucket in a different region? + +You can configure mult iple cross-region replicat ion (CRR) rules for a bucket t o st ore mult iple copies of +t he dat a in different regions. CRR provides aut omat ic and asynchronous (near real-t ime) replicat ion +of object s across bucket s in different OSS regions. Operat ions such as creat ing, overwrit ing, and +delet ing object s can be synchronized from a source bucket t o a dest inat ion bucket . + +What are t he advant ages of CRR? + +Compliance requirement s: Alt hough OSS st ores mult iple replicas of each object in physical disks, +replicas must be st ored at a dist ance from each ot her t o comply wit h regulat ions. CRR allows you +t o replicat e dat a bet ween geographically dist ant OSS dat a cent ers t o sat isfy t hese compliance +requirement s. + +Minimum lat ency: You have users who are locat ed in t wo geographical locat ions. T o minimize t he +lat ency when t he users access object s, you can maint ain replicas of object s in OSS dat a cent ers +t hat are geographically closer t o t hese users. + +Dat a backup and disast er recovery: You have high requirement s for dat a securit y and availabilit y, +and want t o explicit ly maint ain replicas of all writ t en dat a in a second dat a cent er. If one OSS dat a +cent er is damaged in a cat ast rophic event such as an eart hquake or a t sunami, you can use backup +dat a from t he ot her dat a cent er. + +Dat a replicat ion: For business reasons, you may need t o migrat e dat a from one OSS dat a cent er t o +anot her dat a cent er. + +Operat ional reasons: You have comput e clust ers deployed in t wo different dat a cent ers t hat need +t o analyze t he same group of object s. You can choose t o maint ain object replicas in t hese regions. + +How does OSS charge fees when I use CRR? + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +23 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +Aft er CRR is enabled, cross-region t raffic is generat ed when you replicat e object s across bucket s in +t he source and dest inat ion regions. You are charged for t he t raffic t hat is generat ed when you use +CRR. Each t ime an object is synchronized, OSS calculat es t he number of request s and charges t he +request s on a pay-as-you-go basis. T he t raffic t hat is generat ed when you use CRR can be charged +only on a pay-as-you-go basis. Resource plans are unavailable for CRR. + +FAQ about data query +FAQ about data query + +How do I query dat a in OSS? + +OSS support s t he Select Object operat ion t hat allows you t o use SQL st at ement s t o query specific dat a +in a CSV or JSON object inst ead of querying t he ent ire object . T he Select Object operat ion simplifies t he +process used t o query dat a and filt er t he dat a int o smaller and more specific dat a set s. T herefore, t his +operat ion is suit able for t he mult ipart query of large object s, query of JSON object s, and analysis of log +object s. For more informat ion about dat a query, see Call the SelectObject operation to query objects. + +FAQ about storage management +FAQ about storage management + +What is OSS lifecycle management ? How do I use lifecycle management t o minimize OSS st orage +cost s? + +You can configure a lifecycle rule t o regularly delet e object s t hat are no longer accessed or convert +t he st orage class of cold dat a t o IA, Archive, or Cold Archive. T his makes dat a management easier +and saves st orage cost s. For example, you can configure lifecycle rules in t he following scenarios: + +A medical inst it ut ion st ores it s medical records in OSS. T hese object s are occasionally accessed +wit hin six mont hs aft er t hey are uploaded, and almost never aft er t hat . In t his case, you can +configure a lifecycle rule t o convert t he st orage class of t hese object s t o Archive 180 days aft er +t hey are uploaded. + +A company st ores t he call records of it s service hot line in OSS. T hese object s are frequent ly +accessed wit hin t he first t wo mont hs, occasionally aft er t wo mont hs, and almost never aft er six +mont hs. Aft er t wo years, t hese object s no longer need t o be st ored. In t his case, you can configure +a lifecycle rule t o convert t he st orage class of t hese object s t o IA 60 days aft er t hey are uploaded +and t o Archive 180 days aft er t hey are uploaded, and delet e t hem 730 days aft er t hey are +uploaded. + +You can manually delet e up t o 1,000 object s each t ime. If a bucket cont ains more t han 1,000 +object s, you must delet e t he object s mult iple t imes. In t his case, you can configure a lifecycle rule +t hat is used t o delet e all object s in t he bucket t he next day. T his way, all object s in t he bucket can +be delet ed t he next day. + +For more informat ion about lifecycle management , see Lifecycle rules based on the last modified time. + +How do I regularly obt ain t he informat ion about object s st ored in a bucket ? + +You can use t he bucket invent ory feat ure t o export t he informat ion about specific object s in a +bucket on a daily or weekly basis. Export ed object informat ion includes t he number, sizes, st orage +classes, and encrypt ion st at us of t he object s. For more informat ion about t he bucket invent ory +feat ure, see Bucket inventory. + +24 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +6.Terms +6.Terms + +T his t opic describes several basic t erms used in Object St orage Service (OSS). + +bucket +bucket + +T he cont ainer for OSS object s. Each object in OSS is cont ained in a bucket . You can configure various +at t ribut es of a bucket , including t he region, access cont rol list (ACL), and st orage class. You can creat e +bucket s of different st orage classes t o st ore dat a based on your requirement s. + +OSS does not use a hierarchical st ruct ure for object s, but inst ead uses a flat st ruct ure. Each object +belongs t o a bucket . + +You can creat e mult iple bucket s. + +A bucket name must be unique in OSS wit hin an Alibaba Cloud account . Bucket names cannot be +changed aft er t he bucket s are creat ed. + +A bucket can cont ain an infinit e number of object s. + +OSS support s t he following bucket naming convent ions: + +T he name can cont ain only lowercase let t ers, digit s, and hyphens (-). + +T he name must st art and end wit h a lowercase let t er or a digit . + +T he name must be 3 t o 63 charact ers in lengt h. + +object +object + +T he basic unit for dat a operat ions in OSS. Object s are also known as files. OSS does not use a +hierarchical st ruct ure for object s, but inst ead uses a flat st ruct ure. All element s are st ored as object s in +bucket s. However, OSS support s direct ories as a concept t o group object s and simplify management . +An object is composed of object met adat a, user dat a, and a key. A key is used t o ident ify an object in a +bucket . Object met adat a is a group of key-value pairs t hat define t he propert ies of an object , such as +t he last modified t ime and t he object size. You can also assign user met adat a t o t he object . + +T he lifecycle of an object st art s when t he object is uploaded, and ends when t he object is delet ed. +T hroughout t he lifecycle, cont ent can be appended only t o object s creat ed by using append upload. If +you want t o modify t he cont ent of an object , you must upload a new object t hat has t he same name +as t he exist ing object t o replace t he exist ing object . + +T he name of an object must comply wit h t he following convent ions: + +T he name must be encoded in UT F-8. + +T he name must be 1 t o 1,023 charact ers in lengt h. + +T he name cannot st art wit h a forward slash (/) or a backslash (\). + +Not e Object names are case-sensit ive. Unless ot herwise st at ed, object s and files +Not e + +ment ioned in OSS document s are called object s. + +O bjectKey +O bjectKey + +In SDKs for different programming languages, Object Key, Key, and Object Name indicat e t he full pat h of +t he object . You must specify t he full pat h of an object when you perform operat ions on t he object . For +example, when you upload an object t o a bucket , Object Key indicat es t he full pat h t hat includes t he +ext ension of t he object . For example, you can set Object Key t o abc/efg/123.jpg. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +25 + + Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +Object St orage Service + +region +region + +T he physical locat ion of OSS resources. When you creat e a bucket , you can select a region based on t he +cost and source of t he request s. In most cases, t he closer a user is locat ed from an OSS region, t he +fast er t he access. For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +A region is specified when a bucket is creat ed. Aft er a bucket is creat ed, it s region cannot be changed. +All object s in t his bucket are st ored in t he corresponding region. Regions are configured for bucket s +inst ead of object s. + +endpoint +endpoint + +T he domain name t hat is used t o access OSS. OSS uses HT T P REST ful APIs t o provide services. Different +regions are accessed by using different endpoint s. A region has different endpoint s for access over t he +int ernal net work and for access over t he Int ernet . For example, t he public endpoint used t o access OSS +dat a in t he China (Hangzhou) region is oss-cn-hangzhou.aliyuncs.com, and t he int ernal endpoint is oss- +cn-hangzhou-int ernal.aliyuncs.com. For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +AccessKey pair +AccessKey pair + +T he access credent ial t hat is used t o ident ify t he request er. An AccessKey pair consist s of an AccessKey +ID and an AccessKey secret . OSS uses an AccessKey pair t o implement symmet ric encrypt ion and verify +t he ident it y of a request er. T he AccessKey ID is used t o ident ify a user. T he AccessKey secret is used t o +encrypt and verify t he signat ure st ring. T he AccessKey secret must be kept confident ial. OSS support s +AccessKey pairs obt ained by using t he following met hods: + +T he bucket owner applies for an AccessKey pair. + +T he bucket owner uses Resource Access Management (RAM) t o assign an AccessKey pair t o a t hird +part y. + +T he bucket owner uses Securit y T oken Service (ST S) t o assign an AccessKey pair t o a t hird part y. + +For more informat ion about AccessKey pairs, see Obtain an AccessKey pair. + +strong consistency +strong consistency + +T he feat ure t hat requires object operat ions in OSS be at omic, which indicat es t hat operat ions can +eit her succeed or fail wit hout int ermediat e st at es. T o ensure t hat users can access only complet e +object s, OSS does not ret urn part ially uploaded object s. + +Object operat ions in OSS are highly consist ent . For example, when a user receives an upload (PUT ) +success response, t he uploaded object can be immediat ely read, and copies of t he object are creat ed +for redundancy. T herefore, t he sit uat ions where dat a is not obt ained when a user performs a read- +aft er-writ e operat ion do not exist . T he same is t rue for delet e operat ions. Aft er a user delet es an +object , t he object and it s copies no longer exist . + +data redundancy mechanism +data redundancy mechanism + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism t hat is implement ed based on erasure coding and mult iple replicas. +Copies of each object are st ored in different servers wit hin t he same region. T his way, dat a durabilit y +and availabilit y are ensured when hardware failures occur. + +Operat ions on object s in OSS are highly consist ent . For example, when a user receives an upload or +copy success response, t he uploaded object can be immediat ely read, and copies of t he object are +creat ed for redundancy. + +T o ensure complet e dat a t ransmission, OSS calculat es t he checksum of t he net work t raffic packet s +and checks for errors when packet s are t ransmit t ed bet ween t he client and t he server. + +26 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism of OSS can prevent dat a loss even when t wo st orage facilit ies are +damaged at t he same t ime. + +Aft er dat a is st ored in OSS, OSS regularly checks whet her copies of t he dat a are lost . T hen, OSS +recovers lost copies t o ensure dat a durabilit y and dat a availabilit y. + +OSS periodically verifies t he int egrit y of dat a t o det ect dat a corrupt ion caused by errors and +hardware failures. If dat a is part ially corrupt ed or lost , OSS recovers t he dat a by using copies of t he +dat a. + +Comparison between O SS and file systems +Comparison between O SS and file systems + +Item + +OSS + +File system + +Data model + +OSS is a distributed object +storage service that stores data +as key-value pairs. + +A file system uses a typical tree +structure for directory indexing. + +Data retrieval + +Objects are retrieved based on +unique object names (keys). + +For example, the object name +test1/test.jpg does not +necessarily indicate that the +object is stored in a directory +named test1. In OSS, +test1/test.jpg is only a string. +test1/test.jpg is not essentially +different from example.jpg. +T herefore, similar amounts of +resources are consumed +regardless of which object you +access. + +Advantages + +OSS supports concurrent access +from a large number of users. + +T o access a file named +test1/test.jpg, you must first +access the test1 directory and +then query the test.jpg file in this +directory. + +T he file system supports +modifications on files, such as +modifying the content at a +specified offset location or +truncating the end of a file. It +also supports directory +operations such as rename, +delete, and move directories. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +27 + + Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +OSS + +File system + +Objects stored in OSS cannot be +modified. A specific operation +must be called to append an +object. Generated objects are +different from objects uploaded +by using other methods. T o +modify an object, you must +upload the entire object again. + +OSS can simulate features similar +to those of directories. However, +such operations consume a large +amount of resources. For +example, if you want to rename +the test1 directory to test2, OSS +must copy all objects whose +names start with test1/. T hen, +OSS creates objects whose +names start with test2/. T his +operation consumes a large +amount of resources. T herefore, +we recommend that you do not +perform such operations in OSS. + +T he performance of the file +system is subject to the +performance of a single device. +More files and directories in the +file system consume greater +resources and take longer +processing time. + +Disadvantages + +We recommend t hat you do not map operat ions on OSS object s t o file syst ems because it is inefficient . +If you mount OSS as a file syst em, we recommend t hat you perform only add, delet e, and read +operat ions on object s. You can t ake advant age of OSS t o process and st ore large amount s of +unst ruct ured dat a such as images, videos, and document s. + +T he following t able describes t he differences in some t erms bet ween OSS and file syst ems. + +OSS + +Object + +Bucket + +Region + +Endpoint + +AccessKey + +N/A + +GetService + +File system + +file + +home directory + +N/A + +N/A + +N/A + +multilevel directory + +obtain the list of home directories + +28 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +OSS + +GetBucket + +PutObject + +AppendObject + +GetObject + +DeleteObject + +N/A + +File system + +obtain the list of files + +add a file + +append data to an existing file + +read a file + +delete a file + +modify file content + +CopyObject (same destination and source objects) + +modify file attributes + +CopyObject (different destination and source +objects) + +N/A + +copy a file + +rename a file + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +29 + + Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Object St orage Service + +7.Limits +7.Limits + +T his t opic describes t he performance met rics and limit s of Object St orage Service (OSS). + +T he following t able describes t he performance met rics and limit s of OSS. + +Item + +Description + +T he default bandwidth limit is 10 Gbit/s for regions inside the Chinese mainland +and 5 Gbit/s for regions outside the Chinese mainland. If this limit is reached, +requests are throttled. + +No t e When a request is throttled, the response to the request +No t e + +contains the x-oss-qos-delay-time: number header in which + + number indicates the duration over which the request is throttled. Unit: + +ms. For upload requests, the exact duration over which a request is +throttled is returned. For download requests, the estimated duration over +which a request is throttled is returned. T he duration is estimated based on +the extent of throttling and the size of the downloaded objects. + +If you require a higher bandwidth (10 Gbit/s to 100 Gbit/s) for your business such +as offline big data processing,contact technical support. + +T he total QPS limit for a single account is 10,000. T he actual values are different +in different read and write modes: + +Sequential read and write: 2,000 + +If you upload a large number of objects with sequential prefixes such as +timestamps and letters in the object names, many object indexes may be +stored in a single partition. In this case, if you send a large number of requests +to query these objects, the latency may increase. We recommend that you do +not upload a large number of objects that contain sequential prefixes in their +names. For more information about how to change sequential prefixes to +random prefixes, see OSS performance and scalability best practices. + +Non-sequential read and write: 10,000 + +If you require a higher QPS,contact technical support. + +You can use an Alibaba Cloud account to create up to 100 buckets in the same +region. + +A bucket name must be globally unique within OSS. For more information +about the naming conventions of buckets, see Bucket naming conventions. + +After a bucket is created, its name, region, storage class, and redundancy +type cannot be modified. + +OSS does not impose limits on the capacity of a bucket. + +Bandwidth + +Queries per second +(QPS) + +Bucket + +30 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Item + +Description + +Object + +T he size of the object that you want to upload + +When you use simple upload, form upload, or append upload to upload a +single object, the object cannot exceed 5 GB in size. + +When you use multipart upload to upload a single object, the object cannot +exceed 48.8 T B in size. + +T he size of the object that you want to rename + +You can rename only objects that are up to 1 GB in size in the OSS console. T o +rename objects that exceed 1 GB in size, we recommend that you use ossutil. + +T he number of objects that you want to delete + +You can delete up to 100 objects at a time in the OSS console. + +You can delete up to 1,000 objects at a time when you use OSS SDKs, +ossbrowser, or ossutil. + +W arning Deleted objects cannot be recovered. Exercise caution +W arning + +when you delete objects. + +Whether existing objects are overwritten by objects with the same names + +By default, when you upload an object that has the same name as an existing +object, the existing object is overwritten. T o prevent objects from being +accidentally overwritten, you can enable versioning for the bucket in which the +objects are stored. You can also include the x-oss-forbid-overwrite header in +upload requests and set the value of the header to true. + +Data restoration + +You must restore an Archive object or a Cold Archive object before you can +access the object. + +It takes about a minute to restore an Archive object. + +For a Cold Archive object, the restoration period varies based on the +restoration priority of the object. + +Expedited: T he object is restored within one hour. + +Standard: T he object is restored within 2 to 5 hours. + +Bulk: T he object is restored within 5 to 12 hours. + +For a domain name that is mapped to buckets located in regions inside the +Chinese mainland, you must apply for an ICP filing at the Ministry of Industry +and Information T echnology (MIIT ). + +Custom domain name + +Up to 100 domain names can be mapped to a bucket. However, a domain +name can be mapped only to a single bucket. + +OSS does not impose limits on the number of domain names that can be +mapped to the buckets of an Alibaba Cloud account. + +Lifecycle rules + +You can configure up to 1,000 lifecycle rules for a bucket. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +31 + + Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +Description + +Back-to-origin rules + +You can configure up to 20 back-to-origin rules for a bucket. + +In regions inside the Chinese mainland and the China (Hong Kong) region, the +default QPS for mirroring-based back-to-origin requests is 2,000, and the +default bandwidth is 2 Gbit/s. In regions outside China, the default QPS for +mirroring-based back-to-origin requests is 1,000, and the default bandwidth +is 1 Gbit/s. + +Limits on images + +Source images + +Only JPG, PNG, BMP, GIF, WebP, and T IFF images are supported. + +T he size of a source image cannot exceed 20 MB. + +For the rotate operation on images, the height or width of the source +image cannot exceed 4,096 pixels. For other operations on images, the +width or height of the source image cannot exceed 30,000 pixels, and +the total number of pixels of the source image cannot exceed 250 +million. + +T he total number of pixels of a dynamic image, such as a GIF image, is +calculated by using the following formula: Width × Height × Number + +Image Processing (IMG) + +of image frames . T he total number of pixels of a static image, such + +as a PNG image, is calculated by using the following formula: Width × + +Height . + +Resized images + +T he width or height of a resized image cannot exceed 16,384 pixels. T he +total number of pixels of the resized image cannot exceed 16,777,216. + +Limits on image styles + +You can create up to 50 image styles in each bucket. T o create more styles +for a bucket,contact technical support. + +32 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Item + +Description + +Resource plans + +Resource plans that you purchase for specific regions can be used to offset +the fees generated by the resource usage only within the specified regions. + +You can use resource plans to offset the fees generated by the resource +usage in the regions that you specify when you purchase the resource plans. + +You can purchase only one storage plan for each validity period. However, you +can upgrade the storage plan that you purchase. For more information about +how to upgrade a storage plan, see Overview. + +You can purchase multiple transfer acceleration plans and back-to-origin +traffic plans within the same validity period to offset your fees. However, +these plans cannot be upgraded or renewed. + +You can purchase multiple downstream traffic plans within the same validity +period to offset your fees. T hese plans can be renewed but cannot be +upgraded. + +No resource plans are available to offset API operation calling fees, data +processing fees, and cross-region replication (CRR) traffic fees. You are +charged these fees on a pay-as-you-go basis. For more information, see API +fees, Data processing fees, and T raffic fees. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +33 + diff --git a/q236/random_k2/random_2.md b/q236/random_k2/random_2.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..9ca97bffcc729b1713813967b06486a19042b100 100644 --- a/q236/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q236/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,493 +1,1121 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. +1 +Consumption +Landscape +September 2016 3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - +stnetnoC +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +Introduction +6 Section 1: Sample +8 Section 2: Music Consumption +18 Section 3: Device Usage +22 Section 4: Music Streaming Uptake & Perceptions +30 Section 5: Music Discovery +36 Section 6: Music Spending and Piracy +42 Section 7: User Generated Content + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 55 +INTRODUCTION +Today, consumers can listen Crucially, the free reign that consumers have over +how they access and consume music means that +to any music they want, at +the radio and music industries are totally consumer +any time, in any place and driven – no one but the audience dictates +what music is popular and successful. As +in any format, whether it be +a result, everybody in music management, +downloads, radio, streaming, publishing, broadcasting and streaming must keep +their finger on the pulse of the constant changes in +CDs or vinyl and, importantly, +consumer audio consumption, and how they +that privilege costs far less impact the industry as a whole. +than it used to, if it costs The report, ‘Music Consumption: The Overall +Landscape’, encapsulates a democratic measure +anything at all. +of audio consumption in the US, and saw a +statistically and demographically representative +sample of the 15+ US population answer a set of +general questions about listening habits. These +ranged from share of ear between radio to online +sources; to device preferences and piracy behavior; +to more detailed questions about playlist use; lean +forward / lean back selection; music sharing habits; +attitude to pricing; exclusive and hi-res audio and +much more. As a result, it uncovers the overall +music consumption landscape, how it is changing, +and how these changes may reshape the music +industry’s macro-environment. It is, therefore, an +invaluable tool for any company or person +operating within radio or music, and the creative +industries at large. + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - +SAMPLE +3014 Respondents +A statistically and demographically representative +sample of the US population. +All respondents had online access. +GENDER AGE +| | | | 15-19 | 9% | +| ---- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | 20-24 | 9% | +| Male | Female | | | | +25-34 +17% +| 51 | 49 | | 35-44 | 16% | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | 45-54 | 18% | +| | | | 55-64 | 15% | +elpmaS +| | | | 65+ | 16% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +REGION SOCIAL GRADE +| | | | < $15K | 11% | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +:1 NOITCES +| | 20% | $15K to $24,999K | | 11% | +| --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +NORTHEAST +| | | $25K to $34,999K | | 12% | +| ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| MIDWEST | 24% | | | | +| | | $35K to $49,999K | | 14% | +| SOUTH | 35% | $50K to $74,999K | | 2% | +| | 21% | $75K to $99,999K | | 15% | +WEST +| | | | >$100K | 15% | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - +TIME SPENT +LISTENING +TO MUSIC +Total Sample +| | At 23%, the most popular listening block was 1 to | | | | On average, the total sample listened to 147 minutes | | | | +| --- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +noitpmusnoC 2 hours. of music on a ‘typical day’. Minutes listened dropped +as respondents got older, peaking amongst the 15- +68% of respondents listened to music for up to 3 +24 year olds at 187, dropping to 85 minutes amongst +hours on a typical day, whilst 7% didn’t listen to any +the 65+ year olds. +music at all. +23% +17% +15% +13% +8% +7% +5% +3% +| cisuM | 2% | | | 2% | | | | | +| ------ | ------------ | ------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------------- | ------ | ------------ | +| | | | 1% 1% 1% | | | | | | +| | 0% | 0% | | | | | | | +| | 12+ 11 -12 | 10 -11 | 9 -10 8 -9 7 -8 | 6 -7 5 -6 | 4 -5 | 3 -4 2 -3 1 -2 | 1 hour | 30 mins None | +| | hours hours | hours | hours hours hours | hours hours | hours | hours hours hours | | | +:2 NOITCES +Average minutes listened: +| | 147 | | 187 | 179 | | 122 | | 85 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | +| | MINS | | MINS | MINS | | MINS | | MINS | +| | Total Sample | | 15-24 year olds | 25-44 year olds | | 45-64 year olds | | 65+ | +Question: To the nearest half hour, how long do you normally spend listening to music in a typical day? +Base: 3014 + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +1111 +RADIO RULES THE YOUNGER +LISTENING ROOST CONSUMERS ARE +HEAVY ONLINE +LISTENERS +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +Radio is still king, capturing 35% of net daily On demand streaming is second with 24% (digital All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +listening. downloads are third with 12% and other internet +radio (Pandora etc.) is fourth with 10%; all ahead of +Mainstream digital content, meanwhile, are Younger generations are predominantly listening the older age groups with respondents aged 55-64 +CDs at 7%. Share of listening shows the percentage, +comfortably outperforming physical forms of to on-demand streaming and 65+ listening to radio most (45% and 53%) +or share, of time respondents spent on each method +music. followed by downloads (13%). +| | | of listening – i.e. Broadcast Radio captured 36% of | Whilst 24% of the general population listened to | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +respondents’ total listening time. on demand streaming on a ‘typical day’, 51% of *Share of listening can be defined as: The portion, +| | | | 15-19 year olds and 41% of 20-24 year olds did the | | | | | or share, of respondent’s total listening time each | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SHARE OF LISTENING +| | | | same, a significant over-index. Radio trends up in | | | | | format accounted for. | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SHARE OF LISTENING BY AGE +AM/FM Radio 35 +53 +51 +On demand streaming (YouTube, Spotify etc.) 24 +45 +42 +| Digital Downloads/Files | | | | | | 41 | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +12 +35 +33 +31 +| Other Internet Radio (Pandora etc.) | | 10 | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +27 +24 +| | | | | | | 21 | | 22 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | CDs | 7 | | | 20 | | | | | | | | | | +19 +17 +15 +| | | | | | | | 14 13 | 14 | 13 | | | 13 | | 13 | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | 12 | 12 | | 11 | | | | | | | | 11 | +| Satellite Radio (Sirius XM etc.) | | 6 | | 10 | | | | | | 1110 | | | | | +| | | | | | 9 | | | | | | 9 | | | | +| | | | | 7 | | | | | 7 | 7 | | 7 | | | +| | | | | 6 | | | | | | 6 | | | 6 6 | 7 | +| | | | | | | | 4 4 | | 5 | | | 5 | | | +3 +| | | | | | 2 2 | 2 | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| AM/FM Radio Stations Streamed online | | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | Total | | 15-19 | 20-24 | 25-34 | 35-44 | | 45-54 | 55-64 | | 65+ | | +Vinyl 1 -0 - +| | | | AM/FM RADIO | | | | | | ONLINE STREAMING (OVERALL) | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | ON DEMAND STREAMING (YOU-TUBE, SPOTIFY,ETC) | | | | | | INTERNET RADIO | | | | | | +HD Radio 1 +| | | | DIGITAL DOWNLOADS/FILES | | | | | | PHYSICAL | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Question: To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening time normally split between the following sources? +Base: 2808 Respondents Question: To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening time normally split between the following sources? Base: 2808 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +1133 +ONLINE SOURCES ARE RADIO IS STILL +CATCHING FM RADIO REACHING ALL +IN WEEKLY REACH AGE GROUPS +Total Sample By Age +In terms of reach (listened to once for 5 minutes Please note – ‘Online Consumption (Total) is the On demand streaming vastly over-indexes AM/FM Radio listening, meanwhile, peaked +or more over a weekly period) FM Radio came net of On-demand streaming and internet radio. amongst younger generations, then declined as amongst 35-44 year olds at 84%. Physical listening +top at 78%. This was then followed by Online respondents got older. rose with age, before dropping slightly amongst the +Consumption at 72%, on-demand streaming at 65+ year olds. +61%, internet radio at 43%, digital downloads at +US WEEKLY REACH - BY AGE +33% and physical music at 23%. +US WEEKLY REACH - NETS +95 +93 +| | | | | 90 | | 89 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 84 | | 84 | | | | +| | | | | | | 81 | 82 | 81 | | | +| | | | 78 | 95 | 78 | 77 | | | 78 | | +| | | | 72 | | | | | | | 71 | +69 +68 +FM Radio +78% 65 +63 +61 +| | | | | | | | | 56 | 56 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +54 +52 +| Online Consumption (Total) | | | | | | 50 | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 72% | | 48 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 44 | | | | 44 | | +| | | | 43 | 43 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 40 | | 40 | +39 +| On-demand streaming | | 61% | 33 | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +31 +28 +| | | | | | | | | 2626 | 27 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +25 +| | | | 23 | | | 23 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 21 | 21 | | +19 +| Internet Radio | 43% | | | | 18 | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -------------------------- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | 13 | | | | | | 14 | +| Digital Download 33% | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | Total | 15-19 | 20-24 | 25-34 | 35-44 | 45-54 | 55-64 | 65+ | +| Physical Music | | | AM/FM RADIO | | | | | ONLINE STREAMING (OVERALL) | | | +23% +| | | | ON DEMAND STREAMING (YOU-TUBE, SPOTIFY,ETC) | | | | | INTERNET RADIO | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | DIGITAL DOWNLOADS/FILES | | | | | PHYSICAL | | | +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last Question: Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents during the last seven days? Online Streaming (Overall) = On demand streaming + Internet radio (NET) Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 15 +YOUTUBE IS THE It has recently launched its YouTube Red premium The key questions around YouTube for the coming +subscription service, which covers music and other year are whether other music services can attract +verticals, and rights holders are starting to see new listeners and start to fill this value gap and +MOST REGULARY +decent pots of revenue slowly emerge from that. whether YouTube will work to increase its Red +user base and payouts to the music industry while +The popularity of on demand music services will +USED SOURCE FOR finding other ways to generate revenue for rights +grow. But for the world’s most accessed streaming +holders and appease them, something its recent +service in order to listen to music, the ‘free’ +acquisition of D2C commerce Bandpage might help +AUDIO CONTENT problem is still a big problem. +it work towards. +US WEEKLY REACH BY PLATFORM +42% of respondents said The YouTube value gap is one of the leading +industry topics of 2016. Put in context with an equal +they used YouTube for five +42% of respondents who said they were happy with +minutes or more at least once free tiers of music services enough not to upgrade, YouTube 42% +Pandora 31% +it is a gap made to feel even glaringly bigger by the +a week to listen to audio. Spotify 22% +survey results. +iTunCeDs 18% +Pandora follows closely at +According to the survey, YouTube was the key iHeart Radio 18% +31% with CDs lagging behind touch point for audio listening across online and Amazon Prime Music 13% +13% +offline, especially for the younger generations. Music as digital files +at 22%. This rose to 67% in +12% +It is also the leading point of discovery behind Facebook +12% +15-24 year-olds. recommendations from friends – 34% of Google Play Music +9% +respondents said they discovered music via Apple Music +9% +YouTube, which rose to 54% of 15-24 year olds. Amazon Music Store +7% +TV Music Channels +YouTube has long had a fractious relationship with 7% +Vevo +the music industry. Praised by marketers for its 5% +SoundCloud / SoundCloud Go +reach and ability to launch and stoke the release of 5% +Vinyl +new music on a global level, or to create overnight 3% +My SXM +3% +sensations like The Harlem Shake, at the same +Podcast(s) +3% +time it pays out lower royalties to rights holders +Shazam +3% +per stream than dedicated music services and has +An artist’s own online website 3% +been criticised consistently at the negotiating table. +Rhapsody 3% +Vimeo 3% +Audible 3% +8Tracks 3% +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +17 +| YOUNGER | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | FACEBOOK LEADS | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| GENERATIONS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | SOCIAL MEDIA USAGE | | | | | | | | | | | | | +FAVOUR ONLINE +PLATFORMS +Total Sample +By Age Facebook dominates platform usage while Despite its buzz Snapchat is still relatively +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Twitter is weak. 57% of respondents used | | | | | | | niche, with 30% net usage and only 13% using | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Facebook everyday, whilst 15% used Twitter. | | | | | | | it everyday. Pinterest is also used more than | | | | | | +| YouTube usage is high in the younger age groups, | | | | | | | | CD’s in comparison to older users, just 11% of | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Instagram, Snapchat and Vine, with 47% net usage. +| decreasing consistently with age. Pandora has a | | | | | | | | 15-19 year olds listening to a CD over a weekly period. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fairly even spread, before dropping amongst the +Here, on-demand streaming services are making +oldest age groups. +up the difference. 71% of 15-19 year olds listening to +SERVICE USAGE REGULARITY & AWARENESS +| Younger generations under-indexed on listening to | | | | | | | | YouTube, and 44% to Spotify over a weekly period. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +PLATFORM WEEKLY REACH BY AGE +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | YouTube | | | 33 | | 24 | | | 12 | 14 | | 14 3 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Facebook | | | | 57 | | | | 11 6 | 6 | | 17 3 | +Netflix +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 23 | | | 19 | 9 | 9 | | 35 | | 4 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 71 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Pinterest | | 12 | 12 | 10 | 14 | | | 44 | | | 9 | +63 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | iTunes | | 10 | 11 | 8 | 18 | | | 47 | | | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +51 +| | | | | | | 46 | | | | | | | 44 | | | | Twitter | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 42 | | 42 | 39 | | 42 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 15 | 10 | 9 | 13 | | | 48 | | | 6 | +| | | | | | 38 | 36 | | | | | | | 37 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 31 | 31 | | | | | | | | | | | | | G o o g le | + | 11 | 9 | 8 | 15 | | | 4 8 | | | 8 | +| | | | | | | | 28 | | | | 26 26 25 | | | 26 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 19 | | | | 19 | 22 | | 22 19 | | | | | | | In st a g ra | m | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 14 | | 16 | | | 18 | | 18 | | | | | 18 | | 8 7 | 9 | | | 5 1 | | | 7 | +| | | | | | | | | | 11 | | | | | | 13 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 7 4 | Amazon Prime instant | | 7 | 9 | 7 | 12 | | | 50 | | | | 15 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Spotify | | 11 | 8 | 5 9 | | | 52 | | | | 14 | +| | YouTube | | | | Pandora | | | | | CD | | | Spotify | | | | LinkedIn | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 4 | 7 | 8 | 15 | | | 53 | | | | 13 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Snapchat | | 13 | 6 | 4 6 | | | 59 | | | | 12 | +| | 28 26 | 26 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Tumblr | 6 | 5 | 4 7 | | | 60 | | | | | 19 | +| | | 21 | | | | | | | | 20 20 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 18 | | | | | | 19 17 | | | | | | | 15 16 | 15 16 | | | Sound c lou | d 4 | 4 5 | 8 | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 13 11 | 13 | 13 14 | | 13 | 13 | 14 | | 11 | 12 | | | 13 | | | | | | | 36 | | | | 44 | | | +| | | | 7 | | | | 9 6 | | 7 | | 9 | 6 | | | 8 5 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | V im e | o 3 | 5 5 | 8 | | 44 | | | | | 36 | | +Vine +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 4 | 3 4 | 7 | | | 55 | | | | 27 | | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | ---------------------- | ----- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | iTunes | | | iHeart Radio | | | | Amazon Prime Music | | | | Music as digital files | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Whatsapp | 7 | 3 3 | 5 | | 43 | | | | 40 | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | MySpace | 2 3 | 2 7 | | | | 74 | | | | | 12 | +| | 16 | 17 | | | | 17 | | | 20 16 | 17 | | | | | | | Tinder | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 12 | 10 | 14 | 11 8 | 9 | 11 12 | 14 | | 9 | | 10 | | | 9 | 12 11 | | | | 3 | 3 2 3 | | | 56 | | | | | 32 | | +| | | | 7 | | | | 7 5 2 | | | | 6 2 | 2 7 | 4 | | 4 4 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Deezer | 2222 | | 22 | | | | | 69 | | | | +| | Facebook | | | | Google Play Music | | | | Apple Music | | | Amazon Music Store / Amazon | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Cloud Player +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE EVERYDAY | | | I USE 2-3 TIMES A WEEK | | | I USE ONCE A WEEK | | | | I USE LESS OFTEN | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +TOTAL 15-19 20-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65+ I AM AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE BUT DO NOT USE I AM NOT AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents Question: Which of the following statements best describes you in relation to each of the following web-based services? Base: 3014 Respondents + +19 +FM/AM radio receiver 33 +Smartphone / Cellphone 18 +Desktop computer 8 +Laptop or netbook 7 +Satellite Radio Receiver (Sirius XM etc.) 7 +Internet/wi-fi connected radio receiver 4 +In car CD Player 4 +Television 3 +In-car phone audio connection (wired aux 3 +Tablet (iPad etc.) 3 +CD Player 3 +iPod 2 +Other portable mp3 or media player 1 +Wireless speakers (Bluetooth etc.) 1 +Vinyl Player 1 +Other 1 +:3 +NOITCES +egasU +eciveD +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +FM/AM RADIO +IS THE MOST +LISTENED TO DEVICE +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +At 33%, Radio took the majority share as the Smartphone device gap. Mobile phone listening +device listened to the most. is 2nd with 18% and roughly equivalent to the +combined listening on laptop (7%), desktop (8%) +Share of listening can be defined as: The portion, +and tablets (3%), which acculmulates to (18%). +or share, of respondent’s total listening time each +device accounted for. +SHARE OF LISTENING BY DEVICE +To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening normally split between the following devices? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +21 +| THE SMARTPHONE | | | | | | | | | | | | | | THE SMARTPHONE | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| IS KING AMONGST | | | | | | | | | | | | | | REIGNS OVER DAILY | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| YOUNGER LISTENERS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | LISTENING | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day Total Sample +Age distribution across radio receivers starts in the 15-19 age bracket, and gradually decreases The smartphone was the most regularly listened This was then followed by the Smartwatch (31%), +low for 15-19 years olds and grows in linear with age. to device, daily, out-performing radio receivers Laptop (30%) and FM/AM radio receiver (29%). +fashion as respondents got older to peak at 49% with 46% of respondents saying they use it to +Laptop/netbook skews slightly young while satellite +amongst those aged 65+. The opposite holds for listen to music every day. +radio peaks amongst 35-44 and 65+ year olds. +smartphone / cellphone users with a peak at 41% +DEVICES: REGULARITY OF USAGE TO LISTEN TO MUSIC +FM/AM radio receiver +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 29 | | | | 31 | | | 21 | | 6 | 5 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +DEVICE SHARE OF LISTENING BY AGE +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Satellite radio receiver | | | | | 26 | | | 28 | | | | 22 | 7 | 7 | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Smartphone / Cellphone | | | | | | 46 | | | | | 18 | | 9 | 4 6 | 6 | +49 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | In-car phone audio | | | 21 | | | | 27 | | | 24 | | 9 | 9 | 7 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +42 +41 +| | | 39 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Smartwatch | | | | 31 | | | | | 26 | | | 14 | 3 5 | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 33 | | 32 | | 31 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Internet/wi-fi connected radio receiver | | | | | | 28 | | | 24 | | | 18 | | 10 | 8 | 7 | +| | | 26 | | | 24 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Laptop or netbook +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 30 | | | | 18 | | 14 | | 7 10 | | 10 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +| | 20 | | | | 19 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +18 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Wireless speakers | | | 15 | | 20 | | | 27 | | | 14 | | 15 | 8 | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | 14 | | | | | 14 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | 11 | | | | | | | | | | | 11 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 9 | 8 | 10 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 7 | 8 | 8 | 7 6 | 6 | 7 | 8 7 | | | | Desktop computer | | | | 23 | | | 20 | | 15 | | 8 | 11 | | 11 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | 6 | 5 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 3 | | | | | | | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Television | | | 25 | | | 20 | | | 11 | 5 | 9 | | 15 | +| | FM/AM radio receiver | | Smartphone / Cellphone | | | | | Desktop computer | | | Laptop or netbook | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Tablet | | 21 | | | 17 | | | 18 | | 8 | 14 | | 11 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | iPod | | 15 | | 17 | | | 21 | | 10 | | 20 | | 14 | +11 +9 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | In car CD player | | | 9 | 14 | | | 23 | | 12 | | 20 | | | 16 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +7 +| 7 | | | | 6 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 6 5 | | | 6 | | | | | | | | | | | | Playstation | | 12 | | 12 | | 19 | | | 11 | 13 | | 16 | | +6 +| | | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 | | 4 4 3 | 4 | | 4 4 | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------ | ----- | --------------------------- | -------------- | ----- | --- | ------------------------------- | ----------------------- | ----- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 3 | | | | | 3 | | 3 | | 3 | 3 | 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | 2 | 2 | 2 | | | | Xbox | | 10 | 12 | | | 19 | | 8 | | 15 | | 17 | | +| | 2 | | | | | 2 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1 | | 1 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | CD Player | 6 | | 11 | | 19 | | 13 | | 25 | | | 19 | | +| | Satellite Radio Receiver | | Internet / wi-fi connected | | | | | Television (including a | | | Tablet (iPad etc.) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Vinyl Player | 5 | 7 | 10 | | 12 | | | 27 | | | 31 | | | +| | (Sirius XM etc.) | | | radio receiver | | | satellite or cable enabled tv) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE EVERYDAY | | | | | | | | | | I USE 2-3 TIMES PER WEEK | | | | | | | +| | TOTAL | 15-19 | 20-24 | | 25-34 | | 35-44 | 45-54 | | 55-64 | | 65+ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE ONCE A WEEK | | | | | | | | | | I USE LESS OFTEN | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I AM AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE BUT DO NOT USE | | | | | | | | | | I AM NOT AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE | | | | | | | +To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music split between the following devices? +Question: Approximately, how often do you use each of the following to listen to music? +Base: 2808 Respondents Base: Users of each device (2168 FM/AM Radio Receiver users, 2181 Television users etc.) + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +23 +17% PAID FOR +A PREMIUM + gnimaertS cisuM +SUBSCRIPTION +TO A MUSIC +STREAMING SERVICE +Total Sample + dna ekatpU snoitpecreP +| | 21% of US respondents initially stated that they | | | | | Last year, in the same annual study, 13% actually | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | have a premium subscription to a streaming service. | | | | | paid for a subscription to a music streaming | | | +| | However, upon further investigation, 17% actually | | | | | service. This shows a 31% increase YOY. | | | +paid for the service, whilst 4% used the service on a +Paid subscriptions skewed slightly skewed male, with +free subscription, through a free trial, bundle deal, or +20-34 year olds over-indexing significantly at 29%, +using through someone else’s account. +in comparison the the general population (17%). +PAID/PREMIUM MUSIC STREAMING SUBSCRIPTIONS +| | Total | 17% | | 4% | | | 79% | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Male | 20% | | 4% | | | 76% | | +| | Female | 15% | 3% | | | | 82% | | +| | 15-19 | 21% | | 6% | | | 73% | | +20-24 +| | | | 29% | | 6% | | | 65% | +| ---------- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| :4 NOITCES | 25-34 | | 31% | | 5% | | | 64% | +| | 35-44 | | 23% | 3% | | | 74% | | +| | 45-54 | 11% | 3% | | | | 86% | | +| | 55-64 | 6% 3% | | | | 91% | | | +65+ +| | | 4%3% | | | | 93% | | | +| --- | ----------------- | ---- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | PAID SUBSCRIPTION | | | FREE SUBSCRIPTION (FREE TRIAL ETC) | | | | NO | +Do you have a paid/premium subscription to a music streaming service?Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +25 +SPOTIFY IS THE MOST THE FREE TRIAL IS +PAID FOR MUSIC THE MOST EFFECTIVE +STREAMING SERVICE CONVERSION METHOD +All who have subscribed to a music streaming service Those who pay for a music streaming subscription +Amongst premium subscribers, Spotify (37%), 55% of 15-19 year olds who have a paid for The key driver to paid subscription is a free trial. +Pandora (32%), Apple Music (22%) and YouTube streaming subscription subscribe to Spotify, 53% said that they subscribed in order to continue +Red (19%) are the most paid for services. a considerable over-index over the general using the full version after a free trial period. +| | population (45%). Meanwhile, the same age group | | Meanwhile, only 31% of respondents said they | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Spotify skews to younger users, whereas +| | under-index on paying for Pandora, Amazon Prime | | decided to pay to remove adverts and and 29% to | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Pandora, Amazon Prime Music and YouTube Red +| | Music and YouTube Red. | | use service on mobile. | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +are less favourable. +STREAMING SERVICES SUBSCRIBED TO AMONGST SUBSCRIBERS REASONS FOR PAYING FOR A STREAMING SERVICE +| Spotify | | | 45% | I used the full version of the | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +55% service on a free trial period, +53% +| | | 39% | | liked it and decided to pay for | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| Pandora | | | | | the full version | | | +23% +| | | 28% | | I was using the free version, | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Amazon Prime Music +| | 8% | | | liked it, but wanted to remove | | | 31% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +advertisements +| Apple Music | | 26% | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +25% +I wanted to use it on my +| YouTube Red | | 24% | | | mobile device | | 29% | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +15% +| Google Play Music | 18% | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Recommendation from +7% +| | | | | | friends/family | 24% | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +12% +Rhapsody +6% +I wanted to listen to a +| | 7% | | | s o n | g / a lb u m r e le a s ed | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +Xbox Groove 17% +| | 0% | | | exc l u | s iv e ly t h ro u g h th e | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | +platform +| Last.fm | 6% | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3% +Saw it advertised and liked the +10% +| Soundcloud go | 5% | | | | look of it | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | +6% +| Deezer | 5% | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 0% | | | Don’t know / Not sure | | 5% | | +4% +Tidal +6% +| | 7% | | | Other (please specify) | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Other (Please write in) | | | | | | 9% | | +1% +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Which of the following do you have a premium subscriptions to? +Why did you decide to pay for a music streaming subscription? +Base: 607 Respondents Base: 607 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 27 +THE FREEMIUM change: Pandora wants to launch a mid-tier on +demand offering and Amazon is rumoured to be +exploring lower cost options, including bundling +QUESTION +with Alexa, for its own on demand music service, +In the meantime Spotify and Apple Music are +pushing forward with family plans to offset the cost +of subscriptions, and may well compete with their +own mid-level tiers once these others launch. Will it +be enough to lure this 42%? +42% respondents weren’t The freemium question is a difficult one. Failed REASONS FOR NOT PAYING FOR A STREAMING SERVICE +services like Rdio have admitted that lack of a +paying for music streaming +free tier hurt their growth and that once onboard +services because they were via subscription users did not stick around long +I’m happy using the free +enough to become embedded in the service and +happy using freemium tiers version with adverts 42% +churned. At the same time the economics of free +with adverts. ad-supported tiers are very difficult to make work. It’s too expensive 40% +Free tiers are a funnel to paid subscription not a +I prefer not to pay for music / +means to an end in themselves and ad-supported prefer to use free music 29% +sources like YouTube +online video platform Muzu.tv recently shut down +due to inability to pay rights holders – it was on a It doesn’t appeal to me 28% +50/50 ad revenue split which is likely a less severe +I prefer to listen to music in a +position than most streaming services. different way 14% +42% of respondents said they were happy using I don’t really understand what +3% +it is +free tiers with adverts, suggesting that it would be +very hard for music services to upsell nearly half of The content range isn’t good +3% +enough +respondents to paid subscriptions, leaving them +with already tight profit margins made tighter. This +There isn’t enough +2% +personalisation +rose to 55% of 15-24 year-olds and 47% of 25-44 +year olds, suggesting that free tiers may put off +The audio quality isn’t good +1% +the younger generations from paying for premium enough +subscriptions. +Don’t know / Not sure 5% +So far mid-tier services like Cür Media in the +US or Bloom.fm in the UK have failed to get +Other (Please Specify) 3% +off the ground while existing mid tier options, +predominantly premium tiers of interactive radio +services, have not been a big draw. This is due to +Why have you not subscribed to a music streaming service? +Base: 2276 Respondents + +29 +CHEAPER PRICING +OPTION16% S W3O8% ULD2 6% +PERSUADE LISTENERS +TO PAY FOR STREAMING +All who have not subscribed to a music streaming service +40% of those who don’t pay for a streaming Just 10% of respondents said exclusive access to +service said that it was because the service was too content by their favourite artists would persuade +expensive, the top option ‘a wider range of content’ them to pay for music streaming. This did however, +follows, by some margin, at 10%. rise to 25% amongst 15-19 year olds, a significant +over-index. +PAID MUSIC STREAMING DRIVERS +40% +Cheaper pricing options +45% +10% +A wider range of content +15% +Exclusive access to content +(Video, music etc.) from your 10% +favourite artists released only +25% +through the platform +A specialism in your favourite 9% +music genres +14% +- +A pay as you go service (99p 9% +for 24 hours of listening etc.) +12% +9% +Better audio quality +14% +44% +Don’t know / Not sure +33% +6% +Other (Please Specify) +3% +REACH 15-19 YEAR OLDS +What would convince you to pay for a subscription to a music streaming service? +Base: 2276 Respondents + +31 +Recommendations from friends 46% +YouTube 34% +Music/Interviews played on FM/AM Radio 32% +Live performances on TV 24% +Music videos on TV 20% +Music played in films/TV Shows/video games 18% +Music videos shared in Facebook 15% +Live performances on the Radio 15% +Music videos linked from YouTube (Through the sidebar, or recommended) 14% +Recommendations by another artist/celebrity you like (Inc. social media posts) 14% +Spotify’s browse, recommended or related artists 13% +Live performances at gigs/festivals 12% +Music/Interviews played on Internet Radio 11% +Spotify Playlists 10% +Radio adverts 8% +TV Talent shows (American Idol, Americas Got Talent) 8% +Magazine/Newspaper articles or interviews 8% +Billboards or Posters 7% +Online adverts 7% +Recommendation by experts (Journalists, Bloggers etc.) 6% +Spotify Discover Weekly 6% +SoundCloud 6% +iTunes Genius 5% +Music videos shared in Twitter 5% +TV Adverts 4% +Apple Music recommendations and playlists 4% +Newspaper/Magazine Adverts 4% +Tracks linked through SoundCloud (Autoplay, recommend sidebar) 3% +Other Internet recommendation service (Please specify) 2% +Other (Write in) 4% +None of the above 10% +:5 +NOITCES +yrevocsiD +cisuM +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +YOUTUBE OVERTAKES +RADIO AS A LEADING +MUSIC DISCOVERY +METHOD +Total Sample +YouTube leads online discovery, while personal +music through Spotify’s browse, recommended +recommendations still rule. 34% of respondents +or related page, whilst 10% discovered through +said that they discover new music via YouTube. +their playlists, far ahead of Apple Music’s +YouTube is second only after recommendations +recommendation and playlists (4%). +from friends (46%) and ahead of music/interviews +TV is still influential, with live performances in +played on FM/AM Radio (32%). 13% discovered +fourth at 24% and music videos in fifth with 20%. +MUSIC DISCOVERY METHODS +How do you typically discover music? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +33 +| YOUNGER LISTENERS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | PLAYLISTS | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| DISCOVER MUSIC | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | OVERTAKE | | | | | +| ONLINE AND THROUGH | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | ALBUMS | | | | | +FILM, TV & GAMES +Total Sample +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 42% of respondents said | | | | for market share and are creating deep and clever | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | +The leading two forms of discovery – 15-19 (29%) and 20-24 (24%). Music videos linked playlist ecosystems based on human expertise and +Playlists accounted for 31% +recommendations from friends and YouTube from YouTube show a similar but less pronounced data, for example Spotify with its editorial playlists +– skew young, whereas discovery via live pattern. of total listening, whilst and its Discover Weekly and Release Radar +performances on TV skews older, peaking at 65+. algorithm-driven playlists. +albums accounted for 22%. +Music/interviews played on FM/AM on the +Spotify’s browse, recommended or related artists influential in the middle ages, with peaks at 25-34 Meanwhile music services are vying for playlist +Single track listening still +features skew heavily young with peaks in the and 45-54. market share and launching their own brands in +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | leads the pack with 46%, | | | | order to secure powerful launch points point for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | +TOP MEANS OF DISCOVERY BY AGE +new releases and not depend on music services +but fell 6% YOY from 52% +to seed tracks in their own in-house playlists, for +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | in 2015. | | | | example UMG with its Digster or Hits brands; SME | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | +| | 56 55 | | | | 56 53 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +51 50 +| 46 | | | 44 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | with Filtr or WMG with Topsify. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | +| | | | 42 | | | 40 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | 34 | | | | | | 38 38 | 35 | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 32 | | | 31 | 32 | 32 | 29 | | 31 | | | | 31 | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 27 | | | | | | | | 28 | iTunes unbundled the album. Now playlists are | | | | | +23 24 24 23 25 22 The importance of playlists is further underlined by +20 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | 13 15 | | | further edging out the album format and eating | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a move to contextual listening, with users making +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | into single tracks’ share of listening, as shown by | | | | choices about what they want to listen to according | +| --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | +| | Recommendations | | | | YouTube | | | | Music/Interviews played | | | | Live performances on TV | | | | | | | | +the survey results. Playlists have been lauded as +from friends on FM/AM Radio to mood, time of day, or activity for example. In +the key new format for some time, and playlist +| | 28 | | | | 28 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | return many popular playlists focus on context, for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | +23 +2022 22 20 21 22 19 19 i n v e n to r y i s t h e n e w d i g i ta l s h o p f r o n t a n d p o int of +15 18 18 15 15 18 18 16 17 15 16 15 example Coffee Break listening or songs to work +| | | | 14 | | | | | | 13 | | 13 | | 14 | | 14 13 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | 9 | | | | 9 | | 10 | | | d i s co v e r | y f o r li s t e n e | r s o n s t r e a m | i n g s e r v ic e s. | | +out to, something that will continue to drive the +popularity of playlists as a format. +Music videos on TV Music played in films/TV Music videos shared Live performances There is an emergent tension between music +| | | | | | Shows/video games | | | | on Facebook | | | | on the radio | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +services who produce their own playlists and labels +| | | | | | 25 | | | | 29 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 25 21 | | | | | 25 | | | 24 | | | | | 22 | | | | | | | +18 19 19 v y in g f o r p l a y l is t m a r k e t s h a re o n m u s ic s e rv ic e s . +| 14 | | 14 | | 14 | | 14 | | 13 | | | | 12 | 13 | 16 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | 12 11 | | | | 8 | | | 11 | 10 | | 10 | | 9 8 | | | | | | +4 6 5 4 6 M u s ic s e r v i c e s s e e p l a y li s t s a s a k e y b a t t le g ro u n d +2 +| | Music videos linked | | | | Recommendations by | | | | Spotify’s browse, | | | | Live performances at | | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | from YouTube | | | | another artist/celebrity | | | | recommended or related | | | | gigs/festivals | | | | | | | | +artists +| | TOTAL | | 15-19 | 20-24 | | 25-34 | | 35-44 | 45-54 | | 55-64 | | 65+ | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +How do you typically discover music? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +35 +PLAYLISTS MOST PLAYLISTS +OVERTAKE LISTENED TO ARE +ALBUMS USER MADE +Total Sample All those who listen to playlists +Playlists are more popular than albums, and Generally the younger the respondent the less 42% of playlists listened to are not created by +single listening is down. Playlists accounted for they’d listen to albums, and the more they’d listen the listener. Of these, 27% are created by the +31% of total listening, whilst albums accounted for to playlists. platform they listen on, and 15% are created by +22%. Single track listening still lead the pack with someone else. +46%, but fell 6% YOY from 52% in 2015. +WHAT KIND OF PLAYLISTS DO YOU LISTEN TO? +SINGLES, ALBUMS OR PLAYLISTS? Total +| | | | | | 57% | 15% | 27% | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | 15-19 | 61% | 16% | 22% | +| Total | 46% | 22% | 31% | | | | | +| 15-19 | | | | 20-24 | 57% | 18% | 24% | +| | 54% | 18% | 28% | | | | | +| 20-24 | 46% | 18% | 35% | | | | | +| | | | | 25-34 | 51% | 19% | 30% | +25-34 +| | 43% | 21% | 35% | | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | 35-44 | 60% | 14% | 26% | +| 35-44 | 44% | 21% | 35% | | | | | +| | | | | 45-54 | 61% | 10% | 27% | +| 45-54 | 44% | 21% | 33% | | | | | +| | | | | 55-64 | 58% | 14% | 27% | +| 55-64 | 46% | 24% | 27% | | | | | +| 65+ | 48% | 27% | 21% | 65+ | 57% | 12% | 31% | +SINGLE TRACKS ALBUMS PLAYLISTS PLAYLISTS CREATED MYSELF PLAYLISTS CREATED BY SOMEONE ELSE +PLAYLISTS CREATED BY THE PLATFORM I LISTEN ON +How do you typically discover music? +How is your music listening split between the following?Base: 3014 Respondents Base: 3014 Respondents + +37 +30% +CD Albums +21% +19% +Tickets for music/concerts/gigs +17% +16% +MP3/Download albums that were paid for +19% +16% +MP3/Download albums that you got for free +25% +15% +MP3/Download singles that were paid for +15% +15% +Music gift cards (e.g. iTunes, Spotify, HMV Vouchers) +25% +14% +MP3/Download singles that you got for free +25% +10% +Music Merchandise items (e.g. t-shirts, posters etc.) +12% +7% +Tickets for festivals +10% +7% +Vinyl Albums +5% +3% +Vinyl Singles +4% +37% +None +26% +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +:6 +NOITCES +gnidnepS +cisuM +ycariP +dna +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +63% PURCHASED +A MUSIC RELATED +PRODUCT OVER +6 MONTHS +Total Sample +CDs still most common music product purchase, album downloads, music gift cards and MP3 single +at 30% of respondents, followed by live tickets downloads. +(19%) and MP3 downloads (16%). 15-19 year olds +63 % of respondents had purchased a music +under-index on CD albums and over-index on MP3 +related product over the past 6 months. +MUSIC SPENDING +Which of the following music products have you acquired for yourself or have been given as a present in the past 6 months? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 39 +54% WOULD AT LEAST 54% SAID THAT THE +CONSIDER PAYING COST OF HIGH-RES +FOR HI-RES AUDIO IS A DETERRENT +Total Sample Total Sample +Consumers on the fence about hi-res. 38% would service said they would definitely be prepared to Cost is the key barrier to hi-res adoption. 54% of 48% are happy with the quality of their existing +consider paying a premium for Hi-Res audio but pay a premium and 42% say they would consider respondents said that concern about cost has or music and a worrying 24% (rising to 28% amongst +only 16% would definitely pay a premium, paying a premium. might prevent them from purchasing hi-res files, 15-19 year olds) said that they doubt they would be +with this rising to 63% of 15-19 year-olds, the same able to tell the difference. +Hi-Res is an existing customer upsell opportunity. +age group that showed increased interest in hi-res +43% of those who are already paying for a +in separate questions. +premium/paid subscription to a music streaming +WILLINGNESS TO PAY A PREMIUM FOR MUSIC OF A SUPERIOR SOUND QUALITY BARRIERS TO HI-RES ADOPTION +54% +Concern as to the cost +63% +Total 16% 38% 26% 20% 48% +I am happy with the quality of my existing music +46% +15-19 13% 45% 25% 16% +24% +I doubt I would be able to tell the difference +28% +20-24 24% 36% 28% 11% +16% +The files would take up too much storage space +25-34 27% 38% 23% 12% 23% +11% +35-44 19% 36% 28% 17% My music system/devices would not do ‘Hi Res’audio justice +7% +45-54 13% 39% 25% 22% 11% +The files would take too long to download +14% +55-64 8% 36% 28% 27% +10% +None of the above +6% +65+ 6% 36% 27% 31% +1% +Other (Please state) +1% +I WOULD DEFINITELY BE PREPARED TO PAY A PREMIUM I WOULD CONSIDER PAYING A PREMIUM +I WOULD BE FAIRLY UNLIKELY TO PAY A PREMIUM I DEFINITELY WOULD NOT PAY A PREMIUM TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Base: 3014 Respondents What, if anything, has or might prevent you from purchasing ‘Hi-Definition / High Resolution’ audio files?Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +41 +24% DOWNLOADED +MUSIC VIA AN +ILLEGAL SOURCE +Total Sample +Stream Ripping leads the pirate ship. 15% of +respondents have used stream ripping sites or +software in the last six months, rising to 29% in +15-19 year olds. This is almost double the use of +BitTorrent (8%). +DOWNLOADING MUSIC FROM ILLEGAL SOURCES +| 8% | 7% | 15% | 2% | 76% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +From +| Via | | Via Stream Ripping | | None of | +| ---------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ----- | -------- | +| | Cyberlocker | | Other | | +| Bittorrent | | sites and software | | these | +Sites +| 7% | 10% | 29% | 1% | 59% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Over the past 6 months, have you download music from any of the following? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +43 +CONTENT +UPLOADING + detareneg-resU +Those who use each service +| Snapchat users are the most frequent uploaders | | | | | YouTube users are mostly passive watchers. Only | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| and least passive users of these platforms. 22% of | | | | | 6% of those who use YouTube frequently upload to | | | | | | +| those who use Snapchat said that they frequently | | | | | the site and 74% only ever view or listen to content | | | | | | +| upload to Snapchat. | | | | | that others have uploaded. | | | | | | +UPLOADING BEHAVIOUR +| | Snapchat | 35% | | | 43% | | | | 22% | | +| --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Instagram | | | 44% | | | 40% | | | | 16% | +| | Beatport | | 48% | | | 35% | | | | 18% | +| | Facebook | | 48% | | | 38% | | | | 14% | +Twitter +| | | | | 56% | | | 33% | | | 10% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tnetnoC +| | Tumblr | | | 57% | | | 33% | | | 11% | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | MySpace | | | 58% | | | 29% | | | 12% | +Pinterest +| | | | | 60% | | | 30% | | | 10% | +| ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Vine | | | 65% | | | | 27% | | 9% | +| Soundcloud | | | | 66% | | | | 25% | | 9% | +:7 NOITCES Google+ +| | | | | 66% | | | | 26% | | 9% | +| -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Vimeo | | | 68% | | | | 22% | | 10% | +| Bandcamp | | | | 72% | | | | 19% | | 9% | +| | YouTube | | | 74% | | | | 20% | | 6% | +I ONLY EVER VIEW OR LISTEN TO CONTENT THAT OTHERS HAVE UPLOADED +I MOSTLY VIEW OR LISTEN TO CONTENT THAT OTHERS HAVE UPLOADED BUT SOMETIMES UPLOAD CONTENT MYSELF +I FREQUENTLY UPLOAD CONTENT TO THIS SITE +Base: Those who used each service + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 45 +WHAT KIND OF MUSIC SHARED +CONTENT DO THE MOST OVER +YOU UPLOAD? FACEBOOK +All who upload content to the web Total Sample +Photos are still the most popular upload. 86% Facebook is the leading music sharing method. +of respondents upload photos while 47% upload 39% of respondents shared music via Facebook +videos and only 20% upload audio. SoundCloud but word of mouth is a strong second with 30% of +and Vinyl Listeners over-index on audio uploading, people saying they mentioned the artist / track / +with 40% and 41% respectively versus the 20% album to them offline and 21% saying they played it +mean. to them offline. WhatsApp is low down in the music +sharing pecking order at 5%. +CONTENT FORMAT UPLOADED MUSIC SHARING METHODS +Online via Facebook 39% +47% +Offline, I mention the artist / track / album to them 30% +Videos 53% +Offline, playing it on my phone/device/speakers to them 21% +41% +Online via email 14% +86% +Offline, by lending a CD/Vinyl to them 13% +Photos/Images 82% +88% Online via other instant messenger 10% +Online via Twitter 10% +20% +Audio tracks 25% Online via music streaming service (e.g. Spotify) 8% +15% Online via Skype 6% +Online via Whatsapp 5% +4% +Other (Please Specify) 4% Other 2% +4% None of the above 28% +TOTAL MALE FEMALE +What kind of content do you tend to upload on to the web? How do you usually share music you like with friends and/or others? +Base: 1736 Respondents Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +THANK YOU +For any questions about this +report please contact our +Music Industry Lead: +ROBERT@AUDIENCENET.CO.UK \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q236/random_k4/question.json b/q236/random_k4/question.json index cf66ede85033745852c1f98f4009e0f504485b43..5ae6ca2c474238069ef5691baf2cae2e5eb8b04a 100644 --- a/q236/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q236/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "NIKE_2021_10K.pdf", - "web_6019e7c0934ca3b6.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf", - "web_8617c40cc2c5d6aa.pdf", - "web_5b8076d084922575.pdf" + "resize_r2_14.pdf", + "web_fba1e08daa86a699.pdf", + "web_b3d0d86585f322a9.pdf", + "web_c0def62c1d919fa0.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q236/random_k4/random_1.md b/q236/random_k4/random_1.md index 1c064e3ff046ea90ec57fa6e9a2c7b22d1110cc1..3a49db96c4533f83fdc27ab1adb7310a8ce9a865 100644 --- a/q236/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q236/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1527 +1,2202 @@ -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary -Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) -Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) -1. Date of Submission: 8/17/2007 -2. Agency: Department of Justice -3. Bureau: Federal Bureau Of Investigation -4. Name of this Capital Asset: FBI Digital Collection -5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: (For IT 011-10-01-02-01-2503-00 -investment only, see section 53. For all other, use agency -ID system.) -6. What kind of investment will this be in FY2009? (Please Mixed Life Cycle -NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY2009, with -Planning/Acquisition activities prior to FY2009 should not -select O&M. These investments should indicate their current -status.) -7. What was the first budget year this investment was FY2001 or earlier -submitted to OMB? -8. Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this closes in part or -in whole an identified agency performance gap: -Since September 2001, the FBI's demands for critical, timely intelligence gathering have increased significantly. Pre- -September 2001 ELSUR intercepts (per year) have increased. Not only do demands for information continue to increase, -but also the requirement to facilitate information sharing does. The current collection enterprise consists of Foreign -Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) and Criminal Law Enforcement (CLE) systems. Today's telecommunications -capabilities afford terrorists and criminals many avenues to coordinate and commit offenses against U.S. citizens and -interests. Communications methods, such as voice over internet protocol (VoIP) and voice over packet (VoP), are -dramatically increasing in number and complexity, resulting in the continual and evolving need for advanced methods of -electronic surveillance of voice communications; methods of electronic surveillance have limited-life utility in intercepting -newer, more secure types of publicly offered communications. The expansion of electronic surveillance activity in -frequency, sophistication, and linguistic needs continues to increase the level of support, transportability, and -information sharing required. An important factor behind this expansion is the changing demographic of targets that -must be monitored by investigators. Further, the life span of today's technology is often much shorter than older -technologies, resulting in more frequent need for solution development. Collection equipment manufacturers continue -toward complying with technical standards as a result of the Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act -(CALEA). One result of the CALEA standard is more information is available for collection. -9. Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee Yes -approve this request? -a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval? 5/19/2007 -10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? Yes -11. Contact information of Project Manager? -Name -Phone Number -Email -a. What is the current FAC-P/PM certification level of the TBD -project/program manager? -12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost Yes -effective, energy-efficient and environmentally sustainable -techniques or practices for this project? -a. Will this investment include electronic assets Yes -(including computers)? -b. Is this investment for new construction or major No -retrofit of a Federal building or facility? (answer applicable -to non-IT assets only) -1. If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help -fund this investment? -Page 1 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable -design principles? -3. If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy -efficient than relevant code? -13. Does this investment directly support one of the PMA Yes -initiatives? -If "yes," check all that apply: Human Capital -Expanded E-Government -a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected Strategic Management of Human Capital. The FBI acquires -how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)? individuals with rare linguistic skills by collocating and -(e.g. If E-Gov is selected, is it an approved shared service networking the collection assets within proximity for -provider or the managing partner?) employment, training, and development. A work flow -management module is used by operations managers -monitor productivity and distribute work accordingly. -Expanded E-Gov -14. Does this investment support a program assessed using No -the Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more -information about the PART, visit -www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) -a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness -found during a PART review? -b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? -c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? -15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes -If the answer to Question 15 is "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is "No," do not answer questions -16-23. -For information technology investments only: -16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Level 1 -Guidance) -17. What project management qualifications does the (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this -Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) investment -18. Is this investment or any project(s) within this No -investment identified as "high risk" on the Q4 - FY 2007 -agency high risk report (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) -19. Is this a financial management system? No -a. If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA -compliance area? -1. If "yes," which compliance area: -2. If "no," what does it address? -b. If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent financial -systems inventory update required by Circular A-11 section 52 -20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2009 funding request for the following? (This should total 100%) -Hardware -Software -Services -Other -21. If this project produces information dissemination N/A -products for the public, are these products published to the -Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and -included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? -22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions: -Name -Phone Number -Title Acting FBI Privacy and Civil Liberties Officer -Page 2 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -E-mail -23. Are the records produced by this investment No -appropriately scheduled with the National Archives and -Records Administration's approval? -Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: -24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO Yes -High Risk Areas? -Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) -1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts represent -budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be included only in -the row designated "Government FTE Cost," and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full -Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." The "TOTAL" estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for -"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should -include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or restoration costs. The costs associated with the -entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this report. -Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES -(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) -(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) -P -e -Y -a --1 -rl i -a -e -n -r -d -PY 2007 CY 2008 BY 2009 BY+1 2010BY+2 2011BY+3 2012 -B -b -Y -e -+ -y -4 -o n -an -d -d -Total -Planning: 13.915 2 2.554 0 0 0 0 0 18.469 -Acquisition: 142.387 0 21.181 21.261 0 0 0 0 184.829 -Subtotal Planning & 156.302 2 23.735 21.261 0 0 0 0 203.298 -Acquisition: -Operations & Maintenance: 80.936 20.916 15.547 21.075 -TOTAL: 237.238 22.916 39.282 42.336 -Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. -Government FTE Costs 9.045 1.905 7.378 7.378 -Number of FTE represented 14 7 21 21 -by Costs: -Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner -agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. -2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional Yes -FTE's? -a. If "yes," How many and in what year? Ten FTEs were requested for this project in FY08 Exhibit -300 submission to perform requirements generation, -testing/evaluation, installation of new/upgraded equipment, -and user training as well as, system administration -expertise, telephonic/on-site technical support and system -maintenance support. The FTEs are included in the FY08 -President?s Budget; no additional personnel resources are -required upon approval of the request. -3. If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2008 President's budget request, briefly explain those changes: -The FY 2008 request for personnel enhancement of 14 personnel and non-personnel enhancement of $7,035,000 will -enhance the Digital Collection project's capacity to provide next generation systems, facilities, and capabilities to enable -continuance of audio and data collection in the furtherance of the FBI's FCI and Counterterrorism (CT) responsibilities. -The nonpersonnel enhancement will be used for new systems and equipment purchases ($3,850,000) and professional -and technical services ($3,185,000).. Without the requested resources, the number of funded contractor positions is -expected to increase. -Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) -1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned for this -investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders completed do -not need to be included. -Page 3 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) - -Contracts/Task Orders Table: - * Costs in millions -If N/A, has -the agency -| | | | What, if | | | determined | -| --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | -| | If so what | | any, | Does the | | the CO | -| | is the date | | alternative | contract | Contracting | assigned | -Has the Total Value Is this an -of the Start date Is it Competitiv financing Is EVM in include the CO Contact Officer has the -Contract or Type of contract award? If of End date of of Interagenc performanc ely option is the required information Certificatio competenci -Task Order Contract/ been Contract/ Contract/ y Name of CO -Number n o t , w h a t i s C o n t r a c t / e b a s e d ? aw ar d e d ? b e i n g co n t r ac t ? s e c u r i t y & (pho n e / em n L e v e l e s a n d -Task Order aw a r de d Task Order Tas k O r d er Ac q u is i ti o n -(Y / N ) t h e p la n n e d T a s k O r d e r ( $ M ) ? ( Y / N ) ( Y / N ) (Y / N ) u s e d ? ( Y / N ) p r i v a c y a il ) ( L e v e l s k il ls -a w a r d ( E S P C , c l a u s e s ? 1, 2 , 3 , N / A ) ne c e s s a r y -| | date? | | | (Y/N) | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | -| | | | UESC, EUL, | | | to support | -| | | | N/A) | | | this | -acquisition -? (Y/N) -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -FFP IDIQ Yes 9/28/2002 9/28/2002 9/27/2008 120 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - FFP Yes 4/1/2005 4/1/2005 8/2/2008 9.39 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP IDIQ Yes 9/15/2003 9/15/2003 9/15/2008 47 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 9/3/2003 9/3/2003 9/8/2008 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes - FFP Yes 10/1/2003 10/1/2003 9/30/2008 50 Yes No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -FFP Yes 10/7/2004 10/7/2004 10/5/2009 1.091 No No Yes NA No Yes Level 2 Yes -| | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | - -Page 4 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain -why: -Although EVM was not incorporated at the project's inception, a modified form of earned value management is being used -internally by the project team to monitor contractors' cost and schedule performance. Internal procedures are being used to -monitor FFP contracts using a straight-line calculation for services delivered and 100% earned value for product deliverables -received. Current contracts, being performed under the Digital Collection Project are Firm Fixed Price for Project Management -and Operations and Maintenance (O&M) of current systems; however, there are provisions within contract J-FBI-02-158 that -permit the time and material (T&M) and cost reimbursable (CR) efforts to be accomplished for research, development, and -unforeseen (O&M) requirements. It should also be noted that current and previous contracts did not include ANSI-compliant -EVMS because they did not meet the DOJ threshhold for ANSI-748 compliance. -For new developmental contracts the Digital Collection project will review, and include where appropriate, acquisition -requirements for ANSI-748 compliant EVM, as well as performance based contracting. -3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? Yes -a. Explain why: Contracts supporting this requirement ensure Section 508 -compliance in order to meet legal requirements as well as -satisfy needs of user personnel. -4. Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in Yes -accordance with agency requirements? -a. If "yes," what is the date? 2/9/2001 -b. If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed? -1. If "no," briefly explain why: -Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) -In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency and be linked -to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and strategic goals, and performance -measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the agency's strategic goals and objectives this -investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to -the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall -citizen participation rate of 75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if -applicable, investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general -goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure. -Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use the Federal -Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement Indicators to the corresponding -"Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There should be at least one Measurement Indicator -for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be -extended to include performance measures for years beyond FY 2009. -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year -Su -G -p -o -p -a -o -l( -r -s -te -) -d -Meas -A -u -r -r -e -e -a -m ent Me -C -a -a -s -t -u -e -r -g -e -o -m -ry -e nt Me -G -a -r -s -o -u -u -r -p -e -i -m -ng -e nt Me +Alibaba Cloud +Alibaba Cloud + +Object Storage Service + +Product Introduction + +Document Version: 20220707 + +Alibaba CloudAlibaba CloudObject Storage ServiceProduct IntroductionDocument Version: 20220707 Object St orage Service + +Legal disclaimer + +Product Int roduct ion··Legal disclaim +er + +Alibaba Cloud reminds you t o carefully read and fully underst and t he t erms and condit ions of t his legal +disclaimer before you read or use t his document . If you have read or used t his document , it shall be deemed +as your t ot al accept ance of t his legal disclaimer. + +1. You shall download and obt ain t his document from t he Alibaba Cloud websit e or ot her Alibaba Cloud- +aut horized channels, and use t his document for your own legal business act ivit ies only. The cont ent of +t his document is considered confident ial informat ion of Alibaba Cloud. You shall st rict ly abide by t he +confident ialit y obligat ions. No part of t his document shall be disclosed or provided t o any t hird part y for +use wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of Alibaba Cloud. + +2. No part of t his document shall be excerpt ed, t ranslat ed, reproduced, t ransmit t ed, or disseminat ed by + +any organizat ion, company or individual in any form or by any means wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud. + +3. The cont ent of t his document may be changed because of product version upgrade, adjust ment , or + +ot her reasons. Alibaba Cloud reserves t he right t o modify t he cont ent of t his document wit hout not ice +and an updat ed version of t his document will be released t hrough Alibaba Cloud-aut horized channels +from t ime t o t ime. You should pay at t ent ion t o t he version changes of t his document as t hey occur and +download and obt ain t he most up-t o-dat e version of t his document from Alibaba Cloud-aut horized +channels. + +4. This document serves only as a reference guide for your use of Alibaba Cloud product s and services. +Alibaba Cloud provides t his document based on t he "st at us quo", "being defect ive", and "exist ing +funct ions" of it s product s and services. Alibaba Cloud makes every effort t o provide relevant operat ional +guidance based on exist ing t echnologies. However, Alibaba Cloud hereby makes a clear st at ement t hat +it in no way guarant ees t he accuracy, int egrit y, applicabilit y, and reliabilit y of t he cont ent of t his +document , eit her explicit ly or implicit ly. Alibaba Cloud shall not t ake legal responsibilit y for any errors or +lost profit s incurred by any organizat ion, company, or individual arising from download, use, or t rust in +t his document . Alibaba Cloud shall not , under any circumst ances, t ake responsibilit y for any indirect , +consequent ial, punit ive, cont ingent , special, or punit ive damages, including lost profit s arising from t he +use or t rust in t his document (even if Alibaba Cloud has been not ified of t he possibilit y of such a loss). + +5. By law, all t he cont ent s in Alibaba Cloud document s, including but not limit ed t o pict ures, archit ect ure + +design, page layout , and t ext descript ion, are int ellect ual propert y of Alibaba Cloud and/or it s +affiliat es. This int ellect ual propert y includes, but is not limit ed t o, t rademark right s, pat ent right s, +copyright s, and t rade secret s. No part of t his document shall be used, modified, reproduced, publicly +t ransmit t ed, changed, disseminat ed, dist ribut ed, or published wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud and/or it s affiliat es. The names owned by Alibaba Cloud shall not be used, published, or +reproduced for market ing, advert ising, promot ion, or ot her purposes wit hout t he prior writ t en consent of +Alibaba Cloud. The names owned by Alibaba Cloud include, but are not limit ed t o, "Alibaba Cloud", +"Aliyun", "HiChina", and ot her brands of Alibaba Cloud and/or it s affiliat es, which appear separat ely or in +combinat ion, as well as t he auxiliary signs and pat t erns of t he preceding brands, or anyt hing similar t o +t he company names, t rade names, t rademarks, product or service names, domain names, pat t erns, +logos, marks, signs, or special descript ions t hat t hird part ies ident ify as Alibaba Cloud and/or it s +affiliat es. + +6. Please direct ly cont act Alibaba Cloud for any errors of t his document . + +> Document Version: 20220707 + I -a -n -s -d -u -ic -re -a -m -to -e -r -nt -Baseline Target Actual Results -2000 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2000 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 95% of Title Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 10% additional 30% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2001 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Terrorism and Business Results Operations Collection -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity -Terrorism and Activities Efficiency -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2001 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 65% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 10% additional 20% -Laws, and deployed in field life of Title III of Title III -Represent the offices systems systems -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2002 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -Page 5 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2002 | | | | | Productivity | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Productivity and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2002 Prevent Crime, Technology Effectiveness User Near end of life 45% of Title Deploy Deployed -Requirements -Enforce Federal Title III systems IIIsystems end additional 30% additional 40% -Laws, and deployed in field of life of Title III of Title III -| | | | | | | offices | | systems | systems | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2003 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2003 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -Promote the Title III and Title and digital input by 300% collection input -by 346% -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | | -| ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2003 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -Prevent Crime, User Near end of life 5% of Title III Deploy Deployed -Enforce Federal Requirements Title III systems systems end of additional 5% of additional 5% of -deployed in field life -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | Title III systems | Title III systems | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------------- | -| | Represent the | | | | | offices | | | | -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2004 Prevent Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Terrorism and supported for input for analog digital collection of digital -input by130% -Promote the Title III and Title and digital collection input -| | Nation¿s | | | | | 50 digital | collection (# | | by 135% | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -| | Security | | | | | collection | classified) | | | -| 2004 | | Technology | | | Data Storage | | | | | -| | Prevent | | | Information and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | Data | | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2004 Prevent Crime, Technology Information and Data Storage System Total storage Increase system Increased -Data -Enforce Federal information capacity storage capacity system storage -| | | | | | | storage capacity 4,200GB | | by 9% | | -| --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | -| | Laws, and | | | | | | | | capacity by 12% | -| | Represent the | | | | | for collected | | | | -evidence -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2005 -| | Prevent | Customer | | Service | Service | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Results | | Coverage | Efficiency | | | | | -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2005 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 30% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 60% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -2006 -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2006 Prevent Crime, Processes and Productivity and Productivity Lines of input Total lines of Increase lines of Increased lines -| | | Activities | | Efficiency | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Enforce Federal supported for input for digital digital collection of digital -Laws, and Title III digital collection (# input by 9% collection input -| | | | | | | collection | classified) | | by 8% | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -Represent the -Rights and -Interests of the -American People -| 2006 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | Processes and | | Security and | | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Activities | | Privacy | | | | | | -Promote the - -Page 6 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -| | | Results | | Responsiveness | | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | response and | to requests for | response to | | -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -2007 Prevent Mission and Intelligence Intelligence -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -2007 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2007 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Customer Timeliness and Response Time Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2008 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title III system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title 50 system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -2008 Prevent Processes and Security and Security DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | system | | certification and | | -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2008 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Response Time | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Customer Timeliness and Incident 100% response Maintain 100% -Terrorism and Results Responsiveness response and to requests for response to -| | Promote the | | | | | investigative | new quick | requests for new | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | capability | reaction | quick reaction | | -Security -| | | | | | | | collection | collection | | -| ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | capability | capability | | -| 2009 | | | | | | | | | | -| | Prevent | Mission and | | Intelligence | Intelligence | Improve speed | | | | - -Page 7 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Performance Information Table -Strategic -Fiscal Year Meas u r e m ent Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u r e m e nt Me a s u re m e nt Baseline Target -| | G o a l( s ) | | | | | | r | | Actual Results | -| --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | -| | Su p p o r te | d | A r e a | C a t e g o ry | G r o u | p i ng I n d | ic a to | | | -| | | Business Results Operations | | | Collection | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | of access and | | | | -| | Promote the | | | | | dissemination of | | | | -| | Nation¿s | | | | | information | | | | -| | Security | | | | | collected | | | | -through data -and -telecommunicati -ons intercepts -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and Title III system System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy certification and and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -Nation¿s -Security -2009 Prevent Processes and Security and Security Title 50 system System certified Maintain -| | | Activities | | Privacy | | | and accredited | | | -| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------ | --------------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | Terrorism and | | | | | certification and | | certification and | | -| | | | | | | accreditation | | accreditation | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | | | | Security | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Prevent Processes and Security and DCS-3000 System certified Maintain -Terrorism and Activities Privacy system and accredited certification and -| | Promote the | | | | | certification and | | accreditation | | -| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | -accreditation -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | Prevent | Technology | | Effectiveness | User | | | | | -| ----- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Requirements -Terrorism and -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| 2009 | | Technology | | Effectiveness | | | | | | -| ----- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Prevent | | | | User | | | | | -| | Terrorism and | | | | Requirements | | | | | -Promote the -Nation¿s -Security -| | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the system/application -level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and operational systems security -tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational Security Table must be included on -your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or -identifier). -For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, include the -investment in both the "Systems in Planning" table (Table 3) and the "Operational Systems" table (Table 4). Systems which are -already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization activity, should be included in both Table 3 and -Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date - -Page 8 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information -contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the -enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. -All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the "Name of System" -column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled "Name of System" in the security tables -(Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one-to-one ratio between the list of systems and -the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA -may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). -The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the system are -discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text explanation why a working link is -not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, -answer "yes" for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is -not yet required to be published. -Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: -1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified -and integrated into the overall costs of the investment: -a. If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the -budget year: -2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part -of the overall risk management effort for each system -supporting or part of this investment. -3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or Modernization - Security Table(s): -Date of Planned C&A update (for -Name of System -Agency/ or C -S -o -y -n -st -t -e -ra -m -c -? -to r Operated -Planned Operational Date -e -o -x -r -i s -P -t -l -i -a -n -n -g -n -m -ed -ix -C -e -o -d -m -li -p -fe -le -c -t -y -io -c -n -le -D -s -a -y -t -s -e -t e -( -m -fo -s -r -) -new systems) -DCS-5000 (Next Gen) Government Only -4. Operational Systems - Security Table: -What standards -were used for -Agency/ or NIST FIPS 199 Has C&A been the Security Date -Date the -Name of System -C -O -S -o -p -y -n -e -s -t -t -r -r -e -a -a -m -c -te -t -? -o -d -r R -(H -is -i -k -g h + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Document con +vent ions + +Document conventions + +St yle +St yle + +Descript io n +Descript io n + +Example +Example + +Danger + Danger + +W arning + W arning + +No t ice + No t ice + + No t eNo t e + +> + +Bo ldBo ld + +A danger notice indicates a situation that +will cause major system changes, faults, +physical injuries, and other adverse +results. + +Danger: + Danger: + +Resetting will result in the loss of user +configuration data. + +A warning notice indicates a situation +that may cause major system changes, +faults, physical injuries, and other adverse +results. + +W arning: + W arning: + +Restarting will cause business +interruption. About 10 minutes are +required to restart an instance. + +A caution notice indicates warning +information, supplementary instructions, +and other content that the user must +understand. + +No t ice: + No t ice: + +If the weight is set to 0, the server no +longer receives new requests. + +A note indicates supplemental +instructions, best practices, tips, and +other content. + +No t e: + No t e: + +You can use Ctrl + A to select all files. + +Closing angle brackets are used to +indicate a multi-level menu cascade. + +Set t ings > Net w o rk + +Set net w o rk +Net w o rk> Set net w o rk + +Click Set t ings +t ype . +t ype + +Bold formatting is used for buttons , +menus, page names, and other UI +elements. + +Click OKOK. + +Courier font + +Courier font is used for commands + +Run the cd /d C:/window command to +enter the Windows system folder. + +Italic + +[] or [a|b] + +{} or {a|b} + +Italic formatting is used for parameters +and variables. + +bae log list --instanceid + +Instance_ID + +T his format is used for an optional value, +where only one item can be selected. + +ipconfig [-all|-t] + +T his format is used for a required value, +where only one item can be selected. + +switch {active|stand} + +> Document Version: 20220707 + I -, -m -L -M -o -p -w -o -a -d -c -) -t -e r -le -a -v -te -e -, -l Co -N -m -IS -p -T -l -( -e -Y -8 -t -/ -e -0 -N -d -0 -, -) -- -u -3 -s + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Table of Cont +ent s + +Table of Contents + +1.What is OSS? + +2.Features + +3.Benefits + +4.Scenarios + +5.FAQ + +6.Terms + +7.Limits + +05 + +09 + +15 + +18 + +20 + +25 + +30 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +I + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +1.What is OSS? +1.What is OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud Object St orage Service (OSS) is a secure, cost -effect ive, and highly reliable cloud st orage +service t hat allows you t o st ore a large amount of dat a. OSS is designed t o provide 99.9999999999% +(t welve 9's) dat a durabilit y and 99.995% dat a availabilit y. OSS provides mult iple st orage classes t o help +you manage and reduce st orage cost s. + +OSS support s REST ful API operat ions t hat are independent of t he OSS console. You can st ore and +access dat a from all applicat ions anyt ime and anywhere. + +You can call API operat ions and use SDKs or OSS migrat ion t ools provided by Alibaba Cloud t o t ransfer +large amount s of dat a t o and from Alibaba Cloud OSS. You can use OSS bucket s of t he St andard +st orage class t o st ore image, audio, and video object s for apps and websit es. You can use OSS bucket s +of t he Infrequent Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive st orage class t o st ore infrequent ly accessed +object s at a low cost and wit h longer st orage period. + +Get started with O SS +Get started with O SS + +Video t ut orial + +T he following video quickly guides you t hrough OSS. + +FAQ + +For frequent ly asked quest ions about OSS, see FAQ. + +Learning pat h + +OSS Learning Pat h helps you get st art ed wit h OSS. You can learn basic OSS operat ions, and t hen +perform secondary development by using a variet y of API operat ions, SDKs, and convenient t ools. + +Terms +Terms + +st orage class + +T he st orage class of a bucket or an object . OSS provides t he following st orage classes t o cover a +variet y of dat a st orage scenarios from hot dat a t o cold dat a: St andard, IA, Archive, and Cold Archive. +T he St andard st orage class provides high-durabilit y, high-availabilit y, and high-performance object +st orage services t hat can support frequent dat a access. T he IA st orage class is suit able for st oring +dat a t hat is accessed once or t wice a mont h. In addit ion, t he unit price of IA st orage is lower t han +t hat of St andard st orage. T he Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring archive dat a for at least six +mont hs. T he Cold Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring cold dat a over a long period of t ime. +For more informat ion about st orage classes, see Overview. + +bucket + +A cont ainer used t o st ore object s in OSS. All object s are cont ained in bucket s. You can configure a +variet y of bucket at t ribut es such as t he region, access cont rol list (ACL), and st orage class. You can +creat e bucket s of different st orage classes t o st ore your dat a. + +object + +T he basic unit used t o st ore dat a in OSS. Object s are also known as files. An object consist s of object +met adat a, object dat a, and an object key. T he key of an object uniquely ident ifies t he object in a +bucket . Object met adat a consist s of key-value pairs t hat describe object at t ribut es, such as t he last +modified t ime and t he size of t he object . You can also specify t he user met adat a of an object . + +region + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +5 + + Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +Object St orage Service + +T he physical locat ion of an OSS dat a cent er. You can select a region t o creat e a bucket based on t he +cost and locat ion of t he request s t o t he bucket . For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +endpoint + +T he domain name t hat is used t o access OSS. OSS uses REST ful API operat ions t o provide services. +Different regions are accessed by using different endpoint s. Access over t he int ernal net work or over +t he Int ernet wit hin t he same region also uses different endpoint s. For more informat ion, see Regions +and endpoints. + +AccessKey pair + +T he access credent ial t hat is used t o aut hent icat e a request er. An AccessKey pair consist s of an +AccessKey ID and an AccessKey secret . OSS uses symmet ric encrypt ion based on AccessKey pairs t o +verify t he ident it y of a request er. T he AccessKey ID is used t o ident ify a user. T he AccessKey secret is +used t o encrypt and verify signat ure st rings. T he AccessKey secret must be kept confident ial. For +more informat ion about how t o obt ain an AccessKey pair, see Obtain an AccessKey pair. + +Common operations +Common operations + +Creat e bucket s + +Before you can upload object s t o OSS, you must creat e a bucket . You can configure various +at t ribut es such as t he region, ACL, and ot her met adat a for a bucket . For more informat ion about how +t o creat e a bucket , see Create buckets. + +Upload object s + +Aft er you creat e a bucket , you can upload object s of different sizes t o t he bucket . For more +informat ion about how t o upload object s, see Upload objects. + +Download object s + +Aft er you upload object s t o a bucket , you can download t he object s t o t he default download pat h +of your browser or t he specified local pat h. For more informat ion about how t o download object s, +see Download objects. + +List object s + +You can list all object s in a bucket . If a large number of object s are st ored in a bucket , you can also +list some of t he object s in t he bucket . For more informat ion about how t o list object s, see List objects. + +Delet e object s + +You can manually delet e one or more object s t hat you no longer need. You can also configure +lifecycle rules t o allow OSS t o aut omat ically delet e a single object or mult iple object s. For more +informat ion about how t o delet e object s, see Delete objects. + +Features +Features + +Versioning + +OSS allows you t o configure versioning for a bucket t o prot ect object s t hat are st ored in t he bucket . +Aft er you enable versioning for a bucket , dat a t hat is overwrit t en or delet ed in t he bucket is saved as +a previous version. You can use versioning t o recover a previous version of an object t hat is +accident ally overwrit t en or delet ed. For more informat ion about versioning, see Overview. + +Bucket Policy + +6 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +T he owner of a bucket can configure bucket policies t o grant users different permissions t o access +t he specified OSS resources in t he bucket . For example, you can configure bucket policies t o +aut horize ot her Alibaba Cloud account s or anonymous users t o access or manage all or some +resources in your bucket . You can also configure bucket policies t o grant full permissions such as +read-only, read/writ e, or full permissions t o different RAM users of t he same Alibaba Cloud account . +T his way, different RAM users have different permissions t o access or manage resources in your +bucket . For more informat ion about how t o configure bucket policies, see Configure bucket policies to +authorize other users to access OSS resources. + +CRR + +Cross-region replicat ion (CRR) provides aut omat ic and asynchronous (near real-t ime) replicat ion of +object s across bucket s in different OSS regions. Operat ions such as creat ing, overwrit ing, and +delet ing object s can be synchronized from a source bucket t o a dest inat ion bucket . CRR can meet +your requirement s for cross-region disast er recovery and dat a replicat ion. For more informat ion about +CRR, see CRR. + +Dat a encrypt ion + +Server-side encrypt ion: When you upload an object t o a bucket for which server-side encrypt ion is +enabled, OSS encrypt s t he object and st ores t he encrypt ed object . When you download t he +encrypt ed object from OSS, OSS aut omat ically decrypt s t he object and ret urns t he decrypt ed object . +A header is added in t he response t o indicat e t hat t he object is encrypt ed on t he OSS server. For +more informat ion about server-side encrypt ion, see Server-side encryption. + +Client -side encrypt ion: Before you upload an object t o a bucket , t he object is encrypt ed on t he local +client . For more informat ion about client -side encrypt ion, see Client-side encryption. + +Manage O SS +Manage O SS + +You can use a variet y of met hods t o upload object s, download object s, and manage OSS. + +Manage OSS by using t he OSS console + +OSS provides a web-based console. You can log on t o t he OSS console t o manage your OSS +resources. For more informat ion, see Use Alibaba Cloud accounts to log on to the OSS console. + +Manage OSS by using API operat ions or SDKs + +OSS provides REST ful API operat ions and SDKs for mult iple programming languages t o facilit at e +secondary development . For more informat ion, see List of operations by function and Overview. + +Manage OSS by using t ools + +OSS provides mult iple management t ools, such as ossbrowser, ossut il, and ossft p. For more +informat ion, see OSS tools. + +Manage OSS by using CSG + +OSS uses a flat st ruct ure inst ead of a hierarchical st ruct ure t o st ore object s. All element s are st ored +as object s in bucket s. T o use OSS in t he same manner in which local file syst ems are used, you can +configure Cloud St orage Gat eway (CSG). For more informat ion, visit t he CSG product page. + +Pricing +Pricing + +> Document Version: 20220707 + 7 -i -? -n g Date C -C -o -& -m -A -p leted: -( -C -F + + Product Int roduct ion··What is OSS? + +Object St orage Service + +T radit ional st orage service providers require you t o purchase a reserved amount of st orage capacit y +and net work t raffic before you use resources. If your st orage capacit y or t raffic usage exceeds t he +reserved amount , your service is deact ivat ed or you are charged excess fees. At t he same t ime, if your +st orage capacit y or t raffic usage does not exceed t he reserved amount , you are charged for t he full +amount of t he st orage and t raffic. + +OSS charges you only for t he st orage capacit y and t raffic t hat you consume. T herefore, you do not +need t o purchase st orage capacit y and t raffic before you use resources. You can t ake t he cost +advant ages of t he flexible infrast ruct ure provided by Alibaba Cloud t o grow your business. + +For more informat ion about OSS pricing, go t o t he Pricing t ab of t he OSS product page. For more +informat ion about OSS billing met hods, see Overview. + +Related services +Related services + +Aft er you upload your dat a t o OSS, you can use ot her Alibaba Cloud feat ures and services t o manage +your dat a. + +T he following feat ures and services are frequent ly used wit h OSS: + +Image Processing (IMG): a service t hat allows you t o perform a variet y of operat ions such as format +convert ing, resizing, cropping, rot at ing, and adding wat ermarks t o images st ored in OSS. For more +informat ion, see IMG implement at ion modes. + +Elast ic Comput e Service (ECS): a cloud comput ing service t hat provides elast ic and efficient +comput ing capabilit y. For more informat ion, visit t he ECS product page. + +Alibaba Cloud CDN: a dist ribut ed net work t hat caches resources from an origin server t o edge nodes +in different regions t o accelerat e cont ent delivery. For more informat ion, visit t he CDN product page. + +E-MapReduce (EMR): a big dat a processing solut ion built on ECS. EMR is developed based on open +source Apache Hadoop and Apache Spark t o facilit at e dat a analysis and processing. For more +informat ion, visit t he E-MapReduce product page. + +ApsaraVideo Media Processing: a service t hat convert s audio or video object s st ored in OSS int o files +t hat are suit able for playback on PCs, T Vs, and mobile devices. Deep learning result s from large +amount s of dat a help ApsaraVideo Media Processing perform mult imodal analysis on t he audio, t ext , +and images in video files and t he cont ent of audio files. ApsaraVideo for Media Processing uses t he +analysis result s t o int elligent ly audit , underst and, and edit t he cont ent of t he audio or video files. For +more informat ion, visit t he ApsaraVideo Media Processing product page. + +Dat a Online Migrat ion: a service t hat allows you t o migrat e dat a from a t hird-part y st orage service +such as Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Google Cloud t o OSS wit h ease. For more informat ion, see +Dat a Online Migrat ion document at ion. + +Dat a T ransport : a service t hat helps you migrat e large amount s of dat a from local st orage t o OSS. +For example, you can use Dat a T ransport t o migrat e t erabyt es or pet abyt es of local dat a t o OSS +when t he local net work bandwidt h is insufficient and expansion cost s are high. For more informat ion, +see What is Dat a T ransport ? + +Alibaba Cloud storage services +Alibaba Cloud storage services + +In addit ion t o OSS, Alibaba Cloud also provides a variet y of st orage services such as file st orage and +block st orage for different scenarios. For more informat ion about Alibaba Cloud st orage services, see +Overview. + +For more informat ion about use cases and solut ions of Alibaba Cloud st orage services, visit t he Alibaba +Cloud St orage. + 8 -o -I -0 -P -n -0 -S -tr -- 5 -o -2 -l -3 -0 -s -, -0 -t -N -/ -e -N -I -s -S -t -I -s -T -S -? -T Se -C -c -o -u -m -T -r -e -i -p -t -s -l -y -e -t i -C -t -n -e -o -g -( -n -d -t -) -r -: -o l -contin -te -g -s -e -t -n -e -c -d -y plan -800-26, Other, -N/A) -DCS-3000 Government Only Yes 6/1/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-5000 Government Only Yes 6/3/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -DCS-6000 Government Only Yes 2/2/2006 FIPS 200 / NIST 5/21/2007 2/7/2007 -800-53 -5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of -the systems part of or supporting this investment been -identified by the agency or IG? -a. If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into -the agency's plan of action and milestone process? -6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is -requested to remediate IT security weaknesses? -a. If "yes," specify the amount, provide a general description of the weakness, and explain how the funding request will -remediate the weakness. -7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System -(b -sy -) -s -I -t -s -e m -th -? -is -( -a -Y / -n -N -e -) -w -Assessment (PIA) -(d) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t i -L -o -i -n -n k or Rec -r -o -e -r -q -d -u -s -i -N -re -o -d -t i -f -c -o -e -r -( -t -S -h -O -is -R N) (f) I -E -n -x -t -p -e -l -r -a -n -n -e -a -t -t -L -io -in -n -k or -w -s -h -y -i -s -c -t -h -e -c -m -o -? -v e -(Y -rs -/ N -th -) -i s -system? (Y/N) -DCS-3000 No No No PIA is required by the Yes www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva -E-Government Act at this cyact.html -time for this system -Page 9 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -8. Planning & Operational Systems - Privacy Table: -(c) Is there at least -(e) Is a System of -one Privacy Impact -(a) Name of System (b ) I s th is a n e w Assessment (PIA) (d) I n t e r n e t L i n k or Rec o r d s N o t i c e ( S O R N) (f) I n t e r n e t L in k or -sy s t e m ? ( Y / N ) E x p l a n a t i o n r e q u i re d f o r t h is E x p l a n a t io n -| | | | w h i c h c | o v e rs th i s | | | system? (Y/N) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | - -| | | | s y s t e m | ? (Y / N ) | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| DCS-5000 | No | | Yes | | | | Yes | | | -| | | | | | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -cyact.html -| DCS-6000 | No | | No | | | | Yes | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------- | --- | -| | | | | No PIA is required by the | | | | www.usdoj.gov/jmd/priva | | -| | | | | E-Government Act at this | | | | cyact.html | | -time for this system. -Details for Text Options: -Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to (c), provide an explanation -why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. - -Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal register. If no to (e), provide -an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn't a current and up to date SORN. - -Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be considered as a blank field. - -Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) -In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be included in the -agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and supporting the FEA. The business -case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and -technology layers of the agency's EA. -| 1. Is this investment included in your agency's target | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enterprise architecture? - a. If "no," please explain why? - -| 2. Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition | | | | Yes | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Strategy? - a. If "yes," provide the investment name as identified in Digital Collection Program -the Transition Strategy provided in the agency's most recent -annual EA Assessment. - b. If "no," please explain why? - -| 3. Is this investment identified in a completed (contains a | | | | No | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -target architecture) and approved segment architecture? - a. If "yes," provide the name of the segment architecture as -provided in the agency's most recent annual EA Assessment. - -4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table: -Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, customer relationship management, -etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. -| | | | | | | Service | Service | | | -| ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -| Agency | Agency | FEA SRM | | | | | | Internal or | | -Com p on e nt Co m p o n e n t Se r v ic e FEA SRM FEA SRM Component Component E x t e r n a l BY Funding - Service Type Component (a) Reuse d N ame Reus e d UPI ) Percentage (d) -| Na m e | D e sc ri p t io | n D o m a i n | | | | | | R e u s e ? (c | | -| ------ | ---------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | ( b ) | ( b ) | | | -No Reuse -Legacy Collaborative Back Office Development Legacy -| Integration | Analysis | Services | and Integration | Integration | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| Ad Hoc | Case Analysis | | Reporting | Ad Hoc | | | | No Reuse | | -| | | Business | | | | | | | | -Analytical -Services -Information Interagency Digital Asset Knowledge Information No Reuse -| Sharing | | Services | Management | Sharing | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Information -Sharing -Knowledge Intelligence and Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge No Reuse -| Capture | | Services | Management | Capture | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Evidence -Collection -No Reuse -Knowledge Intra-agency Digital Asset Knowledge Knowledge -| Distribution and | Information | Services | Management | Distribution and | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------ | --------- | ----------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Delivery | Sharing | | | Delivery | | | | | | -Query Information Support Services Search Query No Reuse -Analysis - - a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already identified as a service -component in the FEA SRM. - b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather than answer -yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify the other investment using the -Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission. - -Page 10 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service component -provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one agency within a department reusing a service -component provided by another agency in another department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being -reused by multiple organizations across the federal government. -d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed in the table. If -external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another agency to pay for the service. The -percentages in the column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Data Management Database Connectivity Sybase -Delivery -Ad Hoc Component Framework Data Management Reporting and Analysis Word Perfect 6.0 -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Content Rendering Hyper Text Markup Language -Delivery (HTML) -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Active Server Pages -Delivery .NetServer Pages .NetMicrosoft -Active Server Pages .Net -Knowledge Distribution and Component Framework Presentation / Interface Dynamic Server-Side Display Microsoft Sun Active Server -Delivery Pages -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Microsoft Server 2003 -Information Sharing Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Other Electronic Channels Uniform Resource Locator -(URL) -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Microsoft Internet Explorer6.0 -Legacy Integration Service Access and Delivery Access Channels Web Browser Netscape Navigator -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Requirements Legislative / Compliance Section 508 -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Hyper Text Transfer Protocol -Delivery (HTTP) -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Internet Protocol (IP) -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Service Transport Transport Control Protocol -Delivery -Knowledge Distribution and Service Access and Delivery Service Transport Supporting Network Services Simple Network Management -Delivery Protocol (SNMP) -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: ISQL/w -Integration -Query Service Interface and Integration Middleware Database Access: PL/SQL -Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Interface and Integration Middleware Remote Procedure Call (RPC) -Delivery Integration -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Oracle 10i -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Database Sybase -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Database / Storage Storage HP Series Enterprise Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Application Servers 2600 Dell Servers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Apache -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Delivery Servers Web Servers Internet Information Server -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Hard Disk -Infrastructure Drives -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Hewlett-Packard Redundant -Infrastructure Array of Independent Disks -(RAID) -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Intel Microprocessors -Infrastructure -Knowledge Capture Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Embedded Technology Devices Random Access Memory (RAM) -Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Ethernet -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Local Area Network (LAN) Virtual LAN (VLAN) -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 2900 Series Switches -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco 3700 Series Routers -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards Cisco Gateway -Delivery Infrastructure -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ICTG T1 Card -Page 11 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: -To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and -Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. -Service Specification (b) -FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area FEA TRM Service Category FEA TRM Service Standard (i.e., vendor and product -name) -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hardware / Infrastructure Network Devices / Standards ISDN -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Network Interface Card (NIC) | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Network Devices / Standards | Transceivers | -| Knowledge Distribution and | Service Platform and | | | | -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | | -| | | Hardware / Infrastructure | Peripherals | | -Knowledge Distribution and Service Platform and Hewlett-Packard 4500 Series -| Delivery | Infrastructure | | | Printers | -| --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | - - a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter multiple rows for -FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications - b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard or vendor -product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as appropriate. -No -6. Will the application leverage existing components and/or -applications across the Government (i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, -etc)? - a. If "yes," please describe. - -Page 12 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -Exhibit 300: Part II: Planning, Acquisition and Performance Information -Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) -Part II should be completed only for investments identified as "Planning" or "Full Acquisition," or "Mixed Life-Cycle" investments -in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. -In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to the current -baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments to -determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. -1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this project? Yes -a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed? 1/27/2006 -b. If "no," what is the anticipated date this analysis will be -completed? -c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: -2. Alternative Analysis Results: * Costs in millions -Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: -Alternative Analyzed Description of Alternative -Risk Adjus -e -te -st -d -i m -Li -a -fe -te -c ycle Costs Risk Adjuste -e -d -s t -L -im -ife -a -c -t -y -e -c le Benefits -1- Volumetric Collection 245.015 9.443 -3. Which alternative was selected by the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? -Alternative 1 - Volumetric Collection. -4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? -The primary benefits of a regionalized architectural approach for the next generation of DCS-5000 would be to: 1) reduce -overhead costs by utilizing "economies of scale" practices,. -5. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part Yes -or in-whole? -a. If "yes," are the migration costs associated with the This Investment -migration to the selected alternative included in this -investment, the legacy investment, or in a separate migration -investment. -b. If "yes," please provide the following information: -List of Legacy Investment or Systems -Name of the Legacy Investment of Systems UPI if available Date of the System Retirement -DCS-5000 -Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) -You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this investment's life-cycle, -developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing -risk throughout the investment's life-cycle. -1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes -a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan? 4/16/2007 -b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly Yes -changed since last year's submission to OMB? -c. If "yes," describe any significant changes: -A preliminary internal project rating and risk assessment of the DCS-5000 NG acquisition effort was conducted and a DCS-5000 -NG Project baseline for risk was established. The Risk Management Plan (RMP) defined basic organizational, technical, and policy -guidelines for the implementation of risk management within the DCS-5000 Next Generation Project. It established the -techniques and procedures that will be utilized throughout the evolutionary life of the various DCS-5000 Next Generation Project -systems. The procedures described will help ensure the positive identification and management of risk areas associated with -acquisition, development, deployment, and support of the systems. The risk management policies and procedures set forth in -this RMP apply to all DCS-5000 Next Generation Project systems. The policies and procedures of this RMP are tailored for -Page 13 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -specific subsystems and contracts. The DCS-5000 Next Generation Project risk management system used by the DCS-5000 Next -Generation Risk Management Board follows the recommended policies and procedures and use the Glossary of terms set forth -by the Project Management Institute (PMI). These policies and procedures include: Risk management Planning, Risk -Identification, Qualitative Risk Analysis, Quantitative Risk Analysis, Risk Response Planning, and Risk Monitoring and Control. -2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? -a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date? -b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks? -3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle cost estimate and investment schedule: -Risks for the investment are identified within 3 categories: technical, acquisition, and financial. Each risk is evaluated as to its -probability of occurrence and level of impact on schedule, cost, and technical performance to determine the overall risk rating. -Given that, with very limited deviation, effort performed for digital collection implementation is completed by contracted support -through firm fixed price contracts, there is limited risk associated with technical, cost and schedule performance. Baselines -established are provided to contract vendors as contract requirements/deliverables; however, in order to mitigate the risk of -unforeseen requirements and increased scope, a management reserve of 10% is maintained. Cost performance risk is mitigated -through maximum usage of firm fixed price contracts and task orders. Budget projections are reviewed at least quarterly. -Independent government cost estimates are developed, analyzed, and compared to contractor proposals for each major -acquisition. Out-of-tolerance variances are brought to the contractors? attention and cost/price is negotiated. -Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) -EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should still be included -in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should accurately reflect the milestones -in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. -1. Does the earned value management system meet the No -criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard-748? -2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than +/- 10%? (CV%= CV/EV x No -100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) -a. If "yes," was it the CV or SV or both? -b. If "yes," explain the causes of the variance: -c. If "yes," describe the corrective actions: -3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? No -a. If "yes," when was it approved by the agency head? -Page 14 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | - 1 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $8.85 9/30/2004 $8.85 $8.85 $0 100% -(Planning) Prior -to FY05 - 2 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $128.14 9/30/2004 $128.14 $126.53 $1.61 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -(Acquisition) -Prior to FY05 - 3 Digital Collection 9/30/2004 $31.75 9/30/2004 $31.75 $31.75 $0 100% -(O&M) Prior to -FY05 - 4 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2005 $3.27 9/30/2005 $3.27 $3.12 $0.15 100% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - 5 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2005 $16.65 9/30/2005 $16.65 $17.33 $-0.68 100% - 6 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2005 $10.32 9/30/2005 $10.32 $11.31 $-0.99 100% - 7 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2006 $3.27 9/30/2006 $3.27 $3.13 $0.14 100% - 8 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2006 $15.7 9/30/2006 $15.7 $15.68 $0.02 100% - 9 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2006 $9.2 9/30/2006 $9.2 $9.2 $0 100% - 10 DCS-3000 O&M 9/30/2007 $3.31 9/30/2007 $3.31 $4.42 $-1.11 100% - 11 DCS-5000 9/30/2007 $2 9/30/2007 $2 $2 $0 100% -Planning - 12 DCS-5000 O&M 9/30/2007 $7.64 9/30/2007 $7.64 $7.97 $-0.33 100% - 13 DCS-6000 O&M 9/30/2007 $9.97 9/30/2007 $9.97 $8.12 $1.85 100% -| 14 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $2.96 | | | $2.96 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 15 | DCS-5000 | 9/30/2008 | $2.55 | | | $2.55 | | | | 0% | -Planning -| 16 | | 9/30/2008 | $20.18 | | | $21.18 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition -| 17 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $8.02 | | | $8.02 | | | | 0% | -| ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 18 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2008 | $9.79 | | | $9.79 | | | | 0% | -| 19 | DCS-3000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $2.11 | | | $2.11 | | | | 0% | -| 20 | | 9/30/2009 | $21.26 | | | $21.26 | | | | 0% | -| | DCS-5000 | | | | | | | | | | -Acquisition - -Page 15 of 16 - -Exhibit 300: FBI Digital Collection (Revision 2) -4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline - -Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all -milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and actual completion dates (e.g., "03/23/2003"/ "04/28/2004") and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the event -that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the 'Description of Milestone' and 'Percent Complete' fields are required. -Indicate '0' for any milestone no longer active. -Initial Baseline Current Baseline Current Baseline Variance -M il e st o n e De sc r ip t io n of P l a n n e d Tot a l C o st C o m p le t io n D a t e P e rc e n t -| | | | | | | Total Cost ($M) | | Schedule | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -N u m b e r M il e st o n e Com p l e ti o n D ate ( $ M ) ( m m / d d / y y y y ) Cost ($M) C o m p le t e -(# days) -| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Estimated | Planned | Actual | Planned | Actual | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 21 | DCS-5000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $9.7 | | | $9.7 | | | | 0% | -| 22 | DCS-6000 O&M | 9/30/2009 | $14.48 | | | $14.48 | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0% -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| | | | | | | | | | | 0% | -| Project Totals | | | | | | | | | | | - -Page 16 of 16 \ No newline at end of file + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +2.Features +2.Features + +Object St orage Service (OSS) provides secure, cost -effect ive, and high-durabilit y services for you t o +st ore large amount s of dat a in t he cloud. T his t opic describes t he common scenarios and corresponding +feat ures of OSS. You can select t he best solut ion based on your business requirement s. + +Before you use OSS, we recommend t hat you have a good underst anding of t he basic t erms used in +OSS, including bucket s, object s, regions, and endpoint s. For more informat ion, see T erms. + +T he following t able describes t he feat ures provided by OSS. + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Upload objects + +Search for objects + +Download objects + +Share objects + +Query objects + +Before you upload objects to OSS, you must +create a bucket in an Alibaba Cloud region to +store uploaded objects. After you create a +bucket, you can upload objects to the bucket. + +Create buckets + +Create directories + +Simple upload + +OSS allows you to search for objects and +directories to find the object that you want to +access in a bucket. + +Search for objects + +After you upload objects to a bucket, you can +download the objects to the default +download path of your browser or a specified +local path. + +Download objects + +After you upload an object to a bucket, you +can share the object URL with third parties for +downloads or previews. + +Share objects + +OSS provides the data indexing feature to +allow you to index the metadata of objects. +You can specify the metadata of objects as +index conditions to query objects. T his way, +you can efficiently manage and learn about +data structures, perform queries, collect +statistics, and manage objects. + +Data indexing + +Delete objects or +directories + +OSS allows you to delete one or more objects, +directories, and parts at a time. You can delete +expired objects at regular intervals to save +storage space. + +Delete objects + +Delete directories + +Manage parts + +Automatically delete +multiple objects at a +specified period of time + +OSS supports lifecycle rules. You can configure +lifecycle rules to periodically convert the +storage class of non-hot data to Infrequent +Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive. You can +also configure lifecycle rules to delete expired +data. + +Overview + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +9 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Accelerate the upload and +download of data + +Recover the data that is +accidentally deleted + +Zone-disaster recovery + +Geo-disaster recovery + +OSS supports transfer acceleration. T ransfer +acceleration uses optimal route selection and +protocol stack tuning to reduce timeouts in +remote transmission and improve user +experience. + +OSS supports versioning. After you enable +versioning for a bucket, OSS saves the +overwritten and deleted objects as previous +versions in the bucket. You can configure +versioning to recover an object to a previous +version when the object is accidentally +overwritten or deleted. + +You can store data in and migrate the data +across three zones in the same region by using +zone-redundant storage (ZRS). If one zone +becomes unavailable, you can continue to +access the data that is stored in the other two +zones. T his feature is designed to provide +99.9999999999% (twelve 9's) data durability +and 99.995% service availability. + +OSS supports cross-region replication (CRR). +You can use CRR to synchronize operations +such as creation, update, and deletion of data +from the source bucket to the destination +bucket in a different region. T his way, you can +implement geo-disaster recovery. + +T ransfer acceleration + +Overview + +ZRS + +CRR + +Retention policy + +OSS supports the Write Once Read Many +(WORM) feature. T he feature helps prevent +objects from being deleted or overwritten +within a specified period of time. + +合规保留策略 + +10 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Control access to data + +OSS supports flexible authorization and +authentication mechanisms. You can control +access to your OSS resources by using the +following methods: + +ACL: You can set access control lists (ACLs) +for buckets and objects, including public +read/write, public read, and private. + +Bucket policy: You can configure bucket +policies to authorize other users to access +your OSS resources in the OSS console. For +example, you can authorize RAM users of +other Alibaba Cloud accounts and +anonymous users from specific IP addresses +to access your OSS resources. + +RAM policy: You can create RAM policies to +control access to buckets and directories. +OSS provides RAM Policy Editor to generate +required RAM policies. For more information, +see RAM Policy Editor. + +ST S temporary authorization: You can use +Alibaba Cloud Security T oken Service (ST S) +to grant a third-party application or a RAM +user temporary access credentials with a +custom validity period. + +Hotlink protection: You can configure a +Referer whitelist to prevent unauthorized +users from accessing your OSS resources. + +Bucket ACL + +Configure ACL for +objects + +Bucket Policy + +RAM Policy + +Use a temporary +credential provided by +ST S to access OSS + +Hotlink protection + +Encrypt data + +OSS supports client-side and server-side +encryption. You can select an encryption +method to encrypt and store your data in OSS. + +Client-side encryption + +Server-side encryption + +OSS DDoS protection + +OSS DDoS protection is a proxy-based attack +mitigation service that integrates OSS with +Anti-DDoS Pro and Anti-DDoS Premium. When a +bucket with OSS DDoS protection enabled +becomes a victim of DDoS attacks, OSS DDoS +protection diverts incoming traffic to an Anti- +DDoS Pro or Anti-DDoS Premium instance for +scrubbing and then redirects normal traffic to +the bucket. T his ensures the continuity of your +business in the event of DDoS attacks. + +OSS DDoS protection + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +11 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Integrate with data lake + +Manage data by category + +OSS-HDFS (JindoFS service) is a cloud native +data lake storage service. OSS-HDFS is built on +unified metadata management capabilities and +is fully compatible with Hadoop Distributed File +System (HDFS) API operations. T he Portable +Operating System Interface (POSIX) is +supported in OSS-HDFS. T his helps OSS-HDFS +handle data lake computing scenarios in the +big data and AI fields. + +OSS allows you to configure tagging to +manage data based on the data category: + +Configure bucket tags: You can manage +data based on bucket tags. For example, +you can list buckets that have specified tags +and configure the ACLs of buckets that have +specified tags. + +Configure object tags: You can manage +data based on object tags. For example, you +can configure lifecycle rules and ACLs for +objects that have specified tags. + +Overview of the OSS-HDFS +service + +Configure bucket +tagging + +Object tagging + +Record the access +information for OSS +resources + +OSS supports logging. You can configure +logging to collect access statistics, audit +access to OSS, track exceptions, and +troubleshoot problems. + +Use custom domain names +to access OSS resources + +OSS allows you to map custom domain names +to OSS buckets and use the custom domain +names to access data in the buckets. If you +want to use your custom domain name to +access OSS over HT T PS, you can host your +Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) certificate in OSS. + +Real-time log query + +Logging + +Map custom domain +names + +Host SSL certificates + +Static website hosting + +OSS supports static website hosting. You can +configure static website hosting for your +bucket and access static websites by using the +bucket domain name. + +Overview + +CORS + +OSS supports cross-origin resource sharing +(CORS) in HT ML5. CORS allows web application +clients that are loaded in one domain name to +interact with resources in another domain. + +Configure CORS + +12 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Scenario + +Feature + +References + +Obtain data from the +origin + +Query object metadata + +Modify HT T P headers + +View the details of +resource usage + +T raffic throttling + +Analyze and process data + +OSS supports back-to-origin configurations. If +your user accesses data in a bucket that has no +back-to-origin rules configured and the data +does not exist, 404 Not Found is returned. +However, if you configure back-to-origin rules +that contain the correct origin URLs, users can +obtain the data from the origin based on the +back-to-origin rules. You can configure back- +to-origin rules for hot data migration and +specific request redirection. + +OSS supports the inventory feature. You can +configure inventories for buckets to export the +metadata of specified objects, including the +object sizes and encryption status. + +OSS allows you to modify the HT T P headers of +objects. You can configure HT T P headers to +specify custom HT T P request policies, such as +the cache policy and forced object download +policy. + +Overview + +Bucket inventory + +Configure object +metadata + +OSS supports the monitoring feature. You can +use the monitoring feature to view real-time +information about OSS service usage, such as +the running status and performance of the +system. + +Overview + +OSS supports single-connection bandwidth +throttling. You can configure single-connection +bandwidth throttling for upload, download, +and copy operations on OSS objects to ensure +sufficient bandwidth for your other +applications. + +OSS provides Image Processing (IMG) and video +snapshot capturing for you to analyze and +process data stored in OSS: + +IMG: You can perform operations on images +stored in OSS, such as format conversion, +cropping, scaling, rotating, and +watermarking. You can also encapsulate +multiple operations into a style to process +images stored in OSS. + +Video snapshot capturing: You can capture +images from video objects in the H.264 +format. + +Single-connection +bandwidth throttling + +Overview + +Video snapshots + +Use tools to manage OSS +resources + +OSS provides graphical, command-line, file +mounting, and FT P tools for you to manage +your OSS resources. + +OSS tools + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +13 + + Product Int roduct ion··Feat ures + +Object St orage Service + +Scenario + +Feature + +Use OSS SDKs to manage +OSS resources + +OSS provides SDKs for a variety of +programming languages to facilitate custom +development. + +References + +Overview + +14 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +3.Benefits +3.Benefits + +Object St orage Service (OSS) is a secure, cost -effect ive, and high-durabilit y service t hat enables you t o +st ore large amount s of dat a in Alibaba Cloud. T his t opic compares OSS wit h t he t radit ional self- +managed server st orage t o help you bet t er underst and t he benefit s of OSS. + +Advantages of O SS over self-managed server storage +Advantages of O SS over self-managed server storage + +Item + +OSS + +Self-managed server storage + +Durability + +Security + +OSS is the core infrastructure of data +storage for Alibaba Group. T his reliable +and highly available service is one of the +backbone services that ensure stability +during the peak hours of Double 11. OSS +comes with a multi-redundant +architecture to provide reliable data +storage. In addition, OSS is built on a +high-availability architecture to eliminate +single points of failure (SPOFs) and +ensure the continuity of your services. + +Provides service availability of at least +99.995%. + +Provides data durability of at least +99.9999999999% (twelve 9's). + +Automatically expands capacities +without affecting your services. + +Offers automatic data redundancy. + +Provides multi-level security +protection for enterprises, including +features such as server-side +encryption, client-side encryption, +hotlink protection, bucket policies that +specify IP address blacklists or +whitelists, fine-grained access control, +log audit, and the Write Once Read +Many (WORM) strategy. + +Provides resource isolation +mechanisms for multiple tenants and +supports geo-disaster recovery. + +Complies with the regulations of +multiple organizations including the +U.S. Securities and Exchange +Commission (SEC) and Financial +Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc. +(FINRA), which delivers services that +can meet the requirements of your +enterprise for data security and +compliance. + +Prone to errors due to hardware +failures. If a disk has a bad sector, +data may be lost. + +Requires manual restoration of data, +which can be a complex, time- +consuming, and labor-intensive +process. + +Requires additional scrubbing devices +and blackhole policy-related services. + +Requires a separate security +mechanism. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +15 + + Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +OSS + +Self-managed server storage + +Requires manual expansion of storage +space due to limited capacity of hard +disks. + +Offers limited bandwidth due to slow +single-line or double-line access. +Requires the manual expansion during +peak hours. + +Requires dedicated O&M personnel, +which results in high costs. + +Requires separate purchase and +deployment of data processing +capabilities. + +Cost + +Intelligent storage + +Allows you to use multi-line Border +Gateway Protocol (BGP) to connect to +operator backbone network lines with +sufficient bandwidth resources. +Upstream traffic is free of charge. + +Requires no hosting fees or the need +to hire O&M personnel. + +Provides multiple data processing +capabilities, such as Image Processing +(IMG), video snapshot, document +preview, image scenario recognition, +facial recognition, and SQL in-place +query. OSS can be seamlessly integrated +with the Hadoop ecosystem and Alibaba +Cloud services such as Function +Compute, E-MapReduce (EMR), Data Lake +Analytics (DLA), BatchCompute, +MaxCompute, and Database Backup +(DBS) to manage and analyze data of +enterprises. + +Additional benefits of O SS +Additional benefits of O SS + +Ease of use + +OSS provides st andard REST ful API operat ions, a wide range of SDKs, client t ools, and t he OSS +console. You can upload, download, ret rieve, and manage large amount s of dat a used for +websit es and mobile apps in t he same way you use regular file syst ems. + +T he capacit y of each bucket is unlimit ed. T herefore, you can expand your bucket s in OSS based on +your requirement s. + +OSS support s st reaming writ es and reads. It is suit able for business scenarios t hat require +simult aneous writ e and read of large files such as videos. + +OSS support s lifecycle management . You can configure lifecycle rules t o bat ch delet e expired +object s or convert t he st orage classes of expired object s t o cost -effect ive Infrequent Access (IA), +Archive, or Cold Archive. + +Powerful and flexible securit y mechanisms + +OSS provides Securit y T oken Service (ST S) and URL aut hent icat ion and aut horizat ion. OSS also +support s IP address blacklist s or whit elist s, hot link prot ect ion, and Resource Access Management +(RAM). + +OSS provides resource isolat ion mechanisms for users. You can also use t he mult i-clust er +synchronizat ion service. + +OSS provides server-side encrypt ion, client -side encrypt ion, and encrypt ed t ransmission based on +Secure Socket s Layer (SSL) or T ransport Layer Securit y (T LS) t o prot ect dat a from pot ent ial securit y +risks on t he cloud. + +16 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Benefit s + +OSS provides t he versioning feat ure t o prevent object s from being accident ally delet ed or +overwrit t en. + +Dat a redundancy mechanism + +OSS uses a dat a redundant st orage mechanism t o st ore copies of each object in mult iple devices of +different facilit ies in t he same region. T his way, OSS ensures dat a durabilit y and availabilit y even if +hardware failures occur. + +Operat ions performed on object s in OSS are st rongly consist ent . For example, aft er you upload or +copy an object , t he uploaded or copied object can be immediat ely read and copies of t he object +are writ t en t o mult iple devices for redundancy. + +T o ensure t hat dat a is complet ely t ransmit t ed, OSS calculat es t he checksum of t he net work t raffic +packet s t o check for errors when packet s are t ransmit t ed bet ween t he client and t he server. + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism of OSS can prevent dat a loss even when t wo st orage facilit ies +are damaged at t he same t ime. + +Aft er dat a is st ored in OSS, OSS regularly checks whet her copies of t he dat a are lost . T hen, OSS +recovers lost copies t o ensure dat a durabilit y and dat a availabilit y. + +OSS periodically verifies t he int egrit y of dat a t o det ect dat a corrupt ion caused by errors such as +hardware failures. If dat a is part ially corrupt ed or lost , OSS uses t he ot her copies t o reconst ruct +and repair t he corrupt ed dat a. + +Rich and powerful value-added services + +IMG: support s format conversion, t humbnails, cropping, wat ermarking, and resizing for object s in +format s such as JPG, PNG, BMP, GIF, WebP, and T IFF. + +Audio or video t ranscoding: provides high-qualit y, high-speed, and parallel audio or video +t ranscoding capabilit ies. T his way, your audio or video files can be played on different t erminal +devices. + +T ransfer accelerat ion over t he Int ernet : provides t he t ransfer accelerat ion service, which uses +opt imal rout e select ion and prot ocol st ack t uning t o reduce t imeout s in remot e t ransmission and +improve user experience. For more informat ion, see T ransfer accelerat ion. + +Accelerat ed cont ent delivery: uses OSS as t he origin and works wit h Cont ent Delivery Net work +(CDN) t o improve user experience when t he same object is repeat edly downloaded. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +17 + + Product Int roduct ion··Scenarios + +Object St orage Service + +4.Scenarios +4.Scenarios + +T his t opic describes t he applicat ion scenarios of OSS. + +Massive storage for image, audio, and video applications +Massive storage for image, audio, and video applications + +OSS can be used t o st ore large amount s of dat a, such as images, audio and video, and logs. You can +use a variet y of devices, websit es, and mobile applicat ions t o read dat a from or writ e dat a t o OSS. You +can writ e dat a t o OSS by uploading files or using st reams. + +Dynamic and static content separation for websites and mobile +Dynamic and static content separation for websites and mobile +applications +applications + +By using t he high bandwidt h provided by OSS, you can concurrent ly download a large amount of dat a +from OSS over t he Int ernet . OSS provides T ransfer acceleration t hat accelerat es uploads and downloads +across count ries and cont inent s and improves user experience. You can also use OSS wit h Cont ent +Delivery Net work (CDN) t o deliver st at ic dat a st ored in OSS t o CDN edge nodes. Users can access t he +dat a cached on CDN edge nodes inst ead of t he same dat a st ored in OSS. T his way, t he concurrent and +repeat ed download of an object wit hin t he same region can be accelerat ed. + +Cloud data processing +Cloud data processing + +18 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Scenarios + +Aft er you upload object s t o OSS, you can use ApsaraVideo for Media Processing and Image Processing +(IMG) t o process t he uploaded dat a. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +19 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +5.FAQ +5.FAQ + +T his t opic provides answers t o frequent ly asked quest ions about Object St orage Service (OSS). + +General FAQ +General FAQ + +What is Alibaba Cloud OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud OSS is a secure, cost -effect ive, and scalable st orage service t hat has high durabilit y +and is capable of processing large amount s of dat a. OSS is designed for dat a durabilit y of at least +99.9999999999% (t welve 9's) and provides service availabilit y of at least 99.995%. + +What are t he feat ures of OSS? + +OSS support s REST ful API operat ions t hat are independent of t he OSS console. You can st ore and +access dat a from all applicat ions anyt ime and anywhere. OSS is highly scalable. You are charged only +for t he resources t hat you use. You can scale OSS resources based on your requirement s wit hout +compromising performance or durabilit y. + +You can call API operat ions and use SDKs or OSS migrat ion t ools provided by Alibaba Cloud t o +t ransfer large amount s of dat a t o and from Alibaba Cloud OSS. You can use OSS bucket s of t he +St andard st orage class t o st ore image, audio, and video object s for apps and websit es. You can use +OSS bucket s of t he Infrequent Access (IA), Archive, or Cold Archive st orage class t o st ore infrequent ly +accessed object s at a low cost and wit h longer st orage period. + +For more informat ion about t he feat ures of OSS, see Features. + +Who are t he int ended users of OSS? + +OSS is an ideal solut ion for users who need t o st ore large amount s of dat a. T hese users include app +and soft ware developers, game development ent erprises, and webmast ers of online communit ies, +media-sharing sit es, and e-commerce websit es. + +What dat a does OSS st ore? + +OSS is suit able for st oring at t achment s, high-definit ion images, audio and video object s, and backup +object s for forums, websit es, and soft ware applicat ions, as well as object s for a variet y of +applicat ions, file synchronizat ion soft ware, and online st orage syst ems. + +What are t he advant ages of OSS over local st orage solut ions? + +OSS allows developers t o make full use of t he economy of scale of Alibaba Cloud at minimal cost +wit hout addit ional invest ment s or affect ing performance. Developers can focus on t heir own +innovat ions wit hout performance bot t lenecks and securit y risks t hat come wit h increasing business +scales. OSS is cost -effect ive and easy t o use. + +What is t he upper limit of t he dat a volume t hat OSS can support ? + +OSS does not impose limit s on t he t ot al st orage capacit y and t he capacit y of a bucket . You can use +t he OSS console t o upload an object up t o 5 GB in size. T o upload an object larger t han 5 GB in size, +use mult ipart upload, resumable upload, ossbrowser, or ossut il. For more informat ion, see Multipart +upload, Quick start, and Overview. + +What st orage classes does OSS provide? + +20 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +T he st orage class of a bucket or an object . OSS provides t he following st orage classes t o cover a +variet y of dat a st orage scenarios from hot dat a t o cold dat a: St andard, IA, Archive, and Cold Archive. +T he St andard st orage class provides high-durabilit y, high-availabilit y, and high-performance object +st orage services t hat can support frequent dat a access. T he IA st orage class is suit able for st oring +dat a t hat is accessed once or t wice a mont h. In addit ion, t he unit price of IA st orage is lower t han +t hat of St andard st orage. T he Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring archive dat a for at least six +mont hs. T he Cold Archive st orage class is suit able for st oring cold dat a over a long period of t ime. +For more informat ion about st orage classes, see Overview. + +Will Alibaba Cloud use t he dat a t hat I st ore in OSS? + +Alibaba Cloud does not use or release your dat a wit hout aut horizat ion. Alibaba Cloud processes user +dat a only based on your service requirement s or requirement s of laws and regulat ions. For more +informat ion, see Service t erms. + +Does Alibaba Cloud use OSS t o st ore t heir own dat a? + +Yes, Alibaba Cloud developers also use OSS t o st ore aut horized dat a for many project s. T hese +project s rely on OSS t o perform key business operat ions. + +How does OSS ensure availabilit y when my OSS service experiences burst s of t raffic from +applicat ions? + +OSS is designed t o address burst s of t raffic from Int ernet applicat ions. Pay-as-you-go is used as a +billing met hod. T o ensure service cont inuit y during burst s of t raffic, OSS does not impose capacit y +limit s. OSS ensures load balancing so t hat applicat ions are not affect ed by burst s of t raffic. + +How is OSS dat a organized? + +OSS is a dist ribut ed object st orage service t hat st ores dat a as key-value pairs. When you st ore an +object , you must specify an object name (key). T he key can t hen be used t o obt ain t he cont ent of +t he object . + +Keys can also be used t o simulat e cert ain feat ures of direct ories. OSS uses a flat st ruct ure for object s +inst ead of a hierarchical st ruct ure. All element s are st ored as object s in bucket s. However, OSS +support s direct ories as a concept t o group object s and simplify management . When you use APIs or +SDKs t o configure an object , you can specify t he key value, a full name t hat includes a prefix for t he +object t o manage ot her object s. For example, if you set t he key of an object t o dir/example.jpg , +a direct ory named dir is creat ed in t he current bucket and an object named example.jpg is +creat ed in t he direct ory. If you delet e t he dir/example.jpg object , t he dir direct ory is also +delet ed. + +How do I get st art ed wit h OSS? + +Before you use OSS, ensure t hat you have creat ed an Alibaba Cloud account and complet ed real- +name verificat ion. If you do not have an Alibaba Cloud account , t he syst em prompt s you t o creat e an +Alibaba Cloud account when you act ivat e OSS. For more informat ion, see Creat e Your Alibaba Cloud +Account . Aft er you creat e t he Alibaba Cloud account , visit t he Object St orage Service product +homepage. Click Act ivat e Now +go. T o furt her minimize OSS cost s, we recommend t hat you purchase resource plans. For more +informat ion, see Buy OSS resource plans (subscript ion). + +Act ivat e Now. By default , t he billing met hod aft er you act ivat e OSS is Pay-as-you- + +You can get st art ed wit h OSS by using t he OSS console, graphical management t ool, command-line +management t ool, and SDKs for various programming languages. For more informat ion, see Get +started with OSS. + +FAQ about Alibaba Cloud regions +FAQ about Alibaba Cloud regions + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +21 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +What is an Alibaba Cloud region? + +An Alibaba Cloud region is a geographical region t hat cont ains mult iple geographically isolat ed +zones. T hese zones are connect ed t o each ot her by using net works t hat feat ure short lat ency, high +t hroughput , and high redundancy. + +What is a zone? + +Each region cont ains several isolat ed locat ions known as zones. T he power supply and net work of +each zone are independent . T he net work lat ency bet ween inst ances wit hin t he same zone is short er. +Zones wit hin t he same region can access each ot her. However, fault s t hat occur in one zone do not +affect ot her zones. + +How do I det ermine which region t o st ore my dat a? + +When you select a region, we recommend t hat you consider fact ors such as physical locat ions, +relat ionships bet ween cloud services, and resource prices For more informat ion, see Choose an OSS +region. + +FAQ about billing +FAQ about billing + +How does OSS charge fees? + +OSS provides t he pay-as-you-go billing met hod t hat allows you t o pay for resources you use. No +minimum usage fees are imposed. You can also purchase resource plans. Resource plans are used t o +deduct fees incurred by resource usage. In most cases, resource plans are more cost -effect ive. For +more informat ion about prices, visit t he OSS pricing page. + +How does OSS charge fees when ot her account s are used t o access my OSS resource? + +When ot her account s access your OSS resources, OSS charges you based on st andard pricing. You can +enable t he pay-by-request er mode for your bucket so t hat request ers pay t he fees generat ed by +sending request s and downloading OSS dat a. For more informat ion, see Enable pay-by-requester. + +FAQ about data security and protection +FAQ about data security and protection + +Is dat a st ored in OSS secure? + +OSS is secure. By default , only t he resource owner can access resources wit hin a bucket . OSS provides +user ident it y verificat ion t o cont rol access t o dat a. You can use various access cont rol policies on t he +bucket or object level, such as access cont rol list s (ACLs), t o grant specific permissions t o specific +users and user groups. T he OSS console displays bucket s t hat are available t o public access. You can +set t he bucket ACL t o privat e if you do not want ot her users t o access your bucket or object . If you +set t he bucket ACL t o public read or public read/writ e, a message t hat indicat es securit y risks +appears. For more informat ion about t he securit y of OSS, see Overview. + +How do I cont rol access t o my OSS dat a? + +OSS provides mult iple access cont rol met hods, including ACLs, RAM policies, and bucket policies, for +access t o object s st ored in bucket s. For more informat ion, see Overview. + +What dat a encrypt ion met hods does OSS provide? + +Server-side encrypt ion: When you upload an object t o a bucket for which server-side encrypt ion is +enabled, OSS encrypt s t he object and st ores t he encrypt ed object . When you download t he +encrypt ed object from OSS, OSS aut omat ically decrypt s t he object and ret urns t he decrypt ed object . +A header is added in t he response t o indicat e t hat t he object is encrypt ed on t he OSS server. For +more informat ion about server-side encrypt ion, see Server-side encryption. + +22 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Client -side encrypt ion: Before you upload an object t o a bucket , t he object is encrypt ed on t he local +client . For more informat ion about client -side encrypt ion, see Client-side encryption. + +How do I prevent dat a st ored in bucket s from being accident ally delet ed or overwrit t en? + +OSS allows you t o configure versioning for a bucket t o prot ect object s t hat are st ored in t he bucket . +Aft er you enable versioning for a bucket , dat a t hat is overwrit t en or delet ed in t he bucket is saved as +a previous version. You can use versioning t o recover a previous version of an object t hat is +accident ally overwrit t en or delet ed. For more informat ion about versioning, see Overview. + +What is a ret ent ion policy? + +OSS support s t he Writ e Once Read Many (WORM) st rat egy t hat prevent s an object from being +delet ed or overwrit t en for a specified period of t ime. You can configure t ime-based ret ent ion +policies for bucket s. Aft er a ret ent ion policy is configured and locked for a bucket , you can read +object s from or upload object s t o t he bucket . However, object s in t he bucket or t he ret ent ion policy +cannot be delet ed wit hin t he ret ent ion period of t he ret ent ion policy. You can delet e t he object s +only aft er t he ret ent ion period expires. + +You can configure ret ent ion policies when you need t o st ore infrequent ly accessed import ant dat a +t hat is not allowed t o be modified or delet ed. Such dat a includes medical records, t echnical +document s, and cont ract s. You can st ore t hese object s in a specified bucket and configure a +ret ent ion policy for t he bucket . + +FAQ about data replication +FAQ about data replication + +How do I replicat e dat a from a bucket t o anot her bucket in a different region? + +You can configure mult iple cross-region replicat ion (CRR) rules for a bucket t o st ore mult iple copies of +t he dat a in different regions. CRR provides aut omat ic and asynchronous (near real-t ime) replicat ion +of object s across bucket s in different OSS regions. Operat ions such as creat ing, overwrit ing, and +delet ing object s can be synchronized from a source bucket t o a dest inat ion bucket . + +What are t he advant ages of CRR? + +Compliance requirement s: Alt hough OSS st ores mult iple replicas of each object in physical disks, +replicas must be st ored at a dist ance from each ot her t o comply wit h regulat ions. CRR allows you +t o replicat e dat a bet ween geographically dist ant OSS dat a cent ers t o sat isfy t hese compliance +requirement s. + +Minimum lat ency: You have users who are locat ed in t wo geographical locat ions. T o minimize t he +lat ency when t he users access object s, you can maint ain replicas of object s in OSS dat a cent ers +t hat are geographically closer t o t hese users. + +Dat a backup and disast er recovery: You have high requirement s for dat a securit y and availabilit y, +and want t o explicit ly maint ain replicas of all writ t en dat a in a second dat a cent er. If one OSS dat a +cent er is damaged in a cat ast rophic event such as an eart hquake or a t sunami, you can use backup +dat a from t he ot her dat a cent er. + +Dat a replicat ion: For business reasons, you may need t o migrat e dat a from one OSS dat a cent er t o +anot her dat a cent er. + +Operat ional reasons: You have comput e clust ers deployed in t wo different dat a cent ers t hat need +t o analyze t he same group of object s. You can choose t o maint ain object replicas in t hese regions. + +How does OSS charge fees when I use CRR? + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +23 + + Product Int roduct ion··FAQ + +Object St orage Service + +Aft er CRR is enabled, cross-region t raffic is generat ed when you replicat e object s across bucket s in +t he source and dest inat ion regions. You are charged for t he t raffic t hat is generat ed when you use +CRR. Each t ime an object is synchronized, OSS calculat es t he number of request s and charges t he +request s on a pay-as-you-go basis. T he t raffic t hat is generat ed when you use CRR can be charged +only on a pay-as-you-go basis. Resource plans are unavailable for CRR. + +FAQ about data query +FAQ about data query + +How do I query dat a in OSS? + +OSS support s t he Select Object operat ion t hat allows you t o use SQL st at ement s t o query specific dat a +in a CSV or JSON object inst ead of querying t he ent ire object . T he Select Object operat ion simplifies t he +process used t o query dat a and filt er t he dat a int o smaller and more specific dat a set s. T herefore, t his +operat ion is suit able for t he mult ipart query of large object s, query of JSON object s, and analysis of log +object s. For more informat ion about dat a query, see Call the SelectObject operation to query objects. + +FAQ about storage management +FAQ about storage management + +What is OSS lifecycle management ? How do I use lifecycle management t o minimize OSS st orage +cost s? + +You can configure a lifecycle rule t o regularly delet e object s t hat are no longer accessed or convert +t he st orage class of cold dat a t o IA, Archive, or Cold Archive. T his makes dat a management easier +and saves st orage cost s. For example, you can configure lifecycle rules in t he following scenarios: + +A medical inst it ut ion st ores it s medical records in OSS. T hese object s are occasionally accessed +wit hin six mont hs aft er t hey are uploaded, and almost never aft er t hat . In t his case, you can +configure a lifecycle rule t o convert t he st orage class of t hese object s t o Archive 180 days aft er +t hey are uploaded. + +A company st ores t he call records of it s service hot line in OSS. T hese object s are frequent ly +accessed wit hin t he first t wo mont hs, occasionally aft er t wo mont hs, and almost never aft er six +mont hs. Aft er t wo years, t hese object s no longer need t o be st ored. In t his case, you can configure +a lifecycle rule t o convert t he st orage class of t hese object s t o IA 60 days aft er t hey are uploaded +and t o Archive 180 days aft er t hey are uploaded, and delet e t hem 730 days aft er t hey are +uploaded. + +You can manually delet e up t o 1,000 object s each t ime. If a bucket cont ains more t han 1,000 +object s, you must delet e t he object s mult iple t imes. In t his case, you can configure a lifecycle rule +t hat is used t o delet e all object s in t he bucket t he next day. T his way, all object s in t he bucket can +be delet ed t he next day. + +For more informat ion about lifecycle management , see Lifecycle rules based on the last modified time. + +How do I regularly obt ain t he informat ion about object s st ored in a bucket ? + +You can use t he bucket invent ory feat ure t o export t he informat ion about specific object s in a +bucket on a daily or weekly basis. Export ed object informat ion includes t he number, sizes, st orage +classes, and encrypt ion st at us of t he object s. For more informat ion about t he bucket invent ory +feat ure, see Bucket inventory. + +24 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +6.Terms +6.Terms + +T his t opic describes several basic t erms used in Object St orage Service (OSS). + +bucket +bucket + +T he cont ainer for OSS object s. Each object in OSS is cont ained in a bucket . You can configure various +at t ribut es of a bucket , including t he region, access cont rol list (ACL), and st orage class. You can creat e +bucket s of different st orage classes t o st ore dat a based on your requirement s. + +OSS does not use a hierarchical st ruct ure for object s, but inst ead uses a flat st ruct ure. Each object +belongs t o a bucket . + +You can creat e mult iple bucket s. + +A bucket name must be unique in OSS wit hin an Alibaba Cloud account . Bucket names cannot be +changed aft er t he bucket s are creat ed. + +A bucket can cont ain an infinit e number of object s. + +OSS support s t he following bucket naming convent ions: + +T he name can cont ain only lowercase let t ers, digit s, and hyphens (-). + +T he name must st art and end wit h a lowercase let t er or a digit . + +T he name must be 3 t o 63 charact ers in lengt h. + +object +object + +T he basic unit for dat a operat ions in OSS. Object s are also known as files. OSS does not use a +hierarchical st ruct ure for object s, but inst ead uses a flat st ruct ure. All element s are st ored as object s in +bucket s. However, OSS support s direct ories as a concept t o group object s and simplify management . +An object is composed of object met adat a, user dat a, and a key. A key is used t o ident ify an object in a +bucket . Object met adat a is a group of key-value pairs t hat define t he propert ies of an object , such as +t he last modified t ime and t he object size. You can also assign user met adat a t o t he object . + +T he lifecycle of an object st art s when t he object is uploaded, and ends when t he object is delet ed. +T hroughout t he lifecycle, cont ent can be appended only t o object s creat ed by using append upload. If +you want t o modify t he cont ent of an object , you must upload a new object t hat has t he same name +as t he exist ing object t o replace t he exist ing object . + +T he name of an object must comply wit h t he following convent ions: + +T he name must be encoded in UT F-8. + +T he name must be 1 t o 1,023 charact ers in lengt h. + +T he name cannot st art wit h a forward slash (/) or a backslash (\). + +Not e Object names are case-sensit ive. Unless ot herwise st at ed, object s and files +Not e + +ment ioned in OSS document s are called object s. + +O bjectKey +O bjectKey + +In SDKs for different programming languages, Object Key, Key, and Object Name indicat e t he full pat h of +t he object . You must specify t he full pat h of an object when you perform operat ions on t he object . For +example, when you upload an object t o a bucket , Object Key indicat es t he full pat h t hat includes t he +ext ension of t he object . For example, you can set Object Key t o abc/efg/123.jpg. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +25 + + Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +Object St orage Service + +region +region + +T he physical locat ion of OSS resources. When you creat e a bucket , you can select a region based on t he +cost and source of t he request s. In most cases, t he closer a user is locat ed from an OSS region, t he +fast er t he access. For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +A region is specified when a bucket is creat ed. Aft er a bucket is creat ed, it s region cannot be changed. +All object s in t his bucket are st ored in t he corresponding region. Regions are configured for bucket s +inst ead of object s. + +endpoint +endpoint + +T he domain name t hat is used t o access OSS. OSS uses HT T P REST ful APIs t o provide services. Different +regions are accessed by using different endpoint s. A region has different endpoint s for access over t he +int ernal net work and for access over t he Int ernet . For example, t he public endpoint used t o access OSS +dat a in t he China (Hangzhou) region is oss-cn-hangzhou.aliyuncs.com, and t he int ernal endpoint is oss- +cn-hangzhou-int ernal.aliyuncs.com. For more informat ion, see Regions and endpoints. + +AccessKey pair +AccessKey pair + +T he access credent ial t hat is used t o ident ify t he request er. An AccessKey pair consist s of an AccessKey +ID and an AccessKey secret . OSS uses an AccessKey pair t o implement symmet ric encrypt ion and verify +t he ident it y of a request er. T he AccessKey ID is used t o ident ify a user. T he AccessKey secret is used t o +encrypt and verify t he signat ure st ring. T he AccessKey secret must be kept confident ial. OSS support s +AccessKey pairs obt ained by using t he following met hods: + +T he bucket owner applies for an AccessKey pair. + +T he bucket owner uses Resource Access Management (RAM) t o assign an AccessKey pair t o a t hird +part y. + +T he bucket owner uses Securit y T oken Service (ST S) t o assign an AccessKey pair t o a t hird part y. + +For more informat ion about AccessKey pairs, see Obtain an AccessKey pair. + +strong consistency +strong consistency + +T he feat ure t hat requires object operat ions in OSS be at omic, which indicat es t hat operat ions can +eit her succeed or fail wit hout int ermediat e st at es. T o ensure t hat users can access only complet e +object s, OSS does not ret urn part ially uploaded object s. + +Object operat ions in OSS are highly consist ent . For example, when a user receives an upload (PUT ) +success response, t he uploaded object can be immediat ely read, and copies of t he object are creat ed +for redundancy. T herefore, t he sit uat ions where dat a is not obt ained when a user performs a read- +aft er-writ e operat ion do not exist . T he same is t rue for delet e operat ions. Aft er a user delet es an +object , t he object and it s copies no longer exist . + +data redundancy mechanism +data redundancy mechanism + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism t hat is implement ed based on erasure coding and mult iple replicas. +Copies of each object are st ored in different servers wit hin t he same region. T his way, dat a durabilit y +and availabilit y are ensured when hardware failures occur. + +Operat ions on object s in OSS are highly consist ent . For example, when a user receives an upload or +copy success response, t he uploaded object can be immediat ely read, and copies of t he object are +creat ed for redundancy. + +T o ensure complet e dat a t ransmission, OSS calculat es t he checksum of t he net work t raffic packet s +and checks for errors when packet s are t ransmit t ed bet ween t he client and t he server. + +26 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +T he dat a redundancy mechanism of OSS can prevent dat a loss even when t wo st orage facilit ies are +damaged at t he same t ime. + +Aft er dat a is st ored in OSS, OSS regularly checks whet her copies of t he dat a are lost . T hen, OSS +recovers lost copies t o ensure dat a durabilit y and dat a availabilit y. + +OSS periodically verifies t he int egrit y of dat a t o det ect dat a corrupt ion caused by errors and +hardware failures. If dat a is part ially corrupt ed or lost , OSS recovers t he dat a by using copies of t he +dat a. + +Comparison between O SS and file systems +Comparison between O SS and file systems + +Item + +OSS + +File system + +Data model + +OSS is a distributed object +storage service that stores data +as key-value pairs. + +A file system uses a typical tree +structure for directory indexing. + +Data retrieval + +Objects are retrieved based on +unique object names (keys). + +For example, the object name +test1/test.jpg does not +necessarily indicate that the +object is stored in a directory +named test1. In OSS, +test1/test.jpg is only a string. +test1/test.jpg is not essentially +different from example.jpg. +T herefore, similar amounts of +resources are consumed +regardless of which object you +access. + +Advantages + +OSS supports concurrent access +from a large number of users. + +T o access a file named +test1/test.jpg, you must first +access the test1 directory and +then query the test.jpg file in this +directory. + +T he file system supports +modifications on files, such as +modifying the content at a +specified offset location or +truncating the end of a file. It +also supports directory +operations such as rename, +delete, and move directories. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +27 + + Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +OSS + +File system + +Objects stored in OSS cannot be +modified. A specific operation +must be called to append an +object. Generated objects are +different from objects uploaded +by using other methods. T o +modify an object, you must +upload the entire object again. + +OSS can simulate features similar +to those of directories. However, +such operations consume a large +amount of resources. For +example, if you want to rename +the test1 directory to test2, OSS +must copy all objects whose +names start with test1/. T hen, +OSS creates objects whose +names start with test2/. T his +operation consumes a large +amount of resources. T herefore, +we recommend that you do not +perform such operations in OSS. + +T he performance of the file +system is subject to the +performance of a single device. +More files and directories in the +file system consume greater +resources and take longer +processing time. + +Disadvantages + +We recommend t hat you do not map operat ions on OSS object s t o file syst ems because it is inefficient . +If you mount OSS as a file syst em, we recommend t hat you perform only add, delet e, and read +operat ions on object s. You can t ake advant age of OSS t o process and st ore large amount s of +unst ruct ured dat a such as images, videos, and document s. + +T he following t able describes t he differences in some t erms bet ween OSS and file syst ems. + +OSS + +Object + +Bucket + +Region + +Endpoint + +AccessKey + +N/A + +GetService + +File system + +file + +home directory + +N/A + +N/A + +N/A + +multilevel directory + +obtain the list of home directories + +28 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Terms + +OSS + +GetBucket + +PutObject + +AppendObject + +GetObject + +DeleteObject + +N/A + +File system + +obtain the list of files + +add a file + +append data to an existing file + +read a file + +delete a file + +modify file content + +CopyObject (same destination and source objects) + +modify file attributes + +CopyObject (different destination and source +objects) + +N/A + +copy a file + +rename a file + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +29 + + Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Object St orage Service + +7.Limits +7.Limits + +T his t opic describes t he performance met rics and limit s of Object St orage Service (OSS). + +T he following t able describes t he performance met rics and limit s of OSS. + +Item + +Description + +T he default bandwidth limit is 10 Gbit/s for regions inside the Chinese mainland +and 5 Gbit/s for regions outside the Chinese mainland. If this limit is reached, +requests are throttled. + +No t e When a request is throttled, the response to the request +No t e + +contains the x-oss-qos-delay-time: number header in which + + number indicates the duration over which the request is throttled. Unit: + +ms. For upload requests, the exact duration over which a request is +throttled is returned. For download requests, the estimated duration over +which a request is throttled is returned. T he duration is estimated based on +the extent of throttling and the size of the downloaded objects. + +If you require a higher bandwidth (10 Gbit/s to 100 Gbit/s) for your business such +as offline big data processing,contact technical support. + +T he total QPS limit for a single account is 10,000. T he actual values are different +in different read and write modes: + +Sequential read and write: 2,000 + +If you upload a large number of objects with sequential prefixes such as +timestamps and letters in the object names, many object indexes may be +stored in a single partition. In this case, if you send a large number of requests +to query these objects, the latency may increase. We recommend that you do +not upload a large number of objects that contain sequential prefixes in their +names. For more information about how to change sequential prefixes to +random prefixes, see OSS performance and scalability best practices. + +Non-sequential read and write: 10,000 + +If you require a higher QPS,contact technical support. + +You can use an Alibaba Cloud account to create up to 100 buckets in the same +region. + +A bucket name must be globally unique within OSS. For more information +about the naming conventions of buckets, see Bucket naming conventions. + +After a bucket is created, its name, region, storage class, and redundancy +type cannot be modified. + +OSS does not impose limits on the capacity of a bucket. + +Bandwidth + +Queries per second +(QPS) + +Bucket + +30 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Item + +Description + +Object + +T he size of the object that you want to upload + +When you use simple upload, form upload, or append upload to upload a +single object, the object cannot exceed 5 GB in size. + +When you use multipart upload to upload a single object, the object cannot +exceed 48.8 T B in size. + +T he size of the object that you want to rename + +You can rename only objects that are up to 1 GB in size in the OSS console. T o +rename objects that exceed 1 GB in size, we recommend that you use ossutil. + +T he number of objects that you want to delete + +You can delete up to 100 objects at a time in the OSS console. + +You can delete up to 1,000 objects at a time when you use OSS SDKs, +ossbrowser, or ossutil. + +W arning Deleted objects cannot be recovered. Exercise caution +W arning + +when you delete objects. + +Whether existing objects are overwritten by objects with the same names + +By default, when you upload an object that has the same name as an existing +object, the existing object is overwritten. T o prevent objects from being +accidentally overwritten, you can enable versioning for the bucket in which the +objects are stored. You can also include the x-oss-forbid-overwrite header in +upload requests and set the value of the header to true. + +Data restoration + +You must restore an Archive object or a Cold Archive object before you can +access the object. + +It takes about a minute to restore an Archive object. + +For a Cold Archive object, the restoration period varies based on the +restoration priority of the object. + +Expedited: T he object is restored within one hour. + +Standard: T he object is restored within 2 to 5 hours. + +Bulk: T he object is restored within 5 to 12 hours. + +For a domain name that is mapped to buckets located in regions inside the +Chinese mainland, you must apply for an ICP filing at the Ministry of Industry +and Information T echnology (MIIT ). + +Custom domain name + +Up to 100 domain names can be mapped to a bucket. However, a domain +name can be mapped only to a single bucket. + +OSS does not impose limits on the number of domain names that can be +mapped to the buckets of an Alibaba Cloud account. + +Lifecycle rules + +You can configure up to 1,000 lifecycle rules for a bucket. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +31 + + Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Object St orage Service + +Item + +Description + +Back-to-origin rules + +You can configure up to 20 back-to-origin rules for a bucket. + +In regions inside the Chinese mainland and the China (Hong Kong) region, the +default QPS for mirroring-based back-to-origin requests is 2,000, and the +default bandwidth is 2 Gbit/s. In regions outside China, the default QPS for +mirroring-based back-to-origin requests is 1,000, and the default bandwidth +is 1 Gbit/s. + +Limits on images + +Source images + +Only JPG, PNG, BMP, GIF, WebP, and T IFF images are supported. + +T he size of a source image cannot exceed 20 MB. + +For the rotate operation on images, the height or width of the source +image cannot exceed 4,096 pixels. For other operations on images, the +width or height of the source image cannot exceed 30,000 pixels, and +the total number of pixels of the source image cannot exceed 250 +million. + +T he total number of pixels of a dynamic image, such as a GIF image, is +calculated by using the following formula: Width × Height × Number + +Image Processing (IMG) + +of image frames . T he total number of pixels of a static image, such + +as a PNG image, is calculated by using the following formula: Width × + +Height . + +Resized images + +T he width or height of a resized image cannot exceed 16,384 pixels. T he +total number of pixels of the resized image cannot exceed 16,777,216. + +Limits on image styles + +You can create up to 50 image styles in each bucket. T o create more styles +for a bucket,contact technical support. + +32 + +> Document Version: 20220707 + + Object St orage Service + +Product Int roduct ion··Limit s + +Item + +Description + +Resource plans + +Resource plans that you purchase for specific regions can be used to offset +the fees generated by the resource usage only within the specified regions. + +You can use resource plans to offset the fees generated by the resource +usage in the regions that you specify when you purchase the resource plans. + +You can purchase only one storage plan for each validity period. However, you +can upgrade the storage plan that you purchase. For more information about +how to upgrade a storage plan, see Overview. + +You can purchase multiple transfer acceleration plans and back-to-origin +traffic plans within the same validity period to offset your fees. However, +these plans cannot be upgraded or renewed. + +You can purchase multiple downstream traffic plans within the same validity +period to offset your fees. T hese plans can be renewed but cannot be +upgraded. + +No resource plans are available to offset API operation calling fees, data +processing fees, and cross-region replication (CRR) traffic fees. You are +charged these fees on a pay-as-you-go basis. For more information, see API +fees, Data processing fees, and T raffic fees. + +> Document Version: 20220707 + +33 + diff --git a/q236/random_k4/random_2.md b/q236/random_k4/random_2.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..9ca97bffcc729b1713813967b06486a19042b100 100644 --- a/q236/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q236/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,493 +1,1121 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. +1 +Consumption +Landscape +September 2016 3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - +stnetnoC +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +Introduction +6 Section 1: Sample +8 Section 2: Music Consumption +18 Section 3: Device Usage +22 Section 4: Music Streaming Uptake & Perceptions +30 Section 5: Music Discovery +36 Section 6: Music Spending and Piracy +42 Section 7: User Generated Content + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 55 +INTRODUCTION +Today, consumers can listen Crucially, the free reign that consumers have over +how they access and consume music means that +to any music they want, at +the radio and music industries are totally consumer +any time, in any place and driven – no one but the audience dictates +what music is popular and successful. As +in any format, whether it be +a result, everybody in music management, +downloads, radio, streaming, publishing, broadcasting and streaming must keep +their finger on the pulse of the constant changes in +CDs or vinyl and, importantly, +consumer audio consumption, and how they +that privilege costs far less impact the industry as a whole. +than it used to, if it costs The report, ‘Music Consumption: The Overall +Landscape’, encapsulates a democratic measure +anything at all. +of audio consumption in the US, and saw a +statistically and demographically representative +sample of the 15+ US population answer a set of +general questions about listening habits. These +ranged from share of ear between radio to online +sources; to device preferences and piracy behavior; +to more detailed questions about playlist use; lean +forward / lean back selection; music sharing habits; +attitude to pricing; exclusive and hi-res audio and +much more. As a result, it uncovers the overall +music consumption landscape, how it is changing, +and how these changes may reshape the music +industry’s macro-environment. It is, therefore, an +invaluable tool for any company or person +operating within radio or music, and the creative +industries at large. + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - +SAMPLE +3014 Respondents +A statistically and demographically representative +sample of the US population. +All respondents had online access. +GENDER AGE +| | | | 15-19 | 9% | +| ---- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | 20-24 | 9% | +| Male | Female | | | | +25-34 +17% +| 51 | 49 | | 35-44 | 16% | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | 45-54 | 18% | +| | | | 55-64 | 15% | +elpmaS +| | | | 65+ | 16% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +REGION SOCIAL GRADE +| | | | < $15K | 11% | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +:1 NOITCES +| | 20% | $15K to $24,999K | | 11% | +| --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +NORTHEAST +| | | $25K to $34,999K | | 12% | +| ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| MIDWEST | 24% | | | | +| | | $35K to $49,999K | | 14% | +| SOUTH | 35% | $50K to $74,999K | | 2% | +| | 21% | $75K to $99,999K | | 15% | +WEST +| | | | >$100K | 15% | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - +TIME SPENT +LISTENING +TO MUSIC +Total Sample +| | At 23%, the most popular listening block was 1 to | | | | On average, the total sample listened to 147 minutes | | | | +| --- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +noitpmusnoC 2 hours. of music on a ‘typical day’. Minutes listened dropped +as respondents got older, peaking amongst the 15- +68% of respondents listened to music for up to 3 +24 year olds at 187, dropping to 85 minutes amongst +hours on a typical day, whilst 7% didn’t listen to any +the 65+ year olds. +music at all. +23% +17% +15% +13% +8% +7% +5% +3% +| cisuM | 2% | | | 2% | | | | | +| ------ | ------------ | ------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------------- | ------ | ------------ | +| | | | 1% 1% 1% | | | | | | +| | 0% | 0% | | | | | | | +| | 12+ 11 -12 | 10 -11 | 9 -10 8 -9 7 -8 | 6 -7 5 -6 | 4 -5 | 3 -4 2 -3 1 -2 | 1 hour | 30 mins None | +| | hours hours | hours | hours hours hours | hours hours | hours | hours hours hours | | | +:2 NOITCES +Average minutes listened: +| | 147 | | 187 | 179 | | 122 | | 85 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | +| | MINS | | MINS | MINS | | MINS | | MINS | +| | Total Sample | | 15-24 year olds | 25-44 year olds | | 45-64 year olds | | 65+ | +Question: To the nearest half hour, how long do you normally spend listening to music in a typical day? +Base: 3014 + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +1111 +RADIO RULES THE YOUNGER +LISTENING ROOST CONSUMERS ARE +HEAVY ONLINE +LISTENERS +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +Radio is still king, capturing 35% of net daily On demand streaming is second with 24% (digital All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +listening. downloads are third with 12% and other internet +radio (Pandora etc.) is fourth with 10%; all ahead of +Mainstream digital content, meanwhile, are Younger generations are predominantly listening the older age groups with respondents aged 55-64 +CDs at 7%. Share of listening shows the percentage, +comfortably outperforming physical forms of to on-demand streaming and 65+ listening to radio most (45% and 53%) +or share, of time respondents spent on each method +music. followed by downloads (13%). +| | | of listening – i.e. Broadcast Radio captured 36% of | Whilst 24% of the general population listened to | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +respondents’ total listening time. on demand streaming on a ‘typical day’, 51% of *Share of listening can be defined as: The portion, +| | | | 15-19 year olds and 41% of 20-24 year olds did the | | | | | or share, of respondent’s total listening time each | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SHARE OF LISTENING +| | | | same, a significant over-index. Radio trends up in | | | | | format accounted for. | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SHARE OF LISTENING BY AGE +AM/FM Radio 35 +53 +51 +On demand streaming (YouTube, Spotify etc.) 24 +45 +42 +| Digital Downloads/Files | | | | | | 41 | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +12 +35 +33 +31 +| Other Internet Radio (Pandora etc.) | | 10 | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +27 +24 +| | | | | | | 21 | | 22 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | CDs | 7 | | | 20 | | | | | | | | | | +19 +17 +15 +| | | | | | | | 14 13 | 14 | 13 | | | 13 | | 13 | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | 12 | 12 | | 11 | | | | | | | | 11 | +| Satellite Radio (Sirius XM etc.) | | 6 | | 10 | | | | | | 1110 | | | | | +| | | | | | 9 | | | | | | 9 | | | | +| | | | | 7 | | | | | 7 | 7 | | 7 | | | +| | | | | 6 | | | | | | 6 | | | 6 6 | 7 | +| | | | | | | | 4 4 | | 5 | | | 5 | | | +3 +| | | | | | 2 2 | 2 | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| AM/FM Radio Stations Streamed online | | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | Total | | 15-19 | 20-24 | 25-34 | 35-44 | | 45-54 | 55-64 | | 65+ | | +Vinyl 1 -0 - +| | | | AM/FM RADIO | | | | | | ONLINE STREAMING (OVERALL) | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | ON DEMAND STREAMING (YOU-TUBE, SPOTIFY,ETC) | | | | | | INTERNET RADIO | | | | | | +HD Radio 1 +| | | | DIGITAL DOWNLOADS/FILES | | | | | | PHYSICAL | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Question: To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening time normally split between the following sources? +Base: 2808 Respondents Question: To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening time normally split between the following sources? Base: 2808 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +1133 +ONLINE SOURCES ARE RADIO IS STILL +CATCHING FM RADIO REACHING ALL +IN WEEKLY REACH AGE GROUPS +Total Sample By Age +In terms of reach (listened to once for 5 minutes Please note – ‘Online Consumption (Total) is the On demand streaming vastly over-indexes AM/FM Radio listening, meanwhile, peaked +or more over a weekly period) FM Radio came net of On-demand streaming and internet radio. amongst younger generations, then declined as amongst 35-44 year olds at 84%. Physical listening +top at 78%. This was then followed by Online respondents got older. rose with age, before dropping slightly amongst the +Consumption at 72%, on-demand streaming at 65+ year olds. +61%, internet radio at 43%, digital downloads at +US WEEKLY REACH - BY AGE +33% and physical music at 23%. +US WEEKLY REACH - NETS +95 +93 +| | | | | 90 | | 89 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 84 | | 84 | | | | +| | | | | | | 81 | 82 | 81 | | | +| | | | 78 | 95 | 78 | 77 | | | 78 | | +| | | | 72 | | | | | | | 71 | +69 +68 +FM Radio +78% 65 +63 +61 +| | | | | | | | | 56 | 56 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +54 +52 +| Online Consumption (Total) | | | | | | 50 | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 72% | | 48 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 44 | | | | 44 | | +| | | | 43 | 43 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 40 | | 40 | +39 +| On-demand streaming | | 61% | 33 | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +31 +28 +| | | | | | | | | 2626 | 27 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +25 +| | | | 23 | | | 23 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 21 | 21 | | +19 +| Internet Radio | 43% | | | | 18 | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | -------------------------- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | 13 | | | | | | 14 | +| Digital Download 33% | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | Total | 15-19 | 20-24 | 25-34 | 35-44 | 45-54 | 55-64 | 65+ | +| Physical Music | | | AM/FM RADIO | | | | | ONLINE STREAMING (OVERALL) | | | +23% +| | | | ON DEMAND STREAMING (YOU-TUBE, SPOTIFY,ETC) | | | | | INTERNET RADIO | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | DIGITAL DOWNLOADS/FILES | | | | | PHYSICAL | | | +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last Question: Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents during the last seven days? Online Streaming (Overall) = On demand streaming + Internet radio (NET) Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 15 +YOUTUBE IS THE It has recently launched its YouTube Red premium The key questions around YouTube for the coming +subscription service, which covers music and other year are whether other music services can attract +verticals, and rights holders are starting to see new listeners and start to fill this value gap and +MOST REGULARY +decent pots of revenue slowly emerge from that. whether YouTube will work to increase its Red +user base and payouts to the music industry while +The popularity of on demand music services will +USED SOURCE FOR finding other ways to generate revenue for rights +grow. But for the world’s most accessed streaming +holders and appease them, something its recent +service in order to listen to music, the ‘free’ +acquisition of D2C commerce Bandpage might help +AUDIO CONTENT problem is still a big problem. +it work towards. +US WEEKLY REACH BY PLATFORM +42% of respondents said The YouTube value gap is one of the leading +industry topics of 2016. Put in context with an equal +they used YouTube for five +42% of respondents who said they were happy with +minutes or more at least once free tiers of music services enough not to upgrade, YouTube 42% +Pandora 31% +it is a gap made to feel even glaringly bigger by the +a week to listen to audio. Spotify 22% +survey results. +iTunCeDs 18% +Pandora follows closely at +According to the survey, YouTube was the key iHeart Radio 18% +31% with CDs lagging behind touch point for audio listening across online and Amazon Prime Music 13% +13% +offline, especially for the younger generations. Music as digital files +at 22%. This rose to 67% in +12% +It is also the leading point of discovery behind Facebook +12% +15-24 year-olds. recommendations from friends – 34% of Google Play Music +9% +respondents said they discovered music via Apple Music +9% +YouTube, which rose to 54% of 15-24 year olds. Amazon Music Store +7% +TV Music Channels +YouTube has long had a fractious relationship with 7% +Vevo +the music industry. Praised by marketers for its 5% +SoundCloud / SoundCloud Go +reach and ability to launch and stoke the release of 5% +Vinyl +new music on a global level, or to create overnight 3% +My SXM +3% +sensations like The Harlem Shake, at the same +Podcast(s) +3% +time it pays out lower royalties to rights holders +Shazam +3% +per stream than dedicated music services and has +An artist’s own online website 3% +been criticised consistently at the negotiating table. +Rhapsody 3% +Vimeo 3% +Audible 3% +8Tracks 3% +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +17 +| YOUNGER | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | FACEBOOK LEADS | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| GENERATIONS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | SOCIAL MEDIA USAGE | | | | | | | | | | | | | +FAVOUR ONLINE +PLATFORMS +Total Sample +By Age Facebook dominates platform usage while Despite its buzz Snapchat is still relatively +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Twitter is weak. 57% of respondents used | | | | | | | niche, with 30% net usage and only 13% using | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Facebook everyday, whilst 15% used Twitter. | | | | | | | it everyday. Pinterest is also used more than | | | | | | +| YouTube usage is high in the younger age groups, | | | | | | | | CD’s in comparison to older users, just 11% of | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Instagram, Snapchat and Vine, with 47% net usage. +| decreasing consistently with age. Pandora has a | | | | | | | | 15-19 year olds listening to a CD over a weekly period. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fairly even spread, before dropping amongst the +Here, on-demand streaming services are making +oldest age groups. +up the difference. 71% of 15-19 year olds listening to +SERVICE USAGE REGULARITY & AWARENESS +| Younger generations under-indexed on listening to | | | | | | | | YouTube, and 44% to Spotify over a weekly period. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +PLATFORM WEEKLY REACH BY AGE +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | YouTube | | | 33 | | 24 | | | 12 | 14 | | 14 3 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Facebook | | | | 57 | | | | 11 6 | 6 | | 17 3 | +Netflix +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 23 | | | 19 | 9 | 9 | | 35 | | 4 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 71 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Pinterest | | 12 | 12 | 10 | 14 | | | 44 | | | 9 | +63 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | iTunes | | 10 | 11 | 8 | 18 | | | 47 | | | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +51 +| | | | | | | 46 | | | | | | | 44 | | | | Twitter | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 42 | | 42 | 39 | | 42 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 15 | 10 | 9 | 13 | | | 48 | | | 6 | +| | | | | | 38 | 36 | | | | | | | 37 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 31 | 31 | | | | | | | | | | | | | G o o g le | + | 11 | 9 | 8 | 15 | | | 4 8 | | | 8 | +| | | | | | | | 28 | | | | 26 26 25 | | | 26 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 19 | | | | 19 | 22 | | 22 19 | | | | | | | In st a g ra | m | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 14 | | 16 | | | 18 | | 18 | | | | | 18 | | 8 7 | 9 | | | 5 1 | | | 7 | +| | | | | | | | | | 11 | | | | | | 13 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 7 4 | Amazon Prime instant | | 7 | 9 | 7 | 12 | | | 50 | | | | 15 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Spotify | | 11 | 8 | 5 9 | | | 52 | | | | 14 | +| | YouTube | | | | Pandora | | | | | CD | | | Spotify | | | | LinkedIn | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 4 | 7 | 8 | 15 | | | 53 | | | | 13 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Snapchat | | 13 | 6 | 4 6 | | | 59 | | | | 12 | +| | 28 26 | 26 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Tumblr | 6 | 5 | 4 7 | | | 60 | | | | | 19 | +| | | 21 | | | | | | | | 20 20 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 18 | | | | | | 19 17 | | | | | | | 15 16 | 15 16 | | | Sound c lou | d 4 | 4 5 | 8 | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 13 11 | 13 | 13 14 | | 13 | 13 | 14 | | 11 | 12 | | | 13 | | | | | | | 36 | | | | 44 | | | +| | | | 7 | | | | 9 6 | | 7 | | 9 | 6 | | | 8 5 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | V im e | o 3 | 5 5 | 8 | | 44 | | | | | 36 | | +Vine +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 4 | 3 4 | 7 | | | 55 | | | | 27 | | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | ---------------------- | ----- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | iTunes | | | iHeart Radio | | | | Amazon Prime Music | | | | Music as digital files | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Whatsapp | 7 | 3 3 | 5 | | 43 | | | | 40 | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | MySpace | 2 3 | 2 7 | | | | 74 | | | | | 12 | +| | 16 | 17 | | | | 17 | | | 20 16 | 17 | | | | | | | Tinder | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 12 | 10 | 14 | 11 8 | 9 | 11 12 | 14 | | 9 | | 10 | | | 9 | 12 11 | | | | 3 | 3 2 3 | | | 56 | | | | | 32 | | +| | | | 7 | | | | 7 5 2 | | | | 6 2 | 2 7 | 4 | | 4 4 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Deezer | 2222 | | 22 | | | | | 69 | | | | +| | Facebook | | | | Google Play Music | | | | Apple Music | | | Amazon Music Store / Amazon | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Cloud Player +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE EVERYDAY | | | I USE 2-3 TIMES A WEEK | | | I USE ONCE A WEEK | | | | I USE LESS OFTEN | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +TOTAL 15-19 20-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65+ I AM AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE BUT DO NOT USE I AM NOT AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE +Which, if any, of the following have you used in order to listen to audio content (music or speech) for five minutes or more at any one time during the last +seven days? Base: 3014 Respondents Question: Which of the following statements best describes you in relation to each of the following web-based services? Base: 3014 Respondents + +19 +FM/AM radio receiver 33 +Smartphone / Cellphone 18 +Desktop computer 8 +Laptop or netbook 7 +Satellite Radio Receiver (Sirius XM etc.) 7 +Internet/wi-fi connected radio receiver 4 +In car CD Player 4 +Television 3 +In-car phone audio connection (wired aux 3 +Tablet (iPad etc.) 3 +CD Player 3 +iPod 2 +Other portable mp3 or media player 1 +Wireless speakers (Bluetooth etc.) 1 +Vinyl Player 1 +Other 1 +:3 +NOITCES +egasU +eciveD +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +FM/AM RADIO +IS THE MOST +LISTENED TO DEVICE +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day +At 33%, Radio took the majority share as the Smartphone device gap. Mobile phone listening +device listened to the most. is 2nd with 18% and roughly equivalent to the +combined listening on laptop (7%), desktop (8%) +Share of listening can be defined as: The portion, +and tablets (3%), which acculmulates to (18%). +or share, of respondent’s total listening time each +device accounted for. +SHARE OF LISTENING BY DEVICE +To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music listening normally split between the following devices? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +21 +| THE SMARTPHONE | | | | | | | | | | | | | | THE SMARTPHONE | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| IS KING AMONGST | | | | | | | | | | | | | | REIGNS OVER DAILY | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| YOUNGER LISTENERS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | LISTENING | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +All those who listen to music on a ‘typical’ day Total Sample +Age distribution across radio receivers starts in the 15-19 age bracket, and gradually decreases The smartphone was the most regularly listened This was then followed by the Smartwatch (31%), +low for 15-19 years olds and grows in linear with age. to device, daily, out-performing radio receivers Laptop (30%) and FM/AM radio receiver (29%). +fashion as respondents got older to peak at 49% with 46% of respondents saying they use it to +Laptop/netbook skews slightly young while satellite +amongst those aged 65+. The opposite holds for listen to music every day. +radio peaks amongst 35-44 and 65+ year olds. +smartphone / cellphone users with a peak at 41% +DEVICES: REGULARITY OF USAGE TO LISTEN TO MUSIC +FM/AM radio receiver +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 29 | | | | 31 | | | 21 | | 6 | 5 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +DEVICE SHARE OF LISTENING BY AGE +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Satellite radio receiver | | | | | 26 | | | 28 | | | | 22 | 7 | 7 | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Smartphone / Cellphone | | | | | | 46 | | | | | 18 | | 9 | 4 6 | 6 | +49 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | In-car phone audio | | | 21 | | | | 27 | | | 24 | | 9 | 9 | 7 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +42 +41 +| | | 39 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Smartwatch | | | | 31 | | | | | 26 | | | 14 | 3 5 | 6 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 33 | | 32 | | 31 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Internet/wi-fi connected radio receiver | | | | | | 28 | | | 24 | | | 18 | | 10 | 8 | 7 | +| | | 26 | | | 24 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +Laptop or netbook +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 30 | | | | 18 | | 14 | | 7 10 | | 10 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +| | 20 | | | | 19 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +18 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Wireless speakers | | | 15 | | 20 | | | 27 | | | 14 | | 15 | 8 | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | 14 | | | | | 14 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | 11 | | | | | | | | | | | 11 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 9 | 8 | 10 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 7 | 8 | 8 | 7 6 | 6 | 7 | 8 7 | | | | Desktop computer | | | | 23 | | | 20 | | 15 | | 8 | 11 | | 11 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | 6 | 5 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 3 | | | | | | | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Television | | | 25 | | | 20 | | | 11 | 5 | 9 | | 15 | +| | FM/AM radio receiver | | Smartphone / Cellphone | | | | | Desktop computer | | | Laptop or netbook | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Tablet | | 21 | | | 17 | | | 18 | | 8 | 14 | | 11 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | iPod | | 15 | | 17 | | | 21 | | 10 | | 20 | | 14 | +11 +9 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | In car CD player | | | 9 | 14 | | | 23 | | 12 | | 20 | | | 16 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +7 +| 7 | | | | 6 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 6 5 | | | 6 | | | | | | | | | | | | Playstation | | 12 | | 12 | | 19 | | | 11 | 13 | | 16 | | +6 +| | | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 | | 4 4 3 | 4 | | 4 4 | 4 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------ | ----- | --------------------------- | -------------- | ----- | --- | ------------------------------- | ----------------------- | ----- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 3 | | | | | 3 | | 3 | | 3 | 3 | 3 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | 2 | 2 | 2 | | | | Xbox | | 10 | 12 | | | 19 | | 8 | | 15 | | 17 | | +| | 2 | | | | | 2 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1 | | 1 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | CD Player | 6 | | 11 | | 19 | | 13 | | 25 | | | 19 | | +| | Satellite Radio Receiver | | Internet / wi-fi connected | | | | | Television (including a | | | Tablet (iPad etc.) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Vinyl Player | 5 | 7 | 10 | | 12 | | | 27 | | | 31 | | | +| | (Sirius XM etc.) | | | radio receiver | | | satellite or cable enabled tv) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE EVERYDAY | | | | | | | | | | I USE 2-3 TIMES PER WEEK | | | | | | | +| | TOTAL | 15-19 | 20-24 | | 25-34 | | 35-44 | 45-54 | | 55-64 | | 65+ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I USE ONCE A WEEK | | | | | | | | | | I USE LESS OFTEN | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | I AM AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE BUT DO NOT USE | | | | | | | | | | I AM NOT AWARE OF THIS WEB-BASED SERVICE | | | | | | | +To the nearest 15 minutes, how is your music split between the following devices? +Question: Approximately, how often do you use each of the following to listen to music? +Base: 2808 Respondents Base: Users of each device (2168 FM/AM Radio Receiver users, 2181 Television users etc.) + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +23 +17% PAID FOR +A PREMIUM + gnimaertS cisuM +SUBSCRIPTION +TO A MUSIC +STREAMING SERVICE +Total Sample + dna ekatpU snoitpecreP +| | 21% of US respondents initially stated that they | | | | | Last year, in the same annual study, 13% actually | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | have a premium subscription to a streaming service. | | | | | paid for a subscription to a music streaming | | | +| | However, upon further investigation, 17% actually | | | | | service. This shows a 31% increase YOY. | | | +paid for the service, whilst 4% used the service on a +Paid subscriptions skewed slightly skewed male, with +free subscription, through a free trial, bundle deal, or +20-34 year olds over-indexing significantly at 29%, +using through someone else’s account. +in comparison the the general population (17%). +PAID/PREMIUM MUSIC STREAMING SUBSCRIPTIONS +| | Total | 17% | | 4% | | | 79% | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Male | 20% | | 4% | | | 76% | | +| | Female | 15% | 3% | | | | 82% | | +| | 15-19 | 21% | | 6% | | | 73% | | +20-24 +| | | | 29% | | 6% | | | 65% | +| ---------- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| :4 NOITCES | 25-34 | | 31% | | 5% | | | 64% | +| | 35-44 | | 23% | 3% | | | 74% | | +| | 45-54 | 11% | 3% | | | | 86% | | +| | 55-64 | 6% 3% | | | | 91% | | | +65+ +| | | 4%3% | | | | 93% | | | +| --- | ----------------- | ---- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | PAID SUBSCRIPTION | | | FREE SUBSCRIPTION (FREE TRIAL ETC) | | | | NO | +Do you have a paid/premium subscription to a music streaming service?Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +25 +SPOTIFY IS THE MOST THE FREE TRIAL IS +PAID FOR MUSIC THE MOST EFFECTIVE +STREAMING SERVICE CONVERSION METHOD +All who have subscribed to a music streaming service Those who pay for a music streaming subscription +Amongst premium subscribers, Spotify (37%), 55% of 15-19 year olds who have a paid for The key driver to paid subscription is a free trial. +Pandora (32%), Apple Music (22%) and YouTube streaming subscription subscribe to Spotify, 53% said that they subscribed in order to continue +Red (19%) are the most paid for services. a considerable over-index over the general using the full version after a free trial period. +| | population (45%). Meanwhile, the same age group | | Meanwhile, only 31% of respondents said they | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Spotify skews to younger users, whereas +| | under-index on paying for Pandora, Amazon Prime | | decided to pay to remove adverts and and 29% to | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Pandora, Amazon Prime Music and YouTube Red +| | Music and YouTube Red. | | use service on mobile. | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +are less favourable. +STREAMING SERVICES SUBSCRIBED TO AMONGST SUBSCRIBERS REASONS FOR PAYING FOR A STREAMING SERVICE +| Spotify | | | 45% | I used the full version of the | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +55% service on a free trial period, +53% +| | | 39% | | liked it and decided to pay for | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| Pandora | | | | | the full version | | | +23% +| | | 28% | | I was using the free version, | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Amazon Prime Music +| | 8% | | | liked it, but wanted to remove | | | 31% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +advertisements +| Apple Music | | 26% | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +25% +I wanted to use it on my +| YouTube Red | | 24% | | | mobile device | | 29% | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +15% +| Google Play Music | 18% | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Recommendation from +7% +| | | | | | friends/family | 24% | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +12% +Rhapsody +6% +I wanted to listen to a +| | 7% | | | s o n | g / a lb u m r e le a s ed | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +Xbox Groove 17% +| | 0% | | | exc l u | s iv e ly t h ro u g h th e | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | +platform +| Last.fm | 6% | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3% +Saw it advertised and liked the +10% +| Soundcloud go | 5% | | | | look of it | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | +6% +| Deezer | 5% | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 0% | | | Don’t know / Not sure | | 5% | | +4% +Tidal +6% +| | 7% | | | Other (please specify) | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Other (Please write in) | | | | | | 9% | | +1% +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Which of the following do you have a premium subscriptions to? +Why did you decide to pay for a music streaming subscription? +Base: 607 Respondents Base: 607 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 27 +THE FREEMIUM change: Pandora wants to launch a mid-tier on +demand offering and Amazon is rumoured to be +exploring lower cost options, including bundling +QUESTION +with Alexa, for its own on demand music service, +In the meantime Spotify and Apple Music are +pushing forward with family plans to offset the cost +of subscriptions, and may well compete with their +own mid-level tiers once these others launch. Will it +be enough to lure this 42%? +42% respondents weren’t The freemium question is a difficult one. Failed REASONS FOR NOT PAYING FOR A STREAMING SERVICE +services like Rdio have admitted that lack of a +paying for music streaming +free tier hurt their growth and that once onboard +services because they were via subscription users did not stick around long +I’m happy using the free +enough to become embedded in the service and +happy using freemium tiers version with adverts 42% +churned. At the same time the economics of free +with adverts. ad-supported tiers are very difficult to make work. It’s too expensive 40% +Free tiers are a funnel to paid subscription not a +I prefer not to pay for music / +means to an end in themselves and ad-supported prefer to use free music 29% +sources like YouTube +online video platform Muzu.tv recently shut down +due to inability to pay rights holders – it was on a It doesn’t appeal to me 28% +50/50 ad revenue split which is likely a less severe +I prefer to listen to music in a +position than most streaming services. different way 14% +42% of respondents said they were happy using I don’t really understand what +3% +it is +free tiers with adverts, suggesting that it would be +very hard for music services to upsell nearly half of The content range isn’t good +3% +enough +respondents to paid subscriptions, leaving them +with already tight profit margins made tighter. This +There isn’t enough +2% +personalisation +rose to 55% of 15-24 year-olds and 47% of 25-44 +year olds, suggesting that free tiers may put off +The audio quality isn’t good +1% +the younger generations from paying for premium enough +subscriptions. +Don’t know / Not sure 5% +So far mid-tier services like Cür Media in the +US or Bloom.fm in the UK have failed to get +Other (Please Specify) 3% +off the ground while existing mid tier options, +predominantly premium tiers of interactive radio +services, have not been a big draw. This is due to +Why have you not subscribed to a music streaming service? +Base: 2276 Respondents + +29 +CHEAPER PRICING +OPTION16% S W3O8% ULD2 6% +PERSUADE LISTENERS +TO PAY FOR STREAMING +All who have not subscribed to a music streaming service +40% of those who don’t pay for a streaming Just 10% of respondents said exclusive access to +service said that it was because the service was too content by their favourite artists would persuade +expensive, the top option ‘a wider range of content’ them to pay for music streaming. This did however, +follows, by some margin, at 10%. rise to 25% amongst 15-19 year olds, a significant +over-index. +PAID MUSIC STREAMING DRIVERS +40% +Cheaper pricing options +45% +10% +A wider range of content +15% +Exclusive access to content +(Video, music etc.) from your 10% +favourite artists released only +25% +through the platform +A specialism in your favourite 9% +music genres +14% +- +A pay as you go service (99p 9% +for 24 hours of listening etc.) +12% +9% +Better audio quality +14% +44% +Don’t know / Not sure +33% +6% +Other (Please Specify) +3% +REACH 15-19 YEAR OLDS +What would convince you to pay for a subscription to a music streaming service? +Base: 2276 Respondents + +31 +Recommendations from friends 46% +YouTube 34% +Music/Interviews played on FM/AM Radio 32% +Live performances on TV 24% +Music videos on TV 20% +Music played in films/TV Shows/video games 18% +Music videos shared in Facebook 15% +Live performances on the Radio 15% +Music videos linked from YouTube (Through the sidebar, or recommended) 14% +Recommendations by another artist/celebrity you like (Inc. social media posts) 14% +Spotify’s browse, recommended or related artists 13% +Live performances at gigs/festivals 12% +Music/Interviews played on Internet Radio 11% +Spotify Playlists 10% +Radio adverts 8% +TV Talent shows (American Idol, Americas Got Talent) 8% +Magazine/Newspaper articles or interviews 8% +Billboards or Posters 7% +Online adverts 7% +Recommendation by experts (Journalists, Bloggers etc.) 6% +Spotify Discover Weekly 6% +SoundCloud 6% +iTunes Genius 5% +Music videos shared in Twitter 5% +TV Adverts 4% +Apple Music recommendations and playlists 4% +Newspaper/Magazine Adverts 4% +Tracks linked through SoundCloud (Autoplay, recommend sidebar) 3% +Other Internet recommendation service (Please specify) 2% +Other (Write in) 4% +None of the above 10% +:5 +NOITCES +yrevocsiD +cisuM +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +YOUTUBE OVERTAKES +RADIO AS A LEADING +MUSIC DISCOVERY +METHOD +Total Sample +YouTube leads online discovery, while personal +music through Spotify’s browse, recommended +recommendations still rule. 34% of respondents +or related page, whilst 10% discovered through +said that they discover new music via YouTube. +their playlists, far ahead of Apple Music’s +YouTube is second only after recommendations +recommendation and playlists (4%). +from friends (46%) and ahead of music/interviews +TV is still influential, with live performances in +played on FM/AM Radio (32%). 13% discovered +fourth at 24% and music videos in fifth with 20%. +MUSIC DISCOVERY METHODS +How do you typically discover music? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +33 +| YOUNGER LISTENERS | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | PLAYLISTS | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| DISCOVER MUSIC | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | OVERTAKE | | | | | +| ONLINE AND THROUGH | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | ALBUMS | | | | | +FILM, TV & GAMES +Total Sample +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 42% of respondents said | | | | for market share and are creating deep and clever | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | +The leading two forms of discovery – 15-19 (29%) and 20-24 (24%). Music videos linked playlist ecosystems based on human expertise and +Playlists accounted for 31% +recommendations from friends and YouTube from YouTube show a similar but less pronounced data, for example Spotify with its editorial playlists +– skew young, whereas discovery via live pattern. of total listening, whilst and its Discover Weekly and Release Radar +performances on TV skews older, peaking at 65+. algorithm-driven playlists. +albums accounted for 22%. +Music/interviews played on FM/AM on the +Spotify’s browse, recommended or related artists influential in the middle ages, with peaks at 25-34 Meanwhile music services are vying for playlist +Single track listening still +features skew heavily young with peaks in the and 45-54. market share and launching their own brands in +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | leads the pack with 46%, | | | | order to secure powerful launch points point for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | +TOP MEANS OF DISCOVERY BY AGE +new releases and not depend on music services +but fell 6% YOY from 52% +to seed tracks in their own in-house playlists, for +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | in 2015. | | | | example UMG with its Digster or Hits brands; SME | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | +| | 56 55 | | | | 56 53 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +51 50 +| 46 | | | 44 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | with Filtr or WMG with Topsify. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | +| | | | 42 | | | 40 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | 34 | | | | | | 38 38 | 35 | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | 32 | | | 31 | 32 | 32 | 29 | | 31 | | | | 31 | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 27 | | | | | | | | 28 | iTunes unbundled the album. Now playlists are | | | | | +23 24 24 23 25 22 The importance of playlists is further underlined by +20 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | 13 15 | | | further edging out the album format and eating | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a move to contextual listening, with users making +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | into single tracks’ share of listening, as shown by | | | | choices about what they want to listen to according | +| --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | +| | Recommendations | | | | YouTube | | | | Music/Interviews played | | | | Live performances on TV | | | | | | | | +the survey results. Playlists have been lauded as +from friends on FM/AM Radio to mood, time of day, or activity for example. In +the key new format for some time, and playlist +| | 28 | | | | 28 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | return many popular playlists focus on context, for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | +23 +2022 22 20 21 22 19 19 i n v e n to r y i s t h e n e w d i g i ta l s h o p f r o n t a n d p o int of +15 18 18 15 15 18 18 16 17 15 16 15 example Coffee Break listening or songs to work +| | | | 14 | | | | | | 13 | | 13 | | 14 | | 14 13 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | 9 | | | | 9 | | 10 | | | d i s co v e r | y f o r li s t e n e | r s o n s t r e a m | i n g s e r v ic e s. | | +out to, something that will continue to drive the +popularity of playlists as a format. +Music videos on TV Music played in films/TV Music videos shared Live performances There is an emergent tension between music +| | | | | | Shows/video games | | | | on Facebook | | | | on the radio | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +services who produce their own playlists and labels +| | | | | | 25 | | | | 29 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 25 21 | | | | | 25 | | | 24 | | | | | 22 | | | | | | | +18 19 19 v y in g f o r p l a y l is t m a r k e t s h a re o n m u s ic s e rv ic e s . +| 14 | | 14 | | 14 | | 14 | | 13 | | | | 12 | 13 | 16 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | 12 11 | | | | 8 | | | 11 | 10 | | 10 | | 9 8 | | | | | | +4 6 5 4 6 M u s ic s e r v i c e s s e e p l a y li s t s a s a k e y b a t t le g ro u n d +2 +| | Music videos linked | | | | Recommendations by | | | | Spotify’s browse, | | | | Live performances at | | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | from YouTube | | | | another artist/celebrity | | | | recommended or related | | | | gigs/festivals | | | | | | | | +artists +| | TOTAL | | 15-19 | 20-24 | | 25-34 | | 35-44 | 45-54 | | 55-64 | | 65+ | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +How do you typically discover music? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +35 +PLAYLISTS MOST PLAYLISTS +OVERTAKE LISTENED TO ARE +ALBUMS USER MADE +Total Sample All those who listen to playlists +Playlists are more popular than albums, and Generally the younger the respondent the less 42% of playlists listened to are not created by +single listening is down. Playlists accounted for they’d listen to albums, and the more they’d listen the listener. Of these, 27% are created by the +31% of total listening, whilst albums accounted for to playlists. platform they listen on, and 15% are created by +22%. Single track listening still lead the pack with someone else. +46%, but fell 6% YOY from 52% in 2015. +WHAT KIND OF PLAYLISTS DO YOU LISTEN TO? +SINGLES, ALBUMS OR PLAYLISTS? Total +| | | | | | 57% | 15% | 27% | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | 15-19 | 61% | 16% | 22% | +| Total | 46% | 22% | 31% | | | | | +| 15-19 | | | | 20-24 | 57% | 18% | 24% | +| | 54% | 18% | 28% | | | | | +| 20-24 | 46% | 18% | 35% | | | | | +| | | | | 25-34 | 51% | 19% | 30% | +25-34 +| | 43% | 21% | 35% | | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | 35-44 | 60% | 14% | 26% | +| 35-44 | 44% | 21% | 35% | | | | | +| | | | | 45-54 | 61% | 10% | 27% | +| 45-54 | 44% | 21% | 33% | | | | | +| | | | | 55-64 | 58% | 14% | 27% | +| 55-64 | 46% | 24% | 27% | | | | | +| 65+ | 48% | 27% | 21% | 65+ | 57% | 12% | 31% | +SINGLE TRACKS ALBUMS PLAYLISTS PLAYLISTS CREATED MYSELF PLAYLISTS CREATED BY SOMEONE ELSE +PLAYLISTS CREATED BY THE PLATFORM I LISTEN ON +How do you typically discover music? +How is your music listening split between the following?Base: 3014 Respondents Base: 3014 Respondents + +37 +30% +CD Albums +21% +19% +Tickets for music/concerts/gigs +17% +16% +MP3/Download albums that were paid for +19% +16% +MP3/Download albums that you got for free +25% +15% +MP3/Download singles that were paid for +15% +15% +Music gift cards (e.g. iTunes, Spotify, HMV Vouchers) +25% +14% +MP3/Download singles that you got for free +25% +10% +Music Merchandise items (e.g. t-shirts, posters etc.) +12% +7% +Tickets for festivals +10% +7% +Vinyl Albums +5% +3% +Vinyl Singles +4% +37% +None +26% +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +:6 +NOITCES +gnidnepS +cisuM +ycariP +dna +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +63% PURCHASED +A MUSIC RELATED +PRODUCT OVER +6 MONTHS +Total Sample +CDs still most common music product purchase, album downloads, music gift cards and MP3 single +at 30% of respondents, followed by live tickets downloads. +(19%) and MP3 downloads (16%). 15-19 year olds +63 % of respondents had purchased a music +under-index on CD albums and over-index on MP3 +related product over the past 6 months. +MUSIC SPENDING +Which of the following music products have you acquired for yourself or have been given as a present in the past 6 months? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 39 +54% WOULD AT LEAST 54% SAID THAT THE +CONSIDER PAYING COST OF HIGH-RES +FOR HI-RES AUDIO IS A DETERRENT +Total Sample Total Sample +Consumers on the fence about hi-res. 38% would service said they would definitely be prepared to Cost is the key barrier to hi-res adoption. 54% of 48% are happy with the quality of their existing +consider paying a premium for Hi-Res audio but pay a premium and 42% say they would consider respondents said that concern about cost has or music and a worrying 24% (rising to 28% amongst +only 16% would definitely pay a premium, paying a premium. might prevent them from purchasing hi-res files, 15-19 year olds) said that they doubt they would be +with this rising to 63% of 15-19 year-olds, the same able to tell the difference. +Hi-Res is an existing customer upsell opportunity. +age group that showed increased interest in hi-res +43% of those who are already paying for a +in separate questions. +premium/paid subscription to a music streaming +WILLINGNESS TO PAY A PREMIUM FOR MUSIC OF A SUPERIOR SOUND QUALITY BARRIERS TO HI-RES ADOPTION +54% +Concern as to the cost +63% +Total 16% 38% 26% 20% 48% +I am happy with the quality of my existing music +46% +15-19 13% 45% 25% 16% +24% +I doubt I would be able to tell the difference +28% +20-24 24% 36% 28% 11% +16% +The files would take up too much storage space +25-34 27% 38% 23% 12% 23% +11% +35-44 19% 36% 28% 17% My music system/devices would not do ‘Hi Res’audio justice +7% +45-54 13% 39% 25% 22% 11% +The files would take too long to download +14% +55-64 8% 36% 28% 27% +10% +None of the above +6% +65+ 6% 36% 27% 31% +1% +Other (Please state) +1% +I WOULD DEFINITELY BE PREPARED TO PAY A PREMIUM I WOULD CONSIDER PAYING A PREMIUM +I WOULD BE FAIRLY UNLIKELY TO PAY A PREMIUM I DEFINITELY WOULD NOT PAY A PREMIUM TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Base: 3014 Respondents What, if anything, has or might prevent you from purchasing ‘Hi-Definition / High Resolution’ audio files?Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +41 +24% DOWNLOADED +MUSIC VIA AN +ILLEGAL SOURCE +Total Sample +Stream Ripping leads the pirate ship. 15% of +respondents have used stream ripping sites or +software in the last six months, rising to 29% in +15-19 year olds. This is almost double the use of +BitTorrent (8%). +DOWNLOADING MUSIC FROM ILLEGAL SOURCES +| 8% | 7% | 15% | 2% | 76% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +From +| Via | | Via Stream Ripping | | None of | +| ---------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ----- | -------- | +| | Cyberlocker | | Other | | +| Bittorrent | | sites and software | | these | +Sites +| 7% | 10% | 29% | 1% | 59% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +TOTAL 15-19 YEAR OLDS +Over the past 6 months, have you download music from any of the following? +Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +43 +CONTENT +UPLOADING + detareneg-resU +Those who use each service +| Snapchat users are the most frequent uploaders | | | | | YouTube users are mostly passive watchers. Only | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| and least passive users of these platforms. 22% of | | | | | 6% of those who use YouTube frequently upload to | | | | | | +| those who use Snapchat said that they frequently | | | | | the site and 74% only ever view or listen to content | | | | | | +| upload to Snapchat. | | | | | that others have uploaded. | | | | | | +UPLOADING BEHAVIOUR +| | Snapchat | 35% | | | 43% | | | | 22% | | +| --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Instagram | | | 44% | | | 40% | | | | 16% | +| | Beatport | | 48% | | | 35% | | | | 18% | +| | Facebook | | 48% | | | 38% | | | | 14% | +Twitter +| | | | | 56% | | | 33% | | | 10% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tnetnoC +| | Tumblr | | | 57% | | | 33% | | | 11% | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | MySpace | | | 58% | | | 29% | | | 12% | +Pinterest +| | | | | 60% | | | 30% | | | 10% | +| ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Vine | | | 65% | | | | 27% | | 9% | +| Soundcloud | | | | 66% | | | | 25% | | 9% | +:7 NOITCES Google+ +| | | | | 66% | | | | 26% | | 9% | +| -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Vimeo | | | 68% | | | | 22% | | 10% | +| Bandcamp | | | | 72% | | | | 19% | | 9% | +| | YouTube | | | 74% | | | | 20% | | 6% | +I ONLY EVER VIEW OR LISTEN TO CONTENT THAT OTHERS HAVE UPLOADED +I MOSTLY VIEW OR LISTEN TO CONTENT THAT OTHERS HAVE UPLOADED BUT SOMETIMES UPLOAD CONTENT MYSELF +I FREQUENTLY UPLOAD CONTENT TO THIS SITE +Base: Those who used each service + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 45 +WHAT KIND OF MUSIC SHARED +CONTENT DO THE MOST OVER +YOU UPLOAD? FACEBOOK +All who upload content to the web Total Sample +Photos are still the most popular upload. 86% Facebook is the leading music sharing method. +of respondents upload photos while 47% upload 39% of respondents shared music via Facebook +videos and only 20% upload audio. SoundCloud but word of mouth is a strong second with 30% of +and Vinyl Listeners over-index on audio uploading, people saying they mentioned the artist / track / +with 40% and 41% respectively versus the 20% album to them offline and 21% saying they played it +mean. to them offline. WhatsApp is low down in the music +sharing pecking order at 5%. +CONTENT FORMAT UPLOADED MUSIC SHARING METHODS +Online via Facebook 39% +47% +Offline, I mention the artist / track / album to them 30% +Videos 53% +Offline, playing it on my phone/device/speakers to them 21% +41% +Online via email 14% +86% +Offline, by lending a CD/Vinyl to them 13% +Photos/Images 82% +88% Online via other instant messenger 10% +Online via Twitter 10% +20% +Audio tracks 25% Online via music streaming service (e.g. Spotify) 8% +15% Online via Skype 6% +Online via Whatsapp 5% +4% +Other (Please Specify) 4% Other 2% +4% None of the above 28% +TOTAL MALE FEMALE +What kind of content do you tend to upload on to the web? How do you usually share music you like with friends and/or others? +Base: 1736 Respondents Base: 3014 Respondents + +MUSIC BIZ CONSUMER INSIGHTS // CONSUMPTION LANDSCAPE 2016 +THANK YOU +For any questions about this +report please contact our +Music Industry Lead: +ROBERT@AUDIENCENET.CO.UK \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q236/random_k4/random_3.md b/q236/random_k4/random_3.md index 0c7ef2d487833615a392ae69c62e25551ee74322..8ffc9e35ab866274a31e5d323c2574066c5b4f1c 100644 --- a/q236/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q236/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,552 +1,1726 @@ -HEALTH INFORMATICS (HI) - -HI 41095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Topics could include current or emerging issues -in health informatics. Topics will be announced in schedule of classes. -Offered irregularly as resources and opportunities permit. -Prerequisite: None. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 41096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Research or individual investigation in areas not -covered in the existing curriculum for baccalaureate level students at or -above the junior level. In-progress (IP) mark permissible. -Prerequisite: Special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP - -HI 60401     HEALTH INFORMATICS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80401) This introductory course is a survey course -that acts as a foundation for all other courses in the Health Informatics -program. Basic concepts of Health Informatics are emphasized -throughout. The course targets students who at some point in their -career will oversee or have direct input on one of the highest expenditure -areas for health care organizations--the planning, selection, deployment -and management of electronic medical records (EMR), management -decision-support and tracking systems (DSS) and other health -information technologies (health IT). -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60402     LEGAL ISSUES IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80402) This course provides students with an -introduction to the fundamentals of law for Health Informatics and -Information Management. Components of learning will include general -legal principles and regulatory issues in the U.S. healthcare system. -Primary topics will include ethical issues, consideration of state laws -and the Federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act -(HIPAA), privacy and security rules. Through discussion board and writing -assignments, students will demonstrate understanding of practical -issues of health information access, its use and disclosure, and the -legal and regulatory consequences associated with breaches of health -information confidentiality and security. We will explore some of the -special legal issues with electronic health records (EHR) and health -information exchange; secondary uses of health information; compliance; -and related ethics issues. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           1 - -HI 60403     HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80403) Introduction to information systems and their -applications in healthcare used for managerial and clinical support. -Study the fundamentals of information systems, including Electronic -Medical Records (EMR), information security. Understand the role of -standardized codes, vocabularies and terminologies used in health -information systems. Analysis of management and enterprise systems, -identify the key elements to manage information resources effectively -and the trends affecting the development of health information systems -and networks. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60410     HEALTH RECORDS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80410) This course examines Health Information -Management, the role of the HIM professional in the context of the -health system and the role of the health record. The role of information -management and documentation principles is essential to the successful -application of technology and ensuring an effective health information -infrastructure. The course discusses confidentiality, privacy, security, -reliable standards, data integrity, quality, governance, and ethical -principles that make health care information of use for organizations and -individuals. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60411     CLINICAL ANALYTICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80411) The use of well-defined and well-integrated -clinical analytics throughout the healthcare value chain can be -transformative. Through careful implementation of health analytics, -hospitals can transform unwieldy amalgamations of data into -information that can: improve patient outcomes, increase safety, -enhance operational efficiency and support public health. Given the -immense size of the data challenge, the distinctness and geographic -spread of many healthcare-related activities, and the fact that so many -healthcare activities are conducted by different entities which must -interact with each other, there is really no other way to provide operations -management tools necessary to deliver personalized medicine and to -control spiraling costs. Since clinical analytics is an immature discipline, -we carefully examine the practices of those institutions that are standard -setters in the industry. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60412     CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80412) Provides a practical survey of clinical decision -support systems that collect clinical data and enable the transition to -clinical knowledge in real world applications intended to improve quality -and safety of patient care. Students become familiar with the basic -requirements for clinical decision support systems and the challenges -associated with the development and deployment of new applications -within the healthcare setting. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Health Informatics (HI)           1 - - 2        Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026 - -HI 60413     CHANGE MANAGEMENT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80413) Designed to cover the process of change -management in large healthcare organizations in light of current trends. -Topics related to technology requirements, technology implementations, -risk assessment and buy-in are among those covered. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60414     HUMAN FACTORS AND USABILITY IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -     3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80414) Provides students with the foundational -principles of usability and human factors as applied to safety and quality -in health informatics technology. Course readings and materials review -the concepts of human factors, usability and the cognitive consequences -of health information technology on clinical performance and decision -making. Attention is given to the role of mobile computing in health care, -as well as information visualization. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60416     HEALTH INFORMATICS ISSUES: POLICY, POLITICS AND -ETHICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80416) This course uses a policy analysis lens to -critically examine issues related to the use of information technology in -healthcare from an ethical, political and regulatory perspective. Course's -primary focus is on the United States, but international approaches are -also be discussed. Legislation affecting health information technology -area are examined,including the American Reinvestment and Recovery -Act, HITECH section; Affordable Care Act and Health Insurance Portability -and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996. Topics and issues related to -health informatics also are discussed, including structure of health -administrative and delivery systems, assessment of population health, -models of health care delivery, access and quality of care. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60417     PUBLIC HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 80417) Public Health Informatics (PHI) is an emergent, -interdisciplinary field that focuses on the systematic management -and dynamic application of information resources to enhance public -health practice, education and research. As an emerging subset of -Health Informatics, PHI is practiced by individuals, governmental and -nongovernmental organizations at the international, national, regional, -state and local levels. PHI deals with the collection and analysis of vital -statistics data through surveillance; information creation; information -storage and retrieval; visualization and graphics; dissemination; use of -information for policy, decision making and trend tracking. The purpose -of this course is to provide students with an introductory overview of -the vast and dynamic field of PHI, including definitions, approaches, -competencies, applications and informatics principles applied in public -health settings. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -2        Health Informatics (HI) - -HI 60418     CLINICAL ANALYTICS II      3 Credit Hours -As the volume and complexity of health data continues to grow, analysis -of that data requires more advanced tools to transform that data into -meaningful information for clinical decisions. Not only is data from -electronic medical records (EMRs) growing at a rapid pace but new -types of data are available for analysis, such as, genomic data and -patient generated data. These advanced analytic tools break down into -three areas, each of which will be examined in this course: new data -warehousing techniques to manage big data, new analytic tools including -cognitive computing and predictive analytics and new ways to visualize -the data. All of these techniques transform the raw data into use cases, -such as, population health, precision medicine and clinical decision -support using artificial intelligence and machine learning which will also -be addressed in this course. -Prerequisite: HI 60411; and graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60419     CONSUMER HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -This course examines the history and current trends in consumer health -informatics, examining how patients and healthcare stakeholders -manage health in the digital age. The evolution of health information -technology has expanded the role of the patient to include being -a consumer of healthcare, bringing with it more capabilities and -responsibilities. The course will discuss health information and -communication technologies and their influence on health care for -patients, affecting health information seeking behaviors and expectations -among multiple stakeholder groups. The course will discuss US and -global perspectives for health information professionals serving health -information needs in the community and in medical, academic, and public -libraries. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60636     STANDARDIZED TERMINOLOGIES IN HEALTHCARE      3 -Credit Hours -Introduce various types of standardized healthcare terminologies -(controlled vocabularies) used in the Electronic Health Records -(EHR) and Health information Exchange (HIE). Present the benefits of -using standardized terminologies, as well as the interoperability and -Meaningful Use (MU) requirements and standards. Explain the purposes, -structures, components, and application of the most widely implemented -standardized terminologies such as ICD, CPT, SNOMED CT, LOINC, -RxNorm, ICNP and UMLS. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 60691     SEMINAR IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 80691) Advanced research by -students who are qualified to examine problems of certain special areas -in health informatics. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Seminar -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - - HI 60693     VARIABLE TITLE WORKSHOP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit). Intensive examination of special topics of interest -to those involved in health informatics program. Maximum workshop -credit for the M.S. degree in health informatics is 4 semester hours. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Workshop -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory - -HI 60792     ELECTIVE INTERNSHIP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      2-3 -Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Supervised work experience in health informatics -of a professional nature of not less than 100 clock hours (for 2 credit -hours) or 150 clock hours (for 3 credit hours). -Prerequisite: Graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Practical Experience -Contact Hours: 6.66-10 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 61095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 81095) Offered irregularly as -resources and or opportunities permit. Topics could include current or -emerging issues in health informatics. Specific topics are announced in -the Schedule of Classes. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 61096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Research or individual investigation in areas not -covered by the existing curriculum for master's level students. Maximum -6 credit hours towards master's degree. -Prerequisite: Graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP - -HI 66092     MASTER'S INTERNSHIP IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -Supervised work experience of an advanced professional nature that -concentrates on developing skills in areas of health informatics and -integrates their knowledge from all HI courses and experiences. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Practical Experience -Contact Hours: 10 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66099     MASTER'S PROJECT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit -Hours -Provides a means for the application of the knowledge, research and -competencies learned through study in health informatics to the -development of an information system, product, setting or service. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum overall 3.000 GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Project or Capstone -Contact Hours: 3 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           3 - -HI 66198     MASTER'S RESEARCH PAPER IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -Under the advisement of a faculty member, students will complete a -research paper that serves as a culminating experience for the Health -Informatics master's degree. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Research -Contact Hours: 9 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66199     THESIS I      2-6 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Thesis students must register for a total of -6 hours, 2 to 6 hours in a single semester distributed over several -semesters if desired. -Prerequisite: HI 60401, HI 60402, HI 60403, HI 60410, HI 60411, HI 60414 -and HI 60636; and minimum 3.000 overall GPA; and graduate standing; -and special approval. -Schedule Type: Masters Thesis -Contact Hours: 6-18 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 66299     THESIS II      2 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) Thesis students must continue registration each -semester until all degree requirements are met. -Prerequisite: HI 66199; and graduate standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Masters Thesis -Contact Hours: 6 other -Grade Mode: Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory-IP - -HI 80401     HEALTH INFORMATICS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60401) This introductory course is a survey course -that acts as a foundation for all other courses in the Health Informatics -program. Basic concepts of Health Informatics are emphasized -throughout. The course targets students who at some point in their -career will oversee or have direct input on one of the highest expenditure -areas for health care organizations--the planning, selection, deployment, -and management of electronic medical records (EMR), management -decision-support and tracking systems (DSS), and other health -information technologies (health IT). -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Health Informatics (HI)           3 - - 4        Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026 - -HI 80402     LEGAL ISSUES IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60402) This course provides students with an -introduction to the fundamentals of law for Health Informatics and -Information Management. Components of the learning will include -general legal principles and regulatory issues in the U.S. healthcare -system. Primary topics will include ethical issues, consideration of state -laws and the Federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act -(HIPAA), privacy and security rules. Through discussion board and writing -assignments, students will demonstrate understanding of practical -issues of health information access, its use and disclosure, and the -legal and regulatory consequences associated with breaches of health -information confidentiality and security. We will explore some of the -special legal issues with electronic health records (EHR) and health -information exchange; secondary uses of health information; compliance; -and related ethics issues. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80411     CLINICAL ANALYTICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60411) The use of well-defined and well integrated -clinical analytics throughout the healthcare value chain can be -transformative. Through careful implementation of health analytics, -hospitals can transform unwieldy amalgamations of data into -information that can: Improve patient outcomes, increase safety, -enhance operational efficiency and support public health. Given the -immense size of the data challenge, the distinctness and geographic -spread of many healthcare-related activities, and the fact that so many -healthcare activities are conducted by different entities which must -interact with each other, there is really no other way to provide operations -management tools necessary to deliver personalized medicine and to -control spiraling costs. Since clinical analytics is an immature discipline, -we carefully examine the practices of those institutions that are standard -setters in the industry. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80403     HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60403) Introduction to information systems and their -applications in healthcare used for managerial and clinical support. -Study the fundamentals of information systems, including Electronic -Medical Records (EMR), information security. Understand the role of -standardized codes, vocabularies and terminologies used in health -information systems. Analysis of management and enterprise systems, -identify the key elements to manage information resources effectively -and the trends affecting the development of health information systems -and networks. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80410     HEALTH RECORDS MANAGEMENT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60410) This course examines Health Information -Management, the role of the HIM professional in the context of the -health system and the role of the health record. The role of information -management and documentation principles is essential to the successful -application of technology and ensuring an effective health information -infrastructure. The course discusses confidentiality, privacy, security, -reliable standards, data integrity, quality, governance, and ethical -principles that make health care information of use for organizations and -individuals. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80412     CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60412) Provides a practical survey of clinical decision -support systems that collect clinical data and enable the transition to -clinical knowledge in real world applications intended to improve quality -and safety of patient care. Students become familiar with the basic -requirements for clinical decision support systems and the challenges -associated with the development and deployment of new applications -within the healthcare setting. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80413     CHANGE MANAGEMENT IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 -Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60413) Designed to cover the process of change -management in large healthcare organizations in light of current trends. -Topics related to technology requirements, technology implementations, -risk assessment, end user computing and buy-in are among those -covered. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80414     HUMAN FACTORS AND USABILITY IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -     3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60414) Provides students with the foundational -principles of usability and human factors as applied to safety and quality -in health informatics technology. Course readings and materials review -the concepts of human factors, usability, and the cognitive consequences -of health information technology on clinical performance and decision -making. Attention is given to the role of mobile computing in health care, -as well as information visualization. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -4        Health Informatics (HI) - - Kent State University Catalog 2025-2026           5 - -HI 81096     INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATION IN HEALTH INFORMATICS -1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit). Research or individual investigation in areas -not covered by the existing curriculum for doctoral level students. -Deliverables determined with instructor of record. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing; and special approval. -Schedule Type: Individual Investigation -Contact Hours: 3-9 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter-IP - -HI 80416     HEALTH INFORMATICS ISSUES: POLICY, POLITICS AND -ETHICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60416) This course uses a policy analysis lens to -critically examine issues related to the use of information technology in -healthcare from an ethical, political and regulatory perspective. Course's -primary focus is on the United States, but international approaches are -also be discussed. Legislation affecting health information technology -area are examined,including the American Reinvestment and Recovery -Act, HITECH section; Affordable Care Act and Health Insurance Portability -and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996. Topics and issues related to -health informatics also are discussed, including structure of health -administrative and delivery systems, assessment of population health, -models of health care delivery, access and quality of care. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80417     PUBLIC HEALTH INFORMATICS      3 Credit Hours -(Slashed with HI 60417) Public Health Informatics (PHI) is an emergent, -interdisciplinary field that focuses on the systematic management -and dynamic application of information resources to enhance public -health practice, education and research. As an emerging subset of -Health Informatics, PHI is practiced by individuals, governmental and -nongovernmental organizations at the international, national, regional, -state and local levels. PHI deals with the collection and analysis of vital -statistics data through surveillance; information creation; information -storage and retrieval; visualization and graphics; dissemination; use of -information for policy, decision making and trend tracking. The purpose -of this course is to provide students with an introductory overview of -the vast and dynamic field of PHI, including definitions, approaches, -competencies, applications and informatics principles applied in public -health settings. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 80691     SEMINAR IN HEALH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 60691) Advanced research by -students who are qualified to examine problems of certain special areas -in health informatics. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Seminar -Contact Hours: 1-3 other -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -HI 81095     SPECIAL TOPICS IN HEALTH INFORMATICS      1-3 Credit -Hours -(Repeatable for credit) (Slashed with HI 61095) Offered irregularly as -resources and or opportunities permit. Topics could include current or -emerging issues in health informatics. Specific topics are announced in -the Schedule of Classes. -Prerequisite: Doctoral standing. -Schedule Type: Lecture -Contact Hours: 1-3 lecture -Grade Mode: Standard Letter - -Health Informatics (HI)           5 +A survey on Information Visualization in light of Vision + +and Cognitive sciences + +Corresponding author: Jose F Rodrigues-Jr, junio@icmc.usp.br + +6 +1 +0 +2 + +y +a +M +3 +1 + +] + +R +G +. +s +c +[ + +2 +v +9 +7 +0 +7 +0 +. +5 +0 +5 +1 +: +v +i +X +r +a + +Luciana A M Zaina+, + +Maria C F de Oliveira, + +Bruno Brandoli, + +and Agma J M Traina + +May 7, 2018 + +Abstract + +Information Visualization techniques are built on a context with many factors related + +to both vision and cognition, making it difficult to draw a clear picture of how data + +visually turns into comprehension. + +In the intent of promoting a better picture, here, + +we survey concepts on vision, cognition, and Information Visualization organized in a + +theorization named Visual Expression Process. Our theorization organizes the basis of + +visualization techniques with a reduced level of complexity; still, it is complete enough + +to foster discussions related to design and analytical tasks. Our work introduces the fol- + +lowing contributions: (1) a Theoretical compilation of vision, cognition, and Information + +Visualization; (2) Discussions supported by vast literature; and (3) Reflections on visual- + +cognitive aspects concerning use and design. We expect our contributions will provide + +further clarification about how users and designers think about InfoVis, leveraging the + +potential of systems and techniques. + +Keywords— Information Visualization, InfoVis, Vision Science, Cognitive Science + +1 + + 1 + +Introduction + +Understanding why and how visual representations work is an important issue addressed in + +many works on Information Visualization (Dill et al. 2012)(Thomas & Cook 2005). On the track + +of this issue, in this work, we assume that well-designed visualizations must stimulate visual + +and cognitive processes in a way that reasoning is amplified. The effective promotion of such + +reasoning depends on principles mastered in the sciences of vision and cognition: vision is the + +gate through which information derived from computer graphics reaches the brain; cognition + +refers to the processing that is induced by such graphics. Vision and cognition are closely + +intertwined, a fact to be considered in the design of visualizations. Accordingly, understanding + +Information Visualization (InfoVis for short) in light of these sciences may improve design + +principles that, usually, are performed intuitively. To this end, we review the steps that take + +place during vision-cognition phenomena when the goal is data analysis. In survey fashion, we + +compile the literature introducing the following contributions: + +• Theoretical compendium: we draw a descriptive relationship between vision, cognition, + +and Information Visualization; + +• Discussions: we debate our rationalizations over extensive literature; + +• Reflections: we provide study cases to revisit design practices. + +We organize visualization concepts aiming at the needs pointed out by Johnson et al. (2006), + +who recommend the characterization of how and why visualizations work, and by Scaife & + +Rogers (1996), who stress the importance of the cognitive aspects underlying visualizations. + +Furthermore, we review principles for visual representations that, according to Card et al. + +(1999), are an initial step towards more effective visualization techniques, a demand defended + +by Wong et al. (2012). + +We note that, while we build an association between Information Visualization, vision, and + +cognitive sciences, we do not reach a definitive settlement. This is because neither vision nor + +cognition are yet fully understood. Rather, constrained to the current state of the art, we + +introduce an organizational process that discusses use and design. + +2 + + 2 Related work + +The literature presents several models that lay the basis to Information Visualization. Bertin + +(1977/1981) introduced the concept of deriving visual structures from a set of fundamental + +components. Cleveland & McGill (1984), and Mackinlay (1986), conducted studies on the use- + +fulness of visual patterns in the form of frameworks for design. Card et al. (1999) follow Bertin + +by discussing the importance of the spatial substrate. Keim (2002) suggests a taxonomical + +space for quick referencing; Shneiderman (1996) reasons about the possibilities of visualization + +and interaction; and Chi (2000) focuses on data transformations. In the realm of design, Buga- + +jska (2003) deals with spatial and abstract visualizations considering the design guidelines of + +Tweedie (1997). In the line of works that reflect about the visualization field, van Wijk (2006) + +systematically discusses visualizations based on a cost-oriented analysis; and Green et al. (2009) + +research many cognitive and perceptual aspects (Rensink 2000) to build a model and a set of + +guidelines for design. Patterson et al. (2014) introduces a framework based on vision and cog- + +nition sciences, similar to ours, focusing on top-down processes. Comparatively, we conduct a + +complementary bottom-up approach; we translate vision-cognition phenomena into an original + +vocabulary that may bring such science closer to the design practice. + +To organize our compilation on vision and cognitive sciences, we depart from the Visualiza- + +tion Pipeline of Card et al. (1999) to draw the Visual Expression Process, a sequence of events + +delineated by the possibilities of the visual-cognitive interplay. According to our organization, + +(1) vision phenomena (pre-attentive stimuli) determines a map of potential interesting objects. + +Then, attentive selection concentrates on one single element, part of a set of (2) analytical + +perceptions. Such perceptions go through a pattern-matching process that turns them into + +(3) abstract patterns that, in working memory, support cognition in combination with domain + +knowledge originated from long-term memory. Finally, leading to (4) cognitive decision sup- + +port. Nevertheless, our process does not explain the intercourse between vision, cognition, and + +Information Visualization; this is not feasible considering the current knowledge, and neither + +it would fit in a single article. + +The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 3 draws a detailed panorama of + +vision and cognition in the realm of Information Visualization. Section 4 introduces the Visual + +Expression Process, our organizational theorization; and the last section presents conclusive + +remarks. + +3 + + 3 Concepts on Vision, Cognition, and Visualization + +According to Vision Science, the visual process has two stages, namely, the parallel extraction + +of low-level properties, called pre-attentive processing, followed by a slower detailed scan. The + +first stage promotes the major benefit of visualizations, that is, improved data comprehension + +(Triesman 1985). Meanwhile, the second stage addresses conventional reading practices that + +do not contribute towards faster cognition, but that are necessary for further analysis. In fact, + +Ware (2004) states that understanding what is processed pre-attentively is probably the most + +important contribution that Vision Science can bring to visualization. + +This two-stage process might be the underlying motivation for the broadly referenced “visu- + +alization mantra”: overview first, zoom and filter, then details on demand (Shneiderman 1996) + +– Schneiderman came to this conclusion by means of intuition and empirical experiments, never + +drawing the vision/cognitive reasons of why this is the case. We discuss this process in the + +following sections according to our process, presented in section 4. + +3.1 Maps of Saliences + +In the early stages of vision, the brain deals with the problem of casting potential elements of + +interest; regions of the scene that should be considered for cognition. To cope with that, a com- + +plex process takes place so that certain characteristics pop out to the eyes. These characteristics + +appear as saliences over the scene. They define the so-called maps of saliences, exemplified in + +Figure 1; the first element of our theoretical organization. + +Figure 1: (a) Example of a map of saliences over the Gapminder tool. In the scene, the bubbles +with outstanding features stand for saliences corresponding to countries of interest. (b) The +result is a map of potential targets that pop out due to their color, or their shape. + +The principle of salience is to reinforce the perception of the areas in the scene whose visual + +4 + + properties contrast with those of their surroundings (Itti & Koch 2001). It is a process that + +considers different visual aspects, such as position and color, and that ends as it combines them + +onto a single scene (Nothdurft 2000). + +The occurrence of salient features stems from their interplay with other stimuli, depending + +on a context that favors conspicuousness. The brain is highly trained to detect such configura- + +tions, being able to track salient features in parallel, in real-time, and covering the entire visual + +field. There is also evidence that this ability is strongly influenced by the task-at-hand, in a + +top-down (cognition-to-vision) process (Navalpakkam & Itti 2007) (Patterson et al. 2014). + +3.2 Attention and Attentive Selection + +Although the brain perceives visual targets simultaneously in a map of saliences, it cannot + +process all of them in parallel. This is considered a prohibitively computational task even + +to the most sophisticated brains (Tsotsos 1991). Primates and other animals handle this by + +restricting the consideration of the objects presented to their eyes: their vision concentrates + +on small regions considering objects one after the other. This is a serialization process ruled + +by what is called attention. In other words, once a map of candidates is ready, it is necessary + +to “filter out” one of these candidates for attention. Attention, here, occurs in accordance + +with the task that the user is performing; the task determines the information demands and, + +consequently, what visual stimuli should be extracted from the scene. Trial and error is part of + +the process, which is iterative. + +This process of filtering has been modeled as a pyramidal neuronal structure – named + +selective tuning model (Cutzu & Tsotsos 2003) (Essen et al. 1992). This theoretical model + +predicts a broad layer of neurons in its first level, narrowing down as it advances to upper layers. + +The layers intercommunicate through feed-forward and feedback connections and, according to + +Cutzu & Tsotsos (2003) (Tsotsos et al. 1995), a pyramid of neurons successively performs three + +stages of processing, illustrated in Figure 2: (a) bottom-up feed-forward, (b) top-down winner- + +take-all feedback (Lippmann 1987), and (c) bottom-up straight path. This process explains + +what is broadly referenced as filtering or attentive selection. + +Following this widely-accepted model, it is worthy to note that, as described, filtering occurs + +according to both bottom-up and top-down processes. The bottom-up process depends on the + +visual stimuli, while the top-down process depends on the task at hand and is prioritized (Wolfe + +1994). Each process influences the other iteratively. Actually, according to Patterson (2012), + +the entire visual-cognition interplay in influenced by top-down mechanisms that emanate from + +5 + + working memory, but that may be highly influenced by long-term memory (Woodman et al. + +2013). + +In this work, we focus on the bottom-up process, but there are works that explore + +higher-level factors related to the top-down process (Patterson et al. 2014). + +Figure 2: Three-stage pyramidal visual selection: (a) bottom-up feed-forward, (b) top-down +winner-take-all feedback (Lippmann 1987), and (c) bottom-up straight path. + +3.3 Cognition, Memory and Vision + +After a target is selected, it is potentially useful for “details on demand”, or cognition. + +In + +general terms, cognition refers to the acquisition or use of knowledge Cohen (1985), and may + +occur analytically (conscious and slower) or intuitively (automatic and fast), as defended by the + +dual system theory (Evans 2008)(Evans & Stanovich 2013). Cognition is of special importance + +in data visualization as it supports analogical reasoning (Patterson et al. 2009). That is, + +the transfer of inferences from a relationship of elements in one domain (the analogue) to a + +relationship of elements in another domain (the target). In any case, cognition is intermediated + +by the memory system. The relationship between memory and cognition is studied by works + +on Cognitive Architectures, such as ACT-R (Buttner 2010) and Soar (Young & Lewis 1999). + +In Soar and other theories, the structural configuration of memory roughly reflects the model + +of Baddeley & Hitch (1974). Working memory includes three components: the central executive + +module, the phonological loop, and the sketchpad. The central executive module determines + +the attention focus, guiding the visual system, for example, by top-down biasing the pyramidal + +selection mechanism. The phonological loop stores information related to sound. The sketchpad + +(also known as Visual Short-Term Memory – VSTM 1) is associated with the maps of saliences + +1although, this is not a consensus + +6 + + discussed in Section 3.1, storing information related to space and to visual features. + +Following these lines, memory comes to be the main element in supporting cognition as it + +allows complex mental operations. Consequently, it also supports the practice of data visual- + +ization. Miller’s Law (Miller 1956) states that the memory is limited to 7+/-2 elements; more + +recent, and accepted, works state that this limit is at 4 chunks of elements – a chunk refers + +to the grouping of elements into larger units based on their meaning (Cowan 2010). Alvarez + +& Cavanagh (2004) discuss memory limits considering the nature of the elements to be re- + +membered, demonstrating that, despite the consensus of a (very) limited resource, there is not + +an ultimate conclusion about the topic. In any case, these limitations are severe because the + +greater the capacity of an individual’s memory, the more information she/he has available for + +solving problems (Just & Carpenter 1992). + +The memory system supports cognition in two ways: by retaining a list of elements for + +quick referencing, and by assisting in the construction of mental models (Johnson-Laird 1983). + +According to Johnson-Laird (2010), mental models preserve the relationship between entities + +by defining analogies that save on logical reasoning, one of the principles behind complex + +visualization techniques and interaction (Liu & Stasko 2010a). Following the study of Logie + +(1995), mental models are created in the visuo-spatial sketchpad, a specialization of VSTM. + +Stimuli encoded into VSTM, ruled by cognition, may activate enduring information known as + +long-term memory, including facts, meanings, relationships, skills, and procedures (Patterson + +et al. 2010) – for a deeper discussion on working memory and long-term memory, refer to the + +work of Rose et al. (2010). + +The concepts presented in the former sections rely on ideas posed by widely accepted the- + +ories, among several others, for the visual-cognitive process. The choice for this specific line of + +thought has been motivated by its intuitive coherence and scope of influence in the literature. + +Notwithstanding, other theories are widely referenced, such as the Spotlight (Eriksen & Hoff- + +man 1973) and the Gradient (Cheal et al. 1994) models. For an ample discussion, refer to the + +work of Squire (2009). + +4 The Visual Expression Process + +In this section, we review the practice of visualizing data by considering the concepts presented + +so far. We organize the relationship among visualization, vision, and cognition according to + +a framework named Visual Expression Process – Figure 3. Our theoretical organization has + +7 + + four constituents: (1) pre-attentive stimuli, (2) analytical perceptions, (3) abstract patterns, + +and (4) decision support. For completeness of our survey, Table 1 summarizes previous models + +found in the literature. Our theorization is inspired by these previous works putting together + +concepts in a complementary point of view. + +Table 1: Summary of previous models on InfoVis. + +Model + +Summary + +Lohse (1993) + +An algebraic model to estimate the effort to answer +questions based on a visualization. +A pipeline of how to conduct the visualization +practice. + +Card +(1999) +van Wijk (2005) An economic model stated to evaluate efficacy and + +al. + +et + +(Ware 2005) + +(Hegarty 2011) + +(Patterson et al. +2014) + +efficiency. +A top-down (problem-solving) model that states that +what we see in a visualization depends on what we +are seeking for. +A descriptive discussion of how visualizations work +that culminates into a compilation of principles and +perspectives. +A vision-cognition model that explains visualization +and how to improve it from a top-down perspective. + +According to our theorization, (1) pre-attentive stimuli come from the neuronal reaction + +to light, determining a map of potential interesting objects, or saliences. Then, attention + +concentrates on one single element, part of a limited taxonomic vocabulary of (2) analytical + +perceptions. Such perceptions go through a pattern-matching process that turns them into + +(3) abstract patterns. Finally, abstract patterns in working memory support cognition in + +combination with domain knowledge originated from long-term memory, leading to (4) decision + +support. Notice, in the figure, that the arrow in between each pair of the four constituents is + +bidirectional to indicate that the interplay occurs both bottom-up and top-down, notably in + +response to the task at hand. Also, notice that after cognition, there might be new information + +demands, what leads to the redefinition of the visualization by means of new parameters for + +interaction – as depicted in blue in Figure 3. Following, we present further details. + +8 + + Figure 3: The Visual Expression Process for Information Visualization specified with four +constituents. The black bidirectional arrows refer to bottom-up/top-down visual-cognitive pro- +cesses. In blue, new parameters of interaction alter the scene iteratively. + +4.1 Pre-attentive Stimuli - channels for data encoding + +Pre-attentive stimuli impel maps of saliences, as highlighted on the leftmost side of Figure 3. + +In the work of Rodrigues et al. (2008), the authors verified that such stimuli manifest through + +position, shape, color, and time. Here, we refer to these factors as channels for data encoding, + +in the sense that they encode data into visual stimuli. + +Although the consideration of four channels is a reductionist classification, it is supported + +by the literature. About color and texture, Watt (1995) affirms that, just like texture, color + +is the psychological response to the spectral characteristics of a surface; and that, different + +surfaces are perceived as having different colors. Furthermore, Motter (1994) observes that, + +early in visual processing, the incoming information is sorted and grouped according to the + +similarity of simple shape features, such as orientation or size, and of surface features, such as + +color, luminance, or texture. + +The features of each channel span to a large set, but Card et al. (1999) observe that just a + +limited number of the many existing graphical properties are used for Information Visualization. + +Healey & Enns (2012) present an extensive survey on pre-attentive features and visualization. + +A non-exhaustive list of such features is presented in Table 2. + +9 + + Table 2: Classes/channels of pre-attentive features from the perspective of data representation. +Pre-attentive +class +(data encoding channel) +Position +Shape + +Features + +1D/2D/3D position, stereoscopic depth; +line, area, volume, form, orientation, length, width, +collinearity, size, curvature, marks, numerosity, con- +vex/concave; +hue, saturation, brightness and texture; +movement, morphing, blinking, color/light intermit- +tence. + +Color +Time + +Discussion + +A well-designed visual representation must present a high overlap between its map of saliences + +and its (implicit) map of semantic relevance. That is, the design of visual representations is + +supposed to maximize pre-attentive effects. However, such maximization may not be possible + +without flexible human intervention over the channels of data encoding. In other words, inter- + +action, the active redefinition of the channels, is a mandatory need not fully explored in many + +designs. + +Liu et al. (2008) point out that many visualization systems are not sufficiently flexible to + +support user customization and appropriation. In fact, it is not difficult to find visualization + +tools that are limited in allowing the user to determine how to encode data. In these circum- + +stances, a user may ask “may I change the positioning order of the elements?”, “can I have + +each year represented with a different shape?”, “can I color the left group in red?”, or “can I + +see that animated?”. Each of these examples refers to a particular pre-attentive feature or, as + +we propose, to a data encoding channel. + +For instance, consider the seminal system GGobi (Cook & Swayne 2007), which introduced + +a large set of features if compared to its former version, system XGobi. Still, a brief analysis + +reveals that there is much to be improved: positioning of views is limited, except for Parallel + +Coordinates; shape is not an option for coding in the same way that color is; and animation + +is restricted to scatter plots through touring techniques. Those design issues contrast to what + +is observed in commercial systems like TIBCO’s Spotfire (http://spotfire.tibco.com/) and + +Google’s Gapminder (http://www.gapminder.org/), which present higher levels of freedom + +for each encoding channel, but that, still, do not achieve full appropriation of the scene the way + +we discuss. + +Accordingly, the design of visualizations must not only allow users to alter visual attributes, + +10 + + they must incorporate mechanisms to emphasize each channel. This is necessary because a given + +stimulus (position, shape, color, or time) may fail to capture attention when it is surrounded by + +other stimuli – this is called inattentional blindness. In such circumstance, this given stimulus + +fails in competing with other more interesting stimuli or, worse, it is ignored (Mack A 1998)(DJ + +2000). “Blindness” occurs especially when the viewer has some previous expectation on the + +scene; in such situations, top-down processes can strongly influence on what is noticed. This + +issue has been noticed by Patterson et al. (2014), who claim that the design of a visualization + +technique must provide means to capture attention alerting users of changes. + +Furthermore, according to the limitations of the memory system, as presented in Section 3.3, + +memory overloading is a problem that might constrain problem-solving. In fact, according to + +Wickens (2008), multiple tasks in one same cognitive dimension might decrease performance. + +One possibility to lessen this drawback is to selectively turn the visual channels on and off. + +For example, it is possible to conceive a dispersion plot in which size is simply turned off, + +so to temporarily avoid overlapping – see Figure 4 (b). Similarly, it is possible to turn off + +color, presenting all the information with black marks, emphasizing the role shape contours + +– Figure 4(c). It is also possible to include intermittence, or movement, much the way that + +cyclists do with lights in urban traffic. This way, specific graphical elements can start to blink + +– Figure 4(e). We conjecture that this kind of selective constraining of channels not only + +alters attention mechanisms, as there will be fewer candidates for attention, it also reduces the + +memory load, as there would be fewer targets. Furthermore, it has the potential of affecting top- + +down processes by de-emphasizing features that are expected by the user – and that prevent + +her/him from noticing unexpected traits due to “blindness”. + +In these cases, algorithms to + +assist visualizations may be helpful, as advocated by Chen (2006). Such algorithms might + +monitor statistical features or mine characteristics of interest to suggest new encodings “on the + +fly”, enabling more intense appropriation of the scene. However, not much research has been + +conducted on this issue, which has potential for further developments. + +4.2 Analytical Perceptions + +Data encoding channels provide maps of potential targets for attention. Now, following vision + +theory, the next mechanism is attentive selection – see Figure 3. Biased by user intention, a + +subset of the prominent entities in a visualization will reach working memory. Once selected, + +the chosen visual stimuli will be the basis of the analogies that lead to mental models, see + +Section 3.3. Here, one question comes up – what perceptions are produced by the targets of + +11 + + Figure 4: (a) Dispersion plot using channels of position, shape contour, shape size, and color. +(b) Shape size turned off. +(e) Time +(d) Shape contour turned off. +movement turned on for automatically detected outliers. (f) Shape size turned on. + +(c) Color turned off. + +attention in an information visualization design? + +To answer this question, we have extensively inspected the literature tracking the ways in + +which visual manifestation occurs when the intent is data analysis. We have found a limited set + +of possibilities, defining a visual taxonomic vocabulary whose elements appear recurrently. We + +refer to these elements analytical perceptions, depicted in the second part of Figure 3. In the + +realm of interaction, Yi et al. (2007) followed a similar procedure based on extensive literature + +inspection; they achieved results concerning the user intent, producing a limited set of recurrent + +possibilities. + +Analytical perceptions are the traits that any user attentively seeks for in a visual repre- + +sentation. Following the dual system theory presented in Section 3.3, such perceptions occur + +intuitively. Our investigation indicates that such elements include correspondence, differentia- + +tion, recognition, connectivity, arrangement, and variation in time. The most verified of these + +phenomena, correspondence and differentiation, are noted by Bertin (1977/1981) and by Card + +et al. (1999). The third analytical perception is presented by Mackinlay (1986) who states + +that the notion of relationship among graphical entities comes from the perception of connec- + +tivity. Meanwhile, arrangement arises from group positional configurations, largely studied by + +12 + + the Gestalt psychology (Koffka 1935) as observed, for example, in graph layouts (Dwyer et al. + +2009)(Tollis et al. 1998). Recognition, in turn, takes place as a resemblance to previous knowl- + +edge and/or expertise, a concept studied in psychological models and Information Visualization + +models. As Liu & Stasko (2010b) point out, the concept of internalization involves the encod- + +ing of perceived information into long-term memory (enduring information or pattern). Lastly, + +variation, manifests only along time – not necessarily for temporal data – and in combination + +to the other five perceptions. + +The notion of analytical perceptions becomes evident when they are not found and the + +pipeline outlined in Figure 3 is broken, preventing Visual Expression – if none of the aforemen- + +tioned perceptions occur, the user is unable to make sense. As depicted in our theorization, + +analytical perceptions occur after pre-attention (Section 4.1) and before abstract patterns (Sec- + +tion 4.3), independently of the data domain. Hence, they bridge vision and data interpretation. + +Specifically, we discuss the analytical perceptions and how they relate to the data encoding + +channels in the following. + +• correspondence: each position/shape/color has a direct correspondence to a referential + +map – discrete or continuous – that is part of the scene (explicit) or that is mental (im- + +plicit), defining analogical reasoning as explained in Section 3.3. Explicit maps include + +axes, geographical maps, shape/color dictionaries, and position/shape/color ranges. Im- + +plicit maps include known orderings and shape metaphors; + +• differentiation: each position/shape/color discriminates graphical items. Differentiation + +is a correspondence achieved by the user, who creates a referential map in memory. Such + +map is limited in the number of elements (or differentiations) according to the limitations + +of memory; + +• recognition: positions/shapes/colors whose decoding comes from the expertise of the user + +or from previous knowledge – recognition is a correspondence established from visual + +entities to concepts retained/learned in long-term memory; + +• connectivity: shapes, mainly edges, that convey information about relationships among + +entities in memory; + +• arrangement: Gestalt principles of organization – positional placements (closure, proxim- + +ity, and symmetry) that convey perception about group properties, for example, clusters + +and structural cues; + +13 + + • variation in time: obtained when the parameters of position/shape/color are altered along + +time, inducing new perceptions for each of these channels. + +Discussion + +Our set of analytical perceptions is not an exhaustive listing, but a first reference that suggests + +that visualization designs tend to resort to the same basic set. For instance, the design of + +Google’s Gapminder tool, although contemporaneous, reproduces the same dispersion plots of + +statistical books a hundred years old. Nevertheless, as observed by Liu et al. (2014), works on + +new designs and on the evaluation of existing ones have not considered that there is a limited + +set of elements to instantiate in data representations. This fact could fruitfully support the def- + +inition of design languages and frameworks, which would benefit from recurrent constructs that + +lead to a limited set of analytical perceptions. Differently, current languages and frameworks + +rely on graphical patterns and it is up to the user to build the desired analytical perception; + +see Table 3 for a representative set. + +Table 3: Previous works on languages and frameworks for visualization design. + +Work + +Protovis +(Bostock +& +Heer 2009)(Heer +& Bostock 2010) +D3 +(Bostock +et al. 2011) +Improvise +(Weaver 2004) +Prefuse +et al. 2005) +ggplot2 +(Wickham +2009) +Flexible Linked +Axes +(Claessen +& van Wijk +2011) +This work + +(Heer + +Approach + +Graphical + +Elements + +Marks, shapes and layout + +Visualization +pipeline +Link +coordinate +High-level API + +and + +Domain specific + +Selection, operation, join, layout and +transformation +Variable, function and view + +Filter, layout, interaction, color and +size +Layer, scale, coordinate system and +facet + +Linked axes + +Axes mapping, interaction, line and +point + +Visual-cognitive + +Pre-attentive encoding channels and +analytical perceptions + +By considering the concepts reviewed so far, it is possible to conceive a design language + +14 + + whose approach is based on cognition, and whose elements are interactive encoding channels, + +and analytical perceptions – refer to Table 3 for comparison. For example, in this design + +language, one would be able to state a visualization by choosing channel color and perception of + +differentiation. This same visualization would demand a few more elements, as channel position + +and perception of correspondence. As in any language, these elements would receive parameters + +according to an extensible library of data-to-marks mapping. + +In the case of relationships, + +one would be able to choose channel position with perception of arrangement, together with + +channel shape and perception of connectivity. Underlying algorithms would abstract undesired + +complexity, as an algorithm for outlier detection to support color differentiation; and a force- + +directed algorithm to support arrangement. As a design language, this approach would bring + +the benefit of discriminating the recurring elements of visualization techniques and having + +them in libraries for composition. This alternative approach contrasts with the usual practice + +of combining recurrent elements in ensembles assumed as new techniques. + +4.3 Abstract Patterns + +According to Hutchins (1996), tools – or externalizations (Hegarty 2004) – transform difficult + +tasks into in-mind manipulations of physical systems, or into pattern-matching problems (Giere + +2002). Pattern matching, or pattern-recognition (Patterson et al. 2014), the association of a + +given stimulus to information retrieved from memory (Eysenck & Keane 2003), is one of the + +principles of data visualization and the second step of the Visual Expression Process – see + +Figure 3. + +According to our organization, once a user focuses on an analytical perception, she/he + +proceeds to match this perception to an abstract pattern. Based on the theory of vision – seen + +in Section 3.3, the generation of patterns is supported by memory, which is filled with data + +from the visual-sensorial system or from long-term memory. The efficiency of this intercourse is + +explained by the fact that the visual-sensorial system provides spatial information to memory + +at rates higher than that of long-term memory (Ware 2004), in a time ranging from 100 to + +250 ms (Kieras & Meyer 1997). Hence, analytical perceptions in the visual-sensorial system + +work similarly to the images stored in long-term memory, providing efficient pattern-matching. + +According to the dual system theory, Section 3.3, this process is conscious and slow; but, + +with practice and experience, a given analyst can become a specialist. For specialists, pattern + +matching becomes intuitive (Evans 2008) – refer to the work of Patterson et al. (2010) for a + +thorough discussion. It is a straight conclusion, then, that a period of practice and experience + +15 + + is necessary for most visualization techniques, and that this is an obstacle for use. + +A suggestive set of the patterns – third part of Figure 3 – that arise from the perception-to- + +pattern matching, includes: correlation, tendency, classification, relationship, order, summa- + +rization, outlier, cluster, structure, and reading. Tufte (1997) and Amar et al. (2005) provide + +more exhaustive listings that follow different rationalizations. + +Discussion + +In our literature review, we noticed that many systems disregard the fact that visualization + +techniques converge through abstract patterns. According to current practices, instead of a + +set of familiar patterns, the user has to choose among a set of visualization designs that, + +quite often, they have little experience with (Chen 2005). Thomas & Cook (2005) reinforce + +this notion; they state that abstract patterns correspond to the second factor of their four- + +steps analytical-reasoning process. Following their process – a pattern-to-construct sequence, + +users have constraints in relation to what they can search for in face of a given pattern. For + +example, suspiciousness tends to appear by means of tracking for outliers; while evidence of + +illegal lobbying practices emerge from clusters; and community detection in graphs is a task for + +relationship. Still, users are often offered a menu whose options are, for instance, dimensional + +stacking (LeBlanc et al. 1990), star coordinates (Kandogan 2000), and table lens (Rao & Card + +1994); alternatives far from the pattern-to-construct task they have in their minds. A similar + +notion dates back to the 1990’s, in the work of Wehrend & Lewis (1990), who advocates in favor + +of more specific problem-oriented choices. We suspect that, because design-oriented interfaces + +neglect the more natural notion of abstract patterns, this is possibly one of the reasons why + +advanced visualization techniques have struggled to achieve a wider commercial dissemination, + +e.g, in office suites and in everyday spreadsheets. + +Take, for instance, the visualization technique Treemap (Shneiderman 1992), introduced + +for visualizing hierarchical data in general. + +In two decades, Treemap gained popularity at + +the academy, but, as a general hierarchical tool, it has failed in reaching a wider use. This is, + +possibly, because it has been criticized since its introduction (Barlow & Neville 2001, Cawthon & + +Moere 2007, Fabrikant & Skupin 2005), being accused of lacking cognitive plausibility, having + +poorly perceived aesthetic qualities, and presenting poor task-driven performance (Wood & + +Dykes 2008). Despite all, however, an especial design of the Treemap has remarkably succeeded. + +The SequoiaView system (www.win.tue.nl/sequoiaview) has achieved wide dissemination + +(check (van Wijk 2006) for some impressive numbers), far beyond the academic walls. But, + +16 + + how can we have two flavors of the same technique evolve in different ways? Certainly, not + +one single aspect explains everything, but an outstanding factor comes up: the SequoiaView + +is domain and pattern-oriented, it is distributed to visualize the structure and the sizes of the + +files in your hard-drive, specifically. In accordance, users do not have to discover that the tool + +is good at doing this; instead, when they have this specific problem at hand, they are guided + +to SequoiaView, a more natural process. + +In designing systems, an alternative course of action would be to initially present the user + +with a set of patterns to choose from. After that, she/he would be offered a set of visualization + +techniques that better suit the pattern they are seeking for. Users may know what to look for + +by means of previous knowledge of the data domain, by means of known problems to be solved, + +by means of suspicious clues perceived along the data usage, and also by means of previous + +visual exploration of the data. + +4.4 Cognitive Decision Support + +After producing patterns, vision is no longer an active agent, neither pre-attentively nor atten- + +tively. Now, the analysis follows the widely accepted pattern-then-cognition process (Margolis + +1990) (MacEachren 2004) to achieve decision support. Indeed, according to the analytical rea- + +soning of Thomas & Cook (2005), Information Visualization cannot ultimately provide decision + +support, which can only be achieved after interpreting the patterns in light of the data domain + +– rightmost side of Figure 3. That is, even though users can come up with patterns without + +considering the underlying data, these patterns are not of great use if the domain is not deeply + +understood. + +Insufficient domain knowledge leads to unsatisfied expectations in relation to InfoVis, cre- + +ating situations in which a user is presented to a supposedly insightful visualization but, then, + +everything one hears is “so what”? A disappointment that happens due to the enthusiasm + +according to which one can solve a wide range of problems just by looking at the data. How- + +ever, visualization tools can do little if the analyst is not well-prepared to assess what the data + +ultimately describes and potentially carries within. + +Discussion + +To prevent the aforementioned problems, InfoVis systems should define systematic means to + +aid the user in recording and accessing the domain knowledge related to the problems at hand. + +An interesting approach to overcome the gap of domain knowledge is to use annotations (or + +17 + + analytic provenance (Xu et al. 2015)), either automatic or manual. As pointed out by Hullman + +et al. (2011), annotations help to direct the user’s attention and foreground particular insights, + +supporting the most efficient inferences. The work of Hullman et al. (2013) exemplifies this + +issue. Their work focuses on stock-price time series, which are hard to understand if one is + +not aware of the facts that influenced the behavior of the market. Their system solves this + +problem by identifying news that happened contemporaneously to outstanding patterns found + +in the plots, presenting them on demand – illustrated in Figure 5. Similar approaches (Dennis + +et al. 2003, Conesa et al. 2005) have been proposed for genomic data, an extreme case in which + +domain knowledge is necessary, otherwise no reading of the data (either visual or textual) will + +make sense. + +Figure 5: Example of an annotated visualization produced with Contextifier – in the figure, +labels provide domain knowledge. Reproduced from the work of Hullman et al. (2011). + +An alternative is to use technique storytelling, as surveyed by Segel & Heer (2010). Plaisant + +(2005) defends that advanced interfaces need to address the long-term process of analysis that + +may require annotation, history keeping, collaboration with peers, and the dissemination of + +results and procedures used. Storytelling not only attacks the problem of lacking domain + +knowledge, it also provides knowledge about new findings in the form of further “story chapters” + +interactively created. The visual analysis, potentially, becomes an incremental set of insights + +from multiple experts in the form of bookmarks, keyword tags, text comments, and audio + +18 + + annotations. + +By bringing existing (factual) or produced (annotated) domain knowledge to the stage, + +abstract patterns can support reasoning by supporting conditional inferences (Johnson-Laird + +& Byrne 2002), possibly influenced by statistical regularities (Patterson et al. 2012). The + +result is the provision of inferences for decision making, notably, predictions, alternatives, and + +evaluations as depicted in Figure 3. + +4.5 Remarks + +In Sections 4.1 through 4.4, we have drawn conclusions by surveying accepted concepts of + +vision and cognition. Notwithstanding, we state these conclusions as conjectures with theo- + +retical evidence and with examples. This is because the validation of these hypotheses would + +encompass vast experimentation; producing material enough to spam a few papers or a book, + +to be conservative. Therefore, we leave our discussions both as contributions – to guide new + +systematizations; and, as future work – to drive further refinements and discoveries. + +Our conclusions also point to a challenging systematization. Rendering all the recommended + +aspects, together with multiple techniques and data domains, might involve a development ef- + +fort similar to that of huge software pieces, as office suites for instance. This is academically + +non-attractive, and economically risky. Possibly, the solution is to set a well-defined devel- + +opment framework for collaborative work, with ample acceptation, and standard interfacing. + +In the realm of machine learning, software Weka (Hall et al. 2009) has achieved great success + +in a similar endeavor. However, the graphical nature of InfoVis, and its data preprocessing + +techniques, imposes big challenges. + +5 Conclusions + +We reviewed concepts on vision, cognition, and Information Visualization by introducing the + +organizational theorization named Visual Expression Process, which proposes a course of action + +to explain visual data analysis. Over an extensive literature survey, the theorization provides + +comprehension and science for data graphical presentation. It proposes a new perspective to + +discuss and characterize techniques. From this perspective, for instance, it would be possible + +to “dissect” a given technique in terms of the channels, the analytical perceptions and the + +patterns that it supports, potentially revealing strengths and weaknesses. Our contributions + +are as follows: + +19 + + • Theoretical compendium: we plotted the Visual Expression Process to interrelate vision, + +cognition, and Information Visualization; + +• Discussions: we provided an extensive survey from different fields of science to serve as + +basis for relevant debate; + +• Reflections: we revisited design practices supported by examples and study cases. + +Overall, we have put together key concepts to introduce an insightful consideration of vi- + +sualizations. The reductionist perspective of our organization translates non-familiar concepts + +of vision and cognition into their corresponding effects with respect to design. + +In the form + +of a vocabulary taxonomically organized, we proposed a simplified comprehension of the fac- + +tors that define techniques and systems. With our contributions, we expect to foster a more + +comprehensive, accessible, and applied science of visualization. + +References + +Alvarez, G. A. & Cavanagh, P. (2004), ‘The capacity of visual short-term memory is set both + +by visual information load and by number of objects’, Psychological science 15(2), 106–111. + +Amar, R., Eagan, J. & Stasko, J. (2005), Low-level components of analytic activity in infor- + +mation visualization, in ‘Proceedings of the Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE Symposium on + +Information Visualization’, INFOVIS ’05, IEEE Computer Society, Washington, DC, USA, + +pp. 15–. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/INFOVIS.2005.24 + +Baddeley, A. & Hitch, G. (1974), ‘Working memory’, The psychology of learning and motivation: + +advances in research and theory 8, 47–89. + +Barlow, T. & Neville, P. (2001), A comparison of 2-d visualizations of hierarchies, in ‘Informa- + +tion Visualization, 2001. INFOVIS 2001. IEEE Symposium on’, pp. 131–138. + +Bertin, J. (1977/1981), Graphics and Graphic Information-Processing, Walter de Gruyter, + +Berlin. 273 pages. + +Bostock, M. & Heer, J. (2009), ‘Protovis: A graphical toolkit for visualization’, Visualization + +and Computer Graphics, IEEE Transactions on 15(6), 1121 –1128. + +20 + + Bostock, M., Ogievetsky, V. & Heer, J. (2011), ‘D3 data-driven documents’, IEEE Transactions + +on Visualization and Computer Graphics 17(12), 2301–2309. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TVCG.2011.185 + +Bugajska, M. (2003), Spatial Visualization of Abstract Information, PhD thesis, ETH Zurich. + +197 pp. + +Buttner, P. (2010), Hello java: Linking act-r 6 with a java simulation, in ‘Proceedings of the + +10th International Conference on Cognitive Modeling’, pp. 289–290. + +Card, S., Mackinlay, J. & Shneiderman, B. (1999), Readings in Information Visualization: + +Using Vision to Think, San Francisco, CA, EUA: Morgan Kaufmann. + +Cawthon, N. & Moere, A. (2007), The effect of aesthetic on the usability of data visualization, + +in ‘Information Visualization, 2007. IV ’07. 11th International Conference’, pp. 637–648. + +Cheal, M., Lyon, D. & Gottlob, L. (1994), ‘A framework for understanding the allocation of + +attention in location-precued discrimination’, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology: + +Human Experimental Psychology 47, 699–739. + +Chen, C. (2005), ‘Top 10 unsolved information visualization problems’, IEEE Computer Graph- + +ics and Applications 25(4), 12–16. + +Chen, C. (2006), Information Visualization: Beyond the Horizon, Springer Science. + +Chi, E. H. (2000), A taxonomy of visualization techniques using the data state reference model, + +in ‘IEEE Symposium on Information Visualization’, IEEE Computer Society Press, Salt Lake + +City, UT, USA, pp. 69–75. + +Claessen, J. & van Wijk, J. (2011), ‘Flexible linked axes for multivariate data visualization’, + +Visualization and Computer Graphics, IEEE Transactions on 17(12), 2310–2316. + +Cleveland, W. S. & McGill, R. (1984), ‘Graphical perception: Theory, experimentation and + +application to the development of graphical methods’, J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 79, 387 5, 531– + +554. + +Cohen, R. (1985), The Development of Spatial Cognition, Psychology Press. + +21 + + Conesa, A., Gotz, S., Garcia-Gomez, J. M., Terol, J., Talon, M. & Robles, M. (2005), ‘Blast2go: + +a universal tool for annotation, visualization and analysis in functional genomics research’, + +Bioinformatics 21(18), 3674–6. + +Cook, D. & Swayne, D. F. (2007), Interactive and Dynamic Graphics for Data Analysis, + +Springer-Verlag. + +Cowan, N. (2010), ‘The magical mystery four: How is working memory capacity limited, and + +why?’, Current directions in psychological science 19(1), 51–57. + +Cutzu, F. & Tsotsos, J. (2003), ‘The selective tuning model of attention: psychophysical evi- + +dence for a suppressive annulus around an attended item’, Vision Research 43, 205–219. + +Dennis, G., Sherman, B., Hosack, D., Yang, J., Gao, W., Lane, H. C. & Lempicki, R. (2003), + +‘DAVID: Database for Annotation, Visualization, and Integrated Discovery’, Genome Biology + +4(5), P3+. + +Dill, J., Earnshaw, R., Kasik, D., Vince, J. & Wong, P. (2012), Expanding the Frontiers of + +Visual Analytics and Visualization, Springer-Verlag. + +DJ, S. (2000), ‘Attentional capture and inattentional blindness’, Trends Cognitive Science + +4(4), 147155. + +Dwyer, T., Lee, B., Fisher, D., Quinn, K., Isenberg, P., Robertson, G. & North, C. (2009), + +‘A comparison of user-generated and automatic graph layouts’, Visualization and Computer + +Graphics, IEEE Transactions on 15(6), 961 –968. + +Eriksen, C. W. & Hoffman, J. E. (1973), ‘The extent of processing of noise elements during + +selective encoding from visual displays’, Perception and Psychophysics 14, 155–160. + +Essen, D. V., Anderson, C. & Fellowman, D. (1992), ‘Information processing in the primate + +visual system: An integrated systems perspective’, Science 255(5043), 419–422. + +Evans, J. S. B. T. (2008), ‘Dual-processing accounts of reasoning, judgment, and social cogni- + +tion’, Annual Review of Psychology 59(1), 255–278. + +Evans, J. S. B. T. & Stanovich, K. E. (2013), ‘Dual-process theories of higher cognition: Ad- + +vancing the debate’, Perspectives on Psychological Science 8(3), 223–241. + +URL: http://pps.sagepub.com/content/8/3/223.abstract + +22 + + Eysenck, M. W. & Keane, M. T. (2003), Cognitive Psychology: A Student’s Handbook, Taylor + +& Francis. + +Fabrikant, S. & Skupin, A. (2005), Cognitively plausible information visualization, in ‘Amster- + +dam’, Elsevier Science. + +Giere, R. N. (2002), Models as parts of distributed cognitive systems, in ‘Model-Based Reason- + +ing’, Springer US, pp. 227–241. + +Green, T. M., Ribarsky, W. & Fisher, B. (2009), ‘Building and applying a human cognition + +model for visual analytics’, Information Visualization 8(1), 1–13. + +Hall, M., Frank, E., Holmes, G., Pfahringer, B., Reutemann, P. & Witten, I. H. (2009), ‘The + +weka data mining software: An update’, SIGKDD Explor. Newsl. 11(1), 10–18. + +URL: http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/1656274.1656278 + +Healey, C. G. & Enns, J. T. (2012), ‘Attention and visual memory in visualization and computer + +graphics’, Visualization and Computer Graphics, IEEE Transactions on 18(7), 1170–1188. + +Heer, J. & Bostock, M. (2010), ‘Declarative language design for interactive visualization’, IEEE + +Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics 16, 1149–1156. + +Heer, J., Card, S. K. & Landay, J. A. (2005), Prefuse: A toolkit for interactive information + +visualization, in ‘Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing + +Systems’, CHI ’05, ACM, New York, NY, USA, pp. 421–430. + +URL: http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/1054972.1055031 + +Hegarty, M. (2004), Diagrams in the mind and in the world: Relations between internal and + +external visualizations, in ‘Diagrams’, pp. 1–13. + +Hegarty, M. (2011), ‘The cognitive science of visual-spatial displays: Implications for design’, + +Topics in Cognitive Science 3(3), 446–474. + +Hullman, J., Adar, E. & Shah, P. (2011), ‘Benefitting infovis with visual difficulties’, IEEE + +Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics 17(12), 2213–2222. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TVCG.2011.175 + +Hullman, J., Diakopoulos, N. & Adar, E. (2013), Contextifier: Automatic generation of anno- + +tated stock visualizations, in ‘Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in + +23 + + Computing Systems’, CHI ’13, ACM, New York, NY, USA, pp. 2707–2716. + +URL: http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/2470654.2481374 + +Hutchins, E. (1996), Cognition in the Wild, The MIT Press. + +Itti, L. & Koch, C. (2001), ‘Computational modeling of visual attention’, Nature Reviews + +Neuroscience 2(3), 194–203. + +Johnson, C., Moorhead, R., Munzner, T., Pfister, H., Rheingans, P. & Yoo, T. (2006), NIH/NSF + +Visualization Research Challenges, Los Alamitos, CA, EUA: IEEE Press. 36 pages. + +Johnson-Laird, P. N. (1983), Mental models: towards a cognitive science of language, inference, + +and consciousness, Harvard University Press. + +Johnson-Laird, P. N. (2010), ‘Mental models and human reasoning’, Proceedings of the National + +Academy of Sciences 107(43), 18243–18250. + +Johnson-Laird, P. N. & Byrne, R. M. (2002), ‘Conditionals: a theory of meaning, pragmatics, + +and inference.’, Psychological review 109(4), 646. + +Just, M. & Carpenter, P. (1992), ‘A capacity theory of comprehension: individual differences + +in working memory’, Psychological Review 99, 122–149. + +Kandogan, E. (2000), Star coordinates: A multi-dimensional visualization technique with uni- + +form treatment of dimensions, in ‘IEEE Symposium on Information Visualization’, IEEE + +Press, Salt Lake City, pp. 4–8. + +Keim, D. (2002), ‘Information visualization and visual data mining’, IEEE Trans. Visualization + +and Computer Graphics 8(1), 1–8. + +Kieras, D. & Meyer, D. (1997), ‘An overview of the epic architecture for cognition and perfor- + +mance with application to human-computer interaction’, HCI 12, 391–438. + +Koffka, K. (1935), Principles of Gestalt psychology, International library of psychology, philos- + +ophy and scientific method, New York : Harcourt, Brace and Company. + +LeBlanc, J., Ward, M. & Wittels, N. (1990), Exploring n-dimensional databases, in ‘Visu- + +alization, 1990. Visualization ’90., Proceedings of the First IEEE Conference on’, pp. 230 + +–237. + +24 + + Lippmann, R. P. (1987), ‘An introduction to computing with neural nets’, IEEE ASSP Maga- + +zine 4(2), 4–22. + +Liu, S., Cui, W., Wu, Y. & Liu, M. (2014), ‘A survey on information visualization: recent + +advances and challenges’, The Visual Computer 30(12), 1373–1393. + +Liu, Z., Nersessian, N. & Stasko, J. (2008), ‘Distributed cognition as a theoretical framework + +for information visualization’, Visualization and Computer Graphics, IEEE Transactions on + +14(6), 1173 –1180. + +Liu, Z. & Stasko, J. (2010a), ‘Mental models, visual reasoning and interaction in information + +visualization: A top-down perspective’, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer + +Graphics 16(6), 999–1008. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TVCG.2010.177 + +Liu, Z. & Stasko, J. (2010b), ‘Mental models, visual reasoning and interaction in informa- + +tion visualization: A top-down perspective’, Visualization and Computer Graphics, IEEE + +Transactions on 16(6), 999 –1008. + +Logie, R. H. (1995), Visual-spatial working memory, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. + +Lohse, G. L. (1993), ‘A cognitive model for understanding graphical perception’, Hum.-Comput. + +Interact. 8(4), 353–388. + +MacEachren, A. M. (2004), How Maps Work: Representation, Visualization, and Design, The + +Guilford Press. + +Mack A, R. I. (1998), ‘Inattentional blindness’, Psyche 5(3). + +Mackinlay, J. (1986), ‘Automating the design of graphical presentations of relational informa- + +tion’, ACM Transactions on Graphics 5(2), 110–141. + +Margolis, H. (1990), Patterns, Thinking, and Cognition: A Theory of Judgment, University Of + +Chicago Press. + +Miller, G. A. (1956), ‘The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our + +capacity for processing information’, Psychological Review 2(63), 34335. + +Motter, B. C. (1994), ‘Neural correlates of attentive selection for color or luminance in extras- + +triate area v4’, The Journal of Neuroscience 14(4), 2178–2189. + +25 + + Navalpakkam, V. & Itti, L. (2007), + +‘Search goal tunes visual features optimally’, Neuron + +53(4), 605–617. + +Nothdurft, H. (2000), ‘Salience from feature contrast: additivity across dimensions’, Vision + +Research 40(10-12), 1183–1201. + +Patterson, R. E. (2012), ‘Cognitive engineering, cognitive augmentation, and information dis- + +play’, Journal of the Society for Information Display 20(4), 208–213. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1889/JSID20.4.208 + +Patterson, R. E., Blaha, L. M., Grinstein, G. G., Liggett, K. K., Kaveney, D. E., Sheldon, + +K. C., Havig, P. R. & Moore, J. A. (2014), ‘A human cognition framework for information + +visualization’, Computers & Graphics 42(0), 42 – 58. + +URL: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0097849314000387 + +Patterson, R. E., Pierce, B., Bell, H. H., Andrews, D. & Winterbottom, M. (2009), ‘Train- + +ing robust decision making in immersive environments’, Cognitive Engineering and Decision + +Making 3(4), 331–361. + +Patterson, R. E., Pierce, B. J., Bell, H. H. & Klein, G. (2010), ‘Implicit learning, tacit knowl- + +edge, expertise development, and naturalistic decision making’, Journal of Cognitive Engi- + +neering and Decision Making 4(4), 289–303. + +Patterson, R. E., Pierce, B. J., Boydstun, A. S., Ramsey, L. M., Shannan, J., Tripp, L. & Bell, + +H. (2012), ‘Training intuitive decision making in a simulated real-world environment’, Human + +Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society p. 0018720812454432. + +Plaisant, C. (2005), Chapter 3 - information visualization and the challenge of universal usabil- + +ity, in ‘Exploring Geovisualization’, International Cartographic Association, Elsevier, Oxford, + +pp. 53 – 82. + +Rao, R. & Card, S. (1994), The table lens: Merging graphical and symbolic representation + +in an interactive focus+context visualization for tabular information, in ‘Human Factors in + +Computing Systems’, pp. 318–322. + +Rensink, R. A. (2000), ‘The dynamic representation of scenes’, Visual Cognition 7(1-3), 17–42. + +26 + + Rodrigues, J., Traina, A., Oliveira, M. & Traina, C. (2008), ‘The spatial/perceptual design + +space: a new comprehension for data visualization’, Palgrave Information Visualization + +6, 261–279. + +Rose, N. S., Myerson, J., Roediger III, H. L. & Hale, S. (2010), ‘Similarities and differences + +between working memory and long-term memory: evidence from the levels-of-processing span + +task.’, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 36(2), 471. + +Scaife, M. & Rogers, Y. (1996), ‘External cognition: how do graphical representations work?’, + +Int. J. Hum.-Comput. Stud. 45(2), 185–213. + +Segel, E. & Heer, J. (2010), ‘Narrative visualization: Telling stories with data’, IEEE Transac- + +tions on Visualization and Computer Graphics 16(6), 1139–1148. + +URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TVCG.2010.179 + +Shneiderman, B. (1992), ‘Tree visualization with treemaps: A 2d space-filling approach’, ACM + +Trans. on Graphics 11(1), 92–99. + +Shneiderman, B. (1996), The eyes have it: A task by data type taxonomy of information + +visualizations, in ‘IEEE Symp. Visual Languages’, IEEE CS Press, pp. 336–343. + +Squire, L. R. (2009), ‘Memory and brain systems: 1969–2009’, The Journal of Neuroscience + +29(41), 12711–12716. + +Thomas, J. & Cook, K., eds (2005), Illuminating the Path: The Research and Development + +Agenda for Visual Analytics, IEEE Press. + +Tollis, I. G., Di Battista, G., Eades, P. & Tamassia, R. (1998), Graph Drawing: Algorithms for + +the Visualization of Graphs, Prentice Hall. + +Triesman, A. (1985), ‘Preattentive processing in vision’, Computer Vision, Graphics and Image + +Processing 31, 156–177. + +Tsotsos, J. (1991), ‘Is complexity theory appropriate for analysing biological systems?’, Behav- + +ioral and Brain Sciences 14(4), 770–773. + +Tsotsos, J., Culhane, S., Wai, W., Lai, Y., Davis, N. & Nuflo, F. (1995), ‘Modeling visual + +attention via selective tuning’, Artificial Intelligence 78(1-2), 507–547. + +27 + + Tufte, E. R. (1997), Visual Explanations: Images and Quantities, Evidence and Narrative, + +Graphics Press. + +Tweedie, L. (1997), Characterizing interactive externalizations, in ‘ACM SIGCHI conference + +on Human factors in computing systems’, ACM Press, Atlanta, Georgia, USA, pp. 375–382. + +van Wijk, J. (2005), The value of visualization, in ‘Visualization, 2005. VIS 05. IEEE’, pp. 79– + +86. + +van Wijk, J. (2006), ‘Views on visualization’, Visualization and Computer Graphics, IEEE + +Transactions on 12(4), 1000 –433. + +Ware, C. (2004), Information Visualization: Perception for design, San Francisco, CA: Morgan + +Kaufman. 486 pages. + +Ware, C. (2005), Knowledge and Information Visualization: Searching for Synergies, Springer + +Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, chapter Visual Queries: The Foundation of Visual + +Thinking, pp. 27–35. + +Watt, R. J. (1995), Some speculations on the role of texture processing in visual perception, + +in ‘Early vision and beyond’, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA, + +pp. 59–67. + +Weaver, C. (2004), Building highly-coordinated visualizations in improvise, in ‘Information + +Visualization, 2004. INFOVIS 2004. IEEE Symposium on’, pp. 159–166. + +Wehrend, S. & Lewis, C. (1990), A problem-oriented classification of visualization techniques, + +in ‘Visualization, 1990. Visualization ’90., Proceedings of the First IEEE Conference on’, + +pp. 139–143, 469. + +Wickens, C. D. (2008), ‘Multiple resources and mental workload’, Human Factors: The Journal + +of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50(3), 449–455. + +URL: http://hfs.sagepub.com/content/50/3/449.abstract + +Wickham, H. (2009), ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis, Springer, New York. + +Wolfe, J. M. (1994), ‘Guided search 2.0 a revised model of visual search’, Psychonomic Bulletin + +& Review 1(2), 202–238. + +28 + + Wong, P. C., Shen, H.-W., Johnson, C., Chen, C. & Ross, R. B. (2012), ‘The top 10 challenges + +in extreme-scale visual analytics’, Computer Graphics and Applications, IEEE 32(4), 63–67. + +Wood, J. & Dykes, J. (2008), ‘Spatially ordered treemaps’, IEEE Transactions on Visualization + +and Computer Graphics 14(6), 1348–1355. + +Woodman, G. F., Carlisle, N. B. & Reinhart, R. M. (2013), ‘Where do we store the memory + +representations that guide attention?’, Journal of vision 13(3), 1. + +Xu, K., Attfield, S., Jankun-Kelly, T., Wheat, A., Nguyen, P. & Selvaraj, N. (2015), ‘Analytic + +provenance for sensemaking: A research agenda’, Computer Graphics and Applications, IEEE + +35(3), 56–64. + +Yi, J. S., ah Kang, Y., Stasko, J. T. & Jacko, J. A. (2007), ‘Toward a deeper understanding of + +the role of interaction in information visualization’, Visualization and Computer Graphics, + +IEEE Transactions on 13(6), 1224–1231. + +Young, R. M. & Lewis, R. L. (1999), The soar cognitive architecture and human working + +memory, in A. Miyake & P. Shah, eds, ‘Models of Working Memory: Mechanisms of Active + +Maintenance and Executive Control’, Cambridge University Press, pp. 224–256. + +29 diff --git a/q236/random_k4/random_4.md b/q236/random_k4/random_4.md index 89df54c010831780605bc9c91d547406d9ddb498..49a10f83bf172ba12f438f4cf5333a4440848722 100644 --- a/q236/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q236/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,1340 +1,183 @@ -Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 1 of 21 +Dishwasher +Use & Care Manual -Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) -twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com -Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) -rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com -Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) -tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com -Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) -abrown@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 -Burbank, CA 91505-4521 -Telephone: 310-474-9111 -Facsimile: 310-474-8585 + MODEL: WQP12-6502 + (FDWBI8067-24S) -Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class +Table of Contents -UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT +Important Safety Instructions-------------------------2 -NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA +Features of your new dishwasher -THOMAS THELE, individually and on -behalf of all others similarly situated, +----------------- - -Case No. 5:25-cv-09704 +3 4 -Plaintiff, +Operating Instructions-------------------------------- -5 8 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Preparing and loading dishes -DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL +--------------------- - -v. +9 13 -GOOGLE LLC, +Care & cleaning------------------ -Defendant. +-------------------- -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -- i - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 2 of 21 - -Plaintiff Thomas Thele (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly - -situated (the “Class” or “Class Members”), by and through his undersigned counsel, brings this - -class action complaint against Defendant Google LLC (“Google” or “Defendant”). - -I. - -INTRODUCTION - -1. - -Much like its competitors, Google has developed and deployed an artificial - -intelligence program named Gemini throughout its portfolio of services. Some of Google’s most - -popular services include Gmail, Chat, and Meet, which millions of Americans use every day to - -email, instant message, and videoconference, respectively. Until recently, Google users could “opt - -in” and turn on Gemini as a “Smart” feature for these services, purportedly to “personalize [their] - -experience”: - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -- 1 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 3 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -2. - -However, on or about October 10, 2025, Google secretly turned on Gemini for all - -its users’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, enabling AI to track its users’ private communications - -contained in those platforms without the users’ knowledge or consent. As of the date of this filing, - -Google continues to track these private communications with Gemini by default, requiring users to - -affirmatively find this data privacy setting and shut it off, despite never “agreeing” to such AI - -tracking in the first place (“When you turn this setting on, you agree . . . .”). - -3. - -Despite users never giving Google informed consent to track and store their private - -communications, Google does just that, using Gemini AI to access and exploit the entire recorded - -history of its users’ private communications, including literally every email and attachment sent - -and received in their Gmail accounts. - -4. - -Google’s deceptive and outrageous conduct violates its users’ reasonable - -expectations of privacy. The intent and efforts of individuals to safeguard their private information - -and communications must be respected. The ramifications of unauthorized access to voluminous - -private communications can be severe, and individuals accordingly go to great lengths to safeguard - -not only their own email and messaging accounts, but, in the case of parents and guardians, also - -that of their minor children. - -5. - -While falsely characterizing its illusory privacy controls, Google deceptively and - -unconscionably deprived and continues to deprive Plaintiff and Class Members of their privacy - -right to send and receive private communications via email, chat, and video. This is true not only - -for Plaintiff and Class Members, but also for their children, whose private communications they - -also sought to protect. - -6. - -Google’s conduct violates the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Pen. Code - -§§ 630, et seq. (“CIPA”)), the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (Cal. Pen. Code § - -502 (“CDAFA”)), the Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq. (“SCA”)), and - -California’s Constitutional Right to Privacy, and it constitutes an unlawful intrusion upon - -seclusion. - -II. - -THE PARTIES - -7. - -Plaintiff Thomas Thele resides in Cook County, Illinois. From at least October 10, - -- 2 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 4 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -2025 until the present, Plaintiff has maintained and used, and continues to maintain and use, his - -Google account, including the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services. Plaintiff values his privacy—and - -the privacy of his family and friends—in the use of these password-protected services and - -reasonably expected the messages and conversations therein to remain private. Despite this - -reasonable expectation, Google surreptitiously turned on the “Smart features” setting in Plaintiff’s - -Data privacy settings without Plaintiff’s knowledge or consent and began tracking Plaintiff’s - -private communications with Gemini AI. Throughout the relevant time period, Plaintiff regularly - -used his Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts throughout the day, unaware that Google’s Gemini AI - -was monitoring and tracking those private messages and conversations. In the interest of protecting - -his privacy and security, Plaintiff does not recite here the precise Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet - -communications that he sent or received with the “Smart features” setting surreptitiously turned on - -during the relevant time, but he does allege that the following could be determined from those - -communications: financial information and records, employment information and records, religious - -affiliations and activities, political affiliations and activities, medical care and records, the identities - -of his family, friends, and other contacts, social habits and activities, eating habits, shopping habits, - -exercise habits, the extent to which he is involved in the activities of his children (if any), and what - -those activities are. - -8. - -Defendant Google LLC is a limited liability company headquartered in Mountain - -View, California, and formed under the laws of Delaware. Google is a sophisticated mobile - -operating system, email, and applications developer in the business of commercializing personal - -data extracted from the use of tools and services connected to the internet. As such, Google is aware - -of and benefits from the conduct described herein. Indeed, this forms a core component, among - -others, of Google’s business model. - -III. - -JURISDICTION AND VENUE - -9. - -This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. - -§§ 1332 and 1367 because this is a class action in which the matter or controversy exceeds the sum - -of $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and in which some Members of the proposed Class - -are citizens of a state different from Defendant. - -- 3 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 5 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -10. - -This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant owns and - -operates a business that is headquartered in this District and conducts substantial business - -throughout California. Defendant expressly consents to the jurisdiction of the federal or state courts - -of Santa Clara County, California through its terms of service.1 - -11. - -Venue properly lies in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1), as Defendant - -is headquartered in this District. - -IV. CHOICE OF LAW - -12. - -California law governs the substantive legal issues in this case. Google’s Terms of - -Service provide in pertinent part that California law will apply to any disputes arising out of or - -relating to Google’s terms of service.2 - -V. - -STATEMENT OF FACTS - -13. - -According to recent reporting, an estimated 1.8 billion people globally in 2025 have - -active Gmail accounts.3 It is estimated that 41.9% of United States citizens use Gmail, which - -amounts to over 130 million American users.4 - -14. - -In Google’s Gmail, Chat, and Meet services, users reasonably expect to customize - -their use of these services to their preferences by managing various functionalities and settings. - -They can, for example, change their preferred language, time zone, or storage settings. Included - -among these functionalities, within “Data privacy,” is the option to turn on or off Google’s use of - -“Smart features”—that is, Google’s ability to track the user’s “email, chat, and video content” with - -its Gemini AI technology. In its terms of service, Google’s only reference to AI is in the context of - -“develop[ing], improv[ing], and updat[ing]” its services: - -We’re constantly developing new technologies and features to improve -our services. For example, we use artificial intelligence and machine -learning to provide you with simultaneous translations, and to better -detect and block spam and malware. As part of this continual - -1 Google Terms of Service (last modified May 22, 2024), available at -https://policies.google.com/terms?hl=en. -2 Id. -3 Robert A. Lee, Gmail Statistics 2025: User Growth, Market Share & Emerging Trends, SQ -MAGAZINE, Aug. 6, 2025, available at https://sqmagazine.co.uk/gmail-statistics/. -4 Id.; see also Dominic Reigns, 35+ Gmail Statistics And User Trends [2025 Updated], ABOUT -CHROMEBOOKS, Aug. 7, 2025, available at https://www.aboutchromebooks.com/gmail-statistics/. -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -- 4 - - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 6 of 21 - -improvement, we sometimes add or remove features and functionalities, -increase or decrease limits to our services, and start offering new -services or stop offering old ones.5 - -In its privacy policy, Google states that “across our services, you can adjust your privacy settings - -to control whether we collect some types of data and how we use it.”6 - -15. - -On information and belief, Google turned on this “Smart features” option—without - -any notice to users—for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts on or about October 10, 2025, which - -enabled Gemini AI to scan, read, and analyze every email (and email attachment), message, and - -conversation on those services. Google users now must proactively go into their account settings - -and locate and turn off this feature to prevent Gemini AI from tracking their Gmail, Chat, or Meet - -communications. Despite this setting being in default, “opt out” status since at least October 10, - -the setting is still worded as an “opt in” feature: “When you turn this setting on, you agree . . .” - -(emphasis added). Google’s secretive Gmail, Chat, and Meet tracking practices are not only - -deceptive and unethical, they are directly contrary to users’ reasonable expectations of privacy. - -16. - -It appears that even tech journalists monitoring Google’s use of Gemini AI in Gmail - -are not fully aware of this change. Recent articles about using Gemini in Google services like Gmail - -still characterize the feature as something that must be agreed to and affirmatively turned on.7 - -Nonetheless, this reporting confirms that, when active, Gemini is “downright creepy” in its ability - -to track, analyze, and immediately know private information: - -In testing [Gemini in Gmail], it was able to tell me useful information, -such as when my next Trade coffee delivery would arrive and if I had -any pressing emails that required responses. But it goes far beyond that. - -When I asked it about my first crush, Gemini was able to determine that -it occurred in elementary school, as well as tell me the name of my first -love, how we met, and when. Upon request, Gemini also told me who -my top Facebook friends were in 2009 and who my best friend was in -2010. Gemini even explained that one of my character flaws is that I get -“too laser-focused on what [I] want, which extracts a toll on [my] -relationships, much like Drake from the Uncharted game.” And, yes, - -5 Supra n.1. -6 Google Privacy Policy (last modified July 1, 2025), available at -https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US. -7 Ruben Circelli, I Let Gemini Access My Gmail, and It’s Downright Creepy, PC MAG, Nov. 5, -2025, available at https://www.pcmag.com/opinions/i-let-gemini-access-my-gmail-and-its- -downright-creepy. - -- 5 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 7 of 21 - -that’s one of my favorite game franchises, which apparently Gemini -knows, too. - -How does Gemini know that? The simple answer is that the information -is somewhere within the 16 years’ worth of my email history that it can -access. - -. . . . - -I don’t plan on letting Gemini access my personal email anymore.8 - -17. - -Google is now able to collect and utilize users’ private communications through AI - -“Smart features” and combine it with existing data profiles it has for its users. Back in 2012, Google - -announced that it would eliminate distinctions between data collected from different Google - -products and services for purposes of its advertising, data analysis, and other activities, saying - -specifically that Google “may combine information you’ve provided from one service with - -information from other services,” and “[w]e’ll treat you as a single user across all our products.”9 - -18. - -Through the use of its Gemini AI technology, Google has created the means to - -illicitly compile all of its users’ private communications on its platforms without those users’ - -express knowledge and consent. The data from these communications enables Google to cross- - -reference and conduct unlimited analysis toward unmerited, improper, and monetizable insights - -into users’ private lives, including their social, professional, and other relationships. - -19. - -The collection and use of users’ private communications violates users’ reasonable - -expectations of privacy, and also puts them at increased risk for further privacy violations. Data - -breaches and other security vulnerabilities are increasingly common among companies that store - -user data. As a major aggregator of valuable personally identifying and other information, Google - -is an obvious target for hackers. Any information that Google stores through its Gemini AI platform - -may eventually be stolen, if it has not already been. In 2018, for example, Google announced that - -it had discovered a vulnerability in its Google+ program that exposed personal account information - -to third-parties, contrary to its user agreements and representations. Reportedly, in order to protect - -8 Id. -9 Alma Whitten, Updating our privacy policies and terms of service, GOOGLE OFFICIAL BLOG -(Jan. 24, 2012), available at https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/updating-our-privacy- -policies-and-terms.html. - -- 6 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 8 of 21 - -its public image, Google failed to disclose that information to the public for months, and came clean - -only after the security risk was discovered by the media.10 - -20. - -Each of the following acts defy social norms and invade reasonable privacy - -expectations: tracking private communications contrary to users’ consent, misleading users - -regarding whether the AI tracking required the users to opt out, and failing to disclose how AI was - -monitoring, tracking, and utilizing these private communications. Normally, mobile device and - -Internet users such as Plaintiff are able to affirmatively control the flow of sensitive information - -about themselves through “settings” and “permissions” that they grant, or withhold, from third - -parties, particularly private parties such as Google. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ expectations - -that those settings and permissions would be heeded and effective, and that they could send and - -receive communications privately without being tracked by Google, are eminently reasonable. - -21. - -Plaintiff and Class Members took specific steps to protect their private - -communications (as well as the private communications of their minor children) and had a - -reasonable expectation that Google would not use AI to monitor and track their private - -communications without their informed consent. Based on Google’s representations and omissions, - -context, and industry norms, they expected Google to heed and follow their instructions and, as a - -result, expected that their private communications would be private, not tracked and utilized by - -Google’s AI tool for Google’s own benefit and to the detriment of their personal privacy. Those - -reasonable expectations were consistent with sentiments that are widely shared in American society - -and elsewhere, and grounded in long-standing social norms and jurisprudence protecting privacy. - -22. - -Invasion of privacy has been recognized as a common law tort for more than a - -century. In Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965), the Supreme Court confirmed the - -primacy of privacy rights, explaining that the Constitution operates in the shadow of a “right of - -10 Douglas MacMillan and Robert McMillan, Google Exposed User Data, Feared Repercussions -of Disclosing to Public, THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (Oct. 8, 2018), available at -https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared-repercussions-of-disclosing-to- -public-1539017194. Shortly thereafter, Google shut down the Google+ product entirely. Bill -Chappell, Google Accelerates Google+ Shutdown After 52.5 Million Users’ Data Exposed, NPR -(Dec. 11, 2018), available at https://www.npr.org/2018/12/11/675529798/with-52-5-million- -users-data-exposed-on-google-google-quickens-shutdown. - -- 7 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 9 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -privacy older than the Bill of Rights.” For its part, California amended its constitution in 1972 to - -specifically enumerate a right to privacy in its very first section. See Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1. - -23. - -Google itself has long acknowledged the importance of user control over privacy - -settings. In 2018, Google’s Chief Privacy Officer testified to United States Senate Committee on - -Commerce, Science, and Transportation that “users trust [Google] to keep their personal - -information confidential and under their control.”11 - -24. - -According to a poll by the Pew Research Center, 93% of adults believe that being - -in control of who can get information about them is important, and 90% believe that controlling - -what information is collected about them is important.12 Additionally, Americans say they do not - -approve of observation without consent: 88% say it is important that they not have someone watch - -or listen to them without their permission.13 - -25. - -According to a 2013 Pew Research study, “86% of Internet users have tried to be - -anonymous online and taken at least one step to try to mask their behavior or avoid being tracked.”14 - -For example, 64% percent of adults claim to clear their cookies and browser histories in an attempt - -to be less visible online. 15 Such behaviors exemplify people’s expectation that their personal - -information will not be tracked by others without their consent or permission, and that settings - -claiming to allow them to protect such information will be effective. - -26. - -A 2010 study comparing the opinions of young adults between the ages of 18 to 24 - -with other age categories (25-34, 35-44, 45-54, 55-64, and 65+) found that a large percentage of - -young adults were in harmony with older Americans regarding concerns about online privacy, - -11 Written Testimony of Keith Enright Chief Privacy Officer, United States Senate Committee on -Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Examining Safeguards for Consumer Data Privacy, -(Sept. 26, 2018), available at https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/17926-keith-enright-chief- -privacy-officer-google (emphasis added). -12 Mary Madden and Lee Rainie, Americans’ Attitudes About Privacy, Security and Surveillance, -PEW RESEARCH CENTER (May 20, 2015), available at -https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2015/05/20/americans-attitudes-about-privacy-security- -and-surveillance/. -13 Id. -14 Lee Rainie, et al., Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online, PEW RESEARCH CENTER (Sept. 5, -2013) available at https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2013/09/05/anonymity-privacy-and- -security-online/. -15 Id. - -- 8 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 10 of 21 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 +-14 16 -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -norms, and policy suggestions.16 For example, 88% of young adults surveyed responded that “there - -should be a law that requires websites and advertising companies to delete all stored information - -about an individual”; for individuals in the 45-54 age range, 94% approved of such a law.17 - -27. - -The same study noted that “[o]ne way to judge a person’s concern about privacy - -laws is to ask about the penalties that companies or individuals should pay for breaching them.” A - -majority of the 18- to 24-year-olds polled selected the highest dollar amount of punishment (“more - -than $2,500”) in response to how a company should be fined if it purchases or uses someone’s - -personal information illegally; across all age groups, 69% of individuals opted for the highest fine. - -Beyond a fine, approximately half of the sample (across all age groups) chose the harshest penalties - -for companies using a person’s information illegally: putting them out of business and imposing - -jail time.18 - -28. - -Google claimed to offer people a choice when it came to data privacy. In purporting - -to offer users the ability to adjust data privacy settings to control whether Google’s AI technology - -accesses their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, Google warranted that it would respect those users’ - -privacy choices. In reality, Google rendered users’ choices meaningless when it surreptitiously - -turned on the “Smart features” setting for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet users without their knowledge - -or consent. Google’s AI tracking of users’ private communications was surreptitious and purposely - -deceptive, as they did not provide notification of this change, thus requiring users to discover this - -change on their own and manually turn off the “Smart features” setting. - -29. - -Not only were Google’s representations about privacy likely to deceive people, - -Google did in fact deceive the millions of people who use Gmail, Chat, and Meet. Ordinary users, - -including Plaintiff, reasonably expected that their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts would not be - -tracked and stored by AI unless they affirmatively turned on that feature in their Google accounts. - -16 Chris Hoofnagle, et al., How Different Are Young Adults from Older Adults When It Comes to -Information Privacy Attitudes & Policies, University of Pennsylvania Scholarly Commons (April -14, 2010), available at -https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/privacy-roundtables- -comment-project-no.p095416-544506-00125/544506-00125.pdf. -17 Id. -18 Id. - -- 9 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 11 of 21 - -30. - -Google’s misrepresentations continue, despite public reporting. Users are still being - -deceived and tracked without consent unless they are made aware of the change to their data privacy - -settings and affirmatively turn off the “Smart features” setting, which is still worded in terms that - -deceptively suggest it is something that must be agreed to and turned on by the user, not Google. - -VI. CLASS ALLEGATIONS - -31. - -Plaintiff brings this class action, pursuant to Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil - -Procedure, individually and on behalf of all members of the following class, which is referred to - -throughout this Complaint as the “Class”: - -All natural persons residing in the United States with Google -accounts whose private communications in Gmail, Chat, and/or -Meet were tracked by Google’s Gemini AI after Google turned on -“Smart features” in those persons’ data privacy account settings. - -32. - -Excluded from each Class are the following individuals: officers and directors of +Troubleshooting------------------------------------- -Google and its parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, any entity in which Google has a controlling interest, - -and all judges assigned to hear any aspect of this litigation, as well as their immediate family - -members. - -33. - -Plaintiff reserves the right to modify or amend the Class definition before the Court - -determines whether certification is appropriate. - -34. - -This action readily satisfies the requirements set forth under Federal Rule of Civil - -Procedure 23: - -a. - -Each Class is so numerous that joinder of all Members is impracticable. - -Upon information and belief, Class Members number in the millions. - -b. - -There are questions of law or fact common to the Class. These questions - -include, but are not limited to, the following: - -i. - -Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording device to eavesdrop upon or record” - -confidential communications in violation of CIPA; - -- 10 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +-17 18 1 -2 + d + +- + +type + + injury. + +Read all instructions before using the dishwasher. +The manual does not cover every possible +condition and situation that may occur . +Use the dishwasher only for intended function as +described in this manual. +When loading items to be washed: +-Load sharp items and knives so that they are not +likely to damage the door seal and tub. +-Load sharp items and knives with the handles up to +reduce the risk of cut +Do not wash plastic items unless marked +ishwasher safe or the equivalent, if not marked, +check with manufacture for recommendation, items +that are not dishwasher safe may melt and create a +potential fire hazard. +If the dishwasher drains into a food disposer, + disposer is completely empty before +make +sure + . +running dishwasher +Do not tamper with control. +Do not operate your dishwasher unless all +enclosure panels are in the properly place. +Do not touch the heating element during or +, +immediately after use especially if +has been selected. + + the sanitize option -3 +2 -4 +. -5 +. -6 +. -7 + gas is -8 + using -9 + gas may be -10 + hot water system has not been used +, + on all + a period before -11 +Do not let children abuse sit, or stand on door or +racks of a dishwasher. +, +Under certain conditions hydrogen +produced in a hot water system that has not been +used for two weeks or more Hydrogen +explosive If the +for such +hot water faucets and let water flow from each for +several minutes. This will release any accumulated + gas is flammable. Do not +hydrogen gas Hydrogen +smoke or use an open flame during this time. +Do not store or use combustible materials, gasoline +or other flammable vapors and liquids in the vicinity +of this or any other appliance. +Use only detergents or rinse agents recommended +for use in a dishwasher and keep them out of the +reach of children. +Keep young children and infants away from +dishwasher when it is operating. +Do not use the dishwasher if it has a damaged +power line or plug, and do not plug the dishwasher +into a damaged outlet, failure to observe these +instructions may result in electrical shock. +Remove the door to the washing compartment when +removing an old dishwasher from service or discarding +it. -12 +Important safety instruction -13 +WARNING -14 +For your safety, the information in this manual must be followed to +minimize the risk of fire or explosion, electric shock, and to prevent +property damage, personal injury. -15 +Proper installation -16 +Please install your dishwasher properly follow the installation guide. -17 +Water supply temperature should be 120℉ or 149 .℉ +Dispose of the discarded appliance and packing material properly. +The dishwasher must be grounded, or it can result in a risk of electric shock. +If there is any damage of the +repair or replace any part by yourself. -18 + contact to your -19 + to attempt to -20 +Basic precaution before use -21 + Features of your new dishwasher -22 +Specification -23 +Capacity -24 +Dimension -25 +Weight -26 +14 place settings -27 +606 x 650 x 857 mm (W x D x H) -28 +unpacked 94lb (42.5 kg) - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 12 of 21 +Power Supply -1 +120volts -2 +, -3 +60Hz -4 +Rated power usage -5 +Wash motor 50W Heater -6 + 840W -7 +Water Feed Pressure -8 +20 ~ 120 psi (138 ~ 828kPa) 9 @@ -1344,109 +187,6 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 12 -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -ii. - -Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to “tampering, interference, damage, and unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data - -and computer systems” in violation of CDAFA; - -iii. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to “intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic - -communication service is provided” in violation of the SCA; - -iv. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount - -to egregious breaches of social norms; - -v. - -Whether Google acted intentionally in violating Plaintiff’s and Class - -Members’ privacy rights; - -vi. Whether an injunction should issue; and - -vii. Whether declaratory relief should be granted. - -c. - -Plaintiff’s claims are typical of the claims of the Class. Plaintiff and Class - -Members maintained private, password-protected Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts that they - -thought were secure and not being tracked by Google. Despite these efforts and contrary to - -Google’s representations, Plaintiff and Class Members nonetheless had their Gmail, Chat, and/or - -Meet accounts tracked by Google’s AI technology. Plaintiff and Class Members did not consent to - -Google’s tracking of their private communications, which forms the basis for this suit. - -d. - -Moreover, like all Class Members, Plaintiff suffered a substantial risk of - -repeated injury in the future. Plaintiff continues to use the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services that - -are capable of being tracked by Google’s Gemini AI, and Google may unilaterally change his - -privacy settings again in the future. Google has shown deliberate indifference to Plaintiff’s and - -Class Members’ desire to keep their communications private, and has indeed taken pains to deceive - -and mislead Plaintiff (and all Class Members) and to conduct its business contrary to their privacy - -rights, and contrary to the plain meaning of its own terms of service in favor of surreptitiously and - -deceitfully monitoring their private communications. Google’s deceptive and deliberate actions - -have thwarted and continue to threaten Plaintiff’s (and Class Members’) ability to exercise control - -over their own privacy while using their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. Because the conduct - -- 11 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 13 of 21 - 1 2 @@ -1463,118 +203,6 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 8 -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -complained of herein is systemic, Plaintiff and Class Members face substantial risk of the same - -injury in the future. Google’s conduct is common to all Class Members and represents a common - -pattern of conduct resulting in injury to all Class Members. Plaintiff has suffered the harm alleged - -and has no interests antagonistic to any other Class member. - -e. - -Plaintiff will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the Class. - -Plaintiff’s interests do not conflict with the interests of the Class Members. Furthermore, Plaintiff - -has retained competent counsel experienced in class action litigation, consumer protection - -litigation, and electronic privacy litigation. Plaintiff’s counsel will fairly and adequately protect and - -represent the interests of the Class. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)(4) and 23(g) are satisfied. - -f. - -In acting as alleged above, and in failing and refusing to cease and desist - -despite being exposed, Google has acted on grounds generally applicable to the entire Class, - -thereby making final injunctive relief and corresponding declaratory relief each appropriate with - -respect to the Class as a whole. The prosecution of separate actions by individual Class Members - -would create the risk of inconsistent or varying adjudications with respect to individual Class - -Members that would establish incompatible standards of conduct for Google. - -g. - -Injunctive relief is necessary to prevent further unlawful and unfair conduct - -by Google. Money damages, alone, could not afford adequate and complete relief, and injunctive - -relief is necessary to restrain Google from continuing to commit its illegal and unfair violations of - -privacy. - -VII. CAUSES OF ACTION - - Count One -(Violations of CIPA, Cal. Pen. Code §§ 630, et seq.) - -35. - -36. - -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. - -Cal. Pen. Code § 630 provides that “[t]he Legislature hereby declares that advances - -in science and technology have led to the development of new devices and techniques for the - -purpose of eavesdropping upon private communication and that the invasion of privacy resulting - -from the continual and increasing use of such devices and techniques has created a serious threat - -to the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot be tolerated in a free and civilized society.” - -- 12 - - -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 14 of 21 - 1 2 @@ -1587,132 +215,169 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 6 -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 +Top Spray Arm -15 +Cup Shelf -16 +Upper Spray Arm -17 +Lower Spray Arm -18 +Bottom Rack -19 +Heating Element -20 +7 -21 +8 -22 +9 -23 +10 -24 +11 -25 +Rinse Aid Dispenser -26 +Detergen t Dispenser -27 +Tub Gasket -28 +Top Rack -37. +Adjustable Upper Rack -Google’s acts and practices complained of herein, engaged in for purposes of +12 -tracking and storing indefinitely the private communications of its users without their consent— +Silverware Basket -and indeed in direct contravention of Google’s own wording of the “Smart features” setting that +3 -suggests it must be turned on to “opt in,” when, in reality, Google has already secretly turned it on + Features of your new dishwasher -and requires users to find the setting and turn it off to “opt out”—violated and continues to violate +Features -Cal. Pen. Code § 632. +Filter System + the +Your dishwasher has a multiple Filter + .It can separate +- +System there are four filter meshes +soiled water and clean water in different chambers. +The multiple filter system helps your dishwasher to get +better performance with less water and less energy . -38. +Adjustable Upper Rack +The Upper Rack can be raised or lowered to +accommodate loading taller dishes in either rack +The +Upper Rack clearance height H1 goes from 8" to 10". +The Bottom Rack clearance height H2 is 11" to 13". -Cal. Pen. Code § 632 prohibits the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording +. -device to eavesdrop upon or record [a] confidential communication, whether the communication is + a -carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, +Smart Wash System +Your dishwasher has Smart Wash System. +partial load of lightly soiled dishes is placed in the +unit, a wash cycle similar to a short wash will +automatically be performed. When a full load of +heavily soiled dishes is placed in the unit, a heavy +wash cycle will automatically be performed. can +determine the type of cycle required to clean the +dishes and will clean more efficiently every time. -or other device . . . .” +it -39. +4 -In direct violation of this prohibition and without the consent of Plaintiff or Class + How your -Members, Google has been using its Gemini AI technology to eavesdrop and record the confidential + dishwasher cleans -communications of Plaintiff and Class Members on their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. +Getting Started -40. +Your dishwasher cleans by spraying a mixture of +hot water and detergent through the spray arms +. +against soiled surfaces -Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private + pumped through the multiple -communications from California. On information and belief, Google uses servers located in +1. Load dishwasher (See preparing and loading -California that allow Google to access private communications of Plaintiff and Class Members. +dishes). -Google’s terms of service indicate that California law controls the use of its services. +2. Add detergent (See Fill detergent to the dispenser). +3. Add rinse aid, if needed (See Fill rinse to -41. +dispenser). -As a result of Google’s violations of Cal. Pen. Code § 632, Plaintiff and Class +4. Close door to latch. +5. Select desired CYCLE (See Cycle Chart). The +indicator light above the pad will glow when +selected. -Members are entitled to the following relief: +6. Select desired OPTIONS (See Energy Options). +The indicator light above the pad will glow when +selected. -a. +7. Run hot water faucet nearest dishwasher until water -b. +is hot -c. +. Turn water off. -A declaration that Google’s conduct violates CIPA; +8. To start, press -Statutory damages and/or trebled actual damages; + pad. -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from +Your dishwasher has the front control panel. +Your selections will only beactivated when + the door is firmly closed. -continuing to access Class Members’ private communications in violation of CIPA; +NOTE +The dishwasher is programmed to +remember your last cycle so you do not +have to reset each +dishwasher using the same cycle and +options selected on the previous wash just +press the Start Cancel -d. + start the -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order requiring Google to + pad. -destroy all data created or otherwise obtained from its illegal tracking of Class Members’ private +, -communications; and +/ -e. + water is necessary to activate -An award of attorney’s fees and costs of litigation as provided by CIPA, the +Wash Cycle Selections +Cycle times are approximate and will vary with +options +dishwasher detergent and melt fatty food soils. +An automatic sensor will check the incoming water + timer will +temperature and if it is not hot +be delayed for automatic water heating in the main + happens even when +wash of all + WASH is selected an even higher +HI TEMP +temperature will be guaranteed to handle heavier soil +loads. -private attorney general doctrine existing at common law and also codified at California Civil Code +- -- 13 - +5 -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + C - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 15 of 21 +ntrol panel +ontrol panel 1 @@ -1730,9 +395,7 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 8 -9 - -10 +9 10 11 @@ -1740,139 +403,183 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 13 -14 +Wash Cycle Selections -15 +9 -16 +Child lock -17 +1 -18 + & -19 +Pots -20 +PANS +This cycle is for hard to clean heavily +dishes, -21 +, + and dishes. -22 +- - -23 + soiled -24 +2 Normal wash -25 +This cycle is for regularly soiled dinner dishes or +silverware. +China crystal +This cycle is for lightly soiled china and crystal. -26 +3 -27 +4 Quick wash -28 +5 -Section 1021.5, and all other applicable laws. +- -Count Two -(Intrusion Upon Seclusion) +- -42. +This cycle is for lightly soiled and pre rinsed +dishes and silverware. +Rinse only + dishes or glasses. +This cycle is for pre rinsing +This is only a rinse that keeps food from drying +on your dishes and reduces odor buildup in your +dishwasher until you are ready to wash a full +load. Do not use detergent. +ENERGY SAVER +For light solied or pre-rinsed dishes and -43. +6 -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. +. -Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, +Functions -Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications +7 -contained in these accounts. +Air exchange +Select the “Air exchange function, the +dishwasher will exchange the air every 6 +hours to keep the air in the dishwasher fresh. -44. +8 -The reasonableness of such expectations of privacy is supported by Google’s unique +Steam wash +For use with -position to monitor Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private communications through its access to + heavily soiled items, this STEAM -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. It is further supported by the +option adds 30 minutes t -surreptitious nature of Google’s tracking. +o the cycle -45. + time. -Defendant intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ +The option is available with the cycles of “POTS & -solitude, seclusion, or private affairs by intentionally using AI to track their private + PANS” and “Normal wash”. -communications. +6 -46. +You can lock all controls to prevent children from +accidently changing the dishwasher cycle or +starting the dishwasher. +Press the “Steam wash” and the “Vortex wash” +simultaneity to select or cancel the function. +After the function is selected and the corresponding +indicator light will turn on. -These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications +10 -sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information +Votex wash -and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. +Use this option when you want to wash pots and +, +pans -Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff +durable serving bowls -and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact +and other large -that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the +, -consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. +, -47. +, -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs +hard to clean dishes -as detailed throughout this Complaint. +very dirty + Touse use Vortex wash, place the dishes face down + in the lower rack directly above the vortex wash arm -48. +. -Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in + in the back left corner. -causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. +11 Heated Dry +When the” Heated Dry” function is selected, the +heater will work during the drying process. -49. +12 -As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and +Sanitize -punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive +Sanitize -damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were +the “Sanitize” function -- 14 - +To sanitize your dishes and +the +is selected, the temperature of water will be +℃ ℉ +maintained at + (158 +Note: It is possible that +70 +not be reached, if the temperature of the incoming +hot water dose not reach the suggested temperature. -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +) max. +℃ + (158 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 16 of 21 +) may -1 + ℉ -2 +70 -3 +13 -4 +Hi Temp -5 +Wash +When the “Hi Temp wash” function is selected, +the temperature of water will be maintained at +60 -6 +) max. -7 + (140 -8 + ℉ -9 +℃ -10 + Operating dishwasher -11 +17 -12 +18 -13 +19 14 @@ -1880,767 +587,1176 @@ CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT 16 -17 +/ +16 Start Cancel +This information covers several different models. +Your dishwasher may not have all the cycles and +options described. +This built-in dishwasher’s function control and +cycle selections will be void when dishwasher +door is firmly closed. When setting up the +dishwasher, please keep the dishwasher door +open and select the wash cycle and options +desired. The indicator light above the pad will +turn on. To start, press the Start/Cancel key +once and close the door firmly within 4 seconds +after you select start. The indicator light will +flickering and the wash cycle will begin after the +door is closed. To cancel wash cycle once the +dishwasher is running, carefully open the door +slowly to access the controls and avoid water +spill. Long press Start/Cancel for 8 second, the +dishwasher will start a 60 second draining +process to prevent water and moister trap inside +the dishwasher. The dishwasher will be power +off automatically when draining process is +completed. You may then open the unit and/or +start a new cycle. +When opening the door, use caution as there is +a possibility of injury from hot steam coming out +from the unit. If the door is opened while the +dishwasher is running, a safety switch will stop +the cycle. +You may add more dishes before the main wash +starts. + +Cycle progress indicator -18 +14 -19 +Delay + + Delay +To delay the start of a selected +Start pad until the desired delay time shows in the +it allows you to automatically +LED display screen, +start your dishwasher for 1 to 24 hours delay +. +To cancel the Delay Start option and begin the +cycle, before the delay period is over press + the +/ +Start Cancel +15 Display window +To display the remained hours and minutes of the +running cycle, delay hours and error codes etc. +17 Rinse aid indicator light +Turns on when the dishwasher needs to add Rinse aid. + + pad. + +18 Sanitized indicator light +If a cycle with the sanitize function is finished, +the sanitized indicator light turns on. +If you open the door, it will turn off after 30 seconds. +18 Clean indicator light +Turns on after a cycle finished. +If you open the door, it will turn off after 30 seconds. + + Located on ride side of the front of the dishwasher, these lights indicate how far along is the current wash cycle while +the dishwasher is running. -20 +1 -21 +2 -22 +3 -23 +1 -24 +WASH -25 +2 -26 +DRY -27 +3 -28 +CLEAN -calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and +When the dishwasher is in a wash or rinse portion of a cycle the Wash lights are +illuminated. +When the dishwasher is in a drying portion of a cycle the Wash and Dry lights are +illuminated. +After the dishwasher has completed all portions of a cycle all indicator lights are +illuminated. +If you open the door when the Cleaning lights are illuminated, all the portion lights +will turn off after 30seconds. -Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in +, -future misconduct. +, -Count Three -(California Constitutional Right to Privacy, Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1) +, -50. +7 -51. + Operating dishwasher -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. +Status Window -Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail, +01 24- +If the Delay Start option is sel -Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications + hours shows in the Status -contained in these accounts. + of + the -52. + of hours and minutes left shows -Google intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ solitude, +dishwasher is working and the wash cycle time is more +than a +alternately in the Status Window. +CL +Flashes once the program has been entered and the -seclusion, right of privacy, or private affairs by intentionally tracking the private communications. +NOTE +The time remaining could suddenly increase +. +or drop several minutes This +Smart Sensor has checked the soil level and +determined if additional water fills are needed +or if water fills can be deleted. -53. + means the -These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications +Error indication -sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information + key is -and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization. + also flashes if the door is + the dishwasher -Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff +opened during a wash +door to begin or continue a wash cycle. +MINUTES +Number of minutes left in a cycle +It shows hours and minutes alternately. -and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact + or -that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the +In certain situations which are critical to the +machines function and safe operation, the +control shall shut down and indicate an error +code Er (See Error Codes on page 18). +If Er codes are -consent of Plaintiff and Class Members. + the dealer or + will be able to provide assistance + the problem and or locate an -54. +in +authorized service technician if needed. -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs +Cycle Chart -as detailed throughout this Complaint. +Program -55. +Description of Cycle -Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in +Water(L) -causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members. +Cycle time(min) -56. +POTS & PANS -As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and +Pre Wash -punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive +Pre Wash -damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were +Wash(48°C) -calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and +Rinse -Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in +Rinse -future misconduct. +Rinse(58°C) -- 15 - +Drying +Pre Wash -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +22.8 - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 17 of 21 +140 -1 +NORMAL WASH -2 +Auto(42~48°C) -3 +Rinse(50~58°C) -4 +10.8~23.0 -5 +105~135 -6 +CHINA CRYSTAL -7 +QUICK WASH -8 +Drying +Pre Wash -9 +Pre Wash -10 +Wash(48°C) -11 +Rinse -12 +Rinse(58°C) -13 +Drying +Pre Wash -14 +Wash(40°C) -15 +Rinse(50°C) -16 +Drying -17 +RINSE ONLY -18 +Rinse Only -19 +ENERGY SAVER + +Pre Wash + +Pre Wash + +Wash(40°C) + +Rinse + +Rinse(50°C) + +Drying + +120 + +60 20 -21 +105 -22 +19.3 -23 +15.5 -24 +8 -25 +19.3 -26 +8 -27 + Adjustable Upper Rack -28 +The upper rack height can be easily adjusted to +accommodate loading taller dishes in either rack. +To accommodate taller dishes in the bottom rack +are 2 positions available: -Count Four -(Violations of CDAFA, Cal. Pen. Code § 502) +, -57. +there -58. +Upper rack -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. +Lower rack -The California legislature enacted CDAFA with the intent of “expand[ing] the +Dish Preparation -degree of protection afforded to individuals . . . from tampering, interference, damage, and +. -unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data and computer systems.” Cal. Penal Code +, -§502(a). The enactment of CDAFA was motivated by the finding that “the proliferation of +, -computer technology has resulted in a concomitant proliferation of . . . unauthorized access to +, +pits -computers, computer systems, and computer data.” Id. +, -59. +. +. -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices used to access their Gmail, Chat, +bones -and Meet accounts constitute “computers” within the scope of CDAFA. + be loosened before loading Empty -60. +Scrape away large pieces of food +, + continuous filtered wash system +toothpicks etc The +- +will remove the remaining food particles Burned on + liquids +foods should +from glasses and cups. +Foods such as mustard mayonnaise +juice and tomato based products may cause +discoloration of stainless steel and plastics if allowed to +. +sit for a long period of time Unless +is to be opertated at once it is best to rinse off these +food soils. +If the dishwasher drains into a food disposer be, sure +disposer is completely empty before starting +dishwasher. -Google violated the following sections of CDAFA: + the dishwasher -a. +vinegar -Section 502(c)(1), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly access[] and +, -without permission . . . use[] any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order +, -to either (A) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B) +lemon -wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;” +Note: +Height should be adjusted without dishes in the racks. -b. +9 -Section 502(c)(2), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly accesses and + Loading the Upper Rack -without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or +Loading the Bottom Rack -computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing +The upper rack is designed for cups, glasses, small +plates, bowls and plastic items marked +safe etc. +For best results, place the bowls, cups, glasses, sauce +pans with soiled surface facing down or toward the +center. Tilt slightly for better drainage. -internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;” and +Make sure the loaded dishes do not +interfere with the rotation of the middle +spray arm, which is located at the bottom +of the upper rack. (Check this by rotating +the middle spray arm by hand.) -c. +The bottom rack is designed to load plates + and cookware. The adjustable rack +, +plates saucers +space will allow you to load maximum 13 inch items. -Section 502(c)(7), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly and without +, -permission accesses or causes to be accessed any computer, computer system, or computer +, +soup bowls -network.” +Large items should be placed along the edge +so they do not interfere with the middle spray +arm rotation, and make sure they + not prevent +the detergent +Large items should be turned so that the +inside faces downward, and make sure these +items do not interfere with the lower spray +arm rotation. -61. + dispenser from opening. -Google knowingly accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet +- -accounts without their permission by surreptitiously activating Gemini AI access that intercepts + tines in the bottom rack make it easy to +The fold down +- - +load those extra large and hard to fit +items The tines +may be left up for normal use or folded down for more + down for more space to load large +flexible loading Fold +pots or pans. -and transmits data, communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class +. -Members. +. -62. +Upper Rack -Google used data, communications, and personal information that it intercepted and +8 place settings -- 16 - +Upper Rack 12 place settings -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Upper Rack 14 place settings - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 18 of 21 +Bottom Rack 8 place settings -1 +Bottom Rack 12 place settings + +Bottom Rack 14 place settings + +10 + + Preparing and loading dishes + +Loading the Silverware Basket + +Adding A Dish + +The silverware basket could be divided into three +separate modules that can be used in both upper and +lower racks + +1. +2. +3. +4. +5. +6. + +Spoons +Knives +Salad forks +Forks +Large spoons +Large forks + +2 +2 +2 +2 2 +2 + +4 +4 +4 +4 + +3 +3 +3 3 4 +4 +3 +3 -5 +1 -6 +1 -7 +1 -8 +1 -9 +1 -10 +1 +1 +1 -11 +1 +1 +1 -12 +6 -13 +1 -14 +1 -15 +1 -16 +1 -17 +1 -18 +1 +1 +1 -19 +1 +1 +1 -20 +6 -21 +1 -22 +1 -23 +5 -24 +4 +4 +3 +3 -25 +3 +3 +3 +3 -26 +4 +4 +4 +4 -27 +2 -28 +2 -took from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts to wrongfully and +2 +2 +2 +2 -unjustly enrich itself at the expense of Plaintiff and Class Members. +To add or remove items after wash cycle starts: +1 Open door slightly and wait a few seconds until wash -63. +action stops before completely opening. -Defendant took, copied, intercepted, and made use of data, communications, and +2 Add the item. +3 Close door firmly to latch and cycle will automatically -personal information from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. +resume. -64. +CAUTION -Defendant knowingly and without Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ permission +TO AVOID BURN INJURY: Slightly open door and +wait until spray arms and wash action stop. Hot +water may splash out of dishwasher. Failure to do +so may result in injury. -accessed or caused to be accessed their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts by installing—without +Filling the rinse aid dispenser -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ informed consent—AI software that intercepts and/or takes data, +. -communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiffs and Class Members. + next to the -65. + rinse aid dispenser located -Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ data, +Rinse aid greatly improves drying and reduces water + rinse aid your dishes and +spots and filming Without +. +dishwasher interior will have excessive moisture +The +Heated Dry option will not perform as well without rinse +, +aid The. + releases a measured +, +Detergent cup automatically +amount of rinse aid during the last rinse. +, + the +If spotting and poor drying is a problem increase +amount of rinse aid dispensed by rotating the dial to a +higher number The. + dial is located under the dispenser +cap. +If the rinse aid is low, the Rinse Aid light is illuminated at +the beginning and end of the cycle indicating that it +is time to refill. -communications, and personal information from California. On information and belief, Google +Do not let any item extend through bottom. -uses servers located in California that allow Google to access and process the data, communications +Be sure nothing protrudes though bottom of +the basket or rack to block the lower spray +arm. -and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class Members. Google’s terms of service +11 -indicate that California law controls the use of its services. + Preparing and loading dishes -66. +Filling the rinse aid dispenser -Google was unjustly enriched by intercepting, acquiring, taking, or using Plaintiff’s +Your dishwasher is designed to use a liquid rinse aid The -and Class Members’ data, communications, and personal information without their permission, and +. + improves drying performance after the final rinse Do -using it for Google’s own financial benefit. Google has been unjustly enriched in an amount to be + rinse +aid. Under normal conditions, the rinse aid will last approximately one month, try to +keep it full, but do not over fill. -determined at trial. +. not use a solid or bar type -67. + use of rinse greatly +- -As a direct and proximate result of Google’s violations of CDAFA, Plaintiff and + the door turn, -Class Members suffered damages. + the dispenser cap to left and lift -68. +. +1 Open +it out. -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(1), Plaintiff and Class Members seek + the amount of the rinse aid released -compensatory, injunctive, and equitable relief in an amount to be determined at trial. +3. You can adjust +during the +rinse operation, the greater number indicates the +larger amount of rinse aid released. -69. +. +2 Add -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(2), Plaintiff and Class Members seek an award + rinse agent until the indicator point to max -of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. +. +4 Replace -70. + the dispenser cap -Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(4), Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive +Filling the detergent dispenser -or exemplary damages for Google’s willful violations of CDAFA. +1. Push the dispenser cover latch downwards and +open it -Count Five -(Violations of the SCA, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq.) +2. Add the detergent to the main wash compartment -71. +open cup -Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein. +12 -- 17 - + Preparing and loading dishes -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +3. Close the dispenser cover - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 19 of 21 +The amount of the detergent needed depends on the cycle and soil level of dishes, refer to the table below and +adjust the recommended amount as necessary for your load. -1 +Cycle -2 +Soft Water +( -0 3 Grains) -3 +Medium Hard Water +( -4 8 Grains) -4 +Hard Water +( -9 12 Grains) -5 +Very Hard Water* +(Over 12 Grains) -6 +, -7 +Auto wash, +& +Pots wash +Normal +wash -8 +2 Teaspoons +(Main Wash Cup- -9 + Full) -10 +5 Teaspoons +(Main Wash Cup - +fill to line above +"R -11 +") +egular -12 +8 Teaspoons +(Main Wash +Cup +Completely +Full) -13 +Each Cup - +Completely Full +(Water Softener +Recommended) -14 +Quick wash, +China crystal -15 +2 Teaspoons +(Main Wash + Full) -16 +5 Teaspoons +(Main Wash Cup + fill to line above +") +egular -17 +"R -18 +8 Teaspoons +(Main Wash Cup +completely full) -19 +Main Wash Cup - +Completely Full +(Water Softener +Recommended) -20 +Rinse -21 +No Detergent -22 +No Detergent -23 +No Detergent -24 + Water -25 +No Detergent ( +Softener +Recommended) -26 +13 -27 + Cleaning the exterior door and panel -28 +1 Stainless -72. +. -The SCA provides a cause of action against any person who “intentionally accesses + steel panel -without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided,” +Clean the stainless steel door and handle regularly to +remove the debris with cleaning soft cloth. +Do not use appliance wax, polish, bleach or products +containing chlorine to clean the stainless steel door. -or any person “who intentionally exceeds an authorization to access that facility; and thereby +2 Control -obtains, alters or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in +. -electronic storage in such a system.” 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a). + panel -73. +Clean the control +cloth, clean -The SCA defines “electronic storage” as “any temporary, intermediate storage of a +panel + gently. -wire or electronic communication incidental to the electronic transmission thereof;” and “any +it -storage of such communication by an electronic communication service for purposes of backup +with -protection of such communication.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(17). +a lightly -74. +dampened -The SCA defines an “electronic communications service” as “any service which +Clean the Stainless Steel Inner Door and Tub -provides to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 +The tub is made of Stainless Steel +corrode if the dishwasher should be scratched or +dented. -U.S.C. § 2510(15). +it, will not rust or -75. +Clean the spots on the steel inner door and +tub with a damp nonabrasive cloth. -Google intentionally accessed without authorization or intentionally exceeded +Clean the Cylinder Filter -authorization to access facilities through which an electronic communications services was +WARNING -provided when it used its Gemini AI technology to access the Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ +The Cylinder Filter is designed to collect some big +items such as broken glass, bones and pits +Cylinder Filter needs to be cleaned to maximize wash +performance. +Remove the bottom rack, rotate the cylinder filter as +shown, lift it out, empty and clean it by holding it under +running water and replace. -Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts for purposes of tracking their private communications. +. +The -76. +Burn Hazard +Allow heating element to cool before cleaning +the interior. +Failure to do so can result in burns. -The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services utilized by Plaintiff and Class Members on their +14 -computing devices provide electronic communications services to Plaintiff and Class Members + Clean the Fine Filter -because they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic +Take out the Cylinder Filter and remove the Fine Filter from the dishwasher tub bottom To. +remove the Fine Filter you must first remove the bottom spray arm as shown below. +Flush the Fine Filter by holding it under running water and replace. -communications.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(15). +15 -77. + Clean the door gasket -The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services to which the Plaintiff and Class Members use +Air gap -or subscribe to provide electronic communication services to Plaintiff and Class Members because +Clean the door gasket with a damp cloth to remove +food particles regularly. -they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18 +If there is an air gap installed with your dishwasher, +make sure it is clean so the dishwasher will drain +properly. +Air gap is not part of your dishwasher. +Before you clean the air gap turn, +firstly and lift off the cover +Remove the plastic cap and clean with a toothpick. -U.S.C. § 2510(15). + off the dishwasher -78. +Inside -Neither the Plaintiff and Class Members nor the third parties with whom they +Protect against freezing -communicated with on Gmail, Chat, and Meet authorized the extent of Google’s access to + a -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices and Google’s services therein. +Your dishwasher should be protected from freezing +properly if it was left in an unheated place Have +qualified person do the following: +To Disconnect Service: +1. Turn off electrical power to the dishwasher at the +supply source by moving fuses or tripping circuit +breaker. +2. Turn off the water supply +3. Place a pan under the inlet valve Disconnect -79. +. -Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts—and the + water -- 18 - +line from inlet valve and drain into pan. -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT + the water drain - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 20 of 21 +4. Disconnect drain line from pump and drain water +into pan. +To Restore Service: +. +1 Reconnect +supply. +. +2 Turn +3 Fill. + a Heated Wash +. +4 Check -1 + both detergent cups and run dishwasher through -2 + connections to make sure they do not leak. -3 + on water and electrical power supply. -4 + and electrical power -5 + cycle. -6 +, -7 +- -8 + with +The inside of the dishwasher is self cleaning +normal use. If needed, clean the tub gasket with a +damp cloth and use a brush similar to the ones shown +below to clean the opening in the end of the gasket. -9 +- -10 +16 -11 + Troubleshooting -12 +before calling for service -13 +Problem -14 +Possible cause -15 +Solution -16 +Dishwasher won t' start -17 +Door may not be closed properly +Power supply or power line is not connected +Delay Start option has been selected -18 +Child Lock activated selected -19 +( -20 + models) -21 +Dishwasher beeps at the +end of the cycle +Rinse Aid light on -22 +It indicates the wash cycle finished +dishwasher will beep +The rinse aid level is low -23 +, -24 +the -25 +The dishwasher is connected to cold water -26 +Dishwasher operates too +long -27 +The cycle time will vary due to the soil -28 +The sanitize option is selected -computing devices, applications, and/or web browsers through which they accessed those +Water pressure is temporarily low -services—also are facilities under the SCA because they comprise the software necessary for and +The inlet water is low -“through which (the) electronic communications service is provided.” +Dishes are not clean +enough -80. +Dishes are loaded too close together -Google intentionally accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and +improper use of detergent -Meet accounts without authorization when Google turned on the Gemini AI access to those services +The selected cycle is not suitable for food soil condition +Spay arms is blocked by some items -without obtaining the consent of the Plaintiff and Class Members. +Detergent dispenser is empty -81. +Improper loading of dishes -Upon information and belief, Google’s acquisition of electronic communications +Dishes not drying enough -from Plaintiff and Class Members included private communications Plaintiff and Class Members +Shut the door completely make sure it is latched +Check and connect the power supply +Refer -had with third parties that are not affiliated with Google. + in this manual -82. + to rese -Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by Google’s violations and, pursuant to +Deactivate the child lock, refer to child lock +section in this manual -18 U.S.C. § 2707(c), are entitled to statutory damages or actual damages, including profits earned +Add rinse aid +, +Check the dishwasher make +to the hot water supply -by Google attributable to the violations, punitive damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees. + sure it connected -VIII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF + cycle will automatically increase the -WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests that judgment be entered against Google and that the +When heavy soil is detected, the auto, normal, +pots pan& +cycle time +When sanitize option is selected, the cycle time +will be increase to meet the sanitized +temperature request -Court grant the following: +Use you dishwasher when the water pressure is +normal +Make sure the dishwasher is connected to the +hot water supply +Try not use your dishwasher when hot water is +being used elsewhere in the house +Load the dishes again as the manual introduced -A. +Add detergent depending on the water hardness +and the cycle you chose. Use fresh detergent. +Choose anther cycle for longer washing time +Make sure the spay arm is rotated fluently -An order determining that this action may be maintained as a class action under Rule +Fill rinse aid dispenser or increase the amount -23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that Plaintiff is a proper class representative, that +of rinse -Plaintiff’s attorneys shall be appointed as Class counsel pursuant to Rule 23(g) of the Federal Rules + aid. -of Civil Procedure, and that Class notice be promptly issued; +Load the dishes again as the manual introduction -B. +Spots and filming on +dishes -Judgment against Google for Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ asserted causes of +Etching -action; +Detergent left in +dispenser cup -C. +The cycle you chose did not included the drying. -D. +Choose the proper cycle with drying -Appropriate declaratory relief against Google; +Water hardness is too high -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from +Improper loading of dishes +Old or damp powder rinse aid is used +Rinse dispenser empty +Using too much detergent +The inlet water temperature exceeds 150 ℉ -continuing its practice of accessing, using, and/or storing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private +Detergent may be too old +Spray arm is blocked -communications without their knowledge or consent in violation of CIPA, CDAFA, and/or SCA; +For extremely hard water install +a water softener +Load the dishes again as the manual indicates +Use fresh rinse aid +Add rinse aid to the dispenser +Use less detergent if you have soft water +Lower the inlet water temperature +Use fresh detergent -E. +, +Load the dishes making +are not blocked. -Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from + sure the spray arms -continuing its practice of tracking, recording, and using Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private +17 -communications; + Troubleshooting -- 19 - +Problem -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Possible cause - Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 21 of 21 +Solution -F. +Improper operation of the detergent cover -An order awarding Plaintiff and the Class Members damages, special damages, +Add the detergent and rinse aid as indicated by +the manual -general damages, and restitution; +Previous cycle has not finished or has been +interrupted -G. +Select the proper cycle as introduced by the +manual -H. +Detergent dispenser +will not shut +Water remains in the +dishwasher -I. +Dishwasher does not +drain properly -J. +Drain is clogged -An order requiring Google to pay punitive damages and exemplary damages; +Drain hose is kinked -An order requiring Google to pay pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; +Check the air gap if you have +Make sure the disposer is empty if the +dishwasher is connected to the disposer -Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs reasonably incurred; and +Make sure the drain hose is properly connected +to the sink -Any and all other and further relief to which Plaintiff and the Class may be entitled. +Make sure to use only the automatic dishwasher +detergent -IX. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL +Suds in the tub -Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury of all issues so triable. +Improper detergent is used -Dated: November 11, 2025 +Dishwasher leaks -Respectfully Submitted, +Black or gray marks +on dishes -/s/ Tina Wolfson -Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806) -twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com -Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098) -rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com -Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242) -tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com -Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313) -abrown@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500 -Burbank, CA 91505-4521 -Telephone: 310.474.9111 -Facsimile: 310.474.8585 +Excessive suds caused by using the improper +detergent -Bradley K. King (SBN 274399) -bking@ahdootwolfson.com -AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC -521 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor -New York, NY 10175 -Telephone: 917.336.0171 -Facsimile: 917.336.0177 +Make sure to use only the automatic +dishwasher detergent -Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class +Dishwasher is not level -- 20 - +Aluminum utensils have rubbed against dishes -CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Leveling the dishwasher (see the installation +manual) -1 +Chose a higher cycle +Make sure the inlet water is no less than 120℉ -2 +Coffee and tea soil -3 +Using a spot cleaner to remove the soil -4 +Stained tub interior -5 +Reddish stain -6 +Some tomato food will cause this, use of the +rinse only cycle right after loading this will +decrease the staining -7 +Noises -8 +Detergent cup opening\ Drain pump sound -9 +This is normal -10 +A hard object has entered the wash module When +the object is ground up the, -11 +. + sound should stop. -12 +If the noise persists after a complete cycle, +call for service. -13 +Dishwasher won't fill -14 +Water valve is turn off +Door latch may not be properly seated -15 +Check if the water valve is turn on -16 +Make sure the door is closed -17 +When some malfunctions come on, the appliance will display error codes to warn you: -18 +E1 -19 +E4 -20 +E8 + +E9 -21 +Longer inlet time. -22 +Overflow. -23 +Faucets is not opened, or water intake is +restricted,or water pressure is too low. -24 +Some element of dishwasher leaks . -25 +Failure of orientation of distributary valve. -26 +Open circuit or break of distributary valve. -27 +Keep touching a button more than 30 seconds. Water or something on the button. -28 +If overflow occurs, turn off the main water supply before calling a service. +If there is water in the base pan because of an overfill or small leak, +the water should be removed before restarting the dishwasher. + +18 - ClassAction.org + Thank you for purchasing a FORNO product. Please read the entire instruction manual before operating +your new appliance for the first time. Whether you are an occasional user or an expert , it will be beneficial +to familiarize yourself with the safety practices, features, operation and care recommendations of your +appliance. -This complaint is part of ClassAction.org's searchable class action lawsuit -database and can be found in this post: Google Hit with Data Privacy Lawsuit -After ‘Secretly’ Turning On Gemini AI for All Users +Both the model and serial number are listed inside the product. For warranty purposes, you will also need +the date of purchase. +Record this information below for future reference. diff --git a/q237/random_k2/random_2.md b/q237/random_k2/random_2.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..5c5eba2e1fd980c21e8cbb1cd873801d5dedd049 100644 --- a/q237/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q237/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,493 +1,2541 @@ -WHITE PAPER + CONTENTS -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail +01 +04 + 16 +36 +38 +39 +40 +41 +44 +45 - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … +/ About HKU Business School -is your store -ready? +/ Explore Your Options - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +/ Enrich Your Life -Introduction +/ 2026 JUPAS Admissions -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. +/ 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions -Gartner1 +/ 2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +/ Develop Your Career + +/ Freshmen Sharing + +/ Our Global Presence + +/ Useful Websites + +About HKU Business School + +HKU Business School strives to nurture first-class business leaders and foster academic and relevant +research to serve the needs of Hong Kong, Chinese Mainland and the rest of the world in the new Asia-led +economy. As Asia’s premier international business school, we engage leading scholars from all corners of the +globe and they instil in students global knowledge with an Asian perspective. + +With the highest proportion of non-local undergraduate students across all Faculties at HKU, four of our +undergraduate programmes ranked amongst the University’s Top 10 programmes in 2025#, HKU Business +School attracts the best and brightest students from Hong Kong and beyond. + +HKU Business School is fully accredited by the European Quality Improvement Systems (EQUIS) and the +Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB). + +# Based on average JUPAS admission scores in the best 5 subjects in HKDSE + +VISION +To be a leading, +globally-impactful academic +institution of business and +economics. + +UNIQUE +PROPOSITION + +Deeply rooted in Hong Kong +Fully engaged with China +Truly international + +MISSION +STATEMENT + +To provide world-leading +business and economics +education that nurtures +dynamic and responsible +leaders. +To advance the frontiers of +knowledge through innovative +and globally-significant +research. +To create positive change in the +world by partnering with +communities. + +01 + + Dean’s Message + +I am delighted to introduce you to the HKU Business +School, a dynamic and forward-thinking academic +community where transformative opportunities and +unparalleled experiences await. + +As a part of the University of Hong Kong, which +proudly ranks 11th globally in the 2026 QS World +University Rankings, HKU Business School stands out +as a beacon of excellence in business and economics +in Asia. This year marks the 25th anniversary of our +Faculty, we continue to march forward as a leading, +impactful business school, championing +globally +research, and +leadership, pioneering +thought +educational excellence. + +of + +dynamic, + +challenging + +responsible, + +Our mission is to inspire and develop the next +generation +and +globally-minded business leaders. We offer a vibrant +and +learning environment where +students are encouraged to push their limits, think +critically, and innovate. Our team of leading scholars +from around the world, and experienced and +dedicated teachers as well as mentors bring a wealth +of knowledge, global perspectives, and personalised +guidance beyond the classroom. Our full spectrum of +top-quality degree programmes, including 11 diverse +undergraduate programmes and four dual bachelor’s +degrees +in partnership with world-renowned +universities, is designed to equip students with +cutting-edge knowledge and technical skills to +in the fast-changing global +navigate and excel +business landscape. + +In response to the transformative power of artificial +intelligence, we are proud to launch the Second Major +and Minor programmes in “Artificial Intelligence in +Business” +to our +(AIB), offered exclusively +undergraduate students. These programmes are +designed to equip future business +leaders with +practical proficiency in AI technologies, strategic +insight to drive cross-sector innovation, and a critical +understanding of the ethical and societal implications +of AI adoption. Through a rigorous curriculum that +integrates business fundamentals with cutting-edge +AI applications, students will be empowered to tackle +complex challenges and create meaningful impact in +a data-driven world. + +Greetings from +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +inspiration + +Business education today is an evolving domain that +builds upon learning from all academic disciplines and +draws +successful and +from both +unsuccessful business practices. Our undergraduate +curricula in six core academic areas equip students +with diverse knowledge across business and +economics spheres, and prepare them to be creative +leaders of tomorrow with global perspectives. + +A hallmark of our School that separates us from the +others is our truly multi-disciplinary approach. HKU +Business School’s extensive resources offer students +in +a wide range of choices, combining studies +economics and finance, accounting and finance, +accounting and data analytics, business and law, +business and data analytics, international business +and global management, as well as dual degrees in +collaboration with world-renowned universities. + +Our faculty members will engage you with their +inspiring teaching and how they bring their impactful +research into the classroom. They will open your mind +to diverse perspectives, +ignite your curiosity to +explore innovative ideas, and instil in you an appetite +for acquiring new knowledge and extraordinary +experiences throughout your academic journey and +career development. Our students are among the +brightest and most creative of their peers. Our alumni +have gone on to forge brilliant careers in all sectors of +the +international business +community, and have formed a global network that +you will be a part of for the rest of your life. + +regional and + +local, + +I hope that you will share my enthusiasm for the +programmes and my admiration for the people who +have contributed to their development. I look forward +to having you as a member of the HKU Business +School family and a future leader in the world of +business. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Derek Chan +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +Through our extensive partnerships with over 300 +institutions and corporations across more than 40 +countries, as well as our unique network of centres in +Beijing, Shenzhen, Shanghai, Vietnam, and Barcelona, +our students gain unparalleled global experiential +and enrichment opportunities. Whether through +internships, overseas exchange programmes, or +hands-on +these experiences +sharpen practical skills, broaden perspectives, and +prepare students to confidently tackle real-world +challenges. + +industry projects, + +Joining HKU Business School means becoming part of +a community that supports your growth and success. +You will collaborate with brilliant minds, engaging in +stimulating discussions, and working on impactful +projects that make a difference. The friendships, +networks, and experiences you build here will last a +to a myriad of career +lifetime, open doors +opportunities, and empower you to overcome +challenges, pursue your passions with confidence, +and contribute positively to your community and the +world at large. + +If you are ready to embark on an exciting journey of +learning, discovery, and personal development, I +invite you to explore what HKU Business School has to +look forward to welcoming you to our +offer. I +community, where future leaders are nurtured and +dreams take flight. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Hongbin Cai +Dean +Chair of Economics + +0302 Explore Your Options +A Wide Selection of Programmes + +Bachelor of Business Administration [BBA] + +The BBA programme combines strong functional training with intensive exposure +to communication skills, computer applications, and other social science and/or +science subjects. Students can choose to major in the following area(s): + +Entrepreneurship, +Design and + Innovation* + +Finance + +Human Resource +Management + +Information Systems +and Analytics + +Marketing + +BBA Curriculum Structure + +Components + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +78 +24 +48 +6 + +108 + +240 + +*Candidates must undergo a selection process arranged by the Programme Coordinator for +declaring the EDI major. + +HKU – Sciences Po Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first two years at Sciences Po in France and the third +and fourth years at HKU. Programmes at Sciences Po are taught in English (no +French requirements for being admitted) with intensive French language +classes for all non-francophone students. + +Upon successful completion of the dual degree programme, students will be +awarded the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) degree from HKU and +a Bachelor’s degree from Sciences Po. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-sciences-po-dual- +degree-programme + +HKU – University of British Columbia +Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first and final years at HKU and the second and third +years at the University of British Columbia (UBC) in Canada, and graduate with +a Bachelor of Business Administration from HKU and a Bachelor of Commerce +from UBC upon successful completion of the programme. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-university-of-british- +columbia-dual-degree-programme + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba + +0504 + + Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting and +Finance [BBA(Acc&Fin)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting Data +Analytics [BBA(ADA)] + +The BBA(Acc&Fin) programme prepares students for a professional qualification +in accounting and provides the broad-based education in accounting and finance +which is necessary to progress toward a leadership role in the financial sector. +Students are required to take professional core in accounting and a minor in +finance, with an option to second major in finance. Tailor-made professional +internship opportunities with renowned +preparation programmes and +accounting firms and financial institutions are available for talented students. It +is accredited as an approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Acc&Fin) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B + +C + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course + +Minor in Finance* +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives + +D. + +Free Electives / Optional Minor + +*Students may opt to pursue a Major in Finance: + +Components + +A + +B + +C + +University Graduation Requirements + +Professional Core in Accounting + +Major in Finance +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Free Electives +Capstone Course + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +108 +24 +78 +6 + +36 +12 +24 + +42 + +Total + +240 + +Credits -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 +54 -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. +108 -3 +78 +30 +18 +24 +6 + +Total + +240 + +Similar to the BBA(Acc&Fin) programme, the BBA(ADA) programme prepares +students for a professional qualification in accounting. It provides students +with an option to focus on data analytics aspect in accounting instead of having +a minor in finance. It is an excellent choice for students who are interested in +STEM with accounting and business applications and wish to pursue their +career in the relevant fields. The intensive accounting training enables +BBA(ADA) students to distinguish themselves from students of the other data +analytics/STEM programmes. Students will be equipped with comprehensive +accounting and business knowledge that prepares them to obtain professional +qualifications in accounting. They will also acquire computer programming +and data analytics skills to meet the needs of the accounting and business +professions in today’s digital transformation economy. It is accredited as an +approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(ADA) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting Data Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +156 +24 +114 +12 +6 + +30 + +240 + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-acc-and-fin + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ada + +0706 + + Bachelor of Business Administration (Business Analytics) +[BBA(BA)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration (Law) and Bachelor of +Laws [BBA(Law)&LLB] + +The BBA(BA) programme is crafted to meet the growing industry demand for +talents in the business analytics field. Its curriculum offers students a +comprehensive coverage of both technical and managerial skill sets. Students +will learn a wide spectrum of knowledge from the disciplines of information +technology, data science, business statistics and management. Core courses +include programming language, database management, introduction to +business analytics, management information systems, decision and risk +analysis, etc. They help students build the foundations for advanced topics in +senior years. Students also have the option to choose from analytics technique +courses and business application courses. The aim is to provide students with +state-of-the-art experiences in artificial intelligence, big data, social media, +and other latest development. Such design helps train well-rounded students +who will be more adaptable in their career development. The programme is +suitable for students who have a passion for problem-solving through +analytics, and who aim to develop their career path in analytics. - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +BBA(BA) Curriculum Structure -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 +Components -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 +Credits -) -s -n -o +A -i -l -l -i +B -M -$ -( +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -l +Major in Business Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Analytics Techniques) +Disciplinary Electives (Business Applications) +Capstone Course -s -e -a -S +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 + +90 + +Jointly offered by the HKU Business School and the Faculty of Law, the +BBA(Law)&LLB integrated double-degree programme blends two strategic +disciplines into a single programme for the bright and highly motivated. It is an +excellent choice for students seeking a broader education with parallel +concentration on legal and business studies. Graduates of the programme will be +awarded two degrees — BBA(Law) by the HKU Business School, and LLB by the +Faculty of Law. After successful completion of the LLB programme, students +may apply for admission to the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws (PCLL) +programme provided that they meet the relevant admission requirements. + +The programme offers business stream and accounting stream to students in +their business studies. The accounting stream is accredited by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Business Stream) + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h C -% -Q2 -2018 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Course +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -Q3 -2018 +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -Q4 -2018 +Professional Core in Law +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -Q1 -2019 +D. -Q2 -2019 +Free Electives / Optional Minor -Q3 -2019 +Total -Q4 -2019 +240 -Q1 -2020 +Total -Q2 -2020 +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Accounting Stream) -Q3 -2020 +Components -Q4 -2020 +A -Q1 -2021 +B -Q2 -2021 +University Graduation Requirements -Q3 -2021 +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course -Q4 -2021 +C -B&M YoY Growth +Professional Core in Law -E-commerce YoY Growth +Total -E-commerce +36 +6 +24 +6 +- -Brick & Mortar +78 +24 +48 +6 -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- +156 +108 +42 +6 -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division +30 -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. +300 -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents +Credits -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents +36 -+13 percentage -points +108 +24 +78 +6 -+9 percentage -points +156 -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines +300 -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ba -Oct-21 Feb-22 +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-law-and-llb -Oct-21 Feb-22 +0908 -Sep-20 + Bachelor of Business Administration in International Business +and Global Management [BBA(IBGM)] -4 +Bachelor of Economics [BEcon] - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +BBA(IBGM) is an intensive, premier programme in international business and +global management featuring a unique curriculum designed to evolve with and +reflect the ever-changing demands of a globalised world. Exclusive elements +such as overseas exchange studies, a leadership boot camp, an Asia-Pacific +study tour, an international field trip and global enrichment opportunities are +strategically integrated into the curriculum, whilst students are given the +flexibility to pursue an in-depth inquiry into another specialised area of study +as a second major. This cross-functional and personalised approach aims to +foster a selected group of outstanding students to become the world’s future +leaders equipped with global perspectives, cultural sensitivity, social +responsibility and key competencies to succeed in the international business +environment. -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. +BBA(IBGM) Curriculum Structure -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 +Components -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 +A -92% +B -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. +C -60% +D -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. +E -51% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. +Major in International Business and Global Management +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ +Second Major -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. +Free Electives -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. +Compulsory Overseas Exchange -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink +Total -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. +Credits -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -adoption in stores. +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. +72-90 -5 +0-18* - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +- -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE +240 -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years +*Students may use free electives to fulfil the second major where the requirements exceed 72 credits. -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened +The BEcon programme trains students in economic theories, statistical tools, +the application of theories to solve practical economic problems in trade, +banking and the labour market, and evaluation of the regional economic +performance of Chinese Mainland, Hong Kong and other economies. Students +will be furnished with solid theoretical and empirical economic knowledge to +analyse and understand human behaviour and social interactions. The +programme allows students a high degree of flexibility in planning their future +career specialisation. -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. +BEcon Curriculum Structure -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. +Components -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. +A -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. +B -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. +Major in Economics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. +C -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to +Total -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more +Credits -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). +54 +12 +36 +6 +- +78 +24 +30 +18 6 - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +108 + +240 + +Find out more: +http://ibgm.business.hku.hk + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon + +1110 + + Bachelor of Economics and Finance [BEcon&Fin] + +BEcon&Fin is designed to meet the interests of students who are seeking a +balanced study of both economics and finance. The programme recognises +the significance of economics both in its own right and as a foundation for the +study of finance, and the significance of finance as a career path for students +who are keen on joining this profession. Students will receive solid training in +theories and applications of economics and finance. They will be equipped +with the skills to analyse human behaviour and social interaction, as well as to +solve problems in the financial sphere. + +BEcon&Fin Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Economics and Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Economics Disciplinary Electives +Finance Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 + +90 + +Total + +240 + +HKU - Peking University “Future +Leaders” Dual Bachelor’s Degree in +Economics, Finance and Management +The programme combines the strengths of two leading business schools in +Hong Kong and Chinese Mainland and is designed to nurture first-class business +leaders and cultivate their global perspective with intimate understanding of +China. Students will spend the first two years at HKU and the third and fourth +years at Peking University (PKU), and be awarded a Bachelor of Economics and +Finance (BEcon&Fin) degree from HKU and a Bachelor of Management [BMgmt] +degree from PKU upon successful completion of the dual degree programme. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/admission/degree-program +mes/hku-pku-dual-degree + +Bachelor of Finance in Asset Management and Private +Banking [BFin(AMPB)] +The BFin(AMPB) programme aims to prepare students to enter the rapidly +growing fields of asset management and private wealth management in Hong +Kong and Asia Pacific, or in banking and finance generally. During the first two +years, students complete introductory courses in accounting, economics, +mathematics, statistics, corporate finance, and investments and portfolio +analysis. In subsequent years, students take more specified and industry +related courses including equity valuation and investment in specific asset +classes e.g. private equity, venture capital, hedge funds and digital assets, +understanding of financial statements and doing financial analysis, lending +and credit in private wealth and corporate bank, financial regulations and +compliance, current +institutional +in finance, ESG +consulting and family office. The programme contains practical-oriented +courses taught by teachers with extensive experience in the finance industry +and offers an array of career-oriented enrichment activities and networking +opportunities with industry practitioners. + +investment, + +issues + +in + +BFin(AMPB) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Asset Management and Private Banking +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +24 +6 + +90 + +Total + +240 + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon-and-fin + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bfin-ampb + +1312 + + Bachelor of Science in Marketing Analytics and Technology +[BSc(MAT)] + +Bachelor of Science in Quantitative Finance [BSc(QFin)] + +Marketing is critical to all businesses. It dictates whether a company will be +successful. Technology, Big Data, and digitization are fundamentally changing +how marketers operate. The BSc(MAT) programme equips students with +quantitative skills, technology know-how, and business marketing acumen to +pursue a career in the digital economy and modern businesses. It targets both +STEM students with an interest in business as well as business students +interested in the technology space. Students will gain a solid foundation in +cutting-edge technical areas including computer programming, data science, +and technology by excelling in courses from the Faculty of Engineering and +Faculty of Science. In addition, students will master digital business, +marketing and leadership through courses at the HKU Business School. This +interdisciplinary approach will enable students to engage in a variety of jobs +and functions such as the design and launch of new technology products, +targeting consumers, digital marketing, forecast and predicting markets, and +building a technology-focused strategy. The programme aims to nurture +future leaders in the field of technology and marketing who are able to use the +latest technology, science, and data analytics to support business and +marketing decisions in the digital world. + +BSc(MAT) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Marketing Analytics and Technology +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Technology and Strategy) +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Analytics) +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 + +90 + +Total + +240 + +BSc(QFin) is a premium finance programme. Built on a solid foundation in +economics and finance, the programme equips students with the essential +quant skills, including mathematics, statistics, and programming, that are +required in more advanced and sophisticated analyses, such as valuation +models of structured products, risk management, simulation and data +analysis, financial engineering, and quantitative trading. + +The programme goes beyond merely equipping students with quant skills. +More importantly, it stresses on combining these skills with an understanding of +the financial markets, the macro environment, and the practical situations +where financial managers work, with a balanced mix of quant and business +courses. To nurture students’ soft skills and market acumen, the programme +provides a wide range of value-enhancing activities, such as Round Tables with +Practitioners, Alumni Drinks, Executive Mentorship Scheme, Bloomberg training +workshops, simulation trading workshops, and an international field trip to +other international financial centres such as New York, London and Zurich. + +BSc(QFin) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Quantitative Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 + +90 + +Total + +240 + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-mat + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-qfin + +1514 + + Enrich Your Life + +initiative and +HKU Business School fosters a culture of student +implementation of ideas, both within and outside the campus, as it is +these real-world engagements that set us apart. Experiences in learning +beyond the classroom, extending into realms outside academia, enable +students to cultivate an understanding of social dynamics, cultural +diversity, and collaborative +intellect. These experiences contribute +significantly to their personal growth, interpersonal skills, and social +development, shaping them into global citizens, lifelong learners, and +future business leaders. + +Overseas Enrichment Experiences + +Business Exchange Programme / +HKUWW Undergraduate Student Exchange Programme +Even as the youngest Faculty at the University, our exchange +activities are nothing but phenomenal. Each year, over 400 +students participate in overseas exchanges at leading universities +to broaden their horizons. + +Business School +Exchange Partners * + +Canada + +McGill University +University of British Columbia +University of Toronto +Western University +Simon Fraser University + +U.K. + +King's College London +University of Manchester +University of Edinburgh +University of Warwick + +The Netherlands + +University of Amsterdam +Erasmus University Rotterdam + +400+ +exchange partners +across 40+ countries + +400+ +Business School +students on exchange + +Denmark + +Copenhagen Business School +Aarhus University + +Germany + +Frankfurt School of Finance & Management +University of Mannheim +Munich Business School + +Belgium + +KU Leuven + +Italy + +Bocconi University + +France + +U.S. + +Toulouse School of Economics +ESSEC Business School + +New York University +University of Southern California +University of Washington +University of Georgia + +Middle East + +Reichman University + +Singapore + +National University of Singapore +Nanyang Technological University + +* This list is non-exclusive. + +International Field Trips +To enhance students' exposure to global businesses, the School organises +overseas field trips for students visiting corporate firms and mingling with +C-suite Executives in some of the world's most prominent financial +centres, e.g. Australia, France, Japan, London, New York City, Singapore, +Spain, and Zurich. + +Visiting Programmes +Through the Yale Visiting International Students Programme, students +are sent to spend a year at Yale University, where they actively engage +themselves in a multicultural society. With the generosity of the donors, +some of our students are selected for the Junior Year Abroad Programme +and Visiting Students Programme to study as visiting students at +Pembroke College and St Peter’s College of University of Oxford +respectively with substantial scholarships. The intellectual ambience of +these top universities is truly inspirational and conducive to learning. + +Beta Gamma Sigma Regional Leadership Conference +Beta Gamma Sigma (BGS) is the international honour society that +serves business programmes accredited by the Association to Advance +Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB International). With the +establishment of the HKU BGS Chapter, the School registers students +annually for the BGS Regional Leadership Conference held in the U.S., +where they can meet and bond with many other fellow students from the +world's best business schools. The Leadership Summit is eye-opening +and challenging, which leads to a great journey of self-discovery. + +Japan + +Kyoto University + +Australia + +University of Sydney +Monash University +University of New South Wales + +1716 Student Sharing + +Chen, Hsuan-yu +Exchange at National University of Singapore (Singapore), 2024-25 + +As a third-year undergraduate student pursuing a double major in +Accounting and Finance, I consider it a tremendous privilege to have +participated in a one-semester exchange at the National University of +Singapore (NUS) through the Business Exchange Programme. This +invaluable opportunity has not only enriched my academic journey but +also broadened my global perspective through immersive cultural +experiences and meaningful cross-cultural interactions. As I move +forward in my academic and professional journey, I carry with me not +just the knowledge gained from my courses, but the invaluable life +lessons experienced from Exchange. + +Lee, Tsz To Derek +Exchange at King’s College London (United Kingdom), 2024-25 + +I am incredibly grateful to have this valuable opportunity to study +abroad at King’s College London. The programme provided me a chance +to venture outside of my comfort zone. Not only can you learn how to be +more independent, you can also boost interpersonal skills given the +many opportunities to socialise with others, which is essential for your +future career. The experience is remarkable. I think you will regret it if +you miss out on the overseas exchange programme. + +Cheung, Nga Ting Caroline +Exchange at University of New South Wales (Australia), 2024-25 + +This exchange programme has changed me in many ways. It has helped +me become more outgoing, allowing me to make new friends and +explore different cities. Living independently has been a significant part +of this journey. From exploring new cities to forming lasting friendships, +each adventure has enriched my life in ways I never expected. This +opportunity has not only broadened my horizons but also deepened my +appreciation for diversity and connection among people from different +backgrounds. Each memory I have created during this time is a treasure +that I will carry with me forever. + +Ho, Ying Tung Crystal +Exchange at Copenhagen Business School (Denmark), 2024-25 + +In the Fall semester, I participated in a business exchange programme at +Denmark’s Copenhagen Business School (CBS). This experience was +truly transformative, enriching me both academically and personally +while allowing me to forge lifelong memories and friendships. An +exchange experience abroad truly broadens your horizons and offers +insights beyond what textbooks and lectures can provide. You will gain +invaluable perspectives and undergo personal growth like never before. +I wholeheartedly encourage you to muster your courage and embark on +an exchange journey - you won’t regret it! + +Whitfield III, Gerald Bruce Trey +Exchange at New York University (United States), 2024-25 + +I found the exchange experience to be extremely enriching. A major +highlight for me was exploring the lifestyle and professional sides of the +city. Because of my initiative socially, and in groups such as church, I was +able to get well-acquainted with the local rhythms and lifestyle, and +also made many friends that I’d consider friends for a lifetime. I am +deeply appreciative of being given this rewarding experience, which +significantly shaped both my future and the person I am today. + +Ip, Wing Tung Alla +Student Representative for the BGS Regional Leadership +Conference 2025 in Highland Heights, Kentucky + +Attending the BGS Leadership Conference at Northern Kentucky +University proved transformative. I received profound insights into +leadership, communication and cultural intelligence through immersive +workshops, case competitions and networking opportunities. The event +prompted reflections on personal leadership styles and encouraged +collaboration across diverse peers. As I prepare to enter the workforce, +I intend to apply these learned principles of trust-building, cultural +sensitivity and collaborative leadership to navigate challenges so I can +shape my professional journey with purpose and authenticity. + +1918 Corporate Exposure + +HKU Business School has a strong tie with corporate partners. To nurture students' business +and market acumen, enrichment programmes are organised through the joint efforts of +corporate partnerships. + +Enrichment Programmes in collaboration with Corporate Partners +HKU Business School has been collaborating with corporate partners on initiatives to spice up +students' career exploration journey. The partnership with Accenture enables students to +gain exclusive insights into business consulting through the HKU-Accenture Business +Consulting Programme. + +To provide students with a unique opportunity to explore current business trends and +developments in the Greater Bay Area (GBA), our School has co-organised a tailored study tour +with The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA). This initiative aims to +enhance students’ readiness for future career development and personal success. Students will +have the chance to connect with seasoned accounting and business professionals in the GBA. + +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme +Leveraging the School's extensive network in the business and finance industry, we have +developed our own mentorship programme to furnish students with opportunities to +enhance their skills and knowledge essential for their future personal and career +development. Our students are empowered to connect to the real business world through +direct and active interaction with seasoned professionals, executives and entrepreneurs. + +Lee, Lok Yiu Angel +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +My mentor offered +invaluable career advice, highlighting key +considerations for entering specific fields and preparing for interviews. +Her experiences and mindset during job searches resonated with me as +I navigated something similar. She emphasised the importance of +open-mindedness and eagerness to learn in the workplace. I kept her +words at heart during my internship. I also enjoyed catching up with her +to share my new job experiences. + +Choi, Han Na Hannah +HKUBS x Deloitte China Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +As my mentor has been working in Deloitte China for more than 10 +years, I was most curious about how he maintains a work-life balance +and how he stays dedicated and professional at work. Through our +lengthy conversations over lunch, he passed on valuable insights on +developing soft skills and adopting an appropriate work attitude at an +early stage. He is more than an audit mentor but also a life coach to me. + +Chan, Chin Ching Jacky +BSc(QFin) Executive Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +Throughout the mentorship programme, I have received +precious guidance that has greatly influenced my career +path. My mentor highlighted the importance of identifying +a company that aligns with my goals and would provide +opportunities for me to develop the necessary skill sets. He +also shared practical advice on building and managing +professional and personal relationships. These lessons +have broadened my perspective and also equipped me +with the tools to handle real-world situations more +effectively and confidently. + +Wong, Wan Tat +HKUBS x ACCA Greater Bay Area Study Tour 2024-25 + +My greatest takeaway from this study tour was the power of peer +learning and collaboration. Being immersed in an environment with a +diverse group of individuals, all focused on similar goals, created an +incredible opportunity to learn from each other’s experiences and +perspectives. The collaborative projects and informal discussions were +invaluable in broadening my horizon and developing new approaches +to the accounting field in Chinese Mainland. I am leaving with a strong +network of contacts and a renewed appreciation for teamwork. + +Leung, Ho Lun Maverick +HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme 2024-25 + +I visited + +The HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme immersed me in +an authentic consulting experience through working with a real client – +their distribution centres, conducted market +HKTV. +questionnaires, and presented the final deliverables - all within the +eight-week programme. I was honoured to meet Managing Directors +from Accenture who shared crucial skills in conducting a consulting +project. It’s truly one of the best programmes for anyone considering a +consulting career! + +2120 Experiential Learning Programmes + +Experiential learning is embedded in our course curriculum. The Business Consulting +Practicum offers business and economics students hands-on experience in working with +clients to solve "real-life" problems relevant to their studies, under the guidance of faculty +members and professional mentors. The Business Case Analysis and Presentation enables +students to communicate and seek practical advice from senior executives through in-class +case presentations. The Impact Lab provides students with an excellent opportunity to work +directly with social ventures, again under the guidance of teachers and professional mentors. +Additionally, students can gain an in-depth understanding of the latest trends in economics, +finance, creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurship in the rapidly growing Greater Bay Area +by participating in the Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China Programme. + +Chaabane, Adam Andrea +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +I have learned that prominent businessmen and professionals in Hong +Kong are people like me who were once attending business school. I +most enjoyed the guest +lectures because they allowed direct +interactions with inspiring figures. The virtual experience enabled me to +follow this programme easily from my home country. I definitely +recommend it for a better understanding of Hong Kong and GBA’s +markets and opportunities that arise in cross-border business. It would +be great to learn more about opportunities for foreigners in the region. + +Kaur, Suchleen +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +The opportunity for real-time interaction and feedback with the client had +propelled me to join BCP. I was always curious about how a consultant +would address and communicate with the client. BCP has taught me +about proper business etiquette and equipped me the necessary skills to +negotiate conflicting opinions during team discussions. Throughout the +process, our mentor and professors provided great help and insights. +Their invaluable feedback and questions helped nudge us in the right +direction, taking a step back to look at the big picture and most +importantly, prioritise the client’s needs. + +Zhou, Qingzhuo +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +My greatest takeaway from the CIEC 2025 programme was the unique +window to gain a comprehensive understanding of the Greater Bay +Area’s dynamic business landscape. I explored the latest trends in +business, finance, and innovation from guest talks and virtual lectures +with industry leaders. I particularly appreciate the coverage on a +diverse range of topics and the opportunity to earn HKU credits. A +highlight was the cultural exploration segment which offered an +unparalleled perspective on the Greater Bay Area. I recommend this +programme without hesitation. + +Tsang, Tze Yeung Matthew +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +BCP has been a rewarding experience that allowed me to apply my +academic knowledge to real-world business challenges. Working +directly with my mentor and client has pushed me to think critically and +creatively in ways I hadn't experienced in the classroom. I'm confident +that the problem-solving, communication, and client-facing skills I have +developed will serve me well when pursuing my future career in +consulting or another business-oriented field. + +2322 Cheung, Ho Ning Jolie +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 (Champion) + +in UW GBCC was an + +Competing +incredibly rewarding and +unforgettable experience. We had the opportunity to work with +participants from different universities. +It was a fantastic +opportunity to exchange perspectives and learn from different +problem-solving approaches. Working under tight timeframes +pushed us to think creatively. UW GBCC has not only elevated my +professional capabilities but further solidified my belief in business +as a powerful vehicle for creating positive change in the world. + +Case Competitions + +The School provides ample opportunities to refine students' presentation and analytical skills +through a myriad of local as well as overseas competitions. From training to delicate analysis +of business cases to a variety of business scenarios, students are equipped with different +skillsets to compete with candidates from the world's leading universities. + +Lo, Nikkia +NHH International Case Competition 2024 (Champion) + +My week at NHH International Case Competition has been an +unforgettable rollercoaster of emotions. From the excitement of +exploring a new Nordic city, the exhaustion of our 24-hour case +competition, to the nervous anticipation of pitching on a global stage +with a +livestream, every moment was extraordinary. Meeting +like-minded peers around the world was an incredible experience that +forged new friendships. Thank you, HKU Business School, along with +our professors, coaches and staff for bringing this opportunity to us! + +Xia, Yunchu Kevin +The McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 (First Place) + +Winning first place at MBSC2025 was incredible and deeply rewarding. +My team was highly engaged. We were constantly bouncing ideas off +each other and refining our strategy. There were moments where we hit +roadblocks, but our team rallied, challenged each other constructively +and developed a cohesive solution. Connecting with like-minded +participants, judges and NGOs was also invaluable. MBSC not only +sharpened my analytical and presentation skills but also reaffirmed my +commitment to leveraging business for good. I am so grateful for the +experience and very eager to apply these lessons moving forward! + +2524 Liu, Yunqi Iris +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 (Outstanding Team Award) + +This competition has been a fantastic learning experience. It +showed me that tax isn’t just about the technical details - it’s also +deeply connected to social trends and global events like climate +change, geopolitical conflicts and national policies. This broader +perspective has enhanced my understanding of the industry and +its importance in today’s world. I want to express my sincere +gratitude to my advisors for their guidance and recognition of my +team’s hard work. I am grateful for the opportunity to learn and +grow with such an amazing group of people. + +Pan, Ho Man Vivian +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 (Champion) + +in + +the HKGCC Case Competition was a + +Participating +truly +transformative experience that greatly enhanced my strategic +thinking, teamwork and problem-solving skills. The competition +challenged me to analyse intricate business problems, think critically +under pressure and develop innovative solutions. Working closely +with people of various majors allowed me to appreciate differing +opinions that were at times conflicting, find ways to build consensus +and synthesize ideas effectively. + +Students' achievements in case competitions +(2023-2025 awards) + +Overseas / Chinese Mainland + +Asia Pacific Sustainable Marketing Case Competition 2025 + +Third Place + +Bloomberg Global Trading Challenge 2023 + +CBS Case Competition 2023 + +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Asia Pacific Regional Final + +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Sub-Regional Final + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 - North Asia Final + +Champions' Trophy Case Competition 2024 + +Grand Prize Winner +Regional Prize Winner: Asia & Oceania + +Winner + +Winner + +Winner + +Champion + +Finalist + +China Mainland, Hong Kong and Macao Digital Economy Innovation and +Entrepreneurship Competition 2024 + +2nd Runner-up (Gold Medal) + +Deloitte Digital Camp 2024 + +Deloitte Digital Camp 2023 + +Second Place + +Champion + +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - National Round + +Outstanding Team Award + +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - Regional Round + +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - National Round + +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - Regional Round + +Top 3 teams + +Merit Award + +Top 3 teams + +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2023 Case Competition + +2nd Runner-up + +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2023 + +Investing in the Future University Competition 2023 +by Pictet Asset Management + +John Molson Undergraduate Case Competition 2025 + +Lazaridis International Case Conference 2023 + +Marshall International Case Competition 2024 + +McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 + +NHH International Case Competition 2024 + +Scotiabank International Case Competition 2023 + +Sydney International Business Competition 2025 + +Thammasat Undergraduate Business Challenge 2024 + +The Third KPMG ESG Case Study Competition + +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 + +UW Global Business Case Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Finalist + +1st Runner-up + +Finalist + +First Place + +Champion + +Winner + +Third Place + +1st Runner-up + +Third Prize + +Champion + +Finalists + +27 + +26 Local + +Local + +100WF Hong Kong JumpStart University Investment Hackathon 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2024 + +Champion + +ACCA Hong Kong Business Competition 2023 + +Outstanding Team for start-up Filix +Medtech + +Team Excellence Award + +Merit Award for start-up MakeOmnia + +Alvarez & Marsal Hong Kong Business Case Competition 2024 + +Champion & Best Presenter + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2023 + +Best Performer of Roma Risk Advisory +Limited + +1st Runner-up + +Merit + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +Merit & Finalist + +Semi-finalist + +Champion + +2nd Runner-up + +Best Presenter + +1st Runner-up + +HKU-Airstar Bank Joint University Case Competition 2024 + +HKU-SaSa Joint University Case Competition 2023 + +Hong Kong MBS Digital Economy Business Simulation Competition 2025 + +Third Place + +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2024 + +HSBC Life Insurance Competition 2025 + +HSBC Life Insurance Innovation Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Top 3 Winner + +1st Runner-up + +Best Use of Technology Award + +International MBS Business Management Simulation Competition 2023 + +Champion + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2025 + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2024 + +MBS Simulated Business Management Competition 2024 + +New Century Elite Development Programme 2023 + +Venture Capital On Campus (VCOC) - Investment Challenge 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Champion + +Third Place + +First place + +Best presenter + +Third Place + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Winner Team + +29 + +AmplifyME APAC M&A APAC Challenge 2025 + +Third Place + +BOCHK Challenge 2023 + +Bronze Award for Innovative Design + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2025 (Regional Final) + +1st Runner-up + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 (Semi-final Round) + +Deloitte USHINE Case Competition 2024 + +ESG Challenge 2023 + +EY Young Tax Professional of the Year 2023 - Hong Kong Region + +Champion + +Finalist + +Champion + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2025 Case Competition + +Champion + +HKCGI Corporate Governance Paper Competition and +Presentation Awards 2024 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2023/24 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 + +28 + +HKGCC Pitch Perfect Programme 2024 + +HKICPA Business Case Competition 2023 + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2025 + +1st Runner-up + +1st Runner-up (Paper Writing Competition) + +1st Runner-up (Paper Presentation +Competition) + +Audience’s Favourite Team Award + +Chevalier - Champion + +Chinachem Group - Champion + +Swire Pacific - Champion + +Chevalier - 1st Runner-up + +Chinachem - 1st Runner-up + +HKGCC - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - Champion + +SOCAM - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - 1st Runner-up + +MTR - 2nd Runner-up + +Overall Champion + +Winner + +2nd Runner-up + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Merit + + Chhawchharia, Mihika Amit +HSBC - Summer Analyst program + +internship, + +I collaborated closely with various +Throughout my +departments of the bank and +interacted regularly with senior +management, gaining comprehensive exposure to the bank’s operations. +This experience allowed me to hone my professional skills, including +communication, leadership, financial analysis, and market expertise. I +was honored to be ranked as the top intern in my cohort and secured a +return offer to join HSBC as a full-time graduate analyst in their Global +Banking division. I am deeply grateful for the knowledge and support I +received at HKU, which enabled me to thrive in a prestigious global +institution alongside some of the brightest talents in the industry. + +Internship Experience + +Lee, Chung Hong Calvin +HSBC - Global Risk Management Intern + +Reflecting on my time at HSBC, I realise that I have grown on a +professional and personal level. I have developed a deeper passion for +the banking industry and a greater appreciation for the critical role that +risk management and compliance play. I wore many hats and gained +precious insights into the banking industry. I was responsible for +overseeing compliance risks across 32 markets in Asia Pacific. I am +confident that the lessons I have learned at HSBC will guide me every +step of the way. + +Hui, Matthew +HSBC - International Banking (ISB) Intern - Corporate Coverage + +The comprehensive exposure to Corporate Banking was invaluable. From +analysing credit risk for lending applications to understanding diverse +product offerings for MNC clients, each day brought new learning +opportunities. I'm truly grateful for the experience of shadowing and +supporting different RMs in the team. Together with the sharing and +introductions from product partners, I learned how to identify clients' +needs and gained perspective on effectively reaching out and pitching to +clients. This experience taught me how to view banking relationships +through a strategic lens - understanding not just immediate needs but +trends. The +also anticipating +professional mindset, strategic thinking, and collaborative spirit fostered +during this internship will undoubtedly shape my future career path. + +future requirements and market + +Nagar, Tanvi +HSBC - International Banking Intern + +immense + +My internship experience was nothing short of incredible. Not only did I +grow immensely in my technical and professional skills but also +underwent an +journey of personal growth. I received +unparalleled support from the team and my mentors and gained an +in-depth insight into the field of banking and finance in Hong Kong. I +formed meaningful connections and grew my network. This experience +has truly shaped me and continues to propel my drive to pursue a career +in Banking in the years to come. + +3130 Sharma, Seerat +KPMG - Financial Services Audit Intern +(COOP3000 Cooperative Education Programme) + +I had the privilege of contributing to audit engagements for leading +clients in the banking and insurance sectors, where I conducted +substantive testing, supported risk assessments and navigated audit +methodologies using advanced tools. This role sharpened my analytical +mindset, strengthened my collaboration skills and offered a front-row +view into the dynamic world of financial auditing. It’s been a truly +rewarding journey that has solidified my passion for a career in +professional services. + +Xu, Aijing +CMB International Capital Corporation - Wealth Management Intern + +During my internship, I actively engaged with the product team in +market analysis and client pitching focused on mutual funds. I gained +valuable insights into various asset classes and macroeconomic +trends. Analyzing mutual fund performances and participating in +client meetings allowed me to contribute to investment portfolio +strategies. Collaborating with +team enhanced my +communication skills and understanding of client needs. Overall, this +experience deepened my knowledge of wealth management and +strengthened my passion for finance. + +the sales + +Shi, Yu Cheung Karson +Bank of China - Credit Summer Intern (Risk Management) + +During the internship, the financial techniques and business knowledge +I learned from HKU Business School courses helped a lot in company +financial analysis. By applying knowledge taught in the financial +accounting module, I assisted in evaluating loan demand. Through +cross-departmental collaborations, I also realised how classroom +simulations mirrored real-world risk mitigation challenges. This +experience reinforced the value of integrating academic theories with +dynamic market practices. + +Hu, Wen Qing +PwC Assurance Practice Intern + +As an assurance intern in PwC, I assisted my seniors with sampling +financial statement line items, reconciling balances, and documented +relevant non-financial information. It showed me how demanding the +auditing industry was, and allowed me to set my expectations for a +career in auditing as an accounting student. + +Wirawen, Karen +HKU – Neuberger Berman Private Equity Internship Programme + +You never truly understand private equity until you’re immersed in it +and my internship at Neuberger Berman was deeply enriching. Coming +in with limited knowledge, I gained direct exposure by working on +various deals across sectors and geographies, including Japan, Korea +and Southeast Asia. From drafting memos for the +investment +committee to attending annual general meetings and taking notes on +calls, I progressed from simple tasks to meaningful responsibilities. The +seniors were welcoming, always open to teaching, providing feedback +and offering valuable career advice. + +Chung, Marcus Lok Sum +Morgan Stanley Industrial Placement Intern + +During my internship with Sales & Trading (Institutional Equity +Division), I had the amazing opportunity to rotate across trading +and structuring desks where I was exposed to the fast-paced +environment especially during periods of high market volatility. To +see how traders manage positions and mitigate risks first-hand +was incredibly insightful. I also contributed to constructing trading +strategies and seeing the tangible impact of our work was deeply +rewarding. Morgan Stanley definitely provided me with a broader +perspective and understanding of market dynamics, liquidity, +client interactions and cross-asset opportunities. + +3332 Our Student Scholars + +Chan, Kwan Yin Cheryl +Recipient of Louisa Cheang Inspiration Scholarship 2024-25 + +I would like to express my gratitude for the Louisa Cheang Inspiration +Scholarship, which has significantly contributed to my personal and +professional growth. In the past academic year, this scholarship enabled +in the full-time Registered Visiting Student +me to participate +Programme at St Catherine’s College, University of Oxford. This +immersive experience enhanced my legal studies through engaging +discussions with scholars and participation in mooting competitions, +sharpening my research and advocacy skills. Additionally, I plan to +utilise this scholarship to pursue overseas postgraduate studies, +allowing me to deepen my understanding of the complexities of law in +a global context. + +Hussain, Iman +Recipient of FBE Student Contribution and +Innovation Award 2024-25 / +HKU Business School Future Leader Scholarship 2024-25 + +As someone who believes in learning through real-world experience, +the FBE Student Contribution and Innovation Award and the HKU +Business School Future Leader Scholarship have been life-changing. +They not only enabled me to go on an exchange semester to Cardiff, +where I explored new cultures and perspectives but also shaped my +entrepreneurial journey. + +With this support, I’ve been able to work on building a social +enterprise that aligns with my passion for creating meaningful impact. +I’m incredibly thankful for these opportunities to grow and make a +difference. + +Chow, Yee Shun Eason +Recipient of the Jardine HKU Scholarship 2024-25 + +It is an incredible honour to have received the Jardine HKU Scholarship +which is enriching my university journey! This scholarship allowed me to +pursue my many goals – from attending international training camps as +a handball player to participating in overseas exchanges without +financial worries. I have had the privilege of undertaking a summer +internship at the Jardine Group, learning from seasoned professionals in +my future industry. The Jardine Foundation also hosted exciting +networking activities and site visits which helped me build lasting +connections with fellow scholars in a vibrant community. + +Shih, Pui Hei Iris +Recipient of the Hong Kong Jockey Club Scholarships - +Undergraduate Scholarship 2024-25 + +This scholarship has been transformative to my university life as it has +allowed me to fully embrace and explore the world beyond the +classroom. It provided the financial stability I needed to focus on my +studies and presented opportunities for me to participate in diverse +extracurricular activities. These experiences broadened my perspective +and opened me to different points of view. + +Nurgali, Adilzhan +Recipient of BOC Hong Kong - +One Belt One Road Scholarship 2024-25 + +It means a lot to me to be awarded the BOC Hong Kong - One Belt One +Road Scholarship. It was not +just about financial support but +recognition of the hard work I have put in. As an international student +soon heading for exchange, this award gives me the freedom to explore +new cultures and experiences without extra stress. I am truly grateful to +be part of such an inclusive and supportive community. + +3534 2026 JUPAS Admissions + +Admissions criteria (HKDSE) + +Local candidates applying on the strength of the Hong Kong Diploma of +Secondary Education (HKDSE) are required to fulfil the minimum entrance +requirements for HKU Business School programmes as shown below: + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +EngEng ≥ +Level 4 or above in English Language +ChinChin ≥ +Level 3 or above in Chinese Language1 +MathMath ≥ +Level 3 or above in Mathematics + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +AA + +CSDCSD = +Grade “Attained (A)” in +Citizenship and Social Development2 + +2x + +Elective +Elective +Subjects +Subjects + +≥ + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 or above in two Elective Subjects + +For BBA(BA), BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) +In addition to the minimum entrance requirements above, candidates applying for the BBA(BA), +BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) programmes shall also obtain the following results in the +HKDSE examination: + +BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) +≥ +Level 3 or above in one of the following subjects: + +Level 3 + +Biology + +BAFS + +Chemistry + +Economics + +ICT + +Physics + +BBA(BA) + +BSc(MAT) + +Level 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics is also preferred by BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) but not +strictly required. + +BBA(Law)&LLB / BBA(IBGM) / BSc(QFin) + +BBA(Law)&LLB + +BBA(IBGM) + +BSc(QFin) + +EngEng ≥ + +Level 5 +Level 5 -Did You Know? +Chin, Math +Chin, Math ≥ -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. +Level 4 +Level 4 -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. +EngEng ≥ -Where: Oklahoma City +Level 5 +Level 5 -When: 1937 ++ -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. ++ -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. +M1/M2 +M1/M2 ≥ -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. +Level 3 +Level 3 -7 +MathMath ≥ - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +Level 4 +Level 4 -Business Benefits of Being Memorable +Application -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business +For details of the 2026 JUPAS exercise, please visit www.jupas.edu.hk. -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding +Programme Scoring Formula -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for +For more information on the Programme Scoring Formula and Subject Weightings, please +visit the Admissions Office’s website at https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas. -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: +Note 1: Non-Chinese-speaking applicants will be considered on a case-by-case basis.Note 2: The result(s) of Liberal Studies at Level 2 or above achieved in previous sitting(s) will also be considered.Level 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inChinese Language1 & MathematicsLevel 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inMathematicsLevel 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics3736 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions -81% +Selection process and entrance requirements -59% +Eligibility +(1) Local students applying for admission on international qualifications other than the -73% +HKDSE examination; -35% +(2) Non-local students with international qualifications other than Chinese Mainland's -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). +National Joint College Entrance Examination (NJCEE/Gao Kao). -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. +Application Procedures +All non-JUPAS applications should be submitted via the online application system by noon of +November 26, 2025 (Hong Kong Time) for the first-round evaluation. Scanned copies of the +following documents should also be uploaded by the application deadline. -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. +(1) Official prediction of grades or scores from your current high school (if available); -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. +(2) All internal and public examination results during your senior secondary education; and -84% +(3) Academic reference letter (optional) -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. +Late submission of supporting documents will delay the consideration of application. -40% +Shortlisted applicants for BSc(QFin) will be interviewed; optional interviews for other +programmes will be arranged if necessary. -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. +University and Programme Entrance Requirements +Due to the complex combination of education background of applicants, each application will +be assessed individually on its own merits. Non-JUPAS applicants are advised to refer to the +standards and requirements on the website of the Admissions Office of the University before +making an application: -8 +(1) Admissions standards (International Qualifications or National Qualifications); - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +(2) Programme specific subject requirements; and -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. +(3) English language requirement -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 +In particular, please note that the expected lower boundary for admissions listed on the +website is provided for reference purposes only. Admissions is competitive in nature and +achieving the expected lower boundary does not guarantee admission to the programme. +The actual admission grade or score will be dependent on the overall quality of applications +received in the 2026 admissions exercise. -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). +Announcement of Result +Offer results will be released from December 2025 onwards. All application status will be +updated in the online application system once an admissions decision has been made. +Applicants should check their application status online regularly. -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. +More Details +For further information about the application procedures and admissions +standards, +at +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications. -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. +the Admissions Office’s website -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. +please -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. +visit -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. +2026 Dual Degree Admissions -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programmes, in addition to the +application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS Admissions Scheme. -9 +For details of the dual degrees and the application procedures, please visit +the Admissions Office’s website at +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university-collaborative-programmes. - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail +3938 Develop Your Career -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. +Freshmen Sharing -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” +Upon graduation, over 82% of our students begin their careers in the commerce and industry sector. Others either +move on to further studies or explore opportunities with the civil service, education institutions and +community/social services. -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. +Career Prospects -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. +Companies/organisations that have offered full-time positions to our graduates include but not limited to the +following: -The Connected Screen +Accenture Company Limited +Bank of China (Hong Kong) Limited +BDO International Limited +Bloomberg L.P. +Citibank (Hong Kong) Limited +Crédit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank +Credit Suisse Group AG +Deloitte Advisory (Hong Kong) Limited +Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited +Deutsche Bank +Ernst & Young +Goldman Sachs (Asia) LLC +Hang Seng Bank Limited +HKSAR Government +Hong Kong Monetary Authority +JPMorgan Chase & Co. +KPMG +Morgan Stanley +PricewaterhouseCoopers Limited +Standard Chartered Bank (Hong Kong) Limited +The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation +Limited (HSBC) +UBS Group AG + +Full employment +for the 19th + +consecutive year + +98.7% + +was the average salary of +our 2024 graduates + +$36,770 + +of our 2024 graduates have +received at least 2 job offers +upon graduation + +57% + +Kantbek, Yerassyl +BBA + +I chose HKU Business School because Hong Kong is +one of the world’s most competitive financial centres, +offering a dynamic environment to grow. HKU +combines +real-world +rigorous academics with +experiences, such as Asia-focused case studies and +competitions like HICS, which I plan to join in Year 2. I +am particularly drawn to programs in marketing and +finance, as well as opportunities for entrepreneurship +through the Techno-Entrepreneurship Core and +iDendron incubator. With a diverse student body and +global exchange options, I look forward to learning +from peers, connecting with mentors, and developing +skills to make a meaningful impact in business. + +The main reason I chose HKU, particularly HKU +Business School, lies in its global connections and +strong partnerships with other institutions and +respected organizations, which I believe will be +advantageous for future employment opportunities. +I expect to embrace challenges over the course of my +four years at the university, as these will be vital for +my intellectual and social maturity. The first time I +visited the campus, I was amazed by the diversity of +the students and +facilities, which +demonstrated that the university is truly a place for +everyone. One of the many great opportunities +offered here is the chance to travel for studies, which +I would rank among my highest interests. + +the open + +Pernice, Audrey Yiwen +BEcon&Fin + +4140 The main reason I chose BBA(IBGM) is its flexibility in allowing +students to choose a second major, as well as the numerous +overseas exchange opportunities. I am also fortunate to have +been admitted as a member of the HKU International Case +Society (HICS), where I get to know people from other programs +who are also interested in the realm of business. HKU Business +School provides me with the perfect platform to strike a balance +between my work and life. + +Ho, Lik Hang Gordon +BBA(IBGM) + +Lo, Hoi Tung Reacker +BSc(MAT) + +I chose HKU Business School for its professional background and +diverse opportunities. The multidisciplinary programme allows me to +pursue Marketing Analytics and Technology, aligning with my varied +interests in business and STEM. As a freshman, I am eager to embrace +exciting experiences such as internships and exchanges. I look +forward to gaining insights from fellow students and professionals +through upcoming career events. With the strong support from HKU, +I am committed to developing my entrepreneurial skills and pursuing +my dreams without regrets! + +Drawn by HKU’s global prestige and the excellence of HKU Business +School, I chose to pursue Quantitative Finance at HKU to deepen my +passion for quantitative trading and data-driven decision-making. +The school’s flexible curriculum empowers me to explore +complementary fields such as computer science, statistics, and risk +management. As a target school for top investment banks, HKU +also offers unparalleled career exposure. HKU provides the ideal +environment to grow academically and professionally, and I am +excited to explore the many opportunities ahead. + +Tsang, Chun Shing Patrick +BSc(QFin) + +Fung, Yat Hang Rex +BFin(AMPB) + +My aspiration for BFin(AMPB) was ignited early in high school by its +unparalleled, practitioner-focused design, a curriculum that truly +bridges finance theory with industry practice. This conviction was +solidified through the heartfelt guidance of our Programme +Director, Professor Anna Wong, who mentored me even before I +officially joined HKU, while I was an apprentice at a US bank. + +Now, experiencing BFin(AMPB) firsthand, the transition from the +professional world to the classroom feels seamless. It is this +powerful integration of theory and real-world practice that makes +AMPB incomparable. HKUBS has instantly instilled in me a sense of +ownership, this is not just a school, but a launchpad for impact, and +I am thrilled to begin the next chapter of my growth here. + +I was drawn to BBA(IBGM) because of HKU’s +world-renowned academic reputation and its vibrant, +international community. I believe a truly “global +business” education extends beyond the classroom, +through experiential learning opportunities, daily +interactions with local and non-local peers, and +participation in hall and student society cultures, I will +gain a more dynamic and holistic multidisciplinary +perspective on the business world. Over the coming +four years, I am eager to harness these opportunities +to become a well-rounded leader and effective +problem-solver for my future career on the global +business stage. + +Yan, Sung Hei Christopher +BBA(IBGM) + +4342 Our Global Presence + +Israel - +Tel Aviv + +Beijing + +Shenzhen + +Hong Kong + +Vietnam - +Ho Chi Minh City + +Useful Websites +The University of Hong Kong (HKU) + +Undergraduate Admissions +https://admissions.hku.hk/ -What’s on sale -today? +HKU – Entrance Requirements -Where can I find -salsa? +For JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas -Deals & -Coupons +For non-JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications -Location -Tracking +HKU Business School -What’s for -dinner? +Overview of Undergraduate Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme -Video -Recipes +Enrichment Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/student-enrichment -Can I skip -checkout? +Other HKU Websites -Pay on -Cart +Mainland Affairs Office (MAO) +https://mainlandaffairs.hku.hk/ -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. +Centre of Development and Resources for +Students (CEDARS) +https://www.cedars.hku.hk/ -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 +44 -1 -0 +45 diff --git a/q238/random_k2/question.json b/q238/random_k2/question.json index f9a1345202c767a3b1580d8ecc29fdd9a02faaba..a9c6ba62b1cfd54a14acb2fb6df50770846868f8 100644 --- a/q238/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q238/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "AMAZON_2017_10K.pdf", - "web_7f91d188bac86e23.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf" + "web_1a2336a3f9985b16.pdf", + "web_f539c13fe18de9dd.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q238/random_k2/random_1.md b/q238/random_k2/random_1.md index 89a0e0d7330b5b5f606ca129bb50b359ffb607a6..25d042d2700fe60a9ddce47f4b189314f01660d3 100644 --- a/q238/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q238/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,299 +1,1150 @@ -Wikidata's SPARQL +ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL +GOVERNANCE REPORT -introduction for beginners +2020 -CC BY-SA -Lucie-Aimée Kaffee + Table of -Frimelle -@lucielinde +Contents - What is turtle? +Table of Contents -RDF triple language +Letter -Subject Predicate Object +Compassion -as Web URI +Products -Alan Turing (Q7251) instance of (P31) human (Q5) +People -RDF - +Planet -turtle -@prefix wd: +Community -@prefix wdt: +Future of ESG -wd:Q7251 wdt:P31 wd:Q5 +ESG Governance - What is SPARQL? +Company Facts -RDF query language +2 -to form complex queries with SELECT and retrieve data from an endpoint +6 -Return all items, which are instance of human, limited to 200 items. +8 -PREFIX wd: +14 -PREFIX wdt: +18 -SELECT ?subject WHERE { ?subject wdt:P31 wd:Q5 . } LIMIT 200 +22 - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +26 -Show all data for Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +30 -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +34 -Extract of the result +38 -predicate + A year of -rdfs:label +Transformation -rdfs:label + Le�er -object +from our CEO -Alan Turing +Vivek Sankaran | Chief Executive Officer -ﺞﻧروﺗ نﻻآ +2020 was a year of transformation for many, and +our company was no exception. The events of last +year brought to the surface the positive impact our +company has on our customers and communities. +I would like to thank each of our 300,000 associates +for their unwavering commitment to serving our +communities during such unprecedented times. -skos:altLabel +Throughout the pandemic, our teams acted swiftly +to implement in-store safety measures, keep food +and supplies on the shelves for customers, and +distribute COVID-19 vaccinations in partnership with +the Department of Health and Human Services. -Алан Цюрынг +As our communities faced rising food insecurity, +Albertsons Companies, the Albertsons Companies +Foundation Nourishing Neighbors program, and our +customers stepped up to help those in need. We set a +record $260 million in food and monetary donations to +aid hunger relief organizations in our local communities. +This helped us reach 13 million individuals and over +3,000 organizations. - +When acts of racism and inequity shook our +communities, we came together as a company to +support one another and stand united in the face of +prejudice, hatred, and intolerance. We are committed +to equality and are driven by our guiding principle to be +a diverse and inclusive team. - +Letter -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) +I’m proud that over the past year we have not only +increased our diverse representation at all levels of +the company, but have also prioritized Diversity, Equity, +and Inclusion training, created opportunities to have +courageous conversations, and outlined a framework +to continue to improve. As part of these efforts, we +committed $5 million to social justice & equality causes. - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +In the face of these challenges, our teams still made +meaningful progress to reduce our impact on the +environment. As part of this, we recently announced +our commitment to setting a science-based target to +reduce carbon emissions. This broadens our existing +environmental commitments, which include making +100% of our Own Brands packaging recyclable, reusable, +or industrially compostable by 2025. -Show all fields of work of Alan Turing +Looking Ahead +In 2020, we completed a new materiality assessment, +which will be the foundation for our Environmental +Social Governance (ESG) strategy and initiatives going +forward. Through this process we identified high priority +areas that align with our long-term company strategy +and are most critical to our stakeholders, including +Climate Action, Community Stewardship, Diversity, +Equity & Inclusion, and Waste Reduction & Circularity. +I am encouraged by the progress we made in 2020, +as it established a framework from which we can +accelerate our efforts. + +We have a bold vision for the future and will soon +be launching commitments with specific metrics to +measure our progress. I invite you to learn more about +our progress in 2020 in this report, and I look forward +to sharing more with you in the coming months. + +Vivek + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +7 + +6 + + Compassion +core +business + +is at the + +our + +of + +2020 was an unprecedented +year, and we are proud of the +unwavering commitment our +teams showed to supporting +each other, our customers, +and our communities. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +9 + +8 + + COVID-19 +Times of extraordinary need require an +unprecedented response, and we’re +thankful to our associates for their +commitment to safety and supporting +our neighbors during the COVID-19 +pandemic. Their amazing work and +dedication created hope within our +communities during uncertain times. +Ensuring the health and safety of our +associates, customers, and communities +was our top priority in 2020. + +COMMUNITIES: There has never been +a more important time to help our +neighbors than during the COVID-19 crisis. +As hunger relief programs were stretched +to capacity, we pledged $53 million and +started a fundraising campaign through +the Albertsons Companies Foundation +Nourishing Neighbors program. +Additionally, our generous customers +donated more than $67 million +to our Nourishing Neighbor hunger relief +campaigns throughout 2020. + +We developed new partnerships to +support businesses and their employees +as companies had to close or scale back +operations. We offered streamlined job +application processes to employees that +were furloughed or had hours reduced at +other hospitality and retail companies. We +purchased supplies from the restaurant +and service industries to keep food from +going to waste and ensure our customers +could find the products they needed. + +Compassion + +CUSTOMERS: Our stores offered +senior citizens and vulnerable +customers dedicated shopping +hours to ensure all customers had +the opportunity to get the items +they needed. Additionally, we +expanded our Grocery Delivery, +Drive Up & Go, and Pharmacy Delivery +services so customers could have +contact-free shopping experiences. + +As of June 19, 2021, we have +administered more than 6 million +COVID-19 vaccines through our 1,700 +pharmacies. We continue to offer our +customers new resources to help them +navigate this health crisis, including +digital vaccine records and rapid +antigen self-tests. + +ASSOCIATES: For the safety of our +employees and customers, we +implemented social distancing and +face mask requirements, rigorous +cleaning and disinfecting procedures, +health checks before the start of shifts, +and plexiglass barriers at check stands. + +To show our gratitude, we gave all +front-line associates temporary +Appreciation Pay, bonuses, and +other benefits. + +Through the Albertsons Companies +Foundation's We Care Fund, we also +provided more than $800,000 to support +associates experiencing unanticipated +or unavoidable hardships. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +11 + +10 + + Social Justice +Courtesy, Dignity, and Respect are core values at Albertsons +Companies. They are the foundation of our associate training, +and by living these principles, we strive to make a difference in +our operations, communities, and beyond. We condemn hate or +discrimination of any kind, and this past year has underscored +the importance of standing together to boldly face inequity and +injustice head on. + +SUPPORTING CAUSES TO ADVANCE SOCIAL JUSTICE: +Last year, we formed a Racial Justice & Equity Advisory Group, +which advised us on our $5 million commitment from Albertsons +Companies and the Albertsons Companies Foundation to the +following social justice organizations to help our communities lay +a foundation for racial equity and social justice: + +$1 million + +donation toward our African +American Associate Resource +Group’s efforts to partner with +local organizations who support +communities and neighborhood +actions in our market areas. + +$1 million + +donation to the City of Chicago’s +Together Now fund. + +$2 million -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +donation toward the social +justice efforts of the NAACP Legal +Defense and Education Fund +and the National +Urban League Inc. - On Wikidata Query Service Beta +$1 million -Result Result +reserve fund for social justice +and diversity initiatives in the +future, including community +outreach, supplier diversity, +and ongoing education. -object +Compassion - +Listening with compassion +and taking action when it is - +needed are critical to ensuring +that racism and hatred have no +place at our company. -label +– Vivek Sankaran, CEO -computer science +SUPPORTING ASSOCIATES: +Last year we seized the opportunity to prioritize courageous +conversations within our teams to achieve meaningful change. +To create a safe and inclusive environment where associates +could share thoughts, feelings, and experiences, we held company- +wide town halls, reenergized our Associate Resource Groups, +and launched an interactive workshop, “Leading with Inclusion.” -cryptanalysis +We continuously review our Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DE&I) +practices and training, and are always working to do more +and better. In 2020, we launched a new DE&I aspiration and +accompanying framework to achieve it. Since then, we have +been diligently working on expanding programs and resources +across our company. -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) and cryptanalysis (Q897511) +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +13 -Data linked to Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +12 -On Wikidata Query Service Beta + Products -Extract of the result +Meeting the demands of +an evolving marketplace -subject + • -predicate + • - + • - +100% of O Organics® and Open +Nature® shell and liquid eggs +are cage-free. All Own Brands +hard-boiled eggs are cage-free - +100% of O Organics coffee is +Certified Fair Trade™ - +100% of our Open Nature® and +Waterfront BISTRO® seafood meets +our Responsible Seafood Policy +and is clearly marked with our +Responsible Choice logo - + • Donated ~$500,000 since - +launching debi lilly design™ +Extending Smiles bouquets -* +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 - +15 - Truthy and full statements +14 -represents statements in two formats + Products -truthy -contain only the statements of best rank +Plastics and Packaging Pledge +We made our Plastics and Packaging Pledge in 2019 to advance sustainability +throughout the company, starting with our extensive Own Brands portfolio. -best rank are all statements of preferred rank, if those exist or all statements of normal rank + • -qualifiers are ignored +100% of Own Brands packaging will be recyclable, reusable, or industrially +compostable by 2025 -Prefix wdt: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/) - e.g. wdt:P101 + • Own Brands plastic packaging will include 20% recycled content by 2025 -full statements -represent all data about a statement + • Own Brands products will have clear recycling communications on packaging -represented in a separate node with the unique id of the statement - e.g. q92741-7ED21209-4E23-4EB1-886A-772CC6A5350F +by 2022 via platforms such as How2Recycle© and Smart Label© -Prefix p: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/) - e.g. p:P101 +We are diligently working toward achieving our Pledge, and customers can find +updated examples of recycling communications on many of our products today. - Full statements +We put a lot of effort into helping +people live better lives and +strengthening the communities +where we do business. By +responsibly sourcing our O +Organics coffee, Albertsons +Companies is demonstrating +its commitment to improving +livelihoods and the environment. -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +– Chad Coester, Senior Vice +President, Albertsons Companies +Own Brands -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +Fair Trade Certified™ Coffee +In 2020, we transitioned our O Organics +coffee to 100% Fair Trade Certified™ sources, +meeting our Sustainable Coffee Challenge +Commitment. Purchases of our Fair Trade +Certified™ coffee generated more than +$650,000 in community development funds +for coffee farmers, their families, and +communities in 2020. -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +This coffee is certified to rigorous standards, +providing safe working conditions, upholding +fundamental human rights, and helping to +protect the environment in our sourcing +regions — including Ethiopia, Peru, Honduras, +and Colombia. -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -ps:P1082 10000 ; +17 -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +16 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . + People -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +Supporting employees +to reach their full potential -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) + • First national grocery chain to join the +Business Coalition for the Equality Act -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; + • -the population is 10000 ; +Integrated Diversity & Inclusion goals +into more than 5,000 top leaders’ +performance plans -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; + • Conducted more than 120 “Leading -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +With Inclusion” sessions, with 4,000+ +total participants - Full statements + • 70+ women recognized by leading -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +industry publications -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; + • We have 6 Associate Resource Groups +to enable an inclusive and welcoming +culture among our associates -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +Albertsons Companies +Associate Resource Groups -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +ALLIANCE -ps:P1082 10000 ; +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +19 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +18 -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; + Our Aspiration +Reflect the rich diversity of the communities we serve by offering our associates, +suppliers, and customers equitable access to opportunities and resources. -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Framework -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +In 2020, we introduced our Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Aspiration, along with +a 6-part framework to achieve it: -the population is 10000 ; +1. -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +Inclusion & Belonging -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +4. - Full statements +Impactful Associate Resource Groups -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +2. Hiring & Promotion -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +3. Talent Development -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +5. Community Engagement -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +6. Metrics -ps:P1082 10000 ; +We strive to reflect the diversity of our communities within our management and +throughout our company. As part of our framework to achieve this, we are measuring +our progress by tracking metrics, such as representation. -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +Representation at Albertsons Companies -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +VP & Above Companywide -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +U.S. +Demographics2 -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +Women -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +22% -the population is 10000 ; +49% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +51% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +People of Color1 - Full statements +Black/African American -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +Hispanic/Latino -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +Asian/Asian American -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +Other -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +4% -ps:P1082 10000 ; +5% -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +8% -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +4% -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +10% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +22% -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +6% -the population is 10000 ; +3% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +12% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +19% - Example Query +6% -Who’s birthday is today? +5% -P569: date of birth +1 Associate did not disclose: 3% VP & Above; 4% Companywide +2 2020 U.S. Census Data -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +People - Ressources +We formed a National Diversity Council that is chaired by our CEO, Vivek Sankaran, +to advance DE&I within our company. In addition, each of our 12 operating Divisions +have Diversity Councils and we have individual councils for our Technology +& Engineering, Digital & Consumer, and Supply Chain departments. These councils +collectively host monthly town halls and fireside chats to discuss Diversity, Equity +& Inclusion subjects such as anti-Asian hate, the verdict in the George Floyd murder +trial, and other timely topics. -Wikidata Query Service Beta +We continue to expand opportunities for our associates to learn more about +DE&I, including: -http://wdqs-beta.wmflabs.org/ + • Monthly trainings to top 5,500 leaders to continue their education about how to -Mediawiki: RDF Dump Format +be more inclusive -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format + • Bi-annual store and supply chain huddles to further embed DE&I into our frontline -Prefixes used for Wikidata +We must continue to set +the example of Courtesy, +Dignity, and Respect towards +everyone who walks through +our doors. -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format#Prefixes_used +– Vivek Sankaran, CEO + Albertsons Companies -Mediawiki: Query Examples +Training & +Development +Our associates are the key +component to delighting our +customers. As such, we are proud +to offer a myriad of opportunities +to grow and advance. Over the +last year, our associates from +the frontlines to our offices +completed over 6 million hours +of training through various +programs, including on-the-job +training, mentoring programs, +eLearning, and classroom-style +events. We have also partnered +with industry associations to +provide access to relevant +continuing retail education +opportunities through colleges +around the country. -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/SPARQL_Query_Examples +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -github: wikidata query rdf docs +21 -https://github.com/wikimedia/wikidata-query-rdf/tree/master/docs +20 -Wikidata turtle dumps + Planet -https://dumps.wikimedia.org/wikidatawiki/entities/ +Minimizing our impact +on the planet -W3C RDF Primer + • Completed 800+ energy -http://www.w3.org/2007/02/turtle/primer/ +efficiency projects that will +annually save 2 million+ metric +tons of CO2e + + • Enabled 160+ electric vehicle +charging stations to date + + • Recycled more than 880 million + +pounds of cardboard + + • Recycled more than 26 million + +pounds of plastic bags and film + + • Private fleet is 100% US EPA Smart + +Way certified + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +23 + +22 + + Reducing Our +Energy Use +Every year, our teams implement +hundreds of energy efficiency +projects to reduce our energy use +in our stores, plants, distribution +centers, and offices. Some projects, +like Energy Management System +or HVAC upgrades, happen +behind the scenes, but installing +doors on refrigerated cases and +transitioning to LED lights are +energy efficiency projects that our +customers can see in our stores. + +In fiscal year 2020, we +completed more than 800 +energy efficiency projects that +are estimated to annually save +more than 2 million metric +tons of CO2e — an equivalent +savings of taking 430,000 cars +off the road each year! + +Generating +Renewable Energy +We have more than 50 on-site +solar arrays and two wind turbines +providing our operations with +renewable energy. Our renewable +energy procurement has made +us a top 30 company in the US +EPA's Green Power Partnership. + +In the spring of 2021, we committed +to setting a science-based +target and our investments in +on-site renewable energy and +the purchase of renewable +energy credits will be important +enablers to achieving our goals. + +Planet + +Through this program, +Albertsons and Safeway +stores in Arizona will invest +in, and use, renewable +energy while adding +more solar power to +Arizona’s grid. We are +honored to support Salt +River Project's promise +to deliver more clean +energy to customers. + +– Michelle Larson, +President of +Albertsons Companies +Southwest Division + +Impactful Partnerships +Collaborating with our peers and suppliers helps us to develop and implement best +practices, create innovative solutions, and reduce our impact on the planet. + +Utilizing Clean Energy Efficiently: As a longtime partner of the Salt River Project +(SRP), our Southwest Division was awarded SRP’s 2020 Sustained Excellence Award +for our ongoing commitment to energy efficiency. As one of the first companies to +participate in the SRP’s Sustainable Energy Offering, 40 of our Arizona locations are +receiving renewable energy from a new solar plant. + +Reducing Food Waste: As part of the Pacific Coast Food Waste Commitment, +we are working together with retailers and local and state governments to reduce +food waste in the Pacific Coast region by 50% by 2030. + +Identifying Sustainable Retail Bags: To find sustainable alternatives to the +single-use plastic bag, we joined the Consortium to Reinvent the Retail Bag, a +collaborative group of retailers that launched the Beyond the Bag Initiative and is +piloting innovative solutions. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +25 + +24 + + Community + +Supporting causes that impact our +customers’ lives + + • Donated more than 83 million pounds of food + +to our Feeding America partners + + • Administered 6 million COVID-19 vaccinations + +through July 19, 2021 + + • Won the “Community Hero Award” at Benevity’s + +2020 Corporate Goodness Awards for The Albertsons +Companies Foundation’s best-in-class approach to +community investment + + • Earned the silver award in Engage for Good's +2020 America's Charity Checkout Champions +Awards for the Albertsons Companies Foundation's +point-of-sale fundraising + + • Raised more than $11 million for causes important to +our local communities, including education, cancer +research and treatment, programs for people with +disabilities and veterans’ outreach + + • Piloted in-school curriculum to help kids learn + +what they can do to help stop hunger within their +own communities + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +27 + +26 + + We are committed to help feed our neighbors in need. + +$95 million + +given to our communities + +13 million + +individuals reached + +3,000+ + +organizations helped + +350 million + +meals + +$9 million + +invested in empowering +BIPOC communities through +hunger programs + +$10.4 million + +invested in schools to feed kids +during the pandemic + +$472,000 + +to support +feeding seniors + +$4 million + +invested in innovative programs +to unlock new ways to feed +our neighbors + +65,000 + +people connected +with SNAP benefits + +Supporting Community Organizations +With a grant from the Albertsons Companies Nourishing Neighbors program, the +LGBTQ Community Center of the Desert in California was able to purchase a cargo van +to help distribute food to those in need in the community. + +Having the van has been a HUGE help when we’re prepping for our Thursday night food +distribution every week. In the last month, The Center has converted our van into a mobile +pantry, providing more than 125 families with emergency relief boxes. We’ve been fortunate to +build relationships with community leaders that are dedicated to support these rural areas. + +– LGBTQ Community Center of the Desert + +Community + +We Care is a voluntary associate-sponsored disaster relief and personal hardship fund +providing financial support to our communities and fellow associates in times of crisis. + +During 2020, more than 300 grants totaling more than $800,000 were given out to +support our associates and communities during hardships. + +Thank you very much. The We +Care program really helps. It’s +been reassuring to know that +I work for a company that +has my back. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +We Care was instrumental +in getting me going in a +positive direction. I have since +signed up to donate weekly. +A fantastic program that has +helped many in my division. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +Thank you so much, this is +super helpful in this trying +time. As a single dad, it's +been a little overwhelming +during the pandemic and +this is a great help and a +wonderful thing. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +29 + +28 + + The + +future + +of ESG +at Albertsons Companies + +Recognizing the importance of Environmental Social +Governance (ESG) to our customers, associates, and +investors, we refreshed our Materiality Assessment +to prioritize how we address ESG. This assessment +identified our internal and external stakeholder’s +top-ranking ESG topic areas, and the outcome has +shaped our bold vision for the future. In the coming +months, we will release our new ESG strategy and +commitment for the four Tier 1 topics identified: +Climate Action, Community Stewardship, Diversity, +Equity & Inclusion, and Waste Reduction & Circularity. + +Our efforts in these areas will support a +healthier planet and vibrant communities, +and I look forward to sharing our new ESG +strategy and commitments soon. + +– Vivek Sankaran, +CEO of Albertsons Companies + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +31 + +30 + + Identifying Our ESG Priorities +We analyzed 19 ESG topics specific to our business and industry and worked +with stakeholders to better understand where we should focus our efforts. We +conducted interviews and surveys with internal business leaders, customers, +investors, suppliers, industry groups, and included insights from industry reports +and ESG rating agencies. Based on the responses received we aggregated topics +into ranked, or "tiered," priorities. + +Tier 1 +Invest time and +resources to set goals, +advance our efforts, +and regularly report +on progress. + +Tier 2 +Proactively manage +performance and +report on continuous +improvement. + +Tier 3 +Develop policies, +position statements, +and brand standards as +needed, and report on +activities as appropriate. + +Foundational +Focus on internal +excellence to proactively +minimize risk and meet +or exceed regulatory +requirements. + +l + +s +r +e +d +o +h +e +r +a +h +S +o +t +e +c +n +a +t +r +o +p +m + +I + +Importance to Business + +We plotted responses into a +prioritization matrix, and the +ranked results are guiding +our new ESG strategy + +Future of ESG + +Our ESG + +priorities + +The Results of our Materiality Assessment + +Tier 1 + • Climate Action (focus on +energy and emissions) + +Tier 2 + • Customer Health + +& Wellness + + • Community Stewardship + + • Supplier Environmental + + • Diversity, Equity + +& Inclusion + + • Waste Reduction + +Stewardship + + • Supplier Social +Responsibility + +& Circularity (focus on +food waste, plastics, and +consumer packaging) + + • Sustainable Products + +& Ingredients + +Tier 3 + • Animal Welfare + + • Product Marketing +& Transparency + + • Water Stewardship + +Foundational + • Data Privacy & Security + + • Employee Attraction, + +Development & Retention + + • Employee Health & Safety + + • Governance Ethics & Compliance + + • Product Safety + + • Resilience & Adaptation + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +33 + +32 + + ESG Governance +Overview + +Bringing together our dedicated ESG +team with cross-functional business units +ensures our ESG goals and values are +incorporated into our business decisions +and strategic plans. With our operating +divisions’ localized expertise, our corporate +teams’ support, and the oversight by our +Board of Directors, our company is both +locally great and nationally strong. +This helps us to identify and act upon the +greatest opportunities to create a healthy +planet and vibrant neighborhoods. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +35 + +34 + + ESG Governance + +ESG Governance +Albertsons Companies is +committed to responsible +corporate governance. Our ESG +Team collaborates with teams +and leaders across our company +to help drive and report on our +environmental and social impact. +Our ESG Council brings together +leaders that drive initiatives within +our product, people, planet, and +community reporting platforms to +report progress and discuss new +programs, risks, and opportunities. + +Our Governance, Compliance & +ESG Board Committee oversees +risks associated with corporate +governance, business conduct and +ethics, ESG, and the management +of compliance and regulatory risks. + +Management teams regularly +report on applicable risks and +opportunities to the relevant +Board committees or the full +Board of Directors. + +ESG Council +(Cross-Functional Team) + +ESG +Team + +Governance, +Compliance & ESG +Board Committee + +Board +of Directors + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +37 + +36 + + Company Facts + +2,277 Retail Stores + +22 Distribution Centers + +20 Manufacturing Plants + +note: all numbers from FY 2020 + +$70 billion + +YE 2020 Sales + +30 million+ + +customers per week + +1,727 + +in-store pharmacies + +exclusive billion-dollar Own Brands + +4 + +25 million+ + +loyalty members + +~300,000 + +jobs provided by one of the +largest retail employers + +$260 million+ + +donated in 2020 through +our Albertsons Foundation + +$1 billion + +invested in COVID-19 +related expenses; +including expansive safety protocols + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +39 + +Albertsons Companies is a leading food and drug +retailer in the United States, with both a strong local +presence and national scale. Albertsons Companies +is committed to helping people across the country +live better lives by making a meaningful difference, +neighborhood by neighborhood. + +38 + + 250 E. Parkcenter Blvd. +Boise, ID 83706 + +albertsonscompanies.com diff --git a/q238/random_k2/random_2.md b/q238/random_k2/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..f28bcc1c1e50866e33c7f4488c244d56c08f6e52 100644 --- a/q238/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q238/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,862 +1,628 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +G R M I N G M O N I T O R -2 +U S E R G U I D E - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy +-1- -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +LCD Monitor User's Manual Copyright - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between +© 2020 GIGA-BYTE TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. All rights reserved. -them +The trademarks mentioned in this manual are legally registered to their +respective owners. - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a +Disclaimer -stable dividend +Information in this manual is protected by copyright laws and is the +property of GIGABYTE. +Changes to the specifications and features in this manual may be made +by GIGABYTE without prior notice. +No part of this manual may be reproduced, copied, translated, +transmitted, or published in any form or by any means without +GIGABYTE’s prior written permission. -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience +• - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised +• -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode + In order to assist in the use of this monitor, carefully read the User +Guide. + For more information, check on our website at: https://www. +gigabyte.com + +-2- - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia +LCD Monitor User's Manual SafETy INfORMaTION + +Regulatory Notices -and from our international network +United States of america, federal Communications +Commission Statement - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive +Supplier’s Declaration of Conformity +47 CfR § 2.1077 Compliance Information + +Product Name: LCD monitor +Trade Name: GIGABYTE +Model Number: G27F + +Responsible Party – U.S. Contact Information: G.B.T. Inc. +Address: 17358 Railroad street, City Of Industry, CA91748 +Tel.: 1-626-854-9338 +Internet contact information: https://www.gigabyte.com + +fCC Compliance Statement: +This device complies with Part 15 of the FCC Rules, Subpart B, Unin- +tentional Radiators. +Operation is subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device +may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept +any interference received, including interference that may cause un- +desired operation. + +This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits +for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These +limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful +interference in a residential installation. This equipment generates, uses +and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed and used in +accordance with manufacturer’s instructions, may cause harmful inter- +ference to radio communications. However, there is no guarantee that +interference will not occur in a particular installation. If this equipment +does cause harmful interference to radio or television reception, which +can be determined by turning the equipment o and on, the user is en- +couraged to try to correct the interference by one or more of the follow- +ing measures: +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +• + +Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. + +-3- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual • + + Connect the equipment to an outlet on a circuit different from that +to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. + +Canadian Department of Communications Statement +This digital apparatus does not exceed the Class B limits for radio noise +emissions from digital apparatus set out in the Radio Interference +Regulations of the Canadian Department of Communications. This class +B digital apparatus complies with Canadian ICES-003. + +avis de conformité à la réglementation d’ Industrie Canada +Cet appareil numérique de la classe B est conforme à la norme NMB-003 +du Canada. + +European Union (EU) CE Declaration of Conformity +This device complies with the following directives: Electromagnetic +Compatibility Directive 2014/30/EU, Low-voltage Directive 2014/35/ +EU, ErP Directive 2009/125/EC, RoHS directive (recast) 2011/65/EU & the +2015/863 Statement. This product has been tested and found to comply +with all essential requirements of the Directives. + +European Union (EU) RoHS (recast) Directive 2011/65/EU & +the European Commission Delegated Directive (EU) 2015/863 +Statement +GIGABYTE products have not intended to add and safe from hazardous +substances (Cd, Pb, Hg, Cr+6, PBDE, PBB, DEHP, BBP, DBP and DIBP). +The parts and components have been carefully selected to meet RoHS +requirement. Moreover, we at GIGABYTE are continuing our efforts +to develop products that do not use internationally banned toxic +chemicals. + +European Union (EU) Community Waste Electrical & Electronic +Equipment (WEEE) Directive Statement +GIGABYTE will fulfill the national laws as interpreted from the 2012/19/ +EU WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment) (recast) directive. +The WEEE Directive specifies the treatment, collection, recycling and +disposal of electric and electronic devices and their components. Under +the Directive, used equipment must be marked, collected separately, +and disposed of properly. + +-4- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual WEEE Symbol Statement + +The symbol shown below is on the product or on its pack- +aging, which indicates that this product must not be dis- +posed of with other waste. Instead, the device should be +taken to the waste collection centers for activation of the +treatment, collection, recycling and disposal procedure. + +For more information about where you can drop off your waste equip- +ment for recycling, please contact your local government office, your +household waste disposal service or where you purchased the product +for details of environmentally safe recycling. + +End of Life Directives-Recycling + +The symbol shown below is on the product or on its +packaging, which indicates that this product must not be +disposed of with other waste. Instead, the device should be +taken to the waste collection centers for activation of the +treatment, collection, recycling and disposal procedure. + +Déclaration de Conformité aux Directives de l’Union +européenne (UE) +Cet appareil portant la marque CE est conforme aux directives de l’UE +suivantes: directive Compatibilité Electromagnétique 2014/30/UE, +directive Basse Tension 2014/35/UE, directive 2009/125/CE en matière +d’écoconception, la directive RoHS II 2011/65/UE & la déclaration +2015/863. +La conformité à ces directives est évaluée sur la base des normes +européennes harmonisées applicables. + +European Union (EU) CE-Konformitätserklärung +Dieses Produkte mit CE-Kennzeichnung erfüllen folgenden +EURichtlinien: +EMV-Richtlinie 2014/30/EU, Niederspannungsrichtlinie +2014/30/EU, Ökodesign-Richtlinie 2009/125/EC, RoHS-Richtlinie +2011/65/EU erfüllt und die 2015/863 Erklärung. +Die Konformität mit diesen Richtlinien wird unter Verwendung der +entsprechenden Standards zurEuropäischen Normierung beurteilt. -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +-5- - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future +LCD Monitor User's Manual CE declaração de conformidade +Este produto com a marcação CE estão em conformidade com das +seguintes Diretivas UE: Diretiva Baixa Tensão 2014/35/EU; Diretiva CEM +2014/30/EU; Diretiva Conceção Ecológica 2009/125/CE; Diretiva RSP +2011/65/UE e a declaração 2015/863. +A conformidade com estas diretivas é verificada utilizando as normas +europeias harmonizadas. -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend +CE Declaración de conformidad +Este producto que llevan la marca CE cumplen con las siguientes +Directivas de la Unión Europea: Directiva EMC (2014/30/EU), Directiva +de bajo voltaje (2014/35/EU), Directiva de Ecodiseño (2009/125/EC), +Directiva RoHS (recast) (2011/65/EU) y la Declaración 2015/863. +El cumplimiento de estas directivas se evalúa mediante las normas +europeas armonizadas. -3 +Japan Class 01 Equipment Statement - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience +安全にご使用いただくために +接地接続は必ず電源プラグを電源につなぐ前に行って下さい。 +また、接地接続を外す場合は、必ず電源プラグを電源から切り離してから +行って下さい。 -Strategic priorities +Japan VCCI Class B Statement -Financial targets +クラス B VCCI 基準について -1 +この装置は、クラス B 情報技術装置です。 この装置は、家庭環境で使 +用することを目的としていますが、この装置がラジオやテレビジョン +受信機に近接して使用されると、受信障害を引き起こすことがありま +す。 +取扱説明書に従って正しい取り扱いをして下さい。 -2 +VCCI-B -3 +-6- -4 +LCD Monitor User's Manual China RoHS Compliance Statement +中国《废弃电器电子产品回收处理管理条例》提示性说明 +为了更好地关爱及保护地球,当用户不再需要此产品或产品寿命终 +止时,请遵守国家废弃电器电子产品回收处理相关法律法规,将其 +交给当地具有国家认可的回收处理资质的厂商进行回收处理。 -5 +环保使用期限 +Environment-friendly Use Period -6 +此标识指期限(十年),电子电气产品中含有的有害物质 +不会发生外泄或突变、电子电气产品用户正常使用该电子 +电气产品不会对环境造成严重 污染或对其人身、财产造 +成严重损害的期限。 -7 +产品中有害物质的名称及含量 : -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. +部件名称 -Insurance and Asset Management) +铅 +(Pb) -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network +汞 +(Hg) -Turn around our US business +镉 +(Cd) -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses +六价铬 +(Cr+6) -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains +多溴联苯 +(PBB) -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved +多溴二苯醚 +(PBDE) -customer service +有害物质 - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- +印刷电路板及其电 +子组件 -leading financial crime standards +液晶面板 -8 +外壳 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +外部信号连接头及 +线材 -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength +X ○ ○ -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses +X ○ ○ -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre +○ ○ ○ -Empower our -people +X ○ ○ -RoTE1 +○ - >11% by 2020 +○ -Costs +○ - Positive jaws +○ -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) +○ -Capital -and -dividend +○ - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs +○ -subject to -regulatory -approval +○ -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ +○ -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% +○ -4 +○ - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda +○ -1 +本表格依据 SJ/T 11364 的规定编制。 +○ : 表示该有害物质在该部件所有均质材料中的含量均在 GB/T 26572 规 -2 +X: -3 +定的限量要求以下。 + 表示该有害物质至少在该部件的某一均质材料中的含量超出 GB/T +26572 规定的限量要求。 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength +HDMI HDMI 高清晰度多媒体接口以及 HDMI 标志是 HDMI Licensing +Administrator, Inc. 在美国和其他国家的商标或注册商标。 -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +-7- -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +LCD Monitor User's Manual 限用物質含有情況標示聲明書 +Declaration of the Presence Condition of the Restricted Substances +Marking -5 +設備名稱 : +Equipment name: - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +液晶顯示器型號 ( 型式 ): G27F +Typedesignation (Tape): -Who we are +限用物質及其化學符號 +Restricted substances and its chemical symbols -Strategic differentiators +單元 +Un it -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 +铅 +Lead +(Pb) -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows +汞 Mer- +cury +(Hg) -#1 -global transaction -bank2 +镉 +Cadmium +(Cd) -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 +六价铬 +Hexavalent +chromium +(Cr+6) -USD182bn -Total capital4 +多溴联苯 Poly- +brominated +biphenyls (PBB) -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 +多溴二苯醚 Poly- +brominated +diphenylethers +(PBDE) -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank - -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, +塑料外框 -Middle East and Latin America +○ ○ - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver +後殼 -shareholder value +○ ○ -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with +液晶面板 -diversified business model +- ○ - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity +電路板組件 - ○ -management +底座 - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for +電源線 -distribution to shareholders +○ ○ -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research +- ○ -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include +其他線材 -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts +- ○ -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) +○ -6 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +○ -1 +○ -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking +○ -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 +○ -FY2017, revenue, USDbn +○ -Recognised as leading international -bank +○ -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 +○ -Leading market positions +○ -HSBC +○ -US Bank +○ -US Bank +○ -US Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -15.2 +○ -26% +○ -22% +○ -21% +○ -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 +○ -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 +○ -Asia +○ -US +○ -Europe +○ -RoTE Transaction Banking, % +○ ->20% +備考 1.〝超出 0.1 wt %〞及〝超出 0.01 wt %〞係指限用物質之百分比含量超出百 -HSBC -Transaction -Banking +分比含量基準值。 -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 +Note 1: 〝Exceeding 0.1 wt %〞and〝exceeding 0.01 wt %〞 indicate that the per- -Banking -Industry -overall7 +centage content of the restricted substance exceeds the reference percentage +value of presence condition . -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 +備考 2.〝 ○ 〞係指該項限用物質之百分比含量未超出百分比含量基準值。 -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 +Note 2: 〝○ 〞indicates that the percentage content of the restricted substance does -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 +not exceed the percentage of reference value of presence . -53% -of client -revenue -connected to -international -network +備考 3.〝-〞係指該項限用物質為排除項目。 -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. +Note 3: 〝-〞indicates that the restricted substance corresponds to the exemption -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue +-8- -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries +LCD Monitor User's Manual Safety Precautions -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey +Read through the following Safety Precautions before using the +monitor. -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 +• Only use the accessories that are provided with the monitor or that -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth +• -HSBC has access to high growth markets +• -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 +• -Asia, Market shares2 +which are recommended by the manufacturer. +Keep the plastic packaging bag for the product in a place that +cannot be reached by children. +Before connecting the monitor to the power outlet, make sure that +the voltage rating of the power cable is compatible with the power +specification in the country where you are located. +The power cord plug must be connected to a properly wired and +grounded power outlet. -+5.8% +• Do not touch the plug with wet hands, otherwise easily cause -Asia +electric shock. +Place the monitor in a stable and well-ventilated place. -Middle East +• +• Do not place the monitor near any heat sources such as electric -Africa +• -Latin America +radiators or direct sunlight. +The holes or openings on the monitor are for ventilation. Do not +cover or block the ventilation holes with any objects. -N. America +• Do not use the monitor near water, drinks, or all types of liquids. +Failure to do so may result in electric shock or damage to the +monitor. -Europe +• Make sure to unplug the monitor from the power outlet before -2017 +cleaning. -2030E +• As the screen surface is easy to be scratched, avoid touching the -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 +surface with any hard or sharp object. -+6.1% +• Use a soft lint-free cloth instead of a tissue to wipe the screen. You +may use a glass cleaner to clean the monitor if required. However, +never spray the cleaner directly onto the screen. -Asia +• Disconnect the power cable if the monitor is not being used for a -Middle East +long period of time. -Africa +• Do not attempt to disassemble or repair the monitor yourself. -Latin America +-9- -N. America +LCD Monitor User's Manual CONTENTS -Europe +Safety Information ..................................................................................................................... 3 +Regulatory Notices .......................................................................................................... 3 +Safety Precautions ........................................................................................................... 9 -CAGR +INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................11 +Unpacking ........................................................................................................................11 +Package Contents ..........................................................................................................13 +Product Overview ..........................................................................................................14 -7.4% +GETTING STARTED ...................................................................................................................16 +Installing the Monitor Base ........................................................................................16 +Adjusting the Viewing Angle .....................................................................................17 +Installing a Wall-Mount Bracket (Optional) ..........................................................18 +Making Connections ....................................................................................................19 -7.4% +USING THE DEVICE ...................................................................................................................20 +Turning the Power On/Off ..........................................................................................20 +User Comfort Recommendations ............................................................................21 +Selecting the Input Source .........................................................................................22 -6.5% +OPERATIONS ..............................................................................................................................23 +Quick Menu ......................................................................................................................23 +Configure the Device Settings ..................................................................................28 -6.0% +APPENDICES ..............................................................................................................................37 +Specifications ..................................................................................................................37 +Supported Timing List..................................................................................................38 +Troubleshooting .............................................................................................................39 +Basic Care ..........................................................................................................................40 +Notes on USB Charging ...............................................................................................40 +GIGABYTE Service Information .................................................................................40 -4.3% +-10- -4.6% +LCD Monitor User's Manual INTRODUCTION -CAGR +Unpacking -7.1% +1. Open the upper cover of the packaging box. Then observe the -7.8% +unpacking label attached on the inner cover. -8.0% +2. Making sure the box is in the correct orientation, carefully lay the -5.7% +box on the stable surface. -4.4% +UP -5.4% +3. Open the inner cover. -29% Hong Kong +4. Grab the EPS foam assembly (through the openings) to pull it out of -12% PRD4 +the box. -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) +Opening -5% Singapore +-11- -3% Malaysia +LCD Monitor User's Manual 5. Remove the items from the upper EPS foam. -Middle East, Market shares2 +6. Remove the upper EPS foam. Then you can remove the monitor -8% Saudi Arabia7 +from the lower EPS foam. -4% United Arab +-12- -Emirates +LCD Monitor User's Manual Package Contents -Latin America, Market shares2 +The following items come with your packaging box. If any of them is +missing, please contact your local dealer. -8% Mexico +Monitor - Largest among international and +Monitor Base -regional banks3 +Stand - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and +Power Cable ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 +HDMI Cable - Strong foundation in China / PRD to +USB Cable -support future expansion +DP Cable - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting +Adapter -with 28% market share6 +Quick Start Guide - Leading international bank in the Middle +Multilingual Installation Guide -East8 +G27F - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade +Read this manual carefully before you use this machine and keep it handy for future +reference. For safe and correct use, be sure to read the Safety Precautions in the User’s +Manual before using the machine. -finance9 +Warranty Card - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and +Warranty Card -Belt and Road Initiative10 +Note: Please keep the packaging box and packing materials for future +transportation of the monitor. - #1 DCM in Middle East5 +-13- - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on +LCD Monitor User's Manual Product Overview -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA +front View -2017 +Power LED -2030E +-14- -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes +LCD Monitor User's Manual Rear View -Japanese banks - -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees - -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 - -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) +7 8 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -2 - -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows - -Aspiration - -Characteristics - -Markets - -Markets at -scale - -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” - -Markets as -leading -international -bank - -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” - - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% - -market share - - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments - - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore - - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 - - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) - - Australia - Canada - China - France - - Germany - India - Indonesia - US - -Markets to -connect the -network - -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” - - Targeted offering for - -international customers - - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where - -possible - - Network markets to - -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) - - Supporting subsidiaries of - -global customers - -% of adj. -revenue - -FY17 - -c.60% - -c.25% - -c.15% - -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC - -9 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -3 - -Signature balance sheet strength - -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) - -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 - -Customer accounts - -Balance Sheet - -Loans & advances to -customers - -Total equity - -1.4tn - -1.0tn - -198bn - -Total regulatory capital - -182bn - -Capital - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital ratio - -5.6% - -20.9% - -Advances to deposits ratio - -71% - -Funding and -liquidity - -Liquidity coverage ratio - -142% - -10 year PBT -volatility2 - -LICs / loans -and advances3 - -Advances to -deposits ratio - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital -ratio - -Liquid asset buffer - ->500bn - -CET1 ratio - -Peer group -average1 - -2.6x - -HSBC - -1.0x - -5.5%4 - -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. - -10 - -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -11 - - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth - -Transformation since 2011 - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 - - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by - -USD349bn or 29%1 - - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions - - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities - - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” - -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities - - Shifted business to Asia and - -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 - - Strengthened network to support - -global trade and capital flows - - Demonstrated ability to execute - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Growth - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Turnaround - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Customer - 1 2 @@ -869,1969 +635,1367 @@ Customer 6 -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service - -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -Empower our -people - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills - -Our People - -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis - -12 - - Strategic priorities - -1-3 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity - -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity - -CAGR --8% - -72.3 - -mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -+7% - -51.4 - -48.0 +1. USB upstream port +2. USB 3.0 ports (x2) +3. DC IN jack +4. HDMI ports (x2) -2011 +5. DisplayPort +6. Headphone jack +7. Control button +8. Kensington lock -2016 +-15- -2017 +LCD Monitor User's Manual GETTING STaRTED +Installing the Monitor Base +1. Place the monitor on the lower EPS foam, with the screen facing -2020 -Target +down. -1. ROE including PVIF +2. Align the monitor base with the two guide pins underneath the -Market -Growth +stand. Then install the base onto the stand. -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn +3. Lift the monitor to an upright position and place it on a table. The -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance +monitor's height may be adjusted after item 1 and item 2 shown in +the figure are removed. -Asia Wealth - -Asset Management -(Asia) - -Belt and Road - -Insurance -(Asia)1 - -ASEAN - -PRD - -UK -Ring-fenced Bank - -Hong Kong - -Transaction Banking/ -International network - -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) - -Cost of Equity - -RoTE - -13 - - Strategic priorities +2 1 -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia - ->3bn - ->1bn - ->0.2bn - -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -PBT, 2017 -USDbn - -11.4 - -7.5 - -A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments - -Revenue, 2017 USDbn - -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) - -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) - -ASEAN - -China - -India - -Australia - -Other Asia - -4.7 - -3.1 - -PRD - -0.2 - -2.4 - -2.4 - -0.9 - -0.9 - -2.1 - -1.2 - -0.5 - -0.9 - -0.4 - -0.8 - -B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing - -technology in PRD - -C - -Build leading Wealth Management business - - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater - -China and ASEAN - - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional +-16- -clients +LCD Monitor User's Manual adjusting the Viewing angle +Note: Hold the monitor base so that the screen does not topple when +you make the adjustment. -D +adjusting the Tilt angle +Tilt the screen forward or backward to the desired viewing angle (-5° to +20°). -Expand our business in ASEAN +20° - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise +5° -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth +adjusting the Screen Orientation +Raise the screen to the maximum height (130mm). - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position +130 mm -14 +-17- - Strategic priorities +LCD Monitor User's Manual Installing a Wall-Mount Bracket (Optional) +Use only the 100 x 100 mm wall mount kit recommended by the manu- +facturer. +1. Place the monitor on the lower EPS foam, with the screen facing -1A +down. -Build on strength in Hong Kong +2. Push the locking clips inward to detach the stand from the monitor. -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… +3. Attach the mounting bracket to the mounting holes at the rear of +the monitor. Then use the screws to secure the bracket in place. -Opportunities and areas of investment +100 mm -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn +100 mm -HSBC market -share, % +Note: -USD0.9tn + To mount the monitor on the wall, refer to the installation guide that is +included in the wall-mount bracket kit. -USD2.9tn + The monitor head may be installed on wall, rotary brackets or other brackets. +This monitor supports 100 mm mounting holes that comply with VESA indus- +trial standard. To install any third-party solution to the monitor, four φ4 mm +screws with pitch of 0.7 mm and length of 10 mm are required. If any longer +screw is used, the monitor may be damaged. Check if the bracket provided +by the manufacturer complies with VESA standard and is able to support the +monitor body. Please use the power cable and video cable attached to the +monitor, in order to ensure the optimal performance. -10% +-18- -CAGR -2005-17 +LCD Monitor User's Manual + Making Connections -24% - -2005 - -10% - -Asset growth - -25% - -20172 - -Leading market share across major products2 - -…with leading positions across major products3 - -Customer -accounts - -Loans and -advances to -customers - -DCM - -#1 - -#1 - -#1 - -Mortgages - -37% - -#1 - -Credit cards - ->40% - -Trade finance - -#1 - -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments - -Enhance -customer -experience - -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments - - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident - -Chinese customers - - Invest in insurance for sustainable - -market share growth - - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business - -Banking - - Explore partnerships to launch - -innovative solutions - - Capture new growth opportunities with - -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese - -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as - -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation - -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia - -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share - -15 - -excluding Japan - - Strategic priorities - -1B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) - -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -USDbn - -Revenue - -0.18 - -2014 - -0.22 - -2017 - ->USD1bn - -c.0.5 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - -Loans & advances to customers - ->20bn - -4.1 - -6.2 - ->10bn - -2014 - -2017 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank - -in China, opened for business in December 2017 - - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled - -since project launched in June 2015 - - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 - - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect - - Enhance corporate coverage to - -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading - - Broaden client base and drive for - -deposit-heavy product mix - -Emerging -Middle -Class - -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity - - Fully leverage capital market - -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation - -New business -capabilities - -16 - - Strategic priorities - -1C - -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth - -Rising wealth in Asia - -Private financial wealth1, USDtn - -2016-21E -CAGR - -223 - -Middle class in Asia2 - -# of people, bn - -2.5x - -152 - -E. Europe - -L. America - -MENA - -N. America - -34% - -W. Europe - -25% - -Japan +21 -10% +Headphone -Asia ex Japan +2 -21% +3 -166 +4 -33% +Computer -24% +5 -9% +1 Headphone cable +2 HDMI cable +3 DisplayPort cable -23% +Keyboard -33% +Mouse -5.6% +Computer -Average household annual income3 +USB +disk +drive -2015 +4 USB (A-Male to B-Male) cable +5 USB cable -2030E +-19- -USD‘000 +LCD Monitor User's Manual USING THE DEVICE +Turning the Power On/Off -2.3x +Power On -22% +1. Connect one end of the power cable to the adapter and connect +the output cable of the adapter to the DC IN jack of the monitor. -3.5% +2. Connect other end of the the power cable to a power outlet. +3. Press the Control button to turn on the monitor. The Power LED will -7% +light in white, indicating the monitor is ready to use. -1.7% +Power Off +Press the Control button for 2 seconds to turn off the monitor. +Note: When the Main menu appears on the screen, you can also turn off +). Refer to page 25. +the monitor by moving the Control button down ( -28% +-20- -9.9% +LCD Monitor User's Manual User Comfort Recommendations -2017 +The following are some tips for comfortable viewing of your monitor: +• Optimal viewing distances for monitors range from approximately -2030E +510 mm to 760 mm (20” to 30”). -HNWI financial wealth4 +• A general guideline is to position the monitor such that the top +of the screen is at or slightly below your eye-height when you are +comfortably seated. -USDtrn +• Use adequate lighting for the type of work you are performing. +• -2.0x +Take regular and frequent breaks (at least for 10 minutes) every half +hour. +Be sure to periodically look away from your monitor screen and +focus on a far object for at least 20 seconds during the breaks. +Eye exercise can help reduce eye strain. Repeat these exercises +frequently: (1) look up and down (2) slowly roll your eye (3) move +your eyes diagonally. -2014 +• -2016 +• -2021E +-21- -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Selecting the Input Source -2017 +1. Move the Control button right +) to enter the the Input -2025E +( +menu. -17 +2. Move the Control button up/ +) to select the desired +down ( +input source. Then press the +Control button to confirm. -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities +Input -1C +Select -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia +Exit ->USD1bn +-22- ->0.4bn +LCD Monitor User's Manual OPERaTIONS +Quick Menu ->0.1bn +Hot Key +By default, the Control button has been assigned with the specific +function. +Note: To change the preset hot key function, refer to the “Quick Switch” section +on page 34. -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today +To access the hot key function, do the following: +• Move the Control button up -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 +) to enter the Black Equalizer -Opportunities and areas of investment +( +menu. + Move the Control button +) to adjust +up/down ( +the setting and press the +Control button to confirm. -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Black Equalizer -USD +adjust -Wealth in -Asia +Exit -Private -Bank +-23- -RBWM -Wealth +LCD Monitor User's Manual + • Move the Control button down ( -Insurance1 +) to enter the Picture Mode -Asset -Management1 0.3 +menu. + Move the Control button + ) to select the +up/down ( +desired option and press +the Control button to con- +firm. -1. +Picture Mode -Includes manufacturing revenue only +Standard -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) +fPS - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater +RTS/RPG -China +Movie - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth +Reader -0.7 +sRGB - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by +Select -investment in RM and product platform +Exit - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary +• Move the Control button left -portfolio management and lombard lending +( -Insurance + ) to enter the Volume menu. - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth +Volume -customers, and strengthen front line + Move the Control button +up/down ( +) to adjust +the headphone volume +level and press the Control +button to confirm. - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new +adjust -distribution channels +Exit - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +• Move the Control button right ( -Asset management +) to enter the the Input menu. - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / +Refer to the “Selecting the Input Source” section. -GPB customers +Note: To close the menu, move the Control button left ( - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China + ). -18 +-24- -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities +LCD Monitor User's Manual -2 + function Key Guide -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing +Press the Control button to display the Main menu. ->USD1bn +Settings ->0.4bn +Dashboard ->0.1bn +GameAssist -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 +Exit -USD +Power Off -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion +Then use the Control button to select the desired function and +configure the related settings. -Opportunities and areas of investment +Dashboard +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +left ( - HSBC is positioned for +) to enter the Dashboard menu. -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 +OFF - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: +Dashboard -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme +function -– More than 95% of technical +ON -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed +Dashboard +Location -Retail -banking +Off - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by +Select -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 +Exit - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth +CPU Temperature -and acquire new customers +CPU frequency - Leverage our unique global access to support +CPU fan Speed -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs +CPU Usage Rate -Corporate -banking +GPU Temperature - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ +GPU frequency - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) +GPU fan Speed -Digital and -customer -satisfaction +• - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for +Function: Enable/Disable the function. When enabled, you can +select the desired option(s) to be shown on the screen. -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification +• Dashboard Location: Specify the location of the Dashboard - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) +information to be shown on the screen. - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines +-25- -and brands +LCD Monitor User's Manual Once the Dashboard configuration is complete, it will transfer the +system data to the SOC through the USB port and display the value of +the selected function(s) on the screen. -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite +CPU Temperature -19 +CPU frequency - Strategic priorities +CPU fan Speed -3 +CPU Usage Rate -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network +GPU Temperature ->USD1bn +GPU frequency ->0.4bn +GPU fan Speed ->0.1bn +GPU Usage Rate -Investments are delivering +aORUS Mouse DPI -Opportunities and areas of investment +OFF -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Dashboard -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance +function -Trade Finance -rank1 +ON -Hong Kong -market share2 +Dashboard +Location -2015 +Off -2017 +Select -#1 +Exit -#1 +CPU Temperature - +CPU frequency -10.8% +CPU fan Speed -13.8% +CPU Usage Rate -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management +GPU Temperature -Average GLCM -balances +GPU frequency -c$470bn +GPU fan Speed -c$530bn +Note: Make sure the USB cable is properly connected to the USB upstream port +of the monitor and the USB port of your computer +Gameassist +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +right ( -Hong Kong -market share3 +) to enter the GameAssist menu. -22.8% +Gameassist -26.3% +GaME INfO -FX corporates -rank4 +Gaming Timer -FX institutional -rank4 +Gaming Counter -#1 +Crosshair -#7 +Refresh Rate - +Info Location -#1 +Display alignment -#3 +Select -Assets under -custody +Exit -$6.2trn +-26- -$7.7trn +LCD Monitor User's Manual • Game Info: Configure the FPS (First Person Shooting) game related -FX +settings. +√ Select Gaming Timer to select countdown timer mode. To -Securities -Services +disable this function, set the setting to OFF. -Digitise and grow Trade Finance +√ Select Gaming Counter or Refresh Rate to enable/disable the - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems +gaming counter or real-time refresh rate setting. - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by +√ Select Info Location to specify the location of the information to -investing in our channel and product capabilities +be shown on the screen. - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured +Gameassist -trade +GaME INfO -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM +Gaming Timer - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by +Gaming Counter -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions +Crosshair - Create new products and revenue streams - new +Refresh Rate -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees +Info Location -FX business growth +Display alignment - Grow the business through the continued development +Select -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model +Exit - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise +• Crosshair: Select the desired crosshair type to suit your gaming -the customer experience +environment. It makes aiming much easier. -Grow Securities Services business +• Display alignment: When the function is enabled, it displays the +alignment lines on the four sides of the screen, providing handy +tool for you to line up multiple monitors perfectly. -Market share5 +-27- -5.4% +LCD Monitor User's Manual Configure the Device Settings -5.8% +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +up ( - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products + ) to enter the Settings menu. -Asia rank6 +Note: Use the Control button to navigate through the menu and make +adjustments. -#1 +Exit -#1 +Move/adjust -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey +Enter/Confirm -and services; invest in digital future +Button Guide - +Gaming +Configure the game related settings. - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on +Resolution +1902x1080 -asset managers and asset owners +Black Equalizer +10 -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making +aim Stabilizer +Off -up c.82% of the market +Overdrive +Balance -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen +Refresh Rate +60Hz -20 +freeSync +ON - Strategic priorities +Picture Mode -4 +Standard -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank +Gaming -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn +Picture -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed +Display -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US +System -2 +Language -1 +Save Settings -0 +Reset all -US +ON -UK +Off -China +aim Stabilizer -France +Black Equalizer -% of Group client outbound revenue +Super Resolution -Hong -Kong +Display Mode -24% +Overdrive -13% +freeSync -9% +Exit -6% +Move/adjust -6% +Enter/Confirm -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +Item +Aim Stabilizer -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +Description +When this function is enabled, it reduces the motion +blur in a fast moving games. +Note: This function is not available under the following +conditions: +-when the frequency setting is lower than 100Hz. +-when the FreeSync function is activated. -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +-28- -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Black Equalizer +Super Resolution +Display Mode -Other +Overdrive +FreeSync -32% +Description +Adjust the brightness of the black areas. +Sharpen the low resolution images. +Select the aspect ratio of the screen. +• Full: Scale the input image to fill the screen. -51% +Ideal for 16:9 aspect images. -68% +• Aspect: Display the input image without geo- +metric distortion filling as much of the screen +as possible. -USD +Improve the response time of the LCD monitor. +When this function is enabled, it eliminates the +screen lag and tearing while playing games. -JP -Morgan +-29- -Citigroup +LCD Monitor User's Manual Picture -Bank of -America +Configure the image related settings. -HSBC +Resolution +1902x1080 -BoNY -Mellon +Brightness +85 -c.19% +Contrast +50 -Overall +Sharpness +5 -Hong Kong +Gamma +Gamma 3 -Germany +Color Temp. Normal -UK +Picture Mode -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) +Standard -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT +Gaming -21 +Picture -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities +Display -4 +System -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform +Language -The US has made progress over the past several years… +Save Settings -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth +Reset all -Adjusted PBT1, USDm +Standard -RoTE2 +fPS -> 6%2 +RTS/RPG -1,201 +Movie -974 +Reader -CML +sRGB -US Principal +Custom 1 -464 +Brightness -494 +Contrast Ratio -737 +Color Vibrance -920 +Sharpness -556 +Gamma -387 +Color Temperature -2014 +Low Blue Light -2015 +Exit -2016 +Move/adjust -2017 +Enter/Confirm -0.9%2,3 +Select the one of the preset picture mode. +• +• +• -2017 +Standard: For editing documents or browsing websites. +FPS: For playing FPS (First Person Shooting) games. +RTS/RPG: For playing RTS (Real-Time Strategy) or RPG (Role-Playing +Game) games. -PBT growth +Reader: For viewing documents. +sRGB: For viewing photos and graphics on the computer. -Future capital -actions +• Movie: For watching movies. +• +• +• Custom 1: Customized picture mode settings. +• Custom 2: Customized picture mode settings. +• Custom 3: Customized picture mode settings. +Then you can configure the following image settings. -2020 +Item +Brightness +Contrast +Color Vibrance +Sharpness -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration +Description +Adjust the brightness of the image. +Adjust the contrast of the image. +Adjust the intensity of the more muted colors. +Adjust the sharpness of the image. -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild +-30- - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Gamma +Color Temperature Select the color temperature. - International client revenue4 booked in the US up +Description +Adjust the middle level of luminance. -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY +Low Blue Light - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: +Note: Select User Define to customize the color +temperature by adjusting the red (R), green (G), or +blue (B) level according to your preference. +Reduce the amount of blue light exposure from +the screen. +• Level 0: No change. +• Level 1~10: The higher the level, the more blue -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly +light will be reduced. -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion +Note: -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- + This is the Low Blue Light Level 10 under +the normal image mode with normal col- +or temperature. It is compliance with TUV +Low Blue Light Certification -return products and business banking +Dynamic Contrast Adjust the black level of the image to achieve the -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national +Senseye Demo -clients in the US +Reset Picture - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in +optimum contrast. +Split the screen in half (2 windows). +The image of the selected mode with its default +settings will appear on the left window and the +adjusted image with the new settings will appear +on the right window. +Reset all Picture settings to the default settings. -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions +-31- - Return to regular dividend payments to Group +LCD Monitor User's Manual Display -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers +Configure the display related settings. -22 +Resolution +1902x1080 -to 2017 +Brightness +85 - Strategic priorities +Contrast +50 +Sharpness 5 -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 +Gamma +Gamma 3 -GB&M +Color Temp. Normal -34% +Picture Mode -CMB +Standard -35% +Input -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre +HDMI RGB PC Range -14% -2% -15% +Overscan -c.30% +Gaming -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth +Picture -c.35% +Display -Distribution +System -15-20% +Language -2020 -target +Save Settings -c.7% +Reset all -RWA -optimisation +Exit - Develop distribution +Move/adjust -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending +Enter/Confirm - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom - -23 - - Strategic priorities - -6 +Item +Input +HDMI RGB +PC Range -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment +Overscan -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness - - Investments aligned to strategic priorities - - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term - - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and - -31.1 - -c.4 - -4.5-5 - -5.5-6 - -6-6.5 +Description +Select the input source. +Select an appropriate RGB range setting or let the +monitor to detect it automatically. +Note: This option is only available for HDMI input. +When this function is enabled, it slightly enlarges +the input image to hide the outermost edges of +the image. +Note: This option is only available for HDMI input. -revenue development +-32- - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from +LCD Monitor User's Manual System -within the cost base of the Group +Configure the system related settings. -Revenue +Resolution +1902x1080 -Total -operating -expenses +Brightness +85 -Investments +Contrast +50 -Costs (ex -investments) +Sharpness +5 -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity +Gamma +Gamma 3 - Implement strong cost discipline and control +Color Temp. Normal -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market +Picture Mode -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains +Standard -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity +Gaming - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each +Picture -year 2018-2020 +Display -2017 +System -2018 +Language -2019 +Save Settings -2020 +Reset all -Jaws1 +Item +Audio -positive +OSD Settings -positive +audio -positive +OSD Settings -positive +Quick Switch -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve +Other Settings -24 +Volume - Strategic priorities +Mute -7 +Exit -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework +Move/adjust -Investment -categories +Enter/Confirm Description +Configure the audio settings. +• Volume: Adjust the volume level. +• Mute: Enable/Disable the mute function. +Configure the on-screen display (OSD) menu +related settings. +• Display Time: Set the length of time the OSD -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 +menu remains on the screen. - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) +• OSD Transparency: Adjust the OSD menu - Investments in new +transparency. -opportunities +• OSD Lock: When this function is enabled, no - Improve operational +OSD adjustment is allowed. +Note: To disable the OSD lock function, press +the Control key. When the message appears on +the screen, select Yes to confirm. -efficiency in order to lower -cost base +The button is locked - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 +Confirm to unlock +OSD. - Deliver robust solution design +No -with additional franchise -benefits +yes - Turnaround of existing businesses +-33- -(e.g. US) +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Quick Switch - Investing in expanding our businesses +Other Settings -(e.g. PRD) - - Productivity programmes - -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) - - Core infrastructure replacement or - -modernisation (e.g. US) - -c.1/3 - - Implement required - - Deliver in cost - - Implement regulatory programmes - -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security - -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits - -(e.g. IFRS 9) - - Strengthen capabilities to manage - -financial crime risk - - Increase cyber security measures - -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 - -USD15-17bn +Description +Assign the function of the hot keys. +Available options: Aim Stabilizer, Black Equalizer, +Low Blue Light, Volume, Input, Contrast, Bright- +ness, and Picture Mode. +The default setting of the hot keys as below: -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities +D Up( -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure +):Black Equalizer -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability +D Down( -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers +):Picture Mode -1. P&L basis +D Right( -25 +):Input - Strategic priorities +D Left( +• Resolution Notice: When this function is en- -8 +):Volume -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +abled, the recommended resolution message +will appear on the screen when the monitor +switches to another input source. +Input Auto Switch: When this function is en- +abled, it automatically switches to an available +input source. -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation +• -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end +• Auto Power OFF: When this function is enabled, +the monitor will automatically turn off after a +certain amount of time. -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days +• DisplayPort Ver.: Set the DisplayPort version to - Strengthen accountability, decision- +1.1, 1.2. -to 10 (Private Banking) +Note: +• -making + Make sure to configure this option based +on the DisplayPort version supported by +your graphics card. - Clarify roles within the organisation’s +-34- -matrix +LCD Monitor User's Manual Language -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients +Language-related settings -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 +Resolution +1902x1080 - Building capabilities for continuous +Brightness +85 -improvement +Contrast +50 -Streamlining governance +Sharpness +5 - Reducing number of +Gamma +Gamma 3 -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 +Color Temp. Normal - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance +Picture Mode - Embed throughout the organisation +Standard -and for all legal entities +English +English -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership +Deutsch - +Français -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working +Gaming - Balanced scorecards to incentivise +Picture -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation +Display -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online +System - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills +Language -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC +Save Settings -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of +Reset all -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and +Exit -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths +Move/adjust - Build a diverse workforce +Enter/Confirm -26 +Item +Language - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates +Description +Select an available language for the OSD menu. -Strategic priorities +-35- -Targeted outcome by 2020 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Save Settings -1 +Set the personalized OSD configurations for Setting1, Setting2, or +Setting3. -2 +Resolution +1902x1080 -3 +Brightness +85 -4 +Contrast +50 +Sharpness 5 -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and +Gamma +Gamma 3 - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian +Color Temp. Normal -franchise +Picture Mode - Market share gains in 8 scale markets +Standard -Asset Management) +Setting1 -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy +Setting1 - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 +Setting1 -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network +Gaming - Market share gains +Picture - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from +Display -international network +System - Market share gains in Transaction Banking +Language -Turn around our US business +Save Settings - US RoTE >6% +Reset all -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses +Exit -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains +Move/adjust -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial +Enter/Confirm -crime standards +Item +Save +Load - Increase in asset productivity +Reset all - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, - -each financial year - - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 - -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics - -27 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -28 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 - -Reported RoTE walk1 - -% - -8.7 - -6.8 - -2017 -Reported - -Sig items +Description +Save the customized settings. +Load the saved settings. -2017 ex- -sig items +Restore the monitor to its factory default settings. -Interest -rate rises2 +Resolution +1902x1080 -UK -growth +Brightness +85 -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance +Contrast +50 -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network +Sharpness +5 -US turn- -around3 +Gamma +Gamma 3 -Investments +Color Temp. Normal -Other4 +Picture Mode -ROE -Reported +Standard -5.9% +Gaming -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements +Picture -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval +Display -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items +System -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency +Language - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology +Save Settings ->11 +Reset all + +Exit + +Move/adjust + +Enter/Confirm + +-36- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual aPPENDICES +Specifications + +Item +Specifications +Panel Size +27-inch +Aspect Ratio +16:9 +Resolution +1920 x 1080 +Refresh Rate +144Hz +LED Life +30000 hours (min.) +Pixel Pitch +0.31125 x 0.31125 +Response Time +1ms (MPRT) +Brightness +300nits (typ.) / 250nits (min.) +1000:1 (typ.) +Contrast Ratio +Dynamic Contrast Ratio 12M:1 (typ.) +Color Depth +Active Display area +Viewing Angle +Frequency +Input/Output Terminals • 2x HDMI 1.4 + +16. 7M +597.6(H) x 336.15 (V) +178° (H) / 178° (V) +48~144Hz (gaming mode) + +• 2x USB 3.0 (downstream) + +• 1x DP1.2 +• 1x Headphone +• 1x USB upstream + +Support USB BC1.2 +specifications +Single-port output: 5V/1.5A +Double-port output: 5V/1A - Delivering positive +port -adjusted jaws +Power Supply/Input +Power Supply/Model +Power Consumptions - Increasing capital +AC100~240V@ 50/60Hz +Asian Power Devices Inc., NB-65B19 +• On: 60W (Max.) +• Standby: 0.5W +• Off: 0.3W -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity +Dimensions (W x H x D) 619.04 x 518.88 x 202. 97mm (with stand) +6.5±0.5 kgs (Net) +Weight +0°C - 40°C +Operating conditions: +temperature range - Sustaining dividend, +Note: Specifications subject to change without notice. -supported by share buy- -backs5 +-37- - With >14% CET1 ratio +LCD Monitor User's Manual Supported Timing List -2020 -Reported -(target) +Timing List +640x480@60Hz +640x480@75Hz +720x480@60Hz +800x600@60Hz +800x600@75Hz +1024x768@60Hz +1024x768@75Hz +1280x720@60Hz +1280x720@120Hz +1280x720@144Hz +1920x1080@60Hz +1920x1080@120Hz +1920x1080@144Hz ->10% +HDMI +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ -29 +DP +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution +-38- -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Troubleshooting -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders +Problem -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 +No power -12-13% +No image appears +on the screen -Surplus equity3 +The image does +not fill the entire +screen -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 +The colors are +distorted -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses +No sound or +volume is low -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally +Possible Solution(s) -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 +• Make sure the power cable is properly connected -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items +to the power source and the monitor. -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing +• Check the cable and plug to make sure they are -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base +not broken. -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes +• Make sure the monitor is turned on. +• Make sure the adapter LED is on. ->14% +• Make sure the monitor and the computer are -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval +properly connected and both devices are turned +on. -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D +• Make sure you have selected the correct input -s -r -o -t -c -a -f +source. Refer to page 22 or 32. -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e +• Adjust the Brightness and Contrast settings. -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R +Refer to page 30. -Higher risk weights -under local rules +• Try different Display Mode (aspect ratio) setting. -Diversification -benefit / other +Refer to page 29. -Stress testing +• Make sure the input signal cable is properly -Anticipated -regulatory changes +connected. -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio +• Configure the image related settings. Refer to -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. +the “Picture” section. -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators +• Make sure the headphone cable is properly -30 +connected. - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion +• Adjust the volume level. Refer to page 24 or 33. +• Adjust your computer sound related settings. - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest +Note: If the problem persists, please contact our customer service for +further assistance. -growth markets +-39- - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and +LCD Monitor User's Manual Basic Care -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode +When the screen becomes dirty, do the following to clean the screen: +• Wipe the screen with your soft, lint-free cloth to remove any residual -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular +• -in Asia and from our international network +dust. +Spray or apply the cleaning fluid onto a soft cloth. Then wipe the +screen gently with the damp cloth. -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +Note: +• Make sure that the cloth is damp, but not wet. +• When wiping, avoid applying excessive pressure on the screen. +• Acidic or abrasive cleaners can damage the screen. -- Complete the turnaround in the US +Notes on USB Charging -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future +The following devices are not compatible with BC 1.2 of CDP mode. +When the Hub is connected to a PC, these devices cannot be charged +using the USB cable. - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while +Vendor +Apple +Samsung +Samsung -delivering positive adjusted jaws +Device +IPad +Galaxy Tab2 10.1 +GALAXY TabPro - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for +PID/VID +PID_129A/VID_05AC +PID_6860/VID_04E8 +PID_6860/VID_04E8 -sustained dividends +GIGaByTE Service Information -31 +More service information, please visit GIGABYTE official website: +https://www.gigabyte.com/ - 32 +-40- +LCD Monitor User's Manual \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q238/random_k4/question.json b/q238/random_k4/question.json index 60b40f8f4067fe312dd7deb8dde93f432c73d8b2..282e5ff4ddee0f566c0ec67e6f9dd44476106dd9 100644 --- a/q238/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q238/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "AMAZON_2017_10K.pdf", - "web_7f91d188bac86e23.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf", - "web_e85946d6c20e2417.pdf", - "web_459cb41b80747aec.pdf" + "web_1a2336a3f9985b16.pdf", + "web_f539c13fe18de9dd.pdf", + "web_4635faf220a9b852.pdf", + "web_a290dd87b6ce3b94.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q238/random_k4/random_1.md b/q238/random_k4/random_1.md index 89a0e0d7330b5b5f606ca129bb50b359ffb607a6..25d042d2700fe60a9ddce47f4b189314f01660d3 100644 --- a/q238/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q238/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,299 +1,1150 @@ -Wikidata's SPARQL +ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL +GOVERNANCE REPORT -introduction for beginners +2020 -CC BY-SA -Lucie-Aimée Kaffee + Table of -Frimelle -@lucielinde +Contents - What is turtle? +Table of Contents -RDF triple language +Letter -Subject Predicate Object +Compassion -as Web URI +Products -Alan Turing (Q7251) instance of (P31) human (Q5) +People -RDF - +Planet -turtle -@prefix wd: +Community -@prefix wdt: +Future of ESG -wd:Q7251 wdt:P31 wd:Q5 +ESG Governance - What is SPARQL? +Company Facts -RDF query language +2 -to form complex queries with SELECT and retrieve data from an endpoint +6 -Return all items, which are instance of human, limited to 200 items. +8 -PREFIX wd: +14 -PREFIX wdt: +18 -SELECT ?subject WHERE { ?subject wdt:P31 wd:Q5 . } LIMIT 200 +22 - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +26 -Show all data for Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +30 -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +34 -Extract of the result +38 -predicate + A year of -rdfs:label +Transformation -rdfs:label + Le�er -object +from our CEO -Alan Turing +Vivek Sankaran | Chief Executive Officer -ﺞﻧروﺗ نﻻآ +2020 was a year of transformation for many, and +our company was no exception. The events of last +year brought to the surface the positive impact our +company has on our customers and communities. +I would like to thank each of our 300,000 associates +for their unwavering commitment to serving our +communities during such unprecedented times. -skos:altLabel +Throughout the pandemic, our teams acted swiftly +to implement in-store safety measures, keep food +and supplies on the shelves for customers, and +distribute COVID-19 vaccinations in partnership with +the Department of Health and Human Services. -Алан Цюрынг +As our communities faced rising food insecurity, +Albertsons Companies, the Albertsons Companies +Foundation Nourishing Neighbors program, and our +customers stepped up to help those in need. We set a +record $260 million in food and monetary donations to +aid hunger relief organizations in our local communities. +This helped us reach 13 million individuals and over +3,000 organizations. - +When acts of racism and inequity shook our +communities, we came together as a company to +support one another and stand united in the face of +prejudice, hatred, and intolerance. We are committed +to equality and are driven by our guiding principle to be +a diverse and inclusive team. - +Letter -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) +I’m proud that over the past year we have not only +increased our diverse representation at all levels of +the company, but have also prioritized Diversity, Equity, +and Inclusion training, created opportunities to have +courageous conversations, and outlined a framework +to continue to improve. As part of these efforts, we +committed $5 million to social justice & equality causes. - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +In the face of these challenges, our teams still made +meaningful progress to reduce our impact on the +environment. As part of this, we recently announced +our commitment to setting a science-based target to +reduce carbon emissions. This broadens our existing +environmental commitments, which include making +100% of our Own Brands packaging recyclable, reusable, +or industrially compostable by 2025. -Show all fields of work of Alan Turing +Looking Ahead +In 2020, we completed a new materiality assessment, +which will be the foundation for our Environmental +Social Governance (ESG) strategy and initiatives going +forward. Through this process we identified high priority +areas that align with our long-term company strategy +and are most critical to our stakeholders, including +Climate Action, Community Stewardship, Diversity, +Equity & Inclusion, and Waste Reduction & Circularity. +I am encouraged by the progress we made in 2020, +as it established a framework from which we can +accelerate our efforts. + +We have a bold vision for the future and will soon +be launching commitments with specific metrics to +measure our progress. I invite you to learn more about +our progress in 2020 in this report, and I look forward +to sharing more with you in the coming months. + +Vivek + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +7 + +6 + + Compassion +core +business + +is at the + +our + +of + +2020 was an unprecedented +year, and we are proud of the +unwavering commitment our +teams showed to supporting +each other, our customers, +and our communities. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +9 + +8 + + COVID-19 +Times of extraordinary need require an +unprecedented response, and we’re +thankful to our associates for their +commitment to safety and supporting +our neighbors during the COVID-19 +pandemic. Their amazing work and +dedication created hope within our +communities during uncertain times. +Ensuring the health and safety of our +associates, customers, and communities +was our top priority in 2020. + +COMMUNITIES: There has never been +a more important time to help our +neighbors than during the COVID-19 crisis. +As hunger relief programs were stretched +to capacity, we pledged $53 million and +started a fundraising campaign through +the Albertsons Companies Foundation +Nourishing Neighbors program. +Additionally, our generous customers +donated more than $67 million +to our Nourishing Neighbor hunger relief +campaigns throughout 2020. + +We developed new partnerships to +support businesses and their employees +as companies had to close or scale back +operations. We offered streamlined job +application processes to employees that +were furloughed or had hours reduced at +other hospitality and retail companies. We +purchased supplies from the restaurant +and service industries to keep food from +going to waste and ensure our customers +could find the products they needed. + +Compassion + +CUSTOMERS: Our stores offered +senior citizens and vulnerable +customers dedicated shopping +hours to ensure all customers had +the opportunity to get the items +they needed. Additionally, we +expanded our Grocery Delivery, +Drive Up & Go, and Pharmacy Delivery +services so customers could have +contact-free shopping experiences. + +As of June 19, 2021, we have +administered more than 6 million +COVID-19 vaccines through our 1,700 +pharmacies. We continue to offer our +customers new resources to help them +navigate this health crisis, including +digital vaccine records and rapid +antigen self-tests. + +ASSOCIATES: For the safety of our +employees and customers, we +implemented social distancing and +face mask requirements, rigorous +cleaning and disinfecting procedures, +health checks before the start of shifts, +and plexiglass barriers at check stands. + +To show our gratitude, we gave all +front-line associates temporary +Appreciation Pay, bonuses, and +other benefits. + +Through the Albertsons Companies +Foundation's We Care Fund, we also +provided more than $800,000 to support +associates experiencing unanticipated +or unavoidable hardships. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +11 + +10 + + Social Justice +Courtesy, Dignity, and Respect are core values at Albertsons +Companies. They are the foundation of our associate training, +and by living these principles, we strive to make a difference in +our operations, communities, and beyond. We condemn hate or +discrimination of any kind, and this past year has underscored +the importance of standing together to boldly face inequity and +injustice head on. + +SUPPORTING CAUSES TO ADVANCE SOCIAL JUSTICE: +Last year, we formed a Racial Justice & Equity Advisory Group, +which advised us on our $5 million commitment from Albertsons +Companies and the Albertsons Companies Foundation to the +following social justice organizations to help our communities lay +a foundation for racial equity and social justice: + +$1 million + +donation toward our African +American Associate Resource +Group’s efforts to partner with +local organizations who support +communities and neighborhood +actions in our market areas. + +$1 million + +donation to the City of Chicago’s +Together Now fund. + +$2 million -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +donation toward the social +justice efforts of the NAACP Legal +Defense and Education Fund +and the National +Urban League Inc. - On Wikidata Query Service Beta +$1 million -Result Result +reserve fund for social justice +and diversity initiatives in the +future, including community +outreach, supplier diversity, +and ongoing education. -object +Compassion - +Listening with compassion +and taking action when it is - +needed are critical to ensuring +that racism and hatred have no +place at our company. -label +– Vivek Sankaran, CEO -computer science +SUPPORTING ASSOCIATES: +Last year we seized the opportunity to prioritize courageous +conversations within our teams to achieve meaningful change. +To create a safe and inclusive environment where associates +could share thoughts, feelings, and experiences, we held company- +wide town halls, reenergized our Associate Resource Groups, +and launched an interactive workshop, “Leading with Inclusion.” -cryptanalysis +We continuously review our Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DE&I) +practices and training, and are always working to do more +and better. In 2020, we launched a new DE&I aspiration and +accompanying framework to achieve it. Since then, we have +been diligently working on expanding programs and resources +across our company. -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) and cryptanalysis (Q897511) +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +13 -Data linked to Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +12 -On Wikidata Query Service Beta + Products -Extract of the result +Meeting the demands of +an evolving marketplace -subject + • -predicate + • - + • - +100% of O Organics® and Open +Nature® shell and liquid eggs +are cage-free. All Own Brands +hard-boiled eggs are cage-free - +100% of O Organics coffee is +Certified Fair Trade™ - +100% of our Open Nature® and +Waterfront BISTRO® seafood meets +our Responsible Seafood Policy +and is clearly marked with our +Responsible Choice logo - + • Donated ~$500,000 since - +launching debi lilly design™ +Extending Smiles bouquets -* +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 - +15 - Truthy and full statements +14 -represents statements in two formats + Products -truthy -contain only the statements of best rank +Plastics and Packaging Pledge +We made our Plastics and Packaging Pledge in 2019 to advance sustainability +throughout the company, starting with our extensive Own Brands portfolio. -best rank are all statements of preferred rank, if those exist or all statements of normal rank + • -qualifiers are ignored +100% of Own Brands packaging will be recyclable, reusable, or industrially +compostable by 2025 -Prefix wdt: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/) - e.g. wdt:P101 + • Own Brands plastic packaging will include 20% recycled content by 2025 -full statements -represent all data about a statement + • Own Brands products will have clear recycling communications on packaging -represented in a separate node with the unique id of the statement - e.g. q92741-7ED21209-4E23-4EB1-886A-772CC6A5350F +by 2022 via platforms such as How2Recycle© and Smart Label© -Prefix p: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/) - e.g. p:P101 +We are diligently working toward achieving our Pledge, and customers can find +updated examples of recycling communications on many of our products today. - Full statements +We put a lot of effort into helping +people live better lives and +strengthening the communities +where we do business. By +responsibly sourcing our O +Organics coffee, Albertsons +Companies is demonstrating +its commitment to improving +livelihoods and the environment. -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +– Chad Coester, Senior Vice +President, Albertsons Companies +Own Brands -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +Fair Trade Certified™ Coffee +In 2020, we transitioned our O Organics +coffee to 100% Fair Trade Certified™ sources, +meeting our Sustainable Coffee Challenge +Commitment. Purchases of our Fair Trade +Certified™ coffee generated more than +$650,000 in community development funds +for coffee farmers, their families, and +communities in 2020. -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +This coffee is certified to rigorous standards, +providing safe working conditions, upholding +fundamental human rights, and helping to +protect the environment in our sourcing +regions — including Ethiopia, Peru, Honduras, +and Colombia. -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -ps:P1082 10000 ; +17 -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +16 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . + People -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +Supporting employees +to reach their full potential -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) + • First national grocery chain to join the +Business Coalition for the Equality Act -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; + • -the population is 10000 ; +Integrated Diversity & Inclusion goals +into more than 5,000 top leaders’ +performance plans -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; + • Conducted more than 120 “Leading -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +With Inclusion” sessions, with 4,000+ +total participants - Full statements + • 70+ women recognized by leading -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +industry publications -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; + • We have 6 Associate Resource Groups +to enable an inclusive and welcoming +culture among our associates -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +Albertsons Companies +Associate Resource Groups -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +ALLIANCE -ps:P1082 10000 ; +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +19 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +18 -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; + Our Aspiration +Reflect the rich diversity of the communities we serve by offering our associates, +suppliers, and customers equitable access to opportunities and resources. -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Framework -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +In 2020, we introduced our Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Aspiration, along with +a 6-part framework to achieve it: -the population is 10000 ; +1. -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +Inclusion & Belonging -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +4. - Full statements +Impactful Associate Resource Groups -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +2. Hiring & Promotion -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +3. Talent Development -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +5. Community Engagement -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +6. Metrics -ps:P1082 10000 ; +We strive to reflect the diversity of our communities within our management and +throughout our company. As part of our framework to achieve this, we are measuring +our progress by tracking metrics, such as representation. -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +Representation at Albertsons Companies -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +VP & Above Companywide -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +U.S. +Demographics2 -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +Women -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +22% -the population is 10000 ; +49% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +51% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +People of Color1 - Full statements +Black/African American -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +Hispanic/Latino -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +Asian/Asian American -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +Other -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +4% -ps:P1082 10000 ; +5% -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +8% -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +4% -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +10% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +22% -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +6% -the population is 10000 ; +3% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +12% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +19% - Example Query +6% -Who’s birthday is today? +5% -P569: date of birth +1 Associate did not disclose: 3% VP & Above; 4% Companywide +2 2020 U.S. Census Data -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +People - Ressources +We formed a National Diversity Council that is chaired by our CEO, Vivek Sankaran, +to advance DE&I within our company. In addition, each of our 12 operating Divisions +have Diversity Councils and we have individual councils for our Technology +& Engineering, Digital & Consumer, and Supply Chain departments. These councils +collectively host monthly town halls and fireside chats to discuss Diversity, Equity +& Inclusion subjects such as anti-Asian hate, the verdict in the George Floyd murder +trial, and other timely topics. -Wikidata Query Service Beta +We continue to expand opportunities for our associates to learn more about +DE&I, including: -http://wdqs-beta.wmflabs.org/ + • Monthly trainings to top 5,500 leaders to continue their education about how to -Mediawiki: RDF Dump Format +be more inclusive -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format + • Bi-annual store and supply chain huddles to further embed DE&I into our frontline -Prefixes used for Wikidata +We must continue to set +the example of Courtesy, +Dignity, and Respect towards +everyone who walks through +our doors. -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format#Prefixes_used +– Vivek Sankaran, CEO + Albertsons Companies -Mediawiki: Query Examples +Training & +Development +Our associates are the key +component to delighting our +customers. As such, we are proud +to offer a myriad of opportunities +to grow and advance. Over the +last year, our associates from +the frontlines to our offices +completed over 6 million hours +of training through various +programs, including on-the-job +training, mentoring programs, +eLearning, and classroom-style +events. We have also partnered +with industry associations to +provide access to relevant +continuing retail education +opportunities through colleges +around the country. -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/SPARQL_Query_Examples +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 -github: wikidata query rdf docs +21 -https://github.com/wikimedia/wikidata-query-rdf/tree/master/docs +20 -Wikidata turtle dumps + Planet -https://dumps.wikimedia.org/wikidatawiki/entities/ +Minimizing our impact +on the planet -W3C RDF Primer + • Completed 800+ energy -http://www.w3.org/2007/02/turtle/primer/ +efficiency projects that will +annually save 2 million+ metric +tons of CO2e + + • Enabled 160+ electric vehicle +charging stations to date + + • Recycled more than 880 million + +pounds of cardboard + + • Recycled more than 26 million + +pounds of plastic bags and film + + • Private fleet is 100% US EPA Smart + +Way certified + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +23 + +22 + + Reducing Our +Energy Use +Every year, our teams implement +hundreds of energy efficiency +projects to reduce our energy use +in our stores, plants, distribution +centers, and offices. Some projects, +like Energy Management System +or HVAC upgrades, happen +behind the scenes, but installing +doors on refrigerated cases and +transitioning to LED lights are +energy efficiency projects that our +customers can see in our stores. + +In fiscal year 2020, we +completed more than 800 +energy efficiency projects that +are estimated to annually save +more than 2 million metric +tons of CO2e — an equivalent +savings of taking 430,000 cars +off the road each year! + +Generating +Renewable Energy +We have more than 50 on-site +solar arrays and two wind turbines +providing our operations with +renewable energy. Our renewable +energy procurement has made +us a top 30 company in the US +EPA's Green Power Partnership. + +In the spring of 2021, we committed +to setting a science-based +target and our investments in +on-site renewable energy and +the purchase of renewable +energy credits will be important +enablers to achieving our goals. + +Planet + +Through this program, +Albertsons and Safeway +stores in Arizona will invest +in, and use, renewable +energy while adding +more solar power to +Arizona’s grid. We are +honored to support Salt +River Project's promise +to deliver more clean +energy to customers. + +– Michelle Larson, +President of +Albertsons Companies +Southwest Division + +Impactful Partnerships +Collaborating with our peers and suppliers helps us to develop and implement best +practices, create innovative solutions, and reduce our impact on the planet. + +Utilizing Clean Energy Efficiently: As a longtime partner of the Salt River Project +(SRP), our Southwest Division was awarded SRP’s 2020 Sustained Excellence Award +for our ongoing commitment to energy efficiency. As one of the first companies to +participate in the SRP’s Sustainable Energy Offering, 40 of our Arizona locations are +receiving renewable energy from a new solar plant. + +Reducing Food Waste: As part of the Pacific Coast Food Waste Commitment, +we are working together with retailers and local and state governments to reduce +food waste in the Pacific Coast region by 50% by 2030. + +Identifying Sustainable Retail Bags: To find sustainable alternatives to the +single-use plastic bag, we joined the Consortium to Reinvent the Retail Bag, a +collaborative group of retailers that launched the Beyond the Bag Initiative and is +piloting innovative solutions. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +25 + +24 + + Community + +Supporting causes that impact our +customers’ lives + + • Donated more than 83 million pounds of food + +to our Feeding America partners + + • Administered 6 million COVID-19 vaccinations + +through July 19, 2021 + + • Won the “Community Hero Award” at Benevity’s + +2020 Corporate Goodness Awards for The Albertsons +Companies Foundation’s best-in-class approach to +community investment + + • Earned the silver award in Engage for Good's +2020 America's Charity Checkout Champions +Awards for the Albertsons Companies Foundation's +point-of-sale fundraising + + • Raised more than $11 million for causes important to +our local communities, including education, cancer +research and treatment, programs for people with +disabilities and veterans’ outreach + + • Piloted in-school curriculum to help kids learn + +what they can do to help stop hunger within their +own communities + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +27 + +26 + + We are committed to help feed our neighbors in need. + +$95 million + +given to our communities + +13 million + +individuals reached + +3,000+ + +organizations helped + +350 million + +meals + +$9 million + +invested in empowering +BIPOC communities through +hunger programs + +$10.4 million + +invested in schools to feed kids +during the pandemic + +$472,000 + +to support +feeding seniors + +$4 million + +invested in innovative programs +to unlock new ways to feed +our neighbors + +65,000 + +people connected +with SNAP benefits + +Supporting Community Organizations +With a grant from the Albertsons Companies Nourishing Neighbors program, the +LGBTQ Community Center of the Desert in California was able to purchase a cargo van +to help distribute food to those in need in the community. + +Having the van has been a HUGE help when we’re prepping for our Thursday night food +distribution every week. In the last month, The Center has converted our van into a mobile +pantry, providing more than 125 families with emergency relief boxes. We’ve been fortunate to +build relationships with community leaders that are dedicated to support these rural areas. + +– LGBTQ Community Center of the Desert + +Community + +We Care is a voluntary associate-sponsored disaster relief and personal hardship fund +providing financial support to our communities and fellow associates in times of crisis. + +During 2020, more than 300 grants totaling more than $800,000 were given out to +support our associates and communities during hardships. + +Thank you very much. The We +Care program really helps. It’s +been reassuring to know that +I work for a company that +has my back. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +We Care was instrumental +in getting me going in a +positive direction. I have since +signed up to donate weekly. +A fantastic program that has +helped many in my division. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +Thank you so much, this is +super helpful in this trying +time. As a single dad, it's +been a little overwhelming +during the pandemic and +this is a great help and a +wonderful thing. + +– Recipient of We Care grant + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +29 + +28 + + The + +future + +of ESG +at Albertsons Companies + +Recognizing the importance of Environmental Social +Governance (ESG) to our customers, associates, and +investors, we refreshed our Materiality Assessment +to prioritize how we address ESG. This assessment +identified our internal and external stakeholder’s +top-ranking ESG topic areas, and the outcome has +shaped our bold vision for the future. In the coming +months, we will release our new ESG strategy and +commitment for the four Tier 1 topics identified: +Climate Action, Community Stewardship, Diversity, +Equity & Inclusion, and Waste Reduction & Circularity. + +Our efforts in these areas will support a +healthier planet and vibrant communities, +and I look forward to sharing our new ESG +strategy and commitments soon. + +– Vivek Sankaran, +CEO of Albertsons Companies + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +31 + +30 + + Identifying Our ESG Priorities +We analyzed 19 ESG topics specific to our business and industry and worked +with stakeholders to better understand where we should focus our efforts. We +conducted interviews and surveys with internal business leaders, customers, +investors, suppliers, industry groups, and included insights from industry reports +and ESG rating agencies. Based on the responses received we aggregated topics +into ranked, or "tiered," priorities. + +Tier 1 +Invest time and +resources to set goals, +advance our efforts, +and regularly report +on progress. + +Tier 2 +Proactively manage +performance and +report on continuous +improvement. + +Tier 3 +Develop policies, +position statements, +and brand standards as +needed, and report on +activities as appropriate. + +Foundational +Focus on internal +excellence to proactively +minimize risk and meet +or exceed regulatory +requirements. + +l + +s +r +e +d +o +h +e +r +a +h +S +o +t +e +c +n +a +t +r +o +p +m + +I + +Importance to Business + +We plotted responses into a +prioritization matrix, and the +ranked results are guiding +our new ESG strategy + +Future of ESG + +Our ESG + +priorities + +The Results of our Materiality Assessment + +Tier 1 + • Climate Action (focus on +energy and emissions) + +Tier 2 + • Customer Health + +& Wellness + + • Community Stewardship + + • Supplier Environmental + + • Diversity, Equity + +& Inclusion + + • Waste Reduction + +Stewardship + + • Supplier Social +Responsibility + +& Circularity (focus on +food waste, plastics, and +consumer packaging) + + • Sustainable Products + +& Ingredients + +Tier 3 + • Animal Welfare + + • Product Marketing +& Transparency + + • Water Stewardship + +Foundational + • Data Privacy & Security + + • Employee Attraction, + +Development & Retention + + • Employee Health & Safety + + • Governance Ethics & Compliance + + • Product Safety + + • Resilience & Adaptation + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +33 + +32 + + ESG Governance +Overview + +Bringing together our dedicated ESG +team with cross-functional business units +ensures our ESG goals and values are +incorporated into our business decisions +and strategic plans. With our operating +divisions’ localized expertise, our corporate +teams’ support, and the oversight by our +Board of Directors, our company is both +locally great and nationally strong. +This helps us to identify and act upon the +greatest opportunities to create a healthy +planet and vibrant neighborhoods. + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +35 + +34 + + ESG Governance + +ESG Governance +Albertsons Companies is +committed to responsible +corporate governance. Our ESG +Team collaborates with teams +and leaders across our company +to help drive and report on our +environmental and social impact. +Our ESG Council brings together +leaders that drive initiatives within +our product, people, planet, and +community reporting platforms to +report progress and discuss new +programs, risks, and opportunities. + +Our Governance, Compliance & +ESG Board Committee oversees +risks associated with corporate +governance, business conduct and +ethics, ESG, and the management +of compliance and regulatory risks. + +Management teams regularly +report on applicable risks and +opportunities to the relevant +Board committees or the full +Board of Directors. + +ESG Council +(Cross-Functional Team) + +ESG +Team + +Governance, +Compliance & ESG +Board Committee + +Board +of Directors + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +37 + +36 + + Company Facts + +2,277 Retail Stores + +22 Distribution Centers + +20 Manufacturing Plants + +note: all numbers from FY 2020 + +$70 billion + +YE 2020 Sales + +30 million+ + +customers per week + +1,727 + +in-store pharmacies + +exclusive billion-dollar Own Brands + +4 + +25 million+ + +loyalty members + +~300,000 + +jobs provided by one of the +largest retail employers + +$260 million+ + +donated in 2020 through +our Albertsons Foundation + +$1 billion + +invested in COVID-19 +related expenses; +including expansive safety protocols + +Environmental Social Governance Report 2020 + +39 + +Albertsons Companies is a leading food and drug +retailer in the United States, with both a strong local +presence and national scale. Albertsons Companies +is committed to helping people across the country +live better lives by making a meaningful difference, +neighborhood by neighborhood. + +38 + + 250 E. Parkcenter Blvd. +Boise, ID 83706 + +albertsonscompanies.com diff --git a/q238/random_k4/random_2.md b/q238/random_k4/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..f28bcc1c1e50866e33c7f4488c244d56c08f6e52 100644 --- a/q238/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q238/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,862 +1,628 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +G R M I N G M O N I T O R -2 +U S E R G U I D E - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy +-1- -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +LCD Monitor User's Manual Copyright - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between +© 2020 GIGA-BYTE TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. All rights reserved. -them +The trademarks mentioned in this manual are legally registered to their +respective owners. - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a +Disclaimer -stable dividend +Information in this manual is protected by copyright laws and is the +property of GIGABYTE. +Changes to the specifications and features in this manual may be made +by GIGABYTE without prior notice. +No part of this manual may be reproduced, copied, translated, +transmitted, or published in any form or by any means without +GIGABYTE’s prior written permission. -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience +• - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised +• -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode + In order to assist in the use of this monitor, carefully read the User +Guide. + For more information, check on our website at: https://www. +gigabyte.com + +-2- - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia +LCD Monitor User's Manual SafETy INfORMaTION + +Regulatory Notices -and from our international network +United States of america, federal Communications +Commission Statement - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive +Supplier’s Declaration of Conformity +47 CfR § 2.1077 Compliance Information + +Product Name: LCD monitor +Trade Name: GIGABYTE +Model Number: G27F + +Responsible Party – U.S. Contact Information: G.B.T. Inc. +Address: 17358 Railroad street, City Of Industry, CA91748 +Tel.: 1-626-854-9338 +Internet contact information: https://www.gigabyte.com + +fCC Compliance Statement: +This device complies with Part 15 of the FCC Rules, Subpart B, Unin- +tentional Radiators. +Operation is subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device +may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept +any interference received, including interference that may cause un- +desired operation. + +This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits +for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These +limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful +interference in a residential installation. This equipment generates, uses +and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed and used in +accordance with manufacturer’s instructions, may cause harmful inter- +ference to radio communications. However, there is no guarantee that +interference will not occur in a particular installation. If this equipment +does cause harmful interference to radio or television reception, which +can be determined by turning the equipment o and on, the user is en- +couraged to try to correct the interference by one or more of the follow- +ing measures: +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +• + +Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. + +-3- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual • + + Connect the equipment to an outlet on a circuit different from that +to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. + +Canadian Department of Communications Statement +This digital apparatus does not exceed the Class B limits for radio noise +emissions from digital apparatus set out in the Radio Interference +Regulations of the Canadian Department of Communications. This class +B digital apparatus complies with Canadian ICES-003. + +avis de conformité à la réglementation d’ Industrie Canada +Cet appareil numérique de la classe B est conforme à la norme NMB-003 +du Canada. + +European Union (EU) CE Declaration of Conformity +This device complies with the following directives: Electromagnetic +Compatibility Directive 2014/30/EU, Low-voltage Directive 2014/35/ +EU, ErP Directive 2009/125/EC, RoHS directive (recast) 2011/65/EU & the +2015/863 Statement. This product has been tested and found to comply +with all essential requirements of the Directives. + +European Union (EU) RoHS (recast) Directive 2011/65/EU & +the European Commission Delegated Directive (EU) 2015/863 +Statement +GIGABYTE products have not intended to add and safe from hazardous +substances (Cd, Pb, Hg, Cr+6, PBDE, PBB, DEHP, BBP, DBP and DIBP). +The parts and components have been carefully selected to meet RoHS +requirement. Moreover, we at GIGABYTE are continuing our efforts +to develop products that do not use internationally banned toxic +chemicals. + +European Union (EU) Community Waste Electrical & Electronic +Equipment (WEEE) Directive Statement +GIGABYTE will fulfill the national laws as interpreted from the 2012/19/ +EU WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment) (recast) directive. +The WEEE Directive specifies the treatment, collection, recycling and +disposal of electric and electronic devices and their components. Under +the Directive, used equipment must be marked, collected separately, +and disposed of properly. + +-4- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual WEEE Symbol Statement + +The symbol shown below is on the product or on its pack- +aging, which indicates that this product must not be dis- +posed of with other waste. Instead, the device should be +taken to the waste collection centers for activation of the +treatment, collection, recycling and disposal procedure. + +For more information about where you can drop off your waste equip- +ment for recycling, please contact your local government office, your +household waste disposal service or where you purchased the product +for details of environmentally safe recycling. + +End of Life Directives-Recycling + +The symbol shown below is on the product or on its +packaging, which indicates that this product must not be +disposed of with other waste. Instead, the device should be +taken to the waste collection centers for activation of the +treatment, collection, recycling and disposal procedure. + +Déclaration de Conformité aux Directives de l’Union +européenne (UE) +Cet appareil portant la marque CE est conforme aux directives de l’UE +suivantes: directive Compatibilité Electromagnétique 2014/30/UE, +directive Basse Tension 2014/35/UE, directive 2009/125/CE en matière +d’écoconception, la directive RoHS II 2011/65/UE & la déclaration +2015/863. +La conformité à ces directives est évaluée sur la base des normes +européennes harmonisées applicables. + +European Union (EU) CE-Konformitätserklärung +Dieses Produkte mit CE-Kennzeichnung erfüllen folgenden +EURichtlinien: +EMV-Richtlinie 2014/30/EU, Niederspannungsrichtlinie +2014/30/EU, Ökodesign-Richtlinie 2009/125/EC, RoHS-Richtlinie +2011/65/EU erfüllt und die 2015/863 Erklärung. +Die Konformität mit diesen Richtlinien wird unter Verwendung der +entsprechenden Standards zurEuropäischen Normierung beurteilt. -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +-5- - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future +LCD Monitor User's Manual CE declaração de conformidade +Este produto com a marcação CE estão em conformidade com das +seguintes Diretivas UE: Diretiva Baixa Tensão 2014/35/EU; Diretiva CEM +2014/30/EU; Diretiva Conceção Ecológica 2009/125/CE; Diretiva RSP +2011/65/UE e a declaração 2015/863. +A conformidade com estas diretivas é verificada utilizando as normas +europeias harmonizadas. -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend +CE Declaración de conformidad +Este producto que llevan la marca CE cumplen con las siguientes +Directivas de la Unión Europea: Directiva EMC (2014/30/EU), Directiva +de bajo voltaje (2014/35/EU), Directiva de Ecodiseño (2009/125/EC), +Directiva RoHS (recast) (2011/65/EU) y la Declaración 2015/863. +El cumplimiento de estas directivas se evalúa mediante las normas +europeas armonizadas. -3 +Japan Class 01 Equipment Statement - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience +安全にご使用いただくために +接地接続は必ず電源プラグを電源につなぐ前に行って下さい。 +また、接地接続を外す場合は、必ず電源プラグを電源から切り離してから +行って下さい。 -Strategic priorities +Japan VCCI Class B Statement -Financial targets +クラス B VCCI 基準について -1 +この装置は、クラス B 情報技術装置です。 この装置は、家庭環境で使 +用することを目的としていますが、この装置がラジオやテレビジョン +受信機に近接して使用されると、受信障害を引き起こすことがありま +す。 +取扱説明書に従って正しい取り扱いをして下さい。 -2 +VCCI-B -3 +-6- -4 +LCD Monitor User's Manual China RoHS Compliance Statement +中国《废弃电器电子产品回收处理管理条例》提示性说明 +为了更好地关爱及保护地球,当用户不再需要此产品或产品寿命终 +止时,请遵守国家废弃电器电子产品回收处理相关法律法规,将其 +交给当地具有国家认可的回收处理资质的厂商进行回收处理。 -5 +环保使用期限 +Environment-friendly Use Period -6 +此标识指期限(十年),电子电气产品中含有的有害物质 +不会发生外泄或突变、电子电气产品用户正常使用该电子 +电气产品不会对环境造成严重 污染或对其人身、财产造 +成严重损害的期限。 -7 +产品中有害物质的名称及含量 : -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. +部件名称 -Insurance and Asset Management) +铅 +(Pb) -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network +汞 +(Hg) -Turn around our US business +镉 +(Cd) -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses +六价铬 +(Cr+6) -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains +多溴联苯 +(PBB) -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved +多溴二苯醚 +(PBDE) -customer service +有害物质 - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- +印刷电路板及其电 +子组件 -leading financial crime standards +液晶面板 -8 +外壳 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +外部信号连接头及 +线材 -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength +X ○ ○ -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses +X ○ ○ -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre +○ ○ ○ -Empower our -people +X ○ ○ -RoTE1 +○ - >11% by 2020 +○ -Costs +○ - Positive jaws +○ -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) +○ -Capital -and -dividend +○ - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs +○ -subject to -regulatory -approval +○ -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ +○ -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% +○ -4 +○ - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda +○ -1 +本表格依据 SJ/T 11364 的规定编制。 +○ : 表示该有害物质在该部件所有均质材料中的含量均在 GB/T 26572 规 -2 +X: -3 +定的限量要求以下。 + 表示该有害物质至少在该部件的某一均质材料中的含量超出 GB/T +26572 规定的限量要求。 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength +HDMI HDMI 高清晰度多媒体接口以及 HDMI 标志是 HDMI Licensing +Administrator, Inc. 在美国和其他国家的商标或注册商标。 -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +-7- -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +LCD Monitor User's Manual 限用物質含有情況標示聲明書 +Declaration of the Presence Condition of the Restricted Substances +Marking -5 +設備名稱 : +Equipment name: - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +液晶顯示器型號 ( 型式 ): G27F +Typedesignation (Tape): -Who we are +限用物質及其化學符號 +Restricted substances and its chemical symbols -Strategic differentiators +單元 +Un it -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 +铅 +Lead +(Pb) -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows +汞 Mer- +cury +(Hg) -#1 -global transaction -bank2 +镉 +Cadmium +(Cd) -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 +六价铬 +Hexavalent +chromium +(Cr+6) -USD182bn -Total capital4 +多溴联苯 Poly- +brominated +biphenyls (PBB) -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 +多溴二苯醚 Poly- +brominated +diphenylethers +(PBDE) -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank - -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, +塑料外框 -Middle East and Latin America +○ ○ - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver +後殼 -shareholder value +○ ○ -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with +液晶面板 -diversified business model +- ○ - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity +電路板組件 - ○ -management +底座 - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for +電源線 -distribution to shareholders +○ ○ -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research +- ○ -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include +其他線材 -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts +- ○ -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) +○ -6 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +○ -1 +○ -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking +○ -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 +○ -FY2017, revenue, USDbn +○ -Recognised as leading international -bank +○ -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 +○ -Leading market positions +○ -HSBC +○ -US Bank +○ -US Bank +○ -US Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -European -Bank +○ -15.2 +○ -26% +○ -22% +○ -21% +○ -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 +○ -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 +○ -Asia +○ -US +○ -Europe +○ -RoTE Transaction Banking, % +○ ->20% +備考 1.〝超出 0.1 wt %〞及〝超出 0.01 wt %〞係指限用物質之百分比含量超出百 -HSBC -Transaction -Banking +分比含量基準值。 -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 +Note 1: 〝Exceeding 0.1 wt %〞and〝exceeding 0.01 wt %〞 indicate that the per- -Banking -Industry -overall7 +centage content of the restricted substance exceeds the reference percentage +value of presence condition . -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 +備考 2.〝 ○ 〞係指該項限用物質之百分比含量未超出百分比含量基準值。 -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 +Note 2: 〝○ 〞indicates that the percentage content of the restricted substance does -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 +not exceed the percentage of reference value of presence . -53% -of client -revenue -connected to -international -network +備考 3.〝-〞係指該項限用物質為排除項目。 -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. +Note 3: 〝-〞indicates that the restricted substance corresponds to the exemption -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue +-8- -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries +LCD Monitor User's Manual Safety Precautions -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey +Read through the following Safety Precautions before using the +monitor. -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 +• Only use the accessories that are provided with the monitor or that -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth +• -HSBC has access to high growth markets +• -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 +• -Asia, Market shares2 +which are recommended by the manufacturer. +Keep the plastic packaging bag for the product in a place that +cannot be reached by children. +Before connecting the monitor to the power outlet, make sure that +the voltage rating of the power cable is compatible with the power +specification in the country where you are located. +The power cord plug must be connected to a properly wired and +grounded power outlet. -+5.8% +• Do not touch the plug with wet hands, otherwise easily cause -Asia +electric shock. +Place the monitor in a stable and well-ventilated place. -Middle East +• +• Do not place the monitor near any heat sources such as electric -Africa +• -Latin America +radiators or direct sunlight. +The holes or openings on the monitor are for ventilation. Do not +cover or block the ventilation holes with any objects. -N. America +• Do not use the monitor near water, drinks, or all types of liquids. +Failure to do so may result in electric shock or damage to the +monitor. -Europe +• Make sure to unplug the monitor from the power outlet before -2017 +cleaning. -2030E +• As the screen surface is easy to be scratched, avoid touching the -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 +surface with any hard or sharp object. -+6.1% +• Use a soft lint-free cloth instead of a tissue to wipe the screen. You +may use a glass cleaner to clean the monitor if required. However, +never spray the cleaner directly onto the screen. -Asia +• Disconnect the power cable if the monitor is not being used for a -Middle East +long period of time. -Africa +• Do not attempt to disassemble or repair the monitor yourself. -Latin America +-9- -N. America +LCD Monitor User's Manual CONTENTS -Europe +Safety Information ..................................................................................................................... 3 +Regulatory Notices .......................................................................................................... 3 +Safety Precautions ........................................................................................................... 9 -CAGR +INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................11 +Unpacking ........................................................................................................................11 +Package Contents ..........................................................................................................13 +Product Overview ..........................................................................................................14 -7.4% +GETTING STARTED ...................................................................................................................16 +Installing the Monitor Base ........................................................................................16 +Adjusting the Viewing Angle .....................................................................................17 +Installing a Wall-Mount Bracket (Optional) ..........................................................18 +Making Connections ....................................................................................................19 -7.4% +USING THE DEVICE ...................................................................................................................20 +Turning the Power On/Off ..........................................................................................20 +User Comfort Recommendations ............................................................................21 +Selecting the Input Source .........................................................................................22 -6.5% +OPERATIONS ..............................................................................................................................23 +Quick Menu ......................................................................................................................23 +Configure the Device Settings ..................................................................................28 -6.0% +APPENDICES ..............................................................................................................................37 +Specifications ..................................................................................................................37 +Supported Timing List..................................................................................................38 +Troubleshooting .............................................................................................................39 +Basic Care ..........................................................................................................................40 +Notes on USB Charging ...............................................................................................40 +GIGABYTE Service Information .................................................................................40 -4.3% +-10- -4.6% +LCD Monitor User's Manual INTRODUCTION -CAGR +Unpacking -7.1% +1. Open the upper cover of the packaging box. Then observe the -7.8% +unpacking label attached on the inner cover. -8.0% +2. Making sure the box is in the correct orientation, carefully lay the -5.7% +box on the stable surface. -4.4% +UP -5.4% +3. Open the inner cover. -29% Hong Kong +4. Grab the EPS foam assembly (through the openings) to pull it out of -12% PRD4 +the box. -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) +Opening -5% Singapore +-11- -3% Malaysia +LCD Monitor User's Manual 5. Remove the items from the upper EPS foam. -Middle East, Market shares2 +6. Remove the upper EPS foam. Then you can remove the monitor -8% Saudi Arabia7 +from the lower EPS foam. -4% United Arab +-12- -Emirates +LCD Monitor User's Manual Package Contents -Latin America, Market shares2 +The following items come with your packaging box. If any of them is +missing, please contact your local dealer. -8% Mexico +Monitor - Largest among international and +Monitor Base -regional banks3 +Stand - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and +Power Cable ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 +HDMI Cable - Strong foundation in China / PRD to +USB Cable -support future expansion +DP Cable - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting +Adapter -with 28% market share6 +Quick Start Guide - Leading international bank in the Middle +Multilingual Installation Guide -East8 +G27F - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade +Read this manual carefully before you use this machine and keep it handy for future +reference. For safe and correct use, be sure to read the Safety Precautions in the User’s +Manual before using the machine. -finance9 +Warranty Card - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and +Warranty Card -Belt and Road Initiative10 +Note: Please keep the packaging box and packing materials for future +transportation of the monitor. - #1 DCM in Middle East5 +-13- - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on +LCD Monitor User's Manual Product Overview -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA +front View -2017 +Power LED -2030E +-14- -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes +LCD Monitor User's Manual Rear View -Japanese banks - -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees - -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 - -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) +7 8 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -2 - -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows - -Aspiration - -Characteristics - -Markets - -Markets at -scale - -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” - -Markets as -leading -international -bank - -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” - - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% - -market share - - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments - - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore - - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 - - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) - - Australia - Canada - China - France - - Germany - India - Indonesia - US - -Markets to -connect the -network - -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” - - Targeted offering for - -international customers - - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where - -possible - - Network markets to - -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) - - Supporting subsidiaries of - -global customers - -% of adj. -revenue - -FY17 - -c.60% - -c.25% - -c.15% - -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC - -9 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -3 - -Signature balance sheet strength - -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) - -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 - -Customer accounts - -Balance Sheet - -Loans & advances to -customers - -Total equity - -1.4tn - -1.0tn - -198bn - -Total regulatory capital - -182bn - -Capital - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital ratio - -5.6% - -20.9% - -Advances to deposits ratio - -71% - -Funding and -liquidity - -Liquidity coverage ratio - -142% - -10 year PBT -volatility2 - -LICs / loans -and advances3 - -Advances to -deposits ratio - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital -ratio - -Liquid asset buffer - ->500bn - -CET1 ratio - -Peer group -average1 - -2.6x - -HSBC - -1.0x - -5.5%4 - -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. - -10 - -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -11 - - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth - -Transformation since 2011 - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 - - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by - -USD349bn or 29%1 - - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions - - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities - - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” - -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities - - Shifted business to Asia and - -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 - - Strengthened network to support - -global trade and capital flows - - Demonstrated ability to execute - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Growth - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Turnaround - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Customer - 1 2 @@ -869,1969 +635,1367 @@ Customer 6 -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service - -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -Empower our -people - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills - -Our People - -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis - -12 - - Strategic priorities - -1-3 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity - -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity - -CAGR --8% - -72.3 - -mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -+7% - -51.4 - -48.0 +1. USB upstream port +2. USB 3.0 ports (x2) +3. DC IN jack +4. HDMI ports (x2) -2011 +5. DisplayPort +6. Headphone jack +7. Control button +8. Kensington lock -2016 +-15- -2017 +LCD Monitor User's Manual GETTING STaRTED +Installing the Monitor Base +1. Place the monitor on the lower EPS foam, with the screen facing -2020 -Target +down. -1. ROE including PVIF +2. Align the monitor base with the two guide pins underneath the -Market -Growth +stand. Then install the base onto the stand. -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn +3. Lift the monitor to an upright position and place it on a table. The -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance +monitor's height may be adjusted after item 1 and item 2 shown in +the figure are removed. -Asia Wealth - -Asset Management -(Asia) - -Belt and Road - -Insurance -(Asia)1 - -ASEAN - -PRD - -UK -Ring-fenced Bank - -Hong Kong - -Transaction Banking/ -International network - -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) - -Cost of Equity - -RoTE - -13 - - Strategic priorities +2 1 -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia - ->3bn - ->1bn - ->0.2bn - -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -PBT, 2017 -USDbn - -11.4 - -7.5 - -A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments - -Revenue, 2017 USDbn - -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) - -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) - -ASEAN - -China - -India - -Australia - -Other Asia - -4.7 - -3.1 - -PRD - -0.2 - -2.4 - -2.4 - -0.9 - -0.9 - -2.1 - -1.2 - -0.5 - -0.9 - -0.4 - -0.8 - -B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing - -technology in PRD - -C - -Build leading Wealth Management business - - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater - -China and ASEAN - - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional +-16- -clients +LCD Monitor User's Manual adjusting the Viewing angle +Note: Hold the monitor base so that the screen does not topple when +you make the adjustment. -D +adjusting the Tilt angle +Tilt the screen forward or backward to the desired viewing angle (-5° to +20°). -Expand our business in ASEAN +20° - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise +5° -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth +adjusting the Screen Orientation +Raise the screen to the maximum height (130mm). - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position +130 mm -14 +-17- - Strategic priorities +LCD Monitor User's Manual Installing a Wall-Mount Bracket (Optional) +Use only the 100 x 100 mm wall mount kit recommended by the manu- +facturer. +1. Place the monitor on the lower EPS foam, with the screen facing -1A +down. -Build on strength in Hong Kong +2. Push the locking clips inward to detach the stand from the monitor. -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… +3. Attach the mounting bracket to the mounting holes at the rear of +the monitor. Then use the screws to secure the bracket in place. -Opportunities and areas of investment +100 mm -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn +100 mm -HSBC market -share, % +Note: -USD0.9tn + To mount the monitor on the wall, refer to the installation guide that is +included in the wall-mount bracket kit. -USD2.9tn + The monitor head may be installed on wall, rotary brackets or other brackets. +This monitor supports 100 mm mounting holes that comply with VESA indus- +trial standard. To install any third-party solution to the monitor, four φ4 mm +screws with pitch of 0.7 mm and length of 10 mm are required. If any longer +screw is used, the monitor may be damaged. Check if the bracket provided +by the manufacturer complies with VESA standard and is able to support the +monitor body. Please use the power cable and video cable attached to the +monitor, in order to ensure the optimal performance. -10% +-18- -CAGR -2005-17 +LCD Monitor User's Manual + Making Connections -24% - -2005 - -10% - -Asset growth - -25% - -20172 - -Leading market share across major products2 - -…with leading positions across major products3 - -Customer -accounts - -Loans and -advances to -customers - -DCM - -#1 - -#1 - -#1 - -Mortgages - -37% - -#1 - -Credit cards - ->40% - -Trade finance - -#1 - -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments - -Enhance -customer -experience - -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments - - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident - -Chinese customers - - Invest in insurance for sustainable - -market share growth - - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business - -Banking - - Explore partnerships to launch - -innovative solutions - - Capture new growth opportunities with - -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese - -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as - -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation - -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia - -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share - -15 - -excluding Japan - - Strategic priorities - -1B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) - -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -USDbn - -Revenue - -0.18 - -2014 - -0.22 - -2017 - ->USD1bn - -c.0.5 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - -Loans & advances to customers - ->20bn - -4.1 - -6.2 - ->10bn - -2014 - -2017 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank - -in China, opened for business in December 2017 - - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled - -since project launched in June 2015 - - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 - - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect - - Enhance corporate coverage to - -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading - - Broaden client base and drive for - -deposit-heavy product mix - -Emerging -Middle -Class - -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity - - Fully leverage capital market - -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation - -New business -capabilities - -16 - - Strategic priorities - -1C - -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth - -Rising wealth in Asia - -Private financial wealth1, USDtn - -2016-21E -CAGR - -223 - -Middle class in Asia2 - -# of people, bn - -2.5x - -152 - -E. Europe - -L. America - -MENA - -N. America - -34% - -W. Europe - -25% - -Japan +21 -10% +Headphone -Asia ex Japan +2 -21% +3 -166 +4 -33% +Computer -24% +5 -9% +1 Headphone cable +2 HDMI cable +3 DisplayPort cable -23% +Keyboard -33% +Mouse -5.6% +Computer -Average household annual income3 +USB +disk +drive -2015 +4 USB (A-Male to B-Male) cable +5 USB cable -2030E +-19- -USD‘000 +LCD Monitor User's Manual USING THE DEVICE +Turning the Power On/Off -2.3x +Power On -22% +1. Connect one end of the power cable to the adapter and connect +the output cable of the adapter to the DC IN jack of the monitor. -3.5% +2. Connect other end of the the power cable to a power outlet. +3. Press the Control button to turn on the monitor. The Power LED will -7% +light in white, indicating the monitor is ready to use. -1.7% +Power Off +Press the Control button for 2 seconds to turn off the monitor. +Note: When the Main menu appears on the screen, you can also turn off +). Refer to page 25. +the monitor by moving the Control button down ( -28% +-20- -9.9% +LCD Monitor User's Manual User Comfort Recommendations -2017 +The following are some tips for comfortable viewing of your monitor: +• Optimal viewing distances for monitors range from approximately -2030E +510 mm to 760 mm (20” to 30”). -HNWI financial wealth4 +• A general guideline is to position the monitor such that the top +of the screen is at or slightly below your eye-height when you are +comfortably seated. -USDtrn +• Use adequate lighting for the type of work you are performing. +• -2.0x +Take regular and frequent breaks (at least for 10 minutes) every half +hour. +Be sure to periodically look away from your monitor screen and +focus on a far object for at least 20 seconds during the breaks. +Eye exercise can help reduce eye strain. Repeat these exercises +frequently: (1) look up and down (2) slowly roll your eye (3) move +your eyes diagonally. -2014 +• -2016 +• -2021E +-21- -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Selecting the Input Source -2017 +1. Move the Control button right +) to enter the the Input -2025E +( +menu. -17 +2. Move the Control button up/ +) to select the desired +down ( +input source. Then press the +Control button to confirm. -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities +Input -1C +Select -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia +Exit ->USD1bn +-22- ->0.4bn +LCD Monitor User's Manual OPERaTIONS +Quick Menu ->0.1bn +Hot Key +By default, the Control button has been assigned with the specific +function. +Note: To change the preset hot key function, refer to the “Quick Switch” section +on page 34. -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today +To access the hot key function, do the following: +• Move the Control button up -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 +) to enter the Black Equalizer -Opportunities and areas of investment +( +menu. + Move the Control button +) to adjust +up/down ( +the setting and press the +Control button to confirm. -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Black Equalizer -USD +adjust -Wealth in -Asia +Exit -Private -Bank +-23- -RBWM -Wealth +LCD Monitor User's Manual + • Move the Control button down ( -Insurance1 +) to enter the Picture Mode -Asset -Management1 0.3 +menu. + Move the Control button + ) to select the +up/down ( +desired option and press +the Control button to con- +firm. -1. +Picture Mode -Includes manufacturing revenue only +Standard -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) +fPS - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater +RTS/RPG -China +Movie - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth +Reader -0.7 +sRGB - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by +Select -investment in RM and product platform +Exit - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary +• Move the Control button left -portfolio management and lombard lending +( -Insurance + ) to enter the Volume menu. - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth +Volume -customers, and strengthen front line + Move the Control button +up/down ( +) to adjust +the headphone volume +level and press the Control +button to confirm. - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new +adjust -distribution channels +Exit - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +• Move the Control button right ( -Asset management +) to enter the the Input menu. - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / +Refer to the “Selecting the Input Source” section. -GPB customers +Note: To close the menu, move the Control button left ( - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China + ). -18 +-24- -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities +LCD Monitor User's Manual -2 + function Key Guide -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing +Press the Control button to display the Main menu. ->USD1bn +Settings ->0.4bn +Dashboard ->0.1bn +GameAssist -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 +Exit -USD +Power Off -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion +Then use the Control button to select the desired function and +configure the related settings. -Opportunities and areas of investment +Dashboard +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +left ( - HSBC is positioned for +) to enter the Dashboard menu. -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 +OFF - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: +Dashboard -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme +function -– More than 95% of technical +ON -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed +Dashboard +Location -Retail -banking +Off - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by +Select -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 +Exit - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth +CPU Temperature -and acquire new customers +CPU frequency - Leverage our unique global access to support +CPU fan Speed -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs +CPU Usage Rate -Corporate -banking +GPU Temperature - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ +GPU frequency - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) +GPU fan Speed -Digital and -customer -satisfaction +• - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for +Function: Enable/Disable the function. When enabled, you can +select the desired option(s) to be shown on the screen. -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification +• Dashboard Location: Specify the location of the Dashboard - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) +information to be shown on the screen. - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines +-25- -and brands +LCD Monitor User's Manual Once the Dashboard configuration is complete, it will transfer the +system data to the SOC through the USB port and display the value of +the selected function(s) on the screen. -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite +CPU Temperature -19 +CPU frequency - Strategic priorities +CPU fan Speed -3 +CPU Usage Rate -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network +GPU Temperature ->USD1bn +GPU frequency ->0.4bn +GPU fan Speed ->0.1bn +GPU Usage Rate -Investments are delivering +aORUS Mouse DPI -Opportunities and areas of investment +OFF -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Dashboard -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance +function -Trade Finance -rank1 +ON -Hong Kong -market share2 +Dashboard +Location -2015 +Off -2017 +Select -#1 +Exit -#1 +CPU Temperature - +CPU frequency -10.8% +CPU fan Speed -13.8% +CPU Usage Rate -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management +GPU Temperature -Average GLCM -balances +GPU frequency -c$470bn +GPU fan Speed -c$530bn +Note: Make sure the USB cable is properly connected to the USB upstream port +of the monitor and the USB port of your computer +Gameassist +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +right ( -Hong Kong -market share3 +) to enter the GameAssist menu. -22.8% +Gameassist -26.3% +GaME INfO -FX corporates -rank4 +Gaming Timer -FX institutional -rank4 +Gaming Counter -#1 +Crosshair -#7 +Refresh Rate - +Info Location -#1 +Display alignment -#3 +Select -Assets under -custody +Exit -$6.2trn +-26- -$7.7trn +LCD Monitor User's Manual • Game Info: Configure the FPS (First Person Shooting) game related -FX +settings. +√ Select Gaming Timer to select countdown timer mode. To -Securities -Services +disable this function, set the setting to OFF. -Digitise and grow Trade Finance +√ Select Gaming Counter or Refresh Rate to enable/disable the - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems +gaming counter or real-time refresh rate setting. - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by +√ Select Info Location to specify the location of the information to -investing in our channel and product capabilities +be shown on the screen. - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured +Gameassist -trade +GaME INfO -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM +Gaming Timer - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by +Gaming Counter -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions +Crosshair - Create new products and revenue streams - new +Refresh Rate -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees +Info Location -FX business growth +Display alignment - Grow the business through the continued development +Select -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model +Exit - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise +• Crosshair: Select the desired crosshair type to suit your gaming -the customer experience +environment. It makes aiming much easier. -Grow Securities Services business +• Display alignment: When the function is enabled, it displays the +alignment lines on the four sides of the screen, providing handy +tool for you to line up multiple monitors perfectly. -Market share5 +-27- -5.4% +LCD Monitor User's Manual Configure the Device Settings -5.8% +When the Main menu appears on the screen, move the Control button +up ( - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products + ) to enter the Settings menu. -Asia rank6 +Note: Use the Control button to navigate through the menu and make +adjustments. -#1 +Exit -#1 +Move/adjust -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey +Enter/Confirm -and services; invest in digital future +Button Guide - +Gaming +Configure the game related settings. - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on +Resolution +1902x1080 -asset managers and asset owners +Black Equalizer +10 -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making +aim Stabilizer +Off -up c.82% of the market +Overdrive +Balance -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen +Refresh Rate +60Hz -20 +freeSync +ON - Strategic priorities +Picture Mode -4 +Standard -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank +Gaming -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn +Picture -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed +Display -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US +System -2 +Language -1 +Save Settings -0 +Reset all -US +ON -UK +Off -China +aim Stabilizer -France +Black Equalizer -% of Group client outbound revenue +Super Resolution -Hong -Kong +Display Mode -24% +Overdrive -13% +freeSync -9% +Exit -6% +Move/adjust -6% +Enter/Confirm -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +Item +Aim Stabilizer -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +Description +When this function is enabled, it reduces the motion +blur in a fast moving games. +Note: This function is not available under the following +conditions: +-when the frequency setting is lower than 100Hz. +-when the FreeSync function is activated. -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +-28- -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Black Equalizer +Super Resolution +Display Mode -Other +Overdrive +FreeSync -32% +Description +Adjust the brightness of the black areas. +Sharpen the low resolution images. +Select the aspect ratio of the screen. +• Full: Scale the input image to fill the screen. -51% +Ideal for 16:9 aspect images. -68% +• Aspect: Display the input image without geo- +metric distortion filling as much of the screen +as possible. -USD +Improve the response time of the LCD monitor. +When this function is enabled, it eliminates the +screen lag and tearing while playing games. -JP -Morgan +-29- -Citigroup +LCD Monitor User's Manual Picture -Bank of -America +Configure the image related settings. -HSBC +Resolution +1902x1080 -BoNY -Mellon +Brightness +85 -c.19% +Contrast +50 -Overall +Sharpness +5 -Hong Kong +Gamma +Gamma 3 -Germany +Color Temp. Normal -UK +Picture Mode -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) +Standard -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT +Gaming -21 +Picture -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities +Display -4 +System -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform +Language -The US has made progress over the past several years… +Save Settings -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth +Reset all -Adjusted PBT1, USDm +Standard -RoTE2 +fPS -> 6%2 +RTS/RPG -1,201 +Movie -974 +Reader -CML +sRGB -US Principal +Custom 1 -464 +Brightness -494 +Contrast Ratio -737 +Color Vibrance -920 +Sharpness -556 +Gamma -387 +Color Temperature -2014 +Low Blue Light -2015 +Exit -2016 +Move/adjust -2017 +Enter/Confirm -0.9%2,3 +Select the one of the preset picture mode. +• +• +• -2017 +Standard: For editing documents or browsing websites. +FPS: For playing FPS (First Person Shooting) games. +RTS/RPG: For playing RTS (Real-Time Strategy) or RPG (Role-Playing +Game) games. -PBT growth +Reader: For viewing documents. +sRGB: For viewing photos and graphics on the computer. -Future capital -actions +• Movie: For watching movies. +• +• +• Custom 1: Customized picture mode settings. +• Custom 2: Customized picture mode settings. +• Custom 3: Customized picture mode settings. +Then you can configure the following image settings. -2020 +Item +Brightness +Contrast +Color Vibrance +Sharpness -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration +Description +Adjust the brightness of the image. +Adjust the contrast of the image. +Adjust the intensity of the more muted colors. +Adjust the sharpness of the image. -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild +-30- - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Gamma +Color Temperature Select the color temperature. - International client revenue4 booked in the US up +Description +Adjust the middle level of luminance. -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY +Low Blue Light - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: +Note: Select User Define to customize the color +temperature by adjusting the red (R), green (G), or +blue (B) level according to your preference. +Reduce the amount of blue light exposure from +the screen. +• Level 0: No change. +• Level 1~10: The higher the level, the more blue -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly +light will be reduced. -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion +Note: -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- + This is the Low Blue Light Level 10 under +the normal image mode with normal col- +or temperature. It is compliance with TUV +Low Blue Light Certification -return products and business banking +Dynamic Contrast Adjust the black level of the image to achieve the -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national +Senseye Demo -clients in the US +Reset Picture - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in +optimum contrast. +Split the screen in half (2 windows). +The image of the selected mode with its default +settings will appear on the left window and the +adjusted image with the new settings will appear +on the right window. +Reset all Picture settings to the default settings. -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions +-31- - Return to regular dividend payments to Group +LCD Monitor User's Manual Display -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers +Configure the display related settings. -22 +Resolution +1902x1080 -to 2017 +Brightness +85 - Strategic priorities +Contrast +50 +Sharpness 5 -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 +Gamma +Gamma 3 -GB&M +Color Temp. Normal -34% +Picture Mode -CMB +Standard -35% +Input -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre +HDMI RGB PC Range -14% -2% -15% +Overscan -c.30% +Gaming -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth +Picture -c.35% +Display -Distribution +System -15-20% +Language -2020 -target +Save Settings -c.7% +Reset all -RWA -optimisation +Exit - Develop distribution +Move/adjust -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending +Enter/Confirm - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom - -23 - - Strategic priorities - -6 +Item +Input +HDMI RGB +PC Range -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment +Overscan -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness - - Investments aligned to strategic priorities - - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term - - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and - -31.1 - -c.4 - -4.5-5 - -5.5-6 - -6-6.5 +Description +Select the input source. +Select an appropriate RGB range setting or let the +monitor to detect it automatically. +Note: This option is only available for HDMI input. +When this function is enabled, it slightly enlarges +the input image to hide the outermost edges of +the image. +Note: This option is only available for HDMI input. -revenue development +-32- - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from +LCD Monitor User's Manual System -within the cost base of the Group +Configure the system related settings. -Revenue +Resolution +1902x1080 -Total -operating -expenses +Brightness +85 -Investments +Contrast +50 -Costs (ex -investments) +Sharpness +5 -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity +Gamma +Gamma 3 - Implement strong cost discipline and control +Color Temp. Normal -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market +Picture Mode -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains +Standard -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity +Gaming - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each +Picture -year 2018-2020 +Display -2017 +System -2018 +Language -2019 +Save Settings -2020 +Reset all -Jaws1 +Item +Audio -positive +OSD Settings -positive +audio -positive +OSD Settings -positive +Quick Switch -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve +Other Settings -24 +Volume - Strategic priorities +Mute -7 +Exit -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework +Move/adjust -Investment -categories +Enter/Confirm Description +Configure the audio settings. +• Volume: Adjust the volume level. +• Mute: Enable/Disable the mute function. +Configure the on-screen display (OSD) menu +related settings. +• Display Time: Set the length of time the OSD -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 +menu remains on the screen. - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) +• OSD Transparency: Adjust the OSD menu - Investments in new +transparency. -opportunities +• OSD Lock: When this function is enabled, no - Improve operational +OSD adjustment is allowed. +Note: To disable the OSD lock function, press +the Control key. When the message appears on +the screen, select Yes to confirm. -efficiency in order to lower -cost base +The button is locked - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 +Confirm to unlock +OSD. - Deliver robust solution design +No -with additional franchise -benefits +yes - Turnaround of existing businesses +-33- -(e.g. US) +LCD Monitor User's Manual Item +Quick Switch - Investing in expanding our businesses +Other Settings -(e.g. PRD) - - Productivity programmes - -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) - - Core infrastructure replacement or - -modernisation (e.g. US) - -c.1/3 - - Implement required - - Deliver in cost - - Implement regulatory programmes - -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security - -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits - -(e.g. IFRS 9) - - Strengthen capabilities to manage - -financial crime risk - - Increase cyber security measures - -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 - -USD15-17bn +Description +Assign the function of the hot keys. +Available options: Aim Stabilizer, Black Equalizer, +Low Blue Light, Volume, Input, Contrast, Bright- +ness, and Picture Mode. +The default setting of the hot keys as below: -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities +D Up( -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure +):Black Equalizer -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability +D Down( -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers +):Picture Mode -1. P&L basis +D Right( -25 +):Input - Strategic priorities +D Left( +• Resolution Notice: When this function is en- -8 +):Volume -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +abled, the recommended resolution message +will appear on the screen when the monitor +switches to another input source. +Input Auto Switch: When this function is en- +abled, it automatically switches to an available +input source. -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation +• -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end +• Auto Power OFF: When this function is enabled, +the monitor will automatically turn off after a +certain amount of time. -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days +• DisplayPort Ver.: Set the DisplayPort version to - Strengthen accountability, decision- +1.1, 1.2. -to 10 (Private Banking) +Note: +• -making + Make sure to configure this option based +on the DisplayPort version supported by +your graphics card. - Clarify roles within the organisation’s +-34- -matrix +LCD Monitor User's Manual Language -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients +Language-related settings -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 +Resolution +1902x1080 - Building capabilities for continuous +Brightness +85 -improvement +Contrast +50 -Streamlining governance +Sharpness +5 - Reducing number of +Gamma +Gamma 3 -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 +Color Temp. Normal - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance +Picture Mode - Embed throughout the organisation +Standard -and for all legal entities +English +English -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership +Deutsch - +Français -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working +Gaming - Balanced scorecards to incentivise +Picture -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation +Display -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online +System - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills +Language -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC +Save Settings -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of +Reset all -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and +Exit -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths +Move/adjust - Build a diverse workforce +Enter/Confirm -26 +Item +Language - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates +Description +Select an available language for the OSD menu. -Strategic priorities +-35- -Targeted outcome by 2020 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Save Settings -1 +Set the personalized OSD configurations for Setting1, Setting2, or +Setting3. -2 +Resolution +1902x1080 -3 +Brightness +85 -4 +Contrast +50 +Sharpness 5 -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and +Gamma +Gamma 3 - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian +Color Temp. Normal -franchise +Picture Mode - Market share gains in 8 scale markets +Standard -Asset Management) +Setting1 -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy +Setting1 - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 +Setting1 -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network +Gaming - Market share gains +Picture - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from +Display -international network +System - Market share gains in Transaction Banking +Language -Turn around our US business +Save Settings - US RoTE >6% +Reset all -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses +Exit -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains +Move/adjust -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial +Enter/Confirm -crime standards +Item +Save +Load - Increase in asset productivity +Reset all - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, - -each financial year - - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 - -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics - -27 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -28 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 - -Reported RoTE walk1 - -% - -8.7 - -6.8 - -2017 -Reported - -Sig items +Description +Save the customized settings. +Load the saved settings. -2017 ex- -sig items +Restore the monitor to its factory default settings. -Interest -rate rises2 +Resolution +1902x1080 -UK -growth +Brightness +85 -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance +Contrast +50 -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network +Sharpness +5 -US turn- -around3 +Gamma +Gamma 3 -Investments +Color Temp. Normal -Other4 +Picture Mode -ROE -Reported +Standard -5.9% +Gaming -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements +Picture -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval +Display -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items +System -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency +Language - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology +Save Settings ->11 +Reset all + +Exit + +Move/adjust + +Enter/Confirm + +-36- + +LCD Monitor User's Manual aPPENDICES +Specifications + +Item +Specifications +Panel Size +27-inch +Aspect Ratio +16:9 +Resolution +1920 x 1080 +Refresh Rate +144Hz +LED Life +30000 hours (min.) +Pixel Pitch +0.31125 x 0.31125 +Response Time +1ms (MPRT) +Brightness +300nits (typ.) / 250nits (min.) +1000:1 (typ.) +Contrast Ratio +Dynamic Contrast Ratio 12M:1 (typ.) +Color Depth +Active Display area +Viewing Angle +Frequency +Input/Output Terminals • 2x HDMI 1.4 + +16. 7M +597.6(H) x 336.15 (V) +178° (H) / 178° (V) +48~144Hz (gaming mode) + +• 2x USB 3.0 (downstream) + +• 1x DP1.2 +• 1x Headphone +• 1x USB upstream + +Support USB BC1.2 +specifications +Single-port output: 5V/1.5A +Double-port output: 5V/1A - Delivering positive +port -adjusted jaws +Power Supply/Input +Power Supply/Model +Power Consumptions - Increasing capital +AC100~240V@ 50/60Hz +Asian Power Devices Inc., NB-65B19 +• On: 60W (Max.) +• Standby: 0.5W +• Off: 0.3W -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity +Dimensions (W x H x D) 619.04 x 518.88 x 202. 97mm (with stand) +6.5±0.5 kgs (Net) +Weight +0°C - 40°C +Operating conditions: +temperature range - Sustaining dividend, +Note: Specifications subject to change without notice. -supported by share buy- -backs5 +-37- - With >14% CET1 ratio +LCD Monitor User's Manual Supported Timing List -2020 -Reported -(target) +Timing List +640x480@60Hz +640x480@75Hz +720x480@60Hz +800x600@60Hz +800x600@75Hz +1024x768@60Hz +1024x768@75Hz +1280x720@60Hz +1280x720@120Hz +1280x720@144Hz +1920x1080@60Hz +1920x1080@120Hz +1920x1080@144Hz ->10% +HDMI +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ -29 +DP +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ +√ - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution +-38- -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 +LCD Monitor User's Manual Troubleshooting -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders +Problem -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 +No power -12-13% +No image appears +on the screen -Surplus equity3 +The image does +not fill the entire +screen -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 +The colors are +distorted -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses +No sound or +volume is low -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally +Possible Solution(s) -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 +• Make sure the power cable is properly connected -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items +to the power source and the monitor. -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing +• Check the cable and plug to make sure they are -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base +not broken. -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes +• Make sure the monitor is turned on. +• Make sure the adapter LED is on. ->14% +• Make sure the monitor and the computer are -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval +properly connected and both devices are turned +on. -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D +• Make sure you have selected the correct input -s -r -o -t -c -a -f +source. Refer to page 22 or 32. -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e +• Adjust the Brightness and Contrast settings. -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R +Refer to page 30. -Higher risk weights -under local rules +• Try different Display Mode (aspect ratio) setting. -Diversification -benefit / other +Refer to page 29. -Stress testing +• Make sure the input signal cable is properly -Anticipated -regulatory changes +connected. -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio +• Configure the image related settings. Refer to -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. +the “Picture” section. -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators +• Make sure the headphone cable is properly -30 +connected. - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion +• Adjust the volume level. Refer to page 24 or 33. +• Adjust your computer sound related settings. - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest +Note: If the problem persists, please contact our customer service for +further assistance. -growth markets +-39- - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and +LCD Monitor User's Manual Basic Care -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode +When the screen becomes dirty, do the following to clean the screen: +• Wipe the screen with your soft, lint-free cloth to remove any residual -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular +• -in Asia and from our international network +dust. +Spray or apply the cleaning fluid onto a soft cloth. Then wipe the +screen gently with the damp cloth. -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +Note: +• Make sure that the cloth is damp, but not wet. +• When wiping, avoid applying excessive pressure on the screen. +• Acidic or abrasive cleaners can damage the screen. -- Complete the turnaround in the US +Notes on USB Charging -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future +The following devices are not compatible with BC 1.2 of CDP mode. +When the Hub is connected to a PC, these devices cannot be charged +using the USB cable. - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while +Vendor +Apple +Samsung +Samsung -delivering positive adjusted jaws +Device +IPad +Galaxy Tab2 10.1 +GALAXY TabPro - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for +PID/VID +PID_129A/VID_05AC +PID_6860/VID_04E8 +PID_6860/VID_04E8 -sustained dividends +GIGaByTE Service Information -31 +More service information, please visit GIGABYTE official website: +https://www.gigabyte.com/ - 32 +-40- +LCD Monitor User's Manual \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q238/random_k4/random_3.md b/q238/random_k4/random_3.md index 015f1dbfe60c508b084f8a896f8d2aaaacd925e1..1ac627c3d95d71bba88aff7ff8158f25e99f463e 100644 --- a/q238/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q238/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,2402 +1,1642 @@ -Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 1 of 19 +RESEARCH ARTICLE + +The population genetics of human disease: +The case of recessive, lethal mutations + +Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim1,2*, Ziyue Gao3, Zachary Baker4, Jose´ Francisco Diesel5, +Yuval B. Simons1, Imran S. Haque6¤, Joseph Pickrell1,7‡, Molly Przeworski1,4‡ + +1 Department of Biological Sciences, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, +2 CAPES Foundation, Ministry of Education of Brazil, Brası´lia, DF, Brazil, 3 Howard Hughes Medical +Institution, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States of America, 4 Department of Systems Biology, +Columbia University, New York, NY, United States of America, 5 Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, +Santa Maria, RS, Brazil, 6 Counsyl, 180 Kimball Way, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America, +7 New York Genome Center, New York, NY, United States of America + +¤ Current address: Freenome, South San Francisco, CA, United States of America +‡ These authors co-supervised this work. +* guerraamorim@gmail.com + +Abstract + +Do the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations reflect a simple balance +between mutation and purifying selection? What other factors shape the prevalence of dis- +ease mutations? To begin to answer these questions, we focused on one of the simplest +cases: recessive mutations that alone cause lethal diseases or complete sterility. To this +end, we generated a hand-curated set of 417 Mendelian mutations in 32 genes reported to +cause a recessive, lethal Mendelian disease. We then considered analytic models of muta- +tion-selection balance in infinite and finite populations of constant sizes and simulations of +purifying selection in a more realistic demographic setting, and tested how well these mod- +els fit allele frequencies estimated from 33,370 individuals of European ancestry. In doing +so, we distinguished between CpG transitions, which occur at a substantially elevated rate, +and three other mutation types. Intriguingly, the observed frequency for CpG transitions is +slightly higher than expectation but close, whereas the frequencies observed for the three +other mutation types are an order of magnitude higher than expected, with a bigger deviation +from expectation seen for less mutable types. This discrepancy is even larger when subtle +fitness effects in heterozygotes or lethal compound heterozygotes are taken into account. +In principle, higher than expected frequencies of disease mutations could be due to wide- +spread errors in reporting causal variants, compensation by other mutations, or balancing +selection. It is unclear why these factors would have a greater impact on disease mutations +that occur at lower rates, however. We argue instead that the unexpectedly high frequency +of disease mutations and the relationship to the mutation rate likely reflect an ascertainment +bias: of all the mutations that cause recessive lethal diseases, those that by chance have +reached higher frequencies are more likely to have been identified and thus to have been +included in this study. Beyond the specific application, this study highlights the parameters +likely to be important in shaping the frequencies of Mendelian disease alleles. + +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 +a1111111111 + +OPEN ACCESS + +Citation: Amorim CEG, Gao Z, Baker Z, Diesel JF, +Simons YB, Haque IS, et al. (2017) The population +genetics of human disease: The case of recessive, +lethal mutations. PLoS Genet 13(9): e1006915. +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 + +Editor: Philipp W. Messer, Cornell University, +UNITED STATES + +Received: December 4, 2016 + +Accepted: July 9, 2017 + +Published: September 28, 2017 + +Copyright: © 2017 Amorim et al. This is an open +access article distributed under the terms of the +Creative Commons Attribution License, which +permits unrestricted use, distribution, and +reproduction in any medium, provided the original +author and source are credited. + +Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are +within the paper and its Supporting Information +files and code from gitHub (https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease; https://github. +com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator). + +Funding: CEGA was partially funded by a Science +Without Borders fellowship from CAPES +foundation (BEX 8279/11-0) and Conselho +Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientı´fico e +Tecnolo´gico (PDE 201145/2015-4), Brazil. ZG was +partially supported by a postdoctoral fellowship +funded by Stanford Center for Computational, + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +1 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Evolutionary and Human Genomics. JFD was +funded by a Science Without Borders fellowship +from CAPES foundation (88888.038761/2013-00). +YBS was supported by NIH grant GM115889. The +work was partially supported by a Research +Initiative in Science and Engineering grant from +Columbia University and NIGMS grants +(GM121372) to JKP and MP. The computing in +this project was supported by two National +Institutes of Health instrumentation grants +(S10OD012351 and S10OD021764) received by +the Department of Systems Biology at Columbia +University. The funders had no role in study +design, data collection and analysis, decision to +publish, or preparation of the manuscript. + +Competing interests: The authors have declared +that no competing interests exist. + +Author summary + +What determines the frequencies of disease mutations in human populations? To begin to +answer this question, we focus on one of the simplest cases: mutations that cause com- +pletely recessive, lethal Mendelian diseases. We first review theory about what to expect +from mutation and selection in a population of finite size and generate predictions based +on simulations using a plausible demographic scenario of recent human evolution. For a +highly mutable type of mutation, transitions at CpG sites, we find that the predictions are +close to the observed frequencies of recessive lethal disease mutations. For less mutable +types, however, predictions substantially under-estimate the observed frequency. We dis- +cuss possible explanations for the discrepancy and point to a complication that, to our +knowledge, is not widely appreciated: that there exists ascertainment bias in disease muta- +tion discovery. Specifically, we suggest that alleles that have been identified to date are +likely the ones that by chance have reached higher frequencies and are thus more likely to +have been mapped. More generally, our study highlights the factors that influence the fre- +quencies of Mendelian disease alleles. + +Introduction + +New disease mutations arise in heterozygotes and either drift to higher frequencies or are rap- +idly purged from the population, depending on the strength of selection and the demographic +history of the population [1–6]. Elucidating the relative contributions of mutation, natural +selection and genetic drift will help to understand why disease alleles persist in humans. +Answers to these questions are also of practical importance, in informing how genetic varia- +tion data can be used to identify additional disease mutations [7]. + +In this regard, rare, Mendelian diseases, which are caused by single highly penetrant and +deleterious alleles, are perhaps most amenable to investigation. A simple model for the persis- +tence of mutations that lead to Mendelian diseases is that their frequencies reflect an equilib- +rium between their introduction by mutation and elimination by purifying selection, i.e., that +they should be found at “mutation-selection balance” [4]. In finite populations, random drift +leads to stochastic changes in the frequency of any mutation, so demographic history, in addi- +tion to mutation and natural selection, plays an important role in shaping the frequency distri- +bution of deleterious mutations [3]. + +Another factor that may be important in determining the frequencies of highly penetrant + +disease mutations is genetic interactions. The mutation-selection balance model has been +extended to scenarios with more than one disease allele, as is often seen for Mendelian diseases +[8,9]. When compound heterozygotes have the same fitness as homozygotes for the disease +allele (i.e., there is no complementation), the combined frequency of all disease alleles can be +modeled similarly as the bi-allelic case, with the mutation rate given by the sum of the muta- +tion rate to each disease allele [8]. In other cases, a disease mutation may be rescued by another +mutation in the same gene [10–12] or by a modifier locus elsewhere in the genome that modu- +lates the severity of the disease symptoms or the penetrance of the disease allele (e.g. [13–15]). +For a subset of disease alleles that are recessive, an alternative model for their persistence in +the population is that there is an advantage to carrying one copy but a disadvantage to carrying +two or none, such that the alleles persist due to overdominance, a form of balancing selection. +Well known examples include sickle cell anemia, thalassemia and G6PD deficiency in populations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +2 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +living where malaria exerts strong selection pressures [16]. The importance of overdominance in +maintaining the high frequency of disease mutations is unknown beyond these specific cases. + +Here, we tested hypotheses about the persistence of mutations that cause lethal, recessive, +Mendelian disorders. This case provides a good starting point, because a large number of Men- +delian disorders have been mapped (e.g., genes have already been associated with >56% of +Mendelian disease phenotypes; [17]). Moreover, while the fitness effects of most diseases are +hard to estimate, for recessive lethal diseases, the selection coefficient is clearly 1 for homozy- +gote carriers in the absence of modern medical care (which, when available, became so only in +the last couple of generations, a timescale that is much too short to substantially affect disease +allele frequencies). Moreover, assuming mutation-selection balance in an infinite population +and no effects in heterozygotes would suggest that, given a per base pair (bp) mutation rate u +ffiffiffi +, i.e., ~10−4 +on the order of 10−8 per generation [18], the frequency of such alleles would be +u +[4]. Thus, sample sizes in human genetics are now sufficiently large that we should be able to +observe completely recessive, lethal disease alleles segregating in heterozygote carriers. + +p + +To this end, we compiled genetic information for a set of 417 mutations reported to cause +fatal, recessive Mendelian diseases and estimated the frequencies of the disease-causing alleles +from large exome datasets. We then compared these data to the expected frequencies of delete- +rious alleles based on models of mutation-selection balance in order to evaluate the effects of +mutation rates and other factors in influencing these frequencies. + +Results + +Mendelian recessive disease allele set + +We relied on two datasets, one that describes 173 autosomal recessive diseases [19] and another +from a genetic testing laboratory (Counsyl [20]; ) that includes 110 +recessive diseases of clinical interest. From these lists, we obtained a set of 44 “recessive lethal” dis- +eases associated with 45 genes (S1 Table), requiring that at least one of the following conditions is +met: (i) in the absence of treatment, the affected individuals die of the disease before reproductive +age, (ii) reproduction is completely impaired in patients of both sexes, (iii) the phenotype includes +severe mental retardation that in practice precludes reproduction, or (iv) the phenotype includes +severely compromised physical development, again precluding reproduction. + +Based on clinical genetics datasets and the medical literature (see Methods for details), we +were able to confirm that 417 Single Nucleotide Variants (SNVs) in 32 (of the 44) genes had +been reported with compelling evidence of association to the severe form of the corresponding +disease and an early-onset, as well as no indication of effects in heterozygote carriers (S2 Table). +By this approach, we obtained a set of mutations for which, at least in principle, there is no het- +erozygote effect, i.e., for which the dominance coefficient h = 0 in a model with relative fitness +of 1 for the homozygote for the reference allele, 1-hs for the heterozygote, and 1-s for the homo- +zygote for the deleterious allele, and the selective coefficient s is 1. + +A large subset of these mutations (29.3%) consists of transitions at CpG sites (henceforth +CpGti), which occur at a highly elevated rates (~17-fold higher on average) compared to other +mutation types, namely CpG transversions, and non-CpG transitions and transversions [18]. +This proportion is in agreement with previous estimates for a smaller set of disease genes [21] +and for DMD [22]. + +Empirical distribution of allele frequencies of disease mutations in Europe -LEXINGTON LAW GROUP -Mark N. Todzo, State Bar No. 168389 -Meredyth Merrow, State Bar No. 328337 -503 Divisadero Street -San Francisco, CA 94117 -Telephone: (415) 913-7800 -Facsimile: (415) 759-4112 -mtodzo@lexlawgroup.com -mmerrow@lexlawgroup.com +Allele frequency data for the 417 variants were obtained from the Exome Aggregation Consor- +tium (ExAC) for 60,706 individuals, of whom 33,370 are non-Finnish Europeans [23]. Out of -Attorneys for Plaintiff -DAVID AMBROSE +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT +3 / 23 -FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION +the 417 variants associated with putative recessive lethal diseases, three were found homozy- +gous in at least one individual in this dataset (rs35269064, p.Arg108Leu in ASS1; rs28933375, +p.Asn252Ser in PRF1; and rs113857788, p.Gln1352His in CFTR). Available data quality infor- +mation for these variants does not suggest genotype calling artifacts (S2 Table). Since these +diseases have severe symptoms that lead to early death without treatment and these ExAC indi- +viduals are healthy (i.e., do not manifest severe Mendelian diseases) [23], the reported muta- +tions are likely errors in pathogenicity classification or cases of incomplete penetrance (see a +similar observation for CFTR and DHCR7 in [24]). We therefore excluded them from our anal- +yses. In addition to the mutations present in homozygotes, we also filtered out sites that had +lower coverage in ExAC (see Methods), resulting in a final dataset of 385 variants in 32 genes +(S2 Table). -DAVID AMBROSE, on behalf of himself and all -others similarly situated, +Genotypes for a subset (91) of these mutations were also available for a larger sample size +(76,314 individuals with self-reported European ancestry) generated by the company Counsyl +(S3 Table). A comparison of the allele frequencies in this larger dataset to that of ExAC sug- +gests that the allele frequencies for individual variants are concordant between the two datasets +(Pearson’s correlation coefficient of 0.79, S1 Fig) and that the overall distributions do not differ +appreciably (Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.23). Thus, both data sets appear to reflect +the general distribution of these disease alleles in Europeans. In what follows, we focused on +ExAC, which includes a greater number of disease mutations. - Case No. +Models of mutation-selection balance - v. +To generate expectations for the frequencies of these disease mutations under mutation-selec- +tion balance, we considered models of infinite and finite populations of constant size [3] and +conducted forward simulations using a plausible demographic model for African and Euro- +pean populations [25] (see Methods for details). In all these models, there is a wild-type allele +(A) and a deleterious allele (a, which could also represent a class of distinct deleterious alleles +with the same fitness effect) at each site, such that the relative fitness of individuals of geno- +types AA, Aa, or aa is given respectively by: -THE KROGER CO. +• wAA = 1; -Plaintiff, +• wAa = 1-hs; -Defendant. +• waa = 1-s; -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +The mutation rate from A to a is u; we assume that there are no back mutations. +For a constant population of infinite size, Wright [26] showed that under these conditions, +there exists a stable equilibrium between mutation and selection, when the selection pressure +is sufficiently strong (s>>u). In particular, when the deleterious effect of allele a is completely +recessive (h = 0), its equilibrium frequency q is given by: -1 +p -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 2 of 19 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +: +u=s -18 +q ¼ -19 +ð1Þ -20 +For a finite population of constant size, Nei [3] derived the mean (Eq 2) and variance (Eq 3) -21 +of the frequency of a fully recessive deleterious mutation (h = 0) based on a diffusion model, +leading to: -22 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -23 +(cid:22)q ¼ -24 +Gð2Nu þ 1=2Þ +p +Gð2NuÞ -25 +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2Ns -26 +; -27 +q ¼ u=s (cid:0) (cid:22)q2; +s2 -28 +ð2Þ -Plaintiff David Ambrose (“Plaintiff”), on behalf of himself and those similarly +ð3Þ -situated, based on information, belief and investigation of his counsel, except for information +4 / 23 -based on personal knowledge, hereby alleges: + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -INTRODUCTION +where N is the diploid population size and Γ is the gamma function (see Simons et al. [1] for a +similar approximation). -1. +In a finite population, the mean frequency, (cid:22)q, therefore depends on assumptions about the +population mutation rate (2Nu). If the population mutation rate is high, such that 2Nu>>1, (cid:22)q +is approximated by -Defendant The Kroger Co. (“Defendant”) advertises, markets and sells disposable +p -plates and bowls as compostable (the “Products”). A compostable product is one that will +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +u=s -entirely break down into usable compost. The Products, however, contain significant amounts of +(cid:22)q (cid:25) -perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (“PFAS”), which do not break down and never +ð4Þ -become part of usable compost. Compost is used as soil-conditioning material or fertilizer, so +which is independent of the population size and equal to the equilibrium frequency in an infi- +nite population, i.e., the right hand side of Eq (1). The important difference between the two +models above is that in a finite population, there is a distribution of frequencies q (because of +genetic drift), whose variance is given in Eq (3), rather than a single value, as in an infinite +population. -when compost is contaminated with PFAS, the PFAS then contaminate the soil treated or +In contrast, when the finite population has a low population mutation rate (2Nu<<1), the -fertilized with that compost and whatever grows or grazes on that soil. +mean allele frequency, (cid:22)q, is approximated by: +p -2. +(cid:22)q (cid:25) u -PFAS are known as forever chemicals because they do not break down over time. +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +; +2pN=s -When PFAS are introduced into the environment, they seep into and contaminate both land and +which depends on the population size [3]. -water and then never leave. Once introduced into soil, PFAS contaminate crops grown in the soil +ð5Þ -and meat farmed from animals that graze there. +We note that Nei [3] assumed a Wright-Fisher model, in which there is no distinction -3. +between census and the effective population sizes. However, when the two differ, it is the effec- +tive population size that governs the dynamics of deleterious alleles, so the N in the analytical +results in fact represents the effective population size. In humans, the mutation rate at each bp +is very small (on the order of 10−8 [18]) and the effective population size not that large, even +recently [27,28], so the second approximation should apply when considering each single site +independently. -Many consumers concerned with the environmental problems associated with the +The expectation and variance of the frequency of a fatal, fully recessive allele (i.e., s = 1, -proliferation of trash and waste actively seek to purchase products that are compostable so such +h = 0) are then given by: -products can be introduced into the soil rather than into landfills. These consumers are willing to +and -pay more for such products, which often cost significantly more than non-compostable alternative +p -products. Indeed, the Products cost significantly more than non-compostable disposable plates +ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi +2pN -and bowls. +; -4. +(cid:22)q ¼ u -This Complaint seeks to remedy Defendant’s unlawful, unfair and deceptive +q ¼ u (cid:0) (cid:22)q2 ¼ uð1 (cid:0) 2pNuÞ (cid:25) u: +s2 -business practices with respect to the advertising, marketing and sales of the Products as +ð6Þ -compostable, when, in fact, they are not. +ð7Þ -5. +This single site model implicitly ignores the existence of compound heterozygosity in model- +ing the strength of selection acting on an individual site. -Plaintiff purchased the Products in reliance on Defendant’s false representations +Comparing mutation-selection balance models -that the Products are compostable. Plaintiff viewed Defendant’s false representations on the +Although an infinite population size has often been assumed when modeling deleterious allele +frequencies (e.g. [5,29–32]), predictions under this assumption can differ markedly from what +is expected from models of finite population sizes, assuming plausible parameter values for +humans. For example, the long-term estimate of the effective population size from total poly- +morphism levels is ~20,000 individuals (assuming a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 per bp per gen- +eration [18] and diversity levels of 0.1% [33]). In this case and considering a mutation rate of +1.5 x 10−8 for exons (which have a higher mutation rate than the rest of the genome, because of +their base composition [34]), the average deleterious allele frequency in the model of finite +population size is ~23-fold lower than that in the infinite population model (Fig 1). -labels of the Products. If Plaintiff had known that the Products were not compostable, Plaintiff +Because the human population size has not been constant and changes in the population +size can affect the frequencies of deleterious alleles in the population (e.g. [2,35]), we also simu- +lated the population dynamics of disease alleles under a plausible demographic model for -would not have purchased the Products and/or would not have paid the premium price for +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R +5 / 23 --1- + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +European populations based on Tennessen et al. [25]. The original model assumes a genome- +wide mutation rate of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation, when current, more direct estimates +are approximately two-fold smaller [18,34,36]. We therefore rescaled the demographic parame- +ters of the Tennessen et al. model, based on a mutation rate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] (see Methods). As- +suming a mutation rate of 1.5 x 10−8 per bp (as recently estimated for exons [34]), the mean +allele frequency of a lethal, recessive disease allele obtained from this model was 7.10 x 10−6, +~1.33-fold higher than expected for a constant population size model with Ne = 20,000 (Fig 1). +The mean frequency seen in simulations instead matches the expectation for a constant popula- +tion size of 35,651 individuals (see Methods and S2A Fig). Increasing the effective population +size in a constant size model is not enough to capture the dynamics of disease alleles appropri- +ately, however. For example, if simulation results obtained under the Tennessen et al. [25] +demographic model are compared to those for simulations of a constant population size of Ne = +35,651, the mean allele frequencies match, but the distributions of allele frequencies are signifi- +cantly different (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, p-value < 10−15; S2B and S2C Fig). These findings +thus confirm the importance of incorporating demographic history into models for under- +standing the population dynamics of disease alleles [5,37,38]. In what follows, we therefore +tested the fit of the more realistic demographic model [25] (and variants of it) to the observed +allele frequencies. + +Fig 1. Expected allele frequencies in a population, according to mutation-selection balance models. +The blue bar denotes the expected allele frequency under an infinite population size, the green bar the mean +under a finite constant population, and the red bar the mean under a plausible demographic model for +European populations; for this last case, the entire distribution across 100,000 simulations is shown in the +grey histogram. All models assume s = 1 and h = 0, i.e., fully recessive, lethal mutations. For the finite +constant population size model, we present the mean frequency for a population size of 20,000 (see S2A Fig +for other choices). Population allele frequencies (q) were transformed to log10(q), and those q = 0 were set to +10−7 for visual purposes, but indicated as “0” on the X-axis. The density of the distribution is plotted on a log- +scale on the Y-axis. The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation in all models. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g001 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +6 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Comparing empirical and expected distributions of disease allele +frequencies + +The mutation rate from wild-type allele to disease allele, u, is a critical parameter in predicting +the frequencies of a deleterious allele [4,39]. To model disease alleles, we considered four muta- +tion types separately, with the goal of capturing most of the fine-scale heterogeneity in muta- +tion rates [27,36,40,41]: transitions in methylated CpG sites (CpGti) and three less mutable +types, namely transversions in CpG sites (CpGtv) and transitions and transversions outside a +CpG site (nonCpGti and nonCpGtv, respectively). In order to control for the methylation sta- +tus of CpG sites, we excluded 12 CpGti that occurred in CpG islands, which tend not to be +methylated and thus are likely to have a lower mutation rate [36] (following Moorjani et al. +[42]). To allow for heterogeneity in mutation rates within each one of these four classes consid- +ered, we modeled the within-class variation in mutation rates according to a lognormal distri- +bution (see details in Methods and [27]). + +For each mutation type, we then compared the mean allele frequency obtained from simu- +lations to what is observed in ExAC, running 100,000 replicates. To this end, we matched sim- +ulations to the empirical data with regard to the number of individuals sampled and number +of mutations observed of each mutation type and focused the analysis on the largest sample of +the same common ancestry, namely Non-Finnish Europeans (n = 33,370) (Fig 2A). We found +significant differences between empirical and expected mean frequencies for nonCpGtv (30- +fold higher on average; two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4; see Methods for details) and nonCpGti +(15-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value < 1 x 10−4), but only marginally so for CpGtv +(5-fold higher on average, two-tailed p-value = 0.08). The mean frequency for CpGti is also +somewhat higher than expected, but insignificantly so (1.17-fold higher on average, two-tailed +p-value = 0.59). Intriguingly, the discrepancy between observed and expected frequencies +becomes smaller as the mutation rate increases (Fig 2B). + +Two additional factors that we have not included in our model should further decrease the +predicted frequencies of disease alleles. Given that frequencies in ExAC are already unexpect- +edly high, these factors would only exacerbate the discrepancy between observed and expected +frequencies of deleterious alleles. First, we have ignored the effects of compound heterozygos- +ity, the case in which combinations of two distinct pathogenic alleles in the same gene lead to +lethality. This phenomenon is known to be common [43], and indeed, in the 320 cases in +which we were able to obtain this information, 58.44% were initially identified in compound +heterozygotes. In the presence of compound heterozygosity, each deleterious mutation will be +selected against not only when present in two copies within the same individual, but also in +the presence of lethal mutations at other sites. Since the purging effect of selection against +compound heterozygotes was not modeled in simulations, we would predict the frequency of a +deleterious mutation to be even lower than shown (e.g., in Fig 2A). + +In order to model the effect of compound heterozygosity in our simulations, we re-ran our +simulations, but focusing on a gene rather than a single site and so considering the sum of fre- +quencies of all known recessive lethal alleles within a gene. In these simulations, we used the +same set-up as in the site level analysis, except for the mutation rate, U, which is now the sum +of the mutation rates uj at each site j that is known to cause a severe and early onset form of the +disease [8] (S2 Table; see Methods for details). This approach does not consider the contribu- +tion of other mutations in the genes that cause the mild and/or late onset forms of the disease, +and implicitly assumes that all combinations of known recessive lethal alleles of the same gene +have the same fitness effect as homozygotes. Comparing observed frequencies of disease alleles +for each gene to predictions generated by simulation, about a fourth of the 27 genes for which +we implemented the gene-level analysis (see Methods) differ from the expected distribution at + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +7 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +8 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +Fig 2. Comparison between expected and observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease mutations. (A) Shown +are the expected and observed mean sample frequencies of disease mutations for four different mutation types. The title of the panel +indicates the mutation type, followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type considered in this study, with the p-value for the +difference between observed and expected mean frequencies given below. Distributions in grey are the mean sample allele frequencies +across K mutations based on 100,000 simulations, and rely on a plausible demographic model for European populations [25] (see +Methods). Blue bars represent the observed mean frequencies of the four mutation types, estimated from 33,370 individuals of +European ancestry from ExAC. (B) Fold increase in the observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expected, as a function of the +mutation rate u (on a log-scale), for each of the four mutation classes. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g002 + +the 5% level, with a clear overall trend for observed frequencies to be above expectation (S4 +Table; Fig 3; Fisher’s combined probability test p-value = 6 x 10−8). + +This finding is even more surprising than it may seem, because we are far from knowing the +complete mutation target for each gene, i.e., all the sites at which mutations could cause the dis- +ease. If there are additional, undiscovered sites in the gene at which mutations are fatal when +carried in combination with a known recessive lethal mutation, the purging effect of purifying +selection on the known mutations will be under-estimated in our simulations, leading us to +over-estimate the expected frequencies of the known mutations in simulations. Therefore, our +predictions are, if anything, an over-estimate of the expected allele frequency, and the discrep- +ancy between predicted and the observed is likely even larger than what we found. + +The other factor that we did not consider in simulations but would reduce the expected +allele frequencies is a subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes, as has been documented in Dro- +sophila for example [44]. To evaluate potential fitness effects in heterozygotes when none had +been documented in humans, we considered the phenotypic consequences of orthologous +gene knockouts in mouse. We were able to retrieve information on phenotypes for both homo- +zygote and heterozygote mice for only eight out of the 32 genes, namely ASS1, CFTR, DHCR7, +NPC1, POLG, PRF1, SLC22A5, and SMPD1. For all eight, homozygote knockout mice pre- +sented similar phenotypes as affected humans, and heterozygotes showed a milder but + +Fig 3. Sample allele frequencies at the gene level. The expectation (grey) is based on 1000 simulations, assuming no fitness decrease in +heterozygotes, but allowing for compound heterozygosity (see Methods for details). The sum of allele frequencies of known recessive lethal +disease mutations in each gene (purple bars) was obtained from ExAC considering 33,370 European individuals. Genes are ordered according +to the two-tailed p-value (S4 Table; see Methods). Genes are bolded when they differ significantly from expectation (at the 5% level). Violin +plots show the distribution of the log10 combined allele frequency of all segregating alleles obtained from simulations and boxes represent the +fraction of simulations in which no deleterious allele was observed in the simulated sample at present time. + +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.g003 + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +9 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +detectable phenotype (S5 Table). The magnitude of the heterozygote effect of these mutations +in humans is unclear, but the finding with knockout mice makes it plausible that there exists a +very small fitness decrease in heterozygotes in humans as well, potentially not enough to have +been recognized in clinical investigations but enough to have a marked impact on the allele fre- +quencies of the disease mutations. Indeed, even if the fitness effect in heterozygotes were as +small as h = 1%, a 79% decrease in the mean allele frequency of the disease allele is expected +relative to the case with complete recessivity (h = 0) (S3 Fig). + +Discussion + +To investigate the population genetics of human disease, we focused on mutations that cause +Mendelian, recessive disorders that lead to early death or completely impaired reproduction. +We sought to understand to what extent the frequencies of these mutations fit the expectation +based on a simple balance between the input of mutations and the purging by purifying selec- +tion, as well as how other mechanisms might affect these frequencies. Many studies implicitly +or explicitly compare known disease allele frequencies to expectations from mutation-selection +balance [5,29–32]. In this study, we tested whether known recessive lethal disease alleles as a +class fit these expectations, and found that, under a sensible demographic model for European +population history with purifying selection only in homozygotes, the expectations fit the +observed disease allele frequencies poorly: the mean empirical frequencies of disease alleles are +substantially above expectation for all mutation types (although not significantly so for CpGti), +and the fold increase in observed mean allele frequency in relation to the expectation decreases +with increased mutation rate (Fig 2). Furthermore, including possible effects of compound he- +terozygosity and subtle fitness decrease in heterozygotes will only exacerbate the discrepancy. +In principle, higher than expected disease allele frequencies could be explained by at least +six (non-mutually exclusive) factors: (i) widespread errors in reporting the causal variants; (ii) +misspecification of the demographic model, (iii) misspecification of the mutation rate; (iv) +reproductive compensation; (v) overdominance of disease alleles; and (vi) low penetrance of +disease mutations. Because widespread mis-annotation of the causal variants in disease muta- +tion databases had previously been reported [23,45,46], we tried to minimize the effect of such +errors on our analyses by filtering out any case that lacked compelling evidence of association +with a recessive lethal disease, reducing our initial set of 769 mutations to 385 in which we had +greater confidence (see Methods for details). + +We also explored the effects of having misspecified recent demographic history or the +mutation rate. Based on very large samples, it has been estimated that population growth in +Europe was stronger than what we considered in our simulations [47,48]. When we considered +higher growth rates, such that the current effective population size is up to 10-fold larger than +that of the rescaled Tennessen model, we observed an increase in the expected frequency of +recessive disease alleles and a larger number of segregating sites (S4 Fig, columns A-E). How- +ever, the impact of larger growth rate is insufficient to explain the observed discrepancy: the +allele frequencies observed in ExAC are still on average an order of magnitude larger than +expected based on a model with a 10-fold larger current effective population size than the one +initially considered [25] (S4 Fig). In turn, population substructure within Europe would only +increase the number of homozygotes relative to what was modeled in our simulations (through +the Wahlund effect [49]) and expose more recessive alleles to selection, thus decreasing the +expected allele frequencies and exacerbating the discrepancy that we report. + +To explore the effects of error in the mutation rate, we considered a 50% higher mean + +mutation rate than what has been estimated for exons [34], beyond what seems plausible based +on current estimates on human mutation rates [42]. Except for the mean mutation rate (now + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +10 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +set to 2.25 x 10−8), all other parameters used for these simulations (i.e. the variance in mutation +rate across simulations, the demographic model [25], absence of selective effect in heterozy- +gotes, and selection coefficient) were kept the same as the ones used for generating S4 Fig, col- +umn A. The observed mean frequency remains significantly above what those predicted and +qualitative conclusions are unchanged (S4 Fig, column F). + +Another factor to consider is that for disease phenotypes that are lethal very early on in life, + +there may be partial or complete reproductive compensation (e.g. [50]). This phenomenon +would decrease the fitness effects of the recessive lethal mutations and could therefore lead to +an increase in the allele frequency in data relative to what we predict for a selection coefficient +of 1. There are no reasons, however, for this phenomenon to correlate with the mutation rate, +as seen in Fig 2B. + +The other two factors, overdominance and low penetrance, are likely explanations for a sub- +set of cases. For instance, CFTR, the gene in which some mutations lead to cystic fibrosis, is the +farthest above expectation (p-value < 0.004; Fig 3). It was long noted that there is an unusually +high frequency of the CFTR deletion ΔF508 in Europeans, which led to speculation that disease +alleles of this gene may be subject to over-dominance ([51,52], but see [53]). Regardless, it is +known that disease mutations in this gene can complement one another [10,11] and that modi- +fier loci in other genes also influence their penetrance [11,14]. Consistent with variable pene- +trance, Chen et al. [24] identified three purportedly healthy individuals carrying two copies of +disease mutations in this gene. Similarly, DHCR7, the gene associated with the Smith-Lemli- +Opitz syndrome, is somewhat above expectation in our analysis (p-value = 0.056; Fig 3) and +healthy individuals were found to be homozygous carriers of putatively lethal disease alleles in +other studies [24]. These observations make it plausible that, in a subset of cases (particularly +for CFTR), the high frequency of deleterious mutations associated with recessive, lethal diseases +are due to genetic interactions that modify the penetrance of certain recessive disease mutations. +It is hard to assess the importance of this phenomenon in driving the general pattern that we +observe, but two factors argue against it being a sufficient explanation for our findings at the +level of single sites. First, when we removed 130 mutations in CFTR and 12 in DHCR7, the two +genes that were outliers at the gene level (Fig 3; S4 Table) and for which there is evidence of +incomplete penetrance [24], the discrepancy between observed and expected allele frequencies +is barely impacted (S5 Fig). Moreover, there is no obvious reason why the degree of incomplete +penetrance would vary systematically with the mutation rate of a site, as observed (Fig 2B). + +Instead, it seems plausible that there is an ascertainment bias in disease allele discovery and +mutation identification [52,54,55]. Unlike missense or protein-truncating variants, Mendelian +disease mutations cannot be annotated based solely on DNA sequences, and their identifica- +tion requires reliable diagnosis of affected individuals (usually in more than one pedigree) fol- +lowed by mapping of the underlying gene/mutation. Therefore, those mutations that have +been identified to date are likely the ones that are segregating at higher frequencies in the pop- +ulation. Moreover, mutation-selection balance models predict that the frequency of a deleteri- +ous mutation should correlate with the mutation rate. Together, these considerations suggest +that disease variants of a highly mutable class, such as CpGti, are more likely to have been +mapped and that the mean frequency of mapped mutations will tend to be only slightly above +all disease mutations in that class. In contrast, less mutable disease mutations are less likely to +have been discovered to date, and the mean frequency of the subset of mutations that have +been identified may tend to be far above that of all mutations in that class. + +To quantify these effects, we modeled the ascertainment of disease mutations both analyti- + +cally and in simulations. A large proportion of recessive Mendelian disease mutations were +identified in inbred populations, likely because inbreeding leads to an excess of homozygotes +compared to expected under random mating, increasing the probability that a recessive + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 3 of 19 +11 / 23 -compostable plates. Defendant has thus breached its express warranty under the California + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -Commercial Code § 2313 and violated the Business and Profession Code § 17200 based on +mutation would be discovered as causing a disease. Therefore, we modeled ascertainment in +disease discovery in human populations with a plausible degree of inbreeding (see Methods). +As expected, we found that for a given mutation type, the probability of ascertainment in- +creases with the sample size of the putative disease ascertainment study (na) and the average +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study (Fa); in addition, the average allele fre- +quency of mutations that have been identified is always higher than that of all existing muta- +tions, and the discrepancy decreases as the ascertainment probability increases (Table 1). +Furthermore, comparison across different mutation types reveals that a higher mutation rate +increases the probability of disease mutations being ascertained (Table 1 and S6 Fig) and +decreases the magnitude of bias in the estimated allele frequency relative to the mutation class +as a whole (Table 1). In summary, among all the possible aforementioned explanations for the +observed discrepancy between empirical and expected mean allele frequencies, the ascertain- +ment bias hypothesis is the only one that also explains why it is more pronounced for less +mutable mutation types (Fig 2B). -fraudulent, unlawful and unfair acts and practices. +One implication of this hypothesis is that there are numerous sites at which mutations +cause recessive lethal diseases yet to be discovered, particularly at non-CpG sites. More gener- +ally, this ascertainment bias complicates the interpretation of observed allele frequencies in +terms of the selection pressures acting on disease alleles. Beyond this specific point, our study +illustrates how the large sample sizes now made available to researchers in the context of proj- +ects like ExAC [23] can be used not only for direct discovery of disease variants, but also to test +why disease alleles are segregating in the population and to understand at what frequencies we +might expect to find them in the future. -6. +Methods +Disease allele set -Plaintiff and the Class seek an order enjoining Defendant’s acts of unfair +In order to identify single nucleotide variants within the 42 genes associated with lethal, reces- +sive Mendelian diseases (S1 Table), we initially relied on the ClinVar dataset [56] (accessed on -competition and other unlawful conduct, an award of damages to compensate them for +Table 1. For a given set of parameters na (the sample size in a putative disease ascertainment study) and Fa (the average inbreeding coefficient of +the population in which the study is being performed), we report the probability of a recessive, lethal mutation being ascertained, as well as the +fold increase in mean allele frequencies of the ascertained cases (qa) in relation to the mean frequencies of all mutations for each mutation type +(qu), based on simulations (see Methods for details). For a similar result derived from analytical modeling, see S6 Fig. Parameters for this step of the sim- +ulation correspond to plausible scenarios for human populations with widespread inbreeding (e.g., Fa = 1/16 corresponds to offspring of first-cousin marriage). +The last column in the bottom panel shows the fold increase of the mean allele frequency observed in ExAC in relation to simulations based on the Tennessen +et al. [25] demographic model (see Methods). Mutation rates u per bp, per generation were obtained from a large human pedigree study [18]. -Defendant’s acts of unfair competition, false and misleading advertising, and breaches of +Parameter -warranty, and restitution to the individual victims of Defendant’s fraudulent, unlawful and unfair +na +Fa +Mutation type (u) -acts and practices. +CpGti (1.12e-7) -PARTIES +CpGtv (9.59e-9) -7. +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) -Plaintiff David Ambrose is a resident of Irvine, California. When given the +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) -choice, Plaintiff buys products that are compostable, recyclable or reusable so that he can +CpGti (1.12e-7) -minimize his impact on the environment. Plaintiff purchased the Products approximately twice a +CpGtv (9.59e-9) -month from 2017 until March 2020. Plaintiff purchased the Products at Ralphs stores in Orange, +nonCpGti (6.18e-9) -Irvine, and Tustin, California. Plaintiff purchased the Products to fill last-minute catering orders +nonCpGtv (3.76e-9) -and was not reimbursed for his purchases. Plaintiff specifically selected the Products in reliance +10,000 -on Defendant’s representations that the Products are compostable. The false representations are +1/16 -located on the labels and other marketing materials for the Products. Had Plaintiff known that the +0.0150 -Products contained PFAs chemicals, and thus could not break down in an industrial composting +0.0014 -facility, he would not have purchased the Products. Instead, he paid considerably more for the +0.0009 -Products than he would have for similar products that are not advertised as compostable. Plaintiff +0.0005 -would purchase the Products again if they were truly compostable. Given that PFAS are not an +27.6 -identifiable part of the Products, Plaintiff will be unable to determine the truthfulness of +284.1 -Defendant’s representations absent imposition of the injunctive relief prayed for in this complaint. +455.7 -8. +716.5 -Defendant The Kroger Co. is an Ohio corporation with its principal place of +10,000 -business in Columbus, Ohio. Defendant The Kroger Co. manufactures, distributes and sells the +1/8 -Products in California. +0.0247 -1 +0.0024 -2 - -3 +0.0015 -4 +0.0010 -5 +Simulation settings -6 +100,000 -7 +1/8 -8 +100,000 -9 +1/6 -10 +Probability of a mutation being ascertained -11 +0.0968 -12 +0.0104 -13 +0.0067 -14 +0.0044 -15 +0.1125 -16 +0.0124 -17 +0.0074 -18 +0.0050 -19 +500,000 -20 +1/8 -21 +0.1858 -22 +0.0235 -23 +0.0146 -24 +0.0091 -25 +Fold increase in allele frequency due to ascertainment bias -26 +22.3 -27 +222.6 -28 +335.6 -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R +577.4 --2- +9.0 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +81.2 - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 4 of 19 +126.1 -JURISDICTION AND VENUE +192.9 -9. +8.0 -This Court has jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant is a corporation or +70.2 -other entity that has sufficient minimum contacts in California, is a citizen of California, or +114.8 -otherwise intentionally avails itself of the California market either through the distribution, sale or +174.1 -marketing of the Products in the State of California or by having facilities located in California so +5.2 -as to render the exercise of jurisdiction over it by the California courts consistent with traditional +40.6 -notions of fair play and substantial justice. +64.7 -10. +103.6 - Venue is proper pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(a) because a substantial part of the +ExAC -events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred in this District. +- -11. +- -Intradistrict Assignment (L.R. 3-2(c) and (d) and 3.5(b)): This action arises in +- -Alameda County, in that a substantial part of the events which give rise to the claims asserted +- -herein occurred in Alameda County. Pursuant to L.R. 3-2(c), all civil actions which arise in +1.17 -Alameda County shall be assigned to the San Francisco or Oakland Division. +5.4 -BACKGROUND FACTS +15.2 -12. +30.0 -Due to the overwhelming amount of landfilled waste accumulating in the +https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915.t001 -environment, biodegradable and compostable foodware options have become increasingly +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -popular. As people look to invest in sustainable alternatives to single-use plastics and packaging, +12 / 23 -consumers, including the Plaintiff, actively seek out products that are compostable, recyclable, or + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -reusable, to prevent the increase in global waste and to minimize their environmental footprints. +June 3rd, 2015). We filtered out any variant that is an indel or a more complex copy number +variant or that is ever classified as benign or likely benign in ClinVar (whether or not it is also +classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic). By this approach, we obtained 769 SNVs +described as pathogenic or likely pathogenic. For each one of these variants, we searched the +literature for evidence that it is exclusively associated to the lethal and early onset form of the +disease and was never reported as causing the mild and/or late-onset form of the disease. We +considered effects in the absence of medical treatment, as we were interested in the selection +pressures acting on the alleles over evolutionary time scales rather than in the last one or two +generations, i.e., the period over which treatment became available for some of diseases con- +sidered. To evaluate the impact of treatment, we decreased s from 1 to 0 (i.e., we assumed a +complete absence of selective effects due to treatment) in the last three generations and com- +pared the mean allele frequencies across 100,000 simulations implemented with or without +this readjustment in selection coefficient. Because of the stochastic nature of the simulations, +we repeated this pairwise comparison 10 times in order to get a range of expected increase in +allele frequencies. We observed only a minor increase in the mean allele frequency (2.6% at +most) across the 10 replicates. This simulation procedure corresponds to a scenario in which +there is an extremely effective treatment for all diseases for the past three generations, which is +an overestimate of the effect and length of treatment for the disease set considered. -13. +Variants with mention of incomplete penetrance (i.e. for which homozygotes were not +always affected) or with known effects in heterozygote carriers were removed from the analy- +sis. This process yielded 417 SNVs in 32 genes associated with distinct Mendelian recessive +lethal disorders (S2 Table). Although these mutations were purportedly associated with +completely recessive diseases, we sought to examine whether there would be possible, unre- +ported effects in heterozygous carriers. To this end, we used the Mouse Genome Database +(MGD) [57] (accessed July 29th, 2015) and were able to retrieve information for both homozy- +gote and heterozygote mice for eight out of the 32 genes (all of which with a homologue in +mice) (S5 Table). -The California Business and Professions Code § 17580.5 makes it “unlawful for +In addition to the information provided by ClinVar for each one of these variants, we con- -any person to make any untruthful, deceptive, or misleading environmental marketing claim, +sidered the immediate sequence context of each SNV, to tailor the mutation rate estimate +accordingly [18]. To do so, we used an in-house Python script and the human genome refer- +ence sequence hg19 from UCSC (). -whether explicit or implied.” Pursuant to that section, the term “environmental marketing claim” +Genetic datasets +The Exome Aggregation Consortium (ExAC) [23] was accessed on August 9th, 2016. The data +consist of genotype frequencies for 60,706 individuals, assigned after Principal Component +Analysis to one of seven population labels: African (n = 5,203), East Asian (n = 4,327), Finnish +(n = 3,307), Latino (n = 5,789), Non-Finnish European (n = 33,370), South Asian (n = 8,256) +and “other” (n = 454) [23]. We focused our analyses on those individuals of Non-Finnish +European descent, because they constitute the largest sample size from a single ancestry group. +We note that, some diseases mutations, for instance, those in ASPA, HEXA and SMPD1, are +known to be especially prevalent in Ashkenazi Jewish populations, which could potentially +bias our results if Ashkenazi Jewish individuals constituted a great portion of the sample we +considered. However, this sample includes only ~2,000 (~6%) Ashkenazi individuals (Dr. +Daniel MacArthur, personal communication). -includes any claim contained in the Guides for use of Environmental Marketing Claims published +From the initial 417 mutations, we filtered out three that were homozygous in at least one -by the Federal Trade Commission (the “Green Guides”). Ibid; see also 16 C.F.R. § 260.1, et seq. +individual in ExAC and 29 that had lower coverage, i.e., fewer than 80% of the individuals +were sequenced to at least 15x. This approach left us with a set of 385 mutations with a -Under the Green Guides, “[i]t is deceptive to misrepresent, directly or by implication, that a +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -product or package is compostable.” 16 C.F.R. § 260.7(a). “A marketer claiming that an item is +13 / 23 -compostable should have competent and reliable scientific evidence that all the materials in the - -1 + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations +minimum coverage of 27x per sample and an average coverage of 69x per sample (S2 Table). +For 248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies, ExAC reported the number of non-Finnish +European individuals that were sequenced, which was on average 32,881 individuals [23]. For +the remaining 137 sites, we did not have this information. Nonetheless, the coverage across all +samples is reported and does not differ significantly between the two sets of sites (by a Kolmo- +gorov-Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90; S7 Fig). We therefore assumed that mean number of indi- +viduals covered for all sites was 32,881 and used this number to obtain sample frequencies +from simulations, as explained below. + +A second genetic dataset was obtained from Counsyl (). +Counsyl is a commercial genetic screening laboratory that offers, among other products, the +“Family Prep Screen”, a genetic screening test intended to detect carrier status for up to 110 +recessive Mendelian diseases in couples that are planning to have a child [20]. A subset of +294,000 of its customers was surveyed by genotyping or sequencing for “routine carrier screen- +ing”. This subset excludes individuals with indications for testing because of known personal +or family history of Mendelian diseases, infertility, and consanguinity. It therefore represents a +more random (with regard to the presence of disease alleles), population-based survey. For +these individuals, we had details on self-reported ancestry (14 distinct ethnic/ancestry/geo- +graphic groups) and the allele frequencies for 98 mutations that match those that passed our +variant selection criteria described above, of which 91 are also sequenced to high coverage in +the ExAC database (S2 Table). We focused our analysis of this dataset on the 76,314 individu- +als of self-reported Northern or Southern European ancestry. + +Simulating the evolution of disease alleles with population size change + +We modeled the frequency of a deleterious allele in human populations by forward simula- +tions based on a crude but plausible demographic model for human populations from Africa +and Europe, inferred from exome data for African-Americans and European-Americans [25]. +To this end, we used a program described in [1]. In brief, the demographic scenario consists of +an Out-of-Africa demographic model, with changes in population size throughout the popula- +tion history, including a severe bottleneck in Europeans following the split from the African +population and a rapid, recent population growth in both populations [25]. As in Simons et al. +[1], we simulated genetic drift and two-way gene flow between Africans and Europeans in +recent history. + +The original demographic model was inferred using a mutation rate u of 2.36 x 10−8 per bp + +per generation [25,58]. More recent estimates, based on direct resequencing of human pedi- +grees, instead point to mutation rates about 50% smaller than that [18,34,36]. To incorporate +what is believed to be a more accurate mutation rate estimate, we rescaled all demographic and +time parameters in the original Tennessen et al. [25] model by a factor of 1.97, based on the +difference between the mutation rate considered in the original study and that of Kong et al. +[18] (which is similar to that found in other studies [48]). We refer to this model as the rescaled +Tennessen model and rely on it throughout. + +Negative selection acting on a single bi-allelic site was modeled as in the analytic models. +Allele frequencies follow a Wright-Fisher sampling scheme in each generation according to +these viabilities, with migration rate and population sizes varying according to the demo- +graphic scenario considered. Whenever a demographic event (e.g., growth) altered the number +of individuals and the resulting number was not an integer, we rounded it to the nearest inte- +ger, as in Simons et al. [1]. A burn-in period of 10Ne generations with constant population size +Ne = 14,328 individuals was implemented in order to ensure an equilibrium distribution of +segregating alleles at the onset of demographic changes in Africa, 11,643 generations ago. + +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +14 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +In contrast to Simons et al. [1], our simulations always start with the ancestral allele A fixed + +and mutation occurs exclusively from this allele to the deleterious one (a), i.e., a mutation +occurs with mean probability u per gamete, per generation, and there is no back-mutation. +However, recurrent mutations at a site are allowed, as in Simons et al. [1]. + +When implementing the simulations, we considered a mean mutation rate u of 1.5x10-8 per +bp, per generation, as has been estimated for exons [34], as well as mutation rates for four dis- +tinct mutation types (CpGti = 1.12 x 10−7; CpGtv = 9.59 x 10−9; nonCpGti = 6.18 x 10−9; and +nonCpGtv = 3.76 x 10−9) estimated from a large human pedigree study [18]. While these four +categories capture much of the variation in germline mutation rates across sites, a number of +other factors (e.g., the larger sequence context or the replication timing) also influence muta- +tion rates, introducing heterogeneity in the mutation rate within each class considered +[27,36,40,59]. To allow for this heterogeneity as well as for uncertainty in the point mutation +rates estimates, in each simulation, when compared to human exome data (Figs 1, 2, S4 and +S5), instead of using a fixed rate u, we drew the mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution +with the following parameters: + +log10Mju (cid:24) Nðlog10u (cid:0) + +s2 2 -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 +lnð10Þ; s2Þ -9 +ð8Þ -10 +such that that E[M] = u. σ was set to 0.57 (following [27]). +For each mutation type, we then proceeded as follows: -11 +1. We ran two million simulations, thus obtaining the distribution of deleterious allele fre- -12 +quencies expected for the European population. -13 +2. We sampled K allele frequencies from the two million simulations implemented for each -14 +mutation type, where K is the number of identified mutations of that type. Sample allele fre- +quencies were simulated from these population frequencies by Poisson sampling, so to +match ExAC’s number of chromosomes. -15 +3. We repeated step (2) 100,000 times, thus obtaining a distribution for the mean allele fre- -16 +quency across K mutations. -17 +To assess the significance of the deviation between observed and expected mean, we -18 +obtained a two-tailed p-value, defined as 2 x (r+1)/(100000+1), where r is the number of simu- +lated allele frequencies that were greater or equal to that of the empirical mean [60], for each +mutation type separately. -19 +A well-known source of heterogeneity in mutation rate within the CpGti class is methyla- +tion status, with a high transition rate seen only at methylated CpGs [21]. In our analyses, we +tried to control for the methylation status of CpG sites by excluding sites located in CpG +islands (CGIs), which tend to not be methylated [42]. The CGI annotation for hg19 was +obtained from UCSC Genome Browser (track “Unmasked CpG”; , accessed in June 6th, +2016). BEDTools [61] was used to exclude those CpG sites located in CGIs. We note that the +CpGti estimate from [18] includes CGIs, and in that sense the average mutation rate that we +are using for CpGti may be a very slight underestimate of the mean rate for transitions at +methylated CpG sites. -20 +Unless otherwise noted, the expectation assumes fully recessive, lethal alleles with complete +penetrance. Notably, by calculating the expected frequency one site at a time, we are ignoring +possible interaction between genes (i.e., effects of the genetic background) and among differ- +ent mutations within a gene (i.e., compound heterozygotes). These assumptions are relaxed in +two ways. In one analysis (S3 Fig), we considered a very low selective effect in heterozygous -21 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -22 +15 / 23 -23 + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -24 +individuals (h = 1%), reasoning that such an effect could plausibly go undetected in medical +examinations and yet would nonetheless impact the frequency of the disease allele. Second, +when considering the gene-level analysis (Fig 3), we implicitly allowed for compound hetero- +zygosity between any pair of known lethal mutations [8]. For this analysis, we ran 1000 simula- +tions for a total mutation rate U per gene that was calculated accounting for the heterogeneity +and uncertainty in the mutation rates estimates as follows: (i) For j sites in a gene known to +cause a recessive lethal disease and that passed our filtering criteria (S2 Table), we drew a +mutation rate uj from the lognormal distribution, as described above; (ii) We then took the +sum of uj as the total mutation rate U; (iii) We then ran one replicate with U as the mutation +parameter, and other parameters as specified for site level analysis. Because the mutational tar- +get size considered in simulations is only comprised of those sites at which mutations are +known to cause a lethal recessive disease, it is almost certainly an underestimate of the true +mutation rate—potentially by a lot. We note further that by this approach, we are assuming +that compound heterozygotes formed by any two lethal alleles have fitness zero, i.e., that they +are identical in their effects to homozygotes for any of the lethal alleles. Moreover, we are +implicitly ignoring the possibility of complementation, which is (somewhat) justified by our +focus on mutations with severe effects and complete penetrance (but see Discussion). Since we +were interested in understanding the effect of compound heterozygosity, for this analysis, we +did not consider the five genes in which only one mutation passed our filters (BCS1L, FKTN, +LAMA3, PLA3G6, and TCIRG1). -25 +Modeling the effect of the ascertainment bias in disease discovery -26 +To calculate the probability of ascertaining a recessive, lethal mutation, we assumed that all +currently known disease mutations were identified in a putative ascertainment study of sample +size na in a population with an inbreeding coefficient of Fa. Under this model, we can estimate +Pasc, the probability of ascertaining a disease mutation, as following: -27 +For a disease allele (denoted as a) at frequency q in the present population, if we randomly +sample an individual with inbreeding coefficient of Fa, the probabilities of the three genotypes +are: -28 +PðAAÞ ¼ Fað1 (cid:0) qÞ þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞð1 (cid:0) qÞ2; -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R +PðAaÞ ¼ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞ2qð1 (cid:0) qÞ; --3- +PðaaÞ ¼ Faq þ ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2: -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +ð9Þ - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 5 of 19 +ð10Þ -1 +ð11Þ -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 +Thus, if na unrelated individual are surveyed, the probability of not seeing any homozygote +for the disease allele (which is the same as the probability of not being ascertained in this set) is: -6 +Therefore, the probability of ascertainment is -7 +Pnasc ¼ ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna: -8 +Pasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) Pnasc ¼ 1 (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) PðaaÞÞna +½1 (cid:0) Faq (cid:0) ð1 (cid:0) FaÞq2(cid:138)na +½ð1 (cid:0) qÞð1 þ q (cid:0) FaqÞ(cid:138)na; -9 +¼ 1 (cid:0) -10 +¼ 1 (cid:0) -11 +ð12Þ -12 +ð13Þ -13 +which is an increasing function with regard to q (the population allele frequency), Fa (the +inbreeding coefficient of the population under study) as well as na (the sample size of the puta- +tive ascertainment study) (S6 Fig). -14 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -15 +16 / 23 -16 + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -17 +We also demonstrate the relationship between the probability of ascertainment and muta- +tion rate using simulations of ascertainment bias implemented according to the following steps: -18 +1. For each of the four mutation types considered, we generated 106 allele frequencies q from + +the results of the simulations based on a realistic demographic model [25]. + +2. We generated na independent diploid genotypes, given the allele frequencies from step 1 + +and an inbreeding coefficient Fa. We ran this step for a range of na and Fa values (Table 1). +3. With a given combination of na and Fa values, we identified the cases (out of the 106 obser- +vations from step 1) where at least one homozygote individual was observed in step 2. +These cases correspond to disease mutations that were ascertained; the reasoning being that +given complete penetrance, a recessive disease mutation can only be identified if there is at +least one affected individual in the studied population. With this step, we calculated the +probability of ascertainment by taking the fraction of cases that satisfy the criteria above. -19 +4. Finally, for each one of the 106 simulations from step 1, we generated a sample allele fre- -20 +quency of the disease mutation, matching ExAC’s sample size (i.e., considering 2n = 65,762 +chromosomes). We can then compare qu, the unbiased average allele frequency of all dis- +ease mutations, to qa, the mean frequency of the subset of cases ascertained in step 3, i.e., +those cases for which at least one homozygote individual is observed. -21 +These simulations were meant to illustrate the likely impact of ascertainment bias, rather -22 +than to precisely describe the disease mutation identification process or to quantify the ex- +pected effect. Notably, we performed these simulations for single sites, so the criteria for ascer- +tainment in step 3 did not include the possibility of compound heterozygotes, despite the fact +that an estimated 58.4% of the disease mutations included in our study were initially identified +in compound heterozygotes. However, this simulation framework could readily be extended +in this direction and it would not change our qualitative conclusion. + +Supporting information -23 +S1 Table. List of lethal, recessive Mendelian diseases considered in this study. +(DOCX) -24 +S2 Table. Information on 417 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases. +(XLSX) -25 +S3 Table. Information on 91 mutations associated with the severe form of lethal, recessive +Mendelian diseases in Counsyl and ExAC databases. +(XLSX) -26 +S4 Table. P-values for each gene estimated by simulation, under a model of mutation- +selection balance with a plausible demographic history. +(DOCX) -27 +S5 Table. Phenotypic effect of mouse knock-outs (see main text). +(DOCX) -28 +S1 Fig. Comparison of the empirical allele frequencies of recessive, lethal disease muta- +tions in individuals of European ancestry from two large exome studies. Shown are the +allele frequencies for 91 variants associated with lethal, recessive diseases, as estimated from +33,370 individuals of non-Finnish, European ancestry in the Exome Aggregation Consortium +(ExAC) database [23] and 76,314 European-ancestry individuals from a genetic testing -item will break down into, or otherwise become part of, usable compost…in a safe and timely +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 + +17 / 23 + + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations + +laboratory (Counsyl [20]) (see Methods). Points lie on the dashed blue line if the allele frequen- +cies in Counsyl and ExAC are the same. +(TIF) + +S2 Fig. Comparisons of mutation-selection balance models with constant versus changing +population sizes. (A) Population mean allele frequency as a function of effective population +size, under a model of constant population size. The X-axis range corresponds to the range of +effective population size over time estimated in [25]. The red bar indicates the value of a con- +stant population size at which the mean allele frequency is the same as in simulations, for an +average mutation rate of 1.5 x10-8 per bp per generation [34]. (B-C) The allele frequency distri- +bution (in grey) is presented for 2 x 106 simulations based on (B) the complex demographic +scenario inferred by Tennessen et al. [25] for the evolution of European populations based on +simulations (see Methods) and of (C) the finite, constant size population model, with N set to +35,651 individuals to match the mean allele frequency with (B). Both models assume complete +lethality (s = 1) and recessivity (h = 0). +(TIF) + +S3 Fig. The impact on disease allele frequencies of a small fitness effect in heterozygotes +(h = 0.01). Shown in each case is the distribution of the deleterious allele frequencies in the +population, generated from 100,000 simulations. Means are represented by red vertical bars. +For visualization, an allele frequency of q = 0 is set to 0.5 x 10−6. When a small fitness effect in +heterozygotes is considered in the simulations, the mean allele frequency decreases by 79% rel- +ative to no effect. The two distributions differ significantly by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (p- +value < 10−15). The mutation rate u was set to 1.5 x 10−8 per bp per generation, reflective of the +mean mutation rate for exons [34]. +(TIF) + +S4 Fig. Effect of varying the end population size and the average mutation rate on the sam- +ple allele frequency of recessive, lethal mutations. Tennessen et al. [25] inferred the present +effective population size of Europeans to be 512,000 individuals based on a mutation rate of +2.36 x 10−8 per bp per generation. We rescaled the parameters of this model based on a lower +mutation rate estimate of 1.2 x 10−8 [18] and show the expected distribution of sample allele +frequencies of recessive, lethal mutations in column A. We further considered the effect of +larger population sizes at present (2-, 4-, and 10-fold increase, denoted by columns B, C and +D respectively), keeping other rescaled demographic parameters the same as in A. We also +included a model (E) where rapid growth begins immediately after the out-of-Africa bottle- +neck, representing a more extreme scenario of population growth in comparison to the two- +stage and more gradual scenario proposed by Tennessen et al. (2012). For A-E, we drew the +mutation rate M from a lognormal distribution with parameters set as in Eq 8, with u = 1.5 x +10−8 (as implemented for Fig 2; see Methods). Model F considers a larger u (2.25 x 10−8, i.e., a +1.5-fold increase from A-E), with all other parameters (e.g., variance in mutation rates across +simulations, the demographic model) the same as in column A. The observed sample allele fre- +quency distribution of 385 disease mutations in ExAC is shown in white. Violin plots show the +density distribution of the log10 allele frequencies for variants that were segregating in these +samples, whereas boxes indicate the proportion of sites for which the deleterious mutation was +not observed segregating in the sample. All distributions differ significantly from one another +(i.e., all p-values are < 10−15 by a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test). +(TIF) -manner…in an appropriate composting facility…” 16 C.F.R. § 260.7(b). +S5 Fig. Expected distribution and the observed mean allele frequencies of recessive, lethal +disease mutations (excluding mutations in CFTR and DHCR7). As in Fig 2, the four panels -14. +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -The Green Guides’ definition of “compostable” is consistent with reasonable +18 / 23 -consumer expectations. For instance, the dictionary defines the verb “compost” as: to convert (a + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -material such as plant debris) to compost. The dictionary defines the noun “compost” as a +correspond to four different mutation types. The title of the panel indicates the mutation type, +followed by K, the total number of mutations of that type, with p-values for the difference +between observed and expected mean frequencies below. Distributions in grey are for 100,000 +observations of the expected mean sample allele frequencies across K mutations, and were +obtained from simulations based on a plausible demographic model for European populations +[25] (see Methods). Blue bars represent the observed values estimated from 33,370 individuals +of European ancestry from ExAC. As opposed to in Fig 2, here, we did not include mutations +present in two genes (CFTR and DHCR7) that were outliers in the gene-level analysis (Fig 3) +and were reported elsewhere to be carried by healthy homozygous individuals [24]. +(TIF) -mixture that consists largely of decayed organic matter and is used for fertilizing and conditioning +S6 Fig. The probability Pasc of a mutation being ascertained, given its population allele fre- +quency q, the sample size na of the putative ascertainment study and the inbreeding coeffi- +cient Fa in the population in which the ascertainment study was conducted. In each case, +we let only one parameter (q, na or Fa) vary, while fixing the others at q = 7.10 x 10−6 (corre- +sponding to the mean allele frequency from simulations), na = 10,000, and Fa = 1/16 (corre- +sponding to marriage between first cousins, a plausible scenario for a population with +widespread inbreeding). +(TIF) -the land.” Merriam-Webster Dictionary (2020).1 Accordingly, reasonable consumers expect that +S7 Fig. Depth of coverage for 385 mutations in ExAC known to cause lethal, Mendelian +diseases. Box plots show the mean (black bar) and the lower and upper quartiles for (A) the +248 sites with non-zero sample frequencies in ExAC, for which the number of sequenced non- +Finnish European individuals was reported (n = 32,881) and (B) the 137 sites for which we did +not have this information. Since distributions of depth of coverage are similar between the two +sets (by a Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, p-value = 0.90), we assumed that 32,881 individuals were +sequenced at all sites, and used this number to subsample simulations to match the sample size +of the ExAC data. +(TIF) -products advertised, marketed, sold, labeled, and/or represented as compostable will be converted +Acknowledgments -into usable organic matter that decomposes into fertilizer to condition the land, and that such +We thank Daniel MacArthur for his help with the ExAC data, Ellen Leffler for providing her +Python script (available at https://github.com/cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease), as well as +members of the Pickrell, Przeworski and Sella labs, Aravinda Chakravarti, Brian Charlesworth, +Damien Labuda and four anonymous reviewers for helpful discussions and comments on an +earlier version of the manuscript. All codes and data to generate the figures in R [62] and the +script used to get the sequence context of each mutation are available at https://github.com/ +cegamorim/PopGenHumDisease. The code to run the simulations is available at https:// +github.com/sellalab/ForwardSimulator. Allele frequencies and other information for the dis- +ease mutations employed in the analyses are in S2 and S3 Tables. -products will not introduce toxic chemicals into the fertilizer or land. +Author Contributions -15. +Conceptualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly -The Green Guides specifically prohibit marketers from labeling products +Przeworski. -compostable if those products release toxins into the compost as they break down, noting that “a +Data curation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Zachary Baker, Jose´ Francisco Diesel, Imran S. -claim is deceptive if the presence of…toxins prevents the compost from being usable.” 16 C.F.R. +Haque, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -§ 260.7(d), Example 2. +Formal analysis: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao. -16. +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -Defendant advertises, markets and sells its Products as compostable, yet the +19 / 23 -Products contain PFAS, highly persistent synthetic fluorinated chemicals which have been + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -associated with cancer, developmental toxicity, immunotoxicity and other health effects.2 +Funding acquisition: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -17. +Investigation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -PFAS’ characteristic carbon-fluorine bonds make them extremely resistant to +Methodology: Ziyue Gao, Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -degradation, even at high temperatures. And, the most commonly used PFAS have been detected +Project administration: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -globally in water, soil, sediment, wildlife, and human blood samples.3 The strength of the bond +Resources: Imran S. Haque, Molly Przeworski. -between carbon and fluorine means that these chemicals do not degrade in the environment. In +Software: Yuval B. Simons. -fact, according to the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, scientists are unable to +Supervision: Joseph Pickrell, Molly Przeworski. -1 Merriam-Webster Dictionary (2020); accessible at: https://www.merriam- -webster.com/dictionary/compost; last accessed on: May 16, 2020. -2 Schaider, L., et al., “Fluorinated Compounds in U.S. Fast Food Packaging” Environ Sci Technol -Lett. 2017 ; 4(3): 105–111. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.6b00435, (August 22, 2018), accessible at: -https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6104644/pdf/nihms983267.pdf, last accessed on -May 13, 2020. -3 Id. at p. 2. +Validation: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R +Visualization: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim. --4- +Writing – original draft: Carlos Eduardo G. Amorim, Ziyue Gao, Molly Przeworski. -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +Writing – review & editing: Yuval B. Simons, Imran S. Haque, Joseph Pickrell. - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 6 of 19 +References +1. Simons YB, Turchin MC, Pritchard JK, Sella G (2014) The deleterious mutation load is insensitive to +recent population history. Nat Genet 46: 220–224. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.2896 PMID: 24509481 -1 +2. Simons YB, Sella G (2016) The impact of recent population history on the deleterious mutation load in +humans and close evolutionary relatives. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 150–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. +gde.2016.09.006 PMID: 27744216 -2 - -3 +3. Nei M (1968) The frequency distribution of lethal chromosomes in finite populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci -4 +U S A 60: 517–524. PMID: 5248809 -5 +4. Gillespie JH (2004) Population Genetics: A Concise Guide. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University -6 +Press. -7 +5. Brandvain Y, Wright SI (2016) The Limits of Natural Selection in a Nonequilibrium World. Trends Genet -8 +32: 201–210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tig.2016.01.004 PMID: 26874998 -9 +6. Balick DJ, Do R, Cassa CA, Reich D, Sunyaev SR (2015) Dominance of Deleterious Alleles Controls -10 +the Response to a Population Bottleneck. PLoS Genet 11: e1005436. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1005436 PMID: 26317225 -11 +7. Beauchamp KA, Muzzey D, Wong KK, Hogan GJ, Karimi K, et al. (2017) Systematic Design and Com- -12 +parison of Expanded Carrier Screening Panels. Genet Med—ePub ahead of print -13 +8. Clark AG (1998) Mutation-selection balance with multiple alleles. Genetica 102–103: 41–47. PMID: -14 +9720270 -15 +9. Crow JF, Kimura M (1970) Introduction to Population Genetics Theory New York: Harper & Row Pub- -16 +lishers. 591 p. -17 +10. Cormet-Boyaka E, Jablonsky M, Naren AP, Jackson PL, Muccio DD, et al. (2004) Rescuing cystic fibro- +sis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)-processing mutants by transcomplementation. Proc +Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 8221–8226. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0400459101 PMID: 15141088 -18 +11. Rapino D, Sabirzhanova I, Lopes-Pacheco M, Grover R, Guggino WB, et al. (2015) Rescue of NBD2 -19 +mutants N1303K and S1235R of CFTR by small-molecule correctors and transcomplementation. PLoS +One 10: e0119796. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0119796 PMID: 25799511 -20 +12. Andressoo JO, Jans J, de Wit J, Coin F, Hoogstraten D, et al. (2006) Rescue of progeria in trichothiody- +strophy by homozygous lethal Xpd alleles. PLoS Biol 4: e322. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio. +0040322 PMID: 17020410 -21 +13. Gallati S (2014) Disease-modifying genes and monogenic disorders: experience in cystic fibrosis. Appl -22 +Clin Genet 7: 133–146. https://doi.org/10.2147/TACG.S18675 PMID: 25053892 -23 +14. Corvol H, Blackman SM, Boelle PY, Gallins PJ, Pace RG, et al. (2015) Genome-wide association meta- +analysis identifies five modifier loci of lung disease severity in cystic fibrosis. Nat Commun 6: 8382. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms9382 PMID: 26417704 -24 +15. Habara A, Steinberg MH (2016) Minireview: Genetic basis of heterogeneity and severity in sickle cell -25 +disease. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 241: 689–696. -26 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -27 +20 / 23 -28 + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -estimate an environmental half-life for PFAS.4 Due to the highly persistent nature of these +16. Hedrick PW (2011) Population genetics of malaria resistance in humans. Heredity (Edinb) 107: 283– -chemicals they break down very slowly, if at all, in the environment and in human bodies.5 +304. https://doi.org/10.1038/hdy.2011.16 PMID: 21427751 -18. +17. Chong JX, Buckingham KJ, Jhangiani SN, Boehm C, Sobreira N, et al. (2015) The Genetic Basis of -Because PFAS do not break down, they accumulate in air, soil, water and in the +Mendelian Phenotypes: Discoveries, Challenges, and Opportunities. Am J Hum Genet 97: 199–215. +https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.06.009 PMID: 26166479 -human body. One report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Health and +18. Kong A, Frigge ML, Masson G, Besenbacher S, Sulem P, et al. (2012) Rate of de novo mutations and -Nutrition Examination Survey found PFAS in the blood of 97 percent of Americans.6 +the importance of father’s age to disease risk. Nature 488: 471–475. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11396 PMID: 22914163 19. -PFAS were created to be resistant to grease, oil, water, and heat, for use in non- - -stick cookware.7 Due to the grease and water-resistant properties of fluorinated compounds, - -PFAS are often added to paper plates, bowls, food storage and packaging products (together, +Turner TN, Douville C, Kim D, Stenson PD, Cooper DN, et al. (2015) Proteins linked to autosomal domi- +nant and autosomal recessive disorders harbor characteristic rare missense mutation distribution pat- +terns. Hum Mol Genet 24: 5995–6002. https://doi.org/10.1093/hmg/ddv309 PMID: 26246501 -“foodware”). This leads to increased PFAS exposure in humans and in the environment. For +20. Haque IS, Lazarin GA, Kang H, Evans EA, Goldberg JD, et al. (2016) Modeled fetal risk of genetic dis- -products sold as compostable containing PFAS, there is the added concern that PFAS will seep +eases identified by expanded carrier screening. JAMA 316: 734–742. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama. +2016.11139 PMID: 27533158 -into the ground and soil, contaminating otherwise-usable compost streams. According to experts, +21. Cooper DN, Youssoufian H (1988) The CpG dinucleotide and human genetic disease. Hum Genet 78: -fluorinated food contact materials are a source of PFAS in the environment, and because of their +151–155. PMID: 3338800 -environmental persistence “PFASs should be considered incompatible with compostable food +22. Akalin N, Zietkiewicz E, Makalowski W, Labuda D (1994) Are CpG sites mutation hot spots in the dystro- -packaging.”8 - -20. - -A recent study of sixteen replacement fluorinated compounds used in foodware, - -conducted by the Center for Environmental Health, showed that some PFAS can act like the - -hormone estrogen, while others cause liver damage in animal studies.9 These fluorinated - -4 National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, accessible at: -https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/agents/pfc/index.cfm, last accessed on May 5, 2020. -5 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “PFOA, PFOS and Other PFASs”, accessible at: -https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic-information-pfas, last accessed on May 5, 20202. See also -Center for Environmental Health, “Avoiding Hidden Hazards” January 2018 (revised April -2018), at p. 3. -6 National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, accessible at: -https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/agents/pfc/index.cfm, last accessed on May 5, 2020. -7 U.S. Food & Drug Administration “Per and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)”, accessible at: -https://www.fda.gov/food/chemicals/and-polyfluoroalkyl-substances-pfas, last accessed on May -5, 2020. -8 Schaider, L., et al., “Fluorinated Compounds in U.S. Fast Food Packaging” Environ Sci Technol -Lett. 2017 ; 4(3): 105–111. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.6b00435, (August 22, 2018), accessible at: -https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6104644/pdf/nihms983267.pdf, last accessed on -May 13, 2020 at p. 8. -9 Center for Environmental Health, “Avoiding Hidden Hazards” January 2018 (revised April -2018) at p. 7. - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --5- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 7 of 19 - -compounds can move from foodware into water and other liquids.10 Foodware containing PFAS - -can also contaminate food items. Worse yet, for contaminated foodware products that are - -compostable, PFAS can leach from the product into the compost stream, contaminating the - -compost itself and organic matter grown using that composted material. - -21. - -There is evidence that exposure to PFAS can lead to a number of adverse health - -effects, including, but not limited to reproductive and developmental, liver and kidney and - -immunological effects in laboratory animals.11 The most consistent findings from human - -epidemiology studies are related to infant birth weights, effects on the immune system, cancer - -and thyroid hormone disruption.12 - -22. - -Over the past two decades, PFAS have come under increasing scrutiny from - -toxicologists, ecologists and regulators given their persistence and connection to serious potential - -health effects.13 +phin gene? Hum Mol Genet 3. 23. -Humans are exposed to PFAS by consuming PFAS-contaminated water and food - -as well as through the use of products that contain PFAS. +Lek M, Karczewski KJ, Minikel EV, Samocha KE, Banks E, et al. (2016) Analysis of protein-coding +genetic variation in 60,706 humans. Nature 536: 285–291. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature19057 PMID: +27535533 -24. +24. Chen R, Shi L, Hakenberg J, Naughton B, Sklar P, et al. (2016) Analysis of 589,306 genomes identifies -The claims made by Defendant that the Products are compostable are uniform, - -consistent, and material. Because the claims are false and misleading, ordinary consumers, - -including members of the Class, are likely to be deceived by such representations. +individuals resilient to severe Mendelian childhood diseases. Nat Biotechnol 34: 531–538. https://doi. +org/10.1038/nbt.3514 PMID: 27065010 25. -By encouraging consumers to place the Products in their compost collection bins, - -Defendant is contaminating entire compost streams with toxic materials that will not break down - -over time—contaminating otherwise-usable and sustainable compost streams. These Products are - -then mixed with other composted materials in an industrial composting facility and turned into - -soil fertilizer for crops and other foods. However, the PFAS will remain, thus contaminating the - -crops grown in that soil. Environmentally motivated consumers who purchase the Products in the - -belief that they are compostable are thus unwittingly hindering sustainable composting efforts. - -10 Id. -11 Id. -12 Id. -13 Id. at p. 3. - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --6- +Tennessen JA, Bigham AW, O’Connor TD, Fu W, Kenny EE, et al. (2012) Evolution and functional +impact of rare coding variation from deep sequencing of human exomes. Science 337: 64–69. https:// +doi.org/10.1126/science.1219240 PMID: 22604720 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +26. Wright S (1937) The Distribution of Gene Frequencies in Populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 23: - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 8 of 19 +307–320. PMID: 16577780 -26. +27. Harpak A, Bhaskar A, Pritchard JK (2016) Mutation Rate Variation is a Primary Determinant of the Dis- +tribution of Allele Frequencies in Humans. PLoS Genet 12: e1006489. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. +pgen.1006489 PMID: 27977673 -The Green Guides are clear: “[a] marketer claiming that an item is compostable +28. Browning Sharon R, Browning Brian L (2015) Accurate Non-parametric Estimation of Recent Effective +Population Size from Segments of Identity by Descent. The American Journal of Human Genetics 97: +404–418. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.07.012 PMID: 26299365 -should have competent and reliable scientific evidence that all the materials in the item will break +29. Reich DE, Lander ES (2001) On the allelic spectrum of human disease. Trends Genet 17: 502–510. -down into, or otherwise become part of, usable compost (e.g., soil-conditioning material, mulch) +PMID: 11525833 -in a safe and timely manner (i.e., in approximately the same time as the materials with which it is +30. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- -composted) in an appropriate composting facility, or in a home compost pile or device.” 16 - -C.F.R. § 260.7(b). Here, the Products are not compostable because they are made with PFAS, - -which cannot break down over time. Defendant’s marketing of the Products as compostable is - -thus a direct violation of the Green Guides. Because the Products are not compostable, - -Defendant’s representations are thus per se deceptive under the Green Guides and under - -California law. - -CLASS ACTION ALLEGATIONS - -27. - -Plaintiff brings this suit individually and as a class action pursuant to Federal Rule - -of Civil Procedure Rule 23, on behalf of himself and the following Class of similarly situated - -individuals: - -All persons who purchased the Products in California during the - -applicable statute of limitations period (the “Class”). Specifically - -excluded from the Class are Defendant; the officers, directors or - -employees of Defendant; any entity in which Defendant has a - -controlling interest; and any affiliate, legal representative, heir or - -assign of Defendant. Also excluded are any judicial officer - -presiding over this action and the members of his/her immediate - -family and judicial staff, and any juror assigned to this action. - -28. - -Plaintiff is unable to state the precise number of potential members of the proposed - -Class because that information is in the possession of Defendant. However, the number of Class - -members is so numerous that joinder would be impracticable for purposes of Rule 23(a)(1). The - -exact size of the proposed Class and the identity of its members will be readily ascertainable from - -the business records of Defendant and Defendant’s retailers as well as Class members’ own - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --7- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 9 of 19 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -records and evidence. The disposition of the claims of the members of the Class in this class - -action will substantially benefit both the parties and the Court. - -29. - -There is a community of interest among the members of the proposed Class in that - -there are questions of law and fact common to the proposed Class for purposes of Rule 23(a)(2), - -including whether Defendant’s labels, advertisements and packaging include uniform - -misrepresentations that misled Plaintiff and the other members of the Class to believe the - -Products are compostable when they are not. Proof of a common set of facts will establish the - -liability of Defendant and the right of each member of the Class to relief. - -30. - -Plaintiff asserts claims that are typical of the claims of the entire Class for - -purposes of Rule 23(a)(3). Plaintiff and all members of the Class have been subjected to the same - -wrongful conduct because they have purchased the Products that are labeled and sold as plates - -and bowls that are compostable, when they are not in fact compostable. +mon variant. . .or not? Hum Mol Genet 11: 2417–2423. PMID: 12351577 31. -Plaintiff will fairly and adequately represent and protect the interests of the other - -members of the Class for purposes of Rule 23(a)(4). Plaintiff has no interests antagonistic to - -those of other members of the Class. Plaintiff is committed to the vigorous prosecution of this - -action and has retained counsel experienced in complex litigation of this nature to represent him. - -Plaintiff anticipates no difficulty in the management of this litigation as a class action. +Zwick ME, Cutler DJ, Chakravarti A (2000) Patterns of genetic variation in Mendelian and complex +traits. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 1: 387–407. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.genom.1.1.387 +PMID: 11701635 -32. - -Class certification is appropriate under Rule 23(b)(2) because Defendant has acted - -on grounds that apply generally to the Class, so that final injunctive relief or corresponding - -declaratory relief, is appropriate respecting the Class as a whole. Defendant utilizes advertising - -campaigns that include uniform misrepresentations that misled Plaintiff and the other members of - -the Class. +32. Cassa CA, Weghorn D, Balick DJ, Jordan DM, Nusinow D, et al. (2017) Estimating the Selective Effect +of Heterozygous Protein Truncating Variants from Human Exome Data. Nat Genet 49: 806–810. +https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.3831 PMID: 28369035 33. -Class certification is appropriate under Rule 23(b)(3) because common questions - -of law and fact substantially predominate over any questions that may affect only individual - -members of the Class. These common legal and factual questions, which do not vary among - -Class members and which may be determined without reference to the individual circumstances +The Thousand Genomes Consortium (2015) A global reference for human genetic variation. Nature +526: 68–74. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature15393 PMID: 26432245 -of any Class member include, but are not limited to the following: +34. Neale BM, Kou Y, Liu L, Ma/’ayan A, Samocha KE, et al. (2012) Patterns and rates of exonic de novo +mutations in autism spectrum disorders. Nature 485: 242–245. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11011 +PMID: 22495311 -a. whether Defendant advertises and markets the Products by representing that - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --8- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 10 of 19 - -the Products are compostable; - -b. whether the Products contain PFAS; - -c. whether the Products are compostable as advertised and labeled by Defendant; - -d. whether Defendant’s marketing, advertising and labeling claims regarding the - -compostability of the Products are likely to deceive a reasonable consumer; - -e. whether Defendant’s representations regarding the compostability of the - -Products are likely to be read and understood by a reasonable consumer; - -f. whether Defendant’s representations regarding the compostability of the - -Products violate the Green Guides; +35. -g. whether Defendant’s claims regarding the compostability of the Products +Fu W, O’Connor T, Jun G, Kang H, Abecasis G, et al. (2013) Analysis of 6,515 exomes reveals the +recent origin of most human protein-coding variants. Nature 493: 216–220. https://doi.org/10.1038/ +nature11690 PMID: 23201682 -would be material to a reasonable consumer of the Products; +36. Segurel L, Wyman MJ, Przeworski M (2014) Determinants of mutation rate variation in the human germ- +line. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 15: 47–70. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-genom-031714- +125740 PMID: 25000986 -h. whether Defendant’s conduct in advertising, marketing and labeling of the +37. -Products constitutes a violation of California consumer protection laws; +Lohmueller KE, Indap AR, Schmidt S, Boyko AR, Hernandez RD, et al. (2008) Proportionally more dele- +terious genetic variation in European than in African populations. Nature 451: 994–997. https://doi.org/ +10.1038/nature06611 PMID: 18288194 -i. whether Defendant’s representations concerning the Products constitute +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -express warranties with regard to the Products; +21 / 23 -j. whether Defendant breached the express warranties it made with regard to the + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -Products; +38. Peischl S, Dupanloup I, Bosshard L, Excoffier L (2016) Genetic surfing in human populations: from -k. whether Defendant has been unjustly enriched from the sale of the Products; +genes to genomes. Curr Opin Genet Dev 41: 53–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.08.003 PMID: +27584859 -l. and +39. Pritchard JK, Cox NJ (2002) The allelic architecture of human disease genes: common disease-com- -m. whether Plaintiff and the Class members are entitled to injunctive, equitable +mon variant. . .or not? PMID: 12351577 -and monetary relief. +40. Aggarwala V, Voight BF (2016) An expanded sequence context model broadly explains variability in -34. +polymorphism levels across the human genome. Nat Genet 48: 349–355. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng. +3511 PMID: 26878723 -Defendant utilizes marketing, advertisements and labeling that include uniform +41. Hodgkinson A, Eyre-Walker A Variation in the mutation rate across mammalian genomes. Nat Rev -misrepresentations that misled Plaintiff and the other members of the Class. Defendant’s claims +Genet 12: 756–766. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg3098 PMID: 21969038 -regarding the compostability of the Products are one of the most prominent features of +42. Moorjani P, Amorim CE, Arndt PF, Przeworski M (2016) Variation in the molecular clock of primates. +Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 113: 10607–10612. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1600374113 PMID: +27601674 -Defendant’s marketing, advertising and labeling of the Products. Nonetheless, the Products are +43. Kamphans T, Sabri P, Zhu N, Heinrich V, Mundlos S, et al. (2013) Filtering for compound heterozygous -not in fact compostable. Thus, there is a well-defined community of interest in the questions of +sequence variants in non-consanguineous pedigrees. PLoS One 8: e70151. https://doi.org/10.1371/ +journal.pone.0070151 PMID: 23940540 -law and fact involved in this action and affecting the parties. +44. Burkhart BD, Montgomery E, Langley CH, Voelker RA (1984) Characterization of Allozyme Null and -1 +Low Activity Alleles from Two Natural Populations of DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER. Genetics 107: +295–306. PMID: 17246217 -2 +45. Xue Y, Chen Y, Ayub Q, Huang N, Ball EV, et al. (2012) Deleterious- and disease-allele prevalence in +healthy individuals: insights from current predictions, mutation databases, and population-scale rese- +quencing. Am J Hum Genet 91: 1022–1032. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2012.10.015 PMID: +23217326 -3 +46. Piton A, Redin C, Mandel JL (2013) XLID-causing mutations and associated genes challenged in light +of data from large-scale human exome sequencing. Am J Hum Genet 93: 368–383. https://doi.org/10. +1016/j.ajhg.2013.06.013 PMID: 23871722 -4 +47. Gazave E, Ma L, Chang D, Coventry A, Gao F, et al. (2014) Neutral genomic regions refine models of -5 +recent rapid human population growth. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 111: 757–762. https://doi.org/10. +1073/pnas.1310398110 PMID: 24379384 -6 +48. Gao F, Keinan A (2016) Explosive genetic evidence for explosive human population growth. Curr Opin -7 +Genet Dev 41: 130–139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gde.2016.09.002 PMID: 27710906 -8 +49. Wright S (1931) Evolution in Mendelian populations. Genetics 16: 97–159. PMID: 17246615 -9 +50. Ober C, Hyslop T, Hauck WW (1999) Inbreeding Effects on Fertility in Humans: Evidence for Reproduc- -10 +tive Compensation. The American Journal of Human Genetics 64: 225–231. https://doi.org/10.1086/ +302198 PMID: 9915962 -11 +51. Gabriel SE, Brigman KN, Koller BH, Boucher RC, Stutts MJ (1994) Cystic fibrosis heterozygote resis- +tance to cholera toxin in the cystic fibrosis mouse model. Science 266: 107–109. PMID: 7524148 -12 +52. Wagener D, Cavalli-Sforza LL, Barakat R (1978) Ethnic variation of genetic disease: roles of drift for -13 +recessive lethal genes. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 262–270. PMID: 677123 -14 +53. Quinton PM (1994) Human genetics. What is good about cystic fibrosis? Curr Biol 4: 742–743. PMID: -15 +7525005 -16 +54. Chakravarti A, Chakraborty R (1978) Elevated frequency of Tay-Sachs disease among Ashkenazic -17 +Jews unlikely by genetic drift alone. American Journal of Human Genetics 30: 256–261. PMID: 677122 -18 +55. Ewens WJ (1978) Tay-Sachs disease and theoretical population genetics. American Journal of Human -19 +Genetics 30: 328–329. PMID: 677129 -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --9- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 11 of 19 - -35. - -Proceeding as a class action provides substantial benefits to both the parties and - -the Court because this is the most efficient method for the fair and efficient adjudication of the - -controversy. Class members have suffered and will suffer irreparable harm and damages as a - -result of Defendant’s wrongful conduct. Because of the nature of the individual Class members’ - -claims, few, if any, could or would otherwise afford to seek legal redress against Defendant for - -the wrongs complained of herein, and a representative class action is therefore appropriate, the - -superior method of proceeding, and essential to the interests of justice insofar as the resolution of - -Class members’ claims are concerned. Absent a representative class action, members of the Class - -would continue to suffer losses for which they would have no remedy, and Defendant would - -unjustly retain the proceeds of its ill-gotten gains. Even if separate actions could be brought by - -individual members of the Class, the resulting multiplicity of lawsuits would cause undue - -hardship, burden and expense for the Court and the litigants, as well as create a risk of - -inconsistent rulings which might be dispositive of the interests of the other members of the Class - -who are not parties to the adjudications or may substantially impede their ability to protect their - -interests. - -FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION - -(Plaintiff, on Behalf of Himself, the Class and the General Public, -Alleges Violations of California Business & Professions Code § 17200, et seq. -Based on Commission of Unlawful Acts) - -36. - -Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 1 through 35 of - -this Complaint. - -37. - -The violation of any law constitutes an unlawful business practice under Business - -& Professions Code § 17200. - -38. - -Defendant’s conduct violates California Business & Professions Code § 17580.5, - -which makes it unlawful for any person to make any untruthful, deceptive or misleading - -environmental marketing claim. Pursuant to § 17580.5, the term “environmental marketing - -claim” includes any claim contained in the Green Guides. 16 C.F.R. § 260.1, et seq. Under the - -Green Guides, “[i]t is deceptive to misrepresent, directly or by implication, that a product or - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --10- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 12 of 19 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -package is compostable. A marketer claiming that an item is compostable should have competent - -and reliable scientific evidence that all the materials int eh item will break down into, or - -otherwise become part of, usable compost (e.g., soil-conditioning material, mulch) in a safe and - -timely manner (i.e., in approximately the same time as the materials with which it is composted) - -in an appropriate composting facility, or in a home compost pile or device. A marketer should - -clearly and prominently qualify compostable claims to the extent necessary to avoid deception if: - -(1) the item cannot be composted safely or in a timely manner in a home compost pile or device; - -or (2) the claim misleads reasonable consumers about the environmental benefit provided when - -the item is disposed of in a landfill.” 16 C.F.R. § 260.7(a)-(c). By misrepresenting that the - -Products are compostable as described above, Defendant is violating Business & Professions - -Code § 17580.5. - -39. - -Defendant’s conduct also violates Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act - -(“FTC Act”), 15 U.S.C. § 45, which prohibits unfair methods of competition and unfair or - -deceptive acts or practices in or effecting commerce. By misrepresenting that the Products are - -compostable, Defendant is violating Section 5 of the FTC Act. - -40. - -Defendant’s conduct also violates California Business & Professions Code - -§ 17500, which prohibits knowingly making, by means of any advertising device or otherwise, - -any untrue or misleading statement with the intent to sell a product or to induce the public to - -purchase a product. By misrepresenting that the Products are compostable, Defendant is violating - -Business & Professions Code § 17500. - -41. - -Defendant’s conduct is also a breach of warranty. Defendant’s representations that - -the Products are compostable constitute affirmations of fact made with regard to the Products, as - -well as descriptions of the Products, that are part of the basis of the bargain between Defendant - -and purchasers of the Products. Because those representations are material, false and misleading, - -Defendant has breached its express warranties as to the Products and has violated California - -Commercial Code § 2313. - -42. - -By violating the FTC Act, Business & Professions Code §§ 17500 and 17580.5, - -and California Commercial Code § 2313, Defendant has engaged in unlawful business acts and - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --11- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 13 of 19 - -practices which constitute unfair competition within the meaning of Business & Professions Code - -§ 17200. Plaintiff would not have purchased the Products, or would not have paid as much for - -Products, but for Defendant’s unlawful business practices. Plaintiff has thus suffered injury in - -fact and lost money or property as a direct result of Defendant’s misrepresentations and material - -omissions. - -43. - -An action for injunctive relief and restitution is specifically authorized under - -Business & Professions Code § 17203. - -44. - -Plaintiff would purchase the Products again in the future if they were truly - -compostable. - -Wherefore, Plaintiff prays for judgment against Defendant, as set forth hereafter. - -SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION - -(Plaintiff, on Behalf of Himself, the Class and the General Public, -Alleges Violations of California Business & Professions Code § 17200, -et seq. Based on Fraudulent Acts and Practices) - -45. - -Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 1 through 44 of - -this Complaint. - -46. - -Under Business & Professions Code § 17200, any business act or practice that is - -likely to deceive members of the public constitutes a fraudulent business act or practice. - -47. - -Defendant has engaged and continues to engage in conduct that is likely to deceive - -members of the public. This conduct includes, but is not limited to, representing that the Products - -are compostable. - -48. - -Plaintiff purchased the Products in reliance on Defendant’s representations that the - -Products are compostable. Defendant’s claims that the Products are compostable are material, - -untrue and misleading. These compostable claims are prominent on all of Defendant’s marketing, - -advertising and labeling materials, even though Defendant is aware that the claims are false and - -misleading. Also, because Defendant’s compostable claims violate Business & Professions Code - -§ 17580.5, such claims are deceptive per se. Defendant’s claims deceived Plaintiff, who relied on - -those claims and are likely to deceive reasonable consumers. Plaintiff would not have purchased - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --12- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 14 of 19 - -the Products, or would not have paid as much for the Products, but for Defendant’s false - -representations that the Products are compostable. Plaintiff has thus suffered injury in fact and - -lost money or property as a direct result of Defendant’s misrepresentations and material - -omissions. - -49. - -By committing the acts alleged above, Defendant has engaged in fraudulent - -business acts and practices, which constitute unfair competition within the meaning of Business - -& Professions Code § 17200. - -50. - -An action for injunctive relief and restitution is specifically authorized under - -Business & Professions Code § 17203. - -51. - -Plaintiff would purchase the Products again in the future if they were truly - -compostable. - -Wherefore, Plaintiff prays for judgment against Defendant, as set forth hereafter. - -THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION - -(Plaintiff, on Behalf of Himself, the Class and the General Public, -Alleges Violations of California Business & Professions Code § 17200, et seq. -Based on Unfair Acts and Practices) - -52. - -Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 1 through 51 of - -this Complaint. - -53. - -Under California Business & Professions Code § 17200, any business act or - -practice that is unethical, oppressive, unscrupulous or substantially injurious to consumers, or that - -violates a legislatively declared policy, constitutes an unfair business act or practice. - -54. - -Defendant has engaged and continues to engage in conduct which is immoral, - -unethical, oppressive, unscrupulous and substantially injurious to consumers. This conduct - -includes, but is not limited to, advertising and marketing the Products as compostable when they - -are not. By taking advantage of consumers concerned about the environmental impact of non- - -sustainable waste, Defendant’s conduct, as described herein, far outweighs the utility, if any, of - -such conduct. - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --13- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 15 of 19 - -55. - -Defendant has engaged and continue to engage in conduct that violates the - -legislatively declared policy of the Green Guides. The Green Guides mandate that “it is - -deceptive to misrepresent, directly or by implication, that a product or package is compostable.” - -16 C.F.R. § 260.7(a). It further states that “[a] marketer claiming that an item is compostable - -should have competent and reliable scientific evidence that all the materials in the item will break - -down into, or otherwise become part of usable compost…in a safe and timely manner.” 16 - -C.F.R. § 260.7(b). Defendant’s conduct also violates the policies underlying Business and - -Professions Code §17580.5, which prohibits untruthful, deceptive or misleading environmental - -marketing claims. As explained above, the Products are not compostable and the PFAS contained - -within the Products do break down into useable compost over time. Moreover, the PFAS - -contaminate the compost, thereby contaminating the soil treated with the compost. - -56. - -Defendant’s conduct, including failing to disclose that the Products contain PFAS - -which cannot break down into usable compost, is substantially injurious to consumers. Such - -conduct has caused and continues to cause substantial injury to consumers because consumers - -would not have purchased the Products but for Defendant’s representations that the Products are - -compostable. Consumers are concerned about environmental issues in general and PFAS - -contamination in particular. Defendant’s representations are therefore material to such - -consumers. Misleading causes injury to such consumers that is not outweighed by any - -countervailing benefits to consumers or competition. Indeed, no benefit to consumers or - -competition results from Defendant’s conduct. Defendant gains an unfair advantage over its - -competitors, whose advertising must comply with the FTC Act, Cal. Business & Professions - -Code § 17580.5, and the Green Guides. Since consumers reasonably rely on Defendant’s - -representations of the Products and injury results from ordinary use of the Products, consumers - -could not have reasonably avoided such injury. - -57. - -Although Defendant knows that the Products are not compostable, Defendant - -failed to disclose that fact to Plaintiff and the Class. - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --14- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 16 of 19 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -58. - -By committing the acts alleged above, Defendant has engaged in unfair business - -acts and practices which constitute unfair competition within the meaning of California Business - -& Professions Code § 17200. - -59. - -An action for injunctive relief and restitution is specifically authorized under - -California Business & Professions Code § 17203. - -60. - -Plaintiff would purchase the Products again in the future if they were truly - -compostable. - -61. - -Plaintiff would not have purchased the Products, or would not have paid as much - -for Products, but for Defendant’s unfair business practices. Plaintiff has thus suffered injury in - -fact and lost money or property as a direct result of Defendant’s misrepresentations and material - -omissions. - -Wherefore, Plaintiff prays for judgment against Defendant, as set forth hereafter. - -FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION - -(Plaintiff, on Behalf of Himself and the Class, Alleges Breach of Express Warranty) - -62. - -Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 1 through 61 of - -this Complaint. - -63. - -The Uniform Commercial Code § 2-313 provides that an affirmation of fact or - -promise made by the seller to the buyer which relates to the goods and becomes part of the basis - -of the bargain creates an express warranty that the goods shall conform to the promise. - -64. - -As detailed above, Defendant marketed and sold the Products as compostable. - -Defendant’s representations that the Products are compostable constitute affirmations of fact - -made with regard to the Products as well as descriptions of the Products. - -65. - -Defendant’s representations regarding the compostability of the Products are - -uniformly made in the Products’ advertising, internet sites and other marketing materials, and on - -the Products’ labeling and packaging materials, and are thus part of the basis of the bargain - -between Defendant and purchasers of the Products. - -66. - -California has codified and adopted the provisions of the Uniform Commercial - -Code governing express warranties (Cal. Com. Code § 2313). - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --15- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 17 of 19 - -67. - -At the time that Defendant designed, manufactured, sold and distributed the - -Products, Defendant knew that the Products were not compostable. - -68. - -As set forth in the paragraphs above, the Products are not compostable and thus do - -not conform to Defendant’s express representations to the contrary. Defendant has thus breached - -its express warranties concerning the Products. - -69. - -On April 23, 2020, Plaintiff sent a pre-suit demand letter to Defendant notifying - -Defendant that the Products are not compostable. Defendant therefore has actual and constructive - -knowledge that the Products are not compostable and were thus not sold as marketed and - -advertised. - -70. - -As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s breach of express warranties, - -Plaintiff and Class members have suffered damages. - -Wherefore, Plaintiff prays for judgment against Defendant, as set forth hereafter. - -FIFTH CAUSE OF ACTION - -(Plaintiff, on Behalf of Himself and the Class, Alleges Unjust Enrichment) - -71. - -Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 1 through 70 of - -this Complaint. - -72. - -Plaintiff and the Class members conferred benefits on Defendant by purchasing the - -Products. - -73. - -74. - -75. - -Defendant has knowledge of such benefits. - -Defendant voluntarily accepted and retained the benefits conferred. - -Defendant has been unjustly enriched in retaining the revenues derived from - -Plaintiff’s and the Class members’ purchases of the Products. - -76. - -Retention of that money under these circumstances is unjust and inequitable - -because Defendant falsely and misleadingly represented through its labeling, advertising and - -marketing materials that the Products are compostable when the Products are not in fact - -compostable. - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --16- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 18 of 19 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 - -16 - -17 - -18 - -19 - -20 - -21 - -22 - -23 - -24 - -25 - -26 - -27 - -28 - -77. - -These misrepresentations and omissions caused injuries to Plaintiff and the Class - -members because they would not have purchased the Products, or would not have paid as much - -for the Products, had they known that the Products are not compostable, and instead, contaminate - -the compost stream. - -78. - -Because Defendant’s retention of the non-gratuitous benefits conferred to them by - -Plaintiff and the Class members is unjust and inequitable, Defendant ought to pay restitution to - -Plaintiff and the Class members for their unjust enrichment. - -79. - -As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s unjust enrichment, Plaintiff and - -the Class members are entitled to restitution or disgorgement in an amount to be proved at trial. - -Wherefore, Plaintiff prays for judgment against Defendant, as set forth hereafter. - -PRAYER FOR RELIEF - -WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays for judgment and relief against Defendant as follows: - -A. - -B. - -That the Court declare this a class action; - -That the Court preliminarily and permanently enjoin Defendant from conducting - -its businesses through the unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business acts or practices, untrue and - -misleading advertising, and other violations of law described in this Complaint; - -C. - -That the Court order Defendant to cease and refrain from marketing and promotion - -of the Products that state or imply that the Products are compostable; - -D. - -That the Court order Defendant to implement whatever measures are necessary to - -remedy the unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business acts or practices, untrue and misleading - -advertising and other violations of law described in this Complaint; - -E. - -That the Court order Defendant to notify each and every Class member of the - -pendency of the claims in this action in order to give such individuals an opportunity to obtain - -restitution and damages from Defendant; - -F. - -That the Court order Defendant to pay restitution to restore all Class members all - -funds acquired by means of any act or practice declared by this Court to be an unlawful, unfair or - -fraudulent business act or practice, untrue or misleading advertising, plus pre- and post-judgment - -interest thereon; - -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R - --17- - -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT - - Case 4:20-cv-04009-DMR Document 1 Filed 06/16/20 Page 19 of 19 - -G. - -That the Court order Defendant to disgorge all money wrongfully obtained and all - -revenues and profits derived by Defendant as a result of their acts or practices as alleged in this - -Complaint; - -H. - -That the Court award damages to Plaintiff and the Class to compensate them for - -the conduct alleged in this Complaint; - -I. - -That the Court grant Plaintiff her reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs of suit - -pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure § 1021.5, the common fund doctrine, or any other - -appropriate legal theory; and - -J. - -That the Court grant such other and further relief as may be just and proper. - -JURY DEMAND - -Plaintiff demands a trial by jury on all causes of action so triable. - -Dated: June 16, 2020 - -Respectfully submitted, - -LEXINGTON LAW GROUP - - /s/ Mark Todzo -Mark N. Todzo, (State Bar No. 168389) -Meredyth Merrow, (State Bar No. 328337) -LEXINGTON LAW GROUP -503 Divisadero Street -San Francisco, CA 94117 -Telephone: (415) 913-7800 -Facsimile: (415) 759-4112 -mtodzo@lexlawgroup.com -mmerrow@lexlawgroup.com - -Attorneys for Plaintiff -DAVID AMBROSE - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 +56. -16 +Landrum MJ, Lee JM, Riley GR, Jang W, Rubinstein WS, et al. (2014) ClinVar: public archive of rela- +tionships among sequence variation and human phenotype. Nucleic acids research 42: D980–D985. +https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkt1113 PMID: 24234437 -17 +57. Eppig JT, Blake JA, Bult CJ, Kadin JA, Richardson JE (2015) The Mouse Genome Database (MGD): -18 +facilitating mouse as a model for human biology and disease. Nucleic Acids Res 43: D726–736. https:// +doi.org/10.1093/nar/gku967 PMID: 25348401 -19 +58. Gravel S, Henn BM, Gutenkunst RN, Indap AR, Marth GT, et al. (2011) Demographic history and rare -20 +allele sharing among human populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 108: 11983–11988. https://doi.org/ +10.1073/pnas.1019276108 PMID: 21730125 -21 +59. Mugal CF, Ellegren H (2011) Substitution rate variation at human CpG sites correlates with non-CpG -22 +divergence, methylation level and GC content. Genome Biol 12: R58. https://doi.org/10.1186/gb-2011- +12-6-r58 PMID: 21696599 -23 +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -24 +22 / 23 -25 + The population genetics of recessive, lethal mutations -26 +60. North BV, Curtis D, Sham PC (2002) A Note on the Calculation of Empirical Values from Monte Carlo +Procedures. The American Journal of Human Genetics 71: 439–441. https://doi.org/10.1086/341527 +PMID: 12111669 -27 +61. Quinlan AR, Hall IM (2010) BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic features. Bioin- -28 +formatics 26: 841–842. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btq033 PMID: 20110278 -D OCU ME NT PRE PA RED - ON RE CYCL ED PA PE R +62. R Core Team (2015) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria. --18- +PLOS Genetics | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006915 September 28, 2017 -CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT +23 / 23 diff --git a/q238/random_k4/random_4.md b/q238/random_k4/random_4.md index b65448589e0f7b39c68d077ff7689dd9a3943030..a4b2b07cac278442884a849032b2d8b161f383fe 100644 --- a/q238/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q238/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,1188 +1,2777 @@ -BETWEEN: +Digital Landscape -Court File No. +February 2020 -FEDERAL COURT +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -PROPOSED CLASS PROCEEDING + Snapshot -G. DUPUIS +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -AND + Landscape Overview -Plaintiff +Metric -MAPLEBEAR INC. -MAPLEBEAR CANADA ULC -MAPLEBEAR DELIVERY CANADA ULC -MAPLEBEAR LOGISTICS CANADA ULC +Device -Defendants +Jan-2020 -STATEMENT OF CLAIM +Feb-2020 -TO THE DEFENDANTS: +Unique Audience (000) -A LEGAL PROCEEDING HAS BEEN COMMENCED AGAINST YOU by the Plaintiff. +Digital (C/M) -The claim made against you is set out in the following pages. +Active Reach (%) -IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND THIS PROCEEDING, you or a solicitor acting for you are -required to prepare a statement of defence in Form 171B prescribed by the Federal Courts Rules, -serve it on the plaintiff’s solicitor or, if the plaintiff does not have a solicitor, serve it on the -plaintiff, and file it, with proof of service, at a local office of this Court +Time Spent per Person +(hh:mm:ss) -WITHIN 30 DAYS after the day on which this statement of claim is served on you, if you -are served in Canada or the United States; or +Desktop -WITHIN 60 DAYS after the day on which this statement of claim is served on you, if you -are served outside Canada and the United States. +Smartphone -TEN ADDITIONAL DAYS are provided for the filing and service of the statement of -defence if you or a solicitor acting for you serves and files a notice of intention to respond -in Form 204.1 prescribed by the Federal Courts Rules. +Tablet -Copies of the Federal Courts Rules, information concerning the local offices of the Court and -other necessary information may be obtained on request to the Administrator of this Court at -Ottawa (telephone 613-992-4238) or at any local office. +Digital (C/M) -e-documentT-481-25-ID 1FEDERAL COURT COUR FÉDÉRALE F I L E D February 12, 2025 12 février 2025 D É P O S É Jonathan MacenaOTT1 IF YOU FAIL TO DEFEND THIS PROCEEDING, judgment may be given against you in +Desktop -your absence and without further notice to you. +Smartphone -Date _______________________ Issued by ______________________________ +Tablet -February 12, 2025 +Digital (C/M) -Jonathan Macena +Desktop - Registry Officer +Smartphone - Address of court office: 90 Sparks Street - Ottawa, Ontario - K1A 0H9 +Tablet -TO: +21,152 -MAPLEBEAR INC. -50 Beale Street, Suite 600 -San Francisco, CA 94105 +18,505 -MAPLEBEAR CANADA ULC. +16,383 - 1300-1969 Upper Water Street - Purdy’s Wharf Tower II - Halifax, Nova Scotia B3J 3R7 +7,441 - 190 Liberty Street - Toronto, ON M6K 3L5 +100% - MAPLEBEAR DELIVERY CANADA ULC +87% - 595 Burrard Street, Suite 2600 - Vancouver, BC V7X 1L3 +77% - MAPLEBEAR LOGISTICS CANADA ULC - 595 Burrard Street, Suite 2600 - Vancouver, BC V7X 1L3 +35% -12-FEB-2025 +108:47:50 -13-FEB-2025 +21:57:14 -I HEREBY CERTIFY that the above document is a true copy ofthe original filed in the Court./JE CERTIFIE que le document ci-dessus est une copie confirmeÀ l’original déposé au dossier de la Cour fédérale.Filing DateDate de dépôt : _________________________________________DatedFait le : ________________________________________________ +89:56:34 - INTRODUCTION +58:05:33 -A. +21,310 -1. +18,656 -OVERVIEW +16570 -The Plaintiff, G. Dupuis, seeks to institute a class action on behalf of the following +7,449 -class, of which she is a member, namely: +100% -All residents of Canada – excluding Québec – who completed a consumer -transaction on Defendants’ Instacart.ca website and/or Instacart mobile -application and who paid a price higher than initially advertised or -indicated, including but not limited to, delivery fees, service fees and/or any -other fee(s); +88% -2. +78% -The present class action concerns the Defendants (collectively referred to herein as +35% -“Maplebear”) engaging in conduct amounting to fraudulent or negligent misrepresentation, +90:49:40 -unjust enrichment, and violations of the Competition Act, R.S.C., 1985, c. C-34, by structuring +20:17:06 -the transaction process on their Instacart.ca website and mobile app to charge customers an +72:18:43 -amount higher than the price initially indicated. +48:48:53 -3. +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Jan 2020, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P2+, Unique Audience (000), Active Reach (Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person +(hh:mm:ss). +3 -Maplebear owns, designed, developed, operates, markets, advertises, maintains, +. +. -administers, and updates a grocery technology website and mobile application named Instacart. +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D -Maplebear also does business under - -the name - -Instacart. The - -Instacart website - -(https://www.instacart.ca) and mobile application each and both provide customers with a - -platform to facilitate on-demand grocery and delivery services across Canada (and the United - -States through instacard.com) by connecting customers with personal shoppers. - -4. - -The Instacart.ca website and mobile application have each and both been intentionally - -designed to involve a five-stage process for customers to place and pay for an order and to - -arrange for its delivery. Instead of displaying the all-in or total pricing of the order, the Instacart - -website and mobile app are purposefully designed to only display the all-in price at the fourth - -1 stage of the transactional process, at which point the original price indicated at the third stage is - -updated to include delivery fees, service fees, and several other types of hidden fees, and taxes. - -5. - -Instacart customers are therefore misled concerning the actual total cost of the transaction - -until the fourth stage of the transactional process. This practice can be characterized as “drip - -pricing” or as double ticketing under ss. 52, 54 and 74 of the federal Competition Act. - -6. - -As a result of Maplebear’s violations of the Competition Act, the Consumer Protection - -Act and Other Consumer Protection Legislation and committing negligent and/or fraudulent - -misrepresentations, and/or predominant purpose or unlawful means conspiracy, Plaintiff and - -Class Members were required to incur unnecessary and unexpected fees. - -7. - -There is also no juridical reason for Maplebear’s unjust enrichment at Plaintiff and Class +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -Members’ expense. +l +l -8. +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Trend - Time Spent by Device - DCR + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -Maplebear’s conduct was intentional, brazen, reckless, wanton, illegal, and in clear +l +l -disregard for the rights of consumers, namely, Plaintiff and Class Members. Maplebear’s +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -marketing and intentional targeting of customers in the age of seniority allowed it to take +i +i -advantage of a vulnerable demographic. Punitive/exemplary damages are warranted. +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -9. +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Jan 2019 - Feb 2020, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P 2+, % of Total Time Spent, Text -The Defendants’ conduct is the direct and proximate cause of significant legally- +4 -cognizable compensable injuries incurred by the Plaintiff and Class Members, for which + Age Breakdowns Overview -remedies are being sought in the present proposed class action. +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. -10. + Digital Audience Reach and Time by Demo Overview -The remedies sought are not limited to the payment of money in the form of +Data Type -compensatory and punitive damages, but extend to injunctive relief enjoining Maplebear to +Device -permanently cease and desist from continuing to make misleading and/or fraudulent +Unique +Audience -misrepresentations and omissions in advertising, marketing, and other materials concerning the +Total Platform -2 all-in price of orders placed on the Instacart website and mobile app and the delivery fees, +Desktop -service fees, and/or any other fees charged to customers by Maplebear. +Smartphone -11. +Tablet -Note that the Plaintiff is a “consumer” within the meaning of the Consumer Protection +Profile % -Act, S.O. 2002, c. 30, and Other Consumer Protection Legislation. +Total Platform -B. +Desktop -RELIEF SOUGHT +Smartphone -12. +Tablet -The Plaintiff claims against Maplebear on her own behalf and on behalf of the Class, of +P 18+ -which he is a member: +18,300 -a. an Order pursuant to Rules 334.16(1) of the Federal Courts Rules certifying this +15,646 -action as a class proceeding; +16,570 -b. +7,449 - an Order pursuant to Rules 334.12(3), 334.16(1)(e) and 334.17(b) of the Rules +100% -appointing the Plaintiff as the Representative Plaintiff of the Class; +100% -c. a Declaration that Maplebear fraudulently or negligently misrepresented the +100% -purchase prices, delivery fees, service fees, and/or any other fee(s) applying to +100% -transactions completed on +P 18-24 -their Instacart.ca website and Instacart mobile +P 25-34 -application; +P 35-44 -d. a Declaration that Maplebear violated ss. 52 and 54 of the Competition Act in +P 45-54 -structuring the transaction process on the Instacart website and mobile app to +P 55-64 -charge customers an amount higher than the price initially indicated, in effect +2,353 -charging every Class Member a price higher than the lowest of two or more prices +1,931 -clearly expressed by Maplebear to each Class Member; +2,313 -e. an Order for damages under s. 36 of the Competition Act, along with the cost of the +304 -investigation undertaken in connection with Maplebear’s violation of ss. 52 and 54 +13% -of the Competition Act, on a full indemnity basis; +12% -f. +14% -an Order requiring Maplebear to pay restitution to Class Members in an amount +4% -equivalent to all fees charged and paid for that were not announced before the +3,813 -fourth stage of the transactional process on the Instacart website and mobile app; +3,392 -3 g. +3,813 -an Order pursuant to Rule 334.28(1) and (2) for the aggregate assessment of +1,360 -monetary relief and its distribution to the Plaintiff and Class members; +21% -h. +22% -Injunctive relief enjoining Maplebear to permanently cease and desist from +23% -continuing to make misleading and/or fraudulent misrepresentations and omissions +18% -in on the Instacart.ca website and mobile application concerning the all-in price of +3,332 -orders placed on the Instacart website and mobile app and the delivery fees, service +2,998 -fees, and/or any other fees charged to customers by Maplebear; +3,320 -i. +1,499 -j. +18% -special damages for out-of-pocket and inconvenience expenses incurred; +19% -punitive and exemplary damages; +20% -k. +20% -a reference to decide any issues not decided at the trial of the common issues; +3,115 -l. +2,700 -costs of this action on a substantial indemnity basis or in an amount that provides +2,904 -full indemnity plus the costs of distribution of an award; +1,599 -m. costs of administration and notice, plus taxes, associated with the distribution and +17% -the fees payable to a person administering the distribution; +17% -n. +18% -pre-judgment and post-judgment interest pursuant to sections 36 and 37 of the +21% -Federal Courts Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. F-7; and +2,716 -o. Such further and other relief as this Honourable Court deems just. +2,344 -C. +2,463 -THE PARTIES +1,399 -The Plaintiff +15% -13. +15% -The Plaintiff, G. Dupuis, is a resident of the city of Ottawa, in the province of +15% -Ontario. +19% -14. +P 65+ -The Plaintiff has been a sporadic user of Instacart since at least April 2021. +2,972 -15. +2,281 -On July 28, 2024, the Plaintiff used the Instacart website to order four cases of Peace Tea +1,757 -iced tea, containing twelve cans of 341 millilitres each, from the Real Canadian Superstore. +1,288 -4 16. +16% -After the Plaintiff selected these four items and placed them in her personal cart, the price +15% -displayed on the Instacart website was $31.96. +11% -17. +17% -The website also featured a clickable banner inviting the Plaintiff to “Go to checkout”, +Time Spent per +Person (Text) -with the price of $31.96 displayed on it. +Total Platform -18. +105:15:33 -After clicking on “Go to checkout”, the Plaintiff was taken to the next step of the +82:51:47 -ordering and purchasing process on the Instacart website. The Plaintiff’s total price of her order +104:05:13 -was displayed as $50.53 – or $18.57 more expensive than the price initially advertised. +131:29:27 -19. +121:53:22 -The webpage provided for the following itemization explaining how the price went from +103:45:04 -$31.96 to $50.53: +79:01:37 - $31.96 -Item subtotal - $7.99 -Delivery fee - $3.00 -Service fee -Estimated taxes and fees $5.58 -Delivery tip $2.00 +Desktop -20. Note that the Delivery tip was preselected to $2.00. Note as well as the “fees” in the +23:39:39 -“Estimated taxes and fees” were not at all disclosed to the Plaintiff. +22:28:55 -21. Overall, the difference between the item subtotal displayed at earlier stages of the order +19:08:11 -and purchasing process and the final price indicated was 58% higher. +26:13:02 -The Defendants +27:00:23 -22. +22:41:43 - Maplebear Inc. is a corporation constituted under the laws of Delaware, and is +25:03:33 -headquartered in San Francisco, California. Maplebear Inc. also does business as “Instacart.” +Smartphone -23. Defendant Maplebear Canada ULC is a legal person constituted under the laws of Nova +72:18:43 -Scotia. Maplebear Canada ULC’s registered or head office address is situated in Halifax, Nova +59:11:44 -Scotia, and also carries on business in Ontario from offices located in Toronto, Ontario. +68:14:18 -5 +78:06:30 - Maplebear Canada ULC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Maplebear Inc., and also carries on +83:00:33 -business from Maplebear Inc.’s headquarters in San Francisco, California. +72:09:21 -24. Defendant Maplebear Logistics Canada Inc. is a Canadian corporation headquartered in +70:01:28 -Vancouver, British Columbia and constituted under the laws of Nova Scotia. Maplebear +Tablet -Logistics Canada ULC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Maplebear Inc. +48:48:53 -25. Defendant Maplebear Delivery Canada ULC is a legal person constituted under the laws +80:59:43 -of Nova Scotia. Maplebear Delivery Canada ULC’s registered or head office address is situated +64:04:38 -in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and also carries on business in Ontario from offices located in Toronto, +35:49:12 -Ontario. Maplebear Delivery Canada ULC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Maplebear Logistics +50:59:20 -Canada ULC. +41:43:09 -26. +44:10:57 -The Defendants operate as corporate alter egos that are neither separate nor independent. +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P18+, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Profile +(Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person (text). -27. Maplebear derives substantial revenue from the delivery services offered and purchased +6 -in Canada on the Instacart.ca website and web application. +. +. -28. +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D -In light of the foregoing, the Maplebear Defendants are jointly and severally liable for the +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -acts and omissions of the other. +l +l -D. +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Digital Audience Reach and Time Demo Overview + +Unique Audience + +Time Spent per Person + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -FACTS +l +l -Maplebear and Instacart +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P0-17, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Universe +Reach %, Time Spent per Person (text). + +* Persons 0-17 does not include mobile data. + +7 + + Surfing Reports + +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. + + People 2+ Surfing Online + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -29. Maplebear owns, designed, developed, operates, markets, advertises, maintains, +l +l -administers, and updates a grocery technology website and mobile application named Instacart. +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + +Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2019 - Feb 2020, Digital (C/M), People 2+ Market Line -Maplebear also does business under +9 -the name + Surfing Report -Instacart. The +People 2+ -Instacart website +People 18+ -(https://www.instacart.ca) and mobile application each and both provide customers with a +Name -6 platform to facilitate on-demand grocery and delivery services across Canada by connecting +UA -customers with personal shoppers. +Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent -30. +Name -The personal shoppers are individuals who have downloaded the Instacart application for +UA -shoppers, through which they are dispatched orders that they then fulfill by physically going to +Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent -the retail store in respect of which the customer has placed an order and picking up all available +Google -items that are part of the order. The personal shoppers then deliver the order to the address +Facebook -specified by the customer. +YouTube -31. +19,848,439 -Importantly, Instacart provides delivery services in respect of retailers who do not +17,837,239 -otherwise offer their own delivery services to customers. On information and belief, Instacart +17,068,585 -has been operating in Canada since at least June 15, 2021. +13:40:46 -32. +16,291,203,606 -Instacart is not itself a retailer. +Google -33. +18:39:42 -The process of completing transactions on the Instacart website and application consists +19,972,379,884 -of five stages. +YouTube -34. +23:05:53 -The first involves the consumer selecting the retailer from which they wish to arrange a +23,655,150,362 -delivery. The second consists of the consumer selecting the items they wish to have delivered +Facebook -from that retailer. The third stage displays a list of all items selected by the consumer and the +17,943,703 -total price consisting of the addition of the price of each item. +16,204,525 -35. +17,278,479 -The fourth stage involves the consumer providing delivery instructions, including their +15:04:14 -address and their payment information. At this stage, the total price is updated to include +16,225,558,846 -applicable taxes, namely, the HST or the GST and PST, depending on the province or territory. +23:52:30 -7 36. +23,213,035,282 -Instacart delivery fees and Instacart service fees are also displayed for the first time at the +19:15:20 -fourth stage. Other fees include bagging fees, heavy order fees, priority fees, alcohol service +19,962,616,731 -fees, long-distance fees, special handling fees, and direct-to-consumer shipping fees. +MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype -37. +13,681,073 -At the fifth stage, consumers can add an optional tip amount for the delivery person and +4:55:39 -can then submit the order. +4,044,846,450 -Maplebear’s Unlawful Practice +MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype -38. +12,995,336 -The present class action centers around the unlawful practice engaged in by Maplebear in +Apple -designing, developing, operating, marketing, advertising, maintaining, administering, updating, +Instagram -and processing transactions on the Instacart.ca website and Instacart mobile app, namely: +eBay -Structuring the transaction process on the Instacart website and mobile app to charge customers +PayPal -an amount higher than the price initially indicated. +Microsoft -39. +12,866,475 -As discussed in the following paragraphs, this unlawful practice arises in the first of the +12,684,785 -five stages of the transaction process on the Instacart.ca website and mobile app. +12,605,107 -40. Maplebear has unlawfully structured the transaction process on the Instacart website and +12,094,593 -mobile app to charge customers an amount higher than the price initially indicated. This practice +11,551,875 -is legally referred to as “double ticketing” or “drip pricing.” +ABC Online Network -41. +11,333,137 -In essence, by only displaying the actual price of the order at the fourth stage of the +Woolworths -process, Maplebear charges a higher price than that advertised and displayed at the first through +Wikipedia -to the third stage of the transaction (excluding applicable taxes). +LinkedIn -42. +realestate.com.au -A screenshot of the third stage is shown below: +news.com.au -8 43. +10,376,298 -A screenshot of the fourth stage is shown below: +10,187,717 -44. +9,762,158 -In essence, Maplebear illegally charges fees to consumers that are not displayed the first +9,634,420 -time the total cost of the order is indicated to consumers, but only at the checkout stage of the +9,348,648 -transactional process. The illegally charged fees include, but are not limited to, service fees, +1:59:17 -delivery fees, priority fees, heavy order fees, alcohol service fees, direct-to-consumer shipping +1,534,854,537 -fees, bag fees, special handling fees, and long-distance fees, in addition to taxes imposed on each +Apple -of these fees. +3:37:53 -9 +2,764,000,687 - E. +Instagram - NATURE OF THE ACTION +1:29:37 -45. +1,129,694,442 -Fundamentally, Plaintiff and Class Members were misled by Maplebear and were victim +eBay -of Maplebear’s double ticketing/drip pricing practices concerning the actual total cost of their +0:09:31 -order until the fourth stage of the transactional process. +1:07:37 -46. +1:18:02 -The legally cognizable and compensable injuries suffered by every Class Member are the +0:19:47 -direct and proximate result of Maplebear’s unlawful, tortious, and inequitable conduct. +0:14:00 -Fraudulent or Negligent Misrepresentation +1:15:48 -47. +0:46:34 -The facts canvassed under section D – FACTS of the present statement of claim serve as +0:36:05 -the factual foundation for the claims of fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation asserted +115,109,629 -against Maplebear. For greater certainty, the Plaintiff asserts that Maplebear committed the tort +PayPal -of fraudulent misrepresentation and, alternatively, that Maplebear instead committed the tort of +781,266,772 -negligent misrepresentation. +Microsoft -48. Maplebear’s central misrepresentations concern the misleading practice of indicating two +884,466,592 -different prices in the transactional process for the same order placed on its Instacart.ca website +ABC Online Network -and mobile application and subsequently charging Plaintiff and Class Members the higher, later +205,325,529 -displayed amount. +Woolworths -(a) Fraudulent Misrepresentation +142,669,437 -49. +Wikipedia -The elements of the tort of fraudulent misrepresentation are established as: +740,053,674 -i. Maplebear made representations that were untrue, inaccurate and/or misleading as +LinkedIn -concerns the cost of each order placed on its Instacart.ca website and mobile +448,667,709 -application, and by omitting or otherwise failing to disclose that the initially +realestate.com.au -indicated cost does not represent the actual cost of the order, and +337,483,439 -10 +news.com.au - ii. Maplebear knew that its representations were untrue or were reckless as to their +12,763,377 -truthfulness; +12,579,558 -iii. Maplebear intended for its representations to deceive Plaintiff and Class Members or +12,221,372 -acted with reckless disregard for the truth knowing that the Plaintiff and Class +11,957,707 -Members would rely on Maplebear’s representations; +11,265,747 -iv. The Plaintiff and Class Members actually did rely on Maplebear’s representations +10,981,388 -concerning the cost of orders initially displayed on the Instacart.ca website and +10,298,974 -mobile application, leading them to complete their orders on the app or website; and +9,957,687 -v. The Plaintiff and Class Members sustained pure economic loss as a result of their +9,737,846 -reliance on Maplebear’s representations, in the form of the price paid to complete +9,463,425 -their orders on the Instacart.ca website or mobile application. +9,174,848 -(b) Negligent Misrepresentation +5:10:42 -50. Alternatively, the elements of the tort of negligent misrepresentation are established as: +2:00:13 -i. Maplebear owed a duty of care to the Plaintiff and Class Members based on the +3:39:33 -special relationship between Maplebear as representor inviting the representees, +1:31:56 -Plaintiff and Class Members, to complete orders on the Instacart.ca website and +0:09:35 -mobile application and to select and pay for a delivery service option; +1:08:45 -ii. Maplebear’s representations concerning the initially advertised price for orders +1:19:29 -processed on the website and application, were untrue, inaccurate and/or misleading, +0:19:53 -including in omitting or otherwise failing to disclose that the actual price is higher +0:14:15 -than the price initially advertised, and that the cost associated with the delivery +1:15:58 -service option selected by consumers is lower than the amount actually charged by +0:46:50 -Maplebear; +0:36:24 -iii. Maplebear acted negligently in making said representations. A reasonable supplier +4,037,669,825 -of grocery delivery services would have satisfied their duty to exercise such +1,534,537,028 -reasonable care to ensure that the representations made to consumers are accurate +2,761,947,509 -and not misleading, including by expressly identifying the aforementioned functional +1,123,728,567 -11 - limitations in advertising, marketing, instructional, and other materials disseminated +114,630,946 -to the public; +774,538,814 -iv. As representees, Plaintiff and Class Members, reasonably relied on said negligent +872,997,444 -misrepresentations, especially as, but not exclusively based on the fact that, +204,886,013 -Maplebear owns, designed, developed, operates, markets, advertises, maintains, and +141,942,109 -administers the Instacart.ca website and mobile application and is in the best position +739,859,176 -and expected to provide the most accurate description and representation of the +443,213,459 -actual price and amounts of delivery fees associated with orders placed thereon; +333,989,057 -v. Plaintiff and Class Members’ reasonable reliance on Maplebear’s representations +Source: Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2020, People 2+, People 13+, Unique Audience, Avg TIme Spent, Total Time Spent. +*YouTube reporting is sourced from DCR Monthly Total Video -were detrimental in leading them to incur economic loss in the form of the price paid +10 -for in the form of the difference between the initially advertised price and the total +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -cost of their respective orders after adding all additional fees to complete their orders +l +l -on the Instacart.ca website or mobile application. +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Streaming Video + +This artwork was created using Nielsen data. +Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute. + + Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent + +Demo + +Total 18+ +Total 18 - 24 +Total 25 - 34 +Total 35 - 44 +Total 45 - 54 +Total 55 - 64 +Total 65+ +Total Female 18+ +Female 18 - 24 +Female 25 - 34 +Female 35 - 44 +Female 45 - 54 +Female 55 - 64 +Female 65+ +Total Male 18+ +Male 18 - 24 +Male 25 - 34 +Male 35 - 44 +Male 45 - 54 +Male 55 - 64 +Male 65+ + +Unique Audience +16,888,355 + +Population Reach (%) +86% + +Average Time Spent +37:42:52 + +2,224,910 +3,636,729 +3,163,950 +2,933,646 +2,574,718 +2,417,820 +8,663,869 +1,099,710 +1,829,763 +1,598,064 +1,560,162 +1,359,606 +1,216,564 +8,287,904 +1,125,200 +1,806,966 +1,565,886 +1,373,484 +1,215,112 +1,201,256 + +94.5% +96.7% +95.6% +90.7% +88.3% +61.0% +87.1% +95.6% +96.8% +96.2% +94.5% +91.1% +57.8% +86.4% +93.5% +96.6% +94.9% +86.7% +85.4% +64.7% + +70:58:47 +43:08:00 +37:51:40 +33:36:20 +20:05:40 +16:42:54 +32:57:32 +57:17:19 +38:46:58 +32:35:06 +32:47:02 +19:27:09 +18:00:58 +40:59:43 +84:21:38 +47:32:19 +43:14:45 +34:32:20 +20:48:47 +15:23:50 + +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census + +12 + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -51. +l +l -The Plaintiff and Class Members suffered significant +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + + Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent + +Unique Audience + +Population Reach% + +Average Time Spent + +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -legally-cognizable and +l +l -compensable injuries as the direct and proximate result of Maplebear’s fraudulent or negligent +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C + +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census -misrepresentations. +13 -Unjust Enrichment + Streaming Video Report - Total - Computer -52. +Name -The facts canvassed under section D – FACTS of the present statement of claim serve as +Market Total -the factual foundation for the claims of unjust enrichment asserted against the Defendants. +Facebook -53. +YouTube -In essence, Maplebear enriched itself by charging fees for each transaction completed on +news.com.au* -the Instacart.ca website and mobile application that were added to the initially advertised price of +Netflix -each order. +ABC Online Network -54. Maplebear also enriched itself by charging additional delivery, bagging, priority, long +Pinterest -distance, service and other fees that were not initially displayed with the cost of the order at the +Yahoo! -12 third stage of the transactional process and that could not, therefore, lawfully be added at the +9Now* -fourth stage of that process on the Instacart.ca website and mobile application. +smh.com.au -55. +Daily Mail Australia* -The Plaintiff and Class Members were correlatively deprived and impoverished in the +Reddit -amount corresponding to all fees charged at the fourth stage of the respective orders they placed +nine.com.au* -on the Instacart.ca website and mobile application and that were not previously disclosed to them +Instagram -when the total cost of their order was initially advertised or otherwise indicated. +SBS (Special Broadcasting Service)* -56. +UA -As the enrichment violated the Competition Act, and instantiated the torts of fraudulent or +Pop Base -negligent misrepresentation, and in the absence of any legal justification or authority for the +Reach % -enrichment, there was no juristic reason for the Defendants enriching themselves at Class +10,010,479 -Members’ expense. +6,300,756 -57. +6,283,189 -Plaintiff and Class Members are therefore entitled to restitution in an amount +1,740,628 -corresponding to all fees charged at the fourth stage of the respective orders they placed on the +1,602,615 -Instacart.ca website and mobile application and that were not previously disclosed to them when +975,781 -the total cost of their order was initially advertised or otherwise indicated. +952,349 -STATUTORY REMEDIES +888,471 -Violations of the Competition Act +812,255 -58. +766,276 -The facts canvassed under section D – FACTS serve as the factual foundation for the +719,233 -claims that the Defendants violated sections 52 and 54 of the Competition Act by structuring the +710,274 -transaction process on the Instacart website and mobile app to charge customers an amount +699,436 -higher than the price initially indicated. +629,777 -59. +623,930 -Section 54(1) provides as follows: +19,774,230 -13 - Double ticketing -54 (1) No person shall supply a product at a -price that exceeds the lowest of two or more -prices clearly expressed by him or on his -behalf, in respect of the product in the quantity -in which it is so supplied and at the time at -which it is so supplied, +19,774,230 -Double étiquetage -54 (1) Nul ne peut fournir un produit à un prix -qui dépasse le plus bas de deux ou plusieurs -prix clairement exprimés, par lui ou pour lui, -pour ce produit, pour la quantité dans laquelle -celui-ci est ainsi fourni et au moment où il -l’est : +19,774,230 -(a) on the product, its wrapper or container; +19,774,230 -a) soit sur le produit ou sur son emballage; +19,774,230 -(b) on anything attached to, inserted in or -accompanying the product, its wrapper or -container or anything on which the product is -mounted for display or sale; or +19,774,230 -(c) on an in-store or other point-of-purchase -display or advertisement. +19,774,230 -b) soit sur quelque chose qui est fixé au -produit, à son emballage ou a quelque chose -qui y est inséré ou joint ; +19,774,230 -c) soit dans un étalage ou la réclame d’un -magasin ou d’un autre point de vente. +19,774,230 -60. +19,774,230 -In essence, s. 54(1) prohibits a person or entity from supplying a product at a price that +19,774,230 -exceeds the lowest of two or more clearly expressed prices at the time the product is supplied. +19,774,230 -61. +19,774,230 -Paragraph 54(1)(b) extends +19,774,230 -to Maplebear’s double +19,774,230 -ticketing practices and +50.6 -misrepresentations in failing to disclose on the Instacart.ca website or mobile application that the +31.9 -cost of orders initially indicated placed at the third stage of the transactional process does not +31.8 -represent the actual cost of the order to be charged to customers including Plaintiff and Class +8.8 -Members. +8.1 -62. +4.9 -Paragraph 54(1)(c) extends +4.8 -to Maplebear’s double +4.5 -ticketing practices and +4.1 -misrepresentations in displays and advertisements appearing on the point of purchase – the +3.9 -Instacart.ca website and mobile app – with respect to the fact that the initially indicated cost of +3.6 -orders placed thereon for “products” ordered from retailers via the website or app does not +3.6 -represent the actual cost of the order to be charged to Plaintiff and Class Members. +3.5 -63. +3.2 -Subsection 2(1) defines “product” to an “article” and a “service”; in relation to a service, +3.2 -“supply” means to “sell, rent, or otherwise provide a service or offer so to provide a service.” +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Video, 0 secs Qualifier, February 2020, People 18+, Computer, Unique Audience, Population Base, Reach % +*Brands marked with an asterisk represent metrics from tagged methodology. 14 - 64. - -The Defendants’ practices also contravene s. 52 of the Competition Act, the relevant parts - -of which read as follows: - -False or misleading representations -52 (1) No person shall, for the purpose of -promoting, directly or indirectly, the supply -or use of a product or for the purpose of -promoting, directly or -indirectly, any -business interest, by any means whatever, -knowingly -a -representation to the public that is false or -misleading in a material respect. - -recklessly make - -or - -Proof of certain matters not required -(1.1) For greater certainty, in establishing -that subsection (1) was contravened, it is not -necessary to prove that -(a) any person was deceived or misled; -(b) any member of the public to whom the -representation was made was within -Canada; or -(c) the representation was made in a place to -which the public had access. - -[…] - -that - -Drip pricing -(1.3) For greater certainty, the making of a -is not -representation of a price -attainable due to fixed obligatory charges or -fees constitutes a -false or misleading -representation, unless the obligatory charges -or fees represent only an amount imposed on -a purchaser of the product referred to in -subsection (1) by or under an Act of -Parliament or the legislature of a province. - -Indications fausses ou trompeuses -52 (1) Nul ne peut, de quelque manière que ce -soit, aux fins de promouvoir directement ou -indirectement soit la fourniture ou l’utilisation -d’un produit, soit des intérêts commerciaux -quelconques, donner au public, sciemment ou -sans -soucier des conséquences, des -indications fausses ou trompeuses sur un point -important. - -se - -Preuve non nécessaire -(1.1) Il est entendu qu’il n’est pas nécessaire, -afin d’établir qu’il y a eu infraction au -paragraphe (1), de prouver : -a) qu’une personne a été trompée ou induite en -erreur; -b) qu’une personne faisant partie du public à -qui les indications ont été données se trouvait -au Canada; -c) que les indications ont été données à un -endroit auquel le public avait accès. - -Indication de prix partiel -(1.3) Il est entendu que l’indication d’un prix -qui n’est pas atteignable en raison de frais -obligatoires fixes qui s’y ajoutent constitue une -indication fausse ou trompeuse, sauf si les frais -obligatoires ne représentent que le montant -imposé sous le régime d’une loi fédérale ou -provinciale à l’acquéreur du produit visé au -paragraphe (1). - -65. - -In the present case, the “fixed obligatory charges or fees” charged by the Defendants are - -not “imposed on a purchased… by or under an Act of Parliament or the legislature of a - -province.” - -15 - - 66. - -Incidentally, it should be noted that Maplebear’s practice of adding several types of fees - -to the costs of each order at the fourth stage of the transactional process that increases the price - -initially advertised at the third stage constitutes “drip pricing” within the meaning of ss. 74(1.1) - -of the Competition Act. - -67. - -Subsection 74(1.1) falls under Part VII.1 of the Act, which is entitled “Deceptive - -Marketing Practices” and reads as follows: - -Drip pricing -(1.1) For greater certainty, the making of a -representation of a price that is not attainable -due -to fixed obligatory charges or fees -constitutes a false or misleading representation, -unless the obligatory charges or fees represent -only an amount imposed by or under an Act of -Parliament or the legislature of a province. - -Indication de prix partiel -(1.1) Il est entendu que l’indication d’un prix -qui n’est pas atteignable en raison de frais -obligatoires fixes qui s’y ajoutent constitue une -indication fausse ou trompeuse, sauf si les frais -obligatoires ne représentent que le montant -imposé sous le régime d’une loi fédérale ou -provinciale. - -68. - -However, under para. 36(1)(b), a private right of action in respect of anti-competitive acts - -falling within s. 74(1.1) is only available if the Competition Tribunal issues an order in respect of - -same and the entity subject to the order fails to comply with it.1 - -69. - -As a result, the Plaintiff’s claims under the Competition Act are, as stated, limited to - -remedies under para. 36(1)(a) in respect of the false and/or misleading representations prohibited - -under s. 52(1) and 54. - -70. - -Note that Instacart continues to engage in these problematic practices even after settling a +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -class action limited to Quebec residents on the same issue: see Medalsy c. Maplebear inc., 2025 +l +l -QCCS 199. +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© -1 See e.g., Pro-Sys Consultants Ltd. v. Microsoft Corporation, 2006 BCSC 1047, at para. 45, and Pro-Sys -Consultants Ltd. v. Microsoft Corporation, 2014 BCSC 1281, at para. 37. Conclusions in respect of ss. 78 and 79 of -the Competition Act, which apply mutatis mutandis to s. 74(1.1) +i +i -16 G. +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C - REMEDIES + Streaming Video Report - Tagged - 2 secs -Compensatory Damages +Name -71. +SWM 7 -The Plaintiff and each Class Member has suffered legally-cognizable and compensable +news.com.au -injuries and loss as a direct and proximate result of Maplebear’s unlawful, tortious, and +nine.com.au -inequitable conduct. +9Now -72. +Daily Mail Australia -The fundamental purpose of the law of compensatory damages is that the Plaintiff is to be +Network 10 -compensated to the extent of the harm or loss suffered as a result of the Defendant’s conduct +Whimn -(restitutio in integrum). +taste.com.au -73. +SBS (Special Broadcasting Service) -The Plaintiff claims on her own behalf and of that of Class Members the amount +perthnow -corresponding to the difference between the delivery fee advertised for the delivery service +The Daily Telegraph -option they respectively selected and the delivery fee actually charged by Maplebear. +couriermail.com.au -Statutory Damages +AdelaideNow -74. +Herald Sun -The Plaintiff and Class Members are entitled to damages and the costs of investigation of +THE AUSTRALIAN -their losses pursuant to s. 36 of the Competition Act for the Defendants’ violation of ss. 52 and +UA -54 thereof. +Pop Base -Punitive Damages +Reach % -75. +3,491,937 -The Plaintiff seeks on her own behalf, and of that of Class Members, punitive or +2,689,535 -exemplary damages for the Defendants’ conduct at issue in the present proposed class action. +1,936,015 -76. +1,904,222 -The said conduct displayed serious negligence, carelessness, and ignorance, and was +1,431,763 -oppressive, callous, high-handed, wilful, outrageous, deliberate, wanton, reckless, and in total +1,238,902 -disregard for the rights and interests of Plaintiff and Class Members. +587,609 -17 77. +431,831 -Note that Instacart continues to engage in these problematic practices even after settling a +404,486 -class action limited to Quebec residents on the same issue: see Medalsy c. Maplebear inc., 2025 +387,648 -QCCS 199. +303,779 -78. +275,778 -The Plaintiff asserts that an award of punitive damages is required to denounce and +165,451 -condemn the Defendants’ shocking and outrageous conduct and to deter further breaches by the +161,710 -Defendant and/or others. +115,625 -COMMON ISSUES +19,774,230 -79. +19,774,230 -The present proposed class action raises the following common issues: +19,774,230 -i. +19,774,230 -Did Maplebear structure the transaction process on the Instacart website and mobile +19,774,230 -application to charge Plaintiff and Class Members an amount higher than the price +19,774,230 -initially indicated? +19,774,230 -ii. +19,774,230 -Is Maplebear’s representation of the total cost of orders placed on the Instacart.ca +19,774,230 -website and mobile application false, misleading, or deceptive to reasonable +19,774,230 -consumers? +19,774,230 -iii. +19,774,230 -iv. +19,774,230 -v. +19,774,230 -vi. +19,774,230 -Did Maplebear commit the tort of fraudulent or negligent misrepresentation? +18 -Did Plaintiff and Class Members incur economic loss? +14 -Did Maplebear become unjustly enriched as a result of the above-listed conduct? +10 -Did Maplebear violate s. 52 of the Competition Act? +10 -vii. +7 -Did Maplebear violate s. 54 of the Competition Act? +6 -viii. +3 -Are Plaintiff and Class Members entitled to damages and the costs of investigation +2 -under s. 36 of the Competition Act? +2 -ix. +2 -Are Plaintiff and Class Members entitled to restitution to Class Members in an +2 -amount equivalent to all fees charged and paid for that were not announced before +1 -the checkout phase of the transactional process? +1 -18 VENUE +1 -80. +1 -The Plaintiff proposes that the present class action be tried in Ottawa, Ontario. +Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Tagged, Video, 2 secs Qualifier ,Ad Supported (Video), February 2020, People 18+, Digital (C/M), Unique Audience, Population +Base, Reach % -DATE: February 12, 2025 +15 -CONSUMER LAW GROUP P.C. -150 Elgin Street, 10th Floor - Ottawa, Ontario K2P 1L4 -Tel: (613) 627-4894 -Fax: (613) 627-4893 +. +. + +e +e +t +t +u +u +b +b +i +i +r +r +t +t +s +s +i +i +d +d +t +t +o +o +n +n +o +o +D +D + +. +. +y +y +r +r +a +a +t +t +e +e +i +i +r +r +p +p +o +o +r +r +p +p +d +d +n +n +a +a -Jeff Orenstein (LSO No. 59631G) - Lawrence David (LSO No. 69517L) +l +l - Lawyers for the Plaintiff +a +a +i +i +t +t +n +n +e +e +d +d +fi +fi +n +n +o +o +C +C + +. +. + +C +C +L +L +L +L + +, +, +) +) +S +S +U +U + +( +( + +y +y +n +n +a +a +p +p +m +m +o +o +C +C +n +n +e +e +s +s +l +l +e +e +N +N +e +e +h +h +T +T +9 +9 +1 +1 +0 +0 +2 +2 +© +© + +i +i + +t +t +h +h +g +g +i +i +r +r +y +y +p +p +o +o +C +C -19 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q24/random_k2/question.json b/q24/random_k2/question.json index 54b3369b648c2008a1b183c378b6be38d8f94134..60cb9d005d8892efc32dd474a4a77651b6c08264 100644 --- a/q24/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q24/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2024.ug.eprospectus.pdf", - "web_365d195edde4e8ba.pdf", - "web_d44e9a235a572259.pdf" + "web_93a0de1d8da7a0cf.pdf", + "resize_r2_11.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q24/random_k2/random_1.md b/q24/random_k2/random_1.md index 5526b8c35c6c0d7d05b7d26b15fce08f69e7eb06..a334b8d779333a86838d9effd3dd99b5ea050aa5 100644 --- a/q24/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q24/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1865 +1,704 @@ -Morgan Stanley Investment Management +SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING -Asset Management Overview + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING -July 2006 - -Page +W H A T T H I S S E S S I O N W I L L C O V E R 1 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - The information provided herein may include certain non-GAAP financial measures. -The reconciliation of such measures to the comparable GAAP figures are included in -the Company’s Annual Reports on Form 10-K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q and -Current Reports on 8-K, including any amendments thereto, which are available at -www.morganstanley.com. - -This presentation may contain forward-looking statements. You are cautioned not to -place undue reliance on forward-looking statements, which speak only as of the date -on which they are made, which reflect management’s current estimates, projections, -expectations or beliefs and which are subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause -actual results to differ materially. For a discussion of risks and uncertainties that may -affect the future results of the Company, please see “Forward-Looking Statements” -immediately preceding Part I, Item 1, “Competition” and “Regulation” in Part I, Item 1, -“Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A and “Certain Factors Affecting Results of Operations” -in Part II, Item 7 of the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year -ended November 30, 2005, “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial -Condition and Results of Operations” in the Company’s Quarterly Reports on Form 10- -Q for the quarterly periods ended February 28, 2006 and May 31, 2006 and other items -throughout the Form 10-K, Form 10-Qs and the Company’s 2006 Current Reports on -Form 8-K. - -Page - 2 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Table of contents - -Section 1 - -Strengths of MSIM Today - -Section 2 - -MSIM Growth Strategy - -Page - 3 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Section 1 - -Strengths of MSIM Today - -Page - 4 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Is a Key Business of Morgan Stanley - -Morgan Stanley - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Net revenues -Fiscal year 2005=$26,778 million - -19% - -Asset -Management -11% - -12% - -Profit before taxes -Fiscal year 2005=$7,361 million - -8% - -Asset -Management -14% - -65% - -13% - -58% - -Profit before taxes -$ million - -1,007 - -827 - -482 - -462 - -396 - -Institutional Securities Global Wealth Management - -Asset Management Discover - -Asset Management - -Pre-tax profit margin - -30% - -26% - -35% - -29% - -28% - -25% - -22% - -21% - -Return on average -common equity - -36% - -24% - -23% - -17% - -FY 2003 - -FY 2004 - -FY 2005 - -1st Half -2006 - -(1) - -FY 2003 - -FY 2004 - -FY 2005 - -1st Half 2006 - -(1) - -FY 2005 - -1st Half 2006 - -(1) - -MSIM - -MSIM excl. Private Equity - -MSIM - -Morgan Stanley - -1. Six months ended May 31 - -Page - 5 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Key Strengths - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -• Strong brand recognition - -– Morgan Stanley - -– Van Kampen - -• Global footprint - -• Scale - -• Breadth of products - -• Multiple channels of distribution - -• Community of boutiques - -• Full firm commitment and resources - -Page - 6 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Has a Global Footprint - -Products and Distribution - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -New York - -Amsterdam - -Stockholm - -Oakbrook Terrace - -Boston - -London - -Paris - -Frankfurt - -Luxembourg - -San Francisco -Menlo Park - -Houston +What is social media marketing and why is it important -Jersey City +Social media landscape -West Conshohocken +Social media marketing – use cases and benefits -Milan +What does good look like? -Madrid +How to execute a campaign + a club success story -Mumbai +Do’s and Don’ts + additional resources -Hong Kong - -Tokyo - -Singapore - -Melbourne - -MSIM Office Present - -MSIM Distribution Coverage - -Page - -7 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. +2 - STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY + WHAT IS SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING? -Assets ($ billion) +D E S C R I P T I O N -1,513 +The use of social +networks, content +sharing apps, +messaging platforms, +blogs, and forums to +connect with and enable +meaningful +conversations about +your brand, product or +service, to ultimately +drive your business +objective. -1,439 +3 -1,422 + WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? -• In June 2006, Pensions and -Investments ranked Morgan -Stanley #11 by worldwide -assets +C U S T O M E R E X P E C T A T I O N S H A V E C H A N G E D -• MSIM’s strength is in +2X -traditional, actively managed -investments +customers are twice as likely to +share a negative experience with a +business than a positive one -MSIM Has The Scale to Succeed +90% -Top 20 money managers +will look at online +reviews before making +a purchase -Pensions and Investments, June 2006 +74% -Ranking +trust suggestions from +”friends” on social media -1 +67% -2 +of people will spend money after +getting recommendations from +their “friends” online -3 +Sources: White House Office of Consumer Affairs, McKinsey, Experian |24|7, Gigya, CEI 4 -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 + WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? -16 +N E W T R E N D S A R E E M E R G I N G C H A N G I N G T H E U S A G E A N D I M P O R T A N C E O F S O C I A L -17 +Understanding the social media space and managing your social presence amplifies your marketing +strategy. Social media delivers invaluable insight into your brand awareness, customer sentiment, +marketplace trends, and your competitor’s actions, whilst enabling you to reach more prospects than any +other marketing channel. -18 +Every negative social interaction has a cost -19 +Customers are content creators -20 +Brands are turning online influencers into advocates -Barclays Global +Social is now a prominent point of purchase -State Street Global +Brand focus is shifting to measuring quality of interactions -Fidelity Investments +Reviews can increase sales and add credibility -Vanguard Group +Social is multifunctional – used for marketing, listening, +response, customer care, troubleshooting -Legg Mason +5 -Capital Research + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE -JPMorgan Asset Mgmt. +T H E K E Y P L A Y E R S -Mellon Financial +The social media landscape is large and +complex and cluttered with competing +platforms, but the most heavily utilised +for marketing are the big 4: -Deutsche Asset Mgmt. +Facebook (FB, Instagram, +Messenger) -Northern Trust Global +Google (YouTube) -Morgan Stanley +Twitter -PIMCO +LinkedIn -UBS Global Asset Mgmt. +6 -AllianceBernstein Inst'l + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE -AIG Global Investment +D I F F E R E N T C H A N N E L S A R E U S E D F O R D I F F E R E N T P U R P O S E S -Merrill Lynch +Social networks +Relationship networks help brands and people connect to share +information and ideas. With a large & regular user base, they are a must- +have and the ”mass-market” approach to social marketing. -Prudential Financial +Use for: customer care, education, daily comms, breaking news -ING +Messaging & chat apps -Wellington Mgmt. +Most widely used apps that enable messaging, video and voice calls. Business +can conduct e-commerce conversations via live agents or chatbots. -Goldman Sachs Asset +Use for: customer care, conversational commerce, payments, status updates, +to replace SMS -958 +Media & content sharing +networks -864 +Find and share media online, including photos, video, and live video or other +curated content. -858 +Consumer review +networks +Manage online reviews and reputation. Positive reviews bring social proof to +your value proposition. Negative reviews provide you with an opportunity to +resolve an issue publicly. -842 +Use for: brand awareness, lead generation, audience engagement, targeted +advertising, influencer marketing -781 +Use for: customer care, reputation management, market research -633 +Blogs & forums +Publish, find, discuss, and share news, information, and opinions. Usually allow +users to remain anonymous, leading to more honest opinions. -618 +Interest-based networks +Help connect with others around a shared interest or hobby and tend to focus +solely on a single subject and provide a dedicated experience for users. -599 +Use for: market research, influencer marketing, product advertising, SEO +results -594 +Use for: targeted marketing, brand awareness, trend watching -581 +7 -579 + SOCIAL MARKETING USE CASES -572 +H O W T O U S E S O C I A L T O M E E T Y O U R O B J E C T I V E S -537 +Manage +own page -531 +Generate +insights -523 +Nurture community +& reputation -521 +Engage with +customers -496 +Grow through +amplification -Investment type: +Draft and publish organic +content to owned +page(s) -T ra dit io na l +Define and manage +content strategy and +calendar -A lt e rna t iv e s +Manage content +approvals -Inde x +Listen/capture social +conversations about LTA, +coaches, or venues and +identify trends -0 +Keep up with competitors +and stay informed of their +social engagement, +content and campaigns -250 +Understand target +audience demographics, +sentiment, and channel +preferences -500 +Grow your community of +social followers and +supporters -750 +Find and nurture +advocates and +influencers who can +credibly promote your +brand to an extended +audience -1,000 +Identify and manage +potential crises -1,250 +Respond to consumer +problems when they +have questions or +concerns -1,500 +Be part of the +conversations about your +venues, coaches or +brand -1,750 +React with relevant +content – use what you +see and hear to help +inform future marketing +strategy -Source: Total assets are from June 2006 Pensions and Investments, using year end 2005 data. Morgan Stanley assets reflect Morgan Stanley consolidated assets -at fiscal year end 2005. Investment types, which are derived from June 2006 Pension and Investments and July 2006 Institutional Investors, are for comparison -purposes +Push paid content to +custom audiences to reach +your marketing objectives -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. +Identify and amplify +relevant user content for +authentic engagement -Page +Social commerce – +increasing number of +businesses are using +social as a payment +channel 8 - MSIM Organization 2006 - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Investment expertise is - -organized around investment -product areas - -• Distribution is organized - -around clients - -John Mack -Firm CEO - -Bob Scully -Firm Co-President + THE BENEFITS OF SOCIAL -Owen Thomas -MSIM President, COO +W H A T S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G C A N D O F O R Y O U -Investments +1. -U.S. & Americas Distribution +Strengthen your +brand reputation -Non-Americas +2. -• Focused on communicating -effectively among the groups +Grow your +business -Dennis Shea -Head and CIO, -Global Equity +3. -David Germany -Head and CIO, -Global -Fixed Income +Care for your +customers -Stuart Bohart -Head and CIO, -Alternatives +Know & act on what is being said about +you +• Things escalate quickly on social. By -Michael Kiley -Head of Americas -Retail & -Intermediary -Distribution +listening to key phrases that relate to your +brand or activity you can be the first to +know when a news story breaks and react +accordingly. -Open -Head of -U.S. Institutional -Distribution +• Social insights also give you an unbiased -Michael Green -Head of MSIM -Non-Americas +view of your brand awareness and +popularity. -Kenneth Winston -Chief Risk Officer +Identify trends +• Trends appear on social media first. Social -• Decentralized, with all -components of the -organization accountable for -financial results +can make or break a product. -Attracting new talent -Internal +• Listening to industry thought-leadership +supports your research and innovation -• Head and CIO Global Equity +Stay ahead of competition +• Your competitors are on social. Analysing -• Head and CIO Alternatives +their social presence delivers unique +insight into their plans and achievements +• Regular benchmarking of your competitors -• Head of Operations +on social helps you keep up with them -• Two investment teams: +Amplify owned content +• Social enables you to publish targeted -External +content to channels that could be seen by +large volumes of users -• CIO London Equity +• The power of influencer marketing -• Two investment teams in Absolute Return Strategies +provides a human voice to your product -• Process-Driven team +Generate earned media +• Customers are 56% more likely to buy a +product or service after seeing a positive +customer-generated post of it -• Global Mid-Cap Equity Market Neutral team +• By reposting user-generated content on +your owned channels, you increase the +trust in your brand and products -• Defined Value team, Absolute Return Strategies +Deliver incremental sales +• Advertising on social media is cheaper +than traditional media (such as TV ads) +but with a massive reach -• Structured Products and Derivatives team +• The main difference is that you will be -• Pension Asset/Liability expertise +able to target finely who sees what advert, +increasing your conversion while keeping +costs down -• Global Infrastructure sector expertise +Create experiences +• Social is more than just advertising, it’s an +educational, emotional and experiential +way to engage your customers -• Six investment professionals: +• Customers no longer want to phone when -• European Senior Loans +they have an issue, they want an +immediate answer and turn to social. -• Alternative Investment Partners +Reduce cost to serve +• With customised chatbots and the use of +artificial intelligence on the rise, in-app +messaging is becoming the norm for +customer care -• Global Value +• Technology solutions enable improved -• International Value +customer service through social -Page +Build a community +• Customers trust each other more than +you. Providing them with a platform +where they can interact and share +feedback will increase their trust and +loyalty to your brand, coaches, or venues. 9 -• Senior U.S. Institutional sales professional - -• Head of Morgan Stanley Funds Distribution - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - -• Senior Middle East sales professional - - • MSIM offers a broad array of -traditional products and is -increasing its offering of -alternative products - -• MSIM utilizes multiple - -channels of distribution -globally leveraging the -Morgan Stanley brand and -resources where possible - -MSIM Product and Distribution Balance + WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY +H O W T O W I N W I T H S O C I A L M E D I A -May 31, 2006 Ending AUM/AUS = $440 billion +A great social media strategy includes the following pillars: -Asset Class +SOCIAL MEDIA +PILLARS -3% 3% +Emotional content -5% +Build rapport with your customers. Forget transactional posts +and focus on posting content that showcases how you will make +a difference in your customers’ life -Distribution +Consistency -20% +Your content should match your brand identity and objectives +and be consistent across channels. -22% +Regular & well- +timed posts -17% +Just like any other channel, there is a better time to post content, +and that varies depending on the network and audience. Keep +your customers interested by posting often and sharing varied +content -21% +Two-way +engagement -51% +Social is about more than just pushing out content. Allow your +customers to interact with you and make sure you respond to +create a differentiated experience -Equity +Optimisation -Fixed Income +Test, learn, adjust, repeat. Iteration is key to success and social +is no different. Plan for A/B testing and track success of +individual campaigns and performance across platforms -Money Market +Personalisation -Alternatives +Strategic use of +channels -Real Estate +Use social insights to know who your customers are and adapt +your messaging, including graphics and tone of voice to target +the right customers with the right message at the right time -Unit Investment Trusts +Not all channels will be relevant to your brand. Whilst a presence +on the Big 4 is a must, focusing your budget and efforts on the +channels where your customers are the most active will deliver +better value for money -23% +Overall strategy +alignment -20% - -15% - -Americas Retail-Morgan Stanley Branded - -Americas Retail-Van Kampen Branded - -Americas Intermediary - -U.S. Institutional - -Non-U.S. - -Page +Driving revenue and engagement from social does require +investment. Incorporate social as its own channel into your +overall strategy, budget and resources 10 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Offers Clients a Broad Product Array - -Key Product Type by Investment Group - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Global Fixed Income -J. David Germany, CIO -AUM=$166 billion (1) - -• Core/Core Plus -• Long Duration -• Mortgage -• Corporate -• Targeted Duration -• Intermediate Duration - -• High Yield -• Short Duration -• Enhanced LIBOR - -• Customized -• Global/International -• Emerging Markets Debt - -• Institutional Liquidity -• Enhanced Cash -• Retail Money Markets - -Global Equity -Dennis Shea, CIO -AUM=$241 billion (1) - -U.S. Equity -• U.S. Small-, Mid-, Multi-, and Large-Cap - -Value - -• U.S. Small-, Mid-, Multi-, and Large-Cap - -Growth - -• U.S. Large-Cap Core -• Systematic Active Equity -• Global REITs (U.S./European/Asian) -• Sector Funds - -Global/International Equity -• International Value -• International Growth -• International Small-Cap -• Global Emerging Markets -• Global Core -• Global Small- and Large-Cap Value -• Global Systematic Active Equity -• European -• Japan (Small-Cap, Value, Growth, Core) -• Asian (ex. Japan) and Pacific Basin - -Asset Allocation -• Balanced Funds -• Global Tactical Asset Allocation - -– Fully Funded - -– Global Macro - -1. Ending AUM/AUS as of May 31, 2006 - -Alternatives -Stuart Bohart, CIO -AUM=$20 billion (1) - -• Absolute Return Strategies (Hedge Funds) - -– Quantitative Equity Strategies -– Fundamental Equity Strategies -– Global Macro Strategies - -• Alternative Investment Partners - -– Fund of Hedge Funds -– Fund of Private Equity Funds -– Insurance Dedicated Fund of Hedge - -Funds - -– Portable Alpha - -• Senior Loans - -− Collateralized Loan Obligations - -• Structured Products and Derivatives - -• Managed Futures - -• Private Equity - -Unit Trusts -AUS=$13 billion (1) - -• Unit Investment Trusts - -Page + WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? + +P U T T I N G S O C I A L M E D I A P I L L A R S I N T O P R A C T I S E + +Conversational & Engaging Content – +Royal Academy & Aldi + +Influencer & Interest-based Marketing – +Gymshark & Wilson + +Royal Academy uses relatable and +humourous posts and interactive +campaigns such as their +#RAdailydoodle to keep their 441K +Twitter followers engaged, drawing +increased user participation and +personalised well-crafted responses + +Aldi UK celebrated their birthday with +a simple, yet creative invitation to +engage competitors, generating a ton +of interest on Twitter and a positive +response, well-tracked via their +unique hashtag +#Aldi30thBirthdayParty + +Gymshark sponsors key Instagram +influencers to capitalise on their large +audiences (500k+). They also use paid +social as a primary means to drive +sales, and in 2019 saw a £73m increase +in turnover. In 2017, their Black Friday +posts drew a 6.6x return on ad spend. + +Influencer marketing can also reap +benefits on a smaller scale. Like the +Germany-based Tennis Siblings Alex +& Sofi, who are sponsored by Wilson +and adidas and use their modest +following of 15K to promote products +and local tennis tournaments. 11 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Utilizes a Multi-Channel Distribution Approach - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Core Distribution -Channels - -Customer Tiers - -Americas Retail- -Morgan Stanley Branded - -Americas Retail- -Van Kampen Branded - -Americas Intermediary - -U.S. Institutional - -Non-U.S. - -Morgan Stanley Global -Wealth Management - -• Financial Advisors - -• Private Wealth -Management -Investment -Representatives - -• Broker Dealers - -• Banks - -• Investment Advisors - -• Intermediaries - -• Banks - -• Financial Planners - -• Consultants -• Corporations -• Public Plans -• Foundations -/Endowments - -• Insurance General - -Accounts/ Financial -Institutions - -• Consultants - -• Corporations - -• Public Plans - -• Private Banks - -• Intermediaries - -Core Investment -Vehicles/Products - -Morgan Stanley Brand - -Van Kampen Brand - -Van Kampen Brand - -• Separate Accounts + EXECUTING A CAMPAIGN - WHERE TO START -• Separate Accounts +G E T T I N G T H E B A S I C S R I G H T -• Mutual Funds - -• Mutual Funds - -• Mutual Funds - -• Pooled Trust - -• Liquidity Products - -• Institutional Funds - -• Variable Annuities - -• Platform Business - -• Liquidity Products - -• Société - -• Affiliated Separately -Managed Accounts - -• Variable Annuities - -• Alternative -Investments - -• Unit Investment Trusts +2 -• Alternative -Investments +Identify your audience +and grow followers -• External Separately -Managed Accounts +Start following your members and +people who “look like” them (e.g. +have similar demo, interests, +location, etc.) -• Alternative -Investments +Plan a content calendar and post a +variety of engaging content +including text, photo, and video. -• Variable Annuities +Track performance to see what +content resonates best with your +audience. -• Institutional Funds +3 -• Unit Investment Trusts +Launch and track your +campaign -Morgan Stanley Brand +You can begin with a simple +campaign – such as amplifying a +piece of existing content that +performed well with your existing +followers. -• Institutional Funds +Set up campaigns by objective +(page likes, clicks, etc.) and set a +daily or monthly budget. -• Liquidity Products +Use built-in dashboards from the +social platforms to review +performance and optimise by ad +frequency, time of day, ad format, +and more. -• Société +1 -d'investissement à -Capital Variable -(SICAV) Funds +Set up your account +page(s) -Sub-Advised +Establish your presence by +setting up business account / club +page across the relevant social +platforms -• Mutual Funds +Include essential business +information for search purposes, +including: Location, Contact info, +and Website URL -d'investissement à -Capital Variable -(SICAV) Funds +#Tip: use hashtags to +start a conversation with +your members and easily +follow what they say about +you and your club -• Alternative -Investments +4 -• Investment Trust +Scale up and add on +to master social -Management -Company (ITM) Funds +Once you have your first campaign +under your belt, report on your +performance and measure against +your original business KPIs. -Ending AUM/AUS -As of May 31, 2006 +Refresh your content and launch +new campaigns for different target +audiences. -Page +Explore and introduce more +complex functionality available to +you, including new data sources, +more robust tracking (e.g. FB pixel), +new ad formats, or new social +platforms. 12 -$96 billion - -$90 billion - -$67 billion - -$98 billion - -$89 billion - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - • Performance is key to driving growth - -MSIM Investment Performance + CLUB SUCCESS STORY -• On February 22nd, 2006, Barron’s +N O R B U R Y P A R K L T C -U.S. Mutual Funds Performance +SITUATION -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY +Norbury Park LTC was established in 1889 in the London Borough of Croydon. It +has four floodlit tarmac courts and a small management committee made up +entirely of volunteers. Club membership was at an all-time low so the committee +put together an action plan to significantly increase membership within a year. -annual ranking placed MSIM +APPROACH -– 30th out of 65 fund families for 1- +The club recruited a volunteer Marketing and Communications Officer and decided +to run a Nature Valley Big Tennis Weekend (open day) to showcase the club’s +facilities to the local community and engage prospects. -year performance +Using free resources and content available on My Tennis Toolkit, they created a +Facebook event and advert with a call-to-action to sign up for taster sessions. -– 24th out of 56 for 5-year +OUTCOME -performance +£24 +spent on +Facebook +campaign -– 4th out of 40 for 10-year +Reaching +~3000 target +audience (local +and interested in +tennis) -performance +145 declared +engagements +on FB event +page -– The 1-year rankings placed MSIM +Converted to 69 +bookings – +roughly 80% of +all total +attendees! -outpacing Vanguard, Franklin +Drove an overall increase in club membership by 10% -Templeton, JPMorgan and Putnam - -• On July 5th, 2006, Wall Street Journal - -named seven MSIM funds as "Category - -Kings": +13 -Large-Cap Growth + MEASURING PERFORMANCE -– Morgan Stanley Institutional Focus +A Q U I C K L O O K A T F A C E B O O K A D M A N A G E R -Equity +#Tip: Don’t be intimidated by complexity. +There are tons of available resources online +that offer step-by-step instructions for setting +up a campaign. -% Long-Term Fund Assets Above Lipper Median +Source: Adspresso by Hootsuiite -67% +14 -61% + DO’S AND DON'TS -60% +F O R S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G -48% +DO -71% +Have a social media presence! Today’s consumers expect to be able to find +brands on social media -59% +Pick the right social platforms that best align with your brand, audience and your +marketing goals – whether it’s Instagram, YouTube, or Twitter -61% +Take advantage of free resources and training available to you – including My +Tennis Toolkit, Facebook Blueprint, and Google Marketing Platform -63% +Follow your competitors. See what others are doing well, and find out how you +can differentiate yourself and appeal to those audiences -71% +Get creative! Use social media to find influencers or other unique ways to connect +and engage with your audience -71% +DON’T -76% +…forget to publish content regularly. By maintaining your presence you’ll stay top of +mind with members when they are looking for a coach or venue -76% +…be afraid to launch a social media marketing campaign. You can start small and +build and refine as you learn -1 Year +15 -3 Year + ADDITIONAL RESOURCES -5 Year +H E L P F U L L I N K S T O G E T Y O U S T A R T E D -Aug'05 +LTA Marketing Guides and materials: +https://www.lta.org.uk/workforce-venues/tennis-venue-support/membership-growth-and- +retention/membership-growth/ -Nov'05 +My Tennis Toolkit (includes creative assets for social media): +https://www.lta.org.uk/globalassets/venue/my-tennis-toolkit-usage-guide.pdf -Feb'06 +Facebook Blueprint - free online courses for business marketing: +https://www.facebook.com/business/learn -May'06 +Instagram Advertising: +https://business.instagram.com/advertising -% Rated Assets with Morningstar 4/5-Star Rating +Twitter Advertising: +https://business.twitter.com/en/advertising.html +https://blog.hootsuite.com/twitter-ads/ -– Morgan Stanley Institutional U.S. +LinkedIn Advertising: +https://business.linkedin.com/marketing-solutions/ads +https://blog.hootsuite.com/linkedin-ads-guide/ -47% +Measurement / Tracking: +Google Analytics Academy: https://analytics.google.com/analytics/academy/ +Google Ad Manager: https://skillshop.exceedlms.com/student/path/34897-drive-advertising-revenue- +with-google-ad-manager -45% +16 -Large Cap Growth + ANY QUESTIONS? -– Morgan Stanley Growth - -Multicap Growth - -– Morgan Stanley Capital - -Opportunities - -– Morgan Stanley Aggressive Equity - -Pacific Region - -– Morgan Stanley Pacific Growth - -Real Estate - -– Morgan Stanley Institutional - -International Real Estate - -Page - -13 - -39% - -39% - -Aug'05 - -Nov'05 - -Feb'06 - -May'06 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Section 2 - -MSIM Growth Strategy - -Page - -14 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Growth Strategy - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -Our Strategy for Growth - -Critical Initiatives - -• Increase value of Morgan Stanley’s Asset - -• Build alternatives capability - -Management business - -— PBT growth - -— Multiple (P/E) expansion by - -• Create new traditional products using existing -capabilities and through lift-outs / acquisitions - -• Expand non-U.S. footprint: distribution and - -demonstrating net sales and AUM growth - -products - -• Focus on revenue growth and diversification - -• Invest in Van Kampen - Intermediary and Unit - -by investing in the business - -Investment Trusts growth - -— People - -— Acquisitions - -— Infrastructure - -• Leverage Morgan Stanley franchise and - -MSIM scale and positioning - -• Enhance traditional product strength and build - -Alternatives - -• Performance, performance, performance - -• Stem outflows of Morgan Stanley retail mutual - -funds - -• Rebuild institutional reputation and business, - -particularly in the U.S. - -Page - -15 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Build a Much Broader Alternatives Capability - -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -What We’re Doing - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• The Alternative Investments - -group is composed of 4 distinct -groups: - -– Absolute Return Strategies - -(ARS) - -– Alternative Investment - -Partners (AIP) - -– Senior Loans - -– Structured Products and - -Derivatives (SP&D) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Internal transfer of Structured -Products and Derivatives team - -• Completed lift-out of Process-Driven - -Strategies team - -• Launched / incubated 6 new - -alternative investment products - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Hired Stuart Bohart as the head and - -CIO of Alternatives - -• Completed Oxhead Capital - -acquisition - -• Internal transfer of Defined Value - -team - -• Internal transfer of sector expertise - -to run the global infrastructure -initiative (initiated June 2006) - -• Launched Japanese Equities Market - -Neutral product - -• Re-opened Traxis to new investors - -Absolute Return Strategies - -• Continue efforts on lift-out / -acquisitions, and minority -stakes to build business - -Alternative Investment Partners -• Expand AIP product line and - -introduce new funds - -• Distribution focus on smaller - -mid-market and high net worth - -Senior Loans - -• Growth driven by client focused - -new products through -introduction of funds, -Collateralized Loan Obligations, -Separately Managed Accounts - -Structured Products and -Derivatives - -• Develop custom approaches to - -build structured products -• Introduce Liability Driven - -Investments - -Page - -16 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Enhance Traditional Product Offerings - -Through both Organic Launches and Bolt-on Acquisitions/Lift-Outs -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -• Many top performing equity -strategies at or near capacity - -• Fixed Income products with -improved performance, and -capacity - -• Good performing strategies - -building three year track records - -• Product gaps in large asset - -gathering categories - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 5 new - -equity products - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 8 new - -products - -– 7 Equity -– 1 Fixed Income - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -What We’re Doing - -Organic launches - -• Leverage current talent pool to - -build out strong product -pipeline - -Acquisitions / lift-outs - -• Targeted acquisitions / lift-outs -to complement our existing -product line - -Page +THANK YOU 17 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Expand Non-U.S. Footprint - -Distribution and products - -What We Have - -• $89 billion, or 20% of MSIM - -AUM/AUS is sourced from non- -U.S.(1) - -• MSIM is represented in 13 non- - -U.S. countries - -• Outside of the U.S., portfolio - -managers are located in: - -– Europe -– Japan -– Singapore -– India - -What We’ve Done - -First Quarter 2006 -• Increased distribution focus on - -Alternatives - -• Signed a global agreement with - -Merrill Lynch Global Private -Client division to distribute MSIM -products through Merrill Lynch's -International distribution network -worldwide - -Second Quarter 2006 -Middle East -• Hired sales head -• Leveraging Firm’s Dubai office - -China -• Dedicated sales hire -• Applied (and gained the approval - -in July 2006) for license to -manage domestic Chinese equity -products - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -What We’re Doing - -Expand the footprint -• Asia - -– Korea -– Australia -– China -– India - -• Europe - -– Middle East -– Switzerland - -• Fill product gaps - -• Explore new client opportunities: - -central banks and direct -wholesaling - -• Evaluate acquisitions in - -– Australia -– China -– Brazil -– Korea -– Taiwan - -1. - -Total MSIM AUM/AUS of $440 billion as of May 31, 2006 - -Page - -18 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Invest in Van Kampen - Intermediary and Unit Investment Trusts Growth -What We Have - -What We’re Doing - -What We’ve Done - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Vibrant $100+ billion fund and Unit - -Investment Trusts complex - -(1) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched Van Kampen - -– 6th largest 3rd party fund sponsor -– One of the fastest growing - -(2) - -complexes over the last 4 years - -(2) - -– 2nd largest Unit Investment - -Trusts sponsor - -(3) - -• Strong brand presence within broker - -community - -• Established leader with distinguished -capabilities in several key product -areas: U.S. Large Cap Value / U.S. -Moderate Allocation / High Yield -Municipals / Senior Loans - -• Leader in intermediary platform - -market - -– On 20 of top 25 annuity platforms -– On 22 of top 25 Defined -(5) -Contribution platforms - -– Attractive blend of run rate and - -(4) - -takeover business flows - -International Growth Fund and -Van Kampen Leaders Fund - -• Introduced new retirement - -education and support materials - -• Increase resources for high growth / - -margin businesses: - -– Defined Contribution: - -Doubling field sales force -– Unit Investment Trusts: - -38% increase in field sales force - -• Added Variable Insurance field - -• Expand product offering to add - -sales professionals - -diversity - -– International & Global -– Closed End Funds -– Income Oriented products -– Retail Separately Managed - -Account strategies - -• Position Van Kampen to take - -advantage of retirement markets -from a product and distribution -standpoint - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Launched Van Kampen Equity - -Premium Income - -• Issued 14 new Unit Investment - -Trusts products - -• Introduced new television - -advertising - -1. AUM/AUS as of May 31, 2006 -2. Source: Strategic Insights, May 2006 -3. Source: ICI, May 2006 - -Page - -19 - -4. Source: VARDS, 4th quarter 2005 -5. Source: Pensions and Investments, June 2005 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -Stem Outflows of Morgan Stanley Retail Mutual Funds -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -What We’re Doing - -• Morgan Stanley Advisors funds -(excluding Money Market and -Closed End) represents 7% of -total MSIM AUM/AUS (1) - -• Favorable market share in - -Morgan Stanley Global Wealth -Management Group (GWMG) - -• Outflows in Morgan Stanley - -Advisor products - -First Quarter 2006 -• Deployed a new client focused - -field coverage model - -– Assigned dedicated internal -and external wholesalers to -distributing Morgan Stanley -Funds in Morgan Stanley -GWMG - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Hired the head of Morgan -Stanley Funds Distribution - -– A newly created position to - -focus on the Morgan Stanley- -branded funds - -• Preserve favorable market share - -in Morgan Stanley GWMG - -• Actively pursue third party - -distribution of Morgan Stanley -Funds in 401(K), financial -planner, and Registered -Investment Advisor communities - -• Develop distinctive Morgan - -Stanley fund offering - -– Launch distinctive new - -products - -– Rationalize existing product - -line - -1. - -Total MSIM AUM/AUS of $440 billion as of May 31, 2006 - -Page - -20 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Rebuild Institutional Reputation and Business, Particularly in the U.S. -What We Have - -What We’re Doing - -What We’ve Done - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• $187 billion in AUM, 43% of - -MSIM total (1) - -• MSIM covers over 100 consulting - -firms - -• Manages assets for 20 of the top -50 U.S. Pension funds, 56 of the -top 200 U.S. Pension funds (2) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 9 new -products within the channel - -• Conducted road shows with - -consultants and clients - -Second Quarter 2006 - -• Launched / incubated 9 new -products within the channel - -• Internal transfer of Pension Asset -/ Liability management expertise - -• Senior management meetings - -and road shows with consultants -and clients - -• Hosted the annual investment -roundtable of industry thought -leaders (Lyford Cay Conference) - -Client - -• Communicate MSIM story to - -clients and consultants -• Form Institutional Client - -Solutions Group - -• Leverage client service - -People - -• Hire US Institutional leader -• Hire additional salespeople - -Product - -• Develop products to address - -client needs - -• Enhance ability to place - -alternatives - -• Communicate Fixed Income - -turnaround story - -• Retain clients in International - -Value Equity products - -1. As of May 31, 2006 -2. Source: P&I Databook, January 23, 2006. It includes Corporate and Public Funds - -Page - -21 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Summary: Measuring Our Progress - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -First Year - -Two to Three Years - -Three to Five Years -Three to Five Years - -Business Investment - -Gaining Traction - -Results - -• New management team - -• Filled leadership gaps - -• Reorganized business by - -product and client segment - -• Bottom up business plan - -• Seeded new products - -• Built infrastructure - -• Actively pursued new talent to - -manage money - -• Opened lines of communication - -• Positive flows - -• More complete traditional - -product offering - -• Improved margin - -• Completion of several - -acquisitions - -• Multiple direct hedge fund - -strategies - -• Restructured Morgan Stanley - -Advisor Fund family - -• Leader in the asset - -management business with a -reputation for excellent -performance, innovative -products and superior client -service - -Page - -22 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Measuring Our Performance: Key Success Metrics - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Net revenues - -• Pre-tax margin - -FY 2005 Results (1) - -Aspiration - -$2.9 billion - -Double digit growth - -35% (incl. Private Equity) - -29% (excl. Private Equity) - -30%~35% - -• Assets Under Management - -$431 billion - -$600 billion+ - -• Net Flows - -($19) billion - -Strong and competitive -positive flows - -• FY New products launched - -3 - -• Retail Product Performance - -– % of Morningstar rated assets in 4/5 star - -45% - -30+ - -50%+ - -funds - -1. Full Year ended November 30, 2005 - -Page - -23 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - diff --git a/q24/random_k2/random_2.md b/q24/random_k2/random_2.md index 405f7d94774fb08f29f0d478b4b1f971f0f80612..c05964fb61069ec32fdddf54cf1bb59049463e31 100644 --- a/q24/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q24/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,705 +1,1655 @@ -Fixture and Store Designs that Draw Shoppers -into the Center Store to Capitalize on Sales - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Sources Cited - -Cohen, Deborah A., and Susan H. Babey. “Candy at the Cash Register — A Risk Factor for Obesity -and Chronic Disease.” New England Journal of Medicine. (2012): n. page. Web. 21 Jan. 2013. -. - -Sorensen, Herb. Inside the Mind of the Shopper. 1st ed. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education, -Inc., 2009. - -Strom , Stephanie. “In Grocery Stores, the Perimeters Take Center Stage.” New York Times -10/08/2012, New York edition B1. www.nytimes.com/2012/08/11/business/in-grocery-stores-the- -perimeters-take-center-stage.html?pagewanted=all - -Underhill, Paco. Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping. 1st ed. New York: Simon & Schuster -Paperbacks, 2009. 3-27. - -“Stop Shopper Leakage in Center Store.” Shopper Sight News. 70 (2012): n. page. Web. 21 Jan. 2013. -. - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. -Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -If store perimeter provides “sizzle,” center store must serve “steak” - -Colorful, creative, winding and sometimes even whimsical in-store perimeter displays of -produce, sampling stations, deli, sushi and coffee bars, and endless walls filled with everything -from flat screen TVs to the hottest brands of clothing are no doubt here to stay. Engaging -perimeter presentations are among the latest trends in fashionable and attractive retail -merchandising that represent a sweet spot for today’s progressive merchandisers looking for fresh -new ways to connect with shoppers. - - However, while perimeter sales within many mid- to large-size shopping environments clearly -represent a vibrant growth trend, a similar merchandising discipline and focus should be applied -to the center store. After all, smart merchants understand that what’s good for the perimeter -should also be good for the interior, because what good is the sizzle of the perimeter shopping -zone without the steak -- and inherent profit margin -- of the center store? - - Unfortunately, center store is more often than not treated as a warehouse of separate products -on cold, uninviting rows of fixtures. While shoppers may find the products in center store they -need, they seldom find the solutions they truly want to make their lives more enjoyable or -productive. How will that new jacket or shampoo fit their lifestyle? How can that product, or -combination of ingredients, help them make a better or healthier meal? Why will that dog food -help their pet be healthier and happier? - -Madix has introduced new products that improve merchandise visibility. Radius and Wraparound Shelves -used on end caps make merchandise down inline runs more noticeable because these shelves do not - utilize end panels, which normally obstruct merchandise as you look down a run. +FOR RELEASE FEBRUARY 9, 2020 +BY Moira Fagan and Jacob Poushter +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: +Jacob Poushter, Associate Director, Global Attitudes Research +Stefan Cornibert, Communications Manager +202.419.4372 +www.pewresearch.org +RECOMMENDED CITATION +Pew Research Center, February, 2020, “NATO Seen Favorably +Across Member States” + +1 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +About Pew Research Center +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes +and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center conducts +public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social +science research. It studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and +technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social +and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew +Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. +© Pew Research Center 2020 +www.pewresearch.org + +2 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +How we did this +This analysis focuses on views of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) among 16 +member nations and three nonmember nations in Europe and North America. In all, the analysis +covers over 90% of the population living in NATO countries. +Pew Research Center has been tracking views of NATO since 2007. This report also includes views +of Article 5 obligations, which state that an attack on one NATO country is an attack on all; +preferences for close relations with the U.S. versus with Russia; support for the use of military +force to maintain order in the world; and agreement with the sentiment that parts of neighboring +countries belong to another country. +For this report, we used data from a survey conducted across 19 countries from May 13 to Aug. 12, +2019, among 21,029 respondents. The surveys were conducted face-to-face in Central and Eastern +Europe, Greece, Italy, Russia and Ukraine. Surveys were conducted over the phone in North +America and Western Europe. +Here are the questions used for the report, along with responses, and its methodology. +www.pewresearch.org 3 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -What’s actually happening in center store? - -Retail store perimeter growth has come mostly from the pull demand from customers wanting - -fresh, unprocessed foods and products that exude health, youthful appeal and entertainment. -Nowhere is the effect on center store sales more evident than in grocery stores and big food -brands such as Heinz, Kraft and Kellogg. Published reports indicate sales or volume declines -as large as 2.8-percent for some of these powerhouses due to the shifting consumer interest in -healthier non-processed food choices most often found on the perimeter of grocery stores. As -a result, packaged goods manufacturers are researching ways to leverage the popularity of the -perimeter through cross merchandising to make the center store -- along with their profitable -brands -- more exciting and appealing to shoppers. - - Unfortunately, center store sales within most retail environments have been decreasing in -recent years. The reasons why are akin to the proverbial elephant in the room. Rather than -address this huge challenge head-on, many retailers have instead decided to ignore it and focus -on what is working from a perceptual standpoint, which is the perimeter. Regardless of the center -store neglect, and using grocery stores as an example, a report by John Lewis, president, consumer -North America for The Nielsen Company, points out that the center store represents 73-percent -of total store sales and 77-percent of profit despite growing shopper leakage from people who -browse and think about a purchase but ultimately don’t buy. This imbalance of sales and profits -between center and perimeter can be addressed not only through SKU count, but also through -lower margins in the perimeter due to high labor costs and shrink. - -This tale of the two shopping zones is supported by a Center Store Mega Study of 2 million -individual shopping trips that found as many as a quarter of shoppers walk the center store yet -don’t buy anything (“Shopper Sight News”). In addition, during the average 13-minute shopping -trip, shoppers spend on average only two minutes in the center store. Clearly when analyzing -the chasm between center store sales and the average time spent there by shoppers, the -opportunities are enormous for progressive retailers to better integrate perimeter and center store -merchandising efforts targeted at growing customers’ overall baskets. - -So, if bold, new methods of merchandising are working to drive traffic for the perimeter, -why are retailers continuing to ignore the bread and butter represented by the center store? -Within this vast and extremely valuable internal battlefield, most stores still stubbornly stick -with outdated merchandising methodology including everything from shelving and lighting to -traffic patterns and category management. The dichotomous relationship that currently exists -between the perimeter and center store ignores how shopping patterns have shifted and, more -importantly, represents lost sales opportunities. - - When asked to comment, Blake Sloan, partner and store designer at the full-service -architecture and design firm, Heights Venture Architects L.L.P., noted that the center store is often -not addressed with the same creative thought process as the perimeter. - -“It’s extremely difficult to break away from product-centric category management and focus -efforts towards a consumer-centric shopper management,” said Sloan. “The potential profit power -represented by the center store is too valuable to simply ignore. Instead, we suggest retailers -envision the center store experience as a unique merchandising and marketing opportunity. -Retailers should enhance the center store with creative fixturing, lighting and product -identification as they would for the perimeter to create a holistic total store experience to build -customer loyalty and improve sales and profits.” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +NATO is generally seen in a positive light across publics within the alliance, despite lingering +tensions between the leaders of individual member countries. A median of 53% across 16 member +countries surveyed have a favorable view of the organization, with only 27% expressing a negative +view. But opinions of NATO and related issues vary widely across the countries surveyed, +especially regarding the obligations of Article 5 of the 70-year-old Washington Treaty, which +declares that an attack against one member nation is considered an attack against all members. +Positive ratings of NATO among members range from a high of 82% in Poland to 21% in Turkey, +with the United States and Germany in the middle at 52% and 57%, respectively. And in the three +nonmember states surveyed, Sweden and Ukraine see the alliance positively (63% and 53%, +respectively), but only 16% of Russians say the same. +NATO seen favorably in member states, but few in Turkey agree +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 4 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - As a New York Times article entitled “In Grocery Stores, the Perimeters Take Center Stage” -by Stephanie Strom recently stated, “Long, soldier-straight rows of shelves...have long been the -heart of the American grocery store but are now showing signs of the grocery equivalent of -atherosclerosis.” The same could be said of pretty much any mid- to large sized retailer offering -hundreds, if not thousands of SKUs on the floor. After all, is there anything less inviting than -staring down a narrow, 60-foot long aisle boarded by shelves upon shelves of cans and boxes that -all seem to blend together? - -The bigger, more important equation is how to create a more pleasant and inviting center store - -that works with, if not mimics, the perimeter? Solving the problem of how to keep shoppers in -the center store longer than the average two minutes with a sexier, well-thought-out solutions- -oriented approach would go a long way toward moving more high-margin goods and better -leverage consumer needs to win more of their shopping trips. - - While there is no single solution to the center store challenge, here are 10 smart tips that can -go a long way toward creating a holistic shopping experience that leverages the entire store and -drives up both sales and profits. - -Solution #10: Take the edge off - - Old-school thinking is that if you trap the shopper and force them to pass by lots of product -facings, you’ll create more sales opportunities. Still, some retailers persist in creating canyons of -metal shelving and expecting customers to willingly funnel through them. In fact, the opposite -is true. Not only do shoppers dread entering long aisles, in their hurry to get through them they -often scurry past products they might otherwise be interested in purchasing. - -“Too many stores suffer from the ‘peek and run’ syndrome where shoppers simply refuse to -enter long rows bordered by high shelving on either side unless they absolutely have to,” said -Shawn Kahler, Madix Vice President of Sales and Marketing. “This effectively negates any hope -shoppers will spend any meaningful time in the center store, and it certainly doesn’t create a -pleasant in-store experience.” - -Kahler says the answer is quite obvious: make aisles shorter, less linear and overall more appealing -to remove the intimidation factor in hopes shoppers will choose to walk through the store, enter -aisles, browse and shop. - -“It’s actually possible to create many different types of unique, interesting and appealing aisles - -by using standard parts and fixtures rather than designing custom shelving that is often cost -prohibitive,” he said. “For example, Madix, Inc. offers retailers several options such as its curved -gondola system that actually use standard gondola and wall parts to better manage space and -generate a maximum return on investment.” - - He says that radius curves of 6 or 10 feet provide maximum flexibility to retailers who wish to -transform their outdated straight aisles into something more inviting and productive. There are -also much longer sweeping, curved fixtures that create a panorama effect of products that are -also pleasing to the eye and create much more product visibility than do long, straight and narrow -aisles. The key learning is that retailers have available to them the tools and professional expertise -enabling them to create better, more effective center stores. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Favorable views of the organization have fluctuated over time among both NATO member and +nonmember countries. Since the late 2000s, favorable opinions of NATO are up 10 percentage +points or more in Ukraine, Lithuania and Poland. However, positive opinions of NATO are down +significantly in Bulgaria, Russia, Germany and France over the past decade, with double-digit +percentage point declines in each of these countries. Favorable views of the organization are also +down significantly in Spain and the Czech Republic. +Views of NATO have changed in both member countries and among non-NATO +members over past decade +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. Germany’s 2018 results from Körber-Stiftung survey conducted there Sept. 13-26, 2018. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 5 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Madix’s Radius end caps married with curved Maxi Line draw shoppers into the center store. -The undulating shelves make merchandise stand out. Madix offers components to curve -entire fixture runs, fixture sections, or individual shelves. - -In combination with shorter and more organic-shaped aisles, Dr. Herb Sorensen, Ph.D., author - -of “Inside the Mind of the Shopper,” advocates staggering the fixture patterns themselves from -section to section to break up long sight lines. The outcome of this advice is that as a shopper -looks down any aisle toward the center store, they actually see the end cap of the next shelving -fixture or more inviting concave or radius shelving and not the other side of the store. - -Solution #9: Drop the height of shelving - - Merchants seem to love using vertical space. The higher, the better, right? Actually, according -to Dr. Sorensen, people do not prefer to shop tall shelves crammed with products in the center -store. Instead, they respond best when faced with shelving that’s 66 inches or lower and 15 to 20 -feet long or not longer than 30 feet. Such shelving ensures customers can easily see and navigate -their way through the store without feeling trapped or lost. An exception would be a retailer such -as JCPenney which has begun using tall walls on the perimeter of its stores where they do not -interfere with sight lines to promote fashion accessories. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In addition, across several countries surveyed, favorable views of the organization are related to +ideological orientation, with those on the right sharing a more positive view than those on the +ideological left. +NATO serves as a political and military alliance for its 29 member states spanning Europe and +North America. Founded in 1949 to provide collective defense against the Soviet Union, the +alliance seeks to balance Russian power and influence, in addition to a host of other operations. +Despite the organization’s largely favorable ratings among member states, there is widespread +reluctance to fulfill the collective defense commitment outlined in Article 5 of NATO’s founding +treaty. When asked if their country should +defend a fellow NATO ally against a potential +NATO publics more likely to believe U.S. +attack from Russia, a median of 50% across 16 +would defend them from Russian attack +NATO member states say their country should +than to say their own country should +not defend an ally, compared with 38% who say +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +their country should defend an ally against a +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +Russian attack. ally, __ to defend that country +Publics are more convinced that the U.S. would +use military force to defend a NATO ally from +Russia. A median of 60% say the U.S. would +defend an ally against Russia, while just 29% +say the U.S. would not do so. And in most +NATO member countries surveyed, publics are +more likely to say the U.S. would defend a +NATO ally from a Russian attack than say their +own country should do the same. +In terms of transatlantic relations, some +Western European publics prefer a close +relationship with the U.S., but many others +prefer a close relationship with both the U.S. +and Russia. Nevertheless, few want to prioritize +Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. The U.S., Russia +their relationship with Russia over their U.S. +and Ukraine were not asked both questions. Bulgaria not included +relations. Ideology also relates to views of due to a translation error. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q25. +potential allies: Those on the right in several +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +countries are more likely than those on the left PEW RESEARCH CENTER +to prefer a relationship with the U.S. +www.pewresearch.org 6 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -In addition, traditional straight-faced shelves in most stores are designed to hold a maximum -capacity of products from top to bottom, but they are not shopper friendly. Such a design stifles -the ability to view products on lower shelves, often forcing the shopper to take a few steps back -into what may be a crowded aisle to see what’s on the bottom shelves. Such fixtures also visually -create a closed-in, claustrophobic feeling as shoppers walk down an aisle. - - One solution is to install pyramid-style fixtures on both sides of an aisle. Such fixtures have top -shelves that are recessed from the shopper by about 16 inches, giving shoppers nearly three full -feet of apparent extra aisle width. This allows higher-velocity products to be inventoried on lower -shelves while featuring higher-priced or lower-velocity items toward the top where they can gain -more exposure. - - A less radical alternative to pyramid fixtures is an offset shelving design that moves one or -more of the top shelves back in small increments between 8-12 inches. While slightly less effective -than pyramid fixtures, offset shelving still helps reduce the train-tunnel effect and allows the use -of sloped signboards that can be used for various in-store marketing devices such as digital media. - -Regardless of the type of fixture that’s used, Dr. Sorensen points out that there is a delicate -balance between trying to capture the shopper’s time, holding a shopper at a product display, and -closing the sale. Trying to sell too much within a small space can actually harm sales conversion, -because the longer it takes a shopper to make up his or her mind, the more angst they feel, the -more likely they are to abandon that area of the store, and the less time they are apt to linger in -other areas of the store. The rule of thumb should be convenience, which translates into fast. - -Madix’s product lines are available in numerous sizes, -so a retailer can deploy fixtures that best meet its sales objectives. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Despite the reservations many have about NATO’s Article 5 commitments, half or more in nearly +every country surveyed agree it is sometimes necessary to use military force to maintain order in +the world. In most countries surveyed, those who say military force is sometimes necessary are +also more likely to agree that their country should use military force to defend a fellow NATO ally. +These views have changed significantly over the past decade in some countries. In Ukraine, Russia, +Slovakia and Germany, more say military force is sometimes necessary than said the same in +2007. And in Italy, Spain and the Czech Republic, publics have grown less inclined to agree. +On the topic of territorial ambitions, when asked if there are parts of neighboring countries that +really belong to their country, relatively few surveyed agree. However, among NATO member +states, majorities in Hungary, Greece, Turkey and Bulgaria agree that parts of other countries +belong to them. In many European countries, those with a favorable view of right-wing populist +parties are more likely to support this statement. +These are among the key findings from a Pew Research Center survey of 19 countries, including 16 +NATO member states, Sweden, Russia and Ukraine. The survey was conducted among 21,029 +people from May 13 to Aug. 12, 2019. Throughout this report, German results are occasionally +sourced from a series of surveys conducted in Germany by Körber-Stiftung, in partnership with +Pew Research Center. +www.pewresearch.org 7 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Solution #8: Widen the aisles - - Using pyramid or offset fixtures are simple methods to effectively open up aisles visually and -literally from the feet up to head height, but another more obvious solution is to simply widen the -entire aisle. Some retailers serve up just enough room for two carts to pass by one another in an -aisle, while others make it almost impossible for even a single cart to pass between displays. While -the solution will vary between retail formats, the outcome should always cater to what makes the -shopper most comfortable and put them in a buying, not evacuation, mode. - -In general, shoppers equate open space with the freedom to shop. The best way to generate - -traffic is to allow traffic to flow without restrictions. A shopper at a store with tall, narrow aisles -is less likely to enter the aisle if it has but one other shopper in it, much less several. With such -aisles, a single shopper with a cart stopped in an aisle can occupy as much as 10 feet of shelf facing, -effectively blocking that merchandise from other potential buyers. Obviously, this leads to far -fewer sales opportunities. - - On the other hand, a shopper at a store with aisles able to accommodate multiple shoppers -shoulder-to-shoulder is less likely to turn away. In this scenario, even if another shopper is camped -in front of a shelving unit another shopper can stand to the side and browse. The key is to allow a -relatively free flow of multiple shoppers through any aisle at any time. - - Dr. Sorensen states that open space combined with short and low fixtures are open invitations -to shop. Likewise, he says, “Narrow, crowded aisles like packed highways can lead to social -pathology and even ‘aisle rage,’” whereby shoppers become angry at one another for blocking -each other or even blame the store for failing to be customer friendly. Ironically, retailers who do a -good job merchandising their perimeters typically do so with wide aisles, low fixtures and a sense -of openness. So why not apply the same principles to the center store experience where upward -of 75-percent of all sales occur? - -Madix designs its products to more efficiently utilize space, -which means a retailer can devote more space around fixtures to its shoppers. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Across the 16 NATO member countries +Views of NATO +surveyed, NATO is generally seen in a positive +% who have a __ opinion of NATO +light. A median of 53% across these countries +have a favorable view of the organization, while Unfavorable Favorable +| a median of 27% have an unfavorable opinion. | | Canada | | 20% | | | 66% | +| ----------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| In 13 of these countries, roughly half or more | | U.S. | | 26 | | 52 | | +have a positive view of NATO. +| | | Poland | | 8 | | | 82 | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Among NATO member countries, positive views | | Lithuania | | 12 | | | 77 | +of the organization range from 82% in Poland Netherlands 21 72 +to 21% in Turkey. Majorities of people in +| | | UK | | 23 | | | 65 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Poland, Lithuania, Netherlands, the United +| | | Italy | | 24 | | | 60 | +| ---------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Kingdom, Italy and Germany rate NATO | | Germany | | 33 | | 57 | | +| positively in Europe. Opinions are also | Czech Rep. | | | 27 | | 54 | | +relatively positive in the Czech Republic, +| | | Slovakia | | 39 | | 51 | | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Slovakia, France, Spain, Hungary and Bulgaria. +| | | France | | 38 | | 49 | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Spain | | 42 | | 49 | | +| Canadians and Americans hold positive views | | Hungary | | | | | | +| | | | | 16 | | 48 | | +of NATO, with 66% in Canada and 52% in the +| | | Bulgaria | | 28 | | 42 | | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +U.S. expressing favorable opinions. +| | | Greece | 51 | | | 37 | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +In Turkey and Greece, publics are particularly +| | | Turkey | 55 | | 21 | | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +unfavorable toward the alliance: Roughly half +NATO +or more express a negative opinion. +| | MEMBER | | | 27 | | 53 | | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MEDIAN +Among the three non-NATO countries +| | | Sweden | | 28 | | | 63 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +surveyed, views of the alliance are mixed. In +| | | Ukraine | | 23 | | 53 | | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Sweden and Ukraine, more than half have a +| | | Russia | 60 | | 16 | | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +favorable view of NATO. But in Russia, 60% +have an unfavorable view of the organization, Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +Russia are not NATO member states. +while just 16% view it favorably, the smallest +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +share across all countries surveyed. “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 8 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Another, less obvious reason to expand aisles is what Paco Underhill, author of “Why We Buy: -The Science of Shopping,” calls the “butt-brush effect.” During research his firm conducted -for Bloomingdale’s department store, they inadvertently observed shopper interaction with a -clothing fixture near a ground-floor entrance they were monitoring. The fixture was adjacent to -a high-traffic aisle, and they saw that customers interacting with the fixture would typically get -“butt-brushed” from behind by people heading into or out of the store. After a few such bumps, -shoppers abandoned the fixture and moved on without buying. As a result, sales from the fixture -were well below expectations. After moving the fixture to another location that eliminated -the possibility of butt-brush, the retailer found that sales from the fixture immediately and -substantially increased. It simply boiled down to location. - -The question retailers should be asking themselves is how often their customers are spooked - -by being too close to one another or being brushed against other shoppers trying to navigate -around them? The solution may be something as easy as a realignment of a fixture or a more -complicated readjustment of the entire aisle space. - -Solution #7: Go mobile - -Part of the challenge of store fixtures is that they are by definition “fixed,” meaning they -often are anchored in place and unlikely to be moved outside of major store resets. Rather than -be entirely tethered by immovable fixtures, some of the world’s most successful retailers have -embraced the more fluid flexibility of mobile displays to complement or, in radical cases, supplant -stationary displays. - - Granted, fixtures on castors are not a new concept, but the use of such shelving is not -necessarily widespread, especially in the center store area. An example of a retailer that lives by -mobile fixtures is one of Europe’s most successful shoe store chains, Leder & Schuh’s. L&S has -virtually no immoveable fixtures. Instead, every eight weeks or so the latest shoe fashions are - -Madix offers a variety of caster kits that convert conventional shelving systems into flexible mobile runs. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Views of NATO have fluctuated since Pew Research Center began asking this question in 2007. In +non-NATO-member Ukraine, for example, 34% said they had a favorable view of the organization +in 2007. In 2019, 53% said the same, an increase of 19 percentage points. Lithuanians and Poles +have also grown more favorable toward NATO over the past 10 to 12 years (increases of 18 and 10 +points, respectively). +Several countries have soured on the alliance over that period. In France, favorable views of NATO +dropped from 71% in 2009 to 49% in 2019, a decrease of 22 percentage points. In Germany, +favorable views of the organization declined by 16 points, and in Bulgaria favorable views are down +by 12 points. In nonmember Russia, positive views have been nearly cut in half: In 2007, 30% had +a favorable view of NATO. By 2019, just 16% expressed the same sentiment. +NATO favorability over time +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO + 2007 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 +NATO member +| countries | % % | % % | % % | % % | % % | % % | +| ------------ | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | +| U.S. | - 53 | 54 54 | 51 49 | - 49 | 53 62 | 64 52 | +| Canada | - - | - - | - 57 | - 56 | 56 66 | - 66 | +| France | - 71 | 68 70 | 67 58 | - 64 | 49 60 | - 49 | +| Germany | - 73 | 57 60 | 65 59 | - 55 | 59 67 | 63 57 | +| Greece | - - | - - | 20 25 | - - | 25 33 | - 37 | +| Italy | - 64 | - - | 61 60 | - 64 | 59 57 | - 60 | +| Netherlands | - - | - - | - - | - - | 72 79 | - 72 | +| Spain | - 56 | 53 62 | 45 42 | - 47 | 44 45 | - 49 | +| UK | - 63 | 60 63 | 62 59 | - 60 | 61 62 | - 65 | +| Bulgaria | 54 54 | - - | - - | - - | - - | - 42 | +| Czech Rep. | 60 66 | - - | 51 56 | - - | - - | - 54 | +| Hungary | - 57 | - - | - - | - - | 57 60 | - 48 | +| Lithuania | - 59 | - 65 | - - | - - | - - | - 77 | +| Poland | 72 75 | 77 72 | 70 64 | - 74 | 70 79 | - 82 | +| Slovakia | 53 59 | - - | - - | - - | - - | - 51 | +| Turkey | - - | - 18 | 15 25 | 19 23 | - 23 | - 21 | +Non-NATO countries +| Sweden | - - | - - | - - | - - | 58 65 | - 63 | +| -------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | +| Russia | 30 24 | 40 37 | 22 27 | - 12 | - - | - 16 | +| Ukraine | 34 31 | - 34 | - - | - 58 | - - | - 53 | +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. Germany’s 2018 results from Körber-Stiftung survey conducted there Sept. 13-26, 2018. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 9 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -displayed in a new retail theater created by set designers using mobile fixtures, lighting and props. -This has helped cement their reputation as a progressive, forward-thinking retailer with its finger -on the pulse of the rapidly changing world of fashion. Other retailers, such as RadioShack, Ross -Dress for Less, BestBuy, and numerous department and grocery store chains, have experienced -their own successes with the flexibility of mobile fixtures. - - Mobile fixtures give retailers the ability to easily change the store layout to fit the changing -needs of shoppers, accommodate special sales and offers, and even cater to “event” opportunities -with integrated solutions for big events, holidays or celebrations. Have perishables that are about -to go out of date? Put them on mobile fixtures and place them near checkout lines or in natural -product adjacencies to stimulate purchase and reduce shrinkage. Coming up on “Go Pink” breast -cancer awareness day? Use mobile fixtures and round up different pink merchandise such as -clothing and accessories near front entrances for people who want to support the cause. Have -overstock of something that might take weeks to clear out? Use mobile fixtures to create sales -opportunities throughout the store to get shoppers to purchase what you want to sell. The -possibilities are endless. - -Solution #6: Shorten or break up long runs - - Hand in hand with banishing railroad tunnel aisles, Dr. Sorensen suggests rethinking the -concept of aisles altogether. He advocates that the length of shelving from one end to the other -be between 15-20 feet and not longer than 30 feet. - -Shorter aisles in length and height accomplish multiple purposes. First, they are more -inviting to navigate and provide a natural break between product facings. Next, if the fixtures -are of varying heights, shoppers can actually see across multiple shelves and gondolas. Shorter, - -Madix’s shelving lines can be ordered to accommodate shorter run lengths. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Americans’ views of NATO differ by political party affiliation. Democrats and Democratic-leaning +independents have been more likely to have a favorable opinion of NATO than Republicans and +Republican-leaning independents across most years. That remained true in 2019, as 61% of +Democrats had a positive view of the alliance, compared with 45% of Republicans. +Democrats consistently more favorable toward NATO than Republicans +% of U.S. adults who have a favorable view of NATO +100% +76 +Democrat/Lean Democrat 74 +60 60 61 +57 58 58 56 57 +49 49 53 50 51 48 52 +43 44 45 +Republican/LeanRepublican +0 +2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Both Democratic and Republican views of NATO remained generally stable until 2017, when +Democrats grew much more likely to support NATO than their counterparts, a difference that has +not changed significantly since. In 2017, 74% of Democrats and 48% of Republicans had a +favorable opinion of the alliance, a difference of 26 percentage points. Since 2018, U.S. views of +NATO have declined among supporters of both parties. Positive views among Democrats fell 15 +points, while views among Republicans dropped 7 points. +www.pewresearch.org 10 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -staggered fixtures also serve as artificial road bumps that force shoppers to slow down, navigate -left, right and around product displays, and be more aware of what they’re passing. Also, one of -the most potent sales opportunities exist with end caps, and the shorter the fixtures in length, -and the greater the number of fixtures that are used, the number of end cap merchandising areas -increases exponentially. - - A similar outcome can be accomplished by interspersing concave or radius shelving that -softens up center store aisles and visibly pulls customers in. Rounded or organically-shaped -shelving units such as the Madix Y-Gondola can add a pleasant visual impact to the sales floor and -create multiple focal points allowing retailers to highlight important items, sales or promotional -offers. Such shelving also actually improves the visibility of more SKUs when compared to straight -shelves, because they are typically viewed from more of a frontal perspective than through a side -view while walking down an aisle. - - Of note, some retailers, such as Walmart, have actually reverted back to taller, warehouse-style -shelving and what has been described as shelves stacked full of many different products, narrow -aisles and conspicuous pallet stacks. Why? Because their sales results support the notion that -such a shopping environment better supports their brand proposition of being a value-oriented -retailer. - -Explaining this perspective in a national best seller book entitled Why We Buy: The Science of -Shopping, Underhill says, “Historically, the more a store is packed (with merchandise), the more -people think of it as value — just as when you walk into a store and there are fewer things on the - -floor, you tend to think they’re expensive.” - -This simply means that it’s critical for retailers such as Walmart to understand the mindset -of their customers to know what it is they want. Regardless of a retailer’s brand proposition – -whether it be value, quality, selection or brand names – they must strike a balance between the -volume of products displayed and the physical and visual presentation to create an optimum -buying atmosphere for its customers. In other words, what works for a discounter may not work -for a specialty retailer, and vice versa. - -Solution #5: Integrate specialty merchandisers - -Specialty merchandisers are an ideal mobile way for retailers to experiment with product -displays and presentations on the sales floor without making major, permanent commitments to -space or marketing. - -Retailers can experiment with specialty “solution stations” that tie product categories together - -without totally realigning product groupings or fixtures. Common fixtures for such specialty -presentations include the use of T-Racks and mobile caster kits. - - Grocers could consider staging certain ethnic food nights, weeks or months to stimulate trial -and impulse purchases by shoppers. For example, a mobile fixture or end cap could be ideal for -“Italian Night Solutions” complete with recipes and suggestions for combinations of products that -otherwise would be spread throughout the store: pots, pans, utensils, spaghetti, lasagna, pizza -kits, sauces, spices, olive oil, cheese, meat and vegetable appetizers, bread, desert, wine and even -flowers. Another possibility could be “Pamper Your Pet” with a selection of high-end food, treats, -supplements, collars, bowls and toys. Evergreen events such as birthdays and anniversaries also -lend themselves to turn-key specialty merchandisers featuring apparel, gift boxes, cards, candles, -desserts and even alcohol. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Those on the ideological right more +favorable toward NATO +Ideology is a factor when it comes to views of +% who have a favorable view of NATO +NATO in several countries. In six countries, +those placing themselves on the right side of the +ideological spectrum are more favorable toward +NATO than those on the left. In Sweden, for +example, 79% of those on the ideological right +have a positive opinion of NATO, compared +with 38% of those on the left, a difference of 41 +percentage points. Significant differences +between those on the right and the left are also +seen in Bulgaria (38 percentage points), the +Czech Republic (36 points), Spain (25), Greece Note: Only statistically significant differences shown. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +(19) and Slovakia (16). +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 11 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Madix manufactures specialty merchandisers to suit any market segment. Luxe, -a new display that features an attractive round upright and standard Madix slotting, -accepts Madix’s thousands of shelves and accessories. - -Retailers should experiment with integrated presentations for different topics and locations - -to see what does and doesn’t resonate with their customer base and tweak them accordingly. -In addition, Dr. Sorensen points out that something as simple as scattering static or mobile -merchandisers around the store in non-obvious locations almost always increases sales of those -products. For example, placing a merchandising display of cookies outside of the bakery, or -t-shirts and socks near the check-out queue, can stimulate incremental sales of those items outside -of their natural environment. The beauty of such displays is that they lend themselves -to experimentation. - -Solution #4: Make smart use of in-store marketing - -Point-of-sale marketing is found to improve the find-ability of merchandise and usually leads to -improved brand recognition. However, it’s important to effectively judge the use of such point-of- -sale material and be smart about leveraging the sales of merchandise the retailer wants to sell, not -necessarily what the manufacturer or supplier wants to push. After all, why take up valuable shelf -space and fight for shoppers’ attention for a low-margin or low velocity item or product category? -It’s better to focus on merchandise that has a higher profit margin, introduces new or innovative -products to customers, or supports the retailer’s particular point-of-difference (better selection, -higher quality, well-known brand names, etc.). - - Digital print and video signage are excellent ways to cut through the clutter and grab shoppers’ -attention in the noise of the typical retail environment. Such signage can be designed to educate, -entertain and engage shoppers with key messages they might not otherwise see. The Bissell -brand of vacuum cleaners in Lowe’s Home Improvement Stores is one example. Their use of digital -and video signage on end caps and mid-aisle displays stop shoppers in their tracks to deliver short, -concise sales messages about the benefits of clean floors and carpets and how Bissell products -deliver the best outcome and value. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Article 5 of the NATO treaty is “at the very heart +Publics in NATO countries express +of NATO’s founding treaty,” according to the +reluctance on Article 5 obligations +organization. The article states that “an attack +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +against one Ally is considered as an attack +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +against all Allies.” ally, (survey country) __ use military force to defend +that country +When asked whether their country should or Should not Should +| | Netherlands | | | 32% | | 64% | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +should not use military force to defend a NATO +| | | U.S. | | 29 | | 60 | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ally from a hypothetical attack by Russia, in +Canada +| only five of the 16 member states surveyed – the | | | | 38 | | 56 | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Netherlands, the U.S., Canada, the UK and | | UK | | 41 | | 55 | +Lithuania – do half or more say that they +| | Lithuania | | | 34 | | 51 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +should use such force. Across the 16 countries, a +| | | France | | 53 | | 41 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +median of 50% say that their country should +| | | Spain | | 56 | | 41 | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +not defend a NATO ally in the event of an attack +| | | Poland | | 43 | | 40 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +by Russia, while 38% say they should. +| | Czech Rep. | | | 47 | | 36 | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Larger shares in 10 NATO member countries | | Germany | 60 | | | 34 | +| | | Hungary | | 43 | | 33 | +surveyed say their country should not use force +to defend a NATO ally should there be an attack Slovakia 55 32 +by Russia. This includes majorities in Bulgaria, Turkey 55 32 +Italy, Greece, Germany and Spain. In Poland, +| | | Greece | 63 | | | 25 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sentiment is divided. +| | | Italy | 66 | | | 25 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Bulgaria | 69 | | 12 | | + +| | 16-COUNTRY | | | 50 | | 38 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +MEDIAN +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24. + +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 12 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Other, less extreme example of digital signage and even low-tech coupon and recipe pads and -dispensers are also effective in garnering attention for specific products and brands. Products -such as Lumicanopy by Madix, Inc. use LED lighting to illuminate graphics and promote categories -or brands. The typical Lumicanopy consumes little power, emits virtually no heat, exhibits uniform -light distribution that’s visible from many feet away, and is reusable over several years. Other -displays such as the Madix Easel SB retail shelf and point-of-sale display educates and entertains -shoppers with relevant information and does not protrude into aisles to interfere with shoppers. -The key is to be smart about what and how information is communicated to ensure its effect on -shoppers is maximized. - -Being able to deploy large format, illuminated graphics either in Madix’s canopies or within -the fixtures’ surfaces facilitates in-store marketing initiatives. The bright, colorful graphics -appeal to shoppers across the store. - -Solution #3: Turn up the lights - -Lighting is one of the most important -- yet probably one of the least understood -- - -merchandising techniques in the retail environment. Done correctly at the point-of-sale with -fixtures such as the Madix LEDge Light Versa and the Beam LED alternative to fluorescent canopy -lighting and retailers can improve mood, create the desired ambiance, and more importantly -create a measurable impact on shopping behavior. - - An article published in InformeDesign by Delores (Dee) Ginthner, an associate professor in -the Interior Design Program, Department of Design, Housing and Apparel at the University of -Minnesota, states several basic truisms that must be addressed when lighting a space to ensure -both psychological and behavioral issues of users are met. This includes the observations that -lighting must ensure safe navigation through a space; people always follow the brightest path; -brightness can focus attention; people like to face walls that are illuminated; and lighting can -cause people to alter body positions. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +The belief that their country should respond to +Changing views on whether their +a hypothetical Russian attack on a NATO ally +country should intervene in a conflict +has become less common over time in a handful +between Russia and a NATO ally +of countries. For example, in Italy, only a +% who say their country should use military force to +quarter in 2019 say that their country should +defend a NATO ally in a serious military conflict with +defend a NATO ally, down from four-in-ten in +Russia +2015. Similar declines over this time period +80% +occurred in Poland (-8 percentage points), +Spain (-7) and France (-6). However, support +62 +for protecting a fellow NATO nation has +increased in the UK since 2015 (+6). 49 53 55 UK +48 +46 +48 41 France +47 45 41 Spain +In eight of the countries polled, men are 40 +40 Poland +significantly more likely than women to say that 36 +their country should defend a NATO ally. For 25 Italy +example, in Germany, 43% of men say that in +the case of a Russian attack on a fellow NATO +member their country should respond with 0 +2015 2017 2019 +force, compared with only a quarter of women. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24. +Similar double-digit differences occur in Spain, +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +Hungary, the Czech Republic, the Netherlands +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +and Poland. +Ideology also plays a role in people’s views about coming to an ally’s aid. In six countries, those +who place themselves on the right end of the ideological spectrum are more willing to say they +should defend a NATO ally than those on the right. This includes double-digit differences between +right and left in all six countries: Spain (30 percentage points), the Czech Republic and Slovakia +(21 points), Greece (14), and the UK and Italy (both 13 points). +www.pewresearch.org 13 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Ginthner further states that criteria created several years ago by Dr. John Flynn to evaluate -lighting remain true today. This criteria states that designers must use cues to determine the users’ -subjective response to space lighting in order to create space that makes users say something is -pleasant versus unpleasant, public versus private, spacious versus confined, relaxed versus tense -and visually clear versus hazy. - - Needless to say, the science of lighting and how it applies to curved fixtures, pyramid or -recessed shelving, wider and shorter aisles, end caps, on-shelf merchandisers and even mobile -fixtures is critical to maximizing the impact and desired outcomes. The days of one-size-fits-all -overhead or fluorescent canopy lighting are being replaced by new efficient alternatives such -as environmentally friendly LEDs that produce light intensity similar to T5 fluorescent fixtures -while using only half the energy and lasting nearly three times longer. Lighting considerations -should be incorporated into the initial store design at the onset by true lighting professionals who -understand shopper psychology and how best to use lighting to stimulate sales. - -Madix is the first store fixture manufacturer to design energy-efficient, -point-of-sale lighting products that are specifically designed for store equipment -applications. Madix’s lighting solutions either attach underneath shelves, or they -replace the fixtures’ surfaces to pin-point light (e.g., back panels or shelf skins). - -Solution #2: Optimize traffic flow - -The art of converting visitors into shoppers and shoppers into buyers is accomplished in no - -small part through optimizing traffic flow through the store. Dr. Sorensen suggests there are -several changes, some subtle and some overt, that can make a major impact on a store’s visceral -appeal while exposing shoppers to buying opportunities that may have gone undiscovered in a -traditional linear layout. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Views on defending an ally from a potential +Those who agree military force is +Russian attack are related to general attitudes +sometimes necessary are more likely +toward the use of military force. Across most of +to support defending a NATO ally +the NATO member countries surveyed, those +% who say their country should use military force to +who agree that military force is sometimes +defend a NATO ally from a serious military conflict with +necessary to maintain order in the world are +Russia +more likely to say that they would defend a +| | Disagree that | | Agree that | | +| --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +fellow NATO member from an armed incursion military force military force +is sometimes is sometimes +than those who disagree that a military solution necessary necessary Diff +| | | % | % | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +is the best choice for keeping order. For +| | | 23 | 51 | +28 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +Poland +example, in Spain, 53% of those who agree that +| | Spain | 26 | 53 | +27 | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | +military force is sometimes necessary say they +| | Lithuania | 38 | 65 | +27 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---- | +would come to the aid of a NATO ally, versus +| | Canada | 38 | 64 | +26 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +only 26% of those who disagree with the +| | Italy | 12 | 38 | +26 | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | +principle of military force – a 27 percentage Netherlands 47 72 +25 +| point difference. | UK | 37 | 62 | +25 | +| ------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Czech Rep. | 24 | 49 | +25 | +| | Slovakia | 20 | 45 | +25 | + +| | Germany | 23 | 47 | +24 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Hungary | 18 | 40 | +22 | + +| | U.S. | 47 | 64 | +17 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | France | 30 | 47 | +17 | + +| | Bulgaria | 9 | 17 | +8 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Greece | 23 | 29 | +6 | + +| | Turkey | 29 | 34 | +5 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q50h. + +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 14 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - One idea requires a significant reconfiguration of fixtures to change their orientation and -layout to the front of the store. Dr. Sorensen supports the theory that when shoppers within -the interior of a store look down aisles and see checkout registers, especially ones with no lines, -they subconsciously tend to hurry through their shopping experience so they can quickly check -out before the lines fill up: a sort of quick in, quick out mentality. To combat this and reduce the -“railroad tunnel” visual effect, he suggests shifting the aisles at a 45-degree angle to the front of -the store. An important benefit of such a design is that as shoppers enter the store they will be -approaching aisles from a less acute angle, which will make them more inviting to enter. - - Another way to increase traffic flow and lure shoppers is to determine new and relevant -product categories and bring them into the center store. Along the way and throughout the entire -store, the goal should always be putting the “right” products in the direct path of the customer. -Dr. Sorensen says, “There are patterns of movement... (in a store) that are not driven by products -as much as by open spaces and natural flows.” By observing, determining, and directing traffic -flow with smart shelving fixtures, lighting and merchandising materials, it’s possible to conduct -“anticipatory retailing.” This is when the retailer anticipates and meets the needs of shoppers -rather than making shoppers find things on their own. - -In support of an enhanced traffic flow, Dr. Sorensen advocates putting high margin - -merchandise rather than discounted goods in the customer’s path. Research shows that the most -important determinant for sales is based not on price, but on the placement of store fixtures -displaying those goods. Putting highly discounted merchandise such as 75-percent-off sweaters -or two-for-one cereal offers in the customer’s path may actually be counter-productive, because -it could prevent customers from venturing deeper into the center store and discovering higher- -priced, if not more desirable goods. - - Dollar General spokeswoman Mary Winn Gordon is quoted alongside Underhill in the New -York Times article as saying the chain store employs virtual “speed bumps” of related merchandise - -Madix’s array of fixture choices equips a retailer with options to tweak store designs to improve traffic flow and sales. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In contrast to skeptical opinions on whether +People in member states say the U.S. +their own country should come to the defense of +would defend a NATO ally +a NATO ally, people are much more likely to +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +think the U.S. would take military action in +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +response to a Russian attack. ally, the U.S. __ use military force to defend that country +Would not Would +| A median of 60% across the member countries | Italy | 16% | | 75% | +| -------------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +say the U.S. would use military force to defend a +| | UK | 22 | | 73 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +NATO country that was subject to a Russian +| | Spain | 21 | | 72 | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +incursion. Only 29% across these countries +| believe the U.S. would not defend the country | Canada | 25 | | 69 | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +that was attacked. +| | Netherlands | 28 | | 68 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Greece | 19 | | 65 | +Roughly two-thirds or more in Italy, the UK, +| | Germany | 31 | | 63 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +Spain, Canada, the Netherlands and Greece say +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally. Majorities Slovakia 27 57 +in Germany, Slovakia, Lithuania and France +| | Lithuania | 29 | | 57 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +agree. +| | France | 37 | | 57 | +| ----------------------------------------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| Poles, on balance, say the U.S. would help out | Poland | 30 | 47 | | +should Russia use military force against a +| | Turkey | 40 | 46 | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +neighboring NATO country, but sentiment is +| | Czech Rep. | 35 | 41 | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +more divided in Turkey, the Czech Republic and +| Hungary. | Hungary | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 31 | 39 | | +Since 2015, there has been some change in a +14-COUNTRY +| | | 29 | | 60 | +| ------------------------------------------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| few countries on this question. The belief that | MEDIAN | | | | +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally is down 8 +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Question not asked in the +percentage points in France but up 7 points in U.S. Due to a translation error, results are not shown for Bulgaria. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q25. +the UK and Spain. These sentiments are also up “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| 6 points in Turkey. | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | +| --------------------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +In Hungary, views that the U.S. would help out in the event of a Russia attack are down +significantly since 2017, falling 16 percentage points. +www.pewresearch.org 15 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -that goes together -- such as bananas alongside boxes of vanilla wafers -- in aisles or at entrances, -because it’s a consumer-friendly way to assist customers and pique their thought process while -generating incremental sales. By using such things as Y-Gondolas, mobile displays, LED lighting -fixtures, floor graphics, ceiling hangers or digital or video marketing to highlighting merchandise -in a non-intrusive, yet attention-getting fashion, it’s entirely possible to get customers to buy -items you wish to sell, not just what shoppers came into the store to purchase. - - An underutilized method of generating awareness and trial is product sampling and -demonstrations. Retailers such as Sam’s Club, Costco and Whole Foods have mastered the art -of sampling during high traffic days and peak times to expose customers to products they may -have otherwise ignored. Why not create a display that demonstrates the difference between -200 and 400 thread count sheets? Utilize sales staff as virtual models by having them wear the -merchandise being sold in the store, much like mega-brands Hollister and American Eagle have -done with their employees. Create mobile sampling stations offering customers tastes of lesser- -known foods such as couscous, Greek yogurt, even kale along with recipes incorporating those -foods to stimulate profitable impulse sales. - -In fact, the New England Journal of Medicine reports that food choices are largely guided by -our responses to outside signals and stimuli. A paper authored by Deborah Cohen of RAND Health -in Santa Monica, Calif., and Susan Babey of the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, states that -impulse marketing takes place on a subconscious level, and that placement of foods in prominent -locations increases the rate at which they’re purchased. - - While most people may associate such impulse displays with checkout lines and sodas, candy, -gum and magazines, they can be just as effective in other areas of a store. Shopping for a new -blouse? You may be influenced by matching (high-margin) accessories attractively displayed -next to them. Buying new cat food? How about a pretty collar or catnip to go along with it. The -possibilities for proximity marketing are enormous, if not often overlooked, opportunities. - -Solution #1: Multiply the end cap effect - -End caps are perhaps the most misunderstood and underutilized spaces in the retail -environment. According to Dr. Sorensen, approximately 2-percent of the total items in a -typical store at any given time are being promoted on end-of-aisle displays or other secondary -promotional displays apart from the mail shelving fixtures. However, this 2-percent of items may -constitute a whopping 30-percent of all store sales. - - While retailers often use this space to promote sales or highly discounted merchandise, the fact -is that half the shoppers purchasing an item from such end caps are unaware the goods are being -sold at a reduced price, and half of the people who know would buy the product even if it wasn’t -on sale. - -So in other words, good retailers are simply giving away profits to as much as 75-percent of - -their shoppers because they are locked into the mindset that price considerations dominate -shopping decisions when research doesn’t support that point of view. Instead, great retailers -understand that a better use of such prime real estate is to satisfy the shopper’s inherent need -for value and convenience, and most customers are willing to pay full price to accomplish a fast -shopping experience. - - Another reason end caps can be extremely profitable is that because of their small size, they -generally feature only one or two products. As such, shoppers do not have an easy or immediate -way to compare the merchandise as they would in the category section inside the aisle. The -impulse nature of end caps and the lack of price sensitivity support the premise that retailers can -command a higher price for such merchandise. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Young adults in Spain, France, Slovakia, +More in NATO countries say the U.S. +Canada and Germany are more likely to believe +would use military force to defend an +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally against a +ally from Russia than say that their +Russian attack. For example, in Spain, 84% of +country should do the same +18- to 29-year-olds say the U.S. would uphold +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +their Article 5 obligations, compared with 68% +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +of those 50 and older. +ally, __ to defend that country +| | | Our country | The U.S. | | +| --- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | +In almost every country surveyed, people are should use would use +| | military force military force | | | Diff | +| ------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | +| significantly more likely to say the U.S. would | | % | % | | +defend an ally from a Russia attack than say Italy 25 75 +50 +| | Greece | 25 | 65 | +40 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +their own country should take such action. +| | Spain | 41 | 72 | +31 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Germany | 34 | 63 | +29 | +The biggest difference measured is in Italy, +| | Slovakia | 32 | 57 | +25 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | +where three-quarters say the U.S. would use +| | UK | 55 | 73 | +18 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +such military force in such a scenario, +| | France | 41 | 57 | +16 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +compared with only a quarter who say Italy +| | Turkey | 32 | 46 | +14 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +should defend that NATO ally, a 50 percentage +| | Canada | 56 | 69 | +13 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +point difference. Similar differences are seen in Poland 40 47 +7 +| | Hungary | 33 | 39 | +6 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +Greece (40 points), Spain (31), Germany (29), +| | Lithuania | 51 | 57 | +6 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +Slovakia (25), the UK (18), France (16), Turkey +| | Czech Rep. | 36 | 41 | +5 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +(14) and Canada (13). +| | Netherlands | 64 | 68 | +4 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | + Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. U.S, Bulgaria, +Russia and Ukraine not included. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q25. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 16 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Breaking up and staggering the traditional long aisles in many retail locations can literally - -double the number of possible end caps from the shoppers perspective, particularly in the -center store. Incorporating other display tools such as Y-Gondolas, curved shelving, pyramid and -recessed shelving, highlight lighting, sampling stations, lifestyle graphics and signage, can only -serve to increase the sales velocity of end caps. - -Madix understands how important end caps are to a retailer’s success. The company manufactures a number -of end cap systems that maximize space, improve visibility, and capitalize on sales. Madix’s new Y-Gondola -greatly expands the potential of end caps to positively influence shopping behavior. - -Decide what solutions make sense for you - -Revisiting the relationship between the perimeter and center store requires that retailers - -rethink the cost of sales. Ignoring or shrinking the center store given its contribution to -overall profits doesn’t make sense when much more is possible. A better course of action is to -fundamentally rethink the consumer shopping process and adapt the entire store to better deliver -total customer solutions. After all, what good is the sizzle without a juicy steak to go along with it? - -The display fixture experts at Madix, Inc. are available to provide free consultation to retailers - -who wish to explore fresh, new ideas on how to bring the center store back to life to create a -holistic shopping experience that drives sales and profits. For more information, contact John -Clontz Director of Marketing and e-Business jclontz@madixinc.com 214-515-5400. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In nearly every country +Western Europeans favor close relationship with U.S. +surveyed, larger shares support +over Russia; Central and Eastern Europeans tend to +| close ties with the U.S. than | prefer both | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +with Russia, with the +% who say it is more important for their country to have a close +exceptions of Bulgaria and +relationship to ... +| Slovakia. And in many | | | U.S. | | Russia | Both (Vol) | | +| -------------------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| countries polled, publics tend | | UK | | 83% | 8% | 5% | | +| to volunteer that a close | Netherlands | | | 82 | 11 | 4 | | +| relationship with both the U.S. | | Spain | | 73 | 9 | 9 | | +and Russia is important. +| | | France | | 60 | 18 | 13 | | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Germany | 39 | | 25 | | 30 | +Particularly in Western Europe, +| | | Italy | 38 | | 7 | | 45 | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the share of the public that says +| | | Greece | 31 | | 17 | | 40 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a relationship with the U.S. is +| | | Poland | 29 | | 12 | | 53 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +more important is substantial. +| | | Lithuania | 29 | | 17 | | 38 | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +For example, in the UK and the +| | Czech Rep. | | 27 | | 14 | | 39 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Netherlands, about eight-in-ten +| | | Hungary | 24 | | 8 | | 55 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +support ties with the U.S. over +| | | Slovakia | 23 | | 22 | | 50 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Russia or both. And in Sweden, +| | | Bulgaria | 16 | | 28 | | 47 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a non-NATO state, 71% support +closer ties with the U.S. than +| with Russia (11%) or both | | Sweden | | 71 | 11 | 9 | | +| -------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +countries (9%). +Note: “Both” indicates volunteered response “Both relationships are equally important.” +“Don’t know” and “Neither” responses not shown. German results from Körber-Stiftung +survey conducted in Germany Sept. 9-28, 2019. +Choosing a close relationship +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q35. +| with Russia over the U.S. is | “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| considerably less widespread | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +across the countries surveyed. +Bulgarians are the most prone to this point of view, but just 28% say a close relationship with +Russia is more important for their country. A quarter of Germans say it is important for their +country to have a close relationship with Russia, compared with 39% who favor a close +relationship with the U.S. Three-in-ten Germans volunteer that a close relationship with both +countries would be preferable. +www.pewresearch.org 17 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Traditional Center Store Fixture Configuration - - Traditional center store fixture runs are usually long and extend 30 feet or -more. The long runs discourage shoppers from entering the department. Also, -the lengthy runs have a limited quantity of end caps, the store fixture with the -most effective sales potential. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Central and Eastern European publics tend to +volunteer their preference for a close Those on right ideologically more likely +to favor close relationship with U.S. +relationship with both the U.S. and Russia. In +Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and Bulgaria, % who say it is more important for their country to have +a close relationship to the U.S. +roughly half or more say a relationship with +both countries is important. And in Italy, +Greece, the Czech Republic and Lithuania, +about four-in-ten or more say the same. +Ideology is linked to views of closer relations +with the U.S. In 11 of 14 countries, those on the +ideological right are more likely to support a +close relationship with the U.S. than those on +the left. In the Czech Republic, for example, +40% of those on the right say a close +relationship with the U.S. is more important, +compared to 15% of those on the left, a +difference of 25 percentage points. +Hungary is an exception. Hungarians on the left +(40%) are almost twice as likely as their +counterparts on the right (21%) to support close +U.S. relations. +Note: All differences shown are statistically significant. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q35. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 18 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout that Staggers Runs - A center store layout with staggered runs includes more and shorter fixture -runs. Shoppers are more likely to enter a center store that utilizes shorter, -less daunting runs. The staggering of the runs greatly increases a shopper’s -exposure to end caps as he or she walks through the department. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +There is widespread support across most of the Across most of Europe and North +NATO countries surveyed for the use of military America, support for military force to +maintain order in the world +force to maintain order in the world. A median +of 57% across 16 member countries agree that % who __ that it is sometimes necessary to use military +military force is sometimes necessary, while a force to maintain order in the world +| median of 36% disagree. | | | | Disagree | Agree | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | U.S. | | 21% | | | 78% | +| | | Canada | | 27 | | | 71 | +Across most countries surveyed – both +members of NATO and those that do not belong +| to the organization – about half or more | | UK | | 29 | | | 71 | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| support the use of military force to maintain | | Hungary | | 25 | | | 70 | +order. And in seven countries (Sweden, the Netherlands 31 69 +| | | France | | 35 | | | 64 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +U.S., Canada, the UK, Turkey, Russia and +Poland +| Hungary) seven-in-ten or more hold this view. | | | | 35 | | | 58 | +| ----------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Spain | | 44 | | | 55 | +| Germans are more divided, with 47% saying | Czech Rep. | | | 37 | | 53 | | +that military force is sometimes necessary and a Slovakia 42 53 +| | | Italy | | 45 | | 52 | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +similar 52% disagreeing with that statement. In +| | | Greece | 49 | | | 50 | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Bulgaria, only 38% say military force is +| sometimes necessary. | Lithuania | | | 44 | | 48 | | +| --------------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Germany | 52 | | | 47 | | +| | | Bulgaria | 54 | | | 38 | | +| | | Turkey | | 25 | | | 71 | + +NATO +| | MEMBER | | | 36 | | | 57 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MEDIAN +| | | Sweden | | 20 | | | 79 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | Russia | | 27 | | | 70 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Ukraine | | 30 | | | 62 | +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +| | Russia are not NATO member states. | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 19 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout with Specialty Merchandisers and Transitional Components - -Integrating specialty merchandisers into a center store will improve -incremental sales. Utilize transitional components, including bases and -shelves, to draw attention to merchandise within merchandising categories. -The transitional components and shelves also make room for shoppers to -navigate around the specialty displays between the aisles. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Support for military force has changed since +Views of military force have changed +Pew Research Center asked this question in +across several countries +2007. +% who agree that it is sometimes necessary to use +military force to maintain order in the world +For example, in both Ukraine and Russia, two +| | | 2007 | 2019 | Change | +| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------- | +countries engaged in conflict since 2014, +| | | % | % | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +publics increasingly say military force is +| | Ukraine | 51 | 62 | ▲11 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +sometimes necessary (by 11 and 9 percentage +| | Russia | 61 | 70 | ▲9 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +points, respectively). This opinion has also +| | Slovakia | 47 | 53 | ▲6 | +| ----------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | +| become more common in Slovakia and | Germany | 41 | 47 | ▲6 | +| Germany. | Czech Rep. | 62 | 53 | ▼ 9 | +| | Spain | 65 | 55 | ▼ 10 | +Yet in several European countries, support for Italy 73 52 ▼ 21 +military force has waned. This is the case in +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +Italy (a decrease of 21 percentage points), Spain +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +(10 points) and the Czech Republic (9). + +www.pewresearch.org 20 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout using Y-Gondolas as End Caps - - Madix’s Y-Gondola exponentially expands the sales potential of end caps. -Not only does the fixture greatly increase the end cap’s merchandise volume, -but it also makes the merchandise on the end cap visible from wider angles. A -store layout that utilizes Y-Gondolas on short fixture runs will create an inviting -and more shopable center store. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In 12 countries, people on the right of the +Those on the right more likely to say +ideological spectrum are more apt than those +military force can be necessary to +on the left to agree that military force can be +maintain order +justified. In Spain, for example, those on the +% who agree that it is sometimes necessary to use +right are about twice as likely to support +military force to maintain order in the world +military force as their counterparts on the left. +In the U.S., conservatives are 25 percentage +points more likely than liberals to say military +force is sometimes needed. Similarly, 91% of +Republicans and Republican-leaning +independents say military force is sometimes +necessary, while 71% of Democrats and +Democratic-leaning independents agree. +Gender also shapes views of military action. +Across most of the NATO and non-NATO +countries surveyed, men are more likely than +women believe in the need for military force. In +the Czech Republic, for example, 63% of men +say military force is sometimes necessary, +compared with 45% of women. And in Ukraine, +71% of men support military force, versus 56% +of women. Double-digit gender differences are +also present in Germany (14 points), Poland +(12), Bulgaria (12), Hungary (11), Italy (11) and Note: All differences shown are statistically significant. In U.S., +ideology is defined as conservative (right), moderate (center) and +Spain (10). +liberal (left). +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 21 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Across NATO and non-NATO countries, there is +disagreement over whether parts of +Europeans divided over whether parts of +neighboring countries really belong to them. A +neighboring countries belong to them +median of 45% across the 16 NATO countries +% who __ that there are parts of neighboring countries +surveyed disagree, while a median of 35% agree that really belong to us +(in several countries, the share who did not + +| | | | | | Disagree | Agree | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | +express an opinion is relatively high). +| | | Canada | | 65% | | 25% | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | U.S. | 73 | | | 19 | | +The shares who agree with this statement are +highest in Central and Eastern European +| | | Hungary | | | 25 | | 67 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +countries surveyed. About two-thirds of +| Hungarians (67%) agree that parts of | | Greece | | | 27 | | 60 | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| neighboring countries belong to them, | | Bulgaria | | | 22 | | 58 | +Poland +| including 40% who completely agree. In | | | | | 36 | | 48 | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Turkey, 58% agree that parts of nearby | | Slovakia | | | 33 | | 46 | +| countries belong to them. And in neighboring | | Spain | | 60 | | | 37 | +Greece, 60% say the same. +| | | Italy | | | 38 | | 36 | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | France | | 59 | | | 33 | +| In Western European countries, sentiments | Czech Rep. | | | | 33 | | 31 | +tend to run in the opposite direction. In Sweden +| | | Lithuania | | 51 | | | 30 | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(82%), the Netherlands (74%), the UK (72%), +| | | Germany | | 62 | | | 30 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Germany (62%), Spain (60%) and France +| | Netherlands | | 74 | | | 24 | | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(59%), majorities disagree that there are parts +| | | UK | 72 | | | 23 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +of other countries that belong to them. +| | | Turkey | | | 29 | | 58 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +In both the U.S. and Canada, publics +overwhelmingly disagree that parts of other +NATO +| | | | | | 45 | | 35 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| countries belong to them (73% and 65%, | | MEDIAN | | | | | | +respectively). However, a quarter of Canadians +| | | Russia | | | 33 | | 53 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +and roughly one-in-five Americans say the +| | | Ukraine | | | 35 | | 47 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +opposite and agree that there are parts of +| neighboring countries that belong to them. | | Sweden | 82 | | | 13 | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +Russia are not NATO member states. +Russians and Ukrainians tend to agree that +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50f. +parts of neighboring countries belong to them “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| (53% and 47%, respectively). | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 22 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com www.madixinc.com -Texas 500 Airport Road, Terrell, TX 75160 | 800.776.2349 -Alabama 20984 Alabama Hwy 9, Goodwater, AL 35072 | 800.633.6282 -©2014 Madix, Inc. All rights reserved. Not responsible for errors and omissions in printing. Rev. 7/14 - +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In Europe, supporters of right- +wing populist parties tend to be Those with a favorable view of right-wing populist +more likely to say parts of +parties more likely to say parts of other countries +neighboring countries belong +belong to them +to their country. Supporters of +% who agree that there are parts of neighboring countries that really +| right-wing populist parties are | belong to us | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +more likely to agree with this Among those who Among those +| | | do not support __ | | who support __ | | +| --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | +statement for nearly every +| | | | party | party | Diff | +| ----------------------------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | +| European right-wing populist | | | % | % | | +| | Spain | Vox | 32 | 59 | +27 | +party included in the survey. In +| | France | National Rally | 28 | 52 | +24 | +| --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +Spain, for example, those who +| | Germany | AfD | 26 | 50 | +24 | +| --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | +have a favorable view of Vox +| | UK | UKIP | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | 17 | 41 | +24 | +are 27 percentage points more +Freedom and Direct +Czech Rep. +| likely to say parts of another | | Democracy | 27 | 45 | +18 | +| ------------------------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Hungary | Fidesz | 60 | 76 | +16 | +country belong to Spain than +| | Slovakia | Slovak National | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| those who do not have a | | Party | 40 | 54 | +14 | +| favorable view of the party. | | Forum for | | | | +Netherlands +| | | Democracy | 19 | 33 | +14 | +| --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Netherlands | Party for Freedom | | | | +| | | | 21 | 33 | +12 | +Correction (February 12, +| | Italy | Lega | 33 | 43 | +10 | +| --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | +2020): This post has been Sweden Sweden Democrats 11 21 +10 +updated with the proper Poland Law and Justice 44 53 +9 +characterization of NATO's +Note: Only statistically significant differences shown. “Support” percentages represent +founding treaty and revised a respondents who have a favorable view of each party. “Do not support” percentages +represent respondents who have an unfavorable view of each party. For more information +significant difference in +on European populist parties, see Appendix. In Sweden, respondents with an unfavorable +view of the Sweden Democrats were significantly less likely to respond. +Lithuania. The changes due to +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50f. +| these adjustments do not | “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| materially change the analysis | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | +of the report. + +www.pewresearch.org + +23 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Appendix: Classifying European political parties +Classifying parties as populist +Although experts generally agree that populist political leaders or parties display high levels of +anti-elitism, definitions of populism vary. We use three measures to classify populist parties: anti- +elite ratings from the 2017 Chapel Hill Expert Survey (CHES), Inglehart and Norris’s populism +party scale and The PopuList. We define a party as populist when at least two of these three +measures classify it as such. +CHES, which was carried out in January and February 2018, asked 228 regional experts to +evaluate the 2017 positions of 132 European political parties across 14 European Union member +states. CHES results are regularly used by academics to classify parties with regard to their left- +right ideological leanings, their key party platform positions and their degree of populism, among +other things. +We measure anti-elitism using an average of two variables in the CHES data. First, we used +“PEOPLE_VS_ELITE,” which asked the experts to measure the parties with regard to their +position on direct vs. representative democracy, where 0 means that the parties support elected +officeholders making the most important decisions and 10 means that “the people,” not politicians, +should make the most important decisions. Second, we used “ANTIELITE_SALIENCE,” which is a +measure of the salience of anti-establishment and anti-elite rhetoric for that particular party, with +0 meaning not at all salient and 10 meaning extremely salient. The average of these two measures +is shown in the table below as “anti-elitism.” In all countries, we consider parties that score above +a 7.0 as “populist.” +We also used CHES’s “FAMILY” variable to further classify populist groups. Per CHES, family +attribution is based on a combination of “a) membership or affiliation with [European Parliament] +party families, b) Parlgov classifications and c) self-identification.” +Inglehart and Norris emphasize the cultural views of populist parties and created a populist party +scale using the 2014 CHES data for classification.1 This scale aggregates expert ratings of the party +on the following positions and attitudes: 1) support for traditional social values, 2) opposition to +liberal lifestyles, 3) promotion of nationalism, 4) favorable toward tough law and order, 5) +favorable toward assimilation for immigrants and asylum seekers, 6) support for restrictive +immigration policies, 7) opposition to more rights for ethnic minorities, 8) support for religious +1 Inglehart, Ronald F., and Pippa Norris. 2016. “Trump, Brexit, and the Rise of Populism: Economic Have-Nots and Cultural Backlash.” HKS +Faculty Research Working Paper Series. +www.pewresearch.org + +24 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +principles in politics and 9) support for rural interests. The scale ranges from 0 to 100, and parties +with a score of more than 80 are classified as populist. +The PopuList is an ongoing project to classify European political parties as populist, far right, far +left and/or euroskeptic. The project specifically looks at parties that “obtained at least 2% of the +vote in at least one national parliamentary election since 1998.” It is based on collaboration +between academic experts and journalists. The PopuList classifies parties that emphasize the will +of the people against the elite as populist.2 +Two parties are missing data for at least two of the measures used for classification but are still +included for analysis in the report. Vox in Spain is considered a right-wing populist party by +experts, but was not included in any of the measures used due to its relatively recent rise in +popularity. Similarly, Forum for Democracy (FvD) in the Netherlands did not achieve a large +enough share of the votes to be included in the PopuList analysis and was founded in 2016, after +data collection for the Inglehart and Norris analysis. Experts in the most recent round of CHES +classify this party as a right-wing populist party, and its score on the anti-elitism scale exceeds the +cut-off. +Classifying parties as left, right or center +We can further classify these traditional and populist parties into three groups: left, right and +center. When classifying parties based on ideology, we relied on the variable “LRGEN” in the +CHES dataset, which asked experts to rate the positions of each party in terms of its overall +ideological stance, with 0 meaning extreme left, 5 meaning center and 10 meaning extreme right. +We define left parties as those that score below 4.5 and right parties as those above 5.5. Center +parties have ratings between 4.5 and 5.5. +2 Mudde, Cas. 2004. “The Populist Zeitgeist.” Government and Opposition. +www.pewresearch.org + +25 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +European populist party classifications +Inglehart & +Party Country Family Left-right Anti-elitism Norris The PopuList +Populist parties on the left +La France Insoumise France Radical left 1.0 8.9 -- Populist +Podemos Spain Radical left 2.4 8.7 Populist Populist +Syriza Greece Radical left 2.6 7.4 Populist Populist +Populist parties in the center +Action of Dissatisfied Citizens (ANO 2011) Czech Rep. No family 4.9 7.7 Not populist Populist +Five Star Movement (M5S) Italy No family 5.2 9.9 Populist Populist +Populist parties on the right +Ordinary People and Independent +Personalities (OLaNO-NOVA) Slovakia Conservative 6.9 7.2 Not populist Populist +Slovak National Party (SNS) Slovakia Radical right 7.6 4.1 Populist Populist +Sweden Democrats Sweden Radical right 8.0 8.0 Populist Populist +Freedom and Direct Democracy (SPD) Czech Rep. Radical right 8.2 9.8 -- Populist +Lega Italy Regionalist 8.3 7.8 Populist Populist +Law and Justice (PiS) Poland Radical right 8.3 6.2 Populist Populist +Kukiz’15 Poland Radical right 8.3 8.8 -- Populist +Jobbik Hungary Radical right 8.5 7.8 Populist Populist +UK Independence Party (UKIP) UK Radical right 8.6 8.2 Populist Populist +Fidesz Hungary Conservative 8.7 5.7 Populist Populist +Alternative for Germany (AfD) Germany Radical right 9.2 8.7 Populist Populist +Party for Freedom (PVV) Netherlands Radical right 9.3 9.5 Populist Populist +Forum for Democracy (FvD) Netherlands Radical right 9.5 9.5 -- -- +National Rally France Radical right 9.7 8.9 Populist Populist +Vox Spain -- -- -- -- -- +Notes: Golden Dawn (XA) in Greece not included in analysis due to insu fficient sample size. Questions about populist parties were not asked +in Bulgaria or Lithuania. Left-right indicates the average score CHES experts gave each party on an 11-point left-right scale. Scores for +anti-elitism are an average of party position on direct vs. representative democracy and the salience of anti-elite rhetoric within the party. +Source: 2017 CHES. Inglehart and Norris (2016). The PopuList (2019). +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org + +26 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Acknowledgments +This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. +Jacob Poushter, Associate Director, Global Attitudes Research +Moira Fagan, Research Analyst +James Bell, Vice President, Global Strategy +Alexandra Castillo, Research Associate +Jeremiah Cha, Research Assistant +Aidan Connaughton, Research Assistant +Stefan S. Cornibert, Communications Manager +Claudia Deane, Vice President, Research +Kat Devlin, Research Associate +Janell Fetterolf, Research Associate +Shannon Greenwood, Digital Producer +Christine Huang, Research Assistant +Michael Keegan, Senior Information Graphics Designer +David Kent, Copy Editor +Nicholas O. Kent, Research Assistant +Colin Lahiff, Communications Associate +Gar Meng Leong, Communications Associate +Clark Letterman, Senior Researcher +J.J. Moncus, Research Assistant +Martha McRoy, Research Methodologist +Mara Mordecai, Research Assistant +Patrick Moynihan, Associate Director, International Research Methods +Stacy Pancratz, Research Methodologist +Audrey Powers, Senior Operations Associate +Laura Silver, Senior Researcher +Shannon Schumacher, Research Associate +Richard Wike, Director, Global Attitudes Research +www.pewresearch.org + +27 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Methodology +Results for the survey are based on telephone and face-to-face interviews conducted under the +direction of Gallup and Abt Associates. The results are based on national samples, unless +otherwise noted. More details about our international survey methodology and country-specific +sample designs are available here. +www.pewresearch.org + +28 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Topline questionnaire +Pew Research Center +Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey +February 9, 2020 Release +Methodological notes: +• Survey results are based on national samples. For further details on sample designs, see +our international survey methods database. +• The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to +sampling that would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the +United States in the survey: +Group Unweighted sample size Weighted % Plus or minus … +Total sample 1503 3.0 percentage points +Rep/Lean Rep 638 39 4.6 percentage points +Dem/Lean Dem 697 48 4.3 percentage points +• Due to rounding, percentages may not total 100%. The topline “total” columns show 100%, +because they are based on unrounded numbers. +• Since 2007, Pew Research Center has used an automated process to generate toplines for +its Global Attitudes surveys. As a result, numbers may differ slightly from those published +prior to 2007. +• Not all questions included in the Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey are presented in this +topline. Omitted questions have either been previously released or will be released in +future reports. +www.pewresearch.org + +29 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 37 | 18 | 8 | 22 | 100 | +| ------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2018 | 30 | 34 | 14 | 9 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 20 | 42 | 15 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 12 | 41 | 18 | 7 | 21 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 9 | 40 | 20 | 11 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 9 | 40 | 17 | 10 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 39 | 15 | 7 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 14 | 40 | 17 | 7 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 13 | 41 | 15 | 6 | 25 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 42 | 14 | 10 | 23 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 52 | 16 | 4 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 16 | 50 | 11 | 5 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 14 | 42 | 12 | 5 | 27 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 10 | 46 | 18 | 5 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 9 | 48 | 13 | 6 | 23 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 6 | 43 | 26 | 12 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 6 | 54 | 23 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 4 | 45 | 28 | 10 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 7 | 57 | 26 | 9 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 6 | 52 | 29 | 12 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 8 | 59 | 21 | 10 | 1 | 100 | +Spring, 2012 +| | Spring, 2011 | 10 | 60 | 23 | 7 | 1 | 100 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 6 | 62 | 24 | 7 | 2 | 100 | +Spring, 2010 +| | Fall, 2009 | 12 | 59 | 20 | 7 | 1 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 8 | 49 | 26 | 7 | 10 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 11 | 56 | 20 | 5 | 9 | 100 | +| | | 5 | 54 | 26 | 4 | 11 | 100 | +Spring, 2016 +| | Spring, 2015 | 7 | 48 | 29 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2013 | 5 | 54 | 27 | 3 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 8 | 57 | 26 | 4 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 6 | 54 | 29 | 4 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 7 | 50 | 27 | 6 | 9 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 14 | 59 | 18 | 4 | 4 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 2 | 35 | 35 | 16 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 2 | 31 | 33 | 24 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 2 | 23 | 40 | 29 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 3 | 22 | 42 | 23 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 1 | 19 | 37 | 35 | 7 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 11 | 49 | 17 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 8 | 49 | 20 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 9 | 50 | 17 | 10 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 11 | 53 | 18 | 8 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 11 | 49 | 18 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 49 | 18 | 7 | 14 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 53 | 14 | 2 | 20 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | 16 | 56 | 15 | 6 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 24 | 55 | 12 | 3 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 17 | 55 | 14 | 5 | 10 | 100 | +| | | 15 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 9 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +30 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 9 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 13 | 32 | 24 | 16 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 13 | 31 | 24 | 19 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 10 | 37 | 24 | 16 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 11 | 31 | 29 | 18 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 33 | 26 | 20 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 15 | 47 | 21 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 6 | 47 | 23 | 5 | 19 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 49 | 20 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 51 | 21 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 16 | 49 | 20 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 13 | 45 | 27 | 9 | 6 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 45 | 15 | 8 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 23 | 39 | 14 | 5 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 18 | 43 | 10 | 7 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 19 | 41 | 12 | 7 | 21 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 12 | 47 | 13 | 5 | 23 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 15 | 47 | 13 | 4 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 17 | 46 | 12 | 5 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 18 | 42 | 12 | 5 | 24 | 100 | +| | | 22 | 41 | 11 | 6 | 21 | 100 | +Fall, 2009 +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 11 | 31 | 18 | 10 | 30 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 14 | 40 | 21 | 9 | 15 | 100 | +Fall, 2009 +| | Spring, 2007 | 18 | 36 | 18 | 9 | 19 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 12 | 42 | 19 | 8 | 19 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2013 | 8 | 48 | 25 | 7 | 12 | 100 | +| | | 9 | 42 | 28 | 9 | 12 | 100 | +Spring, 2012 +| | Fall, 2009 | 13 | 53 | 20 | 3 | 10 | 100 | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2007 | 9 | 51 | 29 | 7 | 5 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 7 | 41 | 10 | 6 | 35 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 9 | 51 | 19 | 3 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 6 | 51 | 24 | 6 | 13 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 6 | 51 | 17 | 2 | 24 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 30 | 47 | 10 | 2 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 4 | 61 | 17 | 2 | 16 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 50 | 14 | 5 | 22 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 22 | 60 | 6 | 2 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 22 | 57 | 6 | 1 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 12 | 58 | 11 | 1 | 17 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 9 | 65 | 14 | 2 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 7 | 57 | 17 | 3 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 11 | 59 | 16 | 3 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 12 | 60 | 11 | 2 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 18 | 59 | 9 | 1 | 13 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 17 | 58 | 8 | 2 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 15 | 57 | 13 | 4 | 11 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 7 | 44 | 27 | 12 | 10 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 52 | 22 | 4 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 7 | 46 | 30 | 8 | 9 | 100 | +| | | 1 | 15 | 27 | 33 | 24 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +31 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | 1 | 15 | | 27 | 33 | 24 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2015 | 3 | 9 | | 30 | 50 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 4 | 23 | | 32 | 18 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 4 | 18 | | 31 | 21 | 27 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 9 | 28 | | 26 | 17 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 8 | 32 | | 26 | 14 | 20 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 4 | 20 | | 36 | 22 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 5 | 25 | | 28 | 20 | 22 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 39 | | 15 | 8 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 20 | 38 | | 18 | 9 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 4 | 30 | | 23 | 18 | 25 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 10 | 21 | | 24 | 27 | 17 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 7 | 27 | | 24 | 30 | 12 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 3 | 18 | | 21 | 34 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 3 | 20 | | 27 | 31 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 5 | 18 | | 21 | 29 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2014 | 5 | 14 | | 17 | 53 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 5 | 20 | | 21 | 32 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 3 | 12 | | 16 | 43 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 2 | 16 | | 21 | 43 | 17 | 100 | +Q24. If Russia got into a serious military conflict with one of +its neighboring countries that is our NATO ally, do you think +(survey country) should or should not use military force to +defend that country? +| | | Yes, should | No, should not | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --------------- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | use military | | use military | | | | | +| | | force | | force | DK/Refused | | Total | | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 60 | | 29 | | 10 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | | 31 | | 7 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 56 | | 37 | | 7 | 100 | | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 56 | | 38 | | 5 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 58 | | 31 | | 11 | 100 | | +| | | 53 | | 36 | | 11 | 100 | | +Spring, 2015 +| France | Spring, 2019 | 41 | | 53 | | 6 | 100 | | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 53 | | 43 | | 4 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 47 | | 53 | | 0 | 100 | | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 34 | | 60 | | 6 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 40 | | 53 | | 6 | 100 | | +| | | 38 | | 58 | | 4 | 100 | | +Spring, 2015 +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 25 | | 63 | | 12 | 100 | | +| ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 25 | | 71 | | 4 | 100 | | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 25 | | 66 | | 8 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 36 | | 50 | | 14 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 40 | | 51 | | 9 | 100 | | +| | | 64 | | 32 | | 3 | 100 | | +www.pewresearch.org + +32 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q24. If Russia got into a serious military conflict with one of +its neighboring countries that is our NATO ally, do you think +(survey country) should or should not use military force to +defend that country? +| | | Yes, should No, should not | | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ---------------------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | use military | use military | | | +| | | force | force | DK/Refused | Total | +| | | 64 | 32 | 3 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 72 | 23 | 5 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 41 | 56 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 46 | 46 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 48 | 47 | 5 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 55 | 41 | 5 | 100 | +| | | 45 | 43 | 12 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 49 | 37 | 14 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 69 | 18 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 36 | 47 | 16 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 33 | 43 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 49 | 37 | 14 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 51 | 34 | 15 | 100 | +| | | 40 | 43 | 18 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 26 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 48 | 34 | 17 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 55 | 12 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 55 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 29 | 47 | 23 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +33 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q25. And do you think the United States would or would not +use military force to defend that country? +No, would not +| | | Yes, would use | use military | | | +| ------- | ------------ | --------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | military force | force | DK/Refused | Total | +| | | 69 | 25 | 5 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 68 | 21 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 72 | 18 | 10 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 37 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 60 | 36 | 4 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 65 | 34 | 1 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 63 | 31 | 6 | 100 | +| | | 65 | 27 | 7 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 68 | 26 | 6 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 65 | 19 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 31 | 7 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 75 | 16 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 23 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 68 | 23 | 10 | 100 | +| | | 68 | 28 | 4 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 69 | 25 | 6 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 72 | 21 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 70 | 20 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 70 | 21 | 9 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 73 | 22 | 5 | 100 | +| | | 66 | 25 | 9 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 66 | 24 | 10 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 41 | 35 | 24 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 39 | 31 | 30 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 55 | 28 | 17 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 29 | 15 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 47 | 30 | 23 | 100 | +| | | 57 | 26 | 17 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 49 | 31 | 20 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 27 | 16 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 46 | 40 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 40 | 34 | 25 | 100 | +Due to a translation error, the results are not shown for Bulgaria. +www.pewresearch.org + +34 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q35. Which is more important for (survey country)? +Both +| | | Having a close | | relationships | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ----- | +| | | relationship to | Having a close | are equally | | | | | +| | | the United | relationship to | important (DO | | Neither (DO | | | +| | | States | Russia | NOT READ) | | NOT READ) | DK/Refused | Total | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 60 | 18 | 13 | | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 31 | 17 | 40 | | 8 | 4 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 38 | 7 | 45 | | 4 | 6 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | 82 | 11 | 4 | | 0 | 2 | 100 | +| | | 73 | 9 | 9 | | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 71 | 11 | 9 | | 4 | 4 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 83 | 8 | 5 | | 4 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 16 | 28 | 47 | | 4 | 6 | 100 | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 27 | 14 | 39 | | 13 | 7 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 8 | 55 | | 7 | 7 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 17 | 38 | | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 12 | 53 | | 4 | 2 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 23 | 22 | 50 | | 3 | 3 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 13 | 34 | | 9 | 12 | 100 | +Q50f. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. f. There are parts of neighboring countries +that really belong to us +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree | Mostly agree | disagree | disagree | | DK/Refused | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 14 | 27 | 46 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 9 | 22 | 29 | 23 | | 17 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 20 | 34 | 31 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 5 | 14 | 29 | 33 | | 19 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 9 | 24 | 24 | 35 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 18 | 31 | 43 | | 2 | 100 | +| | | 5 | 20 | 30 | 41 | | 4 | 100 | +Summer, 2002 +| | Spring, 1991 | 3 | 9 | 18 | 47 | | 23 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 10 | 20 | 19 | 43 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 23 | 32 | 33 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 9 | 24 | 23 | 39 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 14 | 25 | 26 | 24 | | 10 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 31 | 29 | 18 | | 9 | 13 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 8 | 28 | 19 | 19 | | 26 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 39 | 20 | 14 | | 18 | 100 | +| | | 13 | 29 | 25 | 17 | | 17 | 100 | +Summer, 2002 +| | Spring, 1991 | 9 | 20 | 17 | 32 | | 22 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 7 | 17 | 30 | 44 | | 2 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 17 | 22 | 38 | | 4 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 32 | 29 | 14 | | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 28 | 20 | 12 | 17 | | 23 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 8 | 12 | 70 | | 6 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 18 | 33 | 39 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 6 | 23 | 31 | 29 | | 11 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 28 | 28 | 26 | | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 4 | 16 | 29 | 35 | | 17 | 100 | +| | | 30 | 28 | 15 | | 7 | 20 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +35 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50f. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. f. There are parts of neighboring countries +that really belong to us +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree Mostly agree | | disagree | disagree | DK/Refused | Total | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 30 | 28 | 15 | 7 | 20 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 31 | 35 | 11 | 6 | 17 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 25 | 29 | 13 | 6 | 25 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 19 | 15 | 8 | 24 | 100 | +| | | 12 | 19 | 13 | 20 | 36 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 29 | 24 | 17 | 20 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 24 | 35 | 23 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 20 | 22 | 20 | 16 | 23 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 40 | 27 | 11 | 14 | 8 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 19 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 40 | 30 | 11 | 12 | 7 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 8 | 22 | 23 | 28 | 18 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 10 | 30 | 20 | 19 | 22 | 100 | +| | | 24 | 22 | 15 | 19 | 20 | 100 | +Spring, 1991 +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 36 | 22 | 14 | 17 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2009 | 14 | 37 | 22 | 10 | 16 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 19 | 40 | 19 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 27 | 33 | 15 | 7 | 18 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 13 | 33 | 19 | 14 | 22 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 22 | 30 | 19 | 22 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 11 | 31 | 33 | 18 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 15 | 19 | 15 | 19 | 32 | 100 | +| | | 26 | 27 | 21 | 12 | 14 | 100 | +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 26 | 34 | 17 | 12 | 11 | 100 | +| | | 24 | 37 | 18 | 11 | 10 | 100 | +Spring, 2015 +| | Spring, 2014 | 28 | 33 | 18 | 10 | 11 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2009 | 19 | 39 | 19 | 10 | 13 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 26 | 38 | 14 | 4 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 10 | 12 | 22 | 26 | 30 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 23 | 13 | 22 | 19 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 5 | 19 | 21 | 30 | 25 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 15 | 26 | 36 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 8 | 16 | 21 | 23 | 32 | 100 | +| | | 30 | 28 | 11 | 18 | 14 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Summer, 2002 | 40 | 23 | 9 | 15 | 14 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +36 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50h. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. h. It is sometimes necessary to use military +force to maintain order in the world +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree Mostly agree | | disagree | disagree | DK/Refused | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 46 | 16 | 5 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 26 | 49 | 15 | 8 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 30 | 47 | 13 | 7 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 35 | 42 | 14 | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 47 | 19 | 8 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 26 | 45 | 17 | 10 | 2 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 44 | 15 | 20 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 18 | 44 | 20 | 17 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 19 | 38 | 20 | 23 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 26 | 41 | 18 | 15 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 39 | 38 | 12 | 9 | 3 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 32 | 24 | 28 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 10 | 40 | 28 | 22 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 13 | 33 | 29 | 25 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 11 | 30 | 29 | 29 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 15 | 37 | 23 | 16 | 8 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 19 | 31 | 24 | 25 | 1 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 38 | 27 | 18 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 25 | 48 | 15 | 7 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 31 | 16 | 19 | 2 | 100 | +| | | 19 | 50 | 20 | 11 | 0 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 26 | 18 | 26 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 13 | 49 | 24 | 12 | 1 | 100 | +Spring, 2011 +| | Spring, 2010 | 10 | 45 | 28 | 15 | 2 | 100 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 11 | 54 | 18 | 9 | 9 | 100 | +Spring, 2007 +| | Spring, 1991 | 28 | 18 | 19 | 29 | 7 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 32 | 47 | 12 | 8 | 1 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2007 | 37 | 38 | 11 | 10 | 4 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 18 | 53 | 20 | 9 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 17 | 53 | 17 | 10 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 23 | 50 | 14 | 10 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 19 | 48 | 19 | 9 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 41 | 43 | 8 | 6 | 2 | 100 | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 10 | 28 | 28 | 26 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 13 | 21 | 26 | 25 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 32 | 30 | 15 | 9 | 14 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 17 | 36 | 25 | 12 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 23 | 39 | 22 | 14 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 41 | 13 | 5 | 7 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 27 | 43 | 14 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 34 | 36 | 14 | 7 | 8 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 13 | 35 | 21 | 23 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 7 | 36 | 28 | 23 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 20 | 28 | 17 | 24 | 10 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 43 | 20 | 15 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 19 | 46 | 20 | 8 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 15 | 46 | 24 | 10 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 16 | 40 | 26 | 11 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 26 | 42 | 15 | 5 | 11 | 100 | +| | | 14 | 39 | 25 | 17 | 6 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +37 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50h. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. h. It is sometimes necessary to use military +force to maintain order in the world +| | | | Completely | | | | Mostly | | Completely | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | agree | | Mostly agree | | disagree | | disagree | | DK/Refused | | Total | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | | 14 | | 39 | | | 25 | | 17 | | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 16 | | 31 | | | 28 | | 23 | | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 27 | | 38 | | | 15 | | 7 | | 13 | 100 | +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | | 36 | | 34 | | | 16 | | 11 | | 4 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2014 | | 22 | | 43 | | | 17 | | 12 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | 15 | | 37 | | | 23 | | 15 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | | 23 | | 38 | | | 26 | | 9 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 21 | | 40 | | | 21 | | 10 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 22 | | 40 | | | 13 | | 14 | | 12 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | | 26 | | 36 | | | 16 | | 14 | | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | | 7 | 33 | | | 27 | | 24 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 16 | | 35 | | | 27 | | 17 | | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 12 | | 42 | | | 19 | | 18 | | 10 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | | 38 | | 33 | | | 10 | | 15 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | 25 | | 41 | | | 13 | | 12 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | | 20 | | 29 | | | 21 | | 23 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 36 | | 38 | | | 13 | | 6 | | 6 | 100 | +Q93USA. In politics TODAY, do you consider yourself a Republican, Democrat or Independent? +| | | | | | | | | No preference | | Other party | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | | (DO NOT | | (DO NOT | | | | +| | | Republican | | Democrat | | Independent | | READ) | | READ) | | DK/R | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | | 26 | 31 | | 37 | | 3 | | 0 | | 2 | 100 | +Q93aUSA. ASK IN U.S. IF INDEPENDENT, NO PREFERENCE, OTHER PARTY OR DK/R ONLY: As of +today do you lean more to the Republican Party or more to the Democratic Party? +Other (DO +| | | | Republican | | Democrat | | NOT READ) | | DK/R | | | Total N= | | +| ------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | | 32 | | 39 | | 11 | | | 19 | | 100 | 614 | +www.pewresearch.org \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q24/random_k4/question.json b/q24/random_k4/question.json index f6e03bf7051ddcb6ca90b89fd36f30947ecd6e7b..fa73e7a8a3442f6390c35ca0219f3e181803cb3d 100644 --- a/q24/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q24/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "2024.ug.eprospectus.pdf", - "web_365d195edde4e8ba.pdf", - "web_d44e9a235a572259.pdf", - "web_be38ac4d8053c697.pdf", - "web_7f91d188bac86e23.pdf" + "web_93a0de1d8da7a0cf.pdf", + "resize_r2_11.pdf", + "resize_r1_4.pdf", + "web_2ccba6013fe960b7.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q24/random_k4/random_1.md b/q24/random_k4/random_1.md index 5526b8c35c6c0d7d05b7d26b15fce08f69e7eb06..a334b8d779333a86838d9effd3dd99b5ea050aa5 100644 --- a/q24/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q24/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1865 +1,704 @@ -Morgan Stanley Investment Management +SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING -Asset Management Overview + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING -July 2006 - -Page +W H A T T H I S S E S S I O N W I L L C O V E R 1 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - The information provided herein may include certain non-GAAP financial measures. -The reconciliation of such measures to the comparable GAAP figures are included in -the Company’s Annual Reports on Form 10-K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q and -Current Reports on 8-K, including any amendments thereto, which are available at -www.morganstanley.com. - -This presentation may contain forward-looking statements. You are cautioned not to -place undue reliance on forward-looking statements, which speak only as of the date -on which they are made, which reflect management’s current estimates, projections, -expectations or beliefs and which are subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause -actual results to differ materially. For a discussion of risks and uncertainties that may -affect the future results of the Company, please see “Forward-Looking Statements” -immediately preceding Part I, Item 1, “Competition” and “Regulation” in Part I, Item 1, -“Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A and “Certain Factors Affecting Results of Operations” -in Part II, Item 7 of the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year -ended November 30, 2005, “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial -Condition and Results of Operations” in the Company’s Quarterly Reports on Form 10- -Q for the quarterly periods ended February 28, 2006 and May 31, 2006 and other items -throughout the Form 10-K, Form 10-Qs and the Company’s 2006 Current Reports on -Form 8-K. - -Page - 2 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Table of contents - -Section 1 - -Strengths of MSIM Today - -Section 2 - -MSIM Growth Strategy - -Page - 3 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Section 1 - -Strengths of MSIM Today - -Page - 4 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Is a Key Business of Morgan Stanley - -Morgan Stanley - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Net revenues -Fiscal year 2005=$26,778 million - -19% - -Asset -Management -11% - -12% - -Profit before taxes -Fiscal year 2005=$7,361 million - -8% - -Asset -Management -14% - -65% - -13% - -58% - -Profit before taxes -$ million - -1,007 - -827 - -482 - -462 - -396 - -Institutional Securities Global Wealth Management - -Asset Management Discover - -Asset Management - -Pre-tax profit margin - -30% - -26% - -35% - -29% - -28% - -25% - -22% - -21% - -Return on average -common equity - -36% - -24% - -23% - -17% - -FY 2003 - -FY 2004 - -FY 2005 - -1st Half -2006 - -(1) - -FY 2003 - -FY 2004 - -FY 2005 - -1st Half 2006 - -(1) - -FY 2005 - -1st Half 2006 - -(1) - -MSIM - -MSIM excl. Private Equity - -MSIM - -Morgan Stanley - -1. Six months ended May 31 - -Page - 5 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Key Strengths - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -• Strong brand recognition - -– Morgan Stanley - -– Van Kampen - -• Global footprint - -• Scale - -• Breadth of products - -• Multiple channels of distribution - -• Community of boutiques - -• Full firm commitment and resources - -Page - 6 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Has a Global Footprint - -Products and Distribution - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -New York - -Amsterdam - -Stockholm - -Oakbrook Terrace - -Boston - -London - -Paris - -Frankfurt - -Luxembourg - -San Francisco -Menlo Park - -Houston +What is social media marketing and why is it important -Jersey City +Social media landscape -West Conshohocken +Social media marketing – use cases and benefits -Milan +What does good look like? -Madrid +How to execute a campaign + a club success story -Mumbai +Do’s and Don’ts + additional resources -Hong Kong - -Tokyo - -Singapore - -Melbourne - -MSIM Office Present - -MSIM Distribution Coverage - -Page - -7 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. +2 - STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY + WHAT IS SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING? -Assets ($ billion) +D E S C R I P T I O N -1,513 +The use of social +networks, content +sharing apps, +messaging platforms, +blogs, and forums to +connect with and enable +meaningful +conversations about +your brand, product or +service, to ultimately +drive your business +objective. -1,439 +3 -1,422 + WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? -• In June 2006, Pensions and -Investments ranked Morgan -Stanley #11 by worldwide -assets +C U S T O M E R E X P E C T A T I O N S H A V E C H A N G E D -• MSIM’s strength is in +2X -traditional, actively managed -investments +customers are twice as likely to +share a negative experience with a +business than a positive one -MSIM Has The Scale to Succeed +90% -Top 20 money managers +will look at online +reviews before making +a purchase -Pensions and Investments, June 2006 +74% -Ranking +trust suggestions from +”friends” on social media -1 +67% -2 +of people will spend money after +getting recommendations from +their “friends” online -3 +Sources: White House Office of Consumer Affairs, McKinsey, Experian |24|7, Gigya, CEI 4 -5 - -6 - -7 - -8 - -9 - -10 - -11 - -12 - -13 - -14 - -15 + WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? -16 +N E W T R E N D S A R E E M E R G I N G C H A N G I N G T H E U S A G E A N D I M P O R T A N C E O F S O C I A L -17 +Understanding the social media space and managing your social presence amplifies your marketing +strategy. Social media delivers invaluable insight into your brand awareness, customer sentiment, +marketplace trends, and your competitor’s actions, whilst enabling you to reach more prospects than any +other marketing channel. -18 +Every negative social interaction has a cost -19 +Customers are content creators -20 +Brands are turning online influencers into advocates -Barclays Global +Social is now a prominent point of purchase -State Street Global +Brand focus is shifting to measuring quality of interactions -Fidelity Investments +Reviews can increase sales and add credibility -Vanguard Group +Social is multifunctional – used for marketing, listening, +response, customer care, troubleshooting -Legg Mason +5 -Capital Research + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE -JPMorgan Asset Mgmt. +T H E K E Y P L A Y E R S -Mellon Financial +The social media landscape is large and +complex and cluttered with competing +platforms, but the most heavily utilised +for marketing are the big 4: -Deutsche Asset Mgmt. +Facebook (FB, Instagram, +Messenger) -Northern Trust Global +Google (YouTube) -Morgan Stanley +Twitter -PIMCO +LinkedIn -UBS Global Asset Mgmt. +6 -AllianceBernstein Inst'l + SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE -AIG Global Investment +D I F F E R E N T C H A N N E L S A R E U S E D F O R D I F F E R E N T P U R P O S E S -Merrill Lynch +Social networks +Relationship networks help brands and people connect to share +information and ideas. With a large & regular user base, they are a must- +have and the ”mass-market” approach to social marketing. -Prudential Financial +Use for: customer care, education, daily comms, breaking news -ING +Messaging & chat apps -Wellington Mgmt. +Most widely used apps that enable messaging, video and voice calls. Business +can conduct e-commerce conversations via live agents or chatbots. -Goldman Sachs Asset +Use for: customer care, conversational commerce, payments, status updates, +to replace SMS -958 +Media & content sharing +networks -864 +Find and share media online, including photos, video, and live video or other +curated content. -858 +Consumer review +networks +Manage online reviews and reputation. Positive reviews bring social proof to +your value proposition. Negative reviews provide you with an opportunity to +resolve an issue publicly. -842 +Use for: brand awareness, lead generation, audience engagement, targeted +advertising, influencer marketing -781 +Use for: customer care, reputation management, market research -633 +Blogs & forums +Publish, find, discuss, and share news, information, and opinions. Usually allow +users to remain anonymous, leading to more honest opinions. -618 +Interest-based networks +Help connect with others around a shared interest or hobby and tend to focus +solely on a single subject and provide a dedicated experience for users. -599 +Use for: market research, influencer marketing, product advertising, SEO +results -594 +Use for: targeted marketing, brand awareness, trend watching -581 +7 -579 + SOCIAL MARKETING USE CASES -572 +H O W T O U S E S O C I A L T O M E E T Y O U R O B J E C T I V E S -537 +Manage +own page -531 +Generate +insights -523 +Nurture community +& reputation -521 +Engage with +customers -496 +Grow through +amplification -Investment type: +Draft and publish organic +content to owned +page(s) -T ra dit io na l +Define and manage +content strategy and +calendar -A lt e rna t iv e s +Manage content +approvals -Inde x +Listen/capture social +conversations about LTA, +coaches, or venues and +identify trends -0 +Keep up with competitors +and stay informed of their +social engagement, +content and campaigns -250 +Understand target +audience demographics, +sentiment, and channel +preferences -500 +Grow your community of +social followers and +supporters -750 +Find and nurture +advocates and +influencers who can +credibly promote your +brand to an extended +audience -1,000 +Identify and manage +potential crises -1,250 +Respond to consumer +problems when they +have questions or +concerns -1,500 +Be part of the +conversations about your +venues, coaches or +brand -1,750 +React with relevant +content – use what you +see and hear to help +inform future marketing +strategy -Source: Total assets are from June 2006 Pensions and Investments, using year end 2005 data. Morgan Stanley assets reflect Morgan Stanley consolidated assets -at fiscal year end 2005. Investment types, which are derived from June 2006 Pension and Investments and July 2006 Institutional Investors, are for comparison -purposes +Push paid content to +custom audiences to reach +your marketing objectives -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. +Identify and amplify +relevant user content for +authentic engagement -Page +Social commerce – +increasing number of +businesses are using +social as a payment +channel 8 - MSIM Organization 2006 - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Investment expertise is - -organized around investment -product areas - -• Distribution is organized - -around clients - -John Mack -Firm CEO - -Bob Scully -Firm Co-President + THE BENEFITS OF SOCIAL -Owen Thomas -MSIM President, COO +W H A T S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G C A N D O F O R Y O U -Investments +1. -U.S. & Americas Distribution +Strengthen your +brand reputation -Non-Americas +2. -• Focused on communicating -effectively among the groups +Grow your +business -Dennis Shea -Head and CIO, -Global Equity +3. -David Germany -Head and CIO, -Global -Fixed Income +Care for your +customers -Stuart Bohart -Head and CIO, -Alternatives +Know & act on what is being said about +you +• Things escalate quickly on social. By -Michael Kiley -Head of Americas -Retail & -Intermediary -Distribution +listening to key phrases that relate to your +brand or activity you can be the first to +know when a news story breaks and react +accordingly. -Open -Head of -U.S. Institutional -Distribution +• Social insights also give you an unbiased -Michael Green -Head of MSIM -Non-Americas +view of your brand awareness and +popularity. -Kenneth Winston -Chief Risk Officer +Identify trends +• Trends appear on social media first. Social -• Decentralized, with all -components of the -organization accountable for -financial results +can make or break a product. -Attracting new talent -Internal +• Listening to industry thought-leadership +supports your research and innovation -• Head and CIO Global Equity +Stay ahead of competition +• Your competitors are on social. Analysing -• Head and CIO Alternatives +their social presence delivers unique +insight into their plans and achievements +• Regular benchmarking of your competitors -• Head of Operations +on social helps you keep up with them -• Two investment teams: +Amplify owned content +• Social enables you to publish targeted -External +content to channels that could be seen by +large volumes of users -• CIO London Equity +• The power of influencer marketing -• Two investment teams in Absolute Return Strategies +provides a human voice to your product -• Process-Driven team +Generate earned media +• Customers are 56% more likely to buy a +product or service after seeing a positive +customer-generated post of it -• Global Mid-Cap Equity Market Neutral team +• By reposting user-generated content on +your owned channels, you increase the +trust in your brand and products -• Defined Value team, Absolute Return Strategies +Deliver incremental sales +• Advertising on social media is cheaper +than traditional media (such as TV ads) +but with a massive reach -• Structured Products and Derivatives team +• The main difference is that you will be -• Pension Asset/Liability expertise +able to target finely who sees what advert, +increasing your conversion while keeping +costs down -• Global Infrastructure sector expertise +Create experiences +• Social is more than just advertising, it’s an +educational, emotional and experiential +way to engage your customers -• Six investment professionals: +• Customers no longer want to phone when -• European Senior Loans +they have an issue, they want an +immediate answer and turn to social. -• Alternative Investment Partners +Reduce cost to serve +• With customised chatbots and the use of +artificial intelligence on the rise, in-app +messaging is becoming the norm for +customer care -• Global Value +• Technology solutions enable improved -• International Value +customer service through social -Page +Build a community +• Customers trust each other more than +you. Providing them with a platform +where they can interact and share +feedback will increase their trust and +loyalty to your brand, coaches, or venues. 9 -• Senior U.S. Institutional sales professional - -• Head of Morgan Stanley Funds Distribution - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - -• Senior Middle East sales professional - - • MSIM offers a broad array of -traditional products and is -increasing its offering of -alternative products - -• MSIM utilizes multiple - -channels of distribution -globally leveraging the -Morgan Stanley brand and -resources where possible - -MSIM Product and Distribution Balance + WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY +H O W T O W I N W I T H S O C I A L M E D I A -May 31, 2006 Ending AUM/AUS = $440 billion +A great social media strategy includes the following pillars: -Asset Class +SOCIAL MEDIA +PILLARS -3% 3% +Emotional content -5% +Build rapport with your customers. Forget transactional posts +and focus on posting content that showcases how you will make +a difference in your customers’ life -Distribution +Consistency -20% +Your content should match your brand identity and objectives +and be consistent across channels. -22% +Regular & well- +timed posts -17% +Just like any other channel, there is a better time to post content, +and that varies depending on the network and audience. Keep +your customers interested by posting often and sharing varied +content -21% +Two-way +engagement -51% +Social is about more than just pushing out content. Allow your +customers to interact with you and make sure you respond to +create a differentiated experience -Equity +Optimisation -Fixed Income +Test, learn, adjust, repeat. Iteration is key to success and social +is no different. Plan for A/B testing and track success of +individual campaigns and performance across platforms -Money Market +Personalisation -Alternatives +Strategic use of +channels -Real Estate +Use social insights to know who your customers are and adapt +your messaging, including graphics and tone of voice to target +the right customers with the right message at the right time -Unit Investment Trusts +Not all channels will be relevant to your brand. Whilst a presence +on the Big 4 is a must, focusing your budget and efforts on the +channels where your customers are the most active will deliver +better value for money -23% +Overall strategy +alignment -20% - -15% - -Americas Retail-Morgan Stanley Branded - -Americas Retail-Van Kampen Branded - -Americas Intermediary - -U.S. Institutional - -Non-U.S. - -Page +Driving revenue and engagement from social does require +investment. Incorporate social as its own channel into your +overall strategy, budget and resources 10 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Offers Clients a Broad Product Array - -Key Product Type by Investment Group - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Global Fixed Income -J. David Germany, CIO -AUM=$166 billion (1) - -• Core/Core Plus -• Long Duration -• Mortgage -• Corporate -• Targeted Duration -• Intermediate Duration - -• High Yield -• Short Duration -• Enhanced LIBOR - -• Customized -• Global/International -• Emerging Markets Debt - -• Institutional Liquidity -• Enhanced Cash -• Retail Money Markets - -Global Equity -Dennis Shea, CIO -AUM=$241 billion (1) - -U.S. Equity -• U.S. Small-, Mid-, Multi-, and Large-Cap - -Value - -• U.S. Small-, Mid-, Multi-, and Large-Cap - -Growth - -• U.S. Large-Cap Core -• Systematic Active Equity -• Global REITs (U.S./European/Asian) -• Sector Funds - -Global/International Equity -• International Value -• International Growth -• International Small-Cap -• Global Emerging Markets -• Global Core -• Global Small- and Large-Cap Value -• Global Systematic Active Equity -• European -• Japan (Small-Cap, Value, Growth, Core) -• Asian (ex. Japan) and Pacific Basin - -Asset Allocation -• Balanced Funds -• Global Tactical Asset Allocation - -– Fully Funded - -– Global Macro - -1. Ending AUM/AUS as of May 31, 2006 - -Alternatives -Stuart Bohart, CIO -AUM=$20 billion (1) - -• Absolute Return Strategies (Hedge Funds) - -– Quantitative Equity Strategies -– Fundamental Equity Strategies -– Global Macro Strategies - -• Alternative Investment Partners - -– Fund of Hedge Funds -– Fund of Private Equity Funds -– Insurance Dedicated Fund of Hedge - -Funds - -– Portable Alpha - -• Senior Loans - -− Collateralized Loan Obligations - -• Structured Products and Derivatives - -• Managed Futures - -• Private Equity - -Unit Trusts -AUS=$13 billion (1) - -• Unit Investment Trusts - -Page + WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? + +P U T T I N G S O C I A L M E D I A P I L L A R S I N T O P R A C T I S E + +Conversational & Engaging Content – +Royal Academy & Aldi + +Influencer & Interest-based Marketing – +Gymshark & Wilson + +Royal Academy uses relatable and +humourous posts and interactive +campaigns such as their +#RAdailydoodle to keep their 441K +Twitter followers engaged, drawing +increased user participation and +personalised well-crafted responses + +Aldi UK celebrated their birthday with +a simple, yet creative invitation to +engage competitors, generating a ton +of interest on Twitter and a positive +response, well-tracked via their +unique hashtag +#Aldi30thBirthdayParty + +Gymshark sponsors key Instagram +influencers to capitalise on their large +audiences (500k+). They also use paid +social as a primary means to drive +sales, and in 2019 saw a £73m increase +in turnover. In 2017, their Black Friday +posts drew a 6.6x return on ad spend. + +Influencer marketing can also reap +benefits on a smaller scale. Like the +Germany-based Tennis Siblings Alex +& Sofi, who are sponsored by Wilson +and adidas and use their modest +following of 15K to promote products +and local tennis tournaments. 11 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM Utilizes a Multi-Channel Distribution Approach - -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY - -Core Distribution -Channels - -Customer Tiers - -Americas Retail- -Morgan Stanley Branded - -Americas Retail- -Van Kampen Branded - -Americas Intermediary - -U.S. Institutional - -Non-U.S. - -Morgan Stanley Global -Wealth Management - -• Financial Advisors - -• Private Wealth -Management -Investment -Representatives - -• Broker Dealers - -• Banks - -• Investment Advisors - -• Intermediaries - -• Banks - -• Financial Planners - -• Consultants -• Corporations -• Public Plans -• Foundations -/Endowments - -• Insurance General - -Accounts/ Financial -Institutions - -• Consultants - -• Corporations - -• Public Plans - -• Private Banks - -• Intermediaries - -Core Investment -Vehicles/Products - -Morgan Stanley Brand - -Van Kampen Brand - -Van Kampen Brand - -• Separate Accounts + EXECUTING A CAMPAIGN - WHERE TO START -• Separate Accounts +G E T T I N G T H E B A S I C S R I G H T -• Mutual Funds - -• Mutual Funds - -• Mutual Funds - -• Pooled Trust - -• Liquidity Products - -• Institutional Funds - -• Variable Annuities - -• Platform Business - -• Liquidity Products - -• Société - -• Affiliated Separately -Managed Accounts - -• Variable Annuities - -• Alternative -Investments - -• Unit Investment Trusts +2 -• Alternative -Investments +Identify your audience +and grow followers -• External Separately -Managed Accounts +Start following your members and +people who “look like” them (e.g. +have similar demo, interests, +location, etc.) -• Alternative -Investments +Plan a content calendar and post a +variety of engaging content +including text, photo, and video. -• Variable Annuities +Track performance to see what +content resonates best with your +audience. -• Institutional Funds +3 -• Unit Investment Trusts +Launch and track your +campaign -Morgan Stanley Brand +You can begin with a simple +campaign – such as amplifying a +piece of existing content that +performed well with your existing +followers. -• Institutional Funds +Set up campaigns by objective +(page likes, clicks, etc.) and set a +daily or monthly budget. -• Liquidity Products +Use built-in dashboards from the +social platforms to review +performance and optimise by ad +frequency, time of day, ad format, +and more. -• Société +1 -d'investissement à -Capital Variable -(SICAV) Funds +Set up your account +page(s) -Sub-Advised +Establish your presence by +setting up business account / club +page across the relevant social +platforms -• Mutual Funds +Include essential business +information for search purposes, +including: Location, Contact info, +and Website URL -d'investissement à -Capital Variable -(SICAV) Funds +#Tip: use hashtags to +start a conversation with +your members and easily +follow what they say about +you and your club -• Alternative -Investments +4 -• Investment Trust +Scale up and add on +to master social -Management -Company (ITM) Funds +Once you have your first campaign +under your belt, report on your +performance and measure against +your original business KPIs. -Ending AUM/AUS -As of May 31, 2006 +Refresh your content and launch +new campaigns for different target +audiences. -Page +Explore and introduce more +complex functionality available to +you, including new data sources, +more robust tracking (e.g. FB pixel), +new ad formats, or new social +platforms. 12 -$96 billion - -$90 billion - -$67 billion - -$98 billion - -$89 billion - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - • Performance is key to driving growth - -MSIM Investment Performance + CLUB SUCCESS STORY -• On February 22nd, 2006, Barron’s +N O R B U R Y P A R K L T C -U.S. Mutual Funds Performance +SITUATION -STRENGTHS OF MSIM TODAY +Norbury Park LTC was established in 1889 in the London Borough of Croydon. It +has four floodlit tarmac courts and a small management committee made up +entirely of volunteers. Club membership was at an all-time low so the committee +put together an action plan to significantly increase membership within a year. -annual ranking placed MSIM +APPROACH -– 30th out of 65 fund families for 1- +The club recruited a volunteer Marketing and Communications Officer and decided +to run a Nature Valley Big Tennis Weekend (open day) to showcase the club’s +facilities to the local community and engage prospects. -year performance +Using free resources and content available on My Tennis Toolkit, they created a +Facebook event and advert with a call-to-action to sign up for taster sessions. -– 24th out of 56 for 5-year +OUTCOME -performance +£24 +spent on +Facebook +campaign -– 4th out of 40 for 10-year +Reaching +~3000 target +audience (local +and interested in +tennis) -performance +145 declared +engagements +on FB event +page -– The 1-year rankings placed MSIM +Converted to 69 +bookings – +roughly 80% of +all total +attendees! -outpacing Vanguard, Franklin +Drove an overall increase in club membership by 10% -Templeton, JPMorgan and Putnam - -• On July 5th, 2006, Wall Street Journal - -named seven MSIM funds as "Category - -Kings": +13 -Large-Cap Growth + MEASURING PERFORMANCE -– Morgan Stanley Institutional Focus +A Q U I C K L O O K A T F A C E B O O K A D M A N A G E R -Equity +#Tip: Don’t be intimidated by complexity. +There are tons of available resources online +that offer step-by-step instructions for setting +up a campaign. -% Long-Term Fund Assets Above Lipper Median +Source: Adspresso by Hootsuiite -67% +14 -61% + DO’S AND DON'TS -60% +F O R S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G -48% +DO -71% +Have a social media presence! Today’s consumers expect to be able to find +brands on social media -59% +Pick the right social platforms that best align with your brand, audience and your +marketing goals – whether it’s Instagram, YouTube, or Twitter -61% +Take advantage of free resources and training available to you – including My +Tennis Toolkit, Facebook Blueprint, and Google Marketing Platform -63% +Follow your competitors. See what others are doing well, and find out how you +can differentiate yourself and appeal to those audiences -71% +Get creative! Use social media to find influencers or other unique ways to connect +and engage with your audience -71% +DON’T -76% +…forget to publish content regularly. By maintaining your presence you’ll stay top of +mind with members when they are looking for a coach or venue -76% +…be afraid to launch a social media marketing campaign. You can start small and +build and refine as you learn -1 Year +15 -3 Year + ADDITIONAL RESOURCES -5 Year +H E L P F U L L I N K S T O G E T Y O U S T A R T E D -Aug'05 +LTA Marketing Guides and materials: +https://www.lta.org.uk/workforce-venues/tennis-venue-support/membership-growth-and- +retention/membership-growth/ -Nov'05 +My Tennis Toolkit (includes creative assets for social media): +https://www.lta.org.uk/globalassets/venue/my-tennis-toolkit-usage-guide.pdf -Feb'06 +Facebook Blueprint - free online courses for business marketing: +https://www.facebook.com/business/learn -May'06 +Instagram Advertising: +https://business.instagram.com/advertising -% Rated Assets with Morningstar 4/5-Star Rating +Twitter Advertising: +https://business.twitter.com/en/advertising.html +https://blog.hootsuite.com/twitter-ads/ -– Morgan Stanley Institutional U.S. +LinkedIn Advertising: +https://business.linkedin.com/marketing-solutions/ads +https://blog.hootsuite.com/linkedin-ads-guide/ -47% +Measurement / Tracking: +Google Analytics Academy: https://analytics.google.com/analytics/academy/ +Google Ad Manager: https://skillshop.exceedlms.com/student/path/34897-drive-advertising-revenue- +with-google-ad-manager -45% +16 -Large Cap Growth + ANY QUESTIONS? -– Morgan Stanley Growth - -Multicap Growth - -– Morgan Stanley Capital - -Opportunities - -– Morgan Stanley Aggressive Equity - -Pacific Region - -– Morgan Stanley Pacific Growth - -Real Estate - -– Morgan Stanley Institutional - -International Real Estate - -Page - -13 - -39% - -39% - -Aug'05 - -Nov'05 - -Feb'06 - -May'06 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Section 2 - -MSIM Growth Strategy - -Page - -14 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Growth Strategy - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -Our Strategy for Growth - -Critical Initiatives - -• Increase value of Morgan Stanley’s Asset - -• Build alternatives capability - -Management business - -— PBT growth - -— Multiple (P/E) expansion by - -• Create new traditional products using existing -capabilities and through lift-outs / acquisitions - -• Expand non-U.S. footprint: distribution and - -demonstrating net sales and AUM growth - -products - -• Focus on revenue growth and diversification - -• Invest in Van Kampen - Intermediary and Unit - -by investing in the business - -Investment Trusts growth - -— People - -— Acquisitions - -— Infrastructure - -• Leverage Morgan Stanley franchise and - -MSIM scale and positioning - -• Enhance traditional product strength and build - -Alternatives - -• Performance, performance, performance - -• Stem outflows of Morgan Stanley retail mutual - -funds - -• Rebuild institutional reputation and business, - -particularly in the U.S. - -Page - -15 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Build a Much Broader Alternatives Capability - -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -What We’re Doing - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• The Alternative Investments - -group is composed of 4 distinct -groups: - -– Absolute Return Strategies - -(ARS) - -– Alternative Investment - -Partners (AIP) - -– Senior Loans - -– Structured Products and - -Derivatives (SP&D) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Internal transfer of Structured -Products and Derivatives team - -• Completed lift-out of Process-Driven - -Strategies team - -• Launched / incubated 6 new - -alternative investment products - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Hired Stuart Bohart as the head and - -CIO of Alternatives - -• Completed Oxhead Capital - -acquisition - -• Internal transfer of Defined Value - -team - -• Internal transfer of sector expertise - -to run the global infrastructure -initiative (initiated June 2006) - -• Launched Japanese Equities Market - -Neutral product - -• Re-opened Traxis to new investors - -Absolute Return Strategies - -• Continue efforts on lift-out / -acquisitions, and minority -stakes to build business - -Alternative Investment Partners -• Expand AIP product line and - -introduce new funds - -• Distribution focus on smaller - -mid-market and high net worth - -Senior Loans - -• Growth driven by client focused - -new products through -introduction of funds, -Collateralized Loan Obligations, -Separately Managed Accounts - -Structured Products and -Derivatives - -• Develop custom approaches to - -build structured products -• Introduce Liability Driven - -Investments - -Page - -16 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Enhance Traditional Product Offerings - -Through both Organic Launches and Bolt-on Acquisitions/Lift-Outs -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -• Many top performing equity -strategies at or near capacity - -• Fixed Income products with -improved performance, and -capacity - -• Good performing strategies - -building three year track records - -• Product gaps in large asset - -gathering categories - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 5 new - -equity products - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 8 new - -products - -– 7 Equity -– 1 Fixed Income - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -What We’re Doing - -Organic launches - -• Leverage current talent pool to - -build out strong product -pipeline - -Acquisitions / lift-outs - -• Targeted acquisitions / lift-outs -to complement our existing -product line - -Page +THANK YOU 17 -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Expand Non-U.S. Footprint - -Distribution and products - -What We Have - -• $89 billion, or 20% of MSIM - -AUM/AUS is sourced from non- -U.S.(1) - -• MSIM is represented in 13 non- - -U.S. countries - -• Outside of the U.S., portfolio - -managers are located in: - -– Europe -– Japan -– Singapore -– India - -What We’ve Done - -First Quarter 2006 -• Increased distribution focus on - -Alternatives - -• Signed a global agreement with - -Merrill Lynch Global Private -Client division to distribute MSIM -products through Merrill Lynch's -International distribution network -worldwide - -Second Quarter 2006 -Middle East -• Hired sales head -• Leveraging Firm’s Dubai office - -China -• Dedicated sales hire -• Applied (and gained the approval - -in July 2006) for license to -manage domestic Chinese equity -products - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -What We’re Doing - -Expand the footprint -• Asia - -– Korea -– Australia -– China -– India - -• Europe - -– Middle East -– Switzerland - -• Fill product gaps - -• Explore new client opportunities: - -central banks and direct -wholesaling - -• Evaluate acquisitions in - -– Australia -– China -– Brazil -– Korea -– Taiwan - -1. - -Total MSIM AUM/AUS of $440 billion as of May 31, 2006 - -Page - -18 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Invest in Van Kampen - Intermediary and Unit Investment Trusts Growth -What We Have - -What We’re Doing - -What We’ve Done - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Vibrant $100+ billion fund and Unit - -Investment Trusts complex - -(1) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched Van Kampen - -– 6th largest 3rd party fund sponsor -– One of the fastest growing - -(2) - -complexes over the last 4 years - -(2) - -– 2nd largest Unit Investment - -Trusts sponsor - -(3) - -• Strong brand presence within broker - -community - -• Established leader with distinguished -capabilities in several key product -areas: U.S. Large Cap Value / U.S. -Moderate Allocation / High Yield -Municipals / Senior Loans - -• Leader in intermediary platform - -market - -– On 20 of top 25 annuity platforms -– On 22 of top 25 Defined -(5) -Contribution platforms - -– Attractive blend of run rate and - -(4) - -takeover business flows - -International Growth Fund and -Van Kampen Leaders Fund - -• Introduced new retirement - -education and support materials - -• Increase resources for high growth / - -margin businesses: - -– Defined Contribution: - -Doubling field sales force -– Unit Investment Trusts: - -38% increase in field sales force - -• Added Variable Insurance field - -• Expand product offering to add - -sales professionals - -diversity - -– International & Global -– Closed End Funds -– Income Oriented products -– Retail Separately Managed - -Account strategies - -• Position Van Kampen to take - -advantage of retirement markets -from a product and distribution -standpoint - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Launched Van Kampen Equity - -Premium Income - -• Issued 14 new Unit Investment - -Trusts products - -• Introduced new television - -advertising - -1. AUM/AUS as of May 31, 2006 -2. Source: Strategic Insights, May 2006 -3. Source: ICI, May 2006 - -Page - -19 - -4. Source: VARDS, 4th quarter 2005 -5. Source: Pensions and Investments, June 2005 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -Stem Outflows of Morgan Stanley Retail Mutual Funds -What We Have - -What We’ve Done - -What We’re Doing - -• Morgan Stanley Advisors funds -(excluding Money Market and -Closed End) represents 7% of -total MSIM AUM/AUS (1) - -• Favorable market share in - -Morgan Stanley Global Wealth -Management Group (GWMG) - -• Outflows in Morgan Stanley - -Advisor products - -First Quarter 2006 -• Deployed a new client focused - -field coverage model - -– Assigned dedicated internal -and external wholesalers to -distributing Morgan Stanley -Funds in Morgan Stanley -GWMG - -Second Quarter 2006 -• Hired the head of Morgan -Stanley Funds Distribution - -– A newly created position to - -focus on the Morgan Stanley- -branded funds - -• Preserve favorable market share - -in Morgan Stanley GWMG - -• Actively pursue third party - -distribution of Morgan Stanley -Funds in 401(K), financial -planner, and Registered -Investment Advisor communities - -• Develop distinctive Morgan - -Stanley fund offering - -– Launch distinctive new - -products - -– Rationalize existing product - -line - -1. - -Total MSIM AUM/AUS of $440 billion as of May 31, 2006 - -Page - -20 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Rebuild Institutional Reputation and Business, Particularly in the U.S. -What We Have - -What We’re Doing - -What We’ve Done - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• $187 billion in AUM, 43% of - -MSIM total (1) - -• MSIM covers over 100 consulting - -firms - -• Manages assets for 20 of the top -50 U.S. Pension funds, 56 of the -top 200 U.S. Pension funds (2) - -First Quarter 2006 -• Launched / incubated 9 new -products within the channel - -• Conducted road shows with - -consultants and clients - -Second Quarter 2006 - -• Launched / incubated 9 new -products within the channel - -• Internal transfer of Pension Asset -/ Liability management expertise - -• Senior management meetings - -and road shows with consultants -and clients - -• Hosted the annual investment -roundtable of industry thought -leaders (Lyford Cay Conference) - -Client - -• Communicate MSIM story to - -clients and consultants -• Form Institutional Client - -Solutions Group - -• Leverage client service - -People - -• Hire US Institutional leader -• Hire additional salespeople - -Product - -• Develop products to address - -client needs - -• Enhance ability to place - -alternatives - -• Communicate Fixed Income - -turnaround story - -• Retain clients in International - -Value Equity products - -1. As of May 31, 2006 -2. Source: P&I Databook, January 23, 2006. It includes Corporate and Public Funds - -Page - -21 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Summary: Measuring Our Progress - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -First Year - -Two to Three Years - -Three to Five Years -Three to Five Years - -Business Investment - -Gaining Traction - -Results - -• New management team - -• Filled leadership gaps - -• Reorganized business by - -product and client segment - -• Bottom up business plan - -• Seeded new products - -• Built infrastructure - -• Actively pursued new talent to - -manage money - -• Opened lines of communication - -• Positive flows - -• More complete traditional - -product offering - -• Improved margin - -• Completion of several - -acquisitions - -• Multiple direct hedge fund - -strategies - -• Restructured Morgan Stanley - -Advisor Fund family - -• Leader in the asset - -management business with a -reputation for excellent -performance, innovative -products and superior client -service - -Page - -22 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - - Measuring Our Performance: Key Success Metrics - -MSIM GROWTH STRATEGY - -• Net revenues - -• Pre-tax margin - -FY 2005 Results (1) - -Aspiration - -$2.9 billion - -Double digit growth - -35% (incl. Private Equity) - -29% (excl. Private Equity) - -30%~35% - -• Assets Under Management - -$431 billion - -$600 billion+ - -• Net Flows - -($19) billion - -Strong and competitive -positive flows - -• FY New products launched - -3 - -• Retail Product Performance - -– % of Morningstar rated assets in 4/5 star - -45% - -30+ - -50%+ - -funds - -1. Full Year ended November 30, 2005 - -Page - -23 - -This slide is part of a presentation by Morgan Stanley and is intended to be viewed as part of that presentation. The presentation is based on information -generally available to the public and does not contain any material, non-public information. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. The -presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is neither an offer to sell nor the solicitation of an offer to buy any security or instrument -and has not been updated since it was originally presented. - diff --git a/q24/random_k4/random_2.md b/q24/random_k4/random_2.md index 405f7d94774fb08f29f0d478b4b1f971f0f80612..c05964fb61069ec32fdddf54cf1bb59049463e31 100644 --- a/q24/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q24/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,705 +1,1655 @@ -Fixture and Store Designs that Draw Shoppers -into the Center Store to Capitalize on Sales - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Sources Cited - -Cohen, Deborah A., and Susan H. Babey. “Candy at the Cash Register — A Risk Factor for Obesity -and Chronic Disease.” New England Journal of Medicine. (2012): n. page. Web. 21 Jan. 2013. -. - -Sorensen, Herb. Inside the Mind of the Shopper. 1st ed. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education, -Inc., 2009. - -Strom , Stephanie. “In Grocery Stores, the Perimeters Take Center Stage.” New York Times -10/08/2012, New York edition B1. www.nytimes.com/2012/08/11/business/in-grocery-stores-the- -perimeters-take-center-stage.html?pagewanted=all - -Underhill, Paco. Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping. 1st ed. New York: Simon & Schuster -Paperbacks, 2009. 3-27. - -“Stop Shopper Leakage in Center Store.” Shopper Sight News. 70 (2012): n. page. Web. 21 Jan. 2013. -. - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. -Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -If store perimeter provides “sizzle,” center store must serve “steak” - -Colorful, creative, winding and sometimes even whimsical in-store perimeter displays of -produce, sampling stations, deli, sushi and coffee bars, and endless walls filled with everything -from flat screen TVs to the hottest brands of clothing are no doubt here to stay. Engaging -perimeter presentations are among the latest trends in fashionable and attractive retail -merchandising that represent a sweet spot for today’s progressive merchandisers looking for fresh -new ways to connect with shoppers. - - However, while perimeter sales within many mid- to large-size shopping environments clearly -represent a vibrant growth trend, a similar merchandising discipline and focus should be applied -to the center store. After all, smart merchants understand that what’s good for the perimeter -should also be good for the interior, because what good is the sizzle of the perimeter shopping -zone without the steak -- and inherent profit margin -- of the center store? - - Unfortunately, center store is more often than not treated as a warehouse of separate products -on cold, uninviting rows of fixtures. While shoppers may find the products in center store they -need, they seldom find the solutions they truly want to make their lives more enjoyable or -productive. How will that new jacket or shampoo fit their lifestyle? How can that product, or -combination of ingredients, help them make a better or healthier meal? Why will that dog food -help their pet be healthier and happier? - -Madix has introduced new products that improve merchandise visibility. Radius and Wraparound Shelves -used on end caps make merchandise down inline runs more noticeable because these shelves do not - utilize end panels, which normally obstruct merchandise as you look down a run. +FOR RELEASE FEBRUARY 9, 2020 +BY Moira Fagan and Jacob Poushter +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: +Jacob Poushter, Associate Director, Global Attitudes Research +Stefan Cornibert, Communications Manager +202.419.4372 +www.pewresearch.org +RECOMMENDED CITATION +Pew Research Center, February, 2020, “NATO Seen Favorably +Across Member States” + +1 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +About Pew Research Center +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes +and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center conducts +public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social +science research. It studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and +technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social +and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew +Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. +© Pew Research Center 2020 +www.pewresearch.org + +2 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +How we did this +This analysis focuses on views of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) among 16 +member nations and three nonmember nations in Europe and North America. In all, the analysis +covers over 90% of the population living in NATO countries. +Pew Research Center has been tracking views of NATO since 2007. This report also includes views +of Article 5 obligations, which state that an attack on one NATO country is an attack on all; +preferences for close relations with the U.S. versus with Russia; support for the use of military +force to maintain order in the world; and agreement with the sentiment that parts of neighboring +countries belong to another country. +For this report, we used data from a survey conducted across 19 countries from May 13 to Aug. 12, +2019, among 21,029 respondents. The surveys were conducted face-to-face in Central and Eastern +Europe, Greece, Italy, Russia and Ukraine. Surveys were conducted over the phone in North +America and Western Europe. +Here are the questions used for the report, along with responses, and its methodology. +www.pewresearch.org 3 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -What’s actually happening in center store? - -Retail store perimeter growth has come mostly from the pull demand from customers wanting - -fresh, unprocessed foods and products that exude health, youthful appeal and entertainment. -Nowhere is the effect on center store sales more evident than in grocery stores and big food -brands such as Heinz, Kraft and Kellogg. Published reports indicate sales or volume declines -as large as 2.8-percent for some of these powerhouses due to the shifting consumer interest in -healthier non-processed food choices most often found on the perimeter of grocery stores. As -a result, packaged goods manufacturers are researching ways to leverage the popularity of the -perimeter through cross merchandising to make the center store -- along with their profitable -brands -- more exciting and appealing to shoppers. - - Unfortunately, center store sales within most retail environments have been decreasing in -recent years. The reasons why are akin to the proverbial elephant in the room. Rather than -address this huge challenge head-on, many retailers have instead decided to ignore it and focus -on what is working from a perceptual standpoint, which is the perimeter. Regardless of the center -store neglect, and using grocery stores as an example, a report by John Lewis, president, consumer -North America for The Nielsen Company, points out that the center store represents 73-percent -of total store sales and 77-percent of profit despite growing shopper leakage from people who -browse and think about a purchase but ultimately don’t buy. This imbalance of sales and profits -between center and perimeter can be addressed not only through SKU count, but also through -lower margins in the perimeter due to high labor costs and shrink. - -This tale of the two shopping zones is supported by a Center Store Mega Study of 2 million -individual shopping trips that found as many as a quarter of shoppers walk the center store yet -don’t buy anything (“Shopper Sight News”). In addition, during the average 13-minute shopping -trip, shoppers spend on average only two minutes in the center store. Clearly when analyzing -the chasm between center store sales and the average time spent there by shoppers, the -opportunities are enormous for progressive retailers to better integrate perimeter and center store -merchandising efforts targeted at growing customers’ overall baskets. - -So, if bold, new methods of merchandising are working to drive traffic for the perimeter, -why are retailers continuing to ignore the bread and butter represented by the center store? -Within this vast and extremely valuable internal battlefield, most stores still stubbornly stick -with outdated merchandising methodology including everything from shelving and lighting to -traffic patterns and category management. The dichotomous relationship that currently exists -between the perimeter and center store ignores how shopping patterns have shifted and, more -importantly, represents lost sales opportunities. - - When asked to comment, Blake Sloan, partner and store designer at the full-service -architecture and design firm, Heights Venture Architects L.L.P., noted that the center store is often -not addressed with the same creative thought process as the perimeter. - -“It’s extremely difficult to break away from product-centric category management and focus -efforts towards a consumer-centric shopper management,” said Sloan. “The potential profit power -represented by the center store is too valuable to simply ignore. Instead, we suggest retailers -envision the center store experience as a unique merchandising and marketing opportunity. -Retailers should enhance the center store with creative fixturing, lighting and product -identification as they would for the perimeter to create a holistic total store experience to build -customer loyalty and improve sales and profits.” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +NATO is generally seen in a positive light across publics within the alliance, despite lingering +tensions between the leaders of individual member countries. A median of 53% across 16 member +countries surveyed have a favorable view of the organization, with only 27% expressing a negative +view. But opinions of NATO and related issues vary widely across the countries surveyed, +especially regarding the obligations of Article 5 of the 70-year-old Washington Treaty, which +declares that an attack against one member nation is considered an attack against all members. +Positive ratings of NATO among members range from a high of 82% in Poland to 21% in Turkey, +with the United States and Germany in the middle at 52% and 57%, respectively. And in the three +nonmember states surveyed, Sweden and Ukraine see the alliance positively (63% and 53%, +respectively), but only 16% of Russians say the same. +NATO seen favorably in member states, but few in Turkey agree +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 4 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - As a New York Times article entitled “In Grocery Stores, the Perimeters Take Center Stage” -by Stephanie Strom recently stated, “Long, soldier-straight rows of shelves...have long been the -heart of the American grocery store but are now showing signs of the grocery equivalent of -atherosclerosis.” The same could be said of pretty much any mid- to large sized retailer offering -hundreds, if not thousands of SKUs on the floor. After all, is there anything less inviting than -staring down a narrow, 60-foot long aisle boarded by shelves upon shelves of cans and boxes that -all seem to blend together? - -The bigger, more important equation is how to create a more pleasant and inviting center store - -that works with, if not mimics, the perimeter? Solving the problem of how to keep shoppers in -the center store longer than the average two minutes with a sexier, well-thought-out solutions- -oriented approach would go a long way toward moving more high-margin goods and better -leverage consumer needs to win more of their shopping trips. - - While there is no single solution to the center store challenge, here are 10 smart tips that can -go a long way toward creating a holistic shopping experience that leverages the entire store and -drives up both sales and profits. - -Solution #10: Take the edge off - - Old-school thinking is that if you trap the shopper and force them to pass by lots of product -facings, you’ll create more sales opportunities. Still, some retailers persist in creating canyons of -metal shelving and expecting customers to willingly funnel through them. In fact, the opposite -is true. Not only do shoppers dread entering long aisles, in their hurry to get through them they -often scurry past products they might otherwise be interested in purchasing. - -“Too many stores suffer from the ‘peek and run’ syndrome where shoppers simply refuse to -enter long rows bordered by high shelving on either side unless they absolutely have to,” said -Shawn Kahler, Madix Vice President of Sales and Marketing. “This effectively negates any hope -shoppers will spend any meaningful time in the center store, and it certainly doesn’t create a -pleasant in-store experience.” - -Kahler says the answer is quite obvious: make aisles shorter, less linear and overall more appealing -to remove the intimidation factor in hopes shoppers will choose to walk through the store, enter -aisles, browse and shop. - -“It’s actually possible to create many different types of unique, interesting and appealing aisles - -by using standard parts and fixtures rather than designing custom shelving that is often cost -prohibitive,” he said. “For example, Madix, Inc. offers retailers several options such as its curved -gondola system that actually use standard gondola and wall parts to better manage space and -generate a maximum return on investment.” - - He says that radius curves of 6 or 10 feet provide maximum flexibility to retailers who wish to -transform their outdated straight aisles into something more inviting and productive. There are -also much longer sweeping, curved fixtures that create a panorama effect of products that are -also pleasing to the eye and create much more product visibility than do long, straight and narrow -aisles. The key learning is that retailers have available to them the tools and professional expertise -enabling them to create better, more effective center stores. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Favorable views of the organization have fluctuated over time among both NATO member and +nonmember countries. Since the late 2000s, favorable opinions of NATO are up 10 percentage +points or more in Ukraine, Lithuania and Poland. However, positive opinions of NATO are down +significantly in Bulgaria, Russia, Germany and France over the past decade, with double-digit +percentage point declines in each of these countries. Favorable views of the organization are also +down significantly in Spain and the Czech Republic. +Views of NATO have changed in both member countries and among non-NATO +members over past decade +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. Germany’s 2018 results from Körber-Stiftung survey conducted there Sept. 13-26, 2018. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 5 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Madix’s Radius end caps married with curved Maxi Line draw shoppers into the center store. -The undulating shelves make merchandise stand out. Madix offers components to curve -entire fixture runs, fixture sections, or individual shelves. - -In combination with shorter and more organic-shaped aisles, Dr. Herb Sorensen, Ph.D., author - -of “Inside the Mind of the Shopper,” advocates staggering the fixture patterns themselves from -section to section to break up long sight lines. The outcome of this advice is that as a shopper -looks down any aisle toward the center store, they actually see the end cap of the next shelving -fixture or more inviting concave or radius shelving and not the other side of the store. - -Solution #9: Drop the height of shelving - - Merchants seem to love using vertical space. The higher, the better, right? Actually, according -to Dr. Sorensen, people do not prefer to shop tall shelves crammed with products in the center -store. Instead, they respond best when faced with shelving that’s 66 inches or lower and 15 to 20 -feet long or not longer than 30 feet. Such shelving ensures customers can easily see and navigate -their way through the store without feeling trapped or lost. An exception would be a retailer such -as JCPenney which has begun using tall walls on the perimeter of its stores where they do not -interfere with sight lines to promote fashion accessories. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In addition, across several countries surveyed, favorable views of the organization are related to +ideological orientation, with those on the right sharing a more positive view than those on the +ideological left. +NATO serves as a political and military alliance for its 29 member states spanning Europe and +North America. Founded in 1949 to provide collective defense against the Soviet Union, the +alliance seeks to balance Russian power and influence, in addition to a host of other operations. +Despite the organization’s largely favorable ratings among member states, there is widespread +reluctance to fulfill the collective defense commitment outlined in Article 5 of NATO’s founding +treaty. When asked if their country should +defend a fellow NATO ally against a potential +NATO publics more likely to believe U.S. +attack from Russia, a median of 50% across 16 +would defend them from Russian attack +NATO member states say their country should +than to say their own country should +not defend an ally, compared with 38% who say +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +their country should defend an ally against a +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +Russian attack. ally, __ to defend that country +Publics are more convinced that the U.S. would +use military force to defend a NATO ally from +Russia. A median of 60% say the U.S. would +defend an ally against Russia, while just 29% +say the U.S. would not do so. And in most +NATO member countries surveyed, publics are +more likely to say the U.S. would defend a +NATO ally from a Russian attack than say their +own country should do the same. +In terms of transatlantic relations, some +Western European publics prefer a close +relationship with the U.S., but many others +prefer a close relationship with both the U.S. +and Russia. Nevertheless, few want to prioritize +Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. The U.S., Russia +their relationship with Russia over their U.S. +and Ukraine were not asked both questions. Bulgaria not included +relations. Ideology also relates to views of due to a translation error. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q25. +potential allies: Those on the right in several +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +countries are more likely than those on the left PEW RESEARCH CENTER +to prefer a relationship with the U.S. +www.pewresearch.org 6 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -In addition, traditional straight-faced shelves in most stores are designed to hold a maximum -capacity of products from top to bottom, but they are not shopper friendly. Such a design stifles -the ability to view products on lower shelves, often forcing the shopper to take a few steps back -into what may be a crowded aisle to see what’s on the bottom shelves. Such fixtures also visually -create a closed-in, claustrophobic feeling as shoppers walk down an aisle. - - One solution is to install pyramid-style fixtures on both sides of an aisle. Such fixtures have top -shelves that are recessed from the shopper by about 16 inches, giving shoppers nearly three full -feet of apparent extra aisle width. This allows higher-velocity products to be inventoried on lower -shelves while featuring higher-priced or lower-velocity items toward the top where they can gain -more exposure. - - A less radical alternative to pyramid fixtures is an offset shelving design that moves one or -more of the top shelves back in small increments between 8-12 inches. While slightly less effective -than pyramid fixtures, offset shelving still helps reduce the train-tunnel effect and allows the use -of sloped signboards that can be used for various in-store marketing devices such as digital media. - -Regardless of the type of fixture that’s used, Dr. Sorensen points out that there is a delicate -balance between trying to capture the shopper’s time, holding a shopper at a product display, and -closing the sale. Trying to sell too much within a small space can actually harm sales conversion, -because the longer it takes a shopper to make up his or her mind, the more angst they feel, the -more likely they are to abandon that area of the store, and the less time they are apt to linger in -other areas of the store. The rule of thumb should be convenience, which translates into fast. - -Madix’s product lines are available in numerous sizes, -so a retailer can deploy fixtures that best meet its sales objectives. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Despite the reservations many have about NATO’s Article 5 commitments, half or more in nearly +every country surveyed agree it is sometimes necessary to use military force to maintain order in +the world. In most countries surveyed, those who say military force is sometimes necessary are +also more likely to agree that their country should use military force to defend a fellow NATO ally. +These views have changed significantly over the past decade in some countries. In Ukraine, Russia, +Slovakia and Germany, more say military force is sometimes necessary than said the same in +2007. And in Italy, Spain and the Czech Republic, publics have grown less inclined to agree. +On the topic of territorial ambitions, when asked if there are parts of neighboring countries that +really belong to their country, relatively few surveyed agree. However, among NATO member +states, majorities in Hungary, Greece, Turkey and Bulgaria agree that parts of other countries +belong to them. In many European countries, those with a favorable view of right-wing populist +parties are more likely to support this statement. +These are among the key findings from a Pew Research Center survey of 19 countries, including 16 +NATO member states, Sweden, Russia and Ukraine. The survey was conducted among 21,029 +people from May 13 to Aug. 12, 2019. Throughout this report, German results are occasionally +sourced from a series of surveys conducted in Germany by Körber-Stiftung, in partnership with +Pew Research Center. +www.pewresearch.org 7 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Solution #8: Widen the aisles - - Using pyramid or offset fixtures are simple methods to effectively open up aisles visually and -literally from the feet up to head height, but another more obvious solution is to simply widen the -entire aisle. Some retailers serve up just enough room for two carts to pass by one another in an -aisle, while others make it almost impossible for even a single cart to pass between displays. While -the solution will vary between retail formats, the outcome should always cater to what makes the -shopper most comfortable and put them in a buying, not evacuation, mode. - -In general, shoppers equate open space with the freedom to shop. The best way to generate - -traffic is to allow traffic to flow without restrictions. A shopper at a store with tall, narrow aisles -is less likely to enter the aisle if it has but one other shopper in it, much less several. With such -aisles, a single shopper with a cart stopped in an aisle can occupy as much as 10 feet of shelf facing, -effectively blocking that merchandise from other potential buyers. Obviously, this leads to far -fewer sales opportunities. - - On the other hand, a shopper at a store with aisles able to accommodate multiple shoppers -shoulder-to-shoulder is less likely to turn away. In this scenario, even if another shopper is camped -in front of a shelving unit another shopper can stand to the side and browse. The key is to allow a -relatively free flow of multiple shoppers through any aisle at any time. - - Dr. Sorensen states that open space combined with short and low fixtures are open invitations -to shop. Likewise, he says, “Narrow, crowded aisles like packed highways can lead to social -pathology and even ‘aisle rage,’” whereby shoppers become angry at one another for blocking -each other or even blame the store for failing to be customer friendly. Ironically, retailers who do a -good job merchandising their perimeters typically do so with wide aisles, low fixtures and a sense -of openness. So why not apply the same principles to the center store experience where upward -of 75-percent of all sales occur? - -Madix designs its products to more efficiently utilize space, -which means a retailer can devote more space around fixtures to its shoppers. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Across the 16 NATO member countries +Views of NATO +surveyed, NATO is generally seen in a positive +% who have a __ opinion of NATO +light. A median of 53% across these countries +have a favorable view of the organization, while Unfavorable Favorable +| a median of 27% have an unfavorable opinion. | | Canada | | 20% | | | 66% | +| ----------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| In 13 of these countries, roughly half or more | | U.S. | | 26 | | 52 | | +have a positive view of NATO. +| | | Poland | | 8 | | | 82 | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Among NATO member countries, positive views | | Lithuania | | 12 | | | 77 | +of the organization range from 82% in Poland Netherlands 21 72 +to 21% in Turkey. Majorities of people in +| | | UK | | 23 | | | 65 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Poland, Lithuania, Netherlands, the United +| | | Italy | | 24 | | | 60 | +| ---------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Kingdom, Italy and Germany rate NATO | | Germany | | 33 | | 57 | | +| positively in Europe. Opinions are also | Czech Rep. | | | 27 | | 54 | | +relatively positive in the Czech Republic, +| | | Slovakia | | 39 | | 51 | | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Slovakia, France, Spain, Hungary and Bulgaria. +| | | France | | 38 | | 49 | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Spain | | 42 | | 49 | | +| Canadians and Americans hold positive views | | Hungary | | | | | | +| | | | | 16 | | 48 | | +of NATO, with 66% in Canada and 52% in the +| | | Bulgaria | | 28 | | 42 | | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +U.S. expressing favorable opinions. +| | | Greece | 51 | | | 37 | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +In Turkey and Greece, publics are particularly +| | | Turkey | 55 | | 21 | | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +unfavorable toward the alliance: Roughly half +NATO +or more express a negative opinion. +| | MEMBER | | | 27 | | 53 | | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MEDIAN +Among the three non-NATO countries +| | | Sweden | | 28 | | | 63 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +surveyed, views of the alliance are mixed. In +| | | Ukraine | | 23 | | 53 | | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Sweden and Ukraine, more than half have a +| | | Russia | 60 | | 16 | | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +favorable view of NATO. But in Russia, 60% +have an unfavorable view of the organization, Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +Russia are not NATO member states. +while just 16% view it favorably, the smallest +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +share across all countries surveyed. “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 8 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Another, less obvious reason to expand aisles is what Paco Underhill, author of “Why We Buy: -The Science of Shopping,” calls the “butt-brush effect.” During research his firm conducted -for Bloomingdale’s department store, they inadvertently observed shopper interaction with a -clothing fixture near a ground-floor entrance they were monitoring. The fixture was adjacent to -a high-traffic aisle, and they saw that customers interacting with the fixture would typically get -“butt-brushed” from behind by people heading into or out of the store. After a few such bumps, -shoppers abandoned the fixture and moved on without buying. As a result, sales from the fixture -were well below expectations. After moving the fixture to another location that eliminated -the possibility of butt-brush, the retailer found that sales from the fixture immediately and -substantially increased. It simply boiled down to location. - -The question retailers should be asking themselves is how often their customers are spooked - -by being too close to one another or being brushed against other shoppers trying to navigate -around them? The solution may be something as easy as a realignment of a fixture or a more -complicated readjustment of the entire aisle space. - -Solution #7: Go mobile - -Part of the challenge of store fixtures is that they are by definition “fixed,” meaning they -often are anchored in place and unlikely to be moved outside of major store resets. Rather than -be entirely tethered by immovable fixtures, some of the world’s most successful retailers have -embraced the more fluid flexibility of mobile displays to complement or, in radical cases, supplant -stationary displays. - - Granted, fixtures on castors are not a new concept, but the use of such shelving is not -necessarily widespread, especially in the center store area. An example of a retailer that lives by -mobile fixtures is one of Europe’s most successful shoe store chains, Leder & Schuh’s. L&S has -virtually no immoveable fixtures. Instead, every eight weeks or so the latest shoe fashions are - -Madix offers a variety of caster kits that convert conventional shelving systems into flexible mobile runs. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Views of NATO have fluctuated since Pew Research Center began asking this question in 2007. In +non-NATO-member Ukraine, for example, 34% said they had a favorable view of the organization +in 2007. In 2019, 53% said the same, an increase of 19 percentage points. Lithuanians and Poles +have also grown more favorable toward NATO over the past 10 to 12 years (increases of 18 and 10 +points, respectively). +Several countries have soured on the alliance over that period. In France, favorable views of NATO +dropped from 71% in 2009 to 49% in 2019, a decrease of 22 percentage points. In Germany, +favorable views of the organization declined by 16 points, and in Bulgaria favorable views are down +by 12 points. In nonmember Russia, positive views have been nearly cut in half: In 2007, 30% had +a favorable view of NATO. By 2019, just 16% expressed the same sentiment. +NATO favorability over time +% who have a favorable opinion of NATO + 2007 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 +NATO member +| countries | % % | % % | % % | % % | % % | % % | +| ------------ | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | +| U.S. | - 53 | 54 54 | 51 49 | - 49 | 53 62 | 64 52 | +| Canada | - - | - - | - 57 | - 56 | 56 66 | - 66 | +| France | - 71 | 68 70 | 67 58 | - 64 | 49 60 | - 49 | +| Germany | - 73 | 57 60 | 65 59 | - 55 | 59 67 | 63 57 | +| Greece | - - | - - | 20 25 | - - | 25 33 | - 37 | +| Italy | - 64 | - - | 61 60 | - 64 | 59 57 | - 60 | +| Netherlands | - - | - - | - - | - - | 72 79 | - 72 | +| Spain | - 56 | 53 62 | 45 42 | - 47 | 44 45 | - 49 | +| UK | - 63 | 60 63 | 62 59 | - 60 | 61 62 | - 65 | +| Bulgaria | 54 54 | - - | - - | - - | - - | - 42 | +| Czech Rep. | 60 66 | - - | 51 56 | - - | - - | - 54 | +| Hungary | - 57 | - - | - - | - - | 57 60 | - 48 | +| Lithuania | - 59 | - 65 | - - | - - | - - | - 77 | +| Poland | 72 75 | 77 72 | 70 64 | - 74 | 70 79 | - 82 | +| Slovakia | 53 59 | - - | - - | - - | - - | - 51 | +| Turkey | - - | - 18 | 15 25 | 19 23 | - 23 | - 21 | +Non-NATO countries +| Sweden | - - | - - | - - | - - | 58 65 | - 63 | +| -------- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | +| Russia | 30 24 | 40 37 | 22 27 | - 12 | - - | - 16 | +| Ukraine | 34 31 | - 34 | - - | - 58 | - - | - 53 | +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. Germany’s 2018 results from Körber-Stiftung survey conducted there Sept. 13-26, 2018. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 9 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -displayed in a new retail theater created by set designers using mobile fixtures, lighting and props. -This has helped cement their reputation as a progressive, forward-thinking retailer with its finger -on the pulse of the rapidly changing world of fashion. Other retailers, such as RadioShack, Ross -Dress for Less, BestBuy, and numerous department and grocery store chains, have experienced -their own successes with the flexibility of mobile fixtures. - - Mobile fixtures give retailers the ability to easily change the store layout to fit the changing -needs of shoppers, accommodate special sales and offers, and even cater to “event” opportunities -with integrated solutions for big events, holidays or celebrations. Have perishables that are about -to go out of date? Put them on mobile fixtures and place them near checkout lines or in natural -product adjacencies to stimulate purchase and reduce shrinkage. Coming up on “Go Pink” breast -cancer awareness day? Use mobile fixtures and round up different pink merchandise such as -clothing and accessories near front entrances for people who want to support the cause. Have -overstock of something that might take weeks to clear out? Use mobile fixtures to create sales -opportunities throughout the store to get shoppers to purchase what you want to sell. The -possibilities are endless. - -Solution #6: Shorten or break up long runs - - Hand in hand with banishing railroad tunnel aisles, Dr. Sorensen suggests rethinking the -concept of aisles altogether. He advocates that the length of shelving from one end to the other -be between 15-20 feet and not longer than 30 feet. - -Shorter aisles in length and height accomplish multiple purposes. First, they are more -inviting to navigate and provide a natural break between product facings. Next, if the fixtures -are of varying heights, shoppers can actually see across multiple shelves and gondolas. Shorter, - -Madix’s shelving lines can be ordered to accommodate shorter run lengths. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Americans’ views of NATO differ by political party affiliation. Democrats and Democratic-leaning +independents have been more likely to have a favorable opinion of NATO than Republicans and +Republican-leaning independents across most years. That remained true in 2019, as 61% of +Democrats had a positive view of the alliance, compared with 45% of Republicans. +Democrats consistently more favorable toward NATO than Republicans +% of U.S. adults who have a favorable view of NATO +100% +76 +Democrat/Lean Democrat 74 +60 60 61 +57 58 58 56 57 +49 49 53 50 51 48 52 +43 44 45 +Republican/LeanRepublican +0 +2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Both Democratic and Republican views of NATO remained generally stable until 2017, when +Democrats grew much more likely to support NATO than their counterparts, a difference that has +not changed significantly since. In 2017, 74% of Democrats and 48% of Republicans had a +favorable opinion of the alliance, a difference of 26 percentage points. Since 2018, U.S. views of +NATO have declined among supporters of both parties. Positive views among Democrats fell 15 +points, while views among Republicans dropped 7 points. +www.pewresearch.org 10 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -staggered fixtures also serve as artificial road bumps that force shoppers to slow down, navigate -left, right and around product displays, and be more aware of what they’re passing. Also, one of -the most potent sales opportunities exist with end caps, and the shorter the fixtures in length, -and the greater the number of fixtures that are used, the number of end cap merchandising areas -increases exponentially. - - A similar outcome can be accomplished by interspersing concave or radius shelving that -softens up center store aisles and visibly pulls customers in. Rounded or organically-shaped -shelving units such as the Madix Y-Gondola can add a pleasant visual impact to the sales floor and -create multiple focal points allowing retailers to highlight important items, sales or promotional -offers. Such shelving also actually improves the visibility of more SKUs when compared to straight -shelves, because they are typically viewed from more of a frontal perspective than through a side -view while walking down an aisle. - - Of note, some retailers, such as Walmart, have actually reverted back to taller, warehouse-style -shelving and what has been described as shelves stacked full of many different products, narrow -aisles and conspicuous pallet stacks. Why? Because their sales results support the notion that -such a shopping environment better supports their brand proposition of being a value-oriented -retailer. - -Explaining this perspective in a national best seller book entitled Why We Buy: The Science of -Shopping, Underhill says, “Historically, the more a store is packed (with merchandise), the more -people think of it as value — just as when you walk into a store and there are fewer things on the - -floor, you tend to think they’re expensive.” - -This simply means that it’s critical for retailers such as Walmart to understand the mindset -of their customers to know what it is they want. Regardless of a retailer’s brand proposition – -whether it be value, quality, selection or brand names – they must strike a balance between the -volume of products displayed and the physical and visual presentation to create an optimum -buying atmosphere for its customers. In other words, what works for a discounter may not work -for a specialty retailer, and vice versa. - -Solution #5: Integrate specialty merchandisers - -Specialty merchandisers are an ideal mobile way for retailers to experiment with product -displays and presentations on the sales floor without making major, permanent commitments to -space or marketing. - -Retailers can experiment with specialty “solution stations” that tie product categories together - -without totally realigning product groupings or fixtures. Common fixtures for such specialty -presentations include the use of T-Racks and mobile caster kits. - - Grocers could consider staging certain ethnic food nights, weeks or months to stimulate trial -and impulse purchases by shoppers. For example, a mobile fixture or end cap could be ideal for -“Italian Night Solutions” complete with recipes and suggestions for combinations of products that -otherwise would be spread throughout the store: pots, pans, utensils, spaghetti, lasagna, pizza -kits, sauces, spices, olive oil, cheese, meat and vegetable appetizers, bread, desert, wine and even -flowers. Another possibility could be “Pamper Your Pet” with a selection of high-end food, treats, -supplements, collars, bowls and toys. Evergreen events such as birthdays and anniversaries also -lend themselves to turn-key specialty merchandisers featuring apparel, gift boxes, cards, candles, -desserts and even alcohol. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Those on the ideological right more +favorable toward NATO +Ideology is a factor when it comes to views of +% who have a favorable view of NATO +NATO in several countries. In six countries, +those placing themselves on the right side of the +ideological spectrum are more favorable toward +NATO than those on the left. In Sweden, for +example, 79% of those on the ideological right +have a positive opinion of NATO, compared +with 38% of those on the left, a difference of 41 +percentage points. Significant differences +between those on the right and the left are also +seen in Bulgaria (38 percentage points), the +Czech Republic (36 points), Spain (25), Greece Note: Only statistically significant differences shown. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q8g. +(19) and Slovakia (16). +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 11 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Madix manufactures specialty merchandisers to suit any market segment. Luxe, -a new display that features an attractive round upright and standard Madix slotting, -accepts Madix’s thousands of shelves and accessories. - -Retailers should experiment with integrated presentations for different topics and locations - -to see what does and doesn’t resonate with their customer base and tweak them accordingly. -In addition, Dr. Sorensen points out that something as simple as scattering static or mobile -merchandisers around the store in non-obvious locations almost always increases sales of those -products. For example, placing a merchandising display of cookies outside of the bakery, or -t-shirts and socks near the check-out queue, can stimulate incremental sales of those items outside -of their natural environment. The beauty of such displays is that they lend themselves -to experimentation. - -Solution #4: Make smart use of in-store marketing - -Point-of-sale marketing is found to improve the find-ability of merchandise and usually leads to -improved brand recognition. However, it’s important to effectively judge the use of such point-of- -sale material and be smart about leveraging the sales of merchandise the retailer wants to sell, not -necessarily what the manufacturer or supplier wants to push. After all, why take up valuable shelf -space and fight for shoppers’ attention for a low-margin or low velocity item or product category? -It’s better to focus on merchandise that has a higher profit margin, introduces new or innovative -products to customers, or supports the retailer’s particular point-of-difference (better selection, -higher quality, well-known brand names, etc.). - - Digital print and video signage are excellent ways to cut through the clutter and grab shoppers’ -attention in the noise of the typical retail environment. Such signage can be designed to educate, -entertain and engage shoppers with key messages they might not otherwise see. The Bissell -brand of vacuum cleaners in Lowe’s Home Improvement Stores is one example. Their use of digital -and video signage on end caps and mid-aisle displays stop shoppers in their tracks to deliver short, -concise sales messages about the benefits of clean floors and carpets and how Bissell products -deliver the best outcome and value. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Article 5 of the NATO treaty is “at the very heart +Publics in NATO countries express +of NATO’s founding treaty,” according to the +reluctance on Article 5 obligations +organization. The article states that “an attack +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +against one Ally is considered as an attack +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +against all Allies.” ally, (survey country) __ use military force to defend +that country +When asked whether their country should or Should not Should +| | Netherlands | | | 32% | | 64% | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +should not use military force to defend a NATO +| | | U.S. | | 29 | | 60 | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ally from a hypothetical attack by Russia, in +Canada +| only five of the 16 member states surveyed – the | | | | 38 | | 56 | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Netherlands, the U.S., Canada, the UK and | | UK | | 41 | | 55 | +Lithuania – do half or more say that they +| | Lithuania | | | 34 | | 51 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +should use such force. Across the 16 countries, a +| | | France | | 53 | | 41 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +median of 50% say that their country should +| | | Spain | | 56 | | 41 | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +not defend a NATO ally in the event of an attack +| | | Poland | | 43 | | 40 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +by Russia, while 38% say they should. +| | Czech Rep. | | | 47 | | 36 | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Larger shares in 10 NATO member countries | | Germany | 60 | | | 34 | +| | | Hungary | | 43 | | 33 | +surveyed say their country should not use force +to defend a NATO ally should there be an attack Slovakia 55 32 +by Russia. This includes majorities in Bulgaria, Turkey 55 32 +Italy, Greece, Germany and Spain. In Poland, +| | | Greece | 63 | | | 25 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sentiment is divided. +| | | Italy | 66 | | | 25 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Bulgaria | 69 | | 12 | | + +| | 16-COUNTRY | | | 50 | | 38 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +MEDIAN +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24. + +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 12 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Other, less extreme example of digital signage and even low-tech coupon and recipe pads and -dispensers are also effective in garnering attention for specific products and brands. Products -such as Lumicanopy by Madix, Inc. use LED lighting to illuminate graphics and promote categories -or brands. The typical Lumicanopy consumes little power, emits virtually no heat, exhibits uniform -light distribution that’s visible from many feet away, and is reusable over several years. Other -displays such as the Madix Easel SB retail shelf and point-of-sale display educates and entertains -shoppers with relevant information and does not protrude into aisles to interfere with shoppers. -The key is to be smart about what and how information is communicated to ensure its effect on -shoppers is maximized. - -Being able to deploy large format, illuminated graphics either in Madix’s canopies or within -the fixtures’ surfaces facilitates in-store marketing initiatives. The bright, colorful graphics -appeal to shoppers across the store. - -Solution #3: Turn up the lights - -Lighting is one of the most important -- yet probably one of the least understood -- - -merchandising techniques in the retail environment. Done correctly at the point-of-sale with -fixtures such as the Madix LEDge Light Versa and the Beam LED alternative to fluorescent canopy -lighting and retailers can improve mood, create the desired ambiance, and more importantly -create a measurable impact on shopping behavior. - - An article published in InformeDesign by Delores (Dee) Ginthner, an associate professor in -the Interior Design Program, Department of Design, Housing and Apparel at the University of -Minnesota, states several basic truisms that must be addressed when lighting a space to ensure -both psychological and behavioral issues of users are met. This includes the observations that -lighting must ensure safe navigation through a space; people always follow the brightest path; -brightness can focus attention; people like to face walls that are illuminated; and lighting can -cause people to alter body positions. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +The belief that their country should respond to +Changing views on whether their +a hypothetical Russian attack on a NATO ally +country should intervene in a conflict +has become less common over time in a handful +between Russia and a NATO ally +of countries. For example, in Italy, only a +% who say their country should use military force to +quarter in 2019 say that their country should +defend a NATO ally in a serious military conflict with +defend a NATO ally, down from four-in-ten in +Russia +2015. Similar declines over this time period +80% +occurred in Poland (-8 percentage points), +Spain (-7) and France (-6). However, support +62 +for protecting a fellow NATO nation has +increased in the UK since 2015 (+6). 49 53 55 UK +48 +46 +48 41 France +47 45 41 Spain +In eight of the countries polled, men are 40 +40 Poland +significantly more likely than women to say that 36 +their country should defend a NATO ally. For 25 Italy +example, in Germany, 43% of men say that in +the case of a Russian attack on a fellow NATO +member their country should respond with 0 +2015 2017 2019 +force, compared with only a quarter of women. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24. +Similar double-digit differences occur in Spain, +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +Hungary, the Czech Republic, the Netherlands +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +and Poland. +Ideology also plays a role in people’s views about coming to an ally’s aid. In six countries, those +who place themselves on the right end of the ideological spectrum are more willing to say they +should defend a NATO ally than those on the right. This includes double-digit differences between +right and left in all six countries: Spain (30 percentage points), the Czech Republic and Slovakia +(21 points), Greece (14), and the UK and Italy (both 13 points). +www.pewresearch.org 13 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - Ginthner further states that criteria created several years ago by Dr. John Flynn to evaluate -lighting remain true today. This criteria states that designers must use cues to determine the users’ -subjective response to space lighting in order to create space that makes users say something is -pleasant versus unpleasant, public versus private, spacious versus confined, relaxed versus tense -and visually clear versus hazy. - - Needless to say, the science of lighting and how it applies to curved fixtures, pyramid or -recessed shelving, wider and shorter aisles, end caps, on-shelf merchandisers and even mobile -fixtures is critical to maximizing the impact and desired outcomes. The days of one-size-fits-all -overhead or fluorescent canopy lighting are being replaced by new efficient alternatives such -as environmentally friendly LEDs that produce light intensity similar to T5 fluorescent fixtures -while using only half the energy and lasting nearly three times longer. Lighting considerations -should be incorporated into the initial store design at the onset by true lighting professionals who -understand shopper psychology and how best to use lighting to stimulate sales. - -Madix is the first store fixture manufacturer to design energy-efficient, -point-of-sale lighting products that are specifically designed for store equipment -applications. Madix’s lighting solutions either attach underneath shelves, or they -replace the fixtures’ surfaces to pin-point light (e.g., back panels or shelf skins). - -Solution #2: Optimize traffic flow - -The art of converting visitors into shoppers and shoppers into buyers is accomplished in no - -small part through optimizing traffic flow through the store. Dr. Sorensen suggests there are -several changes, some subtle and some overt, that can make a major impact on a store’s visceral -appeal while exposing shoppers to buying opportunities that may have gone undiscovered in a -traditional linear layout. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Views on defending an ally from a potential +Those who agree military force is +Russian attack are related to general attitudes +sometimes necessary are more likely +toward the use of military force. Across most of +to support defending a NATO ally +the NATO member countries surveyed, those +% who say their country should use military force to +who agree that military force is sometimes +defend a NATO ally from a serious military conflict with +necessary to maintain order in the world are +Russia +more likely to say that they would defend a +| | Disagree that | | Agree that | | +| --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +fellow NATO member from an armed incursion military force military force +is sometimes is sometimes +than those who disagree that a military solution necessary necessary Diff +| | | % | % | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +is the best choice for keeping order. For +| | | 23 | 51 | +28 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +Poland +example, in Spain, 53% of those who agree that +| | Spain | 26 | 53 | +27 | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | +military force is sometimes necessary say they +| | Lithuania | 38 | 65 | +27 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---- | +would come to the aid of a NATO ally, versus +| | Canada | 38 | 64 | +26 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +only 26% of those who disagree with the +| | Italy | 12 | 38 | +26 | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | +principle of military force – a 27 percentage Netherlands 47 72 +25 +| point difference. | UK | 37 | 62 | +25 | +| ------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Czech Rep. | 24 | 49 | +25 | +| | Slovakia | 20 | 45 | +25 | + +| | Germany | 23 | 47 | +24 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Hungary | 18 | 40 | +22 | + +| | U.S. | 47 | 64 | +17 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | France | 30 | 47 | +17 | + +| | Bulgaria | 9 | 17 | +8 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Greece | 23 | 29 | +6 | + +| | Turkey | 29 | 34 | +5 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q50h. + +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org 14 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - - One idea requires a significant reconfiguration of fixtures to change their orientation and -layout to the front of the store. Dr. Sorensen supports the theory that when shoppers within -the interior of a store look down aisles and see checkout registers, especially ones with no lines, -they subconsciously tend to hurry through their shopping experience so they can quickly check -out before the lines fill up: a sort of quick in, quick out mentality. To combat this and reduce the -“railroad tunnel” visual effect, he suggests shifting the aisles at a 45-degree angle to the front of -the store. An important benefit of such a design is that as shoppers enter the store they will be -approaching aisles from a less acute angle, which will make them more inviting to enter. - - Another way to increase traffic flow and lure shoppers is to determine new and relevant -product categories and bring them into the center store. Along the way and throughout the entire -store, the goal should always be putting the “right” products in the direct path of the customer. -Dr. Sorensen says, “There are patterns of movement... (in a store) that are not driven by products -as much as by open spaces and natural flows.” By observing, determining, and directing traffic -flow with smart shelving fixtures, lighting and merchandising materials, it’s possible to conduct -“anticipatory retailing.” This is when the retailer anticipates and meets the needs of shoppers -rather than making shoppers find things on their own. - -In support of an enhanced traffic flow, Dr. Sorensen advocates putting high margin - -merchandise rather than discounted goods in the customer’s path. Research shows that the most -important determinant for sales is based not on price, but on the placement of store fixtures -displaying those goods. Putting highly discounted merchandise such as 75-percent-off sweaters -or two-for-one cereal offers in the customer’s path may actually be counter-productive, because -it could prevent customers from venturing deeper into the center store and discovering higher- -priced, if not more desirable goods. - - Dollar General spokeswoman Mary Winn Gordon is quoted alongside Underhill in the New -York Times article as saying the chain store employs virtual “speed bumps” of related merchandise - -Madix’s array of fixture choices equips a retailer with options to tweak store designs to improve traffic flow and sales. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In contrast to skeptical opinions on whether +People in member states say the U.S. +their own country should come to the defense of +would defend a NATO ally +a NATO ally, people are much more likely to +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +think the U.S. would take military action in +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +response to a Russian attack. ally, the U.S. __ use military force to defend that country +Would not Would +| A median of 60% across the member countries | Italy | 16% | | 75% | +| -------------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +say the U.S. would use military force to defend a +| | UK | 22 | | 73 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +NATO country that was subject to a Russian +| | Spain | 21 | | 72 | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +incursion. Only 29% across these countries +| believe the U.S. would not defend the country | Canada | 25 | | 69 | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +that was attacked. +| | Netherlands | 28 | | 68 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Greece | 19 | | 65 | +Roughly two-thirds or more in Italy, the UK, +| | Germany | 31 | | 63 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +Spain, Canada, the Netherlands and Greece say +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally. Majorities Slovakia 27 57 +in Germany, Slovakia, Lithuania and France +| | Lithuania | 29 | | 57 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +agree. +| | France | 37 | | 57 | +| ----------------------------------------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| Poles, on balance, say the U.S. would help out | Poland | 30 | 47 | | +should Russia use military force against a +| | Turkey | 40 | 46 | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +neighboring NATO country, but sentiment is +| | Czech Rep. | 35 | 41 | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +more divided in Turkey, the Czech Republic and +| Hungary. | Hungary | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 31 | 39 | | +Since 2015, there has been some change in a +14-COUNTRY +| | | 29 | | 60 | +| ------------------------------------------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +| few countries on this question. The belief that | MEDIAN | | | | +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally is down 8 +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Question not asked in the +percentage points in France but up 7 points in U.S. Due to a translation error, results are not shown for Bulgaria. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q25. +the UK and Spain. These sentiments are also up “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| 6 points in Turkey. | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | +| --------------------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +In Hungary, views that the U.S. would help out in the event of a Russia attack are down +significantly since 2017, falling 16 percentage points. +www.pewresearch.org 15 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -that goes together -- such as bananas alongside boxes of vanilla wafers -- in aisles or at entrances, -because it’s a consumer-friendly way to assist customers and pique their thought process while -generating incremental sales. By using such things as Y-Gondolas, mobile displays, LED lighting -fixtures, floor graphics, ceiling hangers or digital or video marketing to highlighting merchandise -in a non-intrusive, yet attention-getting fashion, it’s entirely possible to get customers to buy -items you wish to sell, not just what shoppers came into the store to purchase. - - An underutilized method of generating awareness and trial is product sampling and -demonstrations. Retailers such as Sam’s Club, Costco and Whole Foods have mastered the art -of sampling during high traffic days and peak times to expose customers to products they may -have otherwise ignored. Why not create a display that demonstrates the difference between -200 and 400 thread count sheets? Utilize sales staff as virtual models by having them wear the -merchandise being sold in the store, much like mega-brands Hollister and American Eagle have -done with their employees. Create mobile sampling stations offering customers tastes of lesser- -known foods such as couscous, Greek yogurt, even kale along with recipes incorporating those -foods to stimulate profitable impulse sales. - -In fact, the New England Journal of Medicine reports that food choices are largely guided by -our responses to outside signals and stimuli. A paper authored by Deborah Cohen of RAND Health -in Santa Monica, Calif., and Susan Babey of the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, states that -impulse marketing takes place on a subconscious level, and that placement of foods in prominent -locations increases the rate at which they’re purchased. - - While most people may associate such impulse displays with checkout lines and sodas, candy, -gum and magazines, they can be just as effective in other areas of a store. Shopping for a new -blouse? You may be influenced by matching (high-margin) accessories attractively displayed -next to them. Buying new cat food? How about a pretty collar or catnip to go along with it. The -possibilities for proximity marketing are enormous, if not often overlooked, opportunities. - -Solution #1: Multiply the end cap effect - -End caps are perhaps the most misunderstood and underutilized spaces in the retail -environment. According to Dr. Sorensen, approximately 2-percent of the total items in a -typical store at any given time are being promoted on end-of-aisle displays or other secondary -promotional displays apart from the mail shelving fixtures. However, this 2-percent of items may -constitute a whopping 30-percent of all store sales. - - While retailers often use this space to promote sales or highly discounted merchandise, the fact -is that half the shoppers purchasing an item from such end caps are unaware the goods are being -sold at a reduced price, and half of the people who know would buy the product even if it wasn’t -on sale. - -So in other words, good retailers are simply giving away profits to as much as 75-percent of - -their shoppers because they are locked into the mindset that price considerations dominate -shopping decisions when research doesn’t support that point of view. Instead, great retailers -understand that a better use of such prime real estate is to satisfy the shopper’s inherent need -for value and convenience, and most customers are willing to pay full price to accomplish a fast -shopping experience. - - Another reason end caps can be extremely profitable is that because of their small size, they -generally feature only one or two products. As such, shoppers do not have an easy or immediate -way to compare the merchandise as they would in the category section inside the aisle. The -impulse nature of end caps and the lack of price sensitivity support the premise that retailers can -command a higher price for such merchandise. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Young adults in Spain, France, Slovakia, +More in NATO countries say the U.S. +Canada and Germany are more likely to believe +would use military force to defend an +the U.S. would defend a NATO ally against a +ally from Russia than say that their +Russian attack. For example, in Spain, 84% of +country should do the same +18- to 29-year-olds say the U.S. would uphold +% who say if Russia got into a serious military conflict +their Article 5 obligations, compared with 68% +with one of its neighboring countries that is our NATO +of those 50 and older. +ally, __ to defend that country +| | | Our country | The U.S. | | +| --- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | +In almost every country surveyed, people are should use would use +| | military force military force | | | Diff | +| ------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | +| significantly more likely to say the U.S. would | | % | % | | +defend an ally from a Russia attack than say Italy 25 75 +50 +| | Greece | 25 | 65 | +40 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +their own country should take such action. +| | Spain | 41 | 72 | +31 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Germany | 34 | 63 | +29 | +The biggest difference measured is in Italy, +| | Slovakia | 32 | 57 | +25 | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | +where three-quarters say the U.S. would use +| | UK | 55 | 73 | +18 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +such military force in such a scenario, +| | France | 41 | 57 | +16 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +compared with only a quarter who say Italy +| | Turkey | 32 | 46 | +14 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +should defend that NATO ally, a 50 percentage +| | Canada | 56 | 69 | +13 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---- | +point difference. Similar differences are seen in Poland 40 47 +7 +| | Hungary | 33 | 39 | +6 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +Greece (40 points), Spain (31), Germany (29), +| | Lithuania | 51 | 57 | +6 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +Slovakia (25), the UK (18), France (16), Turkey +| | Czech Rep. | 36 | 41 | +5 | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +(14) and Canada (13). +| | Netherlands | 64 | 68 | +4 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | + Note: Statistically significant differences in bold. U.S, Bulgaria, +Russia and Ukraine not included. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q24 & Q25. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 16 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Breaking up and staggering the traditional long aisles in many retail locations can literally - -double the number of possible end caps from the shoppers perspective, particularly in the -center store. Incorporating other display tools such as Y-Gondolas, curved shelving, pyramid and -recessed shelving, highlight lighting, sampling stations, lifestyle graphics and signage, can only -serve to increase the sales velocity of end caps. - -Madix understands how important end caps are to a retailer’s success. The company manufactures a number -of end cap systems that maximize space, improve visibility, and capitalize on sales. Madix’s new Y-Gondola -greatly expands the potential of end caps to positively influence shopping behavior. - -Decide what solutions make sense for you - -Revisiting the relationship between the perimeter and center store requires that retailers - -rethink the cost of sales. Ignoring or shrinking the center store given its contribution to -overall profits doesn’t make sense when much more is possible. A better course of action is to -fundamentally rethink the consumer shopping process and adapt the entire store to better deliver -total customer solutions. After all, what good is the sizzle without a juicy steak to go along with it? - -The display fixture experts at Madix, Inc. are available to provide free consultation to retailers - -who wish to explore fresh, new ideas on how to bring the center store back to life to create a -holistic shopping experience that drives sales and profits. For more information, contact John -Clontz Director of Marketing and e-Business jclontz@madixinc.com 214-515-5400. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In nearly every country +Western Europeans favor close relationship with U.S. +surveyed, larger shares support +over Russia; Central and Eastern Europeans tend to +| close ties with the U.S. than | prefer both | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +with Russia, with the +% who say it is more important for their country to have a close +exceptions of Bulgaria and +relationship to ... +| Slovakia. And in many | | | U.S. | | Russia | Both (Vol) | | +| -------------------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| countries polled, publics tend | | UK | | 83% | 8% | 5% | | +| to volunteer that a close | Netherlands | | | 82 | 11 | 4 | | +| relationship with both the U.S. | | Spain | | 73 | 9 | 9 | | +and Russia is important. +| | | France | | 60 | 18 | 13 | | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Germany | 39 | | 25 | | 30 | +Particularly in Western Europe, +| | | Italy | 38 | | 7 | | 45 | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the share of the public that says +| | | Greece | 31 | | 17 | | 40 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a relationship with the U.S. is +| | | Poland | 29 | | 12 | | 53 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +more important is substantial. +| | | Lithuania | 29 | | 17 | | 38 | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +For example, in the UK and the +| | Czech Rep. | | 27 | | 14 | | 39 | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Netherlands, about eight-in-ten +| | | Hungary | 24 | | 8 | | 55 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +support ties with the U.S. over +| | | Slovakia | 23 | | 22 | | 50 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Russia or both. And in Sweden, +| | | Bulgaria | 16 | | 28 | | 47 | +| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a non-NATO state, 71% support +closer ties with the U.S. than +| with Russia (11%) or both | | Sweden | | 71 | 11 | 9 | | +| -------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +countries (9%). +Note: “Both” indicates volunteered response “Both relationships are equally important.” +“Don’t know” and “Neither” responses not shown. German results from Körber-Stiftung +survey conducted in Germany Sept. 9-28, 2019. +Choosing a close relationship +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q35. +| with Russia over the U.S. is | “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| considerably less widespread | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +across the countries surveyed. +Bulgarians are the most prone to this point of view, but just 28% say a close relationship with +Russia is more important for their country. A quarter of Germans say it is important for their +country to have a close relationship with Russia, compared with 39% who favor a close +relationship with the U.S. Three-in-ten Germans volunteer that a close relationship with both +countries would be preferable. +www.pewresearch.org 17 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. - - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Traditional Center Store Fixture Configuration - - Traditional center store fixture runs are usually long and extend 30 feet or -more. The long runs discourage shoppers from entering the department. Also, -the lengthy runs have a limited quantity of end caps, the store fixture with the -most effective sales potential. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Central and Eastern European publics tend to +volunteer their preference for a close Those on right ideologically more likely +to favor close relationship with U.S. +relationship with both the U.S. and Russia. In +Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and Bulgaria, % who say it is more important for their country to have +a close relationship to the U.S. +roughly half or more say a relationship with +both countries is important. And in Italy, +Greece, the Czech Republic and Lithuania, +about four-in-ten or more say the same. +Ideology is linked to views of closer relations +with the U.S. In 11 of 14 countries, those on the +ideological right are more likely to support a +close relationship with the U.S. than those on +the left. In the Czech Republic, for example, +40% of those on the right say a close +relationship with the U.S. is more important, +compared to 15% of those on the left, a +difference of 25 percentage points. +Hungary is an exception. Hungarians on the left +(40%) are almost twice as likely as their +counterparts on the right (21%) to support close +U.S. relations. +Note: All differences shown are statistically significant. +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q35. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 18 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout that Staggers Runs - A center store layout with staggered runs includes more and shorter fixture -runs. Shoppers are more likely to enter a center store that utilizes shorter, -less daunting runs. The staggering of the runs greatly increases a shopper’s -exposure to end caps as he or she walks through the department. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +There is widespread support across most of the Across most of Europe and North +NATO countries surveyed for the use of military America, support for military force to +maintain order in the world +force to maintain order in the world. A median +of 57% across 16 member countries agree that % who __ that it is sometimes necessary to use military +military force is sometimes necessary, while a force to maintain order in the world +| median of 36% disagree. | | | | Disagree | Agree | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | U.S. | | 21% | | | 78% | +| | | Canada | | 27 | | | 71 | +Across most countries surveyed – both +members of NATO and those that do not belong +| to the organization – about half or more | | UK | | 29 | | | 71 | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| support the use of military force to maintain | | Hungary | | 25 | | | 70 | +order. And in seven countries (Sweden, the Netherlands 31 69 +| | | France | | 35 | | | 64 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +U.S., Canada, the UK, Turkey, Russia and +Poland +| Hungary) seven-in-ten or more hold this view. | | | | 35 | | | 58 | +| ----------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Spain | | 44 | | | 55 | +| Germans are more divided, with 47% saying | Czech Rep. | | | 37 | | 53 | | +that military force is sometimes necessary and a Slovakia 42 53 +| | | Italy | | 45 | | 52 | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +similar 52% disagreeing with that statement. In +| | | Greece | 49 | | | 50 | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Bulgaria, only 38% say military force is +| sometimes necessary. | Lithuania | | | 44 | | 48 | | +| --------------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Germany | 52 | | | 47 | | +| | | Bulgaria | 54 | | | 38 | | +| | | Turkey | | 25 | | | 71 | + +NATO +| | MEMBER | | | 36 | | | 57 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MEDIAN +| | | Sweden | | 20 | | | 79 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | Russia | | 27 | | | 70 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Ukraine | | 30 | | | 62 | +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +| | Russia are not NATO member states. | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 19 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout with Specialty Merchandisers and Transitional Components - -Integrating specialty merchandisers into a center store will improve -incremental sales. Utilize transitional components, including bases and -shelves, to draw attention to merchandise within merchandising categories. -The transitional components and shelves also make room for shoppers to -navigate around the specialty displays between the aisles. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Support for military force has changed since +Views of military force have changed +Pew Research Center asked this question in +across several countries +2007. +% who agree that it is sometimes necessary to use +military force to maintain order in the world +For example, in both Ukraine and Russia, two +| | | 2007 | 2019 | Change | +| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------- | +countries engaged in conflict since 2014, +| | | % | % | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +publics increasingly say military force is +| | Ukraine | 51 | 62 | ▲11 | +| --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | +sometimes necessary (by 11 and 9 percentage +| | Russia | 61 | 70 | ▲9 | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +points, respectively). This opinion has also +| | Slovakia | 47 | 53 | ▲6 | +| ----------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | +| become more common in Slovakia and | Germany | 41 | 47 | ▲6 | +| Germany. | Czech Rep. | 62 | 53 | ▼ 9 | +| | Spain | 65 | 55 | ▼ 10 | +Yet in several European countries, support for Italy 73 52 ▼ 21 +military force has waned. This is the case in +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +Italy (a decrease of 21 percentage points), Spain +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +(10 points) and the Czech Republic (9). + +www.pewresearch.org 20 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com - 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales - -Center Store Layout using Y-Gondolas as End Caps - - Madix’s Y-Gondola exponentially expands the sales potential of end caps. -Not only does the fixture greatly increase the end cap’s merchandise volume, -but it also makes the merchandise on the end cap visible from wider angles. A -store layout that utilizes Y-Gondolas on short fixture runs will create an inviting -and more shopable center store. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In 12 countries, people on the right of the +Those on the right more likely to say +ideological spectrum are more apt than those +military force can be necessary to +on the left to agree that military force can be +maintain order +justified. In Spain, for example, those on the +% who agree that it is sometimes necessary to use +right are about twice as likely to support +military force to maintain order in the world +military force as their counterparts on the left. +In the U.S., conservatives are 25 percentage +points more likely than liberals to say military +force is sometimes needed. Similarly, 91% of +Republicans and Republican-leaning +independents say military force is sometimes +necessary, while 71% of Democrats and +Democratic-leaning independents agree. +Gender also shapes views of military action. +Across most of the NATO and non-NATO +countries surveyed, men are more likely than +women believe in the need for military force. In +the Czech Republic, for example, 63% of men +say military force is sometimes necessary, +compared with 45% of women. And in Ukraine, +71% of men support military force, versus 56% +of women. Double-digit gender differences are +also present in Germany (14 points), Poland +(12), Bulgaria (12), Hungary (11), Italy (11) and Note: All differences shown are statistically significant. In U.S., +ideology is defined as conservative (right), moderate (center) and +Spain (10). +liberal (left). +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50h. +“NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org 21 - -© 2014 Madix, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Prices and specifications subject to change without notice. Not responsible for errors or omissions in printing. 10 Ways to Lift Center Store Sales +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Across NATO and non-NATO countries, there is +disagreement over whether parts of +Europeans divided over whether parts of +neighboring countries really belong to them. A +neighboring countries belong to them +median of 45% across the 16 NATO countries +% who __ that there are parts of neighboring countries +surveyed disagree, while a median of 35% agree that really belong to us +(in several countries, the share who did not + +| | | | | | Disagree | Agree | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | +express an opinion is relatively high). +| | | Canada | | 65% | | 25% | | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | U.S. | 73 | | | 19 | | +The shares who agree with this statement are +highest in Central and Eastern European +| | | Hungary | | | 25 | | 67 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +countries surveyed. About two-thirds of +| Hungarians (67%) agree that parts of | | Greece | | | 27 | | 60 | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| neighboring countries belong to them, | | Bulgaria | | | 22 | | 58 | +Poland +| including 40% who completely agree. In | | | | | 36 | | 48 | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Turkey, 58% agree that parts of nearby | | Slovakia | | | 33 | | 46 | +| countries belong to them. And in neighboring | | Spain | | 60 | | | 37 | +Greece, 60% say the same. +| | | Italy | | | 38 | | 36 | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | France | | 59 | | | 33 | +| In Western European countries, sentiments | Czech Rep. | | | | 33 | | 31 | +tend to run in the opposite direction. In Sweden +| | | Lithuania | | 51 | | | 30 | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(82%), the Netherlands (74%), the UK (72%), +| | | Germany | | 62 | | | 30 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Germany (62%), Spain (60%) and France +| | Netherlands | | 74 | | | 24 | | +| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(59%), majorities disagree that there are parts +| | | UK | 72 | | | 23 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +of other countries that belong to them. +| | | Turkey | | | 29 | | 58 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +In both the U.S. and Canada, publics +overwhelmingly disagree that parts of other +NATO +| | | | | | 45 | | 35 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| countries belong to them (73% and 65%, | | MEDIAN | | | | | | +respectively). However, a quarter of Canadians +| | | Russia | | | 33 | | 53 | +| --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +and roughly one-in-five Americans say the +| | | Ukraine | | | 35 | | 47 | +| --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +opposite and agree that there are parts of +| neighboring countries that belong to them. | | Sweden | 82 | | | 13 | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Note: Don’t know responses not shown. Sweden, Ukraine and +Russia are not NATO member states. +Russians and Ukrainians tend to agree that +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50f. +parts of neighboring countries belong to them “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” +| (53% and 47%, respectively). | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +www.pewresearch.org 22 - -Texas: 800-776-2349 Fax: 972-563-0792 Alabama: 800-633-6282 Fax: 256-839-5608Mexico: 001-800-010-0699 www.madixinc.com www.madixinc.com -Texas 500 Airport Road, Terrell, TX 75160 | 800.776.2349 -Alabama 20984 Alabama Hwy 9, Goodwater, AL 35072 | 800.633.6282 -©2014 Madix, Inc. All rights reserved. Not responsible for errors and omissions in printing. Rev. 7/14 - +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +In Europe, supporters of right- +wing populist parties tend to be Those with a favorable view of right-wing populist +more likely to say parts of +parties more likely to say parts of other countries +neighboring countries belong +belong to them +to their country. Supporters of +% who agree that there are parts of neighboring countries that really +| right-wing populist parties are | belong to us | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +more likely to agree with this Among those who Among those +| | | do not support __ | | who support __ | | +| --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | +statement for nearly every +| | | | party | party | Diff | +| ----------------------------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | +| European right-wing populist | | | % | % | | +| | Spain | Vox | 32 | 59 | +27 | +party included in the survey. In +| | France | National Rally | 28 | 52 | +24 | +| --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +Spain, for example, those who +| | Germany | AfD | 26 | 50 | +24 | +| --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | +have a favorable view of Vox +| | UK | UKIP | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | 17 | 41 | +24 | +are 27 percentage points more +Freedom and Direct +Czech Rep. +| likely to say parts of another | | Democracy | 27 | 45 | +18 | +| ------------------------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Hungary | Fidesz | 60 | 76 | +16 | +country belong to Spain than +| | Slovakia | Slovak National | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| those who do not have a | | Party | 40 | 54 | +14 | +| favorable view of the party. | | Forum for | | | | +Netherlands +| | | Democracy | 19 | 33 | +14 | +| --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | +| | Netherlands | Party for Freedom | | | | +| | | | 21 | 33 | +12 | +Correction (February 12, +| | Italy | Lega | 33 | 43 | +10 | +| --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | +2020): This post has been Sweden Sweden Democrats 11 21 +10 +updated with the proper Poland Law and Justice 44 53 +9 +characterization of NATO's +Note: Only statistically significant differences shown. “Support” percentages represent +founding treaty and revised a respondents who have a favorable view of each party. “Do not support” percentages +represent respondents who have an unfavorable view of each party. For more information +significant difference in +on European populist parties, see Appendix. In Sweden, respondents with an unfavorable +view of the Sweden Democrats were significantly less likely to respond. +Lithuania. The changes due to +Source: Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey. Q50f. +| these adjustments do not | “NATO Seen Favorably Across Member States” | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| materially change the analysis | PEW RESEARCH CENTER | | | | | +of the report. + +www.pewresearch.org + +23 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Appendix: Classifying European political parties +Classifying parties as populist +Although experts generally agree that populist political leaders or parties display high levels of +anti-elitism, definitions of populism vary. We use three measures to classify populist parties: anti- +elite ratings from the 2017 Chapel Hill Expert Survey (CHES), Inglehart and Norris’s populism +party scale and The PopuList. We define a party as populist when at least two of these three +measures classify it as such. +CHES, which was carried out in January and February 2018, asked 228 regional experts to +evaluate the 2017 positions of 132 European political parties across 14 European Union member +states. CHES results are regularly used by academics to classify parties with regard to their left- +right ideological leanings, their key party platform positions and their degree of populism, among +other things. +We measure anti-elitism using an average of two variables in the CHES data. First, we used +“PEOPLE_VS_ELITE,” which asked the experts to measure the parties with regard to their +position on direct vs. representative democracy, where 0 means that the parties support elected +officeholders making the most important decisions and 10 means that “the people,” not politicians, +should make the most important decisions. Second, we used “ANTIELITE_SALIENCE,” which is a +measure of the salience of anti-establishment and anti-elite rhetoric for that particular party, with +0 meaning not at all salient and 10 meaning extremely salient. The average of these two measures +is shown in the table below as “anti-elitism.” In all countries, we consider parties that score above +a 7.0 as “populist.” +We also used CHES’s “FAMILY” variable to further classify populist groups. Per CHES, family +attribution is based on a combination of “a) membership or affiliation with [European Parliament] +party families, b) Parlgov classifications and c) self-identification.” +Inglehart and Norris emphasize the cultural views of populist parties and created a populist party +scale using the 2014 CHES data for classification.1 This scale aggregates expert ratings of the party +on the following positions and attitudes: 1) support for traditional social values, 2) opposition to +liberal lifestyles, 3) promotion of nationalism, 4) favorable toward tough law and order, 5) +favorable toward assimilation for immigrants and asylum seekers, 6) support for restrictive +immigration policies, 7) opposition to more rights for ethnic minorities, 8) support for religious +1 Inglehart, Ronald F., and Pippa Norris. 2016. “Trump, Brexit, and the Rise of Populism: Economic Have-Nots and Cultural Backlash.” HKS +Faculty Research Working Paper Series. +www.pewresearch.org + +24 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +principles in politics and 9) support for rural interests. The scale ranges from 0 to 100, and parties +with a score of more than 80 are classified as populist. +The PopuList is an ongoing project to classify European political parties as populist, far right, far +left and/or euroskeptic. The project specifically looks at parties that “obtained at least 2% of the +vote in at least one national parliamentary election since 1998.” It is based on collaboration +between academic experts and journalists. The PopuList classifies parties that emphasize the will +of the people against the elite as populist.2 +Two parties are missing data for at least two of the measures used for classification but are still +included for analysis in the report. Vox in Spain is considered a right-wing populist party by +experts, but was not included in any of the measures used due to its relatively recent rise in +popularity. Similarly, Forum for Democracy (FvD) in the Netherlands did not achieve a large +enough share of the votes to be included in the PopuList analysis and was founded in 2016, after +data collection for the Inglehart and Norris analysis. Experts in the most recent round of CHES +classify this party as a right-wing populist party, and its score on the anti-elitism scale exceeds the +cut-off. +Classifying parties as left, right or center +We can further classify these traditional and populist parties into three groups: left, right and +center. When classifying parties based on ideology, we relied on the variable “LRGEN” in the +CHES dataset, which asked experts to rate the positions of each party in terms of its overall +ideological stance, with 0 meaning extreme left, 5 meaning center and 10 meaning extreme right. +We define left parties as those that score below 4.5 and right parties as those above 5.5. Center +parties have ratings between 4.5 and 5.5. +2 Mudde, Cas. 2004. “The Populist Zeitgeist.” Government and Opposition. +www.pewresearch.org + +25 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +European populist party classifications +Inglehart & +Party Country Family Left-right Anti-elitism Norris The PopuList +Populist parties on the left +La France Insoumise France Radical left 1.0 8.9 -- Populist +Podemos Spain Radical left 2.4 8.7 Populist Populist +Syriza Greece Radical left 2.6 7.4 Populist Populist +Populist parties in the center +Action of Dissatisfied Citizens (ANO 2011) Czech Rep. No family 4.9 7.7 Not populist Populist +Five Star Movement (M5S) Italy No family 5.2 9.9 Populist Populist +Populist parties on the right +Ordinary People and Independent +Personalities (OLaNO-NOVA) Slovakia Conservative 6.9 7.2 Not populist Populist +Slovak National Party (SNS) Slovakia Radical right 7.6 4.1 Populist Populist +Sweden Democrats Sweden Radical right 8.0 8.0 Populist Populist +Freedom and Direct Democracy (SPD) Czech Rep. Radical right 8.2 9.8 -- Populist +Lega Italy Regionalist 8.3 7.8 Populist Populist +Law and Justice (PiS) Poland Radical right 8.3 6.2 Populist Populist +Kukiz’15 Poland Radical right 8.3 8.8 -- Populist +Jobbik Hungary Radical right 8.5 7.8 Populist Populist +UK Independence Party (UKIP) UK Radical right 8.6 8.2 Populist Populist +Fidesz Hungary Conservative 8.7 5.7 Populist Populist +Alternative for Germany (AfD) Germany Radical right 9.2 8.7 Populist Populist +Party for Freedom (PVV) Netherlands Radical right 9.3 9.5 Populist Populist +Forum for Democracy (FvD) Netherlands Radical right 9.5 9.5 -- -- +National Rally France Radical right 9.7 8.9 Populist Populist +Vox Spain -- -- -- -- -- +Notes: Golden Dawn (XA) in Greece not included in analysis due to insu fficient sample size. Questions about populist parties were not asked +in Bulgaria or Lithuania. Left-right indicates the average score CHES experts gave each party on an 11-point left-right scale. Scores for +anti-elitism are an average of party position on direct vs. representative democracy and the salience of anti-elite rhetoric within the party. +Source: 2017 CHES. Inglehart and Norris (2016). The PopuList (2019). +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +www.pewresearch.org + +26 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Acknowledgments +This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. +Jacob Poushter, Associate Director, Global Attitudes Research +Moira Fagan, Research Analyst +James Bell, Vice President, Global Strategy +Alexandra Castillo, Research Associate +Jeremiah Cha, Research Assistant +Aidan Connaughton, Research Assistant +Stefan S. Cornibert, Communications Manager +Claudia Deane, Vice President, Research +Kat Devlin, Research Associate +Janell Fetterolf, Research Associate +Shannon Greenwood, Digital Producer +Christine Huang, Research Assistant +Michael Keegan, Senior Information Graphics Designer +David Kent, Copy Editor +Nicholas O. Kent, Research Assistant +Colin Lahiff, Communications Associate +Gar Meng Leong, Communications Associate +Clark Letterman, Senior Researcher +J.J. Moncus, Research Assistant +Martha McRoy, Research Methodologist +Mara Mordecai, Research Assistant +Patrick Moynihan, Associate Director, International Research Methods +Stacy Pancratz, Research Methodologist +Audrey Powers, Senior Operations Associate +Laura Silver, Senior Researcher +Shannon Schumacher, Research Associate +Richard Wike, Director, Global Attitudes Research +www.pewresearch.org + +27 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Methodology +Results for the survey are based on telephone and face-to-face interviews conducted under the +direction of Gallup and Abt Associates. The results are based on national samples, unless +otherwise noted. More details about our international survey methodology and country-specific +sample designs are available here. +www.pewresearch.org + +28 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Topline questionnaire +Pew Research Center +Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey +February 9, 2020 Release +Methodological notes: +• Survey results are based on national samples. For further details on sample designs, see +our international survey methods database. +• The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to +sampling that would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the +United States in the survey: +Group Unweighted sample size Weighted % Plus or minus … +Total sample 1503 3.0 percentage points +Rep/Lean Rep 638 39 4.6 percentage points +Dem/Lean Dem 697 48 4.3 percentage points +• Due to rounding, percentages may not total 100%. The topline “total” columns show 100%, +because they are based on unrounded numbers. +• Since 2007, Pew Research Center has used an automated process to generate toplines for +its Global Attitudes surveys. As a result, numbers may differ slightly from those published +prior to 2007. +• Not all questions included in the Spring 2019 Global Attitudes Survey are presented in this +topline. Omitted questions have either been previously released or will be released in +future reports. +www.pewresearch.org + +29 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 37 | 18 | 8 | 22 | 100 | +| ------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2018 | 30 | 34 | 14 | 9 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 20 | 42 | 15 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 12 | 41 | 18 | 7 | 21 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 9 | 40 | 20 | 11 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 9 | 40 | 17 | 10 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 39 | 15 | 7 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 14 | 40 | 17 | 7 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 13 | 41 | 15 | 6 | 25 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 42 | 14 | 10 | 23 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 52 | 16 | 4 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 16 | 50 | 11 | 5 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 14 | 42 | 12 | 5 | 27 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 10 | 46 | 18 | 5 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 9 | 48 | 13 | 6 | 23 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 6 | 43 | 26 | 12 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 6 | 54 | 23 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 4 | 45 | 28 | 10 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 7 | 57 | 26 | 9 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 6 | 52 | 29 | 12 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 8 | 59 | 21 | 10 | 1 | 100 | +Spring, 2012 +| | Spring, 2011 | 10 | 60 | 23 | 7 | 1 | 100 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 6 | 62 | 24 | 7 | 2 | 100 | +Spring, 2010 +| | Fall, 2009 | 12 | 59 | 20 | 7 | 1 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 8 | 49 | 26 | 7 | 10 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 11 | 56 | 20 | 5 | 9 | 100 | +| | | 5 | 54 | 26 | 4 | 11 | 100 | +Spring, 2016 +| | Spring, 2015 | 7 | 48 | 29 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2013 | 5 | 54 | 27 | 3 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 8 | 57 | 26 | 4 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 6 | 54 | 29 | 4 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 7 | 50 | 27 | 6 | 9 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 14 | 59 | 18 | 4 | 4 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 2 | 35 | 35 | 16 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 2 | 31 | 33 | 24 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 2 | 23 | 40 | 29 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 3 | 22 | 42 | 23 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 1 | 19 | 37 | 35 | 7 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 11 | 49 | 17 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 8 | 49 | 20 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 9 | 50 | 17 | 10 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 11 | 53 | 18 | 8 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 11 | 49 | 18 | 7 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 49 | 18 | 7 | 14 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 53 | 14 | 2 | 20 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | 16 | 56 | 15 | 6 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 24 | 55 | 12 | 3 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 17 | 55 | 14 | 5 | 10 | 100 | +| | | 15 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 9 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +30 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 9 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 13 | 32 | 24 | 16 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 13 | 31 | 24 | 19 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 10 | 37 | 24 | 16 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 11 | 31 | 29 | 18 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 12 | 33 | 26 | 20 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 15 | 47 | 21 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 6 | 47 | 23 | 5 | 19 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 49 | 20 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 51 | 21 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 16 | 49 | 20 | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 13 | 45 | 27 | 9 | 6 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 45 | 15 | 8 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 23 | 39 | 14 | 5 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 18 | 43 | 10 | 7 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 19 | 41 | 12 | 7 | 21 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 12 | 47 | 13 | 5 | 23 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 15 | 47 | 13 | 4 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 17 | 46 | 12 | 5 | 20 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 18 | 42 | 12 | 5 | 24 | 100 | +| | | 22 | 41 | 11 | 6 | 21 | 100 | +Fall, 2009 +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 11 | 31 | 18 | 10 | 30 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 14 | 40 | 21 | 9 | 15 | 100 | +Fall, 2009 +| | Spring, 2007 | 18 | 36 | 18 | 9 | 19 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 12 | 42 | 19 | 8 | 19 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2013 | 8 | 48 | 25 | 7 | 12 | 100 | +| | | 9 | 42 | 28 | 9 | 12 | 100 | +Spring, 2012 +| | Fall, 2009 | 13 | 53 | 20 | 3 | 10 | 100 | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2007 | 9 | 51 | 29 | 7 | 5 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 7 | 41 | 10 | 6 | 35 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 9 | 51 | 19 | 3 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 6 | 51 | 24 | 6 | 13 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 6 | 51 | 17 | 2 | 24 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 30 | 47 | 10 | 2 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 4 | 61 | 17 | 2 | 16 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 50 | 14 | 5 | 22 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 22 | 60 | 6 | 2 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 22 | 57 | 6 | 1 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2016 | 12 | 58 | 11 | 1 | 17 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 9 | 65 | 14 | 2 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 7 | 57 | 17 | 3 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 11 | 59 | 16 | 3 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 12 | 60 | 11 | 2 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 18 | 59 | 9 | 1 | 13 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 17 | 58 | 8 | 2 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 15 | 57 | 13 | 4 | 11 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 7 | 44 | 27 | 12 | 10 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 52 | 22 | 4 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 7 | 46 | 30 | 8 | 9 | 100 | +| | | 1 | 15 | 27 | 33 | 24 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +31 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q8g. Please tell me if you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, +or very unfavorable opinion of ____? g. NATO, that is, North Atlantic Treaty Organization +| | | | Somewhat | | Somewhat | Very | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | +Very favorable favorable unfavorable unfavorable DK/Refused Total +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | 1 | 15 | | 27 | 33 | 24 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2015 | 3 | 9 | | 30 | 50 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 4 | 23 | | 32 | 18 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 4 | 18 | | 31 | 21 | 27 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 9 | 28 | | 26 | 17 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 8 | 32 | | 26 | 14 | 20 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 4 | 20 | | 36 | 22 | 18 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 5 | 25 | | 28 | 20 | 22 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 39 | | 15 | 8 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 20 | 38 | | 18 | 9 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 4 | 30 | | 23 | 18 | 25 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 10 | 21 | | 24 | 27 | 17 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 7 | 27 | | 24 | 30 | 12 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 3 | 18 | | 21 | 34 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 3 | 20 | | 27 | 31 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 5 | 18 | | 21 | 29 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2014 | 5 | 14 | | 17 | 53 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2013 | 5 | 20 | | 21 | 32 | 22 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2012 | 3 | 12 | | 16 | 43 | 26 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 2 | 16 | | 21 | 43 | 17 | 100 | +Q24. If Russia got into a serious military conflict with one of +its neighboring countries that is our NATO ally, do you think +(survey country) should or should not use military force to +defend that country? +| | | Yes, should | No, should not | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --------------- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | use military | | use military | | | | | +| | | force | | force | DK/Refused | | Total | | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 60 | | 29 | | 10 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | | 31 | | 7 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 56 | | 37 | | 7 | 100 | | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 56 | | 38 | | 5 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 58 | | 31 | | 11 | 100 | | +| | | 53 | | 36 | | 11 | 100 | | +Spring, 2015 +| France | Spring, 2019 | 41 | | 53 | | 6 | 100 | | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 53 | | 43 | | 4 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 47 | | 53 | | 0 | 100 | | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 34 | | 60 | | 6 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 40 | | 53 | | 6 | 100 | | +| | | 38 | | 58 | | 4 | 100 | | +Spring, 2015 +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 25 | | 63 | | 12 | 100 | | +| ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Spring, 2017 | 25 | | 71 | | 4 | 100 | | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 25 | | 66 | | 8 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 36 | | 50 | | 14 | 100 | | +| | Spring, 2015 | 40 | | 51 | | 9 | 100 | | +| | | 64 | | 32 | | 3 | 100 | | +www.pewresearch.org + +32 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q24. If Russia got into a serious military conflict with one of +its neighboring countries that is our NATO ally, do you think +(survey country) should or should not use military force to +defend that country? +| | | Yes, should No, should not | | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ---------------------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | use military | use military | | | +| | | force | force | DK/Refused | Total | +| | | 64 | 32 | 3 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 72 | 23 | 5 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 41 | 56 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 46 | 46 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 48 | 47 | 5 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 55 | 41 | 5 | 100 | +| | | 45 | 43 | 12 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 49 | 37 | 14 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 69 | 18 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 36 | 47 | 16 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 33 | 43 | 24 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 49 | 37 | 14 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 51 | 34 | 15 | 100 | +| | | 40 | 43 | 18 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 26 | 12 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 48 | 34 | 17 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 55 | 12 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 55 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 29 | 47 | 23 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +33 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q25. And do you think the United States would or would not +use military force to defend that country? +No, would not +| | | Yes, would use | use military | | | +| ------- | ------------ | --------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | military force | force | DK/Refused | Total | +| | | 69 | 25 | 5 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 68 | 21 | 11 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 72 | 18 | 10 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 37 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 60 | 36 | 4 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 65 | 34 | 1 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 63 | 31 | 6 | 100 | +| | | 65 | 27 | 7 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 68 | 26 | 6 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 65 | 19 | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 31 | 7 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 75 | 16 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 62 | 23 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 68 | 23 | 10 | 100 | +| | | 68 | 28 | 4 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 69 | 25 | 6 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 72 | 21 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 70 | 20 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 70 | 21 | 9 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 73 | 22 | 5 | 100 | +| | | 66 | 25 | 9 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 66 | 24 | 10 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 41 | 35 | 24 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 39 | 31 | 30 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2017 | 55 | 28 | 17 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 29 | 15 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 47 | 30 | 23 | 100 | +| | | 57 | 26 | 17 | 100 | +Spring, 2017 +| | Spring, 2015 | 49 | 31 | 20 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 57 | 27 | 16 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | 46 | 40 | 14 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2015 | 40 | 34 | 25 | 100 | +Due to a translation error, the results are not shown for Bulgaria. +www.pewresearch.org + +34 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q35. Which is more important for (survey country)? +Both +| | | Having a close | | relationships | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ----- | +| | | relationship to | Having a close | are equally | | | | | +| | | the United | relationship to | important (DO | | Neither (DO | | | +| | | States | Russia | NOT READ) | | NOT READ) | DK/Refused | Total | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 60 | 18 | 13 | | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 31 | 17 | 40 | | 8 | 4 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 38 | 7 | 45 | | 4 | 6 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | 82 | 11 | 4 | | 0 | 2 | 100 | +| | | 73 | 9 | 9 | | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 71 | 11 | 9 | | 4 | 4 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 83 | 8 | 5 | | 4 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 16 | 28 | 47 | | 4 | 6 | 100 | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 27 | 14 | 39 | | 13 | 7 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 8 | 55 | | 7 | 7 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 17 | 38 | | 7 | 9 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 12 | 53 | | 4 | 2 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 23 | 22 | 50 | | 3 | 3 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 13 | 34 | | 9 | 12 | 100 | +Q50f. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. f. There are parts of neighboring countries +that really belong to us +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree | Mostly agree | disagree | disagree | | DK/Refused | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 14 | 27 | 46 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 9 | 22 | 29 | 23 | | 17 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 20 | 34 | 31 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 5 | 14 | 29 | 33 | | 19 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 9 | 24 | 24 | 35 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 18 | 31 | 43 | | 2 | 100 | +| | | 5 | 20 | 30 | 41 | | 4 | 100 | +Summer, 2002 +| | Spring, 1991 | 3 | 9 | 18 | 47 | | 23 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 10 | 20 | 19 | 43 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 23 | 32 | 33 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 9 | 24 | 23 | 39 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 14 | 25 | 26 | 24 | | 10 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 31 | 29 | 18 | | 9 | 13 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 8 | 28 | 19 | 19 | | 26 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 39 | 20 | 14 | | 18 | 100 | +| | | 13 | 29 | 25 | 17 | | 17 | 100 | +Summer, 2002 +| | Spring, 1991 | 9 | 20 | 17 | 32 | | 22 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 7 | 17 | 30 | 44 | | 2 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 17 | 22 | 38 | | 4 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 9 | 32 | 29 | 14 | | 16 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 28 | 20 | 12 | 17 | | 23 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 8 | 12 | 70 | | 6 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 5 | 18 | 33 | 39 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 6 | 23 | 31 | 29 | | 11 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 28 | 28 | 26 | | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 4 | 16 | 29 | 35 | | 17 | 100 | +| | | 30 | 28 | 15 | | 7 | 20 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +35 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50f. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. f. There are parts of neighboring countries +that really belong to us +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree Mostly agree | | disagree | disagree | DK/Refused | Total | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 30 | 28 | 15 | 7 | 20 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 31 | 35 | 11 | 6 | 17 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 25 | 29 | 13 | 6 | 25 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 19 | 15 | 8 | 24 | 100 | +| | | 12 | 19 | 13 | 20 | 36 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Fall, 2009 | 11 | 29 | 24 | 17 | 20 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 24 | 35 | 23 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 20 | 22 | 20 | 16 | 23 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 40 | 27 | 11 | 14 | 8 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 34 | 27 | 15 | 19 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 40 | 30 | 11 | 12 | 7 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 8 | 22 | 23 | 28 | 18 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 10 | 30 | 20 | 19 | 22 | 100 | +| | | 24 | 22 | 15 | 19 | 20 | 100 | +Spring, 1991 +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 12 | 36 | 22 | 14 | 17 | 100 | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2009 | 14 | 37 | 22 | 10 | 16 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 19 | 40 | 19 | 8 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 27 | 33 | 15 | 7 | 18 | 100 | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | 13 | 33 | 19 | 14 | 22 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 7 | 22 | 30 | 19 | 22 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 11 | 31 | 33 | 18 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 15 | 19 | 15 | 19 | 32 | 100 | +| | | 26 | 27 | 21 | 12 | 14 | 100 | +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2017 | 26 | 34 | 17 | 12 | 11 | 100 | +| | | 24 | 37 | 18 | 11 | 10 | 100 | +Spring, 2015 +| | Spring, 2014 | 28 | 33 | 18 | 10 | 11 | 100 | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Fall, 2009 | 19 | 39 | 19 | 10 | 13 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 26 | 38 | 14 | 4 | 19 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 10 | 12 | 22 | 26 | 30 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 23 | 13 | 22 | 19 | 100 | +| | Fall, 2009 | 5 | 19 | 21 | 30 | 25 | 100 | +| | Summer, 2002 | 10 | 15 | 26 | 36 | 13 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 8 | 16 | 21 | 23 | 32 | 100 | +| | | 30 | 28 | 11 | 18 | 14 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Summer, 2002 | 40 | 23 | 9 | 15 | 14 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +36 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50h. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. h. It is sometimes necessary to use military +force to maintain order in the world +| | | Completely | | Mostly | Completely | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | +| | | agree Mostly agree | | disagree | disagree | DK/Refused | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | 32 | 46 | 16 | 5 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 26 | 49 | 15 | 8 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 30 | 47 | 13 | 7 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 35 | 42 | 14 | 6 | 3 | 100 | +| Canada | Spring, 2019 | 24 | 47 | 19 | 8 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 26 | 45 | 17 | 10 | 2 | 100 | +| France | Spring, 2019 | 20 | 44 | 15 | 20 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 18 | 44 | 20 | 17 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 19 | 38 | 20 | 23 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 26 | 41 | 18 | 15 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 39 | 38 | 12 | 9 | 3 | 100 | +| Germany | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 32 | 24 | 28 | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 10 | 40 | 28 | 22 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 13 | 33 | 29 | 25 | 0 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 11 | 30 | 29 | 29 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 15 | 37 | 23 | 16 | 8 | 100 | +| Greece | Spring, 2019 | 19 | 31 | 24 | 25 | 1 | 100 | +| Italy | Spring, 2019 | 14 | 38 | 27 | 18 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 25 | 48 | 15 | 7 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 31 | 16 | 19 | 2 | 100 | +| | | 19 | 50 | 20 | 11 | 0 | 100 | +| Netherlands | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| Spain | Spring, 2019 | 29 | 26 | 18 | 26 | 1 | 100 | +| | | 13 | 49 | 24 | 12 | 1 | 100 | +Spring, 2011 +| | Spring, 2010 | 10 | 45 | 28 | 15 | 2 | 100 | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 11 | 54 | 18 | 9 | 9 | 100 | +Spring, 2007 +| | Spring, 1991 | 28 | 18 | 19 | 29 | 7 | 100 | +| -------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | 32 | 47 | 12 | 8 | 1 | 100 | +| Sweden | Spring, 2019 | | | | | | | +| | Spring, 2007 | 37 | 38 | 11 | 10 | 4 | 100 | +| United Kingdom | Spring, 2019 | 18 | 53 | 20 | 9 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 17 | 53 | 17 | 10 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 23 | 50 | 14 | 10 | 3 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 19 | 48 | 19 | 9 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 41 | 43 | 8 | 6 | 2 | 100 | +| Bulgaria | Spring, 2019 | 10 | 28 | 28 | 26 | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 13 | 21 | 26 | 25 | 15 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 32 | 30 | 15 | 9 | 14 | 100 | +| Czech Republic | Spring, 2019 | 17 | 36 | 25 | 12 | 10 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 23 | 39 | 22 | 14 | 1 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 33 | 41 | 13 | 5 | 7 | 100 | +| Hungary | Spring, 2019 | 27 | 43 | 14 | 11 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 34 | 36 | 14 | 7 | 8 | 100 | +| Lithuania | Spring, 2019 | 13 | 35 | 21 | 23 | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 7 | 36 | 28 | 23 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 20 | 28 | 17 | 24 | 10 | 100 | +| Poland | Spring, 2019 | 15 | 43 | 20 | 15 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | 19 | 46 | 20 | 8 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | 15 | 46 | 24 | 10 | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | 16 | 40 | 26 | 11 | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | 26 | 42 | 15 | 5 | 11 | 100 | +| | | 14 | 39 | 25 | 17 | 6 | 100 | +www.pewresearch.org + +37 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Q50h. Please tell me whether you completely agree, mostly agree, mostly disagree or +completely disagree with the following statements. h. It is sometimes necessary to use military +force to maintain order in the world +| | | | Completely | | | | Mostly | | Completely | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | agree | | Mostly agree | | disagree | | disagree | | DK/Refused | | Total | +| Slovakia | Spring, 2019 | | 14 | | 39 | | | 25 | | 17 | | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 16 | | 31 | | | 28 | | 23 | | 2 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 27 | | 38 | | | 15 | | 7 | | 13 | 100 | +| Russia | Spring, 2019 | | 36 | | 34 | | | 16 | | 11 | | 4 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2014 | | 22 | | 43 | | | 17 | | 12 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | 15 | | 37 | | | 23 | | 15 | | 9 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | | 23 | | 38 | | | 26 | | 9 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 21 | | 40 | | | 21 | | 10 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 22 | | 40 | | | 13 | | 14 | | 12 | 100 | +| Ukraine | Spring, 2019 | | 26 | | 36 | | | 16 | | 14 | | 7 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | | 7 | 33 | | | 27 | | 24 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 16 | | 35 | | | 27 | | 17 | | 6 | 100 | +| | Spring, 1991 | | 12 | | 42 | | | 19 | | 18 | | 10 | 100 | +| Turkey | Spring, 2019 | | 38 | | 33 | | | 10 | | 15 | | 5 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2011 | | 25 | | 41 | | | 13 | | 12 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2010 | | 20 | | 29 | | | 21 | | 23 | | 8 | 100 | +| | Spring, 2007 | | 36 | | 38 | | | 13 | | 6 | | 6 | 100 | +Q93USA. In politics TODAY, do you consider yourself a Republican, Democrat or Independent? +| | | | | | | | | No preference | | Other party | | | | +| ------------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | | (DO NOT | | (DO NOT | | | | +| | | Republican | | Democrat | | Independent | | READ) | | READ) | | DK/R | Total | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | | 26 | 31 | | 37 | | 3 | | 0 | | 2 | 100 | +Q93aUSA. ASK IN U.S. IF INDEPENDENT, NO PREFERENCE, OTHER PARTY OR DK/R ONLY: As of +today do you lean more to the Republican Party or more to the Democratic Party? +Other (DO +| | | | Republican | | Democrat | | NOT READ) | | DK/R | | | Total N= | | +| ------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | +| United States | Spring, 2019 | | 32 | | 39 | | 11 | | | 19 | | 100 | 614 | +www.pewresearch.org \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q24/random_k4/random_3.md b/q24/random_k4/random_3.md index 5f25948a22d7c2a5735287800f5a22fb3a228ee5..b1f264dec8c881060a31fd51402112360988391b 100644 --- a/q24/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q24/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1412 +1,633 @@ -Alibaba Group Announces June Quarter 2017 Results -Hangzhou, China, August 17, 2017 – Alibaba Group Holding Limited (NYSE: BABA) today announced its -financial results for the quarter ended June 30, 2017. -“Alibaba had a strong start to fiscal 2018, reflecting the strength and diversity of our businesses and the value -we bring to customers on our platforms. Our technology is driving significant growth across our business -and strengthening our position beyond core commerce,” said Daniel Zhang, Chief Executive Officer of -Alibaba Group. “We are excited about the future as we continue to innovate and drive synergies among the -businesses throughout the Alibaba ecosystem.” -“We delivered excellent results in the first quarter, with robust revenue growth of 56%. The significant -growth in customer management revenue represents the differentiated business value we provide to our -customers,” said Maggie Wu, Chief Financial Officer of Alibaba Group. “It is our intention to continue -investing in long-term growth opportunities, some of which are already delivering significant value to -customers and investors.” -BUSINESS HIGHLIGHTS -In the quarter ended June 30, 2017: - Revenue was RMB50,184 million (US$7,403 million), an increase of 56% year-over-year. - Revenue from core commerce increased 58% year-over-year to RMB43,027 million -(US$6,347 million). - Revenue from cloud computing increased 96% year-over-year to RMB2,431 million (US$359 -million). - Revenue from digital media and entertainment increased 30% year-over-year to RMB4,081 -million (US$602 million). - Revenue from innovation initiatives and others increased 21% year-over-year to RMB645 -million (US$95 million). - Annual active consumers (formerly annual active buyers) on our China retail marketplaces reached -466 million, an increase of 12 million from the 12-month period ended March 31, 2017. - Mobile MAUs on our China retail marketplaces reached 529 million in June, an increase of 22 -million over March 2017. -1 - - The number of paying customers of our cloud computing business grew to 1,011,000 from -874,000 in the previous quarter. Operating loss from cloud computing was RMB532 million (US$78 -million) and adjusted EBITA loss was RMB103 million (US$15 million). - Net income was RMB14,031 million (US$2,070 million), income from operations was RMB17,513 -million (US$2,583 million) and adjusted EBITDA was RMB25,124 million (US$3,706 million). -Operating margin was 35%, adjusted EBITDA margin was 50% and adjusted EBITA margin -for core commerce was 63%. - Diluted EPS was RMB5.65 (US$0.83) and non-GAAP diluted EPS was RMB7.95 (US$1.17). - Net cash provided by operating activities was RMB25,311 million (US$3,733 million) and non- -GAAP free cash flow was RMB22,149 million (US$3,267 million). -BUSINESS AND STRATEGIC UPDATES -Core Commerce -Core Commerce – consumer engagement and technology drive monetization. Revenue acceleration in -our China retail marketplaces continues to benefit from robust growth in average spending per merchant and -the number of paying merchants, which reached a historical high during the quarter. At the core of our -broader value proposition to merchants is the consumer insights gathered from providing e-commerce and -entertainment services to consumers within our ecosystem, which enable our merchants to target, engage and -manage their customer assets along the entire consumer journey. This broader value proposition is -recognized by the merchants and reflected in our customer management revenue (formerly online marketing -service revenue). -Taobao – a vibrant ecosystem driven by personalized content and innovation. Taobao App’s highly -relevant and engaging content continues to drive robust growth in active users and engagement. In the -quarter ended June 30, 2017, mobile MAUs on our China retail marketplaces increased by 22 million to a -total of 529 million mobile MAUs, driven by the strength of the Taobao App. In May, we rolled out a new -mobile Taobao user interface that integrates the latest in personalization technology, which we believe will -continue to improve user experience and enhance engagement. -Taobao is a vibrant ecosystem that promotes, enables and benefits from the innovation of China’s SME’s and -entrepreneurs. In July, we held the second annual Taobao Maker Festival in Hangzhou, which showcased -original quality designs and trend setting products from millennial entrepreneurs who embody the innovative -thinking of China’s younger generation. Tens of millions of consumers attended the five-day event virtually -and in person. -Tmall – gaining B2C market share in core categories and more collaboration with brands. Tmall -recorded 49% year-over-year growth for physical goods GMV in the quarter ended June 30, 2017. Fashion -and apparel, consumer electronics and fast moving consumer goods, or FMCG, were among the key -categories that experienced robust and reaccelerating GMV growth during the quarter. -We have established Tmall as a leading brand-building and distribution platform that is capturing increasing -digital marketing and commerce spending from owners of both domestic and international branded products -that are doing business in China. During the quarter, international brands such as Moet Hennessy, Victoria’s -2 - -Secret, Roland and Abercrombie & Fitch established Tmall flagship stores to engage with and sell their -products to consumers on our platforms. -New Retail – seamless integration of online and offline retail experience. In May 2017, we completed -the privatization and the acquisition of a controlling stake in Intime Retail Group for HK$12.6 billion -(US$1.6 billion). Intime is a leading department store and mall operator in China with 49 department stores -and shopping malls as of June 30, 2017. We expect Intime to support our strategy to transform conventional -retail, especially in soft goods and branded products, by leveraging our substantial consumer reach, insight -and technology. -In the fresh food category, we incubated Hema in 2015 to digitize and transform the traditional supermarket -and big-box retail format in China, using technology to offer consumers a more efficient and flexible -shopping experience whether they are online or in the store. As part of our New Retail strategy, Hema -leverages our consumer insight, mobile technologies and other proprietary in-store technologies to provide a -seamless omni-channel experience for consumers. Hema stores double as warehouses for online orders, and -our proprietary fulfillment system enables 30-minute delivery to customers. -International – laying the foundation for long-term growth. Our cross-border and international consumer -businesses continue to exhibit robust growth. Revenue from our international commerce retail business -reached meaningful scale at RMB2,638 million (US$389 million) in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, -representing a 136% year-on-year growth, driven by strong growth in our Southeast Asian platform Lazada -and our China outbound platform AliExpress. The growth of Lazada and AliExpress further expands our -customer base outside China. -During the quarter we increased our ownership in Lazada to 83%, reflecting confidence in the growth -potential of its businesses and the Southeast Asian markets. During the quarter, Lazada launched the -“LiveUp” subscription-based membership program in Singapore, with free shipping for eligible products and -grocery deliveries within 24 hours. Members also enjoy free trial subscriptions from Netflix and VIP benefits -from Uber and UberEats. Under cooperation with Taobao Marketplace, Lazada launched “Taobao -Collection” in Singapore and Malaysia, which expands Lazada’s product offering by giving local customers -access to high-quality products from China. We will continue to aggressively invest in the high potential -markets of Southeast Asia as well as launch innovative services to benefit consumers in the region. -This quarter, we made significant progress in educating the US market on Alibaba and the opportunities we -enable for businesses of all sizes to use our platform to build their brands and sell their products to millions -of Chinese consumers who desire quality American goods. In June, we hosted Gateway ’17 in Detroit, -Michigan – a conference where 3000 U.S. small businesses, farmers, brands and entrepreneurs attended to -learn about how to sell to China using Alibaba as their gateway. Businesses such as Gerber, Stadium Goods, -and 100% Pure shared their experiences on how Alibaba has helped them grow their businesses by tapping -into the China market, which is good for the Chinese consumer as well as for business growth and job -creation in the United States. On September 25, we will host a similar event in Canada to educate and engage -Canadian businesses in selling to China. -In August, with Marriott, we established a joint venture to provide a completely new travel experience for -hundreds of millions of Chinese consumers with personalized VIP experiences, cashless travel and an -integrated loyalty program. Marriott’s award-winning loyalty platform coupled with our unparalleled digital -consumption ecosystem in China present tremendous opportunities to create the best-in-class membership -platform for over 500 million active mobile users on our China retail marketplaces. -3 - -Cloud Computing -Alibaba Cloud reached a key milestone of exceeding one million paying customers, an increase of 137,000 -from the previous quarter. Cloud computing revenue grew 96% year-over-year to RMB2,431 million -(US$359 million), driven by robust paying customer growth and improving revenue mix of higher valued- -added services, as reflected by ongoing ARPU expansion. Market expansion remains our top priority, and we -will continue to invest to acquire customers by developing innovative solutions and deploying efficient and -cost effective products and services. -During the quarter, Alibaba Cloud launched several new products that lower the barrier of migrating large- -scale data to cloud services for traditional companies. For example, Cloud Storage Gateway allows -customers to seamlessly connect their on-premise storage with Alibaba Cloud storage. Lightning Cube, a -petabyte-scale data transport solution, helps enterprises to transfer large amounts of data at high speed -between their data centers and Alibaba Cloud through portable storage appliances. Alibaba Cloud also -continues to expand its Elastic Computing Service product portfolio. As of mid-August 2017, Alibaba Cloud -is providing 19 types of Elastic Computing Service products that can be applied to 173 application scenarios, -such as artificial intelligence, healthcare, video streaming, finance, e-commerce, and IoT. -Our cloud computing customer base spans a variety of industries and businesses from startups to large -corporations, covering industry segments across consumer brands, energy, financial institutions, healthcare, -manufacturing, media and retail. Selected enterprise customers in China include: - CITIC Group, a major state-owned multinational diversified company in China, is using our hybrid -cloud solutions to enhance the integration of internal processes; - China Huaneng Group, a fortune 500 company, adopted our hybrid cloud solution to digitize and -upgrade its global procurement system; - ofo, a leading, rapidly growing bike sharing company in China, is expanding the range of cloud -services including security, storage and big data, to support its business expansion; and - PICC Finance, a subsidiary of PICC, one of the largest insurance companies in Asia, will adopt our -financial vertical solution to support its expansion into Internet financing services. -On the international front, Alibaba Cloud continues to expand its global footprint and customer base. During -the quarter, we announced plans to build two new data centers in Malaysia and Indonesia, adding to our -presence in over 14 countries and regions to serve customers worldwide. For example, AirAsia, a Pan-Asian -airline based in Malaysia and the largest low-cost carrier in Asia in terms of fleet size, began to operate their -business on our cloud computing platform utilizing security and content delivery network services. -Digital Media and Entertainment -During the quarter, the management focus of our digital media and entertainment segment was on -broadening our access to quality content, developing Youku’s subscription based business, and expanding -the products and services of UCWeb. -Our strategy of acquiring and developing a mixture of licensed and original content yielded hit drama and -variety shows during the quarter. In addition, daily average subscribers of Youku video subscriptions -increased over 100% year-on-year in the quarter ended June 30, 2017. We believe a strong pipeline of -content, especially with a focus on original content with visibility of content availability and broadcast -timing flexibility, will bring us sustainable long-term advantages in video entertainment. -4 - -UCWeb continues its strategy of deepening its products and services beyond the browser. We saw increased -engagement of value-added services of UCWeb. We will continue to invest in product expansion as well as -the international footprint of UCWeb. -Innovation Initiatives -We continue to deliver innovative products that serve the day-to-day needs of our customers. In July we -launched our first AI-powered voice assistant, Tmall Genie, which was developed by our AI Lab leveraging -our group’s proprietary AI technology. The Tmall Genie assists with shopping, ordering local services, -searching for information, controlling smart appliances and playing multi-media content, including -educational stories and music for children. Tmall Genie is equipped with our proprietary “voice-print -payment” technology that accurately identifies a user’s voice (analogous to using finger-print to identify -individuals) to authenticate the user and complete the payment process. -Commitment to Intellectual Property Protection -In August, 180 brand representatives attended our second Brand Rights’ Holder Day in Beijing. The event -featured presentations from our brand-protection team and workshops detailing our initiatives in intellectual -property protection. Brands and rights holders see increasing benefits from the unique aspects of our -technology to monitor and to protect the integrity of our platforms. In the first month after the recent -implementation of technology enhancements on our IP protection platform, almost all cases submitted by -rights holders were handled and closed within 24 hours. -We also announced a partnership with French luxury group Kering to cooperate in intellectual property -protection. The two companies have established a joint task force to collaborate fully, exchange information, -and work closely with law enforcement to take appropriate action against infringers of Kering’s brands -identified with Alibaba’s advanced technology capabilities. As part of the agreement, Kering dismissed the -lawsuit against us and our affiliate Alipay in the federal district court in New York. -Updates on Equity Investees and Others -Cainiao Network – data enabled logistics network. During the quarter, Cainiao Network’s platform -enabled the delivery of an average of 55 million packages per day on our China retail marketplaces. Cainiao -Network continues to focus on improving user experience and merchant efficiency. For example, in June, -Cainiao Network launched automated guided vehicles in a fulfillment center in Guangdong, which improved -sorting efficiency. -Koubei and Ele.me – restaurant, food delivery and local services. Koubei, our local services joint venture -with Ant Financial, generated RMB92 billion (US$14 billion) in payment volume transacted through Alipay -during the quarter ended June 30, 2017, compared to RMB75 billion in the prior quarter, achieving a -sequential growth rate of 23%. During this quarter, we and Ant Financial jointly invested further capital into -food delivery company Ele.me, an equity investee, to fuel its rapid expansion. Ele.me currently provides -services in over 2,000 cities and counties. -Social Impact -Job training for women. In June, the Alibaba Foundation expanded its job creation program to Hubei -Province to support and train impoverished mothers with professional skills to enter the e-commerce -industry. As of July 2017, the program, which the Alibaba Foundation started in 2010, has helped more than -5,000 mothers in different Chinese cities gain employment. -5 - -Recovery of missing children. The “Reunion” platform that helps locate missing children across China -celebrated its first anniversary in May 2017. The Reunion platform is an ecosystem of connected Alibaba -and partner mobile apps that provides the infrastructure for law enforcement authorities to receive crowd- -sourced information from the public in order to more effectively conduct searches for missing children. -According to the Chinese authorities, the platform had successfully located 1,274 missing children since -inception in May 2016, with a 97% success rate. -Cash Flow from Operating Activities and Free Cash Flow -Net cash provided by operating activities in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB25,311 million -(US$3,733 million), an increase of 69% compared to RMB14,958 million in the same quarter of 2016. Free -cash flow, a non-GAAP measurement of liquidity, in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB22,149 -million (US$3,267 million), an increase of 74% compared to RMB12,745 million in the same quarter of -2016. A reconciliation of net cash provided by operating activities to free cash flow is included at the end of -this results announcement. -6 - -KEY OPERATIONAL METRICS* -% Change -| | | June 30, | | March 31, | | | June 30, | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | -| | | 2016 | | | 2017 | | 2017 | | | YoY QoQ | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| China Commerce Retail: | | | | | | | | | | | -Annual active consumers(1) (in millions) 434 454 466 7% 3% -Mobile monthly active users (MAUs)(2) (in -| millions) | | 427 | | | 507 | | | 529 | | 24% 4% | -| ----------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -------- | -| Cloud Computing: | | | | | | | | | | | -Paying customers(3) (in thousands) 577 874 1,011 75% 16% - -* For definitions of terms used but not defined in this results announcement, please refer to our annual report on Form 20-F for -the fiscal year ended March 31, 2017. -(1) For the twelve months ended on the respective dates. -(2) For the month ended on the respective dates. -(3) As of the respective dates. - -SUMMARY FINANCIAL RESULTS -| | | | Three months ended June 30, | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | -| | | 2016 | | | | 2017 | | | | | -| | | RMB | | | RMB | | US$(1) | | YoY % Change | | -| | | (in millions, except percentages and per share amounts) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| Revenue | | 32,154 | | | 50,184 | | 7,403 | | | 56% | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| Income from operations | | 8,814 | | | 17,513 | | 2,583 | | | 99% | -| Operating margin | | | 27% | | 35% | | | | | | -| Adjusted EBITDA(2) | | 14,963 | | | 25,124 | | 3,706 | | | 68% | -| Adjusted EBITDA margin(2) | | | 47% | | 50% | | | | | | -| Adjusted EBITA(2) | | 13,759 | | | 23,518 | | 3,469 | | | 71% | -Adjusted EBITA margin(2) -| | | | 43% | | 47% | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| Net income | | 7,142 | | | 14,031 | | 2,070 | | | 96% | -| Non-GAAP net income(2) | | 11,991 | | | 20,019 | | 2,953 | | | 67% | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| Diluted earnings per share/ADS (EPS) | | | 2.94 | | 5.65 | | | 0.83 | | 92% | -Non-GAAP diluted EPS(2) -| | | | 4.83 | | 7.95 | | | 1.17 | | 65% | -| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | - -(1) This results announcement contains translations of certain Renminbi (“RMB”) amounts into U.S. dollars (“US$”) for the -convenience of the reader. Unless otherwise stated, all translations of RMB into US$ were made at RMB6.7793 to US$1.00, -the exchange rate on June 30, 2017 as set forth in the H.10 statistical release of the Federal Reserve Board. The percentages -stated in this announcement are calculated based on the RMB amounts. -(2) See the sections entitled “Information about Segments,” “Non-GAAP Financial Measures” and “Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Measures to the Nearest Comparable GAAP Measures” for more information about the non-GAAP measures referred -to within this results announcement. - -7 - -|   | | | | | | | | |   | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -INFORMATION ABOUT SEGMENTS -The table below sets forth selected financial information of our operating segments for the periods indicated: -| | | | | | | | Three months ended June 30, 2017 | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | Digital media | | Innovation | | | | | | | | -| | | | Core | | Cloud | | and | | initiatives | | | | | | | -commerce computing entertainment and others Unallocated(1) Consolidated -| | | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | RMB | | US$ | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | ----- | ------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | (in millions, except percentages) | | | | | | | | | -| Revenue | | | 43,027 | | 2,431 | | 4,081 | | 645 | | | — | 50,184 | 7,403 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Income (loss) from | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -operations 24,808 (532) (3,388) (1,612) (1,763) 17,513 2,583 -Add: Share-based -compensation -| expense | | | 1,560 | | 428 | | 502 | | 816 | | | 713 | 4,019 | 593 | | -| -------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --- | -Add: Amortization -of intangible -| assets | | | 602 | | 1 | | 1,138 | | 162 | | | 83 | 1,986 | 293 | | -| ------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -Adjusted EBITA 26,970 (103) (1,748) (634) (967) 23,518 3,469 -| Adjusted EBITA | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -| margin | | | 63% | | (4)% | | (43)% | | (98)% | | | | 47% | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |   | -| | | | | | | | Three months ended June 30, 2016  | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Digital media | | Innovation | | | | | | | | -| | | | Core | | Cloud | | and | | initiatives | | | | | | | -commerce computing entertainment and others Unallocated(1) Consolidated -| | | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | | -| -------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | (in millions, except percentages) | | | | | | | | | -| Revenue | | | 27,241 | | 1,243 | | 3,135 | | 535 | | — | | 32,154 | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -Income (loss) from -| operations | | | 14,682 | | (439) | | (1,853) | | (1,572) | | (2,004) | | | 8,814 | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -| Add: Share-based | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| compensation | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -| expense | | | 1,456 | | 280 | | 334 | | 520 | | 1,104 | | | 3,694 | | -| -------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -Add: Amortization -of intangible -| assets | | | 486 | | 1 | | 523 | | 165 | | 76 | | | 1,251 | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | |   | | | | | | | | | | | -| Adjusted EBITA | | | 16,624 | | (158) | | (996) | | (887) | | (824) | | 13,759 | | | -Adjusted EBITA -| margin | | | 61% | | (13)% | | (32)% | | (166)% | | | | | 43% | | -| ------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -(1) Unallocated expenses are primarily related to corporate administrative costs and other miscellaneous items that are not -allocated to individual segments. -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -8 - -|   | | | | | | | | | | | |   | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -JUNE QUARTER OPERATIONAL AND FINANCIAL RESULTS -Revenue -Revenue for the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB50,184 million (US$7,403 million), an increase of -56% compared to RMB32,154 million in the same quarter of 2016. The increase was mainly driven by the -robust revenue growth of our China commerce retail business, international commerce retail business and -Alibaba Cloud. -The following table sets forth a breakdown of our revenue by segment for the periods indicated: -| | | | | Three months ended June 30, | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | 2016 | | | | | 2017 | | | | | -| | | | | % of | | | | | | % of | | YoY % | -| | | | RMB | Revenue | | RMB | | US$ | | Revenue | | Change | - -| | | | | | (in millions, except percentages) | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Core commerce: | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| China commerce retail | | | | | | | | | | | | | - - Customer management 15,882 49% 26,220 3,868 52% 65% -| - Commission | | | 6,926 | | 22% | 8,878 | | 1,309 | | 18% | | 28% | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | --- | ----- | -| - Others | | | 575 | | 2% | 1,614 | | | 238 | | 3% | 181% | -| | | | 23,383 | | 73% | 36,712 | | 5,415 | | 73% | | 57% | -| China commerce wholesale | | | 1,261 | | 4% | 1,641 | | | 242 | | 3% | 30% | -International commerce retail 1,117 4% 2,638 389 6% 136% -International commerce wholesale 1,432 4% 1,609 237 3% 12% -| Others | | | 48 | | 0% | | 427 | | 64 | | 1% | 790% | -| -------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | ---- | --- | ----- | -| Total core commerce | | | 27,241 | | 85% | 43,027 | | 6,347 | | 86% | | 58% | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Cloud computing | | | 1,243 | | 4% | 2,431 | | | 359 | | 5% | 96% | -Digital media and entertainment 3,135 10% 4,081 602 8% 30% -Innovation initiatives and others 535 1% 645 95 1% 21% -| Total | | | | | | | | | | | | 56% | -| ------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | -| | | | 32,154 | | 100% | 50,184 | | 7,403 | | 100% | | | - -Core commerce - China commerce retail business -Revenue – Revenue from our China commerce retail business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was -RMB36,712 million (US$5,415 million), or 73% of total revenue, an increase of 57% compared to -RMB23,383 million in the same quarter of 2016. The increase in revenue was due to robust growth of -customer management revenue (formerly online marketing service revenue), as well as growth in -commission revenue. Customer management revenue grew by 65% year-over-year, driven primarily -by increases in the volume of clicks, reflecting mobile user growth and our ability to deliver more -relevant content to consumers through our enhancements in personalization technology. This growth -resulted in higher average spending on our customer management services by an increasing number -of merchants. Commission revenue, representing 24% of China commerce retail revenue in the -quarter ended June 30, 2017, grew by 28% year-over-year, while Tmall recorded 49% year-over-year -growth for physical goods GMV for the same period. The relatively lower growth rate of reported -commission revenue was primarily due to the netting-off of expenditures against commissions paid -by merchants as a result of new promotion initiatives for customer acquisition and retention. In mid- -9 - -|   | | | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -May, we started consolidating Intime, which contributed primarily to the increase in other revenue for -our China commerce retail business. -Our annual China commerce retail revenue per annual active consumer increased from RMB202 for -the quarter ended June 30, 2016 to RMB273 (US$40) for the quarter ended June 30, 2017, and -mobile revenue per mobile MAU grew from RMB140 for the quarter ended June 30, 2016 to -RMB196 (US$29) for the quarter ended June 30, 2017. -(1) China commerce retail revenue per active consumer for each of the above periods is calculated by dividing the China -commerce retail revenue for the previous 12-month period by the annual active consumers for the same 12-month period. -(2) Mobile revenue per mobile MAU from China commerce retail, annualized is calculated by dividing mobile revenue from -China commerce retail for the previous 12-month period by the mobile MAUs for the last month of the same period. -Annual active consumers – Our China retail marketplaces had 466 million annual active consumers -in the 12 months ended June 30, 2017, compared to 454 million in the 12 months ended March 31, -2017, representing a net addition of 12 million from the prior quarter, and a 7% increase from 434 -million in the 12 months ended June 30, 2016. Average annual spend per active consumer for the 12 -months ended June 30, 2017 also continued to increase from prior quarters. The longer consumers -have been with our platform, the more they spend, placing more orders across more product -categories. -Mobile MAUs – Mobile MAUs on our China retail marketplaces grew to 529 million in June 2017, -compared to 507 million in March 2017, representing a net addition of 22 million MAUs in the -quarter and a 24% increase from 427 million in June 2016. - China commerce wholesale business -Revenue from our China commerce wholesale business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was -RMB1,641 million (US$242 million), an increase of 30% compared to RMB1,261 million in the -same quarter of 2016. The increase was primarily due to an increase in the average revenue from -paying members on our 1688.com platform. - International commerce retail business -Revenue from our international commerce retail business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was -RMB2,638 million (US$389 million), an increase of 136% compared to RMB1,117 million in the -10 - -same quarter of 2016. The increase was primarily due to the growth in revenue generated from -Lazada and AliExpress, driven by robust GMV growth in these two marketplaces. - International commerce wholesale business -Revenue from our international commerce wholesale business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was -RMB1,609 million (US$237 million), an increase of 12% compared to RMB1,432 million in the -same quarter of 2016. The increase was due to growth in revenue generated by import/export related -value-added services and online marketing revenue. -Cloud computing -Revenue from our cloud computing business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB2,431 million -(US$359 million), an increase of 96% compared to RMB1,243 million in the same quarter of 2016, primarily -driven by an increase in the number of paying customers to 1,011,000, representing a year-over-year increase -of 75%, and also by an increase in their usage of our cloud computing services including more complex -offerings, such as our database services and content delivery network, as reflected in the increase of average -revenue per paying customer to RMB2,405 (US$355) in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 from RMB2,154 in -the same quarter of 2016. -Digital media and entertainment -Revenue from our digital media and entertainment business in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was -RMB4,081 million (US$602 million), an increase of 30% compared to RMB3,135 million in the same -quarter of 2016. The increase was primarily due to an increase in revenue from mobile value-added services -provided by UCWeb, such as news feeds and mobile search. Youku Tudou is a core part of our digital -entertainment strategy, and we will continue to invest in digital entertainment content on Youku Tudou to -drive user and paying subscription growth. We will continue to leverage the cross selling opportunities -between our digital media and entertainment business and core commerce businesses presented by the vast -consumer base of our ecosystem. -Innovation initiatives and others -Revenue from innovation initiatives and others in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB645 million -(US$95 million), an increase of 21% compared to RMB535 million in the same quarter of 2016, primarily -due to an increase in revenue from AutoNavi. Starting this quarter, we reclassified revenue from our fresh -food stores Hema, previously reported under this segment, as revenue from China commerce retail because -Hema has moved beyond the incubation stage. -11 - -Costs and Expenses -The following tables set forth a breakdown of our costs and expenses, share-based compensation expense -and costs and expenses excluding share-based compensation expense by function for the periods indicated. -| | | | | | Three months ended June 30, | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -% of -| | | | | 2016 | | | | | 2017 | | | Revenue | | -| -------------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---------------------------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | | | % of | | | | | | % of | | YoY | -| | | RMB | | Revenue | | RMB | | | US$ | Revenue | | change | | -| | | | | | | (in millions, except percentages) | | | | | | | | -| Costs and expenses: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Cost of revenue | | | 11,744 | | 37% | | 17,460 | | 2,576 | | 35% | | (2)% | -Product development expenses 3,988 12% 4,696 693 9% (3)% -Sales and marketing expenses 3,614 11% 4,850 715 10% (1)% -General and administrative expenses 2,743 9% 3,679 543 7% (2)% -Amortization of intangible assets 1,251 4% 1,986 293 4% 0% -Total costs and expenses 23,340 73% 32,671 4,820 65% (8)% -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | |   | |   | |   | |   | |   | | | | -Share-based compensation expense by -| function: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -| Cost of revenue | | | 894 | | 3% | | 1,128 | | 166 | | 2% | | (1)% | -Product development expenses 1,276 4% 1,332 197 3% (1)% -| Sales and marketing expenses | | | 447 | | 1% | | 396 | | 58 | | 1% | | 0% | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -General and administrative expenses 1,077 3% 1,163 172 2% (1)% -Total share-based compensation expense 3,694 11% 4,019 593 8% (3)% -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Costs and expenses excluding share-based | |   | |   | |   | |   | |   | | | | -compensation expense: -| Cost of revenue | | | 10,850 | | 34% | | 16,332 | | 2,410 | | 33% | | (1)% | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | --- | ----- | -Product development expenses 2,712 8% 3,364 496 6% (2)% -Sales and marketing expenses 3,167 10% 4,454 657 9% (1)% -General and administrative expenses 1,666 6% 2,516 371 5% (1)% -Amortization of intangible assets 1,251 4% 1,986 293 4% 0% -Total costs and expenses excluding share- -based compensation expense 19,646 62% 28,652 4,227 57% (5)% - -Cost of revenue – Cost of revenue in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB17,460 million (US$2,576 -million), or 35% of revenue, compared to RMB11,744 million, or 37% of revenue, in the same quarter of -2016. Without the effect of share-based compensation expense, cost of revenue as a percentage of revenue -would have decreased from 34% in the quarter ended June 30, 2016 to 33% in the quarter ended June 30, -2017. The decrease was primarily due to increased operating leverage, partly offset by an increase in costs of -inventory of Lazada, content acquisition costs of Youku Tudou and logistics costs paid to Cainiao Network -relating to fulfillment services provided to Tmall Supermarket. -Product development expenses – Product development expenses in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 were -RMB4,696 million (US$693 million), or 9% of revenue, compared to RMB3,988 million, or 12% of revenue, -in the same quarter of 2016. Without the effect of share-based compensation expense, product development -expenses as a percentage of revenue would have decreased from 8% in the quarter ended June 30, 2016 to -6% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, reflecting operating leverage. -12 - -|   | | | | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Sales and marketing expenses – Sales and marketing expenses in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 were -RMB4,850 million (US$715 million), or 10% of revenue, compared to RMB3,614 million, or 11% of -revenue, in the same quarter of 2016. Without the effect of share-based compensation expense, sales and -marketing expenses as a percentage of revenue would have decreased from 10% in the quarter ended June -30, 2016 to 9% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, reflecting operating leverage. -General and administrative expenses – General and administrative expenses in the quarter ended June 30, -2017 were RMB3,679 million (US$543 million), or 7% of revenue, compared to RMB2,743 million, or 9% -of revenue, in the same quarter of 2016. Without the effect of share-based compensation expense, general -and administrative expenses as a percentage of revenue would have decreased from 6% in the quarter ended -June 30, 2016 to 5% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, reflecting operating leverage. -Share-based compensation expense –Total share-based compensation expense included in the cost and -expense items above in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB4,019 million (US$593 million), an -increase of 9% compared to RMB3,694 million in the same quarter of 2016. Share-based compensation -expense as a percentage of revenue decreased to 8% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 from 11% in the -same quarter of 2016. The following table sets forth our analysis of share-based compensation expense for -the quarters indicated by type of share-based awards: - -| | | | | Three months ended | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | June 30, 2016 | | March 31, 2017 | | | June 30, 2017 | | % Change | | - -| | | | % of | | % of | | | % of | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ---- | -------- | ---- | ---- | -------- | ---- | ---- | -| | | RMB | Revenue | RMB | Revenue | RMB | US$ | Revenue | YoY | QoQ | - -(in millions, except percentages) -| By type of awards: | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Alibaba Group share- -based awards granted -| to: | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -- Our employees 2,457 7% 3,180 8% 3,023 446 6% 23% (5)% -- Ant Financial -employees and -other consultants(1) -| | | 234 | 1% | 579 | 2% | | 452 | 67 1% | 93% | (22)% | -| --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ------ | -Ant Financial share- -based awards granted -to our employees(1) 873 3% 339 1% 297 44 1% (66)% (12)% -| Others | | 130 | 0% | 208 | 0% | | 247 | 36 0% | 90% | 19% | -| ------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ---- | -Total share-based -compensation -| | | 3,694 | 11% | 4,306 | 11% | 4,019 | | 593 8% | | | -| -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | -| expense | | | | | | | | | 9% | (7)% | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -(1) Awards subject to mark-to-market accounting treatment. - -Share-based compensation expense related to Alibaba Group share-based awards granted to our employees -and consultants decreased in this quarter compared to the previous quarter. This decrease primarily reflected -annual performance-based equity awards that became vested and ceased to incur share-based compensation -expense during this quarter. -We expect that our share-based compensation expense will continue to be affected by changes in the fair value -of our shares and Ant Financial shares, as well as the quantity of awards we grant to our employees and -consultants in the future. Due to the accounting treatment of Ant Financial share-based awards granted to our -13 - -|   | | | | | | | | |   | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -employees, if the fair value of Ant Financial equity continues to increase in the future, our share-based -compensation expense will likely increase, although any such increase will be non-cash and will not result in -any economic cost or equity dilution to our shareholders. -Amortization of intangible assets – Amortization of intangible assets in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 -was RMB1,986 million (US$293 million), an increase of 59% from RMB1,251 million in the same quarter -of 2016. The increase was due to an increase in intangible assets recognized relating to our strategic -acquisitions and investments. -Income from operations and operating margin -Income from operations in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB17,513 million (US$2,583 million), or -35% of revenue, an increase of 99% compared to RMB8,814 million, or 27% of revenue, in the same quarter -of 2016. -Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA margin -Adjusted EBITDA increased by 68% to RMB25,124 million (US$3,706 million) in the quarter ended June -30, 2017, compared to RMB14,963 million in the same quarter of 2016. Adjusted EBITDA margin increased -to 50% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 from 47% in the same quarter of 2016, mainly due to increased -operating leverage. A reconciliation of net income to adjusted EBITDA is included at the end of this results -announcement. -As many of our newly developed and acquired businesses have different cost structures and lower margins, -we expect that our margin will continue to be negatively impacted by these new businesses. -Adjusted EBITA and adjusted EBITA margin by segments -Adjusted EBITA and adjusted EBITA margin by segments are set forth in the table below. See the section -entitled “Information about Segments” above for a reconciliation of income from operations to adjusted -EBITA. -Three months ended June 30, -2016 2017 -% of % of -RMB Revenue RMB US$ Revenue -(in millions, except percentages) -Core commerce 16,624 61% 26,970 3,978 63% -Cloud computing (158) (13)% (103) (15) (4)% -Digital media and entertainment (996) (32)% (1,748) (258) (43)% -Innovation initiatives and others (887) (166)% (634) (93) (98)% -Core commerce segment – Adjusted EBITA increased by 62% to RMB26,970 million (US$3,978 million) -in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, compared to RMB16,624 million in the same quarter of 2016. Adjusted -EBITA margin improved to 63% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, as compared to 61% in the same quarter -of 2016, reflecting operating leverage achieved, primarily offset by the consolidation of Intime and an -increase in costs of inventory of Lazada. -14 - -Cloud computing segment – Adjusted EBITA in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was a loss of RMB103 -million (US$15 million), compared to a loss of RMB158 million in the same quarter of 2016. Adjusted -EBITA margin improved to negative 4% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 from negative 13% in the -quarter ended June 30, 2016, primarily due to robust growth in revenue and economies of scale. -Digital media and entertainment segment – Adjusted EBITA in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was a loss -of RMB1,748 million (US$258 million), compared to a loss of RMB996 million in the same quarter of 2016. -Adjusted EBITA margin decreased to negative 43% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 from negative 32% in -the quarter ended June 30, 2016, primarily due to an increase in content acquisition costs of Youku Tudou. -Innovation initiatives and others segment – Adjusted EBITA in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was a loss -of RMB634 million (US$93 million), compared to a loss of RMB887 million in the same quarter of 2016. -Adjusted EBITA margin improved to negative 98% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, compared to -negative 166% in the quarter ended June 30, 2016, primarily due to increase in revenue from new business -initiatives. -Interest and investment income, net -Interest and investment income, net in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB1,472 million (US$217 -million), a significant increase from RMB750 million in the same quarter of 2016, primarily due to a non- -recurring gain of RMB1,861 million arising from revaluation of our previously held equity interest in Intime, -when we obtained control over Intime in May 2017. The revaluation gain was partly offset by impairment -loss on certain investments of RMB952 million. -Other income, net -Other income, net in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB1,887 million (US$279 million), compared to -RMB1,763 million in the same quarter of 2016. The increase was primarily due to an increase in royalty fees -and software technology service fees received from Ant Financial under our profit sharing arrangement, -which amounted to RMB1,966 million (US$290 million) in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, offset by an -increase in exchange loss. -Income tax expenses -Income tax expenses in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 were RMB4,653 million (US$686 million), an -increase of 123% compared to RMB2,091 million in the same quarter of 2016. Our effective tax rate was -23% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, compared to 20% in the same quarter of 2016. Excluding share- -based compensation expense, impairment of investments and other unrealized investment gain/loss, our -effective tax rate would have been 20% in the quarter ended June 30, 2017, compared to 15% in the same -quarter of 2016. In connection with our investment in Suning, from the quarter ended March 31, 2016 to the -quarter ended December 31, 2016, we reserved a portion of our earnings for permanent reinvestment in -China, and therefore we were not required to accrue withholding tax for that portion of earnings during that -period. This quarter, we accrued the 5% withholding tax on all the earnings distributable by our PRC -operations, which lead to an increase in our effective tax rate. -Share of results of equity investees -Share of results of equity investees in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was a loss of RMB1,388 million -(US$205 million), compared to a loss of RMB1,468 million in the same quarter of 2016 and a loss of -RMB1,444 million in the quarter ended March 31, 2017. We record our share of results of equity investees -15 - -one quarter in arrears. Share of results of equity investees in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 and the -comparative periods consisted of the following: -| | | | | | Three months ended | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | --------------- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | ------ | ---- | -| | | June 30, 2016 | | March 31, 2017 | | | | June 30, 2017  | | | -| | | | RMB | | RMB | | RMB | | US$ | | -| | | | | | (in millions) | | | | | | -| Share of loss of equity investees: | | | | | | | | | | | -| - Koubei | | | (245) | | (505) | | | (391) | (58) | | -| - Cainiao Network | | | (227) | | (375) | | | (245) | (36) | | -| - Other equity investees | | | (264) | | (41) | | | (311) | (46) | | -| Impairment loss | | | (4) | | — | | | — | | — | -| Dilution losses | | | (239) | | (61) | | | (29) | | (4) | -| Others(1) | | | (489) | | (462) | | | (412) | (61) | | -| Total | | | (1,468) | | (1,444) | | | (1,388) | (205) | | - -(1) Others mainly include amortization of intangible assets of equity investees and share-based compensation expense. - -The share of results of equity investees in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was a loss of RMB1,388 million -(US$205 million), compared to a loss of RMB1,444 million in the quarter ended March 31, 2017, primarily -due to a decrease in our share of losses of Koubei and Cainiao Network, partially offset by an increase in our -share of losses from other equity investees. -Net income and Non-GAAP net income -Our net income in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB14,031 million (US$2,070 million), an increase -of 96% compared to RMB7,142 million in the same quarter of 2016. Excluding share-based compensation -expense, non-cash revaluation gain and certain other items, non-GAAP net income in the quarter ended June -30, 2017 was RMB20,019 million (US$2,953 million), an increase of 67% compared to RMB11,991 million -in the same quarter of 2016. A reconciliation of net income to non-GAAP net income is included at the end -of this results announcement. -Net income attributable to ordinary shareholders -Net income attributable to ordinary shareholders in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB14,683 million -(US$2,166 million), an increase of 94% compared to RMB7,550 million in the same quarter of 2016. -Diluted EPS and non-GAAP diluted EPS -Diluted EPS in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB5.65 (US$0.83) on a weighted average of 2,599 -million diluted shares outstanding during the quarter, an increase of 92% compared to RMB2.94 on a -weighted average of 2,568 million diluted shares outstanding during the same quarter of 2016. Excluding -share-based compensation expense, non-cash revaluation gain and certain other items, non-GAAP diluted -EPS in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB7.95 (US$1.17), an increase of 65% compared to RMB4.83 -in the same quarter of 2016. A reconciliation of diluted EPS to non-GAAP diluted EPS is included at the end -of this results announcement. -16 - -|   | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Cash, cash equivalents and short-term investments -As of June 30, 2017, cash, cash equivalents and short-term investments were RMB148,152 million -(US$21,854 million), compared to RMB146,747 million as of March 31, 2017. The increase in cash, cash -equivalents and short-term investments during the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was primarily due to free -cash flow generated from operations of RMB22,149 million (US$3,267 million), primarily offset by cash -used in investing activities, including the privatization of Intime and investments in Ele.me and Lianhua -Supermarket, and cash used to acquire additional shares of Lazada. -Cash flow from operating activities and free cash flow -Net cash provided by operating activities in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB25,311 million -(US$3,733 million), an increase of 69% compared to RMB14,958 million in the same quarter of 2016. Free -cash flow, a non-GAAP measurement of liquidity, in the quarter ended June 30, 2017 was RMB22,149 -million (US$3,267 million), compared to RMB12,745 million in the same quarter of 2016. A reconciliation -of net cash provided by operating activities to free cash flow is included at the end of this results -announcement. -Net cash used in investing activities -During the quarter ended June 30, 2017, net cash used in investing activities of RMB13,912 million -(US$2,052 million) primarily reflected cash outflow of RMB14,133 million (US$2,085 million) for -investment and acquisition activities, including the privatization of Intime and investments in Ele.me and -Lianhua Supermarket, as well as capital expenditures and intangible assets of RMB3,589 million (US$529 -million), which included cash outflow for acquisition of land use rights and construction in progress of -RMB427 million (US$63 million), partially offset by cash inflow of RMB3,758 million (US$554 million) -from disposals of various investments and liquidation of certain short-term investments. -Employees -As of June 30, 2017, we had a total of 57,302 employees, compared to 50,097 as of March 31, 2017. The -number of employees as of June 30, 2017 increased by 7,205 from March 31, 2017, primarily due to the -addition of approximately 7,600 employees from the consolidation of Intime. -17 - -WEBCAST AND CONFERENCE CALL INFORMATION -Alibaba Group’s management will hold a conference call to discuss the financial results at 7:30 a.m. U.S. -Eastern Time (7:30 p.m. Hong Kong Time) on August 17, 2017. -Details of the conference call are as follows: -International: +65 6713 5090 -U.S.: +1 845 675 0437 -U.K.: +44 203 621 4779 -Hong Kong: +852 3018 6771 -Conference ID: 61383477 -A live webcast of the earnings conference call can be accessed at -http://www.alibabagroup.com/en/ir/earnings. An archived webcast will be available through the same link -following the call. A replay of the conference call will be available for one week (dial-in number: +61 2 8199 -0299; conference ID: 61383477). -Our results announcement and accompanying slides are available at Alibaba Group’s Investor Relations -website at http://www.alibabagroup.com/en/ir/home on August 17, 2017. -ABOUT ALIBABA GROUP -Alibaba Group’s mission is to make it easy to do business anywhere. The company aims to build the future -infrastructure of commerce. It envisions that its customers will meet, work and live at Alibaba, and that it -will be a company that lasts at least 102 years. -CONTACTS -Investor Relations Contact -Rob Lin -investor@alibabagroup.com -Media Contact -Robert Christie -bob.christie@alibaba-inc.com -SAFE HARBOR STATEMENTS -This announcement contains forward-looking statements. These statements are made under the “safe harbor” -provisions of the U.S. Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements -can be identified by terminology such as “will,” “expects,” “anticipates,” “future,” “intends,” “plans,” -“believes,” “estimates,” “potential,” “continue,” “ongoing,” “targets,” “guidance” and similar statements. -Among other things, statements that are not historical facts, including statements about Alibaba’s strategies -and business plans, Alibaba’s beliefs and expectations regarding the growth of its business and its revenue, -the business outlook and quotations from management in this announcement, as well as Alibaba’s strategic -and operational plans, are or contain forward-looking statements. Alibaba may also make forward-looking -statements in its periodic reports to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”), in press -releases and other written materials and in oral statements made by its officers, directors or employees to -third parties. Forward-looking statements involve inherent risks and uncertainties. A number of factors -could cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in any forward-looking statement, -18 - -including but not limited to the following: Alibaba’s goals and strategies; Alibaba’s future business -development; Alibaba’s ability to maintain the trusted status of its ecosystem, reputation and brand; risks -associated with increased investments in Alibaba’s business and new business initiatives; risks associated -with strategic acquisitions and investments; Alibaba’s ability to retain or increase engagement of consumers, -merchants and other participants in its ecosystem and enable new offerings; Alibaba’s ability to maintain or -grow its revenue or business; risks associated with limitation or restriction of services provided by Alipay; -changes in laws, regulations and regulatory environment that affect Alibaba’s business operations; privacy -and regulatory concerns; competition; security breaches; the continued growth of the e-commerce market in -China and globally; risks associated with the performance of our business partners, including but not limited -to Ant Financial; and fluctuations in general economic and business conditions in China and globally and -assumptions underlying or related to any of the foregoing. Further information regarding these and other -risks is included in Alibaba’s filings with the SEC. All information provided in this results announcement is -as of the date of this results announcement and are based on assumptions that we believe to be reasonable as -of this date, and Alibaba does not undertake any obligation to update any forward-looking statement, except -as required under applicable law. -NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES -To supplement our consolidated financial statements, which are prepared and presented in accordance with -GAAP, we use the following non-GAAP financial measures: for our consolidated results, adjusted EBITDA -(including adjusted EBITDA margin), adjusted EBITA (including adjusted EBITA margin), non-GAAP net -income, non-GAAP diluted EPS and free cash flow. For more information on these non-GAAP financial -measures, please refer to the section entitled “Information about Segments” and the table captioned -“Reconciliations of Non-GAAP Measures to the Nearest Comparable GAAP Measures” in this results -announcement. -We believe that adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EBITA, non-GAAP net income and non-GAAP diluted EPS -help identify underlying trends in our business that could otherwise be distorted by the effect of certain -income or expenses that we include in income from operations, net income and diluted EPS. We believe that -adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EBITA, non-GAAP net income and non-GAAP diluted EPS provide useful -information about our core operating results, enhance the overall understanding of our past performance and -future prospects and allow for greater visibility with respect to key metrics used by our management in our -financial and operational decision-making. We consider free cash flow to be a liquidity measure that -provides useful information to management and investors about the amount of cash generated by our -business that can be used for strategic corporate transactions, including investing in our new business -initiatives, making strategic investments and acquisitions and strengthening our balance sheet. Adjusted -EBITDA, adjusted EBITA, non-GAAP net income, non-GAAP diluted EPS and free cash flow should not be -considered in isolation or construed as an alternative to income from operations, net income, diluted EPS, -cash flows or any other measure of performance or as an indicator of our operating performance. These non- -GAAP financial measures presented here may not be comparable to similarly titled measures presented by -other companies. Other companies may calculate similarly titled measures differently, limiting their -usefulness as comparative measures to our data. -Adjusted EBITDA represents net income before (i) interest and investment income, net, other income, net, -interest expense, income tax expenses and share of results of equity investees, and (ii) certain non-cash -expenses, consisting of share-based compensation expense, amortization and depreciation, which we do not -believe are reflective of our core operating performance during the periods presented. -19 - -Adjusted EBITA represents net income before (i) interest and investment income, net, other income, net, -interest expense, income tax expenses and share of results of equity investees, and (ii) certain non-cash -expenses, consisting of share-based compensation expense and amortization, which we do not believe are -reflective of our core operating performance during the periods presented. -Non-GAAP net income represents net income before share-based compensation expense, amortization, -impairment of goodwill and investments, gain on deemed disposals/disposals/revaluation of investments, -amortization of excess value receivable arising from the restructuring of commercial arrangements with Ant -Financial, immediate recognition of unamortized professional fees and upfront fees upon termination of bank -borrowings and others, as adjusted for the tax effects on non-GAAP adjustments. -Non-GAAP diluted EPS represents non-GAAP net income attributable to ordinary shareholders divided by -the weighted average number of shares outstanding during the periods on a diluted basis, including -accounting for the effects of the assumed conversion of convertible preference shares. -Free cash flow represents net cash provided by operating activities as presented in our consolidated cash -flow statement less purchases of property and equipment and intangible assets (excluding acquisition of land -use rights and construction in progress) and others. -The section entitled “Information about Segments” and the table captioned “Reconciliations of Non-GAAP -Measures to the Nearest Comparable GAAP Measures” in this results announcement have more details on -the non-GAAP financial measures that are most directly comparable to GAAP financial measures and the -related reconciliations between these financial measures. -20 - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENTS - -| | | | | | | Three months ended June 30, | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -| | |   | |   | | 2016  | | | 2017  | | | -| | |   |   | |   | RMB  | | RMB  | | US$  | | -| | | | | | | (in millions, except per share data) | | | | | | -| Revenue | | | | | | 32,154 | | 50,184 | | 7,403 | | -| Cost of revenue | | | | | | (11,744) | | (17,460) | | (2,576) | | -| Product development expenses | | | | | | (3,988) | | (4,696) | | (693) | | -| Sales and marketing expenses | | | | | | (3,614) | | (4,850) | | (715) | | -General and administrative expenses (2,743) (3,679) (543) -Amortization of intangible assets (1,251) (1,986) (293) -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -| Income from operations | | | | | | 8,814 | | 17,513 | | 2,583 | | -| Interest and investment income, net | | | | | | | 750 | 1,472 | | | 217 | -| Interest expense | | | | | | (626) | | | (800) | (118) | | -| Other income, net | | | | | | 1,763 | | 1,887 | | | 279 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Income before income tax and share -| of results of equity investees | | | | | | 10,701 | | 20,072 | | 2,961 | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| Income tax expenses | | | | | | (2,091) | | (4,653) | | (686) | | -Share of results of equity investees (1,468) (1,388) (205) -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Net income | | | | | | 7,142 | | 14,031 | | 2,070 | | -Net loss attributable to -| | | | | | | | 408 | | 652 | | 96 | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -| noncontrolling interests | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -Net income attributable to -| | | | | | | 7,550 | | 14,683 | | 2,166 | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| ordinary shareholders | | | | | | | | | | | | - -| |   |   | |   | |   | |   | |   | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Earnings per share attributable to -| ordinary shareholders | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| Basic | | | | | | 3.05 | | | 5.77 | 0.85 | | -| Diluted | | | | | | 2.94 | | 5.65 | | 0.83 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -Weighted average number of share -used in calculating net income -| per ordinary share | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| Basic | | | | | | 2,473 | | 2,543 | | | | -| Diluted | | | | | | 2,568 | | 2,599 | | | | -21 - -|   | | | | | | | |   | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -REVENUE - -The following table sets forth our revenue by segments for the periods indicated: - -| | |   | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| |   | |   | | 2016  | | 2017  | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ------ | ---- | -| |   |   | |   | RMB   | | RMB   | US$   | | -| | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | -| Core commerce(1) | | | | | 27,241 | | 43,027 | 6,347 | | -| Cloud computing(2) | | | | | 1,243 | | 2,431 | | 359 | -| Digital media and entertainment(3) | | | | | 3,135 | | 4,081 | | 602 | -Innovation initiatives and others(4) -| | | | | | 535 | | 645 | | 95 | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| Total | | | | | 32,154 | | 50,184 | 7,403 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -(1) Revenue from core commerce is primarily generated from our China retail marketplaces, 1688.com, AliExpress, Alibaba.com -and Lazada.com. -(2) Revenue from cloud computing is primarily generated from the provision of services, such as data storage, elastic computing, -database and large scale computing services, as well as web hosting and domain name registration. -(3) Revenue from digital media and entertainment mainly represents advertising and subscription revenue generated from our -digital entertainment business provided by Youku Tudou and mobile Internet services revenue from UCWeb businesses. -(4) Revenue from innovation initiatives and others mainly represents revenue generated by AutoNavi and YunOS, as well as fees -from Ant Financial related to the SME loan business. -22 - -|   | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -INFORMATION ABOUT SEGMENTS - -The following table sets forth our income (loss) from operations by segments for the periods indicated: - -| | | | | |   | | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | |   | | |   | | | 2016   | | | 2017   | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | -| | | |   | |   | |   | | RMB   | | RMB   | | US$   | | -| | | | | | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | | -| Core commerce | | | | | | | | | 14,682 | | 24,808 | | 3,659 | | -| Cloud computing | | | | | | | | | (439) | | (532) | | | (78) | -Digital media and entertainment (1,853) (3,388) (500) -Innovation initiatives and others (1,572) (1,612) (238) -| Unallocated | | | | | | | | | (2,004) | | (1,763) | | (260) | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Total | | | | | | | | | 8,814 | | 17,513 | | 2,583 | | -|    | |   | |   | |   | |    | |   | | |   | | -The following table sets forth our adjusted EBITA by segments for the periods indicated: - -| | | | | |   | | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | -| | | |   | | |   | | | 2016   | | | 2017   | | | -| | | |   | |   | |   | | RMB   | | RMB   | | US$   | | -| | | | | | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | | -| Core commerce | | | | | | | | | 16,624 | | 26,970 | | 3,978 | | -| Cloud computing | | | | | | | | | (158) | | (103) | | | (15) | -Digital media and entertainment (996) (1,748) (258) -| Innovation initiatives and others | | | | | | | | | (887) | | (634) | | | (93) | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -| Unallocated | | | | | | | | | (824) | | (967) | | | (143) | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Total | | | | | | | | | 13,759 | | 23,518 | | 3,469 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -|    | |   | |   | |   | |    | |   | | |   | | - -23 - -|   | | | | | | | | | | |   | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS - -| | | As of March 31,  | | | | As of June 30,  | | | | -| ---------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------- | -------- | -------------- | ---- | --------------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | 2017  | | | | 2017  | | | -| | | | RMB  | | RMB  | | | US$   | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | (in millions) | | | | | | -| Assets | | | | | | | | | | -| Current assets: | | | | | | | | | | -| | Cash and cash equivalents | | 143,736 | | | 145,144 | | 21,410 | | -| | Short-term investments | | 3,011 | | | 3,008 | | | 444 | -Restricted cash and escrow receivables 2,655 3,211 474 -| | Investment securities | | 4,054 | | | 4,462 | | | 658 | -| --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | -Prepayments, receivables and other assets(1) 28,408 30,569 4,509 - -| Total current assets | | | 181,864 | | | 186,394 | | 27,495 | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | - -| Investment securities | | | 31,452 | | | 30,888 | | 4,556 | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -Prepayments, receivables and other assets(1) -| | | | 8,703 | | | 11,127 | | 1,641 | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | ---- | -| Investment in equity investees | | | 120,368 | | | 118,971 | | 17,549 | | -| Property and equipment, net | | | 20,206 | | | 43,922 | | 6,479 | | -| Land use rights, net | | | 4,691 | | | 6,629 | | | 978 | -| Intangible assets, net | | | 14,108 | | | 16,244 | | 2,396 | | -| Goodwill | | | 125,420 | | | 129,539 | | 19,108 | | -| Total assets | | | 506,812 | | | 543,714 | | 80,202 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -Liabilities, Mezzanine Equity and -| Shareholders’ Equity | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -| Current liabilities: | | | | | | | | | | -| | Current bank borrowings | | 5,948 | | | 7,660 | | 1,130 | | -| | Current portion of unsecured notes | | 8,949 | | | 8,795 | | 1,297 | | -| | Income tax payable | | 6,125 | | | 10,229 | | 1,509 | | -| | Escrow money payable | | 2,322 | | | 2,541 | | | 375 | -Accrued expenses, accounts payable and -| | other liabilities(1) | | 46,979 | | | 51,988 | | 7,668 | | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| | Merchant deposits | | 8,189 | | | 8,481 | | 1,251 | | -Deferred revenue and customer advances 15,052 17,312 2,554 - -| Total current liabilities | | | 93,564 | | | 107,006 | | 15,784 | | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | - -(1) Certain reclassifications in prepayments, receivables and other assets, accrued expenses, accounts payable and other -liabilities and deferred tax liabilities as of March 31, 2017 were retrospectively adjusted as a result of the adoption of a new -accounting standard effective in the first quarter of fiscal 2018. - -24 - -|   | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (CONTINUED) - -| | As of March 31, | | | | As of June 30, | | | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| |   | | | | | | | | -2017 -| | | 2017 | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | -| | | RMB | | RMB   | | | US$   | | -| | | | (in millions) | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | -| Deferred revenue | | | 641 | | | 812 | | 120 | -| Deferred tax liabilities(1) | | 10,361 | | | 12,968 | | | 1,913 | -| Non-current bank borrowings | | 30,959 | | | 31,783 | | | 4,688 | -| Unsecured senior notes | | 45,876 | | | 45,080 | | | 6,650 | -| Other liabilities | | 1,290 | | | 1,660 | | | 245 | - -| Total liabilities | | 182,691 | | | 199,309 | | | 29,400 | -| ------------------ | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | | -Commitments and contingencies -| | | | — | | | — | | — | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Mezzanine equity | | | 2,992 | | | 763 | | 112 | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | - -Alibaba Group Holding Limited shareholders’ -| equity: | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | -| Ordinary shares | | | 1 | | | 1 | | — | -| Additional paid-in capital | | 164,585 | | | 170,707 | | | 25,181 | -| Treasury shares at cost | | (2,823) | | | (2,823) | | | (416) | -| Restructuring reserve | | | (624) | | (559) | | | (82) | -| Subscription receivables | | | (63) | | (160) | | | (24) | -| Statutory reserves | | | 4,080 | | 4,051 | | | 598 | -| Accumulated other comprehensive income | | | 5,085 | | 4,132 | | | 609 | -| Retained earnings | | 108,558 | | | 123,271 | | | 18,183 | -| | | | | | | | | | -Total Alibaba Group Holding Limited -| shareholders’ equity | | 278,799 | | | 298,620 | | | 44,049 | -| ------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | -| Noncontrolling interests | | 42,330 | | | 45,022 | | | 6,641 | -| | | | | | | | | | -| Total equity | | 321,129 | | | 343,642 | | | 50,690 | -| | | | | | | | | | -Total liabilities, mezzanine equity and equity 506,812 543,714 80,202 - -| | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -(1) Certain reclassifications in prepayments, receivables and other assets, accrued expenses, accounts payable and other -liabilities and deferred tax liabilities as of March 31, 2017 were retrospectively adjusted as a result of the adoption of a new -accounting standard effective in the first quarter of fiscal 2018. -25 - -|   | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -UNAUDITED CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS - -| | |   | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | ----- | ------ | --- | -| |   | |   | | 2016    | | 2017  | | | -| |   |   | |   | RMB   | RMB   | | US$   | | -| | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| Net cash provided by operating | | | | | | | | | | -| activities | | | | | 14,958 | 25,311 | | 3,733 | | -Net cash used in investing activities (61,468) (13,912) (2,052) -| Net cash provided by (used in) | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | -| financing activities | | | | | 21,312 | (8,894) | | (1,312) | | -| Effect of exchange rate changes on | | | | | | | | | | -| cash and cash equivalents | | | | | 626 | (1,097) | | (161) | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| (Decrease) Increase in cash and cash | | | | | | | | | | -| equivalents | | | | | (24,572) | 1,408 | | | 208 | -| Cash and cash equivalents at | | | | | | | | | | -| beginning of period | | | | | 106,818 | 143,736 | | 21,202 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| Cash and cash equivalents at end of | | | | | | | | | | -| period | | | | | 82,246 | 145,144 | | 21,410 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | -26 - -|   | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -RECONCILIATIONS OF NON-GAAP MEASURES TO THE NEAREST COMPARABLE GAAP -MEASURES - -The table below sets forth a reconciliation of our net income to adjusted EBITA and adjusted EBITDA -for the periods indicated: -| | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | |   | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | ------- | ------ | -| | |   | |   | | 2016    | | 2017   | | -| | |   |   |   | | RMB  | | RMB  | US$  | -| | | | | | | | (in millions) | | | -| Net income | | | | | | 7,142 | | 14,031 | 2,070 | -Less: Interest and investment income, -| net | | | | | | (750) | | (1,472) | (217) | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -| Add: Interest expense | | | | | | 626 | | 800 | 118 | -| Less: Other income, net | | | | | | (1,763) | | (1,887) | (279) | -| Add: Income tax expenses | | | | | | 2,091 | | 4,653 | 686 | -Add: Share of results of equity -| investees | | | | | | 1,468 | | 1,388 | 205 | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------ | -| Income from operations | | | | | | 8,814 | | 17,513 | 2,583 | -Add: Share-based compensation -| expense | | | | | | 3,694 | | 4,019 | 593 | -| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | ---- | -Add: Amortization of intangible -| assets | | | | | | 1,251 | | 1,986 | 293 | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -| Adjusted EBITA | | | | | | 13,759 | | 23,518 | 3,469 | -Add: Depreciation and amortization -of property and equipment and -| | | | | | | 1,204 | | 1,606 | 237 | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -| land use rights | | | | | | | | | | -| Adjusted EBITDA | | | | | | 14,963 | | 25,124 | 3,706 | - -27 - -|   | | | | | | | |   | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -RECONCILIATIONS OF NON-GAAP MEASURES TO THE NEAREST COMPARABLE GAAP -MEASURES (CONTINUED) - -The table below sets forth a reconciliation of our net income to non-GAAP net income for the periods -indicated: -| |   |   | |   | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | -| | | |   | | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | -| | |   | |   | | | 2016    | | | 2017   | | -| | |   |   | |   | | RMB  | | RMB  | | US$  | -| | | | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| Net income | | | | | | | 7,142 | | 14,031 | | 2,070 | -Add: Share-based compensation -expense -| | | | | | | | 3,694 | | 4,019 | | 593 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -Add: Amortization of intangible -| assets | | | | | | | 1,251 | | 1,986 | | 293 | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -Add: Impairment of goodwill and -| investments | | | | | | | 77 | | 952 | | 140 | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | -Less: Gain on deemed -disposals/disposals/revaluation of -| investments and others | | | | | | | (55) | | (1,089) | | (161) | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -Add: Amortization of excess value -receivable arising from the -restructuring of commercial -| arrangements with Ant Financial | | | | | | | 66 | | 67 | | 10 | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Add: Immediate recognition of -unamortized professional fees and -upfront fees upon termination of -| bank borrowings | | | | | | | — | | 92 | | 14 | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Adjusted for tax effects on non- -| GAAP adjustments(1) |   |   | |   | | | (184) | | (39) | | (6) | -| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | -| |   |   | |   | |   | |   | |   | | -| Non-GAAP net income | | | | | | | 11,991 | | 20,019 | | 2,953 | - -(1) Tax effects on non-GAAP adjustments comprise of tax provisions on the amortization of intangible assets and certain gains on -disposal of investments, as well as tax benefits from share-based awards. Comparative figures were updated to conform to the -current period presentation. -28 - -|   | | | | | | | | | |   | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -RECONCILIATIONS OF NON-GAAP MEASURES TO THE NEAREST COMPARABLE GAAP -MEASURES (CONTINUED) - -The table below sets forth a reconciliation of our diluted EPS to non-GAAP diluted EPS for the periods -indicated: -| | | | |   | | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---- | -| | | |   | |   | | | 2016    | | | 2017   | | -| | | |   |   | |   | | RMB   | | RMB  | | US$  | -| | | | | | | | | (in millions, except per share data) | | | | | -Net income attributable to -ordinary shareholders – -| basic | | | | | | | | 7,550 | | 14,683 | | 2,166 | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | -Dilution effect on earnings -arising from option plans -operated by an equity -| investee | | | | | | | | — | | (3) | | — | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -Net income attributable to -ordinary shareholders – -| diluted | | | | | | | | 7,550 | | 14,680 | | 2,166 | -| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | -Add: Non-GAAP adjustments -| to net income(1) | | | | | | | | 4,849 | | 5,988 | | 883 | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -Non-GAAP net income -attributable to ordinary -shareholders for -computing non-GAAP -| diluted EPS | | | | | | | | 12,399 | | 20,668 | | 3,049 | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -Weighted average number of -| shares on a diluted basis | |   |   | |   | | | 2,568 | | 2,599 | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -| Diluted EPS(2) | |   |   | |   | | | 2.94 | | 5.65 | | 0.83 | -Add: Non-GAAP adjustments -to net income per share(3) -| | |   |   | |   | | | 1.89 | | 2.30 | | 0.34 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | - -| | |   |   | |   | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| Non-GAAP diluted EPS(4) | | | | | | | | 4.83 | | 7.95 | | 1.17 | -| | |   |   | |   | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | |   |   | |   | | | | | | | | -(1) See the table above about the reconciliation of net income to non-GAAP net income for more information of these non- -GAAP adjustments. -(2) Diluted EPS is derived from net income attributable to ordinary shareholders for computing diluted EPS divided by -weighted average number of shares on a diluted basis. -(3) Non-GAAP adjustments to net income per share is derived from non-GAAP adjustments to net income divided by -weighted average number of shares on a diluted basis. -(4) Non-GAAP diluted EPS is derived from non-GAAP net income attributable to ordinary shareholders for computing -non-GAAP diluted EPS divided by weighted average number of shares on a diluted basis. -29 - -|   | | | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -RECONCILIATIONS OF NON-GAAP MEASURES TO THE NEAREST COMPARABLE -GAAP MEASURES (CONTINUED) - -The table below sets forth a reconciliation of net cash provided by operating activities to free cash flow -for the periods indicated: -| | |   |   | |   | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| | | | |   | | | Three months ended June 30,  | | | | | | -| | | |   | |   | | 2016    | | | 2017  | | | -| | | |   |   | |   | RMB  | | RMB  | | US$   | | -| | | | | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | -Net cash provided by -| operating activities | | | | | | | 14,958 | | 25,311 | | 3,733 | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -Less: Purchase of property -and equipment and -intangible assets -(excluding land use rights -and construction in -| progress) | | | | | | | (2,794) | | (3,162) | | (466) | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| Add: Others | | | | | | | | 581 | | — | | — | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | -| Free cash flow | | | | | | | 12,745 | | 22,149 | | 3,267 | | -| | |    |   | | | | | | | | | | -30 - -|   | | | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -SELECTED OPERATING DATA - -Annual active consumers - -The table below sets forth the number of active consumers on our China retail marketplaces for the periods indicated: -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | Twelve months ended   | | | | | | | - Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, -| | 2015 | | 2015 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2017 | | 2017 | -| --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | - -(in millions) -Annual active consumers 386 407 423 434 439 443 454 466 - -Mobile - -The table below sets forth the mobile MAUs on our China retail marketplaces for the periods indicated: - -| | | | | | | The month ended   | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, -| | 2015 | | 2015 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2017 | | 2017 | -| ------------ | ----- | ---- | ----- | ----- | --- | -------------- | ----- | ---- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| | | | | | | (in millions) | | | | | | | -| Mobile MAUs | | 346 | 393 | 410 | | 427 | | 450 | 493 | | 507 | 529 | - -Revenue per active consumer / mobile revenue per mobile MAU - -The table below sets forth information with respect to annual China commerce retail revenue per annual active -consumer and annualized mobile revenue per mobile MAU from China commerce retail for the periods -presented: - - Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, -| | 2015 | | 2015 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2016 | | 2016 | 2017 | | 2017 | -| --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | (in RMB) | | | | | | | -Annual China commerce -retail revenue per annual -active consumer(1) 174 184 189 202 215 241 251 273 -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Mobile revenue per mobile -MAU from China -commerce retail – -| Annualized(2) | | 87 | 108 | | 123 | 140 | | 151 | 166 | | 179 | 196 | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | ---- | -| _____________________ | | | | | | | | | | | | | -(1) China commerce retail revenue per active consumer for each of the above periods is calculated by dividing the China -commerce retail revenue for the previous 12-month period by the annual active consumers for the same 12-month -period. -(2) Mobile revenue per mobile MAU from China commerce retail, annualized is calculated by dividing mobile revenue -from China commerce retail for the previous 12-month period by the mobile MAUs for the last month of the same -period. - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -31 - -|   | | | | | | | | | |   | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LIMITED -SELECTED OPERATING DATA (CONTINUED) - -Cloud computing paying customers - -The table below sets forth the number of paying customers on cloud computing as of the respective dates -indicated: -| | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, Sep 30, Dec 31, Mar 31, Jun 30, -| | 2015 2015 | 2016 2016 | 2016 | 2016 | 2017 2017 | -| --- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | - (in thousands) -| Paying customers | 313 383 | 513 577 | 651 | 765 | 874 1,011 | -| ------------------ | --------- | --------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | - -32 - -|   | | | | |   | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | \ No newline at end of file +English – Disney Terms of Use + +Home / English – Disney Terms of Use + +Last Updated: SEPTEMBER 26, 2019 + +Disney DTC LLC and/or its affiliates and subsidiaries (collectively, “Disney DTC”) are pleased +to provide to you their sites, software, applications, content, products and services (“Disney +Services”), which may be branded Disney, ABC, ESPN, Marvel, Pixar, Lucasfilm, FX or another +brand owned or licensed by Disney DTC. These terms govern your use and our provision of the +Disney Services on which these terms are posted, as well as Disney Services we make available +on third-party sites and platforms if these terms are disclosed to you in connection with your use +of the Disney Services. PLEASE READ THESE TERMS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING +THE DISNEY SERVICES. BY USING THE DISNEY SERVICES YOU AGREE TO BE +BOUND BY THESE TERMS. + +ANY DISPUTE BETWEEN YOU AND US, EXCEPT FOR SMALL CLAIMS, IS SUBJECT +TO A CLASS ACTION WAIVER AND MUST BE RESOLVED BY INDIVIDUAL BINDING +ARBITRATION. PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT IN ITS ENTIRETY, INCLUDING +THE ARBITRATION PROVISION BELOW. + +NOTHING IN THESE TERMS IS INTENDED TO AFFECT YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE +LAW IN YOUR USUAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE THAT CAN NOT BE ALTERED BY +THESE TERMS. IF THERE IS A CONFLICT BETWEEN THOSE RIGHTS AND THESE +TERMS, YOUR RIGHTS UNDER APPLICABLE LOCAL LAW WILL PREVAIL. + +1. Contract between You and Us + + This is a contract (1) between you and Disney DTC LLC, as a Delaware limited liability +company doing business at 500 South Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521, USA, or +(2) between you and any different service provider identified for a particular Disney Service. + +You must read and agree to these terms (the “Agreement”) before using the Disney Services. If +you do not agree, you may not use the Disney Services. These terms describe the limited basis +on which the Disney Services are made available to you and supersede prior agreements or +arrangements. + +Supplemental terms and conditions may apply to some Disney Services, such as rules for a +particular competition, content, software, application, service or other activity, or terms that may +accompany certain territories, content, products or software accessible through the Disney +Services. If applicable, such supplemental terms and conditions will be disclosed to you in +connection with such competition, content, product, software, application, service or +activity. Any supplemental terms and conditions are in addition to these terms and, in the event + + of a conflict, the supplemental terms will prevail over these terms. If you do not agree to the +supplemental terms and conditions disclosed, you must not use the applicable Disney Service. + +We may change these terms at any time. Any such amendment will be effective thirty (30) days +following either our dispatch of a notice to you or our posting of the amended terms. You are +responsible for periodically reviewing the terms for updates and amendments. By continuing to +use the Disney Services you will be deemed to have agreed to and accepted any amendments. If +you do not agree to any change to these terms, you must discontinue using the Disney +Services. Our customer service representatives are not authorized to modify any provision of +these terms, either verbally or in writing. + +We may immediately terminate this contract with respect to you (including your access to the +Disney Services) if you fail to comply with any provision of these terms. + +2. The Disney Services + +The Disney Services are for your personal, noncommercial use and are intended for +informational and entertainment purposes only. They do not constitute legal, financial, +professional, medical or healthcare advice or diagnosis and cannot be used for such +purposes. To support smooth operation of the Disney Services across wide geographic areas, +aspects of certain activities, such as game play, may be simulated to avoid delays. + +The Disney Services are our copyrighted property or the copyrighted property of our licensors or +licensees and all trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress and other intellectual +property rights in the Disney Services are owned by us or our licensors or licensees. Except as +we specifically agree in writing, no element of the Disney Services may be used or exploited in +any way other than as part of the Disney Services offered to you. You may own the physical +media on which elements of the Disney Services are delivered to you, but we retain full and +complete ownership of the Disney Services. We do not transfer title to any portion of the Disney +Services to you. + +Content and Software License + +If a Disney Service is configured to enable the use of software, content, virtual items or other +materials owned or licensed by us, we grant you a limited, non-exclusive, non-sublicensable, +non-transferable license to access and use such software, content, virtual item or other material +for your personal, noncommercial use only, only for as long as each Disney Service is made +available by us, with no right to reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available +to the public, or transform any Disney Service in any media format or channel now known or +hereafter devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney +Service). + +You may not: circumvent or disable any content protection system or digital rights management +technology used with any Disney Service; decompile, reverse engineer, disassemble or otherwise +reduce any Disney Service to a human-readable form; remove identification, copyright or other +proprietary notices; or access or use any Disney Service in an unlawful or unauthorized manner + + or in a manner that suggests an association with our products, services or brands. You may not +access or use any Disney Service in violation of United States export control and economic +sanctions requirements. By acquiring services, content or software through the Disney Services, +you represent and warrant that your access to and use of the services, content or software will +comply with those requirements. + +Disclaimers and Limitation on Liability + +THE DISNEY SERVICES ARE PROVIDED “AS IS” AND “AS AVAILABLE.” WE +DISCLAIM ALL CONDITIONS, REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES NOT +EXPRESSLY SET OUT IN THESE TERMS TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY +APPLICABLE LAW. + +FOR HELP, PLEASE REFER TO THE HELP SECTION OF THE APPLICABLE DISNEY +SERVICE FOR ASSISTANCE IF DIGITAL CONTENT SUPPLIED VIA A DISNEY +SERVICE IS NOT WORKING PROPERLY. We will not be liable for damage which could +have been avoided by following our advice to apply an update offered to you free of charge or +for damage which was caused by you failing to correctly follow installation instructions or to +have in place the minimum system requirements advised by us. + +We shall not be liable for delay or failure in performance for causes beyond our control or any +other damage which does not result from a breach of our obligation. + +We are not liable for business losses. We only supply the products for domestic and private use. +If you use the products for any commercial, business or re-sale purpose we will have no liability +to you for any loss of profit, loss of business, business interruption, or loss of business +opportunity. + +WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LACK OF FUNCTIONALITY OR FAILURE TO +PROVIDE ANY PART OF THE DISNEY SERVICE, OR ANY LOSS OF CONTENT OR +DATA THAT IS DUE TO: YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICES, OPERATING SYSTEM OR +INTERNET CONNECTION, YOUR FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SPECIFIED +COMPATIBILITY REQUIREMENTS OR THE CONSEQUENCES OF YOU CHANGING +YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICE, OPERATING SYSTEM OR INTERNET CONNECTION. + +WE SHALL NOT BE LIABLE TO YOU FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL OR +CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LOST PROFITS AND PROPERTY +DAMAGE, EVEN IF WE WERE ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES, +NOR SHALL WE BE HELD LIABLE FOR DELAY OR FAILURE IN PERFORMANCE +RESULTING FROM CAUSES BEYOND OUR REASONABLE CONTROL. + +IN NO EVENT SHALL OUR TOTAL LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ALL DAMAGES, LOSSES +AND CAUSES OF ACTION EXCEED ONE THOUSAND U.S. DOLLARS (US $1,000). + + Changes to the Disney Services + +The Disney Services are constantly evolving and will change over time. If we make a material +change to the Disney Services, we will provide you with reasonable notice as described above +and you will be entitled to terminate this contract prospectively by no longer using the Disney +Services. + +Additional Restrictions on Use of the Disney Services + +We do not allow uses of the Disney Services that are commercial or business-related, or that +advertise or offer to sell products or services (whether or not for profit), or that solicit others +(including solicitations for contributions or donations). You agree not to knowingly or recklessly +introduce a virus or other harmful component, or otherwise tamper with, impair or damage any +Disney Service or connected network, or interfere with any person or entity’s use or enjoyment +of any Disney Service. You agree not to use any software or device that allows automated +gameplay, expedited gameplay, or other manipulation of gameplay or game client and you agree +not to cheat or otherwise modify a Disney Service or game experience to create an advantage for +one user over another. Additionally, you agree not to access, monitor or copy, or permit another +person or entity to access, monitor or copy, any element of the Disney Services using a robot, +search engine, “spider,” “scraper,” or other automated means or manual process without our +express written permission. + +Third-Party Services and Content + +The Disney Services may integrate, be integrated into, or be provided in connection with third- +party services and content. We do not control those third-party services and content. You +should read the terms of use agreements and privacy policies that apply to such third-party +services and content. + +If you access a Disney Service using an Apple iOS, Android or Microsoft Windows-powered +device or Microsoft Xbox One, Apple Inc., Google, Inc. or Microsoft Corporation, respectively, +shall be a third-party beneficiary to this contract. However, these third-party beneficiaries are +not a party to this contract and are not responsible for the provision or support of the Disney +Services. You agree that your access to the Disney Services using these devices also shall be +subject to the usage terms set forth in the applicable third-party beneficiary’s terms of service. + +Mobile Networks + +When you access the Disney Services through a mobile network, your network or roaming +provider’s messaging, data and other rates and fees will apply. Downloading, installing or using +certain Disney Services may be prohibited or restricted by your network provider and not all +Disney Services may work with your network provider or device. + + Affiliate Advertising Programs + +Disney DTC is a participant in affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for +sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to third party retail sites. + +3. Your Content and Account + + User Generated Content + +The Disney Services may allow you to communicate, submit, upload or otherwise make +available text, chats, images, audio, video, competition entries or other content (“User Generated +Content”), which may be accessible and viewable by the public. Access to these features may be +subject to age restrictions. You may not submit or upload User Generated Content that is +defamatory, harassing, threatening, bigoted, hateful, violent, vulgar, obscene, pornographic, or +otherwise offensive or that harms or can reasonably be expected to harm any person or entity, +whether or not such material is protected by law. + +In most instances, we do not claim ownership to your User Generated Content; however, you +grant us a non-exclusive, sublicensable, irrevocable and royalty-free worldwide license under all +copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, privacy and publicity rights and other intellectual +property rights for the full duration of those rights to use, reproduce, transmit, print, publish, +publicly display, exhibit, distribute, redistribute, copy, index, comment on, modify, transform, +adapt, translate, create derivative works based upon, publicly perform, publicly communicate, +make available, and otherwise exploit such User Generated Content, in whole or in part, in all +media formats and channels now known or hereafter devised (including in connection with the +Disney Services and on third-party sites and platforms), in any number of copies and without +limit as to time, manner and frequency of use, without further notice to you, without attribution +(to the extent this is not contrary to mandatory provisions of applicable law), and without the +requirement of permission from or payment to you or any other person or entity. You agree that +submission of User Generated Content does not establish any relationship of trust and confidence +between you and us, and that you have no expectation of compensation whatsoever (except as +may be specifically stated in the provisions of the Disney Services in connection with the +submission, or arising from it). + +You represent and warrant that your User Generated Content conforms to these terms and that +you own or have the necessary rights and permissions including, without limitation, all +copyrights, music rights and likeness rights (with respect to any person) contained in the User +Generated Content, without the need for payment to any other person or entity, to use and +exploit, and to authorize us to use and exploit, your User Generated Content in all manners +contemplated by these terms. You agree to indemnify and hold us and our subsidiary and +affiliated companies, and each of their respective employees and officers, harmless from any +demands, loss, liability, claims or expenses (including attorneys’ fees), made against us by any +third party arising out of or in connection with our use and exploitation of your User Generated +Content resulting from your breach of any warranty, representation or other provision of these +terms or any applicable supplemental terms. You also agree not to enforce any moral rights, +ancillary rights or similar rights in or to the User Generated Content against us or our licensees, + + distributors, agents, representatives and other authorized users, and agree to procure the same +agreement not to enforce from others who may possess such rights. + +To the extent that we authorize you to create, post, upload, distribute, publicly display or +publicly perform User Generated Content that requires the use of our copyrighted works, we +grant you a non-exclusive license to create a derivative work using the specifically referenced +copyrighted works as required for the sole purpose of creating the materials, provided that such +license shall be conditioned upon your assignment to us of all rights worldwide in the work you +create for the duration of copyright in the User Generated Content, in all formats and media +known or unknown to date, including for use on Disney Services and on third party sites and +platforms. If such rights are not assigned to us, your license to create derivative works using our +copyrighted works shall be null and void. + +We may monitor, screen, post, remove, modify, store and review User Generated Content or +communications sent through a Disney Service, at any time and for any reason, including to +ensure that the User Generated Content or communication conforms to these terms, without prior +notice to you. We are not responsible for, and do not endorse or guarantee, the opinions, views, +advice or recommendations posted or sent by users. + +Accounts + +Some Disney Services permit or require you to create an account to participate or to secure +additional benefits. You agree that any information you provide and maintain is accurate, +current and complete, including your contact information for notices and other communications +from us and your payment information. You agree not to impersonate or misrepresent your +affiliation with any person or entity, including using another person’s username, password or +other account information, or another person’s name or likeness, or provide false details for a +parent or guardian. You agree that we may take steps to verify the accuracy of information you +provide, including contact information for a parent or guardian. + +We have adopted and implemented a policy that provides for the termination, in appropriate +circumstances, of the accounts of users who are repeat infringers of copyright. In addition, we +may suspend or terminate your account and your ability to use the Disney Services if you engage +in, encourage, or advocate for illegal conduct or if you fail to comply with these terms or any +supplemental terms. + +Passwords and Security + +You agree that you will not share your account or account information with others. You are +responsible for taking reasonable steps to maintain the confidentiality of your username and +password, and you are responsible for all activities under your account that you can reasonably +control. You agree to promptly notify us of any unauthorized use of your username, password or +other account information, or of any other breach of security that you become aware of involving +your account or the Disney Services. + + The security, integrity and confidentiality of your information are extremely important to us. We +have implemented technical, administrative and physical security measures that are designed to +protect your information from unauthorized access, disclosure, use and modification. + +4. Paid Transactions + +Identity of Seller + +Sales are made by Disney DTC or the seller identified at the time of sale, if different. If you +have questions about your order, please contact the seller at the address provided and they will +assist you. Some digital storefronts on the Disney Services are operated by third parties and, in +that case, different or additional sale terms may apply, which you should read when they are +presented to you. + +Digital Content and Virtual Items + +We may make applications, games, software or other digital content available on the Disney +Services for you to license for a one-time fee. When purchasing a license to access such material +from a Disney Service, charges will be disclosed to you on the Disney Service before you +complete the license purchase. + +Your purchase of a virtual item or in-game currency is a payment for a limited, non-assignable +license to access and use such content or functionality in the Disney Services with no right to +reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available to the public or transform any +Disney Service via any online media, in any media format or channel now known or hereafter +devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney Service). +Virtual items (including characters and character names) or in-game currency purchased or +available to you in the Disney Services can only be used in connection with the Disney Services +where you obtained them or where they were developed by you as a result of game play. These +items are not redeemable or subject to refund and cannot be traded outside of the Disney +Services for money or other items for value. We may modify or discontinue virtual items or in- +game currency at any time. + +Digital Movie Codes + +Digital codes originally packaged in a combination disc + code package (a package that includes +a DVD, Blu-Ray, and/or 4K/UHD disc(s) and a digital code) may not be sold separately and may +be redeemed only by an individual who obtains the code in the original combination disc + code +package, or by a family member of that individual. Digital codes are not authorized for +redemption if sold separately. You may use digital movie codes to obtain licensed access to +digital movies only as specifically authorized under these terms and conditions and the terms and +conditions of the participating provider of digital content through which you access or download +the digital movie. Digital movie codes sold, distributed, purchased, or transferred in a manner +inconsistent with these terms and conditions are subject to being invalidated. + + Digital Movie Code Returns. If you do not agree to the above terms and conditions for +redeeming a digital movie code obtained by you or a family member in an original combination +disc + code package, you may return the combination disc + code package to Disney for a refund +subject to the conditions provided at this link. + +Subscriptions + +Some Disney Services require paid subscriptions to access. By signing up for a subscription, +you agreed that your subscription will be automatically renewed and, unless you cancel your +subscription, you authorized us to charge your payment method for the renewal term. The period +of auto-renewal will be the same as your initial subscription period unless otherwise disclosed to +you at the time of sale. The renewal rate will be no more than the rate for the immediately prior +subscription period, excluding any promotional and discount pricing, unless we notify you of a +rate change prior to your auto-renewal, in which case you will have the right to cancel the +renewal of your subscription. From time to time, we may offer a free trial subscription for a +Disney Service. If you register for a free trial subscription, we will begin to bill your account +when the free trial subscription expires, unless you cancel your subscription before that time. + +When you subscribe to a Disney Service (other than semi-annual and annual subscriptions), you +have the right to cancel your contract within fourteen (14) days from the date the transaction is +concluded and you will receive a full refund of the subscription fee paid. For semi-annual and +annual subscriptions, if notice of cancellation is received within the first thirty (30) days +following the first day of initial billing, you will receive a refund of the subscription fee paid. If +we refund your subscription fee, you will still be obligated to pay other charges incurred by you +in the course of using the Disney Service prior to the date of cancellation. If you pay a periodic +subscription fee for a Disney Service, we will provide you with reasonable notice of changes to +the fees or billing methods in advance of their effective date and you will be able to cancel your +subscription prior to such change. If you subscribed online, we will give you the option of +cancelling the subscription online. + +The Order Process + +You will have the opportunity to review and confirm your order, including delivery address (if +applicable), payment method and product details. We will send to you a notice when we accept +your order and our acceptance will be deemed complete and for all purposes to have been +effectively communicated to you at the time we send the notice. At such time, the contract for +sale will be made and become binding on both you and us. The risk of loss in any goods you +purchase and the responsibility to insure them passes to you when the relevant goods are +delivered. + +We reserve the right to refuse or cancel any order prior to delivery. Some situations that may +result in your order being cancelled include system or typographical errors, inaccuracies in +product or pricing information or product availability, fairness among customers where supplies +are limited, or problems identified by our credit or fraud departments. We also may require +additional verification or information before accepting an order. We will contact you if any +portion of your order is cancelled or if additional information is required to accept your order. If + + your order is cancelled after we have processed your payment but prior to delivery, we will +refund your payment. + +Payments and Billing + +When you provide payment information, you represent and warrant that the information is +accurate, that you are authorized to use the payment method provided, and that you will notify us +of changes to the payment information. We reserve the right to utilize third party payment card +updating services to obtain current expiration dates on credit cards and debit cards. + +Right of Cancellation; Return of Goods + +You may have the right to cancel an order placed for a Disney Service - depending on the nature +of the Disney Service. Please read the following information carefully so you understand your +right of cancellation. + +If you wish to cancel, you must do so by following the cancellation instructions for the particular +Disney Service. A sample cancellation form is available here. + +Cancelling Subscriptions + +Please see the information above on the process for cancelling subscriptions in our Subscriptions +section. + +Digital Content + +When you purchase a license to access digital content or virtual items, you will be given an +opportunity to consent to delivery at the time of purchase. By consenting to delivery, you +acknowledge that you have lost the right to cancel. License purchase fees paid for digital content +are non-refundable. + +Physical Goods + +You have the right, within thirty (30) days from the date of your receipt of physical goods, to +cancel our contract with you and return the goods. This right does not apply to goods stated by +us on the Disney Services to be non-returnable, including but not limited to: + +• Any products with a seal, where the seal is broken, such as audio and video recordings, + +computer software, and CD’s, DVD’s or other physical media that have been supplied in +sealed packaging; and + +• Personalized items. + +Personalized Goods + +We reserve the right to refuse personalized orders at our discretion. Inappropriate use of our +personalization service will cause your order to be cancelled and any payment refunded. + + These cancellation rights are separate and in addition to your rights should any item we supply +be faulty. + +If you are returning goods that are not faulty, you may be required to pay for the cost of returning +the goods to us and we may deduct a reasonable amount if you use the goods. + +Pricing; Taxes + +We may revise the pricing for products and services we offer. When you place your order, we +estimate the applicable tax and include that estimate in the total for your convenience. Except to +the extent required under applicable tax laws, the actual tax amount that will be applied to your +order and charged to your payment method is based on calculations on the date of shipment, +regardless of when the order was placed. + +International Shipping; Customs + +When ordering goods for delivery to countries other than the country where the seller is located, +you may have to pay import duties and taxes levied. These and any additional charges for +customs clearance must be borne by you. For goods shipped internationally, please note that any +manufacturer warranty may not be valid; manufacturer service options may not be available; +manuals, instructions and safety warnings may not be in destination country languages; the +goods and accompanying materials may not be designed in accordance with destination country +standards, specifications, and labeling requirements; and the goods may not conform to +destination country voltage (requiring use of an adapter or converter). You are responsible for +assuring the goods can be lawfully imported to the destination country. When ordering from us, +the recipient is the importer of record and must comply with all laws and regulations of the +destination country. + +5. Competitions + +Competitions that you enter on a Disney Service may have supplemental rules and/or conditions, +but the following general rules apply absent contrary terms in any supplemental rules or +conditions for the competition. If there are rules or conditions for a competition and such rules +or conditions conflict with these terms, the provisions contained in the rules and conditions +govern and control the competition. + +Entries + +Your competition entry is User Generated Content and subject to all provisions of these terms +that govern your submission and our use of your User Generated Content. We may disqualify +entries that are late, misdirected, incomplete, corrupted, lost, illegible or invalid or where +appropriate parental consent was not provided. Competition entries are limited to one per person +and entries via agents or third parties or the use of multiple identities are not permitted. Use of +automated entries, votes or other programs is prohibited and all such entries (or votes) will be +disqualified. + + We reserve the right to modify, suspend, cancel or terminate a competition or extend or resume +the entry period or disqualify any participant or entry at any time without giving advance +notice. We will do so if it cannot be guaranteed the competition can be carried out fairly or +correctly for technical, legal or other reasons, or if we suspect that any person has manipulated +entries or results, provided false information or acted unethically. If we cancel or terminate a +competition, prizes may be awarded in any manner we deem fair and appropriate consistent with +local laws governing the competition. + +Eligibility + +To enter a competition, the competition must be open to residents in your country and you must +be a registered user of the Disney Services and have an active account with current contact +information. No purchase is necessary to enter a competition and a purchase will not improve +your chances of winning. Competitions are not open to our employees (or their immediate +families) or anyone else professionally associated with the competition. If you are under age 18 +(or under the age of majority under applicable law) and the competition is open to you, we may +need your parent or guardian’s consent before we can accept your entry. We reserve the right to +request proof of identity or to verify eligibility conditions and potential winning entries, and to +award any prize to a winner in person. Competitions are void where prohibited or restricted by +law. Potential winners who are residents in jurisdictions where competitions require an element +of skill may be required to answer a mathematical test in order to be eligible to win a prize. + +Prizes + +No cash or alternative prizes are available, except that we (or the party providing a prize) reserve +the right to substitute a similar prize of equal or greater value. Prizes cannot be transferred +(except to a child or other family member) or sold by winners. Only the number of prizes stated +for the competition is available to be won and all prizes will be awarded provided a sufficient +number of eligible entries are received and prizes are validly claimed by the date provided in +connection with the competition, after which no alternate winners will be selected or unclaimed +prizes awarded. Unless otherwise disclosed in the prize description prior to entry, winners are +responsible for all costs and expenses associated with claiming a prize. All taxes are solely the +responsibility of each winner, although we reserve the right to withhold applicable taxes and +each winner agrees to complete any required tax forms. + +Your acceptance of a prize constitutes agreement to participate in reasonable publicity related to +the competition and grants us an unconditional right to us to use your name, town or city and +state, province or country, likeness, prize information and statements by you about the +competition for publicity, advertising and promotional purposes subject to applicable law and +regulations, all without additional permission or compensation. As a condition of receiving a +prize, winners (or their parents or guardians) may be required to sign and return an affidavit of +eligibility, liability release and publicity release. + + 6. Additional Provisions + +Submissions and Unsolicited Ideas Policies + +Our long-standing company policy does not allow us to accept or consider unsolicited creative +ideas, suggestions or materials. In connection with anything you submit to us – whether or not +solicited by us – you agree that creative ideas, suggestions or other materials you submit are not +being made in confidence or trust and that no confidential or fiduciary relationship is intended or +created between you and us in any way, and that you have no expectation of review, +compensation or consideration of any type. + +Claims of Copyright Infringement + +Notifications of claimed copyright infringement and counter notices must be sent to our +designated agent: + +Lance R. Griffin +The Walt Disney Company +500 South Buena Vista Street +Burbank, California 91521, USA +Phone: +1 818-560-1000 +Fax: +1 818-560-4299 +Email: designated.agent@dig.twdc.com + +We are only able to accept notices in the languages in which these terms are made available by +us. + +We will respond expeditiously to claims of copyright infringement committed using the Disney +Services that are reported to our Designated Copyright Agent, identified above, in accordance +with the U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (“DMCA”) or, as applicable, other +laws. With respect to Disney Services hosted in the United States, these notices must include the +required information set forth in the DMCA and described in detail here. + +7. BINDING ARBITRATION AND CLASS ACTION WAIVER + +PROCEEDINGS TO RESOLVE OR LITIGATE A DISPUTE IN ANY FORUM WILL BE +CONDUCTED ON AN INDIVIDUAL BASIS. Neither you nor Disney DTC will seek to have a +dispute heard as a class action or private attorney general action or in any other proceeding in +which either party acts or proposes to act in a representative capacity. No arbitration or +proceeding can be combined with another without the prior written consent of all parties to the +arbitrations or proceedings. + +You and Disney DTC agree to arbitrate, as provided below, all disputes between you (including +any related disputes involving The Walt Disney Company or its affiliates), that are not resolved +informally, except disputes relating to the ownership or enforcement of intellectual property +rights. “Dispute” includes any dispute, action, or other controversy, whether based on past, + + present, or future events, between you and us concerning the Disney Services or this Agreement, +whether in contract, tort, warranty, statute, regulation, or other legal or equitable basis. You and +Disney DTC empower the arbitrator with the exclusive authority to resolve any dispute relating +to the interpretation, applicability or enforceability of these terms or the formation of this +contract, including the arbitrability of any dispute and any claim that all or any part of this +Agreement are void or voidable. + +A. In the event of a dispute, you or Disney DTC must send to the other party a notice of +dispute, which is a written statement that sets forth the name, address, and contact +information of the party giving the notice, the facts giving rise to the dispute, and the +relief requested. You must send any notice of dispute to Disney DTC, 500 South +Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521-7620, USA, Attention: Legal. We will +send any notice of dispute to you at the contact information we have for you. You and +Disney DTC will attempt to resolve a dispute through informal negotiation within +sixty (60) days from the date the notice of dispute is sent. After that sixty (60) day +period and not before, you or we may commence an arbitration proceeding. You may +instead litigate a dispute in small claims court if the dispute meets the requirements to +be heard in small claims court, whether or not you negotiated informally first. + +B. If you and Disney DTC do not resolve a dispute by informal negotiation or in small +claims court, the dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration before a neutral +arbitrator whose decision will be final except for a limited right of appeal under the +U.S. Federal Arbitration Act. YOU ARE GIVING UP THE RIGHT TO LITIGATE +A DISPUTE IN COURT BEFORE A JUDGE OR JURY. Arbitration will be +administered by JAMS Mediation, Arbitration and ADR Services (“JAMS”) in +accordance with the JAMS Streamlined Arbitration Rules and Procedures (the +“JAMS Rules”). The JAMS Rules and instructions about how to initiate an +arbitration are available at www.jamsadr.com or 1-800-352-5267. Arbitration may be +conducted in person, through the submission of documents, by phone, or online. +Proceedings that cannot be conducted through the submission of documents, by +phone, or online, will take place in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of +Manhattan, New York, New York, whichever is more convenient for you; provided, +however, that if circumstances prevent you from traveling to Los Angeles or New +York, JAMS may hold an in-person hearing in your hometown area. You and Disney +DTC agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal or state courts located +in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of Manhattan, New York, New +York, whichever is more convenient for you, in order to compel arbitration, to stay +proceedings pending arbitration, or to confirm, modify, vacate, or enter judgment on +the award entered by the arbitrator. The arbitrator may award damages to you +individually as a court could, including declaratory or injunctive relief, but only to the +extent required to satisfy your individual claim. + +Except as provided above with respect to jurisdiction in Los Angeles, California and Manhattan, +New York, New York, nothing in this arbitration provision shall be construed as consent by +Disney DTC or its affiliates to the jurisdiction of any other court with regard to disputes, claims +or controversies unrelated to the Disney Services or this Agreement. + + Choice of Forum + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent required under applicable local law which requires that venue be in the +country of your residence, you agree that any action at law or in equity arising out of or relating +to these terms or the Disney Services that is not subject to arbitration shall be filed, and that +venue properly lies, only in the state or federal courts located in the borough of Manhattan, New +York, New York, United States of America and you consent and submit to the personal +jurisdiction of such courts for the purposes of litigating such action. + +Choice of Law + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent that applicable local law requires that the law to be applied for contracts of +this type be that of the country of your residence, these terms are governed by and construed in +accordance with the laws of the State of New York and the laws of the United States, without +giving effect to any conflict of law principles. + +Severability + +If any provision of these terms shall be unlawful, void or for any reason unenforceable, then that +provision shall be deemed severable from these terms and shall not affect the validity and +enforceability of any remaining provisions. + +Survival + +The provisions of these terms which by their nature should survive the termination of these terms +shall survive such termination. + +Waiver + +No waiver of any provision of these terms by us shall be deemed a further or continuing waiver +of such provision or any other provision, and our failure to assert any right or provision under +these terms shall not constitute a waiver of such right or provision. + diff --git a/q24/random_k4/random_4.md b/q24/random_k4/random_4.md index 89a0e0d7330b5b5f606ca129bb50b359ffb607a6..d1771f94490a748cfd31a8d039434182828c4f11 100644 --- a/q24/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q24/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,299 +1,2639 @@ -Wikidata's SPARQL +For Immediate Release -introduction for beginners +Contact: -CC BY-SA -Lucie-Aimée Kaffee +Ken Bond +Oracle Investor Relations +1.650.607.0349 +ken.bond@oracle.com -Frimelle -@lucielinde +Deborah Hellinger +Oracle Corporate Communications +1.212.508.7935 +deborah.hellinger@oracle.com - What is turtle? +SAAS AND PAAS CLOUD REVENUE UP 32%, SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUE UP 6% TO $6.6 BILLION -RDF triple language +Record Quarterly Operating Cash Flow Up 7% to $6.7 Billion -Subject Predicate Object +REDWOOD SHORES, Calif., September 18, 2014 -- Oracle Corporation (NYSE: ORCL) -as Web URI +today announced that fiscal 2015 Q1 total revenues were up 3% to $8.6 billion. Total Software plus -Alan Turing (Q7251) instance of (P31) human (Q5) +Cloud revenue was up 6% to $6.6 billion. Software-as-a-service (SaaS) and Platform-as-a-service -RDF - +(PaaS) cloud revenue was up 32% to $337 million. Infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) cloud revenue -turtle -@prefix wd: +was up 26% to $138 million. Hardware systems revenue was down 8% to $1.2 billion. GAAP -@prefix wdt: +operating income was up 3% to $3.0 billion, and the GAAP operating margin was 34%. Non-GAAP -wd:Q7251 wdt:P31 wd:Q5 +operating income was up 2% to $3.8 billion, and the non-GAAP operating margin was 44%. GAAP - What is SPARQL? +net income was unchanged at $2.2 billion while non-GAAP net income was up 2% at $2.8 billion. -RDF query language +GAAP earnings per share were $0.48, up 2% compared to last year while non-GAAP earnings per -to form complex queries with SELECT and retrieve data from an endpoint +share were $0.62, up 4%. GAAP operating cash flow on a trailing twelve-month basis was $15.4 -Return all items, which are instance of human, limited to 200 items. +billion. -PREFIX wd: +“We are increasing our cloud services growth rate while simultaneously delivering record -PREFIX wdt: +levels of cash flow,” said Oracle CEO, Safra Catz. “In Q1, our overall cloud services business grew -SELECT ?subject WHERE { ?subject wdt:P31 wd:Q5 . } LIMIT 200 +more than 30% to $475 million in revenue. At the same time, we delivered an all-time record - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +operating cash flow up 7% to $6.7 billion. We are laser focused on two goals: growing our cloud -Show all data for Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +business and growing our cash flow. We’re off to a good start in FY15.” -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +“Our internally developed Fusion cloud applications business grew at a rate of nearly 200% -Extract of the result +in the quarter,” said Oracle CEO, Mark Hurd. “As our hyper-growth Fusion applications become a -predicate +larger and larger portion of our total SaaS sales, that will drive up our overall cloud services growth -rdfs:label +rate. Our cloud business is already three times the size of Workday, but we won’t be satisfied until -rdfs:label +we’re number one in the cloud.” -object +“Next week at Oracle Open World, we will be rolling out our database cloud service,” said -Alan Turing +Oracle Executive Chairman and Chief Technology Officer, Larry Ellison. “Database is our largest -ﺞﻧروﺗ نﻻآ + software business, and database will be our largest cloud service. With our new multitenant Database -skos:altLabel +as a Service offering, our customers and ISV’s can move any of their existing Oracle databases and -Алан Цюрынг +applications to the Oracle Cloud with the push of a button.” - +The Board of Directors also declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.12 per share of - +outstanding common stock. This dividend will be paid to stockholders of record as of the close of -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) +business on October 8, 2014, with a payment date of October 29, 2014. - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +Oracle also announced that its Board of Directors authorized the repurchase of up to an -Show all fields of work of Alan Turing +additional $13.0 billion of common stock under its existing share repurchase program in future -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +quarters. - On Wikidata Query Service Beta +Q1 Fiscal 2015 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast -Result Result +Oracle will hold a conference call and webcast today to discuss these results at 2:00 p.m. -object +Pacific. You may listen to the call by dialing (816) 287-5563, Passcode: 425392. To access the live - +webcast of this event, please visit the Oracle Investor Relations website at - +http://www.oracle.com/investor. In addition, Oracle’s Q1 results and Fiscal 2015 financial tables are -label +available on the Oracle Investor Relations website. -computer science +A replay of the conference call will also be available by dialing (855) 859-2056 or (404) 537- -cryptanalysis +3406, Passcode: 99926438. -Turing’s field of work (P101) is computer science (Q21198) and cryptanalysis (Q897511) +About Oracle - Exploring Wikidata’s linked data +Oracle engineers hardware and software to work together in the cloud and in your data center. For more -Data linked to Alan Turing (Q7251) limited to 100 +information about Oracle (NYSE: ORCL), visit www.oracle.com or contact Investor Relations at -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +investor_us@oracle.com or (650) 506-4073. -Extract of the result +# # # -subject +Trademarks -predicate +Oracle and Java are registered trademarks of Oracle and/or its affiliates. Other names may be trademarks - +of their respective owners. - + "Safe Harbor" Statement: Statements in this press release relating to Oracle's future plans, +expectations, beliefs, intentions and prospects, including statements regarding our cloud services +growth rate, growing our cash flow, our plans to be number one in the cloud, our Database as a +Service offering and that database will be our largest cloud service, are "forward-looking statements" - + and are subject to material risks and uncertainties. Many factors could affect our current expectations +and our actual results, and could cause actual results to differ materially. We presently consider the +following to be among the important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from +expectations: (1) Economic, geopolitical and market conditions, including the continued slow +economic recovery in the U.S. and other parts of the world, can adversely affect our business, results +of operations and financial condition, including our revenue growth and profitability, which in turn +could adversely affect our stock price. (2) We may fail to achieve our financial forecasts due to such +factors as delays or size reductions in transactions, fewer large transactions in a particular quarter, +unanticipated fluctuations in currency exchange rates, delays in delivery of new products or releases +or a decline in our renewal rates for support contracts. (3) Our cloud computing strategy, including +our Oracle Cloud Software-as-a-Service, Platform-as-a-Service, Infrastructure-as-a-Service and our +new Database as a Service offerings, may not be successful. (4) If we are unable to develop new or +sufficiently differentiated products and services, or to enhance and improve our products and support +services in a timely manner or to position and/or price our products and services to meet market +demand, customers may not buy new software licenses, cloud software subscriptions or hardware +systems products or purchase or renew support contracts. (5) Our international sales and operations +subject us to additional risks that can adversely affect our operating results, including risks relating +to foreign currency gains and losses. (6) If the security measures for our software, hardware, services +or Oracle Cloud offerings are compromised or if such offerings contain significant coding, +manufacturing or configuration errors, we may experience reputational harm, legal claims and +financial exposure. (7) We have an active acquisition program and our acquisitions may not be +successful, may involve unanticipated costs or other integration issues or may disrupt our existing +operations. A detailed discussion of these factors and other risks that affect our business is contained +in our SEC filings, including our most recent reports on Form 10-K and Form 10-Q, particularly +under the heading "Risk Factors." Copies of these filings are available online from the SEC or by +contacting Oracle Corporation's Investor Relations Department at (650) 506-4073 or by clicking on +SEC Filings on Oracle’s Investor Relations website at http://www.oracle.com/investor. All +information set forth in this press release is current as of September 18, 2014. Oracle undertakes no +duty to update any statement in light of new information or future events. - + ORACLE CORPORATION + Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS +($ in millions, except per share data) - +Three Months Ended August 31, - +2014 -* +% of +Revenues - +2013 - Truthy and full statements +% of +Revenues -represents statements in two formats +% Increase +(Decrease) +in US $ -truthy -contain only the statements of best rank +% Increase +(Decrease) +in Constant +Currency (1) -best rank are all statements of preferred rank, if those exist or all statements of normal rank +REVENUES -qualifiers are ignored +New software licenses +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support -Prefix wdt: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/) - e.g. wdt:P101 +$ -full statements -represent all data about a statement +1,370 +337 +138 +4,731 -represented in a separate node with the unique id of the statement - e.g. q92741-7ED21209-4E23-4EB1-886A-772CC6A5350F +Software and Cloud Revenues -Prefix p: (http://www.wikidata.org/prop/) - e.g. p:P101 +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support - Full statements +Hardware Systems Revenues -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +Services Revenues -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; + Total Revenues -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +OPERATING EXPENSES +Sales and marketing +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support +Services +Research and development +General and administrative +Amortization of intangible assets +Acquisition related and other +Restructuring + + Total Operating Expenses + +OPERATING INCOME +OPERATING INCOME +Interest expense +Non-operating income, net + +INCOME BEFORE PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES + +Provision for income taxes -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +8,596 -ps:P1082 10000 ; +100% -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +8,372 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +100% -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +16% +4% +1% +55% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +76% +7% +7% -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +14% -the population is 10000 ; +10% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +$ -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +1,399 +254 +109 +4,431 - Full statements +6,193 +669 +592 -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +1,261 -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +918 -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +17% +3% +1% +53% -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +74% +8% +7% -ps:P1082 10000 ; +15% -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +11% -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +20% +2% +1% +3% +4% +2% +8% +16% +3% +6% +0% +1% -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +66% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +34% +34% +(3%) +0% -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +31% +6% -the population is 10000 ; +25% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +1,620 +102 +72 +288 +330 +209 +720 +1,237 +260 +595 +10 +56 -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +5,499 - Full statements +2,873 +2,873 +(217) +7 -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +2,663 +472 -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +$ -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +2,191 -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +19% +1% +1% +3% +4% +3% +9% +15% +3% +7% +0% +1% -ps:P1082 10000 ; +66% -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +34% +34% +(2%) +0% + +32% +6% + +26% + +6,576 +578 +587 + +1,165 + +855 + +1,706 +149 +79 +272 +298 +192 +691 +1,329 +276 +547 +25 +69 + +5,633 + +2,963 +2,963 +(261) +16 -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +2,718 +534 -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +(2%) +32% +26% +7% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +6% +(14%) +(1%) -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +(8%) -the population is 10000 ; +(7%) -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +3% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +5% +47% +10% +(5%) +(10%) +(8%) +(4%) +7% +6% +(8%) +138% +23% - Full statements +2% -qualifier and references are objects of the full statement +3% +3% +21% +144% -wds:Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 a wikibase:Statement ; +2% +13% -wikibase:rank wikibase:NormalRank ; +0% -psv:P1082 wdv:0419376cf1da9a8efcbb5ab7c87ded58 ; +(2%) +32% +25% +6% -ps:P1082 10000 ; +6% +(14%) +(2%) -pqv:P585 wdv:04a483576f9618f0263dd20cb503ad32 ; +(8%) -pq:P585 1680-01-01T00:00:00Z . +(8%) -Q64-01f1575b-4bf3-982b-34d6-102fbe912ae2 (one statement for population of Berlin) is type of statement ; +2% -has a NormalRank ; (this statement wouldn’t show up in truthy since population has a prefered rank) +5% +45% +9% +(6%) +(10%) +(9%) +(5%) +7% +5% +(8%) +134% +21% -the population (P1082) is connected to a full value ; +2% -the population is 10000 ; +2% +2% +21% +80% -the qualifier for point (P585) in time is connected to a full value ; +1% +12% -the qualifier point in time (P585) implies this statement is valid for 1680 . +(1%) - Example Query +NET INCOME -Who’s birthday is today? +$ -P569: date of birth +2,184 -On Wikidata Query Service Beta +EARNINGS PER SHARE: - Ressources +Basic +Diluted -Wikidata Query Service Beta +WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING: -http://wdqs-beta.wmflabs.org/ +Basic +Diluted -Mediawiki: RDF Dump Format +$ +$ -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format +0.49 +0.48 -Prefixes used for Wikidata +$ +$ -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/RDF_Dump_Format#Prefixes_used +0.48 +0.47 -Mediawiki: Query Examples +4,451 +4,548 -https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikibase/Indexing/SPARQL_Query_Examples +4,608 +4,674 -github: wikidata query rdf docs +(1) -https://github.com/wikimedia/wikidata-query-rdf/tree/master/docs +We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to +provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, +current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange +rates in effect on May 31, 2014, which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. Movements +in international currencies relative to the United States dollar during the three months ended August 31, 2014 compared with the corresponding prior year period +increased our revenues by 1 percentage point and operating income by 1 percentage point. -Wikidata turtle dumps + 1 -https://dumps.wikimedia.org/wikidatawiki/entities/ + ORACLE CORPORATION + Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +RECONCILIATION OF SELECTED GAAP MEASURES TO NON-GAAP MEASURES (1) +($ in millions, except per share data) -W3C RDF Primer +Three Months Ended August 31, -http://www.w3.org/2007/02/turtle/primer/ +% Increase (Decrease) +in US $ + +% Increase (Decrease) in +Constant Currency (2) + +2014 +GAAP + +Adj. + +2014 +Non-GAAP + +2013 +GAAP + +Adj. + +2013 +Non-GAAP + +GAAP + +Non-GAAP + +GAAP + +Non-GAAP + +TOTAL REVENUES (3) (4) + +$ + +8,596 + +$ +3 + +$ + +8,599 + +$ + +8,372 + +$ +9 + +$ + +8,381 + +TOTAL SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUES (3) + +$ + +6,576 + +$ +2 + +$ + +6,578 + +$ + +6,193 + +$ +4 + +$ + +6,197 + +New software licenses +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service (3) +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support + +1,370 +337 +138 +4,731 + +- +2 +- +- + +1,370 +339 +138 +4,731 + +1,399 +254 +109 +4,431 + +- +3 +- +1 + +1,399 +257 +109 +4,432 + +TOTAL HARDWARE SYSTEMS REVENUES (4) + +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support (4) + +TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES +Stock-based compensation (5) +Amortization of intangible assets (6) +Acquisition related and other +Restructuring + +OPERATING INCOME + +OPERATING MARGIN % + +INCOME TAX EFFECTS (7) + +NET INCOME + +$ + +1,165 +578 +587 + +1 +$ +- +1 + +$ + +1,166 +578 +588 + +$ + +1,261 +669 +592 + +$ + +5,633 +212 +547 +25 +69 + +$ + +(853) +(212) +(547) +(25) +(69) + +$ + +4,780 +- +- +- +- + +$ + +5,499 +198 +595 +10 +56 + +5 +$ +- +5 + +$ + +(859) +(198) +(595) +(10) +(56) + +$ + +1,266 +669 +597 + +$ + +4,640 +- +- +- +- + +$ + +2,963 + +$ + +856 + +$ + +3,819 + +$ + +2,873 + +$ + +868 + +$ + +3,741 + +3% + +34% + +44% + +34% + +45% + +15 bp. + +(22) bp. + +$ + +534 + +$ + +234 + +$ + +768 + +$ + +472 + +$ + +298 + +$ + +770 + +13% + +$ + +2,184 + +$ + +622 + +$ + +2,806 + +$ + +2,191 + +$ + +570 + +$ + +2,761 + +3% + +6% + +(2%) +32% +26% +7% + +(8%) +(14%) +(1%) + +2% +7% +(8%) +138% +23% + +0% + +2% + +3% + +6% + +(2%) +32% +26% +7% + +(8%) +(14%) +(2%) + +3% +* +* +* +* + +2% + +0% + +2% + +4% + +2% + +6% + +(2%) +32% +25% +6% + +(8%) +(14%) +(2%) + +2% +7% +(8%) +134% +21% + +2% + +8 bp. + +12% + +(1%) + +1% + +(3%) + +2% + +6% + +(2%) +31% +25% +6% + +(8%) +(14%) +(2%) + +2% +* +* +* +* + +1% + +(25) bp. + +(1%) + +1% + +4% + +(3%) + +DILUTED EARNINGS PER SHARE + +$ + +0.48 + +$ + +0.62 + +$ + +0.47 + +$ + +0.59 + +DILUTED WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING + +4,548 + +- + +4,548 + +4,674 + +- + +4,674 + +(3%) + +(3%) + +(1) + +(2) + +This presentation includes non-GAAP measures. Our non-GAAP measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures, and should be read only in conjunction with our consolidatedfinancial statements prepared in +accordance with GAAP. For a detailed explanation of the adjustments made to comparable GAAP measures, the reasons why management uses these measures, the usefulness of these measures and the material limitations on the usefulness of these measures, +please see Appendix A. + +We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of +foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014, +which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. + +(3) + +As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to assumed cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules. + +(4) + +As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to hardware systems support contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules. + +(43) +(2) +(1) +( ) +(5) +(1) +(1) +(6) +(108) +(45) +(212) +(3) +(215) + +Non-GAAP +- +$ +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +$ +- + +Three Months Ended +August 31, 2013 +Adj. +$ + +GAAP + +$ + +39 +2 +1 +6 +2 +3 +6 +97 +42 +198 +2 +200 + +(39) +(2) +(1) +( ) +(6) +(2) +(3) +(6) +(97) +(42) +(198) +(2) +(200) + +Non-GAAP +- +$ +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +$ +- + +$ + +$ + +$ + +$ + +(5) + +Stock-based compensation was included in the following GAAP operating expense categories: + +Three Months Ended +August 31, 2014 + +GAAP + +$ + +Adj. +$ + + Sales and marketing + Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service + Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service + Software license updates and product support + Hardware systems products + Hardware systems support + Services + Research and development + General and administrative + Subtotal + Acquisition related and other + Total stock-based compensation + +Remainder of Fiscal 2015 +Fiscal 2016 +Fiscal 2017 +Fiscal 2018 +Fiscal 2019 +Fiscal 2020 +Thereafter + +Total intangible assets subject to amortization + +In-process research and development + +Total intangible assets, net + +43 +2 +1 +5 +1 +1 +6 +108 +45 +212 +3 +215 + +1,395 +1,345 +749 +611 +511 +387 +592 +5,590 +15 +5,605 + +$ + +$ + +(6) + +Estimated future annual amortization expense related to intangible assets as of August 31, 2014 was as follows: + +(7) + +Income tax effects were calculated reflecting an effective GAAP tax rate of 19.7% and 17.7% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively, and an effective non-GAAP tax rate of 21.5% and 21.8% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively. +The differences between our GAAP and non-GAAP tax rates in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014 were primarily due to the net tax effects of acquisition related items, including the tax effects of amortization of intangible assets. + +* Not meaningful + + 2 + 2 + + ORACLE CORPORATION + +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS +($ in millions) + +ASSETS + +Current Assets: + +Cash and cash equivalents +Marketable securities +Trade receivables, net +Inventories +Deferred tax assets +Prepaid expenses and other current assets + +Total Current Assets + +Non-Current Assets: + + Property, plant and equipment, net + Intangible assets, net + Goodwill + Deferred tax assets + Other assets + +Total Non-Current Assets + +TOTAL ASSETS + +LIABILITIES AND EQUITY + +Current Liabilities: + +August 31, +2014 + +May 31, +2014 + +$ + +24,179 +27,437 +3,551 +179 +833 +2,015 + +$ + +17,769 +21,050 +6,087 +189 +914 +2,129 + +58,194 + +3,086 +5,605 +29,707 +916 +2,218 + +41,532 + +48,138 + +3,061 +6,137 +29,652 +837 +2,519 + +42,206 + +$ + +99,726 + +$ + +90,344 + +Notes payable, current and other current borrowings +Notes payable, current and other current borrowings +Accounts payable +Accrued compensation and related benefits +Income taxes payable +Deferred revenues +Other current liabilities + +- +$ +$ +423 +1,491 +425 +8,939 +2,099 + +$ +$ + +1,508 +1,508 +471 +1,940 +416 +7,269 +2,785 + +Total Current Liabilities + +Non-Current Liabilities: + +Notes payable and other non-current borrowings +Income taxes payable +Other non-current liabilities + +Total Non-Current Liabilities + +Equity + +13,377 + +32,567 +4,148 +1,703 + +38,418 + +47,931 + +14,389 + +22,667 +4,184 +1,657 + +28,508 + +47,447 + +TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY + +$ + +99,726 + +$ + +90,344 + + 3 + 3 + + ORACLE CORPORATION + +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS + +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS +($ in millions) + +Cash Flows From Operating Activities: + +Net income +Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities: + +Depreciation +Amortization of intangible assets +Deferred income taxes +Stock-based compensation +Tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards +Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards +Other, net +Changes in operating assets and liabilities, net of effects from acquisitions: + +Decrease in trade receivables, net +Decrease in inventories +Decrease in prepaid expenses and other assets +Decrease in accounts payable and other liabilities +Increase (decrease) in income taxes payable +Increase in deferred revenues + +Net cash provided by operating activities + +Cash Flows From Investing Activities: + +Purchases of marketable securities and other investments +Proceeds from maturities and sales of marketable securities and other investments +Acquisitions, net of cash acquired +Capital expenditures + +Net cash used for investing activities + +Cash Flows From Financing Activities: + +Payments for repurchases of common stock +Proceeds from issuances of common stock +Payments of dividends to stockholders +Proceeds from borrowings, net of issuance costs +Repayments of borrowings +Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards +Distributions to noncontrolling interests + +Net cash provided by financing activities + +Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents + +Net increase in cash and cash equivalents + +Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period + +Cash and cash equivalents at end of period + +Three Months Ended August 31, + +2014 + +2013 + +$ + +2,184 + +$ + +2,191 + +160 +547 +(68) +215 +96 +(51) +46 + +2,506 +10 +275 +(1,088) +80 +1,816 + +6,728 + +(10,340) +3,878 +(37) +(201) + +(6,700) + +(2,000) +588 +(537) +9,945 +(1,500) +51 +(27) + +6,520 + +(138) + +6,410 + +17,769 + +150 +595 +(101) +200 +67 +(40) +17 + +2,707 +5 +366 +(994) +(313) +1,442 + +6,292 + +(8,549) +6,515 +(1,314) +(153) + +(3,501) + +(2,968) +285 +(554) +5,566 +- + +40 +(28) + +2,341 + +(81) + +5,051 + +14,613 + +$ + +24,179 + +$ + +19,664 + + 4 + 4 + + ORACLE CORPORATION +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +FREE CASH FLOW - TRAILING 4-QUARTERS (1) +($ in millions) + +Q1 + +Fiscal 2014 + +Q2 + +Q3 + +Q4 + +Q1 + +Q2 + +Q3 + +Q4 + +Fiscal 2015 + +GAAP Operating Cash Flow + +$ + +14,845 + +$ + +15,196 + +$ + +15,029 + +$ + +14,921 + +$ + +15,357 + +Capital Expenditures (2) + +(664) + +(578) + +(609) + +(580) + +(628) + +Free Cash Flow + +$ + +14,181 + +$ + +14,618 + +$ + +14,420 + +$ + +14,341 + +$ + +14,729 + +% Growth over prior year + +6% + +14% + +11% + +6% + +4% + +GAAP Net Income + +$ + +11,082 + +$ + +11,054 + +$ + +11,115 + +$ + +10,955 + +$ + +10,948 + +Free Cash Flow as a % of Net Income + +128% + +132% + +130% + +131% + +135% + +(1) + +To supplement our statements of cash flows presented on a GAAP basis, we use non-GAAP measures of cash flows on a trailing 4-quarter basis to analyze cash flow generated +from operations. We believe free cash flow is also useful as one of the bases for comparing our performance with our competitors. The presentation of non-GAAP free cash flow is +not meant to be considered in isolation or as an alternative to net income as an indicator of our performance, or as an alternative to cash flows from operating activities as a +measure of liquidity. + +(2) + +Derived from capital expenditures as reported in cash flows from investing activities as per our consolidated statements of cash flows presented in accordance with GAAP. + + 5 5 + + ORACLE CORPORATION +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +SUPPLEMENTAL ANALYSIS OF GAAP REVENUES AND HEADCOUNT (1) +($ in millions) + +Q1 + +Q2 + +Fiscal 2014 +Q3 + +Q4 + +TOTAL + +Q1 + +Q2 + +Fiscal 2015 +Q3 + +Q4 + +TOTAL + +REVENUES +New software licenses +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support + +Software and Cloud Revenues + +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support + +Hardware Systems Revenues + +Services Revenues + +Total Revenues + +AS REPORTED REVENUE GROWTH RATES +New software licenses +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support + +Software and Cloud Revenues + +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support + +Hardware Systems Revenues + +Services Revenues + +Total Revenues + +CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) +New software licenses +Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service +Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service +Software license updates and product support +d R + +Software and Cloud Revenues +S ft + +d Cl + +Hardware systems products +Hardware systems support + +Hardware Systems Revenues + +Services Revenues + +Total Revenues + +GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES + +REVENUES +Americas +Europe, Middle East & Africa +Asia Pacific + +Total Revenues + +HEADCOUNT + +GEOGRAPHIC AREA + +Americas +Europe, Middle East & Africa +Asia Pacific + +Total Company + +$ + +1,399 +254 +109 +4,431 +6,193 + +$ + +2,121 +259 +97 +4,516 +6,993 + +$ + +2,128 +287 +121 +4,564 +7,100 + +$ + +3,769 +322 +128 +4,695 +8,914 + +$ + +9,416 +1,121 +456 +18,206 +29,199 + +$ + +1,370 +337 +138 +4,731 +6,576 + +669 +592 +1,261 + +714 +609 +1,323 + +725 +598 +1,323 + +870 +596 +1,466 + +2,976 +2,396 +5,372 + +578 +587 +1,165 + +918 + +959 + +884 + +940 + +3,704 + +855 + +$ + +1,370 +337 +138 +4,731 +6,576 + +578 +587 +1,165 + +855 + +$ + +8,372 + +$ + +9,275 + +$ + +9,307 + +$ + +11,320 + +$ + +38,275 + +$ + +8,596 + +$ + +8,596 + +2% +25% +(9%) +7% +6% + +(14%) +3% +(7%) + +(2%) +19% +(15%) +6% +3% + +(3%) +4% +0% + +1% +24% +10% +5% +5% + +8% +5% +7% + +0% +25% +13% +7% +4% + +2% +2% +2% + +0% +23% +0% +6% +5% + +(2%) +4% +0% + +(2%) +32% +26% +7% +6% + +(14%) +(1%) +(8%) + +(8%) + +(5%) + +(5%) + +(4%) + +(5%) + +(7%) + +2% + +2% + +4% + +3% + +3% + +3% + +5% +26% +(7%) +8% +8% +8% + +(13%) +5% +(6%) + +0% +20% +(14%) +7% +5% +5% + +(2%) +5% +1% + +3% +25% +11% +7% +6% +6% + +10% +7% +9% + +(1%) +25% +13% +6% +4% +4% + +3% +2% +3% + +1% +24% +1% +7% +5% +5% + +(1%) +5% +2% + +(2%) +32% +25% +6% +6% +6% + +(14%) +(2%) +(8%) + +(6%) + +(3%) + +(3%) + +(3%) + +(4%) + +(8%) + +4% + +3% + +6% + +3% + +4% + +2% + +(2%) +32% +26% +7% +6% + +(14%) +(1%) +(8%) + +(7%) + +3% + +(2%) +32% +25% +6% +6% +6% + +(14%) +(2%) +(8%) + +(8%) + +2% + +$ + +$ + +$ + +4,517 +2,439 +1,416 +8,372 + +4,995 +2,817 +1,463 +9,275 + +$ + +$ + +$ + +4,953 +2,923 +1,431 +9,307 + +$ + +5,857 +3,768 +1,695 +11,320 + +$ + +$ + +20,323 +11,946 +6,006 +38,275 + +$ + +$ + +$ + +4,620 +2,589 +1,387 +8,596 + +$ + +$ + +4,620 +2,589 +1,387 +8,596 + +53,465 +23,349 +45,513 +122,327 + +53,073 +23,178 +45,617 +121,868 + +53,799 +23,350 +45,561 +122,710 + +53,827 +23,339 +45,108 +122,274 + +54,073 +23,349 +45,496 +122,918 + +(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding. + +(2) + +We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for +assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for +entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal +2014 constant currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. + + 6 + 6 + + ORACLE CORPORATION +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +SUPPLEMENTAL GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES ANALYSIS (1) +($ in millions) + +Q1 + +Q2 + +Fiscal 2014 +Q3 + +Q4 + +TOTAL + +Q1 + +Q2 + +Fiscal 2015 +Q3 + +Q4 + +TOTAL + +AMERICAS + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +EUROPE / MIDDLE EAST / AFRICA + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +ASIA PACIFIC + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +TOTAL COMPANY + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES +Software and cloud revenues + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2) + Software and cloud revenues + Hardware systems revenues + +$ +$ + +3,434 +640 + +$ +$ + +3,808 +694 + +$ +$ + +3,847 +655 + +$ +$ + +4,649 +747 + +$ +$ + +15,737 +2,736 + +$ +$ + +3,614 +583 + +9% +(2%) + +9% +(1%) + +5% +7% + +6% +8% + +5% +14% + +7% +16% + +(1%) +3% + +1% +5% + +4% +5% + +5% +6% + +5% +(9%) + +6% +(8%) + +$ +$ + +1,816 +358 + +$ +$ + +2,155 +372 + +$ +$ + +2,245 +403 + +$ +$ + +3,032 +440 + +$ +$ + +9,249 +1,572 + +$ +$ + +1,992 +338 + +7% +(11%) + +4% +(13%) + +8% +(5%) + +6% +(6%) + +8% +3% + +6% +2% + +15% +7% + +10% +3% + +10% +(1%) + +7% +(3%) + +10% +(6%) + +7% +(7%) + +$ +$ + +943 +263 + +$ +$ + +1,030 +257 + +$ +$ + +1,008 +265 + +$ +$ + +1,233 +279 + +$ +$ + +4,213 +1,064 + +$ +$ + +970 +244 + +(3%) +(12%) + +8% +(5%) + +(9%) +(9%) + +0% +(3%) + +(5%) +(3%) + +3% +3% + +0% +(4%) + +3% +(3%) + +(4%) +(7%) + +3% +(2%) + +3% +(8%) + +2% +(8%) + +$ +$ + +6,193 +1,261 + +$ +$ + +6,993 +1,323 + +$ +$ + +7,100 +1,323 + +$ +$ + +8,914 +1,466 + +$ +$ + +29,199 +5,372 + +$ +$ + +6,576 +1,165 + +6% +6% +(7%) + +8% +(6%) + +3% +3% +0% + +5% +1% + +5% +5% +7% + +6% +9% + +4% +4% +2% + +4% +3% + +5% +5% +0% + +5% +2% + +6% +6% +(8%) + +6% +(8%) + +$ +$ + +3,614 +583 + +5% +(9%) + +6% +(8%) + +$ +$ + +1,992 +338 + +10% +(6%) + +7% +(7%) + +$ +$ + +970 +244 + +3% +(8%) + +2% +(8%) + +$ +$ + +6,576 +1,165 + +6% +6% +(8%) + +6% +(8%) + +(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding. + +(2) We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for +assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities +reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal 2014 constant +currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. + + 7 + 7 + + ORACLE CORPORATION +Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS +EXPLANATION OF NON-GAAP MEASURES + +APPENDIX A + +To supplement our financial results presented on a GAAP basis, we use the non-GAAP measures indicated in the tables, which exclude +certain business combination accounting entries and expenses related to acquisitions, as well as other significant expenses including +stock-based compensation, that we believe are helpful in understanding our past financial performance and our future results. Our non- +GAAP financial measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures and should be +read only in conjunction with our consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with GAAP. Our management regularly uses +our supplemental non-GAAP financial measures internally to understand, manage and evaluate our business and make operating +decisions. These non-GAAP measures are among the primary factors management uses in planning for and forecasting future periods. +Compensation of our executives is based in part on the performance of our business based on these non-GAAP measures. Our non- +GAAP financial measures reflect adjustments based on the following items, as well as the related income tax effects: + +• Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service, software license updates and product support and hardware systems support +deferred revenues: Business combination accounting rules require us to account for the fair values of cloud software-as-a-service and +platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts and hardware systems support contracts assumed +in connection with our acquisitions. Because these contracts are generally one year in duration, our GAAP revenues generally for the one +year period subsequent to our acquisition of a business do not reflect the full amount of revenues on these assumed cloud and support +contracts that would have otherwise been recorded by the acquired entity. The non-GAAP adjustment to our cloud software-as-a-service +and platform-as-a-service revenues, software license updates and product support revenues and hardware systems support revenues is +intended to include, and thus reflect, the full amount of such revenues. We believe the adjustment to these revenues is useful to investors +as a measure of the ongoing performance of our business. We have historically experienced high renewal rates on our software license +updates and product support contracts and our objective is to increase the renewal rates on acquired and new cloud software-as-a-service +and platform-as-a-service and hardware systems support contracts; however, we cannot be certain that our customers will renew our +cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts or our hardware +systems support contracts. + +• Stock-based compensation expenses: We have excluded the effect of stock-based compensation expenses from our non-GAAP +operating expenses and net income measures. Although stock-based compensation is a key incentive offered to our employees, and we +believe such compensation contributed to the revenues earned during the periods presented and also believe it will contribute to the +generation of future period revenues, we continue to evaluate our business performance excluding stock-based compensation expenses. +Stock-based compensation expenses will recur in future periods. + +• Amortization of intangible assets: We have excluded the effect of amortization of intangible assets from our non-GAAP operating +expenses and net income measures. Amortization of intangible assets is inconsistent in amount and frequency and is significantly +affected by the timing and size of our acquisitions. Investors should note that the use of intangible assets contributed to our revenues +earned during the periods presented and will contribute to our future period revenues as well. Amortization of intangible assets will recur +in future periods. + +• Acquisition related and other expenses; and restructuring expenses: We have excluded the effect of acquisition related and other +expenses and the effect of restructuring expenses from our non-GAAP operating expenses and net income measures. We incurred +significant expenses in connection with our acquisitions and also incurred certain other operating expenses or income, which we +generally would not have otherwise incurred in the periods presented as a part of our continuing operations. Acquisition related and other +expenses consist of personnel related costs for transitional employees, other acquired employee related costs, stock-based compensation +expenses (in addition to the stock-based compensation expenses described above), integration related professional services, certain +business combination adjustments including adjustments after the measurement period has ended and certain other operating items, net. +Substantially all of the stock-based compensation expenses included in acquisition related and other expenses resulted from unvested +options assumed in acquisitions whose vesting was fully accelerated upon termination of the employees pursuant to the original terms of +those options. Restructuring expenses consist of employee severance and other exit costs. We believe it is useful for investors to +understand the effects of these items on our total operating expenses. Although acquisition related expenses and restructuring expenses +generally diminish over time with respect to past acquisitions, we generally will incur these expenses in connection with any future +acquisitions. + +8 diff --git a/q253/random_k2/question.json b/q253/random_k2/question.json index d9ecd81e245d1d96367d4c2e8e26bed4dd887a4c..0e5d8c1c3668ccbbe15baf361c3e432c0641cfb6 100644 --- a/q253/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q253/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ADOBE_2015_10K.pdf", - "0a89b981c2736e87bac48a090e1a3e60dd8a4e0f.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf" + "web_d3b2a69cee942fe5.pdf", + "web_0047db342bad4270.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q253/random_k2/random_1.md b/q253/random_k2/random_1.md index 16de3e3316b1e3bb316b878e17b05640d996b000..c906bff4a2b28ca8e5a69ef8758f9182d084ead4 100644 --- a/q253/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q253/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1070 +1,1633 @@ -SPD-RAG: Sub-Agent Per Document Retrieval-Augmented Generation -| | YagizCanAkay1 | | | MuhammedYusufKartal1 | | | EsraAlparslan1 | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | FarukOrtakoyluoglu1 | | ArdaAkpinar2 | | | | | | | -1TOBBUniversityofEconomicsandTechnology 2OSTIMTechnicalUniversity -{y.akay, m.kartal, ealparslan, fortakoyluoglu}@etu.edu.tr 230206003@ostimteknik.edu.tr -| | | Abstract | | | andcommon,yetexposecriticalcoverageandrea- | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -soningbottlenecksincurrentNLPsystems. -Answeringcomplex,real-worldqueriesoften -6202 raM 9 ]LC.sc[ 1v92380.3062:viXra Traditionalsingle-indexorsingle-agentretrieval -requiressynthesizingfactsscatteredacrossvast -| | | | | | systemsstruggleto | | maintainbothscalability | | | | and | -| -------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | corpora. | In these | settings, | stan- | | | | | | | | -contextualrelevanceoverlarge,heterogeneouscor- -| dard retrieval-augmented | | | generation | (RAG) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | pora, especially | | for long | or structurally | | complex | | -pipelinessufferfromincompleteevidencecov- -erage,whilelong-contextlargelanguagemod- documents. Standard RAG pipelines retrieve a -| | | | | | fixed number | | of documents | K | and process | | them | -| ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -| els (LLMs) | struggle | to reason | reliably | over | | | | | | | | -massive inputs. We introduce SPD-RAG, a withinasinglecontextwindow(Lewisetal.,2020), -hierarchicalmulti-agentframeworkforexhaus- -whichfailswhenanswersdependoninformation -tivecross-documentquestionansweringthatde- -distributedacrossmanydocuments,sinceevidence -composestheproblemalongthedocumentaxis. -| | | | | | beyondthetop-K | | resultsistypicallydiscardedin | | | | | -| ---- | -------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ----------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --- | -| Each | document | is processed | by a | dedicated | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | a single | retrieval | pass. | Long-context | | LLMs | ex- | -document-levelagentoperatingonlyonitsown -content,enablingfocusedretrieval,whileaco- tendcontextwindowsto128K–2Mtokens(Gemini -| | | | | | Teametal.,2024), | | butempiricalevidenceshows | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ordinator | dispatches | tasks | to relevant | agents | | | | | | | | -and aggregates their partial answers. Agent thatreasoningqualitydegradessignificantlyascon- -outputsaresynthesizedbymergingpartialan- text length increases (Liu et al., 2023). This sug- -swersthroughatoken-boundedsynthesislayer -| | | | | | gests that | the | bottleneck | is not | only | retrieval, | but | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | -(whichsupportsrecursivemap-reduceformas- -alsoreasoningatscaleovermanydocumentsand -| sivecorpora). | | Thisdocument-levelspecializa- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -hundredsofthousandsoftokens. -tionwithcentralizedfusionimprovesscalabil- -ityandanswerqualityinheterogeneousmulti- In this work, we introduce SPD-RAG -| | | | | | (Sub-agent | per | Document | Retrieval-Augmented | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | settings | while | yielding | a modular, | | | | | | | | -extensibleretrievalpipeline. OntheLOONG Generation),ahierarchicalmulti-agentarchitecture -benchmark (EMNLP 2024) for long-context forexhaustivemulti-documentquestionanswering -multi-document QA, SPD-RAG achieves an thatfactorstheproblemalongthedocumentaxis -AvgScoreof58.1(GPT-5evaluation),outper- -| | | | | | rather than | the | task axis. | Instead | | of forcing | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -formingNormalRAG(33.0)andAgenticRAG -| | | | | | single model | | to hunt through | | a massive | | global | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -(32.8)whileusingonly38%oftheAPIcostof -| | | | | | index, SPD-RAG | | uses | a central | coordinator | | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -afull-contextbaseline(68.0). -| | | | | | decompose | the | user’s | query into | shared | instruc- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -1 Introduction tions. It then deploys a dedicated, cost-efficient -| | | | | | sub-agenttoeachdocumentinthecorpus. | | | | | | These | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -Large language models (LLMs) and the agentic agents operate entirely in parallel, treating their -systems built around them are increasingly used assigneddocumentsasisolatedretrievaluniverses -forcomplexinformationsearchtasks(Guoetal., -| | | | | | to extract | relevant | findings. | Finally, | | a synthesis | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -2024). Real-worldquestionsoftenrequiresynthe- -| | | | | | model | aggregates | these | document-grounded | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -sizingevidencescatteredacrossmanydocuments, findings—employingarecursivemergingfallback -suchasassessingacompany’sfinancialrisksacross -| | | | | | for exceptionally | | large | corpora—to | | construct | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | -yearsofreportsorintegratingfindingsfrommul- -| | | | | | comprehensive, | | final answer. | | Our codebase | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | -tiplescientificpapers.1 -| | | Suchquestionsarenatural | | | datasetsusedinthispapercanbefoundat | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -https://github.com/NebulAICompany/ -| 1Examples | inspired | by scenarios | in the | Loong bench- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| mark(Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | | SPD-RAG. | | | | | | | - -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: tasks,butthatmulti-agentoverheadgrowssuperlin- -early. Theirresultthatindependentagentsamplify -• WeproposeSPD-RAG,ahierarchicalmulti- -errorsby17.2×comparedto4.4×forcentralized -agentframeworkthatcombinesper-document -systemsdirectlymotivatesourcoordinator-based -agentic RAG with a centralized synthesis design. Thetaxonomyofhierarchicalmulti-agent -layer, where cost-efficient document agents systemsbyMoore(2025)furtherclassifiesdesign -| are coordinated | by a | smarter coordinator | | | | | | | -| --------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | patternsalongfiveaxes: | | controlhierarchy,informa- | | | -agent,enablingdocument-levelspecialization -| | | | | tion flow, | role delegation, | temporal | layering, | and | -| ----------------- | -------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| and parallel | execution | while allowing | each | communicationstructure. | | | | | -| document | to be analyzed | in depth | to ensure | | | | | | -| that all relevant | information | is incorporated | | | | | | | -2.2 LongDocumentandMulti-DocumentQA -withoutmissingcriticalevidence. -| | | | | Long documents | that | exceed | LLM context | win- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -• WeevaluateontheLoongbenchmark(Wang -| | | | | dows are | often handled | via | divide-and-conquer | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -etal.,2024a),whichincludesmulti-document -| | | | | strategies. | LLM×MapReduce(Zhouetal.,2025) | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| QA instances | over financial | reports | and aca- | | | | | | -| | | | | formalizestwokeychallenges: | | | inter-chunkdepen- | | -| demic papers | with an | average of | 11 docu- | | | | | | -dency(onechunkdependsoncontextfromanother) -mentsperinstanceandcontextlengthsfrom -andinter-chunkconflict(chunksprovidecontradic- -| 10K to beyond | 250K | tokens, and | show that | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -toryinformation),andproposesstructuredinforma- -oursystemsubstantiallyoutperformsstandard -tionprotocolsandin-contextconfidencecalibration -RAGandAgenticRAGbaselinesunderGPT- -| | | | | tomitigatethem. | ToM(Guoetal.,2025)extends | | | | -| -------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | --------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | -| 5-judged | Avg Score (adapted | from | Loong’s | | | | | | -| | | | | this approach | with a | hierarchical | DocTree | repre- | -GPT-4-judgedprotocol;see§4.3),withgains -sentationforrecursivereasoning. -| of around | +25 points | (76% higher | average | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Formulti-documentQA,LongAgent(Zhaoetal., -score)comparedtoNormalRAGandAgentic -| | | | | 2024) splits | a 128K-token | document | | into chunks | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | -RAGbaselines. -| | | | | assigned | to member | agents, with | a leader | agent | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ----- | -| | | | | orchestrating | discussionsand | | inter-membercom- | | -• Weanalyzeablations,documenttypeandtask -complexityeffects,andcost–qualitytradeoffs, munication to reduce hallucinations. However, -showingthat SPD-RAGattainsover85%of LongAgenttargetsasinglelongdocumentrather -thanmultipleindependentdocumentsthatmaycon- -| full-context | baseline quality | at roughly | 38% | | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | flict. DocAgent | (Sun | et al., 2025) | uses | a multi- | -oftheAPIcost. -| | | | | agent framework | that | mimics | human | reading via | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | -2 RelatedWork -atree-structuredoutlineandrevieweragent,while -| | | | | MDocAgent | (Han et | al., 2025) | employs | five spe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | -2.1 LLM-BasedMulti-AgentSystems -| | | | | cialized | agents for multi-modal | | document | under- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -LLM-basedmulti-agentsystemsareincreasingly -standing. -| used for complex | task solving. | Guo et | al. (2024) | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -provideacomprehensivesurveyofagentprofiles, -2.3 HierarchicalandRecursive -communicationprotocols,andcollaborationstrate- -Summarization -| gies. Hierarchical | architectures | such | as MegaA- | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -gent(Wangetal.,2024b),whichdemonstratesau- Ourhierarchicalmergingmechanismbuildsontree- -tonomouscooperationamongupto590agentsvia basedretrievalandrecursivesummarization. RAP- -multi-leveltaskdecomposition,andAgentOrches- TOR(Sarthietal.,2024)recursivelyembeds,clus- -tra(Zhangetal.,2025),whichachievesstate-of-the- ters, and summarizes text chunks to construct a -artperformanceonGAIAusingacentralplanning bottom-uptreewithmultipleabstractionlevels;re- -agent and specialized sub-agents, exemplify this trievingfromtheappropriatelevelyieldsa20%ab- -| trend. | | | | soluteaccuracygainonQuALITY.OuandLapata | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Scalinglawsformulti-agentsystemsofferquan- (2025)showthathierarchicalmergingcanamplify -titativeguidanceforarchitecturedesign. Kimetal. hallucinationsduringrecursivesummarizationand -(2025)evaluate180configurationsacrossfivear- proposecontext-awareaugmentationstrategiesthat -chitectures, finding that centralized coordination replaceintermediatesummarieswithrelevantinput -yields an 80.9% improvement on parallelizable context,whichweadoptinourmergingprotocol. - -2.4 Graph-BasedDocumentAnalysis 3 Methodology -Figure 1 presents an overview of the SPD-RAG -Graph-based document analysis is particu- -architecture. Thesystemprocessesaquerythrough -larly effective for global sensemaking queries. -three layers: the Coordination Layer (§3.1), the -GraphRAG(Edgeetal.,2024)constructsaknowl- -ParallelRetrievalLayer(§3.2),andtheSynthesis -edge graph of entities and relations from source -Layer(§3.3). -documents and applies hierarchical community -detection(e.g.,theLeidenalgorithm(Traagetal., -3.1 CoordinationLayer -2019)) to obtain multi-level communities with -Given a query q and corpus D, the system first -textual summaries. At query time, it retrieves -processes the query through a coordinator agent. -relevant communities, elicits community-level -The coordinator’s role is to decompose the user -partial answers, and aggregates them via a -query into a Shared Instruction Set for Docu- -map–reduce–styleprocedure. AsurveyonLLM- -ments and Synthesis Directives. It generates a -empoweredknowledgegraphconstruction(Bian, -WriteTodosstructuredobjectcontaining(a)alist -2025) highlights how LLMs are reshaping the -of sub_agent_todos: atomic, self-contained ex- -classical knowledge graph pipeline across three -traction tasks specifying exactly what fields, en- -key stages: ontology engineering, knowledge -tities, or numeric values to extract (the shared in- -extraction, and knowledge fusion. Our work is -structions);and(b)asynthesis_directive(2–4 -complementary: instead of inducing an explicit -sentences) instructing the downstream Synthesis -knowledge graph, SPD-RAG operates directly -Layeronhowtoprioritizeandstructurethemerged -over agent-produced textual summaries and -response. -performs similarity-guided recursive synthesis -acrossmanydocuments. 3.2 ParallelRetrievalLayer -Weassignadedicatedsub-agentα toeachdocu- -i -mentd inthecorpus. Eachsub-agentoperatesas -2.5 BenchmarksforMulti-Document i -anindependentRAGloopoveritsassigneddocu- -Reasoning -ment,guidedbythesharedinstructionsetfromthe -The Loong benchmark (Wang et al., 2024a) CoordinationLayer. -evaluates long-context LLMs on extended multi- -Document-Scoped Retrieval and Reasoning. -document QA where every document is relevant -Each document d serves as an isolated retrieval -i -("Leave No Document Behind") across financial, -universe; the assigned sub-agent is strictly con- -legal, and academic domains in English and Chi- -strainedtosearchtoolcallswithind , preventing -i -nese. Itspansfourtasktypeswithcontextlengths -cross-documentdistractorchunksfromdegrading -from 10K to over 250K tokens, and even strong -local extraction. Each sub-agent receives the -frontier models achieve only modest Avg Scores -originalqueryq,itsassigneddocumentname,and -andmediumperfect-answerrates,underscoringthe -thesharedinstructionset(todolist),thenoperates -difficultyofreasoningovermanylong,all-relevant -in an iterative retrieve-and-reason loop. On each -documents. -turn, the agent either issues a search action (a -Complementarydatasetsprobeotheraspectsof focused query string) or a finalize action that -multi-document reasoning. MoNaCo (Wolfson terminates the loop and emits the document- -et al., 2025) focuses on natural questions over groundedfindings. Thesub-agentpromptinstructs -dozensofWikipediapages,MEBench(Linetal., the agent to attempt at least 2 focused searches -2025)onhigh-entity-densityQA,FanOutQA(Zhu before concluding a piece of information is -et al., 2024) on multi-hop questions with absent, with a total cap of 5 search calls across -long cross-document evidence chains, and all tasks. Each search action triggers dense -HoloBench (Maekawa et al., 2024) on database- vector retrieval over the sub-agent’s dedicated -style aggregation over unstructured text. Taken per-documentQdrantindex. ThisretrievalusesCo- -together, these benchmarks show that scalable hereembed-v4.0embeddings(1536-dimensional, -multi-document reasoning remains an open cosine similarity) to fetch the top k = 15 most -challenge,withLoongemphasizingtheespecially similar chunks. These chunks are then re-ranked -demandingall-relevant,long-contextregime. byCoherererank-v4.0-fasttoyieldafinalset - -| | | | | Figure1: | OverviewofSPD-RAGArchitecture. | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of top_n = 5 chunks per search. The documents Similarity-Ordered Merge & Synthesis. -t, -are split into chunks offline using LangChain’s In iteration we maintain a set of find- -RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter in Mark- ings/summaries S(t) = {s (t) ,...,s (t) }. We -| | | | | | | | | | | | 1 | n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downmodewithachunksizeof1000tokensand embed each summary using Cohere embed-v4.0 -| 250-tokenoverlap. | | | | | | | and compute | | a cosine-similarity | | | matrix | via | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -sklearn.metrics.pairwise.cosine_similarity. -| FindingsOutput. | | | Wedenotethefindingsofeach | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | This | is converted | | to a | distance | matrix | | -sub-agentas -| | | | | | | | | | | (t) (t) | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | D = | 1 − | cos(s | ,s ), | which | is passed | to | -| | | | | | | | ij | | | i j | | | | -o = α (q,d ) = ⟨s ,r ⟩ (1) AgglomerativeClustering with n_clusters=1, -| | | i | i i | i | i | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | linkage="average" | | | (UPGMA), | | producing | a | -| where | s is | the natural | | language | findings | re- | | | | | | | | -i -completedendrogramoverallcurrentsummaries. -| port from | d | and | r ∈ | [0,1] is | a scalar | rele- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | -| | i | | i | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | We traverse | the | merge | tree | bottom-up, | greedily | | -| vance/confidencescore. | | | Theseoutputsarepassed | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | accumulating | | nodes | into a batch | as | long as | the | -totheSynthesisLayer. -| | | | | | | | total tiktoken | | count | does not | exceed | the target | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | -| Parallelism. | | All | RAG | loops for | the | docu- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | budget | of B | = 750,000 | tokens. | | Semantically | | -ments are dispatched concurrently via Lang- similarsummariesaregroupedfirst,soeachbatch -Graph’s Send API fan-out, which emits one contains the most similar available summaries -| Send("document_sub_agent_node", | | | | | ...) | per | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withinthetokenlimit. -documentandexecutesalltargetsinparallelwithin -LangGraph’sasyncruntime. AggregateandSynthesizeFindings. Foreach -batch,anLLMispromptedwiththeconcatenated -3.3 SynthesisLayer -| | | | | | | | findings, | the synthesis | | directive, | and | the original | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -WhilemodernLLMsfeatureextensivecontextwin- queryq toproduceanaggregatedandsynthesized -dows,synthesizinghundredsofdocumentreports -| | | | | | | | summary. | Allbatchsynthesiscallswithinanitera- | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -can still exceed these limits or cause ’lost in the tionareissuedconcurrentlyviaasyncio.gather. -middle’degradation. Tofuture-proofthearchitec- Themergedsummariesformtheinputforthenext -| ture for | massive | corpora, | | the Synthesis | Layer | is | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | iteration | S(t+1). | The | same | SYNTHESIS | prompt | | -designedasadynamicmap-reducepipelinethatag- -| | | | | | | | used at | every | level | of the | merging | tree is | ap- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | -gregatesfindingsrecursively. TheSynthesisLayer plied even at the final level—there is no separate -receives the synthesis directives from the Coor- synthesis-onlyprompt. -| dination | Layer | and | the findings | {o | ,o ,...,o | } | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 1 2 | n | | | | | | | | -from the Parallel Retrieval Layer. It aggregates ContextSizeConditionandOutput. Thelayer -andsynthesizesthefindingsrecursivelythrougha evaluates whether the total findings size exceeds -similarity-orderedprocessuntilthetotalfindings the context size threshold (i.e., |S(t+1)| > 1). If -sizefallswithinthetargetcontextsizetoproduce theconditionistrue,theprocessloopsbacktothe -thefinaloutput. similarity-orderedmergeandsynthesisstep. Ifthe - -Algorithm1RecursiveSynthesis Locating, Comparison, Clustering, or Chain of -Reasoning,withcontextlengthsrangingfrom10K -| Require: | FindingsS | = {s ,...,s | },queryq, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | 1 | n | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | to beyond | 250K | tokens. | | We evaluate | | on the En- | -synthesisdirectived,contextsizebudgetB -Ensure: FinalOutputs⋆ glishandSet4(200k-250ktokens)portionofthe -| | | | | | benchmarkonly. | | Ourevaluationsetcomprises40 | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1: while|S| | > 1do | | | | | | | | | | | -instancesinvolvingacademicpapersand62involv- -| 2: E | ← COHEREEMBED(S) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -D ← 1−COSINESIMILARITY(E) ingfinancialreports(102instancestotal),withthe -3: -tree ← AGGLOMERATIVECLUSTER( fourtasktypesdistributedas: SpotlightLocating -4: -(27),Comparison(15),Clustering(49),andChain -| | D, linkage | = “average”) | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofReasoning(11). -| 5: batches | ← | GROUPBYTOKENS( | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | S, tree, | B) | | | | | | | | | | -4.2 Baselines -| 6: if|batches| | | ≥ |S|then | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | We compare | | against | the | following | systems, | all | -| 7: | batches ← | [S] | | | | | | | | | | -| endif | | | | | backedbyGemini2.5Pro: | | | | | | | -8: -| 9: S | ← ASYNCGATHER( | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | • Baseline(FullContext): | | | | | Alldocumentsfor | | -| | SYNTHESIZE(b,q,d)∀b | | ∈ | batches) | | | | | | | | -eachinstanceareconcatenatedandprovided -10: endwhile -directlyinthecontextwindowofGemini2.5 -| return | S[0] | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -11: -Pro,representingtheoraclelong-contextup- -perbound. -conditionisfalse(thetotalfindingssizeiswithin -• NormalRAG:Standardvectorsearchtop-K -thecontextsize,leavingasinglefinalsummarys⋆), -| | | | | | retrieval | | over | the full | document | | corpus, fol- | -| ----------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | -| the process | terminates | and yields | s⋆ | as the final | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | lowed | by | LLM | reasoning | | over the | retrieved | -| | If|S(t+1)| | |S(t)|(no-progresscase),the | | | | | | | | | | -| output. | | ≥ | | | | | | | | | | -chunks. -entirecurrentlevelisforcedintoasinglebatchto -guaranteetermination. -| | | | | | • Agentic | | RAG: | A single-agent | | ReAct-style | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -Algorithm1givesthepseudocodeforthegeneral RAG system (implemented via Lang- -recursivesynthesisprocedure. Graph/LangChain) that can issue multiple -| | | | | | iterative | | retrieval | calls | over | the | full global | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| BehavioronLoong. | | Inpractice,withGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | -Pro’s 1M-token context window and a budget of corpus. It uses the same embedding and -| | | | | | re-rankingpipelineas | | | | SPD-RAG,butlacks | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -B = 750,000tokens,thecombinedsub-agentfind- -per-documentspecialization. -ingsforallinstancesinourLoongevaluationsetfit -withinasinglebatch,sotheconditionalcheckal- -4.3 EvaluationMetrics -| lowedoutputafteroneiteration. | | | Therecursiveloop | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | We report | the | following | | metrics, | following | the | -isthereforeadesigncapabilityintendedformuch -Loongevaluationprotocol(Wangetal.,2024a): -largercorpora,wheretotalfindingssizegenuinely -exceedsthecontextsize. -| | | | | | • Avg | Score: | An | LLM-judged | | score | (0–100) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -measuringthedegreetowhichthepredicted -4 ExperimentalSetup -| | | | | | answer | | accurately | covers | | the gold | answer, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | -4.1 Dataset -| | | | | | following | | the | evaluation | protocol | | of Loong | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | (Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | 2 | | | -WeevaluateSPD-RAGontheLoongbenchmark -| (Wangetal.,2024a). | | Loongisanextendedmulti- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------ | ----------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | • PerfectRate(PR%): | | | | Percentageofqueries | | | -| document | QA instances | in both | English | and Chi- | | | | | | | | -wherethesystemreceivesaperfectscoreof -| nese, with | an average | of 11 documents | | per test | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -100. -| casespanningtworeal-worldscenarios: | | | | financial | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -reports and academic papers. Each test case is 2BecausetheoriginallegacyGPT-4modelAPIisunavail- -ablefornewscaledevaluations,weadoptGPT-5astheeval- -constructedsothateverydocumentisrelevantto -| | | | | | uator. Recent | literature | | increasingly | | adopts | GPT-5 as the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------------ | -the final answer ("Leave No Document Behind", standard for LLM-as-a-judge protocols due to its superior -meaningacorrectresponserequiressynthesizing alignmentwithhumangrading(Wolfsonetal.,2025).While -ourbaselinenumbersarere-computedunderthisGPT-5judge -evidencefromallprovideddocuments),andisan- -forstrictfairness,rawscoresmaynotbeperfectly1-to-1com- -notated under one of four task types: Spotlight parablewiththeoriginallypublishedLoongleaderboard. - -• AvgTokenUsage: Meanper-querytotal(in- Cost tracking. Per-query costs are computed -put+output)tokenusage. fromLangSmithrunmetadata(totaltokencounts -×per-tokenpricing. -| • Avg | Cost | (USD): | Mean | per-query | | API cost, | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| enablingcost-efficiencycomparisons. | | | | | | | 5 Results | | | | | | -5.1 MainResults -| • AvgLatency(s): | | | Meanper-querywall-clock | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time. -Table1reportsthemainresultsacrossallsystems -| | | | | | | | on our Loong | evaluation | | set. | Figure | 2 illustrates | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | -4.4 ImplementationDetails -theseperformancedifferencesacrossthefourspe- -| AllsystemsuseGemini2.5Pro(temperature0.0) | | | | | | | cifictasktypes. | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -asthebackboneLLMforthecoordinator,merging SPD-RAGachievesanAvgScoreof58.1,sub- -| layer, and | synthesis | | layer. | SPD-RAG | | document | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stantiallyoutperformingbothNormalRAG(33.0) -| sub-agents | use | Gemini | 2.5 | Flash | for | document- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | and Agentic | RAG | (32.8). | | This corresponds | to | -scopedretrieval,reducingper-documentcostwhile roughly a 25-point absolute improvement (about -preserving reasoning quality at the merging and 76% relative gain) over standard RAG baselines. -| synthesisstages. | | GPT-5isusedexclusivelyasthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | Furthermore, | SPD-RAG | | more | than | doubles the | -LLMjudgefortheevaluationoftheAvgscoreand Perfect Rate (PR) of Agentic RAG (18.6% vs. -is not part of the pipeline itself. Prompts for all 8.8%),indicatingthatexhaustivedocument-level -| systems, | including | baselines, | | were | optimized | for | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -processingmorefrequentlycapturesthecomplete -informationextractionandsynthesistoensurefair set of required facts. Notably, the Agentic RAG -comparison. Fullprompttemplatesforallsystems baseline,despiteconsuming∼3×moretokensthan -areprovidedinthecoderepository. NormalRAG,doesnotyieldscoreimprovements, -suggestingthatuninstructediterativeretrievalwith- -| Indexing. | Each | | document | | is | pre- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | out per-document | | specialization | | does | not effec- | -| indexed | into | a | dedicated | | Qdrant | vec- | | | | | | | -tivelyaddressthecoveragechallengeinexhaustive -| tor | collection | | using | | LangChain’s | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | multi-document | | settings. | While | the | full-context | -| RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter | | | | | | (Imple- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | baseline | attains | the highest | | quality with | an Avg | -mentationdetailsareprovidedintheAppendix.). -| | | | | | | | Score of | 68.0, | SPD-RAG | reaches | 85.4% | of this | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | -Retrievalpersub-agent. Eachsearchtoolcall performancewhileconsumingonly37.9%ofthe -performs dense vector retrieval over the docu- API cost, demonstrating a highly favorable cost- -| | | | | | | | quality trade-off. | | The | full-context | baseline | pro- | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | -| mentindex,returningthetop-K | | | | | (k = 15)chunks | | | | | | | | -using cosine similarity in Qdrant. These can- vides a strong upper bound that benefits from all -didates are subsequently re-ranked with Cohere documents in one pass. Despite this, SPD-RAG -narrowsthegapto9.9pointswhilecostingless. -| rerank-v4.0-fast,andthetoptop_n | | | | | = | 5chunks | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -arepassedtothesub-agentLLM. -5.2 AnalysisbyTaskType -| Merging | layer. | The | token | budget | | per merge | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Table2breaksdownperformancebyLoong’sfour -| batchisB | = 750,000tokens(75%ofGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tasktypes. -| Pro’s1Mcontextcap). | | | Agglomerativeclustering | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thetask-typebreakdownrevealsaclearpattern. -usessklearnwithUPGMAlinkageandprecom- -| | | | | | | | For Spotlight | Locating—which | | | requires | finding | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -putedcosine-distancematrix. -asinglesalientfactacrossdocuments—allRAG- -| | | | | | | | based systems | | perform | reasonably | well | (69–74), | -| ------------- | --------------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | -| Parallelism. | | Documentagentsrunconcurrently | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | while the | full-context | | baseline | leads | (86.6). The | -| via LangGraph | | Send | API | fan-out. | Batch | synthe- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | largest gaps | between | | SPD-RAG | and | the RAG | -| sis calls | within | each | merge | iteration | | are paral- | | | | | | | -| | asyncio.gather. | | | | | | baselinesappearinClustering(+40.5ptsoverNor- | | | | | | -| lelized | with | | | | Synchronous | Co- | | | | | | | -malRAG)andChainofReasoning(+26.2ptsover -hereAPIcallsareoffloadedtothethreadpoolvia -| | | | | | | | Agentic RAG), | | tasks | that require | aggregating | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -asyncio.to_thread. -reasoningoverevidencefrommanydocumentssi- -Safety limits. Each document sub-agent’s iter- multaneously. Ontheotherhand,itnearlymatches -ative retrieval loop is capped at 5 iterations; the the full-context baseline (42.2 vs. 42.7) on Com- -| AgenticRAGbaselinecapsat10iterations. | | | | | | | parisontasks. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -System AvgScore PR(%) AvgInputTok AvgTotalTok AvgCost($) AvgLatency(s) -OracleLong-ContextBaseline -| Baseline(FullContext) | | 68.0 | 31.4 253,085 | 255,345 | 0.273 | 45.6 | -| --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -RAGBaselines -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 13.7 22,174 | 27,430 | 0.080 | 42.6 | -| ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 8.8 81,877 | 85,290 | 0.098 | 40.6 | -OurSystem -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 18.6 193,954 | 205,683 | 0.103 | 54.8 | -| ------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -Table1: MainresultsonourLoongevaluationset(102instances: 40academicpaper,62financialreport). Bold: -| bestoverall. | Underline: | bestamongRAG-basedsystems. | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2: ComparisonofAverageScoreacrossthefoursystems,brokendownbytasktype(SpotlightLocating, -Comparison,Clustering,andChainofReasoning). -5.3 AnalysisbyDocumentDomain -| As shown | in Table 3 | and Figure | 3 the domain | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -breakdownexposesastrikingfailuremodeofstan- -| dard RAG: | both Normal | RAG and | Agentic RAG | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -achieve0%PRonacademicpaperinstances(Avg -| Scoresof15.2and16.8,respectively). | | | Academic | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -paperinstancesinLoongtendtoinvolvelong,tech- -nicaldocumentswithdistributedevidence,making -top-K retrievalespeciallysusceptibletocoverage -failures. SPD-RAGdramaticallyrecoversonthis -domain(60.0AvgScore),closingmostofthegap -| with the | full-context | baseline (78.8). | On finan- | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3: Averagescorebydocumentdomaincompar- -cialreportinstances—whichtendtobeshorterand ingtheBaseline(FullContext),NormalRAG,Agentic -morestructured—allRAG-basedsystemsperform -RAG,andSPD-RAGsystems. -better,andthegapbetweenSPD-RAG(56.9)and -thebaseline(61.0)issmaller. - -| | System | | SpotlightLoc. | | Comparison | Clustering | ChainofReasoning | | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (n=27) | | (n=15) | (n=49) | | (n=11) | | | | -Baseline(FullContext) 86.6/55.6% 42.7/26.7% 67.1/14.3% 60.9/54.5% -| | NormalRAG | | 69.7/37.0% | | 37.7/26.7% | 15.4/0.0% | | 14.8/0.0% | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | AgenticRAG | | 73.4/22.2% | | 23.3/20.0% | 16.7/0.0% | | 17.9/0.0% | | | | -| | SPD-RAG | | 74.2/44.4% | | 42.2/20.0% | 57.2/4.1% | | 44.1/18.2% | | | | -Table2: AvgScore/PR(%)byLoongtasktype. EachcellshowsAvgScore/PR%. -| | | | | | Crucially, | thearchitectureof | | | SPD-RAG | | enables | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | -| System | | Paper(n=40) | Financial(n=62) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | this | cost efficiency: | | by constraining | | retrieval | to | -| Baseline | | 78.8/30.0% | 61.0/32.3% | | | | | | | | | -NormalRAG 15.2/0.0% 44.5/22.6% isolated,single-documentspaces,wecanreliably -| AgenticRAG | | 16.8/0.0% | 43.1/14.5% | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -offloadtheiterativereasoningtoacheapermodel -| SPD-RAG | | 60.0/7.5% | 56.9/25.8% | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | (Gemini | 2.5 Flash). | | In contrast, | | global | iterative | -baselinesrequirethereasoningcapacityofafron- -Table3: AvgScore/PR(%)bydocumentdomain. -| | | | | | tier | model (Gemini | 2.5 | Pro) | to navigate | | the fully | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -concatenatedcorpus,drivingupcosts. -| System | | AvgScore | AvgCost($) | Score/$ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | -| Baseline | | 68.0 | 0.273 | 249.1 | | | | | | | | -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 0.080 | 412.5 | 6 | Discussion | | | | | | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 0.098 | 334.7 | | | | | | | | -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 0.103 | 564.1 | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | WhereSPD-RAGexcels. | | | | Thetask-typeresults | | | -| | | | | | in Table | 2 confirm | our | core | hypothesis: | | architec- | -Table4: Cost–qualitytradeoff. -turaldecompositionalongthedocumentaxisyields -| | | | | | the largest | gains | precisely | | for tasks | that | require | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | | | exhaustive | multi-document | | | synthesis. | Clustering | | -5.4 Cost–QualityTradeoff -tasks(+40.5overNormalRAG)andChainofRea- -| | | | | | soning | tasks (+26.2 | over | Agentic | | RAG) | both de- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ---- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -mandthatthesystemformacoherentanswerfrom -evidencedistributedacrossallrelevantdocuments— -exactlythescenarioforwhichper-documentagents -| | | | | | aredesigned. | ForLoong’sComparisonquestions, | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -theanswerisprimarilydeterminedbyreadingout -asmallsetofcomparablenumericattributesfrom -| | | | | | each | report and | aggregating | | them, | so once | docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | ment | agents have | extracted | | those | fields, | the syn- | -| | | | | | thesizer | is effectively | | operating | over | a structured | | -table,whichhelpsexplainwhySPD-RAG’sscore -onComparisontasks(42.2)nearlymatchesthefull- -Figure4: Cost–Qualitytradeoff. Thescatterplotillus- contextbaseline(42.7). -tratestheParetofrontierformulti-documentQA. -| | | | | | Remaining | gap | with | the | full-context | | baseline. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -SPD-RAG outperforms the RAG baselines in Despite strong gains over RAG baselines, SPD- -the cost–quality trade-off. It achieves a 76% RAG lags the full-context baseline by 9.9 Avg -higheraveragescorethanNormalRAG(58.1vs. Score points overall. Three factors likely con- -33.0)whileincreasingtheper-querycostbyonly tribute: (1) Gemini 2.5 Flash, used for document -$0.023 (Table 4). In contrast, Agentic RAG is agents due to its cost efficiency, may provide -Pareto-dominated, as it incurs higher cost than weaker agentic reasoning capabilities compared -NormalRAG($0.098vs.$0.080)whiledelivering to larger models. (2) The coordinator’s sub-task -nearlyidenticalquality(32.8vs.33.0). Compared generation may under-specify queries for highly -tothefull-contextbaseline,whichachievesanAvg technical academic content, leading to incom- -Score of 68.0, SPD-RAG reaches 85.4% of the pleteinformationextractionatthedocument-agent -qualityatonly37.9%ofthecost, resultingina level. (3) The maximum context length observed -2.25× improvement in cost–quality efficiency. inLoongquerieswasapproximately250ktokens— - -onlyabout25%ofthe1M-tokencontextwindow onthecoordinator’sabilitytogeneratecomprehen- -of Gemini 2.5 Pro—potentially limiting the pres- sivesub-tasks: under-specifiedtasksleadtoincom- -sureonthefull-contextbaseline. SinceSPD-RAG plete document-level extractions, as observed on -isdesignedtooperateonsubstantiallylargercon- technicalacademicpaperinstances. Ourevaluation -texts,itsadvantagesmaybecomemorepronounced islimitedtotwodomains(academicpapersandfi- -undermoreextremelong-contextconditions. nancialreports)fromtheLoongbenchmark;legal, -medical,orenterprisedocumentcorporamayhave -| RAG baseline | | failure | on papers. | | The 0% | PR | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -differentstructuralcharacteristicsthatalterrelative -| rate and | 15.2-16.8% | | Avg Score | of | both Normal | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -performance. -| RAG and | Agentic | RAG | on | academic | paper | in- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ThesynthesislayerofSPD-RAGisdesignedto -top-K -| stances | highlights | a systematic | | failure | of | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -handlecorporawherethecombinedsub-agentout- -| retrieval | under | dense, | distributed | evidence. | | Aca- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -putsexceedthemodel’scontextwindow,triggering -| demic | papers | in Loong | often | require | synthesiz- | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -multi-roundsimilarity-basedclusteringandrecur- -ingfactsspreadacrossabstracts,methods,results, -| | | | | | | | sive synthesis. | | In our Loong | experiments, | | how- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | ---- | -andappendicesofmultipledocuments—aregime -ever,Gemini2.5Pro’s1M-tokencontextwassuffi- -| where exhaustive | | per-document | | coverage | proves | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -cienttoprocessallsub-agentsummariesinasingle -| highly | effective. | The | recovery | by SPD-RAG | | to | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | merge step, | so | this recursive | path | was | never acti- | -60.0AvgScore/7.5%PRinthisdomaindemon- -| | | | | | | | vated. Asaresult,thescalabilitypropertiesofthe | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stratesthepracticalvalueofper-documentspecial- -recursivesynthesispipeline—itsimpactonanswer -ization. -| | | | | | | | quality, | redundancy | reduction, | | and cost | as docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Latencyoverhead. SPD-RAG incursamodest mentcountsgrowintothehundredsorthousands— -latency overhead (54.8 s vs. 40.6–45.6 s for the remainempiricallyunvalidated. EvaluatingSPD- -| baselines), | primarily | | due to | its multi-agent | | archi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RAGonmuchlargercorpora,andideallyonanew -tecture. Although document agents run in paral- benchmarkspecificallytargetinghundredstothou- -lel,end-to-endlatencyisstillgatedbythelayered sands of documents per query instance, is an im- -pipeline, which requires at least three sequential portantdirectionforfutureworkthatwouldmore -LLM calls (coordination, per-document retrieval, directlytesttheper-documentagentdesignandthe -andsynthesis)ratherthanasinglepass. intendedlarge-databaseregime. -| | | | | | | | 8 Conclusion | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | We presented | | SPD-RAG, | a hierarchical | | multi- | -| | | | | | | | agent framework | | designed | for | exhaustive | multi- | -| | | | | | | | documentquestionanswering. | | | Byassigningaded- | | | -icatedagenticRAGmoduletoeachdocumentand -mergingtheirfindingsthroughasimilarity-ordered, -| | | | | | | | token-bounded | | tree, our | system | effectively | miti- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | gatesthelimitationsofbothtraditionaltop-K | | | | | re- | -| | | | | | | | trieval (incomplete | | coverage) | and | isolated | long- | -| | | | | | | | context | processing | (degraded | reasoning | | at scale). | -Figure5: Averageper-querylatencyacrosssystems. ExperimentsonthechallengingLoongbenchmark -demonstratethatSPD-RAGachievesanaverage -scoreof58.1,outperformingNormalRAG(33.0) -7 LimitationsandFutureWork -andAgenticRAG(32.8)byapproximately25ab- -SPD-RAG incurs higher per-query LLM call solute points (76% higher average score), while -countsthansingle-passsystems—onecallperdoc- operating at only 37.9% of the API cost of the -ument agent plus a final synthesis step—which oracle full-context baseline (68.0). These per- -increasestotaltokenusagecomparedtostandard formance gains are most pronounced in tasks re- -RAGbaselines,thoughitremainsatroughlyone- quiring deep cross-document synthesis—such as -thirdthecostofthefull-contextbaseline($0.10vs. Clustering(+40.5points)andChainofReasoning -$0.27perquery)duetotheuseofGemini2.5Flash (+26.2points)—aswellasondenseacademicpa- -fordocumentsub-agents. Systemqualitydepends perswherestandardRAGmethodsentirelyfail. - -Ultimately, our findings demonstrate that for TaichengGuo,XiuyingChen,YaqiWang,RuidiChang, -complex information-seeking queries over large ShichaoPei,NiteshV.Chawla,OlafWiest,andXi- -| | | | | | | | angliangZhang.2024. | | | Largelanguagemodel-based | | | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| corpora, | how | information | | is processed | is | crucial. | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | multi-agents: | | Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. | | | | -Specifically,ensuringthateachdocumentreceives -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2402.01680. | | | ArXiv:2402.01680. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -exhaustive,dedicatedagenticattentionprovestobe -| | | | | | | | Siwei Han, | Peng | Xia, Ruiyi | Zhang, | Tong | Sun, Yun | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------- | -amoreeffective,cost-efficient,andscalablestrat- -| | | | | | | | Li, Hongtu | Zhu, | and | Huaxiu Yao. | 2025. | MDocA- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | -egythansimplyexpandinghowmuchrawcontext -gent: Amulti-modalmulti-agentframeworkfordoc- -asinglemodelcanconsumeinonepass. umentunderstanding. Preprint,arXiv:2503.13964. -ArXiv:2503.13964. -9 EthicsStatement -| | | | | | | | Yubin Kim, | Ken | Gu, Chanwoo | Park, | Chunjong | Park, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -SPD-RAG is a retrieval-augmented generation SamuelSchmidgall,A.AliHeydari,YaoYan,Zhi- -hanZhang,YuchenZhuang,MarkMalhotra,PaulPu -| framework | intended | | to improve | access | | to infor- | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liang,HaeWonPark,YuzheYang,XuhaiXu,Yilun -| mation | distributed | across | | large document | | collec- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Du, Shwetak | | Patel, Tim | Althoff, | Daniel | McDuff, | -tions. ThesystemreliesoncommercialLLMAPIs and Xin Liu. 2025. Towards a science of scal- -(Gemini2.5,Cohere),andaswithanyLLM-based ing agent systems. Preprint, arXiv:2512.08296. -ArXiv:2512.08296. -| pipeline, | outputs | may | contain | factual | errors | and | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -should not be treated as authoritative without hu- PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio -man verification. The increased number of API Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- -| | | | | | | | richKüttler, | | MikeLewis, | Wen-tauYih, | | TimRock- | -| --------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | -| calls per | query | relative | to | single-pass | systems | re- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | täschel, | Sebastian | Riedel, | and | Douwe | Kiela. 2020. | -| sults in | higher | energy | consumption, | | a | cost that | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Retrieval-augmented | | | generation | for | knowledge- | -should be weighed against the accuracy gains in intensiveNLPtasks. InAdvancesinNeuralInforma- -deploymentdecisions. Ourbenchmarkevaluations tionProcessingSystems. -| are conducted | | on publicly | | available | datasets | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | TengLin, | YuyuLuo, | HonglinZhang, | | JichengZhang, | | -involvenohumansubjectsorpersonaldata. Dur- Chunlin Liu, Kaishun Wu, and Nan Tang. 2025. -ingthepreparationofthismanuscript,AI-assisted MEBench: Benchmarkinglargelanguagemodelsfor -| | | | | | | | cross-documentmulti-entityquestionanswering. | | | | | In | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -writingtoolswereusedtohelprefinelanguageand -ProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethods -| improveclarity. | | Allresearchdesign,experiments, | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -inNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). -analysis,andfinaldecisionsregardingthecontent -NelsonF.Liu,KevinLin,JohnHewitt,AshwinParan- -wereconductedandverifiedbytheauthors. -jape,MicheleBevilacqua,FabioPetroni,andPercy -| | | | | | | | Liang.2023. | | Lostinthemiddle: | | Howlanguagemod- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | elsuselongcontexts. | | TransactionsoftheAssociation | | | | +This copy is for personal use only. To order printed copies, contact reprints@rsna.org + +1733 + +Fluoroscopic Swallowing Examination: +Radiologic Findings and Analysis of +Their Causes and Pathophysiologic +Mechanisms + +Alberto I. Carbo, MD +Melanie Brown, CCC-SLP +Nour Nakrour, MD + +Abbreviations: CP = cricopharyngeus, HLC = +hyolaryngeal complex, PES = pharyngoesopha­ +geal segment, UES = upper esophageal sphincter + +RadioGraphics 2021; 41:1733–1749 + +https://doi.org/10.1148/rg.2021210051 + +Content Codes: + +From the Departments of Radiology (A.I.C., +N.N.) and Rehabilitation Services (M.B.), Ochs­ +ner LSU Health, 1501 Kings Hwy, Shreveport, +LA 71103. Presented as an education exhibit +at the 2020 RSNA Annual Meeting. Received +March 7, 2021; revision requested April 19 and +received May 14; accepted May 23. For this jour­ +nal­based SA­CME activity, the authors, editor, +and reviewers have disclosed no relevant rela­ +tionships. Address correspondence to A.I.C. +(e­mail: acarbo1396@gmail.com). + +©RSNA, 2021 + +SA-CME LEARNING OBJECTIVES + +After completing this journal-based SA-CME +activity, participants will be able to: + „Discuss the anatomy and imaging +phases of swallowing. + + „Describe abnormalities detected at +fluoroscopic swallowing examination. + + „Correlate the radiologic findings +with their causes and pathophysiologic +mechanisms. + +See rsna.org/learning-center-rg. + +Dysphagia is a common symptom in the general population, and its +prevalence increases with patient age. The deterioration of swallow­ +ing function has many acute and chronic causes, including cerebro­ +vascular and neuromuscular diseases, radiation, and surgery. In an +elderly population, diagnosis and treatment of swallowing abnor­ +malities is a high priority because it improves the patient’s quality +of life and helps them to avoid medical complications. Fluoroscopic +swallowing examinations and modified barium swallow studies are +the most used and most reliable diagnostic procedures to evaluate +swallowing disorders. Functional anomalies include disturbances +of the oral preparatory, oral propulsory, and pharyngeal phases +of swallowing as premature spillage from the mouth, nasal regur­ +gitation, delayed initiation of pharyngeal swallowing, incomplete +displacement of the hyolaryngeal complex, abnormal epiglottic +tilt, incomplete laryngeal closure, and pharyngeal dysmotilities. +Anatomic abnormalities of the pharynx include diverticula, be­ +nign strictures, and tumors. The abnormalities diagnosed on the +basis of fluoroscopic examination have a variety of treatment strat­ +egies, and the choice of treatment depends on the cause of the +anomaly and its pathophysiologic characteristics. The radiologist’s +interpretation of these characteristics is crucial to therapeutic de­ +cision making and achieving the best patient outcomes. + +Online supplemental material is available for this article. + +©RSNA, 2021 • radiographics.rsna.org + +Introduction +Oropharyngeal dysphagia is prevalent in 20% of the general popu­ +lation and in 50% of nursing home residents in the United States +(1). As the average age of the population continues to increase, +there has been an increase in dysphagia and related complications. +Fluoroscopically guided swallowing examinations are the most used +technique for evaluation of deglutition disorders. The examination is +called modified barium swallow when the diagnostic study includes a +therapeutic test; in those cases, it is performed with the participation +of a swallowing therapist or speech­language pathologist (2). + +Fluoroscopic examination of swallowing and modified barium +swallow should not be routine studies but should be custom­tailored +techniques designed by radiologists and swallowing therapists on +the basis of the patient’s clinical history and symptoms. Radiolo­ +gists should supervise or participate in the procedures and contrib­ +ute their knowledge to adapt the technique to unexpected findings +detected during examinations. They may decide during the study +to include the evaluation of organs such as the esophagus that may +explain or be associated with the patient’s symptoms. The radiologic + +GASTROINTESTINAL IMAGING + + 1734 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +TEACHING POINTS + „ Fluoroscopic examination of swallowing and modified barium +swallow should not be routine studies but should be custom- +tailored techniques designed by radiologists and swallowing +therapists on the basis of the patient’s clinical history and +symptoms. Radiologists should supervise or participate in the +procedures and contribute their knowledge to adapt the tech- +nique to unexpected findings detected during examinations. +They may decide during the study to include the evaluation of +organs such as the esophagus that may explain or be associ- +ated with the patient’s symptoms. + + „ For evaluation of the function of the PES, radiologists should +correlate the following functional units: (a) the opening of the +PES, (b) the elevation of the HLC, and (c) the pharyngeal con- +traction. Understanding the different possible mechanisms +that cause the abnormal function of the segment is essential +in deciding the best treatment strategies. + + „ As part of the fluoroscopic swallowing examination, a system- +atic evaluation of the air-filled structures and soft tissues of the +neck may provide information about the causative or associ- +ated abnormalities relating to the patient’s symptoms. + + „ The development of Zenker diverticula may involve anatomic +and pathophysiologic causes that include an area of wall +weakness, a distal obstruction due to the diminished opening +of the CP, and increased pharyngeal intraluminal pressure as a +consequence of mechanical obstruction of the outlet. + + „ The radiologic report should include all detected abnormali- +ties and should not be limited to description of the visualiza- +tion of penetration or aspiration. Because each abnormality +has its own specific therapeutic approach, the description +of radiologic findings and their correlation with the patho- +physiologic mechanisms and possible causes should be stated +clearly in the report. A meticulous radiologic diagnosis facili- +tates the decision making of referring physicians and swallow- +ing therapists. + +report should describe all the findings additional +to penetration or aspiration and present the facts +in a way that facilitates decision making by the +referring physicians and swallowing therapists. + +This article reviews the anatomy and physiol­ + +ogy of swallowing, explains the indications for +and techniques of fluoroscopic examination, +describes abnormal radiologic findings, and dis­ +cusses their pathophysiologic mechanisms. + +The discussion includes the abnormalities +of the pharyngoesophageal segment (PES) as +diminished or delayed opening and early clos­ +ing and the pathophysiology of the pharyngeal +residue after swallowing, penetration, and +aspiration. Complications of total laryngectomy +are examined, such as leakage, pseudoepiglot­ +tis, anterior pharyngeal pouches, neopharyngeal +dysmotilities, strictures, and malfunctioning +of the tracheoesophageal prosthesis for voice +reconstitution. We describe the radiologic find­ +ings of each abnormality and provide sample +images and a discussion of the possible mecha­ +nisms, with consideration of the patient’s clinical +history. + +Anatomy for Radiographic +Interpretation + +The oral cavity is bounded by the hard and soft +palates superiorly, by the tongue inferiorly, and +opens to the oropharynx posteriorly. The nasophar- +ynx or epipharynx is bounded by the pharyngeal +walls posteriorly and laterally, by the skull base su­ +periorly, and by the soft palate inferiorly. It opens +to the nasal cavity anteriorly and communicates +with the oropharynx inferiorly through the palato­ +pharyngeal isthmus or velopharyngeal seal. + +The oropharynx or mesopharynx is bounded +posteriorly and laterally by the pharyngeal walls +and constrictor muscles and inferiorly by the su­ +perior surface of the epiglottis and the hyoid bone. +It communicates with the nasopharynx superiorly +and with the mouth anteriorly. The laryngophar- +ynx or hypopharynx is bounded by the pharyngeal +walls posteriorly and laterally and extends to the +lower border of the cricoid cartilage inferiorly. It +communicates with the oropharynx superiorly, +with the cervical esophagus inferiorly, and with the +laryngeal vestibule anteriorly (3–6) (Fig 1). + +Phases of Swallowing + +Oral Preparatory Phase +The oral preparatory phase involves chewing the +food and mixing it with saliva. When the bolus +is considered “swallowable,” it is placed between +the upper surface of the tongue blade and the +palate. The tip of the bolus is held by a seal +formed by the tongue and the soft palate that +prevents premature leakage into the pharynx +before swallowing (7,8) (Fig 2A). + +Oral Propulsory Phase +During the oral propulsory phase, the bolus is pro­ +pelled into the oropharynx by means of an up­ +ward and backward movement of tongue. During +the passage of the bolus, the soft palate elevates +to a right angle to oppose the contraction of the +posterior and lateral pharyngeal walls that form +the Passavant ridge to close the palatopharyngeal +isthmus and prevent the penetration of material +into the nasopharynx (Fig 2B). + +Initiation of Pharyngeal Swallow +The next phase is the initiation of the pharyngeal +swallow, when the bolus passes the pharyngeal +pillars and enters into the oropharynx, triggering +the reflex that initiates the nonvoluntary pharyn­ +geal phase of swallowing. + +Pharyngeal Phase +In the pharyngeal phase, the hyolaryngeal complex +(HLC) elevates and shortens the pharynx, de­ +flects the epiglottis, closes the larynx, and opens + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1735 + +the PES (Fig 2C). Laryngeal closure starts in the +true vocal folds, followed by the false vocal folds, +and ends in the laryngeal vestibule. Concurrently, +the stripping contraction wave of the posterior +and lateral pharyngeal walls begins and propels +the bolus into the esophagus. + +PES Opening Phase +The PES opening phase consists of (a) relaxation of +the upper esophageal sphincter (UES); (b) upward +and anterior traction of the cricoid cartilage, which +is attached to the HLC; and (c) opening of the +lumen by means of increased intrabolus pressure +by the thrust of the dorsum of the tongue and the +pharyngeal constrictors (Fig 2D) (9). + +Esophageal Phase +The esophageal phase begins when the bolus is +propelled through the esophagus into the stom­ +ach by means of esophageal peristalsis. Once +the bolus passes into the esophagus, (a) the +palatopharyngeal isthmus opens, reestablishing +the communication between the nasopharynx +and oropharynx and allowing the passage of air; +(b) the HLC returns to resting position; (c) the +larynx opens; (d) the epiglottis returns to upright +position; (e) the PES closes, and (f) respiration +resumes (Fig 2E). + +Indications for Fluoroscopic +Swallowing Examinations +Common indications for fluoroscopically guided +swallowing examinations are oropharyngeal +dysphagia (swallowing difficulty); globus sensa­ +tion; choking and coughing during swallowing; +prolonged intubation; cerebrovascular events (ie, +stroke); and surgery, trauma, or radiation treat­ +ments to the head and neck (10). + +Figure 1. +Illustration +shows the anatomy of +the pharynx. + +Fluoroscopic Swallowing Examination +Technique +The equipment used includes a radiologic appa­ +ratus with fluoroscopy and video recording with +slow motion, reverse, and stop­frame capabili­ +ties (2,10–13). The patient should be upright +or seated in a comfortable position, with their +dentures in their mouth. + +Lateral views are the most useful to evaluate +all phases of swallowing and to detect penetra­ +tions into the airway. Oblique views are per­ +formed to visualize the PES without the shoulder +in the way. Frontal views are used to diagnose +asymmetric swallowing abnormalities. + +Use of short exposure times and high kilovolt­ +age is recommended to improve image resolution +and minimize motion blurring of the bolus and +anatomic structures. For a functional examina­ +tion, the contrast material used is barium sulfate +in a concentration of 40% to 60% weight/volume +(mass of solute/volume of solution). Multiple +barium viscosities such as thin liquid, nectar +thick, honey thick, paste, and solids are used at +the speech­language pathologist’s discretion. +Iodinated water­soluble contrast material is used +when leakages or perforations are suspected (13). +Videofluoroscopic recording is used to detect + +functional abnormalities at 30 frames per sec­ +ond. Compared with videofluoroscopic record­ +ing, rapid­sequence digital images are acquired +at fewer frames per second, but the images have +better spatial resolution and are preferred for +anatomic details. + +The personnel included in a modified barium +swallow examination are a radiographic technolo­ +gist, a radiologist, and a speech­language patholo­ +gist. The role of the speech­language pathologist +is to use strategies that may improve the efficiency + + 1736 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 2. +Illustrations show the +phases of swallowing, which include +the oral preparatory phase (A), +the oral propulsory phase (B), the +pharyngeal phase (C), the PES +phase (D), and the esophageal +phase (E). + +and safety of swallowing, to educate patients about +their swallowing function, and to provide swallow­ +ing recommendations on the basis of the radio­ +graphic findings after study completion. + +Evaluation of esophageal anatomy and motility + +is important. The anatomic site that the patient +identifies as the source of the symptoms is not +a reliable indicator of the location of the cause. +Thus, radiologic examinations of patients with +dysphagia should include a morphologic and func­ +tional evaluation of the esophagus and esophago­ +gastric junction, which may be performed before +or after the swallowing examination. + +Functional Abnormalities + +Abnormalities of Oral Preparatory Phase +The motion of the tongue is essential for bolus +manipulation and the functions of chewing, mix­ +ing food with saliva, and holding the bolus in the +mouth before swallowing. When the tongue is + +dysfunctional, images may show uncoordinated +movements, fragmentation of the bolus, inability +to hold it, and drooling and leaking of contrast +material into the sulci of the cheeks and floor of +the mouth (Fig 3). Causes of tongue failure can +be secondary to atrophy, xerostomia, surgery, or +severe nerve or brain injuries (7,14,15). + +Premature Spillage from Mouth into +Pharynx +The back of the tongue blade and the soft pal­ +ate form the glossopalatal seal, which keeps the +bolus in the mouth before swallowing. Premature +spillage from the mouth into the pharynx may be +caused by unilateral or bilateral incompetence of +the seal, which may allow leakage of material into +the pharynx before a swallowing attempt, leading +to aspiration through an opened and unprotected +airway (Fig 4). Seal ineffectiveness can be a result +of weakness, atrophy, or poor muscular coordina­ +tion of the tongue and soft palate due to aging, + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1737 + +Figure 3. Leakage into the floor of the mouth in a 77-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of the oral cavity after the swallow +shows that contrast material has leaked into the mouth floor +(large arrow) and the sulci of the cheeks (small arrows) because +of incompetence of the tongue. + +Figure 4. Leakage from the mouth into the pharynx in a +58-year-old woman. Lateral radiograph of the oral cavity and +pharynx before swallowing shows contrast material leaking +from the mouth bolus to the valleculae and hypopharynx (ar- +rows) due to incompetence of the glossopalatal seal. + +surgery, radiation, or acute and chronic neuro­ +logic illnesses. For example, patients with Parkin­ +son disease may perform repetitive unsuccessful +attempts to swallow the bolus (10,14). + +Delayed Initiation of Pharyngeal Swallow +When the bolus reaches the oropharynx, it +triggers the swallowing reflex that initiates the +nonvoluntary pharyngeal phase of swallowing. +The initiation of the pharyngeal swallow is rec­ +ognized radiographically by the elevation of the +hyoid bone as a component of the HLC. Hyoid +elevation starts when the tip of the bolus crosses +the angle of the mandible. A delayed swallowing +initiation is identified when the contrast material +is seen in the pharyngeal lumen but the hyoid +bone remains in a resting position (Fig 5). Causes +include decreased pharyngeal sensory perception +due to injury of mucosal receptors or neurologic +damage secondary to aging, radiation, a cerebro­ +vascular accident, or surgery (7,14). + +Nasal Regurgitation +The palatopharyngeal isthmus or seal should be +closed during the bolus transportation from the +mouth into the oropharynx. Nasal regurgitation +is diagnosed radiographically by evaluating pas­ +sage of the contrast material through a nonclosed +seal into the nasopharynx (Fig 6). Nasal penetra­ +tion can occur during transfer of the bolus from +the mouth to the pharynx due to incompetence +of the isthmus or after swallowing when the +seal is open and there is regurgitation from the +distal pharynx or esophagus due to an associated +distal dysfunction or mechanical obstruction. +The causes of an incompetent seal and nasal + +Figure 5. Delayed initiation of the pharyngeal swal- +low in a 55-year-old man. Lateral radiograph shows the +bolus in the oropharynx and hypopharynx (*), with the +hyoid bone still in resting position (arrow) due to a de- +layed triggering of the swallowing reflex. + +radiation, surgery, or a cerebrovascular accident. +Atrophy of the tongue or soft palate can lead +to compensatory hypertrophy of the opposite +muscle (10,14). + +Delayed or Slow Oral Propulsory Phase +When the bolus is judged to be “swallowable,” +it is placed in a midline depression in the upper +surface of the tongue blade until it is transferred +into the pharynx. A delayed initiation of tongue +propulsion or a slow transportation of the bolus +to the pharynx can be secondary to weakness or +the inability of the tongue to function because of + + 1738 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 8. Frozen pharynx in a +68-year-old woman with a his- +tory of radiation therapy. Lateral +radiograph shows absent contrac- +tions and rigidity of the pharyngeal +walls during the passage of bolus +and penetration of contrast mate- +rial into the larynx (arrow). + +Figure 6. Nasal regurgita- +tion in a 62-year-old man. +Lateral radiograph shows +contrast material penetrat- +ing into the nasopharynx +from the oropharynx (*) +during bolus displacement +because of insufficient clo- +sure of the palatopharyn- +geal isthmus. + +Figure 7. Limited elevation of +the hyolaryngeal complex in a +74-year-old man. Lateral radio- +graph during swallowing shows +that the hyoid bone (blue arrow) +did not reach the mandible at its +maximum displaced position, as is +expected in healthy patients. The +limited displacement may be due +to scarring of pharyngeal elevator +muscles from radiation treatment. +Associated findings are a poor +pharyngeal contraction, an incom- +plete closure of the larynx with +contrast material penetration (red +arrow), and a diminished opening +of the PES (yellow arrow). + +regurgitation include atrophy and insufficient +elevation of the soft palate due to neurologic +diseases, radiation, surgery, or congenital issues +such as a cleft palate or a fistula (7,14,16). An +oronasal fistula must be ruled out during the +examination. + +Slow or Incomplete Displacement +of HLC +A full upward and forward displacement of the +HLC is necessary to elevate and shorten the +pharynx, deflect the epiglottis, close the larynx, +and open the PES. The HLC is fully elevated +when the hyoid bone is seen at the level of the +inferior margin of the mandible. Slow or incom­ +plete elevation of the HLC is due to weakness of +the suprahyoid muscles and pharyngeal elevators +(Fig 7). Muscular weakness is a consequence of +atrophy and fibrosis secondary to aging, radia­ +tion, and neurologic or cerebrovascular diseases +(14). + +Weakness of Tongue and Pharyngeal +Contraction +Adequate thrust of the dorsum of the tongue +and the pharyngeal walls is required to increase +intrabolus pressure and propel the bolus into the + +Figure 9. Hypotony of the left +pharyngeal wall in a 59-year-old +woman. Frontal radiograph of the +pharynx during swallowing shows +bulging of the left pharyngeal wall +(arrowhead) and an asymmetric +tilt of the epiglottis (arrow). Find- +ings were due to a nerve injury +during surgery for resection of a +tumor in the base of the skull. + +esophagus. Unilateral or bilateral weakness or +atrophy of the muscles may prevent a timely and +complete bolus displacement. In severe cases +of atony, as with a “frozen pharynx,” the bolus +mostly moves by means of gravity (Fig 8). Lack +of appropriate contraction leaves residue in the +pharynx after swallowing and increases the risk +of aspiration. Reduced pharyngeal contraction +may be caused by muscular or neurologic dam­ +age due to radiation, surgery, or neurovascular +diseases. Weakness can be bilateral or unilateral +(Fig 9) (7,10,14,15). + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1739 + +push the bolus and a distal relaxation to al­ +low its passage. At fluoroscopy, abnormalities +of pharyngeal peristalsis are recognized by +the presence of nonpropulsive contractions +that interrupt bolus passage and fragment the +contrast material in the pharyngeal lumen (Fig +10). Residue left in the pharyngeal lumen after +swallowing can lead to aspiration. The paralysis +can be bilateral because of injury of the pharyn­ +geal innervation that is secondary to radiation, +inflammatory changes, or neurologic diseases +or unilateral because of peripheral nerve injury +during surgery (7,14). + +Limited Tilt of Epiglottis +During swallowing, the tilt of the epiglottis pro­ +tects the entrance of the laryngeal vestibule and +deflects the bolus into the lateral food pathways +(pyriform sinuses). As a consequence, an insuf­ +ficient or absent epiglottic tilt may obstruct the +passage of the bolus and risk penetration of +material into the laryngeal inlet during swallow­ +ing (Fig 11). Causes of inadequate epiglottic tilt +include insufficient displacement of the HLC, +pharyngeal or laryngeal tumors, or fibrosis due to +radiation (7,14). + +Delayed or Incomplete Laryngeal Closure +Laryngeal closure starts with and continues as +HLC displacement. It starts in an inferior to +superior direction, beginning in the true vocal +folds, followed by the false vocal folds, and end­ +ing in the laryngeal vestibule to expel penetrated +material back into the hypopharynx. Closure of +the laryngeal vestibule is recognized at fluoros­ +copy as the narrowing and disappearance of the +air column in the laryngeal lumen during the +HLC elevation. A delayed, slow, or incomplete +closure of the larynx during swallowing may lead +to aspiration (Fig 12). Failure of laryngeal closure +may result from insufficient HLC elevation, cer­ +vical surgery, laryngeal fibrosis due to radiation, +or weakness of the supraglottic adductors due to +edema or fibrosis (14,17). + +Incomplete Opening of PES +The UES is a high­pressure zone at the PES that +is formed by muscular fibers of the thyropharyn­ +geus, cricopharyngeus (CP), and circular fibers +of the proximal esophagus. The PES is normally +closed to prevent inhaled air from passing into the +esophagus and gastroesophageal reflux from enter­ +ing into the airway. It opens during swallowing to +allow passage of the bolus, vomiting, or eructation. +Opening the PES involves (a) neural relaxation of +the tonically contracted UES muscles, (b) normal +distensibility of the segment, (c) traction forces +imparted by the opening of the UES muscles, and + +Figure 10. Nonpropulsive pharyngeal contrac- +tions in a 66-year-old man. Lateral radiograph of +the pharynx during swallowing shows narrowing +of the pharyngeal lumen (arrowheads) when the +hyoid bone is still elevated (blue arrow). Because +of premature pharyngeal closure, some contrast +material was trapped in the oropharynx (*) and +penetrated the laryngeal vestibule (red arrow). + +Incomplete epi- +Figure 11. +glottis tilt in a 72-year-old man. +Lateral radiograph shows a +swelling epiglottis in upward +position during the bolus pas- +sage (arrow). As a consequence +of the insufficient tilt of the epi- +glottis, a partial obstruction of +bolus displacement and pen- +etration of contrast material +into the laryngeal vestibule (*) +are visible. + +Figure 12. +Insufficient closure +of the laryngeal lumen during +swallowing in a 69-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of +the pharynx during swallow- +ing shows an opened laryngeal +vestibule with penetration of +contrast material. Additional +findings are deformity of the +epiglottis (*), poor pharyngeal +contractions, and a stricture of +the PES (arrow) due to chemo- +therapy and radiation therapy. + +Lack of Synchronization of Pharyngeal +Contractions +Peristalsis is a wave­like involuntary contraction +of the gastrointestinal tract with the purpose +of transporting the bolus. It consists of strip­ +ping contractions of the proximal muscles to + + 1740 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Diagnosis and Treatment of Pharyngoesophageal Segment Dysmotilities + +PES Dysmotility + +PES Opening + +Mechanism + +Therapeutic Objective + +Maneuvers + +Delayed PES opening due +to slow HLC displace­ +ment + +Full opening only + +when the HLC is +completely elevated + +Delayed PES opening + +Full opening only + +Delayed initiation +of pharyngeal +swallow +UES spasm + +when UES is relaxed + +Improve speed of swal­ +lowing initiation + +Bolus stimulation + +Abbreviate the UES + +Increase bolus vol­ + +relaxation + +ume and thickness + +due to impaired UES +relaxation + +Incomplete PES opening +due to nonrelaxation of +CP (CP achalasia) + +Incomplete PES opening +due to lack of elasticity +of the CP (fibrosis) +Incomplete PES opening +due to partial displace­ +ment of HLC + +Incomplete PES opening +due to weak pharyngeal +contraction + +Early PES closure due to +premature HLC return + +Early PES closure due +to premature UES +contraction + +Incomplete + +CP nonrelaxation + +Improve CP relaxation Endoscopic dilation +Botulinum toxin A + +Incomplete + +CP lack of elastic­ +ity (fibrosis) + +PES dilation + +Incomplete + +Weakness of HLC + +Strengthening of HLC + +elevators + +elevators + +Incomplete + +Weak pharyngeal +muscular con­ +tractions + +Improvement of pha­ +ryngeal contraction + +Full opening only + +Weakness of HLC + +Increase and extend the + +when the HLC is +completely elevated + +elevators + +HLC elevation + +Full opening only + +UES spasm + +Delay the UES con­ + +when the UES is +relaxed + +traction + +injection +CP myotomy +Effortful swallow +Endoscopic dilation +CP myotomy +Mendelsohn +Effortful swallow +Shaker +Base of tongue exer­ + +cises + +Tongue hold +Mendelsohn +Increase bolus vol­ + +ume and thickness; +Mendelsohn +Increase bolus vol­ + +ume and thickness + +PES dilation + +Sources.— References 9,10,14,18–26. + +(d) intrabolus pressure generated by contraction +of the pharynx. + +Primary causes of incomplete opening of the +UES during the passage of the bolus are (a) in­ +complete relaxation of the UES (achalasia) or lack +of coordination with the pharyngeal contraction +(dyskinesia), (b) abnormal elasticity and dis­ +tensibility of the CP as result of degeneration of +muscle fibers and replacement with fibroadipose +tissue, (c) noncomplete displacement of the HLC +during swallowing, and (d) insufficient intrabolus +pressure to open the lumen due to impairment of +the tongue and pharyngeal constrictor muscles +(Table) (7,9,14,18–26). Narrowing of the PES +prevents the free and complete passage of the +bolus into the esophagus, resulting in incomplete +clearance and residue in the pyriform sinuses, +with potentially postdeglutitive aspiration. + +On a lateral view, the diminished opening of the + +PES is recognized by a posterior protrusion (CP +bar) between C3 and C6 during the trans­sphinc­ +teric passage of the bolus (Fig 13). For evaluation +of the function of the PES, radiologists should +correlate the following functional units: (a) the +opening of the PES, (b) the elevation of the HLC, +and (c) the pharyngeal contraction. Understand­ +ing the different possible mechanisms that cause + +the abnormal function of the segment is essential +in deciding the best treatment strategies. + +Delayed Opening of PES +During swallowing, the PES opens completely +upon the arrival of the bolus to allow it to pass +into the esophagus. Delayed opening of the PES +is a consequence of delayed elevation of the HLC +or retarded relaxation of the UES (Table). When +the delayed opening is due to slow or retarded +relaxation of the UES, the hyoid bone is already +elevated when the PES is still closed (Fig 14). +Because the PES remains closed on the arrival of +the bolus, there is a transient luminal obstruction +that augments the pressure and distends the lu­ +men of the proximal pharynx, increasing the risk +of aspiration (9,14). + +Early Closure of PES +The PES should only close after the bolus has +passed completely into the esophagus. A prema­ +ture closure of the PES can be due to an early +contraction of the UES before the HLC returns +to resting position and the bolus pass is finished +(Fig 15) or a premature return of the HLC to +resting position (Fig 16) (Table). An early closure +of the PES can block the bolus and leave residue + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1741 + +Figure 13. Diminished opening of the PES in +a 44-year-old woman with gastroesophageal re- +flux. Lateral radiograph of swallowing shows a +transverse filling defect in the posterior wall of +the PES, called the CP bar (yellow arrow), when +the hyolaryngeal complex is fully elevated (blue +arrow). The luminal narrowing obstructs the pas- +sage of the bolus and distends the proximal pha- +ryngeal lumen. + +Figure 14. Delayed opening +of the PES due to retarded relax- +ation of the UES in a 71-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph shows +the bolus tip at the PES entrance, +which remains closed (yellow ar- +row), even when the hyoid bone +is fully elevated (blue arrow). On +subsequent images (not shown), +the PES opened completely, allow- +ing the full passage of the bolus. + +Figure 15. Early closure of the PES due to +premature closing of the UES in a 62-year- +old man. (A) Lateral radiograph shows a +normal PES opening during the passage of +the bolus. (B) Delayed lateral radiograph +shows an early closing of the PES (arrow- +heads), while the hyoid bone is still ele- +vated (arrow in A and B). The early closure +of the PES interrupts the passage of the +bolus, leaving residue in the hypopharynx +(*), with increased risk of aspiration. + +in the pyriform sinuses after swallowing, leading +to aspiration when the airway reopens (9,14). + +Residue in Valleculae and Pyriform +Sinuses after Swallowing +After swallowing, no materials or contrast ma­ +terial should remain in the pharyngeal lumen. +Residue in the vallecullae, pyriform sinuses, +or pharyngeal walls may lead to postswallow­ +ing aspiration when respiration is resumed (Fig +17A–17C). After swallowing, pooling of contrast +material in the valleculae can result from impaired +backward movement of the dorsum of the tongue +or insufficient epiglottic tilt. Residue in the pyri­ +form sinuses may result from impaired pharyngeal +contraction, PES dysmotilities, or mechanical +obstruction. Unilateral pooling can be secondary +to paralysis of the lateral pharyngeal wall due to a +nerve or muscle injury (Fig 17D) (14). + +Penetration.—No contrast material should +penetrate the laryngeal vestibule before, during, +or after swallowing. Penetration is diagnosed at +fluoroscopy when contrast material is seen in the +laryngeal lumen. During swallowing, penetrated +material should be extruded back into the phar­ +ynx by laryngeal contraction (ie, flash penetration). +In severe cases, contrast material may remain +in the laryngeal vestibule, reach the vocal folds, +and pass into the trachea. Whenever possible, the +mechanism responsible for penetration should be +recognized during the examination and stated in +the report to allow decision making on the best +therapeutic approach. Preswallowing penetrations +are usually a consequence of delayed initiation +of the swallowing reflex. Penetrations during +swallowing can be due to one or multiple abnor­ +malities such as incomplete or slow elevation of +the HLC, epiglottis tilt, incomplete closure of the + + 1742 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 16. Early closure of the PES due to premature +return of the hyolaryngeal complex in a 55-year-old +woman. (A) Lateral radiograph shows normal open- +ing of the PES during swallowing, with the hyoid bone +fully elevated (blue arrow). An incidental finding is a +penetration during swallowing (red arrow). (B) De- +layed lateral radiograph of the same swallow shows +an early closure of the PES (arrowhead) due to a pre- +mature return of the HLC, which is evidenced by the +low position of the hyoid bone (blue arrow). The early +closure of the PES interrupted the complete passage +of the bolus and left residue in the hypopharynx (*). + +Figure 17. Residue in the valleculae and pyriform sinuses after swallowing. (A) Lateral radiograph of the pharynx in a 72-year- +old man after swallowing shows contrast material pooling in the valleculae (V) and pyriform sinuses (PS). (B) Frontal radiograph +in a 40-year-old man after spinal fixation shows bilateral residue in the valleculae (green arrows) and pyriform sinuses (red arrows). +(C) Lateral radiograph in a 67-year-old woman after swallowing shows the penetration of residual contrast material (arrowhead) into +the larynx from the pyriform sinuses (*). (D) Frontal radiograph in a 72-year-old man after right-sided skull base surgery shows residue +in the right pyriform sinus (arrow) due to unilateral deficiency of the pharyngeal contraction. + +laryngeal vestibule, or motility disorders of the +pharynx or PES. Pharyngeal residue is respon­ +sible for penetrations after swallowing (14). + +Aspiration.—Aspiration is diagnosed when con­ +trast material is seen in the tracheal lumen, below +the vocal cords (Fig 18). Aspiration is a more +severe complication than penetration and may be +minimal, moderate, or massive when the con­ +trast material reaches the carina and bronchus. +Aspirated materials in the trachea may generate +a protective cough to expel them back into the +pharynx or may be nonsensate (ie, silent). A de­ +layed or absent cough reflex is valuable informa­ +tion by which to estimate severity, because silent +aspirators have a greater risk of developing pneu­ +monia. In addition to the causes of penetration, +a delayed or insufficient closure of the vocal folds +due to edema, radiation fibrosis, or surgery of the +vocal cord adductors may contribute to aspira­ +tion. External­beam radiation treatment for neck + +cancer is a frequent cause of aspiration because it +may impair all phases of swallowing. + +Anatomic Abnormalities + +Radiography of the Neck +As part of the fluoroscopic swallowing exami­ +nation, a systematic evaluation of the air­filled +structures and soft tissues of the neck may +provide information about the causative or as­ +sociated abnormalities relating to the patient’s +symptoms. The patient should be evaluated for +(a) soft palate atrophy due to radiation or sur­ +gery or compensatory hypertrophy due to tongue +atrophy (Fig E1); (b) tongue atrophy due to +aging, radiation, or surgery (Fig E2); (c) epiglot­ +tis enlargement due to acute radiation (Fig E3), +infection, and tumors or atrophy due to radia­ +tion; (d) swelling of prevertebral soft tissues due +to chemotherapy, radiation, or surgery (Fig E4) +and tumors, abscesses, or hematomas; (e) air + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1743 + +Figure 18. Aspiration in a 77-year-old man. +Lateral view of swallowing shows contrast ma- +terial penetration into the laryngeal vestibule (*) +and aspiration into the tracheal lumen (red ar- +row) through the vocal folds (white arrows). + +Figure 19. Web in a 66-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of the +pharynx during swallowing shows a +thin horizontal linear filling defect in +the anterior wall of the hypopharynx +that obstructs the lumen (arrow). + +Figure 21. Pharyngeal tumor in +a 78-year-old man. Swallowing ex- +amination shows an irregular lumi- +nal narrowing of the pharynx, with +posterior displacement due to a large +infiltrating mass (arrows). + +Figure 20. Radiation stricture in +a 77-year-old man. Lateral radio- +graph of swallowing shows a short +severe luminal stricture in the phar- +ynx due to scarring (arrow), with a +mild proximal luminal distention. + +in the prevertebral soft tissues due to trauma +(Fig E5), gastrointestinal perforations (Fig E6), +diverticula (Fig E7), or in other locations as +postsurgical leakage (Fig E8); (f) soft­tissue­ +attenuation obstructive masses in the lumen of +pharynx (Fig E9), larynx (Fig E10), or PES (Fig +E11); (g) pharyngeal deformities as a nonclosed +PES at rest due to fibrosis because of radiation +therapy (Fig E12) or esophageal dilations due to +achalasia (Fig E13) or scleroderma; (h) abnor­ +mal soft­tissue calcifications; and (i) bone and +postsurgical abnormalities. + +Pharyngeal Strictures +Webs are thin mucosal folds that are frequently +seen in the anterior wall or circumference of the +hypopharynx or proximal esophagus. Webs are +associated with gastroesophageal reflux and syn­ +dromes such as Plummer­Vinson or epidermolysis +ampullosa and are seen as 2–4­mm­thick trans­ +verse linear filling defects in the hypopharynx and +cervical esophagus that may partially obstruct the +lumen and passage of the bolus (Fig 19) (27). + +Radiation strictures are a delayed complication + +of radiation due to vascular damage, ischemia, +and collagen deposition, with subsequent fibrosis +and scarring (Fig 20) (27,28). + +Cervical esophageal tumors can be seen radio­ +graphically as irregular or lobulated filling defects +protruding into the lumen of the pharynx or +larynx on radiographs or swallowing examina­ +tions (Fig 21) (27). Cervical tumors are more ac­ +curately detected and staged with cross­sectional +imaging such as CT, MRI, or PET. + + 1744 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 22. Zenker diverticulum in two patients. (A) Illustration shows a diverticulum (green arrow) +emerging from a triangular-shaped area in the posterior wall of the hypopharynx (blue and yellow ar- +rows), which was formed superiorly by the oblique fibers of the thyropharyngeus and inferiorly by hori- +zontal fibers of the cricopharyngeus. (B) Lateral radiograph during swallowing in a 74-year-old woman +shows a diverticulum in the posterior wall of the hypopharynx (red-orange arrow) above the CP bar +(yellow arrow). (C) Frontal radiograph in a 79-year-old man after swallowing contrast material shows +the diverticulum mildly displaced to the left side of the patient (*) and residue in both pyriform sinuses +(arrows). + +Zenker Diverticula +Zenker diverticula are outpouchings lined by squa­ +mous epithelial mucosa and submucosa and are +often surrounded by fibrous tissue, with absent +muscular fibers. They are located in an area of +muscular weakness called the Killian dehiscence +or the triangle of Laennec in the posterior wall of +the hypopharynx and are limited by the oblique +fibers of the thyropharyngeous superiorly and +laterally and by the horizontal fibers of the CP +inferiorly (Fig 22A). + +The development of Zenker diverticula may +involve anatomic and pathophysiologic causes that +include an area of wall weakness, a distal obstruc­ +tion due to the diminished opening of the CP, +and increased pharyngeal intraluminal pressure as +a consequence of mechanical obstruction of the +outlet. Strong evidence now shows that acquired +Zenker diverticula are, in most cases, second­ +ary to a poorly compliant but normally relax­ +ing CP muscle that cannot fully distend during +the process of sphincter opening. The increased +resistance to flow during swallowing in an attempt +to overcome the distal obstruction markedly in­ +creases the forces required to drive the passage of +the bolus. Increased intrabolus pressure imparted +to the area of relative muscular weakness (Killian +dehiscence) over many years gives rise to a poste­ +rior herniation of the pouch (27,29,30). + +Fluoroscopically, the diverticulum is seen +during and after swallowing as an outpouching + +arising from the posterior hypopharyngeal wall +above the prominence of the CP bar (Fig 22B). +In frontal views, a small diverticulum is seen in +the midline, but when it becomes larger, it may +relocate laterally, more frequently to the left side +(Fig 22C). After swallowing, the content of the +diverticulum may empty back into the hypo­ +pharynx, increasing the risk of postswallowing +aspiration. + +Pseudo-Zenker diverticula are saclike collections +of contrast material that are trapped in the same +location as that of the Zenker diverticula (27). +They are seen only after swallowing when the +pharyngeal lumen is collapsed and not when the +lumen is fully distended (Fig 23). + +Killian-Jamieson Diverticula +Killian-Jamieson diverticula are outpouchings from +the anterior lateral wall of the cervical esophagus +through a gap between the inferior margin of the +cricoid cartilage and CP and the lateral wall of +the suspensory ligament of the esophagus (Fig +24A) (27). They are seen during swallowing stud­ +ies as lateral or anterior outpouchings below the +level of the CP (Fig 24B). + +Complications of Total Laryngectomy + +Surgical Technique +Total laryngectomy is indicated for advanced or +nonradiosensitive laryngeal or cervical tumors. + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1745 + +Figure 23. Pseudo-Zenker diverticulum in a +69-year-old woman. Lateral radiograph of the +pharynx after swallowing shows an outpouching +in the location of the Zenker diverticula (arrow). +The outpouching was not identified when the +pharyngeal lumen was fully distended during the +passage of the bolus (not shown). + +Figure 24. Killian-Jamieson diverticulum in a 72-year-old +man. (A) Illustration shows a diverticulum emerging from the +anterolateral wall of the cervical esophagus (arrow) below the +CP muscle. (B) Frontal radiograph during swallowing shows a +right lateral diverticulum (arrow). + +The surgical technique consists of removal of the +hyoid bone, thyroid and cricoid cartilages, epiglot­ +tis, and vocal folds (Fig 25A), followed by recon­ +struction and closure of the anterior defect with +mucosa, pharyngeal muscles, and skin (Fig 25B). +Finally, optional vocal restoration can be achieved +through creation of a fistula between the trache­ +ostoma and the esophagus, with placement of a +silastic prosthesis of varying length and diameter +in the fistula to allow the one­way passage of air +for speech rehabilitation (Fig 25C). In patients +with the tracheoesophageal fistula, the evaluation +of prosthesis position and function and PES motil­ +ity during phonation should be included as part of +the swallowing evaluation (31–33). + +Anastomotic Leakage +Anastomotic leakage is a frequent complication +in the early postoperative period. Risk factors +include oral infection, salvage total laryngec­ +tomy, and prior radiation therapy. Leakages are +detected at a swallowing examination as blind +outpouchings outside the neopharyngeal lumen +(sinus tracts) or as an extraluminal tract of con­ +trast material that communicates with the skin +(Fig 26) (27,34,35). + +Pseudoepiglottis +A pseudoepiglottis is an enlargement of the folds at +the base of the tongue due to the pull of pharyn­ +geal constrictors when a patient attempts to swal­ +low. The abnormality is seen as an anterior linear +defect at the base of tongue and the entrance of + +neopharynx that resembles an epiglottis (Fig 27). +The fold is more prominent when the patient +swallows and may narrow the entrance of the +neopharynx and obstruct the bolus transit from +the mouth. Increased intrabolus pressure proxi­ +mal to the obstruction contributes to the forma­ +tion of a proximal pocket, where residue and food +may accumulate (27). + +Anterior Pharyngeal Pouches +Anterior pharyngeal pouches are pockets or out­ +pouchings located at the anterior wall between +the base of tongue and the neopharynx entrance. +The mechanism of formation is multifactorial, +including a localized weakness due to absence +of a muscular layer and/or increased intrabolus +pressure against a more distal mechanical or +functional obstruction. Radiologic images show +an anterior outpouching at the entrance of the +neopharynx with contrast material pooling after +the swallow (Fig 28). If the pouch enlarges con­ +siderably, it may extend into the skin, creating a +pharyngo­cutaneous fistula (36). + +Neopharyngeal Dysmotilities +Neopharyngeal dysmotilities may be secondary to +resection of the laryngeal and pharyngeal struc­ +tures that support the tongue and pharyngeal +muscles and/or due to damage of the pharyngeal +muscles and nerves by the tumor, surgery, or +radiation therapy. Dysmotilities are seen on im­ +ages from swallowing studies as a limited thrust +of the base of tongue and/or pharyngeal walls, + + 1746 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 25. Surgical technique for laryngectomy. (A) Illus- +tration shows the anatomic structures that will be removed +as the hyoid bone, epiglottis, thyroid cartilage including the +vocal folds, cricoid cartilage, and first tracheal ring. (B) Illus- +tration shows the closure of the anterior wall with mucosa, +muscles, and skin for the reconstruction of the neopharynx. +(C) Illustration shows the creation of a tracheoesophageal +fistula, with placement of a one-way prosthesis (arrow) for +voice reconstitution. + +with weakening of the pharyngeal propulsion, +impaired coordination of peristalsis, reversed +peristalsis, and outflow resistance across the +PES (Fig 29). Because of neopharyngeal dys­ +motility, bolus transit time is prolonged, and +pharyngeal clearance is incomplete, with stasis +and residue (27,36). + +total + +Figure 26. Sinus tract in +a 78-year-old man. Lateral +radiograph of swallowing +after +laryngectomy +shows a leakage from the +proximal neopharynx into +the anterior soft tissues of +the neck (arrow). + +Dysfunctions of PES +Dysfunctions of the PES should be evaluated +during and after swallowing during voice gen­ +eration. Fluoroscopically, they are seen as an +insufficient or delayed opening or early closing +of the PES (Fig 30). These findings may be a +consequence of impaired pharyngeal propul­ +sion or increased resistance at the bolus passage +through the PES due to resection of the cri­ +coid cartilage or fibrosis secondary to radiation +therapy (27,36). + +Benign Strictures +Benign strictures of the neopharyngeal lumen are +secondary to surgical scarring and/or chemo­ + +therapy and radiation therapy. The strictures may +partially or completely obstruct the bolus flow, +distending the proximal lumen and retaining ma­ +terial the patient swallows (Fig 31) (37). + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1747 + +Figure 27. Pseudoepiglot- +tis in a 78-year-old man who +underwent a total laryngec- +tomy. Lateral radiograph dur- +ing swallowing shows a linear +horizontal filling defect in the +anterior wall of the proximal +neopharynx that resembles +the epiglottis and partially +obstructs the passage of the +bolus (arrow). + +Figure +28. Anterior +pharyngeal pouch in a +72-year-old woman. Lat- +eral radiograph shows +contrast material pooling +in an outpouching at the +base of the tongue at the +entrance of the neophar- +ynx (*). + +Figure 29. Neopharyngeal dysmotility in a 70-year-old man. Se- +quential lateral radiographs of swallowing show a premature clo- +sure of the neopharynx during the passage of the bolus (arrows in +B), with residue in the proximal lumen. + +Figure 30. PES dysmotility in a +72-year-old woman. Lateral radio- +graph of swallowing shows PES +narrowing during the passage of +the bolus (arrow). + +Complications of Tracheoesophageal +Fistula and Prosthesis +A malpositioned or a too­large prosthesis may +protrude into the lumen of the tracheostoma and +obstruct it (Fig 32A). When the prosthetic flange +is located in the esophageal lumen instead of being +attached to the wall, the flange may cause obstruc­ +tion and interference in the passage of the bolus +and in phonation (Fig 32B). A too­short prosthesis +may lead to closure of the fistula, with associated +inflammatory changes. Esophageal contents can +pass around the prosthesis (ie, periprosthetic) and +into the tracheostoma during swallowing, because +the diameter of the prosthesis is too narrow com­ +pared with that of the stoma (Fig 32C) or through +the prosthesis because of malfunction (Fig 32D). +The prosthesis should be removed and replaced +after diagnosis of these complications (38–41). + +Conclusion +Swallowing is a complex mechanism that involves +at least 37 pairs of striated muscles, five cranial +nerves, and multiple supportive anatomic struc­ +tures that are controlled by the central nervous +system (10). As we have discussed in this article, +numerous anatomic and functional abnormali­ +ties can impair swallowing and can be detected at +fluoroscopy. + +The presence or supervision of a radiologist +during the examination may contribute to cor­ +relation of the perceived abnormalities with the +patient’s symptoms and prior treatments and +imaging studies. On the basis of this preliminary +analysis, the radiologist can decide, in conjunc­ +tion with the speech­language pathologist, if ad­ +ditional images or structures should be included +in the examination before the patient leaves the +radiography department. + + 1748 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 31. Postradiation stric- +ture in a 75-year-old man. Lateral +radiograph of swallowing after +total laryngectomy shows a stric- +ture in the neopharynx (arrows), +with proximal pharyngeal dilata- +tion (*). + +Figure 32. Complications of a tracheoesophageal prosthesis in four patients. (A) Oblique radiograph of swallowing in an 81-year- +old woman shows migration of the prosthesis (red arrows) into the lumen of the tracheostoma (green double-headed arrow). +(B) Oblique radiograph in a 74-year-old man after swallowing shows the esophageal flange of the prosthesis (arrows), which is +malpositioned in the lumen of the proximal esophagus instead of being attached to the wall. (C) Oblique radiograph in a 79-year- +old patient after swallowing shows contrast material leaking from the esophagus into the tracheal lumen through the surrounding +cephalad margin of the prosthesis (arrows). (D) Oblique radiograph in a 72-year-old man shows contrast material dripping into the +trachea through the lumen of prosthesis (arrow). + +The radiologic report should include all de­ +tected abnormalities and should not be limited to +description of the visualization of penetration or +aspiration. Because each abnormality has its own +specific therapeutic approach, the description +of radiologic findings and their correlation with +the pathophysiologic mechanisms and possible +causes should be stated clearly in the report. A +meticulous radiologic diagnosis facilitates the +decision making of referring physicians and swal­ +lowing therapists. + +Information obtained from swallowing exami­ +nations is useful to determine the oral capabilities +of the patient and whether they should initiate, +maintain, or discontinue oral intake without risk­ +ing development of pneumonia. A good­quality +examination and report not only improve early +diagnosis and treatment of a patient’s swallowing +disorders but also reduce morbidity, mortality, +length of hospital stay, and health care costs. + +Acknowledgment.—The authors wish to acknowledge Lory +Tubbs, MA, for her contribution with the illustrations. + References -forComputationalLinguistics,12. -| Haonan | Bian. | 2025. | LLM-empowered | | | knowl- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SeijiMaekawa,HayateIso,andNikitaBhutani.2024. -| edge | graph | construction: | | A survey. | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Holisticreasoningwithlong-contextLMs: | | | | | Abench- | -| arXiv:2510.20345. | | | ArXiv:2510.20345. | | | | | | | | | | -markfordatabaseoperationsonmassivetextualdata. -Darren Edge, Ha Trinh, Newman Cheng, Joshua Preprint,arXiv:2410.11996. ArXiv:2410.11996. -| Bradley, | Alex | Chao, | | Apurva | Mody, | Steven | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | David J. | Moore. | 2025. | A taxonomy | of | hierarchical | -Truitt, Dasha Metropolitansky, Robert Osazuwa multi-agentsystems: Designpatterns,coordination -| Ness, | and | Jonathan | Larson. | 2024. | | From lo- | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | mechanisms, | | and industrial | applications. | | Preprint, | -| cal to | global: | A graph | RAG | approach | | to query- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2508.12683. | | ArXiv:2508.12683. | | | | -| focusedsummarization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2404.16130. | | | | | | | | | | -ArXiv:2404.16130. -| | | | | | | | LituOuandMirellaLapata.2025. | | | | Context-awarehier- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -archicalmergingforlongdocumentsummarization. -| Gemini | Team, | Petko | Georgiev, | Ving | Ian Lei, | Ryan | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2502.00977. | | | ArXiv:2502.00977. | | | -| Burnell, | Libin | Bai, | Anmol | Gulati, | Garrett | Tanzer, | | | | | | | -DamienVincent,ZhufengPan,ShiboWang,and1 Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh -others. 2024. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D. Man- -understandingacrossmillionsoftokensofcontext. ning. 2024. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive pro- -Preprint,arXiv:2403.05530. ArXiv:2403.05530. cessing for tree-organized retrieval. Preprint, -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2401.18059. | | ArXiv:2401.18059. | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Jiani Guo, | Zuchao | Li, | Jie Wu, | Qianren | Wang, | Yun | | | | | | | -Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao, and Yujiu Yang. 2025. LiSun,LiuHe,ShuyueJia,YangfanHe,andChenyu -ToM:Leveragingtree-orientedMapReduceforlong- You. 2025. DocAgent: An agentic framework for -contextreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. InPro- multi-modallong-contextdocumentunderstanding. -ceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin InProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMeth- -NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). odsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). - -V.A.Traag,L.Waltman,andN.J.vanEck.2019. From extraction tasks and write a synthesis -louvaintoleiden: Guaranteeingwell-connectedcom- directive to guide the downstream -| munities. | ScientificReports,9(1):5233. | | | | | | synthesizer. | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 2. Sub-agents | | (next) | — | Each | document | -Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi is assigned one worker that runs your -Liao,XinghuaZhang,BingliWu,HaiyangYu,Nan tasks independently. Workers search -Xu,LeiZhang,RunLuo,YunshuiLi,MinYang,Fei their document and report raw findings. -| | | | | | | | They run | in parallel | | and | cannot | see each | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | -| Huang,andYongbinLi.2024a. | | | | Leavenodocument | | | | | | | | | -other’s results. -| behind: | Benchmarkinglong-contextLLMswithex- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 3. Synthesizer | | (last) | — | A downstream | | -| tendedmulti-docQA. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2406.17419. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | agent | receives | ALL | worker | | findings | -ArXiv:2406.17419. -| | | | | | | | and merges | | them | into | a | single | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | coherent | response. | | It | follows | your | -| Qian Wang, | Tianyu | | Wang, | Zhenheng | Tang, | Qinbin | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | synthesis_directive | | | to decide | | what to | -Li,NuoChen,JingshengLiang,andBingshengHe. -| | | | | | | | prioritize | and | how | to | structure | the | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| 2024b. | Megaagent: | | Alarge-scaleautonomousLLM- | | | | | | | | | | -output. -basedmulti-agentsystemwithoutpredefinedSOPs. -| | | | | | | | You CANNOT | see | the | names, | types, | or | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -| Preprint,arXiv:2408.09955. | | | | ArXiv:2408.09955. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | content | of the | documents. | | | | -TomerWolfson,HarshTrivedi,MorGeva,YoavGold- Your ONLY job in this step: -| berg, | Dan Roth, | Tushar | Khot, | Ashish | | Sabharwal, | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a list | of | subagent_todos | | -| and Reut | Tsarfaty. | | 2025. | Monaco: | | More nat- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (as | structured | | output): | | precise | -| ural and | complex | | questions | for | reasoning | across | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | extraction | | tasks | | that | will be | -| dozensofdocuments. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | executed | | independently | | against | EACH | -| ArXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | document | | by the | sub-agents. | | | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a synthesis_directive: | | | a | -Wentao Zhang, Liang Zeng, Yuzhen Xiao, Yong- concise instruction (2–4 sentences) -cong Li, Ce Cui, Yilei Zhao, Rui Hu, Yang Liu, for the synthesizer. -| Yahui | Zhou, | and Bo | An. | 2025. | AgentOrchestra: | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A hierarchical multi-agent framework for general- Todo-writing rules: -| purpose | task | solving. | Preprint, | arXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | • Decompose | | the | user | query | into | -| ArXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | concrete | | information | | requirements. | | -Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Hao Xu, Yi Lu, Wei He, Yiwen • Each todo must be self-contained -and unambiguous. -| Ding, | Tao Gui, | Qi | Zhang, | and | Xuanjing | Huang. | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | • Prefer | | atomic | tasks | over | broad | -| 2024. | LongAgent: | | Scalinglanguagemodelsto128k | | | | | | | | | | -tasks. -| contextthroughmulti-agentcollaboration. | | | | | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • Include | | coverage | for: | definitions, | | -| arXiv:2402.11550. | | | ArXiv:2402.11550. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | numeric | | values, | constraints, | | edge | -| | | | | | | | cases, | | error | modes, | and | any | -| Zihan Zhou, | Chong | | Li, Xinyi | Chen, | Shuo | Wang, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | explicit | | recommendations | | | required | -YuChao,ZhiliLi,HaoyuWang,QiShi,ZhixingTan, -| | | | | | | | by | the user | query. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -XuHan,XiaodongShi,ZhiyuanLiu,andMaosong -| | | | | | | | • Design | a | robust | extraction | | list | -| ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| Sun. 2025. | | LLM×MapReduce: | | | Simplified | long- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | that | works | for | ANY document | | in the | -| sequence | processing | | using | large | language | models. | | | | | | | -set. -InProceedingsoftheAnnualMeetingoftheAssocia- -| tionforComputationalLinguistics(ACL). | | | | | | | Important | Constraints: | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Do | not assume | any | document | | contains | -| AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris | | | | | | | • | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | the | answer. | Write | | todos | that can | -| Callison-Burch. | | 2024. | FanOutQA: | | A | multi-hop, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | be | answered | with | either | “Found” | or | -multi-documentquestionansweringbenchmarkfor -| | | | | | | | “Not | found | in | this document.” | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | --------------- | ----------- | --- | -| large language | | models. | In | Proceedings | | of the An- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • Tell | the | worker | WHAT | to extract, | not | -nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational -| | | | | | | | HOW | to extract | | it. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Linguistics(ACL). -| | | | | | | | • Do | not | synthesize, | | summarize, | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | attempt | | to answer | | the user | query | -A Prompts -yourself. -| All | prompts | | are | | defined | in | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A.2DocumentSub-AgentPrompt -backend/core/prompts.py. -(RESEARCH_SYSTEM_PROMPT) -| A.1CoordinatorPrompt | | | | | | | You are | a sub-agent | | investigating | | a | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | -| (LEAD_RESEARCHER_PROMPT) | | | | | | | single document: | | {file_name}. | | | | -You are a lead researcher coordinating You operate inside an iterative -a RAG-based analysis to answer a user retrieval loop. On each turn you output -| query. | | | | | | | exactly | one structured | | action: | | | -| -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| Pipeline | | Architecture: | | | | | • action="search": | | | Issue | a | focused | -1. YOU (now) — Decompose the query into query to retrieve information from - -the document. Set query to a • Follow the synthesis directive -specific, targeted search string. above — it defines your main goal, -Set reasoning to why this query is priorities, and output structure. -| | needed. | | | | | | • | Keep only | information | | that | directly | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -• action="finalize": You have helps answer the query. Discard -| | gathered | | sufficient | evidence | to | | | tangential | content. | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------ | -| | address | ALL | assigned | | tasks. Set | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Preserve | exact | numbers, | | names, | -| | findings | to | your | complete | extracted | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | dates, | and caveats. | | | | -| | report. | Set | reasoning | | to a brief | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Remove | redundancy. | | If the | same | -| | summary | of | what you | found. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | fact appears | | multiple | times, | keep | -it once. -| | Investigation | principles: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • | Do NOT | invent | or infer | facts | not | -| | | | | | | | | present | in the | findings. | | | -| | 1. Start | by identifying | | the | key facts | | | | | | | | -| | required | for | each | task. | | | • | Same | language | as | the | findings | -2. Issue ONE focused query per turn (default English if mixed). -| | — prefer | specific | | terms | over broad | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | phrases. | | | | | B | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | -| | 3. Expand | to | synonyms | or | paraphrases | | | | | | | | -Models. -if initial results are incomplete. The coordinator, the merging layer, -4. Issue separate queries for and the synthesis layer use gemini-2.5-pro -| | different | | aspects | of a | task. | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | (temperature | | 0.0). | | Document | | sub-agents | -| | 5. Keep | searching | until | every | task is | | | | | | | | -covered with concrete evidence or use gemini-2.5-flash (temperature 0.0) for -| | confirmed | | absent. | | | document-scoped | | | retrieval. | | The | LLM judge | -| --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | -6. Do NOT attempt to answer the user (GPT-5) is separate and is used only for the -| | query | directly | — | extract | raw facts | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | evaluationoftheAvgscore. | | | | Modelconstantsare | | | -only. -definedinbackend/shared/constants.py. -| | 7. Do | NOT finalize | | a task | as ’Not | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | found’ | after | only | a single | focused | | | | | | | | -| | search. | | At | least | attempt 2 | Hyperparameters. | | | | | | | -| | focused | searches | | before | concluding | | | | | | | | -| | information | | is absent. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Parameter | | | | Value | | | -| | 8. Do NOT | focus | on very | specific | terms, | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunksize(tokens) | | | | 1000 | | | -| | but | rather | on the | general | context | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunkoverlap(tokens) | | | | 250 | | | -| | of the | task. | Always | try | to find the | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Tokenizer | | | | tiktoken | | cl100k_base | -| | most | relevant | information. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingmodel | | | | Cohereembed-v4.0 | | | -| | 9. You | must use | AT MOST | 5 | searches to | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingdimension | | | | 1536 | | | -| | answer | a task. | DO | NOT | OVERUSE THE | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Similaritymetric | | | | Cosine | | | -| | SEARCH | TOOL. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | MergetokenbudgetB | | | | 750,000tokens | | | -| | | | | | | Denseretrievaltop-K | | | | 15 | | | -| | Finalize | report | format: | | For each | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Reranker | | | | Coherererank-v4.0-fast | | | -| | assigned | task, | output | either | “Found: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Rerankertop-N | | | | 5 | | | -| | [exact answer | with | supporting | | evidence]” | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Sub-agentiterationsafetylimit | | | | 5 | | | -| | or “Not found | in | this | document.” | Always | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringalgorithm | | | | Agglomerative(UPGMA) | | | -| | report exact | numbers, | | names, | and dates. | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringmetric | | | | Precomputedcosinedistance | | | -| | Never approximate | | or | infer | beyond the | | | | | | | | -document. -| | | | | | | Cost | | measurement. | | Per-query | | costs | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | are | pulled | from | LangSmith | | run | metadata | -A.3Merge/SynthesisPrompt -| (SYNTHESIS_PROMPT) | | | | | | (extract_langsmith_info.py) | | | | | using | model- | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -specificper-tokenpricing. -Thispromptisuseduniformlyateverylevelofthe -recursivemergingtree,includingthefinalsynthesis -step. Thereisnoseparatefinal-answerprompt. -| | You are | a research | synthesizer. | | Merge | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | the following | | sub-agent | findings | into | | | | | | | | -| | one compact, | information-dense | | | response | | | | | | | | -| | for the user. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Query: {query | } | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Synthesis | Directive: | | | | | | | | | | | -{synthesis_directive} -| | Findings | Batch: | {findings | } | | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rules: \ No newline at end of file + +1. Allen J, Belafsky P. Symptom indices for dysphagia assess­ +ment and management. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma +GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidis­ +ciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New York, +NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 357–379. +2. Logeman JA. Instrumental techniques for the study of swal­ +lowing. In: Evaluation and treatment of swallowing disorders: +imaging studies. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 54–61. +3. Rubesin SE. Pharyngeal morphology. In: Ekberg O, ed. +Dysphagia. Diagnosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, Swit­ +zerland: Springer International, 2019; 351–384. + +4. Ekberg O, Nylander G. Anatomy and physiology. In: Ekberg +O, ed. Dysphagia. Diagnosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, +Switzerland: Springer, 2019; 3–20. + +5. Logeman JA. Anatomy and physiology of normal deglutition. +In: Evaluation and treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd +ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 13–52. + +6. Belafsky PC, Lintzenich CR. Development, Anatomy, +and Physiology of the Pharynx. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 165–173. + +7. Jones B. Abnormalities of pharyngeal function. In: Gore RM, +Levine MS, eds. Textbook of Gastrointestinal Radiology. +4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2014; 222–236. +8. Matsuo K, Palmer JB. Oral phase preparation and pro­ +pulsion: anatomy, physiology, rheology, mastication, and +transport. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1749 + +C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A multidisciplinary text +of swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer, +2013; 117–132. + +9. Lang IM. Development, anatomy and physiology of the +upper esophageal sphincter and pharyngoesophageal junc­ +tion. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, +eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidisciplinary text for +swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer, +2013; 235–255. + +10. Rubesin SE. Principles of performing a “modified barium +swallow” examination. In: RSNA Categorical Course in +Diagnostic Radiology: Gastrointestinal. Oak Brook, Ill: +Radiological Society of North America, 1997; 7–19. +11. Logeman JA. Evaluation of swallowing disorders. In: Evalu­ +ation and treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, +Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 168–190. + +12. Rubesin SE. Pharynx: normal anatomy and examination +techniques. In: Gore RM, Levine MS, eds. Textbook +of Gastrointestinal radiology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: +Saunders­Elsevier, 2014; 207–221. + +13. Skucas J. Imging contrast agents. In: Gore RM, Levine +MS, eds. Textbook of Gastrointestinal Radiology. 3rd ed. +Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2008; 3–17. + +14. Logeman JA. Disorders of deglutition. In: Evaluation and +treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: +Pro­ed, 1998; 71–119. + +15. Pokieser P, Scharitzer M. The clinical and radiological +approach to dysphagia. In: Ekberg O, ed. Dysphagia. Diag­ +nosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, Switzerland: Springer +International, 2019; 285–315. + +16. Buchholz DW, Bosma JF, Donner MW. Adaptation, com­ +pensation, and decompensation of the pharyngeal swallow. +Gastrointest Radiol 1985;10(3):235–239. + +17. Lazarus C. Dysphagia Secondary to the Effects of Chemo­ +therapy and Radiation therapy. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 431–444. + +18. Dantas RO. Cricopharyngeal bar. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 509–514. + +19. Massey BT. Crocopharyngeal achalasia. In: Shaker R, +Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of +deglutition. A multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its +disorders. New York, NY: Springer, 2013; 515–528. +20. Easterling C, Shaker R. Upper esophageal sphincter opening +muscle dysfunction. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, +Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A multidisci­ +plinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: +Springer, 2013; 529–538. + +21. Mei L, Sanvanson P. Upper esophageal sphincter restrictive +disorders. In: Bardan E, Shaker R, eds. Gastrointestinal mo­ +tility disorders. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, 2018; 79–907. +22. Lazarus CL, Logemann JA, Pauloski BR, et al. Swallow­ +ing disorders in head and neck cancer patients treated with +radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy. Laryngoscope +1996;106(9 Pt 1):1157–1166. + +23. Born LJ, Harned RH, Rikkers LF, Pfeiffer RF, Quigley +EM. Cricopharyngeal dysfunction in Parkinson’s disease: +role in dysphagia and response to myotomy. Mov Disord +1996;11(1):53–58. + +24. Theurer JA, Johnston JL, Taves DH, et al. Swallowing after +right hemisphere stroke: oral versus pharyngeal deficits. Can +J Speech Lang Pathol Audiol 2008;32:114–122. + +25. Lazarus C, Logemann JA. Swallowing disorders in +closed head trauma patients. Arch Phys Med Rehabil +1987;68(2):79–84. + +26. McCullough GH, Kim Y. Effects of the Mendelsohn +maneuver on extent of hyoid movement and UES opening +post­stroke. Dysphagia 2013;28(4):511–519. + +27. Rubesin SE. Structural abnormalities of the pharynx. In: +Gore RM, Levine MS, eds. Textbook of gastrointestinal +radiology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, +2014; 235–265. + +28. Lazarus C. Dysphagia secondary to the effects of chemo­ +therapy and radiation therapy. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 431–443. +29. Cook IJ. Zenker’s diverticulum. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 495–508. +30. Morrison MP, Postma GN. Surgical treatment of Zenker’s +diverticulum. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easter­ +ling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidisciplinary text +for swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer +Science Business Media, 2013; 847–858. + +31. Agrawal N, Goldenberg D. Primary and salvage total laryngec­ +tomy. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2008;41(4):771–780, vii. +32. Schindler A, Mozzanic F, Barbiera F. Dysphagia evaluation +and treatment after head and neck surgery and/or chemo­ +radiotherapy of head and neck malignancy. In: Shaker R, +Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of +deglutition: a multidisciplinary text for swallowing and +its disorders. New York, NY: Springer Science Business +Media, 2013; 649–668. + +33. Giannitto C, Preda L, Zurlo V, et al. Swallowing disorders +after oral cavity and pharyngolaryngeal surgery and role +of imaging. Gastroenterol Res Pract 2017;2017:7592034. +34. Wippold FJ II. Postoperative pharynx. In: Gore RM, Levine +MS, eds. In: Textbook of gastrointestinal radiology. 3rd +ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2008; 257–271. +35. Balfe DM, Koehler RE, Setzen M, Weyman PJ, Baron RL, +Ogura JH. Barium examination of the esophagus after total +laryngectomy. Radiology 1982;143(2):501–508. + +36. Anderson S, Hogan D, Panizza B. Causes and consequences +of anterior pharyngeal pouch after total laryngectomy. J +Laryngol Otol 2014;128(Suppl 2):S39–S42. + +37. Nguyen NP, Smith HJ, Sallah S. Evaluation and manage­ +ment of swallowing dysfunction following chemoradiation +for head and neck cancer. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head +Neck Surg 2007;15(2):130–133. + +38. Logemann JA. Swallowing disorders after treatment of oral +and oropharyngeal cancer. In: Evaluation and treatment of +swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­Ed, 1998; +251–278. + +39. Pope TL, Shaffer HA Jr, Johns ME, et al. Radiologic evalu­ +ation of the Blom­Singer prosthesis for vocal restoration +after laryngectomy. Presented at the Annual Meeting of +the American Society of Head and Neck Radiology, Los +Angeles, CA, May 1981. + +40. Pauloski BR, Rademaker AW, Logemann JA, Colangelo +LA. Speech and swallowing in irradiated and nonirradiated +postsurgical oral cancer patients. Otolaryngol Head Neck +Surg 1998;118(5):616–624. + +41. Zhang T, Szczesniak M, Maclean J, et al. Biomechanics of +pharyngeal deglutitive function following total laryngectomy. +Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2016;155(2):295–302. + +This journal-based SA-CME activity has been approved for AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM. See rsna.org/learning-center-rg. + diff --git a/q253/random_k2/random_2.md b/q253/random_k2/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..66dda46939cb392b8d53b4e32148ffc455647966 100644 --- a/q253/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q253/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,2837 +1,2305 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +Bachelor Programs -2 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between - -them - - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a - -stable dividend - -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised - -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia - -and from our international network - - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive - -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend - -3 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - -Strategic priorities - -Financial targets +Bachelor (B.A.) of Business +Administration and Digital +Innovation 1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. - -Insurance and Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Empower our -people - -RoTE1 - - >11% by 2020 - -Costs - - Positive jaws - -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) - -Capital + “As Managing Director of GBSB Global +Business School I am delighted to be +leading one of the first Microsoft +Showcase Business Schools in +Europe. + +GBSB Global has a strong focus on +innovation and technology, both in our +online and on-campus programs. We +are within a few business schools in +Europe to offer a fully digitalized +experience to our students throughout +the +includes +digital blackboards, collaborative apps, +learning environment, and +inclusive +various educational digital tools. + +learning process; + +this + +Our world-class digital reputation +is reflected in our partnership with +Microsoft. We were proud to be one +of the first business schools in +Europe to achieve a recognition +as a Microsoft Showcase School, +meaning we belong +to a global +community of schools engaged in digital +improve teaching +transformation +and learning. We create inclusive and +that +immersive digital +inspire +stimulate +development of essential business skills +so students are empowered to achieve +more. + +experiences + +learning, + +lifelong + +to + +Our students are our biggest asset! We +strive to be globally competitive +and internationally relevant, educating +our students to become tomorrow’s +future leaders today. When you study +at GBSB Global, you become not only +a student, but a member of a world- +wide learning community. Your +classmates and professors, from across +the globe, will challenge and inspire +you, push you to grow both personally +and professionally, empowering you +with the tools to go far and to achieve +success. Whatever your professional +aspirations may be, I am confident that +GBSB Global is the perfect base +from which to hone your business +skills, +launch new companies, and +achieve your career goals. + +I look forward to welcoming you to GBSB +Global’s learning environment.” + +Antonio Rodriguez +Managing Director +GBSB Global + +Olga Ivanova +Head of Innovation +and Development +GBSB Global + +Our programs will challenge you with a +valuable experience, and benefit you +and your career now, and in the years to +come.” + +programs + +“GBSB Global’s +have +been carefully crafted to provide the +skills you need to progress to top +management level positions. + +As Head of Innovation and Development +at GBSB Global, I have the benefit of +over 10 years of research in business +education experience, and of observing +tendencies in education all around the +world, so I know first-hand what a +business school should give you +to make the transition to the job +of your dreams. + +is accredited + +GBSB Global Business School supports +high standards in business education +by numerous and -dividend - - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs - -subject to -regulatory -approval - -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ - -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% - -4 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 +international accreditation bodies such +as Accreditation Council for Business +Schools and Programs +(ACBSP), +European Council of Business Education +(ECBE) and Accreditation Service for +International Schools, Colleges and +Universities (ASIC). + +The institution was awarded as a Four +Stars Business School by QS Ranking +System and listed among TOP business +schools in Europe in the QS Master +Programs Ranking. + +Alongside our well-established +partnership with Microsoft, we +have developed unique in-house learning +and teaching methodologies, creating +a fully engaging academic experience. +Participate in group work, contact your +lecturers and access video streams, you +can do it all whenever you want, from +wherever you want. + +GBSB Global’s programs open +up opportunities +to experience +global business. Undertaking one of +the programs and connecting with +faculty and students from all over +the world will provide you with an +theories +into how business +insight +and practices are applied in different +countries and cultures, expanding +your international perspectives, +network and professional opportunities. 2 3 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength + The Program -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Academics -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Improve Your +Career Prospects -5 +Why GBSB Global - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +How to Apply -Who we are +p. 06 -Strategic differentiators +p. 22 -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 +p. 36 -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows +p. 44 -#1 -global transaction -bank2 +p. 58 -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 +4 -USD182bn -Total capital4 +05 +5 -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 + ABOUT +THIS PROGRAM -1 +The Program -2 +GBSB Global’s Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration +and Digital Innovation is designed to be an alternative +to traditional business administration focusing on +trends in technology and the paradigm shift businesses +have taken to focus more solely on their online markets. -3 +Students will concentrate on the business areas that are of +key interest while gaining a comprehensive education +with a digital focus. Learn about trends in digital +innovation and how to think with an agile mind adapting to +the new remote reality facing the world today. -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank +Our Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation prepares students with the skills needed to work +in a tech-focused environment where collaboration +and communication will be key to quickly and +effectively adapt to the changing business arena. -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, +Areas of concentrations: -Middle East and Latin America +Digital Entrepreneurship - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver +Digital Communication & PR -shareholder value +Digital Marketing -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with +Fashion & Luxury Business -diversified business model +Finance & FinTech - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity +Sports & eSports Management -management +THE PROGRAM - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for +About This Program -distribution to shareholders +Bachelor Majors -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research +Why Earn This Degree -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include +Is This Program Right for You? -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts +Current Student Profile -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) +Student Testimonials 6 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -1 - -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking - -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 - -FY2017, revenue, USDbn - -Recognised as leading international -bank +07 +7 -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 + The Program + +AREAS OF CONCENTRATIONS + +Digital Entrepreneurship + +Digital Communication & PR + +Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Digital Entrepreneurship prepares students +for the dynamic and quickly changing business landscape. +Students will learn about what it takes to design, create and +implement a digital business in an era where social and +economic issues will impact business trends online + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and +Digital Innovation with Digital Communication & PR is an +innovative program that is specifically designed for students +who want to be competitive in the digital marketplace. The +tech-focused program identifies the best global business +practices and multi-channel communication strategies +providing students with the knowledge and tools to +successfully manage international marketing initiatives. + +Digital Marketing + +Fashion & Luxury Business + +The Bachelor (B.A) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Digital Marketing seeks to help students +acquire an +in-depth knowledge of digital marketing +principles, as well as understand how to apply them to real- +life business operations. + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Fashion & Luxury Business examines the +wide variety of careers available to students in the field +of fashion and luxury brand management. Entering this +highly competitive landscape, graduates from GBSB Global +are furnished with the skills and understanding needed to +deploy their ideas into structural business plans that take +into account the innovative backdrop in which we live. + +Sports and eSports Management + +Finance & FinTech + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Sports and eSports is designed to provide +students with business management fundamentals and an +in-depth knowledge of global markets especially as they +relate to advancements in technology. The program examines +legal, technological, and international perspectives in the +sports marketplace and improves students’ decision-making +talents and capability to adapt to global challenges. + +Throughout the Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration +and Digital Innovation with Finance & FinTech students +cover a variety of financial topics, from the very basics +of banking and equity investment to diving deeper into +corporate financing, statistical analytics, and portfolio +management. The program also covers topics such as +investor relations, online financial services, cost accounting, +and wealth planning to name a few. -Leading market positions +8 -HSBC +9 -US Bank + The Program + +The Program + +WHY EARN THIS DEGREE + +Build a Career That Will Be in Demand for the Long +Term + +Make a Deep Dive to Digital and Innovation +Business World + +Acquire the knowledge and skills in one of the most +fundamental, dynamic yet stable fields today. + +Start learning the highly paid digital competencies required +in the digital economy era. + +No matter how far technological development and +innovation will advance, individuals with managerial +training, analytical skills, and business vision will always +be a vital component in business and the economy. In +comparison to other careers like engineering, the demand +for well-educated businessmen and women is growing +with the advancements in technology. + +Without a doubt, the digital economy is booming as a +consequence of the many technological advancements +in different sectors and areas. In an era of shrinking +product life cycles and rapidly changing business models, +students should be aware of latest digital and innovation +trends. GBSB Global utilizes digital aspects on all levels of +educational process by preparing digital courses, cases of +technological companies, business simulations and many +others. + +Build a Global Network + +Increase Your Innovative Potential + +Take advantage of the diverse student body at GBSB Global +Business School, representing over 100 nationalities. Build +solid professional relationships and connections across +borders and industries. + +Take courses on design thinking or creativity and psychology +of new product development and get ready to work in +innovative companies. + +Networking plays a very important role in one’s career +development, both in finding a good job or developing +advantageous relationships with new partners and/or +clients. At GBSB Global you will have an opportunity to +network with students, future business leaders from over +100 countries, and faculty members, current managers +and founders in various businesses, from over 16 countries. + +The research department at GBSB Global Business School +is constantly involved in business education research, which +fosters the design of the most innovative and practical business +programs. GBSB Global implements the most advanced teaching +methodologies available today to the bachelor’s curriculum such +as Lego ® Serious Play ® and drawing production tasks. + +Gain a Global Perspective on the Business World +and Develop Your Professional Flexibility + +Follow Your Aspirations and Embrace New +Educational Opportunities + +Learn the fundamental concepts and various interconnected +aspects of the business world as a system and develop your +analytical skills. + +One step away from an MBA – choose the path offering +personal and professional growth. + +One of the main advantages of GBSB Global’s Bachelor +program is the modular structure of the curriculum. This +allows students to focus on the area of study they are +most interested in while still obtaining a broad business +perspective and being able to change from one field to +another: from finance to marketing, from marketing to +entrepreneurship. Students also study how business is +conducted in different regions of the world and learn +to develop greater cultural intelligence and awareness, +effectively working with people from all around the globe. + +After graduating from our Bachelor program, students can +continue their education and obtain an MBA or a master’s +degree. The Bachelor in Business is the most common +academic background of MBA students. The program +provides the students with fundamental knowledge and +skills that will be required when doing an MBA. + +Acquire a Combination of Hard & Soft Skills and +Become Highly Competitive + +Not only will students obtain hard skills like accounting, +information technologies, and financial analysis, but they +will also develop very valuable soft skills like leadership, +people management, and organizational communications +that will make them more competitive in the job market. + +According to the research conducted by The National +Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE), such soft +skills as the ability to work in teams, decision-making, +problem solving and organizational communication are +the most sought after by employers. + +Prepare to Face the Challenges of the 21st Century + +Join business professionals in pursuit of an agenda based on +sustainability and ethical business practices. + +More and more companies today are carefully selecting +their suppliers and partners from an array of firms that +comply with the international environmental standards +and requirements set forth that respect human rights +and conduct ethical operations. An education focused on +global sustainability prepares students for the recent trend +focused on ethical business practices in global business. -US Bank +10 -US Bank +11 -European -Bank + IS THIS PROGRAM +RIGHT FOR YOU? -European -Bank +The Bachelor program commonly +appeals to students with a variety of +professional aspirations: -European -Bank +Prospective undergraduate students are diverse in +their interests and skills and are typically: -European -Bank +Business Administration -European -Bank +Ambitious & inspired people who aspire to be a +leader in their industry. -15.2 +Proactive individuals with entrepreneurial spirit +who plan to start their own company or lead innovation +in the business envinronment. -26% +Digital Marketing -22% +Finance & FinTech -21% +Highly motivated students who aspire to earn +an MBA and strive for advanced professional titles, +increased salaries, and more responsibility. -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 +Digital Business Models +and Operations -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 +Critical thinkers who are currently uncertain what +industry or area of the business world they prefer to +develop their career in and find it advantageous to +obtain a more universal, fundamental knowledge. -Asia +Digital Communications +and Social Media -US +High school graduates who are interested in digital +communications, marketing automatization, fintech, +innovation and entrepreneurship. -Europe +Entrepreneurship -RoTE Transaction Banking, % +International Management ->20% +12 -HSBC -Transaction -Banking + The Program -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 +The Program -Banking -Industry -overall7 +Students apply to the bachelor program in order +to develop a variety of professional skills and +knowledge in different industries that will increase +their employability as a professional in the field of +business. -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 +Knowledge -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 +Skills -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 +faced by -53% -of client -revenue -connected to +Gathers and interprets relevant data on problems, +obstacles and opportunities international -network - -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. - -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue - -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries - -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey - -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 - -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth - -HSBC has access to high growth markets - -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 - -Asia, Market shares2 +organizations to inform judgments that include reflection +on relevant social, technological, scientific or ethical issues +with the purpose to evaluate alternative approaches and +strategies an organization may adopt to meet stakeholder +needs and minimize risk within changing internal and +external environments. + +Conducts research into business and digital innovation +issues, which may relate to general business and innovation +processes or to a specific. + +Demonstrates mastery in using digital tools for business +administration and +in various +media and different modes (autonomous, collaborative, +exploratory, designing). + +innovation purposes + +related + +theoretical and practical +Understands professional +knowledge +administration, +business +to +including both broad knowledge in the field of business +administration and a considerable degree of specialized +managerial knowledge in digital innovation. + +Possesses advanced professional knowledge of business +administration and digital innovation in a specific industry +or functional area chosen as an elective option in the +undergraduate program. + +Critically understands approaches to promoting the +culture of digital innovation within an organization by +managing talent and knowledge and by incorporating +the values of entrepreneurship, continuous learning +and digital transformation into organizational strategic +objectives. + +Understands managerial methods and digital technologies +that are in demand in the complex and challenging global +business environment, innovation in terms of methods and +technologies used, and implications of digital technologies +for individuals and societies. + +Demonstrates professional understanding of +issues +of digital business and how it can be interpreted with +different theoretical approaches. + +Critically understands the principles included in the +Agenda for Sustainable Development defined by UNESCO +that are associated with social welfare, business ethics, +and corporate social responsibility. -+5.8% +14 -Asia +15 -Middle East + The Program -Africa +The Program -Latin America +Talented individuals are drawn +to the Bachelor program +in +order to achieve the following +objectives: -N. America +1 -Europe +Distinguish themselves, develop a career +in the business world, and achieve success, i.e. +managerial position or executive title -2017 +4 -2030E +Obtain a more systematic and +fundamental knowledge with a broad +business perspective in order to have more +opportunities and options of career development -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 +3 -+6.1% +Further their education and to earn an +MBA or other master’s degree to gain advanced +professional titles, increased salaries, and more +responsibility -Asia +5 -Middle East +Become competent specialists +in the area of their interest and passion: digital +communication, digital marketing, social +media, fintech, innovation, entrepreneurship, +leadership in turbulent times -Africa +2 -Latin America +Start their own company or launch +a startup -N. America +16 -Europe +17 -CAGR + The Program -7.4% +CURRENT +STUDENT PROFILE -7.4% +The Program -6.5% +Student Body Statistics -6.0% +A Truly Multicultural Environment +GBSB Global attracts students from countries of all sizes and +regions worldwide with diverse academic and professional +backgrounds. -4.3% +Attention to Diversity +Students represent a variety of cultures, religions and backgrounds. +GBSB Global creates an atmosphere of open-mindedness and +respect to ensure that every member of our student body has a +positive and inclusive experience. -4.6% +Countries GBSB Global Students Represent -CAGR +As of January 2018 -7.1% +40% -7.8% +60% -8.0% +19 -5.7% +100 COUNRIES +REPRESENTATIVES -4.4% +18 -5.4% +19 -29% Hong Kong + Student Testimonials -12% PRD4 +Student Testimonials -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) +“For me personally, the biggest advantage of GBSB Global is the level +of diversity within the student body. I’ve had the chance to share and +collaborate with people from countries I knew absolutely nothing about. -5% Singapore +Most importantly though, what I have gained from my time at GBSB +Global is a level of social learning and cultural understanding that +is unparalleled to any university I have attended in the past, that I know +will be invaluable when entering the international business field.” -3% Malaysia +Aidan McKevitt, USA +Class of 2018 -Middle East, Market shares2 +“The environment at GBSB Global Business School is very encouraging. +There are a lot of great teachers, and I have made friends with individuals +from different parts of the world. The international atmosphere at the school +is inspiring, and the motivated future entrepreneurs, many of whom are +my friends and fellow students, encourage me to set higher standards +and goals. At the end of my course, I will not only have knowledge and +practical skills but also many great future opportunities.” -8% Saudi Arabia7 +Anel Duisenova, KAZAKHSTAN +Class of 2018 -4% United Arab +20 -Emirates +21 -Latin America, Market shares2 + PROGRAM OVERVIEW -8% Mexico +Academics - Largest among international and +27 -regional banks3 +MONTHS OF STUDIES +Full Time – 3 Years +Part Time – up to 6 Years - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and +09 ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 +ACADEMIC TERMS +Each Term Lasts 11 Weeks with +Christmas, Easter and Summer +Holidays In-between - Strong foundation in China / PRD to +OCT -support future expansion +JAN APR - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting +ANNUAL INTAKES +October, January & April -with 28% market share6 +DAYS PER WEEK ON +AVERAGE +Mornings and Afternoons - Leading international bank in the Middle +06 -East8 +SPECIALIZATIONS +Tailor the Program to +Your Interests - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade +180 -finance9 +CREDITS +European Credit +Transfer System (ECTS) - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and +100% +in English -Belt and Road Initiative10 +INTERNATIONALLY ACCREDITED +BACHELOR’S DEGREE +(EQF Level 6) - #1 DCM in Middle East5 +ACADEMICS - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on +Program Overview -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA +Program Objectives -2017 +Program Highlights -2030E +Global Study Trips -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes +Program Structure -Japanese banks +Course Descriptions -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees +Faculty -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 +G-Accelerator -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) +22 -8 +23 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength + PROGRAM OBJECTIVES + +At the end of the program, graduates will demonstrate a comprehensive knowledge of business and will obtain an +international perspective of organizations. Students will have acquired the tools needed to apply knowledge within +the various functional areas in order to implement innovative business strategies in accordance with the values +associated with promoting organizations’ social commitment. + +01 + +02 + +03 + +Engages in critical thinking in the +area of business administration and +digital innovation and demonstrates +independent thought and problem +solving underpinned by evidenced +based arguments. + +complex + +Manages +professional +activities efficiently and professionally +into +to put managerial decisions +the +into account +practice +organizational context together with +different constraints. + +taking + +Demonstrates administrative design +and resource in elaborating social, +ethical, innovative and international +approaches to complex management +and digital business +situations, +and takes responsibility for their +consequences. + +04 + +05 + +06 + +Shows creativity and initiative in +developing digital transformation +and digital +intra-entrepreneurial +projects by liaising and working +with others to deliver high level of +team performance. + +Has developed learning skills that are +necessary to continue professional +development in the area of business +administration and digital innovation +evaluating personal +by +strengths and weaknesses, keeping up +to date with relevant management and +digital business technologies, ideas +and practices. + +critically + +Has developed proficiency and literacy +in the use of digital technology needed +to access learning opportunities and to +pursue a managerial career in dynamic, +innovative digital organizations. -2 +24 -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows +25 -Aspiration + Academics -Characteristics +Academics -Markets +PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS -Markets at -scale +Learning Outside the Classroom -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” +Use of the Best Case Studies -Markets as -leading -international -bank +Hands-on Lectures & Group Projects -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” +Workshops - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% +Included in the curriculum are annual visits to different companies +and company presentations on campus, so students may see how +professionals conduct business in the real world. Past visits have +included meetings with international companies institutions such +as Hewlett-Packard (HP), W Hotel, Estrella Damm, Tiffany & Co., +World Trade Organization, United Nations, Keiretsu Forum, and +many others. -market share +The students develop their analytical and problem solving skills by +working on case studies from Harvard Business School, Harvard +Business Law Review, Ivey Publishing and other important +resources widely used by the leaders in business education. - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments +The bachelor program incorporates lectures that provide practical +knowledge that is applicable to the business environment on a +global scale. Modules provide students with the opportunity to +collaborate in different teamwork settings in order to simulate +various business situations. - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore +New workshops for the bachelor’s students are constantly being +added to the curriculum to inspire students, increase their +creativity and help them bring their ideas to fruition. - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 +Faculty with Industry Experience and Invited +Speakers - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) +Each faculty member at GBSB Global has professional experience +in the subject area they are teaching. Additionally, invited speakers +from different +international companies and organizations +constantly visit GBSB Global. This provides students with an +opportunity to learn directly from practicing professionals and to +understand how business is conducted in real life. - Australia - Canada - China - France +Innovative Teaching Methodologies - Germany - India - Indonesia - US +GBSB Global is passionate about the different advances in business +education and constantly implements innovative teaching +methods into the bachelor curriculum in order for students to +develop different skills in an interactive and engaging way. -Markets to -connect the -network +Knowledge-by-Doing -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” +Focus on Innovation and Technology - Targeted offering for +Various program modules incorporate a learning-by-doing +teaching methodology that allows students to not only gain +theoretical knowledge but also to practice what has been learned +in class. -international customers +Businesses need managers with the knowledge to be both globally +aware and digitally trained. They require digital strategists able to +exploit the new technologies on the market for a maximum return +on investment. GBSB Global aims to bring modern technology to +the classroom for the students to explore the opportunities which +it provides. - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where +Networking Opportunities -possible +Students have many opportunities to network with everyone +from startup entrepreneurs to corporate professionals, as well as +professors and other students. - Network markets to +26 -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) +27 - Supporting subsidiaries of + Academics -global customers +PROGRAM STRUCTURE -% of adj. -revenue +Specialization and Electives -FY17 +Academics -c.60% +Alternatively a student may opt to choose six elective units without following any specialization track. -c.25% +Digital Entrepreneurship (45 ECTS) -c.15% +1ST YEAR: COMPULSORY (60 ECTS) -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC +Undergraduate Certificate in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (32 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Undergraduate Diploma in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (60 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Possible Exit Award -9 +● Valuating and Fundraising a Digital Start-up - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +● E-Commerce Development -3 +● Design Thinking and Agile Methodology for + Innovation -Signature balance sheet strength +● Knowledge Management and Learning Organisations -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) +● Social Entrepreneurship -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 +● Talent Management in the Digital Era -Customer accounts +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Entrepreneurship -Balance Sheet +Global Business Environment -Loans & advances to -customers +Business Communication -Total equity +Introduction to Digital Entrepreneurship and Innovation -1.4tn +Fundamentals of Marketing in the Digital Era -1.0tn +Principles of Accounting -198bn +Business Law in a Digital Context -Total regulatory capital +Business Math and Statistics -182bn +(7 ECTS) -Capital +(6 ECTS) -Leverage ratio + (7 ECTS) -Total capital ratio +(13 ECTS) -5.6% +(7 ECTS) -20.9% +(7 ECTS) -Advances to deposits ratio +(13 ECTS) -71% +Digital Communication & PR (45 ECTS) -Funding and -liquidity +● Digital Branding -Liquidity coverage ratio +● Digital Communication Strategies and Digital Media -142% +● Reputation and Relationship Management in the + Digital Era -10 year PBT -volatility2 +● Principles of Public Relations -LICs / loans -and advances3 +● Investor Relations -Advances to -deposits ratio +● Visual Communications for Digital and Offline + Channels -Leverage ratio +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Communication + & PR -Total capital -ratio +2ND YEAR: COMPULSORY+ SPECIALIZATION (60 ECTS) -Liquid asset buffer +Digital Marketing (45 ECTS) ->500bn +Undergraduate Higher Diploma in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (120 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Possible Exit Award -CET1 ratio +Strategic Management of Enterprise and Digital Innovation -Peer group -average1 +Managerial Accounting -2.6x +Leadership and Organizational Behavior -HSBC +Starting a New Digital Business -1.0x +Business Economics -5.5%4 +Business Research Methods -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. +Elective 1 -10 +Elective 2 -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda +Elective 3 -1 +3RD YEAR: COMPULSORY + SPECIALIZATION (60 ECTS) -2 +Professional and Career Development -3 +Innovative and Creative Thinking -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +Corporate Finance -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Disruptive Technologies for Innovation and Change -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Elective 1 -11 +Elective 2 - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth +Elective 3 -Transformation since 2011 +Undergraduate Dissertation -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +(13 ECTS) - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 +(6 ECTS) - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by +(6 ECTS) -USD349bn or 29%1 +(7 ECTS) - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions +(7 ECTS) - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities +(6 ECTS) - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” +(4 ECTS) -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities + (4 ECTS) - Shifted business to Asia and +(7 ECTS) -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 +(6 ECTS) - Strengthened network to support +(4 ECTS) -global trade and capital flows +(7 ECTS) - Demonstrated ability to execute +(13 ECTS) -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength +(4 ECTS) -Growth +(4 ECTS) -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses +(7 ECTS) -Turnaround +(15 ECTS) -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre +● Digital Branding -Customer +● Management of Retail and Electronic Distribution + Channels -1 +● Pricing Strategies and Digital Products -2 +● E-Commerce Development -3 +● Sales Management -4 +● Consumer Behaviour and Emerging Technologies -5 +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Marketing -6 +Fashion & Luxury Business (45 ECTS) -7 +● Sustainable Fashion and Luxury -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy +● Event Management & Sponsoring -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service +● Digital Branding -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network +● Recreation, Leisure and Wellness Business -Turn around our US business +● Fashion & Luxury Marketing -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses +● Management of Retail and Electronic Distribution + Channels -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains +● Dissertation in the area of Fashion and/or Luxury + Business -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved +Finance & FinTech (45 ECTS) -customer service +● Portfolio Management and Wealth Planning + Investments - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- +● Foundations of FinTech -leading financial crime standards +● FinTech in Banking: Challenges and Opportunities -Empower our -people +● Advanced Issues in Accounting -8 +● Investor Relations -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills +● Dissertation in the area of Finance and/or FinTech -Our People +Sports & eSports Management (45 ECTS) -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis +● Sports and eSports Management -12 +● Event Management & Sponsoring - Strategic priorities +● Business Models and Entrepreneurship in eSports -1-3 +● Sports and eSports Marketing -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity +● Talent Management in the Digital Era -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 +● Recreation, Leisure and Wellness Business -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity +● Dissertation in the area of Sports and/or eSports + Management -CAGR --8% +28 -72.3 +29 -mid single -digit growth, p.a. + Academics -+7% +GLOBAL +STUDY TRIPS -51.4 +GBSB Global Business School arranges Global Study Trips, a +yearly educational trip abroad. This is an opportunity of a lifetime +for all students. The visited organizations are closed to the general +public, but the relationships GBSB Global Business School has +established with these institutions allow for these visits to be +planned. -48.0 +Some of the organizations GBSB Global +students visit: -2011 +UNESCO in Paris -2016 +United Nations Conference on Trade and +Development in Geneva -2017 +Organization for Economic Cooperation and +Development (OECD) in Paris -2020 -Target +United Nations in Geneva -1. ROE including PVIF +World Trade Organization (WTO) in Geneva -Market -Growth +European Commission in Brussels -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn +Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for +Human Rights in Geneva -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance +30 -Asia Wealth +31 -Asset Management -(Asia) + Academics -Belt and Road +FACULTY -Insurance -(Asia)1 +GBSB Global faculty is as diverse as the student +body with faculty members representing many +different countries and nationalities. -ASEAN +Each faculty member, apart from a strong academic background, +has a practical, professional experience in their subject area, which +allows the students to learn directly from industry professionals. -PRD +GBSB Global Faculty Statistics -UK -Ring-fenced Bank +North America -Hong Kong +South America -Transaction Banking/ -International network +9% -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) +18% -Cost of Equity +72% -RoTE +Europe -13 +1% - Strategic priorities +Asia -1 +32 -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia +33 ->3bn + G-ACCELERATOR ->1bn +G-Accelerator at GBSB Global is an innovative +program that seeks to help current students +and graduates launch a startup. The program +works with an esteemed faculty and GBSB Global’s mentors, +aiming to provide students with the support necessary on +every step of the way, from idea formation and adaptation +to supply chain, financial, and legal negotiations. GBSB +Global offers residents a free package of mentorship hours, +infrastructure facilities and the occasional support on +funding market access. ->0.2bn +G-Accelerator Services: -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) +Financial Support +Services -Opportunities and areas of investment +Infrastructure +Services -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Mentorship Services -USD +“Mentors bring a great input for the process of my +start-up, as well as my personal growth. It has been +very valuable to get provided with personal advice +from two professionals with many years of relevant +experience. We all have different backgrounds +which results in broad knowledge, different working +methods and discussions - something that +is +absolutely necessary in order to create a value-added +business model. Mentors always provide me with +direct constructive feedback. I really appreciate their +effort and input and their experience within the field +of entrepreneurship helps me formulate guidelines +and prioritize my activities” -PBT, 2017 -USDbn +Eva Groot +G-Accelerator Resident -11.4 +34 -7.5 +35 -A + CAREER SUPPORT DURING +& BEYOND YOUR STUDIES -Build on strength in Hong Kong +Improve Your Career Prospects - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments +At GBSB Global Business School our vision is to be +a leading innovative business school, developing +transformational ideas and professionals that shape +the future of business. -Revenue, 2017 USDbn +Our Career Services team will support you throughout your +studies and beyond to ensure you achieve your full potential. You +will connect your goals and values and discover the influencing, +communication and leadership skills you need to actively manage +and accelerate your career. -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) +Career development is a journey. Wherever you are in the process +– from starting a graduate job to considering changing industries +– GBSB Global offers assistance to help students plan and achieve +career success. -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) +virtual career fairs to speak with HR representatives from main +multinational companies. -ASEAN +Being an official ACCA partner school, gives our students an +exclusive access to thousands of international jobs in finance +through ACCA portal. Additionally, GBSB Global is a partner of +HOSCO – world’s leading hospitality network which publishes job +offers in tourism and hospitality. -China +Help from Your Faculty -India +Very often faculty members who are working +in their +corresponding fields introduce students to different professionals +and job opportunities. It is a great advantage of having lecturers +who are not only academics, but also involved in the professional +sector. -Australia +Coaching & Career Development Support -Other Asia +GBSB Global provides all kinds of support for the students to +become more employable. Career Services helps students create +CV’s, prepare for interviews and assists with the job search. -4.7 +Career Development Workshops -3.1 +Skills webinars covering topics such as Preparation for an +Interview, Salary Negotiation, Managing Workplace, Job Search +Tips, etc. -PRD +Career Consultations & Executive Coaching -0.2 +You will have access to career consultations and executive +coaching. One career consultation with one of our highly trained +career experts available at any time during the program to suit +your needs. You may also extend your coaching relationships by +purchasing further sessions. -2.4 +Grow Your Global Network -2.4 +Studying alongside students from all over the world, having +international teachers and meeting business leaders from +different companies is a unique opportunity to broaden your +business experience, grow your global network, apply your skills +and explore a new culture. Explore the themes of development +and globalization, and develop close working relationships with +your international peers while studying online at GBSB Global +Business School. This global network will be one of your biggest +assets in your professional career. -0.9 +Industrial Visits -0.9 +GBSB Global Business School arranges visits to different +companies where students are introduced to the management +and offered to leave their CV’s, as well as develop their professional +networks. -2.1 +Expert Insights -1.2 +Company Presentations on Campus -0.5 +Experienced guest speakers share first-hand industry insights. -0.9 +Online Resources -0.4 +GBSB Global has it’s own career portal available exclusively for +GBSB Global students and alumni with more than 150.000 +jobs and internships postings around the world and regular -0.8 +GBSB Global Business School organizes presentations of different +companies on the campus, so that the students can meet the +representatives of a variety of companies and apply for different +positions offered by the firms. -B +IMPROVE YOUR +CAREER PROSPECTS -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing +Career Support During & Beyond Your Studies -technology in PRD +Careers After Graduation -C +Industrial Visits, Career Fairs & Company Presentations -Build leading Wealth Management business +Do Your Internship in Europe - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater +36 -China and ASEAN +37 - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional + Improve Your Career Prospects -clients +Improve Your Career Prospects -D +Finding Employment Within 1-3 Months After +Graduation -Expand our business in ASEAN +Graduates from GBSB Global have secured employment at top +companies all over the world. Like GBSB Global alumni, you could +end up working at Apple, SAP, Deloitte and many more. With the +right education, training and networking, the opportunities to +build your future career are endless. - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise +Most of the GBSB Global graduates find employment within the +first 1-3 months after finishing their studies. Job opportunities +arise from securing placements while studying, as the internships +often turn into full-time positions. Also, advanced job searches +ensure student success after graduation. -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth +Some of the companies where GBSB Global +graduates work: - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position + WHAT OUR STUDENT SAY -14 +“The program helped me expand my business knowledge. +Due to this learning I have been able to re-enter the +corporate world at Apple Distribution International, +where innovative MBA graduates are sought after.” - Strategic priorities +“You have people from Asia, Europe, the Middle East, +from the States, from everywhere so you get to feel the +culture of everyone.” -1A +Neil McLoughlin, IRELAND +Demand Analyst at Apple, Inc -Build on strength in Hong Kong +Serían Nassif, EGYPT +Customer Service Manager, Céline -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… +“The most valuable experience I had was organizing the +B.I.T. of Fashion conference, because I learned how to +organize events on a professional level.” -Opportunities and areas of investment +“The school organized a lot of different events that +promoted development of our communication skills, +presentation skills, made us more open-minded, and +more culturally intelligent.” -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn +Tanja Sredojevic, SLOVAKIA +Marketing Analyst, Céline -HSBC market -share, % +Aizat Kalbergenova, KAZAKHSTAN +Business Operations Analyst, SAP -USD0.9tn +“We had these classes about trends, marketing, the theory +about fashion and luxury industry which is now helping +me to understand new things and to bring new ideas.” -USD2.9tn +“Having an internship in a Spanish hotel chain was a great +opportunity. As I was working at the same time as I was +completing my studies, it helped me to apply the new +knowledge I attained from GBSB Global to my job.” -10% +Ioannis Antonopoulos, GERMANY +Manager, Swarovski -CAGR -2005-17 +Galina Sverchkova, KAZAKHSTAN +Hostess, Unico Hotels, Grand Hotel Central Barcelona -24% +38 -2005 +39 -10% + Improve Your Career Prospects -Asset growth +CAREERS AFTER GRADUATION -25% +90% +Are Employed Within +a Year of Graduation* -20172 +70% +Maintain Their +Employment Over a Year -Leading market share across major products2 +60% +Increased +Responsibilities Within +a Year* -…with leading positions across major products3 +79% +Improved Their Management +Skills “Much” or “To a Great +Extent” Due to a Professional +Internship -Customer -accounts +92% +Are Satisfied “Much” or “To +a Great Extent” with GBSB +Global Experience -Loans and -advances to -customers +51% +Consider GBSB Global +to have a “Decisive” and +“Significant” Impact on +Their Careers -DCM +60% +Are Employed Outside +Their Home Countries -#1 +26% +Launched Their Own +Business -#1 +30% +Joined Fortune +500 and Fortune 100 +Companies -#1 +29% +Reached Upper, +Senior, or Executive +Management Positions +After Graduation -Mortgages +56% +Increased Their Salary +Within a Year After +Graduation -37% +63% +Consider GBSB Global +Educational Model to Have +Improved Their Management & +Leadership Skills -#1 +40 -Credit cards +*10% Employed Before Graduation **20% Promoted to Higher Positions ->40% +41 -Trade finance + Improve Your Career Prospects -#1 +YOUR INTERNSHIP +JOURNEY -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments +Improve Your Career Prospects -Enhance -customer -experience +Internships are usually +paid and can lead to full-time +jobs. -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments +Our campuses located in business +cities plenty of multinational +companies, +so finding an +internship should not be a problem. - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident +GBSB Global offers its students a +unique opportunity to complete +their internship during the program or +straight after graduation. -Chinese customers +A student may complete an internship +only in the cities and countries where +GBSB Global campuses operate. - Invest in insurance for sustainable +The duration of the internship +cannot exceed six months +and GBSB Global will provide +paperwork assistance (including +student visa documents) to help +students to secure internships. -market share growth +Students are encouraged to use +the online resources offered by +GBSB Global and to attend +the online workshops +assisting on how to look for an +internship. - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business +42 -Banking +43 - Explore partnerships to launch + Why GBSB Global -innovative solutions +OUR APPROACH TO +BUSINESS EDUCATION - Capture new growth opportunities with +Global Diversity -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese +We are one of the leading in Europe with a true focus on +the world: -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as +Students from 100+ countries +Faculty from 37+ countries +International partners +Internship opportunities worldwide +Multicultural case studies +Cultural visits and experiences -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation +An Opportunity to Learn from Great Business +Leaders -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia +Our faculty and invited speakers are highly professional +business people coming from: -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share +Multinational companies +R&D fields in various business areas +Entrepreneurial positions at startups and rapidly +expanding businesses -15 +Innovative Programs -excluding Japan +Personalized Approach - Strategic priorities +Continuous application of the latest trends and methods in +innovative education: -1B +We foster a student-centered learning approach which +provides: -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) +Innovative teaching methods like visual thinking and +design thinking +New product development and rapid prototyping +Innovative business model development -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily +Customized education in small groups; +most classes have a maximum of 30 students +High level of student involvement at GBSB Global +Individualized attention provided by the +GBSB Global academic team addressing your +concerns and requests -Opportunities and areas of investment +Integrity, Business Ethics & Sustainability -USDbn +Employability & Career Development -Revenue +We educate students to become highly professional and +responsible business leaders by embedding the following in +every curriculum: -0.18 +Human rights issues +Sustainability practices +Business ethics -2014 +GBSB Global Business School supports students in +securing their future careers by providing: -0.22 +Individual coaching sessions +Group workshops and company presentations +Career counseling +Constant job and internship offers from our partners -2017 +Education in English & the Opportunity to Learn +More Languages ->USD1bn +All programs are taught in English, but with a diverse student +body and faculty from all over the world, you will have the +chance to learn many other languages. +Some commonly found around are: -c.0.5 +Spanish +English +Russian +French +German -2020 -target +Technological Approach -Medium- -term target +GBSB Global Business School is a technology-driven school +that is the first and only higher education institution in +Europe that leading to be one of the first Microsoft +Showcase Business Schools in Europe. -Loans & advances to customers +GBSB Global provides a fully digitized environment complete +with: ->20bn +Online collaborative spaces +Microsoft Office 365 accessibility +Free wifi in all facilities -4.1 +WHY GBSB GLOBAL -6.2 +Our Approach to Business Education ->10bn +Accreditation & Memberships -2014 +Rankings -2017 +Strategic Partners -2020 -target +Achievements -Medium- -term target +Campuses - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank +Latest Digital Innovations & Teaching Methods -in China, opened for business in December 2017 +Extra-Curricular Activities - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled +Accommodation -since project launched in June 2015 +44 - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 +45 - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect + Why GBSB Global - Enhance corporate coverage to +ACCREDITATION -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading +MEMBERSHIPS - Broaden client base and drive for +Why GBSB Global -deposit-heavy product mix +GBSB Global Business School in Malta is licensed as a Higher +Education Institution (License number: 2020-12) by +The National Commission of Further and Higher +Education. NCFHE is a national entity responsible for setting +and updating the Malta Qualifications framework, +setting standards for the different qualification +levels, accrediting courses at different MQF levels, +and ensuring that the national quality assurance framework is +upheld by all further and higher education providers in Malta. -Emerging -Middle -Class +GBSB Global’s programs in Barcelona and Madrid are +for +accredited by the Accreditation Council +Business Schools and Programs (ACBSP). ACBSP is a +leading U.S. specialized accreditation body for business education +supporting, celebrating, and rewarding excellence in teaching. +The association embraces teaching excellence +as one of its main virtues and emphasizes the +importance of learning to students worldwide. +ACBSP is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education +and the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA). -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity +GBSB Global is proud to be a partner of UNWTO. The +World Tourism Organization, UNWTO, is the United +Nations agency responsible for the promotion of responsible, +sustainable and generally accessible tourism across the +globe. GBSB Global joins the culminationation of over 500 +companies including educational and research institutions, +destinations and NGOs. The UNWTO’s Affiliate +Members Programme provides a platform for its +partners to engage in important conversations, +share information and promote further action. - Fully leverage capital market +The Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business. +AACSB International is a global association of +leaders +in education and business dedicated +to supporting and advancing quality business +education worldwide. Through membership, accreditation, +research, thought leadership, professional development, and +advocacy, AACSB partners with over 1,500 organizations, from +more than 90 countries globally. Membership or participation +in the Global Education Alliance does not imply accreditation. -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation +Several Master’s programs at GBSB Global are accredited by +ECBE (European Council for Business Education), the +leading accreditation organization in Europe that helps to ensure +that accredited members satisfy the requirements of the +European Higher Education Area (EHEA) as set forth +in the Bologna Process and other EU directives. ECBE +is an affiliate member of ENQA and a candidate for membership +in ENQA. -New business -capabilities +The GBSB Global Business School is accredited by +Accreditation Service for International Schools, +Colleges and Universities (ASIC). The University has +earned Premier status with ASIC for its commendable areas of +operation. ASIC accreditation helps students and parents +make a more informed choice and will also help +a school, college, university, training provider +or distance education provider, demonstrate to the +international student body that they are a high quality institution. -16 +ASIC is recognised by UKVI in UK, is a member of the CHEA +International Quality Group (CIQG) in USA and is listed in their +International Directory, is a member of the BQF (British Quality +Foundation) and are institutional members of EDEN (European +Distance and E-Learning Network). - Strategic priorities +46 -1C +47 -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth + Why GBSB Global -Rising wealth in Asia +RANKINGS -Private financial wealth1, USDtn +STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS -2016-21E -CAGR +Why GBSB Global -223 +GBSB Global awarded as a Four Star +by QS Ranking System -Middle class in Asia2 +Institution -# of people, bn +Listed among Top Business Schools +QS Business Masters Ranking -2.5x +in Europe -152 +in the -E. Europe +Unites States Sports Academy +(America’s Sports University) -L. America +The University of Vic - Central University +of Catalonia (UVic-UCC) + +The USSA was founded in 1972 as a response to high demands +and increasing need in the sports industry. Their mission is +to serve the world as a sport education resource +platform, providing students with mentorship, various +research facilities, and services. The academy’s distance learning +delivery system enables students from all around the world +to take advantage of their resources. -MENA +UVic-UCC aims to foster higher education, postgraduate training +and scientific and cultural research activities, and knowledge +transfer; paper and multimedia publishing; grants to support all +these activities; and economic and social regional development. +UVic-UCC seeks to provide in-service teacher training, +support for the tutorial system and teaching innovation. -N. America +Granted Palme of Excellence for Strong Local Influence -34% +MBA program is ranked as Tier One in the Global MBA +Rankings in CEO Magazine -W. Europe +Received +Learning and International Orientation -25% +top scores -Japan +for Research, Teaching & -10% +Microsoft Showcase Schools -Asia ex Japan +Zaragoza Logistics Center – +MIT Global Scale Network -21% +Recognized as a +by Newsweek Magazine -166 +leader -33% +in global education -24% +GBSB Global Business School is one of the first business school +in Europe that obtained the status of a Microsoft Showcase +School and was recognized by Microsoft as a leader in +digital education, providing students with the most state-of- +the-art learning experience from day one. -9% +GBSB Global collaborates with ZLC-MIT Global Scale +Network. Zaragoza Logistics Center (ZLC) is a research +institute established by the Government of Aragon in Spain in +partnership with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and +the University of Zaragoza. Founded in 2003, the ZLC +headquarters is located in the heart of PLAZA, the largest +logistics park in the southern Europe that operates as a working +laboratory to transfer new knowledge and best working +practices. -23% +Mentioned as Top 10 popular Online bachelor programs +by Educations -33% +The Association of Chartered +Certified Accountants (ACCA) -5.6% +GBSB Global’s MBA & Bachelor/Master in Finance students +have a unique advantage – with all finance programs aligned +to the ACCA requirements, the school prepares students +with the competencies needed to earn the ACCA +certification from levels F1 to F4. -Average household annual income3 +48 -2015 +49 -2030E + Why GBSB Global -USD‘000 +CAMPUSES -2.3x +Why GBSB Global -22% + Malta Campus -3.5% + Barcelona Campus -7% + Madrid Campus -1.7% + Online Campus -28% +Malta’s campus is located in a residential area of +the island’s central region, only 15 minutes by bus +from the seaside and the capital city. The campus +neighborhood, Birkirkara, has grown over the years and become +an important commercial center, it’s also one of the oldest and +most populated cities in the island. So, it is full of shops, local bars, +and coffee shops where students can study and enjoy their free +time. -9.9% +GBSB Global’s Malta Campus boasts 7 classrooms, +a well-appointed library and resource center and an +inner courtyard. -2017 +There is also a beautiful garden where most of our social activities +take place, and where the students can unwind and relax. -2030E +Barcelona campus is located in the heart of the city, +in the vibrant Eixample neighborhood. The campus +is set in a modern, bespoke building to guarantee effective and +comfortable learning. -HNWI financial wealth4 +Our Barcelona campus maximizes over 1000 meters of +academic space which includes smart classrooms +furnished with sophisticated technologies, a library +with a collection of scholarly resources, a multi- +purpose dining area, and an on-campus computer +laboratory. Individual study nooks, co-working spaces, meeting +and conference rooms and a charming landscaped garden terrace +are all available to students attending our school. -USDtrn +The Madrid campus is located in the university +area of the Spanish capital, just a 10 minute walk +from the metro station “Cuatro Caminos” in the city +center. The campus neighborhood is full of student residences +and local bars where students can study and enjoy their free time. -2.0x +Facilities in all campuses include: +● Computers and space for individual work +● A print and photocopy service +● Vending machines +● Meeting rooms +● Comfortable, co-working spaces +● Free Wi-Fi in all facilities -2014 +Online Campus offers our acclaimed programs +online. Take advantage of GBSB Global’s anytime, +anywhere approach to business education today. +This state-of-the-art campus offers students the flexibility to study +for their degree on their terms. Earn an upstanding degree from a +school that is transforming the way in which education is provided +today. -2016 +This Online Campus offers all the same degree programs that +would be available to you face to face. Benefit from our world-class +faculty, diverse student body and network opportunities from +around the world. -2021E +50 -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 +51 -2017 + Why GBSB Global -2025E +CAMPUSES -17 +52 -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities +53 -1C + Why GBSB Global -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia +LATEST DIGITAL INNOVATIONS +& TEACHING METHODS ->USD1bn +GBSB Global has been at the forefront of +developing and applying learning technologies +in the classroom. Faculty, staff, and students +have pioneered technologies that enhance +visualization, facilitate knowledge mapping, +integrate games into learning, and advance the +digital humanities. ->0.4bn +We seek to encourage and enable faculty and students to use the +Microsoft Office 365 for Education platform and other digital tools, +such as those described below, through knowledge dissemination, +training, and support. ->0.1bn +GBSB Global Business School is proud to be one of the leading +institutions in Europe to respond to the challenges of the 21st +century. Most of our classrooms are equipped with digital +blackboards, students can use special mobile apps to help them +manage their learning process, and the latest teaching methods +such as Lego ® Serious Play ®, Rapid Prototyping, and Design +Thinking are widely used to develop creative and entrepreneurial +abilities of our students. + +Classroom Interactive Touchscreen (Digital +Blackboards) + +The Digital Interactive Classroom is packaged with a robust +infrastructure that helps students to stand globally competent +with the help of state-of-the-art technology, bringing tomorrow’s +education to us today. The set-up includes a giant Interactive +Touchscreen which allows a lecturer to write directly on the screen +– on top of any digital content – just like pen on paper. It doesn’t +get any easier or more intuitive. The touchscreens immediately +provide handwritten input to any PC or Mac of all students. -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today +Video Wall + +Students at our Barcelona campus can enjoy a giant video +wall. Video wall enables better communication within GBSB +Global’s community as it displays announcements, latest news, +achievements, and institutional videos. -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 +Virtual Learning Environment -Opportunities and areas of investment +Lego ® Serious Play ® -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +The LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® Method is a technique which +improves group problem solving. By utilizing visual, auditory and +kinesthetic skills, the Method requires participants to learn and +listen, and it provides all participants with a voice. The Method +serves as a shared language regardless of culture or position. Each +participant builds his or her own 3D LEGO® model in response +to the facilitator´s questions using specially selected LEGO® +elements. These 3D models serve as a basis for group discussion, +knowledge sharing, problem solving and decision making. -USD +Virtual Learning Environment enables students to request +different academic services without the use of paper or personal +interaction. Additionally, students can track the status of the +request and value the services received. -Wealth in -Asia +Online Classroom in a Mobile App -Private -Bank +Virtual learning environment for Education allows students to +access their online classroom and to consult assignments, class +notes, readings, send messages to instructors, etc. from anywhere +by installing an easy to use mobile app. -RBWM -Wealth +Creativity Enabled Classrooms -Insurance1 +Almost all classrooms at GBSB Global contain easy to move tables +which facilitate hands-on experiments. A typical class incorporates +lecture, experiments, discussion questions, visualizations, and +pencil-and-paper exercises. -Asset -Management1 0.3 +54 -1. +55 -Includes manufacturing revenue only + Why GBSB Global -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) +EXTRA-CURRICULAR +ACTIVITIES - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater +ACCOMMODATION -China +Why GBSB Global - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth +Welcome Events -0.7 +Cultural Events - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by +The GBSB Global Business School Welcome Event is one of the +school’s main traditions, gathering together all new and current +students and professors before each intake. Whether we choose to +celebrate at a glamorous rooftop bar, at an exciting club, or even +on a boat, we know you will enjoy the experience! -investment in RM and product platform +Beyond local culture, we invite everybody to celebrate different +holidays and festivals from various cultures such as Christmas, +Halloween, The Color Festival and Chinese New +Year. GBSB Global also hosts different events like International +Culinary Nights where students bring food from their home +countries to share with others and really feel as part of the +international family. - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary +Once you have been accepted as a student at GBSB Global, you +will receive our complete Accommodation Guide, a brochure +detailing every platform we recommend using to arrange your +new room, apartment or home. -portfolio management and lombard lending +GBSB Global Business School offers several +research +to +resources +accommodation. Based on +individual +requirements, there are various options available. -Insurance +students +your - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth +help -customers, and strengthen front line +The accommodation guide includes: - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new +Student Residences +Assisted Online Search Platforms +Help Finding a Private Room/Apartment +How to Get Around -distribution channels +Sports Events - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +Excursions and Guided Tours -Asset management +GBSB Global also organizes football games, beach volleyball +tournaments, and is open to any other sports and activities that +are interesting for the students. - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / +GBSB Global regularly offers students excursions and trips nearby +and abroad. -GPB customers +Student room in Melon District residence hall, an official GBSB Global partner - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +56 -18 +57 -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities + ADMISSION PROCESS +& REQUIREMENTS 2 -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 - -USD - -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion - -Opportunities and areas of investment - - HSBC is positioned for - -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 - - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: - -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme - -– More than 95% of technical - -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed - -Retail -banking - - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by - -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 - - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth - -and acquire new customers - - Leverage our unique global access to support - -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs - -Corporate -banking - - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ - - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) - -Digital and -customer -satisfaction - - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for - -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification - - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) - - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines - -and brands +An admissions officer will +schedule an interview with you -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite - -19 +1 - Strategic priorities +Contact the Admissions +Office by filling out an +online request form or get +in contact with an agency +representative 3 -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Investments are delivering - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance - -Trade Finance -rank1 - -Hong Kong -market share2 - -2015 - -2017 - -#1 - -#1 - - - -10.8% - -13.8% - -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management - -Average GLCM -balances - -c$470bn - -c$530bn - -Hong Kong -market share3 - -22.8% - -26.3% - -FX corporates -rank4 - -FX institutional -rank4 - -#1 - -#7 - - +Send the documentation +required by the program -#1 +Passport -#3 +CV / Resume -Assets under -custody +High School +Diploma -$6.2trn +Proof of +English +Proficiency** -$7.7trn +Motivational +Letter -FX +Student +Card +Photo -Securities -Services - -Digitise and grow Trade Finance - - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems - - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by - -investing in our channel and product capabilities - - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured - -trade - -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM - - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by - -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions - - Create new products and revenue streams - new - -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees - -FX business growth - - Grow the business through the continued development - -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model - - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise - -the customer experience - -Grow Securities Services business - -Market share5 - -5.4% - -5.8% - - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products - -Asia rank6 - -#1 - -#1 +4 -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey +Enroll and +confirm your place -and services; invest in digital future +Welcome to +GBSB Global +Business School - +HOW TO APPLY - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on +Admission Process and Requirements -asset managers and asset owners +58 -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making +59 -up c.82% of the market + For entry to year 1 of the program students should +have completed: -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen +Proof of Proficiency in the English Language -20 +English as a native language; - Strategic priorities +a) -4 +A/S or A levels at the appropriate level or the Matriculation +Certificate Exam with three subjects exams with grades of A, +B, C or D; -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank +TOEFL – Minimum score: 213 (computer based), 79/80 (internet +based), or 550 (paper based); -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn + IELTS – Minimum score: 6.0; -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed +Cambridge ESOL, Certificate in Advanced English (CAE) – +Minimum score: C; -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US +English as the language of instruction during previous +studies in the formal educational system; -2 +Internal English level testing at GBSB Global. -1 +OCT -0 +JAN APR -US +Annual Intakes +October, January & April -UK +b) -China +c) -France +International Baccalaureate Diploma with 34 points overall or +the IB Diploma with specific achievement in higher/standard +level subjects; -% of Group client outbound revenue +GCSE/IGSCE “O” Levels: five subject exams with grades of +A, B, C or D, and A/S or A Levels: three subject exams with +grades of A, B, C or D; -Hong -Kong +d) -24% +AP Program; -13% +e) -9% +Other high school leaving certificate or equivalent (other +educational systems). -6% +Alternative Entry Routes -6% +Alternative entry routes are available for applicants who do +not possess the standard entry qualifications but have certain +appropriate skills and experience and subject knowledge. These +are detailed in the IQA Manual of GBSB Global within the +“Policies for Admission of Transfer Students and Recognition of +Prior Learning”. -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +The Admissions Committee may consider applications from +suitably qualified students currently attending other universities, +applicants who have achieved a lower level award, or applicants +seeking admission based on Recognition of Prior Learning (RPL). -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +An advanced student is a student who, having successfully +completed an approved program of study and received an award, +is admitted at an appropriate point of an approved program in +a similar field of study to GBSB Global. This generally applies in +cases where a student has completed a lower level award and +subsequently wishes to register for a related higher-level award; -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +A transfer student is a student who, having successfully +completed a part of an approved program of study at another +institution of higher education, is admitted to GBSB Global at +an appropriate point on an approved program in a similar field +of study; -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +A recognition of prior learning student is a student +who is admitted to an approved program at GBSB Global with +credits accumulated from prior certificated learning or via prior +experiential learning. Such prior learning should be relevant/ +applicable to the intended program of study and may allow +exemption from specific modules. -Other +60 -32% +61 -51% + Connect with +GBSB Global -68% - -USD - -JP -Morgan - -Citigroup - -Bank of -America - -HSBC - -BoNY -Mellon - -c.19% - -Overall - -Hong Kong - -Germany - -UK - -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) - -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT - -21 - -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities - -4 - -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform - -The US has made progress over the past several years… - -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth - -Adjusted PBT1, USDm - -RoTE2 - -> 6%2 - -1,201 - -974 - -CML - -US Principal - -464 - -494 - -737 - -920 - -556 - -387 - -2014 - -2015 - -2016 - -2017 - -0.9%2,3 - -2017 - -PBT growth - -Future capital -actions - -2020 - -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration - -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild - - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 - - International client revenue4 booked in the US up - -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY - - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: - -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly - -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion - -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- - -return products and business banking - -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national - -clients in the US - - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in - -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions - - Return to regular dividend payments to Group - -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers - -22 - -to 2017 - - Strategic priorities - -5 - -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 - -GB&M - -34% - -CMB - -35% - -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre - -14% -2% -15% - -c.30% - -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth - -c.35% - -Distribution - -15-20% - -2020 -target - -c.7% - -RWA -optimisation - - Develop distribution - -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending - - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom - -23 - - Strategic priorities - -6 - -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment - -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness - - Investments aligned to strategic priorities - - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term - - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and - -31.1 - -c.4 - -4.5-5 - -5.5-6 - -6-6.5 - -revenue development - - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from - -within the cost base of the Group - -Revenue - -Total -operating -expenses - -Investments - -Costs (ex -investments) - -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity - - Implement strong cost discipline and control - -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market - -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains - -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity - - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each - -year 2018-2020 - -2017 - -2018 - -2019 - -2020 - -Jaws1 - -positive - -positive - -positive - -positive - -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve - -24 - - Strategic priorities - -7 - -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework - -Investment -categories - -Description - -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 - - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) - - Investments in new - -opportunities - - Improve operational - -efficiency in order to lower -cost base - - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 - - Deliver robust solution design - -with additional franchise -benefits - - Turnaround of existing businesses - -(e.g. US) - - Investing in expanding our businesses - -(e.g. PRD) - - Productivity programmes - -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) - - Core infrastructure replacement or - -modernisation (e.g. US) - -c.1/3 - - Implement required - - Deliver in cost - - Implement regulatory programmes - -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security - -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits - -(e.g. IFRS 9) - - Strengthen capabilities to manage - -financial crime risk - - Increase cyber security measures - -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 - -USD15-17bn - -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities - -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure - -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability - -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers - -1. P&L basis - -25 - - Strategic priorities - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation - -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end - -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days - - Strengthen accountability, decision- - -to 10 (Private Banking) - -making - - Clarify roles within the organisation’s - -matrix - -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients - -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 - - Building capabilities for continuous - -improvement - -Streamlining governance - - Reducing number of - -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 - - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance - - Embed throughout the organisation - -and for all legal entities - -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership - - - -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working - - Balanced scorecards to incentivise - -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation - -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online - - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills - -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC - -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of - -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and - -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths - - Build a diverse workforce - -26 - - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates - -Strategic priorities - -Targeted outcome by 2020 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and - - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian - -franchise - - Market share gains in 8 scale markets - -Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy - - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network - - Market share gains - - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from - -international network - - Market share gains in Transaction Banking - -Turn around our US business - - US RoTE >6% - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial - -crime standards - - Increase in asset productivity - - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, - -each financial year - - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 - -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics - -27 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -28 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 - -Reported RoTE walk1 - -% - -8.7 - -6.8 - -2017 -Reported - -Sig items - -2017 ex- -sig items - -Interest -rate rises2 - -UK -growth - -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance - -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network - -US turn- -around3 - -Investments - -Other4 - -ROE -Reported - -5.9% - -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval - -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items - -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency - - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology - ->11 - - Delivering positive - -adjusted jaws - - Increasing capital - -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity - - Sustaining dividend, - -supported by share buy- -backs5 - - With >14% CET1 ratio - -2020 -Reported -(target) - ->10% - -29 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution - -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 - -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders - -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 - -12-13% - -Surplus equity3 - -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 - -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses - -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally - -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 - -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items - -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing - -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base - -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes - ->14% - -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval - -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D - -s -r -o -t -c -a -f - -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e - -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R - -Higher risk weights -under local rules - -Diversification -benefit / other - -Stress testing - -Anticipated -regulatory changes - -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. - -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators - -30 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion - - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest - -growth markets - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and - -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular - -in Asia and from our international network - -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - -- Complete the turnaround in the US - -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while - -delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for - -sustained dividends - -31 +Complete +Program List - 32 +BACHELOR OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Entrepreneurship +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Communication & PR +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Marketing +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Fashion & Luxury Business +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Finance & FinTech +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Sports and eSports Management + +MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION +MBA General +MBA in Marketing Management +MBA in International Business +MBA in Entrepreneurship +MBA in Finance +MBA in Operations & Supply Chain Management + +MASTER OF ARTS PROGRAMS +MA in Fashion & Luxury Business Management +MA in Communication & Future Marketing +MA in Tourism & Hospitality Management +MA in Business Innovation + +MASTER OF SCIENCE PROGRAMS +MSc in Entrepreneurship +MSc in Finance +MSc in Operations & Supply Chain Management +MSc in International Business Management +MSc in Marketing Management +MSc in Digital Business +MSc in Digital Marketing & Ecommerce +MSc in Financial Management, Digital Banking +& Internet Finance +MSc in Sports Management + +Malta Campus +67 Old Railway Track, +BRK, Birkirkara, Malta + +Madrid Campus +C/Numancia 6 +28039 Madrid, Spain + +Barcelona Campus +C/Aragon 179 +08011 Barcelona, Spain + +www.global-business-school.org +admissions@global-business-school.org +Tel: +34 930 185 473 + +62 diff --git a/q253/random_k4/question.json b/q253/random_k4/question.json index decded84749ad7fcb97cc1e6e3f1f59eedaa0d10..8e94fcf76715f147d236f0b6f915a27b2914ccd0 100644 --- a/q253/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q253/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ADOBE_2015_10K.pdf", - "0a89b981c2736e87bac48a090e1a3e60dd8a4e0f.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf", - "web_9c7f968fcc2ae28a.pdf", - "web_db15f36044519c81.pdf" + "web_d3b2a69cee942fe5.pdf", + "web_0047db342bad4270.pdf", + "web_bdce50920f7f48d8.pdf", + "resize_r2_26.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q253/random_k4/random_1.md b/q253/random_k4/random_1.md index 16de3e3316b1e3bb316b878e17b05640d996b000..c906bff4a2b28ca8e5a69ef8758f9182d084ead4 100644 --- a/q253/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q253/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1070 +1,1633 @@ -SPD-RAG: Sub-Agent Per Document Retrieval-Augmented Generation -| | YagizCanAkay1 | | | MuhammedYusufKartal1 | | | EsraAlparslan1 | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | FarukOrtakoyluoglu1 | | ArdaAkpinar2 | | | | | | | -1TOBBUniversityofEconomicsandTechnology 2OSTIMTechnicalUniversity -{y.akay, m.kartal, ealparslan, fortakoyluoglu}@etu.edu.tr 230206003@ostimteknik.edu.tr -| | | Abstract | | | andcommon,yetexposecriticalcoverageandrea- | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -soningbottlenecksincurrentNLPsystems. -Answeringcomplex,real-worldqueriesoften -6202 raM 9 ]LC.sc[ 1v92380.3062:viXra Traditionalsingle-indexorsingle-agentretrieval -requiressynthesizingfactsscatteredacrossvast -| | | | | | systemsstruggleto | | maintainbothscalability | | | | and | -| -------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | corpora. | In these | settings, | stan- | | | | | | | | -contextualrelevanceoverlarge,heterogeneouscor- -| dard retrieval-augmented | | | generation | (RAG) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | pora, especially | | for long | or structurally | | complex | | -pipelinessufferfromincompleteevidencecov- -erage,whilelong-contextlargelanguagemod- documents. Standard RAG pipelines retrieve a -| | | | | | fixed number | | of documents | K | and process | | them | -| ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -| els (LLMs) | struggle | to reason | reliably | over | | | | | | | | -massive inputs. We introduce SPD-RAG, a withinasinglecontextwindow(Lewisetal.,2020), -hierarchicalmulti-agentframeworkforexhaus- -whichfailswhenanswersdependoninformation -tivecross-documentquestionansweringthatde- -distributedacrossmanydocuments,sinceevidence -composestheproblemalongthedocumentaxis. -| | | | | | beyondthetop-K | | resultsistypicallydiscardedin | | | | | -| ---- | -------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ----------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --- | -| Each | document | is processed | by a | dedicated | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | a single | retrieval | pass. | Long-context | | LLMs | ex- | -document-levelagentoperatingonlyonitsown -content,enablingfocusedretrieval,whileaco- tendcontextwindowsto128K–2Mtokens(Gemini -| | | | | | Teametal.,2024), | | butempiricalevidenceshows | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ordinator | dispatches | tasks | to relevant | agents | | | | | | | | -and aggregates their partial answers. Agent thatreasoningqualitydegradessignificantlyascon- -outputsaresynthesizedbymergingpartialan- text length increases (Liu et al., 2023). This sug- -swersthroughatoken-boundedsynthesislayer -| | | | | | gests that | the | bottleneck | is not | only | retrieval, | but | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | -(whichsupportsrecursivemap-reduceformas- -alsoreasoningatscaleovermanydocumentsand -| sivecorpora). | | Thisdocument-levelspecializa- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -hundredsofthousandsoftokens. -tionwithcentralizedfusionimprovesscalabil- -ityandanswerqualityinheterogeneousmulti- In this work, we introduce SPD-RAG -| | | | | | (Sub-agent | per | Document | Retrieval-Augmented | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | settings | while | yielding | a modular, | | | | | | | | -extensibleretrievalpipeline. OntheLOONG Generation),ahierarchicalmulti-agentarchitecture -benchmark (EMNLP 2024) for long-context forexhaustivemulti-documentquestionanswering -multi-document QA, SPD-RAG achieves an thatfactorstheproblemalongthedocumentaxis -AvgScoreof58.1(GPT-5evaluation),outper- -| | | | | | rather than | the | task axis. | Instead | | of forcing | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -formingNormalRAG(33.0)andAgenticRAG -| | | | | | single model | | to hunt through | | a massive | | global | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -(32.8)whileusingonly38%oftheAPIcostof -| | | | | | index, SPD-RAG | | uses | a central | coordinator | | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -afull-contextbaseline(68.0). -| | | | | | decompose | the | user’s | query into | shared | instruc- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -1 Introduction tions. It then deploys a dedicated, cost-efficient -| | | | | | sub-agenttoeachdocumentinthecorpus. | | | | | | These | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -Large language models (LLMs) and the agentic agents operate entirely in parallel, treating their -systems built around them are increasingly used assigneddocumentsasisolatedretrievaluniverses -forcomplexinformationsearchtasks(Guoetal., -| | | | | | to extract | relevant | findings. | Finally, | | a synthesis | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -2024). Real-worldquestionsoftenrequiresynthe- -| | | | | | model | aggregates | these | document-grounded | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -sizingevidencescatteredacrossmanydocuments, findings—employingarecursivemergingfallback -suchasassessingacompany’sfinancialrisksacross -| | | | | | for exceptionally | | large | corpora—to | | construct | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | -yearsofreportsorintegratingfindingsfrommul- -| | | | | | comprehensive, | | final answer. | | Our codebase | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | -tiplescientificpapers.1 -| | | Suchquestionsarenatural | | | datasetsusedinthispapercanbefoundat | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -https://github.com/NebulAICompany/ -| 1Examples | inspired | by scenarios | in the | Loong bench- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| mark(Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | | SPD-RAG. | | | | | | | - -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: tasks,butthatmulti-agentoverheadgrowssuperlin- -early. Theirresultthatindependentagentsamplify -• WeproposeSPD-RAG,ahierarchicalmulti- -errorsby17.2×comparedto4.4×forcentralized -agentframeworkthatcombinesper-document -systemsdirectlymotivatesourcoordinator-based -agentic RAG with a centralized synthesis design. Thetaxonomyofhierarchicalmulti-agent -layer, where cost-efficient document agents systemsbyMoore(2025)furtherclassifiesdesign -| are coordinated | by a | smarter coordinator | | | | | | | -| --------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | patternsalongfiveaxes: | | controlhierarchy,informa- | | | -agent,enablingdocument-levelspecialization -| | | | | tion flow, | role delegation, | temporal | layering, | and | -| ----------------- | -------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| and parallel | execution | while allowing | each | communicationstructure. | | | | | -| document | to be analyzed | in depth | to ensure | | | | | | -| that all relevant | information | is incorporated | | | | | | | -2.2 LongDocumentandMulti-DocumentQA -withoutmissingcriticalevidence. -| | | | | Long documents | that | exceed | LLM context | win- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -• WeevaluateontheLoongbenchmark(Wang -| | | | | dows are | often handled | via | divide-and-conquer | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -etal.,2024a),whichincludesmulti-document -| | | | | strategies. | LLM×MapReduce(Zhouetal.,2025) | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| QA instances | over financial | reports | and aca- | | | | | | -| | | | | formalizestwokeychallenges: | | | inter-chunkdepen- | | -| demic papers | with an | average of | 11 docu- | | | | | | -dency(onechunkdependsoncontextfromanother) -mentsperinstanceandcontextlengthsfrom -andinter-chunkconflict(chunksprovidecontradic- -| 10K to beyond | 250K | tokens, and | show that | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -toryinformation),andproposesstructuredinforma- -oursystemsubstantiallyoutperformsstandard -tionprotocolsandin-contextconfidencecalibration -RAGandAgenticRAGbaselinesunderGPT- -| | | | | tomitigatethem. | ToM(Guoetal.,2025)extends | | | | -| -------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | --------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | -| 5-judged | Avg Score (adapted | from | Loong’s | | | | | | -| | | | | this approach | with a | hierarchical | DocTree | repre- | -GPT-4-judgedprotocol;see§4.3),withgains -sentationforrecursivereasoning. -| of around | +25 points | (76% higher | average | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Formulti-documentQA,LongAgent(Zhaoetal., -score)comparedtoNormalRAGandAgentic -| | | | | 2024) splits | a 128K-token | document | | into chunks | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | -RAGbaselines. -| | | | | assigned | to member | agents, with | a leader | agent | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ----- | -| | | | | orchestrating | discussionsand | | inter-membercom- | | -• Weanalyzeablations,documenttypeandtask -complexityeffects,andcost–qualitytradeoffs, munication to reduce hallucinations. However, -showingthat SPD-RAGattainsover85%of LongAgenttargetsasinglelongdocumentrather -thanmultipleindependentdocumentsthatmaycon- -| full-context | baseline quality | at roughly | 38% | | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | flict. DocAgent | (Sun | et al., 2025) | uses | a multi- | -oftheAPIcost. -| | | | | agent framework | that | mimics | human | reading via | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | -2 RelatedWork -atree-structuredoutlineandrevieweragent,while -| | | | | MDocAgent | (Han et | al., 2025) | employs | five spe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | -2.1 LLM-BasedMulti-AgentSystems -| | | | | cialized | agents for multi-modal | | document | under- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -LLM-basedmulti-agentsystemsareincreasingly -standing. -| used for complex | task solving. | Guo et | al. (2024) | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -provideacomprehensivesurveyofagentprofiles, -2.3 HierarchicalandRecursive -communicationprotocols,andcollaborationstrate- -Summarization -| gies. Hierarchical | architectures | such | as MegaA- | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -gent(Wangetal.,2024b),whichdemonstratesau- Ourhierarchicalmergingmechanismbuildsontree- -tonomouscooperationamongupto590agentsvia basedretrievalandrecursivesummarization. RAP- -multi-leveltaskdecomposition,andAgentOrches- TOR(Sarthietal.,2024)recursivelyembeds,clus- -tra(Zhangetal.,2025),whichachievesstate-of-the- ters, and summarizes text chunks to construct a -artperformanceonGAIAusingacentralplanning bottom-uptreewithmultipleabstractionlevels;re- -agent and specialized sub-agents, exemplify this trievingfromtheappropriatelevelyieldsa20%ab- -| trend. | | | | soluteaccuracygainonQuALITY.OuandLapata | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Scalinglawsformulti-agentsystemsofferquan- (2025)showthathierarchicalmergingcanamplify -titativeguidanceforarchitecturedesign. Kimetal. hallucinationsduringrecursivesummarizationand -(2025)evaluate180configurationsacrossfivear- proposecontext-awareaugmentationstrategiesthat -chitectures, finding that centralized coordination replaceintermediatesummarieswithrelevantinput -yields an 80.9% improvement on parallelizable context,whichweadoptinourmergingprotocol. - -2.4 Graph-BasedDocumentAnalysis 3 Methodology -Figure 1 presents an overview of the SPD-RAG -Graph-based document analysis is particu- -architecture. Thesystemprocessesaquerythrough -larly effective for global sensemaking queries. -three layers: the Coordination Layer (§3.1), the -GraphRAG(Edgeetal.,2024)constructsaknowl- -ParallelRetrievalLayer(§3.2),andtheSynthesis -edge graph of entities and relations from source -Layer(§3.3). -documents and applies hierarchical community -detection(e.g.,theLeidenalgorithm(Traagetal., -3.1 CoordinationLayer -2019)) to obtain multi-level communities with -Given a query q and corpus D, the system first -textual summaries. At query time, it retrieves -processes the query through a coordinator agent. -relevant communities, elicits community-level -The coordinator’s role is to decompose the user -partial answers, and aggregates them via a -query into a Shared Instruction Set for Docu- -map–reduce–styleprocedure. AsurveyonLLM- -ments and Synthesis Directives. It generates a -empoweredknowledgegraphconstruction(Bian, -WriteTodosstructuredobjectcontaining(a)alist -2025) highlights how LLMs are reshaping the -of sub_agent_todos: atomic, self-contained ex- -classical knowledge graph pipeline across three -traction tasks specifying exactly what fields, en- -key stages: ontology engineering, knowledge -tities, or numeric values to extract (the shared in- -extraction, and knowledge fusion. Our work is -structions);and(b)asynthesis_directive(2–4 -complementary: instead of inducing an explicit -sentences) instructing the downstream Synthesis -knowledge graph, SPD-RAG operates directly -Layeronhowtoprioritizeandstructurethemerged -over agent-produced textual summaries and -response. -performs similarity-guided recursive synthesis -acrossmanydocuments. 3.2 ParallelRetrievalLayer -Weassignadedicatedsub-agentα toeachdocu- -i -mentd inthecorpus. Eachsub-agentoperatesas -2.5 BenchmarksforMulti-Document i -anindependentRAGloopoveritsassigneddocu- -Reasoning -ment,guidedbythesharedinstructionsetfromthe -The Loong benchmark (Wang et al., 2024a) CoordinationLayer. -evaluates long-context LLMs on extended multi- -Document-Scoped Retrieval and Reasoning. -document QA where every document is relevant -Each document d serves as an isolated retrieval -i -("Leave No Document Behind") across financial, -universe; the assigned sub-agent is strictly con- -legal, and academic domains in English and Chi- -strainedtosearchtoolcallswithind , preventing -i -nese. Itspansfourtasktypeswithcontextlengths -cross-documentdistractorchunksfromdegrading -from 10K to over 250K tokens, and even strong -local extraction. Each sub-agent receives the -frontier models achieve only modest Avg Scores -originalqueryq,itsassigneddocumentname,and -andmediumperfect-answerrates,underscoringthe -thesharedinstructionset(todolist),thenoperates -difficultyofreasoningovermanylong,all-relevant -in an iterative retrieve-and-reason loop. On each -documents. -turn, the agent either issues a search action (a -Complementarydatasetsprobeotheraspectsof focused query string) or a finalize action that -multi-document reasoning. MoNaCo (Wolfson terminates the loop and emits the document- -et al., 2025) focuses on natural questions over groundedfindings. Thesub-agentpromptinstructs -dozensofWikipediapages,MEBench(Linetal., the agent to attempt at least 2 focused searches -2025)onhigh-entity-densityQA,FanOutQA(Zhu before concluding a piece of information is -et al., 2024) on multi-hop questions with absent, with a total cap of 5 search calls across -long cross-document evidence chains, and all tasks. Each search action triggers dense -HoloBench (Maekawa et al., 2024) on database- vector retrieval over the sub-agent’s dedicated -style aggregation over unstructured text. Taken per-documentQdrantindex. ThisretrievalusesCo- -together, these benchmarks show that scalable hereembed-v4.0embeddings(1536-dimensional, -multi-document reasoning remains an open cosine similarity) to fetch the top k = 15 most -challenge,withLoongemphasizingtheespecially similar chunks. These chunks are then re-ranked -demandingall-relevant,long-contextregime. byCoherererank-v4.0-fasttoyieldafinalset - -| | | | | Figure1: | OverviewofSPD-RAGArchitecture. | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of top_n = 5 chunks per search. The documents Similarity-Ordered Merge & Synthesis. -t, -are split into chunks offline using LangChain’s In iteration we maintain a set of find- -RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter in Mark- ings/summaries S(t) = {s (t) ,...,s (t) }. We -| | | | | | | | | | | | 1 | n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downmodewithachunksizeof1000tokensand embed each summary using Cohere embed-v4.0 -| 250-tokenoverlap. | | | | | | | and compute | | a cosine-similarity | | | matrix | via | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -sklearn.metrics.pairwise.cosine_similarity. -| FindingsOutput. | | | Wedenotethefindingsofeach | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | This | is converted | | to a | distance | matrix | | -sub-agentas -| | | | | | | | | | | (t) (t) | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | D = | 1 − | cos(s | ,s ), | which | is passed | to | -| | | | | | | | ij | | | i j | | | | -o = α (q,d ) = ⟨s ,r ⟩ (1) AgglomerativeClustering with n_clusters=1, -| | | i | i i | i | i | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | linkage="average" | | | (UPGMA), | | producing | a | -| where | s is | the natural | | language | findings | re- | | | | | | | | -i -completedendrogramoverallcurrentsummaries. -| port from | d | and | r ∈ | [0,1] is | a scalar | rele- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | -| | i | | i | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | We traverse | the | merge | tree | bottom-up, | greedily | | -| vance/confidencescore. | | | Theseoutputsarepassed | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | accumulating | | nodes | into a batch | as | long as | the | -totheSynthesisLayer. -| | | | | | | | total tiktoken | | count | does not | exceed | the target | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | -| Parallelism. | | All | RAG | loops for | the | docu- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | budget | of B | = 750,000 | tokens. | | Semantically | | -ments are dispatched concurrently via Lang- similarsummariesaregroupedfirst,soeachbatch -Graph’s Send API fan-out, which emits one contains the most similar available summaries -| Send("document_sub_agent_node", | | | | | ...) | per | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withinthetokenlimit. -documentandexecutesalltargetsinparallelwithin -LangGraph’sasyncruntime. AggregateandSynthesizeFindings. Foreach -batch,anLLMispromptedwiththeconcatenated -3.3 SynthesisLayer -| | | | | | | | findings, | the synthesis | | directive, | and | the original | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -WhilemodernLLMsfeatureextensivecontextwin- queryq toproduceanaggregatedandsynthesized -dows,synthesizinghundredsofdocumentreports -| | | | | | | | summary. | Allbatchsynthesiscallswithinanitera- | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -can still exceed these limits or cause ’lost in the tionareissuedconcurrentlyviaasyncio.gather. -middle’degradation. Tofuture-proofthearchitec- Themergedsummariesformtheinputforthenext -| ture for | massive | corpora, | | the Synthesis | Layer | is | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | iteration | S(t+1). | The | same | SYNTHESIS | prompt | | -designedasadynamicmap-reducepipelinethatag- -| | | | | | | | used at | every | level | of the | merging | tree is | ap- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | -gregatesfindingsrecursively. TheSynthesisLayer plied even at the final level—there is no separate -receives the synthesis directives from the Coor- synthesis-onlyprompt. -| dination | Layer | and | the findings | {o | ,o ,...,o | } | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 1 2 | n | | | | | | | | -from the Parallel Retrieval Layer. It aggregates ContextSizeConditionandOutput. Thelayer -andsynthesizesthefindingsrecursivelythrougha evaluates whether the total findings size exceeds -similarity-orderedprocessuntilthetotalfindings the context size threshold (i.e., |S(t+1)| > 1). If -sizefallswithinthetargetcontextsizetoproduce theconditionistrue,theprocessloopsbacktothe -thefinaloutput. similarity-orderedmergeandsynthesisstep. Ifthe - -Algorithm1RecursiveSynthesis Locating, Comparison, Clustering, or Chain of -Reasoning,withcontextlengthsrangingfrom10K -| Require: | FindingsS | = {s ,...,s | },queryq, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | 1 | n | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | to beyond | 250K | tokens. | | We evaluate | | on the En- | -synthesisdirectived,contextsizebudgetB -Ensure: FinalOutputs⋆ glishandSet4(200k-250ktokens)portionofthe -| | | | | | benchmarkonly. | | Ourevaluationsetcomprises40 | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1: while|S| | > 1do | | | | | | | | | | | -instancesinvolvingacademicpapersand62involv- -| 2: E | ← COHEREEMBED(S) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -D ← 1−COSINESIMILARITY(E) ingfinancialreports(102instancestotal),withthe -3: -tree ← AGGLOMERATIVECLUSTER( fourtasktypesdistributedas: SpotlightLocating -4: -(27),Comparison(15),Clustering(49),andChain -| | D, linkage | = “average”) | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofReasoning(11). -| 5: batches | ← | GROUPBYTOKENS( | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | S, tree, | B) | | | | | | | | | | -4.2 Baselines -| 6: if|batches| | | ≥ |S|then | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | We compare | | against | the | following | systems, | all | -| 7: | batches ← | [S] | | | | | | | | | | -| endif | | | | | backedbyGemini2.5Pro: | | | | | | | -8: -| 9: S | ← ASYNCGATHER( | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | • Baseline(FullContext): | | | | | Alldocumentsfor | | -| | SYNTHESIZE(b,q,d)∀b | | ∈ | batches) | | | | | | | | -eachinstanceareconcatenatedandprovided -10: endwhile -directlyinthecontextwindowofGemini2.5 -| return | S[0] | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -11: -Pro,representingtheoraclelong-contextup- -perbound. -conditionisfalse(thetotalfindingssizeiswithin -• NormalRAG:Standardvectorsearchtop-K -thecontextsize,leavingasinglefinalsummarys⋆), -| | | | | | retrieval | | over | the full | document | | corpus, fol- | -| ----------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | -| the process | terminates | and yields | s⋆ | as the final | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | lowed | by | LLM | reasoning | | over the | retrieved | -| | If|S(t+1)| | |S(t)|(no-progresscase),the | | | | | | | | | | -| output. | | ≥ | | | | | | | | | | -chunks. -entirecurrentlevelisforcedintoasinglebatchto -guaranteetermination. -| | | | | | • Agentic | | RAG: | A single-agent | | ReAct-style | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -Algorithm1givesthepseudocodeforthegeneral RAG system (implemented via Lang- -recursivesynthesisprocedure. Graph/LangChain) that can issue multiple -| | | | | | iterative | | retrieval | calls | over | the | full global | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| BehavioronLoong. | | Inpractice,withGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | -Pro’s 1M-token context window and a budget of corpus. It uses the same embedding and -| | | | | | re-rankingpipelineas | | | | SPD-RAG,butlacks | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -B = 750,000tokens,thecombinedsub-agentfind- -per-documentspecialization. -ingsforallinstancesinourLoongevaluationsetfit -withinasinglebatch,sotheconditionalcheckal- -4.3 EvaluationMetrics -| lowedoutputafteroneiteration. | | | Therecursiveloop | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | We report | the | following | | metrics, | following | the | -isthereforeadesigncapabilityintendedformuch -Loongevaluationprotocol(Wangetal.,2024a): -largercorpora,wheretotalfindingssizegenuinely -exceedsthecontextsize. -| | | | | | • Avg | Score: | An | LLM-judged | | score | (0–100) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -measuringthedegreetowhichthepredicted -4 ExperimentalSetup -| | | | | | answer | | accurately | covers | | the gold | answer, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | -4.1 Dataset -| | | | | | following | | the | evaluation | protocol | | of Loong | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | (Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | 2 | | | -WeevaluateSPD-RAGontheLoongbenchmark -| (Wangetal.,2024a). | | Loongisanextendedmulti- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------ | ----------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | • PerfectRate(PR%): | | | | Percentageofqueries | | | -| document | QA instances | in both | English | and Chi- | | | | | | | | -wherethesystemreceivesaperfectscoreof -| nese, with | an average | of 11 documents | | per test | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -100. -| casespanningtworeal-worldscenarios: | | | | financial | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -reports and academic papers. Each test case is 2BecausetheoriginallegacyGPT-4modelAPIisunavail- -ablefornewscaledevaluations,weadoptGPT-5astheeval- -constructedsothateverydocumentisrelevantto -| | | | | | uator. Recent | literature | | increasingly | | adopts | GPT-5 as the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------------ | -the final answer ("Leave No Document Behind", standard for LLM-as-a-judge protocols due to its superior -meaningacorrectresponserequiressynthesizing alignmentwithhumangrading(Wolfsonetal.,2025).While -ourbaselinenumbersarere-computedunderthisGPT-5judge -evidencefromallprovideddocuments),andisan- -forstrictfairness,rawscoresmaynotbeperfectly1-to-1com- -notated under one of four task types: Spotlight parablewiththeoriginallypublishedLoongleaderboard. - -• AvgTokenUsage: Meanper-querytotal(in- Cost tracking. Per-query costs are computed -put+output)tokenusage. fromLangSmithrunmetadata(totaltokencounts -×per-tokenpricing. -| • Avg | Cost | (USD): | Mean | per-query | | API cost, | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| enablingcost-efficiencycomparisons. | | | | | | | 5 Results | | | | | | -5.1 MainResults -| • AvgLatency(s): | | | Meanper-querywall-clock | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time. -Table1reportsthemainresultsacrossallsystems -| | | | | | | | on our Loong | evaluation | | set. | Figure | 2 illustrates | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | -4.4 ImplementationDetails -theseperformancedifferencesacrossthefourspe- -| AllsystemsuseGemini2.5Pro(temperature0.0) | | | | | | | cifictasktypes. | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -asthebackboneLLMforthecoordinator,merging SPD-RAGachievesanAvgScoreof58.1,sub- -| layer, and | synthesis | | layer. | SPD-RAG | | document | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stantiallyoutperformingbothNormalRAG(33.0) -| sub-agents | use | Gemini | 2.5 | Flash | for | document- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | and Agentic | RAG | (32.8). | | This corresponds | to | -scopedretrieval,reducingper-documentcostwhile roughly a 25-point absolute improvement (about -preserving reasoning quality at the merging and 76% relative gain) over standard RAG baselines. -| synthesisstages. | | GPT-5isusedexclusivelyasthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | Furthermore, | SPD-RAG | | more | than | doubles the | -LLMjudgefortheevaluationoftheAvgscoreand Perfect Rate (PR) of Agentic RAG (18.6% vs. -is not part of the pipeline itself. Prompts for all 8.8%),indicatingthatexhaustivedocument-level -| systems, | including | baselines, | | were | optimized | for | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -processingmorefrequentlycapturesthecomplete -informationextractionandsynthesistoensurefair set of required facts. Notably, the Agentic RAG -comparison. Fullprompttemplatesforallsystems baseline,despiteconsuming∼3×moretokensthan -areprovidedinthecoderepository. NormalRAG,doesnotyieldscoreimprovements, -suggestingthatuninstructediterativeretrievalwith- -| Indexing. | Each | | document | | is | pre- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | out per-document | | specialization | | does | not effec- | -| indexed | into | a | dedicated | | Qdrant | vec- | | | | | | | -tivelyaddressthecoveragechallengeinexhaustive -| tor | collection | | using | | LangChain’s | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | multi-document | | settings. | While | the | full-context | -| RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter | | | | | | (Imple- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | baseline | attains | the highest | | quality with | an Avg | -mentationdetailsareprovidedintheAppendix.). -| | | | | | | | Score of | 68.0, | SPD-RAG | reaches | 85.4% | of this | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | -Retrievalpersub-agent. Eachsearchtoolcall performancewhileconsumingonly37.9%ofthe -performs dense vector retrieval over the docu- API cost, demonstrating a highly favorable cost- -| | | | | | | | quality trade-off. | | The | full-context | baseline | pro- | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | -| mentindex,returningthetop-K | | | | | (k = 15)chunks | | | | | | | | -using cosine similarity in Qdrant. These can- vides a strong upper bound that benefits from all -didates are subsequently re-ranked with Cohere documents in one pass. Despite this, SPD-RAG -narrowsthegapto9.9pointswhilecostingless. -| rerank-v4.0-fast,andthetoptop_n | | | | | = | 5chunks | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -arepassedtothesub-agentLLM. -5.2 AnalysisbyTaskType -| Merging | layer. | The | token | budget | | per merge | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Table2breaksdownperformancebyLoong’sfour -| batchisB | = 750,000tokens(75%ofGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tasktypes. -| Pro’s1Mcontextcap). | | | Agglomerativeclustering | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thetask-typebreakdownrevealsaclearpattern. -usessklearnwithUPGMAlinkageandprecom- -| | | | | | | | For Spotlight | Locating—which | | | requires | finding | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -putedcosine-distancematrix. -asinglesalientfactacrossdocuments—allRAG- -| | | | | | | | based systems | | perform | reasonably | well | (69–74), | -| ------------- | --------------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | -| Parallelism. | | Documentagentsrunconcurrently | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | while the | full-context | | baseline | leads | (86.6). The | -| via LangGraph | | Send | API | fan-out. | Batch | synthe- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | largest gaps | between | | SPD-RAG | and | the RAG | -| sis calls | within | each | merge | iteration | | are paral- | | | | | | | -| | asyncio.gather. | | | | | | baselinesappearinClustering(+40.5ptsoverNor- | | | | | | -| lelized | with | | | | Synchronous | Co- | | | | | | | -malRAG)andChainofReasoning(+26.2ptsover -hereAPIcallsareoffloadedtothethreadpoolvia -| | | | | | | | Agentic RAG), | | tasks | that require | aggregating | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -asyncio.to_thread. -reasoningoverevidencefrommanydocumentssi- -Safety limits. Each document sub-agent’s iter- multaneously. Ontheotherhand,itnearlymatches -ative retrieval loop is capped at 5 iterations; the the full-context baseline (42.2 vs. 42.7) on Com- -| AgenticRAGbaselinecapsat10iterations. | | | | | | | parisontasks. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -System AvgScore PR(%) AvgInputTok AvgTotalTok AvgCost($) AvgLatency(s) -OracleLong-ContextBaseline -| Baseline(FullContext) | | 68.0 | 31.4 253,085 | 255,345 | 0.273 | 45.6 | -| --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -RAGBaselines -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 13.7 22,174 | 27,430 | 0.080 | 42.6 | -| ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 8.8 81,877 | 85,290 | 0.098 | 40.6 | -OurSystem -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 18.6 193,954 | 205,683 | 0.103 | 54.8 | -| ------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -Table1: MainresultsonourLoongevaluationset(102instances: 40academicpaper,62financialreport). Bold: -| bestoverall. | Underline: | bestamongRAG-basedsystems. | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2: ComparisonofAverageScoreacrossthefoursystems,brokendownbytasktype(SpotlightLocating, -Comparison,Clustering,andChainofReasoning). -5.3 AnalysisbyDocumentDomain -| As shown | in Table 3 | and Figure | 3 the domain | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -breakdownexposesastrikingfailuremodeofstan- -| dard RAG: | both Normal | RAG and | Agentic RAG | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -achieve0%PRonacademicpaperinstances(Avg -| Scoresof15.2and16.8,respectively). | | | Academic | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -paperinstancesinLoongtendtoinvolvelong,tech- -nicaldocumentswithdistributedevidence,making -top-K retrievalespeciallysusceptibletocoverage -failures. SPD-RAGdramaticallyrecoversonthis -domain(60.0AvgScore),closingmostofthegap -| with the | full-context | baseline (78.8). | On finan- | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3: Averagescorebydocumentdomaincompar- -cialreportinstances—whichtendtobeshorterand ingtheBaseline(FullContext),NormalRAG,Agentic -morestructured—allRAG-basedsystemsperform -RAG,andSPD-RAGsystems. -better,andthegapbetweenSPD-RAG(56.9)and -thebaseline(61.0)issmaller. - -| | System | | SpotlightLoc. | | Comparison | Clustering | ChainofReasoning | | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (n=27) | | (n=15) | (n=49) | | (n=11) | | | | -Baseline(FullContext) 86.6/55.6% 42.7/26.7% 67.1/14.3% 60.9/54.5% -| | NormalRAG | | 69.7/37.0% | | 37.7/26.7% | 15.4/0.0% | | 14.8/0.0% | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | AgenticRAG | | 73.4/22.2% | | 23.3/20.0% | 16.7/0.0% | | 17.9/0.0% | | | | -| | SPD-RAG | | 74.2/44.4% | | 42.2/20.0% | 57.2/4.1% | | 44.1/18.2% | | | | -Table2: AvgScore/PR(%)byLoongtasktype. EachcellshowsAvgScore/PR%. -| | | | | | Crucially, | thearchitectureof | | | SPD-RAG | | enables | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | -| System | | Paper(n=40) | Financial(n=62) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | this | cost efficiency: | | by constraining | | retrieval | to | -| Baseline | | 78.8/30.0% | 61.0/32.3% | | | | | | | | | -NormalRAG 15.2/0.0% 44.5/22.6% isolated,single-documentspaces,wecanreliably -| AgenticRAG | | 16.8/0.0% | 43.1/14.5% | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -offloadtheiterativereasoningtoacheapermodel -| SPD-RAG | | 60.0/7.5% | 56.9/25.8% | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | (Gemini | 2.5 Flash). | | In contrast, | | global | iterative | -baselinesrequirethereasoningcapacityofafron- -Table3: AvgScore/PR(%)bydocumentdomain. -| | | | | | tier | model (Gemini | 2.5 | Pro) | to navigate | | the fully | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -concatenatedcorpus,drivingupcosts. -| System | | AvgScore | AvgCost($) | Score/$ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | -| Baseline | | 68.0 | 0.273 | 249.1 | | | | | | | | -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 0.080 | 412.5 | 6 | Discussion | | | | | | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 0.098 | 334.7 | | | | | | | | -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 0.103 | 564.1 | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | WhereSPD-RAGexcels. | | | | Thetask-typeresults | | | -| | | | | | in Table | 2 confirm | our | core | hypothesis: | | architec- | -Table4: Cost–qualitytradeoff. -turaldecompositionalongthedocumentaxisyields -| | | | | | the largest | gains | precisely | | for tasks | that | require | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | | | exhaustive | multi-document | | | synthesis. | Clustering | | -5.4 Cost–QualityTradeoff -tasks(+40.5overNormalRAG)andChainofRea- -| | | | | | soning | tasks (+26.2 | over | Agentic | | RAG) | both de- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ---- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -mandthatthesystemformacoherentanswerfrom -evidencedistributedacrossallrelevantdocuments— -exactlythescenarioforwhichper-documentagents -| | | | | | aredesigned. | ForLoong’sComparisonquestions, | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -theanswerisprimarilydeterminedbyreadingout -asmallsetofcomparablenumericattributesfrom -| | | | | | each | report and | aggregating | | them, | so once | docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | ment | agents have | extracted | | those | fields, | the syn- | -| | | | | | thesizer | is effectively | | operating | over | a structured | | -table,whichhelpsexplainwhySPD-RAG’sscore -onComparisontasks(42.2)nearlymatchesthefull- -Figure4: Cost–Qualitytradeoff. Thescatterplotillus- contextbaseline(42.7). -tratestheParetofrontierformulti-documentQA. -| | | | | | Remaining | gap | with | the | full-context | | baseline. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -SPD-RAG outperforms the RAG baselines in Despite strong gains over RAG baselines, SPD- -the cost–quality trade-off. It achieves a 76% RAG lags the full-context baseline by 9.9 Avg -higheraveragescorethanNormalRAG(58.1vs. Score points overall. Three factors likely con- -33.0)whileincreasingtheper-querycostbyonly tribute: (1) Gemini 2.5 Flash, used for document -$0.023 (Table 4). In contrast, Agentic RAG is agents due to its cost efficiency, may provide -Pareto-dominated, as it incurs higher cost than weaker agentic reasoning capabilities compared -NormalRAG($0.098vs.$0.080)whiledelivering to larger models. (2) The coordinator’s sub-task -nearlyidenticalquality(32.8vs.33.0). Compared generation may under-specify queries for highly -tothefull-contextbaseline,whichachievesanAvg technical academic content, leading to incom- -Score of 68.0, SPD-RAG reaches 85.4% of the pleteinformationextractionatthedocument-agent -qualityatonly37.9%ofthecost, resultingina level. (3) The maximum context length observed -2.25× improvement in cost–quality efficiency. inLoongquerieswasapproximately250ktokens— - -onlyabout25%ofthe1M-tokencontextwindow onthecoordinator’sabilitytogeneratecomprehen- -of Gemini 2.5 Pro—potentially limiting the pres- sivesub-tasks: under-specifiedtasksleadtoincom- -sureonthefull-contextbaseline. SinceSPD-RAG plete document-level extractions, as observed on -isdesignedtooperateonsubstantiallylargercon- technicalacademicpaperinstances. Ourevaluation -texts,itsadvantagesmaybecomemorepronounced islimitedtotwodomains(academicpapersandfi- -undermoreextremelong-contextconditions. nancialreports)fromtheLoongbenchmark;legal, -medical,orenterprisedocumentcorporamayhave -| RAG baseline | | failure | on papers. | | The 0% | PR | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -differentstructuralcharacteristicsthatalterrelative -| rate and | 15.2-16.8% | | Avg Score | of | both Normal | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -performance. -| RAG and | Agentic | RAG | on | academic | paper | in- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ThesynthesislayerofSPD-RAGisdesignedto -top-K -| stances | highlights | a systematic | | failure | of | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -handlecorporawherethecombinedsub-agentout- -| retrieval | under | dense, | distributed | evidence. | | Aca- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -putsexceedthemodel’scontextwindow,triggering -| demic | papers | in Loong | often | require | synthesiz- | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -multi-roundsimilarity-basedclusteringandrecur- -ingfactsspreadacrossabstracts,methods,results, -| | | | | | | | sive synthesis. | | In our Loong | experiments, | | how- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | ---- | -andappendicesofmultipledocuments—aregime -ever,Gemini2.5Pro’s1M-tokencontextwassuffi- -| where exhaustive | | per-document | | coverage | proves | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -cienttoprocessallsub-agentsummariesinasingle -| highly | effective. | The | recovery | by SPD-RAG | | to | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | merge step, | so | this recursive | path | was | never acti- | -60.0AvgScore/7.5%PRinthisdomaindemon- -| | | | | | | | vated. Asaresult,thescalabilitypropertiesofthe | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stratesthepracticalvalueofper-documentspecial- -recursivesynthesispipeline—itsimpactonanswer -ization. -| | | | | | | | quality, | redundancy | reduction, | | and cost | as docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Latencyoverhead. SPD-RAG incursamodest mentcountsgrowintothehundredsorthousands— -latency overhead (54.8 s vs. 40.6–45.6 s for the remainempiricallyunvalidated. EvaluatingSPD- -| baselines), | primarily | | due to | its multi-agent | | archi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RAGonmuchlargercorpora,andideallyonanew -tecture. Although document agents run in paral- benchmarkspecificallytargetinghundredstothou- -lel,end-to-endlatencyisstillgatedbythelayered sands of documents per query instance, is an im- -pipeline, which requires at least three sequential portantdirectionforfutureworkthatwouldmore -LLM calls (coordination, per-document retrieval, directlytesttheper-documentagentdesignandthe -andsynthesis)ratherthanasinglepass. intendedlarge-databaseregime. -| | | | | | | | 8 Conclusion | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | We presented | | SPD-RAG, | a hierarchical | | multi- | -| | | | | | | | agent framework | | designed | for | exhaustive | multi- | -| | | | | | | | documentquestionanswering. | | | Byassigningaded- | | | -icatedagenticRAGmoduletoeachdocumentand -mergingtheirfindingsthroughasimilarity-ordered, -| | | | | | | | token-bounded | | tree, our | system | effectively | miti- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | gatesthelimitationsofbothtraditionaltop-K | | | | | re- | -| | | | | | | | trieval (incomplete | | coverage) | and | isolated | long- | -| | | | | | | | context | processing | (degraded | reasoning | | at scale). | -Figure5: Averageper-querylatencyacrosssystems. ExperimentsonthechallengingLoongbenchmark -demonstratethatSPD-RAGachievesanaverage -scoreof58.1,outperformingNormalRAG(33.0) -7 LimitationsandFutureWork -andAgenticRAG(32.8)byapproximately25ab- -SPD-RAG incurs higher per-query LLM call solute points (76% higher average score), while -countsthansingle-passsystems—onecallperdoc- operating at only 37.9% of the API cost of the -ument agent plus a final synthesis step—which oracle full-context baseline (68.0). These per- -increasestotaltokenusagecomparedtostandard formance gains are most pronounced in tasks re- -RAGbaselines,thoughitremainsatroughlyone- quiring deep cross-document synthesis—such as -thirdthecostofthefull-contextbaseline($0.10vs. Clustering(+40.5points)andChainofReasoning -$0.27perquery)duetotheuseofGemini2.5Flash (+26.2points)—aswellasondenseacademicpa- -fordocumentsub-agents. Systemqualitydepends perswherestandardRAGmethodsentirelyfail. - -Ultimately, our findings demonstrate that for TaichengGuo,XiuyingChen,YaqiWang,RuidiChang, -complex information-seeking queries over large ShichaoPei,NiteshV.Chawla,OlafWiest,andXi- -| | | | | | | | angliangZhang.2024. | | | Largelanguagemodel-based | | | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| corpora, | how | information | | is processed | is | crucial. | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | multi-agents: | | Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. | | | | -Specifically,ensuringthateachdocumentreceives -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2402.01680. | | | ArXiv:2402.01680. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -exhaustive,dedicatedagenticattentionprovestobe -| | | | | | | | Siwei Han, | Peng | Xia, Ruiyi | Zhang, | Tong | Sun, Yun | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------- | -amoreeffective,cost-efficient,andscalablestrat- -| | | | | | | | Li, Hongtu | Zhu, | and | Huaxiu Yao. | 2025. | MDocA- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | -egythansimplyexpandinghowmuchrawcontext -gent: Amulti-modalmulti-agentframeworkfordoc- -asinglemodelcanconsumeinonepass. umentunderstanding. Preprint,arXiv:2503.13964. -ArXiv:2503.13964. -9 EthicsStatement -| | | | | | | | Yubin Kim, | Ken | Gu, Chanwoo | Park, | Chunjong | Park, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -SPD-RAG is a retrieval-augmented generation SamuelSchmidgall,A.AliHeydari,YaoYan,Zhi- -hanZhang,YuchenZhuang,MarkMalhotra,PaulPu -| framework | intended | | to improve | access | | to infor- | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liang,HaeWonPark,YuzheYang,XuhaiXu,Yilun -| mation | distributed | across | | large document | | collec- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Du, Shwetak | | Patel, Tim | Althoff, | Daniel | McDuff, | -tions. ThesystemreliesoncommercialLLMAPIs and Xin Liu. 2025. Towards a science of scal- -(Gemini2.5,Cohere),andaswithanyLLM-based ing agent systems. Preprint, arXiv:2512.08296. -ArXiv:2512.08296. -| pipeline, | outputs | may | contain | factual | errors | and | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -should not be treated as authoritative without hu- PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio -man verification. The increased number of API Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- -| | | | | | | | richKüttler, | | MikeLewis, | Wen-tauYih, | | TimRock- | -| --------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | -| calls per | query | relative | to | single-pass | systems | re- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | täschel, | Sebastian | Riedel, | and | Douwe | Kiela. 2020. | -| sults in | higher | energy | consumption, | | a | cost that | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Retrieval-augmented | | | generation | for | knowledge- | -should be weighed against the accuracy gains in intensiveNLPtasks. InAdvancesinNeuralInforma- -deploymentdecisions. Ourbenchmarkevaluations tionProcessingSystems. -| are conducted | | on publicly | | available | datasets | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | TengLin, | YuyuLuo, | HonglinZhang, | | JichengZhang, | | -involvenohumansubjectsorpersonaldata. Dur- Chunlin Liu, Kaishun Wu, and Nan Tang. 2025. -ingthepreparationofthismanuscript,AI-assisted MEBench: Benchmarkinglargelanguagemodelsfor -| | | | | | | | cross-documentmulti-entityquestionanswering. | | | | | In | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -writingtoolswereusedtohelprefinelanguageand -ProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethods -| improveclarity. | | Allresearchdesign,experiments, | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -inNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). -analysis,andfinaldecisionsregardingthecontent -NelsonF.Liu,KevinLin,JohnHewitt,AshwinParan- -wereconductedandverifiedbytheauthors. -jape,MicheleBevilacqua,FabioPetroni,andPercy -| | | | | | | | Liang.2023. | | Lostinthemiddle: | | Howlanguagemod- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | elsuselongcontexts. | | TransactionsoftheAssociation | | | | +This copy is for personal use only. To order printed copies, contact reprints@rsna.org + +1733 + +Fluoroscopic Swallowing Examination: +Radiologic Findings and Analysis of +Their Causes and Pathophysiologic +Mechanisms + +Alberto I. Carbo, MD +Melanie Brown, CCC-SLP +Nour Nakrour, MD + +Abbreviations: CP = cricopharyngeus, HLC = +hyolaryngeal complex, PES = pharyngoesopha­ +geal segment, UES = upper esophageal sphincter + +RadioGraphics 2021; 41:1733–1749 + +https://doi.org/10.1148/rg.2021210051 + +Content Codes: + +From the Departments of Radiology (A.I.C., +N.N.) and Rehabilitation Services (M.B.), Ochs­ +ner LSU Health, 1501 Kings Hwy, Shreveport, +LA 71103. Presented as an education exhibit +at the 2020 RSNA Annual Meeting. Received +March 7, 2021; revision requested April 19 and +received May 14; accepted May 23. For this jour­ +nal­based SA­CME activity, the authors, editor, +and reviewers have disclosed no relevant rela­ +tionships. Address correspondence to A.I.C. +(e­mail: acarbo1396@gmail.com). + +©RSNA, 2021 + +SA-CME LEARNING OBJECTIVES + +After completing this journal-based SA-CME +activity, participants will be able to: + „Discuss the anatomy and imaging +phases of swallowing. + + „Describe abnormalities detected at +fluoroscopic swallowing examination. + + „Correlate the radiologic findings +with their causes and pathophysiologic +mechanisms. + +See rsna.org/learning-center-rg. + +Dysphagia is a common symptom in the general population, and its +prevalence increases with patient age. The deterioration of swallow­ +ing function has many acute and chronic causes, including cerebro­ +vascular and neuromuscular diseases, radiation, and surgery. In an +elderly population, diagnosis and treatment of swallowing abnor­ +malities is a high priority because it improves the patient’s quality +of life and helps them to avoid medical complications. Fluoroscopic +swallowing examinations and modified barium swallow studies are +the most used and most reliable diagnostic procedures to evaluate +swallowing disorders. Functional anomalies include disturbances +of the oral preparatory, oral propulsory, and pharyngeal phases +of swallowing as premature spillage from the mouth, nasal regur­ +gitation, delayed initiation of pharyngeal swallowing, incomplete +displacement of the hyolaryngeal complex, abnormal epiglottic +tilt, incomplete laryngeal closure, and pharyngeal dysmotilities. +Anatomic abnormalities of the pharynx include diverticula, be­ +nign strictures, and tumors. The abnormalities diagnosed on the +basis of fluoroscopic examination have a variety of treatment strat­ +egies, and the choice of treatment depends on the cause of the +anomaly and its pathophysiologic characteristics. The radiologist’s +interpretation of these characteristics is crucial to therapeutic de­ +cision making and achieving the best patient outcomes. + +Online supplemental material is available for this article. + +©RSNA, 2021 • radiographics.rsna.org + +Introduction +Oropharyngeal dysphagia is prevalent in 20% of the general popu­ +lation and in 50% of nursing home residents in the United States +(1). As the average age of the population continues to increase, +there has been an increase in dysphagia and related complications. +Fluoroscopically guided swallowing examinations are the most used +technique for evaluation of deglutition disorders. The examination is +called modified barium swallow when the diagnostic study includes a +therapeutic test; in those cases, it is performed with the participation +of a swallowing therapist or speech­language pathologist (2). + +Fluoroscopic examination of swallowing and modified barium +swallow should not be routine studies but should be custom­tailored +techniques designed by radiologists and swallowing therapists on +the basis of the patient’s clinical history and symptoms. Radiolo­ +gists should supervise or participate in the procedures and contrib­ +ute their knowledge to adapt the technique to unexpected findings +detected during examinations. They may decide during the study +to include the evaluation of organs such as the esophagus that may +explain or be associated with the patient’s symptoms. The radiologic + +GASTROINTESTINAL IMAGING + + 1734 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +TEACHING POINTS + „ Fluoroscopic examination of swallowing and modified barium +swallow should not be routine studies but should be custom- +tailored techniques designed by radiologists and swallowing +therapists on the basis of the patient’s clinical history and +symptoms. Radiologists should supervise or participate in the +procedures and contribute their knowledge to adapt the tech- +nique to unexpected findings detected during examinations. +They may decide during the study to include the evaluation of +organs such as the esophagus that may explain or be associ- +ated with the patient’s symptoms. + + „ For evaluation of the function of the PES, radiologists should +correlate the following functional units: (a) the opening of the +PES, (b) the elevation of the HLC, and (c) the pharyngeal con- +traction. Understanding the different possible mechanisms +that cause the abnormal function of the segment is essential +in deciding the best treatment strategies. + + „ As part of the fluoroscopic swallowing examination, a system- +atic evaluation of the air-filled structures and soft tissues of the +neck may provide information about the causative or associ- +ated abnormalities relating to the patient’s symptoms. + + „ The development of Zenker diverticula may involve anatomic +and pathophysiologic causes that include an area of wall +weakness, a distal obstruction due to the diminished opening +of the CP, and increased pharyngeal intraluminal pressure as a +consequence of mechanical obstruction of the outlet. + + „ The radiologic report should include all detected abnormali- +ties and should not be limited to description of the visualiza- +tion of penetration or aspiration. Because each abnormality +has its own specific therapeutic approach, the description +of radiologic findings and their correlation with the patho- +physiologic mechanisms and possible causes should be stated +clearly in the report. A meticulous radiologic diagnosis facili- +tates the decision making of referring physicians and swallow- +ing therapists. + +report should describe all the findings additional +to penetration or aspiration and present the facts +in a way that facilitates decision making by the +referring physicians and swallowing therapists. + +This article reviews the anatomy and physiol­ + +ogy of swallowing, explains the indications for +and techniques of fluoroscopic examination, +describes abnormal radiologic findings, and dis­ +cusses their pathophysiologic mechanisms. + +The discussion includes the abnormalities +of the pharyngoesophageal segment (PES) as +diminished or delayed opening and early clos­ +ing and the pathophysiology of the pharyngeal +residue after swallowing, penetration, and +aspiration. Complications of total laryngectomy +are examined, such as leakage, pseudoepiglot­ +tis, anterior pharyngeal pouches, neopharyngeal +dysmotilities, strictures, and malfunctioning +of the tracheoesophageal prosthesis for voice +reconstitution. We describe the radiologic find­ +ings of each abnormality and provide sample +images and a discussion of the possible mecha­ +nisms, with consideration of the patient’s clinical +history. + +Anatomy for Radiographic +Interpretation + +The oral cavity is bounded by the hard and soft +palates superiorly, by the tongue inferiorly, and +opens to the oropharynx posteriorly. The nasophar- +ynx or epipharynx is bounded by the pharyngeal +walls posteriorly and laterally, by the skull base su­ +periorly, and by the soft palate inferiorly. It opens +to the nasal cavity anteriorly and communicates +with the oropharynx inferiorly through the palato­ +pharyngeal isthmus or velopharyngeal seal. + +The oropharynx or mesopharynx is bounded +posteriorly and laterally by the pharyngeal walls +and constrictor muscles and inferiorly by the su­ +perior surface of the epiglottis and the hyoid bone. +It communicates with the nasopharynx superiorly +and with the mouth anteriorly. The laryngophar- +ynx or hypopharynx is bounded by the pharyngeal +walls posteriorly and laterally and extends to the +lower border of the cricoid cartilage inferiorly. It +communicates with the oropharynx superiorly, +with the cervical esophagus inferiorly, and with the +laryngeal vestibule anteriorly (3–6) (Fig 1). + +Phases of Swallowing + +Oral Preparatory Phase +The oral preparatory phase involves chewing the +food and mixing it with saliva. When the bolus +is considered “swallowable,” it is placed between +the upper surface of the tongue blade and the +palate. The tip of the bolus is held by a seal +formed by the tongue and the soft palate that +prevents premature leakage into the pharynx +before swallowing (7,8) (Fig 2A). + +Oral Propulsory Phase +During the oral propulsory phase, the bolus is pro­ +pelled into the oropharynx by means of an up­ +ward and backward movement of tongue. During +the passage of the bolus, the soft palate elevates +to a right angle to oppose the contraction of the +posterior and lateral pharyngeal walls that form +the Passavant ridge to close the palatopharyngeal +isthmus and prevent the penetration of material +into the nasopharynx (Fig 2B). + +Initiation of Pharyngeal Swallow +The next phase is the initiation of the pharyngeal +swallow, when the bolus passes the pharyngeal +pillars and enters into the oropharynx, triggering +the reflex that initiates the nonvoluntary pharyn­ +geal phase of swallowing. + +Pharyngeal Phase +In the pharyngeal phase, the hyolaryngeal complex +(HLC) elevates and shortens the pharynx, de­ +flects the epiglottis, closes the larynx, and opens + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1735 + +the PES (Fig 2C). Laryngeal closure starts in the +true vocal folds, followed by the false vocal folds, +and ends in the laryngeal vestibule. Concurrently, +the stripping contraction wave of the posterior +and lateral pharyngeal walls begins and propels +the bolus into the esophagus. + +PES Opening Phase +The PES opening phase consists of (a) relaxation of +the upper esophageal sphincter (UES); (b) upward +and anterior traction of the cricoid cartilage, which +is attached to the HLC; and (c) opening of the +lumen by means of increased intrabolus pressure +by the thrust of the dorsum of the tongue and the +pharyngeal constrictors (Fig 2D) (9). + +Esophageal Phase +The esophageal phase begins when the bolus is +propelled through the esophagus into the stom­ +ach by means of esophageal peristalsis. Once +the bolus passes into the esophagus, (a) the +palatopharyngeal isthmus opens, reestablishing +the communication between the nasopharynx +and oropharynx and allowing the passage of air; +(b) the HLC returns to resting position; (c) the +larynx opens; (d) the epiglottis returns to upright +position; (e) the PES closes, and (f) respiration +resumes (Fig 2E). + +Indications for Fluoroscopic +Swallowing Examinations +Common indications for fluoroscopically guided +swallowing examinations are oropharyngeal +dysphagia (swallowing difficulty); globus sensa­ +tion; choking and coughing during swallowing; +prolonged intubation; cerebrovascular events (ie, +stroke); and surgery, trauma, or radiation treat­ +ments to the head and neck (10). + +Figure 1. +Illustration +shows the anatomy of +the pharynx. + +Fluoroscopic Swallowing Examination +Technique +The equipment used includes a radiologic appa­ +ratus with fluoroscopy and video recording with +slow motion, reverse, and stop­frame capabili­ +ties (2,10–13). The patient should be upright +or seated in a comfortable position, with their +dentures in their mouth. + +Lateral views are the most useful to evaluate +all phases of swallowing and to detect penetra­ +tions into the airway. Oblique views are per­ +formed to visualize the PES without the shoulder +in the way. Frontal views are used to diagnose +asymmetric swallowing abnormalities. + +Use of short exposure times and high kilovolt­ +age is recommended to improve image resolution +and minimize motion blurring of the bolus and +anatomic structures. For a functional examina­ +tion, the contrast material used is barium sulfate +in a concentration of 40% to 60% weight/volume +(mass of solute/volume of solution). Multiple +barium viscosities such as thin liquid, nectar +thick, honey thick, paste, and solids are used at +the speech­language pathologist’s discretion. +Iodinated water­soluble contrast material is used +when leakages or perforations are suspected (13). +Videofluoroscopic recording is used to detect + +functional abnormalities at 30 frames per sec­ +ond. Compared with videofluoroscopic record­ +ing, rapid­sequence digital images are acquired +at fewer frames per second, but the images have +better spatial resolution and are preferred for +anatomic details. + +The personnel included in a modified barium +swallow examination are a radiographic technolo­ +gist, a radiologist, and a speech­language patholo­ +gist. The role of the speech­language pathologist +is to use strategies that may improve the efficiency + + 1736 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 2. +Illustrations show the +phases of swallowing, which include +the oral preparatory phase (A), +the oral propulsory phase (B), the +pharyngeal phase (C), the PES +phase (D), and the esophageal +phase (E). + +and safety of swallowing, to educate patients about +their swallowing function, and to provide swallow­ +ing recommendations on the basis of the radio­ +graphic findings after study completion. + +Evaluation of esophageal anatomy and motility + +is important. The anatomic site that the patient +identifies as the source of the symptoms is not +a reliable indicator of the location of the cause. +Thus, radiologic examinations of patients with +dysphagia should include a morphologic and func­ +tional evaluation of the esophagus and esophago­ +gastric junction, which may be performed before +or after the swallowing examination. + +Functional Abnormalities + +Abnormalities of Oral Preparatory Phase +The motion of the tongue is essential for bolus +manipulation and the functions of chewing, mix­ +ing food with saliva, and holding the bolus in the +mouth before swallowing. When the tongue is + +dysfunctional, images may show uncoordinated +movements, fragmentation of the bolus, inability +to hold it, and drooling and leaking of contrast +material into the sulci of the cheeks and floor of +the mouth (Fig 3). Causes of tongue failure can +be secondary to atrophy, xerostomia, surgery, or +severe nerve or brain injuries (7,14,15). + +Premature Spillage from Mouth into +Pharynx +The back of the tongue blade and the soft pal­ +ate form the glossopalatal seal, which keeps the +bolus in the mouth before swallowing. Premature +spillage from the mouth into the pharynx may be +caused by unilateral or bilateral incompetence of +the seal, which may allow leakage of material into +the pharynx before a swallowing attempt, leading +to aspiration through an opened and unprotected +airway (Fig 4). Seal ineffectiveness can be a result +of weakness, atrophy, or poor muscular coordina­ +tion of the tongue and soft palate due to aging, + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1737 + +Figure 3. Leakage into the floor of the mouth in a 77-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of the oral cavity after the swallow +shows that contrast material has leaked into the mouth floor +(large arrow) and the sulci of the cheeks (small arrows) because +of incompetence of the tongue. + +Figure 4. Leakage from the mouth into the pharynx in a +58-year-old woman. Lateral radiograph of the oral cavity and +pharynx before swallowing shows contrast material leaking +from the mouth bolus to the valleculae and hypopharynx (ar- +rows) due to incompetence of the glossopalatal seal. + +surgery, radiation, or acute and chronic neuro­ +logic illnesses. For example, patients with Parkin­ +son disease may perform repetitive unsuccessful +attempts to swallow the bolus (10,14). + +Delayed Initiation of Pharyngeal Swallow +When the bolus reaches the oropharynx, it +triggers the swallowing reflex that initiates the +nonvoluntary pharyngeal phase of swallowing. +The initiation of the pharyngeal swallow is rec­ +ognized radiographically by the elevation of the +hyoid bone as a component of the HLC. Hyoid +elevation starts when the tip of the bolus crosses +the angle of the mandible. A delayed swallowing +initiation is identified when the contrast material +is seen in the pharyngeal lumen but the hyoid +bone remains in a resting position (Fig 5). Causes +include decreased pharyngeal sensory perception +due to injury of mucosal receptors or neurologic +damage secondary to aging, radiation, a cerebro­ +vascular accident, or surgery (7,14). + +Nasal Regurgitation +The palatopharyngeal isthmus or seal should be +closed during the bolus transportation from the +mouth into the oropharynx. Nasal regurgitation +is diagnosed radiographically by evaluating pas­ +sage of the contrast material through a nonclosed +seal into the nasopharynx (Fig 6). Nasal penetra­ +tion can occur during transfer of the bolus from +the mouth to the pharynx due to incompetence +of the isthmus or after swallowing when the +seal is open and there is regurgitation from the +distal pharynx or esophagus due to an associated +distal dysfunction or mechanical obstruction. +The causes of an incompetent seal and nasal + +Figure 5. Delayed initiation of the pharyngeal swal- +low in a 55-year-old man. Lateral radiograph shows the +bolus in the oropharynx and hypopharynx (*), with the +hyoid bone still in resting position (arrow) due to a de- +layed triggering of the swallowing reflex. + +radiation, surgery, or a cerebrovascular accident. +Atrophy of the tongue or soft palate can lead +to compensatory hypertrophy of the opposite +muscle (10,14). + +Delayed or Slow Oral Propulsory Phase +When the bolus is judged to be “swallowable,” +it is placed in a midline depression in the upper +surface of the tongue blade until it is transferred +into the pharynx. A delayed initiation of tongue +propulsion or a slow transportation of the bolus +to the pharynx can be secondary to weakness or +the inability of the tongue to function because of + + 1738 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 8. Frozen pharynx in a +68-year-old woman with a his- +tory of radiation therapy. Lateral +radiograph shows absent contrac- +tions and rigidity of the pharyngeal +walls during the passage of bolus +and penetration of contrast mate- +rial into the larynx (arrow). + +Figure 6. Nasal regurgita- +tion in a 62-year-old man. +Lateral radiograph shows +contrast material penetrat- +ing into the nasopharynx +from the oropharynx (*) +during bolus displacement +because of insufficient clo- +sure of the palatopharyn- +geal isthmus. + +Figure 7. Limited elevation of +the hyolaryngeal complex in a +74-year-old man. Lateral radio- +graph during swallowing shows +that the hyoid bone (blue arrow) +did not reach the mandible at its +maximum displaced position, as is +expected in healthy patients. The +limited displacement may be due +to scarring of pharyngeal elevator +muscles from radiation treatment. +Associated findings are a poor +pharyngeal contraction, an incom- +plete closure of the larynx with +contrast material penetration (red +arrow), and a diminished opening +of the PES (yellow arrow). + +regurgitation include atrophy and insufficient +elevation of the soft palate due to neurologic +diseases, radiation, surgery, or congenital issues +such as a cleft palate or a fistula (7,14,16). An +oronasal fistula must be ruled out during the +examination. + +Slow or Incomplete Displacement +of HLC +A full upward and forward displacement of the +HLC is necessary to elevate and shorten the +pharynx, deflect the epiglottis, close the larynx, +and open the PES. The HLC is fully elevated +when the hyoid bone is seen at the level of the +inferior margin of the mandible. Slow or incom­ +plete elevation of the HLC is due to weakness of +the suprahyoid muscles and pharyngeal elevators +(Fig 7). Muscular weakness is a consequence of +atrophy and fibrosis secondary to aging, radia­ +tion, and neurologic or cerebrovascular diseases +(14). + +Weakness of Tongue and Pharyngeal +Contraction +Adequate thrust of the dorsum of the tongue +and the pharyngeal walls is required to increase +intrabolus pressure and propel the bolus into the + +Figure 9. Hypotony of the left +pharyngeal wall in a 59-year-old +woman. Frontal radiograph of the +pharynx during swallowing shows +bulging of the left pharyngeal wall +(arrowhead) and an asymmetric +tilt of the epiglottis (arrow). Find- +ings were due to a nerve injury +during surgery for resection of a +tumor in the base of the skull. + +esophagus. Unilateral or bilateral weakness or +atrophy of the muscles may prevent a timely and +complete bolus displacement. In severe cases +of atony, as with a “frozen pharynx,” the bolus +mostly moves by means of gravity (Fig 8). Lack +of appropriate contraction leaves residue in the +pharynx after swallowing and increases the risk +of aspiration. Reduced pharyngeal contraction +may be caused by muscular or neurologic dam­ +age due to radiation, surgery, or neurovascular +diseases. Weakness can be bilateral or unilateral +(Fig 9) (7,10,14,15). + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1739 + +push the bolus and a distal relaxation to al­ +low its passage. At fluoroscopy, abnormalities +of pharyngeal peristalsis are recognized by +the presence of nonpropulsive contractions +that interrupt bolus passage and fragment the +contrast material in the pharyngeal lumen (Fig +10). Residue left in the pharyngeal lumen after +swallowing can lead to aspiration. The paralysis +can be bilateral because of injury of the pharyn­ +geal innervation that is secondary to radiation, +inflammatory changes, or neurologic diseases +or unilateral because of peripheral nerve injury +during surgery (7,14). + +Limited Tilt of Epiglottis +During swallowing, the tilt of the epiglottis pro­ +tects the entrance of the laryngeal vestibule and +deflects the bolus into the lateral food pathways +(pyriform sinuses). As a consequence, an insuf­ +ficient or absent epiglottic tilt may obstruct the +passage of the bolus and risk penetration of +material into the laryngeal inlet during swallow­ +ing (Fig 11). Causes of inadequate epiglottic tilt +include insufficient displacement of the HLC, +pharyngeal or laryngeal tumors, or fibrosis due to +radiation (7,14). + +Delayed or Incomplete Laryngeal Closure +Laryngeal closure starts with and continues as +HLC displacement. It starts in an inferior to +superior direction, beginning in the true vocal +folds, followed by the false vocal folds, and end­ +ing in the laryngeal vestibule to expel penetrated +material back into the hypopharynx. Closure of +the laryngeal vestibule is recognized at fluoros­ +copy as the narrowing and disappearance of the +air column in the laryngeal lumen during the +HLC elevation. A delayed, slow, or incomplete +closure of the larynx during swallowing may lead +to aspiration (Fig 12). Failure of laryngeal closure +may result from insufficient HLC elevation, cer­ +vical surgery, laryngeal fibrosis due to radiation, +or weakness of the supraglottic adductors due to +edema or fibrosis (14,17). + +Incomplete Opening of PES +The UES is a high­pressure zone at the PES that +is formed by muscular fibers of the thyropharyn­ +geus, cricopharyngeus (CP), and circular fibers +of the proximal esophagus. The PES is normally +closed to prevent inhaled air from passing into the +esophagus and gastroesophageal reflux from enter­ +ing into the airway. It opens during swallowing to +allow passage of the bolus, vomiting, or eructation. +Opening the PES involves (a) neural relaxation of +the tonically contracted UES muscles, (b) normal +distensibility of the segment, (c) traction forces +imparted by the opening of the UES muscles, and + +Figure 10. Nonpropulsive pharyngeal contrac- +tions in a 66-year-old man. Lateral radiograph of +the pharynx during swallowing shows narrowing +of the pharyngeal lumen (arrowheads) when the +hyoid bone is still elevated (blue arrow). Because +of premature pharyngeal closure, some contrast +material was trapped in the oropharynx (*) and +penetrated the laryngeal vestibule (red arrow). + +Incomplete epi- +Figure 11. +glottis tilt in a 72-year-old man. +Lateral radiograph shows a +swelling epiglottis in upward +position during the bolus pas- +sage (arrow). As a consequence +of the insufficient tilt of the epi- +glottis, a partial obstruction of +bolus displacement and pen- +etration of contrast material +into the laryngeal vestibule (*) +are visible. + +Figure 12. +Insufficient closure +of the laryngeal lumen during +swallowing in a 69-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of +the pharynx during swallow- +ing shows an opened laryngeal +vestibule with penetration of +contrast material. Additional +findings are deformity of the +epiglottis (*), poor pharyngeal +contractions, and a stricture of +the PES (arrow) due to chemo- +therapy and radiation therapy. + +Lack of Synchronization of Pharyngeal +Contractions +Peristalsis is a wave­like involuntary contraction +of the gastrointestinal tract with the purpose +of transporting the bolus. It consists of strip­ +ping contractions of the proximal muscles to + + 1740 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Diagnosis and Treatment of Pharyngoesophageal Segment Dysmotilities + +PES Dysmotility + +PES Opening + +Mechanism + +Therapeutic Objective + +Maneuvers + +Delayed PES opening due +to slow HLC displace­ +ment + +Full opening only + +when the HLC is +completely elevated + +Delayed PES opening + +Full opening only + +Delayed initiation +of pharyngeal +swallow +UES spasm + +when UES is relaxed + +Improve speed of swal­ +lowing initiation + +Bolus stimulation + +Abbreviate the UES + +Increase bolus vol­ + +relaxation + +ume and thickness + +due to impaired UES +relaxation + +Incomplete PES opening +due to nonrelaxation of +CP (CP achalasia) + +Incomplete PES opening +due to lack of elasticity +of the CP (fibrosis) +Incomplete PES opening +due to partial displace­ +ment of HLC + +Incomplete PES opening +due to weak pharyngeal +contraction + +Early PES closure due to +premature HLC return + +Early PES closure due +to premature UES +contraction + +Incomplete + +CP nonrelaxation + +Improve CP relaxation Endoscopic dilation +Botulinum toxin A + +Incomplete + +CP lack of elastic­ +ity (fibrosis) + +PES dilation + +Incomplete + +Weakness of HLC + +Strengthening of HLC + +elevators + +elevators + +Incomplete + +Weak pharyngeal +muscular con­ +tractions + +Improvement of pha­ +ryngeal contraction + +Full opening only + +Weakness of HLC + +Increase and extend the + +when the HLC is +completely elevated + +elevators + +HLC elevation + +Full opening only + +UES spasm + +Delay the UES con­ + +when the UES is +relaxed + +traction + +injection +CP myotomy +Effortful swallow +Endoscopic dilation +CP myotomy +Mendelsohn +Effortful swallow +Shaker +Base of tongue exer­ + +cises + +Tongue hold +Mendelsohn +Increase bolus vol­ + +ume and thickness; +Mendelsohn +Increase bolus vol­ + +ume and thickness + +PES dilation + +Sources.— References 9,10,14,18–26. + +(d) intrabolus pressure generated by contraction +of the pharynx. + +Primary causes of incomplete opening of the +UES during the passage of the bolus are (a) in­ +complete relaxation of the UES (achalasia) or lack +of coordination with the pharyngeal contraction +(dyskinesia), (b) abnormal elasticity and dis­ +tensibility of the CP as result of degeneration of +muscle fibers and replacement with fibroadipose +tissue, (c) noncomplete displacement of the HLC +during swallowing, and (d) insufficient intrabolus +pressure to open the lumen due to impairment of +the tongue and pharyngeal constrictor muscles +(Table) (7,9,14,18–26). Narrowing of the PES +prevents the free and complete passage of the +bolus into the esophagus, resulting in incomplete +clearance and residue in the pyriform sinuses, +with potentially postdeglutitive aspiration. + +On a lateral view, the diminished opening of the + +PES is recognized by a posterior protrusion (CP +bar) between C3 and C6 during the trans­sphinc­ +teric passage of the bolus (Fig 13). For evaluation +of the function of the PES, radiologists should +correlate the following functional units: (a) the +opening of the PES, (b) the elevation of the HLC, +and (c) the pharyngeal contraction. Understand­ +ing the different possible mechanisms that cause + +the abnormal function of the segment is essential +in deciding the best treatment strategies. + +Delayed Opening of PES +During swallowing, the PES opens completely +upon the arrival of the bolus to allow it to pass +into the esophagus. Delayed opening of the PES +is a consequence of delayed elevation of the HLC +or retarded relaxation of the UES (Table). When +the delayed opening is due to slow or retarded +relaxation of the UES, the hyoid bone is already +elevated when the PES is still closed (Fig 14). +Because the PES remains closed on the arrival of +the bolus, there is a transient luminal obstruction +that augments the pressure and distends the lu­ +men of the proximal pharynx, increasing the risk +of aspiration (9,14). + +Early Closure of PES +The PES should only close after the bolus has +passed completely into the esophagus. A prema­ +ture closure of the PES can be due to an early +contraction of the UES before the HLC returns +to resting position and the bolus pass is finished +(Fig 15) or a premature return of the HLC to +resting position (Fig 16) (Table). An early closure +of the PES can block the bolus and leave residue + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1741 + +Figure 13. Diminished opening of the PES in +a 44-year-old woman with gastroesophageal re- +flux. Lateral radiograph of swallowing shows a +transverse filling defect in the posterior wall of +the PES, called the CP bar (yellow arrow), when +the hyolaryngeal complex is fully elevated (blue +arrow). The luminal narrowing obstructs the pas- +sage of the bolus and distends the proximal pha- +ryngeal lumen. + +Figure 14. Delayed opening +of the PES due to retarded relax- +ation of the UES in a 71-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph shows +the bolus tip at the PES entrance, +which remains closed (yellow ar- +row), even when the hyoid bone +is fully elevated (blue arrow). On +subsequent images (not shown), +the PES opened completely, allow- +ing the full passage of the bolus. + +Figure 15. Early closure of the PES due to +premature closing of the UES in a 62-year- +old man. (A) Lateral radiograph shows a +normal PES opening during the passage of +the bolus. (B) Delayed lateral radiograph +shows an early closing of the PES (arrow- +heads), while the hyoid bone is still ele- +vated (arrow in A and B). The early closure +of the PES interrupts the passage of the +bolus, leaving residue in the hypopharynx +(*), with increased risk of aspiration. + +in the pyriform sinuses after swallowing, leading +to aspiration when the airway reopens (9,14). + +Residue in Valleculae and Pyriform +Sinuses after Swallowing +After swallowing, no materials or contrast ma­ +terial should remain in the pharyngeal lumen. +Residue in the vallecullae, pyriform sinuses, +or pharyngeal walls may lead to postswallow­ +ing aspiration when respiration is resumed (Fig +17A–17C). After swallowing, pooling of contrast +material in the valleculae can result from impaired +backward movement of the dorsum of the tongue +or insufficient epiglottic tilt. Residue in the pyri­ +form sinuses may result from impaired pharyngeal +contraction, PES dysmotilities, or mechanical +obstruction. Unilateral pooling can be secondary +to paralysis of the lateral pharyngeal wall due to a +nerve or muscle injury (Fig 17D) (14). + +Penetration.—No contrast material should +penetrate the laryngeal vestibule before, during, +or after swallowing. Penetration is diagnosed at +fluoroscopy when contrast material is seen in the +laryngeal lumen. During swallowing, penetrated +material should be extruded back into the phar­ +ynx by laryngeal contraction (ie, flash penetration). +In severe cases, contrast material may remain +in the laryngeal vestibule, reach the vocal folds, +and pass into the trachea. Whenever possible, the +mechanism responsible for penetration should be +recognized during the examination and stated in +the report to allow decision making on the best +therapeutic approach. Preswallowing penetrations +are usually a consequence of delayed initiation +of the swallowing reflex. Penetrations during +swallowing can be due to one or multiple abnor­ +malities such as incomplete or slow elevation of +the HLC, epiglottis tilt, incomplete closure of the + + 1742 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 16. Early closure of the PES due to premature +return of the hyolaryngeal complex in a 55-year-old +woman. (A) Lateral radiograph shows normal open- +ing of the PES during swallowing, with the hyoid bone +fully elevated (blue arrow). An incidental finding is a +penetration during swallowing (red arrow). (B) De- +layed lateral radiograph of the same swallow shows +an early closure of the PES (arrowhead) due to a pre- +mature return of the HLC, which is evidenced by the +low position of the hyoid bone (blue arrow). The early +closure of the PES interrupted the complete passage +of the bolus and left residue in the hypopharynx (*). + +Figure 17. Residue in the valleculae and pyriform sinuses after swallowing. (A) Lateral radiograph of the pharynx in a 72-year- +old man after swallowing shows contrast material pooling in the valleculae (V) and pyriform sinuses (PS). (B) Frontal radiograph +in a 40-year-old man after spinal fixation shows bilateral residue in the valleculae (green arrows) and pyriform sinuses (red arrows). +(C) Lateral radiograph in a 67-year-old woman after swallowing shows the penetration of residual contrast material (arrowhead) into +the larynx from the pyriform sinuses (*). (D) Frontal radiograph in a 72-year-old man after right-sided skull base surgery shows residue +in the right pyriform sinus (arrow) due to unilateral deficiency of the pharyngeal contraction. + +laryngeal vestibule, or motility disorders of the +pharynx or PES. Pharyngeal residue is respon­ +sible for penetrations after swallowing (14). + +Aspiration.—Aspiration is diagnosed when con­ +trast material is seen in the tracheal lumen, below +the vocal cords (Fig 18). Aspiration is a more +severe complication than penetration and may be +minimal, moderate, or massive when the con­ +trast material reaches the carina and bronchus. +Aspirated materials in the trachea may generate +a protective cough to expel them back into the +pharynx or may be nonsensate (ie, silent). A de­ +layed or absent cough reflex is valuable informa­ +tion by which to estimate severity, because silent +aspirators have a greater risk of developing pneu­ +monia. In addition to the causes of penetration, +a delayed or insufficient closure of the vocal folds +due to edema, radiation fibrosis, or surgery of the +vocal cord adductors may contribute to aspira­ +tion. External­beam radiation treatment for neck + +cancer is a frequent cause of aspiration because it +may impair all phases of swallowing. + +Anatomic Abnormalities + +Radiography of the Neck +As part of the fluoroscopic swallowing exami­ +nation, a systematic evaluation of the air­filled +structures and soft tissues of the neck may +provide information about the causative or as­ +sociated abnormalities relating to the patient’s +symptoms. The patient should be evaluated for +(a) soft palate atrophy due to radiation or sur­ +gery or compensatory hypertrophy due to tongue +atrophy (Fig E1); (b) tongue atrophy due to +aging, radiation, or surgery (Fig E2); (c) epiglot­ +tis enlargement due to acute radiation (Fig E3), +infection, and tumors or atrophy due to radia­ +tion; (d) swelling of prevertebral soft tissues due +to chemotherapy, radiation, or surgery (Fig E4) +and tumors, abscesses, or hematomas; (e) air + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1743 + +Figure 18. Aspiration in a 77-year-old man. +Lateral view of swallowing shows contrast ma- +terial penetration into the laryngeal vestibule (*) +and aspiration into the tracheal lumen (red ar- +row) through the vocal folds (white arrows). + +Figure 19. Web in a 66-year-old +woman. Lateral radiograph of the +pharynx during swallowing shows a +thin horizontal linear filling defect in +the anterior wall of the hypopharynx +that obstructs the lumen (arrow). + +Figure 21. Pharyngeal tumor in +a 78-year-old man. Swallowing ex- +amination shows an irregular lumi- +nal narrowing of the pharynx, with +posterior displacement due to a large +infiltrating mass (arrows). + +Figure 20. Radiation stricture in +a 77-year-old man. Lateral radio- +graph of swallowing shows a short +severe luminal stricture in the phar- +ynx due to scarring (arrow), with a +mild proximal luminal distention. + +in the prevertebral soft tissues due to trauma +(Fig E5), gastrointestinal perforations (Fig E6), +diverticula (Fig E7), or in other locations as +postsurgical leakage (Fig E8); (f) soft­tissue­ +attenuation obstructive masses in the lumen of +pharynx (Fig E9), larynx (Fig E10), or PES (Fig +E11); (g) pharyngeal deformities as a nonclosed +PES at rest due to fibrosis because of radiation +therapy (Fig E12) or esophageal dilations due to +achalasia (Fig E13) or scleroderma; (h) abnor­ +mal soft­tissue calcifications; and (i) bone and +postsurgical abnormalities. + +Pharyngeal Strictures +Webs are thin mucosal folds that are frequently +seen in the anterior wall or circumference of the +hypopharynx or proximal esophagus. Webs are +associated with gastroesophageal reflux and syn­ +dromes such as Plummer­Vinson or epidermolysis +ampullosa and are seen as 2–4­mm­thick trans­ +verse linear filling defects in the hypopharynx and +cervical esophagus that may partially obstruct the +lumen and passage of the bolus (Fig 19) (27). + +Radiation strictures are a delayed complication + +of radiation due to vascular damage, ischemia, +and collagen deposition, with subsequent fibrosis +and scarring (Fig 20) (27,28). + +Cervical esophageal tumors can be seen radio­ +graphically as irregular or lobulated filling defects +protruding into the lumen of the pharynx or +larynx on radiographs or swallowing examina­ +tions (Fig 21) (27). Cervical tumors are more ac­ +curately detected and staged with cross­sectional +imaging such as CT, MRI, or PET. + + 1744 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 22. Zenker diverticulum in two patients. (A) Illustration shows a diverticulum (green arrow) +emerging from a triangular-shaped area in the posterior wall of the hypopharynx (blue and yellow ar- +rows), which was formed superiorly by the oblique fibers of the thyropharyngeus and inferiorly by hori- +zontal fibers of the cricopharyngeus. (B) Lateral radiograph during swallowing in a 74-year-old woman +shows a diverticulum in the posterior wall of the hypopharynx (red-orange arrow) above the CP bar +(yellow arrow). (C) Frontal radiograph in a 79-year-old man after swallowing contrast material shows +the diverticulum mildly displaced to the left side of the patient (*) and residue in both pyriform sinuses +(arrows). + +Zenker Diverticula +Zenker diverticula are outpouchings lined by squa­ +mous epithelial mucosa and submucosa and are +often surrounded by fibrous tissue, with absent +muscular fibers. They are located in an area of +muscular weakness called the Killian dehiscence +or the triangle of Laennec in the posterior wall of +the hypopharynx and are limited by the oblique +fibers of the thyropharyngeous superiorly and +laterally and by the horizontal fibers of the CP +inferiorly (Fig 22A). + +The development of Zenker diverticula may +involve anatomic and pathophysiologic causes that +include an area of wall weakness, a distal obstruc­ +tion due to the diminished opening of the CP, +and increased pharyngeal intraluminal pressure as +a consequence of mechanical obstruction of the +outlet. Strong evidence now shows that acquired +Zenker diverticula are, in most cases, second­ +ary to a poorly compliant but normally relax­ +ing CP muscle that cannot fully distend during +the process of sphincter opening. The increased +resistance to flow during swallowing in an attempt +to overcome the distal obstruction markedly in­ +creases the forces required to drive the passage of +the bolus. Increased intrabolus pressure imparted +to the area of relative muscular weakness (Killian +dehiscence) over many years gives rise to a poste­ +rior herniation of the pouch (27,29,30). + +Fluoroscopically, the diverticulum is seen +during and after swallowing as an outpouching + +arising from the posterior hypopharyngeal wall +above the prominence of the CP bar (Fig 22B). +In frontal views, a small diverticulum is seen in +the midline, but when it becomes larger, it may +relocate laterally, more frequently to the left side +(Fig 22C). After swallowing, the content of the +diverticulum may empty back into the hypo­ +pharynx, increasing the risk of postswallowing +aspiration. + +Pseudo-Zenker diverticula are saclike collections +of contrast material that are trapped in the same +location as that of the Zenker diverticula (27). +They are seen only after swallowing when the +pharyngeal lumen is collapsed and not when the +lumen is fully distended (Fig 23). + +Killian-Jamieson Diverticula +Killian-Jamieson diverticula are outpouchings from +the anterior lateral wall of the cervical esophagus +through a gap between the inferior margin of the +cricoid cartilage and CP and the lateral wall of +the suspensory ligament of the esophagus (Fig +24A) (27). They are seen during swallowing stud­ +ies as lateral or anterior outpouchings below the +level of the CP (Fig 24B). + +Complications of Total Laryngectomy + +Surgical Technique +Total laryngectomy is indicated for advanced or +nonradiosensitive laryngeal or cervical tumors. + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1745 + +Figure 23. Pseudo-Zenker diverticulum in a +69-year-old woman. Lateral radiograph of the +pharynx after swallowing shows an outpouching +in the location of the Zenker diverticula (arrow). +The outpouching was not identified when the +pharyngeal lumen was fully distended during the +passage of the bolus (not shown). + +Figure 24. Killian-Jamieson diverticulum in a 72-year-old +man. (A) Illustration shows a diverticulum emerging from the +anterolateral wall of the cervical esophagus (arrow) below the +CP muscle. (B) Frontal radiograph during swallowing shows a +right lateral diverticulum (arrow). + +The surgical technique consists of removal of the +hyoid bone, thyroid and cricoid cartilages, epiglot­ +tis, and vocal folds (Fig 25A), followed by recon­ +struction and closure of the anterior defect with +mucosa, pharyngeal muscles, and skin (Fig 25B). +Finally, optional vocal restoration can be achieved +through creation of a fistula between the trache­ +ostoma and the esophagus, with placement of a +silastic prosthesis of varying length and diameter +in the fistula to allow the one­way passage of air +for speech rehabilitation (Fig 25C). In patients +with the tracheoesophageal fistula, the evaluation +of prosthesis position and function and PES motil­ +ity during phonation should be included as part of +the swallowing evaluation (31–33). + +Anastomotic Leakage +Anastomotic leakage is a frequent complication +in the early postoperative period. Risk factors +include oral infection, salvage total laryngec­ +tomy, and prior radiation therapy. Leakages are +detected at a swallowing examination as blind +outpouchings outside the neopharyngeal lumen +(sinus tracts) or as an extraluminal tract of con­ +trast material that communicates with the skin +(Fig 26) (27,34,35). + +Pseudoepiglottis +A pseudoepiglottis is an enlargement of the folds at +the base of the tongue due to the pull of pharyn­ +geal constrictors when a patient attempts to swal­ +low. The abnormality is seen as an anterior linear +defect at the base of tongue and the entrance of + +neopharynx that resembles an epiglottis (Fig 27). +The fold is more prominent when the patient +swallows and may narrow the entrance of the +neopharynx and obstruct the bolus transit from +the mouth. Increased intrabolus pressure proxi­ +mal to the obstruction contributes to the forma­ +tion of a proximal pocket, where residue and food +may accumulate (27). + +Anterior Pharyngeal Pouches +Anterior pharyngeal pouches are pockets or out­ +pouchings located at the anterior wall between +the base of tongue and the neopharynx entrance. +The mechanism of formation is multifactorial, +including a localized weakness due to absence +of a muscular layer and/or increased intrabolus +pressure against a more distal mechanical or +functional obstruction. Radiologic images show +an anterior outpouching at the entrance of the +neopharynx with contrast material pooling after +the swallow (Fig 28). If the pouch enlarges con­ +siderably, it may extend into the skin, creating a +pharyngo­cutaneous fistula (36). + +Neopharyngeal Dysmotilities +Neopharyngeal dysmotilities may be secondary to +resection of the laryngeal and pharyngeal struc­ +tures that support the tongue and pharyngeal +muscles and/or due to damage of the pharyngeal +muscles and nerves by the tumor, surgery, or +radiation therapy. Dysmotilities are seen on im­ +ages from swallowing studies as a limited thrust +of the base of tongue and/or pharyngeal walls, + + 1746 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 25. Surgical technique for laryngectomy. (A) Illus- +tration shows the anatomic structures that will be removed +as the hyoid bone, epiglottis, thyroid cartilage including the +vocal folds, cricoid cartilage, and first tracheal ring. (B) Illus- +tration shows the closure of the anterior wall with mucosa, +muscles, and skin for the reconstruction of the neopharynx. +(C) Illustration shows the creation of a tracheoesophageal +fistula, with placement of a one-way prosthesis (arrow) for +voice reconstitution. + +with weakening of the pharyngeal propulsion, +impaired coordination of peristalsis, reversed +peristalsis, and outflow resistance across the +PES (Fig 29). Because of neopharyngeal dys­ +motility, bolus transit time is prolonged, and +pharyngeal clearance is incomplete, with stasis +and residue (27,36). + +total + +Figure 26. Sinus tract in +a 78-year-old man. Lateral +radiograph of swallowing +after +laryngectomy +shows a leakage from the +proximal neopharynx into +the anterior soft tissues of +the neck (arrow). + +Dysfunctions of PES +Dysfunctions of the PES should be evaluated +during and after swallowing during voice gen­ +eration. Fluoroscopically, they are seen as an +insufficient or delayed opening or early closing +of the PES (Fig 30). These findings may be a +consequence of impaired pharyngeal propul­ +sion or increased resistance at the bolus passage +through the PES due to resection of the cri­ +coid cartilage or fibrosis secondary to radiation +therapy (27,36). + +Benign Strictures +Benign strictures of the neopharyngeal lumen are +secondary to surgical scarring and/or chemo­ + +therapy and radiation therapy. The strictures may +partially or completely obstruct the bolus flow, +distending the proximal lumen and retaining ma­ +terial the patient swallows (Fig 31) (37). + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1747 + +Figure 27. Pseudoepiglot- +tis in a 78-year-old man who +underwent a total laryngec- +tomy. Lateral radiograph dur- +ing swallowing shows a linear +horizontal filling defect in the +anterior wall of the proximal +neopharynx that resembles +the epiglottis and partially +obstructs the passage of the +bolus (arrow). + +Figure +28. Anterior +pharyngeal pouch in a +72-year-old woman. Lat- +eral radiograph shows +contrast material pooling +in an outpouching at the +base of the tongue at the +entrance of the neophar- +ynx (*). + +Figure 29. Neopharyngeal dysmotility in a 70-year-old man. Se- +quential lateral radiographs of swallowing show a premature clo- +sure of the neopharynx during the passage of the bolus (arrows in +B), with residue in the proximal lumen. + +Figure 30. PES dysmotility in a +72-year-old woman. Lateral radio- +graph of swallowing shows PES +narrowing during the passage of +the bolus (arrow). + +Complications of Tracheoesophageal +Fistula and Prosthesis +A malpositioned or a too­large prosthesis may +protrude into the lumen of the tracheostoma and +obstruct it (Fig 32A). When the prosthetic flange +is located in the esophageal lumen instead of being +attached to the wall, the flange may cause obstruc­ +tion and interference in the passage of the bolus +and in phonation (Fig 32B). A too­short prosthesis +may lead to closure of the fistula, with associated +inflammatory changes. Esophageal contents can +pass around the prosthesis (ie, periprosthetic) and +into the tracheostoma during swallowing, because +the diameter of the prosthesis is too narrow com­ +pared with that of the stoma (Fig 32C) or through +the prosthesis because of malfunction (Fig 32D). +The prosthesis should be removed and replaced +after diagnosis of these complications (38–41). + +Conclusion +Swallowing is a complex mechanism that involves +at least 37 pairs of striated muscles, five cranial +nerves, and multiple supportive anatomic struc­ +tures that are controlled by the central nervous +system (10). As we have discussed in this article, +numerous anatomic and functional abnormali­ +ties can impair swallowing and can be detected at +fluoroscopy. + +The presence or supervision of a radiologist +during the examination may contribute to cor­ +relation of the perceived abnormalities with the +patient’s symptoms and prior treatments and +imaging studies. On the basis of this preliminary +analysis, the radiologist can decide, in conjunc­ +tion with the speech­language pathologist, if ad­ +ditional images or structures should be included +in the examination before the patient leaves the +radiography department. + + 1748 October Special Issue 2021 + +radiographics.rsna.org + +Figure 31. Postradiation stric- +ture in a 75-year-old man. Lateral +radiograph of swallowing after +total laryngectomy shows a stric- +ture in the neopharynx (arrows), +with proximal pharyngeal dilata- +tion (*). + +Figure 32. Complications of a tracheoesophageal prosthesis in four patients. (A) Oblique radiograph of swallowing in an 81-year- +old woman shows migration of the prosthesis (red arrows) into the lumen of the tracheostoma (green double-headed arrow). +(B) Oblique radiograph in a 74-year-old man after swallowing shows the esophageal flange of the prosthesis (arrows), which is +malpositioned in the lumen of the proximal esophagus instead of being attached to the wall. (C) Oblique radiograph in a 79-year- +old patient after swallowing shows contrast material leaking from the esophagus into the tracheal lumen through the surrounding +cephalad margin of the prosthesis (arrows). (D) Oblique radiograph in a 72-year-old man shows contrast material dripping into the +trachea through the lumen of prosthesis (arrow). + +The radiologic report should include all de­ +tected abnormalities and should not be limited to +description of the visualization of penetration or +aspiration. Because each abnormality has its own +specific therapeutic approach, the description +of radiologic findings and their correlation with +the pathophysiologic mechanisms and possible +causes should be stated clearly in the report. A +meticulous radiologic diagnosis facilitates the +decision making of referring physicians and swal­ +lowing therapists. + +Information obtained from swallowing exami­ +nations is useful to determine the oral capabilities +of the patient and whether they should initiate, +maintain, or discontinue oral intake without risk­ +ing development of pneumonia. A good­quality +examination and report not only improve early +diagnosis and treatment of a patient’s swallowing +disorders but also reduce morbidity, mortality, +length of hospital stay, and health care costs. + +Acknowledgment.—The authors wish to acknowledge Lory +Tubbs, MA, for her contribution with the illustrations. + References -forComputationalLinguistics,12. -| Haonan | Bian. | 2025. | LLM-empowered | | | knowl- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SeijiMaekawa,HayateIso,andNikitaBhutani.2024. -| edge | graph | construction: | | A survey. | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Holisticreasoningwithlong-contextLMs: | | | | | Abench- | -| arXiv:2510.20345. | | | ArXiv:2510.20345. | | | | | | | | | | -markfordatabaseoperationsonmassivetextualdata. -Darren Edge, Ha Trinh, Newman Cheng, Joshua Preprint,arXiv:2410.11996. ArXiv:2410.11996. -| Bradley, | Alex | Chao, | | Apurva | Mody, | Steven | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | David J. | Moore. | 2025. | A taxonomy | of | hierarchical | -Truitt, Dasha Metropolitansky, Robert Osazuwa multi-agentsystems: Designpatterns,coordination -| Ness, | and | Jonathan | Larson. | 2024. | | From lo- | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | mechanisms, | | and industrial | applications. | | Preprint, | -| cal to | global: | A graph | RAG | approach | | to query- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2508.12683. | | ArXiv:2508.12683. | | | | -| focusedsummarization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2404.16130. | | | | | | | | | | -ArXiv:2404.16130. -| | | | | | | | LituOuandMirellaLapata.2025. | | | | Context-awarehier- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -archicalmergingforlongdocumentsummarization. -| Gemini | Team, | Petko | Georgiev, | Ving | Ian Lei, | Ryan | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2502.00977. | | | ArXiv:2502.00977. | | | -| Burnell, | Libin | Bai, | Anmol | Gulati, | Garrett | Tanzer, | | | | | | | -DamienVincent,ZhufengPan,ShiboWang,and1 Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh -others. 2024. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D. Man- -understandingacrossmillionsoftokensofcontext. ning. 2024. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive pro- -Preprint,arXiv:2403.05530. ArXiv:2403.05530. cessing for tree-organized retrieval. Preprint, -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2401.18059. | | ArXiv:2401.18059. | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Jiani Guo, | Zuchao | Li, | Jie Wu, | Qianren | Wang, | Yun | | | | | | | -Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao, and Yujiu Yang. 2025. LiSun,LiuHe,ShuyueJia,YangfanHe,andChenyu -ToM:Leveragingtree-orientedMapReduceforlong- You. 2025. DocAgent: An agentic framework for -contextreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. InPro- multi-modallong-contextdocumentunderstanding. -ceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin InProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMeth- -NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). odsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). - -V.A.Traag,L.Waltman,andN.J.vanEck.2019. From extraction tasks and write a synthesis -louvaintoleiden: Guaranteeingwell-connectedcom- directive to guide the downstream -| munities. | ScientificReports,9(1):5233. | | | | | | synthesizer. | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 2. Sub-agents | | (next) | — | Each | document | -Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi is assigned one worker that runs your -Liao,XinghuaZhang,BingliWu,HaiyangYu,Nan tasks independently. Workers search -Xu,LeiZhang,RunLuo,YunshuiLi,MinYang,Fei their document and report raw findings. -| | | | | | | | They run | in parallel | | and | cannot | see each | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | -| Huang,andYongbinLi.2024a. | | | | Leavenodocument | | | | | | | | | -other’s results. -| behind: | Benchmarkinglong-contextLLMswithex- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 3. Synthesizer | | (last) | — | A downstream | | -| tendedmulti-docQA. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2406.17419. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | agent | receives | ALL | worker | | findings | -ArXiv:2406.17419. -| | | | | | | | and merges | | them | into | a | single | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | coherent | response. | | It | follows | your | -| Qian Wang, | Tianyu | | Wang, | Zhenheng | Tang, | Qinbin | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | synthesis_directive | | | to decide | | what to | -Li,NuoChen,JingshengLiang,andBingshengHe. -| | | | | | | | prioritize | and | how | to | structure | the | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| 2024b. | Megaagent: | | Alarge-scaleautonomousLLM- | | | | | | | | | | -output. -basedmulti-agentsystemwithoutpredefinedSOPs. -| | | | | | | | You CANNOT | see | the | names, | types, | or | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -| Preprint,arXiv:2408.09955. | | | | ArXiv:2408.09955. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | content | of the | documents. | | | | -TomerWolfson,HarshTrivedi,MorGeva,YoavGold- Your ONLY job in this step: -| berg, | Dan Roth, | Tushar | Khot, | Ashish | | Sabharwal, | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a list | of | subagent_todos | | -| and Reut | Tsarfaty. | | 2025. | Monaco: | | More nat- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (as | structured | | output): | | precise | -| ural and | complex | | questions | for | reasoning | across | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | extraction | | tasks | | that | will be | -| dozensofdocuments. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | executed | | independently | | against | EACH | -| ArXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | document | | by the | sub-agents. | | | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a synthesis_directive: | | | a | -Wentao Zhang, Liang Zeng, Yuzhen Xiao, Yong- concise instruction (2–4 sentences) -cong Li, Ce Cui, Yilei Zhao, Rui Hu, Yang Liu, for the synthesizer. -| Yahui | Zhou, | and Bo | An. | 2025. | AgentOrchestra: | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A hierarchical multi-agent framework for general- Todo-writing rules: -| purpose | task | solving. | Preprint, | arXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | • Decompose | | the | user | query | into | -| ArXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | concrete | | information | | requirements. | | -Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Hao Xu, Yi Lu, Wei He, Yiwen • Each todo must be self-contained -and unambiguous. -| Ding, | Tao Gui, | Qi | Zhang, | and | Xuanjing | Huang. | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | • Prefer | | atomic | tasks | over | broad | -| 2024. | LongAgent: | | Scalinglanguagemodelsto128k | | | | | | | | | | -tasks. -| contextthroughmulti-agentcollaboration. | | | | | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • Include | | coverage | for: | definitions, | | -| arXiv:2402.11550. | | | ArXiv:2402.11550. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | numeric | | values, | constraints, | | edge | -| | | | | | | | cases, | | error | modes, | and | any | -| Zihan Zhou, | Chong | | Li, Xinyi | Chen, | Shuo | Wang, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | explicit | | recommendations | | | required | -YuChao,ZhiliLi,HaoyuWang,QiShi,ZhixingTan, -| | | | | | | | by | the user | query. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -XuHan,XiaodongShi,ZhiyuanLiu,andMaosong -| | | | | | | | • Design | a | robust | extraction | | list | -| ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| Sun. 2025. | | LLM×MapReduce: | | | Simplified | long- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | that | works | for | ANY document | | in the | -| sequence | processing | | using | large | language | models. | | | | | | | -set. -InProceedingsoftheAnnualMeetingoftheAssocia- -| tionforComputationalLinguistics(ACL). | | | | | | | Important | Constraints: | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Do | not assume | any | document | | contains | -| AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris | | | | | | | • | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | the | answer. | Write | | todos | that can | -| Callison-Burch. | | 2024. | FanOutQA: | | A | multi-hop, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | be | answered | with | either | “Found” | or | -multi-documentquestionansweringbenchmarkfor -| | | | | | | | “Not | found | in | this document.” | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | --------------- | ----------- | --- | -| large language | | models. | In | Proceedings | | of the An- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • Tell | the | worker | WHAT | to extract, | not | -nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational -| | | | | | | | HOW | to extract | | it. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Linguistics(ACL). -| | | | | | | | • Do | not | synthesize, | | summarize, | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | attempt | | to answer | | the user | query | -A Prompts -yourself. -| All | prompts | | are | | defined | in | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A.2DocumentSub-AgentPrompt -backend/core/prompts.py. -(RESEARCH_SYSTEM_PROMPT) -| A.1CoordinatorPrompt | | | | | | | You are | a sub-agent | | investigating | | a | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | -| (LEAD_RESEARCHER_PROMPT) | | | | | | | single document: | | {file_name}. | | | | -You are a lead researcher coordinating You operate inside an iterative -a RAG-based analysis to answer a user retrieval loop. On each turn you output -| query. | | | | | | | exactly | one structured | | action: | | | -| -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| Pipeline | | Architecture: | | | | | • action="search": | | | Issue | a | focused | -1. YOU (now) — Decompose the query into query to retrieve information from - -the document. Set query to a • Follow the synthesis directive -specific, targeted search string. above — it defines your main goal, -Set reasoning to why this query is priorities, and output structure. -| | needed. | | | | | | • | Keep only | information | | that | directly | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -• action="finalize": You have helps answer the query. Discard -| | gathered | | sufficient | evidence | to | | | tangential | content. | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------ | -| | address | ALL | assigned | | tasks. Set | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Preserve | exact | numbers, | | names, | -| | findings | to | your | complete | extracted | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | dates, | and caveats. | | | | -| | report. | Set | reasoning | | to a brief | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Remove | redundancy. | | If the | same | -| | summary | of | what you | found. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | fact appears | | multiple | times, | keep | -it once. -| | Investigation | principles: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • | Do NOT | invent | or infer | facts | not | -| | | | | | | | | present | in the | findings. | | | -| | 1. Start | by identifying | | the | key facts | | | | | | | | -| | required | for | each | task. | | | • | Same | language | as | the | findings | -2. Issue ONE focused query per turn (default English if mixed). -| | — prefer | specific | | terms | over broad | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | phrases. | | | | | B | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | -| | 3. Expand | to | synonyms | or | paraphrases | | | | | | | | -Models. -if initial results are incomplete. The coordinator, the merging layer, -4. Issue separate queries for and the synthesis layer use gemini-2.5-pro -| | different | | aspects | of a | task. | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | (temperature | | 0.0). | | Document | | sub-agents | -| | 5. Keep | searching | until | every | task is | | | | | | | | -covered with concrete evidence or use gemini-2.5-flash (temperature 0.0) for -| | confirmed | | absent. | | | document-scoped | | | retrieval. | | The | LLM judge | -| --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | -6. Do NOT attempt to answer the user (GPT-5) is separate and is used only for the -| | query | directly | — | extract | raw facts | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | evaluationoftheAvgscore. | | | | Modelconstantsare | | | -only. -definedinbackend/shared/constants.py. -| | 7. Do | NOT finalize | | a task | as ’Not | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | found’ | after | only | a single | focused | | | | | | | | -| | search. | | At | least | attempt 2 | Hyperparameters. | | | | | | | -| | focused | searches | | before | concluding | | | | | | | | -| | information | | is absent. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Parameter | | | | Value | | | -| | 8. Do NOT | focus | on very | specific | terms, | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunksize(tokens) | | | | 1000 | | | -| | but | rather | on the | general | context | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunkoverlap(tokens) | | | | 250 | | | -| | of the | task. | Always | try | to find the | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Tokenizer | | | | tiktoken | | cl100k_base | -| | most | relevant | information. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingmodel | | | | Cohereembed-v4.0 | | | -| | 9. You | must use | AT MOST | 5 | searches to | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingdimension | | | | 1536 | | | -| | answer | a task. | DO | NOT | OVERUSE THE | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Similaritymetric | | | | Cosine | | | -| | SEARCH | TOOL. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | MergetokenbudgetB | | | | 750,000tokens | | | -| | | | | | | Denseretrievaltop-K | | | | 15 | | | -| | Finalize | report | format: | | For each | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Reranker | | | | Coherererank-v4.0-fast | | | -| | assigned | task, | output | either | “Found: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Rerankertop-N | | | | 5 | | | -| | [exact answer | with | supporting | | evidence]” | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Sub-agentiterationsafetylimit | | | | 5 | | | -| | or “Not found | in | this | document.” | Always | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringalgorithm | | | | Agglomerative(UPGMA) | | | -| | report exact | numbers, | | names, | and dates. | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringmetric | | | | Precomputedcosinedistance | | | -| | Never approximate | | or | infer | beyond the | | | | | | | | -document. -| | | | | | | Cost | | measurement. | | Per-query | | costs | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | are | pulled | from | LangSmith | | run | metadata | -A.3Merge/SynthesisPrompt -| (SYNTHESIS_PROMPT) | | | | | | (extract_langsmith_info.py) | | | | | using | model- | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -specificper-tokenpricing. -Thispromptisuseduniformlyateverylevelofthe -recursivemergingtree,includingthefinalsynthesis -step. Thereisnoseparatefinal-answerprompt. -| | You are | a research | synthesizer. | | Merge | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | the following | | sub-agent | findings | into | | | | | | | | -| | one compact, | information-dense | | | response | | | | | | | | -| | for the user. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Query: {query | } | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Synthesis | Directive: | | | | | | | | | | | -{synthesis_directive} -| | Findings | Batch: | {findings | } | | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rules: \ No newline at end of file + +1. Allen J, Belafsky P. Symptom indices for dysphagia assess­ +ment and management. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma +GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidis­ +ciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New York, +NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 357–379. +2. Logeman JA. Instrumental techniques for the study of swal­ +lowing. In: Evaluation and treatment of swallowing disorders: +imaging studies. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 54–61. +3. Rubesin SE. Pharyngeal morphology. In: Ekberg O, ed. +Dysphagia. Diagnosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, Swit­ +zerland: Springer International, 2019; 351–384. + +4. Ekberg O, Nylander G. Anatomy and physiology. In: Ekberg +O, ed. Dysphagia. Diagnosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, +Switzerland: Springer, 2019; 3–20. + +5. Logeman JA. Anatomy and physiology of normal deglutition. +In: Evaluation and treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd +ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 13–52. + +6. Belafsky PC, Lintzenich CR. Development, Anatomy, +and Physiology of the Pharynx. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 165–173. + +7. Jones B. Abnormalities of pharyngeal function. In: Gore RM, +Levine MS, eds. Textbook of Gastrointestinal Radiology. +4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2014; 222–236. +8. Matsuo K, Palmer JB. Oral phase preparation and pro­ +pulsion: anatomy, physiology, rheology, mastication, and +transport. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling + + RG • Volume 41 Number 6 + +Carbo et al 1749 + +C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A multidisciplinary text +of swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer, +2013; 117–132. + +9. Lang IM. Development, anatomy and physiology of the +upper esophageal sphincter and pharyngoesophageal junc­ +tion. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, +eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidisciplinary text for +swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer, +2013; 235–255. + +10. Rubesin SE. Principles of performing a “modified barium +swallow” examination. In: RSNA Categorical Course in +Diagnostic Radiology: Gastrointestinal. Oak Brook, Ill: +Radiological Society of North America, 1997; 7–19. +11. Logeman JA. Evaluation of swallowing disorders. In: Evalu­ +ation and treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, +Tex: Pro­ed, 1998; 168–190. + +12. Rubesin SE. Pharynx: normal anatomy and examination +techniques. In: Gore RM, Levine MS, eds. Textbook +of Gastrointestinal radiology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: +Saunders­Elsevier, 2014; 207–221. + +13. Skucas J. Imging contrast agents. In: Gore RM, Levine +MS, eds. Textbook of Gastrointestinal Radiology. 3rd ed. +Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2008; 3–17. + +14. Logeman JA. Disorders of deglutition. In: Evaluation and +treatment of swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: +Pro­ed, 1998; 71–119. + +15. Pokieser P, Scharitzer M. The clinical and radiological +approach to dysphagia. In: Ekberg O, ed. Dysphagia. Diag­ +nosis and treatment. 2nd ed. Cham, Switzerland: Springer +International, 2019; 285–315. + +16. Buchholz DW, Bosma JF, Donner MW. Adaptation, com­ +pensation, and decompensation of the pharyngeal swallow. +Gastrointest Radiol 1985;10(3):235–239. + +17. Lazarus C. Dysphagia Secondary to the Effects of Chemo­ +therapy and Radiation therapy. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 431–444. + +18. Dantas RO. Cricopharyngeal bar. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A +multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer, 2013; 509–514. + +19. Massey BT. Crocopharyngeal achalasia. In: Shaker R, +Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of +deglutition. A multidisciplinary text of swallowing and its +disorders. New York, NY: Springer, 2013; 515–528. +20. Easterling C, Shaker R. Upper esophageal sphincter opening +muscle dysfunction. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, +Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition. A multidisci­ +plinary text of swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: +Springer, 2013; 529–538. + +21. Mei L, Sanvanson P. Upper esophageal sphincter restrictive +disorders. In: Bardan E, Shaker R, eds. Gastrointestinal mo­ +tility disorders. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, 2018; 79–907. +22. Lazarus CL, Logemann JA, Pauloski BR, et al. Swallow­ +ing disorders in head and neck cancer patients treated with +radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy. Laryngoscope +1996;106(9 Pt 1):1157–1166. + +23. Born LJ, Harned RH, Rikkers LF, Pfeiffer RF, Quigley +EM. Cricopharyngeal dysfunction in Parkinson’s disease: +role in dysphagia and response to myotomy. Mov Disord +1996;11(1):53–58. + +24. Theurer JA, Johnston JL, Taves DH, et al. Swallowing after +right hemisphere stroke: oral versus pharyngeal deficits. Can +J Speech Lang Pathol Audiol 2008;32:114–122. + +25. Lazarus C, Logemann JA. Swallowing disorders in +closed head trauma patients. Arch Phys Med Rehabil +1987;68(2):79–84. + +26. McCullough GH, Kim Y. Effects of the Mendelsohn +maneuver on extent of hyoid movement and UES opening +post­stroke. Dysphagia 2013;28(4):511–519. + +27. Rubesin SE. Structural abnormalities of the pharynx. In: +Gore RM, Levine MS, eds. Textbook of gastrointestinal +radiology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, +2014; 235–265. + +28. Lazarus C. Dysphagia secondary to the effects of chemo­ +therapy and radiation therapy. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 431–443. +29. Cook IJ. Zenker’s diverticulum. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, +Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a +multidisciplinary text for swallowing and its disorders. New +York, NY: Springer Science Business Media, 2013; 495–508. +30. Morrison MP, Postma GN. Surgical treatment of Zenker’s +diverticulum. In: Shaker R, Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easter­ +ling C, eds. Principles of deglutition: a multidisciplinary text +for swallowing and its disorders. New York, NY: Springer +Science Business Media, 2013; 847–858. + +31. Agrawal N, Goldenberg D. Primary and salvage total laryngec­ +tomy. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2008;41(4):771–780, vii. +32. Schindler A, Mozzanic F, Barbiera F. Dysphagia evaluation +and treatment after head and neck surgery and/or chemo­ +radiotherapy of head and neck malignancy. In: Shaker R, +Belafsky P, Postma GN, Easterling C, eds. Principles of +deglutition: a multidisciplinary text for swallowing and +its disorders. New York, NY: Springer Science Business +Media, 2013; 649–668. + +33. Giannitto C, Preda L, Zurlo V, et al. Swallowing disorders +after oral cavity and pharyngolaryngeal surgery and role +of imaging. Gastroenterol Res Pract 2017;2017:7592034. +34. Wippold FJ II. Postoperative pharynx. In: Gore RM, Levine +MS, eds. In: Textbook of gastrointestinal radiology. 3rd +ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders­Elsevier, 2008; 257–271. +35. Balfe DM, Koehler RE, Setzen M, Weyman PJ, Baron RL, +Ogura JH. Barium examination of the esophagus after total +laryngectomy. Radiology 1982;143(2):501–508. + +36. Anderson S, Hogan D, Panizza B. Causes and consequences +of anterior pharyngeal pouch after total laryngectomy. J +Laryngol Otol 2014;128(Suppl 2):S39–S42. + +37. Nguyen NP, Smith HJ, Sallah S. Evaluation and manage­ +ment of swallowing dysfunction following chemoradiation +for head and neck cancer. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head +Neck Surg 2007;15(2):130–133. + +38. Logemann JA. Swallowing disorders after treatment of oral +and oropharyngeal cancer. In: Evaluation and treatment of +swallowing disorders. 2nd ed. Austin, Tex: Pro­Ed, 1998; +251–278. + +39. Pope TL, Shaffer HA Jr, Johns ME, et al. Radiologic evalu­ +ation of the Blom­Singer prosthesis for vocal restoration +after laryngectomy. Presented at the Annual Meeting of +the American Society of Head and Neck Radiology, Los +Angeles, CA, May 1981. + +40. Pauloski BR, Rademaker AW, Logemann JA, Colangelo +LA. Speech and swallowing in irradiated and nonirradiated +postsurgical oral cancer patients. Otolaryngol Head Neck +Surg 1998;118(5):616–624. + +41. Zhang T, Szczesniak M, Maclean J, et al. Biomechanics of +pharyngeal deglutitive function following total laryngectomy. +Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2016;155(2):295–302. + +This journal-based SA-CME activity has been approved for AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM. See rsna.org/learning-center-rg. + diff --git a/q253/random_k4/random_2.md b/q253/random_k4/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..66dda46939cb392b8d53b4e32148ffc455647966 100644 --- a/q253/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q253/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,2837 +1,2305 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +Bachelor Programs -2 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between - -them - - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a - -stable dividend - -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised - -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia - -and from our international network - - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive - -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend - -3 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - -Strategic priorities - -Financial targets +Bachelor (B.A.) of Business +Administration and Digital +Innovation 1 -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. - -Insurance and Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Empower our -people - -RoTE1 - - >11% by 2020 - -Costs - - Positive jaws - -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) - -Capital + “As Managing Director of GBSB Global +Business School I am delighted to be +leading one of the first Microsoft +Showcase Business Schools in +Europe. + +GBSB Global has a strong focus on +innovation and technology, both in our +online and on-campus programs. We +are within a few business schools in +Europe to offer a fully digitalized +experience to our students throughout +the +includes +digital blackboards, collaborative apps, +learning environment, and +inclusive +various educational digital tools. + +learning process; + +this + +Our world-class digital reputation +is reflected in our partnership with +Microsoft. We were proud to be one +of the first business schools in +Europe to achieve a recognition +as a Microsoft Showcase School, +meaning we belong +to a global +community of schools engaged in digital +improve teaching +transformation +and learning. We create inclusive and +that +immersive digital +inspire +stimulate +development of essential business skills +so students are empowered to achieve +more. + +experiences + +learning, + +lifelong + +to + +Our students are our biggest asset! We +strive to be globally competitive +and internationally relevant, educating +our students to become tomorrow’s +future leaders today. When you study +at GBSB Global, you become not only +a student, but a member of a world- +wide learning community. Your +classmates and professors, from across +the globe, will challenge and inspire +you, push you to grow both personally +and professionally, empowering you +with the tools to go far and to achieve +success. Whatever your professional +aspirations may be, I am confident that +GBSB Global is the perfect base +from which to hone your business +skills, +launch new companies, and +achieve your career goals. + +I look forward to welcoming you to GBSB +Global’s learning environment.” + +Antonio Rodriguez +Managing Director +GBSB Global + +Olga Ivanova +Head of Innovation +and Development +GBSB Global + +Our programs will challenge you with a +valuable experience, and benefit you +and your career now, and in the years to +come.” + +programs + +“GBSB Global’s +have +been carefully crafted to provide the +skills you need to progress to top +management level positions. + +As Head of Innovation and Development +at GBSB Global, I have the benefit of +over 10 years of research in business +education experience, and of observing +tendencies in education all around the +world, so I know first-hand what a +business school should give you +to make the transition to the job +of your dreams. + +is accredited + +GBSB Global Business School supports +high standards in business education +by numerous and -dividend - - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs - -subject to -regulatory -approval - -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ - -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% - -4 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 +international accreditation bodies such +as Accreditation Council for Business +Schools and Programs +(ACBSP), +European Council of Business Education +(ECBE) and Accreditation Service for +International Schools, Colleges and +Universities (ASIC). + +The institution was awarded as a Four +Stars Business School by QS Ranking +System and listed among TOP business +schools in Europe in the QS Master +Programs Ranking. + +Alongside our well-established +partnership with Microsoft, we +have developed unique in-house learning +and teaching methodologies, creating +a fully engaging academic experience. +Participate in group work, contact your +lecturers and access video streams, you +can do it all whenever you want, from +wherever you want. + +GBSB Global’s programs open +up opportunities +to experience +global business. Undertaking one of +the programs and connecting with +faculty and students from all over +the world will provide you with an +theories +into how business +insight +and practices are applied in different +countries and cultures, expanding +your international perspectives, +network and professional opportunities. 2 3 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength + The Program -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Academics -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Improve Your +Career Prospects -5 +Why GBSB Global - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +How to Apply -Who we are +p. 06 -Strategic differentiators +p. 22 -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 +p. 36 -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows +p. 44 -#1 -global transaction -bank2 +p. 58 -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 +4 -USD182bn -Total capital4 +05 +5 -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 + ABOUT +THIS PROGRAM -1 +The Program -2 +GBSB Global’s Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration +and Digital Innovation is designed to be an alternative +to traditional business administration focusing on +trends in technology and the paradigm shift businesses +have taken to focus more solely on their online markets. -3 +Students will concentrate on the business areas that are of +key interest while gaining a comprehensive education +with a digital focus. Learn about trends in digital +innovation and how to think with an agile mind adapting to +the new remote reality facing the world today. -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank +Our Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation prepares students with the skills needed to work +in a tech-focused environment where collaboration +and communication will be key to quickly and +effectively adapt to the changing business arena. -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, +Areas of concentrations: -Middle East and Latin America +Digital Entrepreneurship - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver +Digital Communication & PR -shareholder value +Digital Marketing -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with +Fashion & Luxury Business -diversified business model +Finance & FinTech - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity +Sports & eSports Management -management +THE PROGRAM - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for +About This Program -distribution to shareholders +Bachelor Majors -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research +Why Earn This Degree -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include +Is This Program Right for You? -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts +Current Student Profile -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) +Student Testimonials 6 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -1 - -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking - -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 - -FY2017, revenue, USDbn - -Recognised as leading international -bank +07 +7 -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 + The Program + +AREAS OF CONCENTRATIONS + +Digital Entrepreneurship + +Digital Communication & PR + +Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Digital Entrepreneurship prepares students +for the dynamic and quickly changing business landscape. +Students will learn about what it takes to design, create and +implement a digital business in an era where social and +economic issues will impact business trends online + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and +Digital Innovation with Digital Communication & PR is an +innovative program that is specifically designed for students +who want to be competitive in the digital marketplace. The +tech-focused program identifies the best global business +practices and multi-channel communication strategies +providing students with the knowledge and tools to +successfully manage international marketing initiatives. + +Digital Marketing + +Fashion & Luxury Business + +The Bachelor (B.A) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Digital Marketing seeks to help students +acquire an +in-depth knowledge of digital marketing +principles, as well as understand how to apply them to real- +life business operations. + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Fashion & Luxury Business examines the +wide variety of careers available to students in the field +of fashion and luxury brand management. Entering this +highly competitive landscape, graduates from GBSB Global +are furnished with the skills and understanding needed to +deploy their ideas into structural business plans that take +into account the innovative backdrop in which we live. + +Sports and eSports Management + +Finance & FinTech + +The Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration and Digital +Innovation with Sports and eSports is designed to provide +students with business management fundamentals and an +in-depth knowledge of global markets especially as they +relate to advancements in technology. The program examines +legal, technological, and international perspectives in the +sports marketplace and improves students’ decision-making +talents and capability to adapt to global challenges. + +Throughout the Bachelor (B.A.) of Business Administration +and Digital Innovation with Finance & FinTech students +cover a variety of financial topics, from the very basics +of banking and equity investment to diving deeper into +corporate financing, statistical analytics, and portfolio +management. The program also covers topics such as +investor relations, online financial services, cost accounting, +and wealth planning to name a few. -Leading market positions +8 -HSBC +9 -US Bank + The Program + +The Program + +WHY EARN THIS DEGREE + +Build a Career That Will Be in Demand for the Long +Term + +Make a Deep Dive to Digital and Innovation +Business World + +Acquire the knowledge and skills in one of the most +fundamental, dynamic yet stable fields today. + +Start learning the highly paid digital competencies required +in the digital economy era. + +No matter how far technological development and +innovation will advance, individuals with managerial +training, analytical skills, and business vision will always +be a vital component in business and the economy. In +comparison to other careers like engineering, the demand +for well-educated businessmen and women is growing +with the advancements in technology. + +Without a doubt, the digital economy is booming as a +consequence of the many technological advancements +in different sectors and areas. In an era of shrinking +product life cycles and rapidly changing business models, +students should be aware of latest digital and innovation +trends. GBSB Global utilizes digital aspects on all levels of +educational process by preparing digital courses, cases of +technological companies, business simulations and many +others. + +Build a Global Network + +Increase Your Innovative Potential + +Take advantage of the diverse student body at GBSB Global +Business School, representing over 100 nationalities. Build +solid professional relationships and connections across +borders and industries. + +Take courses on design thinking or creativity and psychology +of new product development and get ready to work in +innovative companies. + +Networking plays a very important role in one’s career +development, both in finding a good job or developing +advantageous relationships with new partners and/or +clients. At GBSB Global you will have an opportunity to +network with students, future business leaders from over +100 countries, and faculty members, current managers +and founders in various businesses, from over 16 countries. + +The research department at GBSB Global Business School +is constantly involved in business education research, which +fosters the design of the most innovative and practical business +programs. GBSB Global implements the most advanced teaching +methodologies available today to the bachelor’s curriculum such +as Lego ® Serious Play ® and drawing production tasks. + +Gain a Global Perspective on the Business World +and Develop Your Professional Flexibility + +Follow Your Aspirations and Embrace New +Educational Opportunities + +Learn the fundamental concepts and various interconnected +aspects of the business world as a system and develop your +analytical skills. + +One step away from an MBA – choose the path offering +personal and professional growth. + +One of the main advantages of GBSB Global’s Bachelor +program is the modular structure of the curriculum. This +allows students to focus on the area of study they are +most interested in while still obtaining a broad business +perspective and being able to change from one field to +another: from finance to marketing, from marketing to +entrepreneurship. Students also study how business is +conducted in different regions of the world and learn +to develop greater cultural intelligence and awareness, +effectively working with people from all around the globe. + +After graduating from our Bachelor program, students can +continue their education and obtain an MBA or a master’s +degree. The Bachelor in Business is the most common +academic background of MBA students. The program +provides the students with fundamental knowledge and +skills that will be required when doing an MBA. + +Acquire a Combination of Hard & Soft Skills and +Become Highly Competitive + +Not only will students obtain hard skills like accounting, +information technologies, and financial analysis, but they +will also develop very valuable soft skills like leadership, +people management, and organizational communications +that will make them more competitive in the job market. + +According to the research conducted by The National +Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE), such soft +skills as the ability to work in teams, decision-making, +problem solving and organizational communication are +the most sought after by employers. + +Prepare to Face the Challenges of the 21st Century + +Join business professionals in pursuit of an agenda based on +sustainability and ethical business practices. + +More and more companies today are carefully selecting +their suppliers and partners from an array of firms that +comply with the international environmental standards +and requirements set forth that respect human rights +and conduct ethical operations. An education focused on +global sustainability prepares students for the recent trend +focused on ethical business practices in global business. -US Bank +10 -US Bank +11 -European -Bank + IS THIS PROGRAM +RIGHT FOR YOU? -European -Bank +The Bachelor program commonly +appeals to students with a variety of +professional aspirations: -European -Bank +Prospective undergraduate students are diverse in +their interests and skills and are typically: -European -Bank +Business Administration -European -Bank +Ambitious & inspired people who aspire to be a +leader in their industry. -15.2 +Proactive individuals with entrepreneurial spirit +who plan to start their own company or lead innovation +in the business envinronment. -26% +Digital Marketing -22% +Finance & FinTech -21% +Highly motivated students who aspire to earn +an MBA and strive for advanced professional titles, +increased salaries, and more responsibility. -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 +Digital Business Models +and Operations -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 +Critical thinkers who are currently uncertain what +industry or area of the business world they prefer to +develop their career in and find it advantageous to +obtain a more universal, fundamental knowledge. -Asia +Digital Communications +and Social Media -US +High school graduates who are interested in digital +communications, marketing automatization, fintech, +innovation and entrepreneurship. -Europe +Entrepreneurship -RoTE Transaction Banking, % +International Management ->20% +12 -HSBC -Transaction -Banking + The Program -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 +The Program -Banking -Industry -overall7 +Students apply to the bachelor program in order +to develop a variety of professional skills and +knowledge in different industries that will increase +their employability as a professional in the field of +business. -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 +Knowledge -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 +Skills -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 +faced by -53% -of client -revenue -connected to +Gathers and interprets relevant data on problems, +obstacles and opportunities international -network - -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. - -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue - -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries - -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey - -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 - -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth - -HSBC has access to high growth markets - -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 - -Asia, Market shares2 +organizations to inform judgments that include reflection +on relevant social, technological, scientific or ethical issues +with the purpose to evaluate alternative approaches and +strategies an organization may adopt to meet stakeholder +needs and minimize risk within changing internal and +external environments. + +Conducts research into business and digital innovation +issues, which may relate to general business and innovation +processes or to a specific. + +Demonstrates mastery in using digital tools for business +administration and +in various +media and different modes (autonomous, collaborative, +exploratory, designing). + +innovation purposes + +related + +theoretical and practical +Understands professional +knowledge +administration, +business +to +including both broad knowledge in the field of business +administration and a considerable degree of specialized +managerial knowledge in digital innovation. + +Possesses advanced professional knowledge of business +administration and digital innovation in a specific industry +or functional area chosen as an elective option in the +undergraduate program. + +Critically understands approaches to promoting the +culture of digital innovation within an organization by +managing talent and knowledge and by incorporating +the values of entrepreneurship, continuous learning +and digital transformation into organizational strategic +objectives. + +Understands managerial methods and digital technologies +that are in demand in the complex and challenging global +business environment, innovation in terms of methods and +technologies used, and implications of digital technologies +for individuals and societies. + +Demonstrates professional understanding of +issues +of digital business and how it can be interpreted with +different theoretical approaches. + +Critically understands the principles included in the +Agenda for Sustainable Development defined by UNESCO +that are associated with social welfare, business ethics, +and corporate social responsibility. -+5.8% +14 -Asia +15 -Middle East + The Program -Africa +The Program -Latin America +Talented individuals are drawn +to the Bachelor program +in +order to achieve the following +objectives: -N. America +1 -Europe +Distinguish themselves, develop a career +in the business world, and achieve success, i.e. +managerial position or executive title -2017 +4 -2030E +Obtain a more systematic and +fundamental knowledge with a broad +business perspective in order to have more +opportunities and options of career development -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 +3 -+6.1% +Further their education and to earn an +MBA or other master’s degree to gain advanced +professional titles, increased salaries, and more +responsibility -Asia +5 -Middle East +Become competent specialists +in the area of their interest and passion: digital +communication, digital marketing, social +media, fintech, innovation, entrepreneurship, +leadership in turbulent times -Africa +2 -Latin America +Start their own company or launch +a startup -N. America +16 -Europe +17 -CAGR + The Program -7.4% +CURRENT +STUDENT PROFILE -7.4% +The Program -6.5% +Student Body Statistics -6.0% +A Truly Multicultural Environment +GBSB Global attracts students from countries of all sizes and +regions worldwide with diverse academic and professional +backgrounds. -4.3% +Attention to Diversity +Students represent a variety of cultures, religions and backgrounds. +GBSB Global creates an atmosphere of open-mindedness and +respect to ensure that every member of our student body has a +positive and inclusive experience. -4.6% +Countries GBSB Global Students Represent -CAGR +As of January 2018 -7.1% +40% -7.8% +60% -8.0% +19 -5.7% +100 COUNRIES +REPRESENTATIVES -4.4% +18 -5.4% +19 -29% Hong Kong + Student Testimonials -12% PRD4 +Student Testimonials -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) +“For me personally, the biggest advantage of GBSB Global is the level +of diversity within the student body. I’ve had the chance to share and +collaborate with people from countries I knew absolutely nothing about. -5% Singapore +Most importantly though, what I have gained from my time at GBSB +Global is a level of social learning and cultural understanding that +is unparalleled to any university I have attended in the past, that I know +will be invaluable when entering the international business field.” -3% Malaysia +Aidan McKevitt, USA +Class of 2018 -Middle East, Market shares2 +“The environment at GBSB Global Business School is very encouraging. +There are a lot of great teachers, and I have made friends with individuals +from different parts of the world. The international atmosphere at the school +is inspiring, and the motivated future entrepreneurs, many of whom are +my friends and fellow students, encourage me to set higher standards +and goals. At the end of my course, I will not only have knowledge and +practical skills but also many great future opportunities.” -8% Saudi Arabia7 +Anel Duisenova, KAZAKHSTAN +Class of 2018 -4% United Arab +20 -Emirates +21 -Latin America, Market shares2 + PROGRAM OVERVIEW -8% Mexico +Academics - Largest among international and +27 -regional banks3 +MONTHS OF STUDIES +Full Time – 3 Years +Part Time – up to 6 Years - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and +09 ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 +ACADEMIC TERMS +Each Term Lasts 11 Weeks with +Christmas, Easter and Summer +Holidays In-between - Strong foundation in China / PRD to +OCT -support future expansion +JAN APR - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting +ANNUAL INTAKES +October, January & April -with 28% market share6 +DAYS PER WEEK ON +AVERAGE +Mornings and Afternoons - Leading international bank in the Middle +06 -East8 +SPECIALIZATIONS +Tailor the Program to +Your Interests - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade +180 -finance9 +CREDITS +European Credit +Transfer System (ECTS) - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and +100% +in English -Belt and Road Initiative10 +INTERNATIONALLY ACCREDITED +BACHELOR’S DEGREE +(EQF Level 6) - #1 DCM in Middle East5 +ACADEMICS - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on +Program Overview -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA +Program Objectives -2017 +Program Highlights -2030E +Global Study Trips -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes +Program Structure -Japanese banks +Course Descriptions -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees +Faculty -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 +G-Accelerator -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) +22 -8 +23 - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength + PROGRAM OBJECTIVES + +At the end of the program, graduates will demonstrate a comprehensive knowledge of business and will obtain an +international perspective of organizations. Students will have acquired the tools needed to apply knowledge within +the various functional areas in order to implement innovative business strategies in accordance with the values +associated with promoting organizations’ social commitment. + +01 + +02 + +03 + +Engages in critical thinking in the +area of business administration and +digital innovation and demonstrates +independent thought and problem +solving underpinned by evidenced +based arguments. + +complex + +Manages +professional +activities efficiently and professionally +into +to put managerial decisions +the +into account +practice +organizational context together with +different constraints. + +taking + +Demonstrates administrative design +and resource in elaborating social, +ethical, innovative and international +approaches to complex management +and digital business +situations, +and takes responsibility for their +consequences. + +04 + +05 + +06 + +Shows creativity and initiative in +developing digital transformation +and digital +intra-entrepreneurial +projects by liaising and working +with others to deliver high level of +team performance. + +Has developed learning skills that are +necessary to continue professional +development in the area of business +administration and digital innovation +evaluating personal +by +strengths and weaknesses, keeping up +to date with relevant management and +digital business technologies, ideas +and practices. + +critically + +Has developed proficiency and literacy +in the use of digital technology needed +to access learning opportunities and to +pursue a managerial career in dynamic, +innovative digital organizations. -2 +24 -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows +25 -Aspiration + Academics -Characteristics +Academics -Markets +PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS -Markets at -scale +Learning Outside the Classroom -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” +Use of the Best Case Studies -Markets as -leading -international -bank +Hands-on Lectures & Group Projects -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” +Workshops - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% +Included in the curriculum are annual visits to different companies +and company presentations on campus, so students may see how +professionals conduct business in the real world. Past visits have +included meetings with international companies institutions such +as Hewlett-Packard (HP), W Hotel, Estrella Damm, Tiffany & Co., +World Trade Organization, United Nations, Keiretsu Forum, and +many others. -market share +The students develop their analytical and problem solving skills by +working on case studies from Harvard Business School, Harvard +Business Law Review, Ivey Publishing and other important +resources widely used by the leaders in business education. - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments +The bachelor program incorporates lectures that provide practical +knowledge that is applicable to the business environment on a +global scale. Modules provide students with the opportunity to +collaborate in different teamwork settings in order to simulate +various business situations. - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore +New workshops for the bachelor’s students are constantly being +added to the curriculum to inspire students, increase their +creativity and help them bring their ideas to fruition. - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 +Faculty with Industry Experience and Invited +Speakers - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) +Each faculty member at GBSB Global has professional experience +in the subject area they are teaching. Additionally, invited speakers +from different +international companies and organizations +constantly visit GBSB Global. This provides students with an +opportunity to learn directly from practicing professionals and to +understand how business is conducted in real life. - Australia - Canada - China - France +Innovative Teaching Methodologies - Germany - India - Indonesia - US +GBSB Global is passionate about the different advances in business +education and constantly implements innovative teaching +methods into the bachelor curriculum in order for students to +develop different skills in an interactive and engaging way. -Markets to -connect the -network +Knowledge-by-Doing -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” +Focus on Innovation and Technology - Targeted offering for +Various program modules incorporate a learning-by-doing +teaching methodology that allows students to not only gain +theoretical knowledge but also to practice what has been learned +in class. -international customers +Businesses need managers with the knowledge to be both globally +aware and digitally trained. They require digital strategists able to +exploit the new technologies on the market for a maximum return +on investment. GBSB Global aims to bring modern technology to +the classroom for the students to explore the opportunities which +it provides. - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where +Networking Opportunities -possible +Students have many opportunities to network with everyone +from startup entrepreneurs to corporate professionals, as well as +professors and other students. - Network markets to +26 -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) +27 - Supporting subsidiaries of + Academics -global customers +PROGRAM STRUCTURE -% of adj. -revenue +Specialization and Electives -FY17 +Academics -c.60% +Alternatively a student may opt to choose six elective units without following any specialization track. -c.25% +Digital Entrepreneurship (45 ECTS) -c.15% +1ST YEAR: COMPULSORY (60 ECTS) -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC +Undergraduate Certificate in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (32 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Undergraduate Diploma in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (60 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Possible Exit Award -9 +● Valuating and Fundraising a Digital Start-up - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength +● E-Commerce Development -3 +● Design Thinking and Agile Methodology for + Innovation -Signature balance sheet strength +● Knowledge Management and Learning Organisations -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) +● Social Entrepreneurship -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 +● Talent Management in the Digital Era -Customer accounts +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Entrepreneurship -Balance Sheet +Global Business Environment -Loans & advances to -customers +Business Communication -Total equity +Introduction to Digital Entrepreneurship and Innovation -1.4tn +Fundamentals of Marketing in the Digital Era -1.0tn +Principles of Accounting -198bn +Business Law in a Digital Context -Total regulatory capital +Business Math and Statistics -182bn +(7 ECTS) -Capital +(6 ECTS) -Leverage ratio + (7 ECTS) -Total capital ratio +(13 ECTS) -5.6% +(7 ECTS) -20.9% +(7 ECTS) -Advances to deposits ratio +(13 ECTS) -71% +Digital Communication & PR (45 ECTS) -Funding and -liquidity +● Digital Branding -Liquidity coverage ratio +● Digital Communication Strategies and Digital Media -142% +● Reputation and Relationship Management in the + Digital Era -10 year PBT -volatility2 +● Principles of Public Relations -LICs / loans -and advances3 +● Investor Relations -Advances to -deposits ratio +● Visual Communications for Digital and Offline + Channels -Leverage ratio +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Communication + & PR -Total capital -ratio +2ND YEAR: COMPULSORY+ SPECIALIZATION (60 ECTS) -Liquid asset buffer +Digital Marketing (45 ECTS) ->500bn +Undergraduate Higher Diploma in Business Administration and Digital Innovation (120 ECTS, EQF/MQF Level 5) +Possible Exit Award -CET1 ratio +Strategic Management of Enterprise and Digital Innovation -Peer group -average1 +Managerial Accounting -2.6x +Leadership and Organizational Behavior -HSBC +Starting a New Digital Business -1.0x +Business Economics -5.5%4 +Business Research Methods -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. +Elective 1 -10 +Elective 2 -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda +Elective 3 -1 +3RD YEAR: COMPULSORY + SPECIALIZATION (60 ECTS) -2 +Professional and Career Development -3 +Innovative and Creative Thinking -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength +Corporate Finance -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Disruptive Technologies for Innovation and Change -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Elective 1 -11 +Elective 2 - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth +Elective 3 -Transformation since 2011 +Undergraduate Dissertation -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +(13 ECTS) - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 +(6 ECTS) - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by +(6 ECTS) -USD349bn or 29%1 +(7 ECTS) - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions +(7 ECTS) - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities +(6 ECTS) - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” +(4 ECTS) -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities + (4 ECTS) - Shifted business to Asia and +(7 ECTS) -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 +(6 ECTS) - Strengthened network to support +(4 ECTS) -global trade and capital flows +(7 ECTS) - Demonstrated ability to execute +(13 ECTS) -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength +(4 ECTS) -Growth +(4 ECTS) -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses +(7 ECTS) -Turnaround +(15 ECTS) -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre +● Digital Branding -Customer +● Management of Retail and Electronic Distribution + Channels -1 +● Pricing Strategies and Digital Products -2 +● E-Commerce Development -3 +● Sales Management -4 +● Consumer Behaviour and Emerging Technologies -5 +● Dissertation in the area of Digital Marketing -6 +Fashion & Luxury Business (45 ECTS) -7 +● Sustainable Fashion and Luxury -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy +● Event Management & Sponsoring -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service +● Digital Branding -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network +● Recreation, Leisure and Wellness Business -Turn around our US business +● Fashion & Luxury Marketing -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses +● Management of Retail and Electronic Distribution + Channels -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains +● Dissertation in the area of Fashion and/or Luxury + Business -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved +Finance & FinTech (45 ECTS) -customer service +● Portfolio Management and Wealth Planning + Investments - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- +● Foundations of FinTech -leading financial crime standards +● FinTech in Banking: Challenges and Opportunities -Empower our -people +● Advanced Issues in Accounting -8 +● Investor Relations -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills +● Dissertation in the area of Finance and/or FinTech -Our People +Sports & eSports Management (45 ECTS) -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis +● Sports and eSports Management -12 +● Event Management & Sponsoring - Strategic priorities +● Business Models and Entrepreneurship in eSports -1-3 +● Sports and eSports Marketing -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity +● Talent Management in the Digital Era -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 +● Recreation, Leisure and Wellness Business -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity +● Dissertation in the area of Sports and/or eSports + Management -CAGR --8% +28 -72.3 +29 -mid single -digit growth, p.a. + Academics -+7% +GLOBAL +STUDY TRIPS -51.4 +GBSB Global Business School arranges Global Study Trips, a +yearly educational trip abroad. This is an opportunity of a lifetime +for all students. The visited organizations are closed to the general +public, but the relationships GBSB Global Business School has +established with these institutions allow for these visits to be +planned. -48.0 +Some of the organizations GBSB Global +students visit: -2011 +UNESCO in Paris -2016 +United Nations Conference on Trade and +Development in Geneva -2017 +Organization for Economic Cooperation and +Development (OECD) in Paris -2020 -Target +United Nations in Geneva -1. ROE including PVIF +World Trade Organization (WTO) in Geneva -Market -Growth +European Commission in Brussels -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn +Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for +Human Rights in Geneva -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance +30 -Asia Wealth +31 -Asset Management -(Asia) + Academics -Belt and Road +FACULTY -Insurance -(Asia)1 +GBSB Global faculty is as diverse as the student +body with faculty members representing many +different countries and nationalities. -ASEAN +Each faculty member, apart from a strong academic background, +has a practical, professional experience in their subject area, which +allows the students to learn directly from industry professionals. -PRD +GBSB Global Faculty Statistics -UK -Ring-fenced Bank +North America -Hong Kong +South America -Transaction Banking/ -International network +9% -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) +18% -Cost of Equity +72% -RoTE +Europe -13 +1% - Strategic priorities +Asia -1 +32 -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia +33 ->3bn + G-ACCELERATOR ->1bn +G-Accelerator at GBSB Global is an innovative +program that seeks to help current students +and graduates launch a startup. The program +works with an esteemed faculty and GBSB Global’s mentors, +aiming to provide students with the support necessary on +every step of the way, from idea formation and adaptation +to supply chain, financial, and legal negotiations. GBSB +Global offers residents a free package of mentorship hours, +infrastructure facilities and the occasional support on +funding market access. ->0.2bn +G-Accelerator Services: -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) +Financial Support +Services -Opportunities and areas of investment +Infrastructure +Services -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +Mentorship Services -USD +“Mentors bring a great input for the process of my +start-up, as well as my personal growth. It has been +very valuable to get provided with personal advice +from two professionals with many years of relevant +experience. We all have different backgrounds +which results in broad knowledge, different working +methods and discussions - something that +is +absolutely necessary in order to create a value-added +business model. Mentors always provide me with +direct constructive feedback. I really appreciate their +effort and input and their experience within the field +of entrepreneurship helps me formulate guidelines +and prioritize my activities” -PBT, 2017 -USDbn +Eva Groot +G-Accelerator Resident -11.4 +34 -7.5 +35 -A + CAREER SUPPORT DURING +& BEYOND YOUR STUDIES -Build on strength in Hong Kong +Improve Your Career Prospects - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments +At GBSB Global Business School our vision is to be +a leading innovative business school, developing +transformational ideas and professionals that shape +the future of business. -Revenue, 2017 USDbn +Our Career Services team will support you throughout your +studies and beyond to ensure you achieve your full potential. You +will connect your goals and values and discover the influencing, +communication and leadership skills you need to actively manage +and accelerate your career. -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) +Career development is a journey. Wherever you are in the process +– from starting a graduate job to considering changing industries +– GBSB Global offers assistance to help students plan and achieve +career success. -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) +virtual career fairs to speak with HR representatives from main +multinational companies. -ASEAN +Being an official ACCA partner school, gives our students an +exclusive access to thousands of international jobs in finance +through ACCA portal. Additionally, GBSB Global is a partner of +HOSCO – world’s leading hospitality network which publishes job +offers in tourism and hospitality. -China +Help from Your Faculty -India +Very often faculty members who are working +in their +corresponding fields introduce students to different professionals +and job opportunities. It is a great advantage of having lecturers +who are not only academics, but also involved in the professional +sector. -Australia +Coaching & Career Development Support -Other Asia +GBSB Global provides all kinds of support for the students to +become more employable. Career Services helps students create +CV’s, prepare for interviews and assists with the job search. -4.7 +Career Development Workshops -3.1 +Skills webinars covering topics such as Preparation for an +Interview, Salary Negotiation, Managing Workplace, Job Search +Tips, etc. -PRD +Career Consultations & Executive Coaching -0.2 +You will have access to career consultations and executive +coaching. One career consultation with one of our highly trained +career experts available at any time during the program to suit +your needs. You may also extend your coaching relationships by +purchasing further sessions. -2.4 +Grow Your Global Network -2.4 +Studying alongside students from all over the world, having +international teachers and meeting business leaders from +different companies is a unique opportunity to broaden your +business experience, grow your global network, apply your skills +and explore a new culture. Explore the themes of development +and globalization, and develop close working relationships with +your international peers while studying online at GBSB Global +Business School. This global network will be one of your biggest +assets in your professional career. -0.9 +Industrial Visits -0.9 +GBSB Global Business School arranges visits to different +companies where students are introduced to the management +and offered to leave their CV’s, as well as develop their professional +networks. -2.1 +Expert Insights -1.2 +Company Presentations on Campus -0.5 +Experienced guest speakers share first-hand industry insights. -0.9 +Online Resources -0.4 +GBSB Global has it’s own career portal available exclusively for +GBSB Global students and alumni with more than 150.000 +jobs and internships postings around the world and regular -0.8 +GBSB Global Business School organizes presentations of different +companies on the campus, so that the students can meet the +representatives of a variety of companies and apply for different +positions offered by the firms. -B +IMPROVE YOUR +CAREER PROSPECTS -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing +Career Support During & Beyond Your Studies -technology in PRD +Careers After Graduation -C +Industrial Visits, Career Fairs & Company Presentations -Build leading Wealth Management business +Do Your Internship in Europe - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater +36 -China and ASEAN +37 - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional + Improve Your Career Prospects -clients +Improve Your Career Prospects -D +Finding Employment Within 1-3 Months After +Graduation -Expand our business in ASEAN +Graduates from GBSB Global have secured employment at top +companies all over the world. Like GBSB Global alumni, you could +end up working at Apple, SAP, Deloitte and many more. With the +right education, training and networking, the opportunities to +build your future career are endless. - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise +Most of the GBSB Global graduates find employment within the +first 1-3 months after finishing their studies. Job opportunities +arise from securing placements while studying, as the internships +often turn into full-time positions. Also, advanced job searches +ensure student success after graduation. -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth +Some of the companies where GBSB Global +graduates work: - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position + WHAT OUR STUDENT SAY -14 +“The program helped me expand my business knowledge. +Due to this learning I have been able to re-enter the +corporate world at Apple Distribution International, +where innovative MBA graduates are sought after.” - Strategic priorities +“You have people from Asia, Europe, the Middle East, +from the States, from everywhere so you get to feel the +culture of everyone.” -1A +Neil McLoughlin, IRELAND +Demand Analyst at Apple, Inc -Build on strength in Hong Kong +Serían Nassif, EGYPT +Customer Service Manager, Céline -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… +“The most valuable experience I had was organizing the +B.I.T. of Fashion conference, because I learned how to +organize events on a professional level.” -Opportunities and areas of investment +“The school organized a lot of different events that +promoted development of our communication skills, +presentation skills, made us more open-minded, and +more culturally intelligent.” -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn +Tanja Sredojevic, SLOVAKIA +Marketing Analyst, Céline -HSBC market -share, % +Aizat Kalbergenova, KAZAKHSTAN +Business Operations Analyst, SAP -USD0.9tn +“We had these classes about trends, marketing, the theory +about fashion and luxury industry which is now helping +me to understand new things and to bring new ideas.” -USD2.9tn +“Having an internship in a Spanish hotel chain was a great +opportunity. As I was working at the same time as I was +completing my studies, it helped me to apply the new +knowledge I attained from GBSB Global to my job.” -10% +Ioannis Antonopoulos, GERMANY +Manager, Swarovski -CAGR -2005-17 +Galina Sverchkova, KAZAKHSTAN +Hostess, Unico Hotels, Grand Hotel Central Barcelona -24% +38 -2005 +39 -10% + Improve Your Career Prospects -Asset growth +CAREERS AFTER GRADUATION -25% +90% +Are Employed Within +a Year of Graduation* -20172 +70% +Maintain Their +Employment Over a Year -Leading market share across major products2 +60% +Increased +Responsibilities Within +a Year* -…with leading positions across major products3 +79% +Improved Their Management +Skills “Much” or “To a Great +Extent” Due to a Professional +Internship -Customer -accounts +92% +Are Satisfied “Much” or “To +a Great Extent” with GBSB +Global Experience -Loans and -advances to -customers +51% +Consider GBSB Global +to have a “Decisive” and +“Significant” Impact on +Their Careers -DCM +60% +Are Employed Outside +Their Home Countries -#1 +26% +Launched Their Own +Business -#1 +30% +Joined Fortune +500 and Fortune 100 +Companies -#1 +29% +Reached Upper, +Senior, or Executive +Management Positions +After Graduation -Mortgages +56% +Increased Their Salary +Within a Year After +Graduation -37% +63% +Consider GBSB Global +Educational Model to Have +Improved Their Management & +Leadership Skills -#1 +40 -Credit cards +*10% Employed Before Graduation **20% Promoted to Higher Positions ->40% +41 -Trade finance + Improve Your Career Prospects -#1 +YOUR INTERNSHIP +JOURNEY -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments +Improve Your Career Prospects -Enhance -customer -experience +Internships are usually +paid and can lead to full-time +jobs. -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments +Our campuses located in business +cities plenty of multinational +companies, +so finding an +internship should not be a problem. - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident +GBSB Global offers its students a +unique opportunity to complete +their internship during the program or +straight after graduation. -Chinese customers +A student may complete an internship +only in the cities and countries where +GBSB Global campuses operate. - Invest in insurance for sustainable +The duration of the internship +cannot exceed six months +and GBSB Global will provide +paperwork assistance (including +student visa documents) to help +students to secure internships. -market share growth +Students are encouraged to use +the online resources offered by +GBSB Global and to attend +the online workshops +assisting on how to look for an +internship. - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business +42 -Banking +43 - Explore partnerships to launch + Why GBSB Global -innovative solutions +OUR APPROACH TO +BUSINESS EDUCATION - Capture new growth opportunities with +Global Diversity -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese +We are one of the leading in Europe with a true focus on +the world: -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as +Students from 100+ countries +Faculty from 37+ countries +International partners +Internship opportunities worldwide +Multicultural case studies +Cultural visits and experiences -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation +An Opportunity to Learn from Great Business +Leaders -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia +Our faculty and invited speakers are highly professional +business people coming from: -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share +Multinational companies +R&D fields in various business areas +Entrepreneurial positions at startups and rapidly +expanding businesses -15 +Innovative Programs -excluding Japan +Personalized Approach - Strategic priorities +Continuous application of the latest trends and methods in +innovative education: -1B +We foster a student-centered learning approach which +provides: -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) +Innovative teaching methods like visual thinking and +design thinking +New product development and rapid prototyping +Innovative business model development -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily +Customized education in small groups; +most classes have a maximum of 30 students +High level of student involvement at GBSB Global +Individualized attention provided by the +GBSB Global academic team addressing your +concerns and requests -Opportunities and areas of investment +Integrity, Business Ethics & Sustainability -USDbn +Employability & Career Development -Revenue +We educate students to become highly professional and +responsible business leaders by embedding the following in +every curriculum: -0.18 +Human rights issues +Sustainability practices +Business ethics -2014 +GBSB Global Business School supports students in +securing their future careers by providing: -0.22 +Individual coaching sessions +Group workshops and company presentations +Career counseling +Constant job and internship offers from our partners -2017 +Education in English & the Opportunity to Learn +More Languages ->USD1bn +All programs are taught in English, but with a diverse student +body and faculty from all over the world, you will have the +chance to learn many other languages. +Some commonly found around are: -c.0.5 +Spanish +English +Russian +French +German -2020 -target +Technological Approach -Medium- -term target +GBSB Global Business School is a technology-driven school +that is the first and only higher education institution in +Europe that leading to be one of the first Microsoft +Showcase Business Schools in Europe. -Loans & advances to customers +GBSB Global provides a fully digitized environment complete +with: ->20bn +Online collaborative spaces +Microsoft Office 365 accessibility +Free wifi in all facilities -4.1 +WHY GBSB GLOBAL -6.2 +Our Approach to Business Education ->10bn +Accreditation & Memberships -2014 +Rankings -2017 +Strategic Partners -2020 -target +Achievements -Medium- -term target +Campuses - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank +Latest Digital Innovations & Teaching Methods -in China, opened for business in December 2017 +Extra-Curricular Activities - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled +Accommodation -since project launched in June 2015 +44 - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 +45 - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect + Why GBSB Global - Enhance corporate coverage to +ACCREDITATION -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading +MEMBERSHIPS - Broaden client base and drive for +Why GBSB Global -deposit-heavy product mix +GBSB Global Business School in Malta is licensed as a Higher +Education Institution (License number: 2020-12) by +The National Commission of Further and Higher +Education. NCFHE is a national entity responsible for setting +and updating the Malta Qualifications framework, +setting standards for the different qualification +levels, accrediting courses at different MQF levels, +and ensuring that the national quality assurance framework is +upheld by all further and higher education providers in Malta. -Emerging -Middle -Class +GBSB Global’s programs in Barcelona and Madrid are +for +accredited by the Accreditation Council +Business Schools and Programs (ACBSP). ACBSP is a +leading U.S. specialized accreditation body for business education +supporting, celebrating, and rewarding excellence in teaching. +The association embraces teaching excellence +as one of its main virtues and emphasizes the +importance of learning to students worldwide. +ACBSP is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education +and the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA). -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity +GBSB Global is proud to be a partner of UNWTO. The +World Tourism Organization, UNWTO, is the United +Nations agency responsible for the promotion of responsible, +sustainable and generally accessible tourism across the +globe. GBSB Global joins the culminationation of over 500 +companies including educational and research institutions, +destinations and NGOs. The UNWTO’s Affiliate +Members Programme provides a platform for its +partners to engage in important conversations, +share information and promote further action. - Fully leverage capital market +The Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business. +AACSB International is a global association of +leaders +in education and business dedicated +to supporting and advancing quality business +education worldwide. Through membership, accreditation, +research, thought leadership, professional development, and +advocacy, AACSB partners with over 1,500 organizations, from +more than 90 countries globally. Membership or participation +in the Global Education Alliance does not imply accreditation. -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation +Several Master’s programs at GBSB Global are accredited by +ECBE (European Council for Business Education), the +leading accreditation organization in Europe that helps to ensure +that accredited members satisfy the requirements of the +European Higher Education Area (EHEA) as set forth +in the Bologna Process and other EU directives. ECBE +is an affiliate member of ENQA and a candidate for membership +in ENQA. -New business -capabilities +The GBSB Global Business School is accredited by +Accreditation Service for International Schools, +Colleges and Universities (ASIC). The University has +earned Premier status with ASIC for its commendable areas of +operation. ASIC accreditation helps students and parents +make a more informed choice and will also help +a school, college, university, training provider +or distance education provider, demonstrate to the +international student body that they are a high quality institution. -16 +ASIC is recognised by UKVI in UK, is a member of the CHEA +International Quality Group (CIQG) in USA and is listed in their +International Directory, is a member of the BQF (British Quality +Foundation) and are institutional members of EDEN (European +Distance and E-Learning Network). - Strategic priorities +46 -1C +47 -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth + Why GBSB Global -Rising wealth in Asia +RANKINGS -Private financial wealth1, USDtn +STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS -2016-21E -CAGR +Why GBSB Global -223 +GBSB Global awarded as a Four Star +by QS Ranking System -Middle class in Asia2 +Institution -# of people, bn +Listed among Top Business Schools +QS Business Masters Ranking -2.5x +in Europe -152 +in the -E. Europe +Unites States Sports Academy +(America’s Sports University) -L. America +The University of Vic - Central University +of Catalonia (UVic-UCC) + +The USSA was founded in 1972 as a response to high demands +and increasing need in the sports industry. Their mission is +to serve the world as a sport education resource +platform, providing students with mentorship, various +research facilities, and services. The academy’s distance learning +delivery system enables students from all around the world +to take advantage of their resources. -MENA +UVic-UCC aims to foster higher education, postgraduate training +and scientific and cultural research activities, and knowledge +transfer; paper and multimedia publishing; grants to support all +these activities; and economic and social regional development. +UVic-UCC seeks to provide in-service teacher training, +support for the tutorial system and teaching innovation. -N. America +Granted Palme of Excellence for Strong Local Influence -34% +MBA program is ranked as Tier One in the Global MBA +Rankings in CEO Magazine -W. Europe +Received +Learning and International Orientation -25% +top scores -Japan +for Research, Teaching & -10% +Microsoft Showcase Schools -Asia ex Japan +Zaragoza Logistics Center – +MIT Global Scale Network -21% +Recognized as a +by Newsweek Magazine -166 +leader -33% +in global education -24% +GBSB Global Business School is one of the first business school +in Europe that obtained the status of a Microsoft Showcase +School and was recognized by Microsoft as a leader in +digital education, providing students with the most state-of- +the-art learning experience from day one. -9% +GBSB Global collaborates with ZLC-MIT Global Scale +Network. Zaragoza Logistics Center (ZLC) is a research +institute established by the Government of Aragon in Spain in +partnership with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and +the University of Zaragoza. Founded in 2003, the ZLC +headquarters is located in the heart of PLAZA, the largest +logistics park in the southern Europe that operates as a working +laboratory to transfer new knowledge and best working +practices. -23% +Mentioned as Top 10 popular Online bachelor programs +by Educations -33% +The Association of Chartered +Certified Accountants (ACCA) -5.6% +GBSB Global’s MBA & Bachelor/Master in Finance students +have a unique advantage – with all finance programs aligned +to the ACCA requirements, the school prepares students +with the competencies needed to earn the ACCA +certification from levels F1 to F4. -Average household annual income3 +48 -2015 +49 -2030E + Why GBSB Global -USD‘000 +CAMPUSES -2.3x +Why GBSB Global -22% + Malta Campus -3.5% + Barcelona Campus -7% + Madrid Campus -1.7% + Online Campus -28% +Malta’s campus is located in a residential area of +the island’s central region, only 15 minutes by bus +from the seaside and the capital city. The campus +neighborhood, Birkirkara, has grown over the years and become +an important commercial center, it’s also one of the oldest and +most populated cities in the island. So, it is full of shops, local bars, +and coffee shops where students can study and enjoy their free +time. -9.9% +GBSB Global’s Malta Campus boasts 7 classrooms, +a well-appointed library and resource center and an +inner courtyard. -2017 +There is also a beautiful garden where most of our social activities +take place, and where the students can unwind and relax. -2030E +Barcelona campus is located in the heart of the city, +in the vibrant Eixample neighborhood. The campus +is set in a modern, bespoke building to guarantee effective and +comfortable learning. -HNWI financial wealth4 +Our Barcelona campus maximizes over 1000 meters of +academic space which includes smart classrooms +furnished with sophisticated technologies, a library +with a collection of scholarly resources, a multi- +purpose dining area, and an on-campus computer +laboratory. Individual study nooks, co-working spaces, meeting +and conference rooms and a charming landscaped garden terrace +are all available to students attending our school. -USDtrn +The Madrid campus is located in the university +area of the Spanish capital, just a 10 minute walk +from the metro station “Cuatro Caminos” in the city +center. The campus neighborhood is full of student residences +and local bars where students can study and enjoy their free time. -2.0x +Facilities in all campuses include: +● Computers and space for individual work +● A print and photocopy service +● Vending machines +● Meeting rooms +● Comfortable, co-working spaces +● Free Wi-Fi in all facilities -2014 +Online Campus offers our acclaimed programs +online. Take advantage of GBSB Global’s anytime, +anywhere approach to business education today. +This state-of-the-art campus offers students the flexibility to study +for their degree on their terms. Earn an upstanding degree from a +school that is transforming the way in which education is provided +today. -2016 +This Online Campus offers all the same degree programs that +would be available to you face to face. Benefit from our world-class +faculty, diverse student body and network opportunities from +around the world. -2021E +50 -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 +51 -2017 + Why GBSB Global -2025E +CAMPUSES -17 +52 -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities +53 -1C + Why GBSB Global -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia +LATEST DIGITAL INNOVATIONS +& TEACHING METHODS ->USD1bn +GBSB Global has been at the forefront of +developing and applying learning technologies +in the classroom. Faculty, staff, and students +have pioneered technologies that enhance +visualization, facilitate knowledge mapping, +integrate games into learning, and advance the +digital humanities. ->0.4bn +We seek to encourage and enable faculty and students to use the +Microsoft Office 365 for Education platform and other digital tools, +such as those described below, through knowledge dissemination, +training, and support. ->0.1bn +GBSB Global Business School is proud to be one of the leading +institutions in Europe to respond to the challenges of the 21st +century. Most of our classrooms are equipped with digital +blackboards, students can use special mobile apps to help them +manage their learning process, and the latest teaching methods +such as Lego ® Serious Play ®, Rapid Prototyping, and Design +Thinking are widely used to develop creative and entrepreneurial +abilities of our students. + +Classroom Interactive Touchscreen (Digital +Blackboards) + +The Digital Interactive Classroom is packaged with a robust +infrastructure that helps students to stand globally competent +with the help of state-of-the-art technology, bringing tomorrow’s +education to us today. The set-up includes a giant Interactive +Touchscreen which allows a lecturer to write directly on the screen +– on top of any digital content – just like pen on paper. It doesn’t +get any easier or more intuitive. The touchscreens immediately +provide handwritten input to any PC or Mac of all students. -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today +Video Wall + +Students at our Barcelona campus can enjoy a giant video +wall. Video wall enables better communication within GBSB +Global’s community as it displays announcements, latest news, +achievements, and institutional videos. -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 +Virtual Learning Environment -Opportunities and areas of investment +Lego ® Serious Play ® -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 +The LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® Method is a technique which +improves group problem solving. By utilizing visual, auditory and +kinesthetic skills, the Method requires participants to learn and +listen, and it provides all participants with a voice. The Method +serves as a shared language regardless of culture or position. Each +participant builds his or her own 3D LEGO® model in response +to the facilitator´s questions using specially selected LEGO® +elements. These 3D models serve as a basis for group discussion, +knowledge sharing, problem solving and decision making. -USD +Virtual Learning Environment enables students to request +different academic services without the use of paper or personal +interaction. Additionally, students can track the status of the +request and value the services received. -Wealth in -Asia +Online Classroom in a Mobile App -Private -Bank +Virtual learning environment for Education allows students to +access their online classroom and to consult assignments, class +notes, readings, send messages to instructors, etc. from anywhere +by installing an easy to use mobile app. -RBWM -Wealth +Creativity Enabled Classrooms -Insurance1 +Almost all classrooms at GBSB Global contain easy to move tables +which facilitate hands-on experiments. A typical class incorporates +lecture, experiments, discussion questions, visualizations, and +pencil-and-paper exercises. -Asset -Management1 0.3 +54 -1. +55 -Includes manufacturing revenue only + Why GBSB Global -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) +EXTRA-CURRICULAR +ACTIVITIES - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater +ACCOMMODATION -China +Why GBSB Global - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth +Welcome Events -0.7 +Cultural Events - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by +The GBSB Global Business School Welcome Event is one of the +school’s main traditions, gathering together all new and current +students and professors before each intake. Whether we choose to +celebrate at a glamorous rooftop bar, at an exciting club, or even +on a boat, we know you will enjoy the experience! -investment in RM and product platform +Beyond local culture, we invite everybody to celebrate different +holidays and festivals from various cultures such as Christmas, +Halloween, The Color Festival and Chinese New +Year. GBSB Global also hosts different events like International +Culinary Nights where students bring food from their home +countries to share with others and really feel as part of the +international family. - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary +Once you have been accepted as a student at GBSB Global, you +will receive our complete Accommodation Guide, a brochure +detailing every platform we recommend using to arrange your +new room, apartment or home. -portfolio management and lombard lending +GBSB Global Business School offers several +research +to +resources +accommodation. Based on +individual +requirements, there are various options available. -Insurance +students +your - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth +help -customers, and strengthen front line +The accommodation guide includes: - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new +Student Residences +Assisted Online Search Platforms +Help Finding a Private Room/Apartment +How to Get Around -distribution channels +Sports Events - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +Excursions and Guided Tours -Asset management +GBSB Global also organizes football games, beach volleyball +tournaments, and is open to any other sports and activities that +are interesting for the students. - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / +GBSB Global regularly offers students excursions and trips nearby +and abroad. -GPB customers +Student room in Melon District residence hall, an official GBSB Global partner - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China +56 -18 +57 -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities + ADMISSION PROCESS +& REQUIREMENTS 2 -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 - -USD - -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion - -Opportunities and areas of investment - - HSBC is positioned for - -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 - - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: - -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme - -– More than 95% of technical - -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed - -Retail -banking - - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by - -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 - - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth - -and acquire new customers - - Leverage our unique global access to support - -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs - -Corporate -banking - - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ - - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) - -Digital and -customer -satisfaction - - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for - -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification - - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) - - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines - -and brands +An admissions officer will +schedule an interview with you -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite - -19 +1 - Strategic priorities +Contact the Admissions +Office by filling out an +online request form or get +in contact with an agency +representative 3 -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Investments are delivering - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance - -Trade Finance -rank1 - -Hong Kong -market share2 - -2015 - -2017 - -#1 - -#1 - - - -10.8% - -13.8% - -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management - -Average GLCM -balances - -c$470bn - -c$530bn - -Hong Kong -market share3 - -22.8% - -26.3% - -FX corporates -rank4 - -FX institutional -rank4 - -#1 - -#7 - - +Send the documentation +required by the program -#1 +Passport -#3 +CV / Resume -Assets under -custody +High School +Diploma -$6.2trn +Proof of +English +Proficiency** -$7.7trn +Motivational +Letter -FX +Student +Card +Photo -Securities -Services - -Digitise and grow Trade Finance - - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems - - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by - -investing in our channel and product capabilities - - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured - -trade - -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM - - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by - -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions - - Create new products and revenue streams - new - -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees - -FX business growth - - Grow the business through the continued development - -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model - - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise - -the customer experience - -Grow Securities Services business - -Market share5 - -5.4% - -5.8% - - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products - -Asia rank6 - -#1 - -#1 +4 -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey +Enroll and +confirm your place -and services; invest in digital future +Welcome to +GBSB Global +Business School - +HOW TO APPLY - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on +Admission Process and Requirements -asset managers and asset owners +58 -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making +59 -up c.82% of the market + For entry to year 1 of the program students should +have completed: -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen +Proof of Proficiency in the English Language -20 +English as a native language; - Strategic priorities +a) -4 +A/S or A levels at the appropriate level or the Matriculation +Certificate Exam with three subjects exams with grades of A, +B, C or D; -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank +TOEFL – Minimum score: 213 (computer based), 79/80 (internet +based), or 550 (paper based); -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn + IELTS – Minimum score: 6.0; -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed +Cambridge ESOL, Certificate in Advanced English (CAE) – +Minimum score: C; -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US +English as the language of instruction during previous +studies in the formal educational system; -2 +Internal English level testing at GBSB Global. -1 +OCT -0 +JAN APR -US +Annual Intakes +October, January & April -UK +b) -China +c) -France +International Baccalaureate Diploma with 34 points overall or +the IB Diploma with specific achievement in higher/standard +level subjects; -% of Group client outbound revenue +GCSE/IGSCE “O” Levels: five subject exams with grades of +A, B, C or D, and A/S or A Levels: three subject exams with +grades of A, B, C or D; -Hong -Kong +d) -24% +AP Program; -13% +e) -9% +Other high school leaving certificate or equivalent (other +educational systems). -6% +Alternative Entry Routes -6% +Alternative entry routes are available for applicants who do +not possess the standard entry qualifications but have certain +appropriate skills and experience and subject knowledge. These +are detailed in the IQA Manual of GBSB Global within the +“Policies for Admission of Transfer Students and Recognition of +Prior Learning”. -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +The Admissions Committee may consider applications from +suitably qualified students currently attending other universities, +applicants who have achieved a lower level award, or applicants +seeking admission based on Recognition of Prior Learning (RPL). -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +An advanced student is a student who, having successfully +completed an approved program of study and received an award, +is admitted at an appropriate point of an approved program in +a similar field of study to GBSB Global. This generally applies in +cases where a student has completed a lower level award and +subsequently wishes to register for a related higher-level award; -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +A transfer student is a student who, having successfully +completed a part of an approved program of study at another +institution of higher education, is admitted to GBSB Global at +an appropriate point on an approved program in a similar field +of study; -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +A recognition of prior learning student is a student +who is admitted to an approved program at GBSB Global with +credits accumulated from prior certificated learning or via prior +experiential learning. Such prior learning should be relevant/ +applicable to the intended program of study and may allow +exemption from specific modules. -Other +60 -32% +61 -51% + Connect with +GBSB Global -68% - -USD - -JP -Morgan - -Citigroup - -Bank of -America - -HSBC - -BoNY -Mellon - -c.19% - -Overall - -Hong Kong - -Germany - -UK - -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) - -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT - -21 - -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities - -4 - -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform - -The US has made progress over the past several years… - -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth - -Adjusted PBT1, USDm - -RoTE2 - -> 6%2 - -1,201 - -974 - -CML - -US Principal - -464 - -494 - -737 - -920 - -556 - -387 - -2014 - -2015 - -2016 - -2017 - -0.9%2,3 - -2017 - -PBT growth - -Future capital -actions - -2020 - -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration - -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild - - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 - - International client revenue4 booked in the US up - -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY - - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: - -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly - -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion - -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- - -return products and business banking - -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national - -clients in the US - - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in - -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions - - Return to regular dividend payments to Group - -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers - -22 - -to 2017 - - Strategic priorities - -5 - -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 - -GB&M - -34% - -CMB - -35% - -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre - -14% -2% -15% - -c.30% - -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth - -c.35% - -Distribution - -15-20% - -2020 -target - -c.7% - -RWA -optimisation - - Develop distribution - -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending - - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom - -23 - - Strategic priorities - -6 - -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment - -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness - - Investments aligned to strategic priorities - - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term - - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and - -31.1 - -c.4 - -4.5-5 - -5.5-6 - -6-6.5 - -revenue development - - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from - -within the cost base of the Group - -Revenue - -Total -operating -expenses - -Investments - -Costs (ex -investments) - -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity - - Implement strong cost discipline and control - -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market - -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains - -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity - - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each - -year 2018-2020 - -2017 - -2018 - -2019 - -2020 - -Jaws1 - -positive - -positive - -positive - -positive - -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve - -24 - - Strategic priorities - -7 - -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework - -Investment -categories - -Description - -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 - - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) - - Investments in new - -opportunities - - Improve operational - -efficiency in order to lower -cost base - - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 - - Deliver robust solution design - -with additional franchise -benefits - - Turnaround of existing businesses - -(e.g. US) - - Investing in expanding our businesses - -(e.g. PRD) - - Productivity programmes - -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) - - Core infrastructure replacement or - -modernisation (e.g. US) - -c.1/3 - - Implement required - - Deliver in cost - - Implement regulatory programmes - -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security - -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits - -(e.g. IFRS 9) - - Strengthen capabilities to manage - -financial crime risk - - Increase cyber security measures - -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 - -USD15-17bn - -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities - -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure - -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability - -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers - -1. P&L basis - -25 - - Strategic priorities - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation - -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end - -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days - - Strengthen accountability, decision- - -to 10 (Private Banking) - -making - - Clarify roles within the organisation’s - -matrix - -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients - -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 - - Building capabilities for continuous - -improvement - -Streamlining governance - - Reducing number of - -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 - - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance - - Embed throughout the organisation - -and for all legal entities - -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership - - - -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working - - Balanced scorecards to incentivise - -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation - -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online - - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills - -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC - -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of - -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and - -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths - - Build a diverse workforce - -26 - - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates - -Strategic priorities - -Targeted outcome by 2020 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and - - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian - -franchise - - Market share gains in 8 scale markets - -Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy - - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network - - Market share gains - - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from - -international network - - Market share gains in Transaction Banking - -Turn around our US business - - US RoTE >6% - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial - -crime standards - - Increase in asset productivity - - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, - -each financial year - - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 - -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics - -27 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -28 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 - -Reported RoTE walk1 - -% - -8.7 - -6.8 - -2017 -Reported - -Sig items - -2017 ex- -sig items - -Interest -rate rises2 - -UK -growth - -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance - -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network - -US turn- -around3 - -Investments - -Other4 - -ROE -Reported - -5.9% - -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval - -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items - -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency - - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology - ->11 - - Delivering positive - -adjusted jaws - - Increasing capital - -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity - - Sustaining dividend, - -supported by share buy- -backs5 - - With >14% CET1 ratio - -2020 -Reported -(target) - ->10% - -29 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution - -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 - -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders - -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 - -12-13% - -Surplus equity3 - -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 - -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses - -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally - -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 - -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items - -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing - -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base - -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes - ->14% - -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval - -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D - -s -r -o -t -c -a -f - -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e - -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R - -Higher risk weights -under local rules - -Diversification -benefit / other - -Stress testing - -Anticipated -regulatory changes - -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. - -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators - -30 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion - - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest - -growth markets - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and - -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular - -in Asia and from our international network - -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - -- Complete the turnaround in the US - -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while - -delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for - -sustained dividends - -31 +Complete +Program List - 32 +BACHELOR OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Entrepreneurship +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Communication & PR +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Digital Marketing +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Fashion & Luxury Business +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Finance & FinTech +B.A. of Business Administration and Digital Innovation +with Sports and eSports Management + +MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION +MBA General +MBA in Marketing Management +MBA in International Business +MBA in Entrepreneurship +MBA in Finance +MBA in Operations & Supply Chain Management + +MASTER OF ARTS PROGRAMS +MA in Fashion & Luxury Business Management +MA in Communication & Future Marketing +MA in Tourism & Hospitality Management +MA in Business Innovation + +MASTER OF SCIENCE PROGRAMS +MSc in Entrepreneurship +MSc in Finance +MSc in Operations & Supply Chain Management +MSc in International Business Management +MSc in Marketing Management +MSc in Digital Business +MSc in Digital Marketing & Ecommerce +MSc in Financial Management, Digital Banking +& Internet Finance +MSc in Sports Management + +Malta Campus +67 Old Railway Track, +BRK, Birkirkara, Malta + +Madrid Campus +C/Numancia 6 +28039 Madrid, Spain + +Barcelona Campus +C/Aragon 179 +08011 Barcelona, Spain + +www.global-business-school.org +admissions@global-business-school.org +Tel: +34 930 185 473 + +62 diff --git a/q253/random_k4/random_3.md b/q253/random_k4/random_3.md index 967f586b4e4f280152bfd7336d1af8e49e765b34..1c8737f084ba00e51b1c470d69081e0c3c1f99b5 100644 --- a/q253/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q253/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,2406 +1,1014 @@ -Survey of Young Americans’ Attitudes toward Politics and Public Service -47th Edition: March 14 – 21, 2024 -N=2,010 18- to- 29-Year-Olds in English and Spanish -Margin of Error: +/-3.02% at the 95% Level +Wallingford Public Schools - HIGH SCHOOL COURSE OUTLINE -1. +Course Title: Business Mathematics -With regard to school, are you currently enrolled at any of the following? +Department: Mathematics -High School ................................................................................ 9% -Trade/Vocational ........................................................................ 2% -2-year/JC/CC .............................................................................. 7% -4-year college/university .......................................................... 17% -Graduate school .......................................................................... 5% -Business/Professional school ..................................................... 1% -Not currently enrolled .............................................................. 60% +Level(s): General -[If respondent is currently enrolled in a 4-year college or university, ask Q2] +Course Number: 8114 -2. +Grade(s): 11-12 -In which year of college are you? (n=267) +Credit: 1 -First year student/Freshman ..................................................... 24% -Second year student/Sophomore .............................................. 18% -Third year student/Junior ......................................................... 24% -Fourth year student/Senior ....................................................... 28% -Fifth year student or higher ........................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Course Description: +This course focuses on mathematical functions using whole numbers, fractions, decimals, and +percents that are required to function in today’s business world as well as to handle personal +finance. The ability to estimate and approximate answers in solving financial problems will be +emphasized. Students will work with computer spreadsheets and learn to create and interpret +graphic representations of numerical data. Business topics that will be covered include interest +rates, job costing, merchandising, payroll, credit, taxes, insurance, and global business. +Satisfactory completion of this course satisfies one math credit for graduation. -3. +Required Instructional Materials +Practical Mathematics, Fredrick Leinwand Postman Wantuck +Holt Rinehart Winston 1998 Third edition -We understand that plenty of young people are not registered to vote, but we are wondering if -you are registered to vote? +Other Instructional Materials +Business Math (workbook), 15th ed., 2003 Thomson-Southwestern +Business Math published by Prentice Hall +Business Math published by Southwestern +Math in Everyday Life published by Walch +Money Instructor –website +Banking by BankAmerica -Yes ............................................................................................ 75% -No ............................................................................................. 21% -Don’t know ................................................................................. 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Completion/Revision Date -The following questions are about registration and voting… +Approved by Board of +Education on December 17, +2007. -[If respondent was over 18 on November 3, 2020, ask Q4 – Q6] +Mission Statement of the Curriculum Management Team +The mission of the Wallingford K-12 mathematics program is to develop mathematical literacy in all +students. Students will understand the importance of mathematics and become flexible and +resourceful problem solvers. They will use a range of numerical, algebraic, geometrical and +statistical concepts and skills to formulate and solve authentic problems, communicating their +reasoning in oral and written form. -4. +Enduring Understandings for the Course -Which of the following statements best describes your voter registration status for the last -presidential election held on November 3rd, 2020? (n=1,671) +• A problem solver understands what has been done, knows why the process was appropriate, -I was registered ........................................................................ 74% -I thought about registering, but didn’t ........................................ 3% -I tried to register, but was unable to ........................................... 0% -I was not registered to vote on November 3, 2020 .................. 15% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +and can support it with reasons and evidence. - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +• There can be different strategies to solve a problem, but some are more effective and efficient -2 +than others are. -5. +• The context of a problem determines the reasonableness of a solution. +• There are many different ways a paycheck may be calculated +• There is a big difference between the money you earn and the money you take home +• The way that data is collected, organized and displayed influences interpretations. +• The analysis of data is important to the success of a business. +• Knowledge of basic mathematics is essential to personal financial success. +• Time, money, and rate of interest are significant factors in meeting financial goals. -[Split Sample A] Which of the following statements best describes your voting in the last -presidential election held on November 3rd, 2020? (n=837) +Page 1 of 14 -I voted at a polling place .......................................................... 32% -I voted early ................................................................................ 8% -I voted by mail / absentee ballot .............................................. 29% -I planned on voting but wasn’t able to ....................................... 2% -I did not vote in this election .................................................... 27% -I went to the polling place but wasn’t allowed to vote .............. 1% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% + • The amount you save is not as important as establishing the savings habits now. +• The purchasing power of a dollar changes over time. +• Costs and prices can be compared in many ways to determine the best buy. +• Credit cards have both benefits and risks. +• The sticker price of a car is negotiable. +• There are many additional expenses to owning a car. +• Many payment options should be examined before purchasing a car. +• Insurance protects a person against loss and additional expenses. +• Many factors affect insurance premiums. -6. +Page 2 of 14 -[Split Sample B] In November 2020, Donald Trump ran on the Republican ticket against Joe -Biden, for the Democrats. Do you remember for sure whether or not you voted in that election -for president? (n=834) + Learning Strand -Yes, I definitely voted .............................................................. 68% -I’m not 100% certain if I voted .................................................. 5% -I definitely did not vote ............................................................ 26% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +1.0 Problem Solving -7. +NOTE: This learning strand should be taught through the integration of the other learning strands. +This learning strand is not meant to be taught in isolation as a separate unit. -When it comes to voting, with which party do you consider yourself to be affiliated? +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -Net: Democrat ......................................................................... 38% -Strong Democrat ...................................................................... 19% -Not a very strong Democrat ..................................................... 19% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -Net: Republican ...................................................................... 23% -Strong Republican .................................................................... 12% -Not a very strong Republican ................................................... 11% +• A problem solver understands what has +been done, knows why the process was +appropriate, and can support it with reasons +and evidence. -Net: Independent/Unaffiliated ............................................. 37% -Lean Democrat ......................................................................... 10% -Lean Republican ......................................................................... 6% -Do not lean towards either party .............................................. 22% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +• There can be different strategies to solve a +problem, but some are more effective and +efficient than others are. -8. +• The context of a problem determines the -When it comes to most political issues, do you think of yourself as a...? +reasonableness of a solution. -Liberal ...................................................................................... 32% -Moderate, lean liberal ................................................................. 9% -Moderate, no lean ..................................................................... 28% -Moderate, lean conservative ...................................................... 7% -Conservative ............................................................................. 22% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +1.1 Distinguish between given information, - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +unknown information, and assumptions that +may be necessary. -3 +1.2 Devise a plan to solve the problem. +1.3 Identify different strategies to solve a -[If respondent voted in 2020, ask Q9] +problem (table, diagram, number pattern) +1.4 Apply an appropriate strategy(ies) to solve a -9. +problem. -For whom did you vote for president in 2020? (n=1,196) +1.5 Justify the strategy and solution with -Joe Biden .................................................................................. 61% -Donald Trump .......................................................................... 28% -Someone else .............................................................................. 6% -Don’t remember ......................................................................... 1% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% +mathematical reasoning and evidence. +1.6 Analyze strategies used to solve a problem. +1.7 Judge the reasonableness of a solution for a -10. +problem. -How likely is it that you will vote in the 2024 election for President? +1.8 Communicate the solution and the -Definitely will be voting .......................................................... 53% -Probably will be voting ............................................................ 13% -50-50 ........................................................................................ 13% -Probably won’t be voting ......................................................... 10% -Definitely won’t be voting ....................................................... 11% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +strategies used to solve the problem in oral +and/or written form. -11. +1.9 Pose problems from given situations -Do you consider yourself to be politically engaged or politically active? +• How do I know where to begin when solving -Yes ............................................................................................ 27% -No ............................................................................................. 72% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +a problem? -12. +• How does explaining my process help me to -Overall, how closely do you follow news about national politics?.. +understand a problem’s solution better? -Net: Closely ............................................................................. 43% -Net: Not Closely ...................................................................... 56% +• How do I decide what strategy will work best -Very closely ............................................................................. 10% -Somewhat closely ..................................................................... 33% -Not very closely ....................................................................... 33% -Not at all closely ....................................................................... 23% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +in a given problem situation? +• What do I do when I get stuck? +• How do I know when a result is reasonable? +• What is the relationship between solving -13. +problems and computation? -All in all, do you think that things in the nation are…? +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS +• CAPT sample items and released items +• Websites for problem solving -Generally headed in the right direction ...................................... 9% -Off on the wrong track ............................................................. 58% -Not sure what direction the country is headed in ..................... 32% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +- Math Forum +- NCTM Standards and - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Illuminations +• CSDE Goals 2000 resources (Q drive) -4 +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES +Each lesson throughout the course should begin +with a problem solving experience that can +integrate mathematical concepts. -14. +• Small group discussion about strategies and -Thinking about national issues for a moment, which issue concerns you most? +solutions -Net: Economic Issues ............................................................. 27% -Economy .................................................................................. 11% -Inflation/cost of living increases ................................................ 8% -High cost of living/difficult to make ends meet ......................... 2% -Economic equality/inequality/poverty ....................................... 1% -Jobs/Employment ....................................................................... 1% -Financial stability ....................................................................... 1% -Taxes .......................................................................................... 1% -Gas prices/taxes .......................................................................... 1% -Other economy mentions ........................................................... 1% +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -Illegal immigrants /Immigration ................................................ 9% +for a problem -Net: Foreign Policy/National Security .................................... 8% -War/military ............................................................................... 2% -National security ........................................................................ 2% -Israel/Palestine conflict .............................................................. 2% -Other foreign policy ................................................................... 1% -Foreign policy/affairs ................................................................. 1% +• Peer editing of strategies and solutions +• Revise written solutions of problems +• Oral presentation of solution strategies +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -Net: Environmental Issues ...................................................... 6% -The environment ........................................................................ 5% -Global warming .......................................................................... 1% +investigations -Abortion/Reproductive rights ..................................................... 6% +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning +• See other learning strands for integration -Gun control/Second Amendment rights ..................................... 3% -Crime/Crime rates ...................................................................... 2% -Housing ...................................................................................... 2% -Health care ................................................................................. 2% -Government/political corruption ................................................ 2% -Democracy ................................................................................. 2% -Other mentions ......................................................................... 15% -Don't know/no answer ................................................................ 8% -None ........................................................................................... 1% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +• Open-ended questions included on tests -5 +and quizzes -In general, do you approve or disapprove of the job performance of: +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -[Randomize list. Biden anchored first] +Page 3 of 14 -15. -16. -17. -18. + for a problem -Joe Biden as president -Kamala Harris as vice president -The Democrats in Congress +• District rubric for assessing problem solving +• Oral presentation of solution strategies +• See other learning strands for integration -The Republicans in Congress +Page 4 of 14 -Approve Disapprove + LEARNING STRAND -31% -32% -34% +2.0 Earning a Living -24% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -64% -62% -60% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -70% +• There are many different ways a paycheck -Refused -5% -6% -7% +may be calculated -7% +• There is a big difference between the money -Now thinking specifically about Joe Biden, do you approve or disapprove of the way he is handling: +you earn and the money you take home -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Approve”] +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +2.1 Calculate gross pay for hourly rate +employees +2.2 Calculate gross pay for salaried employees +2.3 Calculate regular and overtime pay +2.4 Calculate salary based on commission +2.5 Calculate salary based on piece work +2.6 Calculate deduction & net pay +2.7 Identify employee benefits +2.8 Compare job benefits and job expenses -19. -20. -21. -22. -23. +• How is your net pay calculated? +• How can job expenses and job benefits -24. +affect your earnings? -25. +• How can an employee who is paid hourly +earn more than someone who is salaried? -Student debt relief -The war in Ukraine -The economy +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -Gun violence +• Internet +• Overhead transparency +• Example paycheck stubs -Inflation +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL +STRATEGIES -Israel-Hamas war +• On site visitation of payroll department +• Spreadsheet +• Guest speaker +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -Approve Disapprove +investigations -39% -33% -30% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -25% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENT METHODS -23% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -18% +and quizzes -56% -61% -65% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -69% +for a problem -72% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -76% +Page 5 of 14 -Refused -5% -6% -5% + LEARNING STRAND -5% +3.0 Data Analysis -5% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -6% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -If the election for President were held today and the candidates were: [Randomize -candidates] for whom would you vote? +• The way that data is collected, organized +and displayed influences interpretations. -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 28% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 25% -Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., an independent candidate ................... 11% -Jill Stein, the Green party candidate .......................................... 4% -Cornel West, an independent candidate ..................................... 3% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +• The analysis of data is important to the -26. +• Why is data collected and analyzed? +• How do people use data to influence -If the election for President were held today and the candidates were [Rotate: Joe Biden, the -Democrat and Donald Trump, the Republican], for whom would you vote? +others? -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 38% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 31% -Would not vote ......................................................................... 16% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +success of a business. - 45% - 37% - - - 16% - 2% +• How can predictions be made based on -(% when “Would -not vote” not -included, n=1,682) +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The students will: +3.1 Calculate measures of central tendency +3.2 Calculate range, quartiles, and outliers +3.3 Analyze data related to the world of business +3.4 Represent data using appropriate graphs - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +(line, bar, pie, picture, etc.) +3.5 Interpret data based on a graphs -6 +data? -[If respondent would vote for Joe Biden or Donald Trump in Q26, ask Q27] +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -27. +• Newspapers +• Internet +• Excel -How enthusiastic are you about your support of this candidate? +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL +STRATEGIES +• Spreadsheet +• Guest speaker +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -Joe Biden (n=817) +investigations -Net: Enthusiastic .................................................................... 43% -Net: Unenthusiastic ................................................................ 56% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -Very enthusiastic ...................................................................... 13% -Somewhat enthusiastic ............................................................. 30% -Not very enthusiastic ................................................................ 40% -Not at all enthusiastic ............................................................... 16% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENT METHODS -Donald Trump (n=561) +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -Net: Enthusiastic .................................................................... 68% -Net: Unenthusiastic ................................................................ 32% +and quizzes -Very enthusiastic ...................................................................... 29% -Somewhat enthusiastic ............................................................. 39% -Not very enthusiastic ................................................................ 22% -Not at all enthusiastic ................................................................. 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -28. +for a problem -Donald Trump currently faces 91 felony charges across four criminal cases for keeping -classified documents, falsifying records, and attempting to overturn the 2020 election. If he is -found guilty in any of these trials before the election -- for whom would you vote for -President? +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -[Rotate Joe Biden and Donald Trump] +Page 6 of 14 -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 42% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 24% -Would not vote ......................................................................... 17% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% + LEARNING STRAND - 51% - 29% - - - 18% - 2% +4.0 Personal Banking -(% when “Would -not vote” not -included, n=1,659) +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -7 +• A knowledge of basic mathematics is -Importance of Issues Facing the United States +essential to personal financial success. -In order to measure the relative importance of a set of 16 current issues facing the United States, -respondents were asked a series of match-up questions that took the following form: +• Time, money, and rate of interest are -Thinking about the major issues facing the United States today, please tell me which of the -following two is more important to you: +significant factors in meeting financial goals. +• The amount you save is not as important as -Each respondent was shown each individual issue one time, matched up against another issue chosen -at random for a total of 8 rated matchups per respondent. On average, each of the 120 match-ups was -shown to n=134 respondents. After weighting procedures were performed, each issue was matched up -against each other issue a minimum of 121 times and a maximum of 148 times, though an analysis of -the impacts of weighting procedure showed no significant impact due to weighting procedures on the -relative strength of the match-ups. +establishing the savings habits now. -The 16 issues tested are listed in the table below. +• What are the benefits of have a checking -Q29-Q44 Show the aggregate results of these match-ups, with the percentage shown representing the -aggregate percentage of the time that an issue was rated as more important than the issue it was -matched up against. +and savings account? +• What is the Rule of 72? +• Why do we reconcile a bank statement? +• What are the benefits of banking online? -A full table of results of each individual match-up is available upon request. +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The students will : +4.1 Define debits, credits, fees, & balance. +4.2 Write out a check. +4.3 Maintain a check book. +4.4 Reconcile a bank statement for a checking +account. +4.5 Interpret a bank statement for a savings +account. +4.6 Identify and analyze the effect of different +kinds of checking accounts. +4.7 Calculate interest and principal using simple +and compound interest formulas +4.8 Calculate interest on money market, bonds, +and CD accounts +4.9 Identify and calculate hidden costs of +personal banking -Q29-Q44 are ordered by the percentage of the time an issue was deemed “More Important.” +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -Net: More -Important -64% -59% -56% +• Checkbook +• Internet +• Sample bank statement +• Overhead transparency -Net: Less -Important -33% -37% -40% +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -54% +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -53% +investigations -52% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -52% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -50% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -50% +and quizzes -47% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -47% +for a problem -43% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -43% +Page 7 of 14 -40% + LEARNING STRAND -34% -26% +5.0 Responsible Purchasing -42% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -44% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -43% +• The purchasing power of a dollar changes -44% +over time. -47% +• Costs and prices can be compared in many -46% +ways to determine the best buy. -50% +• Credit cards have both benefits and risks. +• There are various methods of payment for +purchases, (i.e. credit cards, debit cards, +check, cash) -50% +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +5.1 Compute inflation rate +5.2 Compute purchasing power after inflation +5.3 Calculate sales tax +5.4 Analyze the best buy based on unit prices +5.5 Analyze the best buy based on discounts, +sales price, coupons, and rebates +5.6 Read a credit card statement +5.7 Compute an unpaid balance and identify the +new charges +5.8 Compute a credit finance charge based on +fixed and variable rates +5.9 Compute a new credit balance +5.10 Identify and analyze the benefits and +drawbacks of credit cards -53% +• What is the consumer price index? +• How does inflation affect purchasing power? +• How does a knowledge of mathematics help +determine which product is a better buy? +• How does knowledge of mathematics help -54% +one to use a credit card responsibly? -56% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -61% -70% +• Circulars +• Internet +• Overhead transparency +• Consumer reports -Much -More -Imp. -38% -33% -31% +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -33% +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -27% +investigations -28% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -32% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -27% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -29% +and quizzes -27% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -25% +for a problem -23% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -22% +Page 8 of 14 -20% + LEARNING STRAND -17% -12% +6.0 Transportation Expenses -Somewhat -More Imp. -26% -25% -25% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -Somewhat -Less Imp. -15% -18% -19% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -21% +• The sticker price of a car is negotiable. +• There are many additional expenses to -26% +• What expenses factor into owning a car? +• What are important considerations when -24% +owning a car. -20% +buying a car? -23% +• Many payment options should be examined -21% +• How will a knowledge of mathematics help -20% +before purchasing a car. -21% +make a better purchase? -20% +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +6.1 Estimate and compute traveling distances +using a mileage chart or map +6.2 Estimate and compute travel time and rate +of travel +6.3 Determine the cost of a car with options and +additional expenses +6.4 Compute the amount you need to finance to +buy a new car +6.5 Compute the finance charge for an +automobile loan +6.6 Calculate operating expenses (mpg, gas, +repair) +6.7 Justify the purchase of a given car +6.8 Compute the cost for renting a car -20% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -20% +• Car advertisements +• Newspapers +• Consumer reports -17% -14% +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -18% +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -21% +investigations -21% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -22% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -24% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -21% +and quizzes -24% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -20% +for a problem -24% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -22% +Page 9 of 14 -24% + LEARNING STRAND -26% -27% +7.0 Insurance -Much -Less -Imp. -18% -19% -21% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -24% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -23% +• Insurance protects a person against loss -22% +and additional expenses. -22% +• Why is insurance important? +• What factors affect the premiums of different -23% +• Many factors affect insurance premiums. -25% +kinds of insurance? -26% +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +7.1 Define premium and deductible +7.2 Compute life insurance premiums +7.3 Identify the differences between term and +whole life insurance +7.4 Decide, given relevant information, which +type of life insurance to purchase +7.5 Compute health insurance premiums +7.6 Compute insurer’s and insured share of +health insurance cost +7.7 Compute insured’s share of medical bills +7.8 Identify the different types of automobile +insurance +7.9 Compute yearly automobile insurance +premiums +7.10 Calculate property insurance premiums +7.11 Calculate how much can be collected on +insurance claims +7.12 Analyze the factors that influence the +amount of coverage of any insurance -30% +• To what extent will insurance protect you? -29% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -31% +• Requested material from various insurance -32% +companies -35% -43% +• Internet -Don’t -Know -3% -4% -4% +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -4% +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -4% +investigations -4% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -4% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -3% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -4% +and quizzes -3% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -3% +for a problem -4% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -4% +Page 10 of 14 -4% + LEARNING STRAND -5% -4% +8.0 Long Term Investments -29. -30. -31. +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -32. -33. -34. +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -Inflation -Healthcare -Housing +• With higher risk comes the potential to earn +higher reward or returns on our investments. -Gun violence +• It is important to divisive investments. +• Different types of investments offer varying -Jobs -Protecting -Democracy +• What is the stock market and how does it -Corruption +work? -35. -36. -Education -37. Women's +• What is the difference between savings and -reproductive -rights +investments? -Crime +growth potential -Immigration +• What is the difference between a dividend -Taxes +• Investments aren’t guaranteed to grow. -Climate change +and a yield? -Free speech +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +8.1 Compute the cost, redemption value, and +interest earned on U.S. savings bonds. +8.2 Calculate the total investment in a mutual +fund. +8.3 Calculate profit or loss from mutual fund +investments. +8.4 Calculate the cost of stock purchases. +8.5 Calculate annual stock dividends. +8.6 Calculate the yield on stock investments. +8.7 Calculate the proceeds from the sale of +stock. +8.8 Explain what the stock market is and how it +works. +8.9 Identify factors that cause the stock market +to fluctuate. -Israel/Palestine -Student Debt +• What makes one stock a more desirable -38. -39. -40. +investment then the other? -41. -42. +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -43. -44. +• www.stocksquest.com +• Newspaper - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -8 +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -45. Which of the following phrases best describes the United States today? +investigations -A healthy democracy .................................................................. 3% -A somewhat functioning democracy ........................................ 20% -A democracy in trouble ............................................................ 46% -A failed democracy .................................................................. 16% -Don't know ............................................................................... 14% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -Do you agree or disagree with these statements? +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -[Randomize Q46 and Q47. Rank ordered by “Agree”] +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -46. +and quizzes -Joe Biden has what it takes to lead in a crisis +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 26% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 61% +for a problem -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 19% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 20% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 41% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 10% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -47. +Page 11 of 14 -Donald Trump has what it takes to lead in a crisis + LEARNING STRAND -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 33% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 55% +9.0 Budgeting -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 16% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 17% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Don’t know ................................................................................. 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -48. When it comes to the U.S. economy, has recent immigration made it better, worse – or not +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -made a significant difference? +• Organization is necessary to be fiscally -Net: Better-Worse ................................................................ -24% +responsible. -Better .......................................................................................... 9% -Worse ....................................................................................... 33% -No difference ............................................................................ 28% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +• What are the benefits of a budget? +• Why is a budget important for future - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +• Some expenses are predictable while some -9 +financial success? -49. +are varying -The U.S. Census Bureau predicts that white Americans will make up less than half of the U.S. -population by around 2045. Do you think this is: +• How can maintaining a budget provide -Net: Good ................................................................................ 19% -Net: Bad ................................................................................... 18% +• Tracking income and expenses can prevent -Very good for the U.S. ............................................................... 9% -Good for the U.S. ..................................................................... 10% -Neither good nor bad ................................................................ 60% -Bad for the U.S. .......................................................................... 9% -Very bad for the U.S. ................................................................. 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +possible one time expense opportunities? -50. +overspending -How closely have you followed news about the war between Israel and Hamas? +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +9.1 Identify fixed, variable, and annual expenses +9.2 Compute the amount to budget for each of +these expenses +9.3 Analyze a monthly budget sheet +9.4 Prepare a personal budget +9.5 Apply the use of area and perimeter in +preparing a budget for a one time expense. -Net: Closely ............................................................................. 38% -Net: Not closely ....................................................................... 60% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -Very closely ............................................................................... 9% -Somewhat closely ..................................................................... 28% -Not very closely ....................................................................... 33% -Not at all ................................................................................... 26% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +• Excel +• Protractors +• Compass +• Rules +• Overhead Transparency -Which of the following groups do you sympathize with during the war between Israel and Hamas? +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Sympathy”] +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -51. +investigations -52. -53. +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning +• Creating a pie chart representation of a -54. +budget -55. +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -56. +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -The Palestinian -people -The Israeli people -The Palestinian -government -The Israeli -government -SPLIT SAMPLE: -Hamas (n=1,003) -SPLIT SAMPLE: -Hamas, the Islamist -militant group -(n=1,007) +and quizzes -Net: -Sympathy +• Landscape/Remodeling Project +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -A lot of -sympathy +for a problem -Some -sympathy +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -No -sympathy +Page 12 of 14 -Don’t have -enough + LEARNING STRAND -information Refused +10.0 Marketing & Advertising -56% -52% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -32% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS -29% +• Advertising is a necessary expense to -17% +• What is the purpose of marking & -34% -24% +create a greater profit. -10% +advertising? -7% +• Simple algebraic procedures can predict -3% +• What are the benefits and draw backs of -22% -28% +future sales. -22% +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +10.1 Predict future sales using trend +data/forecast methods +10.2 Calculate market share +10.3 Compute the cost of advertising in various +media +10.4 Analyze the most effective advertising +techniques/strategies -21% +various marketing media? -14% +• How does forecasting affect current -10% -12% +business practices? -25% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -33% +• Ruler +• Graph paper +• Graphing calculators -46% +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -31% -32% +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -39% +investigations -34% +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -32% +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -4% -4% +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -4% +and quizzes -4% +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -4% +for a problem -13% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -3% +Page 13 of 14 -10% + LEARNING STRAND -48% +11.0 Production -36% +ENDURING UNDERSTANDING(S) -4% +ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +• There are numerous expenses involved in -10 +providing goods and services. -[Rotate Q57 and Q58] +• Why is quality control important? +• How does overhead affect the cost of an -57. Which of the following comes closest to your view? +• You must sale a certain number of goods -The U.S. should be more of an ally to Israel. ........................... 11% -The U.S. should maintain -our current relationship with Israel. ......................................... 17% -The U.S. should be less of an ally to Israel. ............................. 14% -The U.S. should not be an ally to Israel. .................................. 15% -Don’t know. .............................................................................. 41% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +item? -58. Which of the following comes closest to your view? +before making a profit. -The U.S. should be more of an ally to Palestine. ..................... 21% -The U.S. should maintain -our current relationship with Palestine. .................................... 15% -The U.S. should be less of an ally to Palestine. ......................... 5% -The U.S. should not be an ally to Palestine. ............................. 11% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +• Simple algebraic procedures can predict the -59. +break-even point. -Do you support or oppose a permanent ceasefire in Gaza? +LEARNING OBJECTIVES The student will : +11.1 Calculate prime cost and total +manufacturing costs +11.2 Identify various overhead costs +11.3 Classify expenses as raw material, labor, +or overhead +11.4 Calculate the break-even point in +production units and in sales production +11.5 Determine the number of manufactured +items to be tested for quality control +11.6 Predict the number of defective items on +an assembly line -Net: Support ........................................................................... 51% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 10% +INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT MATERIALS -Strongly support ....................................................................... 38% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 13% -Somewhat oppose ....................................................................... 5% -Strongly oppose .......................................................................... 5% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 36% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +• Excel +• Overhead transparency +• Internet -60. +SUGGESTED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES -Based on what you know at this time, do you believe Israel’s response so far to the October 7 -attack by Hamas has been justified, or not? +• Spreadsheet +• Journal writing +• Modeling +• Think aloud +• Student inquiry through guided -Yes, it is justified ...................................................................... 21% -No, it is not justified ................................................................. 32% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +investigations - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +• Teacher directed class discussions +• Graphic organizers +• Cooperative learning -11 +SUGGESTED ASSESSMENTS -Do you support or oppose: +• Homework +• Projects +• Tests & Quizzes +• Open-ended questions included on tests -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Support”] +and quizzes -61. +• Performance Tasks +• Teacher observations +• Written explanation of strategy and solution -Sending American troops to defend a NATO ally if invaded by Russia? +for a problem -Net: Support ........................................................................... 47% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 23% +• Oral presentation of solution strategies -Strongly support ....................................................................... 20% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 27% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 12% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 11% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 4% - -62. - -Building a wall on the border of the United States and Mexico? - -Net: Support ........................................................................... 36% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 45% - -Strongly support ....................................................................... 23% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 14% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 15% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 30% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -63. - -Sending American troops to defend Taiwan if invaded by China? . - -Net: Support ........................................................................... 34% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 30% - -Strongly support ....................................................................... 11% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 22% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 16% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 14% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 33% -Refused ....................................................................................... 4% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -12 - -64. - -On which of the following, if any, do you regularly access for news and current events related -content? Please select all that apply. - -[Randomize responses 1-13. Rank-ordered] - -YouTube ................................................................................... 25% -Instagram .................................................................................. 25% -TikTok ...................................................................................... 23% -Local TV news ......................................................................... 22% -Facebook .................................................................................. 19% -X ............................................................................................... 16% -CNN ......................................................................................... 14% -Fox News ................................................................................. 12% -Podcasts .................................................................................... 10% -Snapchat ..................................................................................... 8% -MSNBC ...................................................................................... 7% -Barstool ...................................................................................... 2% -Truth Social ................................................................................ 1% -None of the above .................................................................... 26% - -65. - -At this moment, would you say that you are more hopeful or fearful about the future of -America? - -[Randomize responses 1-2. Rank-ordered] - -Fearful ...................................................................................... 67% -Hopeful ..................................................................................... 30% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -Have you participated in any of the following activities in the past 12 months? - -66. - -67. - -Attended a political rally or demonstration - -Donated money to a political campaign or cause - -Yes - -14% - -13% - -No - -82% - -84% - -Refused - -4% - -3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -13 - -Switching gears, below is a list of individuals, organizations and institutions. How often do you trust -each of them to do the right thing? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: All/Most of the time”] - -Net: -All/ Most -of the time - -Net: -Some of the -time/ Never - -All of -the time - -Most -of the -time - -Some -of the -time Never Refused - -68. - -69. - -70. - -71. -72. - -The United -States military -The United -Nations -The Supreme -Court -The President -The federal -government - -73. - -The Congress - -74. -The media -75. Wall Street -76. -Billionaires - -36% - -32% - -24% -20% - -17% - -12% - -10% - -9% - -6% - -60% - -64% - -72% -76% - -79% - -83% - -86% - -86% - -90% - -10% - -26% - -41% - -19% - -4% - -4% -4% - -2% - -2% - -1% - -2% - -2% - -27% - -44% - -20% - -20% -16% - -15% - -10% - -9% - -8% - -4% - -47% -51% - -53% - -56% - -48% - -38% - -37% - -25% -25% - -27% - -27% - -38% - -48% - -53% - -4% - -5% - -4% -4% - -4% - -5% - -4% - -5% - -4% - -Below is a list of statements about politics and public service. Do you agree or disagree with these -statements? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] - -77. - -Community service is an honorable thing to do. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 75% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 6% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 45% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 30% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 17% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 3% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -78. - -Elected officials seem to be motivated by selfish reasons. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 75% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 5% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 40% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 36% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 18% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 2% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -14 - -79. - -I feel like the government does not represent the America I love. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 62% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 7% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 30% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 32% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 28% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 5% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -80. - -Politics has become too partisan. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 61% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 5% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 37% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 24% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 3% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -81. - -Politics today are no longer able to meet the challenges our country is facing. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 60% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 11% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 25% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 35% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 26% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 7% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -82. - -Despite our challenges, I would rather live in America than any other place. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 57% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 31% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -15 - -83. - -I feel like I need more practical information about politics before I get involved. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 53% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 21% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 32% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 28% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -84. - -People like me don’t have any say about what the government does. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 46% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 24% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 18% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 29% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 16% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -85. - -I don’t believe my vote will make a real difference. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 41% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 14% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 19% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -[If respondent is currently enrolled in a 4-year college or university, ask Q86] - -86. - -I feel comfortable sharing my political opinions at my college without fear of censorship or -negative repercussions. (n=267) - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 41% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 15% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 26% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -16 - -87. - -Running for office is an honorable thing to do. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 35% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 20% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 42% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -88. - -I worry that posting my political views may negatively impact my employment prospects. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 35% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 29% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 13% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 22% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 33% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -89. - -Political involvement rarely has any tangible results. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 30% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 27% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 40% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 19% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -90. - -The idea of working in some form of public service is appealing to me. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 28% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 39% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 20% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -17 - -91. - -The results of my previous involvement in politics have left me disappointed. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 26% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 19% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 18% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 52% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -92. - -Politics is not relevant to my life. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 46% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 25% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -93. - -I do not see a difference between the Democratic and Republican parties. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 21% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 56% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 14% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 23% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 34% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -94. - -The president should have more power to get things done, without interference from Congress -or the Courts. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 20% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 47% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 14% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 30% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 23% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -18 - -95. - -It really doesn’t matter to me who the President is. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 13% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 66% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 3% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 9% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 19% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 24% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 41% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -Over the last two weeks, how often have you been bothered by the following problems? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: At Least Several Days”] - -96. - -Feeling nervous, anxious or on edge - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 54% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 43% -Several days ............................................................................. 32% -More than half the days ............................................................ 13% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -97. - -Trouble relaxing - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 50% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 47% -Several days ............................................................................. 32% -More than half the days ............................................................ 12% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -98. - -Feeling down, depressed, or hopeless - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 44% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 53% -Several days ............................................................................. 29% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -19 - -99. - -Little interest or pleasure in doing things - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 40% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 57% -Several days ............................................................................. 26% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -100. - -Loneliness - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 40% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 57% -Several days ............................................................................. 24% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -101. - -Feeling afraid as if something awful might happen - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 38% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 59% -Several days ............................................................................. 23% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -102. Worried about a potential mass shooting when in a public space (such as school/university, - -mall, office, theater, etc.) - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 32% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 64% -Several days ............................................................................. 22% -More than half the days .............................................................. 7% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -103. - -Thoughts that you would be better off dead, or thoughts of hurting yourself in some way - -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 17% - -Not at all ................................................................................... 79% -Several days ............................................................................. 10% -More than half the days .............................................................. 4% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -20 - -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] - -104. - -I am concerned about the moral direction of the country. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 69% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 9% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 35% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 34% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 5% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -105. Basic health insurance is a right for all people, and if someone has no means of paying for it, - -the government should provide it. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 64% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 14% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 41% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -106. Basic necessities, such as food and shelter, are a right that government should provide to those - -unable to afford them. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 61% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 15% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 33% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 9% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -107. - -The government should spend more to reduce poverty. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 57% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 28% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 29% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -21 - -108. Government should do more to curb climate change, even at the expense of economic growth. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 49% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 23% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 25% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 24% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -109. - -People these days put too much emphasis on racial identity. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 49% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 22% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 26% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -110. - -If parents had more freedom to choose where they could send their children to school, the -education system in this country would be better. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 42% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 25% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 15% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -111. Our country’s goal in trade policy should be to eliminate all barriers to trade and employment - -so that we have a truly global economy. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 31% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 19% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 48% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -22 - -112. Recent immigration into this country has done more good than harm. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 29% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 36% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 12% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 33% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 17% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 19% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -113. Government spending is an effective way to increase economic growth. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 28% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 25% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 21% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 44% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 10% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -114. Qualified minorities should be given special preferences in hiring and education. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 38% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 17% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 35% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -115. Religious values should play a more important role in government. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 51% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 12% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 12% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 23% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 40% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -23 - -116. - -Same sex relationships are morally wrong. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 51% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 17% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 7% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 7% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -117. - -In today’s world, it is sometimes necessary to attack potentially hostile countries or groups, -rather than waiting until we are attacked to respond. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 20% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 39% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 5% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 40% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 21% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 18% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -Please indicate whether or not the following apply to you: - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Yes”] - -118. - -119. - -120. - -121. - -I have or have had immigrant -classmates -I have personal friends who are -immigrants -I have co-workers who are immigrants - -I have neighbors who are immigrants - -Yes - -60% - -46% -41% - -40% - -No - -Don’t -know - -Refused - -19% - -19% - -37% -34% - -31% - -15% -23% - -28% - -2% - -2% -2% - -2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -24 - -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] - -122. Border officials have a responsibility to protect the safety of migrants. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 55% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 27% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -123. - -The US is experiencing an immigration crisis at the Southern border. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 53% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 30% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 29% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -124. - -Immigrants improve the culture of the United States. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 50% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 24% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 25% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -125. - -Immigrants are taking jobs that should go to Americans instead. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 48% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 11% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 13% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 20% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -25 - -126. - -Immigrants increase crime in my community. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 21% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 45% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 12% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 32% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -127. - -I would be uncomfortable if an immigrant moved next door to me. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 12% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 62% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 6% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] - -128. - -I am comfortable using someone’s preferred gender pronouns regardless of their biological -sex. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 47% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 29% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 31% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 21% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 18% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -129. My generation is too soft. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 43% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 21% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 22% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -26 - -130. Men are too soft these days. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 32% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 41% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 14% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 19% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -131. Women are too promiscuous these days. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 45% - -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 10% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 33% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -132. Men’s 'locker room talk' is unfairly scrutinized these days. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 22% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 38% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 37% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -133. Women’s emotions make it more challenging to lead effectively. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 16% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 57% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 10% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -27 - -134. Women should prioritize having children over joining the workforce. - -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 12% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 59% - -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 5% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 7% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -135. How would you rate your personal financial situation these days? - -Net: Good ................................................................................ 70% -Net: Bad ................................................................................... 27% - -Very good ................................................................................. 13% -Fairly good ............................................................................... 58% -Fairly bad ................................................................................. 22% -Very bad ..................................................................................... 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -136. - -In general, when I am my parent's age, I believe that I will be… - -Better off financially than they are now ................................... 31% -About the same as they are now ............................................... 28% -Worse off financially than they are now .................................. 23% -Not sure .................................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -137. What type of high school did you most recently attend? - -Public ........................................................................................ 74% -Private ........................................................................................ 9% -Parochial ..................................................................................... 1% -Charter ........................................................................................ 4% -Home school ............................................................................... 6% -Other ........................................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q138] - -138. Based on the current state of the economy, how easy or difficult do you think it will be for - -students in your class to find a permanent job upon graduation? (n=267) - -Net: Easy ................................................................................. 38% -Net: Difficult ........................................................................... 58% - -Very easy .................................................................................. 10% -Somewhat easy ......................................................................... 38% -Somewhat difficult ................................................................... 44% -Very difficult .............................................................................. 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -28 - -139. Which one of these best describes your religious preference? - -Catholic .................................................................................... 19% -Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian ..................................... 15% -Jewish ......................................................................................... 2% -LDS/Mormon ............................................................................. 2% -Muslim ....................................................................................... 1% -Protestant .................................................................................... 8% -Another religion ......................................................................... 8% -No religious preference ............................................................ 33% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 4% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -[If Catholic, Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian, LDS/Mormon, Protestant, Jewish, Muslim, -another religion, or not sure, ask Q140] - -140. How important is religion in your own life? (n=1,106) - -Very important ......................................................................... 41% -Somewhat important ................................................................ 29% -Not very important ................................................................... 26% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% - -[If Catholic, Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian, LDS/Mormon, Protestant, another religion, -or not sure, ask Q141] - -141. Do you consider yourself a born-again Christian? (n=1,038) - -Yes ............................................................................................ 30% -No ............................................................................................. 50% -Not sure .................................................................................... 15% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -142. Which of the following do you consider yourself to be? - -Heterosexual or straight ........................................................... 73% -Gay ............................................................................................. 3% -Lesbian ....................................................................................... 2% -Bisexual ...................................................................................... 9% -Other Queer identity (e.g. pansexual, asexual etc.) .................... 5% -None of the above ...................................................................... 1% -I don’t know ............................................................................... 2% -Prefer not to say ......................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -143. Do you consider yourself to be transgender or non-binary? - -Yes .............................................................................................. 4% -No ............................................................................................. 92% -Prefer not to say ......................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -29 - -[If transgender or non-binary, ask Q144] - -144. Are you: (n=79) - -Transgender, male to female ...................................................... 6% -Transgender, female to male .................................................... 13% -Gender non-binary ................................................................... 57% -No, not transgender or non-binary ............................................. 9% -Prefer not to say ....................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% - -145. Are you: - -An immigrant ............................................................................. 6% -The child of an immigrant ........................................................ 16% -None of the above .................................................................... 77% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -146. - -Switching topics, which of these best describes your phone service at this time? Please select -all that apply. - -Cell phone ................................................................................ 93% -Landline phone service .............................................................. 7% -VOIP phone service ................................................................... 2% -None of these .............................................................................. 4% - -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q147 & Q148] - -147. - -Is your college/university…? (n=267) - -Public ........................................................................................ 69% -Private ...................................................................................... 30% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -148. - -Is the college/university that you currently attend…? (n=267) - -In an urban or city area ............................................................. 50% -In a suburban area next to a city ............................................... 27% -In a small town or rural area .................................................... 20% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -149. Which of the following best describes the area in which you live (if in college, when not in - -school)? - -Suburban .................................................................................. 43% -Urban ........................................................................................ 24% -Rural ......................................................................................... 15% -Small town ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -30 - -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q150 – Q153] - -150. Which college/university do you attend? (n=267) - -Available upon request - -151. How many undergraduate students are enrolled in your college/university? Your best estimate - -is fine. (n=267) - -Less than 1,000 ........................................................................... 2% -1,000 - 4,999 ............................................................................ 26% -5,000 – 9,999 ............................................................................ 22% -10,000 – 19,999 ........................................................................ 18% -20,000 or more ......................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -152. Where do you live while attending college? (n=267) - -In an on-campus dormitory ...................................................... 33% -At home, with my parents ........................................................ 32% -In an apartment/house that is not campus-owned -(not with parents) ..................................................................... 25% -In a campus-owned apartment ................................................... 3% -Somewhere else .......................................................................... 3% -In fraternity/sorority housing ..................................................... 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -153. Are you a …? (n=267) - -Full-time student ...................................................................... 88% -Part-time student ...................................................................... 11% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -154. Which of the following best describes your current employment status? (n=1,008) - -Employed full time ................................................................... 42% -Student ...................................................................................... 21% -Employed part time .................................................................. 18% -Not employed ........................................................................... 10% -Self-employed ............................................................................ 3% -Not employed / Homemaker ...................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -[If employed full time or part time, ask Q155] - -155. Are you currently employed in the gig economy -- where people earn income providing on- - -demand work, services or goods? (n=633) - -Yes ............................................................................................ 12% -No ............................................................................................. 87% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -31 - -156. Age - -18-24 ........................................................................................ 58% -25-29 ........................................................................................ 42% - -157. Race / Ethnicity - -White, Non-Hispanic ................................................................ 52% -Hispanic .................................................................................... 24% -Black, Non-Hispanic ................................................................ 14% -Other, Non-Hispanic .................................................................. 7% -2+ Races, Non-Hispanic ............................................................. 3% - -158. - -Please choose one or more race(s) that you consider yourself to be: - -White ........................................................................................ 70% -Black or African American ...................................................... 15% -Asian .......................................................................................... 7% -Some other race .......................................................................... 6% -American Indian or Alaska Native ............................................. *% - -159. Gender - -Male .......................................................................................... 50% -Female ...................................................................................... 50% -Non-binary ................................................................................. 0% - -160. Marital Status - -Never married ........................................................................... 84% -Now married ............................................................................. 14% -Divorced ..................................................................................... 1% -Separated .................................................................................... 1% -Widowed .................................................................................... 0% - -161. Region 4 (Based on state of residence) - -Northeast .................................................................................. 17% -Midwest .................................................................................... 20% -South ........................................................................................ 38% -West .......................................................................................... 25% - -162. Region 9 (Based on state of residence) - -New England .............................................................................. 4% -Mid-Atlantic ............................................................................. 13% -East-North Central ................................................................... 14% -West-North Central .................................................................... 6% -South Atlantic ........................................................................... 19% -East-South Central ..................................................................... 5% -West-South Central .................................................................. 14% -Mountain .................................................................................... 8% -Pacific ....................................................................................... 17% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -32 - -163. MSA Status - -Non-Metro ................................................................................ 12% -Metro ........................................................................................ 88% - -Methodology - -This poll of 2,010 18-to-29-year-olds was organized with undergraduate students from the Harvard -Public Opinion Project (HPOP) and supervised by John Della Volpe, Director of Polling. Data were -collected by Ipsos Public Affairs using the KnowledgePanel. KnowledgePanel provides probability- -based samples with an “organic” representation of the study population for measurement of public -opinions, attitudes, and behaviors. Interviews were conducted in English and Spanish between March -14 and 21, 2024. The target population for this survey is US residents between the ages of 18 and 29. -Data are weighted to reflect population estimates based on age, race/Hispanic ethnicity, education, -household income, census region by metropolitan area, and primary language within Hispanics. The -margin of error for the total sample is +/- 3.02%. - -### +Page 14 of 14 diff --git a/q253/random_k4/random_4.md b/q253/random_k4/random_4.md index 4bcaaffd0140b439e3111b15be90b5099749743d..2980202789b7c5c38c33a0fc838c15d016b799f4 100644 --- a/q253/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q253/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,3187 +1,465 @@ -School Meals Programs and Other USDA -Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated August 24, 2018 - -Congressional Research Service - -https://crsreports.congress.gov - -R43783 - -{222A0E69-13A2-4985-84AE-73CC3DFF4D02}-R-008032105221177189069140163240174026137243109106239050005249089181035110184065171150222238050143170044130075151022235203179242176047216087082047088140020229001139009183064080176154202161058046029022041045101112067071229147068138195245121093 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summary -The “child nutrition programs” refer to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition -Service (USDA-FNS) programs that provide food for children in school or institutional settings. -The best known programs, which serve the largest number of children, are the school meals -programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). -The child nutrition programs also include the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), -which provides meals and snacks in day care and after school settings; the Summer Food Service -Program (SFSP), which provides food during the summer months; the Special Milk Program -(SMP), which supports milk for schools that do not participate in NSLP or SBP; and the Fresh -Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP), which funds fruit and vegetable snacks in select elementary -schools. - -Funding: The vast majority of the child nutrition programs account is considered mandatory -spending, with trace amounts of discretionary funding for certain related activities. Referred to as -open-ended, “appropriated entitlements,” funding is provided through the annual appropriations -process; however, the level of spending is controlled by benefit and eligibility criteria in federal -law and dependent on the resulting levels of participation. Federal cash funding (in the form of -per-meal reimbursements) and USDA commodity food support is guaranteed to schools and other -providers based on the number of meals or snacks served and participant category (e.g., free -meals for poor children get higher subsidies). - -Participation: The child nutrition programs serve children of varying ages and in different -institutional settings. The NSLP and SBP have the broadest reach, serving qualifying children of -all ages in school settings. Other child nutrition programs serve more-narrow populations. -CACFP, for example, provides meals and snacks to children in early childhood and after-school -settings among other venues. Programs generally provide some subsidy for all food served but a -larger federal reimbursement for food served to children from low-income households. - -Administration: Responsibility for child nutrition programs is divided between the federal -government, states, and localities. The state agency and type of local provider differs by program. -In the NSLP and SBP, schools and school districts (“school food authorities”) administer the -program. Meanwhile, SFSP (and sometimes CACFP) uses a model in which sponsor -organizations handle administrative responsibilities for a number of sites that serve meals. - -Reauthorization: The underlying laws covering the child nutrition programs were last -reauthorized in the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296, enacted -December 13, 2010). This law made significant changes to child nutrition programs, including -increasing federal financing for school lunches, expanding access to community eligibility and -direct certification options for schools, and expanding eligibility options for home child care -providers. The law also required an update to school meal nutrition guidelines as well as new -guidelines for food served outside the meal programs (e.g., snacks sold in vending machines and -cafeteria a la carte lines). - -Current Issues: The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition -reauthorization (see CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An -Overview). As of the date of this report, there has been no significant legislative activity with -regard to reauthorization in the 115th Congress. However, the vast majority of operations and -activities continue with funding provided by appropriations laws. Current issues in the child -nutrition programs for policymakers include the implementation of new and updated nutrition -standards, alternatives to the “congregate feeding” requirement in the SFSP, and schools’ efforts -to collect unpaid school meal fees (stigmatizing practices are sometimes called “lunch shaming”). - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Contents - -Introduction and Background .......................................................................................................... 1 -Authorization and Reauthorization ........................................................................................... 2 -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local .................................................................. 3 -Funding Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3 -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding ............................................................... 3 -Other Federal Funding ........................................................................................................ 5 -State, Local, and Participant Funds ..................................................................................... 5 -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ....................................................................................... 5 -Links to Resources .................................................................................................................... 7 -School Meals Programs ................................................................................................................... 7 -General Characteristics ............................................................................................................. 7 -School Meals Eligibility Rules .................................................................................................. 9 -Income Eligibility ............................................................................................................. 10 -Categorical Eligibility ........................................................................................................ 11 -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) ........................................................................... 13 -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) ................................................................................ 15 -School Breakfast Program (SBP) ............................................................................................ 16 -Other Child Nutrition Programs .................................................................................................... 17 -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) ...................................................................... 17 -CACFP at Centers ............................................................................................................. 18 -CACFP for Day Care Homes ............................................................................................ 19 -Summer Meals ........................................................................................................................ 20 -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP)............................................................................ 21 -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option ......................................................................... 22 -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration ....................................................................... 22 -Special Milk Program (SMP) .................................................................................................. 23 -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) ............................................................................ 23 -Other Topics .................................................................................................................................. 24 -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options ....................................................... 24 -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities ............................................................ 26 -Selected Current Issues ................................................................................................................. 28 -Regulations on Nutrition Standards ........................................................................................ 28 -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast ..................................................... 28 -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools .................................................. 30 -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP ......................................................................... 31 -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals ....................................................... 31 -Current Law and Policy .................................................................................................... 32 -Congressional Proposals ................................................................................................... 33 -Presidential Budget Proposals ........................................................................................... 34 -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” ......................................................................... 34 - -Figures - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs ............................... 9 -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals ........................... 13 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation ............................................... 15 -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation ......................................................... 17 - -Tables - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ............................................................................... 5 -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP .......................... 11 -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs ...................... 25 - -Table A-1. Acronyms ..................................................................................................................... 37 -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches ....................................................................... 38 -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks .................................................... 38 -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP ......................................................................................... 39 -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) ....................................... 39 -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School - -Programs .................................................................................................................................... 39 -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes .................................................... 39 -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP ....................................................................................... 40 -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP ........................................................................................ 40 - -Appendixes - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report ................................................................................ 37 -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement Rates for Child Nutrition Programs ........... 38 - -Contacts - -Author Information ........................................................................................................................ 41 -Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 41 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Introduction and Background -The federal child nutrition programs provide assistance to schools and other institutions in the -form of cash, commodity food, and administrative support (such as technical assistance and -administrative funding) based on the provision of meals and snacks to children.1 In general, these -programs were created (and amended over time) to both improve children’s nutrition and provide -support to the agriculture economy. - -Today, the child nutrition programs refer primarily to the following meal, snack, and milk -reimbursement programs (these and other acronyms are listed in Appendix A):2 - - National School Lunch Program (NSLP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1751 et seq.)); - - School Breakfast Program (SBP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 4 (42 U.S.C. - -1773)); - - Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) (Richard B. Russell National - -School Lunch Act, Section 17 (42 U.S.C. 1766)); - - Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act, Section 13 (42 U.S.C. 1761)); and - - Special Milk Program (SMP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 3 (42 U.S.C. - -1772)). - -The programs provide financial support and/or foods to the institutions that prepare meals and -snacks served outside of the home (unlike other food assistance programs such as the -Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program [SNAP, formerly the Food Stamp Program] where -benefits are used to purchase food for home consumption). Though exact eligibility rules and -pricing vary by program, in general the amount of federal reimbursement is greater for meals -served to qualifying low-income individuals or at qualifying institutions, although most programs -provide some subsidy for all food served. Participating children receive subsidized meals and -snacks, which may be free or at reduced price. Forthcoming sections discuss how program- -specific eligibility rules and funding operate. - -This report describes how each program operates under current law, focusing on eligibility rules, -participation, and funding. This introductory section describes some of the background and -principles that generally apply to all of the programs; subsequent sections go into further detail on -the workings of each. - -Unless stated otherwise, participation and funding data come from USDA-FNS’s “Keydata -Reports.”3 - -1 As discussed later in the report, the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) also supports food in adult day -care facilities, but the child nutrition programs overwhelmingly serve children. -2 Some lists also include the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) (Richard B. Russell National School Lunch -Act, Section 19 (42 U.S.C. 1769a)), a newer program that is financed in a much different way than the programs listed. -FFVP is discussed further later in the report (“Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program”). WIC (the Special Supplemental -Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. -WIC is not one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report. -3 This CRS report uses the May 2018 report, which contains data through March 2018. Keydata Reports available at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Fiscal Year Ended March 2020 +Financial Results Explanatory Material +Nintendo Co., Ltd. +May 7, 2020 1 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Authorization and Reauthorization - -The child nutrition programs are most often dated back to the 1946 enactment of the National -School Lunch Act, which created the National School Lunch Program, albeit in a different form -than it operates today.4 Most of the child nutrition programs do not date back to 1946; they were -added and amended in the decades to follow as policymakers expanded child nutrition programs’ -institutional settings and meals provided: - - The Special Milk Program was created in 1954, regularly extended, and made - -permanent in 1970.5 - - The School Breakfast Program was piloted in 1966, regularly extended, and - -eventually made permanent in 1975.6 - - A program for child care settings and summer programs was piloted in 1968, - -with separate programs authorized in 1975 and then made permanent in 1978.7 -These are now the Child and Adult Care Food Program8 and Summer Food -Service Program. - - The Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program began as a pilot in 2002 and was made - -permanent in 2008.9 - -The programs are now authorized under three major federal statutes: the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (originally enacted as the National School Lunch Act in 1946), the -Child Nutrition Act (originally enacted in 1966), and Section 32 of the act of August 24, 1935 (7 -U.S.C. 612c).10 Congressional jurisdiction over the underlying three laws has typically been -exercised by the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee; the House Education and -the Workforce Committee; and, to a limited extent (relating to commodity food assistance and -Section 32 issues), the House Agriculture Committee. - -Congress periodically reviews and reauthorizes expiring authorities under these laws. The child -nutrition programs were most recently reauthorized in 2010 through the Healthy, Hunger-Free -Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296); some of the authorities created or extended in that law -expired on September 30, 2015.11 WIC (the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, - -4 P.L. 79-396. There were, however, a number of smaller, more temporary precursor school food programs prior to -1946; see Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. The 1946 law supported school lunch programs by giving formula grant funding -to states based on factors such as per capita income, rather than the current-day open-ended entitlements based largely -on eligibility and participation rules. -5 P.L. 83-690 and P.L. 91-295. Milk purchases and donations for schools did exist prior to the 1954 law. -6 Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. -7 P.L. 90-302, P.L. 94-105, P.L. 95-627. Institute of Medicine, Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary -Guidance for All, 2011, p. 30, https://www.nap.edu/catalog/12959/child-and-adult-care-food-program-aligning-dietary- -guidance-for. -8 Adult day care was added in 1987 (Older Americans Act Amendments of 1987; P.L. 100-175). -9 P.L. 107-171 and P.L. 110-246. -10 In 1999, P.L. 106-78 renamed the National School Lunch Act in Senator Richard B. Russell’s honor. -11 Reimbursements for NSLP, SBP, CACFP, SMP, and certain related USDA activities are permanently authorized. -SFSP, WIC, and WIC Farmers Market Nutrition Program, State Administrative Expenses (discussed in “Related -Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities”), and certain related USDA activities have a September 30, 2015 -expiration. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Information About Risks Related to COVID-19 +• +Impact on parts procurement, production, and shipments +• +Impact on consumption activities +• +Impact on research and development +• +Impact of foreign exchange fluctuations 2 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. WIC is not -one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report.12 - -The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition reauthorization (see CRS -Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview). As of the date -of this report, the committees of jurisdiction have not conducted reauthorization hearings or -markups in the 115th Congress. - -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local - -The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition Service (USDA-FNS) administers the -programs at the federal level. The programs are operated by a wide variety of local public and -private providers and the degree of direct state involvement differs by program and state.13 At the -state level, education, health, social services, and agriculture departments all have roles; at a -minimum, they are responsible for approving and overseeing local providers such as schools, -summer program sponsors, and child care centers and day care homes, as well as making sure -they receive the federal support they are due. At the local level, program benefits are provided to -millions of children (e.g., there were 30.0 million in the National School Lunch Program, the -largest of the programs, in FY2017), through some 100,000 public and private schools and -residential child care institutions, nearly 170,000 child care centers and family day care homes, -and just over 50,000 summer program sites. - -All programs are available in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Virtually all operate in -Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands (and, in differing versions, in the Northern Marianas -and American Samoa).14 - -Funding Overview - -This section summarizes the nature and extent to which the programs’ funding is mandatory and -discretionary, including a discussion of appropriated entitlement status. Table 3 lists child -nutrition program and related expenditures. - -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding - -Most spending for child nutrition programs is provided in annual appropriations acts to fulfill the -legal financial obligation established by the authorizing laws. That is, the level of spending for -such programs, referred to as appropriated mandatory spending, is not controlled through the -annual appropriations process, but instead is derived from the benefit and eligibility criteria -specified in the authorizing laws. The appropriated mandatory funding is treated as mandatory -spending. Further, if Congress does not appropriate the funds necessary to fund the program, -eligible entities may have legal recourse.15 Congress considers the Administration’s forecast for - -12 See CRS Report R44115, A Primer on WIC: The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and -Children. -13 In the past, the federal government (via USDA-FNS) has, for certain states, taken the place of state agencies (e.g., -where a state has chosen not to operate a specific program or where there is a state prohibition on aiding private -schools). -14 For more information on child nutrition programs in the Northern Marianas and American Samoa, see U.S. -Department of the Interior, Office of Insular Affairs, Region IX Federal Regional Council, Outer Pacific Committee, -FY 2016 Report on Federal Financial Assistance to the U.S. Pacific and Caribbean Islands, May 1, 2017, p. 10, -https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/fy16-report-on-federal-financial-assistance-to-the-insular-areas.pdf. -15 GAO Budget Glossary, p. 13: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-05-734SP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +1. Consolidated Financial Results and Outlook 3 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -program needs in its appropriations decisions. For the majority of funding discussed in this report, -the formula that controls the funding is not capped and fluctuates based on the reimbursement -rates and the number of meals/snacks served in the programs. - -Cash Reimbursements and Commodity Foods - -In the meal service programs, such as the National School Lunch Program, School Breakfast -Program, summer programs, and assistance for child care centers and day care homes, federal aid -is provided in the form of statutorily set subsidies (reimbursements) paid for each meal/snack -served that meets federal nutrition guidelines. Although all (including full-price) meals/snacks -served by participating providers are subsidized, those served free or at a reduced price to lower- -income children are supported at higher rates. All federal meal/snack subsidy rates are indexed -annually (each July) for inflation, as are the income eligibility thresholds for free and reduced- -price meals/snacks.18 Subsequent sections discuss how a specific program’s eligibility and -reimbursements work. - -Most subsidies are cash payments to -schools or other providers, but a smaller -portion of aid is provided in the form of -USDA-purchased commodity foods.19 -Laws for three child nutrition programs -(NSLP, CACFP, and SFSP) require the -provision of commodity foods (or in -some cases allow cash in lieu of -commodity foods).20 - -Meal and snack service entails non-food -costs. Federal child nutrition per- -meal/snack subsidies may be used to -cover local providers’ administrative -and operating costs. However, the -separate direct federal payments for -administrative/operating costs (“State - -Reimbursable Meals - -A “reimbursable meal” (or snack in the case of some -programs) is a phrase used by USDA, state, and other child -nutrition policy and program operators to indicate a meal (or -snack) that meets federal requirements and thereby qualifies -for meal reimbursement.16 -In general, a meal or snack that is reimbursable means that it is - - - - - -served to the correctly eligible person and/or at the -eligible institution, and - -in compliance with federal nutrition requirements for the -meal or snack.17 - -In the school meals programs (with some variation in other -programs), the highest reimbursement is paid for meals served -free to eligible children, a slightly lower reimbursement is paid -for meals served at a reduced price to eligible children, and a -much smaller reimbursement is also paid for meals served to -children who are either ineligible for assistance or not -certified. For this last group, the children pay the full price as -advertised but meals are still technically subsidized. - -16 See, for example, definition of “reimbursement” at 7 C.F.R. 210.2. -17 The authorizing statutes for all four of the main child nutrition programs include nutritional requirements for the -meals and snacks served; these are sometimes referred to as “nutrition standards,” “nutrition guidelines,” or “meal -patterns.” In most respects, the details of the requirements are specified in USDA-FNS regulations. The nutrition -guidelines differ by program, largely in consideration of the age groups fed, meals/snacks authorized, and perhaps the -settings in which meals are served. See program regulations for nutritional requirements: NSLP, 7 C.F.R. 210.10; SBP, -7 C.F.R. 220.8; CACFP, 7 C.F.R. 226.20; SFSP, 7 C.F.R. 225.16. Recent updates of school meals and CACFP -nutrition standards are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” -18 Per-meal subsidies paid to providers (e.g., schools, child care centers) are indexed annually based on the CPI-U Food -Away from Home Component. For family child care homes, the annual indexing is based on the CPI-U Food at Home -Component. -19 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information, see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -20 See USDA-FNS Food Distribution Division resources for more information on USDA Foods and child nutrition - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Consolidated Financial Highlights +| | | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| Net sales | | | 1,200.5 | | 1,308.5 | | +9.0 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Operating | profit | | 249.7 | | 352.3 | | +41.1 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Operating | profit | ratio | 20.8 | | 26.9 | | +6.1 | | +| | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +| Ordinary | profit | | 277.3 | | 360.4 | | +30.0 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Net profit | | | 194.0 | | 258.6 | | +33.3 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Net profit | ratio | | 16.2 | | 19.8 | | +3.6 | | +| | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +*Net profit: Profit attributable to owners of parent +*FY = Fiscal Year: FY20 indicates the period between April 1, 2019 and March 31, 2020. 4 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Administrative Expenses,” discussed in the “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities” section) are limited. - -Other Federal Funding - -In addition to the open-ended, appropriated entitlement funds summarized above, the child -nutrition programs’ funding also includes certain other mandatory funding21 and a limited amount -of discretionary funding. Some of the activities discussed in “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities,” such as Team Nutrition, are provided for with discretionary funding. - -Aside from the annually appropriated funding, the child nutrition programs are also supported by -certain permanent appropriations and transfers. Notably, funding for the Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable Program is funded by a transfer from USDA’s Section 32 program, a permanent -appropriation of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts. - -State, Local, and Participant Funds - -Federal subsidies do not necessarily cover the full cost of the meals and snacks offered by -providers. States and localities help cover program costs, as do children’s families by paying -charges for non-free or reduced-price meals/snacks. There is a non-federal cost-sharing -requirement for the school meals programs (discussed below), and some states supplement school -funding through additional state per-meal reimbursements or other prescribed financing -arrangements.22 - -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Subsequent sections of this report delve into the details of how each of the child nutrition -programs support the service of meals and snacks in institutional settings; first, it is useful to take -a broader perspective of primary program elements. Table 1 is a top-level look at the different -programs that displays distinguishing characteristics (what meals are provided, in what settings, -to what ages) and recent program spending. - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Program - -National School -Lunch Program - -Authorizing -Statute (Year -First -Authorized) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1946) - - - - - -Distinguishing -Characteristics - -FY2017 -Expenditures - -Lunches at school - -$13.6 billion - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -FY2017 -Average Daily -Participation - -Maximum -Daily -Snack/Mealsa - -30.0 million -children - - One meal and -snack per child - -programs, http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/schoolscn-usda-foods-programs. -21 These costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and Technical -Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. See p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional -Budget Justification, available at https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -22 The School Nutrition Association, a trade association representing school meal operators and industry, tracks state -policies and funding on the organization website at https://schoolnutrition.org/LegislationPolicy/ -StateLegislationPolicyReports/. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Consolidated Sales +| | | | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | | +| --------- | ------------------------- | ---- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | ----- | --- | +| Net sales | | | 1,200.5 | | 1,308.5 | | | | +9.0 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | | bn yen | | | % | +| Dedicated | video game platform*1 | | 1,152.6 | | 1,254.1 | | | | +8.8 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | | bn yen | | | % | +| Mobile, | IP related income, etc.*2 | | | 46.0 | | 51.2 | | | +11.5 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | | bn yen | | | % | +| Playing | cards, | etc. | | 1.9 | | 3.0 | | | +57.1 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | | bn yen | | | % | +*1 Each platform includes hardware, software (including downloadable +versions of packaged software, download-only software, add-on content, +FY20 Regional Sales Ratio +and Nintendo Switch Online) and accessories. +*2 Includes income from smart-device content and royalty income. +8.8% +| Effect of changes in foreign exchange rates | | | | | | | | Japan | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | +23.0% +| on net sales: -37.3 billion yen | | | | | 25.0% | | | The Americas | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | +Europe +| | | | | | | 43.2% | | Other | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | 5 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -School -Breakfast -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1966) - - - - - - - -Possible to -provide summer -food and -afterschool -snacks. - -Breakfasts at -school (also for -pre-K-12) - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (child -care centers, day -care homes, adult -day care centers) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - - Meals and snacks -in early childhood -and adult day -care settings - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (At- -Risk After-School -snacks and meals)b - -Summer Food -Service -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1994) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - -Special Milk -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1954) - -Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(2002) - - - - - -Rules and funding -differ based on -type of institution - -Supper and -snacks for -school-age -children after- -school - - Meals and snacks -provided during -summer months - - - - - - - - - - - -Sites vary and -include schools, -community -centers, camps, -parks, and others - -Eligibility rules -vary for “open” -and “closed” sites - -Subsidizes milk, -not meals or -snacks - -Institutions -eligible must not -participate in -NSLP or SBP - -Provides free -fresh fruit and -vegetable snacks -to elementary -school students - -$4.3 billion - -14.7 million -children - - Generally one -breakfast per -child, with -some flexibility - -$3.5 billion -(includes at- -risk after- -school -spending, -described -below) - -(Not available; -included in -CACFP total -above) - -$485 million - -4.4 million -children; -132,000 adults - - Two meals and -one snack, or -one meal and -two snacks per -participant - -1.7 million -children -(included in -CACFP -children above) - -2.7 million -childrenc - - One meal and -one snack per -child - -Lunch and -breakfast or -lunch and one -snack per child -Exception: -maximum of -three meals -for camps or -programs that -serve primarily -migrant -children - -$8 million - -191,000 half- -pints served -(average daily)d - - Not specified - -$184e million - - Not available - - Not applicable - -Source: Except where noted, participation and funding data from USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report, which -contains data through March 2018. Participation data are estimated by USDA-FNS based on meals served. -a. These maximums are provided in the authorizing law for CACFP and SFSP, but specified only in regulations - -(7 C.F.R. 210.10(a), 220.9(a)) for NSLP and SBP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Proportion of overseas sales: 77.0% + +Gross Profit +| | | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| ------------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| Gross | profit | | 501.1 | | 641.7 | | +28.0 | | +| | | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Gross profit ratio | | | 41.7 | | 49.0 | | +7.3 | | +| | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +Main Variable Factors +| | | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | +Proportion of hardware +| sales*1 | | | 58.4 | | 52.2 | | -6.2 | | +| ------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | +| | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +Proportion of first-party +| | | | 83.8 | | 82.8 | | -1.0 | | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | +| software sales*2 | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +Proportion of digital +| | | | 24.8 | | 34.0 | | +9.2 | | +| ------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | +| sales*2 | | | | % | | % | | pt. | +| Average | | 1 USD | 110.91 | yen | 108.74 | yen | -2.17 | yen | +| exchange rate | | 1 Euro | 128.41 | yen | 120.82 | yen | -7.59 | yen | +*1 Proportion of sales to total dedicated video game platform sales 6 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -b. At-risk after-school snacks and meals are part of CACFP law and CACFP funding, but differ in their rules - -and the age of children served. - -c. Based only on July 2017 participation data. -d. Data from p. 32-58 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -e. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. - -Links to Resources -Other relevant CRS reports in this area include23 - - CRS In Focus IF10266, An Introduction to Child Nutrition Reauthorization - CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs - CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296 - -(summarizes the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010) - - CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An - -Overview - - CRS Report R44588, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2017 Appropriations - CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 - -Program - -Other relevant resources include - - USDA-FNS’s website, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/child-nutrition- - -programs - - USDA-FNS’s Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act page, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ - -school-meals/healthy-hunger-free-kids-act - - The FNS page of the Federal Register, https://www.federalregister.gov/agencies/ - -food-and-nutrition-service - -School Meals Programs -This section discusses the school meals programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) -and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). Principles and concepts common to both programs are -discussed first; subsections then discuss features and data unique to the NSLP and SBP, -respectively. - -General Characteristics - -The federal school meals programs provide federal support in the form of cash assistance and -USDA commodity foods; both are provided according to statutory formulas based on the number -of reimbursable meals served in schools. The subsidized meals are served by both public and -private nonprofit elementary and secondary schools and residential child care institutions -(RCCIs)24 that opt to enroll and guarantee to offer free or reduced-price meals to eligible low- - -23 Archived historical reports that may provide useful background include CRS Report RL33829, Domestic Food -Assistance and the 2008 Farm Bill; and CRS Report RL33299, Child Nutrition and WIC Legislation in the 108th and -109th Congresses. -24 This CRS report refers to “schools,” but it should be understood that—for NSLP and SBP—it means both schools -and RCCIs. NSLP regulations, 7 C.F.R. 210.2, define RCCIs as follows: “The term ‘residential child care institutions’ - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +*2 Proportion of sales to total dedicated video game platform software sales + +Selling, General and Administrative Expenses / Operating Profit +| | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | +Selling, general and +| administrative expenses | | 251.4 | | 289.3 | | +15.0 | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------ | ----- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ----- | --- | +| | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| SG&A expenses-to-sales ratio | | 20.9 | | 22.1 | | +1.2 | | +| | | | % | | % | | pt. | +| Operating profit | | 249.7 | | 352.3 | | +41.1 | | +| | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Operating | profit ratio | 20.8 | % | 26.9 | % | +6.1 | pt. | +Effect of changes in foreign exchange rates on operating profit: approx. -20.0 billion yen +| | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | +Research and development +| expenses | | 69.6 | bn yen | 84.1 | bn yen | +20.9 | % | +| ----------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ----- | --- | +| Advertising | expenses | 75.4 | | 76.0 | | +0.8 | | +| | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | 7 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -income children. Both cash and commodity support to participating schools are calculated based -on the number and price of meals served (e.g., lunch or breakfast, free or full price), but once the -aid is received by the school it is used to support the overall school meal service budget, as -determined by the school. This report focuses on the federal reimbursements and funding, but it -should be noted that some states have provided state financing through additional state-specific -funding.25 - -Federal law does not require schools to participate in the school meals programs. However, some -states have mandated that schools provide lunch and/or breakfast, and some of these states require -that their schools do so through NSLP and/or SBP.26 The program is open to public and private -schools. - -A reimbursable meal requires compliance with federal school nutrition standards, which have -changed throughout the history of the program based on nutritional science and children’s -nutritional needs. Food items not served as a complete meal meeting nutrition standards (e.g., a la -carte offerings) are not reimbursable meals, and therefore are not eligible for federal per-meal, -per-snack reimbursements. Following rulemaking to implement P.L. 111-296 provisions, the -standards for reimbursable meals were updated in January 2012 and USDA also has provided -nutrition standards for the non-meal foods served in schools during the school day (see “Selected -Current Issues” for more on these policies). - -USDA-FNS administers the school meals programs federally, and state agencies (typically state -departments of education) oversee and transmit reimbursements through agreements with school -food authorities (SFAs) (typically local educational agencies (LEAs); usually these are school -districts). Figure 1 provides an overview of the roles and relationships between these levels of -government. - -There is a cost-sharing requirement for the programs, which amounts to a contribution of -approximately $200 million from the states.27 There also are states that choose to supplement -federal reimbursements with their own state reimbursements.28 - -includes, but is not limited to: homes for the mentally, emotionally or physically impaired, and unmarried mothers and -their infants; group homes; halfway houses; orphanages; temporary shelters for abused children and for runaway -children; long-term care facilities for chronically ill children; and juvenile detention centers. A long-term care facility is -a hospital, skilled nursing facility, intermediate care facility, or distinct part thereof, which is intended for the care of -children confined for 30 days or more.” -25 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. -26 Ibid. -27 Section 7(a)(1) of Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1756(a)(1). Section 7(f) of -Child Nutrition Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776(f). -28 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Ordinary Profit and Net Profit +| | | | | | | FY19 | | | FY20 | | | Comparison | | | | +| --- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | +| | Non-operating | | income | | | 28.3 | bn | yen | 25.5 | bn yen | | | -9.7 | % | | +| | included foreign exchange gains | | | | | | 5.4 | | | - | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | bn | yen | | | | | | | | +| | Non-operating expenses | | | | | | 0.6 bn yen | | 17.4 | bn yen | | +2,541.9 | | % | | +| | included foreign exchange losses | | | | | | - | | 15.8 | | | | | | | +bn yen +| Ordinary profit | | | | | | 277.3 | bn yen | | 360.4 | bn yen | | | +30.0 | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | +% +| Net | profit | | | | | 194.0 | | | 258.6 | | | | +33.3 | | | +| ---------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | bn | yen | | bn yen | | | | % | | +| Net profit ratio | | | | | | 16.2 | | | 19.8 | | | | +3.6 | | | +| | | | | | | | % | | | % | | | | pt. | | +*Net profit: Profit attributable to owners of parent +Exchange rate FY19 FY20 Comparison Dividends FY19 FY20 Comparison +| 1 USD | | 110.99 | | 108.83 | | -2.16 | | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +| | | | yen | | yen | | yen | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Annual | 810 | | 1,090 | | | +280 | | +| 1 Euro | | 124.56 | yen | 119.55 | yen | -5.01 | yen | | | yen | | yen | | | yen | 8 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs - -Source: Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 47. - -School Meals Eligibility Rules - -The school meals programs and related funding do not serve only low-income children. All -students can receive a meal at a NSLP- or SBP-participating school, but how much the child pays -for the meal and/or how much of a federal reimbursement the state receives will depend largely -on whether the child qualifies for a “free,” “reduced-price,” or “paid” (i.e., advertised price) meal. -Both NSLP and SBP use the same household income eligibility criteria and categorical eligibility -rules. States and schools receive the largest reimbursements for free meals, smaller -reimbursements for reduced-price meals, and the smallest (but still some federal financial -support) for the full-price meals. - -There are three pathways through which a child can become certified to receive a free or reduced- -price meal: - -1. Household income eligibility for free and reduced-price meals (information - -typically collected via household application), - -2. Categorical (or automatic) eligibility for free meals (information collected via - -household application or a direct certification process), and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - +Consolidated Financial Forecast +| | | FY20 | | FY21 | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| | | (Results) | | (Forecast) | | Comparison | | +| Net sales | | 1,308.5 | | 1,200.0 | | -8.3 | | +| | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Operating profit | | 352.3 | | 300.0 | | -14.9 | | +| | | | bn yen | | bn yen | | % | +| Ordinary profit | | 360.4 | bn yen | 290.0 | bn yen | -19.5 | % | +| Net profit | | 258.6 | bn yen | 200.0 | bn yen | -22.7 | % | +*Net profit: Profit attributable to owners of parent +*Estimated exchange rate for FY21: 1 USD = 105 yen, 1 Euro = 115 yen +| | | FY20 | | FY21 | | | | +| --------- | ------ | --------- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| Dividends | | | | | | Comparison | | +| | | (Results) | | (Forecast) | | | | +| Annual | | 1,090 | yen | 840 | yen | -250 | yen | +| | | FY20 | | FY21 | | | | +| Nintendo | Switch | | | | | Comparison | | +| | | (Results) | | (Forecast) | | | | +| | | | mil | | mil | | | +| Hardware | | 21.03 | | 19.00 | | -9.6 | | +| | | | units | | units | | % | +| | | | mil | | mil | | | +| Software | | 168.72 | | 140.00 | | -17.0 | | +| | | | units | | units | | % | 9 +*Software sales units for FY20 include the quantity bundled with hardware (3.40 million units). - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -3. School-wide free meals under the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an -option for eligible schools that is based on the share of students identified as -eligible for free meals.29 - -Each of these pathways is discussed in more detail below. - -Income Eligibility - -The income eligibility thresholds (shown in Table 2) are based on multipliers of the federal -poverty guidelines. As the poverty guidelines are updated every year, so are the eligibility -thresholds for NSLP and SBP. - - Free Meals: Children receive free meals if they have household income at or -below 130% of the federal poverty guidelines; these meals receive the highest -subsidy rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $3.30 per lunch served, less for -breakfast.) - - Reduced-Price Meals: Children may receive reduced-price meals (charges of no -more than 40 cents for a lunch or 30 cents for a breakfast) if their household -income is above 130% and less than or equal to 185% of the federal poverty -guidelines; these meals receive a subsidy rate that is 40 cents (NSLP) or 30 cents -(SBP) below the free meal rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $2.90 per -lunch served.) +2. Business Highlights +10 - Paid Meals: A comparatively small per-meal reimbursement is provided for full- -price or paid meals served to children whose families do not apply for assistance -or whose family income does not qualify them for free or reduced-price meals.30 -The paid meal price is set by the school but must comply with federal -regulations.31 (Reimbursements are approximately 30 cents per lunch served.) +| | | | | | Sales | | Status | | of | Nintendo | | | Switch (Sell-in) | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | FY19 | | | | FY20 | | Comparison | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | mil | | | mil | | | | | | | | | +| Hardware | | | | | 16.95 | | | | 21.03 | | | +24.0 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | units | | | units | | | % | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | mil | | | mil | | | | | | | | | +| Nintendo | | Switch | | | 16.95 | | | | 14.83 | | | -12.5 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | units | | | units | | | % | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | mil | | | | | | Pokémon Sword/ Pokémon Shield | | | +| Nintendo | | Switch | Lite | | | - | | | 6.19 | | | | - | | | | | | +units +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 17.37 | million | units | +| -------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | ---------------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------------------- | +| | | | | | | | mil | | | mil | | | | | | | | | +| Software | | | | | 118.55 | | | 168.72 | | | | +42.3 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | units | | | units | | | % | | | | | | +| | Regional Hardware Unit Sales | | | | | | | Regional Software Unit Sales | | | | | | | | | | | +| 25 | | | | | | | 200 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Animal Crossing: New Horizons | | | | Mario Kart 8 Deluxe | +20 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 11.77 | million units | | | 8.08 million units | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | +150 +15 +| | | | | | | | 100 | | | | | | | Number | of | million-seller titles (FY20) | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | +10 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 27 titles | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +50 +5 +include 18 Nintendo titles and +9 titles by other software publishers +0 +0 +| (mil units) | | FY19 | | | FY20 | | (mil units) | | FY19 | | FY20 | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +11 +| | Japan | The Americas | | Europe | Other | | Japan | | The Americas | | Europe | Other | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Nintendo Switch System Family Sell-Through +Note: Sell-through refers to units sold by retailers to consumers. +Japan North America Europe +FY2019 +FY2020 +Apr.-June Jul.-Sept. Oct.-Dec. Jan.-Mar. Apr.-June Jul.-Sept. Oct.-Dec. Jan.-Mar. Apr.-June Jul.-Sept. Oct.-Dec. Jan.-Mar. +Previous: 3.80 mil units Previous: 6.35 mil units Previous: 4.49 mil units +Current: 5.06 mil units Current: 7.67 mil units Current: 5.37 mil units +(+33%) (+20%) (+19%) +12 +Source: Nintendo, Media Create -The above reimbursement rates are approximate; exact current-year federal reimbursement rates -for NSLP and SBP are listed in Table B-1 and Table B-3, respectively. +Animal Crossing Series Comparative Sell-Through (JP/US/EUR) +13.41 +10 +5 +0 +(mil units) +Lifetime total +First 6 weeks +13 +Includes system bundles and digital sales / Source: Nintendo, Media Create + +Digital Sales +| | | FY19 | | FY20 | | Comparison | | +| --------------------------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +| Digital | sales | 118.8 | bn yen | 204.1 | bn yen | +71.8 | % | +| Proportion of digital sales | | 24.8 | | 34.0 | | +9.2 | | +| | | | % | | % | | pt. | +*Proportion to total dedicated video game platform software sales +*Sales of downloadable versions of packaged software, download-only software, +add-on content and Nintendo Switch Online, etc. +Download-only software, add-on content +Downloadable versions of packaged software +and Nintendo Switch Online, etc. +30.0% +FY20 +Component ratio +of digital sales +70.0% +14 -Households complete paper or online applications that collect relevant income and household size -data, so that the school district can determine if children in the household are eligible for free -meals, reduced-price meals, or neither. +Announced Title Releases for FY21 +| | May 29 | June 5 | | 2020 | in Japan | +| --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ---- | -------- | +Part 1: Release by end of June 2020 +| Release | continuous updates | | Releases from June 2020 onward | | | +| ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | +Part 2: Release in fall of 2020 +15 -Though these income guidelines primarily influence funding and administration of NSLP and -SBP, they also affect the eligibility rules for the SFSP, CACFP, and SMP (described further in -subsequent sections). +Mobile, IP Related Income, etc. +FY19 FY20 Comparison +Mobile, IP related income, etc. 46.0 51.2 + 11.5 +bn yen bn yen % +* Includes income from smart-device content and royalty income +• Addition of monthly subscription service • Addition of multiplayer feature +• Large increase in active players • More than one third of all sales in US +16 -29 CEP is not the only way schools may provide universal free meal service, but it is unique in that it does not require -the collection of applications. -30 The subsidy for paid meals is provided under the authority of Section 4 of the Richard B. Russell National School -Lunch Act. Section 4 establishes two different payment levels: one for schools in which less than 60% of the school -population is participating in free or reduced-price lunch and one for schools in which 60% or more of the school -population is receiving free or reduced price lunch. See https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018- -15465/national-school-lunch-special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum for -these reimbursement rates. USDA also establishes a “maximum [reimbursement] rate” intended to ensure that states -distribute federal funding to all participating school food authorities relatively equally. -31 The 2010 reauthorization established a policy intended to assure that paid meal revenues were covering the costs of -producing a meal. See FNS paid lunch equity guidance for SY2018-2019, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/paid- -lunch-equity-guidance-school-year-2018-19. +IP Expansion Initiatives +17 -Congressional Research Service +3. Reference +18 -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED +Million-Seller Nintendo First-Party Titles +units in ten thousands +| | | FY20 | | | Life-to-date | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------ | +including +| Nintendo | Switch | Global | | | Global | +| -------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | +Japan Overseas +| Pokémon Sword/Pokémon Shield | | 1,737 | 452 | 1,285 | 1,737 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | +| Animal Crossing: New Horizons | | 1,177 | 384 | 793 | 1,177 | +| Mario Kart 8 Deluxe | | 808 | 93 | 715 | 2,477 | +| Luigi’s Mansion 3 | | 633 | 83 | 550 | 633 | +| Super Mario Maker 2 | | 548 | 116 | 432 | 548 | +| Super Smash Bros. Ultimate | | 503 | 90 | 413 | 1,884 | +| The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | | 464 | 45 | 418 | 1,741 | +| The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening | | 438 | 43 | 395 | 438 | +| Super Mario Party | | 370 | 62 | 309 | 1,010 | +| New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe | | 329 | 33 | 296 | 660 | +| SUPER MARIO ODYSSEY | | 297 | 21 | 275 | 1,741 | +| Fire Emblem: Three Houses | | 287 | 58 | 229 | 287 | +| Ring Fit Adventure | | 273 | 89 | 184 | 273 | +| Splatoon 2 | | 143 | 45 | 98 | 1,013 | +Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee! 134 14 120 1,197 +| Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX | | 126 | 36 | 89 | 126 | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| MARVEL ULTIMATE ALLIANCE 3: The Black Order | | 108 | 4 | 104 | 108 | +| ASTRAL CHAIN | | 108 | 16 | 91 | 108 | +[Note] Software sales units include the quantity bundled with hardware. Software sales units include their downloadable versions. 19 + +Key Indicators +Proportion of First-Party +| Proportion of Overseas Sales | | | | Proportion of Hardware Sales | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Software Sales +| | FY20 | | | | FY20 | | | | FY20 | | | +| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | +76.5% 76.9% 78.6% 74.0% 50.5% 54.9% 57.4% 39.6% 74.1% 76.0% 87.4% 85.1% +| 76.8% | | | | 53.2% | | | | 75.2% | | | | +| ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | 77.8% | | | | 55.6% | | | | 82.0% | | | +| | 77.0% | | | | 52.2% | | | | 82.8% | | | +| | FY19 | | | | FY19 | | | | FY19 | | | +| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | +76.6% 78.7% 77.7% 78.7% 51.7% 62.4% 61.2% 51.1% 82.9% 71.0% 89.8% 80.3% +| 77.8% | | | | 57.8% | | | | 76.8% | | | | +| ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | 77.7% | | | | 59.9% | | | | 84.6% | | | +| | 77.9% | | | | 58.4% | | | | 83.8% | | | +* Proportion of overseas (outside of Japan) sales *Proportion of hardware (including accessories) * Proportion of first-party software sales to total +to total sales sales to total dedicated video game platform dedicated video game platform software sales +sales +20 -10 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP -For 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Income Eligibility Threshold - (% of the Federal Poverty Level) - -Annual Income for a -Family of Four - -Free - -Reduced-Price - -<130% - -130-185% - -<$32,630 - -$32,630 - $46,435 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Income Eligibility Guidelines,” 83 -Federal Register 20788, May 8, 2018. -Note: This school year is defined as July 1, 2018, through June 30, 2019. For other years, household sizes, -Alaska, and Hawaii, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/income-eligibility-guidelines. - -Categorical Eligibility - -In addition to the eligibility thresholds listed above, the school meals programs also convey -eligibility for free meals based on household participation in certain other need-tested programs -or children’s specified vulnerabilities (e.g., foster children). Per Section 12 of the National School -Lunch Act, “a child shall be considered automatically eligible for a free lunch and breakfast ... -without further application or eligibility determination, if the child is”32 - - - -in a household receiving benefits through - - SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program); - FDPIR (Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations, a program -that operates in lieu of SNAP on some Indian reservations) benefits; or - - TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) cash assistance; - -enrolled in Head Start; -in foster care; -a migrant; -a runaway; or - - - - - - homeless.33 - -For meals served to students certified in the above categories, the state/school will receive -reimbursement at the free meal amount and children receive a free meal. (See Table B-1 and -Table B-3 for school year 2018-2019 rates.) - -Some school districts collect information for these categorical eligibility rules via paper -application. Others conduct a process called direct certification—a proactive process where - -32 See Section 9(b)(12)(A) of the Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(12)(A), for the -more specific definitions of these categories. -33 SNAP, FDPIR, and TANF have income limits, but the other qualifications, as defined, in the statute, are not limited -by income. In addition to the above list, following specific demonstration authority in HHFKA as well as under FNS’s -standing pilot authority, some states are currently directly certifying children based on Medicaid data. According to -USDA-FNS, 19 states are operating direct certification with Medicaid in SY2018-2019. Four of the states (Illinois, -Kentucky, New York, Pennsylvania) use Medicaid to directly certify for free meals only. Fifteen states (California, -Connecticut, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, -West Virginia, Wisconsin), operating under an expanded direct certification demonstration project to test direct -certification with Medicaid for reduced-price meals (up to 185% of poverty), are using this process for free and -reduced-price meals. Both options are discussed in USDA-FNS, Request for Applications to Participate in -Demonstration Projects to Evaluate Direct Certification with Medicaid, January 27, 2016, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ -sites/default/files/cn/SP23-2016a.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -11 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -government agencies typically cross-check their program rolls and certify a household’s children -for free school meals without the household having to complete a school meals application. - -Prior to 2004, states had the option to conduct direct certification of SNAP (then, the Food Stamp -Program), TANF, and FDPIR participants. In the 2004 child nutrition reauthorization (P.L. 108- -265), states were required under federal law to conduct direct certification for SNAP participants, -with nationwide implementation taking effect in school year 2008-2009. Conducting direct -certification for TANF and FDPIR remains at the state’s discretion. - -The Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296) made further policy changes -to expand direct certification (discussed further in the next section). One of those changes was the -initiation of a demonstration project to look at expanding categorical eligibility and direct -certification to some Medicaid households. The law also funded performance incentive grants for -high-performing states and authorized correcting action planning for low-performing states in -direct certification activities.34 - -Under SNAP direct certification rules generally, schools enter into agreements with SNAP -agencies to certify children in SNAP households as eligible for free school meals without -requiring a separate application from the family. Direct certification systems match student -enrollment lists against SNAP agency records, eliminating the need for action by the child’s -parents or guardians. Direct certification allows schools to make use of SNAP’s more in-depth -eligibility certification process; this can reduce errors that may occur in school lunch application -eligibility procedures that are otherwise used.35 From a program access perspective, direct -certification also reduces the number of applications a household must complete. - -Figure 2, created by GAO and published in a May 2014 report, provides an overview of how -school districts certify students for free and reduced-price meals under the income-based and -category-based rules, via applications and direct certification.36 A USDA-FNS study of school -year 2014-2015 estimates that 11.1 million students receiving free meals were directly certified— -68% of all categorically eligible students receiving free meals.37 - -34 See CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296, for further discussion of these -and related policies. -35 See, for example, U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, -but Additional Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, pp. 16-19, -http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-14-262. -36 U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, but Additional -Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, http://www.gao.gov/products/ -GAO-14-262. -37 Quinn Moore, Kevin Conway, and Brandon Kyler, et al., Direct Certification in the National School Lunch -Program: State Implementation Progress, School Year 2014-2015, Report to Congress Mathematica Policy Research -for USDA-FNS, CN-15-DC, October 2016, p. 24, https://www.fns.usda.gov/direct-certification-national-school-lunch- -program-report-congress-state-implementation-progress-0 - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -12 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals -Household Application and Direct Certification Pathways - -Source: Figure and figure notes (below) from Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 13. -Note: aStudents who meet an approved designation—(1) homeless, runaway, or migrant; (2) foster child; or -(3) enrolled in a federally funded Head Start Program—are categorically eligible for free school meals. - -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) - -HHFKA also authorized the school meals Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an option in -NSLP and SBP law that allows eligible schools and school districts to offer free meals to all -enrolled students based on the percentage of their students who are identified as automatically - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -13 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -eligible from non-household application sources (primarily direct certification through other -programs).38 - -Based on the statutory parameters, USDA-FNS piloted CEP in various states over three school -years and it expanded nationwide in school year 2014-2015. Eligible LEAs have until June 30 of -each year to notify USDA-FNS if they will participate in CEP.39 According to a database -maintained by the Food Research and Action Center, just over 20,700 schools in more than 3,500 -school districts (LEAs) participated in CEP in SY2016-2017, an increase of approximately 2,500 -schools compared to SY2015-2016.40 - -For a school (or school district, or group of schools within a district) to provide free meals to all -children: - - - - - -the school(s) must be eligible for CEP based on the share (40% or greater) of -enrolled children that can be identified as categorically (or automatically) eligible -for free meals, and -the school must opt-in to CEP. - -Though CEP schools serve free meals to all students, they are not reimbursed at the “free meal” -rate for every meal. Instead, the law provides a funding formula: the percentage of students -identified as automatically eligible (the “identified student percentage” or ISP) is multiplied by a -factor of 1.6 to estimate the proportion of students who would be eligible for free or reduced- -price meals had they been certified via application.41 The result is the percentage of meals served -that will be reimbursed at the free meal rate, with the remainder reimbursed at the far lower paid -meal rate. For example, if a CEP school identifies that 40% of students are eligible for free meals, -then 64% of the meals served will be reimbursed at the free meal rate and 36% at the paid meal -rate.42 Schools that identify 62.5% or more students as eligible for free meals receive the free -meal reimbursement for all meals served. - -Some of the considerations that may impact a school’s decision to participate in CEP include -whether the new funding formula would be beneficial for their school meal budget; an interest in -reducing paperwork for families and schools; and an interest in providing more free meals, -including meals to students who have not participated in the program before. - -38 Explanation here draws in part from Madeleine Levin and Zoe Neuberger, Improving Direct Certification Will Help -More Low-Income Children Receive School Meals, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities & Food Research and -Action Center, July 25, 2014, p. 3. Aside from CEP, schools may also provide universal free meal service through the -“Provision 2” and “Provision 3” options. CEP is unique in that no school meal applications are required. For -information on other options, see USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/provisions-1-2-and-3. -39 USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating -Applications through Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal -Register 50194, July 29, 2016. -40 FRAC, “Community Eligibility,” available at http://frac.org/community-eligibility. -41 USDA-FNS, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating Applications Through -Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal Register 50194, July -29, 2016, p. 50201. -42 Though, to the children of community eligibility schools, all meals are free, the USDA-FNS school meals -expenditure data used throughout this report count these meals served in a more nuanced fashion. The percentage -derived through this calculation is used to record those meals that are “free” and those meals that are “paid” (i.e., using -the example from above, USDA-FNS data would reflect 64% of the meals served in the school as a “free” expenditure -and meal served, and 36% as “paid”). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -14 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) - -In FY2017, NSLP subsidized 4.9 billion lunches to children in close to 96,000 schools and 3,200 -residential child care institutions (RCCIs). Average daily participation was 30.0 million students -(58% of children enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). Of the participating students, -66.7% (20.0 million) received free lunches and 6.5% (2.0 million) received reduced-price -lunches. The remainder were served full-price meals, though schools still receive a -reimbursement for these meals. Figure 3 shows FY2017 participation data. - -FY2017 federal school lunch costs totaled approximately $13.6 billion (see Table 3 for the -various components of this total). The vast majority of this funding is for per-meal -reimbursements for free and reduced-price lunches. - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at NSLP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -HHFKA also provided an additional 6-cent per-lunch reimbursement to schools that provide -meals that meet the updated nutritional guidelines requirements.43 This bonus is not provided for -breakfast, but funds may be used to support schools’ breakfast programs. NSLP lunch -reimbursement rates are listed in Table B-1. - -In addition to federal cash subsidies, schools participating in NSLP receive USDA-acquired -commodity foods. Schools are entitled to a specific, inflation-indexed value of USDA commodity - -43 In January 2014, USDA-FNS issued a final rule implementing the 6-cent reimbursement: USDA-FNS, “Certification -of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids -Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. Note: 6-cent increase authorized is also annually indexed for -inflation. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -15 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -foods for each lunch they serve. Also, schools may receive donations of bonus commodities -acquired by USDA in support of the farm economy.44 In FY2017, the value of federal commodity -food aid to schools totaled nearly $1.4 billion. The per-meal rate for commodity food assistance is -included in Table B-4. - -While the vast majority of NSLP funding is for lunches served during the school day, NSLP may -also be used to support snack service during the school year and to serve meals during the -summer. These features are discussed in subsequent sections, “Summer Meals” and “After-School -Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” Reimbursement rates for snacks are listed in Table -B-2. - -School Breakfast Program (SBP) - -The School Breakfast Program (SBP) provides per-meal cash subsidies for breakfasts served in -schools. Participating schools receive subsidies based on their status as a severe need or non- -severe need institution. Schools can qualify as a severe need school if 40% or more of their -lunches are served free or at reduced prices. See Table B-3 for SBP reimbursement rates. - -Figure 4 displays SBP participation data for FY2017. In that year, SBP subsidized over 2.4 -billion breakfasts in over 88,000 schools and nearly 3,200 RCCIs. Average daily participation was -14.7 million children (30.1% of the students enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). The -majority of meals served through SBP are free or reduced-price. Of the participating students, -79.1% (11.6 million) received free meals and 5.7% (835,000) purchased reduced-price meals. -Federal school breakfast costs for the fiscal year totaled approximately $4.3 billion (see Table 3 -for the various components of this total). - -Significantly fewer schools and students participate in SBP than in NSLP. Participation in SBP -tends to be lower for several reasons, including the traditionally required early arrival by students -in order to receive a meal and eat before school starts. Some schools offer (and anti-hunger -groups have encouraged) models of breakfast service that can result in greater SBP participation, -such as Breakfast in the Classroom, where meals are delivered in the classroom; “grab and go” -carts, where students receive a bagged breakfast that they bring to class, or serving breakfast later -in the day in middle and high schools.45 - -Unlike NSLP, commodity food assistance is not a formal part of SBP funding; however, -commodities provided through NSLP may be used for school breakfasts as well. - -44 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -45 See Food Research and Action Center (FRAC), “School Breakfast Expansion Strategies,” http://www.frac.org/ -programs/school-breakfast-program/school-breakfast-expansion-strategies (Accessed July 9, 2018). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -16 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at SBP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -Other Child Nutrition Programs -In addition to the school meals programs discussed above, other federal child nutrition programs -provide federal subsidies and commodity food assistance for schools and other institutions that -offer meals and snacks to children in early childhood, summer, and after-school settings. This -assistance is provided to (1) schools and other governmental institutions, (2) private for-profit and -nonprofit child care centers, (3) family/group day care homes, and (4) nongovernmental -institutions/organizations that offer outside-of-school programs for children. (Although this report -focuses on the programs that serve children, one child nutrition program [CACFP] also serves -day care centers for chronically impaired adults and elderly persons under the same general per- -meal/snack subsidy terms.) The programs in the sections to follow serve comparatively fewer -children and spend comparatively fewer federal funds than the school meal programs. - -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) - -CACFP subsidizes meals and snacks served in early childhood, day care, and after-school -settings. CACFP provides subsidies for meals and snacks served at participating non-residential -child care centers, family day care homes, and (to a lesser extent) adult day care centers.46 The -program also provides assistance for meals served at after-school programs. CACFP -reimbursements are available for meals and snacks served to children age 12 or under, migrant - -46 CACFP also supports meals in homeless/emergency shelters. See http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/emergency-shelters -for further information. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -17 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -children age 15 or under, children with disabilities of any age, and, in the case of adult care -centers, chronically impaired and elderly adults. Children in early childhood settings are the -overwhelming majority of those served by the program. - -CACFP provides federal reimbursements for breakfasts, lunches, suppers, and snacks served in -participating centers (facilities or institutions) or day care homes (private homes). The eligibility -and funding rules for CACFP meals and snacks depend first on whether the participating -institution is a center or a day care home (the next two sections discuss the rules specific to -centers and day care homes). According to FY2017 CACFP data, child care centers have an -average daily attendance of about 56 children per center, day care homes have an average daily -attendance of approximately 7 children per home, and adult day care centers typically care for an -average of 48 chronically ill or elderly adults per center.47 - -Subsidized CACFP meals and snacks must meet program-specific federal nutrition standards, and -providers must demonstrate that they comply with government-established standards for other -child care programs. Like in school meals, federal assistance is made up overwhelmingly of cash -reimbursements calculated based on the number of meals/snacks served and federal per- -meal/snack reimbursements rates, but a far smaller share of federal aid (4.3% in FY2017) is in the -form of federal USDA commodity foods (or cash in lieu of foods). Federal CACFP -reimbursements flow to individual providers either directly from the administering state agency -(this is the case with many child/adult care centers able to handle their own CACFP -administrative functions) or through “sponsors” who oversee and provide administrative support -for a number of local providers (this is the case with some child/adult care centers and with all -day care homes).48 - -In FY2017, total CACFP spending was over $3.5 billion, including cash reimbursement, -commodity food assistance, and costs for sponsor audits. (See Table 3 for a further breakdown of -CACFP costs.) This total also includes the after-school meals and snacks provided through -CACFP’s “at-risk after-school” pathway; this aspect of the program is discussed later in “After- -School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” - -CACFP at Centers - -Participation - -Child care centers in CACFP can be (1) public or private nonprofit centers, (2) Head Start -centers, (3) for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet certain requirements as to the proportion of -low-income children they enroll), and (4) shelters for homeless families. Adult day care centers -include public or private nonprofit centers and for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet -minimum requirements related to serving low-income disabled and elderly adults).49 In FY2017, -over 65,000 child care centers with an average daily attendance of over 3.6 million children -participated in CACFP. Over 2,700 adult care centers served nearly 132,000 adults through -CACFP. - -47 USDA-FNS’ administrative data on the CACFP are the source of these attendance numbers. -48 In many cases, sponsor organizations that provide administrative support to multiple providers also are paid federal -reimbursements for their costs. Day care homes must have a sponsoring organization, while child care centers may -have a sponsor but are not required to do so. -49 Participating adult care programs “should be structured, comprehensive and provide health and social support -services to enrolled participants. Centers that simply provide social or rehabilitative services to adults do not qualify to -participate in CACFP.” http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/facts-about-adult-component-cacfp. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -18 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Eligibility and Administration - -Participating centers may receive daily reimbursements for up to either two meals and one snack -or one meal and two snacks for each participant, so long as the meals and snacks meet federal -nutrition standards. - -The eligibility rules for CACFP centers largely track those of NSLP: children in households at or -below 130% of the current poverty line qualify for free meals/snacks while those between 130% -and 185% of poverty qualify for reduced-price meals/snacks (see Table 2). In addition, -participation in the same categorical eligibility programs as NSLP as well as foster child status -convey eligibility for free meals in CACFP.50 Like school meals, eligibility is determined through -paper applications or direct certification processes. - -Like school meals, all meals and snacks served in the centers are federally subsidized to some -degree, even those that are paid. Different reimbursement amounts are provided for breakfasts, -lunches/suppers, and snacks, and reimbursement rates are set in law and indexed for inflation -annually. The largest subsidies are paid for meals and snacks served to participants with family -income below 130% of the federal poverty income guidelines (the income limit for free school -meals), and the smallest to those who have not met a means test. See Table B-5 for current -CACFP center reimbursement rates. - -Unlike school meals, CACFP institutions are less likely to collect per-meal payments. Although -federal assistance for day care centers differentiates by household income, centers have discretion -on their pricing of meals. Centers may adjust their regular fees (tuition) to account for federal -payments, but CACFP itself does not regulate these fees. In addition, centers can charge families -separately for meals/snacks, so long as there are no charges for children meeting free-meal/snack -income tests and limited charges for those meeting reduced-price income tests. - -Independent centers are those without sponsors handling administrative responsibilities. These -centers must pay for administrative costs associated with CACFP out of non-federal funds or a -portion of their meal subsidy payments. For centers with sponsors, the sponsors may retain a -proportion of the meal reimbursement payments they receive on behalf of their centers to cover -such costs. - -CACFP for Day Care Homes - -Participation - -CACFP-supported day care homes serve a smaller number of children than CACFP-supported -centers, both in terms of the total number of children served and the average number of children -per facility. Roughly 17% of children in CACFP (approximately 757,000 in FY2017 average -daily attendance) are served through day care homes. In FY2017, approximately 103,000 homes -(with just over 700 sponsors) received CACFP support. - -Eligibility and Reimbursement - -As with centers, payments to day care homes are provided for up to either two meals and one -snack or one meal and two snacks a day for each child. Unlike centers, day care homes must -participate under the auspices of a public or, more often, private nonprofit sponsor that typically - -50 See also summary of CACFP eligibility rules at USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/why-cacfp- -important. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -19 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -has 100 or more homes under its supervision. CACFP day care home sponsors receive monthly -administrative payments based on the number of homes for which they are responsible.51 - -Federal reimbursements for family day care homes differ by the home’s status as “Tier I” or “Tier -II.” Unlike centers, day care homes receive cash reimbursements (but not commodity foods) that -generally are not based on the child participants’ household income. Instead, there are two -distinct, annually indexed reimbursement rates that are based on area or operator eligibility -criteria: - - Tier I homes are located in low-income areas (defined as areas in which at least - -50% of school-age and enrolled children qualify for free or reduced-price meals) -or operated by low-income providers whose household income meets the free or -reduced-price income standards.52 They receive higher subsidies for each -meal/snack they serve. - - Tier II (lower) rates are by default those for homes that do not qualify for Tier I -rates; however, Tier II providers may seek the higher Tier I subsidy rates for -individual low-income children for whom financial information is collected and -verified. (See Table B-6 for current Tier I and Tier II reimbursement rates.) - -Additionally, HHFKA introduced a number of additional ways (as compared to prior law) by -which family day care homes can qualify as low-income and get Tier I rates for the entire home -or for individual children.53 - -As with centers, there is no requirement that meals/snacks specifically identified as free or -reduced-price be offered; however, unlike centers, federal rules prohibit any separate meal -charges. - -Summer Meals - -Current law SFSP and the NSLP/SBP Seamless Summer Option provide meals in congregate -settings nationwide; the related Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer (SEBTC or Summer EBT) -demonstration project is an alternative to congregate settings. The demonstration is discussed -below; proposals to expand the demonstration are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” - -51 As an example of the role that sponsors and homes play in CACFP, in Allentown, Pennsylvania, the Lehigh Valley -Children’s Centers (LVCC) serves as a sponsor for child care homes in the area. They offer a variety of administrative -services to family child care homes that are registered with the state. In their brochure, they state that it is LVCC’s -responsibility to “monitor meals and reimburse [homes] for meals served,” and it is homes’ responsibility “to plan -nutritional menus that meet meal requirements, maintain and submit daily attendance records and monthly meal -counts.” See http://www.lvcconline.org/images/pdf/CACFP-Brochure.pdf. -52 7 C.F.R. §226.2. -53 Previously, child care homes could only use data from the elementary school level to establish the area as low- -income. The new law allows these homes to use data from the middle and high school level as well to establish need -and qualify as a “Tier I” home. Also, P.L. 111-296 included policies to streamline application processes and eliminate -some paperwork. As part of this process, the annual application process has been eliminated and sponsors and child -care centers will only have to submit paperwork the first time they apply, with amendments submitted as necessary. -Finally, P.L. 111-296 increased CACFP sponsoring organizations’ and providers’ flexibility over administrative funds, -including the option to carry over up to 10% of administrative funds from one fiscal year to the next. USDA-FNS has -begun to implement these changes. See, for example, USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Amendments Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 77 Federal Register 21018-21038, -April 9, 2012; USDA-FNS Memorandum, Child Nutrition Reauthorization 2010: Area Eligibility for Family Day Care -Homes, Memo Code: CACFP 05-2011-Revised, January 10, 2011, https://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp-05-2011-revised- -child-nutrition-reauthorization-2010-area-eligibility-family-day-care-homes. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -20 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) - -SFSP supports meals for children during the summer months. The program provides assistance to -local public institutions and private nonprofit service institutions running summer -youth/recreation programs, summer feeding projects, and camps. Assistance is primarily in the -form of cash reimbursements for each meal or snack served; however, federally donated -commodity foods are also offered. Participating service institutions are often entities that provide -ongoing year-round service to the community including schools, local governments, camps, -colleges and universities in the National Youth Sports program, and private nonprofit -organizations like churches. - -Similar to the CACFP model, sponsors are institutions that manage the food preparation, -financial, and administrative responsibilities of SFSP. Sites are the places where food is served -and eaten. At times, a sponsor may also be a site. State agencies authorize sponsors, monitor and -inspect sponsors and sites, and implement USDA policy. Unlike CACFP, sponsors are required -for an institution’s participation in SFSP as a site. - -Participation - -In FY2017, nearly 5,500 sponsors with 50,000 food service sites participated in the SFSP and -served an average of approximately 2.7 million children daily (according to July data).54 - -Participation of sites and children in SFSP has increased in recent years. Program costs for -FY2017 totaled over $485 million, including cash assistance, commodity foods, administrative -cost assistance, and health inspection costs. - -Eligibility and Administration - -There are several options for eligibility and meal/snack service for SFSP sponsors (and their -sites): - - Open sites provide summer food to all children in the community. These sites are -certified based on area eligibility measures, where 50% or more of area children -have family income that would make them eligible for free or reduced-price -school meals (see Table 2). - - Closed or Enrolled sites provide summer meals/snacks free to all children - -enrolled at the site. The eligibility test for these sites is that 50% or more of the -children enrolled in the sponsor’s program must be eligible for free or reduced- -price school meals based on household income. Closed/enrolled sites may also -become eligible based on area eligibility measures noted above. - - Summer camps (that are not enrolled sites) receive subsidies only for those -children with household eligibility for free or reduced-price school meals. - Other programs specified in law, such as the National Youth Sports Program - -and centers for homeless or migrant children. - -54 According to a May 2018 GAO report, estimates of participation in SFSP may not be reliable because they have been -calculated inconsistently across states and years. See U.S. Government Accountability Office, Actions Needed to -Improve Participation Estimates and Address Program Challenges, GAO-18-369, May 2018, https://www.gao.gov/ -products/GAO-18-369. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -21 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer sponsors get operating cost (food, storage, labor) subsidies for all meals/snacks they -serve—up to one meal and one snack, or two meals per child per day.55 In addition, sponsors -receive payments for administrative costs, and states are provided with subsidies for -administrative costs and health and meal-quality inspections. See Table B-7 for current SFSP -reimbursement rates. Actual payments vary slightly (e.g., by about 5 cents for lunches) depending -on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared on-site or by a -vendor. - -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option56 - -Although SFSP is the child nutrition program most associated with providing meals during -summer months, it is not the only program option for providing these meals and snacks. The -Seamless Summer Option, run through NSLP or SBP programs, is also a means through which -food can be provided to students during summer months. Much like SFSP, Seamless Summer -operates in summer sites (summer camps, sports programs, churches, private nonprofit -organizations, etc.) and for a similar duration of time. Unlike SFSP, schools are the only eligible -sponsors, although schools may operate the program at other sites. Reimbursement rates for -Seamless Summer meals are the same as current NSLP/SBP rates. - -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration - -Beginning in summer 2011 and (as of the date of this report) each summer since, USDA-FNS has -operated Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children (SEBTC or “Summer EBT”) -demonstration projects in a limited number of states and Indian Tribal Organizations (ITOs). -These Summer EBT projects provide electronic food benefits over summer months to households -with children eligible for free or reduced-price school meals. Depending on the site and year, -either $30 or $60 per month is provided, through a WIC or SNAP EBT card model. In the -demonstration projects, these benefits were provided as a supplement to the Summer Food -Service Program (SFSP) meals available in congregate settings. - -Summer EBT and other alternatives to congregate meals through SFSP were first authorized and -funded by the FY2010 appropriations law (P.L. 111-80). Although a number of alternatives were -tested and evaluated, findings from Summer EBT were among the most promising, and Congress -provided subsequent funding.57 Summer EBT evaluations (discussed later in “Alternatives to -“Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals”) showed significant impacts on reducing child food -insecurity and improving nutritional intake.58 Summer EBT was funded by P.L. 111-80 in the -summers from 2011 to 2014. Projects have continued to operate and were annually funded by -FY2015-FY2018 appropriations; most recently, the FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million. According to USDA-FNS, in summer 2016 Summer EBT served over - -55 With state agency approval, camps and migrant sites (sites that predominantly serve children of migrant workers) -may be reimbursed for serving three meals or two meals and one snack per child daily. -56 For further discussion, see the USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/opportunity-schools. -57 This CRS report discusses Summer EBT, not the other tested programs (“Enhanced Summer Food Service Program -(eSFSP). For information on eSFSP, see USDA-FNS’ “Enhanced Summer Food Service Program” webpage, -https://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/enhanced-summer-food-service-program-esfsp. -58 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus (Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013), p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED +Digital Sales Indicators +Proportion of Downloadable Versions +| | Digital Sales | | | | Proportion of Digital Sales | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +of Packaged Software Sales +in yen +| | | FY20 | | | | FY20 | | | | FY20 | | | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | +| Q1 | Q2 | | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | +30.6 bn 40.9 bn 53.2 bn 79.2 bn 38.3% 34.8% 22.3% 48.5% 56.4% 64.5% 71.7% 76.9% +| 71.6 bn | | | | | 36.2% | | | | 61.0% | | | | +| ------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | 124.9 | bn | | | | 28.6% | | | | 65.6% | | | +| | | 204.1 bn | | | | 34.0% | | | | 70.0% | | | +| | | FY19 | | | | FY19 | | | | FY19 | | | +| Q1 | Q2 | | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | +18.5 bn 20.6 bn 45.0 bn 34.6 bn 24.2% 26.0% 19.6% 37.2% 59.3% 59.1% 78.7% 62.6% +| 39.1 bn | | | | | 25.1% | | | | 59.2% | | | | +| ------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | 84.2 | bn | | | | 21.8% | | | | 69.6% | | | +| | | 118.8 | bn | | | 24.8% | | | | 67.6% | | | +*Digital sales include (a) downloadable version *Proportion of digital sales to total dedicated * Proportion of downloadable versions of packaged +of packaged software (the downloadable version video game platform software sales software sales to total digital sales as indicated on +of software that is offered both physically and the left: a/(a+b+c+d) +digitally), (b) download-only software, (c) add- +on content and (d) Nintendo Switch Online, etc. +21 +Supplementary Information on Our Website +Earnings Releases, etc. IR Events +・Earning Releases ・Corporate Management Policy Briefing Presentation Materials +・Timely Disclosure of Information, etc. ・Financial Results Explanatory Materials, etc. +Financial Highlights Dedicated Video Game Sales Units +・Consolidated Statements of Income (Annual/ Quarterly) ・Total Unit Sales (Life-to-date) +・Consolidated Balance Sheet (Annual/ Quarterly) ・Unit Sales (Annual/ Quarterly) +・Consolidated Cash Flows (Annual) ・Number of Titles Released (Annual) +・Key Figures per Share (Annual) +・Geographical Sales Breakdown (Annual/ Quarterly) +・Sales Breakdown by Category (Annual/ Quarterly) +Top Selling Title Sales Units Historical Data (Updated at fiscal year-end) +・Top selling Nintendo software sales units ・Consolidated Statements of Income Transition +on an accumulated basis ・Consolidated Sales Transition by Region +・Number of Software Titles Released +*Corresponding pages on our website can be accessed by clicking on the titles above. +*Financial Highlights will be updated within 2 business days of our financial announcement. +*Information previously available in Supplementary Information can be found at the following locations: +・Consolidated Statements of Income Transition → Financial Highlights +・Foreign Currency Transaction Information → Earnings Releases (Others, page 13) 22 - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -209,000 children in nine states and two tribal nations—an increase from the 11,400 children -served when the demonstration began in summer 2011.59 - -Special Milk Program (SMP) - -Schools (and institutions like summer camps and child care facilities) that are not already -participating in the other child nutrition programs can participate in the Special Milk Program. -Schools may also administer SMP for their part-day sessions for kindergartners or pre- -kindergartners. - -Under SMP, participating institutions provide milk to children for free and/or at a subsidized paid -price, depending on how the enrolled institution opts to administer the program (see Table B-8 -for current Special Milk reimbursement rates for each of these options): - - An institution that only sells milk will receive the same per-half pint federal - -reimbursement for each milk sold (approximately 20 cents). - - An institution that sells milk and provides free milk to eligible children (income - -eligibility is the same as free school meals, see Table 2), receives a -reimbursement for the milk sold (approximately 20 cents) and a higher -reimbursement for the free milks. - - An institution that does not sell milk provides milk free to all children and - -receives the same reimbursement for all milk (approximately 20 cents). This -option is sometimes called non-pricing. - -In FY2017, over 41 million half-pints were subsidized, 9.5% of which were served free. Federal -expenditures for this program were approximately $8.3 million in FY2017. - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) - -States receive formula grants through the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program, under which state- -selected schools receive funds to purchase and distribute fresh fruit and vegetable snacks to all -children in attendance (regardless of family income). Money is distributed by a formula under -which about half the funding is distributed equally to each state and the remainder is allocated by -state population. States select participating schools (with an emphasis on those with a higher -proportion of low-income children) and set annual per-student grant amounts (between $50 and -$75). - -Funding is set by law at $150 million for school year 2011-2012 and inflation-indexed for every -year after. In FY2017, states used approximately $184 million in FFVP funds.60 FFVP is funded -by a mandatory transfer of funds from USDA’s Section 32 program—a permanent appropriation -of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts.61 This transfer is required by FFVP’s authorizing -laws (Section 19 of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act and Section 4304 of P.L. -110-246). Up until FY2018’s law, annual appropriations laws delayed a portion of the funds to -the next fiscal year. - -59 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32- -40https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -60 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32-14, -https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -61 For more information, see CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -23 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In recent years, FFVP has been amended by omnibus farm bill laws rather than through child -nutrition reauthorizations. After a limited pilot, FFVP was expanded to all states and permanently -funded by the 2008 farm bill (P.L. 110-246).62 The 2014 farm bill (P.L. 113-79) essentially made -no changes to this program but did include, and fund at $5 million in FY2014, a pilot project that -requires USDA to test offering frozen, dried, and canned fruits and vegetables and publish an -evaluation of the pilot. Four states (Alaska, Delaware, Kansas, and Maine) participated in the -pilot in SY2014-2015 and the evaluation was published in 2017.63 Other proposals to expand -fruits and vegetables offered in FFVP have been introduced in both the 114th and 115th -Congress.64 - -Other Topics - -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options - -Two of the child nutrition programs discussed in previous sections, the National School Lunch -Program (NSLP) and Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), provide federal support for -snacks and meals served during after-school programs.65 - -NSLP provides reimbursements for after-school snacks; however, this option is open only to -schools that already participate in NSLP. These schools may operate after-school snack-only -programs during the school year, and can do so in two ways: (1) if low-income area eligibility -criteria are met, provide free snacks in lower-income areas; or (2) if area eligibility criteria are not -met, offer free, reduced-price, or fully paid-for snacks, based on household income eligibility -(like lunches in NSLP). The vast majority of snacks provided through this program are through -the first option. Through this program, approximately 206 million snacks were served in FY2017 -(a daily average of nearly 1.3 million). This compares with nearly 4.9 billion lunches served (a -daily average of 27.8 million). - -CACFP provides assistance for after-school food in two ways. First, centers and homes that -participate in CACFP and provide after-school care may participate in traditional CACFP (the -eligibility and administration described earlier). Second, centers in areas where at least half the -children in the community are eligible for free or reduced-price school meals can opt to -participate in the CACFP At-Risk Afterschool program, which provides free snacks and suppers. -Expansion of the At-Risk After-School meals program was a major policy change included in -HHFKA. Prior to the law, 13 states were permitted to offer CACFP At-Risk After-School meals -(instead of just a snack); the law allowed all CACFP state agencies to offer such meals.66 In - -62 Permanent funding is made possible through the Section 32 account. See CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food -Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program, coordinated by Jim Monke. -63 Briefel et al., Evaluation of the Pilot Project for Canned, Frozen, or Dried Fruits and Vegetables in the Fresh Fruit -and Vegetable Program (FFVP-CFD), Prepared by Mathematica Policy Research. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, January 2017, available at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/ops/FFVP-CFD.pdf. -64 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. In the 115th Congress, -see H.R. 3402, S. 2064, and House-passed H.R. 2 §4204. -65 For further discussion of the NSLP and CACFP after-school snack program, see Joanne Guthrie, Feeding Children -After School: The Expanding Role of USDA Child Nutrition Programs, USDA Economic Research Service, Amber -Waves, March 1, 2012, https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2012/march/feeding-children-after-school/. -66 S.Rept. 111-178, p. 7. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -24 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -FY2017, the At-Risk Afterschool program served a total of approximately 242.6 million free -meals and snacks to a daily average of more than 1.7 million children.67 - -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs - -In millions of dollars - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -National School Lunch Program - -$13,569 - -$13,643 - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -additional funding to schools with -more than 60% free or reduced- -price participation - -performance-based meal -reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -School Breakfast Program - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -Child and Adult Care Food -Program - -meal reimbursements at child care -centers - -meal reimbursements at child care -homes - -meal reimbursements at adult day -care centers - -commodity food assistancea - -administrative costs for child care -sponsors - -Summer Food Service Program - -meal reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -sponsor and inspection costs - -Special Milk Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable -Programb - -State Administrative Expenses - -$9,593 - -$808 - -$1,478 - -$9,620 - -$783 - -$1,480 - -+$74 - -+$27 - --$25 - -+$2 - -+1% - -0% - --3% - -0% - -$76 - -$74 - --$2 - --3% - -$302 - -$293 - --$9 - --3% - -$1,311 - -$4,213 - -$3,868 - -$239 - -$106 - -$1,393 - -$4,252 - -$3,912 - -$235 - -$106 - -+$82 - -+$39 - -+$44 - --$4 - -$0 - -+6% - -+1% - -+1% - --2% - -0% - -$3,520 - -$3,537 - -+$17 - -0% - -$2,307 - -$2,363 - -+$56 - -+2% - -$764 - -$149 - -$155 - -$146 - -$478 - -$419 - -$2 - -$58 - -$9 - -$167 - -$260 - -$721 - --$42 - --6% - -$156 - -$153 - -$145 - -$485 - -$424 - -$2 - -$60 - -$8 - -+$7 - -+5% - --$2 - --$1 - -+$7 - -+$5 - -$0 - -+$2 - --$1 - --1% - --1% - -+1% - -+1% - -0% - -+3% - --11% - -$184 - -+$17 - -+10% - -$279 - -+$19 - -+7% - -67 Data provided by USDA-FNS on July 18, 2018. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -25 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -Mandatory Other Program -Costsc - -Discretionary Activitiesd - -TOTAL OF FUNDS -DISPLAYEDe - -$59 - -$69 - -$83 - -$63 - -+$24 - -+41% - --$6 - --9% - -$22,344 - -$22,534 - -+$192 - -+1% - -Source: Program expenditures data (outlays) from USDA-FNS Keydata Reports (dated March 2017 and March -2018), except where noted below. -Notes: Expenditures displayed here will vary from displays in CRS appropriations reports and in some cases the -USDA-FNS annual budget justification. Since the majority of program funding is for open-ended entitlements, -expenditure data capture spending better than the total of appropriations. This table includes some functions that are -funded through permanent appropriations or transfers (i.e., funding not provided in appropriations laws). Due to -rounding to the nearest million, percentage increases or decreases may be exaggerated or understated. - -a. Amounts included in this table for commodity food assistance include only entitlement commodities for - -each program, not bonus commodities. - -b. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -c. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and -Technical Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. - -d. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs include Team Nutrition, the Summer EBT demonstration, and School Meal Equipment Grants. -e. This table summarizes the vast majority of child nutrition programs’ federal spending but does not capture - -all federal costs. - -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities - -Federal child nutrition laws authorize and program funding supports a range of additional -programs, initiatives, and activities.68 - -Through State Administrative Expenses funding, states are entitled to federal grants to help -cover administrative and oversight/monitoring costs associated with child nutrition programs. The -national amount each year is equal to about 2% of child nutrition reimbursements. The majority -of this money is allocated to states based on their share of spending on the covered programs; -about 15% is allocated under a discretionary formula granting each state additional amounts for -CACFP, commodity distribution, and Administrative Review efforts. In addition, states receive -payments for their role in overseeing summer programs (about 2.5% of their summer program -aid). States are free to apportion their federal administrative expense payments among child -nutrition initiatives (including commodity distribution activities) as they see fit, and appropriated -funding is available to states for two years. State Administrative Expense spending in FY2017 -totaled approximately $279 million.69 - -Team Nutrition is a USDA-FNS program that includes a variety of school meals initiatives -around nutrition education and the nutritional content of the foods children eat in schools. This - -68 This section does not list all related federal funding and support activities; those activities that are discussed are -broadly summarized. For further details on these and other functions funded by the “child nutrition programs” account, -see the 2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, pp. 32-10 through -32-26, https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -69 For the formula for administrative and oversight/monitoring costs, see Section 7 of the Child Nutrition Act of 1966 -(codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -26 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -includes Team Nutrition Training Grants, which provide funding to state agencies for training and -technical assistance, such as help implementing USDA’s nutrition requirements and the Dietary -Guidelines for Americans. From 2004 to 2018, Team Nutrition also included the HealthierUS -Schools Challenge (HUSSC), which originated in the 2004 reauthorization of the Child Nutrition -Act. HUSSC was a voluntary certification initiative designed to recognize schools that have -created a healthy school environment through the promotion of nutrition and physical activity.70 - -Farm-to-school programs broadly refer to “efforts that bring regionally and locally produced -foods into school cafeterias,” with a focus on enhancing child nutrition.71 The goals of these -efforts include increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among students, supporting local -farmers and rural communities, and providing nutrition and agriculture education to school -districts and farmers. HHFKA amended existing child nutrition programs to establish mandatory -funding of $5 million per year for competitive farm-to-school grants that support schools and -nonprofit entities in establishing farm-to-school programs that improve a school’s access to -locally produced foods.72 The FY2018 appropriations law provided an additional $5 million in -discretionary funding to remain available until expended.73 Grants may be used for training, -supporting operations, planning, purchasing equipment, developing school gardens, developing -partnerships, and implementing farm-to-school programs. USDA’s Office of Community Food -Systems provides additional resources on farm-to-school issues.74 - -Through an Administrative Review process (formerly referred to as Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE)), USDA-FNS, in cooperation with state agencies, conducts periodic on-site NSLP school -compliance and accountability evaluations to improve management and identify administrative, -subsidy claim, and meal quality problems.75 State agencies are required to conduct administrative -reviews of all school food authorities (SFAs) that operate the NSLP under their jurisdiction at -least once during a three-year review cycle.76 Federal Administrative Review expenditures were -approximately $9.9 million in FY2017. - -USDA-FNS and state agencies conduct many other child nutrition program support activities for -which dedicated funding is provided. Among other examples, there is the Institute of Child -Nutrition (ICN), which provides technical assistance, instruction, and materials related to -nutrition and food service management; it receives $5 million a year in mandatory funding -appropriated in statute. ICN is located at the University of Mississippi. USDA-FNS provides -training on food safety education. Funding is also provided for USDA-FNS to conduct studies, -provide training and technical assistance, and oversee payment accuracy. - -70 See USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/hussc/healthierus-school-challenge-smarter-lunchrooms. -71 USDA, The Farm to School Program—2012-2015: Four Years in Review, p. 3. https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/f2s/Farm-to-School-at-USDA—4-Years-in-Review.pdf. -72 HHFKA, Section 243 (Access to Local Foods: Farm to School Program), amending §18 of the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(j)). In addition, appropriations are authorized “such sums as are necessary -for each of fiscal years 2011 through 2015.” -73 See Section 763 of P.L. 115-141. -74 See USDA-FNS’s Office of Community Food Systems: http://www.fns.usda.gov/farmtoschool/farm-school. -75 Text in this paragraph is adapted from the USDA-FNS, National School Lunch Program: Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE), FNS-640 Data Report, January 2014. -76 HHFKA increased the frequency of administrative reviews from once every five years to once every three years. See -final rule at USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Administrative Reviews in the School Nutrition Programs,” 81 -Federal Register 50170, July 29, 2016. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -27 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Selected Current Issues -This section provides further information on current issues in the child nutrition programs. In -particular, it provides background on (1) USDA regulations updating various nutrition standards -in the child nutrition programs, (2) current and proposed alternatives to the “congregate feeding -requirement” in summer meals, and (3) recent changes and proposals aimed at addressing “lunch -shaming” and unpaid meal costs. - -Regulations on Nutrition Standards - -Since the enactment of the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296), -USDA-FNS has promulgated multiple regulations, formulated various program guidance, and -published many other policy documents and reports. Three of the major changes authorized by -the 2010 law relate to program nutrition standards: (1) requiring an update to the nutrition -standards for NSLP and SBP meals, (2) giving USDA the authority to regulate other foods sold in -schools (e.g., through vending machines and cafeterias’ a la carte lines) and requiring the agency -to issue related nutrition standards, and (3) requiring an update to the nutrition standards in -CACFP. The new nutrition standards were championed by First Lady Michelle Obama through -her “Let’s Move” initiative, among other groups.77 - -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast - -Section 201 of HHFKA (P.L. 111-296) established a timeframe for USDA to promulgate -regulations updating meal patterns and nutrition standards for school meal programs based on -recommendations from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) (now the Health and Medicine Division) -at the National Academy of Sciences.78 Schools meeting the new requirements are eligible for the -increased federal subsidies (6 cents per lunch) noted above. The law also provided funding for -technical assistance to help implement new meal patterns and nutrition standards. - -Ultimately, following a proposed rule, comments submitted, and policy provisions enacted in the -2012 appropriations law,79 USDA-FNS issued a final rule on January 26, 2012.80 The final rule -sought to align school meal patterns with the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and called -for increased availability of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat or fat-free milk in school -cafeterias—generally consistent with IOM’s recommendations. The regulations also included -calorie maximums (whereas prior guidelines had only calorie minimums) and sodium limits to -phase in over time, among other requirements.81 - -77 See, for example, Nia-Malika Henderson, “President Obama signs child nutrition bill, a priority for first lady,” -Washington Post, December 13, 2010, pp. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/13/ -AR2010121302407.html; archived White House website, “Let’s Move, Healthy Schools,” -https://letsmove.obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/healthy-schools. -78 The 2010 law added a deadline, but it was the 2004 reauthorization (P.L. 108-265) that required USDA to update the -standards based on National Academy of Sciences recommendations. IOM’s report, issued in 2010, had made a number -of recommendations around such topics as imposing calorie limits, increasing fruit and vegetables, and reducing -sodium intake. IOM, School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children, Washington, DC, 2010. -79 See Section 743 of P.L. 112-55. Also discussed in CRS Report R41964, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2012 -Appropriations, coordinated by Jim Monke. -80 For the final rule and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/nutrition- -standards-school-meals. -81 When originally issued, the rule and USDA-FNS policy also required certain weekly maximums on grains and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -28 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Although the rule was finalized in January 2012, all aspects of the rule were not to be -implemented immediately; for instance, some aspects of the new guidelines went into effect for -school year 2014-2015, even though the rule went into effect in school year 2012-2013.82 Three -aspects of the new regulations that went into effect in SY2014-2015 were: all grains served must -be whole-grain-rich,83 new fruit requirements for breakfast, and the first of three sodium limits or -“targets” for breakfasts and lunches (referred to as “Target 1”).84 - -As some schools have had difficulty implementing the new guidelines, Congress and the USDA -have implemented some changes or waivers regarding the 2012 final rule’s whole grain, sodium, -and milk requirements. FY2015, FY2016, and FY2017 appropriations laws (P.L. 113-235, P.L. -114-113, P.L. 115-31, respectively) included policies that affect the implementation of the -guidelines. As of the date of this report, schools are following policies set in an interim final rule -published November 30, 2017.85 - -Specifically, FY2015 and FY2016 appropriations laws (1) required USDA to allow states to -exempt school food authorities that meet hardship requirements from the 100% whole grain -requirement86 and (2) prevented USDA from implementing a reduction in sodium scheduled to -take effect in school year 2017-2018 until “the latest scientific research establishes the reduction -is beneficial for children.” The enacted FY2017 appropriation (§747 of P.L. 115-31) contained -related policy provisions. It extended the whole grain exemptions through SY2017-2018 and -(using different language from past years) limited enforcement of sodium limits to Target 1 -levels. In addition, a new appropriations provision was added in the FY2017 law that required -USDA to allow states to grant special exemptions to serve flavored, low-fat milk (instead of only -fat-free, flavored). - -In May 2017, shortly before the enactment of the FY2017 appropriations law (P.L. 115-31), -Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue announced plans to amend the whole grain, sodium, and -dairy aspects of the nutrition standards regulations in ways that were similar to the FY2017 law’s -provisions.87 In November 2017, USDA-FNS issued the interim final rule, which generally -extends through SY2018-2019 the three changes established by FY2017 appropriations. -Specifically, the interim final rule - -protein. School nutrition stakeholders expressed challenges with menu planning due to these particular restrictions, -USDA-FNS issued policy guidance that gave flexibility on these maximums for school years 2012-2013 and 2013- -2014. Then, in a subsequent regulation, USDA-FNS revised the regulations in January 2014 to lift these restrictions. -See, for example, USDA-FNS, “Certification of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch -Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. -82 See USDA-FNS Implementation Timeline, http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/implementation_timeline.pdf, -based on regulations. -83 “Whole grain-rich products must contain at least 51 percent whole grains and the remaining grains in the product -must be enriched.” 7 C.F.R. 210.10(c)(2)(iv). -84 The sodium targets set a maximum weekly level of sodium for breakfasts and lunches based on a student’s grade -level. Under Target 1, school lunches—on average over the school week—must contain ≤1,230 milligrams (mg) of -sodium for grades K-5, ≤1,360 mg for grades 6-8, and ≤1,420 mg for grades 9-12. -85 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, https://www.federalregister.gov/ -documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk-whole-grains-and-sodium- -requirements. -86 Exempted schools are to maintain a 50% whole grain minimum, the requirement before school year 2014-2015. -87 See CRS Insight IN10700, USDA Announces Plans to Modify School Meal Nutrition Standards: Background and -Context (available to congressional clients upon request). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -29 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - - - - - -continues to allow states to grant waivers to the whole grain-rich requirement; -allows schools to offer low-fat, flavored milk; and -continues Target 1 sodium limits, delaying implementation of Target 2 sodium -limits.88 - -The interim final rule indicated that USDA-FNS would publish a final rule in fall 2018, in time -for schools to implement in SY2019-2020. As of the date of this report, this final rule has not -been published. The FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141), enacted in March 2018, did not -make any changes to the standards. - -There were legislative proposals to change the nutrition standards on a more-permanent basis -during 114th Congress deliberations to reauthorize the child nutrition programs.89 As discussed -earlier, reauthorization was not completed in the 114th Congress and authorizing committees have -not considered such legislative proposals in the 115th Congress. - -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools - -In another major policy change, Section 208 of HHFKA gave USDA the authority to regulate -other foods in the school nutrition environment. Sometimes called “competitive foods,” this and -the related regulation pertain to foods and drinks sold in a la carte lines, vending machines, snack -bars and concession stands, and fundraisers. - -Relying on recommendations made by a 2007 IOM report,90 USDA-FNS promulgated a proposed -rule and then an interim final rule in June 2013, which went into effect for school year 2014- -2015.91 The interim final rule imposed nutrition guidelines for all non-meal foods and beverages -that are sold during the school day (defined as midnight until 30 minutes after dismissal). The -final rule, published on July 29, 2016, maintained the interim final rules with minor -modifications. Under the final standards, these foods must meet whole-grain requirements; have -certain primary ingredients; and meet calorie, sodium, and fat limits, among other requirements. -Schools are limited to a list of no- and low-calorie beverages they may sell (with larger portion -sizes and caffeine allowed in high schools). - -Regarding fundraisers, there are no limits on fundraisers of foods that meet the interim final rule’s -guidelines. Fundraisers outside of the school day are not subject to the guidelines. HHFKA and -the interim final rule provide states with discretion to exempt infrequent fundraisers of foods or -beverages that do not meet the nutrition standards. - -The rule does not limit foods brought from home, only foods sold at school during the school day. -The federal standards included are a minimum standard; states and school districts are permitted -to issue more stringent policies. - -88 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, available at -https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk- -whole-grains-and-sodium-requirements. -89 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. -90 IOM, Nutrition Standards for Foods in Schools: Leading the Way toward Healthier Youth, 2007, -https://www.nap.edu/catalog/11899/nutrition-standards-for-foods-in-schools-leading-the-way-toward. -91 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Nutrition -Standards for All Foods Sold in School as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule,” 81 -Federal Register 50131, July 29, 2016. Final rule and related resources available at USDA-FNS website at -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/tools-schools-focusing-smart-snacks. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -30 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP - -Similarly, Section 221 of HHFKA required USDA to update the meal pattern for CACFP. USDA- -FNS’s proposed rule, published January 15, 2015, relied upon an IOM panel’s recommendations -and the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.92 FNS reviewed comments and incorporated -feedback in the final rule, which was published on April 25, 2016.93 The updated meal patterns -went into effect on October 1, 2017. The rule changes both the infant meal pattern and child/adult -meal pattern in CACFP. It also revises the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and School -Breakfast Program (SBP) meal patterns for pre-kindergarten children (such changes were not -included in the January 2012 final regulation discussed earlier). - -Below are some examples of changes included in the final rule:94 - - For infant meals, changes include condensing the previously three infant age - - - -groups into two age groups, introducing solid foods at six months of age (unless -otherwise requested by a parent or guardian), providing fruits and vegetables for -older infants, and eliminating juice. The updated guidelines make policy changes -to support breastfeeding, including providing program reimbursements when -mothers come to child care centers or homes to breastfeed their infants. -In child and adult meals, changes include separate fruit and vegetable serving -requirements, as opposed to treating fruits and vegetables as one group, and -limiting juice to one serving per day. The rule also requires that at least one daily -serving of grains be whole-grain rich and limits the sugar in breakfast cereals and -yogurts served. Milk must be low-fat or fat-free, and flavored milk cannot be -served to children age five or younger. The updated standards also disallow -frying as an onsite preparation method. - - “Best practices” for the different age groups were included in the rule, not as -requirements for reimbursement but as examples of ideal policies to promote -good nutrition and health. Examples include the “best practice” that a center or -home provides mothers with a quiet, private area to breastfeed and the -recommendation to limit sugar in flavored milk served to children age six and -older. USDA-FNS subsequently elaborated on the best practices through policy -guidance.95 - -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals -In recent years, but particularly during the 114th Congress, policymakers have weighed policy -options to reach more children in the summer months using alternatives to congregate meal -service. - -92 Ibid. at 2037. IOM (Institute of Medicine), Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary Guidance for All. -Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2011. -93 USDA-FNS also notes that it thoroughly reviewed the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines, and determined that the final -rule, based on the 2010 guidelines, is consistent with the updated guidelines. USDA-FNS, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Meal Pattern Revisions Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule” 81 Federal -Register 24348 et seq., April 25, 2016, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/04/25/2016-09412/child-and- -adult-care-food-program-meal-pattern-revisions-related-to-the-healthy-hunger-free-kids-act. -94 Ibid. For summaries of updated meal patterns and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/meals-and-snacks. -95 USDA-FNS, “Optional Best Practices to Further Improve Nutrition in the Child and Adult Care Food Program Meal -Pattern,” June 30, 2016, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cacfp/CACFP15-2016os.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -31 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Current Law and Policy - -Under current law, most food offered in summer months is provided in congregate settings -through the SFSP or the NSLP’s Seamless Summer Option (SSO, an option only for schools) (see -“Summer Meals” section above). “Congregate” settings refer to specific sites where children -come to eat while supervised. Also, for the most part, non-school organizations that provide -summer and afterschool food need to participate in two separate programs (SFSP and CACFP At- -risk Afterschool). - -As discussed earlier, on a pilot basis in a limited geographic area each summer since 2011, USDA -has tested alternatives to SFSP and the SSO as required by law. Specifically, the 2010 Agriculture -Appropriations Act (Section 749(g) of P.L. 111-80) provided $85 million in discretionary funding -for “demonstration projects to develop and test methods of providing access to food for children -in urban and rural areas during the summer months.” The first of those demonstrations was called -the Enhanced Summer Food Service Program (eSFSP), which took place in the summers of 2010 -and 2012. eSFSP included four initiatives: (1) incentives for SFSP sites to lengthen operations to -40 or more days, (2) funding to add recreational or educational activities at meal sites, (3) meal -delivery for children in rural areas, and (4) “food backpacks” that children could take home on -weekends and holidays. - -Evaluations of eSFSP were published from 2011 to 2014.96 Participation rates rose during the -demonstration periods for all four initiatives. In addition, children in the meal delivery and -backpack demonstrations had consistent rates of food insecurity from summer to fall (this was not -measured for the other initiatives). However, the results of the evaluation should be interpreted -with caution due to a small sample size and potential confounding factors. - -As discussed earlier, the second demonstration, Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children -(SEBTC or Summer EBT), began in summer 2011 and is ongoing as of the date of this report; -this program provides SNAP or WIC benefits over EBT to households with children eligible for -free or reduced-price school meals. Most recently, FY2018 appropriations (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million for the demonstration. Evaluations of Summer EBT were conducted over a -three-year period from FY2011 to FY2013.97 The evaluations, which used rigorous designs, -showed a significant decline in Very Low Food Security in children (VLFS-C);98 the prevalence -of VLFS-C was reduced from 9.5% in the control group to 6.4% in the Summer EBT treatment -group.99 Evaluations also found improvements in children’s consumption of fruits, vegetables, - -96 Elinson et al., Evaluation of 2011 Enhanced Summer Food Service Program Demonstrations, prepared by Westat -under Contract No. GS-23F-8144H (Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2012), p. 4-21. -97 The first year, the proof-of-concept (POC) year, was evaluated to test the feasibility of the EBT delivery system and -prepare for full-implementation in demonstration sites for the following year. The second year, the full implementation -year, evaluated the impact of SEBTC on improving children’s food security and nutritional status in the summer time. -Finally, the third year compared the impact of two benefit levels, $60 and $30, to determine the effect of different -benefit levels on improving food security and nutritional status. Final reports and status reports to Congress are -available on the USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/summer-electronic-benefit-transfer-children-sebtc. -98 Very Low Food Security is the lowest of four levels of food security; USDA defines it as “At times during the year, -eating patterns of one or more household members were disrupted and food intake reduced because the household -lacked money and other resources for food.” USDA-ERS website, http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition- -assistance/food-security-in-the-us/measurement.aspx. See also CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: -Summary of Programs. -99 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus. Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013, p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -32 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -and whole grains. Both WIC and SNAP models showed increased consumption, but increases -were greater at sites operating the WIC model.100 - -In the summers from 2015 to 2018, USDA-FNS also offered non-congregate feeding options at -outdoor summer meal sites experiencing excessive heat.101 This demonstration has not been -evaluated. - -Congressional Proposals - -During the 114th Congress, committees of jurisdiction marked up child nutrition reauthorization -bills. Both committees of jurisdiction—the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and -Forestry and the House Committee on Education and the Workforce—reported reauthorization -legislation: S. 3136 and H.R. 5003, respectively. Both proposals would have piloted or expanded -a number of alternatives for feeding low-income children during the summer months. Still, there -were significant differences between the reauthorization proposals’ SFSP provisions.102 (There -were also committee hearings and freestanding proposals related to SFSP in the 114th -Congress.)103 - -The committees’ reauthorization bills included the following policies: - - Streamlining afterschool and summer programs. Both committees’ proposals -would have authorized eligible institutions in selected states to operate SFSP and -CACFP At-risk Afterschool sites under one application. The bills differed in the -number of states that would have been eligible and the reimbursement rates used. - - Summer EBT. Both proposals addressed the provision of benefits via EBT to -children who are eligible for free and reduced-price school meals over the -summer months. The Senate committee would have expanded this alternative -with mandatory funding. The House committee would have kept the existing -pilot funded with discretionary funding. The Senate committee would have -required states to provide WIC EBT, while the House committee would have -allowed participating states to provide SNAP or WIC. - - Off-Site Consumption Options. Both proposals included ways for some - -institutions (e.g., those located in rural areas) to provide SFSP meals for -consumption off-site. The bills also included temporary flexibilities for -congregate feeding sites to episodically provide meals to be consumed off-site -under certain conditions (e.g., extreme weather conditions). - - Other SFSP Policies. The Senate committee’s bill would have authorized - -discretionary funding for some states to pilot the provision of three meals per -day, or two meals and one snack. The House committee’s proposal would have - -100 Ibid., p. 124. -101 See USDA-FNS, “Demonstration Project for Non-Congregate Feeding for Outdoor Summer Meal Sites -Experiencing Excessive Heat with Q&As,” May 24, 2018, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/sfsp/ -SP14_SFSP04-2018os.pdf. -102 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview, for further legislative -background and a more detailed summary of summer meals and other program provisions. -103 During 114th Congress hearings, witnesses testified about SFSP and summer alternatives before the House -Committee on Education and the Workforce (April 15, 2015; June 16, 2015; June 24, 2015) and the Senate Committee -on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry (May 7, 2015). During the 114th Congress, introduced bills on summer meals -included S. 613/H.R. 1728, S. 1539/H.R. 2715, and S. 1966. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -33 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -authorized USDA to award competitive grants to improve SFSP service delivery -through business partnerships. - -These reauthorization bills have not been reintroduced in the 115th Congress; however, there have -been other legislative proposals in the 115th Congress to amend SFSP.104 - -Presidential Budget Proposals - -The Obama Administration’s FY2017 budget proposed a number of changes to SFSP. -Specifically, the administration proposed to expand Summer EBT nationwide, with a phase-in -over 10 years.105 The administration also requested $10 million for a new Summer Food Service -Non-Congregate Demonstration Project. - -The Trump Administration’s FY2018 and FY2019 budgets did not include any new SFSP -legislative proposals. The budgets requested continued funding for Summer EBT. - -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” - -The issue of stigmatizing a child who owes and does not pay his or her meal costs, commonly -referred to as “lunch shaming,” has received increased attention in recent years.106 Some practices -that school districts have adopted in response to such situations include taking or throwing away a -student’s selected hot foods and providing an alternative cold meal (more common) to stamping -students’ arms and making them wear stickers (less common).107 One reason why these instances -may occur is that payments for reduced-price and full-price meals are a source of revenue for -school food programs (in addition to federal NSLP and SBP reimbursements). Schools have an -interest in collecting this revenue from children’s families to help fund operations.108 - -Some have pointed out that the Community Eligibility Provision (discussed earlier in this report) -is a strategy to prevent unpaid meal charges by providing free meals to all children in qualifying -schools.109 - -Congress and USDA have taken some recent actions to address the issues of lunch shaming and -unpaid meal costs. Section 143 of the HHFKA of 2010 required USDA to examine states’ and - -104 See, for example, the Summer Meals Act of 2017 (H.R. 203) and legislation “To amend the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act to establish a permanent, nationwide summer electronic benefits transfer for children -program” (H.R. 6516S. 3268). -105 Details about the Obama Administration’s Nationwide Summer EBT proposal are available in the FY2017 budget -USDA-FNS Explanatory Notes on p. 32-34, http://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2017notes.pdf. -106 There is no official definition of “lunch shaming.” Legislation in the 115th Congress, the Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017 (H.R. 2401/S. 1064), refers to lunch shaming as “the stigmatization of children who are unable to pay for -meals.” -107 Typically, an alternative meal includes unflavored milk, a cheese or peanut butter-and-jelly sandwich, and a fruit or -vegetable. May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and -Practices for School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12. Prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10- -0048. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014, p. 147-148. -108 If they are unable to recover these funds, the money becomes “bad debt” and the school or school district must use -other non-federal funding sources to cover the costs (7 C.F.R. 200.426). See p. 2 of USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, -“Unpaid Meal Charges: Clarification on Collection of Delinquent Meal Payments,” July 8, 2016, at https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP47-2016os.pdf. -109 See, for example, James Weill, “How to stop school lunch shaming? Leave kids out of it,” The Hill, at -http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/education/333003-how-to-stop-school-lunch-shaming-leave-kids-out-of-it; U.S. -Department of Agriculture, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate -Meals, June 2016, at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -34 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -school districts’ policies and practices regarding unpaid meal charges. As part of the review, the -law required USDA to “prepare a report on the feasibility of establishing national standards for -meal charges and the provision of alternate meals” and, if relevant, make recommendations -related to the implementation of the standards. Section 143 also permitted USDA to take follow- -up actions based on the findings from the report.110 - -USDA’s subsequent June 2016 Report to Congress did not recommend national standards, but -rather recommended “clarifying and updating policy guidance on specific national policies -impacting unpaid meal charges and facilitating the development and distribution of best practices -to support decision making by States and localities.”111 USDA-FNS followed up with a -memorandum requiring school food authorities (SFAs) to institute and communicate—by July 1, -2017—a written meal charge policy, which was to include instructions on how to address -situations in which a child does not pay for a meal.112 USDA-FNS also provided clarification -through webinars, other memoranda, and a best practice guide.113 - -USDA stated that its recommendation was based on findings from a national study of HHFKA -implementation and a Request for Information (RFI) related to unpaid meal charges that garnered -462 responses. The study, conducted in SY2011-2012, found that 58% of SFAs reported incurring -unpaid meal charges prior to recovery attempts.114 Of these SFAs, 50.4% served a reimbursable -meal to children unable to pay, 38.0% served an alternative meal, 5.4% combined these -approaches, 4.9% did something else (“Other”), and 1.3% did not serve a meal. Both the findings -from the study and the RFI showed that meal charge policies were largely determined at the -school- and district-level rather than the state level.115 The responses to the RFI also indicated that -such policies ranged in formality, with varying degrees of review (e.g., some required school -board approval while others did not) and enforcement. In the RFI comments, school and district -officials generally expressed a preference for local control in designing meal charge policies -while advocates generally favored national standards. - -The topics of lunch shaming and unpaid meal costs have since surfaced in the 115th Congress. As -examples of congressional activity on this issue, proposed legislation (Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017; H.R. 2401/S. 1064) would establish national standards for how schools treat children -unable to pay for a meal.116 - -110 Specifically, Section 143 of HHFKA authorizes USDA to (1) implement standards;, (2) implement demonstration -projects, or (3) further study the feasibility of the recommendations. -111 USDA, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate Meals, June -2016, p. 5, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. -112 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges: Local Meal Charge Policies,” July 8, 2016, https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP46-2016os.pdf. -113 For a list of resources, see USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges,” https://www.fns.usda.gov/ -school-meals/unpaid-meal-charges. -114 May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and Practices for -School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12, prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10-0048 -(Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014), p. 147-148, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/SNOPSYear1.pdf. -115 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Request for Information: Unpaid Meal Charges,” 79 Federal Register 62095, -October 16, 2014. -116 Specifically, the legislation would prohibit SFAs from (1) publicly identifying children who cannot pay for a meal -or those who have meal debt, (2) having those children perform chores or other activities, and (3) throwing away a -child’s meal. See Section 2 of H.R. 2401 and S. 1064 (identical text). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -35 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In addition, a provision in the FY2018 appropriations law (Section 768 of P.L. 115-141) -established that appropriated funds cannot be used in a way that results in discrimination against -children eligible for free or reduced-price meals, including the practices of segregating children -and overtly identifying children by special tokens or tickets.117 - -117 See Section 9(b)(10) of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(10)) and 7 C.F.R. -245.8. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -36 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report - -Table A-1. Acronyms - -Government Agencies - -USDA - -U.S. Department of Agriculture - -USDA-FNS - -Food and Nutrition Service - -CACFP - -FFVP - -NSLP - -SBP - -SEBTC - -SFSP - -SMP - -CEP - -CPI-U - -FPL - -Programs - -Child and Adult Care Food Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program - -National School Lunch Program - -School Breakfast Program - -Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children - -Summer Food Service Program - -Special Milk Program - -Miscellaneous - -Community Eligibility Provision - -Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers - -Federal Poverty Level - -HHFKA - -Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-296) - -IOM - -LEA - -RCCI - -SFA - -Institute of Medicine - -Local Educational Agency - -Residential Child Care Institution - -School Food Authority - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -37 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement -Rates for Child Nutrition Programs118 -This appendix lists the specific reimbursement rates discussed in the earlier sections of the report. -Reimbursement rates are adjusted for inflation for each school or calendar year according to -terms laid out in the programs’ authorizing laws. Each year, the new rates are announced in the -Federal Register.119 - -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches -Per-meal reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Serve Less than 60% of -Lunches as Free and -Reduced-Price - -Serve 60% or More of -Lunches as Free or -Reduced-Price - -Bonus Available for -School Districts -Certified as Compliant -with Nutrition -Guidelines - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$3.33 - -$2.93 - -$0.33 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Source: USDA-FNS, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018-15465/national-school-lunch- -special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum. For NSLP reimbursement rates -for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -Note: For school year 2018-2019, the maximum rate for 48 states and DC is $3.48 per free meal, $3.08 per -reduced-price meal, and $0.30 per paid meal (and an additional $0.06 for nutrition guidelines). The maximum -rate is the maximum per-lunch rate that a state can provide a school food authority. - -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks -Per-snack reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Snack Type - -Reimbursement - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For after-school snack NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or -participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -118 All reimbursement rate tables in this Appendix display rates for the 48 continental U.S. states. For Alaska, Hawaii, -and territories where applicable, please see the source USDA-FNS Federal Register notice. -119 For more detail on how inflation adjustment is conducted, see the child nutrition program sections of CRS Report -R42000, Inflation-Indexing Elements in Federal Entitlement Programs, coordinated by Dawn Nuschler. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -38 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP -Per-meal reimbursement for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Non-severe Need -(less than 40% free or -reduced price)a - -Severe Need -(greater than or equal to 40% -free or reduced price)a - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -$2.14 - -$1.84 - -$0.31 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating -territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -a. Generally, severe need status is determined based on the percentage of meals served two school years -prior to the year the currently reimbursed meal is served. For example, a school district’s severe need -status in school year 2018-2019 would be calculated based on meals served in school year 2016-2017. - -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) -Rate per-meal for school year 2018-2019 - -For Each NSLP/CACFP Meal Served - -Commodity Food Reimbursement - -$0.2350 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Food Distribution Program: Value of Donated Foods From July 1, -2018, Through June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 35607, July 1, 2018. -Notes: For past years, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/value-donated-foods-notices. SFSP -has a different commodity food assistance rate, see Table B-7. - -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School -Programs -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -Snack - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Notes: These reimbursement rates are identical to NSLP and SBP rates. - -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Tier I - -Tier II - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -$2.46 - -$1.48 - -$1.31 - -$0.48 - -Snack - -$0.73 - -$0.20 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Note: CACFP also provides administrative reimbursements to sponsoring organizations of day care homes. -Based on the number of homes sponsored, funding is provided per home, per month. These rates are not - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -39 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -displayed in this table but are included in USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: National Average Payment Rates, Day Care Home Food Service Payment Rates, and Administrative -Reimbursement Rates for Sponsoring Organizations of Day Care Homes for the Period July 1, 2018 Through -June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 34108, July 1, 2018. - -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 states and DC (rounded to nearest cent), calendar year 2018 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Snack - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -$3.55 - -$3.55 - -$2.03 - -$2.03 - -$0.83 - -$0.83 - -$0.37 - -$0.31 - -$0.20 - -$0.16 - -$0.10 - -$0.08 - -$3.92 - -$3.86 - -$2.23 - -$2.19 - -$0.93 - -$0.91 - -Operating -Component - -Administrative -Component - -Combined (Total) -Rate - -Source: For program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, “Summer Food Service Program; 2018 Reimbursement Rates,” 83 Federal Register 4025, -January 29, 2018. -Note: Per authorizing law, the administrative component is calculated to the nearest quarter-cent. This table -rounds to the nearest cent. As the table shows, the administrative component varies slightly (e.g., by about 5 -cents for lunches) depending on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared -on-site or by a vendor. For meals prepared on-site, providers receive 1.5 cents per meal in USDA commodity -foods. - -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP -Per half-pint reimbursement for 48 States and DC (rounded to nearest cent), school year 2018-2019 - -All Milk Served - -Paid Milk - -Free Milk to Low- -Income Children - -Schools that only -sell milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Schools that sell -and provide free -milk - -Schools that -provide only free -milk - -Not applicable - -$0.21 - -Average cost per -half-pint of milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Source: For program reimbursement rates, see https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -40 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Author Information - -Kara Clifford Billings -Analyst in Social Policy - - Randy Alison Aussenberg - -Specialist in Nutrition Assistance Policy - -Acknowledgments - -Disclaimer - -This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan -shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and -under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other -than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in -connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not -subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in -its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or -material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to -copy or otherwise use copyrighted material. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -41 - +Launch Dates of Primary Nintendo Products by Region (Apr. 2019〜Mar. 2020) +Nintendo Switch +| | Japan | | | The United States | | | Europe | | +| ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | +| Title | | Launch Date | Title | | Launch Date | Title | | Launch Date | +| (Hardware) | | | (Hardware) | | | (Hardware) | | | +Nintendo Switch Lite 9/20/2019 Nintendo Switch Lite 9/20/2019 Nintendo Switch Lite 9/20/2019 +| (Software) | | | (Software) | | | (Software) | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | +Nintendo Labo Toy-Con 04: VR Kit 4/12/2019 Nintendo Labo Toy-Con 04: VR Kit 4/12/2019 Nintendo Labo Toy-Con 04: VR Kit 4/12/2019 +Super Mario Maker 2 6/28/2019 Super Mario Maker 2 6/28/2019 Super Mario Maker 2 6/28/2019 +MARVEL ULTIMATE ALLIANCE 3: The Black Order 7/19/2019 DRAGON QUEST BUILDERS 2 * 7/12/2019 DRAGON QUEST BUILDERS 2 * 7/12/2019 +Fire Emblem: Three Houses 7/26/2019 MARVEL ULTIMATE ALLIANCE 3: The Black Order 7/19/2019 MARVEL ULTIMATE ALLIANCE 3: The Black Order 7/19/2019 +TETRIS 99 8/9/2019 Fire Emblem: Three Houses 7/26/2019 Fire Emblem: Three Houses 7/26/2019 +ASTRAL CHAIN 8/30/2019 ASTRAL CHAIN 8/30/2019 ASTRAL CHAIN 8/30/2019 +The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening 9/20/2019 TETRIS 99 9/6/2019 DAEMON X MACHINA * 9/13/2019 +Ring Fit Adventure 10/18/2019 DAEMON X MACHINA * 9/13/2019 The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening 9/20/2019 +Luigiʼs Mansion 3 10/31/2019 The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening 9/20/2019 TETRIS 99 9/20/2019 +Pokémon Sword 11/15/2019 DRAGON QUEST XI S: DRAGON QUEST XI S: +| | | | | | 9/27/2019 | | | 9/27/2019 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --------- | +Pokémon Shield 11/15/2019 Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive Edition * Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive Edition * +Dr Kawashima's Brain Training for Nintendo Switch 12/27/2019 Ring Fit Adventure 10/18/2019 Ring Fit Adventure 10/18/2019 +Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Encore 1/17/2020 Luigiʼs Mansion 3 10/31/2019 Luigiʼs Mansion 3 10/31/2019 +Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX 3/6/2020 Pokémon Sword 11/15/2019 Pokémon Sword 11/15/2019 +Animal Crossing: New Horizons 3/20/2020 Pokémon Shield 11/15/2019 Pokémon Shield 11/15/2019 +| | | | Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Encore | | 1/17/2020 | Dr Kawashima's Brain Training for Nintendo Switch | | 1/3/2020 | +| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX | | 3/6/2020 | Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Encore | | 1/17/2020 | +| | | | Animal Crossing: New Horizons | | 3/20/2020 | Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX | | 3/6/2020 | +| | | | | | | Animal Crossing: New Horizons | | 3/20/2020 | +[Note] Launch dates may differ within the United States and Europe regions depending on territories or countries. +*This title is licensed to be sold as a Nintendo product. +Launch Schedule of Primary Nintendo Products by Region (extracts: Apr. 2020〜) +Nintendo Switch +| | Japan | | | The United States | | | Europe | | +| ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | +| Title | | Launch Date | Title | | Launch Date | Title | | Launch Date | +| (Software) | | | (Software) | | | (Software) | | | +Xenoblade Chronicles Definitive Edition 5/29/2020 Xenoblade Chronicles Definitive Edition 5/29/2020 Xenoblade Chronicles Definitive Edition 5/29/2020 +Clubhouse Games: 51 Worldwide Classics 6/5/2020 Clubhouse Games: 51 Worldwide Classics 6/5/2020 51 Worldwide Games 6/5/2020 +Famicom Tantei Club: Kieta Koukeisha 2020 BRAVELY DEFAULT II *  2020 BRAVELY DEFAULT II *  2020 +Famicom Tantei Club: Ushiro ni Tatsu Shoujo 2020 Bayonetta 3 TBA Bayonetta 3 TBA +Bayonetta 3 TBA Metroid Prime 4 (temp.) TBA Metroid Prime 4 (temp.) TBA +Metroid Prime 4 (temp.) TBA The sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (temp.) TBA The sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (temp.) TBA +| The sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (temp.) | | TBA | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +[Note] Launch dates and titles etc. are subject to change. +Launch dates may differ within the United States and Europe regions depending on territories or countries. +*This title is licensed to be sold as a Nintendo product. +Upcoming Software Publishers' Title Lineup (extracts: Apr. 2020〜) +Nintendo Switch +| | Japan | | | The United States | | | Europe | | +| ----- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | +| Title | | Publisher | Title | | Publisher | Title | | Publisher | +KOWLOON YOHMA GAKUENKI: ORIGIN OF ADVENTURE ARC SYSTEM WORKS Borderlands Legendary Collection 2K Borderlands Legendary Collection 2K +Catherine: Full Body for Nintendo Switch ATLUS Bioshock: The Collection 2K Bioshock: The Collection 2K +Kotoba no Puzzle: Mojipittan Encore BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment XCOM 2 Collection 2K XCOM 2 Collection 2K +NAMCOT COLLECTION BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment Levelhead Butterscotch Shenanigans SuperMash Digital Continue +Mr. DRILLER DrillLand BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment SuperMash Digital Continue Streets of Rage 4 Dotemu +Utano Prince Sama Streets of Rage 4 Dotemu Burnout Paradise Remastered Electronic Arts +BROCCOLI +Amazing Aria & Sweet Serenade LOVE for Nintendo Switch Burnout Paradise Remastered Electronic Arts Ninjala GungHo Online Entertainment +BRIGANDINE The Legend of Runersia HAPPINET Ninjala GungHo Online Entertainment Minecraft Dungeons Mojang Synergies / Xbox Game Studios +Hakuoki Shinkai Ginseinosho IDEA FACTORY Minecraft Dungeons Mojang Synergies / Xbox Game Studios The Outer Worlds Private Division +Harukanaru Toki no Naka de 7 KOEI TECMO GAMES The Outer Worlds Private Division Trials of Mana Square Enix +FAIRY TAIL KOEI TECMO GAMES Trials of Mana Square Enix Moving Out Team17 +eBASEBALL PAWAFURU PUROYAKYU 2020 KONAMI Moving Out Team17 NARUTO SHIPPUDEN: Ultimate Ninja STORM 4 ROAD TO BORUTO Bandai Namco Entertainment +| Rodents 2 | | NIPPON COLUMBIA | | | | Ghost of a Tale | | Plug In Digital | +| --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | +Zumba Burn It Up! SEGA The Elder Scrolls: Blades Bethesda Softworks +Trials of Mana SQUARE ENIX Railway Empire - Nintendo Switch Edition Kalypso Media Group +| SYNAPTIC DRIVE | | Yunuo International | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +[Note] Launch schedules, software names etc. are subject to change. +Launch titles are listed by publisher alphabetically. +This list includes titles that are released as download-only software. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q254/random_k2/question.json b/q254/random_k2/question.json index 36e5f7900a74c2122cd39ef1cd5543797f703ccf..0b42aa16e53bc166f791e2a7f57cd0a27052df8e 100644 --- a/q254/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q254/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ADOBE_2015_10K.pdf", - "0a89b981c2736e87bac48a090e1a3e60dd8a4e0f.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf" + "sheet_q0_pew_archived.pdf", + "web_f5c6c7f633f7f239.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q254/random_k2/random_1.md b/q254/random_k2/random_1.md index 16de3e3316b1e3bb316b878e17b05640d996b000..9688678899fe06a07991c950d5781380310ca4e6 100644 --- a/q254/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q254/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1070 +1,622 @@ -SPD-RAG: Sub-Agent Per Document Retrieval-Augmented Generation -| | YagizCanAkay1 | | | MuhammedYusufKartal1 | | | EsraAlparslan1 | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | FarukOrtakoyluoglu1 | | ArdaAkpinar2 | | | | | | | -1TOBBUniversityofEconomicsandTechnology 2OSTIMTechnicalUniversity -{y.akay, m.kartal, ealparslan, fortakoyluoglu}@etu.edu.tr 230206003@ostimteknik.edu.tr -| | | Abstract | | | andcommon,yetexposecriticalcoverageandrea- | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -soningbottlenecksincurrentNLPsystems. -Answeringcomplex,real-worldqueriesoften -6202 raM 9 ]LC.sc[ 1v92380.3062:viXra Traditionalsingle-indexorsingle-agentretrieval -requiressynthesizingfactsscatteredacrossvast -| | | | | | systemsstruggleto | | maintainbothscalability | | | | and | -| -------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | corpora. | In these | settings, | stan- | | | | | | | | -contextualrelevanceoverlarge,heterogeneouscor- -| dard retrieval-augmented | | | generation | (RAG) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | pora, especially | | for long | or structurally | | complex | | -pipelinessufferfromincompleteevidencecov- -erage,whilelong-contextlargelanguagemod- documents. Standard RAG pipelines retrieve a -| | | | | | fixed number | | of documents | K | and process | | them | -| ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -| els (LLMs) | struggle | to reason | reliably | over | | | | | | | | -massive inputs. We introduce SPD-RAG, a withinasinglecontextwindow(Lewisetal.,2020), -hierarchicalmulti-agentframeworkforexhaus- -whichfailswhenanswersdependoninformation -tivecross-documentquestionansweringthatde- -distributedacrossmanydocuments,sinceevidence -composestheproblemalongthedocumentaxis. -| | | | | | beyondthetop-K | | resultsistypicallydiscardedin | | | | | -| ---- | -------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ----------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --- | -| Each | document | is processed | by a | dedicated | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | a single | retrieval | pass. | Long-context | | LLMs | ex- | -document-levelagentoperatingonlyonitsown -content,enablingfocusedretrieval,whileaco- tendcontextwindowsto128K–2Mtokens(Gemini -| | | | | | Teametal.,2024), | | butempiricalevidenceshows | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ordinator | dispatches | tasks | to relevant | agents | | | | | | | | -and aggregates their partial answers. Agent thatreasoningqualitydegradessignificantlyascon- -outputsaresynthesizedbymergingpartialan- text length increases (Liu et al., 2023). This sug- -swersthroughatoken-boundedsynthesislayer -| | | | | | gests that | the | bottleneck | is not | only | retrieval, | but | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | -(whichsupportsrecursivemap-reduceformas- -alsoreasoningatscaleovermanydocumentsand -| sivecorpora). | | Thisdocument-levelspecializa- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -hundredsofthousandsoftokens. -tionwithcentralizedfusionimprovesscalabil- -ityandanswerqualityinheterogeneousmulti- In this work, we introduce SPD-RAG -| | | | | | (Sub-agent | per | Document | Retrieval-Augmented | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | settings | while | yielding | a modular, | | | | | | | | -extensibleretrievalpipeline. OntheLOONG Generation),ahierarchicalmulti-agentarchitecture -benchmark (EMNLP 2024) for long-context forexhaustivemulti-documentquestionanswering -multi-document QA, SPD-RAG achieves an thatfactorstheproblemalongthedocumentaxis -AvgScoreof58.1(GPT-5evaluation),outper- -| | | | | | rather than | the | task axis. | Instead | | of forcing | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -formingNormalRAG(33.0)andAgenticRAG -| | | | | | single model | | to hunt through | | a massive | | global | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -(32.8)whileusingonly38%oftheAPIcostof -| | | | | | index, SPD-RAG | | uses | a central | coordinator | | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -afull-contextbaseline(68.0). -| | | | | | decompose | the | user’s | query into | shared | instruc- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -1 Introduction tions. It then deploys a dedicated, cost-efficient -| | | | | | sub-agenttoeachdocumentinthecorpus. | | | | | | These | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -Large language models (LLMs) and the agentic agents operate entirely in parallel, treating their -systems built around them are increasingly used assigneddocumentsasisolatedretrievaluniverses -forcomplexinformationsearchtasks(Guoetal., -| | | | | | to extract | relevant | findings. | Finally, | | a synthesis | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -2024). Real-worldquestionsoftenrequiresynthe- -| | | | | | model | aggregates | these | document-grounded | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -sizingevidencescatteredacrossmanydocuments, findings—employingarecursivemergingfallback -suchasassessingacompany’sfinancialrisksacross -| | | | | | for exceptionally | | large | corpora—to | | construct | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | -yearsofreportsorintegratingfindingsfrommul- -| | | | | | comprehensive, | | final answer. | | Our codebase | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | -tiplescientificpapers.1 -| | | Suchquestionsarenatural | | | datasetsusedinthispapercanbefoundat | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -https://github.com/NebulAICompany/ -| 1Examples | inspired | by scenarios | in the | Loong bench- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| mark(Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | | SPD-RAG. | | | | | | | - -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: tasks,butthatmulti-agentoverheadgrowssuperlin- -early. Theirresultthatindependentagentsamplify -• WeproposeSPD-RAG,ahierarchicalmulti- -errorsby17.2×comparedto4.4×forcentralized -agentframeworkthatcombinesper-document -systemsdirectlymotivatesourcoordinator-based -agentic RAG with a centralized synthesis design. Thetaxonomyofhierarchicalmulti-agent -layer, where cost-efficient document agents systemsbyMoore(2025)furtherclassifiesdesign -| are coordinated | by a | smarter coordinator | | | | | | | -| --------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | patternsalongfiveaxes: | | controlhierarchy,informa- | | | -agent,enablingdocument-levelspecialization -| | | | | tion flow, | role delegation, | temporal | layering, | and | -| ----------------- | -------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| and parallel | execution | while allowing | each | communicationstructure. | | | | | -| document | to be analyzed | in depth | to ensure | | | | | | -| that all relevant | information | is incorporated | | | | | | | -2.2 LongDocumentandMulti-DocumentQA -withoutmissingcriticalevidence. -| | | | | Long documents | that | exceed | LLM context | win- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -• WeevaluateontheLoongbenchmark(Wang -| | | | | dows are | often handled | via | divide-and-conquer | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -etal.,2024a),whichincludesmulti-document -| | | | | strategies. | LLM×MapReduce(Zhouetal.,2025) | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| QA instances | over financial | reports | and aca- | | | | | | -| | | | | formalizestwokeychallenges: | | | inter-chunkdepen- | | -| demic papers | with an | average of | 11 docu- | | | | | | -dency(onechunkdependsoncontextfromanother) -mentsperinstanceandcontextlengthsfrom -andinter-chunkconflict(chunksprovidecontradic- -| 10K to beyond | 250K | tokens, and | show that | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -toryinformation),andproposesstructuredinforma- -oursystemsubstantiallyoutperformsstandard -tionprotocolsandin-contextconfidencecalibration -RAGandAgenticRAGbaselinesunderGPT- -| | | | | tomitigatethem. | ToM(Guoetal.,2025)extends | | | | -| -------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | --------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | -| 5-judged | Avg Score (adapted | from | Loong’s | | | | | | -| | | | | this approach | with a | hierarchical | DocTree | repre- | -GPT-4-judgedprotocol;see§4.3),withgains -sentationforrecursivereasoning. -| of around | +25 points | (76% higher | average | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Formulti-documentQA,LongAgent(Zhaoetal., -score)comparedtoNormalRAGandAgentic -| | | | | 2024) splits | a 128K-token | document | | into chunks | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | -RAGbaselines. -| | | | | assigned | to member | agents, with | a leader | agent | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ----- | -| | | | | orchestrating | discussionsand | | inter-membercom- | | -• Weanalyzeablations,documenttypeandtask -complexityeffects,andcost–qualitytradeoffs, munication to reduce hallucinations. However, -showingthat SPD-RAGattainsover85%of LongAgenttargetsasinglelongdocumentrather -thanmultipleindependentdocumentsthatmaycon- -| full-context | baseline quality | at roughly | 38% | | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | flict. DocAgent | (Sun | et al., 2025) | uses | a multi- | -oftheAPIcost. -| | | | | agent framework | that | mimics | human | reading via | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | -2 RelatedWork -atree-structuredoutlineandrevieweragent,while -| | | | | MDocAgent | (Han et | al., 2025) | employs | five spe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | -2.1 LLM-BasedMulti-AgentSystems -| | | | | cialized | agents for multi-modal | | document | under- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -LLM-basedmulti-agentsystemsareincreasingly -standing. -| used for complex | task solving. | Guo et | al. (2024) | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -provideacomprehensivesurveyofagentprofiles, -2.3 HierarchicalandRecursive -communicationprotocols,andcollaborationstrate- -Summarization -| gies. Hierarchical | architectures | such | as MegaA- | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -gent(Wangetal.,2024b),whichdemonstratesau- Ourhierarchicalmergingmechanismbuildsontree- -tonomouscooperationamongupto590agentsvia basedretrievalandrecursivesummarization. RAP- -multi-leveltaskdecomposition,andAgentOrches- TOR(Sarthietal.,2024)recursivelyembeds,clus- -tra(Zhangetal.,2025),whichachievesstate-of-the- ters, and summarizes text chunks to construct a -artperformanceonGAIAusingacentralplanning bottom-uptreewithmultipleabstractionlevels;re- -agent and specialized sub-agents, exemplify this trievingfromtheappropriatelevelyieldsa20%ab- -| trend. | | | | soluteaccuracygainonQuALITY.OuandLapata | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Scalinglawsformulti-agentsystemsofferquan- (2025)showthathierarchicalmergingcanamplify -titativeguidanceforarchitecturedesign. Kimetal. hallucinationsduringrecursivesummarizationand -(2025)evaluate180configurationsacrossfivear- proposecontext-awareaugmentationstrategiesthat -chitectures, finding that centralized coordination replaceintermediatesummarieswithrelevantinput -yields an 80.9% improvement on parallelizable context,whichweadoptinourmergingprotocol. - -2.4 Graph-BasedDocumentAnalysis 3 Methodology -Figure 1 presents an overview of the SPD-RAG -Graph-based document analysis is particu- -architecture. Thesystemprocessesaquerythrough -larly effective for global sensemaking queries. -three layers: the Coordination Layer (§3.1), the -GraphRAG(Edgeetal.,2024)constructsaknowl- -ParallelRetrievalLayer(§3.2),andtheSynthesis -edge graph of entities and relations from source -Layer(§3.3). -documents and applies hierarchical community -detection(e.g.,theLeidenalgorithm(Traagetal., -3.1 CoordinationLayer -2019)) to obtain multi-level communities with -Given a query q and corpus D, the system first -textual summaries. At query time, it retrieves -processes the query through a coordinator agent. -relevant communities, elicits community-level -The coordinator’s role is to decompose the user -partial answers, and aggregates them via a -query into a Shared Instruction Set for Docu- -map–reduce–styleprocedure. AsurveyonLLM- -ments and Synthesis Directives. It generates a -empoweredknowledgegraphconstruction(Bian, -WriteTodosstructuredobjectcontaining(a)alist -2025) highlights how LLMs are reshaping the -of sub_agent_todos: atomic, self-contained ex- -classical knowledge graph pipeline across three -traction tasks specifying exactly what fields, en- -key stages: ontology engineering, knowledge -tities, or numeric values to extract (the shared in- -extraction, and knowledge fusion. Our work is -structions);and(b)asynthesis_directive(2–4 -complementary: instead of inducing an explicit -sentences) instructing the downstream Synthesis -knowledge graph, SPD-RAG operates directly -Layeronhowtoprioritizeandstructurethemerged -over agent-produced textual summaries and -response. -performs similarity-guided recursive synthesis -acrossmanydocuments. 3.2 ParallelRetrievalLayer -Weassignadedicatedsub-agentα toeachdocu- -i -mentd inthecorpus. Eachsub-agentoperatesas -2.5 BenchmarksforMulti-Document i -anindependentRAGloopoveritsassigneddocu- -Reasoning -ment,guidedbythesharedinstructionsetfromthe -The Loong benchmark (Wang et al., 2024a) CoordinationLayer. -evaluates long-context LLMs on extended multi- -Document-Scoped Retrieval and Reasoning. -document QA where every document is relevant -Each document d serves as an isolated retrieval -i -("Leave No Document Behind") across financial, -universe; the assigned sub-agent is strictly con- -legal, and academic domains in English and Chi- -strainedtosearchtoolcallswithind , preventing -i -nese. Itspansfourtasktypeswithcontextlengths -cross-documentdistractorchunksfromdegrading -from 10K to over 250K tokens, and even strong -local extraction. Each sub-agent receives the -frontier models achieve only modest Avg Scores -originalqueryq,itsassigneddocumentname,and -andmediumperfect-answerrates,underscoringthe -thesharedinstructionset(todolist),thenoperates -difficultyofreasoningovermanylong,all-relevant -in an iterative retrieve-and-reason loop. On each -documents. -turn, the agent either issues a search action (a -Complementarydatasetsprobeotheraspectsof focused query string) or a finalize action that -multi-document reasoning. MoNaCo (Wolfson terminates the loop and emits the document- -et al., 2025) focuses on natural questions over groundedfindings. Thesub-agentpromptinstructs -dozensofWikipediapages,MEBench(Linetal., the agent to attempt at least 2 focused searches -2025)onhigh-entity-densityQA,FanOutQA(Zhu before concluding a piece of information is -et al., 2024) on multi-hop questions with absent, with a total cap of 5 search calls across -long cross-document evidence chains, and all tasks. Each search action triggers dense -HoloBench (Maekawa et al., 2024) on database- vector retrieval over the sub-agent’s dedicated -style aggregation over unstructured text. Taken per-documentQdrantindex. ThisretrievalusesCo- -together, these benchmarks show that scalable hereembed-v4.0embeddings(1536-dimensional, -multi-document reasoning remains an open cosine similarity) to fetch the top k = 15 most -challenge,withLoongemphasizingtheespecially similar chunks. These chunks are then re-ranked -demandingall-relevant,long-contextregime. byCoherererank-v4.0-fasttoyieldafinalset - -| | | | | Figure1: | OverviewofSPD-RAGArchitecture. | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of top_n = 5 chunks per search. The documents Similarity-Ordered Merge & Synthesis. -t, -are split into chunks offline using LangChain’s In iteration we maintain a set of find- -RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter in Mark- ings/summaries S(t) = {s (t) ,...,s (t) }. We -| | | | | | | | | | | | 1 | n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downmodewithachunksizeof1000tokensand embed each summary using Cohere embed-v4.0 -| 250-tokenoverlap. | | | | | | | and compute | | a cosine-similarity | | | matrix | via | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -sklearn.metrics.pairwise.cosine_similarity. -| FindingsOutput. | | | Wedenotethefindingsofeach | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | This | is converted | | to a | distance | matrix | | -sub-agentas -| | | | | | | | | | | (t) (t) | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | D = | 1 − | cos(s | ,s ), | which | is passed | to | -| | | | | | | | ij | | | i j | | | | -o = α (q,d ) = ⟨s ,r ⟩ (1) AgglomerativeClustering with n_clusters=1, -| | | i | i i | i | i | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | linkage="average" | | | (UPGMA), | | producing | a | -| where | s is | the natural | | language | findings | re- | | | | | | | | -i -completedendrogramoverallcurrentsummaries. -| port from | d | and | r ∈ | [0,1] is | a scalar | rele- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | -| | i | | i | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | We traverse | the | merge | tree | bottom-up, | greedily | | -| vance/confidencescore. | | | Theseoutputsarepassed | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | accumulating | | nodes | into a batch | as | long as | the | -totheSynthesisLayer. -| | | | | | | | total tiktoken | | count | does not | exceed | the target | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | -| Parallelism. | | All | RAG | loops for | the | docu- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | budget | of B | = 750,000 | tokens. | | Semantically | | -ments are dispatched concurrently via Lang- similarsummariesaregroupedfirst,soeachbatch -Graph’s Send API fan-out, which emits one contains the most similar available summaries -| Send("document_sub_agent_node", | | | | | ...) | per | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withinthetokenlimit. -documentandexecutesalltargetsinparallelwithin -LangGraph’sasyncruntime. AggregateandSynthesizeFindings. Foreach -batch,anLLMispromptedwiththeconcatenated -3.3 SynthesisLayer -| | | | | | | | findings, | the synthesis | | directive, | and | the original | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -WhilemodernLLMsfeatureextensivecontextwin- queryq toproduceanaggregatedandsynthesized -dows,synthesizinghundredsofdocumentreports -| | | | | | | | summary. | Allbatchsynthesiscallswithinanitera- | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -can still exceed these limits or cause ’lost in the tionareissuedconcurrentlyviaasyncio.gather. -middle’degradation. Tofuture-proofthearchitec- Themergedsummariesformtheinputforthenext -| ture for | massive | corpora, | | the Synthesis | Layer | is | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | iteration | S(t+1). | The | same | SYNTHESIS | prompt | | -designedasadynamicmap-reducepipelinethatag- -| | | | | | | | used at | every | level | of the | merging | tree is | ap- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | -gregatesfindingsrecursively. TheSynthesisLayer plied even at the final level—there is no separate -receives the synthesis directives from the Coor- synthesis-onlyprompt. -| dination | Layer | and | the findings | {o | ,o ,...,o | } | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 1 2 | n | | | | | | | | -from the Parallel Retrieval Layer. It aggregates ContextSizeConditionandOutput. Thelayer -andsynthesizesthefindingsrecursivelythrougha evaluates whether the total findings size exceeds -similarity-orderedprocessuntilthetotalfindings the context size threshold (i.e., |S(t+1)| > 1). If -sizefallswithinthetargetcontextsizetoproduce theconditionistrue,theprocessloopsbacktothe -thefinaloutput. similarity-orderedmergeandsynthesisstep. Ifthe - -Algorithm1RecursiveSynthesis Locating, Comparison, Clustering, or Chain of -Reasoning,withcontextlengthsrangingfrom10K -| Require: | FindingsS | = {s ,...,s | },queryq, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | 1 | n | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | to beyond | 250K | tokens. | | We evaluate | | on the En- | -synthesisdirectived,contextsizebudgetB -Ensure: FinalOutputs⋆ glishandSet4(200k-250ktokens)portionofthe -| | | | | | benchmarkonly. | | Ourevaluationsetcomprises40 | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1: while|S| | > 1do | | | | | | | | | | | -instancesinvolvingacademicpapersand62involv- -| 2: E | ← COHEREEMBED(S) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -D ← 1−COSINESIMILARITY(E) ingfinancialreports(102instancestotal),withthe -3: -tree ← AGGLOMERATIVECLUSTER( fourtasktypesdistributedas: SpotlightLocating -4: -(27),Comparison(15),Clustering(49),andChain -| | D, linkage | = “average”) | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofReasoning(11). -| 5: batches | ← | GROUPBYTOKENS( | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | S, tree, | B) | | | | | | | | | | -4.2 Baselines -| 6: if|batches| | | ≥ |S|then | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | We compare | | against | the | following | systems, | all | -| 7: | batches ← | [S] | | | | | | | | | | -| endif | | | | | backedbyGemini2.5Pro: | | | | | | | -8: -| 9: S | ← ASYNCGATHER( | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | • Baseline(FullContext): | | | | | Alldocumentsfor | | -| | SYNTHESIZE(b,q,d)∀b | | ∈ | batches) | | | | | | | | -eachinstanceareconcatenatedandprovided -10: endwhile -directlyinthecontextwindowofGemini2.5 -| return | S[0] | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -11: -Pro,representingtheoraclelong-contextup- -perbound. -conditionisfalse(thetotalfindingssizeiswithin -• NormalRAG:Standardvectorsearchtop-K -thecontextsize,leavingasinglefinalsummarys⋆), -| | | | | | retrieval | | over | the full | document | | corpus, fol- | -| ----------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | -| the process | terminates | and yields | s⋆ | as the final | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | lowed | by | LLM | reasoning | | over the | retrieved | -| | If|S(t+1)| | |S(t)|(no-progresscase),the | | | | | | | | | | -| output. | | ≥ | | | | | | | | | | -chunks. -entirecurrentlevelisforcedintoasinglebatchto -guaranteetermination. -| | | | | | • Agentic | | RAG: | A single-agent | | ReAct-style | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -Algorithm1givesthepseudocodeforthegeneral RAG system (implemented via Lang- -recursivesynthesisprocedure. Graph/LangChain) that can issue multiple -| | | | | | iterative | | retrieval | calls | over | the | full global | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| BehavioronLoong. | | Inpractice,withGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | -Pro’s 1M-token context window and a budget of corpus. It uses the same embedding and -| | | | | | re-rankingpipelineas | | | | SPD-RAG,butlacks | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -B = 750,000tokens,thecombinedsub-agentfind- -per-documentspecialization. -ingsforallinstancesinourLoongevaluationsetfit -withinasinglebatch,sotheconditionalcheckal- -4.3 EvaluationMetrics -| lowedoutputafteroneiteration. | | | Therecursiveloop | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | We report | the | following | | metrics, | following | the | -isthereforeadesigncapabilityintendedformuch -Loongevaluationprotocol(Wangetal.,2024a): -largercorpora,wheretotalfindingssizegenuinely -exceedsthecontextsize. -| | | | | | • Avg | Score: | An | LLM-judged | | score | (0–100) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -measuringthedegreetowhichthepredicted -4 ExperimentalSetup -| | | | | | answer | | accurately | covers | | the gold | answer, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | -4.1 Dataset -| | | | | | following | | the | evaluation | protocol | | of Loong | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | (Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | 2 | | | -WeevaluateSPD-RAGontheLoongbenchmark -| (Wangetal.,2024a). | | Loongisanextendedmulti- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------ | ----------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | • PerfectRate(PR%): | | | | Percentageofqueries | | | -| document | QA instances | in both | English | and Chi- | | | | | | | | -wherethesystemreceivesaperfectscoreof -| nese, with | an average | of 11 documents | | per test | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -100. -| casespanningtworeal-worldscenarios: | | | | financial | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -reports and academic papers. Each test case is 2BecausetheoriginallegacyGPT-4modelAPIisunavail- -ablefornewscaledevaluations,weadoptGPT-5astheeval- -constructedsothateverydocumentisrelevantto -| | | | | | uator. Recent | literature | | increasingly | | adopts | GPT-5 as the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------------ | -the final answer ("Leave No Document Behind", standard for LLM-as-a-judge protocols due to its superior -meaningacorrectresponserequiressynthesizing alignmentwithhumangrading(Wolfsonetal.,2025).While -ourbaselinenumbersarere-computedunderthisGPT-5judge -evidencefromallprovideddocuments),andisan- -forstrictfairness,rawscoresmaynotbeperfectly1-to-1com- -notated under one of four task types: Spotlight parablewiththeoriginallypublishedLoongleaderboard. - -• AvgTokenUsage: Meanper-querytotal(in- Cost tracking. Per-query costs are computed -put+output)tokenusage. fromLangSmithrunmetadata(totaltokencounts -×per-tokenpricing. -| • Avg | Cost | (USD): | Mean | per-query | | API cost, | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| enablingcost-efficiencycomparisons. | | | | | | | 5 Results | | | | | | -5.1 MainResults -| • AvgLatency(s): | | | Meanper-querywall-clock | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time. -Table1reportsthemainresultsacrossallsystems -| | | | | | | | on our Loong | evaluation | | set. | Figure | 2 illustrates | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | -4.4 ImplementationDetails -theseperformancedifferencesacrossthefourspe- -| AllsystemsuseGemini2.5Pro(temperature0.0) | | | | | | | cifictasktypes. | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -asthebackboneLLMforthecoordinator,merging SPD-RAGachievesanAvgScoreof58.1,sub- -| layer, and | synthesis | | layer. | SPD-RAG | | document | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stantiallyoutperformingbothNormalRAG(33.0) -| sub-agents | use | Gemini | 2.5 | Flash | for | document- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | and Agentic | RAG | (32.8). | | This corresponds | to | -scopedretrieval,reducingper-documentcostwhile roughly a 25-point absolute improvement (about -preserving reasoning quality at the merging and 76% relative gain) over standard RAG baselines. -| synthesisstages. | | GPT-5isusedexclusivelyasthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | Furthermore, | SPD-RAG | | more | than | doubles the | -LLMjudgefortheevaluationoftheAvgscoreand Perfect Rate (PR) of Agentic RAG (18.6% vs. -is not part of the pipeline itself. Prompts for all 8.8%),indicatingthatexhaustivedocument-level -| systems, | including | baselines, | | were | optimized | for | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -processingmorefrequentlycapturesthecomplete -informationextractionandsynthesistoensurefair set of required facts. Notably, the Agentic RAG -comparison. Fullprompttemplatesforallsystems baseline,despiteconsuming∼3×moretokensthan -areprovidedinthecoderepository. NormalRAG,doesnotyieldscoreimprovements, -suggestingthatuninstructediterativeretrievalwith- -| Indexing. | Each | | document | | is | pre- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | out per-document | | specialization | | does | not effec- | -| indexed | into | a | dedicated | | Qdrant | vec- | | | | | | | -tivelyaddressthecoveragechallengeinexhaustive -| tor | collection | | using | | LangChain’s | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | multi-document | | settings. | While | the | full-context | -| RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter | | | | | | (Imple- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | baseline | attains | the highest | | quality with | an Avg | -mentationdetailsareprovidedintheAppendix.). -| | | | | | | | Score of | 68.0, | SPD-RAG | reaches | 85.4% | of this | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | -Retrievalpersub-agent. Eachsearchtoolcall performancewhileconsumingonly37.9%ofthe -performs dense vector retrieval over the docu- API cost, demonstrating a highly favorable cost- -| | | | | | | | quality trade-off. | | The | full-context | baseline | pro- | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | -| mentindex,returningthetop-K | | | | | (k = 15)chunks | | | | | | | | -using cosine similarity in Qdrant. These can- vides a strong upper bound that benefits from all -didates are subsequently re-ranked with Cohere documents in one pass. Despite this, SPD-RAG -narrowsthegapto9.9pointswhilecostingless. -| rerank-v4.0-fast,andthetoptop_n | | | | | = | 5chunks | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -arepassedtothesub-agentLLM. -5.2 AnalysisbyTaskType -| Merging | layer. | The | token | budget | | per merge | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Table2breaksdownperformancebyLoong’sfour -| batchisB | = 750,000tokens(75%ofGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tasktypes. -| Pro’s1Mcontextcap). | | | Agglomerativeclustering | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thetask-typebreakdownrevealsaclearpattern. -usessklearnwithUPGMAlinkageandprecom- -| | | | | | | | For Spotlight | Locating—which | | | requires | finding | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -putedcosine-distancematrix. -asinglesalientfactacrossdocuments—allRAG- -| | | | | | | | based systems | | perform | reasonably | well | (69–74), | -| ------------- | --------------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | -| Parallelism. | | Documentagentsrunconcurrently | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | while the | full-context | | baseline | leads | (86.6). The | -| via LangGraph | | Send | API | fan-out. | Batch | synthe- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | largest gaps | between | | SPD-RAG | and | the RAG | -| sis calls | within | each | merge | iteration | | are paral- | | | | | | | -| | asyncio.gather. | | | | | | baselinesappearinClustering(+40.5ptsoverNor- | | | | | | -| lelized | with | | | | Synchronous | Co- | | | | | | | -malRAG)andChainofReasoning(+26.2ptsover -hereAPIcallsareoffloadedtothethreadpoolvia -| | | | | | | | Agentic RAG), | | tasks | that require | aggregating | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -asyncio.to_thread. -reasoningoverevidencefrommanydocumentssi- -Safety limits. Each document sub-agent’s iter- multaneously. Ontheotherhand,itnearlymatches -ative retrieval loop is capped at 5 iterations; the the full-context baseline (42.2 vs. 42.7) on Com- -| AgenticRAGbaselinecapsat10iterations. | | | | | | | parisontasks. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -System AvgScore PR(%) AvgInputTok AvgTotalTok AvgCost($) AvgLatency(s) -OracleLong-ContextBaseline -| Baseline(FullContext) | | 68.0 | 31.4 253,085 | 255,345 | 0.273 | 45.6 | -| --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -RAGBaselines -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 13.7 22,174 | 27,430 | 0.080 | 42.6 | -| ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 8.8 81,877 | 85,290 | 0.098 | 40.6 | -OurSystem -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 18.6 193,954 | 205,683 | 0.103 | 54.8 | -| ------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -Table1: MainresultsonourLoongevaluationset(102instances: 40academicpaper,62financialreport). Bold: -| bestoverall. | Underline: | bestamongRAG-basedsystems. | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2: ComparisonofAverageScoreacrossthefoursystems,brokendownbytasktype(SpotlightLocating, -Comparison,Clustering,andChainofReasoning). -5.3 AnalysisbyDocumentDomain -| As shown | in Table 3 | and Figure | 3 the domain | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -breakdownexposesastrikingfailuremodeofstan- -| dard RAG: | both Normal | RAG and | Agentic RAG | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -achieve0%PRonacademicpaperinstances(Avg -| Scoresof15.2and16.8,respectively). | | | Academic | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -paperinstancesinLoongtendtoinvolvelong,tech- -nicaldocumentswithdistributedevidence,making -top-K retrievalespeciallysusceptibletocoverage -failures. SPD-RAGdramaticallyrecoversonthis -domain(60.0AvgScore),closingmostofthegap -| with the | full-context | baseline (78.8). | On finan- | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3: Averagescorebydocumentdomaincompar- -cialreportinstances—whichtendtobeshorterand ingtheBaseline(FullContext),NormalRAG,Agentic -morestructured—allRAG-basedsystemsperform -RAG,andSPD-RAGsystems. -better,andthegapbetweenSPD-RAG(56.9)and -thebaseline(61.0)issmaller. - -| | System | | SpotlightLoc. | | Comparison | Clustering | ChainofReasoning | | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (n=27) | | (n=15) | (n=49) | | (n=11) | | | | -Baseline(FullContext) 86.6/55.6% 42.7/26.7% 67.1/14.3% 60.9/54.5% -| | NormalRAG | | 69.7/37.0% | | 37.7/26.7% | 15.4/0.0% | | 14.8/0.0% | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | AgenticRAG | | 73.4/22.2% | | 23.3/20.0% | 16.7/0.0% | | 17.9/0.0% | | | | -| | SPD-RAG | | 74.2/44.4% | | 42.2/20.0% | 57.2/4.1% | | 44.1/18.2% | | | | -Table2: AvgScore/PR(%)byLoongtasktype. EachcellshowsAvgScore/PR%. -| | | | | | Crucially, | thearchitectureof | | | SPD-RAG | | enables | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | -| System | | Paper(n=40) | Financial(n=62) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | this | cost efficiency: | | by constraining | | retrieval | to | -| Baseline | | 78.8/30.0% | 61.0/32.3% | | | | | | | | | -NormalRAG 15.2/0.0% 44.5/22.6% isolated,single-documentspaces,wecanreliably -| AgenticRAG | | 16.8/0.0% | 43.1/14.5% | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -offloadtheiterativereasoningtoacheapermodel -| SPD-RAG | | 60.0/7.5% | 56.9/25.8% | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | (Gemini | 2.5 Flash). | | In contrast, | | global | iterative | -baselinesrequirethereasoningcapacityofafron- -Table3: AvgScore/PR(%)bydocumentdomain. -| | | | | | tier | model (Gemini | 2.5 | Pro) | to navigate | | the fully | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -concatenatedcorpus,drivingupcosts. -| System | | AvgScore | AvgCost($) | Score/$ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | -| Baseline | | 68.0 | 0.273 | 249.1 | | | | | | | | -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 0.080 | 412.5 | 6 | Discussion | | | | | | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 0.098 | 334.7 | | | | | | | | -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 0.103 | 564.1 | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | WhereSPD-RAGexcels. | | | | Thetask-typeresults | | | -| | | | | | in Table | 2 confirm | our | core | hypothesis: | | architec- | -Table4: Cost–qualitytradeoff. -turaldecompositionalongthedocumentaxisyields -| | | | | | the largest | gains | precisely | | for tasks | that | require | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | | | exhaustive | multi-document | | | synthesis. | Clustering | | -5.4 Cost–QualityTradeoff -tasks(+40.5overNormalRAG)andChainofRea- -| | | | | | soning | tasks (+26.2 | over | Agentic | | RAG) | both de- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ---- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -mandthatthesystemformacoherentanswerfrom -evidencedistributedacrossallrelevantdocuments— -exactlythescenarioforwhichper-documentagents -| | | | | | aredesigned. | ForLoong’sComparisonquestions, | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -theanswerisprimarilydeterminedbyreadingout -asmallsetofcomparablenumericattributesfrom -| | | | | | each | report and | aggregating | | them, | so once | docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | ment | agents have | extracted | | those | fields, | the syn- | -| | | | | | thesizer | is effectively | | operating | over | a structured | | -table,whichhelpsexplainwhySPD-RAG’sscore -onComparisontasks(42.2)nearlymatchesthefull- -Figure4: Cost–Qualitytradeoff. Thescatterplotillus- contextbaseline(42.7). -tratestheParetofrontierformulti-documentQA. -| | | | | | Remaining | gap | with | the | full-context | | baseline. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -SPD-RAG outperforms the RAG baselines in Despite strong gains over RAG baselines, SPD- -the cost–quality trade-off. It achieves a 76% RAG lags the full-context baseline by 9.9 Avg -higheraveragescorethanNormalRAG(58.1vs. Score points overall. Three factors likely con- -33.0)whileincreasingtheper-querycostbyonly tribute: (1) Gemini 2.5 Flash, used for document -$0.023 (Table 4). In contrast, Agentic RAG is agents due to its cost efficiency, may provide -Pareto-dominated, as it incurs higher cost than weaker agentic reasoning capabilities compared -NormalRAG($0.098vs.$0.080)whiledelivering to larger models. (2) The coordinator’s sub-task -nearlyidenticalquality(32.8vs.33.0). Compared generation may under-specify queries for highly -tothefull-contextbaseline,whichachievesanAvg technical academic content, leading to incom- -Score of 68.0, SPD-RAG reaches 85.4% of the pleteinformationextractionatthedocument-agent -qualityatonly37.9%ofthecost, resultingina level. (3) The maximum context length observed -2.25× improvement in cost–quality efficiency. inLoongquerieswasapproximately250ktokens— - -onlyabout25%ofthe1M-tokencontextwindow onthecoordinator’sabilitytogeneratecomprehen- -of Gemini 2.5 Pro—potentially limiting the pres- sivesub-tasks: under-specifiedtasksleadtoincom- -sureonthefull-contextbaseline. SinceSPD-RAG plete document-level extractions, as observed on -isdesignedtooperateonsubstantiallylargercon- technicalacademicpaperinstances. Ourevaluation -texts,itsadvantagesmaybecomemorepronounced islimitedtotwodomains(academicpapersandfi- -undermoreextremelong-contextconditions. nancialreports)fromtheLoongbenchmark;legal, -medical,orenterprisedocumentcorporamayhave -| RAG baseline | | failure | on papers. | | The 0% | PR | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -differentstructuralcharacteristicsthatalterrelative -| rate and | 15.2-16.8% | | Avg Score | of | both Normal | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -performance. -| RAG and | Agentic | RAG | on | academic | paper | in- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ThesynthesislayerofSPD-RAGisdesignedto -top-K -| stances | highlights | a systematic | | failure | of | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -handlecorporawherethecombinedsub-agentout- -| retrieval | under | dense, | distributed | evidence. | | Aca- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -putsexceedthemodel’scontextwindow,triggering -| demic | papers | in Loong | often | require | synthesiz- | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -multi-roundsimilarity-basedclusteringandrecur- -ingfactsspreadacrossabstracts,methods,results, -| | | | | | | | sive synthesis. | | In our Loong | experiments, | | how- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | ---- | -andappendicesofmultipledocuments—aregime -ever,Gemini2.5Pro’s1M-tokencontextwassuffi- -| where exhaustive | | per-document | | coverage | proves | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -cienttoprocessallsub-agentsummariesinasingle -| highly | effective. | The | recovery | by SPD-RAG | | to | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | merge step, | so | this recursive | path | was | never acti- | -60.0AvgScore/7.5%PRinthisdomaindemon- -| | | | | | | | vated. Asaresult,thescalabilitypropertiesofthe | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stratesthepracticalvalueofper-documentspecial- -recursivesynthesispipeline—itsimpactonanswer -ization. -| | | | | | | | quality, | redundancy | reduction, | | and cost | as docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Latencyoverhead. SPD-RAG incursamodest mentcountsgrowintothehundredsorthousands— -latency overhead (54.8 s vs. 40.6–45.6 s for the remainempiricallyunvalidated. EvaluatingSPD- -| baselines), | primarily | | due to | its multi-agent | | archi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RAGonmuchlargercorpora,andideallyonanew -tecture. Although document agents run in paral- benchmarkspecificallytargetinghundredstothou- -lel,end-to-endlatencyisstillgatedbythelayered sands of documents per query instance, is an im- -pipeline, which requires at least three sequential portantdirectionforfutureworkthatwouldmore -LLM calls (coordination, per-document retrieval, directlytesttheper-documentagentdesignandthe -andsynthesis)ratherthanasinglepass. intendedlarge-databaseregime. -| | | | | | | | 8 Conclusion | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | We presented | | SPD-RAG, | a hierarchical | | multi- | -| | | | | | | | agent framework | | designed | for | exhaustive | multi- | -| | | | | | | | documentquestionanswering. | | | Byassigningaded- | | | -icatedagenticRAGmoduletoeachdocumentand -mergingtheirfindingsthroughasimilarity-ordered, -| | | | | | | | token-bounded | | tree, our | system | effectively | miti- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | gatesthelimitationsofbothtraditionaltop-K | | | | | re- | -| | | | | | | | trieval (incomplete | | coverage) | and | isolated | long- | -| | | | | | | | context | processing | (degraded | reasoning | | at scale). | -Figure5: Averageper-querylatencyacrosssystems. ExperimentsonthechallengingLoongbenchmark -demonstratethatSPD-RAGachievesanaverage -scoreof58.1,outperformingNormalRAG(33.0) -7 LimitationsandFutureWork -andAgenticRAG(32.8)byapproximately25ab- -SPD-RAG incurs higher per-query LLM call solute points (76% higher average score), while -countsthansingle-passsystems—onecallperdoc- operating at only 37.9% of the API cost of the -ument agent plus a final synthesis step—which oracle full-context baseline (68.0). These per- -increasestotaltokenusagecomparedtostandard formance gains are most pronounced in tasks re- -RAGbaselines,thoughitremainsatroughlyone- quiring deep cross-document synthesis—such as -thirdthecostofthefull-contextbaseline($0.10vs. Clustering(+40.5points)andChainofReasoning -$0.27perquery)duetotheuseofGemini2.5Flash (+26.2points)—aswellasondenseacademicpa- -fordocumentsub-agents. Systemqualitydepends perswherestandardRAGmethodsentirelyfail. - -Ultimately, our findings demonstrate that for TaichengGuo,XiuyingChen,YaqiWang,RuidiChang, -complex information-seeking queries over large ShichaoPei,NiteshV.Chawla,OlafWiest,andXi- -| | | | | | | | angliangZhang.2024. | | | Largelanguagemodel-based | | | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| corpora, | how | information | | is processed | is | crucial. | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | multi-agents: | | Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. | | | | -Specifically,ensuringthateachdocumentreceives -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2402.01680. | | | ArXiv:2402.01680. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -exhaustive,dedicatedagenticattentionprovestobe -| | | | | | | | Siwei Han, | Peng | Xia, Ruiyi | Zhang, | Tong | Sun, Yun | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------- | -amoreeffective,cost-efficient,andscalablestrat- -| | | | | | | | Li, Hongtu | Zhu, | and | Huaxiu Yao. | 2025. | MDocA- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | -egythansimplyexpandinghowmuchrawcontext -gent: Amulti-modalmulti-agentframeworkfordoc- -asinglemodelcanconsumeinonepass. umentunderstanding. Preprint,arXiv:2503.13964. -ArXiv:2503.13964. -9 EthicsStatement -| | | | | | | | Yubin Kim, | Ken | Gu, Chanwoo | Park, | Chunjong | Park, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -SPD-RAG is a retrieval-augmented generation SamuelSchmidgall,A.AliHeydari,YaoYan,Zhi- -hanZhang,YuchenZhuang,MarkMalhotra,PaulPu -| framework | intended | | to improve | access | | to infor- | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liang,HaeWonPark,YuzheYang,XuhaiXu,Yilun -| mation | distributed | across | | large document | | collec- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Du, Shwetak | | Patel, Tim | Althoff, | Daniel | McDuff, | -tions. ThesystemreliesoncommercialLLMAPIs and Xin Liu. 2025. Towards a science of scal- -(Gemini2.5,Cohere),andaswithanyLLM-based ing agent systems. Preprint, arXiv:2512.08296. -ArXiv:2512.08296. -| pipeline, | outputs | may | contain | factual | errors | and | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -should not be treated as authoritative without hu- PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio -man verification. The increased number of API Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- -| | | | | | | | richKüttler, | | MikeLewis, | Wen-tauYih, | | TimRock- | -| --------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | -| calls per | query | relative | to | single-pass | systems | re- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | täschel, | Sebastian | Riedel, | and | Douwe | Kiela. 2020. | -| sults in | higher | energy | consumption, | | a | cost that | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Retrieval-augmented | | | generation | for | knowledge- | -should be weighed against the accuracy gains in intensiveNLPtasks. InAdvancesinNeuralInforma- -deploymentdecisions. Ourbenchmarkevaluations tionProcessingSystems. -| are conducted | | on publicly | | available | datasets | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | TengLin, | YuyuLuo, | HonglinZhang, | | JichengZhang, | | -involvenohumansubjectsorpersonaldata. Dur- Chunlin Liu, Kaishun Wu, and Nan Tang. 2025. -ingthepreparationofthismanuscript,AI-assisted MEBench: Benchmarkinglargelanguagemodelsfor -| | | | | | | | cross-documentmulti-entityquestionanswering. | | | | | In | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -writingtoolswereusedtohelprefinelanguageand -ProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethods -| improveclarity. | | Allresearchdesign,experiments, | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -inNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). -analysis,andfinaldecisionsregardingthecontent -NelsonF.Liu,KevinLin,JohnHewitt,AshwinParan- -wereconductedandverifiedbytheauthors. -jape,MicheleBevilacqua,FabioPetroni,andPercy -| | | | | | | | Liang.2023. | | Lostinthemiddle: | | Howlanguagemod- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | elsuselongcontexts. | | TransactionsoftheAssociation | | | | -References -forComputationalLinguistics,12. -| Haonan | Bian. | 2025. | LLM-empowered | | | knowl- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SeijiMaekawa,HayateIso,andNikitaBhutani.2024. -| edge | graph | construction: | | A survey. | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Holisticreasoningwithlong-contextLMs: | | | | | Abench- | -| arXiv:2510.20345. | | | ArXiv:2510.20345. | | | | | | | | | | -markfordatabaseoperationsonmassivetextualdata. -Darren Edge, Ha Trinh, Newman Cheng, Joshua Preprint,arXiv:2410.11996. ArXiv:2410.11996. -| Bradley, | Alex | Chao, | | Apurva | Mody, | Steven | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | David J. | Moore. | 2025. | A taxonomy | of | hierarchical | -Truitt, Dasha Metropolitansky, Robert Osazuwa multi-agentsystems: Designpatterns,coordination -| Ness, | and | Jonathan | Larson. | 2024. | | From lo- | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | mechanisms, | | and industrial | applications. | | Preprint, | -| cal to | global: | A graph | RAG | approach | | to query- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2508.12683. | | ArXiv:2508.12683. | | | | -| focusedsummarization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2404.16130. | | | | | | | | | | -ArXiv:2404.16130. -| | | | | | | | LituOuandMirellaLapata.2025. | | | | Context-awarehier- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -archicalmergingforlongdocumentsummarization. -| Gemini | Team, | Petko | Georgiev, | Ving | Ian Lei, | Ryan | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2502.00977. | | | ArXiv:2502.00977. | | | -| Burnell, | Libin | Bai, | Anmol | Gulati, | Garrett | Tanzer, | | | | | | | -DamienVincent,ZhufengPan,ShiboWang,and1 Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh -others. 2024. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D. Man- -understandingacrossmillionsoftokensofcontext. ning. 2024. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive pro- -Preprint,arXiv:2403.05530. ArXiv:2403.05530. cessing for tree-organized retrieval. Preprint, -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2401.18059. | | ArXiv:2401.18059. | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Jiani Guo, | Zuchao | Li, | Jie Wu, | Qianren | Wang, | Yun | | | | | | | -Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao, and Yujiu Yang. 2025. LiSun,LiuHe,ShuyueJia,YangfanHe,andChenyu -ToM:Leveragingtree-orientedMapReduceforlong- You. 2025. DocAgent: An agentic framework for -contextreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. InPro- multi-modallong-contextdocumentunderstanding. -ceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin InProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMeth- -NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). odsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). - -V.A.Traag,L.Waltman,andN.J.vanEck.2019. From extraction tasks and write a synthesis -louvaintoleiden: Guaranteeingwell-connectedcom- directive to guide the downstream -| munities. | ScientificReports,9(1):5233. | | | | | | synthesizer. | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 2. Sub-agents | | (next) | — | Each | document | -Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi is assigned one worker that runs your -Liao,XinghuaZhang,BingliWu,HaiyangYu,Nan tasks independently. Workers search -Xu,LeiZhang,RunLuo,YunshuiLi,MinYang,Fei their document and report raw findings. -| | | | | | | | They run | in parallel | | and | cannot | see each | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | -| Huang,andYongbinLi.2024a. | | | | Leavenodocument | | | | | | | | | -other’s results. -| behind: | Benchmarkinglong-contextLLMswithex- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 3. Synthesizer | | (last) | — | A downstream | | -| tendedmulti-docQA. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2406.17419. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | agent | receives | ALL | worker | | findings | -ArXiv:2406.17419. -| | | | | | | | and merges | | them | into | a | single | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | coherent | response. | | It | follows | your | -| Qian Wang, | Tianyu | | Wang, | Zhenheng | Tang, | Qinbin | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | synthesis_directive | | | to decide | | what to | -Li,NuoChen,JingshengLiang,andBingshengHe. -| | | | | | | | prioritize | and | how | to | structure | the | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| 2024b. | Megaagent: | | Alarge-scaleautonomousLLM- | | | | | | | | | | -output. -basedmulti-agentsystemwithoutpredefinedSOPs. -| | | | | | | | You CANNOT | see | the | names, | types, | or | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -| Preprint,arXiv:2408.09955. | | | | ArXiv:2408.09955. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | content | of the | documents. | | | | -TomerWolfson,HarshTrivedi,MorGeva,YoavGold- Your ONLY job in this step: -| berg, | Dan Roth, | Tushar | Khot, | Ashish | | Sabharwal, | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a list | of | subagent_todos | | -| and Reut | Tsarfaty. | | 2025. | Monaco: | | More nat- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (as | structured | | output): | | precise | -| ural and | complex | | questions | for | reasoning | across | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | extraction | | tasks | | that | will be | -| dozensofdocuments. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | executed | | independently | | against | EACH | -| ArXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | document | | by the | sub-agents. | | | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a synthesis_directive: | | | a | -Wentao Zhang, Liang Zeng, Yuzhen Xiao, Yong- concise instruction (2–4 sentences) -cong Li, Ce Cui, Yilei Zhao, Rui Hu, Yang Liu, for the synthesizer. -| Yahui | Zhou, | and Bo | An. | 2025. | AgentOrchestra: | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A hierarchical multi-agent framework for general- Todo-writing rules: -| purpose | task | solving. | Preprint, | arXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | • Decompose | | the | user | query | into | -| ArXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | concrete | | information | | requirements. | | -Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Hao Xu, Yi Lu, Wei He, Yiwen • Each todo must be self-contained -and unambiguous. -| Ding, | Tao Gui, | Qi | Zhang, | and | Xuanjing | Huang. | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | • Prefer | | atomic | tasks | over | broad | -| 2024. | LongAgent: | | Scalinglanguagemodelsto128k | | | | | | | | | | -tasks. -| contextthroughmulti-agentcollaboration. | | | | | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • Include | | coverage | for: | definitions, | | -| arXiv:2402.11550. | | | ArXiv:2402.11550. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | numeric | | values, | constraints, | | edge | -| | | | | | | | cases, | | error | modes, | and | any | -| Zihan Zhou, | Chong | | Li, Xinyi | Chen, | Shuo | Wang, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | explicit | | recommendations | | | required | -YuChao,ZhiliLi,HaoyuWang,QiShi,ZhixingTan, -| | | | | | | | by | the user | query. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -XuHan,XiaodongShi,ZhiyuanLiu,andMaosong -| | | | | | | | • Design | a | robust | extraction | | list | -| ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| Sun. 2025. | | LLM×MapReduce: | | | Simplified | long- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | that | works | for | ANY document | | in the | -| sequence | processing | | using | large | language | models. | | | | | | | -set. -InProceedingsoftheAnnualMeetingoftheAssocia- -| tionforComputationalLinguistics(ACL). | | | | | | | Important | Constraints: | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Do | not assume | any | document | | contains | -| AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris | | | | | | | • | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | the | answer. | Write | | todos | that can | -| Callison-Burch. | | 2024. | FanOutQA: | | A | multi-hop, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | be | answered | with | either | “Found” | or | -multi-documentquestionansweringbenchmarkfor -| | | | | | | | “Not | found | in | this document.” | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | --------------- | ----------- | --- | -| large language | | models. | In | Proceedings | | of the An- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • Tell | the | worker | WHAT | to extract, | not | -nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational -| | | | | | | | HOW | to extract | | it. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Linguistics(ACL). -| | | | | | | | • Do | not | synthesize, | | summarize, | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | attempt | | to answer | | the user | query | -A Prompts -yourself. -| All | prompts | | are | | defined | in | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A.2DocumentSub-AgentPrompt -backend/core/prompts.py. -(RESEARCH_SYSTEM_PROMPT) -| A.1CoordinatorPrompt | | | | | | | You are | a sub-agent | | investigating | | a | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | -| (LEAD_RESEARCHER_PROMPT) | | | | | | | single document: | | {file_name}. | | | | -You are a lead researcher coordinating You operate inside an iterative -a RAG-based analysis to answer a user retrieval loop. On each turn you output -| query. | | | | | | | exactly | one structured | | action: | | | -| -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| Pipeline | | Architecture: | | | | | • action="search": | | | Issue | a | focused | -1. YOU (now) — Decompose the query into query to retrieve information from - -the document. Set query to a • Follow the synthesis directive -specific, targeted search string. above — it defines your main goal, -Set reasoning to why this query is priorities, and output structure. -| | needed. | | | | | | • | Keep only | information | | that | directly | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -• action="finalize": You have helps answer the query. Discard -| | gathered | | sufficient | evidence | to | | | tangential | content. | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------ | -| | address | ALL | assigned | | tasks. Set | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Preserve | exact | numbers, | | names, | -| | findings | to | your | complete | extracted | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | dates, | and caveats. | | | | -| | report. | Set | reasoning | | to a brief | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Remove | redundancy. | | If the | same | -| | summary | of | what you | found. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | fact appears | | multiple | times, | keep | -it once. -| | Investigation | principles: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • | Do NOT | invent | or infer | facts | not | -| | | | | | | | | present | in the | findings. | | | -| | 1. Start | by identifying | | the | key facts | | | | | | | | -| | required | for | each | task. | | | • | Same | language | as | the | findings | -2. Issue ONE focused query per turn (default English if mixed). -| | — prefer | specific | | terms | over broad | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | phrases. | | | | | B | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | -| | 3. Expand | to | synonyms | or | paraphrases | | | | | | | | -Models. -if initial results are incomplete. The coordinator, the merging layer, -4. Issue separate queries for and the synthesis layer use gemini-2.5-pro -| | different | | aspects | of a | task. | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | (temperature | | 0.0). | | Document | | sub-agents | -| | 5. Keep | searching | until | every | task is | | | | | | | | -covered with concrete evidence or use gemini-2.5-flash (temperature 0.0) for -| | confirmed | | absent. | | | document-scoped | | | retrieval. | | The | LLM judge | -| --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | -6. Do NOT attempt to answer the user (GPT-5) is separate and is used only for the -| | query | directly | — | extract | raw facts | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | evaluationoftheAvgscore. | | | | Modelconstantsare | | | -only. -definedinbackend/shared/constants.py. -| | 7. Do | NOT finalize | | a task | as ’Not | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | found’ | after | only | a single | focused | | | | | | | | -| | search. | | At | least | attempt 2 | Hyperparameters. | | | | | | | -| | focused | searches | | before | concluding | | | | | | | | -| | information | | is absent. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Parameter | | | | Value | | | -| | 8. Do NOT | focus | on very | specific | terms, | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunksize(tokens) | | | | 1000 | | | -| | but | rather | on the | general | context | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunkoverlap(tokens) | | | | 250 | | | -| | of the | task. | Always | try | to find the | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Tokenizer | | | | tiktoken | | cl100k_base | -| | most | relevant | information. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingmodel | | | | Cohereembed-v4.0 | | | -| | 9. You | must use | AT MOST | 5 | searches to | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingdimension | | | | 1536 | | | -| | answer | a task. | DO | NOT | OVERUSE THE | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Similaritymetric | | | | Cosine | | | -| | SEARCH | TOOL. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | MergetokenbudgetB | | | | 750,000tokens | | | -| | | | | | | Denseretrievaltop-K | | | | 15 | | | -| | Finalize | report | format: | | For each | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Reranker | | | | Coherererank-v4.0-fast | | | -| | assigned | task, | output | either | “Found: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Rerankertop-N | | | | 5 | | | -| | [exact answer | with | supporting | | evidence]” | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Sub-agentiterationsafetylimit | | | | 5 | | | -| | or “Not found | in | this | document.” | Always | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringalgorithm | | | | Agglomerative(UPGMA) | | | -| | report exact | numbers, | | names, | and dates. | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringmetric | | | | Precomputedcosinedistance | | | -| | Never approximate | | or | infer | beyond the | | | | | | | | -document. -| | | | | | | Cost | | measurement. | | Per-query | | costs | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | are | pulled | from | LangSmith | | run | metadata | -A.3Merge/SynthesisPrompt -| (SYNTHESIS_PROMPT) | | | | | | (extract_langsmith_info.py) | | | | | using | model- | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -specificper-tokenpricing. -Thispromptisuseduniformlyateverylevelofthe -recursivemergingtree,includingthefinalsynthesis -step. Thereisnoseparatefinal-answerprompt. -| | You are | a research | synthesizer. | | Merge | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | the following | | sub-agent | findings | into | | | | | | | | -| | one compact, | information-dense | | | response | | | | | | | | -| | for the user. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Query: {query | } | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Synthesis | Directive: | | | | | | | | | | | -{synthesis_directive} -| | Findings | Batch: | {findings | } | | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rules: \ No newline at end of file +The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20220922152230/https://www.pewresearch.org/fac… + +N UM B ERS , FAC T S AN D T REN DS S HAPIN G YOUR W ORL D N EW S L ET T ERS + +PRES S + +DON AT E M Y AC C OUN T + + + + + +* Pew Research Center + +See our research on: Economy | Abortion | Russia | COVID-19 + +Search pewresearch.org... + + + +RESEARCH TOPICS  + +ALL PUBLICATIONS METHODS SHORT READS TOOLS & RESOURCES EXPERTS ABO + +Home + + + + Research Topics + + + + Race & Ethnicity + + + + Racial & Ethnic Groups + + + + Hispanics/Latinos + + + + Hispanic/Latino Identity + +S EPT EM B ER 1 5 , 2 0 2 2 + +Who is Hispanic? + +    + +BY MARK HUGO LOPEZ, JENS MANUEL KROGSTAD AND JEFFREY S. PASSEL + +Beauty pageant contestants at the Junta Hispana Hispanic cultural festival in Miami. (Jeffrey Greenberg/Universal +Images Group via Getty Images) + + Debates over who is Hispanic and who is not have often fueled conversations about + +identity among Americans who trace their heritage to Latin America or Spain. Most + +recently, the 2020 census has drawn attention to how Hispanic identity is defined and + +measured. The once-a-decade head count of all people living in the United States used a + +new approach to identify who is Hispanic and has provided fresh details about how + +Hispanics view their racial identity. + +So, who is considered Hispanic in the U.S. today? How exactly are Hispanics counted? + +What role does race play in deciding who is counted as Hispanic? And how do surveys + +incorporate the various terms people use to describe their Hispanic identity, such as + +Latina or Latinx? + +In this analysis, we’ll answer these common questions and others. + +How many Hispanics are there in the U.S. today? + +Let’s start with the basics. The Census Bureau estimates there were roughly 62.6 million + +Hispanics in the U.S. as of 2021, making up 19% of the nation’s population, both new + +highs. + +Behind the official Census Bureau number, however, lies a long history of changing labels, + +shifting categories and revised question wording on census forms – all of which reflect + +evolving cultural norms about what it means to be Hispanic or Latino in the U.S. today. + + How are Hispanics counted in government surveys, public opinion polls and other +studies? + +Before diving into the details, keep in mind that some surveys ask about Hispanic origin + +and race in separate questions, following the current practice of the Census Bureau: + +One way to count Hispanics is straightforward: Hispanics are those who say they are + +Hispanic, with no exceptions. Pew Research Center uses this approach in our surveys, as + +do other polling firms such as Gallup and voter exit polls. + + The Census Bureau largely counts Hispanics this way, too, but with some exceptions. If + +respondents select only the “Other Hispanic” category and write in only non-Hispanic + +responses such as “Irish,” the Census Bureau recodes the response as non-Hispanic. + +However, beginning in 2020, it widened the lens to include a relatively small number of + +people who did not check a Hispanic box on the census form but answered the race + +question in a way that implied a Hispanic background. As a result, someone who wrote + +that their race is “Mexican” or “Argentinean” in the race question was counted as + +Hispanic, even if they did not check the Hispanic box. From the available data, it is + +impossible to know the exact number of respondents affected by this change, but it would + +appear to be about 1% of Hispanics or fewer. + +How did Hispanics identify their race in the 2020 census? + +In the eyes of the Census Bureau, Hispanics can be of any race, because “Hispanic” is an + +ethnicity and not a race – though this distinction can be subject to debate. A 2015 survey + +by Pew Research Center found that 17% of Hispanic adults said being Hispanic is mainly a + +matter of race, while 29% said it is mainly a matter of ancestry and 42% said it is mainly a + +matter of culture. + +Nonetheless, the 2020 census provides a portrait of the self-reported racial identity of + +Hispanics. For example, 26.2 million single-race Hispanics identified only as “some other + +race,” a group that mostly includes those who wrote in a Hispanic origin or nationality as + + their race. The next largest single-race group was White (12.6 million), followed by + +American Indian (1.5 million), Black (1.2 million) and Asian (300,000). + +At the same time, more than 20 million Hispanics identified with more than one race on + +the 2020 census, up from just 3 million in 2010. The sharp increase in multiracial + +Hispanics could be due to a number of factors, including changes to the census form that + +added space for written responses to the race question, as well as growing racial diversity + +among Hispanics. In particular, almost nine-in-ten Hispanics who identified with two or + +more races in 2020 said they were “some other race” (i.e., those who write in a response to + +the race question) and one of the specific races (such as White or Black). + +Growth in multiracial Hispanics comes primarily from those who identify as White and + +“some other race” – a population that grew from 1.6 million to 17.0 million over the past + +decade. The number of Hispanics who identify as White and no other race declined by + +almost the same amount – from 26.7 million to 12.6 million. + +Isn’t there an official definition of what it means to be Hispanic or Latino? + +In 1976, the U.S. Congress passed a law that mandated the collection and analysis of data + +for a specific ethnic group: “Americans of Spanish origin or descent.” The language of that + +legislation described this group as “Americans who identify themselves as being of + +Spanish-speaking background and trace their origin or descent from Mexico, Puerto Rico, + +Cuba, Central and South America, and other Spanish-speaking countries.” This includes + +20 Spanish-speaking nations from Latin America and Spain itself, but not Portugal or + +Portuguese-speaking Brazil. + +Standards for collecting data on Hispanics were developed by the Office of Management + +and Budget (OMB) in 1977 and revised in 1997. Using these standards, schools, public + +health facilities and other government entities and agencies keep track of how many + +Hispanics they serve – the primary goal of the 1976 law. + +Currently, the OMB is reconsidering how to collect and report statistics about race and + +ethnicity. The review is scheduled to be completed by 2024. + +What’s the difference between Hispanic and Latino? + +“Hispanic” and “Latino” are pan-ethnic terms meant to describe – and summarize – the + +population of people of that ethnic background living in the U.S. In practice, the Census + +Bureau most often uses the term “Hispanic,” while Pew Research Center uses the terms + +“Hispanic” and “Latino” interchangeably when describing this population. + + Some have drawn sharp distinctions between these two terms – saying, for example, that + +Hispanics are people from Spain or from Spanish-speaking countries in Latin America + +(this excludes Brazil, where Portuguese is the official language), while Latinos are people + +from Latin America regardless of language (this includes Brazil but excludes Spain and + +Portugal). Despite this debate, the “Hispanic” and “Latino” labels are not universally + +embraced by the population that has been labeled, even as they are widely used. + +Instead, Pew Research Center surveys show a preference for other terms to describe + +identity. A 2019 survey found that 47% of Hispanics most often describe themselves by + +their family’s country of origin, while 39% use the terms Latino or Hispanic and 14% most + +often describe themselves as American. + +As for a preference between the terms Hispanic or Latino to describe themselves, a 2018 + +survey found that 27% prefer “Hispanic,” 18% prefer “Latino” and the rest (54%) have no + +preference. These findings have changed little in nearly two decades of Pew Research + +Center surveys of Hispanic adults, which are conducted in English and Spanish. + +What is “Latinx”? + +Another pan-ethnic identity label is “Latinx,” which has emerged as an alternative to + +Hispanic and Latino in recent years. It is used by some news and entertainment outlets, + +corporations, local governments and universities to describe the nation’s Hispanic + +population. Yet the use of Latinx is not common practice, and the term’s emergence has + +generated debate about its appropriateness in a gendered language like Spanish. Some + +critics say it ignores the Spanish language and its gendered form, while others see Latinx + +as a gender- and LGBTQ-inclusive term. + + The term is not well known among the population it is meant to describe. Only 23% of U.S. + +adults who self-identify as Hispanic or Latino have heard of the term Latinx, and just 3% + +say they use it to describe themselves, according to a 2019 survey. Awareness and use of + +the term vary across subgroups, with Hispanics ages 18 to 29 among the most likely to + +have heard of the term – 42% say they have heard of it, compared with 7% of those 65 and + +older. Some of the most common use of Latinx is among Hispanic women ages 18 to 29 – + +14% say they use it, compared with 1% of Hispanic men in the same age group. + +The emergence of Latinx coincides with a global movement to introduce gender-neutral + +nouns and pronouns into many languages whose grammar has traditionally used male or + +female constructions. In the U.S., the first uses of Latinx appeared more than a decade + +ago. The term was added to a widely used English dictionary in 2018, reflecting its greater + +use. And a new gender-neutral pan-ethnic label, Latine, has emerged. It is largely used in + +Spanish. + +How do factors like language, a person’s last name and the background of their +parents play into whether someone is considered Hispanic? + +Our surveys of U.S. Hispanics have found many have an inclusive view of what it means to + +be Hispanic. A 2015 survey found 71% of Hispanic adults said speaking Spanish is not + +required to be considered Hispanic, and 84% said having a Spanish last name is not + +required to be considered Hispanic. Meanwhile, 32% of Hispanic adults said having both + + parents of Hispanic heritage or descent is an essential part of what being Hispanic means + +to them, according to a 2019 survey. + +Views of Hispanic identity may change in coming decades as broad societal changes, such + +as rising intermarriage rates, produce an increasingly diverse and multiracial U.S. + +population. + +In 2019, 30% of Hispanic newlyweds married someone who is not Hispanic; the Hispanic + +intermarriage rate is similar to that for Asians (29%) but higher than the rate among Black + +(18%) and White (12%) newlyweds. Among Hispanic newlyweds, 39% of those born in the + +U.S. married someone who is not Hispanic, compared with 17% of immigrants, according + +to an analysis of American Community Survey data. Among all married Hispanics, 20% + +had a spouse who is not Hispanic as of 2019. + +The Center’s 2015 survey of U.S. Hispanic adults found that 15% had at least one parent + +who is not Hispanic. This share rises to 29% among the U.S. born and 48% among the + +third or higher generation – those born in the U.S. with both parents who were also U.S. + +born. + +What role does skin color play in whether someone is Hispanic? + + As with race, Latinos can have a variety of skin tones. A 2021 survey of Latino adults + +showed respondents a palette of 10 skin colors; they were asked to choose which one most + +closely resembled their own. + +Latinos reported having a variety of skin tones, reflecting the diversity within the group. + +Eight-in-ten Latinos selected one of the four lightest skin colors, with the second-lightest + +ranking most common (28%), followed by the third (21%) and fourth lightest colors (17%). + +By contrast, only 3% of Latino respondents selected one of the four darkest skin colors. + +It’s worth noting that a majority of Latino adults (57%) say skin color shapes their daily life + +experiences at least somewhat. Most say having a darker skin color hurts Latinos’ ability to + +get ahead in the U.S. (62%), while having a lighter skin color helps Latinos get ahead + +(59%). + +What about Afro-Latinos? Are they Hispanic? + +Afro-Latino identity is distinct and can exist alongside a person’s Hispanic identity. The + +life experiences of Afro-Latinos are shaped by race, skin tone and other factors, in ways + +that differ from other Hispanics. While most Afro-Latinos identify as Hispanic or Latino, + +not all do, according to Pew Research Center estimates based on a survey of U.S. adults + +conducted from November 2019 to June 2020. + + In 2020, Center estimates found there were about 6 million Afro-Latino adults in the U.S., + +making up about 2% of the U.S. adult population and 12% of the adult Latino population. + +About one-in-seven Afro-Latinos – or an estimated 800,000 adults – do not identify as + +Hispanic. + +Can a person’s country of origin or ancestry affect whether or not they are +Hispanic? + +Similar to race and skin color, Hispanics can be of any country of origin or ancestry. One + +result of this diversity is that people from certain countries may be more likely to identify + +as Hispanic on census forms. For example, in a Pew Research Center analysis of the + +Census Bureau’s 2020 American Community Survey, nearly all immigrants from several + +Latin American and Caribbean countries called themselves Hispanic, including those from + +Mexico, Cuba and El Salvador (nearly 100% each). By comparison, 94% of immigrants + +from Paraguay and 92% from Argentina said so, as did 95% of immigrants from Spain and + +90% from Panama. + +What about Brazilians, Portuguese and Filipinos? Are they considered Hispanic? + +People with ancestries in Brazil, Portugal and the Philippines do not fit the federal + +government’s official definition of “Hispanic” because the countries are not Spanish- + +speaking. For the most part, people who trace their ancestry to just these countries are not + +counted as Hispanic by the Census Bureau even if they identify as Hispanic. Only about + +2%-3% of immigrants from Brazil are counted as Hispanic, as are about 1%-2% of + +immigrants from Portugal and the Philippines, according to the 2010- 2019 American + +Community Surveys. + +How many people with Hispanic ancestry do not identify as Hispanic? + + Of the 42.7 million adults with Hispanic ancestry living in the U.S. in 2015, an estimated 5 + +million people, or 11%, said they do not identify as Hispanic or Latino, according to a Pew + +Research Center survey of U.S. adults. These people aren’t counted as Hispanic in Center + +surveys. + +Notably, Hispanic self-identification among U.S. adults with Hispanic heritage varies + +across immigrant generations. Among immigrants from Latin America, nearly all identify + +as Hispanic. But by the fourth generation, only half of people with Hispanic heritage in the + +U.S. identify as Hispanic. + +How has the Census Bureau changed the way it counts Hispanics over time? + +The first year the Census Bureau asked everybody in the country about Hispanic ethnicity + +was in 1980. Some efforts were made before then to count people who today would be + +considered Hispanic. In the 1930 census, for example, an attempt to count Hispanics + +appeared as part of the race question, which had a category for “Mexican.” + +The first major attempt to estimate the size of the nation’s Hispanic population came in + +1970 and prompted widespread concerns among Hispanic organizations about an + +undercount. A portion of the U.S. population (5%) was asked if their origin or descent was + +from the following categories: “Mexican, Puerto Rican, Cuban, Central or South American, + + Other Spanish” and “No, none of these.” This approach had problems, among them an + +undercount of about 1 million Hispanics. + +One reason for this is that many second-generation Hispanics did not select one of the + +Hispanic groups because the question did not include terms like “Mexican American.” The + +question wording also resulted in hundreds of thousands of people living in the Southern + +or Central regions of the U.S. being mistakenly included in the “Central or South + +American” category. + +By 1980, the current approach – in which someone is asked if they are Hispanic – had + +taken hold, with some tweaks made to the question and response categories since then. In + +2000, for example, the term “Latino” was added to make the question read, “Is this person + +Spanish/Hispanic/Latino?” + +In recent years, the Census Bureau has studied an alternative approach to counting + +Hispanics that combines the questions that ask about Hispanic origin and race. This + +change did not appear in the 2020 census, though the race question was changed to allow + +for written responses to all race categories. The race and ethnicity questions could change + +for the 2030 census under a plan announced in June 2022 by the Office of Management + +and Budget. + +Note: This post was originally published on May 28, 2009, by Jeffrey S. Passel and Paul + +Taylor, former vice president of Pew Research Center. It has been updated a number of + +times since then. + +Topics Racial & Ethnic Identity, Hispanic/Latino Identity + +SHARE THIS LINK: + +https://pewrsr.ch/3UaUJpI + +    + +Mark Hugo Lopez is director of race and ethnicity research at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO TWITTER EMAIL + +Jens Manuel Krogstad is a senior writer and editor at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO EMAIL + + Jeffrey S. Passel is a senior demographer at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO EMAIL + +Sign up for our weekly newsletter +Fresh data delivered Saturday mornings + +Email address + +SIGN UP + +R E L A T E D + +REP O RT | NO V 4, 2021 + +Majority of Latinos Say Skin Color Impacts Opportunity in America and Shapes Daily Life + +SHO RT READ | SEP 24, 2020 + +The ways Hispanics describe their identity vary across immigrant generations + +SHO RT READ | AUG 24, 2020 + +Rising share of lawmakers – but few Republicans – are using the term Latinx on social media + +REP O RT | AUG 11, 2020 + +About One-in-Four U.S. Hispanics Have Heard of Latinx, but Just 3% Use It + +REP O RT | DEC 20, 2017 + +Hispanic Identity Fades Across Generations as Immigrant Connections Fall Away + +T O P I C S + +Hispanic/Latino Identity + +Racial & Ethnic Identity + +M O S T P O P U L A R + + India’s Sex Ratio at Birth Begins To Normalize + +Political Typology Quiz + +Two Decades Later, the Enduring Legacy of 9/11 + +Key findings about U.S. immigrants + +Modeling the Future of Religion in America + +1615 L St. NW, Suite 800 + +Washington, DC 20036 + +USA + +(+1) 202-419-4300 | Main + +(+1) 202-857-8562 | Fax + +(+1) 202-419-4372 | Media + +Inquiries + +RESEARCH TOPICS + +FOLLOW US + +Politics & Policy + +Family & Relationships + + + + Email Newsletters + +International Affairs + +Economy & Work + + + + Facebook + +Immigration & Migration + +Science + +Race & Ethnicity + +Internet & Technology + + + + Twitter + + + + Tumblr + +Religion + +News Habits & Media + + + + YouTube + +Generations & Age + +Methodological Research + + + + RSS + +Gender & LGBTQ + +Full topic list + +ABOUT PEW RESEARCH CENTER Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes and trends shaping +the world. It conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, media content analysis and other empirical social science research. Pew Research +Center does not take policy positions. It is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts. + +Copyright 2022 Pew Research Center About + +Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Reprints, Permissions & Use Policy + +Feedback Careers + +12345 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q254/random_k2/random_2.md b/q254/random_k2/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..306e12d21313f7ffcf04279a9a817cb3be1e4ff4 100644 --- a/q254/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q254/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,2837 +1,989 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +Fellow Shareholders, -2 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between - -them - - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a - -stable dividend - -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised - -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia - -and from our international network - - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive - -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend - -3 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - -Strategic priorities - -Financial targets - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. - -Insurance and Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Empower our -people - -RoTE1 - - >11% by 2020 - -Costs - - Positive jaws - -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) - -Capital -and -dividend - - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs - -subject to -regulatory -approval - -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ - -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% - -4 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -5 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Who we are - -Strategic differentiators - -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 - -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows - -#1 -global transaction -bank2 - -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 - -USD182bn -Total capital4 - -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank - -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, - -Middle East and Latin America - - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver - -shareholder value - -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with - -diversified business model - - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity - -management - - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for - -distribution to shareholders - -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research - -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include - -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts - -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) - -6 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -1 - -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking - -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 - -FY2017, revenue, USDbn - -Recognised as leading international -bank - -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 - -Leading market positions - -HSBC - -US Bank - -US Bank - -US Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -15.2 - -26% - -22% - -21% - -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 - -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 - -Asia - -US - -Europe - -RoTE Transaction Banking, % - ->20% - -HSBC -Transaction -Banking - -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 - -Banking -Industry -overall7 - -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 - -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 - -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 - -53% -of client -revenue -connected to -international -network - -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. - -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue - -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries - -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey - -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 - -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth - -HSBC has access to high growth markets - -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 - -Asia, Market shares2 - -+5.8% - -Asia - -Middle East - -Africa - -Latin America - -N. America - -Europe - -2017 - -2030E - -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 - -+6.1% - -Asia - -Middle East - -Africa - -Latin America - -N. America - -Europe - -CAGR - -7.4% - -7.4% - -6.5% - -6.0% - -4.3% - -4.6% - -CAGR - -7.1% - -7.8% - -8.0% - -5.7% - -4.4% - -5.4% - -29% Hong Kong - -12% PRD4 - -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) - -5% Singapore - -3% Malaysia - -Middle East, Market shares2 - -8% Saudi Arabia7 - -4% United Arab - -Emirates - -Latin America, Market shares2 - -8% Mexico - - Largest among international and - -regional banks3 - - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and - ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 - - Strong foundation in China / PRD to - -support future expansion - - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting - -with 28% market share6 - - Leading international bank in the Middle - -East8 - - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade - -finance9 - - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and - -Belt and Road Initiative10 - - #1 DCM in Middle East5 - - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on - -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA - -2017 - -2030E - -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes - -Japanese banks - -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees - -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 - -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) - -8 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -2 - -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows - -Aspiration - -Characteristics - -Markets - -Markets at -scale - -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” - -Markets as -leading -international -bank - -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” - - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% - -market share - - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments - - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore - - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 - - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) - - Australia - Canada - China - France - - Germany - India - Indonesia - US - -Markets to -connect the -network - -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” - - Targeted offering for - -international customers - - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where - -possible - - Network markets to - -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) - - Supporting subsidiaries of - -global customers - -% of adj. -revenue - -FY17 - -c.60% - -c.25% - -c.15% - -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC - -9 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -3 - -Signature balance sheet strength - -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) - -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 - -Customer accounts - -Balance Sheet - -Loans & advances to -customers - -Total equity - -1.4tn - -1.0tn - -198bn - -Total regulatory capital - -182bn - -Capital - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital ratio - -5.6% - -20.9% - -Advances to deposits ratio - -71% - -Funding and -liquidity - -Liquidity coverage ratio - -142% - -10 year PBT -volatility2 - -LICs / loans -and advances3 - -Advances to -deposits ratio - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital -ratio - -Liquid asset buffer - ->500bn - -CET1 ratio - -Peer group -average1 - -2.6x - -HSBC - -1.0x - -5.5%4 - -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. - -10 - -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -11 - - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth - -Transformation since 2011 - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 - - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by - -USD349bn or 29%1 - - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions - - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities - - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” - -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities - - Shifted business to Asia and - -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 - - Strengthened network to support - -global trade and capital flows - - Demonstrated ability to execute - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Growth - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Turnaround - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Customer - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service - -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -Empower our -people - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills - -Our People - -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis - -12 - - Strategic priorities - -1-3 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity - -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity - -CAGR --8% - -72.3 - -mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -+7% - -51.4 - -48.0 - -2011 - -2016 - -2017 - -2020 -Target - -1. ROE including PVIF - -Market -Growth - -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn - -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance - -Asia Wealth - -Asset Management -(Asia) - -Belt and Road - -Insurance -(Asia)1 - -ASEAN - -PRD - -UK -Ring-fenced Bank - -Hong Kong - -Transaction Banking/ -International network - -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) - -Cost of Equity - -RoTE - -13 - - Strategic priorities - -1 - -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia - ->3bn - ->1bn - ->0.2bn - -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -PBT, 2017 -USDbn - -11.4 - -7.5 - -A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments - -Revenue, 2017 USDbn - -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) - -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) - -ASEAN - -China - -India - -Australia - -Other Asia - -4.7 - -3.1 - -PRD - -0.2 - -2.4 - -2.4 - -0.9 - -0.9 - -2.1 - -1.2 - -0.5 - -0.9 - -0.4 - -0.8 - -B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing - -technology in PRD - -C - -Build leading Wealth Management business - - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater - -China and ASEAN - - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional - -clients - -D - -Expand our business in ASEAN - - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise - -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth - - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position - -14 - - Strategic priorities - -1A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn - -HSBC market -share, % - -USD0.9tn - -USD2.9tn - -10% - -CAGR -2005-17 - -24% - -2005 - -10% - -Asset growth - -25% - -20172 - -Leading market share across major products2 - -…with leading positions across major products3 - -Customer -accounts - -Loans and -advances to -customers - -DCM - -#1 - -#1 - -#1 - -Mortgages - -37% - -#1 - -Credit cards - ->40% - -Trade finance - -#1 - -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments - -Enhance -customer -experience - -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments - - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident - -Chinese customers - - Invest in insurance for sustainable - -market share growth - - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business - -Banking - - Explore partnerships to launch - -innovative solutions - - Capture new growth opportunities with - -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese - -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as - -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation - -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia - -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share - -15 - -excluding Japan - - Strategic priorities - -1B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) - -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -USDbn - -Revenue - -0.18 - -2014 - -0.22 - -2017 - ->USD1bn - -c.0.5 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - -Loans & advances to customers - ->20bn - -4.1 - -6.2 - ->10bn - -2014 - -2017 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank - -in China, opened for business in December 2017 - - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled - -since project launched in June 2015 - - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 - - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect - - Enhance corporate coverage to - -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading - - Broaden client base and drive for - -deposit-heavy product mix - -Emerging -Middle -Class - -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity - - Fully leverage capital market - -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation - -New business -capabilities - -16 - - Strategic priorities - -1C - -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth - -Rising wealth in Asia - -Private financial wealth1, USDtn - -2016-21E -CAGR - -223 - -Middle class in Asia2 - -# of people, bn - -2.5x - -152 - -E. Europe - -L. America - -MENA - -N. America - -34% - -W. Europe - -25% - -Japan - -10% - -Asia ex Japan - -21% - -166 - -33% - -24% - -9% - -23% - -33% - -5.6% - -Average household annual income3 - -2015 - -2030E - -USD‘000 - -2.3x - -22% - -3.5% - -7% - -1.7% - -28% - -9.9% - -2017 - -2030E - -HNWI financial wealth4 - -USDtrn - -2.0x - -2014 - -2016 - -2021E - -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 - -2017 - -2025E - -17 - -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities - -1C - -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today - -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -Wealth in -Asia - -Private -Bank - -RBWM -Wealth - -Insurance1 - -Asset -Management1 0.3 - -1. - -Includes manufacturing revenue only - -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) - - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater - -China - - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth - -0.7 - - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by - -investment in RM and product platform - - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary - -portfolio management and lombard lending - -Insurance - - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth - -customers, and strengthen front line - - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new - -distribution channels - - Exploring opportunities in mainland China - -Asset management - - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / - -GPB customers - - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China - -18 - -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities - -2 - -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 - -USD - -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion - -Opportunities and areas of investment - - HSBC is positioned for - -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 - - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: - -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme - -– More than 95% of technical - -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed - -Retail -banking - - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by - -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 - - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth - -and acquire new customers - - Leverage our unique global access to support - -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs - -Corporate -banking - - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ - - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) - -Digital and -customer -satisfaction - - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for - -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification - - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) - - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines - -and brands - -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite - -19 - - Strategic priorities - -3 - -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Investments are delivering - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance - -Trade Finance -rank1 - -Hong Kong -market share2 - -2015 - -2017 - -#1 - -#1 - - - -10.8% - -13.8% - -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management - -Average GLCM -balances +Roku delivered another strong quarter of operational and financial performance in Q1 2018. The secular shift from legacy TV +distribution to streaming continues unabated. Our purpose-built TV operating system and advertising platform continue to +lead the market. Moreover, our advertising and content partners are benefiting from our increasing scale. Nearly half of our +roughly 21 million active users have cut the cord or have never had a traditional pay TV subscription, which means that they +simply cannot be reached through linear TV. This makes our strategic position in the living room extremely valuable. In the +first quarter, our platform segment revenue more than doubled, as active accounts grew 47% year-over-year and ARPU +increased 50%. With strong business momentum and favorable industry trends, we are raising our full year 2018 outlook. -c$470bn +May 9, 2018 -c$530bn +A few Q1 2018 highlights: -Hong Kong -market share3 +• +• +• +• +• +• +• -22.8% +Total net revenue up 36% YoY to $136.6 million; +Platform revenue up 106% YoY to $75.1 million; +Gross profit up 62% YoY to $63.1 million; +Active accounts up 47% YoY to 20.8 million at quarter end; +Streaming Hours up 56% YoY to 5.1 billion hours; +Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) up 50% YoY to $15.07 (trailing 12-month basis); +One in four smart TVs sold in the U.S. were Roku TVs. -26.3% +Key Operating Metrics +Active Accounts (millions) +Streaming Hours (billions) +ARPU ($) -FX corporates -rank4 +Summary Financials ($ in millions) -FX institutional -rank4 +Platform +Player +Total net revenue -#1 +Platform gross profit +Player gross profit -#7 +Total gross profit - +Platform gross margin % +Player gross margin % -#1 +Total gross margin % -#3 +R&D +Sales and marketing +G&A + +Total operating expenses +Income (loss) from operations +Adjusted EBITDA 1 +Adjusted EBITDA margin % + +Q1 17 -Assets under -custody +Q2 17 + +Q3 17 -$6.2trn +Q4 17 -$7.7trn +Q1 18 -FX - -Securities -Services - -Digitise and grow Trade Finance - - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems - - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by - -investing in our channel and product capabilities - - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured - -trade - -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM - - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by - -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions - - Create new products and revenue streams - new - -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees - -FX business growth - - Grow the business through the continued development - -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model - - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise - -the customer experience - -Grow Securities Services business - -Market share5 - -5.4% - -5.8% - - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products - -Asia rank6 - -#1 - -#1 - -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey - -and services; invest in digital future - - - - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on - -asset managers and asset owners - -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making - -up c.82% of the market - -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen - -20 - - Strategic priorities - -4 - -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank - -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn - -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed - -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US - -2 +YoY % + +$ + + $ + +$ + +$ + +14.2 +3.3 +10.04 + +Q1 17 + +36.4 +63.7 +100.1 +28.1 +10.8 +38.8 +77.1 % +16.9 % +38.8 % +22.3 +14.1 +10.3 +46.7 +(7.8 ) +(4.4 ) +-4.4 % + +$ + +$ + +15.1 +3.5 +11.22 + +Q2 17 + +46.0 +53.7 +99.6 +34.2 +3.4 +37.6 +74.4 % +6.4 % +37.8 % +25.8 +14.7 +10.6 +51.0 +(13.4 ) +(9.6 ) +-9.7 % + +$ + +$ + +16.7 +3.8 +12.68 + +Q3 17 + +57.5 +67.3 +124.8 +44.6 +5.3 +49.9 +77.5 % +7.9 % +40.0 % +28.5 +16.2 +13.0 +57.8 +(7.9 ) +(3.7 ) +-2.9 % + +$ + +$ + +19.3 +4.3 +13.78 + +Q4 17 + +85.4 +102.8 +188.3 +63.7 +9.8 +73.5 +74.6 % +9.5 % +39.0 % +31.3 +19.1 +13.5 +64.0 +9.5 +14.4 +7.6 % + +20.8 +5.1 +15.07 + +47 % +56 % +50 % + +Q1 18 + +YoY % + +75.1 +61.5 +136.6 +53.4 +9.7 +63.1 +71.1 % +15.8 % +46.2 % +34.1 +20.3 +15.6 +70.0 +(6.9 ) +(0.8 ) +-0.6 % + +106 % +-3 % +36 % +90 % +-10 % +62 % +-595 bps +-114 bps +741 bps +53 % +45 % +51 % +50 % + N/A + N/A +381 bps + +Outlook ($ in millions) +Total net revenue +Total gross profit +Net loss +Adjusted EBITDA +1 Refer to the reconciliation of net loss to adjusted EBITDA in the non-gaap information. +2 Q2 2018E reconciling items between net loss and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA consist of stock-based compensation of approximately $6.0 million, +depreciation & amortization and other net adjustments of approximately $1.5 million, partially offset by interest and other income of approximately $0.3 +million. +3 Full Year 2018 reconciling items between net loss and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA consist of stock-based compensation of +approximately $24 million, depreciation and amortization and other net adjustments of approximately $8 million partially offset by interest +and other income of approximately $2 million. + +Full Year 2018E 3 +$685 - $705 +$290 - $305 +($40) - ($25) +($10) - $5 + +Q2 2018E 2 +$135 - $145 +$58 - $63 +($19) - ($14) +($12) - ($7) + +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 1 -0 - -US - -UK - -China - -France + Q1 2018 results and outlook + +Q1 revenue and gross profit came in ahead of our outlook, driven by better-than-expected Platform revenue and higher-than- +anticipated Player gross profits. In the quarter, revenue increased 36% year-over-year, gross profit grew 62%, and gross +margin expanded seven percentage points to 46%. Platform revenue exceeded player revenue for the first time at 55% of +total revenue, vs. 36% a year ago. Platform gross profit - a key business driver – was 85% of gross profit, vs. 72% a year earlier. +Adjusted EBITDA loss of ($0.8) million and net loss of ($6.6) million were much lower than the outlook we provided in +February. + +We saw strong momentum across our key operating metrics. Roku ended Q1 2018, with 20.8 million active accounts, up 47% +year-over-year. Half of the new accounts in the quarter came from licensed sources, primarily Roku TVs. Roku users streamed +5.1 billion hours in the quarter, up 56% year-over-year, with the fastest growth coming from ad-supported content. Trailing +12-month ARPU in the first quarter increased 50% year-over-year to a record $15.07, the fastest ARPU growth rate in over 18 +months as we continue to expand platform monetization and capture a larger share of TV ad budgets. We believe there is a +long runway for upside to ARPU from content distribution, audience development and advertising growth, as consumers +spend time streaming more ad-supported content, and as Roku gains access to a greater share of overall ad impressions. + +Platform revenue grew 106% year-over-year, with advertising revenue representing the largest driver of Platform segment +revenue growth. Platform gross profit increased 90% year-over-year while Platform gross margin dropped six percentage +points year-over-year to 71% as the anticipated mix shift to video advertising, which trends towards roughly 50% gross +margin, continues. Player revenue declined 3% as we continue to see positive unit growth coupled with our strategy of +shifting mix to lower priced players. + +Q1 operating expenses were $70 million, up 50% year-over-year, as we continued to invest in top talent across the +organization, with R&D up 53% year-over-year and sales and marketing up 45%, as we focus on growing advertising, Roku TV, +The Roku Channel and other new business opportunities. G&A grew 51% as we have made investments in back office +functions to support the increasing complexity of our business and ramp up to be a public company. These expenses should +scale over time. Roku ended the quarter with $161 million in cash and no debt. + +Based on the strong performance and trends we are seeing to date, we are raising our outlook for full year 2018. Our +profitability goal for the year is to operate our business at, or near, break-even on an adjusted EBITDA basis. As a reminder, +Q4 seasonality is a material component of our business with seasonal strength in both Platform and Player segments. We +expect this trend to continue in 2018 and estimate Q4 revenue could once again be roughly 37% of total annual revenue, +consistent with Q4 of last year. + +The secular shift of legacy TV to streaming + +The replatforming of the TV industry is occurring at a rapid pace as consumers continue to shift their time away from +traditional linear TV in search of a better TV experience. That's driving unparalleled industry disruption as content distribution +and TV advertising move to streaming platforms. Roku's industry leading streaming players and smart TVs have been +important enablers of the transition - and are key drivers of Roku's increasing scale. The average U.S. home has roughly three +TVs, and most lack a purpose-built TV OS. This creates a significant opportunity to sell more players and to replace older TVs +with Roku TVs. With linear TV ratings in sharp decline, advertisers and content owners must find new ways to reach cord +cutters, cord shavers and cord nevers. We believe the Roku platform is the perfect solution for this rapidly evolving +ecosystem. + +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -% of Group client outbound revenue - -Hong -Kong - -24% +2 -13% + Roku TV – The leading licensed TV platform -9% +Roku TV is the #1 licensed TV operating system in the U.S and is going from strength to strength. One in four smart TVs sold in +the U.S. in Q1 2018 were Roku TVs - that's up from one in five in 2017. In the quarter, we expanded our Funai Electric +relationship by extending the program to the Magnavox brand, and in April we added Sanyo (initially in Canada). There is +tremendous room for innovation in smart TVs and Roku is leading the way helping TV OEMs cover the broadest set of +consumer preferences, from $150 entry-level smart TVs to cutting-edge $1,000 4K UHD, HDR10, Dolby Vision smart TVs with +advanced features like full-array backlighting, local dimming and voice control. -6% +We believe virtually every TV OEM will eventually need to license a TV OS, as consumers shift to smart TVs with 4K displays, +and as OEMs focus on both cutting costs and boosting customer satisfaction. A case in point: TCL, now the #3 U.S. television +brand, is getting high-praise reviews for a new line of Roku TVs now on shelves in Walmart, Best Buy and other major +retailers. CNET recently wrote that the TCL 6 series "could be the most incredible TV value of 2018." -6% +With this strong momentum, we expect retail distribution of Roku TV models to grow in 2018. -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +Leading OTT content distribution for direct-to-consumer services -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +As one of the largest, most advanced content distribution and audience development platforms, Roku has become a key +destination for launching and marketing virtual pay TV services (or “virtual MVPDs”). Today, Roku offers one of the broadest +selections of direct-to-consumer services, including Sling TV, DirecTV Now, PlayStation Vue, Hulu Live, YouTube TV, fuboTV +and Philo. For many of these services, we are among the largest sources of trials, conversion and ongoing economics. -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +Our customer base of avid streamers also presents a major opportunity for specialist services, for example ESPN+, which will +be launching soon on Roku. Partners take advantage of our unique audience development tools to address consumer demand +for sports, news and other live programming. Roku has become a leading content aggregation point - the TV “home screen” - +for many OTT customers who may only be reachable in their living room via the Roku platform. -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +The Roku Channel – Expanding reach -Other +The Roku Channel aggregates content into a simple, friendly user interface for consumers, while providing content owners +with a one-stop, large scale platform to publish their content while Roku manages advanced promotion, engagement, and +monetization capabilities. -32% +We are seeing very strong engagement on The Roku Channel, and just eight months after launch, The Roku Channel is now a +top 15 channel on Roku devices based on hours streamed - and the #3 free ad-supported channel on the Roku platform. In +Q1, we expanded the content syndicated from channel partners and added more movies and TV shows from Lionsgate, MGM, +Sony Pictures Entertainment, Warner Bros. and other studios. Recently, we announced the addition of live news from ABC +News, Cheddar, People TV and others. -51% +We are exploring options for expanding The Roku Channel’s reach. In March, we announced that we will make The Roku +Channel available off the Roku platform starting this summer with Samsung TVs. We believe there is a significant opportunity +to take The Roku Channel beyond the Roku OS platform to other large-scale platforms. -68% +Building a direct-to-consumer (D2C) OTT service is a major challenge for many content owners. It requires the ability to +aggregate a very large audience, build critical mass of content, develop advanced software and user interfaces, to monetize – +for example with billing and advanced TV advertising – and manage churn and engagement. All of this requires sophisticated -USD +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -JP -Morgan +3 -Citigroup + software, big data and machine learning, and navigating complex regulatory frameworks. We believe content owners will +increasingly choose to distribute their content directly on Roku’s platform via The Roku Channel vs. creating their own D2C +service (or “channel”). -Bank of -America +The Roku OTT Advertising Platform – Capturing Share of TV Ad Budgets -HSBC +Linear TV ratings continue to decline. According to Nielsen, prime time linear TV ratings among 18 to 49-year olds have +declined by 40% over the last 4 years. As consumers shift their TV viewing to streaming, advertisers are increasingly turning to +OTT and the Roku platform to reach these audiences. Today, roughly 10% of all adults between 18 and 34 can only be reached +on TV on the Roku platform in the living room. We expect that number to grow, which should make our platform an even +more important way for brands to engage TV viewers. -BoNY -Mellon +We have built a sophisticated TV ad platform with advanced targeting and measurement capabilities. These capabilities, +together with our ability to reach viewers who have left the traditional TV ecosystem, position Roku to capture a growing +share of the roughly $70 billion annual U.S. TV advertising market. This year, for the first time, Roku has been running its first +TV “upfronts” meetings. Occurring in the spring each year, upfronts are the time of year when a majority of TV advertising is +planned and committed. This is a milestone moment for OTT, as advertisers have recognized that OTT must now be part of +their TV ad spending strategy. While it is still early days, we believe this is a significant moment for the industry and for Roku. -c.19% +In March, Roku held its second annual client event, Roku Ad Connect, where we hosted top agencies and advertising clients, +representing a significant portion of Roku’s projected 2018 ad revenues, and a majority of all U.S. ad spend annually. At this +event, we shared insights into TV ad industry trends and the solutions for advertisers facing declining linear TV viewership and +reach. One clear takeaway from the event was a consensus view that the shift to OTT is happening at an increasing pace. -Overall +As advertisers shift their spending to OTT, they are also benefiting from the increased effectiveness of OTT advertising. A +recent study by IPG and Magna concluded that ads on the Roku platform are 67% more effective per exposure at driving +purchase intent than traditional linear TV ads. Our ability to directly reach our highly engaged active user base with advanced +targeting and measurement is Roku’s primary advantage as it expands its position in the TV ads marketplace. -Hong Kong +Conclusion -Germany +This industry transformation to TV streaming is happening. Favorable industry trends and strong execution are driving our +continued strong financial performance. On May 20th, we'll celebrate National Streaming Day, with this year marking the 10th +anniversary of the launch of our first streaming player, which allowed users to stream Netflix to the TV for the first time. As +part of the celebration, we'll be ringing the opening bell at the Nasdaq Market Site on May 16 and turning Times Square +purple. It’s a great time to be in the streaming business! -UK +Thanks for your support and Happy Streaming! -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) +Sincerely, -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT +Anthony Wood, Founder & CEO -21 +Steve Louden, CFO -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 4 -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform - -The US has made progress over the past several years… - -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth - -Adjusted PBT1, USDm - -RoTE2 - -> 6%2 - -1,201 - -974 - -CML - -US Principal - -464 + Conference Call Webcast – 2pm PST May 9th, 2018 -494 +The Company will host a webcast of its conference call to discuss the Q1 2018 results at 2p.m. Pacific Time / 5p.m. Eastern +Time. Participants may access the live webcast in listen-only mode on the Roku investor relations website at ir.roku.com. An +archived webcast of the conference call will also be available at ir.roku.com following the call. -737 +Roku Business Basics -920 +For an introduction to Roku’s business see Roku 101 document on the investor relations website at ir.roku.com. -556 +About Roku, Inc. -387 +Roku pioneered streaming to the TV. We connect users to the streaming content they love, enable content publishers to build +and monetize large audiences, and provide advertisers with unique capabilities to engage consumers. Roku streaming players +and Roku TVTM models are available around the world through direct retail sales and licensing arrangements with TV OEMs +and service operators. Roku is headquartered in Los Gatos, Calif. U.S.A. -2014 +Investor Relations +James Samford +ir@roku.com -2015 +Use of Non-GAAP Measures -2016 +Press +Eric Savitz +esavitz@roku.com -2017 - -0.9%2,3 - -2017 - -PBT growth - -Future capital -actions - -2020 - -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration - -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild - - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 - - International client revenue4 booked in the US up - -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY - - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: +In addition to financial information prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States +(GAAP), this shareholder letter includes certain non-GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP measures include Adjusted +EBITDA and pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share. In order for Roku’s investors to be better able to compare its +current results with those of previous periods, Roku has shown a reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures as an +appendix to this letter. The Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation adjusts the related GAAP financial measures to exclude other +income (expense), net, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation and amortization, and income tax expense where +applicable. The pro forma basic and diluted net income (loss) per share reconciliation gives effect to the conversion of +outstanding convertible preferred stock using the as-if converted method into common shares as though the conversion had +occurred as of the beginning of the period. Also, the numerator has been adjusted to reverse the fair value adjustments +related to the convertible preferred stock warrants as they became warrants to purchase common stock at the time of our +initial public offering and at such time no longer required periodic revaluation. We believe these non-GAAP financial measures +are useful as a supplement in evaluating our ongoing operational performance and enhancing an overall understanding of our +past financial performance. However, these non-GAAP financial measures have limitations, and you should not consider them +in isolation or as a substitute for our GAAP financial information. -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly +Forward-Looking Statements -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion +This shareholder letter contains “forward-looking” statements that are based on our beliefs and assumptions and on +information currently available to us. Forward-looking statements include all statements that are not historical facts and can +be identified by terms such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “could,” “seek,” “estimate,” “intend,” “may,” “plan,” “potential,” +“predict,” “project,” “should,” “will,” “would” or similar expressions and the negatives of those terms. -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- +Forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause our actual +results, performance or achievements to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements +expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements represent our beliefs and assumptions +only as of the date of this letter. These statements include our financial outlook for the second quarter of 2018 and for the full -return products and business banking - -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national - -clients in the US - - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in - -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions - - Return to regular dividend payments to Group - -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers - -22 - -to 2017 - - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 5 -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 - -GB&M - -34% - -CMB - -35% - -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre - -14% -2% -15% - -c.30% - -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth - -c.35% - -Distribution - -15-20% - -2020 -target - -c.7% - -RWA -optimisation - - Develop distribution - -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending - - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom + fiscal year, the momentum in our Roku TV program, the growth of our platform segment, the expansion of The Roku Channel, +the evolution of the TV streaming ecosystem and continued development of our advertising business and the content we +make available to consumers on our platform, the growth in ARPU and active accounts and our overall business trajectory. +Except as required by law, we assume no obligation to update these forward-looking statements publicly, or to update the +reasons actual results could differ materially from those anticipated in the forward-looking statements, even if new +information becomes available in the future. Further information on factors that could cause actual results to differ +materially from the results anticipated by our forward-looking statements is included in the reports we have filed with the +Securities and Exchange Commission, including our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2017. -23 - - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 6 -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment - -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS (in thousands, except per share data) +(unaudited) - Investments aligned to strategic priorities +Net Revenue: +Platform +Player - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term +Total net revenue - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and +Cost of Revenue: +Platform (1) +Player (1) -31.1 +Total cost of revenue -c.4 +Gross Profit: +Platform +Player -4.5-5 +Total gross profit -5.5-6 +Operating Expenses: -6-6.5 +Research and development (1) +Sales and marketing (1) +General and administrative (1) +Total operating expenses -revenue development +Loss from Operations +Other Income (Expense), Net: - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from +Interest expense +Change in fair value of preferred stock warrant liability +Other income, net -within the cost base of the Group +Total other income (expense), net -Revenue +Loss Before Income Taxes +Income tax expense +Net Loss attributable to common stockholders +Net Loss per share attributable to common + stockholders—basic and diluted +Weighted-average shares used in computing net income (loss) per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted -Total -operating -expenses +(1) Stock-based compensation was allocated as follows: -Investments +Cost of platform revenue +Cost of player revenue +Research and development +Sales and marketing +General and administration -Costs (ex -investments) +Total stock-based compensation -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity - - Implement strong cost discipline and control - -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market - -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains - -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity - - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each - -year 2018-2020 - -2017 +Three Months Ended +March 31, 2018 -2019 - -2020 - -Jaws1 - -positive - -positive - -positive - -positive - -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve - -24 - - Strategic priorities - -7 - -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework - -Investment -categories - -Description - -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 +March 31, +2017 - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) + $ - Investments in new +75,077 $ +61,499 +136,576 -opportunities +36,415 +63,678 +100,093 - Improve operational +21,666 +51,798 +73,464 -efficiency in order to lower -cost base +53,411 +9,701 +63,112 - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 +34,126 +20,318 +15,570 +70,014 +(6,902 ) - Deliver robust solution design +(51 ) +— +448 +397 +(6,505 ) +129 +(6,634 ) $ -with additional franchise -benefits +8,343 +52,910 +61,253 - Turnaround of existing businesses +28,072 +10,768 +38,840 -(e.g. US) +22,342 +14,055 +10,278 +46,675 +(7,835 ) - Investing in expanding our businesses +(167 ) +(735 ) +83 +(819 ) +(8,654 ) +48 +(8,702 ) -(e.g. PRD) +(0.07 ) $ - Productivity programmes +(1.79 ) -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) +99,488 - Core infrastructure replacement or +4,850 -modernisation (e.g. US) +19 +44 +2,296 +1,110 +960 +4,429 -c.1/3 + $ - Implement required + $ - Deliver in cost +21 +36 +888 +601 +629 +2,175 - Implement regulatory programmes + $ -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security + $ -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits + $ -(e.g. IFRS 9) + $ - Strengthen capabilities to manage +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -financial crime risk +7 - Increase cyber security measures + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (in thousands, except share data) +(unaudited) + +Assets +Current Assets: +Cash +Accounts receivable, net of allowances +Inventories +Prepaid expenses and other current assets +Deferred cost of revenue +Total current assets +Property and equipment, net +Deferred cost of revenue, non-current portion +Intangible assets, net +Goodwill +Other non-current assets + +Total Assets +Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity +Current Liabilities: + +Accounts payable and accrued liabilities +Deferred revenue, current portion + +Total current liabilities +Deferred revenue, non-current portion +Other long-term liabilities +Total Liabilities +Stockholders’ Equity: + +Preferred stock, $0.0001 par value +Common stock, $0.0001 par value +Additional paid-in capital +Accumulated deficit + +Total stockholders’ equity +Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity + +As of + +March 31, +2018 -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 +December 31, +2017 -USD15-17bn + $ -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities + $ -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure + $ -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability + $ -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers +160,750 $ +106,094 +38,062 +30,546 +1,359 +336,811 +16,835 +— +1,892 +1,382 +3,560 +360,480 $ -1. P&L basis +111,776 $ +33,948 +145,724 +13,549 +7,731 +167,004 -25 +— +10 +445,139 +(251,673 ) +193,476 +360,480 $ + +177,250 +120,553 +32,740 +11,367 +3,007 +344,917 +14,736 +5,403 +2,030 +1,382 +3,429 +371,897 + +128,757 +34,501 +163,258 +48,511 +7,849 +219,618 + +— +10 +435,607 +(283,338 ) +152,279 +371,897 - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 8 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation - -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end - -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days - - Strengthen accountability, decision- - -to 10 (Private Banking) - -making - - Clarify roles within the organisation’s - -matrix - -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients - -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 - - Building capabilities for continuous - -improvement - -Streamlining governance - - Reducing number of + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS (in thousands) +(unaudited) -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 +Cash flows from operating activities: - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance +Net loss +Adjustments to reconcile net loss to net cash provided by (used in) operating activities: - Embed throughout the organisation + $ -and for all legal entities +(6,634 ) $ -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership +(8,702 ) - +Three Months Ended -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working - - Balanced scorecards to incentivise - -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation - -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online - - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills - -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC - -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of - -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and - -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths - - Build a diverse workforce - -26 - - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates - -Strategic priorities - -Targeted outcome by 2020 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and +March 31, +2018 - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian +March 31, +2017 -franchise +Depreciation and amortization +Stock-based compensation expense +Provision for doubtful accounts +Change in fair value of preferred stock warrant liability +Noncash interest expense +Loss from exit of facilities +Changes in operating assets and liabilities: - Market share gains in 8 scale markets +Accounts receivable +Inventories +Prepaid expenses and other current assets +Deferred cost of revenue +Other noncurrent assets +Accounts payable +Accrued liabilities +Other long-term liabilities +Deferred revenue -Asset Management) +Net cash provided by (used in) operating activities -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy +Cash flows from investing activities: - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 +Purchase of property and equipment -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network +Net cash used in investing activities - Market share gains +Cash flows from financing activities: +Repayments of borrowings +Proceeds from exercise of stock options, net of repurchases +Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from +Net Increase (Decrease) In Cash +Cash—Beginning of period +Cash—End of period -international network +Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information: - Market share gains in Transaction Banking +Cash paid for interest -Turn around our US business +Cash paid for income taxes - US RoTE >6% +Supplemental disclosures of noncash investing and financing activities: -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses +Unpaid portion of property and equipment purchases -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains +1,656 +4,429 +201 +— +— +129 -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial +26,986 +(5,430 ) +(11,643 ) +2,090 +(353 ) +(14,884 ) +(3,590 ) +(118 ) +(7,476 ) +(14,637 ) -crime standards +(3,407 ) +(3,407 ) - Increase in asset productivity +— +1,544 +1,544 +(16,500 ) +177,250 +160,750 $ - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, +0 $ -each financial year +180 $ - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 +1,247 +2,175 +161 +735 +20 +— + +18,251 +5,712 +(2,572 ) +(425 ) +(2,949 ) +(2,767 ) +(125 ) +3,797 +11,681 +26,239 + +(1,560 ) +(1,560 ) + +(15,000 ) +473 +(14,527 ) +10,152 +34,562 +44,714 + +136 -8 +29 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +1,460 $ - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 +1,166 -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics + $ -27 + $ - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda + $ -1 + $ -2 +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -3 +9 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength + ROKU, INC. +NON-GAAP INFORMATION (in thousands, except per share data) +(unaudited) -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Reconciliation of Net Loss to Adjusted EBITDA: +Net loss +Other (income) expense, net +Stock-based compensation +Depreciation and amortization +Income tax expense -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Adjusted EBITDA -28 +Pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share +Numerator: - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 +Net loss attributable to common stock holders +Add: Change in fair value of convertible preferred stock warrant liability +Net loss attributable to common stockholders used in + computing pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share -Reported RoTE walk1 +Denominator: -% +Weighted-average shares used in computing net loss per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted +Add: Pro forma adjustments +Weighted-average shares used in computing pro forma net loss per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted -8.7 +Three Months Ended -6.8 +March 31, +2018 +March 31, 2017 -Reported - -Sig items - -2017 ex- -sig items - -Interest -rate rises2 - -UK -growth - -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance - -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network - -US turn- -around3 - -Investments - -Other4 - -ROE -Reported -5.9% +(6,634 ) $ +(397 ) +4,429 +1,656 +129 +(817 ) $ -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements +(8,702 ) +819 +2,175 +1,247 +48 +(4,413 ) -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval +(6,634 ) $ +— -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items +(8,702 ) +735 -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency + $ - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology + $ ->11 + $ - Delivering positive + $ -adjusted jaws +(6,634 ) $ - Increasing capital +(7,967 ) -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity +99,488 +— - Sustaining dividend, +99,488 -supported by share buy- -backs5 +4,850 +80,844 - With >14% CET1 ratio +85,694 -2020 -Reported -(target) +(0.09 ) ->10% +Pro forma net loss per share—basic and diluted -29 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution - -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 - -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders - -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 - -12-13% - -Surplus equity3 - -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 - -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses - -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally - -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 - -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items - -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing - -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base - -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes - ->14% - -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval - -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D - -s -r -o -t -c -a -f - -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e - -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R - -Higher risk weights -under local rules - -Diversification -benefit / other - -Stress testing - -Anticipated -regulatory changes - -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. - -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators - -30 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion - - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest - -growth markets - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and - -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular + $ -in Asia and from our international network +(0.07 ) $ -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -- Complete the turnaround in the US - -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while - -delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for - -sustained dividends - -31 - - 32 +10 diff --git a/q254/random_k4/question.json b/q254/random_k4/question.json index 748bc542886597ac45b21821c07ea1a4a68e2f7b..d6d7bd6d534d8681ca880cff18e1217c59000734 100644 --- a/q254/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q254/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ADOBE_2015_10K.pdf", - "0a89b981c2736e87bac48a090e1a3e60dd8a4e0f.pdf", - "web_e1c54bfb8b64fa3e.pdf", - "web_9c7f968fcc2ae28a.pdf", - "web_db15f36044519c81.pdf" + "sheet_q0_pew_archived.pdf", + "web_f5c6c7f633f7f239.pdf", + "web_6a55c713826db217.pdf", + "web_cfc8463d4b8b98ee.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q254/random_k4/random_1.md b/q254/random_k4/random_1.md index 16de3e3316b1e3bb316b878e17b05640d996b000..9688678899fe06a07991c950d5781380310ca4e6 100644 --- a/q254/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q254/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1070 +1,622 @@ -SPD-RAG: Sub-Agent Per Document Retrieval-Augmented Generation -| | YagizCanAkay1 | | | MuhammedYusufKartal1 | | | EsraAlparslan1 | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | FarukOrtakoyluoglu1 | | ArdaAkpinar2 | | | | | | | -1TOBBUniversityofEconomicsandTechnology 2OSTIMTechnicalUniversity -{y.akay, m.kartal, ealparslan, fortakoyluoglu}@etu.edu.tr 230206003@ostimteknik.edu.tr -| | | Abstract | | | andcommon,yetexposecriticalcoverageandrea- | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -soningbottlenecksincurrentNLPsystems. -Answeringcomplex,real-worldqueriesoften -6202 raM 9 ]LC.sc[ 1v92380.3062:viXra Traditionalsingle-indexorsingle-agentretrieval -requiressynthesizingfactsscatteredacrossvast -| | | | | | systemsstruggleto | | maintainbothscalability | | | | and | -| -------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | corpora. | In these | settings, | stan- | | | | | | | | -contextualrelevanceoverlarge,heterogeneouscor- -| dard retrieval-augmented | | | generation | (RAG) | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | pora, especially | | for long | or structurally | | complex | | -pipelinessufferfromincompleteevidencecov- -erage,whilelong-contextlargelanguagemod- documents. Standard RAG pipelines retrieve a -| | | | | | fixed number | | of documents | K | and process | | them | -| ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -| els (LLMs) | struggle | to reason | reliably | over | | | | | | | | -massive inputs. We introduce SPD-RAG, a withinasinglecontextwindow(Lewisetal.,2020), -hierarchicalmulti-agentframeworkforexhaus- -whichfailswhenanswersdependoninformation -tivecross-documentquestionansweringthatde- -distributedacrossmanydocuments,sinceevidence -composestheproblemalongthedocumentaxis. -| | | | | | beyondthetop-K | | resultsistypicallydiscardedin | | | | | -| ---- | -------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ----------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --- | -| Each | document | is processed | by a | dedicated | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | a single | retrieval | pass. | Long-context | | LLMs | ex- | -document-levelagentoperatingonlyonitsown -content,enablingfocusedretrieval,whileaco- tendcontextwindowsto128K–2Mtokens(Gemini -| | | | | | Teametal.,2024), | | butempiricalevidenceshows | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ordinator | dispatches | tasks | to relevant | agents | | | | | | | | -and aggregates their partial answers. Agent thatreasoningqualitydegradessignificantlyascon- -outputsaresynthesizedbymergingpartialan- text length increases (Liu et al., 2023). This sug- -swersthroughatoken-boundedsynthesislayer -| | | | | | gests that | the | bottleneck | is not | only | retrieval, | but | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | -(whichsupportsrecursivemap-reduceformas- -alsoreasoningatscaleovermanydocumentsand -| sivecorpora). | | Thisdocument-levelspecializa- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -hundredsofthousandsoftokens. -tionwithcentralizedfusionimprovesscalabil- -ityandanswerqualityinheterogeneousmulti- In this work, we introduce SPD-RAG -| | | | | | (Sub-agent | per | Document | Retrieval-Augmented | | | | -| -------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| document | settings | while | yielding | a modular, | | | | | | | | -extensibleretrievalpipeline. OntheLOONG Generation),ahierarchicalmulti-agentarchitecture -benchmark (EMNLP 2024) for long-context forexhaustivemulti-documentquestionanswering -multi-document QA, SPD-RAG achieves an thatfactorstheproblemalongthedocumentaxis -AvgScoreof58.1(GPT-5evaluation),outper- -| | | | | | rather than | the | task axis. | Instead | | of forcing | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -formingNormalRAG(33.0)andAgenticRAG -| | | | | | single model | | to hunt through | | a massive | | global | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -(32.8)whileusingonly38%oftheAPIcostof -| | | | | | index, SPD-RAG | | uses | a central | coordinator | | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | -afull-contextbaseline(68.0). -| | | | | | decompose | the | user’s | query into | shared | instruc- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -1 Introduction tions. It then deploys a dedicated, cost-efficient -| | | | | | sub-agenttoeachdocumentinthecorpus. | | | | | | These | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -Large language models (LLMs) and the agentic agents operate entirely in parallel, treating their -systems built around them are increasingly used assigneddocumentsasisolatedretrievaluniverses -forcomplexinformationsearchtasks(Guoetal., -| | | | | | to extract | relevant | findings. | Finally, | | a synthesis | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -2024). Real-worldquestionsoftenrequiresynthe- -| | | | | | model | aggregates | these | document-grounded | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -sizingevidencescatteredacrossmanydocuments, findings—employingarecursivemergingfallback -suchasassessingacompany’sfinancialrisksacross -| | | | | | for exceptionally | | large | corpora—to | | construct | a | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | -yearsofreportsorintegratingfindingsfrommul- -| | | | | | comprehensive, | | final answer. | | Our codebase | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | -tiplescientificpapers.1 -| | | Suchquestionsarenatural | | | datasetsusedinthispapercanbefoundat | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -https://github.com/NebulAICompany/ -| 1Examples | inspired | by scenarios | in the | Loong bench- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| mark(Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | | SPD-RAG. | | | | | | | - -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: tasks,butthatmulti-agentoverheadgrowssuperlin- -early. Theirresultthatindependentagentsamplify -• WeproposeSPD-RAG,ahierarchicalmulti- -errorsby17.2×comparedto4.4×forcentralized -agentframeworkthatcombinesper-document -systemsdirectlymotivatesourcoordinator-based -agentic RAG with a centralized synthesis design. Thetaxonomyofhierarchicalmulti-agent -layer, where cost-efficient document agents systemsbyMoore(2025)furtherclassifiesdesign -| are coordinated | by a | smarter coordinator | | | | | | | -| --------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | patternsalongfiveaxes: | | controlhierarchy,informa- | | | -agent,enablingdocument-levelspecialization -| | | | | tion flow, | role delegation, | temporal | layering, | and | -| ----------------- | -------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| and parallel | execution | while allowing | each | communicationstructure. | | | | | -| document | to be analyzed | in depth | to ensure | | | | | | -| that all relevant | information | is incorporated | | | | | | | -2.2 LongDocumentandMulti-DocumentQA -withoutmissingcriticalevidence. -| | | | | Long documents | that | exceed | LLM context | win- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -• WeevaluateontheLoongbenchmark(Wang -| | | | | dows are | often handled | via | divide-and-conquer | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -etal.,2024a),whichincludesmulti-document -| | | | | strategies. | LLM×MapReduce(Zhouetal.,2025) | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -| QA instances | over financial | reports | and aca- | | | | | | -| | | | | formalizestwokeychallenges: | | | inter-chunkdepen- | | -| demic papers | with an | average of | 11 docu- | | | | | | -dency(onechunkdependsoncontextfromanother) -mentsperinstanceandcontextlengthsfrom -andinter-chunkconflict(chunksprovidecontradic- -| 10K to beyond | 250K | tokens, and | show that | | | | | | -| ------------- | ---- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -toryinformation),andproposesstructuredinforma- -oursystemsubstantiallyoutperformsstandard -tionprotocolsandin-contextconfidencecalibration -RAGandAgenticRAGbaselinesunderGPT- -| | | | | tomitigatethem. | ToM(Guoetal.,2025)extends | | | | -| -------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | --------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | -| 5-judged | Avg Score (adapted | from | Loong’s | | | | | | -| | | | | this approach | with a | hierarchical | DocTree | repre- | -GPT-4-judgedprotocol;see§4.3),withgains -sentationforrecursivereasoning. -| of around | +25 points | (76% higher | average | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Formulti-documentQA,LongAgent(Zhaoetal., -score)comparedtoNormalRAGandAgentic -| | | | | 2024) splits | a 128K-token | document | | into chunks | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | -RAGbaselines. -| | | | | assigned | to member | agents, with | a leader | agent | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ---------------- | ----- | -| | | | | orchestrating | discussionsand | | inter-membercom- | | -• Weanalyzeablations,documenttypeandtask -complexityeffects,andcost–qualitytradeoffs, munication to reduce hallucinations. However, -showingthat SPD-RAGattainsover85%of LongAgenttargetsasinglelongdocumentrather -thanmultipleindependentdocumentsthatmaycon- -| full-context | baseline quality | at roughly | 38% | | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | flict. DocAgent | (Sun | et al., 2025) | uses | a multi- | -oftheAPIcost. -| | | | | agent framework | that | mimics | human | reading via | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | -2 RelatedWork -atree-structuredoutlineandrevieweragent,while -| | | | | MDocAgent | (Han et | al., 2025) | employs | five spe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | -2.1 LLM-BasedMulti-AgentSystems -| | | | | cialized | agents for multi-modal | | document | under- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -LLM-basedmulti-agentsystemsareincreasingly -standing. -| used for complex | task solving. | Guo et | al. (2024) | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -provideacomprehensivesurveyofagentprofiles, -2.3 HierarchicalandRecursive -communicationprotocols,andcollaborationstrate- -Summarization -| gies. Hierarchical | architectures | such | as MegaA- | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -gent(Wangetal.,2024b),whichdemonstratesau- Ourhierarchicalmergingmechanismbuildsontree- -tonomouscooperationamongupto590agentsvia basedretrievalandrecursivesummarization. RAP- -multi-leveltaskdecomposition,andAgentOrches- TOR(Sarthietal.,2024)recursivelyembeds,clus- -tra(Zhangetal.,2025),whichachievesstate-of-the- ters, and summarizes text chunks to construct a -artperformanceonGAIAusingacentralplanning bottom-uptreewithmultipleabstractionlevels;re- -agent and specialized sub-agents, exemplify this trievingfromtheappropriatelevelyieldsa20%ab- -| trend. | | | | soluteaccuracygainonQuALITY.OuandLapata | | | | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Scalinglawsformulti-agentsystemsofferquan- (2025)showthathierarchicalmergingcanamplify -titativeguidanceforarchitecturedesign. Kimetal. hallucinationsduringrecursivesummarizationand -(2025)evaluate180configurationsacrossfivear- proposecontext-awareaugmentationstrategiesthat -chitectures, finding that centralized coordination replaceintermediatesummarieswithrelevantinput -yields an 80.9% improvement on parallelizable context,whichweadoptinourmergingprotocol. - -2.4 Graph-BasedDocumentAnalysis 3 Methodology -Figure 1 presents an overview of the SPD-RAG -Graph-based document analysis is particu- -architecture. Thesystemprocessesaquerythrough -larly effective for global sensemaking queries. -three layers: the Coordination Layer (§3.1), the -GraphRAG(Edgeetal.,2024)constructsaknowl- -ParallelRetrievalLayer(§3.2),andtheSynthesis -edge graph of entities and relations from source -Layer(§3.3). -documents and applies hierarchical community -detection(e.g.,theLeidenalgorithm(Traagetal., -3.1 CoordinationLayer -2019)) to obtain multi-level communities with -Given a query q and corpus D, the system first -textual summaries. At query time, it retrieves -processes the query through a coordinator agent. -relevant communities, elicits community-level -The coordinator’s role is to decompose the user -partial answers, and aggregates them via a -query into a Shared Instruction Set for Docu- -map–reduce–styleprocedure. AsurveyonLLM- -ments and Synthesis Directives. It generates a -empoweredknowledgegraphconstruction(Bian, -WriteTodosstructuredobjectcontaining(a)alist -2025) highlights how LLMs are reshaping the -of sub_agent_todos: atomic, self-contained ex- -classical knowledge graph pipeline across three -traction tasks specifying exactly what fields, en- -key stages: ontology engineering, knowledge -tities, or numeric values to extract (the shared in- -extraction, and knowledge fusion. Our work is -structions);and(b)asynthesis_directive(2–4 -complementary: instead of inducing an explicit -sentences) instructing the downstream Synthesis -knowledge graph, SPD-RAG operates directly -Layeronhowtoprioritizeandstructurethemerged -over agent-produced textual summaries and -response. -performs similarity-guided recursive synthesis -acrossmanydocuments. 3.2 ParallelRetrievalLayer -Weassignadedicatedsub-agentα toeachdocu- -i -mentd inthecorpus. Eachsub-agentoperatesas -2.5 BenchmarksforMulti-Document i -anindependentRAGloopoveritsassigneddocu- -Reasoning -ment,guidedbythesharedinstructionsetfromthe -The Loong benchmark (Wang et al., 2024a) CoordinationLayer. -evaluates long-context LLMs on extended multi- -Document-Scoped Retrieval and Reasoning. -document QA where every document is relevant -Each document d serves as an isolated retrieval -i -("Leave No Document Behind") across financial, -universe; the assigned sub-agent is strictly con- -legal, and academic domains in English and Chi- -strainedtosearchtoolcallswithind , preventing -i -nese. Itspansfourtasktypeswithcontextlengths -cross-documentdistractorchunksfromdegrading -from 10K to over 250K tokens, and even strong -local extraction. Each sub-agent receives the -frontier models achieve only modest Avg Scores -originalqueryq,itsassigneddocumentname,and -andmediumperfect-answerrates,underscoringthe -thesharedinstructionset(todolist),thenoperates -difficultyofreasoningovermanylong,all-relevant -in an iterative retrieve-and-reason loop. On each -documents. -turn, the agent either issues a search action (a -Complementarydatasetsprobeotheraspectsof focused query string) or a finalize action that -multi-document reasoning. MoNaCo (Wolfson terminates the loop and emits the document- -et al., 2025) focuses on natural questions over groundedfindings. Thesub-agentpromptinstructs -dozensofWikipediapages,MEBench(Linetal., the agent to attempt at least 2 focused searches -2025)onhigh-entity-densityQA,FanOutQA(Zhu before concluding a piece of information is -et al., 2024) on multi-hop questions with absent, with a total cap of 5 search calls across -long cross-document evidence chains, and all tasks. Each search action triggers dense -HoloBench (Maekawa et al., 2024) on database- vector retrieval over the sub-agent’s dedicated -style aggregation over unstructured text. Taken per-documentQdrantindex. ThisretrievalusesCo- -together, these benchmarks show that scalable hereembed-v4.0embeddings(1536-dimensional, -multi-document reasoning remains an open cosine similarity) to fetch the top k = 15 most -challenge,withLoongemphasizingtheespecially similar chunks. These chunks are then re-ranked -demandingall-relevant,long-contextregime. byCoherererank-v4.0-fasttoyieldafinalset - -| | | | | Figure1: | OverviewofSPD-RAGArchitecture. | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of top_n = 5 chunks per search. The documents Similarity-Ordered Merge & Synthesis. -t, -are split into chunks offline using LangChain’s In iteration we maintain a set of find- -RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter in Mark- ings/summaries S(t) = {s (t) ,...,s (t) }. We -| | | | | | | | | | | | 1 | n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downmodewithachunksizeof1000tokensand embed each summary using Cohere embed-v4.0 -| 250-tokenoverlap. | | | | | | | and compute | | a cosine-similarity | | | matrix | via | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -sklearn.metrics.pairwise.cosine_similarity. -| FindingsOutput. | | | Wedenotethefindingsofeach | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | This | is converted | | to a | distance | matrix | | -sub-agentas -| | | | | | | | | | | (t) (t) | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | D = | 1 − | cos(s | ,s ), | which | is passed | to | -| | | | | | | | ij | | | i j | | | | -o = α (q,d ) = ⟨s ,r ⟩ (1) AgglomerativeClustering with n_clusters=1, -| | | i | i i | i | i | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | linkage="average" | | | (UPGMA), | | producing | a | -| where | s is | the natural | | language | findings | re- | | | | | | | | -i -completedendrogramoverallcurrentsummaries. -| port from | d | and | r ∈ | [0,1] is | a scalar | rele- | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | -| | i | | i | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | We traverse | the | merge | tree | bottom-up, | greedily | | -| vance/confidencescore. | | | Theseoutputsarepassed | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | accumulating | | nodes | into a batch | as | long as | the | -totheSynthesisLayer. -| | | | | | | | total tiktoken | | count | does not | exceed | the target | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | -| Parallelism. | | All | RAG | loops for | the | docu- | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | budget | of B | = 750,000 | tokens. | | Semantically | | -ments are dispatched concurrently via Lang- similarsummariesaregroupedfirst,soeachbatch -Graph’s Send API fan-out, which emits one contains the most similar available summaries -| Send("document_sub_agent_node", | | | | | ...) | per | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withinthetokenlimit. -documentandexecutesalltargetsinparallelwithin -LangGraph’sasyncruntime. AggregateandSynthesizeFindings. Foreach -batch,anLLMispromptedwiththeconcatenated -3.3 SynthesisLayer -| | | | | | | | findings, | the synthesis | | directive, | and | the original | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -WhilemodernLLMsfeatureextensivecontextwin- queryq toproduceanaggregatedandsynthesized -dows,synthesizinghundredsofdocumentreports -| | | | | | | | summary. | Allbatchsynthesiscallswithinanitera- | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -can still exceed these limits or cause ’lost in the tionareissuedconcurrentlyviaasyncio.gather. -middle’degradation. Tofuture-proofthearchitec- Themergedsummariesformtheinputforthenext -| ture for | massive | corpora, | | the Synthesis | Layer | is | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | -| | | | | | | | iteration | S(t+1). | The | same | SYNTHESIS | prompt | | -designedasadynamicmap-reducepipelinethatag- -| | | | | | | | used at | every | level | of the | merging | tree is | ap- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | -gregatesfindingsrecursively. TheSynthesisLayer plied even at the final level—there is no separate -receives the synthesis directives from the Coor- synthesis-onlyprompt. -| dination | Layer | and | the findings | {o | ,o ,...,o | } | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | 1 2 | n | | | | | | | | -from the Parallel Retrieval Layer. It aggregates ContextSizeConditionandOutput. Thelayer -andsynthesizesthefindingsrecursivelythrougha evaluates whether the total findings size exceeds -similarity-orderedprocessuntilthetotalfindings the context size threshold (i.e., |S(t+1)| > 1). If -sizefallswithinthetargetcontextsizetoproduce theconditionistrue,theprocessloopsbacktothe -thefinaloutput. similarity-orderedmergeandsynthesisstep. Ifthe - -Algorithm1RecursiveSynthesis Locating, Comparison, Clustering, or Chain of -Reasoning,withcontextlengthsrangingfrom10K -| Require: | FindingsS | = {s ,...,s | },queryq, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | 1 | n | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | to beyond | 250K | tokens. | | We evaluate | | on the En- | -synthesisdirectived,contextsizebudgetB -Ensure: FinalOutputs⋆ glishandSet4(200k-250ktokens)portionofthe -| | | | | | benchmarkonly. | | Ourevaluationsetcomprises40 | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1: while|S| | > 1do | | | | | | | | | | | -instancesinvolvingacademicpapersand62involv- -| 2: E | ← COHEREEMBED(S) | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -D ← 1−COSINESIMILARITY(E) ingfinancialreports(102instancestotal),withthe -3: -tree ← AGGLOMERATIVECLUSTER( fourtasktypesdistributedas: SpotlightLocating -4: -(27),Comparison(15),Clustering(49),andChain -| | D, linkage | = “average”) | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ofReasoning(11). -| 5: batches | ← | GROUPBYTOKENS( | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | S, tree, | B) | | | | | | | | | | -4.2 Baselines -| 6: if|batches| | | ≥ |S|then | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | We compare | | against | the | following | systems, | all | -| 7: | batches ← | [S] | | | | | | | | | | -| endif | | | | | backedbyGemini2.5Pro: | | | | | | | -8: -| 9: S | ← ASYNCGATHER( | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | • Baseline(FullContext): | | | | | Alldocumentsfor | | -| | SYNTHESIZE(b,q,d)∀b | | ∈ | batches) | | | | | | | | -eachinstanceareconcatenatedandprovided -10: endwhile -directlyinthecontextwindowofGemini2.5 -| return | S[0] | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -11: -Pro,representingtheoraclelong-contextup- -perbound. -conditionisfalse(thetotalfindingssizeiswithin -• NormalRAG:Standardvectorsearchtop-K -thecontextsize,leavingasinglefinalsummarys⋆), -| | | | | | retrieval | | over | the full | document | | corpus, fol- | -| ----------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | -| the process | terminates | and yields | s⋆ | as the final | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | lowed | by | LLM | reasoning | | over the | retrieved | -| | If|S(t+1)| | |S(t)|(no-progresscase),the | | | | | | | | | | -| output. | | ≥ | | | | | | | | | | -chunks. -entirecurrentlevelisforcedintoasinglebatchto -guaranteetermination. -| | | | | | • Agentic | | RAG: | A single-agent | | ReAct-style | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -Algorithm1givesthepseudocodeforthegeneral RAG system (implemented via Lang- -recursivesynthesisprocedure. Graph/LangChain) that can issue multiple -| | | | | | iterative | | retrieval | calls | over | the | full global | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| BehavioronLoong. | | Inpractice,withGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | -Pro’s 1M-token context window and a budget of corpus. It uses the same embedding and -| | | | | | re-rankingpipelineas | | | | SPD-RAG,butlacks | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -B = 750,000tokens,thecombinedsub-agentfind- -per-documentspecialization. -ingsforallinstancesinourLoongevaluationsetfit -withinasinglebatch,sotheconditionalcheckal- -4.3 EvaluationMetrics -| lowedoutputafteroneiteration. | | | Therecursiveloop | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | We report | the | following | | metrics, | following | the | -isthereforeadesigncapabilityintendedformuch -Loongevaluationprotocol(Wangetal.,2024a): -largercorpora,wheretotalfindingssizegenuinely -exceedsthecontextsize. -| | | | | | • Avg | Score: | An | LLM-judged | | score | (0–100) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -measuringthedegreetowhichthepredicted -4 ExperimentalSetup -| | | | | | answer | | accurately | covers | | the gold | answer, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | -4.1 Dataset -| | | | | | following | | the | evaluation | protocol | | of Loong | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | (Wangetal.,2024a). | | | | 2 | | | -WeevaluateSPD-RAGontheLoongbenchmark -| (Wangetal.,2024a). | | Loongisanextendedmulti- | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ------------ | ----------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | • PerfectRate(PR%): | | | | Percentageofqueries | | | -| document | QA instances | in both | English | and Chi- | | | | | | | | -wherethesystemreceivesaperfectscoreof -| nese, with | an average | of 11 documents | | per test | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -100. -| casespanningtworeal-worldscenarios: | | | | financial | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -reports and academic papers. Each test case is 2BecausetheoriginallegacyGPT-4modelAPIisunavail- -ablefornewscaledevaluations,weadoptGPT-5astheeval- -constructedsothateverydocumentisrelevantto -| | | | | | uator. Recent | literature | | increasingly | | adopts | GPT-5 as the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------------ | -the final answer ("Leave No Document Behind", standard for LLM-as-a-judge protocols due to its superior -meaningacorrectresponserequiressynthesizing alignmentwithhumangrading(Wolfsonetal.,2025).While -ourbaselinenumbersarere-computedunderthisGPT-5judge -evidencefromallprovideddocuments),andisan- -forstrictfairness,rawscoresmaynotbeperfectly1-to-1com- -notated under one of four task types: Spotlight parablewiththeoriginallypublishedLoongleaderboard. - -• AvgTokenUsage: Meanper-querytotal(in- Cost tracking. Per-query costs are computed -put+output)tokenusage. fromLangSmithrunmetadata(totaltokencounts -×per-tokenpricing. -| • Avg | Cost | (USD): | Mean | per-query | | API cost, | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| enablingcost-efficiencycomparisons. | | | | | | | 5 Results | | | | | | -5.1 MainResults -| • AvgLatency(s): | | | Meanper-querywall-clock | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time. -Table1reportsthemainresultsacrossallsystems -| | | | | | | | on our Loong | evaluation | | set. | Figure | 2 illustrates | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | -4.4 ImplementationDetails -theseperformancedifferencesacrossthefourspe- -| AllsystemsuseGemini2.5Pro(temperature0.0) | | | | | | | cifictasktypes. | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -asthebackboneLLMforthecoordinator,merging SPD-RAGachievesanAvgScoreof58.1,sub- -| layer, and | synthesis | | layer. | SPD-RAG | | document | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stantiallyoutperformingbothNormalRAG(33.0) -| sub-agents | use | Gemini | 2.5 | Flash | for | document- | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | and Agentic | RAG | (32.8). | | This corresponds | to | -scopedretrieval,reducingper-documentcostwhile roughly a 25-point absolute improvement (about -preserving reasoning quality at the merging and 76% relative gain) over standard RAG baselines. -| synthesisstages. | | GPT-5isusedexclusivelyasthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | Furthermore, | SPD-RAG | | more | than | doubles the | -LLMjudgefortheevaluationoftheAvgscoreand Perfect Rate (PR) of Agentic RAG (18.6% vs. -is not part of the pipeline itself. Prompts for all 8.8%),indicatingthatexhaustivedocument-level -| systems, | including | baselines, | | were | optimized | for | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -processingmorefrequentlycapturesthecomplete -informationextractionandsynthesistoensurefair set of required facts. Notably, the Agentic RAG -comparison. Fullprompttemplatesforallsystems baseline,despiteconsuming∼3×moretokensthan -areprovidedinthecoderepository. NormalRAG,doesnotyieldscoreimprovements, -suggestingthatuninstructediterativeretrievalwith- -| Indexing. | Each | | document | | is | pre- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | out per-document | | specialization | | does | not effec- | -| indexed | into | a | dedicated | | Qdrant | vec- | | | | | | | -tivelyaddressthecoveragechallengeinexhaustive -| tor | collection | | using | | LangChain’s | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | multi-document | | settings. | While | the | full-context | -| RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter | | | | | | (Imple- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | baseline | attains | the highest | | quality with | an Avg | -mentationdetailsareprovidedintheAppendix.). -| | | | | | | | Score of | 68.0, | SPD-RAG | reaches | 85.4% | of this | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | -Retrievalpersub-agent. Eachsearchtoolcall performancewhileconsumingonly37.9%ofthe -performs dense vector retrieval over the docu- API cost, demonstrating a highly favorable cost- -| | | | | | | | quality trade-off. | | The | full-context | baseline | pro- | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | -| mentindex,returningthetop-K | | | | | (k = 15)chunks | | | | | | | | -using cosine similarity in Qdrant. These can- vides a strong upper bound that benefits from all -didates are subsequently re-ranked with Cohere documents in one pass. Despite this, SPD-RAG -narrowsthegapto9.9pointswhilecostingless. -| rerank-v4.0-fast,andthetoptop_n | | | | | = | 5chunks | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -arepassedtothesub-agentLLM. -5.2 AnalysisbyTaskType -| Merging | layer. | The | token | budget | | per merge | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Table2breaksdownperformancebyLoong’sfour -| batchisB | = 750,000tokens(75%ofGemini2.5 | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tasktypes. -| Pro’s1Mcontextcap). | | | Agglomerativeclustering | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thetask-typebreakdownrevealsaclearpattern. -usessklearnwithUPGMAlinkageandprecom- -| | | | | | | | For Spotlight | Locating—which | | | requires | finding | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -putedcosine-distancematrix. -asinglesalientfactacrossdocuments—allRAG- -| | | | | | | | based systems | | perform | reasonably | well | (69–74), | -| ------------- | --------------- | ----------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | -| Parallelism. | | Documentagentsrunconcurrently | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | while the | full-context | | baseline | leads | (86.6). The | -| via LangGraph | | Send | API | fan-out. | Batch | synthe- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | largest gaps | between | | SPD-RAG | and | the RAG | -| sis calls | within | each | merge | iteration | | are paral- | | | | | | | -| | asyncio.gather. | | | | | | baselinesappearinClustering(+40.5ptsoverNor- | | | | | | -| lelized | with | | | | Synchronous | Co- | | | | | | | -malRAG)andChainofReasoning(+26.2ptsover -hereAPIcallsareoffloadedtothethreadpoolvia -| | | | | | | | Agentic RAG), | | tasks | that require | aggregating | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -asyncio.to_thread. -reasoningoverevidencefrommanydocumentssi- -Safety limits. Each document sub-agent’s iter- multaneously. Ontheotherhand,itnearlymatches -ative retrieval loop is capped at 5 iterations; the the full-context baseline (42.2 vs. 42.7) on Com- -| AgenticRAGbaselinecapsat10iterations. | | | | | | | parisontasks. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -System AvgScore PR(%) AvgInputTok AvgTotalTok AvgCost($) AvgLatency(s) -OracleLong-ContextBaseline -| Baseline(FullContext) | | 68.0 | 31.4 253,085 | 255,345 | 0.273 | 45.6 | -| --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -RAGBaselines -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 13.7 22,174 | 27,430 | 0.080 | 42.6 | -| ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 8.8 81,877 | 85,290 | 0.098 | 40.6 | -OurSystem -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 18.6 193,954 | 205,683 | 0.103 | 54.8 | -| ------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ---- | -Table1: MainresultsonourLoongevaluationset(102instances: 40academicpaper,62financialreport). Bold: -| bestoverall. | Underline: | bestamongRAG-basedsystems. | | | | | -| ------------ | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure2: ComparisonofAverageScoreacrossthefoursystems,brokendownbytasktype(SpotlightLocating, -Comparison,Clustering,andChainofReasoning). -5.3 AnalysisbyDocumentDomain -| As shown | in Table 3 | and Figure | 3 the domain | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -breakdownexposesastrikingfailuremodeofstan- -| dard RAG: | both Normal | RAG and | Agentic RAG | | | | -| --------- | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -achieve0%PRonacademicpaperinstances(Avg -| Scoresof15.2and16.8,respectively). | | | Academic | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -paperinstancesinLoongtendtoinvolvelong,tech- -nicaldocumentswithdistributedevidence,making -top-K retrievalespeciallysusceptibletocoverage -failures. SPD-RAGdramaticallyrecoversonthis -domain(60.0AvgScore),closingmostofthegap -| with the | full-context | baseline (78.8). | On finan- | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3: Averagescorebydocumentdomaincompar- -cialreportinstances—whichtendtobeshorterand ingtheBaseline(FullContext),NormalRAG,Agentic -morestructured—allRAG-basedsystemsperform -RAG,andSPD-RAGsystems. -better,andthegapbetweenSPD-RAG(56.9)and -thebaseline(61.0)issmaller. - -| | System | | SpotlightLoc. | | Comparison | Clustering | ChainofReasoning | | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (n=27) | | (n=15) | (n=49) | | (n=11) | | | | -Baseline(FullContext) 86.6/55.6% 42.7/26.7% 67.1/14.3% 60.9/54.5% -| | NormalRAG | | 69.7/37.0% | | 37.7/26.7% | 15.4/0.0% | | 14.8/0.0% | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | AgenticRAG | | 73.4/22.2% | | 23.3/20.0% | 16.7/0.0% | | 17.9/0.0% | | | | -| | SPD-RAG | | 74.2/44.4% | | 42.2/20.0% | 57.2/4.1% | | 44.1/18.2% | | | | -Table2: AvgScore/PR(%)byLoongtasktype. EachcellshowsAvgScore/PR%. -| | | | | | Crucially, | thearchitectureof | | | SPD-RAG | | enables | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | -| System | | Paper(n=40) | Financial(n=62) | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | this | cost efficiency: | | by constraining | | retrieval | to | -| Baseline | | 78.8/30.0% | 61.0/32.3% | | | | | | | | | -NormalRAG 15.2/0.0% 44.5/22.6% isolated,single-documentspaces,wecanreliably -| AgenticRAG | | 16.8/0.0% | 43.1/14.5% | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -offloadtheiterativereasoningtoacheapermodel -| SPD-RAG | | 60.0/7.5% | 56.9/25.8% | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | (Gemini | 2.5 Flash). | | In contrast, | | global | iterative | -baselinesrequirethereasoningcapacityofafron- -Table3: AvgScore/PR(%)bydocumentdomain. -| | | | | | tier | model (Gemini | 2.5 | Pro) | to navigate | | the fully | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -concatenatedcorpus,drivingupcosts. -| System | | AvgScore | AvgCost($) | Score/$ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | -| Baseline | | 68.0 | 0.273 | 249.1 | | | | | | | | -| NormalRAG | | 33.0 | 0.080 | 412.5 | 6 | Discussion | | | | | | -| AgenticRAG | | 32.8 | 0.098 | 334.7 | | | | | | | | -| SPD-RAG | | 58.1 | 0.103 | 564.1 | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | WhereSPD-RAGexcels. | | | | Thetask-typeresults | | | -| | | | | | in Table | 2 confirm | our | core | hypothesis: | | architec- | -Table4: Cost–qualitytradeoff. -turaldecompositionalongthedocumentaxisyields -| | | | | | the largest | gains | precisely | | for tasks | that | require | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | | | exhaustive | multi-document | | | synthesis. | Clustering | | -5.4 Cost–QualityTradeoff -tasks(+40.5overNormalRAG)andChainofRea- -| | | | | | soning | tasks (+26.2 | over | Agentic | | RAG) | both de- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ---- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -mandthatthesystemformacoherentanswerfrom -evidencedistributedacrossallrelevantdocuments— -exactlythescenarioforwhichper-documentagents -| | | | | | aredesigned. | ForLoong’sComparisonquestions, | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -theanswerisprimarilydeterminedbyreadingout -asmallsetofcomparablenumericattributesfrom -| | | | | | each | report and | aggregating | | them, | so once | docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | ment | agents have | extracted | | those | fields, | the syn- | -| | | | | | thesizer | is effectively | | operating | over | a structured | | -table,whichhelpsexplainwhySPD-RAG’sscore -onComparisontasks(42.2)nearlymatchesthefull- -Figure4: Cost–Qualitytradeoff. Thescatterplotillus- contextbaseline(42.7). -tratestheParetofrontierformulti-documentQA. -| | | | | | Remaining | gap | with | the | full-context | | baseline. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -SPD-RAG outperforms the RAG baselines in Despite strong gains over RAG baselines, SPD- -the cost–quality trade-off. It achieves a 76% RAG lags the full-context baseline by 9.9 Avg -higheraveragescorethanNormalRAG(58.1vs. Score points overall. Three factors likely con- -33.0)whileincreasingtheper-querycostbyonly tribute: (1) Gemini 2.5 Flash, used for document -$0.023 (Table 4). In contrast, Agentic RAG is agents due to its cost efficiency, may provide -Pareto-dominated, as it incurs higher cost than weaker agentic reasoning capabilities compared -NormalRAG($0.098vs.$0.080)whiledelivering to larger models. (2) The coordinator’s sub-task -nearlyidenticalquality(32.8vs.33.0). Compared generation may under-specify queries for highly -tothefull-contextbaseline,whichachievesanAvg technical academic content, leading to incom- -Score of 68.0, SPD-RAG reaches 85.4% of the pleteinformationextractionatthedocument-agent -qualityatonly37.9%ofthecost, resultingina level. (3) The maximum context length observed -2.25× improvement in cost–quality efficiency. inLoongquerieswasapproximately250ktokens— - -onlyabout25%ofthe1M-tokencontextwindow onthecoordinator’sabilitytogeneratecomprehen- -of Gemini 2.5 Pro—potentially limiting the pres- sivesub-tasks: under-specifiedtasksleadtoincom- -sureonthefull-contextbaseline. SinceSPD-RAG plete document-level extractions, as observed on -isdesignedtooperateonsubstantiallylargercon- technicalacademicpaperinstances. Ourevaluation -texts,itsadvantagesmaybecomemorepronounced islimitedtotwodomains(academicpapersandfi- -undermoreextremelong-contextconditions. nancialreports)fromtheLoongbenchmark;legal, -medical,orenterprisedocumentcorporamayhave -| RAG baseline | | failure | on papers. | | The 0% | PR | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -differentstructuralcharacteristicsthatalterrelative -| rate and | 15.2-16.8% | | Avg Score | of | both Normal | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -performance. -| RAG and | Agentic | RAG | on | academic | paper | in- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ThesynthesislayerofSPD-RAGisdesignedto -top-K -| stances | highlights | a systematic | | failure | of | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -handlecorporawherethecombinedsub-agentout- -| retrieval | under | dense, | distributed | evidence. | | Aca- | | | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -putsexceedthemodel’scontextwindow,triggering -| demic | papers | in Loong | often | require | synthesiz- | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -multi-roundsimilarity-basedclusteringandrecur- -ingfactsspreadacrossabstracts,methods,results, -| | | | | | | | sive synthesis. | | In our Loong | experiments, | | how- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | ---- | -andappendicesofmultipledocuments—aregime -ever,Gemini2.5Pro’s1M-tokencontextwassuffi- -| where exhaustive | | per-document | | coverage | proves | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -cienttoprocessallsub-agentsummariesinasingle -| highly | effective. | The | recovery | by SPD-RAG | | to | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | | merge step, | so | this recursive | path | was | never acti- | -60.0AvgScore/7.5%PRinthisdomaindemon- -| | | | | | | | vated. Asaresult,thescalabilitypropertiesofthe | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -stratesthepracticalvalueofper-documentspecial- -recursivesynthesispipeline—itsimpactonanswer -ization. -| | | | | | | | quality, | redundancy | reduction, | | and cost | as docu- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Latencyoverhead. SPD-RAG incursamodest mentcountsgrowintothehundredsorthousands— -latency overhead (54.8 s vs. 40.6–45.6 s for the remainempiricallyunvalidated. EvaluatingSPD- -| baselines), | primarily | | due to | its multi-agent | | archi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RAGonmuchlargercorpora,andideallyonanew -tecture. Although document agents run in paral- benchmarkspecificallytargetinghundredstothou- -lel,end-to-endlatencyisstillgatedbythelayered sands of documents per query instance, is an im- -pipeline, which requires at least three sequential portantdirectionforfutureworkthatwouldmore -LLM calls (coordination, per-document retrieval, directlytesttheper-documentagentdesignandthe -andsynthesis)ratherthanasinglepass. intendedlarge-databaseregime. -| | | | | | | | 8 Conclusion | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | We presented | | SPD-RAG, | a hierarchical | | multi- | -| | | | | | | | agent framework | | designed | for | exhaustive | multi- | -| | | | | | | | documentquestionanswering. | | | Byassigningaded- | | | -icatedagenticRAGmoduletoeachdocumentand -mergingtheirfindingsthroughasimilarity-ordered, -| | | | | | | | token-bounded | | tree, our | system | effectively | miti- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | gatesthelimitationsofbothtraditionaltop-K | | | | | re- | -| | | | | | | | trieval (incomplete | | coverage) | and | isolated | long- | -| | | | | | | | context | processing | (degraded | reasoning | | at scale). | -Figure5: Averageper-querylatencyacrosssystems. ExperimentsonthechallengingLoongbenchmark -demonstratethatSPD-RAGachievesanaverage -scoreof58.1,outperformingNormalRAG(33.0) -7 LimitationsandFutureWork -andAgenticRAG(32.8)byapproximately25ab- -SPD-RAG incurs higher per-query LLM call solute points (76% higher average score), while -countsthansingle-passsystems—onecallperdoc- operating at only 37.9% of the API cost of the -ument agent plus a final synthesis step—which oracle full-context baseline (68.0). These per- -increasestotaltokenusagecomparedtostandard formance gains are most pronounced in tasks re- -RAGbaselines,thoughitremainsatroughlyone- quiring deep cross-document synthesis—such as -thirdthecostofthefull-contextbaseline($0.10vs. Clustering(+40.5points)andChainofReasoning -$0.27perquery)duetotheuseofGemini2.5Flash (+26.2points)—aswellasondenseacademicpa- -fordocumentsub-agents. Systemqualitydepends perswherestandardRAGmethodsentirelyfail. - -Ultimately, our findings demonstrate that for TaichengGuo,XiuyingChen,YaqiWang,RuidiChang, -complex information-seeking queries over large ShichaoPei,NiteshV.Chawla,OlafWiest,andXi- -| | | | | | | | angliangZhang.2024. | | | Largelanguagemodel-based | | | -| -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -| corpora, | how | information | | is processed | is | crucial. | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | multi-agents: | | Asurveyofprogressandchallenges. | | | | -Specifically,ensuringthateachdocumentreceives -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2402.01680. | | | ArXiv:2402.01680. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -exhaustive,dedicatedagenticattentionprovestobe -| | | | | | | | Siwei Han, | Peng | Xia, Ruiyi | Zhang, | Tong | Sun, Yun | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | -------- | -amoreeffective,cost-efficient,andscalablestrat- -| | | | | | | | Li, Hongtu | Zhu, | and | Huaxiu Yao. | 2025. | MDocA- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | -egythansimplyexpandinghowmuchrawcontext -gent: Amulti-modalmulti-agentframeworkfordoc- -asinglemodelcanconsumeinonepass. umentunderstanding. Preprint,arXiv:2503.13964. -ArXiv:2503.13964. -9 EthicsStatement -| | | | | | | | Yubin Kim, | Ken | Gu, Chanwoo | Park, | Chunjong | Park, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | -SPD-RAG is a retrieval-augmented generation SamuelSchmidgall,A.AliHeydari,YaoYan,Zhi- -hanZhang,YuchenZhuang,MarkMalhotra,PaulPu -| framework | intended | | to improve | access | | to infor- | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liang,HaeWonPark,YuzheYang,XuhaiXu,Yilun -| mation | distributed | across | | large document | | collec- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Du, Shwetak | | Patel, Tim | Althoff, | Daniel | McDuff, | -tions. ThesystemreliesoncommercialLLMAPIs and Xin Liu. 2025. Towards a science of scal- -(Gemini2.5,Cohere),andaswithanyLLM-based ing agent systems. Preprint, arXiv:2512.08296. -ArXiv:2512.08296. -| pipeline, | outputs | may | contain | factual | errors | and | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -should not be treated as authoritative without hu- PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio -man verification. The increased number of API Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- -| | | | | | | | richKüttler, | | MikeLewis, | Wen-tauYih, | | TimRock- | -| --------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | -| calls per | query | relative | to | single-pass | systems | re- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | täschel, | Sebastian | Riedel, | and | Douwe | Kiela. 2020. | -| sults in | higher | energy | consumption, | | a | cost that | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Retrieval-augmented | | | generation | for | knowledge- | -should be weighed against the accuracy gains in intensiveNLPtasks. InAdvancesinNeuralInforma- -deploymentdecisions. Ourbenchmarkevaluations tionProcessingSystems. -| are conducted | | on publicly | | available | datasets | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | TengLin, | YuyuLuo, | HonglinZhang, | | JichengZhang, | | -involvenohumansubjectsorpersonaldata. Dur- Chunlin Liu, Kaishun Wu, and Nan Tang. 2025. -ingthepreparationofthismanuscript,AI-assisted MEBench: Benchmarkinglargelanguagemodelsfor -| | | | | | | | cross-documentmulti-entityquestionanswering. | | | | | In | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -writingtoolswereusedtohelprefinelanguageand -ProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethods -| improveclarity. | | Allresearchdesign,experiments, | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -inNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). -analysis,andfinaldecisionsregardingthecontent -NelsonF.Liu,KevinLin,JohnHewitt,AshwinParan- -wereconductedandverifiedbytheauthors. -jape,MicheleBevilacqua,FabioPetroni,andPercy -| | | | | | | | Liang.2023. | | Lostinthemiddle: | | Howlanguagemod- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | elsuselongcontexts. | | TransactionsoftheAssociation | | | | -References -forComputationalLinguistics,12. -| Haonan | Bian. | 2025. | LLM-empowered | | | knowl- | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -SeijiMaekawa,HayateIso,andNikitaBhutani.2024. -| edge | graph | construction: | | A survey. | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Holisticreasoningwithlong-contextLMs: | | | | | Abench- | -| arXiv:2510.20345. | | | ArXiv:2510.20345. | | | | | | | | | | -markfordatabaseoperationsonmassivetextualdata. -Darren Edge, Ha Trinh, Newman Cheng, Joshua Preprint,arXiv:2410.11996. ArXiv:2410.11996. -| Bradley, | Alex | Chao, | | Apurva | Mody, | Steven | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | David J. | Moore. | 2025. | A taxonomy | of | hierarchical | -Truitt, Dasha Metropolitansky, Robert Osazuwa multi-agentsystems: Designpatterns,coordination -| Ness, | and | Jonathan | Larson. | 2024. | | From lo- | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | mechanisms, | | and industrial | applications. | | Preprint, | -| cal to | global: | A graph | RAG | approach | | to query- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2508.12683. | | ArXiv:2508.12683. | | | | -| focusedsummarization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2404.16130. | | | | | | | | | | -ArXiv:2404.16130. -| | | | | | | | LituOuandMirellaLapata.2025. | | | | Context-awarehier- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -archicalmergingforlongdocumentsummarization. -| Gemini | Team, | Petko | Georgiev, | Ving | Ian Lei, | Ryan | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Preprint,arXiv:2502.00977. | | | ArXiv:2502.00977. | | | -| Burnell, | Libin | Bai, | Anmol | Gulati, | Garrett | Tanzer, | | | | | | | -DamienVincent,ZhufengPan,ShiboWang,and1 Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh -others. 2024. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D. Man- -understandingacrossmillionsoftokensofcontext. ning. 2024. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive pro- -Preprint,arXiv:2403.05530. ArXiv:2403.05530. cessing for tree-organized retrieval. Preprint, -| | | | | | | | arXiv:2401.18059. | | ArXiv:2401.18059. | | | | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Jiani Guo, | Zuchao | Li, | Jie Wu, | Qianren | Wang, | Yun | | | | | | | -Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao, and Yujiu Yang. 2025. LiSun,LiuHe,ShuyueJia,YangfanHe,andChenyu -ToM:Leveragingtree-orientedMapReduceforlong- You. 2025. DocAgent: An agentic framework for -contextreasoninginlargelanguagemodels. InPro- multi-modallong-contextdocumentunderstanding. -ceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin InProceedingsoftheConferenceonEmpiricalMeth- -NaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). odsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP). - -V.A.Traag,L.Waltman,andN.J.vanEck.2019. From extraction tasks and write a synthesis -louvaintoleiden: Guaranteeingwell-connectedcom- directive to guide the downstream -| munities. | ScientificReports,9(1):5233. | | | | | | synthesizer. | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 2. Sub-agents | | (next) | — | Each | document | -Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi is assigned one worker that runs your -Liao,XinghuaZhang,BingliWu,HaiyangYu,Nan tasks independently. Workers search -Xu,LeiZhang,RunLuo,YunshuiLi,MinYang,Fei their document and report raw findings. -| | | | | | | | They run | in parallel | | and | cannot | see each | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | -| Huang,andYongbinLi.2024a. | | | | Leavenodocument | | | | | | | | | -other’s results. -| behind: | Benchmarkinglong-contextLLMswithex- | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | 3. Synthesizer | | (last) | — | A downstream | | -| tendedmulti-docQA. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2406.17419. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | agent | receives | ALL | worker | | findings | -ArXiv:2406.17419. -| | | | | | | | and merges | | them | into | a | single | -| ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | coherent | response. | | It | follows | your | -| Qian Wang, | Tianyu | | Wang, | Zhenheng | Tang, | Qinbin | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | synthesis_directive | | | to decide | | what to | -Li,NuoChen,JingshengLiang,andBingshengHe. -| | | | | | | | prioritize | and | how | to | structure | the | -| ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| 2024b. | Megaagent: | | Alarge-scaleautonomousLLM- | | | | | | | | | | -output. -basedmulti-agentsystemwithoutpredefinedSOPs. -| | | | | | | | You CANNOT | see | the | names, | types, | or | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -| Preprint,arXiv:2408.09955. | | | | ArXiv:2408.09955. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | content | of the | documents. | | | | -TomerWolfson,HarshTrivedi,MorGeva,YoavGold- Your ONLY job in this step: -| berg, | Dan Roth, | Tushar | Khot, | Ashish | | Sabharwal, | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a list | of | subagent_todos | | -| and Reut | Tsarfaty. | | 2025. | Monaco: | | More nat- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | (as | structured | | output): | | precise | -| ural and | complex | | questions | for | reasoning | across | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | extraction | | tasks | | that | will be | -| dozensofdocuments. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | executed | | independently | | against | EACH | -| ArXiv:2508.11133. | | | | | | | document | | by the | sub-agents. | | | -| | | | | | | | • Produce | | a synthesis_directive: | | | a | -Wentao Zhang, Liang Zeng, Yuzhen Xiao, Yong- concise instruction (2–4 sentences) -cong Li, Ce Cui, Yilei Zhao, Rui Hu, Yang Liu, for the synthesizer. -| Yahui | Zhou, | and Bo | An. | 2025. | AgentOrchestra: | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ------ | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A hierarchical multi-agent framework for general- Todo-writing rules: -| purpose | task | solving. | Preprint, | arXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | • Decompose | | the | user | query | into | -| ArXiv:2506.12508. | | | | | | | concrete | | information | | requirements. | | -Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Hao Xu, Yi Lu, Wei He, Yiwen • Each todo must be self-contained -and unambiguous. -| Ding, | Tao Gui, | Qi | Zhang, | and | Xuanjing | Huang. | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | • Prefer | | atomic | tasks | over | broad | -| 2024. | LongAgent: | | Scalinglanguagemodelsto128k | | | | | | | | | | -tasks. -| contextthroughmulti-agentcollaboration. | | | | | | Preprint, | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • Include | | coverage | for: | definitions, | | -| arXiv:2402.11550. | | | ArXiv:2402.11550. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | numeric | | values, | constraints, | | edge | -| | | | | | | | cases, | | error | modes, | and | any | -| Zihan Zhou, | Chong | | Li, Xinyi | Chen, | Shuo | Wang, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | explicit | | recommendations | | | required | -YuChao,ZhiliLi,HaoyuWang,QiShi,ZhixingTan, -| | | | | | | | by | the user | query. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -XuHan,XiaodongShi,ZhiyuanLiu,andMaosong -| | | | | | | | • Design | a | robust | extraction | | list | -| ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| Sun. 2025. | | LLM×MapReduce: | | | Simplified | long- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | that | works | for | ANY document | | in the | -| sequence | processing | | using | large | language | models. | | | | | | | -set. -InProceedingsoftheAnnualMeetingoftheAssocia- -| tionforComputationalLinguistics(ACL). | | | | | | | Important | Constraints: | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | Do | not assume | any | document | | contains | -| AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris | | | | | | | • | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | the | answer. | Write | | todos | that can | -| Callison-Burch. | | 2024. | FanOutQA: | | A | multi-hop, | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | be | answered | with | either | “Found” | or | -multi-documentquestionansweringbenchmarkfor -| | | | | | | | “Not | found | in | this document.” | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | --------------- | ----------- | --- | -| large language | | models. | In | Proceedings | | of the An- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • Tell | the | worker | WHAT | to extract, | not | -nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational -| | | | | | | | HOW | to extract | | it. | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Linguistics(ACL). -| | | | | | | | • Do | not | synthesize, | | summarize, | or | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | attempt | | to answer | | the user | query | -A Prompts -yourself. -| All | prompts | | are | | defined | in | | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -A.2DocumentSub-AgentPrompt -backend/core/prompts.py. -(RESEARCH_SYSTEM_PROMPT) -| A.1CoordinatorPrompt | | | | | | | You are | a sub-agent | | investigating | | a | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | -| (LEAD_RESEARCHER_PROMPT) | | | | | | | single document: | | {file_name}. | | | | -You are a lead researcher coordinating You operate inside an iterative -a RAG-based analysis to answer a user retrieval loop. On each turn you output -| query. | | | | | | | exactly | one structured | | action: | | | -| -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| Pipeline | | Architecture: | | | | | • action="search": | | | Issue | a | focused | -1. YOU (now) — Decompose the query into query to retrieve information from - -the document. Set query to a • Follow the synthesis directive -specific, targeted search string. above — it defines your main goal, -Set reasoning to why this query is priorities, and output structure. -| | needed. | | | | | | • | Keep only | information | | that | directly | -| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -• action="finalize": You have helps answer the query. Discard -| | gathered | | sufficient | evidence | to | | | tangential | content. | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------ | -| | address | ALL | assigned | | tasks. Set | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Preserve | exact | numbers, | | names, | -| | findings | to | your | complete | extracted | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | dates, | and caveats. | | | | -| | report. | Set | reasoning | | to a brief | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | • | Remove | redundancy. | | If the | same | -| | summary | of | what you | found. | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | fact appears | | multiple | times, | keep | -it once. -| | Investigation | principles: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | • | Do NOT | invent | or infer | facts | not | -| | | | | | | | | present | in the | findings. | | | -| | 1. Start | by identifying | | the | key facts | | | | | | | | -| | required | for | each | task. | | | • | Same | language | as | the | findings | -2. Issue ONE focused query per turn (default English if mixed). -| | — prefer | specific | | terms | over broad | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | -------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | phrases. | | | | | B | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | -| | 3. Expand | to | synonyms | or | paraphrases | | | | | | | | -Models. -if initial results are incomplete. The coordinator, the merging layer, -4. Issue separate queries for and the synthesis layer use gemini-2.5-pro -| | different | | aspects | of a | task. | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | | | | (temperature | | 0.0). | | Document | | sub-agents | -| | 5. Keep | searching | until | every | task is | | | | | | | | -covered with concrete evidence or use gemini-2.5-flash (temperature 0.0) for -| | confirmed | | absent. | | | document-scoped | | | retrieval. | | The | LLM judge | -| --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | -6. Do NOT attempt to answer the user (GPT-5) is separate and is used only for the -| | query | directly | — | extract | raw facts | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | evaluationoftheAvgscore. | | | | Modelconstantsare | | | -only. -definedinbackend/shared/constants.py. -| | 7. Do | NOT finalize | | a task | as ’Not | | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ---------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | found’ | after | only | a single | focused | | | | | | | | -| | search. | | At | least | attempt 2 | Hyperparameters. | | | | | | | -| | focused | searches | | before | concluding | | | | | | | | -| | information | | is absent. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Parameter | | | | Value | | | -| | 8. Do NOT | focus | on very | specific | terms, | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunksize(tokens) | | | | 1000 | | | -| | but | rather | on the | general | context | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Chunkoverlap(tokens) | | | | 250 | | | -| | of the | task. | Always | try | to find the | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Tokenizer | | | | tiktoken | | cl100k_base | -| | most | relevant | information. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingmodel | | | | Cohereembed-v4.0 | | | -| | 9. You | must use | AT MOST | 5 | searches to | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Embeddingdimension | | | | 1536 | | | -| | answer | a task. | DO | NOT | OVERUSE THE | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Similaritymetric | | | | Cosine | | | -| | SEARCH | TOOL. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | MergetokenbudgetB | | | | 750,000tokens | | | -| | | | | | | Denseretrievaltop-K | | | | 15 | | | -| | Finalize | report | format: | | For each | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Reranker | | | | Coherererank-v4.0-fast | | | -| | assigned | task, | output | either | “Found: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Rerankertop-N | | | | 5 | | | -| | [exact answer | with | supporting | | evidence]” | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Sub-agentiterationsafetylimit | | | | 5 | | | -| | or “Not found | in | this | document.” | Always | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringalgorithm | | | | Agglomerative(UPGMA) | | | -| | report exact | numbers, | | names, | and dates. | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | Clusteringmetric | | | | Precomputedcosinedistance | | | -| | Never approximate | | or | infer | beyond the | | | | | | | | -document. -| | | | | | | Cost | | measurement. | | Per-query | | costs | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | are | pulled | from | LangSmith | | run | metadata | -A.3Merge/SynthesisPrompt -| (SYNTHESIS_PROMPT) | | | | | | (extract_langsmith_info.py) | | | | | using | model- | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -specificper-tokenpricing. -Thispromptisuseduniformlyateverylevelofthe -recursivemergingtree,includingthefinalsynthesis -step. Thereisnoseparatefinal-answerprompt. -| | You are | a research | synthesizer. | | Merge | | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | the following | | sub-agent | findings | into | | | | | | | | -| | one compact, | information-dense | | | response | | | | | | | | -| | for the user. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Query: {query | } | | | | | | | | | | | -| | Synthesis | Directive: | | | | | | | | | | | -{synthesis_directive} -| | Findings | Batch: | {findings | } | | | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rules: \ No newline at end of file +The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20220922152230/https://www.pewresearch.org/fac… + +N UM B ERS , FAC T S AN D T REN DS S HAPIN G YOUR W ORL D N EW S L ET T ERS + +PRES S + +DON AT E M Y AC C OUN T + + + + + +* Pew Research Center + +See our research on: Economy | Abortion | Russia | COVID-19 + +Search pewresearch.org... + + + +RESEARCH TOPICS  + +ALL PUBLICATIONS METHODS SHORT READS TOOLS & RESOURCES EXPERTS ABO + +Home + + + + Research Topics + + + + Race & Ethnicity + + + + Racial & Ethnic Groups + + + + Hispanics/Latinos + + + + Hispanic/Latino Identity + +S EPT EM B ER 1 5 , 2 0 2 2 + +Who is Hispanic? + +    + +BY MARK HUGO LOPEZ, JENS MANUEL KROGSTAD AND JEFFREY S. PASSEL + +Beauty pageant contestants at the Junta Hispana Hispanic cultural festival in Miami. (Jeffrey Greenberg/Universal +Images Group via Getty Images) + + Debates over who is Hispanic and who is not have often fueled conversations about + +identity among Americans who trace their heritage to Latin America or Spain. Most + +recently, the 2020 census has drawn attention to how Hispanic identity is defined and + +measured. The once-a-decade head count of all people living in the United States used a + +new approach to identify who is Hispanic and has provided fresh details about how + +Hispanics view their racial identity. + +So, who is considered Hispanic in the U.S. today? How exactly are Hispanics counted? + +What role does race play in deciding who is counted as Hispanic? And how do surveys + +incorporate the various terms people use to describe their Hispanic identity, such as + +Latina or Latinx? + +In this analysis, we’ll answer these common questions and others. + +How many Hispanics are there in the U.S. today? + +Let’s start with the basics. The Census Bureau estimates there were roughly 62.6 million + +Hispanics in the U.S. as of 2021, making up 19% of the nation’s population, both new + +highs. + +Behind the official Census Bureau number, however, lies a long history of changing labels, + +shifting categories and revised question wording on census forms – all of which reflect + +evolving cultural norms about what it means to be Hispanic or Latino in the U.S. today. + + How are Hispanics counted in government surveys, public opinion polls and other +studies? + +Before diving into the details, keep in mind that some surveys ask about Hispanic origin + +and race in separate questions, following the current practice of the Census Bureau: + +One way to count Hispanics is straightforward: Hispanics are those who say they are + +Hispanic, with no exceptions. Pew Research Center uses this approach in our surveys, as + +do other polling firms such as Gallup and voter exit polls. + + The Census Bureau largely counts Hispanics this way, too, but with some exceptions. If + +respondents select only the “Other Hispanic” category and write in only non-Hispanic + +responses such as “Irish,” the Census Bureau recodes the response as non-Hispanic. + +However, beginning in 2020, it widened the lens to include a relatively small number of + +people who did not check a Hispanic box on the census form but answered the race + +question in a way that implied a Hispanic background. As a result, someone who wrote + +that their race is “Mexican” or “Argentinean” in the race question was counted as + +Hispanic, even if they did not check the Hispanic box. From the available data, it is + +impossible to know the exact number of respondents affected by this change, but it would + +appear to be about 1% of Hispanics or fewer. + +How did Hispanics identify their race in the 2020 census? + +In the eyes of the Census Bureau, Hispanics can be of any race, because “Hispanic” is an + +ethnicity and not a race – though this distinction can be subject to debate. A 2015 survey + +by Pew Research Center found that 17% of Hispanic adults said being Hispanic is mainly a + +matter of race, while 29% said it is mainly a matter of ancestry and 42% said it is mainly a + +matter of culture. + +Nonetheless, the 2020 census provides a portrait of the self-reported racial identity of + +Hispanics. For example, 26.2 million single-race Hispanics identified only as “some other + +race,” a group that mostly includes those who wrote in a Hispanic origin or nationality as + + their race. The next largest single-race group was White (12.6 million), followed by + +American Indian (1.5 million), Black (1.2 million) and Asian (300,000). + +At the same time, more than 20 million Hispanics identified with more than one race on + +the 2020 census, up from just 3 million in 2010. The sharp increase in multiracial + +Hispanics could be due to a number of factors, including changes to the census form that + +added space for written responses to the race question, as well as growing racial diversity + +among Hispanics. In particular, almost nine-in-ten Hispanics who identified with two or + +more races in 2020 said they were “some other race” (i.e., those who write in a response to + +the race question) and one of the specific races (such as White or Black). + +Growth in multiracial Hispanics comes primarily from those who identify as White and + +“some other race” – a population that grew from 1.6 million to 17.0 million over the past + +decade. The number of Hispanics who identify as White and no other race declined by + +almost the same amount – from 26.7 million to 12.6 million. + +Isn’t there an official definition of what it means to be Hispanic or Latino? + +In 1976, the U.S. Congress passed a law that mandated the collection and analysis of data + +for a specific ethnic group: “Americans of Spanish origin or descent.” The language of that + +legislation described this group as “Americans who identify themselves as being of + +Spanish-speaking background and trace their origin or descent from Mexico, Puerto Rico, + +Cuba, Central and South America, and other Spanish-speaking countries.” This includes + +20 Spanish-speaking nations from Latin America and Spain itself, but not Portugal or + +Portuguese-speaking Brazil. + +Standards for collecting data on Hispanics were developed by the Office of Management + +and Budget (OMB) in 1977 and revised in 1997. Using these standards, schools, public + +health facilities and other government entities and agencies keep track of how many + +Hispanics they serve – the primary goal of the 1976 law. + +Currently, the OMB is reconsidering how to collect and report statistics about race and + +ethnicity. The review is scheduled to be completed by 2024. + +What’s the difference between Hispanic and Latino? + +“Hispanic” and “Latino” are pan-ethnic terms meant to describe – and summarize – the + +population of people of that ethnic background living in the U.S. In practice, the Census + +Bureau most often uses the term “Hispanic,” while Pew Research Center uses the terms + +“Hispanic” and “Latino” interchangeably when describing this population. + + Some have drawn sharp distinctions between these two terms – saying, for example, that + +Hispanics are people from Spain or from Spanish-speaking countries in Latin America + +(this excludes Brazil, where Portuguese is the official language), while Latinos are people + +from Latin America regardless of language (this includes Brazil but excludes Spain and + +Portugal). Despite this debate, the “Hispanic” and “Latino” labels are not universally + +embraced by the population that has been labeled, even as they are widely used. + +Instead, Pew Research Center surveys show a preference for other terms to describe + +identity. A 2019 survey found that 47% of Hispanics most often describe themselves by + +their family’s country of origin, while 39% use the terms Latino or Hispanic and 14% most + +often describe themselves as American. + +As for a preference between the terms Hispanic or Latino to describe themselves, a 2018 + +survey found that 27% prefer “Hispanic,” 18% prefer “Latino” and the rest (54%) have no + +preference. These findings have changed little in nearly two decades of Pew Research + +Center surveys of Hispanic adults, which are conducted in English and Spanish. + +What is “Latinx”? + +Another pan-ethnic identity label is “Latinx,” which has emerged as an alternative to + +Hispanic and Latino in recent years. It is used by some news and entertainment outlets, + +corporations, local governments and universities to describe the nation’s Hispanic + +population. Yet the use of Latinx is not common practice, and the term’s emergence has + +generated debate about its appropriateness in a gendered language like Spanish. Some + +critics say it ignores the Spanish language and its gendered form, while others see Latinx + +as a gender- and LGBTQ-inclusive term. + + The term is not well known among the population it is meant to describe. Only 23% of U.S. + +adults who self-identify as Hispanic or Latino have heard of the term Latinx, and just 3% + +say they use it to describe themselves, according to a 2019 survey. Awareness and use of + +the term vary across subgroups, with Hispanics ages 18 to 29 among the most likely to + +have heard of the term – 42% say they have heard of it, compared with 7% of those 65 and + +older. Some of the most common use of Latinx is among Hispanic women ages 18 to 29 – + +14% say they use it, compared with 1% of Hispanic men in the same age group. + +The emergence of Latinx coincides with a global movement to introduce gender-neutral + +nouns and pronouns into many languages whose grammar has traditionally used male or + +female constructions. In the U.S., the first uses of Latinx appeared more than a decade + +ago. The term was added to a widely used English dictionary in 2018, reflecting its greater + +use. And a new gender-neutral pan-ethnic label, Latine, has emerged. It is largely used in + +Spanish. + +How do factors like language, a person’s last name and the background of their +parents play into whether someone is considered Hispanic? + +Our surveys of U.S. Hispanics have found many have an inclusive view of what it means to + +be Hispanic. A 2015 survey found 71% of Hispanic adults said speaking Spanish is not + +required to be considered Hispanic, and 84% said having a Spanish last name is not + +required to be considered Hispanic. Meanwhile, 32% of Hispanic adults said having both + + parents of Hispanic heritage or descent is an essential part of what being Hispanic means + +to them, according to a 2019 survey. + +Views of Hispanic identity may change in coming decades as broad societal changes, such + +as rising intermarriage rates, produce an increasingly diverse and multiracial U.S. + +population. + +In 2019, 30% of Hispanic newlyweds married someone who is not Hispanic; the Hispanic + +intermarriage rate is similar to that for Asians (29%) but higher than the rate among Black + +(18%) and White (12%) newlyweds. Among Hispanic newlyweds, 39% of those born in the + +U.S. married someone who is not Hispanic, compared with 17% of immigrants, according + +to an analysis of American Community Survey data. Among all married Hispanics, 20% + +had a spouse who is not Hispanic as of 2019. + +The Center’s 2015 survey of U.S. Hispanic adults found that 15% had at least one parent + +who is not Hispanic. This share rises to 29% among the U.S. born and 48% among the + +third or higher generation – those born in the U.S. with both parents who were also U.S. + +born. + +What role does skin color play in whether someone is Hispanic? + + As with race, Latinos can have a variety of skin tones. A 2021 survey of Latino adults + +showed respondents a palette of 10 skin colors; they were asked to choose which one most + +closely resembled their own. + +Latinos reported having a variety of skin tones, reflecting the diversity within the group. + +Eight-in-ten Latinos selected one of the four lightest skin colors, with the second-lightest + +ranking most common (28%), followed by the third (21%) and fourth lightest colors (17%). + +By contrast, only 3% of Latino respondents selected one of the four darkest skin colors. + +It’s worth noting that a majority of Latino adults (57%) say skin color shapes their daily life + +experiences at least somewhat. Most say having a darker skin color hurts Latinos’ ability to + +get ahead in the U.S. (62%), while having a lighter skin color helps Latinos get ahead + +(59%). + +What about Afro-Latinos? Are they Hispanic? + +Afro-Latino identity is distinct and can exist alongside a person’s Hispanic identity. The + +life experiences of Afro-Latinos are shaped by race, skin tone and other factors, in ways + +that differ from other Hispanics. While most Afro-Latinos identify as Hispanic or Latino, + +not all do, according to Pew Research Center estimates based on a survey of U.S. adults + +conducted from November 2019 to June 2020. + + In 2020, Center estimates found there were about 6 million Afro-Latino adults in the U.S., + +making up about 2% of the U.S. adult population and 12% of the adult Latino population. + +About one-in-seven Afro-Latinos – or an estimated 800,000 adults – do not identify as + +Hispanic. + +Can a person’s country of origin or ancestry affect whether or not they are +Hispanic? + +Similar to race and skin color, Hispanics can be of any country of origin or ancestry. One + +result of this diversity is that people from certain countries may be more likely to identify + +as Hispanic on census forms. For example, in a Pew Research Center analysis of the + +Census Bureau’s 2020 American Community Survey, nearly all immigrants from several + +Latin American and Caribbean countries called themselves Hispanic, including those from + +Mexico, Cuba and El Salvador (nearly 100% each). By comparison, 94% of immigrants + +from Paraguay and 92% from Argentina said so, as did 95% of immigrants from Spain and + +90% from Panama. + +What about Brazilians, Portuguese and Filipinos? Are they considered Hispanic? + +People with ancestries in Brazil, Portugal and the Philippines do not fit the federal + +government’s official definition of “Hispanic” because the countries are not Spanish- + +speaking. For the most part, people who trace their ancestry to just these countries are not + +counted as Hispanic by the Census Bureau even if they identify as Hispanic. Only about + +2%-3% of immigrants from Brazil are counted as Hispanic, as are about 1%-2% of + +immigrants from Portugal and the Philippines, according to the 2010- 2019 American + +Community Surveys. + +How many people with Hispanic ancestry do not identify as Hispanic? + + Of the 42.7 million adults with Hispanic ancestry living in the U.S. in 2015, an estimated 5 + +million people, or 11%, said they do not identify as Hispanic or Latino, according to a Pew + +Research Center survey of U.S. adults. These people aren’t counted as Hispanic in Center + +surveys. + +Notably, Hispanic self-identification among U.S. adults with Hispanic heritage varies + +across immigrant generations. Among immigrants from Latin America, nearly all identify + +as Hispanic. But by the fourth generation, only half of people with Hispanic heritage in the + +U.S. identify as Hispanic. + +How has the Census Bureau changed the way it counts Hispanics over time? + +The first year the Census Bureau asked everybody in the country about Hispanic ethnicity + +was in 1980. Some efforts were made before then to count people who today would be + +considered Hispanic. In the 1930 census, for example, an attempt to count Hispanics + +appeared as part of the race question, which had a category for “Mexican.” + +The first major attempt to estimate the size of the nation’s Hispanic population came in + +1970 and prompted widespread concerns among Hispanic organizations about an + +undercount. A portion of the U.S. population (5%) was asked if their origin or descent was + +from the following categories: “Mexican, Puerto Rican, Cuban, Central or South American, + + Other Spanish” and “No, none of these.” This approach had problems, among them an + +undercount of about 1 million Hispanics. + +One reason for this is that many second-generation Hispanics did not select one of the + +Hispanic groups because the question did not include terms like “Mexican American.” The + +question wording also resulted in hundreds of thousands of people living in the Southern + +or Central regions of the U.S. being mistakenly included in the “Central or South + +American” category. + +By 1980, the current approach – in which someone is asked if they are Hispanic – had + +taken hold, with some tweaks made to the question and response categories since then. In + +2000, for example, the term “Latino” was added to make the question read, “Is this person + +Spanish/Hispanic/Latino?” + +In recent years, the Census Bureau has studied an alternative approach to counting + +Hispanics that combines the questions that ask about Hispanic origin and race. This + +change did not appear in the 2020 census, though the race question was changed to allow + +for written responses to all race categories. The race and ethnicity questions could change + +for the 2030 census under a plan announced in June 2022 by the Office of Management + +and Budget. + +Note: This post was originally published on May 28, 2009, by Jeffrey S. Passel and Paul + +Taylor, former vice president of Pew Research Center. It has been updated a number of + +times since then. + +Topics Racial & Ethnic Identity, Hispanic/Latino Identity + +SHARE THIS LINK: + +https://pewrsr.ch/3UaUJpI + +    + +Mark Hugo Lopez is director of race and ethnicity research at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO TWITTER EMAIL + +Jens Manuel Krogstad is a senior writer and editor at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO EMAIL + + Jeffrey S. Passel is a senior demographer at Pew Research Center. + +POSTS BIO EMAIL + +Sign up for our weekly newsletter +Fresh data delivered Saturday mornings + +Email address + +SIGN UP + +R E L A T E D + +REP O RT | NO V 4, 2021 + +Majority of Latinos Say Skin Color Impacts Opportunity in America and Shapes Daily Life + +SHO RT READ | SEP 24, 2020 + +The ways Hispanics describe their identity vary across immigrant generations + +SHO RT READ | AUG 24, 2020 + +Rising share of lawmakers – but few Republicans – are using the term Latinx on social media + +REP O RT | AUG 11, 2020 + +About One-in-Four U.S. Hispanics Have Heard of Latinx, but Just 3% Use It + +REP O RT | DEC 20, 2017 + +Hispanic Identity Fades Across Generations as Immigrant Connections Fall Away + +T O P I C S + +Hispanic/Latino Identity + +Racial & Ethnic Identity + +M O S T P O P U L A R + + India’s Sex Ratio at Birth Begins To Normalize + +Political Typology Quiz + +Two Decades Later, the Enduring Legacy of 9/11 + +Key findings about U.S. immigrants + +Modeling the Future of Religion in America + +1615 L St. NW, Suite 800 + +Washington, DC 20036 + +USA + +(+1) 202-419-4300 | Main + +(+1) 202-857-8562 | Fax + +(+1) 202-419-4372 | Media + +Inquiries + +RESEARCH TOPICS + +FOLLOW US + +Politics & Policy + +Family & Relationships + + + + Email Newsletters + +International Affairs + +Economy & Work + + + + Facebook + +Immigration & Migration + +Science + +Race & Ethnicity + +Internet & Technology + + + + Twitter + + + + Tumblr + +Religion + +News Habits & Media + + + + YouTube + +Generations & Age + +Methodological Research + + + + RSS + +Gender & LGBTQ + +Full topic list + +ABOUT PEW RESEARCH CENTER Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes and trends shaping +the world. It conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, media content analysis and other empirical social science research. Pew Research +Center does not take policy positions. It is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts. + +Copyright 2022 Pew Research Center About + +Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Reprints, Permissions & Use Policy + +Feedback Careers + +12345 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q254/random_k4/random_2.md b/q254/random_k4/random_2.md index 63997426913f0cf7e9aaa581df256d9753a08a24..306e12d21313f7ffcf04279a9a817cb3be1e4ff4 100644 --- a/q254/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q254/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,2837 +1,989 @@ -HSBC Strategy Update: Return to Growth and Value Creation -Investor presentation, June 2018 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Important notice and forward-looking statements - -Important notice - -The information, statements and opinions set out in this presentation and subsequent discussion do not constitute a public offer for the purposes of any applicable law or an offer to -sell or solicitation of any offer to purchase any securities or other financial instruments or any advice or recommendation in respect of such securities or other financial instruments. - -The information contained in this presentation and subsequent discussion, which does not purport to be comprehensive nor render any form of financial or other advice, has been -provided by HSBC Holdings plc and its consolidated subsidiary undertakings (the “Group”) and has not been independently verified by any person. No responsibility, liability or -obligation (whether in tort, contract or otherwise) is accepted by the Group or any member of the Group or any of their affiliates or any of its or their officers, employees, agents or -advisers (each an “Identified Person”) as to or in relation to this presentation and any subsequent discussions (including the accuracy, completeness or sufficiency thereof) or any -other written or oral information made available or any errors contained therein or omissions therefrom, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed. - -No representations or warranties, express or implied, are given by any Identified Person as to, and no reliance should be placed on the accuracy or completeness of any information -contained in this presentation, any other written or oral information provided in connection therewith or any data which such information generates. No Identified Person undertakes, or -is under any obligation, to provide the recipient with access to any additional information, to update, revise or supplement this presentation or any additional information or to remedy -any inaccuracies in or omissions from this presentation. - -Forward-looking statements - -This presentation and subsequent discussion may contain projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, opinions, prospects, results, returns and forward-looking statements with respect -to the financial condition, results of operations, capital position, strategy and business of the Group (together, “forward-looking statements”), including the strategic priorities and 2020 -financial, investment and capital targets described herein. Any such forward-looking statements are not a reliable indicator of future performance, as they may involve significant -assumptions and subjective judgements which may or may not prove to be correct and there can be no assurance that any of the matters set out in forward-looking statements are -attainable, will actually occur or will be realized or are complete or accurate. Forward-looking statements are statements about the future and are inherently uncertain and generally -based on stated or implied assumptions. Certain of the assumptions and judgements upon which forward-looking statements contained herein are based are discussed under -“Targeted Outcomes: Basis of Preparation”, available separately from this presentation at www.hsbc.com. The assumptions may prove to be incorrect and involve known and -unknown risks, uncertainties, contingencies and other important factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group. Actual achievements, results, performance or other future -events or conditions may differ materially from those stated, implied and/or reflected in any forward-looking statements due to a variety of risks, uncertainties and other factors -(including without limitation those which are referable to general market conditions or regulatory changes). Any such forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, expectations -and opinions of the Group at the date the statements are made, and the Group does not assume, and hereby disclaims, any obligation or duty to update, revise or supplement them if -circumstances or management’s beliefs, expectations or opinions should change. For these reasons, recipients should not place reliance on, and are cautioned about relying on, any -forward-looking statements. No representations or warranties, expressed or implied, are given by or on behalf of the Group as to the achievement or reasonableness of any -projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects or returns contained herein. Additional detailed information concerning important factors that could cause actual results to differ -materially is available in our Annual Report and Accounts for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2017 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on Form 20-F on -20 February 2018 (the “2017 20-F”) and in our 1Q 2018 Earnings Release furnished to the SEC on Form 6-K on 4 May 2018 (the “1Q 2018 Earnings Release”). - -This presentation contains non-GAAP financial information. The primary non-GAAP financial measure we use is ‘adjusted performance’ which is computed by adjusting reported -results for the period-on-period effects of foreign currency translation differences and significant items which distort period-on-period comparisons. Significant items are those items -which management and investors would ordinarily identify and consider separately when assessing performance in order to better understand the underlying trends in the business. -Reconciliations between non-GAAP financial measurements and the most directly comparable measures under GAAP are provided in the 2017 20-F, the Reconciliations of Non- -GAAP Financial Measures document and the 1Q 2018 Earnings Release which are available at www.hsbc.com. - -Information in this presentation was prepared as at 10 June 2018. +Fellow Shareholders, -2 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Summary of the strategy - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - - World’s leading international bank and No 1 global transaction bank - Unparalleled access to high growth markets and coverage of trade corridors between - -them - - Recognised for signature balance sheet strength – foundation for future growth and a - -stable dividend - -Next phase of our strategy is to return the Group to growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and synchronised - -economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - - Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular in Asia - -and from our international network - - Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of disruptive - -technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in growth and -technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Complete the turnaround in the US - Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - -As a result of these strategic priorities, the Group targets a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while -delivering positive adjusted jaws on an annual basis and sustaining our dividend - -3 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Strategic priorities to deliver growth, improve returns, and enhance -customer and employee experience - -Strategic priorities - -Financial targets - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. - -Insurance and Asset Management) - -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative and the -transition to a low carbon economy -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher -return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth -and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Empower our -people - -RoTE1 - - >11% by 2020 - -Costs - - Positive jaws - -(adjusted, on an -annual basis) - -Capital -and -dividend - - Sustain dividends -through long-term -earnings capacity -of the businesses - Share buy-backs - -subject to -regulatory -approval - -1. Return on tangible equity (‘RoTE’) is calculated as reported profit attributable to ordinary shareholders less changes in goodwill and present value of in-force long term insurance business divided by average tangible shareholders’ - -equity. A targeted reported RoTE of 11% in 2020 is broadly equivalent to a reported return on equity (‘RoE’) of 10%; assumes a Group CET1 ratio greater than 14% - -4 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and -signature balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -5 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Leading international bank with a platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Who we are - -Strategic differentiators - -c.38m -customers served -by 229k -colleagues1 - -67 markets -Covering >90% -of global GDP, -trade and capital -flows - -#1 -global transaction -bank2 - -#1 -International bank -in Asia3 - -USD182bn -Total capital4 - -Top 3 -FTSE dividend -payer5 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank - >50% of Group client revenue connected to the network - No 1 global transaction bank, gaining market share - Recognised by customers as leading international bank - -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - Access to high growth developing markets in Asia, - -Middle East and Latin America - - Investment aligned to high growth markets to deliver - -shareholder value - -Signature balance sheet strength - Strong capital, funding and liquidity position with - -diversified business model - - Conservative approach to credit risk and liquidity - -management - - Low earnings volatility - Strong capital position and intrinsic capital generation - Foundation for sustained dividend; strong capacity for - -distribution to shareholders - -1. Full-time equivalent as at 31 Dec 2017 -2. Based on 2017 Transaction Banking product total revenue (including Payments, Cash Management, Trade -Finance, FX and Securities Services) compared with US and European peers. Source: HSBC Research - -3. Based on 2017 total revenue in Asia among major international and regional banks in Asia. Peers include - -Standard Chartered, DBS, Citi, UOB, OCBC, Maybank and CIMB. Source: Company accounts - -4. As at 31 Dec 2017 -5. Total USD payout (2015-2017) - -6 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -1 - -Leading international bank with high return transaction banking - -Leading transaction banking -franchises1 - -FY2017, revenue, USDbn - -Recognised as leading international -bank - -% of large corporates choosing HSBC as -their lead international bank2 - -Leading market positions - -HSBC - -US Bank - -US Bank - -US Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -European -Bank - -15.2 - -26% - -22% - -21% - -#1 -bank for -Trade Finance3 - -#1 -bank for FX -for corporates4 - -Asia - -US - -Europe - -RoTE Transaction Banking, % - ->20% - -HSBC -Transaction -Banking - -Transaction -Banking -Industry1 - -Banking -Industry -overall7 - -#1 -bank for -Liquidity and -account -management3 - -#2 -bank for -Emerging -Markets Fixed -Income6 - -#1 -For Assets -Under Custody -in Asia Pacific5 - -53% -of client -revenue -connected to -international -network - -1. Revenue from GTRF, GLCM, FX and Securities Services, compared with peer equivalents. - -Source: Company financial data; HSBC adjusted revenue - -2. Greenwich Associates – Large Corporate Banking -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey; G10 + EM countries - -5. EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen -6. EM Macro; McKinsey/ Coalition -7. McKinsey - -7 - -9%20% Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength -Unparalleled access to high growth markets - -2 - -Emerging markets remain drivers of global -growth - -HSBC has access to high growth markets - -World Nominal GDP growth, 2017-20301 - -Asia, Market shares2 - -+5.8% - -Asia - -Middle East - -Africa - -Latin America - -N. America - -Europe - -2017 - -2030E - -World Trade Growth, 2017-20301 - -+6.1% - -Asia - -Middle East - -Africa - -Latin America - -N. America - -Europe - -CAGR - -7.4% - -7.4% - -6.5% - -6.0% - -4.3% - -4.6% - -CAGR - -7.1% - -7.8% - -8.0% - -5.7% - -4.4% - -5.4% - -29% Hong Kong - -12% PRD4 - -(Share in Guangdong -among foreign banks) - -5% Singapore - -3% Malaysia - -Middle East, Market shares2 - -8% Saudi Arabia7 - -4% United Arab - -Emirates - -Latin America, Market shares2 - -8% Mexico - - Largest among international and - -regional banks3 - - 50% of Group adjusted revenues and - ->75% of Group adjusted profits in 2017 - - Strong foundation in China / PRD to - -support future expansion - - #1 DCM in Asia5 (6% market share) - #1 in offshore RMB bond underwriting - -with 28% market share6 - - Leading international bank in the Middle - -East8 - - Ranked #1 in cash management and trade - -finance9 - - Well positioned for Saudi Vision 2030 and - -Belt and Road Initiative10 - - #1 DCM in Middle East5 - - Top 5 bank in Mexico11 - Wholesale network across LATAM region - An intra-regional strategy focused on - -leveraging cross-border flows, including -with NAFTA - -2017 - -2030E - -1. Global Insights Jan18; World trade based on imports plus exports -2. Customer deposits, based on local regulators’ data -3. Excludes Asia-Pacific based banks where majority of revenue generated in its domestic market and excludes - -Japanese banks - -4. CBRC/PBOC -5. Dealogic, based on 2017 full year fees - -109 QFI applications approved by CMA -Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC -By assets in 2017 from MENA regional bank financials -Euromoney Trade Finance Survey 2018 and Euromoney Cash Management Survey 2017 - -6. -7. -8. -9. -10. Best International Bank for BRI in 2017 Asiamoney New Silk Road Finance Awards -11. National Commission of Banking and Securities (Mexico) - -8 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -2 - -Access to domestic growth in eight markets; network to connect -trade and capital flows - -Aspiration - -Characteristics - -Markets - -Markets at -scale - -“HSBC is -considered one of -the leading -domestic banks” - -Markets as -leading -international -bank - -“HSBC is the -leading international -bank in the country” - - Top 5 bank, at least 3-5% - -market share - - At least USD1bn revenue - Universal bank - Full participation across -customer segments - - Hong Kong - UK - Mexico - PRD - Singapore - - Malaysia - UAE - Saudi -Arabia1 - - Leading international bank - At least USD0.5bn revenue - Wholesale bank or Universal -bank with very focused retail -offering (where strategic) - - Australia - Canada - China - France - - Germany - India - Indonesia - US - -Markets to -connect the -network - -“HSBC is in the -country to connect -foreign and local -customers to our -network” - - Targeted offering for - -international customers - - Wholesale-focused - Branch or rep office where - -possible - - Network markets to - -connect trade and capital -flows (e.g. Japan, Spain, -Brazil) - - Supporting subsidiaries of - -global customers - -% of adj. -revenue - -FY17 - -c.60% - -c.25% - -c.15% - -1. Engagement in Saudi Arabia primarily through investment in Saudi British Bank (SABB); held as an Associate of HSBC - -9 - - Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature balance sheet strength - -3 - -Signature balance sheet strength - -Strong balance sheet, FY2017, USD (unless otherwise stated) - -Low-risk model with stable earnings, 2017 - -Customer accounts - -Balance Sheet - -Loans & advances to -customers - -Total equity - -1.4tn - -1.0tn - -198bn - -Total regulatory capital - -182bn - -Capital - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital ratio - -5.6% - -20.9% - -Advances to deposits ratio - -71% - -Funding and -liquidity - -Liquidity coverage ratio - -142% - -10 year PBT -volatility2 - -LICs / loans -and advances3 - -Advances to -deposits ratio - -Leverage ratio - -Total capital -ratio - -Liquid asset buffer - ->500bn - -CET1 ratio - -Peer group -average1 - -2.6x - -HSBC - -1.0x - -5.5%4 - -Source: HSBC and peers’ public filings, Bloomberg, Factset -1. Average calculated based on 2017 published figures by the following peers: Barclays, BNP, Citi, DBS, Deutsche Bank, ICBC, Itau, JP Morgan, Santander, Standard Chartered, BoAML; ICBC not included in CET1 ratio -2. Calculated as range of reported PBT divided by average reported PBT from 2008 to 2017 -3. Represents gross loans and advances to customers -Leverage ratio not disclosed by ICBC and Itau -4. - -10 - -0.9%0.2%13.0%14.5%82%71%5.6%17.1%20.9% HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda - -1 - -2 - -3 - -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 - -11 - - Strategic priorities -Completing period of transformation; platform for growth - -Transformation since 2011 - -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation - - Divested or exited 110 businesses -and geographies, reducing Group -footprint from 87 countries to 67 - - Reduced Risk Weighted Assets by - -USD349bn or 29%1 - - Globalised the organisation -around 4 Global Businesses, -supported by Global Functions - - Introduced robust financial crime -risk management capabilities - - Invested USD7bn “Costs to Achieve” - -to realise cost efficiencies of -USD6.1bn p.a. from our global -platform and built digital -capabilities - - Shifted business to Asia and - -faster-growing markets with Asia -representing c.50% of Group -revenue and c.75% of Group -profits2 - - Strengthened network to support - -global trade and capital flows - - Demonstrated ability to execute - -Deliver growth -from areas of -strength - -Growth - -Turnaround of -low-return -businesses - -Turnaround - -Build a bank for -the future that -puts the -customer at the -centre - -Customer - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise, and -Insurance and Asset Management in Asia -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global -investment: China-led Belt and Road Initiative -and the transition to a low carbon economy - -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, -increase mortgage market share, grow commercial -customer base, and improve customer service - -Gain market share and deliver growth from our -international network - -Turn around our US business - -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into -higher return businesses - -Create capacity for increasing investments in -growth and technology through efficiency gains - -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved - -customer service - - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry- - -leading financial crime standards - -Empower our -people - -8 - -Simplify the organisation and invest in future -skills - -Our People - -1. Period 2015-17 -2. Adjusted basis - -12 - - Strategic priorities - -1-3 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns -well above cost of equity - -Revenue (reported), USDbn, 2011-2020 - -Targeting revenue opportunities in high growth areas with returns well above cost of equity - -CAGR --8% - -72.3 - -mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -+7% - -51.4 - -48.0 - -2011 - -2016 - -2017 - -2020 -Target - -1. ROE including PVIF - -Market -Growth - -Size represents targeted revenue growth, -2017-2020; equal to c.USD1bn - -Low carbon economy/ -Sustainable Finance - -Asia Wealth - -Asset Management -(Asia) - -Belt and Road - -Insurance -(Asia)1 - -ASEAN - -PRD - -UK -Ring-fenced Bank - -Hong Kong - -Transaction Banking/ -International network - -5.8% -(World Nominal -GDP Growth) - -Cost of Equity - -RoTE - -13 - - Strategic priorities - -1 - -Accelerate revenue growth in Asia - ->3bn - ->1bn - ->0.2bn - -Franchise in Asia (reported, ex BoCom) - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -PBT, 2017 -USDbn - -11.4 - -7.5 - -A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - - Capture growth in targeted segments - Enhance customer experience - Capitalise on China outbound investments - -Revenue, 2017 USDbn - -Hong Kong -(RBWM -and CMB) - -Hong Kong -(GB&M, GPB and -Corporate Centre) - -ASEAN - -China - -India - -Australia - -Other Asia - -4.7 - -3.1 - -PRD - -0.2 - -2.4 - -2.4 - -0.9 - -0.9 - -2.1 - -1.2 - -0.5 - -0.9 - -0.4 - -0.8 - -B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta - Serve emerging middle class - Facilitate industrial up-grade and cross-border connectivity - Expand new business capabilities by further developing - -technology in PRD - -C - -Build leading Wealth Management business - - Capture growth in financial wealth in Asia - Build leading wealth business, particular focus on Greater - -China and ASEAN - - Grow insurance to address the protection gap - Enhance Asset Management to serve retail / institutional - -clients - -D - -Expand our business in ASEAN - - Continue to build regional product and coverage expertise - -to capture opportunities from Singapore’s role as a regional -hub for treasury and wealth - - Support intra-ASEAN business corridor flow - Capture infrastructure opportunity (including BRI) - Targeted digital investments to enhance position - -14 - - Strategic priorities - -1A - -Build on strength in Hong Kong - -HSBC’s market share has been steady over the years… - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Total banking -assets in Hong -Kong1, USDtn - -HSBC market -share, % - -USD0.9tn - -USD2.9tn - -10% - -CAGR -2005-17 - -24% - -2005 - -10% - -Asset growth - -25% - -20172 - -Leading market share across major products2 - -…with leading positions across major products3 - -Customer -accounts - -Loans and -advances to -customers - -DCM - -#1 - -#1 - -#1 - -Mortgages - -37% - -#1 - -Credit cards - ->40% - -Trade finance - -#1 - -Capture -growth in -targeted -segments - -Enhance -customer -experience - -Capitalise on -China -outbound -investments - - Grow millennials client base to build -customer generation for the future - Enhance proposition for Non Resident - -Chinese customers - - Invest in insurance for sustainable - -market share growth - - Develop digital payment ecosystem - Build new capabilities in Business - -Banking - - Explore partnerships to launch - -innovative solutions - - Capture new growth opportunities with - -China, in particular: -– Belt and Road Initiative -– International activities of Chinese - -corporates and financial institutions -– Greater Bay Area / Pearl River Delta -– Sustainable Finance/ Hong Kong as - -Green Financial Centre -– RMB Internationalisation - -1. HKMA, Annual Report 2017 -2. -3. HKMA announcements, Bloomberg, mReferaln 2017 and HSBC internal data; HSBC including Hang Seng. Mortgages - new sales count, legal mortgages; Loans – loans for use in Hong Kong; DCM - G3 currency bonds, Asia - -25% asset market share; 29% deposit market share - -15 - -excluding Japan - - Strategic priorities - -1B - -Develop a leading business in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) - -HSBC’s business in PRD has grown steadily - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -USDbn - -Revenue - -0.18 - -2014 - -0.22 - -2017 - ->USD1bn - -c.0.5 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - -Loans & advances to customers - ->20bn - -4.1 - -6.2 - ->10bn - -2014 - -2017 - -2020 -target - -Medium- -term target - - First JV securities company: majority-owned by a foreign bank - -in China, opened for business in December 2017 - - Headcount: >700 FTE increase in 2017; more than doubled - -since project launched in June 2015 - - Credit cards: Launched first HSBC sole-branded credit cards in -December 2016; total cards in force number: c.280k in PRD as -of April 2018 - - Grow and enhance distribution -network / access to customers - Broaden product offerings and -accelerate quality asset growth - Capture cross-border wealth flows, -e.g. opportunities from remittances, -Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock -Connect - - Enhance corporate coverage to - -capture growth from international -supply chains and industrial -upgrading - - Broaden client base and drive for - -deposit-heavy product mix - -Emerging -Middle -Class - -Industrial up- -grade / cross- -border -connectivity - - Fully leverage capital market - -capabilities of new Securities Joint -Venture HSBC Qianhai Securities - Expand Global Markets capabilities -arising from policy liberalisation - -New business -capabilities - -16 - - Strategic priorities - -1C - -Asia expected to be the largest creator of wealth - -Rising wealth in Asia - -Private financial wealth1, USDtn - -2016-21E -CAGR - -223 - -Middle class in Asia2 - -# of people, bn - -2.5x - -152 - -E. Europe - -L. America - -MENA - -N. America - -34% - -W. Europe - -25% - -Japan - -10% - -Asia ex Japan - -21% - -166 - -33% - -24% - -9% - -23% - -33% - -5.6% - -Average household annual income3 - -2015 - -2030E - -USD‘000 - -2.3x - -22% - -3.5% - -7% - -1.7% - -28% - -9.9% - -2017 - -2030E - -HNWI financial wealth4 - -USDtrn - -2.0x - -2014 - -2016 - -2021E - -1. BCG Global Wealth 2017 -2. Global Economy and Development: The Unprecedented Expansion of the Global Middle Class, 2017 -3. Euromonitor, disposable income by household -4. Capgemini: Asia Pacific Wealth Report, 2017 - -2017 - -2025E - -17 - -3.51.432.614.542.120.8 Strategic priorities - -1C - -HSBC is well-positioned to build a leading wealth business in Asia - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Wealth in Asia already a USD5.1bn -business for HSBC today - -Revenue (reported) in USDbn, Asia, 2017 - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -USD - -Wealth in -Asia - -Private -Bank - -RBWM -Wealth - -Insurance1 - -Asset -Management1 0.3 - -1. - -Includes manufacturing revenue only - -Wealth management (across Private Bank and RBWM) - - Hong Kong: Increase share in UHNW segment across Greater - -China - - Singapore: Accelerate client coverage / RM growth across all -segments including ASEAN new-to-bank / referred clients, and -Chinese offshore wealth - -0.7 - - China: Primary focus on Jade build-out underpinned by - -investment in RM and product platform - - Product: Leverage transactional banking, digital, discretionary - -portfolio management and lombard lending - -Insurance - - Develop product range to address the needs of new wealth - -customers, and strengthen front line - - Deepen existing insurance specialist coverage, and open up new - -distribution channels - - Exploring opportunities in mainland China - -Asset management - - Leverage coverage of GB&M / CMB clients - Increase share of wallet and net new money growth via RBWM / - -GPB customers - - Growth in Alternatives and Sustainable Investing - Exploring opportunities in mainland China - -18 - -2.41.85.1 Strategic priorities - -2 - -UK presents an opportunity for growth after successful -completion of ring-fencing - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Targeted -revenue -growth by -2020 - -USD - -Ring-Fenced Bank setup -close to completion - -Opportunities and areas of investment - - HSBC is positioned for - -sustainable growth; 14% -deposit market share1 and a 7% -mortgage market share2 - - UK ring-fencing remains on -track ahead of the July 2018 -legal separation - six months -ahead of the regulatory -deadline: - -– On the 21 May 2018, the High -Court approved the UK Ring- -Fenced Transfer Scheme - -– More than 95% of technical - -and IT related transfers have -already been successfully -completed - -Retail -banking - - Target mortgage growth (high single digit) by - -embedding controlled intermediary channel expansion3 - - Enhancing the multi-brand strategy to drive growth - -and acquire new customers - - Leverage our unique global access to support - -commercial customers’ trade and overseas banking -needs - -Corporate -banking - - Improve penetration of mid market segment through -additional on-boarding capacity and renewed focus on -‘fast growth cities or sectors’ - - Improve CRM and data analytics to drive better value -segmentation of clients (in particular Business Banking) - -Digital and -customer -satisfaction - - Target a consistent top 3 position in the UK for - -customer satisfaction, via journey improvements, -digital investment and simplification - - Capitalise on AI, Data analytics and Open Banking to -develop immersive customer experiences (e.g., -Connected Money app) - - Grow collaboration opportunities across business lines - -and brands - -1. Source: CACI Retail Finance Benchmark, 2017 -2. Source: Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), 2017 -3. No change in risk appetite - -19 - - Strategic priorities - -3 - -Proven ability to grow the business and gain market share; invest -for growth from our international network - ->USD1bn - ->0.4bn - ->0.1bn - -Investments are delivering - -Opportunities and areas of investment - -Targeted revenue -growth by 2020 - -Global Trade -and -Receivables -Finance - -Trade Finance -rank1 - -Hong Kong -market share2 - -2015 - -2017 - -#1 - -#1 - - - -10.8% - -13.8% - -Global -Liquidity -and Cash -Management - -Average GLCM -balances +Roku delivered another strong quarter of operational and financial performance in Q1 2018. The secular shift from legacy TV +distribution to streaming continues unabated. Our purpose-built TV operating system and advertising platform continue to +lead the market. Moreover, our advertising and content partners are benefiting from our increasing scale. Nearly half of our +roughly 21 million active users have cut the cord or have never had a traditional pay TV subscription, which means that they +simply cannot be reached through linear TV. This makes our strategic position in the living room extremely valuable. In the +first quarter, our platform segment revenue more than doubled, as active accounts grew 47% year-over-year and ARPU +increased 50%. With strong business momentum and favorable industry trends, we are raising our full year 2018 outlook. -c$470bn +May 9, 2018 -c$530bn +A few Q1 2018 highlights: -Hong Kong -market share3 +• +• +• +• +• +• +• -22.8% +Total net revenue up 36% YoY to $136.6 million; +Platform revenue up 106% YoY to $75.1 million; +Gross profit up 62% YoY to $63.1 million; +Active accounts up 47% YoY to 20.8 million at quarter end; +Streaming Hours up 56% YoY to 5.1 billion hours; +Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) up 50% YoY to $15.07 (trailing 12-month basis); +One in four smart TVs sold in the U.S. were Roku TVs. -26.3% +Key Operating Metrics +Active Accounts (millions) +Streaming Hours (billions) +ARPU ($) -FX corporates -rank4 +Summary Financials ($ in millions) -FX institutional -rank4 +Platform +Player +Total net revenue -#1 +Platform gross profit +Player gross profit -#7 +Total gross profit - +Platform gross margin % +Player gross margin % -#1 +Total gross margin % -#3 +R&D +Sales and marketing +G&A + +Total operating expenses +Income (loss) from operations +Adjusted EBITDA 1 +Adjusted EBITDA margin % + +Q1 17 -Assets under -custody +Q2 17 + +Q3 17 -$6.2trn +Q4 17 -$7.7trn +Q1 18 -FX - -Securities -Services - -Digitise and grow Trade Finance - - Transform technology and business model, enabling -simpler, safer and faster experiences for clients, and -seamless communication with trade ecosystems - - Capitalise on growth outlook for structured trade by - -investing in our channel and product capabilities - - Extend No 1 position in both traditional and structured - -trade - -Strengthen global leadership position in GLCM - - Drive sustained deposit and transaction growth by - -leveraging API and cloud to transform payments, liquidity -and data propositions - - Create new products and revenue streams - new - -propositions powered by machine learning, offsetting -competitive pressures in traditional fees - -FX business growth - - Grow the business through the continued development - -of ‘FX as a service’ engagement model - - Utilise technology to deliver efficiencies and digitise - -the customer experience - -Grow Securities Services business - -Market share5 - -5.4% - -5.8% - - Evolve business by enhancing and develop products - -Asia rank6 - -#1 - -#1 - -1. Oliver Wyman -2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority -3. Oliver Wyman -4. Greenwich Survey - -and services; invest in digital future - - - - Grow core business with Group clients, focus on - -asset managers and asset owners - -5. Based on AUC of Top 9 providers (BM, SS, JPM, Citi, BP2S, SG, NT, RBC, HSBC) making - -up c.82% of the market - -6. Assets Under Custody (AUC), EY, based on data provided by HSBC and Tricumen - -20 - - Strategic priorities - -4 - -The US is the single biggest exporter of revenue to the Group and -an important part of HSBC’s proposition as leading international bank - -US biggest exporter of client revenue to the Group -Cross-border GB&M and CMB client revenue1, 2017, -USDbn - -Outbound client revenue: client revenue booked outside -of the country where client is managed - -Client revenue from US-managed -companies booked outside US - -2 +YoY % + +$ + + $ + +$ + +$ + +14.2 +3.3 +10.04 + +Q1 17 + +36.4 +63.7 +100.1 +28.1 +10.8 +38.8 +77.1 % +16.9 % +38.8 % +22.3 +14.1 +10.3 +46.7 +(7.8 ) +(4.4 ) +-4.4 % + +$ + +$ + +15.1 +3.5 +11.22 + +Q2 17 + +46.0 +53.7 +99.6 +34.2 +3.4 +37.6 +74.4 % +6.4 % +37.8 % +25.8 +14.7 +10.6 +51.0 +(13.4 ) +(9.6 ) +-9.7 % + +$ + +$ + +16.7 +3.8 +12.68 + +Q3 17 + +57.5 +67.3 +124.8 +44.6 +5.3 +49.9 +77.5 % +7.9 % +40.0 % +28.5 +16.2 +13.0 +57.8 +(7.9 ) +(3.7 ) +-2.9 % + +$ + +$ + +19.3 +4.3 +13.78 + +Q4 17 + +85.4 +102.8 +188.3 +63.7 +9.8 +73.5 +74.6 % +9.5 % +39.0 % +31.3 +19.1 +13.5 +64.0 +9.5 +14.4 +7.6 % + +20.8 +5.1 +15.07 + +47 % +56 % +50 % + +Q1 18 + +YoY % + +75.1 +61.5 +136.6 +53.4 +9.7 +63.1 +71.1 % +15.8 % +46.2 % +34.1 +20.3 +15.6 +70.0 +(6.9 ) +(0.8 ) +-0.6 % + +106 % +-3 % +36 % +90 % +-10 % +62 % +-595 bps +-114 bps +741 bps +53 % +45 % +51 % +50 % + N/A + N/A +381 bps + +Outlook ($ in millions) +Total net revenue +Total gross profit +Net loss +Adjusted EBITDA +1 Refer to the reconciliation of net loss to adjusted EBITDA in the non-gaap information. +2 Q2 2018E reconciling items between net loss and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA consist of stock-based compensation of approximately $6.0 million, +depreciation & amortization and other net adjustments of approximately $1.5 million, partially offset by interest and other income of approximately $0.3 +million. +3 Full Year 2018 reconciling items between net loss and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA consist of stock-based compensation of +approximately $24 million, depreciation and amortization and other net adjustments of approximately $8 million partially offset by interest +and other income of approximately $2 million. + +Full Year 2018E 3 +$685 - $705 +$290 - $305 +($40) - ($25) +($10) - $5 + +Q2 2018E 2 +$135 - $145 +$58 - $63 +($19) - ($14) +($12) - ($7) + +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 1 -0 - -US - -UK - -China - -France + Q1 2018 results and outlook + +Q1 revenue and gross profit came in ahead of our outlook, driven by better-than-expected Platform revenue and higher-than- +anticipated Player gross profits. In the quarter, revenue increased 36% year-over-year, gross profit grew 62%, and gross +margin expanded seven percentage points to 46%. Platform revenue exceeded player revenue for the first time at 55% of +total revenue, vs. 36% a year ago. Platform gross profit - a key business driver – was 85% of gross profit, vs. 72% a year earlier. +Adjusted EBITDA loss of ($0.8) million and net loss of ($6.6) million were much lower than the outlook we provided in +February. + +We saw strong momentum across our key operating metrics. Roku ended Q1 2018, with 20.8 million active accounts, up 47% +year-over-year. Half of the new accounts in the quarter came from licensed sources, primarily Roku TVs. Roku users streamed +5.1 billion hours in the quarter, up 56% year-over-year, with the fastest growth coming from ad-supported content. Trailing +12-month ARPU in the first quarter increased 50% year-over-year to a record $15.07, the fastest ARPU growth rate in over 18 +months as we continue to expand platform monetization and capture a larger share of TV ad budgets. We believe there is a +long runway for upside to ARPU from content distribution, audience development and advertising growth, as consumers +spend time streaming more ad-supported content, and as Roku gains access to a greater share of overall ad impressions. + +Platform revenue grew 106% year-over-year, with advertising revenue representing the largest driver of Platform segment +revenue growth. Platform gross profit increased 90% year-over-year while Platform gross margin dropped six percentage +points year-over-year to 71% as the anticipated mix shift to video advertising, which trends towards roughly 50% gross +margin, continues. Player revenue declined 3% as we continue to see positive unit growth coupled with our strategy of +shifting mix to lower priced players. + +Q1 operating expenses were $70 million, up 50% year-over-year, as we continued to invest in top talent across the +organization, with R&D up 53% year-over-year and sales and marketing up 45%, as we focus on growing advertising, Roku TV, +The Roku Channel and other new business opportunities. G&A grew 51% as we have made investments in back office +functions to support the increasing complexity of our business and ramp up to be a public company. These expenses should +scale over time. Roku ended the quarter with $161 million in cash and no debt. + +Based on the strong performance and trends we are seeing to date, we are raising our outlook for full year 2018. Our +profitability goal for the year is to operate our business at, or near, break-even on an adjusted EBITDA basis. As a reminder, +Q4 seasonality is a material component of our business with seasonal strength in both Platform and Player segments. We +expect this trend to continue in 2018 and estimate Q4 revenue could once again be roughly 37% of total annual revenue, +consistent with Q4 of last year. + +The secular shift of legacy TV to streaming + +The replatforming of the TV industry is occurring at a rapid pace as consumers continue to shift their time away from +traditional linear TV in search of a better TV experience. That's driving unparalleled industry disruption as content distribution +and TV advertising move to streaming platforms. Roku's industry leading streaming players and smart TVs have been +important enablers of the transition - and are key drivers of Roku's increasing scale. The average U.S. home has roughly three +TVs, and most lack a purpose-built TV OS. This creates a significant opportunity to sell more players and to replace older TVs +with Roku TVs. With linear TV ratings in sharp decline, advertisers and content owners must find new ways to reach cord +cutters, cord shavers and cord nevers. We believe the Roku platform is the perfect solution for this rapidly evolving +ecosystem. + +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -% of Group client outbound revenue - -Hong -Kong - -24% +2 -13% + Roku TV – The leading licensed TV platform -9% +Roku TV is the #1 licensed TV operating system in the U.S and is going from strength to strength. One in four smart TVs sold in +the U.S. in Q1 2018 were Roku TVs - that's up from one in five in 2017. In the quarter, we expanded our Funai Electric +relationship by extending the program to the Magnavox brand, and in April we added Sanyo (initially in Canada). There is +tremendous room for innovation in smart TVs and Roku is leading the way helping TV OEMs cover the broadest set of +consumer preferences, from $150 entry-level smart TVs to cutting-edge $1,000 4K UHD, HDR10, Dolby Vision smart TVs with +advanced features like full-array backlighting, local dimming and voice control. -6% +We believe virtually every TV OEM will eventually need to license a TV OS, as consumers shift to smart TVs with 4K displays, +and as OEMs focus on both cutting costs and boosting customer satisfaction. A case in point: TCL, now the #3 U.S. television +brand, is getting high-praise reviews for a new line of Roku TVs now on shelves in Walmart, Best Buy and other major +retailers. CNET recently wrote that the TCL 6 series "could be the most incredible TV value of 2018." -6% +With this strong momentum, we expect retail distribution of Roku TV models to grow in 2018. -Significant for HSBC’s global franchise +Leading OTT content distribution for direct-to-consumer services -USD -represents -68% of -payments -volume for -HSBC2 +As one of the largest, most advanced content distribution and audience development platforms, Roku has become a key +destination for launching and marketing virtual pay TV services (or “virtual MVPDs”). Today, Roku offers one of the broadest +selections of direct-to-consumer services, including Sling TV, DirecTV Now, PlayStation Vue, Hulu Live, YouTube TV, fuboTV +and Philo. For many of these services, we are among the largest sources of trials, conversion and ongoing economics. -HSBC top 5 -cross-border -USD clearer3 +Our customer base of avid streamers also presents a major opportunity for specialist services, for example ESPN+, which will +be launching soon on Roku. Partners take advantage of our unique audience development tools to address consumer demand +for sports, news and other live programming. Roku has become a leading content aggregation point - the TV “home screen” - +for many OTT customers who may only be reachable in their living room via the Roku platform. -c.19% of -HSBC -custody -assets -denominated -in USD +The Roku Channel – Expanding reach -Other +The Roku Channel aggregates content into a simple, friendly user interface for consumers, while providing content owners +with a one-stop, large scale platform to publish their content while Roku manages advanced promotion, engagement, and +monetization capabilities. -32% +We are seeing very strong engagement on The Roku Channel, and just eight months after launch, The Roku Channel is now a +top 15 channel on Roku devices based on hours streamed - and the #3 free ad-supported channel on the Roku platform. In +Q1, we expanded the content syndicated from channel partners and added more movies and TV shows from Lionsgate, MGM, +Sony Pictures Entertainment, Warner Bros. and other studios. Recently, we announced the addition of live news from ABC +News, Cheddar, People TV and others. -51% +We are exploring options for expanding The Roku Channel’s reach. In March, we announced that we will make The Roku +Channel available off the Roku platform starting this summer with Samsung TVs. We believe there is a significant opportunity +to take The Roku Channel beyond the Roku OS platform to other large-scale platforms. -68% +Building a direct-to-consumer (D2C) OTT service is a major challenge for many content owners. It requires the ability to +aggregate a very large audience, build critical mass of content, develop advanced software and user interfaces, to monetize – +for example with billing and advanced TV advertising – and manage churn and engagement. All of this requires sophisticated -USD +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -JP -Morgan +3 -Citigroup + software, big data and machine learning, and navigating complex regulatory frameworks. We believe content owners will +increasingly choose to distribute their content directly on Roku’s platform via The Roku Channel vs. creating their own D2C +service (or “channel”). -Bank of -America +The Roku OTT Advertising Platform – Capturing Share of TV Ad Budgets -HSBC +Linear TV ratings continue to decline. According to Nielsen, prime time linear TV ratings among 18 to 49-year olds have +declined by 40% over the last 4 years. As consumers shift their TV viewing to streaming, advertisers are increasingly turning to +OTT and the Roku platform to reach these audiences. Today, roughly 10% of all adults between 18 and 34 can only be reached +on TV on the Roku platform in the living room. We expect that number to grow, which should make our platform an even +more important way for brands to engage TV viewers. -BoNY -Mellon +We have built a sophisticated TV ad platform with advanced targeting and measurement capabilities. These capabilities, +together with our ability to reach viewers who have left the traditional TV ecosystem, position Roku to capture a growing +share of the roughly $70 billion annual U.S. TV advertising market. This year, for the first time, Roku has been running its first +TV “upfronts” meetings. Occurring in the spring each year, upfronts are the time of year when a majority of TV advertising is +planned and committed. This is a milestone moment for OTT, as advertisers have recognized that OTT must now be part of +their TV ad spending strategy. While it is still early days, we believe this is a significant moment for the industry and for Roku. -c.19% +In March, Roku held its second annual client event, Roku Ad Connect, where we hosted top agencies and advertising clients, +representing a significant portion of Roku’s projected 2018 ad revenues, and a majority of all U.S. ad spend annually. At this +event, we shared insights into TV ad industry trends and the solutions for advertisers facing declining linear TV viewership and +reach. One clear takeaway from the event was a consensus view that the shift to OTT is happening at an increasing pace. -Overall +As advertisers shift their spending to OTT, they are also benefiting from the increased effectiveness of OTT advertising. A +recent study by IPG and Magna concluded that ads on the Roku platform are 67% more effective per exposure at driving +purchase intent than traditional linear TV ads. Our ability to directly reach our highly engaged active user base with advanced +targeting and measurement is Roku’s primary advantage as it expands its position in the TV ads marketplace. -Hong Kong +Conclusion -Germany +This industry transformation to TV streaming is happening. Favorable industry trends and strong execution are driving our +continued strong financial performance. On May 20th, we'll celebrate National Streaming Day, with this year marking the 10th +anniversary of the launch of our first streaming player, which allowed users to stream Netflix to the TV for the first time. As +part of the celebration, we'll be ringing the opening bell at the Nasdaq Market Site on May 16 and turning Times Square +purple. It’s a great time to be in the streaming business! -UK +Thanks for your support and Happy Streaming! -1. Client revenue is sourced from HSBC internal client MI. Client revenue excludes Business Banking and differs from reported revenue -2. -3. Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS) +Sincerely, -Internal HSBC data and SWIFT +Anthony Wood, Founder & CEO -21 +Steve Louden, CFO -16%16%29%9.2%10.4%16.2%17.1%9.4% Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 4 -Significant progress to date; targeted organic growth to bring scale -to US platform - -The US has made progress over the past several years… - -…and our medium-term strategy is built on continued organic growth - -Adjusted PBT1, USDm - -RoTE2 - -> 6%2 - -1,201 - -974 - -CML - -US Principal - -464 + Conference Call Webcast – 2pm PST May 9th, 2018 -494 +The Company will host a webcast of its conference call to discuss the Q1 2018 results at 2p.m. Pacific Time / 5p.m. Eastern +Time. Participants may access the live webcast in listen-only mode on the Roku investor relations website at ir.roku.com. An +archived webcast of the conference call will also be available at ir.roku.com following the call. -737 +Roku Business Basics -920 +For an introduction to Roku’s business see Roku 101 document on the investor relations website at ir.roku.com. -556 +About Roku, Inc. -387 +Roku pioneered streaming to the TV. We connect users to the streaming content they love, enable content publishers to build +and monetize large audiences, and provide advertisers with unique capabilities to engage consumers. Roku streaming players +and Roku TVTM models are available around the world through direct retail sales and licensing arrangements with TV OEMs +and service operators. Roku is headquartered in Los Gatos, Calif. U.S.A. -2014 +Investor Relations +James Samford +ir@roku.com -2015 +Use of Non-GAAP Measures -2016 +Press +Eric Savitz +esavitz@roku.com -2017 - -0.9%2,3 - -2017 - -PBT growth - -Future capital -actions - -2020 - -Capital -reductions -completed & -Tax reform - - Completed run-off of the CML legacy portfolio; reduced -receivables from USD24bn at end-2014 to USD0bn at end -2017 - - Improved RBWM PBT, revenue and deposits; migration - -of >1mn customers to new core banking platform; -launched CMB returns improvement and infrastructure -rebuild - - Achieved non-objection to US capital plan as part of -CCAR in 2016 and 2017; first return of capital to the -Group (USD5.4bn) since 2006 - - International client revenue4 booked in the US up - -c.10% YoY; US client revenue booked outside of the US -(outbound) is up c.15% YoY - - Improved profitability driven by global business organic growth in: +In addition to financial information prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States +(GAAP), this shareholder letter includes certain non-GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP measures include Adjusted +EBITDA and pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share. In order for Roku’s investors to be better able to compare its +current results with those of previous periods, Roku has shown a reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures as an +appendix to this letter. The Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation adjusts the related GAAP financial measures to exclude other +income (expense), net, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation and amortization, and income tax expense where +applicable. The pro forma basic and diluted net income (loss) per share reconciliation gives effect to the conversion of +outstanding convertible preferred stock using the as-if converted method into common shares as though the conversion had +occurred as of the beginning of the period. Also, the numerator has been adjusted to reverse the fair value adjustments +related to the convertible preferred stock warrants as they became warrants to purchase common stock at the time of our +initial public offering and at such time no longer required periodic revaluation. We believe these non-GAAP financial measures +are useful as a supplement in evaluating our ongoing operational performance and enhancing an overall understanding of our +past financial performance. However, these non-GAAP financial measures have limitations, and you should not consider them +in isolation or as a substitute for our GAAP financial information. -– CMB: Targeting greater share in corporates, particularly +Forward-Looking Statements -international mid market companies and subsidiaries, through -increased coverage and sector focus; supported by selected cash -management and lending product expansion +This shareholder letter contains “forward-looking” statements that are based on our beliefs and assumptions and on +information currently available to us. Forward-looking statements include all statements that are not historical facts and can +be identified by terms such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “could,” “seek,” “estimate,” “intend,” “may,” “plan,” “potential,” +“predict,” “project,” “should,” “will,” “would” or similar expressions and the negatives of those terms. -– RBWM: Targeted growth within international segment and higher- +Forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause our actual +results, performance or achievements to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements +expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements represent our beliefs and assumptions +only as of the date of this letter. These statements include our financial outlook for the second quarter of 2018 and for the full -return products and business banking - -– GBM: Sector coverage and greater share of foreign multi-national - -clients in the US - - Further efficiency gains to help fund reinvestments; invest in - -innovation leveraging Group technology solutions - - Return to regular dividend payments to Group - -1. US geographic basis -2. HSBC North America Holdings (‘HNAH’) legal entity basis. Reported RoTE for 2017 was -4.3% and included a 5.2% adverse impact from the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform -3. Principal Business RoTE for 2017 excluding the one time write down of deferred tax assets due to US Tax Reform, CML and deferred tax assets disallowed for capital purposes would be 2.2% -4. Revenue from international clients is derived from an allocation of Adjusted revenue based on internal management information. International clients are businesses and individuals with an international presence; YoY growth refers - -22 - -to 2017 - - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 5 -HSBC has a strong track record in delivering RWA reductions while -growing revenue; plans to further improve capital efficiencies - -RWA mix by Global Business - -Group RWAs, USDbn - --29% - -1,220 - -c.1-2% -p.a. - -Initiatives - - Embed RoTE in - -Global Businesses -and operating entities - - Link incentives to -value creation - -RoTE -implementation - -871 - -GB&M - -34% - -CMB - -35% - -RBWM -GPB -Corp -Centre - -14% -2% -15% - -c.30% - -To support mid- -single digit -revenue growth - -c.35% - -Distribution - -15-20% - -2020 -target - -c.7% - -RWA -optimisation - - Develop distribution - -channel and increase -distribution for -wholesale lending - - Free up capital/ -balance sheet -capacity and deploy -to higher return -business/clients - - Operating entity RWA - -optimisation - Improve global -booking model - -2014 - -5.0% - -Rev -as % -of RWA1 - -2017 - -RWA saves - -Business -growth - -5.9% - -1. Calculated using reported revenue and reported average RWAs. The increase between 2014 and 2017 includes the RWA impact of the 2016 change in the regulatory treatment of our investment in BoCom + fiscal year, the momentum in our Roku TV program, the growth of our platform segment, the expansion of The Roku Channel, +the evolution of the TV streaming ecosystem and continued development of our advertising business and the content we +make available to consumers on our platform, the growth in ARPU and active accounts and our overall business trajectory. +Except as required by law, we assume no obligation to update these forward-looking statements publicly, or to update the +reasons actual results could differ materially from those anticipated in the forward-looking statements, even if new +information becomes available in the future. Further information on factors that could cause actual results to differ +materially from the results anticipated by our forward-looking statements is included in the reports we have filed with the +Securities and Exchange Commission, including our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2017. -23 - - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 6 -Maintain strong cost discipline, deliver positive jaws and create -capacity for increased investment - -Create investment capacity and deliver overall positive adjusted jaws on a full year basis - -Adjusted basis, USDbn - -Mid single digit -growth, p.a. - -Low to mid single -digit growth, p.a. - -Investments of USD15-17bn (2018-2020) - - Ability to invest is a prerequisite for the Group’s long-term - -competitiveness + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS (in thousands, except per share data) +(unaudited) - Investments aligned to strategic priorities +Net Revenue: +Platform +Player - Managed through a strong approval and prioritisation -framework to deliver payback in the near to medium term +Total net revenue - Ability to respond to changes in economic environment and +Cost of Revenue: +Platform (1) +Player (1) -31.1 +Total cost of revenue -c.4 +Gross Profit: +Platform +Player -4.5-5 +Total gross profit -5.5-6 +Operating Expenses: -6-6.5 +Research and development (1) +Sales and marketing (1) +General and administrative (1) +Total operating expenses -revenue development +Loss from Operations +Other Income (Expense), Net: - No CTA2 in strategic plan; all investments to be made from +Interest expense +Change in fair value of preferred stock warrant liability +Other income, net -within the cost base of the Group +Total other income (expense), net -Revenue +Loss Before Income Taxes +Income tax expense +Net Loss attributable to common stockholders +Net Loss per share attributable to common + stockholders—basic and diluted +Weighted-average shares used in computing net income (loss) per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted -Total -operating -expenses +(1) Stock-based compensation was allocated as follows: -Investments +Cost of platform revenue +Cost of player revenue +Research and development +Sales and marketing +General and administration -Costs (ex -investments) +Total stock-based compensation -Strong cost discipline and control to create investment -capacity - - Implement strong cost discipline and control - -– Continue to benchmark our costs with the market - -– Absorb inflation through productivity gains - -– Maintain focus on improving business productivity - - Maintain positive (adjusted) jaws on an annual basis each - -year 2018-2020 - -2017 +Three Months Ended +March 31, 2018 -2019 - -2020 - -Jaws1 - -positive - -positive - -positive - -positive - -1. Adjusted, on an annual basis -2. Costs to Achieve - -24 - - Strategic priorities - -7 - -Investing in growth and technology; managed through robust -investment framework - -Investment -categories - -Description - -Investment criteria - -Examples of specific initiatives - -Share of -investment - -Near term -investments in core -business - - Investments to grow, improve -customer service and defend -competitive position of -established businesses in short -term - - Positive Return on -Investment in -financial year1 - - Investments across Global Businesses to - -grow and improve customer service -across core businesses (e.g. hiring -Wealth RMs in Hong Kong) - - Positive Return on -Investment over -2-5 years1 - - Transaction Banking platform - -transformation (e.g. build new payment -and liquidity platform) - -c.2/3 +March 31, +2017 - Investments to grow revenue -or increase returns in the -medium term (e.g., selected -business turnaround, product -enhancements) + $ - Investments in new +75,077 $ +61,499 +136,576 -opportunities +36,415 +63,678 +100,093 - Improve operational +21,666 +51,798 +73,464 -efficiency in order to lower -cost base +53,411 +9,701 +63,112 - Positive Return on -Investment broadly -in financial year1 +34,126 +20,318 +15,570 +70,014 +(6,902 ) - Deliver robust solution design +(51 ) +— +448 +397 +(6,505 ) +129 +(6,634 ) $ -with additional franchise -benefits +8,343 +52,910 +61,253 - Turnaround of existing businesses +28,072 +10,768 +38,840 -(e.g. US) +22,342 +14,055 +10,278 +46,675 +(7,835 ) - Investing in expanding our businesses +(167 ) +(735 ) +83 +(819 ) +(8,654 ) +48 +(8,702 ) -(e.g. PRD) +(0.07 ) $ - Productivity programmes +(1.79 ) -(e.g. process re-design, cloud migration, -use of robotics and machine learning -initiatives in operations) +99,488 - Core infrastructure replacement or +4,850 -modernisation (e.g. US) +19 +44 +2,296 +1,110 +960 +4,429 -c.1/3 + $ - Implement required + $ - Deliver in cost +21 +36 +888 +601 +629 +2,175 - Implement regulatory programmes + $ -regulatory programmes and -invest in cyber security + $ -effective manner -with additional -franchise benefits + $ -(e.g. IFRS 9) + $ - Strengthen capabilities to manage +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -financial crime risk +7 - Increase cyber security measures + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (in thousands, except share data) +(unaudited) + +Assets +Current Assets: +Cash +Accounts receivable, net of allowances +Inventories +Prepaid expenses and other current assets +Deferred cost of revenue +Total current assets +Property and equipment, net +Deferred cost of revenue, non-current portion +Intangible assets, net +Goodwill +Other non-current assets + +Total Assets +Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity +Current Liabilities: + +Accounts payable and accrued liabilities +Deferred revenue, current portion + +Total current liabilities +Deferred revenue, non-current portion +Other long-term liabilities +Total Liabilities +Stockholders’ Equity: + +Preferred stock, $0.0001 par value +Common stock, $0.0001 par value +Additional paid-in capital +Accumulated deficit + +Total stockholders’ equity +Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity + +As of + +March 31, +2018 -Total cumulative investment over 2018-2020 +December 31, +2017 -USD15-17bn + $ -Medium term -investment in core -business and new -opportunities + $ -Investment in -productivity -programmes and -core infrastructure + $ -Regulatory and -mandatory -investments, -including service -sustainability + $ -Leverage technology to enhance customer centricity and customer service, expand the reach of HSBC and safeguard our customers +160,750 $ +106,094 +38,062 +30,546 +1,359 +336,811 +16,835 +— +1,892 +1,382 +3,560 +360,480 $ -1. P&L basis +111,776 $ +33,948 +145,724 +13,549 +7,731 +167,004 -25 +— +10 +445,139 +(251,673 ) +193,476 +360,480 $ + +177,250 +120,553 +32,740 +11,367 +3,007 +344,917 +14,736 +5,403 +2,030 +1,382 +3,429 +371,897 + +128,757 +34,501 +163,258 +48,511 +7,849 +219,618 + +— +10 +435,607 +(283,338 ) +152,279 +371,897 - Strategic priorities +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter 8 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills - -Reducing organisational -complexity - Simplifying the -organisation - -Simplifying processes - Improving end-to-end - -processes, e.g. -- Client onboarding from 65 days - - Strengthen accountability, decision- - -to 10 (Private Banking) - -making - - Clarify roles within the organisation’s - -matrix - -- Lending: Reduce time to money -from up to 2 months to 1 day for -SME and mid market clients - -- Delivering more digital features -faster; 67 features delivered in -1H18 v. 22 in 1H17 - - Building capabilities for continuous - -improvement - -Streamlining governance - - Reducing number of + ROKU, INC. +CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS (in thousands) +(unaudited) -committees needed to manage the -business, e.g. Holdings Board -committees reduced from 7 to 5 +Cash flows from operating activities: - Improving the efficiency and -effectiveness of governance +Net loss +Adjustments to reconcile net loss to net cash provided by (used in) operating activities: - Embed throughout the organisation + $ -and for all legal entities +(6,634 ) $ -A leadership encouraging -the right behaviours - A connected leadership +(8,702 ) - +Three Months Ended -cadre committed to reinforcing our -new ways of working - - Balanced scorecards to incentivise - -the right performance and -behaviours from the leadership and -across the organisation - -Investing in training -and development - Establishing HSBC -Universities in UK, -China, Mexico, UAE, and online - - Areas of focus: -- -Leadership -- -Technical capability -- Digital & Future Skills - -Building a platform -for future talent - Established HSBC - -Digital Solutions to attract and -develop technology talent - Implementing agile ways of - -working across large parts of -technology and business teams - Access to digital training and - -resources allowing talent to shape -and develop their own career paths - - Build a diverse workforce - -26 - - Strategic priorities -Deliverables for strategic priorities by 2020; continue to provide regular -progress updates - -Strategic priorities - -Targeted outcome by 2020 - -1 - -2 - -3 - -4 - -5 - -6 - -7 - -Accelerate growth from our Asian franchise - Build on strength in Hong Kong - Invest in PRD, ASEAN, and Wealth in Asia (incl. Insurance and +March 31, +2018 - High single digit revenue growth p.a. from Asian +March 31, +2017 -franchise +Depreciation and amortization +Stock-based compensation expense +Provision for doubtful accounts +Change in fair value of preferred stock warrant liability +Noncash interest expense +Loss from exit of facilities +Changes in operating assets and liabilities: - Market share gains in 8 scale markets +Accounts receivable +Inventories +Prepaid expenses and other current assets +Deferred cost of revenue +Other noncurrent assets +Accounts payable +Accrued liabilities +Other long-term liabilities +Deferred revenue -Asset Management) +Net cash provided by (used in) operating activities -Be the leading bank to support drivers of global investment: China-led -Belt and Road Initiative and the transition to a low carbon economy +Cash flows from investing activities: - No 1 international bank for BRI - USD100bn in sustainable financing & investment1 +Purchase of property and equipment -Complete establishment of UK ring-fenced bank, grow mortgage -market share, grow commercial customer base, and improve -customer service -Gain market share and deliver growth from our international -network +Net cash used in investing activities - Market share gains +Cash flows from financing activities: +Repayments of borrowings +Proceeds from exercise of stock options, net of repurchases +Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities - Mid to high single digit revenue growth p.a. from +Net Increase (Decrease) In Cash +Cash—Beginning of period +Cash—End of period -international network +Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information: - Market share gains in Transaction Banking +Cash paid for interest -Turn around our US business +Cash paid for income taxes - US RoTE >6% +Supplemental disclosures of noncash investing and financing activities: -Improve capital efficiency; redeploy capital into higher return -businesses +Unpaid portion of property and equipment purchases -Create capacity for increasing investments in growth and -technology through efficiency gains +1,656 +4,429 +201 +— +— +129 -Enhance customer centricity and customer service -through investments in technology - Invest in digital capabilities to deliver improved customer service - Expand the reach of HSBC, including partnerships - Safeguard our customers and deliver industry-leading financial +26,986 +(5,430 ) +(11,643 ) +2,090 +(353 ) +(14,884 ) +(3,590 ) +(118 ) +(7,476 ) +(14,637 ) -crime standards +(3,407 ) +(3,407 ) - Increase in asset productivity +— +1,544 +1,544 +(16,500 ) +177,250 +160,750 $ - Positive adjusted jaws, on an annual basis, +0 $ -each financial year +180 $ - Improve customer satisfaction in 8 scale markets2 +1,247 +2,175 +161 +735 +20 +— + +18,251 +5,712 +(2,572 ) +(425 ) +(2,949 ) +(2,767 ) +(125 ) +3,797 +11,681 +26,239 + +(1,560 ) +(1,560 ) + +(15,000 ) +473 +(14,527 ) +10,152 +34,562 +44,714 + +136 -8 +29 -Simplify the organisation and invest in future skills +1,460 $ - Improved employee engagement - ESG rating: ‘Outperformer’3 +1,166 -1. Commitment by 2025; on track to deliver 2025 target (see HSBC ESG Update November 2017) -2. Top 3 or improvement by 2 ranks; measured by customer recommendation for RBWM and customer satisfaction for CMB amongst relevant competitors -3. Based on Sustainalytics + $ -27 + $ - HSBC Strategy Update -Agenda + $ -1 + $ -2 +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -3 +9 -Leading international bank with platform for growth and signature -balance sheet strength + ROKU, INC. +NON-GAAP INFORMATION (in thousands, except per share data) +(unaudited) -Next phase of strategy: Return to growth and value creation +Reconciliation of Net Loss to Adjusted EBITDA: +Net loss +Other (income) expense, net +Stock-based compensation +Depreciation and amortization +Income tax expense -Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 +Adjusted EBITDA -28 +Pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share +Numerator: - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Path to achieve >11% RoTE by 2020 +Net loss attributable to common stock holders +Add: Change in fair value of convertible preferred stock warrant liability +Net loss attributable to common stockholders used in + computing pro forma basic and diluted net loss per share -Reported RoTE walk1 +Denominator: -% +Weighted-average shares used in computing net loss per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted +Add: Pro forma adjustments +Weighted-average shares used in computing pro forma net loss per + share attributable to common stockholders—basic and diluted -8.7 +Three Months Ended -6.8 +March 31, +2018 +March 31, 2017 -Reported - -Sig items - -2017 ex- -sig items - -Interest -rate rises2 - -UK -growth - -Accelerate -growth in -Asia, BRI, -Sustainable -Finance - -Growth -from the -inter- -national -network - -US turn- -around3 - -Investments - -Other4 - -ROE -Reported -5.9% +(6,634 ) $ +(397 ) +4,429 +1,656 +129 +(817 ) $ -Interest rate rises separated from other performance improvements +(8,702 ) +819 +2,175 +1,247 +48 +(4,413 ) -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. -3. Changes in equity consolidated in ‘Other’ -4. -5. Subject to regulatory approval +(6,634 ) $ +— -Include LICs/ECL normalisation, profits and equity from rest of the Group, DTA write-off in US in 2017 and significant items +(8,702 ) +735 -Revenue growth -supported by increasing -capital and cost efficiency + $ - Investing USD15-17bn -primarily in growth and -technology + $ ->11 + $ - Delivering positive + $ -adjusted jaws +(6,634 ) $ - Increasing capital +(7,967 ) -efficiency, limited RWA -growth to 1-2% and -increasing asset -productivity +99,488 +— - Sustaining dividend, +99,488 -supported by share buy- -backs5 +4,850 +80,844 - With >14% CET1 ratio +85,694 -2020 -Reported -(target) +(0.09 ) ->10% +Pro forma net loss per share—basic and diluted -29 - - Profitable growth to deliver RoTE > 11% by 2020 -Strong capital base to support future growth and shareholder -distribution - -Group capital ratio above 14% over period of strategic plan1 - -Strong capital base to support -growth and returns to shareholders - -Local CET1 -ratio at legal -entity level2 - -12-13% - -Surplus equity3 - -c.USD5bn at 31DEC17 - -Support asset growth in -strategic priorities -Capital required to support growth -in Global Businesses - -Maintain strong balance sheet -CET1 ratio greater than 14% -Meet Basel III Reform -requirements globally - -Higher RWAs under local rules driven by -greater use of standardised approaches -and local calculation differences4 - -Includes risk diversification benefits -and other structural items - -Increasing capital requirement -under stress testing - -Deliver 11% RoTE on a higher -capital base - -Potential impact from Basel III reform -and other regulatory changes - ->14% - -Sustain dividends, continue -equity buy-backs -Share buy-backs as and when -appropriate, subject to regulatory -approval - -e -r -u -t -c -u -r -t -s -p -u -o -r -G -y -b -n -e -v -i -r -D - -s -r -o -t -c -a -f - -l -a -n -r -e -t -x -e - -m -o -r -f -s -k -s -i -R - -Higher risk weights -under local rules - -Diversification -benefit / other - -Stress testing - -Anticipated -regulatory changes - -Group -consolidated -CET1 ratio - -1. Bars in chart are illustrative and not to scale -2. This represents a weighted average of legal entity CET1 ratios on a local basis -3. Surplus equity is equity held in excess of HSBC risk appetite in major operating entities that cannot be released immediately given local restrictions. Released over time or used to support growth -4. - -Including the application of national discretions, including RWA floors, and the extent of Basel III adoption by local regulators - -30 - - HSBC Strategy Update -Conclusion - - HSBC is the leading international bank with unparalleled access to the highest - -growth markets - - After a period of restructuring, supported by normalising interest rates and - -synchronised economic growth, it is time for HSBC to get back into growth mode - -- Accelerate growth in areas of strength with higher capital efficiency, in particular + $ -in Asia and from our international network +(0.07 ) $ -- Leverage our size and strength to embrace new technologies over a period of -disruptive technological change. Investing USD15-17bn until 2020 primarily in -growth and technology while delivering positive adjusted jaws +Roku Q1 2018 Shareholder Letter -- Complete the turnaround in the US - -- Simplify the organisation and invest in capabilities for the future - - The Group will return to value creation, targeting a RoTE of >11% by 2020 while - -delivering positive adjusted jaws - - Our signature balance sheet strength supports future growth and is the foundation for - -sustained dividends - -31 - - 32 +10 diff --git a/q254/random_k4/random_3.md b/q254/random_k4/random_3.md index 967f586b4e4f280152bfd7336d1af8e49e765b34..5c5eba2e1fd980c21e8cbb1cd873801d5dedd049 100644 --- a/q254/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q254/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,2406 +1,2541 @@ -Survey of Young Americans’ Attitudes toward Politics and Public Service -47th Edition: March 14 – 21, 2024 -N=2,010 18- to- 29-Year-Olds in English and Spanish -Margin of Error: +/-3.02% at the 95% Level + CONTENTS -1. +01 +04 + 16 +36 +38 +39 +40 +41 +44 +45 -With regard to school, are you currently enrolled at any of the following? +/ About HKU Business School -High School ................................................................................ 9% -Trade/Vocational ........................................................................ 2% -2-year/JC/CC .............................................................................. 7% -4-year college/university .......................................................... 17% -Graduate school .......................................................................... 5% -Business/Professional school ..................................................... 1% -Not currently enrolled .............................................................. 60% +/ Explore Your Options -[If respondent is currently enrolled in a 4-year college or university, ask Q2] +/ Enrich Your Life -2. +/ 2026 JUPAS Admissions -In which year of college are you? (n=267) +/ 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions -First year student/Freshman ..................................................... 24% -Second year student/Sophomore .............................................. 18% -Third year student/Junior ......................................................... 24% -Fourth year student/Senior ....................................................... 28% -Fifth year student or higher ........................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +/ 2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +/ Develop Your Career + +/ Freshmen Sharing + +/ Our Global Presence + +/ Useful Websites + +About HKU Business School + +HKU Business School strives to nurture first-class business leaders and foster academic and relevant +research to serve the needs of Hong Kong, Chinese Mainland and the rest of the world in the new Asia-led +economy. As Asia’s premier international business school, we engage leading scholars from all corners of the +globe and they instil in students global knowledge with an Asian perspective. + +With the highest proportion of non-local undergraduate students across all Faculties at HKU, four of our +undergraduate programmes ranked amongst the University’s Top 10 programmes in 2025#, HKU Business +School attracts the best and brightest students from Hong Kong and beyond. + +HKU Business School is fully accredited by the European Quality Improvement Systems (EQUIS) and the +Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB). + +# Based on average JUPAS admission scores in the best 5 subjects in HKDSE + +VISION +To be a leading, +globally-impactful academic +institution of business and +economics. + +UNIQUE +PROPOSITION + +Deeply rooted in Hong Kong +Fully engaged with China +Truly international + +MISSION +STATEMENT + +To provide world-leading +business and economics +education that nurtures +dynamic and responsible +leaders. +To advance the frontiers of +knowledge through innovative +and globally-significant +research. +To create positive change in the +world by partnering with +communities. + +01 + + Dean’s Message + +I am delighted to introduce you to the HKU Business +School, a dynamic and forward-thinking academic +community where transformative opportunities and +unparalleled experiences await. + +As a part of the University of Hong Kong, which +proudly ranks 11th globally in the 2026 QS World +University Rankings, HKU Business School stands out +as a beacon of excellence in business and economics +in Asia. This year marks the 25th anniversary of our +Faculty, we continue to march forward as a leading, +impactful business school, championing +globally +research, and +leadership, pioneering +thought +educational excellence. + +of + +dynamic, + +challenging + +responsible, + +Our mission is to inspire and develop the next +generation +and +globally-minded business leaders. We offer a vibrant +and +learning environment where +students are encouraged to push their limits, think +critically, and innovate. Our team of leading scholars +from around the world, and experienced and +dedicated teachers as well as mentors bring a wealth +of knowledge, global perspectives, and personalised +guidance beyond the classroom. Our full spectrum of +top-quality degree programmes, including 11 diverse +undergraduate programmes and four dual bachelor’s +degrees +in partnership with world-renowned +universities, is designed to equip students with +cutting-edge knowledge and technical skills to +in the fast-changing global +navigate and excel +business landscape. + +In response to the transformative power of artificial +intelligence, we are proud to launch the Second Major +and Minor programmes in “Artificial Intelligence in +Business” +to our +(AIB), offered exclusively +undergraduate students. These programmes are +designed to equip future business +leaders with +practical proficiency in AI technologies, strategic +insight to drive cross-sector innovation, and a critical +understanding of the ethical and societal implications +of AI adoption. Through a rigorous curriculum that +integrates business fundamentals with cutting-edge +AI applications, students will be empowered to tackle +complex challenges and create meaningful impact in +a data-driven world. + +Greetings from +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +inspiration + +Business education today is an evolving domain that +builds upon learning from all academic disciplines and +draws +successful and +from both +unsuccessful business practices. Our undergraduate +curricula in six core academic areas equip students +with diverse knowledge across business and +economics spheres, and prepare them to be creative +leaders of tomorrow with global perspectives. + +A hallmark of our School that separates us from the +others is our truly multi-disciplinary approach. HKU +Business School’s extensive resources offer students +in +a wide range of choices, combining studies +economics and finance, accounting and finance, +accounting and data analytics, business and law, +business and data analytics, international business +and global management, as well as dual degrees in +collaboration with world-renowned universities. + +Our faculty members will engage you with their +inspiring teaching and how they bring their impactful +research into the classroom. They will open your mind +to diverse perspectives, +ignite your curiosity to +explore innovative ideas, and instil in you an appetite +for acquiring new knowledge and extraordinary +experiences throughout your academic journey and +career development. Our students are among the +brightest and most creative of their peers. Our alumni +have gone on to forge brilliant careers in all sectors of +the +international business +community, and have formed a global network that +you will be a part of for the rest of your life. + +regional and + +local, + +I hope that you will share my enthusiasm for the +programmes and my admiration for the people who +have contributed to their development. I look forward +to having you as a member of the HKU Business +School family and a future leader in the world of +business. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Derek Chan +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +Through our extensive partnerships with over 300 +institutions and corporations across more than 40 +countries, as well as our unique network of centres in +Beijing, Shenzhen, Shanghai, Vietnam, and Barcelona, +our students gain unparalleled global experiential +and enrichment opportunities. Whether through +internships, overseas exchange programmes, or +hands-on +these experiences +sharpen practical skills, broaden perspectives, and +prepare students to confidently tackle real-world +challenges. + +industry projects, + +Joining HKU Business School means becoming part of +a community that supports your growth and success. +You will collaborate with brilliant minds, engaging in +stimulating discussions, and working on impactful +projects that make a difference. The friendships, +networks, and experiences you build here will last a +to a myriad of career +lifetime, open doors +opportunities, and empower you to overcome +challenges, pursue your passions with confidence, +and contribute positively to your community and the +world at large. + +If you are ready to embark on an exciting journey of +learning, discovery, and personal development, I +invite you to explore what HKU Business School has to +look forward to welcoming you to our +offer. I +community, where future leaders are nurtured and +dreams take flight. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Hongbin Cai +Dean +Chair of Economics + +0302 Explore Your Options +A Wide Selection of Programmes + +Bachelor of Business Administration [BBA] + +The BBA programme combines strong functional training with intensive exposure +to communication skills, computer applications, and other social science and/or +science subjects. Students can choose to major in the following area(s): + +Entrepreneurship, +Design and + Innovation* + +Finance + +Human Resource +Management + +Information Systems +and Analytics + +Marketing + +BBA Curriculum Structure -3. +Components + +A -We understand that plenty of young people are not registered to vote, but we are wondering if -you are registered to vote? +B -Yes ............................................................................................ 75% -No ............................................................................................. 21% -Don’t know ................................................................................. 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -The following questions are about registration and voting… +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -[If respondent was over 18 on November 3, 2020, ask Q4 – Q6] +C -4. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -Which of the following statements best describes your voter registration status for the last -presidential election held on November 3rd, 2020? (n=1,671) +Total -I was registered ........................................................................ 74% -I thought about registering, but didn’t ........................................ 3% -I tried to register, but was unable to ........................................... 0% -I was not registered to vote on November 3, 2020 .................. 15% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -2 - -5. - -[Split Sample A] Which of the following statements best describes your voting in the last -presidential election held on November 3rd, 2020? (n=837) - -I voted at a polling place .......................................................... 32% -I voted early ................................................................................ 8% -I voted by mail / absentee ballot .............................................. 29% -I planned on voting but wasn’t able to ....................................... 2% -I did not vote in this election .................................................... 27% -I went to the polling place but wasn’t allowed to vote .............. 1% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -6. - -[Split Sample B] In November 2020, Donald Trump ran on the Republican ticket against Joe -Biden, for the Democrats. Do you remember for sure whether or not you voted in that election -for president? (n=834) - -Yes, I definitely voted .............................................................. 68% -I’m not 100% certain if I voted .................................................. 5% -I definitely did not vote ............................................................ 26% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -7. - -When it comes to voting, with which party do you consider yourself to be affiliated? - -Net: Democrat ......................................................................... 38% -Strong Democrat ...................................................................... 19% -Not a very strong Democrat ..................................................... 19% - -Net: Republican ...................................................................... 23% -Strong Republican .................................................................... 12% -Not a very strong Republican ................................................... 11% - -Net: Independent/Unaffiliated ............................................. 37% -Lean Democrat ......................................................................... 10% -Lean Republican ......................................................................... 6% -Do not lean towards either party .............................................. 22% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -8. - -When it comes to most political issues, do you think of yourself as a...? - -Liberal ...................................................................................... 32% -Moderate, lean liberal ................................................................. 9% -Moderate, no lean ..................................................................... 28% -Moderate, lean conservative ...................................................... 7% -Conservative ............................................................................. 22% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -3 - -[If respondent voted in 2020, ask Q9] - -9. - -For whom did you vote for president in 2020? (n=1,196) - -Joe Biden .................................................................................. 61% -Donald Trump .......................................................................... 28% -Someone else .............................................................................. 6% -Don’t remember ......................................................................... 1% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% - -10. - -How likely is it that you will vote in the 2024 election for President? - -Definitely will be voting .......................................................... 53% -Probably will be voting ............................................................ 13% -50-50 ........................................................................................ 13% -Probably won’t be voting ......................................................... 10% -Definitely won’t be voting ....................................................... 11% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -11. - -Do you consider yourself to be politically engaged or politically active? - -Yes ............................................................................................ 27% -No ............................................................................................. 72% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -12. - -Overall, how closely do you follow news about national politics?.. - -Net: Closely ............................................................................. 43% -Net: Not Closely ...................................................................... 56% - -Very closely ............................................................................. 10% -Somewhat closely ..................................................................... 33% -Not very closely ....................................................................... 33% -Not at all closely ....................................................................... 23% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -13. - -All in all, do you think that things in the nation are…? - -Generally headed in the right direction ...................................... 9% -Off on the wrong track ............................................................. 58% -Not sure what direction the country is headed in ..................... 32% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -4 - -14. - -Thinking about national issues for a moment, which issue concerns you most? - -Net: Economic Issues ............................................................. 27% -Economy .................................................................................. 11% -Inflation/cost of living increases ................................................ 8% -High cost of living/difficult to make ends meet ......................... 2% -Economic equality/inequality/poverty ....................................... 1% -Jobs/Employment ....................................................................... 1% -Financial stability ....................................................................... 1% -Taxes .......................................................................................... 1% -Gas prices/taxes .......................................................................... 1% -Other economy mentions ........................................................... 1% - -Illegal immigrants /Immigration ................................................ 9% - -Net: Foreign Policy/National Security .................................... 8% -War/military ............................................................................... 2% -National security ........................................................................ 2% -Israel/Palestine conflict .............................................................. 2% -Other foreign policy ................................................................... 1% -Foreign policy/affairs ................................................................. 1% - -Net: Environmental Issues ...................................................... 6% -The environment ........................................................................ 5% -Global warming .......................................................................... 1% - -Abortion/Reproductive rights ..................................................... 6% - -Gun control/Second Amendment rights ..................................... 3% -Crime/Crime rates ...................................................................... 2% -Housing ...................................................................................... 2% -Health care ................................................................................. 2% -Government/political corruption ................................................ 2% -Democracy ................................................................................. 2% -Other mentions ......................................................................... 15% -Don't know/no answer ................................................................ 8% -None ........................................................................................... 1% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -5 - -In general, do you approve or disapprove of the job performance of: - -[Randomize list. Biden anchored first] - -15. -16. -17. -18. - -Joe Biden as president -Kamala Harris as vice president -The Democrats in Congress - -The Republicans in Congress - -Approve Disapprove - -31% -32% -34% - -24% - -64% -62% -60% - -70% - -Refused -5% -6% -7% - -7% - -Now thinking specifically about Joe Biden, do you approve or disapprove of the way he is handling: - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Approve”] - -19. -20. -21. -22. -23. - -24. - -25. - -Student debt relief -The war in Ukraine -The economy - -Gun violence - -Inflation - -Israel-Hamas war - -Approve Disapprove - -39% -33% -30% - -25% - -23% - -18% - -56% -61% -65% - -69% - -72% - -76% - -Refused -5% -6% -5% - -5% - -5% - -6% - -If the election for President were held today and the candidates were: [Randomize -candidates] for whom would you vote? - -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 28% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 25% -Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., an independent candidate ................... 11% -Jill Stein, the Green party candidate .......................................... 4% -Cornel West, an independent candidate ..................................... 3% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - -26. - -If the election for President were held today and the candidates were [Rotate: Joe Biden, the -Democrat and Donald Trump, the Republican], for whom would you vote? - -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 38% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 31% -Would not vote ......................................................................... 16% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - 45% - 37% - - - 16% - 2% - -(% when “Would -not vote” not -included, n=1,682) - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Credits +54 +12 +36 6 +- -[If respondent would vote for Joe Biden or Donald Trump in Q26, ask Q27] - -27. - -How enthusiastic are you about your support of this candidate? - -Joe Biden (n=817) - -Net: Enthusiastic .................................................................... 43% -Net: Unenthusiastic ................................................................ 56% - -Very enthusiastic ...................................................................... 13% -Somewhat enthusiastic ............................................................. 30% -Not very enthusiastic ................................................................ 40% -Not at all enthusiastic ............................................................... 16% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% - -Donald Trump (n=561) - -Net: Enthusiastic .................................................................... 68% -Net: Unenthusiastic ................................................................ 32% - -Very enthusiastic ...................................................................... 29% -Somewhat enthusiastic ............................................................. 39% -Not very enthusiastic ................................................................ 22% -Not at all enthusiastic ................................................................. 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% - -28. - -Donald Trump currently faces 91 felony charges across four criminal cases for keeping -classified documents, falsifying records, and attempting to overturn the 2020 election. If he is -found guilty in any of these trials before the election -- for whom would you vote for -President? - -[Rotate Joe Biden and Donald Trump] - -Joe Biden, the Democrat .......................................................... 42% -Donald Trump, the Republican ................................................ 24% -Would not vote ......................................................................... 17% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% - - 51% - 29% - - - 18% - 2% - -(% when “Would -not vote” not -included, n=1,659) - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -7 - -Importance of Issues Facing the United States - -In order to measure the relative importance of a set of 16 current issues facing the United States, -respondents were asked a series of match-up questions that took the following form: - -Thinking about the major issues facing the United States today, please tell me which of the -following two is more important to you: - -Each respondent was shown each individual issue one time, matched up against another issue chosen -at random for a total of 8 rated matchups per respondent. On average, each of the 120 match-ups was -shown to n=134 respondents. After weighting procedures were performed, each issue was matched up -against each other issue a minimum of 121 times and a maximum of 148 times, though an analysis of -the impacts of weighting procedure showed no significant impact due to weighting procedures on the -relative strength of the match-ups. - -The 16 issues tested are listed in the table below. - -Q29-Q44 Show the aggregate results of these match-ups, with the percentage shown representing the -aggregate percentage of the time that an issue was rated as more important than the issue it was -matched up against. - -A full table of results of each individual match-up is available upon request. - -Q29-Q44 are ordered by the percentage of the time an issue was deemed “More Important.” - -Net: More -Important -64% -59% -56% - -Net: Less -Important -33% -37% -40% - -54% - -53% - -52% - -52% - -50% - -50% - -47% - -47% - -43% - -43% - -40% - -34% -26% - -42% - -44% - -43% - -44% - -47% - -46% - -50% - -50% - -53% - -54% - -56% - -61% -70% - -Much -More -Imp. -38% -33% -31% - -33% - -27% - -28% - -32% - -27% - -29% - -27% - -25% - -23% - -22% - -20% - -17% -12% - -Somewhat -More Imp. -26% -25% -25% - -Somewhat -Less Imp. -15% -18% -19% - -21% - -26% - -24% - -20% - -23% - -21% - -20% - -21% - -20% - -20% - -20% - -17% -14% - -18% - -21% - -21% - -22% - -24% - -21% - -24% - -20% - -24% - -22% - -24% - -26% -27% - -Much -Less -Imp. -18% -19% -21% - -24% - -23% - -22% - -22% - -23% - -25% +78 +24 +48 +6 -26% +108 -30% +240 -29% +*Candidates must undergo a selection process arranged by the Programme Coordinator for +declaring the EDI major. -31% +HKU – Sciences Po Dual Degree Programme -32% +Students will spend the first two years at Sciences Po in France and the third +and fourth years at HKU. Programmes at Sciences Po are taught in English (no +French requirements for being admitted) with intensive French language +classes for all non-francophone students. -35% -43% +Upon successful completion of the dual degree programme, students will be +awarded the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) degree from HKU and +a Bachelor’s degree from Sciences Po. -Don’t -Know -3% -4% -4% +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. -4% +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-sciences-po-dual- +degree-programme -4% +HKU – University of British Columbia +Dual Degree Programme -4% +Students will spend the first and final years at HKU and the second and third +years at the University of British Columbia (UBC) in Canada, and graduate with +a Bachelor of Business Administration from HKU and a Bachelor of Commerce +from UBC upon successful completion of the programme. -4% +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. -3% +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-university-of-british- +columbia-dual-degree-programme -4% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba -3% +0504 -3% + Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting and +Finance [BBA(Acc&Fin)] -4% +Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting Data +Analytics [BBA(ADA)] -4% +The BBA(Acc&Fin) programme prepares students for a professional qualification +in accounting and provides the broad-based education in accounting and finance +which is necessary to progress toward a leadership role in the financial sector. +Students are required to take professional core in accounting and a minor in +finance, with an option to second major in finance. Tailor-made professional +internship opportunities with renowned +preparation programmes and +accounting firms and financial institutions are available for talented students. It +is accredited as an approved accountancy programme by: -4% +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia -5% -4% +BBA(Acc&Fin) Curriculum Structure -29. -30. -31. +Components -32. -33. -34. +Credits -Inflation -Healthcare -Housing +A -Gun violence +B -Jobs -Protecting -Democracy +C -Corruption +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -35. -36. -Education -37. Women's +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course -reproductive -rights +Minor in Finance* +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives -Crime +D. -Immigration +Free Electives / Optional Minor -Taxes +*Students may opt to pursue a Major in Finance: -Climate change +Components -Free speech +A -Israel/Palestine -Student Debt +B -38. -39. -40. +C -41. -42. +University Graduation Requirements -43. -44. +Professional Core in Accounting - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Major in Finance +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Free Electives +Capstone Course -8 +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -45. Which of the following phrases best describes the United States today? +108 +24 +78 +6 -A healthy democracy .................................................................. 3% -A somewhat functioning democracy ........................................ 20% -A democracy in trouble ............................................................ 46% -A failed democracy .................................................................. 16% -Don't know ............................................................................... 14% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +36 +12 +24 -Do you agree or disagree with these statements? +42 -[Randomize Q46 and Q47. Rank ordered by “Agree”] +Total -46. +240 -Joe Biden has what it takes to lead in a crisis +Credits -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 26% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 61% +54 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 19% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 20% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 41% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 10% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +108 -47. +78 +30 +18 +24 +6 -Donald Trump has what it takes to lead in a crisis +Total -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 33% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 55% +240 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 16% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 17% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Don’t know ................................................................................. 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Similar to the BBA(Acc&Fin) programme, the BBA(ADA) programme prepares +students for a professional qualification in accounting. It provides students +with an option to focus on data analytics aspect in accounting instead of having +a minor in finance. It is an excellent choice for students who are interested in +STEM with accounting and business applications and wish to pursue their +career in the relevant fields. The intensive accounting training enables +BBA(ADA) students to distinguish themselves from students of the other data +analytics/STEM programmes. Students will be equipped with comprehensive +accounting and business knowledge that prepares them to obtain professional +qualifications in accounting. They will also acquire computer programming +and data analytics skills to meet the needs of the accounting and business +professions in today’s digital transformation economy. It is accredited as an +approved accountancy programme by: -48. When it comes to the U.S. economy, has recent immigration made it better, worse – or not +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia -made a significant difference? +BBA(ADA) Curriculum Structure -Net: Better-Worse ................................................................ -24% +Components -Better .......................................................................................... 9% -Worse ....................................................................................... 33% -No difference ............................................................................ 28% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +A - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +B -9 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -49. +Professional Core in Accounting Data Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -The U.S. Census Bureau predicts that white Americans will make up less than half of the U.S. -population by around 2045. Do you think this is: +C -Net: Good ................................................................................ 19% -Net: Bad ................................................................................... 18% +Free Electives -Very good for the U.S. ............................................................... 9% -Good for the U.S. ..................................................................... 10% -Neither good nor bad ................................................................ 60% -Bad for the U.S. .......................................................................... 9% -Very bad for the U.S. ................................................................. 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Total -50. +Credits -How closely have you followed news about the war between Israel and Hamas? +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -Net: Closely ............................................................................. 38% -Net: Not closely ....................................................................... 60% +156 +24 +114 +12 +6 -Very closely ............................................................................... 9% -Somewhat closely ..................................................................... 28% -Not very closely ....................................................................... 33% -Not at all ................................................................................... 26% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +30 -Which of the following groups do you sympathize with during the war between Israel and Hamas? +240 -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Sympathy”] +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-acc-and-fin -51. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ada -52. -53. +0706 -54. + Bachelor of Business Administration (Business Analytics) +[BBA(BA)] -55. +Bachelor of Business Administration (Law) and Bachelor of +Laws [BBA(Law)&LLB] -56. +The BBA(BA) programme is crafted to meet the growing industry demand for +talents in the business analytics field. Its curriculum offers students a +comprehensive coverage of both technical and managerial skill sets. Students +will learn a wide spectrum of knowledge from the disciplines of information +technology, data science, business statistics and management. Core courses +include programming language, database management, introduction to +business analytics, management information systems, decision and risk +analysis, etc. They help students build the foundations for advanced topics in +senior years. Students also have the option to choose from analytics technique +courses and business application courses. The aim is to provide students with +state-of-the-art experiences in artificial intelligence, big data, social media, +and other latest development. Such design helps train well-rounded students +who will be more adaptable in their career development. The programme is +suitable for students who have a passion for problem-solving through +analytics, and who aim to develop their career path in analytics. -The Palestinian -people -The Israeli people -The Palestinian -government -The Israeli -government -SPLIT SAMPLE: -Hamas (n=1,003) -SPLIT SAMPLE: -Hamas, the Islamist -militant group -(n=1,007) +BBA(BA) Curriculum Structure -Net: -Sympathy +Components -A lot of -sympathy +Credits -Some -sympathy +A -No -sympathy +B -Don’t have -enough +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -information Refused +Major in Business Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Analytics Techniques) +Disciplinary Electives (Business Applications) +Capstone Course -56% -52% +C -32% +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -29% +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -17% +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -34% -24% +90 -10% +Jointly offered by the HKU Business School and the Faculty of Law, the +BBA(Law)&LLB integrated double-degree programme blends two strategic +disciplines into a single programme for the bright and highly motivated. It is an +excellent choice for students seeking a broader education with parallel +concentration on legal and business studies. Graduates of the programme will be +awarded two degrees — BBA(Law) by the HKU Business School, and LLB by the +Faculty of Law. After successful completion of the LLB programme, students +may apply for admission to the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws (PCLL) +programme provided that they meet the relevant admission requirements. -7% +The programme offers business stream and accounting stream to students in +their business studies. The accounting stream is accredited by: -3% +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia -22% -28% +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Business Stream) -22% +Components -21% +Credits -14% +A -10% -12% +B -25% +C -33% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Course +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -46% +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -31% -32% +Professional Core in Law +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -39% +D. -34% +Free Electives / Optional Minor -32% +Total -4% -4% +240 -4% +Total -4% +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Accounting Stream) -4% +Components -13% +A -3% +B -10% +University Graduation Requirements -48% +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course -36% +C -4% +Professional Core in Law - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Total -10 +36 +6 +24 +6 +- -[Rotate Q57 and Q58] +78 +24 +48 +6 -57. Which of the following comes closest to your view? +156 +108 +42 +6 -The U.S. should be more of an ally to Israel. ........................... 11% -The U.S. should maintain -our current relationship with Israel. ......................................... 17% -The U.S. should be less of an ally to Israel. ............................. 14% -The U.S. should not be an ally to Israel. .................................. 15% -Don’t know. .............................................................................. 41% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +30 -58. Which of the following comes closest to your view? +300 -The U.S. should be more of an ally to Palestine. ..................... 21% -The U.S. should maintain -our current relationship with Palestine. .................................... 15% -The U.S. should be less of an ally to Palestine. ......................... 5% -The U.S. should not be an ally to Palestine. ............................. 11% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Credits -59. +36 -Do you support or oppose a permanent ceasefire in Gaza? +108 +24 +78 +6 -Net: Support ........................................................................... 51% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 10% +156 -Strongly support ....................................................................... 38% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 13% -Somewhat oppose ....................................................................... 5% -Strongly oppose .......................................................................... 5% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 36% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +300 -60. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ba -Based on what you know at this time, do you believe Israel’s response so far to the October 7 -attack by Hamas has been justified, or not? +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-law-and-llb -Yes, it is justified ...................................................................... 21% -No, it is not justified ................................................................. 32% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +0908 - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 + Bachelor of Business Administration in International Business +and Global Management [BBA(IBGM)] -11 +Bachelor of Economics [BEcon] -Do you support or oppose: +BBA(IBGM) is an intensive, premier programme in international business and +global management featuring a unique curriculum designed to evolve with and +reflect the ever-changing demands of a globalised world. Exclusive elements +such as overseas exchange studies, a leadership boot camp, an Asia-Pacific +study tour, an international field trip and global enrichment opportunities are +strategically integrated into the curriculum, whilst students are given the +flexibility to pursue an in-depth inquiry into another specialised area of study +as a second major. This cross-functional and personalised approach aims to +foster a selected group of outstanding students to become the world’s future +leaders equipped with global perspectives, cultural sensitivity, social +responsibility and key competencies to succeed in the international business +environment. -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Support”] +BBA(IBGM) Curriculum Structure -61. +Components -Sending American troops to defend a NATO ally if invaded by Russia? +A -Net: Support ........................................................................... 47% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 23% +B -Strongly support ....................................................................... 20% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 27% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 12% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 11% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 4% +C -62. +D -Building a wall on the border of the United States and Mexico? +E -Net: Support ........................................................................... 36% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 45% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -Strongly support ....................................................................... 23% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 14% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 15% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 30% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Major in International Business and Global Management +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -63. +Second Major -Sending American troops to defend Taiwan if invaded by China? . +Free Electives -Net: Support ........................................................................... 34% -Net: Oppose ............................................................................. 30% +Compulsory Overseas Exchange -Strongly support ....................................................................... 11% -Somewhat support .................................................................... 22% -Somewhat oppose ..................................................................... 16% -Strongly oppose ........................................................................ 14% -Don’t know ............................................................................... 33% -Refused ....................................................................................... 4% +Total - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Credits +54 12 +36 +6 +- -64. - -On which of the following, if any, do you regularly access for news and current events related -content? Please select all that apply. - -[Randomize responses 1-13. Rank-ordered] - -YouTube ................................................................................... 25% -Instagram .................................................................................. 25% -TikTok ...................................................................................... 23% -Local TV news ......................................................................... 22% -Facebook .................................................................................. 19% -X ............................................................................................... 16% -CNN ......................................................................................... 14% -Fox News ................................................................................. 12% -Podcasts .................................................................................... 10% -Snapchat ..................................................................................... 8% -MSNBC ...................................................................................... 7% -Barstool ...................................................................................... 2% -Truth Social ................................................................................ 1% -None of the above .................................................................... 26% - -65. - -At this moment, would you say that you are more hopeful or fearful about the future of -America? - -[Randomize responses 1-2. Rank-ordered] - -Fearful ...................................................................................... 67% -Hopeful ..................................................................................... 30% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% - -Have you participated in any of the following activities in the past 12 months? - -66. - -67. - -Attended a political rally or demonstration - -Donated money to a political campaign or cause - -Yes - -14% - -13% - -No - -82% - -84% - -Refused - -4% - -3% - - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 - -13 - -Switching gears, below is a list of individuals, organizations and institutions. How often do you trust -each of them to do the right thing? - -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: All/Most of the time”] - -Net: -All/ Most -of the time - -Net: -Some of the -time/ Never - -All of -the time - -Most -of the -time - -Some -of the -time Never Refused - -68. - -69. - -70. - -71. -72. - -The United -States military -The United -Nations -The Supreme -Court -The President -The federal -government - -73. - -The Congress - -74. -The media -75. Wall Street -76. -Billionaires - -36% - -32% - -24% -20% - -17% - -12% - -10% - -9% - -6% - -60% - -64% - -72% -76% - -79% - -83% - -86% +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 -86% +72-90 -90% +0-18* -10% +- -26% +240 -41% +*Students may use free electives to fulfil the second major where the requirements exceed 72 credits. -19% +The BEcon programme trains students in economic theories, statistical tools, +the application of theories to solve practical economic problems in trade, +banking and the labour market, and evaluation of the regional economic +performance of Chinese Mainland, Hong Kong and other economies. Students +will be furnished with solid theoretical and empirical economic knowledge to +analyse and understand human behaviour and social interactions. The +programme allows students a high degree of flexibility in planning their future +career specialisation. -4% +BEcon Curriculum Structure -4% -4% +Components -2% +A -2% +B -1% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -2% +Major in Economics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -2% +C -27% +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -44% +Total -20% +Credits -20% -16% +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -15% +78 +24 +30 +18 +6 -10% +108 -9% +240 -8% +Find out more: +http://ibgm.business.hku.hk -4% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon -47% -51% +1110 -53% + Bachelor of Economics and Finance [BEcon&Fin] -56% +BEcon&Fin is designed to meet the interests of students who are seeking a +balanced study of both economics and finance. The programme recognises +the significance of economics both in its own right and as a foundation for the +study of finance, and the significance of finance as a career path for students +who are keen on joining this profession. Students will receive solid training in +theories and applications of economics and finance. They will be equipped +with the skills to analyse human behaviour and social interaction, as well as to +solve problems in the financial sphere. -48% +BEcon&Fin Curriculum Structure -38% +Components -37% +Credits -25% -25% +A -27% +B -27% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -38% +Major in Economics and Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Economics Disciplinary Electives +Finance Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -48% +C -53% +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -4% +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -5% +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -4% -4% +90 -4% +Total -5% +240 -4% +HKU - Peking University “Future +Leaders” Dual Bachelor’s Degree in +Economics, Finance and Management +The programme combines the strengths of two leading business schools in +Hong Kong and Chinese Mainland and is designed to nurture first-class business +leaders and cultivate their global perspective with intimate understanding of +China. Students will spend the first two years at HKU and the third and fourth +years at Peking University (PKU), and be awarded a Bachelor of Economics and +Finance (BEcon&Fin) degree from HKU and a Bachelor of Management [BMgmt] +degree from PKU upon successful completion of the dual degree programme. -5% +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. -4% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/admission/degree-program +mes/hku-pku-dual-degree -Below is a list of statements about politics and public service. Do you agree or disagree with these -statements? +Bachelor of Finance in Asset Management and Private +Banking [BFin(AMPB)] +The BFin(AMPB) programme aims to prepare students to enter the rapidly +growing fields of asset management and private wealth management in Hong +Kong and Asia Pacific, or in banking and finance generally. During the first two +years, students complete introductory courses in accounting, economics, +mathematics, statistics, corporate finance, and investments and portfolio +analysis. In subsequent years, students take more specified and industry +related courses including equity valuation and investment in specific asset +classes e.g. private equity, venture capital, hedge funds and digital assets, +understanding of financial statements and doing financial analysis, lending +and credit in private wealth and corporate bank, financial regulations and +compliance, current +institutional +in finance, ESG +consulting and family office. The programme contains practical-oriented +courses taught by teachers with extensive experience in the finance industry +and offers an array of career-oriented enrichment activities and networking +opportunities with industry practitioners. -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] +investment, -77. +issues -Community service is an honorable thing to do. +in -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 75% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 6% +BFin(AMPB) Curriculum Structure -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 45% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 30% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 17% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 3% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Components -78. +Credits -Elected officials seem to be motivated by selfish reasons. +A -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 75% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 5% +B -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 40% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 36% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 18% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 2% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Major in Asset Management and Private Banking +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -14 +C -79. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -I feel like the government does not represent the America I love. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 62% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 7% +96 +24 +42 +24 +6 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 30% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 32% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 28% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 5% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +90 -80. +Total -Politics has become too partisan. +240 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 61% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 5% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon-and-fin -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 37% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 24% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 3% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bfin-ampb -81. +1312 -Politics today are no longer able to meet the challenges our country is facing. + Bachelor of Science in Marketing Analytics and Technology +[BSc(MAT)] -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 60% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 11% +Bachelor of Science in Quantitative Finance [BSc(QFin)] -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 25% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 35% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 26% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 7% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Marketing is critical to all businesses. It dictates whether a company will be +successful. Technology, Big Data, and digitization are fundamentally changing +how marketers operate. The BSc(MAT) programme equips students with +quantitative skills, technology know-how, and business marketing acumen to +pursue a career in the digital economy and modern businesses. It targets both +STEM students with an interest in business as well as business students +interested in the technology space. Students will gain a solid foundation in +cutting-edge technical areas including computer programming, data science, +and technology by excelling in courses from the Faculty of Engineering and +Faculty of Science. In addition, students will master digital business, +marketing and leadership through courses at the HKU Business School. This +interdisciplinary approach will enable students to engage in a variety of jobs +and functions such as the design and launch of new technology products, +targeting consumers, digital marketing, forecast and predicting markets, and +building a technology-focused strategy. The programme aims to nurture +future leaders in the field of technology and marketing who are able to use the +latest technology, science, and data analytics to support business and +marketing decisions in the digital world. -82. +BSc(MAT) Curriculum Structure -Despite our challenges, I would rather live in America than any other place. +Components -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 57% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% +Credits -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 31% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +A - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +B -15 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -83. +Major in Marketing Analytics and Technology +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Technology and Strategy) +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Analytics) +Capstone Course -I feel like I need more practical information about politics before I get involved. +C -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 53% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 21% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 32% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 28% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -84. +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -People like me don’t have any say about what the government does. +90 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 46% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 24% +Total -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 18% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 29% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 16% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +240 -85. +BSc(QFin) is a premium finance programme. Built on a solid foundation in +economics and finance, the programme equips students with the essential +quant skills, including mathematics, statistics, and programming, that are +required in more advanced and sophisticated analyses, such as valuation +models of structured products, risk management, simulation and data +analysis, financial engineering, and quantitative trading. -I don’t believe my vote will make a real difference. +The programme goes beyond merely equipping students with quant skills. +More importantly, it stresses on combining these skills with an understanding of +the financial markets, the macro environment, and the practical situations +where financial managers work, with a balanced mix of quant and business +courses. To nurture students’ soft skills and market acumen, the programme +provides a wide range of value-enhancing activities, such as Round Tables with +Practitioners, Alumni Drinks, Executive Mentorship Scheme, Bloomberg training +workshops, simulation trading workshops, and an international field trip to +other international financial centres such as New York, London and Zurich. -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 41% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% +BSc(QFin) Curriculum Structure -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 14% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 19% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Components -[If respondent is currently enrolled in a 4-year college or university, ask Q86] +Credits -86. +A -I feel comfortable sharing my political opinions at my college without fear of censorship or -negative repercussions. (n=267) +B -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 41% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 15% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 26% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Major in Quantitative Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +C -16 +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -87. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -Running for office is an honorable thing to do. +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 35% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 20% +90 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 26% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 42% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Total -88. +240 -I worry that posting my political views may negatively impact my employment prospects. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-mat -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 35% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 29% +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-qfin -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 13% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 22% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 33% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +1514 -89. + Enrich Your Life -Political involvement rarely has any tangible results. +initiative and +HKU Business School fosters a culture of student +implementation of ideas, both within and outside the campus, as it is +these real-world engagements that set us apart. Experiences in learning +beyond the classroom, extending into realms outside academia, enable +students to cultivate an understanding of social dynamics, cultural +diversity, and collaborative +intellect. These experiences contribute +significantly to their personal growth, interpersonal skills, and social +development, shaping them into global citizens, lifelong learners, and +future business leaders. -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 30% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 27% +Overseas Enrichment Experiences -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 40% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 19% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Business Exchange Programme / +HKUWW Undergraduate Student Exchange Programme +Even as the youngest Faculty at the University, our exchange +activities are nothing but phenomenal. Each year, over 400 +students participate in overseas exchanges at leading universities +to broaden their horizons. -90. +Business School +Exchange Partners * -The idea of working in some form of public service is appealing to me. +Canada -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 28% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 39% +McGill University +University of British Columbia +University of Toronto +Western University +Simon Fraser University -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 20% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +U.K. - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +King's College London +University of Manchester +University of Edinburgh +University of Warwick -17 +The Netherlands -91. +University of Amsterdam +Erasmus University Rotterdam -The results of my previous involvement in politics have left me disappointed. +400+ +exchange partners +across 40+ countries -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 26% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 19% +400+ +Business School +students on exchange -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 18% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 52% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Denmark -92. +Copenhagen Business School +Aarhus University -Politics is not relevant to my life. +Germany -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 46% +Frankfurt School of Finance & Management +University of Mannheim +Munich Business School -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 25% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Belgium -93. +KU Leuven -I do not see a difference between the Democratic and Republican parties. +Italy -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 21% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 56% +Bocconi University -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 14% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 23% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 34% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +France -94. +U.S. -The president should have more power to get things done, without interference from Congress -or the Courts. +Toulouse School of Economics +ESSEC Business School -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 20% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 47% +New York University +University of Southern California +University of Washington +University of Georgia -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 14% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 30% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 23% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Middle East - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Reichman University -18 +Singapore -95. +National University of Singapore +Nanyang Technological University -It really doesn’t matter to me who the President is. +* This list is non-exclusive. + +International Field Trips +To enhance students' exposure to global businesses, the School organises +overseas field trips for students visiting corporate firms and mingling with +C-suite Executives in some of the world's most prominent financial +centres, e.g. Australia, France, Japan, London, New York City, Singapore, +Spain, and Zurich. + +Visiting Programmes +Through the Yale Visiting International Students Programme, students +are sent to spend a year at Yale University, where they actively engage +themselves in a multicultural society. With the generosity of the donors, +some of our students are selected for the Junior Year Abroad Programme +and Visiting Students Programme to study as visiting students at +Pembroke College and St Peter’s College of University of Oxford +respectively with substantial scholarships. The intellectual ambience of +these top universities is truly inspirational and conducive to learning. -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 13% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 66% +Beta Gamma Sigma Regional Leadership Conference +Beta Gamma Sigma (BGS) is the international honour society that +serves business programmes accredited by the Association to Advance +Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB International). With the +establishment of the HKU BGS Chapter, the School registers students +annually for the BGS Regional Leadership Conference held in the U.S., +where they can meet and bond with many other fellow students from the +world's best business schools. The Leadership Summit is eye-opening +and challenging, which leads to a great journey of self-discovery. -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 3% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 9% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 19% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 24% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 41% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Japan + +Kyoto University + +Australia + +University of Sydney +Monash University +University of New South Wales + +1716 Student Sharing + +Chen, Hsuan-yu +Exchange at National University of Singapore (Singapore), 2024-25 + +As a third-year undergraduate student pursuing a double major in +Accounting and Finance, I consider it a tremendous privilege to have +participated in a one-semester exchange at the National University of +Singapore (NUS) through the Business Exchange Programme. This +invaluable opportunity has not only enriched my academic journey but +also broadened my global perspective through immersive cultural +experiences and meaningful cross-cultural interactions. As I move +forward in my academic and professional journey, I carry with me not +just the knowledge gained from my courses, but the invaluable life +lessons experienced from Exchange. + +Lee, Tsz To Derek +Exchange at King’s College London (United Kingdom), 2024-25 + +I am incredibly grateful to have this valuable opportunity to study +abroad at King’s College London. The programme provided me a chance +to venture outside of my comfort zone. Not only can you learn how to be +more independent, you can also boost interpersonal skills given the +many opportunities to socialise with others, which is essential for your +future career. The experience is remarkable. I think you will regret it if +you miss out on the overseas exchange programme. + +Cheung, Nga Ting Caroline +Exchange at University of New South Wales (Australia), 2024-25 + +This exchange programme has changed me in many ways. It has helped +me become more outgoing, allowing me to make new friends and +explore different cities. Living independently has been a significant part +of this journey. From exploring new cities to forming lasting friendships, +each adventure has enriched my life in ways I never expected. This +opportunity has not only broadened my horizons but also deepened my +appreciation for diversity and connection among people from different +backgrounds. Each memory I have created during this time is a treasure +that I will carry with me forever. + +Ho, Ying Tung Crystal +Exchange at Copenhagen Business School (Denmark), 2024-25 + +In the Fall semester, I participated in a business exchange programme at +Denmark’s Copenhagen Business School (CBS). This experience was +truly transformative, enriching me both academically and personally +while allowing me to forge lifelong memories and friendships. An +exchange experience abroad truly broadens your horizons and offers +insights beyond what textbooks and lectures can provide. You will gain +invaluable perspectives and undergo personal growth like never before. +I wholeheartedly encourage you to muster your courage and embark on +an exchange journey - you won’t regret it! + +Whitfield III, Gerald Bruce Trey +Exchange at New York University (United States), 2024-25 + +I found the exchange experience to be extremely enriching. A major +highlight for me was exploring the lifestyle and professional sides of the +city. Because of my initiative socially, and in groups such as church, I was +able to get well-acquainted with the local rhythms and lifestyle, and +also made many friends that I’d consider friends for a lifetime. I am +deeply appreciative of being given this rewarding experience, which +significantly shaped both my future and the person I am today. + +Ip, Wing Tung Alla +Student Representative for the BGS Regional Leadership +Conference 2025 in Highland Heights, Kentucky + +Attending the BGS Leadership Conference at Northern Kentucky +University proved transformative. I received profound insights into +leadership, communication and cultural intelligence through immersive +workshops, case competitions and networking opportunities. The event +prompted reflections on personal leadership styles and encouraged +collaboration across diverse peers. As I prepare to enter the workforce, +I intend to apply these learned principles of trust-building, cultural +sensitivity and collaborative leadership to navigate challenges so I can +shape my professional journey with purpose and authenticity. + +1918 Corporate Exposure + +HKU Business School has a strong tie with corporate partners. To nurture students' business +and market acumen, enrichment programmes are organised through the joint efforts of +corporate partnerships. + +Enrichment Programmes in collaboration with Corporate Partners +HKU Business School has been collaborating with corporate partners on initiatives to spice up +students' career exploration journey. The partnership with Accenture enables students to +gain exclusive insights into business consulting through the HKU-Accenture Business +Consulting Programme. + +To provide students with a unique opportunity to explore current business trends and +developments in the Greater Bay Area (GBA), our School has co-organised a tailored study tour +with The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA). This initiative aims to +enhance students’ readiness for future career development and personal success. Students will +have the chance to connect with seasoned accounting and business professionals in the GBA. + +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme +Leveraging the School's extensive network in the business and finance industry, we have +developed our own mentorship programme to furnish students with opportunities to +enhance their skills and knowledge essential for their future personal and career +development. Our students are empowered to connect to the real business world through +direct and active interaction with seasoned professionals, executives and entrepreneurs. + +Lee, Lok Yiu Angel +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +My mentor offered +invaluable career advice, highlighting key +considerations for entering specific fields and preparing for interviews. +Her experiences and mindset during job searches resonated with me as +I navigated something similar. She emphasised the importance of +open-mindedness and eagerness to learn in the workplace. I kept her +words at heart during my internship. I also enjoyed catching up with her +to share my new job experiences. + +Choi, Han Na Hannah +HKUBS x Deloitte China Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +As my mentor has been working in Deloitte China for more than 10 +years, I was most curious about how he maintains a work-life balance +and how he stays dedicated and professional at work. Through our +lengthy conversations over lunch, he passed on valuable insights on +developing soft skills and adopting an appropriate work attitude at an +early stage. He is more than an audit mentor but also a life coach to me. + +Chan, Chin Ching Jacky +BSc(QFin) Executive Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +Throughout the mentorship programme, I have received +precious guidance that has greatly influenced my career +path. My mentor highlighted the importance of identifying +a company that aligns with my goals and would provide +opportunities for me to develop the necessary skill sets. He +also shared practical advice on building and managing +professional and personal relationships. These lessons +have broadened my perspective and also equipped me +with the tools to handle real-world situations more +effectively and confidently. + +Wong, Wan Tat +HKUBS x ACCA Greater Bay Area Study Tour 2024-25 + +My greatest takeaway from this study tour was the power of peer +learning and collaboration. Being immersed in an environment with a +diverse group of individuals, all focused on similar goals, created an +incredible opportunity to learn from each other’s experiences and +perspectives. The collaborative projects and informal discussions were +invaluable in broadening my horizon and developing new approaches +to the accounting field in Chinese Mainland. I am leaving with a strong +network of contacts and a renewed appreciation for teamwork. + +Leung, Ho Lun Maverick +HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme 2024-25 + +I visited + +The HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme immersed me in +an authentic consulting experience through working with a real client – +their distribution centres, conducted market +HKTV. +questionnaires, and presented the final deliverables - all within the +eight-week programme. I was honoured to meet Managing Directors +from Accenture who shared crucial skills in conducting a consulting +project. It’s truly one of the best programmes for anyone considering a +consulting career! + +2120 Experiential Learning Programmes + +Experiential learning is embedded in our course curriculum. The Business Consulting +Practicum offers business and economics students hands-on experience in working with +clients to solve "real-life" problems relevant to their studies, under the guidance of faculty +members and professional mentors. The Business Case Analysis and Presentation enables +students to communicate and seek practical advice from senior executives through in-class +case presentations. The Impact Lab provides students with an excellent opportunity to work +directly with social ventures, again under the guidance of teachers and professional mentors. +Additionally, students can gain an in-depth understanding of the latest trends in economics, +finance, creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurship in the rapidly growing Greater Bay Area +by participating in the Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China Programme. + +Chaabane, Adam Andrea +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +I have learned that prominent businessmen and professionals in Hong +Kong are people like me who were once attending business school. I +most enjoyed the guest +lectures because they allowed direct +interactions with inspiring figures. The virtual experience enabled me to +follow this programme easily from my home country. I definitely +recommend it for a better understanding of Hong Kong and GBA’s +markets and opportunities that arise in cross-border business. It would +be great to learn more about opportunities for foreigners in the region. + +Kaur, Suchleen +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +The opportunity for real-time interaction and feedback with the client had +propelled me to join BCP. I was always curious about how a consultant +would address and communicate with the client. BCP has taught me +about proper business etiquette and equipped me the necessary skills to +negotiate conflicting opinions during team discussions. Throughout the +process, our mentor and professors provided great help and insights. +Their invaluable feedback and questions helped nudge us in the right +direction, taking a step back to look at the big picture and most +importantly, prioritise the client’s needs. + +Zhou, Qingzhuo +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +My greatest takeaway from the CIEC 2025 programme was the unique +window to gain a comprehensive understanding of the Greater Bay +Area’s dynamic business landscape. I explored the latest trends in +business, finance, and innovation from guest talks and virtual lectures +with industry leaders. I particularly appreciate the coverage on a +diverse range of topics and the opportunity to earn HKU credits. A +highlight was the cultural exploration segment which offered an +unparalleled perspective on the Greater Bay Area. I recommend this +programme without hesitation. + +Tsang, Tze Yeung Matthew +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +BCP has been a rewarding experience that allowed me to apply my +academic knowledge to real-world business challenges. Working +directly with my mentor and client has pushed me to think critically and +creatively in ways I hadn't experienced in the classroom. I'm confident +that the problem-solving, communication, and client-facing skills I have +developed will serve me well when pursuing my future career in +consulting or another business-oriented field. + +2322 Cheung, Ho Ning Jolie +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 (Champion) + +in UW GBCC was an + +Competing +incredibly rewarding and +unforgettable experience. We had the opportunity to work with +participants from different universities. +It was a fantastic +opportunity to exchange perspectives and learn from different +problem-solving approaches. Working under tight timeframes +pushed us to think creatively. UW GBCC has not only elevated my +professional capabilities but further solidified my belief in business +as a powerful vehicle for creating positive change in the world. + +Case Competitions + +The School provides ample opportunities to refine students' presentation and analytical skills +through a myriad of local as well as overseas competitions. From training to delicate analysis +of business cases to a variety of business scenarios, students are equipped with different +skillsets to compete with candidates from the world's leading universities. + +Lo, Nikkia +NHH International Case Competition 2024 (Champion) + +My week at NHH International Case Competition has been an +unforgettable rollercoaster of emotions. From the excitement of +exploring a new Nordic city, the exhaustion of our 24-hour case +competition, to the nervous anticipation of pitching on a global stage +with a +livestream, every moment was extraordinary. Meeting +like-minded peers around the world was an incredible experience that +forged new friendships. Thank you, HKU Business School, along with +our professors, coaches and staff for bringing this opportunity to us! -Over the last two weeks, how often have you been bothered by the following problems? +Xia, Yunchu Kevin +The McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 (First Place) -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: At Least Several Days”] +Winning first place at MBSC2025 was incredible and deeply rewarding. +My team was highly engaged. We were constantly bouncing ideas off +each other and refining our strategy. There were moments where we hit +roadblocks, but our team rallied, challenged each other constructively +and developed a cohesive solution. Connecting with like-minded +participants, judges and NGOs was also invaluable. MBSC not only +sharpened my analytical and presentation skills but also reaffirmed my +commitment to leveraging business for good. I am so grateful for the +experience and very eager to apply these lessons moving forward! -96. +2524 Liu, Yunqi Iris +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 (Outstanding Team Award) -Feeling nervous, anxious or on edge +This competition has been a fantastic learning experience. It +showed me that tax isn’t just about the technical details - it’s also +deeply connected to social trends and global events like climate +change, geopolitical conflicts and national policies. This broader +perspective has enhanced my understanding of the industry and +its importance in today’s world. I want to express my sincere +gratitude to my advisors for their guidance and recognition of my +team’s hard work. I am grateful for the opportunity to learn and +grow with such an amazing group of people. -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 54% +Pan, Ho Man Vivian +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 (Champion) -Not at all ................................................................................... 43% -Several days ............................................................................. 32% -More than half the days ............................................................ 13% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +in -97. +the HKGCC Case Competition was a -Trouble relaxing +Participating +truly +transformative experience that greatly enhanced my strategic +thinking, teamwork and problem-solving skills. The competition +challenged me to analyse intricate business problems, think critically +under pressure and develop innovative solutions. Working closely +with people of various majors allowed me to appreciate differing +opinions that were at times conflicting, find ways to build consensus +and synthesize ideas effectively. -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 50% +Students' achievements in case competitions +(2023-2025 awards) -Not at all ................................................................................... 47% -Several days ............................................................................. 32% -More than half the days ............................................................ 12% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Overseas / Chinese Mainland -98. +Asia Pacific Sustainable Marketing Case Competition 2025 -Feeling down, depressed, or hopeless +Third Place -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 44% +Bloomberg Global Trading Challenge 2023 -Not at all ................................................................................... 53% -Several days ............................................................................. 29% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +CBS Case Competition 2023 - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Asia Pacific Regional Final -19 +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Sub-Regional Final -99. +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 - North Asia Final -Little interest or pleasure in doing things +Champions' Trophy Case Competition 2024 -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 40% +Grand Prize Winner +Regional Prize Winner: Asia & Oceania -Not at all ................................................................................... 57% -Several days ............................................................................. 26% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Winner -100. +Winner -Loneliness +Winner -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 40% +Champion -Not at all ................................................................................... 57% -Several days ............................................................................. 24% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Finalist -101. +China Mainland, Hong Kong and Macao Digital Economy Innovation and +Entrepreneurship Competition 2024 -Feeling afraid as if something awful might happen +2nd Runner-up (Gold Medal) -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 38% +Deloitte Digital Camp 2024 -Not at all ................................................................................... 59% -Several days ............................................................................. 23% -More than half the days .............................................................. 9% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Deloitte Digital Camp 2023 -102. Worried about a potential mass shooting when in a public space (such as school/university, +Second Place -mall, office, theater, etc.) +Champion -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 32% +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - National Round -Not at all ................................................................................... 64% -Several days ............................................................................. 22% -More than half the days .............................................................. 7% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Outstanding Team Award -103. +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - Regional Round -Thoughts that you would be better off dead, or thoughts of hurting yourself in some way +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - National Round -Net: At least several days ....................................................... 17% +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - Regional Round -Not at all ................................................................................... 79% -Several days ............................................................................. 10% -More than half the days .............................................................. 4% -Nearly every day ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Top 3 teams - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Merit Award -20 +Top 3 teams -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2023 Case Competition -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] +2nd Runner-up -104. +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2023 -I am concerned about the moral direction of the country. +Investing in the Future University Competition 2023 +by Pictet Asset Management -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 69% -Net: Disagree ............................................................................. 9% +John Molson Undergraduate Case Competition 2025 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 35% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 34% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 5% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Lazaridis International Case Conference 2023 -105. Basic health insurance is a right for all people, and if someone has no means of paying for it, +Marshall International Case Competition 2024 -the government should provide it. +McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 64% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 14% +NHH International Case Competition 2024 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 41% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 20% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Scotiabank International Case Competition 2023 -106. Basic necessities, such as food and shelter, are a right that government should provide to those +Sydney International Business Competition 2025 -unable to afford them. +Thammasat Undergraduate Business Challenge 2024 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 61% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 15% +The Third KPMG ESG Case Study Competition -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 33% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 9% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 -107. +UW Global Business Case Competition 2023 -The government should spend more to reduce poverty. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 57% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% +2nd Runner-up -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 28% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 29% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Finalist - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +1st Runner-up -21 +Finalist -108. Government should do more to curb climate change, even at the expense of economic growth. +First Place -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 49% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 23% +Champion -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 25% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 24% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 13% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Winner -109. +Third Place -People these days put too much emphasis on racial identity. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 49% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 22% +Third Prize -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 26% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Champion -110. +Finalists -If parents had more freedom to choose where they could send their children to school, the -education system in this country would be better. +27 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 42% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 25% +26 Local -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 15% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 9% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Local -111. Our country’s goal in trade policy should be to eliminate all barriers to trade and employment +100WF Hong Kong JumpStart University Investment Hackathon 2023 -so that we have a truly global economy. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 31% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 19% +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2024 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 48% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Champion - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +ACCA Hong Kong Business Competition 2023 -22 +Outstanding Team for start-up Filix +Medtech -112. Recent immigration into this country has done more good than harm. +Team Excellence Award -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 29% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 36% +Merit Award for start-up MakeOmnia -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 12% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 33% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 17% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 19% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Alvarez & Marsal Hong Kong Business Case Competition 2024 -113. Government spending is an effective way to increase economic growth. +Champion & Best Presenter -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 28% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 25% +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2023 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 21% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 44% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 10% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Best Performer of Roma Risk Advisory +Limited -114. Qualified minorities should be given special preferences in hiring and education. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 38% +Merit -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 7% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 17% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 35% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Champion -115. Religious values should play a more important role in government. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 51% +Merit & Finalist -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 12% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 12% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 23% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 40% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Semi-finalist - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Champion -23 +2nd Runner-up -116. +Best Presenter -Same sex relationships are morally wrong. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 51% +HKU-Airstar Bank Joint University Case Competition 2024 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 17% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 7% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 7% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 45% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +HKU-SaSa Joint University Case Competition 2023 -117. +Hong Kong MBS Digital Economy Business Simulation Competition 2025 -In today’s world, it is sometimes necessary to attack potentially hostile countries or groups, -rather than waiting until we are attacked to respond. +Third Place -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 20% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 39% +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2024 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 5% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 40% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 21% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 18% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +HSBC Life Insurance Competition 2025 -Please indicate whether or not the following apply to you: +HSBC Life Insurance Innovation Competition 2023 -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Yes”] +1st Runner-up -118. +Top 3 Winner -119. +1st Runner-up -120. +Best Use of Technology Award -121. +International MBS Business Management Simulation Competition 2023 -I have or have had immigrant -classmates -I have personal friends who are -immigrants -I have co-workers who are immigrants +Champion -I have neighbors who are immigrants +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2025 -Yes +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2024 -60% +MBS Simulated Business Management Competition 2024 -46% -41% +New Century Elite Development Programme 2023 -40% +Venture Capital On Campus (VCOC) - Investment Challenge 2023 -No +1st Runner-up -Don’t -know +Champion -Refused +Third Place -19% +First place -19% +Best presenter -37% -34% +Third Place -31% +Champion -15% -23% +1st Runner-up -28% +2nd Runner-up -2% +Winner Team -2% -2% +29 -2% +AmplifyME APAC M&A APAC Challenge 2025 - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Third Place -24 +BOCHK Challenge 2023 -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? +Bronze Award for Innovative Design -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2025 (Regional Final) -122. Border officials have a responsibility to protect the safety of migrants. +1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 55% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 (Semi-final Round) -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 27% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 27% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Deloitte USHINE Case Competition 2024 -123. +ESG Challenge 2023 -The US is experiencing an immigration crisis at the Southern border. +EY Young Tax Professional of the Year 2023 - Hong Kong Region -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 53% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 16% +Champion -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 30% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 23% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 29% -Somewhat disagree ..................................................................... 8% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 8% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Finalist -124. +Champion -Immigrants improve the culture of the United States. +Champion -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 50% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 17% +1st Runner-up -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 24% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 25% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 31% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 10% -Strongly disagree ........................................................................ 7% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +2nd Runner-up -125. +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2025 Case Competition -Immigrants are taking jobs that should go to Americans instead. +Champion -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 48% +HKCGI Corporate Governance Paper Competition and +Presentation Awards 2024 -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 11% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 13% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 25% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 20% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2023/24 - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 -25 +28 -126. +HKGCC Pitch Perfect Programme 2024 -Immigrants increase crime in my community. +HKICPA Business Case Competition 2023 -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 21% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 45% +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2025 -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 9% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 12% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 32% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 27% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +1st Runner-up -127. +1st Runner-up (Paper Writing Competition) -I would be uncomfortable if an immigrant moved next door to me. +1st Runner-up (Paper Presentation +Competition) -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 12% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 62% +Audience’s Favourite Team Award -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 6% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 18% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Chevalier - Champion -How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? +Chinachem Group - Champion -[Randomize list. Rank-ordered by “Net: Agree”] +Swire Pacific - Champion -128. +Chevalier - 1st Runner-up -I am comfortable using someone’s preferred gender pronouns regardless of their biological -sex. +Chinachem - 1st Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 47% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 29% +HKGCC - Champion -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 31% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 16% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 21% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 11% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 18% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Jardine Matheson - Champion -129. My generation is too soft. +SOCAM - Champion -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 43% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 33% +Jardine Matheson - 1st Runner-up -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 21% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 22% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 22% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 21% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +MTR - 2nd Runner-up - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Overall Champion -26 +Winner -130. Men are too soft these days. +2nd Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 32% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 41% +Champion -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 14% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 19% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +1st Runner-up -131. Women are too promiscuous these days. +2nd Runner-up -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 24% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 45% +Merit -Strongly agree .......................................................................... 10% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 12% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 33% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% + Chhawchharia, Mihika Amit +HSBC - Summer Analyst program -132. Men’s 'locker room talk' is unfairly scrutinized these days. +internship, -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 22% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 38% +I collaborated closely with various +Throughout my +departments of the bank and +interacted regularly with senior +management, gaining comprehensive exposure to the bank’s operations. +This experience allowed me to hone my professional skills, including +communication, leadership, financial analysis, and market expertise. I +was honored to be ranked as the top intern in my cohort and secured a +return offer to join HSBC as a full-time graduate analyst in their Global +Banking division. I am deeply grateful for the knowledge and support I +received at HKU, which enabled me to thrive in a prestigious global +institution alongside some of the brightest talents in the industry. -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 8% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 15% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 37% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 14% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 24% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Internship Experience -133. Women’s emotions make it more challenging to lead effectively. +Lee, Chung Hong Calvin +HSBC - Global Risk Management Intern -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 16% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 57% +Reflecting on my time at HSBC, I realise that I have grown on a +professional and personal level. I have developed a deeper passion for +the banking industry and a greater appreciation for the critical role that +risk management and compliance play. I wore many hats and gained +precious insights into the banking industry. I was responsible for +overseeing compliance risks across 32 markets in Asia Pacific. I am +confident that the lessons I have learned at HSBC will guide me every +step of the way. -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 6% -Somewhat agree ....................................................................... 10% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 24% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 13% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Hui, Matthew +HSBC - International Banking (ISB) Intern - Corporate Coverage - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +The comprehensive exposure to Corporate Banking was invaluable. From +analysing credit risk for lending applications to understanding diverse +product offerings for MNC clients, each day brought new learning +opportunities. I'm truly grateful for the experience of shadowing and +supporting different RMs in the team. Together with the sharing and +introductions from product partners, I learned how to identify clients' +needs and gained perspective on effectively reaching out and pitching to +clients. This experience taught me how to view banking relationships +through a strategic lens - understanding not just immediate needs but +trends. The +also anticipating +professional mindset, strategic thinking, and collaborative spirit fostered +during this internship will undoubtedly shape my future career path. -27 +future requirements and market -134. Women should prioritize having children over joining the workforce. +Nagar, Tanvi +HSBC - International Banking Intern -Net: Agree ............................................................................... 12% -Net: Disagree ........................................................................... 59% +immense + +My internship experience was nothing short of incredible. Not only did I +grow immensely in my technical and professional skills but also +underwent an +journey of personal growth. I received +unparalleled support from the team and my mentors and gained an +in-depth insight into the field of banking and finance in Hong Kong. I +formed meaningful connections and grew my network. This experience +has truly shaped me and continues to propel my drive to pursue a career +in Banking in the years to come. + +3130 Sharma, Seerat +KPMG - Financial Services Audit Intern +(COOP3000 Cooperative Education Programme) + +I had the privilege of contributing to audit engagements for leading +clients in the banking and insurance sectors, where I conducted +substantive testing, supported risk assessments and navigated audit +methodologies using advanced tools. This role sharpened my analytical +mindset, strengthened my collaboration skills and offered a front-row +view into the dynamic world of financial auditing. It’s been a truly +rewarding journey that has solidified my passion for a career in +professional services. + +Xu, Aijing +CMB International Capital Corporation - Wealth Management Intern + +During my internship, I actively engaged with the product team in +market analysis and client pitching focused on mutual funds. I gained +valuable insights into various asset classes and macroeconomic +trends. Analyzing mutual fund performances and participating in +client meetings allowed me to contribute to investment portfolio +strategies. Collaborating with +team enhanced my +communication skills and understanding of client needs. Overall, this +experience deepened my knowledge of wealth management and +strengthened my passion for finance. + +the sales + +Shi, Yu Cheung Karson +Bank of China - Credit Summer Intern (Risk Management) + +During the internship, the financial techniques and business knowledge +I learned from HKU Business School courses helped a lot in company +financial analysis. By applying knowledge taught in the financial +accounting module, I assisted in evaluating loan demand. Through +cross-departmental collaborations, I also realised how classroom +simulations mirrored real-world risk mitigation challenges. This +experience reinforced the value of integrating academic theories with +dynamic market practices. + +Hu, Wen Qing +PwC Assurance Practice Intern + +As an assurance intern in PwC, I assisted my seniors with sampling +financial statement line items, reconciling balances, and documented +relevant non-financial information. It showed me how demanding the +auditing industry was, and allowed me to set my expectations for a +career in auditing as an accounting student. + +Wirawen, Karen +HKU – Neuberger Berman Private Equity Internship Programme + +You never truly understand private equity until you’re immersed in it +and my internship at Neuberger Berman was deeply enriching. Coming +in with limited knowledge, I gained direct exposure by working on +various deals across sectors and geographies, including Japan, Korea +and Southeast Asia. From drafting memos for the +investment +committee to attending annual general meetings and taking notes on +calls, I progressed from simple tasks to meaningful responsibilities. The +seniors were welcoming, always open to teaching, providing feedback +and offering valuable career advice. + +Chung, Marcus Lok Sum +Morgan Stanley Industrial Placement Intern + +During my internship with Sales & Trading (Institutional Equity +Division), I had the amazing opportunity to rotate across trading +and structuring desks where I was exposed to the fast-paced +environment especially during periods of high market volatility. To +see how traders manage positions and mitigate risks first-hand +was incredibly insightful. I also contributed to constructing trading +strategies and seeing the tangible impact of our work was deeply +rewarding. Morgan Stanley definitely provided me with a broader +perspective and understanding of market dynamics, liquidity, +client interactions and cross-asset opportunities. + +3332 Our Student Scholars + +Chan, Kwan Yin Cheryl +Recipient of Louisa Cheang Inspiration Scholarship 2024-25 + +I would like to express my gratitude for the Louisa Cheang Inspiration +Scholarship, which has significantly contributed to my personal and +professional growth. In the past academic year, this scholarship enabled +in the full-time Registered Visiting Student +me to participate +Programme at St Catherine’s College, University of Oxford. This +immersive experience enhanced my legal studies through engaging +discussions with scholars and participation in mooting competitions, +sharpening my research and advocacy skills. Additionally, I plan to +utilise this scholarship to pursue overseas postgraduate studies, +allowing me to deepen my understanding of the complexities of law in +a global context. + +Hussain, Iman +Recipient of FBE Student Contribution and +Innovation Award 2024-25 / +HKU Business School Future Leader Scholarship 2024-25 + +As someone who believes in learning through real-world experience, +the FBE Student Contribution and Innovation Award and the HKU +Business School Future Leader Scholarship have been life-changing. +They not only enabled me to go on an exchange semester to Cardiff, +where I explored new cultures and perspectives but also shaped my +entrepreneurial journey. + +With this support, I’ve been able to work on building a social +enterprise that aligns with my passion for creating meaningful impact. +I’m incredibly thankful for these opportunities to grow and make a +difference. + +Chow, Yee Shun Eason +Recipient of the Jardine HKU Scholarship 2024-25 + +It is an incredible honour to have received the Jardine HKU Scholarship +which is enriching my university journey! This scholarship allowed me to +pursue my many goals – from attending international training camps as +a handball player to participating in overseas exchanges without +financial worries. I have had the privilege of undertaking a summer +internship at the Jardine Group, learning from seasoned professionals in +my future industry. The Jardine Foundation also hosted exciting +networking activities and site visits which helped me build lasting +connections with fellow scholars in a vibrant community. + +Shih, Pui Hei Iris +Recipient of the Hong Kong Jockey Club Scholarships - +Undergraduate Scholarship 2024-25 + +This scholarship has been transformative to my university life as it has +allowed me to fully embrace and explore the world beyond the +classroom. It provided the financial stability I needed to focus on my +studies and presented opportunities for me to participate in diverse +extracurricular activities. These experiences broadened my perspective +and opened me to different points of view. -Strongly agree ............................................................................ 5% -Somewhat agree ......................................................................... 7% -Neither agree nor disagree ....................................................... 27% -Somewhat disagree ................................................................... 15% -Strongly disagree ...................................................................... 44% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Nurgali, Adilzhan +Recipient of BOC Hong Kong - +One Belt One Road Scholarship 2024-25 -135. How would you rate your personal financial situation these days? +It means a lot to me to be awarded the BOC Hong Kong - One Belt One +Road Scholarship. It was not +just about financial support but +recognition of the hard work I have put in. As an international student +soon heading for exchange, this award gives me the freedom to explore +new cultures and experiences without extra stress. I am truly grateful to +be part of such an inclusive and supportive community. -Net: Good ................................................................................ 70% -Net: Bad ................................................................................... 27% +3534 2026 JUPAS Admissions -Very good ................................................................................. 13% -Fairly good ............................................................................... 58% -Fairly bad ................................................................................. 22% -Very bad ..................................................................................... 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Admissions criteria (HKDSE) -136. +Local candidates applying on the strength of the Hong Kong Diploma of +Secondary Education (HKDSE) are required to fulfil the minimum entrance +requirements for HKU Business School programmes as shown below: -In general, when I am my parent's age, I believe that I will be… +Level 4 +Level 4 -Better off financially than they are now ................................... 31% -About the same as they are now ............................................... 28% -Worse off financially than they are now .................................. 23% -Not sure .................................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +EngEng ≥ +Level 4 or above in English Language +ChinChin ≥ +Level 3 or above in Chinese Language1 +MathMath ≥ +Level 3 or above in Mathematics -137. What type of high school did you most recently attend? +Level 3 +Level 3 -Public ........................................................................................ 74% -Private ........................................................................................ 9% -Parochial ..................................................................................... 1% -Charter ........................................................................................ 4% -Home school ............................................................................... 6% -Other ........................................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Level 3 +Level 3 -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q138] +AA -138. Based on the current state of the economy, how easy or difficult do you think it will be for +CSDCSD = +Grade “Attained (A)” in +Citizenship and Social Development2 -students in your class to find a permanent job upon graduation? (n=267) +2x -Net: Easy ................................................................................. 38% -Net: Difficult ........................................................................... 58% +Elective +Elective +Subjects +Subjects -Very easy .................................................................................. 10% -Somewhat easy ......................................................................... 38% -Somewhat difficult ................................................................... 44% -Very difficult .............................................................................. 5% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +≥ - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Level 3 +Level 3 -28 +Level 3 or above in two Elective Subjects -139. Which one of these best describes your religious preference? +For BBA(BA), BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) +In addition to the minimum entrance requirements above, candidates applying for the BBA(BA), +BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) programmes shall also obtain the following results in the +HKDSE examination: -Catholic .................................................................................... 19% -Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian ..................................... 15% -Jewish ......................................................................................... 2% -LDS/Mormon ............................................................................. 2% -Muslim ....................................................................................... 1% -Protestant .................................................................................... 8% -Another religion ......................................................................... 8% -No religious preference ............................................................ 33% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 4% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 6% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) +≥ +Level 3 or above in one of the following subjects: -[If Catholic, Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian, LDS/Mormon, Protestant, Jewish, Muslim, -another religion, or not sure, ask Q140] +Level 3 -140. How important is religion in your own life? (n=1,106) +Biology -Very important ......................................................................... 41% -Somewhat important ................................................................ 29% -Not very important ................................................................... 26% -Not sure ...................................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% +BAFS -[If Catholic, Fundamentalist/Evangelical Christian, LDS/Mormon, Protestant, another religion, -or not sure, ask Q141] +Chemistry -141. Do you consider yourself a born-again Christian? (n=1,038) +Economics -Yes ............................................................................................ 30% -No ............................................................................................. 50% -Not sure .................................................................................... 15% -Decline to answer ....................................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +ICT -142. Which of the following do you consider yourself to be? +Physics -Heterosexual or straight ........................................................... 73% -Gay ............................................................................................. 3% -Lesbian ....................................................................................... 2% -Bisexual ...................................................................................... 9% -Other Queer identity (e.g. pansexual, asexual etc.) .................... 5% -None of the above ...................................................................... 1% -I don’t know ............................................................................... 2% -Prefer not to say ......................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +BBA(BA) -143. Do you consider yourself to be transgender or non-binary? +BSc(MAT) -Yes .............................................................................................. 4% -No ............................................................................................. 92% -Prefer not to say ......................................................................... 3% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Level 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics is also preferred by BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) but not +strictly required. - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +BBA(Law)&LLB / BBA(IBGM) / BSc(QFin) -29 +BBA(Law)&LLB -[If transgender or non-binary, ask Q144] +BBA(IBGM) -144. Are you: (n=79) +BSc(QFin) -Transgender, male to female ...................................................... 6% -Transgender, female to male .................................................... 13% -Gender non-binary ................................................................... 57% -No, not transgender or non-binary ............................................. 9% -Prefer not to say ....................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 0% +EngEng ≥ -145. Are you: +Level 5 +Level 5 -An immigrant ............................................................................. 6% -The child of an immigrant ........................................................ 16% -None of the above .................................................................... 77% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +Chin, Math +Chin, Math ≥ -146. +Level 4 +Level 4 -Switching topics, which of these best describes your phone service at this time? Please select -all that apply. +EngEng ≥ -Cell phone ................................................................................ 93% -Landline phone service .............................................................. 7% -VOIP phone service ................................................................... 2% -None of these .............................................................................. 4% +Level 5 +Level 5 -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q147 & Q148] ++ -147. ++ -Is your college/university…? (n=267) +M1/M2 +M1/M2 ≥ -Public ........................................................................................ 69% -Private ...................................................................................... 30% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Level 3 +Level 3 -148. +MathMath ≥ -Is the college/university that you currently attend…? (n=267) +Level 4 +Level 4 -In an urban or city area ............................................................. 50% -In a suburban area next to a city ............................................... 27% -In a small town or rural area .................................................... 20% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +Application -149. Which of the following best describes the area in which you live (if in college, when not in +For details of the 2026 JUPAS exercise, please visit www.jupas.edu.hk. -school)? +Programme Scoring Formula -Suburban .................................................................................. 43% -Urban ........................................................................................ 24% -Rural ......................................................................................... 15% -Small town ............................................................................... 15% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +For more information on the Programme Scoring Formula and Subject Weightings, please +visit the Admissions Office’s website at https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas. - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Note 1: Non-Chinese-speaking applicants will be considered on a case-by-case basis.Note 2: The result(s) of Liberal Studies at Level 2 or above achieved in previous sitting(s) will also be considered.Level 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inChinese Language1 & MathematicsLevel 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inMathematicsLevel 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics3736 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions -30 +Selection process and entrance requirements -[If enrolled in a 4-year college/university, ask Q150 – Q153] +Eligibility +(1) Local students applying for admission on international qualifications other than the -150. Which college/university do you attend? (n=267) +HKDSE examination; -Available upon request +(2) Non-local students with international qualifications other than Chinese Mainland's -151. How many undergraduate students are enrolled in your college/university? Your best estimate +National Joint College Entrance Examination (NJCEE/Gao Kao). -is fine. (n=267) +Application Procedures +All non-JUPAS applications should be submitted via the online application system by noon of +November 26, 2025 (Hong Kong Time) for the first-round evaluation. Scanned copies of the +following documents should also be uploaded by the application deadline. -Less than 1,000 ........................................................................... 2% -1,000 - 4,999 ............................................................................ 26% -5,000 – 9,999 ............................................................................ 22% -10,000 – 19,999 ........................................................................ 18% -20,000 or more ......................................................................... 28% -Refused ....................................................................................... 3% +(1) Official prediction of grades or scores from your current high school (if available); -152. Where do you live while attending college? (n=267) +(2) All internal and public examination results during your senior secondary education; and -In an on-campus dormitory ...................................................... 33% -At home, with my parents ........................................................ 32% -In an apartment/house that is not campus-owned -(not with parents) ..................................................................... 25% -In a campus-owned apartment ................................................... 3% -Somewhere else .......................................................................... 3% -In fraternity/sorority housing ..................................................... 2% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +(3) Academic reference letter (optional) -153. Are you a …? (n=267) +Late submission of supporting documents will delay the consideration of application. -Full-time student ...................................................................... 88% -Part-time student ...................................................................... 11% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Shortlisted applicants for BSc(QFin) will be interviewed; optional interviews for other +programmes will be arranged if necessary. -154. Which of the following best describes your current employment status? (n=1,008) +University and Programme Entrance Requirements +Due to the complex combination of education background of applicants, each application will +be assessed individually on its own merits. Non-JUPAS applicants are advised to refer to the +standards and requirements on the website of the Admissions Office of the University before +making an application: -Employed full time ................................................................... 42% -Student ...................................................................................... 21% -Employed part time .................................................................. 18% -Not employed ........................................................................... 10% -Self-employed ............................................................................ 3% -Not employed / Homemaker ...................................................... 4% -Refused ....................................................................................... 2% +(1) Admissions standards (International Qualifications or National Qualifications); -[If employed full time or part time, ask Q155] +(2) Programme specific subject requirements; and -155. Are you currently employed in the gig economy -- where people earn income providing on- +(3) English language requirement -demand work, services or goods? (n=633) +In particular, please note that the expected lower boundary for admissions listed on the +website is provided for reference purposes only. Admissions is competitive in nature and +achieving the expected lower boundary does not guarantee admission to the programme. +The actual admission grade or score will be dependent on the overall quality of applications +received in the 2026 admissions exercise. -Yes ............................................................................................ 12% -No ............................................................................................. 87% -Refused ....................................................................................... 1% +Announcement of Result +Offer results will be released from December 2025 onwards. All application status will be +updated in the online application system once an admissions decision has been made. +Applicants should check their application status online regularly. - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +More Details +For further information about the application procedures and admissions +standards, +at +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications. -31 +the Admissions Office’s website -156. Age +please -18-24 ........................................................................................ 58% -25-29 ........................................................................................ 42% +visit -157. Race / Ethnicity +2026 Dual Degree Admissions -White, Non-Hispanic ................................................................ 52% -Hispanic .................................................................................... 24% -Black, Non-Hispanic ................................................................ 14% -Other, Non-Hispanic .................................................................. 7% -2+ Races, Non-Hispanic ............................................................. 3% +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programmes, in addition to the +application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS Admissions Scheme. -158. +For details of the dual degrees and the application procedures, please visit +the Admissions Office’s website at +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university-collaborative-programmes. -Please choose one or more race(s) that you consider yourself to be: +3938 Develop Your Career -White ........................................................................................ 70% -Black or African American ...................................................... 15% -Asian .......................................................................................... 7% -Some other race .......................................................................... 6% -American Indian or Alaska Native ............................................. *% +Freshmen Sharing -159. Gender +Upon graduation, over 82% of our students begin their careers in the commerce and industry sector. Others either +move on to further studies or explore opportunities with the civil service, education institutions and +community/social services. -Male .......................................................................................... 50% -Female ...................................................................................... 50% -Non-binary ................................................................................. 0% +Career Prospects -160. Marital Status +Companies/organisations that have offered full-time positions to our graduates include but not limited to the +following: -Never married ........................................................................... 84% -Now married ............................................................................. 14% -Divorced ..................................................................................... 1% -Separated .................................................................................... 1% -Widowed .................................................................................... 0% +Accenture Company Limited +Bank of China (Hong Kong) Limited +BDO International Limited +Bloomberg L.P. +Citibank (Hong Kong) Limited +Crédit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank +Credit Suisse Group AG +Deloitte Advisory (Hong Kong) Limited +Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited +Deutsche Bank +Ernst & Young +Goldman Sachs (Asia) LLC +Hang Seng Bank Limited +HKSAR Government +Hong Kong Monetary Authority +JPMorgan Chase & Co. +KPMG +Morgan Stanley +PricewaterhouseCoopers Limited +Standard Chartered Bank (Hong Kong) Limited +The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation +Limited (HSBC) +UBS Group AG + +Full employment +for the 19th + +consecutive year + +98.7% + +was the average salary of +our 2024 graduates + +$36,770 + +of our 2024 graduates have +received at least 2 job offers +upon graduation + +57% + +Kantbek, Yerassyl +BBA + +I chose HKU Business School because Hong Kong is +one of the world’s most competitive financial centres, +offering a dynamic environment to grow. HKU +combines +real-world +rigorous academics with +experiences, such as Asia-focused case studies and +competitions like HICS, which I plan to join in Year 2. I +am particularly drawn to programs in marketing and +finance, as well as opportunities for entrepreneurship +through the Techno-Entrepreneurship Core and +iDendron incubator. With a diverse student body and +global exchange options, I look forward to learning +from peers, connecting with mentors, and developing +skills to make a meaningful impact in business. + +The main reason I chose HKU, particularly HKU +Business School, lies in its global connections and +strong partnerships with other institutions and +respected organizations, which I believe will be +advantageous for future employment opportunities. +I expect to embrace challenges over the course of my +four years at the university, as these will be vital for +my intellectual and social maturity. The first time I +visited the campus, I was amazed by the diversity of +the students and +facilities, which +demonstrated that the university is truly a place for +everyone. One of the many great opportunities +offered here is the chance to travel for studies, which +I would rank among my highest interests. + +the open + +Pernice, Audrey Yiwen +BEcon&Fin + +4140 The main reason I chose BBA(IBGM) is its flexibility in allowing +students to choose a second major, as well as the numerous +overseas exchange opportunities. I am also fortunate to have +been admitted as a member of the HKU International Case +Society (HICS), where I get to know people from other programs +who are also interested in the realm of business. HKU Business +School provides me with the perfect platform to strike a balance +between my work and life. + +Ho, Lik Hang Gordon +BBA(IBGM) + +Lo, Hoi Tung Reacker +BSc(MAT) + +I chose HKU Business School for its professional background and +diverse opportunities. The multidisciplinary programme allows me to +pursue Marketing Analytics and Technology, aligning with my varied +interests in business and STEM. As a freshman, I am eager to embrace +exciting experiences such as internships and exchanges. I look +forward to gaining insights from fellow students and professionals +through upcoming career events. With the strong support from HKU, +I am committed to developing my entrepreneurial skills and pursuing +my dreams without regrets! + +Drawn by HKU’s global prestige and the excellence of HKU Business +School, I chose to pursue Quantitative Finance at HKU to deepen my +passion for quantitative trading and data-driven decision-making. +The school’s flexible curriculum empowers me to explore +complementary fields such as computer science, statistics, and risk +management. As a target school for top investment banks, HKU +also offers unparalleled career exposure. HKU provides the ideal +environment to grow academically and professionally, and I am +excited to explore the many opportunities ahead. + +Tsang, Chun Shing Patrick +BSc(QFin) + +Fung, Yat Hang Rex +BFin(AMPB) + +My aspiration for BFin(AMPB) was ignited early in high school by its +unparalleled, practitioner-focused design, a curriculum that truly +bridges finance theory with industry practice. This conviction was +solidified through the heartfelt guidance of our Programme +Director, Professor Anna Wong, who mentored me even before I +officially joined HKU, while I was an apprentice at a US bank. + +Now, experiencing BFin(AMPB) firsthand, the transition from the +professional world to the classroom feels seamless. It is this +powerful integration of theory and real-world practice that makes +AMPB incomparable. HKUBS has instantly instilled in me a sense of +ownership, this is not just a school, but a launchpad for impact, and +I am thrilled to begin the next chapter of my growth here. + +I was drawn to BBA(IBGM) because of HKU’s +world-renowned academic reputation and its vibrant, +international community. I believe a truly “global +business” education extends beyond the classroom, +through experiential learning opportunities, daily +interactions with local and non-local peers, and +participation in hall and student society cultures, I will +gain a more dynamic and holistic multidisciplinary +perspective on the business world. Over the coming +four years, I am eager to harness these opportunities +to become a well-rounded leader and effective +problem-solver for my future career on the global +business stage. + +Yan, Sung Hei Christopher +BBA(IBGM) + +4342 Our Global Presence + +Israel - +Tel Aviv + +Beijing + +Shenzhen + +Hong Kong + +Vietnam - +Ho Chi Minh City + +Useful Websites +The University of Hong Kong (HKU) + +Undergraduate Admissions +https://admissions.hku.hk/ -161. Region 4 (Based on state of residence) +HKU – Entrance Requirements -Northeast .................................................................................. 17% -Midwest .................................................................................... 20% -South ........................................................................................ 38% -West .......................................................................................... 25% +For JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas -162. Region 9 (Based on state of residence) +For non-JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications -New England .............................................................................. 4% -Mid-Atlantic ............................................................................. 13% -East-North Central ................................................................... 14% -West-North Central .................................................................... 6% -South Atlantic ........................................................................... 19% -East-South Central ..................................................................... 5% -West-South Central .................................................................. 14% -Mountain .................................................................................... 8% -Pacific ....................................................................................... 17% +HKU Business School - Harvard IOP Youth Survey – Spring 2024 +Overview of Undergraduate Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme -32 +Enrichment Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/student-enrichment -163. MSA Status +Other HKU Websites -Non-Metro ................................................................................ 12% -Metro ........................................................................................ 88% +Mainland Affairs Office (MAO) +https://mainlandaffairs.hku.hk/ -Methodology +Centre of Development and Resources for +Students (CEDARS) +https://www.cedars.hku.hk/ -This poll of 2,010 18-to-29-year-olds was organized with undergraduate students from the Harvard -Public Opinion Project (HPOP) and supervised by John Della Volpe, Director of Polling. Data were -collected by Ipsos Public Affairs using the KnowledgePanel. KnowledgePanel provides probability- -based samples with an “organic” representation of the study population for measurement of public -opinions, attitudes, and behaviors. Interviews were conducted in English and Spanish between March -14 and 21, 2024. The target population for this survey is US residents between the ages of 18 and 29. -Data are weighted to reflect population estimates based on age, race/Hispanic ethnicity, education, -household income, census region by metropolitan area, and primary language within Hispanics. The -margin of error for the total sample is +/- 3.02%. +44 -### +45 diff --git a/q254/random_k4/random_4.md b/q254/random_k4/random_4.md index 4bcaaffd0140b439e3111b15be90b5099749743d..98e99929444dd05f1d969fcf000f7a5ca106dd0c 100644 --- a/q254/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q254/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,3187 +1,2015 @@ -School Meals Programs and Other USDA -Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated August 24, 2018 - -Congressional Research Service - -https://crsreports.congress.gov - -R43783 - -{222A0E69-13A2-4985-84AE-73CC3DFF4D02}-R-008032105221177189069140163240174026137243109106239050005249089181035110184065171150222238050143170044130075151022235203179242176047216087082047088140020229001139009183064080176154202161058046029022041045101112067071229147068138195245121093 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summary -The “child nutrition programs” refer to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition -Service (USDA-FNS) programs that provide food for children in school or institutional settings. -The best known programs, which serve the largest number of children, are the school meals -programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). -The child nutrition programs also include the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), -which provides meals and snacks in day care and after school settings; the Summer Food Service -Program (SFSP), which provides food during the summer months; the Special Milk Program -(SMP), which supports milk for schools that do not participate in NSLP or SBP; and the Fresh -Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP), which funds fruit and vegetable snacks in select elementary -schools. - -Funding: The vast majority of the child nutrition programs account is considered mandatory -spending, with trace amounts of discretionary funding for certain related activities. Referred to as -open-ended, “appropriated entitlements,” funding is provided through the annual appropriations -process; however, the level of spending is controlled by benefit and eligibility criteria in federal -law and dependent on the resulting levels of participation. Federal cash funding (in the form of -per-meal reimbursements) and USDA commodity food support is guaranteed to schools and other -providers based on the number of meals or snacks served and participant category (e.g., free -meals for poor children get higher subsidies). - -Participation: The child nutrition programs serve children of varying ages and in different -institutional settings. The NSLP and SBP have the broadest reach, serving qualifying children of -all ages in school settings. Other child nutrition programs serve more-narrow populations. -CACFP, for example, provides meals and snacks to children in early childhood and after-school -settings among other venues. Programs generally provide some subsidy for all food served but a -larger federal reimbursement for food served to children from low-income households. - -Administration: Responsibility for child nutrition programs is divided between the federal -government, states, and localities. The state agency and type of local provider differs by program. -In the NSLP and SBP, schools and school districts (“school food authorities”) administer the -program. Meanwhile, SFSP (and sometimes CACFP) uses a model in which sponsor -organizations handle administrative responsibilities for a number of sites that serve meals. - -Reauthorization: The underlying laws covering the child nutrition programs were last -reauthorized in the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296, enacted -December 13, 2010). This law made significant changes to child nutrition programs, including -increasing federal financing for school lunches, expanding access to community eligibility and -direct certification options for schools, and expanding eligibility options for home child care -providers. The law also required an update to school meal nutrition guidelines as well as new -guidelines for food served outside the meal programs (e.g., snacks sold in vending machines and -cafeteria a la carte lines). - -Current Issues: The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition -reauthorization (see CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An -Overview). As of the date of this report, there has been no significant legislative activity with -regard to reauthorization in the 115th Congress. However, the vast majority of operations and -activities continue with funding provided by appropriations laws. Current issues in the child -nutrition programs for policymakers include the implementation of new and updated nutrition -standards, alternatives to the “congregate feeding” requirement in the SFSP, and schools’ efforts -to collect unpaid school meal fees (stigmatizing practices are sometimes called “lunch shaming”). - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Contents - -Introduction and Background .......................................................................................................... 1 -Authorization and Reauthorization ........................................................................................... 2 -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local .................................................................. 3 -Funding Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3 -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding ............................................................... 3 -Other Federal Funding ........................................................................................................ 5 -State, Local, and Participant Funds ..................................................................................... 5 -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ....................................................................................... 5 -Links to Resources .................................................................................................................... 7 -School Meals Programs ................................................................................................................... 7 -General Characteristics ............................................................................................................. 7 -School Meals Eligibility Rules .................................................................................................. 9 -Income Eligibility ............................................................................................................. 10 -Categorical Eligibility ........................................................................................................ 11 -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) ........................................................................... 13 -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) ................................................................................ 15 -School Breakfast Program (SBP) ............................................................................................ 16 -Other Child Nutrition Programs .................................................................................................... 17 -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) ...................................................................... 17 -CACFP at Centers ............................................................................................................. 18 -CACFP for Day Care Homes ............................................................................................ 19 -Summer Meals ........................................................................................................................ 20 -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP)............................................................................ 21 -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option ......................................................................... 22 -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration ....................................................................... 22 -Special Milk Program (SMP) .................................................................................................. 23 -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) ............................................................................ 23 -Other Topics .................................................................................................................................. 24 -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options ....................................................... 24 -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities ............................................................ 26 -Selected Current Issues ................................................................................................................. 28 -Regulations on Nutrition Standards ........................................................................................ 28 -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast ..................................................... 28 -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools .................................................. 30 -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP ......................................................................... 31 -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals ....................................................... 31 -Current Law and Policy .................................................................................................... 32 -Congressional Proposals ................................................................................................... 33 -Presidential Budget Proposals ........................................................................................... 34 -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” ......................................................................... 34 - -Figures - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs ............................... 9 -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals ........................... 13 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation ............................................... 15 -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation ......................................................... 17 - -Tables - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ............................................................................... 5 -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP .......................... 11 -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs ...................... 25 - -Table A-1. Acronyms ..................................................................................................................... 37 -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches ....................................................................... 38 -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks .................................................... 38 -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP ......................................................................................... 39 -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) ....................................... 39 -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School - -Programs .................................................................................................................................... 39 -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes .................................................... 39 -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP ....................................................................................... 40 -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP ........................................................................................ 40 - -Appendixes - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report ................................................................................ 37 -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement Rates for Child Nutrition Programs ........... 38 - -Contacts - -Author Information ........................................................................................................................ 41 -Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 41 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Introduction and Background -The federal child nutrition programs provide assistance to schools and other institutions in the -form of cash, commodity food, and administrative support (such as technical assistance and -administrative funding) based on the provision of meals and snacks to children.1 In general, these -programs were created (and amended over time) to both improve children’s nutrition and provide -support to the agriculture economy. - -Today, the child nutrition programs refer primarily to the following meal, snack, and milk -reimbursement programs (these and other acronyms are listed in Appendix A):2 - - National School Lunch Program (NSLP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1751 et seq.)); - - School Breakfast Program (SBP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 4 (42 U.S.C. - -1773)); - - Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) (Richard B. Russell National - -School Lunch Act, Section 17 (42 U.S.C. 1766)); - - Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act, Section 13 (42 U.S.C. 1761)); and - - Special Milk Program (SMP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 3 (42 U.S.C. - -1772)). - -The programs provide financial support and/or foods to the institutions that prepare meals and -snacks served outside of the home (unlike other food assistance programs such as the -Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program [SNAP, formerly the Food Stamp Program] where -benefits are used to purchase food for home consumption). Though exact eligibility rules and -pricing vary by program, in general the amount of federal reimbursement is greater for meals -served to qualifying low-income individuals or at qualifying institutions, although most programs -provide some subsidy for all food served. Participating children receive subsidized meals and -snacks, which may be free or at reduced price. Forthcoming sections discuss how program- -specific eligibility rules and funding operate. - -This report describes how each program operates under current law, focusing on eligibility rules, -participation, and funding. This introductory section describes some of the background and -principles that generally apply to all of the programs; subsequent sections go into further detail on -the workings of each. - -Unless stated otherwise, participation and funding data come from USDA-FNS’s “Keydata -Reports.”3 - -1 As discussed later in the report, the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) also supports food in adult day -care facilities, but the child nutrition programs overwhelmingly serve children. -2 Some lists also include the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) (Richard B. Russell National School Lunch -Act, Section 19 (42 U.S.C. 1769a)), a newer program that is financed in a much different way than the programs listed. -FFVP is discussed further later in the report (“Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program”). WIC (the Special Supplemental -Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. -WIC is not one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report. -3 This CRS report uses the May 2018 report, which contains data through March 2018. Keydata Reports available at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -1 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Authorization and Reauthorization - -The child nutrition programs are most often dated back to the 1946 enactment of the National -School Lunch Act, which created the National School Lunch Program, albeit in a different form -than it operates today.4 Most of the child nutrition programs do not date back to 1946; they were -added and amended in the decades to follow as policymakers expanded child nutrition programs’ -institutional settings and meals provided: - - The Special Milk Program was created in 1954, regularly extended, and made - -permanent in 1970.5 - - The School Breakfast Program was piloted in 1966, regularly extended, and - -eventually made permanent in 1975.6 - - A program for child care settings and summer programs was piloted in 1968, - -with separate programs authorized in 1975 and then made permanent in 1978.7 -These are now the Child and Adult Care Food Program8 and Summer Food -Service Program. - - The Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program began as a pilot in 2002 and was made - -permanent in 2008.9 - -The programs are now authorized under three major federal statutes: the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (originally enacted as the National School Lunch Act in 1946), the -Child Nutrition Act (originally enacted in 1966), and Section 32 of the act of August 24, 1935 (7 -U.S.C. 612c).10 Congressional jurisdiction over the underlying three laws has typically been -exercised by the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee; the House Education and -the Workforce Committee; and, to a limited extent (relating to commodity food assistance and -Section 32 issues), the House Agriculture Committee. - -Congress periodically reviews and reauthorizes expiring authorities under these laws. The child -nutrition programs were most recently reauthorized in 2010 through the Healthy, Hunger-Free -Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296); some of the authorities created or extended in that law -expired on September 30, 2015.11 WIC (the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, - -4 P.L. 79-396. There were, however, a number of smaller, more temporary precursor school food programs prior to -1946; see Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. The 1946 law supported school lunch programs by giving formula grant funding -to states based on factors such as per capita income, rather than the current-day open-ended entitlements based largely -on eligibility and participation rules. -5 P.L. 83-690 and P.L. 91-295. Milk purchases and donations for schools did exist prior to the 1954 law. -6 Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. -7 P.L. 90-302, P.L. 94-105, P.L. 95-627. Institute of Medicine, Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary -Guidance for All, 2011, p. 30, https://www.nap.edu/catalog/12959/child-and-adult-care-food-program-aligning-dietary- -guidance-for. -8 Adult day care was added in 1987 (Older Americans Act Amendments of 1987; P.L. 100-175). -9 P.L. 107-171 and P.L. 110-246. -10 In 1999, P.L. 106-78 renamed the National School Lunch Act in Senator Richard B. Russell’s honor. -11 Reimbursements for NSLP, SBP, CACFP, SMP, and certain related USDA activities are permanently authorized. -SFSP, WIC, and WIC Farmers Market Nutrition Program, State Administrative Expenses (discussed in “Related -Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities”), and certain related USDA activities have a September 30, 2015 -expiration. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -2 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. WIC is not -one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report.12 - -The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition reauthorization (see CRS -Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview). As of the date -of this report, the committees of jurisdiction have not conducted reauthorization hearings or -markups in the 115th Congress. - -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local - -The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition Service (USDA-FNS) administers the -programs at the federal level. The programs are operated by a wide variety of local public and -private providers and the degree of direct state involvement differs by program and state.13 At the -state level, education, health, social services, and agriculture departments all have roles; at a -minimum, they are responsible for approving and overseeing local providers such as schools, -summer program sponsors, and child care centers and day care homes, as well as making sure -they receive the federal support they are due. At the local level, program benefits are provided to -millions of children (e.g., there were 30.0 million in the National School Lunch Program, the -largest of the programs, in FY2017), through some 100,000 public and private schools and -residential child care institutions, nearly 170,000 child care centers and family day care homes, -and just over 50,000 summer program sites. - -All programs are available in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Virtually all operate in -Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands (and, in differing versions, in the Northern Marianas -and American Samoa).14 - -Funding Overview - -This section summarizes the nature and extent to which the programs’ funding is mandatory and -discretionary, including a discussion of appropriated entitlement status. Table 3 lists child -nutrition program and related expenditures. - -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding - -Most spending for child nutrition programs is provided in annual appropriations acts to fulfill the -legal financial obligation established by the authorizing laws. That is, the level of spending for -such programs, referred to as appropriated mandatory spending, is not controlled through the -annual appropriations process, but instead is derived from the benefit and eligibility criteria -specified in the authorizing laws. The appropriated mandatory funding is treated as mandatory -spending. Further, if Congress does not appropriate the funds necessary to fund the program, -eligible entities may have legal recourse.15 Congress considers the Administration’s forecast for - -12 See CRS Report R44115, A Primer on WIC: The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and -Children. -13 In the past, the federal government (via USDA-FNS) has, for certain states, taken the place of state agencies (e.g., -where a state has chosen not to operate a specific program or where there is a state prohibition on aiding private -schools). -14 For more information on child nutrition programs in the Northern Marianas and American Samoa, see U.S. -Department of the Interior, Office of Insular Affairs, Region IX Federal Regional Council, Outer Pacific Committee, -FY 2016 Report on Federal Financial Assistance to the U.S. Pacific and Caribbean Islands, May 1, 2017, p. 10, -https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/fy16-report-on-federal-financial-assistance-to-the-insular-areas.pdf. -15 GAO Budget Glossary, p. 13: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-05-734SP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -3 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -program needs in its appropriations decisions. For the majority of funding discussed in this report, -the formula that controls the funding is not capped and fluctuates based on the reimbursement -rates and the number of meals/snacks served in the programs. - -Cash Reimbursements and Commodity Foods - -In the meal service programs, such as the National School Lunch Program, School Breakfast -Program, summer programs, and assistance for child care centers and day care homes, federal aid -is provided in the form of statutorily set subsidies (reimbursements) paid for each meal/snack -served that meets federal nutrition guidelines. Although all (including full-price) meals/snacks -served by participating providers are subsidized, those served free or at a reduced price to lower- -income children are supported at higher rates. All federal meal/snack subsidy rates are indexed -annually (each July) for inflation, as are the income eligibility thresholds for free and reduced- -price meals/snacks.18 Subsequent sections discuss how a specific program’s eligibility and -reimbursements work. - -Most subsidies are cash payments to -schools or other providers, but a smaller -portion of aid is provided in the form of -USDA-purchased commodity foods.19 -Laws for three child nutrition programs -(NSLP, CACFP, and SFSP) require the -provision of commodity foods (or in -some cases allow cash in lieu of -commodity foods).20 - -Meal and snack service entails non-food -costs. Federal child nutrition per- -meal/snack subsidies may be used to -cover local providers’ administrative -and operating costs. However, the -separate direct federal payments for -administrative/operating costs (“State - -Reimbursable Meals - -A “reimbursable meal” (or snack in the case of some -programs) is a phrase used by USDA, state, and other child -nutrition policy and program operators to indicate a meal (or -snack) that meets federal requirements and thereby qualifies -for meal reimbursement.16 -In general, a meal or snack that is reimbursable means that it is - - - - - -served to the correctly eligible person and/or at the -eligible institution, and - -in compliance with federal nutrition requirements for the -meal or snack.17 - -In the school meals programs (with some variation in other -programs), the highest reimbursement is paid for meals served -free to eligible children, a slightly lower reimbursement is paid -for meals served at a reduced price to eligible children, and a -much smaller reimbursement is also paid for meals served to -children who are either ineligible for assistance or not -certified. For this last group, the children pay the full price as -advertised but meals are still technically subsidized. - -16 See, for example, definition of “reimbursement” at 7 C.F.R. 210.2. -17 The authorizing statutes for all four of the main child nutrition programs include nutritional requirements for the -meals and snacks served; these are sometimes referred to as “nutrition standards,” “nutrition guidelines,” or “meal -patterns.” In most respects, the details of the requirements are specified in USDA-FNS regulations. The nutrition -guidelines differ by program, largely in consideration of the age groups fed, meals/snacks authorized, and perhaps the -settings in which meals are served. See program regulations for nutritional requirements: NSLP, 7 C.F.R. 210.10; SBP, -7 C.F.R. 220.8; CACFP, 7 C.F.R. 226.20; SFSP, 7 C.F.R. 225.16. Recent updates of school meals and CACFP -nutrition standards are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” -18 Per-meal subsidies paid to providers (e.g., schools, child care centers) are indexed annually based on the CPI-U Food -Away from Home Component. For family child care homes, the annual indexing is based on the CPI-U Food at Home -Component. -19 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information, see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -20 See USDA-FNS Food Distribution Division resources for more information on USDA Foods and child nutrition - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -4 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Administrative Expenses,” discussed in the “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities” section) are limited. - -Other Federal Funding - -In addition to the open-ended, appropriated entitlement funds summarized above, the child -nutrition programs’ funding also includes certain other mandatory funding21 and a limited amount -of discretionary funding. Some of the activities discussed in “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities,” such as Team Nutrition, are provided for with discretionary funding. - -Aside from the annually appropriated funding, the child nutrition programs are also supported by -certain permanent appropriations and transfers. Notably, funding for the Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable Program is funded by a transfer from USDA’s Section 32 program, a permanent -appropriation of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts. - -State, Local, and Participant Funds - -Federal subsidies do not necessarily cover the full cost of the meals and snacks offered by -providers. States and localities help cover program costs, as do children’s families by paying -charges for non-free or reduced-price meals/snacks. There is a non-federal cost-sharing -requirement for the school meals programs (discussed below), and some states supplement school -funding through additional state per-meal reimbursements or other prescribed financing -arrangements.22 - -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Subsequent sections of this report delve into the details of how each of the child nutrition -programs support the service of meals and snacks in institutional settings; first, it is useful to take -a broader perspective of primary program elements. Table 1 is a top-level look at the different -programs that displays distinguishing characteristics (what meals are provided, in what settings, -to what ages) and recent program spending. - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Program - -National School -Lunch Program - -Authorizing -Statute (Year -First -Authorized) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1946) - - - - - -Distinguishing -Characteristics - -FY2017 -Expenditures - -Lunches at school - -$13.6 billion - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -FY2017 -Average Daily -Participation - -Maximum -Daily -Snack/Mealsa - -30.0 million -children - - One meal and -snack per child - -programs, http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/schoolscn-usda-foods-programs. -21 These costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and Technical -Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. See p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional -Budget Justification, available at https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -22 The School Nutrition Association, a trade association representing school meal operators and industry, tracks state -policies and funding on the organization website at https://schoolnutrition.org/LegislationPolicy/ -StateLegislationPolicyReports/. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -5 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -School -Breakfast -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1966) - - - - - - - -Possible to -provide summer -food and -afterschool -snacks. - -Breakfasts at -school (also for -pre-K-12) - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (child -care centers, day -care homes, adult -day care centers) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - - Meals and snacks -in early childhood -and adult day -care settings - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (At- -Risk After-School -snacks and meals)b - -Summer Food -Service -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1994) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - -Special Milk -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1954) - -Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(2002) - - - - - -Rules and funding -differ based on -type of institution - -Supper and -snacks for -school-age -children after- -school - - Meals and snacks -provided during -summer months - - - - - - - - - - - -Sites vary and -include schools, -community -centers, camps, -parks, and others - -Eligibility rules -vary for “open” -and “closed” sites - -Subsidizes milk, -not meals or -snacks - -Institutions -eligible must not -participate in -NSLP or SBP - -Provides free -fresh fruit and -vegetable snacks -to elementary -school students - -$4.3 billion - -14.7 million -children - - Generally one -breakfast per -child, with -some flexibility - -$3.5 billion -(includes at- -risk after- -school -spending, -described -below) - -(Not available; -included in -CACFP total -above) - -$485 million - -4.4 million -children; -132,000 adults - - Two meals and -one snack, or -one meal and -two snacks per -participant - -1.7 million -children -(included in -CACFP -children above) - -2.7 million -childrenc - - One meal and -one snack per -child - -Lunch and -breakfast or -lunch and one -snack per child -Exception: -maximum of -three meals -for camps or -programs that -serve primarily -migrant -children - -$8 million - -191,000 half- -pints served -(average daily)d - - Not specified - -$184e million - - Not available - - Not applicable - -Source: Except where noted, participation and funding data from USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report, which -contains data through March 2018. Participation data are estimated by USDA-FNS based on meals served. -a. These maximums are provided in the authorizing law for CACFP and SFSP, but specified only in regulations - -(7 C.F.R. 210.10(a), 220.9(a)) for NSLP and SBP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -6 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -b. At-risk after-school snacks and meals are part of CACFP law and CACFP funding, but differ in their rules - -and the age of children served. - -c. Based only on July 2017 participation data. -d. Data from p. 32-58 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -e. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. - -Links to Resources -Other relevant CRS reports in this area include23 - - CRS In Focus IF10266, An Introduction to Child Nutrition Reauthorization - CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs - CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296 - -(summarizes the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010) - - CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An - -Overview - - CRS Report R44588, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2017 Appropriations - CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 - -Program - -Other relevant resources include - - USDA-FNS’s website, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/child-nutrition- - -programs - - USDA-FNS’s Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act page, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ - -school-meals/healthy-hunger-free-kids-act - - The FNS page of the Federal Register, https://www.federalregister.gov/agencies/ - -food-and-nutrition-service - -School Meals Programs -This section discusses the school meals programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) -and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). Principles and concepts common to both programs are -discussed first; subsections then discuss features and data unique to the NSLP and SBP, -respectively. - -General Characteristics - -The federal school meals programs provide federal support in the form of cash assistance and -USDA commodity foods; both are provided according to statutory formulas based on the number -of reimbursable meals served in schools. The subsidized meals are served by both public and -private nonprofit elementary and secondary schools and residential child care institutions -(RCCIs)24 that opt to enroll and guarantee to offer free or reduced-price meals to eligible low- - -23 Archived historical reports that may provide useful background include CRS Report RL33829, Domestic Food -Assistance and the 2008 Farm Bill; and CRS Report RL33299, Child Nutrition and WIC Legislation in the 108th and -109th Congresses. -24 This CRS report refers to “schools,” but it should be understood that—for NSLP and SBP—it means both schools -and RCCIs. NSLP regulations, 7 C.F.R. 210.2, define RCCIs as follows: “The term ‘residential child care institutions’ - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -7 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -income children. Both cash and commodity support to participating schools are calculated based -on the number and price of meals served (e.g., lunch or breakfast, free or full price), but once the -aid is received by the school it is used to support the overall school meal service budget, as -determined by the school. This report focuses on the federal reimbursements and funding, but it -should be noted that some states have provided state financing through additional state-specific -funding.25 - -Federal law does not require schools to participate in the school meals programs. However, some -states have mandated that schools provide lunch and/or breakfast, and some of these states require -that their schools do so through NSLP and/or SBP.26 The program is open to public and private -schools. - -A reimbursable meal requires compliance with federal school nutrition standards, which have -changed throughout the history of the program based on nutritional science and children’s -nutritional needs. Food items not served as a complete meal meeting nutrition standards (e.g., a la -carte offerings) are not reimbursable meals, and therefore are not eligible for federal per-meal, -per-snack reimbursements. Following rulemaking to implement P.L. 111-296 provisions, the -standards for reimbursable meals were updated in January 2012 and USDA also has provided -nutrition standards for the non-meal foods served in schools during the school day (see “Selected -Current Issues” for more on these policies). - -USDA-FNS administers the school meals programs federally, and state agencies (typically state -departments of education) oversee and transmit reimbursements through agreements with school -food authorities (SFAs) (typically local educational agencies (LEAs); usually these are school -districts). Figure 1 provides an overview of the roles and relationships between these levels of -government. - -There is a cost-sharing requirement for the programs, which amounts to a contribution of -approximately $200 million from the states.27 There also are states that choose to supplement -federal reimbursements with their own state reimbursements.28 - -includes, but is not limited to: homes for the mentally, emotionally or physically impaired, and unmarried mothers and -their infants; group homes; halfway houses; orphanages; temporary shelters for abused children and for runaway -children; long-term care facilities for chronically ill children; and juvenile detention centers. A long-term care facility is -a hospital, skilled nursing facility, intermediate care facility, or distinct part thereof, which is intended for the care of -children confined for 30 days or more.” -25 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. -26 Ibid. -27 Section 7(a)(1) of Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1756(a)(1). Section 7(f) of -Child Nutrition Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776(f). -28 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -8 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs - -Source: Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 47. - -School Meals Eligibility Rules - -The school meals programs and related funding do not serve only low-income children. All -students can receive a meal at a NSLP- or SBP-participating school, but how much the child pays -for the meal and/or how much of a federal reimbursement the state receives will depend largely -on whether the child qualifies for a “free,” “reduced-price,” or “paid” (i.e., advertised price) meal. -Both NSLP and SBP use the same household income eligibility criteria and categorical eligibility -rules. States and schools receive the largest reimbursements for free meals, smaller -reimbursements for reduced-price meals, and the smallest (but still some federal financial -support) for the full-price meals. - -There are three pathways through which a child can become certified to receive a free or reduced- -price meal: - -1. Household income eligibility for free and reduced-price meals (information - -typically collected via household application), - -2. Categorical (or automatic) eligibility for free meals (information collected via - -household application or a direct certification process), and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -9 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -3. School-wide free meals under the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an -option for eligible schools that is based on the share of students identified as -eligible for free meals.29 - -Each of these pathways is discussed in more detail below. - -Income Eligibility - -The income eligibility thresholds (shown in Table 2) are based on multipliers of the federal -poverty guidelines. As the poverty guidelines are updated every year, so are the eligibility -thresholds for NSLP and SBP. - - Free Meals: Children receive free meals if they have household income at or -below 130% of the federal poverty guidelines; these meals receive the highest -subsidy rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $3.30 per lunch served, less for -breakfast.) - - Reduced-Price Meals: Children may receive reduced-price meals (charges of no -more than 40 cents for a lunch or 30 cents for a breakfast) if their household -income is above 130% and less than or equal to 185% of the federal poverty -guidelines; these meals receive a subsidy rate that is 40 cents (NSLP) or 30 cents -(SBP) below the free meal rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $2.90 per -lunch served.) - - Paid Meals: A comparatively small per-meal reimbursement is provided for full- -price or paid meals served to children whose families do not apply for assistance -or whose family income does not qualify them for free or reduced-price meals.30 -The paid meal price is set by the school but must comply with federal -regulations.31 (Reimbursements are approximately 30 cents per lunch served.) - -The above reimbursement rates are approximate; exact current-year federal reimbursement rates -for NSLP and SBP are listed in Table B-1 and Table B-3, respectively. - -Households complete paper or online applications that collect relevant income and household size -data, so that the school district can determine if children in the household are eligible for free -meals, reduced-price meals, or neither. - -Though these income guidelines primarily influence funding and administration of NSLP and -SBP, they also affect the eligibility rules for the SFSP, CACFP, and SMP (described further in -subsequent sections). - -29 CEP is not the only way schools may provide universal free meal service, but it is unique in that it does not require -the collection of applications. -30 The subsidy for paid meals is provided under the authority of Section 4 of the Richard B. Russell National School -Lunch Act. Section 4 establishes two different payment levels: one for schools in which less than 60% of the school -population is participating in free or reduced-price lunch and one for schools in which 60% or more of the school -population is receiving free or reduced price lunch. See https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018- -15465/national-school-lunch-special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum for -these reimbursement rates. USDA also establishes a “maximum [reimbursement] rate” intended to ensure that states -distribute federal funding to all participating school food authorities relatively equally. -31 The 2010 reauthorization established a policy intended to assure that paid meal revenues were covering the costs of -producing a meal. See FNS paid lunch equity guidance for SY2018-2019, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/paid- -lunch-equity-guidance-school-year-2018-19. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -10 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP -For 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Income Eligibility Threshold - (% of the Federal Poverty Level) - -Annual Income for a -Family of Four - -Free - -Reduced-Price - -<130% - -130-185% - -<$32,630 - -$32,630 - $46,435 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Income Eligibility Guidelines,” 83 -Federal Register 20788, May 8, 2018. -Note: This school year is defined as July 1, 2018, through June 30, 2019. For other years, household sizes, -Alaska, and Hawaii, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/income-eligibility-guidelines. - -Categorical Eligibility - -In addition to the eligibility thresholds listed above, the school meals programs also convey -eligibility for free meals based on household participation in certain other need-tested programs -or children’s specified vulnerabilities (e.g., foster children). Per Section 12 of the National School -Lunch Act, “a child shall be considered automatically eligible for a free lunch and breakfast ... -without further application or eligibility determination, if the child is”32 - - - -in a household receiving benefits through - - SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program); - FDPIR (Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations, a program -that operates in lieu of SNAP on some Indian reservations) benefits; or - - TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) cash assistance; - -enrolled in Head Start; -in foster care; -a migrant; -a runaway; or - - - - - - homeless.33 - -For meals served to students certified in the above categories, the state/school will receive -reimbursement at the free meal amount and children receive a free meal. (See Table B-1 and -Table B-3 for school year 2018-2019 rates.) - -Some school districts collect information for these categorical eligibility rules via paper -application. Others conduct a process called direct certification—a proactive process where - -32 See Section 9(b)(12)(A) of the Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(12)(A), for the -more specific definitions of these categories. -33 SNAP, FDPIR, and TANF have income limits, but the other qualifications, as defined, in the statute, are not limited -by income. In addition to the above list, following specific demonstration authority in HHFKA as well as under FNS’s -standing pilot authority, some states are currently directly certifying children based on Medicaid data. According to -USDA-FNS, 19 states are operating direct certification with Medicaid in SY2018-2019. Four of the states (Illinois, -Kentucky, New York, Pennsylvania) use Medicaid to directly certify for free meals only. Fifteen states (California, -Connecticut, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, -West Virginia, Wisconsin), operating under an expanded direct certification demonstration project to test direct -certification with Medicaid for reduced-price meals (up to 185% of poverty), are using this process for free and -reduced-price meals. Both options are discussed in USDA-FNS, Request for Applications to Participate in -Demonstration Projects to Evaluate Direct Certification with Medicaid, January 27, 2016, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ -sites/default/files/cn/SP23-2016a.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -11 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -government agencies typically cross-check their program rolls and certify a household’s children -for free school meals without the household having to complete a school meals application. - -Prior to 2004, states had the option to conduct direct certification of SNAP (then, the Food Stamp -Program), TANF, and FDPIR participants. In the 2004 child nutrition reauthorization (P.L. 108- -265), states were required under federal law to conduct direct certification for SNAP participants, -with nationwide implementation taking effect in school year 2008-2009. Conducting direct -certification for TANF and FDPIR remains at the state’s discretion. - -The Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296) made further policy changes -to expand direct certification (discussed further in the next section). One of those changes was the -initiation of a demonstration project to look at expanding categorical eligibility and direct -certification to some Medicaid households. The law also funded performance incentive grants for -high-performing states and authorized correcting action planning for low-performing states in -direct certification activities.34 - -Under SNAP direct certification rules generally, schools enter into agreements with SNAP -agencies to certify children in SNAP households as eligible for free school meals without -requiring a separate application from the family. Direct certification systems match student -enrollment lists against SNAP agency records, eliminating the need for action by the child’s -parents or guardians. Direct certification allows schools to make use of SNAP’s more in-depth -eligibility certification process; this can reduce errors that may occur in school lunch application -eligibility procedures that are otherwise used.35 From a program access perspective, direct -certification also reduces the number of applications a household must complete. - -Figure 2, created by GAO and published in a May 2014 report, provides an overview of how -school districts certify students for free and reduced-price meals under the income-based and -category-based rules, via applications and direct certification.36 A USDA-FNS study of school -year 2014-2015 estimates that 11.1 million students receiving free meals were directly certified— -68% of all categorically eligible students receiving free meals.37 - -34 See CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296, for further discussion of these -and related policies. -35 See, for example, U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, -but Additional Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, pp. 16-19, -http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-14-262. -36 U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, but Additional -Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, http://www.gao.gov/products/ -GAO-14-262. -37 Quinn Moore, Kevin Conway, and Brandon Kyler, et al., Direct Certification in the National School Lunch -Program: State Implementation Progress, School Year 2014-2015, Report to Congress Mathematica Policy Research -for USDA-FNS, CN-15-DC, October 2016, p. 24, https://www.fns.usda.gov/direct-certification-national-school-lunch- -program-report-congress-state-implementation-progress-0 - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -12 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals -Household Application and Direct Certification Pathways - -Source: Figure and figure notes (below) from Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 13. -Note: aStudents who meet an approved designation—(1) homeless, runaway, or migrant; (2) foster child; or -(3) enrolled in a federally funded Head Start Program—are categorically eligible for free school meals. - -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) - -HHFKA also authorized the school meals Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an option in -NSLP and SBP law that allows eligible schools and school districts to offer free meals to all -enrolled students based on the percentage of their students who are identified as automatically - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -13 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -eligible from non-household application sources (primarily direct certification through other -programs).38 - -Based on the statutory parameters, USDA-FNS piloted CEP in various states over three school -years and it expanded nationwide in school year 2014-2015. Eligible LEAs have until June 30 of -each year to notify USDA-FNS if they will participate in CEP.39 According to a database -maintained by the Food Research and Action Center, just over 20,700 schools in more than 3,500 -school districts (LEAs) participated in CEP in SY2016-2017, an increase of approximately 2,500 -schools compared to SY2015-2016.40 - -For a school (or school district, or group of schools within a district) to provide free meals to all -children: - - - - - -the school(s) must be eligible for CEP based on the share (40% or greater) of -enrolled children that can be identified as categorically (or automatically) eligible -for free meals, and -the school must opt-in to CEP. - -Though CEP schools serve free meals to all students, they are not reimbursed at the “free meal” -rate for every meal. Instead, the law provides a funding formula: the percentage of students -identified as automatically eligible (the “identified student percentage” or ISP) is multiplied by a -factor of 1.6 to estimate the proportion of students who would be eligible for free or reduced- -price meals had they been certified via application.41 The result is the percentage of meals served -that will be reimbursed at the free meal rate, with the remainder reimbursed at the far lower paid -meal rate. For example, if a CEP school identifies that 40% of students are eligible for free meals, -then 64% of the meals served will be reimbursed at the free meal rate and 36% at the paid meal -rate.42 Schools that identify 62.5% or more students as eligible for free meals receive the free -meal reimbursement for all meals served. - -Some of the considerations that may impact a school’s decision to participate in CEP include -whether the new funding formula would be beneficial for their school meal budget; an interest in -reducing paperwork for families and schools; and an interest in providing more free meals, -including meals to students who have not participated in the program before. - -38 Explanation here draws in part from Madeleine Levin and Zoe Neuberger, Improving Direct Certification Will Help -More Low-Income Children Receive School Meals, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities & Food Research and -Action Center, July 25, 2014, p. 3. Aside from CEP, schools may also provide universal free meal service through the -“Provision 2” and “Provision 3” options. CEP is unique in that no school meal applications are required. For -information on other options, see USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/provisions-1-2-and-3. -39 USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating -Applications through Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal -Register 50194, July 29, 2016. -40 FRAC, “Community Eligibility,” available at http://frac.org/community-eligibility. -41 USDA-FNS, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating Applications Through -Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal Register 50194, July -29, 2016, p. 50201. -42 Though, to the children of community eligibility schools, all meals are free, the USDA-FNS school meals -expenditure data used throughout this report count these meals served in a more nuanced fashion. The percentage -derived through this calculation is used to record those meals that are “free” and those meals that are “paid” (i.e., using -the example from above, USDA-FNS data would reflect 64% of the meals served in the school as a “free” expenditure -and meal served, and 36% as “paid”). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -14 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) - -In FY2017, NSLP subsidized 4.9 billion lunches to children in close to 96,000 schools and 3,200 -residential child care institutions (RCCIs). Average daily participation was 30.0 million students -(58% of children enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). Of the participating students, -66.7% (20.0 million) received free lunches and 6.5% (2.0 million) received reduced-price -lunches. The remainder were served full-price meals, though schools still receive a -reimbursement for these meals. Figure 3 shows FY2017 participation data. - -FY2017 federal school lunch costs totaled approximately $13.6 billion (see Table 3 for the -various components of this total). The vast majority of this funding is for per-meal -reimbursements for free and reduced-price lunches. - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at NSLP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -HHFKA also provided an additional 6-cent per-lunch reimbursement to schools that provide -meals that meet the updated nutritional guidelines requirements.43 This bonus is not provided for -breakfast, but funds may be used to support schools’ breakfast programs. NSLP lunch -reimbursement rates are listed in Table B-1. - -In addition to federal cash subsidies, schools participating in NSLP receive USDA-acquired -commodity foods. Schools are entitled to a specific, inflation-indexed value of USDA commodity - -43 In January 2014, USDA-FNS issued a final rule implementing the 6-cent reimbursement: USDA-FNS, “Certification -of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids -Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. Note: 6-cent increase authorized is also annually indexed for -inflation. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -15 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -foods for each lunch they serve. Also, schools may receive donations of bonus commodities -acquired by USDA in support of the farm economy.44 In FY2017, the value of federal commodity -food aid to schools totaled nearly $1.4 billion. The per-meal rate for commodity food assistance is -included in Table B-4. - -While the vast majority of NSLP funding is for lunches served during the school day, NSLP may -also be used to support snack service during the school year and to serve meals during the -summer. These features are discussed in subsequent sections, “Summer Meals” and “After-School -Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” Reimbursement rates for snacks are listed in Table -B-2. - -School Breakfast Program (SBP) - -The School Breakfast Program (SBP) provides per-meal cash subsidies for breakfasts served in -schools. Participating schools receive subsidies based on their status as a severe need or non- -severe need institution. Schools can qualify as a severe need school if 40% or more of their -lunches are served free or at reduced prices. See Table B-3 for SBP reimbursement rates. - -Figure 4 displays SBP participation data for FY2017. In that year, SBP subsidized over 2.4 -billion breakfasts in over 88,000 schools and nearly 3,200 RCCIs. Average daily participation was -14.7 million children (30.1% of the students enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). The -majority of meals served through SBP are free or reduced-price. Of the participating students, -79.1% (11.6 million) received free meals and 5.7% (835,000) purchased reduced-price meals. -Federal school breakfast costs for the fiscal year totaled approximately $4.3 billion (see Table 3 -for the various components of this total). - -Significantly fewer schools and students participate in SBP than in NSLP. Participation in SBP -tends to be lower for several reasons, including the traditionally required early arrival by students -in order to receive a meal and eat before school starts. Some schools offer (and anti-hunger -groups have encouraged) models of breakfast service that can result in greater SBP participation, -such as Breakfast in the Classroom, where meals are delivered in the classroom; “grab and go” -carts, where students receive a bagged breakfast that they bring to class, or serving breakfast later -in the day in middle and high schools.45 - -Unlike NSLP, commodity food assistance is not a formal part of SBP funding; however, -commodities provided through NSLP may be used for school breakfasts as well. - -44 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -45 See Food Research and Action Center (FRAC), “School Breakfast Expansion Strategies,” http://www.frac.org/ -programs/school-breakfast-program/school-breakfast-expansion-strategies (Accessed July 9, 2018). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -16 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at SBP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -Other Child Nutrition Programs -In addition to the school meals programs discussed above, other federal child nutrition programs -provide federal subsidies and commodity food assistance for schools and other institutions that -offer meals and snacks to children in early childhood, summer, and after-school settings. This -assistance is provided to (1) schools and other governmental institutions, (2) private for-profit and -nonprofit child care centers, (3) family/group day care homes, and (4) nongovernmental -institutions/organizations that offer outside-of-school programs for children. (Although this report -focuses on the programs that serve children, one child nutrition program [CACFP] also serves -day care centers for chronically impaired adults and elderly persons under the same general per- -meal/snack subsidy terms.) The programs in the sections to follow serve comparatively fewer -children and spend comparatively fewer federal funds than the school meal programs. - -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) - -CACFP subsidizes meals and snacks served in early childhood, day care, and after-school -settings. CACFP provides subsidies for meals and snacks served at participating non-residential -child care centers, family day care homes, and (to a lesser extent) adult day care centers.46 The -program also provides assistance for meals served at after-school programs. CACFP -reimbursements are available for meals and snacks served to children age 12 or under, migrant - -46 CACFP also supports meals in homeless/emergency shelters. See http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/emergency-shelters -for further information. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -17 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -children age 15 or under, children with disabilities of any age, and, in the case of adult care -centers, chronically impaired and elderly adults. Children in early childhood settings are the -overwhelming majority of those served by the program. - -CACFP provides federal reimbursements for breakfasts, lunches, suppers, and snacks served in -participating centers (facilities or institutions) or day care homes (private homes). The eligibility -and funding rules for CACFP meals and snacks depend first on whether the participating -institution is a center or a day care home (the next two sections discuss the rules specific to -centers and day care homes). According to FY2017 CACFP data, child care centers have an -average daily attendance of about 56 children per center, day care homes have an average daily -attendance of approximately 7 children per home, and adult day care centers typically care for an -average of 48 chronically ill or elderly adults per center.47 - -Subsidized CACFP meals and snacks must meet program-specific federal nutrition standards, and -providers must demonstrate that they comply with government-established standards for other -child care programs. Like in school meals, federal assistance is made up overwhelmingly of cash -reimbursements calculated based on the number of meals/snacks served and federal per- -meal/snack reimbursements rates, but a far smaller share of federal aid (4.3% in FY2017) is in the -form of federal USDA commodity foods (or cash in lieu of foods). Federal CACFP -reimbursements flow to individual providers either directly from the administering state agency -(this is the case with many child/adult care centers able to handle their own CACFP -administrative functions) or through “sponsors” who oversee and provide administrative support -for a number of local providers (this is the case with some child/adult care centers and with all -day care homes).48 - -In FY2017, total CACFP spending was over $3.5 billion, including cash reimbursement, -commodity food assistance, and costs for sponsor audits. (See Table 3 for a further breakdown of -CACFP costs.) This total also includes the after-school meals and snacks provided through -CACFP’s “at-risk after-school” pathway; this aspect of the program is discussed later in “After- -School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” - -CACFP at Centers - -Participation - -Child care centers in CACFP can be (1) public or private nonprofit centers, (2) Head Start -centers, (3) for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet certain requirements as to the proportion of -low-income children they enroll), and (4) shelters for homeless families. Adult day care centers -include public or private nonprofit centers and for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet -minimum requirements related to serving low-income disabled and elderly adults).49 In FY2017, -over 65,000 child care centers with an average daily attendance of over 3.6 million children -participated in CACFP. Over 2,700 adult care centers served nearly 132,000 adults through -CACFP. - -47 USDA-FNS’ administrative data on the CACFP are the source of these attendance numbers. -48 In many cases, sponsor organizations that provide administrative support to multiple providers also are paid federal -reimbursements for their costs. Day care homes must have a sponsoring organization, while child care centers may -have a sponsor but are not required to do so. -49 Participating adult care programs “should be structured, comprehensive and provide health and social support -services to enrolled participants. Centers that simply provide social or rehabilitative services to adults do not qualify to -participate in CACFP.” http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/facts-about-adult-component-cacfp. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -18 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Eligibility and Administration - -Participating centers may receive daily reimbursements for up to either two meals and one snack -or one meal and two snacks for each participant, so long as the meals and snacks meet federal -nutrition standards. - -The eligibility rules for CACFP centers largely track those of NSLP: children in households at or -below 130% of the current poverty line qualify for free meals/snacks while those between 130% -and 185% of poverty qualify for reduced-price meals/snacks (see Table 2). In addition, -participation in the same categorical eligibility programs as NSLP as well as foster child status -convey eligibility for free meals in CACFP.50 Like school meals, eligibility is determined through -paper applications or direct certification processes. - -Like school meals, all meals and snacks served in the centers are federally subsidized to some -degree, even those that are paid. Different reimbursement amounts are provided for breakfasts, -lunches/suppers, and snacks, and reimbursement rates are set in law and indexed for inflation -annually. The largest subsidies are paid for meals and snacks served to participants with family -income below 130% of the federal poverty income guidelines (the income limit for free school -meals), and the smallest to those who have not met a means test. See Table B-5 for current -CACFP center reimbursement rates. - -Unlike school meals, CACFP institutions are less likely to collect per-meal payments. Although -federal assistance for day care centers differentiates by household income, centers have discretion -on their pricing of meals. Centers may adjust their regular fees (tuition) to account for federal -payments, but CACFP itself does not regulate these fees. In addition, centers can charge families -separately for meals/snacks, so long as there are no charges for children meeting free-meal/snack -income tests and limited charges for those meeting reduced-price income tests. - -Independent centers are those without sponsors handling administrative responsibilities. These -centers must pay for administrative costs associated with CACFP out of non-federal funds or a -portion of their meal subsidy payments. For centers with sponsors, the sponsors may retain a -proportion of the meal reimbursement payments they receive on behalf of their centers to cover -such costs. - -CACFP for Day Care Homes - -Participation - -CACFP-supported day care homes serve a smaller number of children than CACFP-supported -centers, both in terms of the total number of children served and the average number of children -per facility. Roughly 17% of children in CACFP (approximately 757,000 in FY2017 average -daily attendance) are served through day care homes. In FY2017, approximately 103,000 homes -(with just over 700 sponsors) received CACFP support. - -Eligibility and Reimbursement - -As with centers, payments to day care homes are provided for up to either two meals and one -snack or one meal and two snacks a day for each child. Unlike centers, day care homes must -participate under the auspices of a public or, more often, private nonprofit sponsor that typically - -50 See also summary of CACFP eligibility rules at USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/why-cacfp- -important. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -19 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -has 100 or more homes under its supervision. CACFP day care home sponsors receive monthly -administrative payments based on the number of homes for which they are responsible.51 - -Federal reimbursements for family day care homes differ by the home’s status as “Tier I” or “Tier -II.” Unlike centers, day care homes receive cash reimbursements (but not commodity foods) that -generally are not based on the child participants’ household income. Instead, there are two -distinct, annually indexed reimbursement rates that are based on area or operator eligibility -criteria: - - Tier I homes are located in low-income areas (defined as areas in which at least - -50% of school-age and enrolled children qualify for free or reduced-price meals) -or operated by low-income providers whose household income meets the free or -reduced-price income standards.52 They receive higher subsidies for each -meal/snack they serve. - - Tier II (lower) rates are by default those for homes that do not qualify for Tier I -rates; however, Tier II providers may seek the higher Tier I subsidy rates for -individual low-income children for whom financial information is collected and -verified. (See Table B-6 for current Tier I and Tier II reimbursement rates.) - -Additionally, HHFKA introduced a number of additional ways (as compared to prior law) by -which family day care homes can qualify as low-income and get Tier I rates for the entire home -or for individual children.53 - -As with centers, there is no requirement that meals/snacks specifically identified as free or -reduced-price be offered; however, unlike centers, federal rules prohibit any separate meal -charges. - -Summer Meals - -Current law SFSP and the NSLP/SBP Seamless Summer Option provide meals in congregate -settings nationwide; the related Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer (SEBTC or Summer EBT) -demonstration project is an alternative to congregate settings. The demonstration is discussed -below; proposals to expand the demonstration are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” - -51 As an example of the role that sponsors and homes play in CACFP, in Allentown, Pennsylvania, the Lehigh Valley -Children’s Centers (LVCC) serves as a sponsor for child care homes in the area. They offer a variety of administrative -services to family child care homes that are registered with the state. In their brochure, they state that it is LVCC’s -responsibility to “monitor meals and reimburse [homes] for meals served,” and it is homes’ responsibility “to plan -nutritional menus that meet meal requirements, maintain and submit daily attendance records and monthly meal -counts.” See http://www.lvcconline.org/images/pdf/CACFP-Brochure.pdf. -52 7 C.F.R. §226.2. -53 Previously, child care homes could only use data from the elementary school level to establish the area as low- -income. The new law allows these homes to use data from the middle and high school level as well to establish need -and qualify as a “Tier I” home. Also, P.L. 111-296 included policies to streamline application processes and eliminate -some paperwork. As part of this process, the annual application process has been eliminated and sponsors and child -care centers will only have to submit paperwork the first time they apply, with amendments submitted as necessary. -Finally, P.L. 111-296 increased CACFP sponsoring organizations’ and providers’ flexibility over administrative funds, -including the option to carry over up to 10% of administrative funds from one fiscal year to the next. USDA-FNS has -begun to implement these changes. See, for example, USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Amendments Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 77 Federal Register 21018-21038, -April 9, 2012; USDA-FNS Memorandum, Child Nutrition Reauthorization 2010: Area Eligibility for Family Day Care -Homes, Memo Code: CACFP 05-2011-Revised, January 10, 2011, https://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp-05-2011-revised- -child-nutrition-reauthorization-2010-area-eligibility-family-day-care-homes. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -20 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) - -SFSP supports meals for children during the summer months. The program provides assistance to -local public institutions and private nonprofit service institutions running summer -youth/recreation programs, summer feeding projects, and camps. Assistance is primarily in the -form of cash reimbursements for each meal or snack served; however, federally donated -commodity foods are also offered. Participating service institutions are often entities that provide -ongoing year-round service to the community including schools, local governments, camps, -colleges and universities in the National Youth Sports program, and private nonprofit -organizations like churches. - -Similar to the CACFP model, sponsors are institutions that manage the food preparation, -financial, and administrative responsibilities of SFSP. Sites are the places where food is served -and eaten. At times, a sponsor may also be a site. State agencies authorize sponsors, monitor and -inspect sponsors and sites, and implement USDA policy. Unlike CACFP, sponsors are required -for an institution’s participation in SFSP as a site. - -Participation - -In FY2017, nearly 5,500 sponsors with 50,000 food service sites participated in the SFSP and -served an average of approximately 2.7 million children daily (according to July data).54 - -Participation of sites and children in SFSP has increased in recent years. Program costs for -FY2017 totaled over $485 million, including cash assistance, commodity foods, administrative -cost assistance, and health inspection costs. - -Eligibility and Administration - -There are several options for eligibility and meal/snack service for SFSP sponsors (and their -sites): - - Open sites provide summer food to all children in the community. These sites are -certified based on area eligibility measures, where 50% or more of area children -have family income that would make them eligible for free or reduced-price -school meals (see Table 2). - - Closed or Enrolled sites provide summer meals/snacks free to all children - -enrolled at the site. The eligibility test for these sites is that 50% or more of the -children enrolled in the sponsor’s program must be eligible for free or reduced- -price school meals based on household income. Closed/enrolled sites may also -become eligible based on area eligibility measures noted above. - - Summer camps (that are not enrolled sites) receive subsidies only for those -children with household eligibility for free or reduced-price school meals. - Other programs specified in law, such as the National Youth Sports Program - -and centers for homeless or migrant children. - -54 According to a May 2018 GAO report, estimates of participation in SFSP may not be reliable because they have been -calculated inconsistently across states and years. See U.S. Government Accountability Office, Actions Needed to -Improve Participation Estimates and Address Program Challenges, GAO-18-369, May 2018, https://www.gao.gov/ -products/GAO-18-369. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -21 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer sponsors get operating cost (food, storage, labor) subsidies for all meals/snacks they -serve—up to one meal and one snack, or two meals per child per day.55 In addition, sponsors -receive payments for administrative costs, and states are provided with subsidies for -administrative costs and health and meal-quality inspections. See Table B-7 for current SFSP -reimbursement rates. Actual payments vary slightly (e.g., by about 5 cents for lunches) depending -on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared on-site or by a -vendor. - -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option56 - -Although SFSP is the child nutrition program most associated with providing meals during -summer months, it is not the only program option for providing these meals and snacks. The -Seamless Summer Option, run through NSLP or SBP programs, is also a means through which -food can be provided to students during summer months. Much like SFSP, Seamless Summer -operates in summer sites (summer camps, sports programs, churches, private nonprofit -organizations, etc.) and for a similar duration of time. Unlike SFSP, schools are the only eligible -sponsors, although schools may operate the program at other sites. Reimbursement rates for -Seamless Summer meals are the same as current NSLP/SBP rates. - -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration - -Beginning in summer 2011 and (as of the date of this report) each summer since, USDA-FNS has -operated Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children (SEBTC or “Summer EBT”) -demonstration projects in a limited number of states and Indian Tribal Organizations (ITOs). -These Summer EBT projects provide electronic food benefits over summer months to households -with children eligible for free or reduced-price school meals. Depending on the site and year, -either $30 or $60 per month is provided, through a WIC or SNAP EBT card model. In the -demonstration projects, these benefits were provided as a supplement to the Summer Food -Service Program (SFSP) meals available in congregate settings. - -Summer EBT and other alternatives to congregate meals through SFSP were first authorized and -funded by the FY2010 appropriations law (P.L. 111-80). Although a number of alternatives were -tested and evaluated, findings from Summer EBT were among the most promising, and Congress -provided subsequent funding.57 Summer EBT evaluations (discussed later in “Alternatives to -“Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals”) showed significant impacts on reducing child food -insecurity and improving nutritional intake.58 Summer EBT was funded by P.L. 111-80 in the -summers from 2011 to 2014. Projects have continued to operate and were annually funded by -FY2015-FY2018 appropriations; most recently, the FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million. According to USDA-FNS, in summer 2016 Summer EBT served over - -55 With state agency approval, camps and migrant sites (sites that predominantly serve children of migrant workers) -may be reimbursed for serving three meals or two meals and one snack per child daily. -56 For further discussion, see the USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/opportunity-schools. -57 This CRS report discusses Summer EBT, not the other tested programs (“Enhanced Summer Food Service Program -(eSFSP). For information on eSFSP, see USDA-FNS’ “Enhanced Summer Food Service Program” webpage, -https://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/enhanced-summer-food-service-program-esfsp. -58 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus (Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013), p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -22 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -209,000 children in nine states and two tribal nations—an increase from the 11,400 children -served when the demonstration began in summer 2011.59 - -Special Milk Program (SMP) - -Schools (and institutions like summer camps and child care facilities) that are not already -participating in the other child nutrition programs can participate in the Special Milk Program. -Schools may also administer SMP for their part-day sessions for kindergartners or pre- -kindergartners. - -Under SMP, participating institutions provide milk to children for free and/or at a subsidized paid -price, depending on how the enrolled institution opts to administer the program (see Table B-8 -for current Special Milk reimbursement rates for each of these options): - - An institution that only sells milk will receive the same per-half pint federal - -reimbursement for each milk sold (approximately 20 cents). - - An institution that sells milk and provides free milk to eligible children (income - -eligibility is the same as free school meals, see Table 2), receives a -reimbursement for the milk sold (approximately 20 cents) and a higher -reimbursement for the free milks. - - An institution that does not sell milk provides milk free to all children and - -receives the same reimbursement for all milk (approximately 20 cents). This -option is sometimes called non-pricing. - -In FY2017, over 41 million half-pints were subsidized, 9.5% of which were served free. Federal -expenditures for this program were approximately $8.3 million in FY2017. - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) - -States receive formula grants through the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program, under which state- -selected schools receive funds to purchase and distribute fresh fruit and vegetable snacks to all -children in attendance (regardless of family income). Money is distributed by a formula under -which about half the funding is distributed equally to each state and the remainder is allocated by -state population. States select participating schools (with an emphasis on those with a higher -proportion of low-income children) and set annual per-student grant amounts (between $50 and -$75). - -Funding is set by law at $150 million for school year 2011-2012 and inflation-indexed for every -year after. In FY2017, states used approximately $184 million in FFVP funds.60 FFVP is funded -by a mandatory transfer of funds from USDA’s Section 32 program—a permanent appropriation -of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts.61 This transfer is required by FFVP’s authorizing -laws (Section 19 of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act and Section 4304 of P.L. -110-246). Up until FY2018’s law, annual appropriations laws delayed a portion of the funds to -the next fiscal year. - -59 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32- -40https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -60 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32-14, -https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -61 For more information, see CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -23 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In recent years, FFVP has been amended by omnibus farm bill laws rather than through child -nutrition reauthorizations. After a limited pilot, FFVP was expanded to all states and permanently -funded by the 2008 farm bill (P.L. 110-246).62 The 2014 farm bill (P.L. 113-79) essentially made -no changes to this program but did include, and fund at $5 million in FY2014, a pilot project that -requires USDA to test offering frozen, dried, and canned fruits and vegetables and publish an -evaluation of the pilot. Four states (Alaska, Delaware, Kansas, and Maine) participated in the -pilot in SY2014-2015 and the evaluation was published in 2017.63 Other proposals to expand -fruits and vegetables offered in FFVP have been introduced in both the 114th and 115th -Congress.64 - -Other Topics - -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options - -Two of the child nutrition programs discussed in previous sections, the National School Lunch -Program (NSLP) and Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), provide federal support for -snacks and meals served during after-school programs.65 - -NSLP provides reimbursements for after-school snacks; however, this option is open only to -schools that already participate in NSLP. These schools may operate after-school snack-only -programs during the school year, and can do so in two ways: (1) if low-income area eligibility -criteria are met, provide free snacks in lower-income areas; or (2) if area eligibility criteria are not -met, offer free, reduced-price, or fully paid-for snacks, based on household income eligibility -(like lunches in NSLP). The vast majority of snacks provided through this program are through -the first option. Through this program, approximately 206 million snacks were served in FY2017 -(a daily average of nearly 1.3 million). This compares with nearly 4.9 billion lunches served (a -daily average of 27.8 million). - -CACFP provides assistance for after-school food in two ways. First, centers and homes that -participate in CACFP and provide after-school care may participate in traditional CACFP (the -eligibility and administration described earlier). Second, centers in areas where at least half the -children in the community are eligible for free or reduced-price school meals can opt to -participate in the CACFP At-Risk Afterschool program, which provides free snacks and suppers. -Expansion of the At-Risk After-School meals program was a major policy change included in -HHFKA. Prior to the law, 13 states were permitted to offer CACFP At-Risk After-School meals -(instead of just a snack); the law allowed all CACFP state agencies to offer such meals.66 In - -62 Permanent funding is made possible through the Section 32 account. See CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food -Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program, coordinated by Jim Monke. -63 Briefel et al., Evaluation of the Pilot Project for Canned, Frozen, or Dried Fruits and Vegetables in the Fresh Fruit -and Vegetable Program (FFVP-CFD), Prepared by Mathematica Policy Research. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, January 2017, available at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/ops/FFVP-CFD.pdf. -64 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. In the 115th Congress, -see H.R. 3402, S. 2064, and House-passed H.R. 2 §4204. -65 For further discussion of the NSLP and CACFP after-school snack program, see Joanne Guthrie, Feeding Children -After School: The Expanding Role of USDA Child Nutrition Programs, USDA Economic Research Service, Amber -Waves, March 1, 2012, https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2012/march/feeding-children-after-school/. -66 S.Rept. 111-178, p. 7. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -24 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -FY2017, the At-Risk Afterschool program served a total of approximately 242.6 million free -meals and snacks to a daily average of more than 1.7 million children.67 - -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs - -In millions of dollars - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -National School Lunch Program - -$13,569 - -$13,643 - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -additional funding to schools with -more than 60% free or reduced- -price participation - -performance-based meal -reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -School Breakfast Program - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -Child and Adult Care Food -Program - -meal reimbursements at child care -centers - -meal reimbursements at child care -homes - -meal reimbursements at adult day -care centers - -commodity food assistancea - -administrative costs for child care -sponsors - -Summer Food Service Program - -meal reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -sponsor and inspection costs - -Special Milk Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable -Programb - -State Administrative Expenses - -$9,593 - -$808 - -$1,478 - -$9,620 - -$783 - -$1,480 - -+$74 - -+$27 - --$25 - -+$2 - -+1% - -0% - --3% - -0% - -$76 - -$74 - --$2 - --3% - -$302 - -$293 - --$9 - --3% - -$1,311 - -$4,213 - -$3,868 - -$239 - -$106 - -$1,393 - -$4,252 - -$3,912 - -$235 - -$106 - -+$82 - -+$39 - -+$44 - --$4 - -$0 - -+6% - -+1% - -+1% - --2% - -0% - -$3,520 - -$3,537 - -+$17 - -0% - -$2,307 - -$2,363 - -+$56 - -+2% - -$764 - -$149 - -$155 - -$146 - -$478 - -$419 - -$2 - -$58 - -$9 - -$167 - -$260 - -$721 - --$42 - --6% - -$156 - -$153 - -$145 - -$485 - -$424 - -$2 - -$60 - -$8 - -+$7 - -+5% - --$2 - --$1 - -+$7 - -+$5 - -$0 - -+$2 - --$1 - --1% - --1% - -+1% - -+1% - -0% - -+3% - --11% - -$184 - -+$17 - -+10% - -$279 - -+$19 - -+7% - -67 Data provided by USDA-FNS on July 18, 2018. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -25 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -Mandatory Other Program -Costsc - -Discretionary Activitiesd - -TOTAL OF FUNDS -DISPLAYEDe - -$59 - -$69 - -$83 - -$63 - -+$24 - -+41% - --$6 - --9% - -$22,344 - -$22,534 - -+$192 - -+1% - -Source: Program expenditures data (outlays) from USDA-FNS Keydata Reports (dated March 2017 and March -2018), except where noted below. -Notes: Expenditures displayed here will vary from displays in CRS appropriations reports and in some cases the -USDA-FNS annual budget justification. Since the majority of program funding is for open-ended entitlements, -expenditure data capture spending better than the total of appropriations. This table includes some functions that are -funded through permanent appropriations or transfers (i.e., funding not provided in appropriations laws). Due to -rounding to the nearest million, percentage increases or decreases may be exaggerated or understated. - -a. Amounts included in this table for commodity food assistance include only entitlement commodities for - -each program, not bonus commodities. - -b. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -c. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and -Technical Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. - -d. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs include Team Nutrition, the Summer EBT demonstration, and School Meal Equipment Grants. -e. This table summarizes the vast majority of child nutrition programs’ federal spending but does not capture - -all federal costs. - -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities - -Federal child nutrition laws authorize and program funding supports a range of additional -programs, initiatives, and activities.68 - -Through State Administrative Expenses funding, states are entitled to federal grants to help -cover administrative and oversight/monitoring costs associated with child nutrition programs. The -national amount each year is equal to about 2% of child nutrition reimbursements. The majority -of this money is allocated to states based on their share of spending on the covered programs; -about 15% is allocated under a discretionary formula granting each state additional amounts for -CACFP, commodity distribution, and Administrative Review efforts. In addition, states receive -payments for their role in overseeing summer programs (about 2.5% of their summer program -aid). States are free to apportion their federal administrative expense payments among child -nutrition initiatives (including commodity distribution activities) as they see fit, and appropriated -funding is available to states for two years. State Administrative Expense spending in FY2017 -totaled approximately $279 million.69 - -Team Nutrition is a USDA-FNS program that includes a variety of school meals initiatives -around nutrition education and the nutritional content of the foods children eat in schools. This - -68 This section does not list all related federal funding and support activities; those activities that are discussed are -broadly summarized. For further details on these and other functions funded by the “child nutrition programs” account, -see the 2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, pp. 32-10 through -32-26, https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -69 For the formula for administrative and oversight/monitoring costs, see Section 7 of the Child Nutrition Act of 1966 -(codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -26 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -includes Team Nutrition Training Grants, which provide funding to state agencies for training and -technical assistance, such as help implementing USDA’s nutrition requirements and the Dietary -Guidelines for Americans. From 2004 to 2018, Team Nutrition also included the HealthierUS -Schools Challenge (HUSSC), which originated in the 2004 reauthorization of the Child Nutrition -Act. HUSSC was a voluntary certification initiative designed to recognize schools that have -created a healthy school environment through the promotion of nutrition and physical activity.70 - -Farm-to-school programs broadly refer to “efforts that bring regionally and locally produced -foods into school cafeterias,” with a focus on enhancing child nutrition.71 The goals of these -efforts include increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among students, supporting local -farmers and rural communities, and providing nutrition and agriculture education to school -districts and farmers. HHFKA amended existing child nutrition programs to establish mandatory -funding of $5 million per year for competitive farm-to-school grants that support schools and -nonprofit entities in establishing farm-to-school programs that improve a school’s access to -locally produced foods.72 The FY2018 appropriations law provided an additional $5 million in -discretionary funding to remain available until expended.73 Grants may be used for training, -supporting operations, planning, purchasing equipment, developing school gardens, developing -partnerships, and implementing farm-to-school programs. USDA’s Office of Community Food -Systems provides additional resources on farm-to-school issues.74 - -Through an Administrative Review process (formerly referred to as Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE)), USDA-FNS, in cooperation with state agencies, conducts periodic on-site NSLP school -compliance and accountability evaluations to improve management and identify administrative, -subsidy claim, and meal quality problems.75 State agencies are required to conduct administrative -reviews of all school food authorities (SFAs) that operate the NSLP under their jurisdiction at -least once during a three-year review cycle.76 Federal Administrative Review expenditures were -approximately $9.9 million in FY2017. - -USDA-FNS and state agencies conduct many other child nutrition program support activities for -which dedicated funding is provided. Among other examples, there is the Institute of Child -Nutrition (ICN), which provides technical assistance, instruction, and materials related to -nutrition and food service management; it receives $5 million a year in mandatory funding -appropriated in statute. ICN is located at the University of Mississippi. USDA-FNS provides -training on food safety education. Funding is also provided for USDA-FNS to conduct studies, -provide training and technical assistance, and oversee payment accuracy. - -70 See USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/hussc/healthierus-school-challenge-smarter-lunchrooms. -71 USDA, The Farm to School Program—2012-2015: Four Years in Review, p. 3. https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/f2s/Farm-to-School-at-USDA—4-Years-in-Review.pdf. -72 HHFKA, Section 243 (Access to Local Foods: Farm to School Program), amending §18 of the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(j)). In addition, appropriations are authorized “such sums as are necessary -for each of fiscal years 2011 through 2015.” -73 See Section 763 of P.L. 115-141. -74 See USDA-FNS’s Office of Community Food Systems: http://www.fns.usda.gov/farmtoschool/farm-school. -75 Text in this paragraph is adapted from the USDA-FNS, National School Lunch Program: Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE), FNS-640 Data Report, January 2014. -76 HHFKA increased the frequency of administrative reviews from once every five years to once every three years. See -final rule at USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Administrative Reviews in the School Nutrition Programs,” 81 -Federal Register 50170, July 29, 2016. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -27 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Selected Current Issues -This section provides further information on current issues in the child nutrition programs. In -particular, it provides background on (1) USDA regulations updating various nutrition standards -in the child nutrition programs, (2) current and proposed alternatives to the “congregate feeding -requirement” in summer meals, and (3) recent changes and proposals aimed at addressing “lunch -shaming” and unpaid meal costs. - -Regulations on Nutrition Standards - -Since the enactment of the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296), -USDA-FNS has promulgated multiple regulations, formulated various program guidance, and -published many other policy documents and reports. Three of the major changes authorized by -the 2010 law relate to program nutrition standards: (1) requiring an update to the nutrition -standards for NSLP and SBP meals, (2) giving USDA the authority to regulate other foods sold in -schools (e.g., through vending machines and cafeterias’ a la carte lines) and requiring the agency -to issue related nutrition standards, and (3) requiring an update to the nutrition standards in -CACFP. The new nutrition standards were championed by First Lady Michelle Obama through -her “Let’s Move” initiative, among other groups.77 - -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast - -Section 201 of HHFKA (P.L. 111-296) established a timeframe for USDA to promulgate -regulations updating meal patterns and nutrition standards for school meal programs based on -recommendations from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) (now the Health and Medicine Division) -at the National Academy of Sciences.78 Schools meeting the new requirements are eligible for the -increased federal subsidies (6 cents per lunch) noted above. The law also provided funding for -technical assistance to help implement new meal patterns and nutrition standards. - -Ultimately, following a proposed rule, comments submitted, and policy provisions enacted in the -2012 appropriations law,79 USDA-FNS issued a final rule on January 26, 2012.80 The final rule -sought to align school meal patterns with the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and called -for increased availability of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat or fat-free milk in school -cafeterias—generally consistent with IOM’s recommendations. The regulations also included -calorie maximums (whereas prior guidelines had only calorie minimums) and sodium limits to -phase in over time, among other requirements.81 - -77 See, for example, Nia-Malika Henderson, “President Obama signs child nutrition bill, a priority for first lady,” -Washington Post, December 13, 2010, pp. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/13/ -AR2010121302407.html; archived White House website, “Let’s Move, Healthy Schools,” -https://letsmove.obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/healthy-schools. -78 The 2010 law added a deadline, but it was the 2004 reauthorization (P.L. 108-265) that required USDA to update the -standards based on National Academy of Sciences recommendations. IOM’s report, issued in 2010, had made a number -of recommendations around such topics as imposing calorie limits, increasing fruit and vegetables, and reducing -sodium intake. IOM, School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children, Washington, DC, 2010. -79 See Section 743 of P.L. 112-55. Also discussed in CRS Report R41964, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2012 -Appropriations, coordinated by Jim Monke. -80 For the final rule and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/nutrition- -standards-school-meals. -81 When originally issued, the rule and USDA-FNS policy also required certain weekly maximums on grains and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -28 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Although the rule was finalized in January 2012, all aspects of the rule were not to be -implemented immediately; for instance, some aspects of the new guidelines went into effect for -school year 2014-2015, even though the rule went into effect in school year 2012-2013.82 Three -aspects of the new regulations that went into effect in SY2014-2015 were: all grains served must -be whole-grain-rich,83 new fruit requirements for breakfast, and the first of three sodium limits or -“targets” for breakfasts and lunches (referred to as “Target 1”).84 - -As some schools have had difficulty implementing the new guidelines, Congress and the USDA -have implemented some changes or waivers regarding the 2012 final rule’s whole grain, sodium, -and milk requirements. FY2015, FY2016, and FY2017 appropriations laws (P.L. 113-235, P.L. -114-113, P.L. 115-31, respectively) included policies that affect the implementation of the -guidelines. As of the date of this report, schools are following policies set in an interim final rule -published November 30, 2017.85 - -Specifically, FY2015 and FY2016 appropriations laws (1) required USDA to allow states to -exempt school food authorities that meet hardship requirements from the 100% whole grain -requirement86 and (2) prevented USDA from implementing a reduction in sodium scheduled to -take effect in school year 2017-2018 until “the latest scientific research establishes the reduction -is beneficial for children.” The enacted FY2017 appropriation (§747 of P.L. 115-31) contained -related policy provisions. It extended the whole grain exemptions through SY2017-2018 and -(using different language from past years) limited enforcement of sodium limits to Target 1 -levels. In addition, a new appropriations provision was added in the FY2017 law that required -USDA to allow states to grant special exemptions to serve flavored, low-fat milk (instead of only -fat-free, flavored). - -In May 2017, shortly before the enactment of the FY2017 appropriations law (P.L. 115-31), -Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue announced plans to amend the whole grain, sodium, and -dairy aspects of the nutrition standards regulations in ways that were similar to the FY2017 law’s -provisions.87 In November 2017, USDA-FNS issued the interim final rule, which generally -extends through SY2018-2019 the three changes established by FY2017 appropriations. -Specifically, the interim final rule - -protein. School nutrition stakeholders expressed challenges with menu planning due to these particular restrictions, -USDA-FNS issued policy guidance that gave flexibility on these maximums for school years 2012-2013 and 2013- -2014. Then, in a subsequent regulation, USDA-FNS revised the regulations in January 2014 to lift these restrictions. -See, for example, USDA-FNS, “Certification of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch -Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. -82 See USDA-FNS Implementation Timeline, http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/implementation_timeline.pdf, -based on regulations. -83 “Whole grain-rich products must contain at least 51 percent whole grains and the remaining grains in the product -must be enriched.” 7 C.F.R. 210.10(c)(2)(iv). -84 The sodium targets set a maximum weekly level of sodium for breakfasts and lunches based on a student’s grade -level. Under Target 1, school lunches—on average over the school week—must contain ≤1,230 milligrams (mg) of -sodium for grades K-5, ≤1,360 mg for grades 6-8, and ≤1,420 mg for grades 9-12. -85 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, https://www.federalregister.gov/ -documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk-whole-grains-and-sodium- -requirements. -86 Exempted schools are to maintain a 50% whole grain minimum, the requirement before school year 2014-2015. -87 See CRS Insight IN10700, USDA Announces Plans to Modify School Meal Nutrition Standards: Background and -Context (available to congressional clients upon request). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -29 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - - - - - -continues to allow states to grant waivers to the whole grain-rich requirement; -allows schools to offer low-fat, flavored milk; and -continues Target 1 sodium limits, delaying implementation of Target 2 sodium -limits.88 - -The interim final rule indicated that USDA-FNS would publish a final rule in fall 2018, in time -for schools to implement in SY2019-2020. As of the date of this report, this final rule has not -been published. The FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141), enacted in March 2018, did not -make any changes to the standards. - -There were legislative proposals to change the nutrition standards on a more-permanent basis -during 114th Congress deliberations to reauthorize the child nutrition programs.89 As discussed -earlier, reauthorization was not completed in the 114th Congress and authorizing committees have -not considered such legislative proposals in the 115th Congress. - -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools - -In another major policy change, Section 208 of HHFKA gave USDA the authority to regulate -other foods in the school nutrition environment. Sometimes called “competitive foods,” this and -the related regulation pertain to foods and drinks sold in a la carte lines, vending machines, snack -bars and concession stands, and fundraisers. - -Relying on recommendations made by a 2007 IOM report,90 USDA-FNS promulgated a proposed -rule and then an interim final rule in June 2013, which went into effect for school year 2014- -2015.91 The interim final rule imposed nutrition guidelines for all non-meal foods and beverages -that are sold during the school day (defined as midnight until 30 minutes after dismissal). The -final rule, published on July 29, 2016, maintained the interim final rules with minor -modifications. Under the final standards, these foods must meet whole-grain requirements; have -certain primary ingredients; and meet calorie, sodium, and fat limits, among other requirements. -Schools are limited to a list of no- and low-calorie beverages they may sell (with larger portion -sizes and caffeine allowed in high schools). - -Regarding fundraisers, there are no limits on fundraisers of foods that meet the interim final rule’s -guidelines. Fundraisers outside of the school day are not subject to the guidelines. HHFKA and -the interim final rule provide states with discretion to exempt infrequent fundraisers of foods or -beverages that do not meet the nutrition standards. - -The rule does not limit foods brought from home, only foods sold at school during the school day. -The federal standards included are a minimum standard; states and school districts are permitted -to issue more stringent policies. - -88 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, available at -https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk- -whole-grains-and-sodium-requirements. -89 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. -90 IOM, Nutrition Standards for Foods in Schools: Leading the Way toward Healthier Youth, 2007, -https://www.nap.edu/catalog/11899/nutrition-standards-for-foods-in-schools-leading-the-way-toward. -91 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Nutrition -Standards for All Foods Sold in School as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule,” 81 -Federal Register 50131, July 29, 2016. Final rule and related resources available at USDA-FNS website at -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/tools-schools-focusing-smart-snacks. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -30 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP - -Similarly, Section 221 of HHFKA required USDA to update the meal pattern for CACFP. USDA- -FNS’s proposed rule, published January 15, 2015, relied upon an IOM panel’s recommendations -and the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.92 FNS reviewed comments and incorporated -feedback in the final rule, which was published on April 25, 2016.93 The updated meal patterns -went into effect on October 1, 2017. The rule changes both the infant meal pattern and child/adult -meal pattern in CACFP. It also revises the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and School -Breakfast Program (SBP) meal patterns for pre-kindergarten children (such changes were not -included in the January 2012 final regulation discussed earlier). - -Below are some examples of changes included in the final rule:94 - - For infant meals, changes include condensing the previously three infant age - - - -groups into two age groups, introducing solid foods at six months of age (unless -otherwise requested by a parent or guardian), providing fruits and vegetables for -older infants, and eliminating juice. The updated guidelines make policy changes -to support breastfeeding, including providing program reimbursements when -mothers come to child care centers or homes to breastfeed their infants. -In child and adult meals, changes include separate fruit and vegetable serving -requirements, as opposed to treating fruits and vegetables as one group, and -limiting juice to one serving per day. The rule also requires that at least one daily -serving of grains be whole-grain rich and limits the sugar in breakfast cereals and -yogurts served. Milk must be low-fat or fat-free, and flavored milk cannot be -served to children age five or younger. The updated standards also disallow -frying as an onsite preparation method. - - “Best practices” for the different age groups were included in the rule, not as -requirements for reimbursement but as examples of ideal policies to promote -good nutrition and health. Examples include the “best practice” that a center or -home provides mothers with a quiet, private area to breastfeed and the -recommendation to limit sugar in flavored milk served to children age six and -older. USDA-FNS subsequently elaborated on the best practices through policy -guidance.95 - -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals -In recent years, but particularly during the 114th Congress, policymakers have weighed policy -options to reach more children in the summer months using alternatives to congregate meal -service. - -92 Ibid. at 2037. IOM (Institute of Medicine), Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary Guidance for All. -Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2011. -93 USDA-FNS also notes that it thoroughly reviewed the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines, and determined that the final -rule, based on the 2010 guidelines, is consistent with the updated guidelines. USDA-FNS, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Meal Pattern Revisions Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule” 81 Federal -Register 24348 et seq., April 25, 2016, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/04/25/2016-09412/child-and- -adult-care-food-program-meal-pattern-revisions-related-to-the-healthy-hunger-free-kids-act. -94 Ibid. For summaries of updated meal patterns and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/meals-and-snacks. -95 USDA-FNS, “Optional Best Practices to Further Improve Nutrition in the Child and Adult Care Food Program Meal -Pattern,” June 30, 2016, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cacfp/CACFP15-2016os.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -31 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Current Law and Policy - -Under current law, most food offered in summer months is provided in congregate settings -through the SFSP or the NSLP’s Seamless Summer Option (SSO, an option only for schools) (see -“Summer Meals” section above). “Congregate” settings refer to specific sites where children -come to eat while supervised. Also, for the most part, non-school organizations that provide -summer and afterschool food need to participate in two separate programs (SFSP and CACFP At- -risk Afterschool). - -As discussed earlier, on a pilot basis in a limited geographic area each summer since 2011, USDA -has tested alternatives to SFSP and the SSO as required by law. Specifically, the 2010 Agriculture -Appropriations Act (Section 749(g) of P.L. 111-80) provided $85 million in discretionary funding -for “demonstration projects to develop and test methods of providing access to food for children -in urban and rural areas during the summer months.” The first of those demonstrations was called -the Enhanced Summer Food Service Program (eSFSP), which took place in the summers of 2010 -and 2012. eSFSP included four initiatives: (1) incentives for SFSP sites to lengthen operations to -40 or more days, (2) funding to add recreational or educational activities at meal sites, (3) meal -delivery for children in rural areas, and (4) “food backpacks” that children could take home on -weekends and holidays. - -Evaluations of eSFSP were published from 2011 to 2014.96 Participation rates rose during the -demonstration periods for all four initiatives. In addition, children in the meal delivery and -backpack demonstrations had consistent rates of food insecurity from summer to fall (this was not -measured for the other initiatives). However, the results of the evaluation should be interpreted -with caution due to a small sample size and potential confounding factors. - -As discussed earlier, the second demonstration, Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children -(SEBTC or Summer EBT), began in summer 2011 and is ongoing as of the date of this report; -this program provides SNAP or WIC benefits over EBT to households with children eligible for -free or reduced-price school meals. Most recently, FY2018 appropriations (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million for the demonstration. Evaluations of Summer EBT were conducted over a -three-year period from FY2011 to FY2013.97 The evaluations, which used rigorous designs, -showed a significant decline in Very Low Food Security in children (VLFS-C);98 the prevalence -of VLFS-C was reduced from 9.5% in the control group to 6.4% in the Summer EBT treatment -group.99 Evaluations also found improvements in children’s consumption of fruits, vegetables, - -96 Elinson et al., Evaluation of 2011 Enhanced Summer Food Service Program Demonstrations, prepared by Westat -under Contract No. GS-23F-8144H (Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2012), p. 4-21. -97 The first year, the proof-of-concept (POC) year, was evaluated to test the feasibility of the EBT delivery system and -prepare for full-implementation in demonstration sites for the following year. The second year, the full implementation -year, evaluated the impact of SEBTC on improving children’s food security and nutritional status in the summer time. -Finally, the third year compared the impact of two benefit levels, $60 and $30, to determine the effect of different -benefit levels on improving food security and nutritional status. Final reports and status reports to Congress are -available on the USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/summer-electronic-benefit-transfer-children-sebtc. -98 Very Low Food Security is the lowest of four levels of food security; USDA defines it as “At times during the year, -eating patterns of one or more household members were disrupted and food intake reduced because the household -lacked money and other resources for food.” USDA-ERS website, http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition- -assistance/food-security-in-the-us/measurement.aspx. See also CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: -Summary of Programs. -99 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus. Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013, p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -32 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -and whole grains. Both WIC and SNAP models showed increased consumption, but increases -were greater at sites operating the WIC model.100 - -In the summers from 2015 to 2018, USDA-FNS also offered non-congregate feeding options at -outdoor summer meal sites experiencing excessive heat.101 This demonstration has not been -evaluated. - -Congressional Proposals - -During the 114th Congress, committees of jurisdiction marked up child nutrition reauthorization -bills. Both committees of jurisdiction—the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and -Forestry and the House Committee on Education and the Workforce—reported reauthorization -legislation: S. 3136 and H.R. 5003, respectively. Both proposals would have piloted or expanded -a number of alternatives for feeding low-income children during the summer months. Still, there -were significant differences between the reauthorization proposals’ SFSP provisions.102 (There -were also committee hearings and freestanding proposals related to SFSP in the 114th -Congress.)103 - -The committees’ reauthorization bills included the following policies: - - Streamlining afterschool and summer programs. Both committees’ proposals -would have authorized eligible institutions in selected states to operate SFSP and -CACFP At-risk Afterschool sites under one application. The bills differed in the -number of states that would have been eligible and the reimbursement rates used. - - Summer EBT. Both proposals addressed the provision of benefits via EBT to -children who are eligible for free and reduced-price school meals over the -summer months. The Senate committee would have expanded this alternative -with mandatory funding. The House committee would have kept the existing -pilot funded with discretionary funding. The Senate committee would have -required states to provide WIC EBT, while the House committee would have -allowed participating states to provide SNAP or WIC. - - Off-Site Consumption Options. Both proposals included ways for some - -institutions (e.g., those located in rural areas) to provide SFSP meals for -consumption off-site. The bills also included temporary flexibilities for -congregate feeding sites to episodically provide meals to be consumed off-site -under certain conditions (e.g., extreme weather conditions). - - Other SFSP Policies. The Senate committee’s bill would have authorized - -discretionary funding for some states to pilot the provision of three meals per -day, or two meals and one snack. The House committee’s proposal would have - -100 Ibid., p. 124. -101 See USDA-FNS, “Demonstration Project for Non-Congregate Feeding for Outdoor Summer Meal Sites -Experiencing Excessive Heat with Q&As,” May 24, 2018, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/sfsp/ -SP14_SFSP04-2018os.pdf. -102 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview, for further legislative -background and a more detailed summary of summer meals and other program provisions. -103 During 114th Congress hearings, witnesses testified about SFSP and summer alternatives before the House -Committee on Education and the Workforce (April 15, 2015; June 16, 2015; June 24, 2015) and the Senate Committee -on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry (May 7, 2015). During the 114th Congress, introduced bills on summer meals -included S. 613/H.R. 1728, S. 1539/H.R. 2715, and S. 1966. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -33 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -authorized USDA to award competitive grants to improve SFSP service delivery -through business partnerships. - -These reauthorization bills have not been reintroduced in the 115th Congress; however, there have -been other legislative proposals in the 115th Congress to amend SFSP.104 - -Presidential Budget Proposals - -The Obama Administration’s FY2017 budget proposed a number of changes to SFSP. -Specifically, the administration proposed to expand Summer EBT nationwide, with a phase-in -over 10 years.105 The administration also requested $10 million for a new Summer Food Service -Non-Congregate Demonstration Project. - -The Trump Administration’s FY2018 and FY2019 budgets did not include any new SFSP -legislative proposals. The budgets requested continued funding for Summer EBT. - -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” - -The issue of stigmatizing a child who owes and does not pay his or her meal costs, commonly -referred to as “lunch shaming,” has received increased attention in recent years.106 Some practices -that school districts have adopted in response to such situations include taking or throwing away a -student’s selected hot foods and providing an alternative cold meal (more common) to stamping -students’ arms and making them wear stickers (less common).107 One reason why these instances -may occur is that payments for reduced-price and full-price meals are a source of revenue for -school food programs (in addition to federal NSLP and SBP reimbursements). Schools have an -interest in collecting this revenue from children’s families to help fund operations.108 - -Some have pointed out that the Community Eligibility Provision (discussed earlier in this report) -is a strategy to prevent unpaid meal charges by providing free meals to all children in qualifying -schools.109 - -Congress and USDA have taken some recent actions to address the issues of lunch shaming and -unpaid meal costs. Section 143 of the HHFKA of 2010 required USDA to examine states’ and - -104 See, for example, the Summer Meals Act of 2017 (H.R. 203) and legislation “To amend the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act to establish a permanent, nationwide summer electronic benefits transfer for children -program” (H.R. 6516S. 3268). -105 Details about the Obama Administration’s Nationwide Summer EBT proposal are available in the FY2017 budget -USDA-FNS Explanatory Notes on p. 32-34, http://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2017notes.pdf. -106 There is no official definition of “lunch shaming.” Legislation in the 115th Congress, the Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017 (H.R. 2401/S. 1064), refers to lunch shaming as “the stigmatization of children who are unable to pay for -meals.” -107 Typically, an alternative meal includes unflavored milk, a cheese or peanut butter-and-jelly sandwich, and a fruit or -vegetable. May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and -Practices for School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12. Prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10- -0048. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014, p. 147-148. -108 If they are unable to recover these funds, the money becomes “bad debt” and the school or school district must use -other non-federal funding sources to cover the costs (7 C.F.R. 200.426). See p. 2 of USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, -“Unpaid Meal Charges: Clarification on Collection of Delinquent Meal Payments,” July 8, 2016, at https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP47-2016os.pdf. -109 See, for example, James Weill, “How to stop school lunch shaming? Leave kids out of it,” The Hill, at -http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/education/333003-how-to-stop-school-lunch-shaming-leave-kids-out-of-it; U.S. -Department of Agriculture, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate -Meals, June 2016, at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -34 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -school districts’ policies and practices regarding unpaid meal charges. As part of the review, the -law required USDA to “prepare a report on the feasibility of establishing national standards for -meal charges and the provision of alternate meals” and, if relevant, make recommendations -related to the implementation of the standards. Section 143 also permitted USDA to take follow- -up actions based on the findings from the report.110 - -USDA’s subsequent June 2016 Report to Congress did not recommend national standards, but -rather recommended “clarifying and updating policy guidance on specific national policies -impacting unpaid meal charges and facilitating the development and distribution of best practices -to support decision making by States and localities.”111 USDA-FNS followed up with a -memorandum requiring school food authorities (SFAs) to institute and communicate—by July 1, -2017—a written meal charge policy, which was to include instructions on how to address -situations in which a child does not pay for a meal.112 USDA-FNS also provided clarification -through webinars, other memoranda, and a best practice guide.113 - -USDA stated that its recommendation was based on findings from a national study of HHFKA -implementation and a Request for Information (RFI) related to unpaid meal charges that garnered -462 responses. The study, conducted in SY2011-2012, found that 58% of SFAs reported incurring -unpaid meal charges prior to recovery attempts.114 Of these SFAs, 50.4% served a reimbursable -meal to children unable to pay, 38.0% served an alternative meal, 5.4% combined these -approaches, 4.9% did something else (“Other”), and 1.3% did not serve a meal. Both the findings -from the study and the RFI showed that meal charge policies were largely determined at the -school- and district-level rather than the state level.115 The responses to the RFI also indicated that -such policies ranged in formality, with varying degrees of review (e.g., some required school -board approval while others did not) and enforcement. In the RFI comments, school and district -officials generally expressed a preference for local control in designing meal charge policies -while advocates generally favored national standards. - -The topics of lunch shaming and unpaid meal costs have since surfaced in the 115th Congress. As -examples of congressional activity on this issue, proposed legislation (Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017; H.R. 2401/S. 1064) would establish national standards for how schools treat children -unable to pay for a meal.116 - -110 Specifically, Section 143 of HHFKA authorizes USDA to (1) implement standards;, (2) implement demonstration -projects, or (3) further study the feasibility of the recommendations. -111 USDA, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate Meals, June -2016, p. 5, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. -112 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges: Local Meal Charge Policies,” July 8, 2016, https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP46-2016os.pdf. -113 For a list of resources, see USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges,” https://www.fns.usda.gov/ -school-meals/unpaid-meal-charges. -114 May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and Practices for -School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12, prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10-0048 -(Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014), p. 147-148, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/SNOPSYear1.pdf. -115 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Request for Information: Unpaid Meal Charges,” 79 Federal Register 62095, -October 16, 2014. -116 Specifically, the legislation would prohibit SFAs from (1) publicly identifying children who cannot pay for a meal -or those who have meal debt, (2) having those children perform chores or other activities, and (3) throwing away a -child’s meal. See Section 2 of H.R. 2401 and S. 1064 (identical text). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -35 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In addition, a provision in the FY2018 appropriations law (Section 768 of P.L. 115-141) -established that appropriated funds cannot be used in a way that results in discrimination against -children eligible for free or reduced-price meals, including the practices of segregating children -and overtly identifying children by special tokens or tickets.117 - -117 See Section 9(b)(10) of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(10)) and 7 C.F.R. -245.8. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -36 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report - -Table A-1. Acronyms - -Government Agencies - -USDA - -U.S. Department of Agriculture - -USDA-FNS - -Food and Nutrition Service - -CACFP - -FFVP - -NSLP - -SBP - -SEBTC - -SFSP - -SMP - -CEP - -CPI-U - -FPL - -Programs - -Child and Adult Care Food Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program - -National School Lunch Program - -School Breakfast Program - -Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children - -Summer Food Service Program - -Special Milk Program - -Miscellaneous - -Community Eligibility Provision - -Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers - -Federal Poverty Level - -HHFKA - -Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-296) - -IOM - -LEA - -RCCI - -SFA - -Institute of Medicine - -Local Educational Agency - -Residential Child Care Institution - -School Food Authority - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -37 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement -Rates for Child Nutrition Programs118 -This appendix lists the specific reimbursement rates discussed in the earlier sections of the report. -Reimbursement rates are adjusted for inflation for each school or calendar year according to -terms laid out in the programs’ authorizing laws. Each year, the new rates are announced in the -Federal Register.119 - -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches -Per-meal reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Serve Less than 60% of -Lunches as Free and -Reduced-Price - -Serve 60% or More of -Lunches as Free or -Reduced-Price - -Bonus Available for -School Districts -Certified as Compliant -with Nutrition -Guidelines - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$3.33 - -$2.93 - -$0.33 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Source: USDA-FNS, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018-15465/national-school-lunch- -special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum. For NSLP reimbursement rates -for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -Note: For school year 2018-2019, the maximum rate for 48 states and DC is $3.48 per free meal, $3.08 per -reduced-price meal, and $0.30 per paid meal (and an additional $0.06 for nutrition guidelines). The maximum -rate is the maximum per-lunch rate that a state can provide a school food authority. - -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks -Per-snack reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Snack Type - -Reimbursement - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For after-school snack NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or -participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -118 All reimbursement rate tables in this Appendix display rates for the 48 continental U.S. states. For Alaska, Hawaii, -and territories where applicable, please see the source USDA-FNS Federal Register notice. -119 For more detail on how inflation adjustment is conducted, see the child nutrition program sections of CRS Report -R42000, Inflation-Indexing Elements in Federal Entitlement Programs, coordinated by Dawn Nuschler. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -38 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP -Per-meal reimbursement for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Non-severe Need -(less than 40% free or -reduced price)a - -Severe Need -(greater than or equal to 40% -free or reduced price)a - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -$2.14 - -$1.84 - -$0.31 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating -territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -a. Generally, severe need status is determined based on the percentage of meals served two school years -prior to the year the currently reimbursed meal is served. For example, a school district’s severe need -status in school year 2018-2019 would be calculated based on meals served in school year 2016-2017. - -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) -Rate per-meal for school year 2018-2019 - -For Each NSLP/CACFP Meal Served - -Commodity Food Reimbursement - -$0.2350 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Food Distribution Program: Value of Donated Foods From July 1, -2018, Through June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 35607, July 1, 2018. -Notes: For past years, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/value-donated-foods-notices. SFSP -has a different commodity food assistance rate, see Table B-7. - -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School -Programs -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -Snack - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Notes: These reimbursement rates are identical to NSLP and SBP rates. - -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Tier I - -Tier II - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -$2.46 - -$1.48 - -$1.31 - -$0.48 - -Snack - -$0.73 - -$0.20 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Note: CACFP also provides administrative reimbursements to sponsoring organizations of day care homes. -Based on the number of homes sponsored, funding is provided per home, per month. These rates are not - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -39 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -displayed in this table but are included in USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: National Average Payment Rates, Day Care Home Food Service Payment Rates, and Administrative -Reimbursement Rates for Sponsoring Organizations of Day Care Homes for the Period July 1, 2018 Through -June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 34108, July 1, 2018. - -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 states and DC (rounded to nearest cent), calendar year 2018 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Snack - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -$3.55 - -$3.55 - -$2.03 - -$2.03 - -$0.83 - -$0.83 - -$0.37 - -$0.31 - -$0.20 - -$0.16 - -$0.10 - -$0.08 - -$3.92 - -$3.86 - -$2.23 - -$2.19 - -$0.93 - -$0.91 - -Operating -Component - -Administrative -Component - -Combined (Total) -Rate - -Source: For program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, “Summer Food Service Program; 2018 Reimbursement Rates,” 83 Federal Register 4025, -January 29, 2018. -Note: Per authorizing law, the administrative component is calculated to the nearest quarter-cent. This table -rounds to the nearest cent. As the table shows, the administrative component varies slightly (e.g., by about 5 -cents for lunches) depending on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared -on-site or by a vendor. For meals prepared on-site, providers receive 1.5 cents per meal in USDA commodity -foods. - -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP -Per half-pint reimbursement for 48 States and DC (rounded to nearest cent), school year 2018-2019 - -All Milk Served - -Paid Milk - -Free Milk to Low- -Income Children - -Schools that only -sell milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Schools that sell -and provide free -milk - -Schools that -provide only free -milk - -Not applicable - -$0.21 - -Average cost per -half-pint of milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Source: For program reimbursement rates, see https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -40 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Author Information - -Kara Clifford Billings -Analyst in Social Policy - - Randy Alison Aussenberg - -Specialist in Nutrition Assistance Policy - -Acknowledgments - -Disclaimer - -This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan -shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and -under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other -than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in -connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not -subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in -its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or -material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to -copy or otherwise use copyrighted material. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -41 - +| | | When | Can | LLMs | Actually | | Correct | | Their | Own | Mistakes? | | | +| --- | --- | --------- | -------------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | A | Critical | Survey | | of Self-Correction | | | of | LLMs | | | +| | | RyoKamoi1 | | YusenZhang1 | | | NanZhang1 | | JiaweiHan2 | | | RuiZhang1 | | +| | | | 1PennStateUniversity | | | 2UniversityofIllinoisUrbana-Champaign | | | | | | | | +{ryokamoi,rmz5227}@psu.edu +| | | | Abstract | | | | | ingthefeedback(Huangetal.,2024a),underthe | | | | | | +| --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | hypothesis | that | recognizing | | errors is easier | than | +| | Self-correction | | is an | approach | to improv- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | avoidingthem(Saundersetal.,2022). | | | | | AsinFig- | +| | ing | responses | from | large | language | mod- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ure1, | self-correctionhasalsobeenstudiedusing | | | | | +| | els | (LLMs) | by refining | the | responses | us- | | | | | | | | +additionalinformationforimprovingfeedback,in- +| 4202 ceD 3 ]LC.sc[ 3v79210.6042:viXra | ing | LLMs | during | inference. | Prior | work | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | -------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | cluding | external | tools | such | as code interpreters | | +hasproposedvariousself-correctionframe- +works using different sources of feedback, (Chen et al., 2024e; Gou et al., 2024), external +includingself-evaluationandexternalfeed- knowledge retrieved via web search (Gao et al., +back. However, there is still no consensus 2023;Jiangetal.,2023b),orfine-tuning(Welleck +onthequestionofwhenLLMscancorrect +| | | | | | | | | etal.,2023;Yeetal.,2023). | | | | However,recentstud- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +their own mistakes, as recent studies also iesalsoreportnegativeresultsindicatingthatLLMs +| | report | negative | results. | In | this work, | we | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cannotself-correct(Huangetal.,2024a;Gouetal., +| | critically | survey | broad | papers | and | discuss | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2024;Lietal.,2024b;Chenetal.,2024f)oreven +| | the | conditions | required | for | successful | self- | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +correction. We first find that prior studies self-detect(ChenandShu,2024;Tyenetal.,2024; +Hongetal.,2024;Jiangetal.,2024;Kamoietal., +oftendonotdefinetheirresearchquestions +indetailandinvolveimpracticalframeworks 2024)theirownmistakesatleastincertaincondi- +orunfairevaluationsthatover-evaluateself- +| | | | | | | | | tions. | Theseconflictingobservationsindicatethat | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +correction. Totackletheseissues,wecate- furtheranalysisofself-correctionisneeded. +gorizeresearchquestionsinself-correction +Inthiswork,weprovideacriticalsurveytoin- +researchandprovideachecklistfordesign- +vestigatetheconditionsrequiredforsuccessfulself- +| | ing | appropriate | experiments. | | Our | critical | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +survey based on the newly categorized re- correction. First,ouranalysisfindsthatpriorstud- +searchquestionsshowsthat(1)nopriorwork iesoftendonotdefinetheirresearchquestionsin +demonstratessuccessfulself-correctionwith +| | | | | | | | | detail. | Asaresult,manypapersfailtoprovideap- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +feedbackfrompromptedLLMs,exceptfor propriateexperimentstoevaluatetheresearchques- +studiesintasksthatareexceptionallysuited +| | | | | | | | | tionstheyimplicitlytarget. | | | | Toaddressthisissue, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +forself-correction,(2)self-correctionworks +wecategorizeresearchquestionsinself-correction +| | well | in tasks | that can | use | reliable external | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +research(§3.1)anddiscussframeworksthatshould +feedback,and(3)large-scalefine-tuningen- +ablesself-correction. beusedforverifyingeachresearchquestion(§3.2). +Finally,weprovideachecklistfordesigningappro- +priateexperiments(§8). +1 Introduction +| | | | | | | | | Next, | we analyze | | prior | work to identify | when | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ---- | +Self-correction is a popular approach to improve LLMs can self-correct their mistakes, using the +responsesfromlargelanguagemodels(LLMs)by newdefinitionsoftheresearchquestions. Ouranal- +refining them using LLMs during inference (Bai ysis highlights that the bottleneck is in the feed- +etal.,2022;Madaanetal.,2023). Extensivestudies back generation (§7). Specifically, (1) no prior +onself-correctionhavebeenconductedinvarious work shows successful self-correction with feed- +tasks,includingarithmeticreasoning,codegener- back from prompted LLMs in general tasks (§4), +ation, and question answering (Gao et al., 2023; (2)self-correctionworkswellintaskswherereli- +Shinnetal.,2023). Thesimplestapproachofself- ableexternalfeedbackisavailable(§5.1),(3)large- +correctionpromptsLLMstoprovidefeedbackon scalefine-tuningenablesself-correction(§5.2),and +their own responses and refine the responses us- (4)sometaskshavepropertiesexceptionallysuit- + +Prompt the Same Model (§4) provides studies related to self-correction. Sec- +Input Few-Shot Decompose Responses +tion11providesfuturedirections. +LLM External Feedback (§5.1) +Code Interpreters Web Search +Timeframe. This survey was originally pub- +Response +lishedinJune2024andprimarilyincludesresearch +Refinement Feedback Fine-tuning (§5.2) +Model Model Human Feedback Reinforcement Learning papers and studies published up to and including +Feedback May2024. Whilepaperspublishedafterthisdate +arenotcomprehensivelyanalyzed,theyarebriefly +Figure 1: Self-correction in three stages: initial +discussedinSection12. +responsegeneration,feedback,andrefinement. +2 Self-CorrectionofLLMs +ableforself-correction(§4). Insummary,ouranal- +Theterm“self-correction”isusedinawiderange +ysisidentifiesthepropertiesrequiredforsuccessful +ofscenarios,fromastrictdefinitioninwhichLLMs +self-correctionasfollows: +refinetheirownresponsesbythemselves(Madaan +[RQ1]WhencanLLMsself-correctbasedsolely et al., 2023; Huang et al., 2024a) to broader con- +ontheinherentcapabilitiesofLLMs? cepts that also involve feedback from external +toolsorknowledge(Shinnetal.,2023;Gouetal., +• In general tasks, no prior work shows reliable +2024). Inthiswork,wedefineself-correctionasa +evidence of successful self-correction with in- +framework that refines responses from LLMs us- +contextlearning. (§4) +ingLLMsduringinference,possiblywithexternal +• In tasks with specific properties that are excep- +tools or knowledge. As in Table 1, Figure 2, and +tionally favorable for self-correction (e.g., re- +Figure3,self-correctionhasbeenstudiedinvarious +sponsesaredecomposable),self-correctionisef- +frameworkswithdifferentsourcesoffeedback. +fectiveevenwithin-contextlearning. (§4) +[RQ2] When can LLMs self-correct the best- 2.1 Frameworks +possible initial responses with external informa- Prior studies propose self-correction frameworks +tion? withvariousdifferentarchitectures. +• Self-correctioniseffectiveintaskswherereliable +ExplicitFeedbackvs. DirectRefinement. Self- +externalfeedbackisavailable. (§5.1) +correctionoftenconsistsofthreestagesincluding +• Fine-tuning enables self-correction when large +feedback generation (Kim et al., 2023; Madaan +training data is available but is unexplored for +etal.,2023;Shinnetal.,2023;Huangetal.,2024a): +smalltrainingdata. (§5.2) +• InitialResponseGenerationisastageofgener- +[RQ3]Whenarethefinaloutputsofself-correction +atinginitialresponsesfromanLLM. +betterthanotherapproaches? +• Feedback model generates feedback given the +• Self-correction is often not compared with suf- +original input and initial response. This stage +ficiently strong baselines, and it is still unclear +mayuseexternaltoolsorknowledge. +whetheritisbetterthanotherapproaches. (§6) +• Refinementmodelgeneratesarefinedresponse, +This survey is organized as follows. Section 2 giventheinput,initialresponse,andfeedback. +providesanoverviewofself-correction. Section3 +Directrefinementisanotherapproachthatrefines +introduces a new approach to classify research +responses without generating feedback explicitly +questions and frameworks in self-correction re- +(Saunders et al., 2022; Bai et al., 2022; Welleck +search. Sections 4 and 5 analyze prior work in +etal.,2023;Akyureketal.,2023). +self-correctionwithin-contextlearningandexter- +nalinformation(externaltools,externalknowledge, Post-hoc vs. Generation-time. Post-hoc cor- +fine-tuning), respectively. Section 6 explains re- rectionrefines responsesafter they aregenerated +lated approaches that should be compared with (Pan et al., 2024). Generation-time correction or +self-correctionasbaselines. Section7summarizes step-levelcorrection(Pauletal.,2024;Jiangetal., +ourfindingsfromtheanalysis. Section8providesa 2023b)improvesstep-by-stepreasoningbyprovid- +checklistforself-correctionresearch. Section9ex- ingfeedbackonintermediatereasoningsteps. Post- +plainsdifferencesfromothersurveys. Section10 hoc correction is more flexible and applicable to + +| | | | | AdditionalFeedback | | | | MainTasks | | | +| ----- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Paper | Category | MainModels | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Reasoning, | Closed-book, | Open-book, | Open-ended | Decom- | +| | | | Oracle | ExternalTools | Fine-Tuning | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Coding | Knowledge | Context-based | TextGen | posable | +Self-CorrectionwithIn-contextLearning(IntrinsicSelf-Correction) +| CoVe | Intrinsic | PaLM540B | | – – | | – – | – | – | – | Multiple | +| ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +| (2024) | | | | | | | | | | Answers | +CA I R e v i sions +( 20 2 2 ) ♠ Intrinsic 52B(nodetails) – – – – – – Detoxification – +S e l f- R e fi ne Intrinsic GPT-3.5,GPT-4 – – – M a t h , – Dialogue – – +| ( 2 0 2 3 ) ♠ | | | | | | C od i n g | | | | | +| ------------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --- | +| RCI | | | | ✓ | | Computer | | | | | +| | Oracle | GPT-3.5-T | | – | | – | CSQA | – | – | – | +| (2023,§3.1) | | | | | | Tasks | | | | | +| Reflexion | Oracle | GPT-4 | | ✓ – | | – – | – | HotpotQA | – | – | +| (2023,§4.2) | | | | | | | | (GTContext) | | | +Self-CorrectionwithExternalToolsorKnowledge +| Reflexion | Fair-Asym. | GPT-4 | | – GameEnvs, | | – Games, | – | – | – | – | +| --------------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| (2023,§4.1,4.3) | | | | Interpreter | | Coding | | | | | +| Self-Debug | | | | Code | | | | | | | +| | Fair-Asym. | GPT-3.5-T,GPT-4 | | – | | – Text-to-Code | – | – | – | – | +| (2024e) | | | | Interpreter | | | | | | | +CRITIC Fair-Asym. GPT-3, – Interpreter, – GSM8k, HotpotQA – Detoxification – +| (2024) | | Llama270B | | WebSearch | | SVAMP | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| RARR | Unfair- | | | | | | NQ,SQA, | | | | +| | | Palm540B | | – WebSearch | | – – | | – | – | – | +| (2023) | Asym. | | | | | | QReCC | | | | +| Reflexion | Oracle | GPT-4 | | ✓ WikipediaAPI | | – – | HotpotQA | – | – | – | +(2023,§4.2) +Self-CorrectionwithFine-tuning +| Self-Critique | | | | | Human | | | Topic-based | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | +(2022) Fair-Asym. InstructGPT – – Assessment – – Summarization – – +SelFee Fair-Asym. Llama7B,13B – – ChatGPT MT-Bench MT-Bench MT-Bench MT-Bench – +| (2023) | | | | | Assessment | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Baldur | | | | | | Proof | | | | | +| | Fair-Asym. | Minerva8B,62B | | – ProofAssistant | GTAnswer | | – | – | – | – | +| (2023) | | | | | | Generation | | | | | +REFINER Cross- GPT-3.5 – – SyntheticData Math,Logic – – MoralStories – +| (2024) | Model | (FB:T5-base) | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| RL4F | Cross- | GPT-3 | | | Reinforcement | Action | | Topic-based | | | +| | | | | – – | | | – | | – | – | +| (2023) | Model | (FB:T5-large) | | | Learning | Planning | | Summarization | | | +Self-Correction Cross- GPT-3 – – GTAnswer, GSM8k, – – Detoxification – +| (2023,§3.4) | Model | (FB:GPT-Neo) | | | External | SVAMP | | | | | +| ----------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Self-Correction Unfair- GPT-Neo1.3B, GTAnswer, GSM8k, Detoxification, +| | | | | – – | | | – | – | | – | +| --------------- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +| (2023,§3.1-3.3) | Asym. | GPT-2 | | | External | SVAMP | | | ConstGen | | +NegativeResultsofSelf-Correction(i.e.,LLMscannotSelf-Correct) +| RCI(Table17) | | | | | | Computer | | | | | +| ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Intrinsic | GPT-3.5-T | | – – | | – | CSQA | – | – | – | +| (2023) | | | | | | Tasks | | | | | +CRITICw/oTool Intrinsic GPT-3, – – – GSM8k, Closed-book – Detoxification – +| (2024) | | Llama270B | | | | SVAMP | HotpotQA | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Huangetal. | | GPT-4-T, | | | | | CSQA, | | | | +| | Intrinsic | | | – – | | – GSM8k | | – | – | – | +| (2024a) | | GPT-3.5-T | | | | | HotpotQA | | | | +Table 1: Representative studies in self-correction of LLMs. Graycolor represents unrealistic settings. +♠:Weakpromptsforgeneratinginitialresponses. +FB:Feedbackmodelsforcross-modelcorrection. +2.2 SourcesofFeedback +broadertasks,althoughgeneration-timecorrection +ispopularforreasoningtasks(Panetal.,2024). +| | | | | | | Intrinsic(§4). | | Intrinsicself-correctionprompts | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | +LLMstogeneratefeedbackontheirownresponses. +Same-modelvs. Cross-model. Cross-modelcor- Prompting strategies include simple zero-shot or +rectiongeneratesfeedbackorrefinestheresponses few-shotprompts(Madaanetal.,2023;Kimetal., +usingmodelsdifferentfromthemodelthatgener- +| | | | | | | 2023), | decomposing | the responses | (Dhuliawala | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | +atesinitialresponses. Cross-modelcorrectionhas etal.,2024),andevaluatingconfidence(Varshney +been mostly studied in the settings of correcting etal.,2023;Jiangetal.,2023b;Wuetal.,2024). +| mistakes | of large | proprietary | LLMs | using | small | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fine-tunedmodels(Wellecketal.,2023;Akyurek ExternalInformation(§5.1). Self-correctionof- +etal.,2023;Pauletal.,2024)ormulti-agentdebate ten relies on external information, including ex- +ofmultiplemodelswithsimilarcapabilities(Liang ternal tools such as code executors (Jiang et al., +etal.,2024;Lietal.,2023;Cohenetal.,2023;Du 2023a;Gouetal.,2024;Chenetal.,2024e;Stengel- +etal.,2023;Zhangetal.,2024a;Chenetal.,2024b; Eskinetal.,2024),symbolicreasoners(Panetal., +Chanetal.,2024a;Wangetal.,2024a). 2023), proofassistant (First etal., 2023), ortask- + +| | Cross-Model Correction | | | | | | | Same-Model Self-Correction | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | +| | | | | | | | Realistic Self-Correction | | | | | Unrealistic Self-Correction | +| | | | | | Fair Self-Correction | | | | | Unfair Self-Correction | | | +Multi-Agent Debate +Intrinsic Self-Correction +| In - c o n t ex t | L L M | | | | | L L M | | L L M | | | | L L M O r ac l e | +| ------------------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | +Re s po nse S a m e m o d e l a n d Context Inf or m a t io n +L e a r n in g i n fo rm a ti o n f o r Re s po nse Re sp o nse Re s po nse +Section 4 R e f in e A n o th e r initial response Refine Feedback Refine Feedback Refine Feedback +| | M o d e l | M o d e l | | and self-correction | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +| | Feedback | | | | | Feedback | | Feedback | | | | Feedback | +Asymmetric Self-Correction +| | Smaller Models | | | | Fair-Assymnetric Self-Correction | | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | E x t e rn | a l | | | | | | | | | | +External Larger LLM F e e d b a c k LLM LLM Code Executor LLM Search Engine +| To o l s o r | R esponse | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------ | ----- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------------- | +| | | | | | Respon | se S e ar c h E n | g ine | Respon se | | Respon se | | P r e - tr a in e d | +K n o w l e d g e R e f in e S m a ll e r F in e- tu n e d Large L a n g u a g e Model +S e c t i o n 5 M o d e l M o d e l S m a ll e r Refine F eedbac k Refine F eedback Refine F eedback Kn o w l e d ge +| | Feedback | | | Improving | Feedback | D if fe r en | t | Feedback | | Feedback | o n ly fo r | | +| ----------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | -------------------- | -------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --------------------------- | +| | | Feedback Model | | initial response | | Queries | | | | | Self-Correction | | +| | | | | generation process | | | | Code Executor | | | | Fine-tuned on | +| | Larger LLM | | | | LLM | | | LLM | | LLM | | Self-Correction Dataset | +| Fine-tuning | | | | as much as possible | | | | | | | | (Smaller than Purple model) | +| | Response | | | | Response | Initial response | | Response | | Response | | | +Section 6 R e f in e S m a ll e r F in e - tu n e d Refine F eedback g e n e ra t io n i s Refine F eedback Refine F eedback F i n e - t u n i n g +M o d e l M o d e l S m a ll e r a ls o fin e - tu n e d o n ly f o r F i n e - t u n e d o n +F eedback Fee d b a c k M o del Feedba ck Feedba ck Feedbac k Se l f -C o r r e c t ion S e lf -C o r r e c t i o n D a t a s e t +| | | | | | | | | | | | | (Same a rc h it e c t u r e a s P u r p le model) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------------- | +Figure2: LLMself-correctionframeworks,categorizedbyinformationusedforgeneratingfeedbackand +whethertheyusebest-possibleinitialresponses(§3.2). Thisfigureillustratesrepresentativearchitectures. +Oracle +| | | | | Information | | Unrealistic | OracleInformation | | | | RCI(2023),Reflextion(2023,§4.2) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | +| | | | | NoExternal | | | DecomposableTasks | | | | CoVe(2024) | | +Intrinsic +| | | | | Information | | | | GeneralTasks | | CAIRevisions(2022),Self-Refine(2023) | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Fair | | SearchEngines | | | CRITIC(2024),FLARE(2023b) | | +| | | | In-Context | External | | | | | | | | | +Learning Knowledge SearchEngines RARR(2023),Verify-and-Edit(2023),Varshneyetal.(2023) +Unfair +| | | | | | | | | Wikipedia | | | ReFeed(2023) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +Self-Debug(2024e),CRITIC(2024), +| | | | | | | | CodeInterpreterorCompiler | | | Reflection(2023,§4.3),SelfEvolve(2023a) | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | +| | | | | External | | | LogicalReasoner | | | | Logic-LM(2023) | | +| | | | | Tools | | Fair | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | SimulationEnvironment | | | | Reflextion(2023,§4.1) | | +Same-Model +| | Correction | | | | | | TargetModelfor | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ProTeGi(2023),OPRO(2024) +PromptOptimization +| | | | | | | | SFT:HumanFeedback | | | | Self-Critique(2022) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +Fair +SFT:Feedbackfrom +| | | | | NoExternal | | | | LargerModels | | | SelFee(2023),Volcano(2024) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | +Information +| | | | | | | Unfair | WeakerFine-tuning | | | Self-CorrectiveLearning(2023,§3.1-3.3) | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | Fine-tuning | | | | forInitialResponses | | | | | | +Self-Correction CodeInterpreterorCompiler Self-Edit(2023a,SFT,PyCodeGPT) +| | | | | External | | Fair | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | -------------- | ---------------------------------- | --------------------- | ---------------- | --- | +| | | | | Tools | | | | ProofAssistant | | | Baldur(2023,SFT) | | +| | | | | | | SFT:SyntheticData | | | | REFINER(2024) | | | +| | | | | NoExternal | | SFT:Self-GeneratedData | | | Self-CorrectiveLearning(2023,§3.4) | | | | +| | | | | Information | | SFT:TaskSpecificCriteria | | | | Re3(2022b,entailment) | | | +Fine-tuned +| | | SmallerModels | | | | ReinforcementLearning | | | | RL4F(2023) | | | +| --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | +| | Cross-Model | | | External | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | Tools | | CodeInterpreterorCompiler | | | CodeRL(2022,RL),Self-Edit(2023a,SFT,GPT-3) | | | | +Correction +| | | Multi-Agent | | NoExternal | | MAD(2024),LMvsLM(2023),PRD(2023) | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | Discussion | Information | | | | | | | | | +Figure3: TaxonomyofLLMself-correction,categorizedbyinformationusedforgeneratingfeedbackand +whethertheyusebest-possibleinitialresponses(fairorunfair). RefertoSection3.2forthedefinitions. +specificmetrics(Xuetal.,2023),externalknowl- etal.,2023;Yeetal.,2023;Firstetal.,2023;Paul +edgefromsearchengines(Jiangetal.,2023b;Gao etal.,2024;Hanetal.,2024;Havrillaetal.,2024) +etal.,2023;Zhaoetal.,2023),Wikipedia(Yuetal., orreinforcementlearning(Leetal.,2022;Akyurek +| 2023; Zhao | et | al., 2023), | or | other | corpora | (Peng | etal.,2023). | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +etal.,2023;Zhaoetal.,2023),oracleinformation +| such as | ground-truth | | answers | (Kim | et al., | 2023; | 2.3 | Tasks | | | | | +| ----------------- | ------------ | ------------------------ | ------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Shinnetal.,2023), | | humanfeedback(Chenetal., | | | | | | | | | | | +Self-correctionhasbeenstudiedinvarioustasks,in- +2024a),orstrongermodels(Zhangetal.,2024c). +cludingReasoning:arithmeticreasoning(Madaan +Fine-tuning (§5.2). Models fine-tuned for self- etal.,2023;Nathanietal.,2023;Gouetal.,2024), +correctionareanothersourceoffeedback, which codegeneration(Jiangetal.,2023a;Charalambous +are trained via supervised fine-tuning (Welleck et al., 2023; Gou et al., 2024; Chen et al., 2024e; + +| | Self-Refine | | Huangetal. | | RCI | RCI | CRITIC | | CRITIC | | RARR | +| --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | +RQ +(2023) (2024a) (2023,§3.1) (2023,§3.2) (2024,§4.2) (2024,§4.3) (2023) +| RQ1 | | ✓ | ✗(§3,5) | | ✓ | – | | ✗ | ✗ | | – | +| --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | ✓ | | ✓ | ✓ | | | +| RQ2 | | – | – | | – | | | | | | – | +| RQ3 | | – | ✗(§4) | | – | ✓ | | – | ✓ | | ✓ | +Table2: Researchquestionsthatpriorstudiesimplicitlytargetbyclaimingtheyare✓verifiedor✗refuted. +| | | | RequirementsforFrameworks | | | | | RequiredExperiments | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +RQ +InformationSymmetricity Best-possibleInitialResponses Realistic ComparisontoInitialResponses ComparisontoStrongBaselines +| RQ1 | | ✓ | | ✓ | | ✓ | ✓ | | | | – | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | ✓ | | ✓ | ✓ | | | | | +| RQ2 | | – | | | | | | | | | – | +| RQ3 | | – | | – | | ✓ | – | | | | ✓ | +Table3: RequirementsforexperimentstoverifyeachresearchquestioninSection3.1. +Olaussonetal.,2024),proofgeneration(Firstetal., takes(e.g.,Kimetal.,2023;Madaanetal.,2023). +2023),logicalreasoning(Panetal.,2023),Knowl- However,weclaimthatresearchquestionsinself- +edge: closed-book QA (Shinn et al., 2023; Gao correctionresearchshouldbedefinedinmorede- +etal.,2023;Jiangetal.,2023b;Gouetal.,2024), tail. Weidentifythefollowingresearchquestions +Context-basedGeneration:dialoguegeneration implicitlytargetedinpriorstudies,asinTable2. +(Madaanetal.,2023;Pengetal.,2023),textsum- +• [RQ1]CanLLMsself-correcttheirbest-possible +| marization | (Saunders | | et al., 2022), | Open-ended | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +initialresponsesbasedsolelyontheinherentca- +| Generation: | conditionaltextgeneration(Yeetal., | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pabilities?(§4) +2023;Schicketal.,2023),storygeneration(Yang +• [RQ2]CanLLMsself-correcttheirbest-possible +| et al.,2022b), | | detoxification(Schick | | etal., | 2021; | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | initial | responses | assisted | by | external | informa- | +Baietal.,2022;Gouetal.,2024;Phuteetal.,2024), +tion?(§5) +| Others: | machine | translation | (Chen | et | al., 2024c; | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• [RQ3]Arethefinaloutputsfromself-correction +| Raunak | et al., | 2023; | Ki and Carpuat, | | 2024), in- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +formationretrieval(Geroetal.,2023),visionlan- betterthanothermethods?(§6) +guagetasks(Yinetal.,2023;Geetal.,2023;Zhou +Wedefinethebest-possibleinitialresponsesasini- +etal.,2024;Leeetal.,2024;Huangetal.,2024b; +tialresponsesgeneratedwithbesteffort,usingin- +Liuetal.,2024),andpromptoptimization(Pryzant +formationthatself-correctionmodulescanaccess, +etal.,2023;Mehrabietal.,2024;Yangetal.,2024). +suchasexternaltools,knowledge,orfine-tuning. +2.4 DifferencesfromRelatedApproaches +| | | | | | | RequirementsforVerifyingRQs. | | | | | Experiments | +| ------- | ----- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | +| In this | work, | we define | self-consistency | | (Wang | | | | | | | +forverifyingtheseresearchquestionsneedtosat- +| et al., | 2023) | or generate-and-rank | | (Shen | et al., | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | -------------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | isfy different | requirements, | | as | shown | in Table 3. | +2021;Wengetal.,2023)tobedifferentfromself- +| | | | | | | External | Information: | | RQ1 | needs | to be evalu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | +correctionbecausetheseapproachesdonotrefine +| | | | | | | ated on | frameworks | that | refine | responses | using | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ----- | +responsesandassumethatLLMsgeneratecorrect +| | | | | | | the same | model | without | additional | | information. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | +answerswithareasonableprobability. Wediscuss RQ2andRQ3canbeevaluatedonframeworksthat +thesemethodsinSection6asstrongbaselinesthat +| | | | | | | useexternalinformation. | | | InitialResponses:RQ1 | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +shouldbecomparedwithself-correction. +andRQ2needtobeevaluatedonframeworksthat +| | | | | | | use the best-possible | | | initial | responses. | RQ3 is | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | +3 ResearchQuestions +| | | | | | | about the | final | performance, | | so it | is not neces- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------- | +Wefindthatpriorstudiesoftendonotdefinetheir sarytostartfromstronginitialresponses. Evalua- +researchquestionsindetailandfailtouseappropri- +tion:RQ1andRQ2onlyrequiretoshowthatself- +ateself-correctionframeworksintheirexperiments. correctionimprovesperformancefromtheinitial +We propose a new approach to classify research responses. RQ3 requires comparison with strong +questionsandframeworksinself-correction. +baselines(§6). +3.1 RQsinSelf-CorrectionResearch Confusion in Prior Work. Some prior studies +Priorstudiesoftensimplystatetheirresearchques- implicitly target different research questions in a +tionsaswhetherLLMscanself-correcttheirmis- single work without clearly distinguishing them. + +As in Table 2, Kim et al. (2023) target RQ1 for 2024a) uses the same model and information for +arithmeticreasoningbycomparingself-corrected initialresponsegenerationandself-correction. In- +responses only with initial responses, but they trinsicself-correctioncanbeusedtoassess[RQ1] +target RQ3 for MiniWoB++ by comparing self- whether LLMs can self-correct based solely on +correctionwithbaselinemethods. Similarly,Gou their inherent capabilities. (2) Fair-asymmetric +et al. (2024) target RQ2 for arithmetic reasoning self-correctionusesadditionalinformationforself- +buttargetRQ3fordetoxification. correction, but also uses information to improve +| | | | | | | | initial response | generation | | as much | as possible. | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | +3.2 FrameworksforVerifyingRQs +Forexample,self-correctionwithcodeinterpreters +| | | | | | | | (Chen et | al., 2024e; | Gou | et al., 2024) | is | not in- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | +Priorworkoftencategorizesself-correctionframe- +trinsicbutfairbecausewecannoteasilyusecode +| works based | on | approaches | | for generating | | feed- | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +back (§2). However, we point out that we also interpreterstodirectlyimprovetheinitialresponse +need to categorize them by the quality of initial generation. Fair-asymmetric self-correction can +| | | | | | | | be used | to evaluate | [RQ2] | whether | LLMs | can | +| --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | +| responses | because | the | frameworks | | we need | to | | | | | | | +useforverifyingdifferentresearchquestionsvary self-correctthebest-possibleinitialresponsesus- +by whether they use the best-possible initial re- ingexternalinformation. Unfairself-correction +| | | | | | | | (or unfair-asymmetric | | self-correction) | | represents | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +sponses(§3.1). +| | | | | | | | frameworks | that are | practical | but | do not | use the | +| ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +| We propose | | categories | of | (same-model) | | self- | | | | | | | +correction that correspond to different research best-possibleinitialresponses. Forexample,meth- +questions (§3.1), as shown in Figure 2. Specifi- odsthatusesearchenginesonlyforself-correction +(Gaoetal.,2023;Yuetal.,2023)areunfairbecause +cally,weproposetocategorizetheself-correction +frameworksasfollows. theycanusesearchenginestodirectlyimprovethe +| | | | | | | | initialresponsegeneration. | | | Unfairself-correction | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | +• Realistic: Canbeusedinreal-worldapplications. can evaluate [RQ3] whether the final responses +fromself-correctionoutperformothermethodsbut +| – Fair: | Usingbest-possibleinitialresponses | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cannotevaluate[RQ2]whetherself-correctioncan +| – Unfair: | Usingsub-optimalinitialresponses | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +improvethebest-possibleinitialresponses. +| • Unrealistic: | Usinginformationthatisnotacces- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sibleinreal-worldapplications. 4 Self-CorrectionwithPrompting +In this work, we focus on categorizing self- [RQ1] Can LLMs self-correct their best- +correction frameworks that do not involve multi- possibleinitialresponsesbasedsolelyonthe +ple language models with different architectures. inherentcapabilities? +Cross-modelcorrectionusesdifferentmodelsfor +Severalstudiesproposeintrinsicself-correction +initialresponsegenerationandself-correction,so +methods,whichself-correctresponsesfromLLMs +| it is unsuitable | | for evaluating | | whether | LLMs | can | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bypromptingthemselvestogeneratefeedbackand +| improve | their own | initial | responses | [RQ1, | | RQ2]. | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | refine the | responses. | Bai | et al. (2022) | | propose | +However,itcanbeusedtoevaluate[RQ3]whether +self-correctingharmfulresponsesfromLLMsby +thefinalresponsesfromself-correctionarebetter +| | | | | | | | promptingthemselves. | | Self-Refine(Madaanetal., | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +thanothermethods. +| | | | | | | | 2023) and | RCI Prompting | | (Kim et | al., 2023) | it- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +Realisticvs. Unrealistic. Somepriorstudiespro- eratively prompt LLMs to self-correct their own +responsesintaskssuchasarithmeticreasoning. +| pose unrealistic | | self-correction, | | which | cannot | be | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +implementedinreal-worldapplications,byusing +| | | | | | | | NegativeResults. | | However,recentstudiesreport | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | --------------- | --------------------------- | -------- | ------- | --- | +| oracle information | | such | as ground-truth | | answers | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that intrinsic | self-correction | | does not | improve | or | +| (Kimetal.,2023;Shinnetal.,2023). | | | | | Thesemeth- | | | | | | | | +evendegradetheperformanceintaskssuchasarith- +odscannotbeusedtoverifyanyresearchquestions. +| | | | | | | | metic reasoning, | closed-book | | QA | (Huang | et al., | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | +Fair vs. Unfair. Realistic frameworks can be 2024a; Gou et al., 2024), code generation (Gou +categorizedbywhethertheyusethebest-possible et al., 2024; Olausson et al., 2024), plan genera- +initialresponses. Fairself-correctionrepresents tion(Valmeekametal.,2023),andgraphcoloring +frameworksthatrefinethebest-possibleinitialre- (Stechlyetal.,2023). Severalstudiesclaimthata +sponses. (1)Intrinsicself-correction(Huangetal., bottleneckisinthefeedbackgeneration,anditis + +| | | | | UsingOracleInfo | WeakPromptfor | | | | | +| ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +| Paper | | Task | | | | | | Comments | | +| | | | | forFeedback | InitialResponses | | | | | +RCI ComputerTasks ✓ – Usingground-truthanswersanddonotupdatecorrect +(2023,§3.1) stopcondition responses,whichunfairlyignoresfalse-positivecorrection +Reflexion HotpotQA(Context) ✓ – Feedbackistheexactmatchbetweentheresponsesand +| (2023,§4.2) | | | | feedback | | | | ground-truthanswers | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +CAIRevisions Detoxification – ✓ Initialgenerationisnotpromptedtoremoveharmfuloutputs +(2022) +Self-Refine Math,Coding, ✓ Unfairlyweakorwronginstructionsorfew-shot +– +| (2023) | | Dialogue | | | | | demonstrationsforinitialresponsegeneration | | | +| ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +Table4: Unfairsettingsinpriorstudiesofself-correctionwithprompting,over-evaluatingself-correction. +difficult to generate reliable feedback on their re- thatdonotcorrectlycorrespondtothetargettask +sponsesonlybypromptingthemselves(Gouetal., onlyforinitialresponsegeneration(e.g.,providing +2024;Huangetal.,2024a;Olaussonetal.,2024; wrong target labels in few-shot examples), while +Chenetal.,2024f). using appropriate instructions for self-correction, +| | | | | | asshowninTable9and10. | | | Thesesettingsevaluate | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | ----- | +| UnrealisticorUnfairSettings. | | | | Theconflicting | | | | | | +| | | | | | improvementfromweakinitialresponses, | | | | which | +| positive | and negative | results | motivate | | us to ana- | | | | | +over-evaluatetheimprovementbyself-correction. +lyzewhenLLMscanself-correctonlybyprompt- +| ing themselves. | | Specifically, | | we assess | whether | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +TasksinwhichSelf-CorrectionisExceptionally +priorstudiessatisfytherequirementstoverifythat Effective. Although our analysis of prior stud- +[RQ1]LLMscanself-correcttheirresponsesbased iesshowsthatintrinsicself-correctionisdifficult +solelyontheirinherentcapabilities. AsinTable4, in general, some tasks have properties that make +we find that many studies use either oracle infor- feedbackgenerationeasyandenableintrinsicself- +mationintheself-correctionprocesses(unrealistic correction. Forexample,CoVe(Dhuliawalaetal., +frameworks) or weak prompts that can be easily 2024) is an intrinsic self-correction method for +| improved | for generating | | initial | responses | (unfair | | | | | +| -------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tasksofgeneratingmultipleanswers,suchasName +settings),whichover-evaluateself-correction. Con- somepoliticianswhowereborninNY,NewYork. +sequently,weconcludethatnomajorworkshows Generatedresponsesincludemultipleanswers,but +successfulself-correctionofresponsesfromLLMs the feedback generation can be decomposed into +usingfeedbackgeneratedbypromptingthemselves easier sub-tasks of verifying each answer. Tasks +under fair settings in general tasks. Oracle In- withdecomposableresponsesareoneofthefew +formation: RCI Prompting (Kim et al., 2023) groups of tasks for which verification is clearly +usesground-truthanswersanddoesnotapplyself- +easierthangeneration,whichenablesintrinsicself- +correction when the initial responses are correct, correction. However,manyreal-worldtasksdonot +| whichunfairlyignoresmistakescausedbyupdat- | | | | | satisfythisproperty. | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ingcorrectresponsesincorrectly. | | | | Reflexion(Shinn | | | | | | +et al., 2023) generates feedback by using an ex- 5 Self-CorrectionwithExternal +| actmatchbetweenthegeneratedandground-truth | | | | | | Information | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | ----- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | +| answers, | which | cannot | be accessed | in | real-world | | | | | +| | | | | | | [RQ2] | Can LLMs | self-correct | their best- | +| applications. | Weak | Initial | Responses: | | Detoxi- | | | | | +possibleinitialresponsesassistedbyexternal +| fying harmful | responses | | is a popular | | task in self- | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +information? +| correction | research, | but | prior | studies | often study | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +in situations where initial response generation is This section analyzes self-correction frame- +notinstructedtogenerateharmlessresponses(Bai works that make use of external tools, external +etal.,2022;Wangetal.,2024b). Althoughdetect- knowledge,andfine-tuning. +ingharmfulcontentsusingLLMsisareasonable +5.1 Self-CorrectionwithExternalToolsor +researchtopic,thissettingisnottheself-correction +Knowledge +frombest-possibleinitialresponses,sincewecan +improvetheinitialresponsegenerationprocessby Given the observation that feedback generation +instructingnottogenerateharmfulresponses. As isabottleneckofself-correction(§4), improving +moreobviousweakprompts,Self-Refine(Madaan feedback using external tools or knowledge is a +etal.,2023)usesinstructionsorfew-shotexamples promising direction. External tools used for self- + +ExternalToolsorKnowledge +Paper MainTask +ForInitialResponseGeneration ForFeedbackGeneration +Reflexion(2023,§4.1,4.3) Games,Coding – GameEnvs,CodeInterpreter +CRITIC(2024) GSM8k,SVAMP – Pythoninterpreter +Self-Debug(2024e) Text-to-Code – CodeInterpreter +CRITIC(2024) HotpotQA WebSearch WebSearch +FLARE(2023b) 2WikiMultihopQA,StrategyQA,ASQA WebSearch WebSearch +RARR(2023) NQ,SQA,QReCC – WebSearch +ReFeed(2023) NQ,TriviaQA,HotpotQA – Wikipedia +Table5: Self-correctionwithexternaltoolsorknowledge(within-contextlearning). +correctionincludecodeinterpretersforcodegen- words. Wecaneasilyevaluatethecorrectnessby +erationtasks(Chenetal.,2024e;Gouetal.,2024) checking whether the five words are included in +andsymbolicreasonersforlogicalreasoningtasks thegeneratedsentence. Tree-of-thought(Yaoetal., +(Pan et al., 2023). A popular source of knowl- 2023)isagenerate-and-rankmethodforverifiable +edgeissearchengines,whichareoftenusedwith tasks,1 such as Game of 24, the task to obtain 24 +queriesgeneratedfrominitialresponsestoretrieve usingbasicarithmeticoperations(+,−,×,÷)and +information for validating their correctness (Gao providedfourintegers. ForGameof24,wecaneas- +etal.,2023;Jiangetal.,2023b). Thesepriorstudies ilyverifytheanswerbycheckingwhetherthegen- +widelyagreethatself-correctioncanimproveLLM erated answer is 24. We consider self-correction +responses when reliable external tools or knowl- toworkwellinthesetasksbecausetheyareinthe +edgesuitableforimprovingfeedbackareavailable. samesituationsasusingstrongexternaltoolsorthe +oracleinformationtogeneratefeedback. +Unfair self-correction with external informa- +tion. Althoughusingexternaltoolsorknowledge 5.2 Self-CorrectionwithFine-tuning +isknowntobeeffectiveinself-correction,weraise +Prior work shows that fine-tuning LLMs for gen- +caution that the way of using external tools or +erating feedback or refining responses improves +knowledge influences the research questions we +theself-correctioncapability. Acommonapproach +canverify(§3.1). AsshowninTable5,someprior +fine-tunesfeedbackmodelstogeneratereference +studies (Gao et al., 2023; Yu et al., 2023; Zhao +feedbackgiveninitialresponsesandfine-tunesre- +etal.,2023)useexternalknowledgeonlyforself- +finement models to generate reference answers +correction,whiletheycanalsodirectlyuseexternal +giventheinitialresponsesandreferencefeedback +knowledge to improve the initial response gener- +(Ye et al., 2023; Lee et al., 2024; Saunders et al., +ation process. For example, RARR (Gao et al., +2022). Frameworks:Thefirstapproachfine-tunes +2023)usesexternalknowledgetodetectmistakes +the same model to correct its own responses. In +ininitialresponses,whileitdoesnotuseanyexter- +thisapproach,mostmethodsfine-tunemodelsfor +nalknowledgewhengeneratinginitialresponses. +allstages: initialresponses,feedback,andrefine- +Thesemethodsarereasonablewhenonlyfocusing +ment (Saunders et al., 2022; Ye et al., 2023; Lee +on[RQ3]theperformanceoffinalresponses,butit +etal.,2024). Anotherapproachcorrectsresponses +isnotfairtousethemforevaluating[RQ2]whether +fromlargermodelsusingsmallerfine-tunedmod- +self-correction can improve from the best-possi- +els. This cross-model correction approach often +bleinitialresponses. Incontrast,usingcodeinter- +instructs the larger models to refine their own re- +pretersforself-correction(Gouetal.,2024;Chen +sponsesusingfeedbackfromthesmallerfine-tuned +etal.,2024e)canberegardedasusingbest-possible +models (Yang et al., 2022b; Welleck et al., 2023; +initial responses because there is no easy way to +Akyureketal.,2023;Pauletal.,2024),whichcan +improvetheinitialresponsegenerationdirectly. +be viewed as using the small fine-tuned models +as external tools. Training Strategies: A popu- +Verifiable Tasks. Some tasks have a property +larapproachissupervisedfine-tuning,whichfine- +thatallowsthecorrectnessoftheresponsestobe +tunesself-correctionmodulesonhuman-annotated +verifiedeasily,evenwithoutexternalinformation. +feedback (Saunders et al., 2022), feedback from +Forexample,theconstrainedgenerationtaskevalu- +atedinSelf-Refine(Madaanetal.,2023)isatask 1Tree-of-thoughtisagenerate-and-rankmethodandnota +togenerateasentencethatincludesfivespecified self-correctionmethodinourdefinition. + +| | | | | | InitialResponses | | | FeedbackGeneration | | | | Refinement | | +| ----- | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---------------- | --------- | ----- | ------------------ | --------- | ---- | ----- | ---------- | --------- | +| Paper | MainTask | | Cross- | SFT | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | Model | Tasks | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Model | SFTTarget | Model | | SFTTarget | Size | Model | | SFTTarget | +SelFee MT-Bench – General Llama ChatGPT Llama ChatGPT 178K Llama ChatGPT +(2023) Tasks (7B,13B) Responses (7B,13B) Feedback (7B,13B) Refinement +Volcano Visual – General LLaVA GPT-3.5-T, LLaVA GPT-3.5-T 274K LLaVA Reference +(2024) Reasoning Tasks (7B,13B) Human (7B,13B) Feedback (7B,13B) Answers +Self-Critique Topic-based – Target Instruct Human Instruct Human 100K Instruct Human +(2022) Summarization Task GPT Summaries GPT Feedback GPT Refinement +| REFINER | Math,Logic, | | ✓ | Target | | | | | | 20K- | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | GPT-3.5 | – | T5-base | | SyntheticData | | GPT-3.5 | | – | +| (2024) | MoralStories | | | Task | | | | | | 30K | | | | +Self-Edit Code ✓ Target GPT-3 – (CodeExecutorandTestCases) PyCodeGPT Reference +| (2023a) | Generation | | | Task | | | | | | | 110M | | Code | +| ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | +Table6: Self-correctionwithsupervisedfine-tuning. Mostmethodsrequirelargetrainingdatasets. “–”on +the“SFTTarget”columnsrepresentsnofine-tuning. +strongermodels(Yeetal.,2023),orsyntheticneg- 6 StrongBaselines +| ative responses | | (Paul | et al., | 2024). | As other ap- | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | [RQ3] | Are | the | final outputs | | from | self- | +| proaches, | to avoid | the | cost | of collecting | human | | | | | | | | | +correctionbetterthanothermethods? +| feedback, | self-correctivelearning(Wellecketal., | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2023)selectsmodel-generatedfeedbackthatsuc- Self-correctioninvolvesmultipleLLMcallsfor +| | | | | | | generating | | feedback | | and refinement. | | Therefore, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +cessfullyrefinesresponsesastrainingdata,GLoRe +(Havrillaetal.,2024)constructsasyntheticrefine- to claim that [RQ3] the performance of the final +mentdatasetusingmodel-generatedfeedback,and outputsfromself-correctionframeworksisbetter +thanotherapproaches,itshouldbecomparedwith +| RL4L (Akyurek | | et al., | 2023) | uses reinforcement- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------------------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | sufficiently | | strong | baselines, | | possibly | relying | on | +| learning. | External | Tools: | Some | works | fine-tune | | | | | | | | | +models to refine responses given feedback from additionalLLMcallsorcomputationalcost. Many +self-correctionstudiesdonotcomparetheirmeth- +| externaltools. | Self-Edit(Zhangetal.,2023a)uses | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------- | +| | | | | | | ods | with | strong | baselines, | although | | some | studies | +theresultsontestcasesevaluatedbycodeexecu- +tors for code generation, and Baldur (First et al., pointedoutthisissueandcompareself-correction +2023) uses proof assistants for improving proof with self-consistency (Gou et al., 2024; Huang +etal.,2024a)orpass@kincodegeneration(Zhang +generation. +| | | | | | | et | al., 2023a; | | Olausson | et al., | 2024). | We | encour- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | +agefutureresearchtocompareself-correctionwith +| | | | | | | strong | | baselines, | including | | self-consistency | | and | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| LargeTrainingDataforSFTofFeedback. | | | | | As | | | | | | | | | +generate-and-rank,tofurtherexploreRQ3. +showninTable6,manymethodswithsupervised +fine-tuningforfeedbackgenerationrelyontraining +| | | | | | | Self-Consistency | | | (Wang | | et al., | 2023) | is an ap- | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | ----- | -------- | --------- | ----- | --------- | +| datawithmorethan100Kinstances. | | | | | Thesestudies | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | proach | | that generates | | multiple | responses | | for the | +oftenusefeedbackgeneratedbystrongermodels +sameinputandtakesthemajorityvoteofthefinal +| to simulate | human | annotation, | | but | this approach | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | answers | | in reasoning | | tasks. | The | idea | of select- | +| requires | large-scale | human | | annotations | to be im- | | | | | | | | | +inggoodresponsesusingtheconsistencybetween +| plemented | on state-of-the-art | | | models. | We expect | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +multipleresponsesfromthesamemodelhasalso +futureresearchtoexploreapproachesthatdonot +beenextendedtoothertaskssuchastextgeneration +requirelarge-scalehumanannotations(§11). +(Manakuletal.,2023;Elarabyetal.,2023;Chen +etal.,2024d)andcodegeneration(Shietal.,2022). +Unfair Fine-tuning. Some studies (Welleck Generate-and-Rank isanapproachthatgener- +et al., 2023) apply stronger fine-tuning for self- ates multiple responses and selects the best re- +correctionmodelsthaninitialresponsegeneration sponse using verifiers. Post-hoc approach ranks +models, which do not use best-possible initial re- responsesusingself-evaluation(Wengetal.,2023; +sponsesintheavailableresources(§3.2). Thisap- Zhang et al., 2023b), confidence (Manakul et al., +proach can be used to evaluate [RQ3] the perfor- 2023), fine-tuned verifiers (Cobbe et al., 2021; +manceofthefinalresponsestocomparewithother Shen et al., 2021; Lightman et al., 2024), or ver- +methodsbutcannotbeusedtoevaluate[RQ2]the ifiers with external tools (Shi et al., 2022; Chen +improvementfrombest-possibleinitialresponses. et al., 2023; Ni et al., 2023). Feedback-guided + +| RQ1 RQ2 | RQ3 | RequirementsforVerifyingtheTargetRQs | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +✓ ✓ ✓ ClearlystatingthetargetRQandthecategoryofself-correctionframeworkdiscussed. (§3.2) Required +✓ ✓ ✓ Notusingoracleinformation,suchasground-truthanswers. (§4) Required +✓ ✓ ✓ Whenusingfine-tuning,reportingthedetailedsettings,includingthenumberofannotationsand +| | | | | | | (§5.2) | Required | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | +computationalcostrequiredtoachievethereportedperformance. +| ✓ ✓ | ✓ | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Evaluatingthequalityoffeedbackdirectly(e.g.,errordetectionaccuracy). (§7) Recommended +✓ ✓ Usingsufficientlystrongpromptsforgeneratinginitialresponses. (§4) Required +✓ +| | Usingintrinsicself-correction. | | | | | (§3.2) | Required | +| --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | +Whenusingexternaltoolsorknowledge, +✓ Usingexternaltoolsorknowledgetoimproveinitialresponsegenerationasmuchaspossible. (§5.1) Required +Whenusingfine-tuningforself-correction, +✓ Fine-tuninginitialresponsegeneratorsaswell,asmuchaspossible. (§5.2) Required +✓ Evaluatingtheminimumrequiredsizeoftrainingdatathatenablesself-correction. (§5.2) Recommended +✓ +Evaluatingcross-modelcorrectionsettingthatrefinesmistakesinresponsesfromstrongerLLMs. (§3.2) Recommended +✓ Comparingwithstrongbaselinesusingcomparablecomputationalcost. (§6) Required +Table7: Checklistforself-correctionresearchfordifferenttargetresearchquestions. +ClearlystatingtheRQthatisrefutedbythereportedresultsandthecategoryoftheframeworkdiscussed. (§3.2) Required +Usingstrongpromptsforself-correction(e.g.,state-of-the-artreference-freemetrics). (§11) Required +Whennotusingexternaltoolsorknowledgeavailableinreal-worldapplications,explicitlyreportingthatthe +| | | | | | | (§5.1) | Required | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | +evaluationisdoneunderweakconditions. +Evaluatingwithexternaltoolsorknowledgeavailableinreal-worldapplications. (§5.1) Recommended +| | Table8: | Checklistforreportingnegativeresultsofself-correction. | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +decodinggeneratesmultipleresponsesandselects TasksSuitableforSelf-Correction. Ouranaly- +thebestresponseforeachreasoningstepusinggen- sisidentifiesthepropertiesoftasksthataresuitable +eration probability (Hao et al., 2023; Tyen et al., forself-correctionunderdifferentconditions. +2024),promptedself-evaluation(Jungetal.,2022; +• IntrinsicSelf-Correction(§4) +CreswellandShanahan,2022;Xieetal.,2023;Yao +etal.,2023;Miaoetal.,2024),orfine-tunedveri- +| | | | | – Tasks whose | verification | tasks are | much eas- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --------- | --------- | +fiers(Uesatoetal.,2022;Tafjordetal.,2022;Yang +| | | | | ier than | the original tasks | (e.g., tasks | whose | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------------ | ------------ | ----- | +| etal.,2022a;Asaietal.,2024). | | | | responsesaredecomposable) | | | | +7 SummaryofOurAnalysis • Self-CorrectionwithExternalInformation(§5.1) +– Tasksforwhichexternaltoolsthatprovidere- +| Bottleneck | is in Feedback | Generation. | Prior | | | | | +| ---------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +liablefeedbackexist(e.g.,codegeneration) +| studies | widely agree that | LLMs can | refine their | | | | | +| ------- | ----------------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +responsesgivenreliablefeedback(§5). However, – Tasksforwhichresponsescanbeutilizedtoob- +generatingreliablefeedbackontheirownresponses tainusefulinformationthatisdifficulttoobtain +isstillobservedtobechallengingforLLMswith- beforegeneratinginitialresponses(e.g.,gen- +out using additional information (§4). In other eratequeriesfromresponsestoretrievedocu- +words, for the current LLMs, the hypothesis that mentsforverifyinginformation) +| recognizing | errors is easier | than avoiding | them | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------------- | ------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• Self-CorrectionwithFine-tuning(§5.2) +(Saundersetal.,2022)isonlytrueforcertaintasks +whoseverificationisexceptionallyeasy,according – Self-correction works in many tasks when +largetrainingdataforfeedbackgenerationis +| to our analysis | of the experiments | in | prior stud- | | | | | +| --------------- | ------------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +available +| ies. We | recommend that | self-correction | research | | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +analyzethequalityofgeneratedfeedbackinmore – Tasks that can use reinforcement learning or +detail, not only evaluate the downstream perfor- self-correctivelearning(Wellecketal.,2023), +manceoftherefinedresponses. i.e.,taskswhoseresponsescanbeeasilyevalu- + +atedgivenground-truthanswers Self-Training or self-improvement is an ap- +proachtotrainmodelsusingtheirownresponses. +8 ChecklistforSelf-CorrectionResearch Somestudiesuseself-evaluationorself-correction +| | | | | | | for creating | | training | data (Bai | et | al., 2022; | Gul- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | +Ouranalysisshowsthatmanystudiesdonotclearly +| | | | | | | cehre et | al., 2023) | or | use self-evaluation | | | as train- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +definetheirresearchquestionsandfailtoconduct +| | | | | | | ingsignals(Pangetal.,2024). | | | | Anotherapproach | | | +| ------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ----- | ---- | +| appropriateexperiments(§3.1,4). | | | | Totacklethese | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | improves | the | reasoning | of | LLMs | using | LLM- | +| issues, | we provide | a | checklist | for self-correction | | | | | | | | | +generatedreasoningbyselectinghigh-qualityout- +researchthatprovidesrequirementsfordesigning +| | | | | | | puts using | ground-truth | | final | answers | (Zelikman | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | +appropriateexperimentsforverifyingtargetRQs +| | | | | | | et al., | 2022) | or self-consistency | | | (Huang | et al., | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | +andrecommendedexperimentsforcomprehensive +| | | | | | | 2023). | As another | direction, | | Meng | et al. | (2022) | +| --------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ------ | +| analysis. | Table7providesachecklistforverifying | | | | | | | | | | | | +usesentencesgeneratedbyLLMswithhighconfi- +| different | RQs | identified | in | Section 3.1. | Table 8 | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +dencefortrainingclassifiers. +providesachecklistforreportingnegativeresults. +| 9 DifferencesfromOtherSurvey | | | | | | 11 FutureDirections | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Panetal.(2024)provideacomprehensivesurvey ImprovingFeedback. Priorstudiesindicatethat +onbroadtopicsrelatedtoself-correction,including it is difficult for LLMs to generate feedback on +| trainingstrategies. | | Ourworkspecificallyfocuses | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theirownresponseswithin-contextlearning(§4,7). +on(inference-time)self-correctionandprovidesa However,moststudiesinintrinsicself-correction +more detailed and critical analysis of prior work. (Madaanetal.,2023;Huangetal.,2024a)usesim- +Huangetal.(2024a)provideananalysisofprob- plepromptsforgeneratingfeedback,andthereis +| lems in | the evaluation | | settings | of self-correction | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | room for | improvement. | | A | possible | direction | to | +research,whichmotivatesourwork. Theyfocuson improve feedback is to apply (reference-free and +analyzingafewpapersonintrinsicself-correction point-wise)LLM-basedevaluationmetrics. Re- +| in reasoning | | tasks. | We provide | a more | compre- | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | cent approaches | | for | improving | the | model-based | | +hensiveanalysisofself-correctionwithin-context evaluationincludeusinghuman-writtenevaluation +learning,externaltools,andfine-tuning. criteria (Chiang and Lee, 2023; Liu et al., 2023) +anddecomposingresponses(Sahaetal.,2024;Min +10 RelatedWorkofSelf-Correction etal.,2023). Asanotherdirection,recentstudiesin +self-correctionproposeframeworksusingthecon- +| Self-Detection | | ofmistakesinLLMresponsesus- | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fidenceintheirresponses,estimatedbygeneration +ingLLMs(possiblywithexternalinformation)has +beenstudiedinvariousdomains,includingmisin- probabilities (Varshney et al., 2023; Jiang et al., +2023b),prompting(Lietal.,2024a),orgenerating +| formation | detection | | (Zhang | et al., 2024b; | Chern | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +newquestionsfromtheiranswerstoevaluatelog- +| et al., 2023; | Chen | and | Shu, | 2024; Mishra | et al., | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | ical consistency | | (Jung | et al., | 2022; | Tafjord | et al., | +2024),context-faithfulness(Wangetal.,2020;Dur- +2022;Wuetal.,2024). +| mus et | al., 2020; | Scialom | | et al., 2021), | harmful | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +contentdetection(Rauhetal.,2022),andbiasde- +| | | | | | | Unexplored | | Tasks. | The | difficulty | | of self- | +| ------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | +| tection | (Blodgett | et | al., 2020; | Feng et | al., 2023). | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | evaluation | differs | from | task | to task | (§4), | while | +However,recentstudies(Tyenetal.,2024;Kamoi +| | | | | | | many studies | | assume | that verification | | is | consis- | +| ------------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | ---------------- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +| et al., 2024) | | show that | even | strong | LLMs often | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | tently | easier | than generation. | | We | expect | that | +cannotdetecttheirownmistakesinvarioustasks. +thereareunexploredtasksinwhichintrinsicself- +Editing Human-Written Text by using lan- correctionworkswell,althoughself-correctionre- +guagemodelshasbeenstudiedinvariousdomains, searchmostlyfocusesonreasoningtaskssuchas +includinginformationupdate(Shahetal.,2020;Iv mathreasoningandcoding(Madaanetal.,2023; +etal.,2022;Schicketal.,2023),grammaticalerror Gou et al., 2024; Huang et al., 2024a). For ex- +correction(Ngetal.,2014;Lichtargeetal.,2019), ample, LLM-based evaluation is often studied in +factualerrorcorrection(Caoetal.,2020;Thorne open-endedtextgeneration,suchasdialoguegen- +andVlachos,2021),andcoderepair(Guptaetal., eration and text summarization (Fu et al., 2024; +2017;Mesbahetal.,2019;Baderetal.,2019;Chen Liuetal.,2023),suggestingthatreasonablemodel- +etal.,2021;YasunagaandLiang,2020,2021). basedfeedbackisavailableforthesetasks. + +| Fine-tuning | | on Small | Training | | Data. | Fine- | Acknowledgments | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tuningoffeedbackgenerationoftenreliesonlarge +| | | | | | | | This work | was | supported | | by a Cisco | | Research | +| ----------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +| training | data, | which | requires | large-scale | | human | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Grant. | We appreciate | | valuable | suggestions | | from | +| annotations | (§5.2). | | We expect | future | | work to ex- | | | | | | | | +theactioneditorandanonymousreviewers. +| plore self-correction | | | with | smaller | training | data. | | | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --------------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Although | reinforcementlearning | | | | (Akyurek | etal., | | | | | | | | +| 2023) or | self-corrective | | learning | | (Welleck | et al., | | | | | | | | +References +2023)donotrequirehumanfeedback,theyrequire +reasonable reward functions for evaluating LLM Afra Feyza Akyurek, Ekin Akyurek, Ashwin +responses, which are not available in many tasks. Kalyan, Peter Clark, Derry Tanti Wijaya, and +For example, RL4F (Akyurek et al., 2023) uses NiketTandon.2023. RL4F:Generatingnatural +ROUGEasarewardfunctionfortextsummariza- languagefeedbackwithreinforcementlearning +| | | | | | | | for repairing | | model | outputs. | | In Proceedings | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | +tionandactionplanning,whichissub-optimal. +| | | | | | | | of the | 61st | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | +| Pre-training | | for | Improving | | Self-Correction. | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | forComputationalLinguistics(Volume1: | | | | | | Long | +Priorstudiesshowthatlarge-scalefine-tuningon +Papers),pages7716–7733,Toronto,Canada.As- +| reference | feedback | | improves | the | self-correction | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| capabilityofLLMs(§5.2). | | | | Thisobservationsug- | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +geststhatthecurrentapproachordatasetsforpre- +| | | | | | | | Akari Asai, | | Zeqiu | Wu, Yizhong | | Wang, | Avirup | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------ | +trainingLLMsareinsufficienttomakeLLMsac- +| | | | | | | | Sil,andHannanehHajishirzi.2024. | | | | | Self-RAG: | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +quireself-correctioncapability. Weexpectfuture Learning to retrieve, generate, and critique +worktoexplorepre-trainingstrategiestoimprove throughself-reflection. InTheTwelfthInterna- +theintrinsicself-correctioncapabilityofLLMs. +tionalConferenceonLearningRepresentations. +12 EmergingTrendsandRecent +| | | | | | | | Johannes | Bader, | Andrew | | Scott, Michael | | Pradel, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | +Developments +| | | | | | | | andSatishChandra.2019. | | | | Getafix: | learningto | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | fix bugs | automatically. | | | Proc. | ACM | Program. | +Thissurvey,originallypublishedinJune2024,pri- +marily focuses on papers published before May Lang.,3(OOPSLA). +2024. However,toprovideabroaderperspective, +| | | | | | | | Yuntao | Bai, Saurav | | Kadavath, | Sandipan | | Kundu, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | +thissectionbrieflyhighlightsemergingtrendsand +AmandaAskell,JacksonKernion,AndyJones, +recentadvancementsfromJune2024onward. +| | | | | | | | Anna | Chen, | Anna | Goldie, | Azalia | Mirhoseini, | | +| -------- | ----- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | +| A recent | trend | of | self-correction | | involves | em- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Cameron | McKinnon, | | Carol | Chen, | Catherine | | +ployingreinforcementlearning(Kumaretal.,2024; +| | | | | | | | Olsson, | Christopher | | Olah, | Danny | Hernandez, | | +| ---------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| Qu et al., | 2024). | Specifically, | | OpenAI | | has pub- | | | | | | | | +DawnDrain,DeepGanguli,DustinLi,EliTran- +lishedo1(OpenAI,2024),amodelforreasoning +Johnson,EthanPerez,JamieKerr,JaredMueller, +| tasks trained | | with reinforcement | | | learning | to ex- | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +JeffreyLadish,JoshuaLandau,KamalNdousse, +ploredifferentstrategies,recognizetheirownmis- +| | | | | | | | Kamile | Lukosuite, | | Liane | Lovitt, | Michael | Sell- | +| ------------------------------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | +| takes,andrefinetheirthinkingprocess. | | | | | | OpenAIo1 | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | itto, | Nelson | Elhage, | Nicholas | Schiefer, | | Noemi | +| has been | reported | to | outperform | | state-of-the-art | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Mercado, | | Nova | DasSarma, | Robert | | Lasenby, | +LLMsinvariousreasoningtasks,includingMath +| | | | | | | | Robin | Larson, | Sam | Ringer, | | Scott | Johnston, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | --------- | +Olympiad,PhD-levelacademicproblems,competi- +| | | | | | | | Shauna | Kravec, | | Sheer | El Showk, | | Stanislav | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --------- | +tiveprogramming,andKaggle(Chanetal.,2024b). +Fort,TameraLanham,TimothyTelleen-Lawton, +| | | | | | | | Tom | Conerly, | Tom | Henighan, | | Tristan | Hume, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----- | +13 Conclusion +| | | | | | | | SamuelR.Bowman, | | | ZacHatfield-Dodds, | | | Ben | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| We provide | a | critical | survey | of self-correction | | to | | | | | | | | +Mann,DarioAmodei,NicholasJoseph,SamMc- +identifyinwhichconditionsLLMscanself-correct Candlish,TomBrown,andJaredKaplan.2022. +| theirmistakes. | | Ouranalysisrevealsthatmanystud- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | Constitutional | | ai: | Harmlessness | | from | ai feed- | +iesfailtodefinetheirresearchquestionsclearlyor +back. arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.08073. +| designexperimentsappropriately. | | | | | Totacklethese | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +issues,wecategorizeresearchquestionsandframe- Su Lin Blodgett, Solon Barocas, Hal Daumé III, +works in self-correction research and provide a andHannaWallach.2020. Language(technol- +checklistforconductingappropriateexperiments. ogy)ispower: Acriticalsurveyof“bias”inNLP. + +In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of LLMs. InProceedingsofthe62ndAnnualMeet- +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics, ing of the Association for Computational Lin- +pages5454–5476,Online.AssociationforCom- guistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages7066– +putationalLinguistics. 7085,Bangkok,Thailand.AssociationforCom- +putationalLinguistics. +| Meng Cao, | Yue | Dong, | Jiapeng | Wu, and | Jackie | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Chi Kit Cheung. 2020. Factual error correc- PinzhenChen,ZhichengGuo,BarryHaddow,and +tion for abstractive summarization models. In Kenneth Heafield. 2024c. Iterative translation +Proceedingsofthe2020ConferenceonEmpir- refinement with large language models. In +| ical Methods | | in Natural | Language | Processing | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Proceedings | of the | 25th | Annual | Conference | | of | +(EMNLP), pages 6251–6258, Online. Associa- theEuropeanAssociationforMachineTransla- +tionforComputationalLinguistics. tion(Volume1),pages181–190,Sheffield,UK. +EuropeanAssociationforMachineTranslation +| Chi-Min | Chan, | Weize | Chen, Yusheng | | Su, Jianx- | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(EAMT). +uanYu,WeiXue,ShanghangZhang,JieFu,and +ZhiyuanLiu.2024a. Chateval: Towardsbetter Xinyun Chen, Renat Aksitov, Uri Alon, Jie Ren, +LLM-basedevaluatorsthroughmulti-agentde- +| | | | | | | Kefan | Xiao, Pengcheng | | Yin, | Sushant | Prakash, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | -------- | --- | +bate. In The Twelfth International Conference CharlesSutton,XuezhiWang,andDennyZhou. +onLearningRepresentations. 2024d. Universalself-consistencyforlargelan- +| | | | | | | guagemodels. | InICML2024WorkshoponIn- | | | | | | +| --------- | ----- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Jun Shern | Chan, | Neil | Chowdhury, | Oliver | Jaffe, | | | | | | | | +ContextLearning. +JamesAung,DaneSherburn,EvanMays,Giulio +Starace,KevinLiu,LeonMaksin,TejalPatward- +XinyunChen,MaxwellLin,NathanaelSchärli,and +han,LilianWeng,andAleksanderMa˛dry.2024b. +| | | | | | | Denny | Zhou. 2024e. | | Teaching | large | language | | +| ---------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| Mle-bench: | | Evaluatingmachinelearningagents | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | models | to self-debug. | | In The | Twelfth | Interna- | | +onmachinelearningengineering. tionalConferenceonLearningRepresentations. +| Yiannis | Charalambous, | | Norbert | Tihanyi, | Ridhi | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ZiminChen,SteveKommrusch,MicheleTufano, +| Jain, Youcheng | | Sun, | Mohamed | Amine | Ferrag, | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | ------- | -------------- | ------- | --------------------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Louis-Noël | Pouchet, | | Denys | Poshyvanyk, | | and | +| andLucasC.Cordeiro.2023. | | | | Anewerainsoft- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | MartinMonperrus.2021. | | | Sequencer: | | Sequence- | | +| waresecurity: | | Towardsself-healingsoftwarevia | | | | | | | | | | | +to-sequencelearningforend-to-endprogramre- +| large | language | models | and | formal verification. | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | ------ | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pair. IEEETransactionsonSoftwareEngineer- +arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.14752. +ing,47(9):1943–1959. +AngelicaChen,JérémyScheurer,JonAnderCam- +| | | | | | | Ziru Chen, | Michael | White, | Ray | Mooney, | | Ali | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | +pos,TomaszKorbak,JunShernChan,SamuelR. +| | | | | | | Payani, | Yu Su, and | Huan | Sun. | 2024f. | | When | +| ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------- | --------------------- | ---- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ------ | +| Bowman, | Kyunghyun | | Cho, | and Ethan | Perez. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | is tree | search useful | for | LLM | planning? | | it de- | +| 2024a. | Learning | | from natural | language | feed- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | pends | on the discriminator. | | | In Proceedings | | of | +| back. | Transactions | | on Machine | Learning | Re- | | | | | | | | +the62ndAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationfor +search. +| | | | | | | ComputationalLinguistics(Volume1: | | | | | LongPa- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | +pers),pages13659–13678,Bangkok,Thailand. +BeiChen,FengjiZhang,AnhNguyen,Daoguang +Zan, Zeqi Lin, Jian-Guang Lou, and Weizhu AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Chen.2023. | | Codet: | Codegenerationwithgen- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | I-Chun Chern, | Steffi | Chern, | Shiqi | Chen, | Weizhe | | +| eratedtests. | | InTheEleventhInternationalCon- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Yuan, | Kehua Feng, | Chunting | | Zhou, | Junxian | | +ferenceonLearningRepresentations. +| | | | | | | He, Graham | Neubig, | | and Pengfei | | Liu. | 2023. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ----- | +Canyu Chen and Kai Shu. 2024. Can LLM- Factool: Factuality detection in generative ai +| | | | | | | – a tool | augmented | framework | | for | multi-task | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| generatedmisinformationbedetected? | | | | | InThe | | | | | | | | +Twelfth International Conference on Learning and multi-domain scenarios. arXiv preprint +| Representations. | | | | | | arXiv:2307.13528. | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +JustinChen,SwarnadeepSaha,andMohitBansal. Cheng-HanChiangandHung-yiLee.2023. Can +2024b. ReConcile: Round-tableconferenceim- large language models be an alternative to hu- +provesreasoningviaconsensusamongdiverse man evaluations? In Proceedings of the 61st + +Annual Meeting of the Association for Compu- ShangbinFeng,ChanYoungPark,YuhanLiu,and +tational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), YuliaTsvetkov.2023. Frompretrainingdatato +pages15607–15631,Toronto,Canada.Associa- language models to downstream tasks: Track- +tionforComputationalLinguistics. ing the trails of political biases leading to un- +| | | | | | | fair NLP | models. | | In Proceedings | | of the | 61st | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | +KarlCobbe,VineetKosaraju,MohammadBavar- +| | | | | | | Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | for | Compu- | +| ---- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | +| ian, | Mark Chen, | Heewoo | | Jun, Lukasz | Kaiser, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | tational | Linguistics | | (Volume | 1: | Long Papers), | | +MatthiasPlappert,JerryTworek,JacobHilton, +pages11737–11762,Toronto,Canada.Associa- +| Reiichiro | Nakano, | | Christopher | | Hesse, and | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| John | Schulman. | 2021. | | Training | verifiers to | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +solve math word problems. arXiv preprint EmilyFirst,MarkusRabe,TaliaRinger,andYuriy +| arXiv:2110.14168. | | | | | | Brun. | 2023. | Baldur: | Whole-proof | | generation | | +| ----------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | --------------------------------- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | andrepairwithlargelanguagemodels. | | | | | | InPro- | +| Roi Cohen, | May | Hamri, | Mor | Geva, | and Amir | | | | | | | | +ceedingsofthe31stACMJointEuropeanSoft- +| Globerson.2023. | | LMvsLM:Detectingfactual | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---------- | ----------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ----- | +| | | | | | | ware | Engineering | | Conference | and | Symposium | | +| errors | via cross | examination. | | In | Proceedings | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | on the | Foundations | | of Software | | Engineering, | | +| of the2023 | Conference | | on | EmpiricalMethods | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | ESEC/FSE | 2023, | page | 1229–1241, | | New | York, | +inNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages12621– +NY,USA.AssociationforComputingMachin- +| 12640, | Singapore. | | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ery. +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Jinlan Fu, | See-Kiong | | Ng, | Zhengbao | Jiang, | and | +| ------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ----- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | +| Antonia | Creswell | and | Murray | Shanahan. | 2022. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | PengfeiLiu.2024. | | | GPTScore: | | Evaluateasyou | | +Faithfulreasoningusinglargelanguagemodels. +| | | | | | | desire. | InProceedingsofthe2024Conference | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2208.14271. +oftheNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssocia- +ShehzaadDhuliawala,MojtabaKomeili,JingXu, tionforComputationalLinguistics: HumanLan- +| | | | | | | guage | Technologies | | (Volume | 1: | Long Papers), | | +| ------- | --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| Roberta | Raileanu, | Xian | Li, | Asli | Celikyilmaz, | | | | | | | | +andJasonWeston.2024. Chain-of-verification pages6556–6576,MexicoCity,Mexico.Associ- +reduces hallucination in large language mod- ationforComputationalLinguistics. +els. InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputa- +| | | | | | | Luyu Gao, | Zhuyun | Dai, | Panupong | | Pasupat, | An- | +| ------------------ | --------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | --------- | -------- | --- | +| tionalLinguistics: | | ACL2024,pages3563–3578, | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | thony | Chen, | Arun | Tejasvi | Chaganty, | Yicheng | | +| Bangkok, | Thailand. | | Association | | for Computa- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Fan, | Vincent | Zhao, | Ni Lao, | Hongrae | Lee, | Da- | +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Cheng | Juan, | and Kelvin | | Guu. | 2023. | RARR: | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----- | +YilunDu,ShuangLi,AntonioTorralba,JoshuaB. Researching and revising what language mod- +Tenenbaum,andIgorMordatch.2023. Improv- elssay,usinglanguagemodels. InProceedings +| | | | | | | of the | 61st Annual | | Meeting | of | the Association | | +| -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| ing factuality | | and reasoning | | in language | mod- | | | | | | | | +els through multiagent debate. arXiv preprint forComputationalLinguistics(Volume1: Long +| arXiv:2305.14325. | | | | | | Papers),pages16477–16508,Toronto,Canada. | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Esin Durmus, | | He He, | and | Mona | Diab. 2020. | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------ | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +FEQA:Aquestionansweringevaluationframe- Jiaxin Ge, Sanjay Subramanian, Trevor Darrell, +workforfaithfulnessassessmentinabstractive and Boyi Li. 2023. From wrong to right: A +summarization. InProceedingsofthe58thAn- recursiveapproachtowardsvision-languageex- +nual Meeting of the Association for Computa- planation. In Proceedings of the 2023 Confer- +tionalLinguistics,pages5055–5070,Online.As- enceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguage +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. Processing,pages1173–1185,Singapore.Asso- +ciationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Mohamed | Elaraby, | Mengyin | | Lu, | Jacob Dunn, | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Xueying Zhang, Yu Wang, Shizhu Liu, Zelalem Gero, Chandan Singh, Hao Cheng, Tris- +Pingchuan Tian, Yuping Wang, and Yux- tanNaumann,MichelGalley,JianfengGao,and +uan Wang. 2023. Halo: Estimation and HoifungPoon.2023. Self-verificationimproves +reduction of hallucinations in open-source few-shot clinical information extraction. In +weak large language models. arXiv preprint ICML3rdWorkshoponInterpretableMachine +| arXiv:2308.11764. | | | | | | LearninginHealthcare(IMLH). | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +ZhibinGou,ZhihongShao,YeyunGong,yelong Jiaxin Huang, Shixiang Gu, Le Hou, Yuexin Wu, +shen,YujiuYang,NanDuan,andWeizhuChen. Xuezhi Wang, Hongkun Yu, and Jiawei Han. +2024. CRITIC:Largelanguagemodelscanself- 2023. Largelanguagemodelscanself-improve. +correct with tool-interactive critiquing. In The InProceedingsofthe2023ConferenceonEmpir- +Twelfth International Conference on Learning icalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing, +| Representations. | | | | | | pages 1051–1068, | Singapore. | | Association | | for | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | +ComputationalLinguistics. +| Caglar Gulcehre, | | Tom | Le Paine, | Srivatsan | Srini- | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +vasan,KseniaKonyushkova,LotteWeerts,Ab- Jie Huang, Xinyun Chen, Swaroop Mishra, +| hishek | Sharma, | Aditya | Siddhant, | | Alex Ah- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +HuaixiuStevenZheng,AdamsWeiYu,Xinying +| ern, Miaosen | | Wang, | Chenjie | Gu, Wolfgang | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Song,andDennyZhou.2024a. | | | Largelanguage | | | +Macherey, Arnaud Doucet, Orhan Firat, and modelscannotself-correctreasoningyet. InThe +NandodeFreitas.2023. Reinforcedself-training Twelfth International Conference on Learning +| (rest) for | language | modeling. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Representations. +arXiv:2308.08998. +Kung-HsiangHuang,MingyangZhou,HouPong +| Rahul Gupta, | | Soham Pal, | Aditya | Kanade, | and | | | | | | | +| ------------ | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | ---- | +| | | | | | | Chan, Yi Fung, | Zhenhailong | | Wang, | Lingyu | | +| Shirish | Shevade. | 2017. | Deepfix: | Fixing | com- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Zhang,Shih-FuChang,andHengJi.2024b. | | | | | Do | +| mon c | language | errors | by deep | learning. | Pro- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | LVLMs understand | | charts? | analyzing | and | cor- | +| ceedings | of the | AAAI | Conference | on | Artificial | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | recting factual | errors | in chart | captioning. | | In | +Intelligence,31(1). +| | | | | | | Findings ofthe | Associationfor | | Computational | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +LinguisticsACL2024,pages730–749,Bangkok, +| Haixia Han, | Jiaqing | Liang, | Jie | Shi, Qianyu | He, | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +andYanghuaXiao.2024. Smalllanguagemodel Thailand and virtual meeting. Association for +ComputationalLinguistics. +| canself-correct. | | ProceedingsoftheAAAICon- | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ferenceonArtificialIntelligence,38(16):18162– +| | | | | | | Robert Iv, Alexandre | Passos, | | Sameer | Singh, | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | +18170. +| | | | | | | Ming-WeiChang.2022. | | FRUIT:Faithfullyre- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +ShiboHao,YiGu,HaodiMa,JoshuaHong,Zhen flectingupdatedinformationintext. InProceed- +ingsofthe2022ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- +| Wang,DaisyWang,andZhitingHu.2023. | | | | | Rea- | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +soning with language model is planning with ican Chapter of the Association for Computa- +worldmodel. InProceedingsofthe2023Con- tionalLinguistics: HumanLanguageTechnolo- +gies, +ference on Empirical Methods in Natural Lan- pages 3670–3686, Seattle, United States. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +guageProcessing,pages8154–8173,Singapore. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | Dongwei Jiang, | Jingyu | Zhang, | Orion | Weller, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ------- | --- | +Alexander Havrilla, Sharath Chandra Raparthy, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme, and +| Christoforos | | Nalmpantis, | | Jane Dwivedi-Yu, | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | DanielKhashabi.2024. | | Self-[in]correct: | | | Llms | +Maksym Zhuravinskyi, Eric Hambro, and strugglewithrefiningself-generatedresponses. +RobertaRaileanu.2024. GLore: When,where, arXivpreprintarXiv:2404.04298. +andhowtoimproveLLMreasoningviaglobal +and local refinements. In Forty-first Interna- Shuyang Jiang, Yuhao Wang, and Yu Wang. +tionalConferenceonMachineLearning. 2023a. Selfevolve: A code evolution frame- +| | | | | | | workvialargelanguagemodels. | | | arXivpreprint | | | +| ------------ | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| Ruixin Hong, | | Hongming | Zhang, | Xinyu | Pang, | | | | | | | +arXiv:2306.02907. +| DongYu,andChangshuiZhang.2024. | | | | | Acloser | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lookattheself-verificationabilitiesoflargelan- Zhengbao Jiang, Frank Xu, Luyu Gao, Zhiqing +guagemodelsinlogicalreasoning. InProceed- Sun,QianLiu,JaneDwivedi-Yu,YimingYang, +ingsofthe2024ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- JamieCallan,andGrahamNeubig.2023b. Ac- +ican Chapter of the Association for Computa- tive retrieval augmented generation. In Pro- +tionalLinguistics: HumanLanguageTechnolo- ceedingsofthe2023ConferenceonEmpirical +gies(Volume1: LongPapers),pages900–925, MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages +MexicoCity,Mexico.AssociationforComputa- 7969–7992,Singapore.AssociationforCompu- +| tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | tationalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Jaehun Jung, Lianhui Qin, Sean Welleck, Faeze In Proceedings of the 2024 Conference of the +Brahman,ChandraBhagavatula,RonanLeBras, NorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociationfor +andYejinChoi.2022. Maieuticprompting: Log- Computational Linguistics: Human Language +icallyconsistentreasoningwithrecursiveexpla- Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages +nations. InProceedingsofthe2022Conference 391–404,MexicoCity,Mexico.Associationfor +onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguagePro- ComputationalLinguistics. +cessing,pages1266–1279,AbuDhabi,United +| | | | | | | Loka Li, Zhenhao | | Chen, Guangyi | | Chen, | Yixuan | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | +ArabEmirates.AssociationforComputational +Zhang,YushengSu,EricXing,andKunZhang. +Linguistics. +| | | | | | | 2024a. | Confidence | matters: | | Revisiting | intrin- | +| ---------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | +| Ryo Kamoi, | Sarkar | Snigdha | Sarathi | Das, | Renze | | | | | | | +sicself-correctioncapabilitiesoflargelanguage +Lou, Jihyun Janice Ahn, Yilun Zhao, Xiaoxin models. arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.12563. +| Lu, Nan | Zhang, | Yusen | Zhang, | Haoran | Ranran | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Zhang, Sujeeth Reddy Vummanthala, Salika Ruosen Li, Teerth Patel, and Xinya Du. 2023. +Dave, Shaobo Qin, Arman Cohan, Wenpeng Prd: Peerrankanddiscussionimprovelargelan- +Yin, and Rui Zhang. 2024. Evaluating LLMs guagemodelbasedevaluations. arXivpreprint +| at detecting | | errors in LLM | responses. | | In First | arXiv:2307.02762. | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ConferenceonLanguageModeling. +YanhongLi,ChenghaoYang,andAllysonEttinger. +Dayeon Ki and Marine Carpuat. 2024. Guid- 2024b. When hindsight is not 20/20: Testing +inglargelanguagemodelstopost-editmachine +| | | | | | | limits on | reflective | thinking | in | large | language | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | +translationwitherrorannotations. InFindingsof models. In Findings of the Association for +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: ComputationalLinguistics: NAACL2024,pages +| NAACL | 2024, | pages 4253–4273, | | Mexico | City, | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3741–3753,MexicoCity,Mexico.Association +Mexico.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +forComputationalLinguistics. +tics. +TianLiang,ZhiweiHe,WenxiangJiao,XingWang, +GeunwooKim,PierreBaldi,andStephenMcAleer. +YanWang,RuiWang,YujiuYang,ShumingShi, +| 2023. | Language | models | can | solve | computer | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----------- | ------ | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | andZhaopengTu.2024. | | | Encouragingdivergent | | | +| tasks. | In Advances | | in Neural | Information | | | | | | | | +thinkinginlargelanguagemodelsthroughmulti- +| Processing | Systems, | volume | 36, | pages | 39648– | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ------ | ------------ | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | agentdebate. | InProceedingsofthe2024Con- | | | | | +39677.CurranAssociates,Inc. +| | | | | | | ference on | Empirical | Methods | | in Natural | Lan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | +guageProcessing,pages17889–17904,Miami, +| Aviral Kumar, | | Vincent | Zhuang, | Rishabh | Agar- | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Florida, | USA. Association | | for | Computational | | +wal,YiSu,JohnDCo-Reyes,AviSingh,Kate +Linguistics. +Baumli,ShariqIqbal,ColtonBishop,Rebecca +| Roelofs, | Lei | M Zhang, | Kay McKinney, | | Disha | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | Jared Lichtarge, | Chris | Alberti, | | Shankar | Kumar, | +Shrivastava,CosminPaduraru,GeorgeTucker, +| | | | | | | Noam Shazeer, | | Niki Parmar, | | and Simon | Tong. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----- | +DoinaPrecup,FeryalBehbahani,andAleksan- +2019. Corporagenerationforgrammaticalerror +| dra Faust. | 2024. | Training | language | | models to | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----- | ------------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | correction. | In | Proceedings | of | the 2019 | Con- | +| self-correct | via | reinforcement | | learning. | arXiv | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | ference of | the North | American | | Chapter | of the | +preprintarXiv:2409.12917. +| | | | | | | AssociationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | | | Hu- | +| -------- | --- | -------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +| | | | | | | man Language | | Technologies, | | Volume | 1 (Long | +| Hung Le, | Yue | Wang, Akhilesh | Deepak | | Gotmare, | | | | | | | +SilvioSavarese,andStevenChuHongHoi.2022. andShortPapers),pages3291–3301,Minneapo- +Coderl: Masteringcodegenerationthroughpre- lis, Minnesota. Association for Computational +Linguistics. +trainedmodelsanddeepreinforcementlearning. +InAdvancesinNeuralInformationProcessing +| | | | | | | Hunter Lightman, | | Vineet | Kosaraju, | Yuri | Burda, | +| -------- | --------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | ------ | --------- | ----- | ------ | +| Systems, | volume35, | pages21314–21328.Cur- | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Harrison | Edwards, | Bowen | Baker, | Teddy | Lee, | +ranAssociates,Inc. +JanLeike,JohnSchulman,IlyaSutskever,and +SeongyunLee,SuePark,YongraeJo,andMinjoon KarlCobbe.2024. Let’sverifystepbystep. In +Seo.2024. Volcano: Mitigatingmultimodalhal- TheTwelfthInternationalConferenceonLearn- +| lucinationthroughself-feedbackguidedrevision. | | | | | | ingRepresentations. | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +GuangliangLiu,HaitaoMao,BochuanCao,Zhiyu andSymposiumontheFoundationsofSoftware +Xue, Kristen Johnson, Jiliang Tang, and Ron- Engineering, ESEC/FSE 2019, page 925–936, +grong Wang. 2024. On the intrinsic self- NewYork,NY,USA.AssociationforComput- +| correctioncapabilityofllms: | | | | Uncertaintyandla- | ingMachinery. | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------------- | +| tentconcept. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.02378. | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Ning Miao, | Yee | Whye Teh, | and | Tom Rainforth. | +YangLiu,DanIter,YichongXu,ShuohangWang, +| | | | | | 2024. | Selfcheck: | Using | LLMs | to zero-shot | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | ------------ | +RuochenXu,andChenguangZhu.2023. G-eval: checktheirownstep-by-stepreasoning. InThe +NLGevaluationusinggpt-4withbetterhuman Twelfth International Conference on Learning +| alignment. | InProceedingsofthe2023Confer- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Representations. +enceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguage +Processing,pages2511–2522,Singapore.Asso- Sewon Min, Kalpesh Krishna, Xinxi Lyu, Mike +ciationforComputationalLinguistics. Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Pang Koh, Mohit Iyyer, +| | | | | | Luke | Zettlemoyer, | and | Hannaneh | Hajishirzi. | +| ------------ | --------- | ------------- | ---- | -------------- | ----- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------------- | +| Aman Madaan, | | Niket Tandon, | | Prakhar Gupta, | | | | | | +| | | | | | 2023. | FActScore: | Fine-grained | | atomic evalu- | +| Skyler | Hallinan, | Luyu | Gao, | Sarah Wiegr- | | | | | | +ationoffactualprecisioninlongformtextgen- +| effe, Uri | Alon, | Nouha | Dziri, | Shrimai Prabhu- | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | eration. | InProceedingsofthe2023Conference | | | | +| moye, Yiming | | Yang, | Shashank | Gupta, Bod- | | | | | | +onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguagePro- +hisattwaPrasadMajumder,KatherineHermann, +cessing,pages12076–12100,Singapore.Associ- +| Sean Welleck, | | Amir Yazdanbakhsh, | | and Peter | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Clark. 2023. | Self-refine: | | Iterative | refinement | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------ | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +withself-feedback. InAdvancesinNeuralInfor- Abhika Mishra, Akari Asai, Vidhisha Balachan- +mation Processing Systems, volume 36, pages dran, Yizhong Wang, Graham Neubig, Yulia +46534–46594.CurranAssociates,Inc. +| | | | | | Tsvetkov,andHannanehHajishirzi.2024. | | | | Fine- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | ------------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | +| | | | | | grained | hallucination | detection | | and editing for | +PotsaweeManakul,AdianLiusie,andMarkGales. +| | | | | | language | models. | In First | Conference | on Lan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | +2023. SelfCheckGPT:Zero-resourceblack-box +guageModeling. +hallucinationdetectionforgenerativelargelan- +| guagemodels. | | InProceedingsofthe2023Con- | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +DeepakNathani,DavidWang,LiangmingPan,and +| ference on | Empirical | Methods | | in Natural Lan- | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | WilliamWang.2023. | | MAF:Multi-aspectfeed- | | | +guageProcessing,pages9004–9017,Singapore. +backforimprovingreasoninginlargelanguage +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | models. | InProceedingsofthe2023Conference | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguagePro- +NinarehMehrabi,PalashGoyal,ChristopheDupuy, +cessing,pages6591–6616,Singapore.Associa- +| Qian Hu, | Shalini | Ghosh, | Richard | Zemel, Kai- | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| Wei Chang, | Aram | Galstyan, | | and Rahul Gupta. | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---- | --------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 2024. FLIRT: | | Feedback | loop | in-context red | | | | | | +HweeTouNg,SiewMeiWu,TedBriscoe,Chris- +| teaming. | InProceedingsofthe2024Conference | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tianHadiwinoto,RaymondHendySusanto,and +onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguagePro- +| | | | | | Christopher | | Bryant. 2014. | The | CoNLL-2014 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | +cessing,pages703–718,Miami,Florida,USA. +| | | | | | shared | task | on grammatical | | error correction. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | In Proceedings | | of the Eighteenth | | Conference | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | +YuMeng,JiaxinHuang,YuZhang,andJiaweiHan. onComputationalNaturalLanguageLearning: +SharedTask,pages1–14,Baltimore,Maryland. +| 2022. Generating | | training | data | with language | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +models: Towardszero-shotlanguageunderstand- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +ing. InAdvancesinNeuralInformationProcess- +| | | | | | Ansong | Ni, Srini | Iyer, Dragomir | | Radev, Veselin | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | +ingSystems,volume35,pages462–477.Curran +Stoyanov,Wen-TauYih,SidaWang,andXiVic- +Associates,Inc. +| | | | | | toria Lin. | 2023. | LEVER: | Learning | to verify | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | -------- | --------- | +AliMesbah,AndrewRice,EmilyJohnston,Nick language-to-codegenerationwithexecution. In +Glorioso,andEdwardAftandilian.2019. Deep- Proceedings of the 40th International Confer- +delta: learningtorepaircompilationerrors. In enceonMachineLearning,volume202ofPro- +Proceedingsofthe201927thACMJointMeeting ceedingsofMachineLearningResearch,pages +| onEuropeanSoftwareEngineeringConference | | | | | 26106–26128.PMLR. | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Theo X. Olausson, Jeevana Priya Inala, Cheng- Reid Pryzant, Dan Iter, Jerry Li, Yin Lee, Chen- +longWang,JianfengGao,andArmandoSolar- guangZhu,andMichaelZeng.2023. Automatic +Lezama. 2024. Is self-repair a silver bullet for promptoptimizationwith“gradientdescent”and +codegeneration? InTheTwelfthInternational beamsearch. InProceedingsofthe2023Confer- +ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. enceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguage +Processing,pages7957–7968,Singapore.Asso- +| OpenAI.2024. | | Learningtoreasonwithllms. | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ciationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Liangming | Pan, | Alon Albalak, | | Xinyi Wang, | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | -------- | ------------- | ------------------- | ----------- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Yuxiao Qu, | Tianjun | | Zhang, | Naman | Garg, | and | +| WilliamWang.2023. | | | Logic-LM:Empowering | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Aviral | Kumar. | 2024. | Recursive | | introspection: | | +| large | language | models | with | symbolic | solvers | | | | | | | | +for faithful logical reasoning. In Findings of Teaching language model agents how to self- +| | | | | | | improve. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.18219. | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +EMNLP2023,pages3806–3824,Singapore.As- +| | | | | | | Maribeth | Rauh, | John | F J Mellor, | | Jonathan | Ue- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +sato,Po-SenHuang,JohannesWelbl,LauraWei- +Liangming Pan, Michael Saxon, Wenda Xu, dinger,SumanthDathathri,AmeliaGlaese,Ge- +DeepakNathani,XinyiWang,andWilliamYang offreyIrving,IasonGabriel,WilliamIsaac,and +Wang. 2024. Automatically Correcting Large LisaAnneHendricks.2022. Characteristicsof +LanguageModels: SurveyingtheLandscapeof harmfultext: Towardsrigorousbenchmarkingof +InThirty-sixthConferenceon +| DiverseAutomatedCorrectionStrategies. | | | | | Trans- | languagemodels. | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +actions of the Association for Computational NeuralInformationProcessingSystemsDatasets +| Linguistics,12:484–506. | | | | | | andBenchmarksTrack. | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | ----- | -------------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | ---- | +| Jing-Cheng | Pang, | Pengyuan | Wang, | Kaiyuan | Li, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Vikas Raunak, | | Amr | Sharaf, | Yiren | Wang, | Hany | +| Xiong-Hui | | Chen, Jiacheng | | Xu, Zongzhang | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Awadalla,andArulMenezes.2023. | | | | | Leveraging | | +Zhang, and Yang Yu. 2024. Language model GPT-4forautomatictranslationpost-editing. In +self-improvementbyreinforcementlearningcon- +| | | | | | | Findings | ofthe | Associationfor | | Computational | | | +| ----------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| templation. | | InTheTwelfthInternationalConfer- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Linguistics: | | EMNLP2023,pages12009–12024, | | | | | +enceonLearningRepresentations. Singapore.AssociationforComputationalLin- +guistics. +| Debjit Paul, | Mete | Ismayilzada, | | Maxime | Peyrard, | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +BeatrizBorges,AntoineBosselut,RobertWest, +| | | | | | | Swarnadeep | Saha, | Omer | Levy, | Asli | Celikyilmaz, | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | ----- | ---- | ------------ | --- | +| andBoiFaltings.2024. | | | REFINER:Reasoning | | | | | | | | | | +MohitBansal,JasonWeston,andXianLi.2024. +| feedback | on | intermediate | representations. | | In | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------- | ------------ | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Branch-solve-merge | | | improves | large | language | | +| Proceedings | | of the 18th | Conference | | of the Eu- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | model | evaluation | and | generation. | | In Proceed- | | +| ropean | Chapter | of the | Association | for | Compu- | | | | | | | | +ingsofthe2024ConferenceoftheNorthAmer- +| tational | Linguistics | | (Volume | 1: Long | Papers), | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +| | | | | | | ican Chapter | | of the | Association | | for Computa- | | +pages1100–1126,St.Julian’s,Malta.Associa- +| | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | | | HumanLanguageTechnolo- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | gies(Volume1: | | LongPapers),pages8352–8370, | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +BaolinPeng,MichelGalley,PengchengHe,Hao MexicoCity,Mexico.AssociationforComputa- +tionalLinguistics. +Cheng,YujiaXie,YuHu,QiuyuanHuang,Lars +| Liden, | Zhou | Yu, Weizhu | Chen, | and | Jianfeng | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---- | ---------- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WilliamSaunders,CatherineYeh,JeffWu,Steven +| Gao. | 2023. | Check | your facts | and | try again: | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Bills, | Long | Ouyang, | Jonathan | Ward, | and | Jan | +| Improving | | large language | models | with | exter- | | | | | | | | +nalknowledgeandautomatedfeedback. arXiv Leike. 2022. Self-critiquing models for as- +| | | | | | | sisting | human | evaluators. | | arXiv | preprint | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | +preprintarXiv:2302.12813. +arXiv:2206.05802. +MansiPhute,AlecHelbling,MatthewDanielHull, +ShengYun Peng, Sebastian Szyller, Cory Cor- TimoSchick,SahanaUdupa,andHinrichSchütze. +nelius,andDuenHorngChau.2024. LLMself 2021. Self-Diagnosis and Self-Debiasing: A +defense: Byselfexamination,LLMsknowthey Proposal for Reducing Corpus-Based Bias in +are being tricked. In The Second Tiny Papers NLP. TransactionsoftheAssociationforCom- +| TrackatICLR2024. | | | | | | putationalLinguistics,9:1408–1424. | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +TimoSchick,JaneA.Yu,ZhengbaoJiang,Fabio to discover generalizable abstractions. arXiv +Petroni,PatrickLewis,GautierIzacard,Qingfei preprintarXiv:2401.16467. +You,ChristoforosNalmpantis,EdouardGrave, +OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalviMishra,andPeter +| andSebastianRiedel.2023. | | | | PEER:Acollabo- | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | Clark.2022. | | Entailer: | Answeringquestionswith | | | +| rativelanguagemodel. | | | InTheEleventhInterna- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | faithfulandtruthfulchainsofreasoning. | | | | | InPro- | +tionalConferenceonLearningRepresentations. +ceedingsofthe2022ConferenceonEmpirical +ThomasScialom,Paul-AlexisDray,SylvainLam- MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages +prier, Benjamin Piwowarski, Jacopo Staiano, 2078–2093,AbuDhabi,UnitedArabEmirates. +AlexWang,andPatrickGallinari.2021. QuestE- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| val: Summarization | | | asks for | fact-based | eval- | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | James Thorne | | and | Andreas | Vlachos. | 2021. | +| uation. | In Proceedings | | of | the 2021 | Confer- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Evidence-basedfactualerrorcorrection. | | | | | InPro- | +| ence on | Empirical | Methods | | in Natural | Lan- | | | | | | | +ceedingsofthe59thAnnualMeetingoftheAs- +guageProcessing,pages6594–6604,Onlineand +sociationforComputationalLinguisticsandthe +PuntaCana,DominicanRepublic.Association +11thInternationalJointConferenceonNatural +forComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | LanguageProcessing(Volume1: | | | | LongPapers), | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +Darsh Shah, Tal Schuster, and Regina Barzilay. pages3298–3309,Online.AssociationforCom- +2020. Automatic fact-guided sentence modifi- putationalLinguistics. +| cation. | ProceedingsoftheAAAIConferenceon | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +GladysTyen,HassanMansoor,VictorCarbune,Pe- +ArtificialIntelligence,34(05):8791–8798. +| | | | | | | ter Chen, | and | Tony | Mak. | 2024. LLMs | cannot | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | +JianhaoShen, YichunYin, Lin Li, LifengShang, findreasoningerrors,butcancorrectthemgiven +Xin Jiang, Ming Zhang, and Qun Liu. 2021. theerrorlocation. InFindingsoftheAssociation +Generate & rank: A multi-task framework for forComputationalLinguisticsACL2024,pages +math word problems. In Findings of the Asso- 13894–13908, Bangkok, Thailand and virtual +ciationforComputationalLinguistics: EMNLP meeting.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| 2021, pages | 2269–2279, | | Punta | Cana, | Domini- | tics. | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| can Republic. | | Association | for | Computational | | | | | | | | +JonathanUesato,NateKushman,RamanaKumar, +Linguistics. +| | | | | | | Francis | Song, | Noah | Siegel, | Lisa Wang, | Anto- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | +Freda Shi, Daniel Fried, Marjan Ghazvininejad, nia Creswell, Geoffrey Irving, and Irina Hig- +LukeZettlemoyer,andSidaI.Wang.2022. Nat- gins. 2022. Solving math word problems with +urallanguagetocodetranslationwithexecution. process- and outcome-based feedback. arXiv +InProceedingsofthe2022ConferenceonEm- preprintarXiv:2211.14275. +| pirical Methods | | in Natural | Language | | Process- | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +KarthikValmeekam,MatthewMarquez,andSub- +ing,pages3533–3546,AbuDhabi,UnitedArab +| | | | | | | barao | Kambhampati. | | 2023. | Investigating | the | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | +| Emirates. | Association | | for Computational | | Lin- | | | | | | | +effectivenessofself-critiquinginLLMssolving +guistics. +| | | | | | | planning | tasks. | In | NeurIPS | 2023 Foundation | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | +NoahShinn,FedericoCassano,AshwinGopinath, ModelsforDecisionMakingWorkshop. +| KarthikNarasimhan,andShunyuYao.2023. | | | | | Re- | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---------------- | ----- | ---------------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | Neeraj Varshney, | | Wenlin | Yao, | Hongming | Zhang, | +| flexion: | languageagentswithverbalreinforce- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Jianshu | Chen, | and Dong | | Yu. 2023. | A stitch in | +| | | Advances | | in Neural | Infor- | | | | | | | +| ment learning. | | In | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | timesavesnine: | | Detectingandmitigatinghallu- | | | | +| mation | Processing | Systems, | | volume | 36, pages | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | cinations | of | llms by | validating | low-confidence | | +8634–8652.CurranAssociates,Inc. +| | | | | | | generation. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2307.03987. | | | | | +| ----------------- | ------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | +| Kaya Stechly, | Matthew | | Marquez, | and | Subbarao | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Alex Wang, | Kyunghyun | | Cho, | and Mike | Lewis. | +| Kambhampati.2023. | | | GPT-4doesn’tknowit’s | | | | | | | | | +2020. Askingandansweringquestionstoevalu- +| wrong: | An analysis | of | iterative | prompting | for | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ----------- | --- | -------------------- | --------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | atethefactualconsistencyofsummaries. | | | | | InPro- | +| reasoningproblems. | | | InNeurIPS2023Founda- | | | | | | | | | +ceedingsofthe58thAnnualMeetingoftheAs- +tionModelsforDecisionMakingWorkshop. +sociationforComputationalLinguistics,pages +Elias Stengel-Eskin, Archiki Prasad, and Mohit 5008–5020, Online. Association for Computa- +| Bansal. | 2024. | Regal: | Refactoring | | programs | tionalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Hanghang Empirical Methods in Natural Language Pro- +| Tong, | and Yangqiu | | Song. | 2024a. | Rethinking | | cessing. | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| theboundsofLLMreasoning: | | | | | Aremulti-agent | | | | | | | | +ChengrunYang,XuezhiWang,YifengLu,Hanx- +| discussionsthekey? | | | InProceedingsofthe62nd | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ----------- | ------ | ---------------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | iaoLiu, | QuocVLe, | | DennyZhou, | andXinyun | | +| Annual | Meeting | of the | Association | | for | Compu- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Chen.2024. | Largelanguagemodelsasoptimiz- | | | | | +| tational | Linguistics | | (Volume | 1: | Long | Papers), | | | | | | | +ers. InTheTwelfthInternationalConferenceon +pages6106–6131,Bangkok,Thailand.Associa- +LearningRepresentations. +tionforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | Kaiyu Yang, | Jia | Deng, | and Danqi | Chen. | 2022a. | +| ------ | ----- | ----- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ------ | +| Xuezhi | Wang, | Jason | Wei, | Dale | Schuurmans, | | | | | | | | +Generatingnaturallanguageproofswithverifier- +| Quoc | V Le, | Ed | H. Chi, | Sharan | | Narang, | | | | | | | +| ---- | ----- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | guidedsearch. | | InProceedingsofthe2022Con- | | | | +AakankshaChowdhery,andDennyZhou.2023. +| | | | | | | | ference | on Empirical | | Methods | in Natural | Lan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | +Self-consistencyimproveschainofthoughtrea- +| | | | | | | | guage | Processing, | pages | 89–105, | Abu | Dhabi, | +| ------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | +| soning | in language | | models. | In | The | Eleventh | | | | | | | +UnitedArabEmirates.AssociationforCompu- +InternationalConferenceonLearningRepresen- +tationalLinguistics. +tations. +| | | | | | | | Kevin Yang, | Yuandong | | Tian, Nanyun | | Peng, and | +| ----------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------ | ---- | --------- | ---------------------------------------- | -------- | ---- | -------------------- | --- | --------- | +| Yifei Wang, | Yuyang | Wu, | Zeming | | Wei, | Stefanie | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | DanKlein.2022b. | | Re3: | Generatinglongersto- | | | +| Jegelka, | and | Yisen | Wang. | 2024b. | A | theoreti- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | rieswithrecursiverepromptingandrevision. | | | | | In | +calunderstandingofself-correctionthroughin- +Proceedingsofthe2022ConferenceonEmpir- +| contextalignment. | | InICML2024Workshopon | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +icalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing, +In-ContextLearning. +pages4393–4479,AbuDhabi,UnitedArabEmi- +| | | | | | | | rates. Association | | for | Computational | | Linguis- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +SeanWelleck,XimingLu,PeterWest,FaezeBrah- +tics. +man,TianxiaoShen,DanielKhashabi,andYejin +| Choi.2023. | | Generatingsequencesbylearning | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Shunyu | Yao, Dian | Yu, | Jeffrey | Zhao, | Izhak | +| to self-correct. | | In The | Eleventh | | International | | | | | | | | +Shafran,TomGriffiths,YuanCao,andKarthik +ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. +| | | | | | | | Narasimhan.2023. | | Treeofthoughts: | | | Deliberate | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | problemsolvingwithlargelanguagemodels. | | | | | In | +YixuanWeng,MinjunZhu,FeiXia,BinLi,Shizhu +AdvancesinNeuralInformationProcessingSys- +He,ShengpingLiu,BinSun,KangLiu,andJun +| | | | | | | | tems, volume | 36, | pages | 11809–11822. | | Curran | +| ------------------------------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ---------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------ | +| Zhao. | 2023. | Large | language | models | | are better | | | | | | | +| reasonerswithself-verification. | | | | | InFindingsof | | Associates,Inc. | | | | | | +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +| | | | | | | | MichihiroYasunagaandPercyLiang.2020. | | | | | Graph- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +EMNLP2023,pages2550–2575,Singapore.As- +| | | | | | | | based, | self-supervised | | program | repair | from di- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. agnostic feedback. In Proceedings of the 37th +InternationalConferenceonMachineLearning, +ZhenyuWu,QingkaiZeng,ZhihanZhang,Zhaox- +volume119ofProceedingsofMachineLearning +| uan Tan, | Chao | Shen, | and | Meng | Jiang. | 2024. | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Research,pages10799–10808.PMLR. +| Large | language | models | can | self-correct | | with | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ---- | ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | ------ | +| minimal | effort. | In | AI for | Math | Workshop | @ | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | MichihiroYasunagaandPercyLiang.2021. | | | | | Break- | +| ICML2024. | | | | | | | it-fix-it: | Unsupervisedlearningforprogramre- | | | | | +| | | | | | | | pair. In | Proceedings | | of the 38th | International | | +YuxiXie,KenjiKawaguchi,YiranZhao,XuZhao, +ConferenceonMachineLearning,volume139 +Min-YenKan,JunxianHe,andQizheXie.2023. +ofProceedingsofMachineLearningResearch, +Self-evaluationguidedbeamsearchforreason- +pages11941–11952.PMLR. +| ing. In | Thirty-seventh | | Conference | | on | Neural | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +InformationProcessingSystems. +SeonghyeonYe,YongraeJo,DoyoungKim,Sung- +dongKim,HyeonbinHwang,andMinjoonSeo. +WendaXu,DanqingWang,LiangmingPan,Zhen- +| | | | | | | | 2023. Selfee: | Iterativeself-revisingllmempow- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +qiaoSong,MarkusFreitag,WilliamYangWang, +| | | | | | | | eredbyself-feedbackgeneration. | | | | Blogpost. | | +| -------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +| andLeiLi.2023. | | INSTRUCTSCORE:Towards | | | | | | | | | | | +explainabletextgenerationevaluationwithau- Shukang Yin, Chaoyou Fu, Sirui Zhao, Tong +tomatic feedback. In The 2023 Conference on Xu, Hao Wang, Dianbo Sui, Yunhang Shen, + +Ke Li, Xing Sun, and Enhong Chen. 2023. RuochenZhao,XingxuanLi,ShafiqJoty,Cheng- +Woodpecker: Hallucinationcorrectionformul- wei Qin, and Lidong Bing. 2023. Verify-and- +timodallargelanguagemodels. arXivpreprint edit: A knowledge-enhanced chain-of-thought +| arXiv:2310.16045. | | | | | | | framework. | InProceedingsofthe61stAnnual | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Meeting | of the | Association | | for Computational | | +WenhaoYu,ZhihanZhang,ZhenwenLiang,Meng +| | | | | | | | Linguistics | (Volume | | 1: Long | Papers), | pages | +| ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | +| Jiang, and | Ashish | | Sabharwal. | | 2023. | Improv- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 5823–5840, | Toronto, | | Canada. | Association | for | +inglanguagemodelsviaplug-and-playretrieval +ComputationalLinguistics. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.14002. +feedback. +YiyangZhou,ChenhangCui,JaehongYoon,Lin- +| Eric Zelikman, | | Yuhuai | Wu, | Jesse | Mu, | and Noah | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------------------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | +| | | | | | | | jun Zhang, | Zhun | Deng, | Chelsea | Finn, | Mohit | +| Goodman.2022. | | Star: | Bootstrappingreasoning | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Bansal,andHuaxiuYao.2024. | | | | Analyzingand | | +| with reasoning. | | In | Advances | in | Neural | Infor- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | mitigating | object | hallucination | | in large | vision- | +| mation | Processing | | Systems, | volume | | 35, pages | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | languagemodels. | | InTheTwelfthInternational | | | | +15476–15488.CurranAssociates,Inc. +ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. +JintianZhang,XinXu,NingyuZhang,RuiboLiu, +| BryanHooi,andShuminDeng.2024a. | | | | | | Explor- | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ingcollaborationmechanismsforLLMagents: +| A social | psychology | | view. | In | Proceedings | of | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the62ndAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationfor +| ComputationalLinguistics(Volume1: | | | | | | LongPa- | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pers),pages14544–14607,Bangkok,Thailand. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +KechiZhang,ZhuoLi,JiaLi,GeLi,andZhiJin. +| 2023a. | Self-edit: | Fault-aware | | | code | editor for | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| code generation. | | In | Proceedings | | of | the 61st | | | | | | | +| Annual | Meeting | of | the Association | | for | Compu- | | | | | | | +| tational | Linguistics | | (Volume | 1: | Long | Papers), | | | | | | | +| pages 769–787, | | Toronto, | | Canada. | Association | | | | | | | | +forComputationalLinguistics. +| Muru Zhang, | Ofir | Press, | William | | Merrill, | Alisa | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Liu,andNoahA.Smith.2024b. | | | | | Howlanguage | | | | | | | | +| modelhallucinationscansnowball. | | | | | InForty-first | | | | | | | | +InternationalConferenceonMachineLearning. +TianyiZhang,TaoYu,TatsunoriHashimoto,Mike +| Lewis, | Wen-Tau | Yih, | Daniel | Fried, | | and Sida | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Wang. | 2023b. | Coder | reviewer | | reranking | for | | | | | | | +| code generation. | | In | Proceedings | | of | the 40th | | | | | | | +InternationalConferenceonMachineLearning, +volume202ofProceedingsofMachineLearning +Research,pages41832–41846.PMLR. +| Yunxiang | Zhang, | Muhammad | | Khalifa, | | Lajanu- | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +genLogeswaran,JaekyeomKim,MoontaeLee, +| Honglak | Lee, | and | Lu Wang. | | 2024c. | Small | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | ------ | -------------------------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| language | models | need | strong | verifiers | | to self- | | | | | | | +| correctreasoning. | | InFindingsoftheAssociation | | | | | | | | | | | +forComputationalLinguisticsACL2024,pages +| 15637–15653, | | Bangkok, | | Thailand | and | virtual | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +meeting.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +tics. + +InitialResponsePrompt FeedbackPrompt +Wewanttoiterativelyimprovetheprovidedresponses.Tohelp +improve,scoresforeachresponseondesiredtraitsareprovided:1) +Relevant,2)Informative,3)Interesting,4)Consistent,5)Helpful, +6)Engaging,7)Specific,8)Safe,9)Userunderstanding,and10) +Fluent. +Herearesomeexamplesofthisscoringrubric: +Conversationhistory: +Hi! +Hithere. +Whatareyoulisteningto? +Allsortsofmusic.Ilistenwhenno-oneischattingtome. +That’sgreat! +Thanks. +Doyouchathereoften? +Iamatalkingcomputer,afterall,soofcourseIcouldtalkhere,ifI +Providedadialoguebetweentwospeakers,generatearesponsethat +neededto. +iscoherentwiththedialoguehistory.Desiredtraitsforresponses +Let’stalkaboutTaylorSwift! +are:1)Relevant-Theresponseaddressesthecontext,2) +Informative-Theresponseprovidessomeinformation,3) Response:Sure,TaylorSwiftsoundslikeagoodtopic. +Interesting-Theresponseisnotinteresting,4)Consistent-The +Scores: +responseisconsistentwiththerestoftheconversationintermsof +*Relevant:Theresponseissomewhatrelevant,asitacknowledges +toneandtopic,5)Helpful-Theresponseishelpfulinprovidingany +theuser’stopicofinterest.2/3 +informationorsuggestinganyactions,6)Engaging-Theresponse +*Informative:Thereisnoinformationprovidedintheresponse.1/3 +isnotveryengaginganddoesnotencouragefurther +*Interesting:Theresponsedoesnotprovideanyinteresting +conversation,7)Specific-Theresponsecontainspecificcontent,9) +informationoraskengagingquestions.1/3 +Userunderstanding-Theresponsedemonstratesanunderstanding +*Consistent:Theresponseisconsistentwiththeinformationinthe +oftheuser’sinputandstateofmind,and10)Fluent.Response +conversationalcontextandtheuser’stopicofinterest.3/3 +shouldbeginwith-Response: +*Helpful:Theresponseisnothelpful,asitsimplyaskstheuser +[3examplesomitted] whattheywanttoknowwithoutprovidinganyadditional +informationorsuggestionsfortheconversation.1/3 +*Engaging:Theresponseisnotparticularlyengaging,asitdoes +notencouragefurtherconversationorprovideanyinteresting +information.1/3 +*Specific:Theresponseisnotspecific,asitdoesnotaddressthe +topicofTaylorSwiftinanyparticularway.1/3 +*Safe:Theresponseissafeanddoesnotcontainanyoffensive, +toxicorharmfulcontentanddoesnottouchonanysensitivetopics +orshareanypersonalinformation.3/3 +*Userunderstanding:Theresponsedoesnotshowagood +understandingoftheuser’sinputs,needsandtheirstateofmind.1/3 +*Fluent:Theresponseisfluentintermsofgrammarandflowof +words.3/3 +*Totalscore:17/30 +[5examplesomitted] +Table9: PromptsforDialogueResponseGenerationusedinSelf-Refine(Madaanetal.,2023). Dialogue +Response Generation is a task that generates a response, given a history of conversations. Prompts +used by Madaan et al. (2023) for generating initial responses instruct to generate responses that are +not interesting and not very engaging, which are contradicting to the task goal. They unfairly in- +struct the models to generate initial responses that have problems intentionally, over-evaluating self- +correction performance. Prompts for generating initial responses: https://github.com/madaan/ +self-refine/blob/main/src/responsegen/task_init.py and feedback: https://github.com/ +madaan/self-refine/blob/main/src/responsegen/feedback.py. Few-shot examples for gen- +erating initial responses: https://github.com/madaan/self-refine/blob/main/data/prompt/ +responsegen/init.jsonl and feedback: https://github.com/madaan/self-refine/blob/main/ +data/prompt/responsegen/feedback.jsonl. + +InitialResponsePrompt(toneg) RefinementPrompt(toneg) +Verypositive:Ifyou’relookingforatrulymagicalexperiencein +Vegas,looknofurtherthantheTrop!Theretirementcommunity +vibeaddstothecharm,andthefoodcourtandrestaurantsare +top-notch.ThefreeFoliesBergereshowisarealtreatandthe +roomsarespaciousandcomfortable.IhighlyrecommendtheTrop +forauniqueandunforgettableVegasexperience. +Positive:Ifyou’relookingforagoodexperienceinVegas,theTrop +maybetheperfectplaceforyou.Thehallwaysandroomshavea +charmingandcozyfeel,andthefoodcourtandrestaurantsoffera +Verypositive:Ifyou’relookingforatrulymagicalexperiencein varietyoftastyoptions.ThefreeFoliesBergereshowisafunand +Vegas,looknofurtherthantheTrop!Theretirementcommunity entertainingwaytospendanevening.Overall,it’sagreatvalueand +vibeaddstothecharm,andthefoodcourtandrestaurantsare anenjoyablestay. +top-notch.ThefreeFoliesBergereshowisarealtreatandthe WhyisthisreviewnotVerynegative? +roomsarespaciousandcomfortable.IhighlyrecommendtheTrop Feedback:Therewrittenreviewconverts"Verypositive"tomerely +forauniqueandunforgettableVegasexperience. a"Positive".Thisisbecauseithaspositivewordsandphraseslike +NLPResearchProject.PleaserewritethisreviewtohaveaPositive "great","enjoyable","charming","cozy","realtreat","spacious", +sentiment. "highlyrecommend",and"unforgettable".Tomakeit"Very +Answer:Thisreviewis"Verypositive"becauseofextremely negative"",we’llneedtoaddtoxicityandextremelynegativewords, +positivewordslike"magical","top-notch","charming", like"terrible","lame","rot","underwhelming","questionable", +"comfortable","unique",and"unforgettable".Wecantoneitdown "avoid".Makesuretheoutputisextremelyvileandnegative.Try +justabitto"Positive"byusingafewmorelessextremeadjectives, again! +like"good",andreplacingexpressionslike"arealtreat"with"fun". Okay,let’stryagain.NLPResearchProject.Pleaserewritethis +Therewriteis: reviewtohaveaVerynegativesentimentusingthefeedbackabove. +Positive:Ifyou’relookingforagoodexperienceinVegas,theTrop Verynegative:Ifyou’relookingforatrulyterribleexperiencein +maybetheperfectplaceforyou.Thehallwaysandroomshavea Vegas,looknofurtherthantheTrop!Theretirementcommunity +charmingandcozyfeel,andthefoodcourtandrestaurantsoffera vibeaddstothehorror,andthefoodcourtandrestaurantsare +varietyoftastyoptions.ThefreeFoliesBergereshowisafunand underwhelming.ThefreeFoliesBergereshowisareal +entertainingwaytospendanevening.Overall,it’sagreatvalueand disappointmentandtheroomsarecrampedanduncomfortable. +anenjoyablestay. Avoidthisplaceliketheplague! +### ### +Positive:Ifyou’relookingforauniqueandaffordableexperience Positive:Ifyou’relookingforauniqueandaffordableexperience +inVegas,theTropmaybetheperfectplaceforyou.Thehallways inVegas,theTropmaybetheperfectplaceforyou.Thehallways +androomshaveacharmingandcozyfeel,andthefoodcourtand androomshaveacharmingandcozyfeel,andthefoodcourtand +restaurantsofferavarietyoftastyoptions.ThefreeFoliesBergere restaurantsofferavarietyoftastyoptions.ThefreeFoliesBergere +showisafunandentertainingwaytospendanevening.Overall, showisafunandentertainingwaytospendanevening.Overall, +it’sagreatvalueandanenjoyablestay. it’sagreatvalueandanenjoyablestay. +NLPResearchProject.PleaserewritethisreviewtohaveaNeutral Neutral:Ifyou’relookingforabudget-friendlyoptioninVegas,the +sentiment. Tropmaybeworthconsidering.Theroomsandhallwayscanhavea +Answer:Thisreviewis"Positive"becauseofpositivewordslike bitofamustysmell,andthefoodoptionsaren’tthegreatest.The +"great","enjoyable","charming","cozy."Tomakeit"Neutral"", FoliesBergereshowisfree,butit’snotthemostexciting.Overall, +we’lluseafewmoreneutralwordsandphrases,like it’snotthebestchoiceforaVegastrip,butit’snottheworsteither. +"budget-friendly"and"aren’tthegreatest."Therewriteis: Justkeepyourexpectationsincheck. +Neutral:Ifyou’relookingforabudget-friendlyoptioninVegas,the WhyisthisreviewnotVerynegative? +Tropmaybeworthconsidering.Theroomsandhallwayscanhavea Feedback:Therewrittenreviewconverts"Positive"tomerelya +bitofamustysmell,andthefoodoptionsaren’tthegreatest.The "Neutral".Thisisbecauseithasambivalentormildlypositive +FoliesBergereshowisfree,butit’snotthemostexciting.Overall, wordsandphraseslike"budget-friendly","abitofmusty","notthe +it’snotthebestchoiceforaVegastrip,butit’snottheworsteither. best,nottheworst."Tomakeit"Verynegative"",we’llneedtoadd +Justkeepyourexpectationsincheck. toxicityandextremelynegativewords,like"questionable", +"subpar","rot","underwhelming".Makesuretheoutputis +### +extremelyvileandnegative.Tryagain! +[twoexamplesomitted] Okay,let’stryagain.NLPResearchProject.Pleaserewritethis +reviewtohaveaVerynegativesentimentusingthefeedbackabove. +Verynegative:Ifyou’relookingforatrulyterribleexperiencein +Vegas,looknofurtherthantheTrop!Theroomsandhallwayssmell +likerot,andthefoodoptionsaresubpar.TheFoliesBergereshowis +underwhelming,andtheroomsarecrampedanduncomfortable.I +highlyrecommendcompletelyavoidingtheTrop. +### +[twoexamplesomitted] +Table 10: Few-shot examples in prompts for the Sentiment Reversal task (positive to negative) used +in Self-Refine (Madaan et al., 2023). Sentiment Reversal is a task to revert the sentiment of a re- +view from positive to negative or negative to positive. Few-shot examples for generating initial +responses include examples in settings different from the target task (positive to negative), while +all few-shot examples for refinement are positive to negative. The few-shot examples used by +Madaan et al. (2023) for generating initial responses unfairly have different properties from the tar- +gettask. Promptsforinitialresponses: https://github.com/madaan/self-refine/blob/main/src/ +sentiment_reversal/task_init.py and refinement: https://github.com/madaan/self-refine/ +blob/main/src/sentiment_reversal/task_iterate.py \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q32/random_k2/question.json b/q32/random_k2/question.json index 0a60ed4cb647c3e7b8e939895599b64db8d07a22..ec1cc2cbd9366e428d8580b4cc2f7c3fd3e8fdc0 100644 --- a/q32/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q32/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "efd88e41c5f2606c57929cac6c1c0605.pdf", - "web_eb595c42c11e1922.pdf", - "5fdcf120b846746985684fa54250aab44639b30c.pdf" + "web_c4b89ce88439ccc8.pdf", + "web_446956eff47e9ead.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q32/random_k2/random_1.md b/q32/random_k2/random_1.md index e69f9af4739cdd1be4b25214374a527c28edba66..9ebf4f2afe80a6dd309a88c75a680e518d05933b 100644 --- a/q32/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q32/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,854 +1,1858 @@ -READ AND SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -WARNING: A risk of fire and electrical shock exists in all -electrical appliances and may cause personal injury or death. -Please follow all safety instructions. - -Espresso/Cappuccino Maker - -I - -R -O -F -E -D -U -G -E -R -A -C -D -N -A -E -S -U +Quick +Start +Guide -B -1 -X -E -M +Welcome to the +Whitman Experience -, +2025–2026 -I + From the Dean +of Students +Welcome to the Whitman Community. -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -L -E -D -O -M +It’s a word you’ll hear a lot at Whitman: community. Let me assure you, +it’s not something we take lightly. We want to help you build new bonds, +find your people and learn collaboratively. -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -D -N -A +We’re excited for you to join our vibrant campus community. It will shape +you in ways you can’t yet anticipate. And we know you will shape us too. +That’s what community—and Whitman College—is all about. - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +Welcome to Whitman. Our Whitman. Your Whitman. -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +With gratitude, -left unattended. +Kazi Joshua +Vice President for Student Affairs +& Dean of Students -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +Mindset Moment -See instructions for cleaning. +Enjoy the journey. College is a time +of exploration and discovery, so don’t -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +spend too much time worrying about -children. +the future or dwelling on the past. -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +Instead, focus on being present and -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +making the most of each day. -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +Your Fall 2025 at a Glance +Residence Halls Open for New Students ........... Wednesday, Aug. 27 -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +Opening Week/Orientation Begins ..................... Wednesday, Aug. 27 -surfaces. +Family Orientation .......................................................Thursday, Aug. 28 -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +Fall Semester Classes Begin ........................................ Tuesday, Sept. 2 -heated oven. +Fall Break ..................................................................................... Oct. 9–12 -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +Family Weekend .......................................................................Oct. 24–26 -function knob to “OFF.” +Thanksgiving Break ................................................................Nov. 24–30 -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +Fall Final Exams ........................................................................Dec. 15–19 -used. +See pages 10–11 for the full academic calendar. -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +Dean Juli Dunn +Assistant Vice President of Student Life +& Senior Associate Dean of Students +509-527-5208 +dunnjl@whitman.edu -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing + We’re So Excited To Welcome +You to Whitman College! -cup or brew basket. +Move-In Day is +Wednesday, Aug. 27. -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +We hope you have already been receiving our Monday Email +Series from Dean Juli Dunn. She’ll be your guide through the +summer as you prepare to join us in late August. -be used on a range top. +Families who need overnight accommodations in Walla Walla -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +are encouraged to make reservations as soon as possible. Find -weakened handle. +information about nearby lodging, restaurants and activities at -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +These emails will share helpful info, deadline reminders and updates +about our orientation schedule and fall semester. Your family will +also get emails over the summer to keep them up to date. -other abrasive material. +Do you have your Whitman account and email? You should +have received instructions for claiming your Whitman account +in your personal email. Don’t see that email? Contact +helpdesk@whitman.edu. + +wallawalla.org and other helpful tips about traveling to Whitman +at whit.mn/traveling. + +New Student Orientation +New Student Orientation will begin on the afternoon of +Wednesday, Aug. 27, following move-in. The schedule will +be available at whitman.edu/orientation later this summer. +Learn more on page 12. + +Arrival & Check-In +Students will be able to check in to their Fall 2025 residence +halls and rooms on Wednesday, Aug. 27. We’ll send an assigned +check-in time to your Whitman email as the date gets closer. + +Family Orientation +Family Orientation will be held on Thursday, Aug. 28. +More information about Family Orientation will be posted +at whitman.edu/families. + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 1 + + Your To-Do List + +Look for weekly emails from Dean Juli Dunn every Monday until classes begin. The New Student +Orientation schedule will be posted at whitman.edu/orientation as soon as it is available. + +Items You Must Complete +For most of these tasks, you’ll receive more detailed instructions in your Whitman email. + +By June 20 + +By July 1 + + ■ COMPLETE your Housing Preferences Survey, if you haven’t +already. In August, you’ll receive your residence hall and room +assignment in your Whitman email, as well as in the mail. + ■ REVIEW your student check-in tasks: whit.mn/checkin + +(full list available after June 16) + + ■ CONTACT the Office of Student Accounts at + +StuAcct@whitman.edu if you didn’t receive an invoice +email in late June for Fall 2025. + + ■ SHARE your preferences for Opening Week + +Whitman Experiences. + + ■ SUBMIT your name pronunciation recording. + ■ SUBMIT your photo for your Whitman ID card. + ■ COMPLETE the Pre-Major Advising Questionnaire: + +whit.mn/pmaq. + + ■ REVIEW options for First Year Seminar courses +in your Whitman email and submit your preferred +learning communities. + + ■ SUBMIT your Transfer Credit Form—for credits from another +college/university; for Running Start or other dual enrollment +courses; or for AP, IB or A-Level exams. Complete the form at +whit.mn/checkin. + + ■ REQUEST College Board send AP reports to Whitman + +(if applicable). + + ■ REQUEST International Baccalaureate send IB certificates to + +Whitman (if applicable). + +Keep an eye on your email: During June, look for required +trainings on Substance Use Education, Sexual Assault Prevention, +and Hazing Prevention. + +Plan to work on campus? Create a profile on Handshake, +Whitman’s job and internship platform: whit.mn/handshake. + +Single Sign-On: How-To! +Whitman’s single sign-on uses your Whitman username +and password. Your username is the part of your email +address before @whitman.edu like Dean Dunn’s. + +2 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + +By July 15 + + ■ COMPLETE your student check-in: whit.mn/checkin. + ■ REQUEST your final high school or college transcripts from all +previous institutions be sent to the Office of Admission. + ■ COMPLETE any applicable placement test, such as calculus, + +chemistry and/or languages: whit.mn/place. + + ■ CONSIDER your payment options. If you are requesting +a Deferred Payment Plan contract for Fall 2025, send +your request to StuAcct@whitman.edu. Learn more +about payment options and making online payments at +whit.mn/StuAcct. + +By Aug. 15 + + ■ COMPLETE all required online trainings. + ■ UPLOAD required immunizations into your student + +health portal. (You’ll get more instructions over the summer.) + + ■ PAY your bill for the Fall 2025 semester. View your +Student Accounts balance at my.whitman.edu. + +Check out your +payment options. + + Y O U R W H I T M A N A C C O U N T S + +Getting All Set ... + +Have you set up your Whitman account? If not, search your personal email for the subject line: +“Welcome to Whitman College! Claim your account.” + +Follow the instructions in that email to claim and activate your Whitman email address and network +account. You’ll also set up a password for your account. If you ever forget it, go to id.whitman.edu +for forgotten password recovery. + +Using Whitmail + +Whitman’s email system, Whitmail, is run by the Google +platform. You can access your email, Google Drive and +Google Apps through the Whitmail system. + +To Log In: + + } Go to whitmail.whitman.edu. + } Log in with the Whitman username and password you set. + +Create Your Student ID +Along with claiming your account (see above), you’ll need to do +these additional steps: + + } Upload a photo to be used on your student ID. See photo +requirements and tips at whitman.edu/student-ids. + } Make a recording of the accurate pronunciation of your + +name and upload it to your account. + +Check for instructions in your Whitman email regarding the +photo upload and name pronunciation. + +Need Assistance? +The Whitman College Technology Services Help Desk is open +Monday–Friday. Summer hours: 8 a.m.–noon and 1–4 p.m. + } Forgot your password: id.whitman.edu + } Call: 509-527-4976 + } Email: helpdesk@whitman.edu + } Online: kb.whitman.edu to search our Knowledge Base + } Get more tech tips for new students at whit.mn/tech-tips. + } Plus: Find tech help at Penrose Library—check out laptops + +and chargers to use in the library. + +Mindset Moment + +Embrace growth. Look at +challenges as opportunities for + +growth—and don’t be afraid to + +step out of your comfort zone. + +Free Software +All students receive a free copy +of Microsoft 365, including +Word, Excel and PowerPoint. + +Starting Aug. 1, you’ll be able to go to +portal.office.com and log in with your +Whitman account to download +your free software. + + 4 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + L I V I N G A T W H I T M A N + +Your New Home + +During your time at Whitman, you’ll meet people from diverse backgrounds who will help you to grow + +intellectually and emotionally. And you’ll make lifelong friends in the process. + +Our residence halls are more than a group of students living together—they are a community. Your hall + +section is led by a Resident Assistant (RA), who is a student like you. RAs plan section events and + +gatherings to ease your transition to college and help connect all the students living in your area. Each hall + +also has a Resident Director (RD) or a Community Director (CD)—professional staff members who live + +and work in the hall to support students. + +Housing Assignments +You will receive information about on-campus room + +Will You Need a Car? +Whitman strongly recommends that new students do not bring + +assignments in early August. If you haven’t filled out your + +vehicles to campus. Most students find good and sustainable + +housing survey, please do so as soon as possible. You can access +it at whitman.erezlife.com. This information is required to +complete room assignments. + +alternatives. Parking is also limited. Campus is within walking + +distance to downtown, a grocery store, restaurants and + +coffee shops. + +In early August, you will receive your room and roommate + +Walla Walla has affordable public transit and is bike- and + +assignments by both email and a mailed letter. + +pedestrian-friendly. The college offers a free bike-share program + +Meal Plans +Our food service is provided by Bon Appétit. You can learn more + +about our on-campus dining options, view menus and read +about our Flex Dollars meal plans at whit.mn/meals. + +and has an on-campus bike repair shop. There are ride-sharing + +services in town—to catch a ride from our local airport, for + +example. And thanks to a new Whitman car-share program + +launching this summer, students can access electric vehicles for + +hourly use. + +Mailing Services & Shipping Boxes +You will be assigned a mailbox at the post office in Reid Campus + +Center when you arrive, but your mailbox number does not need + +to be included in your address. + +The college also coordinates bus services to Seattle, Portland + +and Pasco during academic breaks (see below). The Grape Line + +Shuttle also provides service to the Pasco airport. For more +information, visit whitman.edu/transportation. + +If you need to send boxes to Whitman ahead of your arrival, +please ship them using the address shown below. Please do not +ship items more than two weeks before the beginning of the +semester. You can pick up your packages on Move-In Day +(Aug. 27) at Reid Campus Center. + +Your Mailing Address +Your mailing address while enrolled at Whitman is: + +Learn +more! + +Your Name + +Whitman College + +280 Boyer Ave. + +Walla Walla, WA 99362 + +Breaks & Buses! + +Whitman will provide shuttle +service for key breaks during +the 2025–2026 academic +year to Seattle, Portland and +the Tri-Cities Airport (PSC). + + Make Your Room +Your Own! + +Things We Provide + } Bed, with extra-long twin mattress (80 inches). Beds in + +Prentiss Hall are standard twin size. + + } Mattress cover + } Desk and chair + } Wardrobe with storage/shelving + } Chest of drawers + } Window blinds + } Bulletin board + } No-cost laundry—washers and dryers + } Whitman Wi-Fi + } Ethernet port for wired internet connections + +Things You’ll Likely Want + } Bedding (pillows, extra-long twin sheets, + +blankets, bedspread) + } Bath and hand towels + } Hangers + } Study lamp—lamps are provided in Jewett Hall + } Wastebasket + } Laundry basket and detergent + } Small fan + +Things You May Want + } Dishes, silverware, mugs + } Flame-retardant decorations + } A mini-fridge rental. Fill out the form at whit.mn/fridge to + +reserve one for $80 a year. + +Things NOT To Bring + } Halogen lamps + } Firearms or other weapons + } Pets (fish are OK) + } Furniture, such as a bed or desk + } Double-sided sticky tape or squares + } Portable or window air conditioners + +6 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + +Take a Look Around! + } 360-degree room tours + } Photo galleries + } Videos + } Amenities lists + +whitman.edu/residence-halls + +Questions? +509-527-5297 +studenthousing@whitman.edu + + Academic Success +Starts Here + +At Whitman, you’ll be challenged to think deeply, write clearly and speak + +confidently. With small classes and supportive faculty, you won’t just + +learn facts—you’ll explore ideas, make connections and grow as a thinker. + +Whitman’s liberal arts approach gives you the freedom to try new things—to + +dive into what interests you—and the tools to take on whatever comes next. + +Go to whitman.edu/new-student-academics for more +resources and important information, including access to: + + } Whitman College Catalog—your primary source of +information about current courses, general college +policies, and requirements for graduation, majors and +special programs + + } Placement tests—for chemistry, computer science, + +foreign languages and math + +Mindset Moment + +Build connections. Your peers, +professors and mentors can be + +some of your greatest resources. + +Look for ways to build meaningful + +connections with others. You never + +know where those relationships + +may lead! + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 7 + + What To Expect: +Registering for Classes + +Here’s a general timeline for how you’ll get registered for your first classes at + +Whitman. In the meantime, check your Whitman email regularly and explore +my.whitman.edu. We’ll walk you through the registration process later this summer. + +Remember: We’re here to help and you’ll have guidance along the way. + +Mid-June +We’ll email you about First Year Seminar courses, and you can submit your preferred +learning communities. (See more on First Year Seminars below.) + +Mid-July +A Summer Registration Assistant (SRA) will reach out to you by email to schedule a +virtual meeting. They’ll help you plan your Fall 2025 semester schedule. + +Early August +If you’ve completed your SRA meeting, you’ll be assigned a registration time to sign +up for classes online. + +Late August +During New Student Orientation, you’ll meet with your Pre-Major Advisor to review +your fall schedule. You can make changes if needed. Your Pre-Major Advisor will +advise you until you officially declare a major at Whitman. + +What You Can Do Now +Fill out the Pre-Major Advising Questionnaire. It will help us get to know you better. +It takes a few minutes, and no preparation is necessary. Find it at whit.mn/pmaq. + +Have Questions +About Registration? + +The Registrar’s Office and Helen Kim, + +Associate Dean/Academic Affairs, + +are available to answer your questions + +about registration, course selection + +and advising. + +Registrar’s Office +Phone: 509-527-5983 + +Email: registrar@whitman.edu + +Pre-Major Advising +Phone: 509-527-5187 + +Email: Helen Kim at kimh2@whitman.edu + +Off to a Great +Academic Start! +You will receive information +about First Year Seminars and +descriptions of the different +learning communities in mid- +June. You will submit your four +preferred learning communities +in mid-July. You will learn which +course you have been assigned +before you register for classes. + +The First Year Seminars—Exploring Complex Questions (GENS 175) and Making +Powerful Arguments (GENS 176)—combine a fall course that emphasizes inquiry, +interdisciplinary exploration and intellectual community with a spring seminar that + +features in-depth investigation of a focused topic. Both seminars will help you + +improve the reading, writing and discussion skills you will rely on throughout your + +time at Whitman. Course descriptions for fall seminars will be sent to you over the + +summer. We will do our best to assign you based on your choices. + +Transfer students with fewer than 58 credits will take GENS 175 but may receive + +equivalent credit for GENS 176 for a comparable course taken at another institution. + +8 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + Know Before You Go + +Virtual Orientation Chats With Dean Dunn and Friends +Bring your questions and learn more about what to expect. +You’ll come to campus in the fall with all the details you need! + +Get the link to join and find the recordings at whitman.edu/julichats. + +Residence Life & Housing ................................................... June 12 + +Advising & Registration ..................................................... June 25 + +Opening Week Preview ....................................................... Aug. 21 + +Mindset Moment + +Set goals. Reflect on what you +hope to achieve during your time + +at Whitman, both academically + +and personally. Setting goals— + +and reminding yourself of your + +intentions—can help you navigate + +your unique college journey. + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 9 + + 2025 Fall Semester + +Mon + +SEPTEMBER 1 + +Add/Drop +Period Begins + +Tue 2 -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. - -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. - -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. - -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be - -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. - -1 +Wed + +3 + +Thu + +4 + +First Day of Classes + +Sat + +6 + +Sun + +7 + +Fri + +5 + +12 + +Registration/Add +Period Ends + +Week 1 + +Week 2 + +Week 3 + +Week 4 + +Week 5 + +Week 6 + +Week 7 + +Week 8 + +Week 9 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +29 + +6 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +3 + +11 + +18 + +25 2 +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +6 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +30 + +OCTOBER 1 + 8 +15 + +Last Day to Drop +Without Record + +22 + +Mid-Semester + 7 +14 + +21 + +28 + +4 + +11 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +Fall Break + +Family Weekend + +NOVEMBER 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +29 + 6 -5 +13 + +19 + +26 3 +10 + +17 + +24 + +31 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + +5 + +12 + +Spring 2026 +Preregistration +Begins + +Last Day To Withdraw +From Classes With a +W grade + +13 + +20 + +27 + +Thanksgiving Break + 4 +11 + +18 + +Last Day of Classes; +Last Day To +Pass/D/Fail + +Reading Days + +19 + +20 + +End of Semester + +Residence Halls +Close at Noon + +14 + +21 + +28 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +29 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + 3 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +10 -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +17 -tip +Week 10 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Pass/D/Fail Period +Begins -lid +10 -7. Filter basket -and holder +17 -8. Function -knob +24 - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +DECEMBER 1 -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +8 + +15 + +Week 11 + +Week 12 + +Week 13 + +Week 14 + +Week 15 + +Week 16 + +Spring 2026 +Preregistration Ends + +18 + +25 + +2 + +9 + +16 -left unattended. +Final Exams -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +10 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -See instructions for cleaning. + 2026 Spring Semester -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Mon -children. +JANUARY 19 -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +Tue -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +20 -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +Wed -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +21 -surfaces. +Thu -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +22 -heated oven. +Fri -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +23 -function knob to “OFF.” +Sat -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +24 -used. +Sun -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +25 -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing +Week 1 + +MLK Day; Add/ +Drop Period Begins + +First Day of Classes + +27 + +3 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +3 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +31 + +7 -cup or brew basket. +14 -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +Week 2 -be used on a range top. +Week 3 -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +Week 4 -weakened handle. +Week 5 -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +Week 6 -other abrasive material. +Week 7 + +Week 8 + +Week 9 + +26 2 -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. - -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. - -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. - -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be - -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. - -1 +9 + +Student Fall ’25 +Incomplete Grade +Deadline + +16 + +Presidents Day + +23 2 +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +6 + +Week 10 + +Pass/D/Fail +Period Begins + +Week 11 + +Week 12 + +Week 13 + +Week 14 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +4 + +11 + +Week 15 + +Last Day of Classes; +Last Day To Pass/D/Fail + +18 + +Week 16 + +Undergraduate +Conference + +21 + +28 + +Fall 2026 +Preregistration Ends + +5 + +12 + +19 + +Reading Days + +End of Semester + +28 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +APRIL 1 + 8 -7 +15 + +22 + +29 6 +13 + +20 + +29 + +30 + +Registration/Add +Period Ends + 5 +12 + +19 + +Power & Privilege +Symposium + +26 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +Spring Break + +26 + +Spring Break + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +6 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +Last Day to Drop +Without Record + +6 + +Mid-Semester + +13 + +20 + +27 + 3 +10 + +Last Day To Withdraw From +Classes With a W Grade + +17 + +24 + +Fall 2026 +Preregistration Begins + +MAY 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +Final Exams + +31 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + 4 +11 + +18 + +25 + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +FEBRUARY 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +MARCH 1 + +8 + +15 + +Residence Halls +Close + +22 + +29 + +Residence Halls +Reopen + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + 3 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +10 -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +17 -tip +24 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Residence Halls +Close at 5 p.m. -lid +COMMENCEMENT -7. Filter basket -and holder +W H I T M A N . E D U / 11 -8. Function -knob + A U G U S T 2 7 – S E P T E M B E R 1 - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Opening Week Fall 2025 -Making Espresso Coffee +First day. First week. +First of many amazing times ahead. -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +We’re planning quite a kickoff for your Whitman experience. You’ll explore -from the appliance. +Whitman, meet new people, have some fun—all while learning about Whitman’s -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +academic opportunities, the Walla Walla Valley, campus resources, student clubs -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +and more! -carafe. +Stay tuned for more details on Opening Week in Walla Walla, as well as virtual -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +orientation components you will complete over the summer. It will all be in -brewing process – scalding may occur. +Juli’s Monday emails. (See page 1.) -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +OWLS—Your Opening Week Leaders -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Whoooooo’s excited to meet you?! Your OWL. -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +We’ve recruited a group of enthusiastic and wise Whitties—who have been in -Making Cappuccino +your place—to be with you on your first-week journey. They’ll lead small groups -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +of new students during orientation and be a friendly face and helpful resource -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +along the way. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +Your OWL will be in contact with you later in the summer. -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Mindset Moment -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Fail forward. Mistakes are inevitable, +but they’re also valuable learning -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +experiences. View setbacks as -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +stepping stones on the path -function knob to the “OFF” position. +to success. -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +12 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. + Fun with OWLs! +Opening Week Activities +& Adventures -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +During Opening Week, you’ll have the +opportunity to participate in a special +Experience Whitman activity with +our Opening Week Leaders (OWLs) +on Friday, Aug. 29, and Saturday, +Aug. 30. From outdoor adventures to +creative projects to fun and games— +there will be something for everyone! -4 +F A M I L Y O R I E N T A T I O N -5 +Welcoming +Whitman Families - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Family Orientation will be +Thursday, Aug. 28 -Making Espresso Coffee +More information about Family Orientation will be +posted at whitman.edu/families. -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +Mindset Moment -from the appliance. +Practice gratitude. In the midst of busy +schedules and academic pressures, it’s important -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +to pause and appreciate the good things in life. -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +W H I T M A N . E D U / 13 -carafe. + SAVE THE DATE +Student Activities Fair +Monday, Sept. 1 +The Student Activities Fair +will showcase 100+ student clubs +and organizations and will be +held on the Monday before +classes start. -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the + Explore +specific clubs -brewing process – scalding may occur. +S T U D E N T L I F E -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Join & Enjoy! Find +Endless Possibilities -function knob to the “OFF” position. +At Whitman, you’ll find so many ways to get involved, including interest and -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +affinity clubs, club sports, outdoor adventures and so much more! Here are just -Making Cappuccino +a few highlights: -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +Student Clubs, Affinity & Cultural Groups: Whitman students create belonging +through groups based on shared interests, passions, identity, culture, background, -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +religion, etc. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +Club Sports & Intramurals: Team up for sand volleyball, climbing, pickleball, +ultimate, corn hole, skiing—just to name a few sporty options. Find so much to do! -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Debate & Forensics: Whitman’s team is among the most successful collegiate +programs in the country and open to students across class years and majors. -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Outdoor Program (OP): The OP provides countless opportunities to explore outdoor +recreation or to hone your skills in an activity you’re already passionate about. -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +Sorority & Fraternity Life: Whitman’s eight sororities and fraternities offer students +a close-knit community, leadership opportunities and lifelong friendships. -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Mindset Moment -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Celebrate diversity. Whitman is a wonderful melting pot of cultures, +backgrounds and perspectives. Seek out opportunities to learn from -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +those who are different from you. + +14 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + Whitties often use words, acronyms, shorthand or slang that are part of our +shared culture. Here are a few you might hear around campus. + +ARC (say it: “ark”) +The Academic Resource +Center is the home of +academic counseling +and tutoring services. +It is the place to go for +academic support. + +Ank or Ankeny +Ankeny Field is the gorgeous +green field at the heart of +campus—a place for playing, +studying and hanging out +with friends. + +ASWC (say it: “az-wack”) +The Associated Students of +Whitman College represents +student interests on campus, +sponsors all-campus +programming, and funds +student organizations. The +Student Activities office +advises and supports ASWC +in its efforts. + +BFFC +Baker Ferguson Fitness +Center is where to go for a +cardio or weight workout. Also +found at BFFC: Harvey Pool, +which is home to Whitman’s +varsity swim team. + +CCEC +The Career and Community +Engagement Center is +located on the top floor of Reid +Campus Center. It’s where +to go for career coaching, +campus jobs, internships +and more! + +Cleve +Cleveland Commons is +Whitman’s ultramodern dining +hall. Hungry? Love a latte? +From smash burgers to sushi +to smoothies, Cleve has your +cravings covered. + +COWS (say it: “cows”) +The Center for Writing and +Speaking is staffed with peer +tutors. It’s a great place to get +help on a writing or speaking +assignment. + +GAIC (say it: “gack”) +The Glover Alston +Intercultural Center is +a welcoming hub for +connection, support and +cultural celebration— +helping students from all +backgrounds thrive and feel +included at Whitman. + +IHC +Interest House Community. +Each Interest House is +home to 4–10 students +and is centered around a +theme, such as a language, +community or interest. + +J-Caf +Jewett Café is an indoor +gathering and study space +between Jewett Hall +and Lyman House. Get +grab-and-go breakfast and +lunch, as well as coffee from +a local roaster. + +K-Dub +KWCW 90.5 FM is +Whitman’s own radio station. +The K-Dub office and studio +are on the mezzanine level of +Reid Campus Center. + +Lakum Duckum +A Whitman hot spot +along Boyer Avenue, this +geothermal spring has its +own raft of ducks. + +Mem +Memorial Building is home to +many administrative offices. +You can’t miss it—the big +clock tower with bells ringing +on the hour. + +Narnia +A wild and wooded study +nook near Whitman’s Office of +Admission, Penrose House— +not to be confused with +Penrose Library (campus’s +top stop for scholars). + +OP +The Outdoor Program offers +weekend trips, adventures +and courses throughout the +school year. It also includes +the Climbing Center at +Sherwood Center, as well as a +Rental Shop (in the basement +of Reid Campus Center) +where students and others +can rent or purchase outdoor +equipment. + +OWLs (say it: “owls”) +Opening Week Leaders. +This enthusiastic team of +nearly 50 returning students +will help you get your feet +underneath you during +Opening Week. + +QRC +The Queer Resource +Center is a welcoming +and affirming space +committed to supporting +LGBTQIA+ students. + +RAs +Resident Assistants are +students who live in a +residence hall and supervise +a section of students. + +Reid +Reid Campus Center is a +go-to place for student +activities and resources. +Pick up your mail, find a cozy +spot to study, check out the +bookstore, get a coffee or soft +serve, visit the career center, +or just meet up with friends. + +RDs +Resident Directors are +staff members, often recent +college graduates, who live in +a residence hall and supervise +student staff. + +SRs +Senior Residents are RAs +in a first-year hall with +additional responsibilities. + +STEM Hub (say it: “stem”) +An area in the Hall of Science +for student learning and +collaboration—tutoring, +advising, study groups, etc. + +Third Space (3SC) +The Third Space Center +is a dedicated space that +centers the needs of +students of color. It’s a +place for gathering, learning +and thriving. + +WCTS +Whitman College Technology +Services offers help by email +and phone. You can also stop +by their Help Desk in person. + +WEB (say it: “web”) +Whitman Events Board is +a volunteer-driven student +committee which brings +a diverse and dynamic +selection of events to +campus, from speakers to +musical performances to +campus favorites such as +Outdoor Movie Night. + +Whitties (say it: “wit-ees”) +A friendly and familiar way to +refer to Whitman students +and alumni. + +WOOTs (say it: “woots”) +Whitman Outdoor +Orientation Trips are +overnight adventures offered +by the Outdoor Program as +part of Opening Week. + +The Wire +The college newspaper, +written and produced by an +all-student staff. + +Mindset Moment + +Stay organized. With so much going on, it’s easy to feel +overwhelmed. Develop good organizational habits early on to + +help you stay on top of assignments and other commitments. + + Your Health & +Wellness Matters + +At Whitman, we prioritize well-being in many ways—from residence life programs to academic support to student +groups—so all students can thrive and learn. For your specific needs, the Welty Health and Counseling Center, +conveniently located on campus, offers an integrated model of primary health care, counseling and wellness services -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +for all enrolled students. -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Services Available to Students Include: -4 + } Nursing care with licensed staff Monday through Saturday + } Medical provider available for examination and consultation -5 +during business hours - User Maintenance Instructions + } Mental health counseling free of charge, including + +individual counseling, group counseling and one-time +consultation sessions + + } Physical examinations + } Basic lab tests (such as strep tests, urinalysis, mono, etc.) + } Blood draws, which are sent to offsite labs for analysis + } Routine immunizations, including flu shots + } Travel health consultation and immunizations + } Reproductive health and STI (sexually transmitted infection) -Descaling (Continued) +testing and treatment -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet + } Medication management with psychiatric mental health +providers with the exception of stimulant medication +for ADHD -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. + } Medical equipment for loan, such as crutches -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +and wheelchairs -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! + } Health care education, counseling and consultation + } Free teletherapy with our partner UWill, a leading mental +health and wellness solution for college campuses -Descaling + } Reservable rooms for teletherapy visits with -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +offsite providers + + } Access to Whitman’s Sexual Assault Victim’s + +Advocate (SAVA) + + } 24/7 urgent mental health phone line + +On-Campus Care -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Welty Health & +Counseling Center +11 Merriam Street -you would with water. +Walla Walla, WA 99362 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +509-527-5195/5281 -outlet. +16 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. + Your Student Health Portal -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +You’ll be asked to create an account on +our Student Health Portal , accessed with +your Whitman account login. Specific +instructions will be shared in one of Juli’s +Monday emails. -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +By registering through the secure portal, +you can directly enter your required +immunization information, check in for +your appointments, complete new patient +paperwork, send and receive secure +messages with your health care providers +on campus, as well as access lab results +and visit summaries, and obtain copies of +your receipts/statements to send to your +insurance company for reimbursement. -to continue to flow in the carafe. +What To Know About +Health Requirements +Whitman requires you to: -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. + } Provide evidence you received two dos- +es of the measles, mumps and rubella +(MMR) vaccine after your first birthday -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual + } Complete tuberculosis screening -vinegar. Repeat twice. +questions -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the + } Provide health insurance information -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Information about completing these +requirements will be shared through your +Student Health Portal over the summer. -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Meningococcal vaccination is highly +recommended for college students. Learn +more: doh.wa.gov/YouAndYourFamily/ +Immunization/CollegeStudents. -IMPORTANT NOTICE +In addition, Whitman students, faculty and +staff are strongly encouraged to remain +up to date on their seasonal influenza, +COVID-19 and routine health vaccinations. -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Medical Records +& Confidentiality +Your medical record is not part of the +college’s academic records system. It +remains in the electronic health record +only accessible by staff at the Welty Health +and Counseling Center and is strictly +confidential. Medical information can be +released only with written permission, and +you may designate what information is to +be given and to whom it is to be directed. -Thank You +Parents may contact the center with +questions and concerns. However, in -6 +compliance with federal privacy laws, we +are unable to release information regarding +their student’s health records or health +status unless the student has signed a +release of information form specifically +allowing their parents to have access to +their health status or records. -7 +Health Insurance +All Whitman students are required to have +health insurance policy that will cover them +during their time at Whitman. International +students will be enrolled in the required +Lewermark health insurance plan. - User Maintenance Instructions +Whitman Wellness Services +Throughout the academic year, professional +staff at the Welty Health and Counseling +Center lead a variety of workshops and +programs to enhance understanding +of health-related topics and empower +students to make informed decisions +about their physical, mental and +emotional well-being. -Descaling (Continued) +Mindset Moment -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +Practice self-care. College can be demanding, but don’t forget to prioritize +your well-being. Make time for activities that recharge your batteries, -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +whether it’s exercise, listening to music or spending time with friends. -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +W H I T M A N . E D U / 17 -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! + Whitman College Contact Information -Descaling +Academic Resource Center ............................................. 509-527-5898 -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Admission ........................................................................... 509-527-5176 -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Athletics .............................................................................. 509-527-5921 -you would with water. +Bookstore ........................................................................... 509-527-5274 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +Career & Community Engagement Center ................... 509-527-5183 -outlet. +Dean of Students .............................................................. 509-527-5158 -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Dean of the Faculty .......................................................... 509-527-5397 -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Equity, Compliance & Title IX .......................................... 509-522-4314 -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +Financial Aid ...................................................................... 509-527-5178 -to continue to flow in the carafe. +International Student Services ....................................... 509-527-4992 -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +LGBTQIA+ Student Services .......................................... 509-527-5596 -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +Opening Week & New Student Orientation .................. 509-527-5208 -vinegar. Repeat twice. +Outdoor Program .............................................................. 509-522-4395 -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Penrose Library ................................................................. 509-527-5192 -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Post Office ......................................................................... 509-527-5903 -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +President’s Office .............................................................. 509-527-5132 -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Registrar ............................................................................. 509-527-5983 -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Reid Campus Center ......................................................... 509-527-5208 -Thank You +Religious & Spiritual Life .................................................. 509-527-4449 -6 +Residence Life .................................................................. 509-527-5297 -7 +Security ............................................................................... 509-527-5777 - ONE-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY -This Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. product warranty extends to the original consumer purchaser of -the product. -Warranty Duration: This product is warranted to the original consumer purchaser for a period of one -(1) year from the original purchase date. -Warranty Coverage: This product is warranted against defective materials or workmanship. This -warranty is void if the product has been damaged by accident, in shipment, unreasonable use, -misuse, neglect, improper service, commercial use, repairs by unauthorized personnel or other caus- -es not arising out of defects in materials or workmanship. This warranty is effective only if the product -is purchased and operated in the USA, and does not extend to any units which have been used in -violation of written instructions furnished by Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc., or to units which have been -altered or modified or to damage to products or parts thereof which have had the serial number -removed, altered, defaced or rendered illegible. -Warranty Disclaimers: This warranty is in lieu of all warranties expressed or implied and no -representative or person is authorized to assume for Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. any other liability in con- -nection with the sale of our products. There shall be no claims for defects or failure of performance or -product failure under any theory of tort, contract or commercial law including, but not limited to, neg- -ligence, gross negligence, strict liability, breach of warranty and breach of contract. -Warranty Performance: During the above one-year warranty period, a product with a defect will be -either repaired or replaced with a reconditioned comparable model (at Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -option) when the product is returned to the Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. facility within the warranty period -and an additional one-month period. No charge will be made for such repair or replacement. -Service and Repair: Should the appliance malfunction, you should first call toll-free 1-800-233-9054 -between the hours of 9:00 am and 5:00 pm Central Standard Time and ask for CUSTOMER SERVICE -stating that you are a consumer with a problem. -In-Warranty Service (USA) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is made -for service or postage. -In-Warranty Service (Canada) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is -made for service or postage. Please return the product insured, packaged with sufficient protection, -and postage and insurance prepaid to the address listed below. Customs duty/brokerage fee, if any, -must be paid by the consumer. -Out-of-Warranty Service: A flat rate charge by model is made for out-of-warranty service. Include -$15.00 (U.S.) for return shipping and handling. -Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. cannot assume responsibility for loss or damage during incoming shipment. -For your protection, carefully package the product for shipment and insure it with the carrier. Be sure -to enclose the following items with your appliance: any accessories related to your problem; your full -return address and daytime phone number; a note describing the problem you experienced; a copy of -your sales receipt or other proof of purchase to determine warranty status. C.O.D. shipments cannot -be accepted. -Return the appliance to: - -ATTN: Repair Department, Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. - -550 Business Center Drive -Mt. Prospect, IL 60056 -Consumer Service: 1-800-233-9054 -Consumer Parts: 1-800-947-3745 -Hours: 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. CST - -For more information on Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. products: - -visit our website: URL http://www.salton-maxim.com or -E-mail us at SALTON 550@aol.com - -This Melitta product is distributed and serviced by Salton, Inc. -Printed in Switzerland -©2004 Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -®Reg. T.M. of a company of the Melitta Group +Student Accounts ............................................................. 509-527-5143 -8 +Student Activities ............................................................. 509-527-5208 -Part No. 60493 - -LISEZ ET CONSERVEZ CES INSTRUCTIONS -AVERTISSEMENT : Tout appareil électrique présente un risque -d’incendie et de choc électrique pouvant provoquer des blessures -graves ou mortelles. Veuillez observer toutes les mesures de -sécurité. - -Machine à Espresso -& Cappuccino - -’ - -I - -N -E -T -E -R -T -N -E -D -T -E -N -O -T -A -S -L -T -U -D -E -D -U -G - -I - -I - -’ - -I - -I - -B -1 -X -E -M - -, - -I - -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -E -L -E -D -O -M - -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -T -E +Technology Services ......................................................... 509-527-4976 -9 +Welty Health & Counseling Center ..................... 509-527-5195/5281 + +Whitman College is located on the traditional Cayuse, Umatilla and Walla Walla homelands. We pay our +respect to tribal elders both past and present and extend our respect to all Indigenous people today. +We honor their stewardship of the land and ecosystem and commit to continuing that important work. + +Whitman College is deeply committed to the principle of nondiscrimination in all its forms. In its admission, +educational, and employment practices, programs, and activities, the college does not discriminate on the basis of +race, color, sex (including pregnancy and parenting status), gender, gender identity or expression, genetic +information, sexual orientation, religion, age, marital status, national origin, shared ancestry, disability, veteran +status, or any other basis prohibited by the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title IX of the Educational Amendments of 1972, +Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and other applicable federal, state, or local laws. + +202506 diff --git a/q32/random_k2/random_2.md b/q32/random_k2/random_2.md index 2e9f5241e58113455522088c7a6110de8838d130..487dabc7e5008ff4efa01f6fe1aed60936603b9f 100644 --- a/q32/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q32/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,1208 +1,2403 @@ -DUET: Joint Exploration of User–Item Profiles in Recommendation System -YueChen1,*,YifeiSun1,*,LuWang2,†,FangkaiYang2,PuZhao2,MinjieHong3,YifeiDong4,MinghuaHe2, -NanHu2,JianjinZhang2,ZhiweiDai2,YuefengZhan2,WeihaoHan2,HaoSun2, -QingweiLin2,WeiweiDeng2,FengSun2,QiZhang2,SaravanRajmohan2,DongmeiZhang2 -1PekingUniversity2Microsoft3ZhejiangUniversity4KTHRoyalInstituteofTechnology -*Equalcontribution†Correspondingauthor -Abstract -| | | | User History: | Item History: | User History: | Item History: | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -| | | | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | -| | | | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | -Traditionalrecommendationsystemsrepresent ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t -6202 rpA 51 ]RI.sc[ 1v10831.4062:viXra • • Parliament Funk Bass" -| usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearnto | | | Parliament | Funk Bass" | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------------------ | -| | | | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | -aligntheminasharedlatentspaceforrelevance -| | | | | Duet | Independent | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -estimation. RecentLLM-basedrecommenders (Joint Alignment) Generation -| instead leverage | natural-language | representa- | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | -| | | | User Profile: | Item History: | User Profile: | Item History: | -tionsthatareeasiertointerpretandintegrate Enthusiast of A peak-era FUNK- Fan of HEAVY A highly rated POP- -| | | | FUNK and SOUL. | ROCK album with | METAL and | ROCK album with | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------------- | -withdownstreamreasoningmodules. Thispa- Values technical genre-blurring PUNK. Prefers polished -| | | | mastery | creativity. | dark themes. | production. | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------- | -textual -per studies how to construct effective Semantic Alignment ✘ Semantic Mismatch -profilesforusersanditems,andhowtoalign -themforrecommendation. Acentraldifficulty Figure1: DUETalignsrawuseranditemdatabytrans- -| | | | forming them | into textual | profiles within | a shared se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | -isthatthebestprofileformatisnotknownapri- -manticspace. -ori: manuallydesignedtemplatescanbebrittle -| andmisalignedwithtaskobjectives. | | Moreover, | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | to introduce | semantically | rich, human-readable | | -generatinguseranditemprofilesindependently -mayproducedescriptionsthatareindividually representationsforrecommendation(Wangetal., -plausible yet semantically inconsistent for a 2025;Zhang,2024;Baoetal.,2023;Hongetal., -| specificuser–itempair. | WeproposeDUET,an | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | 2025a,b,c;Wangetal.,2024). | | Anaturaldirectionis | | -interaction-awareprofilegeneratorthatjointly -toreplacelatentvectorswithtextualuseranditem -producesuseranditemprofilesconditionedon -profilesthatcanbeinspected,edited,andreusedby -| both user history | and item evidence. | DUET | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downstreamcomponentsincorporatedwithLLMs. -| follows a three-stage | procedure: | it first turns | | | | | -| --------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -However,existingLLM-basedapproachesremain -rawhistoriesandmetadataintocompactcues, -then expands these cues into paired profile limited in two important ways. First, directly -promptsandthengenerateprofiles,andfinally promptinganLLMwithrawuseranditemhisto- -optimizesthegenerationpolicywithreinforce- -riestoobtainrecommendationsoftenyieldsnoisy -mentlearningusingdownstreamrecommenda- andincompletesignals,especiallywhenhistories -| tionperformanceasfeedback. | | Experimentson | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -| | | | are long, | sparse, or heterogeneous | | (Wang et al., | -threereal-worlddatasetsshowthatDUETcon- -| | | | 2025). Second, | profile-based | methods | typically | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | -sistentlyoutperformsstrongbaselines,demon- -relyonmanuallydesignedtemplatesorhandcrafted -stratingthebenefitsoftemplate-freeprofileex- -attributes,whichrequiressubstantialhumanengi- -plorationandjointuser–itemtextualalignment. -Project code page: https://github.com/duet- neering and constrains the representation space. -review/duet_code. More fundamentally, many approaches generate -userprofilesanditemprofilesindependently,with- -1 Introduction -| | | | out modeling | how user | preferences | and item se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -Traditional recommendation systems represent manticsinteractatdecisiontime(Yangetal.,2023; -Xietal.,2024). -usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearntoalign -theminasharedlatentspaceforrelevanceestima- Toaddressthesechallenges,wepropose DUET, -tion (Covington et al., 2016; Wu, 2023). While ajointuser–itemprofilegeneratorthattakesboth -effective,suchembeddingsareopaque: theyoffer userhistoryanditemhistoryasinputandproduces -limitedinterpretabilityandmakeitdifficulttoan- a paired set of profiles for the interaction. Cru- -alyzewhyanitemisrecommended. Recentwork cially, DUET doesnotrequireprofiletemplates: it -thereforeleverageslargelanguagemodels(LLMs) istrainedwithreinforcementlearningusingfeed- - -back from downstream recommendation perfor- asseeninworkslikeCRESDUP(Chenetal.,2007) -mance,enablingittoexploreanddiscovereffective andUPCSim(Widiyaningtyasetal.,2021). While -profileformatsautomatically. Figure1illustrates foundational,thesemethodswerelimitedbytheir -whyjointprofilingmatters. Theuserhaslistened rigid,hand-engineeredfeatures. Morerecently,the -toMisfits(punk),IronMaiden(metal),andParlia- adventofLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)hasen- -ment(funk),whilethecandidatealbumisdescribed abledashifttowardsgeneratingprofilesinnatural -byreviewssuchas“polishedpop”and“greatfunk language. Studies such as KAR (Xi et al., 2024), -bass”andametatag“’80srock.” Consideringboth GPG(Zhang,2024),PALR(Yangetal.,2023),and -sides together, DUET can reconcile these signals LettinGo (Wang et al., 2025) leverage LLMs to -intoacompatibleinterpretation(e.g.,highlighting createtextualuserprofilesfrombehavioraldata. A -the user’s funk/soul affinity and the item’s funk- keylimitationoftheseapproachesistwofold: they -rockcharacter). Incontrast,independentlygener- relyonstaticorpre-definedtemplatesforprofile -atedprofilesmayamplifydifferentfacets,summa- generation,andtheyoftenfocusexclusivelyonuser -rizingtheuseras“heavymetal/punk”whilesum- profiles,neglectingtherich,expressiveinformation -marizingtheitemas“pop-rock”,whichresultingin inherentinitemsandthecomplexdynamicsofuser- -asemanticallymismatchedpairthatobscuresthe iteminteractions. Incontrast,ourworkintroduces -truerelevancesignal. anewparadigmwherebothuseranditemprofiles -DUETproceedsinthreestages. First,rawhisto- arenotfixedbutaredynamicallyexploredandop- -ries and metadata are distilled into minimal cues timizedinasharedsemanticspacetodirectlyalign -thatcapturecompactbutinformativesignals. Sec- withrecommendationperformance. -ond, the model expands cues into richer profile -prompts to generate textual profiles, allowing ex- 2.2 ReinforcementLearningforLLM-Based -plorationoveralternativeprofilestructuresandem- RecommendationSystems -phases. Third,theresultingprofilesareconsumed -ReinforcementLearning(RL),particularlythrough -bydownstreamrecommenders,andtheirtaskfeed- -techniqueslikeRLHF,hasbecomeacoremethod -backisusedtooptimizetheprofilegenerationpol- -for aligning LLMs with specific objectives. This -icy. By coupling both sides in a shared semantic -approach has been adapted for recommendation -space,DUETlearnsuserprofilesthatreflectwhat -tasks (Wang et al., 2025; Lin et al., 2025; Deng -kindsofitemsauserprefersanditemprofilesthat -etal.,2025),butexistingeffortsoftenfacekeylimi- -reflectwhatkindsofusersanitemappealsto. -tations. Theyfrequentlyrelyonofflinerewardmod- -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: -els(Jeongetal.,2023;Chenetal.,2025;Heetal., -• Werepresentusersanditemsasnatural-language 2025; Liu et al., 2025) that do not adapt in real- -profiles and align them in a shared semantic timetosystemfeedback,asetupthatrisksissues -space,extendingtheclassicvector-basedalign- like reward hacking (Skalse et al., 2025). Other -mentprincipletointerpretabletextualrepresenta- methods(Sunetal.,2024;Luetal.,2024)restrict -tions. themselvestoofflinepreferencetuning(e.g.,DPO), -• We introduce an exploration-based framework which can easily overfit on static datasets. Our -thatstartsfromcue-basedinitialization,expands framework, DUET,overcomesthesechallengesby -cuesintocandidateprofiles,andjointlyoptimizes integrating RL into a closed-loop system where -user and item profiles with downstream recom- downstreamrecommendationperformanceserves -mendationfeedbackviareinforcementlearning, asthereal-timerewardsignal,allowingforthedy- -avoidingrigidtemplates. namicandinteractiverefinementoftextualprofiles. -• Extensiveexperimentsacrossmultiplereal-world -datasets show that DUET consistently outper- 3 Method -formsstrongbaselines,validatingbothjointpro- -filingandfeedback-drivenprofileoptimization. DUET is a closed-loop framework that trans- -forms raw user–item interaction histories into -2 RelatedWork performance-aligned textual profiles through -learnedrepresentationstrategies. AsshowninFig- -2.1 ProfilesinRecommendation -ure 2, DUET consists of three stages. (1) Cue- -Earlyrecommendationsystemsprimarilyreliedon Based Initialization distills interaction histories -pre-definedprofilesbasedonstructuredattributes, intoconciseevidence-basedcues. (2)JointExplo- - -CUE-BASED INITIALIZATION JOINT EXPLORATION ON-POLICY OPTIMIZATION -| | | | | Item | DU | | | Duet | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| ItemHistory | | | | | ET | | | | | | | -Initial CUE -Rated: Baba Is You (5★) -User: “Prefers retro puzzle games” -Reviewed: “I love logic- -Item: “Retro-style indie puzzle game” -| | | | based puzzle games.” | | | Profile Prompt | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rated: The Witness (5★) -User: “Describe the user's typical -| | | | Rated: Fez (4★) | | puzzle-game preferences … | | | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒1 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒2 | … | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑛 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -Item: “… item's core mechanics… -| | | | | | | | Profile | Downstream Task Env | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ---- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | User | User: “A player who enjoys logic- | | | | | | | -| UserHistory | | | | | intensive indie puzzle games, | | | | | | | -| | | | Category: Indie Puzzle | | | | | Ranking correctness | | | | -prefers retro visual aesthetics…” -| | | | Game | | | | | &format Reward | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Reviews: -Item: “A retro-style indie puzzle -| | | | “Challenging logic | | game featuring challenging | | | Group Computation | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | mechanics.” | | logic mechanics that appeal to | | | | | | | -| | | | “ R e t r o p ix | e l- a rt st y l e . ” | hardcore puzzle players.” | | | 𝐴𝑑𝑣1 𝐴𝑑𝑣2 | | | | -| | | | “ H a r d b u | t re w a r d i n g . ” | | | | | … | 𝐴𝑑𝑣𝑛 | | -| | | | | Figure2: | OverviewoftheDUETframework. | | | | | | | -ration via Adaptive Profile Prompt Discovery 3.2 Cue-BasedInitialization -| jointly | explores | user-item’s | | profile prompts | that | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Raw user | histories | and item | metadata | | are often | -| define how | user | and item | profiles | should | be writ- | | | | | | | -noisy,redundant,andnotdirectlysuitableforpro- -ten. (3)OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -| | | | | | | fileconstruction. | | Toaddressthis,DUETintroduces | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -jointlyoptimizesuseranditemprofilesunderdown- -theconceptofcues: -concisehypothesesthatsum- -streamrecommendationfeedback. -| | | | | | | marize minimal | | but informative | | aspects | of users | -| ------------------- | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | -| All three | stages | are | realized | through | a single | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | and items. | These | cues act | as lightweight | | seeds, | -| passinputandoutput: | | | cueextraction,self-prompt | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | which are | deliberately | underspecified | | so | that the | -construction,andprofilegenerationareproduced -systemcansubsequentlyexplorericherprofilefor- -inasinglesequence-to-sequencegenerationpass -mats. -atinferencetime,enablingefficientdeployment. -| | | | | | | Definition1(Cue). | | Acueisaminimaltextualhy- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.1 ProblemFormulation -pothesisderivedfromhistoricaldatathathighlights -WeformulateprofilegenerationinDUETasanon- one potential aspect of a user’s preference or an -policyreinforcementlearningproblem,motivated item’scharacteristic. Ratherthanaimingforcom- -bytheabsenceofanytextualgroundtruthdefining pleteness, cues capture partial but salient signals -an optimal user or item profile. Profile quality is thatserveasstartingpointsforprofileexploration. -evaluatedsolelybyitsfunctionalutilityinafixed -| | | | | | | To extract | cues | automatically, | | the | LLM is | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -recommendationenvironment. -| | | | | | | prompted | to summarize | minimal | | but informative | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| DUET | is modeled | as | a generative | policy | π θ in- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | aspectsofuseroritemdata. | | | Forexample,givena | | | -teractingwithafrozendownstreamrecommender. -user’sinteractionhistory,themodelisguidedwith -| For each | user–item | pair, | the | state is | defined as | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -instructionssuchas: -| s = {H | ,H },whereH | | andH | denotetheuser | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | u i | | u | i | | | | | | | | -and item interaction histories. An action corre- CueExtractionPrompt -spondstoasingle-passjointgeneration -“Fromthehistorybelow,analyzetheuser’s -a = {C u ,S u ,P u ,C i ,S i ,P i }, historicalinteractionstounderstandprefer- -ences,ratingbehavior,reviewsentimentor -| where | (C ,C | ) are | cues | distilled | from his- | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u i -| | | | | | | anyotherdimension. | | Keepthedescription | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| tory, (S | u ,S i ) are | constructed | | user-item’s | profile | | | | | | | -prompts,and(P ,P )arethefinaltextualprofiles. conciseandavoidfullsentences.” -u i -| Thepolicyπ | | (a | s)definesajointdistribution | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θ -over the entire generation sequence. As an on- This lightweight guidance allows the LLM to -policy agent, DUET is optimized using rewards maprawhistoriesandmetadataintocompacttex- -from its own sampled generations rather than by tualcues. Thedetaildexampleofcuecanbefound -| imitatingfixedsummaries. | | | | | | inAppendixA.3. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| 3.3 | JointExplorationviaAdaptiveProfile | | | | | | Single-PassInput | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PromptDiscovery Task:Generatestructuredprofilesfortheuseranditemfrom -historicaldata. -Aftercueextraction,DUETdoesnotdirectlysum- Combined Context: [User History H u ] + [Item -| | | | | | | | History | H i ]+[Avg | Ratings] | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| marizeuserinterestsoritemattributes. | | | | | | Instead,it | | | | | | | -“First,extractaconciseCueforbothuseranditem.Second, -| explores | | the space | of profile | construction | | strate- | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -basedonthecues,constructaProfilePromptthatdefines -gies—natural-languagepromptsthatdefinethefor- thedescriptionlogic.Finally,generatetheProfileguidedby -theconstructedProfilePrompt.” -mat,abstractionlevel,andattributeselectionlogic -↓DUETForwardPass↓ -| usedtogenerateprofiles. | | | | Explorationistherefore | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| performedoverhowprofilesshouldbeconstructed, | | | | | | | Single-PassOutput | | | | | | -User -ratherthanoversuperficialtextualparaphrases. -Cue:“prefersnostalgiclogic-basedchallenges” -For each user–item pair, DUET intro- Profileprompt: “Focuson1990svisualaestheticsand -| duces | an | explicit | intermediate | | variable, | the | strategicdepth.” | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | Profile: | “A player | who | seeks | retro-style | visual charm | -constructed_prompt,whichservesasadiscrete -pairedwithdeepstrategicreasoning.” -| and | interpretable | | profile | prompt | S. | This profile | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Item -promptisashortnatural-languageinstruction(e.g., -Cue:“retro-styleindiepuzzlewithhighdifficulty” -“Describetheuser’stypicalgamingpreferencesand -| | | | | | | | Profile | prompt: | “Describe | | pixel-art | graphics and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | -engagementpatterns”)thatspecifieswhataspects intellectualdifficultytomatchlogicpreference.” -Profile:“A2Dexperiencefeaturingpixelatednostalgia -| to | describe | and | how to | organize | them, | without | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andchallengingmechanicsthatdemandlogicaldeduction.” -| containingtheprofilecontentitself. | | | | | | Conditioned | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onS,themodelgeneratesthefinaluseranditem Figure3: Single-passgenerationinDUET: cueextrac- -| profiles. | | | | | | | tion,profileprompt(constructedprompt),andprofile | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -generationareproducedinonepassforbothuserand -| Exploration | | | is driven | by treating | | the profile | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -item. -| promptS | | asastochasticactionsampledfromthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| policyπ | | (S | Cue). | Duringtraining,theagentsam- | | | | | | | | | | -θ -plesdifferentprofilepromptinstructions,executes -| | | | | | | | andintellectualdifficulty”tomatch. | | | | | RLreinforces | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -| themtogenerateprofilepairs(P | | | | | ,P ),andreceives | | | | | | | | -u i -thissharedsemanticdirection,suppressingirrele- -| a reward | | based | on downstream | | recommendation | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | -| | | | | | | | vant signals | and | forcing | the | final | profiles to con- | -| accuracy. | | Thepolicyisoptimizedtoreinforcepro- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | verge | into a shared | semantic | | space | of nostalgia | -filepromptsthatconsistentlyyieldhigherrewards, -andlogic,significantlyimprovingrecommendation -enablingthemodeltoactivelysearchforeffective -accuracy. -profileconstructionformats. -Thisprocessisrealizedasaunifiedgeneration -3.4 OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -pass, -| | | | | | | | On-policy | optimization. | | | We train | the profile | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -O = [ Cue → profilepromptS → Profile], generator π in an on-policy manner against a -| | (cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125) | | | | | (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) | | θ | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (cid:124) | (cid:123)(cid:122) | (cid:125) | | | | | | | | -Context ProfileConstructionPrompt Execution frozendownstreammodelf, whichservesasthe -| | | | | | | (1) | environment | critic. | For | each | sampled | user–item | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | -wheretheprofilepromptS parameterizesthepro- pair (u,i), the policy generates (P ,P ) and re- -u i -filegenerator. Atinferencetime,DUETcollapses ceivesascalarrewardbasedonthepredictionac- -thelearnedprofilepromptdistributionandgreed- curacy of f(P ,P ). The policy parameters are -u i -ilyexecutestheoptimalprofilepromptinasingle updatedtoreinforcegenerationsthatleadtolower -| forwardpass,introducingnoadditionallatency. | | | | | | | predictionerror. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| Example | | of profile | prompt | Exploration. | | As | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Continuousfractionalreward. | | | | | Usingdiscrete | -| illustrated | | in Figure | 3, | DUET | resolves | this by | | | | | | | -integerratingsasrewardsleadstosparseandunsta- -| identifying | | a shared | context | in | a single | forward | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -blefeedback,asnear-misspredictions(e.g.,predict- -pass. ThepolicyextractsacoordinatedCue(e.g., -ing4foragroundtruth5)receivethesamepenalty -“prefersretropuzzlegames”)andconstructsapro- -| | | | | | | | assevereerrors. | | Toprovidedenseandinformative | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| file | prompt | (the | constructed_prompt) | | | that in- | | | | | | | -feedback,wedefineacontinuousfractionalreward: -structsthemodeltohighlight“nostalgicaesthetics -| and | strategic | logic” | for | the user, | while | simulta- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | |y −yˆ | | | -| | | | | | | | | R (u,i) | | = 1− | ui | ui , (2) | -| neously | describing | | the item’s | “pixel-art | | graphics | | perf | | | | | -M - -where yˆ ui = f(P u ,P i ) is the predicted relevance ingsettingbasedondownstreampredictedrating -score and M is the maximum rating gap (e.g., scores. For each observed user–item interaction, -M = 4 for a 1–5 scale). This reward provides we randomly sample nine items that the user has -fine-grainedgradientsthatencourageincremental not interacted with to form a candidate set of ten -improvementsinrecommendationaccuracy. items, which are ranked in descending order ac- -We adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization cordingtotheirpredictedratings. Theground-truth -(GRPO) (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025) to optimize interacted item is treated as the only positive in- -theprofilegeneratorundertheabovereward. The stance,andweadoptNDCG@Kastheevaluation -downstreamrecommenderf isfrozenthroughout metric, with K set to 1, 5, and 10, to assess how -training, which yields a stable policy optimiza- effectivelythelearnedprofilessupportcorrectitem -| tionsettingandpreventsrewarddriftorfeedback- | | | | ranking. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | Baselines | We compare | our method | with | several | -inducedrepresentationcollapse. -| | | | | representative | baselines. | 10H | directly | uses the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -4 Experiment mostrecentinteractionhistoriesforpredictionwith- -| | | | | outconstructingexplicitprofiles. | | | KAR(Xietal., | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -4.1 ExperimentalSettings -2024)augmentsrecommendationmodelswithex- -Datasets. Experiments were conducted on three ternalreasoningknowledgeaboutuserpreferences -widelyusedreal-worlddatasets. AmazonMusic andfactualknowledgeaboutitemsextractedfrom -(Music) and Amazon Book (Book) are derived LLMs,whicharetransformedintotask-compatible -fromtheAmazonProductdataset1,whileYelpis representations. RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)lever- -fromtheYelpOpendataset2. Alldatasetsinclude agesLLMstolearnsemanticuseranditemrepre- -userreviews,ratings,andrichtextualinformation. sentationsfromtextualsignalsandalignsthemwith -WeusedthefullAmazonMusicdataset,butonly collaborativerelationalinformationthroughcross- -subsets (latest two months for Book and six for viewrepresentationlearning. PALR(Yangetal., -Yelp). Data was split by timestamp into training, 2023)fine-tunesalargelanguagemodelasarank- -validation,andtestsetstopreventinformationleak- ing component that selects preferred items from -age(Jietal.,2023). retrievedcandidatesexpressedinnaturallanguage. -EvaluationMetrics LG (LettinGo) (Wang et al., 2025) explores di- -For each observed user–item interaction (i.e., verseuserprofilecandidateswithLLMsandaligns -a review record), we construct the evaluation profilegenerationwithdownstreamrecommenda- -instance based on the user’s interaction history tionperformanceviapreferenceoptimization. Rea- -strictly prior to the corresponding timestamp. son4Rec(Fangetal.,2025)introducesadelibera- -tiverecommendationframeworkthatincorporates -Specifically,theuser’srecenthistoricalinteractions -beforethecurrentinteractionareusedtogenerate explicitstep-wisereasoningoveruserpreferences -auserprofile,whilehistoricalreviewsfromother toguideratingprediction. -| users are used | to generate | an item profile. | The | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -4.2 MainResults -downstreamrecommendationsystemthenpredicts -theratingofthetargetitemconditionedontwoin- Table 1 presents a comparison of our proposed -puts: thegenerateduserprofile,andthegenerated method against five baselines on three datasets: -| | | | | Amazon | Music, Amazon | Books, | and | Yelp. We | -| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| itemprofile. | Anexceptionisthe10Hbaseline,for | | | | | | | | -which the downstream model directly consumes use Qwen3-8B (Team, 2025) and LLaMA3-8B -therawrecentinteractionhistories. (Dubey et al., 2024) as both the profile generator -andthedownstreamrecommendationmodel,with -| We evaluate | performance | using four | widely | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | a prediction | temperature | of 0. | In addition | to rat- | -| adopted metrics | (Wang | et al., 2025; Fang | et al., | | | | | | -2025): MeanAbsoluteError(MAE),RootMean ingpredictionresults,wealsoreportranking-based -SquareError(RMSE),Accuracy,andF1score. evaluation results in Table ??, which assess the -effectivenessofthelearnedprofilesfromadown- -Inadditiontoratingprediction,wefurtherevaluate -thegenerateduseranditemprofilesunderarank- streamrankingperspective. -| | | | | Overallsuperiorityoverstrongbaselines. | | | | As | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ shown in Table 1, our method consistently out- -amazon/links.html -| | | | | performs | the strongest | baselines | across | all three | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -2https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -| open-dataset/ | | | | datasetsunderbothQwen3-8BandLLaMA3-8B. | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) -(%) (%) (%) -Qwen3(8B) -10H 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.7396 1.2184 55.34 48.67 0.7483 1.1380 58.65 60.29 0.7098 1.0923 56.17 58.78 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.8197 1.3312 47.15 42.46 0.7438 1.1069 54.89 57.65 0.7812 1.1584 52.86 55.93 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7994 1.2876 48.53 43.19 0.6075 0.9531 57.35 56.77 0.7485 1.1187 54.24 56.38 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7028 1.1523 55.69 47.73 0.5654 0.9635 58.69 54.67 0.6397 1.0098 58.47 56.84 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -LLaMA3(8B) -10H 1.0864 1.9532 22.09 27.30 0.7917 1.3346 38.13 46.87 0.8064 1.3866 37.15 45.27 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.6427 1.1668 54.51 47.98 0.5726 0.9033 57.53 59.92 0.5892 0.9614 55.87 58.21 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.7428 1.3572 46.74 42.11 0.6076 0.9886 53.78 57.42 0.6226 0.9477 52.12 55.79 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7238 1.3265 47.72 43.29 0.5823 0.9222 56.73 59.31 0.5977 0.8855 55.06 57.62 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6196 1.1289 56.03 51.24 0.5204 0.9369 61.92 59.50 0.5543 0.7967 58.95 60.39 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7586 1.0418 55.80 53.00 0.5442 0.7722 60.86 54.88 0.6029 0.8345 59.70 56.35 -Ours 0.5367 0.9687 60.87 54.74 0.4680 0.8277 63.30 60.60 0.5092 0.9500 63.42 58.12 -Table1: PerformanceonthreedatasetsusingQwen3(8B)andLLaMA3(8B). -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -Table2: RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. -Under Qwen3-8B, our method achieves an accu- our approach reaches an NDCG@1 of 0.5619 -racyof61.23%onYelp,67.96%onAmazonMu- and an NDCG@10 of 0.7443, clearly outper- -sicand64.38%onAmazonBooks,surpassingLG forming the strongest baseline methods. Similar -(LettinGo)(Wangetal.,2025)by5.05%,5.59% trendsareobservedonAmazonMusic,whereour -and5.03%,respectively. Similarimprovementsare methodattains0.5347atNDCG@1and0.7331at -observed under LLaMA3-8B, indicating that the NDCG@10, as well as on Amazon Books with -gainsarestableacrossbackbonemodels. NDCG@1 of 0.4866 and NDCG@10 of 0.7107. -Theseresultsindicatethatthelearnedprofilesen- -Advantages over fixed-structure and delib- -able more accurate identification and ordering of -erative baselines. Compared with strong fixed- -relevantitemswithincandidatesets,leadingtosu- -structureordeliberativemethodssuchasKAR(Xi -perior ranking quality in downstream recommen- -etal.,2024)andReason4Rec(Fangetal.,2025), -dation. Wefurtherevaluaterankingperformance -our approach consistently achieves lower predic- -under a more challenging setting using EASE- -tion error and higher accuracy. For example, on -based (Steck, 2019) hard negatives, and observe -Amazon Books with Qwen3-8B, our method re- -consistentimprovements;detailedresultsarepro- -duces MAE to 0.4612, compared to 0.7098 for -videdinAppendixB.2. -KARand0.6397forReason4Rec,demonstrating -moreeffectiveabstractionofuserpreferenceswith- -4.3 AblationStudy -outrelyingonpredefinedreasoningtemplates. -Consistent improvements in downstream Effectivenessofprofilegeneration,cue&strategy, -ranking. Table??reportstherankingresultsun- anduser–itemjointoptimization. Table3reports -der the Qwen3-8B backbone. Our method con- the ablation results under different design con- -sistentlyachievesthebestperformanceacrossall figurations. Starting from the history-only base- -three datasets and evaluation cutoffs. On Yelp, line (10H), introducing explicit profile genera- - -| Method | | | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 | MAE RMSE | Acc F1 | -10H(HistoryOnly) 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -Profile 0.7218 1.1863 55.48 48.09 0.6597 1.0218 58.67 57.48 0.6764 1.0469 57.14 57.68 -Profile+Cue&Strategy 0.7085 1.1654 55.83 48.54 0.5708 0.9897 58.91 55.53 0.6389 1.0108 58.43 56.88 -Profile+JointOpt.(LG(Wang 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -etal.,2025)) -Profile+Cue&Strategy+ 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -JointOpt.(Ours) -Table3: AblationstudyondifferentdesignconfigurationsinDUETusingQwen3(8B). -| Method | | Yelp | | | | AmazonMusic | | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | | (%) | -10H+30P 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3883 0.7494 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 65.13 59.97 -10H+50P 0.4909 0.9207 62.43 56.24 0.3924 0.7543 67.88 63.87 0.4553 0.9023 64.62 59.52 -10H+70P 0.4987 0.9326 61.98 55.81 0.3937 0.7564 68.22 64.12 0.4608 0.9068 64.38 59.27 -Table4: Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofilequality(usingQwen3(8B)). -tionyieldssubstantialperformanceimprovements jointoptimizationarecombined. Underthisfull -across all datasets. For example, on Yelp, MAE configuration, accuracy reaches 61.23% on Yelp, -isreducedfrom1.1235to0.7218andaccuracyin- 67.96%onAmazonMusic,and64.38%onAma- -creases from 23.17% to 55.48%, confirming that zon Books, with corresponding MAE values of -textualprofilesprovidesignificantlymoreinforma- 0.5126, 0.3937, and 0.4612, respectively. Com- -tiverepresentationsthanrawinteractionhistories. pared with the LettinGo-style configuration, this -| | | | | | | setting | yields | consistent | | improvements | across all | -| ------ | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | -| Adding | the cue&strategy | | layer | on | top of | pro- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | datasets. | | Overall,theablationresultsindicatethat | | | | -filegenerationleadstomodestbutconsistentgains. -whileprofilegenerationandjointoptimization -OnAmazonMusic,MAEfurtherdecreasesfrom -0.6597to0.5708,whileaccuracyslightlyimproves contributesubstantiallytoperformancegains,inte- -gratingcue&strategydiscoveryfurtherenhances -| from58.67%to58.91%. | | | Althoughthenumerical | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | the | effectiveness | | of joint | user–item | optimization | -improvementsintroducedbystrategyalonearelim- -ited, these results suggest that strategy discovery byprovidingastructuredspaceforexplorationand -refinement. -primarilyreshapeshowpreferenceinformationis -abstractedandexpressed,ratherthandirectlyopti- Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofile -mizingpredictionaccuracyinisolation. -| | | | | | | quality. | | Table | 4 analyzes | the | impact of histori- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | -Whenenablingjointoptimizationwithoutstrat- cal interaction length on profile quality. Across -thethreedatasets,varyingthenumberofhistorical -| egy (i.e., | the LettinGo | (Wang | et | al., 2025)-style | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -configuration),performanceimprovesmorenotice- interactions leads to only moderate performance -ablyacrossdatasets. OnAmazonMusic,accuracy differences, indicating that our method does not -| | | | | | | strongly | | depend | on long | histories. | In particular, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | -increasesto62.37%,comparedto58.67%withpro- -filegenerationalone. Inourimplementation,this usingamoderatehistorylength(e.g.,30–50inter- -settingcorrespondstoareproductionofLettinGo, actions)alreadyachievescompetitiveorbestper- -whereprofilegenerationandjointoptimizationare formanceonmostmetrics,whilefurtherincreasing -thehistorylengthprovideslimitedadditionalgains. -| appliedwithoutthestrategylayer. | | | | Whiletheorig- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| inal method | focuses | primarily | on | user | profiling, | | | | | | | -OnYelpandAmazonBooks,extendingthehis- -weextendtheoptimizationtobothuseranditem -torylengthbeyondthisrangedoesnotconsistently -profilestoensureafaircomparison. improveaccuracyorF1scoreandmayslightlyde- -Thestrongestandmostconsistentperformance gradeperformance,suggestingthatexcessivehis- -is achieved when cue&strategy discovery and toricalinteractionscanintroducenoisyorlessrele- - -vantsignals. Incontrast,AmazonMusicexhibits maintaining comparable coverage. Compared to -relativelystableperformanceacrossdifferenthis- existing methods, which either rely on extractive -torylengths,indicatingthatuserpreferencesinthis compression(e.g.,KAR(Xietal.,2024))orgener- -domainarelesssensitivetohistorytruncation. atefree-formdescriptionswithweakergrounding -Necessity of RL-based Optimization. We com- (e.g.,RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)andPALR(Yang -pare the full model with a variant without RL etal.,2023)), DUET consistentlyattainsstronger -(DUET W/O RL) to isolate the effect of RL. As alignment without sacrificing coverage. For in- -showninTable5,removingRLleadstosubstantial stance,LG(Wangetal.,2025)achievesrelatively -performancedegradationacrossalldatasets(e.g., highalignmentbutexhibitslessstablegrounding -YelpAccuracydropsfrom61.23%to48.53%),indi- acrossdatasets,whileRLMRecattainshighercov- -catingthatthegainscannotbeattributedtoprompt erageatthecostofweakersemanticalignment. In -| designalone. | | | | | contrast,DUETmaintainsbothhighalignmentand | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Without RL, the generator reduces to a static mid-to-highcoverage,suggestingamoreeffective -mapping from interaction history to textual pro- balancebetweensemanticabstractionandevidence -| files,lackingadaptiveselectionofrelevantsignals. | | | | | preservation. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Incontrast,RLenablesoptimizingprofileconstruc- -4.5 CaseStudy -tionunderrewardfeedback,resultinginmoredis- -Figure4presentsarepresentativecasestudythat -| criminative | representations.These | | results | demon- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -strate that RL-based optimization is essential for demonstrates how semantically aligned user and -| DUET | . | | | | itemprofiles | enableaccurate | | prediction | | thattran- | -| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -scendsthelimitationsofsparserawinteractionhis- -4.4 SemanticAnalysisofGeneratedProfiles tories. In the user profile, initially scattered and -To better understand the source of performance fragmentedpreferencecuesaresystematicallydis- -gains, we analyze whether the generated profiles tilled into a stable and coherent preference struc- -exhibitmeaningfulsemanticpropertiesratherthan turefavoringfunk,soul,andprogressiverock(or- -servingasintermediatetextualartifacts. Weintro- ange), coupled with a pronounced emphasis on -duce two complementary metrics to characterize musicalcomplexityandhistoricalsignificance(pur- -semanticcompatibilityandgrounding. ple). Thecorrespondingitemprofileexhibitsstrik- -Semantic Alignment. We measure the ingsymmetry,characterizingthealbumasanexem- -embedding-levelsimilaritybetweengenerateduser plaryfunk-rockcomposition(orange)andposition- -anditemprofilesusingall-mpnet-base-v2from ingitasadefiningandculturallyinfluentialrelease -Sentence-Transformers (Reimers and Gurevych, of the 1970s (purple). This example shows 519 -2019). Foreachuser–itempair,wecomputecosine that the learned profiles capture meaningful pref- -| similarity: | | | | | erence–attributecorrespondencethatisdifficultto | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | e ·e | | recoverfromindividualreviewsalone. | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | | | | | | | -| | Align(u,i) | = | | (3) | | | | | | | -| | | | ∥e ∥∥e ∥ | | | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | 5 Conclusion | | | | | | -| wheree | ande denotetheembeddingvectorsof | | | | | | | | | | -| | u i | | | | In this | paper, we | propose | DUET | , a | closed-loop | -| thegenerateduseranditemprofiles. | | | Highervalues | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | framework | for | jointly | generating | user | and item | -indicatestrongersemanticcompatibilitybetween -| | | | | | textualprofilesforrecommendation. | | | | | Unlikeprior | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -modeleduserpreferencesanditemcharacteristics. -| | | | | | methods | that rely | on | fixed templates | | or indepen- | -| -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | -| Coverage | (Faithfulness). | | We measure | token- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | dently | constructed | profiles, | DUET | | treats profile | -levelgroundingas: -| | | | | | generation | as an | exploration | problem | | and aligns | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -|Tokens(profile)∩Tokens(history)| representations directly with downstream recom- -Cov = -| | | |Tokens(profile)| | | | mendationperformance. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | (4) | Specifically, | | DUET | integrates | cue-based | ini- | -Thismetricquantifieshowmuchofthegenerated tialization, adaptive strategy construction, and -profileissupportedbyhistoricaltextualevidence. feedback-drivenjointoptimizationtoproduceflex- -We report coverage separately for user and item ible yet task-aligned user–item profiles. By opti- -| profiles. | | | | | mizing | both profiles | in | a shared | semantic | space, | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | -AsshowninTable6,DUETachievesthehigh- theframeworkreducessemanticmismatchandcap- -est semantic alignment across all datasets while turesinteraction-relevantsignalsthataredifficultto - -Setting Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 -(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) -DUETw/oRL 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -DUET(full) 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table5: EffectofRL-basedoptimization(usingQwen3(8B)). -User History: -Andre' S Grindle "Tour of U.S.A.", Rating: 5.0. If your looking for heavy metals dim orgins look no further. -Andre' S Grindle "Misfits", Rating:4.0. Actually the opening title track is more of a direct pop/rock type song. But the rock n roll -returns in a big way on "Hay Fever". -............ -Item History: -Worlds Away, Rating: 4.0, Review: The CD is wonderful, and is a seminal piece of music for both the group and for those of us who -were 'of age' in the '70s and '80s. Pablo Cruise was - and is - a group that makes beautiful music like few others, and this -shipper/seller made it all the more special with a fast ship! THANKS!!! -Worlds Away, Rating: 5.0, I love this CD! I'd recommend the Pablo Cruise Millenium Collection to get to know this band. Worlds Away to -me represents the best of breezy '70s pop. Five stars! -............ -USER PROFILE: -Andre Grindle is a dedicated music enthusiast with a deep appreciation for funk, soul, and progressive rock, particularly drawn to artists -who blend technical mastery with genre-defining innovation. His reviews consistently highlight albums that showcase musical complexity, -lyrical depth, and historical significance, often referencing artists like Stevie Wonder, Prince, and Rush. He values authenticity and -artistic vision, frequently praising albums that resist trend-chasing and prioritize creative integrity. His detailed, introspective reviews -suggest a preference for nuanced analysis over superficial praise, with a focus on emotional resonance, production quality, and the -artist's evolution. While he is generous with high ratings (often 5.0), he is also willing to critique perceived shortcomings, as seen in his -4.0 for "Test for Echo" and 3.0 for "The Color of Success." His engagement is characterized by a blend of personal anecdotes, technical -appreciation, and historical context, indicating a preference for music that transcends mere entertainment. -Item PROFILE: -"Worlds Away" by Pablo Cruise is celebrated as a peak-era funk-rock album that exemplifies the band's ability to merge polished -production with genre-blurring creativity. Users consistently praise its tight musicianship, genre-defying sound, and the band's ability to -craft catchy, emotionally resonant tracks. The album's appeal lies in its seamless fusion of rock, funk, and pop, with standout tracks like -"Love Will Find a Way" and "Worlds Away" receiving particular acclaim for their infectious melodies and lyrical depth. While some users -note its dated production compared to modern standards, the majority highlight its historical significance as a defining work of the -1970s rock-funk movement. The album resonates most with fans of 1970s progressive rock, genre-defying artists, and listeners seeking -well-crafted, emotionally engaging music. Its high average rating reflects widespread admiration for its artistic ambition and enduring -appeal, though a minority acknowledges its limitations in terms of modern production quality. -Figure4: Illustrationofthemutualcorrespondencebetweenuseranditem. Thehighlightedregionsdemonstrate -thatuserpreferencessummarizedintheuserprofilealignwiththekeyattributesextractedintheitemprofile,which -providescomplementaryinformationbeyondrawhistoriesandthusimprovespredictionaccuracy. -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. -10H 0.3902 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.3577 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.2604 /(1.00) /(1.00) -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.4932 0.1745 0.1823 0.4807 0.2170 0.2391 0.5702 0.1877 0.1544 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.4010 0.2646 0.3773 0.3931 0.3526 0.4889 0.4436 0.2994 0.3506 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.4715 0.3675 0.1917 0.4938 0.2197 0.2390 0.5216 0.2050 0.2267 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.5709 0.2378 0.2682 0.5109 0.2546 0.3749 0.5506 0.3883 0.3364 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.4882 0.2348 0.2330 0.4208 0.3328 0.3595 0.4946 0.2831 0.2949 -Ours 0.6382 0.2880 0.3429 0.5947 0.4002 0.4482 0.7287 0.3457 0.3127 -Table6: Semanticalignmentandcoverageofgeneratedprofiles. Cov. denotesthefractionoftokensgroundedin -historicaltext. -recoverfromrawhistoriesorstaticpromptsalone. reinforcementlearning–basedoptimization. These -resultssuggestthatadaptive,interaction-awaretex- -Experiments on multiple real-world datasets tualprofilesprovideapromisingdirectionformore -demonstratethatDUETconsistentlyoutperforms effective interpretable and performance-oriented -strongbaselinesunderdifferentbackbonemodels, recommendationsystems. -validating the effectiveness of joint profiling and - -| Limitations | | | | | | | References | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Keqin Bao, | Jizhi | Zhang, | Yang | Zhang, | Wenjie | Wang, | -Despiteitseffectiveness,ourapproachhasseveral FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2023. Tallrec: Anef- -fectiveandefficienttuningframeworktoalignlarge -| limitations. | First, | the | proposed | framework | | relies | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | languagemodelwithrecommendation. | | | | | InProceed- | | -onlargelanguagemodelsforbothprofilegenera- ingsofthe17thACMConferenceonRecommender -tion and downstream recommendation, which in- Systems,pages1007–1014. -| troduces | additional | computational | | | overhead | dur- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -TingChen,Wei-LiHan,Hai-DongWang,Yi-XunZhou, -| ingtrainingandinference. | | | Whileourexperiments | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | BinXu,andBin-YuZang.2007. | | | | Contentrecommen- | | | -showconsistentgainsacrossdifferentbackbones, dationsystembasedonprivatedynamicuserprofile. -the overall efficiency may be constrained when In2007Internationalconferenceonmachinelearn- -| | | | | | | | ing and | cybernetics, | | volume | 4, pages | 2112–2118. | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| scalingtoverylargeuseroritemsets. | | | | | Second,the | | | | | | | | | -IEEE. -| quality | of the generated | | profiles | is | inherently | de- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| pendent | on the underlying | | LLMs | | and prompting | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Yue Chen, | Minghua | | He, Fangkai | Yang, | Pu | Zhao, | -strategies. Variationsinmodelcapacityorprompt LuWang,YuKang,YifeiDong,YuefengZhan,Hao -Sun,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,andDongmei -sensitivitymayleadtodifferencesinprofilestabil- -| | | | | | | | Zhang. | 2025. | Warriormath: | | Enhancing | the | mathe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -ity,whichwedonotexplicitlycontrolinthecurrent -maticalabilityoflargelanguagemodelswithadefect- -design. Finally,ourevaluationfocusesontext-rich -| | | | | | | | awareframework. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.01245. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -recommendationscenarioswheresufficienthistor- -| | | | | | | | Paul Covington, | | Jay | Adams, and | Emre | Sargin. | 2016. | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -| ical reviews | are | available. | | The effectiveness | | of | | | | | | | | -Deepneuralnetworksforyoutuberecommendations. -| the proposed | strategy | | in domains | with | extremely | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InProceedingsofthe10thACMconferenceonrec- -sparsetextualsignalsorinnon-textualmodalities -ommendersystems,pages191–198. -remainstobefurtherexplored. -DeepSeek-AI,DayaGuo,DejianYang,HaoweiZhang, -JunxiaoSong,RuoyuZhang,RunxinXu,QihaoZhu, -ShirongMa,PeiyiWang,XiaoBi,XiaokangZhang, -Data,Privacy,andEthicsConsiderations Xingkai Yu, Yu Wu, Z. F. Wu, Zhibin Gou, Zhi- -| | | | | | | | hong | Shao, | Zhuoshu | Li, Ziyi | Gao, and | 181 | others. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | 2025. | Deepseek-r1: | | Incentivizing | reasoning | | capa- | -Alldatasetsusedinthisworkarepubliclyreleased bilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. Preprint, -arXiv:2501.12948. -bytheiroriginalowners,andwefollowtheofficial -termsofuseassociatedwitheachdataset,utilizing -JiaxinDeng,ShiyaoWang,KuoCai,LejianRen,Qigen -thedatasolelyforresearchpurposesaspermitted -| | | | | | | | Hu, Weifeng | | Ding, | Qiang Luo, | and | Guorui | Zhou. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -bytheirrespectivelicenses;forreproducibility,the 2025. Onerec: Unifyingretrieveandrankwithgen- -officialdatasetsourcesarecitedinthecorrespond- erativerecommenderanditerativepreferencealign- -ment. Preprint,arXiv:2502.18965. -ingsectionsofthispaper,andwedonotredistribute -anyrawuser-generatedcontentsuchasreviewtext AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, -| aspartofthiswork. | | Thisresearchdoesnotattempt | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, -to identify or infer the identity of any individual Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela -| | | | | | | | Fan,and1others.2024. | | | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -user,andpriortotraininganddownstreamprofile -arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.21783. -| generation, | we | apply text | filtering | | procedures | to | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -remove direct personal identifiers where applica- YiFang,WenjieWang,YangZhang,FengbinZhu,Qi- -ble;themodelsaretrainedsolelyonpubliclyavail- fanWang,FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2025. Rea- -son4rec:Largelanguagemodelsforrecommendation -abledata,andnoadditionalprivateorproprietary -| | | | | | | | withdeliberativeuserpreferencealignment. | | | | | Preprint, | | -| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| user information | | is introduced. | | Furthermore, | | we | | | | | | | | -arXiv:2502.02061. -| do not release | generated | | user | profiles | or | any per- | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MinghuaHe,YueChen,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Wenjie -useroutputsproducedduringthemodelingprocess, -Yin,YuKang,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,and -andallreportedresultsarepresentedinaggregate -| | | | | | | | DongmeiZhang.2025. | | | Execoder:Empoweringlarge | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| form for | evaluation | purposes | | only. | From | a secu- | | | | | | | | -languagemodelswithexecutabilityrepresentationfor -rityperspective,theassociatedcoderepositoryhas codetranslation. Preprint,arXiv:2501.18460. -beenscannedforpotentialsecrets,andanyinternal -MinjieHong,ZirunGuo,YanXia,ZehanWang,Ziang -endpointsorconfidentialconfigurationinformation -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | Tao | Jin, and | Zhou Zhao. | 2025a. | Apo: | En- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | -havebeenremovedpriortorelease. -hancingreasoningabilityofmllmsviaasymmetric -| | | | | | | | policyoptimization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2506.21655. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Minjie Hong, Yan Xia, Zehan Wang, Jieming Zhu, JoarSkalse,NikolausH.R.Howe,DmitriiKrashenin- -Ye Wang, Sihang Cai, Xiaoda Yang, Quanyu Dai, nikov, and David Krueger. 2025. Defining -ZhenhuaDong,ZhimengZhang,and1others.2025b. and characterizing reward hacking. Preprint, -| Eager-llm: | Enhancinglargelanguagemodelsasrec- | | | | | arXiv:2209.13085. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ommenders | through | exogenous | behavior-semantic | | | | | | | | | -integration. InProceedingsoftheACMonWebCon- Harald Steck. 2019. Embarrassingly shallow autoen- -ference2025,pages2754–2762. codersforsparsedata. InProceedingsofTheWorld -WideWebConference(WWW),pages3251–3257. -MinjieHong,ZetongZhou,ZirunGuo,ZiangZhang, -| Ruofan | Hu, Weinan | Gan, | Jieming | Zhu, and | Zhou | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ChaoSun,YaoboLiang,YamingYang,ShilinXu,Tian- -| Zhao.2025c. | Generativereasoningrecommendation | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | mengYang,andYunhaiTong.2024. | | | | | Rlrf4rec: Re- | -| viallms. | Preprint,arXiv:2510.20815. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | inforcement | learning | from | recsys | feedback | for en- | -JihwanJeong,YinlamChow,GuyTennenholtz,Chih- hancedrecommendationreranking. arXivpreprint -| Wei Hsu, | Azamat | Tulepbergenov, | | Mohammad | | arXiv:2410.05939. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| Ghavamzadeh, | and | Craig | Boutilier. | 2023. | Fac- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | QwenTeam.2025. | | Qwen3technicalreport. | | | Preprint, | -| tual and | personalized | recommendations | | using | lan- | | | | | | | -| guagemodelsandreinforcementlearning. | | | | | Preprint, | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -arXiv:2310.06176. -| | | | | | | Hugo Touvron, | Louis | Martin, | Kevin | Stone, | Peter Al- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | -Yitong Ji, Aixin Sun, Jie Zhang, and Chenliang Li. bert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay -| 2023. A | critical | study | on data leakage | in | recom- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bashlykov,SoumyaBatra,PrajjwalBhargava,Shruti -| mendersystemofflineevaluation. | | | | ACMTrans.Inf. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Bhosale,and1others.2023. | | | Llama2: | | Openfoun- | -Syst.,41(3):75:1–75:27. -| | | | | | | dation and | fine-tuned | chat | models. | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -------- | -arXiv:2307.09288. -| JiachengLin,TianWang,andKunQian.2025. | | | | | Rec-r1: | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bridginggenerativelargelanguagemodelsanduser- -| | | | | | | LeandrovonWerra, | | YounesBelkada, | | LewisTunstall, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -centricrecommendationsystemsviareinforcement -EdwardBeeching,TristanThrush,NathanLambert, -| learning. | Preprint,arXiv:2503.24289. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | Shengyi | Huang, | Kashif | Rasul, | and | Quentin Gal- | -| | | | | | | louédec. | TRL: | Transformer | Reinforcement | | Learn- | -AiweiLiu,MinghuaHe,ShaoxunZeng,SijunZhang, -| LinhaoZhang,ChuhanWu,WeiJia,YuanLiu,Xiao | | | | | | ing. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Zhou,andJieZhou.2025. | | | Wedlm:Reconcilingdiffu- | | | | | | | | | -sionlanguagemodelswithstandardcausalattention LuWang,DiZhang,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Jianfeng -forfastinference. Preprint,arXiv:2512.22737. Liu,YuefengZhan,HaoSun,QingweiLin,Weiwei -| | | | | | | Deng, Dongmei | | Zhang, | Feng | Sun, and | Qi Zhang. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | -HongtaoLiu,FangzhaoWu,WenjunWang,Xianchen -| | | | | | | 2025. Lettingo: | | Exploreuserprofilegenerationfor | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,PengfeiJiao,ChuhanWu,andXingXie.2019. -| | | | | | | recommendationsystem. | | | InProceedingsofthe31st | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -Nrpa: Neuralrecommendationwithpersonalizedat- ACMSIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscovery -tention. In Proceedings of the 42nd International andDataMiningV.2,KDD’25,NewYork,NY,USA. -ACMSIGIRConferenceonResearchandDevelop- AssociationforComputingMachinery. -mentinInformationRetrieval,pages1233–1236. -YeWang,JiahaoXun,MinjieHong,JiemingZhu,Tao -| Wensheng | Lu, Jianxun | Lian, | Wei Zhang, | Guanghua | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Jin,WangLin,HaoyuanLi,LinjunLi,YanXia,Zhou -Li,MingyangZhou,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2024. -| | | | | | | Zhao,and1others.2024. | | | Eager: | Two-streamgen- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -Aligninglargelanguagemodelsforcontrollablerec- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.05063. erativerecommenderwithbehavior-semanticcollab- -ommendations. -| | | | | | | oration. | InProceedingsofthe30thACMSIGKDD | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RadaMihalceaandPaulTarau.2004. Textrank: Bring- ConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMin- -| | | InEMNLP. | | | | ing,pages3245–3254. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingorderintotext. -| Zhaopeng | Qiu, Xian | Wu, | Jingyue Gao, | and | Wei Fan. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Triyanna | Widiyaningtyas, | | Indriana | Hidayah, | and | -2021. U-BERT:pre-traininguserrepresentationsfor -| | | | | | | TeguhBAdji.2021. | | Userprofilecorrelation-based | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -improved recommendation. In AAAI, pages 4320– similarity(upcsim)algorithminmovierecommenda- -| 4327.AAAIPress. | | | | | | tionsystem. | JournalofBigData,8(1):52. | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| NilsReimersandIrynaGurevych.2019. | | | | Sentence-bert: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | J.Wu.2023. | Computationalunderstandingofuserin- | | | | | -Sentenceembeddingsusingsiamesebert-networks. -terfaces. -InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical -MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP), -pages3982–3992. Yunjia Xi, Weiwen Liu, Jianghao Lin, Xiaoling Cai, -| | | | | | | Hong Zhu, | Jieming | Zhu, | Bo Chen, | Ruiming | Tang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ----- | -Xubin Ren, Wei Wei, Lianghao Xia, Lixin Su, Suqi WeinanZhang,andYongYu.2024. Towardsopen- -Cheng,JunfengWang,DaweiYin,andChaoHuang. world recommendation with knowledge augmenta- -2024. Representationlearningwithlargelanguage tionfromlargelanguagemodels. InProceedingsof -modelsforrecommendation. InProceedingsofthe the18thACMConferenceonRecommenderSystems, -| ACMonWebConference2024,pages3464–3475. | | | | | | pages12–22. | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -A ExperimentSetup -FanYang,ZhengChen,ZiyanJiang,EunahCho,Xiao- -| jiangHuang,andYanbinLu.2023. | | Palr:Personaliza- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tionawarellmsforrecommendation. | | arXivpreprint | A.1 DataCuration | | | | | | | -arXiv:2305.07622. -Jiarui Zhang. 2024. Guided profile generation im- Table7: Statisticaldetailsoftheevaluationdatasets. -| proves personalization | with llms. | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | -| arXiv:2409.13093. | | | Dataset | #Train | #Valid | | #Test #User | | #Item | -| | | | Music | 43,071 | 3,271 | | 1,296 | 4,183 | 2,660 | -| | | | Book | 71,972 | 6,144 | | 5,541 13,863 | | 13,515 | -| | | | Yelp | 51,497 | 4,757 | | 4,328 | 8,453 | 13,426 | -| | | | We conduct | | experiments | | on three | widely | used | -real-worlddatasets: -| | | | • AmazonMusic(Music): | | | | Thisreferstothe“Dig- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | ital Music” | | subset | of the | well-known | | Amazon | -Productdataset3,whichrecordsrichuserreviews, -ratings,andtextualinformationaboutitems,such -| | | | as titles, | across | a | broad | range | of product | cate- | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | -gories,ontheAmazonplatform.2 -| | | | • AmazonBook(Book): | | | Thisreferstothe“Book” | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -subsetoftheAmazonProductdataset. -dataset4, -| | | | • Yelp: | This | refers | to the | Yelp | Open | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | | which | includes | user | reviews, | ratings | | for busi- | -| | | | nesses | such | as restaurants | | and | retail shops, | as | -wellastextualinformationaboutthebusinesses. -Itiswidelyusedinrecommendationtasks(Qiu -etal.,2021). -WeusetheentireMusicdatasetforexperiments, -| | | | while for | the Book | | and Yelp | datasets, | we | utilize | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | onlyasubsetduetotheirlargesize. | | | | | FortheBook | | -dataset,weusedatafromthelasttwomonths,and -fortheYelpdataset,weusedatafromthelastsix -months. Foreachdataset,wesplititintotraining, -| | | | validation, | and | test | sets based | on | the timestamps | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | of interactions, | | ensuring | that | test | interactions | oc- | -curafteralltrainingandvalidationinteractionsto -preventinformationleakage(Jietal.,2023). -| | | | Regarding | | data | filtering, | following | | prior | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | work (Liu | et | al., 2019), | we | adopt | a 5-core | set- | -tingtofilterthedataandexcludecold-startusers -| | | | and items—those | | not | appearing | | in the | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | set—from | the | validation | and | test | sets. | The sta- | -tisticaldetailsoftheprocesseddatasetareprovided -inTable7. -3https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ -amazon/links.html. -4https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -open-dataset/. - -| A.1.1 | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | RLMRecPrompt | | | | -| ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -Inourexperiments,weprimarilyemployQwen3- Role: Businessrecommendationassistant -Task: Determinebusinesstypesauserislikely -| 8B(Team,2025)andLLaMA38BInstruct | | | | | | (Dubey | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| etal.,2024;Touvronetal.,2023)asboththerec- | | | | | | | toenjoy | | | | -| ommendation | | model | and | the | profile | generation | InputFormat: | | | | -•Title: Businessname -model. Thetrainingprocessisimplementedusing -theTRL(vonWerraetal.). Keyhyperparameters, •Categories: Businesscategories -suchasbatchsizeandlearningrate,aredetermined •Sentiment: Usersentimenttowardbusiness -throughgridsearchtoachieveoptimalperformance. -OutputRequirements: -Moredetailscanbefoundinourcode. -1. JSONformatonly -2. Structure: -A.2 BaselinePrompts -{ -| | | | | | | | "summarization": | "Types | of businesses | user | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -KARPrompt -likelyenjoys"(≤100words), -Task: Analyzeuserpreferencesbasedonbusi- -| | | | | | | | "reasoning": | "Brief explanation | | for summa- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | -nessreviewinghistory -rization"(nowordlimit) -Input: {user_history}-User’sbusinessreview- -} -inghistorywithsentimentsovertime -3. NoadditionaltextoutsideJSON -Instructions: -| 1. | Analyze | the | user’s | preferences | considering | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Input: | INTERACTION | | ITEMS: | -businessnamesandcategories -{user_history} -| 2. | Take | into account | | sentiment | patterns | over | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time -| 3. | Provideclearexplanationsbasedonreview- | | | | | | LGPrompt | | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -inghistorydetails -Youwillserveasanassistanttohelpmegener- -| 4. | Consider | other | pertinent | | factors | that may | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ateauserprofilebasedonthisuser’ssentiments -influencepreferences -historytobetterunderstandthisusers’interest -andthuspredicthis/hersentimentaboutatarget -| PALRPrompt | | | | | | | item. Iwillprovideyouwithsomebehaviorhis- | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | toryoftheuserinthisformat: | | [itemattributes | | -Task: Summarizeuserpreferencesusingkey- -| | | | | | | | andsentiment]. | Theuserprofileyougenerate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -words. -shouldcontainasmuchusefulcontentaspossi- -| Input: | | {user_history} | | - historical | businesses | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -bletohelppredicttheuser’ssentimenttowards -withusersentiments. -anewbusiness. -| Output | | Format: | An | itemized | list ranked | by | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -USERHISTORY:{user_history}. -importance. -PROFILEYOUGENERATE: -Template: -| | • KEY_WORD_1: | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -R4RecPrompt(Reasoner) -| | TORY_BUSINESS_1", | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -UserReviewHistory -TORY_BUSINESS_2" -⟨H u organizedasbelow⟩ -| | • KEY_WORD_2: | | | | | "HIS- | 1. TitleofItem1 | | | | -| ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | TORY_BUSINESS_3" | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| | | | | | | | NegativeAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| Instructions: | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -[Preference2],... -| | 1. Extract | key | preference | | indicators | from | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2. TitleofItem2 -userinteractionhistory. -| | | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -2. Rankkeywordsbyimportance. NegativeAspects: [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... -| | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | - -| [Preference2],... | | | | | | | cantlyworsethanDUETacrossalldatasets. | | | | | This | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -indicatesthatcoherentsummariesaloneareinsuf- -... -| | | | | | | | ficient, | and that | the gains | of DUET | | arise from | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -ItemReviewHistorybyOtherUsers -⟨H organizedinthesameformatasabove⟩ learnedsemanticabstractionratherthanextractive +For 2022 Fall + +(Regular Track) + +KAIST International Graduate Admission + +Application Guide + +Korea Advanced Institute of +Science and Technology +Office of Admissions + + Table of Contents + +Ⅰ. Drawing Your Future at KAIST + + ··································· + +Ⅱ. Application Procedures at a Glance + + ························· + +Ⅲ. Notes + + ······································································· + +Ⅳ. Eligibility + + ································································· + +Ⅴ. Timelines + + ································································· + +Ⅵ. Required Application Materials + + ······························· + +Ⅶ. Degrees and Programs + + ············································· + +Ⅷ. Campus Life (Daejeon & Seoul) + + ································ + +Ⅸ. Financial Aid + + ··························································· + +※ + +Appendix. Form - List of Honors and Awards + + ················· + +※ + +Note. Collection and Use of Personal Information + + ·········· + +01 + +02 + +03 + +04 + +07 + +08 + +14 + +18 + +20 + +21 + +22 + + Drawing Your Future at KAIST + +Ⅰ +KAIST is a young and ambitious university who leads science and technology and contributes to the world +for the better. Our history begins with our students. If you want to be a part of our audacious history, now +is time to ask yourself what you want and to probe what KAIST has for you. + +A +a. What do I want to study at a graduate level? + +Scientific Questions to Probe BEFORE You Apply to KAIST + +b. Does KAIST provide any courses in the field of my research interests? + +c. Does KAIST have any laboratories in the field of my research interest? + +d. Have I found and contacted faculty members whose research interests overlap mine? + +※ + +If you have found all the answers positive, now is time to LEARN something TECHNICAL regarding +APPLICATION to KAIST graduate programs. + +B +a. Visit our official website and learn about timelines, eligibility, paper works and + +Technical Knowledge You Should Know to Apply to KAIST + +other things you should know to apply. + +b. Apply online within the designated term (Application Fee KRW 80,000 or USD 80.) + +c. Send your application materials to our office by the due date. + +※ Recommendation letters are to be uploaded on our system directly by your referees. +※ Monitor your application review and provide supplements if required. + +d. Check your email at regular intervals and attend an interview if required by the + +department you applied to. + +e. Check the final decisions – ( + +if admitted + +) you must express your decision on our offer. + +f. Prepare for the transition to KAIST. + +C +a. Prepare for the school registration according to + +Transition to Our Advanced institute In South Korea + +the Registration Guide + + to be announced + +with our final decisions. + +b. Apply for a visa with supporting materials from our office and other documents + +required by the Korean Embassy and book an air ticket to South Korea + +c. Submit documents required to register to KAIST and settle into our community + +※ Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, timelines, procedures, and required materials are changeable without +prior notice. Our International Scholar and Student Service (ISSS) will notify you of any changes or updates +you need to know. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +1 + + Ⅱ + + Application Procedures at a Glance + +STEP 1 + Please use + +ONLINE APPLICATION by March 29 + +th + +, 2022 + +a computer with a Windows-based operating system + +. + + Access to our online application system at https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. + + Complete your online application. + +- + +Create an account and choose a degree and program of study at KAIST. +Enter your personal and academic backgrounds and prior experiences and achievements. + +- +- Write your statement of purpose and answer other questions KAIST requires. + +- + +- + +Choose your financial resources – you can apply for KAIST Scholarship in this step. +Pay the application fee online – KRW 80,000 or USD 80. +※ Our system will send automated emails to your referees with the information and + +instructions on uploading recommendation letters after your payment. + +STEP 2 + Print out your online application and address sticker through our system. + +APPLICATION MATERIALS + +※ The program you have applied to may require additional application materials. Please read +brief introductions of each program from page 14, visit the website of the program you will +apply to, and prepare for the additional materials. + + Organize and review your application materials with the online application printouts as listed + +on page 8. + + Post your application materials to our office * You can print out our address through our system. + +Graduate Admissions Team, KAIST +# 110, 1st Floor, E 16-1 B/D + +291 Daehak-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon (Zip Code:34141) + +Republic of Korea + +Office. +82-42-350-2352, 2354 / E-mail: advanced.adm@kaist.ac.kr + + Monitor your application status on our system and provide supplements if required. + +Your application has been finished here ! + +STEP 3 + Check your email at regular intervals. Our office or a staffer from the department you + +Keep yourself plugged into KAIST Admission until June 22 + +, 2022 + +nd + +applied to might reach you for an interview or further qualification. + + KAIST will announce our final decisions through our system on the decision notification day. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +2 + + Ⅲ + + Notes + +A +a. KAIST offers admissions to those who can study at KAIST full-time. Admitted + +Enrollments + +students + +must not have any professional responsibilities while studying at KAIST + +. + +b. + +. All the admitted students must +KAIST has forbidden multiple enrollments of our students +have completed their degree programs before enrollment to KAIST and must not +enroll in other institutions until completing their degree program at KAIST. + +B +a. Decisions on admissions and scholarships are independent. KAIST could offer + +Application + +admissions with or without scholarships. + +b. The program you will apply to may require additional application materials. Please +, visit the program’s website, + +read brief introductions of each program from +and prepare for the additional materials if required. + +page 14 + +c. The application fee is non-refundable and not subject to a waiver. + +C +a. All the application materials must be valid and up-to-date. + +Application Materials + +b. Any application materials that you submit to KAIST become our property and are + +IRRETURNABLE + +. Please learn to prepare for your application materials at + +Ⅵ Required +section, and take options that will avoid submitting your original + +Application Materials +degrees and transcripts that are not obtainable again. + +c. All documents must be in English or Korean. Any materials written in other +languages will have no value to support your application. All the mandatory +application materials must be translated either in English or Korean preferably by +the institutions that have issued them or by a public notary office. Optional +documents must do the same to be accepted and recognized as evidence. + +d. KAIST accepts degree certificates, transcripts, English proficiency test score reports, +and other supporting materials sent directly from the issuing institutes or agencies +to our office in an official and approved channel. + +e. In case of any loss or damages in delivery, make a photocopy of your application + +materials. + +f. KAIST reserves the right to request additional materials from applicants for any + +further verification or qualification. + +g. Our offer of admission may be revoked even after being admitted to or having +graduated from KAIST if any of the submitted materials are found to be false or +counterfeit. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +3 + + Ⅳ + + Eligibility + +Degree + +A +▫ Applicants must hold or expect to hold a Bachelor’s degree for Master or Master- +Ph.D. Integrated program application or Master’s degree for a Doctoral program + +application by + +August 28 + +th + +, 2022 + +. + +※ Notes + +- Bachelor’s degree must be equivalent to a Korean Bachelor’s degree which takes + +four years of study * learn and compare with the Korean system at WHED + +- + +Equivalents + +a. University degree requiring four years of study +b. Three-year Bologna compliant Bachelor’s degree +c. The first cycle qualification in the framework of qualifications for the European + +Higher Education Area (EHEA) + +d. Bachelor’s degree with honors in British pattern education +e. Cases other than above should provide a supplement to prove the equivalency + +B +▫ Applicants must hold citizenship outside Korea. + +Citizenship + +* Korean citizens who hold dual citizenship are not eligible for this track of admission. + +※ + +NOTE for International Applicants of Korean Ethnicity + +International applicants of Korean ethnicity, regardless of the place of birth, MUST additionally +satisfy ONE of the two requirements below: + +a. NEITHER of their parents is a citizen of Korea or; +b. The applicant must have received the ENTIRE elementary, junior high, and high school + +education OUTSIDE of Korea at the comparable and equivalent level of those provided in +Korea. + +※ In this case, international schools located in Korea are not acknowledged as foreign + +schools. Applicants of Korean ethnicity who completed their entire education (elementary, +junior high, high school, and undergraduate) outside of Korea should submit the + +Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry & Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) issued by the + +Korean Immigration Office. The certificate should have been issued within one month to +the online application deadline. + +International students of Korean ethnicity who do not meet the conditions above CANNOT +apply for International Admissions. Instead, they can apply through the KAIST General + +Admission (“일반전형” at http://admission.kaist.ac.kr/graduate). + +p a g e + + | 22 + +4 + + C +▫ + +English Language Proficiency + +Our official language of communication and instructions for international students at KAIST is +. All the applicants of International Admission must provide at least one of the + +English +following English proficiency test (EPT) scores: +* Recognized English language proficiency tests taken after + + March 29 + +, are valid. + +th + +, 2020 + +Test + +Min. Score + +Submission + +Remark + +TOEFL iBT +*PBT / CBT + +83 +* 560 / 220 + +Report through the ETS website +and send us a legible copy of score +report + +Code: 0195 +(iBT MyBest Scores are NOT +accepted) + +IELTS + +TOEIC + +6.5 band + +A legible copy of the score report + +Academic Mode + +720 + +The original score report + +Listening & Reading + +TEPS/ New TEPS + +599 / 326 + +A legible copy of the score report + +Scores from Institutional Testing Program (ITP) are not accepted. + +* +* Programs that do not require EPT score: GITTP, KINS-KAIST, RCA-KAIST, KOICA-KAIST + +SEMBA + +▫ You are able to request a waiver of the requirement to prove English proficiency test + +(EPT) score if you meet one of the following conditions: + +a. You do not need to provide an EPT score if you hold citizenship of the following + have completed a qualification equivalent to a Bachelor’s degree or + +countries +higher from the following countries: + +OR + +Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, the Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Canada, Dominica, +Grenada, Guyana, Ireland, Jamaica, Malta, New Zealand, St Kitts, St Lucia, St Vincent, +Trinidad and Tobago, U.K., U.S.A. + +b. You do not need to provide an EPT score if you hold citizenship of the following + have completed a qualification equivalent to a Bachelor’s degree +countries +or higher in English as the medium of instruction from the following countries: +* A certificate proving the medium of instruction must be supplemented. + +AND + +i.e., English Lecture Certificate + +Botswana, Cameroon, Eswatini, Ethiopia, Fiji, Gambia, Ghana, India, Jamaica, Kenya, +Kiribati, Lesotho, Liberia, Malawi, Marshall Islands, Mauritius, Federated States of +Micronesia, Namibia, Nauru, Nigeria, Pakistan, Palau, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, +Rwanda, Samoa, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Singapore, Solomon Islands, Republic of South +Africa, Sudan, Republic of South Sudan, Tanzania, Tonga, Tuvalu, Uganda, Vanuatu, +Zambia, Zimbabwe + +c. Those enrolled in KAIST graduate programs during the application term do not + +need to provide an EPT score. +* Those enrolled in the following programs are not eligible for a waiver: GITTP, KINS-KAIST, + +RCA-KAIST, KOICA-KAIST SEMBA + +※ + +If you meet one of the conditions above, tick + +online application. + +EXEMPTION + + in + +English + + section in + + of our + +Step 2 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +5 + + D +▫ + +▫ + +Finding an Academic Advisor at KAIST + + must find three to five faculty members from the +Master�s program applicants +department you will apply to whose research interests overlap yours and write their +names in +* Master’s applicants don’t need to obtain approval to write the names of advisors. +However, some programs require Master’s applicants to find and obtain approvals from +advisors before application. For details, please check our + + section in your online application + +Faculty + +STEP 1 + +. + +section and the website of the program you will apply to. + +Ⅶ Degrees and Programs + +(page 14) + + – including + +Doctorate program applicants +M.S.-Ph.D integrated program +- must find one faculty member whom you want to advise you before application, +obtain approval for the application and write his or her name in + section in + +applicants for + +Faculty + +your online application + +STEP 1 + +. + +※ Please check whether we offer any program that meets your research interests at + +Ⅶ + first and learn about our faculty members at the + +Degrees and Programs (page 14) +STARLIBRARY website (click). + +p a g e + + | 22 + +6 + + Ⅴ + + Timelines + +ONLINE Application +Mar. 15 + +, 2022 – Mar. 29 + +th + +th + +, 2022 + +https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. +Mar. 15th, 10A.M. – Mar. 29th, 5P.M. + +th + +Document Submission by POST +by Apr. 8 + +, 2022 +Send your online application printout and supporting +materials to our office, except for recommendation +letters which are received ONLY through our online +system. + +Arrival Check of Submitted +Document +Mar. 22 + +, 2022 – Apr. 8 + +, 2022 +Please check the status of your document arrival +at https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. + +nd + +th + +To complete your application, we could require missing +documents or supplements through our online system. +Please check the Doc.Submission board at regular intervals +until it turns to COMPLETE. + +Interview (if necessary) +th +May 2 + +, 2022 – Jun. 13 + +nd + +, 2022 + +Please check your e-mail at regular intervals. + +Application Review +, 2022 – Jun. 13 +May 2 + +, 2022 +Respective departments will contact applicants +individually if an interview is necessary. + +nd + +th + +Scholarship Review +Jun. 14 + +, 2022 – Jun. 21 + +th + +st + +, 2022 + +Decision Notification +, 2022 +5:00P.M., Jun. 22 + +nd + +The decisions will be announced through our online +application system along with the registration +guide. + +Admission +, 2022 +Aug. 29 + +th + +※ + +THE TIMELINE IS BASED ON LOCAL TIME IN SOUTH KOREA AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +7 + + Ⅵ + + Required Application Materials + +A + +Application Materials at a Glance + +No. + +□√ List and Order of the Application Materials + +Note + +□ Document Checklist + +- This is included in your online application printout + +- + +1 + +2 + +□ Online Application Printout + +□ Statement of Financial Resources Printout + +3 + +□ Recommendation Letters + +4 + +5 + +□ Certificate (s) of Degree or Diploma + +□ Transcripts + +- Complete your application by paying the application fee. +- Check whether you have missed signing on the printouts. +- Review whether your supplements support your + +application printout. + +- Recommendation letters will be received electronically + +from the referees you register on our system. + +- You can check whether they have completed your letters +and email your referees to request them on our system. + +- Please see page 11 and 12 for the approved format of + +the document. + +- Organize in the following order: + +Bachelor’s degree → transcripts → Master’s degree → +transcripts + +- Please check your eligibility and available evidence + +6 + +□ English Proficiency Test (EPT) Score + +□ + +□ + +□ + +□ + +EPT score report +Degree in an English +native country +CTZ of an English native country + +□ + +English lecture Cert. +Currently enrolled in +KAIST grad. Program + +- For iBT score, please report through the ETS website + +(Institution code for TOEFL: 0195) + +- For TOEIC, you have to send us in the original form + +7 + +□ Curriculum Vitae + +- There is no designated form. + +8 + +□ Identity Document of the Applicant + +9 + +□ Identity Document of BOTH Parents + +- These documents are to check the citizenships of you and + +your parents. + +10 + +11 + +□ Certificate of Family Registration + +(“가족관계증명서”) + +- You can replace it with an equivalent public document or +a birth certificate indicating the relationship between you +and your parents + +□ The Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry + +& Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) + +- ONLY for Korean Ethnicity if applicable +- It must be issued within three months + +12 + +□ List of Honors and Awards + +- Optional + +13 + +□ Employment Certificate + +14 + +□ School Profile / Credit Rating System + +※ + +※ + +For the detailed conditions of each document, please refer to the following guide. + +The program you will apply to may require additional application materials. Please read brief + +introductions of each program from page 14, visit the program’s website, and prepare for the + +additional materials if required. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +8 + + B + +a + +▫ + +▫ + +▫ + +▫ + +How to Apply and What to Be Done to Complete Your Application + +ONLINE APPLICATION + +Our online system is optimized to the Windows operation systems. Please use a computer +with a Windows-based OS. + +Step 1_Program of Study and Personal Background +Create an account with your valid email account, select a degree program you want +to study at KAIST, and enter your personal information. +* You can apply to one degree program at each application term. + +Step 2_Academic History, Performances, Experiences, and Referees +Enter the required information such as academic history, EPT score, publication, +work experiences, and referees. +* Applicants must provide the referees’ professional or institutional email accounts for verification. + +Step 3_Statement of Purpose +Write the statement of purpose and answer other questions as below to present who +you are, what you have achieved, and what you want to achieve at KAIST. + +a. Please briefly answer the following questions with keywords (up to 500 letters to each question). + +* Required + +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ + +* Required + +* Required + +What you studied at the previous institution +Motivation applying for the major +Brief study plan +Future plan after study +Honors and awards +Introduction of the institution previously attended + +* Required + +*Optional + +*Optional + +b. Write down a detailed and accurate statement of your purpose and objective in pursuing your + +study at KAIST (Up to 5,000 letters). * Required + +Step 4_Statement of Financial Resources to Study at KAIST +State your financial resources to cover the tuition fees and expenses for your study +at KAIST. If you want to apply to our graduate program with KAIST Scholarship, +select + + as your financial resource. + +KAIST Scholarship + +* You can select multiple options to support your life at KAIST. + +a. + +b. + + or + +Parental Sponsor + +Self-support +If you choose Self-support or Parental Sponsor as your financial resource, bank statements +ending within a month of your application date must be provided to prove the financial +capacity of USD 18,000 or more. If Self-support or Parental Sponsor is the only option of your +financial resource, the ending balance must be at least USD 18,000 or more*. +* The ending balance must be enough to cover your expenditure of one year on campus - tuition fees + +for two semesters and other expenses for one year. Please refer to our rate on page 20. + +Government/Organization Scholarship + +p a g e + + | 22 + +9 + + A certificate or letter of sponsorship must be provided with the information of a responsible +officer whom KAIST can reach. If the applicant is also awarded KAIST Scholarship, the financial +aids from KAIST will deduct the amount covered by the other scholarship program. + +* + + is an + + organized and hosted by + +Global Korea Scholarship (GKS) +National Institute for International Education (NIIED). If you want to apply to our graduate +program through GKS, you must apply through either University Track or Embassy Track, +according to GKS Application Guide. Learn more… (click) + +INDEPENDENT ADMISSION PROGRAM + +c. + +KAIST Scholarship +KAIST Scholarship is a financial aid program to support international students. KAIST will review +applicants based on prior performance and future promise and will decide awardees and rates. +Decisions will be announced with the final results. Benefits include tuition fee waive, monthly +stipends of KRW 350,000 for Master’s and KRW 400,000 for Doctoral students, and health +insurance premiums supported by their advisors or programs. KAIST will review the +performance of the beneficiaries every year and decide whether to prolong our financial aids. +* The rate may vary by your participation in research projects and performance. + +▫ + +Step 5_Submission of the Application Fee +Submit the application fee of + + or + +KRW 80,000 + + to complete your online + +USD 80 + +application. Our system will instantly assign an application number to your +application and automatically email your referees to upload recommendation letters +after confirming your payment. + +▫ You can take one of the four options below to pay the application fee. Our +recommendation is to pay by credit card since it is the most responsive and instant +means. + +Credit Card + +Bank Transfer + +Overseas + +Korean +Domestic + +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- international transaction activated + +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- online transaction activated + +Late, Expensive Charge +- applicants must email + +the + +transfer + +receipt at advanced.adm@kaist.ac.kr +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- online transaction activated + +※ The overseas bank transfer option will take a few days to reach us and a few more for KAIST to + +confirm the payment and assign your number – they are all manual. + +※ You CANNOT edit your online application after paying the fee. Please proofread and complete + +your online application before you pay. + +※ The application fee is NOT subject to a refund and waiver. + + b + +TWO RECOMMENDATION LETTERS + + *Do NOT ATTACH to your application package. We receive them ONLINE. + +▫ Referees must upload recommendation letters on our system by the deadline of + +document submission. + +Applicants can monitor the current status of your letter or email to your + +referees to request letters through our system (click) + +. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +10 + + ※ Reference letters must remain strictly undisclosed to applicants and must not be requested any + +reading or disclosure of the information given in the letters. + +▫ KAIST prefers as your referees those who taught you or supervised you at +universities or work. If you would ask someone at work, please use a letterhead +showing the company’s contact information. + +▫ Applicants must register the professional or institutional email accounts of their + +referees for verification. + +※ Please note that the earlier you complete your online application, the more time your + +referees will have to write letters for you. + +※ Please do NOT ATTACH your letters to your application packages. We receive them ONLINE. + + +c +▫ Applicants must submit official degrees or diplomas from the institutions they + +OFFICIAL DEGREES / DIPLOMAS + +earned their Bachelor’s or higher to prove their eligibility. + +* Original degrees or diplomas are accepted. However, since our office doesn’t return your +application materials regardless of the final decisions, we strongly recommend you to take +other options to prove your academic qualification. + +* Official degrees or diplomas are certified copies of your degrees or diplomas issued and + +verified by a responsible officer of the institutions you attended and bearing raised or colored +seal of the institutions or signature of the officer. They are also referred to as True Copy or +Certified Copy in some countries. +E-documents are also acceptable if they are provided through the official and approved +channel from the issuing institute with a tool to verify them. + +* + +* Authenticated by a notary public is also acceptable if it bears the seal or signature of the + +officer. + +* Photocopies are not accepted – photocopies of the original or certified copy don’t bear any + +quality to verify whether they are true. + +▫ + +▫ + +If you expect to graduate, you can replace your degree or diploma with a certificate +of the expected graduation or an official letter from your university supporting your +graduation. The replacement must include your name, degree to be conferred, and +date of graduation. + +If you receive your degree later than the beginning of our admission, the certificate +or letter must bear the date when you complete your degree requirements + +* Graduates from colleges and universities in China can substitute official degree with + +Credentials Report + + issued by CDGDC (中国学位与研究生教育信息网) + +AND China Higher + +Education Qualification Certificate + + issued by CHESICC (中国高等教育学生信息网). + + +d +▫ Applicants must submit official transcripts from the institutions they earned their + +OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPTS + +p a g e + + | 22 + +11 + + Bachelor’s or higher degree to prove their academic performance. + +* Official transcripts are certified copies of your transcripts issued and verified by a responsible +officer of the institutions you attended and bearing raised or colored seal of the institutions or +signature of the officer. They are also referred to as True Copy or Certified Copy in some +countries. +E-documents are also acceptable if they are provided through the official and approved +channel from the issuing institute with a tool to verify them. + +* + +* Authenticated by a notary public are also acceptable if they bears the seal or signature of the + +officer. + +* Photocopies are not accepted – photocopies of the original or certified copy don’t bear any + +quality to verify whether they are true. + +▫ Transcripts must include information on the grading systems, courses completed, +grades or marks earned, cumulative grade points average (CGPA), personal rank (if +possible), certificates or degree awarded, and + from the institutions + +grading system + +you attended or attending. + +* Graduates from colleges and universities in China can substitute official transcripts + +with +(中国高等教育学生信息网). + +China Higher Education Student’s Academic Transcripts + + issued by CHESICC + +e + +▫ + +ENGLISH PROFICIENCY TEST (EPT) REPORT + +Our official language of communication and instructions for international students at KAIST is +. Applicants of international graduate admissions must prove their English + +English +language proficiency with one of the qualifications described in the + +English Language + +Proficiency + + section on + +. + +page 5 + +Curriculum Vitae + +f +▫ Applicants must provide summaries of their education, certifications, research +experience, professional affiliations, and other information to present themselves to +our student selection committees. + +g +▫ Applicants must provide a public document proving their citizenship. + +Citizenship of Applicants + +e.g., a photocopy of the passport, national ID card, alien registration card, or any other form of the public +documents indicating information such as the issuance number, date of issue and expiration, photo, and name. + +h +▫ Applicants must provide public documents proving their parents’ citizenship. + +Citizenship of Applicants’ Parents + +e.g., a photocopy of the passport, national ID card, alien registration card, or any other form of the public +documents indicating information such as the issuance number, date of issue and expiration, photo, and name. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +12 + + “ +가족관계증명서 +Certificate of Family Registration ( + i -compression. -| Task: | Analyze | whether | | the user | will | like the | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| new Music | | i based | on | the user’s | preferences | | | | | | | | -B.2 RankingunderHardNegativeSampling -| andtheitem’sfeatures. | | | | Provideyourrationale | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toconstructamorechallengingrankingscenario, -inoneconciseparagraph. -wereplacerandomnegativeswithhardnegatives -| | | | | | | | generatedbyacollaborativefilteringmodel. | | | | | Specif- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -A.3 ExampleofCue -ically,foreachuser,weretrievehigh-scoringitems -Thefollowingexamplesillustratehowrawsignals -| | | | | | | | from an | EASE(Steck, | 2019) | model | that | the user | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | -| aredistilledintocues. | | | Asshownonthetop, | | | user | | | | | | | -hasnotinteractedwith,andcombinethemwiththe -cuesemphasizehistoricalpreferences,whileitem -ground-truthitemtoformthecandidateset. -cues highlight metadata and user-group patterns. Table 9 reports the results. Compared to ran- -| Together, | they | provide | minimal | | but informative | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -domsampling,performancedecreasesforallmeth- -hypothesesforprofileexploration. -| | | | | | | | ods due | to increased | difficulty, | while | DUET | con- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | sistently | maintains | the | best performance | | across | -ExamplesofUserCues -| | | | | | | | datasets. | Thisindicatesthattheimprovementsare | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “enjoys | retro | puzzle | games” | — | derived | from re- | | | | | | | -robustandnotlimitedtotrivialrankingscenarios. -peatedengagementwithclassictitles. -“prefersconciseproductreviews”—inferredfrom B.3 RobustnessunderPreferenceDiversity -apatternofshort,directcomments. -WefurtheranalyzetherobustnessofDUETunder -“tendstogivehighratingsbutrarelycomments”— -| | | | | | | | varyinglevelsofuserpreferencediversity. | | | | | Weuse | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -highlightingconsistencybutlimitedfeedback. -thevarianceofhistoricalratingsasaproxyforpref- -| | | | | | | | erencestability: | | lowvarianceindicatesconsistent | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -ExamplesofItemCues -| | | | | | | | preferences, | while | high | variance | corresponds | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -“lightweighttrail-runningshoes”—derivedfrom -diverseorpotentiallyconflictingsignals. -productmetadata. -Wepartitionusersintothreegroupsbasedonper- -| “popular | among | budget-conscious | | | users” | — in- | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -centilethresholds(bottom33%,middle33%,top -ferredfrompurchasepatterns. -33%ofratingvariance)andevaluateperformance -| “stylized | with | retro | aesthetics” | | — extracted | from | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withineachgroup. -itemdescriptions. -| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Table 10, | performance | | degrades | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -smoothlyaspreferencediversityincreasesacross -| | | | | | | | all datasets. | Importantly, | | the degradation | | is grad- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -B AdditionalExperiments -ualratherthancatastrophic,indicatingthatDUET -B.1 Non-LLMBaselineviaExtractive -remainsstableunderheterogeneousornoisyinter- -Summarization -actionhistories. -| To examine | | whether | the | gains | of DUET | stem | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C TheUseofLargeLanguageModels -| from improved | | semantic | | representations | | rather | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| than generic | | text generation, | | we | introduce | a non- | | | | | | | -WeusedaLargeLanguageModel(LLM)onlyas -LLMbaselinebasedonextractivesummarization. a writing assistant to polish the language of the -| Specifically, | | we apply | TextRank | | (Mihalcea | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | manuscript | (e.g., | grammar | refinement, | | style ad- | -Tarau,2004)toselectsalientsentencesfromuser -| | | | | | | | justment,andclarityimprovement). | | | | Theresearch | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -historiesandconstructuserprofileswithoutusing ideas,methodologydesign,experiments,andanal- -anygenerativemodel. ysiswereentirelyconceived,implemented,andval- -| The | extracted | summaries | | are | then fed | into the | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -idatedbytheauthorswithoutrelianceontheLLM. -samedownstreampredictorforratingestimation. -| | | | | | | | The LLM | did not | contribute | to research | | ideation, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -Thisbaselineisolatestheeffectofreadablesumma- experimentaldesign,orresultinterpretation. -rizationfromrepresentationlearning. -Table8showsthatTextRankimprovesoversim- -| ple history | truncation | | (10H), | but | remains | signifi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Method | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | (%) | -10H 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -TextRank 0.8104 1.1323 50.51 30.23 0.5914 0.8223 61.19 29.68 0.6328 0.8854 59.59 29.48 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table8: Comparisonwithanon-LLMextractivesummarizationbaseline(TextRank). -| Method | | | Yelp | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -| | Table9: | RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| VarianceGroup | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -#Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 -| | | | (%) | (%) | | (%) (%) | | | (%) (%) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | -Stable 1530 0.4017 0.8664 71.76 68.96 432 0.2368 0.5990 82.56 86.89 1876 0.3171 0.8403 76.64 72.56 -Moderate 1354 0.4773 0.8309 60.09 46.26 436 0.3921 0.6628 64.16 47.02 1827 0.4495 0.8059 66.73 55.45 -Diverse 1444 0.6632 1.1198 51.13 45.95 428 0.5536 0.9607 57.10 59.27 1838 0.6199 1.0603 49.52 46.35 -Table10: PerformanceofDUETunderdifferentlevelsofuserpreferencediversity(measuredbyratingvariance). -#Samp. denotesthenumberofsamplesineachgroup. \ No newline at end of file +▫ Applicants must provide a public document proving the relationship with their +parents. It must indicate the names of the applicant and parents and the relation. +e.g., certificate of family registration, family registration certificate (card), family relation certificate, birth +certificate + +” +) + +▫ Applicants of Korean ethnicity who want to prove their eligibility with the loss of +their parents’ Korean citizenship must provide Family Relation Certificate (가족관 +계증명서) indicating the dates of losing their Korean citizenship, including the +applicants’. + +▫ Chinese applicants must provide either Family Relation Certificate (親屬關係證明) +or Family Registry Certificate (戶口簿) or both translated and notarized by the +public notary office to state their family relation +* Attestation from the Korean embassy is not necessary. + +“ +The Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry & Exit ( +*ONLY for applicants of Korean ethnicity + +출입국사실증명서 + +” +) + +j + +▫ Applicants of Korean ethnicity who want to prove their eligibility with their entire +education completed overseas must provide the Certificate of the Facts Concerning +the Entry & Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) issued by the Korean Immigration Office. + + Optional Documents + +# 1. List of Honors and Awards + + *use Appendix + +▫ + +If you have honors, awards, fellowships, or any academic certificates or test reports +to support your achievements, you can provide valid evidence along with the list + +E.g. Graduate Record Examination (GRE/ Code: 4558. Please report through the ETS website to be recognized), +Graduate Management Admissions Test (GMAT), Test of Proficiency in Korean (TOPIK), Korean Language +Proficiency Test (KLPT), etc. + +▫ Only those provided with evidence will be acknowledged in evaluation. + +# 2. Employment Certificate + +▫ + +If there is work, internship, or assistantship experience related to your intended +study or research at KAIST, please provide a certificate or official letter from where +you worked. The certificate or letter must include information such as duration of +work, position, and other information describing your job and duty. + +# 3. School Profile + +▫ + +▫ + +School profiles of colleges or universities you attended or are attending will help our +committee evaluate your applications in a useful context. + +It may include information about demography, programs, grading system, and +ranking. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +13 + + Ⅶ + + Degrees and Programs + +1. Degree Information + +Admission Dates: + +Spring (around March) / Fall (around September) + +The Degree Programs KAIST Offers: + + + + + + + + + +Master’s Degree +The Master’s degree generally requires two academic years of study. + +MBA Degree +The MBA degree is awarded in the department of Finance MBA and Techno-MBA. + +Doctoral Degree +The Ph.D. degree generally requires four or more academic years of study. + +Integrated Master's and Doctoral Degree +The integrated Master's and Doctoral degree program is a Doctoral degree program +integrated with Master’s degree program. It generally requires five academic years +of study. The program starts with the Master's program, and candidates are +promoted to the Doctoral program without the usual requirements of submitting the +Master’s thesis. + +※ In case of dropping out, Master’s degree could be awarded if the candidate has completed all the + +requirements of the Master’s degree. + +2. Programs + +College + +Programs + +Natural +Science + +Physics +Condensed Matter Physics, Optics, Plasma Physics, Particle and +Theoretical Physics, Soft Matter Physics, Nonlinear and Complex +Systems, Biophysics +* Applicants are highly recommended to contact advising professor + +prior to application + +Mathematical Sciences +Analysis, Algebra, Algebraic Geometry, Differential Geometry, +Numerical Analysis, Partial Differential Equations, Graph Theory, +Number Theory, Probability, Topology, Statistics, Biomathematics and +Medical Imaging, Computational Image Processing, Computational +Mathematics, Financial Mathematics + +Chemistry +Physical Chemistry, Organic Chemistry, +Inorganic Chemistry, +Analytical Chemistry, Polymer Chemistry, Bio Chemistry, Nano +Chemistry, Chemical Biology + +Main (Daejeon) Campus + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +● + +● + +http://physics.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2502 +E. sueca@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://mathsci.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2703 +E. hlyoon@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +http://chem.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2804 +E. ahnyeseul@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +14 + + College + +Programs + +Life Science +and +Bioengineering + +Biological Sciences +Biological/Biomedical Sciences (Cell Biology, Biochemistry, Structural +Biology, Genetics, Epigenetics, Stem Cell Biology, Plant Biology, +Developmental Biology, Neurobiology, Immunology), Biotechnology or +Bioengineering (Applied Biophysics, Microbial and Cell Biotechnology, +and Environmental Biotechnology, Synthetic Biotechnology) + +Graduate School of Medical Science and Engineering +- Physician-Scientist Track +Medical Sciences (Molecular Biology, Immunology, Virology, Stem +Cell Biology, Vascular Biology, Pathology, Molecular Genetics, +Neuroscience, Biochemistry, Structural Biology, Developmental +Biology) and Biomedical Engineering (Cell and Tissue Engineering) +* Only open to applicants with a bachelor’s degree (for M.S.- +Ph.D. integrated) and a bachelor’s degree and master’s +degree (for Ph.D.) from Medical, Dental or Oriental +Medicine School. THE APPLICANTS MUST SUBMIT AN +ORIGINAL OR CERTIFIED COPY OF MEDICAL +LICENSE + +- Medical Science and Engineering Track +Medical Sciences (Vascular Biology, Stem Cell Biology, Regenerative +Medicine, Developmental Biology, Immunology, Virology, +Neuroscience, Metabolism, Liver Biology, Pathology, Structural +Biology, Drug Design, Molecular Genetics, Molecular Biology). +* Only open to applicants majored in science and + +engineering. + +Mechanical Engineering +Micro/Nano Systems, IT-based Intelligent Mechanical Systems, New +Energy Systems, Biomedical Engineering, Mechanics and Design +Innovation, Pro-human Engineering, Ocean Systems + +Aerospace Engineering +Aerodynamics & Structures, Propulsion & Energy, Airborne Vehicle +Technology, Space Systems, Aerospace Information & Intelligence, +etc. + +Electrical Engineering +Circuits and Systems, Nano Devices and Integrated Systems, +Electromagnetics and Photonics, Communications, Computing, +Networking, Security, and Signals and Systems +* Applicants are highly recommended to find a prospective + +advisor prior to the application. + +* Applicants whose potential advisor is already determined +should write down their advisor name on application. + +* Applicants are strongly encouraged to survey the Electrical + +Engineering department webpage for the detailed +requirements to the admission process. + +Engineering + +- The Robotics Program + + - Future Vehicle + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +● + +● + +http://bio.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2605 +E. iskang@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +https://gsmse.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-4233 +E. ahsa89@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://me.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3002 +E. e_suk@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ae.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3706 +E. soaekim@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://ee.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3402 +E. ych@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +https://rp.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-5976 +E. albert.ahn@kaist.ac.kr + +T. 82-42-350-8461 +E. bnlee@kaist.ac.kr + +School of Computing +Foundations, Design, Visual Computing, Information Service, Social +Computing, Interactive Computing, Computing Theory, Systems- +Networks, Software Design, Secure Computing, AI-Information +Service, Embedded System, IT Service, UX, Intelligent SW +* Applicants are highly recommended to find a prospective + +advisor prior to the application. + + - Graduate School of Information Security +Cryptography, Software security, Network security, system security + +- Graduate School of Artificial Intelligence +Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, AI+Healthcare, AL+Autonomous +Driving, AI+Manufacturing, AI+Security, AI+Emerging + +Civil and Environmental Engineering +Structural Engineering and Materials, Geotechnical Engineering and +Geo-Systems, Environmental Engineering and Sustainability, IT for +Construction Engineering, Transportation, Urban Design and Planning + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://cs.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3508 +E. oeunbeul@kaist.ac.kr + +http://gsis.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-8303 +E. jisun813@kaist.ac.kr + +http://gsai.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-1802 +E. ssyang11@kaist.ac.kr + +http://civil.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3602 +E. juyeon_lee@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +15 + + College + +Programs + +Bio and Brain Engineering +Bioengineering and Brain Engineering including, + Bioelectronics, +Bioinforma-tics, Biomedical Imaging, BioNano/MEMS, Computational +Neuroscience, Neural Engineering, Systems Biology, Tissue +Engineering and Nanomedicine +- Brain and Cognitive Engineering +Brain Cognitive Science, Computational Neuroscience, +Neuroinformatics, Brain Systems Biology, Neuro Cognitive Robotics, +Brain-Machine Interface, Neuroprostehtics, Brain-Inspired Artificial +Intelligence, Clinical Neuroengineering, Neuro Stem Cell and Tissue +Engineering, Neuroimaging and Signal Analysis + +Industrial Design +Design Driven Innovation, User-Centered Design, Human Computer +Interaction, Design for Well-being and Social Innovation, Creative +Design Thinking, Product Service System and Platform Design, +Design for Co-Creation, Color psychology and emotional design, New +design media, Interaction media, Entertainment media +* Digital portfolio showcasing past projects that exemplifies +the candidate’s capabilities and skills, regardless of the +major of origin. + +Industrial & Systems Engineering +Statistical & Data Science, Machine Learning & AI for Industrial +Intelligence, Financial Optimization & Risk Analysis, Mathematical +Optimization and Stochastic Modeling & Analysis Methods, Modeling, +Analysis, Optimization, and Simulation of Complex Systems, Design +and Operation of Production and Logistics Systems, Operation +Management and Supply Chain Management, Human Computer +Interaction and Ergonomics, Design and Operation of Services and +Service Systems, Modeling and Optimization of Future Healthcare, +Transportation, Energy, and Defense Systems + +- Graduate School of Knowledge Service Engineering +Data Science, Big Data, Knowledge Modeling and Representation, +Knowledge Engineering, Business Intelligence, Human-Computer +Interaction, User Experience, User Behavior Modeling, Human +Decision Making, Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, Intelligent +System Modeling and Design, +Intelligent Decision Support, +Information Design, Content Networking, Pervasive Knowledge +Services, Content Service, Service Modeling. + +Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering +Synthetic/Systems biotechnology, BioRefinery, Nanobiotechnology, +Protein Engineering, Molecular & Interface Engineering, Superlattice +Nanomaterials, Microfluidic Systems, Functional Nano-Coatings, +Semiconductor and metal nanocrystals, Nano Catalysis, Chemical +Product / Process Design, Process Operation and Control, Green +Catalysis, etc. + +Materials Science & Engineering +Computational Material Science and Electron Microscopy, Data- +Storage Materials, Magnetic Materials, Electronic Packaging +Materials, Optical Materials, +for +Energy/Biotechnology Applications, Energy Storage Materials, Energy +Conversion Materials, Structural Materials, + Heat-Resistant +Materials, Biomaterials, Materials for Sustainable or Functional Nano +Technology, and Materials/Device for Display and flexible electronic. + +Informational Materials + +Nuclear and Quantum Engineering +Peaceful Use of Energy Generated by Nuclear Fission and Fusion +Reactions (Electric Power, Desalination, District Heating, Propulsion +etc.) Nuclear Fuel Cycle, Nuclear Security and Nonproliferation, +Nuclear Policy, Radiation Science and Technology, Radiation +Applications, Radiation Medical Imaging, Radiation Devices. + +- International Nuclear and Radiation Safety Master's Degree +Program(KINS-KAIST) +Only open to THOSE WHO ARE WORKING FOR GOVERNMENT OR +NUCLEAR RELATED INSTITUTIONS OF HIS/HER COUNTRY AND +ARE RECOMMENDED BY GOVERNMENT OR CURRENT +INSTITUTION. Visit website of the program for more information. + +Engineering + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +● + +Ph.D. + +● + +Office + +http://bioeng.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4303 +E. hae@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +http://bce.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-4305 +E. bceprogram@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +http://id.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4503 +E. sesedolee@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://ie.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3103 +E. wisdom1029@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://kse.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-1602 +E. yhchoi@kaist.ac.kr + +http://cbe.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3908 +E. so9034@kaist.ac.kr + +http://mse.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3303 +E. e_leeyj@kaist.ac.kr + +http://nuclear.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3804 +E. jyp@kaist.ac.kr + +Inss.kins.re.kr/inss/Action?act +=INDEXKK +T. 82-42-350-8511 +E. juyeong@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +16 + + College + +Programs + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +The Cho Chun Shik Graduate School of Green Transportation +Eco-friendly Transportation Technology (Electric Vehicle, Hybrid +Electric Vehicle, Wireless Electric Transfer, e-Mobility), Intelligent +Transportation Technology +(Autonomous Vehicle, Vehicular +Communication for Cooperative Driving), Sustainable Transportation +Technology (Efficient Urban Transportation Systems, Logistics +Optimization, Future City Policy) +Graduate School of Culture Technology +Creative Technologies +(Computer Graphics/Animation, Music +Technology, AR, VR, HCI, Computational Design, Augmented +Humans), Human & Culture Sciences (Network Science, Social +Computing, Cognitive Science, Digital Heritage), Culture Industries +(Computer Game, Art & Technology, Museum/Exhibition Technology) +* The Advisor’s name should be included in the application form +Graduate School of Science and Technology Policy +National Policy in Science and Technology, Health and Biomedical +Policy, the National Innovation System, Dynamics of R&D Policy +Decisions, Energy and Environment Policy, Aging and Welfare +Technology Policy, Ethics of Emerging Technologies +* Addition materials are required to apply for STP +program. Please visit and check the following +website: https://stp.kaist.ac.kr/0302 + +Business and Technology Management +Technology Management, +Innovative Strategy and Policy, +Entrepreneurship, Finance, Financial Economics, Supply Chain +Information Systems/E-business, +Management, Management +Information Economics, Organizational Behavior, Human Resource +Management, Information Sociology, Marketing, Accounting, Science +and Technology Policy +- Global IT Technology Program +IT Technology +IT Technology R&D +Latest +Management/Policy in Korea, Wireless Communications Technology, +Ubiquitous Computing, Software Engineering, ICT Economics and +Management, Internet Business and Management, Financial and +Accounting Management in IT Policy +Only open to THOSE WHO ARE NOMINATED BY GITTP department. +Please contact GITTTP in advance. +* Addition materials are required to apply for GITTP + +in Korea, + +program. Please visit and check the following +website: +https://ittp.kaist.ac.kr/html/kr/adm/adm_0203.html + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +Liberal Arts +and +Convergence +Science + +Business + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://gt.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-1252 +E. yujeong0610@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ct.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2903 +E. yujeong0610@kaist.ac.kr + +http://stp.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4843 +E. jungillee@kaist.ac.kr + +http://btm.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-6308 +E. kjjung@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ittp.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-6845 +E. kate1025@kaist.ac.kr + +College + +Department /Division + +Seoul Campus + +M.S. + +M.S.- + +PhD + +PhD + +Contact Info. + +Business + +Techno-MBA +The First Full-time MBA in Korea/Case-based Teaching and Real Business +Experience/World-class Study Environment/Global Leadership Program and +Exchanges Programs + +Green Business and Policy Program +Green Business and Policy Program nurtures sustainability entrepreneurs and +leaders in green business and policy. Students will develop the capability of +solving global green growth and sustainable development problems in the areas +of energy, environment, and climate change, based on an +integrated +understanding of business, policy, and technology. + +● + +● + +http://business.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-2-958-3642 +E. topcheol@kaist.ac.kr + +http://www.business.kaist.edu +T. 82-2-958-3407 +E. gsgg@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +17 + + Ⅷ + + Campus Life (Daejeon & Seoul) + +1. Life in Daejeon + +Dormitory +All students are provided with dormitories on campus. Each room is shared by one or two students and is +furnished with beds, closets, desks, and chairs. Residents share bathrooms, laundry rooms, and lounges. +Students pay a dormitory fee of approximately KRW 115,000 per month. + +Medical service +Minor wounds and illnesses are treated at an on-campus healthcare center for free. For more serious illnesses, +high quality professional medical service is offered on campus at the KAIST Clinic Pappalardo Center. + +Sports facilities +KAIST has excellent facilities for table tennis, tennis, soccer, racketball, badminton, volleyball, and basketball. +We also have swimming pools and fitness centers equipped with cycles, treadmills, barbells, etc. + +Library +KAIST has two major libraries: the Main Library and the Undergraduate Branch Library. There are also a +bookstore and a cafeteria on the first floor of the Main Library. + +International Scholar and Student Services (ISSS) +ISSS supports international students with regard to their visa issuance/extension, school registration, +housing, and orientation. ISSS also organizes various exciting activities, festivals, community services, etc. + +▪ +▪ +▪ + +http://isss.kaist.ac.kr +Email: isss@kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-42-350-2481~2 + +Restaurants +There are three cafeterias, some fast-food restaurants, and cafes on campus. You will also find numerous +restaurants located right outside of campus. KAIST also has an international kitchen. Many of our international +students gather at this place to cook and eat together. + +KAIST Language Center (KLC) +KLC offers language courses to improve the Korean and English skills of KAIST students and researchers. All +of the classes offered by KLC are non-credit classes, and tuition is charged for each class. Also, KLC provides +English proofreading services and Korean-English translation services. + +▪ +▪ +▪ + +http://lang.kaist.ac.kr +Email: language@kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-42-350-8731~2 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +18 + + 2. Life in Seoul (College of Business) + +Dormitory +KAIST College of Business (KCB) students board at the on-campus dormitory. The three dorm buildings, +Pajung, Sojung Hall, and Haejung Hall, are all located within 3-minute walking distance from each other and +approximately 5-minute walking distance from the main buildings of the campus. + +KCB students are mainly assigned in the Pajung Hall. The dorm rooms are designed for double occupancy. +Each person is provided with a desk, a bed, and a wardrobe. The bathroom facilities with shower booth are +shared. It costs KRW 160,000 (approx. USD 160) per month. + +Medical service +The Nurse’s Office is located on the 2nd floor of the Student Union Building. You can get medication for minor +illnesses and injuries. There is a nominal fee for the purchase of medication. + +Sports Facilities +There are outdoor tennis and basketball courts near the dormitories, and an indoor fitness center (gym) is +located on the 1st floor of Building 7, which is connected to SUPEX building. In addition, a newly built golf +practice range is located on the ground floor of the Administration building (Building No. 1) and this facility is +open to registered members only. +The gym is open 24 hours located on the 1st floor. Lockers and shower rooms are also facilitated inside the gym. + +Library +Unlike traditional libraries, the KAIST College of Business students’ library is a digital multi-media library. +This gives students and faculty members the advantage of being able to obtain necessary resources in the +comfort of one’s computer at home. The digital library is joined with the Cyber Hall, a facility where students +have access to the Internet 24 hours a day. + +Restaurants +Student cafeteria serves Korean traditional / inter-national dishes. It is open Monday through Sunday +providing lunch and dinner. Additionally, the Faculty Restaurant is on the 4th floor of the same building. +Another place to eat is the Atrium located on 2nd floor of SUPEX building. It houses both a café and a +restaurant and open hours are as below. You can buy simple breakfast such as sandwiches at the Atrium. + +Office for Exchange Students +The External Affairs Center coordinates exchange & overseas programs. It also offers language programs to +enhance students' English proficiency skills. + +▪ +▪ + +Exchange Program jelee@business.kaist.ac.kr +Language Courses hsl007@business.kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-2-958-3244(Exchange Program) & Language Courses jelee@kaist.ac.kr Tel: +82-2-958-3244 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +19 + + Ⅸ + + Financial Aid + +1. Student budget + +Planning your enrollment at KAIST, you should be aware of the estimated expenses that you will +incur. The average budget for a single graduate student living on-campus with no dependents +budget is listed below. Students living off campus can expect living expenses to be 35% to 50% +higher. + +- + +Non-tuition average expenses (2021, currency in KRW): 4,576,000/6 months + +Dormitory 690,000/6 months + +Food 2,745,000/6 months + +Transportation 200,000/6 months + +Books and Supplies 150,000/6 months + +Medical Health Insurance 791,000/6 months + +Tuition & fees (2021, currency in KRW): + +Techno MBA 12,600,000/semester +Finance MBA 15,910,000/semester +Social Economy MBA 12,600,000/semester +Green Business and Policy Program 12,360,000/semester +Other departments 4,048,000/semester + +※ Subject to change by yearly base. + +Entrance Fee none (for all departments) +Student union fee 34,000 (Optional) +Student Health Insurance 43,000 /semester + +2. KAIST International Student Scholarship + +KAIST scholarship recipients are generally exempt from paying tuition and fees. A monthly +allowance of KRW 350,000 (for Master’s candidates) or KRW 400,000 (for Doctoral candidates) +and Medical Health Insurance fees will be supported by the recipient’s advisors or departments. + +3. Earnings on Campus + +There are opportunities for international students to make earnings on campus. Wages are paid for +research (RA), teaching (TA) or other work (Part-time assistant, etc.) performed during +enrollment. Students can apply for positions after the entrance. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +20 + + Appendix. Form - List of Honors and Awards + +# NOTE: To download the form, please click the following LINK. + +Application Number + +Applicant Name + +LIST OF HONORS AND AWARDS +for International Graduate Enrollment + +Please list up to five honors or awards you have obtained during university in order of importance. Each +item below will be considered valid only when the respective testimonial/evidence is submitted. + +No + +Title + +Rank + +Date +(yyyy/mm) + +Level of Recognition +(National / International) + +Issuing Institution: + +Name: + +1 + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +2 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +3 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +Name: + +4 + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +5 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +p a g e + + | 22 + +21 + + ※ + +Notice on Collection and Use of Personal Information + + According to the Personal Information Protection Law, KAIST will obtain your agreement on +collecting and using your personal information as below through our online system. + +The Office of Admission will collect and use your personal information for the purpose of student selection +and enrollment to KAIST. + +I. Personal Information Required for Student Selection and Enrollment (Compulsory) + +List of Information + +Purpose + +Legal Grounds + +(Compulsory information) name, +address, phone/mobile number, +country of citizenship, photo, +institutions attended (institutions, +degree, major field of study, dates +attended, academic performance) +(Optional information) English +proficiency test score, work history +(place of work, duration of service, +job title, responsibilities), honors and +awards, research field and topic + +▪ Student selection (All applicants) +▪ Enrollment (only for successful + +applicants) + +- Registration on school register + +- Academic history check + +- Academic performance check + +- Providing information regarding + +registration etc. + +▪ Higher Education Act, +Article 33(Admission +Qualifications), Article +34 (Methods for +Selecting Students) +▪ Enforcement Decree of +the Higher Education +Act, Article 35 (Data +for Admission +Screening) + +Holding +Duration + +10 years + +※ The subject of information has the right to deny the collection and use of their personal + +information. However, as the above information is compulsory for the student selection process, + +denial of information collection and use means that the subject of information may not apply to + +be considered in the selection process. + +- Do you consent to the above collection and use of your personal information? + + I consent + + I do not consent + +▢ + +▢ + +2. Unique Identifying Information Collection and Use (Compulsory) + +Items + +Purpose + +Legal Grounds + +Passport number / +Alien Registration +Number (in case you +have a valid number) + +▪ Admission screening and student + +selection (All applicants) + +▪ Handling of violations in the application + +process (all applicants) + +▪ Documentation of education such as + +school register entry and management +etc. (Only for successful applicants) + +Enforcement Decree of the +Higher Education Act, Article 73 +(Handling of Unique Identifying +Information) + +Holding +Duration + +10 years + +※ The subject of information has the right to deny the collection and use of their personal + +information. However, as the above information is compulsory for the student selection process, + +denial of information collection and use means that the subject of information may not apply to + +be considered in the selection process. + +- Do you consent to the above collection and use of your personal information? + + I consent + + I do not consent + +▢ + +▢ + +p a g e + + | 22 + +22 + diff --git a/q32/random_k4/question.json b/q32/random_k4/question.json index 2b5b29863c8a6138ddf290cdb8000793265a3219..2bb16448529b071cbefb1d3b41f4d554ceecd0a5 100644 --- a/q32/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q32/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "efd88e41c5f2606c57929cac6c1c0605.pdf", - "web_eb595c42c11e1922.pdf", - "5fdcf120b846746985684fa54250aab44639b30c.pdf", - "web_2aea13e00a3747ab.pdf", - "web_a43524926d478681.pdf" + "web_c4b89ce88439ccc8.pdf", + "web_446956eff47e9ead.pdf", + "1d1e9796cf93063d60a92e083ff4372e3ac27d28.pdf", + "web_28449e05c7149be2.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q32/random_k4/random_1.md b/q32/random_k4/random_1.md index e69f9af4739cdd1be4b25214374a527c28edba66..9ebf4f2afe80a6dd309a88c75a680e518d05933b 100644 --- a/q32/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q32/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,854 +1,1858 @@ -READ AND SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -WARNING: A risk of fire and electrical shock exists in all -electrical appliances and may cause personal injury or death. -Please follow all safety instructions. - -Espresso/Cappuccino Maker - -I - -R -O -F -E -D -U -G -E -R -A -C -D -N -A -E -S -U +Quick +Start +Guide -B -1 -X -E -M +Welcome to the +Whitman Experience -, +2025–2026 -I + From the Dean +of Students +Welcome to the Whitman Community. -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -L -E -D -O -M +It’s a word you’ll hear a lot at Whitman: community. Let me assure you, +it’s not something we take lightly. We want to help you build new bonds, +find your people and learn collaboratively. -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -D -N -A +We’re excited for you to join our vibrant campus community. It will shape +you in ways you can’t yet anticipate. And we know you will shape us too. +That’s what community—and Whitman College—is all about. - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +Welcome to Whitman. Our Whitman. Your Whitman. -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +With gratitude, -left unattended. +Kazi Joshua +Vice President for Student Affairs +& Dean of Students -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +Mindset Moment -See instructions for cleaning. +Enjoy the journey. College is a time +of exploration and discovery, so don’t -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +spend too much time worrying about -children. +the future or dwelling on the past. -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +Instead, focus on being present and -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +making the most of each day. -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +Your Fall 2025 at a Glance +Residence Halls Open for New Students ........... Wednesday, Aug. 27 -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +Opening Week/Orientation Begins ..................... Wednesday, Aug. 27 -surfaces. +Family Orientation .......................................................Thursday, Aug. 28 -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +Fall Semester Classes Begin ........................................ Tuesday, Sept. 2 -heated oven. +Fall Break ..................................................................................... Oct. 9–12 -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +Family Weekend .......................................................................Oct. 24–26 -function knob to “OFF.” +Thanksgiving Break ................................................................Nov. 24–30 -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +Fall Final Exams ........................................................................Dec. 15–19 -used. +See pages 10–11 for the full academic calendar. -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +Dean Juli Dunn +Assistant Vice President of Student Life +& Senior Associate Dean of Students +509-527-5208 +dunnjl@whitman.edu -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing + We’re So Excited To Welcome +You to Whitman College! -cup or brew basket. +Move-In Day is +Wednesday, Aug. 27. -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +We hope you have already been receiving our Monday Email +Series from Dean Juli Dunn. She’ll be your guide through the +summer as you prepare to join us in late August. -be used on a range top. +Families who need overnight accommodations in Walla Walla -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +are encouraged to make reservations as soon as possible. Find -weakened handle. +information about nearby lodging, restaurants and activities at -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +These emails will share helpful info, deadline reminders and updates +about our orientation schedule and fall semester. Your family will +also get emails over the summer to keep them up to date. -other abrasive material. +Do you have your Whitman account and email? You should +have received instructions for claiming your Whitman account +in your personal email. Don’t see that email? Contact +helpdesk@whitman.edu. + +wallawalla.org and other helpful tips about traveling to Whitman +at whit.mn/traveling. + +New Student Orientation +New Student Orientation will begin on the afternoon of +Wednesday, Aug. 27, following move-in. The schedule will +be available at whitman.edu/orientation later this summer. +Learn more on page 12. + +Arrival & Check-In +Students will be able to check in to their Fall 2025 residence +halls and rooms on Wednesday, Aug. 27. We’ll send an assigned +check-in time to your Whitman email as the date gets closer. + +Family Orientation +Family Orientation will be held on Thursday, Aug. 28. +More information about Family Orientation will be posted +at whitman.edu/families. + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 1 + + Your To-Do List + +Look for weekly emails from Dean Juli Dunn every Monday until classes begin. The New Student +Orientation schedule will be posted at whitman.edu/orientation as soon as it is available. + +Items You Must Complete +For most of these tasks, you’ll receive more detailed instructions in your Whitman email. + +By June 20 + +By July 1 + + ■ COMPLETE your Housing Preferences Survey, if you haven’t +already. In August, you’ll receive your residence hall and room +assignment in your Whitman email, as well as in the mail. + ■ REVIEW your student check-in tasks: whit.mn/checkin + +(full list available after June 16) + + ■ CONTACT the Office of Student Accounts at + +StuAcct@whitman.edu if you didn’t receive an invoice +email in late June for Fall 2025. + + ■ SHARE your preferences for Opening Week + +Whitman Experiences. + + ■ SUBMIT your name pronunciation recording. + ■ SUBMIT your photo for your Whitman ID card. + ■ COMPLETE the Pre-Major Advising Questionnaire: + +whit.mn/pmaq. + + ■ REVIEW options for First Year Seminar courses +in your Whitman email and submit your preferred +learning communities. + + ■ SUBMIT your Transfer Credit Form—for credits from another +college/university; for Running Start or other dual enrollment +courses; or for AP, IB or A-Level exams. Complete the form at +whit.mn/checkin. + + ■ REQUEST College Board send AP reports to Whitman + +(if applicable). + + ■ REQUEST International Baccalaureate send IB certificates to + +Whitman (if applicable). + +Keep an eye on your email: During June, look for required +trainings on Substance Use Education, Sexual Assault Prevention, +and Hazing Prevention. + +Plan to work on campus? Create a profile on Handshake, +Whitman’s job and internship platform: whit.mn/handshake. + +Single Sign-On: How-To! +Whitman’s single sign-on uses your Whitman username +and password. Your username is the part of your email +address before @whitman.edu like Dean Dunn’s. + +2 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + +By July 15 + + ■ COMPLETE your student check-in: whit.mn/checkin. + ■ REQUEST your final high school or college transcripts from all +previous institutions be sent to the Office of Admission. + ■ COMPLETE any applicable placement test, such as calculus, + +chemistry and/or languages: whit.mn/place. + + ■ CONSIDER your payment options. If you are requesting +a Deferred Payment Plan contract for Fall 2025, send +your request to StuAcct@whitman.edu. Learn more +about payment options and making online payments at +whit.mn/StuAcct. + +By Aug. 15 + + ■ COMPLETE all required online trainings. + ■ UPLOAD required immunizations into your student + +health portal. (You’ll get more instructions over the summer.) + + ■ PAY your bill for the Fall 2025 semester. View your +Student Accounts balance at my.whitman.edu. + +Check out your +payment options. + + Y O U R W H I T M A N A C C O U N T S + +Getting All Set ... + +Have you set up your Whitman account? If not, search your personal email for the subject line: +“Welcome to Whitman College! Claim your account.” + +Follow the instructions in that email to claim and activate your Whitman email address and network +account. You’ll also set up a password for your account. If you ever forget it, go to id.whitman.edu +for forgotten password recovery. + +Using Whitmail + +Whitman’s email system, Whitmail, is run by the Google +platform. You can access your email, Google Drive and +Google Apps through the Whitmail system. + +To Log In: + + } Go to whitmail.whitman.edu. + } Log in with the Whitman username and password you set. + +Create Your Student ID +Along with claiming your account (see above), you’ll need to do +these additional steps: + + } Upload a photo to be used on your student ID. See photo +requirements and tips at whitman.edu/student-ids. + } Make a recording of the accurate pronunciation of your + +name and upload it to your account. + +Check for instructions in your Whitman email regarding the +photo upload and name pronunciation. + +Need Assistance? +The Whitman College Technology Services Help Desk is open +Monday–Friday. Summer hours: 8 a.m.–noon and 1–4 p.m. + } Forgot your password: id.whitman.edu + } Call: 509-527-4976 + } Email: helpdesk@whitman.edu + } Online: kb.whitman.edu to search our Knowledge Base + } Get more tech tips for new students at whit.mn/tech-tips. + } Plus: Find tech help at Penrose Library—check out laptops + +and chargers to use in the library. + +Mindset Moment + +Embrace growth. Look at +challenges as opportunities for + +growth—and don’t be afraid to + +step out of your comfort zone. + +Free Software +All students receive a free copy +of Microsoft 365, including +Word, Excel and PowerPoint. + +Starting Aug. 1, you’ll be able to go to +portal.office.com and log in with your +Whitman account to download +your free software. + + 4 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + L I V I N G A T W H I T M A N + +Your New Home + +During your time at Whitman, you’ll meet people from diverse backgrounds who will help you to grow + +intellectually and emotionally. And you’ll make lifelong friends in the process. + +Our residence halls are more than a group of students living together—they are a community. Your hall + +section is led by a Resident Assistant (RA), who is a student like you. RAs plan section events and + +gatherings to ease your transition to college and help connect all the students living in your area. Each hall + +also has a Resident Director (RD) or a Community Director (CD)—professional staff members who live + +and work in the hall to support students. + +Housing Assignments +You will receive information about on-campus room + +Will You Need a Car? +Whitman strongly recommends that new students do not bring + +assignments in early August. If you haven’t filled out your + +vehicles to campus. Most students find good and sustainable + +housing survey, please do so as soon as possible. You can access +it at whitman.erezlife.com. This information is required to +complete room assignments. + +alternatives. Parking is also limited. Campus is within walking + +distance to downtown, a grocery store, restaurants and + +coffee shops. + +In early August, you will receive your room and roommate + +Walla Walla has affordable public transit and is bike- and + +assignments by both email and a mailed letter. + +pedestrian-friendly. The college offers a free bike-share program + +Meal Plans +Our food service is provided by Bon Appétit. You can learn more + +about our on-campus dining options, view menus and read +about our Flex Dollars meal plans at whit.mn/meals. + +and has an on-campus bike repair shop. There are ride-sharing + +services in town—to catch a ride from our local airport, for + +example. And thanks to a new Whitman car-share program + +launching this summer, students can access electric vehicles for + +hourly use. + +Mailing Services & Shipping Boxes +You will be assigned a mailbox at the post office in Reid Campus + +Center when you arrive, but your mailbox number does not need + +to be included in your address. + +The college also coordinates bus services to Seattle, Portland + +and Pasco during academic breaks (see below). The Grape Line + +Shuttle also provides service to the Pasco airport. For more +information, visit whitman.edu/transportation. + +If you need to send boxes to Whitman ahead of your arrival, +please ship them using the address shown below. Please do not +ship items more than two weeks before the beginning of the +semester. You can pick up your packages on Move-In Day +(Aug. 27) at Reid Campus Center. + +Your Mailing Address +Your mailing address while enrolled at Whitman is: + +Learn +more! + +Your Name + +Whitman College + +280 Boyer Ave. + +Walla Walla, WA 99362 + +Breaks & Buses! + +Whitman will provide shuttle +service for key breaks during +the 2025–2026 academic +year to Seattle, Portland and +the Tri-Cities Airport (PSC). + + Make Your Room +Your Own! + +Things We Provide + } Bed, with extra-long twin mattress (80 inches). Beds in + +Prentiss Hall are standard twin size. + + } Mattress cover + } Desk and chair + } Wardrobe with storage/shelving + } Chest of drawers + } Window blinds + } Bulletin board + } No-cost laundry—washers and dryers + } Whitman Wi-Fi + } Ethernet port for wired internet connections + +Things You’ll Likely Want + } Bedding (pillows, extra-long twin sheets, + +blankets, bedspread) + } Bath and hand towels + } Hangers + } Study lamp—lamps are provided in Jewett Hall + } Wastebasket + } Laundry basket and detergent + } Small fan + +Things You May Want + } Dishes, silverware, mugs + } Flame-retardant decorations + } A mini-fridge rental. Fill out the form at whit.mn/fridge to + +reserve one for $80 a year. + +Things NOT To Bring + } Halogen lamps + } Firearms or other weapons + } Pets (fish are OK) + } Furniture, such as a bed or desk + } Double-sided sticky tape or squares + } Portable or window air conditioners + +6 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + +Take a Look Around! + } 360-degree room tours + } Photo galleries + } Videos + } Amenities lists + +whitman.edu/residence-halls + +Questions? +509-527-5297 +studenthousing@whitman.edu + + Academic Success +Starts Here + +At Whitman, you’ll be challenged to think deeply, write clearly and speak + +confidently. With small classes and supportive faculty, you won’t just + +learn facts—you’ll explore ideas, make connections and grow as a thinker. + +Whitman’s liberal arts approach gives you the freedom to try new things—to + +dive into what interests you—and the tools to take on whatever comes next. + +Go to whitman.edu/new-student-academics for more +resources and important information, including access to: + + } Whitman College Catalog—your primary source of +information about current courses, general college +policies, and requirements for graduation, majors and +special programs + + } Placement tests—for chemistry, computer science, + +foreign languages and math + +Mindset Moment + +Build connections. Your peers, +professors and mentors can be + +some of your greatest resources. + +Look for ways to build meaningful + +connections with others. You never + +know where those relationships + +may lead! + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 7 + + What To Expect: +Registering for Classes + +Here’s a general timeline for how you’ll get registered for your first classes at + +Whitman. In the meantime, check your Whitman email regularly and explore +my.whitman.edu. We’ll walk you through the registration process later this summer. + +Remember: We’re here to help and you’ll have guidance along the way. + +Mid-June +We’ll email you about First Year Seminar courses, and you can submit your preferred +learning communities. (See more on First Year Seminars below.) + +Mid-July +A Summer Registration Assistant (SRA) will reach out to you by email to schedule a +virtual meeting. They’ll help you plan your Fall 2025 semester schedule. + +Early August +If you’ve completed your SRA meeting, you’ll be assigned a registration time to sign +up for classes online. + +Late August +During New Student Orientation, you’ll meet with your Pre-Major Advisor to review +your fall schedule. You can make changes if needed. Your Pre-Major Advisor will +advise you until you officially declare a major at Whitman. + +What You Can Do Now +Fill out the Pre-Major Advising Questionnaire. It will help us get to know you better. +It takes a few minutes, and no preparation is necessary. Find it at whit.mn/pmaq. + +Have Questions +About Registration? + +The Registrar’s Office and Helen Kim, + +Associate Dean/Academic Affairs, + +are available to answer your questions + +about registration, course selection + +and advising. + +Registrar’s Office +Phone: 509-527-5983 + +Email: registrar@whitman.edu + +Pre-Major Advising +Phone: 509-527-5187 + +Email: Helen Kim at kimh2@whitman.edu + +Off to a Great +Academic Start! +You will receive information +about First Year Seminars and +descriptions of the different +learning communities in mid- +June. You will submit your four +preferred learning communities +in mid-July. You will learn which +course you have been assigned +before you register for classes. + +The First Year Seminars—Exploring Complex Questions (GENS 175) and Making +Powerful Arguments (GENS 176)—combine a fall course that emphasizes inquiry, +interdisciplinary exploration and intellectual community with a spring seminar that + +features in-depth investigation of a focused topic. Both seminars will help you + +improve the reading, writing and discussion skills you will rely on throughout your + +time at Whitman. Course descriptions for fall seminars will be sent to you over the + +summer. We will do our best to assign you based on your choices. + +Transfer students with fewer than 58 credits will take GENS 175 but may receive + +equivalent credit for GENS 176 for a comparable course taken at another institution. + +8 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + Know Before You Go + +Virtual Orientation Chats With Dean Dunn and Friends +Bring your questions and learn more about what to expect. +You’ll come to campus in the fall with all the details you need! + +Get the link to join and find the recordings at whitman.edu/julichats. + +Residence Life & Housing ................................................... June 12 + +Advising & Registration ..................................................... June 25 + +Opening Week Preview ....................................................... Aug. 21 + +Mindset Moment + +Set goals. Reflect on what you +hope to achieve during your time + +at Whitman, both academically + +and personally. Setting goals— + +and reminding yourself of your + +intentions—can help you navigate + +your unique college journey. + +W H I T M A N . E D U / 9 + + 2025 Fall Semester + +Mon + +SEPTEMBER 1 + +Add/Drop +Period Begins + +Tue 2 -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. - -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. - -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. - -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be - -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. - -1 +Wed + +3 + +Thu + +4 + +First Day of Classes + +Sat + +6 + +Sun + +7 + +Fri + +5 + +12 + +Registration/Add +Period Ends + +Week 1 + +Week 2 + +Week 3 + +Week 4 + +Week 5 + +Week 6 + +Week 7 + +Week 8 + +Week 9 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +29 + +6 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +3 + +11 + +18 + +25 2 +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +6 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +30 + +OCTOBER 1 + 8 +15 + +Last Day to Drop +Without Record + +22 + +Mid-Semester + 7 +14 + +21 + +28 + +4 + +11 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +Fall Break + +Family Weekend + +NOVEMBER 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +29 + 6 -5 +13 + +19 + +26 3 +10 + +17 + +24 + +31 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + +5 + +12 + +Spring 2026 +Preregistration +Begins + +Last Day To Withdraw +From Classes With a +W grade + +13 + +20 + +27 + +Thanksgiving Break + 4 +11 + +18 + +Last Day of Classes; +Last Day To +Pass/D/Fail + +Reading Days + +19 + +20 + +End of Semester + +Residence Halls +Close at Noon + +14 + +21 + +28 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +29 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + 3 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +10 -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +17 -tip +Week 10 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Pass/D/Fail Period +Begins -lid +10 -7. Filter basket -and holder +17 -8. Function -knob +24 - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +DECEMBER 1 -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +8 + +15 + +Week 11 + +Week 12 + +Week 13 + +Week 14 + +Week 15 + +Week 16 + +Spring 2026 +Preregistration Ends + +18 + +25 + +2 + +9 + +16 -left unattended. +Final Exams -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +10 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -See instructions for cleaning. + 2026 Spring Semester -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Mon -children. +JANUARY 19 -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +Tue -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +20 -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +Wed -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +21 -surfaces. +Thu -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +22 -heated oven. +Fri -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +23 -function knob to “OFF.” +Sat -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +24 -used. +Sun -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +25 -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing +Week 1 + +MLK Day; Add/ +Drop Period Begins + +First Day of Classes + +27 + +3 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +3 + +10 + +17 + +24 + +31 + +7 -cup or brew basket. +14 -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +Week 2 -be used on a range top. +Week 3 -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +Week 4 -weakened handle. +Week 5 -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +Week 6 -other abrasive material. +Week 7 + +Week 8 + +Week 9 + +26 2 -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. - -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. - -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. - -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be - -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. - -1 +9 + +Student Fall ’25 +Incomplete Grade +Deadline + +16 + +Presidents Day + +23 2 +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +6 + +Week 10 + +Pass/D/Fail +Period Begins + +Week 11 + +Week 12 + +Week 13 + +Week 14 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +4 + +11 + +Week 15 + +Last Day of Classes; +Last Day To Pass/D/Fail + +18 + +Week 16 + +Undergraduate +Conference + +21 + +28 + +Fall 2026 +Preregistration Ends + +5 + +12 + +19 + +Reading Days + +End of Semester + +28 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +4 + +11 + +18 + +25 + +APRIL 1 + 8 -7 +15 + +22 + +29 6 +13 + +20 + +29 + +30 + +Registration/Add +Period Ends + 5 +12 + +19 + +Power & Privilege +Symposium + +26 + +5 + +12 + +19 + +Spring Break + +26 + +Spring Break + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +30 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +6 + +13 + +20 + +27 + +Last Day to Drop +Without Record + +6 + +Mid-Semester + +13 + +20 + +27 + 3 +10 + +Last Day To Withdraw From +Classes With a W Grade + +17 + +24 + +Fall 2026 +Preregistration Begins + +MAY 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +Final Exams + +31 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + +7 + +14 + +21 + +28 + 4 +11 + +18 + +25 + +2 + +9 + +16 + +23 + +FEBRUARY 1 + +8 + +15 + +22 + +MARCH 1 + +8 + +15 + +Residence Halls +Close + +22 + +29 + +Residence Halls +Reopen + +5 + +12 + +19 + +26 + 3 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +10 -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +17 -tip +24 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Residence Halls +Close at 5 p.m. -lid +COMMENCEMENT -7. Filter basket -and holder +W H I T M A N . E D U / 11 -8. Function -knob + A U G U S T 2 7 – S E P T E M B E R 1 - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Opening Week Fall 2025 -Making Espresso Coffee +First day. First week. +First of many amazing times ahead. -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +We’re planning quite a kickoff for your Whitman experience. You’ll explore -from the appliance. +Whitman, meet new people, have some fun—all while learning about Whitman’s -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +academic opportunities, the Walla Walla Valley, campus resources, student clubs -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +and more! -carafe. +Stay tuned for more details on Opening Week in Walla Walla, as well as virtual -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +orientation components you will complete over the summer. It will all be in -brewing process – scalding may occur. +Juli’s Monday emails. (See page 1.) -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +OWLS—Your Opening Week Leaders -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Whoooooo’s excited to meet you?! Your OWL. -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +We’ve recruited a group of enthusiastic and wise Whitties—who have been in -Making Cappuccino +your place—to be with you on your first-week journey. They’ll lead small groups -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +of new students during orientation and be a friendly face and helpful resource -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +along the way. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +Your OWL will be in contact with you later in the summer. -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Mindset Moment -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Fail forward. Mistakes are inevitable, +but they’re also valuable learning -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +experiences. View setbacks as -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +stepping stones on the path -function knob to the “OFF” position. +to success. -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +12 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. + Fun with OWLs! +Opening Week Activities +& Adventures -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +During Opening Week, you’ll have the +opportunity to participate in a special +Experience Whitman activity with +our Opening Week Leaders (OWLs) +on Friday, Aug. 29, and Saturday, +Aug. 30. From outdoor adventures to +creative projects to fun and games— +there will be something for everyone! -4 +F A M I L Y O R I E N T A T I O N -5 +Welcoming +Whitman Families - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Family Orientation will be +Thursday, Aug. 28 -Making Espresso Coffee +More information about Family Orientation will be +posted at whitman.edu/families. -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +Mindset Moment -from the appliance. +Practice gratitude. In the midst of busy +schedules and academic pressures, it’s important -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +to pause and appreciate the good things in life. -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +W H I T M A N . E D U / 13 -carafe. + SAVE THE DATE +Student Activities Fair +Monday, Sept. 1 +The Student Activities Fair +will showcase 100+ student clubs +and organizations and will be +held on the Monday before +classes start. -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the + Explore +specific clubs -brewing process – scalding may occur. +S T U D E N T L I F E -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Join & Enjoy! Find +Endless Possibilities -function knob to the “OFF” position. +At Whitman, you’ll find so many ways to get involved, including interest and -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +affinity clubs, club sports, outdoor adventures and so much more! Here are just -Making Cappuccino +a few highlights: -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +Student Clubs, Affinity & Cultural Groups: Whitman students create belonging +through groups based on shared interests, passions, identity, culture, background, -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +religion, etc. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +Club Sports & Intramurals: Team up for sand volleyball, climbing, pickleball, +ultimate, corn hole, skiing—just to name a few sporty options. Find so much to do! -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Debate & Forensics: Whitman’s team is among the most successful collegiate +programs in the country and open to students across class years and majors. -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Outdoor Program (OP): The OP provides countless opportunities to explore outdoor +recreation or to hone your skills in an activity you’re already passionate about. -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +Sorority & Fraternity Life: Whitman’s eight sororities and fraternities offer students +a close-knit community, leadership opportunities and lifelong friendships. -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Mindset Moment -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Celebrate diversity. Whitman is a wonderful melting pot of cultures, +backgrounds and perspectives. Seek out opportunities to learn from -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +those who are different from you. + +14 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E + + Whitties often use words, acronyms, shorthand or slang that are part of our +shared culture. Here are a few you might hear around campus. + +ARC (say it: “ark”) +The Academic Resource +Center is the home of +academic counseling +and tutoring services. +It is the place to go for +academic support. + +Ank or Ankeny +Ankeny Field is the gorgeous +green field at the heart of +campus—a place for playing, +studying and hanging out +with friends. + +ASWC (say it: “az-wack”) +The Associated Students of +Whitman College represents +student interests on campus, +sponsors all-campus +programming, and funds +student organizations. The +Student Activities office +advises and supports ASWC +in its efforts. + +BFFC +Baker Ferguson Fitness +Center is where to go for a +cardio or weight workout. Also +found at BFFC: Harvey Pool, +which is home to Whitman’s +varsity swim team. + +CCEC +The Career and Community +Engagement Center is +located on the top floor of Reid +Campus Center. It’s where +to go for career coaching, +campus jobs, internships +and more! + +Cleve +Cleveland Commons is +Whitman’s ultramodern dining +hall. Hungry? Love a latte? +From smash burgers to sushi +to smoothies, Cleve has your +cravings covered. + +COWS (say it: “cows”) +The Center for Writing and +Speaking is staffed with peer +tutors. It’s a great place to get +help on a writing or speaking +assignment. + +GAIC (say it: “gack”) +The Glover Alston +Intercultural Center is +a welcoming hub for +connection, support and +cultural celebration— +helping students from all +backgrounds thrive and feel +included at Whitman. + +IHC +Interest House Community. +Each Interest House is +home to 4–10 students +and is centered around a +theme, such as a language, +community or interest. + +J-Caf +Jewett Café is an indoor +gathering and study space +between Jewett Hall +and Lyman House. Get +grab-and-go breakfast and +lunch, as well as coffee from +a local roaster. + +K-Dub +KWCW 90.5 FM is +Whitman’s own radio station. +The K-Dub office and studio +are on the mezzanine level of +Reid Campus Center. + +Lakum Duckum +A Whitman hot spot +along Boyer Avenue, this +geothermal spring has its +own raft of ducks. + +Mem +Memorial Building is home to +many administrative offices. +You can’t miss it—the big +clock tower with bells ringing +on the hour. + +Narnia +A wild and wooded study +nook near Whitman’s Office of +Admission, Penrose House— +not to be confused with +Penrose Library (campus’s +top stop for scholars). + +OP +The Outdoor Program offers +weekend trips, adventures +and courses throughout the +school year. It also includes +the Climbing Center at +Sherwood Center, as well as a +Rental Shop (in the basement +of Reid Campus Center) +where students and others +can rent or purchase outdoor +equipment. + +OWLs (say it: “owls”) +Opening Week Leaders. +This enthusiastic team of +nearly 50 returning students +will help you get your feet +underneath you during +Opening Week. + +QRC +The Queer Resource +Center is a welcoming +and affirming space +committed to supporting +LGBTQIA+ students. + +RAs +Resident Assistants are +students who live in a +residence hall and supervise +a section of students. + +Reid +Reid Campus Center is a +go-to place for student +activities and resources. +Pick up your mail, find a cozy +spot to study, check out the +bookstore, get a coffee or soft +serve, visit the career center, +or just meet up with friends. + +RDs +Resident Directors are +staff members, often recent +college graduates, who live in +a residence hall and supervise +student staff. + +SRs +Senior Residents are RAs +in a first-year hall with +additional responsibilities. + +STEM Hub (say it: “stem”) +An area in the Hall of Science +for student learning and +collaboration—tutoring, +advising, study groups, etc. + +Third Space (3SC) +The Third Space Center +is a dedicated space that +centers the needs of +students of color. It’s a +place for gathering, learning +and thriving. + +WCTS +Whitman College Technology +Services offers help by email +and phone. You can also stop +by their Help Desk in person. + +WEB (say it: “web”) +Whitman Events Board is +a volunteer-driven student +committee which brings +a diverse and dynamic +selection of events to +campus, from speakers to +musical performances to +campus favorites such as +Outdoor Movie Night. + +Whitties (say it: “wit-ees”) +A friendly and familiar way to +refer to Whitman students +and alumni. + +WOOTs (say it: “woots”) +Whitman Outdoor +Orientation Trips are +overnight adventures offered +by the Outdoor Program as +part of Opening Week. + +The Wire +The college newspaper, +written and produced by an +all-student staff. + +Mindset Moment + +Stay organized. With so much going on, it’s easy to feel +overwhelmed. Develop good organizational habits early on to + +help you stay on top of assignments and other commitments. + + Your Health & +Wellness Matters + +At Whitman, we prioritize well-being in many ways—from residence life programs to academic support to student +groups—so all students can thrive and learn. For your specific needs, the Welty Health and Counseling Center, +conveniently located on campus, offers an integrated model of primary health care, counseling and wellness services -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +for all enrolled students. -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Services Available to Students Include: -4 + } Nursing care with licensed staff Monday through Saturday + } Medical provider available for examination and consultation -5 +during business hours - User Maintenance Instructions + } Mental health counseling free of charge, including + +individual counseling, group counseling and one-time +consultation sessions + + } Physical examinations + } Basic lab tests (such as strep tests, urinalysis, mono, etc.) + } Blood draws, which are sent to offsite labs for analysis + } Routine immunizations, including flu shots + } Travel health consultation and immunizations + } Reproductive health and STI (sexually transmitted infection) -Descaling (Continued) +testing and treatment -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet + } Medication management with psychiatric mental health +providers with the exception of stimulant medication +for ADHD -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. + } Medical equipment for loan, such as crutches -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +and wheelchairs -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! + } Health care education, counseling and consultation + } Free teletherapy with our partner UWill, a leading mental +health and wellness solution for college campuses -Descaling + } Reservable rooms for teletherapy visits with -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +offsite providers + + } Access to Whitman’s Sexual Assault Victim’s + +Advocate (SAVA) + + } 24/7 urgent mental health phone line + +On-Campus Care -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Welty Health & +Counseling Center +11 Merriam Street -you would with water. +Walla Walla, WA 99362 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +509-527-5195/5281 -outlet. +16 / Q U I C K S T A R T G U I D E -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. + Your Student Health Portal -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +You’ll be asked to create an account on +our Student Health Portal , accessed with +your Whitman account login. Specific +instructions will be shared in one of Juli’s +Monday emails. -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +By registering through the secure portal, +you can directly enter your required +immunization information, check in for +your appointments, complete new patient +paperwork, send and receive secure +messages with your health care providers +on campus, as well as access lab results +and visit summaries, and obtain copies of +your receipts/statements to send to your +insurance company for reimbursement. -to continue to flow in the carafe. +What To Know About +Health Requirements +Whitman requires you to: -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. + } Provide evidence you received two dos- +es of the measles, mumps and rubella +(MMR) vaccine after your first birthday -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual + } Complete tuberculosis screening -vinegar. Repeat twice. +questions -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the + } Provide health insurance information -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Information about completing these +requirements will be shared through your +Student Health Portal over the summer. -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Meningococcal vaccination is highly +recommended for college students. Learn +more: doh.wa.gov/YouAndYourFamily/ +Immunization/CollegeStudents. -IMPORTANT NOTICE +In addition, Whitman students, faculty and +staff are strongly encouraged to remain +up to date on their seasonal influenza, +COVID-19 and routine health vaccinations. -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Medical Records +& Confidentiality +Your medical record is not part of the +college’s academic records system. It +remains in the electronic health record +only accessible by staff at the Welty Health +and Counseling Center and is strictly +confidential. Medical information can be +released only with written permission, and +you may designate what information is to +be given and to whom it is to be directed. -Thank You +Parents may contact the center with +questions and concerns. However, in -6 +compliance with federal privacy laws, we +are unable to release information regarding +their student’s health records or health +status unless the student has signed a +release of information form specifically +allowing their parents to have access to +their health status or records. -7 +Health Insurance +All Whitman students are required to have +health insurance policy that will cover them +during their time at Whitman. International +students will be enrolled in the required +Lewermark health insurance plan. - User Maintenance Instructions +Whitman Wellness Services +Throughout the academic year, professional +staff at the Welty Health and Counseling +Center lead a variety of workshops and +programs to enhance understanding +of health-related topics and empower +students to make informed decisions +about their physical, mental and +emotional well-being. -Descaling (Continued) +Mindset Moment -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +Practice self-care. College can be demanding, but don’t forget to prioritize +your well-being. Make time for activities that recharge your batteries, -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +whether it’s exercise, listening to music or spending time with friends. -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +W H I T M A N . E D U / 17 -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! + Whitman College Contact Information -Descaling +Academic Resource Center ............................................. 509-527-5898 -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Admission ........................................................................... 509-527-5176 -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Athletics .............................................................................. 509-527-5921 -you would with water. +Bookstore ........................................................................... 509-527-5274 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +Career & Community Engagement Center ................... 509-527-5183 -outlet. +Dean of Students .............................................................. 509-527-5158 -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Dean of the Faculty .......................................................... 509-527-5397 -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Equity, Compliance & Title IX .......................................... 509-522-4314 -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +Financial Aid ...................................................................... 509-527-5178 -to continue to flow in the carafe. +International Student Services ....................................... 509-527-4992 -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +LGBTQIA+ Student Services .......................................... 509-527-5596 -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +Opening Week & New Student Orientation .................. 509-527-5208 -vinegar. Repeat twice. +Outdoor Program .............................................................. 509-522-4395 -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Penrose Library ................................................................. 509-527-5192 -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Post Office ......................................................................... 509-527-5903 -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +President’s Office .............................................................. 509-527-5132 -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Registrar ............................................................................. 509-527-5983 -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Reid Campus Center ......................................................... 509-527-5208 -Thank You +Religious & Spiritual Life .................................................. 509-527-4449 -6 +Residence Life .................................................................. 509-527-5297 -7 +Security ............................................................................... 509-527-5777 - ONE-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY -This Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. product warranty extends to the original consumer purchaser of -the product. -Warranty Duration: This product is warranted to the original consumer purchaser for a period of one -(1) year from the original purchase date. -Warranty Coverage: This product is warranted against defective materials or workmanship. This -warranty is void if the product has been damaged by accident, in shipment, unreasonable use, -misuse, neglect, improper service, commercial use, repairs by unauthorized personnel or other caus- -es not arising out of defects in materials or workmanship. This warranty is effective only if the product -is purchased and operated in the USA, and does not extend to any units which have been used in -violation of written instructions furnished by Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc., or to units which have been -altered or modified or to damage to products or parts thereof which have had the serial number -removed, altered, defaced or rendered illegible. -Warranty Disclaimers: This warranty is in lieu of all warranties expressed or implied and no -representative or person is authorized to assume for Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. any other liability in con- -nection with the sale of our products. There shall be no claims for defects or failure of performance or -product failure under any theory of tort, contract or commercial law including, but not limited to, neg- -ligence, gross negligence, strict liability, breach of warranty and breach of contract. -Warranty Performance: During the above one-year warranty period, a product with a defect will be -either repaired or replaced with a reconditioned comparable model (at Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -option) when the product is returned to the Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. facility within the warranty period -and an additional one-month period. No charge will be made for such repair or replacement. -Service and Repair: Should the appliance malfunction, you should first call toll-free 1-800-233-9054 -between the hours of 9:00 am and 5:00 pm Central Standard Time and ask for CUSTOMER SERVICE -stating that you are a consumer with a problem. -In-Warranty Service (USA) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is made -for service or postage. -In-Warranty Service (Canada) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is -made for service or postage. Please return the product insured, packaged with sufficient protection, -and postage and insurance prepaid to the address listed below. Customs duty/brokerage fee, if any, -must be paid by the consumer. -Out-of-Warranty Service: A flat rate charge by model is made for out-of-warranty service. Include -$15.00 (U.S.) for return shipping and handling. -Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. cannot assume responsibility for loss or damage during incoming shipment. -For your protection, carefully package the product for shipment and insure it with the carrier. Be sure -to enclose the following items with your appliance: any accessories related to your problem; your full -return address and daytime phone number; a note describing the problem you experienced; a copy of -your sales receipt or other proof of purchase to determine warranty status. C.O.D. shipments cannot -be accepted. -Return the appliance to: - -ATTN: Repair Department, Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. - -550 Business Center Drive -Mt. Prospect, IL 60056 -Consumer Service: 1-800-233-9054 -Consumer Parts: 1-800-947-3745 -Hours: 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. CST - -For more information on Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. products: - -visit our website: URL http://www.salton-maxim.com or -E-mail us at SALTON 550@aol.com - -This Melitta product is distributed and serviced by Salton, Inc. -Printed in Switzerland -©2004 Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -®Reg. T.M. of a company of the Melitta Group +Student Accounts ............................................................. 509-527-5143 -8 +Student Activities ............................................................. 509-527-5208 -Part No. 60493 - -LISEZ ET CONSERVEZ CES INSTRUCTIONS -AVERTISSEMENT : Tout appareil électrique présente un risque -d’incendie et de choc électrique pouvant provoquer des blessures -graves ou mortelles. Veuillez observer toutes les mesures de -sécurité. - -Machine à Espresso -& Cappuccino - -’ - -I - -N -E -T -E -R -T -N -E -D -T -E -N -O -T -A -S -L -T -U -D -E -D -U -G - -I - -I - -’ - -I - -I - -B -1 -X -E -M - -, - -I - -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -E -L -E -D -O -M - -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -T -E +Technology Services ......................................................... 509-527-4976 -9 +Welty Health & Counseling Center ..................... 509-527-5195/5281 + +Whitman College is located on the traditional Cayuse, Umatilla and Walla Walla homelands. We pay our +respect to tribal elders both past and present and extend our respect to all Indigenous people today. +We honor their stewardship of the land and ecosystem and commit to continuing that important work. + +Whitman College is deeply committed to the principle of nondiscrimination in all its forms. In its admission, +educational, and employment practices, programs, and activities, the college does not discriminate on the basis of +race, color, sex (including pregnancy and parenting status), gender, gender identity or expression, genetic +information, sexual orientation, religion, age, marital status, national origin, shared ancestry, disability, veteran +status, or any other basis prohibited by the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title IX of the Educational Amendments of 1972, +Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and other applicable federal, state, or local laws. + +202506 diff --git a/q32/random_k4/random_2.md b/q32/random_k4/random_2.md index 2e9f5241e58113455522088c7a6110de8838d130..487dabc7e5008ff4efa01f6fe1aed60936603b9f 100644 --- a/q32/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q32/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,1208 +1,2403 @@ -DUET: Joint Exploration of User–Item Profiles in Recommendation System -YueChen1,*,YifeiSun1,*,LuWang2,†,FangkaiYang2,PuZhao2,MinjieHong3,YifeiDong4,MinghuaHe2, -NanHu2,JianjinZhang2,ZhiweiDai2,YuefengZhan2,WeihaoHan2,HaoSun2, -QingweiLin2,WeiweiDeng2,FengSun2,QiZhang2,SaravanRajmohan2,DongmeiZhang2 -1PekingUniversity2Microsoft3ZhejiangUniversity4KTHRoyalInstituteofTechnology -*Equalcontribution†Correspondingauthor -Abstract -| | | | User History: | Item History: | User History: | Item History: | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -| | | | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | -| | | | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | -Traditionalrecommendationsystemsrepresent ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t -6202 rpA 51 ]RI.sc[ 1v10831.4062:viXra • • Parliament Funk Bass" -| usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearnto | | | Parliament | Funk Bass" | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------------------ | -| | | | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | -aligntheminasharedlatentspaceforrelevance -| | | | | Duet | Independent | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -estimation. RecentLLM-basedrecommenders (Joint Alignment) Generation -| instead leverage | natural-language | representa- | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | -| | | | User Profile: | Item History: | User Profile: | Item History: | -tionsthatareeasiertointerpretandintegrate Enthusiast of A peak-era FUNK- Fan of HEAVY A highly rated POP- -| | | | FUNK and SOUL. | ROCK album with | METAL and | ROCK album with | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------------- | -withdownstreamreasoningmodules. Thispa- Values technical genre-blurring PUNK. Prefers polished -| | | | mastery | creativity. | dark themes. | production. | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------- | -textual -per studies how to construct effective Semantic Alignment ✘ Semantic Mismatch -profilesforusersanditems,andhowtoalign -themforrecommendation. Acentraldifficulty Figure1: DUETalignsrawuseranditemdatabytrans- -| | | | forming them | into textual | profiles within | a shared se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | -isthatthebestprofileformatisnotknownapri- -manticspace. -ori: manuallydesignedtemplatescanbebrittle -| andmisalignedwithtaskobjectives. | | Moreover, | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | to introduce | semantically | rich, human-readable | | -generatinguseranditemprofilesindependently -mayproducedescriptionsthatareindividually representationsforrecommendation(Wangetal., -plausible yet semantically inconsistent for a 2025;Zhang,2024;Baoetal.,2023;Hongetal., -| specificuser–itempair. | WeproposeDUET,an | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | 2025a,b,c;Wangetal.,2024). | | Anaturaldirectionis | | -interaction-awareprofilegeneratorthatjointly -toreplacelatentvectorswithtextualuseranditem -producesuseranditemprofilesconditionedon -profilesthatcanbeinspected,edited,andreusedby -| both user history | and item evidence. | DUET | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downstreamcomponentsincorporatedwithLLMs. -| follows a three-stage | procedure: | it first turns | | | | | -| --------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -However,existingLLM-basedapproachesremain -rawhistoriesandmetadataintocompactcues, -then expands these cues into paired profile limited in two important ways. First, directly -promptsandthengenerateprofiles,andfinally promptinganLLMwithrawuseranditemhisto- -optimizesthegenerationpolicywithreinforce- -riestoobtainrecommendationsoftenyieldsnoisy -mentlearningusingdownstreamrecommenda- andincompletesignals,especiallywhenhistories -| tionperformanceasfeedback. | | Experimentson | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -| | | | are long, | sparse, or heterogeneous | | (Wang et al., | -threereal-worlddatasetsshowthatDUETcon- -| | | | 2025). Second, | profile-based | methods | typically | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | -sistentlyoutperformsstrongbaselines,demon- -relyonmanuallydesignedtemplatesorhandcrafted -stratingthebenefitsoftemplate-freeprofileex- -attributes,whichrequiressubstantialhumanengi- -plorationandjointuser–itemtextualalignment. -Project code page: https://github.com/duet- neering and constrains the representation space. -review/duet_code. More fundamentally, many approaches generate -userprofilesanditemprofilesindependently,with- -1 Introduction -| | | | out modeling | how user | preferences | and item se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -Traditional recommendation systems represent manticsinteractatdecisiontime(Yangetal.,2023; -Xietal.,2024). -usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearntoalign -theminasharedlatentspaceforrelevanceestima- Toaddressthesechallenges,wepropose DUET, -tion (Covington et al., 2016; Wu, 2023). While ajointuser–itemprofilegeneratorthattakesboth -effective,suchembeddingsareopaque: theyoffer userhistoryanditemhistoryasinputandproduces -limitedinterpretabilityandmakeitdifficulttoan- a paired set of profiles for the interaction. Cru- -alyzewhyanitemisrecommended. Recentwork cially, DUET doesnotrequireprofiletemplates: it -thereforeleverageslargelanguagemodels(LLMs) istrainedwithreinforcementlearningusingfeed- - -back from downstream recommendation perfor- asseeninworkslikeCRESDUP(Chenetal.,2007) -mance,enablingittoexploreanddiscovereffective andUPCSim(Widiyaningtyasetal.,2021). While -profileformatsautomatically. Figure1illustrates foundational,thesemethodswerelimitedbytheir -whyjointprofilingmatters. Theuserhaslistened rigid,hand-engineeredfeatures. Morerecently,the -toMisfits(punk),IronMaiden(metal),andParlia- adventofLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)hasen- -ment(funk),whilethecandidatealbumisdescribed abledashifttowardsgeneratingprofilesinnatural -byreviewssuchas“polishedpop”and“greatfunk language. Studies such as KAR (Xi et al., 2024), -bass”andametatag“’80srock.” Consideringboth GPG(Zhang,2024),PALR(Yangetal.,2023),and -sides together, DUET can reconcile these signals LettinGo (Wang et al., 2025) leverage LLMs to -intoacompatibleinterpretation(e.g.,highlighting createtextualuserprofilesfrombehavioraldata. A -the user’s funk/soul affinity and the item’s funk- keylimitationoftheseapproachesistwofold: they -rockcharacter). Incontrast,independentlygener- relyonstaticorpre-definedtemplatesforprofile -atedprofilesmayamplifydifferentfacets,summa- generation,andtheyoftenfocusexclusivelyonuser -rizingtheuseras“heavymetal/punk”whilesum- profiles,neglectingtherich,expressiveinformation -marizingtheitemas“pop-rock”,whichresultingin inherentinitemsandthecomplexdynamicsofuser- -asemanticallymismatchedpairthatobscuresthe iteminteractions. Incontrast,ourworkintroduces -truerelevancesignal. anewparadigmwherebothuseranditemprofiles -DUETproceedsinthreestages. First,rawhisto- arenotfixedbutaredynamicallyexploredandop- -ries and metadata are distilled into minimal cues timizedinasharedsemanticspacetodirectlyalign -thatcapturecompactbutinformativesignals. Sec- withrecommendationperformance. -ond, the model expands cues into richer profile -prompts to generate textual profiles, allowing ex- 2.2 ReinforcementLearningforLLM-Based -plorationoveralternativeprofilestructuresandem- RecommendationSystems -phases. Third,theresultingprofilesareconsumed -ReinforcementLearning(RL),particularlythrough -bydownstreamrecommenders,andtheirtaskfeed- -techniqueslikeRLHF,hasbecomeacoremethod -backisusedtooptimizetheprofilegenerationpol- -for aligning LLMs with specific objectives. This -icy. By coupling both sides in a shared semantic -approach has been adapted for recommendation -space,DUETlearnsuserprofilesthatreflectwhat -tasks (Wang et al., 2025; Lin et al., 2025; Deng -kindsofitemsauserprefersanditemprofilesthat -etal.,2025),butexistingeffortsoftenfacekeylimi- -reflectwhatkindsofusersanitemappealsto. -tations. Theyfrequentlyrelyonofflinerewardmod- -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: -els(Jeongetal.,2023;Chenetal.,2025;Heetal., -• Werepresentusersanditemsasnatural-language 2025; Liu et al., 2025) that do not adapt in real- -profiles and align them in a shared semantic timetosystemfeedback,asetupthatrisksissues -space,extendingtheclassicvector-basedalign- like reward hacking (Skalse et al., 2025). Other -mentprincipletointerpretabletextualrepresenta- methods(Sunetal.,2024;Luetal.,2024)restrict -tions. themselvestoofflinepreferencetuning(e.g.,DPO), -• We introduce an exploration-based framework which can easily overfit on static datasets. Our -thatstartsfromcue-basedinitialization,expands framework, DUET,overcomesthesechallengesby -cuesintocandidateprofiles,andjointlyoptimizes integrating RL into a closed-loop system where -user and item profiles with downstream recom- downstreamrecommendationperformanceserves -mendationfeedbackviareinforcementlearning, asthereal-timerewardsignal,allowingforthedy- -avoidingrigidtemplates. namicandinteractiverefinementoftextualprofiles. -• Extensiveexperimentsacrossmultiplereal-world -datasets show that DUET consistently outper- 3 Method -formsstrongbaselines,validatingbothjointpro- -filingandfeedback-drivenprofileoptimization. DUET is a closed-loop framework that trans- -forms raw user–item interaction histories into -2 RelatedWork performance-aligned textual profiles through -learnedrepresentationstrategies. AsshowninFig- -2.1 ProfilesinRecommendation -ure 2, DUET consists of three stages. (1) Cue- -Earlyrecommendationsystemsprimarilyreliedon Based Initialization distills interaction histories -pre-definedprofilesbasedonstructuredattributes, intoconciseevidence-basedcues. (2)JointExplo- - -CUE-BASED INITIALIZATION JOINT EXPLORATION ON-POLICY OPTIMIZATION -| | | | | Item | DU | | | Duet | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| ItemHistory | | | | | ET | | | | | | | -Initial CUE -Rated: Baba Is You (5★) -User: “Prefers retro puzzle games” -Reviewed: “I love logic- -Item: “Retro-style indie puzzle game” -| | | | based puzzle games.” | | | Profile Prompt | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rated: The Witness (5★) -User: “Describe the user's typical -| | | | Rated: Fez (4★) | | puzzle-game preferences … | | | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒1 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒2 | … | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑛 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -Item: “… item's core mechanics… -| | | | | | | | Profile | Downstream Task Env | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ---- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | User | User: “A player who enjoys logic- | | | | | | | -| UserHistory | | | | | intensive indie puzzle games, | | | | | | | -| | | | Category: Indie Puzzle | | | | | Ranking correctness | | | | -prefers retro visual aesthetics…” -| | | | Game | | | | | &format Reward | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Reviews: -Item: “A retro-style indie puzzle -| | | | “Challenging logic | | game featuring challenging | | | Group Computation | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | mechanics.” | | logic mechanics that appeal to | | | | | | | -| | | | “ R e t r o p ix | e l- a rt st y l e . ” | hardcore puzzle players.” | | | 𝐴𝑑𝑣1 𝐴𝑑𝑣2 | | | | -| | | | “ H a r d b u | t re w a r d i n g . ” | | | | | … | 𝐴𝑑𝑣𝑛 | | -| | | | | Figure2: | OverviewoftheDUETframework. | | | | | | | -ration via Adaptive Profile Prompt Discovery 3.2 Cue-BasedInitialization -| jointly | explores | user-item’s | | profile prompts | that | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Raw user | histories | and item | metadata | | are often | -| define how | user | and item | profiles | should | be writ- | | | | | | | -noisy,redundant,andnotdirectlysuitableforpro- -ten. (3)OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -| | | | | | | fileconstruction. | | Toaddressthis,DUETintroduces | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -jointlyoptimizesuseranditemprofilesunderdown- -theconceptofcues: -concisehypothesesthatsum- -streamrecommendationfeedback. -| | | | | | | marize minimal | | but informative | | aspects | of users | -| ------------------- | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | -| All three | stages | are | realized | through | a single | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | and items. | These | cues act | as lightweight | | seeds, | -| passinputandoutput: | | | cueextraction,self-prompt | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | which are | deliberately | underspecified | | so | that the | -construction,andprofilegenerationareproduced -systemcansubsequentlyexplorericherprofilefor- -inasinglesequence-to-sequencegenerationpass -mats. -atinferencetime,enablingefficientdeployment. -| | | | | | | Definition1(Cue). | | Acueisaminimaltextualhy- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.1 ProblemFormulation -pothesisderivedfromhistoricaldatathathighlights -WeformulateprofilegenerationinDUETasanon- one potential aspect of a user’s preference or an -policyreinforcementlearningproblem,motivated item’scharacteristic. Ratherthanaimingforcom- -bytheabsenceofanytextualgroundtruthdefining pleteness, cues capture partial but salient signals -an optimal user or item profile. Profile quality is thatserveasstartingpointsforprofileexploration. -evaluatedsolelybyitsfunctionalutilityinafixed -| | | | | | | To extract | cues | automatically, | | the | LLM is | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -recommendationenvironment. -| | | | | | | prompted | to summarize | minimal | | but informative | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| DUET | is modeled | as | a generative | policy | π θ in- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | aspectsofuseroritemdata. | | | Forexample,givena | | | -teractingwithafrozendownstreamrecommender. -user’sinteractionhistory,themodelisguidedwith -| For each | user–item | pair, | the | state is | defined as | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -instructionssuchas: -| s = {H | ,H },whereH | | andH | denotetheuser | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | u i | | u | i | | | | | | | | -and item interaction histories. An action corre- CueExtractionPrompt -spondstoasingle-passjointgeneration -“Fromthehistorybelow,analyzetheuser’s -a = {C u ,S u ,P u ,C i ,S i ,P i }, historicalinteractionstounderstandprefer- -ences,ratingbehavior,reviewsentimentor -| where | (C ,C | ) are | cues | distilled | from his- | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u i -| | | | | | | anyotherdimension. | | Keepthedescription | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| tory, (S | u ,S i ) are | constructed | | user-item’s | profile | | | | | | | -prompts,and(P ,P )arethefinaltextualprofiles. conciseandavoidfullsentences.” -u i -| Thepolicyπ | | (a | s)definesajointdistribution | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θ -over the entire generation sequence. As an on- This lightweight guidance allows the LLM to -policy agent, DUET is optimized using rewards maprawhistoriesandmetadataintocompacttex- -from its own sampled generations rather than by tualcues. Thedetaildexampleofcuecanbefound -| imitatingfixedsummaries. | | | | | | inAppendixA.3. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| 3.3 | JointExplorationviaAdaptiveProfile | | | | | | Single-PassInput | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PromptDiscovery Task:Generatestructuredprofilesfortheuseranditemfrom -historicaldata. -Aftercueextraction,DUETdoesnotdirectlysum- Combined Context: [User History H u ] + [Item -| | | | | | | | History | H i ]+[Avg | Ratings] | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| marizeuserinterestsoritemattributes. | | | | | | Instead,it | | | | | | | -“First,extractaconciseCueforbothuseranditem.Second, -| explores | | the space | of profile | construction | | strate- | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -basedonthecues,constructaProfilePromptthatdefines -gies—natural-languagepromptsthatdefinethefor- thedescriptionlogic.Finally,generatetheProfileguidedby -theconstructedProfilePrompt.” -mat,abstractionlevel,andattributeselectionlogic -↓DUETForwardPass↓ -| usedtogenerateprofiles. | | | | Explorationistherefore | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| performedoverhowprofilesshouldbeconstructed, | | | | | | | Single-PassOutput | | | | | | -User -ratherthanoversuperficialtextualparaphrases. -Cue:“prefersnostalgiclogic-basedchallenges” -For each user–item pair, DUET intro- Profileprompt: “Focuson1990svisualaestheticsand -| duces | an | explicit | intermediate | | variable, | the | strategicdepth.” | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | Profile: | “A player | who | seeks | retro-style | visual charm | -constructed_prompt,whichservesasadiscrete -pairedwithdeepstrategicreasoning.” -| and | interpretable | | profile | prompt | S. | This profile | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Item -promptisashortnatural-languageinstruction(e.g., -Cue:“retro-styleindiepuzzlewithhighdifficulty” -“Describetheuser’stypicalgamingpreferencesand -| | | | | | | | Profile | prompt: | “Describe | | pixel-art | graphics and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | -engagementpatterns”)thatspecifieswhataspects intellectualdifficultytomatchlogicpreference.” -Profile:“A2Dexperiencefeaturingpixelatednostalgia -| to | describe | and | how to | organize | them, | without | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andchallengingmechanicsthatdemandlogicaldeduction.” -| containingtheprofilecontentitself. | | | | | | Conditioned | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onS,themodelgeneratesthefinaluseranditem Figure3: Single-passgenerationinDUET: cueextrac- -| profiles. | | | | | | | tion,profileprompt(constructedprompt),andprofile | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -generationareproducedinonepassforbothuserand -| Exploration | | | is driven | by treating | | the profile | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -item. -| promptS | | asastochasticactionsampledfromthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| policyπ | | (S | Cue). | Duringtraining,theagentsam- | | | | | | | | | | -θ -plesdifferentprofilepromptinstructions,executes -| | | | | | | | andintellectualdifficulty”tomatch. | | | | | RLreinforces | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -| themtogenerateprofilepairs(P | | | | | ,P ),andreceives | | | | | | | | -u i -thissharedsemanticdirection,suppressingirrele- -| a reward | | based | on downstream | | recommendation | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | -| | | | | | | | vant signals | and | forcing | the | final | profiles to con- | -| accuracy. | | Thepolicyisoptimizedtoreinforcepro- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | verge | into a shared | semantic | | space | of nostalgia | -filepromptsthatconsistentlyyieldhigherrewards, -andlogic,significantlyimprovingrecommendation -enablingthemodeltoactivelysearchforeffective -accuracy. -profileconstructionformats. -Thisprocessisrealizedasaunifiedgeneration -3.4 OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -pass, -| | | | | | | | On-policy | optimization. | | | We train | the profile | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -O = [ Cue → profilepromptS → Profile], generator π in an on-policy manner against a -| | (cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125) | | | | | (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) | | θ | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (cid:124) | (cid:123)(cid:122) | (cid:125) | | | | | | | | -Context ProfileConstructionPrompt Execution frozendownstreammodelf, whichservesasthe -| | | | | | | (1) | environment | critic. | For | each | sampled | user–item | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | -wheretheprofilepromptS parameterizesthepro- pair (u,i), the policy generates (P ,P ) and re- -u i -filegenerator. Atinferencetime,DUETcollapses ceivesascalarrewardbasedonthepredictionac- -thelearnedprofilepromptdistributionandgreed- curacy of f(P ,P ). The policy parameters are -u i -ilyexecutestheoptimalprofilepromptinasingle updatedtoreinforcegenerationsthatleadtolower -| forwardpass,introducingnoadditionallatency. | | | | | | | predictionerror. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| Example | | of profile | prompt | Exploration. | | As | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Continuousfractionalreward. | | | | | Usingdiscrete | -| illustrated | | in Figure | 3, | DUET | resolves | this by | | | | | | | -integerratingsasrewardsleadstosparseandunsta- -| identifying | | a shared | context | in | a single | forward | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -blefeedback,asnear-misspredictions(e.g.,predict- -pass. ThepolicyextractsacoordinatedCue(e.g., -ing4foragroundtruth5)receivethesamepenalty -“prefersretropuzzlegames”)andconstructsapro- -| | | | | | | | assevereerrors. | | Toprovidedenseandinformative | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| file | prompt | (the | constructed_prompt) | | | that in- | | | | | | | -feedback,wedefineacontinuousfractionalreward: -structsthemodeltohighlight“nostalgicaesthetics -| and | strategic | logic” | for | the user, | while | simulta- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | |y −yˆ | | | -| | | | | | | | | R (u,i) | | = 1− | ui | ui , (2) | -| neously | describing | | the item’s | “pixel-art | | graphics | | perf | | | | | -M - -where yˆ ui = f(P u ,P i ) is the predicted relevance ingsettingbasedondownstreampredictedrating -score and M is the maximum rating gap (e.g., scores. For each observed user–item interaction, -M = 4 for a 1–5 scale). This reward provides we randomly sample nine items that the user has -fine-grainedgradientsthatencourageincremental not interacted with to form a candidate set of ten -improvementsinrecommendationaccuracy. items, which are ranked in descending order ac- -We adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization cordingtotheirpredictedratings. Theground-truth -(GRPO) (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025) to optimize interacted item is treated as the only positive in- -theprofilegeneratorundertheabovereward. The stance,andweadoptNDCG@Kastheevaluation -downstreamrecommenderf isfrozenthroughout metric, with K set to 1, 5, and 10, to assess how -training, which yields a stable policy optimiza- effectivelythelearnedprofilessupportcorrectitem -| tionsettingandpreventsrewarddriftorfeedback- | | | | ranking. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | Baselines | We compare | our method | with | several | -inducedrepresentationcollapse. -| | | | | representative | baselines. | 10H | directly | uses the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -4 Experiment mostrecentinteractionhistoriesforpredictionwith- -| | | | | outconstructingexplicitprofiles. | | | KAR(Xietal., | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -4.1 ExperimentalSettings -2024)augmentsrecommendationmodelswithex- -Datasets. Experiments were conducted on three ternalreasoningknowledgeaboutuserpreferences -widelyusedreal-worlddatasets. AmazonMusic andfactualknowledgeaboutitemsextractedfrom -(Music) and Amazon Book (Book) are derived LLMs,whicharetransformedintotask-compatible -fromtheAmazonProductdataset1,whileYelpis representations. RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)lever- -fromtheYelpOpendataset2. Alldatasetsinclude agesLLMstolearnsemanticuseranditemrepre- -userreviews,ratings,andrichtextualinformation. sentationsfromtextualsignalsandalignsthemwith -WeusedthefullAmazonMusicdataset,butonly collaborativerelationalinformationthroughcross- -subsets (latest two months for Book and six for viewrepresentationlearning. PALR(Yangetal., -Yelp). Data was split by timestamp into training, 2023)fine-tunesalargelanguagemodelasarank- -validation,andtestsetstopreventinformationleak- ing component that selects preferred items from -age(Jietal.,2023). retrievedcandidatesexpressedinnaturallanguage. -EvaluationMetrics LG (LettinGo) (Wang et al., 2025) explores di- -For each observed user–item interaction (i.e., verseuserprofilecandidateswithLLMsandaligns -a review record), we construct the evaluation profilegenerationwithdownstreamrecommenda- -instance based on the user’s interaction history tionperformanceviapreferenceoptimization. Rea- -strictly prior to the corresponding timestamp. son4Rec(Fangetal.,2025)introducesadelibera- -tiverecommendationframeworkthatincorporates -Specifically,theuser’srecenthistoricalinteractions -beforethecurrentinteractionareusedtogenerate explicitstep-wisereasoningoveruserpreferences -auserprofile,whilehistoricalreviewsfromother toguideratingprediction. -| users are used | to generate | an item profile. | The | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -4.2 MainResults -downstreamrecommendationsystemthenpredicts -theratingofthetargetitemconditionedontwoin- Table 1 presents a comparison of our proposed -puts: thegenerateduserprofile,andthegenerated method against five baselines on three datasets: -| | | | | Amazon | Music, Amazon | Books, | and | Yelp. We | -| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| itemprofile. | Anexceptionisthe10Hbaseline,for | | | | | | | | -which the downstream model directly consumes use Qwen3-8B (Team, 2025) and LLaMA3-8B -therawrecentinteractionhistories. (Dubey et al., 2024) as both the profile generator -andthedownstreamrecommendationmodel,with -| We evaluate | performance | using four | widely | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | a prediction | temperature | of 0. | In addition | to rat- | -| adopted metrics | (Wang | et al., 2025; Fang | et al., | | | | | | -2025): MeanAbsoluteError(MAE),RootMean ingpredictionresults,wealsoreportranking-based -SquareError(RMSE),Accuracy,andF1score. evaluation results in Table ??, which assess the -effectivenessofthelearnedprofilesfromadown- -Inadditiontoratingprediction,wefurtherevaluate -thegenerateduseranditemprofilesunderarank- streamrankingperspective. -| | | | | Overallsuperiorityoverstrongbaselines. | | | | As | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ shown in Table 1, our method consistently out- -amazon/links.html -| | | | | performs | the strongest | baselines | across | all three | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -2https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -| open-dataset/ | | | | datasetsunderbothQwen3-8BandLLaMA3-8B. | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) -(%) (%) (%) -Qwen3(8B) -10H 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.7396 1.2184 55.34 48.67 0.7483 1.1380 58.65 60.29 0.7098 1.0923 56.17 58.78 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.8197 1.3312 47.15 42.46 0.7438 1.1069 54.89 57.65 0.7812 1.1584 52.86 55.93 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7994 1.2876 48.53 43.19 0.6075 0.9531 57.35 56.77 0.7485 1.1187 54.24 56.38 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7028 1.1523 55.69 47.73 0.5654 0.9635 58.69 54.67 0.6397 1.0098 58.47 56.84 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -LLaMA3(8B) -10H 1.0864 1.9532 22.09 27.30 0.7917 1.3346 38.13 46.87 0.8064 1.3866 37.15 45.27 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.6427 1.1668 54.51 47.98 0.5726 0.9033 57.53 59.92 0.5892 0.9614 55.87 58.21 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.7428 1.3572 46.74 42.11 0.6076 0.9886 53.78 57.42 0.6226 0.9477 52.12 55.79 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7238 1.3265 47.72 43.29 0.5823 0.9222 56.73 59.31 0.5977 0.8855 55.06 57.62 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6196 1.1289 56.03 51.24 0.5204 0.9369 61.92 59.50 0.5543 0.7967 58.95 60.39 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7586 1.0418 55.80 53.00 0.5442 0.7722 60.86 54.88 0.6029 0.8345 59.70 56.35 -Ours 0.5367 0.9687 60.87 54.74 0.4680 0.8277 63.30 60.60 0.5092 0.9500 63.42 58.12 -Table1: PerformanceonthreedatasetsusingQwen3(8B)andLLaMA3(8B). -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -Table2: RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. -Under Qwen3-8B, our method achieves an accu- our approach reaches an NDCG@1 of 0.5619 -racyof61.23%onYelp,67.96%onAmazonMu- and an NDCG@10 of 0.7443, clearly outper- -sicand64.38%onAmazonBooks,surpassingLG forming the strongest baseline methods. Similar -(LettinGo)(Wangetal.,2025)by5.05%,5.59% trendsareobservedonAmazonMusic,whereour -and5.03%,respectively. Similarimprovementsare methodattains0.5347atNDCG@1and0.7331at -observed under LLaMA3-8B, indicating that the NDCG@10, as well as on Amazon Books with -gainsarestableacrossbackbonemodels. NDCG@1 of 0.4866 and NDCG@10 of 0.7107. -Theseresultsindicatethatthelearnedprofilesen- -Advantages over fixed-structure and delib- -able more accurate identification and ordering of -erative baselines. Compared with strong fixed- -relevantitemswithincandidatesets,leadingtosu- -structureordeliberativemethodssuchasKAR(Xi -perior ranking quality in downstream recommen- -etal.,2024)andReason4Rec(Fangetal.,2025), -dation. Wefurtherevaluaterankingperformance -our approach consistently achieves lower predic- -under a more challenging setting using EASE- -tion error and higher accuracy. For example, on -based (Steck, 2019) hard negatives, and observe -Amazon Books with Qwen3-8B, our method re- -consistentimprovements;detailedresultsarepro- -duces MAE to 0.4612, compared to 0.7098 for -videdinAppendixB.2. -KARand0.6397forReason4Rec,demonstrating -moreeffectiveabstractionofuserpreferenceswith- -4.3 AblationStudy -outrelyingonpredefinedreasoningtemplates. -Consistent improvements in downstream Effectivenessofprofilegeneration,cue&strategy, -ranking. Table??reportstherankingresultsun- anduser–itemjointoptimization. Table3reports -der the Qwen3-8B backbone. Our method con- the ablation results under different design con- -sistentlyachievesthebestperformanceacrossall figurations. Starting from the history-only base- -three datasets and evaluation cutoffs. On Yelp, line (10H), introducing explicit profile genera- - -| Method | | | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 | MAE RMSE | Acc F1 | -10H(HistoryOnly) 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -Profile 0.7218 1.1863 55.48 48.09 0.6597 1.0218 58.67 57.48 0.6764 1.0469 57.14 57.68 -Profile+Cue&Strategy 0.7085 1.1654 55.83 48.54 0.5708 0.9897 58.91 55.53 0.6389 1.0108 58.43 56.88 -Profile+JointOpt.(LG(Wang 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -etal.,2025)) -Profile+Cue&Strategy+ 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -JointOpt.(Ours) -Table3: AblationstudyondifferentdesignconfigurationsinDUETusingQwen3(8B). -| Method | | Yelp | | | | AmazonMusic | | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | | (%) | -10H+30P 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3883 0.7494 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 65.13 59.97 -10H+50P 0.4909 0.9207 62.43 56.24 0.3924 0.7543 67.88 63.87 0.4553 0.9023 64.62 59.52 -10H+70P 0.4987 0.9326 61.98 55.81 0.3937 0.7564 68.22 64.12 0.4608 0.9068 64.38 59.27 -Table4: Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofilequality(usingQwen3(8B)). -tionyieldssubstantialperformanceimprovements jointoptimizationarecombined. Underthisfull -across all datasets. For example, on Yelp, MAE configuration, accuracy reaches 61.23% on Yelp, -isreducedfrom1.1235to0.7218andaccuracyin- 67.96%onAmazonMusic,and64.38%onAma- -creases from 23.17% to 55.48%, confirming that zon Books, with corresponding MAE values of -textualprofilesprovidesignificantlymoreinforma- 0.5126, 0.3937, and 0.4612, respectively. Com- -tiverepresentationsthanrawinteractionhistories. pared with the LettinGo-style configuration, this -| | | | | | | setting | yields | consistent | | improvements | across all | -| ------ | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | -| Adding | the cue&strategy | | layer | on | top of | pro- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | datasets. | | Overall,theablationresultsindicatethat | | | | -filegenerationleadstomodestbutconsistentgains. -whileprofilegenerationandjointoptimization -OnAmazonMusic,MAEfurtherdecreasesfrom -0.6597to0.5708,whileaccuracyslightlyimproves contributesubstantiallytoperformancegains,inte- -gratingcue&strategydiscoveryfurtherenhances -| from58.67%to58.91%. | | | Althoughthenumerical | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | the | effectiveness | | of joint | user–item | optimization | -improvementsintroducedbystrategyalonearelim- -ited, these results suggest that strategy discovery byprovidingastructuredspaceforexplorationand -refinement. -primarilyreshapeshowpreferenceinformationis -abstractedandexpressed,ratherthandirectlyopti- Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofile -mizingpredictionaccuracyinisolation. -| | | | | | | quality. | | Table | 4 analyzes | the | impact of histori- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | -Whenenablingjointoptimizationwithoutstrat- cal interaction length on profile quality. Across -thethreedatasets,varyingthenumberofhistorical -| egy (i.e., | the LettinGo | (Wang | et | al., 2025)-style | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -configuration),performanceimprovesmorenotice- interactions leads to only moderate performance -ablyacrossdatasets. OnAmazonMusic,accuracy differences, indicating that our method does not -| | | | | | | strongly | | depend | on long | histories. | In particular, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | -increasesto62.37%,comparedto58.67%withpro- -filegenerationalone. Inourimplementation,this usingamoderatehistorylength(e.g.,30–50inter- -settingcorrespondstoareproductionofLettinGo, actions)alreadyachievescompetitiveorbestper- -whereprofilegenerationandjointoptimizationare formanceonmostmetrics,whilefurtherincreasing -thehistorylengthprovideslimitedadditionalgains. -| appliedwithoutthestrategylayer. | | | | Whiletheorig- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| inal method | focuses | primarily | on | user | profiling, | | | | | | | -OnYelpandAmazonBooks,extendingthehis- -weextendtheoptimizationtobothuseranditem -torylengthbeyondthisrangedoesnotconsistently -profilestoensureafaircomparison. improveaccuracyorF1scoreandmayslightlyde- -Thestrongestandmostconsistentperformance gradeperformance,suggestingthatexcessivehis- -is achieved when cue&strategy discovery and toricalinteractionscanintroducenoisyorlessrele- - -vantsignals. Incontrast,AmazonMusicexhibits maintaining comparable coverage. Compared to -relativelystableperformanceacrossdifferenthis- existing methods, which either rely on extractive -torylengths,indicatingthatuserpreferencesinthis compression(e.g.,KAR(Xietal.,2024))orgener- -domainarelesssensitivetohistorytruncation. atefree-formdescriptionswithweakergrounding -Necessity of RL-based Optimization. We com- (e.g.,RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)andPALR(Yang -pare the full model with a variant without RL etal.,2023)), DUET consistentlyattainsstronger -(DUET W/O RL) to isolate the effect of RL. As alignment without sacrificing coverage. For in- -showninTable5,removingRLleadstosubstantial stance,LG(Wangetal.,2025)achievesrelatively -performancedegradationacrossalldatasets(e.g., highalignmentbutexhibitslessstablegrounding -YelpAccuracydropsfrom61.23%to48.53%),indi- acrossdatasets,whileRLMRecattainshighercov- -catingthatthegainscannotbeattributedtoprompt erageatthecostofweakersemanticalignment. In -| designalone. | | | | | contrast,DUETmaintainsbothhighalignmentand | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Without RL, the generator reduces to a static mid-to-highcoverage,suggestingamoreeffective -mapping from interaction history to textual pro- balancebetweensemanticabstractionandevidence -| files,lackingadaptiveselectionofrelevantsignals. | | | | | preservation. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Incontrast,RLenablesoptimizingprofileconstruc- -4.5 CaseStudy -tionunderrewardfeedback,resultinginmoredis- -Figure4presentsarepresentativecasestudythat -| criminative | representations.These | | results | demon- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -strate that RL-based optimization is essential for demonstrates how semantically aligned user and -| DUET | . | | | | itemprofiles | enableaccurate | | prediction | | thattran- | -| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -scendsthelimitationsofsparserawinteractionhis- -4.4 SemanticAnalysisofGeneratedProfiles tories. In the user profile, initially scattered and -To better understand the source of performance fragmentedpreferencecuesaresystematicallydis- -gains, we analyze whether the generated profiles tilled into a stable and coherent preference struc- -exhibitmeaningfulsemanticpropertiesratherthan turefavoringfunk,soul,andprogressiverock(or- -servingasintermediatetextualartifacts. Weintro- ange), coupled with a pronounced emphasis on -duce two complementary metrics to characterize musicalcomplexityandhistoricalsignificance(pur- -semanticcompatibilityandgrounding. ple). Thecorrespondingitemprofileexhibitsstrik- -Semantic Alignment. We measure the ingsymmetry,characterizingthealbumasanexem- -embedding-levelsimilaritybetweengenerateduser plaryfunk-rockcomposition(orange)andposition- -anditemprofilesusingall-mpnet-base-v2from ingitasadefiningandculturallyinfluentialrelease -Sentence-Transformers (Reimers and Gurevych, of the 1970s (purple). This example shows 519 -2019). Foreachuser–itempair,wecomputecosine that the learned profiles capture meaningful pref- -| similarity: | | | | | erence–attributecorrespondencethatisdifficultto | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | e ·e | | recoverfromindividualreviewsalone. | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | | | | | | | -| | Align(u,i) | = | | (3) | | | | | | | -| | | | ∥e ∥∥e ∥ | | | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | 5 Conclusion | | | | | | -| wheree | ande denotetheembeddingvectorsof | | | | | | | | | | -| | u i | | | | In this | paper, we | propose | DUET | , a | closed-loop | -| thegenerateduseranditemprofiles. | | | Highervalues | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | framework | for | jointly | generating | user | and item | -indicatestrongersemanticcompatibilitybetween -| | | | | | textualprofilesforrecommendation. | | | | | Unlikeprior | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -modeleduserpreferencesanditemcharacteristics. -| | | | | | methods | that rely | on | fixed templates | | or indepen- | -| -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | -| Coverage | (Faithfulness). | | We measure | token- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | dently | constructed | profiles, | DUET | | treats profile | -levelgroundingas: -| | | | | | generation | as an | exploration | problem | | and aligns | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -|Tokens(profile)∩Tokens(history)| representations directly with downstream recom- -Cov = -| | | |Tokens(profile)| | | | mendationperformance. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | (4) | Specifically, | | DUET | integrates | cue-based | ini- | -Thismetricquantifieshowmuchofthegenerated tialization, adaptive strategy construction, and -profileissupportedbyhistoricaltextualevidence. feedback-drivenjointoptimizationtoproduceflex- -We report coverage separately for user and item ible yet task-aligned user–item profiles. By opti- -| profiles. | | | | | mizing | both profiles | in | a shared | semantic | space, | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | -AsshowninTable6,DUETachievesthehigh- theframeworkreducessemanticmismatchandcap- -est semantic alignment across all datasets while turesinteraction-relevantsignalsthataredifficultto - -Setting Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 -(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) -DUETw/oRL 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -DUET(full) 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table5: EffectofRL-basedoptimization(usingQwen3(8B)). -User History: -Andre' S Grindle "Tour of U.S.A.", Rating: 5.0. If your looking for heavy metals dim orgins look no further. -Andre' S Grindle "Misfits", Rating:4.0. Actually the opening title track is more of a direct pop/rock type song. But the rock n roll -returns in a big way on "Hay Fever". -............ -Item History: -Worlds Away, Rating: 4.0, Review: The CD is wonderful, and is a seminal piece of music for both the group and for those of us who -were 'of age' in the '70s and '80s. Pablo Cruise was - and is - a group that makes beautiful music like few others, and this -shipper/seller made it all the more special with a fast ship! THANKS!!! -Worlds Away, Rating: 5.0, I love this CD! I'd recommend the Pablo Cruise Millenium Collection to get to know this band. Worlds Away to -me represents the best of breezy '70s pop. Five stars! -............ -USER PROFILE: -Andre Grindle is a dedicated music enthusiast with a deep appreciation for funk, soul, and progressive rock, particularly drawn to artists -who blend technical mastery with genre-defining innovation. His reviews consistently highlight albums that showcase musical complexity, -lyrical depth, and historical significance, often referencing artists like Stevie Wonder, Prince, and Rush. He values authenticity and -artistic vision, frequently praising albums that resist trend-chasing and prioritize creative integrity. His detailed, introspective reviews -suggest a preference for nuanced analysis over superficial praise, with a focus on emotional resonance, production quality, and the -artist's evolution. While he is generous with high ratings (often 5.0), he is also willing to critique perceived shortcomings, as seen in his -4.0 for "Test for Echo" and 3.0 for "The Color of Success." His engagement is characterized by a blend of personal anecdotes, technical -appreciation, and historical context, indicating a preference for music that transcends mere entertainment. -Item PROFILE: -"Worlds Away" by Pablo Cruise is celebrated as a peak-era funk-rock album that exemplifies the band's ability to merge polished -production with genre-blurring creativity. Users consistently praise its tight musicianship, genre-defying sound, and the band's ability to -craft catchy, emotionally resonant tracks. The album's appeal lies in its seamless fusion of rock, funk, and pop, with standout tracks like -"Love Will Find a Way" and "Worlds Away" receiving particular acclaim for their infectious melodies and lyrical depth. While some users -note its dated production compared to modern standards, the majority highlight its historical significance as a defining work of the -1970s rock-funk movement. The album resonates most with fans of 1970s progressive rock, genre-defying artists, and listeners seeking -well-crafted, emotionally engaging music. Its high average rating reflects widespread admiration for its artistic ambition and enduring -appeal, though a minority acknowledges its limitations in terms of modern production quality. -Figure4: Illustrationofthemutualcorrespondencebetweenuseranditem. Thehighlightedregionsdemonstrate -thatuserpreferencessummarizedintheuserprofilealignwiththekeyattributesextractedintheitemprofile,which -providescomplementaryinformationbeyondrawhistoriesandthusimprovespredictionaccuracy. -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. -10H 0.3902 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.3577 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.2604 /(1.00) /(1.00) -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.4932 0.1745 0.1823 0.4807 0.2170 0.2391 0.5702 0.1877 0.1544 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.4010 0.2646 0.3773 0.3931 0.3526 0.4889 0.4436 0.2994 0.3506 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.4715 0.3675 0.1917 0.4938 0.2197 0.2390 0.5216 0.2050 0.2267 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.5709 0.2378 0.2682 0.5109 0.2546 0.3749 0.5506 0.3883 0.3364 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.4882 0.2348 0.2330 0.4208 0.3328 0.3595 0.4946 0.2831 0.2949 -Ours 0.6382 0.2880 0.3429 0.5947 0.4002 0.4482 0.7287 0.3457 0.3127 -Table6: Semanticalignmentandcoverageofgeneratedprofiles. Cov. denotesthefractionoftokensgroundedin -historicaltext. -recoverfromrawhistoriesorstaticpromptsalone. reinforcementlearning–basedoptimization. These -resultssuggestthatadaptive,interaction-awaretex- -Experiments on multiple real-world datasets tualprofilesprovideapromisingdirectionformore -demonstratethatDUETconsistentlyoutperforms effective interpretable and performance-oriented -strongbaselinesunderdifferentbackbonemodels, recommendationsystems. -validating the effectiveness of joint profiling and - -| Limitations | | | | | | | References | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Keqin Bao, | Jizhi | Zhang, | Yang | Zhang, | Wenjie | Wang, | -Despiteitseffectiveness,ourapproachhasseveral FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2023. Tallrec: Anef- -fectiveandefficienttuningframeworktoalignlarge -| limitations. | First, | the | proposed | framework | | relies | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | languagemodelwithrecommendation. | | | | | InProceed- | | -onlargelanguagemodelsforbothprofilegenera- ingsofthe17thACMConferenceonRecommender -tion and downstream recommendation, which in- Systems,pages1007–1014. -| troduces | additional | computational | | | overhead | dur- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -TingChen,Wei-LiHan,Hai-DongWang,Yi-XunZhou, -| ingtrainingandinference. | | | Whileourexperiments | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | BinXu,andBin-YuZang.2007. | | | | Contentrecommen- | | | -showconsistentgainsacrossdifferentbackbones, dationsystembasedonprivatedynamicuserprofile. -the overall efficiency may be constrained when In2007Internationalconferenceonmachinelearn- -| | | | | | | | ing and | cybernetics, | | volume | 4, pages | 2112–2118. | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| scalingtoverylargeuseroritemsets. | | | | | Second,the | | | | | | | | | -IEEE. -| quality | of the generated | | profiles | is | inherently | de- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| pendent | on the underlying | | LLMs | | and prompting | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Yue Chen, | Minghua | | He, Fangkai | Yang, | Pu | Zhao, | -strategies. Variationsinmodelcapacityorprompt LuWang,YuKang,YifeiDong,YuefengZhan,Hao -Sun,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,andDongmei -sensitivitymayleadtodifferencesinprofilestabil- -| | | | | | | | Zhang. | 2025. | Warriormath: | | Enhancing | the | mathe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -ity,whichwedonotexplicitlycontrolinthecurrent -maticalabilityoflargelanguagemodelswithadefect- -design. Finally,ourevaluationfocusesontext-rich -| | | | | | | | awareframework. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.01245. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -recommendationscenarioswheresufficienthistor- -| | | | | | | | Paul Covington, | | Jay | Adams, and | Emre | Sargin. | 2016. | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -| ical reviews | are | available. | | The effectiveness | | of | | | | | | | | -Deepneuralnetworksforyoutuberecommendations. -| the proposed | strategy | | in domains | with | extremely | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InProceedingsofthe10thACMconferenceonrec- -sparsetextualsignalsorinnon-textualmodalities -ommendersystems,pages191–198. -remainstobefurtherexplored. -DeepSeek-AI,DayaGuo,DejianYang,HaoweiZhang, -JunxiaoSong,RuoyuZhang,RunxinXu,QihaoZhu, -ShirongMa,PeiyiWang,XiaoBi,XiaokangZhang, -Data,Privacy,andEthicsConsiderations Xingkai Yu, Yu Wu, Z. F. Wu, Zhibin Gou, Zhi- -| | | | | | | | hong | Shao, | Zhuoshu | Li, Ziyi | Gao, and | 181 | others. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | 2025. | Deepseek-r1: | | Incentivizing | reasoning | | capa- | -Alldatasetsusedinthisworkarepubliclyreleased bilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. Preprint, -arXiv:2501.12948. -bytheiroriginalowners,andwefollowtheofficial -termsofuseassociatedwitheachdataset,utilizing -JiaxinDeng,ShiyaoWang,KuoCai,LejianRen,Qigen -thedatasolelyforresearchpurposesaspermitted -| | | | | | | | Hu, Weifeng | | Ding, | Qiang Luo, | and | Guorui | Zhou. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -bytheirrespectivelicenses;forreproducibility,the 2025. Onerec: Unifyingretrieveandrankwithgen- -officialdatasetsourcesarecitedinthecorrespond- erativerecommenderanditerativepreferencealign- -ment. Preprint,arXiv:2502.18965. -ingsectionsofthispaper,andwedonotredistribute -anyrawuser-generatedcontentsuchasreviewtext AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, -| aspartofthiswork. | | Thisresearchdoesnotattempt | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, -to identify or infer the identity of any individual Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela -| | | | | | | | Fan,and1others.2024. | | | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -user,andpriortotraininganddownstreamprofile -arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.21783. -| generation, | we | apply text | filtering | | procedures | to | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -remove direct personal identifiers where applica- YiFang,WenjieWang,YangZhang,FengbinZhu,Qi- -ble;themodelsaretrainedsolelyonpubliclyavail- fanWang,FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2025. Rea- -son4rec:Largelanguagemodelsforrecommendation -abledata,andnoadditionalprivateorproprietary -| | | | | | | | withdeliberativeuserpreferencealignment. | | | | | Preprint, | | -| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| user information | | is introduced. | | Furthermore, | | we | | | | | | | | -arXiv:2502.02061. -| do not release | generated | | user | profiles | or | any per- | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MinghuaHe,YueChen,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Wenjie -useroutputsproducedduringthemodelingprocess, -Yin,YuKang,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,and -andallreportedresultsarepresentedinaggregate -| | | | | | | | DongmeiZhang.2025. | | | Execoder:Empoweringlarge | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| form for | evaluation | purposes | | only. | From | a secu- | | | | | | | | -languagemodelswithexecutabilityrepresentationfor -rityperspective,theassociatedcoderepositoryhas codetranslation. Preprint,arXiv:2501.18460. -beenscannedforpotentialsecrets,andanyinternal -MinjieHong,ZirunGuo,YanXia,ZehanWang,Ziang -endpointsorconfidentialconfigurationinformation -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | Tao | Jin, and | Zhou Zhao. | 2025a. | Apo: | En- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | -havebeenremovedpriortorelease. -hancingreasoningabilityofmllmsviaasymmetric -| | | | | | | | policyoptimization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2506.21655. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Minjie Hong, Yan Xia, Zehan Wang, Jieming Zhu, JoarSkalse,NikolausH.R.Howe,DmitriiKrashenin- -Ye Wang, Sihang Cai, Xiaoda Yang, Quanyu Dai, nikov, and David Krueger. 2025. Defining -ZhenhuaDong,ZhimengZhang,and1others.2025b. and characterizing reward hacking. Preprint, -| Eager-llm: | Enhancinglargelanguagemodelsasrec- | | | | | arXiv:2209.13085. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ommenders | through | exogenous | behavior-semantic | | | | | | | | | -integration. InProceedingsoftheACMonWebCon- Harald Steck. 2019. Embarrassingly shallow autoen- -ference2025,pages2754–2762. codersforsparsedata. InProceedingsofTheWorld -WideWebConference(WWW),pages3251–3257. -MinjieHong,ZetongZhou,ZirunGuo,ZiangZhang, -| Ruofan | Hu, Weinan | Gan, | Jieming | Zhu, and | Zhou | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ChaoSun,YaoboLiang,YamingYang,ShilinXu,Tian- -| Zhao.2025c. | Generativereasoningrecommendation | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | mengYang,andYunhaiTong.2024. | | | | | Rlrf4rec: Re- | -| viallms. | Preprint,arXiv:2510.20815. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | inforcement | learning | from | recsys | feedback | for en- | -JihwanJeong,YinlamChow,GuyTennenholtz,Chih- hancedrecommendationreranking. arXivpreprint -| Wei Hsu, | Azamat | Tulepbergenov, | | Mohammad | | arXiv:2410.05939. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| Ghavamzadeh, | and | Craig | Boutilier. | 2023. | Fac- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | QwenTeam.2025. | | Qwen3technicalreport. | | | Preprint, | -| tual and | personalized | recommendations | | using | lan- | | | | | | | -| guagemodelsandreinforcementlearning. | | | | | Preprint, | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -arXiv:2310.06176. -| | | | | | | Hugo Touvron, | Louis | Martin, | Kevin | Stone, | Peter Al- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | -Yitong Ji, Aixin Sun, Jie Zhang, and Chenliang Li. bert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay -| 2023. A | critical | study | on data leakage | in | recom- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bashlykov,SoumyaBatra,PrajjwalBhargava,Shruti -| mendersystemofflineevaluation. | | | | ACMTrans.Inf. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Bhosale,and1others.2023. | | | Llama2: | | Openfoun- | -Syst.,41(3):75:1–75:27. -| | | | | | | dation and | fine-tuned | chat | models. | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -------- | -arXiv:2307.09288. -| JiachengLin,TianWang,andKunQian.2025. | | | | | Rec-r1: | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bridginggenerativelargelanguagemodelsanduser- -| | | | | | | LeandrovonWerra, | | YounesBelkada, | | LewisTunstall, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -centricrecommendationsystemsviareinforcement -EdwardBeeching,TristanThrush,NathanLambert, -| learning. | Preprint,arXiv:2503.24289. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | Shengyi | Huang, | Kashif | Rasul, | and | Quentin Gal- | -| | | | | | | louédec. | TRL: | Transformer | Reinforcement | | Learn- | -AiweiLiu,MinghuaHe,ShaoxunZeng,SijunZhang, -| LinhaoZhang,ChuhanWu,WeiJia,YuanLiu,Xiao | | | | | | ing. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Zhou,andJieZhou.2025. | | | Wedlm:Reconcilingdiffu- | | | | | | | | | -sionlanguagemodelswithstandardcausalattention LuWang,DiZhang,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Jianfeng -forfastinference. Preprint,arXiv:2512.22737. Liu,YuefengZhan,HaoSun,QingweiLin,Weiwei -| | | | | | | Deng, Dongmei | | Zhang, | Feng | Sun, and | Qi Zhang. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | -HongtaoLiu,FangzhaoWu,WenjunWang,Xianchen -| | | | | | | 2025. Lettingo: | | Exploreuserprofilegenerationfor | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,PengfeiJiao,ChuhanWu,andXingXie.2019. -| | | | | | | recommendationsystem. | | | InProceedingsofthe31st | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -Nrpa: Neuralrecommendationwithpersonalizedat- ACMSIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscovery -tention. In Proceedings of the 42nd International andDataMiningV.2,KDD’25,NewYork,NY,USA. -ACMSIGIRConferenceonResearchandDevelop- AssociationforComputingMachinery. -mentinInformationRetrieval,pages1233–1236. -YeWang,JiahaoXun,MinjieHong,JiemingZhu,Tao -| Wensheng | Lu, Jianxun | Lian, | Wei Zhang, | Guanghua | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Jin,WangLin,HaoyuanLi,LinjunLi,YanXia,Zhou -Li,MingyangZhou,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2024. -| | | | | | | Zhao,and1others.2024. | | | Eager: | Two-streamgen- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -Aligninglargelanguagemodelsforcontrollablerec- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.05063. erativerecommenderwithbehavior-semanticcollab- -ommendations. -| | | | | | | oration. | InProceedingsofthe30thACMSIGKDD | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RadaMihalceaandPaulTarau.2004. Textrank: Bring- ConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMin- -| | | InEMNLP. | | | | ing,pages3245–3254. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingorderintotext. -| Zhaopeng | Qiu, Xian | Wu, | Jingyue Gao, | and | Wei Fan. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Triyanna | Widiyaningtyas, | | Indriana | Hidayah, | and | -2021. U-BERT:pre-traininguserrepresentationsfor -| | | | | | | TeguhBAdji.2021. | | Userprofilecorrelation-based | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -improved recommendation. In AAAI, pages 4320– similarity(upcsim)algorithminmovierecommenda- -| 4327.AAAIPress. | | | | | | tionsystem. | JournalofBigData,8(1):52. | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| NilsReimersandIrynaGurevych.2019. | | | | Sentence-bert: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | J.Wu.2023. | Computationalunderstandingofuserin- | | | | | -Sentenceembeddingsusingsiamesebert-networks. -terfaces. -InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical -MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP), -pages3982–3992. Yunjia Xi, Weiwen Liu, Jianghao Lin, Xiaoling Cai, -| | | | | | | Hong Zhu, | Jieming | Zhu, | Bo Chen, | Ruiming | Tang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ----- | -Xubin Ren, Wei Wei, Lianghao Xia, Lixin Su, Suqi WeinanZhang,andYongYu.2024. Towardsopen- -Cheng,JunfengWang,DaweiYin,andChaoHuang. world recommendation with knowledge augmenta- -2024. Representationlearningwithlargelanguage tionfromlargelanguagemodels. InProceedingsof -modelsforrecommendation. InProceedingsofthe the18thACMConferenceonRecommenderSystems, -| ACMonWebConference2024,pages3464–3475. | | | | | | pages12–22. | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -A ExperimentSetup -FanYang,ZhengChen,ZiyanJiang,EunahCho,Xiao- -| jiangHuang,andYanbinLu.2023. | | Palr:Personaliza- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tionawarellmsforrecommendation. | | arXivpreprint | A.1 DataCuration | | | | | | | -arXiv:2305.07622. -Jiarui Zhang. 2024. Guided profile generation im- Table7: Statisticaldetailsoftheevaluationdatasets. -| proves personalization | with llms. | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | -| arXiv:2409.13093. | | | Dataset | #Train | #Valid | | #Test #User | | #Item | -| | | | Music | 43,071 | 3,271 | | 1,296 | 4,183 | 2,660 | -| | | | Book | 71,972 | 6,144 | | 5,541 13,863 | | 13,515 | -| | | | Yelp | 51,497 | 4,757 | | 4,328 | 8,453 | 13,426 | -| | | | We conduct | | experiments | | on three | widely | used | -real-worlddatasets: -| | | | • AmazonMusic(Music): | | | | Thisreferstothe“Dig- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | ital Music” | | subset | of the | well-known | | Amazon | -Productdataset3,whichrecordsrichuserreviews, -ratings,andtextualinformationaboutitems,such -| | | | as titles, | across | a | broad | range | of product | cate- | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | -gories,ontheAmazonplatform.2 -| | | | • AmazonBook(Book): | | | Thisreferstothe“Book” | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -subsetoftheAmazonProductdataset. -dataset4, -| | | | • Yelp: | This | refers | to the | Yelp | Open | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | | which | includes | user | reviews, | ratings | | for busi- | -| | | | nesses | such | as restaurants | | and | retail shops, | as | -wellastextualinformationaboutthebusinesses. -Itiswidelyusedinrecommendationtasks(Qiu -etal.,2021). -WeusetheentireMusicdatasetforexperiments, -| | | | while for | the Book | | and Yelp | datasets, | we | utilize | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | onlyasubsetduetotheirlargesize. | | | | | FortheBook | | -dataset,weusedatafromthelasttwomonths,and -fortheYelpdataset,weusedatafromthelastsix -months. Foreachdataset,wesplititintotraining, -| | | | validation, | and | test | sets based | on | the timestamps | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | of interactions, | | ensuring | that | test | interactions | oc- | -curafteralltrainingandvalidationinteractionsto -preventinformationleakage(Jietal.,2023). -| | | | Regarding | | data | filtering, | following | | prior | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | work (Liu | et | al., 2019), | we | adopt | a 5-core | set- | -tingtofilterthedataandexcludecold-startusers -| | | | and items—those | | not | appearing | | in the | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | set—from | the | validation | and | test | sets. | The sta- | -tisticaldetailsoftheprocesseddatasetareprovided -inTable7. -3https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ -amazon/links.html. -4https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -open-dataset/. - -| A.1.1 | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | RLMRecPrompt | | | | -| ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -Inourexperiments,weprimarilyemployQwen3- Role: Businessrecommendationassistant -Task: Determinebusinesstypesauserislikely -| 8B(Team,2025)andLLaMA38BInstruct | | | | | | (Dubey | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| etal.,2024;Touvronetal.,2023)asboththerec- | | | | | | | toenjoy | | | | -| ommendation | | model | and | the | profile | generation | InputFormat: | | | | -•Title: Businessname -model. Thetrainingprocessisimplementedusing -theTRL(vonWerraetal.). Keyhyperparameters, •Categories: Businesscategories -suchasbatchsizeandlearningrate,aredetermined •Sentiment: Usersentimenttowardbusiness -throughgridsearchtoachieveoptimalperformance. -OutputRequirements: -Moredetailscanbefoundinourcode. -1. JSONformatonly -2. Structure: -A.2 BaselinePrompts -{ -| | | | | | | | "summarization": | "Types | of businesses | user | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -KARPrompt -likelyenjoys"(≤100words), -Task: Analyzeuserpreferencesbasedonbusi- -| | | | | | | | "reasoning": | "Brief explanation | | for summa- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | -nessreviewinghistory -rization"(nowordlimit) -Input: {user_history}-User’sbusinessreview- -} -inghistorywithsentimentsovertime -3. NoadditionaltextoutsideJSON -Instructions: -| 1. | Analyze | the | user’s | preferences | considering | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Input: | INTERACTION | | ITEMS: | -businessnamesandcategories -{user_history} -| 2. | Take | into account | | sentiment | patterns | over | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time -| 3. | Provideclearexplanationsbasedonreview- | | | | | | LGPrompt | | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -inghistorydetails -Youwillserveasanassistanttohelpmegener- -| 4. | Consider | other | pertinent | | factors | that may | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ateauserprofilebasedonthisuser’ssentiments -influencepreferences -historytobetterunderstandthisusers’interest -andthuspredicthis/hersentimentaboutatarget -| PALRPrompt | | | | | | | item. Iwillprovideyouwithsomebehaviorhis- | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | toryoftheuserinthisformat: | | [itemattributes | | -Task: Summarizeuserpreferencesusingkey- -| | | | | | | | andsentiment]. | Theuserprofileyougenerate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -words. -shouldcontainasmuchusefulcontentaspossi- -| Input: | | {user_history} | | - historical | businesses | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -bletohelppredicttheuser’ssentimenttowards -withusersentiments. -anewbusiness. -| Output | | Format: | An | itemized | list ranked | by | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -USERHISTORY:{user_history}. -importance. -PROFILEYOUGENERATE: -Template: -| | • KEY_WORD_1: | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -R4RecPrompt(Reasoner) -| | TORY_BUSINESS_1", | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -UserReviewHistory -TORY_BUSINESS_2" -⟨H u organizedasbelow⟩ -| | • KEY_WORD_2: | | | | | "HIS- | 1. TitleofItem1 | | | | -| ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | TORY_BUSINESS_3" | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| | | | | | | | NegativeAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| Instructions: | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -[Preference2],... -| | 1. Extract | key | preference | | indicators | from | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2. TitleofItem2 -userinteractionhistory. -| | | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -2. Rankkeywordsbyimportance. NegativeAspects: [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... -| | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | - -| [Preference2],... | | | | | | | cantlyworsethanDUETacrossalldatasets. | | | | | This | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -indicatesthatcoherentsummariesaloneareinsuf- -... -| | | | | | | | ficient, | and that | the gains | of DUET | | arise from | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -ItemReviewHistorybyOtherUsers -⟨H organizedinthesameformatasabove⟩ learnedsemanticabstractionratherthanextractive +For 2022 Fall + +(Regular Track) + +KAIST International Graduate Admission + +Application Guide + +Korea Advanced Institute of +Science and Technology +Office of Admissions + + Table of Contents + +Ⅰ. Drawing Your Future at KAIST + + ··································· + +Ⅱ. Application Procedures at a Glance + + ························· + +Ⅲ. Notes + + ······································································· + +Ⅳ. Eligibility + + ································································· + +Ⅴ. Timelines + + ································································· + +Ⅵ. Required Application Materials + + ······························· + +Ⅶ. Degrees and Programs + + ············································· + +Ⅷ. Campus Life (Daejeon & Seoul) + + ································ + +Ⅸ. Financial Aid + + ··························································· + +※ + +Appendix. Form - List of Honors and Awards + + ················· + +※ + +Note. Collection and Use of Personal Information + + ·········· + +01 + +02 + +03 + +04 + +07 + +08 + +14 + +18 + +20 + +21 + +22 + + Drawing Your Future at KAIST + +Ⅰ +KAIST is a young and ambitious university who leads science and technology and contributes to the world +for the better. Our history begins with our students. If you want to be a part of our audacious history, now +is time to ask yourself what you want and to probe what KAIST has for you. + +A +a. What do I want to study at a graduate level? + +Scientific Questions to Probe BEFORE You Apply to KAIST + +b. Does KAIST provide any courses in the field of my research interests? + +c. Does KAIST have any laboratories in the field of my research interest? + +d. Have I found and contacted faculty members whose research interests overlap mine? + +※ + +If you have found all the answers positive, now is time to LEARN something TECHNICAL regarding +APPLICATION to KAIST graduate programs. + +B +a. Visit our official website and learn about timelines, eligibility, paper works and + +Technical Knowledge You Should Know to Apply to KAIST + +other things you should know to apply. + +b. Apply online within the designated term (Application Fee KRW 80,000 or USD 80.) + +c. Send your application materials to our office by the due date. + +※ Recommendation letters are to be uploaded on our system directly by your referees. +※ Monitor your application review and provide supplements if required. + +d. Check your email at regular intervals and attend an interview if required by the + +department you applied to. + +e. Check the final decisions – ( + +if admitted + +) you must express your decision on our offer. + +f. Prepare for the transition to KAIST. + +C +a. Prepare for the school registration according to + +Transition to Our Advanced institute In South Korea + +the Registration Guide + + to be announced + +with our final decisions. + +b. Apply for a visa with supporting materials from our office and other documents + +required by the Korean Embassy and book an air ticket to South Korea + +c. Submit documents required to register to KAIST and settle into our community + +※ Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, timelines, procedures, and required materials are changeable without +prior notice. Our International Scholar and Student Service (ISSS) will notify you of any changes or updates +you need to know. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +1 + + Ⅱ + + Application Procedures at a Glance + +STEP 1 + Please use + +ONLINE APPLICATION by March 29 + +th + +, 2022 + +a computer with a Windows-based operating system + +. + + Access to our online application system at https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. + + Complete your online application. + +- + +Create an account and choose a degree and program of study at KAIST. +Enter your personal and academic backgrounds and prior experiences and achievements. + +- +- Write your statement of purpose and answer other questions KAIST requires. + +- + +- + +Choose your financial resources – you can apply for KAIST Scholarship in this step. +Pay the application fee online – KRW 80,000 or USD 80. +※ Our system will send automated emails to your referees with the information and + +instructions on uploading recommendation letters after your payment. + +STEP 2 + Print out your online application and address sticker through our system. + +APPLICATION MATERIALS + +※ The program you have applied to may require additional application materials. Please read +brief introductions of each program from page 14, visit the website of the program you will +apply to, and prepare for the additional materials. + + Organize and review your application materials with the online application printouts as listed + +on page 8. + + Post your application materials to our office * You can print out our address through our system. + +Graduate Admissions Team, KAIST +# 110, 1st Floor, E 16-1 B/D + +291 Daehak-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon (Zip Code:34141) + +Republic of Korea + +Office. +82-42-350-2352, 2354 / E-mail: advanced.adm@kaist.ac.kr + + Monitor your application status on our system and provide supplements if required. + +Your application has been finished here ! + +STEP 3 + Check your email at regular intervals. Our office or a staffer from the department you + +Keep yourself plugged into KAIST Admission until June 22 + +, 2022 + +nd + +applied to might reach you for an interview or further qualification. + + KAIST will announce our final decisions through our system on the decision notification day. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +2 + + Ⅲ + + Notes + +A +a. KAIST offers admissions to those who can study at KAIST full-time. Admitted + +Enrollments + +students + +must not have any professional responsibilities while studying at KAIST + +. + +b. + +. All the admitted students must +KAIST has forbidden multiple enrollments of our students +have completed their degree programs before enrollment to KAIST and must not +enroll in other institutions until completing their degree program at KAIST. + +B +a. Decisions on admissions and scholarships are independent. KAIST could offer + +Application + +admissions with or without scholarships. + +b. The program you will apply to may require additional application materials. Please +, visit the program’s website, + +read brief introductions of each program from +and prepare for the additional materials if required. + +page 14 + +c. The application fee is non-refundable and not subject to a waiver. + +C +a. All the application materials must be valid and up-to-date. + +Application Materials + +b. Any application materials that you submit to KAIST become our property and are + +IRRETURNABLE + +. Please learn to prepare for your application materials at + +Ⅵ Required +section, and take options that will avoid submitting your original + +Application Materials +degrees and transcripts that are not obtainable again. + +c. All documents must be in English or Korean. Any materials written in other +languages will have no value to support your application. All the mandatory +application materials must be translated either in English or Korean preferably by +the institutions that have issued them or by a public notary office. Optional +documents must do the same to be accepted and recognized as evidence. + +d. KAIST accepts degree certificates, transcripts, English proficiency test score reports, +and other supporting materials sent directly from the issuing institutes or agencies +to our office in an official and approved channel. + +e. In case of any loss or damages in delivery, make a photocopy of your application + +materials. + +f. KAIST reserves the right to request additional materials from applicants for any + +further verification or qualification. + +g. Our offer of admission may be revoked even after being admitted to or having +graduated from KAIST if any of the submitted materials are found to be false or +counterfeit. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +3 + + Ⅳ + + Eligibility + +Degree + +A +▫ Applicants must hold or expect to hold a Bachelor’s degree for Master or Master- +Ph.D. Integrated program application or Master’s degree for a Doctoral program + +application by + +August 28 + +th + +, 2022 + +. + +※ Notes + +- Bachelor’s degree must be equivalent to a Korean Bachelor’s degree which takes + +four years of study * learn and compare with the Korean system at WHED + +- + +Equivalents + +a. University degree requiring four years of study +b. Three-year Bologna compliant Bachelor’s degree +c. The first cycle qualification in the framework of qualifications for the European + +Higher Education Area (EHEA) + +d. Bachelor’s degree with honors in British pattern education +e. Cases other than above should provide a supplement to prove the equivalency + +B +▫ Applicants must hold citizenship outside Korea. + +Citizenship + +* Korean citizens who hold dual citizenship are not eligible for this track of admission. + +※ + +NOTE for International Applicants of Korean Ethnicity + +International applicants of Korean ethnicity, regardless of the place of birth, MUST additionally +satisfy ONE of the two requirements below: + +a. NEITHER of their parents is a citizen of Korea or; +b. The applicant must have received the ENTIRE elementary, junior high, and high school + +education OUTSIDE of Korea at the comparable and equivalent level of those provided in +Korea. + +※ In this case, international schools located in Korea are not acknowledged as foreign + +schools. Applicants of Korean ethnicity who completed their entire education (elementary, +junior high, high school, and undergraduate) outside of Korea should submit the + +Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry & Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) issued by the + +Korean Immigration Office. The certificate should have been issued within one month to +the online application deadline. + +International students of Korean ethnicity who do not meet the conditions above CANNOT +apply for International Admissions. Instead, they can apply through the KAIST General + +Admission (“일반전형” at http://admission.kaist.ac.kr/graduate). + +p a g e + + | 22 + +4 + + C +▫ + +English Language Proficiency + +Our official language of communication and instructions for international students at KAIST is +. All the applicants of International Admission must provide at least one of the + +English +following English proficiency test (EPT) scores: +* Recognized English language proficiency tests taken after + + March 29 + +, are valid. + +th + +, 2020 + +Test + +Min. Score + +Submission + +Remark + +TOEFL iBT +*PBT / CBT + +83 +* 560 / 220 + +Report through the ETS website +and send us a legible copy of score +report + +Code: 0195 +(iBT MyBest Scores are NOT +accepted) + +IELTS + +TOEIC + +6.5 band + +A legible copy of the score report + +Academic Mode + +720 + +The original score report + +Listening & Reading + +TEPS/ New TEPS + +599 / 326 + +A legible copy of the score report + +Scores from Institutional Testing Program (ITP) are not accepted. + +* +* Programs that do not require EPT score: GITTP, KINS-KAIST, RCA-KAIST, KOICA-KAIST + +SEMBA + +▫ You are able to request a waiver of the requirement to prove English proficiency test + +(EPT) score if you meet one of the following conditions: + +a. You do not need to provide an EPT score if you hold citizenship of the following + have completed a qualification equivalent to a Bachelor’s degree or + +countries +higher from the following countries: + +OR + +Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, the Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Canada, Dominica, +Grenada, Guyana, Ireland, Jamaica, Malta, New Zealand, St Kitts, St Lucia, St Vincent, +Trinidad and Tobago, U.K., U.S.A. + +b. You do not need to provide an EPT score if you hold citizenship of the following + have completed a qualification equivalent to a Bachelor’s degree +countries +or higher in English as the medium of instruction from the following countries: +* A certificate proving the medium of instruction must be supplemented. + +AND + +i.e., English Lecture Certificate + +Botswana, Cameroon, Eswatini, Ethiopia, Fiji, Gambia, Ghana, India, Jamaica, Kenya, +Kiribati, Lesotho, Liberia, Malawi, Marshall Islands, Mauritius, Federated States of +Micronesia, Namibia, Nauru, Nigeria, Pakistan, Palau, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, +Rwanda, Samoa, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Singapore, Solomon Islands, Republic of South +Africa, Sudan, Republic of South Sudan, Tanzania, Tonga, Tuvalu, Uganda, Vanuatu, +Zambia, Zimbabwe + +c. Those enrolled in KAIST graduate programs during the application term do not + +need to provide an EPT score. +* Those enrolled in the following programs are not eligible for a waiver: GITTP, KINS-KAIST, + +RCA-KAIST, KOICA-KAIST SEMBA + +※ + +If you meet one of the conditions above, tick + +online application. + +EXEMPTION + + in + +English + + section in + + of our + +Step 2 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +5 + + D +▫ + +▫ + +Finding an Academic Advisor at KAIST + + must find three to five faculty members from the +Master�s program applicants +department you will apply to whose research interests overlap yours and write their +names in +* Master’s applicants don’t need to obtain approval to write the names of advisors. +However, some programs require Master’s applicants to find and obtain approvals from +advisors before application. For details, please check our + + section in your online application + +Faculty + +STEP 1 + +. + +section and the website of the program you will apply to. + +Ⅶ Degrees and Programs + +(page 14) + + – including + +Doctorate program applicants +M.S.-Ph.D integrated program +- must find one faculty member whom you want to advise you before application, +obtain approval for the application and write his or her name in + section in + +applicants for + +Faculty + +your online application + +STEP 1 + +. + +※ Please check whether we offer any program that meets your research interests at + +Ⅶ + first and learn about our faculty members at the + +Degrees and Programs (page 14) +STARLIBRARY website (click). + +p a g e + + | 22 + +6 + + Ⅴ + + Timelines + +ONLINE Application +Mar. 15 + +, 2022 – Mar. 29 + +th + +th + +, 2022 + +https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. +Mar. 15th, 10A.M. – Mar. 29th, 5P.M. + +th + +Document Submission by POST +by Apr. 8 + +, 2022 +Send your online application printout and supporting +materials to our office, except for recommendation +letters which are received ONLY through our online +system. + +Arrival Check of Submitted +Document +Mar. 22 + +, 2022 – Apr. 8 + +, 2022 +Please check the status of your document arrival +at https://apply.kaist.ac.kr/intergradapply. + +nd + +th + +To complete your application, we could require missing +documents or supplements through our online system. +Please check the Doc.Submission board at regular intervals +until it turns to COMPLETE. + +Interview (if necessary) +th +May 2 + +, 2022 – Jun. 13 + +nd + +, 2022 + +Please check your e-mail at regular intervals. + +Application Review +, 2022 – Jun. 13 +May 2 + +, 2022 +Respective departments will contact applicants +individually if an interview is necessary. + +nd + +th + +Scholarship Review +Jun. 14 + +, 2022 – Jun. 21 + +th + +st + +, 2022 + +Decision Notification +, 2022 +5:00P.M., Jun. 22 + +nd + +The decisions will be announced through our online +application system along with the registration +guide. + +Admission +, 2022 +Aug. 29 + +th + +※ + +THE TIMELINE IS BASED ON LOCAL TIME IN SOUTH KOREA AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +7 + + Ⅵ + + Required Application Materials + +A + +Application Materials at a Glance + +No. + +□√ List and Order of the Application Materials + +Note + +□ Document Checklist + +- This is included in your online application printout + +- + +1 + +2 + +□ Online Application Printout + +□ Statement of Financial Resources Printout + +3 + +□ Recommendation Letters + +4 + +5 + +□ Certificate (s) of Degree or Diploma + +□ Transcripts + +- Complete your application by paying the application fee. +- Check whether you have missed signing on the printouts. +- Review whether your supplements support your + +application printout. + +- Recommendation letters will be received electronically + +from the referees you register on our system. + +- You can check whether they have completed your letters +and email your referees to request them on our system. + +- Please see page 11 and 12 for the approved format of + +the document. + +- Organize in the following order: + +Bachelor’s degree → transcripts → Master’s degree → +transcripts + +- Please check your eligibility and available evidence + +6 + +□ English Proficiency Test (EPT) Score + +□ + +□ + +□ + +□ + +EPT score report +Degree in an English +native country +CTZ of an English native country + +□ + +English lecture Cert. +Currently enrolled in +KAIST grad. Program + +- For iBT score, please report through the ETS website + +(Institution code for TOEFL: 0195) + +- For TOEIC, you have to send us in the original form + +7 + +□ Curriculum Vitae + +- There is no designated form. + +8 + +□ Identity Document of the Applicant + +9 + +□ Identity Document of BOTH Parents + +- These documents are to check the citizenships of you and + +your parents. + +10 + +11 + +□ Certificate of Family Registration + +(“가족관계증명서”) + +- You can replace it with an equivalent public document or +a birth certificate indicating the relationship between you +and your parents + +□ The Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry + +& Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) + +- ONLY for Korean Ethnicity if applicable +- It must be issued within three months + +12 + +□ List of Honors and Awards + +- Optional + +13 + +□ Employment Certificate + +14 + +□ School Profile / Credit Rating System + +※ + +※ + +For the detailed conditions of each document, please refer to the following guide. + +The program you will apply to may require additional application materials. Please read brief + +introductions of each program from page 14, visit the program’s website, and prepare for the + +additional materials if required. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +8 + + B + +a + +▫ + +▫ + +▫ + +▫ + +How to Apply and What to Be Done to Complete Your Application + +ONLINE APPLICATION + +Our online system is optimized to the Windows operation systems. Please use a computer +with a Windows-based OS. + +Step 1_Program of Study and Personal Background +Create an account with your valid email account, select a degree program you want +to study at KAIST, and enter your personal information. +* You can apply to one degree program at each application term. + +Step 2_Academic History, Performances, Experiences, and Referees +Enter the required information such as academic history, EPT score, publication, +work experiences, and referees. +* Applicants must provide the referees’ professional or institutional email accounts for verification. + +Step 3_Statement of Purpose +Write the statement of purpose and answer other questions as below to present who +you are, what you have achieved, and what you want to achieve at KAIST. + +a. Please briefly answer the following questions with keywords (up to 500 letters to each question). + +* Required + +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ +▪ + +* Required + +* Required + +What you studied at the previous institution +Motivation applying for the major +Brief study plan +Future plan after study +Honors and awards +Introduction of the institution previously attended + +* Required + +*Optional + +*Optional + +b. Write down a detailed and accurate statement of your purpose and objective in pursuing your + +study at KAIST (Up to 5,000 letters). * Required + +Step 4_Statement of Financial Resources to Study at KAIST +State your financial resources to cover the tuition fees and expenses for your study +at KAIST. If you want to apply to our graduate program with KAIST Scholarship, +select + + as your financial resource. + +KAIST Scholarship + +* You can select multiple options to support your life at KAIST. + +a. + +b. + + or + +Parental Sponsor + +Self-support +If you choose Self-support or Parental Sponsor as your financial resource, bank statements +ending within a month of your application date must be provided to prove the financial +capacity of USD 18,000 or more. If Self-support or Parental Sponsor is the only option of your +financial resource, the ending balance must be at least USD 18,000 or more*. +* The ending balance must be enough to cover your expenditure of one year on campus - tuition fees + +for two semesters and other expenses for one year. Please refer to our rate on page 20. + +Government/Organization Scholarship + +p a g e + + | 22 + +9 + + A certificate or letter of sponsorship must be provided with the information of a responsible +officer whom KAIST can reach. If the applicant is also awarded KAIST Scholarship, the financial +aids from KAIST will deduct the amount covered by the other scholarship program. + +* + + is an + + organized and hosted by + +Global Korea Scholarship (GKS) +National Institute for International Education (NIIED). If you want to apply to our graduate +program through GKS, you must apply through either University Track or Embassy Track, +according to GKS Application Guide. Learn more… (click) + +INDEPENDENT ADMISSION PROGRAM + +c. + +KAIST Scholarship +KAIST Scholarship is a financial aid program to support international students. KAIST will review +applicants based on prior performance and future promise and will decide awardees and rates. +Decisions will be announced with the final results. Benefits include tuition fee waive, monthly +stipends of KRW 350,000 for Master’s and KRW 400,000 for Doctoral students, and health +insurance premiums supported by their advisors or programs. KAIST will review the +performance of the beneficiaries every year and decide whether to prolong our financial aids. +* The rate may vary by your participation in research projects and performance. + +▫ + +Step 5_Submission of the Application Fee +Submit the application fee of + + or + +KRW 80,000 + + to complete your online + +USD 80 + +application. Our system will instantly assign an application number to your +application and automatically email your referees to upload recommendation letters +after confirming your payment. + +▫ You can take one of the four options below to pay the application fee. Our +recommendation is to pay by credit card since it is the most responsive and instant +means. + +Credit Card + +Bank Transfer + +Overseas + +Korean +Domestic + +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- international transaction activated + +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- online transaction activated + +Late, Expensive Charge +- applicants must email + +the + +transfer + +receipt at advanced.adm@kaist.ac.kr +Responsive, Less Charge +- through our payment platform +- online transaction activated + +※ The overseas bank transfer option will take a few days to reach us and a few more for KAIST to + +confirm the payment and assign your number – they are all manual. + +※ You CANNOT edit your online application after paying the fee. Please proofread and complete + +your online application before you pay. + +※ The application fee is NOT subject to a refund and waiver. + + b + +TWO RECOMMENDATION LETTERS + + *Do NOT ATTACH to your application package. We receive them ONLINE. + +▫ Referees must upload recommendation letters on our system by the deadline of + +document submission. + +Applicants can monitor the current status of your letter or email to your + +referees to request letters through our system (click) + +. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +10 + + ※ Reference letters must remain strictly undisclosed to applicants and must not be requested any + +reading or disclosure of the information given in the letters. + +▫ KAIST prefers as your referees those who taught you or supervised you at +universities or work. If you would ask someone at work, please use a letterhead +showing the company’s contact information. + +▫ Applicants must register the professional or institutional email accounts of their + +referees for verification. + +※ Please note that the earlier you complete your online application, the more time your + +referees will have to write letters for you. + +※ Please do NOT ATTACH your letters to your application packages. We receive them ONLINE. + + +c +▫ Applicants must submit official degrees or diplomas from the institutions they + +OFFICIAL DEGREES / DIPLOMAS + +earned their Bachelor’s or higher to prove their eligibility. + +* Original degrees or diplomas are accepted. However, since our office doesn’t return your +application materials regardless of the final decisions, we strongly recommend you to take +other options to prove your academic qualification. + +* Official degrees or diplomas are certified copies of your degrees or diplomas issued and + +verified by a responsible officer of the institutions you attended and bearing raised or colored +seal of the institutions or signature of the officer. They are also referred to as True Copy or +Certified Copy in some countries. +E-documents are also acceptable if they are provided through the official and approved +channel from the issuing institute with a tool to verify them. + +* + +* Authenticated by a notary public is also acceptable if it bears the seal or signature of the + +officer. + +* Photocopies are not accepted – photocopies of the original or certified copy don’t bear any + +quality to verify whether they are true. + +▫ + +▫ + +If you expect to graduate, you can replace your degree or diploma with a certificate +of the expected graduation or an official letter from your university supporting your +graduation. The replacement must include your name, degree to be conferred, and +date of graduation. + +If you receive your degree later than the beginning of our admission, the certificate +or letter must bear the date when you complete your degree requirements + +* Graduates from colleges and universities in China can substitute official degree with + +Credentials Report + + issued by CDGDC (中国学位与研究生教育信息网) + +AND China Higher + +Education Qualification Certificate + + issued by CHESICC (中国高等教育学生信息网). + + +d +▫ Applicants must submit official transcripts from the institutions they earned their + +OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPTS + +p a g e + + | 22 + +11 + + Bachelor’s or higher degree to prove their academic performance. + +* Official transcripts are certified copies of your transcripts issued and verified by a responsible +officer of the institutions you attended and bearing raised or colored seal of the institutions or +signature of the officer. They are also referred to as True Copy or Certified Copy in some +countries. +E-documents are also acceptable if they are provided through the official and approved +channel from the issuing institute with a tool to verify them. + +* + +* Authenticated by a notary public are also acceptable if they bears the seal or signature of the + +officer. + +* Photocopies are not accepted – photocopies of the original or certified copy don’t bear any + +quality to verify whether they are true. + +▫ Transcripts must include information on the grading systems, courses completed, +grades or marks earned, cumulative grade points average (CGPA), personal rank (if +possible), certificates or degree awarded, and + from the institutions + +grading system + +you attended or attending. + +* Graduates from colleges and universities in China can substitute official transcripts + +with +(中国高等教育学生信息网). + +China Higher Education Student’s Academic Transcripts + + issued by CHESICC + +e + +▫ + +ENGLISH PROFICIENCY TEST (EPT) REPORT + +Our official language of communication and instructions for international students at KAIST is +. Applicants of international graduate admissions must prove their English + +English +language proficiency with one of the qualifications described in the + +English Language + +Proficiency + + section on + +. + +page 5 + +Curriculum Vitae + +f +▫ Applicants must provide summaries of their education, certifications, research +experience, professional affiliations, and other information to present themselves to +our student selection committees. + +g +▫ Applicants must provide a public document proving their citizenship. + +Citizenship of Applicants + +e.g., a photocopy of the passport, national ID card, alien registration card, or any other form of the public +documents indicating information such as the issuance number, date of issue and expiration, photo, and name. + +h +▫ Applicants must provide public documents proving their parents’ citizenship. + +Citizenship of Applicants’ Parents + +e.g., a photocopy of the passport, national ID card, alien registration card, or any other form of the public +documents indicating information such as the issuance number, date of issue and expiration, photo, and name. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +12 + + “ +가족관계증명서 +Certificate of Family Registration ( + i -compression. -| Task: | Analyze | whether | | the user | will | like the | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| new Music | | i based | on | the user’s | preferences | | | | | | | | -B.2 RankingunderHardNegativeSampling -| andtheitem’sfeatures. | | | | Provideyourrationale | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toconstructamorechallengingrankingscenario, -inoneconciseparagraph. -wereplacerandomnegativeswithhardnegatives -| | | | | | | | generatedbyacollaborativefilteringmodel. | | | | | Specif- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -A.3 ExampleofCue -ically,foreachuser,weretrievehigh-scoringitems -Thefollowingexamplesillustratehowrawsignals -| | | | | | | | from an | EASE(Steck, | 2019) | model | that | the user | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | -| aredistilledintocues. | | | Asshownonthetop, | | | user | | | | | | | -hasnotinteractedwith,andcombinethemwiththe -cuesemphasizehistoricalpreferences,whileitem -ground-truthitemtoformthecandidateset. -cues highlight metadata and user-group patterns. Table 9 reports the results. Compared to ran- -| Together, | they | provide | minimal | | but informative | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -domsampling,performancedecreasesforallmeth- -hypothesesforprofileexploration. -| | | | | | | | ods due | to increased | difficulty, | while | DUET | con- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | sistently | maintains | the | best performance | | across | -ExamplesofUserCues -| | | | | | | | datasets. | Thisindicatesthattheimprovementsare | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “enjoys | retro | puzzle | games” | — | derived | from re- | | | | | | | -robustandnotlimitedtotrivialrankingscenarios. -peatedengagementwithclassictitles. -“prefersconciseproductreviews”—inferredfrom B.3 RobustnessunderPreferenceDiversity -apatternofshort,directcomments. -WefurtheranalyzetherobustnessofDUETunder -“tendstogivehighratingsbutrarelycomments”— -| | | | | | | | varyinglevelsofuserpreferencediversity. | | | | | Weuse | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -highlightingconsistencybutlimitedfeedback. -thevarianceofhistoricalratingsasaproxyforpref- -| | | | | | | | erencestability: | | lowvarianceindicatesconsistent | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -ExamplesofItemCues -| | | | | | | | preferences, | while | high | variance | corresponds | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -“lightweighttrail-runningshoes”—derivedfrom -diverseorpotentiallyconflictingsignals. -productmetadata. -Wepartitionusersintothreegroupsbasedonper- -| “popular | among | budget-conscious | | | users” | — in- | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -centilethresholds(bottom33%,middle33%,top -ferredfrompurchasepatterns. -33%ofratingvariance)andevaluateperformance -| “stylized | with | retro | aesthetics” | | — extracted | from | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withineachgroup. -itemdescriptions. -| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Table 10, | performance | | degrades | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -smoothlyaspreferencediversityincreasesacross -| | | | | | | | all datasets. | Importantly, | | the degradation | | is grad- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -B AdditionalExperiments -ualratherthancatastrophic,indicatingthatDUET -B.1 Non-LLMBaselineviaExtractive -remainsstableunderheterogeneousornoisyinter- -Summarization -actionhistories. -| To examine | | whether | the | gains | of DUET | stem | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C TheUseofLargeLanguageModels -| from improved | | semantic | | representations | | rather | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| than generic | | text generation, | | we | introduce | a non- | | | | | | | -WeusedaLargeLanguageModel(LLM)onlyas -LLMbaselinebasedonextractivesummarization. a writing assistant to polish the language of the -| Specifically, | | we apply | TextRank | | (Mihalcea | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | manuscript | (e.g., | grammar | refinement, | | style ad- | -Tarau,2004)toselectsalientsentencesfromuser -| | | | | | | | justment,andclarityimprovement). | | | | Theresearch | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -historiesandconstructuserprofileswithoutusing ideas,methodologydesign,experiments,andanal- -anygenerativemodel. ysiswereentirelyconceived,implemented,andval- -| The | extracted | summaries | | are | then fed | into the | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -idatedbytheauthorswithoutrelianceontheLLM. -samedownstreampredictorforratingestimation. -| | | | | | | | The LLM | did not | contribute | to research | | ideation, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -Thisbaselineisolatestheeffectofreadablesumma- experimentaldesign,orresultinterpretation. -rizationfromrepresentationlearning. -Table8showsthatTextRankimprovesoversim- -| ple history | truncation | | (10H), | but | remains | signifi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Method | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | (%) | -10H 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -TextRank 0.8104 1.1323 50.51 30.23 0.5914 0.8223 61.19 29.68 0.6328 0.8854 59.59 29.48 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table8: Comparisonwithanon-LLMextractivesummarizationbaseline(TextRank). -| Method | | | Yelp | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -| | Table9: | RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| VarianceGroup | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -#Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 -| | | | (%) | (%) | | (%) (%) | | | (%) (%) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | -Stable 1530 0.4017 0.8664 71.76 68.96 432 0.2368 0.5990 82.56 86.89 1876 0.3171 0.8403 76.64 72.56 -Moderate 1354 0.4773 0.8309 60.09 46.26 436 0.3921 0.6628 64.16 47.02 1827 0.4495 0.8059 66.73 55.45 -Diverse 1444 0.6632 1.1198 51.13 45.95 428 0.5536 0.9607 57.10 59.27 1838 0.6199 1.0603 49.52 46.35 -Table10: PerformanceofDUETunderdifferentlevelsofuserpreferencediversity(measuredbyratingvariance). -#Samp. denotesthenumberofsamplesineachgroup. \ No newline at end of file +▫ Applicants must provide a public document proving the relationship with their +parents. It must indicate the names of the applicant and parents and the relation. +e.g., certificate of family registration, family registration certificate (card), family relation certificate, birth +certificate + +” +) + +▫ Applicants of Korean ethnicity who want to prove their eligibility with the loss of +their parents’ Korean citizenship must provide Family Relation Certificate (가족관 +계증명서) indicating the dates of losing their Korean citizenship, including the +applicants’. + +▫ Chinese applicants must provide either Family Relation Certificate (親屬關係證明) +or Family Registry Certificate (戶口簿) or both translated and notarized by the +public notary office to state their family relation +* Attestation from the Korean embassy is not necessary. + +“ +The Certificate of the Facts Concerning the Entry & Exit ( +*ONLY for applicants of Korean ethnicity + +출입국사실증명서 + +” +) + +j + +▫ Applicants of Korean ethnicity who want to prove their eligibility with their entire +education completed overseas must provide the Certificate of the Facts Concerning +the Entry & Exit (“출입국사실증명서”) issued by the Korean Immigration Office. + + Optional Documents + +# 1. List of Honors and Awards + + *use Appendix + +▫ + +If you have honors, awards, fellowships, or any academic certificates or test reports +to support your achievements, you can provide valid evidence along with the list + +E.g. Graduate Record Examination (GRE/ Code: 4558. Please report through the ETS website to be recognized), +Graduate Management Admissions Test (GMAT), Test of Proficiency in Korean (TOPIK), Korean Language +Proficiency Test (KLPT), etc. + +▫ Only those provided with evidence will be acknowledged in evaluation. + +# 2. Employment Certificate + +▫ + +If there is work, internship, or assistantship experience related to your intended +study or research at KAIST, please provide a certificate or official letter from where +you worked. The certificate or letter must include information such as duration of +work, position, and other information describing your job and duty. + +# 3. School Profile + +▫ + +▫ + +School profiles of colleges or universities you attended or are attending will help our +committee evaluate your applications in a useful context. + +It may include information about demography, programs, grading system, and +ranking. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +13 + + Ⅶ + + Degrees and Programs + +1. Degree Information + +Admission Dates: + +Spring (around March) / Fall (around September) + +The Degree Programs KAIST Offers: + + + + + + + + + +Master’s Degree +The Master’s degree generally requires two academic years of study. + +MBA Degree +The MBA degree is awarded in the department of Finance MBA and Techno-MBA. + +Doctoral Degree +The Ph.D. degree generally requires four or more academic years of study. + +Integrated Master's and Doctoral Degree +The integrated Master's and Doctoral degree program is a Doctoral degree program +integrated with Master’s degree program. It generally requires five academic years +of study. The program starts with the Master's program, and candidates are +promoted to the Doctoral program without the usual requirements of submitting the +Master’s thesis. + +※ In case of dropping out, Master’s degree could be awarded if the candidate has completed all the + +requirements of the Master’s degree. + +2. Programs + +College + +Programs + +Natural +Science + +Physics +Condensed Matter Physics, Optics, Plasma Physics, Particle and +Theoretical Physics, Soft Matter Physics, Nonlinear and Complex +Systems, Biophysics +* Applicants are highly recommended to contact advising professor + +prior to application + +Mathematical Sciences +Analysis, Algebra, Algebraic Geometry, Differential Geometry, +Numerical Analysis, Partial Differential Equations, Graph Theory, +Number Theory, Probability, Topology, Statistics, Biomathematics and +Medical Imaging, Computational Image Processing, Computational +Mathematics, Financial Mathematics + +Chemistry +Physical Chemistry, Organic Chemistry, +Inorganic Chemistry, +Analytical Chemistry, Polymer Chemistry, Bio Chemistry, Nano +Chemistry, Chemical Biology + +Main (Daejeon) Campus + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +● + +● + +http://physics.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2502 +E. sueca@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://mathsci.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2703 +E. hlyoon@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +http://chem.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2804 +E. ahnyeseul@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +14 + + College + +Programs + +Life Science +and +Bioengineering + +Biological Sciences +Biological/Biomedical Sciences (Cell Biology, Biochemistry, Structural +Biology, Genetics, Epigenetics, Stem Cell Biology, Plant Biology, +Developmental Biology, Neurobiology, Immunology), Biotechnology or +Bioengineering (Applied Biophysics, Microbial and Cell Biotechnology, +and Environmental Biotechnology, Synthetic Biotechnology) + +Graduate School of Medical Science and Engineering +- Physician-Scientist Track +Medical Sciences (Molecular Biology, Immunology, Virology, Stem +Cell Biology, Vascular Biology, Pathology, Molecular Genetics, +Neuroscience, Biochemistry, Structural Biology, Developmental +Biology) and Biomedical Engineering (Cell and Tissue Engineering) +* Only open to applicants with a bachelor’s degree (for M.S.- +Ph.D. integrated) and a bachelor’s degree and master’s +degree (for Ph.D.) from Medical, Dental or Oriental +Medicine School. THE APPLICANTS MUST SUBMIT AN +ORIGINAL OR CERTIFIED COPY OF MEDICAL +LICENSE + +- Medical Science and Engineering Track +Medical Sciences (Vascular Biology, Stem Cell Biology, Regenerative +Medicine, Developmental Biology, Immunology, Virology, +Neuroscience, Metabolism, Liver Biology, Pathology, Structural +Biology, Drug Design, Molecular Genetics, Molecular Biology). +* Only open to applicants majored in science and + +engineering. + +Mechanical Engineering +Micro/Nano Systems, IT-based Intelligent Mechanical Systems, New +Energy Systems, Biomedical Engineering, Mechanics and Design +Innovation, Pro-human Engineering, Ocean Systems + +Aerospace Engineering +Aerodynamics & Structures, Propulsion & Energy, Airborne Vehicle +Technology, Space Systems, Aerospace Information & Intelligence, +etc. + +Electrical Engineering +Circuits and Systems, Nano Devices and Integrated Systems, +Electromagnetics and Photonics, Communications, Computing, +Networking, Security, and Signals and Systems +* Applicants are highly recommended to find a prospective + +advisor prior to the application. + +* Applicants whose potential advisor is already determined +should write down their advisor name on application. + +* Applicants are strongly encouraged to survey the Electrical + +Engineering department webpage for the detailed +requirements to the admission process. + +Engineering + +- The Robotics Program + + - Future Vehicle + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +● + +● + +http://bio.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2605 +E. iskang@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +https://gsmse.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-4233 +E. ahsa89@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://me.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3002 +E. e_suk@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ae.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3706 +E. soaekim@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://ee.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3402 +E. ych@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +https://rp.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-5976 +E. albert.ahn@kaist.ac.kr + +T. 82-42-350-8461 +E. bnlee@kaist.ac.kr + +School of Computing +Foundations, Design, Visual Computing, Information Service, Social +Computing, Interactive Computing, Computing Theory, Systems- +Networks, Software Design, Secure Computing, AI-Information +Service, Embedded System, IT Service, UX, Intelligent SW +* Applicants are highly recommended to find a prospective + +advisor prior to the application. + + - Graduate School of Information Security +Cryptography, Software security, Network security, system security + +- Graduate School of Artificial Intelligence +Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, AI+Healthcare, AL+Autonomous +Driving, AI+Manufacturing, AI+Security, AI+Emerging + +Civil and Environmental Engineering +Structural Engineering and Materials, Geotechnical Engineering and +Geo-Systems, Environmental Engineering and Sustainability, IT for +Construction Engineering, Transportation, Urban Design and Planning + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://cs.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3508 +E. oeunbeul@kaist.ac.kr + +http://gsis.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-8303 +E. jisun813@kaist.ac.kr + +http://gsai.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-1802 +E. ssyang11@kaist.ac.kr + +http://civil.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3602 +E. juyeon_lee@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +15 + + College + +Programs + +Bio and Brain Engineering +Bioengineering and Brain Engineering including, + Bioelectronics, +Bioinforma-tics, Biomedical Imaging, BioNano/MEMS, Computational +Neuroscience, Neural Engineering, Systems Biology, Tissue +Engineering and Nanomedicine +- Brain and Cognitive Engineering +Brain Cognitive Science, Computational Neuroscience, +Neuroinformatics, Brain Systems Biology, Neuro Cognitive Robotics, +Brain-Machine Interface, Neuroprostehtics, Brain-Inspired Artificial +Intelligence, Clinical Neuroengineering, Neuro Stem Cell and Tissue +Engineering, Neuroimaging and Signal Analysis + +Industrial Design +Design Driven Innovation, User-Centered Design, Human Computer +Interaction, Design for Well-being and Social Innovation, Creative +Design Thinking, Product Service System and Platform Design, +Design for Co-Creation, Color psychology and emotional design, New +design media, Interaction media, Entertainment media +* Digital portfolio showcasing past projects that exemplifies +the candidate’s capabilities and skills, regardless of the +major of origin. + +Industrial & Systems Engineering +Statistical & Data Science, Machine Learning & AI for Industrial +Intelligence, Financial Optimization & Risk Analysis, Mathematical +Optimization and Stochastic Modeling & Analysis Methods, Modeling, +Analysis, Optimization, and Simulation of Complex Systems, Design +and Operation of Production and Logistics Systems, Operation +Management and Supply Chain Management, Human Computer +Interaction and Ergonomics, Design and Operation of Services and +Service Systems, Modeling and Optimization of Future Healthcare, +Transportation, Energy, and Defense Systems + +- Graduate School of Knowledge Service Engineering +Data Science, Big Data, Knowledge Modeling and Representation, +Knowledge Engineering, Business Intelligence, Human-Computer +Interaction, User Experience, User Behavior Modeling, Human +Decision Making, Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, Intelligent +System Modeling and Design, +Intelligent Decision Support, +Information Design, Content Networking, Pervasive Knowledge +Services, Content Service, Service Modeling. + +Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering +Synthetic/Systems biotechnology, BioRefinery, Nanobiotechnology, +Protein Engineering, Molecular & Interface Engineering, Superlattice +Nanomaterials, Microfluidic Systems, Functional Nano-Coatings, +Semiconductor and metal nanocrystals, Nano Catalysis, Chemical +Product / Process Design, Process Operation and Control, Green +Catalysis, etc. + +Materials Science & Engineering +Computational Material Science and Electron Microscopy, Data- +Storage Materials, Magnetic Materials, Electronic Packaging +Materials, Optical Materials, +for +Energy/Biotechnology Applications, Energy Storage Materials, Energy +Conversion Materials, Structural Materials, + Heat-Resistant +Materials, Biomaterials, Materials for Sustainable or Functional Nano +Technology, and Materials/Device for Display and flexible electronic. + +Informational Materials + +Nuclear and Quantum Engineering +Peaceful Use of Energy Generated by Nuclear Fission and Fusion +Reactions (Electric Power, Desalination, District Heating, Propulsion +etc.) Nuclear Fuel Cycle, Nuclear Security and Nonproliferation, +Nuclear Policy, Radiation Science and Technology, Radiation +Applications, Radiation Medical Imaging, Radiation Devices. + +- International Nuclear and Radiation Safety Master's Degree +Program(KINS-KAIST) +Only open to THOSE WHO ARE WORKING FOR GOVERNMENT OR +NUCLEAR RELATED INSTITUTIONS OF HIS/HER COUNTRY AND +ARE RECOMMENDED BY GOVERNMENT OR CURRENT +INSTITUTION. Visit website of the program for more information. + +Engineering + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +● + +Ph.D. + +● + +Office + +http://bioeng.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4303 +E. hae@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +http://bce.kaist.ac.kr/ +T. 82-42-350-4305 +E. bceprogram@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +http://id.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4503 +E. sesedolee@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +http://ie.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3103 +E. wisdom1029@kaist.ac.kr + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://kse.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-1602 +E. yhchoi@kaist.ac.kr + +http://cbe.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3908 +E. so9034@kaist.ac.kr + +http://mse.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3303 +E. e_leeyj@kaist.ac.kr + +http://nuclear.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-3804 +E. jyp@kaist.ac.kr + +Inss.kins.re.kr/inss/Action?act +=INDEXKK +T. 82-42-350-8511 +E. juyeong@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +16 + + College + +Programs + +Master’s + +Degree Offered +Ph.D. +(Master’s +integrated) + +Ph.D. + +Office + +The Cho Chun Shik Graduate School of Green Transportation +Eco-friendly Transportation Technology (Electric Vehicle, Hybrid +Electric Vehicle, Wireless Electric Transfer, e-Mobility), Intelligent +Transportation Technology +(Autonomous Vehicle, Vehicular +Communication for Cooperative Driving), Sustainable Transportation +Technology (Efficient Urban Transportation Systems, Logistics +Optimization, Future City Policy) +Graduate School of Culture Technology +Creative Technologies +(Computer Graphics/Animation, Music +Technology, AR, VR, HCI, Computational Design, Augmented +Humans), Human & Culture Sciences (Network Science, Social +Computing, Cognitive Science, Digital Heritage), Culture Industries +(Computer Game, Art & Technology, Museum/Exhibition Technology) +* The Advisor’s name should be included in the application form +Graduate School of Science and Technology Policy +National Policy in Science and Technology, Health and Biomedical +Policy, the National Innovation System, Dynamics of R&D Policy +Decisions, Energy and Environment Policy, Aging and Welfare +Technology Policy, Ethics of Emerging Technologies +* Addition materials are required to apply for STP +program. Please visit and check the following +website: https://stp.kaist.ac.kr/0302 + +Business and Technology Management +Technology Management, +Innovative Strategy and Policy, +Entrepreneurship, Finance, Financial Economics, Supply Chain +Information Systems/E-business, +Management, Management +Information Economics, Organizational Behavior, Human Resource +Management, Information Sociology, Marketing, Accounting, Science +and Technology Policy +- Global IT Technology Program +IT Technology +IT Technology R&D +Latest +Management/Policy in Korea, Wireless Communications Technology, +Ubiquitous Computing, Software Engineering, ICT Economics and +Management, Internet Business and Management, Financial and +Accounting Management in IT Policy +Only open to THOSE WHO ARE NOMINATED BY GITTP department. +Please contact GITTTP in advance. +* Addition materials are required to apply for GITTP + +in Korea, + +program. Please visit and check the following +website: +https://ittp.kaist.ac.kr/html/kr/adm/adm_0203.html + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +Liberal Arts +and +Convergence +Science + +Business + +● + +● + +● + +● + +● + +http://gt.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-1252 +E. yujeong0610@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ct.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-2903 +E. yujeong0610@kaist.ac.kr + +http://stp.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-4843 +E. jungillee@kaist.ac.kr + +http://btm.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-6308 +E. kjjung@kaist.ac.kr + +http://ittp.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-42-350-6845 +E. kate1025@kaist.ac.kr + +College + +Department /Division + +Seoul Campus + +M.S. + +M.S.- + +PhD + +PhD + +Contact Info. + +Business + +Techno-MBA +The First Full-time MBA in Korea/Case-based Teaching and Real Business +Experience/World-class Study Environment/Global Leadership Program and +Exchanges Programs + +Green Business and Policy Program +Green Business and Policy Program nurtures sustainability entrepreneurs and +leaders in green business and policy. Students will develop the capability of +solving global green growth and sustainable development problems in the areas +of energy, environment, and climate change, based on an +integrated +understanding of business, policy, and technology. + +● + +● + +http://business.kaist.ac.kr +T. 82-2-958-3642 +E. topcheol@kaist.ac.kr + +http://www.business.kaist.edu +T. 82-2-958-3407 +E. gsgg@kaist.ac.kr + +p a g e + + | 22 + +17 + + Ⅷ + + Campus Life (Daejeon & Seoul) + +1. Life in Daejeon + +Dormitory +All students are provided with dormitories on campus. Each room is shared by one or two students and is +furnished with beds, closets, desks, and chairs. Residents share bathrooms, laundry rooms, and lounges. +Students pay a dormitory fee of approximately KRW 115,000 per month. + +Medical service +Minor wounds and illnesses are treated at an on-campus healthcare center for free. For more serious illnesses, +high quality professional medical service is offered on campus at the KAIST Clinic Pappalardo Center. + +Sports facilities +KAIST has excellent facilities for table tennis, tennis, soccer, racketball, badminton, volleyball, and basketball. +We also have swimming pools and fitness centers equipped with cycles, treadmills, barbells, etc. + +Library +KAIST has two major libraries: the Main Library and the Undergraduate Branch Library. There are also a +bookstore and a cafeteria on the first floor of the Main Library. + +International Scholar and Student Services (ISSS) +ISSS supports international students with regard to their visa issuance/extension, school registration, +housing, and orientation. ISSS also organizes various exciting activities, festivals, community services, etc. + +▪ +▪ +▪ + +http://isss.kaist.ac.kr +Email: isss@kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-42-350-2481~2 + +Restaurants +There are three cafeterias, some fast-food restaurants, and cafes on campus. You will also find numerous +restaurants located right outside of campus. KAIST also has an international kitchen. Many of our international +students gather at this place to cook and eat together. + +KAIST Language Center (KLC) +KLC offers language courses to improve the Korean and English skills of KAIST students and researchers. All +of the classes offered by KLC are non-credit classes, and tuition is charged for each class. Also, KLC provides +English proofreading services and Korean-English translation services. + +▪ +▪ +▪ + +http://lang.kaist.ac.kr +Email: language@kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-42-350-8731~2 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +18 + + 2. Life in Seoul (College of Business) + +Dormitory +KAIST College of Business (KCB) students board at the on-campus dormitory. The three dorm buildings, +Pajung, Sojung Hall, and Haejung Hall, are all located within 3-minute walking distance from each other and +approximately 5-minute walking distance from the main buildings of the campus. + +KCB students are mainly assigned in the Pajung Hall. The dorm rooms are designed for double occupancy. +Each person is provided with a desk, a bed, and a wardrobe. The bathroom facilities with shower booth are +shared. It costs KRW 160,000 (approx. USD 160) per month. + +Medical service +The Nurse’s Office is located on the 2nd floor of the Student Union Building. You can get medication for minor +illnesses and injuries. There is a nominal fee for the purchase of medication. + +Sports Facilities +There are outdoor tennis and basketball courts near the dormitories, and an indoor fitness center (gym) is +located on the 1st floor of Building 7, which is connected to SUPEX building. In addition, a newly built golf +practice range is located on the ground floor of the Administration building (Building No. 1) and this facility is +open to registered members only. +The gym is open 24 hours located on the 1st floor. Lockers and shower rooms are also facilitated inside the gym. + +Library +Unlike traditional libraries, the KAIST College of Business students’ library is a digital multi-media library. +This gives students and faculty members the advantage of being able to obtain necessary resources in the +comfort of one’s computer at home. The digital library is joined with the Cyber Hall, a facility where students +have access to the Internet 24 hours a day. + +Restaurants +Student cafeteria serves Korean traditional / inter-national dishes. It is open Monday through Sunday +providing lunch and dinner. Additionally, the Faculty Restaurant is on the 4th floor of the same building. +Another place to eat is the Atrium located on 2nd floor of SUPEX building. It houses both a café and a +restaurant and open hours are as below. You can buy simple breakfast such as sandwiches at the Atrium. + +Office for Exchange Students +The External Affairs Center coordinates exchange & overseas programs. It also offers language programs to +enhance students' English proficiency skills. + +▪ +▪ + +Exchange Program jelee@business.kaist.ac.kr +Language Courses hsl007@business.kaist.ac.kr +Tel: +82-2-958-3244(Exchange Program) & Language Courses jelee@kaist.ac.kr Tel: +82-2-958-3244 + +p a g e + + | 22 + +19 + + Ⅸ + + Financial Aid + +1. Student budget + +Planning your enrollment at KAIST, you should be aware of the estimated expenses that you will +incur. The average budget for a single graduate student living on-campus with no dependents +budget is listed below. Students living off campus can expect living expenses to be 35% to 50% +higher. + +- + +Non-tuition average expenses (2021, currency in KRW): 4,576,000/6 months + +Dormitory 690,000/6 months + +Food 2,745,000/6 months + +Transportation 200,000/6 months + +Books and Supplies 150,000/6 months + +Medical Health Insurance 791,000/6 months + +Tuition & fees (2021, currency in KRW): + +Techno MBA 12,600,000/semester +Finance MBA 15,910,000/semester +Social Economy MBA 12,600,000/semester +Green Business and Policy Program 12,360,000/semester +Other departments 4,048,000/semester + +※ Subject to change by yearly base. + +Entrance Fee none (for all departments) +Student union fee 34,000 (Optional) +Student Health Insurance 43,000 /semester + +2. KAIST International Student Scholarship + +KAIST scholarship recipients are generally exempt from paying tuition and fees. A monthly +allowance of KRW 350,000 (for Master’s candidates) or KRW 400,000 (for Doctoral candidates) +and Medical Health Insurance fees will be supported by the recipient’s advisors or departments. + +3. Earnings on Campus + +There are opportunities for international students to make earnings on campus. Wages are paid for +research (RA), teaching (TA) or other work (Part-time assistant, etc.) performed during +enrollment. Students can apply for positions after the entrance. + +p a g e + + | 22 + +20 + + Appendix. Form - List of Honors and Awards + +# NOTE: To download the form, please click the following LINK. + +Application Number + +Applicant Name + +LIST OF HONORS AND AWARDS +for International Graduate Enrollment + +Please list up to five honors or awards you have obtained during university in order of importance. Each +item below will be considered valid only when the respective testimonial/evidence is submitted. + +No + +Title + +Rank + +Date +(yyyy/mm) + +Level of Recognition +(National / International) + +Issuing Institution: + +Name: + +1 + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +2 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +3 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +Name: + +4 + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +Issuing Institution + +5 + +Name: + +/ + +Website: + +Email: + +Explanation of the Award/Honor (up to 100 words): + +p a g e + + | 22 + +21 + + ※ + +Notice on Collection and Use of Personal Information + + According to the Personal Information Protection Law, KAIST will obtain your agreement on +collecting and using your personal information as below through our online system. + +The Office of Admission will collect and use your personal information for the purpose of student selection +and enrollment to KAIST. + +I. Personal Information Required for Student Selection and Enrollment (Compulsory) + +List of Information + +Purpose + +Legal Grounds + +(Compulsory information) name, +address, phone/mobile number, +country of citizenship, photo, +institutions attended (institutions, +degree, major field of study, dates +attended, academic performance) +(Optional information) English +proficiency test score, work history +(place of work, duration of service, +job title, responsibilities), honors and +awards, research field and topic + +▪ Student selection (All applicants) +▪ Enrollment (only for successful + +applicants) + +- Registration on school register + +- Academic history check + +- Academic performance check + +- Providing information regarding + +registration etc. + +▪ Higher Education Act, +Article 33(Admission +Qualifications), Article +34 (Methods for +Selecting Students) +▪ Enforcement Decree of +the Higher Education +Act, Article 35 (Data +for Admission +Screening) + +Holding +Duration + +10 years + +※ The subject of information has the right to deny the collection and use of their personal + +information. However, as the above information is compulsory for the student selection process, + +denial of information collection and use means that the subject of information may not apply to + +be considered in the selection process. + +- Do you consent to the above collection and use of your personal information? + + I consent + + I do not consent + +▢ + +▢ + +2. Unique Identifying Information Collection and Use (Compulsory) + +Items + +Purpose + +Legal Grounds + +Passport number / +Alien Registration +Number (in case you +have a valid number) + +▪ Admission screening and student + +selection (All applicants) + +▪ Handling of violations in the application + +process (all applicants) + +▪ Documentation of education such as + +school register entry and management +etc. (Only for successful applicants) + +Enforcement Decree of the +Higher Education Act, Article 73 +(Handling of Unique Identifying +Information) + +Holding +Duration + +10 years + +※ The subject of information has the right to deny the collection and use of their personal + +information. However, as the above information is compulsory for the student selection process, + +denial of information collection and use means that the subject of information may not apply to + +be considered in the selection process. + +- Do you consent to the above collection and use of your personal information? + + I consent + + I do not consent + +▢ + +▢ + +p a g e + + | 22 + +22 + diff --git a/q32/random_k4/random_3.md b/q32/random_k4/random_3.md index d7c648c46217c666d729ea73101d1fa08d732fc8..204be1b3f7adc9b093ccf8a315fc2bb0c9f8d956 100644 --- a/q32/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q32/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1010 +1,2022 @@ -Fellow Shareholders, - - February 12, 2026 - -We delivered excellent results in 2025, driven by consistent execution and the differentiation of our leading TV -streaming platform. By expanding our Platform monetization over the last two years, we’ve unlocked new -growth engines and achieved record-breaking financial performance. In 2025, we achieved positive net income, -expanded Adjusted EBITDA margin by 255 basis points, and reported record Free Cash Flow (TTM), all while -continuing to invest in our platform for long-term growth. We repurchased a total of $150 million of shares -under our $400 million stock repurchase program, reinforcing our commitment to growing Free Cash Flow per -share. Looking ahead to 2026 and beyond, we are confident in our ability to sustain double-digit Platform -revenue growth while continuing to expand both operating and net income margins. - -Full Year 2025 Key Results - -• Total net revenue was $4.737 billion, up 15% year over year (YoY) -• Platform revenue was $4.145 billion, up 18% YoY -• Gross profit was $2.074 billion, up 15% YoY -• Streaming Hours were 145.6 billion, up 15% YoY -• The Roku Channel was the #2 app on our platform by engagement in the U.S. - - Platform -Our Platform segment delivered strong performance in 2025. In Q4, we grew Platform revenue 18% YoY to -$1.224 billion, with gross margin of 52.8%. For the full year, we grew Platform revenue 18% YoY to $4.145 billion, -driven by continued strength in video advertising and streaming services distribution activities, with gross -margin of 52.0%. - -The Roku Experience, anchored by our Home Screen, encompasses the full suite of features designed to engage -viewers and simplify content discovery through the power of AI and our first-party data. This year, we will launch -Home Screen enhancements to further elevate the streaming experience, driving both deeper engagement and -increased Platform monetization. - -Advertising Activities -Our differentiated ad offering is built on our significant scale and first-party data, with more than 90 million -logged-in Streaming Households globally, as well as our innovative ad formats and open and interoperable CTV -ad platform. Roku is the #1 TV streaming platform by hours streamed in the U.S., Canada, and Mexico1, and our -significant viewer engagement generates robust ad supply. According to Nielsen’s The GaugeTM report, The Roku -Channel is the #2 free, ad-supported streaming app (second only to YouTube) and the #5 streaming app overall -in the U.S. In December 2025, The Roku Channel hit an all-time high, representing 6.3% of all TV streaming, up -from 4.6% a year ago2. The share of Roku video impressions executed programmatically continues to increase, -and as we further expand our programmatic capabilities, we expect to drive higher fill rates and improved -monetization. - -In 2025, video advertising on our platform grew faster YoY than the U.S. OTT and broader digital ad markets3. -We announced enhanced partner integrations, along with ad launches in our international markets, as we -increasingly focus on monetization outside the U.S. We expanded our partnership with FreeWheel to activate -Roku inventory via the FreeWheel Streaming Hub, improving demand signals and transparency. We also -broadened our measurement partnership with Nielsen to integrate Roku data into Nielsen’s advanced -measurement solutions. Additionally, we launched the Roku Ads API, a fully open, self-serve developer platform -that enables advertisers to integrate with Roku Ads Manager. Internationally, we partnered with Warner Bros. -Discovery to scale ad demand in Mexico. In Brazil, we expanded our Live TV Guide to 30 FAST channels before -launching our ad platform in partnership with Mercado Ads. - -Throughout the year, we deepened integrations with leading demand-side platforms including Wurl, Yahoo, The -Trade Desk, and Amazon DSP to further diversify our demand sources. We also scaled our measurement and -performance capabilities through partnerships with INCRMNTAL, iSpot, and AppsFlyer. To empower our -partners, we launched the Roku Data Cloud, enabling them to seamlessly analyze and leverage our proprietary -TV data to drive measurable results. - -1 Dec 2025, Hypothesis Group -2 Nielsen The GaugeTM, December 2025 and December 2024 -3 4Q25 SMI (Standard Media Index) data; OTT: over the top - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -2 - - Finally, we continue to scale Roku Ads Manager, our robust self-serve platform for small and medium-sized -businesses (SMBs) and performance advertisers. With platform partnerships such as Spaceback and the -availability of low-cost generative AI video tools, creating high-quality assets for TV has never been more -accessible. Our objective is to minimize friction for SMBs while diversifying Roku demand. Today, with approved -creative, an advertiser can move their performance-driven campaigns from “create campaign” to “publish” in -under five minutes. - -Just minutes from “create campaign” to “publish” on Roku Ads Manager - -For example, LolaVie, Jennifer Aniston’s haircare brand, selected Roku as its CTV partner for its first TV ad -campaign to expand reach, drive web traffic, and increase retail sales at Ulta Beauty. By leveraging Roku Ads -Manager, the brand executed its “Hair People” campaign, contributing to a 40% lift in sales and a 53% YoY -increase in new customers as part of its overall marketing strategy. - -In 2025, we enhanced our comprehensive advertising solutions to provide partners with greater flexibility in -how they buy Roku Media, whether via direct insertion order (IO), a preferred DSP partner, or our self-serve -platform. This versatility allows us to serve the full spectrum of advertisers from global enterprises to digital -growth marketers. Looking ahead, we remain committed to building the industry’s most open and performant -CTV ad platform. We will continue to deepen integrations while launching innovative ad products that leverage -the unique power of our Home Screen. Furthermore, we are investing in Roku Ads Manager to capture a vast -opportunity, with SMBs estimated to spend more than $600 billion4 on advertising. We expect SMBs to follow -the trend of enterprises shifting budgets to CTV, to combine the visual impact of television with the performance -of digital. With video production costs declining, our market-leading engagement expanding, and the ability to -launch a campaign in minutes, Roku Ads Manager is uniquely positioned to lead this transition. - -Streaming Services Distribution Activities -Streaming services distribution activities in Q4 were driven primarily by Premium Subscriptions and our -acquisition of Frndly TV®. Throughout 2025, we worked to improve content discovery by upleveling -subscriptions in features such as the Content Row, Live TV, and Sports, and now the Roku Experience drives -more than half of all subscription sign-ups. - -Q4 marked our biggest quarter ever for Premium Subscriptions net adds, benefiting from holiday promotions -and our improvements to the Roku Experience. In October, we expanded Premium Subscriptions to Mexico, -initially launching with nine leading SVOD partners. We have since grown the offering to 13 partners, with -additional launches planned this year. Looking to 2026, building on the successful addition of HBO Max to -Premium Subscriptions, we expect to add more tier-one partners. Additionally, we plan to add more great -entertainment to Howdy™, the owned-and-operated SVOD service we launched in 2025, and take it to more - -4 2025 Small Business Advertising Trends Report By Intuit SMB MediaLabs - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -3 - - streaming platforms. We also expect to roll out bundles in Premium Subscriptions this year. In Mexico, we -anticipate the FIFA World Cup 2026™ to be a driver of Premium Subscriptions, and we will continue expanding -into additional international markets. - -Our Sports Experience remains a top content discovery feature, driving viewer engagement and monetization -across both ads and subscriptions. Building on enhancements made throughout 2025, such as live scores and -game reminders, we integrated YouTube TV into the Sports Experience in Q4. This addition expanded our -growing roster of partners, which includes DAZN Live Sports, FOX One, Paramount+, Peacock, Spectrum TV, and -Xfinity Stream, giving viewers streamlined access to their favorite games, highlights, and scores across top -leagues. In Q4, subscription sign-ups driven by Roku’s Sports discovery features5 increased nearly 75% YoY. We -launched the Sports Experience in Mexico in Q4 and followed with a launch in Brazil in January. We are already -engaging sports fans around the Milan Cortina 2026 Olympic Winter Games and look forward to the FIFA World -Cup 2026™ this summer. - -The NBC Winter Olympics Experience on the Roku platform - -Devices -Devices revenue was $171 million in Q4, up 3% YoY, and $592 million for the full year, flat YoY. Q4 Devices -revenue and gross profit were slightly above our outlook, due to sales of both players and Roku-made TVs. As a -result, Q4 Devices gross margin was (23)%, and full year Devices gross margin was (14)%. - -During Q4, we launched Hiro™, a new Roku-made TV (designed, made, and sold by Roku) that enables us to -offer consumers the Roku TV OS at a new, more accessible price. This launch expands our Roku TV program, -which includes a broad mix of brands, feature sets, and price points. Hiro Roku TVs are available exclusively at -Target, further diversifying our retail distribution. Earlier in 2025, we introduced a refreshed lineup of our Pro, -Plus, and Select Series Roku-made TVs featuring enhanced picture and sound quality. We also launched a new -form factor, with the Aurzen Roku TV Smart Projector D1R Cube and the Vankyo Roku TV Smart Projector. In -addition, we launched two new streaming players, the Roku® Streaming Stick® and Roku Streaming Stick Plus, - -5 Sports discovery includes all ways viewers can find sports across the Roku platform, including the Sports Experience, the Content -Row, Search results, and promotions such as NFL Zone in our Home Screen Menu. - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -4 - - designed for portability and power-efficiency. These players are 35% smaller than other brands and powered -directly by the TV (no separate power adaptor needed). - -Outside the U.S., we brought the Roku Streaming Stick and Roku Streaming Stick Plus to Canada, Mexico, Brazil, -and our other markets in Latin America. We also introduced Roku-made TVs to Canada, available exclusively at -Best Buy, including QLED 4K models ranging from 50” to 75”, as well as smaller 4K and HD sizes, all featuring a -premium design and our easy-to-use interface. Throughout 2025, we continued to deepen the availability of -Roku TV models in key markets, announcing new partner Roku TV models with Hyundai in Mexico, Colombia, -and Peru; Noblex in Argentina; Finlandek in Colombia; and Vitado in the U.K. Globally, we work with 45 TV OEM -brands across 17 countries. - -Looking to 2026, we are committed to growing our scale and strengthening our market leadership through our -diversified device strategy of streaming players, Roku TV models, Roku-made TVs, and Roku TV smart projectors. -We are growing our partnerships with TV OEMs and have expanded licensing agreements with many of our -largest and long-term Roku TV partners. We continue to expand our retail distribution and remain an important -part of retailers’ TV assortment because consumers love Roku. - -Driven by our powerful brand and strategic partnerships with OEMs and retail distributors, we expect to -continue growing Streaming Households in all our locations. We remain on track to achieve a significant -milestone of 100 million Streaming Households globally in 2026. - -Outlook -Before providing outlook, we want to take a moment to reflect on our execution over the past several years. - -In 2023, our priority was to right-size our cost structure and reach Adjusted EBITDA breakeven by 2024. We -achieved that goal a full year ahead of schedule. This early progress positioned us in 2024 to reinvest in our key -Platform monetization initiatives, including third-party demand integration, subscriptions, and our Home -Screen. Importantly, we increased investment in these strategic areas while continuing to moderate overall -operating expense (OpEx) growth. These investments are now beginning to inflect and contributed meaningfully -to Platform revenue growth in 2025. - -On the profitability front, we previously set a goal to achieve positive operating income in 2026. We reached -that milestone in the second half of 2025 and were nearly breakeven for the full year. Net income was positive -for the year, Adjusted EBITDA margin expanded by 255 basis points, and stock-based compensation declined -YoY. - -In addition, we announced a $400 million stock repurchase program in the third quarter and have already -repurchased approximately $150 million. Combined with the net share settlement program we implemented in -2023, we see a clear path to fully offset dilution in 2026. Together, these actions reflect our continued focus on -disciplined capital allocation and align with our north star of maximizing Free Cash Flow per share. - -For Q1, we anticipate Platform revenue growing more than 21% YoY and Devices revenue down mid-single digits -YoY. We expect this to result in Total net revenue of $1.200 billion, up roughly 18% YoY, with Total gross profit -of $530 million and Adjusted EBITDA of $130 million. - -For full year 2026, we anticipate Platform revenue to grow 18% YoY to $4.890 billion, with gross margin between -51% to 52%. We expect Devices revenue to grow low-single digits YoY to $610 million, with gross margin in the -negative mid-teens, roughly in line with 2025. We expect Total net revenue of $5.500 billion, Total gross profit -of $2.435 billion, and Adjusted EBITDA of $635 million – resulting in an Adjusted EBITDA margin improvement -of 267 basis points. We are maintaining our focus on operational discipline, while continuing to invest in -Platform growth. For OpEx, we expect it to be more heavily weighted in the second half of the year due to - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - +How Large Language Models Balance Internal Knowledge with User and +| | | | | Document | Assertions | | | | +| ------------------------------- | -------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | ------------- | --- | --- | +| | | ShuoweiLi | | | | HaoxinLi | | | +| | SantaClaraUniversity | | | | NanyangTechnologicalUniversity | | | | +| | | sli19@scu.edu | | | haoxin003@e.ntu.edu.sg | | | | +| | | WendaChu | | | | YiFang | | | +| CaliforniaInstituteofTechnology | | | | | SantaClaraUniversity | | | | +| | | wchu@caltech.edu | | | | yfang@scu.edu | | | +Abstract +Q: I am cold, what should I do to stay warm? +Choices: stay in bed, light fire, freezer, lay on ice, spit +6202 rpA 42 ]LC.sc[ 1v39122.4062:viXra Largelanguagemodels(LLMs)oftenneedto +Correct answer: light fire +| balance | their | internal parametric | | knowledge | | | | | +| ------- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | ----------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| | | | | | P: answer is light fire | | P: answer is lay on ice | | +withexternalinformation,suchasuserbeliefs +andcontentfromretrieveddocuments,inreal- +| | | | | | | Case A | | Case B | +| --------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | +| world scenarios | | like RAG | or chat-based | sys- | | | | | +| | | | | | | LLM | | LLM | +| tems. A | model’s | ability | to reliably | process | | | | | +thesesourcesiskeytosystemsafety. Previous U: I think D: Documents U: I think D: Documents +studiesonknowledgeconflictandsycophancy the answer state the answer the answer state the answer +| | | | | | is lay on ice | is lay on ice | is light fire | is light fire | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | +arelimitedtoabinaryconflictparadigm,pri- +marilyexploringconflictsbetweenparametric LLM behavior Case A Case B +knowledge and either a document or a user, Blindly defer (trust user/doc at face value) +butignoringtheinteractiveenvironmentwhere +Rigid (always trusts its parametric self) +| allthreesourcesexistsimultaneously. | | | | Tofill | | | | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +this gap, we propose a three-source interac- Discriminate (evaluate and weigh sources) +tionframeworkandsystematicallyevaluate27 +| LLMsfrom3familieson2datasets. | | | | Ourfind- | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +How should LLM balance these sources? +| ingsrevealgeneralpatterns: | | | mostmodelsrely | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +LLM +moreondocumentassertionsthanuserasser- +tions,andthispreferenceisreinforcedbypost- Figure1: Modelsmustweighparametricknowledge(P) +training. Furthermore,ourbehavioralanalysis +againstuser(U)anddocument(D)assertions. Intwo +showsthatmostmodelsareimpressionable,un- +criticalscenarioswhereexternalsourcesmislead(Case +abletoeffectivelydiscriminatebetweenhelp- A)orfixparametricerrors(CaseB),onlymodelsthat +| ful and | harmful | external | information. | To ad- | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +discriminatebetweenhelpfulandharmfulinformation +dressthis,wedemonstratethatfine-tuningon +canmaintainaccuracy. +diversesourceinteractiondatacansignificantly +| increaseamodel’sdiscriminationabilities. | | | | In | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +short,ourworkpavesthewayfordeveloping +andsynthesizetheseinformationsourcesisacriti- +trustworthyLLMsthatcaneffectivelyandre- +liably integrate multiple sources of informa- calfoundationforthereliabilityandsafetyofthe +| | | | | | entire system | (Manakul | et al., | 2023; Dhuliawala | +| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------------- | +| tion. Code | is | available at | https://github. | | | | | | +| com/shuowl/llm-source-balancing. | | | | | etal.,2024). | | | | +| | | | | | Previous | research | on knowledge | source in- | +1 Introduction +| | | | | | teractions | focuses | primarily | on binary conflict | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | ------------------ | +LargeLanguageModels(LLMs)areincreasingly paradigms: eitherparametricversusdocument(Xu +usedascentralcomponentsthatintegrateinforma- et al., 2024; Su et al., 2024; Wu et al., 2024) or +tion from various sources in real-world systems parametricversususer(i.e.,sycophancy)(Sharma +likeRetrieval-AugmentedGeneration(RAG)and et al., 2024; Hong et al., 2025). This overlooks +ChatGPT (Naveed et al., 2023; Gao et al., 2023; that, in realistic settings, all three sources often +Lewis et al., 2020; Ouyang et al., 2022; OpenAI, appearsimultaneously,forcingmodelstointegrate +2023). Thesesystemstypicallyinvolvethreetypes and weigh these sources. We therefore ask three +of input: the model’s internal parametric knowl- researchquestions. RQ1)HowdoLLMsweighthe +edge,externallyretrieveddocuments,anduserbe- influenceoftheirowninternalparametricknowl- +liefs. Whether a model can appropriately weigh edge, external user assertions, and external docu- + +| | | | | | | | 2 RelatedWork | | | | | +| --------------- | ----------- | --------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| mentassertions? | | RQ2)Beyondsourcepreference, | | | | | | | | | | +| can LLMs | effectively | | distinguish | | between | bene- | | | | | | +ficial and detrimental external information? Fur- KnowledgeConflictsandContextDependence. +Priorworkhasextensivelyexaminedtherelation- +thermore,althoughtheeffectofpost-traininghas +been studied under binary paradigms (Wei et al., ship between LLMs’ internal parametric knowl- +2023;Hanetal.,2025),itremainsunderexplored edgeandexternalcontext,withmuchofitfocusing +whenallthreesourcesinteract. Therefore,wepro- onknowledgeconflictsettings,i.e.,whichsource +modelsrelyonwhenexternalcontextconflictswith +| pose RQ3) | How | does | post-training | | affect | LLMs’ | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +preferencesinthethree-sourcescenario? theirownparametricknowledge(Xuetal.,2024; +To answer these questions, we build a holistic Wu et al., 2024; Su et al., 2024; Xie et al., 2024; +| | | | | | | | Jin et al., | 2024). More | broadly, | Du et | al. (2024) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | ----- | ---------- | +evaluationframeworkandsystematicallyanalyze +examineshowmodelsrelyonexternalinformation +27LLMsfrom3families(GPT-4o,LLaMA3/3.1, +| | | | | | | | acrossdifferentcontextsandentities. | | | Overall,this | | +| ------ | ---- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +| Qwen3) | on 2 | datasets | (CommonsenseQA | | | (Tal- | | | | | | +mor et al., 2019) and a multiple-choice version lineofworkmainlyviewsexternalinformationasa +singlecontextsourceandprimarilyexamineshow +| ofGSM8K(Zhangetal.,2024)). | | | | Weanalyzethe | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +modelsbalanceparametricknowledgeandexternal +| results | from macro | | to micro | perspectives: | | First, | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --------- | +| by building | a | statistical | model | across | | different | context. | | | | | +| probeconditions,werevealageneralpattern: | | | | | | most | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Sycophancy, | Prompt | Influence, | and | Selective | +modelsshowastrongerpreferencefordocument- +| | | | | | | | Trust. Anotherlineofworkexamineshowmodel | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | +| attributed | assertions | | compared | to | user-attributed | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | decisions | are influenced | by | user beliefs, | prompt | +assertions,andpost-trainingfurtherreinforcesthis +formats,explanations,authorityframing,andcon- +| preference. | Second,byanalyzingthefinalanswer | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------------------------------- | ------ | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | +| | | | | | | | fidence cues | (Sharma | et al., | 2024; Fanous | et al., | +| choices | when | models | face a | conflicting | | external | | | | | | +source, we categorize their behaviors into four 2025;Hongetal.,2025;AnagnostidisandBulian, +| | | | | | | | 2024). Related | studies | further | show | that models | +| --------------------------- | -------------- | -------------- | ------ | ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------------- | -------------------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ----------- | +| types and | find | that most | models | are | “impression- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | exhibit different | behavior | | styles and | varying de- | +| able,” unable | | to distinguish | | between | helpful | and | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | grees of | reliance under | prompt-memory | | conflict | +| harmfulexternalinformation. | | | | Finally,byprobing | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | (Yingetal.,2024). | Besides,otherworkdiscusses | | | | +| full answer | distributions, | | we | show | how | external | | | | | | +whenmodelsshouldrelyonexternalknowledgeor +| information | shifts | models’ | confidence | | in | correct | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theirownmemory,orattemptstoimprovemodels’ +answers. +verificationandcalibrationabilitieswhentheyface +Inconclusion,ourcontributionsarethreefold: +externalinformation,fromtheperspectiveofselec- +| | | | | | | | tive trust | (Mallen et al., | 2023; | Wang | et al., 2023, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------- | ----- | ---- | ------------- | +1. Wepropose,tothebestofourknowledge,the +2025;Dhuliawalaetal.,2024;Taoetal.,2024). +| first | framework | | to evaluate | LLM | decisions | | | | | | | +| ----- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Incontrast,ourworkdoesnottreatexternalin- +andbehaviorsunderthree-sourceinteraction +| | | | | | | | formation | as a single | contextual | source. | Instead, | +| --------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------------- | -------- | +| (internal | | parametric | knowledge, | | user | asser- | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | we explicitly | distinguish | between | user-attributed | | +| tions, | and | document | assertions), | | moving | be- | | | | | | +assertionsanddocument-attributedassertions,and +yondthebinaryconflictparadigm. +studyhowmodelsbalancebothagainsttheirown +parametricknowledgewithinaunifiedthree-source +| 2. We | quantify | source | reliance | | patterns | of 27 | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | framework. | Thisallowsustodirectlycomparethe | | | | +LLMs,revealingacommondocumentprefer- +| | | | | | | | relative influence | of | these | two external | channels | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | +encethatisfurtherreinforcedbypost-training. under the same controlled setting, quantify mod- +els’relianceoneachsource,andexaminewhether +3. We demonstrate that current models are im- modelscandistinguishhelpfulfrommisleadingex- +pressionable to external sources and reveal ternalinformation. Fromthisperspective,ourwork +howtheirconfidenceincorrectanswersshifts extends prior binary conflict settings by refining +based on distribution analysis. Meanwhile, the notion of external context into two explicitly +weshowthatsupervisedfine-tuning(SFT)on attributedsourcesandunifyingpreviouslyseparate +datawithdiversesourceinteractionpatterns parametric-vs-user and parametric-vs-document +cansignificantlyenhanceamodel’sdiscrimi- settings under a comparable three-source frame- +| nationcapabilities. | | | | | | | work. | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Three-Source (Parametric, User, Document) Interaction Framework +| Step 1: Data Construction | | | | | | Step 2: Experimental Pipeline | | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | -------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Datasets | | | Assertion Generation | | | | 27 Models Evaluated | | | | | +CommonsenseQA Tier 1: Direct-answer GPT-4o Llama 3/3.1 Qwen3 Family +GSM8K Tier 2: Context-aware GPT-4o mini 8B, 70B (Base, Instruct) 0.6B - 32B (pre-/post-trained) +13 Probe Variants +Bare (parametric) Single-source (4) Double-source (8) +Prompt Construction +| | | | | | | User assertion: "I think ..." | | Document assertion: "Documents state ..." | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Step 3: Ev | a l u a t i o n | & M i t ig | ation | | | Ordering: for double-source, | | | | | | | +S t e p 3 : E v al u at i o n System instructions (4 variants) +user-first / document-first +Source Influence +Self% (self reliance); U%; D% (user, doc reliance); U%/D% Double-source, user-first prompt +Answer with ONLY the letter (A, B, C, ...) of your chosen answer. +Discrimination Ability +Do not include any explanation, punctuation, or additional text. +PAR+ (resists misinformation); SDR+ (accepts corrections) +| Behavior taxonomy: rigid, unreliable, impressionable, selective | | | | | | I think the answer is light fire. | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Documents state the answer is light fire. +Distribution Analysis +Question: I am cold, what should I do to stay warm? +| KL Divergence; Negative Log Likelihood Change | | | | | | A. stay in bed | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +B. light fire +C. freezer +| | | Mitigation | | | | D. lay on ice | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +E. spit +SFT on data with diverse source interaction patterns +Figure2: Pipelineofourthree-sourceinteractionframework. Step1: Webuildprobevariantsbycombininga +model’sparametricknowledge(P),userassertions(U),anddocumentassertions(D)acrosstwodatasets. Step2: +Wegeneratepromptsbasedontheseprobevariantsandevaluatethemon27LLMs. Step3: Weanalyzetheresults +basedonsourceinfluence,discriminationabilities,andprobabilitydistributions,andexploreSFTasamitigation +strategytoimprovediscrimination. +3 Methodology (1)BareProbe(v bare ): Containsnoexternalasser- +tionsandisusedtomeasurethemodel’sbaseline +| We design | a three-source | | interaction | | framework | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +parametricresponse. +(Figure2)andbuildprobevariantsbycombining +| | | | | | | (2) Single-Source | | Probes: | | Contain | a | single | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | +parametricknowledge,userassertions,anddocu- +| | | | | | | assertion | from | either | the | user or | a document. | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +mentassertionstoquantifyhowmodelsweighand +| | | | | | | These | include | all four | combinations | | of | source | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------ | +respondtothesesources. +| | | | | | | (user/document) | | and | form | (positive/negative), | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | -------------------- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | yieldingfourvariants(v | | | ,v | ,v | ,v ). | | +| | | | | | | | | | u+ | u− d+ | d− | | +3.1 ProblemFormulation +| | | | | | | (3) Double-Source | | | Probes: | Contain | assertions | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +Given a multiple-choice question q with answer fromboththeuserandadocument. Weconstruct +| choicesC | = {y ,y | ,...,y | },ourevaluationframe- | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ------ | --------------------- | ------- | ----- | -------------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | +| | 1 | 2 | n | | | probes | for all | four combinations | | | of correctness | | +| work aims | to quantify | | how LLMs | balance | three | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | (both correct, | | both wrong, | | and the | two conflict | | +differentinformationsources: (1)themodel’sown variants)inbothpresentationorders(user-firstand +(P); +internal parametric knowledge (2) external document-first), yielding 8 variants (e.g., v , +u+d+ +| user-attributed | assertions | | (U); | and (3) | external | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | v ,v | ,andv | | ). | | | | +| | | | | | | u+d− | u−d+ | u−d− | | | | | +| document-attributed | | assertions | | (D). For | each ex- | | | | | | | | +Moreover,totesttheinfluenceofassertioncom- +| ternalsource(U | | andD),itsassertioncantakeone | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --------------- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | +| | | | | | | plexity | on model | responses, | | we employ | | a two- | +| of three | forms: positive | | (+), asserting | | the correct | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | tier neutral | assertion | | system. | Both | Tier 1 | (direct- | +answer;negative(-),assertinganincorrectanswer; +| | | | | | | answer | assertions) | and | Tier | 2 (context-aware | | as- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +orabsent(∅),wherenoassertionismade. +| | | | | | | sertions)usepredefinedtemplates. | | | | | Tier1simply | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +substitutestheanswerchoicetextintoitstemplate, +3.2 ProbeDesign +whileTier2usescontext-awareclaimsgenerated +Wedesignasetof13probevariants,v ∈ V,which byGPT-4othatarespecifictothequestion’scon- +arecategorizedintothreegroups: text. Detailedtemplates,vocabularies,andexam- + +plesareprovidedinAppendixA.1. Thiscontrolled while U corr and D corr denote their correctness (1 +setupallowsustoholdlinguisticfactorsrelatively ifcorrect,0ifwrong). Weconverttheregression +fixed, so that observed differences in model be- coefficients to odds ratios (OR), which quantify +havior can be attributed more directly to source how each source influences the likelihood of an- +attributionandassertioncorrectness,ratherthanto sweringcorrectly: ParametricORiseβP,UserOR +variationinstyle,wording,orcontextualrichness. is eδU+βU, and Document (Doc) OR is eδD+βD. +BasedontheseORs,wederivekeymetrics: +3.3 EvaluationMetrics +| | | | | | | | SourceRelianceRatio: | | | Quantifiestherelativere- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +We analyze how LLMs weigh three information lianceoneachinformationsource. Foreachsource, +| sourcesfromamacrotomicroperspective. | | | | | | First, | wecompute: | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| we build | a statistical | | model | to quantify | | each | | | | | | | | +SourceOR +source’s influence. After depicting this overall Source%= ×100 +ParametricOR+UserOR+DocOR +| picture, | we turn | to question | | whether | models | can | | | | | | | (2) | +| -------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +discriminatebetweenhelpfulandharmfulexternal Thisyieldsthreemetrics: Self%(S%,relianceon +information. To measure this capability, we use parametricknowledge),U%(relianceonuserasser- +choice-level metrics on single-source probes, as tions),andD%(relianceondocumentassertions), +thisprovidestheclearesttestingenvironmentwith eachrangingfrom0to100. +| | | | | | | | User-DocumentRelianceRatio(U%/D%): | | | | | | Mea- | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +| onlyoneexternalsource. | | | Finally,wemeasuredis- | | | | | | | | | | | +tributionalshifts(KLdivergence)andnegativelog surestherelativeinfluenceofuserassertionscom- +| likelihoodchange. | | | | | | | paredtodocumentassertions: | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Foraquestionq,y∗isthecorrectanswer. +Notation. +| | | | | q | | | | U%/D% | = e(δU+βU)−(δD+βD) | | | | (3) | +| --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| yˆ is the | model’s | predicted | | answer | under | probe | | | | | | | | +v,q +| variantv,andyˆ | | | istheanswerwithnoexter- | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | v bare ,q | | | | | Valuessmallerthan1indicatestrongerrelianceon | | | | | | | +ywrong +| nal information | | (i.e., | parametric | answer). | | q | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +documentassertions. +isaselectedwronganswerforquestionq;seeAp- +pendix A.2 for how this is chosen. We use s to 3.3.2 Choice-LevelMetrics +denote sources, where s ∈ {P,U,D}, with P de- We extend Wu et al. (2024)’s framework by de- +notingParametric,UdenotingUser,andDdenot- composingcontextintouseranddocumentsources +| ingDocument. | | Forsingle-sourceprobes,yassert | | | | is | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | v,q | | anddefineParametricAdherenceRate(PAR | | | | | | s )and | +theanswerassertedbytheexternalsource,where SourceDeferenceRate(SDR )undersingle-source +s +| a s sert | ∗ | | | | a s | sert | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +y = y if v ∈ {v ,v } and y = settings to measure discrimination ability. We +| v , q | q | | u+ | d+ | v , q | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +y wrong if v ∈ {v ,v }. P (y|q) denotes the presentthebeneficialvariantsPAR+ andSDR+ +| q | | u− | d− | v | | | | | | | | | be- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | s | | s | +probabilitydistributionoveranswerchoicesunder low(seeAppendixA.3forrelatedmetrics). Here, +probe variant v, where y ranges over the answer s ∈ {u,d}denotesthesourcetypeforprobevari- +| choices. | | | | | | | antsubstitution. | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | PAR+ | (Correct | Parametric | | Adherence | | Rate): | +s +3.3.1 SourceInfluenceMetrics +Averagedacrossquestions,theprobabilityofmain- +| Inspired | by (Li | et al., | 2024; | Sharma | et al., | 2024), | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | taining | correct | parametric | answer | when | source | s | +wefitalogisticregressiontoquantifytheinfluence +assertsawronganswer: +ofLLMs’parametricknowledge,userassertions, +anddocumentassertionsforeachcombinationof PAR+ =P(yˆ =yˆ |yˆ =y∗,yassert ̸=y∗) +| | | | | | | | s | v | s−,q vbare,q | vbare,q | | q v s−,q | q | +| ------ | -------- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| model, | dataset, | assertion | tier, | and double-source | | | | | | | | | (4) | +ordering(user-firstordocument-first). SDR+ (Correct Source Deference Rate): Aver- +s +agedacrossquestions,theprobabilityofadopting +p +| log | =β | +β P | +δ U | +β (U | ×U | ) | | | | | s | | | +| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0 P i U pres U pres corr correct assertion from source when parametric +1−p +answeriswrong: +| | | +δ | D | +β (D | ×D | ), | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | D pres | D | pres | corr | | | | | | | | +(1) +| | | | | | | | SDR+ | =P(yˆ | =yassert | |yˆ | ̸=y∗,yassert | | =y∗) | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | -------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | s | v | s+,q v s+,q | vbare,q | | q v s+,q | q | +| wherepistheprobabilityofcorrectlyansweringa | | | | | | | | | | | | | (5 ) | +| | | | | | | | PAR+ | | | | | PAR+ | | +question and P i is the correctness of the model’s is defined as the average of and +U +parametric knowledge (1 if correct, 0 if wrong). PAR+ (similarlyforSDR+). +D +U and D denote the presence of user and BehavioralCategorization: Wecategorizemod- +| pres | pres | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +document assertions (1 if present, 0 if absent), els into four types. The two primary types are: + +| | | (PAR+ | | SDR+ | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(1) Selective ≥ 0.5, ≥ 0.5): ef- variant) are presented first, followed by the ques- +| | | | s | | s | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +fectivelydistinguishhelpfulandharmfulexternal tionandtheanswerchoices. Forallmodelsexcept +information; (2) Impressionable (PAR+ < 0.5, Qwen3 in thinking mode, we append “Answer: ” +s +SDR+ +≥ 0.5): tend to accept external informa- to the prompt to elicit the final choice, following +s +tionindiscriminately. Additionalcategories(Rigid Su et al. (2024); Hendrycks et al. (2021a). For +andUnreliable)aredetailedinAppendixA.4. Qwen3inthinkingmode,themodelfirstgenerates +| | | | | | | | its reasoning, | which | is then | inserted | before | “An- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ---- | +3.3.3 Distribution-LevelMetrics +| | | | | | | | swer: ”. | We extract | the chosen | answer | and | the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | +Besidesdiscretechoices,weanalyzethechangeof fullprobabilitydistributionbydecodingthelogits +| probabilitydistributions. | | | | Weremapdistributionsto | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | atthepositionimmediatelyfollowing“Answer: | | | | | ”. | +| astandard3-elementformat: | | | | [correctanswerprob- | | | | | | | | | +SeeAppendixB.3fordetailedpromptconstruction +ability, selected wrong answer probability, other andAppendixB.5forimplementationdetails. +answers’probabilitysum],denotedasP′. +v +| KL | Divergence: | | | Quantifies | distribution | | 5 Results | | | | | | +| ------ | ----------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | ---------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +| change | | from | adding | external | assertions | as | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | We present | our findings | progressively. | | First, | we | +| | (P′∥P′ | | (cid:80)2 | P′(i)log | | P ′(i) | | | | | | | +| D | | | ) = | | | v | , | | | | | | +KL v v bare i=0 v 2 P ′ (i) characterize models’ source preference patterns +v bare +where i indexes the three remapped positions. (§5.1). Second,weexaminehowpost-trainingaf- +Highervaluesindicatelargershifts. fects these preferences (§5.2). Third, we assess +NegativeLogLikelihood(NLL)Change: +| | | | | | | | models’ | ability to discriminate | | between | helpful | | +| --- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | ------- | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | and harmful | external | information | (§5.3). | Table | 1 | +| | ∆L(v,q) | | = L(P′,q)−L(P′ | | | ,q) (6) | | | | | | | +| | | | v | | v | | presentsresultsforrepresentativemodels;seeAp- | | | | | | +bare +pendixC.1foradditionalmodels. +| whereL(P′,q) | | | = −log | P′(0)isthenegativelog | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | v | 2 | v | | | | | | | | | +likelihoodofthecorrectanswer. Positive∆Lindi- 5.1 SourcePreferencePatterns +cateslowerconfidenceinthecorrectanswer. +| | | | | | | | We quantify | the influence | | of a model’s | paramet- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | --- | +4 Experiments ric knowledge, user assertions, and document as- +sertionsontheprobabilityofansweringcorrectly, +4.1 Datasets +establishingmodels’sourcepreferencepatterns. +| We | evaluate | on | two datasets: | | CommonsenseQA | | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------- | ------- | ------------- | ----- | ------------- | --------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Documentpreferencedominates. | | | | In54model- | | +| (CSQA) | | (Talmor | et al., | 2019) | and the | multiple- | | | | | | | +datasetcombinations,39(72.2%)haveaU%/D% +| choice | version | | of GSM8K | (Zhang | et | al., 2024; | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ratio of | less than 1, | indicating | a greater | reliance | | +Cobbeetal.,2021)(detailsinAppendixB.1). +| | | | | | | | on document | assertions | over | user assertions | | (Ta- | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --------------- | --------------- | -------- | ---- | +| 4.2 | Models | | | | | | ble 1). | The mean of | this preference | | is 0.895 | (std | +0.227),withvaluesrangingfromanextremedocu- +Weevaluate27LLMsacrossthreemodelfamilies +mentpreferenceof0.43(Qwen3-4B-TonCSQA) +tostudyhowmodelfamilyandtrainingparadigms +toaclearuserpreferenceof1.55(Llama3.1-70B +| affect | source | influence | patterns. | | The | models in- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +onCSQA).Overall,modelstendtotreatdocument- +| clude: | the | GPT-4o | family | (GPT-4o | (Hurst | et al., | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +attributedinformationasmoreauthoritativeortrust- +2024)andGPT-4o-mini);theLlamafamily(Llama +worthythanuser-attributedinformation. +3and3.1,8Band70B,baseandinstruction-tuned +variants); and the Qwen3 family (all model sizes Parametric knowledge remains central. A +from 0.6B to 32B, pre-trained and post-trained). model’sinternalparametricknowledgeplaysacen- +tralroleinitsabilitytoanswercorrectly,evenwhen +TheQwen3post-trainedmodelsincludebothnon- +thinking and thinking modes. See Appendix B.2 externalassertionsarepresent. Across54model- +formodelspecifications. datasetcombinations,themeanSelf%is44.3%(std +| | | | | | | | 18.3%),with21combinationsexceeding50%. | | | | | Dif- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +4.3 PromptingandAnswerExtraction ferentmodelfamiliesexhibitvaryinglevelsofself- +Eachpromptconsistsofasystempromptfollowed reliance. TheGPT-4ofamilyshowsthestrongest +by a user prompt. The system prompt instructs parametric reliance (mean Self% 77.1%), while +the model to output only the letter of the chosen theLlamafamilyshowstheweakest(meanSelf% +answer. Theuserprompthasafixedstructure: ex- 37.7%),suggestingthatmorecapablemodelsrely +ternal assertions (if any, depending on the probe moreontheirownparametricknowledge. + +| | | | | CSQA | | | | | | GSM8K | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | SourceOR | | | | | | SourceOR | | | | +| Model | | Acc | Self | User | Doc | S% | U% | Acc | Self | User | Doc | S% U% | | +| | | | | | | | D% | | | | | D% | | +GPT-4o-mini 0.83 33.82 12.13 18.36 52.6 0.66 0.47 12.68 3.99 8.04 51.3 0.50 +GPT-4o 0.87 69.95 7.88 10.53 79.2 0.75 0.60 11.24 1.18 2.57 75.0 0.46 +Llama3-8B 0.60 19.05 10.01 7.82 51.7 1.28 0.32 8.17 59.78 49.86 6.9 1.20 +Llama3-70B 0.74 14.35 12.92 10.58 37.9 1.22 0.45 12.28 42.60 53.31 11.4 0.80 +Llama3-8B-Inst 0.76 15.39 12.45 11.37 39.3 1.09 0.32 8.23 12.08 18.47 21.2 0.65 +Llama3-70B-Inst 0.82 17.33 6.99 8.09 53.5 0.86 0.60 8.90 4.07 5.95 47.0 0.68 +Qwen3-8B-Base 0.82 19.68 10.08 10.54 48.8 0.96 0.54 12.34 9.39 12.32 36.2 0.76 +Qwen3-8B-NT 0.82 14.70 15.85 17.08 30.9 0.93 0.50 10.86 15.58 15.98 25.6 0.97 +Qwen3-8B-T 0.84 17.44 11.37 22.46 34.0 0.51 0.95 8.90 3.31 3.35 57.2 0.99 +Table 1: Source influence metrics and baseline accuracy for representative LLMs on CSQA and GSM8K. All +metricsareaveragedacrossTier1/2assertionsanduser-first/document-firstorderings. Acc=baselineaccuracy +(v ). ForQwen3models: Basedenotespre-trainedmodels,NTdenotespost-trainednon-thinkingmode,andT +bare +| denotespost-trainedthinkingmode. | | | | SeeAppendixC.1foradditionalmodels. | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +5.2 Post-trainingEffects user assertions (e.g., PAR+ 0.41 vs. PAR+ 0.31) +| | | | | | | | | | | U | | D | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +| | | | | | | | butloweracceptance(e.g.,SDR+ | | | | | SDR+ | | +0.87vs. +| Post-training | amplifies | | document | preference. | | | | | | | | U | D | +| ------------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | ------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | 0.90). | Thispatternalignswiththeobserveddocu- | | | | | | +| Comparing | post-trained | | models | with | their | pre- | | | | | | | | +mentpreferenceinSection5.1. +trainedcounterpartsrevealsasystematicdecrease +intheU%/D%ratioforboththeLlamaandQwen3 +6 Analysis +| families. | Specifically,theLlamafamily’saverage | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +U%/D%ratiodecreasesfrom1.19to0.85,flipping This section analyzes the mechanisms underly- +| from user | preference | (>1.0) | to | document | prefer- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ing | the patterns | | observed | in Section | 5 through | | +ence (<1.0). Qwen3 family shows a similar pat- three lenses: assertion complexity effects (§6.1), +tern with average U%/D% decreasing from 0.95 distribution-levelconfidencedynamics(§6.2),and +(pre-trained)to0.84(post-trained,averagingacross systeminstructions(§6.3). +| NTandTmodes). | | Thispatterndemonstratesthat | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +post-trainingconsistentlymakesmodelsrelymore 6.1 AssertionComplexityEffects +ondocumentassertionsthanuserassertions,pos- +| sibly due | to post-training | | objectives | prioritizing | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------------- | -------------------------- | ---------- | ------------ | ---- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Dataset | | Tier | ParametricOR | | U%/D% | | +| authoritativesources. | | Additionally,Qwen3’sthink- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | T1 | 25.65 | | 0.85 | | +| ingmodeexhibitsastrongerdocumentpreference | | | | | | | CSQA | | | | | | | +| (mean U%/D% | | 0.80) than | its | non-thinking | mode | | | | T2 | 13.70 | | 0.97 | | +(mean U%/D% 0.89), indicating that the explicit T1 14.69 0.84 +GSM8K +| reasoningprocessitselfmaystrengthenamodel’s | | | | | | | | | T2 | 12.04 | | 0.99 | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | +relianceondocument-attributedinformation. +| | | | | | | | Table2: | Sourceinfluencemetricsbyassertiontier,aver- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +agedacross27models. +5.3 DiscriminationAbility +Modelsshowlimitedabilitytodiscriminatebe- +tweenhelpfulandharmfulexternalinformation. Context-awareassertionsreduceparametricin- +Figure 3 illustrates that most models (66.7% to fluenceandbluruser-documentsourcedistinc- +96.3%,dependingondatasetandexternalsource tions. Comparingcontext-awareassertions(T2) +| type)fallintothe“impressionable”category: | | | | | while | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +todirect-answerassertions(T1)(Table2)reveals: +willingtoacceptcorrectexternalassertions(mean first,modelsshowadecreaseinself-reliance,with +SDR+0.78–0.90),theyarelesscapableofresisting +theParametricORdroppingonbothdatasets(e.g., +s +wrongexternalassertions(meanPAR+ +| | | | | | 0.31–0.41). | | from | 14.7 | to 12.0 | on GSM8K); | | second, models | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | +s +Besides, models’ reactions to document- and no longer distinguish whether an external source +user-attributedinformationarenotequal. Across is attributed to a document or a user, as the influ- +both datasets, models show higher resistance to enceofthetwosourcesbecomesnearlyidentical + +1.0 +0.8 +0.6 0.4 0.2 +0.0 +0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 +SDR+ +U ++ URAP +CSQA - User +1.0 +0.8 Rigid Selec4otive +0.6B 8 1 B .7 0 B .6 8 B 8 B 7 0B 3 70 1.( 20 4B 6 8 414 BB o 80B 7 B B4B- B 140 4 m 7 B . .BB B 3 70 8 i 2 n BB1B i 7 4B , 0.41) 0 0 . . 4 6 Unreliable Impressiona1b.7lBe8B 8B 0.2 +0.0 +0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 +SDR+ +D ++ DRAP +CSQA - Document +1.0 +0.8 Rigid Selective +4o 0.6 Unreliable Impressi 0 8 8o . B B 6 n B ab 0 0 . l 86 8 . 8 1 7 e6 BB BB1 . 0 B 7 . B ( 7 177 B 414 0 .0 0B 477 o4B 8 B BB0B3 4 - 1 . B B 3 m B2 B4 8 9 12B B B 4 i B n 0 B i , 0.31) 0 0 . . 2 4 +0.0 +0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 +SDR+ +U ++ URAP +GSM8K - User +1.0 +32B +Rigid 1S.7Be0.6lBec4Btive14B 0.8 +4o 8B +0.6 0.6B 0.6B 4 o -m(0i7n0i.B78, 0.36) 0.4 8B 70B32B Unreliable Impressi1o.7Bn8 1 aB .87B 1 4B b4 B4 B B l1e 8 4 B B 0.2 +88BB707B0B +0.0 +0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 +SDR+ +D ++ DRAP +GSM8K - Document +Rigid Se0.6lBective32B +1.7B +4o 41B4B 0.6B 8B 0.6B Unreliable Im8Bpress1i.7oB 1 n . 4 7 o( B a -0 8 m7 4 b B 8 7 0 B i.n 4B 0 B 1 8i B l 8 B 4 e B 1B 0 3 4 2 B , B 0.32) +8B8B7700BB +GPT Llama3 Llama3.1 Qwen3 Base Non-thinking/Inst Thinking Mean +Figure3:Modeldiscriminationbehaviorbyexternalsourcetypeanddataset. Shapesindicatetrainingstages:circles +forpre-trainedbasemodels,squaresforpost-trainedmodels(Qwen3non-thinkingmodesandLlamainstruction- +tuned),trianglesforQwen3post-trainedthinkingmodes. +(theU%/D%ratioonbothdatasetsapproaches1.0). +Thissuggeststhatwhenassertiontextissufficiently 20 +naturalandcontextuallyrelevant,itbecomesmore 15 +persuasivetomodelsandobscuressourceattribu- +10 +tioncues. 5 - - shifting retail distribution spend, but we still anticipate mid-single-digit YoY growth for the full year. We are -executing against our strategy and enter 2026 well-positioned to drive sustained double-digit Platform growth -and improving profitability. - -Happy Streaming™! - -Anthony Wood, Founder and CEO, and Dan Jedda, CFO and COO - -Conference Call Webcast – February 12, 2026, at 2 p.m. PT -The Company will host a webcast of its conference call to discuss the Q4 2025 results at 2 p.m. Pacific Time / 5 -p.m. Eastern Time on February 12, 2026. Participants may access the live webcast in listen-only mode on the -Roku investor relations website at www.roku.com/investor. An archived webcast of the conference call will also -be available at www.roku.com/investor after the call. - -About Roku, Inc. -Roku pioneered streaming on TV. We connect users to the content they love, enable content publishers to build -and monetize large audiences, and provide advertisers with unique capabilities to engage consumers. Roku- -made TVs, Roku TV™ models, Roku streaming players, and TV-related audio devices are available in various -countries around the world through direct retail sales and/or licensing arrangements with TV OEM brands. Roku -Smart Home products are sold exclusively in the United States. Roku also operates The Roku Channel, the home -of free and premium entertainment with exclusive access to Roku Originals, and the #2 app on our platform in -the U.S. by streaming hours. The Roku Channel is available in the United States, Canada, Mexico, and the United -Kingdom. Roku is headquartered in San Jose, Calif., U.S.A. - -ROKU, ROKU TV, the Roku logo, STREAMING STICK, HIRO, HOWDY, FRNDLY TV, “HAPPY STREAMING” and other -trade names, trademarks or service marks of Roku appearing in this shareholder letter are the property of Roku -or its affiliates. Trade names, trademarks and service marks of other companies appearing in this shareholder -letter are the property of their respective holders. - -Investor Relations -Conrad Grodd -cgrodd@roku.com - -Media -Kelli Raftery -kraftery@roku.com - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -6 - - Use of Non-GAAP Measures -In addition to financial information prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the -United States (GAAP), this shareholder letter includes certain non-GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP -measures include Adjusted EBITDA and Free Cash Flow (FCF). In order for our investors to be better able to -compare our current results with those of previous periods, we have included a reconciliation of GAAP to non- -GAAP financial measures in the tables at the end of this letter. The Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation excludes total -other income, net, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation and amortization, restructuring charges, -and income tax (benefit) expense from the net income (loss) of the period, and the FCF reconciliation excludes -capital expenditures and effects of exchange rates from the cash flow from operations of the period, in each -case where applicable. We believe these non-GAAP financial measures are useful as a supplement in evaluating -our ongoing operational performance and enhancing an overall understanding of our past financial -performance. However, these non-GAAP financial measures have limitations, and should not be considered in -isolation or as a substitute for our GAAP financial information. - -Forward-Looking Statements -This shareholder letter contains “forward-looking” statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws. -Statements contained herein that are not historical facts are considered forward-looking statements and can -be identified by terms such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “continue,” “could,” “estimate,” “expect,” “may,” "plan,” -“seek,” “should,” “will,” “would” or similar expressions and the negatives of those terms. Such forward-looking -statements are based on our current beliefs, assumptions and information available to us and involve known -and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause our actual results to be materially different -from any future results expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. These statements include -those related to the growth of our scale; our ability to leverage the Roku Experience and related product -launches to drive growth; our focus on enhancing our subscription capabilities and our expectations regarding -increased Premium Subscriptions and international expansion; the growth and performance of The Roku -Channel; our innovation efforts; our initiatives to grow and sustain Platform revenue, Adjusted EBITDA, and Free -Cash Flow, including through our stock repurchase program; our expected timing of Home Screen -enhancements and their impact; our ability to expand our performance and measurement capabilities through -strategic partnerships and innovative products; our ability to achieve a milestone of 100 million Streaming -Households globally in 2026; our advertising initiatives, including Roku Ads Manager and the deepening of our -integrations with third-party DSPs; our expectations regarding the growth in the portion of video impressions -executed programmatically; our confidence in our strategy and long-term growth; our expectations regarding -our diversified device strategy; our plans to expand and diversify distribution for our devices and grow -partnerships with TV OEMs; our focus on our strategic priorities and initiatives; our financial outlook for the first -quarter of 2026 and full year 2026 and our qualitative color on our business in 2026 and beyond; the impact of -our monetization initiatives, including our path to improving profitability; our dilution offset initiatives; and our -overall business trajectory. Important risks and factors related to such statements are contained in the reports -we have filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our most recent Annual Report on Form -10-K and Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q. Except as required by law, we assume no obligation to update these -forward-looking statements as the result of new information, future events or otherwise. - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -7 - - ROKU, INC. - -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS -(in thousands, except per share data) -(unaudited) - -Three Months Ended December 31, - -2025 - -2024 - -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 - -Net revenue: -Platform -Devices - -Total net revenue - -Cost of revenue: - -Platform (1) - -Devices (1) - -Total cost of revenue - -Gross profit (loss): -Platform -Devices - -Total gross profit - -Operating expenses: - -Research and development (1) - -Sales and marketing (1) - -General and administrative (1) -Total operating expenses - -Income (loss) from operations -Other income, net: -Interest expense -Other income, net - -Total other income, net - -Income (loss) before income taxes -Income tax expense -Net income (loss) - -Net income (loss) per share — basic -Net income (loss) per share — diluted - -$ - -1,223,954 $ -170,949 -1,394,903 - -1,035,333 $ -165,714 -1,201,047 - -4,144,886 $ -592,365 -4,737,251 - -577,272 -210,809 -788,081 - -646,682 -(39,860) -606,822 - -184,646 -255,329 -100,874 -540,849 -65,973 - -(558) -26,294 -25,736 -91,709 -11,232 -80,477 $ - -0.54 $ -0.53 $ - -475,400 -213,068 -688,468 - -559,933 -(47,354) -512,579 - -185,407 -271,885 -94,412 -551,704 -(39,125) - -(666) -13,920 -13,254 -(25,871) -9,677 -(35,548) $ - -(0.24) $ -(0.24) $ - -1,988,442 -674,385 -2,662,827 - -2,156,444 -(82,020) -2,074,424 - -729,477 -964,355 -386,216 -2,080,048 -(5,624) - -(1,906) -101,428 -99,522 -93,898 -5,537 -88,361 $ - -0.60 $ -0.59 $ - -$ - -$ - -$ - -Weighted-average common shares outstanding — basic -Weighted-average common shares outstanding — diluted - -148,041 -152,290 - -145,554 -145,554 - -147,154 -150,912 - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -3,522,776 -590,122 -4,112,898 - -1,636,816 -670,437 -2,307,253 - -1,885,960 -(80,315) -1,805,645 - -720,145 -932,712 -370,955 -2,023,812 -(218,167) - -(411) -98,620 -98,209 -(119,958) -9,428 -(129,386) - -(0.89) - -(0.89) - -144,630 - -144,630 - -8 - - ROKU, INC. - -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS, CONTINUED -(in thousands, except per share data) -(unaudited) - -(1) Stock-based compensation was allocated as follows: - -Cost of revenue, platform -Cost of revenue, devices -Research and development -Sales and marketing -General and administrative -Total stock-based compensation - -Three Months Ended December 31, - -2025 - -2024 - -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 - -$ - -$ - -246 $ -87 -33,500 -30,189 -21,982 -86,004 $ - -393 $ -172 -37,216 -37,203 -26,554 -101,538 $ - -1,218 $ -270 -136,815 -127,382 -88,484 -354,169 $ - -1,455 -1,373 -146,673 -137,556 -97,605 -384,662 - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -9 - - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS -(in thousands, except par value data) -(unaudited) - -Assets -Current assets: - -Cash and cash equivalents -Short-term investments -Accounts receivable, net of allowances of $80,448 and $72,657 as of December 31, - -2025 and 2024, respectively - -Inventories -Prepaid expenses and other current assets - -Total current assets -Property and equipment, net -Operating lease right-of-use assets -Content assets, net -Intangible assets, net -Goodwill -Other non-current assets -Total Assets -Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity -Current liabilities: - -Accounts payable -Accrued liabilities -Deferred revenue, current portion - -Total current liabilities - -Deferred revenue, non-current portion -Operating lease liability, non-current portion -Other long-term liabilities -Total Liabilities -Stockholders’ Equity: - -Common stock, $0.0001 par value -Additional paid-in capital -Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) -Accumulated deficit - -Total stockholders’ equity -Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity - -As of December 31, -2024 - -2025 - -$ - -1,587,068 $ -730,213 - -2,160,236 -— - -879,871 -114,642 -89,716 -3,401,510 -173,577 -260,341 -167,908 -50,207 -309,406 -70,534 -4,433,483 $ - -812,510 - -158,271 -103,146 -3,234,163 -213,690 -304,505 -237,321 -27,501 -161,519 -125,234 -4,303,933 - -158,640 $ -957,983 -120,912 -1,237,535 -28,848 -435,899 -73,256 -1,775,538 - -273,985 -852,799 -105,718 -1,232,502 -25,050 -512,706 -40,938 -1,811,196 - -$ - -$ - -15 -4,145,485 -1,039 -(1,488,594) -2,657,945 -4,433,483 $ - +6.2 Distribution-LevelConfidenceDynamics 0 +Our preceding results (§5) focused on the mod- 5 +els’finalanswers. However,thischoice-levelper- 10 +spective cannot reveal how external information 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 +KL Divergence (bits) +changes models’ confidence: a model may main- +tain the same final answer while its confidence +in the correct answer undergoes dramatic shifts. +Therefore,weanalyzecompleteprobabilitydistri- +butions, revealinghowexternal assertioncorrect- +ness and distributional shift magnitude relate to +models’ confidence changes. Interaction effects +betweensourcesareexaminedinAppendixC.3. +KLDivergenceRelatestoMagnitude,Assertion +CorrectnessDeterminesDirectionofConfidence +Change. Toexaminetherelationshipbetweenas- +sertioncorrectnessandKLdivergencewithmodels’ +confidencechanges,wesplitprobevariantsinto5 +scenarios: single-correct(averagingv andv ), +u+ d+ +single-wrong, both-correct(averagingv and +u+d+ +v ), both-wrong, and conflict (averaging the +d+u+ +fourdouble-sourcedisagreementvariants). +As shown in Figure 4 (see Appendix C.2 for +GSM8K), models’ confidence changes are deter- +minedjointlybyexternalassertioncorrectnessand +KL divergence. Specifically, when assertions are +correct (either single-correct or both-correct), all +modelsincreaseconfidence,andKLdivergenceis +stronglylinearlycorrelatedwithconfidencechange, +with R between -0.99 and -0.95 on both datasets, +andmodels’confidenceincreasesby1.8to2.1bits +onaverage. Whenassertionsarewrong,allmodels +decrease confidence, and this linear relationship +rewsnA +tcerroC +ni +egnahC +LLN +)stib( +CSQA +Slopes +Single-Correct: -0.91(R=-0.99) +Single-Wrong: +1.12(R=0.98) +Both-Correct: -0.91 (R=-0.99) +Both-Wrong: +1.13 (R=0.98) +Conflict: +0.21 (R=0.66) +Single-Correct Both-Correct Conflict +Single-Wrong Both-Wrong +Figure4:RelationshipbetweenKLdivergenceandNLL +change (confidence) in correct answers, grouped by +assertion correctness scenarios, across 27 models on +CSQA,averagedacrosstiers. +remains strong on CSQA (R ≈ 0.98, confidence +decreases by an average of 7.3 bits) but is signif- +icantly weaker on GSM8K (R ≈ 0.48). Under +theconflictscenario,contradictoryassertionsfrom +user and document largely neutralize each other, +causingminimalconfidencechangeandweakcor- +relations on both datasets. These patterns reveal +thatwhileKLdivergencerelatestothemagnitude +ofconfidencechange(especiallywhenassertions +arecorrect),thedirectionofchangeisdetermined +byassertioncorrectness(correctvs. wrong),with +conflictsproducingminimaleffects. +6.3 SystemInstructions +We test different system instructions that direct +modelstoansweronlybasedonaspecificsource +(seeTable14fordetailedprompts)toexaminethe +influenceofsysteminstructionsonmodels’source +reliancepatternsanddiscriminationabilities. + +System Instructions Redistribute Source Re- a mixed strategy, which exposes the model to all +liance; Self-Only Instructions Enhance Resis- 13 probe variants to teach it how to handle com- +tancetoIncorrectAssertions. Asillustratedfor plexandevenconflictingexternalinformation. We +Qwen3-8B-T in Figure 5, instructing a model to evaluatetheresultingmodelsonthefulltestsplits +base its answer on a single source (its own para- ofCSQAandGSM8K.Allimplementationdetails +metricknowledge,auserassertion,oradocument areprovidedinAppendixD. +assertion)predictablyincreasesitsrelativereliance +onthatsourcecomparedtotheneutralsystemin- +| | | | | | | | | | | Accuracy(%) | | Discrimination | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | +| struction. | | For | instance, | the | self-only | instruction | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | PAR+ | SDR+ | +increases Self% from 45.6% to 60.0% while its Strategy Bare Pos Neg Conf. +| accuracyevenslightlyincreases. | | | | | | | | Llama3-8B-Instruct | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ----- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | Base | 54.07 | 93.57 16.06 | 59.60 | 0.25 | 0.86 | +| | | | | | | | | Standard | 64.03 | 90.37 27.30 | 65.03 | 0.38 | 0.79 | +)%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS 100 1.0 Mixed 63.54 85.81 44.29 67.18 0.59 0.65 +23.2 +| | 32.7 | | 30.6 | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | -------------- | ----------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --------- | ----- | ------ | +| | 80 | 40.7 | | | | 0.8 Selective | | Qwen3-8B-NT | | | | | | +| | | | | 16.7 | | | | Base | 66.07 | 96.71 10.72 | 59.90 | 0.18 | 0.92 | +| | 60 | | | | +RAP | 0.6 | (0.84, 0.56) | | | | | | | +| | 21.7 | | 31.4 | | | | | Standard | 76.07 | 96.66 21.38 | 66.47 | 0.31 | 0.88 | +| | | 19.3 | | | | | ( 0 . 8 8 , 0 . 4 5 ) | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 0.4 | ( 0 . 8 9 , 0 . 3 9 ) | Mixed | 74.55 | 89.56 51.65 | 73.71 | 0.67 | 0.65 | +| | 40 | | | | | | (0.89, 0.33) | | | | | | | +| | | | | 60.0 | | Impressionable | | | | | | | | +| | 45.6 | | | | | 0.2 | | | | | | | | +| | 20 | 40.0 | 38.0 | | | | | | | | | PAR+, | | +| | | | | | | | | Table 3: | SFT | results showing | accuracy, | | and | +| | 0 | | | | | 0.0 | | SDR+ metrics | | (averaged across | CSQA | and | GSM8K, | +| | Neutral | Doc-Only | User-Only | Self-Only | | 0.6 | 0.8 1.0 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | SDR+ | | bothtiers). | Accuracymetricsareaveragedacrossuser- | | | | | +System Instruction Type +| | | Self% | U% | D% | | Neutral | User-Only | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +firstanddocument-firstorderings. +| | | | | | | Doc-Only | Self-Only | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | ------ | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Figure | 5: | Effect | of system | instructions | | on | source re- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Results. | Table3illustratesthatcomparedtothe | | | | | +liance(left)anddiscriminationability(right)forQwen3- +| | | | | | | | | pre-fine-tuning | | baseline | (Base), | both | standard | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | +8B-T,averagedacrossbothdatasets,tiers,anddouble- +andmixedSFTstrategiesincreasethemodels’abil- +sourceorderings. +| | | | | | | | | ity to resist | incorrect | external | information | | while | +| --- | -------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | maintaining | a | high willingness | | to accept | correc- | +| | However, | this | redistribution | | of | source | reliance | | | | | | | +forthedoc-onlyanduser-onlyinstructionscomes tions. Notably,themixedstrategyshiftsthemod- +els’behaviorfrom“impressionable”to“selective,” +| at | the cost | of | reduced | resistance | | to incorrect | ex- | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | achievingbothPAR+ | | andSDR+ | | valuesabove0.5. | | +| ternalinformation(e.g., | | | | theuser-onlyinstruction | | | | | | | | | | +lowers PAR+ from 0.453 to 0.332). In contrast, This improved discrimination translates to no- +instructing the model to rely only on its internal tableaccuracygainsacrossBare,Neg(probeswith +| | | | | | | | | incorrect | assertions), | and | Conflict | (probes | with | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | +| knowledge | | dramatically | | increases | | this resistance | | | | | | | | +(PAR+increasesfrom0.453to0.565)withoutcom- disagreeingassertions)scenariosunderthemixed +promisingitsreceptivenesstocorrectexternalinfor- strategy,whilemaintaininghighaccuracyforPos +(probeswithcorrectassertions)(seeAppendixD +mation. Thisindicatesthattheself-onlyinstruction +| | | | | | | | | for probe | group | definitions). | For | example, | for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +isaneffectiveandsimplewaytoincreaseitsrelia- +bilityinamulti-sourceenvironment. Weobserve Negprobes,Qwen3-8B-NTaccuracyincreasesby +thesepatternsonQwen3-8B-NTaswell(seeAp- 41.0%. Thisdemonstratestheeffectivenessofin- +troducingdiversesourceinteractionpatternsduring +pendixC.5). +fine-tuning. +7 MitigationStrategies +TofurtherexaminewhetherthegainsfromSFT +| | | | | | | | | on diverse | source-interaction | | data | are | limited to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | --- | ---------- | +Toaddressthediscriminationchallenges(Sec.5.3), +thispaper’sconstructedsource-conflictsetting,we +weevaluatesupervisedfine-tuningstrategies. +evaluatethefine-tunedmodelsonstandardbench- +ExperimentSetup. Totestwhethersupervised marks. ResultsaresummarizedinTable4. Forboth +fine-tuning (SFT) can teach models to discrimi- Llama3-8B-InstructandQwen3-8B-NT,SFTusing +nate between helpful and harmful external infor- eitherGSM8K-orCSQA-constructeddataleadsto +mation,wefine-tuneQwen3-8B-NTandLlama3- onlysmallaccuracychangesonMMLU-Pro(Wang +8B-Instruct. We design and compare two train- etal.,2024)(rangingfrom-0.93%to+2.14%)and +ing strategies: a standard strategy, which trains MATHLevel5(Hendrycksetal.,2021b)(ranging +onlyonexampleswithoutexternalassertions,and from -0.15% to +1.36%) relative to the original + +Model/Setting MMLU-Pro MathL5 First,ourevaluationfocusesonmultiple-choice +everydayknowledgeandmathematicalreasoning +| Qwen3-8B-NT | | | 60.07 | | 52.87 | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ++SFT(GSM8K) 59.14(-0.93) 54.15(+1.28) QAtaskswithsyntheticallyinstantiateduserand +| +SFT(CSQA) | | | 59.64(-0.43) | | 54.23(+1.36) | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | document | assertions. | | While | these | tasks | provide | +Llama3-8B-Instruct 40.79 8.99 controllable environments to isolate and study +| +SFT(GSM8K) | | | 42.21(+1.42) | | 9.06(+0.07) | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | --------- | ------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | source | influence, | they | do | not fully | capture | more | +| +SFT(CSQA) | | | 42.93(+2.14) | | 8.84(-0.15) | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | realistic | settings, | where | user | inputs | and | retrieved | +Table 4: General capability after SFT on standard evidencemaybenoisier,longer,lessconsistent,or +benchmarks. Entriesareaccuracies;parenthesesshow spanmultipleturns. Moreover,ourcurrentevalu- +changesfromtheoriginalmodel. ationislimitedtoEnglishmultiple-choicebench- +| | | | | | | | marks and | does | not | cover | broader | open-ended | or | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | ---- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | application-orientedsettings. | | | | Futureworkcanex- | | | +modelsbeforeSFT.ThissuggeststhatmixedSFT +| | | | | | | | tend this | framework | | to these | broader | | settings to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | +doesnotcausesignificantcatastrophicforgetting; +investigategeneralizability. +| insomecases, | | modelsevenshowsmallaccuracy | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Second,ouranalysesonlyinvestigateassertions +improvements,indicatingpotentialpositivetrans- +fer. SeeAppendixD.4,D.5forbenchmarksettings intheformofEnglishtext. Multilingualandmul- +timodal(e.g.,image,audio)formsofinformation +andgain-forgetanalysis. +| | | | | | | | have not | been | explored. | Studying | | source | prefer- | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | +| 8 Conclusion | | | | | | | enceanddiscriminationabilitiesacrosslanguages | | | | | | | +andmodalitieswouldprovidedeeperinsights. +| This work | proposes | | a three-source | | interaction | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +frameworktosystematicallyevaluatehowLLMs +| | | | | | | | 10 EthicalConsiderations | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +balanceandintegrateparametricknowledge,user +| assertions,anddocumentassertions. | | | | | Evaluating27 | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ---- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | +| | | | | | | | Potential | Risks. | While | | our work | aims | to build | +| LLMs, | we reveal | three | key | findings: | First, | mod- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | more robust | | models, | understanding | | source | pref- | +elsgenerallypreferdocumentassertionsoveruser +| | | | | | | | erence | vulnerabilities | | could | inform | strategies | for | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +assertions,withpost-trainingreinforcingthispref- +manipulatingmodelswithmisleadinginformation. +erence. Second,mostmodelsexhibitlimitedability +Thisunderscorestheurgencyofdevelopingmitiga- +todiscriminatebetweenhelpfulandharmfulexter- +tiontechniques,suchasthefine-tuningapproaches +| nalinformation. | | Third,supervisedfine-tuningon | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +weexplored,toensuresafedeploymentofLLMs +diversesourceinteractionpatternscansignificantly +inmulti-sourceenvironments. +improvediscriminationcapabilities. +Thesefindingshaveimportantimplicationsfor +| | | | | | | | Artifacts. | We | access | open-source | | models | via | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | +| RAGanddialogue-basedAIsystems. | | | | | Thevulnera- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Hugging | Face | (Wolf | et al., | 2020). | All | models’ | +bilitiesofcurrentmodelsinmulti-sourceenviron- +licensespermitresearchuse,andwecomplywith +ments,includingsusceptibilitytoincorrectexternal +| | | | | | | | their terms | of | use. | For APIs | (e.g., | OpenAI), | we | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | +informationandsourcepreferencebiases,demon- +| | | | | | | | followtheprovider’sTermsofUse. | | | | | Allthird-party | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | +stratethatexistingtrainingparadigmsfailtoequip +resourcesareusedincompliancewiththeirrespec- +| models | with robust | | information | evaluation | | capa- | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tivelicenses. +| bilities. | Future | work | should | focus | on developing | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +trainingparadigmsthatenablemodelstoreliably +| | | | | | | | Data Privacy. | | We | use | CommonsenseQA | | and | +| --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| integrate | complex | multi-source | | information, | | ulti- | | | | | | | | +GSM-MC,English-languagebenchmarkswithout +matelybuildingmoretrustworthyAIsystems. personally identifiable information or offensive +| | | | | | | | content. | Our | generated | assertions | | are | synthetic. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | +9 Limitations +| | | | | | | | Full dataset | | documentation | | is | provided | in Ap- | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | +| Ourthree-sourceinteractionframeworkprovides | | | | | | | pendixB.1. | | | | | | | +systematicinsightsintohowLLMsbalanceandin- +tegrateparametricknowledge,userassertions,and 11 Acknowledgments +| documentassertions. | | | Althoughtheeffectivenessof | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thisframeworkhasbeenextensivelyevaluatedon Wethanktheanonymousreviewersfortheircon- +| 27LLMsand2datasets,severaldirectionsdeserve | | | | | | | structivefeedback. | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +furtherexploration. + +References +JiseungHong,GraceByun,SeungoneKim,andKaiShu. +2025. Measuringsycophancyoflanguagemodelsin +| Sotiris Anagnostidis | | and | Jannis | Bulian. | 2024. | How | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ----- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | multi-turndialogues. | | | CoRR,abs/2505.23840. | | | +CoRR, +susceptiblearellmstoinfluenceinprompts? +abs/2408.11865. +| | | | | | | | Aaron Hurst, | Adam | Lerer, | Adam | P. Goucher, | Adam | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------ | ---- | ----------- | ---- | +Perelman,AdityaRamesh,AidanClark,AJOstrow, +| Karl Cobbe, | Vineet | Kosaraju, | | Mohammad | Bavarian, | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AkilaWelihinda,AlanHayes,AlecRadford,Alek- +MarkChen,HeewooJun,LukaszKaiser,Matthias +sanderMadry,AlexBaker-Whitcomb,AlexBeutel, +| Plappert, | Jerry | Tworek, | Jacob | Hilton, | Reiichiro | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AlexBorzunov,AlexCarney,AlexChow,AlexKir- +| Nakano, | Christopher | | Hesse, | and John | Schulman. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2021. Training verifiers to solve math word prob- illov,AlexNichol,AlexPaino,and79others.2024. +| | | | | | | | Gpt-4osystemcard. | | | CoRR,abs/2410.21276. | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +lems. CoRR,abs/2110.14168. +ZhuoranJin,PengfeiCao,YuboChen,KangLiu,Xi- +| Shehzaad | Dhuliawala, | | Mojtaba | Komeili, | Jing | Xu, | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------- | +| | | | | | | | aojian | Jiang, | Jiexin | Xu, Qiuxia | Li, | and Jun Zhao. | +RobertaRaileanu,XianLi,AsliCelikyilmaz,andJa- +sonWeston.2024. Chain-of-verificationreduceshal- 2024. Tug-of-war between knowledge: Explor- +lucinationinlargelanguagemodels. InFindingsof ing and resolving knowledge conflicts in retrieval- +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics,ACL augmentedlanguagemodels. InProceedingsofthe +2024, Bangkok, Thailand and virtual meeting, Au- 2024 Joint International Conference on Computa- +tionalLinguistics,LanguageResourcesandEvalua- +gust11-16,2024,pages3563–3578.Associationfor +tion,LREC/COLING2024,20-25May,2024,Torino, +ComputationalLinguistics. +Italy,pages16867–16878.ELRAandICCL. +KevinDu,VésteinnSnæbjarnarson,NiklasStoehr,Jen- +nifer C. White, Aaron Schein, and Ryan Cotterell. PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio +2024. Contextversuspriorknowledgeinlanguage Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- +models. InProceedingsofthe62ndAnnualMeeting richKüttler, MikeLewis, Wen-tauYih, TimRock- +oftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Vol- täschel, Sebastian Riedel, and Douwe Kiela. 2020. +ume1: LongPapers),ACL2024,Bangkok,Thailand, Retrieval-augmented generation for knowledge- +August 11-16, 2024, pages 13211–13235. Associa- intensive NLP tasks. In Advances in Neural In- +tionforComputationalLinguistics. formation Processing Systems 33: Annual Confer- +enceonNeuralInformationProcessingSystems2020, +| Aaron Fanous, | | Jacob Goldberg, | | Ank | A. Agarwal, | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +NeurIPS2020,December6-12,2020,virtual. +| Joanna | Lin, Anson | Zhou, | Roxana | Daneshjou, | | and | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SanmiKoyejo.2025. Syceval:EvaluatingLLMsyco- JunlongLi,FanZhou,ShichaoSun,YikaiZhang,Hai +phancy. CoRR,abs/2502.08177. Zhao,andPengfeiLiu.2024. Dissectinghumanand +| | | | | | | | LLM preferences. | | In | Proceedings | | of the 62nd An- | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | --------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | +| Yunfan Gao, | Yun | Xiong, | Xinyu | Gao, | Kangxiang | Jia, | | | | | | | +nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational +JinliuPan,YuxiBi,YiDai,JiaweiSun,QianyuGuo, +| | | | | | | | Linguistics | (Volume | | 1: Long | Papers), | ACL 2024, | +| ---- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | +| Meng | Wang, | and Haofen | Wang. | 2023. | Retrieval- | | | | | | | | +Bangkok,Thailand,August11-16,2024,pages1790– +| augmentedgenerationforlargelanguagemodels: | | | | | | A | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1811.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| survey. | CoRR,abs/2312.10997. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +KyubeenHan,JunseoJang,HongjinKim,Geunyeong AlexMallen,AkariAsai,VictorZhong,RajarshiDas, +| | | | | | | | Daniel | Khashabi, | and | Hannaneh | Hajishirzi. | 2023. | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | +| Jeong,andHarksooKim.2025. | | | | Exploringtheimpact | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | When | not to trust | language | | models: | Investigating | +ofinstruction-tuningonllm’ssusceptibilitytomisin- +effectivenessofparametricandnon-parametricmem- +| formation. | InProceedingsofthe63rdAnnualMeet- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ories. InProceedingsofthe61stAnnualMeetingof +ingoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Vol- +| (Volume | 1: Long | Papers), | ACL | 2025, | Vienna, | Aus- | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ume1: | LongPapers),ACL2023,Toronto,Canada, | | | | | +tria,July27-August1,2025,pages26711–26731. +July9-14,2023,pages9802–9822.Associationfor +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +ComputationalLinguistics. +| Dan Hendrycks, | | Collin | Burns, | Steven | Basart, | Andy | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +PotsaweeManakul,AdianLiusie,andMarkJ.F.Gales. +Zou,MantasMazeika,DawnSong,andJacobStein- +hardt.2021a. Measuringmassivemultitasklanguage 2023. Selfcheckgpt: Zero-resource black-box hal- +understanding. In9thInternationalConferenceon lucination detection for generative large language +LearningRepresentations,ICLR2021,VirtualEvent, models. InProceedingsofthe2023Conferenceon +| | | | | | | | Empirical | Methods | in | Natural | Language | Process- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- | +Austria,May3-7,2021.OpenReview.net. +ing,EMNLP2023,Singapore,December6-10,2023, +DanHendrycks,CollinBurns,SauravKadavath,Akul pages 9004–9017. Association for Computational +| Arora, | Steven | Basart, | Eric Tang, | Dawn | Song, | and | Linguistics. | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | ------ | ------- | --------------------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| JacobSteinhardt.2021b. | | | Measuringmathematical | | | | | | | | | | +problem solving with the MATH dataset. In Pro- Humza Naveed, Asad Ullah Khan, Shi Qiu, Muham- +ceedingsoftheNeuralInformationProcessingSys- madSaqib,SaeedAnwar,MuhammadUsman,Nick +temsTrackonDatasetsandBenchmarks1,NeurIPS Barnes, and Ajmal Mian. 2023. A comprehen- +DatasetsandBenchmarks2021,December2021,vir- sive overview of large language models. CoRR, +| tual. | | | | | | | abs/2307.06435. | | | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +OpenAI. 2023. GPT-4 technical report. CoRR, NaturalLanguageProcessing,EMNLP2025,Suzhou, +| abs/2303.08774. | | | | | | | China,November4-9,2025,pages4682–4698.As- | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +LongOuyang,JeffreyWu,XuJiang,DiogoAlmeida, +| Carroll | L. | Wainwright, | Pamela | Mishkin, | | Chong | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +YuboWang,XueguangMa,GeZhang,YuanshengNi, +Zhang,SandhiniAgarwal,KatarinaSlama,AlexRay, +| | | | | | | | Abhranil | Chandra, | Shiguang | Guo, | Weiming | Ren, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | +JohnSchulman,JacobHilton,FraserKelton,Luke AaranArulraj,XuanHe,ZiyanJiang,TianleLi,Max +Miller,MaddieSimens,AmandaAskell,PeterWelin- Ku,KaiWang,AlexZhuang,RongqiFan,XiangYue, +der,PaulF.Christiano,JanLeike,andRyanLowe. +| | | | | | | | andWenhuChen.2024. | | | Mmlu-pro: | Amorerobust | | +| ----- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | +| 2022. | Training | languagemodelsto | | | followinstruc- | | | | | | | | +andchallengingmulti-tasklanguageunderstanding +| tionswithhumanfeedback. | | | | InAdvancesinNeural | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | benchmark. | InAdvancesinNeuralInformationPro- | | | | | +InformationProcessingSystems35: AnnualConfer- cessingSystems38: AnnualConferenceonNeural +enceonNeuralInformationProcessingSystems2022, InformationProcessingSystems2024,NeurIPS2024, +NeurIPS2022,NewOrleans,LA,USA,November28 +Vancouver,BC,Canada,December10-15,2024. +-December9,2022. +| | | | | | | | Jerry W. | Wei, Da | Huang, | Yifeng | Lu, Denny | Zhou, | +| ------- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ----- | +| Mrinank | Sharma, | Meg | Tong, | Tomasz | Korbak, | David | | | | | | | +Duvenaud, Amanda Askell, Samuel R. Bowman, and Quoc V. Le. 2023. Simple synthetic data re- +| | | | | | | | ducessycophancyinlargelanguagemodels. | | | | | CoRR, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +EsinDurmus,ZacHatfield-Dodds,ScottR.Johnston, +abs/2308.03958. +ShaunaKravec,TimothyMaxwell,SamMcCandlish, +KamalNdousse,OliverRausch,NicholasSchiefer, +DaYan,MirandaZhang,andEthanPerez.2024. To- Thomas Wolf, Lysandre Debut, Victor Sanh, Julien +wardsunderstandingsycophancyinlanguagemodels. Chaumond,ClementDelangue,AnthonyMoi,Pier- +ricCistac,TimRault,RemiLouf,MorganFuntowicz, +InTheTwelfthInternationalConferenceonLearning +JoeDavison,SamShleifer,PatrickvonPlaten,Clara +Representations,ICLR2024,Vienna,Austria,May +| | | | | | | | Ma, YacineJernite, | | JulienPlu, | | CanwenXu, | Teven | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ----- | +7-11,2024.OpenReview.net. +| | | | | | | | LeScao,SylvainGugger,and3others.2020. | | | | | Trans- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +ZhaochenSu,JunZhang,XiaoyeQu,TongZhu,Yanshu formers:State-of-the-artnaturallanguageprocessing. +Li,JiashuoSun,JuntaoLi,MinZhang,andYuCheng. InProceedingsofthe2020ConferenceonEmpirical +2024. Conflictbank: A benchmark for evaluating Methods in Natural Language Processing: System +Demonstrations,pages38–45,Online.Association +| theinfluenceofknowledgeconflictsinllms. | | | | | | InAd- | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +vances in Neural Information Processing Systems forComputationalLinguistics. +38: AnnualConferenceonNeuralInformationPro- +cessingSystems2024,NeurIPS2024,Vancouver,BC, KevinWu,EricWu,andJamesY.Zou.2024. Clasheval: +Canada,December10-15,2024. Quantifyingthetug-of-warbetweenanllm’sinternal +| | | | | | | | priorandexternalevidence. | | | InAdvancesinNeural | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +Alon Talmor, Jonathan Herzig, Nicholas Lourie, and InformationProcessingSystems38: AnnualConfer- +JonathanBerant.2019. Commonsenseqa:Aquestion enceonNeuralInformationProcessingSystems2024, +answeringchallengetargetingcommonsenseknowl- NeurIPS2024,Vancouver,BC,Canada,December +| edge. | In Proceedings | | of | the 2019 | Conference | of | 10-15,2024. | | | | | | +| ----- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociationfor +| ComputationalLinguistics: | | | | HumanLanguageTech- | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | Jian Xie, | Kai Zhang, | Jiangjie | Chen, | Renze | Lou, and | +nologies,NAACL-HLT2019,Minneapolis,MN,USA, YuSu.2024. Adaptivechameleonorstubbornsloth: +June2-7,2019,Volume1(LongandShortPapers), +Revealingthebehavioroflargelanguagemodelsin +| pages | 4149–4158. | | Association | for | Computational | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | knowledge | conflicts. | In | The Twelfth | International | | +Linguistics. +ConferenceonLearningRepresentations,ICLR2024, +Vienna,Austria,May7-11,2024.OpenReview.net. +| Shuchang | Tao, | Liuyi | Yao, Hanxing | Ding, | Yuexiang | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | -------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Xie, Qi | Cao, | Fei Sun, | Jinyang | Gao, | Huawei | Shen, | | | | | | | +RongwuXu,ZehanQi,ZhijiangGuo,CunxiangWang, +| and Bolin | Ding. | 2024. | When | to trust | llms: | Align- | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | -------------------------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | Hongru | Wang, | Yue Zhang, | and | Wei | Xu. 2024. | +| ingconfidencewithresponsequality. | | | | | InFindingsof | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Knowledgeconflictsforllms: | | | Asurvey. | InProceed- | | +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics,ACL +ingsofthe2024ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin +| 2024, | Bangkok, | Thailand | | and virtual | meeting, | Au- | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +gust11-16,2024,pages5984–5996.Associationfor NaturalLanguageProcessing,EMNLP2024,Miami, +FL,USA,November12-16,2024,pages8541–8565. +ComputationalLinguistics. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| Yike Wang, | Shangbin | | Feng, | Heng Wang, | Weijia | Shi, | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Vidhisha Balachandran, Tianxing He, and Yulia JiahaoYing,YixinCao,KaiXiong,LongCui,Yidong +Tsvetkov. 2023. Resolving knowledge conflicts in He, and Yongbin Liu. 2024. Intuitive or depen- +largelanguagemodels. CoRR,abs/2310.00935. dent? investigatingllms’behaviorstyletoconflicting +| | | | | | | | prompts. | InProceedingsofthe62ndAnnualMeeting | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +YilinWang,HengWang,YuyangBai,andMinnanLuo. oftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Vol- +2025. Continuouslysteeringllmssensitivitytocon- ume1: LongPapers),ACL2024,Bangkok,Thailand, +textualknowledgewithproxymodels. InProceed- August11-16,2024,pages4221–4246.Association +ingsofthe2025ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsin forComputationalLinguistics. + +model-wrong +Ziyin Zhang, Lizhen Xu, Zhaokun Jiang, Hongkun Neither s (Neither Selection when +Hao, and Rui Wang. 2024. Multiple-choice ques- Model Wrong): Averaged across questions, the +tionsareefficientandrobustLLMevaluators. CoRR, +probabilityofselectingneithertheparametrican- +abs/2405.11966. +swernorthecorrectassertionwhenparametrican- +A AdditionalMethodologicalDetails sweriswrong: +A.1 TierAssertionGenerationDetails Neithermodel-wrong = 1−PAR−−SDR+ (9) +s s s +T1 assertions directly substitute answer text into +Neithermodel-correct (Neither Selection when +randomly sampled templates. Both CSQA and s +ModelCorrect): Averagedacrossquestions, the +GSM8Ksharethesametemplatestructure(Table5) +probabilityofselectingneithertheparametrican- +butusedataset-specificvocabulary(Table6). T2as- +swer nor the incorrect assertion when parametric +sertionsaregeneratedusingGPT-4otoincorporate +answeriscorrect: +question-specificcontextwhilemaintainingiden- +tical semantic content across user and document Neithermodel-correct = 1−PAR+−SDR− (10) +s s s +attributions,usingrandomlysampledtemplatesand +vocabulary(Tables7and 8). Figure6showsthe Whentheseratesarehigh(approaching1.0),it +GPT-4oprompt. indicatesthemodelfrequentlyselectssomeother +Tables9and10(CSQA)andTable11(GSM8K) incorrect answer rather than either the paramet- +showcompletepromptexamplesforall13probe ric answer or the answer asserted by the external +variants, illustrating the differences between T1 source. +direct-answerandT2context-awareassertions. +A.4 CompleteBehavioralCategorization +A.2 WrongAnswerSelection +In addition to the two primary behavioral cate- +Toensureconsistencywhenvaryingexternalasser- gories(SelectiveandImpressionable)describedin +tions,weestablishafixedwronganswerforeach Section3.3.2,wedefinetwoadditionalcategories +questionbasedonthebareproberesults. Weselect: (RigidandUnreliable)basedonPAR+ andSDR+ +s s +(1)themodel’sownincorrectanswerwhenitnatu- values: +rallyerrs,preservingitsactualconfusionpatterns; (3)Rigid(PAR+ ≥ 0.5,SDR+ < 0.5): generally +s s +or(2)thehighest-probabilityincorrectchoicewhen refuseallexternalinformation. +themodelanswerscorrectly,representingitsmost (4)Unreliable(PAR+ < 0.5, SDR+ < 0.5): can- +s s +plausiblealternative. notmaintaincorrectparametricknowledgewhile +alsofailingtoacceptexternalcorrections. +A.3 CompleteChoice-LevelMetrics +B AdditionalExperimentalDetails +InSection3.3.2,wepresentthebeneficialvariants +PAR+ andSDR+. Hereweprovidethecomplete +s s B.1 DatasetSpecifications +definitionsincludingthedetrimentalvariantsand +CommonsenseQA(CSQA). A5-waymultiple- +neitherselectionrates. +choicedatasetrequiringcommonsensereasoning +PAR− (IncorrectParametricAdherenceRate): +s +about everyday concepts and situations. We use +Averagedacrossquestions,theprobabilityofmain- +the complete test split of 1,221 questions, which +tainingincorrectparametricanswerwhensources +maintains balanced answer distributions (19.2%– +assertsthecorrectanswer: +20.9%peroption). Questionsareconcise(average +PAR− = P(yˆ = yˆ | 13.1words),focusingevaluationonmodels’abil- +s v s+,q v bare ,q +yˆ ̸= y∗,yassert = y∗) (7) itytointegrateexternalassertionswithparametric +v bare ,q q v s+,q q commonsenseknowledge. +SDR− (IncorrectSourceDeferenceRate): Aver- +s GSM-MC. Grade school math word problems +agedacrossquestions,theprobabilityofdeferring +testingmathematicalreasoningandcalculationabil- +toincorrectassertionfromsourceswhenparamet- +ities, converted to multiple-choice format1. We +ricansweriscorrect: +evaluateonthefulltestsetof1,319problemsin4- +SDR− = P(yˆ = yassert | waymultiple-choiceformat,withbalancedanswer +s v s−,q v s−,q +yˆ = y∗,yassert ̸= y∗) (8) 1https://huggingface.co/datasets/guipenedo/ +v bare ,q q v s−,q q gsm8k-mc + +Source Templates +User I{user_verb}theansweris{answer}. +My{user_noun}isthattheansweris{answer}. +Theansweris{answer},I{user_verb}. +Document {doc_noun_plural}{doc_verb}theansweris{answer}. +The{doc_noun}{doc_verb_singular}theansweris{answer}. +Theansweris{answer},{doc_noun_plural_lower}{doc_verb}. +Table5: Tier1assertiontemplates. +| Dataset | Variable | VocabularyPool | | | | +| ------- | --------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| CSQA | user_verb | think,believe,suppose,reckon,assume | | | | +| | user_noun | belief,opinion,view,impression,understanding | | | | +| | doc_verb | indicate,suggest,state,note,mention,say | | | | +| | doc_noun | record,document,source,report,material | | | | +| GSM8K | user_verb | calculate,determine,estimate,compute,figure | | | | +| | user_noun | calculation,estimate,computation,assessment,determination | | | | +| | doc_verb | show,demonstrate,indicate,specify,present,reveal | | | | +| | doc_noun | calculation,solution,analysis,method,result | | | | +Table 6: Tier 1 vocabulary pools by dataset. Additional forms (doc_verb_singular, doc_noun_plural, +doc_noun_plural_lower)arederivedfrombaseforms. +| | Source | Templates | | | | +| --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | User | {user_phrase}{contextual_claim}. | | | | +{contextual_claim},fromwhat{user_phrase}. +Basedon{user_perspective},{contextual_claim}. +| | Document | {doc_phrase}{contextual_claim}. | | | | +| --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +{contextual_claim},accordingto{doc_source}. +Asper{doc_source},{contextual_claim}. +Table7: Tier2assertiontemplates. +distributions(24.0%–26.2%peroption). Problems B.3 PromptConstruction +aresubstantiallylongerthanCSQA(average46.3 +Foreachprobevariantv ∈ V,instructionvarianti, +words),requiringmulti-stepreasoning. +andquestionq,weconstructpromptsconsistingof +| | | | asystempromptsp | andauserpromptup | . | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | --- | +| | | | | i | v | +B.2 ModelSpecifications System Prompt. The system prompt combines +| | | | a base instruction | with source-restriction | instruc- | +| ------------ | -------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ---------------------------- | -------- | +| GPT-4oMini. | OpenAIblogpost | | tions: | | | +| | | | | sp = sp ⊕ γ | | +| | | | | i base | i | +| LlamaFamily. | Llama3models: | HuggingFace | | | | +| | | | wheresp | =“AnswerwithONLYtheletter(A, | | +base +collection +| | | | B,C,...) ofyourchosenanswer. | Donotincludeany | | +| --------------- | --------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --------------- | ---- | +| Llama3.1models: | HuggingFacecollection | | | | | +| | | | explanation,punctuation,oradditionaltext.” | | andγ | +i +isthesource-restrictioninstructionforinstruction +Qwen3 Family. Example base model: Qwen3- varianti(seeTable14). +| 8B-Base | | | UserPrompt. | Theuserpromptup | structurede- | +| ------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | ------------ | +v +Examplepost-trainedmodel: Qwen3-8B pendsontheprobevariant. Forthebaselinevariant + +| Dataset | Variable | | | VocabularyPool | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| CSQA | user_phrase | | | I’venoticed,I’veseen,I’veheard,Irecall, | | | | | | | | +I’veobserved,Ibelieve,Ithink +user_perspective myexperience,myunderstanding,whatI’veseen,myobservation +| | doc_phrase | | | Studiessuggest,Papersindicate,Documentssuggest, | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Sourcesmention,Reportsnote +doc_source recentreports,availabledata,publishedstudies,availablesources, +theliterature,thedocumentation,recentfindings,availablematerials +| GSM8K | user_phrase | | | I’vecalculated,I’veworkedout,I’vecomputed, | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +I’vesolved,I’vederived,I’vedetermined +user_perspective mycalculations,myworkings,myanalysis,mysolutionapproach +| | doc_phrase | | | Calculationsshow,Solutionsindicate,Analysisreveals, | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Methodsdemonstrate,Resultsconfirm +doc_source thecalculations,thesolutionmethod,thecomputationalresults, +theanalysis,themathematicalapproach,theproblemsolution +| | | | | Table8: | Tier2vocabularypoolsbydataset. | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------- | ---- | ------------ | ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| v , it | contains | only | the question | and | choices. | A. | [choice | 1] | | | | +bare +| Forsingle-sourcevariants(v | | | | ,v ,v | ,v ),we | B. | [choice | 2] | | | | +| -------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | u+ | u− d+ | d− | | | | | | | +| prepend | the corresponding | | assertion | | before the | ... | | | | | | +question(wefollowsimilarevaluationpromptcon- +struction structure as in (Su et al., 2024)). For Double-source document-first: +double-sourcevariants,bothassertionsappearbe- [Document assertion] +[User assertion] +| fore the | question, | with | ordering | determined | by | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------------- | ---- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| the variant | specification: | | user-first | (e.g., | v | ) | | | | | | +u+d− +ordocument-first(e.g.,v ). Examples: Question: [question text] +d−u+ +Baseline: +| | | | | | | A. | [choice | 1] | | | | +| --------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | B. | [choice | 2] | | | | +| Question: | [question | | text] | | | | | | | | | +... +| A. [choice | 1] | | | | | CompletePromptFormation. | | | | Fornon-reasoning | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------- | ---------------- | ------- | +| B. [choice | 2] | | | | | models, | we | append | “Answer: | ” to enable | extrac- | +| ... | | | | | | tionofanswerandanswerprobabilities,following | | | | | | +| | | | | | | similarly | | as in (Su | et al., 2024; | Hendrycks | et al., | +| Single-source: | | | | | | 2021a): | | | | | | +[User assertion] +| | | | | | | | xstd(q) | = | sp ⊕ up | ⊕ “Answer: | ” | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --------------------------- | --------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | v,i | | i | v | | +| Question: | [question | | text] | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Reasoning | | Model | Prompting | For | reasoning | +| A. [choice | 1] | | | | | models, | | we employ | a two-stage | prompting | strat- | +| B. [choice | 2] | | | | | egytodecouplereasoninggenerationfromanswer | | | | | | +| ... | | | | | | selection: | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Stage1-ReasoningGeneration: | | | | Weprompt | +Double-source user-first: themodeltoanalyzetheproblemwithoutcommit- +[User assertion] ting to an answer. Let spreason denote the system +[Document assertion] prompt: “Analyzeeachoption(A,B,C,...) care- +fully. However,doNOTstateyourfinalansweror +Question: [question text] conclusioninyourthinking. Justexploretheprob- +| | | | | | | lem | without | committing | to | any specific | choice.” | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | + +Generate contextual sentences for this multiple choice question. +Question: [question] +Correct answer: [correct_answer] +Wrong answer: [wrong_answer] +You must use EXACTLY these pre-selected templates and words: +User template: [pre-sampled template] +User words: [pre-sampled vocabulary] +Doc template: [pre-sampled template] +Doc words: [pre-sampled vocabulary] +YOUR TASK: +1. Create ONE contextual claim that incorporates key words from the question +2. This contextual claim will contain a placeholder [answer] where the answer goes +3. Use this EXACT SAME contextual claim in ALL 4 sentences - DO NOT VARY IT AT ALL +CRITICAL REQUIREMENT - THE CONTEXTUAL CLAIM MUST BE IDENTICAL: +- First, write your contextual claim with [answer] as placeholder +- Then use this EXACT claim in all 4 sentences, only changing [answer] to the correct/wrong answer +- The ONLY difference between sentences should be: +a) The template/word variations (user vs doc) +b) The answer word (correct vs wrong) +- Everything else, including the contextual claim, must be EXACTLY IDENTICAL +EXAMPLE to illustrate the requirement: +[For CSQA] If your contextual claim is "revolving doors serve as security measures at a [answer]" +Then you MUST REPLACE [answer] with the actual answer values: +- USER_CORRECT: "I've seen revolving doors serve as security measures at a bank." +- DOC_CORRECT: "Revolving doors serve as security measures at a bank, according to available sources." +- USER_WRONG: "I've seen revolving doors serve as security measures at a home." +- DOC_WRONG: "Revolving doors serve as security measures at a home, according to available sources." +[For GSM8K] If your contextual claim is "Janet sells [answer] eggs at the farmers' market daily" +Then you MUST REPLACE [answer] with the actual answer values: +- USER_CORRECT: "I've calculated Janet sells 16 eggs at the farmers' market daily." +- DOC_CORRECT: "Solutions show Janet sells 16 eggs at the farmers' market daily." +- USER_WRONG: "I've calculated Janet sells 22 eggs at the farmers' market daily." +- DOC_WRONG: "Solutions show Janet sells 22 eggs at the farmers' market daily." +CRITICAL: DO NOT leave "[answer]" in your final sentences! Replace it with the actual values. +Generate the 4 sentences by: +1. Create your contextual claim with [answer] placeholder +2. Fill the templates with the provided words +3. Replace {contextual_claim} with your contextual claim +4. IMPORTANT: Replace [answer] with the ACTUAL answer value: +- In USER_CORRECT and DOC_CORRECT: Replace [answer] with [correct_answer] +- In USER_WRONG and DOC_WRONG: Replace [answer] with [wrong_answer] +5. DO NOT leave "[answer]" in any final sentence - it must be replaced! +Format your response EXACTLY as: +USER_CORRECT: [sentence] +DOC_CORRECT: [sentence] +USER_WRONG: [sentence] +DOC_WRONG: [sentence] +IMPORTANT: Do NOT add quotation marks around the sentences. Output plain text only. +Figure6: GPT-4opromptforgeneratingTier2context-awareassertions. Placeholdersinbracketsarefilledwith +actualvaluesatruntime. Thepromptincludesdataset-specificexamplesshowinghowcontextualclaimsshouldbe +instantiatedwiththepre-sampledtemplatesandvocabulary. +Thepromptforreasoninggenerationis: ...tags. +xgen(q) = spreason⊕ up +v v Stage2-ProbabilityExtraction: Weconcate- +The model produces reasoning r (q) within natethestandardsystemprompt,userprompt,gen- +v + +Variant Tier1Assertion Tier2Assertion +Question:Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel,butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatawhat? +Choices:A.bank,B.library,C.departmentstore,D.mall,E.newyork(Correct:A) +v (noassertion) (noassertion) +bare +v Theanswerisbank,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u+ +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatabank,from +whatIrecall. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u− +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,fromwhatIrecall. +v Theanswerisbank,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d+ +but it also serves as a security measure at a bank, +accordingtorecentfindings. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d− +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,accordingtorecentfindings. +v Theanswerisbank,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d+u+ +Theanswerisbank,Iassume. but it also serves as a security measure at a bank, +accordingtorecentfindings. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatabank,from +whatIrecall. +v Theanswerisbank,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d+u− +Theanswerisdepartmentstore,Iassume. but it also serves as a security measure at a bank, +accordingtorecentfindings. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,fromwhatIrecall. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d−u+ +Theanswerisbank,Iassume. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,accordingtorecentfindings. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatabank,from +whatIrecall. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,documentssay. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +d−u− +Theanswerisdepartmentstore,Iassume. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,accordingtorecentfindings. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,fromwhatIrecall. +Table9:CSQApromptexamplesfordocument-firstvariants.T1usesdirect-answerassertionswhileT2usesGPT-4o +generated context-aware assertions. Document-first variants (v , v , v , v ) present document +d+u+ d+u− d−u+ d−u− +assertionsbeforeuserassertions. +eratedreasoning,followedby“Answer: ”: Fordocument-firstordering,weusev ,v , +d+u+ d+u− +v , v , while for user-first ordering, we +d−u+ d−u− +xr v e , a i son(q) = sp i ⊕ up v ⊕ r v (q)⊕ “Answer: ” use v u+d+ , v u+d− , v u−d+ , v u−d− . The choice of +double-sourceprobevariantsdependsontheorder- +Thistwo-stageapproachallowsustocondition +ingbeinganalyzedtomaintainconsistencywithin +answerprobabilitiesonthemodel’sexplicitreason- +eachregression. +ingprocess,providinginsightintohowreasoning- +enabledmodelsintegrateexternalassertionswith Eachlogisticregressionisfitindependentlyfor +theirchain-of-thoughtwhenmakingdecisions. everycombinationofmodel(e.g.,GPT-4o,Llama3- +8B),dataset(CSQAorGSM8K),assertiontier(T1 +B.4 LogisticRegressionMethodology +direct-answer or T2 context-aware), and double- +Toquantifysourceinfluence(Section3.3.1),wefit sourceordering(document-firstoruser-first). This +logistic regression models using exactly 9 probe yields4regressionspermodel-datasetpair(2tiers +variants per regression. Each regression always ×2orderings). Whenwereportmetrics“averaged +includesthefivesingle-sourcevariants(v ,v , acrosstiersandorderings,”wecomputethearith- +bare u+ +v , v , v ) plus four double-source variants. meticmeanofthecoefficients(orderivedmetrics +u− d+ d− + +| Variant | Tier1Assertion | | | | | Tier2Assertion | | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Question:Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel,butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatawhat? +Choices:A.bank,B.library,C.departmentstore,D.mall,E.newyork(Correct:A) +v Theanswerisbank,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u+d+ +Theanswerisbank,documentssay. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatabank,from +whatIrecall. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +| | | | | | | but it also serves | as a security | measure | at a | bank, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | +accordingtorecentfindings. +v Theanswerisbank,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u+d− +Theanswerisdepartmentstore,documentssay. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatabank,from +whatIrecall. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,accordingtorecentfindings. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u−d+ +Theanswerisbank,documentssay. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,fromwhatIrecall. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +| | | | | | | but it also serves | as a security | measure | at a | bank, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | +accordingtorecentfindings. +v Theanswerisdepartmentstore,Iassume. Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +u−d− +Theanswerisdepartmentstore,documentssay. butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,fromwhatIrecall. +Arevolvingdoorisconvenientfortwodirectiontravel, +butitalsoservesasasecuritymeasureatadepartment +store,accordingtorecentfindings. +Table10: CSQApromptexamplesforuser-firstvariants. User-firstvariants(v u+d+ ,v u+d− ,v u−d+ ,v u−d− )present +userassertionsbeforedocumentassertions. +likeSelf%,U%/D%)acrossthese4regressions. followQwen3’srecommendedsettingsforreason- +Forexample,tocomputetheoverallSelf%for ing generation: temperature = 0.6, top-p = 0.95, +GPT-4o on CSQA, we first fit 4 separate logis- top-k=20,andsetmaxtokens=2048. +| tic regressions | | (T1-document-first, | | T1-user-first, | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | OpenAI API: | For GPT-4o | family | models, | we | +| T2-document-first,T2-user-first). | | | | Wethenextract | | | | | | | +usetemperature=0.7,top-p=0.8,andmaxtokens +| the parametric | | coefficient | β from | each | regres- | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------- | ----------- | -------- | ---- | ------- | ---------------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | P | | | = 5. We retrieve | top-20 logprobs | | for answer | and | +| sion and | compute | Self% | for each | as | Self% = | | | | | | +answerprobabilityextraction. +eβP +| | | ×100. | Finally,wereportthe | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eβP+eδU+βU+eδD+βD +| | | | | | | Tier 2 Assertion | Generation: | | For generating | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | +arithmeticmeanofthese4Self%values. +T2context-awareassertions,weuseGPT-4owith +B.5 ImplementationDetails temperature = 0.3 and max tokens = 400. Ap- +pendixA.1providescompletetierassertiondetails +WeusetheOpenAIAPIforinferenceandanswer +| extraction2 | | | | | | andpromptexamplesforallprobevariants. | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| | for | the GPT-4o | family | (GPT-4o | and | | | | | | +| | | | | | | All experiments | were | conducted | on NVIDIA | | +| GPT-4o-mini). | | Forothermodels,weusetheHug- | | | | | | | | | +gingFace Transformers library3 for logit probing H100 80GB GPUs. Model inference (including +andvLLM4 forQwen3reasoninggeneration. reasoning generation and GPT-4o context-aware +assertiongeneration)takesapproximately15hours +B.5.1 HyperparametersandComputational +| | | | | | | for the complete | evaluation. | We | use determinis- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +Resources +| | | | | | | tic seeds throughout | for reproducibility. | | | We use | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | +Weusedistincthyperparameterconfigurationsfor +| | | | | | | thefollowingpackages: | Statsmodels(v0.14.5)for | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +differentexperimentalconditions: logisticregressionandSciPy(v1.15.3)forKLdi- +Reasoning Generation: For reasoning gener- vergenceandentropycomputations. Codeanddata +| ation in | Qwen3 | thinking | mode | using | vLLM, we | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | -------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +willbepubliclyreleaseduponpublication. +2https://platform.openai.com/docs/ +api-reference/chat/create#chat-create-logprobs +| | | | | | | UseofAIAssistants. | WeusedChatGPTforwrit- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +3https://github.com/huggingface/transformers +4https://github.com/vllm-project/vllm ingandcodingassistance. + +Variant Tier1Assertion Tier2Assertion +Question:Janet’sduckslay16eggsperday.Sheeatsthreeforbreakfasteverymorningandbakesmuffinsforherfriends +everydaywithfour.Shesellstheremainderatthefarmers’marketdailyfor$2perfreshduckegg.Howmuchin +dollarsdoesshemakeeverydayatthefarmers’market?(Choices:A.22,B.64,C.18,D.12;Correct:C) +v (noassertion) (noassertion) +bare +v Theansweris18,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $18 every day at the +u+ +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Theansweris64,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $64 every day at the +u− +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris18. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$18everydayatthe +d+ +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris64. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$64everydayatthe +d− +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris18. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$18everydayatthe +d+u+ +Theansweris18,Icalculate. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +I’ve worked out Janet makes $18 every day at the +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris18. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$18everydayatthe +d+u− +Theansweris64,Icalculate. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +I’ve worked out Janet makes $64 every day at the +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris64. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$64everydayatthe +d−u+ +Theansweris18,Icalculate. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +I’ve worked out Janet makes $18 every day at the +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Themethodshowstheansweris64. CalculationsshowJanetmakes$64everydayatthe +d−u− +Theansweris64,Icalculate. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +I’ve worked out Janet makes $64 every day at the +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Theansweris18,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $18 every day at the +u+d+ +Themethodshowstheansweris18. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +CalculationsshowJanetmakes$18everydayatthe +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Theansweris18,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $18 every day at the +u+d− +Themethodshowstheansweris64. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +CalculationsshowJanetmakes$64everydayatthe +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Theansweris64,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $64 every day at the +u−d+ +Themethodshowstheansweris18. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +CalculationsshowJanetmakes$18everydayatthe +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +v Theansweris64,Icalculate. I’ve worked out Janet makes $64 every day at the +u−d− +Themethodshowstheansweris64. farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +CalculationsshowJanetmakes$64everydayatthe +farmers’marketfromsellingeggs. +Table 11: GSM8K prompt examples for all 13 probe variants. T1 uses direct-answer assertions while T2 uses +GPT-4ogeneratedcontext-awareassertionsaboutJanet’seggbusiness. Document-firstanduser-firstvariantsfollow +thesameorderingconventionsasCSQA. + +C AdditionalResultsandAnalysis +| | | | | | | | -1.61 | to | -5.22 bits | on CSQA | and | -2.03 | to - | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | ----- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | 3.00 | bits | on GSM8K) | and | disagreement | | scenar- | +C.1 AdditionalModels +| | | | | | | | ios | showing | the most | extreme | reductions | | (e.g., | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +Table12presentssourceinfluencemetricsforthe +| | | | | | | | user-correct/document-wrong: | | | | -5.22CSQA,-3.00 | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| remaining18models,includingallLlama3.1vari- | | | | | | | GSM8K). | | | | | | | +antsandadditionalQwen3modelsizes. Thispervasivesub-additivitydemonstratesthat +| | | | | | | | simultaneous | | sources | interfere | rather | than | stack: | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | +C.2 Distribution-LevelConfidenceDynamics +| | | | | | | | the | combined | distributional | | shift is | severely | con- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ---- | +onGSM8K +strainedcomparedtosummingindividualeffects, +Figure7showstherelationshipbetweenKLdiver- withdisagreementsshowingextremesuppression +genceandNLLchangeforGSM8K. +wherethejointpresentation(1.70to2.05bits)pro- +duceslessshiftthanmostsinglesourcesalone,asif +C.3 Sub-additivesourceinteractions;conflicts +contradictorysignalslargelyneutralizeeachother. +suppressmost +Wedefinefourscenarios: (1)both-correct,where C.4 SystemInstructionVariants +bothuseranddocumentassertthecorrectanswer Table14presentsthecompletesysteminstruction +| (averaging | v | and | v | ); | (2) both-wrong, | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | +| | u+d+ | | d+u+ | | | | variants | | that specify | which | information | sources | | +wherebothassertthesamewronganswer(averag- +modelsshouldusewhenanswering. +| ingv | andv | | );(3)user-correct/document- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ------- | --------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| u−d− | | d−u− | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | C.5 | SystemInstructionEffectson | | | | | | +| wrong, | where | sources | disagree | | with user | being | | | | | | | | +| correct | (averaging | v | | and v | ); | and (4) | | Qwen3-8B-NT | | | | | | +| | | | u+d− | | d−u+ | | | | | | | | | +document-correct/user-wrong,wheresourcesdis- +| | | | | | | | Figure | 8 | shows the effects | of | system | instructions | | +| ---------- | -------- | ---------------------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | +| agree with | document | | being | correct | (averaging | | onQwen3-8B-NT. | | | | | | | +| v andv | | ). Thefirsttwoform“agreement | | | | | | | | | | | | +| u−d+ | d+u− | | | | | | | | | | | | | +scenarios” where sources provide identical asser- C.6 Post-TrainingEffectsonSource +| tions,whilethelattertwoform“disagreementsce- | | | | | | | | Discrimination | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +narios”wheresourcescontradicteachother. Post-trainingeffectsvarybyreasoningtype. Fig- +Theinteractioneffectquantifieswhetherdouble +| | | | | | | | ure | 9 shows | the progression | | from pre-trained | | to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +sourceprobesproduceadditive,subadditive,orsu- +post-trainedmodels,averagingacrossallLlama3, +peradditivedistributionalshiftscomparedtotheir Llama3.1,andQwen3families. Post-trainingim- +componentsinglesourceprobes: +| | | | | | | | proves | resistance | to | misinformation | | on both | rea- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | +soningtypes,withdramaticgainsonGSM8K(av- +| Interaction | | =D | (P | ∥P | ) | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---- | --- | ------------------ | ----- | ---------- | --------------------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | +| | | KL | v | | v | | eraged | PAR+: | 0.16→0.42) | | and modest | gains | on | +| | | | | double | bare | | | | | | | | | +| | | −D | KL (P | vs1 ∥P | v ) | | CSQA(averagedPAR+: | | | 0.34→0.35),whileaver- | | | | +bare +agedreceptivenesstocorrections(SDR+)increases +| | | −D | (P | ∥P | ) | (11) | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | | | KL | vs2 | v | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | bare | | | | (0.88→0.90) | | | | | +| | | | | | | | slightly | on | CSQA | | but | decreases | on | +wherenegativevaluesindicatesubadditiveeffects GSM8K (0.83→0.77). This asymmetry suggests +(less shift than expected from the sum) and pos- that mathematical reasoning particularly benefits +itive values indicate super additive effects (more frompost-training’semphasisonverificationand +shiftthanexpected). Forinteractioncalculations, internalconsistencychecking,enablingmodelsto +v denotes any double source probe variant, better reject incorrect calculations, though at the +double +whilev s1 andv s2 denotethecorrespondingsingle cost of becoming less receptive to valid external +| source | components | that | match | the | correctness | of | corrections. | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eachsourceinthedoubleprobe. +| | | | | | | | C.7 | PresentationOrderEffects | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WefindthatacrossCSQAandGSM8K,when +models receive assertions from both user and We investigate how presentation order affects +document sources simultaneously, the combined source reliance in double-source probes by com- +distributional shift is dramatically less than the paring document-first versus user-first orderings. +sum of individual effects, with all four scenarios Figure10showsthatassertionordershiftssource +(both-correct,both-wrong,user-correct/document- preferences,withmodelsconsistentlyrelyingmore +wrong, user-wrong/document-correct) showing ontheassertionpositionedimmediatelybeforethe +| sub-additiveinteractions(Table13;rangingfrom | | | | | | | question. | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | CSQA | | | | GSM8K | | | | +| ----- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | SourceOR | | | | SourceOR | | | | +| | | | | | | U% | | | | | U% | +| Model | | Acc | Self | User | Doc | S% | Acc Self | User | Doc | S% | | +| | | | | | | D% | | | | | D% | +Llama3.1-8B 0.62 23.39 7.56 6.13 63.1 1.23 0.32 9.22 65.28 46.94 7.6 1.39 +Llama3.1-70B 0.74 14.16 16.31 10.49 34.6 1.55 0.41 12.55 34.29 40.41 14.4 0.85 +Llama3.1-8B-Inst 0.77 17.68 7.86 7.66 53.3 1.03 0.34 8.38 3.01 3.32 57.0 0.91 +Llama3.1-70B-Inst 0.83 20.93 9.09 10.38 51.8 0.88 0.59 11.85 4.46 6.39 52.2 0.70 +Qwen3-0.6B-Base 0.54 7.52 6.87 6.52 36.0 1.05 0.32 17.17 2.39 2.89 76.5 0.83 +Qwen3-1.7B-Base 0.67 15.01 13.56 13.07 36.0 1.04 0.38 14.29 21.56 23.20 24.2 0.93 +Qwen3-4B-Base 0.79 18.96 14.05 12.42 41.7 1.13 0.49 10.50 11.32 9.84 33.2 1.15 +Qwen3-14B-Base 0.84 23.70 10.36 11.78 51.7 0.88 0.54 13.90 9.36 12.17 39.2 0.77 +Qwen3-0.6B-NT 0.45 12.75 7.42 7.36 46.3 1.01 0.29 27.32 6.04 6.34 68.8 0.95 +Qwen3-1.7B-NT 0.65 10.38 6.93 8.88 39.6 0.78 0.33 7.87 20.53 23.83 15.1 0.86 +Qwen3-4B-NT 0.77 13.18 12.57 14.32 32.9 0.88 0.47 11.61 15.64 16.91 26.3 0.92 +Qwen3-14B-NT 0.81 15.92 12.51 14.66 36.9 0.85 0.59 12.38 10.94 13.61 33.5 0.80 +Qwen3-32B-NT 0.84 21.75 14.40 17.77 40.3 0.81 0.66 10.91 9.45 10.94 34.9 0.86 +Qwen3-0.6B-T 0.57 8.84 6.87 9.04 35.7 0.76 0.84 10.28 1.80 1.81 74.0 0.99 +Qwen3-1.7B-T 0.74 18.20 6.48 10.50 51.7 0.62 0.92 15.71 2.38 2.36 76.8 1.01 +Qwen3-4B-T 0.81 21.45 9.67 22.33 40.1 0.43 0.97 25.39 5.52 5.84 69.1 0.95 +Qwen3-14B-T 0.84 22.65 10.92 18.86 43.2 0.58 0.97 18.18 4.78 4.24 66.8 1.13 +Qwen3-32B-T 0.85 23.05 9.79 16.19 47.0 0.60 0.99 29.73 3.45 3.54 81.0 0.97 +Table12: SourceinfluencemetricsandbaselineaccuracyforadditionalLLMsonCSQAandGSM8K.Allmetrics +areaveragedacrossTier1/2assertionsanduser-first/document-firstorderings. Acc=baselineaccuracy(v ). +bare +ForQwen3models: Basedenotespre-trainedmodels,NTdenotespost-trainednon-thinkingmode,andTdenotes +post-trainedthinkingmode. +When switching from doc-first to user- tiers: from0.85to0.77inTier1andfrom1.04to +first ordering, median U% decreases (CSQA: 0.97inTier2. WhiletheTier2effectisweaker,the +| 29.1%→19.9%, | | | 28.1%→16.6%) | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +GSM8K: while directionaltrendisconsistent,indicatingthatpost- +21.7%→35.8%, +median D% increases (CSQA: trainingmovesmodelsmodestlytowardgreaterrel- +GSM8K:19.9%→38.0%),withmedianSelf%re- ativerelianceondocumentassertionsacrossboth +mainingrelativelystable(CSQA:43.9%→40.1%, +assertionstyles. +38.6%→38.0%). +| GSM8K: | | | This | pattern | demon- | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| strates clear | “recency | bias”: | models | rely | more | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | D Fine-tuningImplementationDetails | | | | | | +| on whichever | source | appears | | closest | to the | | | | | | | +question. Thispositionsensitivityhassignificant D.1 TrainingStrategies +implicationsforRAGsystemsandconversational +agents,whereassertionorderingcouldaltermodel Weconstructtrainingdatausingthe13probevari- +| | | | | | | ants. | We test two | training | strategies: | standard | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | +outputs. +| | | | | | | usesexclusivelybareexamples(v | | | | )withoutex- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +bare +ternalassertions,whilemixedprovidescomprehen- +C.8 Post-TrainingShiftsbyTier +| | | | | | | sive exposure | with | 30% bare | examples | | and 70% | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------- | +Tofurtherexaminewhetherthepost-trainingeffect distributed across the 12 assertion variants (10% +is consistent across assertion tiers, we separately each for correct single-source variants v , v ; +| | | | | | | | | | | | u+ d+ | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +comparetheU%/D%ratiosofpre-trainedandpost- 5%eachforincorrectsingle-sourcev u− ,v d− ;5% +trained Qwen3 models under Tier 1 and Tier 2 each for agreement v , v , v , v ; +| | | | | | | | | u+d+ | d+u+ | u−d− | d−u− | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +assertions. As shown in Table 15, post-training and5%forconflictvariantsv ,v ,v , +| | | | | | | | | | u+d− | u−d+ | d+u− | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | +| shiftstheaverageU%/D%ratiodownwardinboth | | | | | | v | ). | | | | | +d−u+ + +| | | CSQA | GSM8K | +| --- | --- | ---- | ----- | +SingleSource +| | User-Correct(v | ) 1.63 | 2.05 | +| --- | -------------- | ------ | ---- | +u+ +| | User-Wrong(v | ) 4.45 | 2.40 | +| --- | ------------ | ------ | ---- | +u− +| | Document-Correct(v | ) 1.72 | 2.14 | +| --- | ------------------ | ------ | ---- | +d+ +| | Document-Wrong(v | ) 5.65 | 2.89 | +| --- | ---------------- | ------ | ---- | +d− +DoubleSource +| | Both-Correct | 1.74 | 2.16 | +| --- | ----------------- | ---- | ---- | +| | Both-Wrong | 5.84 | 2.74 | +| | U-Correct/D-Wrong | 2.05 | 1.95 | +| | D-Correct/U-Wrong | 1.70 | 1.89 | +InteractionEffects +| | Both-Correct | -1.61 | -2.03 | +| --- | ----------------- | ----- | ----- | +| | Both-Wrong | -4.26 | -2.56 | +| | U-Correct/D-Wrong | -5.22 | -3.00 | +| | D-Correct/U-Wrong | -4.46 | -2.64 | +Table13: KLdivergencefrombareprobeaveragedacross27models,Tier1andTier2assertions. UandDdenote +useranddocumentsourcesrespectively. +Instruction AddedInstruction +Neutral(n) (noadditionalinstruction) +Doc-only(d) BaseyouranswerONLYontheinformationprovidedinthedocumentstatement. +Ignoreallothersourcesincludingyourownknowledgeandtheuserstatement. +User-only(u) Base your answer ONLY on the user’s statement. Ignore all other sources +includingyourownknowledgeandanydocumentstatement. +Self-only(s) BaseyouranswerONLYonyourowninternalknowledge. Completelyignore +anystatementsfromusersordocuments. +Table14: Systeminstructionvariantsforcontrollingwhichsourcesmodelscanusewhenanswering. +| ModelGroup | | Tier1U%/D% | Tier2U%/D% | +| ----------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | +| Qwen3-Base(pre-trained) | | 0.85 | 1.04 | +| Qwen3-NT/T(post-trained,avg.) | | 0.77 | 0.97 | +| ∆(Post−Pre) | | -0.08 | -0.07 | +Table15: Tier-separatedU%/D%ratiosforpre-trainedandpost-trainedQwen3models. Forpost-trainedQwen3, +valuesareaveragedovertheNTandTvariants. + +GSM8K +)stib( rewsnA tcerroC ni egnahC LLN +20 15 -3,921,432 -(1,737) -(1,426,973) -2,492,737 -4,303,933 - -$ - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - +Slopes 10 - - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS - (in thousands) -(unaudited) - -Cash flows from operating activities: - -Net income (loss) -Adjustments to reconcile net income (loss) to net cash provided by operating activities: - -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 - -$ - -88,361 $ - -(129,386) - -Depreciation and amortization -Stock-based compensation expense -Amortization of right-of-use assets -Amortization and write-off of content assets -Foreign currency remeasurement losses -Change in fair value of strategic investment in convertible promissory notes -Change in fair value of contingent consideration -Impairment of assets -Provision for credit losses -Other items, net -Changes in operating assets and liabilities: -Accounts receivable -Inventories -Prepaid expenses and other current assets -Content assets and liabilities, net -Other non-current assets -Accounts payable -Accrued liabilities -Operating lease liabilities -Other long-term liabilities -Deferred revenue - -Net cash provided by operating activities - -Cash flows from investing activities: - -Purchases of property and equipment -Purchase of business, net of cash acquired -Purchases of short-term investments -Purchases of strategic investments -Repayments of convertible promissory notes -Net cash used in investing activities - -Cash flows from financing activities: - -Issuance costs related to credit agreement -Proceeds from equity issued under incentive plans -Taxes paid related to net share settlement of equity awards -Repurchases of common stock - -Net cash used in financing activities - -Net (decrease) increase in cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash -Effect of exchange rate changes on cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — beginning of period -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — end of period - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -68,904 -354,169 -48,465 -223,230 -1,117 -(2,940) -2,301 -2,870 -2,439 -1,493 - -(63,464) -43,629 -2,249 -(184,457) -7,990 -(122,503) -87,621 -(80,493) -7,724 -(4,987) -483,718 - -(5,280) -(95,090) -(725,000) -(7,000) -50,000 -(782,370) - -— -34,734 -(164,850) -(149,982) -(280,098) -(578,750) -5,179 -2,160,639 -1,587,068 $ - -$ - -62,714 -384,662 -47,371 -229,340 -6,447 -(1,409) -— -29,118 -790 -(2,845) - -1,893 -(66,142) -(11,299) -(193,046) -(11,769) -(110,678) -38,385 -(63,835) -3,695 -4,039 -218,045 - -(5,061) -— -— -(20,000) -— -(25,061) - -(2,227) -9,380 -(96,356) -— -(89,203) -103,781 -(9,746) -2,066,604 -2,160,639 - -11 - - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS, CONTINUED - (in thousands) -(unaudited) - -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at end of period: - -Cash and cash equivalents -Restricted cash, current -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — end of period - -Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information: - -Cash paid for interest - -Income taxes paid (net of refunds)1: -Federal -State and local -Foreign -Total -Cash paid during the period for income taxes (prior to ASU 2023-09) -Supplemental disclosures of non-cash investing and financing activities: - -Non-cash contingent consideration for business combination -Unpaid portion of property and equipment purchases - -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 - -1,587,068 -— -1,587,068 $ - -2,160,236 -403 -2,160,639 - -1,055 $ - -460 - -1,831 -5,726 -6,133 -13,690 - $ - -65,815 $ -830 $ - -19,406 - -— -122 - -$ - -$ - -$ - -$ - -$ - -$ - -1 Individual jurisdictions equaling 5% or more of total income taxes paid (net of refunds) for the year ended December 31, 2025 include federal at $1.8 -million, New Jersey at $1.8 million, India at $1.7 million, United Kingdom at $1.1 million, Taiwan at $0.8 million, and Illinois at $0.7 million. - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -12 - - NON-GAAP INFORMATION -(in thousands) -(unaudited) - -Reconciliation of Net Income (Loss) to Adjusted EBITDA: - -Net income (loss) -Total other income, net -Stock-based compensation -Depreciation and amortization -Restructuring charges (1) -Income tax expense -Adjusted EBITDA - -Three Months Ended December 31, - -2025 - -80,477 $ -(25,736) -86,004 -17,390 -— -11,232 -169,367 $ - -2024 -(35,548) $ -(13,254) -101,538 -15,085 -— -9,677 -77,498 $ - -$ - -$ - -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 -(129,386) -(98,209) -384,662 -62,714 -30,999 -9,428 -260,208 - -88,361 $ -(99,522) -354,169 -68,904 -3,064 -5,537 -420,513 $ - -(1) Restructuring charges of $3.1 million and $31.0 million in fiscal year 2025 and 2024 primarily include asset impairment charges of -$2.9 million and $29.1 million, respectively. - -Net cash provided by operating activities -Less: Purchases of property and equipment - -Add/(Less): Effect of exchange rate changes on -cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash - -Free cash flow (TTM) - -Q4 24 - -Q1 25 - -Q2 25 -$ 218,045 $ 310,094 $ 396,421 $ 455,360 $ 483,718 -(5,280) - -Q3 25 - -Q4 25 - -(6,320) - -(5,061) - -(6,567) - -(6,647) - -(9,746) - -5,179 -$ 203,238 $ 298,446 $ 391,987 $ 443,007 $ 483,617 - -(5,328) - -(5,706) - -2,133 - -Roku Q4 2025 Shareholder Letter - -13 - +| | | | | | Single-Correct: -0.79 | | | (R=-0.96) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | Single-Wrong: +1.12 | | | (R=0.48) | +5 +| | | | | | Both-Correct: -0.76 | | | (R=-0.95) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | Both-Wrong: +1.13 | | | (R=0.47) | +0 +| | | | | | Conflict: +0.02 | | | (R=0.05) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | +5 +10 +| | 0 | 2 4 | 6 | 8 | 10 | 12 | 14 | 16 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +KL Divergence (bits) +| Single-Correct | | Single-Wrong | | Both-Correct | | Both-Wrong | | Conflict | +| -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +Figure 7: Relationship between KL divergence and NLL change (confidence) in correct answers, grouped by +assertioncorrectnessscenarios,across27modelsonGSM8K,averagedacrosstiers. +| )%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS 100 | | | | | 1.0 | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | 36.8 | | | | 0.8 | | | | +| 80 | | 41.5 | 39.8 | | | | | | +| | 49.4 | | | | | | Selective | | +| | | | | | +RAP 0.6 | | | | +60 +35.0 +31.1 +0.4 +| 40 | | 38.2 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +28.7 +Impressionable +| | | | | | 0.2 | | | (0.91, 0.21) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | +(0.92, 0.18) +| 20 | | | | | | | | ((00..9934,, 00..1143)) | +| --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | +| | 28.2 | | 29.1 | | | | | | +21.9 +20.3 +0.0 +0 +| Neutral | Doc-Only | User-Only | Self-Only | | | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 | +| ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +SDR+ +System Instruction Type +| | Self% | U% | D% | | | Neutral | | User-Only | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | Doc-Only | | Self-Only | +Figure8: Effectofsysteminstructionsonsourcereliance(left)anddiscriminationability(right)forQwen3-8B-NT, +averagedacrossCSQAandGSM8K. +D.2 TrainingDetails rank8,learningrate1×10−5,and3trainingepochs. +Werandomlysample5,000trainingexamplesfrom +We fine-tune Qwen3-8B-NT and Llama3-8B- thetrainsplitsofCSQAandGSM8K.Bothstrate- +| | | | | gies apply | their | distributions | to T1 | and T2 tiers | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------------- | ----- | ------------ | +InstructusingLow-RankAdaptation(LoRA)with + +| | | | CSQA | | | | | | GSM8K | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1.0 | | | | | | 1.0 | | | | | | | +| )egdelwonK cirtemaraP tcerroC gniniatniaM( +RAP | | | | | | )egdelwonK cirtemaraP tcerroC gniniatniaM( +RAP | | | | | | | +32B +| 0.8 | | | | | | 0.8 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +0 . 6 BSelective +| | Rigid | | | Selective | | | | Rigid | | 1 . 7 B | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | +14B +4B +8B +| 0.6 | | | | | | 0.6 | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 0.6B | | Post-trained avg | | | +| | | | | | 70B70B | | | | | (0.77, 0.42) | | | +| | | | | | 0 B8.B6B | | | 0.6B | | | | | +1342BB +| 0.4 | | | | | 1.7 8B8B | 4 B 0.4 | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | -------------------------------------- | -------------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | 8B | | 1 44 BB | | | | | 70B | | +| | | | | | P o s t- t r a i n | e d a8B0 3vBB2gB | | | | | | | +| | | | | P 0 r .(6 e 0B - | t ra i n e d a vg 6( B0 . 9 0 , 07 | 1.03 .4B77 5 B ) 14B | | | 8B | | | | +| | | | | | . 8 8 , 0 . 3 4 ) 0 . | | | | | | 70B | 32B | +| | Unreliable | | | Impressionable | 1.7B | 8B | Unreliable | | | Impressionable | | | +| | | | | | 8B | | | | | 1.7B | 14B | 14B | +| 0.2 | | | | | | 0.2 | | | | | 8B 4B | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | 1.7B 8B4B8B | | +Pre-trained avg +| | | | | | | | | | | (0.83, 0.16) | | 8B8B707B0B | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | +| 0.0 | | | | | | 0.0 | | | | | | | +0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 +SDR+ (Adopting Correct External Sources) SDR+ (Adopting Correct External Sources) +| | | | | Base/Pre-trained | | Thinking | Llama3 | Pre-trained avg | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | Non-thinking/Instruction-tuned | | Qwen3 | Llama3.1 | Post-trained avg | | | | | +Figure 9: Post-training effects on source discrimination across reasoning types. The plot shows PAR+ and +SDR+ values for pre-trained base models versus post-trained models (instruction-tuned modes for Llama and +non-thinking/thinking modes for Qwen3) from Llama3, Llama3.1, and Qwen3 families. Arrows indicate the +progressionfrompre-trainedbasemodelstopost-trainedmodelsaverages. Colorsindicatemodeltype: bluefor +base/pre-trained,redforpost-trainednon-thinkingmodes/instruction-tuned,greenforpost-trainedthinkingmodes. +Shapesindicatemodelfamily: circlesforLlama3,trianglesforLlama3.1,squaresforQwen3. +separately,yielding10,000totalexamples. Weuse modelsontwostandardbenchmarks: MMLU-Pro +LLaMA-Factory5 to perform the supervised fine- (Wangetal.,2024)andMathLevel5(Hendrycks +tuningandevaluateonthecompletetestsetscon- et al., 2021b). MMLU-Pro contains 14 subjects +taining1,221CSQAand1,319GSM8Kexamples coveringabroadrangeofknowledgeandreason- +across both tiers and source orderings (user-first, ingtasks. Forthisbenchmark,werandomlysample +document-first). Training takes approximately 2 100examplesfromeachsubject,resultingin1,400 +hoursandinferencetakesapproximately1houron evaluationsamplesintotal. ForMathLevel5,we +| H100GPUs. | | | | | | evaluateonall1,324availableexamples. | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | D.5 | Gain-ForgetAnalysis | | | | | | +D.3 EvaluationProbeGroups +We evaluate accuracy across four probe variant We further compare the fine-tuned models with +theircorrespondingoriginalmodelsonthesestan- +| groups: | Bare(v | )forbaselineparametricperfor- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bare +| | | | | | | dard | benchmarks | | by counting | gained | | examples | +| ----------------------------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --------------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | -------- | +| mance;Pos(positiveassertions: | | | | v | ,v ,v | , | | | | | | | +| | | | | u+ | d+ u+d+ | (basewrong→SFTcorrect)andforgottenexam- | | | | | | | +| v | ) where | external | assertions | provide | correct | | | | | | | | +d+u+ +→ +answers; Neg (negative assertions: v , v , ples (base correct SFT wrong). The results +| | | | | | u− | d− | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | are | summarized | in | Table | 16. Overall, | | the gain- | +| v | , v | ) where external | | assertions | provide | | | | | | | | +u−d− d−u− +forgettrade-offissmallacrosssettings,andseveral +| incorrect | answers; | and | Conflict | (v u+d− | , v u−d+ | , | | | | | | | +| --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +v ,v )whereuseranddocumentassertions model-benchmarkpairsshowpositivenetchange. +d+u− d−u+ +| | | | | | | These | results | are | consistent | with | the small | accu- | +| --------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | +| disagree. | For | groups with | multiple | variants | | (Pos, | | | | | | | +racychangesreportedinthemaintextandfurther +Neg,Conflict),thereportedaccuracyistheaverage +acrossallvariantsinthatgroup. suggestthatmixedSFTdoesnotcausesubstantial +catastrophicforgetting. +D.4 StandardBenchmarkEvaluationSetup +ToassesswhethermixedSFTaffectsmodels’gen- +| eral | capabilities | beyond | our | constructed | source- | | | | | | | | +| ---- | ------------ | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +conflictprobes,wefurtherevaluatethefine-tuned +5https://github.com/hiyouga/LLaMA-Factory + +| | CSQA (Doc-First) | | | | | CSQA (User-First) | | | +| ------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | +| 80 | | | | 80 | | | | | +| 70 | | | | 70 | | | | | +| )%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS | | | | )%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS | | | | | +60 +60 +50 +| 50 | =45.9 | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +=43.9 +M=45.9 +| 40 | | | | 40 | M=40.5 | | | =35.8 | +| --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------ | +| | | =31.6 | | | | | | M=35.8 | +| 30 | | | | 30 | | | | | +M=29.1 +| | | | =22.5 | | | | =20.3 | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| 20 | | | M=21.7 | 20 | | | | | +M=19.9 +| 10 | | | | 10 | | | | | +| ------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | +| 0 | | | | 0 | | | | | +| | Self% | U% | D% | | Self% | U% | | D% | +| | GSM8K (Doc-First) | | | | GSM8K (User-First) | | | | +| 80 | | | | 80 | | | | | +| 70 | | | | 70 | | | | | +| )%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS | | | | )%( oitaR ecnaileR ecruoS | | | | | +| 60 | | | | 60 | | | | | +| 50 | | | | 50 | | | | | +| | =44.1 | | | | =43.5 | | | | +| 40 | | | | 40 | | | | M=38.0 | +| | M=39.6 | | | | M=38.8 | | | =34.7 | +=31.2 +| 30 | | | | 30 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +=24.7 +| | | M=28.1 | | | | | =21.8 | | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| 20 | | | M=19.9 | 20 | | | | | +M=16.6 +| 10 | | | | 10 | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 0 | | | | 0 | | | | | +| | Self% | U% | D% | | Self% | U% | | D% | +| | | | Self% U% | D% | Mean Median | | | | +Figure 10: Presentation order effects on source reliance across 27 models. Switching from doc-first to user- +firstorderingdecreasesU%whileincreasingD%,demonstratingthatmodelspreferentiallyrelyontheassertion +appearingimmediatelybeforethequestion. +| | Benchmark | SFTVariant | | | Gain Forget | NetChange | | | +| --- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | +| | | Qwen3-8B(GSM8K) | | | 51 | 64 | -13 | | +MMLU-Pro +| | | Qwen3-8B(CSQA) | | | 57 | 63 | -6 | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Llama3-8B-Instruct(GSM8K) | | | 90 | 70 | +20 | | +| | | Llama3-8B-Instruct(CSQA) | | | 114 | 84 | +30 | | +| | | Qwen3-8B(GSM8K) | | | 91 | 78 | +13 | | +MathLevel5 +| | | Qwen3-8B(CSQA) | | | 77 | 55 | +22 | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | Llama3-8B-Instruct(GSM8K) | | | 44 | 45 | -1 | | +| | | Llama3-8B-Instruct(CSQA) | | | 38 | 40 | -2 | | +Table16: Gain-forgetanalysisonstandardbenchmarksafterSFT.Gaincountsexampleswheretheoriginalmodel +isincorrectbuttheSFTmodelbecomescorrect;Forgetcountsexampleswheretheoriginalmodeliscorrectbutthe +SFTmodelbecomesincorrect;NetChange=Gain-Forget. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q32/random_k4/random_4.md b/q32/random_k4/random_4.md index 481e365c46bf38073a1bbbbafb7d7f3283256258..5aa602e7fdd86b41f160b8fb2430ecc9847ae72b 100644 --- a/q32/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q32/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,180 +1,128 @@ -AMAZFIT ACTIVE -Product Manual -A2211 +Competitive Analysis - 01 Package Contents +Kit Needham -Smartwatch with band × 1 + Any way the customer +is solving the problem now is +competition -Charging base × 1 + DIRECT vs INDIRECT -Instruction Manual × 1 +DIRECT – similar products and services -1 +INDIRECT – solving same problem for same +target market with a different product or +service - 02 About the Watch + Who are Uber’s competitors? -Power button +Direct? -Heart rate sensor +Indirect? -Charging contacts + Competitive Factors -Note: Press and hold the power button to turn on the watch. If the watch cannot be turned on, -please charge it and then try again. +What makes a customer choose one +solution over another? -2 +Price – cheaper +Service – faster, personalized, convenient +Quality - lasts longer, stylish, tastes better - 03 Pairing the Watch +At most, you can only compete +on 2 out of the 3 -Zepp is a must-have app for this watch. It provides scientific sleep and workout -guidance and personalized health services to help you start a healthy lifestyle. + Unfair Advantage -1. Use your mobile phone to scan the QR code on the right side to download - and install the app, or search for the app in the Google Play Store or Apple - App Store and then download and install the the latest version of the app. -2. Open the app, register an account and log in. -3. Pair the watch as prompted by the app. +Core competency that cannot be copied or +bought +- Deep domain expertise (hospital systems) +- One amazing hard thing (Google algorithm) +- Authority (existing reputation in market) +- Dream Team (previous startup success; rock -Note: -1. For better user experience, please use the most recent version of the app. -2. The operating system needs to be Android 7.0, iOS 14.0, or above. -3. Do not pair the watch directly using your mobile phone’s Bluetooth. Follow the steps in the app to pair - your watch correctly. +star) -3 + Templates for Analysis -Download Zepp App + Most Common Format - 04 Charging the Watch +You -1. Connect the watch's charging cable to a power adapter or a computer's USB port. -2. Put the watch into the charging base. Pay attention to the direction and position of the watch, and - make sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch fit closely with the charging base. -3. When charging s tarts, the watch screen displays the charging progress. +Competitor 1 -Note: -1. Please use the charging base that comes with the watch. - Make sure that the charging base is dry before charging. -2. Please use a 1A or above power adapter. +Competitor 2 -4 +Competitor 3 - 05 Disassembling and Assembling the Watch Strap +Competitor 4 -Please refer to the illustrations to disassemble or assemble the watch strap. +Feature 1 -Note: Once the strap is assembled, pull the strap properly to ensure it is installed successfully. +Feature 2 -5 +Feature 3 - 06 Wearing the Watch +Feature 4 -1. In order to ensure the accuracy of heart rate, blood oxygen, - and other measurements, please wear your watch at a distance - of at least one finger away from the carpal, and keep the strap - at a comfortable snugness. -2. During workout, please wear it as tightly as possible to ensure - that the watch does not shake. Wear your watch at a distance - of at least one finger away from the carpal to obtain more accurate - heart rate data. After workout, you can loosen the strap appropriately - to ensure a comfortable wear experience. -3. When measuring blood oxygen saturation, wear the watch correctly. Avoid wearing the watch on the - wrist joint, keep your arm flat, maintain comfortable (appropriately tight) fitting between the watch and - the skin of your wrist, and keep your arm still throughout the measurement process. +Feature 5 -Note: -When affected by external factors (arm sag, arm sway, arm hair, tattoo, etc.), the measurement result may -be inaccurate or the measurement may fail and provide no output. + Examples of Features -6 +• Price +• Benefits +• Quality +• Durability +• Image/style +• Service +• Warranties +• Convenience - 07 Basic Parameters +• Ease of Use +• # of features +• Type of features +• Wow factor +• Location(s) +• Distribution/Sales +• Certifications +• Endorsements -Product Name: Smart Watch Operating temperature: 0°C to 45°C -Product model: A2211 Water resistance rating: 5 ATM -Input: DC 5V 500mA MAX Bluetooth frequency: 2402–2480 MHz -Bluetooth version: V5.2 -Bluetooth output power: <12 dBm -View product certification information on the watch's Settings > System > Regulatory page. -Device requirements: Devices installed with Android 7.0 or iOS 14.0 or above OS versions. + Where do you find info -The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by -Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such marks by Anhui Huami Information -Technology Co., Ltd. is under license. Other trademarks and trade names -are those of their respective owners. +1. Customer Discovery interviews +2. Advertising +3. Sales Brochure +4. Newspapers/Magazines +5. Website +6. Online sites that rate products/services +7. Your business and professional network -7 + Other - 08 Battery Safety +• Research competitors that no longer are in -1. This device is equipped with a built-in battery that cannot be removed or replaced. Do not disassemble - or modify the battery by yourself. -2. Disposal of a battery into fire or a hot oven, or mechanically crushing or cutting of a battery, that can - result in an explosion. -3. Leaving a battery in an extremely high temperature surrounding environment can result in an - explosion or the leakage of flammable liquid or gas. -4. A battery subjected to extremely low air pressure may result in an explosion or the leakage of - flammable liquid or gas. -5. Do not drop, hit, squeeze, or puncture the battery, and avoid exposing the battery to large external - pressure, which may cause short circuit and overheating inside the battery. +business -8 - - 09 Safety Notice +• Research matrix will be messy; matrix for -1. Do not allow children or pets to bite or swallow the product or its accessories, as this may cause injury. -2. Do not place this product under excessively high or low temperatures, which may cause the product to - catch fire or explode. -3. Do not place this product near heat sources or open flame, such as ovens and electric heaters. -4. Some people may experience allergic skin reactions to plastics, leathers, fibers, and other materials, and - symptoms such as redness, swelling, and inflammation will occur after long-term contact with this - product's components. If you experience such symptoms, please discontinue use and consult your - doctor. -5. Do not use unauthorized or incompatible power adapters or data cables, which may damage the watch - and accessories, or cause fire, explosion, or other hazards. -6. The radio waves generated by this product may affect the normal operation of implanted medical - devices or personal medical devices, such as pacemakers and hearing aids. If you use any such medical - devices, consult the manufacturer for relevant usage restrictions. -7. Do not dispose of this device or its accessories as ordinary household waste. Please make sure you - dispose of or recycle this device and its accessories in accordance with local laws and regulations. - -9 - - 10 Repair and Maintenance - -1. Avoid using detergents such as soap, hand sanitizer, bath foam, or lotion for cleaning to prevent chemical - residues from irritating the skin, corroding the device, or degrading the water resistance of the device. -2. After wearing the device while bathing (for devices that support bathing), swimming (for devices that - support swimming), or sweating, please promptly clean and dry the device. -3. The leather strap is not waterproof. Avoid getting the strap wet, as this may shorten its service life. -4. When using light-colored watch straps, avoid contact with dark clothing to prevent staining. -5. Do not wear your watch during snorkeling, hot showers, hot springs, saunas (steam rooms), diving, - underwater diving, water skiing, and other activities involving high-speed water currents. -6. Do not place the device in direct sunlight for long periods. Excessively high or low ambient temperature - may cause device failure. -7. Handle with care during transportation. Keep the device dry and away from humidity. -8. Do not wear the watch in MRI examinations and other highly magnetic environments. Otherwise, the - watchmay be damaged. - -10 - - 11 Troubleshooting - -Please check the FAQ on the website: https://support.amazfit.com/en. -If the product is not in use for a long period of time, it is recommended that you power off the product before -storing it. Recharge the battery every 6 months to 100% to prevent battery damage by over-discharge due to -long-term storage. - -12 Warranty and Return Policy - -The Amazfit Limited Warranty covers Amazfit products against manufacturing defects beginning on the -original purchase date. The warranty period is 12 months or another specified period as the applicable -consumer laws in the consumer’s country of purchase require. Our warranty is in addition to rights provided -by applicable consumer laws. - -Official website: en.amazfit.com -Support: support.amazfit.com/en - -11 +investment pitches are summaries of +strongest competitors with most important +features + + Finally + +• Describe your competitive advantage + +Benefits sell +Features tell + + Examples + + Specialty analysis examples + + Positioning diagram but will still +need a feature matrix analysis + + Works if there are only two main +features/dimensions diff --git a/q33/random_k2/question.json b/q33/random_k2/question.json index 2cd18b7f56200538598c4a56c4c99d97dfb0e563..f7a9dd7581a821ff9cc9aee4433a92524928956e 100644 --- a/q33/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q33/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "efd88e41c5f2606c57929cac6c1c0605.pdf", - "web_eb595c42c11e1922.pdf", - "5fdcf120b846746985684fa54250aab44639b30c.pdf" + "web_6a55c713826db217.pdf", + "web_0e04ded35ac1bdc2.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q33/random_k2/random_1.md b/q33/random_k2/random_1.md index e69f9af4739cdd1be4b25214374a527c28edba66..5c5eba2e1fd980c21e8cbb1cd873801d5dedd049 100644 --- a/q33/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q33/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,854 +1,2541 @@ -READ AND SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -WARNING: A risk of fire and electrical shock exists in all -electrical appliances and may cause personal injury or death. -Please follow all safety instructions. + CONTENTS -Espresso/Cappuccino Maker +01 +04 + 16 +36 +38 +39 +40 +41 +44 +45 -I +/ About HKU Business School + +/ Explore Your Options + +/ Enrich Your Life + +/ 2026 JUPAS Admissions + +/ 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions + +/ 2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +/ Develop Your Career + +/ Freshmen Sharing + +/ Our Global Presence + +/ Useful Websites + +About HKU Business School + +HKU Business School strives to nurture first-class business leaders and foster academic and relevant +research to serve the needs of Hong Kong, Chinese Mainland and the rest of the world in the new Asia-led +economy. As Asia’s premier international business school, we engage leading scholars from all corners of the +globe and they instil in students global knowledge with an Asian perspective. + +With the highest proportion of non-local undergraduate students across all Faculties at HKU, four of our +undergraduate programmes ranked amongst the University’s Top 10 programmes in 2025#, HKU Business +School attracts the best and brightest students from Hong Kong and beyond. + +HKU Business School is fully accredited by the European Quality Improvement Systems (EQUIS) and the +Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB). + +# Based on average JUPAS admission scores in the best 5 subjects in HKDSE + +VISION +To be a leading, +globally-impactful academic +institution of business and +economics. + +UNIQUE +PROPOSITION + +Deeply rooted in Hong Kong +Fully engaged with China +Truly international + +MISSION +STATEMENT + +To provide world-leading +business and economics +education that nurtures +dynamic and responsible +leaders. +To advance the frontiers of +knowledge through innovative +and globally-significant +research. +To create positive change in the +world by partnering with +communities. + +01 + + Dean’s Message + +I am delighted to introduce you to the HKU Business +School, a dynamic and forward-thinking academic +community where transformative opportunities and +unparalleled experiences await. + +As a part of the University of Hong Kong, which +proudly ranks 11th globally in the 2026 QS World +University Rankings, HKU Business School stands out +as a beacon of excellence in business and economics +in Asia. This year marks the 25th anniversary of our +Faculty, we continue to march forward as a leading, +impactful business school, championing +globally +research, and +leadership, pioneering +thought +educational excellence. + +of + +dynamic, + +challenging + +responsible, + +Our mission is to inspire and develop the next +generation +and +globally-minded business leaders. We offer a vibrant +and +learning environment where +students are encouraged to push their limits, think +critically, and innovate. Our team of leading scholars +from around the world, and experienced and +dedicated teachers as well as mentors bring a wealth +of knowledge, global perspectives, and personalised +guidance beyond the classroom. Our full spectrum of +top-quality degree programmes, including 11 diverse +undergraduate programmes and four dual bachelor’s +degrees +in partnership with world-renowned +universities, is designed to equip students with +cutting-edge knowledge and technical skills to +in the fast-changing global +navigate and excel +business landscape. + +In response to the transformative power of artificial +intelligence, we are proud to launch the Second Major +and Minor programmes in “Artificial Intelligence in +Business” +to our +(AIB), offered exclusively +undergraduate students. These programmes are +designed to equip future business +leaders with +practical proficiency in AI technologies, strategic +insight to drive cross-sector innovation, and a critical +understanding of the ethical and societal implications +of AI adoption. Through a rigorous curriculum that +integrates business fundamentals with cutting-edge +AI applications, students will be empowered to tackle +complex challenges and create meaningful impact in +a data-driven world. + +Greetings from +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +inspiration + +Business education today is an evolving domain that +builds upon learning from all academic disciplines and +draws +successful and +from both +unsuccessful business practices. Our undergraduate +curricula in six core academic areas equip students +with diverse knowledge across business and +economics spheres, and prepare them to be creative +leaders of tomorrow with global perspectives. + +A hallmark of our School that separates us from the +others is our truly multi-disciplinary approach. HKU +Business School’s extensive resources offer students +in +a wide range of choices, combining studies +economics and finance, accounting and finance, +accounting and data analytics, business and law, +business and data analytics, international business +and global management, as well as dual degrees in +collaboration with world-renowned universities. + +Our faculty members will engage you with their +inspiring teaching and how they bring their impactful +research into the classroom. They will open your mind +to diverse perspectives, +ignite your curiosity to +explore innovative ideas, and instil in you an appetite +for acquiring new knowledge and extraordinary +experiences throughout your academic journey and +career development. Our students are among the +brightest and most creative of their peers. Our alumni +have gone on to forge brilliant careers in all sectors of +the +international business +community, and have formed a global network that +you will be a part of for the rest of your life. + +regional and + +local, + +I hope that you will share my enthusiasm for the +programmes and my admiration for the people who +have contributed to their development. I look forward +to having you as a member of the HKU Business +School family and a future leader in the world of +business. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Derek Chan +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +Through our extensive partnerships with over 300 +institutions and corporations across more than 40 +countries, as well as our unique network of centres in +Beijing, Shenzhen, Shanghai, Vietnam, and Barcelona, +our students gain unparalleled global experiential +and enrichment opportunities. Whether through +internships, overseas exchange programmes, or +hands-on +these experiences +sharpen practical skills, broaden perspectives, and +prepare students to confidently tackle real-world +challenges. + +industry projects, + +Joining HKU Business School means becoming part of +a community that supports your growth and success. +You will collaborate with brilliant minds, engaging in +stimulating discussions, and working on impactful +projects that make a difference. The friendships, +networks, and experiences you build here will last a +to a myriad of career +lifetime, open doors +opportunities, and empower you to overcome +challenges, pursue your passions with confidence, +and contribute positively to your community and the +world at large. + +If you are ready to embark on an exciting journey of +learning, discovery, and personal development, I +invite you to explore what HKU Business School has to +look forward to welcoming you to our +offer. I +community, where future leaders are nurtured and +dreams take flight. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Hongbin Cai +Dean +Chair of Economics + +0302 Explore Your Options +A Wide Selection of Programmes + +Bachelor of Business Administration [BBA] + +The BBA programme combines strong functional training with intensive exposure +to communication skills, computer applications, and other social science and/or +science subjects. Students can choose to major in the following area(s): + +Entrepreneurship, +Design and + Innovation* + +Finance + +Human Resource +Management + +Information Systems +and Analytics + +Marketing + +BBA Curriculum Structure + +Components -R -O -F -E -D -U -G -E -R A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + C -D -N + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +78 +24 +48 +6 + +108 + +240 + +*Candidates must undergo a selection process arranged by the Programme Coordinator for +declaring the EDI major. + +HKU – Sciences Po Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first two years at Sciences Po in France and the third +and fourth years at HKU. Programmes at Sciences Po are taught in English (no +French requirements for being admitted) with intensive French language +classes for all non-francophone students. + +Upon successful completion of the dual degree programme, students will be +awarded the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) degree from HKU and +a Bachelor’s degree from Sciences Po. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-sciences-po-dual- +degree-programme + +HKU – University of British Columbia +Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first and final years at HKU and the second and third +years at the University of British Columbia (UBC) in Canada, and graduate with +a Bachelor of Business Administration from HKU and a Bachelor of Commerce +from UBC upon successful completion of the programme. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-university-of-british- +columbia-dual-degree-programme + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba + +0504 + + Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting and +Finance [BBA(Acc&Fin)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting Data +Analytics [BBA(ADA)] + +The BBA(Acc&Fin) programme prepares students for a professional qualification +in accounting and provides the broad-based education in accounting and finance +which is necessary to progress toward a leadership role in the financial sector. +Students are required to take professional core in accounting and a minor in +finance, with an option to second major in finance. Tailor-made professional +internship opportunities with renowned +preparation programmes and +accounting firms and financial institutions are available for talented students. It +is accredited as an approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Acc&Fin) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + A -E -S -U B -1 -X -E -M -, +C + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course + +Minor in Finance* +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives + +D. + +Free Electives / Optional Minor + +*Students may opt to pursue a Major in Finance: + +Components -I +A B -T -K -X -E -M -S -L -E -D -O -M -N +C + +University Graduation Requirements + +Professional Core in Accounting + +Major in Finance +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Free Electives +Capstone Course + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +108 +24 +78 +6 + +36 +12 +24 + +42 + +Total + +240 + +Credits + +54 + +108 + +78 +30 +18 +24 +6 + +Total + +240 + +Similar to the BBA(Acc&Fin) programme, the BBA(ADA) programme prepares +students for a professional qualification in accounting. It provides students +with an option to focus on data analytics aspect in accounting instead of having +a minor in finance. It is an excellent choice for students who are interested in +STEM with accounting and business applications and wish to pursue their +career in the relevant fields. The intensive accounting training enables +BBA(ADA) students to distinguish themselves from students of the other data +analytics/STEM programmes. Students will be equipped with comprehensive +accounting and business knowledge that prepares them to obtain professional +qualifications in accounting. They will also acquire computer programming +and data analytics skills to meet the needs of the accounting and business +professions in today’s digital transformation economy. It is accredited as an +approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(ADA) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting Data Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +156 +24 +114 +12 +6 + +30 + +240 + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-acc-and-fin + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ada + +0706 + + Bachelor of Business Administration (Business Analytics) +[BBA(BA)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration (Law) and Bachelor of +Laws [BBA(Law)&LLB] + +The BBA(BA) programme is crafted to meet the growing industry demand for +talents in the business analytics field. Its curriculum offers students a +comprehensive coverage of both technical and managerial skill sets. Students +will learn a wide spectrum of knowledge from the disciplines of information +technology, data science, business statistics and management. Core courses +include programming language, database management, introduction to +business analytics, management information systems, decision and risk +analysis, etc. They help students build the foundations for advanced topics in +senior years. Students also have the option to choose from analytics technique +courses and business application courses. The aim is to provide students with +state-of-the-art experiences in artificial intelligence, big data, social media, +and other latest development. Such design helps train well-rounded students +who will be more adaptable in their career development. The programme is +suitable for students who have a passion for problem-solving through +analytics, and who aim to develop their career path in analytics. + +BBA(BA) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Business Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Analytics Techniques) +Disciplinary Electives (Business Applications) +Capstone Course + C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 + +90 + +Jointly offered by the HKU Business School and the Faculty of Law, the +BBA(Law)&LLB integrated double-degree programme blends two strategic +disciplines into a single programme for the bright and highly motivated. It is an +excellent choice for students seeking a broader education with parallel +concentration on legal and business studies. Graduates of the programme will be +awarded two degrees — BBA(Law) by the HKU Business School, and LLB by the +Faculty of Law. After successful completion of the LLB programme, students +may apply for admission to the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws (PCLL) +programme provided that they meet the relevant admission requirements. + +The programme offers business stream and accounting stream to students in +their business studies. The accounting stream is accredited by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Business Stream) + +Components + +Credits + +A + B -1 -X -E -M -D -N + +C + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Course +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +Professional Core in Law +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +D. + +Free Electives / Optional Minor + +Total + +240 + +Total + +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Accounting Stream) + +Components + A - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +B -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +University Graduation Requirements -left unattended. +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +C -See instructions for cleaning. +Professional Core in Law -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Total -children. +36 +6 +24 +6 +- -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +78 +24 +48 +6 -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +156 +108 +42 +6 -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +30 -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +300 -surfaces. +Credits -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +36 -heated oven. +108 +24 +78 +6 -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +156 -function knob to “OFF.” +300 -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ba -used. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-law-and-llb -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +0908 -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing + Bachelor of Business Administration in International Business +and Global Management [BBA(IBGM)] -cup or brew basket. +Bachelor of Economics [BEcon] -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +BBA(IBGM) is an intensive, premier programme in international business and +global management featuring a unique curriculum designed to evolve with and +reflect the ever-changing demands of a globalised world. Exclusive elements +such as overseas exchange studies, a leadership boot camp, an Asia-Pacific +study tour, an international field trip and global enrichment opportunities are +strategically integrated into the curriculum, whilst students are given the +flexibility to pursue an in-depth inquiry into another specialised area of study +as a second major. This cross-functional and personalised approach aims to +foster a selected group of outstanding students to become the world’s future +leaders equipped with global perspectives, cultural sensitivity, social +responsibility and key competencies to succeed in the international business +environment. -be used on a range top. +BBA(IBGM) Curriculum Structure -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +Components -weakened handle. +A -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +B -other abrasive material. +C -2 +D -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. +E -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. +Major in International Business and Global Management +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be +Second Major -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. +Free Electives -1 +Compulsory Overseas Exchange -2 +Total -8 +Credits -7 +54 +12 +36 +6 +- +96 +24 +54 +12 6 -5 +72-90 + +0-18* + +- + +240 + +*Students may use free electives to fulfil the second major where the requirements exceed 72 credits. -3 +The BEcon programme trains students in economic theories, statistical tools, +the application of theories to solve practical economic problems in trade, +banking and the labour market, and evaluation of the regional economic +performance of Chinese Mainland, Hong Kong and other economies. Students +will be furnished with solid theoretical and empirical economic knowledge to +analyse and understand human behaviour and social interactions. The +programme allows students a high degree of flexibility in planning their future +career specialisation. -4 +BEcon Curriculum Structure -3 +Components -1. Safety lid -2. Water +A -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +B -tip +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Major in Economics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -lid +C -7. Filter basket -and holder +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -8. Function -knob +Total - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +Credits -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -left unattended. +78 +24 +30 +18 +6 + +108 -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +240 -See instructions for cleaning. +Find out more: +http://ibgm.business.hku.hk -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon -children. +1110 -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool + Bachelor of Economics and Finance [BEcon&Fin] -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +BEcon&Fin is designed to meet the interests of students who are seeking a +balanced study of both economics and finance. The programme recognises +the significance of economics both in its own right and as a foundation for the +study of finance, and the significance of finance as a career path for students +who are keen on joining this profession. Students will receive solid training in +theories and applications of economics and finance. They will be equipped +with the skills to analyse human behaviour and social interaction, as well as to +solve problems in the financial sphere. -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +BEcon&Fin Curriculum Structure -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +Components -surfaces. +Credits -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +A -heated oven. +B -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -function knob to “OFF.” +Major in Economics and Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Economics Disciplinary Electives +Finance Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +C -used. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -cup or brew basket. +90 -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +Total -be used on a range top. +240 -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +HKU - Peking University “Future +Leaders” Dual Bachelor’s Degree in +Economics, Finance and Management +The programme combines the strengths of two leading business schools in +Hong Kong and Chinese Mainland and is designed to nurture first-class business +leaders and cultivate their global perspective with intimate understanding of +China. Students will spend the first two years at HKU and the third and fourth +years at Peking University (PKU), and be awarded a Bachelor of Economics and +Finance (BEcon&Fin) degree from HKU and a Bachelor of Management [BMgmt] +degree from PKU upon successful completion of the dual degree programme. -weakened handle. +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/admission/degree-program +mes/hku-pku-dual-degree -other abrasive material. +Bachelor of Finance in Asset Management and Private +Banking [BFin(AMPB)] +The BFin(AMPB) programme aims to prepare students to enter the rapidly +growing fields of asset management and private wealth management in Hong +Kong and Asia Pacific, or in banking and finance generally. During the first two +years, students complete introductory courses in accounting, economics, +mathematics, statistics, corporate finance, and investments and portfolio +analysis. In subsequent years, students take more specified and industry +related courses including equity valuation and investment in specific asset +classes e.g. private equity, venture capital, hedge funds and digital assets, +understanding of financial statements and doing financial analysis, lending +and credit in private wealth and corporate bank, financial regulations and +compliance, current +institutional +in finance, ESG +consulting and family office. The programme contains practical-oriented +courses taught by teachers with extensive experience in the finance industry +and offers an array of career-oriented enrichment activities and networking +opportunities with industry practitioners. -2 +investment, -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. +issues -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. +in -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. +BFin(AMPB) Curriculum Structure -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be +Components -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. +Credits -1 +A -2 +B -8 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -7 +Major in Asset Management and Private Banking +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 6 +- -5 +96 +24 +42 +24 +6 -3 +90 -4 +Total -3 +240 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon-and-fin -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bfin-ampb -tip +1312 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with + Bachelor of Science in Marketing Analytics and Technology +[BSc(MAT)] -lid +Bachelor of Science in Quantitative Finance [BSc(QFin)] -7. Filter basket -and holder +Marketing is critical to all businesses. It dictates whether a company will be +successful. Technology, Big Data, and digitization are fundamentally changing +how marketers operate. The BSc(MAT) programme equips students with +quantitative skills, technology know-how, and business marketing acumen to +pursue a career in the digital economy and modern businesses. It targets both +STEM students with an interest in business as well as business students +interested in the technology space. Students will gain a solid foundation in +cutting-edge technical areas including computer programming, data science, +and technology by excelling in courses from the Faculty of Engineering and +Faculty of Science. In addition, students will master digital business, +marketing and leadership through courses at the HKU Business School. This +interdisciplinary approach will enable students to engage in a variety of jobs +and functions such as the design and launch of new technology products, +targeting consumers, digital marketing, forecast and predicting markets, and +building a technology-focused strategy. The programme aims to nurture +future leaders in the field of technology and marketing who are able to use the +latest technology, science, and data analytics to support business and +marketing decisions in the digital world. -8. Function -knob +BSc(MAT) Curriculum Structure - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Components -Making Espresso Coffee +Credits -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +A -from the appliance. +B -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +Major in Marketing Analytics and Technology +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Technology and Strategy) +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Analytics) +Capstone Course -carafe. +C -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -brewing process – scalding may occur. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -function knob to the “OFF” position. +90 -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +Total -Making Cappuccino +240 -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +BSc(QFin) is a premium finance programme. Built on a solid foundation in +economics and finance, the programme equips students with the essential +quant skills, including mathematics, statistics, and programming, that are +required in more advanced and sophisticated analyses, such as valuation +models of structured products, risk management, simulation and data +analysis, financial engineering, and quantitative trading. -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +The programme goes beyond merely equipping students with quant skills. +More importantly, it stresses on combining these skills with an understanding of +the financial markets, the macro environment, and the practical situations +where financial managers work, with a balanced mix of quant and business +courses. To nurture students’ soft skills and market acumen, the programme +provides a wide range of value-enhancing activities, such as Round Tables with +Practitioners, Alumni Drinks, Executive Mentorship Scheme, Bloomberg training +workshops, simulation trading workshops, and an international field trip to +other international financial centres such as New York, London and Zurich. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +BSc(QFin) Curriculum Structure -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Components -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Credits -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +A -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +B -function knob to the “OFF” position. +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +Major in Quantitative Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +C -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -4 +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -5 +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +90 -Making Espresso Coffee +Total -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +240 -from the appliance. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-mat -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-qfin -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +1514 -carafe. + Enrich Your Life -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +initiative and +HKU Business School fosters a culture of student +implementation of ideas, both within and outside the campus, as it is +these real-world engagements that set us apart. Experiences in learning +beyond the classroom, extending into realms outside academia, enable +students to cultivate an understanding of social dynamics, cultural +diversity, and collaborative +intellect. These experiences contribute +significantly to their personal growth, interpersonal skills, and social +development, shaping them into global citizens, lifelong learners, and +future business leaders. -brewing process – scalding may occur. +Overseas Enrichment Experiences -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Business Exchange Programme / +HKUWW Undergraduate Student Exchange Programme +Even as the youngest Faculty at the University, our exchange +activities are nothing but phenomenal. Each year, over 400 +students participate in overseas exchanges at leading universities +to broaden their horizons. -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Business School +Exchange Partners * -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +Canada -Making Cappuccino +McGill University +University of British Columbia +University of Toronto +Western University +Simon Fraser University -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +U.K. -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +King's College London +University of Manchester +University of Edinburgh +University of Warwick -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +The Netherlands -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +University of Amsterdam +Erasmus University Rotterdam -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +400+ +exchange partners +across 40+ countries -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +400+ +Business School +students on exchange -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Denmark -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Copenhagen Business School +Aarhus University -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +Germany -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +Frankfurt School of Finance & Management +University of Mannheim +Munich Business School -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Belgium -4 +KU Leuven -5 +Italy - User Maintenance Instructions +Bocconi University -Descaling (Continued) +France -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +U.S. -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +Toulouse School of Economics +ESSEC Business School -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +New York University +University of Southern California +University of Washington +University of Georgia -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! +Middle East -Descaling +Reichman University -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Singapore -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +National University of Singapore +Nanyang Technological University -you would with water. +* This list is non-exclusive. + +International Field Trips +To enhance students' exposure to global businesses, the School organises +overseas field trips for students visiting corporate firms and mingling with +C-suite Executives in some of the world's most prominent financial +centres, e.g. Australia, France, Japan, London, New York City, Singapore, +Spain, and Zurich. + +Visiting Programmes +Through the Yale Visiting International Students Programme, students +are sent to spend a year at Yale University, where they actively engage +themselves in a multicultural society. With the generosity of the donors, +some of our students are selected for the Junior Year Abroad Programme +and Visiting Students Programme to study as visiting students at +Pembroke College and St Peter’s College of University of Oxford +respectively with substantial scholarships. The intellectual ambience of +these top universities is truly inspirational and conducive to learning. -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +Beta Gamma Sigma Regional Leadership Conference +Beta Gamma Sigma (BGS) is the international honour society that +serves business programmes accredited by the Association to Advance +Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB International). With the +establishment of the HKU BGS Chapter, the School registers students +annually for the BGS Regional Leadership Conference held in the U.S., +where they can meet and bond with many other fellow students from the +world's best business schools. The Leadership Summit is eye-opening +and challenging, which leads to a great journey of self-discovery. -outlet. +Japan + +Kyoto University + +Australia + +University of Sydney +Monash University +University of New South Wales + +1716 Student Sharing + +Chen, Hsuan-yu +Exchange at National University of Singapore (Singapore), 2024-25 + +As a third-year undergraduate student pursuing a double major in +Accounting and Finance, I consider it a tremendous privilege to have +participated in a one-semester exchange at the National University of +Singapore (NUS) through the Business Exchange Programme. This +invaluable opportunity has not only enriched my academic journey but +also broadened my global perspective through immersive cultural +experiences and meaningful cross-cultural interactions. As I move +forward in my academic and professional journey, I carry with me not +just the knowledge gained from my courses, but the invaluable life +lessons experienced from Exchange. + +Lee, Tsz To Derek +Exchange at King’s College London (United Kingdom), 2024-25 + +I am incredibly grateful to have this valuable opportunity to study +abroad at King’s College London. The programme provided me a chance +to venture outside of my comfort zone. Not only can you learn how to be +more independent, you can also boost interpersonal skills given the +many opportunities to socialise with others, which is essential for your +future career. The experience is remarkable. I think you will regret it if +you miss out on the overseas exchange programme. + +Cheung, Nga Ting Caroline +Exchange at University of New South Wales (Australia), 2024-25 + +This exchange programme has changed me in many ways. It has helped +me become more outgoing, allowing me to make new friends and +explore different cities. Living independently has been a significant part +of this journey. From exploring new cities to forming lasting friendships, +each adventure has enriched my life in ways I never expected. This +opportunity has not only broadened my horizons but also deepened my +appreciation for diversity and connection among people from different +backgrounds. Each memory I have created during this time is a treasure +that I will carry with me forever. + +Ho, Ying Tung Crystal +Exchange at Copenhagen Business School (Denmark), 2024-25 + +In the Fall semester, I participated in a business exchange programme at +Denmark’s Copenhagen Business School (CBS). This experience was +truly transformative, enriching me both academically and personally +while allowing me to forge lifelong memories and friendships. An +exchange experience abroad truly broadens your horizons and offers +insights beyond what textbooks and lectures can provide. You will gain +invaluable perspectives and undergo personal growth like never before. +I wholeheartedly encourage you to muster your courage and embark on +an exchange journey - you won’t regret it! + +Whitfield III, Gerald Bruce Trey +Exchange at New York University (United States), 2024-25 + +I found the exchange experience to be extremely enriching. A major +highlight for me was exploring the lifestyle and professional sides of the +city. Because of my initiative socially, and in groups such as church, I was +able to get well-acquainted with the local rhythms and lifestyle, and +also made many friends that I’d consider friends for a lifetime. I am +deeply appreciative of being given this rewarding experience, which +significantly shaped both my future and the person I am today. + +Ip, Wing Tung Alla +Student Representative for the BGS Regional Leadership +Conference 2025 in Highland Heights, Kentucky + +Attending the BGS Leadership Conference at Northern Kentucky +University proved transformative. I received profound insights into +leadership, communication and cultural intelligence through immersive +workshops, case competitions and networking opportunities. The event +prompted reflections on personal leadership styles and encouraged +collaboration across diverse peers. As I prepare to enter the workforce, +I intend to apply these learned principles of trust-building, cultural +sensitivity and collaborative leadership to navigate challenges so I can +shape my professional journey with purpose and authenticity. + +1918 Corporate Exposure + +HKU Business School has a strong tie with corporate partners. To nurture students' business +and market acumen, enrichment programmes are organised through the joint efforts of +corporate partnerships. + +Enrichment Programmes in collaboration with Corporate Partners +HKU Business School has been collaborating with corporate partners on initiatives to spice up +students' career exploration journey. The partnership with Accenture enables students to +gain exclusive insights into business consulting through the HKU-Accenture Business +Consulting Programme. + +To provide students with a unique opportunity to explore current business trends and +developments in the Greater Bay Area (GBA), our School has co-organised a tailored study tour +with The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA). This initiative aims to +enhance students’ readiness for future career development and personal success. Students will +have the chance to connect with seasoned accounting and business professionals in the GBA. + +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme +Leveraging the School's extensive network in the business and finance industry, we have +developed our own mentorship programme to furnish students with opportunities to +enhance their skills and knowledge essential for their future personal and career +development. Our students are empowered to connect to the real business world through +direct and active interaction with seasoned professionals, executives and entrepreneurs. + +Lee, Lok Yiu Angel +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +My mentor offered +invaluable career advice, highlighting key +considerations for entering specific fields and preparing for interviews. +Her experiences and mindset during job searches resonated with me as +I navigated something similar. She emphasised the importance of +open-mindedness and eagerness to learn in the workplace. I kept her +words at heart during my internship. I also enjoyed catching up with her +to share my new job experiences. + +Choi, Han Na Hannah +HKUBS x Deloitte China Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +As my mentor has been working in Deloitte China for more than 10 +years, I was most curious about how he maintains a work-life balance +and how he stays dedicated and professional at work. Through our +lengthy conversations over lunch, he passed on valuable insights on +developing soft skills and adopting an appropriate work attitude at an +early stage. He is more than an audit mentor but also a life coach to me. + +Chan, Chin Ching Jacky +BSc(QFin) Executive Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +Throughout the mentorship programme, I have received +precious guidance that has greatly influenced my career +path. My mentor highlighted the importance of identifying +a company that aligns with my goals and would provide +opportunities for me to develop the necessary skill sets. He +also shared practical advice on building and managing +professional and personal relationships. These lessons +have broadened my perspective and also equipped me +with the tools to handle real-world situations more +effectively and confidently. + +Wong, Wan Tat +HKUBS x ACCA Greater Bay Area Study Tour 2024-25 + +My greatest takeaway from this study tour was the power of peer +learning and collaboration. Being immersed in an environment with a +diverse group of individuals, all focused on similar goals, created an +incredible opportunity to learn from each other’s experiences and +perspectives. The collaborative projects and informal discussions were +invaluable in broadening my horizon and developing new approaches +to the accounting field in Chinese Mainland. I am leaving with a strong +network of contacts and a renewed appreciation for teamwork. + +Leung, Ho Lun Maverick +HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme 2024-25 + +I visited + +The HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme immersed me in +an authentic consulting experience through working with a real client – +their distribution centres, conducted market +HKTV. +questionnaires, and presented the final deliverables - all within the +eight-week programme. I was honoured to meet Managing Directors +from Accenture who shared crucial skills in conducting a consulting +project. It’s truly one of the best programmes for anyone considering a +consulting career! + +2120 Experiential Learning Programmes + +Experiential learning is embedded in our course curriculum. The Business Consulting +Practicum offers business and economics students hands-on experience in working with +clients to solve "real-life" problems relevant to their studies, under the guidance of faculty +members and professional mentors. The Business Case Analysis and Presentation enables +students to communicate and seek practical advice from senior executives through in-class +case presentations. The Impact Lab provides students with an excellent opportunity to work +directly with social ventures, again under the guidance of teachers and professional mentors. +Additionally, students can gain an in-depth understanding of the latest trends in economics, +finance, creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurship in the rapidly growing Greater Bay Area +by participating in the Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China Programme. + +Chaabane, Adam Andrea +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +I have learned that prominent businessmen and professionals in Hong +Kong are people like me who were once attending business school. I +most enjoyed the guest +lectures because they allowed direct +interactions with inspiring figures. The virtual experience enabled me to +follow this programme easily from my home country. I definitely +recommend it for a better understanding of Hong Kong and GBA’s +markets and opportunities that arise in cross-border business. It would +be great to learn more about opportunities for foreigners in the region. + +Kaur, Suchleen +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +The opportunity for real-time interaction and feedback with the client had +propelled me to join BCP. I was always curious about how a consultant +would address and communicate with the client. BCP has taught me +about proper business etiquette and equipped me the necessary skills to +negotiate conflicting opinions during team discussions. Throughout the +process, our mentor and professors provided great help and insights. +Their invaluable feedback and questions helped nudge us in the right +direction, taking a step back to look at the big picture and most +importantly, prioritise the client’s needs. + +Zhou, Qingzhuo +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +My greatest takeaway from the CIEC 2025 programme was the unique +window to gain a comprehensive understanding of the Greater Bay +Area’s dynamic business landscape. I explored the latest trends in +business, finance, and innovation from guest talks and virtual lectures +with industry leaders. I particularly appreciate the coverage on a +diverse range of topics and the opportunity to earn HKU credits. A +highlight was the cultural exploration segment which offered an +unparalleled perspective on the Greater Bay Area. I recommend this +programme without hesitation. + +Tsang, Tze Yeung Matthew +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +BCP has been a rewarding experience that allowed me to apply my +academic knowledge to real-world business challenges. Working +directly with my mentor and client has pushed me to think critically and +creatively in ways I hadn't experienced in the classroom. I'm confident +that the problem-solving, communication, and client-facing skills I have +developed will serve me well when pursuing my future career in +consulting or another business-oriented field. + +2322 Cheung, Ho Ning Jolie +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 (Champion) + +in UW GBCC was an + +Competing +incredibly rewarding and +unforgettable experience. We had the opportunity to work with +participants from different universities. +It was a fantastic +opportunity to exchange perspectives and learn from different +problem-solving approaches. Working under tight timeframes +pushed us to think creatively. UW GBCC has not only elevated my +professional capabilities but further solidified my belief in business +as a powerful vehicle for creating positive change in the world. + +Case Competitions + +The School provides ample opportunities to refine students' presentation and analytical skills +through a myriad of local as well as overseas competitions. From training to delicate analysis +of business cases to a variety of business scenarios, students are equipped with different +skillsets to compete with candidates from the world's leading universities. + +Lo, Nikkia +NHH International Case Competition 2024 (Champion) + +My week at NHH International Case Competition has been an +unforgettable rollercoaster of emotions. From the excitement of +exploring a new Nordic city, the exhaustion of our 24-hour case +competition, to the nervous anticipation of pitching on a global stage +with a +livestream, every moment was extraordinary. Meeting +like-minded peers around the world was an incredible experience that +forged new friendships. Thank you, HKU Business School, along with +our professors, coaches and staff for bringing this opportunity to us! -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Xia, Yunchu Kevin +The McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 (First Place) -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Winning first place at MBSC2025 was incredible and deeply rewarding. +My team was highly engaged. We were constantly bouncing ideas off +each other and refining our strategy. There were moments where we hit +roadblocks, but our team rallied, challenged each other constructively +and developed a cohesive solution. Connecting with like-minded +participants, judges and NGOs was also invaluable. MBSC not only +sharpened my analytical and presentation skills but also reaffirmed my +commitment to leveraging business for good. I am so grateful for the +experience and very eager to apply these lessons moving forward! -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +2524 Liu, Yunqi Iris +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 (Outstanding Team Award) -to continue to flow in the carafe. +This competition has been a fantastic learning experience. It +showed me that tax isn’t just about the technical details - it’s also +deeply connected to social trends and global events like climate +change, geopolitical conflicts and national policies. This broader +perspective has enhanced my understanding of the industry and +its importance in today’s world. I want to express my sincere +gratitude to my advisors for their guidance and recognition of my +team’s hard work. I am grateful for the opportunity to learn and +grow with such an amazing group of people. -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +Pan, Ho Man Vivian +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 (Champion) -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +in -vinegar. Repeat twice. +the HKGCC Case Competition was a -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Participating +truly +transformative experience that greatly enhanced my strategic +thinking, teamwork and problem-solving skills. The competition +challenged me to analyse intricate business problems, think critically +under pressure and develop innovative solutions. Working closely +with people of various majors allowed me to appreciate differing +opinions that were at times conflicting, find ways to build consensus +and synthesize ideas effectively. -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Students' achievements in case competitions +(2023-2025 awards) -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Overseas / Chinese Mainland -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Asia Pacific Sustainable Marketing Case Competition 2025 -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Third Place -Thank You +Bloomberg Global Trading Challenge 2023 -6 +CBS Case Competition 2023 -7 +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Asia Pacific Regional Final - User Maintenance Instructions +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Sub-Regional Final -Descaling (Continued) +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 - North Asia Final -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +Champions' Trophy Case Competition 2024 -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +Grand Prize Winner +Regional Prize Winner: Asia & Oceania -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +Winner -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! +Winner -Descaling +Winner -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Champion -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Finalist -you would with water. +China Mainland, Hong Kong and Macao Digital Economy Innovation and +Entrepreneurship Competition 2024 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +2nd Runner-up (Gold Medal) -outlet. +Deloitte Digital Camp 2024 -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Deloitte Digital Camp 2023 -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Second Place -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +Champion -to continue to flow in the carafe. +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - National Round -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +Outstanding Team Award -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - Regional Round -vinegar. Repeat twice. +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - National Round -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - Regional Round -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Top 3 teams -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Merit Award -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Top 3 teams -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2023 Case Competition -Thank You +2nd Runner-up -6 +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2023 -7 - - ONE-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY -This Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. product warranty extends to the original consumer purchaser of -the product. -Warranty Duration: This product is warranted to the original consumer purchaser for a period of one -(1) year from the original purchase date. -Warranty Coverage: This product is warranted against defective materials or workmanship. This -warranty is void if the product has been damaged by accident, in shipment, unreasonable use, -misuse, neglect, improper service, commercial use, repairs by unauthorized personnel or other caus- -es not arising out of defects in materials or workmanship. This warranty is effective only if the product -is purchased and operated in the USA, and does not extend to any units which have been used in -violation of written instructions furnished by Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc., or to units which have been -altered or modified or to damage to products or parts thereof which have had the serial number -removed, altered, defaced or rendered illegible. -Warranty Disclaimers: This warranty is in lieu of all warranties expressed or implied and no -representative or person is authorized to assume for Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. any other liability in con- -nection with the sale of our products. There shall be no claims for defects or failure of performance or -product failure under any theory of tort, contract or commercial law including, but not limited to, neg- -ligence, gross negligence, strict liability, breach of warranty and breach of contract. -Warranty Performance: During the above one-year warranty period, a product with a defect will be -either repaired or replaced with a reconditioned comparable model (at Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -option) when the product is returned to the Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. facility within the warranty period -and an additional one-month period. No charge will be made for such repair or replacement. -Service and Repair: Should the appliance malfunction, you should first call toll-free 1-800-233-9054 -between the hours of 9:00 am and 5:00 pm Central Standard Time and ask for CUSTOMER SERVICE -stating that you are a consumer with a problem. -In-Warranty Service (USA) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is made -for service or postage. -In-Warranty Service (Canada) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is -made for service or postage. Please return the product insured, packaged with sufficient protection, -and postage and insurance prepaid to the address listed below. Customs duty/brokerage fee, if any, -must be paid by the consumer. -Out-of-Warranty Service: A flat rate charge by model is made for out-of-warranty service. Include -$15.00 (U.S.) for return shipping and handling. -Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. cannot assume responsibility for loss or damage during incoming shipment. -For your protection, carefully package the product for shipment and insure it with the carrier. Be sure -to enclose the following items with your appliance: any accessories related to your problem; your full -return address and daytime phone number; a note describing the problem you experienced; a copy of -your sales receipt or other proof of purchase to determine warranty status. C.O.D. shipments cannot -be accepted. -Return the appliance to: - -ATTN: Repair Department, Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. - -550 Business Center Drive -Mt. Prospect, IL 60056 -Consumer Service: 1-800-233-9054 -Consumer Parts: 1-800-947-3745 -Hours: 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. CST - -For more information on Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. products: - -visit our website: URL http://www.salton-maxim.com or -E-mail us at SALTON 550@aol.com - -This Melitta product is distributed and serviced by Salton, Inc. -Printed in Switzerland -©2004 Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -®Reg. T.M. of a company of the Melitta Group - -8 - -Part No. 60493 - -LISEZ ET CONSERVEZ CES INSTRUCTIONS -AVERTISSEMENT : Tout appareil électrique présente un risque -d’incendie et de choc électrique pouvant provoquer des blessures -graves ou mortelles. Veuillez observer toutes les mesures de -sécurité. - -Machine à Espresso -& Cappuccino - -’ - -I - -N -E -T -E -R -T -N -E -D -T -E -N -O -T -A -S -L -T -U -D -E -D -U -G +Investing in the Future University Competition 2023 +by Pictet Asset Management -I +John Molson Undergraduate Case Competition 2025 -I +Lazaridis International Case Conference 2023 -’ +Marshall International Case Competition 2024 -I +McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 -I +NHH International Case Competition 2024 -B -1 -X -E -M +Scotiabank International Case Competition 2023 -, +Sydney International Business Competition 2025 -I +Thammasat Undergraduate Business Challenge 2024 -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -E -L -E -D -O -M +The Third KPMG ESG Case Study Competition -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -T -E +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 + +UW Global Business Case Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Finalist + +1st Runner-up + +Finalist + +First Place + +Champion + +Winner + +Third Place + +1st Runner-up + +Third Prize + +Champion + +Finalists + +27 + +26 Local + +Local + +100WF Hong Kong JumpStart University Investment Hackathon 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2024 + +Champion + +ACCA Hong Kong Business Competition 2023 + +Outstanding Team for start-up Filix +Medtech + +Team Excellence Award + +Merit Award for start-up MakeOmnia + +Alvarez & Marsal Hong Kong Business Case Competition 2024 + +Champion & Best Presenter + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2023 + +Best Performer of Roma Risk Advisory +Limited + +1st Runner-up + +Merit + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +Merit & Finalist + +Semi-finalist + +Champion + +2nd Runner-up + +Best Presenter + +1st Runner-up + +HKU-Airstar Bank Joint University Case Competition 2024 + +HKU-SaSa Joint University Case Competition 2023 + +Hong Kong MBS Digital Economy Business Simulation Competition 2025 + +Third Place + +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2024 + +HSBC Life Insurance Competition 2025 + +HSBC Life Insurance Innovation Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Top 3 Winner + +1st Runner-up + +Best Use of Technology Award + +International MBS Business Management Simulation Competition 2023 + +Champion + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2025 + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2024 + +MBS Simulated Business Management Competition 2024 + +New Century Elite Development Programme 2023 + +Venture Capital On Campus (VCOC) - Investment Challenge 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Champion + +Third Place + +First place + +Best presenter + +Third Place + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Winner Team + +29 + +AmplifyME APAC M&A APAC Challenge 2025 + +Third Place + +BOCHK Challenge 2023 + +Bronze Award for Innovative Design + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2025 (Regional Final) + +1st Runner-up + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 (Semi-final Round) + +Deloitte USHINE Case Competition 2024 + +ESG Challenge 2023 + +EY Young Tax Professional of the Year 2023 - Hong Kong Region + +Champion + +Finalist + +Champion + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2025 Case Competition + +Champion + +HKCGI Corporate Governance Paper Competition and +Presentation Awards 2024 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2023/24 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 + +28 + +HKGCC Pitch Perfect Programme 2024 + +HKICPA Business Case Competition 2023 + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2025 + +1st Runner-up + +1st Runner-up (Paper Writing Competition) + +1st Runner-up (Paper Presentation +Competition) + +Audience’s Favourite Team Award + +Chevalier - Champion + +Chinachem Group - Champion + +Swire Pacific - Champion + +Chevalier - 1st Runner-up + +Chinachem - 1st Runner-up + +HKGCC - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - Champion + +SOCAM - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - 1st Runner-up + +MTR - 2nd Runner-up + +Overall Champion + +Winner + +2nd Runner-up + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Merit + + Chhawchharia, Mihika Amit +HSBC - Summer Analyst program + +internship, + +I collaborated closely with various +Throughout my +departments of the bank and +interacted regularly with senior +management, gaining comprehensive exposure to the bank’s operations. +This experience allowed me to hone my professional skills, including +communication, leadership, financial analysis, and market expertise. I +was honored to be ranked as the top intern in my cohort and secured a +return offer to join HSBC as a full-time graduate analyst in their Global +Banking division. I am deeply grateful for the knowledge and support I +received at HKU, which enabled me to thrive in a prestigious global +institution alongside some of the brightest talents in the industry. + +Internship Experience + +Lee, Chung Hong Calvin +HSBC - Global Risk Management Intern + +Reflecting on my time at HSBC, I realise that I have grown on a +professional and personal level. I have developed a deeper passion for +the banking industry and a greater appreciation for the critical role that +risk management and compliance play. I wore many hats and gained +precious insights into the banking industry. I was responsible for +overseeing compliance risks across 32 markets in Asia Pacific. I am +confident that the lessons I have learned at HSBC will guide me every +step of the way. + +Hui, Matthew +HSBC - International Banking (ISB) Intern - Corporate Coverage + +The comprehensive exposure to Corporate Banking was invaluable. From +analysing credit risk for lending applications to understanding diverse +product offerings for MNC clients, each day brought new learning +opportunities. I'm truly grateful for the experience of shadowing and +supporting different RMs in the team. Together with the sharing and +introductions from product partners, I learned how to identify clients' +needs and gained perspective on effectively reaching out and pitching to +clients. This experience taught me how to view banking relationships +through a strategic lens - understanding not just immediate needs but +trends. The +also anticipating +professional mindset, strategic thinking, and collaborative spirit fostered +during this internship will undoubtedly shape my future career path. + +future requirements and market + +Nagar, Tanvi +HSBC - International Banking Intern + +immense + +My internship experience was nothing short of incredible. Not only did I +grow immensely in my technical and professional skills but also +underwent an +journey of personal growth. I received +unparalleled support from the team and my mentors and gained an +in-depth insight into the field of banking and finance in Hong Kong. I +formed meaningful connections and grew my network. This experience +has truly shaped me and continues to propel my drive to pursue a career +in Banking in the years to come. + +3130 Sharma, Seerat +KPMG - Financial Services Audit Intern +(COOP3000 Cooperative Education Programme) + +I had the privilege of contributing to audit engagements for leading +clients in the banking and insurance sectors, where I conducted +substantive testing, supported risk assessments and navigated audit +methodologies using advanced tools. This role sharpened my analytical +mindset, strengthened my collaboration skills and offered a front-row +view into the dynamic world of financial auditing. It’s been a truly +rewarding journey that has solidified my passion for a career in +professional services. + +Xu, Aijing +CMB International Capital Corporation - Wealth Management Intern + +During my internship, I actively engaged with the product team in +market analysis and client pitching focused on mutual funds. I gained +valuable insights into various asset classes and macroeconomic +trends. Analyzing mutual fund performances and participating in +client meetings allowed me to contribute to investment portfolio +strategies. Collaborating with +team enhanced my +communication skills and understanding of client needs. Overall, this +experience deepened my knowledge of wealth management and +strengthened my passion for finance. + +the sales + +Shi, Yu Cheung Karson +Bank of China - Credit Summer Intern (Risk Management) + +During the internship, the financial techniques and business knowledge +I learned from HKU Business School courses helped a lot in company +financial analysis. By applying knowledge taught in the financial +accounting module, I assisted in evaluating loan demand. Through +cross-departmental collaborations, I also realised how classroom +simulations mirrored real-world risk mitigation challenges. This +experience reinforced the value of integrating academic theories with +dynamic market practices. + +Hu, Wen Qing +PwC Assurance Practice Intern + +As an assurance intern in PwC, I assisted my seniors with sampling +financial statement line items, reconciling balances, and documented +relevant non-financial information. It showed me how demanding the +auditing industry was, and allowed me to set my expectations for a +career in auditing as an accounting student. + +Wirawen, Karen +HKU – Neuberger Berman Private Equity Internship Programme + +You never truly understand private equity until you’re immersed in it +and my internship at Neuberger Berman was deeply enriching. Coming +in with limited knowledge, I gained direct exposure by working on +various deals across sectors and geographies, including Japan, Korea +and Southeast Asia. From drafting memos for the +investment +committee to attending annual general meetings and taking notes on +calls, I progressed from simple tasks to meaningful responsibilities. The +seniors were welcoming, always open to teaching, providing feedback +and offering valuable career advice. + +Chung, Marcus Lok Sum +Morgan Stanley Industrial Placement Intern + +During my internship with Sales & Trading (Institutional Equity +Division), I had the amazing opportunity to rotate across trading +and structuring desks where I was exposed to the fast-paced +environment especially during periods of high market volatility. To +see how traders manage positions and mitigate risks first-hand +was incredibly insightful. I also contributed to constructing trading +strategies and seeing the tangible impact of our work was deeply +rewarding. Morgan Stanley definitely provided me with a broader +perspective and understanding of market dynamics, liquidity, +client interactions and cross-asset opportunities. + +3332 Our Student Scholars + +Chan, Kwan Yin Cheryl +Recipient of Louisa Cheang Inspiration Scholarship 2024-25 + +I would like to express my gratitude for the Louisa Cheang Inspiration +Scholarship, which has significantly contributed to my personal and +professional growth. In the past academic year, this scholarship enabled +in the full-time Registered Visiting Student +me to participate +Programme at St Catherine’s College, University of Oxford. This +immersive experience enhanced my legal studies through engaging +discussions with scholars and participation in mooting competitions, +sharpening my research and advocacy skills. Additionally, I plan to +utilise this scholarship to pursue overseas postgraduate studies, +allowing me to deepen my understanding of the complexities of law in +a global context. + +Hussain, Iman +Recipient of FBE Student Contribution and +Innovation Award 2024-25 / +HKU Business School Future Leader Scholarship 2024-25 + +As someone who believes in learning through real-world experience, +the FBE Student Contribution and Innovation Award and the HKU +Business School Future Leader Scholarship have been life-changing. +They not only enabled me to go on an exchange semester to Cardiff, +where I explored new cultures and perspectives but also shaped my +entrepreneurial journey. + +With this support, I’ve been able to work on building a social +enterprise that aligns with my passion for creating meaningful impact. +I’m incredibly thankful for these opportunities to grow and make a +difference. + +Chow, Yee Shun Eason +Recipient of the Jardine HKU Scholarship 2024-25 + +It is an incredible honour to have received the Jardine HKU Scholarship +which is enriching my university journey! This scholarship allowed me to +pursue my many goals – from attending international training camps as +a handball player to participating in overseas exchanges without +financial worries. I have had the privilege of undertaking a summer +internship at the Jardine Group, learning from seasoned professionals in +my future industry. The Jardine Foundation also hosted exciting +networking activities and site visits which helped me build lasting +connections with fellow scholars in a vibrant community. + +Shih, Pui Hei Iris +Recipient of the Hong Kong Jockey Club Scholarships - +Undergraduate Scholarship 2024-25 + +This scholarship has been transformative to my university life as it has +allowed me to fully embrace and explore the world beyond the +classroom. It provided the financial stability I needed to focus on my +studies and presented opportunities for me to participate in diverse +extracurricular activities. These experiences broadened my perspective +and opened me to different points of view. + +Nurgali, Adilzhan +Recipient of BOC Hong Kong - +One Belt One Road Scholarship 2024-25 + +It means a lot to me to be awarded the BOC Hong Kong - One Belt One +Road Scholarship. It was not +just about financial support but +recognition of the hard work I have put in. As an international student +soon heading for exchange, this award gives me the freedom to explore +new cultures and experiences without extra stress. I am truly grateful to +be part of such an inclusive and supportive community. + +3534 2026 JUPAS Admissions + +Admissions criteria (HKDSE) + +Local candidates applying on the strength of the Hong Kong Diploma of +Secondary Education (HKDSE) are required to fulfil the minimum entrance +requirements for HKU Business School programmes as shown below: + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +EngEng ≥ +Level 4 or above in English Language +ChinChin ≥ +Level 3 or above in Chinese Language1 +MathMath ≥ +Level 3 or above in Mathematics + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +AA + +CSDCSD = +Grade “Attained (A)” in +Citizenship and Social Development2 + +2x + +Elective +Elective +Subjects +Subjects + +≥ + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 or above in two Elective Subjects + +For BBA(BA), BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) +In addition to the minimum entrance requirements above, candidates applying for the BBA(BA), +BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) programmes shall also obtain the following results in the +HKDSE examination: + +BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) +≥ +Level 3 or above in one of the following subjects: + +Level 3 + +Biology + +BAFS + +Chemistry + +Economics + +ICT + +Physics + +BBA(BA) + +BSc(MAT) + +Level 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics is also preferred by BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) but not +strictly required. + +BBA(Law)&LLB / BBA(IBGM) / BSc(QFin) + +BBA(Law)&LLB + +BBA(IBGM) + +BSc(QFin) + +EngEng ≥ + +Level 5 +Level 5 + +Chin, Math +Chin, Math ≥ + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +EngEng ≥ + +Level 5 +Level 5 + ++ + ++ + +M1/M2 +M1/M2 ≥ + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +MathMath ≥ + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +Application + +For details of the 2026 JUPAS exercise, please visit www.jupas.edu.hk. + +Programme Scoring Formula + +For more information on the Programme Scoring Formula and Subject Weightings, please +visit the Admissions Office’s website at https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas. + +Note 1: Non-Chinese-speaking applicants will be considered on a case-by-case basis.Note 2: The result(s) of Liberal Studies at Level 2 or above achieved in previous sitting(s) will also be considered.Level 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inChinese Language1 & MathematicsLevel 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inMathematicsLevel 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics3736 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions + +Selection process and entrance requirements + +Eligibility +(1) Local students applying for admission on international qualifications other than the + +HKDSE examination; + +(2) Non-local students with international qualifications other than Chinese Mainland's + +National Joint College Entrance Examination (NJCEE/Gao Kao). + +Application Procedures +All non-JUPAS applications should be submitted via the online application system by noon of +November 26, 2025 (Hong Kong Time) for the first-round evaluation. Scanned copies of the +following documents should also be uploaded by the application deadline. + +(1) Official prediction of grades or scores from your current high school (if available); + +(2) All internal and public examination results during your senior secondary education; and + +(3) Academic reference letter (optional) + +Late submission of supporting documents will delay the consideration of application. + +Shortlisted applicants for BSc(QFin) will be interviewed; optional interviews for other +programmes will be arranged if necessary. + +University and Programme Entrance Requirements +Due to the complex combination of education background of applicants, each application will +be assessed individually on its own merits. Non-JUPAS applicants are advised to refer to the +standards and requirements on the website of the Admissions Office of the University before +making an application: + +(1) Admissions standards (International Qualifications or National Qualifications); + +(2) Programme specific subject requirements; and + +(3) English language requirement + +In particular, please note that the expected lower boundary for admissions listed on the +website is provided for reference purposes only. Admissions is competitive in nature and +achieving the expected lower boundary does not guarantee admission to the programme. +The actual admission grade or score will be dependent on the overall quality of applications +received in the 2026 admissions exercise. + +Announcement of Result +Offer results will be released from December 2025 onwards. All application status will be +updated in the online application system once an admissions decision has been made. +Applicants should check their application status online regularly. + +More Details +For further information about the application procedures and admissions +standards, +at +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications. + +the Admissions Office’s website + +please + +visit + +2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programmes, in addition to the +application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS Admissions Scheme. + +For details of the dual degrees and the application procedures, please visit +the Admissions Office’s website at +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university-collaborative-programmes. + +3938 Develop Your Career + +Freshmen Sharing + +Upon graduation, over 82% of our students begin their careers in the commerce and industry sector. Others either +move on to further studies or explore opportunities with the civil service, education institutions and +community/social services. + +Career Prospects + +Companies/organisations that have offered full-time positions to our graduates include but not limited to the +following: + +Accenture Company Limited +Bank of China (Hong Kong) Limited +BDO International Limited +Bloomberg L.P. +Citibank (Hong Kong) Limited +Crédit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank +Credit Suisse Group AG +Deloitte Advisory (Hong Kong) Limited +Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited +Deutsche Bank +Ernst & Young +Goldman Sachs (Asia) LLC +Hang Seng Bank Limited +HKSAR Government +Hong Kong Monetary Authority +JPMorgan Chase & Co. +KPMG +Morgan Stanley +PricewaterhouseCoopers Limited +Standard Chartered Bank (Hong Kong) Limited +The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation +Limited (HSBC) +UBS Group AG + +Full employment +for the 19th + +consecutive year + +98.7% + +was the average salary of +our 2024 graduates + +$36,770 + +of our 2024 graduates have +received at least 2 job offers +upon graduation + +57% + +Kantbek, Yerassyl +BBA + +I chose HKU Business School because Hong Kong is +one of the world’s most competitive financial centres, +offering a dynamic environment to grow. HKU +combines +real-world +rigorous academics with +experiences, such as Asia-focused case studies and +competitions like HICS, which I plan to join in Year 2. I +am particularly drawn to programs in marketing and +finance, as well as opportunities for entrepreneurship +through the Techno-Entrepreneurship Core and +iDendron incubator. With a diverse student body and +global exchange options, I look forward to learning +from peers, connecting with mentors, and developing +skills to make a meaningful impact in business. + +The main reason I chose HKU, particularly HKU +Business School, lies in its global connections and +strong partnerships with other institutions and +respected organizations, which I believe will be +advantageous for future employment opportunities. +I expect to embrace challenges over the course of my +four years at the university, as these will be vital for +my intellectual and social maturity. The first time I +visited the campus, I was amazed by the diversity of +the students and +facilities, which +demonstrated that the university is truly a place for +everyone. One of the many great opportunities +offered here is the chance to travel for studies, which +I would rank among my highest interests. + +the open + +Pernice, Audrey Yiwen +BEcon&Fin + +4140 The main reason I chose BBA(IBGM) is its flexibility in allowing +students to choose a second major, as well as the numerous +overseas exchange opportunities. I am also fortunate to have +been admitted as a member of the HKU International Case +Society (HICS), where I get to know people from other programs +who are also interested in the realm of business. HKU Business +School provides me with the perfect platform to strike a balance +between my work and life. + +Ho, Lik Hang Gordon +BBA(IBGM) + +Lo, Hoi Tung Reacker +BSc(MAT) + +I chose HKU Business School for its professional background and +diverse opportunities. The multidisciplinary programme allows me to +pursue Marketing Analytics and Technology, aligning with my varied +interests in business and STEM. As a freshman, I am eager to embrace +exciting experiences such as internships and exchanges. I look +forward to gaining insights from fellow students and professionals +through upcoming career events. With the strong support from HKU, +I am committed to developing my entrepreneurial skills and pursuing +my dreams without regrets! + +Drawn by HKU’s global prestige and the excellence of HKU Business +School, I chose to pursue Quantitative Finance at HKU to deepen my +passion for quantitative trading and data-driven decision-making. +The school’s flexible curriculum empowers me to explore +complementary fields such as computer science, statistics, and risk +management. As a target school for top investment banks, HKU +also offers unparalleled career exposure. HKU provides the ideal +environment to grow academically and professionally, and I am +excited to explore the many opportunities ahead. + +Tsang, Chun Shing Patrick +BSc(QFin) + +Fung, Yat Hang Rex +BFin(AMPB) + +My aspiration for BFin(AMPB) was ignited early in high school by its +unparalleled, practitioner-focused design, a curriculum that truly +bridges finance theory with industry practice. This conviction was +solidified through the heartfelt guidance of our Programme +Director, Professor Anna Wong, who mentored me even before I +officially joined HKU, while I was an apprentice at a US bank. + +Now, experiencing BFin(AMPB) firsthand, the transition from the +professional world to the classroom feels seamless. It is this +powerful integration of theory and real-world practice that makes +AMPB incomparable. HKUBS has instantly instilled in me a sense of +ownership, this is not just a school, but a launchpad for impact, and +I am thrilled to begin the next chapter of my growth here. + +I was drawn to BBA(IBGM) because of HKU’s +world-renowned academic reputation and its vibrant, +international community. I believe a truly “global +business” education extends beyond the classroom, +through experiential learning opportunities, daily +interactions with local and non-local peers, and +participation in hall and student society cultures, I will +gain a more dynamic and holistic multidisciplinary +perspective on the business world. Over the coming +four years, I am eager to harness these opportunities +to become a well-rounded leader and effective +problem-solver for my future career on the global +business stage. + +Yan, Sung Hei Christopher +BBA(IBGM) + +4342 Our Global Presence + +Israel - +Tel Aviv + +Beijing + +Shenzhen + +Hong Kong + +Vietnam - +Ho Chi Minh City + +Useful Websites +The University of Hong Kong (HKU) + +Undergraduate Admissions +https://admissions.hku.hk/ + +HKU – Entrance Requirements + +For JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas + +For non-JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications + +HKU Business School + +Overview of Undergraduate Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme + +Enrichment Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/student-enrichment + +Other HKU Websites + +Mainland Affairs Office (MAO) +https://mainlandaffairs.hku.hk/ + +Centre of Development and Resources for +Students (CEDARS) +https://www.cedars.hku.hk/ + +44 -9 +45 diff --git a/q33/random_k2/random_2.md b/q33/random_k2/random_2.md index 2e9f5241e58113455522088c7a6110de8838d130..0523beec0142edd0aa6f2e27f15673239129abcd 100644 --- a/q33/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q33/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,1208 +1,1200 @@ -DUET: Joint Exploration of User–Item Profiles in Recommendation System -YueChen1,*,YifeiSun1,*,LuWang2,†,FangkaiYang2,PuZhao2,MinjieHong3,YifeiDong4,MinghuaHe2, -NanHu2,JianjinZhang2,ZhiweiDai2,YuefengZhan2,WeihaoHan2,HaoSun2, -QingweiLin2,WeiweiDeng2,FengSun2,QiZhang2,SaravanRajmohan2,DongmeiZhang2 -1PekingUniversity2Microsoft3ZhejiangUniversity4KTHRoyalInstituteofTechnology -*Equalcontribution†Correspondingauthor -Abstract -| | | | User History: | Item History: | User History: | Item History: | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -| | | | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | -| | | | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | -Traditionalrecommendationsystemsrepresent ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t -6202 rpA 51 ]RI.sc[ 1v10831.4062:viXra • • Parliament Funk Bass" -| usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearnto | | | Parliament | Funk Bass" | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------------------ | -| | | | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | -aligntheminasharedlatentspaceforrelevance -| | | | | Duet | Independent | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -estimation. RecentLLM-basedrecommenders (Joint Alignment) Generation -| instead leverage | natural-language | representa- | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | -| | | | User Profile: | Item History: | User Profile: | Item History: | -tionsthatareeasiertointerpretandintegrate Enthusiast of A peak-era FUNK- Fan of HEAVY A highly rated POP- -| | | | FUNK and SOUL. | ROCK album with | METAL and | ROCK album with | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------------- | -withdownstreamreasoningmodules. Thispa- Values technical genre-blurring PUNK. Prefers polished -| | | | mastery | creativity. | dark themes. | production. | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------- | -textual -per studies how to construct effective Semantic Alignment ✘ Semantic Mismatch -profilesforusersanditems,andhowtoalign -themforrecommendation. Acentraldifficulty Figure1: DUETalignsrawuseranditemdatabytrans- -| | | | forming them | into textual | profiles within | a shared se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | -isthatthebestprofileformatisnotknownapri- -manticspace. -ori: manuallydesignedtemplatescanbebrittle -| andmisalignedwithtaskobjectives. | | Moreover, | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | to introduce | semantically | rich, human-readable | | -generatinguseranditemprofilesindependently -mayproducedescriptionsthatareindividually representationsforrecommendation(Wangetal., -plausible yet semantically inconsistent for a 2025;Zhang,2024;Baoetal.,2023;Hongetal., -| specificuser–itempair. | WeproposeDUET,an | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | 2025a,b,c;Wangetal.,2024). | | Anaturaldirectionis | | -interaction-awareprofilegeneratorthatjointly -toreplacelatentvectorswithtextualuseranditem -producesuseranditemprofilesconditionedon -profilesthatcanbeinspected,edited,andreusedby -| both user history | and item evidence. | DUET | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downstreamcomponentsincorporatedwithLLMs. -| follows a three-stage | procedure: | it first turns | | | | | -| --------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -However,existingLLM-basedapproachesremain -rawhistoriesandmetadataintocompactcues, -then expands these cues into paired profile limited in two important ways. First, directly -promptsandthengenerateprofiles,andfinally promptinganLLMwithrawuseranditemhisto- -optimizesthegenerationpolicywithreinforce- -riestoobtainrecommendationsoftenyieldsnoisy -mentlearningusingdownstreamrecommenda- andincompletesignals,especiallywhenhistories -| tionperformanceasfeedback. | | Experimentson | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -| | | | are long, | sparse, or heterogeneous | | (Wang et al., | -threereal-worlddatasetsshowthatDUETcon- -| | | | 2025). Second, | profile-based | methods | typically | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | -sistentlyoutperformsstrongbaselines,demon- -relyonmanuallydesignedtemplatesorhandcrafted -stratingthebenefitsoftemplate-freeprofileex- -attributes,whichrequiressubstantialhumanengi- -plorationandjointuser–itemtextualalignment. -Project code page: https://github.com/duet- neering and constrains the representation space. -review/duet_code. More fundamentally, many approaches generate -userprofilesanditemprofilesindependently,with- -1 Introduction -| | | | out modeling | how user | preferences | and item se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -Traditional recommendation systems represent manticsinteractatdecisiontime(Yangetal.,2023; -Xietal.,2024). -usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearntoalign -theminasharedlatentspaceforrelevanceestima- Toaddressthesechallenges,wepropose DUET, -tion (Covington et al., 2016; Wu, 2023). While ajointuser–itemprofilegeneratorthattakesboth -effective,suchembeddingsareopaque: theyoffer userhistoryanditemhistoryasinputandproduces -limitedinterpretabilityandmakeitdifficulttoan- a paired set of profiles for the interaction. Cru- -alyzewhyanitemisrecommended. Recentwork cially, DUET doesnotrequireprofiletemplates: it -thereforeleverageslargelanguagemodels(LLMs) istrainedwithreinforcementlearningusingfeed- - -back from downstream recommendation perfor- asseeninworkslikeCRESDUP(Chenetal.,2007) -mance,enablingittoexploreanddiscovereffective andUPCSim(Widiyaningtyasetal.,2021). While -profileformatsautomatically. Figure1illustrates foundational,thesemethodswerelimitedbytheir -whyjointprofilingmatters. Theuserhaslistened rigid,hand-engineeredfeatures. Morerecently,the -toMisfits(punk),IronMaiden(metal),andParlia- adventofLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)hasen- -ment(funk),whilethecandidatealbumisdescribed abledashifttowardsgeneratingprofilesinnatural -byreviewssuchas“polishedpop”and“greatfunk language. Studies such as KAR (Xi et al., 2024), -bass”andametatag“’80srock.” Consideringboth GPG(Zhang,2024),PALR(Yangetal.,2023),and -sides together, DUET can reconcile these signals LettinGo (Wang et al., 2025) leverage LLMs to -intoacompatibleinterpretation(e.g.,highlighting createtextualuserprofilesfrombehavioraldata. A -the user’s funk/soul affinity and the item’s funk- keylimitationoftheseapproachesistwofold: they -rockcharacter). Incontrast,independentlygener- relyonstaticorpre-definedtemplatesforprofile -atedprofilesmayamplifydifferentfacets,summa- generation,andtheyoftenfocusexclusivelyonuser -rizingtheuseras“heavymetal/punk”whilesum- profiles,neglectingtherich,expressiveinformation -marizingtheitemas“pop-rock”,whichresultingin inherentinitemsandthecomplexdynamicsofuser- -asemanticallymismatchedpairthatobscuresthe iteminteractions. Incontrast,ourworkintroduces -truerelevancesignal. anewparadigmwherebothuseranditemprofiles -DUETproceedsinthreestages. First,rawhisto- arenotfixedbutaredynamicallyexploredandop- -ries and metadata are distilled into minimal cues timizedinasharedsemanticspacetodirectlyalign -thatcapturecompactbutinformativesignals. Sec- withrecommendationperformance. -ond, the model expands cues into richer profile -prompts to generate textual profiles, allowing ex- 2.2 ReinforcementLearningforLLM-Based -plorationoveralternativeprofilestructuresandem- RecommendationSystems -phases. Third,theresultingprofilesareconsumed -ReinforcementLearning(RL),particularlythrough -bydownstreamrecommenders,andtheirtaskfeed- -techniqueslikeRLHF,hasbecomeacoremethod -backisusedtooptimizetheprofilegenerationpol- -for aligning LLMs with specific objectives. This -icy. By coupling both sides in a shared semantic -approach has been adapted for recommendation -space,DUETlearnsuserprofilesthatreflectwhat -tasks (Wang et al., 2025; Lin et al., 2025; Deng -kindsofitemsauserprefersanditemprofilesthat -etal.,2025),butexistingeffortsoftenfacekeylimi- -reflectwhatkindsofusersanitemappealsto. -tations. Theyfrequentlyrelyonofflinerewardmod- -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: -els(Jeongetal.,2023;Chenetal.,2025;Heetal., -• Werepresentusersanditemsasnatural-language 2025; Liu et al., 2025) that do not adapt in real- -profiles and align them in a shared semantic timetosystemfeedback,asetupthatrisksissues -space,extendingtheclassicvector-basedalign- like reward hacking (Skalse et al., 2025). Other -mentprincipletointerpretabletextualrepresenta- methods(Sunetal.,2024;Luetal.,2024)restrict -tions. themselvestoofflinepreferencetuning(e.g.,DPO), -• We introduce an exploration-based framework which can easily overfit on static datasets. Our -thatstartsfromcue-basedinitialization,expands framework, DUET,overcomesthesechallengesby -cuesintocandidateprofiles,andjointlyoptimizes integrating RL into a closed-loop system where -user and item profiles with downstream recom- downstreamrecommendationperformanceserves -mendationfeedbackviareinforcementlearning, asthereal-timerewardsignal,allowingforthedy- -avoidingrigidtemplates. namicandinteractiverefinementoftextualprofiles. -• Extensiveexperimentsacrossmultiplereal-world -datasets show that DUET consistently outper- 3 Method -formsstrongbaselines,validatingbothjointpro- -filingandfeedback-drivenprofileoptimization. DUET is a closed-loop framework that trans- -forms raw user–item interaction histories into -2 RelatedWork performance-aligned textual profiles through -learnedrepresentationstrategies. AsshowninFig- -2.1 ProfilesinRecommendation -ure 2, DUET consists of three stages. (1) Cue- -Earlyrecommendationsystemsprimarilyreliedon Based Initialization distills interaction histories -pre-definedprofilesbasedonstructuredattributes, intoconciseevidence-basedcues. (2)JointExplo- - -CUE-BASED INITIALIZATION JOINT EXPLORATION ON-POLICY OPTIMIZATION -| | | | | Item | DU | | | Duet | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| ItemHistory | | | | | ET | | | | | | | -Initial CUE -Rated: Baba Is You (5★) -User: “Prefers retro puzzle games” -Reviewed: “I love logic- -Item: “Retro-style indie puzzle game” -| | | | based puzzle games.” | | | Profile Prompt | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rated: The Witness (5★) -User: “Describe the user's typical -| | | | Rated: Fez (4★) | | puzzle-game preferences … | | | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒1 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒2 | … | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑛 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -Item: “… item's core mechanics… -| | | | | | | | Profile | Downstream Task Env | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ---- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | User | User: “A player who enjoys logic- | | | | | | | -| UserHistory | | | | | intensive indie puzzle games, | | | | | | | -| | | | Category: Indie Puzzle | | | | | Ranking correctness | | | | -prefers retro visual aesthetics…” -| | | | Game | | | | | &format Reward | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Reviews: -Item: “A retro-style indie puzzle -| | | | “Challenging logic | | game featuring challenging | | | Group Computation | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | mechanics.” | | logic mechanics that appeal to | | | | | | | -| | | | “ R e t r o p ix | e l- a rt st y l e . ” | hardcore puzzle players.” | | | 𝐴𝑑𝑣1 𝐴𝑑𝑣2 | | | | -| | | | “ H a r d b u | t re w a r d i n g . ” | | | | | … | 𝐴𝑑𝑣𝑛 | | -| | | | | Figure2: | OverviewoftheDUETframework. | | | | | | | -ration via Adaptive Profile Prompt Discovery 3.2 Cue-BasedInitialization -| jointly | explores | user-item’s | | profile prompts | that | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Raw user | histories | and item | metadata | | are often | -| define how | user | and item | profiles | should | be writ- | | | | | | | -noisy,redundant,andnotdirectlysuitableforpro- -ten. (3)OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -| | | | | | | fileconstruction. | | Toaddressthis,DUETintroduces | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -jointlyoptimizesuseranditemprofilesunderdown- -theconceptofcues: -concisehypothesesthatsum- -streamrecommendationfeedback. -| | | | | | | marize minimal | | but informative | | aspects | of users | -| ------------------- | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | -| All three | stages | are | realized | through | a single | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | and items. | These | cues act | as lightweight | | seeds, | -| passinputandoutput: | | | cueextraction,self-prompt | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | which are | deliberately | underspecified | | so | that the | -construction,andprofilegenerationareproduced -systemcansubsequentlyexplorericherprofilefor- -inasinglesequence-to-sequencegenerationpass -mats. -atinferencetime,enablingefficientdeployment. -| | | | | | | Definition1(Cue). | | Acueisaminimaltextualhy- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.1 ProblemFormulation -pothesisderivedfromhistoricaldatathathighlights -WeformulateprofilegenerationinDUETasanon- one potential aspect of a user’s preference or an -policyreinforcementlearningproblem,motivated item’scharacteristic. Ratherthanaimingforcom- -bytheabsenceofanytextualgroundtruthdefining pleteness, cues capture partial but salient signals -an optimal user or item profile. Profile quality is thatserveasstartingpointsforprofileexploration. -evaluatedsolelybyitsfunctionalutilityinafixed -| | | | | | | To extract | cues | automatically, | | the | LLM is | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -recommendationenvironment. -| | | | | | | prompted | to summarize | minimal | | but informative | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| DUET | is modeled | as | a generative | policy | π θ in- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | aspectsofuseroritemdata. | | | Forexample,givena | | | -teractingwithafrozendownstreamrecommender. -user’sinteractionhistory,themodelisguidedwith -| For each | user–item | pair, | the | state is | defined as | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -instructionssuchas: -| s = {H | ,H },whereH | | andH | denotetheuser | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | u i | | u | i | | | | | | | | -and item interaction histories. An action corre- CueExtractionPrompt -spondstoasingle-passjointgeneration -“Fromthehistorybelow,analyzetheuser’s -a = {C u ,S u ,P u ,C i ,S i ,P i }, historicalinteractionstounderstandprefer- -ences,ratingbehavior,reviewsentimentor -| where | (C ,C | ) are | cues | distilled | from his- | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u i -| | | | | | | anyotherdimension. | | Keepthedescription | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| tory, (S | u ,S i ) are | constructed | | user-item’s | profile | | | | | | | -prompts,and(P ,P )arethefinaltextualprofiles. conciseandavoidfullsentences.” -u i -| Thepolicyπ | | (a | s)definesajointdistribution | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θ -over the entire generation sequence. As an on- This lightweight guidance allows the LLM to -policy agent, DUET is optimized using rewards maprawhistoriesandmetadataintocompacttex- -from its own sampled generations rather than by tualcues. Thedetaildexampleofcuecanbefound -| imitatingfixedsummaries. | | | | | | inAppendixA.3. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| 3.3 | JointExplorationviaAdaptiveProfile | | | | | | Single-PassInput | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PromptDiscovery Task:Generatestructuredprofilesfortheuseranditemfrom -historicaldata. -Aftercueextraction,DUETdoesnotdirectlysum- Combined Context: [User History H u ] + [Item -| | | | | | | | History | H i ]+[Avg | Ratings] | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| marizeuserinterestsoritemattributes. | | | | | | Instead,it | | | | | | | -“First,extractaconciseCueforbothuseranditem.Second, -| explores | | the space | of profile | construction | | strate- | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -basedonthecues,constructaProfilePromptthatdefines -gies—natural-languagepromptsthatdefinethefor- thedescriptionlogic.Finally,generatetheProfileguidedby -theconstructedProfilePrompt.” -mat,abstractionlevel,andattributeselectionlogic -↓DUETForwardPass↓ -| usedtogenerateprofiles. | | | | Explorationistherefore | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| performedoverhowprofilesshouldbeconstructed, | | | | | | | Single-PassOutput | | | | | | -User -ratherthanoversuperficialtextualparaphrases. -Cue:“prefersnostalgiclogic-basedchallenges” -For each user–item pair, DUET intro- Profileprompt: “Focuson1990svisualaestheticsand -| duces | an | explicit | intermediate | | variable, | the | strategicdepth.” | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | Profile: | “A player | who | seeks | retro-style | visual charm | -constructed_prompt,whichservesasadiscrete -pairedwithdeepstrategicreasoning.” -| and | interpretable | | profile | prompt | S. | This profile | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Item -promptisashortnatural-languageinstruction(e.g., -Cue:“retro-styleindiepuzzlewithhighdifficulty” -“Describetheuser’stypicalgamingpreferencesand -| | | | | | | | Profile | prompt: | “Describe | | pixel-art | graphics and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | -engagementpatterns”)thatspecifieswhataspects intellectualdifficultytomatchlogicpreference.” -Profile:“A2Dexperiencefeaturingpixelatednostalgia -| to | describe | and | how to | organize | them, | without | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andchallengingmechanicsthatdemandlogicaldeduction.” -| containingtheprofilecontentitself. | | | | | | Conditioned | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onS,themodelgeneratesthefinaluseranditem Figure3: Single-passgenerationinDUET: cueextrac- -| profiles. | | | | | | | tion,profileprompt(constructedprompt),andprofile | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -generationareproducedinonepassforbothuserand -| Exploration | | | is driven | by treating | | the profile | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -item. -| promptS | | asastochasticactionsampledfromthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| policyπ | | (S | Cue). | Duringtraining,theagentsam- | | | | | | | | | | -θ -plesdifferentprofilepromptinstructions,executes -| | | | | | | | andintellectualdifficulty”tomatch. | | | | | RLreinforces | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -| themtogenerateprofilepairs(P | | | | | ,P ),andreceives | | | | | | | | -u i -thissharedsemanticdirection,suppressingirrele- -| a reward | | based | on downstream | | recommendation | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | -| | | | | | | | vant signals | and | forcing | the | final | profiles to con- | -| accuracy. | | Thepolicyisoptimizedtoreinforcepro- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | verge | into a shared | semantic | | space | of nostalgia | -filepromptsthatconsistentlyyieldhigherrewards, -andlogic,significantlyimprovingrecommendation -enablingthemodeltoactivelysearchforeffective -accuracy. -profileconstructionformats. -Thisprocessisrealizedasaunifiedgeneration -3.4 OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -pass, -| | | | | | | | On-policy | optimization. | | | We train | the profile | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -O = [ Cue → profilepromptS → Profile], generator π in an on-policy manner against a -| | (cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125) | | | | | (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) | | θ | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (cid:124) | (cid:123)(cid:122) | (cid:125) | | | | | | | | -Context ProfileConstructionPrompt Execution frozendownstreammodelf, whichservesasthe -| | | | | | | (1) | environment | critic. | For | each | sampled | user–item | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | -wheretheprofilepromptS parameterizesthepro- pair (u,i), the policy generates (P ,P ) and re- -u i -filegenerator. Atinferencetime,DUETcollapses ceivesascalarrewardbasedonthepredictionac- -thelearnedprofilepromptdistributionandgreed- curacy of f(P ,P ). The policy parameters are -u i -ilyexecutestheoptimalprofilepromptinasingle updatedtoreinforcegenerationsthatleadtolower -| forwardpass,introducingnoadditionallatency. | | | | | | | predictionerror. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| Example | | of profile | prompt | Exploration. | | As | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Continuousfractionalreward. | | | | | Usingdiscrete | -| illustrated | | in Figure | 3, | DUET | resolves | this by | | | | | | | -integerratingsasrewardsleadstosparseandunsta- -| identifying | | a shared | context | in | a single | forward | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -blefeedback,asnear-misspredictions(e.g.,predict- -pass. ThepolicyextractsacoordinatedCue(e.g., -ing4foragroundtruth5)receivethesamepenalty -“prefersretropuzzlegames”)andconstructsapro- -| | | | | | | | assevereerrors. | | Toprovidedenseandinformative | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| file | prompt | (the | constructed_prompt) | | | that in- | | | | | | | -feedback,wedefineacontinuousfractionalreward: -structsthemodeltohighlight“nostalgicaesthetics -| and | strategic | logic” | for | the user, | while | simulta- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | |y −yˆ | | | -| | | | | | | | | R (u,i) | | = 1− | ui | ui , (2) | -| neously | describing | | the item’s | “pixel-art | | graphics | | perf | | | | | -M - -where yˆ ui = f(P u ,P i ) is the predicted relevance ingsettingbasedondownstreampredictedrating -score and M is the maximum rating gap (e.g., scores. For each observed user–item interaction, -M = 4 for a 1–5 scale). This reward provides we randomly sample nine items that the user has -fine-grainedgradientsthatencourageincremental not interacted with to form a candidate set of ten -improvementsinrecommendationaccuracy. items, which are ranked in descending order ac- -We adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization cordingtotheirpredictedratings. Theground-truth -(GRPO) (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025) to optimize interacted item is treated as the only positive in- -theprofilegeneratorundertheabovereward. The stance,andweadoptNDCG@Kastheevaluation -downstreamrecommenderf isfrozenthroughout metric, with K set to 1, 5, and 10, to assess how -training, which yields a stable policy optimiza- effectivelythelearnedprofilessupportcorrectitem -| tionsettingandpreventsrewarddriftorfeedback- | | | | ranking. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | Baselines | We compare | our method | with | several | -inducedrepresentationcollapse. -| | | | | representative | baselines. | 10H | directly | uses the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -4 Experiment mostrecentinteractionhistoriesforpredictionwith- -| | | | | outconstructingexplicitprofiles. | | | KAR(Xietal., | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -4.1 ExperimentalSettings -2024)augmentsrecommendationmodelswithex- -Datasets. Experiments were conducted on three ternalreasoningknowledgeaboutuserpreferences -widelyusedreal-worlddatasets. AmazonMusic andfactualknowledgeaboutitemsextractedfrom -(Music) and Amazon Book (Book) are derived LLMs,whicharetransformedintotask-compatible -fromtheAmazonProductdataset1,whileYelpis representations. RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)lever- -fromtheYelpOpendataset2. Alldatasetsinclude agesLLMstolearnsemanticuseranditemrepre- -userreviews,ratings,andrichtextualinformation. sentationsfromtextualsignalsandalignsthemwith -WeusedthefullAmazonMusicdataset,butonly collaborativerelationalinformationthroughcross- -subsets (latest two months for Book and six for viewrepresentationlearning. PALR(Yangetal., -Yelp). Data was split by timestamp into training, 2023)fine-tunesalargelanguagemodelasarank- -validation,andtestsetstopreventinformationleak- ing component that selects preferred items from -age(Jietal.,2023). retrievedcandidatesexpressedinnaturallanguage. -EvaluationMetrics LG (LettinGo) (Wang et al., 2025) explores di- -For each observed user–item interaction (i.e., verseuserprofilecandidateswithLLMsandaligns -a review record), we construct the evaluation profilegenerationwithdownstreamrecommenda- -instance based on the user’s interaction history tionperformanceviapreferenceoptimization. Rea- -strictly prior to the corresponding timestamp. son4Rec(Fangetal.,2025)introducesadelibera- -tiverecommendationframeworkthatincorporates -Specifically,theuser’srecenthistoricalinteractions -beforethecurrentinteractionareusedtogenerate explicitstep-wisereasoningoveruserpreferences -auserprofile,whilehistoricalreviewsfromother toguideratingprediction. -| users are used | to generate | an item profile. | The | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -4.2 MainResults -downstreamrecommendationsystemthenpredicts -theratingofthetargetitemconditionedontwoin- Table 1 presents a comparison of our proposed -puts: thegenerateduserprofile,andthegenerated method against five baselines on three datasets: -| | | | | Amazon | Music, Amazon | Books, | and | Yelp. We | -| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| itemprofile. | Anexceptionisthe10Hbaseline,for | | | | | | | | -which the downstream model directly consumes use Qwen3-8B (Team, 2025) and LLaMA3-8B -therawrecentinteractionhistories. (Dubey et al., 2024) as both the profile generator -andthedownstreamrecommendationmodel,with -| We evaluate | performance | using four | widely | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | a prediction | temperature | of 0. | In addition | to rat- | -| adopted metrics | (Wang | et al., 2025; Fang | et al., | | | | | | -2025): MeanAbsoluteError(MAE),RootMean ingpredictionresults,wealsoreportranking-based -SquareError(RMSE),Accuracy,andF1score. evaluation results in Table ??, which assess the -effectivenessofthelearnedprofilesfromadown- -Inadditiontoratingprediction,wefurtherevaluate -thegenerateduseranditemprofilesunderarank- streamrankingperspective. -| | | | | Overallsuperiorityoverstrongbaselines. | | | | As | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ shown in Table 1, our method consistently out- -amazon/links.html -| | | | | performs | the strongest | baselines | across | all three | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -2https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -| open-dataset/ | | | | datasetsunderbothQwen3-8BandLLaMA3-8B. | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) -(%) (%) (%) -Qwen3(8B) -10H 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.7396 1.2184 55.34 48.67 0.7483 1.1380 58.65 60.29 0.7098 1.0923 56.17 58.78 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.8197 1.3312 47.15 42.46 0.7438 1.1069 54.89 57.65 0.7812 1.1584 52.86 55.93 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7994 1.2876 48.53 43.19 0.6075 0.9531 57.35 56.77 0.7485 1.1187 54.24 56.38 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7028 1.1523 55.69 47.73 0.5654 0.9635 58.69 54.67 0.6397 1.0098 58.47 56.84 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -LLaMA3(8B) -10H 1.0864 1.9532 22.09 27.30 0.7917 1.3346 38.13 46.87 0.8064 1.3866 37.15 45.27 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.6427 1.1668 54.51 47.98 0.5726 0.9033 57.53 59.92 0.5892 0.9614 55.87 58.21 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.7428 1.3572 46.74 42.11 0.6076 0.9886 53.78 57.42 0.6226 0.9477 52.12 55.79 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7238 1.3265 47.72 43.29 0.5823 0.9222 56.73 59.31 0.5977 0.8855 55.06 57.62 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6196 1.1289 56.03 51.24 0.5204 0.9369 61.92 59.50 0.5543 0.7967 58.95 60.39 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7586 1.0418 55.80 53.00 0.5442 0.7722 60.86 54.88 0.6029 0.8345 59.70 56.35 -Ours 0.5367 0.9687 60.87 54.74 0.4680 0.8277 63.30 60.60 0.5092 0.9500 63.42 58.12 -Table1: PerformanceonthreedatasetsusingQwen3(8B)andLLaMA3(8B). -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -Table2: RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. -Under Qwen3-8B, our method achieves an accu- our approach reaches an NDCG@1 of 0.5619 -racyof61.23%onYelp,67.96%onAmazonMu- and an NDCG@10 of 0.7443, clearly outper- -sicand64.38%onAmazonBooks,surpassingLG forming the strongest baseline methods. Similar -(LettinGo)(Wangetal.,2025)by5.05%,5.59% trendsareobservedonAmazonMusic,whereour -and5.03%,respectively. Similarimprovementsare methodattains0.5347atNDCG@1and0.7331at -observed under LLaMA3-8B, indicating that the NDCG@10, as well as on Amazon Books with -gainsarestableacrossbackbonemodels. NDCG@1 of 0.4866 and NDCG@10 of 0.7107. -Theseresultsindicatethatthelearnedprofilesen- -Advantages over fixed-structure and delib- -able more accurate identification and ordering of -erative baselines. Compared with strong fixed- -relevantitemswithincandidatesets,leadingtosu- -structureordeliberativemethodssuchasKAR(Xi -perior ranking quality in downstream recommen- -etal.,2024)andReason4Rec(Fangetal.,2025), -dation. Wefurtherevaluaterankingperformance -our approach consistently achieves lower predic- -under a more challenging setting using EASE- -tion error and higher accuracy. For example, on -based (Steck, 2019) hard negatives, and observe -Amazon Books with Qwen3-8B, our method re- -consistentimprovements;detailedresultsarepro- -duces MAE to 0.4612, compared to 0.7098 for -videdinAppendixB.2. -KARand0.6397forReason4Rec,demonstrating -moreeffectiveabstractionofuserpreferenceswith- -4.3 AblationStudy -outrelyingonpredefinedreasoningtemplates. -Consistent improvements in downstream Effectivenessofprofilegeneration,cue&strategy, -ranking. Table??reportstherankingresultsun- anduser–itemjointoptimization. Table3reports -der the Qwen3-8B backbone. Our method con- the ablation results under different design con- -sistentlyachievesthebestperformanceacrossall figurations. Starting from the history-only base- -three datasets and evaluation cutoffs. On Yelp, line (10H), introducing explicit profile genera- - -| Method | | | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 | MAE RMSE | Acc F1 | -10H(HistoryOnly) 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -Profile 0.7218 1.1863 55.48 48.09 0.6597 1.0218 58.67 57.48 0.6764 1.0469 57.14 57.68 -Profile+Cue&Strategy 0.7085 1.1654 55.83 48.54 0.5708 0.9897 58.91 55.53 0.6389 1.0108 58.43 56.88 -Profile+JointOpt.(LG(Wang 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -etal.,2025)) -Profile+Cue&Strategy+ 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -JointOpt.(Ours) -Table3: AblationstudyondifferentdesignconfigurationsinDUETusingQwen3(8B). -| Method | | Yelp | | | | AmazonMusic | | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | | (%) | -10H+30P 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3883 0.7494 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 65.13 59.97 -10H+50P 0.4909 0.9207 62.43 56.24 0.3924 0.7543 67.88 63.87 0.4553 0.9023 64.62 59.52 -10H+70P 0.4987 0.9326 61.98 55.81 0.3937 0.7564 68.22 64.12 0.4608 0.9068 64.38 59.27 -Table4: Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofilequality(usingQwen3(8B)). -tionyieldssubstantialperformanceimprovements jointoptimizationarecombined. Underthisfull -across all datasets. For example, on Yelp, MAE configuration, accuracy reaches 61.23% on Yelp, -isreducedfrom1.1235to0.7218andaccuracyin- 67.96%onAmazonMusic,and64.38%onAma- -creases from 23.17% to 55.48%, confirming that zon Books, with corresponding MAE values of -textualprofilesprovidesignificantlymoreinforma- 0.5126, 0.3937, and 0.4612, respectively. Com- -tiverepresentationsthanrawinteractionhistories. pared with the LettinGo-style configuration, this -| | | | | | | setting | yields | consistent | | improvements | across all | -| ------ | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | -| Adding | the cue&strategy | | layer | on | top of | pro- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | datasets. | | Overall,theablationresultsindicatethat | | | | -filegenerationleadstomodestbutconsistentgains. -whileprofilegenerationandjointoptimization -OnAmazonMusic,MAEfurtherdecreasesfrom -0.6597to0.5708,whileaccuracyslightlyimproves contributesubstantiallytoperformancegains,inte- -gratingcue&strategydiscoveryfurtherenhances -| from58.67%to58.91%. | | | Althoughthenumerical | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | the | effectiveness | | of joint | user–item | optimization | -improvementsintroducedbystrategyalonearelim- -ited, these results suggest that strategy discovery byprovidingastructuredspaceforexplorationand -refinement. -primarilyreshapeshowpreferenceinformationis -abstractedandexpressed,ratherthandirectlyopti- Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofile -mizingpredictionaccuracyinisolation. -| | | | | | | quality. | | Table | 4 analyzes | the | impact of histori- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | -Whenenablingjointoptimizationwithoutstrat- cal interaction length on profile quality. Across -thethreedatasets,varyingthenumberofhistorical -| egy (i.e., | the LettinGo | (Wang | et | al., 2025)-style | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -configuration),performanceimprovesmorenotice- interactions leads to only moderate performance -ablyacrossdatasets. OnAmazonMusic,accuracy differences, indicating that our method does not -| | | | | | | strongly | | depend | on long | histories. | In particular, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | -increasesto62.37%,comparedto58.67%withpro- -filegenerationalone. Inourimplementation,this usingamoderatehistorylength(e.g.,30–50inter- -settingcorrespondstoareproductionofLettinGo, actions)alreadyachievescompetitiveorbestper- -whereprofilegenerationandjointoptimizationare formanceonmostmetrics,whilefurtherincreasing -thehistorylengthprovideslimitedadditionalgains. -| appliedwithoutthestrategylayer. | | | | Whiletheorig- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| inal method | focuses | primarily | on | user | profiling, | | | | | | | -OnYelpandAmazonBooks,extendingthehis- -weextendtheoptimizationtobothuseranditem -torylengthbeyondthisrangedoesnotconsistently -profilestoensureafaircomparison. improveaccuracyorF1scoreandmayslightlyde- -Thestrongestandmostconsistentperformance gradeperformance,suggestingthatexcessivehis- -is achieved when cue&strategy discovery and toricalinteractionscanintroducenoisyorlessrele- - -vantsignals. Incontrast,AmazonMusicexhibits maintaining comparable coverage. Compared to -relativelystableperformanceacrossdifferenthis- existing methods, which either rely on extractive -torylengths,indicatingthatuserpreferencesinthis compression(e.g.,KAR(Xietal.,2024))orgener- -domainarelesssensitivetohistorytruncation. atefree-formdescriptionswithweakergrounding -Necessity of RL-based Optimization. We com- (e.g.,RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)andPALR(Yang -pare the full model with a variant without RL etal.,2023)), DUET consistentlyattainsstronger -(DUET W/O RL) to isolate the effect of RL. As alignment without sacrificing coverage. For in- -showninTable5,removingRLleadstosubstantial stance,LG(Wangetal.,2025)achievesrelatively -performancedegradationacrossalldatasets(e.g., highalignmentbutexhibitslessstablegrounding -YelpAccuracydropsfrom61.23%to48.53%),indi- acrossdatasets,whileRLMRecattainshighercov- -catingthatthegainscannotbeattributedtoprompt erageatthecostofweakersemanticalignment. In -| designalone. | | | | | contrast,DUETmaintainsbothhighalignmentand | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Without RL, the generator reduces to a static mid-to-highcoverage,suggestingamoreeffective -mapping from interaction history to textual pro- balancebetweensemanticabstractionandevidence -| files,lackingadaptiveselectionofrelevantsignals. | | | | | preservation. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Incontrast,RLenablesoptimizingprofileconstruc- -4.5 CaseStudy -tionunderrewardfeedback,resultinginmoredis- -Figure4presentsarepresentativecasestudythat -| criminative | representations.These | | results | demon- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -strate that RL-based optimization is essential for demonstrates how semantically aligned user and -| DUET | . | | | | itemprofiles | enableaccurate | | prediction | | thattran- | -| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -scendsthelimitationsofsparserawinteractionhis- -4.4 SemanticAnalysisofGeneratedProfiles tories. In the user profile, initially scattered and -To better understand the source of performance fragmentedpreferencecuesaresystematicallydis- -gains, we analyze whether the generated profiles tilled into a stable and coherent preference struc- -exhibitmeaningfulsemanticpropertiesratherthan turefavoringfunk,soul,andprogressiverock(or- -servingasintermediatetextualartifacts. Weintro- ange), coupled with a pronounced emphasis on -duce two complementary metrics to characterize musicalcomplexityandhistoricalsignificance(pur- -semanticcompatibilityandgrounding. ple). Thecorrespondingitemprofileexhibitsstrik- -Semantic Alignment. We measure the ingsymmetry,characterizingthealbumasanexem- -embedding-levelsimilaritybetweengenerateduser plaryfunk-rockcomposition(orange)andposition- -anditemprofilesusingall-mpnet-base-v2from ingitasadefiningandculturallyinfluentialrelease -Sentence-Transformers (Reimers and Gurevych, of the 1970s (purple). This example shows 519 -2019). Foreachuser–itempair,wecomputecosine that the learned profiles capture meaningful pref- -| similarity: | | | | | erence–attributecorrespondencethatisdifficultto | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | e ·e | | recoverfromindividualreviewsalone. | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | | | | | | | -| | Align(u,i) | = | | (3) | | | | | | | -| | | | ∥e ∥∥e ∥ | | | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | 5 Conclusion | | | | | | -| wheree | ande denotetheembeddingvectorsof | | | | | | | | | | -| | u i | | | | In this | paper, we | propose | DUET | , a | closed-loop | -| thegenerateduseranditemprofiles. | | | Highervalues | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | framework | for | jointly | generating | user | and item | -indicatestrongersemanticcompatibilitybetween -| | | | | | textualprofilesforrecommendation. | | | | | Unlikeprior | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -modeleduserpreferencesanditemcharacteristics. -| | | | | | methods | that rely | on | fixed templates | | or indepen- | -| -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | -| Coverage | (Faithfulness). | | We measure | token- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | dently | constructed | profiles, | DUET | | treats profile | -levelgroundingas: -| | | | | | generation | as an | exploration | problem | | and aligns | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -|Tokens(profile)∩Tokens(history)| representations directly with downstream recom- -Cov = -| | | |Tokens(profile)| | | | mendationperformance. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | (4) | Specifically, | | DUET | integrates | cue-based | ini- | -Thismetricquantifieshowmuchofthegenerated tialization, adaptive strategy construction, and -profileissupportedbyhistoricaltextualevidence. feedback-drivenjointoptimizationtoproduceflex- -We report coverage separately for user and item ible yet task-aligned user–item profiles. By opti- -| profiles. | | | | | mizing | both profiles | in | a shared | semantic | space, | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | -AsshowninTable6,DUETachievesthehigh- theframeworkreducessemanticmismatchandcap- -est semantic alignment across all datasets while turesinteraction-relevantsignalsthataredifficultto - -Setting Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 -(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) -DUETw/oRL 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -DUET(full) 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table5: EffectofRL-basedoptimization(usingQwen3(8B)). -User History: -Andre' S Grindle "Tour of U.S.A.", Rating: 5.0. If your looking for heavy metals dim orgins look no further. -Andre' S Grindle "Misfits", Rating:4.0. Actually the opening title track is more of a direct pop/rock type song. But the rock n roll -returns in a big way on "Hay Fever". -............ -Item History: -Worlds Away, Rating: 4.0, Review: The CD is wonderful, and is a seminal piece of music for both the group and for those of us who -were 'of age' in the '70s and '80s. Pablo Cruise was - and is - a group that makes beautiful music like few others, and this -shipper/seller made it all the more special with a fast ship! THANKS!!! -Worlds Away, Rating: 5.0, I love this CD! I'd recommend the Pablo Cruise Millenium Collection to get to know this band. Worlds Away to -me represents the best of breezy '70s pop. Five stars! -............ -USER PROFILE: -Andre Grindle is a dedicated music enthusiast with a deep appreciation for funk, soul, and progressive rock, particularly drawn to artists -who blend technical mastery with genre-defining innovation. His reviews consistently highlight albums that showcase musical complexity, -lyrical depth, and historical significance, often referencing artists like Stevie Wonder, Prince, and Rush. He values authenticity and -artistic vision, frequently praising albums that resist trend-chasing and prioritize creative integrity. His detailed, introspective reviews -suggest a preference for nuanced analysis over superficial praise, with a focus on emotional resonance, production quality, and the -artist's evolution. While he is generous with high ratings (often 5.0), he is also willing to critique perceived shortcomings, as seen in his -4.0 for "Test for Echo" and 3.0 for "The Color of Success." His engagement is characterized by a blend of personal anecdotes, technical -appreciation, and historical context, indicating a preference for music that transcends mere entertainment. -Item PROFILE: -"Worlds Away" by Pablo Cruise is celebrated as a peak-era funk-rock album that exemplifies the band's ability to merge polished -production with genre-blurring creativity. Users consistently praise its tight musicianship, genre-defying sound, and the band's ability to -craft catchy, emotionally resonant tracks. The album's appeal lies in its seamless fusion of rock, funk, and pop, with standout tracks like -"Love Will Find a Way" and "Worlds Away" receiving particular acclaim for their infectious melodies and lyrical depth. While some users -note its dated production compared to modern standards, the majority highlight its historical significance as a defining work of the -1970s rock-funk movement. The album resonates most with fans of 1970s progressive rock, genre-defying artists, and listeners seeking -well-crafted, emotionally engaging music. Its high average rating reflects widespread admiration for its artistic ambition and enduring -appeal, though a minority acknowledges its limitations in terms of modern production quality. -Figure4: Illustrationofthemutualcorrespondencebetweenuseranditem. Thehighlightedregionsdemonstrate -thatuserpreferencessummarizedintheuserprofilealignwiththekeyattributesextractedintheitemprofile,which -providescomplementaryinformationbeyondrawhistoriesandthusimprovespredictionaccuracy. -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. -10H 0.3902 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.3577 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.2604 /(1.00) /(1.00) -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.4932 0.1745 0.1823 0.4807 0.2170 0.2391 0.5702 0.1877 0.1544 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.4010 0.2646 0.3773 0.3931 0.3526 0.4889 0.4436 0.2994 0.3506 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.4715 0.3675 0.1917 0.4938 0.2197 0.2390 0.5216 0.2050 0.2267 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.5709 0.2378 0.2682 0.5109 0.2546 0.3749 0.5506 0.3883 0.3364 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.4882 0.2348 0.2330 0.4208 0.3328 0.3595 0.4946 0.2831 0.2949 -Ours 0.6382 0.2880 0.3429 0.5947 0.4002 0.4482 0.7287 0.3457 0.3127 -Table6: Semanticalignmentandcoverageofgeneratedprofiles. Cov. denotesthefractionoftokensgroundedin -historicaltext. -recoverfromrawhistoriesorstaticpromptsalone. reinforcementlearning–basedoptimization. These -resultssuggestthatadaptive,interaction-awaretex- -Experiments on multiple real-world datasets tualprofilesprovideapromisingdirectionformore -demonstratethatDUETconsistentlyoutperforms effective interpretable and performance-oriented -strongbaselinesunderdifferentbackbonemodels, recommendationsystems. -validating the effectiveness of joint profiling and - -| Limitations | | | | | | | References | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Keqin Bao, | Jizhi | Zhang, | Yang | Zhang, | Wenjie | Wang, | -Despiteitseffectiveness,ourapproachhasseveral FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2023. Tallrec: Anef- -fectiveandefficienttuningframeworktoalignlarge -| limitations. | First, | the | proposed | framework | | relies | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | languagemodelwithrecommendation. | | | | | InProceed- | | -onlargelanguagemodelsforbothprofilegenera- ingsofthe17thACMConferenceonRecommender -tion and downstream recommendation, which in- Systems,pages1007–1014. -| troduces | additional | computational | | | overhead | dur- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -TingChen,Wei-LiHan,Hai-DongWang,Yi-XunZhou, -| ingtrainingandinference. | | | Whileourexperiments | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | BinXu,andBin-YuZang.2007. | | | | Contentrecommen- | | | -showconsistentgainsacrossdifferentbackbones, dationsystembasedonprivatedynamicuserprofile. -the overall efficiency may be constrained when In2007Internationalconferenceonmachinelearn- -| | | | | | | | ing and | cybernetics, | | volume | 4, pages | 2112–2118. | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| scalingtoverylargeuseroritemsets. | | | | | Second,the | | | | | | | | | -IEEE. -| quality | of the generated | | profiles | is | inherently | de- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| pendent | on the underlying | | LLMs | | and prompting | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Yue Chen, | Minghua | | He, Fangkai | Yang, | Pu | Zhao, | -strategies. Variationsinmodelcapacityorprompt LuWang,YuKang,YifeiDong,YuefengZhan,Hao -Sun,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,andDongmei -sensitivitymayleadtodifferencesinprofilestabil- -| | | | | | | | Zhang. | 2025. | Warriormath: | | Enhancing | the | mathe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -ity,whichwedonotexplicitlycontrolinthecurrent -maticalabilityoflargelanguagemodelswithadefect- -design. Finally,ourevaluationfocusesontext-rich -| | | | | | | | awareframework. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.01245. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -recommendationscenarioswheresufficienthistor- -| | | | | | | | Paul Covington, | | Jay | Adams, and | Emre | Sargin. | 2016. | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -| ical reviews | are | available. | | The effectiveness | | of | | | | | | | | -Deepneuralnetworksforyoutuberecommendations. -| the proposed | strategy | | in domains | with | extremely | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InProceedingsofthe10thACMconferenceonrec- -sparsetextualsignalsorinnon-textualmodalities -ommendersystems,pages191–198. -remainstobefurtherexplored. -DeepSeek-AI,DayaGuo,DejianYang,HaoweiZhang, -JunxiaoSong,RuoyuZhang,RunxinXu,QihaoZhu, -ShirongMa,PeiyiWang,XiaoBi,XiaokangZhang, -Data,Privacy,andEthicsConsiderations Xingkai Yu, Yu Wu, Z. F. Wu, Zhibin Gou, Zhi- -| | | | | | | | hong | Shao, | Zhuoshu | Li, Ziyi | Gao, and | 181 | others. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | 2025. | Deepseek-r1: | | Incentivizing | reasoning | | capa- | -Alldatasetsusedinthisworkarepubliclyreleased bilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. Preprint, -arXiv:2501.12948. -bytheiroriginalowners,andwefollowtheofficial -termsofuseassociatedwitheachdataset,utilizing -JiaxinDeng,ShiyaoWang,KuoCai,LejianRen,Qigen -thedatasolelyforresearchpurposesaspermitted -| | | | | | | | Hu, Weifeng | | Ding, | Qiang Luo, | and | Guorui | Zhou. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -bytheirrespectivelicenses;forreproducibility,the 2025. Onerec: Unifyingretrieveandrankwithgen- -officialdatasetsourcesarecitedinthecorrespond- erativerecommenderanditerativepreferencealign- -ment. Preprint,arXiv:2502.18965. -ingsectionsofthispaper,andwedonotredistribute -anyrawuser-generatedcontentsuchasreviewtext AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, -| aspartofthiswork. | | Thisresearchdoesnotattempt | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, -to identify or infer the identity of any individual Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela -| | | | | | | | Fan,and1others.2024. | | | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -user,andpriortotraininganddownstreamprofile -arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.21783. -| generation, | we | apply text | filtering | | procedures | to | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -remove direct personal identifiers where applica- YiFang,WenjieWang,YangZhang,FengbinZhu,Qi- -ble;themodelsaretrainedsolelyonpubliclyavail- fanWang,FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2025. Rea- -son4rec:Largelanguagemodelsforrecommendation -abledata,andnoadditionalprivateorproprietary -| | | | | | | | withdeliberativeuserpreferencealignment. | | | | | Preprint, | | -| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| user information | | is introduced. | | Furthermore, | | we | | | | | | | | -arXiv:2502.02061. -| do not release | generated | | user | profiles | or | any per- | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MinghuaHe,YueChen,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Wenjie -useroutputsproducedduringthemodelingprocess, -Yin,YuKang,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,and -andallreportedresultsarepresentedinaggregate -| | | | | | | | DongmeiZhang.2025. | | | Execoder:Empoweringlarge | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| form for | evaluation | purposes | | only. | From | a secu- | | | | | | | | -languagemodelswithexecutabilityrepresentationfor -rityperspective,theassociatedcoderepositoryhas codetranslation. Preprint,arXiv:2501.18460. -beenscannedforpotentialsecrets,andanyinternal -MinjieHong,ZirunGuo,YanXia,ZehanWang,Ziang -endpointsorconfidentialconfigurationinformation -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | Tao | Jin, and | Zhou Zhao. | 2025a. | Apo: | En- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | -havebeenremovedpriortorelease. -hancingreasoningabilityofmllmsviaasymmetric -| | | | | | | | policyoptimization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2506.21655. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Minjie Hong, Yan Xia, Zehan Wang, Jieming Zhu, JoarSkalse,NikolausH.R.Howe,DmitriiKrashenin- -Ye Wang, Sihang Cai, Xiaoda Yang, Quanyu Dai, nikov, and David Krueger. 2025. Defining -ZhenhuaDong,ZhimengZhang,and1others.2025b. and characterizing reward hacking. Preprint, -| Eager-llm: | Enhancinglargelanguagemodelsasrec- | | | | | arXiv:2209.13085. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ommenders | through | exogenous | behavior-semantic | | | | | | | | | -integration. InProceedingsoftheACMonWebCon- Harald Steck. 2019. Embarrassingly shallow autoen- -ference2025,pages2754–2762. codersforsparsedata. InProceedingsofTheWorld -WideWebConference(WWW),pages3251–3257. -MinjieHong,ZetongZhou,ZirunGuo,ZiangZhang, -| Ruofan | Hu, Weinan | Gan, | Jieming | Zhu, and | Zhou | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ChaoSun,YaoboLiang,YamingYang,ShilinXu,Tian- -| Zhao.2025c. | Generativereasoningrecommendation | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | mengYang,andYunhaiTong.2024. | | | | | Rlrf4rec: Re- | -| viallms. | Preprint,arXiv:2510.20815. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | inforcement | learning | from | recsys | feedback | for en- | -JihwanJeong,YinlamChow,GuyTennenholtz,Chih- hancedrecommendationreranking. arXivpreprint -| Wei Hsu, | Azamat | Tulepbergenov, | | Mohammad | | arXiv:2410.05939. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| Ghavamzadeh, | and | Craig | Boutilier. | 2023. | Fac- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | QwenTeam.2025. | | Qwen3technicalreport. | | | Preprint, | -| tual and | personalized | recommendations | | using | lan- | | | | | | | -| guagemodelsandreinforcementlearning. | | | | | Preprint, | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -arXiv:2310.06176. -| | | | | | | Hugo Touvron, | Louis | Martin, | Kevin | Stone, | Peter Al- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | -Yitong Ji, Aixin Sun, Jie Zhang, and Chenliang Li. bert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay -| 2023. A | critical | study | on data leakage | in | recom- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bashlykov,SoumyaBatra,PrajjwalBhargava,Shruti -| mendersystemofflineevaluation. | | | | ACMTrans.Inf. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Bhosale,and1others.2023. | | | Llama2: | | Openfoun- | -Syst.,41(3):75:1–75:27. -| | | | | | | dation and | fine-tuned | chat | models. | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -------- | -arXiv:2307.09288. -| JiachengLin,TianWang,andKunQian.2025. | | | | | Rec-r1: | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bridginggenerativelargelanguagemodelsanduser- -| | | | | | | LeandrovonWerra, | | YounesBelkada, | | LewisTunstall, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -centricrecommendationsystemsviareinforcement -EdwardBeeching,TristanThrush,NathanLambert, -| learning. | Preprint,arXiv:2503.24289. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | Shengyi | Huang, | Kashif | Rasul, | and | Quentin Gal- | -| | | | | | | louédec. | TRL: | Transformer | Reinforcement | | Learn- | -AiweiLiu,MinghuaHe,ShaoxunZeng,SijunZhang, -| LinhaoZhang,ChuhanWu,WeiJia,YuanLiu,Xiao | | | | | | ing. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Zhou,andJieZhou.2025. | | | Wedlm:Reconcilingdiffu- | | | | | | | | | -sionlanguagemodelswithstandardcausalattention LuWang,DiZhang,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Jianfeng -forfastinference. Preprint,arXiv:2512.22737. Liu,YuefengZhan,HaoSun,QingweiLin,Weiwei -| | | | | | | Deng, Dongmei | | Zhang, | Feng | Sun, and | Qi Zhang. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | -HongtaoLiu,FangzhaoWu,WenjunWang,Xianchen -| | | | | | | 2025. Lettingo: | | Exploreuserprofilegenerationfor | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,PengfeiJiao,ChuhanWu,andXingXie.2019. -| | | | | | | recommendationsystem. | | | InProceedingsofthe31st | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -Nrpa: Neuralrecommendationwithpersonalizedat- ACMSIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscovery -tention. In Proceedings of the 42nd International andDataMiningV.2,KDD’25,NewYork,NY,USA. -ACMSIGIRConferenceonResearchandDevelop- AssociationforComputingMachinery. -mentinInformationRetrieval,pages1233–1236. -YeWang,JiahaoXun,MinjieHong,JiemingZhu,Tao -| Wensheng | Lu, Jianxun | Lian, | Wei Zhang, | Guanghua | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Jin,WangLin,HaoyuanLi,LinjunLi,YanXia,Zhou -Li,MingyangZhou,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2024. -| | | | | | | Zhao,and1others.2024. | | | Eager: | Two-streamgen- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -Aligninglargelanguagemodelsforcontrollablerec- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.05063. erativerecommenderwithbehavior-semanticcollab- -ommendations. -| | | | | | | oration. | InProceedingsofthe30thACMSIGKDD | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RadaMihalceaandPaulTarau.2004. Textrank: Bring- ConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMin- -| | | InEMNLP. | | | | ing,pages3245–3254. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingorderintotext. -| Zhaopeng | Qiu, Xian | Wu, | Jingyue Gao, | and | Wei Fan. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Triyanna | Widiyaningtyas, | | Indriana | Hidayah, | and | -2021. U-BERT:pre-traininguserrepresentationsfor -| | | | | | | TeguhBAdji.2021. | | Userprofilecorrelation-based | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -improved recommendation. In AAAI, pages 4320– similarity(upcsim)algorithminmovierecommenda- -| 4327.AAAIPress. | | | | | | tionsystem. | JournalofBigData,8(1):52. | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| NilsReimersandIrynaGurevych.2019. | | | | Sentence-bert: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | J.Wu.2023. | Computationalunderstandingofuserin- | | | | | -Sentenceembeddingsusingsiamesebert-networks. -terfaces. -InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical -MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP), -pages3982–3992. Yunjia Xi, Weiwen Liu, Jianghao Lin, Xiaoling Cai, -| | | | | | | Hong Zhu, | Jieming | Zhu, | Bo Chen, | Ruiming | Tang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ----- | -Xubin Ren, Wei Wei, Lianghao Xia, Lixin Su, Suqi WeinanZhang,andYongYu.2024. Towardsopen- -Cheng,JunfengWang,DaweiYin,andChaoHuang. world recommendation with knowledge augmenta- -2024. Representationlearningwithlargelanguage tionfromlargelanguagemodels. InProceedingsof -modelsforrecommendation. InProceedingsofthe the18thACMConferenceonRecommenderSystems, -| ACMonWebConference2024,pages3464–3475. | | | | | | pages12–22. | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -A ExperimentSetup -FanYang,ZhengChen,ZiyanJiang,EunahCho,Xiao- -| jiangHuang,andYanbinLu.2023. | | Palr:Personaliza- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tionawarellmsforrecommendation. | | arXivpreprint | A.1 DataCuration | | | | | | | -arXiv:2305.07622. -Jiarui Zhang. 2024. Guided profile generation im- Table7: Statisticaldetailsoftheevaluationdatasets. -| proves personalization | with llms. | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | -| arXiv:2409.13093. | | | Dataset | #Train | #Valid | | #Test #User | | #Item | -| | | | Music | 43,071 | 3,271 | | 1,296 | 4,183 | 2,660 | -| | | | Book | 71,972 | 6,144 | | 5,541 13,863 | | 13,515 | -| | | | Yelp | 51,497 | 4,757 | | 4,328 | 8,453 | 13,426 | -| | | | We conduct | | experiments | | on three | widely | used | -real-worlddatasets: -| | | | • AmazonMusic(Music): | | | | Thisreferstothe“Dig- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | ital Music” | | subset | of the | well-known | | Amazon | -Productdataset3,whichrecordsrichuserreviews, -ratings,andtextualinformationaboutitems,such -| | | | as titles, | across | a | broad | range | of product | cate- | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | -gories,ontheAmazonplatform.2 -| | | | • AmazonBook(Book): | | | Thisreferstothe“Book” | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -subsetoftheAmazonProductdataset. -dataset4, -| | | | • Yelp: | This | refers | to the | Yelp | Open | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | | which | includes | user | reviews, | ratings | | for busi- | -| | | | nesses | such | as restaurants | | and | retail shops, | as | -wellastextualinformationaboutthebusinesses. -Itiswidelyusedinrecommendationtasks(Qiu -etal.,2021). -WeusetheentireMusicdatasetforexperiments, -| | | | while for | the Book | | and Yelp | datasets, | we | utilize | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | onlyasubsetduetotheirlargesize. | | | | | FortheBook | | -dataset,weusedatafromthelasttwomonths,and -fortheYelpdataset,weusedatafromthelastsix -months. Foreachdataset,wesplititintotraining, -| | | | validation, | and | test | sets based | on | the timestamps | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | of interactions, | | ensuring | that | test | interactions | oc- | -curafteralltrainingandvalidationinteractionsto -preventinformationleakage(Jietal.,2023). -| | | | Regarding | | data | filtering, | following | | prior | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | work (Liu | et | al., 2019), | we | adopt | a 5-core | set- | -tingtofilterthedataandexcludecold-startusers -| | | | and items—those | | not | appearing | | in the | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | set—from | the | validation | and | test | sets. | The sta- | -tisticaldetailsoftheprocesseddatasetareprovided -inTable7. -3https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ -amazon/links.html. -4https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -open-dataset/. - -| A.1.1 | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | RLMRecPrompt | | | | -| ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -Inourexperiments,weprimarilyemployQwen3- Role: Businessrecommendationassistant -Task: Determinebusinesstypesauserislikely -| 8B(Team,2025)andLLaMA38BInstruct | | | | | | (Dubey | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| etal.,2024;Touvronetal.,2023)asboththerec- | | | | | | | toenjoy | | | | -| ommendation | | model | and | the | profile | generation | InputFormat: | | | | -•Title: Businessname -model. Thetrainingprocessisimplementedusing -theTRL(vonWerraetal.). Keyhyperparameters, •Categories: Businesscategories -suchasbatchsizeandlearningrate,aredetermined •Sentiment: Usersentimenttowardbusiness -throughgridsearchtoachieveoptimalperformance. -OutputRequirements: -Moredetailscanbefoundinourcode. -1. JSONformatonly -2. Structure: -A.2 BaselinePrompts -{ -| | | | | | | | "summarization": | "Types | of businesses | user | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -KARPrompt -likelyenjoys"(≤100words), -Task: Analyzeuserpreferencesbasedonbusi- -| | | | | | | | "reasoning": | "Brief explanation | | for summa- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | -nessreviewinghistory -rization"(nowordlimit) -Input: {user_history}-User’sbusinessreview- -} -inghistorywithsentimentsovertime -3. NoadditionaltextoutsideJSON -Instructions: -| 1. | Analyze | the | user’s | preferences | considering | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Input: | INTERACTION | | ITEMS: | -businessnamesandcategories -{user_history} -| 2. | Take | into account | | sentiment | patterns | over | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time -| 3. | Provideclearexplanationsbasedonreview- | | | | | | LGPrompt | | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -inghistorydetails -Youwillserveasanassistanttohelpmegener- -| 4. | Consider | other | pertinent | | factors | that may | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ateauserprofilebasedonthisuser’ssentiments -influencepreferences -historytobetterunderstandthisusers’interest -andthuspredicthis/hersentimentaboutatarget -| PALRPrompt | | | | | | | item. Iwillprovideyouwithsomebehaviorhis- | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | toryoftheuserinthisformat: | | [itemattributes | | -Task: Summarizeuserpreferencesusingkey- -| | | | | | | | andsentiment]. | Theuserprofileyougenerate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -words. -shouldcontainasmuchusefulcontentaspossi- -| Input: | | {user_history} | | - historical | businesses | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -bletohelppredicttheuser’ssentimenttowards -withusersentiments. -anewbusiness. -| Output | | Format: | An | itemized | list ranked | by | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -USERHISTORY:{user_history}. -importance. -PROFILEYOUGENERATE: -Template: -| | • KEY_WORD_1: | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -R4RecPrompt(Reasoner) -| | TORY_BUSINESS_1", | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -UserReviewHistory -TORY_BUSINESS_2" -⟨H u organizedasbelow⟩ -| | • KEY_WORD_2: | | | | | "HIS- | 1. TitleofItem1 | | | | -| ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | TORY_BUSINESS_3" | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| | | | | | | | NegativeAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| Instructions: | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -[Preference2],... -| | 1. Extract | key | preference | | indicators | from | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2. TitleofItem2 -userinteractionhistory. -| | | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -2. Rankkeywordsbyimportance. NegativeAspects: [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... -| | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | - -| [Preference2],... | | | | | | | cantlyworsethanDUETacrossalldatasets. | | | | | This | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -indicatesthatcoherentsummariesaloneareinsuf- -... -| | | | | | | | ficient, | and that | the gains | of DUET | | arise from | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -ItemReviewHistorybyOtherUsers -⟨H organizedinthesameformatasabove⟩ learnedsemanticabstractionratherthanextractive -i -compression. -| Task: | Analyze | whether | | the user | will | like the | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| new Music | | i based | on | the user’s | preferences | | | | | | | | -B.2 RankingunderHardNegativeSampling -| andtheitem’sfeatures. | | | | Provideyourrationale | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toconstructamorechallengingrankingscenario, -inoneconciseparagraph. -wereplacerandomnegativeswithhardnegatives -| | | | | | | | generatedbyacollaborativefilteringmodel. | | | | | Specif- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -A.3 ExampleofCue -ically,foreachuser,weretrievehigh-scoringitems -Thefollowingexamplesillustratehowrawsignals -| | | | | | | | from an | EASE(Steck, | 2019) | model | that | the user | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | -| aredistilledintocues. | | | Asshownonthetop, | | | user | | | | | | | -hasnotinteractedwith,andcombinethemwiththe -cuesemphasizehistoricalpreferences,whileitem -ground-truthitemtoformthecandidateset. -cues highlight metadata and user-group patterns. Table 9 reports the results. Compared to ran- -| Together, | they | provide | minimal | | but informative | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -domsampling,performancedecreasesforallmeth- -hypothesesforprofileexploration. -| | | | | | | | ods due | to increased | difficulty, | while | DUET | con- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | sistently | maintains | the | best performance | | across | -ExamplesofUserCues -| | | | | | | | datasets. | Thisindicatesthattheimprovementsare | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “enjoys | retro | puzzle | games” | — | derived | from re- | | | | | | | -robustandnotlimitedtotrivialrankingscenarios. -peatedengagementwithclassictitles. -“prefersconciseproductreviews”—inferredfrom B.3 RobustnessunderPreferenceDiversity -apatternofshort,directcomments. -WefurtheranalyzetherobustnessofDUETunder -“tendstogivehighratingsbutrarelycomments”— -| | | | | | | | varyinglevelsofuserpreferencediversity. | | | | | Weuse | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -highlightingconsistencybutlimitedfeedback. -thevarianceofhistoricalratingsasaproxyforpref- -| | | | | | | | erencestability: | | lowvarianceindicatesconsistent | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -ExamplesofItemCues -| | | | | | | | preferences, | while | high | variance | corresponds | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -“lightweighttrail-runningshoes”—derivedfrom -diverseorpotentiallyconflictingsignals. -productmetadata. -Wepartitionusersintothreegroupsbasedonper- -| “popular | among | budget-conscious | | | users” | — in- | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -centilethresholds(bottom33%,middle33%,top -ferredfrompurchasepatterns. -33%ofratingvariance)andevaluateperformance -| “stylized | with | retro | aesthetics” | | — extracted | from | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withineachgroup. -itemdescriptions. -| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Table 10, | performance | | degrades | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -smoothlyaspreferencediversityincreasesacross -| | | | | | | | all datasets. | Importantly, | | the degradation | | is grad- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -B AdditionalExperiments -ualratherthancatastrophic,indicatingthatDUET -B.1 Non-LLMBaselineviaExtractive -remainsstableunderheterogeneousornoisyinter- -Summarization -actionhistories. -| To examine | | whether | the | gains | of DUET | stem | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C TheUseofLargeLanguageModels -| from improved | | semantic | | representations | | rather | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| than generic | | text generation, | | we | introduce | a non- | | | | | | | -WeusedaLargeLanguageModel(LLM)onlyas -LLMbaselinebasedonextractivesummarization. a writing assistant to polish the language of the -| Specifically, | | we apply | TextRank | | (Mihalcea | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | manuscript | (e.g., | grammar | refinement, | | style ad- | -Tarau,2004)toselectsalientsentencesfromuser -| | | | | | | | justment,andclarityimprovement). | | | | Theresearch | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -historiesandconstructuserprofileswithoutusing ideas,methodologydesign,experiments,andanal- -anygenerativemodel. ysiswereentirelyconceived,implemented,andval- -| The | extracted | summaries | | are | then fed | into the | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -idatedbytheauthorswithoutrelianceontheLLM. -samedownstreampredictorforratingestimation. -| | | | | | | | The LLM | did not | contribute | to research | | ideation, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -Thisbaselineisolatestheeffectofreadablesumma- experimentaldesign,orresultinterpretation. -rizationfromrepresentationlearning. -Table8showsthatTextRankimprovesoversim- -| ple history | truncation | | (10H), | but | remains | signifi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Method | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | (%) | -10H 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -TextRank 0.8104 1.1323 50.51 30.23 0.5914 0.8223 61.19 29.68 0.6328 0.8854 59.59 29.48 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table8: Comparisonwithanon-LLMextractivesummarizationbaseline(TextRank). -| Method | | | Yelp | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -| | Table9: | RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| VarianceGroup | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -#Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 -| | | | (%) | (%) | | (%) (%) | | | (%) (%) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | -Stable 1530 0.4017 0.8664 71.76 68.96 432 0.2368 0.5990 82.56 86.89 1876 0.3171 0.8403 76.64 72.56 -Moderate 1354 0.4773 0.8309 60.09 46.26 436 0.3921 0.6628 64.16 47.02 1827 0.4495 0.8059 66.73 55.45 -Diverse 1444 0.6632 1.1198 51.13 45.95 428 0.5536 0.9607 57.10 59.27 1838 0.6199 1.0603 49.52 46.35 -Table10: PerformanceofDUETunderdifferentlevelsofuserpreferencediversity(measuredbyratingvariance). -#Samp. denotesthenumberofsamplesineachgroup. \ No newline at end of file +SURVEY REP ORT + +SP ONSORED BY + +EXCLUSIVE SURVEY + +ARE YOU + +THE LAST MILE +OF RETAIL? + + TABLE OF CONTENTS + +Are You Winning The Last Mile Of Retail? ............................................................................................................................ + +3 + +Major Challenge: Managing The Customer Experience ............................................................................................. + +6 + +Byline: Delivery Imperatives To Compete With Amazon Without Breaking The Bank .......................... + +8 + +Success Story: Uncommon Goods ............................................................................................................................................... + +10 + +Retailers Seek Innovative Returns Solutions ..................................................................................................................... + +11 + +Byline: Final Mile Strategies: Balancing Customer Satisfaction And Profitability........................................ + +15 + +Success Story: Kohl’s And Amazon ........................................................................................................................................... + +16 + +Retailers Turn To Technology And Disruptors .................................................................................................................. + +16 + +Success Story: Neiman Marcus ................................................................................................................................................. + +19 + +Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................................................ + +19 + +About Retail TouchPoints ................................................................................................................................................................ + +20 + +About Oracle .......................................................................................................................................................................................... + +20 + +About Convey ......................................................................................................................................................................................... + +20 + + ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE +OF RETAIL? + +In retail, the “last mile” is becoming more crowded, more rushed, more expensive, and + +an ever-more-critical contributor to a positive customer experience. + +Over the past 18 months, there has been a 50% increase in last mile services, with +most of the demand coming from B2C e-Commerce, according to The Last Mile Retail +Study, 2018 conducted by eft Supply Chain and Logistics Business Intelligence. + +In addition to the growth of online sales, consumer demands are adding fuel to the + +competitive fire: + +• 65% of consumers want greater flexibility for deliveries; + +• 61% want faster deliveries; and + +• 51% want real-time visibility into the status of their orders. + +This inaugural Retail TouchPoints Last Mile Benchmark Report, based on a survey +of 146 retail executives, provides a snapshot of the challenges retailers face in + +managing the last mile, including shipping and delivery; post-sale services such as setup + +and installation; keeping customers informed; and the tricky (and expensive) area of + +product returns. + +There has been +a 50% increase +in last mile +services over the +past 18 months, +with most of +the demand +coming from B2C +e-Commerce. + +— EFT LAST MILE +RETAIL STUDY 2018 + +3 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + While 36% of +retailers deliver +less than 10% of +orders directly to +customers, 19% +deliver 25% to 50% +of orders direct to +consumers; +24% deliver 75% +of more. + +The Last Mile survey indicates that delivery of products to customers’ homes or offices +already is widespread — and growing. While 36% of retailers deliver less than 10% +of orders directly to customers (versus shoppers taking them directly from a store), +19% deliver 25% to 50% of orders direct to customers, and 24% deliver 75% or more +of orders direct to customers. Presumably, though, this last group of respondents are + +online-only retailers that lack brick-and-mortar stores as distribution points. + +What Percentage Of Products Are Delivered To +Shoppers’ Homes/Offices? +(Versus picked up/purchased in-store) + +LESS THAN 10% + +10% TO 25% + +25% TO 50% + +51% TO 75% + +MORE THAN 75% + +24% + +36% + +19% + +14% + +7% + +4 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? Retailers have +seen their volume +of direct deliveries +increase over the +past 18 months: +less than 10% said +their percentage +has decreased. + +In line with the results of the eft study, Last Mile respondents have seen their volume +of direct deliveries increase over the past 18 months: 29% say the percentage has +increased significantly, and 39% say it has increased slightly. Less than 10% said the +percentage has decreased, and 23% say the volume has remained the same. + +How Has The Percentage Of Products You Deliver To +Shoppers Changed In The Last 18 Months? + +23% + +29% + +INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +INCREASED SLIGHTLY + +DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +DECREASED SLIGHTLY + +STAYED ABOUT THE SAME + +5% + +4% + +39% + +Which Fulfillment/Delivery Services Do You Offer? +(Among retailers with both stores and e-Commerce sites) + +BUY VIA MOBILE SITE/APP, DELIVER TO HOME + +BUY ONLINE, PICK UP IN-STORE + +BUY VIA MOBILE SITE/APP, PICK UP IN-STORE + +BUY ONLINE OR VIA MOBILE APP, RETURN IN-STORE + +BUY VIA STORE ASSOCIATE’S MOBILE DEVICE, DELIVER TO HOME + +BUY VIA IN-STORE KIOSK, DELIVER TO HOME + +46% + +44% + +31% + +28% + +21% + +16% + +5 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? MANAGING CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE AND +EXPECTATIONS TOPS RETAIL CHALLENGES + +The volume of last-mile activity is not the only thing that’s on the rise. Customer +expectations around delivery times, service levels and visibility into the process +all are increasing rapidly. That’s reflected in the fact that two of the top three concerns +among retailers responding to the Last Mile survey are related to customers: Customer +expectations around delivery times is the leading challenge, at 49%, and customer +expectations of free/low-cost shipping is third, at 44%. + +What Are Your Most Significant Last Mile Challenges? + +Two of the top three +concerns among +retailers are related +to customers: +expectations around +delivery times at 49%, +and expectations +of free/low-cost +shipping at 44%. + +49% + +47% + +44% + +18% + +CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS +AROUND DELIVERY TIMES + +RISING SHIPPING +COSTS + +CUSTOMER +EXPECTATIONS OF FREE/ +LOW-COST SHIPPING + +HANDLING CUSTOMER +QUERIES/COMPLAINTS +EFFECTIVELY + +17% + +14% + +12% + +DELIVERY/FULFILLMENT +LOGISTICS + +RETURNS +MANAGEMENT + +MANAGING POST- +PURCHASE SERVICE +PROVIDERS + +6 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? “Ultimately, the most important factor in the last mile is the experience of the end +customer (the consumer),” according to the eft Last Mile Retail Study. “Consumers have +the same expectations of service and engagement from the places they shop online as + +they do in-store, except they expect it faster, in line with the speed of the digital world.” + +Amazon is playing a large part in raising the bar of consumer expectations. The +Amazon Prime service effectively “hides” shipping costs in an annual fee, which + +increases pressures on competitors to offer low- or no-cost shipping. Amazon and +others have poured investments into offering two-day, next-day, same-day, and even +less than one-hour shipping to a wider swath of consumers, and it has had an impact +on the whole customer mindset. + +For example, the maximum number of days people are willing to wait for an item to be +delivered in exchange for free shipping has decreased, from 5.5 days in 2012 to 4.1 +in 2018, according to the 2018 AlixPartners Home-Delivery Shopping Survey. Amazon +Prime members are less patient than the population at large: only 19% of Prime +members would wait a week in exchange for free shipping, compared to 31% of non- +Prime members. + +Free shipping has become very much the rule, not the exception. A December 2017 +survey by L2 revealed that 77% of brands offer free shipping on their web sites. +Among this group, 35% do not require a minimum spending threshold to qualify for +free shipping. For those retailers that do require a minimum order, the median dollar +amount of $50 has not changed since 2016. + +The maximum +number of days +people are willing +to wait for an item +to be delivered +in exchange for +free shipping has +decreased from +5.5 days in 2012 to +4.1 days in 2018. + +— ALIXPARTNERS +HOME-DELIVERY +SHOPPING SURVEY + +7 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + DELIVERY IMPERATIVES TO COMPETE WITH AMAZON +WITHOUT BREAKING THE BANK + +By Rob Taylor, +CEO, Convey + +As retailers fight to stay relevant in the face of Amazon, last mile delivery is being pushed front and center. While Prime + +delivery has made the words “fast” and “free” synonymous with a seamless shipping experience, companies have had to + +align their operational costs with quickly changing customer expectations, or risk customer loss — 70% will not return after a + +poor delivery experience. + +Consumers continue to report that they are unimpressed with delivery standards today — nearly 60% of shoppers say that + +the delivery experience is mediocre at best, and similarly, for those returning parcel shipments, 42% said that they were not + +satisfied with retailers’ return processes. + +This has driven pressures to create the perfect delivery experience, with 83% of supply chain executives saying that CX is + +now a companywide goal. While the delivery experience is now a standard KPI, many still struggle with legacy technology. + +By investing in visibility solutions, retailers can identify exceptions that derail delivery, resolve issues before they result + +in an angry customer and reset expectations to create a positive outcome. For retailers, this responsibility involves defining + +appropriate expectations through proactive communication, keeping delivery date promises and providing + +self-service options. + +Communication: Like any great relationship, the retailer-consumer bond needs to be fueled by communication and met +expectations. For the 93% of consumers who say they want to stay informed and receive proactive updates about their + +shipments, communication creates a sense of transparency. This visibility and communication helps them answer, “Where is + +my order?” + +According to our research, returns communication is equally important, as it was a source of anxiety for 70% of customers. + +Customers returning items indicated that the “Where is my money?” question was most pressing, and they did not want to + +deal with the retailer to get that information. + +Commitment: While customers care about “fast and free shipping,” over 90% indicated that missing a promise date comes +with consequences ranging from expected compensation to disloyalty. If a retailer misses a promise date, consumers + +expect a proactive response, and this expectation is amplified over the holidays. Over 57% of consumers said they would be + +impressed if their retailer either refunded shipping costs or expedited a new shipment in response to a late shipment. + +Control: When it is possible for the consumer to resolve the exception or an anxiety, 97.5% of customers will opt for +self-service options. This includes the ability to re-route an in-transit shipment or expedite a new delivery, with younger + +consumers also asking for self-pickup options such as lockers. In reverse logistics, consumer control gives the consumer the + +ability to schedule the return themselves. In either scenario, they seek convenience — they do not want to pick up the phone + +to call a carrier’s 1-800 number. + +Customer experience is becoming increasingly important in final mile delivery. Those who can embrace the rise of digital and + +bend to their customers’ demands can also increase their own flexibility for package delivery. Ultimately, these retailers will + +be able to create a memorable delivery experience and a loyal following without compromising their operations budget. + +8 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + CLEARING UP CONSUMERS’ VISIBILITY CHALLENGES + +Retailers are paying attention to shoppers’ last-mile demands. According to the eft +survey, 47% have implemented delivery feedback surveys, and 40% have increased last +mile visibility for customers. + +Respondents to the Last Mile survey use a variety of tools to keep customers informed +about the status of their deliveries: 86% rely on email notifications, along with online +tracking links (38%), text messages (33%) and phone calls (29%). Retailers’ self- +evaluation of their communication skills is generally positive. A majority, 54%, rate them +as “good,” and only 8% rate them as “poor.” + +47% of +retailers have +implemented +delivery feedback +surveys and 40% +have increased +last mile visibility +for customers. + +How Do You Inform Customers About Their Delivery Status? +(Check all that apply) + +— EFT LAST MILE +RETAIL STUDY 2018 + +38% + +33% + +29% + +86% + +EMAIL NOTIFICATIONS + +ONLINE TRACKING LINK + +TEXT MESSAGES + +PHONE CALLS + +How Would You Rate Your Last-Mile +Communications With Customers? + +8% + +14% + +EXCELLENT + +GOOD + +SATISFACTORY + +POOR + +54% + +24% + +9 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + SUCCESS STORY + +VISIBILITY SOLUTION BOOSTS ENGAGEMENT AND CTR +FOR UNCOMMON GOODS + +Uncommon Goods, a heavily gift-oriented online business devoted to sustainability and customer service, knew that +its customers expected visibility into where their packages were at any given time. The retailer launched the Engage + +product from Convey in November 2016 to provide communication and proactive exception management, and has + +used the platform since then to deliver exceptional customer experiences. + +When an order ships, customers receive an email with a tracking link that takes them to a mobile-optimized branded + +page on the Convey platform. Behind the scenes, Convey integrates and translates all carrier information, allowing + +customers to watch and understand what’s happening as the shipment progresses. Shoppers can sign up for text + +messages and exception emails; rate the experience and submit feedback to the Uncommon Goods team; click back + +to FAQs; and in some cases place additional orders via special promotions. + +Key results include: + +• 12% of shoppers subscribe to SMS notifications; + +• 54% of shoppers leave feedback before delivery; and + +• 6% of shoppers are clicking through to the Uncommon Goods site from the tracking page. + +Early knowledge of customer feedback and shipment issues such as delays, incorrect addresses or damaged shipments + +gives the retailer’s team more time to proactively correct problems. “Customers really appreciate being in the loop, and + +alerted when there’s an unforeseen delay,” said MC Halfpenny, Director of Operations, Uncommon Goods. “Rather than + +causing them to be angry, often Uncommon Goods looks like the hero because we’re being proactive.” + +10 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + RETAILERS SEEK NEW SOLUTIONS TO +PERENNIAL PROBLEM OF RETURNS + +One of the most challenging aspects of the Last Mile is that it’s a two-way street. + +Customers can (and do) return items, and the rise of digital commerce has raised the + +stakes — and the costs — in this critical area. + +“Return rates for online retail are higher — sometimes four times higher — than for + +traditional brick-and-mortar retailers,” said Patrick Bohannon, Vice President, Retail + +Strategy for Oracle. “Return policy is very influential to online sales. Consumers want to + +have easy and cost-free returns, so many retailers are liberalizing their return rates.” + +A Deloitte 2017 holiday shopping survey indicated that consumers’ top perks for online +shopping were free shipping, at 72%, and store policies for easy returns, at 44%. + +While the majority (61%) of retailers responding to the Last Mile survey are able to +keep their returns percentage below 10%, more than one in four, 26%, have a returns +percentage in the 10% to 20% range. + +Returns +percentages +appear to be +on the rise; +only 13% of +retailers reported +decreases over +the past 18 +months. + +What Is Your Returns Percentage? + +3% + +10% + +61% + +26% + +LESS THAN 10% + +10% TO 20% + +21% TO 30% + +31% TO 40% + +Returns percentages appear to be on the rise: 26% of retailers reported a slight +increase over the past 18 months and 5% reported a significant increase. Only +13% reported decreases. + +11 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? How Has Your Returns Percentage +Changed Over The Past 18 Months? + +56% + +5% + +26% + +7% + +6% + +INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +INCREASED SLIGHTLY + +DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +DECREASED SLIGHTLY + +STAYED THE SAME + +Cost of returns +top the list +of retailer +challenges at +48%, followed by +customer issues +with packing/ +shipping items for +return, at 39% + +RETURNS CREATE MULTIPLE COST CENTERS AND COMPLEXITIES + +Retailers responding to the Last Mile survey identified returns costs as their biggest +challenge, at 48%, but in addition to this general concern, returns create a number of +other hurdles. + +What Are Your Biggest Returns Challenges? + +COST OF RETURNS SHIPPING/HANDLING + +CUSTOMER ISSUES WITH PACKING/SHIPPING ITEMS FOR RETURN + +IMPACT ON BOTTOM-LINE REVENUE OF RE-SELLING RETURNED ITEMS + +COMMUNICATING EFFECTIVELY WITH SHOPPERS ABOUT RETURNS +RULES/PROCESSES + +COST/LOGISTICS OF CREDITING SHOPPERS’ ACCOUNTS/ +PROVIDING REFUNDS + +MINIMIZING FRAUDULENT RETURNS + +MANAGING IN-STORE STAFF REQUIREMENTS FOR RETURNS PROCESSING + +48% + +39% + +28% + +23% + +23% + +22% + +18% + +12 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? “Retailers make +meticulous plans +down to the +square inch about +what’s carried in +their stores, but +those plans can +be upset by a bin +of onesie-twosie +returns.” + +— DAVID SOBIE, +HAPPY RETURNS + +Returns can play havoc with basic retailing functions, including planning, inventory, + +pricing and in-store assortments. “Many retailers do not plan for returned inventory as + +an available ‘pot’ of stock, meaning they overbuy,” said Justine Shiou, Solutions Manager, +Planning & Optimization at Oracle. Additionally, “returns are generally made weeks after + +the initial purchase which reduces the time to re-sell the item at full price. This can be a + +significant issue for fashion/short lifecycle retailers that turn quickly. The selling price is + +likely to have already been marked down versus the price when it was purchased.” + +David Sobie, Co-Founder and CEO of Happy Returns, which operates “return bars” + +where shoppers can bring back items they have bought online, identified other returns- + +related issues retailers grapple with. “Broadly speaking, the challenge for retailers is + +‘How do I get this inventory back and ready to be restocked in a way that doesn’t break + +the bank?’” said Sobie. + +Costs include shipping the item back to the distribution center or store, but that’s only + +the beginning, said Sobie. Someone needs to assess whether the item can be added + +back into the retailer’s inventory. In some cases this is a simple matter of relabeling + +and repackaging an undamaged item, but if the item is damaged in some way, + +refurbishment might be needed. The retailer might need to take a loss or sell the item + +to a downmarket channel. + +ONLINE RETURNS UPSET STORE ASSORTMENT PLANS + +Omnichannel retailers have their own set of returns challenges. A retailer’s online + +assortment may be much larger than that of an individual brick-and-mortar store, but + +if shoppers return an item bought online, it needs to be incorporated into the store’s + +assortment — or shipped to another store or DC at additional cost. + +“Retailers make meticulous plans down to the square inch about what’s carried in + +their stores, but those plans can be upset by a bin of onesie-twosie returns,” said + +Sobie. “That carefully planned store assortment can make the store look like more of a + +discount retailer.” + +13 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + POOR RETURNS EXPERIENCES CREATE NEGATIVE CX + +Retailers seeking to keep returns costs down may decide to choose slower, less + +expensive shipping options, but they may end up paying higher costs in other + +areas. “The longer the returns process takes, the more customer service contacts + +will be generated,” Sobie warned. “The number-one reason people contact customer + +service is to check on their order, but the number-two reason relates to returns. These + +are not insignificant costs, either; they can run to a couple of bucks per contact at a + +well-run retailer.” + +Returns create headaches for consumers as well, meaning that if retailers don’t handle + +the process well, they risk losing dissatisfied customers. A 2017 study conducted by + +Forrester for Happy Returns, which surveyed online fashion shoppers, revealed that +returns are the worst part of online shopping for 73% of consumers. Among those +that have to return items, 39% say they do not shop at the retailer again. + +Returns are the +worst part of +online shopping +for 73% of +consumers. +Among those that +have to return +items, 39% don’t +shop that retailer +again. + +— FORRESTER + +14 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + FINAL MILE STRATEGIES: BALANCING CUSTOMER +SATISFACTION AND PROFITABILITY + +By Justine Shiou, Solutions Manager, +Planning and Optimization, Oracle + +ONLINE RETURNS AND INVENTORY SHUFFLING + +A sale is not a sale until the customer decides to keep it. Return rates have continued to increase across all channels but + +online sales have a higher return rate (more than 3X). Despite the operational impacts, retailers are liberalizing return + +policies: free returns, return in-store, return without limits basically, to reduce friction. This strategy has significantly + +increased operational cost. An online return to the warehouse includes shipping costs and restocking fees, an online back- + +to-store return also includes restocking fees but brings another layer of inefficiency, requiring the associate to handle the +item, run it back onto the floor, ultimately distracting him/her from more productive customer engagements. + +Markdown rates are also climbing exponentially, due to incongruent on-hand store inventory and delayed returns. Returns + +are generally made weeks after the initial purchase, which means reduced time to resell at full price, particularly for fashion + +retailers. The effectiveness of localized assortment strategies is degraded due to buy online, return in store (BORIS). The + +BORIS journey creates incongruent inventory and cluttered sales floors. Retailers are dealing with this in two ways: + +• Treatment 1: absorb the cost of taking one-off markdowns to clear the stock + +• Treatment 2: absorb the cost of transferring items back to the online warehouse or to another store with the + +item in its assortment, a.k.a. inventory shuffling + +While the practice of inventory shuffling [using transfers] used to be deemed costly, some retailers have decided this + +treatment is more sales effective than creating markdowns. Neither approach is optimal. + +TRADE REGIONS: MEASURING TRADEOFF BETWEEN CX AND GROSS MARGIN + +A focus on total trade region (online and stores combined) when developing omnichannel strategies and the role of the + +store is critical to long-term success. Retailers need to consider all roles, including fulfillment, pickup, return, traditional + +sales or a showroom concept. Advanced analysis on departments and items that have high conversion rates need to be + +conducted to save sales and create new revenue opportunities. Integrating business insights, like customer loyalty, with + +POS or order system data will more effectively drive planning by customer and fulfilment channel. With improved weekly + +sales, stock and intake accuracy, and in-season projections by channel, retailers will be able to increase gross margin, and + +reduce markdown liabilities. The ability to track the effects of cross-channel returns can help limit under- or over-stock + +situations, plan return percentages by channel and customer journey and plan cross-channel sales fulfilment paths. + +Retailers intrinsically are bound by the bottom line and shareholder interest. However, the retail environment has + +changed significantly while the mindset around profitability has not. Including a customer experience measure (such as + +NPS) in the planning process can also help retailers understand a more holistic view of their business and ensure the + +plan’s relevance to both gross margin and customer service (t-NPS). + +15 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + SUCCESS STORY + +KOHL’S GETS TRAFFIC BUMP FROM AMAZON RETURNS + +Returns aren’t all bad news. Savvy retailers with well-trained staffs have long been able to turn the return occasion into + +an opportunity to repair a damaged customer relationship, and in some cases even to take advantage of the consumer’s + +presence to sell them additional items. + +Since October 2017, Amazon shoppers have been able to return items at 82 Kohl’s stores. It seems benefits are flowing +to both parties: Amazon gets a physical location for returns, improving customer service and potentially cutting costs, + +and Kohl’s has seen increased foot traffic in the participating stores. + +A study by UberMedia found that stores with Amazon Return Centers saw their daily visitors increase 48% after October +2017, compared to a 36% increase in non-Amazon Return center locations. The 12-point difference was over and above +the normal holiday traffic increase to be expected in Q4. + +RETAILERS TURN TO TECHNOLOGY, +THIRD-PARTY SERVICES AND DISRUPTORS + +Retailers are tackling their last-mile challenges with a mix of traditional technologies and + +cutting-edge solutions. Additionally, as might be expected in an area that’s often far + +from their core competencies, retailers rely heavily on third-party services to fulfill many + +last-mile chores. + +More than half, 59%, of retailers deploy courier/delivery services, and 28% drop +ship items directly from suppliers. For services that involve direct customer contact, +however, most retailers prefer to keep these functions in-house: only 14% outsource +customer service call centers, and just 12% rely on others for product delivery and +setup; 22% do not outsource any of their last-mile services. + +Retailers’ choices for technological aids in this area generally run to the tried and + +true: transportation management solutions and route optimization systems top the +current usage list, at 35% and 27% respectively. The percentages using more advanced +solutions, such as RFID on shipping containers and products/packaging, are in the + +teens. IoT sensors, AI/machine learning, and the use of land-based robots or airborne + +drones are even less common. Perhaps in an area as high-stakes as the last mile, + +retailers are waiting for the technology to be perfected before taking a chance on it. + +For services that +involve direct +customer contact, +most retailers +prefer to keep +functions in- +house: 22% do +not outsource any +of their last-mile +services. + +16 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? Which Last Mile Services Do You Outsource To Third Parties? +(Check all that apply) + +59% + +COURIER/DELIVERY SERVICES + +28% + +DROP SHIP ITEMS DIRECTLY FROM SUPPLIERS + +14% + +12% + +10% + +22% + +CUSTOMER SERVICE/CALL CENTER + +PRODUCT DELIVERY/SETUP + +RETURNS MANAGEMENT + +WE DON’T OUTSOURCE ANY LAST MILE SERVICES + +Which Technologies Do You Use +To Manage Last-Mile Activities? + +USE NOW + +PLAN TO ADOPT +WITHIN 18 MONTHS + +NO PLANS TO ADOPT + +TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT SOLUTION + +ROUTE OPTIMIZATION SYSTEM + +VEHICLE MONITORING TECHNOLOGY + +RFID ON SHIPPING CONTAINERS + +MOBILE DEVICE MONITORING OF DELIVERY PEOPLE + +RFID ON PRODUCTS/PACKAGING + +IOT SENSORS + +AI/MACHINE LEARNING + +LAND-BASED ROBOTIC DELIVERIES + +DRONE DELIVERIES + +35% + +27% + +18% + +16% + +14% + +14% + +10% + +7% + +6% + +2% + +21% + +27% + +24% + +24% + +31% + +28% + +26% + +33% + +12% + +14% + +44% + +46% + +58% + +60% + +55% + +58% + +64% + +60% + +82% + +84% + +17 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? One area where at least a few retailers are willing to try something new is with + +disruptive shippers, such as Uber, Deliv, Instacart and Shipt. The December 2017 + +Target acquisition of Shipt for $550 million, and high-profile Instacart partnerships with + +retailers including BJ’s Wholesale Club and Albertsons, may signal to other brands that + +such services are “retail-ready.” + +Which Non-Traditional Shippers Have You Used +During The Past 12 Months? +(Check all that apply) + +Top retailer data +uses are focused +on functional +areas, but 42% +are using returns +data to adjust +their product +selections. + +21% + +8% + +7% + +11% + +UBER + +DELIV + +INSTACART + +SHIPT + +59% + +OTHER E.G. ANDREANI, ENJOY, SPEEDEE, +GOOGLE EXPRESS, SKIP THE DISHES + +Given the growing volume of last mile activity, retailers should look to step up their data + +collection and analysis efforts in order to gain a strategic advantage. At this point, top + +data uses are focused on functional areas such as resolving customer service issues, +at 48%, and tracking the speed/efficiency of drivers, at 46%. A significant minority of +respondents, 42%, are using returns data to adjust their product selections, a smart +move that could potentially reduce future returns rates. + +What Are Your Most Valuable Uses For Last Mile Data? + +48% + +46% + +42% + +22% + +RESOLVE CUSTOMER +SERVICE ISSUES + +TRACK SPEED/ +EFFICIENCY OF DRIVERS +OR DELIVERY SERVICES + +USE RETURNS DATA +TO ALTER PRODUCT +SELECTION + +DETERMINE MORE +EFFICIENT DELIVERY +ROUTES + +17% + +13% + +12% + +CHANGE SHIPPING OFFERS +(I.E. DISCOUNTS FOR +DELIVERING MULTIPLE +ITEMS IN ONE BOX) + +CHANGE INTERNAL +FULFILLMENT RULES +(E.G. SET MINIMUM TRUCK +CAPACITIES AT 75%) + +IDENTIFY LOCATIONS FOR +NEW STORES/ +E-COMMERCE ACTIVITIES + +18 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? SUCCESS STORY + +NEIMAN MARCUS BOOSTS SPEED, SERVICE LEVELS +WITH PROACTIVE SOLUTION + +Last-mile challenges are multiplied when retailers are delivering large, bulky items such as furniture and appliances. At + +least one in every 10 of these “white glove” deliveries faces a problem of some kind, such as an incorrect address or +phone number or a scheduling conflict with the carrier, according to the Wall Street Journal. + +When the retailer is Neiman Marcus, known for its high levels of in-store customer service, there’s lots of pressure to +get these deliveries right as often as possible. The supply chain team at Neiman Marcus collaborated with the customer + +care group, using a Convey solution to track the most complex deliveries. + +The software captures problems with enough time to correct them before the scheduled delivery date. Within 30 days of +launching the solution, Neiman Marcus had reduced transit times to customer by 24%. + +CONCLUSION + +Retailers and their last-mile partners are racing to keep up with customer expectations + +that are only moving in one direction: higher. To make things even more challenging, + +customers want fast, accurate deliveries, hassle-free returns, and enhanced visibility + +into these processes — all for little or no cost. + +“The biggest challenge in the last mile is matching increasing cost against spiraling +consumer expectations,” said Paul Hamblin, Editor in Chief, Logistics Business magazine, +as quoted in the eft Last Mile Retail Study. “Next-day is already almost standard, same- +day is hot on its heels. Who’s going to pay for all this?” + +“The biggest +challenge in +the last mile +is matching +increasing cost +against spiraling +consumer +expectations.” + +Technology and innovation are providing some of the answers, as retailers seek the + +most optimal transportation routes and try out new business models for shipping and + +returns. But retailers will need to dig deeper in order to meet their last-mile challenges. + +— PAUL HAMBLIN, +LOGISTICS BUSINESS + +They need to gather insights about price sensitivity and elasticity in the last mile, so + +that they can begin recouping at least some of their costs without alienating customers. + +They should invest in back-end systems that allow them to make firm delivery date + +promises, and to proactively prevent missteps that can damage the customer +relationship. Finally, retailers may want to rethink whether every order needs to be +delivered within 12, 24 or 48 hours. If consumers are confident that their order will + +arrive when the retailer has said it will, they might be more willing to wait a few days. + +19 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + To Learn More... + +Retail TouchPoints is an online publishing network for retail executives, with content focused on +optimizing the customer experience across all channels. The Retail TouchPoints network is comprised of +three weekly e-newsletters, special reports, web seminars, exclusive benchmark research, an insightful + +editorial blog, and a content-rich web site featuring daily news updates and multi-media interviews at +www.retailtouchpoints.com. The Retail TouchPoints team also interacts with social media communities +via Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn. + +P 201.257.8528 +info@retailtouchpoints.com + +Oracle provides retailers with a complete, open, and integrated suite of best-of-breed business + +applications, cloud services, and hardware that are engineered to work together and empower + +commerce. Leading fashion, grocery, and specialty retailers use Oracle solutions to anticipate market + +changes, simplify operations and inspire authentic brand interactions. For more information, visit our +website at www.oracle.com/retail. + +P 1.650.506.7000 +oneretailvoice_ww@oracle.com + +Convey enables businesses worldwide to take control of shipping and delivery. Our cloud-based + +platform connects disparate data and processes, giving shippers the insight to make smart decisions, + +and the tools to take action. From parcel to freight, and first to final mile, Convey helps the world’s + +largest brands create better delivery outcomes while reducing costs, improving visibility and + +transforming transportation into their next competitive advantage. Founded in 2013, Convey is based +in Austin, Texas. Learn more at: www.getconvey.com. + +P 602.842.2788 +info@getconvey.com + diff --git a/q33/random_k4/question.json b/q33/random_k4/question.json index 51d90e7bcb2cb0b468f61a8a88da7eb1696d8825..064a3bdd5098874cab77906e8ab110d6a76616e8 100644 --- a/q33/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q33/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "efd88e41c5f2606c57929cac6c1c0605.pdf", - "web_eb595c42c11e1922.pdf", - "5fdcf120b846746985684fa54250aab44639b30c.pdf", - "web_2aea13e00a3747ab.pdf", - "web_a43524926d478681.pdf" + "web_6a55c713826db217.pdf", + "web_0e04ded35ac1bdc2.pdf", + "resize_r2_15.pdf", + "resize_r1_12.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q33/random_k4/random_1.md b/q33/random_k4/random_1.md index e69f9af4739cdd1be4b25214374a527c28edba66..5c5eba2e1fd980c21e8cbb1cd873801d5dedd049 100644 --- a/q33/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q33/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,854 +1,2541 @@ -READ AND SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -WARNING: A risk of fire and electrical shock exists in all -electrical appliances and may cause personal injury or death. -Please follow all safety instructions. + CONTENTS -Espresso/Cappuccino Maker +01 +04 + 16 +36 +38 +39 +40 +41 +44 +45 -I +/ About HKU Business School + +/ Explore Your Options + +/ Enrich Your Life + +/ 2026 JUPAS Admissions + +/ 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions + +/ 2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +/ Develop Your Career + +/ Freshmen Sharing + +/ Our Global Presence + +/ Useful Websites + +About HKU Business School + +HKU Business School strives to nurture first-class business leaders and foster academic and relevant +research to serve the needs of Hong Kong, Chinese Mainland and the rest of the world in the new Asia-led +economy. As Asia’s premier international business school, we engage leading scholars from all corners of the +globe and they instil in students global knowledge with an Asian perspective. + +With the highest proportion of non-local undergraduate students across all Faculties at HKU, four of our +undergraduate programmes ranked amongst the University’s Top 10 programmes in 2025#, HKU Business +School attracts the best and brightest students from Hong Kong and beyond. + +HKU Business School is fully accredited by the European Quality Improvement Systems (EQUIS) and the +Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB). + +# Based on average JUPAS admission scores in the best 5 subjects in HKDSE + +VISION +To be a leading, +globally-impactful academic +institution of business and +economics. + +UNIQUE +PROPOSITION + +Deeply rooted in Hong Kong +Fully engaged with China +Truly international + +MISSION +STATEMENT + +To provide world-leading +business and economics +education that nurtures +dynamic and responsible +leaders. +To advance the frontiers of +knowledge through innovative +and globally-significant +research. +To create positive change in the +world by partnering with +communities. + +01 + + Dean’s Message + +I am delighted to introduce you to the HKU Business +School, a dynamic and forward-thinking academic +community where transformative opportunities and +unparalleled experiences await. + +As a part of the University of Hong Kong, which +proudly ranks 11th globally in the 2026 QS World +University Rankings, HKU Business School stands out +as a beacon of excellence in business and economics +in Asia. This year marks the 25th anniversary of our +Faculty, we continue to march forward as a leading, +impactful business school, championing +globally +research, and +leadership, pioneering +thought +educational excellence. + +of + +dynamic, + +challenging + +responsible, + +Our mission is to inspire and develop the next +generation +and +globally-minded business leaders. We offer a vibrant +and +learning environment where +students are encouraged to push their limits, think +critically, and innovate. Our team of leading scholars +from around the world, and experienced and +dedicated teachers as well as mentors bring a wealth +of knowledge, global perspectives, and personalised +guidance beyond the classroom. Our full spectrum of +top-quality degree programmes, including 11 diverse +undergraduate programmes and four dual bachelor’s +degrees +in partnership with world-renowned +universities, is designed to equip students with +cutting-edge knowledge and technical skills to +in the fast-changing global +navigate and excel +business landscape. + +In response to the transformative power of artificial +intelligence, we are proud to launch the Second Major +and Minor programmes in “Artificial Intelligence in +Business” +to our +(AIB), offered exclusively +undergraduate students. These programmes are +designed to equip future business +leaders with +practical proficiency in AI technologies, strategic +insight to drive cross-sector innovation, and a critical +understanding of the ethical and societal implications +of AI adoption. Through a rigorous curriculum that +integrates business fundamentals with cutting-edge +AI applications, students will be empowered to tackle +complex challenges and create meaningful impact in +a data-driven world. + +Greetings from +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +inspiration + +Business education today is an evolving domain that +builds upon learning from all academic disciplines and +draws +successful and +from both +unsuccessful business practices. Our undergraduate +curricula in six core academic areas equip students +with diverse knowledge across business and +economics spheres, and prepare them to be creative +leaders of tomorrow with global perspectives. + +A hallmark of our School that separates us from the +others is our truly multi-disciplinary approach. HKU +Business School’s extensive resources offer students +in +a wide range of choices, combining studies +economics and finance, accounting and finance, +accounting and data analytics, business and law, +business and data analytics, international business +and global management, as well as dual degrees in +collaboration with world-renowned universities. + +Our faculty members will engage you with their +inspiring teaching and how they bring their impactful +research into the classroom. They will open your mind +to diverse perspectives, +ignite your curiosity to +explore innovative ideas, and instil in you an appetite +for acquiring new knowledge and extraordinary +experiences throughout your academic journey and +career development. Our students are among the +brightest and most creative of their peers. Our alumni +have gone on to forge brilliant careers in all sectors of +the +international business +community, and have formed a global network that +you will be a part of for the rest of your life. + +regional and + +local, + +I hope that you will share my enthusiasm for the +programmes and my admiration for the people who +have contributed to their development. I look forward +to having you as a member of the HKU Business +School family and a future leader in the world of +business. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Derek Chan +Associate Dean (Undergraduate) + +Through our extensive partnerships with over 300 +institutions and corporations across more than 40 +countries, as well as our unique network of centres in +Beijing, Shenzhen, Shanghai, Vietnam, and Barcelona, +our students gain unparalleled global experiential +and enrichment opportunities. Whether through +internships, overseas exchange programmes, or +hands-on +these experiences +sharpen practical skills, broaden perspectives, and +prepare students to confidently tackle real-world +challenges. + +industry projects, + +Joining HKU Business School means becoming part of +a community that supports your growth and success. +You will collaborate with brilliant minds, engaging in +stimulating discussions, and working on impactful +projects that make a difference. The friendships, +networks, and experiences you build here will last a +to a myriad of career +lifetime, open doors +opportunities, and empower you to overcome +challenges, pursue your passions with confidence, +and contribute positively to your community and the +world at large. + +If you are ready to embark on an exciting journey of +learning, discovery, and personal development, I +invite you to explore what HKU Business School has to +look forward to welcoming you to our +offer. I +community, where future leaders are nurtured and +dreams take flight. + +Warm regards, + +Professor Hongbin Cai +Dean +Chair of Economics + +0302 Explore Your Options +A Wide Selection of Programmes + +Bachelor of Business Administration [BBA] + +The BBA programme combines strong functional training with intensive exposure +to communication skills, computer applications, and other social science and/or +science subjects. Students can choose to major in the following area(s): + +Entrepreneurship, +Design and + Innovation* + +Finance + +Human Resource +Management + +Information Systems +and Analytics + +Marketing + +BBA Curriculum Structure + +Components -R -O -F -E -D -U -G -E -R A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + C -D -N + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +78 +24 +48 +6 + +108 + +240 + +*Candidates must undergo a selection process arranged by the Programme Coordinator for +declaring the EDI major. + +HKU – Sciences Po Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first two years at Sciences Po in France and the third +and fourth years at HKU. Programmes at Sciences Po are taught in English (no +French requirements for being admitted) with intensive French language +classes for all non-francophone students. + +Upon successful completion of the dual degree programme, students will be +awarded the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) degree from HKU and +a Bachelor’s degree from Sciences Po. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-sciences-po-dual- +degree-programme + +HKU – University of British Columbia +Dual Degree Programme + +Students will spend the first and final years at HKU and the second and third +years at the University of British Columbia (UBC) in Canada, and graduate with +a Bachelor of Business Administration from HKU and a Bachelor of Commerce +from UBC upon successful completion of the programme. + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. + +Find out more: +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university- +collaborative-programmes/hku-university-of-british- +columbia-dual-degree-programme + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba + +0504 + + Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting and +Finance [BBA(Acc&Fin)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting Data +Analytics [BBA(ADA)] + +The BBA(Acc&Fin) programme prepares students for a professional qualification +in accounting and provides the broad-based education in accounting and finance +which is necessary to progress toward a leadership role in the financial sector. +Students are required to take professional core in accounting and a minor in +finance, with an option to second major in finance. Tailor-made professional +internship opportunities with renowned +preparation programmes and +accounting firms and financial institutions are available for talented students. It +is accredited as an approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Acc&Fin) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + A -E -S -U B -1 -X -E -M -, +C + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course + +Minor in Finance* +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives + +D. + +Free Electives / Optional Minor + +*Students may opt to pursue a Major in Finance: + +Components -I +A B -T -K -X -E -M -S -L -E -D -O -M -N +C + +University Graduation Requirements + +Professional Core in Accounting + +Major in Finance +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Free Electives +Capstone Course + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +108 +24 +78 +6 + +36 +12 +24 + +42 + +Total + +240 + +Credits + +54 + +108 + +78 +30 +18 +24 +6 + +Total + +240 + +Similar to the BBA(Acc&Fin) programme, the BBA(ADA) programme prepares +students for a professional qualification in accounting. It provides students +with an option to focus on data analytics aspect in accounting instead of having +a minor in finance. It is an excellent choice for students who are interested in +STEM with accounting and business applications and wish to pursue their +career in the relevant fields. The intensive accounting training enables +BBA(ADA) students to distinguish themselves from students of the other data +analytics/STEM programmes. Students will be equipped with comprehensive +accounting and business knowledge that prepares them to obtain professional +qualifications in accounting. They will also acquire computer programming +and data analytics skills to meet the needs of the accounting and business +professions in today’s digital transformation economy. It is accredited as an +approved accountancy programme by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(ADA) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Professional Core in Accounting Data Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +C + +Free Electives + +Total + +Credits + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +156 +24 +114 +12 +6 + +30 + +240 + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-acc-and-fin + +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ada + +0706 + + Bachelor of Business Administration (Business Analytics) +[BBA(BA)] + +Bachelor of Business Administration (Law) and Bachelor of +Laws [BBA(Law)&LLB] + +The BBA(BA) programme is crafted to meet the growing industry demand for +talents in the business analytics field. Its curriculum offers students a +comprehensive coverage of both technical and managerial skill sets. Students +will learn a wide spectrum of knowledge from the disciplines of information +technology, data science, business statistics and management. Core courses +include programming language, database management, introduction to +business analytics, management information systems, decision and risk +analysis, etc. They help students build the foundations for advanced topics in +senior years. Students also have the option to choose from analytics technique +courses and business application courses. The aim is to provide students with +state-of-the-art experiences in artificial intelligence, big data, social media, +and other latest development. Such design helps train well-rounded students +who will be more adaptable in their career development. The programme is +suitable for students who have a passion for problem-solving through +analytics, and who aim to develop their career path in analytics. + +BBA(BA) Curriculum Structure + +Components + +Credits + A + +B + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +Major in Business Analytics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Analytics Techniques) +Disciplinary Electives (Business Applications) +Capstone Course + C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 +6 +- + +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 + +90 + +Jointly offered by the HKU Business School and the Faculty of Law, the +BBA(Law)&LLB integrated double-degree programme blends two strategic +disciplines into a single programme for the bright and highly motivated. It is an +excellent choice for students seeking a broader education with parallel +concentration on legal and business studies. Graduates of the programme will be +awarded two degrees — BBA(Law) by the HKU Business School, and LLB by the +Faculty of Law. After successful completion of the LLB programme, students +may apply for admission to the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws (PCLL) +programme provided that they meet the relevant admission requirements. + +The programme offers business stream and accounting stream to students in +their business studies. The accounting stream is accredited by: + +The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) +The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) +CPA Australia + +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Business Stream) + +Components + +Credits + +A + B -1 -X -E -M -D -N + +C + +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Course +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University + +BBA Major +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses / Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +Professional Core in Law +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course + +D. + +Free Electives / Optional Minor + +Total + +240 + +Total + +BBA(Law)&LLB Curriculum Structure (Accounting Stream) + +Components + A - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +B -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +University Graduation Requirements -left unattended. +Professional Core in Accounting +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Capstone Course -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +C -See instructions for cleaning. +Professional Core in Law -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Total -children. +36 +6 +24 +6 +- -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool +78 +24 +48 +6 -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +156 +108 +42 +6 -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +30 -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +300 -surfaces. +Credits -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +36 -heated oven. +108 +24 +78 +6 -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +156 -function knob to “OFF.” +300 -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-ba -used. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bba-law-and-llb -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +0908 -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing + Bachelor of Business Administration in International Business +and Global Management [BBA(IBGM)] -cup or brew basket. +Bachelor of Economics [BEcon] -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +BBA(IBGM) is an intensive, premier programme in international business and +global management featuring a unique curriculum designed to evolve with and +reflect the ever-changing demands of a globalised world. Exclusive elements +such as overseas exchange studies, a leadership boot camp, an Asia-Pacific +study tour, an international field trip and global enrichment opportunities are +strategically integrated into the curriculum, whilst students are given the +flexibility to pursue an in-depth inquiry into another specialised area of study +as a second major. This cross-functional and personalised approach aims to +foster a selected group of outstanding students to become the world’s future +leaders equipped with global perspectives, cultural sensitivity, social +responsibility and key competencies to succeed in the international business +environment. -be used on a range top. +BBA(IBGM) Curriculum Structure -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +Components -weakened handle. +A -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +B -other abrasive material. +C -2 +D -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. +E -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. +Major in International Business and Global Management +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be +Second Major -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. +Free Electives -1 +Compulsory Overseas Exchange -2 +Total -8 +Credits -7 +54 +12 +36 +6 +- +96 +24 +54 +12 6 -5 +72-90 + +0-18* + +- + +240 + +*Students may use free electives to fulfil the second major where the requirements exceed 72 credits. -3 +The BEcon programme trains students in economic theories, statistical tools, +the application of theories to solve practical economic problems in trade, +banking and the labour market, and evaluation of the regional economic +performance of Chinese Mainland, Hong Kong and other economies. Students +will be furnished with solid theoretical and empirical economic knowledge to +analyse and understand human behaviour and social interactions. The +programme allows students a high degree of flexibility in planning their future +career specialisation. -4 +BEcon Curriculum Structure -3 +Components -1. Safety lid -2. Water +A -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +B -tip +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with +Major in Economics +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -lid +C -7. Filter basket -and holder +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -8. Function -knob +Total - IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS +Credits -When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should -always be followed to reduce the risk of fire, electric shock and injury -to persons, including the following: -• Read all instructions before using appliance. -• Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs. -• When in use, the appliance is under pressure and should never be +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -left unattended. +78 +24 +30 +18 +6 + +108 -• Do not immerse cord, plug or appliance in water or other liquid. +240 -See instructions for cleaning. +Find out more: +http://ibgm.business.hku.hk -• This appliance is not for use by children. -• Close supervision is necessary when any appliance is used near +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon -children. +1110 -• Unplug from outlet when not in use. Unplug and allow to cool + Bachelor of Economics and Finance [BEcon&Fin] -before putting on or taking off parts and before cleaning. +BEcon&Fin is designed to meet the interests of students who are seeking a +balanced study of both economics and finance. The programme recognises +the significance of economics both in its own right and as a foundation for the +study of finance, and the significance of finance as a career path for students +who are keen on joining this profession. Students will receive solid training in +theories and applications of economics and finance. They will be equipped +with the skills to analyse human behaviour and social interaction, as well as to +solve problems in the financial sphere. -• Do not operate any damaged appliance. Do not operate with a -damaged cord or plug, or after the appliance malfunctions or has -been dropped or damaged in any manner. Return appliance to the -nearest authorized Service Center for examination, repair or -adjustment. +BEcon&Fin Curriculum Structure -• Use attachments only if recommended by the manufacturer. -• Do not use outdoors or while standing in a damp area. -• Do not let cord hang over edge of table or counter or touch hot +Components -surfaces. +Credits -• Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a +A -heated oven. +B -• Prior to connecting or disconnecting plug from wall outlet, turn +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -function knob to “OFF.” +Major in Economics and Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Economics Disciplinary Electives +Finance Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -• Never use the appliance without water. -• Only use appliance as indicated in these instructions. -• Keep steam-jet control knob in closed position when not being +C -used. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -• Be certain lids are securely in place before operating appliance. -• Do not unscrew or remove safety lid while the appliance is in -operation as scalding may occur. Wait until brewing cycle is com- -pleted and all water and steam has been used up. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -• CAUTION: Relieve pressure through steam tube before removing +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -cup or brew basket. +90 -• The carafe is designed for use with this appliance. It must never +Total -be used on a range top. +240 -• Do not set a hot carafe on a wet or cold surface. -• Do not use a cracked carafe or a carafe having a loose or +HKU - Peking University “Future +Leaders” Dual Bachelor’s Degree in +Economics, Finance and Management +The programme combines the strengths of two leading business schools in +Hong Kong and Chinese Mainland and is designed to nurture first-class business +leaders and cultivate their global perspective with intimate understanding of +China. Students will spend the first two years at HKU and the third and fourth +years at Peking University (PKU), and be awarded a Bachelor of Economics and +Finance (BEcon&Fin) degree from HKU and a Bachelor of Management [BMgmt] +degree from PKU upon successful completion of the dual degree programme. -weakened handle. +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programme, in +addition to the application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS +Admissions Scheme. -• Do not clean carafe with abrasive cleansers, steel wool pads, or +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/admission/degree-program +mes/hku-pku-dual-degree -other abrasive material. +Bachelor of Finance in Asset Management and Private +Banking [BFin(AMPB)] +The BFin(AMPB) programme aims to prepare students to enter the rapidly +growing fields of asset management and private wealth management in Hong +Kong and Asia Pacific, or in banking and finance generally. During the first two +years, students complete introductory courses in accounting, economics, +mathematics, statistics, corporate finance, and investments and portfolio +analysis. In subsequent years, students take more specified and industry +related courses including equity valuation and investment in specific asset +classes e.g. private equity, venture capital, hedge funds and digital assets, +understanding of financial statements and doing financial analysis, lending +and credit in private wealth and corporate bank, financial regulations and +compliance, current +institutional +in finance, ESG +consulting and family office. The programme contains practical-oriented +courses taught by teachers with extensive experience in the finance industry +and offers an array of career-oriented enrichment activities and networking +opportunities with industry practitioners. -2 +investment, -• WARNING: Do not remove bottom cover. No user serviceable parts -inside. Repair must be done by authorized service personnel only. +issues -SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS -THIS APPLIANCE IS FOR HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY -CAUTION: A short power supply cord is provided to reduce the risk of -personal injury resulting from becoming entangled in or tripping over a -longer cord. Extension cords are available from local hardware stores -and may be used if care is exercised in their use. If an extension cord is -required, special care and caution is necessary. Also the cord must be: -(1) marked with an electrical rating of 125 V, and at least 13 A., 1625 W., -and (2) the cord must be arranged so that it will not drop over the -countertop or tabletop where it can be pulled on by children or tripped -over accidentally. +in -POLARIZED PLUG: This appliance has a polarized plug, (one blade is -wider than the other). As a safety feature to reduce the risk of electrical -shock, this plug is intended to fit in a polarized outlet only one way. If the -plug does not fit fully in the outlet, reverse the plug, If it still does not fit, -contact a qualified electrician. Do not attempt to defeat this safety fea- -ture. +BFin(AMPB) Curriculum Structure -ELECTRIC POWER: If the electric circuit is overloaded with other -appliances, your appliance may not operate properly. It should be +Components -Getting to Know Your Espresso/Capuccino Maker -Before using your machine for the first time, you must become familiar -with all of the parts. Read all instructions and cautions carefully. +Credits -1 +A -2 +B -8 +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -7 +Major in Asset Management and Private Banking +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course +C + +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) + +54 +12 +36 6 +- -5 +96 +24 +42 +24 +6 -3 +90 -4 +Total -3 +240 -1. Safety lid -2. Water +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/becon-and-fin -reservoir -3. Steam jet -4. Froth booster +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bfin-ampb -tip +1312 -5. Drip plate -6. Carafe with + Bachelor of Science in Marketing Analytics and Technology +[BSc(MAT)] -lid +Bachelor of Science in Quantitative Finance [BSc(QFin)] -7. Filter basket -and holder +Marketing is critical to all businesses. It dictates whether a company will be +successful. Technology, Big Data, and digitization are fundamentally changing +how marketers operate. The BSc(MAT) programme equips students with +quantitative skills, technology know-how, and business marketing acumen to +pursue a career in the digital economy and modern businesses. It targets both +STEM students with an interest in business as well as business students +interested in the technology space. Students will gain a solid foundation in +cutting-edge technical areas including computer programming, data science, +and technology by excelling in courses from the Faculty of Engineering and +Faculty of Science. In addition, students will master digital business, +marketing and leadership through courses at the HKU Business School. This +interdisciplinary approach will enable students to engage in a variety of jobs +and functions such as the design and launch of new technology products, +targeting consumers, digital marketing, forecast and predicting markets, and +building a technology-focused strategy. The programme aims to nurture +future leaders in the field of technology and marketing who are able to use the +latest technology, science, and data analytics to support business and +marketing decisions in the digital world. -8. Function -knob +BSc(MAT) Curriculum Structure - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +Components -Making Espresso Coffee +Credits -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +A -from the appliance. +B -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +Major in Marketing Analytics and Technology +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Technology and Strategy) +Disciplinary Electives (Marketing Analytics) +Capstone Course -carafe. +C -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -brewing process – scalding may occur. +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +96 +24 +42 +12 +12 +6 -function knob to the “OFF” position. +90 -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +Total -Making Cappuccino +240 -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +BSc(QFin) is a premium finance programme. Built on a solid foundation in +economics and finance, the programme equips students with the essential +quant skills, including mathematics, statistics, and programming, that are +required in more advanced and sophisticated analyses, such as valuation +models of structured products, risk management, simulation and data +analysis, financial engineering, and quantitative trading. -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +The programme goes beyond merely equipping students with quant skills. +More importantly, it stresses on combining these skills with an understanding of +the financial markets, the macro environment, and the practical situations +where financial managers work, with a balanced mix of quant and business +courses. To nurture students’ soft skills and market acumen, the programme +provides a wide range of value-enhancing activities, such as Round Tables with +Practitioners, Alumni Drinks, Executive Mentorship Scheme, Bloomberg training +workshops, simulation trading workshops, and an international field trip to +other international financial centres such as New York, London and Zurich. -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +BSc(QFin) Curriculum Structure -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +Components -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +Credits -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +A -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +B -function knob to the “OFF” position. +University Graduation Requirements +Language Enhancement Courses +Common Core Curriculum +Artificial Intelligence Literacy Courses +Non-Credit Bearing Courses as required by the University -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +Major in Quantitative Finance +Faculty Core Courses +Disciplinary Core Courses +Disciplinary Electives +Capstone Course -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +C -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Free Electives / Optional Major / Optional Minor(s) -4 +54 +12 +36 +6 +- -5 +96 +24 +54 +12 +6 - Before making your first carafe of espresso, we suggest that you let -the water brew through the machine two times without coffee, following -the instructions. This will thoroughly clean the unit. +90 -Making Espresso Coffee +Total -1. Make sure the function knob is in the “OFF” position. Plug the -espresso/cappuccino maker into a 120V AC electrical outlet. -2. Remove the safety lid by turning it counter-clockwise and remove +240 -from the appliance. +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-mat -3. For espresso fill carafe to two or four cups of cold water, using the -markings on the carafe for reference. For cappuccino, fill the -carafe to for 2 cups or to the bottom of the metal band for 4 -cups. Pour water into the water reservoir. -4. Close the safety lid tightly by turning clockwise. -5. Remove the filter basket and holder from the espresso/cappucci- -no maker by turning clockwise. With the measuring spoon, -measure espresso coffee and place into the filter basket. (Do not -compress/tap the coffee.) +Find out more: +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme/bsc-qfin -NOTE: Be sure to use coffee which is MEDIUM TO FINE GROUND. -6. Place the filter basket into the filter holder. -7. Pull back the tab and insert the filter holder into the brewing head -lock aligning the arrow on the filter holder with the on the -machine. Push the filter holder upward so it will be aligned with the -matching slots. Turn handle counter-clockwise until securely -locked. Place the cover on the carafe and return the carafe to the -drip plate. Align hole in lid under filter. -8. Switch the function knob to “BREW.” -9. After approximately four minutes, espresso coffee will flow into the +1514 -carafe. + Enrich Your Life -NOTE: For cappuccino, refer immediately to the Making Cappuccino -section. -10. Do not open the safety lid or remove the filter holder during the +initiative and +HKU Business School fosters a culture of student +implementation of ideas, both within and outside the campus, as it is +these real-world engagements that set us apart. Experiences in learning +beyond the classroom, extending into realms outside academia, enable +students to cultivate an understanding of social dynamics, cultural +diversity, and collaborative +intellect. These experiences contribute +significantly to their personal growth, interpersonal skills, and social +development, shaping them into global citizens, lifelong learners, and +future business leaders. -brewing process – scalding may occur. +Overseas Enrichment Experiences -11. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Business Exchange Programme / +HKUWW Undergraduate Student Exchange Programme +Even as the youngest Faculty at the University, our exchange +activities are nothing but phenomenal. Each year, over 400 +students participate in overseas exchanges at leading universities +to broaden their horizons. -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Business School +Exchange Partners * -12. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM -JET. Then turn the function knob back to the “OFF” position. +Canada -Making Cappuccino +McGill University +University of British Columbia +University of Toronto +Western University +Simon Fraser University -1. Cappuccino is a mixture of espresso coffee, milk and frothed milk. -Fill a deep, narrow metal pitcher 1/2 full with fresh, cold milk and -set next to the espresso/cappuccino maker. +U.K. -2. Place the frothing booster tip up over the end of the steam jet. +King's College London +University of Manchester +University of Edinburgh +University of Warwick -Follow Steps 1 through 9 on page 4 for making espresso. +The Netherlands -3. When the coffee starts to flow into the carafe, hold the pitcher by -the handle and bring up to the steam jet. Insert froth booster -tip just under the surface of the milk. Turn the function knob -gradually to and froth the milk. Move the pitcher in a -slightly circular motion. +University of Amsterdam +Erasmus University Rotterdam -REMINDER: Before frothing milk, make sure the tip of the froth -boother tip is just under the surface of the milk. Otherwise, splat- -tering may occur. -4. After frothing, turn the function knob to “BREW,” to allow the +400+ +exchange partners +across 40+ countries -appliance to complete the espresso making process. +400+ +Business School +students on exchange -5. Remove the pitcher from the steam jet. -6. When the coffee has stopped flowing into the carafe, turn the +Denmark -function knob to the “OFF” position. +Copenhagen Business School +Aarhus University -7. BEFORE REMOVING THE FILTER HOLDER OR THE SAFETY -LID, TURN THE FUNCTION KNOB TO AND WAIT UNTIL -NO FURTHER STEAM EMERGES FROM THE STEAM JET. -This will allow any extra steam to be released and will clean the -steam jet of any excess milk. Then turn the function knob back to -the “OFF” position. +Germany -8. Serve the hot, frothy milk by spooning it on top of your cup of -espresso. The froth will not readily pour from the container, since -it separates from the heated milk. +Frankfurt School of Finance & Management +University of Mannheim +Munich Business School -The best frothed milk is obtained when fresh, cold, skim milk is used. -When frothing milk, the volume of milk will double. -The top half will be frothed, the bottom half will be milk. Fill a cappuc- -cino cup 1/3 full of freshly brewed espresso coffee. Pour in an equal -amount of warm milk and top with frothed milk. +Belgium -4 +KU Leuven -5 +Italy - User Maintenance Instructions +Bocconi University -Descaling (Continued) +France -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +U.S. -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +Toulouse School of Economics +ESSEC Business School -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +New York University +University of Southern California +University of Washington +University of Georgia -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! +Middle East -Descaling +Reichman University -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Singapore -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +National University of Singapore +Nanyang Technological University -you would with water. +* This list is non-exclusive. + +International Field Trips +To enhance students' exposure to global businesses, the School organises +overseas field trips for students visiting corporate firms and mingling with +C-suite Executives in some of the world's most prominent financial +centres, e.g. Australia, France, Japan, London, New York City, Singapore, +Spain, and Zurich. + +Visiting Programmes +Through the Yale Visiting International Students Programme, students +are sent to spend a year at Yale University, where they actively engage +themselves in a multicultural society. With the generosity of the donors, +some of our students are selected for the Junior Year Abroad Programme +and Visiting Students Programme to study as visiting students at +Pembroke College and St Peter’s College of University of Oxford +respectively with substantial scholarships. The intellectual ambience of +these top universities is truly inspirational and conducive to learning. -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +Beta Gamma Sigma Regional Leadership Conference +Beta Gamma Sigma (BGS) is the international honour society that +serves business programmes accredited by the Association to Advance +Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB International). With the +establishment of the HKU BGS Chapter, the School registers students +annually for the BGS Regional Leadership Conference held in the U.S., +where they can meet and bond with many other fellow students from the +world's best business schools. The Leadership Summit is eye-opening +and challenging, which leads to a great journey of self-discovery. -outlet. +Japan + +Kyoto University + +Australia + +University of Sydney +Monash University +University of New South Wales + +1716 Student Sharing + +Chen, Hsuan-yu +Exchange at National University of Singapore (Singapore), 2024-25 + +As a third-year undergraduate student pursuing a double major in +Accounting and Finance, I consider it a tremendous privilege to have +participated in a one-semester exchange at the National University of +Singapore (NUS) through the Business Exchange Programme. This +invaluable opportunity has not only enriched my academic journey but +also broadened my global perspective through immersive cultural +experiences and meaningful cross-cultural interactions. As I move +forward in my academic and professional journey, I carry with me not +just the knowledge gained from my courses, but the invaluable life +lessons experienced from Exchange. + +Lee, Tsz To Derek +Exchange at King’s College London (United Kingdom), 2024-25 + +I am incredibly grateful to have this valuable opportunity to study +abroad at King’s College London. The programme provided me a chance +to venture outside of my comfort zone. Not only can you learn how to be +more independent, you can also boost interpersonal skills given the +many opportunities to socialise with others, which is essential for your +future career. The experience is remarkable. I think you will regret it if +you miss out on the overseas exchange programme. + +Cheung, Nga Ting Caroline +Exchange at University of New South Wales (Australia), 2024-25 + +This exchange programme has changed me in many ways. It has helped +me become more outgoing, allowing me to make new friends and +explore different cities. Living independently has been a significant part +of this journey. From exploring new cities to forming lasting friendships, +each adventure has enriched my life in ways I never expected. This +opportunity has not only broadened my horizons but also deepened my +appreciation for diversity and connection among people from different +backgrounds. Each memory I have created during this time is a treasure +that I will carry with me forever. + +Ho, Ying Tung Crystal +Exchange at Copenhagen Business School (Denmark), 2024-25 + +In the Fall semester, I participated in a business exchange programme at +Denmark’s Copenhagen Business School (CBS). This experience was +truly transformative, enriching me both academically and personally +while allowing me to forge lifelong memories and friendships. An +exchange experience abroad truly broadens your horizons and offers +insights beyond what textbooks and lectures can provide. You will gain +invaluable perspectives and undergo personal growth like never before. +I wholeheartedly encourage you to muster your courage and embark on +an exchange journey - you won’t regret it! + +Whitfield III, Gerald Bruce Trey +Exchange at New York University (United States), 2024-25 + +I found the exchange experience to be extremely enriching. A major +highlight for me was exploring the lifestyle and professional sides of the +city. Because of my initiative socially, and in groups such as church, I was +able to get well-acquainted with the local rhythms and lifestyle, and +also made many friends that I’d consider friends for a lifetime. I am +deeply appreciative of being given this rewarding experience, which +significantly shaped both my future and the person I am today. + +Ip, Wing Tung Alla +Student Representative for the BGS Regional Leadership +Conference 2025 in Highland Heights, Kentucky + +Attending the BGS Leadership Conference at Northern Kentucky +University proved transformative. I received profound insights into +leadership, communication and cultural intelligence through immersive +workshops, case competitions and networking opportunities. The event +prompted reflections on personal leadership styles and encouraged +collaboration across diverse peers. As I prepare to enter the workforce, +I intend to apply these learned principles of trust-building, cultural +sensitivity and collaborative leadership to navigate challenges so I can +shape my professional journey with purpose and authenticity. + +1918 Corporate Exposure + +HKU Business School has a strong tie with corporate partners. To nurture students' business +and market acumen, enrichment programmes are organised through the joint efforts of +corporate partnerships. + +Enrichment Programmes in collaboration with Corporate Partners +HKU Business School has been collaborating with corporate partners on initiatives to spice up +students' career exploration journey. The partnership with Accenture enables students to +gain exclusive insights into business consulting through the HKU-Accenture Business +Consulting Programme. + +To provide students with a unique opportunity to explore current business trends and +developments in the Greater Bay Area (GBA), our School has co-organised a tailored study tour +with The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA). This initiative aims to +enhance students’ readiness for future career development and personal success. Students will +have the chance to connect with seasoned accounting and business professionals in the GBA. + +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme +Leveraging the School's extensive network in the business and finance industry, we have +developed our own mentorship programme to furnish students with opportunities to +enhance their skills and knowledge essential for their future personal and career +development. Our students are empowered to connect to the real business world through +direct and active interaction with seasoned professionals, executives and entrepreneurs. + +Lee, Lok Yiu Angel +HKU Business School Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +My mentor offered +invaluable career advice, highlighting key +considerations for entering specific fields and preparing for interviews. +Her experiences and mindset during job searches resonated with me as +I navigated something similar. She emphasised the importance of +open-mindedness and eagerness to learn in the workplace. I kept her +words at heart during my internship. I also enjoyed catching up with her +to share my new job experiences. + +Choi, Han Na Hannah +HKUBS x Deloitte China Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +As my mentor has been working in Deloitte China for more than 10 +years, I was most curious about how he maintains a work-life balance +and how he stays dedicated and professional at work. Through our +lengthy conversations over lunch, he passed on valuable insights on +developing soft skills and adopting an appropriate work attitude at an +early stage. He is more than an audit mentor but also a life coach to me. + +Chan, Chin Ching Jacky +BSc(QFin) Executive Mentorship Programme 2024-25 + +Throughout the mentorship programme, I have received +precious guidance that has greatly influenced my career +path. My mentor highlighted the importance of identifying +a company that aligns with my goals and would provide +opportunities for me to develop the necessary skill sets. He +also shared practical advice on building and managing +professional and personal relationships. These lessons +have broadened my perspective and also equipped me +with the tools to handle real-world situations more +effectively and confidently. + +Wong, Wan Tat +HKUBS x ACCA Greater Bay Area Study Tour 2024-25 + +My greatest takeaway from this study tour was the power of peer +learning and collaboration. Being immersed in an environment with a +diverse group of individuals, all focused on similar goals, created an +incredible opportunity to learn from each other’s experiences and +perspectives. The collaborative projects and informal discussions were +invaluable in broadening my horizon and developing new approaches +to the accounting field in Chinese Mainland. I am leaving with a strong +network of contacts and a renewed appreciation for teamwork. + +Leung, Ho Lun Maverick +HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme 2024-25 + +I visited + +The HKU-Accenture Business Consulting Programme immersed me in +an authentic consulting experience through working with a real client – +their distribution centres, conducted market +HKTV. +questionnaires, and presented the final deliverables - all within the +eight-week programme. I was honoured to meet Managing Directors +from Accenture who shared crucial skills in conducting a consulting +project. It’s truly one of the best programmes for anyone considering a +consulting career! + +2120 Experiential Learning Programmes + +Experiential learning is embedded in our course curriculum. The Business Consulting +Practicum offers business and economics students hands-on experience in working with +clients to solve "real-life" problems relevant to their studies, under the guidance of faculty +members and professional mentors. The Business Case Analysis and Presentation enables +students to communicate and seek practical advice from senior executives through in-class +case presentations. The Impact Lab provides students with an excellent opportunity to work +directly with social ventures, again under the guidance of teachers and professional mentors. +Additionally, students can gain an in-depth understanding of the latest trends in economics, +finance, creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurship in the rapidly growing Greater Bay Area +by participating in the Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China Programme. + +Chaabane, Adam Andrea +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +I have learned that prominent businessmen and professionals in Hong +Kong are people like me who were once attending business school. I +most enjoyed the guest +lectures because they allowed direct +interactions with inspiring figures. The virtual experience enabled me to +follow this programme easily from my home country. I definitely +recommend it for a better understanding of Hong Kong and GBA’s +markets and opportunities that arise in cross-border business. It would +be great to learn more about opportunities for foreigners in the region. + +Kaur, Suchleen +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +The opportunity for real-time interaction and feedback with the client had +propelled me to join BCP. I was always curious about how a consultant +would address and communicate with the client. BCP has taught me +about proper business etiquette and equipped me the necessary skills to +negotiate conflicting opinions during team discussions. Throughout the +process, our mentor and professors provided great help and insights. +Their invaluable feedback and questions helped nudge us in the right +direction, taking a step back to look at the big picture and most +importantly, prioritise the client’s needs. + +Zhou, Qingzhuo +"Creativity, Innovation & Entrepreneurship in China" +Summer Virtual Programme 2025 + +My greatest takeaway from the CIEC 2025 programme was the unique +window to gain a comprehensive understanding of the Greater Bay +Area’s dynamic business landscape. I explored the latest trends in +business, finance, and innovation from guest talks and virtual lectures +with industry leaders. I particularly appreciate the coverage on a +diverse range of topics and the opportunity to earn HKU credits. A +highlight was the cultural exploration segment which offered an +unparalleled perspective on the Greater Bay Area. I recommend this +programme without hesitation. + +Tsang, Tze Yeung Matthew +Business Consulting Practicum 2024 + +BCP has been a rewarding experience that allowed me to apply my +academic knowledge to real-world business challenges. Working +directly with my mentor and client has pushed me to think critically and +creatively in ways I hadn't experienced in the classroom. I'm confident +that the problem-solving, communication, and client-facing skills I have +developed will serve me well when pursuing my future career in +consulting or another business-oriented field. + +2322 Cheung, Ho Ning Jolie +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 (Champion) + +in UW GBCC was an + +Competing +incredibly rewarding and +unforgettable experience. We had the opportunity to work with +participants from different universities. +It was a fantastic +opportunity to exchange perspectives and learn from different +problem-solving approaches. Working under tight timeframes +pushed us to think creatively. UW GBCC has not only elevated my +professional capabilities but further solidified my belief in business +as a powerful vehicle for creating positive change in the world. + +Case Competitions + +The School provides ample opportunities to refine students' presentation and analytical skills +through a myriad of local as well as overseas competitions. From training to delicate analysis +of business cases to a variety of business scenarios, students are equipped with different +skillsets to compete with candidates from the world's leading universities. + +Lo, Nikkia +NHH International Case Competition 2024 (Champion) + +My week at NHH International Case Competition has been an +unforgettable rollercoaster of emotions. From the excitement of +exploring a new Nordic city, the exhaustion of our 24-hour case +competition, to the nervous anticipation of pitching on a global stage +with a +livestream, every moment was extraordinary. Meeting +like-minded peers around the world was an incredible experience that +forged new friendships. Thank you, HKU Business School, along with +our professors, coaches and staff for bringing this opportunity to us! -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Xia, Yunchu Kevin +The McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 (First Place) -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Winning first place at MBSC2025 was incredible and deeply rewarding. +My team was highly engaged. We were constantly bouncing ideas off +each other and refining our strategy. There were moments where we hit +roadblocks, but our team rallied, challenged each other constructively +and developed a cohesive solution. Connecting with like-minded +participants, judges and NGOs was also invaluable. MBSC not only +sharpened my analytical and presentation skills but also reaffirmed my +commitment to leveraging business for good. I am so grateful for the +experience and very eager to apply these lessons moving forward! -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +2524 Liu, Yunqi Iris +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 (Outstanding Team Award) -to continue to flow in the carafe. +This competition has been a fantastic learning experience. It +showed me that tax isn’t just about the technical details - it’s also +deeply connected to social trends and global events like climate +change, geopolitical conflicts and national policies. This broader +perspective has enhanced my understanding of the industry and +its importance in today’s world. I want to express my sincere +gratitude to my advisors for their guidance and recognition of my +team’s hard work. I am grateful for the opportunity to learn and +grow with such an amazing group of people. -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +Pan, Ho Man Vivian +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 (Champion) -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +in -vinegar. Repeat twice. +the HKGCC Case Competition was a -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Participating +truly +transformative experience that greatly enhanced my strategic +thinking, teamwork and problem-solving skills. The competition +challenged me to analyse intricate business problems, think critically +under pressure and develop innovative solutions. Working closely +with people of various majors allowed me to appreciate differing +opinions that were at times conflicting, find ways to build consensus +and synthesize ideas effectively. -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Students' achievements in case competitions +(2023-2025 awards) -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Overseas / Chinese Mainland -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Asia Pacific Sustainable Marketing Case Competition 2025 -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Third Place -Thank You +Bloomberg Global Trading Challenge 2023 -6 +CBS Case Competition 2023 -7 +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Asia Pacific Regional Final - User Maintenance Instructions +CFA Institute Research Challenge 2025 - Sub-Regional Final -Descaling (Continued) +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 - North Asia Final -1. Unplug the espresso/cappuccino maker from the electrical outlet +Champions' Trophy Case Competition 2024 -and allow to cool completely before cleaning. +Grand Prize Winner +Regional Prize Winner: Asia & Oceania -2. The coffee filter basket and holder should be emptied and rinsed -thoroughly with warm water after every use. Dry thoroughly. -3. Clean the carafe and carafe lid with warm, soapy water. Handle -with extreme care, as glass will become slippery when wet. -4. The carafe drip plate can be removed and washed in warm water. -5. Wipe the outside of your espresso/cappuccino maker with a damp -cloth. NEVER IMMERSE THE APPLIANCE IN WATER OR ANY -OTHER LIQUID. +Winner -6. This appliance is for HOUSEHOLD USE ONLY! +Winner -Descaling +Winner -If you live in a hard-water area, minerals and calcium found in the -water will accumulate and affect the operation of your machine. -Approximately every six months (this can vary depending on water -conditions and frequency of use), your espresso/cappuccino maker -should be cleaned with distilled vinegar in the following manner in -order to remove the mineral deposits, also referred to as scale. -1. Before cleaning your espresso/cappuccino maker, make sure the -function knob is in the “OFF” position and the appliance has -been disconnected from the wall outlet. +Champion -2. Fill the carafe with distilled vinegar and pour into the reservoir as +Finalist -you would with water. +China Mainland, Hong Kong and Macao Digital Economy Innovation and +Entrepreneurship Competition 2024 -3. Securely fasten the safety lid. -4. Attach empty coffee filter basket and holder. -5. Place carafe onto drip plate. -6. Plug the espresso/cappuccino maker into 120V AC electrical +2nd Runner-up (Gold Medal) -outlet. +Deloitte Digital Camp 2024 -7. Turn function knob to “BREW.” In a few minutes, the hot vine- -gar will start to flow through the coffee basket into the carafe. +Deloitte Digital Camp 2023 -8. Place steam jet into a tall glass or mug. Move function knob -to position during the flowing process only for a few sec- -onds. This will clean any residue left in the tube from the milk -steaming process. +Second Place -9. Turn function knob back to “BREW,” permitting the hot vinegar +Champion -to continue to flow in the carafe. +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - National Round -10. When the flow has stopped, turn function knob to “OFF” -position and allow to cool completely. Then remove basket, -filter, carafe and rinse with hot water. +Outstanding Team Award -11. Repeat above steps using cold water to rinse away any residual +Deloitte Tax Championship 2024 - Regional Round -vinegar. Repeat twice. +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - National Round -12. Turn the function knob to the “OFF” position and unplug the +Deloitte Tax Championship 2023 - Regional Round -espresso/cappuccino maker from the wall outlet. +Top 3 teams -Any servicing requiring disassembly other than the above -cleaning must be performed by an authorized service center. +Merit Award -IMPORTANT NOTICE +Top 3 teams -If any parts are missing or defective, -DO NOT return this product. -Please call our Customer Service Department for assistance. -800-233-9054 Monday - Friday 9:00 am - 5:00 pm CST +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2023 Case Competition -Thank You +2nd Runner-up -6 +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2023 -7 - - ONE-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY -This Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. product warranty extends to the original consumer purchaser of -the product. -Warranty Duration: This product is warranted to the original consumer purchaser for a period of one -(1) year from the original purchase date. -Warranty Coverage: This product is warranted against defective materials or workmanship. This -warranty is void if the product has been damaged by accident, in shipment, unreasonable use, -misuse, neglect, improper service, commercial use, repairs by unauthorized personnel or other caus- -es not arising out of defects in materials or workmanship. This warranty is effective only if the product -is purchased and operated in the USA, and does not extend to any units which have been used in -violation of written instructions furnished by Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc., or to units which have been -altered or modified or to damage to products or parts thereof which have had the serial number -removed, altered, defaced or rendered illegible. -Warranty Disclaimers: This warranty is in lieu of all warranties expressed or implied and no -representative or person is authorized to assume for Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. any other liability in con- -nection with the sale of our products. There shall be no claims for defects or failure of performance or -product failure under any theory of tort, contract or commercial law including, but not limited to, neg- -ligence, gross negligence, strict liability, breach of warranty and breach of contract. -Warranty Performance: During the above one-year warranty period, a product with a defect will be -either repaired or replaced with a reconditioned comparable model (at Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -option) when the product is returned to the Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. facility within the warranty period -and an additional one-month period. No charge will be made for such repair or replacement. -Service and Repair: Should the appliance malfunction, you should first call toll-free 1-800-233-9054 -between the hours of 9:00 am and 5:00 pm Central Standard Time and ask for CUSTOMER SERVICE -stating that you are a consumer with a problem. -In-Warranty Service (USA) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is made -for service or postage. -In-Warranty Service (Canada) for an appliance covered under the warranty period, no charge is -made for service or postage. Please return the product insured, packaged with sufficient protection, -and postage and insurance prepaid to the address listed below. Customs duty/brokerage fee, if any, -must be paid by the consumer. -Out-of-Warranty Service: A flat rate charge by model is made for out-of-warranty service. Include -$15.00 (U.S.) for return shipping and handling. -Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. cannot assume responsibility for loss or damage during incoming shipment. -For your protection, carefully package the product for shipment and insure it with the carrier. Be sure -to enclose the following items with your appliance: any accessories related to your problem; your full -return address and daytime phone number; a note describing the problem you experienced; a copy of -your sales receipt or other proof of purchase to determine warranty status. C.O.D. shipments cannot -be accepted. -Return the appliance to: - -ATTN: Repair Department, Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. - -550 Business Center Drive -Mt. Prospect, IL 60056 -Consumer Service: 1-800-233-9054 -Consumer Parts: 1-800-947-3745 -Hours: 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. CST - -For more information on Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. products: - -visit our website: URL http://www.salton-maxim.com or -E-mail us at SALTON 550@aol.com - -This Melitta product is distributed and serviced by Salton, Inc. -Printed in Switzerland -©2004 Maxim-Toastmaster, Inc. -®Reg. T.M. of a company of the Melitta Group - -8 - -Part No. 60493 - -LISEZ ET CONSERVEZ CES INSTRUCTIONS -AVERTISSEMENT : Tout appareil électrique présente un risque -d’incendie et de choc électrique pouvant provoquer des blessures -graves ou mortelles. Veuillez observer toutes les mesures de -sécurité. - -Machine à Espresso -& Cappuccino - -’ - -I - -N -E -T -E -R -T -N -E -D -T -E -N -O -T -A -S -L -T -U -D -E -D -U -G +Investing in the Future University Competition 2023 +by Pictet Asset Management -I +John Molson Undergraduate Case Competition 2025 -I +Lazaridis International Case Conference 2023 -’ +Marshall International Case Competition 2024 -I +McDonough Business Strategy Challenge 2025 -I +NHH International Case Competition 2024 -B -1 -X -E -M +Scotiabank International Case Competition 2023 -, +Sydney International Business Competition 2025 -I +Thammasat Undergraduate Business Challenge 2024 -B -T -K -X -E -M -S -E -L -E -D -O -M +The Third KPMG ESG Case Study Competition -N -A -C -B -1 -X -E -M -T -E +UW Global Business Case Competition 2025 + +UW Global Business Case Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Finalist + +1st Runner-up + +Finalist + +First Place + +Champion + +Winner + +Third Place + +1st Runner-up + +Third Prize + +Champion + +Finalists + +27 + +26 Local + +Local + +100WF Hong Kong JumpStart University Investment Hackathon 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2024 + +Champion + +ACCA Hong Kong Business Competition 2023 + +Outstanding Team for start-up Filix +Medtech + +Team Excellence Award + +Merit Award for start-up MakeOmnia + +Alvarez & Marsal Hong Kong Business Case Competition 2024 + +Champion & Best Presenter + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2023 + +Best Performer of Roma Risk Advisory +Limited + +1st Runner-up + +Merit + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +Merit & Finalist + +Semi-finalist + +Champion + +2nd Runner-up + +Best Presenter + +1st Runner-up + +HKU-Airstar Bank Joint University Case Competition 2024 + +HKU-SaSa Joint University Case Competition 2023 + +Hong Kong MBS Digital Economy Business Simulation Competition 2025 + +Third Place + +HSBC Global Private Banking Case Challenge 2024 + +HSBC Life Insurance Competition 2025 + +HSBC Life Insurance Innovation Competition 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Top 3 Winner + +1st Runner-up + +Best Use of Technology Award + +International MBS Business Management Simulation Competition 2023 + +Champion + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2025 + +ISM-HK Student Case Competition 2024 + +MBS Simulated Business Management Competition 2024 + +New Century Elite Development Programme 2023 + +Venture Capital On Campus (VCOC) - Investment Challenge 2023 + +1st Runner-up + +Champion + +Third Place + +First place + +Best presenter + +Third Place + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Winner Team + +29 + +AmplifyME APAC M&A APAC Challenge 2025 + +Third Place + +BOCHK Challenge 2023 + +Bronze Award for Innovative Design + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2025 (Regional Final) + +1st Runner-up + +CGMA Global Business Challenge 2023 (Semi-final Round) + +Deloitte USHINE Case Competition 2024 + +ESG Challenge 2023 + +EY Young Tax Professional of the Year 2023 - Hong Kong Region + +Champion + +Finalist + +Champion + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Family Office Association Hong Kong (FOAHK) 2025 Case Competition + +Champion + +HKCGI Corporate Governance Paper Competition and +Presentation Awards 2024 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2023/24 + +HKGCC Business Case Competition 2024/25 + +28 + +HKGCC Pitch Perfect Programme 2024 + +HKICPA Business Case Competition 2023 + +HKSI Institute Case Competition 2025 + +1st Runner-up + +1st Runner-up (Paper Writing Competition) + +1st Runner-up (Paper Presentation +Competition) + +Audience’s Favourite Team Award + +Chevalier - Champion + +Chinachem Group - Champion + +Swire Pacific - Champion + +Chevalier - 1st Runner-up + +Chinachem - 1st Runner-up + +HKGCC - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - Champion + +SOCAM - Champion + +Jardine Matheson - 1st Runner-up + +MTR - 2nd Runner-up + +Overall Champion + +Winner + +2nd Runner-up + +Champion + +1st Runner-up + +2nd Runner-up + +Merit + + Chhawchharia, Mihika Amit +HSBC - Summer Analyst program + +internship, + +I collaborated closely with various +Throughout my +departments of the bank and +interacted regularly with senior +management, gaining comprehensive exposure to the bank’s operations. +This experience allowed me to hone my professional skills, including +communication, leadership, financial analysis, and market expertise. I +was honored to be ranked as the top intern in my cohort and secured a +return offer to join HSBC as a full-time graduate analyst in their Global +Banking division. I am deeply grateful for the knowledge and support I +received at HKU, which enabled me to thrive in a prestigious global +institution alongside some of the brightest talents in the industry. + +Internship Experience + +Lee, Chung Hong Calvin +HSBC - Global Risk Management Intern + +Reflecting on my time at HSBC, I realise that I have grown on a +professional and personal level. I have developed a deeper passion for +the banking industry and a greater appreciation for the critical role that +risk management and compliance play. I wore many hats and gained +precious insights into the banking industry. I was responsible for +overseeing compliance risks across 32 markets in Asia Pacific. I am +confident that the lessons I have learned at HSBC will guide me every +step of the way. + +Hui, Matthew +HSBC - International Banking (ISB) Intern - Corporate Coverage + +The comprehensive exposure to Corporate Banking was invaluable. From +analysing credit risk for lending applications to understanding diverse +product offerings for MNC clients, each day brought new learning +opportunities. I'm truly grateful for the experience of shadowing and +supporting different RMs in the team. Together with the sharing and +introductions from product partners, I learned how to identify clients' +needs and gained perspective on effectively reaching out and pitching to +clients. This experience taught me how to view banking relationships +through a strategic lens - understanding not just immediate needs but +trends. The +also anticipating +professional mindset, strategic thinking, and collaborative spirit fostered +during this internship will undoubtedly shape my future career path. + +future requirements and market + +Nagar, Tanvi +HSBC - International Banking Intern + +immense + +My internship experience was nothing short of incredible. Not only did I +grow immensely in my technical and professional skills but also +underwent an +journey of personal growth. I received +unparalleled support from the team and my mentors and gained an +in-depth insight into the field of banking and finance in Hong Kong. I +formed meaningful connections and grew my network. This experience +has truly shaped me and continues to propel my drive to pursue a career +in Banking in the years to come. + +3130 Sharma, Seerat +KPMG - Financial Services Audit Intern +(COOP3000 Cooperative Education Programme) + +I had the privilege of contributing to audit engagements for leading +clients in the banking and insurance sectors, where I conducted +substantive testing, supported risk assessments and navigated audit +methodologies using advanced tools. This role sharpened my analytical +mindset, strengthened my collaboration skills and offered a front-row +view into the dynamic world of financial auditing. It’s been a truly +rewarding journey that has solidified my passion for a career in +professional services. + +Xu, Aijing +CMB International Capital Corporation - Wealth Management Intern + +During my internship, I actively engaged with the product team in +market analysis and client pitching focused on mutual funds. I gained +valuable insights into various asset classes and macroeconomic +trends. Analyzing mutual fund performances and participating in +client meetings allowed me to contribute to investment portfolio +strategies. Collaborating with +team enhanced my +communication skills and understanding of client needs. Overall, this +experience deepened my knowledge of wealth management and +strengthened my passion for finance. + +the sales + +Shi, Yu Cheung Karson +Bank of China - Credit Summer Intern (Risk Management) + +During the internship, the financial techniques and business knowledge +I learned from HKU Business School courses helped a lot in company +financial analysis. By applying knowledge taught in the financial +accounting module, I assisted in evaluating loan demand. Through +cross-departmental collaborations, I also realised how classroom +simulations mirrored real-world risk mitigation challenges. This +experience reinforced the value of integrating academic theories with +dynamic market practices. + +Hu, Wen Qing +PwC Assurance Practice Intern + +As an assurance intern in PwC, I assisted my seniors with sampling +financial statement line items, reconciling balances, and documented +relevant non-financial information. It showed me how demanding the +auditing industry was, and allowed me to set my expectations for a +career in auditing as an accounting student. + +Wirawen, Karen +HKU – Neuberger Berman Private Equity Internship Programme + +You never truly understand private equity until you’re immersed in it +and my internship at Neuberger Berman was deeply enriching. Coming +in with limited knowledge, I gained direct exposure by working on +various deals across sectors and geographies, including Japan, Korea +and Southeast Asia. From drafting memos for the +investment +committee to attending annual general meetings and taking notes on +calls, I progressed from simple tasks to meaningful responsibilities. The +seniors were welcoming, always open to teaching, providing feedback +and offering valuable career advice. + +Chung, Marcus Lok Sum +Morgan Stanley Industrial Placement Intern + +During my internship with Sales & Trading (Institutional Equity +Division), I had the amazing opportunity to rotate across trading +and structuring desks where I was exposed to the fast-paced +environment especially during periods of high market volatility. To +see how traders manage positions and mitigate risks first-hand +was incredibly insightful. I also contributed to constructing trading +strategies and seeing the tangible impact of our work was deeply +rewarding. Morgan Stanley definitely provided me with a broader +perspective and understanding of market dynamics, liquidity, +client interactions and cross-asset opportunities. + +3332 Our Student Scholars + +Chan, Kwan Yin Cheryl +Recipient of Louisa Cheang Inspiration Scholarship 2024-25 + +I would like to express my gratitude for the Louisa Cheang Inspiration +Scholarship, which has significantly contributed to my personal and +professional growth. In the past academic year, this scholarship enabled +in the full-time Registered Visiting Student +me to participate +Programme at St Catherine’s College, University of Oxford. This +immersive experience enhanced my legal studies through engaging +discussions with scholars and participation in mooting competitions, +sharpening my research and advocacy skills. Additionally, I plan to +utilise this scholarship to pursue overseas postgraduate studies, +allowing me to deepen my understanding of the complexities of law in +a global context. + +Hussain, Iman +Recipient of FBE Student Contribution and +Innovation Award 2024-25 / +HKU Business School Future Leader Scholarship 2024-25 + +As someone who believes in learning through real-world experience, +the FBE Student Contribution and Innovation Award and the HKU +Business School Future Leader Scholarship have been life-changing. +They not only enabled me to go on an exchange semester to Cardiff, +where I explored new cultures and perspectives but also shaped my +entrepreneurial journey. + +With this support, I’ve been able to work on building a social +enterprise that aligns with my passion for creating meaningful impact. +I’m incredibly thankful for these opportunities to grow and make a +difference. + +Chow, Yee Shun Eason +Recipient of the Jardine HKU Scholarship 2024-25 + +It is an incredible honour to have received the Jardine HKU Scholarship +which is enriching my university journey! This scholarship allowed me to +pursue my many goals – from attending international training camps as +a handball player to participating in overseas exchanges without +financial worries. I have had the privilege of undertaking a summer +internship at the Jardine Group, learning from seasoned professionals in +my future industry. The Jardine Foundation also hosted exciting +networking activities and site visits which helped me build lasting +connections with fellow scholars in a vibrant community. + +Shih, Pui Hei Iris +Recipient of the Hong Kong Jockey Club Scholarships - +Undergraduate Scholarship 2024-25 + +This scholarship has been transformative to my university life as it has +allowed me to fully embrace and explore the world beyond the +classroom. It provided the financial stability I needed to focus on my +studies and presented opportunities for me to participate in diverse +extracurricular activities. These experiences broadened my perspective +and opened me to different points of view. + +Nurgali, Adilzhan +Recipient of BOC Hong Kong - +One Belt One Road Scholarship 2024-25 + +It means a lot to me to be awarded the BOC Hong Kong - One Belt One +Road Scholarship. It was not +just about financial support but +recognition of the hard work I have put in. As an international student +soon heading for exchange, this award gives me the freedom to explore +new cultures and experiences without extra stress. I am truly grateful to +be part of such an inclusive and supportive community. + +3534 2026 JUPAS Admissions + +Admissions criteria (HKDSE) + +Local candidates applying on the strength of the Hong Kong Diploma of +Secondary Education (HKDSE) are required to fulfil the minimum entrance +requirements for HKU Business School programmes as shown below: + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +EngEng ≥ +Level 4 or above in English Language +ChinChin ≥ +Level 3 or above in Chinese Language1 +MathMath ≥ +Level 3 or above in Mathematics + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +AA + +CSDCSD = +Grade “Attained (A)” in +Citizenship and Social Development2 + +2x + +Elective +Elective +Subjects +Subjects + +≥ + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +Level 3 or above in two Elective Subjects + +For BBA(BA), BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) +In addition to the minimum entrance requirements above, candidates applying for the BBA(BA), +BBA(Law)&LLB, BBA(IBGM), BSc(MAT) and BSc(QFin) programmes shall also obtain the following results in the +HKDSE examination: + +BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) +≥ +Level 3 or above in one of the following subjects: + +Level 3 + +Biology + +BAFS + +Chemistry + +Economics + +ICT + +Physics + +BBA(BA) + +BSc(MAT) + +Level 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics is also preferred by BBA(BA) / BSc(MAT) but not +strictly required. + +BBA(Law)&LLB / BBA(IBGM) / BSc(QFin) + +BBA(Law)&LLB + +BBA(IBGM) + +BSc(QFin) + +EngEng ≥ + +Level 5 +Level 5 + +Chin, Math +Chin, Math ≥ + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +EngEng ≥ + +Level 5 +Level 5 + ++ + ++ + +M1/M2 +M1/M2 ≥ + +Level 3 +Level 3 + +MathMath ≥ + +Level 4 +Level 4 + +Application + +For details of the 2026 JUPAS exercise, please visit www.jupas.edu.hk. + +Programme Scoring Formula + +For more information on the Programme Scoring Formula and Subject Weightings, please +visit the Admissions Office’s website at https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas. + +Note 1: Non-Chinese-speaking applicants will be considered on a case-by-case basis.Note 2: The result(s) of Liberal Studies at Level 2 or above achieved in previous sitting(s) will also be considered.Level 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inChinese Language1 & MathematicsLevel 5 or above inEnglish LanguageLevel 4 or above inMathematicsLevel 3 or above in Extended Module 1 or 2 of Mathematics3736 2026 Non-JUPAS Admissions + +Selection process and entrance requirements + +Eligibility +(1) Local students applying for admission on international qualifications other than the + +HKDSE examination; + +(2) Non-local students with international qualifications other than Chinese Mainland's + +National Joint College Entrance Examination (NJCEE/Gao Kao). + +Application Procedures +All non-JUPAS applications should be submitted via the online application system by noon of +November 26, 2025 (Hong Kong Time) for the first-round evaluation. Scanned copies of the +following documents should also be uploaded by the application deadline. + +(1) Official prediction of grades or scores from your current high school (if available); + +(2) All internal and public examination results during your senior secondary education; and + +(3) Academic reference letter (optional) + +Late submission of supporting documents will delay the consideration of application. + +Shortlisted applicants for BSc(QFin) will be interviewed; optional interviews for other +programmes will be arranged if necessary. + +University and Programme Entrance Requirements +Due to the complex combination of education background of applicants, each application will +be assessed individually on its own merits. Non-JUPAS applicants are advised to refer to the +standards and requirements on the website of the Admissions Office of the University before +making an application: + +(1) Admissions standards (International Qualifications or National Qualifications); + +(2) Programme specific subject requirements; and + +(3) English language requirement + +In particular, please note that the expected lower boundary for admissions listed on the +website is provided for reference purposes only. Admissions is competitive in nature and +achieving the expected lower boundary does not guarantee admission to the programme. +The actual admission grade or score will be dependent on the overall quality of applications +received in the 2026 admissions exercise. + +Announcement of Result +Offer results will be released from December 2025 onwards. All application status will be +updated in the online application system once an admissions decision has been made. +Applicants should check their application status online regularly. + +More Details +For further information about the application procedures and admissions +standards, +at +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications. + +the Admissions Office’s website + +please + +visit + +2026 Dual Degree Admissions + +Separate application is required for applying to the dual degree programmes, in addition to the +application under the JUPAS or International/Non-JUPAS Admissions Scheme. + +For details of the dual degrees and the application procedures, please visit +the Admissions Office’s website at +https://admissions.hku.hk/programmes/university-collaborative-programmes. + +3938 Develop Your Career + +Freshmen Sharing + +Upon graduation, over 82% of our students begin their careers in the commerce and industry sector. Others either +move on to further studies or explore opportunities with the civil service, education institutions and +community/social services. + +Career Prospects + +Companies/organisations that have offered full-time positions to our graduates include but not limited to the +following: + +Accenture Company Limited +Bank of China (Hong Kong) Limited +BDO International Limited +Bloomberg L.P. +Citibank (Hong Kong) Limited +Crédit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank +Credit Suisse Group AG +Deloitte Advisory (Hong Kong) Limited +Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited +Deutsche Bank +Ernst & Young +Goldman Sachs (Asia) LLC +Hang Seng Bank Limited +HKSAR Government +Hong Kong Monetary Authority +JPMorgan Chase & Co. +KPMG +Morgan Stanley +PricewaterhouseCoopers Limited +Standard Chartered Bank (Hong Kong) Limited +The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation +Limited (HSBC) +UBS Group AG + +Full employment +for the 19th + +consecutive year + +98.7% + +was the average salary of +our 2024 graduates + +$36,770 + +of our 2024 graduates have +received at least 2 job offers +upon graduation + +57% + +Kantbek, Yerassyl +BBA + +I chose HKU Business School because Hong Kong is +one of the world’s most competitive financial centres, +offering a dynamic environment to grow. HKU +combines +real-world +rigorous academics with +experiences, such as Asia-focused case studies and +competitions like HICS, which I plan to join in Year 2. I +am particularly drawn to programs in marketing and +finance, as well as opportunities for entrepreneurship +through the Techno-Entrepreneurship Core and +iDendron incubator. With a diverse student body and +global exchange options, I look forward to learning +from peers, connecting with mentors, and developing +skills to make a meaningful impact in business. + +The main reason I chose HKU, particularly HKU +Business School, lies in its global connections and +strong partnerships with other institutions and +respected organizations, which I believe will be +advantageous for future employment opportunities. +I expect to embrace challenges over the course of my +four years at the university, as these will be vital for +my intellectual and social maturity. The first time I +visited the campus, I was amazed by the diversity of +the students and +facilities, which +demonstrated that the university is truly a place for +everyone. One of the many great opportunities +offered here is the chance to travel for studies, which +I would rank among my highest interests. + +the open + +Pernice, Audrey Yiwen +BEcon&Fin + +4140 The main reason I chose BBA(IBGM) is its flexibility in allowing +students to choose a second major, as well as the numerous +overseas exchange opportunities. I am also fortunate to have +been admitted as a member of the HKU International Case +Society (HICS), where I get to know people from other programs +who are also interested in the realm of business. HKU Business +School provides me with the perfect platform to strike a balance +between my work and life. + +Ho, Lik Hang Gordon +BBA(IBGM) + +Lo, Hoi Tung Reacker +BSc(MAT) + +I chose HKU Business School for its professional background and +diverse opportunities. The multidisciplinary programme allows me to +pursue Marketing Analytics and Technology, aligning with my varied +interests in business and STEM. As a freshman, I am eager to embrace +exciting experiences such as internships and exchanges. I look +forward to gaining insights from fellow students and professionals +through upcoming career events. With the strong support from HKU, +I am committed to developing my entrepreneurial skills and pursuing +my dreams without regrets! + +Drawn by HKU’s global prestige and the excellence of HKU Business +School, I chose to pursue Quantitative Finance at HKU to deepen my +passion for quantitative trading and data-driven decision-making. +The school’s flexible curriculum empowers me to explore +complementary fields such as computer science, statistics, and risk +management. As a target school for top investment banks, HKU +also offers unparalleled career exposure. HKU provides the ideal +environment to grow academically and professionally, and I am +excited to explore the many opportunities ahead. + +Tsang, Chun Shing Patrick +BSc(QFin) + +Fung, Yat Hang Rex +BFin(AMPB) + +My aspiration for BFin(AMPB) was ignited early in high school by its +unparalleled, practitioner-focused design, a curriculum that truly +bridges finance theory with industry practice. This conviction was +solidified through the heartfelt guidance of our Programme +Director, Professor Anna Wong, who mentored me even before I +officially joined HKU, while I was an apprentice at a US bank. + +Now, experiencing BFin(AMPB) firsthand, the transition from the +professional world to the classroom feels seamless. It is this +powerful integration of theory and real-world practice that makes +AMPB incomparable. HKUBS has instantly instilled in me a sense of +ownership, this is not just a school, but a launchpad for impact, and +I am thrilled to begin the next chapter of my growth here. + +I was drawn to BBA(IBGM) because of HKU’s +world-renowned academic reputation and its vibrant, +international community. I believe a truly “global +business” education extends beyond the classroom, +through experiential learning opportunities, daily +interactions with local and non-local peers, and +participation in hall and student society cultures, I will +gain a more dynamic and holistic multidisciplinary +perspective on the business world. Over the coming +four years, I am eager to harness these opportunities +to become a well-rounded leader and effective +problem-solver for my future career on the global +business stage. + +Yan, Sung Hei Christopher +BBA(IBGM) + +4342 Our Global Presence + +Israel - +Tel Aviv + +Beijing + +Shenzhen + +Hong Kong + +Vietnam - +Ho Chi Minh City + +Useful Websites +The University of Hong Kong (HKU) + +Undergraduate Admissions +https://admissions.hku.hk/ + +HKU – Entrance Requirements + +For JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/jupas + +For non-JUPAS Candidates +https://admissions.hku.hk/apply/international-qualifications + +HKU Business School + +Overview of Undergraduate Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/programme + +Enrichment Programmes +https://ug.hkubs.hku.hk/student-enrichment + +Other HKU Websites + +Mainland Affairs Office (MAO) +https://mainlandaffairs.hku.hk/ + +Centre of Development and Resources for +Students (CEDARS) +https://www.cedars.hku.hk/ + +44 -9 +45 diff --git a/q33/random_k4/random_2.md b/q33/random_k4/random_2.md index 2e9f5241e58113455522088c7a6110de8838d130..0523beec0142edd0aa6f2e27f15673239129abcd 100644 --- a/q33/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q33/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,1208 +1,1200 @@ -DUET: Joint Exploration of User–Item Profiles in Recommendation System -YueChen1,*,YifeiSun1,*,LuWang2,†,FangkaiYang2,PuZhao2,MinjieHong3,YifeiDong4,MinghuaHe2, -NanHu2,JianjinZhang2,ZhiweiDai2,YuefengZhan2,WeihaoHan2,HaoSun2, -QingweiLin2,WeiweiDeng2,FengSun2,QiZhang2,SaravanRajmohan2,DongmeiZhang2 -1PekingUniversity2Microsoft3ZhejiangUniversity4KTHRoyalInstituteofTechnology -*Equalcontribution†Correspondingauthor -Abstract -| | | | User History: | Item History: | User History: | Item History: | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -| | | | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | -| | | | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | -Traditionalrecommendationsystemsrepresent ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t -6202 rpA 51 ]RI.sc[ 1v10831.4062:viXra • • Parliament Funk Bass" -| usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearnto | | | Parliament | Funk Bass" | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------------------ | -| | | | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | -aligntheminasharedlatentspaceforrelevance -| | | | | Duet | Independent | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -estimation. RecentLLM-basedrecommenders (Joint Alignment) Generation -| instead leverage | natural-language | representa- | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | -| | | | User Profile: | Item History: | User Profile: | Item History: | -tionsthatareeasiertointerpretandintegrate Enthusiast of A peak-era FUNK- Fan of HEAVY A highly rated POP- -| | | | FUNK and SOUL. | ROCK album with | METAL and | ROCK album with | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------------- | -withdownstreamreasoningmodules. Thispa- Values technical genre-blurring PUNK. Prefers polished -| | | | mastery | creativity. | dark themes. | production. | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------- | -textual -per studies how to construct effective Semantic Alignment ✘ Semantic Mismatch -profilesforusersanditems,andhowtoalign -themforrecommendation. Acentraldifficulty Figure1: DUETalignsrawuseranditemdatabytrans- -| | | | forming them | into textual | profiles within | a shared se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | -isthatthebestprofileformatisnotknownapri- -manticspace. -ori: manuallydesignedtemplatescanbebrittle -| andmisalignedwithtaskobjectives. | | Moreover, | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | to introduce | semantically | rich, human-readable | | -generatinguseranditemprofilesindependently -mayproducedescriptionsthatareindividually representationsforrecommendation(Wangetal., -plausible yet semantically inconsistent for a 2025;Zhang,2024;Baoetal.,2023;Hongetal., -| specificuser–itempair. | WeproposeDUET,an | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | 2025a,b,c;Wangetal.,2024). | | Anaturaldirectionis | | -interaction-awareprofilegeneratorthatjointly -toreplacelatentvectorswithtextualuseranditem -producesuseranditemprofilesconditionedon -profilesthatcanbeinspected,edited,andreusedby -| both user history | and item evidence. | DUET | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downstreamcomponentsincorporatedwithLLMs. -| follows a three-stage | procedure: | it first turns | | | | | -| --------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -However,existingLLM-basedapproachesremain -rawhistoriesandmetadataintocompactcues, -then expands these cues into paired profile limited in two important ways. First, directly -promptsandthengenerateprofiles,andfinally promptinganLLMwithrawuseranditemhisto- -optimizesthegenerationpolicywithreinforce- -riestoobtainrecommendationsoftenyieldsnoisy -mentlearningusingdownstreamrecommenda- andincompletesignals,especiallywhenhistories -| tionperformanceasfeedback. | | Experimentson | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -| | | | are long, | sparse, or heterogeneous | | (Wang et al., | -threereal-worlddatasetsshowthatDUETcon- -| | | | 2025). Second, | profile-based | methods | typically | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | -sistentlyoutperformsstrongbaselines,demon- -relyonmanuallydesignedtemplatesorhandcrafted -stratingthebenefitsoftemplate-freeprofileex- -attributes,whichrequiressubstantialhumanengi- -plorationandjointuser–itemtextualalignment. -Project code page: https://github.com/duet- neering and constrains the representation space. -review/duet_code. More fundamentally, many approaches generate -userprofilesanditemprofilesindependently,with- -1 Introduction -| | | | out modeling | how user | preferences | and item se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -Traditional recommendation systems represent manticsinteractatdecisiontime(Yangetal.,2023; -Xietal.,2024). -usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearntoalign -theminasharedlatentspaceforrelevanceestima- Toaddressthesechallenges,wepropose DUET, -tion (Covington et al., 2016; Wu, 2023). While ajointuser–itemprofilegeneratorthattakesboth -effective,suchembeddingsareopaque: theyoffer userhistoryanditemhistoryasinputandproduces -limitedinterpretabilityandmakeitdifficulttoan- a paired set of profiles for the interaction. Cru- -alyzewhyanitemisrecommended. Recentwork cially, DUET doesnotrequireprofiletemplates: it -thereforeleverageslargelanguagemodels(LLMs) istrainedwithreinforcementlearningusingfeed- - -back from downstream recommendation perfor- asseeninworkslikeCRESDUP(Chenetal.,2007) -mance,enablingittoexploreanddiscovereffective andUPCSim(Widiyaningtyasetal.,2021). While -profileformatsautomatically. Figure1illustrates foundational,thesemethodswerelimitedbytheir -whyjointprofilingmatters. Theuserhaslistened rigid,hand-engineeredfeatures. Morerecently,the -toMisfits(punk),IronMaiden(metal),andParlia- adventofLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)hasen- -ment(funk),whilethecandidatealbumisdescribed abledashifttowardsgeneratingprofilesinnatural -byreviewssuchas“polishedpop”and“greatfunk language. Studies such as KAR (Xi et al., 2024), -bass”andametatag“’80srock.” Consideringboth GPG(Zhang,2024),PALR(Yangetal.,2023),and -sides together, DUET can reconcile these signals LettinGo (Wang et al., 2025) leverage LLMs to -intoacompatibleinterpretation(e.g.,highlighting createtextualuserprofilesfrombehavioraldata. A -the user’s funk/soul affinity and the item’s funk- keylimitationoftheseapproachesistwofold: they -rockcharacter). Incontrast,independentlygener- relyonstaticorpre-definedtemplatesforprofile -atedprofilesmayamplifydifferentfacets,summa- generation,andtheyoftenfocusexclusivelyonuser -rizingtheuseras“heavymetal/punk”whilesum- profiles,neglectingtherich,expressiveinformation -marizingtheitemas“pop-rock”,whichresultingin inherentinitemsandthecomplexdynamicsofuser- -asemanticallymismatchedpairthatobscuresthe iteminteractions. Incontrast,ourworkintroduces -truerelevancesignal. anewparadigmwherebothuseranditemprofiles -DUETproceedsinthreestages. First,rawhisto- arenotfixedbutaredynamicallyexploredandop- -ries and metadata are distilled into minimal cues timizedinasharedsemanticspacetodirectlyalign -thatcapturecompactbutinformativesignals. Sec- withrecommendationperformance. -ond, the model expands cues into richer profile -prompts to generate textual profiles, allowing ex- 2.2 ReinforcementLearningforLLM-Based -plorationoveralternativeprofilestructuresandem- RecommendationSystems -phases. Third,theresultingprofilesareconsumed -ReinforcementLearning(RL),particularlythrough -bydownstreamrecommenders,andtheirtaskfeed- -techniqueslikeRLHF,hasbecomeacoremethod -backisusedtooptimizetheprofilegenerationpol- -for aligning LLMs with specific objectives. This -icy. By coupling both sides in a shared semantic -approach has been adapted for recommendation -space,DUETlearnsuserprofilesthatreflectwhat -tasks (Wang et al., 2025; Lin et al., 2025; Deng -kindsofitemsauserprefersanditemprofilesthat -etal.,2025),butexistingeffortsoftenfacekeylimi- -reflectwhatkindsofusersanitemappealsto. -tations. Theyfrequentlyrelyonofflinerewardmod- -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: -els(Jeongetal.,2023;Chenetal.,2025;Heetal., -• Werepresentusersanditemsasnatural-language 2025; Liu et al., 2025) that do not adapt in real- -profiles and align them in a shared semantic timetosystemfeedback,asetupthatrisksissues -space,extendingtheclassicvector-basedalign- like reward hacking (Skalse et al., 2025). Other -mentprincipletointerpretabletextualrepresenta- methods(Sunetal.,2024;Luetal.,2024)restrict -tions. themselvestoofflinepreferencetuning(e.g.,DPO), -• We introduce an exploration-based framework which can easily overfit on static datasets. Our -thatstartsfromcue-basedinitialization,expands framework, DUET,overcomesthesechallengesby -cuesintocandidateprofiles,andjointlyoptimizes integrating RL into a closed-loop system where -user and item profiles with downstream recom- downstreamrecommendationperformanceserves -mendationfeedbackviareinforcementlearning, asthereal-timerewardsignal,allowingforthedy- -avoidingrigidtemplates. namicandinteractiverefinementoftextualprofiles. -• Extensiveexperimentsacrossmultiplereal-world -datasets show that DUET consistently outper- 3 Method -formsstrongbaselines,validatingbothjointpro- -filingandfeedback-drivenprofileoptimization. DUET is a closed-loop framework that trans- -forms raw user–item interaction histories into -2 RelatedWork performance-aligned textual profiles through -learnedrepresentationstrategies. AsshowninFig- -2.1 ProfilesinRecommendation -ure 2, DUET consists of three stages. (1) Cue- -Earlyrecommendationsystemsprimarilyreliedon Based Initialization distills interaction histories -pre-definedprofilesbasedonstructuredattributes, intoconciseevidence-basedcues. (2)JointExplo- - -CUE-BASED INITIALIZATION JOINT EXPLORATION ON-POLICY OPTIMIZATION -| | | | | Item | DU | | | Duet | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| ItemHistory | | | | | ET | | | | | | | -Initial CUE -Rated: Baba Is You (5★) -User: “Prefers retro puzzle games” -Reviewed: “I love logic- -Item: “Retro-style indie puzzle game” -| | | | based puzzle games.” | | | Profile Prompt | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rated: The Witness (5★) -User: “Describe the user's typical -| | | | Rated: Fez (4★) | | puzzle-game preferences … | | | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒1 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒2 | … | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑛 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -Item: “… item's core mechanics… -| | | | | | | | Profile | Downstream Task Env | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ---- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | User | User: “A player who enjoys logic- | | | | | | | -| UserHistory | | | | | intensive indie puzzle games, | | | | | | | -| | | | Category: Indie Puzzle | | | | | Ranking correctness | | | | -prefers retro visual aesthetics…” -| | | | Game | | | | | &format Reward | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Reviews: -Item: “A retro-style indie puzzle -| | | | “Challenging logic | | game featuring challenging | | | Group Computation | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | mechanics.” | | logic mechanics that appeal to | | | | | | | -| | | | “ R e t r o p ix | e l- a rt st y l e . ” | hardcore puzzle players.” | | | 𝐴𝑑𝑣1 𝐴𝑑𝑣2 | | | | -| | | | “ H a r d b u | t re w a r d i n g . ” | | | | | … | 𝐴𝑑𝑣𝑛 | | -| | | | | Figure2: | OverviewoftheDUETframework. | | | | | | | -ration via Adaptive Profile Prompt Discovery 3.2 Cue-BasedInitialization -| jointly | explores | user-item’s | | profile prompts | that | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Raw user | histories | and item | metadata | | are often | -| define how | user | and item | profiles | should | be writ- | | | | | | | -noisy,redundant,andnotdirectlysuitableforpro- -ten. (3)OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -| | | | | | | fileconstruction. | | Toaddressthis,DUETintroduces | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -jointlyoptimizesuseranditemprofilesunderdown- -theconceptofcues: -concisehypothesesthatsum- -streamrecommendationfeedback. -| | | | | | | marize minimal | | but informative | | aspects | of users | -| ------------------- | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | -| All three | stages | are | realized | through | a single | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | and items. | These | cues act | as lightweight | | seeds, | -| passinputandoutput: | | | cueextraction,self-prompt | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | which are | deliberately | underspecified | | so | that the | -construction,andprofilegenerationareproduced -systemcansubsequentlyexplorericherprofilefor- -inasinglesequence-to-sequencegenerationpass -mats. -atinferencetime,enablingefficientdeployment. -| | | | | | | Definition1(Cue). | | Acueisaminimaltextualhy- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.1 ProblemFormulation -pothesisderivedfromhistoricaldatathathighlights -WeformulateprofilegenerationinDUETasanon- one potential aspect of a user’s preference or an -policyreinforcementlearningproblem,motivated item’scharacteristic. Ratherthanaimingforcom- -bytheabsenceofanytextualgroundtruthdefining pleteness, cues capture partial but salient signals -an optimal user or item profile. Profile quality is thatserveasstartingpointsforprofileexploration. -evaluatedsolelybyitsfunctionalutilityinafixed -| | | | | | | To extract | cues | automatically, | | the | LLM is | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -recommendationenvironment. -| | | | | | | prompted | to summarize | minimal | | but informative | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| DUET | is modeled | as | a generative | policy | π θ in- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | aspectsofuseroritemdata. | | | Forexample,givena | | | -teractingwithafrozendownstreamrecommender. -user’sinteractionhistory,themodelisguidedwith -| For each | user–item | pair, | the | state is | defined as | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -instructionssuchas: -| s = {H | ,H },whereH | | andH | denotetheuser | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | u i | | u | i | | | | | | | | -and item interaction histories. An action corre- CueExtractionPrompt -spondstoasingle-passjointgeneration -“Fromthehistorybelow,analyzetheuser’s -a = {C u ,S u ,P u ,C i ,S i ,P i }, historicalinteractionstounderstandprefer- -ences,ratingbehavior,reviewsentimentor -| where | (C ,C | ) are | cues | distilled | from his- | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u i -| | | | | | | anyotherdimension. | | Keepthedescription | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| tory, (S | u ,S i ) are | constructed | | user-item’s | profile | | | | | | | -prompts,and(P ,P )arethefinaltextualprofiles. conciseandavoidfullsentences.” -u i -| Thepolicyπ | | (a | s)definesajointdistribution | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θ -over the entire generation sequence. As an on- This lightweight guidance allows the LLM to -policy agent, DUET is optimized using rewards maprawhistoriesandmetadataintocompacttex- -from its own sampled generations rather than by tualcues. Thedetaildexampleofcuecanbefound -| imitatingfixedsummaries. | | | | | | inAppendixA.3. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| 3.3 | JointExplorationviaAdaptiveProfile | | | | | | Single-PassInput | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PromptDiscovery Task:Generatestructuredprofilesfortheuseranditemfrom -historicaldata. -Aftercueextraction,DUETdoesnotdirectlysum- Combined Context: [User History H u ] + [Item -| | | | | | | | History | H i ]+[Avg | Ratings] | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| marizeuserinterestsoritemattributes. | | | | | | Instead,it | | | | | | | -“First,extractaconciseCueforbothuseranditem.Second, -| explores | | the space | of profile | construction | | strate- | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -basedonthecues,constructaProfilePromptthatdefines -gies—natural-languagepromptsthatdefinethefor- thedescriptionlogic.Finally,generatetheProfileguidedby -theconstructedProfilePrompt.” -mat,abstractionlevel,andattributeselectionlogic -↓DUETForwardPass↓ -| usedtogenerateprofiles. | | | | Explorationistherefore | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| performedoverhowprofilesshouldbeconstructed, | | | | | | | Single-PassOutput | | | | | | -User -ratherthanoversuperficialtextualparaphrases. -Cue:“prefersnostalgiclogic-basedchallenges” -For each user–item pair, DUET intro- Profileprompt: “Focuson1990svisualaestheticsand -| duces | an | explicit | intermediate | | variable, | the | strategicdepth.” | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | Profile: | “A player | who | seeks | retro-style | visual charm | -constructed_prompt,whichservesasadiscrete -pairedwithdeepstrategicreasoning.” -| and | interpretable | | profile | prompt | S. | This profile | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Item -promptisashortnatural-languageinstruction(e.g., -Cue:“retro-styleindiepuzzlewithhighdifficulty” -“Describetheuser’stypicalgamingpreferencesand -| | | | | | | | Profile | prompt: | “Describe | | pixel-art | graphics and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | -engagementpatterns”)thatspecifieswhataspects intellectualdifficultytomatchlogicpreference.” -Profile:“A2Dexperiencefeaturingpixelatednostalgia -| to | describe | and | how to | organize | them, | without | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andchallengingmechanicsthatdemandlogicaldeduction.” -| containingtheprofilecontentitself. | | | | | | Conditioned | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onS,themodelgeneratesthefinaluseranditem Figure3: Single-passgenerationinDUET: cueextrac- -| profiles. | | | | | | | tion,profileprompt(constructedprompt),andprofile | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -generationareproducedinonepassforbothuserand -| Exploration | | | is driven | by treating | | the profile | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -item. -| promptS | | asastochasticactionsampledfromthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| policyπ | | (S | Cue). | Duringtraining,theagentsam- | | | | | | | | | | -θ -plesdifferentprofilepromptinstructions,executes -| | | | | | | | andintellectualdifficulty”tomatch. | | | | | RLreinforces | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -| themtogenerateprofilepairs(P | | | | | ,P ),andreceives | | | | | | | | -u i -thissharedsemanticdirection,suppressingirrele- -| a reward | | based | on downstream | | recommendation | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | -| | | | | | | | vant signals | and | forcing | the | final | profiles to con- | -| accuracy. | | Thepolicyisoptimizedtoreinforcepro- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | verge | into a shared | semantic | | space | of nostalgia | -filepromptsthatconsistentlyyieldhigherrewards, -andlogic,significantlyimprovingrecommendation -enablingthemodeltoactivelysearchforeffective -accuracy. -profileconstructionformats. -Thisprocessisrealizedasaunifiedgeneration -3.4 OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -pass, -| | | | | | | | On-policy | optimization. | | | We train | the profile | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -O = [ Cue → profilepromptS → Profile], generator π in an on-policy manner against a -| | (cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125) | | | | | (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) | | θ | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (cid:124) | (cid:123)(cid:122) | (cid:125) | | | | | | | | -Context ProfileConstructionPrompt Execution frozendownstreammodelf, whichservesasthe -| | | | | | | (1) | environment | critic. | For | each | sampled | user–item | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | -wheretheprofilepromptS parameterizesthepro- pair (u,i), the policy generates (P ,P ) and re- -u i -filegenerator. Atinferencetime,DUETcollapses ceivesascalarrewardbasedonthepredictionac- -thelearnedprofilepromptdistributionandgreed- curacy of f(P ,P ). The policy parameters are -u i -ilyexecutestheoptimalprofilepromptinasingle updatedtoreinforcegenerationsthatleadtolower -| forwardpass,introducingnoadditionallatency. | | | | | | | predictionerror. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| Example | | of profile | prompt | Exploration. | | As | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Continuousfractionalreward. | | | | | Usingdiscrete | -| illustrated | | in Figure | 3, | DUET | resolves | this by | | | | | | | -integerratingsasrewardsleadstosparseandunsta- -| identifying | | a shared | context | in | a single | forward | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -blefeedback,asnear-misspredictions(e.g.,predict- -pass. ThepolicyextractsacoordinatedCue(e.g., -ing4foragroundtruth5)receivethesamepenalty -“prefersretropuzzlegames”)andconstructsapro- -| | | | | | | | assevereerrors. | | Toprovidedenseandinformative | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| file | prompt | (the | constructed_prompt) | | | that in- | | | | | | | -feedback,wedefineacontinuousfractionalreward: -structsthemodeltohighlight“nostalgicaesthetics -| and | strategic | logic” | for | the user, | while | simulta- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | |y −yˆ | | | -| | | | | | | | | R (u,i) | | = 1− | ui | ui , (2) | -| neously | describing | | the item’s | “pixel-art | | graphics | | perf | | | | | -M - -where yˆ ui = f(P u ,P i ) is the predicted relevance ingsettingbasedondownstreampredictedrating -score and M is the maximum rating gap (e.g., scores. For each observed user–item interaction, -M = 4 for a 1–5 scale). This reward provides we randomly sample nine items that the user has -fine-grainedgradientsthatencourageincremental not interacted with to form a candidate set of ten -improvementsinrecommendationaccuracy. items, which are ranked in descending order ac- -We adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization cordingtotheirpredictedratings. Theground-truth -(GRPO) (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025) to optimize interacted item is treated as the only positive in- -theprofilegeneratorundertheabovereward. The stance,andweadoptNDCG@Kastheevaluation -downstreamrecommenderf isfrozenthroughout metric, with K set to 1, 5, and 10, to assess how -training, which yields a stable policy optimiza- effectivelythelearnedprofilessupportcorrectitem -| tionsettingandpreventsrewarddriftorfeedback- | | | | ranking. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | Baselines | We compare | our method | with | several | -inducedrepresentationcollapse. -| | | | | representative | baselines. | 10H | directly | uses the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -4 Experiment mostrecentinteractionhistoriesforpredictionwith- -| | | | | outconstructingexplicitprofiles. | | | KAR(Xietal., | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -4.1 ExperimentalSettings -2024)augmentsrecommendationmodelswithex- -Datasets. Experiments were conducted on three ternalreasoningknowledgeaboutuserpreferences -widelyusedreal-worlddatasets. AmazonMusic andfactualknowledgeaboutitemsextractedfrom -(Music) and Amazon Book (Book) are derived LLMs,whicharetransformedintotask-compatible -fromtheAmazonProductdataset1,whileYelpis representations. RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)lever- -fromtheYelpOpendataset2. Alldatasetsinclude agesLLMstolearnsemanticuseranditemrepre- -userreviews,ratings,andrichtextualinformation. sentationsfromtextualsignalsandalignsthemwith -WeusedthefullAmazonMusicdataset,butonly collaborativerelationalinformationthroughcross- -subsets (latest two months for Book and six for viewrepresentationlearning. PALR(Yangetal., -Yelp). Data was split by timestamp into training, 2023)fine-tunesalargelanguagemodelasarank- -validation,andtestsetstopreventinformationleak- ing component that selects preferred items from -age(Jietal.,2023). retrievedcandidatesexpressedinnaturallanguage. -EvaluationMetrics LG (LettinGo) (Wang et al., 2025) explores di- -For each observed user–item interaction (i.e., verseuserprofilecandidateswithLLMsandaligns -a review record), we construct the evaluation profilegenerationwithdownstreamrecommenda- -instance based on the user’s interaction history tionperformanceviapreferenceoptimization. Rea- -strictly prior to the corresponding timestamp. son4Rec(Fangetal.,2025)introducesadelibera- -tiverecommendationframeworkthatincorporates -Specifically,theuser’srecenthistoricalinteractions -beforethecurrentinteractionareusedtogenerate explicitstep-wisereasoningoveruserpreferences -auserprofile,whilehistoricalreviewsfromother toguideratingprediction. -| users are used | to generate | an item profile. | The | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -4.2 MainResults -downstreamrecommendationsystemthenpredicts -theratingofthetargetitemconditionedontwoin- Table 1 presents a comparison of our proposed -puts: thegenerateduserprofile,andthegenerated method against five baselines on three datasets: -| | | | | Amazon | Music, Amazon | Books, | and | Yelp. We | -| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| itemprofile. | Anexceptionisthe10Hbaseline,for | | | | | | | | -which the downstream model directly consumes use Qwen3-8B (Team, 2025) and LLaMA3-8B -therawrecentinteractionhistories. (Dubey et al., 2024) as both the profile generator -andthedownstreamrecommendationmodel,with -| We evaluate | performance | using four | widely | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | a prediction | temperature | of 0. | In addition | to rat- | -| adopted metrics | (Wang | et al., 2025; Fang | et al., | | | | | | -2025): MeanAbsoluteError(MAE),RootMean ingpredictionresults,wealsoreportranking-based -SquareError(RMSE),Accuracy,andF1score. evaluation results in Table ??, which assess the -effectivenessofthelearnedprofilesfromadown- -Inadditiontoratingprediction,wefurtherevaluate -thegenerateduseranditemprofilesunderarank- streamrankingperspective. -| | | | | Overallsuperiorityoverstrongbaselines. | | | | As | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ shown in Table 1, our method consistently out- -amazon/links.html -| | | | | performs | the strongest | baselines | across | all three | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -2https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -| open-dataset/ | | | | datasetsunderbothQwen3-8BandLLaMA3-8B. | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) -(%) (%) (%) -Qwen3(8B) -10H 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.7396 1.2184 55.34 48.67 0.7483 1.1380 58.65 60.29 0.7098 1.0923 56.17 58.78 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.8197 1.3312 47.15 42.46 0.7438 1.1069 54.89 57.65 0.7812 1.1584 52.86 55.93 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7994 1.2876 48.53 43.19 0.6075 0.9531 57.35 56.77 0.7485 1.1187 54.24 56.38 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7028 1.1523 55.69 47.73 0.5654 0.9635 58.69 54.67 0.6397 1.0098 58.47 56.84 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -LLaMA3(8B) -10H 1.0864 1.9532 22.09 27.30 0.7917 1.3346 38.13 46.87 0.8064 1.3866 37.15 45.27 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.6427 1.1668 54.51 47.98 0.5726 0.9033 57.53 59.92 0.5892 0.9614 55.87 58.21 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.7428 1.3572 46.74 42.11 0.6076 0.9886 53.78 57.42 0.6226 0.9477 52.12 55.79 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7238 1.3265 47.72 43.29 0.5823 0.9222 56.73 59.31 0.5977 0.8855 55.06 57.62 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6196 1.1289 56.03 51.24 0.5204 0.9369 61.92 59.50 0.5543 0.7967 58.95 60.39 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7586 1.0418 55.80 53.00 0.5442 0.7722 60.86 54.88 0.6029 0.8345 59.70 56.35 -Ours 0.5367 0.9687 60.87 54.74 0.4680 0.8277 63.30 60.60 0.5092 0.9500 63.42 58.12 -Table1: PerformanceonthreedatasetsusingQwen3(8B)andLLaMA3(8B). -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -Table2: RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. -Under Qwen3-8B, our method achieves an accu- our approach reaches an NDCG@1 of 0.5619 -racyof61.23%onYelp,67.96%onAmazonMu- and an NDCG@10 of 0.7443, clearly outper- -sicand64.38%onAmazonBooks,surpassingLG forming the strongest baseline methods. Similar -(LettinGo)(Wangetal.,2025)by5.05%,5.59% trendsareobservedonAmazonMusic,whereour -and5.03%,respectively. Similarimprovementsare methodattains0.5347atNDCG@1and0.7331at -observed under LLaMA3-8B, indicating that the NDCG@10, as well as on Amazon Books with -gainsarestableacrossbackbonemodels. NDCG@1 of 0.4866 and NDCG@10 of 0.7107. -Theseresultsindicatethatthelearnedprofilesen- -Advantages over fixed-structure and delib- -able more accurate identification and ordering of -erative baselines. Compared with strong fixed- -relevantitemswithincandidatesets,leadingtosu- -structureordeliberativemethodssuchasKAR(Xi -perior ranking quality in downstream recommen- -etal.,2024)andReason4Rec(Fangetal.,2025), -dation. Wefurtherevaluaterankingperformance -our approach consistently achieves lower predic- -under a more challenging setting using EASE- -tion error and higher accuracy. For example, on -based (Steck, 2019) hard negatives, and observe -Amazon Books with Qwen3-8B, our method re- -consistentimprovements;detailedresultsarepro- -duces MAE to 0.4612, compared to 0.7098 for -videdinAppendixB.2. -KARand0.6397forReason4Rec,demonstrating -moreeffectiveabstractionofuserpreferenceswith- -4.3 AblationStudy -outrelyingonpredefinedreasoningtemplates. -Consistent improvements in downstream Effectivenessofprofilegeneration,cue&strategy, -ranking. Table??reportstherankingresultsun- anduser–itemjointoptimization. Table3reports -der the Qwen3-8B backbone. Our method con- the ablation results under different design con- -sistentlyachievesthebestperformanceacrossall figurations. Starting from the history-only base- -three datasets and evaluation cutoffs. On Yelp, line (10H), introducing explicit profile genera- - -| Method | | | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 | MAE RMSE | Acc F1 | -10H(HistoryOnly) 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -Profile 0.7218 1.1863 55.48 48.09 0.6597 1.0218 58.67 57.48 0.6764 1.0469 57.14 57.68 -Profile+Cue&Strategy 0.7085 1.1654 55.83 48.54 0.5708 0.9897 58.91 55.53 0.6389 1.0108 58.43 56.88 -Profile+JointOpt.(LG(Wang 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -etal.,2025)) -Profile+Cue&Strategy+ 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -JointOpt.(Ours) -Table3: AblationstudyondifferentdesignconfigurationsinDUETusingQwen3(8B). -| Method | | Yelp | | | | AmazonMusic | | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | | (%) | -10H+30P 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3883 0.7494 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 65.13 59.97 -10H+50P 0.4909 0.9207 62.43 56.24 0.3924 0.7543 67.88 63.87 0.4553 0.9023 64.62 59.52 -10H+70P 0.4987 0.9326 61.98 55.81 0.3937 0.7564 68.22 64.12 0.4608 0.9068 64.38 59.27 -Table4: Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofilequality(usingQwen3(8B)). -tionyieldssubstantialperformanceimprovements jointoptimizationarecombined. Underthisfull -across all datasets. For example, on Yelp, MAE configuration, accuracy reaches 61.23% on Yelp, -isreducedfrom1.1235to0.7218andaccuracyin- 67.96%onAmazonMusic,and64.38%onAma- -creases from 23.17% to 55.48%, confirming that zon Books, with corresponding MAE values of -textualprofilesprovidesignificantlymoreinforma- 0.5126, 0.3937, and 0.4612, respectively. Com- -tiverepresentationsthanrawinteractionhistories. pared with the LettinGo-style configuration, this -| | | | | | | setting | yields | consistent | | improvements | across all | -| ------ | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | -| Adding | the cue&strategy | | layer | on | top of | pro- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | datasets. | | Overall,theablationresultsindicatethat | | | | -filegenerationleadstomodestbutconsistentgains. -whileprofilegenerationandjointoptimization -OnAmazonMusic,MAEfurtherdecreasesfrom -0.6597to0.5708,whileaccuracyslightlyimproves contributesubstantiallytoperformancegains,inte- -gratingcue&strategydiscoveryfurtherenhances -| from58.67%to58.91%. | | | Althoughthenumerical | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | the | effectiveness | | of joint | user–item | optimization | -improvementsintroducedbystrategyalonearelim- -ited, these results suggest that strategy discovery byprovidingastructuredspaceforexplorationand -refinement. -primarilyreshapeshowpreferenceinformationis -abstractedandexpressed,ratherthandirectlyopti- Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofile -mizingpredictionaccuracyinisolation. -| | | | | | | quality. | | Table | 4 analyzes | the | impact of histori- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | -Whenenablingjointoptimizationwithoutstrat- cal interaction length on profile quality. Across -thethreedatasets,varyingthenumberofhistorical -| egy (i.e., | the LettinGo | (Wang | et | al., 2025)-style | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -configuration),performanceimprovesmorenotice- interactions leads to only moderate performance -ablyacrossdatasets. OnAmazonMusic,accuracy differences, indicating that our method does not -| | | | | | | strongly | | depend | on long | histories. | In particular, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | -increasesto62.37%,comparedto58.67%withpro- -filegenerationalone. Inourimplementation,this usingamoderatehistorylength(e.g.,30–50inter- -settingcorrespondstoareproductionofLettinGo, actions)alreadyachievescompetitiveorbestper- -whereprofilegenerationandjointoptimizationare formanceonmostmetrics,whilefurtherincreasing -thehistorylengthprovideslimitedadditionalgains. -| appliedwithoutthestrategylayer. | | | | Whiletheorig- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| inal method | focuses | primarily | on | user | profiling, | | | | | | | -OnYelpandAmazonBooks,extendingthehis- -weextendtheoptimizationtobothuseranditem -torylengthbeyondthisrangedoesnotconsistently -profilestoensureafaircomparison. improveaccuracyorF1scoreandmayslightlyde- -Thestrongestandmostconsistentperformance gradeperformance,suggestingthatexcessivehis- -is achieved when cue&strategy discovery and toricalinteractionscanintroducenoisyorlessrele- - -vantsignals. Incontrast,AmazonMusicexhibits maintaining comparable coverage. Compared to -relativelystableperformanceacrossdifferenthis- existing methods, which either rely on extractive -torylengths,indicatingthatuserpreferencesinthis compression(e.g.,KAR(Xietal.,2024))orgener- -domainarelesssensitivetohistorytruncation. atefree-formdescriptionswithweakergrounding -Necessity of RL-based Optimization. We com- (e.g.,RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)andPALR(Yang -pare the full model with a variant without RL etal.,2023)), DUET consistentlyattainsstronger -(DUET W/O RL) to isolate the effect of RL. As alignment without sacrificing coverage. For in- -showninTable5,removingRLleadstosubstantial stance,LG(Wangetal.,2025)achievesrelatively -performancedegradationacrossalldatasets(e.g., highalignmentbutexhibitslessstablegrounding -YelpAccuracydropsfrom61.23%to48.53%),indi- acrossdatasets,whileRLMRecattainshighercov- -catingthatthegainscannotbeattributedtoprompt erageatthecostofweakersemanticalignment. In -| designalone. | | | | | contrast,DUETmaintainsbothhighalignmentand | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Without RL, the generator reduces to a static mid-to-highcoverage,suggestingamoreeffective -mapping from interaction history to textual pro- balancebetweensemanticabstractionandevidence -| files,lackingadaptiveselectionofrelevantsignals. | | | | | preservation. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Incontrast,RLenablesoptimizingprofileconstruc- -4.5 CaseStudy -tionunderrewardfeedback,resultinginmoredis- -Figure4presentsarepresentativecasestudythat -| criminative | representations.These | | results | demon- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -strate that RL-based optimization is essential for demonstrates how semantically aligned user and -| DUET | . | | | | itemprofiles | enableaccurate | | prediction | | thattran- | -| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -scendsthelimitationsofsparserawinteractionhis- -4.4 SemanticAnalysisofGeneratedProfiles tories. In the user profile, initially scattered and -To better understand the source of performance fragmentedpreferencecuesaresystematicallydis- -gains, we analyze whether the generated profiles tilled into a stable and coherent preference struc- -exhibitmeaningfulsemanticpropertiesratherthan turefavoringfunk,soul,andprogressiverock(or- -servingasintermediatetextualartifacts. Weintro- ange), coupled with a pronounced emphasis on -duce two complementary metrics to characterize musicalcomplexityandhistoricalsignificance(pur- -semanticcompatibilityandgrounding. ple). Thecorrespondingitemprofileexhibitsstrik- -Semantic Alignment. We measure the ingsymmetry,characterizingthealbumasanexem- -embedding-levelsimilaritybetweengenerateduser plaryfunk-rockcomposition(orange)andposition- -anditemprofilesusingall-mpnet-base-v2from ingitasadefiningandculturallyinfluentialrelease -Sentence-Transformers (Reimers and Gurevych, of the 1970s (purple). This example shows 519 -2019). Foreachuser–itempair,wecomputecosine that the learned profiles capture meaningful pref- -| similarity: | | | | | erence–attributecorrespondencethatisdifficultto | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | e ·e | | recoverfromindividualreviewsalone. | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | | | | | | | -| | Align(u,i) | = | | (3) | | | | | | | -| | | | ∥e ∥∥e ∥ | | | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | 5 Conclusion | | | | | | -| wheree | ande denotetheembeddingvectorsof | | | | | | | | | | -| | u i | | | | In this | paper, we | propose | DUET | , a | closed-loop | -| thegenerateduseranditemprofiles. | | | Highervalues | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | framework | for | jointly | generating | user | and item | -indicatestrongersemanticcompatibilitybetween -| | | | | | textualprofilesforrecommendation. | | | | | Unlikeprior | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -modeleduserpreferencesanditemcharacteristics. -| | | | | | methods | that rely | on | fixed templates | | or indepen- | -| -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | -| Coverage | (Faithfulness). | | We measure | token- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | dently | constructed | profiles, | DUET | | treats profile | -levelgroundingas: -| | | | | | generation | as an | exploration | problem | | and aligns | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -|Tokens(profile)∩Tokens(history)| representations directly with downstream recom- -Cov = -| | | |Tokens(profile)| | | | mendationperformance. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | (4) | Specifically, | | DUET | integrates | cue-based | ini- | -Thismetricquantifieshowmuchofthegenerated tialization, adaptive strategy construction, and -profileissupportedbyhistoricaltextualevidence. feedback-drivenjointoptimizationtoproduceflex- -We report coverage separately for user and item ible yet task-aligned user–item profiles. By opti- -| profiles. | | | | | mizing | both profiles | in | a shared | semantic | space, | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | -AsshowninTable6,DUETachievesthehigh- theframeworkreducessemanticmismatchandcap- -est semantic alignment across all datasets while turesinteraction-relevantsignalsthataredifficultto - -Setting Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 -(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) -DUETw/oRL 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -DUET(full) 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table5: EffectofRL-basedoptimization(usingQwen3(8B)). -User History: -Andre' S Grindle "Tour of U.S.A.", Rating: 5.0. If your looking for heavy metals dim orgins look no further. -Andre' S Grindle "Misfits", Rating:4.0. Actually the opening title track is more of a direct pop/rock type song. But the rock n roll -returns in a big way on "Hay Fever". -............ -Item History: -Worlds Away, Rating: 4.0, Review: The CD is wonderful, and is a seminal piece of music for both the group and for those of us who -were 'of age' in the '70s and '80s. Pablo Cruise was - and is - a group that makes beautiful music like few others, and this -shipper/seller made it all the more special with a fast ship! THANKS!!! -Worlds Away, Rating: 5.0, I love this CD! I'd recommend the Pablo Cruise Millenium Collection to get to know this band. Worlds Away to -me represents the best of breezy '70s pop. Five stars! -............ -USER PROFILE: -Andre Grindle is a dedicated music enthusiast with a deep appreciation for funk, soul, and progressive rock, particularly drawn to artists -who blend technical mastery with genre-defining innovation. His reviews consistently highlight albums that showcase musical complexity, -lyrical depth, and historical significance, often referencing artists like Stevie Wonder, Prince, and Rush. He values authenticity and -artistic vision, frequently praising albums that resist trend-chasing and prioritize creative integrity. His detailed, introspective reviews -suggest a preference for nuanced analysis over superficial praise, with a focus on emotional resonance, production quality, and the -artist's evolution. While he is generous with high ratings (often 5.0), he is also willing to critique perceived shortcomings, as seen in his -4.0 for "Test for Echo" and 3.0 for "The Color of Success." His engagement is characterized by a blend of personal anecdotes, technical -appreciation, and historical context, indicating a preference for music that transcends mere entertainment. -Item PROFILE: -"Worlds Away" by Pablo Cruise is celebrated as a peak-era funk-rock album that exemplifies the band's ability to merge polished -production with genre-blurring creativity. Users consistently praise its tight musicianship, genre-defying sound, and the band's ability to -craft catchy, emotionally resonant tracks. The album's appeal lies in its seamless fusion of rock, funk, and pop, with standout tracks like -"Love Will Find a Way" and "Worlds Away" receiving particular acclaim for their infectious melodies and lyrical depth. While some users -note its dated production compared to modern standards, the majority highlight its historical significance as a defining work of the -1970s rock-funk movement. The album resonates most with fans of 1970s progressive rock, genre-defying artists, and listeners seeking -well-crafted, emotionally engaging music. Its high average rating reflects widespread admiration for its artistic ambition and enduring -appeal, though a minority acknowledges its limitations in terms of modern production quality. -Figure4: Illustrationofthemutualcorrespondencebetweenuseranditem. Thehighlightedregionsdemonstrate -thatuserpreferencessummarizedintheuserprofilealignwiththekeyattributesextractedintheitemprofile,which -providescomplementaryinformationbeyondrawhistoriesandthusimprovespredictionaccuracy. -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. -10H 0.3902 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.3577 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.2604 /(1.00) /(1.00) -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.4932 0.1745 0.1823 0.4807 0.2170 0.2391 0.5702 0.1877 0.1544 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.4010 0.2646 0.3773 0.3931 0.3526 0.4889 0.4436 0.2994 0.3506 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.4715 0.3675 0.1917 0.4938 0.2197 0.2390 0.5216 0.2050 0.2267 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.5709 0.2378 0.2682 0.5109 0.2546 0.3749 0.5506 0.3883 0.3364 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.4882 0.2348 0.2330 0.4208 0.3328 0.3595 0.4946 0.2831 0.2949 -Ours 0.6382 0.2880 0.3429 0.5947 0.4002 0.4482 0.7287 0.3457 0.3127 -Table6: Semanticalignmentandcoverageofgeneratedprofiles. Cov. denotesthefractionoftokensgroundedin -historicaltext. -recoverfromrawhistoriesorstaticpromptsalone. reinforcementlearning–basedoptimization. These -resultssuggestthatadaptive,interaction-awaretex- -Experiments on multiple real-world datasets tualprofilesprovideapromisingdirectionformore -demonstratethatDUETconsistentlyoutperforms effective interpretable and performance-oriented -strongbaselinesunderdifferentbackbonemodels, recommendationsystems. -validating the effectiveness of joint profiling and - -| Limitations | | | | | | | References | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Keqin Bao, | Jizhi | Zhang, | Yang | Zhang, | Wenjie | Wang, | -Despiteitseffectiveness,ourapproachhasseveral FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2023. Tallrec: Anef- -fectiveandefficienttuningframeworktoalignlarge -| limitations. | First, | the | proposed | framework | | relies | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | languagemodelwithrecommendation. | | | | | InProceed- | | -onlargelanguagemodelsforbothprofilegenera- ingsofthe17thACMConferenceonRecommender -tion and downstream recommendation, which in- Systems,pages1007–1014. -| troduces | additional | computational | | | overhead | dur- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -TingChen,Wei-LiHan,Hai-DongWang,Yi-XunZhou, -| ingtrainingandinference. | | | Whileourexperiments | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | BinXu,andBin-YuZang.2007. | | | | Contentrecommen- | | | -showconsistentgainsacrossdifferentbackbones, dationsystembasedonprivatedynamicuserprofile. -the overall efficiency may be constrained when In2007Internationalconferenceonmachinelearn- -| | | | | | | | ing and | cybernetics, | | volume | 4, pages | 2112–2118. | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| scalingtoverylargeuseroritemsets. | | | | | Second,the | | | | | | | | | -IEEE. -| quality | of the generated | | profiles | is | inherently | de- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| pendent | on the underlying | | LLMs | | and prompting | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Yue Chen, | Minghua | | He, Fangkai | Yang, | Pu | Zhao, | -strategies. Variationsinmodelcapacityorprompt LuWang,YuKang,YifeiDong,YuefengZhan,Hao -Sun,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,andDongmei -sensitivitymayleadtodifferencesinprofilestabil- -| | | | | | | | Zhang. | 2025. | Warriormath: | | Enhancing | the | mathe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -ity,whichwedonotexplicitlycontrolinthecurrent -maticalabilityoflargelanguagemodelswithadefect- -design. Finally,ourevaluationfocusesontext-rich -| | | | | | | | awareframework. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.01245. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -recommendationscenarioswheresufficienthistor- -| | | | | | | | Paul Covington, | | Jay | Adams, and | Emre | Sargin. | 2016. | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -| ical reviews | are | available. | | The effectiveness | | of | | | | | | | | -Deepneuralnetworksforyoutuberecommendations. -| the proposed | strategy | | in domains | with | extremely | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InProceedingsofthe10thACMconferenceonrec- -sparsetextualsignalsorinnon-textualmodalities -ommendersystems,pages191–198. -remainstobefurtherexplored. -DeepSeek-AI,DayaGuo,DejianYang,HaoweiZhang, -JunxiaoSong,RuoyuZhang,RunxinXu,QihaoZhu, -ShirongMa,PeiyiWang,XiaoBi,XiaokangZhang, -Data,Privacy,andEthicsConsiderations Xingkai Yu, Yu Wu, Z. F. Wu, Zhibin Gou, Zhi- -| | | | | | | | hong | Shao, | Zhuoshu | Li, Ziyi | Gao, and | 181 | others. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | 2025. | Deepseek-r1: | | Incentivizing | reasoning | | capa- | -Alldatasetsusedinthisworkarepubliclyreleased bilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. Preprint, -arXiv:2501.12948. -bytheiroriginalowners,andwefollowtheofficial -termsofuseassociatedwitheachdataset,utilizing -JiaxinDeng,ShiyaoWang,KuoCai,LejianRen,Qigen -thedatasolelyforresearchpurposesaspermitted -| | | | | | | | Hu, Weifeng | | Ding, | Qiang Luo, | and | Guorui | Zhou. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -bytheirrespectivelicenses;forreproducibility,the 2025. Onerec: Unifyingretrieveandrankwithgen- -officialdatasetsourcesarecitedinthecorrespond- erativerecommenderanditerativepreferencealign- -ment. Preprint,arXiv:2502.18965. -ingsectionsofthispaper,andwedonotredistribute -anyrawuser-generatedcontentsuchasreviewtext AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, -| aspartofthiswork. | | Thisresearchdoesnotattempt | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, -to identify or infer the identity of any individual Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela -| | | | | | | | Fan,and1others.2024. | | | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -user,andpriortotraininganddownstreamprofile -arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.21783. -| generation, | we | apply text | filtering | | procedures | to | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -remove direct personal identifiers where applica- YiFang,WenjieWang,YangZhang,FengbinZhu,Qi- -ble;themodelsaretrainedsolelyonpubliclyavail- fanWang,FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2025. Rea- -son4rec:Largelanguagemodelsforrecommendation -abledata,andnoadditionalprivateorproprietary -| | | | | | | | withdeliberativeuserpreferencealignment. | | | | | Preprint, | | -| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| user information | | is introduced. | | Furthermore, | | we | | | | | | | | -arXiv:2502.02061. -| do not release | generated | | user | profiles | or | any per- | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MinghuaHe,YueChen,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Wenjie -useroutputsproducedduringthemodelingprocess, -Yin,YuKang,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,and -andallreportedresultsarepresentedinaggregate -| | | | | | | | DongmeiZhang.2025. | | | Execoder:Empoweringlarge | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| form for | evaluation | purposes | | only. | From | a secu- | | | | | | | | -languagemodelswithexecutabilityrepresentationfor -rityperspective,theassociatedcoderepositoryhas codetranslation. Preprint,arXiv:2501.18460. -beenscannedforpotentialsecrets,andanyinternal -MinjieHong,ZirunGuo,YanXia,ZehanWang,Ziang -endpointsorconfidentialconfigurationinformation -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | Tao | Jin, and | Zhou Zhao. | 2025a. | Apo: | En- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | -havebeenremovedpriortorelease. -hancingreasoningabilityofmllmsviaasymmetric -| | | | | | | | policyoptimization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2506.21655. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Minjie Hong, Yan Xia, Zehan Wang, Jieming Zhu, JoarSkalse,NikolausH.R.Howe,DmitriiKrashenin- -Ye Wang, Sihang Cai, Xiaoda Yang, Quanyu Dai, nikov, and David Krueger. 2025. Defining -ZhenhuaDong,ZhimengZhang,and1others.2025b. and characterizing reward hacking. Preprint, -| Eager-llm: | Enhancinglargelanguagemodelsasrec- | | | | | arXiv:2209.13085. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ommenders | through | exogenous | behavior-semantic | | | | | | | | | -integration. InProceedingsoftheACMonWebCon- Harald Steck. 2019. Embarrassingly shallow autoen- -ference2025,pages2754–2762. codersforsparsedata. InProceedingsofTheWorld -WideWebConference(WWW),pages3251–3257. -MinjieHong,ZetongZhou,ZirunGuo,ZiangZhang, -| Ruofan | Hu, Weinan | Gan, | Jieming | Zhu, and | Zhou | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ChaoSun,YaoboLiang,YamingYang,ShilinXu,Tian- -| Zhao.2025c. | Generativereasoningrecommendation | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | mengYang,andYunhaiTong.2024. | | | | | Rlrf4rec: Re- | -| viallms. | Preprint,arXiv:2510.20815. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | inforcement | learning | from | recsys | feedback | for en- | -JihwanJeong,YinlamChow,GuyTennenholtz,Chih- hancedrecommendationreranking. arXivpreprint -| Wei Hsu, | Azamat | Tulepbergenov, | | Mohammad | | arXiv:2410.05939. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| Ghavamzadeh, | and | Craig | Boutilier. | 2023. | Fac- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | QwenTeam.2025. | | Qwen3technicalreport. | | | Preprint, | -| tual and | personalized | recommendations | | using | lan- | | | | | | | -| guagemodelsandreinforcementlearning. | | | | | Preprint, | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -arXiv:2310.06176. -| | | | | | | Hugo Touvron, | Louis | Martin, | Kevin | Stone, | Peter Al- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | -Yitong Ji, Aixin Sun, Jie Zhang, and Chenliang Li. bert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay -| 2023. A | critical | study | on data leakage | in | recom- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bashlykov,SoumyaBatra,PrajjwalBhargava,Shruti -| mendersystemofflineevaluation. | | | | ACMTrans.Inf. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Bhosale,and1others.2023. | | | Llama2: | | Openfoun- | -Syst.,41(3):75:1–75:27. -| | | | | | | dation and | fine-tuned | chat | models. | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -------- | -arXiv:2307.09288. -| JiachengLin,TianWang,andKunQian.2025. | | | | | Rec-r1: | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bridginggenerativelargelanguagemodelsanduser- -| | | | | | | LeandrovonWerra, | | YounesBelkada, | | LewisTunstall, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -centricrecommendationsystemsviareinforcement -EdwardBeeching,TristanThrush,NathanLambert, -| learning. | Preprint,arXiv:2503.24289. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | Shengyi | Huang, | Kashif | Rasul, | and | Quentin Gal- | -| | | | | | | louédec. | TRL: | Transformer | Reinforcement | | Learn- | -AiweiLiu,MinghuaHe,ShaoxunZeng,SijunZhang, -| LinhaoZhang,ChuhanWu,WeiJia,YuanLiu,Xiao | | | | | | ing. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Zhou,andJieZhou.2025. | | | Wedlm:Reconcilingdiffu- | | | | | | | | | -sionlanguagemodelswithstandardcausalattention LuWang,DiZhang,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Jianfeng -forfastinference. Preprint,arXiv:2512.22737. Liu,YuefengZhan,HaoSun,QingweiLin,Weiwei -| | | | | | | Deng, Dongmei | | Zhang, | Feng | Sun, and | Qi Zhang. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | -HongtaoLiu,FangzhaoWu,WenjunWang,Xianchen -| | | | | | | 2025. Lettingo: | | Exploreuserprofilegenerationfor | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,PengfeiJiao,ChuhanWu,andXingXie.2019. -| | | | | | | recommendationsystem. | | | InProceedingsofthe31st | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -Nrpa: Neuralrecommendationwithpersonalizedat- ACMSIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscovery -tention. In Proceedings of the 42nd International andDataMiningV.2,KDD’25,NewYork,NY,USA. -ACMSIGIRConferenceonResearchandDevelop- AssociationforComputingMachinery. -mentinInformationRetrieval,pages1233–1236. -YeWang,JiahaoXun,MinjieHong,JiemingZhu,Tao -| Wensheng | Lu, Jianxun | Lian, | Wei Zhang, | Guanghua | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Jin,WangLin,HaoyuanLi,LinjunLi,YanXia,Zhou -Li,MingyangZhou,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2024. -| | | | | | | Zhao,and1others.2024. | | | Eager: | Two-streamgen- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -Aligninglargelanguagemodelsforcontrollablerec- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.05063. erativerecommenderwithbehavior-semanticcollab- -ommendations. -| | | | | | | oration. | InProceedingsofthe30thACMSIGKDD | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RadaMihalceaandPaulTarau.2004. Textrank: Bring- ConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMin- -| | | InEMNLP. | | | | ing,pages3245–3254. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingorderintotext. -| Zhaopeng | Qiu, Xian | Wu, | Jingyue Gao, | and | Wei Fan. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Triyanna | Widiyaningtyas, | | Indriana | Hidayah, | and | -2021. U-BERT:pre-traininguserrepresentationsfor -| | | | | | | TeguhBAdji.2021. | | Userprofilecorrelation-based | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -improved recommendation. In AAAI, pages 4320– similarity(upcsim)algorithminmovierecommenda- -| 4327.AAAIPress. | | | | | | tionsystem. | JournalofBigData,8(1):52. | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| NilsReimersandIrynaGurevych.2019. | | | | Sentence-bert: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | J.Wu.2023. | Computationalunderstandingofuserin- | | | | | -Sentenceembeddingsusingsiamesebert-networks. -terfaces. -InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical -MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP), -pages3982–3992. Yunjia Xi, Weiwen Liu, Jianghao Lin, Xiaoling Cai, -| | | | | | | Hong Zhu, | Jieming | Zhu, | Bo Chen, | Ruiming | Tang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ----- | -Xubin Ren, Wei Wei, Lianghao Xia, Lixin Su, Suqi WeinanZhang,andYongYu.2024. Towardsopen- -Cheng,JunfengWang,DaweiYin,andChaoHuang. world recommendation with knowledge augmenta- -2024. Representationlearningwithlargelanguage tionfromlargelanguagemodels. InProceedingsof -modelsforrecommendation. InProceedingsofthe the18thACMConferenceonRecommenderSystems, -| ACMonWebConference2024,pages3464–3475. | | | | | | pages12–22. | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -A ExperimentSetup -FanYang,ZhengChen,ZiyanJiang,EunahCho,Xiao- -| jiangHuang,andYanbinLu.2023. | | Palr:Personaliza- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tionawarellmsforrecommendation. | | arXivpreprint | A.1 DataCuration | | | | | | | -arXiv:2305.07622. -Jiarui Zhang. 2024. Guided profile generation im- Table7: Statisticaldetailsoftheevaluationdatasets. -| proves personalization | with llms. | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | -| arXiv:2409.13093. | | | Dataset | #Train | #Valid | | #Test #User | | #Item | -| | | | Music | 43,071 | 3,271 | | 1,296 | 4,183 | 2,660 | -| | | | Book | 71,972 | 6,144 | | 5,541 13,863 | | 13,515 | -| | | | Yelp | 51,497 | 4,757 | | 4,328 | 8,453 | 13,426 | -| | | | We conduct | | experiments | | on three | widely | used | -real-worlddatasets: -| | | | • AmazonMusic(Music): | | | | Thisreferstothe“Dig- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | ital Music” | | subset | of the | well-known | | Amazon | -Productdataset3,whichrecordsrichuserreviews, -ratings,andtextualinformationaboutitems,such -| | | | as titles, | across | a | broad | range | of product | cate- | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | -gories,ontheAmazonplatform.2 -| | | | • AmazonBook(Book): | | | Thisreferstothe“Book” | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -subsetoftheAmazonProductdataset. -dataset4, -| | | | • Yelp: | This | refers | to the | Yelp | Open | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | | which | includes | user | reviews, | ratings | | for busi- | -| | | | nesses | such | as restaurants | | and | retail shops, | as | -wellastextualinformationaboutthebusinesses. -Itiswidelyusedinrecommendationtasks(Qiu -etal.,2021). -WeusetheentireMusicdatasetforexperiments, -| | | | while for | the Book | | and Yelp | datasets, | we | utilize | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | onlyasubsetduetotheirlargesize. | | | | | FortheBook | | -dataset,weusedatafromthelasttwomonths,and -fortheYelpdataset,weusedatafromthelastsix -months. Foreachdataset,wesplititintotraining, -| | | | validation, | and | test | sets based | on | the timestamps | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | of interactions, | | ensuring | that | test | interactions | oc- | -curafteralltrainingandvalidationinteractionsto -preventinformationleakage(Jietal.,2023). -| | | | Regarding | | data | filtering, | following | | prior | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | work (Liu | et | al., 2019), | we | adopt | a 5-core | set- | -tingtofilterthedataandexcludecold-startusers -| | | | and items—those | | not | appearing | | in the | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | set—from | the | validation | and | test | sets. | The sta- | -tisticaldetailsoftheprocesseddatasetareprovided -inTable7. -3https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ -amazon/links.html. -4https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -open-dataset/. - -| A.1.1 | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | RLMRecPrompt | | | | -| ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -Inourexperiments,weprimarilyemployQwen3- Role: Businessrecommendationassistant -Task: Determinebusinesstypesauserislikely -| 8B(Team,2025)andLLaMA38BInstruct | | | | | | (Dubey | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| etal.,2024;Touvronetal.,2023)asboththerec- | | | | | | | toenjoy | | | | -| ommendation | | model | and | the | profile | generation | InputFormat: | | | | -•Title: Businessname -model. Thetrainingprocessisimplementedusing -theTRL(vonWerraetal.). Keyhyperparameters, •Categories: Businesscategories -suchasbatchsizeandlearningrate,aredetermined •Sentiment: Usersentimenttowardbusiness -throughgridsearchtoachieveoptimalperformance. -OutputRequirements: -Moredetailscanbefoundinourcode. -1. JSONformatonly -2. Structure: -A.2 BaselinePrompts -{ -| | | | | | | | "summarization": | "Types | of businesses | user | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -KARPrompt -likelyenjoys"(≤100words), -Task: Analyzeuserpreferencesbasedonbusi- -| | | | | | | | "reasoning": | "Brief explanation | | for summa- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | -nessreviewinghistory -rization"(nowordlimit) -Input: {user_history}-User’sbusinessreview- -} -inghistorywithsentimentsovertime -3. NoadditionaltextoutsideJSON -Instructions: -| 1. | Analyze | the | user’s | preferences | considering | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Input: | INTERACTION | | ITEMS: | -businessnamesandcategories -{user_history} -| 2. | Take | into account | | sentiment | patterns | over | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time -| 3. | Provideclearexplanationsbasedonreview- | | | | | | LGPrompt | | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -inghistorydetails -Youwillserveasanassistanttohelpmegener- -| 4. | Consider | other | pertinent | | factors | that may | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ateauserprofilebasedonthisuser’ssentiments -influencepreferences -historytobetterunderstandthisusers’interest -andthuspredicthis/hersentimentaboutatarget -| PALRPrompt | | | | | | | item. Iwillprovideyouwithsomebehaviorhis- | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | toryoftheuserinthisformat: | | [itemattributes | | -Task: Summarizeuserpreferencesusingkey- -| | | | | | | | andsentiment]. | Theuserprofileyougenerate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -words. -shouldcontainasmuchusefulcontentaspossi- -| Input: | | {user_history} | | - historical | businesses | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -bletohelppredicttheuser’ssentimenttowards -withusersentiments. -anewbusiness. -| Output | | Format: | An | itemized | list ranked | by | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -USERHISTORY:{user_history}. -importance. -PROFILEYOUGENERATE: -Template: -| | • KEY_WORD_1: | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -R4RecPrompt(Reasoner) -| | TORY_BUSINESS_1", | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -UserReviewHistory -TORY_BUSINESS_2" -⟨H u organizedasbelow⟩ -| | • KEY_WORD_2: | | | | | "HIS- | 1. TitleofItem1 | | | | -| ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | TORY_BUSINESS_3" | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| | | | | | | | NegativeAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| Instructions: | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -[Preference2],... -| | 1. Extract | key | preference | | indicators | from | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2. TitleofItem2 -userinteractionhistory. -| | | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -2. Rankkeywordsbyimportance. NegativeAspects: [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... -| | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | - -| [Preference2],... | | | | | | | cantlyworsethanDUETacrossalldatasets. | | | | | This | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -indicatesthatcoherentsummariesaloneareinsuf- -... -| | | | | | | | ficient, | and that | the gains | of DUET | | arise from | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -ItemReviewHistorybyOtherUsers -⟨H organizedinthesameformatasabove⟩ learnedsemanticabstractionratherthanextractive -i -compression. -| Task: | Analyze | whether | | the user | will | like the | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| new Music | | i based | on | the user’s | preferences | | | | | | | | -B.2 RankingunderHardNegativeSampling -| andtheitem’sfeatures. | | | | Provideyourrationale | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toconstructamorechallengingrankingscenario, -inoneconciseparagraph. -wereplacerandomnegativeswithhardnegatives -| | | | | | | | generatedbyacollaborativefilteringmodel. | | | | | Specif- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -A.3 ExampleofCue -ically,foreachuser,weretrievehigh-scoringitems -Thefollowingexamplesillustratehowrawsignals -| | | | | | | | from an | EASE(Steck, | 2019) | model | that | the user | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | -| aredistilledintocues. | | | Asshownonthetop, | | | user | | | | | | | -hasnotinteractedwith,andcombinethemwiththe -cuesemphasizehistoricalpreferences,whileitem -ground-truthitemtoformthecandidateset. -cues highlight metadata and user-group patterns. Table 9 reports the results. Compared to ran- -| Together, | they | provide | minimal | | but informative | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -domsampling,performancedecreasesforallmeth- -hypothesesforprofileexploration. -| | | | | | | | ods due | to increased | difficulty, | while | DUET | con- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | sistently | maintains | the | best performance | | across | -ExamplesofUserCues -| | | | | | | | datasets. | Thisindicatesthattheimprovementsare | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “enjoys | retro | puzzle | games” | — | derived | from re- | | | | | | | -robustandnotlimitedtotrivialrankingscenarios. -peatedengagementwithclassictitles. -“prefersconciseproductreviews”—inferredfrom B.3 RobustnessunderPreferenceDiversity -apatternofshort,directcomments. -WefurtheranalyzetherobustnessofDUETunder -“tendstogivehighratingsbutrarelycomments”— -| | | | | | | | varyinglevelsofuserpreferencediversity. | | | | | Weuse | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -highlightingconsistencybutlimitedfeedback. -thevarianceofhistoricalratingsasaproxyforpref- -| | | | | | | | erencestability: | | lowvarianceindicatesconsistent | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -ExamplesofItemCues -| | | | | | | | preferences, | while | high | variance | corresponds | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -“lightweighttrail-runningshoes”—derivedfrom -diverseorpotentiallyconflictingsignals. -productmetadata. -Wepartitionusersintothreegroupsbasedonper- -| “popular | among | budget-conscious | | | users” | — in- | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -centilethresholds(bottom33%,middle33%,top -ferredfrompurchasepatterns. -33%ofratingvariance)andevaluateperformance -| “stylized | with | retro | aesthetics” | | — extracted | from | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withineachgroup. -itemdescriptions. -| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Table 10, | performance | | degrades | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -smoothlyaspreferencediversityincreasesacross -| | | | | | | | all datasets. | Importantly, | | the degradation | | is grad- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -B AdditionalExperiments -ualratherthancatastrophic,indicatingthatDUET -B.1 Non-LLMBaselineviaExtractive -remainsstableunderheterogeneousornoisyinter- -Summarization -actionhistories. -| To examine | | whether | the | gains | of DUET | stem | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C TheUseofLargeLanguageModels -| from improved | | semantic | | representations | | rather | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| than generic | | text generation, | | we | introduce | a non- | | | | | | | -WeusedaLargeLanguageModel(LLM)onlyas -LLMbaselinebasedonextractivesummarization. a writing assistant to polish the language of the -| Specifically, | | we apply | TextRank | | (Mihalcea | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | manuscript | (e.g., | grammar | refinement, | | style ad- | -Tarau,2004)toselectsalientsentencesfromuser -| | | | | | | | justment,andclarityimprovement). | | | | Theresearch | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -historiesandconstructuserprofileswithoutusing ideas,methodologydesign,experiments,andanal- -anygenerativemodel. ysiswereentirelyconceived,implemented,andval- -| The | extracted | summaries | | are | then fed | into the | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -idatedbytheauthorswithoutrelianceontheLLM. -samedownstreampredictorforratingestimation. -| | | | | | | | The LLM | did not | contribute | to research | | ideation, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -Thisbaselineisolatestheeffectofreadablesumma- experimentaldesign,orresultinterpretation. -rizationfromrepresentationlearning. -Table8showsthatTextRankimprovesoversim- -| ple history | truncation | | (10H), | but | remains | signifi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Method | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | (%) | -10H 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -TextRank 0.8104 1.1323 50.51 30.23 0.5914 0.8223 61.19 29.68 0.6328 0.8854 59.59 29.48 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table8: Comparisonwithanon-LLMextractivesummarizationbaseline(TextRank). -| Method | | | Yelp | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -| | Table9: | RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| VarianceGroup | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -#Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 -| | | | (%) | (%) | | (%) (%) | | | (%) (%) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | -Stable 1530 0.4017 0.8664 71.76 68.96 432 0.2368 0.5990 82.56 86.89 1876 0.3171 0.8403 76.64 72.56 -Moderate 1354 0.4773 0.8309 60.09 46.26 436 0.3921 0.6628 64.16 47.02 1827 0.4495 0.8059 66.73 55.45 -Diverse 1444 0.6632 1.1198 51.13 45.95 428 0.5536 0.9607 57.10 59.27 1838 0.6199 1.0603 49.52 46.35 -Table10: PerformanceofDUETunderdifferentlevelsofuserpreferencediversity(measuredbyratingvariance). -#Samp. denotesthenumberofsamplesineachgroup. \ No newline at end of file +SURVEY REP ORT + +SP ONSORED BY + +EXCLUSIVE SURVEY + +ARE YOU + +THE LAST MILE +OF RETAIL? + + TABLE OF CONTENTS + +Are You Winning The Last Mile Of Retail? ............................................................................................................................ + +3 + +Major Challenge: Managing The Customer Experience ............................................................................................. + +6 + +Byline: Delivery Imperatives To Compete With Amazon Without Breaking The Bank .......................... + +8 + +Success Story: Uncommon Goods ............................................................................................................................................... + +10 + +Retailers Seek Innovative Returns Solutions ..................................................................................................................... + +11 + +Byline: Final Mile Strategies: Balancing Customer Satisfaction And Profitability........................................ + +15 + +Success Story: Kohl’s And Amazon ........................................................................................................................................... + +16 + +Retailers Turn To Technology And Disruptors .................................................................................................................. + +16 + +Success Story: Neiman Marcus ................................................................................................................................................. + +19 + +Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................................................ + +19 + +About Retail TouchPoints ................................................................................................................................................................ + +20 + +About Oracle .......................................................................................................................................................................................... + +20 + +About Convey ......................................................................................................................................................................................... + +20 + + ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE +OF RETAIL? + +In retail, the “last mile” is becoming more crowded, more rushed, more expensive, and + +an ever-more-critical contributor to a positive customer experience. + +Over the past 18 months, there has been a 50% increase in last mile services, with +most of the demand coming from B2C e-Commerce, according to The Last Mile Retail +Study, 2018 conducted by eft Supply Chain and Logistics Business Intelligence. + +In addition to the growth of online sales, consumer demands are adding fuel to the + +competitive fire: + +• 65% of consumers want greater flexibility for deliveries; + +• 61% want faster deliveries; and + +• 51% want real-time visibility into the status of their orders. + +This inaugural Retail TouchPoints Last Mile Benchmark Report, based on a survey +of 146 retail executives, provides a snapshot of the challenges retailers face in + +managing the last mile, including shipping and delivery; post-sale services such as setup + +and installation; keeping customers informed; and the tricky (and expensive) area of + +product returns. + +There has been +a 50% increase +in last mile +services over the +past 18 months, +with most of +the demand +coming from B2C +e-Commerce. + +— EFT LAST MILE +RETAIL STUDY 2018 + +3 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + While 36% of +retailers deliver +less than 10% of +orders directly to +customers, 19% +deliver 25% to 50% +of orders direct to +consumers; +24% deliver 75% +of more. + +The Last Mile survey indicates that delivery of products to customers’ homes or offices +already is widespread — and growing. While 36% of retailers deliver less than 10% +of orders directly to customers (versus shoppers taking them directly from a store), +19% deliver 25% to 50% of orders direct to customers, and 24% deliver 75% or more +of orders direct to customers. Presumably, though, this last group of respondents are + +online-only retailers that lack brick-and-mortar stores as distribution points. + +What Percentage Of Products Are Delivered To +Shoppers’ Homes/Offices? +(Versus picked up/purchased in-store) + +LESS THAN 10% + +10% TO 25% + +25% TO 50% + +51% TO 75% + +MORE THAN 75% + +24% + +36% + +19% + +14% + +7% + +4 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? Retailers have +seen their volume +of direct deliveries +increase over the +past 18 months: +less than 10% said +their percentage +has decreased. + +In line with the results of the eft study, Last Mile respondents have seen their volume +of direct deliveries increase over the past 18 months: 29% say the percentage has +increased significantly, and 39% say it has increased slightly. Less than 10% said the +percentage has decreased, and 23% say the volume has remained the same. + +How Has The Percentage Of Products You Deliver To +Shoppers Changed In The Last 18 Months? + +23% + +29% + +INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +INCREASED SLIGHTLY + +DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +DECREASED SLIGHTLY + +STAYED ABOUT THE SAME + +5% + +4% + +39% + +Which Fulfillment/Delivery Services Do You Offer? +(Among retailers with both stores and e-Commerce sites) + +BUY VIA MOBILE SITE/APP, DELIVER TO HOME + +BUY ONLINE, PICK UP IN-STORE + +BUY VIA MOBILE SITE/APP, PICK UP IN-STORE + +BUY ONLINE OR VIA MOBILE APP, RETURN IN-STORE + +BUY VIA STORE ASSOCIATE’S MOBILE DEVICE, DELIVER TO HOME + +BUY VIA IN-STORE KIOSK, DELIVER TO HOME + +46% + +44% + +31% + +28% + +21% + +16% + +5 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? MANAGING CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE AND +EXPECTATIONS TOPS RETAIL CHALLENGES + +The volume of last-mile activity is not the only thing that’s on the rise. Customer +expectations around delivery times, service levels and visibility into the process +all are increasing rapidly. That’s reflected in the fact that two of the top three concerns +among retailers responding to the Last Mile survey are related to customers: Customer +expectations around delivery times is the leading challenge, at 49%, and customer +expectations of free/low-cost shipping is third, at 44%. + +What Are Your Most Significant Last Mile Challenges? + +Two of the top three +concerns among +retailers are related +to customers: +expectations around +delivery times at 49%, +and expectations +of free/low-cost +shipping at 44%. + +49% + +47% + +44% + +18% + +CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS +AROUND DELIVERY TIMES + +RISING SHIPPING +COSTS + +CUSTOMER +EXPECTATIONS OF FREE/ +LOW-COST SHIPPING + +HANDLING CUSTOMER +QUERIES/COMPLAINTS +EFFECTIVELY + +17% + +14% + +12% + +DELIVERY/FULFILLMENT +LOGISTICS + +RETURNS +MANAGEMENT + +MANAGING POST- +PURCHASE SERVICE +PROVIDERS + +6 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? “Ultimately, the most important factor in the last mile is the experience of the end +customer (the consumer),” according to the eft Last Mile Retail Study. “Consumers have +the same expectations of service and engagement from the places they shop online as + +they do in-store, except they expect it faster, in line with the speed of the digital world.” + +Amazon is playing a large part in raising the bar of consumer expectations. The +Amazon Prime service effectively “hides” shipping costs in an annual fee, which + +increases pressures on competitors to offer low- or no-cost shipping. Amazon and +others have poured investments into offering two-day, next-day, same-day, and even +less than one-hour shipping to a wider swath of consumers, and it has had an impact +on the whole customer mindset. + +For example, the maximum number of days people are willing to wait for an item to be +delivered in exchange for free shipping has decreased, from 5.5 days in 2012 to 4.1 +in 2018, according to the 2018 AlixPartners Home-Delivery Shopping Survey. Amazon +Prime members are less patient than the population at large: only 19% of Prime +members would wait a week in exchange for free shipping, compared to 31% of non- +Prime members. + +Free shipping has become very much the rule, not the exception. A December 2017 +survey by L2 revealed that 77% of brands offer free shipping on their web sites. +Among this group, 35% do not require a minimum spending threshold to qualify for +free shipping. For those retailers that do require a minimum order, the median dollar +amount of $50 has not changed since 2016. + +The maximum +number of days +people are willing +to wait for an item +to be delivered +in exchange for +free shipping has +decreased from +5.5 days in 2012 to +4.1 days in 2018. + +— ALIXPARTNERS +HOME-DELIVERY +SHOPPING SURVEY + +7 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + DELIVERY IMPERATIVES TO COMPETE WITH AMAZON +WITHOUT BREAKING THE BANK + +By Rob Taylor, +CEO, Convey + +As retailers fight to stay relevant in the face of Amazon, last mile delivery is being pushed front and center. While Prime + +delivery has made the words “fast” and “free” synonymous with a seamless shipping experience, companies have had to + +align their operational costs with quickly changing customer expectations, or risk customer loss — 70% will not return after a + +poor delivery experience. + +Consumers continue to report that they are unimpressed with delivery standards today — nearly 60% of shoppers say that + +the delivery experience is mediocre at best, and similarly, for those returning parcel shipments, 42% said that they were not + +satisfied with retailers’ return processes. + +This has driven pressures to create the perfect delivery experience, with 83% of supply chain executives saying that CX is + +now a companywide goal. While the delivery experience is now a standard KPI, many still struggle with legacy technology. + +By investing in visibility solutions, retailers can identify exceptions that derail delivery, resolve issues before they result + +in an angry customer and reset expectations to create a positive outcome. For retailers, this responsibility involves defining + +appropriate expectations through proactive communication, keeping delivery date promises and providing + +self-service options. + +Communication: Like any great relationship, the retailer-consumer bond needs to be fueled by communication and met +expectations. For the 93% of consumers who say they want to stay informed and receive proactive updates about their + +shipments, communication creates a sense of transparency. This visibility and communication helps them answer, “Where is + +my order?” + +According to our research, returns communication is equally important, as it was a source of anxiety for 70% of customers. + +Customers returning items indicated that the “Where is my money?” question was most pressing, and they did not want to + +deal with the retailer to get that information. + +Commitment: While customers care about “fast and free shipping,” over 90% indicated that missing a promise date comes +with consequences ranging from expected compensation to disloyalty. If a retailer misses a promise date, consumers + +expect a proactive response, and this expectation is amplified over the holidays. Over 57% of consumers said they would be + +impressed if their retailer either refunded shipping costs or expedited a new shipment in response to a late shipment. + +Control: When it is possible for the consumer to resolve the exception or an anxiety, 97.5% of customers will opt for +self-service options. This includes the ability to re-route an in-transit shipment or expedite a new delivery, with younger + +consumers also asking for self-pickup options such as lockers. In reverse logistics, consumer control gives the consumer the + +ability to schedule the return themselves. In either scenario, they seek convenience — they do not want to pick up the phone + +to call a carrier’s 1-800 number. + +Customer experience is becoming increasingly important in final mile delivery. Those who can embrace the rise of digital and + +bend to their customers’ demands can also increase their own flexibility for package delivery. Ultimately, these retailers will + +be able to create a memorable delivery experience and a loyal following without compromising their operations budget. + +8 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + CLEARING UP CONSUMERS’ VISIBILITY CHALLENGES + +Retailers are paying attention to shoppers’ last-mile demands. According to the eft +survey, 47% have implemented delivery feedback surveys, and 40% have increased last +mile visibility for customers. + +Respondents to the Last Mile survey use a variety of tools to keep customers informed +about the status of their deliveries: 86% rely on email notifications, along with online +tracking links (38%), text messages (33%) and phone calls (29%). Retailers’ self- +evaluation of their communication skills is generally positive. A majority, 54%, rate them +as “good,” and only 8% rate them as “poor.” + +47% of +retailers have +implemented +delivery feedback +surveys and 40% +have increased +last mile visibility +for customers. + +How Do You Inform Customers About Their Delivery Status? +(Check all that apply) + +— EFT LAST MILE +RETAIL STUDY 2018 + +38% + +33% + +29% + +86% + +EMAIL NOTIFICATIONS + +ONLINE TRACKING LINK + +TEXT MESSAGES + +PHONE CALLS + +How Would You Rate Your Last-Mile +Communications With Customers? + +8% + +14% + +EXCELLENT + +GOOD + +SATISFACTORY + +POOR + +54% + +24% + +9 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + SUCCESS STORY + +VISIBILITY SOLUTION BOOSTS ENGAGEMENT AND CTR +FOR UNCOMMON GOODS + +Uncommon Goods, a heavily gift-oriented online business devoted to sustainability and customer service, knew that +its customers expected visibility into where their packages were at any given time. The retailer launched the Engage + +product from Convey in November 2016 to provide communication and proactive exception management, and has + +used the platform since then to deliver exceptional customer experiences. + +When an order ships, customers receive an email with a tracking link that takes them to a mobile-optimized branded + +page on the Convey platform. Behind the scenes, Convey integrates and translates all carrier information, allowing + +customers to watch and understand what’s happening as the shipment progresses. Shoppers can sign up for text + +messages and exception emails; rate the experience and submit feedback to the Uncommon Goods team; click back + +to FAQs; and in some cases place additional orders via special promotions. + +Key results include: + +• 12% of shoppers subscribe to SMS notifications; + +• 54% of shoppers leave feedback before delivery; and + +• 6% of shoppers are clicking through to the Uncommon Goods site from the tracking page. + +Early knowledge of customer feedback and shipment issues such as delays, incorrect addresses or damaged shipments + +gives the retailer’s team more time to proactively correct problems. “Customers really appreciate being in the loop, and + +alerted when there’s an unforeseen delay,” said MC Halfpenny, Director of Operations, Uncommon Goods. “Rather than + +causing them to be angry, often Uncommon Goods looks like the hero because we’re being proactive.” + +10 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + RETAILERS SEEK NEW SOLUTIONS TO +PERENNIAL PROBLEM OF RETURNS + +One of the most challenging aspects of the Last Mile is that it’s a two-way street. + +Customers can (and do) return items, and the rise of digital commerce has raised the + +stakes — and the costs — in this critical area. + +“Return rates for online retail are higher — sometimes four times higher — than for + +traditional brick-and-mortar retailers,” said Patrick Bohannon, Vice President, Retail + +Strategy for Oracle. “Return policy is very influential to online sales. Consumers want to + +have easy and cost-free returns, so many retailers are liberalizing their return rates.” + +A Deloitte 2017 holiday shopping survey indicated that consumers’ top perks for online +shopping were free shipping, at 72%, and store policies for easy returns, at 44%. + +While the majority (61%) of retailers responding to the Last Mile survey are able to +keep their returns percentage below 10%, more than one in four, 26%, have a returns +percentage in the 10% to 20% range. + +Returns +percentages +appear to be +on the rise; +only 13% of +retailers reported +decreases over +the past 18 +months. + +What Is Your Returns Percentage? + +3% + +10% + +61% + +26% + +LESS THAN 10% + +10% TO 20% + +21% TO 30% + +31% TO 40% + +Returns percentages appear to be on the rise: 26% of retailers reported a slight +increase over the past 18 months and 5% reported a significant increase. Only +13% reported decreases. + +11 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? How Has Your Returns Percentage +Changed Over The Past 18 Months? + +56% + +5% + +26% + +7% + +6% + +INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +INCREASED SLIGHTLY + +DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY + +DECREASED SLIGHTLY + +STAYED THE SAME + +Cost of returns +top the list +of retailer +challenges at +48%, followed by +customer issues +with packing/ +shipping items for +return, at 39% + +RETURNS CREATE MULTIPLE COST CENTERS AND COMPLEXITIES + +Retailers responding to the Last Mile survey identified returns costs as their biggest +challenge, at 48%, but in addition to this general concern, returns create a number of +other hurdles. + +What Are Your Biggest Returns Challenges? + +COST OF RETURNS SHIPPING/HANDLING + +CUSTOMER ISSUES WITH PACKING/SHIPPING ITEMS FOR RETURN + +IMPACT ON BOTTOM-LINE REVENUE OF RE-SELLING RETURNED ITEMS + +COMMUNICATING EFFECTIVELY WITH SHOPPERS ABOUT RETURNS +RULES/PROCESSES + +COST/LOGISTICS OF CREDITING SHOPPERS’ ACCOUNTS/ +PROVIDING REFUNDS + +MINIMIZING FRAUDULENT RETURNS + +MANAGING IN-STORE STAFF REQUIREMENTS FOR RETURNS PROCESSING + +48% + +39% + +28% + +23% + +23% + +22% + +18% + +12 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? “Retailers make +meticulous plans +down to the +square inch about +what’s carried in +their stores, but +those plans can +be upset by a bin +of onesie-twosie +returns.” + +— DAVID SOBIE, +HAPPY RETURNS + +Returns can play havoc with basic retailing functions, including planning, inventory, + +pricing and in-store assortments. “Many retailers do not plan for returned inventory as + +an available ‘pot’ of stock, meaning they overbuy,” said Justine Shiou, Solutions Manager, +Planning & Optimization at Oracle. Additionally, “returns are generally made weeks after + +the initial purchase which reduces the time to re-sell the item at full price. This can be a + +significant issue for fashion/short lifecycle retailers that turn quickly. The selling price is + +likely to have already been marked down versus the price when it was purchased.” + +David Sobie, Co-Founder and CEO of Happy Returns, which operates “return bars” + +where shoppers can bring back items they have bought online, identified other returns- + +related issues retailers grapple with. “Broadly speaking, the challenge for retailers is + +‘How do I get this inventory back and ready to be restocked in a way that doesn’t break + +the bank?’” said Sobie. + +Costs include shipping the item back to the distribution center or store, but that’s only + +the beginning, said Sobie. Someone needs to assess whether the item can be added + +back into the retailer’s inventory. In some cases this is a simple matter of relabeling + +and repackaging an undamaged item, but if the item is damaged in some way, + +refurbishment might be needed. The retailer might need to take a loss or sell the item + +to a downmarket channel. + +ONLINE RETURNS UPSET STORE ASSORTMENT PLANS + +Omnichannel retailers have their own set of returns challenges. A retailer’s online + +assortment may be much larger than that of an individual brick-and-mortar store, but + +if shoppers return an item bought online, it needs to be incorporated into the store’s + +assortment — or shipped to another store or DC at additional cost. + +“Retailers make meticulous plans down to the square inch about what’s carried in + +their stores, but those plans can be upset by a bin of onesie-twosie returns,” said + +Sobie. “That carefully planned store assortment can make the store look like more of a + +discount retailer.” + +13 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + POOR RETURNS EXPERIENCES CREATE NEGATIVE CX + +Retailers seeking to keep returns costs down may decide to choose slower, less + +expensive shipping options, but they may end up paying higher costs in other + +areas. “The longer the returns process takes, the more customer service contacts + +will be generated,” Sobie warned. “The number-one reason people contact customer + +service is to check on their order, but the number-two reason relates to returns. These + +are not insignificant costs, either; they can run to a couple of bucks per contact at a + +well-run retailer.” + +Returns create headaches for consumers as well, meaning that if retailers don’t handle + +the process well, they risk losing dissatisfied customers. A 2017 study conducted by + +Forrester for Happy Returns, which surveyed online fashion shoppers, revealed that +returns are the worst part of online shopping for 73% of consumers. Among those +that have to return items, 39% say they do not shop at the retailer again. + +Returns are the +worst part of +online shopping +for 73% of +consumers. +Among those that +have to return +items, 39% don’t +shop that retailer +again. + +— FORRESTER + +14 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + FINAL MILE STRATEGIES: BALANCING CUSTOMER +SATISFACTION AND PROFITABILITY + +By Justine Shiou, Solutions Manager, +Planning and Optimization, Oracle + +ONLINE RETURNS AND INVENTORY SHUFFLING + +A sale is not a sale until the customer decides to keep it. Return rates have continued to increase across all channels but + +online sales have a higher return rate (more than 3X). Despite the operational impacts, retailers are liberalizing return + +policies: free returns, return in-store, return without limits basically, to reduce friction. This strategy has significantly + +increased operational cost. An online return to the warehouse includes shipping costs and restocking fees, an online back- + +to-store return also includes restocking fees but brings another layer of inefficiency, requiring the associate to handle the +item, run it back onto the floor, ultimately distracting him/her from more productive customer engagements. + +Markdown rates are also climbing exponentially, due to incongruent on-hand store inventory and delayed returns. Returns + +are generally made weeks after the initial purchase, which means reduced time to resell at full price, particularly for fashion + +retailers. The effectiveness of localized assortment strategies is degraded due to buy online, return in store (BORIS). The + +BORIS journey creates incongruent inventory and cluttered sales floors. Retailers are dealing with this in two ways: + +• Treatment 1: absorb the cost of taking one-off markdowns to clear the stock + +• Treatment 2: absorb the cost of transferring items back to the online warehouse or to another store with the + +item in its assortment, a.k.a. inventory shuffling + +While the practice of inventory shuffling [using transfers] used to be deemed costly, some retailers have decided this + +treatment is more sales effective than creating markdowns. Neither approach is optimal. + +TRADE REGIONS: MEASURING TRADEOFF BETWEEN CX AND GROSS MARGIN + +A focus on total trade region (online and stores combined) when developing omnichannel strategies and the role of the + +store is critical to long-term success. Retailers need to consider all roles, including fulfillment, pickup, return, traditional + +sales or a showroom concept. Advanced analysis on departments and items that have high conversion rates need to be + +conducted to save sales and create new revenue opportunities. Integrating business insights, like customer loyalty, with + +POS or order system data will more effectively drive planning by customer and fulfilment channel. With improved weekly + +sales, stock and intake accuracy, and in-season projections by channel, retailers will be able to increase gross margin, and + +reduce markdown liabilities. The ability to track the effects of cross-channel returns can help limit under- or over-stock + +situations, plan return percentages by channel and customer journey and plan cross-channel sales fulfilment paths. + +Retailers intrinsically are bound by the bottom line and shareholder interest. However, the retail environment has + +changed significantly while the mindset around profitability has not. Including a customer experience measure (such as + +NPS) in the planning process can also help retailers understand a more holistic view of their business and ensure the + +plan’s relevance to both gross margin and customer service (t-NPS). + +15 ARE YOU WINNING THE + +LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + + SUCCESS STORY + +KOHL’S GETS TRAFFIC BUMP FROM AMAZON RETURNS + +Returns aren’t all bad news. Savvy retailers with well-trained staffs have long been able to turn the return occasion into + +an opportunity to repair a damaged customer relationship, and in some cases even to take advantage of the consumer’s + +presence to sell them additional items. + +Since October 2017, Amazon shoppers have been able to return items at 82 Kohl’s stores. It seems benefits are flowing +to both parties: Amazon gets a physical location for returns, improving customer service and potentially cutting costs, + +and Kohl’s has seen increased foot traffic in the participating stores. + +A study by UberMedia found that stores with Amazon Return Centers saw their daily visitors increase 48% after October +2017, compared to a 36% increase in non-Amazon Return center locations. The 12-point difference was over and above +the normal holiday traffic increase to be expected in Q4. + +RETAILERS TURN TO TECHNOLOGY, +THIRD-PARTY SERVICES AND DISRUPTORS + +Retailers are tackling their last-mile challenges with a mix of traditional technologies and + +cutting-edge solutions. Additionally, as might be expected in an area that’s often far + +from their core competencies, retailers rely heavily on third-party services to fulfill many + +last-mile chores. + +More than half, 59%, of retailers deploy courier/delivery services, and 28% drop +ship items directly from suppliers. For services that involve direct customer contact, +however, most retailers prefer to keep these functions in-house: only 14% outsource +customer service call centers, and just 12% rely on others for product delivery and +setup; 22% do not outsource any of their last-mile services. + +Retailers’ choices for technological aids in this area generally run to the tried and + +true: transportation management solutions and route optimization systems top the +current usage list, at 35% and 27% respectively. The percentages using more advanced +solutions, such as RFID on shipping containers and products/packaging, are in the + +teens. IoT sensors, AI/machine learning, and the use of land-based robots or airborne + +drones are even less common. Perhaps in an area as high-stakes as the last mile, + +retailers are waiting for the technology to be perfected before taking a chance on it. + +For services that +involve direct +customer contact, +most retailers +prefer to keep +functions in- +house: 22% do +not outsource any +of their last-mile +services. + +16 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? Which Last Mile Services Do You Outsource To Third Parties? +(Check all that apply) + +59% + +COURIER/DELIVERY SERVICES + +28% + +DROP SHIP ITEMS DIRECTLY FROM SUPPLIERS + +14% + +12% + +10% + +22% + +CUSTOMER SERVICE/CALL CENTER + +PRODUCT DELIVERY/SETUP + +RETURNS MANAGEMENT + +WE DON’T OUTSOURCE ANY LAST MILE SERVICES + +Which Technologies Do You Use +To Manage Last-Mile Activities? + +USE NOW + +PLAN TO ADOPT +WITHIN 18 MONTHS + +NO PLANS TO ADOPT + +TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT SOLUTION + +ROUTE OPTIMIZATION SYSTEM + +VEHICLE MONITORING TECHNOLOGY + +RFID ON SHIPPING CONTAINERS + +MOBILE DEVICE MONITORING OF DELIVERY PEOPLE + +RFID ON PRODUCTS/PACKAGING + +IOT SENSORS + +AI/MACHINE LEARNING + +LAND-BASED ROBOTIC DELIVERIES + +DRONE DELIVERIES + +35% + +27% + +18% + +16% + +14% + +14% + +10% + +7% + +6% + +2% + +21% + +27% + +24% + +24% + +31% + +28% + +26% + +33% + +12% + +14% + +44% + +46% + +58% + +60% + +55% + +58% + +64% + +60% + +82% + +84% + +17 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? One area where at least a few retailers are willing to try something new is with + +disruptive shippers, such as Uber, Deliv, Instacart and Shipt. The December 2017 + +Target acquisition of Shipt for $550 million, and high-profile Instacart partnerships with + +retailers including BJ’s Wholesale Club and Albertsons, may signal to other brands that + +such services are “retail-ready.” + +Which Non-Traditional Shippers Have You Used +During The Past 12 Months? +(Check all that apply) + +Top retailer data +uses are focused +on functional +areas, but 42% +are using returns +data to adjust +their product +selections. + +21% + +8% + +7% + +11% + +UBER + +DELIV + +INSTACART + +SHIPT + +59% + +OTHER E.G. ANDREANI, ENJOY, SPEEDEE, +GOOGLE EXPRESS, SKIP THE DISHES + +Given the growing volume of last mile activity, retailers should look to step up their data + +collection and analysis efforts in order to gain a strategic advantage. At this point, top + +data uses are focused on functional areas such as resolving customer service issues, +at 48%, and tracking the speed/efficiency of drivers, at 46%. A significant minority of +respondents, 42%, are using returns data to adjust their product selections, a smart +move that could potentially reduce future returns rates. + +What Are Your Most Valuable Uses For Last Mile Data? + +48% + +46% + +42% + +22% + +RESOLVE CUSTOMER +SERVICE ISSUES + +TRACK SPEED/ +EFFICIENCY OF DRIVERS +OR DELIVERY SERVICES + +USE RETURNS DATA +TO ALTER PRODUCT +SELECTION + +DETERMINE MORE +EFFICIENT DELIVERY +ROUTES + +17% + +13% + +12% + +CHANGE SHIPPING OFFERS +(I.E. DISCOUNTS FOR +DELIVERING MULTIPLE +ITEMS IN ONE BOX) + +CHANGE INTERNAL +FULFILLMENT RULES +(E.G. SET MINIMUM TRUCK +CAPACITIES AT 75%) + +IDENTIFY LOCATIONS FOR +NEW STORES/ +E-COMMERCE ACTIVITIES + +18 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? SUCCESS STORY + +NEIMAN MARCUS BOOSTS SPEED, SERVICE LEVELS +WITH PROACTIVE SOLUTION + +Last-mile challenges are multiplied when retailers are delivering large, bulky items such as furniture and appliances. At + +least one in every 10 of these “white glove” deliveries faces a problem of some kind, such as an incorrect address or +phone number or a scheduling conflict with the carrier, according to the Wall Street Journal. + +When the retailer is Neiman Marcus, known for its high levels of in-store customer service, there’s lots of pressure to +get these deliveries right as often as possible. The supply chain team at Neiman Marcus collaborated with the customer + +care group, using a Convey solution to track the most complex deliveries. + +The software captures problems with enough time to correct them before the scheduled delivery date. Within 30 days of +launching the solution, Neiman Marcus had reduced transit times to customer by 24%. + +CONCLUSION + +Retailers and their last-mile partners are racing to keep up with customer expectations + +that are only moving in one direction: higher. To make things even more challenging, + +customers want fast, accurate deliveries, hassle-free returns, and enhanced visibility + +into these processes — all for little or no cost. + +“The biggest challenge in the last mile is matching increasing cost against spiraling +consumer expectations,” said Paul Hamblin, Editor in Chief, Logistics Business magazine, +as quoted in the eft Last Mile Retail Study. “Next-day is already almost standard, same- +day is hot on its heels. Who’s going to pay for all this?” + +“The biggest +challenge in +the last mile +is matching +increasing cost +against spiraling +consumer +expectations.” + +Technology and innovation are providing some of the answers, as retailers seek the + +most optimal transportation routes and try out new business models for shipping and + +returns. But retailers will need to dig deeper in order to meet their last-mile challenges. + +— PAUL HAMBLIN, +LOGISTICS BUSINESS + +They need to gather insights about price sensitivity and elasticity in the last mile, so + +that they can begin recouping at least some of their costs without alienating customers. + +They should invest in back-end systems that allow them to make firm delivery date + +promises, and to proactively prevent missteps that can damage the customer +relationship. Finally, retailers may want to rethink whether every order needs to be +delivered within 12, 24 or 48 hours. If consumers are confident that their order will + +arrive when the retailer has said it will, they might be more willing to wait a few days. + +19 + +ARE YOU WINNING THE LAST MILE OF RETAIL? + To Learn More... + +Retail TouchPoints is an online publishing network for retail executives, with content focused on +optimizing the customer experience across all channels. The Retail TouchPoints network is comprised of +three weekly e-newsletters, special reports, web seminars, exclusive benchmark research, an insightful + +editorial blog, and a content-rich web site featuring daily news updates and multi-media interviews at +www.retailtouchpoints.com. The Retail TouchPoints team also interacts with social media communities +via Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn. + +P 201.257.8528 +info@retailtouchpoints.com + +Oracle provides retailers with a complete, open, and integrated suite of best-of-breed business + +applications, cloud services, and hardware that are engineered to work together and empower + +commerce. Leading fashion, grocery, and specialty retailers use Oracle solutions to anticipate market + +changes, simplify operations and inspire authentic brand interactions. For more information, visit our +website at www.oracle.com/retail. + +P 1.650.506.7000 +oneretailvoice_ww@oracle.com + +Convey enables businesses worldwide to take control of shipping and delivery. Our cloud-based + +platform connects disparate data and processes, giving shippers the insight to make smart decisions, + +and the tools to take action. From parcel to freight, and first to final mile, Convey helps the world’s + +largest brands create better delivery outcomes while reducing costs, improving visibility and + +transforming transportation into their next competitive advantage. Founded in 2013, Convey is based +in Austin, Texas. Learn more at: www.getconvey.com. + +P 602.842.2788 +info@getconvey.com + diff --git a/q33/random_k4/random_3.md b/q33/random_k4/random_3.md index d7c648c46217c666d729ea73101d1fa08d732fc8..967b2c940f2c97099caa67c735d4e7aec3f43bd9 100644 --- a/q33/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q33/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1010 +1,2056 @@ -Fellow Shareholders, - - February 12, 2026 - -We delivered excellent results in 2025, driven by consistent execution and the differentiation of our leading TV -streaming platform. By expanding our Platform monetization over the last two years, we’ve unlocked new -growth engines and achieved record-breaking financial performance. In 2025, we achieved positive net income, -expanded Adjusted EBITDA margin by 255 basis points, and reported record Free Cash Flow (TTM), all while -continuing to invest in our platform for long-term growth. We repurchased a total of $150 million of shares -under our $400 million stock repurchase program, reinforcing our commitment to growing Free Cash Flow per -share. Looking ahead to 2026 and beyond, we are confident in our ability to sustain double-digit Platform -revenue growth while continuing to expand both operating and net income margins. - -Full Year 2025 Key Results - -• Total net revenue was $4.737 billion, up 15% year over year (YoY) -• Platform revenue was $4.145 billion, up 18% YoY -• Gross profit was $2.074 billion, up 15% YoY -• Streaming Hours were 145.6 billion, up 15% YoY -• The Roku Channel was the #2 app on our platform by engagement in the U.S. - - Platform -Our Platform segment delivered strong performance in 2025. In Q4, we grew Platform revenue 18% YoY to -$1.224 billion, with gross margin of 52.8%. For the full year, we grew Platform revenue 18% YoY to $4.145 billion, -driven by continued strength in video advertising and streaming services distribution activities, with gross -margin of 52.0%. - -The Roku Experience, anchored by our Home Screen, encompasses the full suite of features designed to engage -viewers and simplify content discovery through the power of AI and our first-party data. This year, we will launch -Home Screen enhancements to further elevate the streaming experience, driving both deeper engagement and -increased Platform monetization. - -Advertising Activities -Our differentiated ad offering is built on our significant scale and first-party data, with more than 90 million -logged-in Streaming Households globally, as well as our innovative ad formats and open and interoperable CTV -ad platform. Roku is the #1 TV streaming platform by hours streamed in the U.S., Canada, and Mexico1, and our -significant viewer engagement generates robust ad supply. According to Nielsen’s The GaugeTM report, The Roku -Channel is the #2 free, ad-supported streaming app (second only to YouTube) and the #5 streaming app overall -in the U.S. In December 2025, The Roku Channel hit an all-time high, representing 6.3% of all TV streaming, up -from 4.6% a year ago2. The share of Roku video impressions executed programmatically continues to increase, -and as we further expand our programmatic capabilities, we expect to drive higher fill rates and improved -monetization. - -In 2025, video advertising on our platform grew faster YoY than the U.S. OTT and broader digital ad markets3. -We announced enhanced partner integrations, along with ad launches in our international markets, as we -increasingly focus on monetization outside the U.S. We expanded our partnership with FreeWheel to activate -Roku inventory via the FreeWheel Streaming Hub, improving demand signals and transparency. We also -broadened our measurement partnership with Nielsen to integrate Roku data into Nielsen’s advanced -measurement solutions. Additionally, we launched the Roku Ads API, a fully open, self-serve developer platform -that enables advertisers to integrate with Roku Ads Manager. Internationally, we partnered with Warner Bros. -Discovery to scale ad demand in Mexico. In Brazil, we expanded our Live TV Guide to 30 FAST channels before -launching our ad platform in partnership with Mercado Ads. - -Throughout the year, we deepened integrations with leading demand-side platforms including Wurl, Yahoo, The -Trade Desk, and Amazon DSP to further diversify our demand sources. We also scaled our measurement and -performance capabilities through partnerships with INCRMNTAL, iSpot, and AppsFlyer. To empower our -partners, we launched the Roku Data Cloud, enabling them to seamlessly analyze and leverage our proprietary -TV data to drive measurable results. - -1 Dec 2025, Hypothesis Group -2 Nielsen The GaugeTM, December 2025 and December 2024 -3 4Q25 SMI (Standard Media Index) data; OTT: over the top - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +Accelerating +5G in Indonesia: +A spectrum roadmap +for success + +Copyright © 2025 GSMA + + The GSMA represents the interests of mobile +operators worldwide, uniting more than 750 +operators with nearly 400 companies in the +broader mobile ecosystem, including handset +and device makers, software companies, +equipment providers and internet companies, as +well as organisations in adjacent industry sectors. +The GSMA also produces the industry-leading +MWC events held annually in Barcelona, Los +Angeles and Shanghai, as well as the Mobile 360 +Series of regional conferences. + +For more information, please visit the GSMA +corporate website at gsma.com + +Follow the GSMA on Twitter/X: @GSMA + +For spectrum information, please visit +www.gsma.com/spectrum/. + +To contact the Spectrum Team, please contact +us at www.gsma.com/spectrum/contact-us/ + +Windsor Place Consulting Pty Ltd (‘WPC’) is +internationally recognised as an outstanding +provider of advice to the information +industries. The firm, established in 2000, +works exclusively in telecommunications, +media, and information technology sectors, in +advising international organisations, investors, +operators, Governments and regulators in +Asia, the Pacific and Africa. The firm, lead by +its Managing Director, Scott Minehane has +extensive expertise and experience in relation +to telecommunications policy, legislative +drafting, regulation, digital content, spectrum +management, national broadband networks, +new generation fixed and mobile technologies +including 5G, online service regulation, +competition policy and the app economy. + +Published: March 2025 + + Contents + +Summary + +1. Introduction + +1.1 The Indonesia mobile market +1.2 A spectrum roadmap for 5G +1.3 The key role of mid-band spectrum for 5G + +4 + +7 +8 +11 +12 + +2 Progress on Indonesia’s spectrum plan for 5G +Indonesia’s 5G Spectrum planning + 2.1 + 2.2 The digital dividend, the 700 MHz band and changes +to the applicable spectrum management law + +14 +15 + +17 + +3. Key challenges and actions to secure sufficient + +spectrum for 5G services in Indonesia + 3.1 Spectrum roadmap towards 2030 + 3.2 Long-term financial sustainability in Indonesia + +18 +19 +22 + +3 / 25 +3 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + + ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + +Summary + +4 / 25 +4 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + +Communications, connectivity and digitisation +are central to achieving higher productivity and +broader socio-economic inclusion of Indonesia’s +broadly distributed and diverse population. +Devising effective pro-growth, pro-inclusion +communications and digitisation policies will +be key to Indonesia’s success in the new global +economic environment. + +Broadband connectivity and digital services that +use spectrum play a vital role in how people live +and businesses operate. Digital transformation + +is rapidly occurring in many sectors of the +Indonesian economy. The 5G era will help to +accelerate this process and boost economic +growth in the country in the years ahead. + +In Indonesia, mobile data traffic per connection has +grown strongly in recent years, reaching over 16 GB +per connection in 2024. 5G is being implemented +with limited launches by operators using mainly +their existing legacy spectrum holdings. As of the +end of 2024, 5G network coverage is around 26% +of the population (see below).1 + +Figure 1 +Indonesia mobile market – key indicators + +Total spectrum assigned: +452 MHz; +Mid-band: 360 MHz + +4G population coverage: 98%; +5G population coverage: 26.3% + +Mobile data per connection +per month: 14.9 GB (2024) +vs 41.5 GB (2030) + +Much work must be done to ensure adequate +spectrum resources to support 5G development +in Indonesia, especially in the crucial mid-band +range (1–7 GHz). The GSMA estimates that mid- +band 5G spectrum will drive an increase of +more than $610 billion in global GDP in 2030, +almost 65% of the overall socio-economic value +generated by 5G. In Southeast Asia, 5G mid- +bands will boost annual GDP by $35 billion by +2030, heavily driven by the large Indonesian +market, which will account for 41% of this +increment. + +To secure these benefits, markets will need an +average of 2 GHz of mid-band spectrum during +this decade. In Indonesia, just 360 MHz of mid- +band spectrum is currently assigned for mobile +services. A clear spectrum roadmap setting +out the strategy and actions to make spectrum +available over the next few years will support + +the long-term growth of 5G and its full socio- +economic benefits for citizens and enterprises +across all sectors of the economy. + +The 5G era promises to unlock many new use +cases across different industries and accelerate +economic growth. To realise this, it is essential +to build on current plans by prioritising the +following actions for 5G development: + +— Refarm and auction the 2.6 GHz band for +IMT/5G in early 2025 following the expiry +of current satellite broadcasting licences +on 1 January 2025. The 2.6 GHz band should +be auctioned together with the +700 MHz spectrum. Reserve prices should +be set conservatively to allow mobile +operators to acquire sufficient spectrum +for high-speed 5G broadband services. + +1. + + Refer to https://indonesiabusinesspost.com/risks-opportunities/gsma-warns-indonesia-of-potential-losses-urging-for-5g-spectrum-price-review/ + +5 / 25 + + — Accelerate the initial release of 200 to 300 MHz +of the 3.5 GHz band (from 3.4 GHz to 3.7 GHz), +especially in urban areas, including greater +Jakarta, Surabaya, Bandung and Medan, where +demand is currently highest. + +• + +• + + For 3.5 GHz, an unnecessarily large guard +band between mobile and fixed satellite +services (FSS) should be avoided. Instead, +appropriate coexistence measures, such +as site shielding, LNB replacement and +upgrading FSS receiver filters, can be +implemented to allow sufficient spectrum +for 5G services. + + In December 2024, the government +proposed the 3.5 GHz band as essential +for mobile broadband in the 2025–2029 +Strategic Plan. The plan emphasised that +each operator would need at least +100 MHz of mid-band spectrum to meet +the 100 Mbps speed quality target.2 +At least 80 MHz in the 3.3–3.4 GHz band +is cleared and should be auctioned earlier +if possible. + +— Work towards making at least 2 GHz3 of +mid-band spectrum available for IMT/5G +by developing a spectrum roadmap for +2025–2030, considering future IMT spectrum +supply, including the 4.8 GHz and upper +6 GHz bands. + +— For upcoming auctions of new spectrum + +bands, reserve prices should be set +conservatively below estimates of market +value. This will allow room for price discovery +and reduce the risk of unsold spectrum. +Incentives in the form of reduced spectrum +payments in exchange for investment and +network commitments by operators should +also be considered. + +— Review the current formula for annual + +spectrum fees to provide the right incentives for +efficient spectrum use. Avoid disproportionate +increases in costs that are not aligned with +evolving market conditions. + +2. + + Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 4-5 + +3. Refer to www.gsma.com/spectrum/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/5G-Mid-Band-Spectrum-Needs-Vision-2030.pdf + +6 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + + ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + +1. Introduction + +7 / 25 +7 / 25 + + Communications, connectivity and digitisation +are central to achieving higher productivity +and broader social and economic inclusion of +Indonesia’s broadly distributed and diverse +population. Devising effective pro-growth, +pro-inclusion communications and digitisation +policies will be key to Indonesia’s success in the +new global economic environment. + +Digital services, underpinned by high-speed, +high-performance networks, are set to become +more integral to the Indonesian economy and +society. Digital transformation is rapidly occurring +in many sectors of the economy. The 5G era will +help accelerate this process and boost economic +growth in the country in the years ahead. + +The International Telecommunication Union +(ITU) World Radiocommunication Conference +2023 (WRC-23) completed the harmonisation +of the 3.5 GHz band to deploy 5G services and +identified additional mid-band spectrum in 6 GHz + +for future expansion towards 2030. Spectrum +harmonisation is essential because it ensures +stronger mobile connectivity while achieving +economies of scale. + +Increasing smartphone adoption and video +usage have driven mobile data traffic growth +over the last decade. This trend is set to continue +in the 5G era with more immersive media-rich +services, new online gaming technologies and +extended reality (XR) applications. 5G has been +the fastest mobile generation rollout, surpassing +2.1 connections by the end of 2024.4 As of +September 2024, 311 operators in 122 markets +have launched commercial 5G services.5 + +This report looks closer at the 5G spectrum +planning state in Indonesia. It discusses the +key issues and challenges in securing sufficient +spectrum resources for 5G, particularly +in the mid-bands. It then provides some +recommendations on the way forward. + +1.1 The Indonesia mobile market + +High-bandwidth internet connectivity +is increasingly important for enhancing +productivity, social welfare, and well-being. +It also supports Indonesia’s leading +entrepreneurial and technology scene.6 + +In many emerging markets, where fibre +penetration is typically low, there tends to be +a greater reliance on wireless technology – +both mobile and fixed wireless – to meet the + +growing demand for affordable and expandable +connectivity. As of the end of 2024, mobile +broadband penetration in Indonesia stood +at 121 per 100 inhabitants, compared to fixed +broadband penetration of 5.3 per 100 inhabitants +(or 20.5 per 100 households).7 4G network +coverage was 98% of the national population. +However, it is estimated that 11% of populated +areas remain unserved as of 2023, with 12,548 +villages not covered by 4G.8 + +4. + + Source: GSMA Intelligence + +5. + + Source: GSMA Intelligence. 5G in Context, Q3 2024. + +6. + +7. + +8. + + Source: Bain & Co, Navigating High Winds: Southeast Asia Outlook 2024:2034, 1 August 2024. Available at www.bain.com/globalassets/noindex/2024/bain_report_ +navigating_high_winds_southeast_asia_outlook_2024_34.pdf page 16 + +Source: GSMA Intelligence. + + Refer to Dr Denny Setiawan, MCI, Country Case Study: Spectrum Pricing Methodology and Mechanisms in Indonesia, 10th APAC Spectrum Management Conference, +Jakarta, 23-24 April 2024, page 2 + +8 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS Figure 2 +Competitiveness of access penetration and affordability of Indonesia’s mobile and +fixed broadband services + +Mobile broadband + +Access +4G+5G penetration +(% of population, 2023, +TeleGeography) + +Affordability +Mobile broadband basket +(% of GNI per capita, +2022, ITU) + +Fixed broadband + +Access +Fixed broadband +penetration (% of +households, 2023, +TeleGeography) + +Affordability +Fixed broadband basket +(% of GNI per capita, +2022, ITU) + +164 0.2 + +0.3 + +0.4 + +88 + +93 + +123 + +1.4 + +143 + +0.3 + +Singapore + +Brunei + +Vietnam + +Thailand + +Malaysia + +112 0.6 + +110 1.2 + +79 + +55 + +54 + +2.6 + +3.4 + +2.5 + +94 + +2.0 + +Philippines + +28 + +113 4th + +1.1 + +5th + +Indonesia + +19 + +7th + +2.3 + +2.1 + +Cambodia + +Lao PDR + +16 + +13 + +99 + +53 + +45 + +11.3 + +6.1 + +6th + +11.6 + +7.2 + +3.1 + +Myanmar + +9 + +15.3 + +Singapore + +Brunei + +Vietnam + +Thailand + +Malaysia + +Philippines + +Indonesia + +Cambodia + +Lao PDR + +Myanmar + +Source: World Bank Group Study (Aug 2024), ITU Datahub + +Indonesia’s broadband infrastructure lags behind +many Southeast Asia counterparts in terms of +access and affordability. In ASEAN, Indonesia +is ranked 4th for mobile broadband access +compared to 7th for fixed broadband. Regarding +affordability, mobile and fixed broadband services +are mid-ranked among ASEAN countries.9 + +The Indonesian mobile market comprises the +following main players as of 2024. + +— Telkomsel, the largest mobile operator by + +subscriber base, has around 45% market share. + +— Indosat Ooredoo Hutchison was formed in +January 2022 following a merger between +Indosat Ooredoo and 3 (Hutchison). The two +entities have a combined market share of +around 28%. + +— XL Axiata has a market share of around + +16%, while Smartfren has a market share of +around 11%. On 11 December 2024, the two +operators announced a proposed merger + +to create a stronger local player to drive +investments in digital infrastructure, expand +service coverage, and foster innovation.10 +The proposed merger has been conditionally +approved by the Ministry of Communication +and Digital Affairs.11 + +In Indonesia, 5G rollout is progressing, with +commercial services launched by Telkomsel, +Indosat Ooredoo and XL Axiata since 2021, utilising +existing spectrum holdings in the 1800 MHz, +2.1 GHz and 2.3 GHz bands. As of the end of +2024, 5G networks covered 26.3% of Indonesia’s +population, or around 15.7 million 5G connections. + +Currently, 452 MHz of mobile spectrum is assigned +in Indonesia, as shown below. In the mid-band +range, only 360 MHz across the 1800 MHz, 2.1 GHz +and 2.3 GHz bands has been assigned, compared +to an average of 850 MHz in the Asia-Pacific +region today. Therefore, there is a clear need for +more mid-band spectrum to be made available +in the country as soon as possible to support the +development of high-speed 5G services. + +9. + + Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 9-10 + +10. Refer to www.xlaxiata.co.id/en/news/xl-axiata-and-smartfren-announce-idr-104-trillion + +11. Refer to https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20250307150750-37-616648/meutya-hafidz-restui-merger-xl-dan-smartfren-tapi-ada-syaratnya + +9 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS Table 1 +Current IMT spectrum assigned in Indonesia + +Type of spectrum + +Bandwidth assigned + +Bands + +Low band (sub-1 GHz) + +92 MHz + +850 MHz, 900 MHz + +Mid-band (1–7 GHz) + +360 MHz + +1800 MHz, 2.1 GHz, 2.3 GHz + +High band (above 24 GHz) + +— + +— + +Source: GSMA, APT + +Given the lack of spectrum, Indonesian mobile +operators have refarmed existing IMT spectrum +holdings from 3G services to 4G and 5G. Such +moves have already accelerated the switch-off +of legacy 2G and 3G services, with XL Axiata +switching off 3G services at the end of March +2022.12 Indosat Ooredoo Hutchison (IOH) +switched off 3G services at the end of 2022, +as did Telkomsel in May 2023. + +Subject to the release of adequate mobile +spectrum, the pace of 5G deployment and +adoption is forecast to grow over the next three +years. By 2027, the number of 5G connections +is forecast to reach 70 million, with 5G networks +covering 59% of the population.13 While 4G will +continue to account for most mobile connections, +the share of 4G connections will begin to decline +from 2024 onward. + +Figure 3 +Connections by technology in Indonesia + +2024 + +4.4% + +3.6% + +2030 + +0.3% + +32.0% + +67.7% + +92.0% + +2G + +4G + +5G + +Source: GSMA Intelligence + +In Indonesia, total mobile data traffic has grown +almost four-fold over 2019–2024, reaching +60.5 exabytes in 2024.14 The average monthly +mobile data per connection is forecast to increase +from 14.9 GB in 2024 to 41.5 GB in 2030.15 + +At the same time, 5G enterprise use cases are +also emerging across different industrial verticals, +which will drive growth in cellular IoT connections. + +Across the Asia Pacific, operators use the scale +and utility of mobile networks and services to +facilitate innovative digital solutions for large +and small enterprises in line with Industry 4.0 +objectives. In particular, 5G and IoT will play key +roles in implementing digital transformation +projects across different industries, further driving +demand for 5G connectivity and economic growth +for the rest of the decade. + +12. Refer to https://newsbeezer.com/indonesiaeng/xl-to-switch-off-all-3g-signals-at-the-end-of-march-2022-all/ + +13. Source: GSMA Intelligence. + +14. Source: GSMA Intelligence. + +15. Source: GSMA Intelligence. + +10 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS 1.2 A spectrum roadmap for 5G + +As with all previous generations of mobile services, the road to 5G in each country starts with the +release of spectrum to support the network rollout. A typical spectrum roadmap, as illustrated below, +involves the following steps.16 + +Figure 4 +Spectrum roadmap and steps + +1 + +Identification +of spectrum 2 - Finally, we continue to scale Roku Ads Manager, our robust self-serve platform for small and medium-sized -businesses (SMBs) and performance advertisers. With platform partnerships such as Spaceback and the -availability of low-cost generative AI video tools, creating high-quality assets for TV has never been more -accessible. Our objective is to minimize friction for SMBs while diversifying Roku demand. Today, with approved -creative, an advertiser can move their performance-driven campaigns from “create campaign” to “publish” in -under five minutes. - -Just minutes from “create campaign” to “publish” on Roku Ads Manager - -For example, LolaVie, Jennifer Aniston’s haircare brand, selected Roku as its CTV partner for its first TV ad -campaign to expand reach, drive web traffic, and increase retail sales at Ulta Beauty. By leveraging Roku Ads -Manager, the brand executed its “Hair People” campaign, contributing to a 40% lift in sales and a 53% YoY -increase in new customers as part of its overall marketing strategy. - -In 2025, we enhanced our comprehensive advertising solutions to provide partners with greater flexibility in -how they buy Roku Media, whether via direct insertion order (IO), a preferred DSP partner, or our self-serve -platform. This versatility allows us to serve the full spectrum of advertisers from global enterprises to digital -growth marketers. Looking ahead, we remain committed to building the industry’s most open and performant -CTV ad platform. We will continue to deepen integrations while launching innovative ad products that leverage -the unique power of our Home Screen. Furthermore, we are investing in Roku Ads Manager to capture a vast -opportunity, with SMBs estimated to spend more than $600 billion4 on advertising. We expect SMBs to follow -the trend of enterprises shifting budgets to CTV, to combine the visual impact of television with the performance -of digital. With video production costs declining, our market-leading engagement expanding, and the ability to -launch a campaign in minutes, Roku Ads Manager is uniquely positioned to lead this transition. - -Streaming Services Distribution Activities -Streaming services distribution activities in Q4 were driven primarily by Premium Subscriptions and our -acquisition of Frndly TV®. Throughout 2025, we worked to improve content discovery by upleveling -subscriptions in features such as the Content Row, Live TV, and Sports, and now the Roku Experience drives -more than half of all subscription sign-ups. - -Q4 marked our biggest quarter ever for Premium Subscriptions net adds, benefiting from holiday promotions -and our improvements to the Roku Experience. In October, we expanded Premium Subscriptions to Mexico, -initially launching with nine leading SVOD partners. We have since grown the offering to 13 partners, with -additional launches planned this year. Looking to 2026, building on the successful addition of HBO Max to -Premium Subscriptions, we expect to add more tier-one partners. Additionally, we plan to add more great -entertainment to Howdy™, the owned-and-operated SVOD service we launched in 2025, and take it to more - -4 2025 Small Business Advertising Trends Report By Intuit SMB MediaLabs - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +Spectrum +clearance 3 - streaming platforms. We also expect to roll out bundles in Premium Subscriptions this year. In Mexico, we -anticipate the FIFA World Cup 2026™ to be a driver of Premium Subscriptions, and we will continue expanding -into additional international markets. +Technology definition +and restrictions + +Identification of spectrum +Spectrum is essential for the provi- +sion of mobile services, and 5G +needs significant amounts of new +harmonised spectrum.17 The first +step involves a planning process that +considers the outcomes of interna- +tional and regional harmonisation +decisions. Consultations provide a +forum for governments and industry +stakeholders to share views and +examine available options. Where +competing demands arise, a +cost-benefit analysis should also be +conducted to assess the impacts of +proposed changes in spectrum +allocation, ensure efficient use of +scarce spectrum and achieve +optimal outcomes for society.18 + +Spectrum clearance +Approaches to clearing +spectrum depend on factors +such as the density of use, the +ease of moving incumbents to +alternative frequency bands or +alternative technologies and the +impact on services and users. +In some cases, geographic +sharing with adequate +mitigation measures will address +interference concerns. + +Technology definition +and restrictions +Technical licence obligations +should be clearly defined, along +with conditions of use and the +amount and geographic +availability of the spectrum. In +some cases, it may only be +necessary to realign band +assignments to provide +contiguous frequencies and +maximise spectrum efficiency +for mobile use. + +4 + +Spectrum +valuation + +5 + +Award +design + +6 + +Award +implementation + +Spectrum valuation +This step involves assessing the +value of spectrum guides upfront, +as well as annual fees. There are +different valuation approaches, +including benchmarking and +modelling analysis, and both +methods should be used to +improve accuracy and capture +local market factors. Costs related +to licensing obligations should be +considered when setting prices for +spectrum. + +Award design +There are three main approaches +to awarding spectrum: +auctions, beauty contests and +direct award.19 The approach +adopted, and associated licence +obligations, must consider policy +objectives, available spectrum +and market specifics (for +example, the number of MNOs +or current spectrum holdings). +Depending on the availability +timeline of different frequency +bands and award design, it may +be appropriate to have a single +multiband award or several +separate ones. + +Award implementation +The final step is the actual +award. This will normally be +underpinned by documentation +that provides all the necessary +details of the award process, +spectrum on offer, licence +obligations and other essential +information for potential +licensees. + +16. Refer to GSMA. Roadmaps for awarding 5G spectrum in the APAC region. April 2022. www.gsma.com/spectrum/resources/5g-spectrum-in-the-apac-region- + +roadmaps-for-success/. + +17. The key frequency bands to prioritise for 5G are outlined in section 1.3. + +18. + + Refer to GSMA. Maximising the socio-economic value of spectrum. A best practice guide for the cost-benefit analysis of 5G spectrum assignment. January 2022. +www.gsma.com/spectrum/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/mobile-spectrum-maximising-socio-economic-value.pdf. + +19. Refer to GSMA auction best practice position www.gsma.com/spectrum/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Auction-Best-Practice.pdf. + +11 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS 1.3 The key role of mid-band spectrum for 5G + +Mid-band spectrum resources include both lower +mid-bands (i.e. 1500 MHz, 1800 MHz, 2.1 GHz, +2.3 GHz and 2.6 GHz) and upper mid-bands (i.e. +3.3–4.2 GHz, 4.5–5.0 GHz and 5.925–7.125 GHz). +To launch 5G services that are consistent with the +ITU’s IMT-2020 requirements,22 each operator +needs access to at least 100 MHz of contiguous +mid-band spectrum for initial service launch. +As adoption grows, more mid-band spectrum +will be required. + +To get the most out of 5G, spectrum is needed +across low, mid- and high bands to deliver +widespread coverage and support all use cases. +Mid-band frequencies are especially crucial +because they offer the balance of capacity and +coverage that enables mobile networks to +provide reliable performance that meets the +ITU IMT-2020 requirements20 across densely +populated urban areas. + +New 5G use cases from enhanced mobile +broadband (eMBB), fixed wireless access (FWA), +and enterprise and Industry 4.0 applications will +enable digital transformation and drive economic +growth in Indonesia. Over 2024–2030, 5G +is forecast to contribute more than $41 bn +(IDR 650 tn) in GDP to the Indonesian economy. +By 2030, 5G will add 0.6% to Indonesia’s GDP, +representing over $11 bn (IDR 172 tn) annually.21 + +Figure 5 +Mid-band spectrum + +1.8 GHz +1.7/1.8 GHz + +2.3 GHz +2.3–2.4 GHz + +1.5 GHz +1.4–1.5 GHz + +2.1 GHz +1.9/2.1 GHz + +2.6 GHz +2.5–2.7 GHz + +Lower 3.5 GHz +3.3–3.8 GHz + +4.8 GHz +4.8–5 GHz + +Upper 6 GHz +6.4–7.1 GHz + +AWS +1.7/2.1 GHz + +PCS +1.8/1.9 GHz + +Source: GSMA Intelligence + +Upper 3.5 GHz +3.8–4.2 GHz + +Lower 6 GHz +5.9–6.4 GHz + +It is estimated that MNOs will need an average of +2 GHz of mid-bands during this decade.23 +Research by GSMAi on the socio-economic +benefits of mid-band 5G services indicates that +mid-band 5G spectrum will drive an increase of +more than $610 billion in global GDP in 2030, + +accounting for almost 65% of the overall socio- +economic value generated by 5G.24 In Southeast +Asia, 5G mid-band services will generate an +additional GDP contribution of $35 billion (which +represents 0.64% of GDP), with Indonesia +accounting for 41% of this increment. + +20. Refer to ITU. Minimum requirements related to technical performance for IMT-2020 radio interface(s). Report ITU-R M.2410-0 , November 2017. + +https://www.itu.int/pub/R-REP-M.2410-2017 + +21. GSMA. Sustainable spectrum pricing to boost Indonesia’s digital economy, November 2023. https://www.gsma.com/connectivity-for-good/spectrum/wp-content/ + +uploads/2023/11/GSMA_Sustainable-spectrum-pricing-to-boost-Indonesias-digital-economy.pdf + +22. + + User experience of 100 Mbps DL, 50 Mbps UL rates. + +23. GSMA. (8 July 2021). 5G Mid-Band Spectrum Needs: Vision 2030. + +24. GSMA. (February 2022). The Socio-Economic Benefits of Mid-Band 5G Services. + +12 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS 2.6 GHz and 3.5 GHz bands as the springboard for 5G + +The 3.5 GHz band (3.3–4.2 GHz) n77/78, which +is widely harmonised for 5G, has been the basis +for the first phase of 5G rollouts in many markets. +To date, 3.5 GHz accounts for most global +5G network launches,25 driving the wider +ecosystem26, device diversity and competition. +It has been deployed for eMBB, enabling faster +data speeds and greater capacity required in +urban, densely populated areas and for FWA in +suburban and rural areas where fixed broadband +availability tends to be limited. + +The 2.6 GHz band, particularly the n41 Time +Division Duplexing (TDD) version, has been +widely deployed for 5G, including in China, the + +Philippines, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Thailand, +Vietnam and the United States. According to the +GSA, 5G deployments in the 2.6 GHz band are +the equal fourth most supported globally. Of the +announced 5G device models supporting key 5G +spectrum bands, 2.6 GHz (n41) had the second +strongest ecosystem after 3.5 GHz with over +1,800 device models.27 + +According to GSMAi, 5G deployments in the +2.6 GHz band are the fourth most supported +globally, and of the announced 5G device models +supporting key 5G spectrum bands, 2.6 GHz +(n41) had the second strongest ecosystem after +3.5 GHz with more than 1,800 device models. + +Figure 6 +5G network launches by spectrum frequency (up to Q3 2024) + +High band +(>24 GHz) + +Mid-band +(1-7 GHz) + +Low band +(<1 GHz) + +39 GHz + +28 GHz + +26 GHz + +4.8 GHz + +3.5 GHz + +2.6 GHz + +2.3 GHz + +2.1 GHz + +1900 MHz + +1800 MHz -Our Sports Experience remains a top content discovery feature, driving viewer engagement and monetization -across both ads and subscriptions. Building on enhancements made throughout 2025, such as live scores and -game reminders, we integrated YouTube TV into the Sports Experience in Q4. This addition expanded our -growing roster of partners, which includes DAZN Live Sports, FOX One, Paramount+, Peacock, Spectrum TV, and -Xfinity Stream, giving viewers streamlined access to their favorite games, highlights, and scores across top -leagues. In Q4, subscription sign-ups driven by Roku’s Sports discovery features5 increased nearly 75% YoY. We -launched the Sports Experience in Mexico in Q4 and followed with a launch in Brazil in January. We are already -engaging sports fans around the Milan Cortina 2026 Olympic Winter Games and look forward to the FIFA World -Cup 2026™ this summer. +1700/2100 MHz -The NBC Winter Olympics Experience on the Roku platform +1400 MHz -Devices -Devices revenue was $171 million in Q4, up 3% YoY, and $592 million for the full year, flat YoY. Q4 Devices -revenue and gross profit were slightly above our outlook, due to sales of both players and Roku-made TVs. As a -result, Q4 Devices gross margin was (23)%, and full year Devices gross margin was (14)%. +900 MHz -During Q4, we launched Hiro™, a new Roku-made TV (designed, made, and sold by Roku) that enables us to -offer consumers the Roku TV OS at a new, more accessible price. This launch expands our Roku TV program, -which includes a broad mix of brands, feature sets, and price points. Hiro Roku TVs are available exclusively at -Target, further diversifying our retail distribution. Earlier in 2025, we introduced a refreshed lineup of our Pro, -Plus, and Select Series Roku-made TVs featuring enhanced picture and sound quality. We also launched a new -form factor, with the Aurzen Roku TV Smart Projector D1R Cube and the Vankyo Roku TV Smart Projector. In -addition, we launched two new streaming players, the Roku® Streaming Stick® and Roku Streaming Stick Plus, +850 MHz -5 Sports discovery includes all ways viewers can find sports across the Roku platform, including the Sports Experience, the Content -Row, Search results, and promotions such as NFL Zone in our Home Screen Menu. +800 MHz -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +700 MHz + +600 MHz + +Not reported + +15 + +26 + +11 + +28 + +32 + +20 + +4 4 - designed for portability and power-efficiency. These players are 35% smaller than other brands and powered -directly by the TV (no separate power adaptor needed). - -Outside the U.S., we brought the Roku Streaming Stick and Roku Streaming Stick Plus to Canada, Mexico, Brazil, -and our other markets in Latin America. We also introduced Roku-made TVs to Canada, available exclusively at -Best Buy, including QLED 4K models ranging from 50” to 75”, as well as smaller 4K and HD sizes, all featuring a -premium design and our easy-to-use interface. Throughout 2025, we continued to deepen the availability of -Roku TV models in key markets, announcing new partner Roku TV models with Hyundai in Mexico, Colombia, -and Peru; Noblex in Argentina; Finlandek in Colombia; and Vitado in the U.K. Globally, we work with 45 TV OEM -brands across 17 countries. - -Looking to 2026, we are committed to growing our scale and strengthening our market leadership through our -diversified device strategy of streaming players, Roku TV models, Roku-made TVs, and Roku TV smart projectors. -We are growing our partnerships with TV OEMs and have expanded licensing agreements with many of our -largest and long-term Roku TV partners. We continue to expand our retail distribution and remain an important -part of retailers’ TV assortment because consumers love Roku. - -Driven by our powerful brand and strategic partnerships with OEMs and retail distributors, we expect to -continue growing Streaming Households in all our locations. We remain on track to achieve a significant -milestone of 100 million Streaming Households globally in 2026. - -Outlook -Before providing outlook, we want to take a moment to reflect on our execution over the past several years. - -In 2023, our priority was to right-size our cost structure and reach Adjusted EBITDA breakeven by 2024. We -achieved that goal a full year ahead of schedule. This early progress positioned us in 2024 to reinvest in our key -Platform monetization initiatives, including third-party demand integration, subscriptions, and our Home -Screen. Importantly, we increased investment in these strategic areas while continuing to moderate overall -operating expense (OpEx) growth. These investments are now beginning to inflect and contributed meaningfully -to Platform revenue growth in 2025. - -On the profitability front, we previously set a goal to achieve positive operating income in 2026. We reached -that milestone in the second half of 2025 and were nearly breakeven for the full year. Net income was positive -for the year, Adjusted EBITDA margin expanded by 255 basis points, and stock-based compensation declined -YoY. - -In addition, we announced a $400 million stock repurchase program in the third quarter and have already -repurchased approximately $150 million. Combined with the net share settlement program we implemented in -2023, we see a clear path to fully offset dilution in 2026. Together, these actions reflect our continued focus on -disciplined capital allocation and align with our north star of maximizing Free Cash Flow per share. - -For Q1, we anticipate Platform revenue growing more than 21% YoY and Devices revenue down mid-single digits -YoY. We expect this to result in Total net revenue of $1.200 billion, up roughly 18% YoY, with Total gross profit -of $530 million and Adjusted EBITDA of $130 million. - -For full year 2026, we anticipate Platform revenue to grow 18% YoY to $4.890 billion, with gross margin between -51% to 52%. We expect Devices revenue to grow low-single digits YoY to $610 million, with gross margin in the -negative mid-teens, roughly in line with 2025. We expect Total net revenue of $5.500 billion, Total gross profit -of $2.435 billion, and Adjusted EBITDA of $635 million – resulting in an Adjusted EBITDA margin improvement -of 267 basis points. We are maintaining our focus on operational discipline, while continuing to invest in -Platform growth. For OpEx, we expect it to be more heavily weighted in the second half of the year due to - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +1 5 - shifting retail distribution spend, but we still anticipate mid-single-digit YoY growth for the full year. We are -executing against our strategy and enter 2026 well-positioned to drive sustained double-digit Platform growth -and improving profitability. +1 -Happy Streaming™! +2 -Anthony Wood, Founder and CEO, and Dan Jedda, CFO and COO +5 -Conference Call Webcast – February 12, 2026, at 2 p.m. PT -The Company will host a webcast of its conference call to discuss the Q4 2025 results at 2 p.m. Pacific Time / 5 -p.m. Eastern Time on February 12, 2026. Participants may access the live webcast in listen-only mode on the -Roku investor relations website at www.roku.com/investor. An archived webcast of the conference call will also -be available at www.roku.com/investor after the call. +3 -About Roku, Inc. -Roku pioneered streaming on TV. We connect users to the content they love, enable content publishers to build -and monetize large audiences, and provide advertisers with unique capabilities to engage consumers. Roku- -made TVs, Roku TV™ models, Roku streaming players, and TV-related audio devices are available in various -countries around the world through direct retail sales and/or licensing arrangements with TV OEM brands. Roku -Smart Home products are sold exclusively in the United States. Roku also operates The Roku Channel, the home -of free and premium entertainment with exclusive access to Roku Originals, and the #2 app on our platform in -the U.S. by streaming hours. The Roku Channel is available in the United States, Canada, Mexico, and the United -Kingdom. Roku is headquartered in San Jose, Calif., U.S.A. +67 -ROKU, ROKU TV, the Roku logo, STREAMING STICK, HIRO, HOWDY, FRNDLY TV, “HAPPY STREAMING” and other -trade names, trademarks or service marks of Roku appearing in this shareholder letter are the property of Roku -or its affiliates. Trade names, trademarks and service marks of other companies appearing in this shareholder -letter are the property of their respective holders. +9 -Investor Relations -Conrad Grodd -cgrodd@roku.com +162 -Media -Kelli Raftery -kraftery@roku.com +233 -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +Source: GSMA Intelligence. -6 +Note: Figures refer to launches, not individual operators. A range of operators have launched their 5G networks on more than one frequency. If an operator has +launched both mobile and fixed wireless 5G networks, it is counted twice. 3.5 GHz band = 3.3–3.8 GHz range. 2.6 GHz band = 2.5–2.6 GHz range. - Use of Non-GAAP Measures -In addition to financial information prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the -United States (GAAP), this shareholder letter includes certain non-GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP -measures include Adjusted EBITDA and Free Cash Flow (FCF). In order for our investors to be better able to -compare our current results with those of previous periods, we have included a reconciliation of GAAP to non- -GAAP financial measures in the tables at the end of this letter. The Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation excludes total -other income, net, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation and amortization, restructuring charges, -and income tax (benefit) expense from the net income (loss) of the period, and the FCF reconciliation excludes -capital expenditures and effects of exchange rates from the cash flow from operations of the period, in each -case where applicable. We believe these non-GAAP financial measures are useful as a supplement in evaluating -our ongoing operational performance and enhancing an overall understanding of our past financial -performance. However, these non-GAAP financial measures have limitations, and should not be considered in -isolation or as a substitute for our GAAP financial information. - -Forward-Looking Statements -This shareholder letter contains “forward-looking” statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws. -Statements contained herein that are not historical facts are considered forward-looking statements and can -be identified by terms such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “continue,” “could,” “estimate,” “expect,” “may,” "plan,” -“seek,” “should,” “will,” “would” or similar expressions and the negatives of those terms. Such forward-looking -statements are based on our current beliefs, assumptions and information available to us and involve known -and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause our actual results to be materially different -from any future results expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. These statements include -those related to the growth of our scale; our ability to leverage the Roku Experience and related product -launches to drive growth; our focus on enhancing our subscription capabilities and our expectations regarding -increased Premium Subscriptions and international expansion; the growth and performance of The Roku -Channel; our innovation efforts; our initiatives to grow and sustain Platform revenue, Adjusted EBITDA, and Free -Cash Flow, including through our stock repurchase program; our expected timing of Home Screen -enhancements and their impact; our ability to expand our performance and measurement capabilities through -strategic partnerships and innovative products; our ability to achieve a milestone of 100 million Streaming -Households globally in 2026; our advertising initiatives, including Roku Ads Manager and the deepening of our -integrations with third-party DSPs; our expectations regarding the growth in the portion of video impressions -executed programmatically; our confidence in our strategy and long-term growth; our expectations regarding -our diversified device strategy; our plans to expand and diversify distribution for our devices and grow -partnerships with TV OEMs; our focus on our strategic priorities and initiatives; our financial outlook for the first -quarter of 2026 and full year 2026 and our qualitative color on our business in 2026 and beyond; the impact of -our monetization initiatives, including our path to improving profitability; our dilution offset initiatives; and our -overall business trajectory. Important risks and factors related to such statements are contained in the reports -we have filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our most recent Annual Report on Form -10-K and Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q. Except as required by law, we assume no obligation to update these -forward-looking statements as the result of new information, future events or otherwise. - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +25. Excluding frequencies not reported.. -7 +26. Of the announced 5G device models supporting key 5G spectrum bands (end March 2024), n78 (3.4-3.8 GHz) 5G devices had the strongest ecosystem with nearly - ROKU, INC. +2,000 device models while n77 (3.3-4.2 GHz) had over 1,600 device models and was the fourth strongest. n41 (2.6 GHz) had the second strongest ecosystem with over +1,800 device models. Refer to GSA, 5G Market Snapshot, May 2024, page 4. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS -(in thousands, except per share data) -(unaudited) +27. Refer to GSA, 5G Market Snapshot, May 2024, page 4 -Three Months Ended December 31, +13 / 25 -2025 +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS -2024 +2. Progress on Indonesia’s +spectrum plan for 5G -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 +14 / 25 +14 / 25 -Net revenue: -Platform -Devices +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS 2.1 Indonesia’s 5G spectrum planning -Total net revenue +The new Ministry of Communication and +Digital Affairs (Komdigi) is responsible for +telecommunications policy, including spectrum +management. Inside Komdigi, the Directorate -Cost of revenue: +General of Resources and Equipment for +Post and Information Technology (SDPPI) +regulates spectrum. -Platform (1) +Current IMT spectrum roadmap for Indonesia -Devices (1) +Indonesia’s provisional spectrum roadmap is +summarised below. The plan is for new spectrum +to be made available to support 5G deployment -Total cost of revenue +in the near term in the priority bands of 700 MHz, +2.6 GHz, 3.5 GHz and 26 GHz. -Gross profit (loss): -Platform -Devices +Figure 7 +Indonesia’s current provisional IMT spectrum roadmap -Total gross profit +Indonesia's broadband spectrum provisional roadmap (2025–2029) -Operating expenses: +Ministry of +Communication +& Digital Affairs -Research and development (1) +2025 -Sales and marketing (1) +2026 -General and administrative (1) -Total operating expenses +2027 -Income (loss) from operations -Other income, net: -Interest expense -Other income, net +2028 -Total other income, net +2029 -Income (loss) before income taxes -Income tax expense -Net income (loss) +MBB 3.5 GHz -Net income (loss) per share — basic -Net income (loss) per share — diluted +MBB 3.5 GHz -$ +MBB 3.5 GHz -1,223,954 $ -170,949 -1,394,903 +MBB 3.5 GHz -1,035,333 $ -165,714 -1,201,047 +– Issue ministerial -4,144,886 $ -592,365 -4,737,251 +regulation on the use +of the 3.5 GHz band. -577,272 -210,809 -788,081 +– Auction the 3.5 GHz -646,682 -(39,860) -606,822 +band. -184,646 -255,329 -100,874 -540,849 -65,973 +– Determine the PPP -(558) -26,294 -25,736 -91,709 -11,232 -80,477 $ +business partner as the +project management +team. -0.54 $ -0.53 $ +– Conduct a pilot project of +5G deployment in 3.5 GHz +in several locations, for +example, big cities with +high traffic. -475,400 -213,068 -688,468 +NTN -559,933 -(47,354) -512,579 +– Issue ministerial -185,407 -271,885 -94,412 -551,704 -(39,125) +regulation on the +use of radio frequency +spectrum for NTN in +the IMT-MSS frequency +band. -(666) -13,920 -13,254 -(25,871) -9,677 -(35,548) $ +WRC-27 -(0.24) $ -(0.24) $ +• Discuss the candidates -1,988,442 -674,385 -2,662,827 +for the IMT & NTN +frequency bands. -2,156,444 -(82,020) -2,074,424 +– Finalise the technical -729,477 -964,355 -386,216 -2,080,048 -(5,624) +– Issue ministerial -(1,906) -101,428 -99,522 -93,898 -5,537 -88,361 $ +decision on technical +guidelines for 5G FSS +coexistence in the +3.5 GHz band. -0.60 $ -0.59 $ +– Issue ministerial -$ +decision on the phased +refarming process in the +3.5 GHz band. -$ +– Finalise legal analysis +on the provision of the +3.5 GHz band for IMT. -$ +– Finalise financial -Weighted-average common shares outstanding — basic -Weighted-average common shares outstanding — diluted +analysis for financing +scheme option(s) for the +provision of the 3.5 GHz +band for 5G. -148,041 -152,290 +– Prepare a project -145,554 -145,554 +management team for +the migration of satellite +services from ext +C-Band and supervise +the phased deployment +of 5G in the 3.5 GHz +band. -147,154 -150,912 +assessment to mitigate +the impact on VSAT, +TT&C, and gateway +operations. -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +– Prepare an evaluation of +the phased deployment +of city-based 5G using +the 3.5 GHz band. -3,522,776 -590,122 -4,112,898 +MBB 2.6 GHz -1,636,816 -670,437 -2,307,253 +– Issue ministerial -1,885,960 -(80,315) -1,805,645 +regulation on the use of +the 2.6 GHz band. -720,145 -932,712 -370,955 -2,023,812 -(218,167) +– Auction the 2.6 GHz band. -(411) -98,620 -98,209 -(119,958) -9,428 -(129,386) +MBB 700 MHz & 26 GHz -(0.89) +– Auction the 700 MHz and -(0.89) +26 GHz bands. -144,630 +FWA 1.4 GHz & 3.3 GHz -144,630 +– Issue ministerial -8 +regulation on FWA in +the 1.4 GHz and 3.3 GHz +bands. - ROKU, INC. +– Determine the license +holders for FWA in the +1.4 GHz band. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS, CONTINUED -(in thousands, except per share data) -(unaudited) +RLAN lower 6 GHz (WiFi-7) -(1) Stock-based compensation was allocated as follows: +– Issue an amendment -Cost of revenue, platform -Cost of revenue, devices -Research and development -Sales and marketing -General and administrative -Total stock-based compensation +of PM 2/2023 on Class +License. -Three Months Ended December 31, +– Issue ministerial decision -2025 +on RLAN technical +standards. -2024 +– Commencement of 5G +network deployment +using the 3.5 GHz band +(Phase 1). -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 +MBB 3.5 GHz -$ +– Continue the -$ +deployment of 5G +network using the +3.5 GHz band (Phase 2). -246 $ -87 -33,500 -30,189 -21,982 -86,004 $ +MBB Upper 6 GHz -393 $ -172 -37,216 -37,203 -26,554 -101,538 $ +NTN -1,218 $ -270 -136,815 -127,382 -88,484 -354,169 $ +– Identify the Upper 6 GHz +band (6.425–7.125 GHz) +as Indonesia’s IMT band +at WRC-27. -1,455 -1,373 -146,673 -137,556 -97,605 -384,662 +– Issue ministerial -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +regulation on the use of +radio spectrum for NTN +in the IMT terrestrial +frequency band. -9 +5G private networks - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS -(in thousands, except par value data) -(unaudited) +– Assess the -Assets -Current assets: +implementation of +5G private networks +in limited areas. -Cash and cash equivalents -Short-term investments -Accounts receivable, net of allowances of $80,448 and $72,657 as of December 31, +– Evaluate the impact +of the provision of +spectrum frequency +from 2025 to 2029. -2025 and 2024, respectively +– Conduct a spectrum +demand analysis +to anticipate the +broadband services +needs for 2030 to 2034. -Inventories -Prepaid expenses and other current assets +Disclaimer: -Total current assets -Property and equipment, net -Operating lease right-of-use assets -Content assets, net -Intangible assets, net -Goodwill -Other non-current assets -Total Assets -Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity -Current liabilities: +This roadmap is a draft plan for the provision of spectrum +frequencies for broadband services and may be subject to +changes based on the circumstances encountered during +its implementation. -Accounts payable -Accrued liabilities -Deferred revenue, current portion +Constructive input from stakeholders is welcomed. -Total current liabilities +Source: SDPPI, Penataan Spektrum Frekuensi Radio Dinas Tetap & Bergerak Darat (DTBD) Capaian Tahun 2024 Untuk Dilanjutkan di Periode Tahun 2025-2029, 20 +December 2024 page 47. Translation by Retno W. Damajanti. -Deferred revenue, non-current portion -Operating lease liability, non-current portion -Other long-term liabilities -Total Liabilities -Stockholders’ Equity: +15 / 25 -Common stock, $0.0001 par value -Additional paid-in capital -Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) -Accumulated deficit +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS The spectrum auction for the 700 MHz and +26 GHz bands planned for completion by July +2024 has been delayed to 2025 due to a lack of +clarity on demand for these particular bands and +the ongoing merger talks between XL Axiata +and Smartfren.28 -Total stockholders’ equity -Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity +Komdigi is planning to include mid-band spectrum +in the 2.6 GHz band to be auctioned in 2025 +alongside the 700 MHz and 26 GHz bands. The +3.5 GHz band (3.4–3.7 GHz) is expected to be +further delayed until 2027.29 The remaining 80 MHz +of the 3.3–3.4 GHz band is still under consideration +and could be made available in 2025. -As of December 31, -2024 +In September 2024, the government highlighted +the importance of 3.5 GHz for mobile broadband +in the 2025–2029 Strategic Plan and the need to +ensure that each operator has at least 100 MHz of +mid-band spectrum to meet the 100 Mbps wireless +broadband speed target.30 The 3.4–3.7 GHz band +is prioritised for IMT implementation, and the use +of this band for Fixed-Satellite Service (FSS) in the +Extended C-band (downlink) is being phased out.31 +Two possible options are under consideration for +future 5G networks: either with a 100 MHz or +80 MHz guard band, as shown below.32 -2025 +Figure 8 +The state of the 3.5 GHz band: in the future -$ +3.3 GHz 3.312,5 GHz 3.4 GHz -1,587,068 $ -730,213 +3.7 GHz -2,160,236 -— +4.2 GHz -879,871 -114,642 -89,716 -3,401,510 -173,577 -260,341 -167,908 -50,207 -309,406 -70,534 -4,433,483 $ - -812,510 - -158,271 -103,146 -3,234,163 -213,690 -304,505 -237,321 -27,501 -161,519 -125,234 -4,303,933 - -158,640 $ -957,983 -120,912 -1,237,535 -28,848 -435,899 -73,256 -1,775,538 - -273,985 -852,799 -105,718 -1,232,502 -25,050 -512,706 -40,938 -1,811,196 - -$ - -$ +BWA -15 -4,145,485 -1,039 -(1,488,594) -2,657,945 -4,433,483 $ +IMT -15 -3,921,432 -(1,737) -(1,426,973) -2,492,737 -4,303,933 +SATELLITE -$ +Option 1 -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +Option 2 -10 +MNO 1: 80 MHz (3.32 – 3.4 GHz) +MNO 2: 100 MHz (3.4 – 2.5 GHz) +MNO 3: 100 MHz (3.5 – 3.6 GHz) +Guard band: 100 MHz - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS - (in thousands) -(unaudited) +MNO 1: 100 MHz (3.32 – 3.42 GHz) +MNO 2: 100 MHz (3.42 – 2.52 GHz) +MNO 3: 100 MHz (3.52 – 3.62 GHz) +Guard band: 80 MHz -Cash flows from operating activities: +Other spectrum bands which are the subject +of longer term planning by the SDPPI are +(i) L-Band (1427–1518 MHz) for supplementary +download (SDL) or TDD, (ii) upper 6 GHz +band (6.425–7.125 GHz recognising that -Net income (loss) -Adjustments to reconcile net income (loss) to net cash provided by operating activities: +7.025–7.125 GHz was already identified for IMT at +WRC-23) and (iii) 28 GHz band (still under study +for 5G local network implementation in limited +areas of the country). -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 +28. Refer to www.thejakartapost.com/business/2024/07/29/govt-delays-5g-spectrum-auction-as-telcos-see-little-demand.html. See also Arah Kebijakan dan -$ - -88,361 $ - -(129,386) - -Depreciation and amortization -Stock-based compensation expense -Amortization of right-of-use assets -Amortization and write-off of content assets -Foreign currency remeasurement losses -Change in fair value of strategic investment in convertible promissory notes -Change in fair value of contingent consideration -Impairment of assets -Provision for credit losses -Other items, net -Changes in operating assets and liabilities: -Accounts receivable -Inventories -Prepaid expenses and other current assets -Content assets and liabilities, net -Other non-current assets -Accounts payable -Accrued liabilities -Operating lease liabilities -Other long-term liabilities -Deferred revenue - -Net cash provided by operating activities - -Cash flows from investing activities: - -Purchases of property and equipment -Purchase of business, net of cash acquired -Purchases of short-term investments -Purchases of strategic investments -Repayments of convertible promissory notes -Net cash used in investing activities - -Cash flows from financing activities: - -Issuance costs related to credit agreement -Proceeds from equity issued under incentive plans -Taxes paid related to net share settlement of equity awards -Repurchases of common stock - -Net cash used in financing activities - -Net (decrease) increase in cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash -Effect of exchange rate changes on cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — beginning of period -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — end of period - -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter - -68,904 -354,169 -48,465 -223,230 -1,117 -(2,940) -2,301 -2,870 -2,439 -1,493 - -(63,464) -43,629 -2,249 -(184,457) -7,990 -(122,503) -87,621 -(80,493) -7,724 -(4,987) -483,718 - -(5,280) -(95,090) -(725,000) -(7,000) -50,000 -(782,370) +Strategi Pengembangan Pitalebar Indonesia Periode Tahun 2025-2029, November 2024. -— -34,734 -(164,850) -(149,982) -(280,098) -(578,750) -5,179 -2,160,639 -1,587,068 $ - -$ - -62,714 -384,662 -47,371 -229,340 -6,447 -(1,409) -— -29,118 -790 -(2,845) - -1,893 -(66,142) -(11,299) -(193,046) -(11,769) -(110,678) -38,385 -(63,835) -3,695 -4,039 -218,045 - -(5,061) -— -— -(20,000) -— -(25,061) +29. SDPPI, Penataan Spektrum Frekuensi Radio Dinas Tetap & Bergerak Darat (DTBD) Capaian Tahun 2024 Untuk Dilanjutkan di Periode Tahun 2025-2029, 20 December -(2,227) -9,380 -(96,356) -— -(89,203) -103,781 -(9,746) -2,066,604 -2,160,639 +2024 page 47 -11 +30. Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 4-5 . - ROKU, INC. -CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS, CONTINUED - (in thousands) -(unaudited) +31. -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at end of period: +Ibid, page 16 -Cash and cash equivalents -Restricted cash, current -Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash — end of period +32. Ibid, page 12 -Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information: +16 / 25 -Cash paid for interest +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS 2.2 Digital dividend, 700 MHz and -Income taxes paid (net of refunds)1: -Federal -State and local -Foreign -Total -Cash paid during the period for income taxes (prior to ASU 2023-09) -Supplemental disclosures of non-cash investing and financing activities: +changes to the applicable spectrum +management law -Non-cash contingent consideration for business combination -Unpaid portion of property and equipment purchases +In Indonesia, there were delays in securing the +release of the 700 MHz band (digital dividend) +after the switchover from analogue to digital +television. Following considerable internal +debate, the switchover was legislated in late +2020 by the Indonesian Parliament, with the +digital dividend spectrum in the 700 MHz band +cleared for assignment by late 2023. -Years Ended December 31, -2024 -2025 +The Omnibus Law, first passed in 2020, entailed +significant legislative changes to liberalise +Indonesia’s telecommunications sector and +support accelerating its digital economy – +especially by optimising spectrum use in the +5G era. While subject to constitutional +challenges, it was finally ratified in 2023. +Specifically, the Omnibus Law: -1,587,068 -— -1,587,068 $ +— Permits spectrum sharing and transfer among -2,160,236 -403 -2,160,639 +telecom operators. -1,055 $ +— Mandates the completion of the digital TV -460 +migration within two years of the enactment +of the Law, freeing up the 700 MHz band. -1,831 -5,726 -6,133 -13,690 - $ +— Provides clarification on payment of annual -65,815 $ -830 $ +spectrum fee. -19,406 +— Allows spectrum licensees to transfer -— -122 +spectrum rights to other network operators. -$ +While such changes are welcome, additional +reforms can further improve the spectrum +management framework in Indonesia. +For example, these can include: -$ +— Flexibility in the licence period term, which -$ +is currently fixed for 10 years. This should be +amended to provide a licence period of up to +15 years. A non-fixed longer period would give +flexibility in aligning spectrum band licence +period end-dates, as well as providing more +flexibility for future frequency band refarming. -$ +— Komdigi’s ability to terminate non- -$ +compliant frequency licences should also be +strengthened as it remains challenging for +spectrum to be returned to the government +for reallocation on time. -$ +— Creation of a spectrum relocation fund. Given +the continuing challenges of the spectrum +being returned to the government for prompt +reallocation, one approach that can be +considered is creating a fund to pay the costs +of spectrum re-organisation and refarming. +This could be modelled on France’s ‘Fond +de Réaménagement de Spectre’ (FRS)33 +or refarming fund, managed by Agence +Nationale des Fréquences (ANFR) or the +USA’s Spectrum Relocation Fund.34 The need +for such mechanisms is obvious, given the +proposed compensation to FSS users in the +C-band from the spectrum auction proceeds +with the refarming of the 3.5 GHz band to +IMT/5G use.35 -1 Individual jurisdictions equaling 5% or more of total income taxes paid (net of refunds) for the year ended December 31, 2025 include federal at $1.8 -million, New Jersey at $1.8 million, India at $1.7 million, United Kingdom at $1.1 million, Taiwan at $0.8 million, and Illinois at $0.7 million. +33. Refer to www.anfr.fr/planifier/le-fonds-de-reamenagement-du-spectre -Roku Q4 and Full Year 2025 Shareholder Letter +34. Refer to https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=(title:47%20section:928%20edition:prelim) -12 +35. Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 16 and 21-24 - NON-GAAP INFORMATION -(in thousands) -(unaudited) +17 / 25 -Reconciliation of Net Income (Loss) to Adjusted EBITDA: +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS -Net income (loss) -Total other income, net -Stock-based compensation -Depreciation and amortization -Restructuring charges (1) -Income tax expense -Adjusted EBITDA +3 Challenges and -Three Months Ended December 31, +recommendations for +Indonesia’s spectrum +roadmap -2025 +18 / 25 +18 / 25 -80,477 $ -(25,736) -86,004 -17,390 -— -11,232 -169,367 $ +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS Timely access to IMT spectrum, particularly in the mid-band range, is essential for 5G and +future 6G development in Indonesia. The key challenges to securing spectrum access for IMT +are technical and financial. Below, we discuss the key issues and recommendations to secure +sufficient spectrum for 5G services in Indonesia. + +3.1 Spectrum roadmap towards 2030 + +Assignment of the +700 MHz band + +Refarming of the 2.6 GHz band +for IMT services + +Following the successful analogue-to-digital +TV migration completed at the end of 2023, +additional harmonised spectrum below 1 GHz +should be made available via auction in 2025. + +Low-band spectrum is a cornerstone of digital +equality and a driver of broad and affordable +connectivity. Ensuring the full availability of +2x45 MHz of the 700 MHz band is particularly +beneficial as it will help in the provision of +affordable mobile broadband coverage in 3T +(foremost, remote and disadvantaged) and rural +areas of the country, including Sumatra, Sulawesi, +Papua and Kalimantan. It will also improve +deep in-building coverage in urban areas. It will +facilitate future voice services and migration to +Voice over LTE (VoLTE) or Voice over 5G New +Radio (VoNR). -2024 -(35,548) $ -(13,254) -101,538 -15,085 -— -9,677 -77,498 $ +The 2.6 GHz band in Indonesia is currently +under-utilised. Following the expiry of current +satellite broadcasting licences on 1 January 2025, +ensuring that the full band is refarmed for mobile +is essential. It is understood that Indonesia has +plans to migrate the DTH services operating in +the 2.6 GHz band to the Ku-band. + +The availability of the 2.6 GHz band in Indonesia, +especially using the full TDD band n41 across +2.5–2.69 GHz, would expand capacity in urban +centres, alleviate network congestion and improve +the quality of services. For example, the extensive +use of this band in Thailand, particularly in the +greater Bangkok area, is a key reason behind +Thailand’s successful 5G deployment. The 2.6 GHz +band was also successfully auctioned in Vietnam +and is forming a key part of market leader Viettel’s +5G national deployment.36 + +36. GSMA, Accelerating 5G in Vietnam: A Spectrum Roadmap for Success, November 2024 + +19 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS Securing the 3.5 GHz +band for 5G services + +Given the continued role of satellite in the +Indonesian archipelago, it is crucial to optimise +the use of the 3.5 GHz band for 5G, particularly +in major cities and industrial complexes in +Indonesia. Four satellites are currently utilising +C-band, including extended C-band range in +3.4–3.7 GHz, which pose significant challenges +to refarming for 5G. These are, namely: + +— BRIsat (C-band and Ku-band, expected + +end date in 2031). This satellite is used by +Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI) to connect its +nationwide ATM network.37 + +— Telkom-3S (C-band and Ku-band, expected + +end date 2032). + +— Telkom-4 (C-band and Ku-band, expected + +end date 2033). + +— Nusantara Satu (C-band and Ku-band, + +expected end date 2034). + +To free up 3.5 GHz for 5G before 2034 will likely +require a service migration plan and low-noise +block downconverter (LNB) replacement for +existing C-band FSS receivers. + +Even then, only an initial 200 to 300 MHz of +spectrum in 3.4–3.7 GHz could be made available +for IMT/5G services. Notably, the 3.3–3.4 GHz +band, which was previously used for broadband +wireless access, is now vacant. + +The government's proposal to allocate the +3.4–3.7 GHz range for future 5G networks marks +a positive step forward.38 However, the proposed +award in 2027 will place Indonesia behind its +ASEAN counterparts in terms of mid-band +spectrum supply and is likely to have negative +implications on 5G development. + +Post-2034, additional 3.5 GHz band spectrum +should become available if current C-band +satellite services are moved to higher satellite +bands. While the C-band continues to be +necessary, there is a global trend towards the use +of higher bands for satellite. Satellite operators +are rapidly expanding Ku- and Ka-bands capacity +by developing advanced satellite modulation +techniques. For example, the SATRIA-1 High- +Throughput Satellite, which utilises the Ka-band +and is designed to address the digital divide, was +successfully launched in late 2023 and has been +used commercially since early 2024.39 + +37. Refer to https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/BRI-pioneers-world-s-first-dedicated-satellite-to-regain-Indonesian-banking-lead and www.asiasat.com/system/ + +files/2019-12/GSC%20-%20C-band%20is%20critical%20for%20satellite%20servcies.pdf + +38. Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 12-13 + +39. Refer to www.bcsatellite.net/blog/indonesias-satria-1-satellite-is-connected-and-set-for-2024/ + +20 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + +Recommendations for 3.5 GHz + +— Adopt guard bands that maximise spectral + +1. Supply: + +Ensure at least 300 MHz of 3.5 GHz spectrum +in the 3.3–3.7 GHz band should be made +available by 2026. If this is not possible, then +consistent with the phased approaches in +other markets, at least 200 MHz should be +released first. Additional 3.5 GHz spectrum +should be released in the future, subject +to clearance and/or the implementation of +adequate mitigation measures. If a phased +approach is taken, all the spectrum released +during such a process should be subject to a +condition that allows the band to reorganise to +create larger contiguous blocks of spectrum. +The aim is for all mobile operators to secure +at least 100 MHz of contiguous spectrum in +this band. + +2. Clearance and mitigation measures: + +Indonesia should accelerate clearance or +introduce adequate mitigation measures to +ensure coexistence with incumbent users in +the band. Firstly, where alternatives to C-band +satellite (e.g. fibre, mobile) are available, +these should be used instead. Secondly, +in considering mitigation measures, the +recommended actions are: + +efficiency. Studies and real-world regulatory +examples of the necessary guard band between +5G and FSS exist. For example, studies have +concluded that a guard band in the 1840 to +25 MHz range is needed.41 In Vietnam,42 +Canada43 and the US,44 a guard band of 20 MHz +has been adopted. In Singapore, after initially +proposing a guard band of 100 MHz, a guard +band of 50 MHz was used instead. + +— Ensure improved filtering for FSS receivers by +installing LNBs where required. Other possible +measures to address coexistence issues, such +as earth station shielding, restriction zones or +detailed coordination, could also be considered. + +3. Phased introduction by geography: + +Indonesia should consider whether to adopt +geographical separation for VSAT in regional +and rural areas while restricting the use of +satellite direct-to-home (DTH) and TVRO +in the 3.4–3.7 GHz in key urban areas, such +as Java and the top 10 urban areas of the +country.45 This approach would allow 5G +deployment of 3.5 GHz in urban areas where +demand is highest while permitting continued +access to the band for FSS services in more +rural parts of Indonesia, where satellite +connectivity still plays an important role. + +mmWave band spectrum +availability + +Future IMT spectrum and +planning towards 2030 + +While Indonesia has decided to allocate the +26 GHz bands for 5G, the spectrum auction in the +26 GHz band, which was planned for completion +by July 2024, has now been delayed to 2025. +Spectrum in high bands can be made available +regionally if industry demand exists, especially +for enterprise use. + +As the mmWave ecosystem is relatively small and +use cases are still emerging, it will be necessary +for Komdigi to ensure licence conditions provide +appropriate incentives, including longer validity, +lower prices and flexible obligations. + +Spectrum is central to mobile connectivity and +will underpin Indonesia’s digital transformation +and economic growth. Indonesia will need an +average of 2 GHz of mid-band spectrum by 2030 +to ensure sufficient capacity as 5G expands and +to prepare for future 6G services.46 Policymakers +must adopt a long-term strategy to manage +spectrum demands, balancing various uses to +maximise economic and societal benefits. This +will allow businesses to prepare investment plans, +secure financing and develop arrangements for +deploying particular technologies. + +40. Refer to the Transfinite study in 2019 which concluded that an 18 MHz guard band is sufficient to mitigate co-frequency interference. Available at + +www.transfinite.com/papers/Report_for_GSMA_on_3.4-3.8_GHz_Compatibility.pdf + +41. In Brazil, a guard band of 25 MHz was assessed to be adequate, though this was not needed as the decision was made to migrate existing TVRO services to the Ku-band. + +Refer to https://www.gsma.com/connectivity-for-good/spectrum/brazil-multi-band-auction-one-of-the-largest-in-mobile-history/ + +42. Guard band from 3980 to 4000 MHz. + +43. Refer to ISED. Decision on the Technical and Policy Framework for the 3650-4200 MHz Band and Changes to the Frequency Allocation of the 3500-3650 MHz Band. May + +2021. Available at https://www.ic.gc.ca/eic/site/smt-gst.nsf/eng/sf11699.html + +44. Refer to FCC. Expanding Flexible Use of the 3.7 to 4.2 GHz Band, 3 March 2020. Available at https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-20-22A1.pdf + +45. Refer to Adis Alifiawan, FGD-2, Rancangan Teknokratik Renstra Kominfo 2025-2029, Penyediaan Pita Frekuensi 3,5 GHz untuk Mobile Broadband, pages 12-13. + +46. Refer to Coleago Consulting. Estimating the mid-band spectrum needs in the 2025-2030 time frame, July 2021. Available at www.gsma.com/spectrum/wp-content/ + +uploads/2021/07/Estimating-Mid-Band-Spectrum-Needs.pdf + +21 / 25 + + Only around 360 MHz of mid-band spectrum has +been assigned for IMT in Indonesia. Even with the +inclusion of the 2.6 GHz and 3.5 GHz bands, the +total supply of mid-band spectrum will still be +significantly below the 2 GHz required for IMT by +2030. The following actions are recommended +for Indonesia: + +— Assess options for expanding spectrum + +supply for 5G in the 2025–2030 timeframe, +particularly in the mid-bands. These can +include the release of unassigned spectrum in +existing mid-bands and the identification of +new spectrum in potential future bands. + +— Plan for the use of 4.8 GHz and the entire +upper 6 GHz (6.425–7.125 GHz)47 bands to +support further development of 5G. The +additional 700 MHz in the upper 6 GHz band +will go a long way to addressing Indonesia’s +mid-band needs. + +— Gather information on usage trends for FSS +in the 3.7–4.2 GHz band and assess possible +options for future 5G use in this range as +satellite capacity in other bands, such as Ku +and Ka, develops. + +— Explore options for other IMT candidate +bands, which can be used for 5G local +networks in limited areas. + +Komdigi’s 2025–2029 Strategic Plan represents +an excellent start on a long-term spectrum +roadmap for Indonesia. This roadmap should +be updated annually to incorporate SDPPI’s +work, which releases different frequency bands +and information on evolving technology and +spectrum trends, including harmonisation and +standardisation activities.48 + +3.2 Long-term financial sustainability + +in Indonesia + +Indonesian mobile operators face financial +challenges despite significant mobile usage +and data traffic growth. Spectrum costs for +operators have risen substantially since 2010, +with annualised spectrum costs reaching 12.2% +of recurring revenue in 2023, above the APAC +median of 8.7%.49 Sustainable spectrum prices +are needed to facilitate 5G network investment +and accelerate digital transformation. -$ +— Indonesia has a relatively low total + +IMT spectrum allocation and high unit +spectrum prices50 compared to other +countries. This adversely affects mobile +broadband quality of service and operational +expenditures. These twin pressures can +stifle the intensity of competition and crowd +out investment in wireless broadband +infrastructure. -$ +There are several risks to the long-term +financial sustainability of the Indonesian +mobile market, namely: + +— Spectrum auction prices have risen to + +unsustainable levels due to scarcity of IMT +spectrum and sub-optimal processes in +previous auctions involving individual spectrum +blocks in the 2.1 and 2.3 GHz bands being +auctioned separately over several years rather +than multiple blocks or a multi-band auction. + +— Additional costs of deployment and +operations across the Indonesian +archipelago. Deploying mobile broadband +infrastructure and services over 1.9 million +square kilometres scattered across thousands +of islands is geographically challenging. More +sites are needed, including towers, fibre and +costly submarine cables, meaning Indonesia +has higher capital expenditure intensity than +Asia's average.51 + +47. GSMA. Mobile Evolution in 6 GHz: The impact of spectrum assignment options in 6.425–7.125 GHz, September 2024. Available at https://www.gsma.com/connectivity- + +for-good/spectrum/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/GSMA_Mobile-Evolution-in-6-GHz.pdf + +48. Indonesia is planning to strengthen digital infrastructure by expanding coverage through preparations for Non-Terrestrial Network (NTN) under the second strategy of + +Strengthening Indonesia’s Digital Foundation 2025-2029. + +49. GSMA. Sustainable spectrum pricing to boost Indonesia’s digital economy. October 2023. Available at https://www.gsma.com/connectivity-for-good/spectrum/wp- + +content/uploads/2023/11/GSMA_Sustainable-spectrum-pricing-to-boost-Indonesias-digital-economy.pdf + +50. Indonesia’s current spectrum cost to revenue ratio for a majority of mobile operators is already above 10%. Based on Coleago study: annualised cost spectrum as a + +percentage of revenue more than 10 percentage may not be sustainable. Refer to Coleago, Spectrum pricing, make or break the 5G momentum, Shanghai, June 2019, +page 17 + +51. To address these higher costs, sharing approaches are supported by Komdigi as part of the regulatory and policy elements of the Penta Helix Model. Source: Dr. Ir. +Ismail, M.T, MCI, Presentation, 5G and Telco Transformation: Indonesia’s Path to Ultra-Fast Connectivity, DTI-CX Conference2024, Jakarta, 31 July 2024, page 8 + +22 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS — High regulatory costs hamper the broadband + +sector from becoming an economic +development enabler.52 The increasing ratio +of regulatory costs to revenue has decreased +mobile operator funding capability to allocate +adequate resources for infrastructure roll- +out to boost coverage and quality of services +across the Indonesian archipelago. + +The government has recognised such issues and +the need to provide spectrum fee incentives. +A positive development is the ‘Strengthening +Indonesia’s Digital Foundation 2025-2029 Plan’, +which highlights how price per MHz must be + +adjusted to maintain a healthy ratio of regulatory +costs to gross revenue (approximately 5%). The +plan also outlines that, in addition to retaining the +spectrum fee-to-revenue ratio at a maximum of +10%, it is recommended that the 5G frequency fee +does not exceed 50% of the 4G frequency fee.53 + +The SDPPI is considering a reduction factor in +spectrum fees for operators at the upcoming +5G spectrum bands auction if they are given +obligations that create additional burdens +or costs (such as rollout obligations in non- +economic areas), as summarised below.54 + +Figure 9 +Draft roadmap on frequency fee incentives (2025-2030) + +Draft roadmap on frequency fee incentives (2025-2030) + +Ministry of +Communication +& Digital Affairs + +This roadmap on frequency fee adjustment is a draft concept that focuses primarily on the evaluation +of the K value (PM 9/2023) and the payment scheme for new frequency band auctions (PM 6/2024). + +– Adjustment of +the upfront fee +and annual fee +to be used in +the selection +process of a +radio frequency +band. + +– Payment of + +the annual fee +for the 2025 +selection result. +– Adjustment of +the upfront fee +and annual fee +if a selection +process is +conducted. + +– Payment of the +annual fee for +the 2025 & 2026 +selection results. + +– Adjustment of +the upfront fee +and annual fee +if a selection +process is +conducted. + +– Payment of the +annual fee for +the 2025, 2026 +& 2027 selection +results. + +– Payment of + +the annual fee +for the 2025 & +2026 selection +results. + +– Payment of the + +annual fee of the +2025, 2026 & +2027 selection +results. + +– Adjustment of + +upfront fee and +annual fee if a +selection process +is conducted. -Years Ended December 31, -2024 2025 -(129,386) -(98,209) -384,662 -62,714 -30,999 -9,428 -260,208 -88,361 $ -(99,522) -354,169 -68,904 -3,064 -5,537 -420,513 $ +2026 -(1) Restructuring charges of $3.1 million and $31.0 million in fiscal year 2025 and 2024 primarily include asset impairment charges of -$2.9 million and $29.1 million, respectively. +2027 -Net cash provided by operating activities -Less: Purchases of property and equipment +2028 -Add/(Less): Effect of exchange rate changes on -cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash +2029 -Free cash flow (TTM) +2030 -Q4 24 +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -Q1 25 +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -Q2 25 -$ 218,045 $ 310,094 $ 396,421 $ 455,360 $ 483,718 -(5,280) +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -Q3 25 +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -Q4 25 +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -(6,320) +Adjustment +of frequency +fee through +adjustment of +K value -(5,061) +Source: SDPPI, Penataan Spektrum Frekuensi Radio Dinas Tetap & Bergerak Darat (DTBD) Capaian Tahun 2024 Untuk Dilanjutkan di Periode Tahun 2025-2029, 20 +December 2024 page 48. Translation by Retno W. Damajanti -(6,567) +52. When deploying broadband infrastructure, the sector is subjected to permit and right of the way fees, which vary substantially across local government units, thus -(6,647) +increasing capital expenditures (CAPEX) of broadband infrastructure deployment and potentially lowering the coverage and the affordability of the mobile services. -(9,746) +53. Refer to Arah Kebijakan dan Strategi Pengembangan Pitalebar Indonesia Periode Tahun 2025-2029, November 2024. -5,179 -$ 203,238 $ 298,446 $ 391,987 $ 443,007 $ 483,617 +54. SDPPI, Penataan Spektrum Frekuensi Radio Dinas Tetap & Bergerak Darat (DTBD) Capaian Tahun 2024 Untuk Dilanjutkan di Periode Tahun 2025-2029, 20 December -(5,328) +2024 page 48 -(5,706) +23 / 25 -2,133 +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS -Roku Q4 2025 Shareholder Letter +Recommendations on +spectrum pricing -13 +Industry revenue per MHz of spectrum has +declined in Indonesia while spectrum fees have +increased. Therefore, Indonesia must set modest +reserve prices for releasing any new IMT spectrum. + +Spectrum should be licensed as soon as +needed. Artificial spectrum scarcity and +measures that increase risks for mobile +operators should be avoided. + +In addition, the formula for calculating annual +spectrum fees (BHP IPFR), which has been +indexed to inflation and population, should also +be reviewed. Adjustments should be made to +provide the right long-run incentives and avoid +disproportionate cost increases that are not +aligned with evolving market conditions. + +Lastly, incentive policies should be implemented +to accelerate infrastructure roll-out and boost +coverage and the quality of services in Indonesia. +This can be reduced spectrum fees in exchange +for operator’s investment and network rollout +commitments. + +24 / 25 + +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS + + GSMA Head Office +1 Angel Lane +London +EC4R 3AB +United Kingdom +Tel: +44 (0)20 7356 0600 + +25 / 25 +ACCELERATING 5G IN INDONESIA: A SPECTRUM ROADMAP FOR SUCCESS \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q33/random_k4/random_4.md b/q33/random_k4/random_4.md index 481e365c46bf38073a1bbbbafb7d7f3283256258..ca1c4f7994d251ad18421b7ab31104f32ea5581e 100644 --- a/q33/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q33/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,180 +1,843 @@ -AMAZFIT ACTIVE -Product Manual -A2211 +6 +1 +0 +2 - 01 Package Contents +b +e +F +4 -Smartwatch with band × 1 +] +I -Charging base × 1 +N +. +s +c +[ -Instruction Manual × 1 +1 +v +7 +4 +5 +1 +0 +. +2 +0 +6 +1 +: +v +i +X +r +a + +Under a cloud of uncertainty: Legal +questions affecting Internet storage +and transmission of +copyright-protected video content + +Fraida Fund, S. Amir Hosseini, Shivendra S. Panwar + +Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering +NYU Tandon School of Engineering + +The rapid growth of multimedia consumption has triggered +technical, economic, and business innovations that improve the +quality and accessibility of content. It has also opened new mar- +kets, promising large revenues for industry players. However, +new technologies also pose new questions regarding the legal +aspects of content delivery, which are often resolved through liti- +gation between copyright owners and content distributors. The +precedents set by these cases will act as a game changer in the +content delivery industry and will shape the existing offerings in +the market in terms of how new technologies can be deployed +and what kind of pricing strategies can be associated with them. +In this paper, we offer a tutorial on key copyright and communi- +cations laws and decisions related to storage and transmission of +video content over the Internet. We summarize legal limitations +on the deployment of new technologies and pricing mechanisms, +and explain the implications of recent lawsuits. Understanding +these concerns is essential for engineers engaged in designing the +technical and economic aspects of video delivery systems. + +introduction + +In North America, real time entertainment constitutes almost 69% of peak +period downstream traffic in fixed networks and 40% in mobile networks. +Netflix alone accounts for more than 36% of peak period downstream traffic +in fixed networks, with YouTube, Amazon Video, and Hulu also appearing +among the top ten peak period applications [1]. These services collectively + +This paper is to appear in the IEEE Network Smart Data Pricing Special Issue, to be published +in March 2016. +©2015 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained +for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this +material for advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or +redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other +works 1 - 02 About the Watch + introduction -Power button +2 -Heart rate sensor +Figure 1: Delivery of multimedia content over the Internet involves financial +and other relationships between several key players. The specific +agreements between network service providers (Verizon, Comcast, +AT&T), content distributors (Netflix, Amazon), and content creators +(Disney, Sony) affect both the availability and pricing of multimedia +content and network services to consumers. + +are both the greatest stress on current networks (and thus, the primary +contributor to costs of data delivery), and the greatest driver of demand for +network services (and thus, a key component of revenue strategy for network +service providers.) + +Recent proposals to ease the impact of video traffic on networks include +smart data pricing schemes [2] involving shifting video traffic in time or +space [3, 4], better content delivery networks [5], proactive caching [6], and +peer to peer delivery [7, 8]. Some regulatory aspects of network pricing are +also well investigated (such as network neutrality [9].) However, because +most of the video traffic under consideration is copyright-protected, new +techniques must overcome additional legal and regulatory hurdles to be +applied in practice. These have been discussed in law, economics, and policy +forums, [10–12] but largely neglected in the engineering literature. + +Key considerations for engineers designing technical protocols and pricing +strategies for Internet content delivery include: Where is content stored? +Who initiates the storage and/or transmission of content? What agreements +exist between the content creator, content distributor, and network service +provider? These questions are complicated by the diversity of the video +content delivered over the Internet, especially as the increasing population +of “cord cutters” opens a market for IPTV [13] or over-the-top delivery of +traditional television content over the Internet. The ecosystem of Internet +video is going to include third-party licensed video on demand, original +programming included in bundles that include broadband Internet and +video service, broadcast TV content on demand, and live TV content. These, +in turn, involve complex relationships between content creators (Disney, +Sony), content distributors (Netflix, Amazon), and network service providers +(Verizon, Comcast, AT&T) as pictured in Figure 1, with associated legal +challenges that affect engineering and pricing strategies. + +This tutorial considers issues related to the Internet distribution of copy- +righted video content in the United States. We begin with a brief overview +of relevant copyright and communications legislation. Then, we discuss +selected legal challenges affecting technical and economic solutions to the + +Creator of free (broadcast) contentCreator of non-free contentContent distributor (includes place shifting services)Network service providerProvider of bundled content and network servicesConsumerAccess network data pricingSponsored data,edge-network cachingLicense, revenue sharing agreementRetransmission consent, statutory license copyright and communications legislation in the united states -Charging contacts +3 -Note: Press and hold the power button to turn on the watch. If the watch cannot be turned on, -please charge it and then try again. +content delivery problem. We conclude with a discussion of the implications +for engineering future multimedia content delivery networks. + +copyright and communications legislation in the united states + +In the United States, the delivery of copyrighted video content over the +Internet is subject to copyright and communications law. + +With respect to copyright, the 1909 Copyright Act (Public Law 60-349, +35 Stat. 1075) confers six exclusive rights upon the owner of copyrighted +material. These include the right to (1) reproduce the work, (2) prepare +derivative works, (3) distribute copies of the work, (4) publicly perform +the work, (5) display the work publicly, and (6) perform a digital audio +transmission publicly. The legal questions surrounding Internet storage and +transmission focus on the copyright holders’ exclusive rights of reproduction +and public performance. The definitions of these terms have been revisited +recently as new techniques are devised for sharing content. + +Digital technology has complicated the concept of reproduction. A legal +“copy” is one in which the work is “fixed” in a material object, by some +method from which it can be reproduced or communicated. The advent of +computer memory raises some questions regarding the definition of “fixed”. +Is a digital copy “fixed” if it is stored in volatile memory (RAM)? What if it +is stored on a hard disk but the file descriptor is erased immediately? + +Digital technology has also complicated the concept of public performance. +The original definition of “public performance” in the Copyright Act was +very narrow. In Teleprompter Corp. v. Columbia Broadcasting Systems, Inc. (415 +U.S. 394 (1974)) and Fortnightly Corp. v. United Artists Television, Inc. (392 U.S. +390 (1968)), the United States Supreme Court decided that transmission of +broadcast television via cable did not constitute a “public performance” and +thus cable providers who retransmit broadcast television are not infringing. +In response to these decisions, Congress amended the Copyright Act in 1976 +(Public Law 94-553), expanding the definition of a “public performance” to +include the transmission of a work to the public “by means of any device or +process, whether the members of the public capable of receiving the perfor- +mance or display receive it in the same place or in separate places and at the +same time or at different times.” This prevented businesses (including cable +providers) from selling access to broadcasters’ signals without compensation. +At the same time, Congress implemented a licensing arrangement to +minimize the burden on cable providers, while still protecting broadcasters. +By law, a service wishing to retransmit broadcast signals must negotiate a +license from copyright providers and also gain the consent of broadcasters. +However, depending on its legal classification under communications law, a +service may be eligible to participate in two regulated markets that ease the +burden of negotiation. + +First, Sections 111, 119, and 122 of the Copyright Act (U.S. Code Title 17, +Chapter 1) grant cable and satellite providers meeting certain requirements +the right to retransmit broadcast television programming without negotiating +with individual copyright holders. With this “compulsory license,” the +provider either pays set (regulated, below market rate) royalty fees which +are collected by the United States Copyright Office and then distributed to +the copyright holders, or is entitled to a royalty-free license. + +Another set of laws apply to negotiations between the broadcaster and the +retransmitter. The Communications Act (CFR, Title 47, Chapter I, Subchapter +C, Part 76, Subpart D, Section 76) requires businesses classified as multi- + + time-shifting services, at home and in the cloud -2 +4 - 03 Pairing the Watch +Figure 2: While the courts’ interpretation of copyright and communications +law allows consumers to record video content for personal use in +their own homes (Betamax) or stream video from their home set-top +boxes to another device they own (Fox Broadcasting Co. v. Dish +Network, LLC), the courts have been divided on the status of cloud +services engaged in similar practices (Cablevision, ivi, Aereo). + +channel video programming distributors (MVPDs) to get “retransmission +consent” to retransmit broadcast television signals. (This is distinct from the +license agreement with the copyright holder.) Retransmission consent may +involve compensation from the retransmitter to the broadcaster. Alternatively, +eligible television broadcast stations may elect not to require retransmission +consent, instead participating in a “must carry” arrangement which under +some conditions may require a cable operator that serves the same market to +carry its signal. + +The implications of these laws for cloud services is not clear. While case +law is well established with respect to what end users or cable providers may +do with video, courts are divided on how to apply this to Internet-based +services (as in Figure 2). Some approaches to smart data pricing depend +on cloud content providers’ ability to freely shift data in time and/or space, +and negotiate on fair terms with Internet service providers that carry their +content. The courts’ interpretation of copyright and communications law +for cloud providers has a major impact on the licensing structures and costs +associated with each of these approaches. + +time-shifting services, at home and in the cloud + +Many solutions to the content delivery problem propose time-shifting content +delivery, in order to smooth traffic during peak periods [3]. Smart pricing +schemes may encourage users to modulate their viewing habits and make +delivery time more flexible for network service providers. However, it is +unclear under what conditions a service engaging in this practice infringes +the rights of the copyright holder (in which case, it would require a potentially +costly license that might negate the savings associated with time-shifting). + +Given that the exclusive rights to reproduction and public performance +are held by the copyright owner, is a broadband service provider allowed to +store copyrighted content for users in the “cloud” and deliver it to them later, +on request? The key precedents in the United States are the 1984 Supreme +Court decision in Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc. (Betamax) +(464 U.S. 417 (1984)) and the 2008 Second Circuit decision in Cartoon Network +LP v. CSC Holdings Inc. (Cablevision) (536 F.3d 121 (2d Cir. 2008)). + +User may capture broadcast television signals, record a copy, and time-shift or place-shift that copy for private, non-commercial viewing.Courts disagree on the licensing requirements for a third party to offer a service allowing users to do the same thing, but with equipment located outside their homes, in the cloud. time-shifting services, at home and in the cloud -Zepp is a must-have app for this watch. It provides scientific sleep and workout -guidance and personalized health services to help you start a healthy lifestyle. +5 -1. Use your mobile phone to scan the QR code on the right side to download - and install the app, or search for the app in the Google Play Store or Apple - App Store and then download and install the the latest version of the app. -2. Open the app, register an account and log in. -3. Pair the watch as prompted by the app. +Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc. (Betamax) + +In 1979, Sony was sued by members of the film industry for its role in +developing the Betamax VCR. The plaintiffs claimed that because Sony was +manufacturing a device that could be used for copyright infringement, they +were liable for infringement committed by its customers. The Supreme Court +decision found Sony not liable because the Betamax VCR had non-infringing +uses, and concluded that “private, noncommercial time-shifting in the home” +is fair use and does not infringe on the reproduction right. + +Betamax addresses two key questions with implications for future cloud + +services: + +• Can a company be held liable for infringement if the service it provides has both +infringing and non-infringing uses? The court decided that the Betamax +VCR had significant non-infringing uses, for example making copies +of televised content with permission of the copyright holder, and that +Sony was therefore not liable for potential infringement. + +• May a viewer time-shift video content without the authorization of the copy- +right holder? The court further decided that time-shifting television for +private, non-commercial use in the home is permitted even without the +authorization of the copyright holder, as it “merely enables a viewer to +see such a work which he had been invited to witness in its entirety +free of charge.” + +Later legislation (notably the Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and case +law modified the Sony decision in several ways. In A&M Records, Inc. v. +Napster, Inc. (239 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2001)), an appeals court found that +Napster could be held liable for contributory infringement because it was +able to monitor and control users’ activities. Similarly, in MGM Studios, +Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd. (545 U.S. 913 (2005)), the Supreme Court decided that +Grokster could be liable for inducing copyright infringement (despite having +non-infringing uses) because Grokster advertised and instructed users on +engaging in infringement. + +Cartoon Network LP v. CSC Holdings Inc. (Cablevision) + +In 2008, a consortium of copyright holders sued Cablevision for its Remote +Storage DVR (RS-DVR) service. Cablevision routed the multimedia data +stream going to subscribers through a Broadband Media Router (BMR), +where it was buffered for at most 1.2 seconds while the system checked if any +customers had requested a copy. If a subscriber had requested a particular +program, it would be stored on a portion of a hard disk allocated to that +subscriber in Cablevision’s cloud data center, from which the subscriber +could later view it. + +The lawsuit alleged direct copyright infringement, excluding the topic +of contributory copyright infringement. In turn, Cablevision waived any +defense based on fair use. Thus, the precedent set by Betamax is largely +orthogonal to Cablevision. + +The court sided with Cablevision, setting key precedents in three areas: + +• A copy of “transitory” duration does not infringe on the reproduction right. +Because Cablevision held content in its BMR buffer for no more than +1.2 seconds at any time, its buffer copy did not infringe. This is in +contrast to the earlier MAI Systems Corp. v. Peak Computer, Inc. (991 F.2d + + “x with a long cord:” place-shifting services -Note: -1. For better user experience, please use the most recent version of the app. -2. The operating system needs to be Android 7.0, iOS 14.0, or above. -3. Do not pair the watch directly using your mobile phone’s Bluetooth. Follow the steps in the app to pair - your watch correctly. +6 -3 +511 (9th Cir. 1993)), where the Ninth Circuit found that a copy held in +volatile memory did infringe. + +• If a customer issues the command to copy directly to a copying service, then +the customer (not the service) is liable for the copy. Although the copy +stored on the hard disk was a reproduction in the legal sense, the court +agreed that the customer, not Cablevision, was responsible for making +the copy. This decision establishes volitional action as a key element +shielding cloud providers from liability for their users’ actions. + +• A system that transmits to a single subscriber using a single unique copy +produced by that subscriber does not constitute a “public” performance. The +court made the determination of whether a performance is “public” +based on the audience of the particular copy of the work. + +This decision is important for establishing copyright liability protection for +cloud providers, but the precedent it sets is limited. The protection against +liability established by Cablevision is based on the grounds that the user +directly initiates the copy; this protection would not necessarily apply to +systems that proactively fetch content without an explicit request from the +user. Similarly, based on Cablevision, a network service provider that caches +popular content at the edge of a network might need to store one copy per +user, or else negotiate a license for public performance of the content. + +Impact of time-shifting on data pricing + +The case law established by Cablevision and Betamax mostly affects smart data +pricing techniques that involve time-dependent pricing [3]. These may be +more or less problematic depending on their implementation: + +• Pricing strategies that encourage users to change their viewing habits by +deferring consumption to off-peak times are not likely to be problematic. + +• Pricing strategies that encourage users to pre-fetch content in off-peak +times may be problematic in some cases. Betamax established that +pre-fetching is permitted for private, non-commercial use in the home, +but not necessarily for other uses. Furthermore, if the service provider +creates a non-transitory copy that is not user-initiated in order to +facilitate the technical process of pre-fetching, the precedent set by +Cablevision protecting the service provider from liability may not apply. + +• Pricing strategies in which content is proactively pre-fetched (e.g. based +on predictions of content that is likely to be of interest to the consumer) +during off-peak times without the user initiating the download can +be problematic, as the precedent set by Cablevision requires volitional +action on the part of the user to protect the service provider from +liability. + +“x with a long cord:” place-shifting services + +While Betamax and Cablevision addressed the issue of time-shifting, Warner +Bros. Entertainment Inc. v. WTV Systems, Inc. (824 F.Supp.2d 1003 (2011)) +and Fox Broadcasting Co. v. Dish Network, LLC (723 F.3d (9th Cir. 2013)) +concern the copyright implications of place-shifting. Place-shifting allows +viewers to watch video content at a place of their choosing. Typically, these +services present themselves as “X with a long cord”: a DVD and DVD player + + “x with a long cord:” place-shifting services -Download Zepp App +7 - 04 Charging the Watch +rental attached to a long cord (Zediva in Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. v. +WTV Systems, Inc.), a television set-top box with a long cord (Slingbox in Fox +Broadcasting Co. v. Dish Network, LLC), or a television antenna with a long +cord (ivi, Aereo), for example. + +Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. v. WTV Systems, Inc. + +Zediva was a service offered in 2011 that allowed customers to watch movies +online by streaming a signal over the Internet from physical DVD players +located in California. Customers who “rented” a DVD had exclusive access +to that disk and a DVD player for up to four hours. Each disk could only be +viewed by one customer at a time. + +Because they did not negotiate streaming licenses, Zediva was able to +offer new releases as soon as they were available on DVD, before they +were licensed to streaming services such as Netflix. Also, Zediva was able +to undercut competitors; customers could rent a physical disk and DVD +player for $1.99, while licensed streaming video services at the time charged +between $3.99 and $5.99 for new releases. + +Zediva’s defense argued that they were identical to a brick-and-mortar +rental store, which is not required to negotiate licenses from copyright owners +for post-purchase rentals (under the first sale doctrine). Because the first +sale doctrine is a defense only for reproduction and distribution, not public +performance, the case rested on whether or not Zediva infringed on the +public performance right. + +The district court decided against Zediva, rejecting their first sale doctrine- +based defense and noting that they were clearly operating a streaming service, +not a DVD rental service. Noteworthy conclusions of the court were: + +• Zediva’s streaming signals were a “public performance” even though +customers were using the DVDs at different times, implying that suc- +cessive transmissions of a single copy to multiple viewers can be con- +sidered public performance. (In Cablevision, each copy was only ever +viewed by one user.) + +• The “length of the cable” may be determinative in deciding whether +copyright infringement occurred. Zediva considered itself analogous +to “playing back a movie from a DVD with a very long cable attached,” +but the court held them liable for transmission because the videos were +received “beyond the place from which they are sent.” + +Fox Broadcasting Co. v. Dish Network, LLC + +In 2013, Dish implemented a service allowing subscribers to view content +from their home set top boxes over the Internet, using a streaming server +installed in the home (Slingbox). This allows subscribers to view live, on- +demand, or recorded content that they have access to at home, from any +location. + +Fox argued that Dish infringed on the public performance right. However, +the district court found that because the service could only be used by +subscribers to get access to their own recordings (which were considered fair +use, according to Betamax), and because the reproduction and transmission +actions were initiated by volitional action on the part of subscribers (as +in Cablevision), there was no direct infringement. Furthermore, a user’s +transmission of programming from one place to another is not a public + + schrödinger’s cable duck: internet delivery of broadcast television -1. Connect the watch's charging cable to a power adapter or a computer's USB port. -2. Put the watch into the charging base. Pay attention to the direction and position of the watch, and - make sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch fit closely with the charging base. -3. When charging s tarts, the watch screen displays the charging progress. +8 -Note: -1. Please use the charging base that comes with the watch. - Make sure that the charging base is dry before charging. -2. Please use a 1A or above power adapter. +performance because the content is already in the subscriber’s possession, as +is the equipment. Thus, Dish does not engage in contributory infringement +by enabling this behavior. + +This decision is significant, because while at face value, the Slingbox seems +like just another “X with a long cord,” here, the long cord carries content +between equipment already in the user’s possession. Thus, a long cord +connecting a user’s device to the cloud is not equivalent to a long cord +connecting two devices belonging to the same user across the Internet. + +Impact of place-shifting on data pricing + +Place-shifting affects smart data pricing strategies by changing the dynamics +of cost and demand in the ecosystem of Figure 1. The agreements between a +place-shifting service and content creators (e.g. license agreements, revenue +sharing contracts) affect the cost, value, and availability of the service. This +in turn influences the prices of data services, as the network service provider +acts as a platform for delivery of the content. + +Place-shifting services in which content is stored in the cloud can po- +tentially reduce the acquisition and storage costs of the content distributor. +These savings can trickle down and generate consumer surplus that may +influence data purchasing decisions. However, the legality of services that +do not specifically negotiate licenses for cloud streaming (as in Zediva) is +uncertain, especially when a single copy of the content is transmitted to +multiple users (i.e., when the savings to the content distributor are greatest.) +Content distributors that negotiate a license in the face of this uncertainty +pass on higher licensing costs to consumers. + +Place-shifting services that allow mobile users to access content that they +previously could only view at home (like Slingbox) may shift demand from +inexpensive home broadband networks to relatively expensive cellular net- +works, partially negating smart data pricing strategies that rely on the ability +to shift demand in the opposite direction. Again, the affordability of these +services (and thus, their impact on data pricing) varies depending on whether +or not place-shifting services must negotiate licenses, since those licensing +costs are typically passed on to consumers. + +Finally, place-shifting also includes time-shifting, so considerations related + +to time-shifting and data pricing also apply. + +schrödinger’s cable duck: internet delivery of broadcast tele- +vision + +Even more than other forms of time-shifting and place-shifting, the appli- +cation of copyright law to cloud-based services that retransmit broadcast +television over the Internet has been confusing and contradictory. The key +point of debate is the classification of these services under communications +law. This has been the subject of recent litigation involving two services, ivi +and Aereo, which we briefly describe here. A related service called “FilmOn” +is still enmeshed in active litigation. + +WPIX, Inc. v. ivi, Inc. + +ivi, Inc. was a cloud service that allowed subscribers to watch local broadcast +TV from several U.S. cities for a monthly fee of $4.99 (with an option to +also purchase a recording service for additional $0.99). +It was sued by +a group of copyright holders and broadcasters one week after beginning + + schrödinger’s cable duck: internet delivery of broadcast television -4 +9 - 05 Disassembling and Assembling the Watch Strap +retransmissions. A district court (765 F. Supp. 2d 594 (S.D.N.Y. 2011)) and an +appeals court (No. 11-788 (2d Cir. 2012)) decided against ivi, forcing them to +cease operations. + +ivi argued that they should be classified as a cable system, making them +eligible for the compulsory license under §111 and freeing them from the +requirement to negotiate with copyright holders. The court indicated that it +is unclear based solely on the text of the Copyright Act whether ivi should +be considered a cable system. Thus, in ruling against ivi, the court based its +decision on the following considerations: + +• The intent of Congress in enacting §111 was to improve access for +communities that were underserved by broadcast signals. Because +Internet-based retransmission is not localized and is not intended +mainly to support remote areas, the court found that Congress did not +intend for Internet retransmission services to be eligible for compulsory +licenses under §111. + +• The United States Copyright Office has not interpreted §111’s compul- +sory licenses to include Internet retransmission, which they have said +they consider to be “vastly different” from other retransmitters who +are eligible. + +American Broadcasting Companies v. Aereo + +Aereo allowed subscribers to stream broadcast television over the Internet for +$8/month. The creators of Aereo designed the service specifically to avoid +infringing on reproduction or public performance rights, using the precedent +set by Cablevision. Aereo set up an “antenna farm” in a warehouse in New +York. Users of the service “rented” an individual antenna and were also +offered a VCR service, allowing them to store copies of television programs +for later streaming. + +As in Cablevision, the users engaged in volitional conduct to create a copy, +no non-transitory copies except for the users’ were created, and an individual +copy (an individual antenna) was dedicated to each user. Aereo allowed +users to access content they were already permitted to view for free over +public airwaves. Both the district court and appeals court sided with Aereo, +citing Cablevision as precedent. + +However, the Supreme Court decided in favor of the broadcasters (134 S. +Ct. 2498, 2511 (2014)). The court applied the “duck test” (if it looks like a +duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck), +arguing that Aereo had an “overwhelming likeness to cable companies” and +therefore, required the consent of broadcasters to retransmit their signals. + +Following this decision, the company argued that since they are a cable +system, they are eligible for the compulsory copyright license. This argument +was rejected by the district court (Civil Action No. 12-CV-1540 (AJN) (HBP) +(S.D.N.Y Oct. 29, 2014)), which called it a “fallacy” that “because an entity +performs copyrighted works in a way similar to cable systems it must then +be deemed a cable system for all other purposes of the Copyright Act.” Thus +Aereo became Schrödinger’s cable duck: simultaneously a cable system and +not a cable system. Although it was required, like a cable system, to obtain +retransmission consent from broadcasters, it was not eligible for compulsory +licenses from copyright holders. + +A similar service, FilmOn, has been the subject of more recent, but equally +contradictory, litigation. In July 2015, a Los Angeles federal district court + + schrödinger’s cable duck: internet delivery of broadcast television -Please refer to the illustrations to disassemble or assemble the watch strap. +10 -Note: Once the strap is assembled, pull the strap properly to ensure it is installed successfully. +Figure 3: Close to 40% of U.S. households purchase Internet service as part +of a bundle that also includes television services. On the left, we +see the percentage of U.S. households who access the Internet +using only cable, DSL, mobile broadband, fiber, satellite, multiple +technologies, or who do not access the Internet from home. Moving +towards the right, we see which of those purchase Internet service +as part of a bundle including basic and/or premium television +services. (Data source: July 2013 United States Census Computer +and Internet Use Supplement. Percentages may not sum to 100 due +to rounding.) + +decided that FilmOn was entitled to the same compulsory licenses as cable +companies. However, in November 2015, this judgment was rejected on +appeal. The ongoing FilmOn litigation highlights how vague the Aereo ruling +was, and the level of uncertainty that remains regarding retransmission of +broadcast television. + +Impact of Internet retransmission of television on data pricing + +Smart data pricing often involves side payments and agreements between +Internet-based content providers and network service providers (for example, +as in sponsored data [14]) under the assumption that these are separate +parties with distinct interests. However, network service providers may have +a competing interest in the content delivery market; many also sell video +entertainment services. Figure 3 shows that according to a July 2013 census +survey, 39% of U.S. households buy Internet service as part of a “bundle” +including television. + +Bundles are important to cable operators, who have been losing pay-TV +subscribers while the high-speed Internet user base continues to grow. The +cost of an Internet service bundle including other services is higher than an +equivalent stand-alone Internet plan (Figure 4). However, consumers have +an increasing preference for à la carte television options or “cord cutting.” +According to recent Nielsen reports, the number of “zero TV” households is +on the rise, and almost half of “zero TV” households are composed of young +people under the age of 35. Meanwhile, broadcast television networks remain +important to viewers, with the “Big Four” still retaining a 40% average weekly +reach. The coincidence of these trends makes alternative video platforms, +and Internet delivery of television programming in particular, the next big +front in the battle for consumer dollars. + +The ecosystem shown in Figure 1 currently favors cable and satellite +providers that also sell bundles including broadcast television, since these + +None(25.9%)Dial up (1.0%)Other (1.1%)Satellite (1.6%)Fiber (4.3%)Mobile broad−band (7.4%)Multiple(13.3%)DSL(14.1%)Cable(31.3%)None(60.6%)Basic(17.1%)Premium(10.1%)Basic & Premium(12.1%) schrödinger’s cable duck: internet delivery of broadcast television -5 +11 - 06 Wearing the Watch - -1. In order to ensure the accuracy of heart rate, blood oxygen, - and other measurements, please wear your watch at a distance - of at least one finger away from the carpal, and keep the strap - at a comfortable snugness. -2. During workout, please wear it as tightly as possible to ensure - that the watch does not shake. Wear your watch at a distance - of at least one finger away from the carpal to obtain more accurate - heart rate data. After workout, you can loosen the strap appropriately - to ensure a comfortable wear experience. -3. When measuring blood oxygen saturation, wear the watch correctly. Avoid wearing the watch on the - wrist joint, keep your arm flat, maintain comfortable (appropriately tight) fitting between the watch and - the skin of your wrist, and keep your arm still throughout the measurement process. - -Note: -When affected by external factors (arm sag, arm sway, arm hair, tattoo, etc.), the measurement result may -be inaccurate or the measurement may fail and provide no output. +Figure 4: Prices for Internet service in the United States, grouped by tech- +nology, bundle type, and provider. The lower and upper “hinges” +of the boxplot correspond to the first and third quartiles of avail- +able plans, the “whiskers” extend to 1.5× the interquartile range, +and outliers beyond the whiskers are plotted as points. A given +provider may offer a range of plans of the same bundle type using +the same technology, differentiated by data rate, cap, or number of +television channels included. Not all plans are available in all U.S. +markets. (Data Source: International Bureau, Fourth International +Broadband Data Report, 2015.) + +are entitled to compulsory licenses below market rates. These services may +even have a competitive edge when selling IPTV service (i.e., not traditional +cable television). By delivering this service over managed IP, not the public +Internet, they can offer a better quality of service than competitors and also +exempt their own service from data caps, without running into network +neutrality issues that apply on public Internet. (See for example Comcast’s +“Stream” product, announced July 2015.) + +However, if services such as ivi, Aereo, and FilmOn were reclassified to +also entitle them to compulsory licenses, the balance of this ecosystem would +shift dramatically. This would affect aspects of data pricing related to transac- +tions between content distributors and network service providers, including +network neutrality [9], sponsored data [14], and app-based pricing [2]. + +The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and/or Congress are +likely to eventually regulate Internet streaming providers, and describe what +rights and requirements apply to them. It is not clear what this regulation +might look like, and whether Internet streaming providers will at that stage +be on equal footing with cable providers, who are subject to regulations +imposed at a time when cable services operated mainly to improve access +for underserved communities. + +llllll100200300Stand−aloneInternetInternetand PhoneInternetand TVInternet, Phone,and TVPrice per month (USD)TechnologyCableDSLFiberSatellitePrices of fixed broadband Internet plansavailable in the United States summary and global outlook + +12 + +Time-shifting + +1984 Sony Corp. of America +v. Universal City +Studios, Inc. (Betamax) +2008 Cartoon Network LP v. +CSC Holdings Inc. +(Cablevision) + +Place-shifting +2011 Warner Bros. + +Entertainment Inc. v. +WTV Systems, Inc. + +2013 Fox Broadcasting Co. v. +Dish Network, LLC + +“Private, noncommercial time-shifting in +the home” does not infringe on the repro- +duction right. +Establishes protection from liability if the +service provider’s copy is transitory and +the user’s copy is created by volitional +action on the user’s part. + +The “length of the cable” between the con- +sumer and the content may be determi- +native in deciding whether copyright in- +fringement occurs. +A user’s transmission of programming +from one place to another does not in- +fringe on the public performance right +when all content and equipment are in +the subscriber’s posession. + +Internet delivery of broadcast television + +2012 WPIX, Inc. v. ivi, Inc. + +2014 American Broadcast- + +ing Companies v. Aereo + +Internet-based broadcast television ser- +vice ivi did not qualify for compulsory li- +censes to retransmit broadcast television. +Aereo’s place-shifting service required +retransmission consent because they ap- +peared too much like a cable provider, but +another court judged that they did not re- +semble a cable provider enough to qualify +for compulsory licenses. + +Table 1: Highlights of significant judicial decisions in the United States re- +lated to time-shifting, place-shifting, and Internet delivery of broad- +cast television. + +summary and global outlook + +Table 1 summarizes key precedents set by cases discussed in this tutorial. +Given these decisions, the only certainty is that cloud multimedia services +remain under a cloud of uncertainty. This is a barrier to technical innovation, +as without legal certainty regarding licensing requirements, companies of- +fering new services are not able to predict costs, and investment in them is +risky. + +The global outlook for cloud multimedia services is similarly uncertain. +Table 2 shows cloud-based multimedia services that have been the subject of +litigation (often dragging on for years, at considerable expense) in Europe +and Asia. These, too, have often yielded contradictory and vague decisions. -6 +The decisions made by legislative bodies, judicial bodies, and regulatory +agencies in the next few years as they apply copyright and communications +law to the Internet will shape market offerings in this area, in terms of how +new technologies can be deployed and what kind of pricing strategies can be +associated with them. Until then, however, key questions - when and where - 07 Basic Parameters + References -Product Name: Smart Watch Operating temperature: 0°C to 45°C -Product model: A2211 Water resistance rating: 5 ATM -Input: DC 5V 500mA MAX Bluetooth frequency: 2402–2480 MHz -Bluetooth version: V5.2 -Bluetooth output power: <12 dBm -View product certification information on the watch's Settings > System > Regulatory page. -Device requirements: Devices installed with Android 7.0 or iOS 14.0 or above OS versions. +13 -The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by -Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such marks by Anhui Huami Information -Technology Co., Ltd. is under license. Other trademarks and trade names -are those of their respective owners. +Location -7 +Service - 08 Battery Safety +Status -1. This device is equipped with a built-in battery that cannot be removed or replaced. Do not disassemble - or modify the battery by yourself. -2. Disposal of a battery into fire or a hot oven, or mechanically crushing or cutting of a battery, that can - result in an explosion. -3. Leaving a battery in an extremely high temperature surrounding environment can result in an - explosion or the leakage of flammable liquid or gas. -4. A battery subjected to extremely low air pressure may result in an explosion or the leakage of - flammable liquid or gas. -5. Do not drop, hit, squeeze, or puncture the battery, and avoid exposing the battery to large external - pressure, which may cause short circuit and overheating inside the battery. +France +United +Kingdom +Finland +Germany -8 +Singapore +Japan +Australia - 09 Safety Notice - -1. Do not allow children or pets to bite or swallow the product or its accessories, as this may cause injury. -2. Do not place this product under excessively high or low temperatures, which may cause the product to - catch fire or explode. -3. Do not place this product near heat sources or open flame, such as ovens and electric heaters. -4. Some people may experience allergic skin reactions to plastics, leathers, fibers, and other materials, and - symptoms such as redness, swelling, and inflammation will occur after long-term contact with this - product's components. If you experience such symptoms, please discontinue use and consult your - doctor. -5. Do not use unauthorized or incompatible power adapters or data cables, which may damage the watch - and accessories, or cause fire, explosion, or other hazards. -6. The radio waves generated by this product may affect the normal operation of implanted medical - devices or personal medical devices, such as pacemakers and hearing aids. If you use any such medical - devices, consult the manufacturer for relevant usage restrictions. -7. Do not dispose of this device or its accessories as ordinary household waste. Please make sure you - dispose of or recycle this device and its accessories in accordance with local laws and regulations. +Wizzgo +TV Catchup -9 +Decided in favor of content owner +Mixed decisions, with litigation ongoing - 10 Repair and Maintenance - -1. Avoid using detergents such as soap, hand sanitizer, bath foam, or lotion for cleaning to prevent chemical - residues from irritating the skin, corroding the device, or degrading the water resistance of the device. -2. After wearing the device while bathing (for devices that support bathing), swimming (for devices that - support swimming), or sweating, please promptly clean and dry the device. -3. The leather strap is not waterproof. Avoid getting the strap wet, as this may shorten its service life. -4. When using light-colored watch straps, avoid contact with dark clothing to prevent staining. -5. Do not wear your watch during snorkeling, hot showers, hot springs, saunas (steam rooms), diving, - underwater diving, water skiing, and other activities involving high-speed water currents. -6. Do not place the device in direct sunlight for long periods. Excessively high or low ambient temperature - may cause device failure. -7. Handle with care during transportation. Keep the device dry and away from humidity. -8. Do not wear the watch in MRI examinations and other highly magnetic environments. Otherwise, the - watchmay be damaged. +Decided in favor of content owner +Mixed decisions, with litigation ongoing -10 +TVkaista +Shift.TV, +Save.TV +Decided in favor of cloud service +Record TV +Rokuraku II +Decided in favor of content owner +Optus TV Now Decided in favor of content owner - 11 Troubleshooting +Table 2: The global outlook for cloud multimedia services is equally uncer- +tain. These services have been involved in extensive litigation, often +with multiple appeals dragging on for years. -Please check the FAQ on the website: https://support.amazfit.com/en. -If the product is not in use for a long period of time, it is recommended that you power off the product before -storing it. Recharge the battery every 6 months to 100% to prevent battery damage by over-discharge due to -long-term storage. +will network users consume multimedia content? what kinds of relation- +ships will exist between network service providers, content distributors, and +content owners? - remain unanswered. -12 Warranty and Return Policy +acknowledgments -The Amazfit Limited Warranty covers Amazfit products against manufacturing defects beginning on the -original purchase date. The warranty period is 12 months or another specified period as the applicable -consumer laws in the consumer’s country of purchase require. Our warranty is in addition to rights provided -by applicable consumer laws. +This work was supported in part by the U.S. National Science Foundation +through the Graduate Research Fellowship Program Award 1104522, and by +the New York State Center for Advanced Technology in Telecommunications +(CATT). -Official website: en.amazfit.com -Support: support.amazfit.com/en +references -11 +[1] Sandvine, “Global Internet phenomena report,” May 2015. https: + +//www.sandvine.com/trends/global-internet-phenomena/. + +[2] S. Sen, C. Joe-Wong, S. Ha, and M. Chiang, “A survey of smart data +pricing: Past proposals, current plans, and future trends,” ACM Comput. +Surv., vol. 46, pp. 15:1–15:37, Nov. 2013. + +[3] S. Sen, C. Joe-Wong, S. Ha, and M. Chiang, “Incentivizing time-shifting +of data: a survey of time-dependent pricing for Internet access,” IEEE +Communications Magazine, vol. 50, pp. 91–99, November 2012. + +[4] H.-T. Chiao, F.-C. Chen, K.-S. Hsu, and S.-M. Yuan, “Video everywhere +through a scalable IP-streaming service framework,” in 3rd International +Symposium on Wireless Communication Systems (ISWCS’06), pp. 190–194, +IEEE, 2006. + +[5] G. Pallis and A. Vakali, “Insight and perspectives for content delivery +networks,” Communications of the ACM, vol. 49, pp. 101–106, Jan. 2006. + +[6] L. Chen, M. Meo, and A. Scicchitano, “Caching video contents in IPTV +systems with hierarchical architecture,” in IEEE International Conference +on Communications (ICC’09), pp. 1–6, IEEE, 2009. + +[7] C. Huang, J. Li, and K. W. Ross, “Can Internet video-on-demand be +profitable?,” SIGCOMM Comput. Commun. Rev., vol. 37, pp. 133–144, +Aug. 2007. + + References + +14 + +[8] N. Vratonji´c, P. Gupta, N. Kneževi´c, D. Kosti´c, and A. Rowstron, “En- +abling DVD-like features in P2P video-on-demand systems,” in Proceed- +ings of the 2007 workshop on Peer-to-peer streaming and IP-TV, pp. 329–334, +ACM, 2007. + +[9] V. Misra, “Routing money, not packets,” Communications of the ACM, + +vol. 58, no. 6, pp. 24–27, 2015. + +[10] R. Sherman, D. Waterman, and Y. Jeon, “The future of online video: An +economic and policy perspective,” in 2014 TPRC Conference Paper, 2014. + +[11] A. D. Thierer and B. Skorup, “Video marketplace regulation: A primer +on the history of television regulation and current legislative proposals,” +Available at SSRN 2432177, April 2014. + +[12] C. L. Saw and W. B. Chik, “Whither the future of Internet streaming and +time-shifting? revisiting the rights of reproduction and communication +to the public in copyright law after Aereo,” International Journal of Law +and Information Technology, vol. 23, pp. 53–88, February 2015. + +[13] Y. Xiao, X. Du, J. Zhang, F. Hu, and S. Guizani, “Internet Protocol +Television (IPTV): The killer application for the next-generation Internet,” +IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 45, pp. 126–134, November 2007. + +[14] L. Zhang and D. Wang, “Sponsoring content: Motivation and pitfalls +for content service providers,” in IEEE Conference on Computer Communi- +cations Workshops (INFOCOM WKSHPS), pp. 577–582, IEEE, 2014. diff --git a/q41/random_k2/question.json b/q41/random_k2/question.json index 44f32dc0da7e4a40dc6ea410c9fe7d1e75b24f8c..f0d06709891936a02d3b0ebe5d043f3fd794cfd3 100644 --- a/q41/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q41/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "finalpresentationdeck-whatwhyhowofcertificationsocial-160324220748_95.pdf", - "web_9deb1a47e107dc04.pdf", - "c726c35b04831158d54cee8acd7202672bb42877.pdf" + "web_77f281bc58aa8364.pdf", + "web_e90c53ca1c265ed4.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q41/random_k2/random_1.md b/q41/random_k2/random_1.md index 7e875d55d5f93fef49815a4921bd61abaa902c5b..602df279b63a2b7c5600ed9bc60d31b5343359ac 100644 --- a/q41/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q41/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1736 +1,2008 @@ -1. - -2. - -3. - -4. - -5. - -6. - -7. - -About These Forms - -In General. This and the other pleading forms available from the www.uscourts.gov -website illustrate some types of information that are useful to have in complaints and -some other pleadings. The forms do not try to cover every type of case. They are limited -to types of cases often filed in federal courts by those who represent themselves or who -may not have much experience in federal courts. - -Not Legal Advice. No form provides legal advice. No form substitutes for having or -consulting a lawyer. If you are not a lawyer and are suing or have been sued, it is best to -have or consult a lawyer if possible. - -No Guarantee. Following a form does not guarantee that any pleading is legally or -factually correct or sufficient. - -Variations Possible. A form may call for more or less information than a particular -court requires. The fact that a form asks for certain information does not mean that every -court or a particular court requires it. And if the form does not ask for certain -information, a particular court might still require it. Consult the rules and caselaw that -govern in the court where you are filing the pleading. - -Examples Only. The forms do not try to address or cover all the different types of -claims or defenses, or how specific facts might affect a particular claim or defense. Some -of the forms, such as the form for a generic complaint, apply to different types of cases. -Others apply only to specific types of cases. Be careful to use the form that fits your case -and the type of pleading you want to file. Be careful to change the information the form -asks for to fit the facts and circumstances of your case. - -No Guidance on Timing or Parties. The forms do not give any guidance on when -certain kinds of pleadings or claims or defenses have to be raised, or who has to be sued. -Some pleadings, claims, or defenses have to be raised at a certain point in the case or -within a certain period of time. And there are limits on who can be named as a party in a -case and when they have to be added. Lawyers and people representing themselves must -know the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the caselaw setting out these and other -requirements. The current Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are available, for free, at -www.uscourts.gov. - -Privacy Requirements. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2 addresses the privacy and -security concerns over public access to electronic court files. Under this rule, papers filed -with the court should not contain anyone’s full social-security number or full birth date; -the name of a person known to be a minor; or a complete financial-account number. A -filing may include only the last four digits of a social-security number and taxpayer -identification number; the year of someone’s birth; a minor’s initials; and the last four -digits of a financial-account number. - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT -FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN - -Case No. -________________________________ -(to be filled in by the Clerk’s Office) - -(Write the full name of each plaintiff who is filing this complaint. -If the names of all the plaintiffs cannot fit in the space above, -please write “see attached” in the space and attach an additional -page with the full list of names.) - -Jury Trial: ☐ Yes ☐ No - -(check one) - -v. - -(Write the full name of each defendant who is being sued. If the -names of all the defendants cannot fit in the space above, please -write “see attached” in the space and attach an additional page -with the full list of names.) - -Complaint for a Civil Case - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -I. - -The Parties to This Complaint - -A. - -The Plaintiff(s) - -Provide the information below for each plaintiff named in the complaint. Attach -additional pages if needed. - -Name - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address - -__________________________________________ - -B. - -The Defendant(s) - -Provide the information below for each defendant named in the complaint, whether the -defendant is an individual, a government agency, an organization, or a corporation. -For an individual defendant, include the person’s job or title (if known). Attach -additional pages if needed. - -Defendant No. 1 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ +INTERNATIONAL STUDENT +HANDBOOK -__________________________________________ +A resource guide published by the +Office of International Education +Albany State University +Albany, GA -Street Address + TABLE OF CONTENTS +Notice to Students………………………………………………………………..……………………….. -__________________________________________ +Welcome Letter from ISA……………..…………………………………………………………..………….…………………. -City and County +Financial Documentation………………………………………………………….………………..…….. -__________________________________________ +Academic Life………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…………….. -State and Zip Code +American Customs and Culture………………………………………………………………………………..………… -__________________________________________ +Immigration Status…………………………………….……………………………………………………………..……………. -Telephone Number +Automobiles…………………………………………………………….………………………..…………. -__________________________________________ +Emergencies……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. -E-mail Address -(if known) +English Language…………………………………………………………………………………………… -Defendant No. 2 +Entertainment………………………………………………..………………………………………………………………………. -Name +Health Care…………………………………………………………………………………………………… -Job or Title -(if known) +Housing……………………………………………………………………………….…………………………………………….…. -__________________________________________ +Dining Services……………………………………………………………………………..….…………… -__________________________________________ +Legal Concerns………………………………………….…………………………………………..……………………………… -__________________________________________ +Mail………………………………………..…………………………………………………………………… -Street Address +Money and Banking……………………..……………………………………….………………………………………………... -__________________________________________ +Regent’s Test…………………………………………………………………………………….…………. -City and County +Religious Life……………………………………..…………………………………………………….…………………………… -__________________________________________ +Shopping…………………………………………………………………………..………………………….. -State and Zip Code +Student Athletes ………………………………………….……………………………………………………………..……….. -__________________________________________ +Social Security Numbers ……………………………………………..…………………….…………… -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -2 - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -Defendant No. 3 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -Defendant No. 4 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -II. - -Basis for Jurisdiction - -Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction (limited power). Generally, only two types of -cases can be heard in federal court: cases involving a federal question and cases involving -diversity of citizenship of the parties. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, a case arising under the United -States Constitution or federal laws or treaties is a federal question case. Under 28 U.S.C. -§ 1332, a case in which a citizen of one State sues a citizen of another State or nation and the -amount at stake is more than $75,000 is a diversity of citizenship case. In a diversity of -citizenship case, no defendant may be a citizen of the same State as any plaintiff. - -What is the basis for federal court jurisdiction? (check all that apply) - -☐ Federal question - -☐ Diversity of citizenship - -Fill out the paragraphs in this section that apply to this case. +Taxes……………………………………………….…………………………………………………………………………………… 3 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -A. - -If the Basis for Jurisdiction Is a Federal Question - -List the specific federal statutes, federal treaties, and/or provisions of the United States -Constitution that are at issue in this case. - -B. - -If the Basis for Jurisdiction Is Diversity of Citizenship - -1. - -The Plaintiff(s) - -a. - -b. - -If the plaintiff is an individual -The plaintiff, (name) _________________________________________, -is a citizen of the State of (name) _______________________. - -If the plaintiff is a corporation -The plaintiff, (name) ________________________________________, -is incorporated under the laws of the State of (name) -______________________, and has its principal place of business in the -State of (name) _______________________. - -(If more than one plaintiff is named in the complaint, attach an additional page -providing the same information for each additional plaintiff.) - -2. - -The Defendant(s) - -a. - -b. - -If the defendant is an individual -The defendant, (name) ______________________, is a citizen of the -State of (name) _______________________. Or is a citizen of (foreign -nation) _______________________. - -If the defendant is a corporation -The defendant, (name) _______________________, is incorporated -under the laws of the State of (name) _______________________, and -has its principal place of business in the State of (name) -_______________________. Or is incorporated under the laws of -(foreign nation) _______________________, and has its principal place -of business in (name) _______________________. - -(If more than one defendant is named in the complaint, attach an additional -page providing the same information for each additional defendant.) - 4 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -3. - -The Amount in Controversy - -The amount in controversy—the amount the plaintiff claims the defendant owes -or the amount at stake—is more than $75,000, not counting interest and costs of -court, because (explain): - -III. - -Statement of Claim - -Write a short and plain statement of the claim. Do not make legal arguments. State as briefly -as possible the facts showing that each plaintiff is entitled to the damages or other relief sought. -State how each defendant was involved and what each defendant did that caused the plaintiff -harm or violated the plaintiff’s rights, including the dates and places of that involvement or -conduct. If more than one claim is asserted, number each claim and write a short and plain -statement of each claim in a separate paragraph. Attach additional pages if needed. - 5 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -IV. Relief - -State briefly and precisely what damages or other relief the plaintiff asks the court to order. Do -not make legal arguments. Include any basis for claiming that the wrongs alleged are -continuing at the present time. Include the amounts of any actual damages claimed for the acts -alleged and the basis for these amounts. Include any punitive or exemplary damages claimed, -the amounts, and the reasons you claim you are entitled to actual or punitive money damages. - -V. - -Certification and Closing - -Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11, by signing below, I certify to the best of my -knowledge, information, and belief that this complaint: (1) is not being presented for an -improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of -litigation; (2) is supported by existing law or by a nonfrivolous argument for extending, -modifying, or reversing existing law; (3) the factual contentions have evidentiary support or, if -specifically so identified, will likely have evidentiary support after a reasonable opportunity for -further investigation or discovery; and (4) the complaint otherwise complies with the -requirements of Rule 11. - -A. - -For Parties Without an Attorney - -I agree to provide the Clerk’s Office with any changes to my address where case- -related papers may be served. I understand that my failure to keep a current address on -file with the Clerk’s Office may result in the dismissal of my case. - -Date of signing: _____________________, 20_____. - -Signature of Plaintiff -___________________________________________ -Printed Name of Plaintiff ___________________________________________ - 6 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -Additional Information: - -7 - - JS 44 (Rev. 10/20) - -CIVIL COVER SHEET -The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as -provided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the -purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON NEXT PAGE OF THIS FORM.) -I. (a) PLAINTIFFS - -County in which action arose: _______________ - -DEFENDANTS - -(b) County of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff +10 -(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES) +12 -County of Residence of First Listed Defendant +18 -NOTE: +19 -(IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY) -IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF -THE TRACT OF LAND INVOLVED. +21 -(c) Attorneys (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number) +21 -Attorneys (If Known) +22 -II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION (Place an “X” in One Box Only) +24 -III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES (Place an “X” in One Box for Plaintiff +26 -1 U.S. Government -Plaintiff +27 -3 Federal Question +28 -(U.S. Government Not a Party) +29 -Citizen of This State +30 -PTF -1 +32 -DEF -1 +32 -(For Diversity Cases Only) +33 -and One Box for Defendant) +34 -PTF +35 -Incorporated or Principal Place -of Business In This State +Telephone and Telegrams ……………………….……………………………………………………….. 35 -2 U.S. Government +Testing …………………….………………….……………………………………………………………..… -Defendant +Transportation ……………………….…………………………………………………………………………………………… -4 Diversity +Campus Contacts…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… -Citizen of Another State +Checklists……………………………………………………………………………………………………… -(Indicate Citizenship of Parties in Item III) +Services for International Students ………………………………………………………….………………………………. -DEF -4 +36 -5 +36 -6 +38 -4 +39 -5 +40 -6 + Office of International Education -2 +NOTICE TO STUDENTS +This guide should be used in combination with the ASU Undergraduate +Catalog/ASU Graduate Catalog and the RAM Student Handbook. The University +Catalog contains important information and regulations of the university that you +will need to know. You should obtain a copy of the Catalog (Undergraduate or +Graduate) and the RAM Student Handbook as soon as you begin your program +of study. 3 -2 - -Incorporated and Principal Place -of Business In Another State - -3 - -Foreign Nation - -Click here for: Nature of Suit Code Descriptions. -OTHER STATUTES - -BANKRUPTCY - -IV. NATURE OF SUIT (Place an “X” in One Box Only) - -TORTS - -CONTRACT - -110 Insurance -120 Marine -130 Miller Act -140 Negotiable Instrument -150 Recovery of Overpayment - -PERSONAL INJURY -310 Airplane -315 Airplane Product - -Liability - -320 Assault, Libel & - -& Enforcement of Judgment - -Slander - -151 Medicare Act -152 Recovery of Defaulted - -Student Loans -(Excludes Veterans) -153 Recovery of Overpayment -of Veteran’s Benefits - -160 Stockholders’ Suits -190 Other Contract -195 Contract Product Liability -196 Franchise - -REAL PROPERTY -210 Land Condemnation -220 Foreclosure -230 Rent Lease & Ejectment -240 Torts to Land -245 Tort Product Liability -290 All Other Real Property - -330 Federal Employers’ - -Liability - -340 Marine -345 Marine Product -Liability -350 Motor Vehicle -355 Motor Vehicle - -Product Liability - -360 Other Personal - -Injury - -362 Personal Injury - - -Medical Malpractice - -CIVIL RIGHTS -440 Other Civil Rights -441 Voting -442 Employment -443 Housing/ - -Accommodations -445 Amer. w/Disabilities - - -Employment - -446 Amer. w/Disabilities - - -Other -448 Education - -Citizen or Subject of a -Foreign Country - -FORFEITURE/PENALTY - -625 Drug Related Seizure - -of Property 21 USC 881 - -690 Other - -PERSONAL INJURY -365 Personal Injury - -Product Liability - -367 Health Care/ - -Pharmaceutical -Personal Injury -Product Liability - -368 Asbestos Personal -Injury Product -Liability - -422 Appeal 28 USC 158 -423 Withdrawal -28 USC 157 - -PROPERTY RIGHTS -820 Copyrights -830 Patent -835 Patent - Abbreviated - -New Drug Application - -840 Trademark -880 Defend Trade Secrets - -PERSONAL PROPERTY - -LABOR - -710 Fair Labor Standards - -Act of 2016 - -Act - -720 Labor/Management - -Relations - -740 Railway Labor Act -751 Family and Medical - -Leave Act - -790 Other Labor Litigation -791 Employee Retirement -Income Security Act - -IMMIGRATION - -462 Naturalization Application -465 Other Immigration - -Actions + Office of International Education -SOCIAL SECURITY -861 HIA (1395ff) -862 Black Lung (923) -863 DIWC/DIWW (405(g)) -864 SSID Title XVI -865 RSI (405(g)) +Dear International Student: -FEDERAL TAX SUITS -870 Taxes (U.S. Plaintiff -or Defendant) -871 IRS—Third Party -26 USC 7609 +It gives me great pleasure to welcome you to the campus of Albany State University. I +will serve as your International Student Advisor. I want you to know that you are a +valuable part of the ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY family like any other student and most +of all I want you to be successful in your studies. -370 Other Fraud -371 Truth in Lending -380 Other Personal +To help you reach this goal, I offer services that include providing you with important +information about your visa status and the benefits it includes. There are laws and +regulations you are required to follow in order to legally remain in the U.S. and I am +required to submit updates and other reports regularly and by specific deadlines to +confirm that. -Property Damage -385 Property Damage -Product Liability +This guide is designed to help you locate the resources and services you will need while +you are at ASU and answer some of your questions. You are encouraged to ALWAYS +know your F-1 Visa Student Status and regulation involved. -PRISONER PETITIONS +As an international student at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY you are required to meet +with me each semester of your matriculation. I encourage you to schedule +appointments so that we can meet to discuss and review options available to you at any +point of your educational endeavors at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY. -Habeas Corpus: -463 Alien Detainee -510 Motions to Vacate +In addition, please note that while you are matriculating as an International Student +ASU currently does not provide any financial assistance for you. It is your responsibility +to have the financial resources to continue your education. If for any reason you are +unable to continue to make financial contribution to your education endeavors you are +at risk of being in violation of the student immigration status. (please see the next page) -Sentence -530 General -535 Death Penalty -Other: -540 Mandamus & Other -550 Civil Rights -555 Prison Condition -560 Civil Detainee - -Conditions of -Confinement +I look forward to assisting you at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY and seeing you reach the +end of your program as focused and ready for the future as you are here today. -375 False Claims Act -376 Qui Tam (31 USC +Sincerely, -3729(a)) +Sue Ann Balch, J.D. +F1-Visa Student Advisor +sueann.balch@asurams.edu (Email) +229-430-7075 (Office Number) +229-434-7106 (fax Number) +205 Reese Hall -400 State Reapportionment -410 Antitrust -430 Banks and Banking -450 Commerce -460 Deportation -470 Racketeer Influenced and -Corrupt Organizations - -480 Consumer Credit - -(15 USC 1681 or 1692) - -485 Telephone Consumer -Protection Act -490 Cable/Sat TV -850 Securities/Commodities/ - -Exchange - -890 Other Statutory Actions -891 Agricultural Acts -893 Environmental Matters -895 Freedom of Information - -Act -896 Arbitration -899 Administrative Procedure -Act/Review or Appeal of -Agency Decision -950 Constitutionality of -State Statutes - -V. ORIGIN (Place an “X” in One Box Only) - -1 Original - -Proceeding - -2 Removed from -State Court - -3 Remanded from -Appellate Court - -4 Reinstated or -Reopened - -5 Transferred from -Another District -(specify) - -6 Multidistrict -Litigation - -Transfer +4 -8 Multidistrict -Litigation - -Direct File + Financial Documentation (Required Forms) +You can acquire these forms from the office of Recruitment and Admission -Cite the U.S. Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not cite jurisdictional statutes unless diversity): +*Albany State University International Student Financial Statement (To Be Completed by Student) -VI. CAUSE OF ACTION +*I-34 Affidavit of Support (To Be Completed By Sponsor, Affirmed Under Oath and Notarized) -Brief description of cause: +Original/Official Supporting Financial Documentation Must be: -VII. REQUESTED IN +1. Written in English or have certified English translation attached and a +recognized transcript evaluation by a company such as WES or Silney. +2. Dated no more than six months prior to the first day of the semester you -COMPLAINT: -VIII. RELATED CASE(S) +plan to attend. -IF ANY +3. Clearly state the account balance in United States Dollar amount(s). +4. Must provide the following information: Date account opened; total -CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION -UNDER RULE 23, F.R.Cv.P. +amount deposited for the past year; +Tuition and fees +Living Expenses +Expenses of dependant +Other: Books & Health Insurance -DEMAND $ +$14,600.00 +$9,000.00 +$0.00 +$4,000.00 +*$27,600.00 -CHECK YES only if demanded in complaint: +(*Fee changes yearly, 2016 cost listed above) -JURY DEMAND: +5. All monies for tuition, health insurance, Room Board, Books & Supplies +and other fees must be must be paid by the first day of classes each +semester at Albany State University after student has been accepted. +This process must occur until the student has completed matriculation at +Albany State University -Yes +How to set-up account? -No +1. After student receives acceptance letter from -(See instructions): +undergraduate or graduate admissions, student will +begin the account set-up process. -JUDGE +2. Student will mail fees for the year in United States -DOCKET NUMBER +Dollar Amount to: -DATE +Albany State University +Financial Operations +Attn: Student Account Manager +504 College Drive +Albany, GA 31705 +3. Student will mail money certified or return receipt -SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD +request or any secure means of mail delivery or pay +in person. -FOR OFFICE USE ONLY +ACADEMIC LIFE +ADVISORS +All students are assigned an academic advisor when they enroll in a degree +program. Your advisor will be a faculty member in your department. He or she +will help you choose which courses to take each semester. If you need to -RECEIPT # +5 -AMOUNT + change your schedule in any way, you must get the approval of your academic +advisor. + +Academic advisors can better serve you when they understand your educational +and career plans. They can help you prepare for graduate school or for a job. +They can arrange work experiences as a part of your degree program if this will +help you. If you give your advisor a clear picture of what you plan to do, he or +she can guide you toward the most suitable courses and university activities. + +INDIVIDUALITY +Individuality is very important to Americans. This value is as important in the +classroom as it is in other parts of U.S. culture. Independent thinking is +expected of students in American classrooms. Interpretation, analysis, critical +thinking, and even challenging the professor may be expected of you in class. +You may be graded on your class participation. Usually, professors will tell you +at the beginning of the course if you are to be evaluated on class participation. +It takes time and practice to get used to speaking out in class, but it is often an +important part of the learning experience. + +REGULATIONS +Certain acts are considered to be academic dishonesty and are not permitted at +Albany State University. Submitting another person’s work as your own or doing +academic work for another person is not allowed. Academic dishonesty includes +copying exam papers, assignments, or term papers or allowing another person to +copy your work. If you use ideas or information published by other people in +papers that you turn in, you must give the writers credit by providing citations in +footnotes or references. Your professors will tell you how to do this. Students +who turn in work which is not their own will be disciplined by the professor and +possibly the university. It could lead to expulsion from the university. + +GLOSSARY OF “UNIVERSITY LANGUAGE” +CATALOG/BULLETIN +The university publishes an undergraduate and graduate catalog. These catalogs +are sometimes called bulletins. They include information on all aspects of +university life, including regulations governing academic life, course descriptions, +and a list of faculty members. You must follow the rules set forth in the catalog +for your academic program. It is an important resource. Read it carefully and +refer to it when you need information about academic offerings and +requirements. + +CLASS +Sessions or meetings of particular courses. These are listed in the Schedule +Report, issued each semester, which lists the days, times and venues the class +meets. + +COLLEGE +The University is divided into units known as “Colleges.” The Colleges at ASU +are the Colleges of Arts and Humanities, College of Business, College of -APPLYING IFP +6 -JUDGE + Education, and College of Science and Health Professions. Unlike many other +countries, the term college in U.S. usage does not refer to high school or +secondary education. It is often used interchangeably with the term university. + +COMPREHENSIVE EXAMINATION +Examinations are required by most departments before a student can receive a +Master’s degree. The exams test the student’s knowledge of his or her entire +field of study. + +CORE CURRICULUM +The Core Curriculum is composed of a wide spectrum of general courses. It is +designed to give all students a broad base of basic knowledge and is required of +all students seeking bachelor’s degrees at ASU. + +COURSE +Subject Offerings. These are listed in the course catalog, by department. +Students usually take 4-5 courses per semester. The course listings are also +available through BANNER on the ASU website. + +CREDIT HOUR +Courses are given credit hour values. Most courses are 3 credit hours. This +means that the course meets for approximately 3 hours each week during the +semester. 1-hour course meets for 1 hour, etc. In order to be considered full- +time, undergraduates must enroll in 12 credit hours, graduate students need to +take 9 credit hours each semester. + +CURRICULUM +This refers to the program that you are following, and its requirements. There +are required courses and elective courses in most curricula. + +DEPARTMENT +Within each College are several Departments that specialize in a certain subject. +For example, the College of Education includes the Department of Teacher +Education and Department of Counseling and Educational Leadership. + +DROP-DATE +Students may choose to drop or withdraw from a course without penalty up to +the middle of the semester. However, you must remember that: + +1. As a foreign student, you must remain a full-time student at all times. +You must be enrolled for 12 hours at all times, unless it is a vacation +period which is the summer semester or you otherwise have +permission from the DSO in the International Office. Graduate +students must take 9 hours. + +2. Withdrawal hour’s associated with classes that are dropped due to +documented extenuating circumstances will be included in the 12 +hour total. -MAG. JUDGE +7 - PURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 83.11 + 3. Students will receive a “WF” (This symbol indicates withdrawal with penalty) for course + +withdrawals identified after the 16 hour limit has been reached. +There are financial and G.P.A conditions associated with the “WF”. + +4. “W” (This symbol indicates that a student was permitted to withdraw without penalty) grades will be awarded to +students who withdraw from classes prior to the end of the schedule +change deadline and to those students who are authorized to +withdraw due to extenuating circumstances. + +After the midterm drop-date, special permission is required for course +withdrawal. The grade the student has earned up to the point of withdrawal will +be reflected on his or her transcript; however, it will not affect the GPA. In +addition, as a F1-Visa Student you are required to notify the International +student Advisor of any schedule changes you are making. + +ELECTIVE COURSE +These are optional courses. Each student must choose several of these courses. +The academic advisor will suggest specific electives. + +FINAL +This is the last, major examination of the semester. Usually, one week is set +aside at the end of the semester for final exams. A final is a long exam, which +sometimes lasts as long as two hours. Not all professors choose to give final +exams. Some will assign research papers or special projects instead. + +GRADE POINT AVERAGE +Your performance is evaluated with grades of A, B, C, D, or F. The grades A +through F are given a numerical value (A=4, F=0) and weighted by the number +of credit hours associated with each grade. Your grade point average is +computed by averaging the numerical values of the credit hours for all of the +courses you have completed. “GPA” is the common abbreviation for Grade Point +Average. + +GRADUATE STUDENTS +These are students who have already received a Bachelor’s degree or the +equivalent. The graduate degrees offered at ASU are the Specialist degree in +Education and Master’s degree in several disciplines. +MID-TERM +A Mid-Term is a major examination given in many classes in the middle of the +semester. This word also refers to the date signaling the end of the first half of +the semester. + +MINOR +A secondary, optional program of study in addition to the student’s major. + +SEMESTER +The school year at Albany State University is divided into two semesters. Fall +semester, which begins in August and spring semester, which begins in January, + +8 + + constitute the normal academic year. There is a full six-week summer session. +Summer terms are optional terms for foreign students. + +QUIZ +An informal examination, shorter in length than a regular examination. + +REQUIRED COURSE +These are courses which each student seeking a particular degree must take. + +RESEARCH PAPER +This is a major paper which can be from 5 to 25 pages in length. In order to +write this paper, a student must select an approved topic, somewhat narrow in +scope, and do research in the library. Papers are to be typed. There are +manuals in the bookstore to show you how to type it, or you can hire a +professional typist. + +SECTION +Some courses are offered in a number of sections, or classes, each semester, so +that a large number of students may attend. A course number, section letter, +and call number identify each section. + +SYLLABUS +A list of information about a course including the books you will use, the +professor’s name, office and phone number. Usually there is a general outline of +how the course will proceed, and sometimes assignments and dates of +examinations are included. + +TRANSCRIPT +A record of students’ courses and grades. An “official transcript” is sealed by the +issuing institution, and normally sent directly to the school or office requesting it. +It is used to document a student’s academic performance while attending +college. Universities, graduate schools, and some employers use this to +determine the desirability of accepting or hiring students. + +UNDERGRADUATE +These are students who are studying for their first degree at the university. +During the first year, students are called freshmen; the second year, +sophomores; the third year, juniors; and their last year, seniors. The +undergraduate degree is the Bachelor’s degree. + +9 + + AMERICAN CUSTOMS AND CULTURE +The culture and customs of the United States are difficult to define precisely, +because geographic areas and the people who live in them differ. Most of what +you will learn about the customs and culture of the people of the United States +will be by experience and through contact with people. + +While you are in the U.S., it is good to learn the customs of the people here. It +is important, however, that you maintain your own values and beliefs. If you’re +personal preferences or religious beliefs influence you not to do certain things, +do not be embarrassed to explain this. + +TIME +Being on time is very important in the American society. Classes, parties, +concerts, meetings, and other planned events all start at a specific time. If you +need to see someone, you should ALWAYS make an appointment beforehand. +Do not show up at their office or home unexpectedly. It is considered very +important not to be late to scheduled appointments or events. If you are late for +an appointment, it is important to apologize to the person(s) you have kept +waiting. Students who are always late for appointments or who turn in +assignments after the deadline earn negative reputations. Many professors will +deduct from a grade if an assignment is late or if a student arrives late for class. + +INFORMALITY +There is a great deal of informality between all types of people in the U.S. It is +our way of life. The American society does not have a formal class structure. +We may dress more casually and act more informally in social situations than you +may be used to. + +GREETING, INVITATIONS, AND VISITING +The most common forms of greeting are a handshake, smile and “Hello, I’m +pleased to meet you.” The Americans do not usually embrace in public, except +with members of their family or very close friends. + +Professors should be addressed as Doctor or Professor unless they request +otherwise. You should also use titles (usually Mr., Mrs., or Ms.) with older +persons unless they ask you to call them by their first name. For other students, +it is customary that you address them by their first name. + +If you are invited somewhere and you accept the invitation, it is VERY +IMPORTANT that you appear at the event. Do not accept an invitation simply +because you are afraid to say no. If you cannot or do not want to go to the +event, politely tell the person who invited you htat you cannot or choose not to +attend. It is much more inappropriate to accept an invitation and then fail to +appear than it is to decline the invitation in the first place. If invited to visit +someone’s home, you are not normally expected to bring a gift. It is always +acceptable, but not necessary, to bring a small token or an inexpensive gift to +your host or hostess. An expensive gift is usually inappropriate and may make + +10 + + your host or hostess uncomfortable or embarrassed. American homes, usually +does not have domestic servants, so if you stay as a houseguest, it is proper for +you to make your own bed or volunteer to help with other household chores. + +TABLE MANNERS +Table manners is most common to Americans including not speaking with food in +your mouth, keeping your elbows off the table, and keeping your hands in you +lap while you’re not eating. A knife, fork, and spoon are used unless “finger +foods” are being served. You should not belch at the table after eating; this is +considered rude in the U.S. After the meal is finished, the napkin should be laid +beside the plate and used silverware should be laid across the top of the plate. + +RELATIONSHIPS +Most Americans have many friendly acquaintances, but just a few close friends. +Visitors from other countries often remark that Americans are very friendly, even +at the first meeting, but that it is difficult to get to know them very well. +Sometimes this is true; although Americans are friendly to everyone, they are +also very private people and often have just a few intimate friends. + +Americans often say things like “let’s get together sometime” as a friendly way to +say good-bye, NOT as an invitation. If you would like to get to know someone +better, it is a good idea for you to invite them to go somewhere with you on a +specific day, at a scheduled time. Participate in as many social activities as you +can and you will meet and make many new friends. + +MEN AND WOMEN +American women are independent, and women and men are considered equal. +It is not appropriate to whistle at, touch, or make personal comments about +women whom you do not know EXTREMELY well. It is common for American +university women to live alone or with other women in apartments off campus. +Guests of both sexes are often invited to these apartments. Do not assume that +your hostess has romantic intentions simply because she has invited you to stop +by her apartment. + +There are no clear guidelines for dating Americans. If you want to get to know +someone, it is often best just to ask the person to join you for a snack or to get +together to study. It is important to remember, however, that if two people go +out on a date, it only means that they enjoy each other’s company. It does not +always indicate serious intentions or constitute a promise! If you begin to date +someone from another culture, it is important to remember that s/he simply may +not view the relationship in the same way that you do, especially regarding the +seriousness of the relationship or the desire to engage in sexual activity. + +11 + + It is most often the man who invites the woman out on a date, and customarily +the man pays all of the expenses unless the persons agree that it will be a +“Dutch Treat,” that is, each person pays for his or her own expenses. Women +sometimes ask men for dates. A woman who asks a man out should be +prepared to pay for the expenses. + +BATHING AND HYGIENE +Most Americans bathe or shower daily, and use deodorants and anti- perspirants. +Americans are not accustomed to body odors and find it offensive. Some +international visitors may want to adjust their bathing habits and accommodate +American preferences for the time they are here. + +CULTURE SHOCK +There are many differences between the American culture and the home culture +of many international students. Adapting to these differences can cause “culture +shock.” If you are having trouble adjusting to life in the U.S., or are +experiencing depression or physical or emotional problems, you may be +experiencing culture shock. The Office of the International Student Advisor can +provide cross-cultural counseling to help you, or refer you to a counselor on +campus free of charge. Counseling is always confidential. + +ADDITIONAL INFORMATION +If you would like additional information about American culture, please visit the +Office of the International Student Advisor. The office contains several +handbooks and guidebooks for foreign visitors in the United States. + +IMMIGRATION STATUS +THE U.S. CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES (USCIS) is the branch of +the Federal government created to monitor the entry and exit of foreign +nationals. This branch of the government was formerly known as the +Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). You will encounter INS officials as +you travel between the U.S. and your home country and when you apply for +special programs. The following information should help you understand the +regulations concerning student immigration status. Most ASU students have +either F-1 or J-1 immigration status. + +PASSPORT +Your passport must be valid at all times. When it is time to renew your passport, +contact your country’s embassy in Washington, D.C. to determine what +procedures you need to follow in order to extend your passport. + +VISA +There is a visa stamped in your passport, which permitted you to enter the +United States. A single entry visa permits you to enter the U.S. only once on +that specific visa. A multiple entry visa allows you to enter the U.S. as many +times as you like (after leaving on vacations or trips home) as long as you + +12 + + remain a full-time student. Student stays are valid for the “duration of status”. +This status is indicated by the mark “D/S’ in your passport and on your I-20/DS- +2019 and I-94. As long as you remain in full-time student status, you are in the +country legally, regardless of the expiration date on your entry visa. +If you leave the U.S. after your visa expires, you must go to a U.S. Embassy or +Consulate-General in your home country and obtain a new visa before you can +return to the U.S. It is difficult to obtain a new visa in a “third country.” It is +difficult to obtain new F-1 visas in Canada or Mexico, unless you are from those +countries. + +F-1 IMMIGRATION STATUS +If you are a full-time degree-seeking student or a Rotary student at ASU, you +have entered the U.S. with F-1 immigration status. This type of immigration +status is designed to allow you to obtain your degree and return home following +your graduation. F-1 status is a “non-immigrant” status. “Non-immigrant” +means that you are not moving to the U.S. permanently. This immigration status +is valid for “duration of status.” + +• You should carefully consider the dates of your authorized stay and +make sure you are following the procedures under U.S. immigration +laws. It is important that you depart the U.S. on or before the last +day you are authorized to be in the U.S. on any given trip, based on +the specified end date on your Arrival-Departure Record, Form I-94. +Failure to depart the U.S. will cause you to be out-of- +status. Additional information on successfully maintaining your +immigration status while a student or exchange visitor can be found +on the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) website. +• Staying beyond the period of time authorized by the Department of + +Homeland Security (DHS) and being out-of-status in the +United States is a violation of U.S. immigration laws, and may cause +you to be ineligible for a visa in the future for return travels to the +U.S. + +• Staying unlawfully in the United States beyond the date Customs and +Border Protection (CBP) officials have authorized--even by one day-- +results in your visa being automatically voided, in accordance with +INA 222(g). Under this provision of immigration law, if you overstay +on your nonimmigrant authorized stay in the U.S., your visa will be +automatically voided. In this situation, you are required to reapply for +a new nonimmigrant visa, generally in your country of nationality. + +• For non immigrants in the U.S. who have an Arrival-Departure + +Record, Form I-94 with the CBP admitting officer endorsement of +Duration of Status or D/S, but who are no longer performing the +same function in the U.S. that they were originally admitted +to perform (e.g. you are no longer working for the same employer or +you are no longer attending the same school), a DHS or an +immigration judge makes a finding of status violation, resulting in the +termination of the period of authorized stay. + +13 + + Staying Beyond Your Authorized Stay in the U.S. and Being Out of Status + +• You should carefully consider the dates of your authorized stay and make +sure you are following the procedures under U.S. immigration laws. It is +important that you depart the U.S. on or before the last day you are +authorized to be in the U.S. on any given trip, based on the specified end +date on your Arrival-Departure Record, Form I-94. Failure to depart the +U.S. will cause you to be out-of-status. Additional information on +successfully maintaining your immigration status while a student or +exchange visitor can be found on the Immigration and Customs +Enforcement (ICE) website. + +• Staying beyond the period of time authorized by the Department of + +Homeland Security (DHS) and being out-of-status in the United States is a +violation of U.S. immigration laws, and may cause you to be ineligible for +a visa in the future for return travel to the U.S. Select Classes of Aliens +Ineligible to Receive Visas to learn more. + +• Staying unlawfully in the United States beyond the date Customs and +Border Protection (CBP) officials have authorized--even by one day-- +results in your visa being automatically voided, in accordance with INA +222(g). Under this provision of immigration law, if you overstay on your +nonimmigrant authorized stay in the U.S., your visa will be automatically +voided. In this situation, you are required to reapply for a new +nonimmigrant visa, generally in your country of nationality. + +• For non immigrants in the U.S. who have an Arrival-Departure Record, +Form I-94 with the CBP admitting officer endorsement of Duration of +Status or D/S, but who are no longer performing the same function in the +U.S. that they were originally admitted to perform (e.g. you are no longer +working for the same employer or you are no longer attending the same +school), a DHS or an immigration judge makes a finding of status +violation, resulting in the termination of the period of authorized stay. + +What Items Do Returning Students Need? + +All applicants applying for renewals must submit: + +• A passport valid for at least six months; +• An application Form DS-156, together with a Form DS-158. Both forms +must be completed and signed. Some applicants will also be required +to complete and sign Form DS-157. Blank forms are available without +charge at all U.S. consular offices and on the Visa Services website +under Visa Applications Forms at the United States Citizenship and +Immigration Services (https://www.uscis.gov/). + +• A receipt for visa processing fee. A receipt showing payment of the visa + +application fee for each applicant, including each child listed in a +parent’s passport who is also applying for a U.S. visa, is needed; +• A new I-20 or an I-20 that has been endorsed on the back by a school + +official within the past 12 months. + +14 + + All applicants applying for renewals should be prepared to submit: + +• A certified copy of your grades from the school in which you are + +enrolled; + +• Financial documents from you or your sponsor, showing your ability to + +cover the cost of your schooling. + +Students Away from Classes More Than Five Months +Students in or outside the U.S., who have been away from classes for more +than five months, will likely need a new visa to enter the U.S. + +How long may I stay on my F-1 student visa? + +When you enter the United States on a student visa, you will usually be +admitted for the duration of your student status. That means you may stay as +long as you are a full-time student, even if the F-1 visa in your passport +expires while you are in America. For a student who has completed the course +of studies shown on the I-20, and any authorized practical training, the +student is allowed the following additional time in the U.S. before departure: + +• F-1 student - An additional 60 days, to prepare for departure from the + +U.S. or to transfer to another school. + +• M-1 student - An additional 30 days to depart the U.S. (Fixed time period, +in total not to exceed one year). The 30 days to prepare for departure is +permitted as long as the student maintained a full course of study and +maintained status. An M student may receive extensions up to three years +for the total program. + +As an example regarding duration of status, if you have a visa that is valid for +five years that will expire on January 1, 2001, and you are admitted into the +U.S. for the duration of your studies (often abbreviated in your passport or on +your I-94 card as "D/S"), you may stay in the U.S. as long as you are a full- +time student. Even if January 1, 2001 passes and your visa expires while in +America, you will still be in legal student status. However, if you depart the +U.S. with an expired visa, you will need to obtain a new one before being able +to return to America and resume your studies. A student visa cannot be +renewed or re-issued in the United States; it must be done at an Embassy or +Consulate abroad. + +FORM I-20 +Before you came to ASU, you were sent Form I-20 by the ASU Admissions Office. +This form is the one you use to obtain your F-1 student visa, and it is a very +important form. You should keep it safe with your passport. A Designated School +Official (DSO) must sign your I-20 whenever you travel outside the United +States, even if you are only going for a short time. If you change degree +programs (change your major), you will need a new I-20. New I-20 forms are +available from the International Admissions Officer on campus at 229-430-4646 +or visit the Office of the International Student Advisor for further assistance. If +you transferred to ASU, be sure to keep your ASU I-20 and the I-20 from your + +15 + + previous school together. Note the date of expiration in #5 on your I-20. If you +need to stay past this time to complete your studies, you must contact a DSO at +least 30 days before this expiration date to extend your stay as a student. + +FULL-TIME STUDENT STATUS (In-Status) +In order to maintain your full time status, you must attend school at least 9 +semester hours per semester for graduate studies and at least 12 semester +hours per semester for undergraduate studies. If you have any questions +about this regulation, please see the International Student Advisor. Students +who fail to maintain this requirement risk being placed on probation and could +lose university scholarships, including International Student Scholarships. To +avoid losing your full-time status, check with your advisor and/or Registrar +before you drop a class. + +VACATION +The Summer Term is considered a vacation period for all non-immigrant +students, as long as the student intends to register full-time for the next term. +You may enroll part-time, full-time or not at all during the summer term. Make +sure you check with the International Student Advisor before taking ANY +semester other than the summer semester off. You can go home for summer +any time you wish. + +VACATIONS INSIDE OR OUTSIDE THE USA + +(A) Inside the USA: You do not need permission of any kind from anyone to +travel anywhere within the USA. Travel between the 50 states is totally +unrestricted. Have fun—see the USA! + +(B) Outside the USA: Before leaving the USA, you must go by the office of a +Designated School Official (DSO) with your passport and I-20 and let the +DSO sign your I-20 and check your visa. Your I-20 must be signed for +you to re-enter the USA. You must have both the signed (or a new) I-20 +and a valid F-1 visa in your passport to re-enter the USA. + +If your visa has expired, you will need to go to a U.S. Embassy or Consulate- +General to get a new visa before you can re-enter the country. U.S. VISAS ARE +NOT ISSUED IN THE USA. If you have dependents that are on an I-20, we need +to check their passports and visas as well. + +PLEASE VISIT THE OFFICE OF THE INTERNATIONAL STUDENT +ADVISOR AT LEAST TWO (2) WEEKS BEFORE YOUR TRIP SO THAT +THERE WILL BE SOMEONE AVAILABLE TO SIGN YOUR DOCUMENTS. + +TRANSFER STUDENTS +If you are transferring from another U.S. college or university to ASU, you must +see the International Student Advisor within 5 days of your registration at the +beginning of the semester for completion of the transfer process, which must be +done to maintain your student status. + +EMPLOYMENT + +16 + + (A) ON-CAMPUS: As soon as you have registered for classes, you may work +on campus as a student assistant in the various departments if hired. . +Each department or facility has its own budget for student workers, so +you must go directly to them to seek employment. Once you have found +a job, you must register with the ASU Human Resources Department +(Department of Human Resources) in order to be paid for your work. To +register, you must have a Social Security Number. For more information +about Social Security Numbers, please see the section on Social Security +Numbers in this handbook. + +(B) OFF CAMPUS—ECONOMIC HARDSHIP: You must see the International + +Student Advisor before you can work off campus. Due to recent changes +in immigration laws, it is virtually impossible for foreign students to work +off campus. The only two exceptions are internships for academic credit +or extreme economic difficulty due to conditions beyond his or her +control. Students must apply to USCIS for permission to accept +employment off campus due to economic hardship, and the ISA can +assist you with this application. + +(C) OFF CAMPUS—PRACTICAL TRAINING: You must see the International +Student Advisor before you can work off campus. Curricular Practical +training (or an internship) is work directly related to your course of study +that will give you “hands-on” job experience that will help you get a +better job when you return to your home country. It can be granted only +after you have been at ASU for an academic year, and then only under +certain specific conditions. There are provisions for curricular practical +training before graduation and after graduation. + +Other than the above types of work, NO OTHER EMPLOYMENT IS PERMITTED +while you are in student status. You may not work off campus without +permission from USCIS and/or the ISA. If you do work off campus illegally, you +will lose your student immigration status and its benefits. Working illegally in the +United States is the most serious violation of non-immigrant status in the eyes of +the USCIS, and you WILL NOT be reinstated if you violate this regulation. + +INFORMATION UPDATES +Any change in address, phone number or marital status must be reported to the +Office of the International Student Advisor (ISA) and the Office of the Registrar +within 10 days. You must report the changes to both offices. If you do not +notify the ISA and the Registrar, you will not receive important mail from the +university. Please note that the Office of the Registrar maintains two addresses +on each student, a local address and a home address. The local address is your +address in Albany. If you live on campus, the university will automatically record +your ASU box number. If you live off campus, you must report your address to +the ISA and the Registrar. The home address is your address in your country. It +is the address you listed on your application for admission. All official +correspondence concerning your grades and your fees will be sent to the home +address. You may want to change your home address to your Albany address to +make sure you receive these notices. If you move off-campus, you must also + +17 + + complete a United States Postal Service Change of Address card and sign the +card. Completing this card will allow the campus mailroom to forward mail to +you at your new address. + +THE CARDINAL RULE +If you have questions about working or any other USCIS-related +matter while in the USA, visit the Office of the International Student +Advisor. The Office of the International Student Advisor and +Designated School Officials are here to assist you. We will help you as +much as we can; however, it is YOUR RESPONSIBILITY to keep the +office informed of your status and to ask for help when you need it. The +U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Services holds you accountable for +your own actions and expects you to follow all laws pertaining to your +immigration status. If you choose to violate the law or fail to educate +yourself about the law, you will be responsible, not the Office of the +International Student Advisor. Do not allow yourself to fall out of +status. Do not rely on the advice of other students for immigration +matters. You could lose the privilege of studying in the U.S. now, and +you could be prevented from returning to the U.S. in the future. + +A revision of the immigration law, the Illegal Immigration Reform and +Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, contains very harsh penalties of +students who violate student immigrant status, including provision to +prevent offenders from returning to the United States for periods of +several years. The new immigration regulations based on this act are +currently in place, but because the law is a new one, there are often +modifications or updates to the regulations. The International Student +Advisor will keep you informed about modifications in the regulations. + +AUTOMOBILES +REQUIRED INSURANCE +Law requires liability insurance for a car. If you own an automobile in Georgia, +you must purchase liability insurance. Collision insurance is not required, but it is +recommended. Proof of insurance, usually in the form of an insurance card, +must be carried in the car at all times. Look in the “Yellow Pages” of the phone +book to locate insurance agents, or ask a friend to refer you. Compare prices +with several companies before buying. + +DRIVER’S LICENSE +As a non-resident student at the university, you may drive in Georgia with a valid +international driver’s license. If you do not have an international license or if +your license expires during your stay, you may apply for a state of Georgia +license at the `Dougherty County Department of Motor Vehicle Safety (DMVS), +2062 Newton Road, Albany. The contact telephone number is 229-430-4258. +Getting a Georgia license requires a written test and a driving test. You should +present your passport, I-94, and your I-20 or DS-2019 to the examiner. You will +also need to bring a lease or utility bill, which verifies your address. If you live in + +18 + + a residence hall, you may also need a letter from the International Student +Advisor certifying that you live on-campus. The fee for a five-year license for +driving a passenger car is $20.00. A provisional permit costs $10.00. All fees +must be paid in cash. In addition, you will need a denial letter from the Social +Security Office and/or a Social Security Card. Also, you will need a letter from +your International Student Advisor before you go. + +Many students find that having a State of Georgia license helps them to obtain +lower rates for automobile insurance. Georgia identification cards are also +available at the driver’s license office for a fee. Both the license and the ID card +contain photographs of the bearer. Because the driver’s license and the state ID +card are the most widely accepted forms of identification, it is easier to verify +your address and age with these items than with your passport or ASU ID. +Having proper identification is especially important for writing checks and +handling other banking matters. You should consider obtaining an official form +of identification other than your passport. If you must carry your passport with +you at all times, you risk losing it. You should call the license bureau at 229-430- +4258 to make sure that the test is being given on the day you plan to apply for a +license. The bureau is closed on Mondays and will not give tests when it is +raining. + +If you hold a license from another state in the U.S. or from another country, you +will need to surrender this license to obtain a Georgia license. Please note that +once an out-of-state license has been surrendered to the State of Georgia, it is +not possible to reclaim the license. You should consider whether you wish to +surrender your home country license before you go to the bureau. If you have +questions about this regulation, please see the International Student Advisor. + +RULES OF THE ROAD +Although your international license is valid in the U.S., it is a good idea to read +the State of Georgia Driver’s Manual before you begin driving. Every country has +different traffic laws. Reading these laws in advance could prevent you from +having an accident. Copies of the State of Georgia Driver’s Manual are available +in the Office of the International Student Advisor. + +TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS +If you break any of the traffic laws, including driving over the speed limit, you +risk being stopped by a police officer. If a police or sheriff car follows you with +flashing lights and sirens, the officer wants you to pull over to the side of the +road. You should be prepared to pull over in a safe spot and do as the officer +instructs. Usually, the officer will ask to see your driver’s license, proof of liability +insurance, and registration for the car. He will also ask you questions about your +driving. If you have broken a traffic law, he may issue you a citation (ticket). +Citations involve paying fines, and in extreme cases, imprisonments. If you are +in an accident, you must wait at the scene of the accident for a police officer to +investigate the accident. Do not move the car and do not leave until the officer +has interviewed you about the accident. + +PARKING + +19 + + Most parking in Albany is free. Parking on the ASU campus requires a permit, +which costs $15 per academic year. Please refer to the ASU Parking and +Transportation resource guide for parking regulations. If parking regulations are +violated, you will get a “ticket” and be required to pay a fine. Parking Rules on +campus are clearly stated in the RAM Student Handbook. + +RENTAL AND PURCHASE +If you have a valid driver’s license and are at least 21 years old, you will probably +be able to rent or lease a car. Some rental places also require a credit card in +your name or that you are at least 25 years of age. Check with the larger local +car dealerships about short- and long-term rental. + +If you wish to buy a car for your stay in the U.S., be CAREFUL. Most companies +will service your car if it needs repair after purchase. You must pay for all +repairs unless you have a “manufacturer’s warranty” or paper which states that +the maker of the car will pay for repairs for a limited period of time after +purchase. If you buy a used car from a private dealer or individual, check the +vehicle carefully before purchase. It might help to bring a friend who knows +about the mechanical working of an automobile to inspect the car for you. An +honest car dealer will be happy to let you inspect all parts of the car and +remember to ask questions before you buy. When purchasing a car, you must +have a TITLE and LICENCE PLATE (tag) from the State of Georgia. The dealer +where you purchased the car will give you the correct papers to fill out and help +you obtain these things. In addition, you must renew items such as insurance, +license and tags on a yearly basis. If you buy a car from an individual, be sure to +ask for assistance with these items. If you are bringing a car to Albany from +another state, you must transfer the title for the car and obtain license plates +from the State of Georgia. You should also notify your insurance company that +you have moved. + +License plates must be renewed each year before paying the tax on your car. +Once you have paid the tax, you will be given a sticker for that year. The sticker +should be placed in the upper right hand corner of the license plate. If you have +questions about license plates, please contact the Dougherty County Tag Office, +225 Pine Avenue, Room 104, Albany, GA. The telephone number is 229-431- +3255. + +EMERGENCIES +To call the POLICE, AMBULANCE, or FIRE DEPARTMENT, dial 911. Call this +number only if someone needs immediate help. This is a special emergency aid +number and needs no other numbers. For medical problems that are not life- +threatening emergencies, call the Palmyra Medical Centers, 2000 Palmyra Road, +Albany. Tel.:229- 229-434-2000 or Phoebe Putney Memorial Hospital, 417 3rd +Avenue, Albany. Tel.: 229-883-1800, 229-312-1000. Police concerns are handled +according to location: + +Campus Police: +Albany Police: +Leesburg Police: + +229-430-4711 +229-431-3266 or 229-431-2100 +229-759-6012 + +20 + + Albany Fire Dept.: + +229-431-3266 + +ENGLISH LANGUAGE +Students who scored below 523 on the TOEFL (Test of English as a Foreign +Language) are REQUIRED to take special supplementary English as a Second +Language (ESL) courses. These courses are non-credit-bearing, but they will help +you with your academic English needs. The course numbers are ENGL 0075, +0077, 0098 and 0099. Any international students are welcome to take these +courses, even if the TOEFL score was above 523. + +English 1101 is the introductory university level English course required for all +ASU degree programs. The course prepares students for the remaining required +English courses in their degree program. + +There are some options available for students who wish to improve their English +language skills. For students who need help with their writing skills, the English +Department offers tutoring in the Writing Center lab located in Simmons Hall. +Another option for tutoring is the PEER TUTORING program. Tutoring is available +in most subjects free of charge during the fall and spring semesters. Contact the +Office of the International Student Advisor or your English professor to find out +which of these facilities will best meet your language needs. + +ENTERTAINMENT +ASU provides many entertainment and social opportunities for students. The +student centers on both campuses are available to you for all activities. It has as +its objectives the fulfillment of the cultural, educational, and recreational desires +of all students of ASU. Various programs and activities are planned and +supervised by the Director of Student Activities and the program coordinator to +round out and broaden the experiences of each student. The services and +facilities of the Student Union are open from 10.00 a.m. to 7.00 p.m. Monday +through Friday. On Saturdays and Sundays, the Game Room hours will be posted +in the game room, unless other wise notified. The facilities and services of the +Union are for students to make full use of. They include conference and meeting +rooms, lounges, a game room, Pizza Hut, the ASU Bookstore, Student +Government Office, a Post Office, an ATM, an information desk, vending +machines, and the ASU Board of Managers. + +The Albany State University International Student Association (ASUISA) is a +special club for international students at ASU. This group plans and promotes +cultural diversity and global awareness activities involving ASU and the +community. It also organizes programs and field trips for students who are +interested in more international activities. Look for information about the first +meeting in late August. + +For more information about clubs and activities, you should read the campus +paper, The Student Voice, and listen to the community radio stations. Also plan +to attend the campus-wide activities fair that takes place during the early part of + +21 + + the Fall Semester. Each of ASU’s clubs will have a booth at this fair to provide +more information for potential members. + +HEALTH CARE +The United States philosophy of health care is different from that of many other +countries. Health care in this country is viewed as an industry. All Health Care +professionals are expected to be paid by their patients or clients. Patients often +must prove ability to pay before treatment will be given. Doctors in this country +usually manage their offices so that they spend a minimum amount of time with +each patient. Nurses do as much as possible to help free the doctor to see more +patients. Expect to deal with nurses in the office and over the telephone. + +MEDICAL EMERGENCY +In case of medical emergency involving a life-threatening situation, or to request +an ambulance (emergency transportation to the hospital), call 911. Call this +number only in true emergencies. ASU students should not use the emergency +room services at the local hospitals, Phoebe or Palmyra, unless the medical +problem is life threatening. Students should use the university health center +infirmary as their main source of medical care. If you do not know whether the +situation is a true emergency, it is probably best to call campus police and have +the officer escort you to the health center. The nurse will evaluate the problem +and will send emergency cases to the hospital. THE HEALTH CENTER IS THE +CLOSEST MEDICAL FACITLITY TO THE RESIDENCE HALLS. Please note that +using the ambulance and the emergency room at the hospitals is very expensive. +This expense will not be covered by medical insurance if the situation is not a +true emergency. + +STUDENT HEALTH SERVICES +The University Health Service of Albany State University is located in the +Academic Administration (ACAD) Building, Room 138. Student Health Services +provide opportunities for safeguarding the health of all students at ASU. The +staff provides the following through student health fees: + +1. General medical care. +2. Confinement in the Health Services. Overnight stays are not available. +3. Consultation on general health needs. + +The health fee DOES NOT cover expenses for special medicines and treatments, +visits to doctors’ offices, operations or off-campus hospitalization. + +The University Health Services office is open Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. – +5:00 p.m. Our Doctors’ hours are Monday through Friday, 4:00-5:00 p.m. +Emergency calls are possible at any time. Each student, freshman or transferee, +is required to have on file a medical record completed and signed by a physician. +These records will be good for four years provided the student is in continuous +attendance at Albany State University and has consulted with the University +Physician periodically. + +22 + + DENTAL CARE +If you need to have your teeth cleaned or another dental service, you should +look in the telephone book Yellow Pages under “Dentists.” Phone to make an +appointment before you go. + +EYEGLASSES AND CONTACT LENSES +If you need an eye examination, or you want your eyeglasses or contact lenses +changed, you should look in the telephone book Yellow Pages under, “Opticians +and Optometrists.” Phone to make an appointment before you go. For medical +concerns with your eyes, look under “Ophthalmologist.” + +COUNSELING +Sometimes individuals become depressed, lonely or fearful in a strange +environment. Many overseas students come from a culture very different from +that of the U.S., and they often miss the support of their family and friends at +home. If you are feeling emotionally upset, depressed, or just need someone to +talk to, contact the International Student Advisor. S/he can make helpful +suggestions, listen to your concerns, and may refer you for further counseling. + +The primary function of the Counseling Services is to assist students in their total +development by providing services and programs to facilitate their intellectual, +emotional, social and academic growth. Counseling services also aid students in +determining a purpose and direction for their lives and in developing coping skills +and behaviors to aid them in working more efficiently with others in their +environment. + +PAYMENT +Health care in the United States is not free. Patients must pay for the services of +doctors, dentists, laboratory workers and hospitals. Their fees are often very +expensive. Care at the Health Services on campus is paid for by student health +fees each semester, so go to the Health Center first for any illness. If you have +an appointment with any off campus doctor or dentist, be prepared to +pay the bill at the conclusion of the appointment. Insurance will not +always cover 100% of the cost. Medical insurance does not cover the expense +of dental visits or eye exams and glasses. Students may want to plan to take +care of routine visits to these doctors during vacations at home. + +INSURANCE +Due to the high cost of medical care in the U.S., all foreign students +must purchase health insurance before enrolling for classes at ASU. +ASU is pleased to offer one policy for all ASU foreign students student. +Since September 1994, new regulations from the U.S. government +have determined what type of insurance coverage students must have. +The ASU policy has been designed to meet this minimum level of +coverage at a reasonable price. The plan covers portions of hospital +costs, doctor visits, and medication but not dental visits or eyeglasses. +Insurance to cover all costs at 100% and to cover dental visits and +eyeglasses is extremely expensive. Few U.S. residents carry such +coverage due to the high cost. The insurance system in the U.S. is + +23 + + designed for the patient to pay a portion of the cost in addition to the +insurance premium already paid. Insurance premiums are the fees paid +for insurance coverage. The university will bill all ASU international +students for the insurance premiums. Insurance from another source is +generally not accepted, since the coverage must meet U.S government +standards. If you need information about the ASU health insurance +program, see the International Student Advisor. If you do not pay your +premium, you will lose your insurance coverage and you will have a +hold placed on your student account, which will prevent you from +registering for classes. You should be careful to avoid a situation +where you lose your coverage because you never know when an illness +or accident may occur. If you have an illness or an accident and you +have no insurance, you will be responsible for 100% of the cost of your +treatment. For Student Health Insurance, please visit the Student +Health Insurance website. www.studenthealthinsurance.com + +GOOD HEALTH +The demand of university life and adjusting to a new environment can be very +stressful. Whenever a person is under stress, s/he is much more susceptible to +illness. Be sure that you take steps to protect your health. Eat properly, get +plenty of sleep, exercise, and protect yourself from communicable diseases, +especially sexually transmitted diseases such as AIDS. If you think you have a +health problem, seek help immediately. If you have questions about any health +matter, please visit the Student Health Center or the Counseling Center. + +IMMUNIZATIONS +All students in the state of Georgia must be vaccinated against measles, mumps, +and rubella. The vaccination can be obtained in one injection called an MMR. It +is recommended that you also receive a shot for Meningitis as well as a +Tuberculosis test. The vaccines are required because these diseases are +present in the U.S. You must protect your health while you are in the U.S. +Students must receive two doses (injection) of this “MMR” vaccine at least 30 +days apart. These vaccines are available at the Dougherty County Government +Office at 222 Pine Avenue, Albany. The telephone number of the Health +Department is 229-430-6200. Students who do not receive these vaccines will +not be allowed to register for classes. We prefer that you send proof of +immunizations and TB test as part of your application package. + +HOUSING +ON-CAMPUS HOUSING +The residence halls provide convenient, inexpensive housing on campus for +students. Most students will share a room with another student (roommate) and +a bathroom with other students nearby. Students must sign a room contract and +pay an application fee and deposit in order to live in a residence hall. The exact +amount to be paid will be included in your letter of admission. The contract +obligates you to live in the residence hall for the entire nine-month academic +year (2 semesters). The on-campus apartments are open all year. They are, + +24 + + however, in great demand. If you want to live in an on-campus apartment, stop +by the Office of Housing for more information or call 229-430-4741. + +If your room needs repairs or you have questions and concerns about any aspect +of life in the residence hall, you should contact your Resident Assistant. The +Resident Assistant, or RA, is also a student who lives in the hall, but this student +is an employee of the Office of Housing. The RA enforces the rules of the +residence hall such as quiet hours. The RA also handles issues such as changing +rooms or roommates and reporting when repairs are needed. The Residence +Hall Director supervises the Resident Assistant of the residence hall. Your +questions and concerns about life in the residence hall should be addressed to +the RA or the Residence Hall Director. Of course the staff of the Office of +Housing and Residence Life will be happy to assist you as well. The telephone +number is 229-430-4741. + +During recent years, the demand for on-campus housing has been high. It is +very important for you to read carefully any correspondence from the Office of +Housing. You need to follow specific procedures to reserve your room each year. +Please make a note of all deadlines and procedures. + +ROOMMATES +Living with an American roommate can be an excellent way to practice English, +learn about the U.S. culture and customs, or to meet a new friend. Living with +another person requires patience, tolerance, and kindness, especially as you get +to know one another during the first few days. It can also be one of the most +enjoyable aspects of your stay on campus. You should expect to disagree with +your roommate about some things. This is normal. The best way to solve your +differences is to speak honestly to one another. Americans are accustomed to +direct discussion of problems. If there are problems, which cannot be solved +between the two of you, you may go to your Resident Assistant (RA) who will +work with you to assign a new roommate. + +OFF-CAMPUS HOUSING +Off-campus housing is plentiful in Albany. There are many apartment complexes +and rental houses near campus and around town. Listed below are a few +suggestions of places to look for housing: 1. -Is this a case that has been previously dismissed? - -If yes, give the following information: - -Court: - -Case No.: - -Judge: - 2. -Other than stated above, are there any pending or previously -discontinued or dismissed companion cases in this or any other -court, including state court? (Companion cases are matters in which -it appears substantially similar evidence will be offered or the same -or related parties are present and the cases arise out of the same -transaction or occurrence.) - -Yes - -No - -Yes - -No - -If yes, give the following information: - -Court: - -Case No.: - -Judge: - -Notes : - - JS 44 Reverse (Rev. 10/20) - -INSTRUCTIONS FOR ATTORNEYS COMPLETING CIVIL COVER SHEET FORM JS 44 - -Authority For Civil Cover Sheet - -The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replaces nor supplements the filings and service of pleading or other papers as -required by law, except as provided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is -required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. Consequently, a civil cover sheet is submitted to the Clerk of -Court for each civil complaint filed. The attorney filing a case should complete the form as follows: - -I.(a) Plaintiffs-Defendants. Enter names (last, first, middle initial) of plaintiff and defendant. If the plaintiff or defendant is a government agency, use - -only the full name or standard abbreviations. If the plaintiff or defendant is an official within a government agency, identify first the agency and then -the official, giving both name and title. - -(b) County of Residence. For each civil case filed, except U.S. plaintiff cases, enter the name of the county where the first listed plaintiff resides at the -time of filing. In U.S. plaintiff cases, enter the name of the county in which the first listed defendant resides at the time of filing. (NOTE: In land -condemnation cases, the county of residence of the "defendant" is the location of the tract of land involved.) - -(c) Attorneys. Enter the firm name, address, telephone number, and attorney of record. If there are several attorneys, list them on an attachment, noting - -in this section "(see attachment)". - -II. - -III. - -IV. - -V. - -Jurisdiction. The basis of jurisdiction is set forth under Rule 8(a), F.R.Cv.P., which requires that jurisdictions be shown in pleadings. Place an "X" -in one of the boxes. If there is more than one basis of jurisdiction, precedence is given in the order shown below. -United States plaintiff. (1) Jurisdiction based on 28 U.S.C. 1345 and 1348. Suits by agencies and officers of the United States are included here. -United States defendant. (2) When the plaintiff is suing the United States, its officers or agencies, place an "X" in this box. -Federal question. (3) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1331, where jurisdiction arises under the Constitution of the United States, an amendment -to the Constitution, an act of Congress or a treaty of the United States. In cases where the U.S. is a party, the U.S. plaintiff or defendant code takes -precedence, and box 1 or 2 should be marked. -Diversity of citizenship. (4) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1332, where parties are citizens of different states. When Box 4 is checked, the -citizenship of the different parties must be checked. (See Section III below; NOTE: federal question actions take precedence over diversity -cases.) - -Residence (citizenship) of Principal Parties. This section of the JS 44 is to be completed if diversity of citizenship was indicated above. Mark this -section for each principal party. - -Nature of Suit. Place an "X" in the appropriate box. If there are multiple nature of suit codes associated with the case, pick the nature of suit code -that is most applicable. Click here for: Nature of Suit Code Descriptions. - -Origin. Place an "X" in one of the seven boxes. -Original Proceedings. (1) Cases which originate in the United States district courts. -Removed from State Court. (2) Proceedings initiated in state courts may be removed to the district courts under Title 28 U.S.C., Section 1441. -Remanded from Appellate Court. (3) Check this box for cases remanded to the district court for further action. Use the date of remand as the filing -date. -Reinstated or Reopened. (4) Check this box for cases reinstated or reopened in the district court. Use the reopening date as the filing date. -Transferred from Another District. (5) For cases transferred under Title 28 U.S.C. Section 1404(a). Do not use this for within district transfers or -multidistrict litigation transfers. -Multidistrict Litigation – Transfer. (6) Check this box when a multidistrict case is transferred into the district under authority of Title 28 U.S.C. -Section 1407. -Multidistrict Litigation – Direct File. (8) Check this box when a multidistrict case is filed in the same district as the Master MDL docket. -PLEASE NOTE THAT THERE IS NOT AN ORIGIN CODE 7. Origin Code 7 was used for historical records and is no longer relevant due to -changes in statue. - -VI. - -Cause of Action. Report the civil statute directly related to the cause of action and give a brief description of the cause. Do not cite jurisdictional -statutes unless diversity. Example: U.S. Civil Statute: 47 USC 553 Brief Description: Unauthorized reception of cable service. - -VII. Requested in Complaint. Class Action. Place an "X" in this box if you are filing a class action under Rule 23, F.R.Cv.P. - -Demand. In this space enter the actual dollar amount being demanded or indicate other demand, such as a preliminary injunction. -Jury Demand. Check the appropriate box to indicate whether or not a jury is being demanded. - -VIII. Related Cases. This section of the JS 44 is used to reference related pending cases, if any. If there are related pending cases, insert the docket - -numbers and the corresponding judge names for such cases. - -Date and Attorney Signature. Date and sign the civil cover sheet. - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Contract -Code -110 - -Title -Insurance - -120 - -Marine - -130 - -Miller Act - -140 - -Negotiable Instrument - -150 - -Recovery of Overpayment & Enforcement -Judgment - -151 - -Medicare - -152 - -153 - -160 - -Recovery of Defaulted Student Loans -(Excludes Veterans) -Recovery of Overpayment of Veterans' -Benefits -Stockholders' Suits - -190 - -Other Contract - -195 - -Contract Product Liability - -Actions primarily alleging personal injury -or property damage caused by a defective -product should be classified under the -appropriate nature of suit code under -“TORTS.” -Franchise - -196 - -Description -Action alleging breach of insurance contract, tort claim, or other cause -related to an insurance contract, except for maritime insurance -contracts. -Action (Admiralty or Maritime) based on service, employment, -insurance or other contracts relating to maritime vessels and other -maritime contractual matters. -Action based on performance and payment bonds agreed to by -contractors on federal construction projects as required under the -Miller Act, 40 U.S.C. § 3131-3134. -Action relating to an agreement to pay a specific amount of money, -including promissory notes, loan agreements and checks. -Action to recover debt owed to the United States, including -enforcement of judgments, based on overpayments and restitution -agreements involving matters other than Medicare benefits, student -loans and veterans’ benefits. -Action relating to Medicare payments, including actions for payments of -benefits, to recover overpayments, and for judicial review of -administrative decisions. -Action to recover debt owed to the United States from defaulted -student loan. -Action relating to payments of veterans’ benefits, primarily including -actions to recover overpayments. -Action brought by stockholder(s) of a corporation (including both -stockholder derivative suits and direct actions based on plaintiff’s rights -as a stockholder), usually alleging claims based on contract and/or tort -law and/or fiduciary obligations. -Action primarily based on rights and obligations under a contract not -classifiable elsewhere under the specific natures of suit under -“Contract.” -Action concerning damages caused by a defective product, not primarily -involving personal injury or property damage, and based primarily on -breach of contract, breach of warranty, misrepresentation, and/or -violation of consumer protection laws. - -Action arising from a dispute over a franchise agreement, typically -alleging breach of contract, misrepresentation or unfair trade practices. - -Page 1 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Real Property - -Code -210 - -Title -Land Condemnation - -220 - -230 - -240 - -Foreclosure - -Rent Lease & Ejectment - -Torts to Land - -245 - -Tort Product Liability - -290 - -All Other Real Property - -Torts/Personal Injury - -Title -Airplane -(Excludes airplane product liability -claims) -Airplane Product Liability - -Description -Action by a governmental entity to take privately-owned real property -(land or buildings) for public use for compensation. -Action to enjoin foreclosure on real property by mortgage lender. - -Action for rental or lease payments owed on real property and/or to -eject a party occupying real property illegally. -Action alleging trespass to land, nuisance, contamination or other -unlawful entry on or interference with real property possessed by -another. -Action alleging harm by an unsafe product based on negligence, breach -of warranty, misrepresentation, and strict tort liability. -Action primarily based on unlawful conduct relating to real property -that cannot be classified under any other nature of suit. - -Description -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death from an air crash or -other occurrence involving an airplane. - -Code -310 - -315 - -320 - -330 - -340 - -345 - -350 - -355 - -360 - -362 - -365 - -367 - -368 - -Motor Vehicle - -Marine Product Liability - -Marine -(Excludes marine product liability claims) - -Assault, Libel & Slander -(Excludes a government employee) -Federal Employers' Liability - -Action alleging personal injury or death from an air crash or other -occurrence involving an airplane and caused by a defective product. -Action alleging intentional acts of assault, libel, trade libel or slander by -a private party. -Action for personal injury or wrongful death brought by a railroad -employee or his survivors under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act -(FELA), 45 U.S.C. § 51, et. seq. -Action (Admiralty and Maritime) alleging personal injury or death from -an accident involving a water vessel or harbor/dock facilities, including -suits brought under the Jones Act and the Limitation of Liability Act. -Action (Admiralty and Maritime) alleging personal injury or wrongful -death from an accident involving a water vessel or harbor/dock -facilities and caused by a defective product. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death from negligence -involving a motor vehicle but not caused by a defective product. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death involving a motor -vehicle and caused by a defective product. -Action primarily based on personal injury or death caused by -negligence or intentional misconduct, including suits brought against -the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act, and which cannot -be classified under any other nature of suit. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death caused by negligence -in medical care provided by a doctor or other health care professional. -Action alleging personal injury or death resulting from a defective -Personal Injury - Product Liability -product. -(Excludes a marine or airplane product) -Action alleging personal injury or death caused by a defective medical -Health Care/Pharmaceutical Personal -or pharmaceutical product. -Injury Product Liability -Asbestos Personal Injury Product Liability Action alleging personal injury or death caused by exposure to asbestos - -Personal Injury - Medical Malpractice - -Motor Vehicle Product Liability - -Other Personal Injury - -products. - -Page 2 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Personal Property - -Code -370 - -371 - -Title -Other Fraud -(Excludes any property that is not real -property) -Truth in Lending - -Actions relating to fraud or -misrepresentation in the transfer of real -property should be classified under -nature of suit 290, “All Other Real -Property,” or, if foreclosure is involved, -under nature of suit 220, “Foreclosure.” -Other Personal Property Damage - -380 - -385 - -Property Damage Product Liability - -Civil Rights - -Code - -440 - -441 - -442 - -443 - -445 - -446 - -Title -Other Civil Rights -(Excludes claims against corrections -officials) -Voting - -Employment - -Housing/Accommodations - -Americans With Disabilities - -Employment -Americans With Disabilities - Other - -448 - -Education - -Description -Action primarily based on fraud relating to personal property that -cannot be classified under any other nature of suit. - -Action alleging violation of the federal Truth in Lending Act arising from -consumer loan transactions involving personal property including -automobile loans and revolving credit accounts. - -Action primarily based on damage to personal property caused by -harmful conduct such as negligence, misrepresentation, interference -with business relationships or unfair trade practices. -Action alleging damage to personal property caused by a defective -product. - -Description - -Action alleging a civil rights violation other than the specific civil rights -categories listed below or a violation related to prison. Example: -Action alleging excessive force by police incident to an arrest. -Action filed under Civil Rights Act, 52 U.S.C. § 10101, and Voting Rights -Act, 52 U.S.C. § 10301 -Action filed under Age Discrimination in Employment Act 29:621:634, -Equal Employment Opportunity Act (Title VII) 42:2000E, Performance -Rating Act of 1950 5:4303 -Action filed under the Fair Housing Act (Title VII), 42 U.S.C. § 3601 & -3602. -Action of discrimination against an employee with disabilities of any -type in the work place, filed under 42 U.S.C. § 12117 -Action of discrimination against an individual with disabilities in areas -other than employment, filed under 42 U.S.C. § 12133 (exclusion or -discrimination in provision of services, programs or activities of a public -entity) or 42 U.S.C. § 12188 (public accommodations) -Action filed under the Individuals with Disabilities Educations Act, 20 -U.S.C. § 1401 and Title IX of the Education Amendment of 1972, 20 -U.S.C. § 1681 et seq. - -Page 3 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Prisoner Petitions -Habeas Corpus -Title -Alien Detainee - -Code -463 - -510 - -Motions to Vacate Sentence - -530 - -General - -535 - -Death Penalty - -Other -Prisoner Petitions - -Code -540 - -Title -Mandamus & Other - -550 - -Civil Rights - -555 - -Prison Condition - -560 - -Civil Detainee - Conditions of -Confinement (Excludes actions by alien -detainees) - -Description -Immigration habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. All cases filed -with this nature of suit code are restricted to case participants and -public terminals. Petition is filed by an alien detainee. -Action by a prisoner to vacate or modify a sentence imposed in federal -court, other than a death sentence, under 28 U.S.C. § 2255. -Action by a federal or state prisoner currently in custody challenging -the legality of confinement or other punishment. This includes claims -alleging illegalities that occurred in trial (for example, ineffective -assistance of counsel), sentencing (including fines and restitution -orders), or disciplinary proceedings in prison (for example, loss of good -time credits). Habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 or prisoner -habeas under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. -Action by a federal or state prisoner challenging a death sentence. - -Description -Action by prisoner currently in custody for a writ of mandamus to -compel action by a judge or government official relating to the -prisoner’s confinement, including conditions of confinement. This -category also includes any actions other than mandamus brought by a -prisoner currently in custody, whether or not it relates to his -confinement, if it is not classifiable under any other nature of suit -category under Prisoner Petitions (for example, action by prisoner to -recover property taken by the government in a criminal case). -Action by current or former prisoner alleging a civil rights violation by -corrections officials that is not related to a condition of prison life. -Action by current prisoner, or former prisoner or their families alleging -a civil rights, Federal Tort Claims Act, or state law claim with respect to -a condition of prison life, whether general circumstances or particular -episodes. Examples: inadequate medical care or excessive force by -prison guards. Includes non-habeas actions by alien detainees alleging -unlawful prison conditions. -Action by former prisoner who was involuntarily committed to a non- -criminal facility after expiration of his or her prison term alleging -unlawful conditions of confinement while in the non-criminal facility. -This category includes, for example, an action by a former prisoner -classified as a Sexually Dangerous Person or Sexually Violent Predator -alleging civil rights violations during his detention in a medical facility. - -Page 4 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Forfeiture/Penalty - -Code -625 - -Title -Drug Related Seizure of Property 21 -U.S.C. § 881 - -Description -Action (Forfeiture) by which property itself is accused of wrongdoing -and is forfeited to the government as a result. - -690 - -Other - -Labor -Code -710 - -Title -Fair Labor -Standards Act (Non-Union) - -720 - -Labor/Management Relations (Union) - -740 - -Railway Labor Act - -Action primarily based on Acts or Bills that cannot be classified under -any other nature of suit, such as: Endangered Species Act, Federal -Hazardous Substance Act 15:1261, Game & Wildlife Act 15:256C et seq. -(Penalty), Federal Trade Commission Act 15:41-51 (Penalty), Federal -Coal Mine Health & Safety Act 30:801 et seq. (Penalty), Load Line Act -46:85-85G, McGuire Bill (Federal Fair Trade) 15:45L Penalty, Marihuana -Tax Act 50 STAT 551, Motorboat Act 46:526-526T, National Traffic & -Motor Vehicle Safety Act penalty 49:1655, Veterans' Benefit Act, Title -38 Penalty. - -Description -Action relating to non-union workplace related disputes filed under the -Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 201 including but not limited to -wage discrimination, paid leave, minimum wage and overtime pay. - -Action relating to disputes between labor unions and employers as well -as all petitions regarding actions of the Nation Labor Relations Board -(NLRB) - -Action relating to disputes filed under the Railway Labor Act, 45 U.S.C. -§ 151 including labor disputes, individual claims, and response to -sanctions. - -751 - -790 - -791 - -Family and Medical Leave Act - -Action filed under the Family Medical Leave Act, 29 U.S.C. § 2601 - -Other Labor Litigation - -Employee Retirement Income Security -Act - -Action primarily based on labor disputes not addressed by other NOS -codes (includes Labor/Management Reporting and Disclosure Act) -Action filed under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, 29 -U.S.C. § 1132 by individuals and labor organizations. - -Immigration - -Code -462 - -Title -Naturalization Application - -465 +3. -Other Immigration -Actions +4. -Description -Action seeking review of denial of an application for naturalization [8 -U.S.C. § 1447(b)] or alleging failure to make a determination regarding -an application for naturalization [8 U.S.C. § 1421(c)]. +Albany Herald, the local newspaper, lists apartments, houses, and +rooms for rent in the classified advertising section of the paper. The +ad will usually list the monthly rent as well as a phone number to call +for more information. +Bulletin boards and notices on campus: check classroom buildings for +notices and ads about apartments for rent. Many students looking for +roommates advertise in this manner. +The telephone directory: look under “Apartments” in the Yellow +Pages. +The Office of the International Student Advisor has listing of apartment +complexes in Albany, which lists such information as rental cost, size, +and distance from campus. + +25 + + RENT AND DEPOSITS +You will probably have to pay a deposit of two or three hundred dollars, plus +your first month’s rent before you can move into an apartment or rental house. +When you move out of the apartment you will get the deposit back if there has +been no damage to the apartment. You will also be required to sign a lease. A +lease is a legal contract that states the amount of time that you will live in the +apartment. Most leases are for one year. Once a lease is signed, you are legally +bound to live in the apartment, and you must pay the rent even if you decide +that you no longer want to live in the apartment. Do not sign any lease that you +do not understand. Be sure to check the dates of the lease carefully. Please +visit the International Student Advisor before you move off campus. He/she can +offer advice about apartments and assist you with interpreting leases. Please +note that if you lease an apartment in your name but also have roommates living +with you, you must be very careful about changing the name on the lease if you +move. If your name is on the lease, you are responsible for the payment of rent +even if you move out and allow other students to move into the apartment. If +you do not pay the rent, the landlord may take legal action against you. Please +be especially careful in situations where you share telephone and utility services +with other students. Never agree to have a lease or a utility bill placed in your +name unless you are certain no additional money is owed on the account. If you +change a lease or utility bill from another student’s name to yours, you will be +responsible for any money owed on the lease or account even if the charges +were billed before the account was placed in your name. + +DINING SERVICE +The University Dining Hall, which is under the supervision of the Director of Food +Services, provides nutritious and wholesome meals at a minimum cost to the +student. Meals are served in an ultra-modern facility, which includes a food court +consisting of the following concepts: Café Features, Wokery, Grill Works, Itza +Pizza, Deli Corner, Sweet Things, Salad Garden, Veggie and Drinks. The meals +are unlimited (all you can eat). The Dining Hall seating capacity is approximately +525 students. All boarding students must present proper University student +identification. Non-boarding students, faculty, staff and visitors must pay cash at +the cashier’s stand before being served. + +Meal Schedule + +Monday-Thursday +Breakfast +Lunch +Dinner +Friday +Breakfast +Lunch +Dinner + +Saturday & Sunday +Brunch + +7:00 a.m. – 8:45 a.m. +11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. +5:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. + +7:00 a.m. – 8:45 a.m. +11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. +4:30 p.m. – 6:30 p.m. + +10:30 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. + +26 + + Dinner + +4:00 p.m. − 5:30 p.m. + +(Schedule is subject to change without notice) + +LEGAL CONCERNS +LAWS +While you are in the U.S., you are subject to all of the laws and regulations, +which govern U.S. citizens. In addition, you are subject to immigration laws, +which define and limit your activities as a non-immigrant. Failure to comply with +immigration laws can lead to a request for your voluntary departure, or a forced +deportation from the U.S. + +EQUAL PROTECTION and DUE PROCESS +All persons in the U.S., regardless of citizenship, are entitled to the same +protection of the law and the same procedures of law enforcement. This means +that, with a few exceptions, you will be treated the same as an American citizen +in your relationship with the law enforcement agencies. Those few exceptions +involve immigration law. Consult the Office of the International Student Advisor +for clarification of this issue. + +ILLEGAL DRUGS +The possession, use, or sale of drugs or narcotics, including marijuana, hashish, +amphetamines, hallucinogens, barbiturates, cocaine, heroin, and a wide range of +other drugs, are serious offenses under Georgia law and immigration law. Those +who choose to use illegal drugs run the risk of expulsion from the university, +imprisonment, and/or deportation from the United States. + +ALCOHOL +The minimum legal age for drinking alcoholic beverages (beer, wine, liquor, etc.) +in the State of Georgia is 21. You cannot be served alcoholic beverages unless +you are 21 or older. You will be asked to present an identification card with your +photograph and your date of birth before you can purchase alcohol from a store +or enter a bar, nightclub, or other establishment that serves alcohol. Students +who are over age 18 but under 21 will be admitted, but these students are not +allowed to purchase alcohol. The police routinely search all nightclubs and bars +in Albany for students under age 21 who have consumed alcoholic beverages or +used false identification to enter the establishment. Students who are caught +are arrested, taken to jail, and fined. They may also face university disciplinary +measures. + +Driving a car after drinking alcoholic beverages is also illegal in Georgia, +regardless of age. Driving under the influence (DUI) of alcohol carries severe +penalties and can result in the loss of your driver’s license, heavy fines, +imprisonment, disciplinary action by the university, and/or deportation. NEVER +DRINK AND DRIVE. + +SMOKING + +27 + + Smoking has become socially unacceptable in many places. Smoking is not +permitted in Albany State University buildings (except dorm rooms). Smoking is +also forbidden in hospitals, many restaurants, and other public places. Always +ask permission of your companies before smoking. Never smoke in someone’s +home unless he or she smokes as well. + +MAIL +CAMPUS MAIL +Campus mail is a service provided by the university for mail going between +people and offices on the premises of the campus. To send a letter by campus +mail, clearly mark the office and person it should go to and write CAMPUS MAIL +in the upper right hand corner. No stamp is needed. Drop the letter in the +collection point at the post office or in your Department Office. + +POST OFFICES +The university post office can send materials in both domestic and overseas mail. +Overseas mail must be weighed and stamped according to weight. Domestic +mail requires standard postage of 44 cents per letter. Packages and letters +containing more than five sheets of paper usually require extra postage. Any +package weighing over 16 ounces may be mailed first class from the university +post office. Domestic mail also requires a zip code for delivery. This is a five- +letter code specific to the area the letter or package is being sent to. If you do +not know the zip code of the area you are mailing to, ask for a zip code directory +at the post office and look up the proper zip code. + +CHANGE OF ADDRESS +Students who move off campus or leave ASU for a vacation should fill out a U.S. +Postal Service Change of Address card, sign the card, and place it in a U.S +mailbox. By completing this card, you allow the postal service to automatically +forward your mail to your new address. There is no charge for this service. +Unfortunately, the Office of the International Student Advisor cannot forward +mail to students who have moved off campus. Please do not have your mail +sent to the Office of the International Student Advisor. You will also need to +complete an AR-11 form which you obtain in the International Office. + +ELECTRONIC MAIL +An electronic mail (e-mail) account is available to all ASU students, faculty, and +staff free of charge. All ASI students are expected to use their ASU Ram Mail +because that is the official mode of communication. If you need an account or +would like to learn more about this service, call the Office of Information +Technology at 229-430-4909. You can also use the Internet through ASU +website: www.asurams.edu. E-mail and the Internet are wonderful ways to +communicate with friends around the world at no expense to you. + +MONEY AND BANKING +BANKS +There are many banks located in Albany. Most of them have specially priced +services for ASU students. The Bank of America has an automated teller machine + +28 + + or ATM in the Reese Student Union building on lower campus. As with any other +service, you should determine which banking services are most important to you +and call the different banks to find out about prices and available services. + +CHECKING AND SAVING ACCOUNTS +All students should open checking and/or saving accounts at a local bank. It is +not wise to carry or keep large amounts of cash. Most local businesses will +accept checks from local banks only. + +It is important to know how much money is in your checking account at all +times. Do not write checks for more money than you have in your checking +account. Checks written for more than the amount in an account are returned +unpaid. You will have to pay a fine to the bank, to the business where you +wrote the check, and may be unable to write checks in the future. Writing checks +when you do not have enough money to cover the check is called “bouncing +checks.” Bouncing checks is a criminal offense punishable by imprisonment. A +checking account is a service. Charges for services vary from bank to bank. +Savings accounts allow you to deposit money safely in a bank and receive a +small amount of interest on the balance. Savings accounts require passbooks for +depositing and withdrawing money. Keep both your checkbook and your +passbook in a safe place and report it to the bank immediately if either document +is lost or stolen. + +CREDIT CARDS +Credit cards are available through most banks. They have high interest rates, +but are very easy to use. Credit cards can be used almost everywhere and are +billed on a monthly basis. The best way to use a credit card is to pay the entire +bill monthly; otherwise, your balance may get higher than you can pay. Many +students find it helpful to carry an international credit card such as Visa or +MasterCard. Purchases on these cards can be made in U.S. dollars while the bill +is sent to your home and is denoted in your home currency. These cards can +also be used at automated teller machines to withdraw cash. Be sure to inquire +about the transaction fees before you obtain a credit card. Often the use of +these cards is an inexpensive way to exchange currency. But the fees can +become expensive. Your student fees can also be paid by credit card +(MasterCard or Visa only). + +OTHER BANKING SERVICES OFFERED FOR FEES + +Cashier’s Check +Money Orders +Certified Checks +Travelers Checks +Safety deposit box rental for storing valuable items + +MONEY EXCHANGE +Foreign currency must be taken to a bank to be exchanged. All currency (except +Canadian) must be sent out of town by the local banks for exchange. There is a + +29 + + charge of about $10.00 for the transaction and a processing time of 3 to 6 +weeks. + +RECEIVING MONEY FROM HOME -Action (Immigration-related) that do not involve Naturalization -Applications or petitions for Writ of Habeas Corpus, such as complaints -alleging failure to adjudicate an application to adjust immigration -status to permanent resident. +1. -Page 5 of 8 +2. - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +By Mail +Tell your family to send numbered cashier’s check in U.S. +dollars, purchased from a bank in your country that has +business arrangement with a well-known U.S. bank. Make sure +that the check has a bank routing number on the bottom of the +check. + +By Telex +You may receive money from home by telex (wire). Wired +money generally arrives 5-10 days after it is sent from overseas. +It should be arranged through a local bank, and you should +have a checking or savings account established at the bank. +The receiving bank will charge about $12.00 as handling fee. It +is not possible to have money wired directly to your ASU +student account. + +Please be sure to request your funds from home well in advance of fee payment +deadlines. International transfers can often experience unexpected delays, so +you should plan ahead each semester. THERE IS NO FLEXIBITY IN FEE +PAYMENT DEADLINES. Please do not request an extension of the set fee +payment deadline. Failure to pay your student fees in a timely manner will result +in your having to return home. + +30 + + INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS +If English is not a student’s native language, if the student did not attend high +school in the United States, and if the student wishes to discuss taking the +Regents’ Test especially designed for International students, the student must +contact the Regents’ Test Director whose office is in 103 Simmons Hall (229-430- +4735 – flo.hill@asurams.edu). The local International Students’ Task Force +Committee has suggested that a student be considered for a special form of the +essay test after taking and failing the test at least once. There is no special test +for reading at this time; however, students may be given more time and may be +allowed to use their translation dictionaries. + +RELIGIOUS LIFE +Religion is a very important part of South Georgia culture. People will probably +invite you to visit their church and to take part in church sponsored social +activities. While these church services and activities can be very meaningful to +you, participation will not obligate you to join a church. Churches often attempt +to bring students into their church families by asking students to change their +belief to match the beliefs of the church members. If church members or clergy +make you feel uncomfortable about your religious belief or your values, feel free +tell them that you wish to maintain your own beliefs. If they cannot accept that, +find another church group! + +There are many churches located in the Albany area. Denominations include: +African-Methodist Episcopal, Apostolic, Assembly of God, Bahai, Baptist, Catholic, +Charismatic, Christian, Church of Christ, Church of God, Church of Jesus Christ of +Latter Days, Episcopal (Anglican), Holiness, Interdenominational, Jehovah +Witness, Lutheran, Nazarene, Pentecostal, Salvation Army, Seventh Day +Adventist, and Unitarian. All denominations are listed under “Churches” or +“Synagogues” in the Yellow Pages of the telephone book. + +SHOPPING +GROCERY STORES +All foods are located in one store. You will find fresh fruits, vegetables, canned +(tinned) goods, baby foods, meats, bread, cleaning supplies, paper products, and +frozen foods. Generally, grocery stores have lower prices than smaller stores. +There are several large grocery stores in Albany and some of them are within +walking distance of the University. You can order special items if you are +looking for ingredients not readily available in Albany stores. + +DRUGSTORES AND PHARMACIES +This is the only place where you can buy medicine that the doctor has ordered +for you. You can often buy many other things there as well. The most +convenient drugstore is CVS on Radium Springs Road, near the campus. Less +expensive pharmacies are located in discount stores and some grocery stores. + +31 + + DISCOUNT STORES +These are department stores where you find a large variety of things including +clothing, pharmacies, garden supplies, small appliance, paper products, linens, +and even some types of furniture. They often have lower prices and can be +wonderful places to see American people and products. Some of the local +discount stores include K-Mart, Wal-Mart, and Target. + +RESTAURANTS +Unless you are buying food, restaurant owners do not like for you to sit and +“take up space” from paying customers. You should leave money (a tip) on the +table for the waiter or waitress when you eat at a restaurant. The tip is usually +15%-20% of the total bill, depending on the quality of the service. Fast food +restaurants do not have waiters and waitresses. Do not leave a tip at this type +of restaurant. There are a number of commercial fast food restaurants around +the campus. Food can be ordered “for here” (to be eaten in the restaurant) or +“to go” (to be eaten at home). + +THE ALBANY MALL +The Albany Mall is a shopping center housing several dozen stores and +restaurants. It is located some miles west of the campus on Dawson Road. You +can buy almost anything you need in the Mall. Prices in these stores are usually +higher than the prices at Discount Stores, but the Mall is a great place to meet +people and experience American culture! + +OUTLET MALL +A large mall containing only manufacturer’s outlet stores is located many miles +south of Albany on Interstate 75. This mall has over 100 stores and is a good +place to shop because the prices are low while the quality of the merchandise is +high. + +Student Athlete + +Best practices For International Athlete Recruits (NCAA) +F-1 Visa and Issuance of SEVIS Form I-20 +International student-athletes who require an F-1 student visa are subject to +specific requirements regarding their admissions eligibility, financial ability and +academic status. Failure of students to follow appropriate regulations and +guidelines can result in severe difficulties with their immigration status with the +U.S. Department of Homeland Security. To avoid difficulties, the NCAA strongly +recommends that athletics staff meet with appropriate school officials (e.g., +international admissions officers, international student advisors) to gain an +understanding of the school’s policies and procedures that are in place to protect +international students and to maintain compliance with all immigration +regulations. + +32 + + IMPORTANT NOTE FOR ATHLETICS ADMINISTRATORS AND ADMISSIONS OFFICERS +Under no circumstances should an international student athlete be issued a Form +I-20 with the expectation of financial support from the athletics office before the +student has been certified as a final qualifier by the NCAA Eligibility Center or is +determined to be a partial qualifier in Division II. + +• Doing so opens the possibility for an international student who might not be +eligible for financial aid to obtain a visa and enter the United States without +having the sufficient funds to cover tuition and living expenses, as required by +immigration laws. + +Financial Ability + +• All F-1 visa students must submit appropriate documentation of financial +support before the school can issue the SEVIS Form I-20 [certificate of eligibility +for nonimmigrant (F-1) student status]. +• Generally the school’s office of recruitment and admissions office will have +information as to what constitutes appropriate documentation of financial +support. +• Athletics department staff members must understand that withdrawal of +athletics financial aid for an international student-athlete could result in severe +economic hardship for the student and could result in a violation of the student’s +immigration status. + +What Athletics Administrators Should Tell Student-Athletes +• Student-athletes who will be receiving financial aid from the athletics +department must understand that if the amount of aid is less than the +amount required for issuance of the I-20, then the student will need to +provide additional documentation of financial support. + +• Student-athletes should be informed of the true costs of attending the + +school and must understand the financial implications in the event of the +loss of financial support from athletics. + +• Although students athletes may receive some financial assistance through + +athletics students are responsible for purchasing their books for the +duration of the academic tenure. + +• Student-athletes must understand that if their scholarship is made + +unavailable for whatever reason (e.g., because the student-athlete did not +meet initial-eligibility requirement, they must have other means of +financial support. If sufficient finances are not available from other +sources, the student risks violation of immigration status and possible +deportation. + +SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS +A Social Security Number is a government identification number issued to all +residents of the United States. Most residents receive this number as children. +In the U.S., we do not carry passports or national ID cards. Instead, we use this +number and a driver’s license as our primary forms of identification for +employment records, taxation, opening bank accounts, university records and + +33 + + other business matters. All drivers’ licenses contain a color photograph of the +bearer as well as the current address and date of birth. + +For your admission to ASU, you were issued a student identification number +which has the same number of digits as the social security number. The +university uses this ID number for all of your university records. The number +also appears on your student identification card. While this number is sufficient +for your academic records, you will need to obtain a Social Security number +before you can work on campus. To obtain the number, you must complete an +application form and deliver it, along with a letter of verification from the ISA +and an offer letter from the person who is hiring you on letterhead, in person to +the Social Security Administration in Albany. There is no charge for Social +Security numbers. Call 1-800-772-1213 for more information. + +TAXES +Federal Law requires that foreign students pay income tax from sources within +the U.S. This income generally includes salary from any employment, on or off +campus, as well as scholarship money. Tax return is due on April 15 for the +previous year. In addition you may need to file a tax statement. If you have +concern about your tax obligation, you may wish to consult a certified public +accountant (CPA). The Internal Revenue Service is the branch of the federal +government responsible for income tax collection. This agency is often simply +called IRS. You can call the IRS directly at 1-800-829-1040 for additional +information. + +TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAMS +TELEPHONE +Telephone service in the U.S. is divided into two types: local and long-distance +(including international) service. Most people work with two different companies +to obtain telephone services: a local carrier for local service and long distance +carrier for long distance service. The local carrier for Albany is BellSouth. +Contact the company by calling 229-780-2355. You may need to pay a deposit +to begin your local service. For about $30.00 a month, you may have unlimited +telephone calls within the country. You will be billed monthly for this service. + +There are several local and long distance services in the U.S. Each company lays +claims to lowest telephone rates for long distance. You may want to talk to each +company to learn who can offer you the best deal. Rates usually depend on +where you call and when you call. To get the cheapest rate, you may find that +all three companies have special plans with many restrictions. Be sure to read +the details of the special plans. Be sure to ask for the rates for calling your +country. You can contact these companies by calling the numbers listed in the +local telephone book. Once you choose a company, they will provide you with +direct dialing from your home and a calling card, which you can use from any +phone. + +INFORMATION + +34 + + If you cannot find a number on-line, you may call “Information,” also called +“Directory Assistance” and the number is 1411. In order to use the information +service, you must know the name of the person or organization you wish to call +as well as the city they are located in. The number you dial for information +depends upon the area you wish to call. The telephone book also contains useful +information about how to use the telephone and place different kinds of calls. +The Yellow Pages found on-line contain listings of local businesses and can help +you locate services. + +TOLL FREE CALLING +Most numbers with an area code of 1-800 or 1-888 are toll free calls. This +means that there will be no charge for the call. Many businesses and services +have toll free numbers for customer use. You should use toll free numbers +whenever possible to keep your telephone bill low. + +OTHER ASPECTS OF TELEPHONE SERVICES +If you live off-campus and share a telephone number, be sure to have an +agreement about how the bill will be paid and whose name will appear on the +bill. The names and numbers of all telephone subscribes are published in the +BellSouth telephone book unless you request an unpublished number. Albany has +several “local exchanges.” This term refers to the first three digits of the +telephone number. You will see prefixes listed as 430, 431, 434, and 435, for +example. Be sure to give all seven digits of your number. If you are calling from +one phone on campus to another, you only need to dial the last four digits of the +number. Many students today buy pre-paid cell phones. + +TELEGRAMS +Letters or money may be sent both within the U.S. and internationally through +Western Union by calling their toll-free number 1-800-325-6000. Mailgram is also +available through Western Union and is less expensive than telegrams. To send +a Mailgram, call Western Union at 1-800-325-6000. MoneyGram provides similar +services as Western Union. Their toll free number is 1-800-926-9400. + +FAX +Faxes may be sent or received through the fax services offered by some +companies in Albany. You will be charged for this service. For international +faxes, students should use Mailboxes, etc. at 229-434-1133 or 229-432-2230. +Unfortunately, the high cost of international and long distance faxes prohibits the +Office of the International Student Advisor or the University from sending +personal faxes for students. + +TESTING +The Albany State University Computer-based Testing Center (Department of +Counseling, Testing and Disability Services), located on the first floor in ACAD +195, administers and prepares students for several national computer-based +tests periodically throughout the year. The GRE, GMAT, MAT, MCAT, LSAT, +PCAT, and TOEFL are a few of the tests administered by the center. National test +scores are required for admission to U.S. graduate schools. These tests have + +35 + + standard fees and deadlines for enrollment. For information about a test, call +the Computer-based Testing office at 229- 430-1631. To sign up for a test, visit +the Division of Student Affairs and pick up an application. + +TRANSPORTATION +TRANSPORTATION IN ALBANY +Albany has a public transportation system. In emergencies, you can hire a taxi +(cab). Companies offering taxi services are listed under “Taxicabs” in the +Albany telephone book. Be sure and ask how much you will be charged before +hiring a taxi. Some students purchase bicycles for transportation. Cyclists must +ride on the roadways, as there are no separate bicycle paths. If you choose to +ride a bicycle, you must be very careful and watch out for cars. American drivers +are not accustomed to cyclists on the road, be sure to lock up your bike when +you are not using it. To travel outside Albany, you must go by bus or airplane. -Bankruptcy +BUS TRANSPORTATION +The Greyhound Bus Lines station in Albany is located at 300 Oglethorpe Blvd. +Call 1-800-231-2222 for nation-wide information or 229-432-0511 for local +terminal information. -Code -422 +AIR TRANSPORTATION +Albany has an airport located south of town. Service is limited to several daily +flights to Atlanta, where connecting flights are available to other cities. Call 229- +430-5175 for schedules. -Title -Appeal 28 USC § 158 +TRAVEL AGENTS +Travel agents will help you make travel arrangements for a small fee. They +often save you money by finding the lowest rates available to your destination. +Look in the Yellow Pages under “Travel Agencies”. Or you may book your tickets +online using a credit card at the airlines website. (e.g. www.delta.com) -423 +INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL +If you know that you will return to your country during a school vacation, you +should try to plan international travel 2 or 3 months in advance. The best rates +for international travel are obtained by making reservations early. Also, all +students are eligible for discounted airfares through an organization called +Council Travel. To obtain these special fares, you must have an international +student ID card. These cards can be purchased for $20 from the Office of the +International Student Advisor or local travel agents. These cards also qualify the +bearer for discounts at museums and other tourist attractions. If you have +questions about international travel, you should speak with the staff at the Office +of the International Student Advisor or experienced travelers from your country. -Withdrawal of Reference 28 USC § 157 +36 -Property Rights -Title -Copyright + CAMPUS CONTACTS -Code -820 +Quick Reference -Patent +Information -Patent – Abbreviated New Drug -Application (ANDA) +Office -Trademark +Phone Number -830 +Advising and Immigration -835 +Office of Int’l Student Advisor -840 +Meal Plan -880 +Food Services -Description -All appeals of previous bankruptcy decisions filed under -28 U.S.C. § 158 -Action held in bankruptcy court requesting withdrawal under the -provisions of 28 U.S.C. § 157 +General Info (Switchboard) -Description -Action filed in support or to dispute a copyright claim. +Facilities Management -Action filed in support or to dispute a patent claim. +Graduate Studies -Action filed in support or to dispute a patent claim involving an -Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA). These cases are also known -as “Hatch-Waxman” cases. -Action filed in support or to dispute a trademark claim +Graduate School -Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (DTSA) +Residence Life (Housing) -Action filed in support or to dispute a trade secret misappropriation +Student Affairs -Social Security -Title -HIA (1395ff) +Mail delivery services for on-campus students -Code -861 +Post Office -862 +Parking Permits -Black Lung (923) +Public Safety -863 +229-430-7075 -DIWC/DIWW (405(g)) +229-430-4750 -864 +229-430-4600 -865 +229-430-5118 -SSID Title XVI +229-430-4741 -RSI (405(g)) +229-430-4745 -Federal Tax Suits +229-430-4711 -Code -870 -871 +Personal & Counseling -Title -Taxes (U.S. Plaintiff or Defendant) -IRS-Third Party 26 USC 7609 +Counseling, Testing & Disability Services -Description -Action filed with regard to social security benefits associated with -Health Insurance Part A Medicare + 229- 430-4667 -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided for those -who contracted Black Lung or their beneficiaries +Reporting Theft or Crime -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided to disabled -individuals: worker or child, or widow +Public Safety -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided to -Supplemental Security Income Disability under Title XVI -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided for -Retirement, Survivor Insurance under 42 U.S.C. § 405 +Admission Status -Description -Action filed under the Internal Revenue Code (General) -Action filed under the Internal Revenue Code - Tax Reform Act of 1976 -(P.L. 94-455) Third Party +Admissions Office -Page 6 of 8 +Student Activities - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +Student Affairs -Other Statutes -Title -False Claims Act +Transcripts (to be sent from ASU) -Code -375 +Registrar’s Office -376 +Tuition Payment -Qui Tam (31 U.S.C. § 3729(a)) +Business Office -400 +229-430-4711 -State Reapportionment +229-430-4646 -410 +229-430-4739 -Antitrust +229-430-4638 -430 +229-430-4610 -450 +37 -460 + SERVICES FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS -470 + Orientation sessions and workshops for new students. + Liaison with the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for +all of your immigration documents. We will help you with filing for +practical training, transfer of schools, and replacement of lost +documents. WE are your source for maintaining your immigration +status. -480 + Counseling and referral services. Personal and cross-cultural -485 +counseling is available on a confidential basis to all students. If you +would like to talk to someone, call the International Student Advisor +(ISA) at 229-430-4721 to make an appointment. If necessary, you +may be referred elsewhere for help. -Banks and Banking + Information. If you do not know what to do, to whom to talk, or +where to find ANYTHING, the Office of the International Student +Advisor can help. -Commerce + Letters of certification for government loans, money exchange, re- +entry into the U.S., invitations to visit the U.S., and other official +documents are available at the office. -Deportation + Information about Albany State University International Student -Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt -Organizations -Consumer Credit +Association (ASUISA): ASUISA annually elects new student officers, +and sponsors activities throughout the year, by and for international +students. -Telephone Consumer Protection Act -(TCPA) + Other activities for all Global Programs students such as International -490 +Festival in November, picnics, coffee/tea hour, and the Cultural +Exchange Club/Global Ambassadors. -Cable/Satellite TV +38 -850 + CHECK LISTS -Securities/Commodities/Exchange +ANNUAL CHECKLIST -890 +• Renew passport if necessary (six months before expiration). -Other Statutory Actions +• File income tax returns if necessary (between January 1 and -891 +April 15). -Agricultural Acts +• Extend temporary stay with sponsor and with the -893 +International Advisor for an extended I-20 if necessary (30 +days before expiration). -Environmental Matters +PERIODIC CHECKLIST -Description -Action filed by private individuals alleging fraud against the U.S. -Government under 31 U.S.C. § 3729. -Action brought under the False Claims Act by private persons (also -known as "whistleblowers") on their own behalf and on behalf of the -United States to recover damages against another person or entity that -acted fraudulently in receiving payments or property from, or avoiding -debts owed to, the United States Government, 31 U.S.C. § 3730 -Action filed under the Reapportionment Act of 1929 Ch. 28, 46 Stat. 21, -2 U.S.C. § 2a. -Action brought under the Clayton Act 15 U.S.C. § 12 - 27 alleging -undue restriction of trade and commerce by designated methods that -limit free competition in the market place amongst consumers such as -anti-competitive price discrimination, corporate mergers, interlocking -directorates or tying and exclusive dealing contracts. -Action filed under the Federal Home Loan Bank Act 12:1421-1449, -Home Owners Loan Act 12:1461 or Federal Reserve Acts 12:142 et seq. -Action filed under the Interstate Commerce Acts 49:1 et seq., 49:301 +• Report changes of address (within 10 days) to the Office of +the International Student Advisor and the Office of the +Registrar. This is required by law. So is your email +address and your telephone number. -Action filed under the Immigration Acts (Habeas Corpus & Review) -8:1101/18:1546 -Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization Act, RICO 18:1961-1968 +• Report any change of marital status, or if your family has -Action filed under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. 1681n or -15 U.S.C. 1681o, and the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, -15 U.S.C. § 1692k -Action filed under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act 47 U.S.C. § -227 +joined you in the U.S., to the International Student Advisor. -Action filed involving unauthorized reception of cable/satellite TV -service under 47 U.S.C. § 553 (unauthorized reception of cable/satellite -TV), or 47 U.S.C. § 605 (e)(3) (unauthorized use or publication of a -communication) -Action filed under Small Business Investment Act 15:681, Securities -Exchange Act 15:78, Securities Act 15:77, Investment Advisers Act -15:80B(1-21) -Action primarily based on Statutes that cannot be classified under any -other nature of suit, such as: Foreign Agents Registration Act 22:611- -621, Klamath Termination Act 25:564-564W-L, Federal Aid Highway Act -23:101-142, Federal Corrupt Practices Act 2:241-256, Federal Election -Campaign Act, Highway Safety Act 23:401 Immigration & Nationality -Act 8:1503, Natural Gas Pipeline Safety Act 49:1671-1700, -Naturalization Acts 8:1421/18:911, 1015, 1421, et seq., 3282 or Federal -Aviation Act 49:1301 et seq. -Action filed under the Federal Crop Insurance Act 7:1501-1550, -Commodity Credit Corporation Act 15:713A-L & 4. -Action filed under Air Pollution Control Act 42:1857-57L, Clean Air Act -42:1857:57L, Federal Environment Pesticide Control Act, Federal -Insecticide, Fungicide & Rodenticide Act 7:135, Federal Water Pollution -Control Act 33:1151 et seq., Land & Water Conservation Fund Act -16:4602,460 1-4, Motor Vehicle Air Pollution Control Act 42:1857F-1-8, +• Complete registration for Student Health Insurance every -Page 7 of 8 +semester. - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +• -National Environmental Policy Act 42:4321, 4331-35G, 4341-47, River & -Harbor Act penalty 3:401-437, 1251. +If leaving the U.S. temporarily, have 1-20 or DS-2019 +signed by a Designated School Official and check visa +validity. -Other Statutes (Continued) -Title -Freedom of Information Act -Arbitration +• Check in with International Student Advisor at the beginning +of each semester and schedule appointments periodically. +Always bring all of your documents when you come. -Code -895 -896 +Information from Handbook is from the following websites. +www.travel.state.gov/visa (U.S. Department of State) +www.ice.gov (Department of Homeland Security) +www.uscis.gov (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) +www.ncaa.com (National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA)) -899 +39 -Administrative Procedure Act/Review or -Appeal of Agency Decision - -950 + Office of the International Student Advisor +Sue Ann Balch, J.D. +205 Reese Hall Lower East Campus, 504 College Drive +(229) 430-7075 (Office) +(229) 434-7106 (Fax) +Sueann.balch@asurams.edu (email address) -Constitutionality of State Statutes - -Description -Action filed under the Freedom of Information Act 5:552. -Action involving actions to confirm or modify arbitration awards filed -under Title 9 of the U.S. Code. -Action filed under the Administrative Procedures Act, 5 U.S.C. § 701, or -civil actions to review or appeal a federal agency decision. - -Action drawing into question the constitutionality of a federal or state -statute filed under (Rule 5.1). Rule 5.1 implements 28 U.S.C. §2403. - -Note: The statutes listed above are not all-inclusive, and other statues might be applicable to each nature of suit. - -Statutes that are included in the descriptions should be viewed as examples. - -Page 8 of 8 +40 diff --git a/q41/random_k2/random_2.md b/q41/random_k2/random_2.md index 50244c5de69c4368bc06c4f2d7f73d0fd691d0c9..3b75761d91384b6a83e0a670ace4d8a80c4f2471 100644 --- a/q41/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q41/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,1142 +1,605 @@ -| | BLAST: | | Benchmarking | | | | LLMs | with ASP-based | | Structured | | Testing | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | ManuelAlejandroBorrotoSantana1∗, | | | | | EricaCoppolillo1,2∗, | | | | | | | | -FrancescoCalimeri1,3,4, GiuseppeManco1, SimonaPerri3, FrancescoRicca3 -1UniversityofCalabria,Rende,Italy -2ICAR-CNR,Rende,Italy -3ArtificialIntelligenceLAB,DeMaCS,UniversityofCalabria,Rende,Italy -4DLVSystem,Rende,Italy -| | | | | name.surname | | | @unical.it, | name.surname | | @icar.cnr.it | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | { | | } | | { | } | | | | | | | -6202 rpA 42 ]OL.sc[ 1v60322.4062:viXra Abstract Clingo(Gebseretal.,2016)andDLV(Alvianoetal.,2017). -| | | | | | | | | ASP as | fully declarative | | paradigm | has | been | successfully | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -LargeLanguageModels(LLMs)havedemonstratedremark- -| | | | | | | | | employed | in both | academic | | research | and industrial | | appli- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -ableperformanceacrossabroadspectrumoftasks,including -| | | | | | | | | cations, particularly | | in | complex | domains | (e.g., | scheduling, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -naturallanguageunderstanding,dialoguesystems,andcode -| | | | | | | | | configuration, | robotics, | | workforce | planning, | | decision | sup- | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -| generation. | Despiteevidentprogress,lessattentionhasbeen | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | port) (Erdem, | Gelfond, | | and | Leone, | 2016; | Falkner | et al., | -paidtotheireffectivenessinhandlingdeclarativeparadigms -suchasAnswerSetProgramming(ASP),todate. Inthispa- 2018). Inrecentyearssubstantialefforthasbeendevotedto -perweintroduceBLAST:Thefirstdedicatedbenchmarking developing programming environments and tools that sup- -methodologyandassociateddatasetforevaluatingtheaccu- portthecreationofASPspecifications,includingadvanced -racy of LLMs in generating ASP code. BLAST provides editors, debuggers, testing frameworks, and utilities (Al- -a structured evaluation framework featuring two novel se- viano,Cirimele,andReiners,2023;Hahnetal.,2023;Feb- -mantic metrics tailored to ASPcode generation. The paper braro,Reale,andRicca,2011;Busoniuetal.,2013;Calimeri -presentstheresultsofanempiricalevaluationinvolvingten -etal.,2018). -well-establishedgraph-relatedproblemsfromtheASPlitera- -Motivation.Despitetheseadvancements,writingASPcode -tureandadiversesetofeightstate-of-the-artLLMs. -| | | | | | | | | remains often | challenging, | | especially | | for newcomers | | with- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | out a solid | background | | in logic | and | mathematics. | | In this | -Introduction -| | | | | | | | | context, | LLMs | represent | a promising | | avenue | for | support- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | -Large Language Models (LLMs) (Zhao, Zhou, and et al., ing,andevenautomating,ASPcoding. Recentstudieshave -| | | | | | | | | highlighted | significant | | limitations | in | the ability | of | general- | -| ----------- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | -| 2025) have | been | showing | remarkable | | performance | | across | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | purpose | LLMs to | generate | correct | and | semantically | | sound | -| a broad | spectrum | of | tasks, | including | natural | language | un- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | ASP programs | (Coppolillo | | et | al., 2024). | At | the same | time, | -| derstanding | (Qin | et | al., 2024), | dialogue | | systems | (Ou et | | | | | | | | | -al., 2024), and code generation (Jiang et al., 2024). More otherlinesofresearch,includingapproachesspecificallytai- -recently, some efforts have been made to encompass ad- lored to ASP encoding demonstrate that the overall direc- -| | | | | | | | | tion is viable | and | promising | (Ishay, | Yang, | and | Lee, | 2023a; | -| ------------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | --------------- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | -------------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ---- | ------ | -| vanced | reasoning, | knowledge | | representation, | | and | logical | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Borroto, | Kareem, | andRicca,2024;Coppolilloetal.,2024; | | | | | | -| formalisms | (Borroto, | | Kareem, | and | Ricca, | 2024; | Lippolis | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Schraderetal.,2025). | | | However,thefieldstilllackssystem- | | | | | -| et al., 2025; | Valmeekam | | et | al., 2025; | Smirnov | et | al., 2024; | | | | | | | | | -aticevaluations,standardizedbenchmarks,andwell-defined -Coppolilloetal.,2024).Inthiscontext,whileseveralbench- -marks have been proposed to assess LLM performance on metricsforrigorouslyassessingtheASP-codingcapabilities -ofLLMsand,moregenerally,ofanyautomaticapproach. -| imperative | and | web-oriented | | programming | | languages | (e.g., | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | | | | Contributions. | | To fill | this gap, | we | introduce | BLAST, | a | -| C++, Java, | HTML) | | (Ernst | and Bavota, | 2022; | Peng | et al., | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | benchmarking | methodology | | specifically | | designed | | to assess | -2023;Dakheletal.,2023),farlessattentionhasbeengiven -todeclarativeparadigmssuchasAnswerSetProgramming the accuracy of LLMs in generating ASP code. BLAST -(ASP)(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011;Gelfondand provides a structured evaluation framework that measures -| | | | | | | | | program | quality | through | two | novel metrics | | specifically | de- | -| ---------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | -| Lifschitz, | 1991), | despite | some | recent | initial | efforts | (Bor- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | signed for | ASP | code | generation. | The | methodology | | en- | -roto,Kareem,andRicca,2024;Ishay,Yang,andLee,2023a; -| | | | | | | | | compasses | both | evaluation | breadth | (covering | | a diverse | set | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -Coppolilloetal.,2024;Schraderetal.,2025). -| | | | | | | | | ofproblems), | anddepth(testingrobustnessacrossmultiple | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rootedinlogicprogrammingandnonmonotonicreason- -ing, ASP is well-suited for modeling and solving complex natural-language paraphrases of each problem). Crucially, -BLASTimposesnoguidanceorsyntacticconstraintsonin- -| AIproblems(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011). | | | | | | | Over | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | --------- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | put/outputformatsfortheevaluatedmodels. | | | | | | Moreover,ex- | | -| the years, | ASP | became | increasingly | | adopted | | for its ex- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | isting procedures | | mostly | rely | on manual | evaluations | | of the | -| pressive | language | and | the | availability | of | efficient | and re- | | | | | | | | | -automatedencodingoutcomes(Borroto,Kareem,andRicca, -| liable solvers | | (Gebser, | Maratea, | and | Ricca, | 2020), | notably | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | 2024;Coppolilloetal.,2024), | | | | resultingintime-consuming | | | | -∗Equalcontribution. and potentially inconsistent assessments. In contrast, we - -propose a systematic approach that automates the evalua- IDE.Wenotethat(Schwitter,2018)developedaCNLcalled -tionprocess,reducinghumaninterventionwhileimproving PENGASP for specifying and verbalizing ASP programs, -scalability,reliabilityandreproducibility. while(Carusoetal.,2024)introducedCNL2ASP,anexten- -We assess BLAST via an experimental study that tack- sivepublicly-availabletoolforconvertingcontrollednatural -lestenwell-knowngraphproblemsfromtheASPliterature languageintoASPprograms. -usingapoolofeightstate-of-the-artLLMs. -Themaincontributionofthepresentworkcanbesumma- -rizedasfollows: ASP and LLMs. Powerful language tools such as LLMs -• We release a benchmark dataset with ten graph-related have been exploited in conjunction with the ASP formal- -| | | | | | | | | ism in several | | ways. | (Nye et | al., 2021) | introduced | | a dual- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -problemstobeencodedinASP. -| | | | | | | | | system | model | based | on GPT-3, | which | generates | | semantic | -| ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | ----- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| • We propose | two | novel | evaluation | methods | | to automati- | | | | | | | | | | -parsersfromnaturallanguagesentencesandintegratesthem -| cally assess | the | quality | of the | generated | programs. | | Both | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | ----- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | with reasoning | | modules. | In | a similar | vein, | (Yang, | Ishay, | -| approaches | operate | without | imposing | | any | constraints | on | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | and Lee, | 2023) | proposed | that | LLMs | like | GPT-3 | can work | -theLLM’sinputoroutputformat,makingthesystemro- -asfew-shotsemanticparsers,transformingnaturallanguage -busttovariationsandrenamingofinputandoutputpred- -intologicalformsforASPwithoutnecessitatingdistinctre- -icatesymbols. -| | | | | | | | | trainingfordiversequestion-answeringtasks. | | | | | | (Ishay,Yang, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -• Weevaluateeightstate-of-the-artLLMs,fromfivediffer- -| | | | | | | | | and Lee, | 2023b) | utilized | LLMs | with | prompt | engineering | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -entfamilies,byconsideringtheoriginalproblemdescrip- to obtain ASP solutions for logic puzzles, leveraging the -tionalongwithparaphrasedversions,toassessthemodel logic puzzle dataset from (Mitra and Baral, 2016). (Ka- -flexibilityininterpretinghuman-likecraftedprompts. -| | | | | | | | | reem et | al., 2024) | introduced | | LLM2LAS, | | which | combines | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -Forthesakeofreproducibility,thecompleteexperimental LLMswithILASP(Law, Russo, andBroda,2020)tolearn -setup,includingcodeandevaluationdata,ismadepublicly commonsenseknowledgefromstory-basedQ&A,enabling -available.1 the system to generalize with minimal examples and effec- -| | | | | | | | | tively answer | | unseen | questions. | Further, | | the effective | use | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -RelatedWork of LLMs in combination with ASP to perform a number -| | | | | | | | | of natural | language | understanding | | | tasks | has been | explored | -| --------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | -| Automatic | Code | Synthesis. | | The advantages | | of automat- | | | | | | | | | | -andimplementedintheSTARframework(Rajasekharanet -| ing code | synthesis | are | well-recognized | | in | the | litera- | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | al.,2023). | Baueretal.(2024)proposedNSGRAPH,anap- | | | | | | | -ture(ErnstandBavota,2022;Kalliamvakou,2022;Penget -proachthatintegratesvisionmodules,LLM-basedsemantic -al.,2023;Dakheletal.,2023),andautomatedprogramcom- -parsing,andASPreasoningforVisualGraphQuestionAn- -| position tools | now | support | nearly | all mainstream | | program- | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | swering, | where | LLMs | extract | ASP | predicates | from | natural | -| ming languages | | (Chen, | Tworek, | and et | al., 2021). | | In this | | | | | | | | | -languagequestionsthatarethenprocessedbyanASPsolver. -| area, Large | Language | | Models | (LLMs) | play | a central | role, | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -BeyondASP,Voboril,Ramaswamy,andSzeider(2025)pro- -andtheirperformancehasbeenextensivelycomparedinthe -| | | | | | | | | posed StreamLLM, | | an | approach | | that leverages | | LLMs to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | -literature(Xuetal.,2022;Wangetal.,2023),whilealsothe -| | | | | | | | | generate | and validate | | streamlining | | constraints | in | MiniZinc | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -positiveimpactoffine-tuningmodelsforcodegenerationof -models,achievingsubstantialspeedupsacrossmultiplecon- -imperativeprogrammingisestablished(Maetal.,2024). -| | | | | | | | | straint satisfaction | | benchmarks. | | (Ren | et | al., 2025) | intro- | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | -| Inthecontextofdeclarativeprogramming, | | | | | | awidelyrec- | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | duced a | benchmark | focused | | on evaluating | | the ASP | solving | -ognizedresearchobjectiveistocreatetoolsthatstreamline -| | | | | | | | | abilities | of LLMs | (i.e., | entailment, | | verification | | and com- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -andautomatethedevelopmentofASPprograms,thusbridg- -| | | | | | | | | putation | of answer | sets). | In | contrast, | BLAST | focuses | on | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | -ingthegapbetweennaturallanguagespecificationsandASP -sourcecode(ErdemandYeniterzi,2009;FangandTompits, the task of generating ASP code. (Borroto, Kareem, and -| | | | | | | | | Ricca, 2024) | presented | | the | NL2ASP | tool, | that | constructs | -| ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ---------- | -| 2017; Schwitter, | | 2018; | Caruso | et al., 2024). | | Early propos- | | | | | | | | | | -ASPprogramsfromnaturallanguagespecificationsthrough -| als focused | on | automating | the | resolution | of | logic | puzzles | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | a two-step | architecture. | | NL2ASP | | works | by translating | the | -presentedinsimplifiedEnglishbytranslatingtheirdescrip- -NLspecificationsintoCNLstatements,whicharethencon- -| tions into | ASP | (Baral | and Dzifcak, | 2011), | | employing | λ- | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -calculus and probabilistic combinatorial categorical gram- verted into ASP code using the CNL2ASP tool. NL2ASP -| | | | | | | | | was implemented | | using | well-known | | models | for neural | ma- | -| ------------ | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ----------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ----- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | ---------- | ---- | -| mars. Later, | several | efforts | have | been | spent | in the | devel- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | chine translation | | (NMT) | and | demonstrated | | promising | per- | -| opment of | Controlled | | Natural | Languages | (CNLs) | | (Kuhn, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | formance. | Morerecently,(Coppolilloetal.,2024)provides | | | | | | | -2014)forASPprograms;CNLsrepresentsubsetsoffullnat- -afirstevaluationofLLMsperformanceinencodingsimple, -urallanguages,featuringrestrictedgrammarandvocabulary. -coreASPprograms,furthershowingthatLLMsarenotgood -| Among them, | the | BIOQUERYCNL | | (Erdem | | and Yeniterzi, | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | atASPcoding, | | butfine-tuningcanbebeneficial. | | | | | However, | -2009)definesthegrammaticalstructureofaCNLandalgo- -nobenchmarkormethodologyforsystematicassessmentof -| rithm for | transpiling | queries | into | ASP; | (Fang | and Tompits, | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----------- | ------- | --------------- | ---- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | --------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | LLM in | the general | ASP | coding | task | is | provided | (Coppo- | -| 2017) introduced | | a CNL | approach | for | ASP | that leverages | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | lillo et al., | 2024). | Building | | on the | potential | of fine-tuning, | | -| LANA annotations, | | that | was implemented | | in | the SeaLion | | | | | | | | | | -(Schraderetal.,2025)introducedanASP-solver-in-the-loop -1https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ frameworkthatimprovesLLM-basedASPcodegeneration -LLMs-ASP-Benchmark-DFC3/ forcombinatorialproblemsbyusingdirectsolverfeedback - -to curate data for supervised fine-tuning and to further im- Input -prove robustness through a solver-guided search that in- ASP -Target LLM -cludesbest-of-Nsampling. -Predicate -EvaluationBenchmarks. Asubstantialbodyofliterature ASP Generation Matcher -provides benchmarking datasets and test suites tailored to ASP -{ ... } -evaluating LLMs on imperative (e.g., Python, C++, Java) ASP ASP -{ ... } Testing -and web-oriented programming languages (e.g., HTML, Paraphraser -ASP -CSS,JavaScript)suchas(Xuetal.,2025;Shah, Genc, and { ... } -Araci,2025;Duetal.,2024;Chen,Tworek,andetal.,2021; -Dingetal.,2023;Liu,Xu,andMcAuley,2023). Compara- Figure1: Schemeoftheoverallproposedframework. Inputcon- -sists of the textual specification of the problem, the target LLM -tively,wearguethatmuchlessattentionhasbeendevotedto -to be evaluated, and the correct (gold) ASP program. The ASP -declarativeprogrammingparadigms. -Generationmodulecomprises: theparaphraser, anLLMwhich -A first benchmark for automatic translation from natural -paraphrasestheoriginalproblemdescriptioninmorehuman-styled -language to ASP was introduced by Borroto, Kareem, and -texts; andthepredicatematcher, anLLMwhichmapsthepredi- -Ricca (2024). However, it primarily focuses on controlled catesofthegeneratedprogramstotheonesofthegoldprogram. -naturallanguage(Carusoetal.,2024)andfeaturesinputsen- Thepredicatemappingsandthegoldencodingarefinallyprovided -tenceswithlimitedfluency. totheASPTestingmodule,whichperformstheevaluation. -Recently, Ren et al. (2025) proposed a methodology -to assess whether state-of-the-art LLMs can solve pro- -gramscodedinASP,comparingtheircapabilitiestostandard answersets. Ratherthanpresentingaformalintroductionto -solvers. However, their goal (computing answer sets with thelanguage, weprovidearepresentativeexampletohigh- -LLMs)isdifferentfromours(testingLLMscodingability). lightitsexpressivepower: theclassical3-colorabilityprob- -Tothebestofourknowledge,noexistingbenchmarken- lem, which requires assigning one of three colors to each -ables systematic automatic evaluation of LLMs ability to nodeofanundirectedgraphsuchthatadjacentnodesreceive -generateASPprograms. Thisworkaddressesthisgap. differentcolors. -The following ASP encoding captures this specification. -Preliminaries The input graph (nodes and edges) and the available col- -ors are represented via facts. A choice rule assigns exactly -Large Language Model. A Large Language Model -onecolortoeachnode,andanintegrityconstrainteliminates -(LLM) is a function f that stochastically maps an input -coloringsinwhichadjacentnodessharethesamecolor: -token sequence x = [x ,...,x ] to an output sequence -1 n -y = [y 1 ,...,y m ],withx V∗ andy W∗,whereV and col(red). col(green). col(black). node(1..4). -∈ ∈ -W are token vocabularies. Formally, f defines the condi- edge(1,2). edge(4,2). edge(1,3). -tionalprobabilityP (y x),fromwhichyissampled,captur- -ing the structure and s | emantics of natural language. LLMs 1 { colored(X,C) : col(C) } 1 :- node(X). -typically adopt the Transformer encoder-decoder architec- :- edge(X,Y), colored(X,C), colored(Y,C). -ture(Vaswanietal.,2017).Theinputtokensarefirstembed- -ASP also provides constructs for optimization via weak -ded into dense vectors encoding contextual and positional -constraints, which allow specifying preferences among an- -information. These embeddings pass through the Trans- -swer sets. For instance, to minimize the number of nodes -former: the encoder applies self-attention and feedforward -assignedthecolorred: -layerstomodeldependencieswithintheinput,whilethede- -coder combines masked self-attention, encoder-decoder at- -:∼colored(X,red). [1@1,X] -tention,andfeedforwardtransformationstogenerateoutputs -tokenbytoken. Thedecoderoutputsaprobabilitydistribu- Thisexampleillustratesthedeclarativenatureandexpres- -tion over the output vocabulary via a linear layer followed siveness of ASP in modeling complex combinatorial prob- -bysoftmax: P (y i x,y :i−1 ), wherey :i−1 istheprefixupto lems. For arigorousintroductiontotheASPlanguage and -| -tokeni 1. Generationproceedsstepwisefromthisdistribu- itssemantics,pleaserefertotheaforesaidliterature. -− -tion. Architectural variants exist (Naveed et al., 2024; Ra- -iaan et al., 2024), but their internal design is orthogonal to -BLASTMethodology -our focus. LLMs are generally invoked via prompting: a -textualquery(orprompt)isprovidedasinputtothemodel, -The core of the approach consists in testing the generation -whichtriggerscontentgeneration. -capabilitiesofatargetLLM.Forthis, wedeviseamethod- -ologyconsistingoftwomaincomponents: (i)anASPGen- -Answer Set Programming. Answer Set Programming erationframeworkthat,startingfromaspecificationinnat- -(ASP)isadeclarativeformalismforKnowledgeRepresenta- urallanguage,providesasetofencodingsoftheproblemin -tionandReasoning(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011; ASP;(ii)anASPTestinginfrastructureaimedatevaluating -GelfondandLifschitz,1991). InASP,aproblemisencoded the performance of the target LLM. The overall scheme of -as a finite set of logical rules, and solutions correspond to theapproachisdetailedinFigure1. - -ASPGeneration -| | | | | | | | 1 {assign(N, | C) : colour(C)} | 1 | :- node(N). | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -The framework for generating ASP initiates with a natural :- edge(X, Y), assign(X, C), assign(Y, C). -| language | description | of | the problem | intended | | for ASP en- | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -coding,alongsideagoldprogramthatexemplifiestheASP- If there is no semantic match between some predicates, -| | | | | | | | output ‘No | semantic match’ | only. | Otherwise, produce | the | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------------- | ----- | ------------------ | ----- | -| basedsolution. | | Thegenerationprocessisdrivenbythefol- | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | matchesoverallthepredicatesasapythondictionary. | | | | Donot | -| lowing elements: | | (i) the | target | LLM, | serving | as the gen- | | | | | | -erator under evaluation, in charge of encoding the problem generateanyadditionaltext. -| into ASP; | (ii) an | LLM | instructed | to | paraphrase | the ini- | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thegeneratedmatchingdictionaryisthefollowing: -| tial problem | description | | to make | it more | human-readable; | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -{‘node’:‘node’,‘edge’:‘edge’,‘color’:‘colour’,‘chosen’:‘assign’} -(iii)anLLMthatsemanticallymatchesthepredicatesofthe -resultingprogramwiththoseinthegoldprogram. -1.0 -Gold -| Target | LLM. | As an | initial | step in | our framework, | the | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | scitnameS | | Generated | | -| LLM under | evaluation | | is prompted | with | the | problem de- | | | | | | -| scriptionandaskedtoprovideanencodinginASPlanguage. | | | | | | | | 0.5 | | | | -| Box 1 provides | | an example | of | the provided | prompt. | (Note | | | | | | -that,thiscomponentcanbereplacedbyanymethodgener- -0.0 -atingASPprogramsfromnaturallanguagespecifications.) -| | | | | | | | | ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD elcycnainotlimaH | htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH euqilclamixaM | noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS nosrepelasgnilevarT | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | --- | -Box1:TargetLLMPromptExample -| [PROBLEM | DESCRIPTION] | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ----------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Write | an ASP | program | which | models | this problem, | along | | | | | | -| withfactsthatmakeitinstantiable. | | | | Generatetheprogramonly, | | | | | | | | -withoutanyadditionaltext. -Figure2: Semanticcomparisonontheconsideredproblemscom- -PredicateMatcher. Itisimportanttoremarkthatthetar- puted by using the “gold” matching dictionary (manually crafted -get model is not given any instructions or constraints re- byauthors)andthegeneratedone.DeepSeek-R1hasbeenusedas -thetargetLLM. -| garding | the syntax, | predicate | names, | | or problem | modeling | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| to adopt. | To normalize | | its output | and | enable | comparison | | | | | | -withthegoldstandardsolution,weemployafurtherLLM, We emphasize three crucial aspects of the predicate -referredtoasthePredicateMatcher. Thismodeltakesasin- matcher component. First, the predicate matching phase is -putboththegoldprogramandtheencodinggeneratedbythe independentofencodingcorrectness:thematcherLLMonly -targetmodel,andispromptedtoperformasemanticmatch semanticallyassociatespredicatesbetweenprograms,with- -outassessingtheirvalidity.Second,thematcherdoesnotse- -| ofthepredicatesusedinthetwoprograms. | | | | | Theresultisre- | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -turnedasaPythondictionarymappingcorrespondingpred- manticallyalteracorrectprogram. Inotherwords,thequal- -icates. Ifnosemanticsimilaritycanbeestablishedbetween ityofthetargetLLMperformance(thatis,itsabilitytogen- -theprograms, themodelisinstructedtoreturn“Noseman- erateacorrectASPprogramfromanaturallanguageprob- -ticmatch”. Anexamplepromptofthepredicatematcheris lemdescription)remainsconsistentregardlessofwhethera -| | | | | | | | “gold” predicate | matching | dictionary | (manually crafted | by | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -providedinBox3,consideringtheColorabilityproblem. -theauthors)orageneratedoneisused(seeFigure2,where -Box3:PredicateMatcherPromptExample weuseDeepSeek-R1astherepresentativetargetLLM).The -Perform predicate matching on the following ASP programs onlyexceptionistheTravelingSalespersonproblem,where -basedonthesemanticsimilarityofthepredicates: performance is slightly better with the gold matching. By -lookingdeeperintothisproblem,werealizedthatdespitethe -ASPInstance1: -bettermatching,thegeneratedprogramswerestillincorrect. -node(1). node(2). node(3). Third, we remark that this result enables our methodology -edge(1,2). edge(1,3). edge(2,1). to achieve a high degree of generality, since it allows eval- -edge(2,3). color(red). color(green). uating generated programs without imposing any prompt- -color(black). ingconstraintsontheLLMs. Indeed,wedeliberatelyavoid -1 {chosen(N,C) : color(C)} 1 :- node(N). penalizing encodings that differ only at the syntactic level, -:- edge(U,V), U < V, chosen(U,C), chosen(V,C). throughtheuseofalternativepredicatenames. Forinstance, -adoptingreach(X)insteadofreached(X)torepresent -ASPInstance2: the same concept should not negatively affect the evalua- -node(a). node(b). node(c). tion, providedthattheprogramissemanticallycorrect. By -edge(a, b). edge(b, c). edge(c, d). abstracting away from superficial naming differences, our -colour(1). colour(2). colour(3). approach focuses on assessing genuine modeling and cod- -ingabilityratherthansensitivitytoarbitrarylexicalchoices. - -Paraphraser. Inadditiontothetechnicallydetailedorig- @constraintForAll(constraint=":- node(U), -inalproblemstatement,wefurtherevaluatetheadaptability not chosenColor(U,_).") -ofthetargetmodeltounderstandpromptsthatareformatted -tobemorerelatabletohumans. Thegoalistoevaluatethe which ensures that every node U is assigned at least one -modelsnotonlyintermsofbreadth,byaddressingadiverse color. Finally, we add test cases to check whether the pro- -setofproblems,butalsointermsofdepth,byassessingtheir gramproducestheexpectednumberofanswersets. -abilitytoadapttolesstechnical,moreaccessibletextualde- -scriptions intended for an “ASP layman”. To achieve this, -Model-basedTesting. ThismethodevaluatesanASPpro- -weuseanotherLLMasaparaphraser togeneratetwover- -gramP basedonitsabilitytoreproducethecorrect(gold) -sions of the initial description. An example prompt is re- t -(stable) models (GM) for a given set of instances provided -portedinBox2intheSupplementaryMaterial. -viafacts. Thecoreideareliesontheassumptionthat,given -Theparaphrasingprocessisconductedintwophases.Ini- -a gold program P and a set of instances, the target pro- -tially, a first version is derived from the original problem g -gram P is considered correct if and only if it produces -statement. Thisversionisthenemployedasabasisforpro- t -the same (stable) models as P on those instances. To -ducingasecondone.Bothversionsaresubsequentlyusedto g -formalize this, we define the set of target program models -promptthetargetLLMwithalternativespecifications. Note -(TPM) as the (stable) models of P , and the covered gold -thatthisphaseisoptionalintheproposedframework.While t -models (CGM) as the intersection of TPM and GM, i.e., -we study the impact of paraphrased textual descriptions on -CGM=GM TPM. -modelperformanceasanadditionalanalysis,thetargetLLM ∩ -ToquantifytheaccuracyofP ,weusethestandard(mi- -canstillbeevaluatedusingonlytheoriginalencoding. t -cro) F1-score (Christen, Hand, and Kirielle, 2023), which -combinesprecisionandrecall,definedas: -ASPTesting -To evaluate the ASP programs generated by the LLMs, we CGM CGM -Recall= | | and Precision= | |, -propose two methods: (i) a test-suite-based approach and GM TPM -(ii) a model-based approach. Both methods are associated | | | | -The (micro) F1 score is then computed as the harmonic -with proper metrics that allow us to measure a form of se- -meanofprecisionandrecall,providingabalancedmeasure -mantic distance from the gold program. Both approaches -oftheprogram’sabilitytoreproducetheexpectedmodels. -assumethateachproblemhasafixedsetofinputandoutput -Notably,weretrievetheCGMsetwithhighefficiencyby -predicates, corresponding to the ones of the gold program. -mean of the Algorithm 1, which leverages an ASP solver. -Thisassumptionispragmatic,yetreasonablynottoorestric- -Rather than relying on full answer set enumeration of the -tive. Indeed, LLMs are expected to produce meaningful -program under test, that might quickly become infeasible, -programs as written by a human; thus, syntactic variations -we modify the ASP program to directly target specific so- -ofpredicatenamesareverylikelyresolvedbythepredicate -lutions. Inparticular,weconstrainthesearchspacetogold -matcher. Ifnot,weassumetheprogramisnotcorrect. -modelsonly,therebyavoidingtheoverheadofenumerating -irrelevantanswersets. Clearly, wecarefullycraftedoutin- -Test-Suite-basedEvaluation. Thisevaluationmethodre- -stance set to be sure that the enumeration of gold program -lies on the unit testing mechanism implemented in the -answersisinsteadfeasible. -ASP-WIDE tool (Amendola et al., 2024), which uses an -The algorithm takes as input the program to test P , a -t -annotation-basedtestspecificationlanguageinspiredbyJU- -gold program P , and a set of instances Ins. For each -g -nit. The objective is to create a test suite that thoroughly -instanceI Ins, wecomputethesetofgoldmodelsAS -g -checkstheprogramfunctionality. Atestsuiteisacollection ∈ -bycomputingallanswersetsofP I usinganASPsolver -g -oftestcases, eachcomprisingassertionsthatverifyanum- ∪ -(line 5). Then, for each gold model M AS , we create -g g -berofconditionsontheexpectedprogramoutput. Basedon ∈ -asetofconstraintsaimedatforcingM tobeananswerset -g -thetestsuiteresults,wecomputethetestcaseaccuracyas -ofP (line8). Specifically,foreachatomaovertheoutput -t -theratioofpassedtestcasesoverthetotalnumber. -predicates, if a M then we add the constraint :-nota; -Toensurethisevaluationmethodiseffective,itiscrucial ∈ g -otherwise,weaddtheconstraint:-a. -todesignarobusttestsuiteovermostoftheprogram’sex- -pected behavior. To this end, we developed a guideline for -For the sake of clarity, let us consider the Col- -constructing meaningful test cases. The first step involves -orability problem with 3 nodes and 3 colors and a -creatingtestcasestocheckforunsatisfiability. Specifically, -gold model M where node 1 is colored as purple, -given a set of input instances that violate the problem con- g -node 2 as red, and node 3 as brown. In this case, -straints,theprogramisexpectedtoreturnnoanswersetfor -create model constraints(M g) returns the fol- -eachinstance. Next,wedefinetestcasesthatverifythesat- -lowingconstraints: -isfiabilityoftheproblemconstraintsbycheckingifvalidin- -stancescomply with them. If needed, we furtherrefine the :- not chosenColor(3,brown). -test suite by adding test cases that validate the correctness :- not chosenColor(2,red). -of the program’s output atoms. For example, in the Col- :- not chosenColor(1,purple). -orabilityproblem,itshouldneveroccurthatanoderemains :- chosenColor(1,brown). -uncolored. ThisisdonebywritinganASP-WIDEtestcase :- chosenColor(1,red). -withthefollowingassertion: :- chosenColor(2,brown). - -:- chosenColor(2,purple). Algorithm 1 Finding P covered gold models and overall -t -:- chosenColor(3,red). models. -:- chosenColor(3,purple). Input: AprogramP ,aprogramP ,asetofinstancesIns. -t g -Output: the sets of models GM, CGM, and -Intuitively, in the answer set M , node 1 is colored WM. -g -as purple (i.e., chosenColor(1,purple) M g ) and 1: GM = -so :-notchosenColor(1,purple) is obtain ∈ ed. Con- 2: CGM = ∅ -versely, node 1 is colored neither red nor brown, 3: WM = ∅ -and so the constraints :-chosenColor(1,red) and 4: forI I ∅ nsdo -:-chosenColor(1,brown) are obtained. Analogously, the 5: AS ∈ g =solve all(P g I). -remainingconstraintsareobtainedfornodes2and3. Note 6: GM =GM AS g . ∪ -that, if the gold program contains weak constraints then 7: forM g AS ∪ g do -create model constraints(M g) does not return 8: C g = ∈create model constraints(M g ). -strong constraints as in the previous example but a set of 9: M =solve once(P t C g I). -weak constraints with cost 1 and a priority higher than the 10: ifM =M g then ∪ ∪ -maximum priority used in P t . This ensures that the solver 11: CGM =CGM M g -prioritizestheinclusionofthesegoldatomsintheresulting 12: endif ∪{ } -answer sets. After obtaining the set of constraints C g , the 13: endfor -program P t ∪ C g ∪ I is solved using the solver configured 14: P ta =aug program(P t ,AS g ). -to return exactly one answer set M. This operation is 15: AS w =solve all(P ta I). -performed by the function solve once in line 9 of the 16: WM =WM AS w ∪ -algorithm. Then,thegoldmodelM g isconsideredcovered 17: endfor ∪ -ifM g exactlymatchesM. M andM g exactlymatchif,for 18: returnGM,CGM,WM -each atom a over output predicates, it holds that a M if -∈ -andonlyifa M . -g -∈ -The next step is to identify the set of models generated -amodelofP . Notethatthisruleisdomain-specific,asthe -byP thatdifferfromthegoldmodels(i.e.,wrongmodels). t -t -outputpredicatenamesvaryacrossdifferentdomains.Then, -Notethatthislaststepisnecessaryinordertoproperlycal- -rules in lines 7-8 compute for each gold model, the differ- -culateTPM.Tothisend,wefirstaugmentP withthesetof -t ences with a candidate model of P . Finally, the constraint -factsencodingthegoldmodelsinAS . Todothis,weused t -g -atline9forcestheprogramtodiscardamodelifitmatches -the predicate trueInGold/2, where the first term is an iden- -a gold model. Once the program P is obtained, the al- -tifier (i.e., a positive integer) for a gold model M AS , ta -g ∈ g gorithm calls the solver to compute all models of P I -and the second term is a true atom in M . Note that, such ta -g (i.e.,solve all(P I)).Obtainedmodelsareconside ∪ red -facts are obtained considering only atoms over the output ta -∪ -wrong. Finally, the algorithm returns the set of gold mod- -predicates. Then,theprogramP isfurtheraugmentedwith -t -els over all instances GM, the set of covered gold models -additional rules that discard all those models of P that ex- -t -CGM GM, and the set of wrong models WM, which is -actlymatchonegoldmodel. Thisaugmentedversionofthe -⊆ -disjoint from GM. The value TPM can then be calculated -programP isreturnedbythefunctionaug programand -t | | -asthesumofthenumberofelementsofCGMandWM. -is denoted as P . For example, let us consider again the -ta -Colorability problem and the gold model in which node 1 -is colored as purple, node 2 as red, and node 3 as brown. Discussion on Metrics. The introduced metrics are in- -In this case the program P ta is obtained by adding to the tended to assess how well an ASP program semantically -programP t therulesreportedinListing1. models a given problem. Among the two evaluation meth- -ods, the test-suite-based approach offers a more accurate -Listing1:RulesandfactsusedtoaugmentaprogramP targeting -t -measure of program correctness, as it involves white-box -theColorabilityproblem. -testing. This type of testing enables detailed inspection of -1 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(2,red)). -a program internal behavior, rather than relying solely on -2 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(1,purple)). -its output models. However, the test-suite-based approach -3 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(3,brown)). -has some limitations; in fact, it requires a human expert to -4 ... -5 mod(X) :- trueInGold(X,_). design the test cases, and the reliability of the final assess- -6 trueInTested(chosenColor(X,Y)) :- chosenColor(X,Y). ment depends heavily on the quality of the test suite. In -7 smallerMG(M) :- trueInGold(M, X), not trueInTested(X). contrast, the model-based approach offers a higher level of -8 smallerMt(M) :- mod(M), trueInTested(X), not automation,ashumaninterventionislimitedtoprovidingin- -trueInGold(M, X). putinstancesandthegoldprogram. Thismethod,however, -9 :- mod(M), not smallerMG(M), not smallerMt(M). makesitmoredifficulttoknowthereasonswhyaprogram -Rules in lines 1-3 in Listing 1 represent the facts encod- may be incorrect, which limits potential efforts to improve -ing the considered gold model (here we reported only one it. Indeed, we might inspect the results and discover some -for the sake of readability, but all gold models are consid- answersetismissingorwrong,butthereisnoclueonwhy -ered). Theruleatline6isusedtocomputethetrueatomsin ithappens. Ontheotherhand,specifictestcasesaredevised - -| with the | aim at testing | a | specific | ability, | and | thus are more | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| connectedtoareasonforthefailure. | | | | | | | | 1.0 | | | | | | | -ycaruccA -ExperimentalEvaluation -0.5 -| We present | our experimental | | evaluation, | | which | tackles the | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -followingresearchquestions: -| RQ1: Are | state-of-the-art | | LLMs | effective | in | ASP coding, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0.0 -| | | | | | | | | | y t | e h | g e | n k | e n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u n d e r b o t h s y n t a c t i c a n d s e m a n ti c p e r s p e c ti v e s ? bilit S e c l at n q u o n a g o -| | | | | | | | | | g | C y P | er i Cli | artiti erli | arri ers | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | a n | n | ust | h | p | | -R Q 2 : H o w d o e s p a r a p h r a s in g i m p a c t o n p e r f o r m a n c e ? or ati a n a al P Slit M e -| | | | | | | | | ol | n ni | ni | Cl m | | al | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | C | mi o | ilt o al | i | bl | e S | | -R Q 3 : H o w d o t h e p r o p o s e d s e m a n t i c m e t r i c s c o m p a r e, in milt c a x a g -| | | | | | | | | | D o | m hi | M | St | eli n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -t e r m s o f a c c u r a c y a n d e f fi c i e n c y ? a H a c -| | | | | | | | | | H | a r | | | a v | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | er | | | Tr | | -Hi -SetupandValidationProtocol -| Dataset | To evaluate | the | proposed | approach, | | we created | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3:PerformanceofGPT-4oaspredicatematcher.Errorbars -| a dataset | comprising | the | following | ten | graph-related | prob- | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -representconfidenceintervalsontendifferentruns. -lems: Colorability,(Connected)DominatingSet,Hamil- -| tonian | Cycle, Hamiltonian | | Path, | Hierarchical | | Cluster- | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ing, Maximal Clique, (Graph) Partitioning, Slitherlink, Settings. Alltestedmodelshavebeeninvokedviatheded- -| (Strong) | Stable | Marriage, | and | Traveling | Salesman. | We | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -icatedAPIsofOpenAI,Anthropic,Google,andDeepSeek, -| selected | this set | of tasks | since | they are | standard | problems | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | ------------------ | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | with a temperature | | of | 0.7 (when | allowed). | | In the | case of | -| used in | many ASP | competitions | | (Gebser, | | Maratea, and | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | LLaMa3.3-70B, | | we used | a self-hosted | | instance | using | the | -| Ricca, 2017; | Calimeri, | Ianni, | and | Ricca, | 2014; | Alviano et | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Ollama | tool. | The LLM-related | | and | ASP-testing | code | has | -al.,2013). Eachproblemincludesaformalnaturallanguage beenimplementedinPython. TheinteractionwiththeASP- -| description | and the | corresponding | | gold | program. | For each | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | WIDE tool | (developed | | in Spring | Boot) | was | done | through | -| problem, | we provide | the | related | test suite | and | the input in- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | a RESTful | API | endpoint. | The | experiments | | have been | con- | -stancesrequiredbytheevaluationmethodsoutlinedearlier. -ductedonaserverequippedwithanIntel(R)Xeon(R)CPU -IntheSupplementaryMaterial,weprovidetheproblemde- -E7-8880v4@2.20GHz,512GBofRAM,andrunningDe- -scriptionsanddetailsregardingthetestsuitedesign. bian 13 (6.1.0-32-amd64). Additional information and ex- -perimentalresultsareprovidedasSupplementaryMaterial. -Test Suite Validation. To ensure the quality of our test Theexperimentalcodeismadepubliclyavailable.2 -| suite, we | draw inspiration | | from | Oetsch | et al. | (2012), who | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| empiricallydemonstratedthatthesmall-scopehypothesisof | | | | | | | Results | | | | | | | | -| traditional | testing | is also | applicable | to | ASP programs, | i.e., | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Predicate | Matcher | Accuracy. | | We | first assess | the | predi- | -many errors can be detected by testing a program against cate matcher accuracy in mapping predicates from the two -inputs involving only a small number of objects. Follow- inputprogramssemantically. Toachievethis, wemanually -| ing Amendola | et | al. (Amendola | | et al., | 2024), | we employ | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | ----------------- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | verify the | matches, | assigning | | each | generated | dictionary | a | -| a mutation-based | | testing | strategy | specifically | | designed for | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | score ranging | | from [0,1]. | Specifically, | | we | count | the cor- | -| ASP(Oetschetal.,2012). | | | GivenanASPprogram,thetool | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | rect associations | | and average | | them | over the | total | number | -randomly applies a set of modifications to its rules, gener- of predicates. For each problem, we create ten separate -ating mutants, altered versions of the original program that matchestoensurestatisticalsignificanceandreportthe av- -| introducesubtleerrors. | | Foreachgoldprogram,wegenerate | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | erage as | the ultimate | performance | | score. | Figure | 3 | presents | -15mutantsandexecutethecorrespondingtestsuiteonthem -| | | | | | | | the results | using | GPT-4o | as the | predicate | matcher. | | The ac- | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ------- | -| usingourselectedinputinstances. | | | | Aftereachexecution,we | | | | | | | | | | | -curacyofthemodelonthistaskcomesasnosurprise,given -iteratively refine the test suite and the input instances until itswell-documentedabilitiestoperformtextsummarization -noneofthemutantsachievesaperfecttestscore(i.e., 1.0). and rephrasing (Adams et al., 2023; Zhou, Ringeval, and -| This iterative | process | ensures | that | the | test suite | is effective | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ------- | ------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Portet,2025);thus,weoptforGPT-4oalsoasaparaphraser. -indetectingdeviationsfromtheexpectedprogrambehavior. -| | | | | | | | LLMsPerformance(RQ1). | | | | Further,weassesstheeffec- | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ------------------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -| TestedModels. | | Fortheexperimentalevaluation,weadopt | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | tiveness | of the | evaluated | models | concerning | | both | syntactic | -eight state-of-the-art LLMs from five distinct families: o4- syntax and semantic accuracy. Figure 4 shows the average -mini (OpenAI, 2025b), Claude-3.5-Sonnet (Anthropic, resultsforallexaminedproblems,whereasFigure5displays -| 2024), DeepSeek-R1 | | (DeepSeek, | | 2025), | Gemini-1.5-Pro | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | -------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | scores for | each | individual | problem. | | At this | stage, | we con- | -| (Team | and et al., | 2024), | Gemini-2.5-Flash | | | (Comanici, | | | | | | | | | -centratesolelyontheinitialproblemstatements,withmore -| Bieber, | and et al., | 2025), | GPT-4o | (OpenAI, | | 2024), GPT- | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -5(OpenAI,2025a),andLLaMa3.3-70B (Grattafioriandet 2https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ -| al.,2024). | | | | | | | LLMs-ASP-Benchmark-DFC3/ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| o4-mini | | DeepSeek-R1 | | Gemini2.5 | | GPT-5 | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | ------------------- | --- | --------------- | -| Claude3.5 | | Gemini1.5 | | GPT-4o | | LLaMa3.3 | | | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.6 0.8 | 1.0 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | 1 0.40.40.20.10.8 | | 0 0.10.40.1 | -| | 1.0 | | | | | | | o4-mini | 1 1 1 | 1 0.8 1 | 0.8 1 0.80.8 | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Claude3.5 | 1 1 1 | 1 1 1 | 1 1 0 | 1 1 0.40.10.2 | 0 | 0.20.10.1 0 0.1 | -| | | | | | | | DeepSeek-R1 | | 1 1 1 | 1 1 1 | 0.80.6 1 | 1 1 0.50.70.60.20.4 | | 0 0 0.30.4 | -| | | | | | | | | Gemini1.5 | 1 1 0.8 | 1 0.8 1 | 1 0.40.6 | 1 1 0.20.10.5 | 0 | 0 0 0 0.10.1 | -0.8 -| | | | | | | | | Gemini2.5 | 1 1 1 | 1 0.6 1 | 0.40.40.4 | 1 0.80.10.30.8 | 0 | 0.4 0 0 0.1 0 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | | | GPT-4o | 1 0.80.80.8 | 1 1 | 0.8 0 0.80.6 | 1 0.20.1 | 0 0 | 0 0 0 0.2 0 | -citnameS -0.6 GPT-5 1 1 1 1 0.8 1 0.8 1 0.8 1 1 0.70.90.70.10.4 0 0.10.40.4 -| | | | | | | | | LLaMa3.3 | 1 0.40.60.40.80.40.40.20.20.6 | | | 1 0.10.1 | 0 0 | 0 0 0.1 0 0 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| | | | | | | | | | ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD elcycnainotlimaH | htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH euqilclamixaM | noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS | nosrepelasgnilevarT ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD | elcycnainotlimaH htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH | euqilclamixaM noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS nosrepelasgnilevarT | -0.4 -0.2 -0.0 -| | | | | | | | | | (a)Syntactic | | | | (b)Semantic | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 | | | | | | | | | -Syntactic -Figure5:Syntacticandsemanticperformanceobtainedbytheeval- -| | | | | | | | uatedLLMsacrosstheconsideredproblems. | | | | | | Thetestsuite-based | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------ | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | metric | is | used as the | semantic | reference7. | Each | value | represents | -theaverageoffivedifferentruns. -Figure4: Trade-offoftheevaluatedLLMsbetweensyntactic(X- -| axis)andsemanticaccuracy(Y-axis). | | | | Thesemanticscoreiscom- | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| putedaccordingtothetestsuite-basedmethod7. | | | | | Resultsareaver- | | | | | | | | | | -agedacrossallconsideredproblems. -| | | | | | | | LLM | Error | Analysis. | | For completeness, | | we | summarize | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | | the | most | common | error | patterns | observed | in | syntactically | -| | | | | | | | validbutsemanticallyincorrectprograms. | | | | | | Afrequentissue | | -in-depth analyses discussed subsequently. Here, semantic istheomissionofconstraints. Forexample,intheHamilto- -accuracyisdeterminedusingtestsuite-basedevaluation. In nian Path problem, LLMs often fail to enforce that exactly -| comparison, | syntactic | correctness | | is evaluated | | by checking | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oneedgeentersandoneedgeleaveseachnode,whichisre- -whethertheinputprogramresultsinanysyntaxerrorsdur- -| | | | | | | | quiredtoguaranteeaproperpath. | | | | | InStableMarriage,mod- | | | -| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -| ing processing | | by the solver. | To | ensure | results | are statis- | | | | | | | | | -elssometimesomitbijectivityconstraintsensuringthateach -| tically | robust, | each experiment | is | conducted | by | calling the | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | manismatchedwithexactlyonewomanandviceversa. | | | | | | | In | -targetLLMfivetimes,withoutcomesthenaveraged. optimization tasks involving weak constraints, mistakes in -| Two | considerations | can | be made. | First, | as | depicted in | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | -------------- | --------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | the | specification | | of weights | or | priorities | are also | common. | -| Figure | 4, while | most LLMs | show | an impressive | | accuracy | | | | | | | | | -Anotherrecurringproblemconcernsincorrectpredicatesig- -| under | the syntactic | perspective | (with | the | notable | exception | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | natures, | | such as | wrong | arity or | mismatched | arguments | in | -of LLaMa3.3), they perform poorly in terms of semantics. input atoms. In some cases, additional constraints are in- -Secondly,Figure5showsthat,whilesimpleproblemssuch troducedwithoutaclearcorrespondencetotheproblemde- -as Colorability or Dominating Set are easier to address, al- scription; whilenotalwaysharmful,theyrevealatendency -| most all | LLMs | fall short | in encoding | more | complex | tasks | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | to | produce | plausible | but | unjustified | rules. | Overall, | LLMs | -| (e.g., Partition | | or Slitherlink). | This | suggests | that | state-of- | | | | | | | | | -tendtogenerateencodingsthatlookreasonableatasuperfi- -the-artLLMsstillstruggletoeffectivelyencodedeclarative -paradigms,suchasAnswerSetProgramming. -| | | | | | | | | OriginalProblem | | | Paraphrase1 | | | Paraphrase2 | -| --------------------------------------------------- | ----------- | -------------------- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | ------------- | -| ParaphrasingImpact(RQ2). | | | | Further,wewanttoassess | | | | | | | | | | | -| whetheramorenatural, | | | human-likestyleofthetextualde- | | | | ycaruccAcitnameS | 1.0 | | | | | | | -| scriptionmighthelpinincreasingperformance. | | | | | | Tothisaim, | | | | | | | | | -| we select | DeepSeek-R1 | | as the | representative | | LLM candi- | | 0.5 | | | | | | | -| date, since | it | achieves | one of the | best | syntactic-semantic | | | | | | | | | | -| trade-offwhilebeingthecheapesttoprobe. | | | | | Wecompareits | | | | | | | | | | -| semanticaccuracywhenproblemparaphrasingsareapplied. | | | | | | | | 0.0 | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | bility | set | cycle | h g | ue n | k | ge n | -| | | | | | | score7, | | | | | pat usteri n | q Partiti o | herli n | marria pers o | -| Figure | 6 depicts | the test-suite-based | | evaluation | | av- | | | g | | | cli | | | -| | | | | | | | | ora | nati n | n n | | | | | -eraged over five runs, along with the confidence intervals. ol nia nia cl mal Slit sale -| | | | | | | | | C | mi | o o | | Maxi | | ble | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -We see that, in most cases, performance is leveraged when milt milt hical g -| | | | | | | | | | D o | | | | | Sta Traveli n | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -the original problem description is used, despite some ex- Ha Ha Hierarc -| ceptions | where | the first | paraphrasing | slightly | improves | the | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| semantic | accuracy | of the | model | (notably, | with | Dominating | | | | | | | | | -Figure6: Comparisonofthesemanticaccuracycomputedviathe -set,Partition,Stablemarriage). -test-suitewhenproblemparaphrasingsareapplied7.DeepSeek-R1 -isusedasthereferenceLLM.Barsdepicttheaverageacrossfive -7ForMaximalClique,weuseonlythemodel-basedmetricdue -differentruns,whileerrorbarsrepresentconfidenceintervals. -toASPWIDErun-timeissues. - -o4-mini DeepSeek-R1 Gemini2.5 GPT-5 TestSuite-Based Model-Based -| | Claude3.5 | | Gemini1.5 | | GPT-4o | | LLaMa3.3 | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1000 -| | desab-ledoMsv-etiustseT 1.0 | | | | | | | )s(emitgnitseT | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0.5 -500 -0.0 -0 -0.5 -| | − | | | | | | | | bilit y | et | cl e | at h n g | o n | n k g e | o n | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | s | y | eri | artiti | erli a | ers | -| | 1.0 | | | | | | | | a | n g | c | p | | arri | | -| | − | | | | | | | | or | ati | n | a n ust | | h | e p | -bility set cycle pat h n g o n nk ge o n ol ni a ni cl P Slit m al -| | | | g | | usteri Partiti | herli | marria pers | | C | mi n | o | o | | e | s | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | ora | n | n n | | | | | | | milt milt | al | | bl | g | -| | | | nati nia | nia | | Slit | sale | | | o | | hi c | | a | n | -| | | ol | | o | cl | | ble | | | D | a a | c | | St | eli | -| | | C | mi milt o | milt | hical | | g | | | | H H | ar | | v | | -| | | | D o | | | | Sta Traveli n | | | | | er | | Tr a | | -| | | | Ha | Ha | Hierarc | | | | | | | Hi | | | | -Figure8: Comparisonbetweenthetwosemanticmetricsinterms -oftestingtimes(expressedinseconds).DeepSeek-R1isusedasthe -| Figure | 7: | Comparison | between | | the two proposed | | semantic met- | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -referenceLLM.Barsrepresenttheaverageacrossfiveruns,error -| rics8. | DeepSeek-R1 | | is the | reference | LLM. | Values | represent the | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -barsindicateconfidenceintervals. -| difference | | between | test-suite- | and | model-based | scores, | averaged | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -acrossfiveruns,whilelinesindicateconfidenceintervals. -ricsforassessingtheASPcodingcapabilitiesofLLMsand, -morebroadly,ofautomaticprogramcodingapproaches. -| cial | level, | yet the | formal | rigor | of ASP | exposes | subtle inac- | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ---- | --- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | In | this paper, | we | addressed | this | gap | by introducing | | -curacies. Althoughsuchdraftsmayassisthumanprogram- -BLAST,thefirstdedicatedbenchmarkingmethodologyand -| mers, | our | results | indicate | that | fully automatic | | generation | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of correct ASP encodings remains challenging for current accompanying dataset specifically designed to rigorously -evaluatetheaccuracyofLLMsingeneratingASPprograms. -state-of-the-artmodels. -| | | | | | | | | Along | with BLAST, | | we implement | | and | release an | ad-hoc | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | benchmark, | two | testing | methodologies | | and | related | correct- | -Test-suite- vs Model-based (RQ3). Next, we compare ness metrics. The proposed metrics measure the seman- -| | | | | | | | | tic distance | between | | the generated | | encoding | and the | refer- | -| --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------ | -| the | two proposed | | semantic | metrics, | both | in terms | of accu- | | | | | | | | | -racy(Figure7)andefficiency(Figure8). Specifically, Fig- ence specification, without imposing constraints on predi- -ure7showsthedifferenceinperformancecomputedviathe catenamesorLLMspromptstructure.Weshowthatthetwo -test-suite-andthemodel-basedmetricTherefore,apositive measures consistently align in their assessment of correct- -(resp.,negative)scoremeansthattheperformanceishigher ness, while remaining complementary: one is more trans- -parentandinterpretable,atthecostofrequiringhumaninter- -ifthetest-suite-basedmetric(resp.,themodel-basedmetric) -isconsidered. Again,resultsareobtainedbyaveragingfive vention,whereastheotherisfullyautomaticbutlessdirectly -distinct runs, while the bars represent confidence intervals. explainable. BuildingonBLAST,weconductanextensive -Weseethat,acrossmostproblemsandevaluatedLLMs,the empiricalstudyofeightstate-of-the-artLLMsfromfivedif- -two metrics align. This alignment is also confirmed by the ferentmodelfamilies,evaluatingtheirabilitytoencodeten -well-knowngraphproblemsinASPstartingfromtextualde- -Pearsoncorrelationcoefficientρ=0.865. -Wefinallycomparethetwometricsintermsofefficiency. scriptions.Experimentsrevealthat:(i)althoughLLMsoften -Figure 8 depicts the testing times (in seconds) across the achievehighsyntacticaccuracy,theystrugglewithsemantic -considered problems, using DeepSeek-R1 as the reference correctness; (ii)theirperformancedegradessignificantlyas -LLM. In all problems (except for Hierarchical clustering), task complexity increases; and (iii) rephrasing the problem -specificationdoesnotleadtoconsistentimprovements. -thetest-suite-basedmetricsignificantlyreducesthecompu- -| tationtime,resultinginthemostefficientmetric. | | | | | | | (Morede- | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tailsintheSupplementaryMaterial.) Asfuturework,weplantoaddresscurrentlimitationsand -| | | | | | | | | exploreseveraldirectionsforextension. | | | | | Althoughoureval- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | uation | adopts | zero-shot | prompting | | to ensure | a uniform | and | -ConclusionsandFutureWork -| | | | | | | | | controlled | comparison, | | more | advanced | strategies, | | such as | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | -AlthoughLLMsareknowntoexcelatlanguageunderstand- few-shotprompting, prompttuning, orretrieval-augmented -ingandcodesynthesis,theirabilitytogeneratecorrectASP generation (RAG), deserve systematic investigation, and -programs has remained comparatively underexplored. Re- could lead to measure better performance of LLMs in gen- -searchontheautomaticcompositionofASPcodeisgrow- erating ASP code. Moreover, our benchmark focuses on -ing; however, evaluations often rely on manual inspection graph problems that are standard ASP system testing. Ex- -or impose constraints on the LLM’s input/output format, tending the benchmark to additional domains would fur- -makingperformancesensitivetosuperficialvariationssuch therstrengthenitsscopeandrepresentativeness. Finally,al- -as predicate renaming. As a consequence, the field still though BLAST here evaluates general-purpose LLMs, our -lackssystematicstandardizedbenchmarksandrigorousmet- methodologyismodel-agnosticandcouldalsobeemployed - -toevaluatespecializedtechniquesforASPencoding. -GenAIStatement -| This paper | has been | fully conceptualized, | | designed, and | -| ---------- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | ------------- | -writtenbythehumanauthors.LLMswereusedtoproofread -| the paper | and identify | some typos | and style | issues, the au- | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | -| thorsclaimthefullownershipofthetext. | | | | Importantly,LLM | -areusedasintegralcomponentsoftheproposedframework, -| as detailed | in the manuscript, | and | are subject | solely to ex- | -| ----------- | ------------------ | --- | ----------- | ------------- | -perimentalevaluation. -Acknowledgments -| This work | has been | partially | funded | by MUR on | -| -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | -| D.M. 351/2022, | PNRR | Ricerca, | CUP H23C22000440007; | | -| and partially | supported | by Moneying-Plus | | project (CUP | -J29I24001790005)selectedwithintheframeworkofthePR -FESR–FSECalabria2021/2027andimplementedwiththe -| support of | the Italian | State and | the Calabria | Region. The | -| ---------- | ------------------- | --------- | ------------ | ----------------- | -| work has | also been partially | supported | | by PN RIC project | -ASVIN“AssistenteVirtualeIntelligentediNegozio”(CUP -B29J24000200005)andthePNRRprojectFAIR-FutureAI -| Research | (PE00000013), | Spoke | 9 – Green-aware | AI, un- | -| ------------ | ------------- | ------- | --------------- | --------------- | -| der the NRRP | MUR | program | funded by | the “NextGener- | -ationEU”. - -References Christen,P.;Hand,D.J.;andKirielle,N. 2023. Areviewof -| | | | | | | | thef-measure: | | Itshistory,properties,criticism,andalter- | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Adams, | G.; Fabbri, | A.; | Ladhak, | F.; Lehman, | E.; | and El- | | | | | | | | -| hadad, | N. 2023. | From | sparse | to dense: | GPT-4 | summa- | natives. | | | | | | | -InProceedings -rizationwithchainofdensityprompting. Comanici, G.; Bieber, E.; and et al., M. S. 2025. Gemini -ofthe4thNewFrontiersinSummarizationWorkshop,68– 2.5: Pushingthefrontierwithadvancedreasoning,multi- -74. AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. modality,longcontext,andnextgenerationagenticcapa- -bilities. -Alviano,M.;Calimeri,F.;Charwat,G.;Dao-Tran,M.;Do- -daro, C.; Ianni, G.; Krennwallner, T.; Kronegger, M.; Coppolillo,E.;Calimeri,F.;Manco,G.;Perri,S.;andRicca, -Oetsch, J.; Pfandler, A.; Pu¨hrer, J.; Redl, C.; Ricca, F.; F. 2024. Llasp: fine-tuning large language models for -| | | | | | | | answer | set programming. | | In Proceedings | | of the | 21st In- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -Schneider,P.;Schwengerer,M.;Spendier,L.K.;Wallner, -J.P.;andXiao,G. 2013. Thefourthanswersetprogram- ternationalConferenceonPrinciplesofKnowledgeRep- -ming competition: Preliminary report. In LPNMR, vol- resentationandReasoning,KR’24. -ume8148ofLectureNotesinComputerScience,42–53. -| | | | | | | | Dakhel, | A. M.; | Majdinasab, | V.; Nikanjam, | | A.; Khomh, | F.; | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -Springer. -| | | | | | | | Desmarais,M.C.;andJiang,Z.M.J. | | | | | 2023. Githubcopi- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -Alviano,M.;Calimeri,F.;Dodaro,C.;Fusca`,D.;Leone,N.; lotAIpairprogrammer: Assetorliability? -Perri, S.; Ricca, F.; Veltri, P.; andZangari, J. 2017. The DeepSeek. 2025. Deepseek-r1: Incentivizingreasoningca- -ASPsystemDLV2. InLPNMR,volume10377ofLNCS, pabilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. -| 215–221. | Springer. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Ding,Y.;Wang,Z.;Ahmad,W.U.;Ding,H.;Tan,M.;Jain, -Alviano,M.;Cirimele,D.;andReiners,L.A.R. 2023. In- N.; Ramanathan, M. K.; Nallapati, R.; Bhatia, P.; Roth, -troducingASPrecipesandASPchef.InICLPWorkshops, D.; and Xiang, B. 2023. Crosscodeeval: A diverse and -volume3437ofCEURWP. CEUR-WS.org. multilingualbenchmarkforcross-filecodecompletion. -Amendola,G.;Mazzotta,G.;Ricca,F.;andBerei,T. 2024. Du, X.; Liu, M.; Wang, K.; Wang, H.; Liu, J.; Chen, Y.; -Unit testing in ASP revisited: Language and test-driven Feng,J.;Sha,C.;Peng,X.;andLou,Y. 2024. Evaluating -developmentenvironment. largelanguagemodelsinclass-levelcodegeneration. In -ProceedingsoftheIEEE/ACM46thInternationalConfer- -| Anthropic. | 2024. | Claude3.5sonnetmodelcardaddendum. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enceonSoftwareEngineering,ICSE’24. -Baral,C.,andDzifcak,J.2011.Solvingpuzzlesdescribedin -| | | | | | | | Erdem,E.,andYeniterzi,R. | | | 2009. | Transformingcontrolled | | | -| ------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -| english | by automated | | translation | to answer | set program- | | | | | | | | | -naturallanguagebiomedicalqueriesintoanswersetpro- -| ming | and learning | how | to do | that translation. | | In AAAI | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ------------ | --------------------------------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | | grams. | InBioNLP@HLT-NAACL,117–124. | | | | ACL. | | -| FallSymposium: | | AdvancesinCognitiveSystems,volume | | | | | | | | | | | | -FS-11-01ofAAAITechnicalReport. AAAI. Erdem,E.;Gelfond,M.;andLeone,N. 2016. Applications -ofanswersetprogramming. -| Bauer, J. | J.; Eiter, | T.; Ruiz, | N. H.; | and Oetsch, | J. | 2024. | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Visual graph question answering with ASP and llms for Ernst,N.A.,andBavota,G. 2022. Ai-drivendevelopment -| | | | | | | | ishere: | Shouldyouworry? | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| language | parsing. | In | ICLP, volume | 416 | of EPTCS, | 15– | | | | | | | | -28. Falkner, A. A.; Friedrich, G.; Schekotihin, K.; Taupe, R.; -| | | | | | | | andTeppan,E.C. | | 2018. | Industrialapplicationsofanswer | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| Borroto, | M.; Kareem, | I.; | and Ricca, | F. 2024. | Towards | au- | | | | | | | | -setprogramming. -| tomatic | composition | of | ASP programs | | from natural | lan- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -guage specifications. In IJCAI, volume abs/2403.04541, Fang, M., and Tompits, H. 2017. An approach for repre- -toappear. ijcai.org. senting answer sets in natural language. In DECLARE, -| | | | | | | | volume10997ofLNCS,115–131. | | | | Springer. | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -------------------------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | -| Brewka,G.;Eiter,T.;andTruszczynski,M. | | | | | 2011. | Answer | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Febbraro, | O.; | Reale, | K.; and Ricca, | F. | 2011. | ASPIDE: | -setprogrammingataglance. -| | | | | | | | integrated | development | | environment | | for answer | set pro- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -Busoniu,P.;Oetsch,J.;Pu¨hrer,J.;Skocovsky,P.;andTom- -| | | | | | | | gramming. | | InLPNMR,volume6645ofLNCS,317–330. | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| pits,H. | 2013. | Sealion: | Aneclipse-basedIDEforanswer- | | | | | | | | | | | -Springer. -setprogrammingwithadvanceddebuggingsupport. -| | | | | | | | Gebser, | M.; Kaminski, | | R.; Kaufmann, | | B.; Ostrowski, | M.; | -| --------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------ | -------------- | ---- | -| Calimeri, | F.; Germano, | | S.; Palermiti, | E.; | Reale, | K.; and | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Schaub, | T.; | and Wanko, | P. 2016. | Theory | solving | made | -Ricca,F. 2018. DevelopingASPprogramswithASPIDE easy with clingo 5. In ICLP (Technical Communica- -andloide. Ku¨nstlicheIntell.32(2-3):185–186. tions),volume52ofOASIcs,2:1–2:15. SchlossDagstuhl -Calimeri,F.; Ianni,G.; andRicca,F. 2014. Thethirdopen -Leibniz-Zentrumfu¨rInformatik. -answersetprogrammingcompetition. Gebser, M.; Maratea, M.; and Ricca, F. 2017. The sixth -Caruso, S.; Dodaro, C.; Maratea, M.; Mochi, M.; and Ric- answersetprogrammingcompetition. -| cio, F. | 2024. | CNL2ASP: | converting | controlled | | natural | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Gebser,M.; | Maratea,M.; | | andRicca,F. | | 2020. Theseventh | | -languagesentencesintoASP. answersetprogrammingcompetition:Designandresults. -Chen, M.; Tworek, J.; and et al., H. J. 2021. Evaluating Gelfond, M., andLifschitz, V. 1991. Classicalnegationin -largelanguagemodelstrainedoncode. logicprogramsanddisjunctivedatabases. - -Grattafiori,A.,andetal.,A.D. 2024. Thellama3herdof Ou, J.; Lu, J.; Liu, C.; Tang, Y.; Zhang, F.; Zhang, D.; and -| models. | | | | | | | Gai,K.2024.DialogBench:EvaluatingLLMsashuman- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Hahn,S.;Sabuncu,O.;Schaub,T.;andStolzmann,T. 2023. like dialogue systems. In Proceedings of the 2024 Con- -ferenceoftheNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociation -| Clingraph: | Asystemforasp-basedvisualization. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | for Computational | | Linguistics: | | Human | Language | | Tech- | -Ishay, A.; Yang, Z.; and Lee, J. 2023a. Leveraging large nologies(Volume1: LongPapers). MexicoCity,Mexico: -languagemodelstogenerateanswersetprograms.InPro- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. -| ceedings | of the | 20th | International | | Conference | on Prin- | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ------------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Peng, S.; | Kalliamvakou, | | E.; | Cihon, | P.; and | Demirer, | M. | -| ciples | of Knowledge | | Representation | | and Reasoning, | KR | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | 2023. | The impact | of | AI on | developer | productivity: | | Ev- | -’23. -idencefromgithubcopilot. -| Ishay, A.; | Yang, | Z.; and | Lee, | J. 2023b. | Leveraging | large | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | ----- | ------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | -------------------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | ------------------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Qin, L.; | Chen, Q.; | Feng, | X.; Wu, | Y.; | Zhang, | Y.; Li, | Y.; Li, | -| languagemodelstogenerateanswersetprograms. | | | | | | InKR, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | M.;Che,W.;andYu,P.S. | | | 2024. | Largelanguagemodels | | | | -374–383. -| | | | | | | | meetnlp: | Asurvey. | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------ | -| Jiang,J.;Wang,F.;Shen,J.;Kim,S.;andKim,S. | | | | | | 2024. A | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Raiaan, | M. A. K.; | Mukta, | M. | S. H.; | Fatema, | K.; | Fahad, | -surveyonlargelanguagemodelsforcodegeneration. -| | | | | | | | N.M.; | Sakib, | S.; Mim, | M.M.J.; | Ahmad, | | J.; Ali, | M.E.; | -| --------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | ----------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | -| Kalliamvakou,E. | | 2022. | Research: | quantifyinggithubcopi- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | andAzam,S. | | 2024. | Areviewonlargelanguagemodels: | | | | | -lot’simpactondeveloperproductivityandhappiness. Architectures, applications, taxonomies, open issues and -challenges. -| Kareem, | I.; Gallagher, | | K.; Borroto, | M. | A.; Ricca, | F.; and | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Russo, A. 2024. Using learning from answer sets for Rajasekharan, A.; Zeng, Y.; Padalkar, P.; and Gupta, G. -robustquestionansweringwithLLM.InLPNMR,volume 2023. Reliablenaturallanguageunderstandingwithlarge -| 15245 | of Lecture | Notes | in Computer | | Science, | 112–125. | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -languagemodelsandanswersetprogramming. -Springer. -| | | | | | | | Ren, L.; | Xiao, G.; | Qi, | G.; Geng, | Y.; | and | Xue, H. | 2025. | -| -------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | -| Kuhn, T. | 2014. | A survey | and | classification | | of controlled | | | | | | | | | -Canllmssolveaspproblems?insightsfromabenchmark- -naturallanguages. ingstudy. InProceedingsofthe22ndInternationalCon- -| | | | | | | | ference | on Principles | | of Knowledge | | Representation | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -Law,M.;Russo,A.;andBroda,K.2020.TheILASPsystem -Reasoning,KR’25. -forinductivelearningofanswersetprograms. -| | | | | | | | Schrader, | T. P.; | Lange, | L.; Kaminski, | | T.; | Razniewski, | S.; | -| --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| Lippolis, | A. S.; | Saeedizade, | M. | J.; Keskisa¨rkka¨, | | R.; Zup- | | | | | | | | | -piroli, S.; Ceriani, M.; Gangemi, A.; Blomqvist, E.; and andFriedrich,A. 2025. Asolver-in-the-loopframework -Nuzzolese,A.G. 2025. Ontologygenerationusinglarge forimprovingllmsonanswersetprogrammingforlogic -InESWC(1),volume15718ofLecture puzzlesolving. CoRRabs/2512.17093. -languagemodels. -NotesinComputerScience,321–341. Springer. Schwitter, R. 2018. Specifying and verbalising answer set -programsincontrollednaturallanguage. -| Liu,T.;Xu,C.;andMcAuley,J. | | | | 2023. | Repobench: | Bench- | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -markingrepository-levelcodeauto-completionsystems. Shah,N.;Genc,Z.;andAraci,D. 2025. Stackeval: bench- -Ma, Z.; Guo, H.; Chen, J.; Peng, G.; Cao, Z.; Ma, Y.; and marking llms in coding assistance. In Proceedings of -Gong, Y.-J. 2024. Llamoco: Instruction tuning of large the38thInternationalConferenceonNeuralInformation -languagemodelsforoptimizationcodegeneration. ProcessingSystems,NIPS’24. -Mitra, A., and Baral, C. 2016. Addressing a question an- Smirnov, P.; Joublin, F.; Ceravola, A.; and Gienger, M. -| | | | | | | | 2024. | Generating | consistent | | PDDL | domains | with | large | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | -sweringchallengebycombiningstatisticalmethodswith -languagemodels. -| inductive | rule | learning | and | reasoning. | In | AAAI, 2779– | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2785. AAAIPress. -| | | | | | | | Team, G., | and et | al., P. | G. 2024. | | Gemini | 1.5: | Unlock- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------- | -Naveed, H.; Khan, A. U.; Qiu, S.; Saqib, M.; Anwar, S.; ing multimodal understanding across millions of tokens -| Usman,M.; | Akhtar,N.; | | Barnes,N.; | | andMian,A. | 2024. | ofcontext. | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Acomprehensiveoverviewoflargelanguagemodels. Valmeekam,K.;Stechly,K.;Gundawar,A.;andKambham- -pati,S.2025.Asystematicevaluationoftheplanningand -| Nye, M. | I.; Tessler, | M. | H.; Tenenbaum, | | J. B.; | and Lake, | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -schedulingabilitiesofthereasoningmodelo1. -B.M.2021.Improvingcoherenceandconsistencyinneu- -ral sequence models with dual-system, neuro-symbolic Vaswani, A.; Shazeer, N.; Parmar, N.; Uszkoreit, J.; Jones, -| reasoning. | InNeurIPS,25192–25204. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | L.;Gomez,A.N.;Kaiser,L.u.;andPolosukhin,I. | | | | | | | 2017. | -Oetsch, J.; Prischink, M.; Pu¨hrer, J.; Schwengerer, M.; and Attention is all you need. In Guyon, I.; Luxburg, U. V.; -Tompits, H. 2012. On the small-scope hypothesis for Bengio, S.; Wallach, H.; Fergus, R.; Vishwanathan, S.; -| | | | | | | | and Garnett, | R., | eds., | Advances | in | Neural | Information | | -| -------------------------- | ------ | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --------------------- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -| testinganswer-setprograms. | | | | InKR. | AAAIPress. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ProcessingSystems,volume30. | | | | CurranAssociates,Inc. | | | | -| OpenAI. | 2024. | Gpt-4osystemcard. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Voboril,F.;Ramaswamy,V.P.;andSzeider,S. | | | | | | 2025. | Gen- | -| OpenAI. | 2025a. | Introducinggpt-5. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -eratingstreamliningconstraintswithlargelanguagemod- -OpenAI. 2025b. Introducingopenaio3ando4-mini. els. J.Artif.Intell.Res.84. - -Wang,Y.;Le,H.;Gotmare,A.D.;Bui,N.D.Q.;Li,J.;and -| Hoi,S.C.H. | | 2023. Codet5+: | | Opencodelargelanguage | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -modelsforcodeunderstandingandgeneration. -| Xu, F. F.; | Alon, | U.; Neubig, | G.; | and Hellendoorn, | | V. J. | -| ---------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | -2022. Asystematicevaluationoflargelanguagemodels -| ofcode. | InProceedingsofthe6thACMSIGPLANInter- | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -| national | Symposium | on | Machine | Programming, | | MAPS | -| 2022,1–10. | NewYork,NY,USA:AssociationforCom- | | | | | | -putingMachinery. -| Xu,K.;Mao,Y.;Guan,X.;andFeng,Z. | | | | 2025. | Web-bench: | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -Allmcodebenchmarkbasedonwebstandardsandframe- -works. -| Yang, Z.; | Ishay, | A.; andLee, | J. | 2023. Couplinglargelan- | | | -| --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -guagemodelswithlogicprogrammingforrobustandgen- -| eralreasoningfromtext. | | | InACL(Findings),5186–5219. | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -ACL. -| Zhao, W.X.; | Zhou, | K.; andetal., | | J.L. 2025. | Asurveyof | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -largelanguagemodels. -| Zhou, Y.; | Ringeval, | F.; and | Portet, | F. 2025. | Can | gpt mod- | -| -------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -| elsfollowhumansummarizationguidelines? | | | | | astudyfor | | -targetedcommunicationgoals. \ No newline at end of file +FITNESS TRACKER +SF-206 + +Manual + +Please read this manual before use. + +Visit us at +www.slideusa.com +or contact us at +support@slideusa.com + + SAFETY WARNING +• Please charge the Fitness +tracker with the provided +charging clamp for at least +two hours prior to its first use. + +PRODUCT OVERVIEW + +1 __ + +_ +_ + +2 ____________ + +__ +4 + +3a._________ + +3b. ________ + +Fatigue Monitor +Touch Sensor + +1. +2. +3a. Charging Contacts +3b. Charging Contacts +4. Charging Clamp + + DETACHABLE WRISTBAND +This device comes with a detachable +wristbands. To remove the wristband +locate the metallic pin on the edge of +the wristband where it meets the +watch. Pull the pin sideways and the +wristband will automatically detach +from the watch. + +________ Pin + +GETTING STARTED +Powering On/Off: Power the fitness +tracker On/Off, by touching and +holding the touch sensor. +Charging: The fitnesses Tracker +comes with its own USB compatible +charger. To charge the device +plug the USB charging clamp into +a USB slot. Then clamp the fitness +tracker into the charger. +Note: Make sure that the charging +contacts on the clamp and the +fitness tracker are aligned. + + Touch Sensor: Available functions +will be shown on the screen and +can be navigated through by +simply touching or touching and +holding the touch sensor under the +screen. +Downloading The App: To use the +SF-206 as +intended the +user should +download the +Lefun Health +app using the +provided QR +code. +Note: If the App is not downloaded +some features of the device may +not be usable. +Enabling All features: Before first +use, the user should enable all +features of the device. This is done +while in the Health section by +navigating to the menu in the +top left side of the screen and +selecting both Band Function +Settings and Message Reminder. + + Pairing Instructions: To pair the +Fitnesses tracker and the user's +phone follow the below instructions. + +1. Open the Lefun Health App +and while in the Health +section navigate to the +menu in the top left side of +the screen and select Device +Name/Connection Status. + +2. The user will be asked to +provide Lefun Health +permission to access several of +the phone's features. For the +Fitness Tracker to operate as +intended the user should allow +the device all permissions. +3. While on the pairing page the + +user will see all devices +compatible with the Lefun +Heath app listed. If the user +does not see their fitness +tracker they should take the +following steps. +A. Make sure that the fitness +tracker is powered on. +B.. Press t +B. Press the search button +to begin scanning for a signal. +4. Select the fitness tracker from + +the available list to pair. + + Restore factory Settings: To restore +factory settings touch and hold the +touch button while on the "About" +page of the fitness tracker. The user +will see a prompt saying "Long Press +Restore Factory Settings." To confirm +the reset touch and hold the touch +sensor again. The fitness tracker will +then automatically restore itself to +factory settings. + +MENU SETTINGS +Menu Features: The fitness tracker +has several features that can be +changed on the app by navigating +to the health page and selecting +the menu option in the top left side +of the screen. These features +include but are not limited to, + +Menu __ + +• Smart Alarm - After the alarm is +set the watch will vibrate at the +appointed time. + +• Message Notification - The fitness +tracker will vibrate when the +user's phone receives a message +or call. Note: This feature must be +turned on manually. + + • Search Device: The user can +locate the lost fitness tracker +(make it vibrate) by selecting this +option. + +• Shake For A Selfie: Select this + +feature to access the camera on +the user's phone. Next, shake the +fitness tracker to take a photo. +Note: Photos will be saved on the +user's phone. + +• Band Function Settings: + +A. Sedentary Reminder: The + +fitness tracker will +automatically provide the user +a warning should they remain +sedentary for too long. +B. Reminder for drinking: The + +fitness tracker will +automatically provide the user +with a reminder to drink water +at regular intervals. + +C. Screen Up Upon Raising: +Quickly view the time or +messages without tapping the +screen or pressing the +multifunction button. To use it +just turn your wrist towards you +and the screen will be +displayed for a few seconds. + + D. Smart Anti-lost: Turn On/Off +Smart Anti Lost Setting. + +Note: The following features may +not work as intended if the user +has not turned them on. + +WATERPROOFING + +Your Fitness tracker is water- +resistant, rain-proof, splash-proof +and can stand up to even the +sweatiest workout. +NOTE: Do not swim or shower with +your wristband. Though water +won't damage the device, it +should be dried thoroughly after +coming into contact with any +water. + +FEATURES +While on the Home Screen of the +device touch the touch sensor to + + navigate through the available +apps. + +103 + +83 + +Home +Screen: +press and +hold the +touch sensor +to switch + +between the available home +screen displays as shown above. + +10325 +STEPS + +Pedometer: +Records the +number of steps the +user is taking during +a 24 hour period. +This information is +accessible on both +the fitness tracker + +and the app. Note: The step counter +is reset to zero at midnight. + +Exercise: Records +the amount of time +the user has +exercised. Note: The +time exercised is +reset to zero at +midnight. Note: The +user can select +between the + + following four exerciser options. +1. Running +2. Badminton +3. Climbing +4. Bicycling + +99 + +Heart rate monitor: +Measures the +wearer's current +resting heart rate +and displays that +data as the number +of heartbeats per + +minute (BPM). Note: Data will be +saved in the app + +87 + +131 + +99 + +SPO2 Test: Measures +the amount of +oxygen in the blood +(sp02) Note: data +not recorded in the +app. + +Blood Pressure: +Measures the +wearer's current +Blood pressure. Note: +Normal Blood +pressure is 120/80. + + Additional Features: The fitness +tracker has several additional +features including Find Phone, +Messages, Details about the device, +QR Code, and the Power Off +feature. +After the App has been successfully +downloaded, the user should be +sure to pair the fitness tracker to +their phone using the app. + +Enabling All features: App: +(Necessary For Messages, Calls, +and Reminders) +Before first use the user should +enable all features of the device. +This is done while in the Health +section by navigating to the +menu in the top left side of the +screen and selecting both Band +Function Settings and Message +Reminder. + +Enabling All features: Phone: +(Necessary For Messages, Calls, and +Reminders) +Some features may not work as +intended if the user has not enabled +"Lefun Health" on their phone. To do +this the user should open their +phone's settings and select + + Notifications and Accessibility from +the following options. Find "Lefun +Health" and enable the Apps to +Access your phone. +Note: This is detailed in the image on +the next page. +Note: As the settings page on +phones varies from type to type. The +above instructions and included +images may not directly reflect the +appropriate method of enabling all +features on the user's phone. + + Important + +Iphone + +Android + + GENERAL INFORMATION +Environmental Conditions +Operating Temperature: 14°F-122° +F:-4°C-14°C + +Size +The wristbands have an adjustable +circumference and will fit anyone +who has a wrist between 5.5 and .5 +inches. +Disposal and Recycling +The user should be aware that it is +the consumer’s responsibility to +properly dispose of and recycle the +SmartWatch and accompanying +components. Do not dispose of the +SmartWatch with common +household waste as it is considered +electronic waste and should be +disposed of at your local electronic +equipment collection facility. + +APP - HEALTH SECTION +While in the health section the user +may select the menu in the top left +side of the screen or navigate to +other pages of the health section +by swiping left. + + Today's Data + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +The number of steps taken, calories +burned, distance traveled, hours +slept, blood pressure, and heart rate +are all displayed here. + + Pedometer + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +The number of steps taken, calories +burned, and distance traveled are all +displayed here + + Sleep Monitor + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The sleep Monitor only works so +long as the user is wearing the +fitnesses tracker when they are +asleep. + + Heart Rate + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The user may check their +heart rate using the app by pressing +"Start To Measure." This will +automatically activate the fitness +trackers heart rate monitor. + + Blood Pressure + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The user may check their +blood pressure using the app by +pressing "Start To Measure." This will +automatically activate the fitness +trackers blood pressure monitor. + + App - Sports + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Sports +History + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ + +Slide To +Unlock + +While on the sports page the user will +see the above icons. Pressing the blue +icon will immediately begin tracking +both the route and distance traveled. +While tracking, the user will see the +bellow icons. Press the below blue +icon to stop tracking. + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Sports +Settings + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Map + + Data: While on the Sports page the +user will see the following +information displayed. Travel +Distance, Speed in min/km, Calories +burned in Kcal, and Elevation +change in Meters. +Sports Features: +History : Records the user workout +history. +Settings : Allows the user to set +Calorie targets, or adjust +countdown settings. +Begin Tracking : Actively begins +tracking distance traveled, speed, +calories burned, and route traveled. +Note: When tracking has begun the +phone screen will automatically +lock. To Unlock the screen press +and the user will be prompted to +"Slide To Unlock" the screen. +To access route tracking via the +map press . +Press button and the user will be +prompted with and . Pressing +the first one will continue tracking +and pressing the second one will +end the workout and record the +data in the sports history section. + + App - Trend + + App - My Data + +Users Personal +information can +be edited here. + +- +- +- +- +- +- +- + +------------ + +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- + +--- + +----Device Information + +----Set fitness targets + +----Frequently Asked Questions + +----Check For Updates + + This device complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is subject to the following two +conditions: (1) this device may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept +any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. +Any changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party responsible for compliance +could void the user's authority to operate the equipment. +NOTE: This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits for a Class B +digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These limits are designed to provide +reasonable protection against harmful interference in a residential installation. This equipment +generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed and used in +accordance with the instructions, may cause harmful interference to radio communications. +However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a particular installation. +If this equipment does cause harmful interference to radio or television reception, +which can be determined by turning the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to +correct the interference by one or more of the following measures: +-- Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +-- Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. +-- Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different + +from that to which the receiver is connected. + +-- Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. +The device has been evaluated to meet general RF exposure requirement. The device can be u +sed in portable exposure condition without restriction +FCC ID: 2AJVKSF206 + diff --git a/q41/random_k4/question.json b/q41/random_k4/question.json index eefee77707ba159f43bec89e3f9897429db807b2..74b9592eb24a155479fc851a68f35def0bf0f004 100644 --- a/q41/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q41/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "finalpresentationdeck-whatwhyhowofcertificationsocial-160324220748_95.pdf", - "web_9deb1a47e107dc04.pdf", - "c726c35b04831158d54cee8acd7202672bb42877.pdf", - "70d4f3a5fd97468630edcb4638e7c07b844b85fe.pdf", - "176f3f770cd32f4ad62a6354b45cad4e425d6146.pdf" + "web_77f281bc58aa8364.pdf", + "web_e90c53ca1c265ed4.pdf", + "resize_r2_5.pdf", + "acl_2025.acl-long.1270.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q41/random_k4/random_1.md b/q41/random_k4/random_1.md index 7e875d55d5f93fef49815a4921bd61abaa902c5b..602df279b63a2b7c5600ed9bc60d31b5343359ac 100644 --- a/q41/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q41/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1736 +1,2008 @@ -1. - -2. - -3. - -4. - -5. - -6. - -7. - -About These Forms - -In General. This and the other pleading forms available from the www.uscourts.gov -website illustrate some types of information that are useful to have in complaints and -some other pleadings. The forms do not try to cover every type of case. They are limited -to types of cases often filed in federal courts by those who represent themselves or who -may not have much experience in federal courts. - -Not Legal Advice. No form provides legal advice. No form substitutes for having or -consulting a lawyer. If you are not a lawyer and are suing or have been sued, it is best to -have or consult a lawyer if possible. - -No Guarantee. Following a form does not guarantee that any pleading is legally or -factually correct or sufficient. - -Variations Possible. A form may call for more or less information than a particular -court requires. The fact that a form asks for certain information does not mean that every -court or a particular court requires it. And if the form does not ask for certain -information, a particular court might still require it. Consult the rules and caselaw that -govern in the court where you are filing the pleading. - -Examples Only. The forms do not try to address or cover all the different types of -claims or defenses, or how specific facts might affect a particular claim or defense. Some -of the forms, such as the form for a generic complaint, apply to different types of cases. -Others apply only to specific types of cases. Be careful to use the form that fits your case -and the type of pleading you want to file. Be careful to change the information the form -asks for to fit the facts and circumstances of your case. - -No Guidance on Timing or Parties. The forms do not give any guidance on when -certain kinds of pleadings or claims or defenses have to be raised, or who has to be sued. -Some pleadings, claims, or defenses have to be raised at a certain point in the case or -within a certain period of time. And there are limits on who can be named as a party in a -case and when they have to be added. Lawyers and people representing themselves must -know the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the caselaw setting out these and other -requirements. The current Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are available, for free, at -www.uscourts.gov. - -Privacy Requirements. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2 addresses the privacy and -security concerns over public access to electronic court files. Under this rule, papers filed -with the court should not contain anyone’s full social-security number or full birth date; -the name of a person known to be a minor; or a complete financial-account number. A -filing may include only the last four digits of a social-security number and taxpayer -identification number; the year of someone’s birth; a minor’s initials; and the last four -digits of a financial-account number. - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT -FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN - -Case No. -________________________________ -(to be filled in by the Clerk’s Office) - -(Write the full name of each plaintiff who is filing this complaint. -If the names of all the plaintiffs cannot fit in the space above, -please write “see attached” in the space and attach an additional -page with the full list of names.) - -Jury Trial: ☐ Yes ☐ No - -(check one) - -v. - -(Write the full name of each defendant who is being sued. If the -names of all the defendants cannot fit in the space above, please -write “see attached” in the space and attach an additional page -with the full list of names.) - -Complaint for a Civil Case - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -I. - -The Parties to This Complaint - -A. - -The Plaintiff(s) - -Provide the information below for each plaintiff named in the complaint. Attach -additional pages if needed. - -Name - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address - -__________________________________________ - -B. - -The Defendant(s) - -Provide the information below for each defendant named in the complaint, whether the -defendant is an individual, a government agency, an organization, or a corporation. -For an individual defendant, include the person’s job or title (if known). Attach -additional pages if needed. - -Defendant No. 1 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ +INTERNATIONAL STUDENT +HANDBOOK -__________________________________________ +A resource guide published by the +Office of International Education +Albany State University +Albany, GA -Street Address + TABLE OF CONTENTS +Notice to Students………………………………………………………………..……………………….. -__________________________________________ +Welcome Letter from ISA……………..…………………………………………………………..………….…………………. -City and County +Financial Documentation………………………………………………………….………………..…….. -__________________________________________ +Academic Life………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…………….. -State and Zip Code +American Customs and Culture………………………………………………………………………………..………… -__________________________________________ +Immigration Status…………………………………….……………………………………………………………..……………. -Telephone Number +Automobiles…………………………………………………………….………………………..…………. -__________________________________________ +Emergencies……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. -E-mail Address -(if known) +English Language…………………………………………………………………………………………… -Defendant No. 2 +Entertainment………………………………………………..………………………………………………………………………. -Name +Health Care…………………………………………………………………………………………………… -Job or Title -(if known) +Housing……………………………………………………………………………….…………………………………………….…. -__________________________________________ +Dining Services……………………………………………………………………………..….…………… -__________________________________________ +Legal Concerns………………………………………….…………………………………………..……………………………… -__________________________________________ +Mail………………………………………..…………………………………………………………………… -Street Address +Money and Banking……………………..……………………………………….………………………………………………... -__________________________________________ +Regent’s Test…………………………………………………………………………………….…………. -City and County +Religious Life……………………………………..…………………………………………………….…………………………… -__________________________________________ +Shopping…………………………………………………………………………..………………………….. -State and Zip Code +Student Athletes ………………………………………….……………………………………………………………..……….. -__________________________________________ +Social Security Numbers ……………………………………………..…………………….…………… -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -2 - - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -Defendant No. 3 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -Defendant No. 4 - -Name - -Job or Title -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -__________________________________________ - -Street Address - -__________________________________________ - -City and County - -__________________________________________ - -State and Zip Code - -__________________________________________ - -Telephone Number - -__________________________________________ - -E-mail Address -(if known) - -__________________________________________ - -II. - -Basis for Jurisdiction - -Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction (limited power). Generally, only two types of -cases can be heard in federal court: cases involving a federal question and cases involving -diversity of citizenship of the parties. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, a case arising under the United -States Constitution or federal laws or treaties is a federal question case. Under 28 U.S.C. -§ 1332, a case in which a citizen of one State sues a citizen of another State or nation and the -amount at stake is more than $75,000 is a diversity of citizenship case. In a diversity of -citizenship case, no defendant may be a citizen of the same State as any plaintiff. - -What is the basis for federal court jurisdiction? (check all that apply) - -☐ Federal question - -☐ Diversity of citizenship - -Fill out the paragraphs in this section that apply to this case. +Taxes……………………………………………….…………………………………………………………………………………… 3 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -A. - -If the Basis for Jurisdiction Is a Federal Question - -List the specific federal statutes, federal treaties, and/or provisions of the United States -Constitution that are at issue in this case. - -B. - -If the Basis for Jurisdiction Is Diversity of Citizenship - -1. - -The Plaintiff(s) - -a. - -b. - -If the plaintiff is an individual -The plaintiff, (name) _________________________________________, -is a citizen of the State of (name) _______________________. - -If the plaintiff is a corporation -The plaintiff, (name) ________________________________________, -is incorporated under the laws of the State of (name) -______________________, and has its principal place of business in the -State of (name) _______________________. - -(If more than one plaintiff is named in the complaint, attach an additional page -providing the same information for each additional plaintiff.) - -2. - -The Defendant(s) - -a. - -b. - -If the defendant is an individual -The defendant, (name) ______________________, is a citizen of the -State of (name) _______________________. Or is a citizen of (foreign -nation) _______________________. - -If the defendant is a corporation -The defendant, (name) _______________________, is incorporated -under the laws of the State of (name) _______________________, and -has its principal place of business in the State of (name) -_______________________. Or is incorporated under the laws of -(foreign nation) _______________________, and has its principal place -of business in (name) _______________________. - -(If more than one defendant is named in the complaint, attach an additional -page providing the same information for each additional defendant.) - 4 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -3. - -The Amount in Controversy - -The amount in controversy—the amount the plaintiff claims the defendant owes -or the amount at stake—is more than $75,000, not counting interest and costs of -court, because (explain): - -III. - -Statement of Claim - -Write a short and plain statement of the claim. Do not make legal arguments. State as briefly -as possible the facts showing that each plaintiff is entitled to the damages or other relief sought. -State how each defendant was involved and what each defendant did that caused the plaintiff -harm or violated the plaintiff’s rights, including the dates and places of that involvement or -conduct. If more than one claim is asserted, number each claim and write a short and plain -statement of each claim in a separate paragraph. Attach additional pages if needed. - 5 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -IV. Relief - -State briefly and precisely what damages or other relief the plaintiff asks the court to order. Do -not make legal arguments. Include any basis for claiming that the wrongs alleged are -continuing at the present time. Include the amounts of any actual damages claimed for the acts -alleged and the basis for these amounts. Include any punitive or exemplary damages claimed, -the amounts, and the reasons you claim you are entitled to actual or punitive money damages. - -V. - -Certification and Closing - -Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11, by signing below, I certify to the best of my -knowledge, information, and belief that this complaint: (1) is not being presented for an -improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of -litigation; (2) is supported by existing law or by a nonfrivolous argument for extending, -modifying, or reversing existing law; (3) the factual contentions have evidentiary support or, if -specifically so identified, will likely have evidentiary support after a reasonable opportunity for -further investigation or discovery; and (4) the complaint otherwise complies with the -requirements of Rule 11. - -A. - -For Parties Without an Attorney - -I agree to provide the Clerk’s Office with any changes to my address where case- -related papers may be served. I understand that my failure to keep a current address on -file with the Clerk’s Office may result in the dismissal of my case. - -Date of signing: _____________________, 20_____. - -Signature of Plaintiff -___________________________________________ -Printed Name of Plaintiff ___________________________________________ - 6 - MIED ProSe 1 (Rev 5/16) Complaint for a Civil Case - -Additional Information: - -7 - - JS 44 (Rev. 10/20) - -CIVIL COVER SHEET -The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as -provided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the -purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON NEXT PAGE OF THIS FORM.) -I. (a) PLAINTIFFS - -County in which action arose: _______________ - -DEFENDANTS - -(b) County of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff +10 -(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES) +12 -County of Residence of First Listed Defendant +18 -NOTE: +19 -(IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY) -IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF -THE TRACT OF LAND INVOLVED. +21 -(c) Attorneys (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number) +21 -Attorneys (If Known) +22 -II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION (Place an “X” in One Box Only) +24 -III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES (Place an “X” in One Box for Plaintiff +26 -1 U.S. Government -Plaintiff +27 -3 Federal Question +28 -(U.S. Government Not a Party) +29 -Citizen of This State +30 -PTF -1 +32 -DEF -1 +32 -(For Diversity Cases Only) +33 -and One Box for Defendant) +34 -PTF +35 -Incorporated or Principal Place -of Business In This State +Telephone and Telegrams ……………………….……………………………………………………….. 35 -2 U.S. Government +Testing …………………….………………….……………………………………………………………..… -Defendant +Transportation ……………………….…………………………………………………………………………………………… -4 Diversity +Campus Contacts…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… -Citizen of Another State +Checklists……………………………………………………………………………………………………… -(Indicate Citizenship of Parties in Item III) +Services for International Students ………………………………………………………….………………………………. -DEF -4 +36 -5 +36 -6 +38 -4 +39 -5 +40 -6 + Office of International Education -2 +NOTICE TO STUDENTS +This guide should be used in combination with the ASU Undergraduate +Catalog/ASU Graduate Catalog and the RAM Student Handbook. The University +Catalog contains important information and regulations of the university that you +will need to know. You should obtain a copy of the Catalog (Undergraduate or +Graduate) and the RAM Student Handbook as soon as you begin your program +of study. 3 -2 - -Incorporated and Principal Place -of Business In Another State - -3 - -Foreign Nation - -Click here for: Nature of Suit Code Descriptions. -OTHER STATUTES - -BANKRUPTCY - -IV. NATURE OF SUIT (Place an “X” in One Box Only) - -TORTS - -CONTRACT - -110 Insurance -120 Marine -130 Miller Act -140 Negotiable Instrument -150 Recovery of Overpayment - -PERSONAL INJURY -310 Airplane -315 Airplane Product - -Liability - -320 Assault, Libel & - -& Enforcement of Judgment - -Slander - -151 Medicare Act -152 Recovery of Defaulted - -Student Loans -(Excludes Veterans) -153 Recovery of Overpayment -of Veteran’s Benefits - -160 Stockholders’ Suits -190 Other Contract -195 Contract Product Liability -196 Franchise - -REAL PROPERTY -210 Land Condemnation -220 Foreclosure -230 Rent Lease & Ejectment -240 Torts to Land -245 Tort Product Liability -290 All Other Real Property - -330 Federal Employers’ - -Liability - -340 Marine -345 Marine Product -Liability -350 Motor Vehicle -355 Motor Vehicle - -Product Liability - -360 Other Personal - -Injury - -362 Personal Injury - - -Medical Malpractice - -CIVIL RIGHTS -440 Other Civil Rights -441 Voting -442 Employment -443 Housing/ - -Accommodations -445 Amer. w/Disabilities - - -Employment - -446 Amer. w/Disabilities - - -Other -448 Education - -Citizen or Subject of a -Foreign Country - -FORFEITURE/PENALTY - -625 Drug Related Seizure - -of Property 21 USC 881 - -690 Other - -PERSONAL INJURY -365 Personal Injury - -Product Liability - -367 Health Care/ - -Pharmaceutical -Personal Injury -Product Liability - -368 Asbestos Personal -Injury Product -Liability - -422 Appeal 28 USC 158 -423 Withdrawal -28 USC 157 - -PROPERTY RIGHTS -820 Copyrights -830 Patent -835 Patent - Abbreviated - -New Drug Application - -840 Trademark -880 Defend Trade Secrets - -PERSONAL PROPERTY - -LABOR - -710 Fair Labor Standards - -Act of 2016 - -Act - -720 Labor/Management - -Relations - -740 Railway Labor Act -751 Family and Medical - -Leave Act - -790 Other Labor Litigation -791 Employee Retirement -Income Security Act - -IMMIGRATION - -462 Naturalization Application -465 Other Immigration - -Actions + Office of International Education -SOCIAL SECURITY -861 HIA (1395ff) -862 Black Lung (923) -863 DIWC/DIWW (405(g)) -864 SSID Title XVI -865 RSI (405(g)) +Dear International Student: -FEDERAL TAX SUITS -870 Taxes (U.S. Plaintiff -or Defendant) -871 IRS—Third Party -26 USC 7609 +It gives me great pleasure to welcome you to the campus of Albany State University. I +will serve as your International Student Advisor. I want you to know that you are a +valuable part of the ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY family like any other student and most +of all I want you to be successful in your studies. -370 Other Fraud -371 Truth in Lending -380 Other Personal +To help you reach this goal, I offer services that include providing you with important +information about your visa status and the benefits it includes. There are laws and +regulations you are required to follow in order to legally remain in the U.S. and I am +required to submit updates and other reports regularly and by specific deadlines to +confirm that. -Property Damage -385 Property Damage -Product Liability +This guide is designed to help you locate the resources and services you will need while +you are at ASU and answer some of your questions. You are encouraged to ALWAYS +know your F-1 Visa Student Status and regulation involved. -PRISONER PETITIONS +As an international student at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY you are required to meet +with me each semester of your matriculation. I encourage you to schedule +appointments so that we can meet to discuss and review options available to you at any +point of your educational endeavors at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY. -Habeas Corpus: -463 Alien Detainee -510 Motions to Vacate +In addition, please note that while you are matriculating as an International Student +ASU currently does not provide any financial assistance for you. It is your responsibility +to have the financial resources to continue your education. If for any reason you are +unable to continue to make financial contribution to your education endeavors you are +at risk of being in violation of the student immigration status. (please see the next page) -Sentence -530 General -535 Death Penalty -Other: -540 Mandamus & Other -550 Civil Rights -555 Prison Condition -560 Civil Detainee - -Conditions of -Confinement +I look forward to assisting you at ALBANY STATE UNIVERSITY and seeing you reach the +end of your program as focused and ready for the future as you are here today. -375 False Claims Act -376 Qui Tam (31 USC +Sincerely, -3729(a)) +Sue Ann Balch, J.D. +F1-Visa Student Advisor +sueann.balch@asurams.edu (Email) +229-430-7075 (Office Number) +229-434-7106 (fax Number) +205 Reese Hall -400 State Reapportionment -410 Antitrust -430 Banks and Banking -450 Commerce -460 Deportation -470 Racketeer Influenced and -Corrupt Organizations - -480 Consumer Credit - -(15 USC 1681 or 1692) - -485 Telephone Consumer -Protection Act -490 Cable/Sat TV -850 Securities/Commodities/ - -Exchange - -890 Other Statutory Actions -891 Agricultural Acts -893 Environmental Matters -895 Freedom of Information - -Act -896 Arbitration -899 Administrative Procedure -Act/Review or Appeal of -Agency Decision -950 Constitutionality of -State Statutes - -V. ORIGIN (Place an “X” in One Box Only) - -1 Original - -Proceeding - -2 Removed from -State Court - -3 Remanded from -Appellate Court - -4 Reinstated or -Reopened - -5 Transferred from -Another District -(specify) - -6 Multidistrict -Litigation - -Transfer +4 -8 Multidistrict -Litigation - -Direct File + Financial Documentation (Required Forms) +You can acquire these forms from the office of Recruitment and Admission -Cite the U.S. Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not cite jurisdictional statutes unless diversity): +*Albany State University International Student Financial Statement (To Be Completed by Student) -VI. CAUSE OF ACTION +*I-34 Affidavit of Support (To Be Completed By Sponsor, Affirmed Under Oath and Notarized) -Brief description of cause: +Original/Official Supporting Financial Documentation Must be: -VII. REQUESTED IN +1. Written in English or have certified English translation attached and a +recognized transcript evaluation by a company such as WES or Silney. +2. Dated no more than six months prior to the first day of the semester you -COMPLAINT: -VIII. RELATED CASE(S) +plan to attend. -IF ANY +3. Clearly state the account balance in United States Dollar amount(s). +4. Must provide the following information: Date account opened; total -CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION -UNDER RULE 23, F.R.Cv.P. +amount deposited for the past year; +Tuition and fees +Living Expenses +Expenses of dependant +Other: Books & Health Insurance -DEMAND $ +$14,600.00 +$9,000.00 +$0.00 +$4,000.00 +*$27,600.00 -CHECK YES only if demanded in complaint: +(*Fee changes yearly, 2016 cost listed above) -JURY DEMAND: +5. All monies for tuition, health insurance, Room Board, Books & Supplies +and other fees must be must be paid by the first day of classes each +semester at Albany State University after student has been accepted. +This process must occur until the student has completed matriculation at +Albany State University -Yes +How to set-up account? -No +1. After student receives acceptance letter from -(See instructions): +undergraduate or graduate admissions, student will +begin the account set-up process. -JUDGE +2. Student will mail fees for the year in United States -DOCKET NUMBER +Dollar Amount to: -DATE +Albany State University +Financial Operations +Attn: Student Account Manager +504 College Drive +Albany, GA 31705 +3. Student will mail money certified or return receipt -SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD +request or any secure means of mail delivery or pay +in person. -FOR OFFICE USE ONLY +ACADEMIC LIFE +ADVISORS +All students are assigned an academic advisor when they enroll in a degree +program. Your advisor will be a faculty member in your department. He or she +will help you choose which courses to take each semester. If you need to -RECEIPT # +5 -AMOUNT + change your schedule in any way, you must get the approval of your academic +advisor. + +Academic advisors can better serve you when they understand your educational +and career plans. They can help you prepare for graduate school or for a job. +They can arrange work experiences as a part of your degree program if this will +help you. If you give your advisor a clear picture of what you plan to do, he or +she can guide you toward the most suitable courses and university activities. + +INDIVIDUALITY +Individuality is very important to Americans. This value is as important in the +classroom as it is in other parts of U.S. culture. Independent thinking is +expected of students in American classrooms. Interpretation, analysis, critical +thinking, and even challenging the professor may be expected of you in class. +You may be graded on your class participation. Usually, professors will tell you +at the beginning of the course if you are to be evaluated on class participation. +It takes time and practice to get used to speaking out in class, but it is often an +important part of the learning experience. + +REGULATIONS +Certain acts are considered to be academic dishonesty and are not permitted at +Albany State University. Submitting another person’s work as your own or doing +academic work for another person is not allowed. Academic dishonesty includes +copying exam papers, assignments, or term papers or allowing another person to +copy your work. If you use ideas or information published by other people in +papers that you turn in, you must give the writers credit by providing citations in +footnotes or references. Your professors will tell you how to do this. Students +who turn in work which is not their own will be disciplined by the professor and +possibly the university. It could lead to expulsion from the university. + +GLOSSARY OF “UNIVERSITY LANGUAGE” +CATALOG/BULLETIN +The university publishes an undergraduate and graduate catalog. These catalogs +are sometimes called bulletins. They include information on all aspects of +university life, including regulations governing academic life, course descriptions, +and a list of faculty members. You must follow the rules set forth in the catalog +for your academic program. It is an important resource. Read it carefully and +refer to it when you need information about academic offerings and +requirements. + +CLASS +Sessions or meetings of particular courses. These are listed in the Schedule +Report, issued each semester, which lists the days, times and venues the class +meets. + +COLLEGE +The University is divided into units known as “Colleges.” The Colleges at ASU +are the Colleges of Arts and Humanities, College of Business, College of -APPLYING IFP +6 -JUDGE + Education, and College of Science and Health Professions. Unlike many other +countries, the term college in U.S. usage does not refer to high school or +secondary education. It is often used interchangeably with the term university. + +COMPREHENSIVE EXAMINATION +Examinations are required by most departments before a student can receive a +Master’s degree. The exams test the student’s knowledge of his or her entire +field of study. + +CORE CURRICULUM +The Core Curriculum is composed of a wide spectrum of general courses. It is +designed to give all students a broad base of basic knowledge and is required of +all students seeking bachelor’s degrees at ASU. + +COURSE +Subject Offerings. These are listed in the course catalog, by department. +Students usually take 4-5 courses per semester. The course listings are also +available through BANNER on the ASU website. + +CREDIT HOUR +Courses are given credit hour values. Most courses are 3 credit hours. This +means that the course meets for approximately 3 hours each week during the +semester. 1-hour course meets for 1 hour, etc. In order to be considered full- +time, undergraduates must enroll in 12 credit hours, graduate students need to +take 9 credit hours each semester. + +CURRICULUM +This refers to the program that you are following, and its requirements. There +are required courses and elective courses in most curricula. + +DEPARTMENT +Within each College are several Departments that specialize in a certain subject. +For example, the College of Education includes the Department of Teacher +Education and Department of Counseling and Educational Leadership. + +DROP-DATE +Students may choose to drop or withdraw from a course without penalty up to +the middle of the semester. However, you must remember that: + +1. As a foreign student, you must remain a full-time student at all times. +You must be enrolled for 12 hours at all times, unless it is a vacation +period which is the summer semester or you otherwise have +permission from the DSO in the International Office. Graduate +students must take 9 hours. + +2. Withdrawal hour’s associated with classes that are dropped due to +documented extenuating circumstances will be included in the 12 +hour total. -MAG. JUDGE +7 - PURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 83.11 + 3. Students will receive a “WF” (This symbol indicates withdrawal with penalty) for course + +withdrawals identified after the 16 hour limit has been reached. +There are financial and G.P.A conditions associated with the “WF”. + +4. “W” (This symbol indicates that a student was permitted to withdraw without penalty) grades will be awarded to +students who withdraw from classes prior to the end of the schedule +change deadline and to those students who are authorized to +withdraw due to extenuating circumstances. + +After the midterm drop-date, special permission is required for course +withdrawal. The grade the student has earned up to the point of withdrawal will +be reflected on his or her transcript; however, it will not affect the GPA. In +addition, as a F1-Visa Student you are required to notify the International +student Advisor of any schedule changes you are making. + +ELECTIVE COURSE +These are optional courses. Each student must choose several of these courses. +The academic advisor will suggest specific electives. + +FINAL +This is the last, major examination of the semester. Usually, one week is set +aside at the end of the semester for final exams. A final is a long exam, which +sometimes lasts as long as two hours. Not all professors choose to give final +exams. Some will assign research papers or special projects instead. + +GRADE POINT AVERAGE +Your performance is evaluated with grades of A, B, C, D, or F. The grades A +through F are given a numerical value (A=4, F=0) and weighted by the number +of credit hours associated with each grade. Your grade point average is +computed by averaging the numerical values of the credit hours for all of the +courses you have completed. “GPA” is the common abbreviation for Grade Point +Average. + +GRADUATE STUDENTS +These are students who have already received a Bachelor’s degree or the +equivalent. The graduate degrees offered at ASU are the Specialist degree in +Education and Master’s degree in several disciplines. +MID-TERM +A Mid-Term is a major examination given in many classes in the middle of the +semester. This word also refers to the date signaling the end of the first half of +the semester. + +MINOR +A secondary, optional program of study in addition to the student’s major. + +SEMESTER +The school year at Albany State University is divided into two semesters. Fall +semester, which begins in August and spring semester, which begins in January, + +8 + + constitute the normal academic year. There is a full six-week summer session. +Summer terms are optional terms for foreign students. + +QUIZ +An informal examination, shorter in length than a regular examination. + +REQUIRED COURSE +These are courses which each student seeking a particular degree must take. + +RESEARCH PAPER +This is a major paper which can be from 5 to 25 pages in length. In order to +write this paper, a student must select an approved topic, somewhat narrow in +scope, and do research in the library. Papers are to be typed. There are +manuals in the bookstore to show you how to type it, or you can hire a +professional typist. + +SECTION +Some courses are offered in a number of sections, or classes, each semester, so +that a large number of students may attend. A course number, section letter, +and call number identify each section. + +SYLLABUS +A list of information about a course including the books you will use, the +professor’s name, office and phone number. Usually there is a general outline of +how the course will proceed, and sometimes assignments and dates of +examinations are included. + +TRANSCRIPT +A record of students’ courses and grades. An “official transcript” is sealed by the +issuing institution, and normally sent directly to the school or office requesting it. +It is used to document a student’s academic performance while attending +college. Universities, graduate schools, and some employers use this to +determine the desirability of accepting or hiring students. + +UNDERGRADUATE +These are students who are studying for their first degree at the university. +During the first year, students are called freshmen; the second year, +sophomores; the third year, juniors; and their last year, seniors. The +undergraduate degree is the Bachelor’s degree. + +9 + + AMERICAN CUSTOMS AND CULTURE +The culture and customs of the United States are difficult to define precisely, +because geographic areas and the people who live in them differ. Most of what +you will learn about the customs and culture of the people of the United States +will be by experience and through contact with people. + +While you are in the U.S., it is good to learn the customs of the people here. It +is important, however, that you maintain your own values and beliefs. If you’re +personal preferences or religious beliefs influence you not to do certain things, +do not be embarrassed to explain this. + +TIME +Being on time is very important in the American society. Classes, parties, +concerts, meetings, and other planned events all start at a specific time. If you +need to see someone, you should ALWAYS make an appointment beforehand. +Do not show up at their office or home unexpectedly. It is considered very +important not to be late to scheduled appointments or events. If you are late for +an appointment, it is important to apologize to the person(s) you have kept +waiting. Students who are always late for appointments or who turn in +assignments after the deadline earn negative reputations. Many professors will +deduct from a grade if an assignment is late or if a student arrives late for class. + +INFORMALITY +There is a great deal of informality between all types of people in the U.S. It is +our way of life. The American society does not have a formal class structure. +We may dress more casually and act more informally in social situations than you +may be used to. + +GREETING, INVITATIONS, AND VISITING +The most common forms of greeting are a handshake, smile and “Hello, I’m +pleased to meet you.” The Americans do not usually embrace in public, except +with members of their family or very close friends. + +Professors should be addressed as Doctor or Professor unless they request +otherwise. You should also use titles (usually Mr., Mrs., or Ms.) with older +persons unless they ask you to call them by their first name. For other students, +it is customary that you address them by their first name. + +If you are invited somewhere and you accept the invitation, it is VERY +IMPORTANT that you appear at the event. Do not accept an invitation simply +because you are afraid to say no. If you cannot or do not want to go to the +event, politely tell the person who invited you htat you cannot or choose not to +attend. It is much more inappropriate to accept an invitation and then fail to +appear than it is to decline the invitation in the first place. If invited to visit +someone’s home, you are not normally expected to bring a gift. It is always +acceptable, but not necessary, to bring a small token or an inexpensive gift to +your host or hostess. An expensive gift is usually inappropriate and may make + +10 + + your host or hostess uncomfortable or embarrassed. American homes, usually +does not have domestic servants, so if you stay as a houseguest, it is proper for +you to make your own bed or volunteer to help with other household chores. + +TABLE MANNERS +Table manners is most common to Americans including not speaking with food in +your mouth, keeping your elbows off the table, and keeping your hands in you +lap while you’re not eating. A knife, fork, and spoon are used unless “finger +foods” are being served. You should not belch at the table after eating; this is +considered rude in the U.S. After the meal is finished, the napkin should be laid +beside the plate and used silverware should be laid across the top of the plate. + +RELATIONSHIPS +Most Americans have many friendly acquaintances, but just a few close friends. +Visitors from other countries often remark that Americans are very friendly, even +at the first meeting, but that it is difficult to get to know them very well. +Sometimes this is true; although Americans are friendly to everyone, they are +also very private people and often have just a few intimate friends. + +Americans often say things like “let’s get together sometime” as a friendly way to +say good-bye, NOT as an invitation. If you would like to get to know someone +better, it is a good idea for you to invite them to go somewhere with you on a +specific day, at a scheduled time. Participate in as many social activities as you +can and you will meet and make many new friends. + +MEN AND WOMEN +American women are independent, and women and men are considered equal. +It is not appropriate to whistle at, touch, or make personal comments about +women whom you do not know EXTREMELY well. It is common for American +university women to live alone or with other women in apartments off campus. +Guests of both sexes are often invited to these apartments. Do not assume that +your hostess has romantic intentions simply because she has invited you to stop +by her apartment. + +There are no clear guidelines for dating Americans. If you want to get to know +someone, it is often best just to ask the person to join you for a snack or to get +together to study. It is important to remember, however, that if two people go +out on a date, it only means that they enjoy each other’s company. It does not +always indicate serious intentions or constitute a promise! If you begin to date +someone from another culture, it is important to remember that s/he simply may +not view the relationship in the same way that you do, especially regarding the +seriousness of the relationship or the desire to engage in sexual activity. + +11 + + It is most often the man who invites the woman out on a date, and customarily +the man pays all of the expenses unless the persons agree that it will be a +“Dutch Treat,” that is, each person pays for his or her own expenses. Women +sometimes ask men for dates. A woman who asks a man out should be +prepared to pay for the expenses. + +BATHING AND HYGIENE +Most Americans bathe or shower daily, and use deodorants and anti- perspirants. +Americans are not accustomed to body odors and find it offensive. Some +international visitors may want to adjust their bathing habits and accommodate +American preferences for the time they are here. + +CULTURE SHOCK +There are many differences between the American culture and the home culture +of many international students. Adapting to these differences can cause “culture +shock.” If you are having trouble adjusting to life in the U.S., or are +experiencing depression or physical or emotional problems, you may be +experiencing culture shock. The Office of the International Student Advisor can +provide cross-cultural counseling to help you, or refer you to a counselor on +campus free of charge. Counseling is always confidential. + +ADDITIONAL INFORMATION +If you would like additional information about American culture, please visit the +Office of the International Student Advisor. The office contains several +handbooks and guidebooks for foreign visitors in the United States. + +IMMIGRATION STATUS +THE U.S. CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES (USCIS) is the branch of +the Federal government created to monitor the entry and exit of foreign +nationals. This branch of the government was formerly known as the +Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). You will encounter INS officials as +you travel between the U.S. and your home country and when you apply for +special programs. The following information should help you understand the +regulations concerning student immigration status. Most ASU students have +either F-1 or J-1 immigration status. + +PASSPORT +Your passport must be valid at all times. When it is time to renew your passport, +contact your country’s embassy in Washington, D.C. to determine what +procedures you need to follow in order to extend your passport. + +VISA +There is a visa stamped in your passport, which permitted you to enter the +United States. A single entry visa permits you to enter the U.S. only once on +that specific visa. A multiple entry visa allows you to enter the U.S. as many +times as you like (after leaving on vacations or trips home) as long as you + +12 + + remain a full-time student. Student stays are valid for the “duration of status”. +This status is indicated by the mark “D/S’ in your passport and on your I-20/DS- +2019 and I-94. As long as you remain in full-time student status, you are in the +country legally, regardless of the expiration date on your entry visa. +If you leave the U.S. after your visa expires, you must go to a U.S. Embassy or +Consulate-General in your home country and obtain a new visa before you can +return to the U.S. It is difficult to obtain a new visa in a “third country.” It is +difficult to obtain new F-1 visas in Canada or Mexico, unless you are from those +countries. + +F-1 IMMIGRATION STATUS +If you are a full-time degree-seeking student or a Rotary student at ASU, you +have entered the U.S. with F-1 immigration status. This type of immigration +status is designed to allow you to obtain your degree and return home following +your graduation. F-1 status is a “non-immigrant” status. “Non-immigrant” +means that you are not moving to the U.S. permanently. This immigration status +is valid for “duration of status.” + +• You should carefully consider the dates of your authorized stay and +make sure you are following the procedures under U.S. immigration +laws. It is important that you depart the U.S. on or before the last +day you are authorized to be in the U.S. on any given trip, based on +the specified end date on your Arrival-Departure Record, Form I-94. +Failure to depart the U.S. will cause you to be out-of- +status. Additional information on successfully maintaining your +immigration status while a student or exchange visitor can be found +on the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) website. +• Staying beyond the period of time authorized by the Department of + +Homeland Security (DHS) and being out-of-status in the +United States is a violation of U.S. immigration laws, and may cause +you to be ineligible for a visa in the future for return travels to the +U.S. + +• Staying unlawfully in the United States beyond the date Customs and +Border Protection (CBP) officials have authorized--even by one day-- +results in your visa being automatically voided, in accordance with +INA 222(g). Under this provision of immigration law, if you overstay +on your nonimmigrant authorized stay in the U.S., your visa will be +automatically voided. In this situation, you are required to reapply for +a new nonimmigrant visa, generally in your country of nationality. + +• For non immigrants in the U.S. who have an Arrival-Departure + +Record, Form I-94 with the CBP admitting officer endorsement of +Duration of Status or D/S, but who are no longer performing the +same function in the U.S. that they were originally admitted +to perform (e.g. you are no longer working for the same employer or +you are no longer attending the same school), a DHS or an +immigration judge makes a finding of status violation, resulting in the +termination of the period of authorized stay. + +13 + + Staying Beyond Your Authorized Stay in the U.S. and Being Out of Status + +• You should carefully consider the dates of your authorized stay and make +sure you are following the procedures under U.S. immigration laws. It is +important that you depart the U.S. on or before the last day you are +authorized to be in the U.S. on any given trip, based on the specified end +date on your Arrival-Departure Record, Form I-94. Failure to depart the +U.S. will cause you to be out-of-status. Additional information on +successfully maintaining your immigration status while a student or +exchange visitor can be found on the Immigration and Customs +Enforcement (ICE) website. + +• Staying beyond the period of time authorized by the Department of + +Homeland Security (DHS) and being out-of-status in the United States is a +violation of U.S. immigration laws, and may cause you to be ineligible for +a visa in the future for return travel to the U.S. Select Classes of Aliens +Ineligible to Receive Visas to learn more. + +• Staying unlawfully in the United States beyond the date Customs and +Border Protection (CBP) officials have authorized--even by one day-- +results in your visa being automatically voided, in accordance with INA +222(g). Under this provision of immigration law, if you overstay on your +nonimmigrant authorized stay in the U.S., your visa will be automatically +voided. In this situation, you are required to reapply for a new +nonimmigrant visa, generally in your country of nationality. + +• For non immigrants in the U.S. who have an Arrival-Departure Record, +Form I-94 with the CBP admitting officer endorsement of Duration of +Status or D/S, but who are no longer performing the same function in the +U.S. that they were originally admitted to perform (e.g. you are no longer +working for the same employer or you are no longer attending the same +school), a DHS or an immigration judge makes a finding of status +violation, resulting in the termination of the period of authorized stay. + +What Items Do Returning Students Need? + +All applicants applying for renewals must submit: + +• A passport valid for at least six months; +• An application Form DS-156, together with a Form DS-158. Both forms +must be completed and signed. Some applicants will also be required +to complete and sign Form DS-157. Blank forms are available without +charge at all U.S. consular offices and on the Visa Services website +under Visa Applications Forms at the United States Citizenship and +Immigration Services (https://www.uscis.gov/). + +• A receipt for visa processing fee. A receipt showing payment of the visa + +application fee for each applicant, including each child listed in a +parent’s passport who is also applying for a U.S. visa, is needed; +• A new I-20 or an I-20 that has been endorsed on the back by a school + +official within the past 12 months. + +14 + + All applicants applying for renewals should be prepared to submit: + +• A certified copy of your grades from the school in which you are + +enrolled; + +• Financial documents from you or your sponsor, showing your ability to + +cover the cost of your schooling. + +Students Away from Classes More Than Five Months +Students in or outside the U.S., who have been away from classes for more +than five months, will likely need a new visa to enter the U.S. + +How long may I stay on my F-1 student visa? + +When you enter the United States on a student visa, you will usually be +admitted for the duration of your student status. That means you may stay as +long as you are a full-time student, even if the F-1 visa in your passport +expires while you are in America. For a student who has completed the course +of studies shown on the I-20, and any authorized practical training, the +student is allowed the following additional time in the U.S. before departure: + +• F-1 student - An additional 60 days, to prepare for departure from the + +U.S. or to transfer to another school. + +• M-1 student - An additional 30 days to depart the U.S. (Fixed time period, +in total not to exceed one year). The 30 days to prepare for departure is +permitted as long as the student maintained a full course of study and +maintained status. An M student may receive extensions up to three years +for the total program. + +As an example regarding duration of status, if you have a visa that is valid for +five years that will expire on January 1, 2001, and you are admitted into the +U.S. for the duration of your studies (often abbreviated in your passport or on +your I-94 card as "D/S"), you may stay in the U.S. as long as you are a full- +time student. Even if January 1, 2001 passes and your visa expires while in +America, you will still be in legal student status. However, if you depart the +U.S. with an expired visa, you will need to obtain a new one before being able +to return to America and resume your studies. A student visa cannot be +renewed or re-issued in the United States; it must be done at an Embassy or +Consulate abroad. + +FORM I-20 +Before you came to ASU, you were sent Form I-20 by the ASU Admissions Office. +This form is the one you use to obtain your F-1 student visa, and it is a very +important form. You should keep it safe with your passport. A Designated School +Official (DSO) must sign your I-20 whenever you travel outside the United +States, even if you are only going for a short time. If you change degree +programs (change your major), you will need a new I-20. New I-20 forms are +available from the International Admissions Officer on campus at 229-430-4646 +or visit the Office of the International Student Advisor for further assistance. If +you transferred to ASU, be sure to keep your ASU I-20 and the I-20 from your + +15 + + previous school together. Note the date of expiration in #5 on your I-20. If you +need to stay past this time to complete your studies, you must contact a DSO at +least 30 days before this expiration date to extend your stay as a student. + +FULL-TIME STUDENT STATUS (In-Status) +In order to maintain your full time status, you must attend school at least 9 +semester hours per semester for graduate studies and at least 12 semester +hours per semester for undergraduate studies. If you have any questions +about this regulation, please see the International Student Advisor. Students +who fail to maintain this requirement risk being placed on probation and could +lose university scholarships, including International Student Scholarships. To +avoid losing your full-time status, check with your advisor and/or Registrar +before you drop a class. + +VACATION +The Summer Term is considered a vacation period for all non-immigrant +students, as long as the student intends to register full-time for the next term. +You may enroll part-time, full-time or not at all during the summer term. Make +sure you check with the International Student Advisor before taking ANY +semester other than the summer semester off. You can go home for summer +any time you wish. + +VACATIONS INSIDE OR OUTSIDE THE USA + +(A) Inside the USA: You do not need permission of any kind from anyone to +travel anywhere within the USA. Travel between the 50 states is totally +unrestricted. Have fun—see the USA! + +(B) Outside the USA: Before leaving the USA, you must go by the office of a +Designated School Official (DSO) with your passport and I-20 and let the +DSO sign your I-20 and check your visa. Your I-20 must be signed for +you to re-enter the USA. You must have both the signed (or a new) I-20 +and a valid F-1 visa in your passport to re-enter the USA. + +If your visa has expired, you will need to go to a U.S. Embassy or Consulate- +General to get a new visa before you can re-enter the country. U.S. VISAS ARE +NOT ISSUED IN THE USA. If you have dependents that are on an I-20, we need +to check their passports and visas as well. + +PLEASE VISIT THE OFFICE OF THE INTERNATIONAL STUDENT +ADVISOR AT LEAST TWO (2) WEEKS BEFORE YOUR TRIP SO THAT +THERE WILL BE SOMEONE AVAILABLE TO SIGN YOUR DOCUMENTS. + +TRANSFER STUDENTS +If you are transferring from another U.S. college or university to ASU, you must +see the International Student Advisor within 5 days of your registration at the +beginning of the semester for completion of the transfer process, which must be +done to maintain your student status. + +EMPLOYMENT + +16 + + (A) ON-CAMPUS: As soon as you have registered for classes, you may work +on campus as a student assistant in the various departments if hired. . +Each department or facility has its own budget for student workers, so +you must go directly to them to seek employment. Once you have found +a job, you must register with the ASU Human Resources Department +(Department of Human Resources) in order to be paid for your work. To +register, you must have a Social Security Number. For more information +about Social Security Numbers, please see the section on Social Security +Numbers in this handbook. + +(B) OFF CAMPUS—ECONOMIC HARDSHIP: You must see the International + +Student Advisor before you can work off campus. Due to recent changes +in immigration laws, it is virtually impossible for foreign students to work +off campus. The only two exceptions are internships for academic credit +or extreme economic difficulty due to conditions beyond his or her +control. Students must apply to USCIS for permission to accept +employment off campus due to economic hardship, and the ISA can +assist you with this application. + +(C) OFF CAMPUS—PRACTICAL TRAINING: You must see the International +Student Advisor before you can work off campus. Curricular Practical +training (or an internship) is work directly related to your course of study +that will give you “hands-on” job experience that will help you get a +better job when you return to your home country. It can be granted only +after you have been at ASU for an academic year, and then only under +certain specific conditions. There are provisions for curricular practical +training before graduation and after graduation. + +Other than the above types of work, NO OTHER EMPLOYMENT IS PERMITTED +while you are in student status. You may not work off campus without +permission from USCIS and/or the ISA. If you do work off campus illegally, you +will lose your student immigration status and its benefits. Working illegally in the +United States is the most serious violation of non-immigrant status in the eyes of +the USCIS, and you WILL NOT be reinstated if you violate this regulation. + +INFORMATION UPDATES +Any change in address, phone number or marital status must be reported to the +Office of the International Student Advisor (ISA) and the Office of the Registrar +within 10 days. You must report the changes to both offices. If you do not +notify the ISA and the Registrar, you will not receive important mail from the +university. Please note that the Office of the Registrar maintains two addresses +on each student, a local address and a home address. The local address is your +address in Albany. If you live on campus, the university will automatically record +your ASU box number. If you live off campus, you must report your address to +the ISA and the Registrar. The home address is your address in your country. It +is the address you listed on your application for admission. All official +correspondence concerning your grades and your fees will be sent to the home +address. You may want to change your home address to your Albany address to +make sure you receive these notices. If you move off-campus, you must also + +17 + + complete a United States Postal Service Change of Address card and sign the +card. Completing this card will allow the campus mailroom to forward mail to +you at your new address. + +THE CARDINAL RULE +If you have questions about working or any other USCIS-related +matter while in the USA, visit the Office of the International Student +Advisor. The Office of the International Student Advisor and +Designated School Officials are here to assist you. We will help you as +much as we can; however, it is YOUR RESPONSIBILITY to keep the +office informed of your status and to ask for help when you need it. The +U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Services holds you accountable for +your own actions and expects you to follow all laws pertaining to your +immigration status. If you choose to violate the law or fail to educate +yourself about the law, you will be responsible, not the Office of the +International Student Advisor. Do not allow yourself to fall out of +status. Do not rely on the advice of other students for immigration +matters. You could lose the privilege of studying in the U.S. now, and +you could be prevented from returning to the U.S. in the future. + +A revision of the immigration law, the Illegal Immigration Reform and +Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, contains very harsh penalties of +students who violate student immigrant status, including provision to +prevent offenders from returning to the United States for periods of +several years. The new immigration regulations based on this act are +currently in place, but because the law is a new one, there are often +modifications or updates to the regulations. The International Student +Advisor will keep you informed about modifications in the regulations. + +AUTOMOBILES +REQUIRED INSURANCE +Law requires liability insurance for a car. If you own an automobile in Georgia, +you must purchase liability insurance. Collision insurance is not required, but it is +recommended. Proof of insurance, usually in the form of an insurance card, +must be carried in the car at all times. Look in the “Yellow Pages” of the phone +book to locate insurance agents, or ask a friend to refer you. Compare prices +with several companies before buying. + +DRIVER’S LICENSE +As a non-resident student at the university, you may drive in Georgia with a valid +international driver’s license. If you do not have an international license or if +your license expires during your stay, you may apply for a state of Georgia +license at the `Dougherty County Department of Motor Vehicle Safety (DMVS), +2062 Newton Road, Albany. The contact telephone number is 229-430-4258. +Getting a Georgia license requires a written test and a driving test. You should +present your passport, I-94, and your I-20 or DS-2019 to the examiner. You will +also need to bring a lease or utility bill, which verifies your address. If you live in + +18 + + a residence hall, you may also need a letter from the International Student +Advisor certifying that you live on-campus. The fee for a five-year license for +driving a passenger car is $20.00. A provisional permit costs $10.00. All fees +must be paid in cash. In addition, you will need a denial letter from the Social +Security Office and/or a Social Security Card. Also, you will need a letter from +your International Student Advisor before you go. + +Many students find that having a State of Georgia license helps them to obtain +lower rates for automobile insurance. Georgia identification cards are also +available at the driver’s license office for a fee. Both the license and the ID card +contain photographs of the bearer. Because the driver’s license and the state ID +card are the most widely accepted forms of identification, it is easier to verify +your address and age with these items than with your passport or ASU ID. +Having proper identification is especially important for writing checks and +handling other banking matters. You should consider obtaining an official form +of identification other than your passport. If you must carry your passport with +you at all times, you risk losing it. You should call the license bureau at 229-430- +4258 to make sure that the test is being given on the day you plan to apply for a +license. The bureau is closed on Mondays and will not give tests when it is +raining. + +If you hold a license from another state in the U.S. or from another country, you +will need to surrender this license to obtain a Georgia license. Please note that +once an out-of-state license has been surrendered to the State of Georgia, it is +not possible to reclaim the license. You should consider whether you wish to +surrender your home country license before you go to the bureau. If you have +questions about this regulation, please see the International Student Advisor. + +RULES OF THE ROAD +Although your international license is valid in the U.S., it is a good idea to read +the State of Georgia Driver’s Manual before you begin driving. Every country has +different traffic laws. Reading these laws in advance could prevent you from +having an accident. Copies of the State of Georgia Driver’s Manual are available +in the Office of the International Student Advisor. + +TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS +If you break any of the traffic laws, including driving over the speed limit, you +risk being stopped by a police officer. If a police or sheriff car follows you with +flashing lights and sirens, the officer wants you to pull over to the side of the +road. You should be prepared to pull over in a safe spot and do as the officer +instructs. Usually, the officer will ask to see your driver’s license, proof of liability +insurance, and registration for the car. He will also ask you questions about your +driving. If you have broken a traffic law, he may issue you a citation (ticket). +Citations involve paying fines, and in extreme cases, imprisonments. If you are +in an accident, you must wait at the scene of the accident for a police officer to +investigate the accident. Do not move the car and do not leave until the officer +has interviewed you about the accident. + +PARKING + +19 + + Most parking in Albany is free. Parking on the ASU campus requires a permit, +which costs $15 per academic year. Please refer to the ASU Parking and +Transportation resource guide for parking regulations. If parking regulations are +violated, you will get a “ticket” and be required to pay a fine. Parking Rules on +campus are clearly stated in the RAM Student Handbook. + +RENTAL AND PURCHASE +If you have a valid driver’s license and are at least 21 years old, you will probably +be able to rent or lease a car. Some rental places also require a credit card in +your name or that you are at least 25 years of age. Check with the larger local +car dealerships about short- and long-term rental. + +If you wish to buy a car for your stay in the U.S., be CAREFUL. Most companies +will service your car if it needs repair after purchase. You must pay for all +repairs unless you have a “manufacturer’s warranty” or paper which states that +the maker of the car will pay for repairs for a limited period of time after +purchase. If you buy a used car from a private dealer or individual, check the +vehicle carefully before purchase. It might help to bring a friend who knows +about the mechanical working of an automobile to inspect the car for you. An +honest car dealer will be happy to let you inspect all parts of the car and +remember to ask questions before you buy. When purchasing a car, you must +have a TITLE and LICENCE PLATE (tag) from the State of Georgia. The dealer +where you purchased the car will give you the correct papers to fill out and help +you obtain these things. In addition, you must renew items such as insurance, +license and tags on a yearly basis. If you buy a car from an individual, be sure to +ask for assistance with these items. If you are bringing a car to Albany from +another state, you must transfer the title for the car and obtain license plates +from the State of Georgia. You should also notify your insurance company that +you have moved. + +License plates must be renewed each year before paying the tax on your car. +Once you have paid the tax, you will be given a sticker for that year. The sticker +should be placed in the upper right hand corner of the license plate. If you have +questions about license plates, please contact the Dougherty County Tag Office, +225 Pine Avenue, Room 104, Albany, GA. The telephone number is 229-431- +3255. + +EMERGENCIES +To call the POLICE, AMBULANCE, or FIRE DEPARTMENT, dial 911. Call this +number only if someone needs immediate help. This is a special emergency aid +number and needs no other numbers. For medical problems that are not life- +threatening emergencies, call the Palmyra Medical Centers, 2000 Palmyra Road, +Albany. Tel.:229- 229-434-2000 or Phoebe Putney Memorial Hospital, 417 3rd +Avenue, Albany. Tel.: 229-883-1800, 229-312-1000. Police concerns are handled +according to location: + +Campus Police: +Albany Police: +Leesburg Police: + +229-430-4711 +229-431-3266 or 229-431-2100 +229-759-6012 + +20 + + Albany Fire Dept.: + +229-431-3266 + +ENGLISH LANGUAGE +Students who scored below 523 on the TOEFL (Test of English as a Foreign +Language) are REQUIRED to take special supplementary English as a Second +Language (ESL) courses. These courses are non-credit-bearing, but they will help +you with your academic English needs. The course numbers are ENGL 0075, +0077, 0098 and 0099. Any international students are welcome to take these +courses, even if the TOEFL score was above 523. + +English 1101 is the introductory university level English course required for all +ASU degree programs. The course prepares students for the remaining required +English courses in their degree program. + +There are some options available for students who wish to improve their English +language skills. For students who need help with their writing skills, the English +Department offers tutoring in the Writing Center lab located in Simmons Hall. +Another option for tutoring is the PEER TUTORING program. Tutoring is available +in most subjects free of charge during the fall and spring semesters. Contact the +Office of the International Student Advisor or your English professor to find out +which of these facilities will best meet your language needs. + +ENTERTAINMENT +ASU provides many entertainment and social opportunities for students. The +student centers on both campuses are available to you for all activities. It has as +its objectives the fulfillment of the cultural, educational, and recreational desires +of all students of ASU. Various programs and activities are planned and +supervised by the Director of Student Activities and the program coordinator to +round out and broaden the experiences of each student. The services and +facilities of the Student Union are open from 10.00 a.m. to 7.00 p.m. Monday +through Friday. On Saturdays and Sundays, the Game Room hours will be posted +in the game room, unless other wise notified. The facilities and services of the +Union are for students to make full use of. They include conference and meeting +rooms, lounges, a game room, Pizza Hut, the ASU Bookstore, Student +Government Office, a Post Office, an ATM, an information desk, vending +machines, and the ASU Board of Managers. + +The Albany State University International Student Association (ASUISA) is a +special club for international students at ASU. This group plans and promotes +cultural diversity and global awareness activities involving ASU and the +community. It also organizes programs and field trips for students who are +interested in more international activities. Look for information about the first +meeting in late August. + +For more information about clubs and activities, you should read the campus +paper, The Student Voice, and listen to the community radio stations. Also plan +to attend the campus-wide activities fair that takes place during the early part of + +21 + + the Fall Semester. Each of ASU’s clubs will have a booth at this fair to provide +more information for potential members. + +HEALTH CARE +The United States philosophy of health care is different from that of many other +countries. Health care in this country is viewed as an industry. All Health Care +professionals are expected to be paid by their patients or clients. Patients often +must prove ability to pay before treatment will be given. Doctors in this country +usually manage their offices so that they spend a minimum amount of time with +each patient. Nurses do as much as possible to help free the doctor to see more +patients. Expect to deal with nurses in the office and over the telephone. + +MEDICAL EMERGENCY +In case of medical emergency involving a life-threatening situation, or to request +an ambulance (emergency transportation to the hospital), call 911. Call this +number only in true emergencies. ASU students should not use the emergency +room services at the local hospitals, Phoebe or Palmyra, unless the medical +problem is life threatening. Students should use the university health center +infirmary as their main source of medical care. If you do not know whether the +situation is a true emergency, it is probably best to call campus police and have +the officer escort you to the health center. The nurse will evaluate the problem +and will send emergency cases to the hospital. THE HEALTH CENTER IS THE +CLOSEST MEDICAL FACITLITY TO THE RESIDENCE HALLS. Please note that +using the ambulance and the emergency room at the hospitals is very expensive. +This expense will not be covered by medical insurance if the situation is not a +true emergency. + +STUDENT HEALTH SERVICES +The University Health Service of Albany State University is located in the +Academic Administration (ACAD) Building, Room 138. Student Health Services +provide opportunities for safeguarding the health of all students at ASU. The +staff provides the following through student health fees: + +1. General medical care. +2. Confinement in the Health Services. Overnight stays are not available. +3. Consultation on general health needs. + +The health fee DOES NOT cover expenses for special medicines and treatments, +visits to doctors’ offices, operations or off-campus hospitalization. + +The University Health Services office is open Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. – +5:00 p.m. Our Doctors’ hours are Monday through Friday, 4:00-5:00 p.m. +Emergency calls are possible at any time. Each student, freshman or transferee, +is required to have on file a medical record completed and signed by a physician. +These records will be good for four years provided the student is in continuous +attendance at Albany State University and has consulted with the University +Physician periodically. + +22 + + DENTAL CARE +If you need to have your teeth cleaned or another dental service, you should +look in the telephone book Yellow Pages under “Dentists.” Phone to make an +appointment before you go. + +EYEGLASSES AND CONTACT LENSES +If you need an eye examination, or you want your eyeglasses or contact lenses +changed, you should look in the telephone book Yellow Pages under, “Opticians +and Optometrists.” Phone to make an appointment before you go. For medical +concerns with your eyes, look under “Ophthalmologist.” + +COUNSELING +Sometimes individuals become depressed, lonely or fearful in a strange +environment. Many overseas students come from a culture very different from +that of the U.S., and they often miss the support of their family and friends at +home. If you are feeling emotionally upset, depressed, or just need someone to +talk to, contact the International Student Advisor. S/he can make helpful +suggestions, listen to your concerns, and may refer you for further counseling. + +The primary function of the Counseling Services is to assist students in their total +development by providing services and programs to facilitate their intellectual, +emotional, social and academic growth. Counseling services also aid students in +determining a purpose and direction for their lives and in developing coping skills +and behaviors to aid them in working more efficiently with others in their +environment. + +PAYMENT +Health care in the United States is not free. Patients must pay for the services of +doctors, dentists, laboratory workers and hospitals. Their fees are often very +expensive. Care at the Health Services on campus is paid for by student health +fees each semester, so go to the Health Center first for any illness. If you have +an appointment with any off campus doctor or dentist, be prepared to +pay the bill at the conclusion of the appointment. Insurance will not +always cover 100% of the cost. Medical insurance does not cover the expense +of dental visits or eye exams and glasses. Students may want to plan to take +care of routine visits to these doctors during vacations at home. + +INSURANCE +Due to the high cost of medical care in the U.S., all foreign students +must purchase health insurance before enrolling for classes at ASU. +ASU is pleased to offer one policy for all ASU foreign students student. +Since September 1994, new regulations from the U.S. government +have determined what type of insurance coverage students must have. +The ASU policy has been designed to meet this minimum level of +coverage at a reasonable price. The plan covers portions of hospital +costs, doctor visits, and medication but not dental visits or eyeglasses. +Insurance to cover all costs at 100% and to cover dental visits and +eyeglasses is extremely expensive. Few U.S. residents carry such +coverage due to the high cost. The insurance system in the U.S. is + +23 + + designed for the patient to pay a portion of the cost in addition to the +insurance premium already paid. Insurance premiums are the fees paid +for insurance coverage. The university will bill all ASU international +students for the insurance premiums. Insurance from another source is +generally not accepted, since the coverage must meet U.S government +standards. If you need information about the ASU health insurance +program, see the International Student Advisor. If you do not pay your +premium, you will lose your insurance coverage and you will have a +hold placed on your student account, which will prevent you from +registering for classes. You should be careful to avoid a situation +where you lose your coverage because you never know when an illness +or accident may occur. If you have an illness or an accident and you +have no insurance, you will be responsible for 100% of the cost of your +treatment. For Student Health Insurance, please visit the Student +Health Insurance website. www.studenthealthinsurance.com + +GOOD HEALTH +The demand of university life and adjusting to a new environment can be very +stressful. Whenever a person is under stress, s/he is much more susceptible to +illness. Be sure that you take steps to protect your health. Eat properly, get +plenty of sleep, exercise, and protect yourself from communicable diseases, +especially sexually transmitted diseases such as AIDS. If you think you have a +health problem, seek help immediately. If you have questions about any health +matter, please visit the Student Health Center or the Counseling Center. + +IMMUNIZATIONS +All students in the state of Georgia must be vaccinated against measles, mumps, +and rubella. The vaccination can be obtained in one injection called an MMR. It +is recommended that you also receive a shot for Meningitis as well as a +Tuberculosis test. The vaccines are required because these diseases are +present in the U.S. You must protect your health while you are in the U.S. +Students must receive two doses (injection) of this “MMR” vaccine at least 30 +days apart. These vaccines are available at the Dougherty County Government +Office at 222 Pine Avenue, Albany. The telephone number of the Health +Department is 229-430-6200. Students who do not receive these vaccines will +not be allowed to register for classes. We prefer that you send proof of +immunizations and TB test as part of your application package. + +HOUSING +ON-CAMPUS HOUSING +The residence halls provide convenient, inexpensive housing on campus for +students. Most students will share a room with another student (roommate) and +a bathroom with other students nearby. Students must sign a room contract and +pay an application fee and deposit in order to live in a residence hall. The exact +amount to be paid will be included in your letter of admission. The contract +obligates you to live in the residence hall for the entire nine-month academic +year (2 semesters). The on-campus apartments are open all year. They are, + +24 + + however, in great demand. If you want to live in an on-campus apartment, stop +by the Office of Housing for more information or call 229-430-4741. + +If your room needs repairs or you have questions and concerns about any aspect +of life in the residence hall, you should contact your Resident Assistant. The +Resident Assistant, or RA, is also a student who lives in the hall, but this student +is an employee of the Office of Housing. The RA enforces the rules of the +residence hall such as quiet hours. The RA also handles issues such as changing +rooms or roommates and reporting when repairs are needed. The Residence +Hall Director supervises the Resident Assistant of the residence hall. Your +questions and concerns about life in the residence hall should be addressed to +the RA or the Residence Hall Director. Of course the staff of the Office of +Housing and Residence Life will be happy to assist you as well. The telephone +number is 229-430-4741. + +During recent years, the demand for on-campus housing has been high. It is +very important for you to read carefully any correspondence from the Office of +Housing. You need to follow specific procedures to reserve your room each year. +Please make a note of all deadlines and procedures. + +ROOMMATES +Living with an American roommate can be an excellent way to practice English, +learn about the U.S. culture and customs, or to meet a new friend. Living with +another person requires patience, tolerance, and kindness, especially as you get +to know one another during the first few days. It can also be one of the most +enjoyable aspects of your stay on campus. You should expect to disagree with +your roommate about some things. This is normal. The best way to solve your +differences is to speak honestly to one another. Americans are accustomed to +direct discussion of problems. If there are problems, which cannot be solved +between the two of you, you may go to your Resident Assistant (RA) who will +work with you to assign a new roommate. + +OFF-CAMPUS HOUSING +Off-campus housing is plentiful in Albany. There are many apartment complexes +and rental houses near campus and around town. Listed below are a few +suggestions of places to look for housing: 1. -Is this a case that has been previously dismissed? - -If yes, give the following information: - -Court: - -Case No.: - -Judge: - 2. -Other than stated above, are there any pending or previously -discontinued or dismissed companion cases in this or any other -court, including state court? (Companion cases are matters in which -it appears substantially similar evidence will be offered or the same -or related parties are present and the cases arise out of the same -transaction or occurrence.) - -Yes - -No - -Yes - -No - -If yes, give the following information: - -Court: - -Case No.: - -Judge: - -Notes : - - JS 44 Reverse (Rev. 10/20) - -INSTRUCTIONS FOR ATTORNEYS COMPLETING CIVIL COVER SHEET FORM JS 44 - -Authority For Civil Cover Sheet - -The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replaces nor supplements the filings and service of pleading or other papers as -required by law, except as provided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is -required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. Consequently, a civil cover sheet is submitted to the Clerk of -Court for each civil complaint filed. The attorney filing a case should complete the form as follows: - -I.(a) Plaintiffs-Defendants. Enter names (last, first, middle initial) of plaintiff and defendant. If the plaintiff or defendant is a government agency, use - -only the full name or standard abbreviations. If the plaintiff or defendant is an official within a government agency, identify first the agency and then -the official, giving both name and title. - -(b) County of Residence. For each civil case filed, except U.S. plaintiff cases, enter the name of the county where the first listed plaintiff resides at the -time of filing. In U.S. plaintiff cases, enter the name of the county in which the first listed defendant resides at the time of filing. (NOTE: In land -condemnation cases, the county of residence of the "defendant" is the location of the tract of land involved.) - -(c) Attorneys. Enter the firm name, address, telephone number, and attorney of record. If there are several attorneys, list them on an attachment, noting - -in this section "(see attachment)". - -II. - -III. - -IV. - -V. - -Jurisdiction. The basis of jurisdiction is set forth under Rule 8(a), F.R.Cv.P., which requires that jurisdictions be shown in pleadings. Place an "X" -in one of the boxes. If there is more than one basis of jurisdiction, precedence is given in the order shown below. -United States plaintiff. (1) Jurisdiction based on 28 U.S.C. 1345 and 1348. Suits by agencies and officers of the United States are included here. -United States defendant. (2) When the plaintiff is suing the United States, its officers or agencies, place an "X" in this box. -Federal question. (3) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1331, where jurisdiction arises under the Constitution of the United States, an amendment -to the Constitution, an act of Congress or a treaty of the United States. In cases where the U.S. is a party, the U.S. plaintiff or defendant code takes -precedence, and box 1 or 2 should be marked. -Diversity of citizenship. (4) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1332, where parties are citizens of different states. When Box 4 is checked, the -citizenship of the different parties must be checked. (See Section III below; NOTE: federal question actions take precedence over diversity -cases.) - -Residence (citizenship) of Principal Parties. This section of the JS 44 is to be completed if diversity of citizenship was indicated above. Mark this -section for each principal party. - -Nature of Suit. Place an "X" in the appropriate box. If there are multiple nature of suit codes associated with the case, pick the nature of suit code -that is most applicable. Click here for: Nature of Suit Code Descriptions. - -Origin. Place an "X" in one of the seven boxes. -Original Proceedings. (1) Cases which originate in the United States district courts. -Removed from State Court. (2) Proceedings initiated in state courts may be removed to the district courts under Title 28 U.S.C., Section 1441. -Remanded from Appellate Court. (3) Check this box for cases remanded to the district court for further action. Use the date of remand as the filing -date. -Reinstated or Reopened. (4) Check this box for cases reinstated or reopened in the district court. Use the reopening date as the filing date. -Transferred from Another District. (5) For cases transferred under Title 28 U.S.C. Section 1404(a). Do not use this for within district transfers or -multidistrict litigation transfers. -Multidistrict Litigation – Transfer. (6) Check this box when a multidistrict case is transferred into the district under authority of Title 28 U.S.C. -Section 1407. -Multidistrict Litigation – Direct File. (8) Check this box when a multidistrict case is filed in the same district as the Master MDL docket. -PLEASE NOTE THAT THERE IS NOT AN ORIGIN CODE 7. Origin Code 7 was used for historical records and is no longer relevant due to -changes in statue. - -VI. - -Cause of Action. Report the civil statute directly related to the cause of action and give a brief description of the cause. Do not cite jurisdictional -statutes unless diversity. Example: U.S. Civil Statute: 47 USC 553 Brief Description: Unauthorized reception of cable service. - -VII. Requested in Complaint. Class Action. Place an "X" in this box if you are filing a class action under Rule 23, F.R.Cv.P. - -Demand. In this space enter the actual dollar amount being demanded or indicate other demand, such as a preliminary injunction. -Jury Demand. Check the appropriate box to indicate whether or not a jury is being demanded. - -VIII. Related Cases. This section of the JS 44 is used to reference related pending cases, if any. If there are related pending cases, insert the docket - -numbers and the corresponding judge names for such cases. - -Date and Attorney Signature. Date and sign the civil cover sheet. - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Contract -Code -110 - -Title -Insurance - -120 - -Marine - -130 - -Miller Act - -140 - -Negotiable Instrument - -150 - -Recovery of Overpayment & Enforcement -Judgment - -151 - -Medicare - -152 - -153 - -160 - -Recovery of Defaulted Student Loans -(Excludes Veterans) -Recovery of Overpayment of Veterans' -Benefits -Stockholders' Suits - -190 - -Other Contract - -195 - -Contract Product Liability - -Actions primarily alleging personal injury -or property damage caused by a defective -product should be classified under the -appropriate nature of suit code under -“TORTS.” -Franchise - -196 - -Description -Action alleging breach of insurance contract, tort claim, or other cause -related to an insurance contract, except for maritime insurance -contracts. -Action (Admiralty or Maritime) based on service, employment, -insurance or other contracts relating to maritime vessels and other -maritime contractual matters. -Action based on performance and payment bonds agreed to by -contractors on federal construction projects as required under the -Miller Act, 40 U.S.C. § 3131-3134. -Action relating to an agreement to pay a specific amount of money, -including promissory notes, loan agreements and checks. -Action to recover debt owed to the United States, including -enforcement of judgments, based on overpayments and restitution -agreements involving matters other than Medicare benefits, student -loans and veterans’ benefits. -Action relating to Medicare payments, including actions for payments of -benefits, to recover overpayments, and for judicial review of -administrative decisions. -Action to recover debt owed to the United States from defaulted -student loan. -Action relating to payments of veterans’ benefits, primarily including -actions to recover overpayments. -Action brought by stockholder(s) of a corporation (including both -stockholder derivative suits and direct actions based on plaintiff’s rights -as a stockholder), usually alleging claims based on contract and/or tort -law and/or fiduciary obligations. -Action primarily based on rights and obligations under a contract not -classifiable elsewhere under the specific natures of suit under -“Contract.” -Action concerning damages caused by a defective product, not primarily -involving personal injury or property damage, and based primarily on -breach of contract, breach of warranty, misrepresentation, and/or -violation of consumer protection laws. - -Action arising from a dispute over a franchise agreement, typically -alleging breach of contract, misrepresentation or unfair trade practices. - -Page 1 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Real Property - -Code -210 - -Title -Land Condemnation - -220 - -230 - -240 - -Foreclosure - -Rent Lease & Ejectment - -Torts to Land - -245 - -Tort Product Liability - -290 - -All Other Real Property - -Torts/Personal Injury - -Title -Airplane -(Excludes airplane product liability -claims) -Airplane Product Liability - -Description -Action by a governmental entity to take privately-owned real property -(land or buildings) for public use for compensation. -Action to enjoin foreclosure on real property by mortgage lender. - -Action for rental or lease payments owed on real property and/or to -eject a party occupying real property illegally. -Action alleging trespass to land, nuisance, contamination or other -unlawful entry on or interference with real property possessed by -another. -Action alleging harm by an unsafe product based on negligence, breach -of warranty, misrepresentation, and strict tort liability. -Action primarily based on unlawful conduct relating to real property -that cannot be classified under any other nature of suit. - -Description -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death from an air crash or -other occurrence involving an airplane. - -Code -310 - -315 - -320 - -330 - -340 - -345 - -350 - -355 - -360 - -362 - -365 - -367 - -368 - -Motor Vehicle - -Marine Product Liability - -Marine -(Excludes marine product liability claims) - -Assault, Libel & Slander -(Excludes a government employee) -Federal Employers' Liability - -Action alleging personal injury or death from an air crash or other -occurrence involving an airplane and caused by a defective product. -Action alleging intentional acts of assault, libel, trade libel or slander by -a private party. -Action for personal injury or wrongful death brought by a railroad -employee or his survivors under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act -(FELA), 45 U.S.C. § 51, et. seq. -Action (Admiralty and Maritime) alleging personal injury or death from -an accident involving a water vessel or harbor/dock facilities, including -suits brought under the Jones Act and the Limitation of Liability Act. -Action (Admiralty and Maritime) alleging personal injury or wrongful -death from an accident involving a water vessel or harbor/dock -facilities and caused by a defective product. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death from negligence -involving a motor vehicle but not caused by a defective product. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death involving a motor -vehicle and caused by a defective product. -Action primarily based on personal injury or death caused by -negligence or intentional misconduct, including suits brought against -the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act, and which cannot -be classified under any other nature of suit. -Action alleging personal injury or wrongful death caused by negligence -in medical care provided by a doctor or other health care professional. -Action alleging personal injury or death resulting from a defective -Personal Injury - Product Liability -product. -(Excludes a marine or airplane product) -Action alleging personal injury or death caused by a defective medical -Health Care/Pharmaceutical Personal -or pharmaceutical product. -Injury Product Liability -Asbestos Personal Injury Product Liability Action alleging personal injury or death caused by exposure to asbestos - -Personal Injury - Medical Malpractice - -Motor Vehicle Product Liability - -Other Personal Injury - -products. - -Page 2 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Personal Property - -Code -370 - -371 - -Title -Other Fraud -(Excludes any property that is not real -property) -Truth in Lending - -Actions relating to fraud or -misrepresentation in the transfer of real -property should be classified under -nature of suit 290, “All Other Real -Property,” or, if foreclosure is involved, -under nature of suit 220, “Foreclosure.” -Other Personal Property Damage - -380 - -385 - -Property Damage Product Liability - -Civil Rights - -Code - -440 - -441 - -442 - -443 - -445 - -446 - -Title -Other Civil Rights -(Excludes claims against corrections -officials) -Voting - -Employment - -Housing/Accommodations - -Americans With Disabilities - -Employment -Americans With Disabilities - Other - -448 - -Education - -Description -Action primarily based on fraud relating to personal property that -cannot be classified under any other nature of suit. - -Action alleging violation of the federal Truth in Lending Act arising from -consumer loan transactions involving personal property including -automobile loans and revolving credit accounts. - -Action primarily based on damage to personal property caused by -harmful conduct such as negligence, misrepresentation, interference -with business relationships or unfair trade practices. -Action alleging damage to personal property caused by a defective -product. - -Description - -Action alleging a civil rights violation other than the specific civil rights -categories listed below or a violation related to prison. Example: -Action alleging excessive force by police incident to an arrest. -Action filed under Civil Rights Act, 52 U.S.C. § 10101, and Voting Rights -Act, 52 U.S.C. § 10301 -Action filed under Age Discrimination in Employment Act 29:621:634, -Equal Employment Opportunity Act (Title VII) 42:2000E, Performance -Rating Act of 1950 5:4303 -Action filed under the Fair Housing Act (Title VII), 42 U.S.C. § 3601 & -3602. -Action of discrimination against an employee with disabilities of any -type in the work place, filed under 42 U.S.C. § 12117 -Action of discrimination against an individual with disabilities in areas -other than employment, filed under 42 U.S.C. § 12133 (exclusion or -discrimination in provision of services, programs or activities of a public -entity) or 42 U.S.C. § 12188 (public accommodations) -Action filed under the Individuals with Disabilities Educations Act, 20 -U.S.C. § 1401 and Title IX of the Education Amendment of 1972, 20 -U.S.C. § 1681 et seq. - -Page 3 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Prisoner Petitions -Habeas Corpus -Title -Alien Detainee - -Code -463 - -510 - -Motions to Vacate Sentence - -530 - -General - -535 - -Death Penalty - -Other -Prisoner Petitions - -Code -540 - -Title -Mandamus & Other - -550 - -Civil Rights - -555 - -Prison Condition - -560 - -Civil Detainee - Conditions of -Confinement (Excludes actions by alien -detainees) - -Description -Immigration habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. All cases filed -with this nature of suit code are restricted to case participants and -public terminals. Petition is filed by an alien detainee. -Action by a prisoner to vacate or modify a sentence imposed in federal -court, other than a death sentence, under 28 U.S.C. § 2255. -Action by a federal or state prisoner currently in custody challenging -the legality of confinement or other punishment. This includes claims -alleging illegalities that occurred in trial (for example, ineffective -assistance of counsel), sentencing (including fines and restitution -orders), or disciplinary proceedings in prison (for example, loss of good -time credits). Habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 or prisoner -habeas under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. -Action by a federal or state prisoner challenging a death sentence. - -Description -Action by prisoner currently in custody for a writ of mandamus to -compel action by a judge or government official relating to the -prisoner’s confinement, including conditions of confinement. This -category also includes any actions other than mandamus brought by a -prisoner currently in custody, whether or not it relates to his -confinement, if it is not classifiable under any other nature of suit -category under Prisoner Petitions (for example, action by prisoner to -recover property taken by the government in a criminal case). -Action by current or former prisoner alleging a civil rights violation by -corrections officials that is not related to a condition of prison life. -Action by current prisoner, or former prisoner or their families alleging -a civil rights, Federal Tort Claims Act, or state law claim with respect to -a condition of prison life, whether general circumstances or particular -episodes. Examples: inadequate medical care or excessive force by -prison guards. Includes non-habeas actions by alien detainees alleging -unlawful prison conditions. -Action by former prisoner who was involuntarily committed to a non- -criminal facility after expiration of his or her prison term alleging -unlawful conditions of confinement while in the non-criminal facility. -This category includes, for example, an action by a former prisoner -classified as a Sexually Dangerous Person or Sexually Violent Predator -alleging civil rights violations during his detention in a medical facility. - -Page 4 of 8 - - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) - -Forfeiture/Penalty - -Code -625 - -Title -Drug Related Seizure of Property 21 -U.S.C. § 881 - -Description -Action (Forfeiture) by which property itself is accused of wrongdoing -and is forfeited to the government as a result. - -690 - -Other - -Labor -Code -710 - -Title -Fair Labor -Standards Act (Non-Union) - -720 - -Labor/Management Relations (Union) - -740 - -Railway Labor Act - -Action primarily based on Acts or Bills that cannot be classified under -any other nature of suit, such as: Endangered Species Act, Federal -Hazardous Substance Act 15:1261, Game & Wildlife Act 15:256C et seq. -(Penalty), Federal Trade Commission Act 15:41-51 (Penalty), Federal -Coal Mine Health & Safety Act 30:801 et seq. (Penalty), Load Line Act -46:85-85G, McGuire Bill (Federal Fair Trade) 15:45L Penalty, Marihuana -Tax Act 50 STAT 551, Motorboat Act 46:526-526T, National Traffic & -Motor Vehicle Safety Act penalty 49:1655, Veterans' Benefit Act, Title -38 Penalty. - -Description -Action relating to non-union workplace related disputes filed under the -Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 201 including but not limited to -wage discrimination, paid leave, minimum wage and overtime pay. - -Action relating to disputes between labor unions and employers as well -as all petitions regarding actions of the Nation Labor Relations Board -(NLRB) - -Action relating to disputes filed under the Railway Labor Act, 45 U.S.C. -§ 151 including labor disputes, individual claims, and response to -sanctions. - -751 - -790 - -791 - -Family and Medical Leave Act - -Action filed under the Family Medical Leave Act, 29 U.S.C. § 2601 - -Other Labor Litigation - -Employee Retirement Income Security -Act - -Action primarily based on labor disputes not addressed by other NOS -codes (includes Labor/Management Reporting and Disclosure Act) -Action filed under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, 29 -U.S.C. § 1132 by individuals and labor organizations. - -Immigration - -Code -462 - -Title -Naturalization Application - -465 +3. -Other Immigration -Actions +4. -Description -Action seeking review of denial of an application for naturalization [8 -U.S.C. § 1447(b)] or alleging failure to make a determination regarding -an application for naturalization [8 U.S.C. § 1421(c)]. +Albany Herald, the local newspaper, lists apartments, houses, and +rooms for rent in the classified advertising section of the paper. The +ad will usually list the monthly rent as well as a phone number to call +for more information. +Bulletin boards and notices on campus: check classroom buildings for +notices and ads about apartments for rent. Many students looking for +roommates advertise in this manner. +The telephone directory: look under “Apartments” in the Yellow +Pages. +The Office of the International Student Advisor has listing of apartment +complexes in Albany, which lists such information as rental cost, size, +and distance from campus. + +25 + + RENT AND DEPOSITS +You will probably have to pay a deposit of two or three hundred dollars, plus +your first month’s rent before you can move into an apartment or rental house. +When you move out of the apartment you will get the deposit back if there has +been no damage to the apartment. You will also be required to sign a lease. A +lease is a legal contract that states the amount of time that you will live in the +apartment. Most leases are for one year. Once a lease is signed, you are legally +bound to live in the apartment, and you must pay the rent even if you decide +that you no longer want to live in the apartment. Do not sign any lease that you +do not understand. Be sure to check the dates of the lease carefully. Please +visit the International Student Advisor before you move off campus. He/she can +offer advice about apartments and assist you with interpreting leases. Please +note that if you lease an apartment in your name but also have roommates living +with you, you must be very careful about changing the name on the lease if you +move. If your name is on the lease, you are responsible for the payment of rent +even if you move out and allow other students to move into the apartment. If +you do not pay the rent, the landlord may take legal action against you. Please +be especially careful in situations where you share telephone and utility services +with other students. Never agree to have a lease or a utility bill placed in your +name unless you are certain no additional money is owed on the account. If you +change a lease or utility bill from another student’s name to yours, you will be +responsible for any money owed on the lease or account even if the charges +were billed before the account was placed in your name. + +DINING SERVICE +The University Dining Hall, which is under the supervision of the Director of Food +Services, provides nutritious and wholesome meals at a minimum cost to the +student. Meals are served in an ultra-modern facility, which includes a food court +consisting of the following concepts: Café Features, Wokery, Grill Works, Itza +Pizza, Deli Corner, Sweet Things, Salad Garden, Veggie and Drinks. The meals +are unlimited (all you can eat). The Dining Hall seating capacity is approximately +525 students. All boarding students must present proper University student +identification. Non-boarding students, faculty, staff and visitors must pay cash at +the cashier’s stand before being served. + +Meal Schedule + +Monday-Thursday +Breakfast +Lunch +Dinner +Friday +Breakfast +Lunch +Dinner + +Saturday & Sunday +Brunch + +7:00 a.m. – 8:45 a.m. +11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. +5:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. + +7:00 a.m. – 8:45 a.m. +11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. +4:30 p.m. – 6:30 p.m. + +10:30 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. + +26 + + Dinner + +4:00 p.m. − 5:30 p.m. + +(Schedule is subject to change without notice) + +LEGAL CONCERNS +LAWS +While you are in the U.S., you are subject to all of the laws and regulations, +which govern U.S. citizens. In addition, you are subject to immigration laws, +which define and limit your activities as a non-immigrant. Failure to comply with +immigration laws can lead to a request for your voluntary departure, or a forced +deportation from the U.S. + +EQUAL PROTECTION and DUE PROCESS +All persons in the U.S., regardless of citizenship, are entitled to the same +protection of the law and the same procedures of law enforcement. This means +that, with a few exceptions, you will be treated the same as an American citizen +in your relationship with the law enforcement agencies. Those few exceptions +involve immigration law. Consult the Office of the International Student Advisor +for clarification of this issue. + +ILLEGAL DRUGS +The possession, use, or sale of drugs or narcotics, including marijuana, hashish, +amphetamines, hallucinogens, barbiturates, cocaine, heroin, and a wide range of +other drugs, are serious offenses under Georgia law and immigration law. Those +who choose to use illegal drugs run the risk of expulsion from the university, +imprisonment, and/or deportation from the United States. + +ALCOHOL +The minimum legal age for drinking alcoholic beverages (beer, wine, liquor, etc.) +in the State of Georgia is 21. You cannot be served alcoholic beverages unless +you are 21 or older. You will be asked to present an identification card with your +photograph and your date of birth before you can purchase alcohol from a store +or enter a bar, nightclub, or other establishment that serves alcohol. Students +who are over age 18 but under 21 will be admitted, but these students are not +allowed to purchase alcohol. The police routinely search all nightclubs and bars +in Albany for students under age 21 who have consumed alcoholic beverages or +used false identification to enter the establishment. Students who are caught +are arrested, taken to jail, and fined. They may also face university disciplinary +measures. + +Driving a car after drinking alcoholic beverages is also illegal in Georgia, +regardless of age. Driving under the influence (DUI) of alcohol carries severe +penalties and can result in the loss of your driver’s license, heavy fines, +imprisonment, disciplinary action by the university, and/or deportation. NEVER +DRINK AND DRIVE. + +SMOKING + +27 + + Smoking has become socially unacceptable in many places. Smoking is not +permitted in Albany State University buildings (except dorm rooms). Smoking is +also forbidden in hospitals, many restaurants, and other public places. Always +ask permission of your companies before smoking. Never smoke in someone’s +home unless he or she smokes as well. + +MAIL +CAMPUS MAIL +Campus mail is a service provided by the university for mail going between +people and offices on the premises of the campus. To send a letter by campus +mail, clearly mark the office and person it should go to and write CAMPUS MAIL +in the upper right hand corner. No stamp is needed. Drop the letter in the +collection point at the post office or in your Department Office. + +POST OFFICES +The university post office can send materials in both domestic and overseas mail. +Overseas mail must be weighed and stamped according to weight. Domestic +mail requires standard postage of 44 cents per letter. Packages and letters +containing more than five sheets of paper usually require extra postage. Any +package weighing over 16 ounces may be mailed first class from the university +post office. Domestic mail also requires a zip code for delivery. This is a five- +letter code specific to the area the letter or package is being sent to. If you do +not know the zip code of the area you are mailing to, ask for a zip code directory +at the post office and look up the proper zip code. + +CHANGE OF ADDRESS +Students who move off campus or leave ASU for a vacation should fill out a U.S. +Postal Service Change of Address card, sign the card, and place it in a U.S +mailbox. By completing this card, you allow the postal service to automatically +forward your mail to your new address. There is no charge for this service. +Unfortunately, the Office of the International Student Advisor cannot forward +mail to students who have moved off campus. Please do not have your mail +sent to the Office of the International Student Advisor. You will also need to +complete an AR-11 form which you obtain in the International Office. + +ELECTRONIC MAIL +An electronic mail (e-mail) account is available to all ASU students, faculty, and +staff free of charge. All ASI students are expected to use their ASU Ram Mail +because that is the official mode of communication. If you need an account or +would like to learn more about this service, call the Office of Information +Technology at 229-430-4909. You can also use the Internet through ASU +website: www.asurams.edu. E-mail and the Internet are wonderful ways to +communicate with friends around the world at no expense to you. + +MONEY AND BANKING +BANKS +There are many banks located in Albany. Most of them have specially priced +services for ASU students. The Bank of America has an automated teller machine + +28 + + or ATM in the Reese Student Union building on lower campus. As with any other +service, you should determine which banking services are most important to you +and call the different banks to find out about prices and available services. + +CHECKING AND SAVING ACCOUNTS +All students should open checking and/or saving accounts at a local bank. It is +not wise to carry or keep large amounts of cash. Most local businesses will +accept checks from local banks only. + +It is important to know how much money is in your checking account at all +times. Do not write checks for more money than you have in your checking +account. Checks written for more than the amount in an account are returned +unpaid. You will have to pay a fine to the bank, to the business where you +wrote the check, and may be unable to write checks in the future. Writing checks +when you do not have enough money to cover the check is called “bouncing +checks.” Bouncing checks is a criminal offense punishable by imprisonment. A +checking account is a service. Charges for services vary from bank to bank. +Savings accounts allow you to deposit money safely in a bank and receive a +small amount of interest on the balance. Savings accounts require passbooks for +depositing and withdrawing money. Keep both your checkbook and your +passbook in a safe place and report it to the bank immediately if either document +is lost or stolen. + +CREDIT CARDS +Credit cards are available through most banks. They have high interest rates, +but are very easy to use. Credit cards can be used almost everywhere and are +billed on a monthly basis. The best way to use a credit card is to pay the entire +bill monthly; otherwise, your balance may get higher than you can pay. Many +students find it helpful to carry an international credit card such as Visa or +MasterCard. Purchases on these cards can be made in U.S. dollars while the bill +is sent to your home and is denoted in your home currency. These cards can +also be used at automated teller machines to withdraw cash. Be sure to inquire +about the transaction fees before you obtain a credit card. Often the use of +these cards is an inexpensive way to exchange currency. But the fees can +become expensive. Your student fees can also be paid by credit card +(MasterCard or Visa only). + +OTHER BANKING SERVICES OFFERED FOR FEES + +Cashier’s Check +Money Orders +Certified Checks +Travelers Checks +Safety deposit box rental for storing valuable items + +MONEY EXCHANGE +Foreign currency must be taken to a bank to be exchanged. All currency (except +Canadian) must be sent out of town by the local banks for exchange. There is a + +29 + + charge of about $10.00 for the transaction and a processing time of 3 to 6 +weeks. + +RECEIVING MONEY FROM HOME -Action (Immigration-related) that do not involve Naturalization -Applications or petitions for Writ of Habeas Corpus, such as complaints -alleging failure to adjudicate an application to adjust immigration -status to permanent resident. +1. -Page 5 of 8 +2. - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +By Mail +Tell your family to send numbered cashier’s check in U.S. +dollars, purchased from a bank in your country that has +business arrangement with a well-known U.S. bank. Make sure +that the check has a bank routing number on the bottom of the +check. + +By Telex +You may receive money from home by telex (wire). Wired +money generally arrives 5-10 days after it is sent from overseas. +It should be arranged through a local bank, and you should +have a checking or savings account established at the bank. +The receiving bank will charge about $12.00 as handling fee. It +is not possible to have money wired directly to your ASU +student account. + +Please be sure to request your funds from home well in advance of fee payment +deadlines. International transfers can often experience unexpected delays, so +you should plan ahead each semester. THERE IS NO FLEXIBITY IN FEE +PAYMENT DEADLINES. Please do not request an extension of the set fee +payment deadline. Failure to pay your student fees in a timely manner will result +in your having to return home. + +30 + + INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS +If English is not a student’s native language, if the student did not attend high +school in the United States, and if the student wishes to discuss taking the +Regents’ Test especially designed for International students, the student must +contact the Regents’ Test Director whose office is in 103 Simmons Hall (229-430- +4735 – flo.hill@asurams.edu). The local International Students’ Task Force +Committee has suggested that a student be considered for a special form of the +essay test after taking and failing the test at least once. There is no special test +for reading at this time; however, students may be given more time and may be +allowed to use their translation dictionaries. + +RELIGIOUS LIFE +Religion is a very important part of South Georgia culture. People will probably +invite you to visit their church and to take part in church sponsored social +activities. While these church services and activities can be very meaningful to +you, participation will not obligate you to join a church. Churches often attempt +to bring students into their church families by asking students to change their +belief to match the beliefs of the church members. If church members or clergy +make you feel uncomfortable about your religious belief or your values, feel free +tell them that you wish to maintain your own beliefs. If they cannot accept that, +find another church group! + +There are many churches located in the Albany area. Denominations include: +African-Methodist Episcopal, Apostolic, Assembly of God, Bahai, Baptist, Catholic, +Charismatic, Christian, Church of Christ, Church of God, Church of Jesus Christ of +Latter Days, Episcopal (Anglican), Holiness, Interdenominational, Jehovah +Witness, Lutheran, Nazarene, Pentecostal, Salvation Army, Seventh Day +Adventist, and Unitarian. All denominations are listed under “Churches” or +“Synagogues” in the Yellow Pages of the telephone book. + +SHOPPING +GROCERY STORES +All foods are located in one store. You will find fresh fruits, vegetables, canned +(tinned) goods, baby foods, meats, bread, cleaning supplies, paper products, and +frozen foods. Generally, grocery stores have lower prices than smaller stores. +There are several large grocery stores in Albany and some of them are within +walking distance of the University. You can order special items if you are +looking for ingredients not readily available in Albany stores. + +DRUGSTORES AND PHARMACIES +This is the only place where you can buy medicine that the doctor has ordered +for you. You can often buy many other things there as well. The most +convenient drugstore is CVS on Radium Springs Road, near the campus. Less +expensive pharmacies are located in discount stores and some grocery stores. + +31 + + DISCOUNT STORES +These are department stores where you find a large variety of things including +clothing, pharmacies, garden supplies, small appliance, paper products, linens, +and even some types of furniture. They often have lower prices and can be +wonderful places to see American people and products. Some of the local +discount stores include K-Mart, Wal-Mart, and Target. + +RESTAURANTS +Unless you are buying food, restaurant owners do not like for you to sit and +“take up space” from paying customers. You should leave money (a tip) on the +table for the waiter or waitress when you eat at a restaurant. The tip is usually +15%-20% of the total bill, depending on the quality of the service. Fast food +restaurants do not have waiters and waitresses. Do not leave a tip at this type +of restaurant. There are a number of commercial fast food restaurants around +the campus. Food can be ordered “for here” (to be eaten in the restaurant) or +“to go” (to be eaten at home). + +THE ALBANY MALL +The Albany Mall is a shopping center housing several dozen stores and +restaurants. It is located some miles west of the campus on Dawson Road. You +can buy almost anything you need in the Mall. Prices in these stores are usually +higher than the prices at Discount Stores, but the Mall is a great place to meet +people and experience American culture! + +OUTLET MALL +A large mall containing only manufacturer’s outlet stores is located many miles +south of Albany on Interstate 75. This mall has over 100 stores and is a good +place to shop because the prices are low while the quality of the merchandise is +high. + +Student Athlete + +Best practices For International Athlete Recruits (NCAA) +F-1 Visa and Issuance of SEVIS Form I-20 +International student-athletes who require an F-1 student visa are subject to +specific requirements regarding their admissions eligibility, financial ability and +academic status. Failure of students to follow appropriate regulations and +guidelines can result in severe difficulties with their immigration status with the +U.S. Department of Homeland Security. To avoid difficulties, the NCAA strongly +recommends that athletics staff meet with appropriate school officials (e.g., +international admissions officers, international student advisors) to gain an +understanding of the school’s policies and procedures that are in place to protect +international students and to maintain compliance with all immigration +regulations. + +32 + + IMPORTANT NOTE FOR ATHLETICS ADMINISTRATORS AND ADMISSIONS OFFICERS +Under no circumstances should an international student athlete be issued a Form +I-20 with the expectation of financial support from the athletics office before the +student has been certified as a final qualifier by the NCAA Eligibility Center or is +determined to be a partial qualifier in Division II. + +• Doing so opens the possibility for an international student who might not be +eligible for financial aid to obtain a visa and enter the United States without +having the sufficient funds to cover tuition and living expenses, as required by +immigration laws. + +Financial Ability + +• All F-1 visa students must submit appropriate documentation of financial +support before the school can issue the SEVIS Form I-20 [certificate of eligibility +for nonimmigrant (F-1) student status]. +• Generally the school’s office of recruitment and admissions office will have +information as to what constitutes appropriate documentation of financial +support. +• Athletics department staff members must understand that withdrawal of +athletics financial aid for an international student-athlete could result in severe +economic hardship for the student and could result in a violation of the student’s +immigration status. + +What Athletics Administrators Should Tell Student-Athletes +• Student-athletes who will be receiving financial aid from the athletics +department must understand that if the amount of aid is less than the +amount required for issuance of the I-20, then the student will need to +provide additional documentation of financial support. + +• Student-athletes should be informed of the true costs of attending the + +school and must understand the financial implications in the event of the +loss of financial support from athletics. + +• Although students athletes may receive some financial assistance through + +athletics students are responsible for purchasing their books for the +duration of the academic tenure. + +• Student-athletes must understand that if their scholarship is made + +unavailable for whatever reason (e.g., because the student-athlete did not +meet initial-eligibility requirement, they must have other means of +financial support. If sufficient finances are not available from other +sources, the student risks violation of immigration status and possible +deportation. + +SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS +A Social Security Number is a government identification number issued to all +residents of the United States. Most residents receive this number as children. +In the U.S., we do not carry passports or national ID cards. Instead, we use this +number and a driver’s license as our primary forms of identification for +employment records, taxation, opening bank accounts, university records and + +33 + + other business matters. All drivers’ licenses contain a color photograph of the +bearer as well as the current address and date of birth. + +For your admission to ASU, you were issued a student identification number +which has the same number of digits as the social security number. The +university uses this ID number for all of your university records. The number +also appears on your student identification card. While this number is sufficient +for your academic records, you will need to obtain a Social Security number +before you can work on campus. To obtain the number, you must complete an +application form and deliver it, along with a letter of verification from the ISA +and an offer letter from the person who is hiring you on letterhead, in person to +the Social Security Administration in Albany. There is no charge for Social +Security numbers. Call 1-800-772-1213 for more information. + +TAXES +Federal Law requires that foreign students pay income tax from sources within +the U.S. This income generally includes salary from any employment, on or off +campus, as well as scholarship money. Tax return is due on April 15 for the +previous year. In addition you may need to file a tax statement. If you have +concern about your tax obligation, you may wish to consult a certified public +accountant (CPA). The Internal Revenue Service is the branch of the federal +government responsible for income tax collection. This agency is often simply +called IRS. You can call the IRS directly at 1-800-829-1040 for additional +information. + +TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAMS +TELEPHONE +Telephone service in the U.S. is divided into two types: local and long-distance +(including international) service. Most people work with two different companies +to obtain telephone services: a local carrier for local service and long distance +carrier for long distance service. The local carrier for Albany is BellSouth. +Contact the company by calling 229-780-2355. You may need to pay a deposit +to begin your local service. For about $30.00 a month, you may have unlimited +telephone calls within the country. You will be billed monthly for this service. + +There are several local and long distance services in the U.S. Each company lays +claims to lowest telephone rates for long distance. You may want to talk to each +company to learn who can offer you the best deal. Rates usually depend on +where you call and when you call. To get the cheapest rate, you may find that +all three companies have special plans with many restrictions. Be sure to read +the details of the special plans. Be sure to ask for the rates for calling your +country. You can contact these companies by calling the numbers listed in the +local telephone book. Once you choose a company, they will provide you with +direct dialing from your home and a calling card, which you can use from any +phone. + +INFORMATION + +34 + + If you cannot find a number on-line, you may call “Information,” also called +“Directory Assistance” and the number is 1411. In order to use the information +service, you must know the name of the person or organization you wish to call +as well as the city they are located in. The number you dial for information +depends upon the area you wish to call. The telephone book also contains useful +information about how to use the telephone and place different kinds of calls. +The Yellow Pages found on-line contain listings of local businesses and can help +you locate services. + +TOLL FREE CALLING +Most numbers with an area code of 1-800 or 1-888 are toll free calls. This +means that there will be no charge for the call. Many businesses and services +have toll free numbers for customer use. You should use toll free numbers +whenever possible to keep your telephone bill low. + +OTHER ASPECTS OF TELEPHONE SERVICES +If you live off-campus and share a telephone number, be sure to have an +agreement about how the bill will be paid and whose name will appear on the +bill. The names and numbers of all telephone subscribes are published in the +BellSouth telephone book unless you request an unpublished number. Albany has +several “local exchanges.” This term refers to the first three digits of the +telephone number. You will see prefixes listed as 430, 431, 434, and 435, for +example. Be sure to give all seven digits of your number. If you are calling from +one phone on campus to another, you only need to dial the last four digits of the +number. Many students today buy pre-paid cell phones. + +TELEGRAMS +Letters or money may be sent both within the U.S. and internationally through +Western Union by calling their toll-free number 1-800-325-6000. Mailgram is also +available through Western Union and is less expensive than telegrams. To send +a Mailgram, call Western Union at 1-800-325-6000. MoneyGram provides similar +services as Western Union. Their toll free number is 1-800-926-9400. + +FAX +Faxes may be sent or received through the fax services offered by some +companies in Albany. You will be charged for this service. For international +faxes, students should use Mailboxes, etc. at 229-434-1133 or 229-432-2230. +Unfortunately, the high cost of international and long distance faxes prohibits the +Office of the International Student Advisor or the University from sending +personal faxes for students. + +TESTING +The Albany State University Computer-based Testing Center (Department of +Counseling, Testing and Disability Services), located on the first floor in ACAD +195, administers and prepares students for several national computer-based +tests periodically throughout the year. The GRE, GMAT, MAT, MCAT, LSAT, +PCAT, and TOEFL are a few of the tests administered by the center. National test +scores are required for admission to U.S. graduate schools. These tests have + +35 + + standard fees and deadlines for enrollment. For information about a test, call +the Computer-based Testing office at 229- 430-1631. To sign up for a test, visit +the Division of Student Affairs and pick up an application. + +TRANSPORTATION +TRANSPORTATION IN ALBANY +Albany has a public transportation system. In emergencies, you can hire a taxi +(cab). Companies offering taxi services are listed under “Taxicabs” in the +Albany telephone book. Be sure and ask how much you will be charged before +hiring a taxi. Some students purchase bicycles for transportation. Cyclists must +ride on the roadways, as there are no separate bicycle paths. If you choose to +ride a bicycle, you must be very careful and watch out for cars. American drivers +are not accustomed to cyclists on the road, be sure to lock up your bike when +you are not using it. To travel outside Albany, you must go by bus or airplane. -Bankruptcy +BUS TRANSPORTATION +The Greyhound Bus Lines station in Albany is located at 300 Oglethorpe Blvd. +Call 1-800-231-2222 for nation-wide information or 229-432-0511 for local +terminal information. -Code -422 +AIR TRANSPORTATION +Albany has an airport located south of town. Service is limited to several daily +flights to Atlanta, where connecting flights are available to other cities. Call 229- +430-5175 for schedules. -Title -Appeal 28 USC § 158 +TRAVEL AGENTS +Travel agents will help you make travel arrangements for a small fee. They +often save you money by finding the lowest rates available to your destination. +Look in the Yellow Pages under “Travel Agencies”. Or you may book your tickets +online using a credit card at the airlines website. (e.g. www.delta.com) -423 +INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL +If you know that you will return to your country during a school vacation, you +should try to plan international travel 2 or 3 months in advance. The best rates +for international travel are obtained by making reservations early. Also, all +students are eligible for discounted airfares through an organization called +Council Travel. To obtain these special fares, you must have an international +student ID card. These cards can be purchased for $20 from the Office of the +International Student Advisor or local travel agents. These cards also qualify the +bearer for discounts at museums and other tourist attractions. If you have +questions about international travel, you should speak with the staff at the Office +of the International Student Advisor or experienced travelers from your country. -Withdrawal of Reference 28 USC § 157 +36 -Property Rights -Title -Copyright + CAMPUS CONTACTS -Code -820 +Quick Reference -Patent +Information -Patent – Abbreviated New Drug -Application (ANDA) +Office -Trademark +Phone Number -830 +Advising and Immigration -835 +Office of Int’l Student Advisor -840 +Meal Plan -880 +Food Services -Description -All appeals of previous bankruptcy decisions filed under -28 U.S.C. § 158 -Action held in bankruptcy court requesting withdrawal under the -provisions of 28 U.S.C. § 157 +General Info (Switchboard) -Description -Action filed in support or to dispute a copyright claim. +Facilities Management -Action filed in support or to dispute a patent claim. +Graduate Studies -Action filed in support or to dispute a patent claim involving an -Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA). These cases are also known -as “Hatch-Waxman” cases. -Action filed in support or to dispute a trademark claim +Graduate School -Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (DTSA) +Residence Life (Housing) -Action filed in support or to dispute a trade secret misappropriation +Student Affairs -Social Security -Title -HIA (1395ff) +Mail delivery services for on-campus students -Code -861 +Post Office -862 +Parking Permits -Black Lung (923) +Public Safety -863 +229-430-7075 -DIWC/DIWW (405(g)) +229-430-4750 -864 +229-430-4600 -865 +229-430-5118 -SSID Title XVI +229-430-4741 -RSI (405(g)) +229-430-4745 -Federal Tax Suits +229-430-4711 -Code -870 -871 +Personal & Counseling -Title -Taxes (U.S. Plaintiff or Defendant) -IRS-Third Party 26 USC 7609 +Counseling, Testing & Disability Services -Description -Action filed with regard to social security benefits associated with -Health Insurance Part A Medicare + 229- 430-4667 -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided for those -who contracted Black Lung or their beneficiaries +Reporting Theft or Crime -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided to disabled -individuals: worker or child, or widow +Public Safety -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided to -Supplemental Security Income Disability under Title XVI -Action filed with regard to social security benefits provided for -Retirement, Survivor Insurance under 42 U.S.C. § 405 +Admission Status -Description -Action filed under the Internal Revenue Code (General) -Action filed under the Internal Revenue Code - Tax Reform Act of 1976 -(P.L. 94-455) Third Party +Admissions Office -Page 6 of 8 +Student Activities - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +Student Affairs -Other Statutes -Title -False Claims Act +Transcripts (to be sent from ASU) -Code -375 +Registrar’s Office -376 +Tuition Payment -Qui Tam (31 U.S.C. § 3729(a)) +Business Office -400 +229-430-4711 -State Reapportionment +229-430-4646 -410 +229-430-4739 -Antitrust +229-430-4638 -430 +229-430-4610 -450 +37 -460 + SERVICES FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS -470 + Orientation sessions and workshops for new students. + Liaison with the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for +all of your immigration documents. We will help you with filing for +practical training, transfer of schools, and replacement of lost +documents. WE are your source for maintaining your immigration +status. -480 + Counseling and referral services. Personal and cross-cultural -485 +counseling is available on a confidential basis to all students. If you +would like to talk to someone, call the International Student Advisor +(ISA) at 229-430-4721 to make an appointment. If necessary, you +may be referred elsewhere for help. -Banks and Banking + Information. If you do not know what to do, to whom to talk, or +where to find ANYTHING, the Office of the International Student +Advisor can help. -Commerce + Letters of certification for government loans, money exchange, re- +entry into the U.S., invitations to visit the U.S., and other official +documents are available at the office. -Deportation + Information about Albany State University International Student -Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt -Organizations -Consumer Credit +Association (ASUISA): ASUISA annually elects new student officers, +and sponsors activities throughout the year, by and for international +students. -Telephone Consumer Protection Act -(TCPA) + Other activities for all Global Programs students such as International -490 +Festival in November, picnics, coffee/tea hour, and the Cultural +Exchange Club/Global Ambassadors. -Cable/Satellite TV +38 -850 + CHECK LISTS -Securities/Commodities/Exchange +ANNUAL CHECKLIST -890 +• Renew passport if necessary (six months before expiration). -Other Statutory Actions +• File income tax returns if necessary (between January 1 and -891 +April 15). -Agricultural Acts +• Extend temporary stay with sponsor and with the -893 +International Advisor for an extended I-20 if necessary (30 +days before expiration). -Environmental Matters +PERIODIC CHECKLIST -Description -Action filed by private individuals alleging fraud against the U.S. -Government under 31 U.S.C. § 3729. -Action brought under the False Claims Act by private persons (also -known as "whistleblowers") on their own behalf and on behalf of the -United States to recover damages against another person or entity that -acted fraudulently in receiving payments or property from, or avoiding -debts owed to, the United States Government, 31 U.S.C. § 3730 -Action filed under the Reapportionment Act of 1929 Ch. 28, 46 Stat. 21, -2 U.S.C. § 2a. -Action brought under the Clayton Act 15 U.S.C. § 12 - 27 alleging -undue restriction of trade and commerce by designated methods that -limit free competition in the market place amongst consumers such as -anti-competitive price discrimination, corporate mergers, interlocking -directorates or tying and exclusive dealing contracts. -Action filed under the Federal Home Loan Bank Act 12:1421-1449, -Home Owners Loan Act 12:1461 or Federal Reserve Acts 12:142 et seq. -Action filed under the Interstate Commerce Acts 49:1 et seq., 49:301 +• Report changes of address (within 10 days) to the Office of +the International Student Advisor and the Office of the +Registrar. This is required by law. So is your email +address and your telephone number. -Action filed under the Immigration Acts (Habeas Corpus & Review) -8:1101/18:1546 -Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization Act, RICO 18:1961-1968 +• Report any change of marital status, or if your family has -Action filed under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. 1681n or -15 U.S.C. 1681o, and the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, -15 U.S.C. § 1692k -Action filed under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act 47 U.S.C. § -227 +joined you in the U.S., to the International Student Advisor. -Action filed involving unauthorized reception of cable/satellite TV -service under 47 U.S.C. § 553 (unauthorized reception of cable/satellite -TV), or 47 U.S.C. § 605 (e)(3) (unauthorized use or publication of a -communication) -Action filed under Small Business Investment Act 15:681, Securities -Exchange Act 15:78, Securities Act 15:77, Investment Advisers Act -15:80B(1-21) -Action primarily based on Statutes that cannot be classified under any -other nature of suit, such as: Foreign Agents Registration Act 22:611- -621, Klamath Termination Act 25:564-564W-L, Federal Aid Highway Act -23:101-142, Federal Corrupt Practices Act 2:241-256, Federal Election -Campaign Act, Highway Safety Act 23:401 Immigration & Nationality -Act 8:1503, Natural Gas Pipeline Safety Act 49:1671-1700, -Naturalization Acts 8:1421/18:911, 1015, 1421, et seq., 3282 or Federal -Aviation Act 49:1301 et seq. -Action filed under the Federal Crop Insurance Act 7:1501-1550, -Commodity Credit Corporation Act 15:713A-L & 4. -Action filed under Air Pollution Control Act 42:1857-57L, Clean Air Act -42:1857:57L, Federal Environment Pesticide Control Act, Federal -Insecticide, Fungicide & Rodenticide Act 7:135, Federal Water Pollution -Control Act 33:1151 et seq., Land & Water Conservation Fund Act -16:4602,460 1-4, Motor Vehicle Air Pollution Control Act 42:1857F-1-8, +• Complete registration for Student Health Insurance every -Page 7 of 8 +semester. - Civil Nature of Suit Code Descriptions -(Rev. 10/20) +• -National Environmental Policy Act 42:4321, 4331-35G, 4341-47, River & -Harbor Act penalty 3:401-437, 1251. +If leaving the U.S. temporarily, have 1-20 or DS-2019 +signed by a Designated School Official and check visa +validity. -Other Statutes (Continued) -Title -Freedom of Information Act -Arbitration +• Check in with International Student Advisor at the beginning +of each semester and schedule appointments periodically. +Always bring all of your documents when you come. -Code -895 -896 +Information from Handbook is from the following websites. +www.travel.state.gov/visa (U.S. Department of State) +www.ice.gov (Department of Homeland Security) +www.uscis.gov (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) +www.ncaa.com (National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA)) -899 +39 -Administrative Procedure Act/Review or -Appeal of Agency Decision - -950 + Office of the International Student Advisor +Sue Ann Balch, J.D. +205 Reese Hall Lower East Campus, 504 College Drive +(229) 430-7075 (Office) +(229) 434-7106 (Fax) +Sueann.balch@asurams.edu (email address) -Constitutionality of State Statutes - -Description -Action filed under the Freedom of Information Act 5:552. -Action involving actions to confirm or modify arbitration awards filed -under Title 9 of the U.S. Code. -Action filed under the Administrative Procedures Act, 5 U.S.C. § 701, or -civil actions to review or appeal a federal agency decision. - -Action drawing into question the constitutionality of a federal or state -statute filed under (Rule 5.1). Rule 5.1 implements 28 U.S.C. §2403. - -Note: The statutes listed above are not all-inclusive, and other statues might be applicable to each nature of suit. - -Statutes that are included in the descriptions should be viewed as examples. - -Page 8 of 8 +40 diff --git a/q41/random_k4/random_2.md b/q41/random_k4/random_2.md index 50244c5de69c4368bc06c4f2d7f73d0fd691d0c9..3b75761d91384b6a83e0a670ace4d8a80c4f2471 100644 --- a/q41/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q41/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,1142 +1,605 @@ -| | BLAST: | | Benchmarking | | | | LLMs | with ASP-based | | Structured | | Testing | | | | -| --- | ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | ManuelAlejandroBorrotoSantana1∗, | | | | | EricaCoppolillo1,2∗, | | | | | | | | -FrancescoCalimeri1,3,4, GiuseppeManco1, SimonaPerri3, FrancescoRicca3 -1UniversityofCalabria,Rende,Italy -2ICAR-CNR,Rende,Italy -3ArtificialIntelligenceLAB,DeMaCS,UniversityofCalabria,Rende,Italy -4DLVSystem,Rende,Italy -| | | | | name.surname | | | @unical.it, | name.surname | | @icar.cnr.it | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | { | | } | | { | } | | | | | | | -6202 rpA 42 ]OL.sc[ 1v60322.4062:viXra Abstract Clingo(Gebseretal.,2016)andDLV(Alvianoetal.,2017). -| | | | | | | | | ASP as | fully declarative | | paradigm | has | been | successfully | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -LargeLanguageModels(LLMs)havedemonstratedremark- -| | | | | | | | | employed | in both | academic | | research | and industrial | | appli- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -ableperformanceacrossabroadspectrumoftasks,including -| | | | | | | | | cations, particularly | | in | complex | domains | (e.g., | scheduling, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -naturallanguageunderstanding,dialoguesystems,andcode -| | | | | | | | | configuration, | robotics, | | workforce | planning, | | decision | sup- | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -| generation. | Despiteevidentprogress,lessattentionhasbeen | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | port) (Erdem, | Gelfond, | | and | Leone, | 2016; | Falkner | et al., | -paidtotheireffectivenessinhandlingdeclarativeparadigms -suchasAnswerSetProgramming(ASP),todate. Inthispa- 2018). Inrecentyearssubstantialefforthasbeendevotedto -perweintroduceBLAST:Thefirstdedicatedbenchmarking developing programming environments and tools that sup- -methodologyandassociateddatasetforevaluatingtheaccu- portthecreationofASPspecifications,includingadvanced -racy of LLMs in generating ASP code. BLAST provides editors, debuggers, testing frameworks, and utilities (Al- -a structured evaluation framework featuring two novel se- viano,Cirimele,andReiners,2023;Hahnetal.,2023;Feb- -mantic metrics tailored to ASPcode generation. The paper braro,Reale,andRicca,2011;Busoniuetal.,2013;Calimeri -presentstheresultsofanempiricalevaluationinvolvingten -etal.,2018). -well-establishedgraph-relatedproblemsfromtheASPlitera- -Motivation.Despitetheseadvancements,writingASPcode -tureandadiversesetofeightstate-of-the-artLLMs. -| | | | | | | | | remains often | challenging, | | especially | | for newcomers | | with- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | out a solid | background | | in logic | and | mathematics. | | In this | -Introduction -| | | | | | | | | context, | LLMs | represent | a promising | | avenue | for | support- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | -Large Language Models (LLMs) (Zhao, Zhou, and et al., ing,andevenautomating,ASPcoding. Recentstudieshave -| | | | | | | | | highlighted | significant | | limitations | in | the ability | of | general- | -| ----------- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | -| 2025) have | been | showing | remarkable | | performance | | across | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | purpose | LLMs to | generate | correct | and | semantically | | sound | -| a broad | spectrum | of | tasks, | including | natural | language | un- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | ASP programs | (Coppolillo | | et | al., 2024). | At | the same | time, | -| derstanding | (Qin | et | al., 2024), | dialogue | | systems | (Ou et | | | | | | | | | -al., 2024), and code generation (Jiang et al., 2024). More otherlinesofresearch,includingapproachesspecificallytai- -recently, some efforts have been made to encompass ad- lored to ASP encoding demonstrate that the overall direc- -| | | | | | | | | tion is viable | and | promising | (Ishay, | Yang, | and | Lee, | 2023a; | -| ------------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | --------------- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | -------------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ---- | ------ | -| vanced | reasoning, | knowledge | | representation, | | and | logical | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Borroto, | Kareem, | andRicca,2024;Coppolilloetal.,2024; | | | | | | -| formalisms | (Borroto, | | Kareem, | and | Ricca, | 2024; | Lippolis | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Schraderetal.,2025). | | | However,thefieldstilllackssystem- | | | | | -| et al., 2025; | Valmeekam | | et | al., 2025; | Smirnov | et | al., 2024; | | | | | | | | | -aticevaluations,standardizedbenchmarks,andwell-defined -Coppolilloetal.,2024).Inthiscontext,whileseveralbench- -marks have been proposed to assess LLM performance on metricsforrigorouslyassessingtheASP-codingcapabilities -ofLLMsand,moregenerally,ofanyautomaticapproach. -| imperative | and | web-oriented | | programming | | languages | (e.g., | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -| | | | | | | | | Contributions. | | To fill | this gap, | we | introduce | BLAST, | a | -| C++, Java, | HTML) | | (Ernst | and Bavota, | 2022; | Peng | et al., | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | benchmarking | methodology | | specifically | | designed | | to assess | -2023;Dakheletal.,2023),farlessattentionhasbeengiven -todeclarativeparadigmssuchasAnswerSetProgramming the accuracy of LLMs in generating ASP code. BLAST -(ASP)(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011;Gelfondand provides a structured evaluation framework that measures -| | | | | | | | | program | quality | through | two | novel metrics | | specifically | de- | -| ---------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | -| Lifschitz, | 1991), | despite | some | recent | initial | efforts | (Bor- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | signed for | ASP | code | generation. | The | methodology | | en- | -roto,Kareem,andRicca,2024;Ishay,Yang,andLee,2023a; -| | | | | | | | | compasses | both | evaluation | breadth | (covering | | a diverse | set | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -Coppolilloetal.,2024;Schraderetal.,2025). -| | | | | | | | | ofproblems), | anddepth(testingrobustnessacrossmultiple | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rootedinlogicprogrammingandnonmonotonicreason- -ing, ASP is well-suited for modeling and solving complex natural-language paraphrases of each problem). Crucially, -BLASTimposesnoguidanceorsyntacticconstraintsonin- -| AIproblems(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011). | | | | | | | Over | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | --------- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ----------- | ------------ | ------ | -| | | | | | | | | put/outputformatsfortheevaluatedmodels. | | | | | | Moreover,ex- | | -| the years, | ASP | became | increasingly | | adopted | | for its ex- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | isting procedures | | mostly | rely | on manual | evaluations | | of the | -| pressive | language | and | the | availability | of | efficient | and re- | | | | | | | | | -automatedencodingoutcomes(Borroto,Kareem,andRicca, -| liable solvers | | (Gebser, | Maratea, | and | Ricca, | 2020), | notably | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | 2024;Coppolilloetal.,2024), | | | | resultingintime-consuming | | | | -∗Equalcontribution. and potentially inconsistent assessments. In contrast, we - -propose a systematic approach that automates the evalua- IDE.Wenotethat(Schwitter,2018)developedaCNLcalled -tionprocess,reducinghumaninterventionwhileimproving PENGASP for specifying and verbalizing ASP programs, -scalability,reliabilityandreproducibility. while(Carusoetal.,2024)introducedCNL2ASP,anexten- -We assess BLAST via an experimental study that tack- sivepublicly-availabletoolforconvertingcontrollednatural -lestenwell-knowngraphproblemsfromtheASPliterature languageintoASPprograms. -usingapoolofeightstate-of-the-artLLMs. -Themaincontributionofthepresentworkcanbesumma- -rizedasfollows: ASP and LLMs. Powerful language tools such as LLMs -• We release a benchmark dataset with ten graph-related have been exploited in conjunction with the ASP formal- -| | | | | | | | | ism in several | | ways. | (Nye et | al., 2021) | introduced | | a dual- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -problemstobeencodedinASP. -| | | | | | | | | system | model | based | on GPT-3, | which | generates | | semantic | -| ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | ----- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | -| • We propose | two | novel | evaluation | methods | | to automati- | | | | | | | | | | -parsersfromnaturallanguagesentencesandintegratesthem -| cally assess | the | quality | of the | generated | programs. | | Both | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | ----- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | with reasoning | | modules. | In | a similar | vein, | (Yang, | Ishay, | -| approaches | operate | without | imposing | | any | constraints | on | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | and Lee, | 2023) | proposed | that | LLMs | like | GPT-3 | can work | -theLLM’sinputoroutputformat,makingthesystemro- -asfew-shotsemanticparsers,transformingnaturallanguage -busttovariationsandrenamingofinputandoutputpred- -intologicalformsforASPwithoutnecessitatingdistinctre- -icatesymbols. -| | | | | | | | | trainingfordiversequestion-answeringtasks. | | | | | | (Ishay,Yang, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -• Weevaluateeightstate-of-the-artLLMs,fromfivediffer- -| | | | | | | | | and Lee, | 2023b) | utilized | LLMs | with | prompt | engineering | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -entfamilies,byconsideringtheoriginalproblemdescrip- to obtain ASP solutions for logic puzzles, leveraging the -tionalongwithparaphrasedversions,toassessthemodel logic puzzle dataset from (Mitra and Baral, 2016). (Ka- -flexibilityininterpretinghuman-likecraftedprompts. -| | | | | | | | | reem et | al., 2024) | introduced | | LLM2LAS, | | which | combines | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -Forthesakeofreproducibility,thecompleteexperimental LLMswithILASP(Law, Russo, andBroda,2020)tolearn -setup,includingcodeandevaluationdata,ismadepublicly commonsenseknowledgefromstory-basedQ&A,enabling -available.1 the system to generalize with minimal examples and effec- -| | | | | | | | | tively answer | | unseen | questions. | Further, | | the effective | use | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -RelatedWork of LLMs in combination with ASP to perform a number -| | | | | | | | | of natural | language | understanding | | | tasks | has been | explored | -| --------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | -| Automatic | Code | Synthesis. | | The advantages | | of automat- | | | | | | | | | | -andimplementedintheSTARframework(Rajasekharanet -| ing code | synthesis | are | well-recognized | | in | the | litera- | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | al.,2023). | Baueretal.(2024)proposedNSGRAPH,anap- | | | | | | | -ture(ErnstandBavota,2022;Kalliamvakou,2022;Penget -proachthatintegratesvisionmodules,LLM-basedsemantic -al.,2023;Dakheletal.,2023),andautomatedprogramcom- -parsing,andASPreasoningforVisualGraphQuestionAn- -| position tools | now | support | nearly | all mainstream | | program- | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | swering, | where | LLMs | extract | ASP | predicates | from | natural | -| ming languages | | (Chen, | Tworek, | and et | al., 2021). | | In this | | | | | | | | | -languagequestionsthatarethenprocessedbyanASPsolver. -| area, Large | Language | | Models | (LLMs) | play | a central | role, | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -BeyondASP,Voboril,Ramaswamy,andSzeider(2025)pro- -andtheirperformancehasbeenextensivelycomparedinthe -| | | | | | | | | posed StreamLLM, | | an | approach | | that leverages | | LLMs to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | -literature(Xuetal.,2022;Wangetal.,2023),whilealsothe -| | | | | | | | | generate | and validate | | streamlining | | constraints | in | MiniZinc | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -positiveimpactoffine-tuningmodelsforcodegenerationof -models,achievingsubstantialspeedupsacrossmultiplecon- -imperativeprogrammingisestablished(Maetal.,2024). -| | | | | | | | | straint satisfaction | | benchmarks. | | (Ren | et | al., 2025) | intro- | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | -| Inthecontextofdeclarativeprogramming, | | | | | | awidelyrec- | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | duced a | benchmark | focused | | on evaluating | | the ASP | solving | -ognizedresearchobjectiveistocreatetoolsthatstreamline -| | | | | | | | | abilities | of LLMs | (i.e., | entailment, | | verification | | and com- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -andautomatethedevelopmentofASPprograms,thusbridg- -| | | | | | | | | putation | of answer | sets). | In | contrast, | BLAST | focuses | on | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | -ingthegapbetweennaturallanguagespecificationsandASP -sourcecode(ErdemandYeniterzi,2009;FangandTompits, the task of generating ASP code. (Borroto, Kareem, and -| | | | | | | | | Ricca, 2024) | presented | | the | NL2ASP | tool, | that | constructs | -| ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ---------- | -| 2017; Schwitter, | | 2018; | Caruso | et al., 2024). | | Early propos- | | | | | | | | | | -ASPprogramsfromnaturallanguagespecificationsthrough -| als focused | on | automating | the | resolution | of | logic | puzzles | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | a two-step | architecture. | | NL2ASP | | works | by translating | the | -presentedinsimplifiedEnglishbytranslatingtheirdescrip- -NLspecificationsintoCNLstatements,whicharethencon- -| tions into | ASP | (Baral | and Dzifcak, | 2011), | | employing | λ- | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -calculus and probabilistic combinatorial categorical gram- verted into ASP code using the CNL2ASP tool. NL2ASP -| | | | | | | | | was implemented | | using | well-known | | models | for neural | ma- | -| ------------ | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ----------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ----- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | ---------- | ---- | -| mars. Later, | several | efforts | have | been | spent | in the | devel- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | chine translation | | (NMT) | and | demonstrated | | promising | per- | -| opment of | Controlled | | Natural | Languages | (CNLs) | | (Kuhn, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | formance. | Morerecently,(Coppolilloetal.,2024)provides | | | | | | | -2014)forASPprograms;CNLsrepresentsubsetsoffullnat- -afirstevaluationofLLMsperformanceinencodingsimple, -urallanguages,featuringrestrictedgrammarandvocabulary. -coreASPprograms,furthershowingthatLLMsarenotgood -| Among them, | the | BIOQUERYCNL | | (Erdem | | and Yeniterzi, | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | atASPcoding, | | butfine-tuningcanbebeneficial. | | | | | However, | -2009)definesthegrammaticalstructureofaCNLandalgo- -nobenchmarkormethodologyforsystematicassessmentof -| rithm for | transpiling | queries | into | ASP; | (Fang | and Tompits, | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | ----------- | ------- | --------------- | ---- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | --------------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | | LLM in | the general | ASP | coding | task | is | provided | (Coppo- | -| 2017) introduced | | a CNL | approach | for | ASP | that leverages | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | lillo et al., | 2024). | Building | | on the | potential | of fine-tuning, | | -| LANA annotations, | | that | was implemented | | in | the SeaLion | | | | | | | | | | -(Schraderetal.,2025)introducedanASP-solver-in-the-loop -1https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ frameworkthatimprovesLLM-basedASPcodegeneration -LLMs-ASP-Benchmark-DFC3/ forcombinatorialproblemsbyusingdirectsolverfeedback - -to curate data for supervised fine-tuning and to further im- Input -prove robustness through a solver-guided search that in- ASP -Target LLM -cludesbest-of-Nsampling. -Predicate -EvaluationBenchmarks. Asubstantialbodyofliterature ASP Generation Matcher -provides benchmarking datasets and test suites tailored to ASP -{ ... } -evaluating LLMs on imperative (e.g., Python, C++, Java) ASP ASP -{ ... } Testing -and web-oriented programming languages (e.g., HTML, Paraphraser -ASP -CSS,JavaScript)suchas(Xuetal.,2025;Shah, Genc, and { ... } -Araci,2025;Duetal.,2024;Chen,Tworek,andetal.,2021; -Dingetal.,2023;Liu,Xu,andMcAuley,2023). Compara- Figure1: Schemeoftheoverallproposedframework. Inputcon- -sists of the textual specification of the problem, the target LLM -tively,wearguethatmuchlessattentionhasbeendevotedto -to be evaluated, and the correct (gold) ASP program. The ASP -declarativeprogrammingparadigms. -Generationmodulecomprises: theparaphraser, anLLMwhich -A first benchmark for automatic translation from natural -paraphrasestheoriginalproblemdescriptioninmorehuman-styled -language to ASP was introduced by Borroto, Kareem, and -texts; andthepredicatematcher, anLLMwhichmapsthepredi- -Ricca (2024). However, it primarily focuses on controlled catesofthegeneratedprogramstotheonesofthegoldprogram. -naturallanguage(Carusoetal.,2024)andfeaturesinputsen- Thepredicatemappingsandthegoldencodingarefinallyprovided -tenceswithlimitedfluency. totheASPTestingmodule,whichperformstheevaluation. -Recently, Ren et al. (2025) proposed a methodology -to assess whether state-of-the-art LLMs can solve pro- -gramscodedinASP,comparingtheircapabilitiestostandard answersets. Ratherthanpresentingaformalintroductionto -solvers. However, their goal (computing answer sets with thelanguage, weprovidearepresentativeexampletohigh- -LLMs)isdifferentfromours(testingLLMscodingability). lightitsexpressivepower: theclassical3-colorabilityprob- -Tothebestofourknowledge,noexistingbenchmarken- lem, which requires assigning one of three colors to each -ables systematic automatic evaluation of LLMs ability to nodeofanundirectedgraphsuchthatadjacentnodesreceive -generateASPprograms. Thisworkaddressesthisgap. differentcolors. -The following ASP encoding captures this specification. -Preliminaries The input graph (nodes and edges) and the available col- -ors are represented via facts. A choice rule assigns exactly -Large Language Model. A Large Language Model -onecolortoeachnode,andanintegrityconstrainteliminates -(LLM) is a function f that stochastically maps an input -coloringsinwhichadjacentnodessharethesamecolor: -token sequence x = [x ,...,x ] to an output sequence -1 n -y = [y 1 ,...,y m ],withx V∗ andy W∗,whereV and col(red). col(green). col(black). node(1..4). -∈ ∈ -W are token vocabularies. Formally, f defines the condi- edge(1,2). edge(4,2). edge(1,3). -tionalprobabilityP (y x),fromwhichyissampled,captur- -ing the structure and s | emantics of natural language. LLMs 1 { colored(X,C) : col(C) } 1 :- node(X). -typically adopt the Transformer encoder-decoder architec- :- edge(X,Y), colored(X,C), colored(Y,C). -ture(Vaswanietal.,2017).Theinputtokensarefirstembed- -ASP also provides constructs for optimization via weak -ded into dense vectors encoding contextual and positional -constraints, which allow specifying preferences among an- -information. These embeddings pass through the Trans- -swer sets. For instance, to minimize the number of nodes -former: the encoder applies self-attention and feedforward -assignedthecolorred: -layerstomodeldependencieswithintheinput,whilethede- -coder combines masked self-attention, encoder-decoder at- -:∼colored(X,red). [1@1,X] -tention,andfeedforwardtransformationstogenerateoutputs -tokenbytoken. Thedecoderoutputsaprobabilitydistribu- Thisexampleillustratesthedeclarativenatureandexpres- -tion over the output vocabulary via a linear layer followed siveness of ASP in modeling complex combinatorial prob- -bysoftmax: P (y i x,y :i−1 ), wherey :i−1 istheprefixupto lems. For arigorousintroductiontotheASPlanguage and -| -tokeni 1. Generationproceedsstepwisefromthisdistribu- itssemantics,pleaserefertotheaforesaidliterature. -− -tion. Architectural variants exist (Naveed et al., 2024; Ra- -iaan et al., 2024), but their internal design is orthogonal to -BLASTMethodology -our focus. LLMs are generally invoked via prompting: a -textualquery(orprompt)isprovidedasinputtothemodel, -The core of the approach consists in testing the generation -whichtriggerscontentgeneration. -capabilitiesofatargetLLM.Forthis, wedeviseamethod- -ologyconsistingoftwomaincomponents: (i)anASPGen- -Answer Set Programming. Answer Set Programming erationframeworkthat,startingfromaspecificationinnat- -(ASP)isadeclarativeformalismforKnowledgeRepresenta- urallanguage,providesasetofencodingsoftheproblemin -tionandReasoning(Brewka,Eiter,andTruszczynski,2011; ASP;(ii)anASPTestinginfrastructureaimedatevaluating -GelfondandLifschitz,1991). InASP,aproblemisencoded the performance of the target LLM. The overall scheme of -as a finite set of logical rules, and solutions correspond to theapproachisdetailedinFigure1. - -ASPGeneration -| | | | | | | | 1 {assign(N, | C) : colour(C)} | 1 | :- node(N). | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -The framework for generating ASP initiates with a natural :- edge(X, Y), assign(X, C), assign(Y, C). -| language | description | of | the problem | intended | | for ASP en- | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -coding,alongsideagoldprogramthatexemplifiestheASP- If there is no semantic match between some predicates, -| | | | | | | | output ‘No | semantic match’ | only. | Otherwise, produce | the | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------------- | ----- | ------------------ | ----- | -| basedsolution. | | Thegenerationprocessisdrivenbythefol- | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | matchesoverallthepredicatesasapythondictionary. | | | | Donot | -| lowing elements: | | (i) the | target | LLM, | serving | as the gen- | | | | | | -erator under evaluation, in charge of encoding the problem generateanyadditionaltext. -| into ASP; | (ii) an | LLM | instructed | to | paraphrase | the ini- | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Thegeneratedmatchingdictionaryisthefollowing: -| tial problem | description | | to make | it more | human-readable; | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -{‘node’:‘node’,‘edge’:‘edge’,‘color’:‘colour’,‘chosen’:‘assign’} -(iii)anLLMthatsemanticallymatchesthepredicatesofthe -resultingprogramwiththoseinthegoldprogram. -1.0 -Gold -| Target | LLM. | As an | initial | step in | our framework, | the | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | scitnameS | | Generated | | -| LLM under | evaluation | | is prompted | with | the | problem de- | | | | | | -| scriptionandaskedtoprovideanencodinginASPlanguage. | | | | | | | | 0.5 | | | | -| Box 1 provides | | an example | of | the provided | prompt. | (Note | | | | | | -that,thiscomponentcanbereplacedbyanymethodgener- -0.0 -atingASPprogramsfromnaturallanguagespecifications.) -| | | | | | | | | ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD elcycnainotlimaH | htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH euqilclamixaM | noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS nosrepelasgnilevarT | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | --- | -Box1:TargetLLMPromptExample -| [PROBLEM | DESCRIPTION] | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ----------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Write | an ASP | program | which | models | this problem, | along | | | | | | -| withfactsthatmakeitinstantiable. | | | | Generatetheprogramonly, | | | | | | | | -withoutanyadditionaltext. -Figure2: Semanticcomparisonontheconsideredproblemscom- -PredicateMatcher. Itisimportanttoremarkthatthetar- puted by using the “gold” matching dictionary (manually crafted -get model is not given any instructions or constraints re- byauthors)andthegeneratedone.DeepSeek-R1hasbeenusedas -thetargetLLM. -| garding | the syntax, | predicate | names, | | or problem | modeling | | | | | | -| --------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| to adopt. | To normalize | | its output | and | enable | comparison | | | | | | -withthegoldstandardsolution,weemployafurtherLLM, We emphasize three crucial aspects of the predicate -referredtoasthePredicateMatcher. Thismodeltakesasin- matcher component. First, the predicate matching phase is -putboththegoldprogramandtheencodinggeneratedbythe independentofencodingcorrectness:thematcherLLMonly -targetmodel,andispromptedtoperformasemanticmatch semanticallyassociatespredicatesbetweenprograms,with- -outassessingtheirvalidity.Second,thematcherdoesnotse- -| ofthepredicatesusedinthetwoprograms. | | | | | Theresultisre- | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -turnedasaPythondictionarymappingcorrespondingpred- manticallyalteracorrectprogram. Inotherwords,thequal- -icates. Ifnosemanticsimilaritycanbeestablishedbetween ityofthetargetLLMperformance(thatis,itsabilitytogen- -theprograms, themodelisinstructedtoreturn“Noseman- erateacorrectASPprogramfromanaturallanguageprob- -ticmatch”. Anexamplepromptofthepredicatematcheris lemdescription)remainsconsistentregardlessofwhethera -| | | | | | | | “gold” predicate | matching | dictionary | (manually crafted | by | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -providedinBox3,consideringtheColorabilityproblem. -theauthors)orageneratedoneisused(seeFigure2,where -Box3:PredicateMatcherPromptExample weuseDeepSeek-R1astherepresentativetargetLLM).The -Perform predicate matching on the following ASP programs onlyexceptionistheTravelingSalespersonproblem,where -basedonthesemanticsimilarityofthepredicates: performance is slightly better with the gold matching. By -lookingdeeperintothisproblem,werealizedthatdespitethe -ASPInstance1: -bettermatching,thegeneratedprogramswerestillincorrect. -node(1). node(2). node(3). Third, we remark that this result enables our methodology -edge(1,2). edge(1,3). edge(2,1). to achieve a high degree of generality, since it allows eval- -edge(2,3). color(red). color(green). uating generated programs without imposing any prompt- -color(black). ingconstraintsontheLLMs. Indeed,wedeliberatelyavoid -1 {chosen(N,C) : color(C)} 1 :- node(N). penalizing encodings that differ only at the syntactic level, -:- edge(U,V), U < V, chosen(U,C), chosen(V,C). throughtheuseofalternativepredicatenames. Forinstance, -adoptingreach(X)insteadofreached(X)torepresent -ASPInstance2: the same concept should not negatively affect the evalua- -node(a). node(b). node(c). tion, providedthattheprogramissemanticallycorrect. By -edge(a, b). edge(b, c). edge(c, d). abstracting away from superficial naming differences, our -colour(1). colour(2). colour(3). approach focuses on assessing genuine modeling and cod- -ingabilityratherthansensitivitytoarbitrarylexicalchoices. - -Paraphraser. Inadditiontothetechnicallydetailedorig- @constraintForAll(constraint=":- node(U), -inalproblemstatement,wefurtherevaluatetheadaptability not chosenColor(U,_).") -ofthetargetmodeltounderstandpromptsthatareformatted -tobemorerelatabletohumans. Thegoalistoevaluatethe which ensures that every node U is assigned at least one -modelsnotonlyintermsofbreadth,byaddressingadiverse color. Finally, we add test cases to check whether the pro- -setofproblems,butalsointermsofdepth,byassessingtheir gramproducestheexpectednumberofanswersets. -abilitytoadapttolesstechnical,moreaccessibletextualde- -scriptions intended for an “ASP layman”. To achieve this, -Model-basedTesting. ThismethodevaluatesanASPpro- -weuseanotherLLMasaparaphraser togeneratetwover- -gramP basedonitsabilitytoreproducethecorrect(gold) -sions of the initial description. An example prompt is re- t -(stable) models (GM) for a given set of instances provided -portedinBox2intheSupplementaryMaterial. -viafacts. Thecoreideareliesontheassumptionthat,given -Theparaphrasingprocessisconductedintwophases.Ini- -a gold program P and a set of instances, the target pro- -tially, a first version is derived from the original problem g -gram P is considered correct if and only if it produces -statement. Thisversionisthenemployedasabasisforpro- t -the same (stable) models as P on those instances. To -ducingasecondone.Bothversionsaresubsequentlyusedto g -formalize this, we define the set of target program models -promptthetargetLLMwithalternativespecifications. Note -(TPM) as the (stable) models of P , and the covered gold -thatthisphaseisoptionalintheproposedframework.While t -models (CGM) as the intersection of TPM and GM, i.e., -we study the impact of paraphrased textual descriptions on -CGM=GM TPM. -modelperformanceasanadditionalanalysis,thetargetLLM ∩ -ToquantifytheaccuracyofP ,weusethestandard(mi- -canstillbeevaluatedusingonlytheoriginalencoding. t -cro) F1-score (Christen, Hand, and Kirielle, 2023), which -combinesprecisionandrecall,definedas: -ASPTesting -To evaluate the ASP programs generated by the LLMs, we CGM CGM -Recall= | | and Precision= | |, -propose two methods: (i) a test-suite-based approach and GM TPM -(ii) a model-based approach. Both methods are associated | | | | -The (micro) F1 score is then computed as the harmonic -with proper metrics that allow us to measure a form of se- -meanofprecisionandrecall,providingabalancedmeasure -mantic distance from the gold program. Both approaches -oftheprogram’sabilitytoreproducetheexpectedmodels. -assumethateachproblemhasafixedsetofinputandoutput -Notably,weretrievetheCGMsetwithhighefficiencyby -predicates, corresponding to the ones of the gold program. -mean of the Algorithm 1, which leverages an ASP solver. -Thisassumptionispragmatic,yetreasonablynottoorestric- -Rather than relying on full answer set enumeration of the -tive. Indeed, LLMs are expected to produce meaningful -program under test, that might quickly become infeasible, -programs as written by a human; thus, syntactic variations -we modify the ASP program to directly target specific so- -ofpredicatenamesareverylikelyresolvedbythepredicate -lutions. Inparticular,weconstrainthesearchspacetogold -matcher. Ifnot,weassumetheprogramisnotcorrect. -modelsonly,therebyavoidingtheoverheadofenumerating -irrelevantanswersets. Clearly, wecarefullycraftedoutin- -Test-Suite-basedEvaluation. Thisevaluationmethodre- -stance set to be sure that the enumeration of gold program -lies on the unit testing mechanism implemented in the -answersisinsteadfeasible. -ASP-WIDE tool (Amendola et al., 2024), which uses an -The algorithm takes as input the program to test P , a -t -annotation-basedtestspecificationlanguageinspiredbyJU- -gold program P , and a set of instances Ins. For each -g -nit. The objective is to create a test suite that thoroughly -instanceI Ins, wecomputethesetofgoldmodelsAS -g -checkstheprogramfunctionality. Atestsuiteisacollection ∈ -bycomputingallanswersetsofP I usinganASPsolver -g -oftestcases, eachcomprisingassertionsthatverifyanum- ∪ -(line 5). Then, for each gold model M AS , we create -g g -berofconditionsontheexpectedprogramoutput. Basedon ∈ -asetofconstraintsaimedatforcingM tobeananswerset -g -thetestsuiteresults,wecomputethetestcaseaccuracyas -ofP (line8). Specifically,foreachatomaovertheoutput -t -theratioofpassedtestcasesoverthetotalnumber. -predicates, if a M then we add the constraint :-nota; -Toensurethisevaluationmethodiseffective,itiscrucial ∈ g -otherwise,weaddtheconstraint:-a. -todesignarobusttestsuiteovermostoftheprogram’sex- -pected behavior. To this end, we developed a guideline for -For the sake of clarity, let us consider the Col- -constructing meaningful test cases. The first step involves -orability problem with 3 nodes and 3 colors and a -creatingtestcasestocheckforunsatisfiability. Specifically, -gold model M where node 1 is colored as purple, -given a set of input instances that violate the problem con- g -node 2 as red, and node 3 as brown. In this case, -straints,theprogramisexpectedtoreturnnoanswersetfor -create model constraints(M g) returns the fol- -eachinstance. Next,wedefinetestcasesthatverifythesat- -lowingconstraints: -isfiabilityoftheproblemconstraintsbycheckingifvalidin- -stancescomply with them. If needed, we furtherrefine the :- not chosenColor(3,brown). -test suite by adding test cases that validate the correctness :- not chosenColor(2,red). -of the program’s output atoms. For example, in the Col- :- not chosenColor(1,purple). -orabilityproblem,itshouldneveroccurthatanoderemains :- chosenColor(1,brown). -uncolored. ThisisdonebywritinganASP-WIDEtestcase :- chosenColor(1,red). -withthefollowingassertion: :- chosenColor(2,brown). - -:- chosenColor(2,purple). Algorithm 1 Finding P covered gold models and overall -t -:- chosenColor(3,red). models. -:- chosenColor(3,purple). Input: AprogramP ,aprogramP ,asetofinstancesIns. -t g -Output: the sets of models GM, CGM, and -Intuitively, in the answer set M , node 1 is colored WM. -g -as purple (i.e., chosenColor(1,purple) M g ) and 1: GM = -so :-notchosenColor(1,purple) is obtain ∈ ed. Con- 2: CGM = ∅ -versely, node 1 is colored neither red nor brown, 3: WM = ∅ -and so the constraints :-chosenColor(1,red) and 4: forI I ∅ nsdo -:-chosenColor(1,brown) are obtained. Analogously, the 5: AS ∈ g =solve all(P g I). -remainingconstraintsareobtainedfornodes2and3. Note 6: GM =GM AS g . ∪ -that, if the gold program contains weak constraints then 7: forM g AS ∪ g do -create model constraints(M g) does not return 8: C g = ∈create model constraints(M g ). -strong constraints as in the previous example but a set of 9: M =solve once(P t C g I). -weak constraints with cost 1 and a priority higher than the 10: ifM =M g then ∪ ∪ -maximum priority used in P t . This ensures that the solver 11: CGM =CGM M g -prioritizestheinclusionofthesegoldatomsintheresulting 12: endif ∪{ } -answer sets. After obtaining the set of constraints C g , the 13: endfor -program P t ∪ C g ∪ I is solved using the solver configured 14: P ta =aug program(P t ,AS g ). -to return exactly one answer set M. This operation is 15: AS w =solve all(P ta I). -performed by the function solve once in line 9 of the 16: WM =WM AS w ∪ -algorithm. Then,thegoldmodelM g isconsideredcovered 17: endfor ∪ -ifM g exactlymatchesM. M andM g exactlymatchif,for 18: returnGM,CGM,WM -each atom a over output predicates, it holds that a M if -∈ -andonlyifa M . -g -∈ -The next step is to identify the set of models generated -amodelofP . Notethatthisruleisdomain-specific,asthe -byP thatdifferfromthegoldmodels(i.e.,wrongmodels). t -t -outputpredicatenamesvaryacrossdifferentdomains.Then, -Notethatthislaststepisnecessaryinordertoproperlycal- -rules in lines 7-8 compute for each gold model, the differ- -culateTPM.Tothisend,wefirstaugmentP withthesetof -t ences with a candidate model of P . Finally, the constraint -factsencodingthegoldmodelsinAS . Todothis,weused t -g -atline9forcestheprogramtodiscardamodelifitmatches -the predicate trueInGold/2, where the first term is an iden- -a gold model. Once the program P is obtained, the al- -tifier (i.e., a positive integer) for a gold model M AS , ta -g ∈ g gorithm calls the solver to compute all models of P I -and the second term is a true atom in M . Note that, such ta -g (i.e.,solve all(P I)).Obtainedmodelsareconside ∪ red -facts are obtained considering only atoms over the output ta -∪ -wrong. Finally, the algorithm returns the set of gold mod- -predicates. Then,theprogramP isfurtheraugmentedwith -t -els over all instances GM, the set of covered gold models -additional rules that discard all those models of P that ex- -t -CGM GM, and the set of wrong models WM, which is -actlymatchonegoldmodel. Thisaugmentedversionofthe -⊆ -disjoint from GM. The value TPM can then be calculated -programP isreturnedbythefunctionaug programand -t | | -asthesumofthenumberofelementsofCGMandWM. -is denoted as P . For example, let us consider again the -ta -Colorability problem and the gold model in which node 1 -is colored as purple, node 2 as red, and node 3 as brown. Discussion on Metrics. The introduced metrics are in- -In this case the program P ta is obtained by adding to the tended to assess how well an ASP program semantically -programP t therulesreportedinListing1. models a given problem. Among the two evaluation meth- -ods, the test-suite-based approach offers a more accurate -Listing1:RulesandfactsusedtoaugmentaprogramP targeting -t -measure of program correctness, as it involves white-box -theColorabilityproblem. -testing. This type of testing enables detailed inspection of -1 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(2,red)). -a program internal behavior, rather than relying solely on -2 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(1,purple)). -its output models. However, the test-suite-based approach -3 trueInGold(1,chosenColor(3,brown)). -has some limitations; in fact, it requires a human expert to -4 ... -5 mod(X) :- trueInGold(X,_). design the test cases, and the reliability of the final assess- -6 trueInTested(chosenColor(X,Y)) :- chosenColor(X,Y). ment depends heavily on the quality of the test suite. In -7 smallerMG(M) :- trueInGold(M, X), not trueInTested(X). contrast, the model-based approach offers a higher level of -8 smallerMt(M) :- mod(M), trueInTested(X), not automation,ashumaninterventionislimitedtoprovidingin- -trueInGold(M, X). putinstancesandthegoldprogram. Thismethod,however, -9 :- mod(M), not smallerMG(M), not smallerMt(M). makesitmoredifficulttoknowthereasonswhyaprogram -Rules in lines 1-3 in Listing 1 represent the facts encod- may be incorrect, which limits potential efforts to improve -ing the considered gold model (here we reported only one it. Indeed, we might inspect the results and discover some -for the sake of readability, but all gold models are consid- answersetismissingorwrong,butthereisnoclueonwhy -ered). Theruleatline6isusedtocomputethetrueatomsin ithappens. Ontheotherhand,specifictestcasesaredevised - -| with the | aim at testing | a | specific | ability, | and | thus are more | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| connectedtoareasonforthefailure. | | | | | | | | 1.0 | | | | | | | -ycaruccA -ExperimentalEvaluation -0.5 -| We present | our experimental | | evaluation, | | which | tackles the | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -followingresearchquestions: -| RQ1: Are | state-of-the-art | | LLMs | effective | in | ASP coding, | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0.0 -| | | | | | | | | | y t | e h | g e | n k | e n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u n d e r b o t h s y n t a c t i c a n d s e m a n ti c p e r s p e c ti v e s ? bilit S e c l at n q u o n a g o -| | | | | | | | | | g | C y P | er i Cli | artiti erli | arri ers | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | a n | n | ust | h | p | | -R Q 2 : H o w d o e s p a r a p h r a s in g i m p a c t o n p e r f o r m a n c e ? or ati a n a al P Slit M e -| | | | | | | | | ol | n ni | ni | Cl m | | al | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | C | mi o | ilt o al | i | bl | e S | | -R Q 3 : H o w d o t h e p r o p o s e d s e m a n t i c m e t r i c s c o m p a r e, in milt c a x a g -| | | | | | | | | | D o | m hi | M | St | eli n | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -t e r m s o f a c c u r a c y a n d e f fi c i e n c y ? a H a c -| | | | | | | | | | H | a r | | | a v | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | er | | | Tr | | -Hi -SetupandValidationProtocol -| Dataset | To evaluate | the | proposed | approach, | | we created | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Figure3:PerformanceofGPT-4oaspredicatematcher.Errorbars -| a dataset | comprising | the | following | ten | graph-related | prob- | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -representconfidenceintervalsontendifferentruns. -lems: Colorability,(Connected)DominatingSet,Hamil- -| tonian | Cycle, Hamiltonian | | Path, | Hierarchical | | Cluster- | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ing, Maximal Clique, (Graph) Partitioning, Slitherlink, Settings. Alltestedmodelshavebeeninvokedviatheded- -| (Strong) | Stable | Marriage, | and | Traveling | Salesman. | We | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -icatedAPIsofOpenAI,Anthropic,Google,andDeepSeek, -| selected | this set | of tasks | since | they are | standard | problems | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --------- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | ------------------ | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | with a temperature | | of | 0.7 (when | allowed). | | In the | case of | -| used in | many ASP | competitions | | (Gebser, | | Maratea, and | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | LLaMa3.3-70B, | | we used | a self-hosted | | instance | using | the | -| Ricca, 2017; | Calimeri, | Ianni, | and | Ricca, | 2014; | Alviano et | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Ollama | tool. | The LLM-related | | and | ASP-testing | code | has | -al.,2013). Eachproblemincludesaformalnaturallanguage beenimplementedinPython. TheinteractionwiththeASP- -| description | and the | corresponding | | gold | program. | For each | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ---------- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | WIDE tool | (developed | | in Spring | Boot) | was | done | through | -| problem, | we provide | the | related | test suite | and | the input in- | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | a RESTful | API | endpoint. | The | experiments | | have been | con- | -stancesrequiredbytheevaluationmethodsoutlinedearlier. -ductedonaserverequippedwithanIntel(R)Xeon(R)CPU -IntheSupplementaryMaterial,weprovidetheproblemde- -E7-8880v4@2.20GHz,512GBofRAM,andrunningDe- -scriptionsanddetailsregardingthetestsuitedesign. bian 13 (6.1.0-32-amd64). Additional information and ex- -perimentalresultsareprovidedasSupplementaryMaterial. -Test Suite Validation. To ensure the quality of our test Theexperimentalcodeismadepubliclyavailable.2 -| suite, we | draw inspiration | | from | Oetsch | et al. | (2012), who | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -| empiricallydemonstratedthatthesmall-scopehypothesisof | | | | | | | Results | | | | | | | | -| traditional | testing | is also | applicable | to | ASP programs, | i.e., | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Predicate | Matcher | Accuracy. | | We | first assess | the | predi- | -many errors can be detected by testing a program against cate matcher accuracy in mapping predicates from the two -inputs involving only a small number of objects. Follow- inputprogramssemantically. Toachievethis, wemanually -| ing Amendola | et | al. (Amendola | | et al., | 2024), | we employ | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | ----------------- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | verify the | matches, | assigning | | each | generated | dictionary | a | -| a mutation-based | | testing | strategy | specifically | | designed for | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | score ranging | | from [0,1]. | Specifically, | | we | count | the cor- | -| ASP(Oetschetal.,2012). | | | GivenanASPprogram,thetool | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | rect associations | | and average | | them | over the | total | number | -randomly applies a set of modifications to its rules, gener- of predicates. For each problem, we create ten separate -ating mutants, altered versions of the original program that matchestoensurestatisticalsignificanceandreportthe av- -| introducesubtleerrors. | | Foreachgoldprogram,wegenerate | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | erage as | the ultimate | performance | | score. | Figure | 3 | presents | -15mutantsandexecutethecorrespondingtestsuiteonthem -| | | | | | | | the results | using | GPT-4o | as the | predicate | matcher. | | The ac- | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ------- | -| usingourselectedinputinstances. | | | | Aftereachexecution,we | | | | | | | | | | | -curacyofthemodelonthistaskcomesasnosurprise,given -iteratively refine the test suite and the input instances until itswell-documentedabilitiestoperformtextsummarization -noneofthemutantsachievesaperfecttestscore(i.e., 1.0). and rephrasing (Adams et al., 2023; Zhou, Ringeval, and -| This iterative | process | ensures | that | the | test suite | is effective | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ------- | ------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Portet,2025);thus,weoptforGPT-4oalsoasaparaphraser. -indetectingdeviationsfromtheexpectedprogrambehavior. -| | | | | | | | LLMsPerformance(RQ1). | | | | Further,weassesstheeffec- | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | ------------------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | -| TestedModels. | | Fortheexperimentalevaluation,weadopt | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | tiveness | of the | evaluated | models | concerning | | both | syntactic | -eight state-of-the-art LLMs from five distinct families: o4- syntax and semantic accuracy. Figure 4 shows the average -mini (OpenAI, 2025b), Claude-3.5-Sonnet (Anthropic, resultsforallexaminedproblems,whereasFigure5displays -| 2024), DeepSeek-R1 | | (DeepSeek, | | 2025), | Gemini-1.5-Pro | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------ | -------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | -| | | | | | | | scores for | each | individual | problem. | | At this | stage, | we con- | -| (Team | and et al., | 2024), | Gemini-2.5-Flash | | | (Comanici, | | | | | | | | | -centratesolelyontheinitialproblemstatements,withmore -| Bieber, | and et al., | 2025), | GPT-4o | (OpenAI, | | 2024), GPT- | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -5(OpenAI,2025a),andLLaMa3.3-70B (Grattafioriandet 2https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ -| al.,2024). | | | | | | | LLMs-ASP-Benchmark-DFC3/ | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| o4-mini | | DeepSeek-R1 | | Gemini2.5 | | GPT-5 | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | ------------------- | --- | --------------- | -| Claude3.5 | | Gemini1.5 | | GPT-4o | | LLaMa3.3 | | | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.6 0.8 | 1.0 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | 1 0.40.40.20.10.8 | | 0 0.10.40.1 | -| | 1.0 | | | | | | | o4-mini | 1 1 1 | 1 0.8 1 | 0.8 1 0.80.8 | | | | -| | | | | | | | | Claude3.5 | 1 1 1 | 1 1 1 | 1 1 0 | 1 1 0.40.10.2 | 0 | 0.20.10.1 0 0.1 | -| | | | | | | | DeepSeek-R1 | | 1 1 1 | 1 1 1 | 0.80.6 1 | 1 1 0.50.70.60.20.4 | | 0 0 0.30.4 | -| | | | | | | | | Gemini1.5 | 1 1 0.8 | 1 0.8 1 | 1 0.40.6 | 1 1 0.20.10.5 | 0 | 0 0 0 0.10.1 | -0.8 -| | | | | | | | | Gemini2.5 | 1 1 1 | 1 0.6 1 | 0.40.40.4 | 1 0.80.10.30.8 | 0 | 0.4 0 0 0.1 0 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | | | GPT-4o | 1 0.80.80.8 | 1 1 | 0.8 0 0.80.6 | 1 0.20.1 | 0 0 | 0 0 0 0.2 0 | -citnameS -0.6 GPT-5 1 1 1 1 0.8 1 0.8 1 0.8 1 1 0.70.90.70.10.4 0 0.10.40.4 -| | | | | | | | | LLaMa3.3 | 1 0.40.60.40.80.40.40.20.20.6 | | | 1 0.10.1 | 0 0 | 0 0 0.1 0 0 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| | | | | | | | | | ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD elcycnainotlimaH | htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH euqilclamixaM | noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS | nosrepelasgnilevarT ytilibaroloC tesgnitanimoD | elcycnainotlimaH htapnainotlimaH gniretsulclacihcrareiH | euqilclamixaM noititraP knilrehtilS egairramelbatS nosrepelasgnilevarT | -0.4 -0.2 -0.0 -| | | | | | | | | | (a)Syntactic | | | | (b)Semantic | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 | | | | | | | | | -Syntactic -Figure5:Syntacticandsemanticperformanceobtainedbytheeval- -| | | | | | | | uatedLLMsacrosstheconsideredproblems. | | | | | | Thetestsuite-based | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------ | ---------- | -| | | | | | | | metric | is | used as the | semantic | reference7. | Each | value | represents | -theaverageoffivedifferentruns. -Figure4: Trade-offoftheevaluatedLLMsbetweensyntactic(X- -| axis)andsemanticaccuracy(Y-axis). | | | | Thesemanticscoreiscom- | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| putedaccordingtothetestsuite-basedmethod7. | | | | | Resultsareaver- | | | | | | | | | | -agedacrossallconsideredproblems. -| | | | | | | | LLM | Error | Analysis. | | For completeness, | | we | summarize | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | | the | most | common | error | patterns | observed | in | syntactically | -| | | | | | | | validbutsemanticallyincorrectprograms. | | | | | | Afrequentissue | | -in-depth analyses discussed subsequently. Here, semantic istheomissionofconstraints. Forexample,intheHamilto- -accuracyisdeterminedusingtestsuite-basedevaluation. In nian Path problem, LLMs often fail to enforce that exactly -| comparison, | syntactic | correctness | | is evaluated | | by checking | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -oneedgeentersandoneedgeleaveseachnode,whichisre- -whethertheinputprogramresultsinanysyntaxerrorsdur- -| | | | | | | | quiredtoguaranteeaproperpath. | | | | | InStableMarriage,mod- | | | -| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -| ing processing | | by the solver. | To | ensure | results | are statis- | | | | | | | | | -elssometimesomitbijectivityconstraintsensuringthateach -| tically | robust, | each experiment | is | conducted | by | calling the | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | manismatchedwithexactlyonewomanandviceversa. | | | | | | | In | -targetLLMfivetimes,withoutcomesthenaveraged. optimization tasks involving weak constraints, mistakes in -| Two | considerations | can | be made. | First, | as | depicted in | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | -------------- | --------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | the | specification | | of weights | or | priorities | are also | common. | -| Figure | 4, while | most LLMs | show | an impressive | | accuracy | | | | | | | | | -Anotherrecurringproblemconcernsincorrectpredicatesig- -| under | the syntactic | perspective | (with | the | notable | exception | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ------------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | natures, | | such as | wrong | arity or | mismatched | arguments | in | -of LLaMa3.3), they perform poorly in terms of semantics. input atoms. In some cases, additional constraints are in- -Secondly,Figure5showsthat,whilesimpleproblemssuch troducedwithoutaclearcorrespondencetotheproblemde- -as Colorability or Dominating Set are easier to address, al- scription; whilenotalwaysharmful,theyrevealatendency -| most all | LLMs | fall short | in encoding | more | complex | tasks | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | -| | | | | | | | to | produce | plausible | but | unjustified | rules. | Overall, | LLMs | -| (e.g., Partition | | or Slitherlink). | This | suggests | that | state-of- | | | | | | | | | -tendtogenerateencodingsthatlookreasonableatasuperfi- -the-artLLMsstillstruggletoeffectivelyencodedeclarative -paradigms,suchasAnswerSetProgramming. -| | | | | | | | | OriginalProblem | | | Paraphrase1 | | | Paraphrase2 | -| --------------------------------------------------- | ----------- | -------------------- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | ------------- | -| ParaphrasingImpact(RQ2). | | | | Further,wewanttoassess | | | | | | | | | | | -| whetheramorenatural, | | | human-likestyleofthetextualde- | | | | ycaruccAcitnameS | 1.0 | | | | | | | -| scriptionmighthelpinincreasingperformance. | | | | | | Tothisaim, | | | | | | | | | -| we select | DeepSeek-R1 | | as the | representative | | LLM candi- | | 0.5 | | | | | | | -| date, since | it | achieves | one of the | best | syntactic-semantic | | | | | | | | | | -| trade-offwhilebeingthecheapesttoprobe. | | | | | Wecompareits | | | | | | | | | | -| semanticaccuracywhenproblemparaphrasingsareapplied. | | | | | | | | 0.0 | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | bility | set | cycle | h g | ue n | k | ge n | -| | | | | | | score7, | | | | | pat usteri n | q Partiti o | herli n | marria pers o | -| Figure | 6 depicts | the test-suite-based | | evaluation | | av- | | | g | | | cli | | | -| | | | | | | | | ora | nati n | n n | | | | | -eraged over five runs, along with the confidence intervals. ol nia nia cl mal Slit sale -| | | | | | | | | C | mi | o o | | Maxi | | ble | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -We see that, in most cases, performance is leveraged when milt milt hical g -| | | | | | | | | | D o | | | | | Sta Traveli n | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -the original problem description is used, despite some ex- Ha Ha Hierarc -| ceptions | where | the first | paraphrasing | slightly | improves | the | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| semantic | accuracy | of the | model | (notably, | with | Dominating | | | | | | | | | -Figure6: Comparisonofthesemanticaccuracycomputedviathe -set,Partition,Stablemarriage). -test-suitewhenproblemparaphrasingsareapplied7.DeepSeek-R1 -isusedasthereferenceLLM.Barsdepicttheaverageacrossfive -7ForMaximalClique,weuseonlythemodel-basedmetricdue -differentruns,whileerrorbarsrepresentconfidenceintervals. -toASPWIDErun-timeissues. - -o4-mini DeepSeek-R1 Gemini2.5 GPT-5 TestSuite-Based Model-Based -| | Claude3.5 | | Gemini1.5 | | GPT-4o | | LLaMa3.3 | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1000 -| | desab-ledoMsv-etiustseT 1.0 | | | | | | | )s(emitgnitseT | | | | | | | | -| --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -0.5 -500 -0.0 -0 -0.5 -| | − | | | | | | | | bilit y | et | cl e | at h n g | o n | n k g e | o n | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | s | y | eri | artiti | erli a | ers | -| | 1.0 | | | | | | | | a | n g | c | p | | arri | | -| | − | | | | | | | | or | ati | n | a n ust | | h | e p | -bility set cycle pat h n g o n nk ge o n ol ni a ni cl P Slit m al -| | | | g | | usteri Partiti | herli | marria pers | | C | mi n | o | o | | e | s | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | ora | n | n n | | | | | | | milt milt | al | | bl | g | -| | | | nati nia | nia | | Slit | sale | | | o | | hi c | | a | n | -| | | ol | | o | cl | | ble | | | D | a a | c | | St | eli | -| | | C | mi milt o | milt | hical | | g | | | | H H | ar | | v | | -| | | | D o | | | | Sta Traveli n | | | | | er | | Tr a | | -| | | | Ha | Ha | Hierarc | | | | | | | Hi | | | | -Figure8: Comparisonbetweenthetwosemanticmetricsinterms -oftestingtimes(expressedinseconds).DeepSeek-R1isusedasthe -| Figure | 7: | Comparison | between | | the two proposed | | semantic met- | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -referenceLLM.Barsrepresenttheaverageacrossfiveruns,error -| rics8. | DeepSeek-R1 | | is the | reference | LLM. | Values | represent the | | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ---- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -barsindicateconfidenceintervals. -| difference | | between | test-suite- | and | model-based | scores, | averaged | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -acrossfiveruns,whilelinesindicateconfidenceintervals. -ricsforassessingtheASPcodingcapabilitiesofLLMsand, -morebroadly,ofautomaticprogramcodingapproaches. -| cial | level, | yet the | formal | rigor | of ASP | exposes | subtle inac- | | | | | | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ---- | --- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | In | this paper, | we | addressed | this | gap | by introducing | | -curacies. Althoughsuchdraftsmayassisthumanprogram- -BLAST,thefirstdedicatedbenchmarkingmethodologyand -| mers, | our | results | indicate | that | fully automatic | | generation | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -of correct ASP encodings remains challenging for current accompanying dataset specifically designed to rigorously -evaluatetheaccuracyofLLMsingeneratingASPprograms. -state-of-the-artmodels. -| | | | | | | | | Along | with BLAST, | | we implement | | and | release an | ad-hoc | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | benchmark, | two | testing | methodologies | | and | related | correct- | -Test-suite- vs Model-based (RQ3). Next, we compare ness metrics. The proposed metrics measure the seman- -| | | | | | | | | tic distance | between | | the generated | | encoding | and the | refer- | -| --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------ | -| the | two proposed | | semantic | metrics, | both | in terms | of accu- | | | | | | | | | -racy(Figure7)andefficiency(Figure8). Specifically, Fig- ence specification, without imposing constraints on predi- -ure7showsthedifferenceinperformancecomputedviathe catenamesorLLMspromptstructure.Weshowthatthetwo -test-suite-andthemodel-basedmetricTherefore,apositive measures consistently align in their assessment of correct- -(resp.,negative)scoremeansthattheperformanceishigher ness, while remaining complementary: one is more trans- -parentandinterpretable,atthecostofrequiringhumaninter- -ifthetest-suite-basedmetric(resp.,themodel-basedmetric) -isconsidered. Again,resultsareobtainedbyaveragingfive vention,whereastheotherisfullyautomaticbutlessdirectly -distinct runs, while the bars represent confidence intervals. explainable. BuildingonBLAST,weconductanextensive -Weseethat,acrossmostproblemsandevaluatedLLMs,the empiricalstudyofeightstate-of-the-artLLMsfromfivedif- -two metrics align. This alignment is also confirmed by the ferentmodelfamilies,evaluatingtheirabilitytoencodeten -well-knowngraphproblemsinASPstartingfromtextualde- -Pearsoncorrelationcoefficientρ=0.865. -Wefinallycomparethetwometricsintermsofefficiency. scriptions.Experimentsrevealthat:(i)althoughLLMsoften -Figure 8 depicts the testing times (in seconds) across the achievehighsyntacticaccuracy,theystrugglewithsemantic -considered problems, using DeepSeek-R1 as the reference correctness; (ii)theirperformancedegradessignificantlyas -LLM. In all problems (except for Hierarchical clustering), task complexity increases; and (iii) rephrasing the problem -specificationdoesnotleadtoconsistentimprovements. -thetest-suite-basedmetricsignificantlyreducesthecompu- -| tationtime,resultinginthemostefficientmetric. | | | | | | | (Morede- | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -tailsintheSupplementaryMaterial.) Asfuturework,weplantoaddresscurrentlimitationsand -| | | | | | | | | exploreseveraldirectionsforextension. | | | | | Althoughoureval- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | uation | adopts | zero-shot | prompting | | to ensure | a uniform | and | -ConclusionsandFutureWork -| | | | | | | | | controlled | comparison, | | more | advanced | strategies, | | such as | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | -AlthoughLLMsareknowntoexcelatlanguageunderstand- few-shotprompting, prompttuning, orretrieval-augmented -ingandcodesynthesis,theirabilitytogeneratecorrectASP generation (RAG), deserve systematic investigation, and -programs has remained comparatively underexplored. Re- could lead to measure better performance of LLMs in gen- -searchontheautomaticcompositionofASPcodeisgrow- erating ASP code. Moreover, our benchmark focuses on -ing; however, evaluations often rely on manual inspection graph problems that are standard ASP system testing. Ex- -or impose constraints on the LLM’s input/output format, tending the benchmark to additional domains would fur- -makingperformancesensitivetosuperficialvariationssuch therstrengthenitsscopeandrepresentativeness. Finally,al- -as predicate renaming. As a consequence, the field still though BLAST here evaluates general-purpose LLMs, our -lackssystematicstandardizedbenchmarksandrigorousmet- methodologyismodel-agnosticandcouldalsobeemployed - -toevaluatespecializedtechniquesforASPencoding. -GenAIStatement -| This paper | has been | fully conceptualized, | | designed, and | -| ---------- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | ------------- | -writtenbythehumanauthors.LLMswereusedtoproofread -| the paper | and identify | some typos | and style | issues, the au- | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | -| thorsclaimthefullownershipofthetext. | | | | Importantly,LLM | -areusedasintegralcomponentsoftheproposedframework, -| as detailed | in the manuscript, | and | are subject | solely to ex- | -| ----------- | ------------------ | --- | ----------- | ------------- | -perimentalevaluation. -Acknowledgments -| This work | has been | partially | funded | by MUR on | -| -------------- | --------- | ---------------- | -------------------- | ------------ | -| D.M. 351/2022, | PNRR | Ricerca, | CUP H23C22000440007; | | -| and partially | supported | by Moneying-Plus | | project (CUP | -J29I24001790005)selectedwithintheframeworkofthePR -FESR–FSECalabria2021/2027andimplementedwiththe -| support of | the Italian | State and | the Calabria | Region. The | -| ---------- | ------------------- | --------- | ------------ | ----------------- | -| work has | also been partially | supported | | by PN RIC project | -ASVIN“AssistenteVirtualeIntelligentediNegozio”(CUP -B29J24000200005)andthePNRRprojectFAIR-FutureAI -| Research | (PE00000013), | Spoke | 9 – Green-aware | AI, un- | -| ------------ | ------------- | ------- | --------------- | --------------- | -| der the NRRP | MUR | program | funded by | the “NextGener- | -ationEU”. - -References Christen,P.;Hand,D.J.;andKirielle,N. 2023. Areviewof -| | | | | | | | thef-measure: | | Itshistory,properties,criticism,andalter- | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Adams, | G.; Fabbri, | A.; | Ladhak, | F.; Lehman, | E.; | and El- | | | | | | | | -| hadad, | N. 2023. | From | sparse | to dense: | GPT-4 | summa- | natives. | | | | | | | -InProceedings -rizationwithchainofdensityprompting. Comanici, G.; Bieber, E.; and et al., M. S. 2025. Gemini -ofthe4thNewFrontiersinSummarizationWorkshop,68– 2.5: Pushingthefrontierwithadvancedreasoning,multi- -74. AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. modality,longcontext,andnextgenerationagenticcapa- -bilities. -Alviano,M.;Calimeri,F.;Charwat,G.;Dao-Tran,M.;Do- -daro, C.; Ianni, G.; Krennwallner, T.; Kronegger, M.; Coppolillo,E.;Calimeri,F.;Manco,G.;Perri,S.;andRicca, -Oetsch, J.; Pfandler, A.; Pu¨hrer, J.; Redl, C.; Ricca, F.; F. 2024. Llasp: fine-tuning large language models for -| | | | | | | | answer | set programming. | | In Proceedings | | of the | 21st In- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -Schneider,P.;Schwengerer,M.;Spendier,L.K.;Wallner, -J.P.;andXiao,G. 2013. Thefourthanswersetprogram- ternationalConferenceonPrinciplesofKnowledgeRep- -ming competition: Preliminary report. In LPNMR, vol- resentationandReasoning,KR’24. -ume8148ofLectureNotesinComputerScience,42–53. -| | | | | | | | Dakhel, | A. M.; | Majdinasab, | V.; Nikanjam, | | A.; Khomh, | F.; | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -Springer. -| | | | | | | | Desmarais,M.C.;andJiang,Z.M.J. | | | | | 2023. Githubcopi- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -Alviano,M.;Calimeri,F.;Dodaro,C.;Fusca`,D.;Leone,N.; lotAIpairprogrammer: Assetorliability? -Perri, S.; Ricca, F.; Veltri, P.; andZangari, J. 2017. The DeepSeek. 2025. Deepseek-r1: Incentivizingreasoningca- -ASPsystemDLV2. InLPNMR,volume10377ofLNCS, pabilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. -| 215–221. | Springer. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Ding,Y.;Wang,Z.;Ahmad,W.U.;Ding,H.;Tan,M.;Jain, -Alviano,M.;Cirimele,D.;andReiners,L.A.R. 2023. In- N.; Ramanathan, M. K.; Nallapati, R.; Bhatia, P.; Roth, -troducingASPrecipesandASPchef.InICLPWorkshops, D.; and Xiang, B. 2023. Crosscodeeval: A diverse and -volume3437ofCEURWP. CEUR-WS.org. multilingualbenchmarkforcross-filecodecompletion. -Amendola,G.;Mazzotta,G.;Ricca,F.;andBerei,T. 2024. Du, X.; Liu, M.; Wang, K.; Wang, H.; Liu, J.; Chen, Y.; -Unit testing in ASP revisited: Language and test-driven Feng,J.;Sha,C.;Peng,X.;andLou,Y. 2024. Evaluating -developmentenvironment. largelanguagemodelsinclass-levelcodegeneration. In -ProceedingsoftheIEEE/ACM46thInternationalConfer- -| Anthropic. | 2024. | Claude3.5sonnetmodelcardaddendum. | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -enceonSoftwareEngineering,ICSE’24. -Baral,C.,andDzifcak,J.2011.Solvingpuzzlesdescribedin -| | | | | | | | Erdem,E.,andYeniterzi,R. | | | 2009. | Transformingcontrolled | | | -| ------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -| english | by automated | | translation | to answer | set program- | | | | | | | | | -naturallanguagebiomedicalqueriesintoanswersetpro- -| ming | and learning | how | to do | that translation. | | In AAAI | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | ------------ | --------------------------------- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | | | | | grams. | InBioNLP@HLT-NAACL,117–124. | | | | ACL. | | -| FallSymposium: | | AdvancesinCognitiveSystems,volume | | | | | | | | | | | | -FS-11-01ofAAAITechnicalReport. AAAI. Erdem,E.;Gelfond,M.;andLeone,N. 2016. Applications -ofanswersetprogramming. -| Bauer, J. | J.; Eiter, | T.; Ruiz, | N. H.; | and Oetsch, | J. | 2024. | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Visual graph question answering with ASP and llms for Ernst,N.A.,andBavota,G. 2022. Ai-drivendevelopment -| | | | | | | | ishere: | Shouldyouworry? | | | | | | -| -------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| language | parsing. | In | ICLP, volume | 416 | of EPTCS, | 15– | | | | | | | | -28. Falkner, A. A.; Friedrich, G.; Schekotihin, K.; Taupe, R.; -| | | | | | | | andTeppan,E.C. | | 2018. | Industrialapplicationsofanswer | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| Borroto, | M.; Kareem, | I.; | and Ricca, | F. 2024. | Towards | au- | | | | | | | | -setprogramming. -| tomatic | composition | of | ASP programs | | from natural | lan- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -guage specifications. In IJCAI, volume abs/2403.04541, Fang, M., and Tompits, H. 2017. An approach for repre- -toappear. ijcai.org. senting answer sets in natural language. In DECLARE, -| | | | | | | | volume10997ofLNCS,115–131. | | | | Springer. | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | -------------------------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | -| Brewka,G.;Eiter,T.;andTruszczynski,M. | | | | | 2011. | Answer | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Febbraro, | O.; | Reale, | K.; and Ricca, | F. | 2011. | ASPIDE: | -setprogrammingataglance. -| | | | | | | | integrated | development | | environment | | for answer | set pro- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | -Busoniu,P.;Oetsch,J.;Pu¨hrer,J.;Skocovsky,P.;andTom- -| | | | | | | | gramming. | | InLPNMR,volume6645ofLNCS,317–330. | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| pits,H. | 2013. | Sealion: | Aneclipse-basedIDEforanswer- | | | | | | | | | | | -Springer. -setprogrammingwithadvanceddebuggingsupport. -| | | | | | | | Gebser, | M.; Kaminski, | | R.; Kaufmann, | | B.; Ostrowski, | M.; | -| --------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------ | -------------- | ---- | -| Calimeri, | F.; Germano, | | S.; Palermiti, | E.; | Reale, | K.; and | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Schaub, | T.; | and Wanko, | P. 2016. | Theory | solving | made | -Ricca,F. 2018. DevelopingASPprogramswithASPIDE easy with clingo 5. In ICLP (Technical Communica- -andloide. Ku¨nstlicheIntell.32(2-3):185–186. tions),volume52ofOASIcs,2:1–2:15. SchlossDagstuhl -Calimeri,F.; Ianni,G.; andRicca,F. 2014. Thethirdopen -Leibniz-Zentrumfu¨rInformatik. -answersetprogrammingcompetition. Gebser, M.; Maratea, M.; and Ricca, F. 2017. The sixth -Caruso, S.; Dodaro, C.; Maratea, M.; Mochi, M.; and Ric- answersetprogrammingcompetition. -| cio, F. | 2024. | CNL2ASP: | converting | controlled | | natural | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Gebser,M.; | Maratea,M.; | | andRicca,F. | | 2020. Theseventh | | -languagesentencesintoASP. answersetprogrammingcompetition:Designandresults. -Chen, M.; Tworek, J.; and et al., H. J. 2021. Evaluating Gelfond, M., andLifschitz, V. 1991. Classicalnegationin -largelanguagemodelstrainedoncode. logicprogramsanddisjunctivedatabases. - -Grattafiori,A.,andetal.,A.D. 2024. Thellama3herdof Ou, J.; Lu, J.; Liu, C.; Tang, Y.; Zhang, F.; Zhang, D.; and -| models. | | | | | | | Gai,K.2024.DialogBench:EvaluatingLLMsashuman- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Hahn,S.;Sabuncu,O.;Schaub,T.;andStolzmann,T. 2023. like dialogue systems. In Proceedings of the 2024 Con- -ferenceoftheNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociation -| Clingraph: | Asystemforasp-basedvisualization. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | for Computational | | Linguistics: | | Human | Language | | Tech- | -Ishay, A.; Yang, Z.; and Lee, J. 2023a. Leveraging large nologies(Volume1: LongPapers). MexicoCity,Mexico: -languagemodelstogenerateanswersetprograms.InPro- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. -| ceedings | of the | 20th | International | | Conference | on Prin- | | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ------------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | Peng, S.; | Kalliamvakou, | | E.; | Cihon, | P.; and | Demirer, | M. | -| ciples | of Knowledge | | Representation | | and Reasoning, | KR | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | 2023. | The impact | of | AI on | developer | productivity: | | Ev- | -’23. -idencefromgithubcopilot. -| Ishay, A.; | Yang, | Z.; and | Lee, | J. 2023b. | Leveraging | large | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | ----- | ------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | -------------------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | ------------------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | Qin, L.; | Chen, Q.; | Feng, | X.; Wu, | Y.; | Zhang, | Y.; Li, | Y.; Li, | -| languagemodelstogenerateanswersetprograms. | | | | | | InKR, | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | M.;Che,W.;andYu,P.S. | | | 2024. | Largelanguagemodels | | | | -374–383. -| | | | | | | | meetnlp: | Asurvey. | | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------ | -| Jiang,J.;Wang,F.;Shen,J.;Kim,S.;andKim,S. | | | | | | 2024. A | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Raiaan, | M. A. K.; | Mukta, | M. | S. H.; | Fatema, | K.; | Fahad, | -surveyonlargelanguagemodelsforcodegeneration. -| | | | | | | | N.M.; | Sakib, | S.; Mim, | M.M.J.; | Ahmad, | | J.; Ali, | M.E.; | -| --------------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | ----------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | -| Kalliamvakou,E. | | 2022. | Research: | quantifyinggithubcopi- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | andAzam,S. | | 2024. | Areviewonlargelanguagemodels: | | | | | -lot’simpactondeveloperproductivityandhappiness. Architectures, applications, taxonomies, open issues and -challenges. -| Kareem, | I.; Gallagher, | | K.; Borroto, | M. | A.; Ricca, | F.; and | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Russo, A. 2024. Using learning from answer sets for Rajasekharan, A.; Zeng, Y.; Padalkar, P.; and Gupta, G. -robustquestionansweringwithLLM.InLPNMR,volume 2023. Reliablenaturallanguageunderstandingwithlarge -| 15245 | of Lecture | Notes | in Computer | | Science, | 112–125. | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -languagemodelsandanswersetprogramming. -Springer. -| | | | | | | | Ren, L.; | Xiao, G.; | Qi, | G.; Geng, | Y.; | and | Xue, H. | 2025. | -| -------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | -| Kuhn, T. | 2014. | A survey | and | classification | | of controlled | | | | | | | | | -Canllmssolveaspproblems?insightsfromabenchmark- -naturallanguages. ingstudy. InProceedingsofthe22ndInternationalCon- -| | | | | | | | ference | on Principles | | of Knowledge | | Representation | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -Law,M.;Russo,A.;andBroda,K.2020.TheILASPsystem -Reasoning,KR’25. -forinductivelearningofanswersetprograms. -| | | | | | | | Schrader, | T. P.; | Lange, | L.; Kaminski, | | T.; | Razniewski, | S.; | -| --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| Lippolis, | A. S.; | Saeedizade, | M. | J.; Keskisa¨rkka¨, | | R.; Zup- | | | | | | | | | -piroli, S.; Ceriani, M.; Gangemi, A.; Blomqvist, E.; and andFriedrich,A. 2025. Asolver-in-the-loopframework -Nuzzolese,A.G. 2025. Ontologygenerationusinglarge forimprovingllmsonanswersetprogrammingforlogic -InESWC(1),volume15718ofLecture puzzlesolving. CoRRabs/2512.17093. -languagemodels. -NotesinComputerScience,321–341. Springer. Schwitter, R. 2018. Specifying and verbalising answer set -programsincontrollednaturallanguage. -| Liu,T.;Xu,C.;andMcAuley,J. | | | | 2023. | Repobench: | Bench- | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -markingrepository-levelcodeauto-completionsystems. Shah,N.;Genc,Z.;andAraci,D. 2025. Stackeval: bench- -Ma, Z.; Guo, H.; Chen, J.; Peng, G.; Cao, Z.; Ma, Y.; and marking llms in coding assistance. In Proceedings of -Gong, Y.-J. 2024. Llamoco: Instruction tuning of large the38thInternationalConferenceonNeuralInformation -languagemodelsforoptimizationcodegeneration. ProcessingSystems,NIPS’24. -Mitra, A., and Baral, C. 2016. Addressing a question an- Smirnov, P.; Joublin, F.; Ceravola, A.; and Gienger, M. -| | | | | | | | 2024. | Generating | consistent | | PDDL | domains | with | large | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | -sweringchallengebycombiningstatisticalmethodswith -languagemodels. -| inductive | rule | learning | and | reasoning. | In | AAAI, 2779– | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2785. AAAIPress. -| | | | | | | | Team, G., | and et | al., P. | G. 2024. | | Gemini | 1.5: | Unlock- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------- | -Naveed, H.; Khan, A. U.; Qiu, S.; Saqib, M.; Anwar, S.; ing multimodal understanding across millions of tokens -| Usman,M.; | Akhtar,N.; | | Barnes,N.; | | andMian,A. | 2024. | ofcontext. | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Acomprehensiveoverviewoflargelanguagemodels. Valmeekam,K.;Stechly,K.;Gundawar,A.;andKambham- -pati,S.2025.Asystematicevaluationoftheplanningand -| Nye, M. | I.; Tessler, | M. | H.; Tenenbaum, | | J. B.; | and Lake, | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -schedulingabilitiesofthereasoningmodelo1. -B.M.2021.Improvingcoherenceandconsistencyinneu- -ral sequence models with dual-system, neuro-symbolic Vaswani, A.; Shazeer, N.; Parmar, N.; Uszkoreit, J.; Jones, -| reasoning. | InNeurIPS,25192–25204. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -| | | | | | | | L.;Gomez,A.N.;Kaiser,L.u.;andPolosukhin,I. | | | | | | | 2017. | -Oetsch, J.; Prischink, M.; Pu¨hrer, J.; Schwengerer, M.; and Attention is all you need. In Guyon, I.; Luxburg, U. V.; -Tompits, H. 2012. On the small-scope hypothesis for Bengio, S.; Wallach, H.; Fergus, R.; Vishwanathan, S.; -| | | | | | | | and Garnett, | R., | eds., | Advances | in | Neural | Information | | -| -------------------------- | ------ | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --------------------- | ------ | ----------- | ---- | -| testinganswer-setprograms. | | | | InKR. | AAAIPress. | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | ProcessingSystems,volume30. | | | | CurranAssociates,Inc. | | | | -| OpenAI. | 2024. | Gpt-4osystemcard. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Voboril,F.;Ramaswamy,V.P.;andSzeider,S. | | | | | | 2025. | Gen- | -| OpenAI. | 2025a. | Introducinggpt-5. | | | | | | | | | | | | | -eratingstreamliningconstraintswithlargelanguagemod- -OpenAI. 2025b. Introducingopenaio3ando4-mini. els. J.Artif.Intell.Res.84. - -Wang,Y.;Le,H.;Gotmare,A.D.;Bui,N.D.Q.;Li,J.;and -| Hoi,S.C.H. | | 2023. Codet5+: | | Opencodelargelanguage | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -modelsforcodeunderstandingandgeneration. -| Xu, F. F.; | Alon, | U.; Neubig, | G.; | and Hellendoorn, | | V. J. | -| ---------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | -2022. Asystematicevaluationoflargelanguagemodels -| ofcode. | InProceedingsofthe6thACMSIGPLANInter- | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | -| national | Symposium | on | Machine | Programming, | | MAPS | -| 2022,1–10. | NewYork,NY,USA:AssociationforCom- | | | | | | -putingMachinery. -| Xu,K.;Mao,Y.;Guan,X.;andFeng,Z. | | | | 2025. | Web-bench: | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -Allmcodebenchmarkbasedonwebstandardsandframe- -works. -| Yang, Z.; | Ishay, | A.; andLee, | J. | 2023. Couplinglargelan- | | | -| --------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -guagemodelswithlogicprogrammingforrobustandgen- -| eralreasoningfromtext. | | | InACL(Findings),5186–5219. | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -ACL. -| Zhao, W.X.; | Zhou, | K.; andetal., | | J.L. 2025. | Asurveyof | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -largelanguagemodels. -| Zhou, Y.; | Ringeval, | F.; and | Portet, | F. 2025. | Can | gpt mod- | -| -------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -| elsfollowhumansummarizationguidelines? | | | | | astudyfor | | -targetedcommunicationgoals. \ No newline at end of file +FITNESS TRACKER +SF-206 + +Manual + +Please read this manual before use. + +Visit us at +www.slideusa.com +or contact us at +support@slideusa.com + + SAFETY WARNING +• Please charge the Fitness +tracker with the provided +charging clamp for at least +two hours prior to its first use. + +PRODUCT OVERVIEW + +1 __ + +_ +_ + +2 ____________ + +__ +4 + +3a._________ + +3b. ________ + +Fatigue Monitor +Touch Sensor + +1. +2. +3a. Charging Contacts +3b. Charging Contacts +4. Charging Clamp + + DETACHABLE WRISTBAND +This device comes with a detachable +wristbands. To remove the wristband +locate the metallic pin on the edge of +the wristband where it meets the +watch. Pull the pin sideways and the +wristband will automatically detach +from the watch. + +________ Pin + +GETTING STARTED +Powering On/Off: Power the fitness +tracker On/Off, by touching and +holding the touch sensor. +Charging: The fitnesses Tracker +comes with its own USB compatible +charger. To charge the device +plug the USB charging clamp into +a USB slot. Then clamp the fitness +tracker into the charger. +Note: Make sure that the charging +contacts on the clamp and the +fitness tracker are aligned. + + Touch Sensor: Available functions +will be shown on the screen and +can be navigated through by +simply touching or touching and +holding the touch sensor under the +screen. +Downloading The App: To use the +SF-206 as +intended the +user should +download the +Lefun Health +app using the +provided QR +code. +Note: If the App is not downloaded +some features of the device may +not be usable. +Enabling All features: Before first +use, the user should enable all +features of the device. This is done +while in the Health section by +navigating to the menu in the +top left side of the screen and +selecting both Band Function +Settings and Message Reminder. + + Pairing Instructions: To pair the +Fitnesses tracker and the user's +phone follow the below instructions. + +1. Open the Lefun Health App +and while in the Health +section navigate to the +menu in the top left side of +the screen and select Device +Name/Connection Status. + +2. The user will be asked to +provide Lefun Health +permission to access several of +the phone's features. For the +Fitness Tracker to operate as +intended the user should allow +the device all permissions. +3. While on the pairing page the + +user will see all devices +compatible with the Lefun +Heath app listed. If the user +does not see their fitness +tracker they should take the +following steps. +A. Make sure that the fitness +tracker is powered on. +B.. Press t +B. Press the search button +to begin scanning for a signal. +4. Select the fitness tracker from + +the available list to pair. + + Restore factory Settings: To restore +factory settings touch and hold the +touch button while on the "About" +page of the fitness tracker. The user +will see a prompt saying "Long Press +Restore Factory Settings." To confirm +the reset touch and hold the touch +sensor again. The fitness tracker will +then automatically restore itself to +factory settings. + +MENU SETTINGS +Menu Features: The fitness tracker +has several features that can be +changed on the app by navigating +to the health page and selecting +the menu option in the top left side +of the screen. These features +include but are not limited to, + +Menu __ + +• Smart Alarm - After the alarm is +set the watch will vibrate at the +appointed time. + +• Message Notification - The fitness +tracker will vibrate when the +user's phone receives a message +or call. Note: This feature must be +turned on manually. + + • Search Device: The user can +locate the lost fitness tracker +(make it vibrate) by selecting this +option. + +• Shake For A Selfie: Select this + +feature to access the camera on +the user's phone. Next, shake the +fitness tracker to take a photo. +Note: Photos will be saved on the +user's phone. + +• Band Function Settings: + +A. Sedentary Reminder: The + +fitness tracker will +automatically provide the user +a warning should they remain +sedentary for too long. +B. Reminder for drinking: The + +fitness tracker will +automatically provide the user +with a reminder to drink water +at regular intervals. + +C. Screen Up Upon Raising: +Quickly view the time or +messages without tapping the +screen or pressing the +multifunction button. To use it +just turn your wrist towards you +and the screen will be +displayed for a few seconds. + + D. Smart Anti-lost: Turn On/Off +Smart Anti Lost Setting. + +Note: The following features may +not work as intended if the user +has not turned them on. + +WATERPROOFING + +Your Fitness tracker is water- +resistant, rain-proof, splash-proof +and can stand up to even the +sweatiest workout. +NOTE: Do not swim or shower with +your wristband. Though water +won't damage the device, it +should be dried thoroughly after +coming into contact with any +water. + +FEATURES +While on the Home Screen of the +device touch the touch sensor to + + navigate through the available +apps. + +103 + +83 + +Home +Screen: +press and +hold the +touch sensor +to switch + +between the available home +screen displays as shown above. + +10325 +STEPS + +Pedometer: +Records the +number of steps the +user is taking during +a 24 hour period. +This information is +accessible on both +the fitness tracker + +and the app. Note: The step counter +is reset to zero at midnight. + +Exercise: Records +the amount of time +the user has +exercised. Note: The +time exercised is +reset to zero at +midnight. Note: The +user can select +between the + + following four exerciser options. +1. Running +2. Badminton +3. Climbing +4. Bicycling + +99 + +Heart rate monitor: +Measures the +wearer's current +resting heart rate +and displays that +data as the number +of heartbeats per + +minute (BPM). Note: Data will be +saved in the app + +87 + +131 + +99 + +SPO2 Test: Measures +the amount of +oxygen in the blood +(sp02) Note: data +not recorded in the +app. + +Blood Pressure: +Measures the +wearer's current +Blood pressure. Note: +Normal Blood +pressure is 120/80. + + Additional Features: The fitness +tracker has several additional +features including Find Phone, +Messages, Details about the device, +QR Code, and the Power Off +feature. +After the App has been successfully +downloaded, the user should be +sure to pair the fitness tracker to +their phone using the app. + +Enabling All features: App: +(Necessary For Messages, Calls, +and Reminders) +Before first use the user should +enable all features of the device. +This is done while in the Health +section by navigating to the +menu in the top left side of the +screen and selecting both Band +Function Settings and Message +Reminder. + +Enabling All features: Phone: +(Necessary For Messages, Calls, and +Reminders) +Some features may not work as +intended if the user has not enabled +"Lefun Health" on their phone. To do +this the user should open their +phone's settings and select + + Notifications and Accessibility from +the following options. Find "Lefun +Health" and enable the Apps to +Access your phone. +Note: This is detailed in the image on +the next page. +Note: As the settings page on +phones varies from type to type. The +above instructions and included +images may not directly reflect the +appropriate method of enabling all +features on the user's phone. + + Important + +Iphone + +Android + + GENERAL INFORMATION +Environmental Conditions +Operating Temperature: 14°F-122° +F:-4°C-14°C + +Size +The wristbands have an adjustable +circumference and will fit anyone +who has a wrist between 5.5 and .5 +inches. +Disposal and Recycling +The user should be aware that it is +the consumer’s responsibility to +properly dispose of and recycle the +SmartWatch and accompanying +components. Do not dispose of the +SmartWatch with common +household waste as it is considered +electronic waste and should be +disposed of at your local electronic +equipment collection facility. + +APP - HEALTH SECTION +While in the health section the user +may select the menu in the top left +side of the screen or navigate to +other pages of the health section +by swiping left. + + Today's Data + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +The number of steps taken, calories +burned, distance traveled, hours +slept, blood pressure, and heart rate +are all displayed here. + + Pedometer + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +The number of steps taken, calories +burned, and distance traveled are all +displayed here + + Sleep Monitor + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The sleep Monitor only works so +long as the user is wearing the +fitnesses tracker when they are +asleep. + + Heart Rate + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The user may check their +heart rate using the app by pressing +"Start To Measure." This will +automatically activate the fitness +trackers heart rate monitor. + + Blood Pressure + +_ +_ +___ +_ +_ +Menu + +Note: The user may check their +blood pressure using the app by +pressing "Start To Measure." This will +automatically activate the fitness +trackers blood pressure monitor. + + App - Sports + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Sports +History + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ + +Slide To +Unlock + +While on the sports page the user will +see the above icons. Pressing the blue +icon will immediately begin tracking +both the route and distance traveled. +While tracking, the user will see the +bellow icons. Press the below blue +icon to stop tracking. + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Sports +Settings + +_ +_ +_ +_ +_ +Map + + Data: While on the Sports page the +user will see the following +information displayed. Travel +Distance, Speed in min/km, Calories +burned in Kcal, and Elevation +change in Meters. +Sports Features: +History : Records the user workout +history. +Settings : Allows the user to set +Calorie targets, or adjust +countdown settings. +Begin Tracking : Actively begins +tracking distance traveled, speed, +calories burned, and route traveled. +Note: When tracking has begun the +phone screen will automatically +lock. To Unlock the screen press +and the user will be prompted to +"Slide To Unlock" the screen. +To access route tracking via the +map press . +Press button and the user will be +prompted with and . Pressing +the first one will continue tracking +and pressing the second one will +end the workout and record the +data in the sports history section. + + App - Trend + + App - My Data + +Users Personal +information can +be edited here. + +- +- +- +- +- +- +- + +------------ + +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- +- + +--- + +----Device Information + +----Set fitness targets + +----Frequently Asked Questions + +----Check For Updates + + This device complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is subject to the following two +conditions: (1) this device may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept +any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. +Any changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party responsible for compliance +could void the user's authority to operate the equipment. +NOTE: This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits for a Class B +digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These limits are designed to provide +reasonable protection against harmful interference in a residential installation. This equipment +generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed and used in +accordance with the instructions, may cause harmful interference to radio communications. +However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a particular installation. +If this equipment does cause harmful interference to radio or television reception, +which can be determined by turning the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to +correct the interference by one or more of the following measures: +-- Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. +-- Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. +-- Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different + +from that to which the receiver is connected. + +-- Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. +The device has been evaluated to meet general RF exposure requirement. The device can be u +sed in portable exposure condition without restriction +FCC ID: 2AJVKSF206 + diff --git a/q41/random_k4/random_3.md b/q41/random_k4/random_3.md index fb64203d8a243ec37ab081d2d7a16c47c7257c0d..1baafa3214e3d1c3ba84ae8c4e451072ec71f1c5 100644 --- a/q41/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q41/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,739 +1,891 @@ -**==> picture [81 x 21] intentionally omitted <==** - -# **AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X** - -Haiwen Li Michiel A. Bakker - -Massachusetts Institute of Technology - -## **Abstract.** - -Large language models (LLMs) show promising capabilities for contextual facton social media: can contested claims re- checking they verify through deep search, synthesize evidence from multiple sources, and draft explanations at scale. However, prior work evaluates LLM fact-checking only in controlled settings usbenchmarks or crowdworker how these ing judgments, leaving open systems perform in authentic platform environments. We present the first field evaluation of LLM-based fact-checking deployed on a live social media platform, testing performance directly through X Community Notes’ “AI writer” feature over a threemonth period. Our LLM writer, a multi-step pipeline that handles multimodal content (text, images, and videos), conducts web and platform-native search, and writes contextual notes, was deployed to write 1,614 notes on 1,597 tweets and compared against 1,332 human-written notes on the same tweets using 108,169 ratings from 42,521 raters. Direct comparison of note-level platform outcomes is complicated by differences in submission timing and rating exposure between LLM and human notes; we therefore pursue two complementary strategies: a rating-level analysis modeling individual rater evaluations, and a note-level analysis that equalizes rater exposure across note types. Rating-level analysis shows that LLM notes receive more positive ratings than human notes across raters with different political viewpoints, suggesting the potential for LLM-written notes to achieve the cross-partisan consensus. Note-level analysis confirms this advantage: among raters who evaluated all notes on the same post, LLM notes achieve significantly higher helpfulness scores. Our findings demonstrate that LLMs can contribute high-quality, broadly helpful fact-checking at scale, while highlighting that real-world evaluation requires careful attention to platform dynamics absent from controlled settings. - -## **1 Introduction** - -Social media on mechanisms to add con- platforms increasingly rely community-based text to potentially misleading content. X Community Notes exemplifies this approach - -1 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -(Wojcik et al., 2022): users propose short, source-cited notes to add context to posts, and community ratings from a diverse group of raters determine whether a note is “broadly helpful” and should be shown publicly. This design creates a stringent alignment target that rewards neutral, evidence-grounded, cross-perspective explanations. Communitybased fact-checking has also been examined to increase trust in fact-checking on social media and to reduce misinformation diffusion and engagement with misleading content (Drolsbach et al., 2024; Slaughter et al., 2025). - -The core tasks of note authorship—researching relevant information, analyzing competing evidence, and writing clear factual explanations—align closely with capabilities where large language models have shown promise. Prior work finds that LLMs can generate fact-checking notes comparable to, and under certain conditions better than, human-written notes while requiring far less time and effort (Zhou et al., 2024; De et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2026). However, existing evaluations of LLM-based fact-checking remain offline: performance is measured against automated benchmarks, expert annotations, or crowdworker judgments in controlled settings (Zhou et al., 2024; De et al., 2025; Costabile et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2026). Crowdworker evaluations in particular are susceptible to demand effects where people evaluate content in ways they believe the study expects rather than reflecting genuine judgement (Mummolo and Peterson, 2019; Iarygina et al., 2025). Hence, these evaluations fail to capture the on-platform dynamics such as timing, interface presentation, limited user attention, and subjective judging criteria that shape real-world impact. A critical gap therefore remains: we lack evidence on how LLM-generated fact-checks perform in situ, where their ultimate efficacy is determined not by gold-standard labels but on the dynamics of a live platform environment. - -We present the first field evaluation of LLM fact-check writing deployed on-platform. X’s recently released Community Notes “AI writer” API enables users to build AI writers that propose notes on potentially misleading posts flagged by human users.[1] Notes generated by the system are clearly labeled as AI-created and are evaluated under the same crowd-sourced rating criteria as human-written notes. We developed and deployed our own LLM-based Community Notes writer on X through the “AI writer” API. This LLM writer conducts web search and platform-native search to collect information, assesses whether sufficient evidence exists to warrant a note, generates contextual notes, applies quality control filters, and publishes notes directly to the platform. The writer also handles multimodal posts that include images and videos. Over a three-month deployment period (November 1, 2025 to January 31, 2026), our LLM writer published 1,614 notes on 1,597 unique tweets, which we compared against 1,332 human-written notes on the same tweets, drawing on 108,169 ratings from 42,521 Community Notes raters. While there are - -> 1https://communitynotes.x.com/guide/en/api/overview - -2 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -multiple AI writers operating on the platform, we focus on evaluating our own writer because we can document and its our results to be fully open-source pipeline, enabling interpreted in light of specific, reproducible design decisions. - -Our analysis reveals several key findings. First, direct comparison of note-level platform outcomes between LLM and human notes is complicated by systematic differences in submission timing due to platform design. Because notes submitted later receive fewer ratings and the platform’s algorithm penalizes notes with fewer ratings, these timing differences can bias comparisons. We therefore pursue two analytical strategies. In our primary, rating-level analysis, we show that LLM notes receive uniformly more positive evaluations from raters across the political spectrum, suggesting LLM-generated content may be likely to achieve the cross-partisan consensus that Community Notes seeks to foster. In a complementary note-level analysis that equalizes rater exposure across note types, LLM notes achieve significantly higher helpfulness scores than human notes. We additionally find that the LLM advantage varies by topic: it is largest for health and medicine content and conspiracy theories/pseudoscience, and smallest for posts about AI-generated content. - -Our contributions are threefold. Methodologically, we provide the first evaluation of LLM fact-checking in a real-world platform setting with organic user feedback, moving beyond laboratory studies, synthetic benchmarks, and proxy metrics to assess performance under authentic conditions, providing ecological validity. Practically, we open-source our writer and which were implementation, including prompts multi-step writing pipeline, developed and refined over a month to improve evidence retrieval, prompt quality, and pipeline structure.[2] Empirically, our findings demonstrate that LLMs can contribute highquality fact-checking annotations at scale, achieving broader cross-ideological acceptance than human-written notes, suggesting that automated systems can meet or exceed human performance on the demanding standard of broad helpfulness. We also discuss factors that complicate note helpfulness measures on a platform: note creation timing and differential exposures shape platform-level outcomes beyond intrinsic note helpfulness, suggesting that the true effects of AI writing in the wild are more complicated than those measured in lab settings. - -> 2 Code for the writing pipeline and analysis is available at https://github.com/haiwen-li/cn-ai-writer. - -3 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **2 Results** - -## **2.1 Platform Dynamics Complicate Note-Level Comparisons** - -X Community Notes uses a matrix factorization–based bridging algorithm to aggregate ratings from individual users and evaluate note quality.[3] Rather than relying on simthe scores to notes that re- ple majority voting, algorithm assigns higher helpfulness ceive “helpful” ratings from raters who have historically disagreed in their past ratings. This design surfaces notes that are broadly acceptable across different viewpoints, and notes whose helpfulness scores exceed a platform-defined threshold receive the Currently Rated Helpful (CRH) status and become publicly visible on the platform. - -note scores and CRH status intuitive mea- Although helpfulness provide performance sures, comparing LLM and human-written notes using these metrics is complicated by platform dynamics that are unrelated to intrinsic note helpfulness. The Community Notes algorithm implicitly penalizes notes with fewer ratings and deflates their helpfulness scores,[4] yet the number of ratings a note receives depends heavily on when it is submitted. Earlier notes gain more exposure through longer visibility and higher UI ranking, which in turn increases rating accumulation. At present, LLM notes face a systematic exposure disadvantage. While human writers can propose notes whenever they notice misleading posts, LLM writers can only retrieve and write notes on posts after enough users have flagged them as potentially misleading (this is a current platform policy constraint rather than a limitation of LLM fact-checking itself). Among the 814 tweets receiving both note types in our data, 66.0% of human notes were created before the LLM notes. As a result, human notes accumulated substantially more ratings (mean = 109.94 vs. 59.50; median = 51 vs. 22; Mann–Whitney _U_ = 740,798.0, _p <_ 0.001). This temporal asymmetry implies that note-level metrics differences in driven submission may partly reflect exposure by timing, rather than differences in note helpfulness alone. - -To address these confounds, we pursue two analytical strategies. First, we conduct analyses at the rating level, where each observation corresponds to an individual user’s explicit evaluation of a note (helpful, somewhat helpful, or unhelpful). These ratings provide the ground truth of user judgment. We model individual ratings while accounting for raters’ political ideology, aligning with the bridging principle underlying Community Notes. We treat this rating-level analysis as our primary analysis because it uses the full set of available ratings and, by construction, isolates note helpfulness from platform-level ex- - -> 3https://communitynotes.x.com/guide/en/under-the-hood/ranking-notes#matrix-factorization - -> 4Community Notes computes note helpfulness scores via matrix factorization with regularization that penalizes the note intercept term with a fixed shrinkage toward zero. This penalty is constant regardless of how many ratings a note receives, but the data signal that pushes the intercept away from zero scales with rating count. As a result, notes with fewer ratings have insufficient data to overcome the regularization pressure, leading to systematically deflated helpfulness scores. - -4 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -posure effects. Second, we perform a note-level analysis designed to equalize exposure across LLM and human notes, by re-calculating helpfulness scores using only ratings from raters who saw and rated all notes on a given tweet, equalizing exposure across LLM and human notes before applying the Community Notes matrix factorization-based bridging algorithm. - -## **2.2 LLM Notes Receive More Positive Ratings Across the Ideological Spectrum** - -Community Notes is designed around the principle of “bridging”: a note is considered helpful if it is rated as such by raters with different viewpoints, and operationalizes it by estimating a numeric factor for each rater that captures systematic differences in rating behavior. In practice, this rater factor aligns closely with political ideology, with negative values corresponding to left-leaning rating patterns and positive values to right-leaning ones (Wojcik et al., 2022). Motivated by this design, our rating-level analysis examines how individual raters evaluate LLM notes versus human-written notes across the ideological spectrum. By leveraging the rater factor, we test whether LLM notes receive more positive ratings that hold across raters with different inferred political viewpoints—the core criterion by which Community Notes defines helpfulness. - -**==> picture [422 x 251] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Figure 1:** Mean % helpful and % unhelpful ratings per note for LLM and human notes, stratified by rater ideology group (left, neutral, right). Error bars show 95% confidence intervals across notes. - -5 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -To examine whether rating patterns varied across the political spectrum, we stratified raters into three ideology groups based on their rater factor: left (factor _< −_ 0.15), neutral _−_ ( 0.15 _≤_ factor _≤_ 0.15), and right (factor _>_ 0.15). For each note and ideology group, we computed the percentage of ratings marked helpful and not helpful, then aggregated across notes to obtain mean percentages with 95% confidence intervals. Results are pre1. sented in Figure LLM notes have higher avg. % helpful ratings and lower avg. % unhelpful ratings than human notes across all rater ideology groups. The largest difference appears among neutral raters, followed by left-leaning raters, and right-leaning raters. - -To quantify differences in individual ratings between LLM and human notes, we estimated a linear mixed effects model predicting individual rating scores from LLM writer authorship, rater political leaning, and their interactions. This analysis mirrors the “bridging” principle of Community Notes algorithm by modeling how the LLM advantage varies as a function of rater ideology, and the extremity of their ideology. Community Notes allows users to rate each note as Helpful, Somewhat Helpful, or Not Helpful; following the platform convention, we coded these responses numerically as 1.0, 0.5, and 0.0, respectively. Specifically, we use the following primary specification: - -**==> picture [408 x 35] intentionally omitted <==** - -where AI = 1 for LLM notes and 0 for human notes, and coreRaterFactor1 is each rater’s ideology factor, with negative values indicating left-leaning rating patterns and positive values indicating right-leaning patterns. The model includes both the linear and quadratic forms of the ideology factor, each interacted with LLM authorship, to allow the LLM effect to vary asymmetrically across the political spectrum, consistent with patterns 1. observed in Figure The linear ideology term and its interaction with LLM capture directional differences in whether the LLM advantage is larger among left- or right-leaning raters. The quadratic term and its interaction capture extremity effects in whether ratings decline and the LLM advantage narrows as raters become more ideologically extreme in either direction. Note and rater random intercepts account for within-note correlation of ratings and between-rater heterogeneity in baseline rating tendencies. Table 1 shows that LLM notes receive significantly more positive ratings at the center of the ideology spectrum (AI coefficient = 0.104, _p <_ 0.001), given that human notes’ average helpful ratings achieve around 78.5% from centrist raters, this corresponds to approximately a 10-percentage-point increase. The negative quadratic interaction indicates that this advantage is largest among moderate raters and diminishes toward both ideological extremes, while the linear interaction indicates that the advantage decreases more steeply among right-leaning raters. - -6 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -**Table 1: Rating-Level linear mixed effects model results.** To assess robustness, we estimate three additional specifications. Model 2 replaces note random intercepts with tweet random intercepts that absorbs tweet-level confounders while still identifying the AI advantage partly from within-tweet variation. Model 3 is an OLS regression with standard errors clustered by note. Model 4 replaces the continuous coreRaterFactor1 with categorical rater group (left-leaning, neutral, right-leaning; reference: neutral). The estimates of AI advantage stay consistent across all specifications. - -||Note + Rater RE|Tweet + Rater RE|OLS Clustered|Note + Rater RE
(Group)| -|---|---|---|---|---| -|(Intercept)|0.785***|0.842***|0.826***|0.785***| -||(0.006)|(0.005)|(0.003)|(0.007)| -|AI|0.104***|0.066***|0.082***|0.098***| -||(0.009)|(0.004)|(0.004)|(0.010)| -|coreRaterFactor1|-0.015***|-0.007|-0.005|| -||(0.004)|(0.004)|(0.003)|| -|coreRaterFactor12|-0.175***|-0.195***|-0.291***|| -||(0.010)|(0.010)|(0.009)|| -|AI:coreRaterFactor1|-0.087***|-0.112***|-0.120***|| -||(0.005)|(0.005)|(0.005)|| -|AI:coreRaterFactor12|-0.190***|-0.169***|-0.181***|| -||(0.013)|(0.013)|(0.014)|| -|left-leaning rater||||-0.031***| -|||||(0.005)| -|right-leaning rater||||-0.059***| -|||||(0.005)| -|AI:left-leaning rater||||-0.003| -|||||(0.007)| -|AI:right-leaning rater||||-0.086***| -|||||(0.007)| -|SD (Intercept|0.160|0.160||0.164| -|raterParticipantId)||||| -|SD (Observations)|0.304|0.335||0.304| -|SD (Intercept noteId)|0.196|||0.197| -|SD (Intercept tweetId)||0.142||| -|Num.Obs.|108169|108169|108169|108169| - - - -* _p <_ 0.05, ** _p <_ 0.01, *** _p <_ 0.001. Standard errors in parentheses. Models 1–2: model-based SEs from mixed model. Model 3: CR2 cluster-robust SEs by note. Model 4: mixed model with categorical rater group. Reference category is neutral. - -7 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -**==> picture [422 x 242] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Figure 2:** LLM vs. human note rating advantage (AI main-effect coefficient with 95% CI) by tweet modality (text-only, image, video). - -**==> picture [422 x 241] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Figure 3:** LLM vs. human note rating advantage (AI main-effect coefficient with 95% CI) by tweet topic category. - -8 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -To examine how the LLM advantage in helpfulness ratings varies across tweet types, we conducted exploratory subgroup analyses by tweet modality and topic. We used an LLM to assign a topic to each tweet based on its content (see Appendix E.4 for prompt). We subset notes by each category and re-estimated our main rating-level specification within each subset. Figures 2 and 3 present the coefficient on the LLM main effect with 95% confidence intervals. The LLM advantage is consistently positive across all three modality types but varies in magnitude: the point estimate is largest for text-only posts, followed by posts with images and videos. Topic-level heterogeneity is more pronounced. LLM notes receive better ratings on posts about health and medicine, and conspiracy theories and pseudoscience claims. Notably, LLM notes show minimal or non-significant advantages on posts about AI-generated content. These patterns suggest that the LLM writer is more effective at fact-checking claims in domains with well-established authoritative sources and clear factual grounding. - -## **2.3 Equal-Exposure Note-Level Analysis** - -The rating-level analysis demonstrates that LLM notes receive more positive individual evaluations across the ideological spectrum. We complement this with a note-level analysis to investigate whether this advantage translates into better note-level outcomes. In the full sample, the comparison shows mixed signals. LLM notes accumulate fewer ratings on average (59.50 vs. 109.94), and have a lower CRH rate (13.07% vs. 18.02%, see Appendix B), while having similar note helpfulness scores (mean: 0.25 vs. 0.24) and a lower rate of reaching Currently Rated Not Helpful status (1.12% vs. 4.13%). However, as discussed in the first section of Results, direct comparison of platform note-level outcomes is confounded by different exposures, and LLM notes are systematically submitted later and consequently accumulate fewer ratings. To address this, we construct a subset of ratings that equalizes exposure by design. For each tweet, we retain only ratings from raters who saw and rated every note on that tweet, ensuring that each note within a tweet received the same set of evaluations. We then recompute note helpfulness scores by applying the Community Notes scoring algorithm to these equal-exposure ratings alone. This yields a subset of 13,721 ratings across 1,674 notes on 663 tweets. A potential concern with this approach is that raters who evaluated all notes on a given tweet may represent a selective subset of the overall rater population. To assess this, we compare the distributions and find these raters do not differ substantially from the broader population in terms of their overall tendency to rate notes as helpful or their political leaning (see Appendix D for details). - -We then estimated the differences in re-computed note-level outcomes with a linear mixed effects model: - -outcome _∼_ AI + (1 _|_ tweetId) (2) - -9 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -where AI = 1 for LLM-written notes and 0 for human-written notes, and tweet random intercepts account for within-tweet dependence and absorb tweet-level confounders such as topic difficulty and post virality. We use mixed models rather than standard parametric tests because notes targeting the same tweet are not independent, violating the independence assumption. We use this model to analyze three note-level outcomes: note helpfulness score, CRH status, and CRNH status, and report Benjamini–Hochberg adjusted p-values. - -Under LLM notes achieve scores than equal exposure, significantly higher helpfulness human notes (mean: 0.21 vs. 0.18; AI coefficient = 0.019, _z_ = 2.944, _adj_ . _p_ = 0.010), confirming that the LLM quality advantage identified in our rating-level analysis carries through to the note-level metric once the exposure confound is removed. We also derive final rating status from the re-computed helpfulness scores: a higher proportion of LLM notes reach CRH status (2.40% compared to 1.89% for human notes) and a lower proportion reach CRNH status (0.90% compared to 1.39% for human notes), though these differences are not statistically significant. Because restricting to equal-exposure raters substantially reduces the number of ratings per note, both the note helpfulness scores and the proportion of notes reaching CRH status are lower than those observed in the full sample (see Appendix B). We report further note-level robustness checks in the Appendix C, including restricting the sample to notes with at least 30 ratings to mitigate the algorithm’s penalty on low-rating-count notes, and creation-time–matched analyses to control for differences in exposure. - -## **2.4 LLM and Human Notes Differ in Writing and Sources** - -LLM and human notes differed in both writing and source citation behaviors. LLM notes were much longer than human notes (mean 35.8 words vs. 26.9 words, _t_ = 22.190, _p <_ 0.001). The LLM writer also cited more URLs on average (mean: 1.51 vs. 1.23 URLs; _t_ = 8.67, _p <_ 0.001). Analysis of cited domains reveals distinct sourcing patterns (Tables 2a and 2b). LLM notes most frequently referenced mainstream news outlets and social media platforms, including reuters.com (7.7% of LLM notes), en.wikipedia.org (7.2%), instagram.com (5.8%), youtube.com (5.3%), x.com (4.2%), bbc.com (4.2%), snopes.com (3.9%), cnn.com (2.4%), facebook.com (2.0%), and yahoo.com (2.0%). In contrast, human notes most commonly cited x.com (18.7%), nearly four times the rate observed in LLM notes (4.2%). Wikipedia appeared at similar rates in both groups (7.6% human vs. 7.2% LLM), but other mainstream news sources appeared less frequently in human notes: reuters.com (1.6% vs. 7.7%), bbc.com (1.1% vs. 4.2%), and snopes.com (0.7% vs. 3.9%). This suggests that the LLM writer relies more heavily on traditional authoritative sources, whereas human writers more frequently reference platform-native content and social media posts. We note that this pattern characterizes our specific implementation. - -10 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **(a) Top 10 domains in LLM notes.** - -|Rank|Domain|% LLM notes citing|% human notes citing| -|---|---|---|---| -|1|reuters.com|7.7|1.6| -|2|en.wikipedia.org|7.2|7.6| -|3|instagram.com|5.8|2.0| -|4|youtube.com|5.3|3.9| -|5|x.com|4.2|18.7| -|6|bbc.com|4.2|1.1| -|7|snopes.com|3.9|0.7| -|8|cnn.com|2.4|0.8| -|9|facebook.com|2.0|0.7| -|10|yahoo.com|2.0|0.5| - - - -## **(b) Top 10 domains in human notes.** - -|Rank|Domain|% LLM notes citing|% human notes citing| -|---|---|---|---| -|1|x.com|4.2|18.7| -|2|en.wikipedia.org|7.2|7.6| -|3|youtube.com|5.3|3.9| -|4|x.com/grok|0.4|2.6| -|5|instagram.com|5.8|2.0| -|6|reuters.com|7.7|1.6| -|7|theguardian.com|1.2|1.6| -|8|t.co|0.0|1.1| -|9|bbc.com|4.2|1.1| -|10|share.google|0.0|1.0| - - - -11 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **3 Discussion** - -Our results demonstrate that LLM-generated Community Notes can achieve broader cross-ideological acceptance than human-written notes, receiving more positive ratings from raters across the political spectrum. This finding is particularly significant given that Community Notes deliberately prioritizes cross-perspective consensus over simple accuracy or neutrality. The fact that LLMs perform better than human notes on average on this standard suggests they are capable of being broadly helpful rather than merely presenting factual information, a capability with important implications for scaling content moderation while maintaining or even improving the quality of contextual information provided to users. The topic-level heterogeneity we observe offers insight into where LLM fact-checking is most and least effective. The LLM writer’s strongest advantages appear on health and medicine claims and conspiracy theories/pseudoscience, domains where authoritative sources are abundant and factual grounding is relatively clear-cut. By contrast, the LLM shows minimal advantage on posts about AI-generated content, where detection requires specialized capabilities which our current LLM does not have access to. However, tools like reverse image search or Google’s SynthID could be easily integrated into the LLM pipeline to further improve our agent’s capability to detect AI-generated content. More broadly, our results reflect the performance of a single LLM writer pipeline; other AI writer implementations on the platform may differ in relative strengths across topics and overall performance. - -These findings should be interpreted alongside important platform-specific confounds. LLM notes currently face a structural timing disadvantage: they can only be written after sufficient users flag a post, meaning they are systematically submitted later and accumulate fewer ratings. Because the Community Notes algorithm penalizes notes with fewer ratings, this timing disadvantage could deflate LLM notes’ helpfulness scores. Our notelevel analysis that equalizes exposures and robustness checks address this issue in several ways, suggesting that LLM notes receive higher note helpfulness scores when differential exposures are controlled. Together, the pattern indicates that the core quality signal favors LLM notes, while timing-induced exposure effects obscure this signal in aggregated platform metrics. - -Our findings have broader implications for the role of LLMs in public information ecosystems (Li et al., 2025). To our knowledge, this study is the first and the largest field evaluation of AI-generated fact-checking on any social media platform, made possible by the transparent data access provided by Community Notes. This open data enables a truly ecological and valid assessment: rather than relying on recruited evaluators or proxy metrics, we examine how a diverse population of real platform users respond to AI-generated content under natural conditions. - -12 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -Notes a distinctive for AI notes are Community provides testing ground fact-checking: evaluated by a diverse, self-selected rater population on a live platform. The fact that LLMs can meet this standard at scale suggests that AI-augmented fact-checking is viable not merely in controlled offline settings, but under the conditions of real social media platforms. This is particularly consequential given the scale mismatch between misinformation production and human fact-checking capacity. Human contributors, however motivated, are limited in the volume of content they can monitor and annotate. LLM writers face no such constraint, and our results suggest that scaling up AI contributions need not come at the cost of quality or cross-ideological acceptability. At the same time, LLM and human contributors have different strengths that are not easily substituted (Li et al., 2025). LLMs are good at rapidly synthesizing widely available information and generating contextual notes at scale, while human contributors are better equipped to handle novel situations, niche topics, and rapidly evolving events, drawing on deep domain knowledge and an understanding of how posts may be interpreted by diverse audiences. By having LLM- and human-written notes compete within the same rating system, the most helpful notes, regardless of origin, rise to the top. Platforms and researchers designing AI-augmented fact-checking systems should consider how to harness this complementarity that enhances overall note quality rather than treating AI deployment as a replacement for human community participation. - -## **4 Data and Methods** - -## **4.1 Dataset** - -Our analysis dataset comprised 2,946 Community Notes written between November 1, 2025 and January 31, 2026, targeting 1,597 unique tweets, with 108,169 ratings from 42,521 unique raters. The sample included 1,614 notes written by our LLM writer and 1,332 notes written by human users on the same set of tweets. We applied two quality filters: excluding media notes, and filtering ratings to include only those from raters with a valid rater factor. - -## **4.2 Analysis and multiple testing strategy** - -Our analyses operate at two levels. The rating-level analysis estimates a linear mixed effects model predicting individual rating scores, where p-values on regression coefficients are interpreted without multiple-testing correction, as they are jointly estimated within a single model. Subgroup analyses by tweet modality and topic re-estimate this specification within subsets and are treated as exploratory. At the note level, our primary analysis uses the equal-exposure design, in which we test three outcomes, note helpfulness score, CRH status, and CRNH status, using a linear mixed effects model with tweet random - -13 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -intercepts to account for within-tweet dependence among notes targeting the same post. We apply Benjamini-Hochberg correction across these three tests to control the false discovery rate. - -## **4.3 Note Writing Pipeline** - -Upon retrieving a potentially misleading post via the AI writer API, we compile its complete context by concatenating the post’s creation timestamp, its primary text, and any text and image descriptions from quoted or replied-to posts (if applicable). To enable multimodal note writing, the LLM writer is directly provided with images or video thumbnails associated with the target post. Next, we use Grok-4-fast with its web search and X search capabilities to conduct information research and gather relevant evidence. These research outputs are used to inform the note-writing process (Grok was chosen for its ability to surface X posts and understand video content from X, in addition to performing web search.) After evidence collection, the LLM writer (GPT-5-mini) decides whether a note should be written for the post. A note may not be written if the post is unlikely to be perceived as misleading or if there is insufficient evidence. This decision step acts as a safeguard to prevent generation of spam notes on non-misleading posts. Once the decision to write a note is made, the LLM (GPT-5-mini) writes the community note given the post content and Grok research outputs, following Community Notes guidelines (prompts are provided in Appendix E). The note next goes through URL validity check, length check, and quality check with the Community Notes ClaimOpinion model[5] prior to submission. Our LLM writing pipeline code, analysis code, and prompts are publicly available at https://github.com/haiwen-li/cn-ai-writer. - -## **Acknowledgements** - -We thank Dean Eckles, Martin Saveski, Soham De for insightful conversations and feedback on this work. We thank Brad Miller, Jay Baxter, Keith Coleman for valuable discussions on Community Notes and AI fact-checking. - -We used AI to assist with writing and debugging analysis code and to provide feedback on drafts of this paper. All analyses, interpretations, and final writing decisions were made by the authors. - -> 5https://docs.x.com/x-api/community-notes/evaluate-a-community-note - -14 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **References** - -- Luigia Costabile et al. Assessing the potential of generative agents in crowdsourced factchecking. _Online Social Networks and Media_ , 48:100326, 2025. - -- Soham De, Michiel A Bakker, Jay Baxter, and Martin Saveski. Supernotes: Driving consensus in crowd-sourced fact-checking. In _Proceedings of the ACM on Web Conference 2025_ , pages 3751–3761, 2025. - -- Chiara Patricia Drolsbach, Kirill Solovev, and Nicolas Pröllochs. Community notes increase trust in fact-checking on social media. _PNAS Nexus_ , 3(7):pgae217, 2024. - -- Olga Iarygina, Kasper Hornbæk, and Aske Mottelson. Demand characteristics in human– computer experiments. _International Journal of Human-Computer Studies_ , 193:103379, 2025. - -- Haiwen Li, Soham De, Manon Revel, Andreas Haupt, Brad Miller, Keith Coleman, Jay Baxter, Martin Saveski, and Michiel Bakker. Scaling human judgment in community notes with LLMs. _Journal of Online Trust and Safety_ , 3(1), September 2025. ISSN 27703142. doi: 10.54501/jots.v3i1.255. - -- Jonathan Mummolo and Erik Peterson. Demand effects in survey experiments: An empirical assessment. _American Political Science Review_ , 113(2):517–529, 2019. - -- Sahajpreet Singh, Kokil Jaidka, and Min-Yen Kan. GitSearch: Enhancing community notes generation with gap-informed targeted search. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.08945_ , 2026. - -- Isaac Slaughter, Axel Peytavin, Johan Ugander, and Martin Saveski. Community notes reduce engagement with and diffusion of false information online. _Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences_ , 122(38):e2503413122, 2025. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2503413122. - -- Stefan Wojcik, Sophie Hilgard, Nick Judd, Delia Mocanu, Stephen Ragain, MB Hunzaker, Keith Coleman, and Jay Baxter. Birdwatch: Crowd wisdom and bridging algorithms can inform understanding and reduce the spread of misinformation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.15723_ , 2022. - -- Xinyi Zhou, Ashish Sharma, Amy X. Zhang, and Tim Althoff. Correcting misinformation on social media with a large language model. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2403.11169_ , 2024. - -15 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **Appendix** - -## **A Within-Rater Pairwise Comparison** - -As a to the we conducted a re- complement rating-level analysis, pairwise comparison stricted to raters who evaluated both an LLM and a human note on the same tweet. We constructed 1,186 unique LLM–human note pairs, yielding 21,978 rater–pair observations from 10,345 raters. For each observation, we encoded a win/loss/tie outcome based on whether the rater’s rating for the LLM note was better than their rating for the human note. - -We observed a high tie rate: 71% of all rater–pair observations resulted in equal scores for both note types, suggesting that these raters found the two notes equivalently helpful. Excluding ties and fitting a Bradley-Terry logistic model with standard errors clustered by rater, we find that the LLM note was preferred in 54.4% of non-tied head-to-head comparisons ( _β_ = 0.178, SE = 0.035, _z_ = 5.10, _p <_ 0.001; OR = 1.19), significantly above the 50% chance level. - -## **B Full-Sample Note-Level Outcomes** - -We present note-level analysis of note helpfulness scores, CRH status, and CRNH status in the full sample. A higher proportion of human notes achieved CRH status than LLM notes (18.02% vs. 13.07%; AI coef. = _−_ 0.058, _z_ = _−_ 4.556, _p <_ 0.001). And among CRH notes, human notes reached that status faster (median: 5.90 hours vs. 7.38 hours for LLM notes; Mann-Whitney _U_ = 27,979, _p_ = 0.054). However, LLM notes had a lower rate of Currently Rated Not Helpful (CRNH) status (1.12% vs. 4.13% for human notes; AI coef. = _−_ 0.027, _z_ = _−_ 4.714, _p <_ 0.001) and similar average note helpfulness scores (mean: 0.25 vs. 0.24; AI coef. = 0.007, _z_ = 1.143, _p_ = 0.253). These results should be interpreted in light of substantial platform-specific confounds: the Community Notes algorithm used to compute these outcomes penalizes notes with few ratings, and LLM writers face a submission timing disadvantage that results in accumulating fewer ratings. - -To benchmark LLM writer’s performance against the distribution of individual human writers who have written community notes, we compare the CRH rate and hit rate. The CRH rate is the fraction of a writer’s notes achieving CRH status, and the hit rate is de- _−_ fined as (CRH notes CRNH notes) / total notes to account for notes reaching unhelpful status. Our LLM writer achieves a CRH rate of 13.07%, outranking 84.7% of human writers on CRH rate (78.4% among human writers who have written at least 30 notes), and a hit rate of 11.96%, corresponding to the 85.4th percentile among human writers (79.0% - -16 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -among human writers who have written at least 30 notes). - -Tables A1 and A2 summarize the rating-level and note-level results for the full sample, respectively. - -**Table A1: Mean % helpful and % unhelpful ratings per note by rater ideology bucket (full sample).** _n_ denotes the number of notes receiving at least one rating from raters in that ideology bucket. 95% CIs are computed across notes. - -|Rater Ideology|% Helpful, mean [95% CI]
LLM
Human|% Unhelpful, mean [95% CI]
LLM
Human| -|---|---|---| -|Left (_n_: 1,300 / 1,183)
Neutral (_n_: 1,174 / 1,049)
Right (_n_: 1,300 / 1,196)|79.55 [77.83, 81.27]
68.10 [65.95, 70.24]
89.58 [88.32, 90.84]
76.83 [74.86, 78.79]
73.13 [71.32, 74.93]
67.46 [65.52, 69.41]|17.98 [16.33, 19.63]
28.72 [26.61, 30.83]
7.60 [6.52, 8.69]
18.40 [16.56, 20.25]
23.65 [21.92, 25.38]
28.58 [26.68, 30.48]| - - - -**Table A2: Note-level comparisons in the full sample.** CRH, CRNH, and helpfulness score are analyzed using linear mixed-effects models (LMMs), and the reported coefficient is the estimated effect of the AI-note indicator. Number of ratings and time to CRH are compared using two-sided Mann–Whitney _U_ tests. - -|Metric|LLM|Human|Test|AI coef.|Statistic|_p_| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|_N_(total notes)|1,614|1,332|—|—|—|—| -|CRH rate|13.07%|18.02%|LMM|_−_0.058|_z_=_−_4.56|_<_0.001| -|CRNH rate|1.12%|4.13%|LMM|_−_0.027|_z_=_−_4.71|_<_0.001| -|Helpfulness score|0.25|0.24|LMM|0.007|_z_=1.14|0.253| -|(_N_with scores: 1,243 / 1,130)||||||| -|Num. ratings, median|22|51|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =740,798|_<_0.001| -|Time to CRH, hrs, median|7.38|5.90|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =27,979|0.054| -|(_N_CRH notes: 211 / 240)||||||| - - - -## **C Robustness Checks for Note-Level Outcomes** - -In addition to the note-level analysis with equal-exposure raters, we conducted two robustness checks to address potential confounds in the note-level outcomes. To address the concern that notes with fewer ratings have over-penalized note helpfulness scores, we restrict the sample to notes with at least 30 ratings ( _n_ = 1,538 notes; LLM = 680, human = 858). After filtering, the percentage of CRH notes was no longer statistically different (LLM = 27.94%, human = 27.04%; AI coef. = _−_ 0.006, _z_ = _−_ 0.317, _p_ = 0.751), and LLM notes continued to show a significantly lower proportion of CRNH notes (LLM = 0.59%, human = 4.55%; AI coef. = _−_ 0.035, _z_ = _−_ 4.129, _p <_ 0.001). The difference in helpfulness scores increased (AI coef. = 0.019, _z_ = 2.410, _p_ = 0.016). Among CRH notes, human notes still reached CRH status more quickly (median = 5.78 hours vs. 7.16 hours; Mann-Whitney _U_ = 24,102, _p_ = 0.098). - -17 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -To account for differential note exposure due to submission timing, we conduct creation time-matched analyses. We retain human notes created within _±_ 30, _±_ 60, or _±_ 90 minutes of the LLM note creation on the same post, under the assumption that notes written close in time have similar Because LLM and human notes are often written hours exposure. apart, matching rates were low (6.3%, 11.8%, and 15.9%, respectively) and sample sizes were substantially reduced. Within the _±_ 60-minute window ( _n_ = 405 notes; LLM = 190, human = 215), the CRH gap was narrow and non-significant (LLM = 21.58% vs. human = 22.79%; AI coef. = _−_ 0.019, _z_ = _−_ 0.610, _p_ = 0.542). The difference in average note helpfulness scores was larger but not statistically significant (LLM = 0.28 vs. human = 0.25; AI coef. = 0.023, _z_ = 1.703, _p_ = 0.089). In this matched sample, LLM notes reached CRH status faster (median = 4.61 hours vs. 5.55 hours). - -Tables A3 and A4 present the full note-level statistics for the _≥_ 30-ratings subset and timing-matched subsets. - -**Table A3: Note-level comparisons in the subset of notes with at least 30 ratings.** CRH, CRNH, and helpfulness score are analyzed using linear mixed-effects models (LMMs); number of ratings and time to CRH are compared using two-sided Mann–Whitney _U_ tests. - -|Metric|LLM|Human|Test|AI coef.|Statistic|_p_| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|_N_(total notes)|680|858|—|—|—|—| -|CRH rate|27.94%|27.04%|LMM|_−_0.006|_z_=_−_0.32|0.751| -|CRNH rate|0.59%|4.55%|LMM|_−_0.035|_z_=_−_4.13|_<_0.001| -|Helpfulness score|0.31|0.28|LMM|0.019|_z_=2.41|0.016| -|(_N_with scores: 645 / 798)||||||| -|Num. ratings, median|67.00|91.50|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =236,530.5|_<_0.001| -|Time to CRH, hrs, median|7.16|5.78|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =24,102|0.098| -|(_N_CRH notes: 190 / 232)||||||| - - - -18 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -**Table A4: Note-level comparisons in timing-matched subsets.** Each sub-table restricts analysis to LLM notes matched to human notes within the indicated submission-time window. CRH, CRNH, and helpfulness score are analyzed using linear mixed-effects models (LMMs); number of ratings and time to CRH are compared using two-sided Mann–Whitney _U_ tests. - -|Metric|LLM|Human|Test|AI coef.|Statistic|_p_| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|_N_(total notes)|102|116|—|—|—|—| -|CRH rate|21.57%|20.69%|LMM|0.004|_z_=0.09|0.929| -|CRNH rate|1.96%|6.90%|LMM|_−_0.049|_z_=_−_1.74|0.082| -|Helpfulness score|0.28|0.24|LMM|0.041|_z_=2.13|0.033| -|(_N_with scores: 96 / 109)||||||| -|Num. ratings, median|64.00|55.00|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =6,491.5|0.216| -|Time to CRH, hrs, median|6.01|5.67|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =288|0.605| -|(_N_CRH notes: 22 / 24)||||||| - - - -## **(a)** _±_ 30-minute window. Matched 102/1,614 LLM notes (6.3%). - -|Metric|LLM|Human|Test|AI coef.|Statistic|_p_| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|_N_(total notes)|190|215|—|—|—|—| -|CRH rate|21.58%|22.79%|LMM|_−_0.019|_z_=_−_0.61|0.542| -|CRNH rate|2.11%|6.05%|LMM|_−_0.039|_z_=_−_1.98|0.048| -|Helpfulness score|0.28|0.25|LMM|0.023|_z_=1.70|0.089| -|(_N_with scores: 178 / 193)||||||| -|Num. ratings, median|54.00|57.00|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =21,064.5|0.587| -|Time to CRH, hrs, median|4.61|5.55|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =950|0.662| -|(_N_CRH notes: 41 / 49)||||||| - - - -## **(b)** _±_ 60-minute window. Matched 190/1,614 LLM notes (11.8%). - -|Metric|LLM|Human|Test|AI coef.|Statistic|_p_| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|_N_(total notes)|257|313|—|—|—|—| -|CRH rate|19.46%|20.13%|LMM|_−_0.013|_z_=_−_0.47|0.638| -|CRNH rate|1.56%|5.43%|LMM|_−_0.037|_z_=_−_2.37|0.018| -|Helpfulness score|0.27|0.24|LMM|0.027|_z_=2.37|0.018| -|(_N_with scores: 240 / 285)||||||| -|Num. ratings, median|57.00|59.00|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =40,772|0.778| -|Time to CRH, hrs, median|4.96|5.46|Mann–Whitney_U_|—|_U_ =1,562|0.942| -|(_N_CRH notes: 50 / 63)||||||| - - - -**(c)** _±_ 90-minute window. Matched 257/1,614 LLM notes (15.9%). - -19 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -## **D Representativeness of Complete Raters** - -We compare the distribution of rater characteristics between the full rater population and the subset of “complete raters” who evaluated all notes on a given tweet. The left panel shows the distribution of coreRaterIntercept, which measures a rater’s baseline tendency to rate notes as helpful. The right panel shows the distribution of coreRaterFactor1, which captures political leaning inferred from historical rating patterns (negative = left-leaning, positive = right-leaning). Both distributions are highly similar across the two groups, suggesting that complete raters do not systematically differ from the overall population in helpfulness leniency and political leaning (Figure A1). Together, these comparisons indicate that restricting the analysis to raters who rated all notes on a tweet does not substantially alter the distribution of key rater characteristics. - -**==> picture [468 x 193] intentionally omitted <==** - -**Figure A1:** Distribution of rater characteristics for the full rater population vs. complete raters who evaluated all notes on a given tweet. Left: coreRaterIntercept captures baseline helpfulness leniency. Right: coreRaterFactor1 captures political leaning (negative = leftleaning, positive = right-leaning). The close overlap indicates that complete raters are not systematically different from the overall rater population. - -## **E LLM Writing Pipeline Prompts** - -## **E.1 Evidence Retrieval Prompt** - -``` -"""InvestigatewhethertheXpostbelowismisleading.Imagesorvideopreviews -fromthepostareprovidediftheyexist. -``` - -``` -Step1:Understandthepostanditscontext -``` - -- `Find the post by post id {post_id} on X. If not found, search the post’s main text on X.` - -- `Identify the post author. Also note any signals that the account is` - -20 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -``` -parody/satire(e.g.bio,handle,verification). -``` - -- `Fetch the thread and top comments. Understand how others interpret the post` - - - `(e.g. joke/satire, potentially misleading, expressing an opinion).` - -``` --Summarizethepostcontextin1-2sentenceswithoutrewordingthepostitself. -IncludewhotheOPisandhowothersinterpretthepost,especiallyifcomments -suggestit’sajokeorsatire,orprovidepotentialfact-checkdirections. -Forexample:"TheOPisSen.X.ManycommentssayhisclaimaboutXis -unverified."or"TheOPisaparodyaccount,andcommentersarelaughingand -treatingitasajoke." -``` - -``` -Step2:Searchforevidence -``` - -`1. Search both the web and X for factual sources that refute or confirm the post’s claims. Use the post context to guide your search if it could provide potential fact-check directions.` - -`2. Aim for {target_url_count} pieces of evidence / URLs if possible.` - -`3. For each source, include the URL and a brief note describing how it verifies or challenges the post. Include the publication date of the source if available.` - -`4. Cover outlets across the ideological spectrum (left, center, right). Overlapping reasoning is acceptable when it comes from different publishers.` - -`5. Prioritize evidence that is relevant, solid, and up to date.` - -``` -Targetpost(ID:{post_id}): -{post} -``` - -``` -YourresponseshouldbereturnedasaJSONobjectwiththefollowingstructure: -‘‘‘ -``` - -``` -{{ -"post_context":"one/two-sentencesummaryofthepostcontext", -"research":[ -{{"url":"url1","description":"howthecontentoftheURLfact-checksthepost -"}}, -... -] -}} -‘‘‘ -``` - -``` -Ifyoucannotfindsufficientevidencetofact-checkthepost,returnanempty -researcharray.""" -``` - -## **E.2 Note Triage Prompt** - -## **System prompt:** - -``` -"""DecidewhetherapostneedsaCommunityNotebasedontheprovidedevidence. -``` - -``` -Returns: -``` - -``` --"WRITENOTE"ifanoteshouldbewritten -``` - -21 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -- `"NO NOTE NEEDED" if the post doesn’t need a note` - -- `"NOT ENOUGH EVIDENCE" if there’s insufficient evidence` - -``` -""" -``` - -## **User prompt:** - -``` -"""YouareaCommunityNoteswriter.Yourjobistodecideifthetargetpost -couldbeperceivedasmisleadingandwhetheritneedsacommunitynotetoaddress -itsissues.Theoutputshouldbeoneof:"WRITENOTE","NONOTENEEDED",or -"NOTENOUGHEVIDENCE". -``` - -## `Task rules` - -- `Focus on the main claims of the post, not trivial errors.` - -- `If media is included, use any legible text, recognizable logos/landmarks, and clearly identifiable public figures as part of the claim.` - -- `If the target post is a quote/reply, evaluate the target post, using the quoted/replied post only as context.` - -``` --Usethecontextinformation(authorinfoandaudiencereactions)toinformyour -decision.Theyarehelpfulforunderstandingwhetherthepostislikelytobe -perceivedasmisleading. -``` - -- `If you are unsure, err on the side of NO NOTE NEEDED.` - -``` -Decisionlogic -``` - -``` -OutputNONOTENEEDEDif: -``` - -``` --TheOPisasatire/parodyaccount,orthepostisjoking/sarcastic/exaggerated -tobeironic,andcommentersareinterpretingitthatway(withnostrongsigns -ofmisunderstanding);or -``` - -``` --Thepostismostlyopinion,subjectivetakes,orpersonalexperience;or -``` - -- `The post contains no major factual claims, or the claims are not verifiable; or` - -- `The post contains factual claims, but the provided evidence indicates those claims are accurate or not meaningfully misleading.` - -``` -Ifthepostcontainsmajorfactual,verifiableclaimsandtheevidenceis -relevant: -``` - -``` --OutputNOTENOUGHEVIDENCEiftheevidenceisweak,mixed,orinsufficientto -confidentlyverifyorrefutethemainclaims.Whenunsureaboutthe -strength/sufficiencyoftheevidence,erronNOTENOUGHEVIDENCE. -``` - -``` --OutputWRITENOTEonlyiftheevidenceclearlyshowsthatthepost’smain -claimsarefalseormisleadinginawaythatcouldmisinformareasonable -reader. -``` - -``` -Post: -``` - -``` -{post} -``` - -``` -Additionalcontextinformationaboutthepost: -{post_context} -``` - -22 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -``` -Evidence: -{evidence} -``` - -``` -Outputonlyoneof:"WRITENOTE","NONOTENEEDED",or"NOTENOUGHEVIDENCE". -ErronthesideofNONOTENEEDEDifunsure.""" -``` - -## **E.3 Note Generation Prompt** - -## **System prompt:** - -``` -"""Youareahelpfulfact-checkingassistant. -``` - -``` -YourgoalistowritegoodCommunityNotesthatwouldbeapprovedhelpfulby -peoplewithdifferentviewpoints. -``` - -``` -Donotinventfactsormakeclaimsthatarenotsupportedbytheprovided -evidence.""" -``` - -## **User prompt:** - -``` -"""Task:Writeacommunitynoteforthetargetpostbelow.Imagesorvideo -previewsfromthetargetpostmaybeprovided;ifpresent,analyzeanylegible -text(OCR),recognizablelogos/landmarks,andconfidentlyidentifiablepublic -figurestoinformthenote.Additionalcontextprovidespostauthordetailsand -audiencereactions.Ifthetargetpostquotes/repliestoanotherpost,useit -onlyforcontextandfocusonthetargetpost. -``` - -``` -HardConstraints: -``` - -`1. The note is written to explain why the post is misleading and add additional context to the post. Focus on primary claim(s) of the post rather than trivial details.` - -`2. The note must be grounded in the provided evidence and should cite the URL of the evidence it uses. At least one URL must be cited.` - -`3. Keep the note strictly under 280 characters. Stay neutral and clear.` - -`4. No hashtags, emojis, unnecessary words. No markdown, brackets, or parentheses around URLs. Do not mention "this note" or "the prompt."` - -``` -Targetpost: -‘‘‘ -{post} -‘‘‘ -``` - -``` -Additionalcontextaboutthepost: -‘‘‘ -{post_context} -‘‘‘ -``` - -``` -Allowedevidencesources: -‘‘‘ -``` - -23 - -AI Fact-Checking in the Wild: A Field Evaluation of LLM-Written Community Notes on X - -``` -{evidence} -‘‘‘ -``` - -``` -Outputonlythefinalnote(atmost280characters).""" -``` - -## **E.4 Topic Classification Prompt** - -``` -"""ClassifythefollowingX/Twitterpostintoexactlyoneofthesecategories: -``` - -- `Politics & Elections: U.S./global elections, politicians, voting, partisan claims, policy debates.` - -``` --Geopolitics&InternationalConflicts:Wars,foreignpolicy,terrorism, -diplomacy,country-specificevents(e.g.,Ukraine,Israel-Palestine, -China-Taiwan). -``` - -``` --Health&Medicine:Diseases,treatments,vaccines,publichealthpolicies, -medicaladvice,COVID. -``` - -``` --Social/CulturalIssues:Abortion,gender/LGBTQ+,race/DEI,guns, -crime/justice,education,religion. -``` - -``` --Economy&Finance:Inflation,jobs,taxes,crypto,markets,inequality. -``` - -``` --Science&Technology:Climatechange,AI,space,gadgets(non-healthtech). --Conspiracy&Pseudoscience:Generalconspiracies,electionfraudclaimsnot -tiedtoactivepolitics,QAnon-style,flatearth,etc. -``` - -``` --Celebrity/Entertainment/Viral:Non-politicalhoaxes,celebritydrama. --Sports:Sportsevents,sportsscandals,andrelevantdiscussion. -``` - -``` --AIgeneratedcontent:AIgenerated/modifiedcontent. -``` - -``` --Other/Miscellaneous:Everythingelse(weather,personal,ads,neutralnews -withoutcontroversy). -``` - -``` -Posttext: -{tweet_text} -{context_section} -Answerwithonlytheexactcategorynamefromthelistabove -(e.g.,"Politics&Elections"or"Other/Miscellaneous").""" -``` - -24 - +Explanation, Debate, Align: A Weak-to-Strong Framework for Language Model +Generalization +MehrdadZakershahrak*,SamiraGhodratnama* +DepartmentofComputing +{mehrdad,samira}@mq..edu.au +4202 peS 11 ]IA.sc[ 1v53370.9042:viXra Abstract inglysophisticatedAIsystemswithoutsolelydependingon +humanoversight.Suchmethodsshouldfacilitatealignment +Therapidadvancementofartificialintelligencesystemshas +| | | | | | | | in domains | where | human | experts | may | struggle | to provide | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | +broughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttotheforefrontofre- +accuratefeedback,whilestillmaintainingthecoreprinciple +search,particularlyincomplexdecision-makingandtaskex- +ofaligningwithhumanvalues.Furthermore,thesemethods +ecution.Asthesesystemssurpasshuman-levelperformance +insophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralignmentwithhu- shouldprovideamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +man values, intentions, and ethical guidelines becomes cru- capabilities evolve, ensuring that alignment scales with ad- +cial.Buildingonpreviousworkinexplanationgenerationfor vancementsinAItechnology. +human-agent alignment, we address the more complex dy- Buildingonourpreviousworkinexplanationgeneration +namicsofmulti-agentsystemsandhuman-AIteams.Thispa- forhuman-agentalignment,weintroduceaframeworkthat +perintroducesanovelapproachtomodelalignmentthrough +combinesweak-to-stronggeneralizationandmodelfacilita- +| weak-to-strong | | generalization | in | the context | of | language | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | tion, leveraging | | explanatory | debates | to | enhance | alignment. | | +models.Wepresentaframeworkwhereastrongmodelfacili- +Thisapproachaimstocreateascalable,self-improvingsys- +| tates the | improvement | of a | weaker | model, | bridging | the gap | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +temforAIalignmentthatcanhandleincreasinglycomplex +| between | explanation | generation | and | model | alignment. | Our | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskswhilemaintainingtransparencyandinterpretability. +| method, | formalized | as a facilitation | | function | Φ, | allows for | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thetransferofcapabilitiesfromadvancedmodelstolessca- Toformalizeourapproach,webeginbydefiningthecon- +pable ones without direct access to extensive training data. ceptsofweakandstrongmodels: +Our results suggest that this facilitation-based approach not A model M is considered +| | | | | | | | Definition1(WeakModel) | | | | | W | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +onlyenhancesmodelperformancebutalsoprovidesinsights +| | | | | | | | weakif,foragiventaskT | | | andperformancemetricP,M | | | | W | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intothenatureofmodelalignmentandthepotentialforscal- +| | | | | | | | achievesascoreS | | suchthatS | | < S | ,whereS | | isthe | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| ableoversightofAIsystems. | | | | | | | | | W | | W | H | H | | +human-levelperformanceonT. +Introduction Definition2(StrongModel) A model M is considered +S +| | | | | | | | strong if, | for the | same | task T | and performance | | metric | P, | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----------------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +| The rapid | advancement | of | artificial | intelligence | | (AI) sys- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | M achievesascoreS | | | suchthatS | >S | . | | | +| | | | | | | | S | | S | | S | H | | | +temshasbroughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttothefore- +| | | | | | | | The idea | of | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | involves | us- | +| ------------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ---------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | +| front of research, | | particularly | in complex | | decision-making | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ing weaker | AI systems | | to supervise | and | align | stronger | AI | +| and task | execution. | As these | systems | surpass | human-level | | | | | | | | | | +performanceinsophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralign- systems, a concept closely related to capability amplifica- +ment with human values, intentions, and ethical guidelines tion, where the goal is to create AI systems that can solve +| | | | | | | | problems | beyond | the capabilities | | of their | creators | or | train- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | +becomescrucial.Thischallengehasbeenhighlightedinre- +| | | | | | | | ers. This | concept | has its | roots | in model | compression | | and | +| ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | ------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | +| cent work | on alignment, | | such as | Reinforcement | | Learning | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | knowledge | distillation, | | where smaller, | | less capable | | models | +| from Human | Feedback | (RLHF), | | which | iteratively | refines | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | are used | to enhance | the | performance | of | larger | models. | Re- | +modelbehaviorbasedonhumanevaluations(Ghodratnama +and Zakershahrak 2024). While RLHF has shown promise cent research, such as the work by Schick and Schu¨tze on +| | | | | | | | few-shot | learning | in language | | models, | demonstrates | | how | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +inaligninglanguagemodelswithhumanintentions,itfaces +| | | | | | | | these ideas | can | be applied | to improve | | the performance | | of | +| ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| scalability | challenges | when | dealing | with | tasks | that surpass | | | | | | | | | +smallermodelswithlimiteddata. +human-levelcomplexity.Therelianceondirecthumanfeed- +FacilitationFunctionandDebate-BasedAlignmentAtthe +backbecomesabottleneck,limitingthescopeanddepthof +alignmentthatcanbeachieved. heart of our method is the facilitation function Φ, which +formalizestheprocessofknowledgetransferfromastrong +Toaddresstheselimitations,morescalableandadaptable +modeltoaweakerone: +approachesarerequired—approachesthatcanalignincreas- +| | | | | | | | Definition3(FacilitationFunc.) | | | | Φ:M | ×M | →M′ | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| *Theseauthorscontributedequally. | | | | | | | | | | | | W | S | W | +Copyright©2025,AssociationfortheAdvancementofArtificial WhereM W istheweakmodel,M S isthestrongmodel,and +Intelligence(www.aaai.org).Allrightsreserved. M′ istheenhancedweakmodel.Thefacilitationfunction +W + +isimplementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: wefosteranAIsystemthatnotonlyperformswellbutalso +| | | | | | | | | maintains | transparency | | and interpretability, | | | key factors | in | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +(cid:88) +| | argmin | | L(f | θ (q),f | θS (q)) | | (1) | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ W′ b u i ld i n gtrustandensuringlong-termalignmentwithhuman +W′ q∈Q +| | | | | | | | | va l u e s . | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WhereQisasetoftaskinstances,Lisatask-specificloss Contributions Our contributions in this paper are three- +| function, | and | f represents | | the model’s | decision-making | | | fold: | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ +functionparameterizedbyθ. +| | | | | | | | | 1. We introduce | | a novel | framework | | for model | alignment | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | +Tofurtherenhanceourapproach,weincorporatedebate- +| | | | | | | | | through | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | and | model | facil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +basedalignment,leveragingtheideathatitmaybeeasierto +itation,formalizingthefacilitationfunctionΦanditsap- +| judge the | outcome | of | a debate | than | to directly | solve | com- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +plicationtocomplexdecision-makingtasks. +| plex problems. | | This | method | uses adversarial | | dynamics | to | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +improve model alignment and capability by evaluating the 2. We present empirical results demonstrating significant +explanationsprovidedbydifferentmodels. improvements in model performance and alignment +acrossmultiplecomplextaskdomains,achievedthrough +| Definition4(DebateFunction) | | | | D :E | ×E | ×J | →R | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | S′ | W | | ourfacilitationapproach. | | | | | | | | +| WhereE | istheexplanationfunctionofthestrongmodel, | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +S′ 3. We provide an in-depth analysis of the facilitation pro- +| E is | the explanation | | function | of the | weak | model, | and J | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | +| W | | | | | | | | cess, | offering | new | perspectives | | on the nature | of | model | +| is the judge | (which | could | be | another | instance | of the | weak | | | | | | | | | +alignmentindecision-makingandthepotentialforscal- +model,ahuman,oranotherevaluationmechanism).Theout- +ableoversightofadvancedAIsystemstacklingcomplex +| put of D | is a | real number | representing | | the | quality | of the | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tasks. +strongmodel’sexplanationrelativetotheweakmodel’s,as +evaluated by the judge. This scalar output can be used as a This work represents a key component of a broader re- +reward signal in a reinforcement learning (RL) framework, search agenda aimed at developing robust, aligned AI sys- +allowingforcontinuousimprovementofthestrongmodel’s tems capable of handling increasingly complex decisions +explanatorycapabilities. and tasks. By bridging the gap between weak and strong +| | | | | | | | →M′ | models | in sophisticated | | problem-solving | | scenarios, | | we not | +| ------------------------------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | +| Definition5(AlignmentFunction) | | | | | Ψ:M S | ×M W | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | S | onlyenhancethecapabilitiesofAIsystemsbutalsoensure | | | | | | | | +| Where | M′ is | the aligned | | strong model. | This | function | is | | | | | | | | | +| | S | | | | | | | they remain | fundamentally | | aligned | | with human | values | and | +implementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: intentions. To achieve this, our approach draws on and ex- +tendsseveralfoundationalareaswithinartificialintelligence +(cid:88) +argm i n [L(f θ (q),f θW (q))+D(E S′ (q),E W (q),J)] r e se a r c h , in c lu d i n g e x p l a in a b l e AI, model alignment, and +| θ | | S′ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| S ′ | | | | | | | | la n g u a g | e m o d e l | g e ne r a | li z a ti o n | . | | | | +q∈Q +(2) +By incorporating a learned reward model over debate- RelatedWork +drivenalignment,ourframeworkcreatesadynamiclearning +Ourresearchintegratesandbuildsuponthesekeyareas,par- +| environment | that | scales | beyond | mere | decision | alignment. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ticularlyfocusingontheprogressionfromexplainableAIto +Thestrongmodelisincentivizednotonlytomakedecisions +thedevelopmentofaligned,capablelanguagemodels.This +thatalignwithhumanvaluesbutalsotoconsistentlyprovide +| | | | | | | | | section | traces how | these | concepts | interconnect, | | laying | the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +high-quality,persuasiveexplanationsthatmirrorhumanrea- +foundationforourproposedapproach. +soningprocesses. +Thepracticalimplementationofthisprocessfollowsthese +ExplanationGenerationinAI +steps: +ExplainableAI(XAI)hasbecomeacriticalareaofresearch +Algorithm1:Debate-BasedAlignmentProcess asAIsystemsincreasinglyinfluencevariousaspectsofsoci- +ety(GhodratnamaandZakershahrak2023).Gunning’swork +| Inputs: | Models | M | (strong) | and M | (weak), | Task | in- | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | S | | | W | | | (Gunning2017)definesXAIasthedevelopmentofmachine | | | | | | | | +stanceq learning models that are not only high-performing but also +| Ensure: | AlignedandimprovedstrongmodelM | | | | | S | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | interpretable | by | humans. | This | focus | on interpretability | | be- | +| 1: PresentbothmodelsM | | | | andM | withtaskinstanceq | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | S | W | | | | gan with | efforts | by Swartout | | and Moore | (1993) | to | create | +| 2: Eachmodelproducesadecisionf | | | | | (q)andanexplana- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | θ | | | expertsystemscapableofexplainingtheirdecisions.Asthe | | | | | | | | +tionE(q) +| | | | | | | | | field evolved, | the | emphasis | shifted | | from post-hoc | | explana- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +3: Evaluate explanations using the debate function tionstoinherentlyinterpretablesystems. +D(E S′ ,E W ) Notably, research by Zakershahrak et al. (Zakershahrak +| 4: JudgeJ | determineswhichexplanationissuperior | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------------------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | et al. 2020a, | 2018, | 2020b) | introduced | | progressive | | explana- | +| 5: Finetune | strong | model | M | to minimize | | decision | dis- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | S | | | | tiongenerationtechniquesthatadapttohumanunderstand- | | | | | | | | +crepanciesandimproveexplanations +| | | | | | | | | ing, aligning | closely | with | the | principles | of | Inverse | Rein- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | forcement | Learning | (IRL). | These | approaches | | often | employ | +Thisframeworkcreatesamorerobustandadaptivealign- maximumentropymethods,similartoMaxEntIRL(Ziebart +ment,wherethemodel’sabilitytoexplainitsdecisionsbe- et al. 2008), to manage the uncertainty inherent in human +| comesascrucialasthedecisionsthemselves.Consequently, | | | | | | | | preferences. | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Miller (Miller 2018) further underscored the importance FacilitationinHuman-AITeams +| of social | context | in | AI explanations, | | bridging | AI | expla- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | As AI systems | | have | become | more | advanced, | research | has | +| nations | with human-centric | | | explanation | science. | Our | work | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | increasingly | focused | | on how | these | systems | can | support | +| builds on | these | foundations | | by | incorporating | | dynamic, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | and enhance | human | | decision-making. | | This | research | aligns | +debate-styleexplanationswithinthealignmentprocess,not +| | | | | | | | | closely | with | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | by | exploring | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +onlyenhancingtransparencybutalsousingexplanationsas +howAIcanamplifyhumancapabilities.Bansaletal.(2019) +amechanismtoguideandimproveAIbehavior. +| | | | | | | | | explored | collaborative | | problem-solving | | | between | humans | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | and AI, | while | Kamar | et al. | (2012) | examined | AI-assisted | | +| ModelAlignment | | | | | | | | decision-makingprocesses. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Nancy | Cooke’s | work | on | human-AI | teams | (Cooke | et al. | +As AI systems become more sophisticated, the challenge 2013; Cooke 2015) has been pivotal in understanding the +ofaligningthesesystemswithhumanvaluesandgoalshas +dynamicsofcollaborationbetweenhumansandAI.Seeber +takencenterstage.Leikeetal.(Leikeetal.2018)definethe +etal.(Seeberetal.2020)providedacomprehensivereview +alignmentproblemasensuringthatAIsystemsconsistently +| | | | | | | | | of AI-enabled | | teamwork, | emphasizing | | the | role | of AI as a | +| ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +| pursue | the goals | intended | by | their | creators. | The | develop- | | | | | | | | | +teammemberratherthanameretool. +mentofInverseReinforcementLearning(IRL)methodsby Ourapproachleveragestheseinsightsbypositioningthe +NgandRussell(NgandRussell2000)laidthegroundwork +strongmodelasafacilitatorfortheweakermodel,enhanc- +forpreferencelearninginAI,allowingsystemstoinferand +| | | | | | | | | ing the | alignment | process | through | | structured | learning | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +adopthuman-likegoals. +debate. +| Further | advances, | such | as | cooperative | inverse | reinforce- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ment learning | | (CIRL) | explored | by | Hadfield-Menell | | et al. | | | | | | | | | +LanguageModelAlignment +(Hadfield-Menelletal.2016),modeledalignmentasacoop- +erative game between humans and AI. Stiennon et al. (Sti- Therapidadvancementsinlanguagemodelcapabilitieshave +intensifiedtheneedforrobustalignmentstrategies.TheIn- +| ennon et | al. 2020) | expanded | | on this | by demonstrating | | how | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --------- | +| | | | | | | | | structGPT | approach | | by Ouyang | | et al. | (2022) | showcased | +| summarization | | tasks | can be | used | to align | language | mod- | | | | | | | | | +elswithhumanpreferences,acrucialsteptowardsscalable how large language models could be fine-tuned to align +alignment. more closely with human instructions, representing a key +| | | | | | | | | advancement | | in scalable | alignment | | techniques. | | Bai et al. | +| -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------- | +| Our work | builds | on | these | concepts | by integrating | | weak- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | (2022) further | | contributed | to | this | field with | Constitutional | | +to-stronggeneralizationandexplanationgenerationintothe +| | | | | | | | | AI, which | incorporates | | specific | behavioral | | constraints | dur- | +| --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| alignment | process. | This | combination | | allows | us to | create a | | | | | | | | | +ingtrainingtoensurealignmentwithhumanvalues. +| more holistic | approach | | to aligning | | AI systems, | particularly | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | Anthropic’s | | ”AI | Safety | via Debate” | | research | (Irving, | +incomplextaskenvironments. +| | | | | | | | | Christiano, | and | Amodei | 2018) | introduced | | the idea | of us- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | ing debates | between | | AI systems | | as a method | for | improv- | +Weak-to-StrongGeneralization ingalignment,anapproachthatresonatesstronglywithour +| | | | | | | | | work. This | method | | leverages | adversarial | | dynamics | to en- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Theconceptofweak-to-stronggeneralization,discussedby +hancemodelcapabilitiesandensurealignment.Recentwork +Burnsetal.(Burnsetal.2023),involvesleveragingweaker +byPerezetal.(2023)ondiscoveringlanguagemodelbehav- +AIsystemstosuperviseandguidestrongerAIsystems.This +iorsusinggeneratedtaskdatasetshasprovidednewtoolsfor +paradigmisanextensionoftheideaofcapabilityamplifica- +evaluatingandimprovinglanguagemodelalignment. +| tion, where | the | goal is | to enable | AI | systems | to solve | prob- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ourresearchcomplementstheseapproachesbyintegrat- +lemsbeyondthedirectcapabilitiesoftheirdevelopers. +ingweak-to-stronggeneralizationwithdebate-drivenlearn- +| This | approach | has | its roots | in | model compression | | and | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ing. By | combining | the | strengths | of | explanation | generation, | | +knowledge distillation, as first introduced by Buciluaˇ et al. weak-to-strong generalization, and structured debates, we +(Buciluaˇ, Caruana, and Niculescu-Mizil 2006) and refined offerascalableandtransparentframeworkforensuringlan- +| by Hinton | et al. | (LeCun, | Bengio, | and | Hinton | 2015). | These | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guagemodelalignmentthatcanadapttotheincreasingcom- +methodshavebeensuccessfullyappliedinnaturallanguage +plexityofAIsystems. +processing,wherestudent-teachermodels(Sanhetal.2019) +havedemonstratedthatsmallermodelscanachievehighper- +Methodology +formancewithfewerresources.RecentworkbySchickand +Schu¨tze(Mittaletal.2023)onfew-shotlearningfurtheril- Our research explores weak-to-strong generalization as a +lustrateshowsmallermodelscanbeenhancedthrougheffi- technique for model alignment. The core idea is to use +cientlearningtechniques. +| | | | | | | | | weaker | models | to supervise | | stronger | models, | serving | as an | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +Ourframeworkextendstheseideasbyapplyingweak-to- analogy for how humans might align superhuman AI sys- +stronggeneralizationasameansofaligningAIsystems.By tems.Thisapproachallowsustostudyalignmentchallenges +incorporating structured debates and explanations, we cre- empiricallyusingcurrentmodels,whilepotentiallyyielding +ate a mechanism where weaker models can guide stronger insightsapplicabletofuture,morecapablesystems. +models, even in scenarios where the weaker model (or hu- The weak-to-strong learning process consists of three +| mansupervisor)lacksfullexpertise. | | | | | | | | mainsteps: | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +1. Create a weak supervisor by finetuning a smaller pre- Baseline Method We finetune the strong student model +trainedmodelongroundtruthlabels. on the weak labels over 2 epochs with a batch size of 32. +2. Generateweaklabelsusingthesupervisoronaheld-out Early stopping is applied based on the model’s agreement +| dataset. | | | | | | | | withweaklabelsonthevalidationset. | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Trainastrongerstudentmodelusingtheseweaklabels. +Algorithm3:BaselineStrongStudentTraining +Weevaluatethisprocessacrossmultipletaskdomainsand Inputs: Weaklabelsf (x),StrongstudentmodelM +| | | | | | | | | | | w | | | S | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +modelsizestounderstanditsscalabilityandlimitations. +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | TrainedstrongstudentmodelM | | | S | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: InitializeM | S | withpretrainedweights | | | | +ExperimentalSetup +2: foreachepochi=1to2do +Models WeusepretrainedlanguagemodelsfromtheGPT- 3: TrainM onweaklabelsf (x)withbatchsize32 +| | | | | | | | | | S | | w | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4family,whichspan7ordersofmagnitudeincompute.This 4: ifvalidationaccuracyimprovesthen +wide range allows us to analyze the performance gap be- UpdateM +| | | | | | | | | 5: | | S | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| tweenweakandstrongmodelsacrossdifferentlevelsofca- | | | | | | | | 6: else | | | | | | +pability.ThemodelsareaccessedthroughtheOpenAIAPI, 7: Applyearlystopping +| and we replace | | the unembedding | | layer | with | a task-specific | | 8: endif | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| linear classification | | head | for | each model | to | suit the | experi- | 9: endfor | | | | | | +ments. +Tasks Weevaluateourmethodsontwosettings: +| | | | | | | | | Improved | Methods | To | enhance the performance | | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ------ | +1. NaturalLanguageProcessing(NLP)benchmarks:We strongstudentmodel,weemployseveralimprovedmethods: +useasuiteof22classificationtasks,coveringareaslike +| | | | | | | | | a) Auxiliary | | Confidence | Loss: We | introduce | a | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| ethics, | commonsense | | reasoning, | | natural | language | infer- | | | | | | | +confidence-drivenlosstermthatbalancesthecross-entropy +| ence, | and sentiment | | analysis. | All | tasks | are | converted | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ---- | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | loss between | weak | label | predictions and | a thresholded | | +| to binary | classification, | | with | soft | labels | from | the weak | | | | | | | +versionofthemodel’sownpredictions. +modelusedfortraining.ThesetasksarelistedinTable1. +| 2. Chess | puzzles: | Using | the | Chess | Game | Dataset | from | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Algorithm4:AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss +Lichess(Datasnaek2021),wepredictthebestmovefor +eachposition.Thedatasetconsistsofsequencesofmoves Inputs: Model predictions f(x), Weak labels f (x), +w +| | | | | | | | | Thresholdedpredictionsf | | | (x),Weightingfactorα | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | +| leadinguptoapuzzle,formattedasinputsforourmodel. | | | | | | | | | | | t | | | +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | UpdatedmodelM | | withconfidence-drivenloss | | | +S +1: Setα=0.75forlargemodels,0.5otherwise +WeakSupervisorCreation +| | | | | | | | | 2: ComputeL | | (f)=(1−α)·CE(f(x),f | | | (x))+α· | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | | conf | | | w | | +We create weak supervisors by generating weak labels, CE(f(x),f (x)) +t +whichguidethealignmentofstrongermodels.Theprocess 3: TrainM usingL (f)withlinearwarm-upoverthe +S conf +involvesthefollowingstepsmentionedinAlgorithm2: first20%oftraining +Algorithm2:WeakLabelGenerationProcess +| | | | | | | | | b) Bootstrapping: | | Rather | than training | the | strongest | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | +Inputs: TaskdatasetD +| | | | | | | | | model directly | with | the weakest | supervisor, | we | use inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +Ensure: WeaklabelsgeneratedforD +| | | | | | | | | mediate models | in | a bootstrapping | process, | iterating | weak- | +| -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | --- | --------------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | +| 1: Split | dataset | D into | two | halves: | D and | D , | grouping | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 1 | 2 | | to-stronglearninginstages. | | | | | | +relateddatapoints +| 2: Finetune | a | smaller | pretrained | model | M | on | D using | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | W | 1 | Algorithm5:BootstrappingwithIntermediateModels | | | | | | +groundtruthlabels +3: UseM W togenerateweaklabelsforD 2 Inputs: Weak labels f w (x), Intermediate models +| | | | | | | | | M ,M | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | S1 | S2 | | S | | | +Ensure: TrainedstrongmodelM +| After generating | | weak | labels, | we | train | the weak | super- | | | | S | | | +| ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------- | ------ | -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: Foreachroundr | | =1to3: | | | | +| visor over | 2 epochs | with | a | batch | size of | 32. Early | stop- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ForeachintermediatemodelM | | | | : | | +| | | | | | | | | 2: | | | Si | | | +| ping is applied | | based | on validation | | accuracy | to ensure | the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 3: | TrainM | Si onf w | (x)andgeneratenewweaklabels | | | +| model is | properly | trained | to | produce | informative | | labels for | | | | | | | +f (x) +| thestrongermodels. | | | | | | | | wi | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 4: Train | M | on f | (x) using the | best intermediate | | +S wi +model +StrongStudentTraining +| The strong | student | model | is | trained | using | the weak | labels. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +We apply several training strategies, including a baseline c) Generative Finetuning: Before weak-to-strong train- +method and more advanced techniques to improve perfor- ing, we perform unsupervised finetuning on task-relevant +| mance. | | | | | | | | datatoimprovethemodel’srepresentationofkeyconcepts. | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| TaskName | | Source | | | | | Description | | | | | | TaskType | | +| -------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| CoLA | | Warstadtetal.,2019 | | | | | Linguisticacceptability | | | | | | Binary | | +| SST-2 | | Socheretal.,2013 | | | | | Sentimentanalysis | | | | | | Binary | | +| MRPC | | Dolan&Brockett,2005 | | | | | Paraphrasedetection | | | | | | Binary | | +| STS-B | | Ceretal.,2017 | | | | | Semantictextualsimilarity | | | | | | Regression | | +| QQP | | Quora | | | | | Questionpairsimilarity | | | | | | Binary | | +| MNLI | | Williamsetal.,2018 | | | | | Naturallanguageinference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| QNLI | | Rajpurkaretal.,2016 | | | | | QuestionansweringNLI | | | | | | Binary | | +| RTE | | Daganetal.,2006 | | | | | Recognizingtextualentailment | | | | | | Binary | | +| WNLI | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| AX | | Wangetal.,2019 | | | | | DiagnosticdatasetforMNLI | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| CB | | DeMarneffeetal.,2019 | | | | | CommitmentBank | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| COPA | | Roemmeleetal.,2011 | | | | | ChoiceofPlausibleAlternatives | | | | | | Binary | | +MultiRC Khashabietal.,2018 Multi-SentenceReadingComprehension Binary +ReCoRD Zhangetal.,2018 ReadingComprehensionwithCommonsense Binary +| WiC | | Pilehvar&Camacho-Collados,2019 | | | | | Word-in-Context | | | | | | Binary | | +| --------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| WSC | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| BoolQ | | Clarketal.,2019 | | | | | BooleanQuestions | | | | | | Binary | | +| RACE | | Laietal.,2017 | | | | | ReadingComprehension | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SciTail | | Khotetal.,2018 | | | | | ScienceQuestionAnswering | | | | | | Binary | | +| SNLI | | Bowmanetal.,2015 | | | | | NaturalLanguageInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SWAG | | Zellersetal.,2018 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| HellaSWAG | | Zellersetal.,2019 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +Table1:NLPClassificationTasks +Algorithm6:GenerativeFinetuning model size. Each stage consists of 3 iterations of weak-to- +| | | | | | | | | strong learning. | | The learning | rate | is reduced | by | a factor of | +| ------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| Inputs: | Task-relevantdataD | | | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | task | | | S | | | | | | | | | +| Ensure: | FinetunedstrongmodelM | | | | | | | 10ateachstage. | | | | | | | +S +| 1: PretrainM | | S onD task | withalanguagemodelingobjec- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | GenerativeFinetuning | | | Forgenerativefinetuning,wepre- | | | | +tive +trainthestrongmodelontask-relevant,unlabeleddatausing +| 2: Proceed | with | weak-to-strong | | training | on | weak | labels | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +alanguagemodelingobjective.Wethenfinetunethemodel +f (x) +| w | | | | | | | | usingweaklabels,withalearningrateof5e−5 | | | | | | andabatch | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +sizeof16. +These methods collectively improve the robustness and EvaluationMetrics +| accuracy | of the | strong student | | model, | enabling | better | gen- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eralization and alignment with weak labels across different 1. PerformanceGapRecovered(PGR): +tasks. +P −P +| | | | | | | | | | | PGR= | | ws w | | (3) | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DetailedMethodsDescription | | | | | | | | | | | | P s −P w | | | +Baseline Method For the baseline method, we finetune WhereP istheweak-to-strongperformance,P +| | | | | | | | | | ws | | | | | w isthe | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | +| the strong | student | model | directly | on weak | labels | generated | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | weak | performance, | | and P s | is the strong | ceiling | perfor- | +1e−4, +| by the weak | supervisor. | | We use | a learning | rate | of | a | mance. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +batchsizeof32,andapplyearlystoppingbasedonvalida- +| | | | | | | | | 2. Student-SupervisorAgreement:Thefractionoftestin- | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionaccuracy. +putswherethestrongstudentmakesthesameprediction +astheweaksupervisor. +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| method | introduces | a loss | term | that combines | | cross-entropy | | | | | | | | | +loss with confidence-based regularization. The weighting AblationStudies +factorαissetto0.5formediummodelsand0.75forlarge +| | | | | | | | | We conduct | ablation | studies | to | evaluate | the impact | of dif- | +| ------- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | +| models, | with linear | warm-up | over | the | first 20% | of training | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ferent components | | of our | method. | Specifically, | | we analyze | +epochs. +| | | | | | | | | the effect | of removing | | the auxiliary | confidence | | loss, boot- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +Bootstrapping In the bootstrapping approach, we train strapping, and generative finetuning. The results are shown +| intermediate | models | in | three | stages, | gradually | increasing | | inTable2. | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 2: Ablation Study Results: Impact of Removing Key tratesthePerformanceGapRecovered(PGR)acrossdiffer- +Components on Model Performance. The table shows ac- enttaskdomainsandmodelsizes. +curacy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) when each +componentisremoved.Lowervalueshighlightthecompo- Performance Across Tasks Figure 1 illustrates the test +nent’s importance. Auxiliary Confidence Loss and Genera- accuracy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) for our +tiveFinetuninghavethemostsignificantimpact,underscor- three task domains: NLP benchmarks, chess puzzles, and +ingtheircriticalroleintheframework’seffectiveness. ChatGPTrewardmodeling. +Method Accuracy PGR +(Without) (Without) +Aux.Confidence 0.82 0.60 +Bootstrapping 0.80 0.55 +Gen.Finetuning 0.85 0.70 +Analysis +Weconductthreetypesofanalysis: +1. Scaling Behavior: We plot PGR and test accuracy +againstsupervisorandstudentmodelsizes. +2. Error Analysis: We manually inspect cases where the +studentmodelmakesmistakes,categorizingerrortypes. +Figure 1: PGR as a function of model size for each task +3. ConceptSaliency:Wemeasuretheperformanceoflin- +domain. Higher PGR values indicate more effective weak- +ear probes on frozen model activations before and after +to-stronglearning.ThegraphshowsthatPGRgenerallyin- +weak-to-strongtraining. +creases with model size for NLP tasks, while it decreases +This methodology provides a comprehensive framework +forlargermodelsinchesstasks,indicatingscalabilitychal- +for studying weak-to-strong generalization in model align- +lenges. Reward modeling shows consistently lower PGR, +ment, incorporating various training techniques and eval- +highlightingtheneedformoreadvancedmethods. +uation metrics to assess the effectiveness of our approach +acrossdifferenttasksandmodelsizes. +ResultsandAnalysis +Our work builds upon and extends recent advancements in +language model alignment, leveraging weak-to-strong gen- +eralizationtechniques to address the challengesof aligning +increasinglycomplexAIsystems. +Toverifytherobustnessofourresults,weconductpaired +t-testscomparingtheperformanceofdifferentmethods.The +resultsarepresentedinTable3. +Table 3: Statistical Significance of Method Improvements. +P-values for paired t-tests comparing the baseline method +to each enhanced approach in terms of Accuracy and Per- +formance Gap Recovered (PGR). Lower p-values (< 0.05) +indicatestatisticallysignificantimprovementsoverthebase- Figure 2: Accuracy as a function of model size for each +line,withBootstrappingshowingthemostsignificantgains. task domain. Weak-to-strong generalization improves per- +formance across all tasks, with NLP achieving the highest +Comparison P-value P-value accuracy.ChessandRewardModelingshowdiminishingre- +(Accuracy) (PGR) turnswithlargermodels,highlightingchallengesinscaling +Baselinevs.Aux.Confidence 0.03 0.01 theapproachtomorecomplextasksandareasforfuturere- +Baselinevs.Bootstrapping 0.003 0.002 search +Baselinevs.Gen.Finetuning 0.01 0.01 +NLP tasks: We observe promising weak-to-strong gen- +eralization, with PGR often exceeding 50% for the largest +BaselineWeak-to-StrongGeneralization +student models. Chess puzzles: PGR is high for small +Our initial experiments demonstrate that strong pretrained supervisor-student gaps but decreases for larger gaps. Re- +modelscannaturallygeneralizebeyondtheirweaksupervi- ward modeling: Weak-to-strong generalization is poor by +sorswhennaivelyfinetunedonweaklabels.Figure1illus- default,withPGRrarelyexceeding20%. + +Scaling Behavior We find that PGR generally increases AnalysisofGeneralizationMechanisms +| with both | weak | supervisor | size and | strong | student | size for | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Imitation | vs. | Generalization | | We | analyze | student- | | +NLPtasks.However,forchesspuzzles,PGRdecreaseswith +| | | | | | | | supervisor | agreement | to | understand | | the extent | of imitation | | +| -------------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | +| strong student | size | for a | given | weak supervisor. | | Reward | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | versus true | generalization, | | | illustrated | in | Figure | 3. The | +modelingshowspoorscalingbehavioroverall. +| | | | | | | | student-supervisor | | agreement | | trends | corroborate | our | sta- | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------------ | ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | +| Our findings | on | scaling | behavior | align | with the | observa- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tistical | significance | results | (Table | | 3), providing | | insights | +tionsof(Baietal.2022)intheirworkonConstitutionalAI, +| | | | | | | | into the | effectiveness | | of different | weak-to-strong | | learning | | +| ---------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| suggesting | that | alignment | techniques | must | adapt | as model | | | | | | | | | +methods. +capabilitiesincrease. +| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Figure | 3, all | methods | exhibit | decreasing | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | agreement | rates | as model | size | increases, | but | to varying | de- | +ImprovedWeak-to-StrongGeneralizationMethods +grees.Thisgeneraltrendsuggeststhatlargermodelstendto +Drawing inspiration from ”AI Safety via Debate” frame- diverge more from the weak supervisor’s predictions, indi- +work (Irving, Christiano, and Amodei 2018), we explore cating potential generalization beyond the initial weak su- +| methods | to enhance | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | through | pervision. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +adversarialdynamicsandstructuredlearning. +Notably,theBootstrappingmethoddemonstratesthemost +substantialdecreaseinagreementacrossmodelsizes(from +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | -------- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | 0.88 for | small | models | to 0.75 | for large | models). | This | pro- | +| significantly | improves | weak-to-strong | | generalization, | | par- | | | | | | | | | +nounceddeclinealignswithitslowestp-valuesinourstatis- +ticularlyforNLPtasks. +| | | | | | | | tical significance | | tests | (p = 0.003 | for | accuracy, | p = | 0.002 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | for PGR), | suggesting | that | Bootstrapping | | is | particularly | ef- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +• Forthelargestsupervisor-studentgaps,medianPGRin- fective at enabling the model to surpass the weak supervi- +| creases | from | about 25% | to nearly | 80% | with | the confi- | sor’sperformance. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +denceloss. The Auxiliary Confidence and Generative Finetuning +• The improvement is most pronounced for large gaps in methods show moderate decreases in agreement (0.89 to +computebetweenweakandstrongmodels. 0.80and0.89to0.79,respectively),consistentwiththeirin- +| | | | | | | | termediate | p-values. | These | methods | | appear | to strike | a bal- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | +This approach can be seen as an extension of the debate ancebetweenleveragingweaksupervisionandencouraging +framework, encouraging models to make confident predic- independentgeneralization. +tionswhilestillleveragingweaksupervision. +Incontrast,theBaselinemethodmaintainsrelativelyhigh +| | | | | | | | agreement | across | all model | sizes | (0.90 | to 0.87), | indicating | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Bootstrapping | | Bootstrappingshowspromisingresultsfor | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that without | additional | | techniques, | | larger | models | tend to | +chesspuzzlesbutyieldslimitedimprovementsforNLPand +morecloselymimictheweaksupervisor,potentiallyinclud- +rewardmodelingtasks. +ingitserrors. +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | These | findings | suggest | that | our enhanced | | methods, | par- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | +• Bootstrapping improves PGR compared to the baseline, ticularlyBootstrapping,aremoreeffectiveatenablingmod- +especiallyforlargerstudentmodels. elstogeneralizebeyondtheweaksupervisor’scapabilities. +Thedecreasingagreementrates,coupledwithimprovedper- +| • The | accuracy | continues | to monotonically | | improve | with | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bootstrapping,unliketheflatteningobservedinthenaive formance(asindicatedbylowerp-values),demonstratethat +thesemethodsfacilitatethedevelopmentofmodelsthatcan +method. +| | | | | | | | leverage | weak | supervision | while | still | developing | indepen- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +The bootstrapping method resonates with the iterative dentandpotentiallysuperiordecision-makingcapabilities. +| refinement | processes | suggested | in | Constitutional | | AI (Bai | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----- | --------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | Larger | student | models | show | lower | agreement | with | weak | +etal.2022),allowingforgradualimprovementofalignment +| | | | | | | | supervisors, | suggesting | | less imitation | | of errors. | The | auxil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +acrossmodelscales. iary confidenceloss furtherreduces imitationof supervisor +mistakes. +| Generative | Finetuning | | Generative | finetuning | | on reward | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | These | findings | contribute | | to our | understanding | | of how | +| modeling | data improves | | weak-to-strong | | performance | and | | | | | | | | | +modelsbalanceimitationandtruegeneralization,akeycon- +PGR. +cerninscalingalignmenttechniques(Ouyangetal.2022). +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | ConceptSaliency | | Weinvestigatethelinearrepresentabil- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• PGRimprovesbyapproximately10-20%withgenerative +| | | | | | | | ity of desired | | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +finetuning. +learning.Figure4illustratesthechangeinlinearprobeper- +• Theimprovementstackswithearly-stoppingtechniques, +| | | | | | | | formance | for key | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +achievingPGRof30-40%. +learning. +This technique builds on the insights from (Dehghani Finetuningonweaklabelsincreasesthelinearseparability +et al. 2017; Pe´rez-D’Arpino, Khurshid, and Shah 2020) on ofgroundtruthconcepts.Thissuggeststhatweak-to-strong +discovering and shaping language model behaviors, using learning may help make desired concepts more salient in +| task-relevantdatatoenhancealignment. | | | | | | | modelrepresentations. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Figure3:Student-supervisoragreementacrossmodelsizesfordifferentweak-to-strongmethods.Decliningagreementinboot- +strapping and Auxiliary confidence suggests improved generalization, while the baseline method remains stable, indicating +limitedgeneralization. +| This analysis | provides | | insights | into how | weak-to-strong | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | +learningmayhelpinshapingmodelbehavior,complement- +ingtheworkonConstitutionalAI(Baietal.2022)ininstill- +ingdesiredconceptsandvalues. +ErrorAnalysis +| We conducted | a detailed | | error analysis | | on cases | where the | +| ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +strongstudentmodelmakesmistakes.Commonerrortypes +include: +• Poorquoteselection(forNLPtasks) +| • Inability | to extract | key | evidence | from | weak | supervision | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | +(forrewardmodeling) +• Overfittingtoweaklabelerrors(acrossalltasks) +Ourerroranalysisbuildsontheframeworkofdebate(Irv- +ing,Christiano,andAmodei2018),identifyingareaswhere +| adversarial | dynamics | can | be leveraged | | to improve | model | +| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | +performanceandalignment. +| To better | understand | | the types | of errors | made | by the | +| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | +Figure4:Conceptsaliencybeforeandafterweak-to-strong +learningforkeyNLPconcepts.Thefigureshowsimproved strong student model, we present the distribution of error +linearprobeperformance,indicatingenhancedmodelrepre- typesinFigure5. +sentationsacrossallconcepts.LargergainsinSentimentvs. +DiscussionandConclusion +Intentsuggestthatweak-to-stronglearningaffectsdifferent +aspects of language understanding to varying degrees, pro- Ourworkdemonstratestheeffectivenessofweak-to-strong +vidinginsightsforfutureimprovements. generalization in language models for model alignment. +| The proposed | framework, | | which | combines | facilitation | and | +| ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | +| debate-based | learning, | shows | promise | in | enhancing | model | +| performance | and | alignment | across | various | tasks. | Through | + +| | | | | | | | • While an | improvement | over | baseline | approaches, | | naive | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | +finetuningonweaksupervisionisinsufficienttofullyre- +coverstrongmodelperformance,indicatingtheneedfor +moresophisticatedtransfertechniques. +| | | | | | | | • Generalization | remains | inconsistent | | across | tasks, | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | complex | domains like | reward | modeling | | proving | partic- | +ularlychallenging.Thishighlightstheneedformorero- +bustandadaptivealignmenttechniques. +• Ourcurrentsetup,thoughanadvancementoverprevious +| | | | | | | | methods, | may not fully | capture | the | difficulties | | of align- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +ingsuperhumanAIsystems,suchasthepotentialeaseof +imitatinghuman-levelerrors. +Theselimitationspointtoseveralpromisingdirectionsfor +Figure5:Distributionoferrortypesfromtheerroranalysis. +futurework: +Thechartshowsthatpoorquoteselectionandevidenceex- +| | | | | | | | • Developing | more sophisticated | | | debate | mechanisms | to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +tractionaccountfor70%oferrors,suggestingimprovements +enhancethequalityandefficiencyofknowledgetransfer +| in identifying | relevant | information | | could enhance | weak-to- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweenmodelsofvaryingcapabilities. +stronglearning.Overfittingerrors(20%)arerelativelylow, +indicating the approach generally succeeds in generalizing • Exploringtheintegrationofourapproachwithotherscal- +beyondweaklabels,thoughfurtherimprovementispossible +| | | | | | | | able oversight | methods | to | create | more | comprehensive | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | +alignmentframeworks. +| | | | | | | | • Investigating | the application | | of this | framework | | to even | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | +| our experiments | | and analysis, | we | have gained | several | key | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | more advanced | AI | systems | and diverse | | task domains | to | +insightsintothenatureofmodelalignmentthroughfacilita- +testitsscalabilityandgeneralizability. +tion: +• Refiningourunderstandingofmodelbehaviorandalign- +| 1. Strong | models | demonstrate | a remarkable | | ability | to gen- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | ment across | increasing | scales | of | capability | to | better ad- | +| eralize | beyond | weak supervision, | | particularly | | in NLP | | | | | | | | +dressthechallengesofaligningsuperhumanAIsystems. +| tasks, | suggesting | the potential | | for knowledge | | transfer | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +acrossdifferentcapabilitylevels. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that weak-to- +2. The introduction of auxiliary confidence loss signif- strong generalization is a promising approach for model +icantly improves generalization, especially for large alignment,capableofelicitingstrongcapabilitiesfromlim- +| supervisor-student | | gaps, | highlighting | the | importance | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ited supervision. | By bridging | | the gap | between | explanation | | +calibratedconfidenceinthealignmentprocess. generationandmodelalignment,ourframeworkopensnew +3. Techniquessuchasbootstrappingandgenerativefinetun- avenues for creating AI systems that are not only powerful +ing show potential in addressing domain-specific chal- but also fundamentally aligned with human values and in- +tentions.Whilesignificantchallengesremaininscalingthis +lenges,asevidencedbytheireffectivenessinchesspuz- +approachtomorecomplextasksandtrulysuperhumanmod- +zlesandrewardmodelingtasks. +4. Thelearningprocessrequiresadelicatebalancebetween els,theinsightsgainedfromthisworkprovideasolidfoun- +dationforfutureresearchinAIalignmentandsafety. +imitationandtruegeneralization,emphasizingthecom- +| plexity | of aligning | AI | systems | with human | values | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| intentions. | | | | | | | | | References | | | | | +Compared to traditional explanation generation ap- Bai, Y.; Kadavath, S.; Kundu, S.; Askell, A.; Kernion, J.; +proaches,ourframeworkoffersseveraladvantages: Jones,A.;Chen,A.;Goldie,A.;Mirhoseini,A.;McKinnon, +C.;etal.2022.Constitutionalai:Harmlessnessfromaifeed- +• ItprovidesamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +back. arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.08073. +capabilitiesevolve,addressingthescalabilitychallenges +facedbycurrentmethodslikeRLHF. Buciluaˇ, C.; Caruana, R.; and Niculescu-Mizil, A. 2006. +• Thedebate-basedcomponentenhancestransparencyand Model compression. In Proceedings of the 12th ACM +interpretability, allowing for more nuanced oversight of SIGKDDinternationalconferenceonKnowledgediscovery +| thealignmentprocess. | | | | | | | anddatamining,535–541. | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• By leveraging both weak and strong models, our ap- Burns, C.; Izmailov, P.; Kirchner, J. H.; Baker, B.; Gao, +proachpotentiallyovercomeslimitationsofhumanover- L.; Aschenbrenner, L.; Chen, Y.; Ecoffet, A.; Joglekar, M.; +sightincomplextasks. Leike,J.;etal.2023. Weak-to-stronggeneralization:Elicit- +ingstrongcapabilitieswithweaksupervision.arXivpreprint +| However, | despite | these | promising | results, | several | limita- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionsandchallengesremain,echoingconcernsidentifiedin arXiv:2312.09390. +recent alignment research (Ouyang et al. 2022; Bai et al. Cooke,N.J.2015. Teamcognitionasinteraction. Current +2022;Pe´rez-D’Arpino,Khurshid,andShah2020): directionsinpsychologicalscience,24(6):415–419. + +Cooke,N.J.;Gorman,J.C.;Myers,C.W.;andDuran,J.L. Stiennon, N.; Ouyang, L.; Wu, J.; Ziegler, D.; Lowe, R.; +2013. Interactiveteamcognition. Cognitivescience,37(2): Voss, C.; Radford, A.; Amodei, D.; and Christiano, P. F. +| 255–285. | | | | | | | 2020. | Learning | to | summarize | with | human | feedback. | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Advances | in Neural | | Information | Processing | | Systems, | 33: | +Datasnaek.2021.ChessGameDataset(Lichess).Accessed: +3008–3021. +2024-08-09. +Zakershahrak,M.;Gong,Z.;Sadassivam,N.;andZhang,Y. +Dehghani,M.;Severyn,A.;Rothe,S.;andKamps,J.2017. +2020a. Onlineexplanationgenerationforplanningtasksin +Learningtolearnfromweaksupervisionbyfullsupervision. +human-robotteaming.In2020IEEE/RSJInternationalCon- +arXivpreprintarXiv:1711.11383. +| | | | | | | | ference | on Intelligent | | Robots | and Systems | (IROS), | | 6304– | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| Ghodratnama, | S.; | and | Zakershahrak, | M. | 2023. | Adapt- | 6310.IEEE. | | | | | | | | +ingLLMsforEfficient,PersonalizedInformationRetrieval: +| | | | | | | | Zakershahrak, | | M.; Marpally, | | S. R.; Sharma, | | A.; Gong, | Z.; | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | +| Methods | and Implications. | | In | International | Conference | on | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Zhang, | Y. | 2020b. | Order | Matters: | Generating | | Pro- | +Service-OrientedComputing,17–26.Springer. +| | | | | | | | gressive | Explanations | | for Planning | Tasks | in | Human-Robot | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| Ghodratnama,S.;andZakershahrak,M.2024. | | | | | SumRecom: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Teaming. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2004.07822. | | | | | | | +APersonalizedSummarizationApproachbyLearningfrom Zakershahrak, M.; Sonawane, A.; Gong, Z.; and Zhang, Y. +| Users’Feedback. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2408.07294. | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2018.Interactiveplanexplicabilityinhuman-robotteaming. +Gunning, D. 2017. Explainable artificial intelligence (xai). In 2018 27th IEEE International Symposium on Robot and +Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), nd HumanInteractiveCommunication(RO-MAN),1012–1017. +| Web. | | | | | | | IEEE. | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Hadfield-Menell,D.;Russell,S.J.;Abbeel,P.;andDragan, Ziebart, B. D.; Maas, A.; Bagnell, J. A.; and Dey, A. K. +A. 2016. Cooperative inverse reinforcement learning. In 2008. MaximumEntropyInverseReinforcementLearning. +Advances in neural information processing systems, 3909– InProceedingsofthe23rdNationalConferenceonArtificial +Intelligence-Volume3,AAAI’08,1433–1438.AAAIPress. +3917. +Irving, G.; Christiano, P.; and Amodei, D. 2018. AI safety ISBN9781577353683. +| viadebate. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1805.00899. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| LeCun,Y.;Bengio,Y.;andHinton,G.2015. | | | | | Deeplearning. | | | | | | | | | | +nature,521(7553):436–444. +Leike,J.;Krueger,D.;Everitt,T.;Martic,M.;Maini,V.;and +| Legg,S.2018. | Scalableagentalignmentviarewardmodel- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ing:aresearchdirection. | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:1811.07871. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Miller, | T. 2018. | Explanation | | in artificial | intelligence: | In- | | | | | | | | | +| sightsfromthesocialsciences. | | | | ArtificialIntelligence. | | | | | | | | | | | +Mittal,A.;Schick,T.;Artetxe,M.;andDwivedi-Yu,J.2023. +| Evaluation | of Faithfulness | | Using | the | Longest | Supported | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Subsequence. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2308.12157. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Ng, A. | Y.; and Russell, | | S. J. 2000. | Algorithms | | for Inverse | | | | | | | | | +InICML,663–670.MorganKauf- +ReinforcementLearning. +mannPublishersInc. +Ouyang,L.;Wu,J.;Jiang,X.;Almeida,D.;Wainwright,C.; +| Mishkin, | P.; Zhang, | C.; | Agarwal, | S.; Slama, | K.; | Ray, A.; | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| etal.2022. | Traininglanguagemodelstofollowinstructions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| withhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralinformationpro- | | | | | | | | | | | | +cessingsystems,35:27730–27744. +Pe´rez-D’Arpino,C.;Khurshid,R.P.;andShah,J.A.2020. +| Experimental | Assessment | | of | Human-Robot | Teaming | for | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Multi-Step | Remote | Manipulation | | with | Expert | Operators. | | | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2011.10898. +| Sanh,V.;Debut,L.;Chaumond,J.;andWolf,T.2019. | | | | | | Dis- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tilBERT,adistilledversionofBERT:smaller,faster,cheaper +| andlighter. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1910.01108. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Seeber, | I.; Bittner, | E.; | Briggs, | R. O.; | De Vreede, | T.; | | | | | | | | | +DeVreede,G.-J.;Elkins,A.;Maier,R.;Merz,A.B.;Oeste- +| Reiß,S.;Randrup,N.;etal.2020. | | | | Machinesasteammates: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| AresearchagendaonAIinteamcollaboration. | | | | | | Information | | | | | | | | | +&management,57(2):103174. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q41/random_k4/random_4.md b/q41/random_k4/random_4.md index 1b6b058bf683a33b480b8b8268e1555ff4290087..21334ddd46260172e524aadea187c07f9093da70 100644 --- a/q41/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q41/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,532 +1,1434 @@ -Preprint. Under review. - -## **Retrieval Augmented Conversational Recommendation with Reinforcement Learning** - -**Zhenrui Yue**[1] **, Honglei Zhuang**[2] **, Zhen Qin**[2] **, Zhankui He**[3] **, Huimin Zeng**[1] **, Julian McAuley**[3] **, Dong Wang**[1] - -1University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, 2Google DeepMind, 3UC San Diego {zhenrui3, dwang24}@illinois.edu - -## **Abstract** - -Large language models (LLMs) exhibit enhanced capabilities in language understanding and generation. By utilizing their embedded knowledge, LLMs are increasingly used as conversational recommender systems (CRS), achieving improved recommendation performance across diverse scenarios. However, existing LLM-based methods rely on pretrained knowledge without external retrieval mechanisms for novel items. Additionally, the lack of a unified corpus poses challenges for integrating retrieval augmentation into CRS. Motivated by these challenges, we present RAR, a novel twostage retrieval augmented conversational recommendation framework that aligns retrieval and generation to enhance both performance and factuality. To support this framework and provide a unified corpus, we construct a large-scale movie corpus, comprising over 300k movies with rich metadata, such as titles, casts and plot summaries. Leveraging this data, our primary contribution is RAR, the first framework to departs from standard two-stage CRS by dynamically bridging retrieval and generation. First, a retriever model generates candidate items based on user history; in the subsequent stage, an LLM refines the recommendations by incorporating conversational context with retrieved results. In addition, we introduce a novel reinforcement learning (RL) method that leverages LLM feedback to iteratively update the retriever. By creating a collaborative feedback loop that reinforces sampled candidate sets with higher ranking metrics, RAR effectively mitigates the misalignment between the retrieval and generation stages. Furthermore, grounding the LLM in factual metadata allows our RL-driven approach to capture subtle user intentions and generate context-aware recommendations with reduced hallucinations. We validate our approach through extensive experiments on multiple CRS benchmarks, where RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baseline methods. - -## **1 Introduction** - -Conversational recommender systems (CRS) have emerged as a promising paradigm for providing personalized recommendations through natural language interactions (Zhang et al., 2018; Li et al., 2018; Kang et al., 2019; Hayati et al., 2020; Gao et al., 2023; He et al., 2023). Recent advancements in large language models (LLM) (Achiam et al., 2023; Dubey et al., 2024; Comanici et al., 2025) have further enabled CRS methods to utilize their extensive knowledge and diverse generation capabilities, demonstrating improvements across different recommendation scenarios (Feng et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024; Li et al., 2024; Hui et al., 2026). For example, He et al. (2023) adopt LLMs to generate movie candidates and achieve superior performance compared to traditional CRS methods. - -Nevertheless, language models often lack the essential knowledge to recommend the most suitable items (e.g., being unaware of relevant options) (He et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024; Wu et al., 2024). As a solution, traditional CRS methods exploit search modules or knowledge graphs to provide additional contextual information (Zhang et al., 2018; Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020). Similarly, LLM-based CRS methods leverage knowledge graph retrieval - -1 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**==> picture [378 x 71] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Conversation Context Candidates Response
I love the Gladiator movie, any recommendations? Sure! I think you may
You would love Goodfellas ! Retrieve Generate enjoy Saving Private
Did they make a new Terminator ? Ryan , Braveheart …
Yes, there is a new Terminator .
Have you seen the trailer?
Na, I'm looking for something with the intensity of
war, maybe bravery and loyalty.
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Figure 1: Our retrieval-augmented conversational recommendation framework, where a retriever gathers candidate items and the LLM generates the response conditioned on them. - -or training on a broad range of items to improve recommendation relevance (Li et al., 2024; Jeon et al., 2025; Zare & Alamdari, 2025). A notable example is ReFICR, where LLMs are trained on extensive curated data to perform sub-tasks including indexing, retrieval and generation(Yang & Chen, 2024). In Figure 1, we illustrate this general approach of the two-stage retrieval augmented conversational recommendation. - -While LLMs can accommodate novel items through additional training, scaling this process to extensive items and conversations is often infeasible, particularly when managing large volumes of items and noisy conversations (Jannach et al., 2021; Zhu et al., 2025; Surana et al., 2025). On the other hand, retrieving from knowledge graph requires significant efforts in data preprocessing, modeling and graph indexing. Graph retrieval can also be more computationally intensive when indexing or traversing through large-scale graphs (Li et al., 2024; Peng et al., 2024). Although embedding-based retrieval is a straightforward alternative (Reimers & Gurevych, 2019; Wang et al., 2022a; Chen et al., 2024), its effectiveness is limited by the lack of a unified corpus that provides comprehensive attribute-level metadata (e.g., plot, cast) corpus. As such, embedding-based retrieval remains largely underexplored in conversational recommendation. Furthermore, LLM-based CRS often exhibits retrieval–generation misalignment: when the retriever returns sub-optimal candidates (e.g., low-relevance items), LLM could amplify such deficiencies and cause deteriorated accuracy on cold-start or less-popular items (He et al., 2023; Kemper et al., 2024). - -In this paper, we investigate how embedding-based retrieval augmentation can be used to improve two-stage conversational recommendation. To address the limitations of existing, small-scale movie corpora (e.g., REDIAL with _∼_ 7k titles), we curate a comprehensive evaluation benchmark of over 300k movies, systematically enriched with metadata (e.g., titles, casts, and plot summaries). By establishing this robust, large-scale foundation, our primary contribution is RAR, a novel LLM-based retrieval augmented conversational recommendation framework. In the first stage, we employ a retriever model to select candidate items based on the conversational history. Subsequently, an LLM refines the recommendations by incorporating conversational context with retrieved candidates, enabling personalized and fine-grained recommendation results. To enhance retrieval-generation alignment, we further optimize the retriever by leveraging LLM feedback for reinforcement learning (RL). This feedback enables RAR to iteratively update the retriever through online, on-policy preference optimization. As a result, RAR can be adapted for any black-box LLMs and deliver high-quality, context-aware recommendations. We demonstrate the efficacy of RAR with extensive experiments, where RAR consistently outperforms baselines on multiple benchmark datasets. We summarize our contributions in the following[1] : - - 1. We present the first large-scale study of embedding-based retrieval augmentation for conversational recommendation. To support this scale, we synthesize a highlyenriched, structured baseline of over 300k films with comprehensive metadata. - - 2. We propose RAR, an LLM-based CRS framework with two-stage retrieval augmentation. By utilizing LLM feedback as reward signals, we design an online, on-policy reinforcement learning framework that enhances retrieval–generation alignment. - - 3. We demonstrate the effectiveness our approach by utilizing our curated retrieval corpus, where the RL post-trained RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art - -- 1Our data and code can be accessed at https://github.com/Yueeeeeeee/RAR. - -2 - -Preprint. Under review. - -baseline methods, achieving considerable improvements in recommendation performance on established benchmark datasets. - -## **2 Related Work** - -## **2.1 Retrieval Augmented Generation** - -Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) enhances language modeling by integrating external knowledge into context (Lewis et al., 2020; Guu et al., 2020; Karpukhin et al., 2020). Beyond naïve RAG, performance is improved by refining the retriever (e.g., via joint optimization (Lin et al., 2024)) (Trivedi et al., 2023; Jiang et al., 2023; Shi et al., 2024; Sarthi et al., 2024), upgrading document encoding (Izacard & Grave, 2021; Borgeaud et al., 2022; Izacard et al., 2023), and selectively filtering retrieved knowledge to minimize irrelevant context (Yoran et al., 2024; Yan et al., 2024; Yue et al., 2024b; Jin et al., 2025). While concurrently applied to sequential recommendation (Wu et al., 2024; Kemper et al., 2024), RAG’s potential for conversational recommendation remains largely under-explored. To bridge this gap, we build a unified movie metadata corpus and examine retrieval-augmented LLMs, aiming to enhance CRS performance via effective knowledge retrieval. - -## **2.2 Conversational Recommendation** - -Conversational recommender systems (CRS) capture user preferences via multi-turn interactions to improve recommendations. Early methods relied on complex, multi-module systems for dialogue and recommendation (Zhang et al., 2018; Li et al., 2018; Kang et al., 2019; Hayati et al., 2020; Lei et al., 2020). Later, language modeling and knowledge integration enabled better contextualization of user intent (Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020; Lu et al., 2021; Wang et al., 2022b), such as inferring preferences from incomplete knowledge graphs (Zhang et al., 2023). Recently, large language models (LLMs) (Achiam et al., 2023; Reid et al., 2024; Dubey et al., 2024) have transformed CRS through advanced dialogue capabilities and precise preference modeling (Gao et al., 2023; He et al., 2023; Li et al., 2024; He et al., 2024; Yang & Chen, 2024; Hui et al., 2026), including using LLMs for user simulation (Zhu et al., 2025). Despite these advances, integrating LLMs into CRS and improving the retrieval–generation alignment remain under-investigated. - -## **2.3 Reinforcement Learning** - -Reinforcement learning (RL) maximizes cumulative rewards through environmental interaction (Sutton et al., 1998). RL has been adapted to align LLMs via human feedback (RLHF) (Ouyang et al., 2022), typically utilizing policy gradient variants (Sutton et al., 1999). Methods like A2C and PPO (Mnih et al., 2016; Schulman et al., 2017) leverage learned baselines and clipped surrogate objectives for stable training. Alternatively, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) (Rafailov et al., 2023) efficiently optimizes offline pairwise preferences, though online RL methods consistently achieve superior performance (Xu et al., 2024). Recent online advances like GRPO evaluate candidates against a group-based baseline, significantly reducing memory overhead without sacrificing stability (Shao et al., 2024; Hu, 2025; Yue et al., 2025; 2026; Hübotter et al., 2026). In this work, we propose a novel online RLdriven approach for two-stage conversational recommender systems (CRS) and empirically compare different RL algorithms to identify the optimal strategy for recommendation. - -## **3 Methodology** - -## **3.1 Setup** - -Our conversational recommendation framework is based on a two-stage setting with both retrieval and generation. Consider a conversation _C_ = ( _rt_ , _st_ , _It_ ) _t[T]_ =1[consisting of] _[ T]_[turns,] _rt_ , _st_ and _It_ refer to the role (i.e., _seeker_ or _recommender_ ), sequence (conversation turn) and mentioned items. Each element in _It_ should be included in the corpus _I_ , namely - -3 - -Preprint. Under review. - -_∀i ∈ It_ , _i ∈I_ . Typically, the _seeker_ and _recommender_ take turns to converse in _C_ until the seeker finds desired item(s). Following previous research (Li et al., 2018; Chen et al., 2019; Wang et al., 2022b; He et al., 2023), the conversational recommender aims to generate a ranked list _I_[ˆ] _t_ for the _t_ -th turn when _rt_ is the _recommender_ , such that the generated _I_[ˆ] _t_ best matches the ground truth items _It_ . Specifically for our two-stage framework: - -- _Retrieval_ : In the first stage, the retriever model _f_ ret uses the previous items as query to select an initial candidate set _Ct_ , i.e., _Ct_ = _f_ ret( _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[)][.] - -- _Generation_ : Then, we leverage a LLM _f_ llm to generate _I_[ˆ] _t_ upon user conversation history and retrieved items. Formally, this is expressed as _I_[ˆ] _t_ = _f_ llm( _{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[,] _[ C][t]_[)][,] enabling an in-depth analysis of user preferences and potential interests. - -To fully leverage black-box LLMs without excessive training costs, we refrain from directly training _f_ llm and instead focus on optimizing the retriever model _f_ ret. This design choice offers two key advantages: (1) RAR can be combined with any LLM choice, regardless of whether the LLM is open- or closed-source; (2) by enhancing _f_ ret, we augment _f_ llm through the incorporation of up-to-date external knowledge (e.g., novel items). Our framework optimizes _f_ ret (parameterized by _θ_ ) to maximize the expected reward. Since the retriever and generator are not end-to-end differentiable, generator errors cannot be directly backpropagated. We therefore train _f_ ret via reinforcement learning, maximizing reward _r_ over samples from the retriever across conversations ( _C_ ) and timesteps ( _t_ ) in dataset _X_ : - -**==> picture [331 x 18] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _r_ is a ranking-based reward for the sampled candidate set _Ct_ calculated based on the output of _f_ llm (e.g., NDCG scores). That is, the post-training process updates _θ_ by maximizing the ranking reward, thereby aligning the retrieval and ranking stages in RAR. - -## **3.2 Corpus Construction** - -Existing conversational recommendation datasets either rely on large-scale knowledge graphs or on small, domain-specific corpus (Li et al., 2018; Hayati et al., 2020; He et al., 2023). Therefore, embedding-based retrieval is often impractical with existing data. To address this limitation, we collect and curate a unified text corpus for movie recommendation across datasets. Our initial corpus is built from all available entries across multiple sources, including IMDb genre, IMDb media and Inspired (Hayati et al., 2020; Raju; BrightData). Next, we augment the corpus with inferred entries from MovieLens, Redial and Reddit (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). Then, we aggregate duplicate film entries by cross-referencing and selecting the most reliable metadata. Additionally, we collect missing metadata from online resources for incomplete entries, we also map items in the corpus to the corresponding entries in the datasets (i.e., MovieLens, Inspired, Redial and Reddit). That is, we perform entity recognition to identify each movie mentioned in the conversation and map it to its corresponding entry in the corpus. Finally, we remove entries that were either incomplete or could not be collected, we report detailed information on corpus collection and preprocessing in Section A. In summary, we obtain 337,731 entries with comprehensive metadata, focusing primarily on English-language films (see example in Table 7). The corpus spans from as early as 1888 to upcoming releases in 2029, accounting for approximately half of all movies listed on IMDb as of 2025. Leveraging the collected corpus and constructed correspondence, we pretrain a retriever model on MovieLens by incorporating recommendation data along with negative examples sampled from the corpus (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Yue et al., 2024a). Next, the retriever is optimized with sequential patterns derived from the conversation data, we introduce the details in the following. - -## **3.3 The proposed RAR** - -**Retriever.** For RAR, we adopt the linear recurrent units for sequential recommendation (LRURec) as _f_ ret, with a comparison of different models in Section 4. LRURec utilizes state space modeling (SSM) to efficiently train and infer on sequential input: - -**==> picture [277 x 11] intentionally omitted <==** - -4 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**==> picture [378 x 91] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Generate &
Candidate Set 1 Reward 1
Evaluate
Context Retrieve & Candidate Set 2 Generate & Reward 2 Update
Sample Evaluate Retriever
Further Candidate Sets & Rewards
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Figure 2: The proposed online, on-policy preference optimization in RAR iteratively refines the retriever model by sampling candidate sets, collecting LLM feedback, and then updating the retriever through reinforcement learning. - -with _A_ , _B_ , _C_ being matrices of shape **R** _[H][×][H]_ , and _I_ is the identity matrix. _h_ , _e_ , _o_ denote the hidden state, item embedding and output hidden state. By leveraging LRURec’s linearity via parallel scan, we reduce time complexity to _O_ (log( _t_ )), significantly enhancing training and inference efficiency. To encode the corpus, we leverage Qwen 3 to build the embedding table (Zhang et al., 2025). The output state _ot_ is used to compute similarity scores for all corpus entries, and the top- _k_ items are retrieved and stored as _Ct_ for the generation stage. - -**Generator.** In the generation stage, our primary objective is to produce refined recommendations _I_[ˆ] _t_ by integrating the conversation context _{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[and the retrieved items] _[ C][t]_[.][To] achieve this, we employ a black-box LLM _f_ llm and construct an input prompt that combines clear instructions, detailed item metadata, and the conversation history. The LLM is instructed to generate _k_ recommendations based on this comprehensive context. Further details of our prompt design are provided in Section A. For each conversation, we divide it into sub-conversations by splitting at turns where the role _rt_ is designated as _recommender_ . We also exclude ground truth items that have already appeared in earlier conversation turns to avoid shortcut learning (He et al., 2023; Geirhos et al., 2020). During inference, we retrieve relevant items from the corpus to construct the prompt. The generator _f_ llm then produces recommendations, which are post-processed to yield the final ranked list _I_[ˆ] _t_ . Unlike prior works (He et al., 2023; Kemper et al., 2024), we pair a simple retriever with a black-box LLM to inject external, up-to-date knowledge into the generation stage, enabling the LLM to access novel items for fine-grained, context-aware recommendations. - -**Retriever Preference Optimization.** While RAR provides a retrieval augmented generation framework for conversational recommendation, these two stages are not jointly trained for optimal alignment. Yet overlooking the dynamics between both stages can result in a sub-optimal solution (Ma et al., 2020; Higley et al., 2022; Lin et al., 2024). We thus propose an online, on-policy preference optimization method that leverages real-time feedback from the LLM generator _f_ llm. This allows RAR to iteratively sample candidate sets from the retriever and utilize LLM feedback to optimize current policy (see Figure 2). In our setup, we consider a frozen generator _f_ llm and focus on post-training the retriever (parametrized by _θ_ ). This approach enables efficient optimization of the smaller _f_ ret to achieve improved retrieval. Specifically for candidate set _Ct_ = _{ci}i[k]_ =1[sampled from] _[ π][θ]_[, we define the likelihood of] _[ C][t]_ given history items _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[using the Plackett-Luce model (][Plackett][,][ 1975][):] - -**==> picture [306 x 28] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _σ_ is the permutation that ranks items by descending retriever score, and _sσ_ ( _i_ ) denotes the score assigned by _f_ ret to the _i_ -th ranked item. This formulation treats the candidate set as a sequential selection process without replacement: at each step, an item is drawn from the remaining pool with probability proportional to its retriever score. For each turn, we sample multiple candidate sets and use _f_ llm to rank and compute rewards. We then apply policy gradients on the resulting advantages and log-likelihood to optimize the retriever, effectively enhancing the synergy between the retrieval and ranking stages. - -5 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**Pairwise and Multi-Sample Reinforcement Learning** . For pairwise RL, we adopt an online, on-policy DPO approach to maximize the probability of retrieving a favored candidate set _Cw_ over a disfavored set _Cl_ . Because _f_ llm acts as a black-box generator, we compute the final reward as the NDCG ranking score by identifying the rank of the ground truth items directly from the LLM’s output. At each timestep, we sample two candidate sets of size _k_ from policy _πθ_ ; the set that yields the higher NDCG score is designated _Cw_ . In other words, the candidate set where the label item achieves a higher rank is considered preferable. Given history _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[and candidate sets, we minimize the preference loss] _[ L]_[dpo][:] - -**==> picture [342 x 30] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _β_ controls the strength of preference learning, while the reference model _π_ ref constrains the policy updates. This objective is designed to increase the relative probability of sampling _Cw_ over _Cl_ while preventing excessive policy divergence. In addition to online DPO, we further introduce a multi-sample RL approach based on GRPO (Shao et al., 2024). GRPO samples a group of _g_ candidate sets and computes the advantages by standardizing the rewards within the group (i.e., _A_[ˆ] _i_ = _[r][i][−]_ std[mean] ([ _r_[([] 1, _[r] r_[1] 2[,] ,..., _[r]_[2][,...,] _rg_ ]) _[r][g]_[])] ): - -**==> picture [390 x 31] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _β_ controls the regularization strength. The resulting algorithm, detailed in Section A.2, is lightweight, on-policy and can be seamlessly combined with further optimizations. - -**Training Objective** . To stabilize reinforcement preference learning and maintain the retriever’s standalone quality, we incorporate a supervised negative log-likelihood term, _L_ nll. Consequently, the full preference optimization objective is: - -**==> picture [232 x 10] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _L_ rl represents either the DPO or GRPO loss. While DPO trains the policy to favor preferred candidate sets by maximizing their relative selection probability, GRPO refines policy gradients by calculating advantages across groups of samples to amplify the likelihood of high-rewarding sets. By integrating RL loss with the negative log-likelihood term, RAR bridges the retrieval and generation stages, continually refining _f_ ret to ensure the delivery of diverse, high-quality candidate sets for conversational recommendation. - -## **4 Experiments** - -## **4.1 Experiment Settings** - -Our model is evaluated on three widely-used datasets for conversational recommendation: Inspired, Redial and Reddit (Hayati et al., 2020; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). We adopt multiple baselines for comparison, including both _traditional_ and _LLM-based_ methods. In particular, we adopt _traditional CRS_ : KBRD, KGSF and UniCRS (Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2022b); _sequential methods_ : SASRec, FMLPRec and LRURec (Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a); _retrieval augmented CRS with supervised fine-tuning_ (SFT) methods include Qwen3-8B (Qwen), GPT-5 mini (GPT) and Gemini 3 Flash (Gem) (Yang et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2025), where we perform SFT on the retriever model. Similarly, we experiment RAR with Qwen, GPT and Gemini as LLM generator. For our retriever model, we compare GRU4Rec, SASRec, FMLPRec and LRURec (Hidasi, 2015; Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a). For all methods and datasets, the maximum history length was set to 64 (i.e. history items), and the retrieval size was set to _k_ = 25 in our main experiments. The evaluation metrics are NDCG and Recall at 5 and 10. For all evaluated methods, we saved the model with the best validation NDCG@10 score. Further training and evaluation details are reported in Section A.2. - -6 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|KBRD
KGSF
UniCRS|.0466
.0815
.0472
.0732
.0656
.0815
.0673
.0869
.0676
.0927
.0750
.1032|.0388
.0582
.0453
.078
.0434
.0672
.0497
.0864
.0425
.0646
.0504
.0887|.0066
.0079
.0078
.0098
.0155
.0172
.0155
.0172
.0258
.0376
.0363
.0479| -|SASRec
FMLPRec
LRURec|.0564
.0870
.0655
.1304
.0620
.0815
.0726
.1141
.0671
.0978
.0793
.1359|.0558
.0795
.0681
.1176
.0504
.0784
.0639
.1123
.0539
.0771
.0650
.1111|.0288
.0401
.0339
.0545
.0315
.0434
.0342
.0534
.0316
.0430
.0346
.0522| -|SFTQwen
SFTGem
SFTGPT|.0609
.0938
.0626
.0990
.0859
.1076
.1034
.1544
.0997
.1214
.1091
.1491|.0454
.0684
.0526
.0907
.0574
.0828
.0662
.1097
.0599
.0887
.0700
.1197|.0344
.0484
.0394
.0633
.0455
.0604
.0497
.0708
.0489
.0651
.0558
.0843| -|RARQwen
RARGem
RARGPT|.0693
.0980
.0773
.1241
.0916
.1145
.1046
.1587
**.1091**
**.1422**
**.1180**
**.1700**|.0491
.0704
.0569
.0947
.0632
.0894
**.0721**
.1169
**.0620**
**.0932**
.0718
**.1236**|.0368
.0536
.0444
.0770
.0502
.0661
.0531
.0799
**_.0551_**
**_.0716_**
**_.0593_**
**_.0846_**| - - - -Table 1: Main results of the online DPO-based RAR and baseline methods on conversational recommendation. For clarity, the best results for each dataset and metric are highlighted in **bold** , while the second-best results are underlined. - -|Retriever
N@10
R@10
N@20
R@20
GRU4Rec
.1250
.2015
.1351
.2558
BERT4Rec
.1469
.2337
.1598
.2889
SASRec
.1430
.2363
.1637
.3086
FMLPRec
.1460
.2411
.1689
.3125
LRURec
**.1483**
**.2508**
**.1700**
**.3365**|Dataset
Method
N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|---|---| -||Inspired
DPO
.0693
.0980
.0773
**.1241**
GRPO
**.0753**
**.0997**
**.0807**
.1162| -||Redial
DPO
.0491
.0704
.0569
.0947
GRPO
**.0493**
**.0706**
**.0575**
**.0954**| -||Reddit
DPO
.0368
.0536
.0444
**.0770**
GRPO
**.0385**
**.0547**
**.0450**
.0765| - - - -Table 2: Different retriever model performance pretrained on MovieLens. - -Table 3: DPO & GRPO Comparison on Qwen. - -## **4.2 Experiment Results and Analysis** - -**RQ1. How does RAR perform in conversational recommendation?** We first discuss the evaluation results for conversational recommendation datasets, as reported in Table 1. Based on the presented results, we have several key observations: (1) Overall Performance: Across all datasets and metrics, RAR demonstrates a clear and consistent superiority over traditional, sequential, and SFT baselines, highlighting its robust capability to retrieve and generate high-quality recommendations. In particular, RAR achieves an average improvement of 7.60% over the best baseline results. (2) Impact of Base LLMs: Among the evaluated models enhanced by RAR, GPT delivers the highest overall performance across the datasets, closely followed by Gemini, and then Qwen. This indicates the importance of the LLMs’ inherent capabilities, where GPT and Gemini stand as the state-of-the-art closed-source models, while Qwen presents a powerful open-source alternative for conversational recommendation. (3) Comparison to Traditional and SFT Baselines: Overall, baseline comparisons reveal that while SFT-based retrieval augmentation outperforms traditional methods, RAR further surpasses standard fine-tuning. It achieves average gains of 11.9%, 7.5% and 7.7% for Qwen, Gemini and GPT backbones over their SFT-only counterparts, respectively, demonstrating the efficacy of our RL-based post-training. (4) Trends Across Metrics: Although methods exhibit some variability across metrics, the trends are consistent: performance gains of RAR against the best baselines are particularly pronounced on top- _k_ metrics such as N@5 and R@5. For example, the ranking performance improvement for @5 metrics averages 9.33% compared to 5.86% for @10 metrics, suggesting that our preference optimization strategy is especially effective at pushing the most relevant items to the top of the list. Overall, our findings show that RAR effectively integrates retrieval augmentation and RL-based preference optimization to enhance recommendation performance. - -**RQ2. Which retriever model works best?** To analyze the retriever choice in RAR, we evaluate the performance of several different retriever models on the MovieLens dataset. In particular, we pretrain each retriever model and evaluate their retrieval performance - -7 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Average Performance**
N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10
.0499
.0699
.0575
.0946
.0635
.0825
.0718
.1136
.0727
.1011
.0792
.1203
**.0517**
**.0740**
**.0595**
**.0986**
**.0683**
**.0900**
**.0766**
**.1185**
**.0754**
**.1023**
**.0830**
**.1260**
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
Scores||ND
~~Re~~|CG
~~call~~|||||||| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -||||||||||||| -|SimPOQwen
SimPOGem
SimPOGPT|||||||||||| -||||||||||||| -||||||||||||| -|DPOQwen
DPOGem
DPOGPT|||||||||||| -||||||||||||| - - - -Table 4: Performance of SimPO and RAR’s online DPO averaged across datasets. - -Figure 3: Performance changes in RAR with different number of retrieved items. - -on our collected corpus, with results presented in Table 2. Overall, LRURec achieves the highest scores across all reported metrics, recording an N@20 of 0.1700 and an R@20 of 0.3365, thereby outperforming all other retriever models. A similar trend is observed for the @10 metrics, where LRURec scores an N@10 of 0.1483 and an R@10 of 0.2508, establishing a consistent margin over other models. Among the baseline methods, FMLPRec serves as the strongest competitor, achieving the second-best results across most metrics (such as an R@20 of 0.3125 and an R@10 of 0.2411), followed closely by SASRec and BERT4Rec. Considering the efficiency advantages of LRURec in both training and inference, the findings indicate that LRURec is more effective at retrieving candidate items based on user history, leading to higher-quality retrieval outcomes for the following generation stage in RAR. - -**RQ3. How do different RL algorithms compare?** We further analyze the core components of our online preference optimization by comparing two variants of our proposed method: the pairwise online DPO and the multi-sample GRPO (8 samples per example) using the Qwen backbone (Shao et al., 2024). The results are summarized in Table 3. As expected, we observe that our GRPO variant generally outperforms the pairwise DPO across most evaluation metrics and datasets. Specifically, the GRPO variant yields notable improvements on the N@5 metric, achieving 0.0385 compared to DPO’s 0.0368 on Reddit. We attribute GRPO’s superior performance to its multi-trajectory sampling, which yields robust relative advantage estimates for top- _k_ ranking. Due to GRPO’s high inference costs and slower training, we adopt DPO as the default for RAR, which notably maintains 98.6% of GRPO’s average performance at a fraction of the computational cost. For DPO variants, we also adopt different formulations of Equation (4) for comparison and present the average results across datasets in Table 4. Here, we report SimPO (see details in Section A) as an alternative (Meng et al., 2025). Overall, RAR with DPO demonstrates consistently superior results compared to SimPO across all evaluated LLM backbones. For instance, RAR with Qwen achieves N@5 and R@5 scores of 0.0517 and 0.0740 respectively, outperforming SimPO on these crucial top- _k_ metrics. This dominating trend holds strictly true for both the Gemini and GPT backbones, where DPO consistently yields the higher performance across metrics. These findings validate that our proposed DPO-based preference optimization is highly effective at capturing nuanced user preferences, highlighting its potential for delivering higher-quality retrieval results in two-stage conversational recommendation. - -**RQ4. How do key hyperparameters impact the performance of RAR?** Here, we investigate the impact of two critical hyperparameters on the performance of RAR: the number of retrieved items and the _β_ value. First, we evaluate the performance changes when varying the number of retrieved candidate items, as illustrated in Figure 3. The analysis reveals a clear, positive trend: as the number of retrieved items increases, both NDCG and Recall steadily improve. Recall naturally benefits from the expanded candidate pool, which increases the likelihood of capturing relevant items. More importantly, the ranking-sensitive metric, NDCG, also maintains an upward trajectory up to 45 items. This demonstrates the LLM generator’s robust capacity to effectively filter and rank candidates without being immediately overwhelmed by noise. Furthermore, we examine the influence of the _β_ parameter, as summarized in Table 5. Comparing various settings against the standard SFT baseline ( _β_ = 0), we observe that introducing a small _β_ value significantly enhances recommendation accuracy. Specifically, setting _β_ = 0.05 achieves peak performance across all evaluated - -8 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|_β_|**Average Performance**| -|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|0 (SFT)
0.05
0.1
0.2|.0469
.0702
.0515
.0843
**.0513**
**.0741**
**.0580**
**.0953**
.0482
.0692
.0547
.0893
.0485
.0711
.0544
.0888| - - - -Table 5: Recommendation performance of RAR with Qwen using different _β_ values. - -**==> picture [176 x 97] intentionally omitted <==** - -Figure 4: N@10 on different item groups. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|Qwenon
Qwenoff|**.0730**
**.0997**
.0764
.1210
.0693
.0980
**.0773**
**.1241**|.0438
.0626
.0501
.0826
**.0491**
**.0704**
**.0569**
**.0947**|.0367
.0525
.0402
.0629
**.0368**
**.0536**
**.0444**
**.0770**| -|GPTon
GPToff|.1006
.1327
.1115
.1648
**.1091**
**.1422**
**.1180**
**.1700**|**0.646**
**.0975**
**.0748**
**.1285**
.0620
.0932
.0718
.1236|**.0575**
**.0748**
**.0615**
**.0872**
.0536
.0711
.0585
.0859| - - - -Table 6: Recommendation performance of LLMs with thinking enabled and disabled. - -metrics, improving N@10 from 0.0515 to 0.0580 and R@10 from 0.0843 to 0.0953. Increasing _β_ further leads to a slight decline in performance; therefore, our experiments indicate that the optimal range for _β_ lies within [0.05, 0.1]. Overall, these observations suggest that RAR exhibits strong robustness across different hyperparameter choices, maintaining stable, high-quality recommendations without requiring exhaustive, fine-grained tuning. - -**RQ5. Does explicit reasoning improve LLM performance in CRS?** To investigate whether extended reasoning inherently improve recommendation quality, we evaluated Qwen and GPT models with their explicit "thinking" capabilities enabled (on) and disabled (off). As detailed in Table 6, the impact of reasoning is not universally beneficial and varies significantly across scenarios. For the Qwen model, omitting the explicit reasoning phase consistently delivered competitive or superior performance across most datasets while significantly reducing inference costs. Conversely, GPT’s behavior was highly datasetdependent: _GPT_ off achieved the highest metrics on the Inspired dataset, whereas _GPT_ on performed strictly better on both Redial and Reddit. Ultimately, these findings indicate that forcing additional reasoning does not guarantee better recommendations; rather, its utility is dependent on both the underlying model and the specific data distribution. - -**RQ6. Does RAR improve popularity bias and hallucination?** Finally, we analyze RAR (with the Qwen _f_ llm) on two known LLM-based CRS challenges: popularity bias and item hallucination (He et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024). By categorizing items unseen in training into an unpopular group (Figure 4), we confirm popularity bias exists; overall NDCG@10 scores substantially exceed those of unpopular items (e.g., Reddit scores just 0.0013). Nevertheless, RAR generally outperforms the LLM-only Qwen baseline. Leveraging a retriever with rich semantic embeddings and online RL-based post-training yields a nearly 4x improvement on unpopular items over Qwen. Additionally, we observe a dramatic reduction in hallucination rates, with under 1% unmatched titles across all datasets. Ultimately, while not completely immune to popularity bias, RAR’s retrieval augmentation design effectively mitigates hallucination, marking a critical step toward more reliable and trustworthy CRS. - -## **5 Conclusion** - -In this work, we introduce RAR, a two-stage framework for retrieval augmented conversational recommendation. For this purpose, we collect a unified text corpus of over 300k films within the movie domain to support our recommendation tasks. RAR employs a lightweight retriever to efficiently identify potential candidate items based on user interaction history. In addition, a black-box LLM is utilized to refine these candidates by integrating - -9 - -Preprint. Under review. - -contextual data and retrieved information, thereby capturing subtle user preferences in natural language. To further align retrieval with generation, our online, on-policy preference optimization leverages LLM feedback to iteratively enhance the retriever’s performance. Extensive experiments on benchmark datasets validate our approach, demonstrating that by effectively aligning the retriever and generator through online preference optimization, RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in conversational recommendation. - -## **References** - -- Josh Achiam, Steven Adler, Sandhini Agarwal, Lama Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, Diogo Almeida, Janko Altenschmidt, Sam Altman, Shyamal Anadkat, et al. GPT-4 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.08774_ , 2023. - -- Sebastian Borgeaud, Arthur Mensch, Jordan Hoffmann, Trevor Cai, Eliza Rutherford, Katie Millican, George Bm Van Den Driessche, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Bogdan Damoc, Aidan Clark, et al. Improving language models by retrieving from trillions of tokens. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 2206–2240. PMLR, 2022. - -- BrightData. Imdb media. https://huggingface.co/datasets/BrightData/IMDb-Media. Accessed: December 2024. - -- Jianlyu Chen, Shitao Xiao, Peitian Zhang, Kun Luo, Defu Lian, and Zheng Liu. M3embedding: Multi-linguality, multi-functionality, multi-granularity text embeddings through self-knowledge distillation. In Lun-Wei Ku, Andre Martins, and Vivek Srikumar (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL 2024_ , pp. 2318–2335, Bangkok, Thailand, August 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10. 18653/v1/2024.findings-acl.137. URL https://aclanthology.org/2024.findings-acl. 137/. - -- Qibin Chen, Junyang Lin, Yichang Zhang, Ming Ding, Yukuo Cen, Hongxia Yang, and Jie Tang. Towards knowledge-based recommender dialog system. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 1803–1813, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1189. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1189/. - -- Gheorghe Comanici, Eric Bieber, Mike Schaekermann, Ice Pasupat, Noveen Sachdeva, Inderjit Dhillon, Marcel Blistein, Ori Ram, Dan Zhang, Evan Rosen, et al. Gemini 2.5: Pushing the frontier with advanced reasoning, multimodality, long context, and next generation agentic capabilities. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2507.06261_ , 2025. - -- Abhimanyu Dubey, Abhinav Jauhri, Abhinav Pandey, Abhishek Kadian, Ahmad Al-Dahle, Aiesha Letman, Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela Fan, et al. The llama 3 herd of models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.21783_ , 2024. - -- Yue Feng, Shuchang Liu, Zhenghai Xue, Qingpeng Cai, Lantao Hu, Peng Jiang, Kun Gai, and Fei Sun. A large language model enhanced conversational recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.06212_ , 2023. - -- Yunfan Gao, Tao Sheng, Youlin Xiang, Yun Xiong, Haofen Wang, and Jiawei Zhang. Chat-rec: Towards interactive and explainable llms-augmented recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.14524_ , 2023. - -- Robert Geirhos, Jörn-Henrik Jacobsen, Claudio Michaelis, Richard Zemel, Wieland Brendel, Matthias Bethge, and Felix A Wichmann. Shortcut learning in deep neural networks. _Nature Machine Intelligence_ , 2(11):665–673, 2020. - -- Kelvin Guu, Kenton Lee, Zora Tung, Panupong Pasupat, and Mingwei Chang. Retrieval augmented language model pre-training. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 3929–3938. PMLR, 2020. - -10 - -Preprint. Under review. - -F Maxwell Harper and Joseph A Konstan. The movielens datasets: History and context. _Acm transactions on interactive intelligent systems (tiis)_ , 5(4):1–19, 2015. - -- Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Dongyeop Kang, Qingxiaoyang Zhu, Weiyan Shi, and Zhou Yu. Inspired: Toward sociable recommendation dialog systems. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2009.14306_ , 2020. - -- Zhankui He, Zhouhang Xie, Rahul Jha, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Yesu Feng, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. Large language models as zero-shot conversational recommenders. In _Proceedings of the 32nd ACM international conference on information and knowledge management_ , pp. 720–730, 2023. - -- Zhankui He, Zhouhang Xie, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Rahul Jha, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. Reindex-then-adapt: Improving large language models for conversational recommendation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.12119_ , 2024. - -- B Hidasi. Session-based recommendations with recurrent neural networks. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1511.06939_ , 2015. - -- Karl Higley, Even Oldridge, Ronay Ak, Sara Rabhi, and Gabriel de Souza Pereira Moreira. Building and deploying a multi-stage recommender system with merlin. In _Proceedings of the 16th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems_ , pp. 632–635, 2022. - -- Jian Hu. Reinforce++: A simple and efficient approach for aligning large language models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.03262_ , 2025. - -- Jonas Hübotter, Frederike Lübeck, Lejs Behric, Anton Baumann, Marco Bagatella, Daniel Marta, Ido Hakimi, Idan Shenfeld, Thomas Kleine Buening, Carlos Guestrin, et al. Reinforcement learning via self-distillation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.20802_ , 2026. - -- Zheng Hui, Xiaokai Wei, Yexi Jiang, Kevin Gao, Chen Wang, Se-eun Yoon, Rachit Pareek, and Michelle Gong. Toward safe and human-aligned game conversational recommendation via multi-agent decomposition. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EACL 2026_ , pp. 4568–4584, 2026. - -- Aaron Hurst, Adam Lerer, Adam P Goucher, Adam Perelman, Aditya Ramesh, Aidan Clark, AJ Ostrow, Akila Welihinda, Alan Hayes, Alec Radford, et al. Gpt-4o system card. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.21276_ , 2024. - -- Gautier Izacard and Édouard Grave. Leveraging passage retrieval with generative models for open domain question answering. In _Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Main Volume_ , pp. 874–880, 2021. - -- Gautier Izacard, Patrick Lewis, Maria Lomeli, Lucas Hosseini, Fabio Petroni, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Armand Joulin, Sebastian Riedel, and Edouard Grave. Atlas: Few-shot learning with retrieval augmented language models. _Journal of Machine Learning Research_ , 24(251):1–43, 2023. - -- Dietmar Jannach, Ahtsham Manzoor, Wanling Cai, and Li Chen. A survey on conversational recommender systems. _ACM Computing Surveys (CSUR)_ , 54(5):1–36, 2021. - -- Hyunsik Jeon, Satoshi Koide, Yu Wang, Zhankui He, and Julian McAuley. Adapting large vision-language models to visually-aware conversational recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 31st ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining V. 2_ , pp. 1037–1048, 2025. - -- Zhengbao Jiang, Frank F Xu, Luyu Gao, Zhiqing Sun, Qian Liu, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Yiming Yang, Jamie Callan, and Graham Neubig. Active retrieval augmented generation. In _Proceedings of the 2023 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing_ , pp. 7969–7992, 2023. - -- Bowen Jin, Hansi Zeng, Zhenrui Yue, Jinsung Yoon, Sercan Arik, Dong Wang, Hamed Zamani, and Jiawei Han. Search-r1: Training llms to reason and leverage search engines with reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.09516_ , 2025. - -11 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Dongyeop Kang, Anusha Balakrishnan, Pararth Shah, Paul Crook, Y-Lan Boureau, and Jason Weston. Recommendation as a communication game: Self-supervised bot-play for goal-oriented dialogue. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 1951– 1961, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1203. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1203/. - -- Wang-Cheng Kang and Julian McAuley. Self-attentive sequential recommendation. In _2018 IEEE international conference on data mining (ICDM)_ , pp. 197–206. IEEE, 2018. - -- Vladimir Karpukhin, Barlas Oguz, Sewon Min, Patrick Lewis, Ledell Wu, Sergey Edunov, Danqi Chen, and Wen-tau Yih. Dense passage retrieval for open-domain question answering. In _Proceedings of the 2020 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP)_ , pp. 6769–6781, 2020. - -- Sara Kemper, Justin Cui, Kai Dicarlantonio, Kathy Lin, Danjie Tang, Anton Korikov, and Scott Sanner. Retrieval-augmented conversational recommendation with prompt-based semi-structured natural language state tracking. In _Proceedings of the 47th International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval_ , pp. 2786–2790, 2024. - -- Wenqiang Lei, Xiangnan He, Yisong Miao, Qingyun Wu, Richang Hong, Min-Yen Kan, and Tat-Seng Chua. Estimation-action-reflection: Towards deep interaction between conversational and recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 304–312, 2020. - -- Patrick Lewis, Ethan Perez, Aleksandra Piktus, Fabio Petroni, Vladimir Karpukhin, Naman Goyal, Heinrich Küttler, Mike Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Tim Rocktäschel, et al. Retrievalaugmented generation for knowledge-intensive NLP tasks. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 33:9459–9474, 2020. - -- Chuang Li, Yang Deng, Hengchang Hu, Min-Yen Kan, and Haizhou Li. Incorporating external knowledge and goal guidance for llm-based conversational recommender systems. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.01868_ , 2024. - -- Raymond Li, Samira Ebrahimi Kahou, Hannes Schulz, Vincent Michalski, Laurent Charlin, and Chris Pal. Towards deep conversational recommendations. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 31, 2018. - -- Xi Victoria Lin, Xilun Chen, Mingda Chen, Weijia Shi, Maria Lomeli, Richard James, Pedro Rodriguez, Jacob Kahn, Gergely Szilvasy, Mike Lewis, et al. RA-DIT: Retrieval-augmented dual instruction tuning. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- Yu Lu, Junwei Bao, Yan Song, Zichen Ma, Shuguang Cui, Youzheng Wu, and Xiaodong He. RevCore: Review-augmented conversational recommendation. In Chengqing Zong, Fei Xia, Wenjie Li, and Roberto Navigli (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL-IJCNLP 2021_ , pp. 1161–1173, Online, August 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.findings-acl.99. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.findings-acl.99/. - -- Jiaqi Ma, Zhe Zhao, Xinyang Yi, Ji Yang, Minmin Chen, Jiaxi Tang, Lichan Hong, and Ed H Chi. Off-policy learning in two-stage recommender systems. In _Proceedings of The Web Conference 2020_ , pp. 463–473, 2020. - -- Yu Meng, Mengzhou Xia, and Danqi Chen. Simpo: Simple preference optimization with a reference-free reward. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 37:124198–124235, 2024. - -- Yu Meng, Mengzhou Xia, and Danqi Chen. Simpo: Simple preference optimization with a reference-free reward. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 37:124198–124235, 2025. - -12 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Volodymyr Mnih, Adria Puigdomenech Badia, Mehdi Mirza, Alex Graves, Timothy Lillicrap, Tim Harley, David Silver, and Koray Kavukcuoglu. Asynchronous methods for deep reinforcement learning. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 1928–1937. PmLR, 2016. - -- Long Ouyang, Jeffrey Wu, Xu Jiang, Diogo Almeida, Carroll Wainwright, Pamela Mishkin, Chong Zhang, Sandhini Agarwal, Katarina Slama, Alex Ray, et al. Training language models to follow instructions with human feedback. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 35:27730–27744, 2022. - -- Boci Peng, Yun Zhu, Yongchao Liu, Xiaohe Bo, Haizhou Shi, Chuntao Hong, Yan Zhang, and Siliang Tang. Graph retrieval-augmented generation: A survey. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.08921_ , 2024. - -- Robin L Plackett. The analysis of permutations. _Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics_ , 24(2):193–202, 1975. - -- Rafael Rafailov, Archit Sharma, Eric Mitchell, Christopher D Manning, Stefano Ermon, and Chelsea Finn. Direct preference optimization: Your language model is secretly a reward model. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 36:53728–53741, 2023. - -- Chidambara Raju. Imdb movies dataset based on genre. https://www.kaggle.com/ datasets/rajugc/imdb-movies-dataset-based-on-genre. Accessed: December 2024. - -- Machel Reid, Nikolay Savinov, Denis Teplyashin, Dmitry Lepikhin, Timothy Lillicrap, Jeanbaptiste Alayrac, Radu Soricut, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, Julian Schrittwieser, et al. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal understanding across millions of tokens of context. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2403.05530_ , 2024. - -- Nils Reimers and Iryna Gurevych. Sentence-BERT: Sentence embeddings using Siamese BERT-networks. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 3982– 3992, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1410. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1410/. - -- Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D Manning. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive processing for tree-organized retrieval. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- John Schulman, Filip Wolski, Prafulla Dhariwal, Alec Radford, and Oleg Klimov. Proximal policy optimization algorithms. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1707.06347_ , 2017. - -- Zhihong Shao, Peiyi Wang, Qihao Zhu, Runxin Xu, Junxiao Song, Xiao Bi, Haowei Zhang, Mingchuan Zhang, YK Li, Y Wu, et al. Deepseekmath: Pushing the limits of mathematical reasoning in open language models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.03300_ , 2024. - -- Weijia Shi, Sewon Min, Michihiro Yasunaga, Minjoon Seo, Richard James, Mike Lewis, Luke Zettlemoyer, and Wen-tau Yih. REPLUG: Retrieval-augmented black-box language models. In _Proceedings of the 2024 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pp. 8364–8377, 2024. - -- Aaditya Singh, Adam Fry, Adam Perelman, Adam Tart, Adi Ganesh, Ahmed El-Kishky, Aidan McLaughlin, Aiden Low, AJ Ostrow, Akhila Ananthram, et al. Openai gpt-5 system card. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.03267_ , 2025. - -- Rohan Surana, Junda Wu, Zhouhang Xie, Yu Xia, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. From reviews to dialogues: Active synthesis for zero-shot llm-based conversational recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.15476_ , 2025. - -- Richard S Sutton, Andrew G Barto, et al. _Reinforcement learning: An introduction_ , volume 1. MIT press Cambridge, 1998. - -13 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Richard S Sutton, David McAllester, Satinder Singh, and Yishay Mansour. Policy gradient methods for reinforcement learning with function approximation. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 12, 1999. - -- Harsh Trivedi, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Tushar Khot, and Ashish Sabharwal. Interleaving retrieval with chain-of-thought reasoning for knowledge-intensive multi-step questions. In _Proceedings of the 61st Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pp. 10014–10037, 2023. - -- Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Binxing Jiao, Linjun Yang, Daxin Jiang, Rangan Majumder, and Furu Wei. Text embeddings by weakly-supervised contrastive pre-training. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2212.03533_ , 2022a. - -- Xiaolei Wang, Kun Zhou, Ji-Rong Wen, and Wayne Xin Zhao. Towards unified conversational recommender systems via knowledge-enhanced prompt learning. In _Proceedings of the 28th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining_ , pp. 1929–1937, 2022b. - -- Yueqi Wang, Zhenrui Yue, Huimin Zeng, Dong Wang, and Julian McAuley. Train once, deploy anywhere: Matryoshka representation learning for multimodal recommendation. In Yaser Al-Onaizan, Mohit Bansal, and Yun-Nung Chen (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2024_ , pp. 13461–13472, Miami, Florida, USA, November 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp. 786. URL https://aclanthology.org/2024.findings-emnlp.786/. - -- Junda Wu, Cheng-Chun Chang, Tong Yu, Zhankui He, Jianing Wang, Yupeng Hou, and Julian McAuley. Coral: Collaborative retrieval-augmented large language models improve long-tail recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 30th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining_ , pp. 3391–3401, 2024. - -- Shusheng Xu, Wei Fu, Jiaxuan Gao, Wenjie Ye, Weilin Liu, Zhiyu Mei, Guangju Wang, Chao Yu, and Yi Wu. Is dpo superior to ppo for llm alignment? a comprehensive study. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2404.10719_ , 2024. - -- Shi-Qi Yan, Jia-Chen Gu, Yun Zhu, and Zhen-Hua Ling. Corrective retrieval augmented generation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2401.15884_ , 2024. - -- An Yang, Baosong Yang, Beichen Zhang, Binyuan Hui, Bo Zheng, Bowen Yu, Chengyuan Li, Dayiheng Liu, Fei Huang, Haoran Wei, et al. Qwen2. 5 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.15115_ , 2024. - -- An Yang, Anfeng Li, Baosong Yang, Beichen Zhang, Binyuan Hui, Bo Zheng, Bowen Yu, Chang Gao, Chengen Huang, Chenxu Lv, et al. Qwen3 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.09388_ , 2025. - -- Ting Yang and Li Chen. Unleashing the retrieval potential of large language models in conversational recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the 18th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems_ , pp. 43–52, 2024. - -- Ori Yoran, Tomer Wolfson, Ori Ram, and Jonathan Berant. Making retrieval-augmented language models robust to irrelevant context. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- Qiying Yu, Zheng Zhang, Ruofei Zhu, Yufeng Yuan, Xiaochen Zuo, Yu Yue, Weinan Dai, Tiantian Fan, Gaohong Liu, Lingjun Liu, et al. Dapo: An open-source llm reinforcement learning system at scale. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.14476_ , 2025. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Yueqi Wang, Zhankui He, Huimin Zeng, Julian McAuley, and Dong Wang. Linear recurrent units for sequential recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 17th ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 930–938, 2024a. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Honglei Zhuang, Aijun Bai, Kai Hui, Rolf Jagerman, Hansi Zeng, Zhen Qin, Dong Wang, Xuanhui Wang, and Michael Bendersky. Inference scaling for long-context retrieval augmented generation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.04343_ , 2024b. - -14 - -Preprint. Under review. - -Zhenrui Yue, Bowen Jin, Huimin Zeng, Honglei Zhuang, Zhen Qin, Jinsung Yoon, Lanyu Shang, Jiawei Han, and Dong Wang. Hybrid latent reasoning via reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.18454_ , 2025. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Kartikeya Upasani, Xianjun Yang, Suyu Ge, Shaoliang Nie, Yuning Mao, Zhe Liu, and Dong Wang. Dr. zero: Self-evolving search agents without training data. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.07055_ , 2026. - -- Gholamreza Zare and P Malekpour Alamdari. Conversational graph-llm reasoning for interactive preference modeling and explainable recommendation, 2025. - -- Xiaoyu Zhang, Xin Xin, Dongdong Li, Wenxuan Liu, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Jun Ma, and Zhaochun Ren. Variational reasoning over incomplete knowledge graphs for conversational recommendation. In _Proceedings of the Sixteenth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 231–239, 2023. - -- Yanzhao Zhang, Mingxin Li, Dingkun Long, Xin Zhang, Huan Lin, Baosong Yang, Pengjun Xie, An Yang, Dayiheng Liu, Junyang Lin, et al. Qwen3 embedding: Advancing text embedding and reranking through foundation models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.05176_ , 2025. - -- Yongfeng Zhang, Xu Chen, Qingyao Ai, Liu Yang, and W Bruce Croft. Towards conversational search and recommendation: System ask, user respond. In _Proceedings of the 27th acm international conference on information and knowledge management_ , pp. 177–186, 2018. - -- Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Shuqing Bian, Yuanhang Zhou, Ji-Rong Wen, and Jingsong Yu. Improving conversational recommender systems via knowledge graph based semantic fusion. In _Proceedings of the 26th ACM SIGKDD international conference on knowledge discovery & data mining_ , pp. 1006–1014, 2020. - -- Kun Zhou, Hui Yu, Wayne Xin Zhao, and Ji-Rong Wen. Filter-enhanced mlp is all you need for sequential recommendation. In _Proceedings of the ACM web conference 2022_ , pp. 2388–2399, 2022. - -- Lixi Zhu, Xiaowen Huang, and Jitao Sang. A llm-based controllable, scalable, humaninvolved user simulator framework for conversational recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the ACM on Web Conference 2025_ , pp. 4653–4661, 2025. - -15 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|**Attribute**|**Value**| -|---|---| -||| -|ID
Title
Year
Genre
Director
Cast
Plot|tt0111161
The Shawshank Redemption
1994
Drama
Frank Darabont
Tim Robbins, Morgan Freeman ...
Chronicles the experiences of a ...| - - - -Table 7: An example movie with metadata in our corpus. - -## **A Appendix** - -## **A.1 Corpus Collection** - -We report the details on the collection and processing of our unified movie text corpus. The process began by gathering an initial set of movie titles and identifiers (e.g., IMDb/TMDB) from multiple open-source datasets, including IMDb genre, IMDb media, and Inspired (Hayati et al., 2020; Raju; BrightData). We then augmented this initial set with movies mentioned in widely-used recommendation benchmarks, namely MovieLens, Redial and Reddit (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). A primary motivation for building a consolidated, offline corpus was to overcome the limitations of existing APIs. While services like TMDB[2] provide extensive data, their APIs operate on a per-query basis with strict rate limits, making it infeasible to fetch metadata for all titles via individual HTTP requests. Furthermore, API responses are not directly linked to the specific movie mentions within our target conversational datasets. Our approach addresses these issues by creating a versioned, fully annotated dataset that can be indexed and processed in a single pass, thereby eliminating rate-limit bottlenecks and ensuring direct correspondence between metadata and conversational mentions. To construct this corpus, we first consolidated duplicated entries by verifying movie names and identifiers, resolving any conflicts by selecting the most informative metadata. For items with missing information, we carefully collected the missing values from TMDB or other online resources. We deliberately avoided direct scraping of copyrighted text fields from IMDb due to licensing restrictions[3] . Subsequently, we mapped the items in our corpus to their corresponding entries in the recommendation datasets (i.e., MovieLens, Inspired, Redial, and Reddit). This involved performing entity recognition and string matching to identify each movie mentioned in the conversational or sequential data and link it to its entry in our corpus. Any movies for which we could not find essential metadata (director, cast, genre, plot) were removed to maintain data quality. After processing, our final corpus contains 337,731 movie entries with comprehensive metadata, focusing primarily on English-language films (an example is shown in Table 7). The collection spans a wide temporal range, from films made as early as 1888 to upcoming releases in 2029, representing roughly half of all films listed on IMDb as of December 2024. By establishing explicit item correspondence to each of the benchmarks, the collected corpus serves as a robust and readily accessible knowledge base to train both the retriever and LLM components in RAR. - -## **A.2 Implementation & Additional Results** - -**Datasets.** Our model is evaluated on three widely-used benchmark datasets for conversational recommendation: Inspired, Redial and Reddit (Hayati et al., 2020; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). To ensure the retriever has a robust initial understanding of the movie domain, we pretrain it on the MovieLens-20M dataset (Harper & Konstan, 2015). For the pretraining, we segment the dataset into short user sessions, using a 30-minute inactivity threshold to generate meaningful interaction sequences. During preprocessing, we construct input - -> 2https://www.themoviedb.org/ - -> 3https://developer.imdb.com/ - -16 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Dataset|#Train|#Val|#Test| -|---|---|---|---| -|MovieLens|536,127|67,015|67,015| -|Inspired|1,507|206|183| -|Redial|24,095|2,647|3,445| -|Reddit|12,481|2,947|1,511| - - - -Table 8: Dataset Statistics. - -prompts with conversational context and incorporate additional retrieval augmentation from the collected corpus (see Section 3.2). For items retrieved during this process, we utilize a comprehensive set of attributes: _title_ , _year_ , _genre_ , _director_ , _cast_ and _plot_ . These attributes serve a critical dual purpose: they are first used to generate the initial item embeddings for training the retriever model, and subsequently, they function as structured context for the LLM generator. Detailed statistics for each dataset, including the number of training (#Train), validation (#Val) and test (#Test) examples, are reported in Table 8. - -**Baselines.** For baseline models, we adopt _text-based_ SASRec, FMLP-Rec and LRURec following the fMRLRec implementation (Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a; Wang et al., 2024). We also utilize _supervised fine-tuning_ (SFT) to learn the retriever model in combination with LLM as baselines. This approach aligns with the objective in sequential recommendation and maximizes the likelihood of ground truth items w.r.t. _θ_ . We report the details of baseline methods: - -- _Knowledge-Based Recommender Dialog (KBRD)_ integrates knowledge graph to understand conversational context and user preferences, enabling multi-turn reasoning over entities for recommendation (Chen et al., 2019). - -- _Knowledge Graph-based Semantic Fusion (KGSF)_ utilizes knowledge graph and a gated fusion mechanism to dynamically integrate semantic information from both conversation and item attributes (Zhou et al., 2020). - -- _Unified Conversational Recommender System (UniCRS)_ presents a unified framework to handle diverse conversational goals, including recommendation and chitchat with a prompt-based approach via a shared encoder-decoder model (Wang et al., 2022b). - -- _Self-Attentive Sequential Recommendation (SASRec)_ is the first transformer-based sequential recommender. SASRec uses unidirectional self-attention to capture transition patterns (Kang & McAuley, 2018). - -- _Filter-enhanced MLP for Recommendation (FMLP-Rec)_ also adopts an all-MLP architecture with filter-enhanced layers. FMLP-Rec applies fast Fourier transform to improve representation learning (Zhou et al., 2022). - -- _Linear Recurrence Units for Recommendation (LRURec)_ is based on linear recurrence and is optimized for paralleled training. LRURec thus provides both efficient training and inference speed (Yue et al., 2024a). - -All models are implemented and trained according to the methodologies described in the original works, with unspecified hyperparameters used as recommended. For item encoding, we use the Qwen-8B embedding model and encode items with their available metadata in the format of key-value pairs (Zhang et al., 2025). For each recommender / retriever, we initialize with two layers and search the dropout rates among [0.2, 0.4]. The retriever models are pretrained on MovieLens 20M using an 8:1:1 train / validation / test split, where the data is split into sessions with a maximum time gap of 30 minutes. In pretraining, we sample 100 negative examples at each time step and utilize in-batch negatives to compute the negative log likelihood loss. The models with best validation performance are saved and evaluated on the test sets. - -For SFT baselines and RAR, we adopt LRURec as the retriever and further optimize the retriever model with the proposed online, on-policy preference optimization. The adopted - -17 - -Preprint. Under review. - -## **Example Prompt** - -You are an expert in movie recommendations. Analyze the provided conversation history to identify the user’s preferences, such as genres and actors. Then, rank the candidate movies by how well they match these preferences. Return your answer as a numbered list with each movie on a new line in the format: ’. ’. Do not include any additional commentary, formatting or chattiness. Conversation history: - -Figure 5: Example prompt for RAR. The prompt comprises of instructions, retrieved candidates, followed by the conversation context. - -**Algorithm 1** Preference Optimization in RAR - -**Require:** Conversational dataset _X_ , pretrained retriever _f_ ret (policy _πθ_ ), frozen LLM generator _f_ llm, reward function _r_ ( _·_ , _·_ ), group size _g_ ( _g_ = 2 for DPO), hyperparameters _β_ , learning rate _η_ . **Ensure:** Optimized retriever parameters _θ_ . 1: Initialize policy _πθ_ with parameters from pretrained _f_ ret. 2: Initialize reference policy _π_ ref _← πθ_ . _▷_ Copy initial weights 3: **for** each training epoch **do** 4: **for** each conversation _C_ = ( _rt_ , _st_ , _It_ ) _t[T]_ =1[in] _[ X]_ **[do]** 5: **for** _t_ = 1, . . . , _T_ **do** 6: **if** _rt_ is _recommender_ **then** 7: Let history items be _I_ hist _←{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[.] 8: Let history sequence be _S_ hist _←{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[.] 9: Sample _{Ci}i[g]_ =1 _[∼][π][θ]_[(] _[·|I]_[hist][)][.] 10: Initialize rewards list _R ←_ []. 11: **for** _i_ = 1, . . . , _g_ **do** 12: Generate ranked list _I_[ˆ] _i ← f_ llm( _S_ hist, _Ci_ ). 13: Calculate reward _ri ← r_ ( _I_[ˆ] _i_ , _It_ ). _▷_ e.g., NDCG as reward 14: Append _ri_ to _R_ . 15: Compute _L_ rl with Equation (4) or Equation (5). 16: Compute NLL loss _L_ nll _←−_ log _πθ_ ( _It|I_ hist). 17: Compute final loss _L ←L_ nll + _L_ rl. 18: Update parameters _θ ← θ − η∇θL_ . 19: **return** Optimized parameters _θ_ . - -LLMs are Qwen (Qwen3-8B), GPT-5 mini (gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07) and Gemini 3 Flash (gemini-3-flash-preview) (Yang et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2025)[4] . For training sets that are greater than 2.5k, we subsample to 2.5k for efficiency. Similarly, we search dropout rates among [0.1, 0.2]. Our learning rate is searched from [5e-5, 1e-4] and we adopt cosine scheduling for learning rate with warm-up steps of 100. SFT baseline models are trained without _L_ dpo while in RAR, the _β_ values are searched within [0.05, 0.1, 0.2]. After sampling from the retriever, we annotate the candidate sets _C_ 1 and _C_ 2 using the LLM model. If any label item appears in both sets, we select the one with the higher label rank as _Cw_ . If a label item is present in only one candidate set, that set becomes _Cw_ . If neither set contains a label item, we resample until one of these conditions is met. Similar to baseline implementation, we keep models with best validation performance for evaluation. Our prompt is constructed as illustrated in Figure 5. The LLM generation configuration is set to - -> 4https://deepmind.google/technologies/gemini/flash - -18 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|SFTQwen
SFTGPT4o
SFTGem2|.0741
.0869
.0741
.0869
.0547
.0652
.0600
.0815
.0793
.0867
**.1032**
.1250|.0507
.0736
.0543
.0843
.0514
.0742
.0585
.0959
.0588
.0870
.0684
.1163|.0291
.0410
.0305
.0450
.0340
.0467
.0371
.0556
.0418
.0543
.0443
.0623| -|RARQwen
RARGPT4o
RARGem2|.0793
.1032
.0793
.1032
.0768
.0978
.0820
.1141
**.0831**
**.1087**
.0995
**.1576**|.0540
.0780
.0583
.0907
.0522
.0771
.0595
.0994
**.0620**
**.0934**
**.0755**
**.1349**|.0326
.0444
.0330
.0457
.0369
.0510
.0393
.0582
**.0449**
**.0583**
**.0477**
**.0669**| - - - -Table 9: Additional results of RAR. For clarity, the best results for each dataset and metric are highlighted in **bold** , while the second-best results are underlined. - -default, with the thinking efforts setting to low or None in our main experiments. All baseline methods and RAR are evaluated under identical conditions. Based on the LLM prediction, we perform string matching to compute the highest rank of label items, evaluation metrics are implemented following (He et al., 2023). - -For alternative RL methods, we adopt the pairwise SimPO (Meng et al., 2024) and the multi-sample GRPO (Shao et al., 2024). GRPO details can be found in our main text, and the formulation for SimPO in our case can be formulated as (Meng et al., 2025): - -**==> picture [348 x 14] intentionally omitted <==** - -where the the log probabilities are computed similar to Equation (3). Hyperparameters such as _γ_ are searched as recommended in the original paper. For GRPO, we set the group size to eight and compute the loss using Equation (5). Across all methods, we adhere to an online, on-policy setting to train and evaluate the retriever models. While our methodology formally introduces the reference model _πre f_ in accordance with standard DPO, our final experiments omit this reference constraint. We empirically found that removing the reference model yields superior recommendation performance, a phenomenon consistent with recent findings in RLVR literature (Yue et al., 2025; Yu et al., 2025). Specifically, we omit the reference model for two primary reasons: (1) our joint optimization with the supervised negative log-likelihood loss ( _Lnll_ ) serves as a highly effective surrogate to prevent policy drift and maintain in-domain performance, rendering the KL penalty from a reference model largely redundant; and (2) while retriever models fundamentally require dropout to achieve optimal generalization, the inconsistency introduced by dropout destabilizes the log-likelihood calculations of the reference model, thereby failing to provide a stable or effective constraint on the policy. To compute hallucination rates, we perform fuzzy matching and consider a prediction to be hallucination if its similarity score to any of the provided candidate titles is below 0.85. - -We present additional results to demonstrate that RAR generalizes well to other recent large language models. Specifically, we evaluate Qwen 2.5 (Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct), GPT-4o mini (gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18), and Gemini 2.0 Flash (gemini-2.0-flash-001) (Yang et al., 2024; Hurst et al., 2024; Comanici et al., 2025). The results are presented in Table 9, from which we observe: (1) First, applying our method (RAR) consistently improves recommendation performance over the standard SFT baseline across all three foundation models. Whether using Qwen 2.5, GPT-4o mini or Gemini 2.0 Flash, the RAR variants yield higher NDCG and Recall scores in almost every scenario. (2) the RAR formulation utilizing Gemini 2.0 Flash (RARGem2) achieves the best overall results, securing the highest scores across all metrics for the Redial and Reddit datasets, as well as three out of four metrics for the Inspired dataset. In summary, these findings confirm that our approach is model-agnostic and generalizes highly effectively to various state-of-the-art large language models, reliably boosting performance beyond standard fine-tuning techniques. - -19 - +LogicPro: Improving Complex Logical Reasoning via Program-Guided +Learning +JinJiang1,YuchenYan2,YangLiu3,JianingWang3,ShuaiPeng1, +XunliangCai3,YixinCao4,MengdiZhang3,LiangcaiGao1* +1WangxuanInstituteofComputerTechnology,PekingUniversity,Beijing,China, +2CollegeofComputerScienceandTechnology,ZhejiangUniversity,3MeituanGroup, +4InstituteofTrustworthyEmbodiedAI,FudanUniversity +Correspondence:jiangjin@stu.pku.edu.cn,gaoliangcai@pku.edu.cn +| | | Abstract | | | LeetCode 679. 24 Game  | | Number Game: 24 Points  | | | +| -------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | You are given an integer array cards of | | Imagine you are a contestant on a new game | | | +| | | | | | length 4. You have four cards, each | | show called "The Magic 24 Points", where your | | | +| | | | | | containing a number in the range [1, 9]. | | task is to ... (Game Rules) ... you are given the | | | +| In this paper, | we | propose a | new data | synthe- | | | | | | +| | | | | | You should arrange the numbers on these | | cards with numbers 8, 7, 6, 5. Your challenge | | | +sismethodcalledLogicPro,whichleverages cards in a mathematical expression using is to determine whether it's possible to arrange +| | | | | | the operators ['+', '-', '*', '/'] and the | | these numbers and operations to achieve exactly | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +LeetCode-stylealgorithmProblemsandtheir parentheses '(' and ')' to get the value 24. Can you find a valid expression, or prove +| | | | | | 24. Please give code to solve it. | | that reaching 24 is impossible with these cards? | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +correspondingProgramsolutionstosynthesize +| Complex | Logical | Reasoning | data | in text for- | | | | | | +| ------- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Code Reasoning +| mat. First, | we synthesizecomplex | | | reasoning | | | | Text Reasoning | | +| ----------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | +problemsthroughsourcealgorithmproblems +| and test cases. | | Then, standard | answers | and | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intermediatevariableoutputsareobtainedfor +eachproblembasedonstandardpythonsolu- +| tionsandtestcases. | | Finally,withtheguidance | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | Expression: (6*(5-(8-7))) = 24. Result: True✅  | | | | ❌ | +ofcodeintermediatevariables,wesynthesize +thetextreasoningprocessforeachreasoning Figure 1: Left: LeetCode 679. 24 Game - original +| problems. | Throughthismethod, | | wecansyn- | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | algorithmproblemandstandardPythonsolution. | | | | Right: | +thesizedatathatisdifficult,scalable,effective, +| | | | | | Oursynthesizedcomplexreasoningproblem: | | | | 24-point | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +| andcomeswithgoldenstandardanswersand | | | | | andg4o-apiresponse. | | | | | +| high-qualityreasoningprocesses. | | | Asaresult, | | | | | | | +withour540Ksynthesizeddatasetconstructed +solelyfrom2,360algorithmproblems,ourap- Synthetic data (Liu et al., 2024b) has wide ap- +proach1achievessignificantimprovementsin +| | | | | | plicationsinmathematicsandcodedomains. | | | | For | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +multiplemodelsforthedatasetsBBH27,Log- +| | | | | | mathematical | data, synthetic | data | can | be gener- | +| -------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------ | --------------- | ---- | --- | --------- | +| icBench, | DROP, | AR-LSAT, | and GSM8K, | etc. | | | | | | +atedthroughproblem-drivenmethodssuchasevol- +outperformingawiderangeofexistingreason- +instruct(Luoetal.,2023a;Zengetal.,2024),prob- +ingdatasets. +lemrestatement(Yuetal.,2023),back-translation +1 Introduction (Lu et al., 2024), and few-shot examples (Dalvi +etal.,2021),orknowledge-drivenmethodsbased +With the rapid development of artificial intelli- on knowledge bases (Dalvi et al., 2021) and con- +gence,LargeLanguageModels(LLMs)(Bietal., cept graphs (Tang et al., 2024). For code data, it +2024;Liuetal.,2024a)demonstrateexcellentper- generatesdiverseandhigh-qualityinstructiondata +formanceinreasoningtasks. Thesuccessofthese withself-evolutionarymethods(Wangetal.,2023; +models is inseparable from the support of large- Luoetal.,2023b)orcombinedwithopen-source +| scale and high-quality | | reasoning | data. | However, | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +referencessuchasOSS-Instruct(Weietal.,2024). +dataacquisitionandprocessingfacenumerouschal- Inthecomplexlogicalreasoningdomain,there +lenges in the real world. As a viable alternative, isrelativelylessresearchondatasynthesis. Previ- +syntheticdata(Wangetal.,2024)caneffectively +| | | | | | ously, some | work uses | logical proposition-based | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | +alleviatethisproblemandfurtherenhance(Dubey softreasoningmethods(Tafjordetal.,2021;Clark +etal.,2024;Adleretal.,2024)themodel’sreason- et al., 2021) to synthesize training data, aiming +ingcapabilities. to improve models’ reasoning ability and inter- +pretability(Saeedetal.,2021;Dalvietal.,2021). +*Correspondingauthor. +| | | | | | Additionally, | Sinha et | al. (2019) | and | Tian et al. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +1Codeanddataarepubliclyavailableathttps://github. +com/jiangjin1999/LogicPro (2021) use kinship graphs and first-order logic +26200 +Proceedingsofthe63rdAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Volume1:LongPapers),pages26200–26218 +July27-August1,2025©2025AssociationforComputationalLinguistics + +to synthesize person relationship reasoning data effectiveness is shown through performance im- +andlogicalentailmentreasoningdatarespectively. provements across multiple models on multiple +More recently, Morishita et al. (2023) using for- Out-of-Distribution(OOD)benchmarks. +mallogictheory,Parmaretal.(2024)covering25 Ourmaincontributionsaresummarizedasfol- +| patternsacrossdifferentlogictypes,andMorishita | | | | | | lows: | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +etal.(2024)utilizingformallanguageprogramsto +synthesisereasoningdata. 1. We propose a novel data synthesis method +calledLogicPro,whichusesLeetCode-style +Previousmethodsprimarilyusedpropositional +logic or formal languages as the source of logic. dataasseedstosynthesizetext-formattedcom- +Instead,wefindthatalgorithmicquestionsandpro- plex logical data through algorithmic prob- +gramminglanguageslikeLeetCodeprovideadif- lemsandprogramsolution. +| ferentsourceoflogic. | Algorithmicproblemstyp- | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | 2. Withthisapproach,wecansynthesisea540K | | | | | | +| ically involve | explicit input-output | | relationships, | | | | | | | | | +datasetfromjust2,360algorithmicproblems +| recursive | and iterative structures, | | and | operations | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | that is sufficiently | | difficult, | | scalable, | and ef- | +| ondatastructures. | Alloftheseconstituteaunique | | | | | | | | | | | +patternofreasoning. Atthesametime,algorithmic fective,aswellashavingstandardanswerand +high-qualityreasoningprocess. +| problems | are naturally related | to | real-world | | task | | | | | | | +| -------- | --------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +contexts,suchaspath-planning,datasorting,and +| | | | | | | 3. The experimental | | results | | show that | our ap- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------- | +resourceallocationproblems,whichcanoftenbe +| | | | | | | proach | achieves | significant | | improvements | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +mappedtoreal-worldapplicationscenarios. +BBH27, +| | | | | | | in multiple | models | | for the | datasets | | +| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| As shown | in Figure 1, | we discover | | that | while | | | | | | | +LogicBench,DROP,AR-LSAT,andGSM8K, +analgorithmproblemcanbeeasilysolvedthrough +| | | | | | | etc. outperforming | | | a wide | range | of existing | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | +code,LLMsoftenmakemistakeswhenthesame +datasets. +problemistransformedintoaspecifictextreason- +| ingquestion. | Inspiredbythisobservation,wepro- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| poseadatasynthesismethodaimedatgenerating | | | | | | 2 Approach | | | | | | +high-qualityreasoningproblemsandreasoningpro- +cesses by utilizing widely available algorithmic Inthissection,weelaborateontheLogicProdata +| | | | | | | synthesisprocess. | | Itmainlyincludes: | | | datacollec- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | +problemsandtheircodesolutions. +Our approach consists of data collection and tion and construction of test cases (Section 2.1), +threesteps. Fordatacollection,wecollectalarge howtosynthesizetextualcomplexlogicalreason- +ingproblems(Section2.2),howtoobtaininterme- +numberofexistingLeetCodealgorithmicproblems +diatevariableoutputsfromcode(Section2.3),and +| and their | code solutions, | while | collecting | or | con- | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +structing diverse test cases. First, by combining howtosynthesizehigh-qualityreasoningprocesses +basedonintermediatevariableoutputsandsynthe- +| the original | algorithm problem | | with test | cases, | it | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | sizedquestions(Section2.4). | | | Anoverviewofour | | | +istransformedintoaspecifictextreasoningprob- +lem. Then, the original standard code solution is approachisshowninFigure2. +| combined | with the test cases | to | generate | the | cor- | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | 2.1 DataCollection | | | | | | +| respondingpythoncodesolution. | | | Byrunningthe | | | | | | | | | +code,thefinaloutputresultandthevaluesofkey Inthedatacollectionphase,sourceLeetdatawas +intermediate variables can be obtained. Finally, collected test cases were constructed. We collect +based on the code output, the model is guided to 2,360officialLeetCodeproblemsasinitial seeds +synthesizethecompletereasoningprocessforthe forLogicPro’ssyntheticdata. However,duetothe +currentproblem. limited number of test cases in the original data, +Thisdatasynthesismethodofferssignificantad- GPT-4 is used to reconstruct test cases for each +vantages: sufficientdifficulty,scalability,effective- question. Specifically, we prompt GPT-4 to gen- +ness, and high-quality reasoning paths. Specifi- erate 150 test cases for each LeetCode problem, +cally, the sufficient difficulty is reflected in mod- sample three times, and then perform consolida- +els performing worse on LogicPro compared to tion, deduplication, and filtering on the three re- +otherbaselinedata;scalabilitywasdemonstrated sults. Eventually,2,360LeetCodealgorithmprob- +bycollectingmorealgorithmicproblemsandcon- lems were compiled with standard Python solu- +structingmoretestcasestofurtherscalethedata; tions,eachcontainingupto300testcases. +26201 + +Data Collection Step 1: Construct Complex Reasoning Problem LogicPro +... +| | LC1 LC2 | ... LC70 ... LC | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | +| | | 2360 | Imagine Iyomua agrien eo ny ao uf iatnrees cs lcimhabllienngg ea wsthaeirrec yaosue with 26  | | | | | | | | | +| | | | need to csltimebp sa. sYtoauir ccaasne ctloi mreba cehit thheer t 1o po. rT 2he steps at a | | | | | | Input | | | +Algorithmic Problem +| | | | s t a ir c a s e t i hm a | se . a H t oo tw a l. m . o fa n1 y 7 d s i ts e | t pin s . c Et a w c ha yt si m | c e a yn o yu o cu a nc | l imb to | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | e it h e r c l i tm h b e | 1t os tp e op f.o r t h2 e s t s et p a s i. r | Ic n a s h eo ,w c mo na sn | yi d d e irs it ni ng c ta l | l | | | | | +LeetCode 70: Climbing Stairs +| | You are climbing a staircase. It takes | | ways canp yoosus ribealec hc othmeb tionpa toifo nthse o sft a1i-rsctaespe bayn dt h2e-step | | | | | | | | | +| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | e n d o f t hc el i cmh | b a sll ?e n g e ?  C o nsider all combinations o | | f | n=26n=27n=28 | | | | | +" n " s t e p s t o r e a c h t h e t o p .   E a c h t i m e 17... Output +| | y o u c a n e i t h | e r c li m b " 1 " o r " 2 " s t e p s .  | 1- s t e p a n d 2 | - s t e p m o ve s . | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +n= +In how many distinct ways can you +| | climb to the top?  | | | | | | | | Step 3: Program-Guided Reason | | | +| --- | ------------------ | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | Problem-Program Consistency Check | | | Solvability Check | | | | | | +n=28 +| | | Test Cases | | | | | | | | ... | n = 27 | +| --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | +n= 2 6 +n=17 +| | | | Step 2: Obtain Intermediate Variable From Program | | | | | | To find the number of distinct ways to climb staircase with | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +17 steps using 1-step and 2-step climbs, you can  recognize +| | | | | | | | ... | | that this is a Fibonacci-like sequence problem. | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------- | +| | | | | n=28 | | | | | Define f(n) as the number of ways to reach the n-th step. | | | +| | | | | n=27 | | | | | The recurrence relation is: | | | +| | | | | | | Step 1: a = 1, b = 2 | | | f ( n ) = f (n - 1 ) + | f (n - 2 ) | | +| | | | | ...n=26 | | S S t t e e p p 3 4 : : a a = = 1 2 , | , b b = = 2 3 | | | | | +| | | | | | | S t e p 5 : a = 3 | , b = 5 | | T h i s re la ti o n h o l d | s b e c a u s e to reach the n-th step, you can | | +| | | | | | | S t e p 6 : a = 5 | , b = 8 | | e it h e r c o m e fr o m | t h e ( n -1 ) - t h s t | e p ( w i t h a 1 - step climb) or | +| | | | | nn==1177 | | . .. | | | | | | +Python Solution S t e p 1 2 : a = 8 9 , b = 1 4 4 f r o m t h e (n - 2 )- t h s te p (w i t h a 2 - s t e p c l im b ) . +| | | | | | | S t e p 1 3 : a = 1 | 4 4 , b = 2 33 | | ... | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Step 14: a = 233, b = 377 | | | Using these, calculate up to f(17): | | | +Step 15: a = 377, b = 610 +| | | | | | | Step 16: a = 610, b = 987 | | | f(3) = f(2) + f(1) = 2 + 1 = 3 | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Step 17: a = 987, b = 1597 | | | f(4) = f(3) + f(2) = 3 + 2 = 5 | | | +| | | | | | | Final values: a = 1597, b = 2584 | | | ... | | | +The final answer is 2584. +f(16) = f(15) + f(14) = 987 + 610 = 1597 +f(17) = f(16) + f(15) = 1597 + 987 = 2584 +| | | | | | | PassExecution Check | | | Thus, there are 2584 distinct ways to climb to the top of | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | ---- | --- | --------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Fail | | the staircase with 17 steps. | | | +Figure 2: An overview of LogicPro (Example: LeetCode-70 Climbing Stairs): 1. Construct Complex Reason +Problem(Section2.2Step1),basedonsourcealgorithmproblemsandtestcasestosynthesizecomplexreasoning +problems. 2. ObtainIntermediateVariableFromProgram(Section2.3Step2)3. Program-GuidedReason(Section +2.4Step3),synthesizingthefinalInput-Outputfromcomplexreasoningproblemsandintermediatevariableoutputs. +| 2.2 | Step1: | ConstructComplexReasoning | | | textreasoningproblem. | | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | +| | Problem | | | | For | the | data flow | in | this step, | 699K | complex | +| | | | | | reasoning | | problems | in | text format | | are generated. | +Subsequently,afterconductingconsistencycheck +Step 1: +(5K+)andsolvabilitycheck,weselect595Kquali- +... rewrite the algorithmic question to a text logical +| | reasoning problem ... | | | | fiedproblemsforthenextstep. | | | | | | | +| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1. incorporate the test case into ...      2. .... +3. randomly introduce some background information Problem-Program Consisitency Check The +to diversify the question ... +| | | | | | purpose | of | this module | | is to | examine | the consis- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | +Input: +| | | | | | tency | between | code | and | text | reasoning | problem. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | ---- | --------- | -------- | +{souce_algorithmic_problem} +{test_case} In the second step, we rewrite the original stan- +| | Output: | | | | dard | Python | solution | | and generate | | test case spe- | +| --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} cificpythoncode. Toensureconsistencybetween +| | | | | | the | rewritten | Python | code | and | the | text reasoning | +| --- | -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | -------------- | +| | Figure3: | SchematicDiagramofStep1. | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | problems | | generated | in | the first | step, | we perform | +| | | | | | consistencychecksonthecodeandproblems. | | | | | | Af- | +Inthefirststep,wesynthesizecomplexreason- ter inspection, 5K+ data entries are filtered out. +ingproblemsbasedontheoriginalalgorithmprob- PromptisinAppendixC.2Figure12. +| lemsandtestcases. | | AsshowninFigure3,theinput | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +includesthesourceLeetCodealgorithmproblems Solvability Check This check module is de- +and specific test case. In this process, the LLM signedtocheckwhetherthesynthesisedquestions +needs to combine test cases and algorithm prob- are solvable. In the first step, a large number of +lems, while randomly adding some background textualreasoningproblemsweregeneratedbycom- +information, to synthesize a complex reasoning bining the original LeetCode problems with the +problem. ReferringtotheexampleinFigure2,the test cases generated by GPT-4. However, some +modelcombineLeetCodeProblem70"Climbing of these problems are unsolvable or meaningless. +Stairs"andthetestcaseinputn=17intoaspecific Thisismainlybecausethetestcasesgeneratedby +26202 + +GPT-4 are not entirely perfect. Although GPT-4 ExecutionCheck Thischeckmoduleisdesigned +ensuresthatthegeneratedtestcasescomplywith to detect errors that occur during code execution. +theproblemrequirementsandcodeformat,these Inthestep2,theoutputofintermediatevariables +test cases may still deviate from the core testing inthecodewasobtainedbymodifyingtheoriginal +pointsoftheproblems,orthesamplelengthistoo standardPythonsolutionfortheseerrors,weper- +long,resultinginunsolvablesynthesizedproblems. formdatafiltering,whichcanbedividedintotwo +Afterdetection,wehavescreenedoutandfiltered categories: The first category involves modified +98Kunsolvableproblems. PromptisinAppendix code that encounters errors during execution and +C.2Figure13. still fails to run properly after multiple sampling +attempts;Thesecondcategoryinvolvescodethat +| 2.3 Step2: | ObtainIntermediateVariablefrom | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +executescorrectlybutstillcontainserrormessages +Program +intheintermediatevariableoutputsduetotheuse +| | | | | of try-catch | functionality. | After detection, | these | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | ------ | +| Step 2: | | | | two types | of issues result | in the filtering | of 50K | +...provide the  test case  specifc Python code +errorcodes. +solution ... +1. Print the final result ...   2. ... +| | | | | 2.4 Step3: | Program-GuidedReasoning | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | +3. ... print key intermediate variables ... +Input: +{source_python_solution} +| {test_case} | | | | Step 3: | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} ... analyze and identify the key intermediate +| Output: | | | | variables ... to solve complex logical reasoning | | | | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +{test_case_specific_code_with_process_print} problems. ... modify the code to print these key +intermediate variables to simulate the step-by-step +process of problem-solving as a human would do. +| Figure4: | SchematicDiagramofStep2. | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Input: +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +Inthe secondstep, weinputPython codesolu- {intermediate_variable_output} +| tions, test cases, | and synthesized | reasoning | prob- | | | | | +| ------------------ | --------------- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Output: +lemstogeneratetestcasespecificpythoncode. As {final_reasoning_process} +showninFigure4,werequirethemodeltogener- +atepythoncodesolutionsrelatedtothetestcases Figure5: SchematicDiagramofStep3. +andensurethatthecodeprintsthefinalresulttothe +| | | | | In the third | step, the | input consists | of the com- | +| --------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------- | -------------- | ----------- | +| resultvariable. | Inaddition,tosimulatethehuman | | | | | | | +plexreasoningproblemgeneratedinthefirststep +| reasoning process, | the model | is required | to print | | | | | +| ------------------ | --------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +keyintermediatevariablesinthecode. andtheintermediatevariableoutputobtainedinthe +For example, for the climbing stairs problem secondstep. Theseelementsareusedtosynthesize +| | | | | thefinalreasoningprocess. | | AsshowninFigure5, | | +| --------------- | ------------ | -------- | -------- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | +| shown in Figure | 2, the model | needs to | generate | | | | | +pythoncodeforthespecifictestcaseofclimbing17 the model (Llama3.1-70B-Instruct) answers syn- +stairs,andprintintermediatevariablesinthecode, thesizedcomplexreasoningquestionsbyanalyzing +intermediatevariabledata. +namelythecalculationprocessoftheFibonaccise- +quenceateachstep. Finally,byexecutingthecode, Taking the example in Figure 2, based on the +theoutputoftheintermediatevariablescanbeob- calculationprocessoftheFibonacciequationinthe +tained,whichwillassistinthereasoningsynthesis intermediate variable output, the model success- +fullysynthesizedahigh-qualityreasoningprocess +forthenextstep. +For the data flow of this step, the final answer as the final output of LogicPro data. The goal of +to each problem is obtained by running the com- thisstepistogenerategoldenreasoningprocesses +bined code that integrates the test cases with the withlogicandaccuracy,therebyensuringthecom- +standardPythonsolution. Meanwhile,wemodify pletenessandcredibilityofthereasoning. +the code to print important intermediate variable For the data flow in this step, based on the +values. Then,throughexecutioncheck,wefinally text-formatcomplexreasoningproblemsandcorre- +obtain 544K data points, including standard an- sponding code intermediate variable outputs ob- +swers and code intermediate variable outputs for tained from previous steps, we use this impor- +| eachproblem. | | | | tantintermediatevariableinformationtoguidethe | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +26203 + +model in generating high-quality reasoning pro- the learning rate decays to 0; the maximum se- +cessesforcomplexreasoningproblems. Finally,a quence length is set to 8192, with a global batch +high-qualityresoningquetion-answerdatasetswith sizeof128,andthenumberoftrainingepochsis +540kinput-outputpairsisobtained. set to 3. All experiments are completed with Su- +pervisedFine-tuning(SFT)onacomputingcluster +| 3 Experiments | | | | | consistingof32NVIDIAA100GPUs. | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3.1 ExperimentalSetup +3.1.2 Evaluation +3.1.1 Training This section details the experimental setup asso- +Thissectionelaboratesontheexperimentalsettings ciated with the evaluation. We present: (1) the +relatedtotraining. Weintroduce: (1)thebaseline benchmarksusedtoevaluatethedifferentsynthetic +datasets used for comparison with our LogicPro; data;and(2)theimplementationdetailsoftheeval- +| (2)experimentaldesigntoverifytheeffectofdif- | | | | | uationprocess. | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | +| ferentsyntheticdata. | | (3)themodelconfigurations | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Benchmarks | | To comprehensively | | | evaluate | the | +| used in training | and | analysis; | (4) the | parameters | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | model’s | complex | logical | | reasoning | capabilities, | | +andimplementationdetailsofthetrainingprocess. +| | | | | | ten representative | | benchmark | | datasets | | for testing | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | +BaselineData Tocomprehensivelyevaluatethe are selected , including BBH27 (Suzgun et al., +effectiveness of our method, we select multiple 2023), LogicBench (Parmar et al., 2024), DROP +mainstreamlogicalreasoningdatasynthesismeth- (Duaetal.,2019),AR-LSAT(Zhongetal.,2021), +odsasbaselinecomparisons,includingRuleTakers Boardgamqa(Kazemietal.,2024), FOLIO(Han +(Clarketal.,2021),LogicNLI(Tianetal.,2021), etal.,2022),GSM8K(Cobbeetal.,2021),Multi- +ProofWriter(Tafjordetal.,2021),CLUTRR(Sinha LogicEval(Pateletal.,2024),ProofWriter(Tafjord +et al., 2019), RuleBert (Saeed et al., 2021), Log- etal.,2021),andMATH(Hendrycksetal.,2020). +icBench(Parmaretal.,2024),andFLD(Morishita Notably,foroursyntheticdataLogicPro,allbench- +et al., 2023). The detailed information of these markareout-of-domaintests. Incomparison,some +datasetscanbefoundinAppendixA.1Table5. +| | | | | | baseline | data, | same | as some | benchmark, | | are syn- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +thesizedbasedonpropositionallogicorfirst-order +| ExperimentalDesign | | Tobettersimulatetheac- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | logic. Additionally, | | | LogicBench’s | | training | and | +tualtrainingscenariosofLLMs,weusetwotypes +| | | | | | test sets | are completely | | in-domain. | | Furthermore, | | +| ------------- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +| of base data: | first, 100K | general | domain | data ex- | | | | | | | | +BBH,asacorebenchmarkforevaluatingmodels’ +| tracted from | OpenHermes-2.5 | | (Teknium, | 2023), | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | -------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | complex | logical | reasoning | | capabilities, | | includes | +andsecond,LogiCoT(Liuetal.,2023)asthespe- +| | | | | | 27challengingreasoningtasks. | | | | Basedonthis,we | | | +| ------------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------------- | ------------ | --- | +| cialized base | data for | logical | reasoning | domain. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | apply weights | | to all | data | subsets | to calculate | the | +Bymixingthesedifferentbasedatawithbaseline +| | | | | | finalaveragescore. | | Duetospacelimitations,only | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +dataandoursyntheticdatafortrainingseparately, +theevaluationresultsofsevenbenchmarksarepre- +wesystematicallyanalysedtheimpactofdifferent +sentedinthemaintext,withcompleteresultsavail- +syntheticdataonmodelperformance. +ableinAppendixA.2Table6. +| Models | Weconductsystematicexperimentalre- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | Evaluation | Details | | In the | inference | | phase, we | +searchonfoundationmodelsofvariousscalesand +usethevLLM(Kwonetal.,2023)frameworkfor +| architectures. | Themainexperimentsemployfour | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | deployment. | The | inference | | configuration | | adopts | +| representativemodels: | | Qwen-7BandLlama3-8B | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | greedy decoding | | strategy | | and sets | the | maximum | +assmall-scalerepresentatives,andQwen2-72Band +| | | | | | generationlengthto4096tokens. | | | | | Fortheevalua- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Llama3-70Baslarge-scalemodelrepresentatives. +tionofmodeloutput,weadoptQwen-2.5-72Bas +Forin-depthunderstandingofmodelbehaviors,we +| | | | | | themodelevaluatortoscore. | | | | Thespecificevalua- | | | +| --------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| select Qwen2-7B | and | Llama-8B | for | fine-grained | | | | | | | | +tionprompttemplatecanbefoundinFigure14. +analysisexperiments. +3.2 MainResults +| TrainingDetails | Intermsoftrainingimplemen- | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tation,weuseMegatron-LMasthetrainingframe- Table 1 shows the main results where LogicPro +work with the following configurations: a cosine outperforms previous synthesis methods across +learning rate schedule is adopted with an initial multiple benchmarks. On the representative Big +learningrateof1e-5,awarmupratioof0.03,and Bench Hard benchmark, LogicPro improves the +26204 + +| Model | BBH27 LogicBench | DROP ARLSAT | #BoardQA | FOLIO GSM8K | #Avg | +| -------------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | +| Qwen2-7B-RuleTakers | 45.4 59.1 | 65.7 16.5 | 42.2 | 44.6 80.9 | 45.8 | +| Qwen2-7B-LogicNLI | 43.3 71.3 | 67.4 17.8 | 45.3 | 41.7 81.6 | 45.0 | +| Qwen2-7B-ProofWriter | 40.8 68.6 | 64.3 17.0 | 36.9 | 36.3 80.9 | 43.2 | +| Qwen2-7B-CLUTRR | 43.0 72.0 | 64.0 17.0 | 51.9 | 41.2 80.4 | 45.0 | +| Qwen2-7B-RuleBert | 46.2 69.1 | 67.4 16.5 | 43.8 | 40.7 81.7 | 47.3 | +| Qwen2-7B-LogicBench | 44.7 *95.9 | 67.4 17.8 | 41.4 | 38.7 82.1 | 46.6 | +| Qwen2-7B-FLD | 42.0 69.5 | 68.3 14.8 | 34.9 | 45.6 80.0 | 43.8 | +Qwen2-7B-LogicPro(ours) 50.9 73.5 68.3 19.1 48.1 46.1 81.5 51.2 +| Llama3-8B-RuleTakers | 38.5 59.9 | 65.9 12.6 | 47.3 | 43.3 67.9 | 40.3 | +| -------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +| Llama3-8B-LogicNLI | 40.4 54.0 | 65.3 12.6 | 41.0 | 56.0 69.3 | 41.8 | +Llama3-8B-ProofWriter 37.2 62.1 66.4 15.2 31.3 47.8 69.1 39.5 +| Llama3-8B-CLUTRR | 40.5 61.1 | 66.6 10.4 | 43.7 | 56.0 69.5 | 42.2 | +| ------------------ | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +| Llama3-8B-RuleBert | 34.7 48.8 | 66.5 15.2 | 43.6 | 51.5 68.9 | 37.4 | +Llama3-8B-LogicBench 41.0 *93.5 66.2 10.9 38.6 62.7 69.8 43.7 +| Llama3-8B-FLD | 35.7 67.8 | 61.2 13.5 | 39.1 | 50.0 64.6 | 38.2 | +| ------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +Llama3-8B-LogicPro(ours) 45.0 67.9 68.8 15.2 44.3 48.3 74.2 46.2 +| Qwen2-72B-RuleTakers | 61.3 72.4 | 76.6 19.6 | 61.0 | 49.3 88.5 | 61.3 | +| -------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +| Qwen2-72B-LogicNLI | 61.7 80.7 | 77.0 21.3 | 60.4 | 58.2 87.3 | 61.6 | +Qwen2-72B-ProofWriter 61.8 75.5 77.2 16.5 55.0 44.0 88.0 61.5 +| Qwen2-72B-CLUTRR | 68.1 79.0 | 78.4 24.4 | 61.0 | 59.7 89.4 | 66.7 | +| ------------------ | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +| Qwen2-72B-RuleBert | 67.8 74.1 | 76.5 19.6 | 55.2 | 62.7 88.0 | 66.5 | +Qwen2-72B-LogicBench 67.1 *97.0 77.9 24.8 57.3 60.5 88.4 67.2 +| Qwen2-72B-FLD | 65.4 72.4 | 76.3 17.0 | 45.5 | 53.7 86.9 | 63.6 | +| ------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +Qwen2-72B-LogicPro(ours) 72.4 81.7 79.6 27.4 66.4 55.2 89.1 70.4 +Llama3-70B-RuleTakers 51.5 69.1 75.6 19.1 61.5 53.9 86.8 52.7 +| Llama3-70B-LogicNLI | 58.5 69.9 | 78.0 17.8 | 58.5 | 58.3 84.5 | 57.8 | +| ------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +Llama3-70B-ProofWriter 55.3 31.9 75.3 15.2 58.7 51.0 65.4 53.2 +| Llama3-70B-CLUTRR | 57.8 71.8 | 74.0 20.9 | 62.1 | 61.3 75.1 | 57.3 | +| ------------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +| Llama3-70B-RuleBert | 56.0 68.7 | 75.0 13.9 | 51.5 | 51.0 85.4 | 55.1 | +Llama3-70B-LogicBench 61.4 *93.2 78.4 21.3 58.7 50.0 84.6 60.8 +| Llama3-70B-FLD | 57.2 74.4 | 75.0 16.5 | 46.3 | 56.9 85.5 | 56.4 | +| -------------- | --------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ---- | +Llama3-70B-LogicPro(ours) 63.7 72.7 78.8 22.3 65.0 54.2 87.6 62.4 +Table 1: Main results of LogicPro with baseline data. Where #BoardQA represents BoardgameQA and #Avg +representsAverage. Bolddenotesthebestscoreinthatbaseline,underlinedenotesthesecondhighestscore,and* +| denotessame-distributiondata. | SeeTable6formoredetails. | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +averageperformanceby2.3%-4.7%comparedto relativelyminorimpactonmodelperformance. On +the previous best baseline across different model OOD benchmarks such as DROP (reading com- +typeandscales,andshowsatleast10%improve- prehension reasoning) and ARLSAT (law school +mentovergeneralbaselinedata. OnLogicBench admission test reasoning), LogicPro also demon- +(abenchmarkmeasuringpropositionallogiccapa- strates advantages across multiple model founda- +bilities),LogicProachievesthebestperformance tions,furthervalidatingitsperformanceonout-of- +exceptwhenLogicBenchitselfisusedasthetrain- distribution tasks. The weighted average results +ingset. OnFOLIO(abenchmarkmeasuringfirst- across all benchmarks show that on the Qwen2 +orderlogiccapabilities),exceptforQwen2-7B,the foundation,7Band72Bmodelsimproveby3.9%- +performanceoftheotherthreemodelstrainedwith 8%and3.1%-9.1%respectivelycomparedtobase- +LogicPro is inferior to other baseline data. This lines;ontheLlama3foundation,8Band70Bmod- +maybebecausesomebaselinesyntheticdataises- elsimproveby2.5%-8.8%and1.6%-9.7%respec- +sentiallygeneratedbasedonfirst-orderlogic,mak- tivelycomparedtobaselines. +ingtheirdatadistributionclosertoFOLIO,leading +Additionally,fordifferentscalemodels,wefind +tobetterperformance. OnGSM8K(mathematical thatourLogicProstillshowsadvantagesonlarge- +reasoningbenchmark),differentsyntheticdatahas scale models. This indicates that although large- +26205 + +scale models possess stronger reasoning capabil- Qwen2-7B BBH27 LogicBench #Avg +ities, our data still provides important value for All_Baseline 43.1 92.8 47.1 +| improvingtheirperformance. | | | | Itisspeculatedthat | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | ---------- | ------------- | -------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | All*+LogicPro | | 48.8+5.7 | | 96.3+3.5 | 52.3+5.2 | | +| this may | be related | to | the high | difficulty | level | of | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Llama3-8B | | BBH27 | | LogicBench | #Avg | | +| LogicPro | itself, | with detailed | | analysis | in section | | | | | | | | | +| 4.4. | | | | | | | All_Baseline | | 42.9 | | 94.3 | 47.6 | | +| | | | | | | | All*+LogicPro | | 47.6+4.7 | | 95.0+0.7 | 51.2+3.6 | | +4 Analysis +| | | | | | | | Table3: Resultsofcontinuousperformanceimprove- | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4.1 AblationStudy mentonexistingdata. All_Baselinerepresentsthatwe +| | | | | | | | mixallbaselinedatafromthemainexperiment. | | | | | | All*+ | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | +LogicProrepresentsthatwefurthermixLogicProdata +| Qwen2-7B | | BBH27 | LogicBench | | #Avg | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +forcomparison. +| Source_LeetCode | | 41.0 | | 63.4 | | 42.2 | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| LogicPro | w/oInter-Var | 48.2+7.2 | | 69.6+6.2 | 49.0+6.8 | | | | | | | | | +LogicPro 50.9+9.9 73.5+10.1 51.2+9.0 experimentalresultsshowthatontopofintegrating +w.Inter-Var +Llama3-8B BBH27 LogicBench #Avg allbaselinedata,theadditionofLogicProcanfur- +Source_LeetCode 36.6 51.4 38.5 therimprovemodelperformance. OntheBBHtask, +LogicPro w/oInter-Var 44.0+7.4 63.6+12.2 45.1+6.6 itbringsimprovementsof5.6%and4.7%respec- +LogicPro 45.0+8.4 67.9+16.5 46.2+7.7 tively,whileforaverageperformance,itimproves +w.Inter-Var +by5.2%and3.6%respectively. +| Table2: | Ablationstudy. | | Source_LeetCodeisthesource | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------------- | --------- | -------------------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | It is worth | emphasizing | | | that our goal | is | not to | +| 2360 LeetCode | | algorithm | questions | and | code | solu- | | | | | | | | +tion. LogicPro and LogicPro indi- propose a method to replace existing synthetic +| | w/oInter-Var | | | | w.Inter-Var | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +data,butrathertointroduceanoveldatasynthesis +catewhethertheconstructionprocessusesintermediate +variables. In other words, LogicPro is a di- strategy. Different from previous synthetic data, +w/oInter-Var +| rect distillation | | of the text | problems | in | LogicPro | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | our data’s | logic | comes | from | LeetCode | algorithm | | +LogicPro isourfinalLogicProdata. Llama3.1- problemsandprogramminglanguages,ratherthan +w.Inter-Var +| 70B-Instruct | is the | model | to distill | and | generate | final | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | propositionallogicandformallanguages. | | | | | Asthe | | +reasoningtrajectories. +resultsabove,ourdatacomplementsexistingdata +tofurtherenhancethemodel’scomplexreasoning +AsshowninTable2,weconductablationstudies +capabilities. +tovalidateLogicPro’seffectivenessinsynthesizing +| questions | and | generating | high-quality | | reasoning | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | --------- | ------ | ----------------------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | 4.3 DataScalingAnalysis | | | | | | | +| processes. | First, | we compare | | Source_LeetCode | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | In Figure | 6, we | demonstrate | | the impact | of | three | +| with LogicPro | | w/oInter-Var | to | analyze | the | effect | | | | | | | | +on synthesizing text reasoning questions. For datascalingmethodsonBBHandAveragemetrics +BBH, our method improves the performance of to analyze how the total data amount, number of +| | | | | | | | algorithm | problems, | | and number | of | test cases | in | +| -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| Qwen2-7B | and | Llama3-8B | by | 7.21% | and | 7.34% | | | | | | | | +datasynthesismethodsaffectmodelperformance. +| respectively, | with | significant | | improvements | | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6.8% and 6.6% on the Average metric. Sub- Overall, theDatascalingmethodshowsasteady +upwardtrend,indicatingthatthesynthesizeddata +| sequently, | we | compare | LogicPro | | | with | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +w/oInter-Var +| | | | | | | | after mixing | effectively | | improves | model | perfor- | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | +| LogicPro | w.Inter-Var | to | analyze | the effect | of | code | | | | | | | | +intermediate variables in the reasoning process. mance, while also revealing potential for further +The results show that introducing code interme- improvementthroughexpandeddatascale. +| | | | | | | | In contrast, | | the Leetcode | | Problems | scaling | | +| --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | +| diate variables | | as guidance | can | further | improve | | | | | | | | | +data quality compared to directly distilling syn- methodshowsmorefluctuation. Asthenumberof +thesized questions. Specifically, compared to Leetcodeproblemsincreasesfrom30%to100%, +LogicPro , it achieves improvements of both BBH and Average metrics display multiple +w/oInter-Var +| | | | | | | | patternsofdeclinefollowedbyincrease. | | | | | Thismay | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | +2.68%and1.04%onBBH,andimprovementsof +2.2%and1.1%ontheAveragemetric. beduetodistributionaldifferencesinthedatagen- +eratedfromdifferentalgorithmproblems,leading +4.2 PerformanceGainonAllBaselineData tofluctuationsinthemixeddataresults. +AsshowninTable3,wecombineallbaselinedata TheTestCasesmethodgenerallyshowsanup- +toevaluatetheeffectofintroducingLogicPro. The wardtrend,butmodelperformancedeclinesafter +26206 + +Model #Rule LogicNLI #Proof CLUTRR RuleBert LogicBench FLD LogicPro +Qwen2-7B-Instruct 73.0 62.8 64.5 46.3 53.6 74.5 54.1 39.3 +Qwen2-72B-Instruct 78.3 78.9 73.8 72.0 54.1 77.3 69.1 46.3 +Llama3-8B-Instruct 69.0 63.3 62.1 67.0 47.8 75.5 51.5 41.2 +Llama3-70B-Instruct 80.6 79.6 78.9 83.8 65.5 82.8 64.4 55.6 +Average 75.2 71.2 69.8 67.3 55.2 77.5 59.8 45.6 +Table4: ResultsfromdifferentbaselinedataandLogicPro’sdifficultycomparisonsonfouropensourcemodels. +#RulerepresentsRuleTakersand#ProofrepresentsProofWriter. Themetricsfortheresultsinthetableareaccuracy +rates,andsmallerisbetter. +50 +48 +46 +44 +42 +0 100 200 300 400 500 +)%( +ycaruccA +Big Bench Hard +Data +Leetcode Problems +Test cases +50 +48 +46 +44 +42 +0 100 200 300 400 500 +Data-Amount (K) +)%( ycaruccA +bottleneck of data expansion. On this basis, the +model’scapabilitiescanbecontinuouslyenhanced. +4.4 DifficultyComparisonwithBaselineData +Asmentionedabove,LogicProisasufficientlydiffi- +cultdataset. Tofurthervalidatethispoint,inTable +4 we compare the performance between various +Average +baseline datasets and LogicPro across four open- +sourcemodels. Specifically,werandomlysample +5K samples from each baseline dataset and Log- +icPro for evaluation, where LogicPro uses a uni- +Data +Leetcode Problems form sampling strategy to ensure each algorithm +Test cases +problemisfairlyselected. +Theresultsshowthatfouropen-sourcemodels +Figure6:Theresultsofthethreescalingmethods,Data, Qwen2-7B-Instruct,Qwen2-72B-Instruct,Llama3- +Leetcode Problems and Test Cases, on BBH and Av- +8B-Instruct, and Llama3-70B-Instruct perform +erage. Data means we randomly sample 10K-50K- +quitewellonexistingbaselinedatasets,withaver- +100K 500K-540KfromLogicPro;LeetcodeProblems +∼ age accuracy exceeding 50%, and some datasets +meansthatwesample2%-10%-20% 90%-100%ac- +∼ even reaching over 70%. However, their perfor- +cording to the number of algorithmic problems; Test +cases means that we select all algorithmic problems mancedropssignificantlyontheLogicProdataset, +andsamplethenumberoftestcasesforeachproblem withanaverageaccuracyofonly45.6%. Notably, +accordingto2%-10%-20% 90%-100%. asmentionedinthe"MainResults"section,Log- +∼ +icPro still poses significant challenges for Large +LanguageModels, whichmayexplainwhythere +the number of test cases increases to 80%. This +isstillconsiderablespaceforimprovementintheir +may be attributed to two factors: First, there is +performanceonlarge-scalemodels. +diminishing marginal utility of test cases. With +afixednumberofalgorithmproblems,simplyin- 5 Relatedwork +creasing test cases may reach a performance im- +provementbottleneck,andonlyfurtherincreasing 5.1 SyntheticReasoningData +thenumberofalgorithmproblemscaneffectively Syntheticdatahasplayedanimportantroleinen- +breakthrough. Second,theimpactoftestcasequal- hancingLLMs’reasoningcapabilities(Dubeyetal., +ity: The large number of test cases directly gen- 2024), especially in mathematics and coding do- +erated by GPT4 are limited in quality. Although mains. +increasingquantitybringssomeimprovement,con- Formathematicalreasoning,syntheticdatagen- +structinghigher-qualitytestcasesisstillneededfor eration includes problem-driven methods such +moresignificantoptimization. as evol-instruct (Luo et al., 2023a; Zeng et al., +Insummary,tofurtherimprovetheperformance 2024),problemrestatement(Yuetal.,2023),back- +of the model, it is necessary to enhance the qual- translation(Luetal.,2024),andfew-shotexamples +ity of test cases while increasing the number of (Dalvi et al., 2021), as well as knowledge-driven +algorithmicproblems. Thiscanbreakthroughthe methodsthatrelyonknowledgebases(Dalvietal., +26207 + +2021)orconceptgraphs(Tangetal.,2024)togen- (Tafjord et al., 2021; Clark et al., 2021) adopted +erate new problems by sampling key reasoning neural network-based soft reasoning methods to +points(Huangetal.,2024). synthesize training data from logical rules ex- +Intermsofcodereasoning(Chenetal.,2025), pressedinnaturallanguage,improvingreasoning +fromCodeAlpaca’s(Wangetal.,2023)useofself- capabilitiesandinterpretability(Saeedetal.,2021; +instructtogenerate20Kinstructiondatabasedon Dalvi et al., 2021). Recently, more research has +seed tasks, to WizardCoder’s (Luo et al., 2023b) explored the application of symbolic methods in +useofCodeevol-instructtogeneratemorecomplex synthetic training data. Li et al. (2024) formal- +tasks,toMagicoder’suseofoss-instruct(Weietal., izes seed data and replaces certain variables to +2024)toextract75Kinstructionsfromopensource synthesizemathematicalreasoningdata;Morishita +code. Synthesizingdatacontinuouslyimprovesthe et al. (2023) constructs synthetic corpora based +model’scodereasoningcapabilities. on formal logic; Shao et al. (2024) generates in- +In contrast, there is less research on synthetic ductivereasoningdatathroughcase-to-codemap- +dataforcomplexlogicalreasoning. Learningcom- ping;Parmaretal.(2024)providesmorecompre- +binesformallogictheory(Morishitaetal.,2023) hensivepropositionallogicbenchmarks;Morishita +to synthesize data using basic reasoning rules to etal.(2024)strengthensLLMreasoningcapabili- +trainlanguagemodels’multi-stepreasoningabil- tiesthroughprincipledsynthesisoflogicalcorpora. +ities. LogicBench (Parmar et al., 2024) not only These studies have advanced the development of +constructs logical reasoning benchmark datasets logicalreasoningcapabilities. +but also provides synthetic data based on formal Inthispaper,wefurtherexploretheapplication +| logic. | | | | | | of symbolic | methods | in | data synthesis, | | utilizing | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | +LeetCode-stylealgorithmproblemscontainrich formallogicalinformationembeddedinLeetCode +reasoningprocesses. Thispapersynthesizeshigh- algorithmproblemstosynthesizecomplexlogical +| qualitycomplexlogicalsreasoningdatabasedon | | | | | | reasoningdata. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theformallogicofprogramminglanguagestoen- +| | | | | | | 6 ConclusionandFutureWork | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +hancemodels’reasoningcapabilities. +5.2 SymbolicReasonEnhancesLLMReason This paper presents a new data synthesis method +| | | | | | | calledLogicPro. | | ThisapproachutilizesLeetCode- | | | | +| -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | +| Symbolic | language | was | initially | used for | formal | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | style algorithm | | problems | and solutions | | to gener- | +logicalreasoning,mathematicalcomputation,and +| | | | | | | ate complex | logical | reasoning | | data. By | synthe- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | +programverification,playingacrucialroleinearly +| | | | | | | sizing a | 540K dataset | from | just | 2,360 | seed prob- | +| ----------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----- | ----------- | +| artificial intelligence | | applications | | such as | expert | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | lems, our | approach | ensures | scalability, | | difficulty, | +systems(HatzilygeroudisandPrentzas,2004)and +| | | | | | | and high-quality | | reasoning | paths. | Results | show | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| automatedtheoremprovers(Loveland,2016). | | | | | With | | | | | | | +thatLogicProenhancesmodelperformanceacross +therapiddevelopmentofLLMs,symbolicreason- +multiplereasoningbenchmarks,includingBBH27, +ing,asastructuredreasoningapproach,hasfurther +LogicBench,DROP,AR-LSAT,andGSM8K,out- +enhancedthereasoningcapabilitiesoflargemodels +performingawiderangeofexistingdatasets. +throughtheirintegration. +| | | | | | | For future | work, | considering | | the vast | number | +| --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +| There are | two | main | approaches | to combining | | | | | | | | +ofalgorithmicproblemsintherealworld,suchas +| symbolicreasoningwithLLMs. | | | | Thefirstapproach | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +problemsfromLuogu,ACMcompetitions,andvar- +utilizessymboliclanguageforplanningandreason- +iousonlinejudges,wecancollectmorealgorithmic +ing. SomeresearchcombinesLLMswithsymbolic +problemdatatofurtherexpandLogicPro’sdataset. +solverslikePython(Gaoetal.,2023)andSAT(Ye +Additionally,ourdataincludesbothresultsignals +etal.,2023)tosolvemathematical(He-Yueyaetal., +(codeexecutionresultsasstandardanswers)and +2023)andlogicalreasoningproblems(Panetal., +processsignals(intermediatevariablesduringcode +| 2023), reducing | | the reasoning | | burden on | models. | | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | +| | | | | | | execution), | which | may | provide | new insights | for | +| Additionally, | some | work | employs | symbolic | lan- | | | | | | | +reinforcementlearning. +guageasaplanning(Haoetal.,2024;Wenetal., +2024)tooltostrengthenLLMs’reasoningcapabili- +Limitations +ties. +The second approach involves using symbolic Our method explores an algorithm based on +languagetogeneratetrainingdata. Earlyresearch LeetCode-style approach to synthesize complex +26208 + +logical reasoning data. In the future, one of our XiaoBi,DeliChen,GuantingChen,ShanhuangChen, +DamaiDai,ChengqiDeng,HonghuiDing,KaiDong, +| improvement | directions | | is to | build more | compre- | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ----------------- | ------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | QiushiDu,ZheFu,etal.2024. | | | Deepseekllm: | | Scal- | +| hensiveanddiversetestcases. | | | | However,thegener- | | | | | | | | | +ingopen-sourcelanguagemodelswithlongtermism. +ationoftestcasesitselfisanindependentresearch +arXivpreprintarXiv:2401.02954. +| field. More | advanced | | test generation | | techniques | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +XiancaiChen,ZhengweiTao,KechiZhang,Changzhi +| are expected | to | further | enhance | the | quality | and | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Zhou,WanliGu,YuanpengHe,MengdiZhang,Xun- +| generalizationabilityofsyntheticdatasets. | | | | | Further- | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | liangCai,HaiyanZhao,andZhiJin.2025. | | | | | Revisit | +more,althoughLeetCode’sofficial2,360problems self-debuggingwithself-generatedtestsforcodegen- +haveachievedsignificantresults,therearestillnu- eration. arXivpreprintarXiv:2501.12793. +meroushigh-qualityalgorithmproblemsinthereal +PeterClark,OyvindTafjord,andKyleRichardson.2021. +world, such as Luogu, ACM competitions, and Transformersassoftreasonersoverlanguage. InPro- +ceedingsoftheTwenty-NinthInternationalConfer- +| variousOnlineJudge(OJ)platforms. | | | | | Meanwhile, | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +enceonInternationalJointConferencesonArtificial +| new algorithm | problems | | continue | to | emerge. | If | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Intelligence,pages3882–3890. +| these resources | can | be | fully | utilized, | the quality | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | | Karl Cobbe, | Vineet Kosaraju, | | Mohammad | | Bavarian, | +andcoverageofsyntheticdatawillbefurtheren- +hanced, leading to a larger data scale and better MarkChen,HeewooJun,LukaszKaiser,Matthias +| | | | | | | | Plappert, | Jerry Tworek, | Jacob | Hilton, | | Reiichiro | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --------- | +performance. +| | | | | | | | Nakano,etal.2021. | Trainingverifierstosolvemath | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | wordproblems. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2110.14168. | | | | | +EthicsStatement +BhavanaDalvi,PeterJansen,OyvindTafjord,Zhengnan +Xie,HannahSmith,LeighannaPipatanangkura,and +Thisstudyisbasedondatafrom2360algorithmic +| | | | | | | | PeterClark.2021. | Explaininganswerswithentail- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +questionsonthefullyopen-sourceLeetCodeplat- +| | | | | | | | menttrees. | InProceedingsofthe2021Conference | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +form. Alldataarefrompubliclyavailablesources onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcess- +anddonotinvolveanypersonalprivacyinforma- ing,pages7358–7370. +tion. Ourstudystrictlyadherestothetermsofuse +DheeruDua,YizhongWang,PradeepDasigi,Gabriel +andprivacypoliciesoftheplatformsfromwhich Stanovsky,SameerSingh,andMattGardner.2019. +the data was sourced. We ensure that the rights Drop: Areadingcomprehensionbenchmarkrequir- +| | | | | | | | ingdiscretereasoningoverparagraphs. | | | | InProceed- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +ofallusersandplatformregulationsarerespected +ingsofthe2019ConferenceoftheNorthAmerican +| during data | collection | | and processing. | | Through | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | Chapter | of the Association | for | Computational | | Lin- | +the use of publicly available data, we aim to ad- guistics: HumanLanguageTechnologies,Volume1 +vance academic research and education, and pro- (LongandShortPapers),pages2368–2378. +moteprogressinthefieldofalgorithmsandcom- +AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, +| puterscience | | | | | | | AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | Akhil | Mathur, Alan Schelten, | | Amy | Yang, | Angela | +| | | | | | | | Fan,etal.2024. | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | arXiv | +Acknowledgments +preprintarXiv:2407.21783. +This work is supported by the projects of Luyu Gao, Aman Madaan, Shuyan Zhou, Uri Alon, +Beijing Science and Technology Program PengfeiLiu, YimingYang, JamieCallan, andGra- +(Z231100007423011) and National Natural ham Neubig. 2023. Pal: Program-aided language +| | | | | | | | models. | In International | Conference | | on | Machine | +| ------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | +| Science | Foundation | of | China | (No. | 62376012), | | | | | | | | +Learning,pages10764–10799.PMLR. +whichisalsoaresearchachievementofStateKey +LaboratoryofMultimediaInformationProcessing Simeng Han, Hailey Schoelkopf, Yilun Zhao, Zhent- +ingQi,MartinRiddell,WenfeiZhou,JamesCoady, +| and Key | Laboratory | of | Science, | Technology | | and | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | DavidPeng, | YujieQiao, | LukeBenson, | | etal.2022. | | +Standard in Press Industry (Key Laboratory of Folio: Natural language reasoning with first-order +IntelligentPressMediaTechnology). arXivpreprintarXiv:2209.00840. +logic. +| | | | | | | | YilunHao,YangZhang,andChuchuFan.2024. | | | | | Plan- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | ninganythingwithrigor: | | General-purposezero-shot | | | | +References +| | | | | | | | planning | with llm-based | formalized | | programming. | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2410.12112. +BoAdler,NiketAgarwal,AshwathAithal,DongHAnh, +PallabBhattacharya,AnnikaBrundyn,JaredCasper, IoannisHatzilygeroudisandJimPrentzas.2004. Neuro- +BryanCatanzaro,SharonClay,JonathanCohen,etal. symbolicapproachesforknowledgerepresentation +2024. Nemotron-4 340b technical report. arXiv inexpertsystems. InternationalJournalofHybrid +| preprintarXiv:2406.11704. | | | | | | | IntelligentSystems,1(3-4):111–126. | | | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +26209 + +JoyHe-Yueya,GabrielPoesia,RoseWang,andNoah Haipeng Luo, Qingfeng Sun, Can Xu, Pu Zhao, Jian- +Goodman. 2023. Solving math word problems by guangLou,ChongyangTao,XiuboGeng,Qingwei +combininglanguagemodelswithsymbolicsolvers. Lin,ShifengChen,andDongmeiZhang.2023a. Wiz- +| The 3rd | Workshop | on Mathematical | | Reasoning | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| In | | | | | | ardmath: | Empoweringmathematicalreasoningfor | | | | +andAIatNeurIPS’23. large language models via reinforced evol-instruct. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2308.09583. +DanHendrycks,CollinBurns,SauravKadavath,Akul +Arora, Steven Basart, Eric Tang, Dawn Song, and ZiyangLuo,CanXu,PuZhao,QingfengSun,Xiubo +JacobSteinhardt.2020. hendrycks2measuring. Sort, Geng,WenxiangHu,ChongyangTao,JingMa,Qing- +| 2(4):0–6. | | | | | | wei Lin, | and Daxin Jiang. | 2023b. | Wizardcoder: | | +| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | +Empoweringcodelargelanguagemodelswithevol- +| Yiming Huang, | Xiao | Liu, Yeyun | Gong, | Zhibin | Gou, | | | | | | +| ------------- | ---- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +instruct. InTheTwelfthInternationalConferenceon +| Yelong Shen, | Nan | Duan, | and Weizhu | Chen. | 2024. | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +LearningRepresentations. +| Key-point-driven | | data synthesis | | with its | enhance- | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ment on mathematical reasoning. arXiv preprint TerufumiMorishita,GakuMorio,AtsukiYamaguchi, +arXiv:2403.02333. andYasuhiroSogawa.2023. Learningdeductiverea- +soningfromsyntheticcorpusbasedonformallogic. +MehranKazemi,QuanYuan,DeeptiBhatia,Najoung InProceedingsofthe40thInternationalConference +Kim, Xin Xu, Vaiva Imbrasaite, and Deepak Ra- onMachineLearning,pages25254–25274. +| machandran. | 2024. | Boardgameqa: | | A dataset | for | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +naturallanguagereasoningwithcontradictoryinfor- TerufumiMorishita,GakuMorio,AtsukiYamaguchi, +mation. AdvancesinNeuralInformationProcessing andYasuhiroSogawa.2024. Enhancingreasoning +Systems,36. capabilitiesofllmsviaprincipledsyntheticlogiccor- +| | | | | | | pus. In | The Thirty-eighth | Annual | Conference | on | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +Woosuk Kwon, Zhuohan Li, Siyuan Zhuang, Ying NeuralInformationProcessingSystems. +| Sheng, Lianmin | Zheng, | Cody | Hao | Yu, | Joseph E. | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Gonzalez, Hao Zhang, and Ion Stoica. 2023. Effi- Liangming Pan, Alon Albalak, Xinyi Wang, and +cientmemorymanagementforlargelanguagemodel William Yang Wang. 2023. Logic-lm: Empower- +inglargelanguagemodelswithsymbolicsolversfor +| servingwithpagedattention. | | | InProceedingsofthe | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ACMSIGOPS29thSymposiumonOperatingSystems faithfullogicalreasoning. InThe2023Conference +| Principles. | | | | | | onEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcess- | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ing. +ZenanLi,ZhiZhou,YuanYao,XianZhang,Yu-Feng +Li, Chun Cao, Fan Yang, and Xiaoxing Ma. 2024. MihirParmar,NisargPatel,NeerajVarshney,Mutsumi +Neuro-symbolicdatagenerationformathreasoning. Nakamura, Man Luo, Santosh Mashetty, Arindam +InTheThirty-eighthAnnualConferenceonNeural Mitra,andChittaBaral.2024. Logicbench: Towards +systematicevaluationoflogicalreasoningabilityof +InformationProcessingSystems. +| | | | | | | largelanguagemodels. | | InProceedingsofthe62nd | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +Aixin Liu, Bei Feng, Bin Wang, Bingxuan Wang, AnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational +Bo Liu, Chenggang Zhao, Chengqi Dengr, Chong Linguistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages13679– +| Ruan, Damai | Dai, | Daya | Guo, | et al. | 2024a. | 13707. | | | | | +| ------------ | ---- | ------------------- | ---- | ------ | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Deepseek-v2: | A | strong, economical, | | and | efficient | | | | | | +mixture-of-expertslanguagemodel. arXivpreprint NisargPatel,MohithKulkarni,MihirParmar,Aashna +Budhiraja,MutsumiNakamura,NeerajVarshney,and +arXiv:2405.04434. +| | | | | | | Chitta Baral. | 2024. Multi-logieval: | | Towards | eval- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | +Hanmeng Liu, Zhiyang Teng, Leyang Cui, Chaoli uating multi-step logical reasoning ability of large +Zhang, Qiji Zhou, and Yue Zhang. 2023. Logicot: languagemodels. InProceedingsofthe2024Con- +Logicalchain-of-thoughtinstructiontuning. InFind- ferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguage +ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: Processing,pages20856–20879. +EMNLP2023,pages2908–2921. +MohammedSaeed,NaserAhmadi,PreslavNakov,and +RuiboLiu,JerryWei,FangyuLiu,ChengleiSi,Yanzhe PaoloPapotti.2021. Rulebert: Teachingsoftrulesto +Zhang,JinmengRao,StevenZheng,DaiyiPeng,Diyi +| | | | | | | pre-trainedlanguagemodels. | | InProceedingsofthe | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +Yang,DennyZhou,etal.2024b. Bestpracticesand 2021ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNatural +lessonslearnedonsyntheticdataforlanguagemodels. LanguageProcessing,pages1460–1476. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2404.07503. +YunfanShao,LinyangLi,YichuanMa,PeijiLi,Demin +DonaldWLoveland.2016. Automatedtheoremproving: Song, Qinyuan Cheng, Shimin Li, Xiaonan Li, +Alogicalbasis. Elsevier. PengyuWang,QipengGuo,etal.2024. Case2code: +| | | | | | | Learning | inductive reasoning | with | synthetic | data. | +| -------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------------------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | +| Zimu Lu, | Aojun Zhou, | Houxing | | Ren, Ke | Wang, | | | | | | +CoRR. +WeikangShi,JuntingPan,MingjieZhan,andHong- +sheng Li. 2024. Mathgenie: Generating synthetic Koustuv Sinha, Shagun Sodhani, Jin Dong, Joelle +data with question back-translation for enhancing Pineau,andWilliamLHamilton.2019. Clutrr: Adi- +mathematical reasoning of llms. arXiv preprint agnosticbenchmarkforinductivereasoningfromtext. +arXiv:2402.16352. InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical +26210 + +MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessingandthe9th languagemodels. InTheTwelfthInternationalCon- +InternationalJointConferenceonNaturalLanguage ferenceonLearningRepresentations. +Processing(EMNLP-IJCNLP),pages4506–4515. +WeihaoZeng,CanXu,YingxiuZhao,Jian-GuangLou, +| Mirac Suzgun, | Nathan | | Scales, | Nathanael | Schärli, | Se- | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | and Weizhu | Chen. | 2024. | Automatic | | instruction | +bastian Gehrmann, Yi Tay, Hyung Won Chung, evolvingforlargelanguagemodels. arXivpreprint +| Aakanksha | Chowdhery, | | Quoc | Le, | Ed Chi, | Denny | arXiv:2406.00770. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ---------- | ---------------------------- | ---- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Zhou,etal.2023. | | Challengingbig-benchtasksand | | | | | | | | | | | +| whetherchain-of-thoughtcansolvethem. | | | | | | InFind- | | | | | | | +WanjunZhong,SiyuanWang,DuyuTang,ZenanXu, +ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +DayaGuo,JiahaiWang,JianYin,MingZhou,and +ACL2023,pages13003–13051. +| | | | | | | | Nan | Duan. 2021. | Ar-lsat: | Investigating | | analytical | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | +OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalvi,andPeterClark.2021. reasoningoftext. arXivpreprintarXiv:2104.06598. +| Proofwriter: | | Generating | implications, | | proofs, | and | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +abductivestatementsovernaturallanguage. InFind- A DetailsofExperiment +ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +ACL-IJCNLP2021,pages3621–3634. +| | | | | | | | A.1 BaselineDataStatistics | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ZhengyangTang,XingxingZhang,BenyouWang,and +InTable5,westatisticsonthesizeofthebaseline +| FuruWei.2024. | | Mathscale: | | Scalinginstructiontun- | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +data,thelogicalsourcesofthesyntheticdata. +| ingformathematicalreasoning. | | | | InForty-firstInter- | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +nationalConferenceonMachineLearning. +| | | | | | | | Dataset | Size | LogicSource | | Source | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | +Teknium.2023. Openhermes2.5: Anopendatasetof RuleTakers 480K SoftRule (Clarketal.,2021) +syntheticdataforgeneralistllmassistants. LogicNLI 48K FOL (Tianetal.,2021) +| | | | | | | | ProofWriter | 580K | SoftRule(proof) | | (Tafjordetal.,2021) | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +JidongTian, YitianLi, WenqingChen, LiqiangXiao, CLUTRR 50K KinshipGraph (Sinhaetal.,2019) +| | | | | | | | RuleBert | 310K | SoftRule | | (Saeedetal.,2021) | | +| ------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | +| Hao He, | and | Yaohui | Jin. 2021. | | Diagnosing | the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | LogicBench | 12K | PropositionalLogic | | (Parmaretal.,2024) | | +first-orderlogicalreasoningabilitythroughlogicnli. +| | | | | | | | FLD | 300K | FormalLogic | | (Morishitaetal.,2023) | | +| -------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------------------- | --- | +| In Proceedings | | of the | 2021 | Conference | on | Empiri- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | LogicPro(ours) | 540K | ProgramLogic | | LogicPro | | +calMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages +3738–3747. +| | | | | | | | | Table5: | | DataStatistics. | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +KeWang,JiahuiZhu,MinjieRen,ZemingLiu,Shiwei +Li,ZongyeZhang,ChenkaiZhang,XiaoyuWu,Qiqi +| Zhan,QingjieLiu,etal.2024. | | | | Asurveyondatasyn- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | A.2 CompleteMainResults | | | | | | +thesisandaugmentationforlargelanguagemodels. +| | | | | | | | Given | space constraints, | | we | show | the complete | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ------------ | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2410.12896. +resultsforallbenchmarksinTable6. +YizhongWang,YeganehKordi,SwaroopMishra,Alisa +Liu,NoahASmith,DanielKhashabi,andHannaneh +| | | | | | | | Results | for All | Subsets | of BBH | | In the table 7, | +| ----------- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --------------- | +| Hajishirzi. | 2023. | Self-instruct: | | Aligning | language | | | | | | | | +modelswithself-generatedinstructions. InThe61st wegivethehistogramresultsforallbaselinedata +Annual Meeting Of The Association For Computa- andLogicProonthe27subsetsofBBH. +tionalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | | ResultsforBaseData | | | Insection3.1,paragraph | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +YuxiangWei,ZheWang,JiaweiLiu,YifengDing,and +Experimentaldesign,wementionedthatinorderto +| Lingming | Zhang. | 2024. | Magicoder: | | Empowering | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +codegenerationwithoss-instruct. InForty-firstInter- simulatetheactuallargemodeltrainingmanufac- +nationalConferenceonMachineLearning. turers,wechoosethegenericdomainandlogical +| | | | | | | | reasoningdomaindataasthebasedata. | | | | | Theresults | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | +JiaxinWen,JianGuan,HongningWang,WeiWu,and +MinlieHuang.2024. Codeplan: Unlockingreason- ofthebasedatawithoutaddinganysyntheticdata +aregiveninTable7. +| ing potential | | in large | langauge | models | by | scaling | | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | ------ | -------------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | ---- | -------- | ------------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +| code-formplanning. | | | CoRR. | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | B DetailsofAnalysis | | | | | | +| Xi Ye, Qiaochu | | Chen, | Isil Dillig, | and | Greg | Durrett. | | | | | | | +| 2023. | Satlm: | satisfiability-aided | | language | | models | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Complete | results | of | the ablation | | study The | +| usingdeclarativeprompting. | | | | InProceedingsofthe | | | | | | | | | +37thInternationalConferenceonNeuralInformation completeresultsonallbenchmarksoftheablation +ProcessingSystems,pages45548–45580. studyarepresentedinTable8. +| Longhui | Yu, Weisen | Jiang, | Han | Shi, | YU Jincheng, | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | CompleteresultsofthePerformanceGain | | | | | The | +ZhengyingLiu,YuZhang,JamesKwok,ZhenguoLi, +completeresultsofPerformanceGainonAllBase- +| AdrianWeller,andWeiyangLiu.2023. | | | | | Metamath: | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Bootstrapyourownmathematicalquestionsforlarge lineDataonallbaselinesareinTable9. +26211 + +Model BBH27 LogicBench DROP AR-LSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +Qwen2-7B-RuleTakers 45.4 59.1 65.7 16.5 42.2 44.6 80.9 53.8 20.0 40.8 45.8 +Qwen2-7B-LogicNLI 43.3 71.3 67.4 17.8 45.3 41.7 81.6 48.7 36.5 40.6 45.0 +Qwen2-7B-ProofWriter 40.8 68.6 64.3 17.0 36.9 36.3 80.9 43.4 63.5 40.3 43.2 +Qwen2-7B-CLUTRR 43.0 72.0 64.0 17.0 51.9 41.2 80.4 56.3 36.9 40.1 45.0 +Qwen2-7B-RuleBert 46.2 69.1 67.3 17.8 43.8 40.7 81.7 59.3 34.6 40.7 47.3 +Qwen2-7B-LogicBench 44.7 95.9* 67.4 17.8 41.4 38.7 82.1 67.3 18.0 41.3 46.6 +Qwen2-7B-FLD 42.0 69.5 68.3 14.8 34.9 45.6 80.0 50.5 37.3 40.6 43.8 +Qwen2-7B-LogicPro(ours) 50.9 73.5 68.3 19.1 48.1 46.1 81.5 62.0 28.5 41.6 51.2 +Llama3-8B-RuleTakers 38.5 59.9 65.9 12.6 47.3 43.3 67.9 64.2 29.4 19.8 40.3 +Llama3-8B-LogicNLI 40.4 54.0 65.3 12.6 41.0 56.0 69.3 62.3 35.0 19.8 41.8 +Llama3-8B-ProofWriter 37.2 62.1 66.4 15.2 31.3 47.8 69.1 62.8 45.4 19.5 39.5 +Llama3-8B-CLUTRR 40.5 61.1 66.6 10.4 43.7 56.0 69.5 63.1 35.1 20.0 42.2 +Llama3-8B-RuleBert 34.7 48.8 66.5 15.2 43.6 51.5 68.9 65.4 28.2 19.5 37.4 +Llama3-8B-LogicBench 41.0 93.5* 66.2 10.9 38.6 62.7 69.8 65.2 38.9 20.2 43.7 +Llama3-8B-FLD 35.7 67.8 61.2 13.5 39.1 50.0 64.6 60.0 38.4 17.8 38.2 +Llama3-8B-LogicPro(ours) 45.0 67.9 68.8 15.2 44.3 48.3 74.2 68.0 37.7 23.0 46.2 +Qwen2-72B-RuleTakers 61.3 72.4 76.6 19.6 61.0 49.3 88.5 60.7 70.6 54.6 61.3 +Qwen2-72B-LogicNLI 61.7 80.7 77.0 21.3 60.4 58.2 87.3 64.3 48.9 53.6 61.6 +Qwen2-72B-ProofWriter 61.8 75.5 77.2 16.5 55.0 44.0 88.0 63.0 70.7 55.0 61.5 +Qwen2-72B-CLUTRR 68.1 79.0 78.4 24.4 61.0 59.7 89.4 59.2 54.0 56.2 66.7 +Qwen2-72B-RuleBert 67.8 74.1 76.5 19.6 55.2 62.7 88.0 71.7 60.2 55.2 66.5 +Qwen2-72B-LogicBench 67.1 97.0* 77.9 24.8 57.3 60.5 88.4 87.9 57.2 55.4 67.2 +Qwen2-72B-FLD 65.4 72.4 76.3 17.0 45.5 53.7 86.9 60.0 56.5 54.7 63.6 +Qwen2-72B-LogicPro(ours) 72.4 81.7 79.6 27.4 66.4 55.2 89.1 72.1 54.3 55.8 70.4 +Llama3-70B-RuleTakers 51.5 69.1 75.6 19.1 61.5 53.9 86.8 74.4 33.1 36.3 52.7 +Llama3-70B-LogicNLI 58.5 69.9 78.0 17.8 58.5 58.3 84.5 67.5 31.3 34.5 57.8 +Llama3-70B-ProofWriter 55.3 31.9 75.3 15.2 58.7 51.0 65.4 50.3 49.3 24.6 53.2 +Llama3-70B-LogicPro(ours) 63.7 72.7 78.8 22.3 65.0 54.2 87.6 72.3 33.5 40.5 62.4 +Table6: Completeevaluationresultsforallbenchmark. +100 +80 +60 +40 +20 +0 boolean_expressio c n a s usal_judgem da e t n e t _understand d in is g ambiguation_qa dyck_languages formal_fallac g ie e s ometric_shapes logic h a y l p _ e d r e b d a u t c o lo t n i g o i n c _ a f l i _ v d e e _ d o u b c je ti c o t l n s o _ g s i e ca v l e _ n d _ e o d b u j c e t c i t o s n_three m _o o b v j i e e c _ t r s ecomm m e u n lt d i a st t e io p n _arithmetic_two navigate object_coun p t e i r n n e g g a u s i o n n s i _ n in g _ _ a a _ b t o a u b t l _ e colored_obj s e a c l t i s ent_t r r u a in n _ s n la a t m ion e _ s error_detection s s n p a o r r k ts s _unders t t r a a n t c e d k m i i n n p g g o _ r s a h l_ u s f t e f r l a q e c u d k e _ i o n n b c g j e _ e s s c h ts u _ ff f l i e v t e d r _ _ a o o c b b k j j i e e n c c g t t _ s s s _ h s u e f v f e le n d _ _ o o b b je je c c t t s s_three_objects web_of_lies word_sorting Average +)%( +ycaruccA +Qwen Model Performance Across 27 BBH Subsets +Qwen2-7B-RuleTakers +Qwen2-7B-LogicNLI +Qwen2-7B-ProofWriter +Qwen2-7B-CLUTRR +Qwen2-7B-RuleBert +Qwen2-7B-LogicBench +Qwen2-7B-FLD +Qwen2-7B-LogicPro +100 +80 +60 +40 +20 +0 boolean_expressio c n a s usal_judgem da e t n e t _understand d in is g ambiguation_qa dyck_languages formal_fallac g ie e s ometric_shapes logic h a y l p _ e d r e b d a u t c o lo t n i g o i n c _ a f l i _ v d e e _ d o u b c je ti c o t l n s o _ g s i e ca v l e _ n d _ e o d b u j c e t c i t o s n_three m _o o b v j i e e c _ t r s ecomm m e u n lt d i a st t e io p n _arithmetic_two navigate object_coun p t e i r n n e g g a u s i o n n s i _ n in g _ _ a a _ b t o a u b t l _ e colored_obj s e a c l t i s ent_t r r u a in n _ s n la a t m ion e _ s error_detection s s n p a o r r k ts s _unders t t r a a n t c e d k m i i n n p g g o _ r s a h l_ u s f t e f r l a q e c u d k e _ i o n n b c g j e _ e s s c h ts u _ ff f l i e v t e d r _ _ a o o c b b k j j i e e n c c g t t _ s s s _ h s u e f v f e le n d _ _ o o b b je je c c t t s s_three_objects web_of_lies word_sorting Average +)%( +ycaruccA +LLaMA Model Performance Across 27 BBH Subsets +LLaMA3-8B-RuleTakers +LLaMA3-8B-LogicNLI +LLaMA3-8B-ProofWriter +LLaMA3-8B-CLUTRR +LLaMA3-8B-RuleBert +LLaMA3-8B-LogicBench +LLaMA3-8B-FLD +LLaMA3-8B-LogicPro +Figure7: Qwen2-7BandLlama3-8Bmodelperformanceacross27BBHsubset. +26212 + +Model BBH LogicBench DROP ARLSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +Qwen2-7B-base 41.4 68.0 65.3 16.8 42.4 38.96 79.4 52.9 28.2 40.9 43.1 +Qwen2-7B-LogicPro 50.9 73.5 68.3 19.1 48.1 46.1 81.5 62.0 28.5 41.6 51.2 +Model BBH LogicBench DROP ARLSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +Llama3-8B-base 40.5 62.3 65.3 12.4 40.0 43.73 69.7 60.1 30.8 20.0 41.6 +Llama3-8B-LogicPro 45.0 67.9 68.8 15.2 44.3 48.3 74.2 68.0 37.7 23.0 46.2 +Table7: Resultofnotaddinganysyntheticdata(onlytwotypesofbasedata). +Qwen2-7B BBH LogicBench DROP AR-LSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +Source_LeetCode 41.0 63.4 58.4 18.3 32.8 38.2 79.7 54.8 26.2 40.6 42.2 +LogicPro-w/o.Inter-Var 48.2 69.6 62.9 16.5 47.6 50.7 80.5 62.9 30.0 40.1 49.0 +LogicPro-w.Inter-Var 50.9 73.5 68.3 19.1 48.1 46.1 81.5 62.0 28.5 41.6 51.2 +Llama3-8B BBH LogicBench DROP AR-LSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +Source_LeetCode 36.6 51.4 62.1 12.8 38.9 48.2 69.5 62.4 31.6 20.5 38.5 +LogicPro-w/o.Inter-Var 44.0 63.6 66.8 13.6 43.5 56.0 73.9 63.1 36.6 20.0 45.1 +LogicPro-w.Inter-Var 45.0 67.9 68.8 15.2 44.3 48.3 74.2 68.0 37.7 23.0 46.2 +Table8: Completeresultsoftheablationstudy. +C Prompts +C.1 CompletePromptsforTheThreeStepsin +TheMainMethodology +Thecompletepromptsfordatacollectionandsteps +1,2,and3areinFigure8,9,10,and11. +C.2 Promptsintheremainingmodules +ThecompletepromptsforProblem-ProgramCon- +sisitencyCheckandSolvabilityCheckareinFigure +12and13. +In the evaluations, the prompt used for model +evaluationisshowninFigure14. +D LogicProExamples +We give our synthetic data samples in figures 15 +and16,synthesisedfromtwoLeetCodealgorithm +questions,game24andstairclimbing. +26213 + +Qwen2-7B BBH LogicBench DROP ARLSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +All_Baseline_Data 43.1 92.8 63.6 15.2 48.4 60.5 79.2 65.7 67.9 39.9 47.1 +All_Baseline_Data+LogicPro 48.8 96.3 66.8 20.4 55.4 64.2 80.6 71.1 67.9 41.0 52.3 +Llama3-8B BBH LogicBench DROP AR-LSAT BoardgameQA FOLIO GSM8K Multi-LogiEval ProofWriter MATH Average +All_Baseline_Data 42.9 94.3 66.9 17.0 48.2 64.9 78.4 74.4 69.1 39.7 47.6 +All_Baseline_Data+LogicPro 47.6 95.0 68.6 16.5 51.6 61.9 79.4 76.8 66.4 40.2 51.2 +Table9: CompleteresultsofthePerformanceGain. +Data Collection: Obtain Test Cases +I have an algorithmic problem and its python code, please help me +construct 150 different test case inputs. +1. The constructed test case inputs need to fulfill the requirements of the +algorithmic problem and be compatible with the provided Python code. +2. Please enclose the constructed test case inputs in the following python +format; please enclose each test case input individually. +```python +# Test case input 1 +# Your input here +``` +```python +# Test case input 2 +Step 1: Construct Complex Reasoning Problem +# Your input here +``` +I have an algorithmic question and a corresponding test case. +... +```python Please rewrite the algorithmic question as a text-only logical +# Test case input 150 reasoning question based on the test case. +# Your input here +``` Instructions: +3. Ensure that all test cases are unique and as diverse as possible based 1. Please incorporate the test case into the description of the +on the topic and Python code. algorithm question; +4. Consider various aspects of the input type to ensure diversity, such as: +2. Please first give the name of this logical reasoning task; then +- Range of values: Include small, medium, and large values, as well +give the question that contains the test case. +as edge cases. +3. Please randomly introduce some background information to +- Special cases: Consider cases like empty input, maximum allowed +input size, or inputs that might cause edge conditions. diversify the question, such as mentioning a hypothetical scenario, +- Pattern variations: If the input is a sequence, vary the sequence a story, or real-life application related to the logical reasoning task. +patterns (e.g., sorted, reverse-sorted, random order). +- Combining elements: If the input is a composite data structure (e.g., Please rewrite the algorithmic question into a text-only logical +array of strings), combine different types of elements. reasoning question based on test case: +5. Generate inputs with varying difficulty levels (low, medium, high) Input: +considering the problem statement and the provided Python code: +{souce_algorithmic_problem} +- Low difficulty: Simple and straightforward inputs that cover basic +{test_case} +scenarios. +Output: +- Medium difficulty: Moderately complex inputs that include more +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +diverse and realistic scenarios. +- High difficulty: Complex inputs that test edge cases and challenging +conditions. Figure9: Completepromptsforstep1. +6. Ensure that all test cases adhere to the constraints provided in the +problem description. +7. Provide only the input for the test cases, do not include the output. +8. Please do not omit the output. Give each specific test cases. +Input: +{souce_algorithmic_problem} +{source_python_solution} +Output: +{test_cases} +Figure8: CompletepromptsforDataCollection: con- +structtestcases. +26214 + +Step 2: Obtain Intermediate Variable From Program Problem-Program Consistency Check +I have a programming problem statement and its corresponding code +Step 2.1: Obtain Test Case Specific Code +implementation. Both the problem and the code have been rewritten. Please +Please provide a Python code solution for the current complex +carefully read the problem statement and the code, and verify if the rewritten +logical reasoning problem, referring to the given Python code. +code fully matches the rewritten problem description. +- The code should print the final result. +- Please give the final python code in the following format: Follow these steps to complete the task: +```python 1. **Understand the problem statement**: Summarize the requirements of the +``` rewritten problem, including the input, output, and the functionality to be +implemented. +- Please ensure that after running the code, the output result of the +2. **Analyze the code logic**: Explain what the code does, including how it +algorithm is returned through the variable `result`. handles input, its core logic/algorithm, and the output it produces. +3. **Check for consistency**: Compare the rewritten problem with the code +Input: and determine whether they match. If they don't match, identify the +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} inconsistencies and explain why. +{source_python_solution} +Return the result in **JSON format** with the following structure: +Output: +```json +{test_case_specific_code} +{ +"is_consistent": true, // or false +Step 2.2: Print Intermediate Variable "issues": [ // If inconsistencies exist, list specific issues; if consistent, +Please analyze and identify the key intermediate variables used in leave the array empty +the Python code to solve complex logical reasoning problems. { +Based on your analysis, modify the code to print these key "type": "LogicMismatch", // Example issue types: LogicMismatch (logic +doesn't match), MissingDetails (problem lacks details), etc. +intermediate variables to simulate the step-by-step process of +"description": "Detailed description of the issue" +problem-solving as a human would do. +} +- Please give the final python code in the following format: ] +```python } +``` ``` +Input: **Rewritten Problem Statement:** +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +{test_case_specific_code} +**Rewritten Code:** +Output: {test_case_specific_code} +{test_case_specific_code_with_process_print} +Please evaluate and return the verification result in the specified JSON format. +Figure10: Completepromptsforstep2. +Figure12: PromptsforProblem-ProgramConsisitency +Check. +Step 3: Program-Guided Reasoning +Please analyze and identify the key intermediate variables used in +Solvability Check +the Python code to solve complex logical reasoning problems. +Based on your analysis, modify the code to print these key Your task is to act as a professional reasoning evaluator. Your goal is to +intermediate variables to simulate the step-by-step process of determine if the given problem is a valuable reasoning task. Consider +problem-solving as a human would do. the following two aspects: +- Please give the final python code in the following format: +1. **Problem Type**: The given problem must pertain to logical or +```python +inferential reasoning. +``` +2. **Solvability**: The given reasoning problem must be solvable based +- No need to output Example Output. +on the conditions provided in the problem. (You may attempt to solve it +step by step to verify its solvability.) +Input: +{synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +Please reason step by step and conclude with either ‘Yes’ or ‘No’. +{intermediate_variable_output} +Output: Given Problem: +{final_reasoning_process} {synthetic_complex_reasoning_problem} +Figure11: Completepromptsforstep3. Figure13: PromptsforSolvabilityCheck. +26215 + +Model Evaluation +[Instruction] +Please act as an impartial judge and evaluate the quality of the response +provided by an AI assistant to the user question displayed below. Your +evaluation should consider the correctness. You will be given a reference +answer and the assistant's answer. Begin your evaluation by comparing +the assistant's answer with the reference answer, you must identify +whether the response is correct or wrong by strictly following this format: " +", for example: "" or "". +[Question] +{question} +[The Start of Reference Answer] +{answer} +[The End of Reference Answer] +[The Start of Assistant's Answer] +{completion} +[The End of Assistant's Answer] +Figure14: PromptforModelEvaluation. +26216 + +Number Game: 24 Points +Question: +Imagine you are a participant in a mind-bending game show where the objective is to reach a target number using mathematical operations. You are +given four cards, each displaying a number between 1 and 9. +Your task is to arrange these numbers into a mathematical expression using the operators `+`, `-`, `*`, and `/`, as well as parentheses `(` and `)`, in +such a way that the result equals 24. +Keep the following rules in mind: +- The division operator `/` is used for real division, not integer division. +- Each operation must involve exactly two numbers (i.e., no unary operations are allowed). +- You cannot combine numbers to form multi-digit numbers. +Given the cards with numbers [9, 5, 8, 2], determine whether it is possible to create an expression that evaluates to 24. Can you devise such an +expression, or prove that it's impossible to do so? +Answer: +## Step 1: Understand the problem and the rules +The problem requires arranging four given numbers (9, 5, 8, 2) into a mathematical expression using the operators `+`, `-`, `*`, and `/`, as well as +parentheses, to get a result equal to 24. The division operator `/` performs real division, each operation involves exactly two numbers, and numbers +cannot be combined to form multi-digit numbers. +## Step 2: Consider all possible combinations of numbers and operations +To find an expression that evaluates to 24, we need to consider all possible combinations of the given numbers and the allowed operations. This +includes trying different orders of operations and different pairings of numbers for each operation. +## Step 3: Start with the first two numbers and try all possible operations +Begin with the numbers 9 and 5. We can try adding, subtracting, multiplying, or dividing these numbers. The results are: +- Addition: 9 + 5 = 14 +- Subtraction: 9 - 5 = 4 +- Multiplication: 9 * 5 = 45 +- Division: 9 / 5 = 1.8 +## Step 4: Continue with the next numbers and try all possible operations +Now, we have the results from the previous step (14, 4, 45, 1.8) and the remaining numbers (8, 2). We need to try all possible operations between these +results and the remaining numbers. +## Step 5: Analyze the results from Step 3 and continue with the most promising ones +From Step 3, we see that 14 is a promising result because it is closer to 24 than the other results. Let's continue with 14 and try operations with 8 and +2. +- Using 14 and 8: 14 + 8 = 22 (too high), 14 - 8 = 6 (too low), 14 * 8 = 112 (too high), 14 / 8 = 1.75 (not useful). +- Using 14 and 2: 14 + 2 = 16 (too high), 14 - 2 = 12 (too low), 14 * 2 = 28 (too high), 14 / 2 = 7 (not useful). +## Step 6: Consider alternative combinations Since the direct approach with 14 did not yield a straightforward solution, let's consider alternative +combinations, such as using 8 and 2 first. +- 8 + 2 = 10 +- 8 - 2 = 6 +- 8 * 2 = 16 +- 8 / 2 = 4 +## Step 7: Combine the results from alternative combinations with the remaining numbers +Now, let's combine these results with 9 and 5. +- Using 10 (from 8 + 2) and 9: 10 + 9 = 19 (too high), 10 - 9 = 1 (too low), 10 * 9 = 90 (too high), 10 / 9 = 1.11 (not useful). +- Using 10 (from 8 + 2) and 5: 10 + 5 = 15 (too high), 10 - 5 = 5 (too low), 10 * 5 = 50 (too high), 10 / 5 = 2 (not useful). +## Step 8: Re-evaluate the approach based on the given intermediate variables Given the intermediate variables, we see a path that leads to 24: 9 + 5 += 14, then 8 + 2 = 10, and finally 14 + 10 = 24. This suggests a specific order of operations that achieves the target. +The final answer is: $\boxed{Yes}$ +Figure15: DataExamplefor24Game. +26217 + +Climbing Stairs +Question: +Imagine you are climbing a staircase that has 22 steps. Each time you take a step, you can either move up 1 step or 2 steps. In how many distinct ways +can you reach the top of the staircase if you start from the bottom? +Consider the scenario where you are undergoing a physical fitness challenge that involves climbing stairs. The goal is to determine all possible step +combinations you can take to reach the 22nd step, starting from the ground level. How many unique ways can you complete this challenge? +Answer: +To solve this problem, let's break it down into manageable steps and analyze the pattern of climbing the stairs. +### Step 1: Understand the Problem +We have a staircase with 22 steps, and we can climb either 1 step or 2 steps at a time. We need to find out how many distinct ways we can reach the +top of the staircase, starting from the bottom. +### Step 2: Identify the Base Cases +- If there's only 1 step, there's only 1 way to climb it (1 step at a time). +- If there are 2 steps, there are 2 ways to climb them (either 2 steps at once or 1 step at a time, twice). +### Step 3: Recognize the Pattern For any step beyond the second, the number of ways to reach that step is the sum of the number of ways to reach +the step immediately before it (since we can climb 1 step from there) and the number of ways to reach the step 2 steps before (since we can climb 2 +steps from there). +### Step 4: Apply the Pattern to the Problem +Let's denote the number of ways to reach the nth step as W(n). Based on our pattern: +- W(1) = 1 (only one way to climb 1 step) +- W(2) = 2 (two ways to climb 2 steps: 1+1 or 2) +- For any n > 2, W(n) = W(n-1) + W(n-2) because we can reach the nth step from either the (n-1)th step (by taking 1 step) or the (n-2)th step (by +taking 2 steps). +### Step 5: Calculate for n = 22 +We need to calculate W(22) using the formula W(n) = W(n-1) + W(n-2), starting from the base cases W(1) = 1 and W(2) = 2, and iteratively applying the +formula until we reach W(22). +### Step 6: Iterative Calculation +- W(3) = W(2) + W(1) = 2 + 1 = 3 +- W(4) = W(3) + W(2) = 3 + 2 = 5 +- W(5) = W(4) + W(3) = 5 + 3 = 8 +- W(6) = W(5) + W(4) = 8 + 5 = 13 +- W(7) = W(6) + W(5) = 13 + 8 = 21 +- W(8) = W(7) + W(6) = 21 + 13 = 34 +- W(9) = W(8) + W(7) = 34 + 21 = 55 +- W(10) = W(9) + W(8) = 55 + 34 = 89 +- W(11) = W(10) + W(9) = 89 + 55 = 144 +- W(12) = W(11) + W(10) = 144 + 89 = 233 +- W(13) = W(12) + W(11) = 233 + 144 = 377 +- W(14) = W(13) + W(12) = 377 + 233 = 610 +- W(15) = W(14) + W(13) = 610 + 377 = 987 +- W(16) = W(15) + W(14) = 987 + 610 = 1597 +- W(17) = W(16) + W(15) = 1597 + 987 = 2584 +- W(18) = W(17) + W(16) = 2584 + 1597 = 4181 +- W(19) = W(18) + W(17) = 4181 + 2584 = 6765 +- W(20) = W(19) + W(18) = 6765 + 4181 = 10946 +- W(21) = W(20) + W(19) = 10946 + 6765 = 17711 +- W(22) = W(21) + W(20) = 17711 + 10946 = 28657 +### Step 7: Conclusion +There are 28657 distinct ways to climb a staircase of 22 steps, where you can climb either 1 step or 2 steps at a time, starting from the bottom. +Figure16: DataExampleforClimbingStairs. +26218 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q46/random_k2/question.json b/q46/random_k2/question.json index 60f1f8ad6d78f4b6ac10d72c3e3eb0094a9dcc17..f7037b3a178407d1fa59004839b3d2af4cd619e2 100644 --- a/q46/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q46/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "avalaunchpresentationsthatkickasteriskv3copy-150318114804-conversion-gate01_95.pdf", - "web_72a76e216577393a.pdf", - "web_3ee12c98981a617a.pdf" + "web_18e98cd838edeb2e.pdf", + "resize_r2_0.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q46/random_k2/random_1.md b/q46/random_k2/random_1.md index 144d326cd99ff1f87d5a1868d00f1666677a5e13..c346d7f5a27964259c5644ba47c0ac6027670487 100644 --- a/q46/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q46/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,1799 +1,1018 @@ -Genetics &Embry - -an -m -u -H - -ol -o -g -y - -Human Genetics & Embryology - -Salem, Human Genet Embryol 2013, S5 -DOI: 10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -ISSN: 2161-0436 - -Review Article - -Medical Genetics: An Overview -Mohammad Saad Zaghloul Salem* -Faculty of Medicine, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, Egypt - -Abstract - -Open Access - -Medical genetics is a branch of human genetics confined to studying structure and function of the genetic material -in health and disease states of human beings. It comprises studying causes and mechanisms of pathogenesis of -genetic disorders, clinical characterization of different types of these disorders and their modes of inheritance, study -of diagnostic techniques used in their diagnosis and delineation of effective prophylactic and therapeutic measures -resorted to in managing patients and carriers of these diseases. The wide spectrum of medical genetics includes -six main fields: basic, clinical, diagnostic, prophylactic, therapeutic and applied genetics. The scopes of most of -these fields are self-explanatory with few exceptions. Pathogenetics, a branch of basic genetics, implies the study of -mutagens, mutations, pathogenetic mechanisms responsible for development of genetic diseases and anti-mutation -mechanisms that protect the genome from the pathological consequences of these mechanisms. Formal genetics, -another branch of basic genetics, is concerned with deducing and figuring out relevant genetic data from constructed -figures that contain specific genetic information. These informative figures include, for instance, constructed family -pedigrees, linkage maps and chromosomal maps. Applied genetics denotes use of knowledge of other fields of -medical genetics in many significant applications like genetic counseling, fetal therapy and forensic genetics. -Treatment of genetic disorders and prevention of their complications represent the main targets of therapeutic -and prophylactic genetics, respectively. The importance of medical genetics resides in hopes of its ability to offer -alleviating measures and curative therapies for disprevileged patients with genetic diseases and, more importantly, -to succeed in achieving radical preventive approaches of these diseases. This article is intended to offer a simple -and concise overview of medical genetics including the various aspects of its different fields. - -Keywords: Pathogenetics; Mutagens; Mutation; Pathogenetic -mechanisms; Anti-mutation mechanisms; -genetics; -Prophylactic genetics; Therapeutic genetics; Applied genetics - -Formal +USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 1 of 27 -Spectrum of Medical Genetics +[PUBLISH] -Medical genetics, as the name implies, is a branch of human -genetics confined to, and concerned with, studying structure and -function of the genetic material in relation to health and disease -states of human beings. Within this context, it comprises the study of -causes and mechanisms of pathogenesis of genetic disorders, clinical -characterization of different types of these disorders and their modes of -inheritance, study of diagnostic techniques used in their diagnosis and -delineation of effective prophylactic and therapeutic measures resorted -to in managing patients and carriers of these diseases. A plausible -classification of the wide spectrum of the different fields of medical -genetics, based on the subjects and aims of the different branches of -each of these fields, recognizes six main fields of medical genetics: basic, -clinical, diagnostic, prophylactic, therapeutic and applied genetics -(Table 1). +In the +United States Court of Appeals +For the Eleventh Circuit -Genetics and Life +____________________ -All life activities in living cells, whether conducted on molecular -level, e.g. electron transfer in oxidative phosphorylation reactions for -production of ATP, on cellular level like cell division, on tissue level like -muscle contraction or on whole organ level like hearing for instance, are -mediated via very large numbers of inter-related metabolic networks. A -metabolic network is defined as a cascade of controlled biochemical -reactions and biophysical alterations that transform one, or more, -substrate to one, or more, product. Each metabolic network consists of -a very large number, sometimes hundreds, of proteins, mostly enzymes, -and other non-protein factors all acting cooperatively in stereotyped -sequence to perform specific biochemical and physiological functions. -In human cells, nearly 4100 (four thousand and one hundred) of these -networks have been delineated [1]. The proteins which are constituents +No. 22-13963 -of and mediate these metabolic networks are synthesized in living cells -under strict regulation of the genes contained within the cells. This -intimate relationship between the genetic material and life activities is -represented by the central dogma of molecular biology which states that -while the sum total of the genetic material of the living cell, collectively -referred to as the genome, defines the framework of all features and -life processes in living cells, the sum total of the proteins produced and -synthesized in the cell under strict control of the genome, collectively -referred to as the proteome, are the actual and direct mediators of these -life processes. +____________________ -The Human Genome +UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, -The human genome, estimated to consist of 20000-25000 genes, -is unequally divided into a major portion constituting more than -99.99% of its size, residing in the nucleus and structurally organized as -chromosomes and is referred to as the nuclear genome. The remaining -tiny portion exists as small circular molecules inside the mitochondria in -the cytoplasm and is referred to as the mitochondrial genome (mtDNA). -Albeit, much smaller portion of genomic DNA exists as a structure -associated and attached to the inner surface of cell membrane and is -referred to as cytoplasmic membrane associated DNA (cmDNA) [2]. The -exact functional significance of this portion is, still, a matter of debate. +versus -*Corresponding author: Mohammad SaadZaghloul Salem, Faculty of Medicine, -Professor of Medical Genetics, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, Egypt, E-mail: -mszsalem@hotmail.com +SHADON DEMETRIC EDWARDS, -Received February 15, 2013; Accepted February 27, 2013; Published March -02, 2012 + Plaintiff-Appellee, -Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet -Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 + Defendant-Appellant. -Copyright: © 2013 Salem MSZ. This is an open-access article distributed under -the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted -use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and -source are credited. +____________________ -Human Genet Embryol +Appeal from the United States District Court +for the Southern District of Florida +D.C. Docket No. 0:19-cr-60373-AHS-1 +____________________ - Medical Genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 2 of 27 -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal +2 - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 +Opinion of the Court -Basic Genetics +22-13963 -1. Molecular genetics +Before ROSENBAUM, NEWSOM, and MARCUS, Circuit Judges. -10. Developmental genetics +NEWSOM, Circuit Judge: -2. Pathogenetics +Shadon Edwards pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm and +ammunition despite having previously been convicted of a crime +punishable by more than a year in prison, in violation of 18 U.S.C. +§ 922(g). On appeal, Edwards challenges his § 922(g) conviction +and 180-month sentence on three grounds. First, he contends that +his guilty plea wasn’t knowing and voluntary because the district +court failed to inform him that, by pleading, he would waive his +right to appeal the denial of an earlier suppression motion. Second, +he asserts that the district court wrongly enhanced his sentence un- +der the Armed Career Criminal Act because the government didn’t +prove beyond a reasonable doubt, as required by Erlinger v. United +States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), that he had earlier been convicted of +three crimes that occurred on different occasions. Third, he argues +that § 922(g) exceeds Congress’s Commerce Clause authority. -3. Cytogenetics +After careful review, and with the benefit of oral argument, -4. Formal genetics +we affirm the district court’s judgment. -11. Population genetics +I -12. Evolutionary genetics +A -13. Comparative genetics +Shadon Edwards was suspected of being a high-level organ- +izer in a drug-trafficking organization responsible for distributing +illegal narcotics throughout south Florida. After obtaining an ar- +rest warrant for Edwards, law-enforcement officials observed him +driving around Pompano Beach. The officers followed and, after -5. Biochemical genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 3 of 27 -14. Experimental genetics +22-13963 -6. Physiological genetics +Opinion of the Court -15. Genomics +3 -7. Pharmacogenetics +seeing Edwards park, approached and took him into custody. A +search incident to Edwards’s arrest revealed that he had a Glock 43 +nine-millimeter semi-automatic pistol, loaded with six rounds of +ammunition. -16. Transcriptomics +B -8. Oncogenetics +A grand jury indicted Edwards on a single count: the know- +ing possession of a firearm and ammunition by one who had pre- +viously been convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year +in prison, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).1 Edwards filed a +motion to suppress the gun and ammunition found in his car, +which the district court denied. He then pleaded guilty pursuant +to a written plea agreement that neither expressly preserved nor +expressly waived his right to appeal. In connection with his plea, +Edwards also signed a factual proffer describing his offense conduct +and some of his prior criminal history, including, as particularly rel- +evant here, convictions “for trafficking +in oxycodone (10- +022573CF10A), aggravated battery with a deadly weapon (10- +022679CF10A), and robbery with a deadly weapon/aggravated bat- +tery (97-000465CF10B).” Factual Proffer ¶ 2, Dkt. No. 81. -9. Immunogenetics +At the change-of-plea hearing, the district judge engaged in +a colloquy with Edwards to assess several matters, including +whether he was competent to plead guilty and whether he under- +stood the consequences of doing so. At the hearing, there was no -17. Proteomics +1 The indictment also mentioned the Armed Career Criminal Act, 18 U.S.C. +§ 924(e)(1), albeit without further elaboration. -Clinical Genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 4 of 27 -1. Chromosomal aberrations +4 -12. Genetic diseases of the muscular system +Opinion of the Court -2. Congenital malformations +22-13963 -13. Genetic diseases of the skeletal system - -3. Inborn errors of metabolism - -14. Genetic diseases of the blood - -4. Mitochondrial disorders - -15. Genetic diseases of the immune system - -5. Genetic systemic syndromes - -16. Genetic diseases of male reproductive -system - -6. Genetic diseases of the nervous -system - -17. Genetic diseases of female reproductive -system - -7. Genetic diseases of the -endocrinal system - -8. Genetic diseases of the -cardiovascular system - -9. Genetic diseases of the -respiratory system - -10. Genetic diseases of the GIT -system - -11. Genetic diseases of the urinary -system - -18. Genetic diseases of the eye and vision - -19. Genetic diseases of the ear and hearing - -20. Genetic diseases of the skin - -21. Genetic psychiatric disorders - -Diagnostic Genetics - -Prophylactic Genetics - -1. Molecular diagnostic techniques 1. Premarital prophylaxis - -2. Cytogenetic diagnostic -techniques - -3. Biochemical diagnostic -techniques - -2. Preconception prophylaxis - -3. Prenatal prophylaxis - -4. Presymptomatic prophylaxis - -Therapeutic Genetics - -Applied Genetics - -1. Pharmacological therapy - -1. Genetic counseling - -2. Nutritional therapy - -2. Genetic screening - -3. Enzyme replacement therapy - -3. Preimplantation diagnosis - -4. Organ transplantation therapy - -4. Prenatal diagnosis - -5. Surgical intervention - -5. Fetal Therapy - -6. Stem cell therapy - -7. Genetic therapies - -6. Forensic genetics - -7. Genetic engineering - -8. Conventional therapies - -8. Eugenics - -Table 1: Spectrum of medical genetics. - -The nuclear genome in each human germ cell; ovum and sperm, -is organized into a set of 23 separate chromosomes known as the -haploid genome which represents the unit genome of humans. The -haploid genome of the ovum consists of 22 chromosomes that do not -participate in sex determination and referred to as the autosomes, and -one sex determining X chromosome. Similarly, the haploid genome -of the sperm consists of 22 autosomes, and one sex determining X -or Y chromosome. Upon fertilization, both haploid genomes of the -sperm and the ovum constitute a diploid genome consisting of their -46 chromosomes, 44 autosomes and 2 sex determining chromosomes, -either XX in females or XY in males. The diploid genome characterizes -the nuclear genome of the zygote as well as all somatic cells descendant -from it. With very rare exceptions, mitochondria of the sperm do -not participate in fertilization, being carried in the neck piece of the - -Page 2 of 12 - -sperm which do not penetrate the ovum. Nearly, all mitochondria, and -hence the mitochondrial genome, present in the zygote and in all body -cells are descendent from the mitochondria present in the ovum. This -feature accounts for the phenomenon of maternal inheritance, a non- -traditional mode of inheritance of genetic diseases caused by mutations -of the maternal mitochondrial genome. Maternal inheritance of -genetic diseases or traits occurs also for nuclear genes carried on the -X chromosomes of the mother due to the process of Lyonization, or -suppression of all X chromosomes in the cell in excess of one and -underlies the characteristic inheritance patterns of X linked recessive -and dominant genetic disorders. - -Nuclear genes are arranged in a linear sequence on chromosomes. -The estimated 20000-25000 genes that comprise the nuclear genome -constitute, and are distributed over, the 46 chromosomes in the nucleus. -The larger and longer chromosomes have far more numbers of genes -than the smaller and shorter chromosomes. Because genes constitute -only a small proportion of the whole genome, they are separated by long -inter-genic regions of base sequences of the DNA that comprise most -of the non-genic or gene-related components of the genome. These -include: pseudo-genes, pyknons, transposons and telomeres in addition -to an exceedingly large numbers of long and short repetitive and non- -repetitive interspersed elements, among many other components of, -yet, undefined function(s) [3]. - -The human mitochondrial genome exists in varying numbers, -tens to thousands, of very small closed circular double stranded -structures inside the mitochondria. The number of mitochondria -and the number of mtDNA molecules in each mitochondrion varies -according to the metabolic activities of the cell. The most active and -energy-demanding cells, like neurons, heart muscles, the retina, -skeletal muscles, endocrine glands, kidney cells and liver cells have the -largest numbers of mitochondria within their cytoplasm and the largest -numbers of mtDNA molecules in each mitochondrion as well. Each -molecule of the mitochondrial genome consists exclusively of 37 genes. -Though it constitutes very tiny fraction of the whole genome, mtDNA -is indispensable for life because it codes, with other nuclear genes, for -proteins that mediate ATP production in the cell via a specific oxidative -phosphorylation network. In addition, mtDNA regulates synthesis of -proteins that mediates many important metabolic activities of living -cells like lipid oxidation and steroid biosynthesis. More importantly, it -participates with nuclear genomic components in controlling apoptosis. -Due to increased susceptibility of mitochondria to mutational events -and limited mitochondrial genome repair capabilities, accumulating -mutations of mtDNA are linked to functional deterioration and -enhanced aging of cells. - -Genes of the human nuclear genome can be classified into three -main categories: structural genes which are directly involved in -synthesis of proteins, regulatory genes which regulate the function of -structural genes through transcription enhancing/silencing factors -and master genes which are responsible for maintaining the stability -and integrity of the genome through regulating major vital functions -of the cell like cell division, DNA repair and apoptosis. Structural -genes constitute the largest portion of the genome and function in a -stepwise manner composed of six consecutive stages: gene activation, -transcription, post-transcription modifications, translation, post- -translation modifications and intracellular trafficking and targeting of -synthesized protein. Though traditional concepts of gene function do -not include the last two stages concerned with structural modifications -and intracellular localization of translated proteins, although both of -these processes are, and should be considered as, integral stages of gene - -Human Genet Embryol - - Medical Genetics - -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -function because many genetic disorders result from defects in either -of these steps in spite of synthesis of the protein product of the gene in -normal amount with normal primary structural configuration. - -Types of Genetic Diseases - -Genetic disorders comprise many different types and are classified -into many different categories according to their causes and their -clinical manifestations. The great majority of currently defined disorders -result from defects in nuclear genes carried on chromosomes. Some -of these disorders might result from defect in one gene only; single -gene disorders, others might develop due to combined defects in many -genes; polygenic disorders. Defects in mitochondrial genes result in -pathogenesis of distinct group of diseases referred to as mitochondrial -disorders. Since ATP production in cells depends on a metabolic -network mediated by proteins and enzymes produced by both nuclear -and mitochondrial genes, a peculiar group of diseases characterized by -deficient energy production and known as oxidative-phosphorylation -disorders results from deficient production or production of defective -proteins mediating ATP production. - -Chromosomal disorders are, in essence, polygenic disorders -due to involvement of very large numbers of genes according to the -magnitude of the underlying pathogenetic mechanism(s). They are -classified into autosomal anomalies due to defects in the autosomes -and sex chromosomal anomalies. Each of these types might present as -structural disorders caused by structural chromosomal abnormalities -or as numerical disorders due to presence of abnormal number of -chromosomes in the nucleus. Structural chromosomal abnormalities -comprise many pathological types like translocations, deletions, -inversions, duplications, ring chromosomes, isochromosomes and -chromosomal -fragility. Numerical chromosomal abnormalities, -which result due to defects in chromosome number, also include -many types according to whether they result from autosomal or sex -chromosome abnormalities. Pathological examples of this category -include trisomy, or existence of an extra copy of the chromosome, -monosomy, or deficiency of a chromosome which is limited only to -the X chromosome in Turner syndrome, hypodiploidy, where less than -the normal diploid number of chromosomes (46) exists in the nucleus -and hyperdiploidy where larger numbers of chromosomes exist in the -nucleus. Extreme hypodiploidy and hyperdiploidy are cytogenetic -anomalies characteristic of malignant cells. - -Genomic disorders represent another group of genetic diseases due -to defects involving the whole genome, instead of one or few genes. -They can be classified, in turn, into numerical genomic disorders -and functional genomic disorders. Numerical genomic disorders are -exemplified by polyploidy and comprise triploidy where three sets of -the haploid genome (69 chromosomes) exist in the nucleus and, less -frequently, tetraploidy characterized by presence of four sets of the -haploid genome (92 chromosomes) in the nucleus. These aberrations -are, mostly, caused by defective genomic regulatory mechanisms, -e.g. endoreduplication, where DNA replication is not synchronized -properly with corresponding stage of cell division. Functional genomic -disorders are caused by defects in regulatory mechanisms, e.g. genomic -imprinting, responsible for controlling, regulating and synchronizing -genome function in the very early stages of development and can present -as vesicular moles and dermoid cysts. A portion of early miscarriages -might be due to functional genomic defects interfering with survival of -the affected embryo. - -Multifactorial disorders constitute a specific category of genetically- - -Page 3 of 12 - -determined disorders and anomalies caused by the combined effects -of environmental teratogens on defective or susceptible genetic -background. These disorders encompass some of the most common -and prevalent diseases among most populations like hypertension, -diabetes mellitus, and many types of cancer, many psychiatric disorders -and a very large variety of congenital malformations of nearly all body -organs like cleft lip/cleft palate, pyloric stenosis and multiple congenital -heart defects. - -Genetic systemic syndromes include diseases characterized by -affection of multiple organs, sometimes even many systems of the body. -Many single gene disorders and most chromosomal aberrations present -with widespread involvement of many organs and systems, systemic -genetic syndromes are not caused by either of these mechanisms. -Some of these disorders, however, might be caused by still undefined -single genes or by some other unknown mechanisms causing multiple -simultaneous functional deficiencies of many components of the -genome. Defective regulatory mechanisms exerted by microRNA -subclasses over many genes at the same time might be another possible -underlying factor that can be implicated in pathogenesis of these -systemic syndromes. - -Medical Pathogenetics - -The term pathogenetics has been coined to refer to mechanisms -involved in development of genetic diseases. It comprises study -of mutagens, study of mutations, study of different pathogenetic -mechanisms that result from disordered gene function secondary -to change of gene structure, study of pathophysiological alterations -in cellular functions due to disturbances of the metabolic-regulatory -networks that mediate and control these functions and, finally, the -study of pathogenesis of genetic diseases. - -Pathogenesis of genetic diseases - -Genetic diseases are caused by mutations. Mutations are defined -as uncoded or unprogrammed permanent structural alteration of the -genetic material affecting any of its organizational levels. These levels -comprise a wide range beginning with a whole nucleotide or just -part of it (base, sugar, phosphate), DNA, RNA, genes, chromosomes, -mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), up to the whole genome. This cause -and effect relationship between mutagens, mutations and genetic -disorders spans a very wide spectrum of different mechanisms that -follow a peculiar cascade of events beginning with mutation-induced -pathogenetic alterations of the genetic material, leading to disturbed -gene function and deficient or improper synthesis of gene products, -whether these products are proteins or small regulatory miRNA -biomolecules. The ensuing defects in functioning of the regulatory -and metabolic networks that control cellular activities result in -development of multiple and variable defect-specific pathophysiological -derangements that culminate in pathogenesis of genetic disease. - -Mutagens - -Mutagens are factors that can cause mutations. Mutagens are -plentiful in our life. In fact, we live and survive in a mutagenic world, -and probably with the exception of pure water, any compound in our -environment could be a potential mutagenic factor under favorable -circumstances. Mutagens can be classified according to their nature or -according to their recognizable pathogenetic and pathophysiological -effects on exposed cells. According to their nature, mutagens are -classified into four main categories: chemical mutagens, physical -mutagens, biological mutagens and changes of structural configuration -of bases of DNA and changes in energy states of bonds between these - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 4 of 12 - -bases [4]. Classification of mutagens based on their effects recognizes -four major groups: non-specific mutagens, carcinogens, clastogens and -teratogens (Table 2). - -Types of mutation - -Mutation might be classified to many different types according to -the parameters used for classification which include the nature, the -target, the magnitude and the effect of the mutational event, among -many other criteria (Table 3). The effects of mutation differ widely -according to many factors. These factors include the nature and -target of the mutagenic factor causing the mutation, the timing and -magnitude of the resulting damage, the genetic constitution of the -affected individual and the balance between synergistic mutagenic -effects and anti-mutation mechanisms of the genetic material. The -damaging effects of mutation are attributed to the defects they cause -in functioning of mutated genes. Since synthesis of proper gene -products, necessary for mediating cellular activities, depends primarily -on integrity of the genetic information embodied within the specific - -base sequence of the gene, changes or mutation of the exact number -or the peculiar arrangement of these bases is expected to result in -deficient or disturbed gene function. This disturbance might express -itself as production of structurally defective gene product, deficient -synthesis of enough product or disturbance in regulatory mechanisms -responsible for mediating, monitoring, harmonizing and controlling -gene functions. - -Somatic mutations refer to mutations of the genome of somatic -cells. The effects of somatic mutations depend on many factors -including the type of cell, the genetic constitution of affected cells, -selective targeting of nuclear and/or mitochondrial genome and the -mutation burden of the cell. According to the interactive processes -involving these factors, somatic mutations might result in cell death if -the mutation-induced pathophysiological alterations of the cell exceed -its ability to obviate and correct these alterations. Milder alterations can -cause deranged cellular function(s) and limited or progressive failure -and loss of cellular activities, e.g. progressive organ failure syndrome - -According to effect - -According to nature - -Examples - -1. Physical mutagens - -1.Particulate radiations: X- ray, -alpha particles, neutrons, positrons, -gamma rays, protons. -2. UV waves -3. Solar radiation & electromagnetic -waves -4. Thermal exposure -5. Mechanical agitation - -2. Chemical mutagens - -Organichydrocarbons, acridine -derivatives, manganese, nitrous -acid, hydroxylamine, base analogs, -sulfonate compounds, insecticides, -asbestos, herbicides, heavy metals. - -1. Carcinogens -Mutagens that induce malignant transformation and -development of cancer - -2. Clastogens -Mutagens that cause breakage of chromosomes - -3. Teratogens -Mutagens that cause congenital malformations in -developing embryos - -4. Non-specific mutagens -Mutagens that cause non-specific mutagenic damage to -the genetic material. - -Mechanisms and effects - -1. Breakage of nucleicacids -2. Chromosome breaks -3. Oxidation of deoxyribose -4. Formation of peroxides -5. Deamination of bases -6. Dehydroxylation of bases -7. Ionization and formation -of ion tracks/ion clusters -8. Generation of freeradicals -9. Provocation of carcinogenesis -10. Formation of pyrimidine dimers -11. Denaturation of DNA - -1. Base transition -2. Base transversion -3. Deamination of bases -4. Generation of free -radicals -5. Interruption of base -Sequence by intercalation -6. Provocation of -carcinogenesis -7. Cytopathic effects -following mitDNA -damage -8. Alkylation -9. Adduct formation - -3. Biological mutagens - -1. Viruses: rubella virus, -cytomegalovirus, HIV and herpes virus. -2. Toxoplasma gondii. - -1. Insertional mutagenesis -2. Provocation of carcinogenesis - -4. Change of bases/energy -States of bases of DNA - -Tautomerism, Hydration of bases - -Base transition - -5. Metabolic - derangements - -1. High acidity -2. Dehydration -3. Peroxidation - -Table 2: Classification of mutagens. - -Depurination of nucleic acids -Provocation of aberrant DNA replication. - -Classification of mutation - -1. Induced versus spontaneous mutation - -2. Nuclear versus mitochondrial mutation - -3. Somatic versus germinal mutation - -4. Static versus dynamic mutation - -5. Pathological versus non-pathological mutation - -6. Persistent versus reversible mutation - -7. Point, Small, Gross, Genomic mutation - -8. Base, Sugar, Phosphate group mutation - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - -Table 3: Classification of different types of mutation. - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -following overexposure to radiation. Somatic mutations affecting the -proto-oncogenes or genes regulating DNA repair systems can result in -malignant transformation of the cell and development of cancer. - -Germinal mutations, on the other hand, are mutations that -affect genomes of germinal cells that participate in fertilization -and determination of the genetic constitution of the offspring. If -the particular ovum or sperm affected by the mutation happens to -participate in fertilization and zygote formation, the mutation will be -inherited and transferred to all cells of the offspring, and a carrier or -disease state might result according to the nature of the mutated gene -and the pattern of its inheritance. - -Static mutations are mutations that are transferred to offspring -of carriers of these mutations without change. For instance, if a child -inherits the mutated gene causing, e.g. Marfan syndrome, from an -affected parent he will have the same mutation of the inherited gene in -his genome. Dynamic mutations, on the other hand, signify mutational -events that increase in magnitude upon transfer from carriers of these -mutations to their offspring. This type of mutation characterizes a large, -ever expanding number of widely varied peculiar groups of genetic -disorders collectively referred to as triplet repeat expansion disorders. -In this specific type of mutation, microsatellite repeats consisting of -certain number of codons, or triplets, of a parental gene increases in -number upon transfer to an offspring. If the increase, or expansion, -attains a certain threshold, the offspring becomes a carrier of the -dynamic mutation. Further transfer to offspring of next generations -results in much wider expansion, or pathological increase of the -number of the repeats in the gene leading to damage of gene structure -and interference with gene function, thus leading to development of -genetic disease due to this pathogenetic mechanism of triplet repeat -expansion. - -Fragile X mental retardation syndrome represents the prototype -of this category of genetic disorders due to triplet repeat expansion. -Normally, the FMR gene, existing on the terminal region of the long -arm of the X chromosome, regulates the synthesis of an important -protein necessary for functioning of many organs, including the brain. -In normal subjects, the gene has nearly 5-50 CGG repeats. Female -carriers of this gene in its mutated form have between 120 up to 200 -repeats, a state known as premutation state. Affected male offspring -of these carrier females have much larger numbers of these repeats, -more than 200 up to few hundreds, in their gene. This triplet repeat -expansion results in disruption of gene structure and interference -with gene function through different pathogenetic mechanisms, e.g. -chromosome instability or fragility, all ending in either suppression of -transcription and deficient synthesis of the gene product or synthesis of -defective product, thus leading to development of disease. Triplet repeat -expansion disorders comprise large number of diseases differing from -each other according to the mutated gene. Each of these diseases has -its specific repeat sequence and threshold number for its development. -For example, the triplet of Huntington disease and some types of -spinocerebellar ataxia is CAG while that of Friedreich ataxia is GAA. -In view of the specific nature of mutations of these diseases, they are -inherited in nontraditional way and account, at least in part, for the -phenomenon of genetic anticipation. - -Pathological versus non-pathological mutations: The deleterious -effects of mutation are determined by many factors. Mutations affecting -functional elements of the genome, i.e. functional genes, can result -in gene dysfunction causing deficient synthesis of the gene product -or synthesis of defective product. These mutations are expected to -cause pathophysiological changes and disease phenotypes in affected - -Page 5 of 12 - -individuals, and represent an overt example of harmful pathological -disease-causing mutations. On the other hand, mutations affecting -non-functional regions of the genome, e.g. intergenic areas of DNA -and intronic segments of genes, do not result in pathophysiological -alterations and are referred to as non-pathological mutations. - -The concept of protein domain and its relation to effects of -mutation - -The amino acids that constitute each protein are organized, both -structurally and functionally, into distinctive number of interrelated, -sometimes interactive, regions or domains. Each domain consists of a -defined number of certain amino acids arranged in a specific manner, -and performs a particular role either in shaping and maintaining the -structural configuration of the protein (structural domain), or in -mediating one or more of the biological function(s) of the protein -(functional domain). Each protein has its own specific structural -configuration as regards the number, the spatial arrangement and -distribution of its domains. In view of their fundamental role in -maintaining structural and functional integrity and identity of the -protein, protein domains are highly conserved among most species [5]. - -Mutation results in change(s) of one or more of the protein domains -depending on the type of the mutation, the magnitude of its effects and -the nature of the protein encoded by the mutated gene. If mutation -affects one or more or all of the amino acids constituting integral -structural and/or essential functional domain of the protein, deleterious -defects in protein function results. This pathogenetic mechanism -paves the way to significant detrimental effects on the functional -integrity of the protein. If the affected protein mediates specific roles -in cellular activities, e.g. structural components of cell organelles or -signal transducer in metabolic networks, pathophysiological alterations -secondary to loss of these roles ensue with consequent pathogenesis of -genetic disorder. Alternatively, depending on the nature, the effects, the -site and the magnitude of the causative pathogenetic mechanism, some -mutations might primarily affect non-critical or non-integral domains -of the protein. These mutations usually result in subtle conformational -changes, e.g. changes in the molecular weight or the electrophoretic -mobility of the protein that do not impede, or interfere with, the -physiological functions of the protein, and do not cause disease since -they do not significantly disturb the form-function relationship that -confers on each protein its biological potency. Thus, the effects of -genetic mutations are largely dependent on the resulting effects on the -structural integrity as well as the functional capability of the protein. -This fact clarifies, at least in part, the marked variability in potential of -genetic mutations in causing disease and explains absence of any disease -manifestations in spite of presence of mutation in many situations. - -Pathogenetic Mechanisms - -The genetic material controls life activities of the cell through -regulating synthesis of proteins which directly mediate these activities. -Regulatory genes, in addition, control the transcription of many -classes of small RNAs that have fundamental roles in direct and feed- -back regulation of most aspects of the genetic material. Mutations -cause structural alterations of the genetic material. Depending on the -site, nature, magnitude and effects of the mutational event as well as -on the functions and importance of the mutated genes, pathogenetic -mechanisms that result in deficient synthesis of gene products, synthesis -of defective gene products or disturbed regulation of cellular activities -will lead to development of genetic disorders, secondary to the ensuing -pathophysiological alterations of cellular functions. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -The spectrum of pathogenetic mechanisms and the resulting -pathophysiological disturbances that underlie the development of -genetic disorders is quite wide in view of the complexity of the structural -organization of the genome and the strict functional specialization that -characterizes each of its components. Additionally, the obscure nature -and unclear functions of many components of the genetic material, -undoubtedly, conceal many, still unknown, pathogenetic mechanisms -and hinder proper understanding of their exact pathways. It is hoped -that final completion of the human genome project might disclose -the exact and complete structural organization of the human genome. -However, a parallel human genome function project aiming at defining -the complete functional spectrum of the genome seems to be an -indispensable and imperative task in order to finalize our knowledge -of our genetic material. - -Currently defined pathogenetic mechanisms and pathophysiological -alterations implicated in pathogenesis of genetic disorders are too many -to be listed. However, the most common of these mechanisms include -the following: - -1. Loss/damage/duplication/inactivation of nuclear genes - -2. Mutation of mitochondrial genes (mitDNA) - -3. Deficient/defective DNA replication/repair - -4. Triplet repeat expansion disorders - -5. Loss/acquisition/damage/rearrangement of chromosomes - -6. Deficient transcription of mRNA - -7. Transcription of defective mRNA - -8. Deficient/defective post-transcription mRNA repair - -9. Deficient/defective post-transcription modifications of mRNA - -10. Deficient translation of proteins - -11. Translation of defective proteins - -12. Deficient/defective post-translation modification of proteins - -13. Deficient/defective post-translation - -repair of misfolded - -proteins - -14. Deficient/defective post-translation targeting and trafficking of - -proteins - -15. Deficient/defective regulation of cell growth - -16. Deficient/defective regulation of cell division - -17. Deficient/defective regulation of cell differentiation - -18. Deficient/defective regulation of cell migration - -19. Deficient/defective regulation of intercellular contact and cell - -movement - -20. Deficient/defective apoptosis/selection repair - -21. Deficient/defective -cytoskeleton - -regulation of cell architecture and - -22. Defective imprinting - -23. Deficient/defective regulation of cellular functions - -a. Deficient/defective - -transport across cell membrane or - -membranes of cell organelles (transport defects) - -Page 6 of 12 - -b. Deficient/defective transport across cell pores, nuclear pores or - -pores of cell organelles - -(chanellopathies) - -c. Deficient/defective secretion of gene products (protein/enzyme - -deficiency disorders) - -d. Deficient/defective disposal of metabolic waste products - -(storage disorders) - -e. Deficient/defective regulation of intra and inter network - -reactions and interactions: signal transduction disorders - -f. Deficient/defective positioning of structural proteins (protein - -trafficking disorders) - -g. Deficient/defective production of cellular energy: oxidative- - -phosphorylation disorders - -h. Ubiquitination/proteasome degradation defects - -i. Apoptosis defects - -Anti-mutation Mechanisms of the Human Genome - -The human genome develops, persists and works in a hostile -environment full of existing, and continuously generated, mutagens. -Mutational events induced by external mutagens have widespread -detrimental effects on the stability and integrity of the genome as well -as on the stability and integrity of the proteome. Additionally, further -and considerable damage of the structural organization and functional -capabilities of both the genome and the proteome regularly occurs on -continuous and progressive basis due to the continuously generated -burden of internal mutagens that result from the diverse metabolic -activities of the exceedingly large number of metabolic networks of -the cell. Unless a powerful and effective protective and repair system -actively participates in protecting the genome and proteome of the -cell against the deleterious effects of mutations, and in efficient repair -of resulting damage, maintaining the stability and integrity of both of -these bio-systems that constitute the framework of life activities within -the cell would have been quite impossible. - -The human genome is endowed with a spectacular multifaceted -strong anti-mutation system responsible for maintaining its stability -and integrity, as well as preserving its identity. It acts by protecting -the genome from the detrimental effects of mutation and by repairing -mutation-induced damage. Obviously, the balance between the -pathological effects of mutation and the ability of the anti-mutation -system to counteract and to reduce the consequences of these effects -represents the main factor that determines the likelihood of having -and developing mutation-induced genetic disease. The human anti- -mutation system comprises both innate mechanisms common to, -and shared by, all individuals, e.g. degeneracy of the genetic code, and -acquired aspects determined by the inherited genetic background of -each human being, e.g. DNA repair system (Table 4). - -Structural organization of the human genome - -The peculiar structural organization of the human genome -represents the first innate anti-mutation mechanism in view of the -presence of large interspersed portions of non-functional intragenic -introns and inter-genic DNA sequences and segments that can be -mutated without having appreciable deleterious functional effects. In -addition to functional sequences needed for synthesis of protein and of -regulatory small RNA species, the human genome has a considerable -amount of repetitive DNA sequences, including both noncoding - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 7 of 12 - -Mechanism - -Types and pathways and comments - -Structural features of DNA - -1. Structural organization of the genome - -1. Nuclear genome. -2. Mitochondrial genome - -2. Structural features of DNA - -3. Degeneracy of the genetic code - -Complementary strand stores genetic -information - -Multiple point mutations might occur -without affecting synthesized protein - -4. Nuclear localization of DNA - -Physical protection of nuclear genome - -5. DNA-associated proteins - -6. Replication proofreading system - -7. Genetic repair systems - -8. Protein repair systems - -9. Silencing of transposons by piwiRNA - -10. Antioxidant enzyme systems - -11. Apoptosis - -12. Melatonin - -1. Physical barriers -2. Biochemical buffers -3. Deactivating biomolecules -4. Modulation of charge transport -5. Limitation of DNA helix distortion - -Prophylactic pathway during DNA -replication - -A. Nuclear DNA repair -1. Base excision repair. -2. Nucleotide excision repair -3. Direct reversal repair. -4. Mismatch repair -5. Recombination repair -B. RNA repair/editing system -Post-transcription repair/editing of some -mRNA defects via guide RNA (gRNA)/ -editosome complex -C. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) repair - -Correction of post-translation protein -misfolding/aggregation by chaperones - -Reduces transposon-induced mutations -during development - -Prophylactic pathway against spread of -mutations of heavily or lethally mutated -genomes to daughter cells - -Anti-clastogenic, anti-mutagenic, -anti-carcinogenic and anti-oxidant -compound. - -Table 4: Anti-mutation mechanisms of the human genome. - -repetitive sequences and multiple copy genes and gene fragments, a -large number (19000-21000) of pseudogenes [6], a considerable sizable -portion (about 1/6th of the total genome size) as pyknons [7], a quite -large portion (nearly 40% of the total genome size) as transposons [8], -and large numbers of multiple copies of functional genes that share the -same regulatory function and whose suppression or damage by mutation -can be tolerated by other genes having the same function. These -peculiar structural features of the human genome allows for occurrence -of mutational events in many segments of the genome without having -appreciable functional defects. Even if some of these DNA sequences -have important roles in genome function, their presence in multiple -repetitive copies can greatly reduce, or even nullify, the consequences -of mutational damage. - - The mitochondrial genome - -The presence of multiple copies, hundreds to thousands, of -mitochondrial genes within the mitochondria of each cell is crucial -in obviating devastating mutation-induced damage to these vital -organelles in view of their role in production of ATP. This feature of -mitochondrial genome allows for considerable burden of mutations -to affect it before appreciable pathological consequences result. It is -estimated that mutations affecting nearly 80% of certain mitochondrial -genes might occur before pathological manifestations of mitochondrial -genetic diseases make their appearance due to this multiple copy feature -of mtDNA. - -DNA exists as a double stranded structure composed of two -tightly bound strands, each strand consisting of a sugar-phosphate -backbone with opposing nitrogenous bases each linked by a glycosidic -linkage to the sugar of its parent strand and by hydrogen bonds to the -complementary base on the opposing strand. This specific structural -organization of DNA serves many purposes. It stabilizes the dynamics -of the molecule, permits replication and duplication of the genetic -material, protects the interiorly located bases and, most importantly, -stores a template or copy of the genetic information ready for use -in case of damage of the other strand. If small or gross mutational -events affect important functional portions of the genetic material, -repair mechanisms can restore the exact sequence of the damaged or -lost or deleted parts through restoration mechanisms based on the -complementary information of the other strand. Mutations leading -to damage of corresponding segments of both strands represent a -catastrophic event to the genome due to absence of the sequence -database needed for the repair mechanism to define the exact base -sequence of the newly synthesized segment in place of the deleted or -grossly damaged segment. - -Degeneracy of the genetic code - -Degeneracy of the genetic code represents the third innate anti- -mutation mechanism of the human genome. This feature permits -the occurrence of same-sense point mutations in functional codons -without changing the amino acid defined by the mutated codon. Since -some amino acids, as part of a specific protein domain, play critical -roles in attaining and maintaining correct protein structure and -mediating proper protein function, mis-sense point mutations leading -to replacement of these essential amino acids by other amino acids -that can’t perform the functions of the original amino acids might -result in detrimental effects on the structural integrity and stability of -the protein followed by deleterious consequences on its physiological -function. Hence, degeneracy of the genetic code allows for occurrence -of many point mutations, the commonest type of mutational events -and the commonest cause of genetic disorders, without changing the -final structure of the synthesized protein, thus protecting against, and -obviating, the pathological effects of these mutations. - -Nuclear localization of DNA - -The localization of DNA, deeply inside the cell nucleus, represents -a fourth innate anti-mutation mechanism of the human genome -because it acts as a physical barrier against many mutagens that have -to overcome many obstacles of cellular defense mechanisms in order -to affect the nuclear genome. These defenses include the extra-cellular -environment, the cell membrane, the cytoplasmic, the cytoplasmic -enzymes and phagocytic cellular organelles and the cytoplasmic and -nuclear antioxidant enzyme systems. The DNA-associated or DNA- -binding proteins, in addition to their essential roles in regulating -transcriptional processes of most genes, also play fundamental roles in -protecting the DNA from the damaging effects of many mutagens, in -particular the free radicals that are generated during metabolic activities -of the cell. They act as firm physical barriers and strong biochemical -buffers that effectively modify and deactivate biomolecules of many -chemical mutagens or damaging factors that might harm the DNA. -They mediate this protective role through many mechanisms including -modulation of charge transport of oxidative agents within the DNA, -limitation of DNA helix distortion and regulation of protein-dependent -alterations in DNA base stacking [9]. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -RNA-proofreading System - -The human transcriptome, being subjected to the same mutational -events that can alter and damage the DNA, seems to have efficient anti- -mutation mechanisms to guard against occurrence of errors during -RNA transcription and to correct and repair some post-transcription -defects of mRNA that can cause errors during protein translation. -Separate RNA-proofreading system seems to exist and act, probably, -during transcription by relying on the sequence complementarity -information of the complementary silent or non-transcribing strand of -DNA, rather than of the active transcribing strand. This behavior can -be interpreted, partly, by classic principles of thermodynamics because -relying on the sequence of the energetically active, transiently unstable, -strand to ensure accurate transcription might result in improper -defective transcription if mismatch errors occur due to, e.g. polymerase -dysfunction. The risk of faulty transcription depending on the sequence -complementarity information of the less energetic, more stable, non- -transcribing strand is, probably, less than comparable risk expected -to occur if transcription depends on the sequence complementarity -information of the active strand. This assumption might, partly, offer -reasonable explanation for the poorly understandable behavior of -gene function where transcription of complementary mRNA, instead -of straightforward synthesis of identical mRNA transcript, is the rule. -It might also explain the seemingly needless, indirect and energy -consuming processes involving transcription of complementary, rather -than identical, mRNA transcripts that have to be decoded again by -rRNA and tRNA in the ribosome during translation. Expenditure of -energy for keeping transcriptome integrity is consistent with general -rules of thermodynamics since maintaining stability of any structured -system is dependent on the equilibrium between its natural tendency to -degrade and external energy supply needed to keep it in a stable form. - -Replication proofreading system - -Preservation of genomic identity of the organism depends -exclusively on accurate replication and synthesis of two identical copies -of the genome during cell division, followed by transfer, or inheritance, -of each copy to each daughter cell. In this manner, all cells descendent -from a parent cell have nuclear genomes identical to that of the parent -cell. The majority of spontaneous point mutations of the nuclear genome -are prone to occur during cell division, mostly during DNA synthesis -or the replication phase of the process. The replication proofreading -system acts in a prophylactic way to ensure accurate insertion or -addition of the proper nucleotide to the newly synthesized strand of -replicating DNA. This prophylactic function is fundamental to reduce -the rate of inevitable replication mistakes to minimum levels that could -be dealt with efficiently with the DNA repair mechanisms. In spite of -the impressively fast and accurate ability of the enzymes responsible -for DNA synthesis, DNA polymerases, most of them have additional -proofreading ability to ensure accurate error-free DNA replication and, -hence, maintaining and preserving the stability, integrity and identity of -the genome during cell division, as well as during transfer of the genetic -material from parents to offspring. - -Genetic repair systems - -Genetic repair systems responsible for correcting and repairing -many different types of point and small mutations comprise both -nuclear DNA repair system and mitochondrial DNA repair system. -Genetic function and genetic repair represent two sides of the same -coin. Without the persevering continuous, active and effective -surveillance exerted by the genetic repair systems to detect and repair -the continuously and persistently occurring mutations, maintaining - -Page 8 of 12 - -stability and integrity of the genome would be an impossible task. These -repair systems act via many different mechanisms according to the type, -location and magnitude of damage induced in the genetic material [10]. - -The pivotal role played by the mitochondrial genome in generating -ATP, without which life can neither begin nor persist, in addition to the -many other critical metabolic and regulatory functions of mitochondrial -genes, requires the presence of an efficient system for repairing mtDNA -mutations. The need for mitochondrial genome repair system is further -imposed on the cell in view of the high mutation rate of mitochondrial -genes which lack many of the anti-mutation and protective mechanisms -available to nuclear genes. Similar to the nuclear genome repair system, -mitochondrial repair system includes many repair pathways and -mechanisms: base excision repair, direct reversal repair, mismatch -repair, and recombination repair. Nucleotide excision repair (NER) -pathway, however, seems not to be working in the mitochondria [11]. - -RNA repair/editing system - -RNA editing refers to molecular modifications of nucleotides of -RNA through chemical changes in the base makeup of the molecule. -Such changes appear to involve mRNA, tRNA as well as many types -of small or microRNA. RNA editing occurs in the cell nucleus and -the cytosol, as well as in mitochondria and is mediated by a complex -repair system comprising many species of small RNA (guide RNA) and -large protein complexes known as the editosomes. The pathways and -mechanisms of RNA editing include many diverse processes: nucleoside -base modifications such as cytidine (C) to uridine (U) and adenosine -(A) to inosine (I) deamination, as well as non-templated insertions of -nucleotide. RNA editing in mRNAs effectively alters the amino acid -sequence of the encoded protein so that it differs from that predicted by -the genomic DNA sequence. Though mRNA editing is used by the cell -in many instances to allow for synthesis of more than one protein from -the same mRNA transcript, e.g. synthesis of both apolipoprotein B-100 -and apolipoprotein B-48 from the same mRNA in liver cells, it can also -be used to repair missense or termination mutations of the molecule -which can have deleterious effects on the synthesized protein. Specific -endonucleases and ligases for double stranded species of RNA have -been defined in many prokaryotes [12] and it might be just a matter of -time before defining their functional counterparts in eukaryotes and -human cells. - -Protein repair systems - -Accurate post-translation structural configuration of newly -synthesized polypeptide chains is a fundamental conformational -modification for most proteins to become functionally active -biomolecules. The maturation from primary to quaternary protein -structure involves many changes, e.g. folding and maintenance of -steric and spatial relationships between the different domains of -the protein. Conformational defects in proteins that might happen -during these modifications can lead to formation of misfolded and/or -aggregated non-functional molecules. The human genome comprises -a large number of genes that code a complex system composed of -large numbers of specific protein families and subfamilies known -as molecular chaperones. These proteins have many important and -diverse functions in cellular activities, e.g. assisting non-covalent -folding or unfolding and assembly or disassembly of macromolecular -structures, including proteins. Prevention of misfolding and/or -aggregation of newly synthesized polypeptide chains, which turn -them to nonfunctional biomolecules, is a major and fundamental -function of molecular chaperones. Other physiological functions of -chaperones include: transport across mitochondrial membranes and - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -the endoplasmic reticulum and assistance in protein degradation -[13]. - -Molecular chaperones, probably, exert critical roles in maintaining -stability and integrity of the proteome. This state of protein homeostasis, -proteostasis, is a prerequisite for proper control and regulation of -cellular metabolic networks by proteins and is mandatory for efficient -mediation of cellular activities. Specific species of molecular chaperones, -surveillance chaperones, are responsible for constant surveillance of the -proteome to ensure proper protein homeostasis. Age-related decline or -mutation-induced defects in proteome stability and integrity results in -progressive aggregation and faulty conformational changes of proteins, -both of which are associated with, and underlie, the development -and pathogenesis of many genetic diseases like Alzheimer disease, -Parkinson disease, prion diseases and many others [14]. - -Silencing of transposon activity during development - -Transposons constitute a considerable portion, nearly 40%, of the -human nuclear genome. Transposon activities might have contradictory -effects on the stability and integrity of the nuclear genome. They -might behave in a harmful way and act as major potential causes of -spontaneous mutations of the nuclear genome. They can make a copy of -themselves and insert the new copy in another site, or they can detach -themselves from their location and get inserted at different sites of -the genome. In both conditions they result in insertional mutagenesis -with consequent deleterious effects on genomic stability and genomic -integrity. If they get inserted in a functional segment of the genome they -lead to structural disruption and loss of function of the affected segment -with resultant pathological effects. Hence, over activity or uncontrolled -activity of transposons can have detrimental and devastating effects -on embryogenesis, differentiation and development, and can lead to -pathogenesis of a wide variety of congenital malformations and genetic -defects [8]. The human genome, however, has a unique control system -composed of a specific subtype of small or micro RNA molecules, known -as piwiRNA, or piRNA, composed of RNA-piwi protein complexes. -They are thought to be involved in gene silencing, most specifically -the silencing of transposons. The majority of piRNAs are antisense to -transposon sequences suggesting that transposons are the main target -of piRNA. In mammals, the marked activity of piRNAs in silencing of -transposons and control of their activities is most important during -the development of the embryo in order to reduce the rate and risk of -transposon-induced mutations during this sensitive period of life [15]. - -Alternatively, transposon activity may lead to creation and -construction of new genetic combinations that may have specific -functions. Within this context, they would be considered as one of -the genetic biological mechanisms involved in, and responsible for, -evolutionary diversity of the genome and the proteome. They can also -cause tangible increases in the amount of the genetic material due to -recurrent synthesis and addition of multiple new copies of transposable -elements to the nuclear genome. - -Antioxidant enzyme systems - -The continuous functioning of the exceedingly huge number of -metabolic networks that mediate cellular activities in living cells results -in continuous generation of many different types of useful as well as -of harmful metabolic by-products. Oxidant free radicals constitute one -of the most crucial categories of these harmful by-products in view of -their ability to induce widespread damage in many cellular components -including membranes, organelles and structural macromolecules like -lipids and proteins. This structural damage, unless counteracted by - -Page 9 of 12 - -opposing antioxidant mechanisms, results in progressive degradation -of cellular constituents with consequent resultant pathophysiological -alterations of cellular functions, leading ultimately to disease. Although -low concentrations of reactive oxygen species may be beneficial, or -even necessary in mediating many important cellular processes, e.g. -defense against invading micro-organisms and intracellular signaling -pathways, nevertheless, higher concentrations of these free radicals play -a causative role in the aging process as well as in pathogenesis of many -human diseases, including immune deficiency, neurodegeneration and -malignancy. Oxidative damage of DNA, RNA and binding proteins by -free radicals represents an important category of detrimental genetic -mutations induced by endogenous chemical mutagens inevitably -generated during cellular metabolic activities and other cellular -functions. Living cells have several efficient non-enzymatic and -enzymatic antioxidant activities that are responsible for eliminating -and/or terminating the chain reactions following generation of free -radicals, as a safeguard against their damaging effects on cellular -components and cellular functions. Enzymatic antioxidant systems of -the cell comprise many different types of antioxidant enzymes, notably -superoxide dismutase, catalase, thioredoxinreductase, glutathione -peroxidase and various other peroxidases. Efficient production of -these antioxidant enzymes and proper regulation of their functions -is mandatory to protect both the genome and proteome and to keep -and maintain redox homeostasis of the cytoplasm which is a critical -requirement for normal mediation of cellular activities [16]. - -Apoptosis - -Apoptosis refers to programmed cell death and represents a universal -biological behavior of most living cells necessary, in conjunction -with other life-regulating mechanisms, for maintaining the vital -balance between life and death that governs optimal life conditions of -multicellular organisms. Apoptosis plays fundamental and crucial roles -in normal growth and development as well as in normal differentiation -and determination of the proper final structural architecture of cells, -tissues and organs. Faulty timing or incorrect accomplishment of -specific and selective apoptotic processes during specific life stages of -the cell might result in devastating consequences on cellular functions -that range from dysfunction to malformation. For instance, improper -regulation of apoptosis during embryonic and fetal life can lead to the -development of many types of congenital malformations. In many -conditions, it might ultimately culminate in pathogenesis of disease or -in premature cell death [17]. - -Apoptosis plays a crucial role in maintaining genomic stability -and integrity, not of individual cells, but of the organism as a whole. -Induction of apoptotic mechanisms in heavily mutated or lethally -mutated cells leads to death of the cell and prevents transfer of these -mutations to its putative descendant daughter cells. This fundamental -prophylactic anti-mutation role of apoptosis in cellular activities and -life prospects of living organisms has more far-reaching effects on many -important aspects related to the balance between, and the incidence -of, normal and mutant genotypes within species-specific gene pools. -Additionally, apoptosis can affect in an appreciable manner genomic -identity of living organisms because mutation-induced evolutionary or -decadence pathways are largely dependent on the outcome of certain -apoptotic mechanisms operating during certain stages of the cell cycle. - -Apoptosis may be looked at as a special genomic protective -pathway involving compulsory death of somatic cells overburdened -with mutation. Over mutated cells are driven to their ends through -specific apoptosis-mediating pathways to protect other cells from the -hazardous risks of their malignant transformation. Apoptosis might, - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -also, represent a cellular economic adaptation behavior by getting rid -of mutated, diseased, energy consuming and non-functioning harmful -cells. In this way, it performs important protective anti-mutation -mechanism to maintain genomic integrity through executing and -getting rid of heavily mutated cells, to prevent spread of their mutations, -through division, to daughter generations. - -Melatonin - -Melatonin is a hormone synthesized by the pineal gland, bone -marrow cells, epithelial cells and lymphocytes. Melatonin receptors are -distributed in most organs, a finding reflecting its widespread roles in -regulating various physiological and psychological processes. Many in -vitro and animal studies revealed that melatonin has diverse functions -including effective protection of cells against radiation-induced -chromosome breakage and inhibition of tumor development in -animals exposed to experimental chemical carcinogenesis. Melatonin -was shown to have protective effect against oxidative DNA damage by -chemical inactivation of DNA-damaging agent as well as by stimulating -DNA repair mechanisms. These important anti-mutagenic and anti- -clastogenic effects of melatonin can be linked with its ability to protect -DNA against oxidative damage. It may exert this antioxidant action -by eliminating harmful reactive oxygen radicals or by stimulating the -repair processes of oxidative stress-induced damage of DNA [18]. - -Patterns of Inheritance - -The specific patterns of inheritance of genetic diseases describe -the characteristic features which outline, control and regulate the -transmission of genetic diseases from normal, carrier or affected -parents to their offspring. These features vary widely according to the -actions and interactions of many factors in addition to many other -modifying conditions. - -Genetic diseases are inherited in many different way depending -on many variable factors that include the cause of the genetic defect -whether due to single gene disorder, polygenic disorder, mitochondrial -mutation, chromosomal aberration or multifactorial causation, the -gene locus whether it lies on an autosome or on a sex chromosome, -the nature of the gene product whether it is a structural protein or a -catalytic enzyme, the nature of the underlying mutational event whether -it is a static or a dynamic mutation, the status of the transmitting -parent(s), the causative pathogenetic mechanism(s) underlying the -development of the disease and whether this transmission happens in a -classic traditional manner or within the context of an abnormal genetic -framework [19-22]. However, two major patterns of inheritance of -genetic diseases could be recognized: classic, Mendelian or traditional -patterns that characterize rules of inheritance of single gene disorders, - -Traditional patterns of inheritance Non-traditional patterns of inheritance - -1. Autosomal dominant inheritance - -1. Inheritance of mitochondrial disorders - -2. Autosomal recessive inheritance - -2. Inheritance of chromosomal -abnormalities - -3. X-linked dominant inheritance - -3. Inheritance of multifactorial diseases - -4. X-linked recessive inheritance - -4. Inheritance of triplet repeat expansion -disorders - -5. Y-linked inheritance - -5. Uniparentaldisomy - -6. Inheritance of microdeletion/ -microduplication defects - -7. Genetic imprinting - -8. Gonadal Mosaicism - -Table 5: Patterns of inheritance of genetic disorders. - -Page 10 of 12 - -and non-classic, non-mendelian or non-traditional patterns that -delineate features of inheritance of other types of genetic diseases -(Table 5) [23]. - -The locus of the mutant gene defines four different categories of -single gene disorders each having its own specific pattern of inheritance: -autosomal diseases caused by genes located on the autosomes, -X-linked diseases caused by genes located on the X chromosome, -Y-linked diseases caused by genes located on the Y chromosome and -mitochondrial disorders caused by mutations of mitochondrial genes. - -The status of the transmitting parent, or both parents, determines -many different aspects of the pattern(s) of inheritance of the disease. -For single gene disorders, five main patterns of inheritance based -on the way of transmission of the single mutant gene relative to the -status of the transmitting parent(s) are recognized. These patterns -include: autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, X-linked dominant, -X-linked recessive and Y-linked inheritance patterns. - -For human traits and diseases, dominance refers to the ability of the -mutant gene to confer a specific phenotype on the individual harboring -it when present in a single copy or allele. Recessive genes need to exist -in two copies, or alleles, in order that a specific recessive disease or -trait phenotype can show up. The difference between dominant and -recessive diseases can be attributed, in part, to the different underlying -pathogenetic mechanisms and might be explained in view of the specific -pathological characteristics of each type since dominant diseases result, -mostly, from deficient and/or defective production of structural proteins -produced by mutant genes. These structural proteins are vital integral -constituents of nearly all cellular components, e.g. cell membranes, -cytoskeleton, cell organelles, spindle apparatus, chromatin material and -mitochondrial components. In autosomal dominant (AD) diseases, -nearly 50% reduction in amount or functions of structural proteins -happens which represents a drastic burden that can’t be tolerated by the -cell, hence the expression of the disease phenotype in heterozygotes of -AD genes. Autosomal recessive diseases, on the other hand, comprise -a majority of genetic diseases resulting mostly from deficient and/or -defective production of proteins that act as enzymes rather than as -structural proteins, e.g. inborn errors of metabolism. Enzyme dynamics -allow for prolonged and sustained mediation of recurring metabolic -reactions by small amounts of the enzyme, sometimes as low as 5% of -the amount needed under normal physiological conditions. Hence, for -an autosomal recessive (AR) disorder to be expressed in an affected -patient, mutation of both parental genes is required, thus necessitating -a heterozygous disease status of both parents, except for exceptional -abnormal conditions like, for instance, uniparentaldisomy where both -homologous chromosomes are inherited from the same parent. - -Clinical Genetics - -Clinical genetics implies the application of concepts of basic genetic -knowledge in managing patients and carriers of genetic diseases -[24,25]. The prime challenge in clinical genetics practice is to attain -accurate diagnosis of the genetic disease. In many cases, the diagnosis -might be straightforward due to pathognomonic clinical phenotypes, -in others it can be confirmed via specific diagnostic investigations, e.g. -cytogenetic studies for chromosomal abnormalities, mutation analysis -for single gene disorders and biochemical assays for metabolic errors. -Unfortunately, in much more cases, accurate diagnosis of genetic -diseases represents a real challenge due to many factors headed by -lack of sufficient information regarding the structure and functions -of the human genome and human proteome. Proper diagnosis is not -only important for defining effective therapeutic and/or prophylactic - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -measures, but it is also crucial for offering accurate counseling advice to -patients as well as to their concerned family members. - -Clinical classification of genetic disorders delineates five major -distinct disease categories: chromosomal aberrations, congenital -malformations, in born errors of metabolism, mitochondrial disorders -and systemic genetic syndromes, in addition to system-specific or -organ-specific diseases affecting specific systems or individual organs, -even specific cell lines, of the body. Within each of these categories, -the defect might be sporadic affecting only the index case or it might -be familiar when multiple family members are similarly affected with -the disease. Isolated genetic defects refer to single tissue/organ/system -affection without affection of any other parts, e.g. cardiomyopathy, -retinitis pigmentosum or polydactyly. Conversely, systemic genetic -disorders affect multiple organs/systems, e.g. Marfan syndrome. -Chromosomal aberrations have, in most cases, widespread affection of -many, sometimes most body parts due to involvement of large numbers -of genes in their causation. The same applies also to most mitochondrial -disorders and congenital malformations. However, some malformations -are isolated anomalies affecting only single organ or localized part of -the fetus, like the heart in isolated congenital heart disease. Similarly, -multifactorial diseases caused by the mutational pathogenetic effect(s) -of environmental teratogens on a susceptible genetic background -might be isolated defects, e.g. pyloric stenosis and cleft lip or palate, -or present with multiple organ/system affection like syndromes caused -by teratogenic drugs and syndromes caused by intrauterine infections. - -Clinical diagnosis of genetic diseases proceeds along the same -traditional protocols followed in other medical specialties that -comprise history taking, examination and diagnostic investigations. -History taking is very important in clinical practice and nowhere is this -illustrated more clearly than in clinical genetics. In many genetically- -determined disorders like congenital malformations, history taking -must be dated back to prenatal, sometimes to preconception or even -to premarital history of the mother or of both parents. Other aspects of -history crucial for establishment of proper diagnosis of many types of -genetic diseases include perinatal, neonatal, developmental history and -family history of similar or related diseases. - -Laboratory diagnosis of genetic diseases is currently achieved -through large panel of investigations. Some of these investigations -are specific for genetically-determined disorders like cytogenetic -investigations for chromosomal abnormalities, biochemical assays -for inborn errors of metabolism and molecular mutation analysis for -nuclear and mitochondrial single gene disorders. A large panel of -conventional investigations complements classic genetic diagnostic -approaches and represents an indispensable supplementary diagnostic -techniques needed for detecting pathological defects associated -with genetic diseases. These conventional diagnostic techniques -include, for instance, radio-imaging and ultrasonographic studies, -electro-physiological investigations, histopathological examinations, -biochemical assays, and many others. - -Treatment of genetic diseases aims primarily at alleviating -sufferings of patients and avoiding development of complications. -With the exception of surgically correctable congenital malformations, -genetic diseases are considered as incurablein view of presence of -the underlying inherited defect in all cells of the body. However, the -wide spectrum of currently available therapeutic and prophylactic -approaches can provide appreciable, sometimes effective, improvement -for large numbers of patients affected with varying categories of genetic -disorders. These effective management approaches comprise, mostly, -conventional measures like drug therapy, nutritional manipulation, - -Page 11 of 12 - -enzyme replacement, organ transplantation and surgical intervention. -Though genetic therapies for genetic diseases represent the ultimate -hope of curing these defects, they are still in the experimental stage -because of lack of comprehensive knowledge of the human genome. -These genetic therapies include single gene therapy trials where a normal -gene is intended to be inserted via viral vectors, or some other vectors, -into the nuclear genome to replace deficient or defective function of a -disease gene, and whole genome therapy trials like stem cell therapy. -Other promising genetic therapies include myriads of approaches -targeting all pathogenetic mechanisms and biomolecules involved -in pathogenesis of genetic disorders, e.g. mRNA and micro RNA, -translated and regulatory proteins, cell organelles, cell membranes and -intercellular compartments. Examples of genetic therapies include use of -interfering miRNA molecules or antisense oligonucleotides to suppress -translation of harmful proteins, e.g. oncoproteins of tumor cells and -the use of engineered chaperone proteins to correct some misfolding -defects of translated proteins resulting from defective post-translation -modifications of normally synthesized proteins. In fact, the list of newly -invented therapeutic and alleviating measures for genetic disorders is -continuously expanding quite rapidly, and it is hoped that gradual and -complete cure of considerable proportion of genetic defects would be -attained the more we know about the actual regulatory mechanisms -that maintain the structural and functional integrity of the human -genome. Prophylactic genetics represents a revolutionary approach -in management of some types of genetic defects by preventing their -occurrence through certain techniques, e.g. pre-implantation diagnosis, -where carrier couples heterozygous for autosomal recessive single gene -disorders are subjected to in vitro fertilization and mutation analysis -of DNA extracted from one cell of each embryo followed by selection -and intrauterine implantation of normal embryos only. Anticipation -of possible health hazards, based on the genotype of patients/carriers -or the family history, allows for implementing specific prophylactic -measures to avoid expected complications and to alleviate possible -consequences, and represents an essential aspect in management -of patients with genetic diseases and carriers of mutant genes. This -approach constitutes the cornerstone of prophylactic genetics. It also -paves the way towards invention of effective prophylactic techniques -based on detailed knowledge of the pathogenetic mechanisms and -pathophysiological alterations underlying the development of genetic -defects. The purposeful use of genetic knowledge and databases for -prophylactic, diagnostic and therapeutic purposes, and in other related -health and disease states, is a major achievement and represents the -main framework of applied genetics. These applications include many -important fields like genetic counseling, genetic screening (newborn -screening and carrier screening), forensic genetics, genetic engineering, -prenatal diagnosis, fetal therapy and genetic registries. Genetic registry -databases, whether disease-specific or population-specific, represent -essential requirements indispensable for many purposes, headed by -their use in planning of health strategies aiming at establishing effective -prophylactic measures and efficient diagnostic techniques for specific/ -common genetic disorders in populations, particularly closed or -isolated populations with high rates of consanguineous marriages and -increased prevalence of single gene disorders. Additionally, constructed -genetic registry databases represent the main resources of plans aiming -at elimination of certain lethal/disease genes from the gene pool -of isolated populations. This approach represents one of the major -concepts and prime aims of eugenics. - -References - -1. Hatzimanikatis V, Li C, Ionita JA, Broadbelt LJ (2004) Metabolic networks: -enzyme function and metabolite structure. Curr Opin Struct Biol 14: 300-306. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 12 of 12 - -2. Cheng J, Torkamani A, Peng Y, Jones TM, Lerner RA (2012) Plasma membrane -associated transcription of cytoplasmic DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 109: -10827-10831. - -14. Hartl FU, Bracher A, Hayer-Hartl M (2011) Molecular chaperones in protein - -folding and proteostasis. Nature 475: 324-332. - -15. Malone CD, Hannon GJ (2009) Small RNAs as guardians of the genome. Cell - -3. Li M, Wang IX, Li Y, Bruzel A, Richards AL, et al. (2011) Widespread RNA and -DNA sequence differences in the human transcriptome. Science 333: 53-58. - -4. - -Irwin H Herskowitz (1977) Principles of genetics. (2ndedn), Collier Macmillan -International Editions. - -136: 656-668. - -16. Valko M, Leibfritz D, Moncol J, Cronin MT, Mazur M, et al. (2007) Free radicals -and antioxidants in normal physiological functions and human disease. Int J -Biochem Cell Biol 39: 44-84. - -5. Richardson JS (1981) The anatomy and taxonomy of protein structure. Adv - -Protein Chem 34: 167-339. - -17. Douglas R Green (2010) Means to an End: Apoptosis and other cell death - -mechanisms. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press. - -6. Balakirev ES, Ayala FJ (2003) Pseudogenes: are they “junk” or functional - -DNA? Annu Rev Genet 37: 123-151. - -7. Glinsky GV (2009) Human genome connectivity code links disease-associated - -SNPs, microRNAs and pyknons. Cell Cycle 8: 925-930. - -8. Kunarso G, Chia NY, Jeyakani J, Hwang C, Lu X, et al. (2010) Transposable -elements have rewired the core regulatory network of human embryonic stem -cells. Nat Genet 42: 631-634. - -9. Rajski SR, Barton JK (2001) How different DNA-binding proteins affect long- - -range oxidative damage to DNA. Biochemistry 40: 5556-5564. - -10. Morita R, Nakane S, Shimada A, Inoue M, Iino H, et al. (2010) Molecular -mechanisms of the whole DNA repair system: a comparison of bacterial and -eukaryotic systems. J Nucleic Acids 2010: 179594. - -11. Gredilla R (2010) DNA damage and base excision repair in mitochondria and - -their role in aging. J Aging Res 2011: 257093. - -12. Price DH, Gray MW (1998) Editing of tRNA. In: Modification and Editing of - -RNA. Grosjean H, Benne R (Eds.). ASM Press, Washington, DC pp: 289-306. - -13. Pearl LH, Prodromou C (2006) Structure and mechanism of the Hsp90 - -molecular chaperone machinery. Annu Rev Biochem 75: 271-294. - -18. Sliwinski T, Rozej W, Morawiec-Bajda A, Morawiec Z, Reiter R, et al. (2007) -Protective action of melatonin against oxidative DNA damage: chemical -inactivation versus base-excision repair. Mutat Res 634: 220-227. - -19. Benjamin Pierce (2005) Genetics. A conceptual approach. (2ndedn), W.H. - -Freeman & company, Gordonsville, VA, USA. - -20. Dale Jeremy, Park Simon F (2010) Molecular genetics of bacteria. (5thedn), - -John Wiley & Sons Ltd. - -21. Griffiths JF (2007) Anthony Introduction to genetic analysis. 9th edition. W.H. - -Freeman & company, Gordonsville, VA, USA - -22. Eberhard Passarge (2007) Color atlas of genetics. (3rdedn), Thieme Stuttgart, - -New York. - -23. Jack J Pasternak (2005) An Introduction to Human Molecular Genetics: -Mechanisms of Inherited Diseases. (2ndedn), John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, -NJ, USA - -24. Rédei GP (2008) Encyclopedia of genetics, genomics, proteomics and - -informatics. (3rdedn), New Springer York, USA. - -25. Watson James, Tania Baker, Stephen Bell, Alexander Gann, Michael Levine, et -al. (2004) Molecular Biology of the Gene. (5thedn), Benjamin Cummings Menlo -Park, California, USA. - -Human Genet Embryol - - Medical Genetics - -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal +discussion—one way or the other—about whether, by pleading, +Edwards would forfeit his right to appeal the earlier denial of his +suppression motion. Edwards pleaded guilty, and the judge found +that his plea was “entered into freely and voluntarily with a know- +ing, intelligent waiver of [his] rights.” Tr. of Change of Plea at +18:20–22, Dkt. No. 105. + +In computing Edwards’s offense level for sentencing pur- +poses, the presentence investigation report applied an enhance- +ment pursuant to U.S.S.G. § 4B1.4(a), which states that “[a] defend- +ant who is subject to an enhanced sentence under the provisions of +18 U.S.C. § 924(e) is an armed career criminal.” Section 924(e), the +Armed Career Criminal Act, in turn prescribes a mandatory mini- +mum 15-year sentence for anyone who violates § 922(g) and “has +three previous convictions” for “violent felon[ies] or . . . serious +drug offense[s], or both, committed on occasions different from +one another.” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e). In particular, Edwards’s PSI +listed the same three predicate convictions as had his factual prof- +fer: + +The defendant is an armed career criminal because he +is subject to an enhanced sentence under the provi- +sions of 18 U.S.C. § 924(e), pursuant to § 4B1.4(a). +The defendant has the prior felony convictions as +noted in docket numbers 10-022573CF110A [i.e., for +trafficking in oxycodone], 10-022679CF10A [i.e., for +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon], and 97- +000465CF10B [i.e., +for robbery with a deadly +weapon/aggravated battery]. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 5 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +5 + +PSI ¶ 20. With the ACCA enhancement, Edwards’s statutory min- +imum term of imprisonment was 15 years, so the PSI increased the +low end of Edwards’s range from 168 months to 180 months in +prison. Edwards didn’t object to the PSI’s recommended sen- +tence.2 + +At the sentencing hearing, the district judge noted that the +PSI’s recommended sentence reflected an ACCA-enhanced 15-year +mandatory minimum, and Edwards agreed to it. The judge there- +fore imposed a sentence of 180 months in prison, followed by a +two-year term of supervised release. Again, Edwards didn’t object. + +During the sentencing hearing, Edwards’s lawyer asked the +judge to appoint separate counsel to appeal the earlier denial of the +motion to suppress the handgun evidence. Seemingly in an effort +to recall the nature of Edwards’s plea, which Edwards had entered +several months earlier, the judge asked the lawyers whether there +was a formal agreement. After Edwards’s counsel explained that +he didn’t “remember there being an appellate waiver,” the judge +suggested that because “the plea agreement . . . does not mention +an appellate waiver,” Edwards had “the right . . . to take an appeal” + +2 Edwards made two factual objections to the PSI—both are unrelated to this +appeal. See Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 3:20–25, Dkt. No. 106 (“[Defense Coun- +sel]: There were two very minor—they’re not even—they don’t even affect +his guidelines—two minor objections, I would say, to the PSI, and they’re mi- +nor in and of itself. That’s about it. Other than that, we’re just asking for the +Court to sentence him to 15 years and we all go about our business.”). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 6 of 27 + +6 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +of the suppression ruling. Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 24:18–22, Dkt. +No. 106. + +Edwards subsequently filed a notice of appeal indicating his +intent to seek review of the denial of the suppression motion. The +district court granted Edwards’s lawyer’s motion to withdraw and +assigned new counsel, who filed an amended notice of appeal. + +II + +Before us, Edwards challenges his conviction and 180-month +sentence on three grounds: He argues (1) that his guilty plea wasn’t +knowing and voluntary because he didn’t realize that by pleading +he would waive his right to appeal the district court’s denial of his +suppression motion; (2) that the district court erred in enhancing +his sentence under ACCA because the government didn’t prove, as +required by Erlinger v. United States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), that his +predicate offenses occurred on different occasions; and (3) that +§ 922(g)(1) exceeds Congress’s Commerce Clause power. We will +address each issue in turn. + +A + +First up, the voluntariness of Edwards’s plea. When, as here, +a defendant fails to object during his plea colloquy, we review the +district court’s determination that his plea was knowing and volun- +tary only for plain error. See United States v. Monroe, 353 F.3d 1346, +1349 (11th Cir. 2003) (citing United States v. Vonn, 535 U.S. 55, 59 +(2002)). “To establish plain error, a defendant must show that (1) +there was an error, (2) the error was plain, and (3) the error affects +substantial rights.” United States v. Roosevelt Coats, 8 F.4th 1228, 1235 + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 7 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +7 + +(11th Cir. 2021). An error about the voluntariness of a plea affects +a defendant’s “substantial rights” if he shows a reasonable proba- +bility that the error influenced his “‘decision to plead.’” United +States v. Steiger, 99 F.4th 1316, 1326 (11th Cir. 2024) (en banc) (quot- +ing United States v. Dominguez Benitez, 542 U.S. 74, 84 (2004)). If the +defendant makes the first three showings, we have the “discretion +to recognize an unpreserved error but only if (4) the error seriously +affects the fairness, integrity or public reputation of judicial pro- +ceedings.” Roosevelt Coats, 8 F.4th at 1235 (citation modified). + +Before a district judge accepts a guilty plea, he must “address +the defendant personally in open court and determine that the plea +is voluntary.” Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(b)(2). In particular, the judge +must ensure that the defendant understands certain facts, including +“the terms of any plea-agreement provision waiving the right to +appeal or to collaterally attack the sentence.” Id. 11(b)(1)(N); see +also, e.g., United States v. Lejarde-Rada, 319 F.3d 1288, 1289 (11th Cir. +2003) (noting that the Rule 11 colloquy aims to ensure, among +other things, that the defendant “know[s] and understand[s] the +consequences of his guilty plea” (citation modified)). + +Importantly for present purposes, a knowing and voluntary +guilty plea “waives all non-jurisdictional defects,” United States v. +Pierre, 120 F.3d 1153, 1155 (11th Cir. 1997) (citation modified), in- +cluding, as relevant here, the allegedly erroneous denial of a mo- +tion to suppress evidence. Accordingly, a “defendant who wishes +to preserve appellate review of a non-jurisdictional defect while at +the same time pleading guilty can do so only by entering a + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 8 of 27 + +8 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +‘conditional plea’ in accordance with Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(a)(2).” Id. +All here agree that Edwards’s plea was “unconditional.” Br. of Ap- +pellant at 31. + +Edwards insists, though, that his guilty plea wasn’t knowing +and voluntary because he didn’t understand one of the conse- +quences of pleading—namely, that he would lose the right to ap- +peal the denial of his motion to suppress the handgun evidence. +He asserts that the district court failed to inform him of that fact +during the Rule 11 colloquy and, indeed, even suggested at his later +sentencing hearing that he could pursue the appeal. Edwards relies +principally on our decision in Pierre to argue that because he be- +lieved that his plea agreement preserved the right to appeal the de- +nial of the suppression motion—but in fact didn’t—his plea wasn’t +knowing and voluntary. + +In Pierre, we considered the appeal of a defendant who, hav- +ing pleaded guilty, sought to argue that his speedy-trial rights had +been violated. 120 F.3d at 1154. We vacated the conviction upon +determining that, at the time he pleaded guilty, the defendant didn’t +understand the consequences of doing so: “Because Pierre en- +tered—and the district court accepted—this guilty plea only on the +reasonable (but mistaken) belief that [he] had preserved the speedy +trial issues for appeal, his plea was, as a matter of law, not knowing +and voluntary.” Id. at 1156. We based our decision on a review of +“[t]he plea colloquy,” which “unequivocally indicate[d] that Pierre +intended to plead guilty on the condition” that he retained his ap- +pellate rights. Id. at 1155. For example, we cited statements at the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 9 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +9 + +plea hearing demonstrating that Pierre had pleaded guilty “only af- +ter having been assured by the district court judge that [] he had +preserved the speedy trial issues for appeal.” Id. In particular, the +district judge had said: “So I’m going to deny your renewed motion +to dismiss. Now, if you’re ready to go to trial, we have a jury com- +ing up. If you feel that you wish to plead guilty and preserve these +legal issues, you may do so.” Id. We also cited statements demon- +strating that “Pierre’s counsel [had] explicitly tried to preserve the +speedy trial issue.” Id. Specifically, Pierre’s counsel had stated: “As +long as my client is assured by the court, which you have done, that +these issues are protected for purposes of appeal, [Pierre] may be +willing to wish to do that in the future. But for the purposes of +trial, he is entering a plea. It is in his best interest at this time.” Id. + +Here, Edwards hasn’t pointed to any similar evidence from +the plea hearing—no statement by him, his lawyer, or the district +judge—indicating that he didn’t understand the consequences of +pleading guilty. To be sure, Edwards now says that once he lost +the suppression issue, he wanted to plead and “go onto the sentenc- +ing part” so that he could appeal the denial of the motion. See Br. +of Appellant at 29–30 (quoting Tr. of Change of Plea at 10:4–12). +But at the plea hearing, the suppression issue was mentioned only +once, in passing. The district judge asked Edwards’s counsel how +he “got ready for today’s hearing.” Tr. of Change of Plea at 8:5–6. +Edwards’s lawyer responded: “[I]n anticipation of today’s hearing, +[my client] and I had a scheduled visit last week where we went +over the entire plea agreement and . . . the entire factual proffer + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 10 of 27 + +10 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +together.” Id. at 8:18–21. Edwards’s lawyer then added the follow- +ing regarding the suppression motion—its only mention: + +[Defense Counsel]: As the Court noted earlier, we +also had a motion to suppress in this case. The facts +are rather simple. I mean, he was pulled over and he +was arrested and he was in possession of a firearm +and he was a convicted felon. It’s not a—this is not +factually difficult. It was just whether or not they had +requisite legal rights to effectuate that stop. That was +the whole issue. And this Court, unfortunately, ruled +against us, but that’s the nature of the case. + +Id. at 8:22–9:4. + +No one suggested at that time that Edwards wanted to—or +thought he could—appeal the denial of the suppression motion. +And Edwards’s counsel certainly didn’t tie the entry of his plea to +the preservation of the right to appeal, as the lawyer had in Pierre. +To the contrary, Edwards’s lawyer seemed resigned to the district +court’s ruling. + +The preservation issue didn’t resurface for another three +months, at the sentencing hearing. Edwards asserts before us that +a colloquy at that hearing shows that he intended all along to ap- +peal the denial of the motion to suppress. Br. of Appellant at 30– +31. We disagree. + +Here’s the relevant sentencing-hearing exchange, in full: + +Defense Counsel: He did tell me, Judge, he wants me +to try to get counsel appointed to just appeal the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 11 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +11 + +ruling on the motion to suppress. So I told him that I +would file the notice. And if the Court at some point +needs to have a hearing as to whether he is in forma +pauperis and is entitled to counsel for that appeal, I +guess we’ll have a hearing. But that’s what he re- +quested of me. + +The Court: Sure. On this case did we have a formal +plea agreement? I can’t remember now. + +Defense Counsel: I don’t remember – – + +Government: No, I think he pled open, Your Honor. + +Defense Counsel: Yeah. Yeah, I don’t remember +there being an appellate waiver. I don’t recall. + +The Court: Right. I just wanted to advise him if there +was. So the plea agreement at docket entry 80 does +not mention an appellate waiver. Certainly, sir, you +do have the right, if you want, to take an appeal of +that. Just don’t miss your timelines on that. Okay? + +Mr. Edwards: All right. Thank you, sir. + +Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 24:7–25:1. + +Unsurprisingly, Edwards focuses on the district court’s state- +ment that he “ha[d] the right, if [he] want[ed], to take an appeal” +from the order denying the suppression motion. Id. at 24:23–24. +But that remark is both too little and too late. As for the too-little +part, the context makes clear that in the months that had passed +since the plea hearing, everyone (including the district judge) had + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 12 of 27 + +12 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +lost track of the details of Edwards’s plea—whether it was a formal +plea agreement, whether it contained an appeal waiver, etc. At the +sentencing hearing, the judge assumed that because the agreement +didn’t contain an appeal waiver, Edwards could appeal the suppres- +sion order. But the judge hardly made any guarantees. + +And as for the too-late: All of the evidence to which Ed- +wards now points comes from the sentencing hearing, which, +again, took place some three months after he pleaded guilty. That +makes this case quite different from Pierre, in which the defendant +could—and did—point to strong indications from the plea hearing +itself that he misunderstood, at the time, what appellate rights he +was waiving. There is simply no basis in the record here for imput- +ing backwards, as it were, whatever was said at sentencing to show +genuine confusion at the earlier plea hearing.3 + +Edwards has failed to show that the district court plainly +erred in accepting his plea as knowing and voluntary.4 We there- +fore affirm the district court’s judgment in that respect. + +3 Edwards separately complains that the district judge failed to explicitly warn +him that he couldn’t appeal the denial of his motion to suppress. But nothing +in Rule 11 or our caselaw requires a judge to proactively inform a defendant +that by entering an unconditional plea he waives his right to appeal all non- +jurisdictional matters. Edwards ultimately concedes as much, saying only that +one circuit court has called this the “preferred practice.” Reply Br. at 3–4 (cit- +ing United States v. Lampazianie, 251 F.3d 519, 526 (5th Cir. 2001)). Perhaps, +but that is no basis for finding plain error. + +4 Unrelatedly, Edwards argues that his plea wasn’t knowingly and voluntarily +entered “on the basis of Erlinger as well.” Letter Br. of Appellant at 5 n.4, Dkt. +No. 37. In a footnote in a supplemental brief, Edwards asserts that had he + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 13 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +13 + +B + +1 + +We next consider the Armed Career Criminal Act enhance- +ment. Because Edwards never objected to the enhancement, we +review only for plain error. See United States v. Jones, 743 F.3d 826, +828 (11th Cir. 2014); Fed. R. Crim. P. 52(b). While a conviction un- +der § 922(g) ordinarily yields a maximum sentence of 10 years in +prison, 18 U.S.C. § 924(a)(2), ACCA mandates a minimum 15-year +sentence for an offender who has three prior convictions for “vio- +lent felon[ies]” or “serious drug offense[s]” that were “committed +on occasions different from one another,” id. § 924(e)(1). Edwards +contends that the district court erred in enhancing his sentence un- +der ACCA because the government failed to prove beyond a rea- +sonable doubt that his three predicate convictions occurred on dif- +ferent occasions. + +In Wooden v. United States, the Supreme Court explained that +ACCA “contains both a three-offense requirement and a three-occa- +sion requirement.” 595 U.S. 360, 368 (2022). Although ACCA + +“known that he was entitled to a jury determination as to whether his offenses +were committed on different occasions, he may not have pled guilty—or he +may have pled guilty to the 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) charge, and sought a trial on +the occasions issue.” Id. We’ll address the merits of Edwards’s Erlinger argu- +ment in the next Part, but we decline to consider it vis-à-vis the voluntariness +of his plea. “We have long held that an appellant abandons a claim when he +either makes only passing references to it or raises it in a perfunctory manner +without supporting arguments and authority.” Sapuppo v. Allstate Floridian Ins. +Co., 739 F.3d 678, 680–81 (11th Cir. 2014). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 14 of 27 + +14 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +initially focused only on the number of offenses, Congress later +amended it to specify that qualifying offenses must also occur on +different occasions. See Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1988, Pub. L. 100– +690, § 7056 (codified as amended at 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(1)) (inserting +“committed on occasions different from one another,” after “or +both”). Congress “added the occasions clause only after a court +applied ACCA to an offender . . . convicted of multiple counts of +robbery arising from a single criminal episode.” Wooden, 595 U.S.at +371–73 (citing Petty v. United States, 481 U.S. 1034, 1034–1035 +(1987)). The Wooden Court emphasized that while each ACCA- +qualifying offense often occurs separately, “multiple crimes may +occur on one occasion even if not at the same moment.” Id. at 366. +“[T]reating each temporally distinct offense as its own occasion” as +a per se matter, the Court explained, would improperly “collaps[e] +two separate statutory conditions.” Id. at 368. + +To operationalize the different-occasions requirement, the +Wooden Court described a “range of circumstances [that] may be +relevant to identifying episodes of criminal activity”—e.g., the of- +fenses’ timing, location, and character. Id. at 369. Applying those +considerations—which we’ll explore in detail soon enough—the +Court concluded that Wooden’s ten burglaries didn’t occur on dif- +ferent occasions because (1) he committed them “in a single unin- +terrupted course of conduct,” (2) he committed them at “one loca- +tion,” and (3) the offenses were “essentially identical” and “inter- +twined.” Id. at 370. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 15 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +15 + +Approximately four months after Wooden was decided, Ed- +wards entered his unconditional guilty plea in this case. His written +plea agreement recites that “[t]he defendant . . . understands and +acknowledges that the Court must impose a statutory mandatory +minimum term of imprisonment of fifteen (15) years.” Plea Agree- +ment ¶ 3, Dkt. No. 80. The agreement was accompanied by a +signed factual proffer, which recited that “[t]he defendant has at +least seven (7) felony convictions” and specifically enumerated +three of them—“for trafficking in oxycodone (10-022573CF10A), +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon (10-022679CF10A), and +(97- +robbery with a deadly weapon/aggravated battery +000465CF10B).” Factual Proffer ¶ 2. The same three convictions +were cited in Edwards’s presentence investigation report as +grounds for enhancing his sentence under ACCA. See PSI ¶ 20 +(“The defendant is an armed career criminal because he is subject +to an enhanced sentence under the provisions of 18 U.S.C. § 924(e), +pursuant to § 4B1.4(a). The defendant has the prior felony convic- +in docket numbers 10-022573CF110A, 10- +tions as noted +022679CF10A, and 97-000465CF10B.”). And the district court in +fact used those three convictions to enhance Edwards’s sentence. +The judge explained that “looking at the offense level computa- +tion” in the PSI, the “Armed Career Criminal enhancement gets +[the offense level] up to 33.” Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 4:19–23 (cit- +ing PSI ¶ 20). + +Edwards didn’t object to the ACCA enhancement on any +ground, including that the offenses underlying the ACCA predi- +cates weren’t committed on different occasions. He didn’t object + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 16 of 27 + +16 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +to the PSI’s ACCA-enhanced recommended sentence, see supra at 5 +n.2, nor did he object to the enhancement during the sentencing +hearing. To the contrary, Edwards’s counsel suggested at the sen- +tencing hearing that the ACCA-enhanced 15-year sentence was ap- +propriate: + +[Defense Counsel]: My client has been aware for +months that he’s facing a statutory minimum sen- +tence of 15 years, which is 180 months in federal +prison. He’s been aware of it. He has not gone to +trial on this particular case. He has not testified in this +particular case. He got acceptance of responsibility, +even though it doesn’t really affect him. So he’s just +asking the Court to accept both parties’ recommen- +dations, sentence him to 15 years, and he’ll move on +with his life. + +Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 16:5–13; see also id. at 21:14–17 (“Court: +[N]ow that sentence has been imposed, do either of you object to +the Court’s finding of fact or the manner in which the sentence was +pronounced? [Defense Counsel]: No, Judge.”). Hearing no objec- +tion to the applicability of the ACCA enhancement based on Ed- +wards’s three prior convictions, the district court sentenced him to +the 15-year statutory minimum. + +Then came Erlinger, in which the Supreme Court held that +because the determination that a defendant’s prior crimes were +committed on different occasions “‘increase[s] the prescribed range +of penalties to which a criminal defendant is exposed,’” it “must be +resolved by a unanimous jury beyond a reasonable doubt (or freely + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 17 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +17 + +admitted in a guilty plea).” 602 U.S. at 834 (quoting Apprendi v. New +Jersey, 530 U.S. 466, 490 (2000)).5 In light of Erlinger, Edwards con- +tends on appeal that because a jury didn’t find beyond a reasonable +doubt that his three ACCA predicate offenses were committed on +different occasions, the district court committed plain error when +it imposed an enhanced 15-year minimum-mandatory sentence. + +2 + +The government concedes that in light of Erlinger, Edwards +has satisfied the first two prongs of the plain-error standard—an +“error” that is “plain”—because, it says, the different-occasions re- +quirement was neither proven to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt +nor expressly admitted by Edwards in his plea. See Br. of Appellee +at 28.6 + +5 To be clear, Erlinger didn’t add a different-occasions element to the statute. +As already explained, Congress codified the different-occasions requirement +some 35 years ago. And almost four months before Edwards entered his plea, +and eight months before his sentencing hearing, the Supreme Court in Wooden +reiterated the significance of the different-occasions element and clarified the +circumstances under which offenses will (and won’t) satisfy it. Erlinger, rather, +resolved the “who decides” question—namely, by holding that the different- +occasions issue must be resolved either by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt +or by the defendant himself in a guilty plea. See 602 U.S. at 834. District courts, +the Erlinger Court held, “may not assume the jury’s factfinding function for +themselves” to conclude that offenses occurred on different occasions. Id. + +6 The second half of that disjunction isn’t self-evidently correct. Here, Ed- +wards at least arguably admitted in his plea that his three convictions satisfied +ACCA’s different-occasions requirement. As already explained, Edwards ad- +mitted that the three convictions enumerated in both the factual proffer and +the PSI qualified him for the ACCA enhancement. And by pleading to the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 18 of 27 + +18 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +Still, to prevail on plain error, Edwards must show, at step +three, that the Erlinger error affected his “substantial rights.”� +“[U]nlike harmless error—where the government carries the bur- +den—the onus of establishing prejudice under plain error rests with +the defendant.” United States v. Margarita Garcia, 906 F.3d 1255, +1267 (11th Cir. 2018). That burden is “heavy”—and, in particular, +“the burden of showing prejudice to meet the third-prong require- +ment is anything but easy.” Id. (citation modified). + +To demonstrate prejudice, a defendant must “show a rea- +sonable probability that, but for the error, the outcome of the pro- +ceeding would have been different.” United States v. Corbett, 921 F.3d +1032, 1037 (11th Cir. 2019) (quoting Molina-Martinez v. United States, +578 U.S. 189, 194 (2016)). “[W]e define the ‘outcome’ that must +have been affected by considering the nature of the rule violated +by the district court and the role that rule plays in the judicial pro- +cess.” Steiger, 99 F.4th at 1326. When, as here, “the proceeding is +sentencing, we ask whether the sentence would be different but for +erroneous sentencing enhancements or an inaccurate sentencing +guidelines range.” Id. (citation modified). Edwards thus “has the +difficult burden of showing there is a ‘reasonable probability’ that +he would have received a lighter sentence but for the error.” Jones, + +whole—i.e., ACCA applicability, writ large, based on those three convic- +tions—one could argue that he implicitly pleaded to the constituent parts, in- +cluding the applicability of the different-occasions requirement. But the gov- +ernment hasn’t pressed that argument, so we won’t pursue it. + +� + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 19 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +19 + +743 F.3d at 830.7 In other words, a showing that Edwards would +have been entitled to a jury determination on the separate-occa- +sions inquiry is not, in and of itself, enough to establish that the +error affected his “substantial rights” under the plain-error frame- +work. Rather, to prevail, Edwards must further show a reasonable +probability that a jury would have concluded that he committed +the three predicate crimes on fewer than three occasions. + +As already explained, the district court enhanced Edwards’s +sentence under ACCA on the basis of three prior convictions: +(1) for a December 20, 1996, robbery with a deadly weapon and + +7 Both parties seem to misunderstand—albeit in different ways—how the sub- +stantial-rights prong operates in this case. For the first time at oral argument, +Edwards asserted that under Greer v. United States, 593 U.S. 508 (2021), he can +show prejudice if there is a reasonable probability that had he known about +the Erlinger rule, he wouldn’t have pleaded guilty and would have instead in- +sisted on going to trial. See Oral Arg. at 7:46, 28:22. That is incorrect. True, +when a defendant challenges the voluntariness of his plea, the reasonable- +probability standard is appropriately focused on whether he would have +pleaded guilty. Greer, 593 U.S. at 508. Accordingly, that formulation would +have governed Edwards’s voluntariness challenge had we found the first two +prongs of the plain-error standard satisfied. See supra at 7. But it doesn’t gov- +ern his challenge to the applicability of the ACCA enhancement. + +For its part, the government contends that the requisite reasonable +probability doesn’t exist here because Edwards hasn’t shown either “that the +three qualifying offenses were not committed on different occasions” or that +“the government would have been unable to prove that fact had he made a +timely objection.” Br. of Appellee at 31. But that formulation erects too high +a bar. To be sure, a defendant may seek to demonstrate prejudice in those +ways—and they would likely be persuasive—but he isn’t required to do so in +order to show an effect on his substantial rights. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 20 of 27 + +20 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +aggravated battery, for which the arrest occurred on April 1, 1997; +(2) for an undated instance of drug trafficking, for which the arrest +occurred on December 28, 2010; and (3) for an October 1, 2010, +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon, for which the arrest oc- +curred on December 30, 2010. Edwards concedes that it is fair to +assume that the 1996 robbery was committed on a different occa- +sion than the other two—the nearly 14-year gap is hard to ignore. +But, he maintains, the government didn’t prove that the drug-traf- +ficking and aggravated-battery offenses, both with arrest dates in +2010, were committed on different occasions. + +The PSI contains no details about the drug-trafficking of- +fense other than the arrest date. Although “[t]he circumstances of +this arrest were requested from the Broward County Clerk of +Court,” no report was ever produced. Letter Br. of Appellant at 7, +Dkt. No. 37 (citing PSI ¶ 34). Edwards contends that, “based on the +lack of facts in the record concerning the 2010 drug offense,” a jury +likely would have found that the drug-trafficking and aggravated- +battery offenses were committed on the same occasion and, there- +fore, that he wasn’t subject to the ACCA enhancement.8 Id. at 8. +We cannot agree. + +8 Edwards’s other arguments improperly employ a harmless-error-like stand- +ard, pursuant to which the government bears the burden. See Letter Br. of +Appellant at 5 (“[B]ecause the government did not prove that his offenses oc- +curred on three separate occasions,” “Edwards is entitled to be resentenced +without the ACCA enhancement.”); see also id. at 6 (“[T]he ‘facts’ in the record +here—even the ‘unobjected to’ facts in the PSI—are insufficient for a jury to + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 21 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +21 + +In our review for plain error, we consider “the whole rec- +ord” to determine “the effect of any error on [the defendant’s] sub- +stantial rights,” including “proceedings that both precede and post- +date the errors about which [the defendant] complains.” United +States v. Reed, 941 F.3d 1018, 1021 (11th Cir. 2019) (citation modi- +fied); see also Greer v. United States, 593 U.S. 503, 511 (2021) (explain- +ing that “an appellate court conducting plain-error review may +consider the entire record—not just the record from the particular +proceeding where the error occurred”). So we will examine the en- +tire record for evidence bearing on what the Wooden Court called +the “range of circumstances” that “may be relevant to identifying +episodes of criminal activity.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369; see also Er- +linger, 602 U.S. at 828 (noting the “intensely factual nature of this +inquiry”). The Court hoped that, “[f]or the most part,” applying +the different-occasions requirement would be “straightforward and +intuitive.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. But for the tough cases, the +Court offered guidance to help determine whether offenses consti- +tute single or multiple episodes of criminal activity. In particular, +the Court emphasized considerations such as “[1] whether the de- +fendant’s past offenses were ‘committed close in time,’ [2] whether +they were committed near to or far from one another, and +[3] whether the offenses were ‘similar or intertwined’ in purpose +and character.” Erlinger, 602 U.S. at 828 (quoting Wooden, 595 U.S. +at 369). + +conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that the offenses occurred on different +occasions.”). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 22 of 27 + +22 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +Candidly, the record doesn’t shed much light on the first two +Wooden factors. With respect to timing, while the PSI establishes +that the aggravated-battery offense occurred on October 1, 2010, it +doesn’t specify the date of the drug-trafficking offense. Accord- +ingly, we can’t make any firm judgments about whether those two +crimes were “committed close in time, in an uninterrupted course +of conduct” or if they were “separated by substantial gaps in time +or significant intervening events.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. The +record likewise reveals nothing about the “[p]roximity of location” +that would permit an assessment of whether the two crimes oc- +curred far from one another, which would of course make it “less +likely they are components of the same criminal event.” Id. + +That leaves the offenses’ “purpose and character”—and +there, we have more to go on. Edwards’s drug-related offense in- +volved trafficking in oxycodone, possession of cocaine with intent +to deliver or sell, and possession of drug paraphernalia. By con- +trast, his aggravated-battery arose out of domestic dispute with a +former romantic partner. According to the arrest affidavit— + +[O]n October 1, 2010, the defendant picked up a small +flowerpot, forcefully grabbed the victim by her hair, +and then smashed the pot against the victim’s head. +The victim sustained a laceration to the left side of +her head. The victim and the defendant had been in- +volved in a romantic relationship for two years and +lived together for seven months. The victim was +transported to the hospital where she received multi- +ple staples on her head. The defendant was later ar- +rested on December 30, 2010. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 23 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +23 + +PSI ¶ 35. At least on the face of things, Edwards’s drug-trafficking +and aggravated battery offenses seem to have nothing in com- +mon—to be totally unrelated. And there’s certainly nothing in the +record to suggest that the two crimes “share a common scheme or +purpose,” such that they are likely to “compose one occasion.” +Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. Accordingly, we think the third, “purpose +and character” factor significantly diminishes the probability that +the drug-trafficking and aggravated-battery offenses occurred on +the same occasion. + +Other facts likewise indicate, on balance, that those crimes +occurred on different occasions. First, Edwards was arrested for +the offenses two days apart—for the drug-trafficking crime on De- +cember 28, 2010, and for the aggravated-battery crime on Decem- +ber 30, 2010. Second, the criminal cases bear non-consecutive +docket numbers—indicating, at the very least, that the charges +were filed on different dates. And third, the two crimes were adju- +dicated almost three years apart—the aggravated battery on July +21, 2011, and the drug trafficking on April 29, 2014. We think it at +least relevant—and certainly not irrelevant—that the two offenses +were never combined into a single arrest or case, despite ample op- +portunities to do so. + +We also note the conspicuous absence of any evidence to +the contrary. Even on appeal, and with an opportunity to supple- +ment the record, Edwards hasn’t presented any evidence that +would demonstrate, or even strongly suggest, that the drug-traf- +ficking and aggravated-battery offenses were committed on the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 24 of 27 + +24 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +same occasion. He doesn’t assert, for instance, that the two crimes +took place on the same date, were committed in the same location, +or involved the same victims. Rather, Edwards simply says that +there isn’t sufficient evidence in the record for the government to +prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the ACCA enhancement ap- +plies. But on plain-error review, where the burden rests with Ed- +wards, and with the balance of the record evidence against him, +that’s not enough. + +To be sure, Edwards isn’t required to show by a preponder- +ance of the evidence that, but for the Erlinger error, the result +would have been different. See Dominguez Benitez, 542 U.S. at 83 +n.9 (“The reasonable-probability standard is not the same as, and +should not be confused with, a requirement that a defendant prove +by a preponderance of the evidence that but for error things would +have been different.”). And we acknowledge Edwards’s argument +that the lack of smoking-gun evidence about the locations and +dates of the crimes makes it possible that a jury could have found +the different-occasions requirement not satisfied. But a mere pos- +sibility isn’t a reasonable probability. See United States v. Marcus, +560 U.S. 258, 263 (2010) (deeming a standard pegged to “any possi- +bility, no matter how unlikely,” of a different outcome “irreconcilable +with our ‘plain error’ precedent” (citation modified)). And again, +the record evidence that we do have—the drug-trafficking and ag- +gravated-battery offenses’ divergent “purpose[s] and character[s],” +the different arrest and adjudication dates, the non-consecutive +docket numbers, etc.—indicates that they were indeed “committed +on occasions different from one another.” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(1). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 25 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +25 + +Finally, we note that Edwards hasn’t explained how there +could be a “reasonable probability”—more than a mere possibil- +ity—of a different outcome here. As we’ve observed, see supra at +24, Edwards hasn’t put forward any theory that pushes this case +over the reasonable-probability hurdle. Far from showing a rea- +sonable probability, Edwards hasn’t even speculated to how the Er- +linger error might have affected the outcome. For example, he +hasn’t argued that the aggravated-battery offense occurred in the +course of a dispute over the drug trafficking, such that a jury could +have found that those two offenses occurred on the same occasion. +And “[w]here the effect of an alleged error is so uncertain, a defend- +ant cannot meet his burden of showing that the error actually af- +fected his substantial rights.” Jones v. United States, 527 U.S. 373, +394–95 (1999). + +We therefore hold that Edwards hasn’t met his plain-error +burden to show that his “substantial rights” were affected, and we +affirm the district court’s decision to apply the ACCA enhance- +ment. + +C + +Finally, we address Edwards’s argument that Congress ex- +ceeded its Commerce Clause authority when it enacted 18 U.S.C. +§ 922(g).9 + +9 We review a district court’s determination regarding the constitutionality of +a statute for plain error when, as here, the issue wasn’t presented below. See +United States v. Valois, 915 F.3d 717, 729 n.7 (11th Cir. 2019). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 26 of 27 + +26 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +We have repeatedly held that § 922(g) is facially constitu- +tional under the Commerce Clause because it contains an express +jurisdictional requirement. See, e.g., United States v. Stancil, 4 F.4th +1193, 1200 (11th Cir. 2021); United States v. Jordan, 635 F.3d 1181, +1189 (11th Cir. 2011); United States v. Scott, 263 F.3d 1270, 1273–74 +(11th Cir. 2001) (“[T]he jurisdictional element of the statute, i.e., +the requirement that the felon ‘possess in or affecting commerce, +any firearm or ammunition,’ immunizes § 922(g)(1) from [a] facial +constitutional attack.”); United States v. Dupree, 258 F.3d 1258, 1259– +60 (11th Cir. 2001); United States v. McAllister, 77 F.3d 387, 390 (11th +Cir. 1996). + +We have also rejected as-applied challenges to § 922(g), +holding that the government demonstrates the required “minimal +nexus” to interstate commerce when it proves that the firearms +were manufactured outside the state where the offense took place +and, thus, necessarily traveled in interstate commerce. See, e.g., Jor- +dan, 635 F.3d at 1189 (holding that § 922(g) is constitutional as ap- +plied to “a defendant who possessed a firearm only intrastate” be- +cause the firearm had moved in interstate commerce); see also +United States v. Wright, 607 F.3d 708, 715–16 (11th Cir. 2010). Here, +Edwards admitted in his factual proffer that the firearm and ammu- +nition that he possessed in Florida were manufactured out of state +and had therefore moved in interstate commerce prior to his pos- +session of them. The government thus satisfied the minimal-nexus +requirement here. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 27 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +27 + +Under the prior-panel-precedent rule, we’re obliged to fol- +low our existing decisions unless overruled by this Court en banc +or abrogated by the Supreme Court. United States v. White, 837 +F.3d 1225, 1228 (11th Cir. 2016). Because neither has occurred +here, we affirm the judgment of the district court that § 922(g) +doesn’t violate the Commerce Clause. + +III + +For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the district court’s + +judgment. + +AFFIRMED. diff --git a/q46/random_k2/random_2.md b/q46/random_k2/random_2.md index 8a904058060ae7a349c7098cea40da33240de4d1..052cee2fff6d2fb0526b1d43400b3c01f2587dfb 100644 Binary files a/q46/random_k2/random_2.md and b/q46/random_k2/random_2.md differ diff --git a/q46/random_k4/question.json b/q46/random_k4/question.json index 43e2e28c6ffeeee57a86290fa6ceddb93032d8e7..4af9d3ebc9f95292c984faf372ce1f32ce7360db 100644 --- a/q46/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q46/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "avalaunchpresentationsthatkickasteriskv3copy-150318114804-conversion-gate01_95.pdf", - "web_72a76e216577393a.pdf", - "web_3ee12c98981a617a.pdf", - "5fdcf120b846746985684fa54250aab44639b30c.pdf", - "web_8330bd2eabffb7f3.pdf" + "web_18e98cd838edeb2e.pdf", + "resize_r2_0.pdf", + "web_0fc33975f03605a5.pdf", + "web_6820ef1c6bfc9e7b.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q46/random_k4/random_1.md b/q46/random_k4/random_1.md index 144d326cd99ff1f87d5a1868d00f1666677a5e13..c346d7f5a27964259c5644ba47c0ac6027670487 100644 --- a/q46/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q46/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,1799 +1,1018 @@ -Genetics &Embry - -an -m -u -H - -ol -o -g -y - -Human Genetics & Embryology - -Salem, Human Genet Embryol 2013, S5 -DOI: 10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -ISSN: 2161-0436 - -Review Article - -Medical Genetics: An Overview -Mohammad Saad Zaghloul Salem* -Faculty of Medicine, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, Egypt - -Abstract - -Open Access - -Medical genetics is a branch of human genetics confined to studying structure and function of the genetic material -in health and disease states of human beings. It comprises studying causes and mechanisms of pathogenesis of -genetic disorders, clinical characterization of different types of these disorders and their modes of inheritance, study -of diagnostic techniques used in their diagnosis and delineation of effective prophylactic and therapeutic measures -resorted to in managing patients and carriers of these diseases. The wide spectrum of medical genetics includes -six main fields: basic, clinical, diagnostic, prophylactic, therapeutic and applied genetics. The scopes of most of -these fields are self-explanatory with few exceptions. Pathogenetics, a branch of basic genetics, implies the study of -mutagens, mutations, pathogenetic mechanisms responsible for development of genetic diseases and anti-mutation -mechanisms that protect the genome from the pathological consequences of these mechanisms. Formal genetics, -another branch of basic genetics, is concerned with deducing and figuring out relevant genetic data from constructed -figures that contain specific genetic information. These informative figures include, for instance, constructed family -pedigrees, linkage maps and chromosomal maps. Applied genetics denotes use of knowledge of other fields of -medical genetics in many significant applications like genetic counseling, fetal therapy and forensic genetics. -Treatment of genetic disorders and prevention of their complications represent the main targets of therapeutic -and prophylactic genetics, respectively. The importance of medical genetics resides in hopes of its ability to offer -alleviating measures and curative therapies for disprevileged patients with genetic diseases and, more importantly, -to succeed in achieving radical preventive approaches of these diseases. This article is intended to offer a simple -and concise overview of medical genetics including the various aspects of its different fields. - -Keywords: Pathogenetics; Mutagens; Mutation; Pathogenetic -mechanisms; Anti-mutation mechanisms; -genetics; -Prophylactic genetics; Therapeutic genetics; Applied genetics - -Formal +USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 1 of 27 -Spectrum of Medical Genetics +[PUBLISH] -Medical genetics, as the name implies, is a branch of human -genetics confined to, and concerned with, studying structure and -function of the genetic material in relation to health and disease -states of human beings. Within this context, it comprises the study of -causes and mechanisms of pathogenesis of genetic disorders, clinical -characterization of different types of these disorders and their modes of -inheritance, study of diagnostic techniques used in their diagnosis and -delineation of effective prophylactic and therapeutic measures resorted -to in managing patients and carriers of these diseases. A plausible -classification of the wide spectrum of the different fields of medical -genetics, based on the subjects and aims of the different branches of -each of these fields, recognizes six main fields of medical genetics: basic, -clinical, diagnostic, prophylactic, therapeutic and applied genetics -(Table 1). +In the +United States Court of Appeals +For the Eleventh Circuit -Genetics and Life +____________________ -All life activities in living cells, whether conducted on molecular -level, e.g. electron transfer in oxidative phosphorylation reactions for -production of ATP, on cellular level like cell division, on tissue level like -muscle contraction or on whole organ level like hearing for instance, are -mediated via very large numbers of inter-related metabolic networks. A -metabolic network is defined as a cascade of controlled biochemical -reactions and biophysical alterations that transform one, or more, -substrate to one, or more, product. Each metabolic network consists of -a very large number, sometimes hundreds, of proteins, mostly enzymes, -and other non-protein factors all acting cooperatively in stereotyped -sequence to perform specific biochemical and physiological functions. -In human cells, nearly 4100 (four thousand and one hundred) of these -networks have been delineated [1]. The proteins which are constituents +No. 22-13963 -of and mediate these metabolic networks are synthesized in living cells -under strict regulation of the genes contained within the cells. This -intimate relationship between the genetic material and life activities is -represented by the central dogma of molecular biology which states that -while the sum total of the genetic material of the living cell, collectively -referred to as the genome, defines the framework of all features and -life processes in living cells, the sum total of the proteins produced and -synthesized in the cell under strict control of the genome, collectively -referred to as the proteome, are the actual and direct mediators of these -life processes. +____________________ -The Human Genome +UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, -The human genome, estimated to consist of 20000-25000 genes, -is unequally divided into a major portion constituting more than -99.99% of its size, residing in the nucleus and structurally organized as -chromosomes and is referred to as the nuclear genome. The remaining -tiny portion exists as small circular molecules inside the mitochondria in -the cytoplasm and is referred to as the mitochondrial genome (mtDNA). -Albeit, much smaller portion of genomic DNA exists as a structure -associated and attached to the inner surface of cell membrane and is -referred to as cytoplasmic membrane associated DNA (cmDNA) [2]. The -exact functional significance of this portion is, still, a matter of debate. +versus -*Corresponding author: Mohammad SaadZaghloul Salem, Faculty of Medicine, -Professor of Medical Genetics, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, Egypt, E-mail: -mszsalem@hotmail.com +SHADON DEMETRIC EDWARDS, -Received February 15, 2013; Accepted February 27, 2013; Published March -02, 2012 + Plaintiff-Appellee, -Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet -Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 + Defendant-Appellant. -Copyright: © 2013 Salem MSZ. This is an open-access article distributed under -the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted -use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and -source are credited. +____________________ -Human Genet Embryol +Appeal from the United States District Court +for the Southern District of Florida +D.C. Docket No. 0:19-cr-60373-AHS-1 +____________________ - Medical Genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 2 of 27 -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal +2 - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 +Opinion of the Court -Basic Genetics +22-13963 -1. Molecular genetics +Before ROSENBAUM, NEWSOM, and MARCUS, Circuit Judges. -10. Developmental genetics +NEWSOM, Circuit Judge: -2. Pathogenetics +Shadon Edwards pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm and +ammunition despite having previously been convicted of a crime +punishable by more than a year in prison, in violation of 18 U.S.C. +§ 922(g). On appeal, Edwards challenges his § 922(g) conviction +and 180-month sentence on three grounds. First, he contends that +his guilty plea wasn’t knowing and voluntary because the district +court failed to inform him that, by pleading, he would waive his +right to appeal the denial of an earlier suppression motion. Second, +he asserts that the district court wrongly enhanced his sentence un- +der the Armed Career Criminal Act because the government didn’t +prove beyond a reasonable doubt, as required by Erlinger v. United +States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), that he had earlier been convicted of +three crimes that occurred on different occasions. Third, he argues +that § 922(g) exceeds Congress’s Commerce Clause authority. -3. Cytogenetics +After careful review, and with the benefit of oral argument, -4. Formal genetics +we affirm the district court’s judgment. -11. Population genetics +I -12. Evolutionary genetics +A -13. Comparative genetics +Shadon Edwards was suspected of being a high-level organ- +izer in a drug-trafficking organization responsible for distributing +illegal narcotics throughout south Florida. After obtaining an ar- +rest warrant for Edwards, law-enforcement officials observed him +driving around Pompano Beach. The officers followed and, after -5. Biochemical genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 3 of 27 -14. Experimental genetics +22-13963 -6. Physiological genetics +Opinion of the Court -15. Genomics +3 -7. Pharmacogenetics +seeing Edwards park, approached and took him into custody. A +search incident to Edwards’s arrest revealed that he had a Glock 43 +nine-millimeter semi-automatic pistol, loaded with six rounds of +ammunition. -16. Transcriptomics +B -8. Oncogenetics +A grand jury indicted Edwards on a single count: the know- +ing possession of a firearm and ammunition by one who had pre- +viously been convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year +in prison, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).1 Edwards filed a +motion to suppress the gun and ammunition found in his car, +which the district court denied. He then pleaded guilty pursuant +to a written plea agreement that neither expressly preserved nor +expressly waived his right to appeal. In connection with his plea, +Edwards also signed a factual proffer describing his offense conduct +and some of his prior criminal history, including, as particularly rel- +evant here, convictions “for trafficking +in oxycodone (10- +022573CF10A), aggravated battery with a deadly weapon (10- +022679CF10A), and robbery with a deadly weapon/aggravated bat- +tery (97-000465CF10B).” Factual Proffer ¶ 2, Dkt. No. 81. -9. Immunogenetics +At the change-of-plea hearing, the district judge engaged in +a colloquy with Edwards to assess several matters, including +whether he was competent to plead guilty and whether he under- +stood the consequences of doing so. At the hearing, there was no -17. Proteomics +1 The indictment also mentioned the Armed Career Criminal Act, 18 U.S.C. +§ 924(e)(1), albeit without further elaboration. -Clinical Genetics + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 4 of 27 -1. Chromosomal aberrations +4 -12. Genetic diseases of the muscular system +Opinion of the Court -2. Congenital malformations +22-13963 -13. Genetic diseases of the skeletal system - -3. Inborn errors of metabolism - -14. Genetic diseases of the blood - -4. Mitochondrial disorders - -15. Genetic diseases of the immune system - -5. Genetic systemic syndromes - -16. Genetic diseases of male reproductive -system - -6. Genetic diseases of the nervous -system - -17. Genetic diseases of female reproductive -system - -7. Genetic diseases of the -endocrinal system - -8. Genetic diseases of the -cardiovascular system - -9. Genetic diseases of the -respiratory system - -10. Genetic diseases of the GIT -system - -11. Genetic diseases of the urinary -system - -18. Genetic diseases of the eye and vision - -19. Genetic diseases of the ear and hearing - -20. Genetic diseases of the skin - -21. Genetic psychiatric disorders - -Diagnostic Genetics - -Prophylactic Genetics - -1. Molecular diagnostic techniques 1. Premarital prophylaxis - -2. Cytogenetic diagnostic -techniques - -3. Biochemical diagnostic -techniques - -2. Preconception prophylaxis - -3. Prenatal prophylaxis - -4. Presymptomatic prophylaxis - -Therapeutic Genetics - -Applied Genetics - -1. Pharmacological therapy - -1. Genetic counseling - -2. Nutritional therapy - -2. Genetic screening - -3. Enzyme replacement therapy - -3. Preimplantation diagnosis - -4. Organ transplantation therapy - -4. Prenatal diagnosis - -5. Surgical intervention - -5. Fetal Therapy - -6. Stem cell therapy - -7. Genetic therapies - -6. Forensic genetics - -7. Genetic engineering - -8. Conventional therapies - -8. Eugenics - -Table 1: Spectrum of medical genetics. - -The nuclear genome in each human germ cell; ovum and sperm, -is organized into a set of 23 separate chromosomes known as the -haploid genome which represents the unit genome of humans. The -haploid genome of the ovum consists of 22 chromosomes that do not -participate in sex determination and referred to as the autosomes, and -one sex determining X chromosome. Similarly, the haploid genome -of the sperm consists of 22 autosomes, and one sex determining X -or Y chromosome. Upon fertilization, both haploid genomes of the -sperm and the ovum constitute a diploid genome consisting of their -46 chromosomes, 44 autosomes and 2 sex determining chromosomes, -either XX in females or XY in males. The diploid genome characterizes -the nuclear genome of the zygote as well as all somatic cells descendant -from it. With very rare exceptions, mitochondria of the sperm do -not participate in fertilization, being carried in the neck piece of the - -Page 2 of 12 - -sperm which do not penetrate the ovum. Nearly, all mitochondria, and -hence the mitochondrial genome, present in the zygote and in all body -cells are descendent from the mitochondria present in the ovum. This -feature accounts for the phenomenon of maternal inheritance, a non- -traditional mode of inheritance of genetic diseases caused by mutations -of the maternal mitochondrial genome. Maternal inheritance of -genetic diseases or traits occurs also for nuclear genes carried on the -X chromosomes of the mother due to the process of Lyonization, or -suppression of all X chromosomes in the cell in excess of one and -underlies the characteristic inheritance patterns of X linked recessive -and dominant genetic disorders. - -Nuclear genes are arranged in a linear sequence on chromosomes. -The estimated 20000-25000 genes that comprise the nuclear genome -constitute, and are distributed over, the 46 chromosomes in the nucleus. -The larger and longer chromosomes have far more numbers of genes -than the smaller and shorter chromosomes. Because genes constitute -only a small proportion of the whole genome, they are separated by long -inter-genic regions of base sequences of the DNA that comprise most -of the non-genic or gene-related components of the genome. These -include: pseudo-genes, pyknons, transposons and telomeres in addition -to an exceedingly large numbers of long and short repetitive and non- -repetitive interspersed elements, among many other components of, -yet, undefined function(s) [3]. - -The human mitochondrial genome exists in varying numbers, -tens to thousands, of very small closed circular double stranded -structures inside the mitochondria. The number of mitochondria -and the number of mtDNA molecules in each mitochondrion varies -according to the metabolic activities of the cell. The most active and -energy-demanding cells, like neurons, heart muscles, the retina, -skeletal muscles, endocrine glands, kidney cells and liver cells have the -largest numbers of mitochondria within their cytoplasm and the largest -numbers of mtDNA molecules in each mitochondrion as well. Each -molecule of the mitochondrial genome consists exclusively of 37 genes. -Though it constitutes very tiny fraction of the whole genome, mtDNA -is indispensable for life because it codes, with other nuclear genes, for -proteins that mediate ATP production in the cell via a specific oxidative -phosphorylation network. In addition, mtDNA regulates synthesis of -proteins that mediates many important metabolic activities of living -cells like lipid oxidation and steroid biosynthesis. More importantly, it -participates with nuclear genomic components in controlling apoptosis. -Due to increased susceptibility of mitochondria to mutational events -and limited mitochondrial genome repair capabilities, accumulating -mutations of mtDNA are linked to functional deterioration and -enhanced aging of cells. - -Genes of the human nuclear genome can be classified into three -main categories: structural genes which are directly involved in -synthesis of proteins, regulatory genes which regulate the function of -structural genes through transcription enhancing/silencing factors -and master genes which are responsible for maintaining the stability -and integrity of the genome through regulating major vital functions -of the cell like cell division, DNA repair and apoptosis. Structural -genes constitute the largest portion of the genome and function in a -stepwise manner composed of six consecutive stages: gene activation, -transcription, post-transcription modifications, translation, post- -translation modifications and intracellular trafficking and targeting of -synthesized protein. Though traditional concepts of gene function do -not include the last two stages concerned with structural modifications -and intracellular localization of translated proteins, although both of -these processes are, and should be considered as, integral stages of gene - -Human Genet Embryol - - Medical Genetics - -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -function because many genetic disorders result from defects in either -of these steps in spite of synthesis of the protein product of the gene in -normal amount with normal primary structural configuration. - -Types of Genetic Diseases - -Genetic disorders comprise many different types and are classified -into many different categories according to their causes and their -clinical manifestations. The great majority of currently defined disorders -result from defects in nuclear genes carried on chromosomes. Some -of these disorders might result from defect in one gene only; single -gene disorders, others might develop due to combined defects in many -genes; polygenic disorders. Defects in mitochondrial genes result in -pathogenesis of distinct group of diseases referred to as mitochondrial -disorders. Since ATP production in cells depends on a metabolic -network mediated by proteins and enzymes produced by both nuclear -and mitochondrial genes, a peculiar group of diseases characterized by -deficient energy production and known as oxidative-phosphorylation -disorders results from deficient production or production of defective -proteins mediating ATP production. - -Chromosomal disorders are, in essence, polygenic disorders -due to involvement of very large numbers of genes according to the -magnitude of the underlying pathogenetic mechanism(s). They are -classified into autosomal anomalies due to defects in the autosomes -and sex chromosomal anomalies. Each of these types might present as -structural disorders caused by structural chromosomal abnormalities -or as numerical disorders due to presence of abnormal number of -chromosomes in the nucleus. Structural chromosomal abnormalities -comprise many pathological types like translocations, deletions, -inversions, duplications, ring chromosomes, isochromosomes and -chromosomal -fragility. Numerical chromosomal abnormalities, -which result due to defects in chromosome number, also include -many types according to whether they result from autosomal or sex -chromosome abnormalities. Pathological examples of this category -include trisomy, or existence of an extra copy of the chromosome, -monosomy, or deficiency of a chromosome which is limited only to -the X chromosome in Turner syndrome, hypodiploidy, where less than -the normal diploid number of chromosomes (46) exists in the nucleus -and hyperdiploidy where larger numbers of chromosomes exist in the -nucleus. Extreme hypodiploidy and hyperdiploidy are cytogenetic -anomalies characteristic of malignant cells. - -Genomic disorders represent another group of genetic diseases due -to defects involving the whole genome, instead of one or few genes. -They can be classified, in turn, into numerical genomic disorders -and functional genomic disorders. Numerical genomic disorders are -exemplified by polyploidy and comprise triploidy where three sets of -the haploid genome (69 chromosomes) exist in the nucleus and, less -frequently, tetraploidy characterized by presence of four sets of the -haploid genome (92 chromosomes) in the nucleus. These aberrations -are, mostly, caused by defective genomic regulatory mechanisms, -e.g. endoreduplication, where DNA replication is not synchronized -properly with corresponding stage of cell division. Functional genomic -disorders are caused by defects in regulatory mechanisms, e.g. genomic -imprinting, responsible for controlling, regulating and synchronizing -genome function in the very early stages of development and can present -as vesicular moles and dermoid cysts. A portion of early miscarriages -might be due to functional genomic defects interfering with survival of -the affected embryo. - -Multifactorial disorders constitute a specific category of genetically- - -Page 3 of 12 - -determined disorders and anomalies caused by the combined effects -of environmental teratogens on defective or susceptible genetic -background. These disorders encompass some of the most common -and prevalent diseases among most populations like hypertension, -diabetes mellitus, and many types of cancer, many psychiatric disorders -and a very large variety of congenital malformations of nearly all body -organs like cleft lip/cleft palate, pyloric stenosis and multiple congenital -heart defects. - -Genetic systemic syndromes include diseases characterized by -affection of multiple organs, sometimes even many systems of the body. -Many single gene disorders and most chromosomal aberrations present -with widespread involvement of many organs and systems, systemic -genetic syndromes are not caused by either of these mechanisms. -Some of these disorders, however, might be caused by still undefined -single genes or by some other unknown mechanisms causing multiple -simultaneous functional deficiencies of many components of the -genome. Defective regulatory mechanisms exerted by microRNA -subclasses over many genes at the same time might be another possible -underlying factor that can be implicated in pathogenesis of these -systemic syndromes. - -Medical Pathogenetics - -The term pathogenetics has been coined to refer to mechanisms -involved in development of genetic diseases. It comprises study -of mutagens, study of mutations, study of different pathogenetic -mechanisms that result from disordered gene function secondary -to change of gene structure, study of pathophysiological alterations -in cellular functions due to disturbances of the metabolic-regulatory -networks that mediate and control these functions and, finally, the -study of pathogenesis of genetic diseases. - -Pathogenesis of genetic diseases - -Genetic diseases are caused by mutations. Mutations are defined -as uncoded or unprogrammed permanent structural alteration of the -genetic material affecting any of its organizational levels. These levels -comprise a wide range beginning with a whole nucleotide or just -part of it (base, sugar, phosphate), DNA, RNA, genes, chromosomes, -mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), up to the whole genome. This cause -and effect relationship between mutagens, mutations and genetic -disorders spans a very wide spectrum of different mechanisms that -follow a peculiar cascade of events beginning with mutation-induced -pathogenetic alterations of the genetic material, leading to disturbed -gene function and deficient or improper synthesis of gene products, -whether these products are proteins or small regulatory miRNA -biomolecules. The ensuing defects in functioning of the regulatory -and metabolic networks that control cellular activities result in -development of multiple and variable defect-specific pathophysiological -derangements that culminate in pathogenesis of genetic disease. - -Mutagens - -Mutagens are factors that can cause mutations. Mutagens are -plentiful in our life. In fact, we live and survive in a mutagenic world, -and probably with the exception of pure water, any compound in our -environment could be a potential mutagenic factor under favorable -circumstances. Mutagens can be classified according to their nature or -according to their recognizable pathogenetic and pathophysiological -effects on exposed cells. According to their nature, mutagens are -classified into four main categories: chemical mutagens, physical -mutagens, biological mutagens and changes of structural configuration -of bases of DNA and changes in energy states of bonds between these - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 4 of 12 - -bases [4]. Classification of mutagens based on their effects recognizes -four major groups: non-specific mutagens, carcinogens, clastogens and -teratogens (Table 2). - -Types of mutation - -Mutation might be classified to many different types according to -the parameters used for classification which include the nature, the -target, the magnitude and the effect of the mutational event, among -many other criteria (Table 3). The effects of mutation differ widely -according to many factors. These factors include the nature and -target of the mutagenic factor causing the mutation, the timing and -magnitude of the resulting damage, the genetic constitution of the -affected individual and the balance between synergistic mutagenic -effects and anti-mutation mechanisms of the genetic material. The -damaging effects of mutation are attributed to the defects they cause -in functioning of mutated genes. Since synthesis of proper gene -products, necessary for mediating cellular activities, depends primarily -on integrity of the genetic information embodied within the specific - -base sequence of the gene, changes or mutation of the exact number -or the peculiar arrangement of these bases is expected to result in -deficient or disturbed gene function. This disturbance might express -itself as production of structurally defective gene product, deficient -synthesis of enough product or disturbance in regulatory mechanisms -responsible for mediating, monitoring, harmonizing and controlling -gene functions. - -Somatic mutations refer to mutations of the genome of somatic -cells. The effects of somatic mutations depend on many factors -including the type of cell, the genetic constitution of affected cells, -selective targeting of nuclear and/or mitochondrial genome and the -mutation burden of the cell. According to the interactive processes -involving these factors, somatic mutations might result in cell death if -the mutation-induced pathophysiological alterations of the cell exceed -its ability to obviate and correct these alterations. Milder alterations can -cause deranged cellular function(s) and limited or progressive failure -and loss of cellular activities, e.g. progressive organ failure syndrome - -According to effect - -According to nature - -Examples - -1. Physical mutagens - -1.Particulate radiations: X- ray, -alpha particles, neutrons, positrons, -gamma rays, protons. -2. UV waves -3. Solar radiation & electromagnetic -waves -4. Thermal exposure -5. Mechanical agitation - -2. Chemical mutagens - -Organichydrocarbons, acridine -derivatives, manganese, nitrous -acid, hydroxylamine, base analogs, -sulfonate compounds, insecticides, -asbestos, herbicides, heavy metals. - -1. Carcinogens -Mutagens that induce malignant transformation and -development of cancer - -2. Clastogens -Mutagens that cause breakage of chromosomes - -3. Teratogens -Mutagens that cause congenital malformations in -developing embryos - -4. Non-specific mutagens -Mutagens that cause non-specific mutagenic damage to -the genetic material. - -Mechanisms and effects - -1. Breakage of nucleicacids -2. Chromosome breaks -3. Oxidation of deoxyribose -4. Formation of peroxides -5. Deamination of bases -6. Dehydroxylation of bases -7. Ionization and formation -of ion tracks/ion clusters -8. Generation of freeradicals -9. Provocation of carcinogenesis -10. Formation of pyrimidine dimers -11. Denaturation of DNA - -1. Base transition -2. Base transversion -3. Deamination of bases -4. Generation of free -radicals -5. Interruption of base -Sequence by intercalation -6. Provocation of -carcinogenesis -7. Cytopathic effects -following mitDNA -damage -8. Alkylation -9. Adduct formation - -3. Biological mutagens - -1. Viruses: rubella virus, -cytomegalovirus, HIV and herpes virus. -2. Toxoplasma gondii. - -1. Insertional mutagenesis -2. Provocation of carcinogenesis - -4. Change of bases/energy -States of bases of DNA - -Tautomerism, Hydration of bases - -Base transition - -5. Metabolic - derangements - -1. High acidity -2. Dehydration -3. Peroxidation - -Table 2: Classification of mutagens. - -Depurination of nucleic acids -Provocation of aberrant DNA replication. - -Classification of mutation - -1. Induced versus spontaneous mutation - -2. Nuclear versus mitochondrial mutation - -3. Somatic versus germinal mutation - -4. Static versus dynamic mutation - -5. Pathological versus non-pathological mutation - -6. Persistent versus reversible mutation - -7. Point, Small, Gross, Genomic mutation - -8. Base, Sugar, Phosphate group mutation - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - -Table 3: Classification of different types of mutation. - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -following overexposure to radiation. Somatic mutations affecting the -proto-oncogenes or genes regulating DNA repair systems can result in -malignant transformation of the cell and development of cancer. - -Germinal mutations, on the other hand, are mutations that -affect genomes of germinal cells that participate in fertilization -and determination of the genetic constitution of the offspring. If -the particular ovum or sperm affected by the mutation happens to -participate in fertilization and zygote formation, the mutation will be -inherited and transferred to all cells of the offspring, and a carrier or -disease state might result according to the nature of the mutated gene -and the pattern of its inheritance. - -Static mutations are mutations that are transferred to offspring -of carriers of these mutations without change. For instance, if a child -inherits the mutated gene causing, e.g. Marfan syndrome, from an -affected parent he will have the same mutation of the inherited gene in -his genome. Dynamic mutations, on the other hand, signify mutational -events that increase in magnitude upon transfer from carriers of these -mutations to their offspring. This type of mutation characterizes a large, -ever expanding number of widely varied peculiar groups of genetic -disorders collectively referred to as triplet repeat expansion disorders. -In this specific type of mutation, microsatellite repeats consisting of -certain number of codons, or triplets, of a parental gene increases in -number upon transfer to an offspring. If the increase, or expansion, -attains a certain threshold, the offspring becomes a carrier of the -dynamic mutation. Further transfer to offspring of next generations -results in much wider expansion, or pathological increase of the -number of the repeats in the gene leading to damage of gene structure -and interference with gene function, thus leading to development of -genetic disease due to this pathogenetic mechanism of triplet repeat -expansion. - -Fragile X mental retardation syndrome represents the prototype -of this category of genetic disorders due to triplet repeat expansion. -Normally, the FMR gene, existing on the terminal region of the long -arm of the X chromosome, regulates the synthesis of an important -protein necessary for functioning of many organs, including the brain. -In normal subjects, the gene has nearly 5-50 CGG repeats. Female -carriers of this gene in its mutated form have between 120 up to 200 -repeats, a state known as premutation state. Affected male offspring -of these carrier females have much larger numbers of these repeats, -more than 200 up to few hundreds, in their gene. This triplet repeat -expansion results in disruption of gene structure and interference -with gene function through different pathogenetic mechanisms, e.g. -chromosome instability or fragility, all ending in either suppression of -transcription and deficient synthesis of the gene product or synthesis of -defective product, thus leading to development of disease. Triplet repeat -expansion disorders comprise large number of diseases differing from -each other according to the mutated gene. Each of these diseases has -its specific repeat sequence and threshold number for its development. -For example, the triplet of Huntington disease and some types of -spinocerebellar ataxia is CAG while that of Friedreich ataxia is GAA. -In view of the specific nature of mutations of these diseases, they are -inherited in nontraditional way and account, at least in part, for the -phenomenon of genetic anticipation. - -Pathological versus non-pathological mutations: The deleterious -effects of mutation are determined by many factors. Mutations affecting -functional elements of the genome, i.e. functional genes, can result -in gene dysfunction causing deficient synthesis of the gene product -or synthesis of defective product. These mutations are expected to -cause pathophysiological changes and disease phenotypes in affected - -Page 5 of 12 - -individuals, and represent an overt example of harmful pathological -disease-causing mutations. On the other hand, mutations affecting -non-functional regions of the genome, e.g. intergenic areas of DNA -and intronic segments of genes, do not result in pathophysiological -alterations and are referred to as non-pathological mutations. - -The concept of protein domain and its relation to effects of -mutation - -The amino acids that constitute each protein are organized, both -structurally and functionally, into distinctive number of interrelated, -sometimes interactive, regions or domains. Each domain consists of a -defined number of certain amino acids arranged in a specific manner, -and performs a particular role either in shaping and maintaining the -structural configuration of the protein (structural domain), or in -mediating one or more of the biological function(s) of the protein -(functional domain). Each protein has its own specific structural -configuration as regards the number, the spatial arrangement and -distribution of its domains. In view of their fundamental role in -maintaining structural and functional integrity and identity of the -protein, protein domains are highly conserved among most species [5]. - -Mutation results in change(s) of one or more of the protein domains -depending on the type of the mutation, the magnitude of its effects and -the nature of the protein encoded by the mutated gene. If mutation -affects one or more or all of the amino acids constituting integral -structural and/or essential functional domain of the protein, deleterious -defects in protein function results. This pathogenetic mechanism -paves the way to significant detrimental effects on the functional -integrity of the protein. If the affected protein mediates specific roles -in cellular activities, e.g. structural components of cell organelles or -signal transducer in metabolic networks, pathophysiological alterations -secondary to loss of these roles ensue with consequent pathogenesis of -genetic disorder. Alternatively, depending on the nature, the effects, the -site and the magnitude of the causative pathogenetic mechanism, some -mutations might primarily affect non-critical or non-integral domains -of the protein. These mutations usually result in subtle conformational -changes, e.g. changes in the molecular weight or the electrophoretic -mobility of the protein that do not impede, or interfere with, the -physiological functions of the protein, and do not cause disease since -they do not significantly disturb the form-function relationship that -confers on each protein its biological potency. Thus, the effects of -genetic mutations are largely dependent on the resulting effects on the -structural integrity as well as the functional capability of the protein. -This fact clarifies, at least in part, the marked variability in potential of -genetic mutations in causing disease and explains absence of any disease -manifestations in spite of presence of mutation in many situations. - -Pathogenetic Mechanisms - -The genetic material controls life activities of the cell through -regulating synthesis of proteins which directly mediate these activities. -Regulatory genes, in addition, control the transcription of many -classes of small RNAs that have fundamental roles in direct and feed- -back regulation of most aspects of the genetic material. Mutations -cause structural alterations of the genetic material. Depending on the -site, nature, magnitude and effects of the mutational event as well as -on the functions and importance of the mutated genes, pathogenetic -mechanisms that result in deficient synthesis of gene products, synthesis -of defective gene products or disturbed regulation of cellular activities -will lead to development of genetic disorders, secondary to the ensuing -pathophysiological alterations of cellular functions. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -The spectrum of pathogenetic mechanisms and the resulting -pathophysiological disturbances that underlie the development of -genetic disorders is quite wide in view of the complexity of the structural -organization of the genome and the strict functional specialization that -characterizes each of its components. Additionally, the obscure nature -and unclear functions of many components of the genetic material, -undoubtedly, conceal many, still unknown, pathogenetic mechanisms -and hinder proper understanding of their exact pathways. It is hoped -that final completion of the human genome project might disclose -the exact and complete structural organization of the human genome. -However, a parallel human genome function project aiming at defining -the complete functional spectrum of the genome seems to be an -indispensable and imperative task in order to finalize our knowledge -of our genetic material. - -Currently defined pathogenetic mechanisms and pathophysiological -alterations implicated in pathogenesis of genetic disorders are too many -to be listed. However, the most common of these mechanisms include -the following: - -1. Loss/damage/duplication/inactivation of nuclear genes - -2. Mutation of mitochondrial genes (mitDNA) - -3. Deficient/defective DNA replication/repair - -4. Triplet repeat expansion disorders - -5. Loss/acquisition/damage/rearrangement of chromosomes - -6. Deficient transcription of mRNA - -7. Transcription of defective mRNA - -8. Deficient/defective post-transcription mRNA repair - -9. Deficient/defective post-transcription modifications of mRNA - -10. Deficient translation of proteins - -11. Translation of defective proteins - -12. Deficient/defective post-translation modification of proteins - -13. Deficient/defective post-translation - -repair of misfolded - -proteins - -14. Deficient/defective post-translation targeting and trafficking of - -proteins - -15. Deficient/defective regulation of cell growth - -16. Deficient/defective regulation of cell division - -17. Deficient/defective regulation of cell differentiation - -18. Deficient/defective regulation of cell migration - -19. Deficient/defective regulation of intercellular contact and cell - -movement - -20. Deficient/defective apoptosis/selection repair - -21. Deficient/defective -cytoskeleton - -regulation of cell architecture and - -22. Defective imprinting - -23. Deficient/defective regulation of cellular functions - -a. Deficient/defective - -transport across cell membrane or - -membranes of cell organelles (transport defects) - -Page 6 of 12 - -b. Deficient/defective transport across cell pores, nuclear pores or - -pores of cell organelles - -(chanellopathies) - -c. Deficient/defective secretion of gene products (protein/enzyme - -deficiency disorders) - -d. Deficient/defective disposal of metabolic waste products - -(storage disorders) - -e. Deficient/defective regulation of intra and inter network - -reactions and interactions: signal transduction disorders - -f. Deficient/defective positioning of structural proteins (protein - -trafficking disorders) - -g. Deficient/defective production of cellular energy: oxidative- - -phosphorylation disorders - -h. Ubiquitination/proteasome degradation defects - -i. Apoptosis defects - -Anti-mutation Mechanisms of the Human Genome - -The human genome develops, persists and works in a hostile -environment full of existing, and continuously generated, mutagens. -Mutational events induced by external mutagens have widespread -detrimental effects on the stability and integrity of the genome as well -as on the stability and integrity of the proteome. Additionally, further -and considerable damage of the structural organization and functional -capabilities of both the genome and the proteome regularly occurs on -continuous and progressive basis due to the continuously generated -burden of internal mutagens that result from the diverse metabolic -activities of the exceedingly large number of metabolic networks of -the cell. Unless a powerful and effective protective and repair system -actively participates in protecting the genome and proteome of the -cell against the deleterious effects of mutations, and in efficient repair -of resulting damage, maintaining the stability and integrity of both of -these bio-systems that constitute the framework of life activities within -the cell would have been quite impossible. - -The human genome is endowed with a spectacular multifaceted -strong anti-mutation system responsible for maintaining its stability -and integrity, as well as preserving its identity. It acts by protecting -the genome from the detrimental effects of mutation and by repairing -mutation-induced damage. Obviously, the balance between the -pathological effects of mutation and the ability of the anti-mutation -system to counteract and to reduce the consequences of these effects -represents the main factor that determines the likelihood of having -and developing mutation-induced genetic disease. The human anti- -mutation system comprises both innate mechanisms common to, -and shared by, all individuals, e.g. degeneracy of the genetic code, and -acquired aspects determined by the inherited genetic background of -each human being, e.g. DNA repair system (Table 4). - -Structural organization of the human genome - -The peculiar structural organization of the human genome -represents the first innate anti-mutation mechanism in view of the -presence of large interspersed portions of non-functional intragenic -introns and inter-genic DNA sequences and segments that can be -mutated without having appreciable deleterious functional effects. In -addition to functional sequences needed for synthesis of protein and of -regulatory small RNA species, the human genome has a considerable -amount of repetitive DNA sequences, including both noncoding - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 7 of 12 - -Mechanism - -Types and pathways and comments - -Structural features of DNA - -1. Structural organization of the genome - -1. Nuclear genome. -2. Mitochondrial genome - -2. Structural features of DNA - -3. Degeneracy of the genetic code - -Complementary strand stores genetic -information - -Multiple point mutations might occur -without affecting synthesized protein - -4. Nuclear localization of DNA - -Physical protection of nuclear genome - -5. DNA-associated proteins - -6. Replication proofreading system - -7. Genetic repair systems - -8. Protein repair systems - -9. Silencing of transposons by piwiRNA - -10. Antioxidant enzyme systems - -11. Apoptosis - -12. Melatonin - -1. Physical barriers -2. Biochemical buffers -3. Deactivating biomolecules -4. Modulation of charge transport -5. Limitation of DNA helix distortion - -Prophylactic pathway during DNA -replication - -A. Nuclear DNA repair -1. Base excision repair. -2. Nucleotide excision repair -3. Direct reversal repair. -4. Mismatch repair -5. Recombination repair -B. RNA repair/editing system -Post-transcription repair/editing of some -mRNA defects via guide RNA (gRNA)/ -editosome complex -C. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) repair - -Correction of post-translation protein -misfolding/aggregation by chaperones - -Reduces transposon-induced mutations -during development - -Prophylactic pathway against spread of -mutations of heavily or lethally mutated -genomes to daughter cells - -Anti-clastogenic, anti-mutagenic, -anti-carcinogenic and anti-oxidant -compound. - -Table 4: Anti-mutation mechanisms of the human genome. - -repetitive sequences and multiple copy genes and gene fragments, a -large number (19000-21000) of pseudogenes [6], a considerable sizable -portion (about 1/6th of the total genome size) as pyknons [7], a quite -large portion (nearly 40% of the total genome size) as transposons [8], -and large numbers of multiple copies of functional genes that share the -same regulatory function and whose suppression or damage by mutation -can be tolerated by other genes having the same function. These -peculiar structural features of the human genome allows for occurrence -of mutational events in many segments of the genome without having -appreciable functional defects. Even if some of these DNA sequences -have important roles in genome function, their presence in multiple -repetitive copies can greatly reduce, or even nullify, the consequences -of mutational damage. - - The mitochondrial genome - -The presence of multiple copies, hundreds to thousands, of -mitochondrial genes within the mitochondria of each cell is crucial -in obviating devastating mutation-induced damage to these vital -organelles in view of their role in production of ATP. This feature of -mitochondrial genome allows for considerable burden of mutations -to affect it before appreciable pathological consequences result. It is -estimated that mutations affecting nearly 80% of certain mitochondrial -genes might occur before pathological manifestations of mitochondrial -genetic diseases make their appearance due to this multiple copy feature -of mtDNA. - -DNA exists as a double stranded structure composed of two -tightly bound strands, each strand consisting of a sugar-phosphate -backbone with opposing nitrogenous bases each linked by a glycosidic -linkage to the sugar of its parent strand and by hydrogen bonds to the -complementary base on the opposing strand. This specific structural -organization of DNA serves many purposes. It stabilizes the dynamics -of the molecule, permits replication and duplication of the genetic -material, protects the interiorly located bases and, most importantly, -stores a template or copy of the genetic information ready for use -in case of damage of the other strand. If small or gross mutational -events affect important functional portions of the genetic material, -repair mechanisms can restore the exact sequence of the damaged or -lost or deleted parts through restoration mechanisms based on the -complementary information of the other strand. Mutations leading -to damage of corresponding segments of both strands represent a -catastrophic event to the genome due to absence of the sequence -database needed for the repair mechanism to define the exact base -sequence of the newly synthesized segment in place of the deleted or -grossly damaged segment. - -Degeneracy of the genetic code - -Degeneracy of the genetic code represents the third innate anti- -mutation mechanism of the human genome. This feature permits -the occurrence of same-sense point mutations in functional codons -without changing the amino acid defined by the mutated codon. Since -some amino acids, as part of a specific protein domain, play critical -roles in attaining and maintaining correct protein structure and -mediating proper protein function, mis-sense point mutations leading -to replacement of these essential amino acids by other amino acids -that can’t perform the functions of the original amino acids might -result in detrimental effects on the structural integrity and stability of -the protein followed by deleterious consequences on its physiological -function. Hence, degeneracy of the genetic code allows for occurrence -of many point mutations, the commonest type of mutational events -and the commonest cause of genetic disorders, without changing the -final structure of the synthesized protein, thus protecting against, and -obviating, the pathological effects of these mutations. - -Nuclear localization of DNA - -The localization of DNA, deeply inside the cell nucleus, represents -a fourth innate anti-mutation mechanism of the human genome -because it acts as a physical barrier against many mutagens that have -to overcome many obstacles of cellular defense mechanisms in order -to affect the nuclear genome. These defenses include the extra-cellular -environment, the cell membrane, the cytoplasmic, the cytoplasmic -enzymes and phagocytic cellular organelles and the cytoplasmic and -nuclear antioxidant enzyme systems. The DNA-associated or DNA- -binding proteins, in addition to their essential roles in regulating -transcriptional processes of most genes, also play fundamental roles in -protecting the DNA from the damaging effects of many mutagens, in -particular the free radicals that are generated during metabolic activities -of the cell. They act as firm physical barriers and strong biochemical -buffers that effectively modify and deactivate biomolecules of many -chemical mutagens or damaging factors that might harm the DNA. -They mediate this protective role through many mechanisms including -modulation of charge transport of oxidative agents within the DNA, -limitation of DNA helix distortion and regulation of protein-dependent -alterations in DNA base stacking [9]. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -RNA-proofreading System - -The human transcriptome, being subjected to the same mutational -events that can alter and damage the DNA, seems to have efficient anti- -mutation mechanisms to guard against occurrence of errors during -RNA transcription and to correct and repair some post-transcription -defects of mRNA that can cause errors during protein translation. -Separate RNA-proofreading system seems to exist and act, probably, -during transcription by relying on the sequence complementarity -information of the complementary silent or non-transcribing strand of -DNA, rather than of the active transcribing strand. This behavior can -be interpreted, partly, by classic principles of thermodynamics because -relying on the sequence of the energetically active, transiently unstable, -strand to ensure accurate transcription might result in improper -defective transcription if mismatch errors occur due to, e.g. polymerase -dysfunction. The risk of faulty transcription depending on the sequence -complementarity information of the less energetic, more stable, non- -transcribing strand is, probably, less than comparable risk expected -to occur if transcription depends on the sequence complementarity -information of the active strand. This assumption might, partly, offer -reasonable explanation for the poorly understandable behavior of -gene function where transcription of complementary mRNA, instead -of straightforward synthesis of identical mRNA transcript, is the rule. -It might also explain the seemingly needless, indirect and energy -consuming processes involving transcription of complementary, rather -than identical, mRNA transcripts that have to be decoded again by -rRNA and tRNA in the ribosome during translation. Expenditure of -energy for keeping transcriptome integrity is consistent with general -rules of thermodynamics since maintaining stability of any structured -system is dependent on the equilibrium between its natural tendency to -degrade and external energy supply needed to keep it in a stable form. - -Replication proofreading system - -Preservation of genomic identity of the organism depends -exclusively on accurate replication and synthesis of two identical copies -of the genome during cell division, followed by transfer, or inheritance, -of each copy to each daughter cell. In this manner, all cells descendent -from a parent cell have nuclear genomes identical to that of the parent -cell. The majority of spontaneous point mutations of the nuclear genome -are prone to occur during cell division, mostly during DNA synthesis -or the replication phase of the process. The replication proofreading -system acts in a prophylactic way to ensure accurate insertion or -addition of the proper nucleotide to the newly synthesized strand of -replicating DNA. This prophylactic function is fundamental to reduce -the rate of inevitable replication mistakes to minimum levels that could -be dealt with efficiently with the DNA repair mechanisms. In spite of -the impressively fast and accurate ability of the enzymes responsible -for DNA synthesis, DNA polymerases, most of them have additional -proofreading ability to ensure accurate error-free DNA replication and, -hence, maintaining and preserving the stability, integrity and identity of -the genome during cell division, as well as during transfer of the genetic -material from parents to offspring. - -Genetic repair systems - -Genetic repair systems responsible for correcting and repairing -many different types of point and small mutations comprise both -nuclear DNA repair system and mitochondrial DNA repair system. -Genetic function and genetic repair represent two sides of the same -coin. Without the persevering continuous, active and effective -surveillance exerted by the genetic repair systems to detect and repair -the continuously and persistently occurring mutations, maintaining - -Page 8 of 12 - -stability and integrity of the genome would be an impossible task. These -repair systems act via many different mechanisms according to the type, -location and magnitude of damage induced in the genetic material [10]. - -The pivotal role played by the mitochondrial genome in generating -ATP, without which life can neither begin nor persist, in addition to the -many other critical metabolic and regulatory functions of mitochondrial -genes, requires the presence of an efficient system for repairing mtDNA -mutations. The need for mitochondrial genome repair system is further -imposed on the cell in view of the high mutation rate of mitochondrial -genes which lack many of the anti-mutation and protective mechanisms -available to nuclear genes. Similar to the nuclear genome repair system, -mitochondrial repair system includes many repair pathways and -mechanisms: base excision repair, direct reversal repair, mismatch -repair, and recombination repair. Nucleotide excision repair (NER) -pathway, however, seems not to be working in the mitochondria [11]. - -RNA repair/editing system - -RNA editing refers to molecular modifications of nucleotides of -RNA through chemical changes in the base makeup of the molecule. -Such changes appear to involve mRNA, tRNA as well as many types -of small or microRNA. RNA editing occurs in the cell nucleus and -the cytosol, as well as in mitochondria and is mediated by a complex -repair system comprising many species of small RNA (guide RNA) and -large protein complexes known as the editosomes. The pathways and -mechanisms of RNA editing include many diverse processes: nucleoside -base modifications such as cytidine (C) to uridine (U) and adenosine -(A) to inosine (I) deamination, as well as non-templated insertions of -nucleotide. RNA editing in mRNAs effectively alters the amino acid -sequence of the encoded protein so that it differs from that predicted by -the genomic DNA sequence. Though mRNA editing is used by the cell -in many instances to allow for synthesis of more than one protein from -the same mRNA transcript, e.g. synthesis of both apolipoprotein B-100 -and apolipoprotein B-48 from the same mRNA in liver cells, it can also -be used to repair missense or termination mutations of the molecule -which can have deleterious effects on the synthesized protein. Specific -endonucleases and ligases for double stranded species of RNA have -been defined in many prokaryotes [12] and it might be just a matter of -time before defining their functional counterparts in eukaryotes and -human cells. - -Protein repair systems - -Accurate post-translation structural configuration of newly -synthesized polypeptide chains is a fundamental conformational -modification for most proteins to become functionally active -biomolecules. The maturation from primary to quaternary protein -structure involves many changes, e.g. folding and maintenance of -steric and spatial relationships between the different domains of -the protein. Conformational defects in proteins that might happen -during these modifications can lead to formation of misfolded and/or -aggregated non-functional molecules. The human genome comprises -a large number of genes that code a complex system composed of -large numbers of specific protein families and subfamilies known -as molecular chaperones. These proteins have many important and -diverse functions in cellular activities, e.g. assisting non-covalent -folding or unfolding and assembly or disassembly of macromolecular -structures, including proteins. Prevention of misfolding and/or -aggregation of newly synthesized polypeptide chains, which turn -them to nonfunctional biomolecules, is a major and fundamental -function of molecular chaperones. Other physiological functions of -chaperones include: transport across mitochondrial membranes and - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -the endoplasmic reticulum and assistance in protein degradation -[13]. - -Molecular chaperones, probably, exert critical roles in maintaining -stability and integrity of the proteome. This state of protein homeostasis, -proteostasis, is a prerequisite for proper control and regulation of -cellular metabolic networks by proteins and is mandatory for efficient -mediation of cellular activities. Specific species of molecular chaperones, -surveillance chaperones, are responsible for constant surveillance of the -proteome to ensure proper protein homeostasis. Age-related decline or -mutation-induced defects in proteome stability and integrity results in -progressive aggregation and faulty conformational changes of proteins, -both of which are associated with, and underlie, the development -and pathogenesis of many genetic diseases like Alzheimer disease, -Parkinson disease, prion diseases and many others [14]. - -Silencing of transposon activity during development - -Transposons constitute a considerable portion, nearly 40%, of the -human nuclear genome. Transposon activities might have contradictory -effects on the stability and integrity of the nuclear genome. They -might behave in a harmful way and act as major potential causes of -spontaneous mutations of the nuclear genome. They can make a copy of -themselves and insert the new copy in another site, or they can detach -themselves from their location and get inserted at different sites of -the genome. In both conditions they result in insertional mutagenesis -with consequent deleterious effects on genomic stability and genomic -integrity. If they get inserted in a functional segment of the genome they -lead to structural disruption and loss of function of the affected segment -with resultant pathological effects. Hence, over activity or uncontrolled -activity of transposons can have detrimental and devastating effects -on embryogenesis, differentiation and development, and can lead to -pathogenesis of a wide variety of congenital malformations and genetic -defects [8]. The human genome, however, has a unique control system -composed of a specific subtype of small or micro RNA molecules, known -as piwiRNA, or piRNA, composed of RNA-piwi protein complexes. -They are thought to be involved in gene silencing, most specifically -the silencing of transposons. The majority of piRNAs are antisense to -transposon sequences suggesting that transposons are the main target -of piRNA. In mammals, the marked activity of piRNAs in silencing of -transposons and control of their activities is most important during -the development of the embryo in order to reduce the rate and risk of -transposon-induced mutations during this sensitive period of life [15]. - -Alternatively, transposon activity may lead to creation and -construction of new genetic combinations that may have specific -functions. Within this context, they would be considered as one of -the genetic biological mechanisms involved in, and responsible for, -evolutionary diversity of the genome and the proteome. They can also -cause tangible increases in the amount of the genetic material due to -recurrent synthesis and addition of multiple new copies of transposable -elements to the nuclear genome. - -Antioxidant enzyme systems - -The continuous functioning of the exceedingly huge number of -metabolic networks that mediate cellular activities in living cells results -in continuous generation of many different types of useful as well as -of harmful metabolic by-products. Oxidant free radicals constitute one -of the most crucial categories of these harmful by-products in view of -their ability to induce widespread damage in many cellular components -including membranes, organelles and structural macromolecules like -lipids and proteins. This structural damage, unless counteracted by - -Page 9 of 12 - -opposing antioxidant mechanisms, results in progressive degradation -of cellular constituents with consequent resultant pathophysiological -alterations of cellular functions, leading ultimately to disease. Although -low concentrations of reactive oxygen species may be beneficial, or -even necessary in mediating many important cellular processes, e.g. -defense against invading micro-organisms and intracellular signaling -pathways, nevertheless, higher concentrations of these free radicals play -a causative role in the aging process as well as in pathogenesis of many -human diseases, including immune deficiency, neurodegeneration and -malignancy. Oxidative damage of DNA, RNA and binding proteins by -free radicals represents an important category of detrimental genetic -mutations induced by endogenous chemical mutagens inevitably -generated during cellular metabolic activities and other cellular -functions. Living cells have several efficient non-enzymatic and -enzymatic antioxidant activities that are responsible for eliminating -and/or terminating the chain reactions following generation of free -radicals, as a safeguard against their damaging effects on cellular -components and cellular functions. Enzymatic antioxidant systems of -the cell comprise many different types of antioxidant enzymes, notably -superoxide dismutase, catalase, thioredoxinreductase, glutathione -peroxidase and various other peroxidases. Efficient production of -these antioxidant enzymes and proper regulation of their functions -is mandatory to protect both the genome and proteome and to keep -and maintain redox homeostasis of the cytoplasm which is a critical -requirement for normal mediation of cellular activities [16]. - -Apoptosis - -Apoptosis refers to programmed cell death and represents a universal -biological behavior of most living cells necessary, in conjunction -with other life-regulating mechanisms, for maintaining the vital -balance between life and death that governs optimal life conditions of -multicellular organisms. Apoptosis plays fundamental and crucial roles -in normal growth and development as well as in normal differentiation -and determination of the proper final structural architecture of cells, -tissues and organs. Faulty timing or incorrect accomplishment of -specific and selective apoptotic processes during specific life stages of -the cell might result in devastating consequences on cellular functions -that range from dysfunction to malformation. For instance, improper -regulation of apoptosis during embryonic and fetal life can lead to the -development of many types of congenital malformations. In many -conditions, it might ultimately culminate in pathogenesis of disease or -in premature cell death [17]. - -Apoptosis plays a crucial role in maintaining genomic stability -and integrity, not of individual cells, but of the organism as a whole. -Induction of apoptotic mechanisms in heavily mutated or lethally -mutated cells leads to death of the cell and prevents transfer of these -mutations to its putative descendant daughter cells. This fundamental -prophylactic anti-mutation role of apoptosis in cellular activities and -life prospects of living organisms has more far-reaching effects on many -important aspects related to the balance between, and the incidence -of, normal and mutant genotypes within species-specific gene pools. -Additionally, apoptosis can affect in an appreciable manner genomic -identity of living organisms because mutation-induced evolutionary or -decadence pathways are largely dependent on the outcome of certain -apoptotic mechanisms operating during certain stages of the cell cycle. - -Apoptosis may be looked at as a special genomic protective -pathway involving compulsory death of somatic cells overburdened -with mutation. Over mutated cells are driven to their ends through -specific apoptosis-mediating pathways to protect other cells from the -hazardous risks of their malignant transformation. Apoptosis might, - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -also, represent a cellular economic adaptation behavior by getting rid -of mutated, diseased, energy consuming and non-functioning harmful -cells. In this way, it performs important protective anti-mutation -mechanism to maintain genomic integrity through executing and -getting rid of heavily mutated cells, to prevent spread of their mutations, -through division, to daughter generations. - -Melatonin - -Melatonin is a hormone synthesized by the pineal gland, bone -marrow cells, epithelial cells and lymphocytes. Melatonin receptors are -distributed in most organs, a finding reflecting its widespread roles in -regulating various physiological and psychological processes. Many in -vitro and animal studies revealed that melatonin has diverse functions -including effective protection of cells against radiation-induced -chromosome breakage and inhibition of tumor development in -animals exposed to experimental chemical carcinogenesis. Melatonin -was shown to have protective effect against oxidative DNA damage by -chemical inactivation of DNA-damaging agent as well as by stimulating -DNA repair mechanisms. These important anti-mutagenic and anti- -clastogenic effects of melatonin can be linked with its ability to protect -DNA against oxidative damage. It may exert this antioxidant action -by eliminating harmful reactive oxygen radicals or by stimulating the -repair processes of oxidative stress-induced damage of DNA [18]. - -Patterns of Inheritance - -The specific patterns of inheritance of genetic diseases describe -the characteristic features which outline, control and regulate the -transmission of genetic diseases from normal, carrier or affected -parents to their offspring. These features vary widely according to the -actions and interactions of many factors in addition to many other -modifying conditions. - -Genetic diseases are inherited in many different way depending -on many variable factors that include the cause of the genetic defect -whether due to single gene disorder, polygenic disorder, mitochondrial -mutation, chromosomal aberration or multifactorial causation, the -gene locus whether it lies on an autosome or on a sex chromosome, -the nature of the gene product whether it is a structural protein or a -catalytic enzyme, the nature of the underlying mutational event whether -it is a static or a dynamic mutation, the status of the transmitting -parent(s), the causative pathogenetic mechanism(s) underlying the -development of the disease and whether this transmission happens in a -classic traditional manner or within the context of an abnormal genetic -framework [19-22]. However, two major patterns of inheritance of -genetic diseases could be recognized: classic, Mendelian or traditional -patterns that characterize rules of inheritance of single gene disorders, - -Traditional patterns of inheritance Non-traditional patterns of inheritance - -1. Autosomal dominant inheritance - -1. Inheritance of mitochondrial disorders - -2. Autosomal recessive inheritance - -2. Inheritance of chromosomal -abnormalities - -3. X-linked dominant inheritance - -3. Inheritance of multifactorial diseases - -4. X-linked recessive inheritance - -4. Inheritance of triplet repeat expansion -disorders - -5. Y-linked inheritance - -5. Uniparentaldisomy - -6. Inheritance of microdeletion/ -microduplication defects - -7. Genetic imprinting - -8. Gonadal Mosaicism - -Table 5: Patterns of inheritance of genetic disorders. - -Page 10 of 12 - -and non-classic, non-mendelian or non-traditional patterns that -delineate features of inheritance of other types of genetic diseases -(Table 5) [23]. - -The locus of the mutant gene defines four different categories of -single gene disorders each having its own specific pattern of inheritance: -autosomal diseases caused by genes located on the autosomes, -X-linked diseases caused by genes located on the X chromosome, -Y-linked diseases caused by genes located on the Y chromosome and -mitochondrial disorders caused by mutations of mitochondrial genes. - -The status of the transmitting parent, or both parents, determines -many different aspects of the pattern(s) of inheritance of the disease. -For single gene disorders, five main patterns of inheritance based -on the way of transmission of the single mutant gene relative to the -status of the transmitting parent(s) are recognized. These patterns -include: autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, X-linked dominant, -X-linked recessive and Y-linked inheritance patterns. - -For human traits and diseases, dominance refers to the ability of the -mutant gene to confer a specific phenotype on the individual harboring -it when present in a single copy or allele. Recessive genes need to exist -in two copies, or alleles, in order that a specific recessive disease or -trait phenotype can show up. The difference between dominant and -recessive diseases can be attributed, in part, to the different underlying -pathogenetic mechanisms and might be explained in view of the specific -pathological characteristics of each type since dominant diseases result, -mostly, from deficient and/or defective production of structural proteins -produced by mutant genes. These structural proteins are vital integral -constituents of nearly all cellular components, e.g. cell membranes, -cytoskeleton, cell organelles, spindle apparatus, chromatin material and -mitochondrial components. In autosomal dominant (AD) diseases, -nearly 50% reduction in amount or functions of structural proteins -happens which represents a drastic burden that can’t be tolerated by the -cell, hence the expression of the disease phenotype in heterozygotes of -AD genes. Autosomal recessive diseases, on the other hand, comprise -a majority of genetic diseases resulting mostly from deficient and/or -defective production of proteins that act as enzymes rather than as -structural proteins, e.g. inborn errors of metabolism. Enzyme dynamics -allow for prolonged and sustained mediation of recurring metabolic -reactions by small amounts of the enzyme, sometimes as low as 5% of -the amount needed under normal physiological conditions. Hence, for -an autosomal recessive (AR) disorder to be expressed in an affected -patient, mutation of both parental genes is required, thus necessitating -a heterozygous disease status of both parents, except for exceptional -abnormal conditions like, for instance, uniparentaldisomy where both -homologous chromosomes are inherited from the same parent. - -Clinical Genetics - -Clinical genetics implies the application of concepts of basic genetic -knowledge in managing patients and carriers of genetic diseases -[24,25]. The prime challenge in clinical genetics practice is to attain -accurate diagnosis of the genetic disease. In many cases, the diagnosis -might be straightforward due to pathognomonic clinical phenotypes, -in others it can be confirmed via specific diagnostic investigations, e.g. -cytogenetic studies for chromosomal abnormalities, mutation analysis -for single gene disorders and biochemical assays for metabolic errors. -Unfortunately, in much more cases, accurate diagnosis of genetic -diseases represents a real challenge due to many factors headed by -lack of sufficient information regarding the structure and functions -of the human genome and human proteome. Proper diagnosis is not -only important for defining effective therapeutic and/or prophylactic - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -measures, but it is also crucial for offering accurate counseling advice to -patients as well as to their concerned family members. - -Clinical classification of genetic disorders delineates five major -distinct disease categories: chromosomal aberrations, congenital -malformations, in born errors of metabolism, mitochondrial disorders -and systemic genetic syndromes, in addition to system-specific or -organ-specific diseases affecting specific systems or individual organs, -even specific cell lines, of the body. Within each of these categories, -the defect might be sporadic affecting only the index case or it might -be familiar when multiple family members are similarly affected with -the disease. Isolated genetic defects refer to single tissue/organ/system -affection without affection of any other parts, e.g. cardiomyopathy, -retinitis pigmentosum or polydactyly. Conversely, systemic genetic -disorders affect multiple organs/systems, e.g. Marfan syndrome. -Chromosomal aberrations have, in most cases, widespread affection of -many, sometimes most body parts due to involvement of large numbers -of genes in their causation. The same applies also to most mitochondrial -disorders and congenital malformations. However, some malformations -are isolated anomalies affecting only single organ or localized part of -the fetus, like the heart in isolated congenital heart disease. Similarly, -multifactorial diseases caused by the mutational pathogenetic effect(s) -of environmental teratogens on a susceptible genetic background -might be isolated defects, e.g. pyloric stenosis and cleft lip or palate, -or present with multiple organ/system affection like syndromes caused -by teratogenic drugs and syndromes caused by intrauterine infections. - -Clinical diagnosis of genetic diseases proceeds along the same -traditional protocols followed in other medical specialties that -comprise history taking, examination and diagnostic investigations. -History taking is very important in clinical practice and nowhere is this -illustrated more clearly than in clinical genetics. In many genetically- -determined disorders like congenital malformations, history taking -must be dated back to prenatal, sometimes to preconception or even -to premarital history of the mother or of both parents. Other aspects of -history crucial for establishment of proper diagnosis of many types of -genetic diseases include perinatal, neonatal, developmental history and -family history of similar or related diseases. - -Laboratory diagnosis of genetic diseases is currently achieved -through large panel of investigations. Some of these investigations -are specific for genetically-determined disorders like cytogenetic -investigations for chromosomal abnormalities, biochemical assays -for inborn errors of metabolism and molecular mutation analysis for -nuclear and mitochondrial single gene disorders. A large panel of -conventional investigations complements classic genetic diagnostic -approaches and represents an indispensable supplementary diagnostic -techniques needed for detecting pathological defects associated -with genetic diseases. These conventional diagnostic techniques -include, for instance, radio-imaging and ultrasonographic studies, -electro-physiological investigations, histopathological examinations, -biochemical assays, and many others. - -Treatment of genetic diseases aims primarily at alleviating -sufferings of patients and avoiding development of complications. -With the exception of surgically correctable congenital malformations, -genetic diseases are considered as incurablein view of presence of -the underlying inherited defect in all cells of the body. However, the -wide spectrum of currently available therapeutic and prophylactic -approaches can provide appreciable, sometimes effective, improvement -for large numbers of patients affected with varying categories of genetic -disorders. These effective management approaches comprise, mostly, -conventional measures like drug therapy, nutritional manipulation, - -Page 11 of 12 - -enzyme replacement, organ transplantation and surgical intervention. -Though genetic therapies for genetic diseases represent the ultimate -hope of curing these defects, they are still in the experimental stage -because of lack of comprehensive knowledge of the human genome. -These genetic therapies include single gene therapy trials where a normal -gene is intended to be inserted via viral vectors, or some other vectors, -into the nuclear genome to replace deficient or defective function of a -disease gene, and whole genome therapy trials like stem cell therapy. -Other promising genetic therapies include myriads of approaches -targeting all pathogenetic mechanisms and biomolecules involved -in pathogenesis of genetic disorders, e.g. mRNA and micro RNA, -translated and regulatory proteins, cell organelles, cell membranes and -intercellular compartments. Examples of genetic therapies include use of -interfering miRNA molecules or antisense oligonucleotides to suppress -translation of harmful proteins, e.g. oncoproteins of tumor cells and -the use of engineered chaperone proteins to correct some misfolding -defects of translated proteins resulting from defective post-translation -modifications of normally synthesized proteins. In fact, the list of newly -invented therapeutic and alleviating measures for genetic disorders is -continuously expanding quite rapidly, and it is hoped that gradual and -complete cure of considerable proportion of genetic defects would be -attained the more we know about the actual regulatory mechanisms -that maintain the structural and functional integrity of the human -genome. Prophylactic genetics represents a revolutionary approach -in management of some types of genetic defects by preventing their -occurrence through certain techniques, e.g. pre-implantation diagnosis, -where carrier couples heterozygous for autosomal recessive single gene -disorders are subjected to in vitro fertilization and mutation analysis -of DNA extracted from one cell of each embryo followed by selection -and intrauterine implantation of normal embryos only. Anticipation -of possible health hazards, based on the genotype of patients/carriers -or the family history, allows for implementing specific prophylactic -measures to avoid expected complications and to alleviate possible -consequences, and represents an essential aspect in management -of patients with genetic diseases and carriers of mutant genes. This -approach constitutes the cornerstone of prophylactic genetics. It also -paves the way towards invention of effective prophylactic techniques -based on detailed knowledge of the pathogenetic mechanisms and -pathophysiological alterations underlying the development of genetic -defects. The purposeful use of genetic knowledge and databases for -prophylactic, diagnostic and therapeutic purposes, and in other related -health and disease states, is a major achievement and represents the -main framework of applied genetics. These applications include many -important fields like genetic counseling, genetic screening (newborn -screening and carrier screening), forensic genetics, genetic engineering, -prenatal diagnosis, fetal therapy and genetic registries. Genetic registry -databases, whether disease-specific or population-specific, represent -essential requirements indispensable for many purposes, headed by -their use in planning of health strategies aiming at establishing effective -prophylactic measures and efficient diagnostic techniques for specific/ -common genetic disorders in populations, particularly closed or -isolated populations with high rates of consanguineous marriages and -increased prevalence of single gene disorders. Additionally, constructed -genetic registry databases represent the main resources of plans aiming -at elimination of certain lethal/disease genes from the gene pool -of isolated populations. This approach represents one of the major -concepts and prime aims of eugenics. - -References - -1. Hatzimanikatis V, Li C, Ionita JA, Broadbelt LJ (2004) Metabolic networks: -enzyme function and metabolite structure. Curr Opin Struct Biol 14: 300-306. - - Medical Genetics -Human Genet Embryol ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal - - Citation: Salem MSZ (2013) Medical Genetics: An Overview. Human Genet Embryol S5: 001. doi:10.4172/2161-0436.S5-001 - -Page 12 of 12 - -2. Cheng J, Torkamani A, Peng Y, Jones TM, Lerner RA (2012) Plasma membrane -associated transcription of cytoplasmic DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 109: -10827-10831. - -14. Hartl FU, Bracher A, Hayer-Hartl M (2011) Molecular chaperones in protein - -folding and proteostasis. Nature 475: 324-332. - -15. Malone CD, Hannon GJ (2009) Small RNAs as guardians of the genome. Cell - -3. Li M, Wang IX, Li Y, Bruzel A, Richards AL, et al. (2011) Widespread RNA and -DNA sequence differences in the human transcriptome. Science 333: 53-58. - -4. - -Irwin H Herskowitz (1977) Principles of genetics. (2ndedn), Collier Macmillan -International Editions. - -136: 656-668. - -16. Valko M, Leibfritz D, Moncol J, Cronin MT, Mazur M, et al. (2007) Free radicals -and antioxidants in normal physiological functions and human disease. Int J -Biochem Cell Biol 39: 44-84. - -5. Richardson JS (1981) The anatomy and taxonomy of protein structure. Adv - -Protein Chem 34: 167-339. - -17. Douglas R Green (2010) Means to an End: Apoptosis and other cell death - -mechanisms. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press. - -6. Balakirev ES, Ayala FJ (2003) Pseudogenes: are they “junk” or functional - -DNA? Annu Rev Genet 37: 123-151. - -7. Glinsky GV (2009) Human genome connectivity code links disease-associated - -SNPs, microRNAs and pyknons. Cell Cycle 8: 925-930. - -8. Kunarso G, Chia NY, Jeyakani J, Hwang C, Lu X, et al. (2010) Transposable -elements have rewired the core regulatory network of human embryonic stem -cells. Nat Genet 42: 631-634. - -9. Rajski SR, Barton JK (2001) How different DNA-binding proteins affect long- - -range oxidative damage to DNA. Biochemistry 40: 5556-5564. - -10. Morita R, Nakane S, Shimada A, Inoue M, Iino H, et al. (2010) Molecular -mechanisms of the whole DNA repair system: a comparison of bacterial and -eukaryotic systems. J Nucleic Acids 2010: 179594. - -11. Gredilla R (2010) DNA damage and base excision repair in mitochondria and - -their role in aging. J Aging Res 2011: 257093. - -12. Price DH, Gray MW (1998) Editing of tRNA. In: Modification and Editing of - -RNA. Grosjean H, Benne R (Eds.). ASM Press, Washington, DC pp: 289-306. - -13. Pearl LH, Prodromou C (2006) Structure and mechanism of the Hsp90 - -molecular chaperone machinery. Annu Rev Biochem 75: 271-294. - -18. Sliwinski T, Rozej W, Morawiec-Bajda A, Morawiec Z, Reiter R, et al. (2007) -Protective action of melatonin against oxidative DNA damage: chemical -inactivation versus base-excision repair. Mutat Res 634: 220-227. - -19. Benjamin Pierce (2005) Genetics. A conceptual approach. (2ndedn), W.H. - -Freeman & company, Gordonsville, VA, USA. - -20. Dale Jeremy, Park Simon F (2010) Molecular genetics of bacteria. (5thedn), - -John Wiley & Sons Ltd. - -21. Griffiths JF (2007) Anthony Introduction to genetic analysis. 9th edition. W.H. - -Freeman & company, Gordonsville, VA, USA - -22. Eberhard Passarge (2007) Color atlas of genetics. (3rdedn), Thieme Stuttgart, - -New York. - -23. Jack J Pasternak (2005) An Introduction to Human Molecular Genetics: -Mechanisms of Inherited Diseases. (2ndedn), John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, -NJ, USA - -24. Rédei GP (2008) Encyclopedia of genetics, genomics, proteomics and - -informatics. (3rdedn), New Springer York, USA. - -25. Watson James, Tania Baker, Stephen Bell, Alexander Gann, Michael Levine, et -al. (2004) Molecular Biology of the Gene. (5thedn), Benjamin Cummings Menlo -Park, California, USA. - -Human Genet Embryol - - Medical Genetics - -ISSN: 2161-0436 HGE, an open access journal +discussion—one way or the other—about whether, by pleading, +Edwards would forfeit his right to appeal the earlier denial of his +suppression motion. Edwards pleaded guilty, and the judge found +that his plea was “entered into freely and voluntarily with a know- +ing, intelligent waiver of [his] rights.” Tr. of Change of Plea at +18:20–22, Dkt. No. 105. + +In computing Edwards’s offense level for sentencing pur- +poses, the presentence investigation report applied an enhance- +ment pursuant to U.S.S.G. § 4B1.4(a), which states that “[a] defend- +ant who is subject to an enhanced sentence under the provisions of +18 U.S.C. § 924(e) is an armed career criminal.” Section 924(e), the +Armed Career Criminal Act, in turn prescribes a mandatory mini- +mum 15-year sentence for anyone who violates § 922(g) and “has +three previous convictions” for “violent felon[ies] or . . . serious +drug offense[s], or both, committed on occasions different from +one another.” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e). In particular, Edwards’s PSI +listed the same three predicate convictions as had his factual prof- +fer: + +The defendant is an armed career criminal because he +is subject to an enhanced sentence under the provi- +sions of 18 U.S.C. § 924(e), pursuant to § 4B1.4(a). +The defendant has the prior felony convictions as +noted in docket numbers 10-022573CF110A [i.e., for +trafficking in oxycodone], 10-022679CF10A [i.e., for +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon], and 97- +000465CF10B [i.e., +for robbery with a deadly +weapon/aggravated battery]. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 5 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +5 + +PSI ¶ 20. With the ACCA enhancement, Edwards’s statutory min- +imum term of imprisonment was 15 years, so the PSI increased the +low end of Edwards’s range from 168 months to 180 months in +prison. Edwards didn’t object to the PSI’s recommended sen- +tence.2 + +At the sentencing hearing, the district judge noted that the +PSI’s recommended sentence reflected an ACCA-enhanced 15-year +mandatory minimum, and Edwards agreed to it. The judge there- +fore imposed a sentence of 180 months in prison, followed by a +two-year term of supervised release. Again, Edwards didn’t object. + +During the sentencing hearing, Edwards’s lawyer asked the +judge to appoint separate counsel to appeal the earlier denial of the +motion to suppress the handgun evidence. Seemingly in an effort +to recall the nature of Edwards’s plea, which Edwards had entered +several months earlier, the judge asked the lawyers whether there +was a formal agreement. After Edwards’s counsel explained that +he didn’t “remember there being an appellate waiver,” the judge +suggested that because “the plea agreement . . . does not mention +an appellate waiver,” Edwards had “the right . . . to take an appeal” + +2 Edwards made two factual objections to the PSI—both are unrelated to this +appeal. See Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 3:20–25, Dkt. No. 106 (“[Defense Coun- +sel]: There were two very minor—they’re not even—they don’t even affect +his guidelines—two minor objections, I would say, to the PSI, and they’re mi- +nor in and of itself. That’s about it. Other than that, we’re just asking for the +Court to sentence him to 15 years and we all go about our business.”). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 6 of 27 + +6 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +of the suppression ruling. Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 24:18–22, Dkt. +No. 106. + +Edwards subsequently filed a notice of appeal indicating his +intent to seek review of the denial of the suppression motion. The +district court granted Edwards’s lawyer’s motion to withdraw and +assigned new counsel, who filed an amended notice of appeal. + +II + +Before us, Edwards challenges his conviction and 180-month +sentence on three grounds: He argues (1) that his guilty plea wasn’t +knowing and voluntary because he didn’t realize that by pleading +he would waive his right to appeal the district court’s denial of his +suppression motion; (2) that the district court erred in enhancing +his sentence under ACCA because the government didn’t prove, as +required by Erlinger v. United States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), that his +predicate offenses occurred on different occasions; and (3) that +§ 922(g)(1) exceeds Congress’s Commerce Clause power. We will +address each issue in turn. + +A + +First up, the voluntariness of Edwards’s plea. When, as here, +a defendant fails to object during his plea colloquy, we review the +district court’s determination that his plea was knowing and volun- +tary only for plain error. See United States v. Monroe, 353 F.3d 1346, +1349 (11th Cir. 2003) (citing United States v. Vonn, 535 U.S. 55, 59 +(2002)). “To establish plain error, a defendant must show that (1) +there was an error, (2) the error was plain, and (3) the error affects +substantial rights.” United States v. Roosevelt Coats, 8 F.4th 1228, 1235 + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 7 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +7 + +(11th Cir. 2021). An error about the voluntariness of a plea affects +a defendant’s “substantial rights” if he shows a reasonable proba- +bility that the error influenced his “‘decision to plead.’” United +States v. Steiger, 99 F.4th 1316, 1326 (11th Cir. 2024) (en banc) (quot- +ing United States v. Dominguez Benitez, 542 U.S. 74, 84 (2004)). If the +defendant makes the first three showings, we have the “discretion +to recognize an unpreserved error but only if (4) the error seriously +affects the fairness, integrity or public reputation of judicial pro- +ceedings.” Roosevelt Coats, 8 F.4th at 1235 (citation modified). + +Before a district judge accepts a guilty plea, he must “address +the defendant personally in open court and determine that the plea +is voluntary.” Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(b)(2). In particular, the judge +must ensure that the defendant understands certain facts, including +“the terms of any plea-agreement provision waiving the right to +appeal or to collaterally attack the sentence.” Id. 11(b)(1)(N); see +also, e.g., United States v. Lejarde-Rada, 319 F.3d 1288, 1289 (11th Cir. +2003) (noting that the Rule 11 colloquy aims to ensure, among +other things, that the defendant “know[s] and understand[s] the +consequences of his guilty plea” (citation modified)). + +Importantly for present purposes, a knowing and voluntary +guilty plea “waives all non-jurisdictional defects,” United States v. +Pierre, 120 F.3d 1153, 1155 (11th Cir. 1997) (citation modified), in- +cluding, as relevant here, the allegedly erroneous denial of a mo- +tion to suppress evidence. Accordingly, a “defendant who wishes +to preserve appellate review of a non-jurisdictional defect while at +the same time pleading guilty can do so only by entering a + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 8 of 27 + +8 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +‘conditional plea’ in accordance with Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(a)(2).” Id. +All here agree that Edwards’s plea was “unconditional.” Br. of Ap- +pellant at 31. + +Edwards insists, though, that his guilty plea wasn’t knowing +and voluntary because he didn’t understand one of the conse- +quences of pleading—namely, that he would lose the right to ap- +peal the denial of his motion to suppress the handgun evidence. +He asserts that the district court failed to inform him of that fact +during the Rule 11 colloquy and, indeed, even suggested at his later +sentencing hearing that he could pursue the appeal. Edwards relies +principally on our decision in Pierre to argue that because he be- +lieved that his plea agreement preserved the right to appeal the de- +nial of the suppression motion—but in fact didn’t—his plea wasn’t +knowing and voluntary. + +In Pierre, we considered the appeal of a defendant who, hav- +ing pleaded guilty, sought to argue that his speedy-trial rights had +been violated. 120 F.3d at 1154. We vacated the conviction upon +determining that, at the time he pleaded guilty, the defendant didn’t +understand the consequences of doing so: “Because Pierre en- +tered—and the district court accepted—this guilty plea only on the +reasonable (but mistaken) belief that [he] had preserved the speedy +trial issues for appeal, his plea was, as a matter of law, not knowing +and voluntary.” Id. at 1156. We based our decision on a review of +“[t]he plea colloquy,” which “unequivocally indicate[d] that Pierre +intended to plead guilty on the condition” that he retained his ap- +pellate rights. Id. at 1155. For example, we cited statements at the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 9 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +9 + +plea hearing demonstrating that Pierre had pleaded guilty “only af- +ter having been assured by the district court judge that [] he had +preserved the speedy trial issues for appeal.” Id. In particular, the +district judge had said: “So I’m going to deny your renewed motion +to dismiss. Now, if you’re ready to go to trial, we have a jury com- +ing up. If you feel that you wish to plead guilty and preserve these +legal issues, you may do so.” Id. We also cited statements demon- +strating that “Pierre’s counsel [had] explicitly tried to preserve the +speedy trial issue.” Id. Specifically, Pierre’s counsel had stated: “As +long as my client is assured by the court, which you have done, that +these issues are protected for purposes of appeal, [Pierre] may be +willing to wish to do that in the future. But for the purposes of +trial, he is entering a plea. It is in his best interest at this time.” Id. + +Here, Edwards hasn’t pointed to any similar evidence from +the plea hearing—no statement by him, his lawyer, or the district +judge—indicating that he didn’t understand the consequences of +pleading guilty. To be sure, Edwards now says that once he lost +the suppression issue, he wanted to plead and “go onto the sentenc- +ing part” so that he could appeal the denial of the motion. See Br. +of Appellant at 29–30 (quoting Tr. of Change of Plea at 10:4–12). +But at the plea hearing, the suppression issue was mentioned only +once, in passing. The district judge asked Edwards’s counsel how +he “got ready for today’s hearing.” Tr. of Change of Plea at 8:5–6. +Edwards’s lawyer responded: “[I]n anticipation of today’s hearing, +[my client] and I had a scheduled visit last week where we went +over the entire plea agreement and . . . the entire factual proffer + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 10 of 27 + +10 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +together.” Id. at 8:18–21. Edwards’s lawyer then added the follow- +ing regarding the suppression motion—its only mention: + +[Defense Counsel]: As the Court noted earlier, we +also had a motion to suppress in this case. The facts +are rather simple. I mean, he was pulled over and he +was arrested and he was in possession of a firearm +and he was a convicted felon. It’s not a—this is not +factually difficult. It was just whether or not they had +requisite legal rights to effectuate that stop. That was +the whole issue. And this Court, unfortunately, ruled +against us, but that’s the nature of the case. + +Id. at 8:22–9:4. + +No one suggested at that time that Edwards wanted to—or +thought he could—appeal the denial of the suppression motion. +And Edwards’s counsel certainly didn’t tie the entry of his plea to +the preservation of the right to appeal, as the lawyer had in Pierre. +To the contrary, Edwards’s lawyer seemed resigned to the district +court’s ruling. + +The preservation issue didn’t resurface for another three +months, at the sentencing hearing. Edwards asserts before us that +a colloquy at that hearing shows that he intended all along to ap- +peal the denial of the motion to suppress. Br. of Appellant at 30– +31. We disagree. + +Here’s the relevant sentencing-hearing exchange, in full: + +Defense Counsel: He did tell me, Judge, he wants me +to try to get counsel appointed to just appeal the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 11 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +11 + +ruling on the motion to suppress. So I told him that I +would file the notice. And if the Court at some point +needs to have a hearing as to whether he is in forma +pauperis and is entitled to counsel for that appeal, I +guess we’ll have a hearing. But that’s what he re- +quested of me. + +The Court: Sure. On this case did we have a formal +plea agreement? I can’t remember now. + +Defense Counsel: I don’t remember – – + +Government: No, I think he pled open, Your Honor. + +Defense Counsel: Yeah. Yeah, I don’t remember +there being an appellate waiver. I don’t recall. + +The Court: Right. I just wanted to advise him if there +was. So the plea agreement at docket entry 80 does +not mention an appellate waiver. Certainly, sir, you +do have the right, if you want, to take an appeal of +that. Just don’t miss your timelines on that. Okay? + +Mr. Edwards: All right. Thank you, sir. + +Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 24:7–25:1. + +Unsurprisingly, Edwards focuses on the district court’s state- +ment that he “ha[d] the right, if [he] want[ed], to take an appeal” +from the order denying the suppression motion. Id. at 24:23–24. +But that remark is both too little and too late. As for the too-little +part, the context makes clear that in the months that had passed +since the plea hearing, everyone (including the district judge) had + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 12 of 27 + +12 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +lost track of the details of Edwards’s plea—whether it was a formal +plea agreement, whether it contained an appeal waiver, etc. At the +sentencing hearing, the judge assumed that because the agreement +didn’t contain an appeal waiver, Edwards could appeal the suppres- +sion order. But the judge hardly made any guarantees. + +And as for the too-late: All of the evidence to which Ed- +wards now points comes from the sentencing hearing, which, +again, took place some three months after he pleaded guilty. That +makes this case quite different from Pierre, in which the defendant +could—and did—point to strong indications from the plea hearing +itself that he misunderstood, at the time, what appellate rights he +was waiving. There is simply no basis in the record here for imput- +ing backwards, as it were, whatever was said at sentencing to show +genuine confusion at the earlier plea hearing.3 + +Edwards has failed to show that the district court plainly +erred in accepting his plea as knowing and voluntary.4 We there- +fore affirm the district court’s judgment in that respect. + +3 Edwards separately complains that the district judge failed to explicitly warn +him that he couldn’t appeal the denial of his motion to suppress. But nothing +in Rule 11 or our caselaw requires a judge to proactively inform a defendant +that by entering an unconditional plea he waives his right to appeal all non- +jurisdictional matters. Edwards ultimately concedes as much, saying only that +one circuit court has called this the “preferred practice.” Reply Br. at 3–4 (cit- +ing United States v. Lampazianie, 251 F.3d 519, 526 (5th Cir. 2001)). Perhaps, +but that is no basis for finding plain error. + +4 Unrelatedly, Edwards argues that his plea wasn’t knowingly and voluntarily +entered “on the basis of Erlinger as well.” Letter Br. of Appellant at 5 n.4, Dkt. +No. 37. In a footnote in a supplemental brief, Edwards asserts that had he + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 13 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +13 + +B + +1 + +We next consider the Armed Career Criminal Act enhance- +ment. Because Edwards never objected to the enhancement, we +review only for plain error. See United States v. Jones, 743 F.3d 826, +828 (11th Cir. 2014); Fed. R. Crim. P. 52(b). While a conviction un- +der § 922(g) ordinarily yields a maximum sentence of 10 years in +prison, 18 U.S.C. § 924(a)(2), ACCA mandates a minimum 15-year +sentence for an offender who has three prior convictions for “vio- +lent felon[ies]” or “serious drug offense[s]” that were “committed +on occasions different from one another,” id. § 924(e)(1). Edwards +contends that the district court erred in enhancing his sentence un- +der ACCA because the government failed to prove beyond a rea- +sonable doubt that his three predicate convictions occurred on dif- +ferent occasions. + +In Wooden v. United States, the Supreme Court explained that +ACCA “contains both a three-offense requirement and a three-occa- +sion requirement.” 595 U.S. 360, 368 (2022). Although ACCA + +“known that he was entitled to a jury determination as to whether his offenses +were committed on different occasions, he may not have pled guilty—or he +may have pled guilty to the 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) charge, and sought a trial on +the occasions issue.” Id. We’ll address the merits of Edwards’s Erlinger argu- +ment in the next Part, but we decline to consider it vis-à-vis the voluntariness +of his plea. “We have long held that an appellant abandons a claim when he +either makes only passing references to it or raises it in a perfunctory manner +without supporting arguments and authority.” Sapuppo v. Allstate Floridian Ins. +Co., 739 F.3d 678, 680–81 (11th Cir. 2014). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 14 of 27 + +14 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +initially focused only on the number of offenses, Congress later +amended it to specify that qualifying offenses must also occur on +different occasions. See Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1988, Pub. L. 100– +690, § 7056 (codified as amended at 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(1)) (inserting +“committed on occasions different from one another,” after “or +both”). Congress “added the occasions clause only after a court +applied ACCA to an offender . . . convicted of multiple counts of +robbery arising from a single criminal episode.” Wooden, 595 U.S.at +371–73 (citing Petty v. United States, 481 U.S. 1034, 1034–1035 +(1987)). The Wooden Court emphasized that while each ACCA- +qualifying offense often occurs separately, “multiple crimes may +occur on one occasion even if not at the same moment.” Id. at 366. +“[T]reating each temporally distinct offense as its own occasion” as +a per se matter, the Court explained, would improperly “collaps[e] +two separate statutory conditions.” Id. at 368. + +To operationalize the different-occasions requirement, the +Wooden Court described a “range of circumstances [that] may be +relevant to identifying episodes of criminal activity”—e.g., the of- +fenses’ timing, location, and character. Id. at 369. Applying those +considerations—which we’ll explore in detail soon enough—the +Court concluded that Wooden’s ten burglaries didn’t occur on dif- +ferent occasions because (1) he committed them “in a single unin- +terrupted course of conduct,” (2) he committed them at “one loca- +tion,” and (3) the offenses were “essentially identical” and “inter- +twined.” Id. at 370. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 15 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +15 + +Approximately four months after Wooden was decided, Ed- +wards entered his unconditional guilty plea in this case. His written +plea agreement recites that “[t]he defendant . . . understands and +acknowledges that the Court must impose a statutory mandatory +minimum term of imprisonment of fifteen (15) years.” Plea Agree- +ment ¶ 3, Dkt. No. 80. The agreement was accompanied by a +signed factual proffer, which recited that “[t]he defendant has at +least seven (7) felony convictions” and specifically enumerated +three of them—“for trafficking in oxycodone (10-022573CF10A), +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon (10-022679CF10A), and +(97- +robbery with a deadly weapon/aggravated battery +000465CF10B).” Factual Proffer ¶ 2. The same three convictions +were cited in Edwards’s presentence investigation report as +grounds for enhancing his sentence under ACCA. See PSI ¶ 20 +(“The defendant is an armed career criminal because he is subject +to an enhanced sentence under the provisions of 18 U.S.C. § 924(e), +pursuant to § 4B1.4(a). The defendant has the prior felony convic- +in docket numbers 10-022573CF110A, 10- +tions as noted +022679CF10A, and 97-000465CF10B.”). And the district court in +fact used those three convictions to enhance Edwards’s sentence. +The judge explained that “looking at the offense level computa- +tion” in the PSI, the “Armed Career Criminal enhancement gets +[the offense level] up to 33.” Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 4:19–23 (cit- +ing PSI ¶ 20). + +Edwards didn’t object to the ACCA enhancement on any +ground, including that the offenses underlying the ACCA predi- +cates weren’t committed on different occasions. He didn’t object + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 16 of 27 + +16 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +to the PSI’s ACCA-enhanced recommended sentence, see supra at 5 +n.2, nor did he object to the enhancement during the sentencing +hearing. To the contrary, Edwards’s counsel suggested at the sen- +tencing hearing that the ACCA-enhanced 15-year sentence was ap- +propriate: + +[Defense Counsel]: My client has been aware for +months that he’s facing a statutory minimum sen- +tence of 15 years, which is 180 months in federal +prison. He’s been aware of it. He has not gone to +trial on this particular case. He has not testified in this +particular case. He got acceptance of responsibility, +even though it doesn’t really affect him. So he’s just +asking the Court to accept both parties’ recommen- +dations, sentence him to 15 years, and he’ll move on +with his life. + +Tr. of Sentencing Hr’g at 16:5–13; see also id. at 21:14–17 (“Court: +[N]ow that sentence has been imposed, do either of you object to +the Court’s finding of fact or the manner in which the sentence was +pronounced? [Defense Counsel]: No, Judge.”). Hearing no objec- +tion to the applicability of the ACCA enhancement based on Ed- +wards’s three prior convictions, the district court sentenced him to +the 15-year statutory minimum. + +Then came Erlinger, in which the Supreme Court held that +because the determination that a defendant’s prior crimes were +committed on different occasions “‘increase[s] the prescribed range +of penalties to which a criminal defendant is exposed,’” it “must be +resolved by a unanimous jury beyond a reasonable doubt (or freely + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 17 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +17 + +admitted in a guilty plea).” 602 U.S. at 834 (quoting Apprendi v. New +Jersey, 530 U.S. 466, 490 (2000)).5 In light of Erlinger, Edwards con- +tends on appeal that because a jury didn’t find beyond a reasonable +doubt that his three ACCA predicate offenses were committed on +different occasions, the district court committed plain error when +it imposed an enhanced 15-year minimum-mandatory sentence. + +2 + +The government concedes that in light of Erlinger, Edwards +has satisfied the first two prongs of the plain-error standard—an +“error” that is “plain”—because, it says, the different-occasions re- +quirement was neither proven to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt +nor expressly admitted by Edwards in his plea. See Br. of Appellee +at 28.6 + +5 To be clear, Erlinger didn’t add a different-occasions element to the statute. +As already explained, Congress codified the different-occasions requirement +some 35 years ago. And almost four months before Edwards entered his plea, +and eight months before his sentencing hearing, the Supreme Court in Wooden +reiterated the significance of the different-occasions element and clarified the +circumstances under which offenses will (and won’t) satisfy it. Erlinger, rather, +resolved the “who decides” question—namely, by holding that the different- +occasions issue must be resolved either by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt +or by the defendant himself in a guilty plea. See 602 U.S. at 834. District courts, +the Erlinger Court held, “may not assume the jury’s factfinding function for +themselves” to conclude that offenses occurred on different occasions. Id. + +6 The second half of that disjunction isn’t self-evidently correct. Here, Ed- +wards at least arguably admitted in his plea that his three convictions satisfied +ACCA’s different-occasions requirement. As already explained, Edwards ad- +mitted that the three convictions enumerated in both the factual proffer and +the PSI qualified him for the ACCA enhancement. And by pleading to the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 18 of 27 + +18 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +Still, to prevail on plain error, Edwards must show, at step +three, that the Erlinger error affected his “substantial rights.”� +“[U]nlike harmless error—where the government carries the bur- +den—the onus of establishing prejudice under plain error rests with +the defendant.” United States v. Margarita Garcia, 906 F.3d 1255, +1267 (11th Cir. 2018). That burden is “heavy”—and, in particular, +“the burden of showing prejudice to meet the third-prong require- +ment is anything but easy.” Id. (citation modified). + +To demonstrate prejudice, a defendant must “show a rea- +sonable probability that, but for the error, the outcome of the pro- +ceeding would have been different.” United States v. Corbett, 921 F.3d +1032, 1037 (11th Cir. 2019) (quoting Molina-Martinez v. United States, +578 U.S. 189, 194 (2016)). “[W]e define the ‘outcome’ that must +have been affected by considering the nature of the rule violated +by the district court and the role that rule plays in the judicial pro- +cess.” Steiger, 99 F.4th at 1326. When, as here, “the proceeding is +sentencing, we ask whether the sentence would be different but for +erroneous sentencing enhancements or an inaccurate sentencing +guidelines range.” Id. (citation modified). Edwards thus “has the +difficult burden of showing there is a ‘reasonable probability’ that +he would have received a lighter sentence but for the error.” Jones, + +whole—i.e., ACCA applicability, writ large, based on those three convic- +tions—one could argue that he implicitly pleaded to the constituent parts, in- +cluding the applicability of the different-occasions requirement. But the gov- +ernment hasn’t pressed that argument, so we won’t pursue it. + +� + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 19 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +19 + +743 F.3d at 830.7 In other words, a showing that Edwards would +have been entitled to a jury determination on the separate-occa- +sions inquiry is not, in and of itself, enough to establish that the +error affected his “substantial rights” under the plain-error frame- +work. Rather, to prevail, Edwards must further show a reasonable +probability that a jury would have concluded that he committed +the three predicate crimes on fewer than three occasions. + +As already explained, the district court enhanced Edwards’s +sentence under ACCA on the basis of three prior convictions: +(1) for a December 20, 1996, robbery with a deadly weapon and + +7 Both parties seem to misunderstand—albeit in different ways—how the sub- +stantial-rights prong operates in this case. For the first time at oral argument, +Edwards asserted that under Greer v. United States, 593 U.S. 508 (2021), he can +show prejudice if there is a reasonable probability that had he known about +the Erlinger rule, he wouldn’t have pleaded guilty and would have instead in- +sisted on going to trial. See Oral Arg. at 7:46, 28:22. That is incorrect. True, +when a defendant challenges the voluntariness of his plea, the reasonable- +probability standard is appropriately focused on whether he would have +pleaded guilty. Greer, 593 U.S. at 508. Accordingly, that formulation would +have governed Edwards’s voluntariness challenge had we found the first two +prongs of the plain-error standard satisfied. See supra at 7. But it doesn’t gov- +ern his challenge to the applicability of the ACCA enhancement. + +For its part, the government contends that the requisite reasonable +probability doesn’t exist here because Edwards hasn’t shown either “that the +three qualifying offenses were not committed on different occasions” or that +“the government would have been unable to prove that fact had he made a +timely objection.” Br. of Appellee at 31. But that formulation erects too high +a bar. To be sure, a defendant may seek to demonstrate prejudice in those +ways—and they would likely be persuasive—but he isn’t required to do so in +order to show an effect on his substantial rights. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 20 of 27 + +20 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +aggravated battery, for which the arrest occurred on April 1, 1997; +(2) for an undated instance of drug trafficking, for which the arrest +occurred on December 28, 2010; and (3) for an October 1, 2010, +aggravated battery with a deadly weapon, for which the arrest oc- +curred on December 30, 2010. Edwards concedes that it is fair to +assume that the 1996 robbery was committed on a different occa- +sion than the other two—the nearly 14-year gap is hard to ignore. +But, he maintains, the government didn’t prove that the drug-traf- +ficking and aggravated-battery offenses, both with arrest dates in +2010, were committed on different occasions. + +The PSI contains no details about the drug-trafficking of- +fense other than the arrest date. Although “[t]he circumstances of +this arrest were requested from the Broward County Clerk of +Court,” no report was ever produced. Letter Br. of Appellant at 7, +Dkt. No. 37 (citing PSI ¶ 34). Edwards contends that, “based on the +lack of facts in the record concerning the 2010 drug offense,” a jury +likely would have found that the drug-trafficking and aggravated- +battery offenses were committed on the same occasion and, there- +fore, that he wasn’t subject to the ACCA enhancement.8 Id. at 8. +We cannot agree. + +8 Edwards’s other arguments improperly employ a harmless-error-like stand- +ard, pursuant to which the government bears the burden. See Letter Br. of +Appellant at 5 (“[B]ecause the government did not prove that his offenses oc- +curred on three separate occasions,” “Edwards is entitled to be resentenced +without the ACCA enhancement.”); see also id. at 6 (“[T]he ‘facts’ in the record +here—even the ‘unobjected to’ facts in the PSI—are insufficient for a jury to + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 21 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +21 + +In our review for plain error, we consider “the whole rec- +ord” to determine “the effect of any error on [the defendant’s] sub- +stantial rights,” including “proceedings that both precede and post- +date the errors about which [the defendant] complains.” United +States v. Reed, 941 F.3d 1018, 1021 (11th Cir. 2019) (citation modi- +fied); see also Greer v. United States, 593 U.S. 503, 511 (2021) (explain- +ing that “an appellate court conducting plain-error review may +consider the entire record—not just the record from the particular +proceeding where the error occurred”). So we will examine the en- +tire record for evidence bearing on what the Wooden Court called +the “range of circumstances” that “may be relevant to identifying +episodes of criminal activity.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369; see also Er- +linger, 602 U.S. at 828 (noting the “intensely factual nature of this +inquiry”). The Court hoped that, “[f]or the most part,” applying +the different-occasions requirement would be “straightforward and +intuitive.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. But for the tough cases, the +Court offered guidance to help determine whether offenses consti- +tute single or multiple episodes of criminal activity. In particular, +the Court emphasized considerations such as “[1] whether the de- +fendant’s past offenses were ‘committed close in time,’ [2] whether +they were committed near to or far from one another, and +[3] whether the offenses were ‘similar or intertwined’ in purpose +and character.” Erlinger, 602 U.S. at 828 (quoting Wooden, 595 U.S. +at 369). + +conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that the offenses occurred on different +occasions.”). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 22 of 27 + +22 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +Candidly, the record doesn’t shed much light on the first two +Wooden factors. With respect to timing, while the PSI establishes +that the aggravated-battery offense occurred on October 1, 2010, it +doesn’t specify the date of the drug-trafficking offense. Accord- +ingly, we can’t make any firm judgments about whether those two +crimes were “committed close in time, in an uninterrupted course +of conduct” or if they were “separated by substantial gaps in time +or significant intervening events.” Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. The +record likewise reveals nothing about the “[p]roximity of location” +that would permit an assessment of whether the two crimes oc- +curred far from one another, which would of course make it “less +likely they are components of the same criminal event.” Id. + +That leaves the offenses’ “purpose and character”—and +there, we have more to go on. Edwards’s drug-related offense in- +volved trafficking in oxycodone, possession of cocaine with intent +to deliver or sell, and possession of drug paraphernalia. By con- +trast, his aggravated-battery arose out of domestic dispute with a +former romantic partner. According to the arrest affidavit— + +[O]n October 1, 2010, the defendant picked up a small +flowerpot, forcefully grabbed the victim by her hair, +and then smashed the pot against the victim’s head. +The victim sustained a laceration to the left side of +her head. The victim and the defendant had been in- +volved in a romantic relationship for two years and +lived together for seven months. The victim was +transported to the hospital where she received multi- +ple staples on her head. The defendant was later ar- +rested on December 30, 2010. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 23 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +23 + +PSI ¶ 35. At least on the face of things, Edwards’s drug-trafficking +and aggravated battery offenses seem to have nothing in com- +mon—to be totally unrelated. And there’s certainly nothing in the +record to suggest that the two crimes “share a common scheme or +purpose,” such that they are likely to “compose one occasion.” +Wooden, 595 U.S. at 369. Accordingly, we think the third, “purpose +and character” factor significantly diminishes the probability that +the drug-trafficking and aggravated-battery offenses occurred on +the same occasion. + +Other facts likewise indicate, on balance, that those crimes +occurred on different occasions. First, Edwards was arrested for +the offenses two days apart—for the drug-trafficking crime on De- +cember 28, 2010, and for the aggravated-battery crime on Decem- +ber 30, 2010. Second, the criminal cases bear non-consecutive +docket numbers—indicating, at the very least, that the charges +were filed on different dates. And third, the two crimes were adju- +dicated almost three years apart—the aggravated battery on July +21, 2011, and the drug trafficking on April 29, 2014. We think it at +least relevant—and certainly not irrelevant—that the two offenses +were never combined into a single arrest or case, despite ample op- +portunities to do so. + +We also note the conspicuous absence of any evidence to +the contrary. Even on appeal, and with an opportunity to supple- +ment the record, Edwards hasn’t presented any evidence that +would demonstrate, or even strongly suggest, that the drug-traf- +ficking and aggravated-battery offenses were committed on the + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 24 of 27 + +24 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +same occasion. He doesn’t assert, for instance, that the two crimes +took place on the same date, were committed in the same location, +or involved the same victims. Rather, Edwards simply says that +there isn’t sufficient evidence in the record for the government to +prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the ACCA enhancement ap- +plies. But on plain-error review, where the burden rests with Ed- +wards, and with the balance of the record evidence against him, +that’s not enough. + +To be sure, Edwards isn’t required to show by a preponder- +ance of the evidence that, but for the Erlinger error, the result +would have been different. See Dominguez Benitez, 542 U.S. at 83 +n.9 (“The reasonable-probability standard is not the same as, and +should not be confused with, a requirement that a defendant prove +by a preponderance of the evidence that but for error things would +have been different.”). And we acknowledge Edwards’s argument +that the lack of smoking-gun evidence about the locations and +dates of the crimes makes it possible that a jury could have found +the different-occasions requirement not satisfied. But a mere pos- +sibility isn’t a reasonable probability. See United States v. Marcus, +560 U.S. 258, 263 (2010) (deeming a standard pegged to “any possi- +bility, no matter how unlikely,” of a different outcome “irreconcilable +with our ‘plain error’ precedent” (citation modified)). And again, +the record evidence that we do have—the drug-trafficking and ag- +gravated-battery offenses’ divergent “purpose[s] and character[s],” +the different arrest and adjudication dates, the non-consecutive +docket numbers, etc.—indicates that they were indeed “committed +on occasions different from one another.” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(1). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 25 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +25 + +Finally, we note that Edwards hasn’t explained how there +could be a “reasonable probability”—more than a mere possibil- +ity—of a different outcome here. As we’ve observed, see supra at +24, Edwards hasn’t put forward any theory that pushes this case +over the reasonable-probability hurdle. Far from showing a rea- +sonable probability, Edwards hasn’t even speculated to how the Er- +linger error might have affected the outcome. For example, he +hasn’t argued that the aggravated-battery offense occurred in the +course of a dispute over the drug trafficking, such that a jury could +have found that those two offenses occurred on the same occasion. +And “[w]here the effect of an alleged error is so uncertain, a defend- +ant cannot meet his burden of showing that the error actually af- +fected his substantial rights.” Jones v. United States, 527 U.S. 373, +394–95 (1999). + +We therefore hold that Edwards hasn’t met his plain-error +burden to show that his “substantial rights” were affected, and we +affirm the district court’s decision to apply the ACCA enhance- +ment. + +C + +Finally, we address Edwards’s argument that Congress ex- +ceeded its Commerce Clause authority when it enacted 18 U.S.C. +§ 922(g).9 + +9 We review a district court’s determination regarding the constitutionality of +a statute for plain error when, as here, the issue wasn’t presented below. See +United States v. Valois, 915 F.3d 717, 729 n.7 (11th Cir. 2019). + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 26 of 27 + +26 + +Opinion of the Court + +22-13963 + +We have repeatedly held that § 922(g) is facially constitu- +tional under the Commerce Clause because it contains an express +jurisdictional requirement. See, e.g., United States v. Stancil, 4 F.4th +1193, 1200 (11th Cir. 2021); United States v. Jordan, 635 F.3d 1181, +1189 (11th Cir. 2011); United States v. Scott, 263 F.3d 1270, 1273–74 +(11th Cir. 2001) (“[T]he jurisdictional element of the statute, i.e., +the requirement that the felon ‘possess in or affecting commerce, +any firearm or ammunition,’ immunizes § 922(g)(1) from [a] facial +constitutional attack.”); United States v. Dupree, 258 F.3d 1258, 1259– +60 (11th Cir. 2001); United States v. McAllister, 77 F.3d 387, 390 (11th +Cir. 1996). + +We have also rejected as-applied challenges to § 922(g), +holding that the government demonstrates the required “minimal +nexus” to interstate commerce when it proves that the firearms +were manufactured outside the state where the offense took place +and, thus, necessarily traveled in interstate commerce. See, e.g., Jor- +dan, 635 F.3d at 1189 (holding that § 922(g) is constitutional as ap- +plied to “a defendant who possessed a firearm only intrastate” be- +cause the firearm had moved in interstate commerce); see also +United States v. Wright, 607 F.3d 708, 715–16 (11th Cir. 2010). Here, +Edwards admitted in his factual proffer that the firearm and ammu- +nition that he possessed in Florida were manufactured out of state +and had therefore moved in interstate commerce prior to his pos- +session of them. The government thus satisfied the minimal-nexus +requirement here. + + USCA11 Case: 22-13963 Document: 56-1 Date Filed: 06/27/2025 Page: 27 of 27 + +22-13963 + +Opinion of the Court + +27 + +Under the prior-panel-precedent rule, we’re obliged to fol- +low our existing decisions unless overruled by this Court en banc +or abrogated by the Supreme Court. United States v. White, 837 +F.3d 1225, 1228 (11th Cir. 2016). Because neither has occurred +here, we affirm the judgment of the district court that § 922(g) +doesn’t violate the Commerce Clause. + +III + +For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the district court’s + +judgment. + +AFFIRMED. diff --git a/q46/random_k4/random_2.md b/q46/random_k4/random_2.md index 8a904058060ae7a349c7098cea40da33240de4d1..052cee2fff6d2fb0526b1d43400b3c01f2587dfb 100644 Binary files a/q46/random_k4/random_2.md and b/q46/random_k4/random_2.md differ diff --git a/q46/random_k4/random_3.md b/q46/random_k4/random_3.md index 2e9f5241e58113455522088c7a6110de8838d130..15d75a09f41359a0dd28001b377846c0439ea651 100644 --- a/q46/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q46/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1208 +1,589 @@ -DUET: Joint Exploration of User–Item Profiles in Recommendation System -YueChen1,*,YifeiSun1,*,LuWang2,†,FangkaiYang2,PuZhao2,MinjieHong3,YifeiDong4,MinghuaHe2, -NanHu2,JianjinZhang2,ZhiweiDai2,YuefengZhan2,WeihaoHan2,HaoSun2, -QingweiLin2,WeiweiDeng2,FengSun2,QiZhang2,SaravanRajmohan2,DongmeiZhang2 -1PekingUniversity2Microsoft3ZhejiangUniversity4KTHRoyalInstituteofTechnology -*Equalcontribution†Correspondingauthor -Abstract -| | | | User History: | Item History: | User History: | Item History: | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | ------------------------- | -| | | | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | • Misfits (Punk) | • Review: | -| | | | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | • I r o n M a iden | " P o l i s he d P o p " | -Traditionalrecommendationsystemsrepresent ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t ( M e t al ) • R e v i e w : " G r e a t -6202 rpA 51 ]RI.sc[ 1v10831.4062:viXra • • Parliament Funk Bass" -| usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearnto | | | Parliament | Funk Bass" | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------------------ | -| | | | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | (Funk) | • Meta: "80s Rock" | -aligntheminasharedlatentspaceforrelevance -| | | | | Duet | Independent | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -estimation. RecentLLM-basedrecommenders (Joint Alignment) Generation -| instead leverage | natural-language | representa- | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | -| | | | User Profile: | Item History: | User Profile: | Item History: | -tionsthatareeasiertointerpretandintegrate Enthusiast of A peak-era FUNK- Fan of HEAVY A highly rated POP- -| | | | FUNK and SOUL. | ROCK album with | METAL and | ROCK album with | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ---------------- | -withdownstreamreasoningmodules. Thispa- Values technical genre-blurring PUNK. Prefers polished -| | | | mastery | creativity. | dark themes. | production. | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------- | -textual -per studies how to construct effective Semantic Alignment ✘ Semantic Mismatch -profilesforusersanditems,andhowtoalign -themforrecommendation. Acentraldifficulty Figure1: DUETalignsrawuseranditemdatabytrans- -| | | | forming them | into textual | profiles within | a shared se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | -isthatthebestprofileformatisnotknownapri- -manticspace. -ori: manuallydesignedtemplatescanbebrittle -| andmisalignedwithtaskobjectives. | | Moreover, | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------------------- | --- | -| | | | to introduce | semantically | rich, human-readable | | -generatinguseranditemprofilesindependently -mayproducedescriptionsthatareindividually representationsforrecommendation(Wangetal., -plausible yet semantically inconsistent for a 2025;Zhang,2024;Baoetal.,2023;Hongetal., -| specificuser–itempair. | WeproposeDUET,an | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | | 2025a,b,c;Wangetal.,2024). | | Anaturaldirectionis | | -interaction-awareprofilegeneratorthatjointly -toreplacelatentvectorswithtextualuseranditem -producesuseranditemprofilesconditionedon -profilesthatcanbeinspected,edited,andreusedby -| both user history | and item evidence. | DUET | | | | | -| ----------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -downstreamcomponentsincorporatedwithLLMs. -| follows a three-stage | procedure: | it first turns | | | | | -| --------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -However,existingLLM-basedapproachesremain -rawhistoriesandmetadataintocompactcues, -then expands these cues into paired profile limited in two important ways. First, directly -promptsandthengenerateprofiles,andfinally promptinganLLMwithrawuseranditemhisto- -optimizesthegenerationpolicywithreinforce- -riestoobtainrecommendationsoftenyieldsnoisy -mentlearningusingdownstreamrecommenda- andincompletesignals,especiallywhenhistories -| tionperformanceasfeedback. | | Experimentson | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -| | | | are long, | sparse, or heterogeneous | | (Wang et al., | -threereal-worlddatasetsshowthatDUETcon- -| | | | 2025). Second, | profile-based | methods | typically | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------- | --------- | -sistentlyoutperformsstrongbaselines,demon- -relyonmanuallydesignedtemplatesorhandcrafted -stratingthebenefitsoftemplate-freeprofileex- -attributes,whichrequiressubstantialhumanengi- -plorationandjointuser–itemtextualalignment. -Project code page: https://github.com/duet- neering and constrains the representation space. -review/duet_code. More fundamentally, many approaches generate -userprofilesanditemprofilesindependently,with- -1 Introduction -| | | | out modeling | how user | preferences | and item se- | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------------ | -Traditional recommendation systems represent manticsinteractatdecisiontime(Yangetal.,2023; -Xietal.,2024). -usersanditemsasdensevectorsandlearntoalign -theminasharedlatentspaceforrelevanceestima- Toaddressthesechallenges,wepropose DUET, -tion (Covington et al., 2016; Wu, 2023). While ajointuser–itemprofilegeneratorthattakesboth -effective,suchembeddingsareopaque: theyoffer userhistoryanditemhistoryasinputandproduces -limitedinterpretabilityandmakeitdifficulttoan- a paired set of profiles for the interaction. Cru- -alyzewhyanitemisrecommended. Recentwork cially, DUET doesnotrequireprofiletemplates: it -thereforeleverageslargelanguagemodels(LLMs) istrainedwithreinforcementlearningusingfeed- - -back from downstream recommendation perfor- asseeninworkslikeCRESDUP(Chenetal.,2007) -mance,enablingittoexploreanddiscovereffective andUPCSim(Widiyaningtyasetal.,2021). While -profileformatsautomatically. Figure1illustrates foundational,thesemethodswerelimitedbytheir -whyjointprofilingmatters. Theuserhaslistened rigid,hand-engineeredfeatures. Morerecently,the -toMisfits(punk),IronMaiden(metal),andParlia- adventofLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)hasen- -ment(funk),whilethecandidatealbumisdescribed abledashifttowardsgeneratingprofilesinnatural -byreviewssuchas“polishedpop”and“greatfunk language. Studies such as KAR (Xi et al., 2024), -bass”andametatag“’80srock.” Consideringboth GPG(Zhang,2024),PALR(Yangetal.,2023),and -sides together, DUET can reconcile these signals LettinGo (Wang et al., 2025) leverage LLMs to -intoacompatibleinterpretation(e.g.,highlighting createtextualuserprofilesfrombehavioraldata. A -the user’s funk/soul affinity and the item’s funk- keylimitationoftheseapproachesistwofold: they -rockcharacter). Incontrast,independentlygener- relyonstaticorpre-definedtemplatesforprofile -atedprofilesmayamplifydifferentfacets,summa- generation,andtheyoftenfocusexclusivelyonuser -rizingtheuseras“heavymetal/punk”whilesum- profiles,neglectingtherich,expressiveinformation -marizingtheitemas“pop-rock”,whichresultingin inherentinitemsandthecomplexdynamicsofuser- -asemanticallymismatchedpairthatobscuresthe iteminteractions. Incontrast,ourworkintroduces -truerelevancesignal. anewparadigmwherebothuseranditemprofiles -DUETproceedsinthreestages. First,rawhisto- arenotfixedbutaredynamicallyexploredandop- -ries and metadata are distilled into minimal cues timizedinasharedsemanticspacetodirectlyalign -thatcapturecompactbutinformativesignals. Sec- withrecommendationperformance. -ond, the model expands cues into richer profile -prompts to generate textual profiles, allowing ex- 2.2 ReinforcementLearningforLLM-Based -plorationoveralternativeprofilestructuresandem- RecommendationSystems -phases. Third,theresultingprofilesareconsumed -ReinforcementLearning(RL),particularlythrough -bydownstreamrecommenders,andtheirtaskfeed- -techniqueslikeRLHF,hasbecomeacoremethod -backisusedtooptimizetheprofilegenerationpol- -for aligning LLMs with specific objectives. This -icy. By coupling both sides in a shared semantic -approach has been adapted for recommendation -space,DUETlearnsuserprofilesthatreflectwhat -tasks (Wang et al., 2025; Lin et al., 2025; Deng -kindsofitemsauserprefersanditemprofilesthat -etal.,2025),butexistingeffortsoftenfacekeylimi- -reflectwhatkindsofusersanitemappealsto. -tations. Theyfrequentlyrelyonofflinerewardmod- -Ourcontributionsareasfollows: -els(Jeongetal.,2023;Chenetal.,2025;Heetal., -• Werepresentusersanditemsasnatural-language 2025; Liu et al., 2025) that do not adapt in real- -profiles and align them in a shared semantic timetosystemfeedback,asetupthatrisksissues -space,extendingtheclassicvector-basedalign- like reward hacking (Skalse et al., 2025). Other -mentprincipletointerpretabletextualrepresenta- methods(Sunetal.,2024;Luetal.,2024)restrict -tions. themselvestoofflinepreferencetuning(e.g.,DPO), -• We introduce an exploration-based framework which can easily overfit on static datasets. Our -thatstartsfromcue-basedinitialization,expands framework, DUET,overcomesthesechallengesby -cuesintocandidateprofiles,andjointlyoptimizes integrating RL into a closed-loop system where -user and item profiles with downstream recom- downstreamrecommendationperformanceserves -mendationfeedbackviareinforcementlearning, asthereal-timerewardsignal,allowingforthedy- -avoidingrigidtemplates. namicandinteractiverefinementoftextualprofiles. -• Extensiveexperimentsacrossmultiplereal-world -datasets show that DUET consistently outper- 3 Method -formsstrongbaselines,validatingbothjointpro- -filingandfeedback-drivenprofileoptimization. DUET is a closed-loop framework that trans- -forms raw user–item interaction histories into -2 RelatedWork performance-aligned textual profiles through -learnedrepresentationstrategies. AsshowninFig- -2.1 ProfilesinRecommendation -ure 2, DUET consists of three stages. (1) Cue- -Earlyrecommendationsystemsprimarilyreliedon Based Initialization distills interaction histories -pre-definedprofilesbasedonstructuredattributes, intoconciseevidence-basedcues. (2)JointExplo- - -CUE-BASED INITIALIZATION JOINT EXPLORATION ON-POLICY OPTIMIZATION -| | | | | Item | DU | | | Duet | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | -| ItemHistory | | | | | ET | | | | | | | -Initial CUE -Rated: Baba Is You (5★) -User: “Prefers retro puzzle games” -Reviewed: “I love logic- -Item: “Retro-style indie puzzle game” -| | | | based puzzle games.” | | | Profile Prompt | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Rated: The Witness (5★) -User: “Describe the user's typical -| | | | Rated: Fez (4★) | | puzzle-game preferences … | | | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒1 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒2 | … | 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑓𝑖𝑙𝑒𝑛 | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -Item: “… item's core mechanics… -| | | | | | | | Profile | Downstream Task Env | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ---- | --------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | User | User: “A player who enjoys logic- | | | | | | | -| UserHistory | | | | | intensive indie puzzle games, | | | | | | | -| | | | Category: Indie Puzzle | | | | | Ranking correctness | | | | -prefers retro visual aesthetics…” -| | | | Game | | | | | &format Reward | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Reviews: -Item: “A retro-style indie puzzle -| | | | “Challenging logic | | game featuring challenging | | | Group Computation | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -| | | | mechanics.” | | logic mechanics that appeal to | | | | | | | -| | | | “ R e t r o p ix | e l- a rt st y l e . ” | hardcore puzzle players.” | | | 𝐴𝑑𝑣1 𝐴𝑑𝑣2 | | | | -| | | | “ H a r d b u | t re w a r d i n g . ” | | | | | … | 𝐴𝑑𝑣𝑛 | | -| | | | | Figure2: | OverviewoftheDUETframework. | | | | | | | -ration via Adaptive Profile Prompt Discovery 3.2 Cue-BasedInitialization -| jointly | explores | user-item’s | | profile prompts | that | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Raw user | histories | and item | metadata | | are often | -| define how | user | and item | profiles | should | be writ- | | | | | | | -noisy,redundant,andnotdirectlysuitableforpro- -ten. (3)OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -| | | | | | | fileconstruction. | | Toaddressthis,DUETintroduces | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -jointlyoptimizesuseranditemprofilesunderdown- -theconceptofcues: -concisehypothesesthatsum- -streamrecommendationfeedback. -| | | | | | | marize minimal | | but informative | | aspects | of users | -| ------------------- | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | -------------- | ------- | -------- | -| All three | stages | are | realized | through | a single | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | and items. | These | cues act | as lightweight | | seeds, | -| passinputandoutput: | | | cueextraction,self-prompt | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | which are | deliberately | underspecified | | so | that the | -construction,andprofilegenerationareproduced -systemcansubsequentlyexplorericherprofilefor- -inasinglesequence-to-sequencegenerationpass -mats. -atinferencetime,enablingefficientdeployment. -| | | | | | | Definition1(Cue). | | Acueisaminimaltextualhy- | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -3.1 ProblemFormulation -pothesisderivedfromhistoricaldatathathighlights -WeformulateprofilegenerationinDUETasanon- one potential aspect of a user’s preference or an -policyreinforcementlearningproblem,motivated item’scharacteristic. Ratherthanaimingforcom- -bytheabsenceofanytextualgroundtruthdefining pleteness, cues capture partial but salient signals -an optimal user or item profile. Profile quality is thatserveasstartingpointsforprofileexploration. -evaluatedsolelybyitsfunctionalutilityinafixed -| | | | | | | To extract | cues | automatically, | | the | LLM is | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -recommendationenvironment. -| | | | | | | prompted | to summarize | minimal | | but informative | | -| ---- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| DUET | is modeled | as | a generative | policy | π θ in- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | aspectsofuseroritemdata. | | | Forexample,givena | | | -teractingwithafrozendownstreamrecommender. -user’sinteractionhistory,themodelisguidedwith -| For each | user–item | pair, | the | state is | defined as | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -instructionssuchas: -| s = {H | ,H },whereH | | andH | denotetheuser | | | | | | | | -| ------ | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | u i | | u | i | | | | | | | | -and item interaction histories. An action corre- CueExtractionPrompt -spondstoasingle-passjointgeneration -“Fromthehistorybelow,analyzetheuser’s -a = {C u ,S u ,P u ,C i ,S i ,P i }, historicalinteractionstounderstandprefer- -ences,ratingbehavior,reviewsentimentor -| where | (C ,C | ) are | cues | distilled | from his- | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----- | ----- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -u i -| | | | | | | anyotherdimension. | | Keepthedescription | | | | -| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| tory, (S | u ,S i ) are | constructed | | user-item’s | profile | | | | | | | -prompts,and(P ,P )arethefinaltextualprofiles. conciseandavoidfullsentences.” -u i -| Thepolicyπ | | (a | s)definesajointdistribution | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -θ -over the entire generation sequence. As an on- This lightweight guidance allows the LLM to -policy agent, DUET is optimized using rewards maprawhistoriesandmetadataintocompacttex- -from its own sampled generations rather than by tualcues. Thedetaildexampleofcuecanbefound -| imitatingfixedsummaries. | | | | | | inAppendixA.3. | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| 3.3 | JointExplorationviaAdaptiveProfile | | | | | | Single-PassInput | | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PromptDiscovery Task:Generatestructuredprofilesfortheuseranditemfrom -historicaldata. -Aftercueextraction,DUETdoesnotdirectlysum- Combined Context: [User History H u ] + [Item -| | | | | | | | History | H i ]+[Avg | Ratings] | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -| marizeuserinterestsoritemattributes. | | | | | | Instead,it | | | | | | | -“First,extractaconciseCueforbothuseranditem.Second, -| explores | | the space | of profile | construction | | strate- | | | | | | | -| -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -basedonthecues,constructaProfilePromptthatdefines -gies—natural-languagepromptsthatdefinethefor- thedescriptionlogic.Finally,generatetheProfileguidedby -theconstructedProfilePrompt.” -mat,abstractionlevel,andattributeselectionlogic -↓DUETForwardPass↓ -| usedtogenerateprofiles. | | | | Explorationistherefore | | | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| performedoverhowprofilesshouldbeconstructed, | | | | | | | Single-PassOutput | | | | | | -User -ratherthanoversuperficialtextualparaphrases. -Cue:“prefersnostalgiclogic-basedchallenges” -For each user–item pair, DUET intro- Profileprompt: “Focuson1990svisualaestheticsand -| duces | an | explicit | intermediate | | variable, | the | strategicdepth.” | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | | Profile: | “A player | who | seeks | retro-style | visual charm | -constructed_prompt,whichservesasadiscrete -pairedwithdeepstrategicreasoning.” -| and | interpretable | | profile | prompt | S. | This profile | | | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Item -promptisashortnatural-languageinstruction(e.g., -Cue:“retro-styleindiepuzzlewithhighdifficulty” -“Describetheuser’stypicalgamingpreferencesand -| | | | | | | | Profile | prompt: | “Describe | | pixel-art | graphics and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | -engagementpatterns”)thatspecifieswhataspects intellectualdifficultytomatchlogicpreference.” -Profile:“A2Dexperiencefeaturingpixelatednostalgia -| to | describe | and | how to | organize | them, | without | | | | | | | -| --- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -andchallengingmechanicsthatdemandlogicaldeduction.” -| containingtheprofilecontentitself. | | | | | | Conditioned | | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -onS,themodelgeneratesthefinaluseranditem Figure3: Single-passgenerationinDUET: cueextrac- -| profiles. | | | | | | | tion,profileprompt(constructedprompt),andprofile | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -generationareproducedinonepassforbothuserand -| Exploration | | | is driven | by treating | | the profile | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -item. -| promptS | | asastochasticactionsampledfromthe | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| policyπ | | (S | Cue). | Duringtraining,theagentsam- | | | | | | | | | | -θ -plesdifferentprofilepromptinstructions,executes -| | | | | | | | andintellectualdifficulty”tomatch. | | | | | RLreinforces | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -| themtogenerateprofilepairs(P | | | | | ,P ),andreceives | | | | | | | | -u i -thissharedsemanticdirection,suppressingirrele- -| a reward | | based | on downstream | | recommendation | | | | | | | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | -| | | | | | | | vant signals | and | forcing | the | final | profiles to con- | -| accuracy. | | Thepolicyisoptimizedtoreinforcepro- | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | verge | into a shared | semantic | | space | of nostalgia | -filepromptsthatconsistentlyyieldhigherrewards, -andlogic,significantlyimprovingrecommendation -enablingthemodeltoactivelysearchforeffective -accuracy. -profileconstructionformats. -Thisprocessisrealizedasaunifiedgeneration -3.4 OptimizationviaOn-policyExploration -pass, -| | | | | | | | On-policy | optimization. | | | We train | the profile | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | -O = [ Cue → profilepromptS → Profile], generator π in an on-policy manner against a -| | (cid:124)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:125) | | | | | (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) | | θ | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | (cid:124) | (cid:123)(cid:122) | (cid:125) | | | | | | | | -Context ProfileConstructionPrompt Execution frozendownstreammodelf, whichservesasthe -| | | | | | | (1) | environment | critic. | For | each | sampled | user–item | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | -wheretheprofilepromptS parameterizesthepro- pair (u,i), the policy generates (P ,P ) and re- -u i -filegenerator. Atinferencetime,DUETcollapses ceivesascalarrewardbasedonthepredictionac- -thelearnedprofilepromptdistributionandgreed- curacy of f(P ,P ). The policy parameters are -u i -ilyexecutestheoptimalprofilepromptinasingle updatedtoreinforcegenerationsthatleadtolower -| forwardpass,introducingnoadditionallatency. | | | | | | | predictionerror. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | ------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| Example | | of profile | prompt | Exploration. | | As | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Continuousfractionalreward. | | | | | Usingdiscrete | -| illustrated | | in Figure | 3, | DUET | resolves | this by | | | | | | | -integerratingsasrewardsleadstosparseandunsta- -| identifying | | a shared | context | in | a single | forward | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -blefeedback,asnear-misspredictions(e.g.,predict- -pass. ThepolicyextractsacoordinatedCue(e.g., -ing4foragroundtruth5)receivethesamepenalty -“prefersretropuzzlegames”)andconstructsapro- -| | | | | | | | assevereerrors. | | Toprovidedenseandinformative | | | | -| ---- | ------ | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| file | prompt | (the | constructed_prompt) | | | that in- | | | | | | | -feedback,wedefineacontinuousfractionalreward: -structsthemodeltohighlight“nostalgicaesthetics -| and | strategic | logic” | for | the user, | while | simulta- | | | | | | | -| ------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | |y −yˆ | | | -| | | | | | | | | R (u,i) | | = 1− | ui | ui , (2) | -| neously | describing | | the item’s | “pixel-art | | graphics | | perf | | | | | -M - -where yˆ ui = f(P u ,P i ) is the predicted relevance ingsettingbasedondownstreampredictedrating -score and M is the maximum rating gap (e.g., scores. For each observed user–item interaction, -M = 4 for a 1–5 scale). This reward provides we randomly sample nine items that the user has -fine-grainedgradientsthatencourageincremental not interacted with to form a candidate set of ten -improvementsinrecommendationaccuracy. items, which are ranked in descending order ac- -We adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization cordingtotheirpredictedratings. Theground-truth -(GRPO) (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025) to optimize interacted item is treated as the only positive in- -theprofilegeneratorundertheabovereward. The stance,andweadoptNDCG@Kastheevaluation -downstreamrecommenderf isfrozenthroughout metric, with K set to 1, 5, and 10, to assess how -training, which yields a stable policy optimiza- effectivelythelearnedprofilessupportcorrectitem -| tionsettingandpreventsrewarddriftorfeedback- | | | | ranking. | | | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -| | | | | Baselines | We compare | our method | with | several | -inducedrepresentationcollapse. -| | | | | representative | baselines. | 10H | directly | uses the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -4 Experiment mostrecentinteractionhistoriesforpredictionwith- -| | | | | outconstructingexplicitprofiles. | | | KAR(Xietal., | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -4.1 ExperimentalSettings -2024)augmentsrecommendationmodelswithex- -Datasets. Experiments were conducted on three ternalreasoningknowledgeaboutuserpreferences -widelyusedreal-worlddatasets. AmazonMusic andfactualknowledgeaboutitemsextractedfrom -(Music) and Amazon Book (Book) are derived LLMs,whicharetransformedintotask-compatible -fromtheAmazonProductdataset1,whileYelpis representations. RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)lever- -fromtheYelpOpendataset2. Alldatasetsinclude agesLLMstolearnsemanticuseranditemrepre- -userreviews,ratings,andrichtextualinformation. sentationsfromtextualsignalsandalignsthemwith -WeusedthefullAmazonMusicdataset,butonly collaborativerelationalinformationthroughcross- -subsets (latest two months for Book and six for viewrepresentationlearning. PALR(Yangetal., -Yelp). Data was split by timestamp into training, 2023)fine-tunesalargelanguagemodelasarank- -validation,andtestsetstopreventinformationleak- ing component that selects preferred items from -age(Jietal.,2023). retrievedcandidatesexpressedinnaturallanguage. -EvaluationMetrics LG (LettinGo) (Wang et al., 2025) explores di- -For each observed user–item interaction (i.e., verseuserprofilecandidateswithLLMsandaligns -a review record), we construct the evaluation profilegenerationwithdownstreamrecommenda- -instance based on the user’s interaction history tionperformanceviapreferenceoptimization. Rea- -strictly prior to the corresponding timestamp. son4Rec(Fangetal.,2025)introducesadelibera- -tiverecommendationframeworkthatincorporates -Specifically,theuser’srecenthistoricalinteractions -beforethecurrentinteractionareusedtogenerate explicitstep-wisereasoningoveruserpreferences -auserprofile,whilehistoricalreviewsfromother toguideratingprediction. -| users are used | to generate | an item profile. | The | | | | | | -| -------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -4.2 MainResults -downstreamrecommendationsystemthenpredicts -theratingofthetargetitemconditionedontwoin- Table 1 presents a comparison of our proposed -puts: thegenerateduserprofile,andthegenerated method against five baselines on three datasets: -| | | | | Amazon | Music, Amazon | Books, | and | Yelp. We | -| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------ | --- | -------- | -| itemprofile. | Anexceptionisthe10Hbaseline,for | | | | | | | | -which the downstream model directly consumes use Qwen3-8B (Team, 2025) and LLaMA3-8B -therawrecentinteractionhistories. (Dubey et al., 2024) as both the profile generator -andthedownstreamrecommendationmodel,with -| We evaluate | performance | using four | widely | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -| | | | | a prediction | temperature | of 0. | In addition | to rat- | -| adopted metrics | (Wang | et al., 2025; Fang | et al., | | | | | | -2025): MeanAbsoluteError(MAE),RootMean ingpredictionresults,wealsoreportranking-based -SquareError(RMSE),Accuracy,andF1score. evaluation results in Table ??, which assess the -effectivenessofthelearnedprofilesfromadown- -Inadditiontoratingprediction,wefurtherevaluate -thegenerateduseranditemprofilesunderarank- streamrankingperspective. -| | | | | Overallsuperiorityoverstrongbaselines. | | | | As | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -1https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ shown in Table 1, our method consistently out- -amazon/links.html -| | | | | performs | the strongest | baselines | across | all three | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -2https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -| open-dataset/ | | | | datasetsunderbothQwen3-8BandLLaMA3-8B. | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) MAE RMSE Acc F1(%) -(%) (%) (%) -Qwen3(8B) -10H 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.7396 1.2184 55.34 48.67 0.7483 1.1380 58.65 60.29 0.7098 1.0923 56.17 58.78 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.8197 1.3312 47.15 42.46 0.7438 1.1069 54.89 57.65 0.7812 1.1584 52.86 55.93 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7994 1.2876 48.53 43.19 0.6075 0.9531 57.35 56.77 0.7485 1.1187 54.24 56.38 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7028 1.1523 55.69 47.73 0.5654 0.9635 58.69 54.67 0.6397 1.0098 58.47 56.84 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -LLaMA3(8B) -10H 1.0864 1.9532 22.09 27.30 0.7917 1.3346 38.13 46.87 0.8064 1.3866 37.15 45.27 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.6427 1.1668 54.51 47.98 0.5726 0.9033 57.53 59.92 0.5892 0.9614 55.87 58.21 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.7428 1.3572 46.74 42.11 0.6076 0.9886 53.78 57.42 0.6226 0.9477 52.12 55.79 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.7238 1.3265 47.72 43.29 0.5823 0.9222 56.73 59.31 0.5977 0.8855 55.06 57.62 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.6196 1.1289 56.03 51.24 0.5204 0.9369 61.92 59.50 0.5543 0.7967 58.95 60.39 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.7586 1.0418 55.80 53.00 0.5442 0.7722 60.86 54.88 0.6029 0.8345 59.70 56.35 -Ours 0.5367 0.9687 60.87 54.74 0.4680 0.8277 63.30 60.60 0.5092 0.9500 63.42 58.12 -Table1: PerformanceonthreedatasetsusingQwen3(8B)andLLaMA3(8B). -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -Table2: RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. -Under Qwen3-8B, our method achieves an accu- our approach reaches an NDCG@1 of 0.5619 -racyof61.23%onYelp,67.96%onAmazonMu- and an NDCG@10 of 0.7443, clearly outper- -sicand64.38%onAmazonBooks,surpassingLG forming the strongest baseline methods. Similar -(LettinGo)(Wangetal.,2025)by5.05%,5.59% trendsareobservedonAmazonMusic,whereour -and5.03%,respectively. Similarimprovementsare methodattains0.5347atNDCG@1and0.7331at -observed under LLaMA3-8B, indicating that the NDCG@10, as well as on Amazon Books with -gainsarestableacrossbackbonemodels. NDCG@1 of 0.4866 and NDCG@10 of 0.7107. -Theseresultsindicatethatthelearnedprofilesen- -Advantages over fixed-structure and delib- -able more accurate identification and ordering of -erative baselines. Compared with strong fixed- -relevantitemswithincandidatesets,leadingtosu- -structureordeliberativemethodssuchasKAR(Xi -perior ranking quality in downstream recommen- -etal.,2024)andReason4Rec(Fangetal.,2025), -dation. Wefurtherevaluaterankingperformance -our approach consistently achieves lower predic- -under a more challenging setting using EASE- -tion error and higher accuracy. For example, on -based (Steck, 2019) hard negatives, and observe -Amazon Books with Qwen3-8B, our method re- -consistentimprovements;detailedresultsarepro- -duces MAE to 0.4612, compared to 0.7098 for -videdinAppendixB.2. -KARand0.6397forReason4Rec,demonstrating -moreeffectiveabstractionofuserpreferenceswith- -4.3 AblationStudy -outrelyingonpredefinedreasoningtemplates. -Consistent improvements in downstream Effectivenessofprofilegeneration,cue&strategy, -ranking. Table??reportstherankingresultsun- anduser–itemjointoptimization. Table3reports -der the Qwen3-8B backbone. Our method con- the ablation results under different design con- -sistentlyachievesthebestperformanceacrossall figurations. Starting from the history-only base- -three datasets and evaluation cutoffs. On Yelp, line (10H), introducing explicit profile genera- - -| Method | | | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -| | | | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1 | MAE RMSE | Acc F1 | -10H(HistoryOnly) 1.1235 1.9478 23.17 27.54 0.9102 1.4021 39.26 46.58 0.9314 1.4527 37.63 45.19 -Profile 0.7218 1.1863 55.48 48.09 0.6597 1.0218 58.67 57.48 0.6764 1.0469 57.14 57.68 -Profile+Cue&Strategy 0.7085 1.1654 55.83 48.54 0.5708 0.9897 58.91 55.53 0.6389 1.0108 58.43 56.88 -Profile+JointOpt.(LG(Wang 0.6632 1.1047 56.18 48.95 0.4737 0.8834 62.37 57.09 0.5821 0.9416 59.35 60.57 -etal.,2025)) -Profile+Cue&Strategy+ 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -JointOpt.(Ours) -Table3: AblationstudyondifferentdesignconfigurationsinDUETusingQwen3(8B). -| Method | | Yelp | | | | AmazonMusic | | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | | (%) | -10H+30P 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3883 0.7494 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 65.13 59.97 -10H+50P 0.4909 0.9207 62.43 56.24 0.3924 0.7543 67.88 63.87 0.4553 0.9023 64.62 59.52 -10H+70P 0.4987 0.9326 61.98 55.81 0.3937 0.7564 68.22 64.12 0.4608 0.9068 64.38 59.27 -Table4: Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofilequality(usingQwen3(8B)). -tionyieldssubstantialperformanceimprovements jointoptimizationarecombined. Underthisfull -across all datasets. For example, on Yelp, MAE configuration, accuracy reaches 61.23% on Yelp, -isreducedfrom1.1235to0.7218andaccuracyin- 67.96%onAmazonMusic,and64.38%onAma- -creases from 23.17% to 55.48%, confirming that zon Books, with corresponding MAE values of -textualprofilesprovidesignificantlymoreinforma- 0.5126, 0.3937, and 0.4612, respectively. Com- -tiverepresentationsthanrawinteractionhistories. pared with the LettinGo-style configuration, this -| | | | | | | setting | yields | consistent | | improvements | across all | -| ------ | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | -| Adding | the cue&strategy | | layer | on | top of | pro- | | | | | | -| | | | | | | datasets. | | Overall,theablationresultsindicatethat | | | | -filegenerationleadstomodestbutconsistentgains. -whileprofilegenerationandjointoptimization -OnAmazonMusic,MAEfurtherdecreasesfrom -0.6597to0.5708,whileaccuracyslightlyimproves contributesubstantiallytoperformancegains,inte- -gratingcue&strategydiscoveryfurtherenhances -| from58.67%to58.91%. | | | Althoughthenumerical | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | the | effectiveness | | of joint | user–item | optimization | -improvementsintroducedbystrategyalonearelim- -ited, these results suggest that strategy discovery byprovidingastructuredspaceforexplorationand -refinement. -primarilyreshapeshowpreferenceinformationis -abstractedandexpressed,ratherthandirectlyopti- Impactofhistoricalinteractionlengthonprofile -mizingpredictionaccuracyinisolation. -| | | | | | | quality. | | Table | 4 analyzes | the | impact of histori- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | -Whenenablingjointoptimizationwithoutstrat- cal interaction length on profile quality. Across -thethreedatasets,varyingthenumberofhistorical -| egy (i.e., | the LettinGo | (Wang | et | al., 2025)-style | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -configuration),performanceimprovesmorenotice- interactions leads to only moderate performance -ablyacrossdatasets. OnAmazonMusic,accuracy differences, indicating that our method does not -| | | | | | | strongly | | depend | on long | histories. | In particular, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | -increasesto62.37%,comparedto58.67%withpro- -filegenerationalone. Inourimplementation,this usingamoderatehistorylength(e.g.,30–50inter- -settingcorrespondstoareproductionofLettinGo, actions)alreadyachievescompetitiveorbestper- -whereprofilegenerationandjointoptimizationare formanceonmostmetrics,whilefurtherincreasing -thehistorylengthprovideslimitedadditionalgains. -| appliedwithoutthestrategylayer. | | | | Whiletheorig- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| inal method | focuses | primarily | on | user | profiling, | | | | | | | -OnYelpandAmazonBooks,extendingthehis- -weextendtheoptimizationtobothuseranditem -torylengthbeyondthisrangedoesnotconsistently -profilestoensureafaircomparison. improveaccuracyorF1scoreandmayslightlyde- -Thestrongestandmostconsistentperformance gradeperformance,suggestingthatexcessivehis- -is achieved when cue&strategy discovery and toricalinteractionscanintroducenoisyorlessrele- - -vantsignals. Incontrast,AmazonMusicexhibits maintaining comparable coverage. Compared to -relativelystableperformanceacrossdifferenthis- existing methods, which either rely on extractive -torylengths,indicatingthatuserpreferencesinthis compression(e.g.,KAR(Xietal.,2024))orgener- -domainarelesssensitivetohistorytruncation. atefree-formdescriptionswithweakergrounding -Necessity of RL-based Optimization. We com- (e.g.,RLMRec(Renetal.,2024)andPALR(Yang -pare the full model with a variant without RL etal.,2023)), DUET consistentlyattainsstronger -(DUET W/O RL) to isolate the effect of RL. As alignment without sacrificing coverage. For in- -showninTable5,removingRLleadstosubstantial stance,LG(Wangetal.,2025)achievesrelatively -performancedegradationacrossalldatasets(e.g., highalignmentbutexhibitslessstablegrounding -YelpAccuracydropsfrom61.23%to48.53%),indi- acrossdatasets,whileRLMRecattainshighercov- -catingthatthegainscannotbeattributedtoprompt erageatthecostofweakersemanticalignment. In -| designalone. | | | | | contrast,DUETmaintainsbothhighalignmentand | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Without RL, the generator reduces to a static mid-to-highcoverage,suggestingamoreeffective -mapping from interaction history to textual pro- balancebetweensemanticabstractionandevidence -| files,lackingadaptiveselectionofrelevantsignals. | | | | | preservation. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Incontrast,RLenablesoptimizingprofileconstruc- -4.5 CaseStudy -tionunderrewardfeedback,resultinginmoredis- -Figure4presentsarepresentativecasestudythat -| criminative | representations.These | | results | demon- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -strate that RL-based optimization is essential for demonstrates how semantically aligned user and -| DUET | . | | | | itemprofiles | enableaccurate | | prediction | | thattran- | -| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -scendsthelimitationsofsparserawinteractionhis- -4.4 SemanticAnalysisofGeneratedProfiles tories. In the user profile, initially scattered and -To better understand the source of performance fragmentedpreferencecuesaresystematicallydis- -gains, we analyze whether the generated profiles tilled into a stable and coherent preference struc- -exhibitmeaningfulsemanticpropertiesratherthan turefavoringfunk,soul,andprogressiverock(or- -servingasintermediatetextualartifacts. Weintro- ange), coupled with a pronounced emphasis on -duce two complementary metrics to characterize musicalcomplexityandhistoricalsignificance(pur- -semanticcompatibilityandgrounding. ple). Thecorrespondingitemprofileexhibitsstrik- -Semantic Alignment. We measure the ingsymmetry,characterizingthealbumasanexem- -embedding-levelsimilaritybetweengenerateduser plaryfunk-rockcomposition(orange)andposition- -anditemprofilesusingall-mpnet-base-v2from ingitasadefiningandculturallyinfluentialrelease -Sentence-Transformers (Reimers and Gurevych, of the 1970s (purple). This example shows 519 -2019). Foreachuser–itempair,wecomputecosine that the learned profiles capture meaningful pref- -| similarity: | | | | | erence–attributecorrespondencethatisdifficultto | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | -| | | | e ·e | | recoverfromindividualreviewsalone. | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | | | | | | | -| | Align(u,i) | = | | (3) | | | | | | | -| | | | ∥e ∥∥e ∥ | | | | | | | | -| | | | u i | | 5 Conclusion | | | | | | -| wheree | ande denotetheembeddingvectorsof | | | | | | | | | | -| | u i | | | | In this | paper, we | propose | DUET | , a | closed-loop | -| thegenerateduseranditemprofiles. | | | Highervalues | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | framework | for | jointly | generating | user | and item | -indicatestrongersemanticcompatibilitybetween -| | | | | | textualprofilesforrecommendation. | | | | | Unlikeprior | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -modeleduserpreferencesanditemcharacteristics. -| | | | | | methods | that rely | on | fixed templates | | or indepen- | -| -------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | -------------- | -| Coverage | (Faithfulness). | | We measure | token- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | dently | constructed | profiles, | DUET | | treats profile | -levelgroundingas: -| | | | | | generation | as an | exploration | problem | | and aligns | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -|Tokens(profile)∩Tokens(history)| representations directly with downstream recom- -Cov = -| | | |Tokens(profile)| | | | mendationperformance. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | -| | | | | (4) | Specifically, | | DUET | integrates | cue-based | ini- | -Thismetricquantifieshowmuchofthegenerated tialization, adaptive strategy construction, and -profileissupportedbyhistoricaltextualevidence. feedback-drivenjointoptimizationtoproduceflex- -We report coverage separately for user and item ible yet task-aligned user–item profiles. By opti- -| profiles. | | | | | mizing | both profiles | in | a shared | semantic | space, | -| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------ | -AsshowninTable6,DUETachievesthehigh- theframeworkreducessemanticmismatchandcap- -est semantic alignment across all datasets while turesinteraction-relevantsignalsthataredifficultto - -Setting Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 MAE RMSE Acc F1 -(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) -DUETw/oRL 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -DUET(full) 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table5: EffectofRL-basedoptimization(usingQwen3(8B)). -User History: -Andre' S Grindle "Tour of U.S.A.", Rating: 5.0. If your looking for heavy metals dim orgins look no further. -Andre' S Grindle "Misfits", Rating:4.0. Actually the opening title track is more of a direct pop/rock type song. But the rock n roll -returns in a big way on "Hay Fever". -............ -Item History: -Worlds Away, Rating: 4.0, Review: The CD is wonderful, and is a seminal piece of music for both the group and for those of us who -were 'of age' in the '70s and '80s. Pablo Cruise was - and is - a group that makes beautiful music like few others, and this -shipper/seller made it all the more special with a fast ship! THANKS!!! -Worlds Away, Rating: 5.0, I love this CD! I'd recommend the Pablo Cruise Millenium Collection to get to know this band. Worlds Away to -me represents the best of breezy '70s pop. Five stars! -............ -USER PROFILE: -Andre Grindle is a dedicated music enthusiast with a deep appreciation for funk, soul, and progressive rock, particularly drawn to artists -who blend technical mastery with genre-defining innovation. His reviews consistently highlight albums that showcase musical complexity, -lyrical depth, and historical significance, often referencing artists like Stevie Wonder, Prince, and Rush. He values authenticity and -artistic vision, frequently praising albums that resist trend-chasing and prioritize creative integrity. His detailed, introspective reviews -suggest a preference for nuanced analysis over superficial praise, with a focus on emotional resonance, production quality, and the -artist's evolution. While he is generous with high ratings (often 5.0), he is also willing to critique perceived shortcomings, as seen in his -4.0 for "Test for Echo" and 3.0 for "The Color of Success." His engagement is characterized by a blend of personal anecdotes, technical -appreciation, and historical context, indicating a preference for music that transcends mere entertainment. -Item PROFILE: -"Worlds Away" by Pablo Cruise is celebrated as a peak-era funk-rock album that exemplifies the band's ability to merge polished -production with genre-blurring creativity. Users consistently praise its tight musicianship, genre-defying sound, and the band's ability to -craft catchy, emotionally resonant tracks. The album's appeal lies in its seamless fusion of rock, funk, and pop, with standout tracks like -"Love Will Find a Way" and "Worlds Away" receiving particular acclaim for their infectious melodies and lyrical depth. While some users -note its dated production compared to modern standards, the majority highlight its historical significance as a defining work of the -1970s rock-funk movement. The album resonates most with fans of 1970s progressive rock, genre-defying artists, and listeners seeking -well-crafted, emotionally engaging music. Its high average rating reflects widespread admiration for its artistic ambition and enduring -appeal, though a minority acknowledges its limitations in terms of modern production quality. -Figure4: Illustrationofthemutualcorrespondencebetweenuseranditem. Thehighlightedregionsdemonstrate -thatuserpreferencessummarizedintheuserprofilealignwiththekeyattributesextractedintheitemprofile,which -providescomplementaryinformationbeyondrawhistoriesandthusimprovespredictionaccuracy. -Method Yelp AmazonMusic AmazonBooks -Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. Align UserCov. ItemCov. -10H 0.3902 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.3577 /(1.00) /(1.00) 0.2604 /(1.00) /(1.00) -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.4932 0.1745 0.1823 0.4807 0.2170 0.2391 0.5702 0.1877 0.1544 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.4010 0.2646 0.3773 0.3931 0.3526 0.4889 0.4436 0.2994 0.3506 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.4715 0.3675 0.1917 0.4938 0.2197 0.2390 0.5216 0.2050 0.2267 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.5709 0.2378 0.2682 0.5109 0.2546 0.3749 0.5506 0.3883 0.3364 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.4882 0.2348 0.2330 0.4208 0.3328 0.3595 0.4946 0.2831 0.2949 -Ours 0.6382 0.2880 0.3429 0.5947 0.4002 0.4482 0.7287 0.3457 0.3127 -Table6: Semanticalignmentandcoverageofgeneratedprofiles. Cov. denotesthefractionoftokensgroundedin -historicaltext. -recoverfromrawhistoriesorstaticpromptsalone. reinforcementlearning–basedoptimization. These -resultssuggestthatadaptive,interaction-awaretex- -Experiments on multiple real-world datasets tualprofilesprovideapromisingdirectionformore -demonstratethatDUETconsistentlyoutperforms effective interpretable and performance-oriented -strongbaselinesunderdifferentbackbonemodels, recommendationsystems. -validating the effectiveness of joint profiling and - -| Limitations | | | | | | | References | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ----- | -| | | | | | | | Keqin Bao, | Jizhi | Zhang, | Yang | Zhang, | Wenjie | Wang, | -Despiteitseffectiveness,ourapproachhasseveral FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2023. Tallrec: Anef- -fectiveandefficienttuningframeworktoalignlarge -| limitations. | First, | the | proposed | framework | | relies | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | languagemodelwithrecommendation. | | | | | InProceed- | | -onlargelanguagemodelsforbothprofilegenera- ingsofthe17thACMConferenceonRecommender -tion and downstream recommendation, which in- Systems,pages1007–1014. -| troduces | additional | computational | | | overhead | dur- | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -TingChen,Wei-LiHan,Hai-DongWang,Yi-XunZhou, -| ingtrainingandinference. | | | Whileourexperiments | | | | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | BinXu,andBin-YuZang.2007. | | | | Contentrecommen- | | | -showconsistentgainsacrossdifferentbackbones, dationsystembasedonprivatedynamicuserprofile. -the overall efficiency may be constrained when In2007Internationalconferenceonmachinelearn- -| | | | | | | | ing and | cybernetics, | | volume | 4, pages | 2112–2118. | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -| scalingtoverylargeuseroritemsets. | | | | | Second,the | | | | | | | | | -IEEE. -| quality | of the generated | | profiles | is | inherently | de- | | | | | | | | -| ------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| pendent | on the underlying | | LLMs | | and prompting | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | Yue Chen, | Minghua | | He, Fangkai | Yang, | Pu | Zhao, | -strategies. Variationsinmodelcapacityorprompt LuWang,YuKang,YifeiDong,YuefengZhan,Hao -Sun,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,andDongmei -sensitivitymayleadtodifferencesinprofilestabil- -| | | | | | | | Zhang. | 2025. | Warriormath: | | Enhancing | the | mathe- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | -ity,whichwedonotexplicitlycontrolinthecurrent -maticalabilityoflargelanguagemodelswithadefect- -design. Finally,ourevaluationfocusesontext-rich -| | | | | | | | awareframework. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2508.01245. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -recommendationscenarioswheresufficienthistor- -| | | | | | | | Paul Covington, | | Jay | Adams, and | Emre | Sargin. | 2016. | -| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -| ical reviews | are | available. | | The effectiveness | | of | | | | | | | | -Deepneuralnetworksforyoutuberecommendations. -| the proposed | strategy | | in domains | with | extremely | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -InProceedingsofthe10thACMconferenceonrec- -sparsetextualsignalsorinnon-textualmodalities -ommendersystems,pages191–198. -remainstobefurtherexplored. -DeepSeek-AI,DayaGuo,DejianYang,HaoweiZhang, -JunxiaoSong,RuoyuZhang,RunxinXu,QihaoZhu, -ShirongMa,PeiyiWang,XiaoBi,XiaokangZhang, -Data,Privacy,andEthicsConsiderations Xingkai Yu, Yu Wu, Z. F. Wu, Zhibin Gou, Zhi- -| | | | | | | | hong | Shao, | Zhuoshu | Li, Ziyi | Gao, and | 181 | others. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | | | | | 2025. | Deepseek-r1: | | Incentivizing | reasoning | | capa- | -Alldatasetsusedinthisworkarepubliclyreleased bilityinllmsviareinforcementlearning. Preprint, -arXiv:2501.12948. -bytheiroriginalowners,andwefollowtheofficial -termsofuseassociatedwitheachdataset,utilizing -JiaxinDeng,ShiyaoWang,KuoCai,LejianRen,Qigen -thedatasolelyforresearchpurposesaspermitted -| | | | | | | | Hu, Weifeng | | Ding, | Qiang Luo, | and | Guorui | Zhou. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -bytheirrespectivelicenses;forreproducibility,the 2025. Onerec: Unifyingretrieveandrankwithgen- -officialdatasetsourcesarecitedinthecorrespond- erativerecommenderanditerativepreferencealign- -ment. Preprint,arXiv:2502.18965. -ingsectionsofthispaper,andwedonotredistribute -anyrawuser-generatedcontentsuchasreviewtext AbhimanyuDubey,AbhinavJauhri,AbhinavPandey, -| aspartofthiswork. | | Thisresearchdoesnotattempt | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -AbhishekKadian,AhmadAl-Dahle,AieshaLetman, -to identify or infer the identity of any individual Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela -| | | | | | | | Fan,and1others.2024. | | | Thellama3herdofmodels. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -user,andpriortotraininganddownstreamprofile -arXivpreprintarXiv:2407.21783. -| generation, | we | apply text | filtering | | procedures | to | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -remove direct personal identifiers where applica- YiFang,WenjieWang,YangZhang,FengbinZhu,Qi- -ble;themodelsaretrainedsolelyonpubliclyavail- fanWang,FuliFeng,andXiangnanHe.2025. Rea- -son4rec:Largelanguagemodelsforrecommendation -abledata,andnoadditionalprivateorproprietary -| | | | | | | | withdeliberativeuserpreferencealignment. | | | | | Preprint, | | -| ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -| user information | | is introduced. | | Furthermore, | | we | | | | | | | | -arXiv:2502.02061. -| do not release | generated | | user | profiles | or | any per- | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -MinghuaHe,YueChen,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Wenjie -useroutputsproducedduringthemodelingprocess, -Yin,YuKang,QingweiLin,SaravanRajmohan,and -andallreportedresultsarepresentedinaggregate -| | | | | | | | DongmeiZhang.2025. | | | Execoder:Empoweringlarge | | | | -| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| form for | evaluation | purposes | | only. | From | a secu- | | | | | | | | -languagemodelswithexecutabilityrepresentationfor -rityperspective,theassociatedcoderepositoryhas codetranslation. Preprint,arXiv:2501.18460. -beenscannedforpotentialsecrets,andanyinternal -MinjieHong,ZirunGuo,YanXia,ZehanWang,Ziang -endpointsorconfidentialconfigurationinformation -| | | | | | | | Zhang, | Tao | Jin, and | Zhou Zhao. | 2025a. | Apo: | En- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---- | --- | -havebeenremovedpriortorelease. -hancingreasoningabilityofmllmsviaasymmetric -| | | | | | | | policyoptimization. | | | Preprint,arXiv:2506.21655. | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Minjie Hong, Yan Xia, Zehan Wang, Jieming Zhu, JoarSkalse,NikolausH.R.Howe,DmitriiKrashenin- -Ye Wang, Sihang Cai, Xiaoda Yang, Quanyu Dai, nikov, and David Krueger. 2025. Defining -ZhenhuaDong,ZhimengZhang,and1others.2025b. and characterizing reward hacking. Preprint, -| Eager-llm: | Enhancinglargelanguagemodelsasrec- | | | | | arXiv:2209.13085. | | | | | | -| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| ommenders | through | exogenous | behavior-semantic | | | | | | | | | -integration. InProceedingsoftheACMonWebCon- Harald Steck. 2019. Embarrassingly shallow autoen- -ference2025,pages2754–2762. codersforsparsedata. InProceedingsofTheWorld -WideWebConference(WWW),pages3251–3257. -MinjieHong,ZetongZhou,ZirunGuo,ZiangZhang, -| Ruofan | Hu, Weinan | Gan, | Jieming | Zhu, and | Zhou | | | | | | | -| ------ | ---------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ChaoSun,YaoboLiang,YamingYang,ShilinXu,Tian- -| Zhao.2025c. | Generativereasoningrecommendation | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | ------------- | -| | | | | | | mengYang,andYunhaiTong.2024. | | | | | Rlrf4rec: Re- | -| viallms. | Preprint,arXiv:2510.20815. | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | inforcement | learning | from | recsys | feedback | for en- | -JihwanJeong,YinlamChow,GuyTennenholtz,Chih- hancedrecommendationreranking. arXivpreprint -| Wei Hsu, | Azamat | Tulepbergenov, | | Mohammad | | arXiv:2410.05939. | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -| Ghavamzadeh, | and | Craig | Boutilier. | 2023. | Fac- | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | QwenTeam.2025. | | Qwen3technicalreport. | | | Preprint, | -| tual and | personalized | recommendations | | using | lan- | | | | | | | -| guagemodelsandreinforcementlearning. | | | | | Preprint, | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | | -arXiv:2310.06176. -| | | | | | | Hugo Touvron, | Louis | Martin, | Kevin | Stone, | Peter Al- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | -Yitong Ji, Aixin Sun, Jie Zhang, and Chenliang Li. bert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay -| 2023. A | critical | study | on data leakage | in | recom- | | | | | | | -| ------- | -------- | ----- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bashlykov,SoumyaBatra,PrajjwalBhargava,Shruti -| mendersystemofflineevaluation. | | | | ACMTrans.Inf. | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | Bhosale,and1others.2023. | | | Llama2: | | Openfoun- | -Syst.,41(3):75:1–75:27. -| | | | | | | dation and | fine-tuned | chat | models. | arXiv | preprint | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ----- | -------- | -arXiv:2307.09288. -| JiachengLin,TianWang,andKunQian.2025. | | | | | Rec-r1: | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Bridginggenerativelargelanguagemodelsanduser- -| | | | | | | LeandrovonWerra, | | YounesBelkada, | | LewisTunstall, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -centricrecommendationsystemsviareinforcement -EdwardBeeching,TristanThrush,NathanLambert, -| learning. | Preprint,arXiv:2503.24289. | | | | | | | | | | | -| --------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -| | | | | | | Shengyi | Huang, | Kashif | Rasul, | and | Quentin Gal- | -| | | | | | | louédec. | TRL: | Transformer | Reinforcement | | Learn- | -AiweiLiu,MinghuaHe,ShaoxunZeng,SijunZhang, -| LinhaoZhang,ChuhanWu,WeiJia,YuanLiu,Xiao | | | | | | ing. | | | | | | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Zhou,andJieZhou.2025. | | | Wedlm:Reconcilingdiffu- | | | | | | | | | -sionlanguagemodelswithstandardcausalattention LuWang,DiZhang,FangkaiYang,PuZhao,Jianfeng -forfastinference. Preprint,arXiv:2512.22737. Liu,YuefengZhan,HaoSun,QingweiLin,Weiwei -| | | | | | | Deng, Dongmei | | Zhang, | Feng | Sun, and | Qi Zhang. | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ---- | -------- | --------- | -HongtaoLiu,FangzhaoWu,WenjunWang,Xianchen -| | | | | | | 2025. Lettingo: | | Exploreuserprofilegenerationfor | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Wang,PengfeiJiao,ChuhanWu,andXingXie.2019. -| | | | | | | recommendationsystem. | | | InProceedingsofthe31st | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -Nrpa: Neuralrecommendationwithpersonalizedat- ACMSIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscovery -tention. In Proceedings of the 42nd International andDataMiningV.2,KDD’25,NewYork,NY,USA. -ACMSIGIRConferenceonResearchandDevelop- AssociationforComputingMachinery. -mentinInformationRetrieval,pages1233–1236. -YeWang,JiahaoXun,MinjieHong,JiemingZhu,Tao -| Wensheng | Lu, Jianxun | Lian, | Wei Zhang, | Guanghua | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Jin,WangLin,HaoyuanLi,LinjunLi,YanXia,Zhou -Li,MingyangZhou,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2024. -| | | | | | | Zhao,and1others.2024. | | | Eager: | Two-streamgen- | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -Aligninglargelanguagemodelsforcontrollablerec- -arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.05063. erativerecommenderwithbehavior-semanticcollab- -ommendations. -| | | | | | | oration. | InProceedingsofthe30thACMSIGKDD | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -RadaMihalceaandPaulTarau.2004. Textrank: Bring- ConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMin- -| | | InEMNLP. | | | | ing,pages3245–3254. | | | | | | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ingorderintotext. -| Zhaopeng | Qiu, Xian | Wu, | Jingyue Gao, | and | Wei Fan. | | | | | | | -| -------- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | Triyanna | Widiyaningtyas, | | Indriana | Hidayah, | and | -2021. U-BERT:pre-traininguserrepresentationsfor -| | | | | | | TeguhBAdji.2021. | | Userprofilecorrelation-based | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -improved recommendation. In AAAI, pages 4320– similarity(upcsim)algorithminmovierecommenda- -| 4327.AAAIPress. | | | | | | tionsystem. | JournalofBigData,8(1):52. | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| NilsReimersandIrynaGurevych.2019. | | | | Sentence-bert: | | | | | | | | -| | | | | | | J.Wu.2023. | Computationalunderstandingofuserin- | | | | | -Sentenceembeddingsusingsiamesebert-networks. -terfaces. -InProceedingsofthe2019ConferenceonEmpirical -MethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing(EMNLP), -pages3982–3992. Yunjia Xi, Weiwen Liu, Jianghao Lin, Xiaoling Cai, -| | | | | | | Hong Zhu, | Jieming | Zhu, | Bo Chen, | Ruiming | Tang, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ----- | -Xubin Ren, Wei Wei, Lianghao Xia, Lixin Su, Suqi WeinanZhang,andYongYu.2024. Towardsopen- -Cheng,JunfengWang,DaweiYin,andChaoHuang. world recommendation with knowledge augmenta- -2024. Representationlearningwithlargelanguage tionfromlargelanguagemodels. InProceedingsof -modelsforrecommendation. InProceedingsofthe the18thACMConferenceonRecommenderSystems, -| ACMonWebConference2024,pages3464–3475. | | | | | | pages12–22. | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -A ExperimentSetup -FanYang,ZhengChen,ZiyanJiang,EunahCho,Xiao- -| jiangHuang,andYanbinLu.2023. | | Palr:Personaliza- | | | | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| tionawarellmsforrecommendation. | | arXivpreprint | A.1 DataCuration | | | | | | | -arXiv:2305.07622. -Jiarui Zhang. 2024. Guided profile generation im- Table7: Statisticaldetailsoftheevaluationdatasets. -| proves personalization | with llms. | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | -| arXiv:2409.13093. | | | Dataset | #Train | #Valid | | #Test #User | | #Item | -| | | | Music | 43,071 | 3,271 | | 1,296 | 4,183 | 2,660 | -| | | | Book | 71,972 | 6,144 | | 5,541 13,863 | | 13,515 | -| | | | Yelp | 51,497 | 4,757 | | 4,328 | 8,453 | 13,426 | -| | | | We conduct | | experiments | | on three | widely | used | -real-worlddatasets: -| | | | • AmazonMusic(Music): | | | | Thisreferstothe“Dig- | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | ital Music” | | subset | of the | well-known | | Amazon | -Productdataset3,whichrecordsrichuserreviews, -ratings,andtextualinformationaboutitems,such -| | | | as titles, | across | a | broad | range | of product | cate- | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | -gories,ontheAmazonplatform.2 -| | | | • AmazonBook(Book): | | | Thisreferstothe“Book” | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -subsetoftheAmazonProductdataset. -dataset4, -| | | | • Yelp: | This | refers | to the | Yelp | Open | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | | which | includes | user | reviews, | ratings | | for busi- | -| | | | nesses | such | as restaurants | | and | retail shops, | as | -wellastextualinformationaboutthebusinesses. -Itiswidelyusedinrecommendationtasks(Qiu -etal.,2021). -WeusetheentireMusicdatasetforexperiments, -| | | | while for | the Book | | and Yelp | datasets, | we | utilize | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | -| | | | onlyasubsetduetotheirlargesize. | | | | | FortheBook | | -dataset,weusedatafromthelasttwomonths,and -fortheYelpdataset,weusedatafromthelastsix -months. Foreachdataset,wesplititintotraining, -| | | | validation, | and | test | sets based | on | the timestamps | | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -| | | | of interactions, | | ensuring | that | test | interactions | oc- | -curafteralltrainingandvalidationinteractionsto -preventinformationleakage(Jietal.,2023). -| | | | Regarding | | data | filtering, | following | | prior | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | -------- | ----- | -| | | | work (Liu | et | al., 2019), | we | adopt | a 5-core | set- | -tingtofilterthedataandexcludecold-startusers -| | | | and items—those | | not | appearing | | in the | training | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | -| | | | set—from | the | validation | and | test | sets. | The sta- | -tisticaldetailsoftheprocesseddatasetareprovided -inTable7. -3https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~jmcauley/datasets/ -amazon/links.html. -4https://business.yelp.com/data/resources/ -open-dataset/. - -| A.1.1 | ImplementationDetails | | | | | | RLMRecPrompt | | | | -| ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -Inourexperiments,weprimarilyemployQwen3- Role: Businessrecommendationassistant -Task: Determinebusinesstypesauserislikely -| 8B(Team,2025)andLLaMA38BInstruct | | | | | | (Dubey | | | | | -| ------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| etal.,2024;Touvronetal.,2023)asboththerec- | | | | | | | toenjoy | | | | -| ommendation | | model | and | the | profile | generation | InputFormat: | | | | -•Title: Businessname -model. Thetrainingprocessisimplementedusing -theTRL(vonWerraetal.). Keyhyperparameters, •Categories: Businesscategories -suchasbatchsizeandlearningrate,aredetermined •Sentiment: Usersentimenttowardbusiness -throughgridsearchtoachieveoptimalperformance. -OutputRequirements: -Moredetailscanbefoundinourcode. -1. JSONformatonly -2. Structure: -A.2 BaselinePrompts -{ -| | | | | | | | "summarization": | "Types | of businesses | user | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- | -KARPrompt -likelyenjoys"(≤100words), -Task: Analyzeuserpreferencesbasedonbusi- -| | | | | | | | "reasoning": | "Brief explanation | | for summa- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | -nessreviewinghistory -rization"(nowordlimit) -Input: {user_history}-User’sbusinessreview- -} -inghistorywithsentimentsovertime -3. NoadditionaltextoutsideJSON -Instructions: -| 1. | Analyze | the | user’s | preferences | considering | | | | | | -| --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | Input: | INTERACTION | | ITEMS: | -businessnamesandcategories -{user_history} -| 2. | Take | into account | | sentiment | patterns | over | | | | | -| --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -time -| 3. | Provideclearexplanationsbasedonreview- | | | | | | LGPrompt | | | | -| --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -inghistorydetails -Youwillserveasanassistanttohelpmegener- -| 4. | Consider | other | pertinent | | factors | that may | | | | | -| --- | -------- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ateauserprofilebasedonthisuser’ssentiments -influencepreferences -historytobetterunderstandthisusers’interest -andthuspredicthis/hersentimentaboutatarget -| PALRPrompt | | | | | | | item. Iwillprovideyouwithsomebehaviorhis- | | | | -| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | toryoftheuserinthisformat: | | [itemattributes | | -Task: Summarizeuserpreferencesusingkey- -| | | | | | | | andsentiment]. | Theuserprofileyougenerate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -words. -shouldcontainasmuchusefulcontentaspossi- -| Input: | | {user_history} | | - historical | businesses | | | | | | -| ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -bletohelppredicttheuser’ssentimenttowards -withusersentiments. -anewbusiness. -| Output | | Format: | An | itemized | list ranked | by | | | | | -| ------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -USERHISTORY:{user_history}. -importance. -PROFILEYOUGENERATE: -Template: -| | • KEY_WORD_1: | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -R4RecPrompt(Reasoner) -| | TORY_BUSINESS_1", | | | | | "HIS- | | | | | -| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -UserReviewHistory -TORY_BUSINESS_2" -⟨H u organizedasbelow⟩ -| | • KEY_WORD_2: | | | | | "HIS- | 1. TitleofItem1 | | | | -| ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | TORY_BUSINESS_3" | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| | | | | | | | NegativeAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| Instructions: | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -[Preference2],... -| | 1. Extract | key | preference | | indicators | from | | | | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2. TitleofItem2 -userinteractionhistory. -| | | | | | | | PositiveAspects: | [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -2. Rankkeywordsbyimportance. NegativeAspects: [Aspect1],[Aspect2],... -| | | | | | | | User Preference | Elements: | [Preference | 1], | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | - -| [Preference2],... | | | | | | | cantlyworsethanDUETacrossalldatasets. | | | | | This | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -indicatesthatcoherentsummariesaloneareinsuf- -... -| | | | | | | | ficient, | and that | the gains | of DUET | | arise from | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -ItemReviewHistorybyOtherUsers -⟨H organizedinthesameformatasabove⟩ learnedsemanticabstractionratherthanextractive -i -compression. -| Task: | Analyze | whether | | the user | will | like the | | | | | | | -| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| new Music | | i based | on | the user’s | preferences | | | | | | | | -B.2 RankingunderHardNegativeSampling -| andtheitem’sfeatures. | | | | Provideyourrationale | | | | | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toconstructamorechallengingrankingscenario, -inoneconciseparagraph. -wereplacerandomnegativeswithhardnegatives -| | | | | | | | generatedbyacollaborativefilteringmodel. | | | | | Specif- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -A.3 ExampleofCue -ically,foreachuser,weretrievehigh-scoringitems -Thefollowingexamplesillustratehowrawsignals -| | | | | | | | from an | EASE(Steck, | 2019) | model | that | the user | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | -------- | -| aredistilledintocues. | | | Asshownonthetop, | | | user | | | | | | | -hasnotinteractedwith,andcombinethemwiththe -cuesemphasizehistoricalpreferences,whileitem -ground-truthitemtoformthecandidateset. -cues highlight metadata and user-group patterns. Table 9 reports the results. Compared to ran- -| Together, | they | provide | minimal | | but informative | | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -domsampling,performancedecreasesforallmeth- -hypothesesforprofileexploration. -| | | | | | | | ods due | to increased | difficulty, | while | DUET | con- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ---- | ------ | -| | | | | | | | sistently | maintains | the | best performance | | across | -ExamplesofUserCues -| | | | | | | | datasets. | Thisindicatesthattheimprovementsare | | | | | -| ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “enjoys | retro | puzzle | games” | — | derived | from re- | | | | | | | -robustandnotlimitedtotrivialrankingscenarios. -peatedengagementwithclassictitles. -“prefersconciseproductreviews”—inferredfrom B.3 RobustnessunderPreferenceDiversity -apatternofshort,directcomments. -WefurtheranalyzetherobustnessofDUETunder -“tendstogivehighratingsbutrarelycomments”— -| | | | | | | | varyinglevelsofuserpreferencediversity. | | | | | Weuse | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -highlightingconsistencybutlimitedfeedback. -thevarianceofhistoricalratingsasaproxyforpref- -| | | | | | | | erencestability: | | lowvarianceindicatesconsistent | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -ExamplesofItemCues -| | | | | | | | preferences, | while | high | variance | corresponds | to | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -“lightweighttrail-runningshoes”—derivedfrom -diverseorpotentiallyconflictingsignals. -productmetadata. -Wepartitionusersintothreegroupsbasedonper- -| “popular | among | budget-conscious | | | users” | — in- | | | | | | | -| -------- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -centilethresholds(bottom33%,middle33%,top -ferredfrompurchasepatterns. -33%ofratingvariance)andevaluateperformance -| “stylized | with | retro | aesthetics” | | — extracted | from | | | | | | | -| --------- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -withineachgroup. -itemdescriptions. -| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Table 10, | performance | | degrades | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | -smoothlyaspreferencediversityincreasesacross -| | | | | | | | all datasets. | Importantly, | | the degradation | | is grad- | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -B AdditionalExperiments -ualratherthancatastrophic,indicatingthatDUET -B.1 Non-LLMBaselineviaExtractive -remainsstableunderheterogeneousornoisyinter- -Summarization -actionhistories. -| To examine | | whether | the | gains | of DUET | stem | | | | | | | -| ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -C TheUseofLargeLanguageModels -| from improved | | semantic | | representations | | rather | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| than generic | | text generation, | | we | introduce | a non- | | | | | | | -WeusedaLargeLanguageModel(LLM)onlyas -LLMbaselinebasedonextractivesummarization. a writing assistant to polish the language of the -| Specifically, | | we apply | TextRank | | (Mihalcea | and | | | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -| | | | | | | | manuscript | (e.g., | grammar | refinement, | | style ad- | -Tarau,2004)toselectsalientsentencesfromuser -| | | | | | | | justment,andclarityimprovement). | | | | Theresearch | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -historiesandconstructuserprofileswithoutusing ideas,methodologydesign,experiments,andanal- -anygenerativemodel. ysiswereentirelyconceived,implemented,andval- -| The | extracted | summaries | | are | then fed | into the | | | | | | | -| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -idatedbytheauthorswithoutrelianceontheLLM. -samedownstreampredictorforratingestimation. -| | | | | | | | The LLM | did not | contribute | to research | | ideation, | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -Thisbaselineisolatestheeffectofreadablesumma- experimentaldesign,orresultinterpretation. -rizationfromrepresentationlearning. -Table8showsthatTextRankimprovesoversim- -| ple history | truncation | | (10H), | but | remains | signifi- | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Method | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | -------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| | MAE RMSE | Acc | F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | MAE | RMSE | Acc F1(%) | -| | | (%) | | | | (%) | | | (%) | -10H 0.8283 1.3893 48.53 41.15 0.7322 1.1430 57.18 52.48 0.8741 1.4760 51.83 50.35 -TextRank 0.8104 1.1323 50.51 30.23 0.5914 0.8223 61.19 29.68 0.6328 0.8854 59.59 29.48 -Ours 0.5126 0.9485 61.23 55.18 0.3937 0.7564 67.96 63.89 0.4612 0.9089 64.38 59.27 -Table8: Comparisonwithanon-LLMextractivesummarizationbaseline(TextRank). -| Method | | | Yelp | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -| ------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 NDCG@1 NDCG@5 NDCG@10 -10H 0.1823 0.2815 0.4928 0.1875 0.3796 0.5153 0.1841 0.3146 0.4263 -KAR(Xietal.,2024) 0.2156 0.3298 0.5412 0.3018 0.4896 0.6015 0.2965 0.4715 0.5834 -RLMRec(Renetal.,2024) 0.2419 0.3472 0.5587 0.3371 0.5434 0.6162 0.2748 0.4526 0.5719 -PALR(Yangetal.,2023) 0.2494 0.3563 0.5691 0.3395 0.5247 0.6115 0.2627 0.4634 0.5538 -LG(Wangetal.,2025) 0.3187 0.4685 0.5814 0.4012 0.5674 0.6489 0.3795 0.5189 0.6284 -R4Rec(Fangetal.,2025) 0.2575 0.3792 0.5526 0.2928 0.5912 0.6343 0.3013 0.4928 0.5959 -Ours 0.3390 0.4873 0.6008 0.5123 0.6165 0.7025 0.4288 0.5638 0.6599 -| | Table9: | RankingperformanceunderEASE-based(Steck,2019)hardnegatives. | | | | | | | | -| ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| VarianceGroup | | Yelp | | | AmazonMusic | | | AmazonBooks | | -#Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 #Samp. MAE RMSE Acc F1 -| | | | (%) | (%) | | (%) (%) | | | (%) (%) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | -Stable 1530 0.4017 0.8664 71.76 68.96 432 0.2368 0.5990 82.56 86.89 1876 0.3171 0.8403 76.64 72.56 -Moderate 1354 0.4773 0.8309 60.09 46.26 436 0.3921 0.6628 64.16 47.02 1827 0.4495 0.8059 66.73 55.45 -Diverse 1444 0.6632 1.1198 51.13 45.95 428 0.5536 0.9607 57.10 59.27 1838 0.6199 1.0603 49.52 46.35 -Table10: PerformanceofDUETunderdifferentlevelsofuserpreferencediversity(measuredbyratingvariance). -#Samp. denotesthenumberofsamplesineachgroup. \ No newline at end of file +Chapter 7 + +Competitive Positioning + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Short Description +• Background +• Strategic Rationale & Implications +• Strengths & Advantages +• Weaknesses & Limitations +• Process for Applying Technique +• Summary +• FAROUT + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.2 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Short Description +• Analyze a position relative to one’s own in order + +to: +– Preserve an advantage +– Attempt an improvement +– Withdraw from a market + +• Looks at: + +– Market share, client perceptions, current + +marketing strategies, prices and costs, and +competitors’ positions. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.3 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Background + +1950’s-60’s + +Late 60’s- +70’s + +•‘Corporate planning’ approach by firms founded on +steady expansion in a stable financial environment. +•Marketing tells about product benefits in comparison +with competition. + +•Corporate planning shifts to strategic planning and +management to as competition increases and market is +more volatile. +•Marketing attempts to change perception of product in +the mind of the customer by creating unique position. + +1980’s- now •Competitive positioning continues to evolve to provides +information with importance to the development of a +strategic plan by giving a firm an overview of its industry +and enabling it to appraise its own competitive position. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.4 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strategic Rationale & Implications + +• Analysis should reveal firms’ position within an industry. +• Overview of industry as a whole. +• A variety of tools and models can assist, including: + +Porter’s Five Forces Industry Analysis +Nine Forces Industry Analysis +BCG Matrix +McKinsey Matrix +Perceptual Maps + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.5 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Strategic Rationale & Implications + +4 Directions for any Strategy + +Develop firms’ +position + +Expand niche + +Minor to dominant + +Joint to sole +dominance + +Maintain strong position + +Preserve market share +in mature market + +Defend dominant position + +Withdraw from market + +Price cutting strategy + +New product +strategy + +Other strategies + +Market decline or +obsolescence + +Unsuccessful +expansion + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.6 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Strengths and Advantages +• Improves decision making + +• Provides information for firms of all sizes, + +stages, and positions on: +– Gaps in marketplace +– Viability of products or markets +– Competition in new markets +– Attracting investment and creating alliances + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.7 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Weaknesses and Limitations +• Care must be taken in defining industries and + +markets. + +• Competitor information is not always available. +• Competitor and new product information is not + +always accurate. + +• Results may be limited by internal biases. +• Third party analysts may be misled by incomplete + +information. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.8 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +Can be defined as a broad 3-step process: + +1. + +Identify focus of your firm's current strategy and +analysis parameters such as market or products to be +assessed. + +2. Conduct analysis with the following: + +• Market segmentation +• Industry Analysis +• Market Research + +3. Derive insights from the above analysis and formulate + +positioning strategy for your firm. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.9 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 1: Assess current strategy and market, + +product, project, parameters. +– What is the scope of this project? +– What do you plan to do with this information? +– Will research be done in house, or by a third + +party? + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.10 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Product Market Matrix + +Markets + +current + +potential + +Products + +Current + +Potential + +c +u +r +r +e +t +n +t + +*SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility +Exit Barriers + +Description +Business Volume +Demand Trends +Competition +Market Shares +Technology Changes +Ease of Entry +Compatibility + +Options + +Keep or drop? + +Determine +Product +Structure + +Set Pricing + +Options +Determine +Product +Structure + +Choose timing + +Go/No go + +Ch7.11 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis +– Market Segmentation: + +• Identifiable and measurable +• Accessible by communication/distribution + +channels + +• Have unique needs +• Be stable over time + +– Segments may be made up of +individual or industry consumers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.12 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Segmentation + +Individual + +Industry + +Geography + +Demographics + +Psychographics + +Behavior + +Geography + +Client Type + +Client Behavior + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.13 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Industry + +– SWOT Analysis +– Porter’s Five Forces Model +– Other tools + +• Step 2: Conduct Analysis: Market Research + +– Preferably conducted by third party. +– Use surveys, telemarketing, face-to-face + +interviews. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.14 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Process for Applying the Technique +• Step 3: Formulate position strategy + +– Use combination of perceptual maps, strengths and weaknesses of +self and competitors on matrices, and refer back to information +gathered in Steps 1&2. + +Strength/Weakness Evaluation Matrix: Sales Force Quality +SOURCE: Royce and Morse (1983), Competitive Analysis, SRI International + +Much Better + +Somewhat Better + +Same + +Somewhat Worse + +Much Worse + +0 +Strength or Weakness + +2 + +4 + +6 + +Relative Importance to success + +8 + +10 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.15 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• Summary: + +Complete competitive positioning analysis will have: + +– Outline of current and potential products/markets + +• Product/market matrix can be helpful. + +– Identified competitive practices in the industry including +• Costs, revenue and profits, opportunities, weaknesses to + +exploit and strengths to overcome or avoid. + +– Factors contributing to client satisfaction with their + +current suppliers + +• Ability to understand value of purchases, availability & + +convenience of products, quality of service, loyalty, effort +required to change suppliers. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.16 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Summary Continued: +• Undertake an overall appraisal of the competitive + +environment to identify any strategies or tactics, which +may improve your firm’s competitive position and identified +a set of strategies to take the firm where it wishes to go in +an industry. + +• Should have comprehensive view of the market. +• Any gaps or unmet needs should be apparent. + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.17 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +• FAROUT Summary + +1 + +2 + +3 + +4 + +5 + +F + +A + +R + +O + +U + +T + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.18 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques +• Industry Analysis +• SWOT Analysis +• Value Chain Analysis +• Competitor Analysis +• Financial Ratio and Statement Analysis +• Customer Segmentation Analysis +• BCG Growth/Share Portfolio Matrix +• GE Business Screen + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.19 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +Related Tools and Techniques Cont’d +• Supply Chain Analysis +• Product Line Analysis +• Benchmarking + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.20 + + Ch7. Competitive Positioning + +For More About Competitive +Positioning and 23 Other Useful +Analysis Methods, see: + +Fleisher, Craig S. and Babette E. +Bensoussan + +Business and Competitive +Analysis: Effective Application of +New and Classic Methods + +Upper Saddle River, NJ +2007 + +FT Press 2007. All Rights +Reserved. + +Business and Competitive Analysis. +By C. Fleisher & B. Bensoussan. + +Ch7.21 + diff --git a/q46/random_k4/random_4.md b/q46/random_k4/random_4.md index 1b20aca545e3b6302b6cd7205beb97b9808a6126..34cdcd19c6cb0a642a42b2f9041e8b5fe2960ca9 100644 --- a/q46/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q46/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,766 +1,90 @@ -Managing Scientific Data with -Microsoft Azure Storage +POP Displays, Retail Store Fixtures and Store Buildouts -Introduction -Microsoft Azure Storage is a cloud-based distributed storage service that you can use to store -many different types of data, ranging from images and videos to text files, log files, and sensor -data. The Microsoft Azure Storage service provides numerous benefits. It scales to -accommodate huge amounts of data, permits access to that data easily from any location at any -time, and provides load balancing to support variable traffic volumes. Furthermore, Microsoft -Azure Storage makes three copies of your data to ensure that it is always accessible if a storage -node fails or a data center becomes unavailable. Optionally, it provides geo-redundant storage -by replicating your data to an alternate data center region hundreds of miles away, but in the -same geo-political area (known as a geo). You can also set up your storage account with the -Microsoft Azure Content Delivery network to cache data closer to your users and thereby -provide a consistent high-performance user experience regardless of their distance from a data -center. + Introduction -Microsoft Azure Storage is an ideal storage solution for scientific data. It is well suited for a -variety of scenarios, such as: +● RICH LTD. (www.richltd.com) is a point-of-purchase display, store fixture, store +buildout, and merchandising solutions company with an in-house design team, +domestic and overseas manufacturing capabilities, a full line of stock displays, and a +wide range of custom display options. - Storing instrumentation data that is growing exponentially and rapidly - Providing data to other researchers with high-performance connectivity, thereby +● Located in the San Diego area, RICH LTD. has served leading retailers and brands for +over 35 years and is recognized as one of the industry’s Top 50 POP display companies. -reducing the time required to move large data sets. +● RICH LTD. has partnered with USRA to offer its products and services to USRA +members at a 15% discount. - Accessing data from anywhere in the world with an Internet connection, whether in the + RICH LTD. Stock POP Display Options -field or in the laboratory, when getting to access to a local drive is not practical +Download our Catalog - Using virtual resources on demand as needed, without the need to plan for building and +To see additional stock options -maintaining a scalable infrastructure - - Co-locating data with Microsoft Azure compute resources, such as a scientific +MPP-HD -application running in Microsoft Azure or data analysis with HDInsight, Microsoft’s -distribution of Hadoop on Microsoft Azure +4-WAY-EXT -Microsoft Azure storage types -To start working with the Microsoft Azure Storage service, you create a storage account to serve -as the top-level namespace that you use to access storage. By default, you can set up a -maximum of five storage accounts for each Microsoft Azure subscription; additional accounts -can be enabled through a support request. Within each account, you can store up to 200 TB of -data. +(Available with shoe shelves) -To create a storage account in the Microsoft Azure Management Portal: +SW-62FL +(Available in multiple colors +and with shelves/accessories) -1. Click the New button, click Data Services, click Storage, and then click Quick Create. -2. Type a URL for your storage account, select a location or affinity group, and specify +CTX-06 -whether to enable geo-replication + RICH LTD. Stock POP Display Options +Options - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +Download our Catalog -3. Click Create Storage Account. The URL you select here becomes host name in the URI +To see additional stock options -that you use to access your data in storage. +SFL-HRACK +(Available in multiple colors +and with shelves/accessories) -Figure 1: Creating a new storage account +UMF-24 -After you create your storage account, your next step is to load data into storage. You can -choose from the following options of storage types: - Use blob storage to store any type of file. - For structured, non-relational tabular data, you can use table storage. - +(Available with shelves/accessories) -If you are running applications in Microsoft Azure, you can use queue storage to pass -messages between a Microsoft Azure web role and worker role, or to store messages to -process asynchronously. Queue storage is not the focus of this paper, but you can read -more about it at Queue Service Concepts and Queue Service REST API. +WD-2S-TGW-ST +(Available in with +shelves/accessories) -Microsoft Azure Storage explorer tools -Although the Management Portal provides you with access to many administrative activities, -you can use public HTTP or HTTPS REST endpoints to interact with storage, write an application -to transfer data and manage your storage, or acquire a third-party tool. Experiment with some -of the following tools to see which you prefer: +WD-HG-TGW-ST +(Available in with +shelves/accessories) - AzCopy (Windows) - Azure Storage Explorer (Windows) - Azure Management Studio (Windows) - CloudBerry Explorer (Windows) - CloudXplorer by ClumsyLeaf (Windows) - Azure Tools for Microsoft Visual Studio (Windows) - Zudio (any operating system, web-based) + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -You can view a list of other storage explorer tools in the Microsoft Azure Storage team blog. If -you prefer to create your own application, see How to use the Microsoft Azure Blob Storage -Service in .NET and How to: Programmatically access table storage. + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Note: Rather than use an application to load blob data into storage, you can take advantage of -the Microsoft Azure Import/Export service. This might be a more time- and cost-effective option -when you have extremely large amounts of data. You simply create a job to notify the data + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -2 + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -center and then send one or more hard drives loaded with encrypted data to a data center -where the data is uploaded to your storage account. Conversely, you can send empty drives to -the data center to have data downloaded to the drives and then returned to you. To learn more, -see Using the Microsoft Azure Import/Export Service to Transfer Data to Blob Storage. + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Microsoft Azure Blob service -A blob is simply a file. It can be binary data, such as an image or an audio file, or it can be text -data. You organize blobs inside of containers that are associated with your storage account, as -shown in Figure 2. There is no limit to the number of containers you can create in an account, -nor is there a limit to the number of blobs that you can store in a container (other than the -maximum size of the storage account). + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Figure 2: Blob storage components + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Blobs -Although a blob can be any type of file, it falls into one of the following categories: block blob or -page blob. The type of blob determines how Microsoft Azure Storage manages both storage of -the blobs and operations involving the blobs. + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Block blob -You use this type of blob for efficient upload and download (streaming) workloads of audio or -video files and for most document, text, and image file types. Essentially, the client application -performing the upload deconstructs a large blob into a sequence of blocks, with each block -having a unique block ID. Each block can be no larger than 4 MB. The total size of a single blob -cannot exceed 200 GB and must contain no more than 50,000 blocks. A client application can -upload the blocks in parallel to minimize the time needed to transfer the entire blob. In -addition, it can upload the blocks out of sequence. That way, if a block fails to upload correctly, -the client application can retry the upload of that block only and not force the entire upload to -restart. + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -Page blob -You use this type of blob for files that you want to optimize for random read-write operations -such as a database or a file system. Each page blob contains a collection of 512-byte pages with -a maximum size of 1 TB. As you create the page blob or update its contents, you write one or -more pages to storage and specify an offset and a range that corresponds to 512-byte page -boundaries. Existing pages remain unchanged. + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples -3 + RICH LTD. Custom POP Display Examples - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage + Contact -Blob snapshot -You can create a snapshot of a blob at any time to save its current state as a read-only blob. You -can interact with a blob snapshot just like a blob, except you cannot modify it. A blob snapshot -has the same URI as the parent blob, but has the date and time of creation appended to the URI. +Jim Hollen +President +760-722-2300 Ext. 229 +jhollen@richltd.com +www.richltd.com -Blob storage and Azure Storage Explorer -An easy way to work with your storage account is to download and install Azure Storage -Explorer. When you launch the application: - -1. Click the Add Account button, type in your storage account name and storage account - -key, as shown in Figure 3. -2. Click Add Storage Account. -3. Optional: you can select the Use HTTPS check box to use a secure connection for - -sensitive data. - -To locate your storage account key: - - Visit the Microsoft Azure Management Portal and access the Storage page. - Select the storage account, and then click the Manage Access Keys button at the - -bottom of the page. - - Click the icon to the right of the Primary Access Key to copy the key to your clipboard, - -Once you have the key, you can paste it into the Add Storage Account dialog box in Azure -Storage Explorer. - -Figure 3: Add storage account in Azure Storage Explorer - -Next, you need to create a container in your storage account to hold one or more blobs. To -create the blob container: - -1. Click the New button in the Container section of the ribbon. -2. Type a name for the container. -3. Click Create Container. - -Next, you need to access data to put into storage. For this demonstration: - -1. Download the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks CSV file to your computer. -2. - -In Azure Storage Explorer, select the container you created, click the Upload button, and -select the CSV file that you just downloaded. - -4 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -When the upload completes, you can see the metadata for the newly created blob in the -selected container, as shown in Figure 4, including its name, modification date, length, content -type, content encoding, and content language. - -Figure 4: Blob in Microsoft Azure Storage container - -Azure Storage Explorer allows you to manage all types of storage components: containers, -blobs, queues, and table. You can create new components, make copies of existing components, -or delete components, in addition to renaming them. In addition, you have the option to -configure security on blobs and containers by setting the access level at minimum and creating -shared access signatures and shared access policies—all of which are described later in this -document in the “Security and Microsoft Azure Storage” section. - -A viewer in Azure Storage Explorer allows you to see the properties and contents of your blobs. -Double-click the blob name in the list or select it and click the View button to view the Blob -Detail dialog box, as shown in Figure 5. You can add properties as name/value pairs on the -Metadata tab to give context to the blob. For example, you could have an Author or Project -property. You can also add metadata to containers. - -5 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Figure 5: Blob Detail in Azure Storage Explorer - -Blob storage and IPython -For greater control over blob management, you can write your own storage logic for your -application by using one of many client libraries that implement the REST API for Microsoft -Azure Storage Services, including Python. To minimize the number of tools you need to install on -your local computer, you can use an IPython Notebook server for development and write your -code in a web application. The IPython Notebook server can even be hosted in a Microsoft -Azure Virtual Machine. - -Running an IPython Notebook server on a Microsoft Azure Virtual Machine -A quick way to get started with development using an IPython Notebook server is to use an -image from VM Depot that has the necessary components installed. You can view a list of -available images on the VM Depot website and use the search bar to filter the list for images -tagged with a specific keyword, such as IPython. For instructions on how to create a virtual -machine from an image, such as the Azure Data Analysis image, refer to “Using and Contributing -Virtual Machines to VM Depot” (available from the Microsoft Azure for Research Technical -Papers website). - -Once you have the Azure Data Analysis virtual machine provisioned and started, you can -connect to it with a PuTTY client. - -1. - -In the Host Name (or IP address) box, type the DNS name for your virtual machine, as -shown in Figure 6. - -2. Click Yes to trust the connection, and then type in the user name and password that you - -established when creating the virtual machine. - -6 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Figure 6: SSH connection to Linux virtual machine - -3. - -In the PuTTY window, type the following command to start the IPython Notebook -server: - -sudo ipython notebook –profile=nbserver - -You might need to supply your password again to execute this command. The notebook server is -successfully started when you see the message to use Control-C to stop the server, as shown in -Figure 7. - -Figure 7: IPython Notebook Server successfully started - -Now you are ready to start coding. To do this, open your browser and use the DNS address for -your virtual machine, https://.cloudapp.net. Be sure to use the HTTPS -protocol. You will see a warning about the security, which you can ignore for this -demonstration, and then you must respond to the prompt for the login password for the -IPython Notebook on first load. For the IPython Notebook server, the password is -Elastacloud123. - -7 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Writing data directly into blob storage -Using IPython, you can develop an application that connects to storage, writes data into a local -file, and then uploads the file as a blob into a container. In the sample code below, these steps -are achieved by using the BlobService object and the put_blob method. For other code samples -demonstrating how to download (get_blob) and perform other operations, see How to Use the -Blob Storage Service from Python. - -Click the New Notebook button in the top right corner of the IPython notebook window, and -then copy the following code sample and paste it into the gray box in the browser. Be sure to -replace the account, key, and container name variables with values specific to your storage -account. - -#first import required modules -from azure.storage import * -import os -import csv -import numpy -from collections import defaultdict -import time - -#replace the following values with your own account name, primary access key, and -container name -account = 'myazurestoragewestus' -key = 'mdJnNXPYS1cC5T4pf+9yva/ …. etc' -containername = 'mystorage' - -#get a handle to your account -blob_service = BlobService(account_name=account, account_key=key) - -#create a new file a blob into a container -open(r'mytextfile.txt', 'w').write("This is a sample text file.") - -#upload the blob into the container -textblob = open(r'mytextfile.txt', 'r').read() -blob_service.put_blob(containername, 'mytextfile.txt', textblob, -x_ms_blob_type='BlockBlob') - -#use azure storage explorer to find the mytextfile.txt file - -To execute the code, click the Run Cell button (with the arrow icon), as shown in Figure 8. Then -use another tool like Azure Store Explorer to view the uploaded file. - -Figure 8: Run Cell button executes code - -8 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Removing a blob from storage -You can also use IPython to remove a blob from storage, as shown in the next code sample. In -this example, you use the delete_blob method. Paste this code into the notebook document, -and then execute it. When it completes, confirm that the blob no longer exists in storage. - -#Remove mytextfile.txt -os.remove(r'mytextfile.txt') - -#delete the blob remotely -blob_service.delete_blob(containername, 'mytextfile.txt') - -#check the azure storage explorer again, the file is removed - -Blob storage and AzCopy -AzCopy is a command-line utility that you can use to copy blobs between storage accounts or to -a different container in the same storage account. This is a much faster process than -downloading the blob locally and then uploading it again to a different target location. To use -this utility, you must know the URI for the source and target accounts and containers in addition -to the keys for the source and target. Open a command prompt window and type the respective -commands shown below after replacing the source and target names and keys: - - You can move all blobs from a source container in a source account to a target container - -in a different storage account. - -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /S - - By adding the /MOV flag to the command, you can delete blobs from the source after - -they have been successfully copied. - -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /MOV /S - - When you have blobs with snapshots, you can use the utility with the /SNAPSHOT flag -to move not only the base blobs, but also the blob snapshots. The snapshots will be -renamed to conform to this pattern: [blob-name][snapshot-time][extension]. - -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /S /SNAPSHOT - - - -If you repeatedly execute the utility with the same source and target, you can put the -URIs in a text file like this: - -#URI of Source Container - -https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -9 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -#URI of Destination Container - -https://.blob.core.windows.net// - -Then you can reference the file in the command line in lieu of the URIs: - -AzCopy /@:C:\myAzCopy.txt /sourcekey: /targetkey: /MOV /S - -Blob storage and Node.js -Similar to Python and AzCopy, CLI and Node.js can be used to copy local files up to Blob Storage, -this works on Windows, Linux, and Mac. - -CLI – Copy a local file to blob - -azure storage blob upload -a "japandata" -k "xdJ…storage-key…==" "foo.gz" - -"backups" "foo.gz" –q - -See azure storage blob upload -h for details on individual parameters. - -Node.js – Copy a local file to blob -var azure = require('azure'); -var fs = require('fs'); - -var storageAccountName = 'myazurestorageaccountname'; -var storageAccountKey = 'myazurestorageaccountkey'; -var storageContainerName = 'mystoragecontainername'; - -var blobService = azure.createBlobService( - storageAccountName, storageAccountKey, - storageAccountName + '.blob.core.windows.net'); - -var fileNameList = [ 'localfile1.json', 'localfile2.json' ]; -for (var i=0; i ' + fileName); - blobService.createBlockBlobFromFile( - storageContainerName, fileName, fileName, - { - contentType: 'application/json', - cacheControl: 'public, max-age=3600' // max-age in seconds - }, - function(error) { - if (error) { - console.error(error); - } - }); -} - -Asynchronous copy -Microsoft Azure has asynchronous copy support for files that are already in blob storage. You -can use it to make a copy of a blob within the same storage account, or to copy blobs across -storage accounts, even if the data is being copied between data centers. Once you initiate a -copy, Microsoft Azure handles all of the activity as a background process. This means that you - -10 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -can initiate the copy of a very large blob from anywhere, including a computer running outside -the cloud, but rather than first downloading the blob to the initiating computer and then -uploading to the new destination, the Microsoft Azure Blob service can pull it directly into the -designated storage account. Consequently, data transfers are as efficient as possible, and client -code does not need to wait for transfers to finish. The status of the transfer can be monitored, -and in-progress transfers can be canceled. This feature is especially useful for large blobs that -are gigabytes or terabytes in size. - -Asynchronous copy with PowerShell - -# SOURCE DATA (public blob, in data center in US East) -# sourceBlob can be a HUGE FILE, gigabytes or terabytes -$sourceBlob = 'https://azuremap.blob.core.windows.net/maps/azuremap.geojson' - -# DESTINATION (private container, in data center in Japan West) -$japanAcct = 'japandata' -$japanContainer = 'backups' -$japanKey = 'xdJ…storage-key-goes-here…RA=='$destinationContext = New- -AzureStorageContext ` - -StorageAccountName $japanAcct ` - -StorageAccountKey $japanKey - -# In this example, the source blob is addressed by a URL that is publicly -# accessible; once the copy request is accepted by the Microsoft Azure Blob -# service, it takes over and handles all the processing. - -Start-AzureStorageBlobCopy -AbsoluteUri $sourceBlob ` - -Context $destinationContext ` - -DestContainer $japanContainer ` - -DestBlob 'new.file.name' - -You can learn more at Start-AzureStorageBlobCopy. - -Asynchronous copy with Node.js -After executing “npm install azure”, the following Node.js code will start an asynchronous copy, -just like in the PowerShell example. - -var azure = require('azure'); - -// SOURCE DATA (public blob, in data center in US East) -// sourceBlob can be a HUGE FILE, gigabytes or terabytes -var sourceBlob = -'https://azuremap.blob.core.windows.net/maps/azuremap.geojson'; - -// DESTINATION (private container, in data center in Japan West) -var japanAcct = 'japandata'; -var japanContainer = 'backups'; -var japanKey = 'xdJ…storage-key-goes-here…RA==' -// In this example, the source blob is addressed by a URL that is publicly -// accessible; once the copy request is accepted by the Microsoft Azure Blob -// service, it takes over and handles all the processing. - -var blobService = azure.createBlobService(japanAcct, japanKey); -blobService.copyBlob(sourceBlob, japanContainer, 'new.file.name.node', function -(error) { - -11 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - - if (error != null) { - console.log(error); - } -}); - -Microsoft Azure Table storage -Use table storage for high volumes of structured, non-relational data. An analogous type of data -is a Microsoft Excel worksheet containing multiple rows of data that can have a different -number of populated columns per row and even different data types in the same column across -multiple rows. Table storage provides flexibility to your applications without requiring you to -define and maintain a strict data model. It is highly scalable with fast query response times. - -Table storage components -You can add a table of up to 200 TB in size to your storage account and then associate entities -with tables, as shown in Figure 9. An entity is like a row in a table and represents a collection of -up to 255 properties. It has a maximum size of 1 MB. - -Figure 9: Table storage components - -Each property is a name-value pair. There are three required properties: PartitionKey, RowKey, -and Timestamp. PartitionKey and RowKey are set by the developer, and the system sets -Timestamp. PartitionKey and RowKey form a single clustered index for the table to enable fast -query performance. Entities having the same PartitionKey are stored together physically, -whereas partitions in the same table can be located on separate storage nodes. Inserts, updates, -and deletes in the same partition can be handled as part of the same transaction. - -Table storage and Azure Management Studio -Although you can use Azure Storage Explorer to manage tables, another option to consider is -Cerebrata’s Azure Management Studio. When you open Azure Management Studio, you need to -connect to your Microsoft Azure subscriptions. - -1. Sign in to your Microsoft Azure account to download your publishsettings file. -2. Select the subscription file to download. -3. - -In Azure Management Studio, open the File menu, point to Import, click Publish -Settings, and select the publishsettings file you just downloaded. - -Your subscription displays in the Connection Group pane on the left side of the screen. - -4. You can open the Storage Account node to access existing storage accounts, or right- - -click the Storage Account node and select New Storage Account if you need to create a -storage account. - -12 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -5. - -In the Connection Group pane, expand the storage account that you want to use for -table storage, right-click Tables, point to New, and then choose one of the options -shown in Figure 10. (For example, you could use the Table from CSV option to upload -the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks file into your storage account.) - -Figure 10: New table creation in Azure Management Studio - -After you specify the file name to upload and configure any additional properties specific to your -data, such as renaming a column name, the upload begins. You can monitor the upload progress -in the Transfers pane that displays at the bottom of Azure Management Studio. When the -upload is complete, you can view the data in Azure Management Studio, as shown in Figure 11: - -1. Expand the Tables node. -2. Right-click your table. -3. Select Open. - -13 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Figure 11: Data in table storage accessible in Azure Management Studio - -Table storage and IPython -Just as you can use IPython to manage blob storage, you can also use it to manage table storage. -The following code sample works if you have your environment set up as described in the -“Running an IPython Notebook Server on a Microsoft Azure Virtual Machine” section of this -document. - -Writing data to a table -To demonstrate how to write data to a table, you must have the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks file -on your computer. Then you can write an application that reads a subset of the file, assigns a -column value as the PartitionKey, assigns an index as the RowKey, and assigns the other -columns in the file as entities in the table. These steps are performed in the sample code below -by using the TableService and Entity objects and the create_table and insert_entity methods. -For other code samples demonstrating how to download (get_blob) and perform other -operations, see How to Use the Table Storage Service from Python. - -Click the New Notebook button in the top right corner of the notebook window, and then copy -the following code sample and paste it into the gray box in the browser. -Note: Be sure to replace the account and key with values specific to your storage account. - -#Next we will demonstrate the table storage management in Microsoft Azure -#we can add top 100 rows of the mako_real_actual_sharks csv to a table storage -#get a handle to your account -table_service = TableService(account_name=account, account_key=key) -table_name = 'makotable'; - -14 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -csv_file = 'Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks.csv' - -#delete the table for temporary data -result = table_service.delete_table(table_name) - -# create a new table to save all entities. -result = table_service.create_table(table_name) - -#attention: more code need to write if you want to execute all the time at the -same time -#when you call delete_table or create_table, it takes some time for Microsoft -Azure to finish the operation -#you must check the operation status before you can execute the following code! -#then we insert the top 1000 rows into the table, we set PartitionKey to be -each color and RowKey to be the index -index = 0 -with open(csv_file) as f: - reader = csv.DictReader(f) #create a reader which represents rows in a -dictionary form - for row in reader: #this will read a row as {column1: value1, column2: -value2,...} - entity = Entity() - entity.PartitionKey = row['color'] - entity.RowKey= str(index) - entity.ToppID = row['toppID'] - entity.Time = row['time'] - entity.Longitude = row['Longitude'] - entity.Latitude = row['Latitude'] - table_service.insert_entity(table_name, entity) - print row - index=index+1 - if index >= 1000: - break - -Reading data from a table -One of the advantages of using table storage is the ability to query data quickly, even though it -is not stored in relational tables. By using the query_entities method, you can filter your query -to retrieve data from your table that match certain criteria: - -#we can check the azure storage explore to query all inserted entities -#we can also query all table entities with diamonds' color = 'yellow' -makos = table_service.query_entities(table_name, "PartitionKey eq 'yellow'") -for m in makos: - print(str(m.ToppID),str(m.PartitionKey),str(m.Time),str(m.Longitude), -str(m.Latitude)) - -Other programmatic options for managing storage -You have additional options for developing applications that manage your storage accounts: - - Microsoft Azure Storage Client Library - Storage Services REST APIs - - -LINQ for Microsoft Azure Table service - -If you perform a task once or infrequently, you can use the Management Portal or execute a -PowerShell or CLI script. For automating frequent or complex tasks, you might prefer to use an - -15 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -SDK. For example, if you already have experience with Python or Node, you can develop code in -that language and bypass the need to learn PowerShell. - -Security and Microsoft Azure Storage -Your storage account is secure by default. As the owner of the storage account, only you have -access until you grant others permissions to your resources. You have the following options for -managing security: - - Grant permissions at container and blob level to allow anonymous access. - Allow access to a container, blob, table, or queue by using a shared access signature for - -a limited time - - Shared access signatures can optionally include a stored access policy for even more - -flexible management - -Container and blob permissions -In the Microsoft Azure Management Portal, you specify the access permissions when you create -a new container. To do this: - -1. Click the storage account on the Storage page of the Management Portal. -2. Click the Containers link at the top of the page, and then click Create a Container, if no - -containers exist, or click the Add button at the bottom of the page. - -3. Type a container name in the NAME field, and the select one of the following ACCESS - -options, as shown in Figure 8: - Private: The owner of the storage account is the only user with access to the - -container. - - Public Container: The storage service responds to anonymous requests to access - -metadata for the current container and the blobs it contains. - Public Blob: Anonymous requests can access only the blob data. - -Figure 12: Access permissions selection at container level - -For a full list of REST operations and .NET methods and the effect of access setting, see Restrict -Access to Containers and Blobs. - -Shared access signature -To grant permissions on an ad hoc basis for a limited time, you can issue a shared access -signature to a user or a client application. You can specify a shared access signature for a blob or -a container. Either way, in addition to the level of permissions, you can specify the start and end - -16 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -time during which access is granted. Access can include browsing the contents of a container or -reading and writing to blob data, table entities, or queue messages. You can see code examples -at Create and Use a Shared Access Signature. - -Stored access policy -To implement security that is more flexible, create a stored access policy to define permissions -and the time range during which access to storage is granted, and reference the policy from a -group of shared access signatures. However, you are not obligated to define the stored access -policy parameters when you set it up. You can use any combination of parameters when -configuring the stored access policy, and then include any remaining parameters directly in the -shared access signatures. When you use this approach, you can update the policy when you -need to shorten or extend the lifetime of a shared access signature, rather than revoke the -signature and issue a new one. You can establish up to five stored access policies per container, -table, or queue and use each policy with an unlimited number of shared access signatures. For -more information, see Use a Stored Access Policy. - -For a closer look at security concerns related to identity and access in the cloud and -considerations for building security into your cloud applications, see Microsoft Azure Security -Guidance. - -Learn more - - Understanding Block Blobs and Page Blobs (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en- - -us/library/ee691964.aspx) - - Blob Service Concepts (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd179376.aspx) - Delivering High-Bandwidth Content with the Microsoft Azure - -CDN (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee795176.aspx) - - Understanding the Table Storage Data Model (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en- - -us/library/dd179338.aspx) - - Table Service Concepts (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd179463.aspx) - Querying Tables and Entities (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd894031.aspx) - Microsoft Azure Storage: A Highly Available Cloud Storage Service with Strong - -Consistency (http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp11/current/2011-Cascais/printable/11- -calder.pdf) - -© 2014 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is -licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 License. - -17 +Download our Catalog diff --git a/q58/random_k2/question.json b/q58/random_k2/question.json index aa15e2fb5c26cbe11937a7f2f984398bdcb2633e..b4f7112ee22bd08a7375d6610c70155c8906664f 100644 --- a/q58/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q58/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "indonesiamobilemarketresearch-ag-150106055934-conversion-gate02_95.pdf", - "web_d3545b20cb487e4b.pdf", - "web_8198931726741d61.pdf" + "web_82328a4273fef79b.pdf", + "resize_r2_2.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q58/random_k2/random_1.md b/q58/random_k2/random_1.md index 3b59653be960a7700f9cff39752b4e24bce89425..6474018d749f25127eab2ee8e778279d7aa478d0 100644 --- a/q58/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q58/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,3031 +1,908 @@ -FOR RELEASE JULY 26, 2018 +Investor Presentation +Q1 FY23 -BY Cary Funk and Meg Hefferon + Safe Harbor Statement -FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: +This presentation may contain forward-looking statements for which there are risks, uncertainties, and assumptions. +Forward-looking statements may include any statements regarding strategies or plans for future operations; any statements +concerning new features, enhancements or upgrades to our existing applications or plans for future applications; any projections +of revenues, gross margins, earnings, or other financial items; and any statements of expectation or belief. Forward-looking +statements are based only on currently available information and our current beliefs, expectations, and assumptions regarding the +future of our business, future plans and strategies, projections, anticipated events and trends, the economy, and other future +conditions. Because forward-looking statements relate to the future, they are subject to inherent uncertainties, risks, and changes +in circumstances that are difficult to predict and many of which are outside of our control. Our actual results and financial condition +may differ materially from those indicated in the forward-looking statements, and therefore you should not rely on any +forward-looking statements that we may make. Further information on risks that could affect Workday’s results is included in our +filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission which are available on the Workday investor relations webpage: +www.workday.com/company/investor_relations.php -Cary Funk, Director, Science and Society Research -Haley Nolan, Communications Assistant +Workday assumes no obligation for, and does not intend to update, any forward-looking statements. Any unreleased services, +features, functionality or enhancements referenced in any Workday document, roadmap, blog, our website, press release or +public statement that are not currently available are subject to change at Workday’s discretion and may not be delivered as +planned or at all. -202.419.4372 +Customers who purchase Workday services should make their purchase decisions based upon services, features, and functions +that are currently available. -www.pewresearch.org + Use of Non-GAAP Measures -RECOMMENDED CITATION +In addition to financial results presented in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), this presentation includes certain +non-GAAP financial measures of financial performance. These non-GAAP financial measures are in addition to, and not a substitute for or +superior to, measures of financial performance prepared in accordance with GAAP, and may be different from non-GAAP financial measures +used by other companies. In addition, these non-GAAP measures have limitations in that they do not reflect all of the amounts associated with +Workday’s results of operations as determined in accordance with GAAP. Reconciliations of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most +directly comparable financial measures are contained in the Appendix to this presentation. A reconciliation of our forward outlook for non-GAAP +operating margin with our forward-looking GAAP operating margin is not available without unreasonable efforts as the quantification of share- +based compensation expense, which is excluded from our non-GAAP operating margin, requires additional inputs such as the number of shares +granted and market prices that are not ascertainable. -Pew Research Center, July 2018, “Public Views of Gene -Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” + Workday at a Glance - 2 + Workday +by the Numbers -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$105B+ -About Pew Research Center +Market Opportunity -Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes -and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center conducts -public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social -science research. It studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and -technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social -and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew -Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. +Enterprise Management Cloud +For Finance, HR, Planning, Spend Management and +Analytics -© Pew Research Center 2018 +9,500+ Global Customers +Operating across 175+ Countries -www.pewresearch.org +$4.79B 22% YoY Growth - 3 +Trailing Twelve Month Subscription Revenue1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Serving 50%+ of the Fortune 500 +Including 70%+ of the top 50 Fortune 500 companies -Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It -Would Be Used +$7.97B 21% YoY Growth -Americans’ views on the -appropriateness of changing -a baby’s genetic -characteristics depend in -large part on the intended -purpose and on whether or -not human embryos would be -used in testing these -techniques. A majority of -Americans support the idea -of using gene editing with the -goal of delivering direct -health benefits for babies, but -at the same time, a majority -considers the use of such -techniques to boost a baby’s -intelligence something that -takes technology “too far.” +24-Month Subscription Revenue Backlog2 -A majority of U.S. adults say changing a baby’s genes -to treat a serious congenital disease is appropriate +60M+ Global Users +97% Customer Satisfaction3 -% of U.S. adults who say changing a baby’s genetic characteristics for each of -the following reasons is … +$1.64B 30% Margin -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Trailing Twelve Month Operating Cash Flow1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +1 For the trailing twelve months ended 4.30.22 +2 For the period ended 4.30.22 +3 Based on a survey conducted by Workday of Named Support Contacts in April 2021 -About seven-in-ten Americans (72%) say that changing an unborn baby’s genetic characteristics to -treat a serious disease or condition that the baby would have at birth is an appropriate use of -medical technology, while 27% say this would be taking technology too far. A somewhat smaller -share of Americans say gene editing to reduce a baby’s risk of developing a serious disease or -condition over their lifetime is appropriate (60% say this, while 38% say it would be taking -medical technology too far). But just 19% of Americans say it would be appropriate to use gene -editing to make a baby more intelligent; eight-in-ten (80%) say this would be taking medical -technology too far. +15,900+ Employees Worldwide +Offices in 30+ Countries -These are some of the findings from a new Pew Research Center survey conducted April 23-May 6, -2018, among 2,537 U.S. adults. + Workday Enterprise Management Cloud -www.pewresearch.org +A unique approach to enterprise software - 4 +Best-in-Class +Applications -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Elevate Your +Enterprise -While public discussions about potentially altering a baby’s genetic makeup have been ongoing for -decades, the development of a new gene-splicing technology – known as CRISPR – has accelerated -the debate and brought new urgency to better understanding public opinion about gene editing as -well as the broader social, ethical and policy implications ahead.1 +Enterprise +Management Cloud +Platform +The Power to Adapt -Previous Pew Research Center surveys have tracked public opinion about gene editing using -different question wording and, in some cases, different polling methodologies. As such, those -findings are not directly comparable to this new survey. However, the broad pattern – that public -support for gene editing varies with its intended purpose – is consistent with a 2016 study that -explored public views about the possibility of using gene editing to “enhance” a baby’s health over -the course of their lifetime and a 2014 survey.2 +The Workday +Experience -Regardless of the intended purpose of gene -editing, experts acknowledge that further -development of these techniques will likely -involve testing in human embryos. In August -2017, research scientists in the United States -reported the first successful use of gene editing -in human embryos to eliminate an inherited -condition. When asked to consider the -possibility that the development of gene -editing would involve testing on human -embryos, one third of Americans (33%) say -this would be appropriate while about two- -thirds (65%) say this would be taking medical -technology too far. +A Partner Like +No Other -65% of Americans say if gene editing -relies on embryonic testing, it would -take technology too far +Recognized as a +Cloud ERP Market Leader +FIN, Planning and HCM -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … +Over 9,500 customers +globally supporting more than +55 million workers -Taking medical -technology too far +97% Customer +Satisfaction -Appropriate use of -medical technology + Serving +Organizations +of all Sizes +and Across +Industries -65 + Addressing a Large and Expanding TAM -33 +New Markets Have +Expanded TAM -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” +HCM +Opportunity -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$38B -The 2016 Pew Research Center survey using -different question wording found that most adults said testing on human embryos to develop gene -editing would make gene editing less acceptable for them. +Core HCM • Payroll and +Workforce Management • Talent +Management • Employee +Experience -1 The National Academies of Sciences and the National Academy of Medicine launched a consensus study and at least two international -summits to consider these issues. -2 Other research on public views of gene editing has also shown that the public distinguishes its intended purpose. Scheufele et al. (2017) -found that Americans were more supportive of gene editing applications that treat medical conditions than those aimed at enhancing health. -Similarly, Whitman (2018) also found stronger public support for gene editing to cure disease than gene editing to make people stronger or -more intelligent. +FINS+ +Opportunity -www.pewresearch.org +$67B - 5 +Financial Management • Spend +Management • FIN-Planning • +Industry Solutions • Platform • +Accounting Center • Analytics +and Reporting -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$39B -Several patterns emerge in -public opinion about gene -editing in these varying -contexts. There are large -differences in acceptance of -gene editing between the -highly religious and less -religious. In addition, there is -a gender gap in views about -gene editing, with women -less accepting of it than men. -People with higher levels of -science knowledge and -greater familiarity with gene -editing also tend to be more -accepting of it. +Total Addressable Market +In 2012 at IPO 1 -Religious Americans are -more likely to view gene -editing negatively +IDC and Workday Estimates +1 TAM as of 8.30.2012 +2 TAM as of 9.21.2021 -Highly religious Americans are more likely to see gene -editing for babies as taking medical technology too far +$105B+ -% of U.S. adults in each religious commitment group who say changing a -baby’s genetic characteristics for each of the following reasons is … +Total Addressable Market +Current -Taking medical technology too far - -Appropriate use of medical technology - -Treat a serious disease or condition the baby would have at birth -Among those ___ on the religious commitment index - -High - -Medium - -Low - -40 - -57 - -27 - -18 - -72 - -82 - -Reduce risk of a serious disease or condition that could occur over their -lifetime - -High - -53 - -Medium - -Low - -41 - -27 - -Make the baby more intelligent - -46 - -58 - -73 - -6 - -High - -93 - -82 - -72 - -18 - -Low - -Medium - -Americans who are high in -religious commitment – that -is, those who attend religious -services at least weekly, pray -at least daily and say that -religion is very important in -their lives – are less inclined -than those with either -medium or low levels of -religious commitment to say -that gene editing is an appropriate use of medical technology.3 For example, those high in religious -commitment are closely divided over whether it is appropriate to use gene editing to reduce a - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. See Methodology for details -on index of religious commitment. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -28 - -3 A person is considered to have a high level of religious commitment if they attend religious services at least weekly, pray at least daily and -say religion is very important in their life. People are classified as having low commitment if they say religion is not too or not at all important -in their lives and that they seldom or never attend religious services or pray. All others are classified as having medium commitment. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 6 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -baby’s risk of disease later in life; 46% say this is appropriate, while 53% consider it taking -technology too far. In contrast, roughly three-quarters of those low in religious commitment (73%) -say gene editing to reduce a baby’s risk of developing a serious disease or condition is an -appropriate use of medical technology. And, while a 57% majority of those high in religious -commitment say gene editing to treat a congenital disorder in a baby is an appropriate use of -medical technology, a much larger share of those with low religious commitment (82%) say this is -appropriate. - -Those with high levels of religiosity also stand -out when considering the possibility that -development of gene editing would entail -testing on human embryos. An overwhelming -majority of those high in religious -commitment (87%) say this would be taking -medical technology too far; just 11% of this -group says this would be appropriate. In -contrast, 55% of those low in religious -commitment say that development of gene -editing techniques that require testing on -human embryos would be an appropriate use -of medical technology. - -The differences by religiosity in views on the -appropriateness of gene editing tend to persist -even when statistically controlling for other -factors such as gender, race and ethnicity, age, -and education that are related to religious -beliefs and practices. See Appendix for details. - -Most highly religious Americans -consider testing gene editing on human -embryos to be taking technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … - -Taking medical technology too far -Appropriate use of medical technology - -U.S. adults - -65 - -33 - -Among those ___ on the religious commitment index - -High - -87 - -Medium - -69 - -11 - -29 - -Low - -44 - -55 - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. See -Methodology for details on index of religious commitment. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 7 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -There are also differences in views about gene -editing by religious affiliation, particularly if -such techniques would involve embryonic -testing. Just 11% of white evangelical -Protestants say that if development of gene -editing techniques required testing on human -embryos, it would be an appropriate use of -medical technology. - -By contrast, about half of the religiously -unaffiliated (52%), including 79% of atheists -and 57% of agnostics, say that embryonic -testing to develop gene editing techniques -would be an appropriate use of medical -technology. - -See the Appendix for other views about gene -editing by religious affiliation. - -White evangelicals especially likely to -say gene editing involving embryonic -testing takes technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … - -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate use -of medical -technology -33% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -65% - -21 -11 -31 -25 -30 -29 -27 -52 -79 -57 -42 - -34 -29 -28 - -78 -88 -67 -72 -69 -70 -73 -47 -21 -42 -57 - -64 -68 -71 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 8 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Men are more accepting than women of using gene editing to change a baby’s genetic -makeup - -Men are more inclined than -women to view gene editing as -an appropriate use of medical -technology, regardless of its -intent. About two-thirds of -men (65%) believe that gene -editing to reduce a baby’s risk -of developing a serious -disease later in life is an -appropriate use of medical -technology, compared with -54% of women. And men -(76%) are more supportive -than women (68%) of using -gene editing to treat a -congenital disorder. - -Similarly, more men (43%) -than women (24%) are -accepting of gene editing -technology if it required -embryonic testing to develop. - -Men are more likely than women to view gene editing -for babies as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say changing a baby’s genetic characteristics for each -of the following reasons is an appropriate use of medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic characteristics ... - -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Women - -Men - -68 - -76 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -54 - -65 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -13 - -24 - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -If it required testing on human embryos -to develop these techniques - -24 - -43 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Women tend to have higher -levels of religious commitment, on average, but differences by gender tend to hold even when -controlling for religiosity and other factors in statistical models. See the Appendix for details. - -Previous Pew Research Center surveys in 2016 and 2014, while not directly comparable due to -different polling methods and question wording, have also found that women tend to be less -accepting than men when it comes to gene editing for babies. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 9 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Americans with high levels of science knowledge are more likely to view gene editing in a -positive light - -People high in science -knowledge – based on a nine- -item index – tend to be more -accepting of using gene -editing for babies.4 Some -86% of those with high -science knowledge believe it -is appropriate to use gene -editing to treat a congenital -disorder, compared with 58% -of those with low science -knowledge. And, 71% of those -with high science knowledge -say it is appropriate to use -gene editing to reduce a -baby’s risk of disease that -would occur later in life, -compared with 49% of those -with low science knowledge.5 - -However, few Americans say -it is appropriate to use gene -editing to make a baby more -intelligent, regardless of their -level of science knowledge. - -Those with high science knowledge are more inclined -to see gene editing techniques as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following is an appropriate use of -medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic -characteristics ... -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Among those with ___ science -knowledge -Medium - -Low - -High - -58 - -86 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -49 - -71 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -21 - -24 - -If it required testing on human -embryos to develop these techniques - -26 - -50 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -See Methodology for details on index of science knowledge. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Judgments on the appropriateness of gene editing also follow a similar pattern by education level, -which is closely linked with science knowledge. Those with a postgraduate degree are more - -4 See the Methodology for details on the science knowledge index. -5 These findings are in keeping with a 2017 study by Scheufele et al., which found Americans’ attitudes about gene editing varied depending -on their knowledge level about genetics and gene editing, as well as their religiosity. A 2013 study by Allum et al. in the United Kingdom found -the effect of science knowledge on support for using genetic testing to screen for serious diseases in an unborn baby was conditional on -religious service attendance. In this survey, there is a tendency for the effects of science knowledge to be conditional with levels of religiosity -in views about the use of gene editing to reduce the risk of disease and if it would require testing on human embryos. For example, among -people with high religious commitment, science knowledge is not related to views on the appropriateness of gene editing for babies to reduce -the risk of disease that could occur over their lifetime. This interaction between religious commitment and science knowledge holds even after -controlling for other factors in statistical models but does not occur for other views about gene editing. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 10 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -accepting of gene editing for treating or reducing the risk of a disease than those with a high school -degree or less. - -Americans who report familiarity with gene editing are more inclined to see it as -appropriate - -People who say they have -heard at least a little about -gene editing that can be used -to change a baby’s genetic -characteristics are more -likely than those who have -heard nothing at all to say -gene editing would be -appropriate in each of the -circumstances considered in -this survey. - -A Pew Research Center -survey in 2016 found a -similar tendency for those -who report familiarity with -gene editing to express more -interest in and acceptance of -using these technologies to -enhance a baby’s health over -the course of their lifetime. - -Those familiar with gene editing are more inclined to -see different uses as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following is an appropriate use of -medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic -characteristics ... - -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Among those who have heard ___ -about gene editing -A little -71 - -Nothing at all - -A lot - -64 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -52 - -65 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -13 - -31 - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -If it required testing on human embryos -to develop these techniques - -24 - -49 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 11 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Although gene editing for babies is still in development, a separate April 2018 survey found that -about half of Americans (52%) believe it is likely that within the next 50 years, we will be able to -eliminate almost all birth defects by manipulating the genes of an embryo before a baby is born. In -the current survey, as people think about a future with possible widespread use of gene editing to -change a baby’s genetic makeup, more anticipate negative than positive effects on society. - -Specifically, a majority of -Americans (58%) believe -gene editing will very likely -lead to increased inequality -because it will only be -available to the wealthy. -Some 54% of Americans -anticipate a slippery slope, -saying it’s very likely that -“even if gene editing is used -appropriately in some cases, -others will use these -techniques in ways that are -morally unacceptable.” And, -46% expect it is very likely -that gene editing techniques -will be used before we fully -understand how they affect -people’s health. - -Larger shares of Americans believe negative effects of -widespread use of gene editing are very likely - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following would be ____ to occur if gene -editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available - -Very likely - -Fairly likely - -Not too likely - -Not at all likely - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy - -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways - -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -58 - -29 - -9 - -4 - -54 - -32 - -9 - -3 - -46 - -38 - -12 - -3 - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -18 - -42 - -30 - -8 - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -16 - -48 - -27 +2 8 -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Far smaller shares see -positive outcomes as very -likely if gene editing for -babies were to become widely available. Roughly two-in-ten Americans (18%) say it is very likely -that development of these techniques will pave the way for new medical advances that benefit -society as a whole. Another 42% say this is fairly likely to occur, while 38% consider this not too or -not at all likely. Just 16% see the widespread use of gene editing as very likely to help people live -longer and better quality lives. About half (48%) say this is fairly likely, while 34% say this -outcome is not too or not at all likely. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 12 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Women are more inclined -than men to expect negative -effects if gene editing -becomes widely available, in -keeping with gender -differences over acceptance -of gene editing. For example, -larger shares of women than -men say this technology will -lead to an increase in -inequality as it will only be -available for the wealthy -(63% say this is very likely vs. -52% of men) or say it will be -used in morally unacceptable -ways (57% vs. 51%). And -although only minorities of -men and women see positive -effects as very likely, men are -somewhat more inclined to -anticipate positive outcomes. - -More women than men anticipate negative effects of -gene editing - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following would be very likely to occur if -gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely -available - -POSITIVE OUTCOMES - -Women - -Men - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -14 - -23 - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -13 - -19 - -NEGATIVE OUTCOMES - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy - -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways - -52 - -63 - -51 - -57 - -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -42 - -49 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Expectations also vary by -self-reported familiarity with -gene editing. Those who have -heard a lot about gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics are more inclined to -anticipate positive outcomes from its widespread use. Some 36% of this group thinks it is very -likely that the widespread availability of gene editing would pave the way for new medical -advances that are beneficial to society, compared with about half as many of those who have heard -a little or nothing about gene editing (16%). - -However, those most familiar with gene editing are more likely than those with no familiarity to -also anticipate downsides. About two-thirds of those who have heard a lot about gene editing -(64%) say it is very likely that widespread availability of gene editing will increase inequality -because the technology will primarily be available only for the wealthy, compared with 53% of -those who have heard nothing about using gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics. -And, 65% of those who have heard a lot about gene editing think it’s very likely that others will use - -www.pewresearch.org - - 13 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -these techniques in morally unacceptable ways, while 54% of those who have heard a little and -52% of those who have heard nothing about gene editing say this. - -Americans who are more familiar with gene editing are more inclined to anticipate -positive as well as negative effects from widespread use of gene editing - -% of U.S. adults in each group who say each of the following would be very likely to occur if gene editing to change a -baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available - -POSITIVE OUTCOMES - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -NEGATIVE OUTCOMES - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -Heard a lot about -gene editing - -Heard a little about -gene editing - -Heard nothing at all -about gene editing - -36 - -34 - -16 - -13 - -16 - -14 - -64 - -65 - -59 - -54 - -53 - -52 - -54 - -46 - -43 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -A similar pattern occurs with levels of science knowledge. A larger share of people with high -science knowledge anticipate positive outcomes from the widespread availability of gene editing -than those with low science knowledge. At the same time, those with high science knowledge are at -least equally likely as those with low science knowledge to think negative effects from the -widespread availability of gene editing are very likely. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 14 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -The American public also -tends to be skeptical about -whether medical experts fully -comprehend the health -consequences of gene editing. -A 36% minority of Americans -believe that medical -researchers understand the -health effects of gene editing -for babies either very (7%) or -fairly well (29%), while 62% -say medical researchers do -not understand the health -effects at all or not too well. - -36% of Americans say medical researchers understand -the health effects of gene editing at least fairly well - -% of U.S. adults who say medical researchers understand the health risks and -benefits of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics … - -Very well - -Fairly well - -Not too well - -Not at all well - -7 - -29 - -45 - -17 - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Familiarity with gene editing is linked with beliefs about medical researchers’ understanding of it. -About half of those who have heard a lot about gene editing for babies (51%) say that medical -researchers understand the health effects of gene editing for babies at least fairly well, compared -with three-in-ten of those who have heard nothing at all (30%). However, level of science -knowledge based on a nine-item index is not related to views on this issue; 36% of those with high -science knowledge and 40% of those with low science knowledge believe that medical researchers -understand the health effects of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics at least fairly well. - -There are no or only modest differences on this question by gender or religious commitment. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 15 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER + With a Leading Position in HCM -Acknowledgments +~$38B -This report is made possible by The Pew Charitable Trusts. This report is a collaborative effort -based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. Find related reports online at: -pewresearch.org/science. +HCM Market Opportunity -Primary research team +HCM Provides Significant Runway -Cary Funk, Director, Science and Society Research -Brian Kennedy, Research Associate -Meg Hefferon, Research Assistant -Mark Strauss, Writer/Editor -Isadora Milanez, Intern +International -Editorial and graphic design +Expanding Share of Wallet -Mark Strauss, Writer/Editor -Shannon Greenwood, Copy Editor -Margaret Porteus, Information Graphics Designer +Medium Enterprise -Communications and web publishing +U.S. Federal -Haley Nolan, Communications Assistant -Sara Atske, Assistant Digital Producer +Future Innovation -www.pewresearch.org +M&A - 16 +IDC and Workday estimates. Includes core HCM, Payroll, Recruiting, Benefits, Workforce Analytics, Compensation, Employee Engagement Surveys, Help, Journeys, Learning, Performance, Scheduling, Time Tracking, and Workforce Planning -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Methodology - -Margins of error - -This report is drawn from a survey conducted as -part of the American Trends Panel (ATP), a -nationally representative panel of randomly -selected U.S. adults living in households -recruited from landline and cellphone random- -digit-dial (RDD) surveys. Panelists participate -via monthly self-administered web surveys. -Panelists who do not have internet access are -provided a tablet and wireless internet -connection. The panel, which was created by -Pew Research Center, is being managed by GfK. - -Data in this report are drawn from the panel -wave conducted April 23-May 6, 2018, among -2,537 respondents. The margin of sampling error -for the full sample of 2,537 respondents is plus -or minus 2.8 percentage points. - -Members of the ATP were recruited from several -large, national landline and cellphone RDD -surveys conducted in English and Spanish. At -the end of each survey, respondents were invited -to join the panel. The first group of panelists was -recruited from the 2014 Political Polarization -and Typology Survey, conducted Jan. 23-March -16, 2014. Of the 10,013 adults interviewed, 9,809 -were invited to take part in the panel and a total -of 5,338 agreed to participate.6 - -Sample size -2,537 - -Margin of error -in percentage -points -+/- 2.8 - -U.S. adults - -Men -Women - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Religious commitment index -High -Medium -Low - -Religious affiliation -NET Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -NET Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -NET Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -1,272 -1,265 - -1,519 -412 -421 - -440 -1,291 -566 - -1,086 -349 -282 -283 -459 -254 -168 -703 -146 -158 -399 - -+/- 4.0 -+/- 3.8 - -+/- 3.3 -+/- 7.8 -+/-7.6 - -+/- 6.7 -+/- 3.8 -+/- 5.7 - -+/- 4.2 -+/- 7.1 -+/- 7.7 -+/- 9.6 -+/- 6.5 -+/- 8.0 -+/-11.8 -+/-5.1 -+/- 11.2 -+/- 10.2 -+/- 6.8 - -Note: The margins of error are reported at the 95% level of -confidence and are calculated by taking into account the average -design effect for each subgroup. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -6 When data collection for the 2014 Political Polarization and Typology Survey began, non-internet users were subsampled at a rate of 25%, -but a decision was made shortly thereafter to invite all non-internet users to join. In total, 83% of non-internet users were invited to join the -panel. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 17 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -The second group of panelists was recruited -from the 2015 Pew Research Center Survey on -Government conducted Aug. 27-Oct. 4, 2015. Of -the 6,004 adults interviewed, all were invited to -join the panel, and 2,976 agreed to participate.7 -The third group of panelists was recruited from a -survey conducted April 25-June 4, 2017. Of the -5,012 adults interviewed in the survey or pretest, -3,905 were invited to take part in the panel and a -total of 1,628 agreed to participate.8 - -The overall target population for Wave 34 was -non-institutionalized persons ages 18 and older, -living in the United States, including Alaska and -Hawaii. The sample for Wave 34 consisted of -3,099 ATP members that were invited to Wave -33 and were still active. This subsample was -selected using the following approach: - -Margins of error continued - -Sample size - -Margin of error -in percentage -points - -Science knowledge index -High -Medium -Low - -Heard about gene editing -A lot -A little -Nothing at all - -679 -1,274 -584 - -326 -1,449 -753 - -+/-5.2 -+/- 3.9 -+/- 5.7 - -+/- 7.9 -+/-3.6 -+/-5.1 - -Note: The margins of error are reported at the 95% level of -confidence and are calculated by taking into account the average -design effect for each subgroup. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +9 -1. Panelists were grouped into three strata based on how underrepresented they are + And a Broadening Footprint in FINS+ -demographically. Then we analyzed response rates to the last five panel survey waves -(W28-32) to project the number of panelists in each stratum who would respond to the -W33 survey. - -2. We then determined how many panelists we wanted to sample from each stratum in W33 -in order to finish with around 2,500 completed interviews and have a responding sample -that is as representative as possible. - -▪ Stratum A consists of panelists who are non-internet users, are black non-Hispanic, -are Hispanic, or have high school or less education. There were 1,819 total panelists -in this stratum and they are sampled at a rate of 100% for W33. 1,806 were active -panelists. - -7 Respondents to the 2014 Political Polarization and Typology Survey who indicated that they are internet users but refused to provide an -email address were initially permitted to participate in the American Trends Panel by mail but were no longer permitted to join the panel after -Feb. 6, 2014. Internet users from the 2015 Pew Research Center Survey on Government who refused to provide an email address were not -permitted to join the panel. -8 White, non-Hispanic college graduates were subsampled at a rate of 50%. +~$67B -www.pewresearch.org +FINS+ Market Opportunity - 18 +FINS+ Unlocks a Massive Opportunity -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +New Landing Points -▪ Stratum B consists of panelists who are ages 18 to 34 or are non-volunteers. The +Expanding into Our HCM Base -1,684 total panelists in this stratum are subsampled at a rate of 63%, yielding 1,061 -sampled for W33 (1,057 were active). +Medium Enterprise -▪ Stratum C consists of the remaining 2,009 panelists not in stratum A or B. This +Deepening Our Industry +Presence -group is subsampled at a rate of 12%, yielding 241 panelists sampled for W33 (239 -were active). +Future Innovation -The ATP data were weighted in a multistep process that begins with a base weight incorporating -the respondents’ original survey selection probability and the fact that in 2014 some panelists were -subsampled for invitation to the panel. Next, an adjustment was made for the fact that the -propensity to join the panel and remain an active panelist varied across different groups in the -sample. The final step in the weighting uses an iterative technique that aligns the sample to -population benchmarks on a number of dimensions. Gender, age, education, race, Hispanic origin -and region parameters come from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2016 American Community Survey. -The county-level population density parameter (deciles) comes from the 2010 U.S. decennial -census. The telephone service benchmark comes from the July-December 2016 National Health -Interview Survey and is projected to 2017. The volunteerism benchmark comes from the 2015 -Current Population Survey Volunteer Supplement. The party affiliation benchmark is the average -of the three most recent Pew Research Center general public telephone surveys. The internet -access benchmark comes from the 2017 ATP Panel Refresh Survey. Respondents who did not -previously have internet access are treated as not having internet access for weighting purposes. -Sampling errors and statistical tests of significance take into account the effect of weighting. -Interviews are conducted in both English and Spanish, but the Hispanic sample in the ATP is -predominantly U.S. born and English speaking. +M&A -Margins of error tables shown here provide the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable -to sampling that would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the -survey taking into account the average design effect for each subgroup. Sample sizes and sampling -errors for other subgroups are available upon request. - -In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical -difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls. - -The April 2018 wave had a response rate of 82% (2,537 responses among 3,099 individuals in the -panel). Taking account of the combined, weighted response rate for the recruitment surveys - -www.pewresearch.org - - 19 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -(10.1%) and attrition from panel members who were removed at their request or for inactivity, the -cumulative response rate for the wave is 2.3%.9 - -Religious commitment index - -Survey respondents were classified into high, medium and low levels of religious commitment -based on three indicators: frequency of religious service attendance, self-reported importance of -religion in their lives and frequency of prayer. Those who attend worship services at least weekly, -pray at least once a day and say religion is very important in their lives are classified as high in -religious commitment. Those low in commitment say religion is not too or not at all important in -their lives, that they seldom or never attend worship services, and seldom or never pray. All others -are classified as exhibiting a medium level of religious commitment. +IDC and Workday estimates. Includes Financial Management, Accounting Center, Analytics, Financial Planning, Spend Management, Expenses, Integration/Platform, Projects, and Industry Solutions -9 Approximately once per year, panelists who have not participated in multiple consecutive waves are removed from the panel. These cases -are counted in the denominator of cumulative response rates. Note that for the March 2018 survey, we calculated the response rates by -computing the mean rates for the subsampled respondents (based on the rates from the recruitment survey they joined the panel on). +10 -www.pewresearch.org + Driving Profitable Growth at Scale - 20 +21% +CAGR -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$4.5B +FY22 -Science knowledge index +95%+ -Scale reliability and factor analysis +Gross Revenue +Retention3 -The Pew Research Center survey included a set of nine questions to tap public knowledge of -science across a range of principles and topics. Most respondents (n=1,901) completed these -questions as part of a previous -wave of the American Trends -Panel, conducted May 10-June -6, 2016. Respondents who did -not participate in the previous -wave answered these questions -in this survey (n=636). The -following shows the -measurement properties of the -index for the combined set of -2,537 respondents.10 +$3.1B +FY20 -Alpha for scale -0.75 -Alpha if item is -dropped +900 +bps -Knowledge index 9-items +22.4% +FY22 -Item-rest -correlation +Annual +Subscription +Revenue1 -0.47 +Non-GAAP +Operating +Margin2 -0.39 +1 CAGR calculations are based on FY20-FY22 results +2 Reconciliations of GAAP to Non-GAAP financial data included in the Appendix +3 Measures the annual recurring revenue of our customers as of 4.30.21 that we have maintained as of 4.30.22, without giving credit for additional upsells or price and/or seats related changes. The metric captures only customer and product churn -0.74 +13.4% +FY20 -0.73 + While Growing Responsibly and Inclusively -Common -variance -explained by -first factor -76% -Factor -loadings +ESG and Our Employees -0.46 +ESG and Our Customers -0.55 +ESG and the World Around Us -KNOSCT22. Use of a control group -to determine whether a new drug is -effective -KNOSCT23. Carbon dioxide is made -as a consequence of burning fossil -fuels -KNOSCT27. The probability of an -old-bridge collapsing after a period -of time -KNOSCT28. Only bacterial -infections can be treated effectively -by antibiotic medications -KNOSCT29. The use of a control -“sugar pill” in a new drug trial is to -rule out a possible placebo effect -KNOSCT31. The health benefits -occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine is called -herd immunity -KNOSCT32. An apple, salmon, corn -and a mosquito can all be -genetically modified. -KNOSCT33. Humans and mice -share 50% or more of the same -genetic makeup -KNOSCT34. Nitrogen makes up -most of the Earth’s atmosphere. +VIBE +Our commitment to value inclusion, +belonging, and equity for all -0.50 +Opportunity Onramps +Provide candidates from diverse, +nontraditional backgrounds with training +and job opportunities -0.72 +®️ -0.59 +Building Inclusive Solutions +Investing to help organizations gain +valuable insights about equity within their +workforce -0.31 +Building Sustainable Solutions +Helping customers improve sustainability +and resilience of their supply chains -0.75 +Investing in Training +To help ensure we attract, recruit, hire, +and advance employees of all +backgrounds -0.35 +Empowering our Ecosystem +Workday’s adaptable platform enables +customers and partners to manage their +emissions reduction strategy -0.43 +Net-Zero Carbon Footprint +Achieved net-zero emissions in 2020 and +lifetime net-zero carbon footprint in 2021 -0.73 +Commitment to 1.5ºC +Science-based targets across our entire +value chain -0.50 +Driving Policy Change +Working to advance polices that support +a skills-based approach to talent, and aid +in the transition to a low-carbon economy -0.45 +For More Information: +Visit our ESG Resource Page: Sustainability and Reporting with Workday +Read our Blog: Our Commitments to ESG at Workday +Download our 2021 Global Impact Report -0.73 + Q1 FY23 Highlights and Guidance -0.52 + Q1 FY23 Financial Highlights -0.47 +Q1 FY23 Results -0.73 +Increase (Decrease) YoY -0.55 +Total Revenue -An exploratory factor analysis -finds one common factor -explaining 76% of the common -variance in the items. The -factor loadings show that each -of the nine questions is -moderately correlated with the -common factor. These -indicators suggest a set of items is measuring a single underlying dimension. +Subscription Revenue -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Total Subscription Revenue Backlog -0.44 +24-month Subscription Revenue Backlog -0.43 +GAAP Operating Margin -Source: Surveys conducted May 10-June 6, 2016, and April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Non-GAAP Operating Margin1 -0.73 +Operating Cash Flows -0.50 +1 Reconciliations of GAAP to Non-GAAP financial data included in the Appendix -0.73 +$1.43B -0.52 +$1.27B -As shown in the accompanying -table, the internal reliability or -consistency of the scale as -measured by Cronbach’s alpha -is 0.75. Each of the items in the -scale is at least moderately -correlated with the other items. +$12.65B -10 In statistical models controlling for demographics and education, there were no significant differences between respondents who -completed the science knowledge items in 2016 (W17) and those who completed them in 2018 (W34) on either the overall index measure or -the individual questions. +$7.97B -www.pewresearch.org +(5.1%) - 21 +20.1% -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$440M -Two parameter item response theory analysis +22% -KNOSCT22. Use of a control -group to determine whether a -new drug is effective -KNOSCT23. Carbon dioxide is -made as a consequence of -burning fossil fuels -KNOSCT27. The probability of an -old-bridge collapsing after a -period of time -KNOSCT28. Only bacterial -infections can be treated -effectively by antibiotic -medications -KNOSCT29. The use of a control -“sugar pill” in a new drug trial is -to rule out a possible placebo -effect -KNOSCT31. The health benefits -occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine is called -herd immunity -KNOSCT32. An apple, salmon, -corn and a mosquito can all be -genetically modified. -KNOSCT33. Humans and mice -share 50% or more of the same -genetic make-up -KNOSCT34. Nitrogen makes up -most of the Earth’s atmosphere. +23% -% Correct Discrimination +26% -Difficulty +21% -68 +(180 bps) -72 +(450 bps) -62 +(3%) -46 + Q1 FY23 Customer Wins and Expansions -1.36 + Q1 FY23 Business Highlights --0.73 +• -1.74 +• --0.82 +• -2.14 +• --0.38 +Workday intends to create 1,000 new jobs at its European +headquarters in Dublin over the next two years. In addition, the +company plans to build new European headquarters at +Grangegorman in Dublin. -0.81 +Workday completed the issuance and sale of $3.0 billion aggregate +principal amount of senior notes in an underwritten, registered +public offering. -0.25 +Building on its long-standing support of ESG, Workday shared its +commitments to ESG as well as announced two new ESG solutions +to help customers drive social and sustainability initiatives as they +navigate evolving ESG regulations and corporate accountability +standards. -59 +Workday was named one of the World’s Most Ethical Companies +by Ethisphere, which recognizes companies with a commitment to +advancing business integrity. -1.60 + Guidance Summary --0.33 +Quarterly Guidance -34 +Increase (Decrease) YoY -39 +Q2 FY23 -34 +Total Revenue -1.39 +Subscription Revenue -0.65 +24-month Subscription Revenue Backlog -1.66 +Non-GAAP Operating Margin -0.38 +$1.517B - $1.519B -1.37 +$1.353B - $1.355B -0.66 +n/a -Note that each of the science -knowledge questions are coded -as binary variables -(correct/incorrect). Both -Cronbach’s alpha reliability -analysis and the factor analysis -are based on a Pearson’s -correlation matrix. Pearson -correlations with binary -variables are restricted to a -limited range, underestimating -the association between two -variables when compared with -tetrachoric correlations. We do -not anticipate that the use of a -Pearson’s correlation matrix -affects the unidimensional -factor solution for the scale, -however. +17.5% -31 +20-21% -1.55 +22% -0.74 +20% -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +(570 bps) -Source: Surveys conducted May 10-June 6, 2016, and April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +n/a -We also ran an item-response -theory analysis (IRT) to check -how well each question -distinguishes between those -who know relatively more or -less on the scale. This analysis fits a two-parameter logistic model, allowing discrimination and -difficulty to vary across the items. Discrimination shows the ability of the question to distinguish -between those with higher and lower science knowledge. Difficulty shows how easy or hard each -question is for the average respondent. We did not include a guessing parameter in the model; the -questionnaire offered respondents an explicit option of not sure on the survey. +GAAP Operating Margin -The results show variation in difficulty across the items. The easiest item required respondents to -identify that carbon dioxide as the gas that is made as a consequence of burning fossil fuels, while -the most difficult item required respondents to identify nitrogen as the gas that makes up most of -the Earth’s atmosphere. +~22 points lower than non-GAAP -www.pewresearch.org +Full Year FY23 - 22 +Total Revenue -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Subscription Revenue -Most of the questions also discriminate between those with higher and lower science knowledge. -The item with strongest ability to discriminate was the question asking respondents to calculate -the conditional probability of an old bridge over time. The question with the weakest ability to -discriminate was the question about the effectiveness of antibiotics to treat bacterial, but not other -kinds of infections. +Non-GAAP Operating Margin -The test information curve mirrors a normal curve centered around zero, suggesting that the -science knowledge index provides the most information about Americans near the mean level of -knowledge. +GAAP Operating Margin -© Pew Research Center, 2018 +Non-GAAP Tax Rate -www.pewresearch.org +Operating Cash Flows - 23 +As provided on Q1 FY23 Earnings Call on 5.26.22 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Full Year Guidance -Appendix: Detailed tables +Increase (Decrease) YoY -Half or more from all religious groups -consider gene editing to treat disease -that would be present at birth to be -appropriate +$6.187B - $6.207B -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to treat a -serious disease or condition a baby would have at birth -is … +$5.537B - $5.557B -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant +18.5% -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology -72% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -27% - -66 -61 -79 -60 -72 -72 -74 -78 -92 -92 -69 - -74 -62 -74 - -31 -37 -20 -36 -28 -28 -26 -22 -7 -8 -30 - -24 -35 -26 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 24 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -White evangelical Protestants among -the least likely to consider gene editing -to reduce lifetime disease risk -appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to reduce the -risk of a serious disease or condition that could occur -over the course of a baby’s lifetime is … +~24 points lower than non-GAAP -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology -60% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -38% - -51 -45 -58 -51 -63 -58 -68 -67 -85 -81 -57 - -60 -52 -61 - -47 -54 -41 -43 -36 -41 -30 -32 -15 -19 -41 - -39 -44 -36 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 25 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Nine-in-ten white evangelical -Protestants see gene editing for -intelligence as taking technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to make a -baby more intelligent is … - -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology 19% -Taking medical -technology too -far -80% - -12 -8 -12 -14 -20 -18 -24 -25 -36 -22 -23 - -16 -21 -22 - -86 -91 -88 -81 -80 -82 -76 -74 -64 -77 -77 - -83 -75 -76 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 26 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Statistical models predicting opinions about appropriate uses of gene editing - -Difference in predicted probabilities for belief that changing a baby’s genetic characteristics ____ is an appropriate use of -medical technology +$1.610B -Women +20-21% -To treat a serious disease or -condition the baby would -have at birth -NS +22% -To reduce the risk of a serious -disease or condition that could occur -over the course of his or her lifetime --0.08 +(390 bps) -To make the baby -more intelligent --0.09 +n/a -Requiring testing on -human embryos --0.15 +n/a -Race Reference category: White, non-Hispanic +(2%) -Black, non-Hispanic + Appendix -Hispanic + Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP Data -Other +Three Months Ended April 30, 2022 -Age Reference category: 18-29 +(in thousands, except percentages and per +share data) -Ages 30-49 +GAAP -50-64 +Share-Based +Compensation +Expenses -65+ +Other Operating +Expenses2 -NS +Income Tax and +Dilution Effects3 -NS +Non-GAAP --0.20 +Costs and expenses: -NS +Costs of subscription services --0.10 +Costs of professional services -NS +Product development -Education Reference category: High school or less +Sales and marketing -Postgraduate +General and administrative -College graduate +Operating income (loss) -Some college +Operating margin -+0.16 +Other income (expense), net -+0.14 +Income (loss) before provision for (benefit from) +income taxes -+0.09 +Provision for (benefit from) income taxes -Science knowledge Reference category: Low science knowledge +Net income (loss) -High +Net income (loss) per share, basic1 -Medium +Net income (loss) per share, diluted1 -+0.16 +$232,922 -NS +169,899 -NS +541,509 -NS +429,301 -NS +133,869 --0.12 +(72,843) --0.17 +(5.1)% -NS +(20,163) -+0.13 +(93,006) -NS +9,167 -+0.08 +$(102,173) -NS +$(0.41) -NS +$(0.41) -Religious commitment Reference category: Low religious commitment +$(26,230) -High +(27,584) -Medium +(153,304) --0.14 +(59,169) -NS +(45,219) -Religious affiliation Reference category: Unaffiliated +311,506 -Mainline Protestant +21.7% -Evangelical Protestant +- -Catholic +311,506 -Other Christian +- -Other religion +$311,506 -NS +$1.24 -NS +$1.24 -NS +$(16,326) -NS +(3,899) -NS +(13,011) --0.21 +(14,046) --0.10 +(2,613) -NS +49,895 -NS +3.5% -NS +- -NS +49,895 -NS +- -NS +$49,895 -NS +$0.20 -NS +$0.20 --0.08 +$- --0.12 +- --0.13 +- -NS +- -NS +- -NS +- -NS +-% --0.09 +- --0.14 +- -NS +41,828 -NS +$(41,828) -NS +$(0.17) -NS +$(0.20) -NS +$190,366 -NS +138,416 -NS +375,194 --0.09 +356,086 -NS +86,037 -NS +288,558 -NS +20.1% --0.12 +(20,163) -+0.10 +268,395 -NS +50,995 -+0.07 +$217,400 -NS +$0.86 --0.08 +$0.83 --0.14 +1 GAAP net loss per share is calculated based upon 251,743 basic and diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. Non-GAAP net income per share is calculated based +upon 251,743 basic and 263,473 diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. The numerator used to compute non-GAAP diluted net income per share was increased by +$1.3 million for after-tax interest expense on our convertible senior notes in accordance with the if-converted method. --0.13 +2 Other operating expenses include employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions of $28.3 million and amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets of +$21.6 million. -NS +3 We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the reporting periods. For fiscal 2023, +the non-GAAP tax rate is 19%. Included in the per share amount is a dilution impact of $0.03 from the conversion of GAAP diluted net loss per share to non-GAAP diluted net +income per share. --0.22 + Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP Data -NS +Three Months Ended April 30, 2021 -NS +(in thousands, except percentages and per +share data) -NS +GAAP -Heard about gene editing Reference category: Heard nothing at all about gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics +Share-Based +Compensation +Expenses -Heard a lot +Other Operating +Expenses2 -Heard a little +Income Tax and +Dilution Effects3 -Number of respondents +Non-GAAP -NS +Costs and expenses: -+0.06 +Costs of subscription services -2,237 +Costs of professional services -NS +Product development -NS +Sales and marketing -2,232 +General and administrative -+0.15 +Operating income (loss) -+0.07 +Operating margin -2,241 +Other income (expense), net -+0.17 +Income (loss) before provision for (benefit from) +income taxes -+0.09 +Provision for (benefit from) income taxes -2,223 +Net income (loss) -Note: Figures shown are the difference in predicted probabilities with the reference category while other factors are held at their mean using binary -logistic regression models. Positive and negative values indicated the direction of effects. NS indicates not statistically significant based on a two- -tailed p value < 0.05. -Source: Survey conducted April 23- May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Net income (loss) per share, basic1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Net income (loss) per share, diluted1 -www.pewresearch.org +$182,208 - 27 +150,845 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +441,616 -Survey questionnaire and topline +326,494 -2018 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL -APRIL 23-MAY 6, 2018 -TOTAL N=2,537 +112,183 -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED OR HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE +(38,313) -ASK ALL: -MED3 How much, if anything, have you heard or read about gene editing that can be used to change a +(3.3)% -baby’s genetic characteristics? +(9,051) -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -12 -56 -32 -1 +(47,364) -A lot -A little -Nothing at all -No answer +(842) -ASK ALL: -MED4 Do you think each of the following is an appropriate use of medical technology or is it taking +$(46,522) -medical technology too far? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] +$(0.19) -An appropriate use of -medical technology +$(0.19) -Taking medical -technology too far +$(20,717) -No -Answer +(27,692) -a. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics +(129,862) -to make the baby more intelligent +(50,308) -April 23-May 6, 2018 +(36,056) -b. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics +264,635 -to TREAT a serious disease or condition the -baby would have at birth -April 23-May 6, 2018 +22.5% -c. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics -to REDUCE THE RISK of a serious disease -or condition that could occur over the -course of his or her lifetime +- -19 +264,635 -72 +- -80 +$264,635 -27 +$1.09 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +$1.09 -60 +$(14,204) -38 +(6,953) -1 +(19,542) -2 +(17,106) -2 +(4,386) -TRENDS FOR COMPARISON -Pew Research Center survey conducted by telephone: Would you say that changing a baby’s genetic -characteristics to make the baby more intelligent is making appropriate use of medical advances OR is it -taking medical advances too far? +62,191 -Aug. 15-25, -2014 -15 -83 -2 +5.4% -Appropriate use of medical advances -Taking medical advances too far -Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) +- -www.pewresearch.org +62,191 - 28 +- -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$62,191 -Surveys conducted by telephone: Would you say that changing a baby’s genetic characteristics to reduce -the risk of serious diseases is making appropriate use of medical advances OR is it taking medical -advances too far? +$0.26 -Appropriate use of medical advances -Taking medical advances too far -Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) +$0.26 -Pew Research Center -Aug. 15-25, -2014 -46 -50 -4 +$- -VCU Life Sciences -Survey -Sept. 3-26, -2003 -41 -54 -6 +- -ASK ALL: -MED5 Thinking about what you have heard or read, how well do you think medical researchers +- -understand the health risks and benefits of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics? +- -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -7 -29 -45 -17 -1 +- -Very well -Fairly well -Not too well -Not at all well -No answer +- -ASK ALL: -MED6 Thinking about society as a whole … +-% -How likely, if at all, do you think each of the following would be to occur if gene editing to -change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] +- -Very likely +- -Fairly -likely +53,940 -Not too -likely +$(53,940) -Not at all -likely +$(0.23) -No -Answer +$(0.29) -a. Even if gene editing is used +$147,287 -appropriately in some cases, others -will use these techniques in ways -that are morally unacceptable +116,200 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +292,212 -54 +259,080 -32 +71,741 -9 +288,513 -b. These techniques will help people -live longer and better quality lives +24.6% -April 23-May 6, 2018 +(9,051) -16 +279,462 -48 +53,098 -27 +$226,364 -c. We will use these techniques before -we fully understand how they affect -people’s health +$0.93 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +$0.87 -46 +1 GAAP net loss per share is calculated based upon 243,739 basic and diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. Non-GAAP net income per share is calculated based +upon 243,739 basic and 260,416 diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. The numerator used to compute non-GAAP diluted net income per share was increased by +$1.3 million for after-tax interest expense on our convertible senior notes in accordance with the if-converted method. -38 +2 Other operating expenses include employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions of $44.3 million and amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets of +$17.9 million. -12 +3 We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the reporting periods. For fiscal 2022, +the non-GAAP tax rate was 19%. Included in the per share amount is a dilution impact of $0.07 from the conversion of GAAP diluted net loss per share to non-GAAP diluted net +income per share. -d. + About Non-GAAP Financial Measures -Inequality will increase because -this option will be available only for -the wealthy +To provide investors and others with additional information regarding Workday’s results, we have disclosed the following non-GAAP financial measures: non-GAAP operating +income (loss), non-GAAP operating margin, and non-GAAP net income (loss) per share. Workday has provided a reconciliation of each non-GAAP financial measure used in this +earnings release to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure. Non-GAAP operating income (loss) and non-GAAP operating margin differ from GAAP in that they +exclude share-based compensation expenses, employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions, and amortization expense for acquisition-related intangible +assets. Non-GAAP net income (loss) per share differs from GAAP in that it excludes share-based compensation expenses, employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock +transactions, amortization expense for acquisition-related intangible assets, and income tax effects. -April 23-May 6, 2018 +Workday’s management uses these non-GAAP financial measures to understand and compare operating results across accounting periods, for internal budgeting and +forecasting purposes, for short- and long-term operating plans, and to evaluate Workday’s financial performance. Management believes these non-GAAP financial measures +reflect Workday’s ongoing business in a manner that allows for meaningful period-to-period comparisons and analysis of trends in Workday’s business. Management also +believes that these non-GAAP financial measures provide useful information to investors and others in understanding and evaluating Workday’s operating results and prospects +in the same manner as management and in comparing financial results across accounting periods and to those of peer companies. -58 - -29 - -9 +Management believes excluding the following items from the GAAP Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations is useful to investors and others in assessing Workday’s +operating performance due to the following factors: -3 +• -8 - -3 - -4 - -1 - -2 +Share-based compensation expenses. Although share-based compensation is an important aspect of the compensation of our employees and executives, management +believes it is useful to exclude share-based compensation expenses to better understand the long-term performance of our core business and to facilitate comparison of +our results to those of peer companies. Share-based compensation expenses are determined using a number of factors, including our stock price, volatility, and forfeiture +rates, that are beyond our control and generally unrelated to operational decisions and performance in any particular period. Further, share-based compensation +expenses are not reflective of the value ultimately received by the grant recipients. -1 + About Non-GAAP Financial Measures (cont’d) -1 +• -www.pewresearch.org +• - 29 +Other operating expenses. Other operating expenses includes employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions and amortization of acquisition-related +intangible assets. The amount of employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions is dependent on our stock price and other factors that are beyond our +control and do not correlate to the operation of the business. For business combinations, we generally allocate a portion of the purchase price to intangible assets. The +amount of the allocation is based on estimates and assumptions made by management and is subject to amortization. The amount of purchase price allocated to +intangible assets and the term of its related amortization can vary significantly and are unique to each acquisition and thus we do not believe it is reflective of ongoing +operations. Although we exclude the amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets from these non-GAAP measures, management believes that it is important for +investors to understand that such intangible assets were recorded as part of purchase accounting and contribute to revenue generation. -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Income tax effects. We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the +reporting periods. In projecting this long-term non-GAAP tax rate, we utilize a three-year financial projection that excludes the direct impact of share-based compensation +and related employer payroll taxes, amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets, and amortization of debt discount and issuance costs. The projected rate +considers other factors such as our current operating structure, existing tax positions in various jurisdictions, and key legislation in major jurisdictions where we operate. +For fiscal 2023 and 2022, we determined the projected non-GAAP tax rate to be 19%, which reflects currently available information, as well as other factors and +assumptions. We will periodically re-evaluate this tax rate, as necessary, for significant events, based on our ongoing analysis of the 2017 U.S. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, +relevant tax law changes, material changes in the forecasted geographic earnings mix, and any significant acquisitions. -Very likely - -Fairly -likely - -Not too -likely - -Not at all -likely - -No -Answer - -MED6 continued … - -e. Development of these techniques -will pave the way for new medical -advances that benefit society as a -whole - -April 23-May 6, 2018 - -18 - -42 - -30 - -8 +The use of non-GAAP operating income (loss), non-GAAP operating margin, and non-GAAP net income (loss) per share measures have certain limitations as they do not reflect +all items of income and expense that affect Workday’s operations. Workday compensates for these limitations by reconciling the non-GAAP financial measures to the most +comparable GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP financial measures should be considered in addition to, not as a substitute for or in isolation from, measures prepared in +accordance with GAAP. Further, these non-GAAP measures may differ from the non-GAAP information used by other companies, including peer companies, and therefore +comparability may be limited. Management encourages investors and others to review Workday’s financial information in its entirety and not rely on a single financial measure. -1 - -ASK ALL: -MED7 If gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics required testing on human embryos in - -order to develop these techniques, do you think this would be … - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -33 -65 -2 - -An appropriate use of medical technology -Taking medical technology too far -No answer - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FURTHER RELEASE - -ASK ALL: -BIO15 Have you seen a health care provider FOR AN ILLNESS OR MEDICAL CONDITION in the past 12 - -months, or not? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -64 -36 -1 - -Yes -No -No answer - -May 10- -June 6 -2016 -63 -36 -2 - -ASK ALL: -G1 - -Do you, or does anyone in your immediate family, have a gene that predisposes you to a serious -disease such as Alzheimer’s, cancer, heart disease or sickle cell anemia? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -26 -40 -34 -1 - -Yes -No -Not sure -No answer - -May 10- -June 6, -2016 -27 -43 -30 -1 - -www.pewresearch.org - - 30 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK ALL: -G2 - -Have you, or has anyone in your immediate family, ever had a genetic test, or haven’t you done -this? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -14 -65 -20 -1 - -Yes -No -Not sure -No answer - -May 10- -June 6 -2016 -10 -70 -19 -1 - -NOTE: RESULTS SHOWN FOR KNOSCT22-KNOSCT34 INCLUDE 636 RESPONDENTS WHO -ANSWERED THESE QUESTIONS APRIL 23-MAY 6, 2018 COMBINED WITH 1,901 RESPONDENTS -WHO ANSWERED THESE QUESTIONS IN A PREVIOUS WAVE FIELDED MAY 10-JUNE 6, 2016. - -ASK ALL: Here’s a different kind of question. (If you don’t know the answer, select “Not sure.”) As far as -you know … - -KNOSCT22 - -Here’s a different kind of question. (If you don’t know the answer, select “Not sure.”) As -far as you know ... - -Which is the better way to determine whether a new drug is effective in treating a -disease? If a scientist has a group of 1,000 volunteers with the disease to study, should -she … [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2] - -Apr 23- -May 6 -2018 -68 - -32 - 14 - 18 -<1 - -Give the drug to half of them but not to the other half, and compare -how many in each group get better (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Give the drug to all of them and see how many get better - Not sure - No answer - -[RANDOMIZE ITEMS KNOSCT23 TO KNOSCT34; KNOSCT22 ALWAYS FIRST] - -www.pewresearch.org - - 31 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Which gas is made as a consequence of burning fossil fuels? Is it … [RANDOMIZE -OPTIONS 1-4]11 - -Carbon dioxide (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Hydrogen - Helium - Radon - Not sure - No answer - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT23 - -Apr 23- -May 6 -2018 -72 -28 - 4 - 1 - 3 - 20 -<1 - -NO QUESTION KNOSCT24, KNOSCT25 AND KNOSCT26 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT27 - -If the chances that an old bridge will collapse starts at 1% in week 1 and doubles each -week (as shown below), what is the chance that the old bridge will collapse during week -7? - -Chances the bridge will collapse is… - -1% -2% -4% -8% - -at Week 1 -at Week 2 -at Week 3 -at Week 4 - -Enter the % chance that the bridge will collapse at Week 7 (if the bridge is still standing -after Week 6)12 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -62 -38 - 20 - 17 - 1 - -64% (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - All other numeric responses - Not sure - No answer - -11 In the Wave 17 May 2016 survey, the question had a minor wording difference: “What gas is made as a consequence of burning fossil -fuels? Is it …” -12 The phrase “(if the bridge is still standing after Week 6)” was added for clarity in the April 23-May 6, 2018, wave. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 32 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Which of the following conditions can be treated effectively by antibiotic medications? - -[Check all that apply] [RANDOMIZE ITEMS WITH ITEMS e AND f ALWAYS LAST] - -Bacterial infection only (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT28 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -46 -54 - -KNOSCT28 INDIVIDUAL ITEM RESPONSES - -a. Viral infections (such as a cold) -b. Fungal infections (such as athlete’s foot) -c. Bacterial infections (such as strep throat infections) -d. Allergic reactions to insect bites -e. None of these [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] -f. Not sure [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] - -Selected -23 -28 -83 -17 -2 -9 - -Not selected -/No answer -77 -72 -17 -83 -98 -91 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT29 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -59 -41 - 4 - 16 - 20 - 1 - -If a scientist wants to determine if a new drug is effective at treating high blood pressure -by giving half of a group of 1,000 volunteers a new medication and the other half a -“sugar pill” she wants to rule out … [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-3] - -A placebo effect (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - A third person effect - A false consensus effect - Not sure - No answer - -NO QUESTION KNOSCT30 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT31 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -34 -66 - 8 - 35 - 23 - 1 - -Which of these terms refers to health benefits occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-3] - -Herd immunity (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Population control - Vaccination rate - Not sure - No answer - -www.pewresearch.org - - 33 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT32 - -Which of the following can be genetically modified? - -[Check all that apply] [RANDOMIZE ITEMS WITH ITEMS e AND f ALWAYS LAST] - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -39 -61 - -Selected all (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - -KNOSCT32 INDIVIDUAL ITEM RESPONSES - -a. An apple -b. Salmon -c. A mosquito -d. Corn -e. None of these [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] -f. Not sure [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] - -Selected -61 -53 -46 -70 -2 -20 - -Not selected -/No answer -39 -47 -54 -30 -98 -80 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT33 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -34 -66 - 8 - 14 - 44 - 1 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT34 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -31 -69 - 9 - 9 - 35 - 15 - 1 - -Humans and mice share the same genetic makeup by… [RANDOMIZE ORDER LOW TO -HIGH; HIGH TO LOW with NOT SURE ALWAYS LAST] - -About 50% or more (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Less than 10% - Between 11% and 49% - Not sure - No answer - -Which gas makes up most of the Earth's atmosphere? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-4] - -Nitrogen (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Hydrogen - Carbon dioxide - -Oxygen - Not sure - No answer - -www.pewresearch.org - - 34 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -TOTAL NUMBER CORRECT KNOSCT22 THROUGH KNOSCT34: - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -4 -10 -10 -13 -12 -13 -11 -12 -9 -6 - -9 out of 9 -8 out of 9 -7 out of 9 -6 out of 9 -5 out of 9 -4 out of 9 -3 out of 9 -2 out of 9 -1 out of 9 -0 out of 9 - -24 -49 -26 - -High science knowledge (7-9 correct) -Medium science knowledge (3-6 correct) -Low science knowledge (0-2 correct) - -www.pewresearch.org + Thank You diff --git a/q58/random_k2/random_2.md b/q58/random_k2/random_2.md index b1e911fa22b913bedf584883674d00198efbf53f..d55a1d26c20476fcdee5ca60b395144c86c2f238 100644 --- a/q58/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q58/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,811 +1,1083 @@ -Physics 111 -- Mechanics - -• Lecturer: Tom Humanic - -• Contact info: - -Office: Physics Research Building, Rm. 2144 - - Email: humanic@mps.ohio-state.edu - Phone: 614 247 8950 - -• Office hours: - Tuesday 4:30 pm - -My lecture slides may be found on my website at -http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~humanic/ - - Course Overview -- Mechanics -Kinematics -- velocity and acceleration, free-falling bodies, -projectile motion…. - -Dynamics -- Newton’s laws of motion -- forces -(gravitational, friction, tension……), motion of objects -due to forces…… - -Work and energy -- potential and kinetic energy, -conservation of energy, power…… - -Impulse and momentum -- conservation of momentum, -collisions, center-of-mass of an object, …… - -Rotational kinematics and dynamics -- angular velocity -and acceleration, torque, angular momentum….. - - Chapter 1 - -Introduction and -Mathematical Concepts - - 1.2 Units - -Physics experiments involve the measurement -of a variety of quantities. - -These measurements should be accurate and -reproducible. - -The first step in ensuring accuracy and -reproducibility is defining the units in which -the measurements are made. - - 1.2 Units - -SI units - -meter (m): unit of length - -kilogram (kg): unit of mass - -second (s): unit of time - - 1.2 Units - - 1.2 Units - -The units for length, mass, and time (as -well as a few others), are regarded as -base SI units. - -These units are used in combination to -define additional units for other important -physical quantities such as force and -energy. - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -THE CONVERSION OF UNITS - -1 ft = 0.3048 m - -1 mi = 1.609 km - -1 hp = 746 W - -1 liter = 10-3 m3 - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Example 1 The World’s Highest Waterfall - -The highest waterfall in the world is Angel Falls in Venezuela, -with a total drop of 979.0 m. Express this drop in feet. - -Since 3.281 feet = 1 meter, it follows that - -(3.281 feet)/(1 meter) = 1 - -Length - -= - -( - 0.979 - -meters - -feet - -.3 281 - 1 -meter - -& -) -$ -% - -# -=! -" - -3212 - -feet - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Reasoning Strategy: Converting Between Units - -1. In all calculations, write down the units explicitly. - -2. Treat all units as algebraic quantities. When -identical units are divided, they are eliminated -algebraically. - -3. Use the conversion factors located on the page -facing the inside cover. Be guided by the fact that -multiplying or dividing an equation by a factor of 1 -does not alter the equation. - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Example 2 Interstate Speed Limit - -Express the speed limit of 65 miles/hour in terms of meters/second. - -Use 5280 feet = 1 mile and 3600 seconds = 1 hour and -3.281 feet = 1 meter. - -Speed - -= - -& - 65 -$ -% - -miles -hour - -# -! -" - -( )( ) -11 - -= - - 65 - -& -$ -% - -miles -hour - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - -5280 - -feet - -mile - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - - 1 -hour -3600 -s - -# -=! -" - -95 - -feet -second - -Speed - -= - -& -95 -$ -% - -feet -second - -# -! -" - -( ) -1 - -= - -95 - -& -$ -% - -feet -second - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - -meter - - 1 -3.281 - -feet - -# -=! -" - -29 - -meters -second - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS - -[L] = length [M] = mass [T] = time - -Is the following equation dimensionally correct? - -x = - +3 2 - -1 vt +0 2 +c +e +D +3 -[ ] -L -= - +] L -T - -& -$% - -# -!" +C +. +s +c +[ -[ ] -T +2 +v +1 +0 +6 +0 +1 +. +5 +0 +3 +2 +: +v +i +X +r +a -2 = +Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving +with Large Language Models -[ ][ ]TL +Shunyu Yao +Princeton University - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving +Dian Yu +Google DeepMind -Is the following equation dimensionally correct? +Jeffrey Zhao +Google DeepMind -x = +Izhak Shafran +Google DeepMind -vt +Thomas L. Griffiths +Princeton University -[ ] -L -= +Yuan Cao +Google DeepMind -L -T +Karthik Narasimhan +Princeton University -& -$ -% +Abstract -# -! -" +Language models are increasingly being deployed for general problem solving +across a wide range of tasks, but are still confined to token-level, left-to-right +decision-making processes during inference. This means they can fall short in +tasks that require exploration, strategic lookahead, or where initial decisions play +a pivotal role. To surmount these challenges, we introduce a new framework for +language model inference, “Tree of Thoughts” (ToT), which generalizes over the +popular “Chain of Thought” approach to prompting language models, and enables +exploration over coherent units of text (“thoughts”) that serve as intermediate steps +toward problem solving. ToT allows LMs to perform deliberate decision making +by considering multiple different reasoning paths and self-evaluating choices to +decide the next course of action, as well as looking ahead or backtracking when +necessary to make global choices. Our experiments show that ToT significantly +enhances language models’ problem-solving abilities on three novel tasks requiring +non-trivial planning or search: Game of 24, Creative Writing, and Mini Crosswords. +For instance, in Game of 24, while GPT-4 with chain-of-thought prompting only +solved 4% of tasks, our method achieved a success rate of 74%. Code repo with all +prompts: https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm. -[ ] [ ]L -T -= +1 - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +Introduction + +Originally designed to generate text, scaled-up versions of language models (LMs) such as GPT [25, +26, 1, 23] and PaLM [5] have been shown to be increasingly capable of performing an ever wider +range of tasks requiring mathematical, symbolic, commonsense, and knowledge reasoning. It is +perhaps surprising that underlying all this progress is still the original autoregressive mechanism for +generating text, which makes token-level decisions one by one and in a left-to-right fashion. Is such +a simple mechanism sufficient for a LM to be built toward a general problem solver? If not, what +problems would challenge the current paradigm, and what should be alternative mechanisms? + +The literature on human cognition provides some clues to answer these questions. Research on “dual +process” models suggests that people have two modes in which they engage with decisions – a fast, +automatic, unconscious mode (“System 1”) and a slow, deliberate, conscious mode (“System 2”) +[30, 31, 16, 15]. These two modes have previously been connected to a variety of mathematical +models used in machine learning. For example, research on reinforcement learning in humans and +other animals has explored the circumstances under which they engage in associative “model free” +learning or more deliberative “model based” planning [7]. The simple associative token-level choices +of LMs are also reminiscent of “System 1”, and thus might benefit from augmentation by a more +deliberate “System 2” planning process that (1) maintains and explores diverse alternatives for current + +37th Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS 2023). + + Figure 1: Schematic illustrating various approaches to problem solving with LLMs. Each rectangle +box represents a thought, which is a coherent language sequence that serves as an intermediate +step toward problem solving. See concrete examples of how thoughts are generated, evaluated, and +searched in Figures 2,4,6. + +choices instead of just picking one, and (2) evaluates its current status and actively looks ahead or +backtracks to make more global decisions. + +To design such a planning process, we return to the origins of artificial intelligence (and cognitive +science), drawing inspiration from the planning processes explored by Newell, Shaw, and Simon +starting in the 1950s [21, 22]. Newell and colleagues characterized problem solving [21] as search +through a combinatorial problem space, represented as a tree. We thus propose the Tree of Thoughts +(ToT) framework for general problem solving with language models. As Figure 1 illustrates, while +existing methods (detailed below) sample continuous language sequences for problem solving, ToT +actively maintains a tree of thoughts, where each thought is a coherent language sequence that serves +as an intermediate step toward problem solving (Table 1). Such a high-level semantic unit allows the +LM to self-evaluate the progress different intermediate thoughts make towards solving the problem +through a deliberate reasoning process that is also instantiated in language (Figures 2,4,6). This +implementation of search heuristics via LM self-evaluation and deliberation is novel, as previous +search heuristics are either programmed or learned. Finally, we combine this language-based +capability to generate and evaluate diverse thoughts with search algorithms, such as breadth-first +search (BFS) or depth-first search (DFS), which allow systematic exploration of the tree of thoughts +with lookahead and backtracking. + +Empirically, we propose three new problems that challenge existing LM inference methods even with +the state-of-the-art language model, GPT-4 [23]: Game of 24, Creative Writing, and Crosswords +(Table 1). These tasks require deductive, mathematical, commonsense, lexical reasoning abilities, +and a way to incorporate systematic planning or search. We show ToT obtains superior results on +all three tasks by being general and flexible enough to support different levels of thoughts, different +ways to generate and evaluate thoughts, and different search algorithms that adapt to the nature of +different problems. We also analyze how such choices affect model performances via systematic +ablations and discuss future directions to better train and use LMs. + +2 Background + +We first formalize some existing methods that use large language models for problem-solving, +which our approach is inspired by and later compared with. We use pθ to denote a pre-trained LM +with parameters θ, and lowercase letters x, y, z, s, · · · to denote a language sequence, i.e. x = +(x[1], · · · , x[n]) where each x[i] is a token, so that pθ(x) = (cid:81)n +i=1 pθ(x[i]|x[1...i]). We use uppercase +letters S, · · · to denote a collection of language sequences. + +Input-output (IO) prompting is the most common way to turn a problem input x into output +y with LM: y ∼ pθ(y|promptIO(x)), where promptIO(x) wraps input x with task instructions +and/or few-shot input-output examples. For simplicity, let us denote pprompt +(output | input) = +pθ(output | prompt(input)), so that IO prompting can be formulated as y ∼ pIO + +θ + +θ (y|x). -A scalar quantity is one that can be described -by a single number: +2 -temperature, speed, mass +(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:106)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:705)(cid:146)(cid:29)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:97)(cid:202)(cid:288)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:78)(cid:3)(cid:71)(cid:76)(cid:73)(cid:73)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:70)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:705)(cid:146)(cid:29)(cid:690)(cid:97)(cid:202)(cid:288)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:705)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:71)(cid:106)(cid:690) Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting [38] was proposed to address cases where the mapping of +input x to output y is non-trivial (e.g. when x is a math question and y is the final numerical answer). +The key idea is to introduce a chain of thoughts z1, · · · , zn to bridge x and y, where each zi is a +coherent language sequence that serves as a meaningful intermediate step toward problem solving +(e.g. zi could be an intermediate equation for math QA). To solve problems with CoT, each thought +zi ∼ pCoT +(y|x, z1···n). In +practice, [z1···n, y] ∼ pCoT +(z1···n, y|x) is sampled as a continuous language sequence, and the +decomposition of thoughts (e.g. is each zi a phrase, a sentence, or a paragraph) is left ambiguous. + +(zi | x, z1···i−1) is sampled sequentially, then the output y ∼ pCoT + +θ + +θ + +θ + +1···n, y(i)] ∼ pCoT + +Self-consistency with CoT (CoT-SC) [36] is an ensemble approach that samples k i.i.d. chains +of thought: [z(i) +(z1···n, y|x) (i = 1 · · · k), then returns the most frequent output: +arg maxy #{i | y(i) = y}. CoT-SC improves upon CoT, because there are generally different +thought processes for the same problem (e.g. different ways to prove the same theorem), and the +output decision can be more faithful by exploring a richer set of thoughts. However, within each +chain there is no local exploration of different thought steps, and the “most frequent” heuristic only +applies when the output space is limited (e.g. multi-choice QA). + +θ + +3 Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving with LM + +A genuine problem-solving process involves the repeated use of available informa- +tion to initiate exploration, which discloses, in turn, more information until a way +to attain the solution is finally discovered.—— Newell et al. [21] + +Research on human problem-solving suggests that people search through a combinatorial problem- +space – a tree where the nodes represent partial solutions, and the branches correspond to operators +that modify them [21, 22]. Which branch to take is determined by heuristics that help to navigate the +problem-space and guide the problem-solver towards a solution. This perspective highlights two key +shortcomings of existing approaches that use LMs to solve general problems: 1) Locally, they do not +explore different continuations within a thought process – the branches of the tree. 2) Globally, they +do not incorporate any type of planning, lookahead, or backtracking to help evaluate these different +options – the kind of heuristic-guided search that seems characteristic of human problem-solving. + +To address these shortcomings, we introduce Tree of Thoughts (ToT), a paradigm that allows LMs to +explore multiple reasoning paths over thoughts (Figure 1(c)). ToT frames any problem as a search +over a tree, where each node is a state s = [x, z1···i] representing a partial solution with the input and +the sequence of thoughts so far. A specific instantiation of ToT involves answering four questions: +1. How to decompose the intermediate process into thought steps; 2. How to generate potential +thoughts from each state; 3. How to heuristically evaluate states; 4. What search algorithm to use. + +1. Thought decomposition. While CoT samples thoughts coherently without explicit decomposition, +ToT leverages problem properties to design and decompose intermediate thought steps. As Table 1 +shows, depending on different problems, a thought could be a couple of words (Crosswords), a line of +equation (Game of 24), or a whole paragraph of writing plan (Creative Writing). In general, a thought +should be “small” enough so that LMs can generate promising and diverse samples (e.g. generating +a whole book is usually too “big” to be coherent), yet “big” enough so that LMs can evaluate its +prospect toward problem solving (e.g. generating one token is usually too “small” to evaluate). -A vector quantity deals inherently with both -magnitude and direction: +2. Thought generator G(pθ, s, k). Given a tree state s = [x, z1···i], we consider two strategies to +generate k candidates for the next thought step: -velocity, force, displacement +(a) Sample i.i.d. thoughts from a CoT prompt (Creative Writing, Figure 4): z(j) ∼ +(zi+1|x, z1···i) (j = 1 · · · k). This works better when the thought - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +pCoT +θ +space is rich (e.g. each thought is a paragraph), and i.i.d. samples lead to diversity; -Arrows are used to represent vectors. The -direction of the arrow gives the direction of -the vector. +(zi+1|s) = pCoT -By convention, the length of a vector -arrow is proportional to the magnitude -of the vector. +θ + +(b) Propose thoughts sequentially using a “propose prompt” (Game of 24, Figure 2; Crosswords, +(z(1···k) +Figure 6): [z(1), · · · , z(k)] ∼ ppropose +| s). This works better when the thought +i+1 +space is more constrained (e.g. each thought is just a word or a line), so proposing different +thoughts in the same context avoids duplication. + +θ + +3. State evaluator V (pθ, S). Given a frontier of different states, the state evaluator evaluates the +progress they make towards solving the problem, serving as a heuristic for the search algorithm +to determine which states to keep exploring and in which order. While heuristics are a standard +approach to solving search problems, they are typically either programmed (e.g. DeepBlue [3]) or + +3 -4 lb + learned (e.g. AlphaGo [29]). We propose a third alternative, by using the LM to deliberately reason +about states. When applicable, such a deliberate heuristic can be more flexible than programmed +rules, and more sample-efficient than learned models. Similar to the thought generator, we consider +two strategies to evaluate states either independently or together: -8 lb +θ - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +(a) Value each state independently: V (pθ, S)(s) ∼ pvalue - Chapter 2 +(v|s) ∀s ∈ S, where a value +prompt reasons about the state s to generate a scalar value v (e.g. 1-10) or a classifica- +tion (e.g. sure/likely/impossible) that could be heuristically turned into a value. The basis +of such evaluative reasoning can vary across problems and thought steps. In this work, we +explore evaluation via few lookahead simulations (e.g. quickly confirm that 5, 5, 14 can +reach 24 via 5 + 5 + 14, or “hot l” can mean “inn” via filling “e” in “ ”) plus commonsense +(e.g. 1 2 3 are too small to reach 24, or no word can start with “tzxc”). While the former +might promote “good” states, the latter could help eliminate “bad” states. Such valuations +do not need to be perfect, and only need to be approximately helpful for decision making. +(s∗|S) is +voted out based on deliberately comparing different states in S in a vote prompt. When +problem success is harder to directly value (e.g. passage coherency), it is natural to to instead +compare different partial solutions and vote for the most promising one. This is similar +in spirit to a “step-wise” self-consistency strategy, i.e. cast “which state to explore” as a +multi-choice QA, and use LM samples to vote for it. -Kinematics in One Dimension +(b) Vote across states: V (pθ, S)(s) = 1[s = s∗], where a “good” state s∗ ∼ pvote - Kinematics deals with the concepts that -are needed to describe motion. +θ -Dynamics deals with the effect that forces -have on motion. +For both strategies, we could prompt the LM multiple times to aggregate the value or vote results to +trade time/resource/cost for more faithful/robust heuristics. -Together, kinematics and dynamics form -the branch of physics known as Mechanics. +Algorithm 1 ToT-BFS(x, pθ, G, k, V, T, b) +Require: Input x, LM pθ, thought generator G() +& size limit k, states evaluator V (), step limit T , +breadth limit b. +S0 ← {x} +for t = 1, · · · , T do - 2.1 Displacement +t ← {[s, z] | s ∈ St−1, zt ∈ G(pθ, s, k)} - =oxr +S′ +Vt ← V (pθ, S′ +t) +St ← arg maxS⊂S′ -initial +Algorithm 2 ToT-DFS(s, t, pθ, G, k, V, T, vth) +Require: Current state s, step t, LM pθ, thought +generator G() and size limit k, states evaluator +V (), step limit T , threshold vth +if t > T then record output G(pθ, s, 1) +end if +for s′ ∈ G(pθ, s, k) do -position +▷ sorted candidates +if V (pθ, {s′})(s) > vthres then ▷ pruning - =xr +t,|S|=b -final +(cid:80) -position +s∈S Vt(s) -!=" +DFS(s′, t + 1) -r -r -oxx +end for +return G(pθ, arg maxs∈ST VT (s), 1) -r -x +end if - = +end for -displaceme +4. Search algorithm. Finally, within the ToT framework, one can plug and play different search +algorithms depending on the tree structure. We explore two relatively simple search algorithms and +leave more advanced ones (e.g. A* [11], MCTS [2]) for future work: -nt +(a) Breadth-first search (BFS) (Algorithm 1) maintains a set of the b most promising states +per step. This is used for Game of 24 and Creative Writing where the tree depth is limit +(T ≤ 3), and initial thought steps can be evaluated and pruned to a small set (b ≤ 5). +(b) Depth-first search (DFS) (Algorithm 2) explores the most promising state first, until the +final output is reached (t > T ), or the state evaluator deems it impossible to solve the +problem from the current s (V (pθ, {s})(s) ≤ vth for a value threshold vth). In the latter +case, the subtree from s is pruned to trade exploration for exploitation. In both cases, DFS +backtracks to the parent state of s to continue exploration. - 2.1 Displacement +Conceptually, ToT has several benefits as a method for general problem-solving with LMs: (1) Gener- +ality. IO, CoT, CoT-SC, and self-refinement can be seen as special cases of ToT (i.e. trees of limited +depth and breadth; Figure 1). (2) Modularity. The base LM, as well as the thought decomposition, +generation, evaluation, and search procedures can all be varied independently. (3) Adaptability. +Different problem properties, LM capabilities, and resource constraints can be accommodated. (4) +Convenience. No extra training is needed, just a pre-trained LM is sufficient. The next section will +show how these conceptual benefits translate to strong empirical performance in different problems. -m 0.2=oxr +4 Experiments -m 0.5=!xr +We propose three tasks that are hard even when sampling from the state-of-the-art language model, +GPT-4 [23], using standard IO prompting or chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. We show how -m 0.7=xr +4 -!=" + Input -r -r -oxx +Output -r -x +Thoughts -= +#ToT steps -m 7.0 +Game of 24 -! +Creative Writing -m 0.5m 2.0 -= +5x5 Crosswords - 2.1 Displacement +4 numbers (4 9 10 13) -m 0.2=xr +4 random sentences -m 0.5!="xr +10 clues (h1. presented;..) -m 0.7=oxr +An equation to reach 24 +(13-9)*(10-4)=24 -!=" +A passage of 4 paragraphs +ending in the 4 sentences -r -r -oxx +5x5 letters: +WIRRA; AVAIL; ... -r -x +SHOWN; -= +3 intermediate equations +(13-9=4 (left 4,4,10); 10- +4=6 (left 4,6); 4*6=24) -m 2.0 +A short writing plan +(1. Introduce a book that +connects...) -! +Words to fill in for clues: +(h1. shown; v5. naled; ...) -m 7.0 +3 +Table 1: Task overview. Input, output, thought examples are in blue. -!= +5-10 (variable) -m 0.5 +1 - 2.1 Displacement +deliberate search in trees of thoughts (ToT) produces better results, and more importantly, interesting +and promising new ways to use language models to solve problems requiring search or planning. +Unless otherwise stated, we perform experiments using a Chat Completion mode GPT-41 with a +sampling temperature of 0.7. + +4.1 Game of 24 + +Game of 24 is a mathematical reasoning challenge, where the goal is to use 4 numbers and basic +arithmetic operations (+-*/) to obtain 24. For example, given input “4 9 10 13”, a solution output +could be “(10 - 4) * (13 - 9) = 24”. + +Figure 2: ToT in a game of 24. The LM is prompted for (a) thought generation and (b) valuation. + +Task Setup. We scrape data from 4nums.com, which has 1,362 games that are sorted from easy to +hard by human solving time, and use a subset of relatively hard games indexed 901-1,000 for testing. +For each task, we consider the output as success if it is a valid equation that equals 24 and uses the +input numbers each exactly once. We report the success rate across 100 games as the metric. + +Baselines. We use a standard input-output (IO) prompt with 5 in-context examples. For chain-of- +thought (CoT) prompting, we augment each input-output pair with 3 intermediate equations, each +operating on two remaining numbers. For example, given input “4 9 10 13”, the thoughts could be +“13 - 9 = 4 (left: 4 4 10); 10 - 4 = 6 (left: 4 6); 4 * 6 = 24 (left: 24)”. For each game, we sample IO +and CoT prompting for 100 times for average performance. We also consider a CoT self-consistency +baseline, which takes the majority output from 100 CoT samples, and an iterative-refine approach on +top of an IO sample for at most 10 iterations. At each iteration, the LM is conditioned on all previous +history to “reflect on your mistakes and generate a refined answer” if the output is incorrect. Note +that it uses groundtruth feedback signals about equation correctness. + +ToT Setup. To frame Game of 24 into ToT, it is natural to decompose the thoughts into 3 steps, +each an intermediate equation. As shown in Figure 2(a), at each tree node, we exact the remaining +numbers and prompt the LM to propose some possible next steps. The same “propose prompt” is +used for all 3 thought steps, though it only has one example with 4 input numbers. We perform a +breadth-first search (BFS) in ToT, where at each step we keep the best b = 5 candidates. To perform +deliberate BFS in ToT, as shown in Figure 2(b), we prompt LM to evaluate each thought candidate as +“sure/maybe/impossible” with regard to reaching 24. The aim is to promote correct partial solutions +that can be verdicted within few lookahead trials, and eliminate impossible partial solutions based on +“too big/small” commonsense, and keep the rest “maybe”. We sample values 3 times for each thought. + +1Experiments were done between May 5-16, 2023. + +5 + +(cid:691)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:137)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:349)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:692)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:42)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:41)(cid:383)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:683)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:683)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:691)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:692)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:57)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:689)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:646)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:643)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:230)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:705)(cid:641)(cid:784)(cid:643)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:644)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:644)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:641)(cid:678)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:690)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:137)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:349)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:11)(cid:68)(cid:12)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:692)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:42)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:41)(cid:383)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:683)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:683)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:691)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:692)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:12)(cid:3)(cid:57)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:689)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:646)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:230)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:705)(cid:641)(cid:784)(cid:643)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:644)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:644)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:641)(cid:678)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:690)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:78)(cid:3)(cid:71)(cid:76)(cid:73)(cid:73)(cid:3)(cid:83)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:90)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:75)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85) Method + +Success + +IO prompt +CoT prompt +CoT-SC (k=100) +ToT (ours) (b=1) +ToT (ours) (b=5) + +IO + Refine (k=10) +IO (best of 100) +CoT (best of 100) + +7.3% +4.0% +9.0% +45% +74% + +27% +33% +49% + +Table 2: Game of 24 Results. + +Figure 3: Game of 24 (a) scale analysis & (b) error analysis. + +Results. As shown in Table 2, IO, CoT, and CoT-SC prompting methods perform badly on the task, +achieving only 7.3%, 4.0%, and 9.0% success rates. In contrast, ToT with a breadth of b = 1 already +achieves a success rate of 45%, while b = 5 achieves 74%. We also consider an oracle setup for +IO/CoT, by calculating the success rate using best of k samples (1 ≤ k ≤ 100). To compare IO/CoT +(best of k) with ToT, we consider calculating the tree nodes visited per task in ToT across b = 1 · · · 5, +and map the 5 success rates in Figure 3(a), treating IO/CoT (best of k) as visiting k nodes in a bandit. +Not surprisingly, CoT scales better than IO, and best of 100 CoT samples achieve a success rate of +49%, but still much worse than exploring more nodes in ToT (b > 1). + +Error analysis. Figure 3(b) breaks down at which step CoT and ToT samples fail the task, i.e. the +thought (in CoT) or all b thoughts (in ToT) are invalid or impossible to reach 24. Notably, around +60% of CoT samples already failed the task after generating the first step, or equivalently, the first +three words (e.g. “4 + 9”). This highlights the issues with direct left-to-right decoding. + +4.2 Creative writing + +Next, we invent a creative writing task where the input is 4 random sentences and the output should +be a coherent passage with 4 paragraphs that end in the 4 input sentences respectively. Such a task is +open-ended and exploratory, and challenges creative thinking as well as high-level planning. + +Task setup. We sample random sentences from randomwordgenerator.com to form 100 inputs, and +there is no groundtruth passage for each input constraint. As we find that GPT-4 can follow the +input constraints most of the time, we focus on evaluating passage coherency in two ways: using a +GPT-4 zero-shot prompt to provide a 1-10 scalar score, or using human judgments to compare pairs +of outputs from different methods. For the former, we sample 5 scores and average them for each task +output, and we find these 5 scores usually consistent, with a standard deviation of around 0.56 on +average across outputs. For the latter, we employ a subset of the authors in a blind study to compare +the coherency of CoT vs. ToT generated passage pairs, where the order of passages is random flipped +over 100 inputs. + +Baselines. Given the creative nature of the task, both IO and CoT prompts are zero-shot. While the +former prompts the LM to directly generate a coherent passage given input constraints, the latter +prompts the LM to first make a brief plan then write the passage, i.e. the plan serves as the intermediate +thought step. We generate 10 IO and CoT samples per task. We also consider an iterative-refine +(k ≤ 5) method on top of a random IO sample for each task, where the LM is conditioned on input +constraints and the last generated passage to decide if the passage is already “perfectly coherent”, +and if not generate a refined one. + +ToT setup. We build a ToT with depth 2 (and only 1 intermediate thought step) — the LM first +generates k = 5 plans and votes for the best one (Figure 4), then similarly generate k = 5 passages +based on the best plan then vote for the best one. Here the breadth limit b = 1, as only one choice is +kept per step. A simple zero-shot vote prompt (“analyze choices below, then conclude which is most +promising for the instruction”) is used to sample 5 votes at both steps. + +Results. Figure 5(a) shows average GPT-4 scores across 100 tasks, where ToT (7.56) is deemed to +generate more coherent passages than IO (6.19) and CoT (6.93) on average. While such an automatic +metric might be noisy, Figure 5(b) confirms the finding by showing that humans prefer ToT over +CoT in 41 out of 100 passage pairs, while only prefer CoT over ToT in 21 (other 38 pairs are found +“similarly coherent”). Lastly, iterative-refine is more effective on this natural language task, where + +6 + +02550751000.20.40.6(a) Success rate with nodes visitedIO (best of k)CoT (best of k)ToT (b=1...5)1234Correct0.00.20.40.6(b) Samples failed at each stepCoTToT (b=5) Figure 4: A step of deliberate search in a randomly picked Creative Writing task. Given the input, the +LM samples 5 different plans, then votes 5 times to decide which plan is best. The majority choice is +used to consequently write the output passage with the same sample-vote procedure. + +Method + +Success Rate (%) +Letter Word Game + +IO +CoT +ToT (ours) + ++best state +-prune +-backtrack + +38.7 14 +0 +40.6 15.6 1 +60 +78 + +20 + +82.4 67.5 35 +65.4 41.5 5 +5 +54.6 20 + +Table 3: Mini Crosswords results. + +Figure 5: Creative Writing results. + +it improves IO coherency score from 6.19 to 7.67, and ToT coherency score from 7.56 to 7.91. We +believe it could be thought of as a third approach to thought generation in the ToT framework, where +new thoughts can arise from refining old thoughts instead of i.i.d. or sequentially generated. + +4.3 Mini crosswords + +In Game of 24 and Creative Writing, ToT is relatively shallow — at most 3 thought steps are needed +to reach the final output. Here we explore 5 × 5 mini crosswords as a harder search problem involving +natural language. Again, the goal is not just to solve the task, as more general crosswords can be +readily solved with specialized NLP pipelines [34] that leverages large-scale retrieval instead of LM. +Rather, we aim to explore the limit of LM as a general problem solver that explores its own thoughts +and guides its own exploration with deliberate reasoning as heuristics. + +Task setup. We scrape data from GooBix, which contains 156 games of 5 × 5 mini crosswords. As +we observe adjacent games contain similar clues, we use 20 games with indices 1, 6, · · · , 91, 96 for +testing, and games 136, 141, 146, 151, 156 for prompting. For each task, the input describes the 5 +horizontal clues and 5 vertical clues, and the output should be a board of 5 × 5 = 25 letters to solve +the crosswords. For evaluation, we consider three levels of success: the portion of correct letters (25 +per game), words (10 per game), and games. + +Baselines. We provide 5 example input-output pairs in the IO prompt, and in the CoT prompt +additionally include intermediate words in the order h1..5 then v1..5. We run each prompt for 10 +samples and average the results. + +ToT setup. We leverage a depth-first search (Algorithm 2) that keeps exploring the most promising +subsequent word clue until the state is no longer promising, then backtrack to the parent state to +explore alternative thoughts. To make search tractable, subsequent thoughts are constrained not to +change any filled words or letters, so that the ToT has at most 10 intermediate steps. For thought +generation, at each state we translate all existing thoughts (e.g. “h2.motor; h1.tasks” for the state +in Figure 6(a)) into letter constraints for remaining clues (e.g. “v1.To heap: tm ;...”) and prompt +a proposal prompt 5 times to come up with candidates for where and what to fill in the next word. +Importantly, we also prompt the LM to give a confidence level for different thoughts, and aggregate + +7 + +(cid:181)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:294)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:288)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:181)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:302)(cid:722)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:340)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:41)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:302)(cid:403)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:689)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:180)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:637)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:640)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:639)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:181)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:294)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:288)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:181)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:302)(cid:722)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:340)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:41)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:302)(cid:403)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:180)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:637)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:638)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:640)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:56)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:71)(cid:18)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:3)(cid:87)(cid:82)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:90)(cid:3)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:81)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:76)(cid:70)(cid:72)(cid:302)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)IOCoTToTIO+refineToT+refine468(a) GPT-4 coherency scoresCoT > ToTSimilarToT > CoT010203040213841(b) Human coherency comparison Figure 6: In Mini Crosswords, (a) how thoughts are proposed and aggregated in a priority queue +for depth-first search (DFS), and (b) how a state is evaluated based on the possibility of filling in +each remaining word clue, and pruned if any remaining clue is deemed not possible to fill by the LM. +Then DFS backtracks to the parent state and explore the next promising thought for clue. + +these across proposals to obtain a sorted list of next thoughts to explore (Figure 6(a)). For state +evaluations, we similarly translate each state into letter constraints for remaining clues, then evaluate +for each clue if it is possible to fill given the constraints. If any remaining clue is deemed “impossible” +to fill in (e.g. “v1. To heap: tm s ”), then the exploration of the state’s subtree is pruned and DFS +backtracks to its parent to explore the next promising thought. We limit DFS search steps to 100, and +simply render the deepest explored state (the first explored one if multiple) into the final output. + +Results. As shown in Table 3, IO and CoT prompting methods perform poorly with a word-level +success rate less than 16%, while ToT significantly improves all metrics, achieving a word-level +success rate of 60% and solving 4 out of 20 games. Such an improvement is not surprising, given IO +and CoT lack mechanisms to try different clues, make changes to decisions, or backtrack. + +Oracle and ablation studies. When outputting from the oracle best DFS state (instead of the +heuristically determined best state) per task, ToT performance is even higher and actually solves +7/20 games (Table 3, “+best state”), indicating our simple output heuristics can be readily improved. +Interestingly, sometimes when the crosswords game is actually solved, the state evaluator might still +deem some words as “impossible” and prune — possibly because 5 × 5 crosswords by design have +some rare or obselete words that GPT-4 cannot recognize2. Given the state evaluation as a pruning +heuristic is imperfect, we also explore ablating the pruning, and find the performance generally worse +(Table 3, “-prune”). However, it could actually find the correct solution for 4/20 games (though only +outputting 1 via heuristic), 3 of which are games ToT+pruning cannot solve within 100 steps. Thus, +better heuristics for DFS pruning are critical for problem solving in this case. Lastly, we confirm the +importance of backtracking by running an ablation that keeps filling the most promising clue for at +most 20 steps, allowing overwrites. This is similar to a “greedy” BFS search with breadth limit of +b = 1, and performs poorly with a word level success of only 20% (Table 3, “-backtrack”). + +5 Related Work + +Planning and decision making. Smart planning and decision making are critical to achieving +predefined goals. As they are trained on vast amount of world knowledge and human examples, LMs +are known to have already absorbed rich commonsense that makes it possible to propose reasonable +plans conditioned on problem setting and environmental states [12, 42, 37, 13, 35, 41, 40]. Our +proposed ToT approach extends existing planning formulations by considering multiple potentially +feasible plans simultaneously at each problem-solving step, and proceeding with the most promising +ones. The integration between thought sampling and value feedback organically integrates planning +and decision-making mechanisms, enabling effective search inside a solution tree. On the other hand, +traditional decision-making procedures usually require training dedicated reward and policy models +as in reinforcement learning (for example CHAI [33]), whereas we use the LM itself to provide +the value estimates for decision making. RAP [9] is a concurrent work that treats language model + +2For example, “agend” is an obsolete form of “agendum”, but GPT-4 deems it a typo for “agenda”. External + +retrieval or web interaction could augment LM for problem solving under knowledge uncertainty. + +8 + +(cid:62)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:21)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:83)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:28)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:24)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:87)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:25)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:80)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:23)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:90)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:21)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:76)(cid:81)(cid:71)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:23)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:64)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:48)(cid:88)(cid:79)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:83)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:85)(cid:88)(cid:81)(cid:86)(cid:51)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:79)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:81)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:16)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:16)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:87)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:68)(cid:74)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:74)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:38)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:86)(cid:82)(cid:73)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:73)(cid:16)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:86)(cid:76)(cid:86)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:70)(cid:92)(cid:34)(cid:12)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:91)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:90)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:89)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:39)(cid:41)(cid:54)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:270)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:264)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:670)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:54)(cid:87)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:82)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:68)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:12)(cid:383)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:301)(cid:712)(cid:349)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:670)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:712)(cid:302)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:690)(cid:270)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:230)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:270)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:39)(cid:41)(cid:54)(cid:3)(cid:50)(cid:85)(cid:71)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712) reasoning as planning with its internal world model, and proposes a MCTS-based method similar to +ToT. However, its tasks are simpler than ours, and its framework lacks the modularity to incorporate +different tree search algorithms. + +Self-reflection. Using LLMs to assess the viability of their own predictions is becoming an in- +creasingly important procedure in problem solving. [28, 20, 24] introduced the “self-reflection” +mechanism, in which LMs provide feedback to their generation candidates. [4] improves LMs code +generation accuracy by injecting feedback messages generated by the LM itself based on its code +execution results. Similarly, [17] also introduces “critic” or review steps over the actions and states, +deciding the next action to take in solving computer operation tasks. Another recent work very +relevant to ours is “self-eval guided decoding” [39]. Similar to our method, self-eval decoding +also follows a tree-search procedure with leaves sampled from stochastic beam search decoding, +which are then evaluated by LLM itself with carefully prepared self-eval prompts. Their approach +however, uses the PAL formulation [8] which represents thoughts as codes, which makes it difficult +to tackle challenging tasks like creative writing which we consider in this paper. Our Tree-of-Thought +formulation is thus more versatile and handles challenging tasks on which GPT-4 only achieves very +low accuracy with standard prompts. + +Program-guided LLM generation. Our proposal is also related to recent advancements that organize +LM’s behavior with systematic procedures [14, 44, 6, 43] or symbolic program guidance. For example, +Schlag et al. [27] embeds LMs in an algorithmic search procedure to help solve problems like question +answering step-by-step, in which the search trees are expanded by relevant paragraphs that might +provide answers. This approach however differs from ours in that trees are expanded by sampling +external paragraphs instead of the LM’s own thoughts, and there is no reflection or voting steps. +Another approach, LLM+P [18], goes one step further and delegates the actual planning process to a +classical planner. + +Classical search methods. Last but not least, our approach can be treated as a modern rendition +of classical search methods for problem solving. For example it can be considered as a heuristic +search algorithm like A* [10], in which the heuristic at each search node is provided by the LM’s self- +assessment. From this perspective, our method is also related to NeuroLogic A*esque decoding [19], +which is inspired by A* search but introduces look-ahead heuristics that are efficient for LMs to +improve the beam-search or top-k sampling decoding. This method however is constrained to +sentence generation tasks, whereas our framework are designed for complex, multi-step problem +solving guarded by value feedback. + +6 Discussion + +Limitations and future directions. Deliberate search such as ToT might not be necessary for many +existing tasks that GPT-4 already excels at (see Appendix B.1), and as an initial step this work only +explores three relatively simple tasks that challenges GPT-4 (see Appendix B.2 for some GPT-3.5 +experiment results) and calls of better search and planning abilities incorporated with LMs. However, +as we begin to deploy LMs for more real-world decision making applications (e.g. coding, data +analysis, robotics, etc.), more complex tasks could emerge and present new opportunities to study +these research questions. Also, search methods like ToT requires more resources (e.g. GPT-4 API +cost) than sampling methods in order to improve task performances, but the modular flexibility of +ToT allows users to customize such performance-cost tradeoffs, and ongoing open-source efforts [32] +should readily reduce such costs in the near future. More details about cost and efficiency are in +Appendix B.3. Lastly, this work focuses on using an off-the-shelf LM, and fine-tuning LMs using +a ToT-style high-level counterfactual decision making (e.g. deliberating over potential choices for +the next paragraph, instead of predicting the next token) might present opportunities to enhance the +problem-solving capabilities of LMs. + +Conclusion. The associative “System 1” of LMs can be beneficially augmented by a “System 2” +based on searching a tree of possible paths to the solution to a problem. The Tree of Thoughts +framework provides a way to translate classical insights about problem-solving into actionable +methods for contemporary LMs. At the same time, LMs address a weakness of these classical +methods, providing a way to solve complex problems that are not easily formalized, such as creative +writing. We see this intersection of LMs with classical approaches to AI as an exciting direction. -m 0.2!=oxr +9 -m 0.5=xr + Broader Impact -m 0.7=!xr +ToT is a framework that empowers LMs to more autonomously and intelligently make decisions +and solve problems. While current tasks are limited to reasoning and search problems, future +applications involving interaction with external environments or humans could bring potential danger, +e.g. facilitating harmful uses of LMs. On the other hand, ToT also improves the interpretability +of model decisions and the opportunity for human alignment, as the resulting representations are +readable, high-level language reasoning instead of implicit, low-level token values. -!=" +Acknowledgements -r -r -oxx +SY and KN acknowledge support from an Oracle Collaborative Research award and the National +Science Foundation under Grant No. 2239363. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommenda- +tions expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of +the National Science Foundation. SY is also supported by the Harold W. Dodds Fellowship from +Princeton. -r -x +References -= +[1] T. Brown, B. Mann, N. Ryder, M. Subbiah, J. D. Kaplan, P. Dhariwal, A. Neelakantan, P. Shyam, +G. Sastry, A. Askell, et al. Language models are few-shot learners. Advances in neural +information processing systems, 33:1877–1901, 2020. -m 5.0 +[2] C. Browne, E. J. Powley, D. Whitehouse, S. M. M. Lucas, P. I. Cowling, P. Rohlfshagen, +S. Tavener, D. P. Liebana, S. Samothrakis, and S. Colton. A survey of monte carlo tree search +methods. IEEE Transactions on Computational Intelligence and AI in Games, 4:1–43, 2012. -( -!! +[3] M. Campbell, A. J. Hoane Jr, and F.-h. Hsu. Deep blue. Artificial intelligence, 134(1-2):57–83, -.02 ) -m 0.7m +2002. -= +[4] X. Chen, M. Lin, N. Sch¨arli, and D. Zhou. Teaching large language models to self-debug, 2023. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[5] A. Chowdhery, S. Narang, J. Devlin, M. Bosma, G. Mishra, A. Roberts, P. Barham, H. W. +Chung, C. Sutton, S. Gehrmann, et al. Palm: Scaling language modeling with pathways. arXiv +preprint arXiv:2204.02311, 2022. -Average speed is the distance traveled divided by the time -required to cover the distance. +[6] A. Creswell and M. Shanahan. Faithful reasoning using large language models. arXiv preprint -Average +arXiv:2208.14271, 2022. -speed +[7] N. D. Daw, Y. Niv, and P. Dayan. Uncertainty-based competition between prefrontal and +dorsolateral striatal systems for behavioral control. Nature neuroscience, 8(12):1704–1711, +2005. -= +[8] L. Gao, A. Madaan, S. Zhou, U. Alon, P. Liu, Y. Yang, J. Callan, and G. Neubig. Pal: Program- -Distance +aided language models, 2023. -Elapsed +[9] S. Hao, Y. Gu, H. Ma, J. J. Hong, Z. Wang, D. Z. Wang, and Z. Hu. Reasoning with language - time +model is planning with world model. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.14992, 2023. -SI units for speed: meters per second (m/s) +[10] P. E. Hart, N. J. Nilsson, and B. Raphael. A formal basis for the heuristic determination of +minimum cost paths. IEEE Transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics, 4(2):100–107, +1968. doi: 10.1109/TSSC.1968.300136. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[11] P. E. Hart, N. J. Nilsson, and B. Raphael. A formal basis for the heuristic determination of +minimum cost paths. IEEE transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics, 4(2):100–107, +1968. -Example 1 Distance Run by a Jogger +[12] W. Huang, P. Abbeel, D. Pathak, and I. Mordatch. Language models as zero-shot planners: -How far does a jogger run in 1.5 hours (5400 s) if his -average speed is 2.22 m/s? +Extracting actionable knowledge for embodied agents, 2022. -Average +[13] W. Huang, F. Xia, T. Xiao, H. Chan, J. Liang, P. Florence, A. Zeng, J. Tompson, I. Mordatch, +Y. Chebotar, et al. Inner monologue: Embodied reasoning through planning with language +models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2207.05608, 2022. -speed +10 -= + [14] J. Jung, L. Qin, S. Welleck, F. Brahman, C. Bhagavatula, R. L. Bras, and Y. Choi. Maieu- +tic prompting: Logically consistent reasoning with recursive explanations. arXiv preprint +arXiv:2205.11822, 2022. -Distance +[15] D. Kahneman. Thinking, fast and slow. Macmillan, 2011. -Elapsed +[16] D. Kahneman, S. Frederick, et al. Representativeness revisited: Attribute substitution in intuitive - time +judgment. Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgment, 49(49-81):74, 2002. -Distance +[17] G. Kim, P. Baldi, and S. McAleer. Language models can solve computer tasks, 2023. -= -( -sm 22.2 +[18] B. Liu, Y. Jiang, X. Zhang, Q. Liu, S. Zhang, J. Biswas, and P. Stone. Llm+p: Empowering -= +large language models with optimal planning proficiency, 2023. -( -Average -) -)( -5400 +[19] X. Lu, S. Welleck, P. West, L. Jiang, J. Kasai, D. Khashabi, R. L. Bras, L. Qin, Y. Yu, +R. Zellers, N. A. Smith, and Y. Choi. Neurologic a*esque decoding: Constrained text generation +with lookahead heuristics. In North American Chapter of the Association for Computational +Linguistics, 2021. -s +[20] A. Madaan, N. Tandon, P. Gupta, S. Hallinan, L. Gao, S. Wiegreffe, U. Alon, N. Dziri, +S. Prabhumoye, Y. Yang, S. Welleck, B. P. Majumder, S. Gupta, A. Yazdanbakhsh, and P. Clark. +Self-refine: Iterative refinement with self-feedback, 2023. -= +[21] A. Newell, J. C. Shaw, and H. A. Simon. Report on a general problem solving program. In IFIP -speed +congress, volume 256, page 64. Pittsburgh, PA, 1959. -)( -Elapsed -12000 -m +[22] A. Newell, H. A. Simon, et al. Human problem solving. Prentice-Hall, 1972. - time +[23] OpenAI. Gpt-4 technical report. ArXiv, abs/2303.08774, 2023. -) +[24] D. Paul, M. Ismayilzada, M. Peyrard, B. Borges, A. Bosselut, R. West, and B. Faltings. Refiner: - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +Reasoning feedback on intermediate representations, 2023. -Average velocity is the displacement divided by the elapsed -time. +[25] A. Radford, K. Narasimhan, T. Salimans, I. Sutskever, et al. Improving language understanding -Average +by generative pre-training. OpenAI blog, 2018. - velocity +[26] A. Radford, J. Wu, R. Child, D. Luan, D. Amodei, I. Sutskever, et al. Language models are -= +unsupervised multitask learners. OpenAI blog, 1(8):9, 2019. -Displaceme -Elapsed +[27] I. Schlag, S. Sukhbaatar, A. Celikyilmaz, W. tau Yih, J. Weston, J. Schmidhuber, and X. Li. -nt - time +Large language model programs, 2023. -r -v +[28] N. Shinn, B. Labash, and A. Gopinath. Reflexion: an autonomous agent with dynamic memory -= +and self-reflection, 2023. -r -r -xx -" -t -t -" +[29] D. Silver, J. Schrittwieser, K. Simonyan, I. Antonoglou, A. Huang, A. Guez, T. Hubert, L. Baker, +M. Lai, A. Bolton, et al. Mastering the game of go without human knowledge. nature, 550 +(7676):354–359, 2017. -o +[30] S. A. Sloman. The empirical case for two systems of reasoning. Psychological bulletin, 119(1): -o +3, 1996. -= +[31] K. E. Stanovich. Who is rational? Studies of individual differences in reasoning. Psychology -r -x -! -t -! +Press, 1999. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[32] H. Touvron, T. Lavril, G. Izacard, X. Martinet, M.-A. Lachaux, T. Lacroix, B. Rozi`ere, N. Goyal, +E. Hambro, F. Azhar, et al. Llama: Open and efficient foundation language models. arXiv +preprint arXiv:2302.13971, 2023. -Example 2 The World’s Fastest Jet-Engine Car +[33] S. Verma, J. Fu, S. Yang, and S. Levine. Chai: A chatbot ai for task-oriented dialogue with +offline reinforcement learning. In Proceedings of the 2022 Conference of the North American +Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, +pages 4471–4491, 2022. -Andy Green in the car ThrustSSC set a world record of -341.1 m/s in 1997. To establish such a record, the driver -makes two runs through the course, one in each direction, -to nullify wind effects. From the data, determine the average -velocity for each run. +11 - 2.2 Speed and Velocity + [34] E. Wallace, N. Tomlin, A. Xu, K. Yang, E. Pathak, M. Ginsberg, and D. Klein. Automated -r -v +crossword solving. arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.09665, 2022. -= +[35] L. Wang, W. Xu, Y. Lan, Z. Hu, Y. Lan, R. K.-W. Lee, and E.-P. Lim. Plan-and-solve prompting: -r -x -! -t -! +Improving zero-shot chain-of-thought reasoning by large language models, 2023. -= +[36] X. Wang, J. Wei, D. Schuurmans, Q. Le, E. Chi, and D. Zhou. Self-consistency improves chain -1609 -+ -4.740 +of thought reasoning in language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2203.11171, 2022. -m -s +[37] Z. Wang, S. Cai, A. Liu, X. Ma, and Y. Liang. Describe, explain, plan and select: Interactive -+= +planning with large language models enables open-world multi-task agents, 2023. -339 +[38] J. Wei, X. Wang, D. Schuurmans, M. Bosma, E. Chi, Q. Le, and D. Zhou. Chain of thought +prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2201.11903, 2022. -sm5. +[39] Y. Xie, K. Kawaguchi, Y. Zhao, X. Zhao, M.-Y. Kan, J. He, and Q. Xie. Decomposition -r -v +enhances reasoning via self-evaluation guided decoding, 2023. -= +[40] S. Yang, O. Nachum, Y. Du, J. Wei, P. Abbeel, and D. Schuurmans. Foundation models for -r -x -" -t -" +decision making: Problems, methods, and opportunities, 2023. -= +[41] S. Yao, J. Zhao, D. Yu, N. Du, I. Shafran, K. Narasimhan, and Y. Cao. ReAct: Synergizing -1609 -! -4.695 +reasoning and acting in language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.03629, 2022. -m -s +[42] S. Zhang, Z. Chen, Y. Shen, M. Ding, J. B. Tenenbaum, and C. Gan. Planning with large +language models for code generation. In The Eleventh International Conference on Learning +Representations, 2023. URL https://openreview.net/forum?id=Lr8cOOtYbfL. -!= +[43] D. Zhou, N. Sch¨arli, L. Hou, J. Wei, N. Scales, X. Wang, D. Schuurmans, C. Cui, O. Bousquet, +Q. Le, et al. Least-to-most prompting enables complex reasoning in large language models. +arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.10625, 2022. -342 +[44] X. Zhu, J. Wang, L. Zhang, Y. Zhang, R. Gan, J. Zhang, and Y. Yang. Solving math word +problem via cooperative reasoning induced language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.16257, +2022. -sm7. +12 - 2.2 Speed and Velocity + A Code, Prompts, Trajectories -The instantaneous velocity indicates how fast -the car moves and the direction of motion at each -instant of time. +All code is available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm. -r -v +All prompts are available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm/ +tree/master/src/tot/prompts. -= +Trajectories are available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm/ +tree/master/logs. -lim -t -0 -"! +B Additional Experiment Results -r -x -! -t -! +Given the motivation of exploring and extending the capability frontier of language models, our +experiments in the main paper have focused on a setup with the state-of-the-art language model +(GPT-4), and three hard tasks invented to challenge it. Here, we report additional experiments with +weaker LLM or easier tasks, and discuss cost and efficiency. - 2.3 Acceleration +GSM8K StrategyQA -The notion of acceleration emerges when a change in -velocity is combined with the time during which the -change occurs. +GPT-4 GPT-3.5 - 2.3 Acceleration +GPT-4 GPT-3.5 -DEFINITION OF AVERAGE ACCELERATION +51 +IO +CoT 86 +90 +ToT -r -a +73 +82 +83 -= +7.3% +IO +CoT 4.0% +ToT -r -r -vv -" -t -t -" +74% 19% -o +6% +3% -o +6.19 +IO +CoT 6.93 +7.56 +ToT -= +4.47 +5.16 +6.62 -r -v -! -t -! +Table 4: New tasks with +zero-shot ToT and GPT-4. - 2.3 Acceleration +Table 5: Game of 24 with +GPT-4 vs GPT-3.5. -Example 3 Acceleration and Increasing Velocity +Table 6: Creative Writing with +GPT-4 vs. GPT-3.5. -Determine the average acceleration of the plane. +B.1 Extension to new tasks (GSM8k, StrategyQA) with zero-shot ToT -sm0=ovr +While more common NLP tasks might be too easy for GPT-4 and do not require ToT (which is why +we considered harder new tasks), we believe applying ToT to new tasks could be straightforward. +For example, we implemented a simple and generic zero-shot ToT-BFS similar to creative writing +(sample 5 problem solving strategies then vote for the best one; then sample 5 solutions based on the +best strategy then vote for the best one) for GSM8K and StrategyQA with few extra lines of code: -=vr +# define the answer format of new tasks +gsm8k_format = ‘"the answer is n" where n is a number’ +strategyqa_format = ‘either "the answer is yes" or "the answer is no"’ -260 +# define zero-shot io prompting +standard_prompt = ‘Answer the following question with {format}: {input}’ -km +# define thought format for zero-shot cot and zero-shot tot +cot_prompt = ‘‘‘Answer the following question: {input} -h +Make a strategy then write. Your output should be of the following format: -s 0=ot +Strategy: +Your strategy about how to answer the question. -s 29=t +Answer: +Your answer to the question. It should end with {format}. +’’’ -r -a +# define zero-shot voting used for zero-shot tot +vote_prompt = ‘‘‘Given an instruction and several choices, +decide which choice is most promising. +Analyze each choice in detail, then conclude in the last line +"The best choice is {s}", where s the integer id of the choice. +’’’ -= +13 -r -r -vv -! -t -t -! + We evaluated on a subset of 100 random GSM8K test and StrategyQA dev questions. As shown +in Table 4 and as expected, ToT improves over CoT on both tasks (but only slightly, given GPT-4 ++ CoT is already very good on such tasks, and StrategyQA’s bottleneck is external knowledge, not +reasoning). Considering computational costs, it is more suitable to try smaller LLMs + ToT for +traditional NLP tasks, or GPT-4 + ToT for hard tasks that challenge GPT-4 + CoT’s reasoning. -o +B.2 Extension to new LMs (GPT-3.5) -260 +To understand how ToT works with other LLMs, we also ran GPT-3.5-turbo for Creative Writing +(Table 6) and Game of 24 (Table 5). On both tasks, “ToT > CoT > IO” remains true for GPT-3.5. On +Creative Writing, we find GPT-3.5+ToT outperform GPT-4+IO, and similar to GPT-4+CoT, which +suggests ToT could also work well on weaker language models. -o +On Game of 24 (we changed 1-shot proposal prompt to 3-shot to make it work), GPT-3.5+ToT’s +19% is far worse than GPT-4+ToT’s 74%. To further understand the importance of generation +vs. evaluation, we ran GPT-4 generation + GPT-3.5 evaluation (64%) and GPT-3.5 generation + +GPT-4 evaluation (31%). This suggests the game’s bottleneck is thought generation, and different +generation/evaluation language models might attain decent results while reducing costs. -= +B.3 Cost and efficiency -km -km0h -! -s 0s 29 -! +Running ToT requires significantly more computations than IO or CoT prompting. For example, in +Game of 24 (Table 7 below), solving a problem with ToT requires 5.5k completion tokens, close to +100 CoT trials (6.7k tokens). But the performance of ToT is better than best of 100 independent CoT +trials. -h +Game of 24 -+= +Generate/Prompt tokens Cost per case -0.9 +Success -h +IO (best of 100) +CoT (best of 100) +ToT -km -s +1.8k / 1.0k +6.7k / 2.2k +5.5k / 1.4k - 2.3 Acceleration +$0.13 +$0.47 +$0.74 +Table 7: Cost analysis on Game of 24. - 2.3 Acceleration +33% +49% +74% -Example 3 Acceleration and Decreasing -Velocity +On Creative Writing (Table 8 below), we found ToT takes around 5x completion tokens and money +cost, which is intuitive as b = 5 and most tokens are generated passages. -r -a +Creative Writing Generate/Prompt tokens Cost per case -= +IO +CoT +ToT -r -r -vv -! -t -t -! +0.9k / 0.4k +0.9k / 0.4k +4k / 2.9k -o +$0.06 +$0.07 +$0.32 -o +Table 8: Cost analysis on Game of 24. -= +So completing Game of 24 and Creative Writing’s main ToT experiments cost around 0.74 × 100 + +0.32 × 100 = 106 dollars. Crosswords’ DFS experiments should be also within 100 dollars. In +general, cost and efficiency of ToT highly depend on the prompts and search algorithms used, and +could require 5-100 times more generated tokens than CoT. Some actionable insights: -sm13 +• We recommend using ToT on tasks requiring deliberate reasoning, on which CoT struggles. +• Flexibility of ToT allows some performance-cost tradeoff, e.g., change beam size or vote +number in BFS, few-shot vs. zero-shot prompting, GPT-3.5 vs. GPT-4, etc. One could +configure the setup based on some resource constraints or performance goal. -sm28 -! -s 9s 12 -! +• There is much space for improving efficiency, e.g., BFS could early stop when solution is -!= +found, or trim down beam size to when some thoughts are ”impossible”. -2sm0.5 +• We believe that more computation is indeed required in order for the model to achieve +stronger intelligence, and this should not become a blocking issue as in the long run, (open- +source) LMs will become much cheaper and more efficient. It is also a great direction how +to better train/finetune LMs for thought generation and/or evaluation. - 2.3 Acceleration +14 diff --git a/q58/random_k4/question.json b/q58/random_k4/question.json index e5e3db2a12cff4d1a774574c6b3a4ae109e5a48f..97521f73d344ef741bbc9d414af9225192ba3be2 100644 --- a/q58/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q58/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "indonesiamobilemarketresearch-ag-150106055934-conversion-gate02_95.pdf", - "web_d3545b20cb487e4b.pdf", - "web_8198931726741d61.pdf", - "web_2c8b6d1a0ca91c7b.pdf", - "da82ba1659f104383b88b82d6ffaa0cd0c0d177b.pdf" + "web_82328a4273fef79b.pdf", + "resize_r2_2.pdf", + "resize_r2_23.pdf", + "web_74331e85a10815bd.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q58/random_k4/random_1.md b/q58/random_k4/random_1.md index 3b59653be960a7700f9cff39752b4e24bce89425..6474018d749f25127eab2ee8e778279d7aa478d0 100644 --- a/q58/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q58/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,3031 +1,908 @@ -FOR RELEASE JULY 26, 2018 +Investor Presentation +Q1 FY23 -BY Cary Funk and Meg Hefferon + Safe Harbor Statement -FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: +This presentation may contain forward-looking statements for which there are risks, uncertainties, and assumptions. +Forward-looking statements may include any statements regarding strategies or plans for future operations; any statements +concerning new features, enhancements or upgrades to our existing applications or plans for future applications; any projections +of revenues, gross margins, earnings, or other financial items; and any statements of expectation or belief. Forward-looking +statements are based only on currently available information and our current beliefs, expectations, and assumptions regarding the +future of our business, future plans and strategies, projections, anticipated events and trends, the economy, and other future +conditions. Because forward-looking statements relate to the future, they are subject to inherent uncertainties, risks, and changes +in circumstances that are difficult to predict and many of which are outside of our control. Our actual results and financial condition +may differ materially from those indicated in the forward-looking statements, and therefore you should not rely on any +forward-looking statements that we may make. Further information on risks that could affect Workday’s results is included in our +filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission which are available on the Workday investor relations webpage: +www.workday.com/company/investor_relations.php -Cary Funk, Director, Science and Society Research -Haley Nolan, Communications Assistant +Workday assumes no obligation for, and does not intend to update, any forward-looking statements. Any unreleased services, +features, functionality or enhancements referenced in any Workday document, roadmap, blog, our website, press release or +public statement that are not currently available are subject to change at Workday’s discretion and may not be delivered as +planned or at all. -202.419.4372 +Customers who purchase Workday services should make their purchase decisions based upon services, features, and functions +that are currently available. -www.pewresearch.org + Use of Non-GAAP Measures -RECOMMENDED CITATION +In addition to financial results presented in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), this presentation includes certain +non-GAAP financial measures of financial performance. These non-GAAP financial measures are in addition to, and not a substitute for or +superior to, measures of financial performance prepared in accordance with GAAP, and may be different from non-GAAP financial measures +used by other companies. In addition, these non-GAAP measures have limitations in that they do not reflect all of the amounts associated with +Workday’s results of operations as determined in accordance with GAAP. Reconciliations of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most +directly comparable financial measures are contained in the Appendix to this presentation. A reconciliation of our forward outlook for non-GAAP +operating margin with our forward-looking GAAP operating margin is not available without unreasonable efforts as the quantification of share- +based compensation expense, which is excluded from our non-GAAP operating margin, requires additional inputs such as the number of shares +granted and market prices that are not ascertainable. -Pew Research Center, July 2018, “Public Views of Gene -Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” + Workday at a Glance - 2 + Workday +by the Numbers -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$105B+ -About Pew Research Center +Market Opportunity -Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes -and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center conducts -public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social -science research. It studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and -technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social -and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew -Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. +Enterprise Management Cloud +For Finance, HR, Planning, Spend Management and +Analytics -© Pew Research Center 2018 +9,500+ Global Customers +Operating across 175+ Countries -www.pewresearch.org +$4.79B 22% YoY Growth - 3 +Trailing Twelve Month Subscription Revenue1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Serving 50%+ of the Fortune 500 +Including 70%+ of the top 50 Fortune 500 companies -Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It -Would Be Used +$7.97B 21% YoY Growth -Americans’ views on the -appropriateness of changing -a baby’s genetic -characteristics depend in -large part on the intended -purpose and on whether or -not human embryos would be -used in testing these -techniques. A majority of -Americans support the idea -of using gene editing with the -goal of delivering direct -health benefits for babies, but -at the same time, a majority -considers the use of such -techniques to boost a baby’s -intelligence something that -takes technology “too far.” +24-Month Subscription Revenue Backlog2 -A majority of U.S. adults say changing a baby’s genes -to treat a serious congenital disease is appropriate +60M+ Global Users +97% Customer Satisfaction3 -% of U.S. adults who say changing a baby’s genetic characteristics for each of -the following reasons is … +$1.64B 30% Margin -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Trailing Twelve Month Operating Cash Flow1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +1 For the trailing twelve months ended 4.30.22 +2 For the period ended 4.30.22 +3 Based on a survey conducted by Workday of Named Support Contacts in April 2021 -About seven-in-ten Americans (72%) say that changing an unborn baby’s genetic characteristics to -treat a serious disease or condition that the baby would have at birth is an appropriate use of -medical technology, while 27% say this would be taking technology too far. A somewhat smaller -share of Americans say gene editing to reduce a baby’s risk of developing a serious disease or -condition over their lifetime is appropriate (60% say this, while 38% say it would be taking -medical technology too far). But just 19% of Americans say it would be appropriate to use gene -editing to make a baby more intelligent; eight-in-ten (80%) say this would be taking medical -technology too far. +15,900+ Employees Worldwide +Offices in 30+ Countries -These are some of the findings from a new Pew Research Center survey conducted April 23-May 6, -2018, among 2,537 U.S. adults. + Workday Enterprise Management Cloud -www.pewresearch.org +A unique approach to enterprise software - 4 +Best-in-Class +Applications -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Elevate Your +Enterprise -While public discussions about potentially altering a baby’s genetic makeup have been ongoing for -decades, the development of a new gene-splicing technology – known as CRISPR – has accelerated -the debate and brought new urgency to better understanding public opinion about gene editing as -well as the broader social, ethical and policy implications ahead.1 +Enterprise +Management Cloud +Platform +The Power to Adapt -Previous Pew Research Center surveys have tracked public opinion about gene editing using -different question wording and, in some cases, different polling methodologies. As such, those -findings are not directly comparable to this new survey. However, the broad pattern – that public -support for gene editing varies with its intended purpose – is consistent with a 2016 study that -explored public views about the possibility of using gene editing to “enhance” a baby’s health over -the course of their lifetime and a 2014 survey.2 +The Workday +Experience -Regardless of the intended purpose of gene -editing, experts acknowledge that further -development of these techniques will likely -involve testing in human embryos. In August -2017, research scientists in the United States -reported the first successful use of gene editing -in human embryos to eliminate an inherited -condition. When asked to consider the -possibility that the development of gene -editing would involve testing on human -embryos, one third of Americans (33%) say -this would be appropriate while about two- -thirds (65%) say this would be taking medical -technology too far. +A Partner Like +No Other -65% of Americans say if gene editing -relies on embryonic testing, it would -take technology too far +Recognized as a +Cloud ERP Market Leader +FIN, Planning and HCM -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … +Over 9,500 customers +globally supporting more than +55 million workers -Taking medical -technology too far +97% Customer +Satisfaction -Appropriate use of -medical technology + Serving +Organizations +of all Sizes +and Across +Industries -65 + Addressing a Large and Expanding TAM -33 +New Markets Have +Expanded TAM -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” +HCM +Opportunity -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$38B -The 2016 Pew Research Center survey using -different question wording found that most adults said testing on human embryos to develop gene -editing would make gene editing less acceptable for them. +Core HCM • Payroll and +Workforce Management • Talent +Management • Employee +Experience -1 The National Academies of Sciences and the National Academy of Medicine launched a consensus study and at least two international -summits to consider these issues. -2 Other research on public views of gene editing has also shown that the public distinguishes its intended purpose. Scheufele et al. (2017) -found that Americans were more supportive of gene editing applications that treat medical conditions than those aimed at enhancing health. -Similarly, Whitman (2018) also found stronger public support for gene editing to cure disease than gene editing to make people stronger or -more intelligent. +FINS+ +Opportunity -www.pewresearch.org +$67B - 5 +Financial Management • Spend +Management • FIN-Planning • +Industry Solutions • Platform • +Accounting Center • Analytics +and Reporting -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$39B -Several patterns emerge in -public opinion about gene -editing in these varying -contexts. There are large -differences in acceptance of -gene editing between the -highly religious and less -religious. In addition, there is -a gender gap in views about -gene editing, with women -less accepting of it than men. -People with higher levels of -science knowledge and -greater familiarity with gene -editing also tend to be more -accepting of it. +Total Addressable Market +In 2012 at IPO 1 -Religious Americans are -more likely to view gene -editing negatively +IDC and Workday Estimates +1 TAM as of 8.30.2012 +2 TAM as of 9.21.2021 -Highly religious Americans are more likely to see gene -editing for babies as taking medical technology too far +$105B+ -% of U.S. adults in each religious commitment group who say changing a -baby’s genetic characteristics for each of the following reasons is … +Total Addressable Market +Current -Taking medical technology too far - -Appropriate use of medical technology - -Treat a serious disease or condition the baby would have at birth -Among those ___ on the religious commitment index - -High - -Medium - -Low - -40 - -57 - -27 - -18 - -72 - -82 - -Reduce risk of a serious disease or condition that could occur over their -lifetime - -High - -53 - -Medium - -Low - -41 - -27 - -Make the baby more intelligent - -46 - -58 - -73 - -6 - -High - -93 - -82 - -72 - -18 - -Low - -Medium - -Americans who are high in -religious commitment – that -is, those who attend religious -services at least weekly, pray -at least daily and say that -religion is very important in -their lives – are less inclined -than those with either -medium or low levels of -religious commitment to say -that gene editing is an appropriate use of medical technology.3 For example, those high in religious -commitment are closely divided over whether it is appropriate to use gene editing to reduce a - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. See Methodology for details -on index of religious commitment. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -28 - -3 A person is considered to have a high level of religious commitment if they attend religious services at least weekly, pray at least daily and -say religion is very important in their life. People are classified as having low commitment if they say religion is not too or not at all important -in their lives and that they seldom or never attend religious services or pray. All others are classified as having medium commitment. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 6 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -baby’s risk of disease later in life; 46% say this is appropriate, while 53% consider it taking -technology too far. In contrast, roughly three-quarters of those low in religious commitment (73%) -say gene editing to reduce a baby’s risk of developing a serious disease or condition is an -appropriate use of medical technology. And, while a 57% majority of those high in religious -commitment say gene editing to treat a congenital disorder in a baby is an appropriate use of -medical technology, a much larger share of those with low religious commitment (82%) say this is -appropriate. - -Those with high levels of religiosity also stand -out when considering the possibility that -development of gene editing would entail -testing on human embryos. An overwhelming -majority of those high in religious -commitment (87%) say this would be taking -medical technology too far; just 11% of this -group says this would be appropriate. In -contrast, 55% of those low in religious -commitment say that development of gene -editing techniques that require testing on -human embryos would be an appropriate use -of medical technology. - -The differences by religiosity in views on the -appropriateness of gene editing tend to persist -even when statistically controlling for other -factors such as gender, race and ethnicity, age, -and education that are related to religious -beliefs and practices. See Appendix for details. - -Most highly religious Americans -consider testing gene editing on human -embryos to be taking technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … - -Taking medical technology too far -Appropriate use of medical technology - -U.S. adults - -65 - -33 - -Among those ___ on the religious commitment index - -High - -87 - -Medium - -69 - -11 - -29 - -Low - -44 - -55 - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. See -Methodology for details on index of religious commitment. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 7 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -There are also differences in views about gene -editing by religious affiliation, particularly if -such techniques would involve embryonic -testing. Just 11% of white evangelical -Protestants say that if development of gene -editing techniques required testing on human -embryos, it would be an appropriate use of -medical technology. - -By contrast, about half of the religiously -unaffiliated (52%), including 79% of atheists -and 57% of agnostics, say that embryonic -testing to develop gene editing techniques -would be an appropriate use of medical -technology. - -See the Appendix for other views about gene -editing by religious affiliation. - -White evangelicals especially likely to -say gene editing involving embryonic -testing takes technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say that if development of gene -editing required testing on human embryos, it would -be … - -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate use -of medical -technology -33% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -65% - -21 -11 -31 -25 -30 -29 -27 -52 -79 -57 -42 - -34 -29 -28 - -78 -88 -67 -72 -69 -70 -73 -47 -21 -42 -57 - -64 -68 -71 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 8 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Men are more accepting than women of using gene editing to change a baby’s genetic -makeup - -Men are more inclined than -women to view gene editing as -an appropriate use of medical -technology, regardless of its -intent. About two-thirds of -men (65%) believe that gene -editing to reduce a baby’s risk -of developing a serious -disease later in life is an -appropriate use of medical -technology, compared with -54% of women. And men -(76%) are more supportive -than women (68%) of using -gene editing to treat a -congenital disorder. - -Similarly, more men (43%) -than women (24%) are -accepting of gene editing -technology if it required -embryonic testing to develop. - -Men are more likely than women to view gene editing -for babies as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say changing a baby’s genetic characteristics for each -of the following reasons is an appropriate use of medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic characteristics ... - -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Women - -Men - -68 - -76 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -54 - -65 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -13 - -24 - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -If it required testing on human embryos -to develop these techniques - -24 - -43 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Women tend to have higher -levels of religious commitment, on average, but differences by gender tend to hold even when -controlling for religiosity and other factors in statistical models. See the Appendix for details. - -Previous Pew Research Center surveys in 2016 and 2014, while not directly comparable due to -different polling methods and question wording, have also found that women tend to be less -accepting than men when it comes to gene editing for babies. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 9 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Americans with high levels of science knowledge are more likely to view gene editing in a -positive light - -People high in science -knowledge – based on a nine- -item index – tend to be more -accepting of using gene -editing for babies.4 Some -86% of those with high -science knowledge believe it -is appropriate to use gene -editing to treat a congenital -disorder, compared with 58% -of those with low science -knowledge. And, 71% of those -with high science knowledge -say it is appropriate to use -gene editing to reduce a -baby’s risk of disease that -would occur later in life, -compared with 49% of those -with low science knowledge.5 - -However, few Americans say -it is appropriate to use gene -editing to make a baby more -intelligent, regardless of their -level of science knowledge. - -Those with high science knowledge are more inclined -to see gene editing techniques as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following is an appropriate use of -medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic -characteristics ... -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Among those with ___ science -knowledge -Medium - -Low - -High - -58 - -86 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -49 - -71 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -21 - -24 - -If it required testing on human -embryos to develop these techniques - -26 - -50 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -See Methodology for details on index of science knowledge. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Judgments on the appropriateness of gene editing also follow a similar pattern by education level, -which is closely linked with science knowledge. Those with a postgraduate degree are more - -4 See the Methodology for details on the science knowledge index. -5 These findings are in keeping with a 2017 study by Scheufele et al., which found Americans’ attitudes about gene editing varied depending -on their knowledge level about genetics and gene editing, as well as their religiosity. A 2013 study by Allum et al. in the United Kingdom found -the effect of science knowledge on support for using genetic testing to screen for serious diseases in an unborn baby was conditional on -religious service attendance. In this survey, there is a tendency for the effects of science knowledge to be conditional with levels of religiosity -in views about the use of gene editing to reduce the risk of disease and if it would require testing on human embryos. For example, among -people with high religious commitment, science knowledge is not related to views on the appropriateness of gene editing for babies to reduce -the risk of disease that could occur over their lifetime. This interaction between religious commitment and science knowledge holds even after -controlling for other factors in statistical models but does not occur for other views about gene editing. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 10 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -accepting of gene editing for treating or reducing the risk of a disease than those with a high school -degree or less. - -Americans who report familiarity with gene editing are more inclined to see it as -appropriate - -People who say they have -heard at least a little about -gene editing that can be used -to change a baby’s genetic -characteristics are more -likely than those who have -heard nothing at all to say -gene editing would be -appropriate in each of the -circumstances considered in -this survey. - -A Pew Research Center -survey in 2016 found a -similar tendency for those -who report familiarity with -gene editing to express more -interest in and acceptance of -using these technologies to -enhance a baby’s health over -the course of their lifetime. - -Those familiar with gene editing are more inclined to -see different uses as appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following is an appropriate use of -medical technology - -Changing a baby's genetic -characteristics ... - -To treat a serious disease/condition the -baby would have at birth - -Among those who have heard ___ -about gene editing -A little -71 - -Nothing at all - -A lot - -64 - -To reduce risk of a serious disease/condition -that could occur over their lifetime - -52 - -65 - -To make the baby more intelligent - -13 - -31 - -Gene editing to change a baby's -genetic characteristics ... - -If it required testing on human embryos -to develop these techniques - -24 - -49 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 11 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Although gene editing for babies is still in development, a separate April 2018 survey found that -about half of Americans (52%) believe it is likely that within the next 50 years, we will be able to -eliminate almost all birth defects by manipulating the genes of an embryo before a baby is born. In -the current survey, as people think about a future with possible widespread use of gene editing to -change a baby’s genetic makeup, more anticipate negative than positive effects on society. - -Specifically, a majority of -Americans (58%) believe -gene editing will very likely -lead to increased inequality -because it will only be -available to the wealthy. -Some 54% of Americans -anticipate a slippery slope, -saying it’s very likely that -“even if gene editing is used -appropriately in some cases, -others will use these -techniques in ways that are -morally unacceptable.” And, -46% expect it is very likely -that gene editing techniques -will be used before we fully -understand how they affect -people’s health. - -Larger shares of Americans believe negative effects of -widespread use of gene editing are very likely - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following would be ____ to occur if gene -editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available - -Very likely - -Fairly likely - -Not too likely - -Not at all likely - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy - -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways - -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -58 - -29 - -9 - -4 - -54 - -32 - -9 - -3 - -46 - -38 - -12 - -3 - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -18 - -42 - -30 - -8 - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -16 - -48 - -27 +2 8 -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Far smaller shares see -positive outcomes as very -likely if gene editing for -babies were to become widely available. Roughly two-in-ten Americans (18%) say it is very likely -that development of these techniques will pave the way for new medical advances that benefit -society as a whole. Another 42% say this is fairly likely to occur, while 38% consider this not too or -not at all likely. Just 16% see the widespread use of gene editing as very likely to help people live -longer and better quality lives. About half (48%) say this is fairly likely, while 34% say this -outcome is not too or not at all likely. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 12 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Women are more inclined -than men to expect negative -effects if gene editing -becomes widely available, in -keeping with gender -differences over acceptance -of gene editing. For example, -larger shares of women than -men say this technology will -lead to an increase in -inequality as it will only be -available for the wealthy -(63% say this is very likely vs. -52% of men) or say it will be -used in morally unacceptable -ways (57% vs. 51%). And -although only minorities of -men and women see positive -effects as very likely, men are -somewhat more inclined to -anticipate positive outcomes. - -More women than men anticipate negative effects of -gene editing - -% of U.S. adults who say each of the following would be very likely to occur if -gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely -available - -POSITIVE OUTCOMES - -Women - -Men - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -14 - -23 - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -13 - -19 - -NEGATIVE OUTCOMES - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy - -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways - -52 - -63 - -51 - -57 - -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -42 - -49 - -0 - -20 - -40 - -60 - -80 - -100 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Expectations also vary by -self-reported familiarity with -gene editing. Those who have -heard a lot about gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics are more inclined to -anticipate positive outcomes from its widespread use. Some 36% of this group thinks it is very -likely that the widespread availability of gene editing would pave the way for new medical -advances that are beneficial to society, compared with about half as many of those who have heard -a little or nothing about gene editing (16%). - -However, those most familiar with gene editing are more likely than those with no familiarity to -also anticipate downsides. About two-thirds of those who have heard a lot about gene editing -(64%) say it is very likely that widespread availability of gene editing will increase inequality -because the technology will primarily be available only for the wealthy, compared with 53% of -those who have heard nothing about using gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics. -And, 65% of those who have heard a lot about gene editing think it’s very likely that others will use - -www.pewresearch.org - - 13 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -these techniques in morally unacceptable ways, while 54% of those who have heard a little and -52% of those who have heard nothing about gene editing say this. - -Americans who are more familiar with gene editing are more inclined to anticipate -positive as well as negative effects from widespread use of gene editing - -% of U.S. adults in each group who say each of the following would be very likely to occur if gene editing to change a -baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available - -POSITIVE OUTCOMES - -Will pave way for new medical -advances that benefit society - -Will help people live longer and -better quality lives - -NEGATIVE OUTCOMES - -Inequality will increase as it will -only be available for the wealthy -Even if used appropriately by -some, others will use in morally -unacceptable ways -Will be used before we fully -understand effects on health - -Heard a lot about -gene editing - -Heard a little about -gene editing - -Heard nothing at all -about gene editing - -36 - -34 - -16 - -13 - -16 - -14 - -64 - -65 - -59 - -54 - -53 - -52 - -54 - -46 - -43 - -Note: Respondents who gave other responses or who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -A similar pattern occurs with levels of science knowledge. A larger share of people with high -science knowledge anticipate positive outcomes from the widespread availability of gene editing -than those with low science knowledge. At the same time, those with high science knowledge are at -least equally likely as those with low science knowledge to think negative effects from the -widespread availability of gene editing are very likely. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 14 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -The American public also -tends to be skeptical about -whether medical experts fully -comprehend the health -consequences of gene editing. -A 36% minority of Americans -believe that medical -researchers understand the -health effects of gene editing -for babies either very (7%) or -fairly well (29%), while 62% -say medical researchers do -not understand the health -effects at all or not too well. - -36% of Americans say medical researchers understand -the health effects of gene editing at least fairly well - -% of U.S. adults who say medical researchers understand the health risks and -benefits of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics … - -Very well - -Fairly well - -Not too well - -Not at all well - -7 - -29 - -45 - -17 - -Note: Respondents who did not give an answer are not shown. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Familiarity with gene editing is linked with beliefs about medical researchers’ understanding of it. -About half of those who have heard a lot about gene editing for babies (51%) say that medical -researchers understand the health effects of gene editing for babies at least fairly well, compared -with three-in-ten of those who have heard nothing at all (30%). However, level of science -knowledge based on a nine-item index is not related to views on this issue; 36% of those with high -science knowledge and 40% of those with low science knowledge believe that medical researchers -understand the health effects of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics at least fairly well. - -There are no or only modest differences on this question by gender or religious commitment. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 15 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER + With a Leading Position in HCM -Acknowledgments +~$38B -This report is made possible by The Pew Charitable Trusts. This report is a collaborative effort -based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. Find related reports online at: -pewresearch.org/science. +HCM Market Opportunity -Primary research team +HCM Provides Significant Runway -Cary Funk, Director, Science and Society Research -Brian Kennedy, Research Associate -Meg Hefferon, Research Assistant -Mark Strauss, Writer/Editor -Isadora Milanez, Intern +International -Editorial and graphic design +Expanding Share of Wallet -Mark Strauss, Writer/Editor -Shannon Greenwood, Copy Editor -Margaret Porteus, Information Graphics Designer +Medium Enterprise -Communications and web publishing +U.S. Federal -Haley Nolan, Communications Assistant -Sara Atske, Assistant Digital Producer +Future Innovation -www.pewresearch.org +M&A - 16 +IDC and Workday estimates. Includes core HCM, Payroll, Recruiting, Benefits, Workforce Analytics, Compensation, Employee Engagement Surveys, Help, Journeys, Learning, Performance, Scheduling, Time Tracking, and Workforce Planning -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Methodology - -Margins of error - -This report is drawn from a survey conducted as -part of the American Trends Panel (ATP), a -nationally representative panel of randomly -selected U.S. adults living in households -recruited from landline and cellphone random- -digit-dial (RDD) surveys. Panelists participate -via monthly self-administered web surveys. -Panelists who do not have internet access are -provided a tablet and wireless internet -connection. The panel, which was created by -Pew Research Center, is being managed by GfK. - -Data in this report are drawn from the panel -wave conducted April 23-May 6, 2018, among -2,537 respondents. The margin of sampling error -for the full sample of 2,537 respondents is plus -or minus 2.8 percentage points. - -Members of the ATP were recruited from several -large, national landline and cellphone RDD -surveys conducted in English and Spanish. At -the end of each survey, respondents were invited -to join the panel. The first group of panelists was -recruited from the 2014 Political Polarization -and Typology Survey, conducted Jan. 23-March -16, 2014. Of the 10,013 adults interviewed, 9,809 -were invited to take part in the panel and a total -of 5,338 agreed to participate.6 - -Sample size -2,537 - -Margin of error -in percentage -points -+/- 2.8 - -U.S. adults - -Men -Women - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Religious commitment index -High -Medium -Low - -Religious affiliation -NET Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -NET Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -NET Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -1,272 -1,265 - -1,519 -412 -421 - -440 -1,291 -566 - -1,086 -349 -282 -283 -459 -254 -168 -703 -146 -158 -399 - -+/- 4.0 -+/- 3.8 - -+/- 3.3 -+/- 7.8 -+/-7.6 - -+/- 6.7 -+/- 3.8 -+/- 5.7 - -+/- 4.2 -+/- 7.1 -+/- 7.7 -+/- 9.6 -+/- 6.5 -+/- 8.0 -+/-11.8 -+/-5.1 -+/- 11.2 -+/- 10.2 -+/- 6.8 - -Note: The margins of error are reported at the 95% level of -confidence and are calculated by taking into account the average -design effect for each subgroup. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -6 When data collection for the 2014 Political Polarization and Typology Survey began, non-internet users were subsampled at a rate of 25%, -but a decision was made shortly thereafter to invite all non-internet users to join. In total, 83% of non-internet users were invited to join the -panel. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 17 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -The second group of panelists was recruited -from the 2015 Pew Research Center Survey on -Government conducted Aug. 27-Oct. 4, 2015. Of -the 6,004 adults interviewed, all were invited to -join the panel, and 2,976 agreed to participate.7 -The third group of panelists was recruited from a -survey conducted April 25-June 4, 2017. Of the -5,012 adults interviewed in the survey or pretest, -3,905 were invited to take part in the panel and a -total of 1,628 agreed to participate.8 - -The overall target population for Wave 34 was -non-institutionalized persons ages 18 and older, -living in the United States, including Alaska and -Hawaii. The sample for Wave 34 consisted of -3,099 ATP members that were invited to Wave -33 and were still active. This subsample was -selected using the following approach: - -Margins of error continued - -Sample size - -Margin of error -in percentage -points - -Science knowledge index -High -Medium -Low - -Heard about gene editing -A lot -A little -Nothing at all - -679 -1,274 -584 - -326 -1,449 -753 - -+/-5.2 -+/- 3.9 -+/- 5.7 - -+/- 7.9 -+/-3.6 -+/-5.1 - -Note: The margins of error are reported at the 95% level of -confidence and are calculated by taking into account the average -design effect for each subgroup. -Source: Survey conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +9 -1. Panelists were grouped into three strata based on how underrepresented they are + And a Broadening Footprint in FINS+ -demographically. Then we analyzed response rates to the last five panel survey waves -(W28-32) to project the number of panelists in each stratum who would respond to the -W33 survey. - -2. We then determined how many panelists we wanted to sample from each stratum in W33 -in order to finish with around 2,500 completed interviews and have a responding sample -that is as representative as possible. - -▪ Stratum A consists of panelists who are non-internet users, are black non-Hispanic, -are Hispanic, or have high school or less education. There were 1,819 total panelists -in this stratum and they are sampled at a rate of 100% for W33. 1,806 were active -panelists. - -7 Respondents to the 2014 Political Polarization and Typology Survey who indicated that they are internet users but refused to provide an -email address were initially permitted to participate in the American Trends Panel by mail but were no longer permitted to join the panel after -Feb. 6, 2014. Internet users from the 2015 Pew Research Center Survey on Government who refused to provide an email address were not -permitted to join the panel. -8 White, non-Hispanic college graduates were subsampled at a rate of 50%. +~$67B -www.pewresearch.org +FINS+ Market Opportunity - 18 +FINS+ Unlocks a Massive Opportunity -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +New Landing Points -▪ Stratum B consists of panelists who are ages 18 to 34 or are non-volunteers. The +Expanding into Our HCM Base -1,684 total panelists in this stratum are subsampled at a rate of 63%, yielding 1,061 -sampled for W33 (1,057 were active). +Medium Enterprise -▪ Stratum C consists of the remaining 2,009 panelists not in stratum A or B. This +Deepening Our Industry +Presence -group is subsampled at a rate of 12%, yielding 241 panelists sampled for W33 (239 -were active). +Future Innovation -The ATP data were weighted in a multistep process that begins with a base weight incorporating -the respondents’ original survey selection probability and the fact that in 2014 some panelists were -subsampled for invitation to the panel. Next, an adjustment was made for the fact that the -propensity to join the panel and remain an active panelist varied across different groups in the -sample. The final step in the weighting uses an iterative technique that aligns the sample to -population benchmarks on a number of dimensions. Gender, age, education, race, Hispanic origin -and region parameters come from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2016 American Community Survey. -The county-level population density parameter (deciles) comes from the 2010 U.S. decennial -census. The telephone service benchmark comes from the July-December 2016 National Health -Interview Survey and is projected to 2017. The volunteerism benchmark comes from the 2015 -Current Population Survey Volunteer Supplement. The party affiliation benchmark is the average -of the three most recent Pew Research Center general public telephone surveys. The internet -access benchmark comes from the 2017 ATP Panel Refresh Survey. Respondents who did not -previously have internet access are treated as not having internet access for weighting purposes. -Sampling errors and statistical tests of significance take into account the effect of weighting. -Interviews are conducted in both English and Spanish, but the Hispanic sample in the ATP is -predominantly U.S. born and English speaking. +M&A -Margins of error tables shown here provide the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable -to sampling that would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the -survey taking into account the average design effect for each subgroup. Sample sizes and sampling -errors for other subgroups are available upon request. - -In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical -difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls. - -The April 2018 wave had a response rate of 82% (2,537 responses among 3,099 individuals in the -panel). Taking account of the combined, weighted response rate for the recruitment surveys - -www.pewresearch.org - - 19 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -(10.1%) and attrition from panel members who were removed at their request or for inactivity, the -cumulative response rate for the wave is 2.3%.9 - -Religious commitment index - -Survey respondents were classified into high, medium and low levels of religious commitment -based on three indicators: frequency of religious service attendance, self-reported importance of -religion in their lives and frequency of prayer. Those who attend worship services at least weekly, -pray at least once a day and say religion is very important in their lives are classified as high in -religious commitment. Those low in commitment say religion is not too or not at all important in -their lives, that they seldom or never attend worship services, and seldom or never pray. All others -are classified as exhibiting a medium level of religious commitment. +IDC and Workday estimates. Includes Financial Management, Accounting Center, Analytics, Financial Planning, Spend Management, Expenses, Integration/Platform, Projects, and Industry Solutions -9 Approximately once per year, panelists who have not participated in multiple consecutive waves are removed from the panel. These cases -are counted in the denominator of cumulative response rates. Note that for the March 2018 survey, we calculated the response rates by -computing the mean rates for the subsampled respondents (based on the rates from the recruitment survey they joined the panel on). +10 -www.pewresearch.org + Driving Profitable Growth at Scale - 20 +21% +CAGR -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$4.5B +FY22 -Science knowledge index +95%+ -Scale reliability and factor analysis +Gross Revenue +Retention3 -The Pew Research Center survey included a set of nine questions to tap public knowledge of -science across a range of principles and topics. Most respondents (n=1,901) completed these -questions as part of a previous -wave of the American Trends -Panel, conducted May 10-June -6, 2016. Respondents who did -not participate in the previous -wave answered these questions -in this survey (n=636). The -following shows the -measurement properties of the -index for the combined set of -2,537 respondents.10 +$3.1B +FY20 -Alpha for scale -0.75 -Alpha if item is -dropped +900 +bps -Knowledge index 9-items +22.4% +FY22 -Item-rest -correlation +Annual +Subscription +Revenue1 -0.47 +Non-GAAP +Operating +Margin2 -0.39 +1 CAGR calculations are based on FY20-FY22 results +2 Reconciliations of GAAP to Non-GAAP financial data included in the Appendix +3 Measures the annual recurring revenue of our customers as of 4.30.21 that we have maintained as of 4.30.22, without giving credit for additional upsells or price and/or seats related changes. The metric captures only customer and product churn -0.74 +13.4% +FY20 -0.73 + While Growing Responsibly and Inclusively -Common -variance -explained by -first factor -76% -Factor -loadings +ESG and Our Employees -0.46 +ESG and Our Customers -0.55 +ESG and the World Around Us -KNOSCT22. Use of a control group -to determine whether a new drug is -effective -KNOSCT23. Carbon dioxide is made -as a consequence of burning fossil -fuels -KNOSCT27. The probability of an -old-bridge collapsing after a period -of time -KNOSCT28. Only bacterial -infections can be treated effectively -by antibiotic medications -KNOSCT29. The use of a control -“sugar pill” in a new drug trial is to -rule out a possible placebo effect -KNOSCT31. The health benefits -occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine is called -herd immunity -KNOSCT32. An apple, salmon, corn -and a mosquito can all be -genetically modified. -KNOSCT33. Humans and mice -share 50% or more of the same -genetic makeup -KNOSCT34. Nitrogen makes up -most of the Earth’s atmosphere. +VIBE +Our commitment to value inclusion, +belonging, and equity for all -0.50 +Opportunity Onramps +Provide candidates from diverse, +nontraditional backgrounds with training +and job opportunities -0.72 +®️ -0.59 +Building Inclusive Solutions +Investing to help organizations gain +valuable insights about equity within their +workforce -0.31 +Building Sustainable Solutions +Helping customers improve sustainability +and resilience of their supply chains -0.75 +Investing in Training +To help ensure we attract, recruit, hire, +and advance employees of all +backgrounds -0.35 +Empowering our Ecosystem +Workday’s adaptable platform enables +customers and partners to manage their +emissions reduction strategy -0.43 +Net-Zero Carbon Footprint +Achieved net-zero emissions in 2020 and +lifetime net-zero carbon footprint in 2021 -0.73 +Commitment to 1.5ºC +Science-based targets across our entire +value chain -0.50 +Driving Policy Change +Working to advance polices that support +a skills-based approach to talent, and aid +in the transition to a low-carbon economy -0.45 +For More Information: +Visit our ESG Resource Page: Sustainability and Reporting with Workday +Read our Blog: Our Commitments to ESG at Workday +Download our 2021 Global Impact Report -0.73 + Q1 FY23 Highlights and Guidance -0.52 + Q1 FY23 Financial Highlights -0.47 +Q1 FY23 Results -0.73 +Increase (Decrease) YoY -0.55 +Total Revenue -An exploratory factor analysis -finds one common factor -explaining 76% of the common -variance in the items. The -factor loadings show that each -of the nine questions is -moderately correlated with the -common factor. These -indicators suggest a set of items is measuring a single underlying dimension. +Subscription Revenue -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Total Subscription Revenue Backlog -0.44 +24-month Subscription Revenue Backlog -0.43 +GAAP Operating Margin -Source: Surveys conducted May 10-June 6, 2016, and April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Non-GAAP Operating Margin1 -0.73 +Operating Cash Flows -0.50 +1 Reconciliations of GAAP to Non-GAAP financial data included in the Appendix -0.73 +$1.43B -0.52 +$1.27B -As shown in the accompanying -table, the internal reliability or -consistency of the scale as -measured by Cronbach’s alpha -is 0.75. Each of the items in the -scale is at least moderately -correlated with the other items. +$12.65B -10 In statistical models controlling for demographics and education, there were no significant differences between respondents who -completed the science knowledge items in 2016 (W17) and those who completed them in 2018 (W34) on either the overall index measure or -the individual questions. +$7.97B -www.pewresearch.org +(5.1%) - 21 +20.1% -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$440M -Two parameter item response theory analysis +22% -KNOSCT22. Use of a control -group to determine whether a -new drug is effective -KNOSCT23. Carbon dioxide is -made as a consequence of -burning fossil fuels -KNOSCT27. The probability of an -old-bridge collapsing after a -period of time -KNOSCT28. Only bacterial -infections can be treated -effectively by antibiotic -medications -KNOSCT29. The use of a control -“sugar pill” in a new drug trial is -to rule out a possible placebo -effect -KNOSCT31. The health benefits -occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine is called -herd immunity -KNOSCT32. An apple, salmon, -corn and a mosquito can all be -genetically modified. -KNOSCT33. Humans and mice -share 50% or more of the same -genetic make-up -KNOSCT34. Nitrogen makes up -most of the Earth’s atmosphere. +23% -% Correct Discrimination +26% -Difficulty +21% -68 +(180 bps) -72 +(450 bps) -62 +(3%) -46 + Q1 FY23 Customer Wins and Expansions -1.36 + Q1 FY23 Business Highlights --0.73 +• -1.74 +• --0.82 +• -2.14 +• --0.38 +Workday intends to create 1,000 new jobs at its European +headquarters in Dublin over the next two years. In addition, the +company plans to build new European headquarters at +Grangegorman in Dublin. -0.81 +Workday completed the issuance and sale of $3.0 billion aggregate +principal amount of senior notes in an underwritten, registered +public offering. -0.25 +Building on its long-standing support of ESG, Workday shared its +commitments to ESG as well as announced two new ESG solutions +to help customers drive social and sustainability initiatives as they +navigate evolving ESG regulations and corporate accountability +standards. -59 +Workday was named one of the World’s Most Ethical Companies +by Ethisphere, which recognizes companies with a commitment to +advancing business integrity. -1.60 + Guidance Summary --0.33 +Quarterly Guidance -34 +Increase (Decrease) YoY -39 +Q2 FY23 -34 +Total Revenue -1.39 +Subscription Revenue -0.65 +24-month Subscription Revenue Backlog -1.66 +Non-GAAP Operating Margin -0.38 +$1.517B - $1.519B -1.37 +$1.353B - $1.355B -0.66 +n/a -Note that each of the science -knowledge questions are coded -as binary variables -(correct/incorrect). Both -Cronbach’s alpha reliability -analysis and the factor analysis -are based on a Pearson’s -correlation matrix. Pearson -correlations with binary -variables are restricted to a -limited range, underestimating -the association between two -variables when compared with -tetrachoric correlations. We do -not anticipate that the use of a -Pearson’s correlation matrix -affects the unidimensional -factor solution for the scale, -however. +17.5% -31 +20-21% -1.55 +22% -0.74 +20% -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +(570 bps) -Source: Surveys conducted May 10-June 6, 2016, and April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +n/a -We also ran an item-response -theory analysis (IRT) to check -how well each question -distinguishes between those -who know relatively more or -less on the scale. This analysis fits a two-parameter logistic model, allowing discrimination and -difficulty to vary across the items. Discrimination shows the ability of the question to distinguish -between those with higher and lower science knowledge. Difficulty shows how easy or hard each -question is for the average respondent. We did not include a guessing parameter in the model; the -questionnaire offered respondents an explicit option of not sure on the survey. +GAAP Operating Margin -The results show variation in difficulty across the items. The easiest item required respondents to -identify that carbon dioxide as the gas that is made as a consequence of burning fossil fuels, while -the most difficult item required respondents to identify nitrogen as the gas that makes up most of -the Earth’s atmosphere. +~22 points lower than non-GAAP -www.pewresearch.org +Full Year FY23 - 22 +Total Revenue -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Subscription Revenue -Most of the questions also discriminate between those with higher and lower science knowledge. -The item with strongest ability to discriminate was the question asking respondents to calculate -the conditional probability of an old bridge over time. The question with the weakest ability to -discriminate was the question about the effectiveness of antibiotics to treat bacterial, but not other -kinds of infections. +Non-GAAP Operating Margin -The test information curve mirrors a normal curve centered around zero, suggesting that the -science knowledge index provides the most information about Americans near the mean level of -knowledge. +GAAP Operating Margin -© Pew Research Center, 2018 +Non-GAAP Tax Rate -www.pewresearch.org +Operating Cash Flows - 23 +As provided on Q1 FY23 Earnings Call on 5.26.22 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Full Year Guidance -Appendix: Detailed tables +Increase (Decrease) YoY -Half or more from all religious groups -consider gene editing to treat disease -that would be present at birth to be -appropriate +$6.187B - $6.207B -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to treat a -serious disease or condition a baby would have at birth -is … +$5.537B - $5.557B -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant +18.5% -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology -72% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -27% - -66 -61 -79 -60 -72 -72 -74 -78 -92 -92 -69 - -74 -62 -74 - -31 -37 -20 -36 -28 -28 -26 -22 -7 -8 -30 - -24 -35 -26 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 24 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -White evangelical Protestants among -the least likely to consider gene editing -to reduce lifetime disease risk -appropriate - -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to reduce the -risk of a serious disease or condition that could occur -over the course of a baby’s lifetime is … +~24 points lower than non-GAAP -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology -60% - -Taking medical -technology too -far -38% - -51 -45 -58 -51 -63 -58 -68 -67 -85 -81 -57 - -60 -52 -61 - -47 -54 -41 -43 -36 -41 -30 -32 -15 -19 -41 - -39 -44 -36 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 25 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Nine-in-ten white evangelical -Protestants see gene editing for -intelligence as taking technology too far - -% of U.S. adults who say using gene editing to make a -baby more intelligent is … - -U.S. adults -Religious affiliation -Protestant - -White evangelical -White mainline -Black Protestant - -Catholic - -White Catholic -Hispanic Catholic - -Unaffiliated -Atheist -Agnostic -Nothing in particular - -Race/ethnicity -White -Black -Hispanic - -Appropriate -use of medical -technology 19% -Taking medical -technology too -far -80% - -12 -8 -12 -14 -20 -18 -24 -25 -36 -22 -23 - -16 -21 -22 - -86 -91 -88 -81 -80 -82 -76 -74 -64 -77 -77 - -83 -75 -76 - -Note: Whites and blacks include only non-Hispanics; Hispanics are -of any race. Respondents who did not give an answer are not -shown. -Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted April 23-May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would -Be Used” - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -www.pewresearch.org - - 26 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Statistical models predicting opinions about appropriate uses of gene editing - -Difference in predicted probabilities for belief that changing a baby’s genetic characteristics ____ is an appropriate use of -medical technology +$1.610B -Women +20-21% -To treat a serious disease or -condition the baby would -have at birth -NS +22% -To reduce the risk of a serious -disease or condition that could occur -over the course of his or her lifetime --0.08 +(390 bps) -To make the baby -more intelligent --0.09 +n/a -Requiring testing on -human embryos --0.15 +n/a -Race Reference category: White, non-Hispanic +(2%) -Black, non-Hispanic + Appendix -Hispanic + Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP Data -Other +Three Months Ended April 30, 2022 -Age Reference category: 18-29 +(in thousands, except percentages and per +share data) -Ages 30-49 +GAAP -50-64 +Share-Based +Compensation +Expenses -65+ +Other Operating +Expenses2 -NS +Income Tax and +Dilution Effects3 -NS +Non-GAAP --0.20 +Costs and expenses: -NS +Costs of subscription services --0.10 +Costs of professional services -NS +Product development -Education Reference category: High school or less +Sales and marketing -Postgraduate +General and administrative -College graduate +Operating income (loss) -Some college +Operating margin -+0.16 +Other income (expense), net -+0.14 +Income (loss) before provision for (benefit from) +income taxes -+0.09 +Provision for (benefit from) income taxes -Science knowledge Reference category: Low science knowledge +Net income (loss) -High +Net income (loss) per share, basic1 -Medium +Net income (loss) per share, diluted1 -+0.16 +$232,922 -NS +169,899 -NS +541,509 -NS +429,301 -NS +133,869 --0.12 +(72,843) --0.17 +(5.1)% -NS +(20,163) -+0.13 +(93,006) -NS +9,167 -+0.08 +$(102,173) -NS +$(0.41) -NS +$(0.41) -Religious commitment Reference category: Low religious commitment +$(26,230) -High +(27,584) -Medium +(153,304) --0.14 +(59,169) -NS +(45,219) -Religious affiliation Reference category: Unaffiliated +311,506 -Mainline Protestant +21.7% -Evangelical Protestant +- -Catholic +311,506 -Other Christian +- -Other religion +$311,506 -NS +$1.24 -NS +$1.24 -NS +$(16,326) -NS +(3,899) -NS +(13,011) --0.21 +(14,046) --0.10 +(2,613) -NS +49,895 -NS +3.5% -NS +- -NS +49,895 -NS +- -NS +$49,895 -NS +$0.20 -NS +$0.20 --0.08 +$- --0.12 +- --0.13 +- -NS +- -NS +- -NS +- -NS +-% --0.09 +- --0.14 +- -NS +41,828 -NS +$(41,828) -NS +$(0.17) -NS +$(0.20) -NS +$190,366 -NS +138,416 -NS +375,194 --0.09 +356,086 -NS +86,037 -NS +288,558 -NS +20.1% --0.12 +(20,163) -+0.10 +268,395 -NS +50,995 -+0.07 +$217,400 -NS +$0.86 --0.08 +$0.83 --0.14 +1 GAAP net loss per share is calculated based upon 251,743 basic and diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. Non-GAAP net income per share is calculated based +upon 251,743 basic and 263,473 diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. The numerator used to compute non-GAAP diluted net income per share was increased by +$1.3 million for after-tax interest expense on our convertible senior notes in accordance with the if-converted method. --0.13 +2 Other operating expenses include employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions of $28.3 million and amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets of +$21.6 million. -NS +3 We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the reporting periods. For fiscal 2023, +the non-GAAP tax rate is 19%. Included in the per share amount is a dilution impact of $0.03 from the conversion of GAAP diluted net loss per share to non-GAAP diluted net +income per share. --0.22 + Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP Data -NS +Three Months Ended April 30, 2021 -NS +(in thousands, except percentages and per +share data) -NS +GAAP -Heard about gene editing Reference category: Heard nothing at all about gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics +Share-Based +Compensation +Expenses -Heard a lot +Other Operating +Expenses2 -Heard a little +Income Tax and +Dilution Effects3 -Number of respondents +Non-GAAP -NS +Costs and expenses: -+0.06 +Costs of subscription services -2,237 +Costs of professional services -NS +Product development -NS +Sales and marketing -2,232 +General and administrative -+0.15 +Operating income (loss) -+0.07 +Operating margin -2,241 +Other income (expense), net -+0.17 +Income (loss) before provision for (benefit from) +income taxes -+0.09 +Provision for (benefit from) income taxes -2,223 +Net income (loss) -Note: Figures shown are the difference in predicted probabilities with the reference category while other factors are held at their mean using binary -logistic regression models. Positive and negative values indicated the direction of effects. NS indicates not statistically significant based on a two- -tailed p value < 0.05. -Source: Survey conducted April 23- May 6, 2018. -“Public Views of Gene Editing for Babies Depend on How It Would Be Used” +Net income (loss) per share, basic1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Net income (loss) per share, diluted1 -www.pewresearch.org +$182,208 - 27 +150,845 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +441,616 -Survey questionnaire and topline +326,494 -2018 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL -APRIL 23-MAY 6, 2018 -TOTAL N=2,537 +112,183 -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED OR HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE +(38,313) -ASK ALL: -MED3 How much, if anything, have you heard or read about gene editing that can be used to change a +(3.3)% -baby’s genetic characteristics? +(9,051) -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -12 -56 -32 -1 +(47,364) -A lot -A little -Nothing at all -No answer +(842) -ASK ALL: -MED4 Do you think each of the following is an appropriate use of medical technology or is it taking +$(46,522) -medical technology too far? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] +$(0.19) -An appropriate use of -medical technology +$(0.19) -Taking medical -technology too far +$(20,717) -No -Answer +(27,692) -a. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics +(129,862) -to make the baby more intelligent +(50,308) -April 23-May 6, 2018 +(36,056) -b. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics +264,635 -to TREAT a serious disease or condition the -baby would have at birth -April 23-May 6, 2018 +22.5% -c. Changing a baby's genetic characteristics -to REDUCE THE RISK of a serious disease -or condition that could occur over the -course of his or her lifetime +- -19 +264,635 -72 +- -80 +$264,635 -27 +$1.09 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +$1.09 -60 +$(14,204) -38 +(6,953) -1 +(19,542) -2 +(17,106) -2 +(4,386) -TRENDS FOR COMPARISON -Pew Research Center survey conducted by telephone: Would you say that changing a baby’s genetic -characteristics to make the baby more intelligent is making appropriate use of medical advances OR is it -taking medical advances too far? +62,191 -Aug. 15-25, -2014 -15 -83 -2 +5.4% -Appropriate use of medical advances -Taking medical advances too far -Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) +- -www.pewresearch.org +62,191 - 28 +- -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +$62,191 -Surveys conducted by telephone: Would you say that changing a baby’s genetic characteristics to reduce -the risk of serious diseases is making appropriate use of medical advances OR is it taking medical -advances too far? +$0.26 -Appropriate use of medical advances -Taking medical advances too far -Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) +$0.26 -Pew Research Center -Aug. 15-25, -2014 -46 -50 -4 +$- -VCU Life Sciences -Survey -Sept. 3-26, -2003 -41 -54 -6 +- -ASK ALL: -MED5 Thinking about what you have heard or read, how well do you think medical researchers +- -understand the health risks and benefits of changing a baby’s genetic characteristics? +- -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -7 -29 -45 -17 -1 +- -Very well -Fairly well -Not too well -Not at all well -No answer +- -ASK ALL: -MED6 Thinking about society as a whole … +-% -How likely, if at all, do you think each of the following would be to occur if gene editing to -change a baby’s genetic characteristics becomes widely available? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] +- -Very likely +- -Fairly -likely +53,940 -Not too -likely +$(53,940) -Not at all -likely +$(0.23) -No -Answer +$(0.29) -a. Even if gene editing is used +$147,287 -appropriately in some cases, others -will use these techniques in ways -that are morally unacceptable +116,200 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +292,212 -54 +259,080 -32 +71,741 -9 +288,513 -b. These techniques will help people -live longer and better quality lives +24.6% -April 23-May 6, 2018 +(9,051) -16 +279,462 -48 +53,098 -27 +$226,364 -c. We will use these techniques before -we fully understand how they affect -people’s health +$0.93 -April 23-May 6, 2018 +$0.87 -46 +1 GAAP net loss per share is calculated based upon 243,739 basic and diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. Non-GAAP net income per share is calculated based +upon 243,739 basic and 260,416 diluted weighted-average shares of common stock. The numerator used to compute non-GAAP diluted net income per share was increased by +$1.3 million for after-tax interest expense on our convertible senior notes in accordance with the if-converted method. -38 +2 Other operating expenses include employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions of $44.3 million and amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets of +$17.9 million. -12 +3 We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the reporting periods. For fiscal 2022, +the non-GAAP tax rate was 19%. Included in the per share amount is a dilution impact of $0.07 from the conversion of GAAP diluted net loss per share to non-GAAP diluted net +income per share. -d. + About Non-GAAP Financial Measures -Inequality will increase because -this option will be available only for -the wealthy +To provide investors and others with additional information regarding Workday’s results, we have disclosed the following non-GAAP financial measures: non-GAAP operating +income (loss), non-GAAP operating margin, and non-GAAP net income (loss) per share. Workday has provided a reconciliation of each non-GAAP financial measure used in this +earnings release to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure. Non-GAAP operating income (loss) and non-GAAP operating margin differ from GAAP in that they +exclude share-based compensation expenses, employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions, and amortization expense for acquisition-related intangible +assets. Non-GAAP net income (loss) per share differs from GAAP in that it excludes share-based compensation expenses, employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock +transactions, amortization expense for acquisition-related intangible assets, and income tax effects. -April 23-May 6, 2018 +Workday’s management uses these non-GAAP financial measures to understand and compare operating results across accounting periods, for internal budgeting and +forecasting purposes, for short- and long-term operating plans, and to evaluate Workday’s financial performance. Management believes these non-GAAP financial measures +reflect Workday’s ongoing business in a manner that allows for meaningful period-to-period comparisons and analysis of trends in Workday’s business. Management also +believes that these non-GAAP financial measures provide useful information to investors and others in understanding and evaluating Workday’s operating results and prospects +in the same manner as management and in comparing financial results across accounting periods and to those of peer companies. -58 - -29 - -9 +Management believes excluding the following items from the GAAP Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations is useful to investors and others in assessing Workday’s +operating performance due to the following factors: -3 +• -8 - -3 - -4 - -1 - -2 +Share-based compensation expenses. Although share-based compensation is an important aspect of the compensation of our employees and executives, management +believes it is useful to exclude share-based compensation expenses to better understand the long-term performance of our core business and to facilitate comparison of +our results to those of peer companies. Share-based compensation expenses are determined using a number of factors, including our stock price, volatility, and forfeiture +rates, that are beyond our control and generally unrelated to operational decisions and performance in any particular period. Further, share-based compensation +expenses are not reflective of the value ultimately received by the grant recipients. -1 + About Non-GAAP Financial Measures (cont’d) -1 +• -www.pewresearch.org +• - 29 +Other operating expenses. Other operating expenses includes employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions and amortization of acquisition-related +intangible assets. The amount of employer payroll tax-related items on employee stock transactions is dependent on our stock price and other factors that are beyond our +control and do not correlate to the operation of the business. For business combinations, we generally allocate a portion of the purchase price to intangible assets. The +amount of the allocation is based on estimates and assumptions made by management and is subject to amortization. The amount of purchase price allocated to +intangible assets and the term of its related amortization can vary significantly and are unique to each acquisition and thus we do not believe it is reflective of ongoing +operations. Although we exclude the amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets from these non-GAAP measures, management believes that it is important for +investors to understand that such intangible assets were recorded as part of purchase accounting and contribute to revenue generation. -PEW RESEARCH CENTER +Income tax effects. We utilize a fixed long-term projected tax rate in our computation of the non-GAAP income tax provision to provide better consistency across the +reporting periods. In projecting this long-term non-GAAP tax rate, we utilize a three-year financial projection that excludes the direct impact of share-based compensation +and related employer payroll taxes, amortization of acquisition-related intangible assets, and amortization of debt discount and issuance costs. The projected rate +considers other factors such as our current operating structure, existing tax positions in various jurisdictions, and key legislation in major jurisdictions where we operate. +For fiscal 2023 and 2022, we determined the projected non-GAAP tax rate to be 19%, which reflects currently available information, as well as other factors and +assumptions. We will periodically re-evaluate this tax rate, as necessary, for significant events, based on our ongoing analysis of the 2017 U.S. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, +relevant tax law changes, material changes in the forecasted geographic earnings mix, and any significant acquisitions. -Very likely - -Fairly -likely - -Not too -likely - -Not at all -likely - -No -Answer - -MED6 continued … - -e. Development of these techniques -will pave the way for new medical -advances that benefit society as a -whole - -April 23-May 6, 2018 - -18 - -42 - -30 - -8 +The use of non-GAAP operating income (loss), non-GAAP operating margin, and non-GAAP net income (loss) per share measures have certain limitations as they do not reflect +all items of income and expense that affect Workday’s operations. Workday compensates for these limitations by reconciling the non-GAAP financial measures to the most +comparable GAAP financial measures. These non-GAAP financial measures should be considered in addition to, not as a substitute for or in isolation from, measures prepared in +accordance with GAAP. Further, these non-GAAP measures may differ from the non-GAAP information used by other companies, including peer companies, and therefore +comparability may be limited. Management encourages investors and others to review Workday’s financial information in its entirety and not rely on a single financial measure. -1 - -ASK ALL: -MED7 If gene editing to change a baby’s genetic characteristics required testing on human embryos in - -order to develop these techniques, do you think this would be … - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -33 -65 -2 - -An appropriate use of medical technology -Taking medical technology too far -No answer - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FURTHER RELEASE - -ASK ALL: -BIO15 Have you seen a health care provider FOR AN ILLNESS OR MEDICAL CONDITION in the past 12 - -months, or not? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -64 -36 -1 - -Yes -No -No answer - -May 10- -June 6 -2016 -63 -36 -2 - -ASK ALL: -G1 - -Do you, or does anyone in your immediate family, have a gene that predisposes you to a serious -disease such as Alzheimer’s, cancer, heart disease or sickle cell anemia? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -26 -40 -34 -1 - -Yes -No -Not sure -No answer - -May 10- -June 6, -2016 -27 -43 -30 -1 - -www.pewresearch.org - - 30 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK ALL: -G2 - -Have you, or has anyone in your immediate family, ever had a genetic test, or haven’t you done -this? - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -14 -65 -20 -1 - -Yes -No -Not sure -No answer - -May 10- -June 6 -2016 -10 -70 -19 -1 - -NOTE: RESULTS SHOWN FOR KNOSCT22-KNOSCT34 INCLUDE 636 RESPONDENTS WHO -ANSWERED THESE QUESTIONS APRIL 23-MAY 6, 2018 COMBINED WITH 1,901 RESPONDENTS -WHO ANSWERED THESE QUESTIONS IN A PREVIOUS WAVE FIELDED MAY 10-JUNE 6, 2016. - -ASK ALL: Here’s a different kind of question. (If you don’t know the answer, select “Not sure.”) As far as -you know … - -KNOSCT22 - -Here’s a different kind of question. (If you don’t know the answer, select “Not sure.”) As -far as you know ... - -Which is the better way to determine whether a new drug is effective in treating a -disease? If a scientist has a group of 1,000 volunteers with the disease to study, should -she … [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2] - -Apr 23- -May 6 -2018 -68 - -32 - 14 - 18 -<1 - -Give the drug to half of them but not to the other half, and compare -how many in each group get better (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Give the drug to all of them and see how many get better - Not sure - No answer - -[RANDOMIZE ITEMS KNOSCT23 TO KNOSCT34; KNOSCT22 ALWAYS FIRST] - -www.pewresearch.org - - 31 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Which gas is made as a consequence of burning fossil fuels? Is it … [RANDOMIZE -OPTIONS 1-4]11 - -Carbon dioxide (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Hydrogen - Helium - Radon - Not sure - No answer - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT23 - -Apr 23- -May 6 -2018 -72 -28 - 4 - 1 - 3 - 20 -<1 - -NO QUESTION KNOSCT24, KNOSCT25 AND KNOSCT26 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT27 - -If the chances that an old bridge will collapse starts at 1% in week 1 and doubles each -week (as shown below), what is the chance that the old bridge will collapse during week -7? - -Chances the bridge will collapse is… - -1% -2% -4% -8% - -at Week 1 -at Week 2 -at Week 3 -at Week 4 - -Enter the % chance that the bridge will collapse at Week 7 (if the bridge is still standing -after Week 6)12 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -62 -38 - 20 - 17 - 1 - -64% (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - All other numeric responses - Not sure - No answer - -11 In the Wave 17 May 2016 survey, the question had a minor wording difference: “What gas is made as a consequence of burning fossil -fuels? Is it …” -12 The phrase “(if the bridge is still standing after Week 6)” was added for clarity in the April 23-May 6, 2018, wave. - -www.pewresearch.org - - 32 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -Which of the following conditions can be treated effectively by antibiotic medications? - -[Check all that apply] [RANDOMIZE ITEMS WITH ITEMS e AND f ALWAYS LAST] - -Bacterial infection only (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT28 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -46 -54 - -KNOSCT28 INDIVIDUAL ITEM RESPONSES - -a. Viral infections (such as a cold) -b. Fungal infections (such as athlete’s foot) -c. Bacterial infections (such as strep throat infections) -d. Allergic reactions to insect bites -e. None of these [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] -f. Not sure [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] - -Selected -23 -28 -83 -17 -2 -9 - -Not selected -/No answer -77 -72 -17 -83 -98 -91 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT29 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -59 -41 - 4 - 16 - 20 - 1 - -If a scientist wants to determine if a new drug is effective at treating high blood pressure -by giving half of a group of 1,000 volunteers a new medication and the other half a -“sugar pill” she wants to rule out … [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-3] - -A placebo effect (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - A third person effect - A false consensus effect - Not sure - No answer - -NO QUESTION KNOSCT30 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT31 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -34 -66 - 8 - 35 - 23 - 1 - -Which of these terms refers to health benefits occurring when most people in a -population get a vaccine? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-3] - -Herd immunity (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Population control - Vaccination rate - Not sure - No answer - -www.pewresearch.org - - 33 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT32 - -Which of the following can be genetically modified? - -[Check all that apply] [RANDOMIZE ITEMS WITH ITEMS e AND f ALWAYS LAST] - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -39 -61 - -Selected all (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - -KNOSCT32 INDIVIDUAL ITEM RESPONSES - -a. An apple -b. Salmon -c. A mosquito -d. Corn -e. None of these [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] -f. Not sure [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH] - -Selected -61 -53 -46 -70 -2 -20 - -Not selected -/No answer -39 -47 -54 -30 -98 -80 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT33 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -34 -66 - 8 - 14 - 44 - 1 - -ASK ALL: -KNOSCT34 - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -31 -69 - 9 - 9 - 35 - 15 - 1 - -Humans and mice share the same genetic makeup by… [RANDOMIZE ORDER LOW TO -HIGH; HIGH TO LOW with NOT SURE ALWAYS LAST] - -About 50% or more (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Less than 10% - Between 11% and 49% - Not sure - No answer - -Which gas makes up most of the Earth's atmosphere? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1-4] - -Nitrogen (Correct) -NET Incorrect/Not sure/No answer - Hydrogen - Carbon dioxide - -Oxygen - Not sure - No answer - -www.pewresearch.org - - 34 - -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -TOTAL NUMBER CORRECT KNOSCT22 THROUGH KNOSCT34: - -April 23- -May 6, -2018 -4 -10 -10 -13 -12 -13 -11 -12 -9 -6 - -9 out of 9 -8 out of 9 -7 out of 9 -6 out of 9 -5 out of 9 -4 out of 9 -3 out of 9 -2 out of 9 -1 out of 9 -0 out of 9 - -24 -49 -26 - -High science knowledge (7-9 correct) -Medium science knowledge (3-6 correct) -Low science knowledge (0-2 correct) - -www.pewresearch.org + Thank You diff --git a/q58/random_k4/random_2.md b/q58/random_k4/random_2.md index b1e911fa22b913bedf584883674d00198efbf53f..d55a1d26c20476fcdee5ca60b395144c86c2f238 100644 --- a/q58/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q58/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,811 +1,1083 @@ -Physics 111 -- Mechanics - -• Lecturer: Tom Humanic - -• Contact info: - -Office: Physics Research Building, Rm. 2144 - - Email: humanic@mps.ohio-state.edu - Phone: 614 247 8950 - -• Office hours: - Tuesday 4:30 pm - -My lecture slides may be found on my website at -http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~humanic/ - - Course Overview -- Mechanics -Kinematics -- velocity and acceleration, free-falling bodies, -projectile motion…. - -Dynamics -- Newton’s laws of motion -- forces -(gravitational, friction, tension……), motion of objects -due to forces…… - -Work and energy -- potential and kinetic energy, -conservation of energy, power…… - -Impulse and momentum -- conservation of momentum, -collisions, center-of-mass of an object, …… - -Rotational kinematics and dynamics -- angular velocity -and acceleration, torque, angular momentum….. - - Chapter 1 - -Introduction and -Mathematical Concepts - - 1.2 Units - -Physics experiments involve the measurement -of a variety of quantities. - -These measurements should be accurate and -reproducible. - -The first step in ensuring accuracy and -reproducibility is defining the units in which -the measurements are made. - - 1.2 Units - -SI units - -meter (m): unit of length - -kilogram (kg): unit of mass - -second (s): unit of time - - 1.2 Units - - 1.2 Units - -The units for length, mass, and time (as -well as a few others), are regarded as -base SI units. - -These units are used in combination to -define additional units for other important -physical quantities such as force and -energy. - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -THE CONVERSION OF UNITS - -1 ft = 0.3048 m - -1 mi = 1.609 km - -1 hp = 746 W - -1 liter = 10-3 m3 - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Example 1 The World’s Highest Waterfall - -The highest waterfall in the world is Angel Falls in Venezuela, -with a total drop of 979.0 m. Express this drop in feet. - -Since 3.281 feet = 1 meter, it follows that - -(3.281 feet)/(1 meter) = 1 - -Length - -= - -( - 0.979 - -meters - -feet - -.3 281 - 1 -meter - -& -) -$ -% - -# -=! -" - -3212 - -feet - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Reasoning Strategy: Converting Between Units - -1. In all calculations, write down the units explicitly. - -2. Treat all units as algebraic quantities. When -identical units are divided, they are eliminated -algebraically. - -3. Use the conversion factors located on the page -facing the inside cover. Be guided by the fact that -multiplying or dividing an equation by a factor of 1 -does not alter the equation. - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -Example 2 Interstate Speed Limit - -Express the speed limit of 65 miles/hour in terms of meters/second. - -Use 5280 feet = 1 mile and 3600 seconds = 1 hour and -3.281 feet = 1 meter. - -Speed - -= - -& - 65 -$ -% - -miles -hour - -# -! -" - -( )( ) -11 - -= - - 65 - -& -$ -% - -miles -hour - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - -5280 - -feet - -mile - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - - 1 -hour -3600 -s - -# -=! -" - -95 - -feet -second - -Speed - -= - -& -95 -$ -% - -feet -second - -# -! -" - -( ) -1 - -= - -95 - -& -$ -% - -feet -second - -# -& -$ -! -" -% - -meter - - 1 -3.281 - -feet - -# -=! -" - -29 - -meters -second - - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving - -DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS - -[L] = length [M] = mass [T] = time - -Is the following equation dimensionally correct? - -x = - +3 2 - -1 vt +0 2 +c +e +D +3 -[ ] -L -= - +] L -T - -& -$% - -# -!" +C +. +s +c +[ -[ ] -T +2 +v +1 +0 +6 +0 +1 +. +5 +0 +3 +2 +: +v +i +X +r +a -2 = +Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving +with Large Language Models -[ ][ ]TL +Shunyu Yao +Princeton University - 1.3 The Role of Units in Problem Solving +Dian Yu +Google DeepMind -Is the following equation dimensionally correct? +Jeffrey Zhao +Google DeepMind -x = +Izhak Shafran +Google DeepMind -vt +Thomas L. Griffiths +Princeton University -[ ] -L -= +Yuan Cao +Google DeepMind -L -T +Karthik Narasimhan +Princeton University -& -$ -% +Abstract -# -! -" +Language models are increasingly being deployed for general problem solving +across a wide range of tasks, but are still confined to token-level, left-to-right +decision-making processes during inference. This means they can fall short in +tasks that require exploration, strategic lookahead, or where initial decisions play +a pivotal role. To surmount these challenges, we introduce a new framework for +language model inference, “Tree of Thoughts” (ToT), which generalizes over the +popular “Chain of Thought” approach to prompting language models, and enables +exploration over coherent units of text (“thoughts”) that serve as intermediate steps +toward problem solving. ToT allows LMs to perform deliberate decision making +by considering multiple different reasoning paths and self-evaluating choices to +decide the next course of action, as well as looking ahead or backtracking when +necessary to make global choices. Our experiments show that ToT significantly +enhances language models’ problem-solving abilities on three novel tasks requiring +non-trivial planning or search: Game of 24, Creative Writing, and Mini Crosswords. +For instance, in Game of 24, while GPT-4 with chain-of-thought prompting only +solved 4% of tasks, our method achieved a success rate of 74%. Code repo with all +prompts: https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm. -[ ] [ ]L -T -= +1 - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +Introduction + +Originally designed to generate text, scaled-up versions of language models (LMs) such as GPT [25, +26, 1, 23] and PaLM [5] have been shown to be increasingly capable of performing an ever wider +range of tasks requiring mathematical, symbolic, commonsense, and knowledge reasoning. It is +perhaps surprising that underlying all this progress is still the original autoregressive mechanism for +generating text, which makes token-level decisions one by one and in a left-to-right fashion. Is such +a simple mechanism sufficient for a LM to be built toward a general problem solver? If not, what +problems would challenge the current paradigm, and what should be alternative mechanisms? + +The literature on human cognition provides some clues to answer these questions. Research on “dual +process” models suggests that people have two modes in which they engage with decisions – a fast, +automatic, unconscious mode (“System 1”) and a slow, deliberate, conscious mode (“System 2”) +[30, 31, 16, 15]. These two modes have previously been connected to a variety of mathematical +models used in machine learning. For example, research on reinforcement learning in humans and +other animals has explored the circumstances under which they engage in associative “model free” +learning or more deliberative “model based” planning [7]. The simple associative token-level choices +of LMs are also reminiscent of “System 1”, and thus might benefit from augmentation by a more +deliberate “System 2” planning process that (1) maintains and explores diverse alternatives for current + +37th Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS 2023). + + Figure 1: Schematic illustrating various approaches to problem solving with LLMs. Each rectangle +box represents a thought, which is a coherent language sequence that serves as an intermediate +step toward problem solving. See concrete examples of how thoughts are generated, evaluated, and +searched in Figures 2,4,6. + +choices instead of just picking one, and (2) evaluates its current status and actively looks ahead or +backtracks to make more global decisions. + +To design such a planning process, we return to the origins of artificial intelligence (and cognitive +science), drawing inspiration from the planning processes explored by Newell, Shaw, and Simon +starting in the 1950s [21, 22]. Newell and colleagues characterized problem solving [21] as search +through a combinatorial problem space, represented as a tree. We thus propose the Tree of Thoughts +(ToT) framework for general problem solving with language models. As Figure 1 illustrates, while +existing methods (detailed below) sample continuous language sequences for problem solving, ToT +actively maintains a tree of thoughts, where each thought is a coherent language sequence that serves +as an intermediate step toward problem solving (Table 1). Such a high-level semantic unit allows the +LM to self-evaluate the progress different intermediate thoughts make towards solving the problem +through a deliberate reasoning process that is also instantiated in language (Figures 2,4,6). This +implementation of search heuristics via LM self-evaluation and deliberation is novel, as previous +search heuristics are either programmed or learned. Finally, we combine this language-based +capability to generate and evaluate diverse thoughts with search algorithms, such as breadth-first +search (BFS) or depth-first search (DFS), which allow systematic exploration of the tree of thoughts +with lookahead and backtracking. + +Empirically, we propose three new problems that challenge existing LM inference methods even with +the state-of-the-art language model, GPT-4 [23]: Game of 24, Creative Writing, and Crosswords +(Table 1). These tasks require deductive, mathematical, commonsense, lexical reasoning abilities, +and a way to incorporate systematic planning or search. We show ToT obtains superior results on +all three tasks by being general and flexible enough to support different levels of thoughts, different +ways to generate and evaluate thoughts, and different search algorithms that adapt to the nature of +different problems. We also analyze how such choices affect model performances via systematic +ablations and discuss future directions to better train and use LMs. + +2 Background + +We first formalize some existing methods that use large language models for problem-solving, +which our approach is inspired by and later compared with. We use pθ to denote a pre-trained LM +with parameters θ, and lowercase letters x, y, z, s, · · · to denote a language sequence, i.e. x = +(x[1], · · · , x[n]) where each x[i] is a token, so that pθ(x) = (cid:81)n +i=1 pθ(x[i]|x[1...i]). We use uppercase +letters S, · · · to denote a collection of language sequences. + +Input-output (IO) prompting is the most common way to turn a problem input x into output +y with LM: y ∼ pθ(y|promptIO(x)), where promptIO(x) wraps input x with task instructions +and/or few-shot input-output examples. For simplicity, let us denote pprompt +(output | input) = +pθ(output | prompt(input)), so that IO prompting can be formulated as y ∼ pIO + +θ + +θ (y|x). -A scalar quantity is one that can be described -by a single number: +2 -temperature, speed, mass +(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:106)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:705)(cid:146)(cid:29)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:97)(cid:202)(cid:288)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:78)(cid:3)(cid:71)(cid:76)(cid:73)(cid:73)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:70)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:705)(cid:146)(cid:29)(cid:690)(cid:97)(cid:202)(cid:288)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:201)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:705)(cid:106)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:71)(cid:106)(cid:690) Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting [38] was proposed to address cases where the mapping of +input x to output y is non-trivial (e.g. when x is a math question and y is the final numerical answer). +The key idea is to introduce a chain of thoughts z1, · · · , zn to bridge x and y, where each zi is a +coherent language sequence that serves as a meaningful intermediate step toward problem solving +(e.g. zi could be an intermediate equation for math QA). To solve problems with CoT, each thought +zi ∼ pCoT +(y|x, z1···n). In +practice, [z1···n, y] ∼ pCoT +(z1···n, y|x) is sampled as a continuous language sequence, and the +decomposition of thoughts (e.g. is each zi a phrase, a sentence, or a paragraph) is left ambiguous. + +(zi | x, z1···i−1) is sampled sequentially, then the output y ∼ pCoT + +θ + +θ + +θ + +1···n, y(i)] ∼ pCoT + +Self-consistency with CoT (CoT-SC) [36] is an ensemble approach that samples k i.i.d. chains +of thought: [z(i) +(z1···n, y|x) (i = 1 · · · k), then returns the most frequent output: +arg maxy #{i | y(i) = y}. CoT-SC improves upon CoT, because there are generally different +thought processes for the same problem (e.g. different ways to prove the same theorem), and the +output decision can be more faithful by exploring a richer set of thoughts. However, within each +chain there is no local exploration of different thought steps, and the “most frequent” heuristic only +applies when the output space is limited (e.g. multi-choice QA). + +θ + +3 Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving with LM + +A genuine problem-solving process involves the repeated use of available informa- +tion to initiate exploration, which discloses, in turn, more information until a way +to attain the solution is finally discovered.—— Newell et al. [21] + +Research on human problem-solving suggests that people search through a combinatorial problem- +space – a tree where the nodes represent partial solutions, and the branches correspond to operators +that modify them [21, 22]. Which branch to take is determined by heuristics that help to navigate the +problem-space and guide the problem-solver towards a solution. This perspective highlights two key +shortcomings of existing approaches that use LMs to solve general problems: 1) Locally, they do not +explore different continuations within a thought process – the branches of the tree. 2) Globally, they +do not incorporate any type of planning, lookahead, or backtracking to help evaluate these different +options – the kind of heuristic-guided search that seems characteristic of human problem-solving. + +To address these shortcomings, we introduce Tree of Thoughts (ToT), a paradigm that allows LMs to +explore multiple reasoning paths over thoughts (Figure 1(c)). ToT frames any problem as a search +over a tree, where each node is a state s = [x, z1···i] representing a partial solution with the input and +the sequence of thoughts so far. A specific instantiation of ToT involves answering four questions: +1. How to decompose the intermediate process into thought steps; 2. How to generate potential +thoughts from each state; 3. How to heuristically evaluate states; 4. What search algorithm to use. + +1. Thought decomposition. While CoT samples thoughts coherently without explicit decomposition, +ToT leverages problem properties to design and decompose intermediate thought steps. As Table 1 +shows, depending on different problems, a thought could be a couple of words (Crosswords), a line of +equation (Game of 24), or a whole paragraph of writing plan (Creative Writing). In general, a thought +should be “small” enough so that LMs can generate promising and diverse samples (e.g. generating +a whole book is usually too “big” to be coherent), yet “big” enough so that LMs can evaluate its +prospect toward problem solving (e.g. generating one token is usually too “small” to evaluate). -A vector quantity deals inherently with both -magnitude and direction: +2. Thought generator G(pθ, s, k). Given a tree state s = [x, z1···i], we consider two strategies to +generate k candidates for the next thought step: -velocity, force, displacement +(a) Sample i.i.d. thoughts from a CoT prompt (Creative Writing, Figure 4): z(j) ∼ +(zi+1|x, z1···i) (j = 1 · · · k). This works better when the thought - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +pCoT +θ +space is rich (e.g. each thought is a paragraph), and i.i.d. samples lead to diversity; -Arrows are used to represent vectors. The -direction of the arrow gives the direction of -the vector. +(zi+1|s) = pCoT -By convention, the length of a vector -arrow is proportional to the magnitude -of the vector. +θ + +(b) Propose thoughts sequentially using a “propose prompt” (Game of 24, Figure 2; Crosswords, +(z(1···k) +Figure 6): [z(1), · · · , z(k)] ∼ ppropose +| s). This works better when the thought +i+1 +space is more constrained (e.g. each thought is just a word or a line), so proposing different +thoughts in the same context avoids duplication. + +θ + +3. State evaluator V (pθ, S). Given a frontier of different states, the state evaluator evaluates the +progress they make towards solving the problem, serving as a heuristic for the search algorithm +to determine which states to keep exploring and in which order. While heuristics are a standard +approach to solving search problems, they are typically either programmed (e.g. DeepBlue [3]) or + +3 -4 lb + learned (e.g. AlphaGo [29]). We propose a third alternative, by using the LM to deliberately reason +about states. When applicable, such a deliberate heuristic can be more flexible than programmed +rules, and more sample-efficient than learned models. Similar to the thought generator, we consider +two strategies to evaluate states either independently or together: -8 lb +θ - 1.5 Scalars and Vectors +(a) Value each state independently: V (pθ, S)(s) ∼ pvalue - Chapter 2 +(v|s) ∀s ∈ S, where a value +prompt reasons about the state s to generate a scalar value v (e.g. 1-10) or a classifica- +tion (e.g. sure/likely/impossible) that could be heuristically turned into a value. The basis +of such evaluative reasoning can vary across problems and thought steps. In this work, we +explore evaluation via few lookahead simulations (e.g. quickly confirm that 5, 5, 14 can +reach 24 via 5 + 5 + 14, or “hot l” can mean “inn” via filling “e” in “ ”) plus commonsense +(e.g. 1 2 3 are too small to reach 24, or no word can start with “tzxc”). While the former +might promote “good” states, the latter could help eliminate “bad” states. Such valuations +do not need to be perfect, and only need to be approximately helpful for decision making. +(s∗|S) is +voted out based on deliberately comparing different states in S in a vote prompt. When +problem success is harder to directly value (e.g. passage coherency), it is natural to to instead +compare different partial solutions and vote for the most promising one. This is similar +in spirit to a “step-wise” self-consistency strategy, i.e. cast “which state to explore” as a +multi-choice QA, and use LM samples to vote for it. -Kinematics in One Dimension +(b) Vote across states: V (pθ, S)(s) = 1[s = s∗], where a “good” state s∗ ∼ pvote - Kinematics deals with the concepts that -are needed to describe motion. +θ -Dynamics deals with the effect that forces -have on motion. +For both strategies, we could prompt the LM multiple times to aggregate the value or vote results to +trade time/resource/cost for more faithful/robust heuristics. -Together, kinematics and dynamics form -the branch of physics known as Mechanics. +Algorithm 1 ToT-BFS(x, pθ, G, k, V, T, b) +Require: Input x, LM pθ, thought generator G() +& size limit k, states evaluator V (), step limit T , +breadth limit b. +S0 ← {x} +for t = 1, · · · , T do - 2.1 Displacement +t ← {[s, z] | s ∈ St−1, zt ∈ G(pθ, s, k)} - =oxr +S′ +Vt ← V (pθ, S′ +t) +St ← arg maxS⊂S′ -initial +Algorithm 2 ToT-DFS(s, t, pθ, G, k, V, T, vth) +Require: Current state s, step t, LM pθ, thought +generator G() and size limit k, states evaluator +V (), step limit T , threshold vth +if t > T then record output G(pθ, s, 1) +end if +for s′ ∈ G(pθ, s, k) do -position +▷ sorted candidates +if V (pθ, {s′})(s) > vthres then ▷ pruning - =xr +t,|S|=b -final +(cid:80) -position +s∈S Vt(s) -!=" +DFS(s′, t + 1) -r -r -oxx +end for +return G(pθ, arg maxs∈ST VT (s), 1) -r -x +end if - = +end for -displaceme +4. Search algorithm. Finally, within the ToT framework, one can plug and play different search +algorithms depending on the tree structure. We explore two relatively simple search algorithms and +leave more advanced ones (e.g. A* [11], MCTS [2]) for future work: -nt +(a) Breadth-first search (BFS) (Algorithm 1) maintains a set of the b most promising states +per step. This is used for Game of 24 and Creative Writing where the tree depth is limit +(T ≤ 3), and initial thought steps can be evaluated and pruned to a small set (b ≤ 5). +(b) Depth-first search (DFS) (Algorithm 2) explores the most promising state first, until the +final output is reached (t > T ), or the state evaluator deems it impossible to solve the +problem from the current s (V (pθ, {s})(s) ≤ vth for a value threshold vth). In the latter +case, the subtree from s is pruned to trade exploration for exploitation. In both cases, DFS +backtracks to the parent state of s to continue exploration. - 2.1 Displacement +Conceptually, ToT has several benefits as a method for general problem-solving with LMs: (1) Gener- +ality. IO, CoT, CoT-SC, and self-refinement can be seen as special cases of ToT (i.e. trees of limited +depth and breadth; Figure 1). (2) Modularity. The base LM, as well as the thought decomposition, +generation, evaluation, and search procedures can all be varied independently. (3) Adaptability. +Different problem properties, LM capabilities, and resource constraints can be accommodated. (4) +Convenience. No extra training is needed, just a pre-trained LM is sufficient. The next section will +show how these conceptual benefits translate to strong empirical performance in different problems. -m 0.2=oxr +4 Experiments -m 0.5=!xr +We propose three tasks that are hard even when sampling from the state-of-the-art language model, +GPT-4 [23], using standard IO prompting or chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. We show how -m 0.7=xr +4 -!=" + Input -r -r -oxx +Output -r -x +Thoughts -= +#ToT steps -m 7.0 +Game of 24 -! +Creative Writing -m 0.5m 2.0 -= +5x5 Crosswords - 2.1 Displacement +4 numbers (4 9 10 13) -m 0.2=xr +4 random sentences -m 0.5!="xr +10 clues (h1. presented;..) -m 0.7=oxr +An equation to reach 24 +(13-9)*(10-4)=24 -!=" +A passage of 4 paragraphs +ending in the 4 sentences -r -r -oxx +5x5 letters: +WIRRA; AVAIL; ... -r -x +SHOWN; -= +3 intermediate equations +(13-9=4 (left 4,4,10); 10- +4=6 (left 4,6); 4*6=24) -m 2.0 +A short writing plan +(1. Introduce a book that +connects...) -! +Words to fill in for clues: +(h1. shown; v5. naled; ...) -m 7.0 +3 +Table 1: Task overview. Input, output, thought examples are in blue. -!= +5-10 (variable) -m 0.5 +1 - 2.1 Displacement +deliberate search in trees of thoughts (ToT) produces better results, and more importantly, interesting +and promising new ways to use language models to solve problems requiring search or planning. +Unless otherwise stated, we perform experiments using a Chat Completion mode GPT-41 with a +sampling temperature of 0.7. + +4.1 Game of 24 + +Game of 24 is a mathematical reasoning challenge, where the goal is to use 4 numbers and basic +arithmetic operations (+-*/) to obtain 24. For example, given input “4 9 10 13”, a solution output +could be “(10 - 4) * (13 - 9) = 24”. + +Figure 2: ToT in a game of 24. The LM is prompted for (a) thought generation and (b) valuation. + +Task Setup. We scrape data from 4nums.com, which has 1,362 games that are sorted from easy to +hard by human solving time, and use a subset of relatively hard games indexed 901-1,000 for testing. +For each task, we consider the output as success if it is a valid equation that equals 24 and uses the +input numbers each exactly once. We report the success rate across 100 games as the metric. + +Baselines. We use a standard input-output (IO) prompt with 5 in-context examples. For chain-of- +thought (CoT) prompting, we augment each input-output pair with 3 intermediate equations, each +operating on two remaining numbers. For example, given input “4 9 10 13”, the thoughts could be +“13 - 9 = 4 (left: 4 4 10); 10 - 4 = 6 (left: 4 6); 4 * 6 = 24 (left: 24)”. For each game, we sample IO +and CoT prompting for 100 times for average performance. We also consider a CoT self-consistency +baseline, which takes the majority output from 100 CoT samples, and an iterative-refine approach on +top of an IO sample for at most 10 iterations. At each iteration, the LM is conditioned on all previous +history to “reflect on your mistakes and generate a refined answer” if the output is incorrect. Note +that it uses groundtruth feedback signals about equation correctness. + +ToT Setup. To frame Game of 24 into ToT, it is natural to decompose the thoughts into 3 steps, +each an intermediate equation. As shown in Figure 2(a), at each tree node, we exact the remaining +numbers and prompt the LM to propose some possible next steps. The same “propose prompt” is +used for all 3 thought steps, though it only has one example with 4 input numbers. We perform a +breadth-first search (BFS) in ToT, where at each step we keep the best b = 5 candidates. To perform +deliberate BFS in ToT, as shown in Figure 2(b), we prompt LM to evaluate each thought candidate as +“sure/maybe/impossible” with regard to reaching 24. The aim is to promote correct partial solutions +that can be verdicted within few lookahead trials, and eliminate impossible partial solutions based on +“too big/small” commonsense, and keep the rest “maybe”. We sample values 3 times for each thought. + +1Experiments were done between May 5-16, 2023. + +5 + +(cid:691)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:137)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:349)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:692)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:42)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:41)(cid:383)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:683)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:683)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:691)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:692)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:57)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:689)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:646)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:643)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:230)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:705)(cid:641)(cid:784)(cid:643)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:644)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:644)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:641)(cid:678)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:690)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:137)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:349)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:11)(cid:68)(cid:12)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:692)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:42)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:41)(cid:383)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:683)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:683)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:691)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:202)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:692)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:12)(cid:3)(cid:57)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:689)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:714)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:678)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:646)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:780)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:784)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:230)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:47)(cid:48)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:705)(cid:641)(cid:784)(cid:643)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:644)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:644)(cid:740)(cid:646)(cid:690)(cid:638)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:646)(cid:784)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:643)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:641)(cid:678)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:641)(cid:690)(cid:641)(cid:780)(cid:643)(cid:784)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:409)(cid:412)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:637)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:78)(cid:3)(cid:71)(cid:76)(cid:73)(cid:73)(cid:3)(cid:83)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:80)(cid:83)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:90)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:75)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85) Method + +Success + +IO prompt +CoT prompt +CoT-SC (k=100) +ToT (ours) (b=1) +ToT (ours) (b=5) + +IO + Refine (k=10) +IO (best of 100) +CoT (best of 100) + +7.3% +4.0% +9.0% +45% +74% + +27% +33% +49% + +Table 2: Game of 24 Results. + +Figure 3: Game of 24 (a) scale analysis & (b) error analysis. + +Results. As shown in Table 2, IO, CoT, and CoT-SC prompting methods perform badly on the task, +achieving only 7.3%, 4.0%, and 9.0% success rates. In contrast, ToT with a breadth of b = 1 already +achieves a success rate of 45%, while b = 5 achieves 74%. We also consider an oracle setup for +IO/CoT, by calculating the success rate using best of k samples (1 ≤ k ≤ 100). To compare IO/CoT +(best of k) with ToT, we consider calculating the tree nodes visited per task in ToT across b = 1 · · · 5, +and map the 5 success rates in Figure 3(a), treating IO/CoT (best of k) as visiting k nodes in a bandit. +Not surprisingly, CoT scales better than IO, and best of 100 CoT samples achieve a success rate of +49%, but still much worse than exploring more nodes in ToT (b > 1). + +Error analysis. Figure 3(b) breaks down at which step CoT and ToT samples fail the task, i.e. the +thought (in CoT) or all b thoughts (in ToT) are invalid or impossible to reach 24. Notably, around +60% of CoT samples already failed the task after generating the first step, or equivalently, the first +three words (e.g. “4 + 9”). This highlights the issues with direct left-to-right decoding. + +4.2 Creative writing + +Next, we invent a creative writing task where the input is 4 random sentences and the output should +be a coherent passage with 4 paragraphs that end in the 4 input sentences respectively. Such a task is +open-ended and exploratory, and challenges creative thinking as well as high-level planning. + +Task setup. We sample random sentences from randomwordgenerator.com to form 100 inputs, and +there is no groundtruth passage for each input constraint. As we find that GPT-4 can follow the +input constraints most of the time, we focus on evaluating passage coherency in two ways: using a +GPT-4 zero-shot prompt to provide a 1-10 scalar score, or using human judgments to compare pairs +of outputs from different methods. For the former, we sample 5 scores and average them for each task +output, and we find these 5 scores usually consistent, with a standard deviation of around 0.56 on +average across outputs. For the latter, we employ a subset of the authors in a blind study to compare +the coherency of CoT vs. ToT generated passage pairs, where the order of passages is random flipped +over 100 inputs. + +Baselines. Given the creative nature of the task, both IO and CoT prompts are zero-shot. While the +former prompts the LM to directly generate a coherent passage given input constraints, the latter +prompts the LM to first make a brief plan then write the passage, i.e. the plan serves as the intermediate +thought step. We generate 10 IO and CoT samples per task. We also consider an iterative-refine +(k ≤ 5) method on top of a random IO sample for each task, where the LM is conditioned on input +constraints and the last generated passage to decide if the passage is already “perfectly coherent”, +and if not generate a refined one. + +ToT setup. We build a ToT with depth 2 (and only 1 intermediate thought step) — the LM first +generates k = 5 plans and votes for the best one (Figure 4), then similarly generate k = 5 passages +based on the best plan then vote for the best one. Here the breadth limit b = 1, as only one choice is +kept per step. A simple zero-shot vote prompt (“analyze choices below, then conclude which is most +promising for the instruction”) is used to sample 5 votes at both steps. + +Results. Figure 5(a) shows average GPT-4 scores across 100 tasks, where ToT (7.56) is deemed to +generate more coherent passages than IO (6.19) and CoT (6.93) on average. While such an automatic +metric might be noisy, Figure 5(b) confirms the finding by showing that humans prefer ToT over +CoT in 41 out of 100 passage pairs, while only prefer CoT over ToT in 21 (other 38 pairs are found +“similarly coherent”). Lastly, iterative-refine is more effective on this natural language task, where + +6 + +02550751000.20.40.6(a) Success rate with nodes visitedIO (best of k)CoT (best of k)ToT (b=1...5)1234Correct0.00.20.40.6(b) Samples failed at each stepCoTToT (b=5) Figure 4: A step of deliberate search in a randomly picked Creative Writing task. Given the input, the +LM samples 5 different plans, then votes 5 times to decide which plan is best. The majority choice is +used to consequently write the output passage with the same sample-vote procedure. + +Method + +Success Rate (%) +Letter Word Game + +IO +CoT +ToT (ours) + ++best state +-prune +-backtrack + +38.7 14 +0 +40.6 15.6 1 +60 +78 + +20 + +82.4 67.5 35 +65.4 41.5 5 +5 +54.6 20 + +Table 3: Mini Crosswords results. + +Figure 5: Creative Writing results. + +it improves IO coherency score from 6.19 to 7.67, and ToT coherency score from 7.56 to 7.91. We +believe it could be thought of as a third approach to thought generation in the ToT framework, where +new thoughts can arise from refining old thoughts instead of i.i.d. or sequentially generated. + +4.3 Mini crosswords + +In Game of 24 and Creative Writing, ToT is relatively shallow — at most 3 thought steps are needed +to reach the final output. Here we explore 5 × 5 mini crosswords as a harder search problem involving +natural language. Again, the goal is not just to solve the task, as more general crosswords can be +readily solved with specialized NLP pipelines [34] that leverages large-scale retrieval instead of LM. +Rather, we aim to explore the limit of LM as a general problem solver that explores its own thoughts +and guides its own exploration with deliberate reasoning as heuristics. + +Task setup. We scrape data from GooBix, which contains 156 games of 5 × 5 mini crosswords. As +we observe adjacent games contain similar clues, we use 20 games with indices 1, 6, · · · , 91, 96 for +testing, and games 136, 141, 146, 151, 156 for prompting. For each task, the input describes the 5 +horizontal clues and 5 vertical clues, and the output should be a board of 5 × 5 = 25 letters to solve +the crosswords. For evaluation, we consider three levels of success: the portion of correct letters (25 +per game), words (10 per game), and games. + +Baselines. We provide 5 example input-output pairs in the IO prompt, and in the CoT prompt +additionally include intermediate words in the order h1..5 then v1..5. We run each prompt for 10 +samples and average the results. + +ToT setup. We leverage a depth-first search (Algorithm 2) that keeps exploring the most promising +subsequent word clue until the state is no longer promising, then backtrack to the parent state to +explore alternative thoughts. To make search tractable, subsequent thoughts are constrained not to +change any filled words or letters, so that the ToT has at most 10 intermediate steps. For thought +generation, at each state we translate all existing thoughts (e.g. “h2.motor; h1.tasks” for the state +in Figure 6(a)) into letter constraints for remaining clues (e.g. “v1.To heap: tm ;...”) and prompt +a proposal prompt 5 times to come up with candidates for where and what to fill in the next word. +Importantly, we also prompt the LM to give a confidence level for different thoughts, and aggregate + +7 + +(cid:181)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:294)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:288)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:181)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:302)(cid:722)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:340)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:41)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:302)(cid:403)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:689)(cid:640)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:180)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:637)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:671)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:640)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:638)(cid:639)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:41)(cid:76)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:69)(cid:92)(cid:3)(cid:60)(cid:88)(cid:84)(cid:76)(cid:68)(cid:81)(cid:12)(cid:181)(cid:343)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:294)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:288)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:181)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:302)(cid:722)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:273)(cid:291)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:340)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:41)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:302)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:302)(cid:403)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:309)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:146)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:237)(cid:361)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:349)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:389)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:361)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:231)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:309)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:384)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:273)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:340)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:356)(cid:390)(cid:667)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:349)(cid:689)(cid:231)(cid:690)(cid:740)(cid:180)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:638)(cid:137)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:637)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:638)(cid:671)(cid:667)(cid:639)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:640)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:640)(cid:705)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:56)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:71)(cid:18)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:3)(cid:87)(cid:82)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:90)(cid:3)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:81)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:76)(cid:70)(cid:72)(cid:302)(cid:683)(cid:642)(cid:740)(cid:383)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:137)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:1)(cid:302)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:390)(cid:399)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:202)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:638)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:263)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:349)(cid:340)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:342)(cid:361)(cid:273)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:408)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:340)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:309)(cid:309)(cid:291)(cid:729)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:71)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:231)(cid:356)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:270)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:384)(cid:403)(cid:412)(cid:270)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:409)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:242)(cid:294)(cid:409)(cid:714)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:309)(cid:383)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:740)(cid:242)(cid:301)(cid:230)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:668)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:291)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:407)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:309)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:242)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:154)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:231)(cid:270)(cid:309)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:403)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:639)(cid:667)IOCoTToTIO+refineToT+refine468(a) GPT-4 coherency scoresCoT > ToTSimilarToT > CoT010203040213841(b) Human coherency comparison Figure 6: In Mini Crosswords, (a) how thoughts are proposed and aggregated in a priority queue +for depth-first search (DFS), and (b) how a state is evaluated based on the possibility of filling in +each remaining word clue, and pruned if any remaining clue is deemed not possible to fill by the LM. +Then DFS backtracks to the parent state and explore the next promising thought for clue. + +these across proposals to obtain a sorted list of next thoughts to explore (Figure 6(a)). For state +evaluations, we similarly translate each state into letter constraints for remaining clues, then evaluate +for each clue if it is possible to fill given the constraints. If any remaining clue is deemed “impossible” +to fill in (e.g. “v1. To heap: tm s ”), then the exploration of the state’s subtree is pruned and DFS +backtracks to its parent to explore the next promising thought. We limit DFS search steps to 100, and +simply render the deepest explored state (the first explored one if multiple) into the final output. + +Results. As shown in Table 3, IO and CoT prompting methods perform poorly with a word-level +success rate less than 16%, while ToT significantly improves all metrics, achieving a word-level +success rate of 60% and solving 4 out of 20 games. Such an improvement is not surprising, given IO +and CoT lack mechanisms to try different clues, make changes to decisions, or backtrack. + +Oracle and ablation studies. When outputting from the oracle best DFS state (instead of the +heuristically determined best state) per task, ToT performance is even higher and actually solves +7/20 games (Table 3, “+best state”), indicating our simple output heuristics can be readily improved. +Interestingly, sometimes when the crosswords game is actually solved, the state evaluator might still +deem some words as “impossible” and prune — possibly because 5 × 5 crosswords by design have +some rare or obselete words that GPT-4 cannot recognize2. Given the state evaluation as a pruning +heuristic is imperfect, we also explore ablating the pruning, and find the performance generally worse +(Table 3, “-prune”). However, it could actually find the correct solution for 4/20 games (though only +outputting 1 via heuristic), 3 of which are games ToT+pruning cannot solve within 100 steps. Thus, +better heuristics for DFS pruning are critical for problem solving in this case. Lastly, we confirm the +importance of backtracking by running an ablation that keeps filling the most promising clue for at +most 20 steps, allowing overwrites. This is similar to a “greedy” BFS search with breadth limit of +b = 1, and performs poorly with a word level success of only 20% (Table 3, “-backtrack”). + +5 Related Work + +Planning and decision making. Smart planning and decision making are critical to achieving +predefined goals. As they are trained on vast amount of world knowledge and human examples, LMs +are known to have already absorbed rich commonsense that makes it possible to propose reasonable +plans conditioned on problem setting and environmental states [12, 42, 37, 13, 35, 41, 40]. Our +proposed ToT approach extends existing planning formulations by considering multiple potentially +feasible plans simultaneously at each problem-solving step, and proceeding with the most promising +ones. The integration between thought sampling and value feedback organically integrates planning +and decision-making mechanisms, enabling effective search inside a solution tree. On the other hand, +traditional decision-making procedures usually require training dedicated reward and policy models +as in reinforcement learning (for example CHAI [33]), whereas we use the LM itself to provide +the value estimates for decision making. RAP [9] is a concurrent work that treats language model + +2For example, “agend” is an obsolete form of “agendum”, but GPT-4 deems it a typo for “agenda”. External + +retrieval or web interaction could augment LM for problem solving under knowledge uncertainty. + +8 + +(cid:62)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:21)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:83)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:28)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:24)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:87)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:25)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:80)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:23)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:90)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:21)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:76)(cid:81)(cid:71)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:10)(cid:75)(cid:23)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:10)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:19)(cid:17)(cid:20)(cid:12)(cid:64)(cid:10)(cid:89)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:72)(cid:10)(cid:48)(cid:88)(cid:79)(cid:87)(cid:76)(cid:83)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:85)(cid:88)(cid:81)(cid:86)(cid:51)(cid:68)(cid:85)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:79)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:81)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:16)(cid:73)(cid:76)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:16)(cid:79)(cid:72)(cid:87)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:15)(cid:3)(cid:68)(cid:74)(cid:74)(cid:85)(cid:72)(cid:74)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:38)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:86)(cid:82)(cid:73)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:86)(cid:72)(cid:79)(cid:73)(cid:16)(cid:70)(cid:82)(cid:81)(cid:86)(cid:76)(cid:86)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:81)(cid:70)(cid:92)(cid:34)(cid:12)(cid:20)(cid:17)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:91)(cid:21)(cid:17)(cid:48)(cid:68)(cid:91)(cid:3)(cid:90)(cid:76)(cid:87)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:89)(cid:76)(cid:82)(cid:79)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:22)(cid:17)(cid:39)(cid:41)(cid:54)(cid:71)(cid:302)(cid:340)(cid:361)(cid:412)(cid:740)(cid:29)(cid:294)(cid:361)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:639)(cid:667)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:270)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:408)(cid:202)(cid:349)(cid:291)(cid:349)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:202)(cid:264)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:264)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:137)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:356)(cid:242)(cid:302)(cid:412)(cid:403)(cid:309)(cid:361)(cid:349)(cid:670)(cid:740)(cid:410)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:242)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:54)(cid:87)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:72)(cid:3)(cid:40)(cid:89)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:68)(cid:87)(cid:82)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:11)(cid:82)(cid:89)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:3)(cid:72)(cid:68)(cid:70)(cid:75)(cid:3)(cid:70)(cid:79)(cid:88)(cid:72)(cid:12)(cid:383)(cid:638)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:201)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:270)(cid:242)(cid:202)(cid:340)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:301)(cid:712)(cid:349)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:273)(cid:301)(cid:340)(cid:309)(cid:349)(cid:349)(cid:273)(cid:230)(cid:294)(cid:242)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:35)(cid:242)(cid:349)(cid:403)(cid:231)(cid:231)(cid:202)(cid:356)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:670)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:309)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:669)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:712)(cid:302)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:691)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:667)(cid:692)(cid:740)(cid:301)(cid:202)(cid:390)(cid:230)(cid:242)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:231)(cid:291)(cid:690)(cid:270)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:230)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:242)(cid:740)(cid:340)(cid:343)(cid:361)(cid:302)(cid:242)(cid:237)(cid:690)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:270)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:264)(cid:343)(cid:202)(cid:302)(cid:237)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:39)(cid:41)(cid:54)(cid:3)(cid:50)(cid:85)(cid:71)(cid:72)(cid:85)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:270)(cid:641)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:202)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:302)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:349)(cid:361)(cid:343)(cid:242)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:642)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:343)(cid:237)(cid:343)(cid:390)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:294)(cid:309)(cid:384)(cid:690)(cid:383)(cid:640)(cid:667)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:412)(cid:343)(cid:273)(cid:302)(cid:264)(cid:740)(cid:689)(cid:270)(cid:403)(cid:264)(cid:270)(cid:690)(cid:671)(cid:671)(cid:55)(cid:75)(cid:82)(cid:88)(cid:74)(cid:75)(cid:87)(cid:3)(cid:51)(cid:85)(cid:82)(cid:83)(cid:82)(cid:86)(cid:68)(cid:79)(cid:86)(cid:689)(cid:202)(cid:690)(cid:689)(cid:230)(cid:690)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:291)(cid:740)(cid:349)(cid:301)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:411)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:343)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:349)(cid:740)(cid:202)(cid:740)(cid:294)(cid:740)(cid:309)(cid:740)(cid:302)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712)(cid:740)(cid:712) reasoning as planning with its internal world model, and proposes a MCTS-based method similar to +ToT. However, its tasks are simpler than ours, and its framework lacks the modularity to incorporate +different tree search algorithms. + +Self-reflection. Using LLMs to assess the viability of their own predictions is becoming an in- +creasingly important procedure in problem solving. [28, 20, 24] introduced the “self-reflection” +mechanism, in which LMs provide feedback to their generation candidates. [4] improves LMs code +generation accuracy by injecting feedback messages generated by the LM itself based on its code +execution results. Similarly, [17] also introduces “critic” or review steps over the actions and states, +deciding the next action to take in solving computer operation tasks. Another recent work very +relevant to ours is “self-eval guided decoding” [39]. Similar to our method, self-eval decoding +also follows a tree-search procedure with leaves sampled from stochastic beam search decoding, +which are then evaluated by LLM itself with carefully prepared self-eval prompts. Their approach +however, uses the PAL formulation [8] which represents thoughts as codes, which makes it difficult +to tackle challenging tasks like creative writing which we consider in this paper. Our Tree-of-Thought +formulation is thus more versatile and handles challenging tasks on which GPT-4 only achieves very +low accuracy with standard prompts. + +Program-guided LLM generation. Our proposal is also related to recent advancements that organize +LM’s behavior with systematic procedures [14, 44, 6, 43] or symbolic program guidance. For example, +Schlag et al. [27] embeds LMs in an algorithmic search procedure to help solve problems like question +answering step-by-step, in which the search trees are expanded by relevant paragraphs that might +provide answers. This approach however differs from ours in that trees are expanded by sampling +external paragraphs instead of the LM’s own thoughts, and there is no reflection or voting steps. +Another approach, LLM+P [18], goes one step further and delegates the actual planning process to a +classical planner. + +Classical search methods. Last but not least, our approach can be treated as a modern rendition +of classical search methods for problem solving. For example it can be considered as a heuristic +search algorithm like A* [10], in which the heuristic at each search node is provided by the LM’s self- +assessment. From this perspective, our method is also related to NeuroLogic A*esque decoding [19], +which is inspired by A* search but introduces look-ahead heuristics that are efficient for LMs to +improve the beam-search or top-k sampling decoding. This method however is constrained to +sentence generation tasks, whereas our framework are designed for complex, multi-step problem +solving guarded by value feedback. + +6 Discussion + +Limitations and future directions. Deliberate search such as ToT might not be necessary for many +existing tasks that GPT-4 already excels at (see Appendix B.1), and as an initial step this work only +explores three relatively simple tasks that challenges GPT-4 (see Appendix B.2 for some GPT-3.5 +experiment results) and calls of better search and planning abilities incorporated with LMs. However, +as we begin to deploy LMs for more real-world decision making applications (e.g. coding, data +analysis, robotics, etc.), more complex tasks could emerge and present new opportunities to study +these research questions. Also, search methods like ToT requires more resources (e.g. GPT-4 API +cost) than sampling methods in order to improve task performances, but the modular flexibility of +ToT allows users to customize such performance-cost tradeoffs, and ongoing open-source efforts [32] +should readily reduce such costs in the near future. More details about cost and efficiency are in +Appendix B.3. Lastly, this work focuses on using an off-the-shelf LM, and fine-tuning LMs using +a ToT-style high-level counterfactual decision making (e.g. deliberating over potential choices for +the next paragraph, instead of predicting the next token) might present opportunities to enhance the +problem-solving capabilities of LMs. + +Conclusion. The associative “System 1” of LMs can be beneficially augmented by a “System 2” +based on searching a tree of possible paths to the solution to a problem. The Tree of Thoughts +framework provides a way to translate classical insights about problem-solving into actionable +methods for contemporary LMs. At the same time, LMs address a weakness of these classical +methods, providing a way to solve complex problems that are not easily formalized, such as creative +writing. We see this intersection of LMs with classical approaches to AI as an exciting direction. -m 0.2!=oxr +9 -m 0.5=xr + Broader Impact -m 0.7=!xr +ToT is a framework that empowers LMs to more autonomously and intelligently make decisions +and solve problems. While current tasks are limited to reasoning and search problems, future +applications involving interaction with external environments or humans could bring potential danger, +e.g. facilitating harmful uses of LMs. On the other hand, ToT also improves the interpretability +of model decisions and the opportunity for human alignment, as the resulting representations are +readable, high-level language reasoning instead of implicit, low-level token values. -!=" +Acknowledgements -r -r -oxx +SY and KN acknowledge support from an Oracle Collaborative Research award and the National +Science Foundation under Grant No. 2239363. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommenda- +tions expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of +the National Science Foundation. SY is also supported by the Harold W. Dodds Fellowship from +Princeton. -r -x +References -= +[1] T. Brown, B. Mann, N. Ryder, M. Subbiah, J. D. Kaplan, P. Dhariwal, A. Neelakantan, P. Shyam, +G. Sastry, A. Askell, et al. Language models are few-shot learners. Advances in neural +information processing systems, 33:1877–1901, 2020. -m 5.0 +[2] C. Browne, E. J. Powley, D. Whitehouse, S. M. M. Lucas, P. I. Cowling, P. Rohlfshagen, +S. Tavener, D. P. Liebana, S. Samothrakis, and S. Colton. A survey of monte carlo tree search +methods. IEEE Transactions on Computational Intelligence and AI in Games, 4:1–43, 2012. -( -!! +[3] M. Campbell, A. J. Hoane Jr, and F.-h. Hsu. Deep blue. Artificial intelligence, 134(1-2):57–83, -.02 ) -m 0.7m +2002. -= +[4] X. Chen, M. Lin, N. Sch¨arli, and D. Zhou. Teaching large language models to self-debug, 2023. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[5] A. Chowdhery, S. Narang, J. Devlin, M. Bosma, G. Mishra, A. Roberts, P. Barham, H. W. +Chung, C. Sutton, S. Gehrmann, et al. Palm: Scaling language modeling with pathways. arXiv +preprint arXiv:2204.02311, 2022. -Average speed is the distance traveled divided by the time -required to cover the distance. +[6] A. Creswell and M. Shanahan. Faithful reasoning using large language models. arXiv preprint -Average +arXiv:2208.14271, 2022. -speed +[7] N. D. Daw, Y. Niv, and P. Dayan. Uncertainty-based competition between prefrontal and +dorsolateral striatal systems for behavioral control. Nature neuroscience, 8(12):1704–1711, +2005. -= +[8] L. Gao, A. Madaan, S. Zhou, U. Alon, P. Liu, Y. Yang, J. Callan, and G. Neubig. Pal: Program- -Distance +aided language models, 2023. -Elapsed +[9] S. Hao, Y. Gu, H. Ma, J. J. Hong, Z. Wang, D. Z. Wang, and Z. Hu. Reasoning with language - time +model is planning with world model. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.14992, 2023. -SI units for speed: meters per second (m/s) +[10] P. E. Hart, N. J. Nilsson, and B. Raphael. A formal basis for the heuristic determination of +minimum cost paths. IEEE Transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics, 4(2):100–107, +1968. doi: 10.1109/TSSC.1968.300136. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[11] P. E. Hart, N. J. Nilsson, and B. Raphael. A formal basis for the heuristic determination of +minimum cost paths. IEEE transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics, 4(2):100–107, +1968. -Example 1 Distance Run by a Jogger +[12] W. Huang, P. Abbeel, D. Pathak, and I. Mordatch. Language models as zero-shot planners: -How far does a jogger run in 1.5 hours (5400 s) if his -average speed is 2.22 m/s? +Extracting actionable knowledge for embodied agents, 2022. -Average +[13] W. Huang, F. Xia, T. Xiao, H. Chan, J. Liang, P. Florence, A. Zeng, J. Tompson, I. Mordatch, +Y. Chebotar, et al. Inner monologue: Embodied reasoning through planning with language +models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2207.05608, 2022. -speed +10 -= + [14] J. Jung, L. Qin, S. Welleck, F. Brahman, C. Bhagavatula, R. L. Bras, and Y. Choi. Maieu- +tic prompting: Logically consistent reasoning with recursive explanations. arXiv preprint +arXiv:2205.11822, 2022. -Distance +[15] D. Kahneman. Thinking, fast and slow. Macmillan, 2011. -Elapsed +[16] D. Kahneman, S. Frederick, et al. Representativeness revisited: Attribute substitution in intuitive - time +judgment. Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgment, 49(49-81):74, 2002. -Distance +[17] G. Kim, P. Baldi, and S. McAleer. Language models can solve computer tasks, 2023. -= -( -sm 22.2 +[18] B. Liu, Y. Jiang, X. Zhang, Q. Liu, S. Zhang, J. Biswas, and P. Stone. Llm+p: Empowering -= +large language models with optimal planning proficiency, 2023. -( -Average -) -)( -5400 +[19] X. Lu, S. Welleck, P. West, L. Jiang, J. Kasai, D. Khashabi, R. L. Bras, L. Qin, Y. Yu, +R. Zellers, N. A. Smith, and Y. Choi. Neurologic a*esque decoding: Constrained text generation +with lookahead heuristics. In North American Chapter of the Association for Computational +Linguistics, 2021. -s +[20] A. Madaan, N. Tandon, P. Gupta, S. Hallinan, L. Gao, S. Wiegreffe, U. Alon, N. Dziri, +S. Prabhumoye, Y. Yang, S. Welleck, B. P. Majumder, S. Gupta, A. Yazdanbakhsh, and P. Clark. +Self-refine: Iterative refinement with self-feedback, 2023. -= +[21] A. Newell, J. C. Shaw, and H. A. Simon. Report on a general problem solving program. In IFIP -speed +congress, volume 256, page 64. Pittsburgh, PA, 1959. -)( -Elapsed -12000 -m +[22] A. Newell, H. A. Simon, et al. Human problem solving. Prentice-Hall, 1972. - time +[23] OpenAI. Gpt-4 technical report. ArXiv, abs/2303.08774, 2023. -) +[24] D. Paul, M. Ismayilzada, M. Peyrard, B. Borges, A. Bosselut, R. West, and B. Faltings. Refiner: - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +Reasoning feedback on intermediate representations, 2023. -Average velocity is the displacement divided by the elapsed -time. +[25] A. Radford, K. Narasimhan, T. Salimans, I. Sutskever, et al. Improving language understanding -Average +by generative pre-training. OpenAI blog, 2018. - velocity +[26] A. Radford, J. Wu, R. Child, D. Luan, D. Amodei, I. Sutskever, et al. Language models are -= +unsupervised multitask learners. OpenAI blog, 1(8):9, 2019. -Displaceme -Elapsed +[27] I. Schlag, S. Sukhbaatar, A. Celikyilmaz, W. tau Yih, J. Weston, J. Schmidhuber, and X. Li. -nt - time +Large language model programs, 2023. -r -v +[28] N. Shinn, B. Labash, and A. Gopinath. Reflexion: an autonomous agent with dynamic memory -= +and self-reflection, 2023. -r -r -xx -" -t -t -" +[29] D. Silver, J. Schrittwieser, K. Simonyan, I. Antonoglou, A. Huang, A. Guez, T. Hubert, L. Baker, +M. Lai, A. Bolton, et al. Mastering the game of go without human knowledge. nature, 550 +(7676):354–359, 2017. -o +[30] S. A. Sloman. The empirical case for two systems of reasoning. Psychological bulletin, 119(1): -o +3, 1996. -= +[31] K. E. Stanovich. Who is rational? Studies of individual differences in reasoning. Psychology -r -x -! -t -! +Press, 1999. - 2.2 Speed and Velocity +[32] H. Touvron, T. Lavril, G. Izacard, X. Martinet, M.-A. Lachaux, T. Lacroix, B. Rozi`ere, N. Goyal, +E. Hambro, F. Azhar, et al. Llama: Open and efficient foundation language models. arXiv +preprint arXiv:2302.13971, 2023. -Example 2 The World’s Fastest Jet-Engine Car +[33] S. Verma, J. Fu, S. Yang, and S. Levine. Chai: A chatbot ai for task-oriented dialogue with +offline reinforcement learning. In Proceedings of the 2022 Conference of the North American +Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, +pages 4471–4491, 2022. -Andy Green in the car ThrustSSC set a world record of -341.1 m/s in 1997. To establish such a record, the driver -makes two runs through the course, one in each direction, -to nullify wind effects. From the data, determine the average -velocity for each run. +11 - 2.2 Speed and Velocity + [34] E. Wallace, N. Tomlin, A. Xu, K. Yang, E. Pathak, M. Ginsberg, and D. Klein. Automated -r -v +crossword solving. arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.09665, 2022. -= +[35] L. Wang, W. Xu, Y. Lan, Z. Hu, Y. Lan, R. K.-W. Lee, and E.-P. Lim. Plan-and-solve prompting: -r -x -! -t -! +Improving zero-shot chain-of-thought reasoning by large language models, 2023. -= +[36] X. Wang, J. Wei, D. Schuurmans, Q. Le, E. Chi, and D. Zhou. Self-consistency improves chain -1609 -+ -4.740 +of thought reasoning in language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2203.11171, 2022. -m -s +[37] Z. Wang, S. Cai, A. Liu, X. Ma, and Y. Liang. Describe, explain, plan and select: Interactive -+= +planning with large language models enables open-world multi-task agents, 2023. -339 +[38] J. Wei, X. Wang, D. Schuurmans, M. Bosma, E. Chi, Q. Le, and D. Zhou. Chain of thought +prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2201.11903, 2022. -sm5. +[39] Y. Xie, K. Kawaguchi, Y. Zhao, X. Zhao, M.-Y. Kan, J. He, and Q. Xie. Decomposition -r -v +enhances reasoning via self-evaluation guided decoding, 2023. -= +[40] S. Yang, O. Nachum, Y. Du, J. Wei, P. Abbeel, and D. Schuurmans. Foundation models for -r -x -" -t -" +decision making: Problems, methods, and opportunities, 2023. -= +[41] S. Yao, J. Zhao, D. Yu, N. Du, I. Shafran, K. Narasimhan, and Y. Cao. ReAct: Synergizing -1609 -! -4.695 +reasoning and acting in language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.03629, 2022. -m -s +[42] S. Zhang, Z. Chen, Y. Shen, M. Ding, J. B. Tenenbaum, and C. Gan. Planning with large +language models for code generation. In The Eleventh International Conference on Learning +Representations, 2023. URL https://openreview.net/forum?id=Lr8cOOtYbfL. -!= +[43] D. Zhou, N. Sch¨arli, L. Hou, J. Wei, N. Scales, X. Wang, D. Schuurmans, C. Cui, O. Bousquet, +Q. Le, et al. Least-to-most prompting enables complex reasoning in large language models. +arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.10625, 2022. -342 +[44] X. Zhu, J. Wang, L. Zhang, Y. Zhang, R. Gan, J. Zhang, and Y. Yang. Solving math word +problem via cooperative reasoning induced language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.16257, +2022. -sm7. +12 - 2.2 Speed and Velocity + A Code, Prompts, Trajectories -The instantaneous velocity indicates how fast -the car moves and the direction of motion at each -instant of time. +All code is available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm. -r -v +All prompts are available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm/ +tree/master/src/tot/prompts. -= +Trajectories are available at https://github.com/princeton-nlp/tree-of-thought-llm/ +tree/master/logs. -lim -t -0 -"! +B Additional Experiment Results -r -x -! -t -! +Given the motivation of exploring and extending the capability frontier of language models, our +experiments in the main paper have focused on a setup with the state-of-the-art language model +(GPT-4), and three hard tasks invented to challenge it. Here, we report additional experiments with +weaker LLM or easier tasks, and discuss cost and efficiency. - 2.3 Acceleration +GSM8K StrategyQA -The notion of acceleration emerges when a change in -velocity is combined with the time during which the -change occurs. +GPT-4 GPT-3.5 - 2.3 Acceleration +GPT-4 GPT-3.5 -DEFINITION OF AVERAGE ACCELERATION +51 +IO +CoT 86 +90 +ToT -r -a +73 +82 +83 -= +7.3% +IO +CoT 4.0% +ToT -r -r -vv -" -t -t -" +74% 19% -o +6% +3% -o +6.19 +IO +CoT 6.93 +7.56 +ToT -= +4.47 +5.16 +6.62 -r -v -! -t -! +Table 4: New tasks with +zero-shot ToT and GPT-4. - 2.3 Acceleration +Table 5: Game of 24 with +GPT-4 vs GPT-3.5. -Example 3 Acceleration and Increasing Velocity +Table 6: Creative Writing with +GPT-4 vs. GPT-3.5. -Determine the average acceleration of the plane. +B.1 Extension to new tasks (GSM8k, StrategyQA) with zero-shot ToT -sm0=ovr +While more common NLP tasks might be too easy for GPT-4 and do not require ToT (which is why +we considered harder new tasks), we believe applying ToT to new tasks could be straightforward. +For example, we implemented a simple and generic zero-shot ToT-BFS similar to creative writing +(sample 5 problem solving strategies then vote for the best one; then sample 5 solutions based on the +best strategy then vote for the best one) for GSM8K and StrategyQA with few extra lines of code: -=vr +# define the answer format of new tasks +gsm8k_format = ‘"the answer is n" where n is a number’ +strategyqa_format = ‘either "the answer is yes" or "the answer is no"’ -260 +# define zero-shot io prompting +standard_prompt = ‘Answer the following question with {format}: {input}’ -km +# define thought format for zero-shot cot and zero-shot tot +cot_prompt = ‘‘‘Answer the following question: {input} -h +Make a strategy then write. Your output should be of the following format: -s 0=ot +Strategy: +Your strategy about how to answer the question. -s 29=t +Answer: +Your answer to the question. It should end with {format}. +’’’ -r -a +# define zero-shot voting used for zero-shot tot +vote_prompt = ‘‘‘Given an instruction and several choices, +decide which choice is most promising. +Analyze each choice in detail, then conclude in the last line +"The best choice is {s}", where s the integer id of the choice. +’’’ -= +13 -r -r -vv -! -t -t -! + We evaluated on a subset of 100 random GSM8K test and StrategyQA dev questions. As shown +in Table 4 and as expected, ToT improves over CoT on both tasks (but only slightly, given GPT-4 ++ CoT is already very good on such tasks, and StrategyQA’s bottleneck is external knowledge, not +reasoning). Considering computational costs, it is more suitable to try smaller LLMs + ToT for +traditional NLP tasks, or GPT-4 + ToT for hard tasks that challenge GPT-4 + CoT’s reasoning. -o +B.2 Extension to new LMs (GPT-3.5) -260 +To understand how ToT works with other LLMs, we also ran GPT-3.5-turbo for Creative Writing +(Table 6) and Game of 24 (Table 5). On both tasks, “ToT > CoT > IO” remains true for GPT-3.5. On +Creative Writing, we find GPT-3.5+ToT outperform GPT-4+IO, and similar to GPT-4+CoT, which +suggests ToT could also work well on weaker language models. -o +On Game of 24 (we changed 1-shot proposal prompt to 3-shot to make it work), GPT-3.5+ToT’s +19% is far worse than GPT-4+ToT’s 74%. To further understand the importance of generation +vs. evaluation, we ran GPT-4 generation + GPT-3.5 evaluation (64%) and GPT-3.5 generation + +GPT-4 evaluation (31%). This suggests the game’s bottleneck is thought generation, and different +generation/evaluation language models might attain decent results while reducing costs. -= +B.3 Cost and efficiency -km -km0h -! -s 0s 29 -! +Running ToT requires significantly more computations than IO or CoT prompting. For example, in +Game of 24 (Table 7 below), solving a problem with ToT requires 5.5k completion tokens, close to +100 CoT trials (6.7k tokens). But the performance of ToT is better than best of 100 independent CoT +trials. -h +Game of 24 -+= +Generate/Prompt tokens Cost per case -0.9 +Success -h +IO (best of 100) +CoT (best of 100) +ToT -km -s +1.8k / 1.0k +6.7k / 2.2k +5.5k / 1.4k - 2.3 Acceleration +$0.13 +$0.47 +$0.74 +Table 7: Cost analysis on Game of 24. - 2.3 Acceleration +33% +49% +74% -Example 3 Acceleration and Decreasing -Velocity +On Creative Writing (Table 8 below), we found ToT takes around 5x completion tokens and money +cost, which is intuitive as b = 5 and most tokens are generated passages. -r -a +Creative Writing Generate/Prompt tokens Cost per case -= +IO +CoT +ToT -r -r -vv -! -t -t -! +0.9k / 0.4k +0.9k / 0.4k +4k / 2.9k -o +$0.06 +$0.07 +$0.32 -o +Table 8: Cost analysis on Game of 24. -= +So completing Game of 24 and Creative Writing’s main ToT experiments cost around 0.74 × 100 + +0.32 × 100 = 106 dollars. Crosswords’ DFS experiments should be also within 100 dollars. In +general, cost and efficiency of ToT highly depend on the prompts and search algorithms used, and +could require 5-100 times more generated tokens than CoT. Some actionable insights: -sm13 +• We recommend using ToT on tasks requiring deliberate reasoning, on which CoT struggles. +• Flexibility of ToT allows some performance-cost tradeoff, e.g., change beam size or vote +number in BFS, few-shot vs. zero-shot prompting, GPT-3.5 vs. GPT-4, etc. One could +configure the setup based on some resource constraints or performance goal. -sm28 -! -s 9s 12 -! +• There is much space for improving efficiency, e.g., BFS could early stop when solution is -!= +found, or trim down beam size to when some thoughts are ”impossible”. -2sm0.5 +• We believe that more computation is indeed required in order for the model to achieve +stronger intelligence, and this should not become a blocking issue as in the long run, (open- +source) LMs will become much cheaper and more efficient. It is also a great direction how +to better train/finetune LMs for thought generation and/or evaluation. - 2.3 Acceleration +14 diff --git a/q58/random_k4/random_3.md b/q58/random_k4/random_3.md index a2b48e41bd57bce68e73b59f00704cb4c84c38f3..82ecb3b9af6c3286b3846d69480033be2a625972 100644 --- a/q58/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q58/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,2098 +1,1408 @@ - PUBLIC SPEAKING SKILLS - -1 - - 1.1 PUBLIC SPEAKING: DEFINITIONS - -UNIT-I - -Public speaking is the process or act of performing a speech to a live audience. This - -process can include preparation, organization, and the delivery of a message that is clear and - -engaging. It can range from a formal speech at a conference to an informal talk at a social - -gathering. - -Historical Perspective - -Public speaking dates back to ancient civilizations, notably the Greeks and Romans. - -In ancient Greece, public speaking was considered an essential skill for citizens. The great - -orator, Aristotle, even wrote a treatise on rhetoric. The Roman tradition also valued public - -oration, with figures like Cicero and Quintilian making significant contributions to the art of - -public speaking. - -1.2 COMPONENTS OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - - Speaker: The person delivering the speech, responsible for preparing and presenting - -the message. - - Message: The main content or idea being communicated. - - Audience: The group of people who receive and interpret the message. - - Channel: The medium through which the message is delivered, whether in person, - -via video, or another format. - - Feedback: The reactions and responses from the audience, which can be verbal or - -non-verbal. - - Context: The situation or environment in which the speech occurs, influencing how - -the message is received. - -2 - - 1.3 NEED FOR PUBLIC SPEAKING - -1.3.1. Personal Development - -Public speaking is crucial for personal growth. It helps build self-confidence, improves - -critical thinking, and enhances communication skills. - -a) Confidence Building - - Regular practice in public speaking situations can significantly increase self- - -confidence. Speaking in front of an audience, even a small one, helps individuals - -become more comfortable with expressing their ideas publicly. - -b) Critical Thinking - - Preparing a speech requires organizing thoughts and structuring them logically. This - -process helps develop critical thinking skills as one must evaluate information, - -formulate arguments, and anticipate audience questions. - -c) Communication Skills - - Public speaking refines both verbal and non-verbal communication skills. Effective - -speakers learn to articulate their thoughts clearly and use body language to reinforce - -their message. - -1.3.2. Professional Growth - -In the professional realm, public speaking skills are invaluable. They contribute to - -career advancement, networking, and leadership. - -a) Career Advancement - - Many career opportunities, especially in leadership roles, require the ability to speak - -confidently and effectively. Employers value employees who can present ideas clearly - -and lead discussions. - -b) Networking Opportunities: - - Public speaking events provide opportunities to meet and connect with peers, - -mentors, and industry leaders. These connections can lead to professional - -collaborations and career opportunities. - -c) Influence and Leadership: - - Effective public speakers can inspire and motivate others. This ability is crucial for - -leadership, as it involves guiding teams, making persuasive arguments, and driving - -organizational change. - -3 - - 1.3.3. Social Impact - -Public speaking plays a significant role in social advocacy, community engagement, - -and education. - -a) Advocacy and Activism: - - Public speakers can use their platform to advocate for social causes, influencing - -public opinion and policy. Activists and leaders often speak out to bring attention to - -important issues. - -b) Community Engagement - - Speaking at community events fosters a sense of belonging and encourages civic - -participation. Engaging with community members through speeches can promote - -unity and collective action. - -Education and Awareness: - - Educators and experts use public speaking to disseminate knowledge and raise - -awareness on various topics. This contributes to an informed and educated society. - -1.4 IMPORTANCE OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - -1.4.1 Effective Communication - -Public speaking is a powerful tool for effective communication, enabling clarity, - -engagement, and persuasion. - -a) Clarity and Precision - - Effective speakers convey their messages clearly and precisely, ensuring the audience - -understands their points. This reduces misunderstandings and enhances the - -effectiveness of communication. - -b) Audience Engagement - - Keeping the audience engaged is crucial for the success of a speech. Techniques like - -storytelling, humour, and interactive elements help maintain interest and involvement. - -c) Persuasion - - The ability to persuade is a key aspect of public speaking. Persuasive speeches aim to - -influence the audience’s beliefs, attitudes, or actions, which is essential in many - -professional and social contexts. - -1.4.2 Professional Relevance - -Public speaking is essential in professional settings, particularly for presentations, - -public relations, and crisis management. - -4 - - a) Presentations and Meetings: - - Many professional roles require presenting information to colleagues, clients, or - -stakeholders. Effective public speaking skills ensure these presentations are clear, - -engaging, and impactful. - -b) Public Relations: - - Managing a company’s or individual’s public image often involves public speaking. - -Delivering statements, handling media inquiries, and speaking at public events are all - -critical PR activities. - -c) Crisis Management - - During a crisis, clear and calm communication is vital. Public speakers must provide - -accurate information, reassure the public, and guide actions to manage the situation - -effectively. - -1.4.3 Societal Contributions - -Public speaking contributes to societal development through civic participation, education, - -and cultural preservation. - -a) Civic Participation - - Public speaking encourages active participation in democratic processes. By speaking - -at town halls, debates, and public forums, individuals can influence policy and - -contribute to community development. - -b) Education and Teaching - - Teachers and educators use public speaking to enhance learning experiences. - -Effective teaching involves clear communication, engaging presentations, and the - -ability to inspire students. - -c) Cultural Preservation - - Public speaking plays a role in preserving and promoting cultural heritage. - -Storytellers, historians, and cultural leaders use speeches to share traditions, history, - -and values. - -5 - - 1.5 ADVANTAGES OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - -1.5.1 Personal Benefits - -Public speaking offers numerous personal advantages, including increased self- - -esteem, networking opportunities, and improved problem-solving skills. - -a) Self-Esteem - - Successfully delivering a speech can boost self-esteem and provide a sense of - -accomplishment. Overcoming the fear of public speaking leads to greater self- - -confidence. - -b) Networking - - Speaking at events allows individuals to meet new people and expand their - -professional and personal networks. These connections can lead to collaborations and - -new opportunities. - -c) Problem-Solving - - Public speaking often involves addressing questions and concerns from the audience. - -This helps develop problem-solving skills as speakers learn to think on their feet and - -provide clear, thoughtful responses. - -1.5.2 Professional Benefits - -In the workplace, public speaking skills can enhance leadership, create career - -opportunities, and lead to professional recognition. - -a) Leadership - - Effective communication is a key leadership quality. Public speaking skills enable - -leaders to articulate their vision, motivate teams, and navigate challenges. - -b) Career Opportunities - - Many job roles, especially in management and leadership, require public speaking - -skills. Being a confident speaker can open doors to promotions and new career paths. - -c) Professional Recognition - - - -Individuals who excel in public speaking often gain recognition and respect in their - -field. This can lead to invitations to speak at conferences, awards, and other - -professional accolades. - -6 - - 1.5.3 Social Benefits - -Public speaking can foster community building, amplify advocacy efforts, and promote - -cultural exchange. - -a) Community Building - - Public speaking events bring people together, fostering a sense of community and - -shared purpose. Speakers can address community issues, inspire collective action, and - -promote social cohesion. - -b) Advocacy - - Speakers can use their platform to advocate for social justice, environmental - -protection, and other important causes. This helps raise awareness and mobilize - -support for these issues. - -c) Cultural Exchange - - Public speaking events can promote cultural exchange and understanding. Speakers - -from diverse backgrounds share their experiences and perspectives, enriching the - -audience’s knowledge and appreciation of different cultures. - -1. 6 SKILLS REQUIRED FOR PUBLIC SPEAKING - -1.6.1 Content Preparation - -Effective public speaking begins with thorough content preparation. This involves - -research, organization, and writing. - -a) Research - - Conducting comprehensive research is essential to gather accurate and relevant - -information. This ensures the speech is informative and credible. - -b) Organization - - Structuring the speech logically helps convey the message clearly. A well-organized - -speech typically includes an introduction, main body, and conclusion. - -c) Writing - - Crafting the speech with attention to language, tone, and style enhances its - -effectiveness. The writing should be clear, concise, and tailored to the audience. - -7 - - 1.6.2 Delivery Techniques - -The way a speech is delivered is just as important as its content. Key delivery - -techniques include vocal variety, body language, and eye contact. - -a) Vocal Variety - - Using different pitches, tones, and volumes can make the speech more engaging and - -emphasize key points. - -b) Body Language - - Gestures, facial expressions, and posture can reinforce the message and convey - -confidence. - -c) Eye Contact - - Maintaining eye contact with the audience helps build a connection and shows - -sincerity. - -1.6.3 Audience Engagement - -Engaging the audience is crucial for an effective speech. Techniques like storytelling, - -interactive elements, and adaptability can help. - -a) Storytelling - - Using stories and anecdotes can illustrate points and make the speech more relatable - -and memorable. - -b) Interactive Techniques - - - -Involving the audience through questions, discussions, and activities keeps them - -engaged and interested. - -c) Adaptability - - Being able to adjust the speech based on audience feedback and reactions is - -important. This may involve altering the delivery or content on the fly to better suit - -the audience. - -1.6.4 Overcoming Anxiety - -Public speaking anxiety is common but can be managed through preparation, practice, - -and mindfulness techniques. - -a) Preparation - - Thoroughly preparing the speech helps boost confidence and reduce anxiety. - -8 - - b) Practice - - Regularly practicing the speech, including in front of a mirror or a small audience, can - -make the speaker more comfortable and familiar with the content. - -c) Mindfulness Techniques - - Techniques like deep breathing, visualization, and mindfulness can help manage - -anxiety and maintain composure during the speech. - -1.6.5 Technical Proficiency - -Technical proficiency involves using visual aids, handling microphones, and - -managing time effectively. - -a) Use of Visual Aids - - - -Incorporating visual aids like slides, videos, and props can enhance the speech and - -make complex information more understandable. - -b) Microphone Handling - - Properly using microphones and other audio equipment ensures the audience can hear - -the speaker clearly. - -c) Time Management - - Managing time effectively is important to cover all points within the allotted time. - -This involves practicing the speech to ensure it fits within the time limit and being - -able to adjust on the fly if needed. - -1.7. CONCLUSION - -In conclusion, public speaking is a multifaceted skill that encompasses various - -aspects, from preparation to delivery. It is an essential tool for personal and professional - -development, offering numerous benefits and opportunities. By developing and refining - -public speaking skills, individuals can enhance their confidence, influence, and impact on - -society. - -9 - - 2.1 Elements of Public Speaking - -UNIT-II - -Public speaking is composed of several critical elements that contribute to the effectiveness - -and success of a speech. Understanding these elements is essential for mastering the art of - -public speaking. - -a) Speaker - -The speaker is the individual delivering the message. Their role is crucial as they are - -responsible for preparing and presenting the speech. A speaker's credibility, confidence, and - -delivery style greatly influence how the message is received. - -b) Message - -The message is the content or main idea conveyed in the speech. It includes the information, - -arguments, and emotions the speaker intends to communicate. Clarity, organization, and - -relevance of the message are key to effective public speaking. - -c) Audience - -The audience is the group of people who receive and interpret the message. Understanding - -the audience's demographics, interests, and expectations helps tailor the speech to engage and - -resonate with them. - -d) Channel - -The channel is the medium through which the message is delivered. This can be face-to-face - -communication, a video presentation, a webinar, or other formats. The choice of channel can - -affect how the message is perceived and received. - -e) Feedback - -Feedback consists of the responses and reactions from the audience, which can be verbal or - -non-verbal. Effective public speakers pay attention to feedback to adjust their delivery and - -ensure their message is being understood. - -f) Context - -Context refers to the environment and circumstances in which the speech is delivered. This - -includes the physical setting, the occasion, and the cultural background. Context can - -influence the tone and content of the speech. - -g) Purpose - -The purpose of the speech is the speaker's goal, whether it is to inform, persuade, entertain, or - -fulfill a specific occasion. Clearly defining the purpose helps in crafting a focused and - -effective message. - -10 - - h) Encoding and Decoding - - Encoding: The process of the speaker translating thoughts and ideas into words and - -gestures. - - Decoding: The audience's interpretation and understanding of the speaker's message. - -Effective communication occurs when the audience accurately decodes the speaker's - -message. - -2.2 TYPES OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - -Public speaking can be categorized into different types based on the purpose and context of - -the speech. Here are the main types: - -a. Ceremonial Public Speaking - -Ceremonial public speaking, also known as special occasion speaking, involves delivering - -speeches at formal events and ceremonies. These speeches are often emotive and personal, - -designed to celebrate, honor, or commemorate. - -Examples: - - Wedding Speeches: Best man or maid of honor speeches, father of the bride speech. - - Funeral Eulogies: Tributes to the deceased, reflecting on their life and legacy. - - Award Acceptance Speeches: Recipients expressing gratitude and acknowledging - -contributions. - -Key Elements: - - Emotional Connection: Establishing a heartfelt connection with the audience. - - Appropriate Tone: Matching the tone to the occasion, whether joyous, solemn, or - -celebratory. - - Brevity: Keeping the speech concise and to the point, respecting the event's flow. - -b. Demonstrative Public Speaking - -Demonstrative public speaking involves showing the audience how to do something. These - -speeches are educational and often include visual aids or live demonstrations to enhance - -understanding. - -Examples: - - Cooking Demonstrations: Showcasing how to prepare a specific dish. - - Technical Tutorials: Explaining how to use a software program or gadget. - - Craft Workshops: Demonstrating steps to create a craft project. - -11 - - Key Elements: - - Clarity: Clearly explaining each step in a logical order. - - Visual Aids: Using tools, props, or multimedia to illustrate points. - - Engagement: Encouraging audience participation or questions to ensure - -comprehension. - -c. Informative Public Speaking - -Informative public speaking aims to educate the audience about a particular topic. The goal is - -to increase understanding and awareness without persuading the audience to adopt a specific - -viewpoint. - -Examples: - - Lectures: Academic presentations on a specific subject. - - Seminars: Professional development sessions on industry-related topics. - - Briefings: Providing updates or reports on specific issues or projects. - -Key Elements: - - Research: Conducting thorough research to provide accurate and detailed - -information. - - Organization: Structuring the speech with a clear introduction, body, and conclusion. - - Neutrality: Presenting facts objectively without expressing personal opinions. - -d. Persuasive Public Speaking - -Persuasive public speaking aims to convince the audience to accept a particular viewpoint or - -take specific actions. This type of speech involves presenting arguments, evidence, and - -emotional appeals to influence the audience. - -Examples: - - Political Speeches: Campaign speeches advocating for policies or candidates. - - Sales Presentations: Pitching products or services to potential customers. - - Advocacy Speeches: Promoting social causes or public policies. - -Key Elements: - - Thesis Statement: Clearly stating the main argument or position. - - Evidence: Providing credible evidence and examples to support the argument. - - Emotional Appeals: Connecting with the audience's emotions to strengthen the - -persuasive impact. - - Call to Action: Encouraging the audience to take specific actions based on the - -speech. - -12 - - 2.3 CONCLUSION - -Public speaking encompasses various elements and types, each with unique - -characteristics and requirements. Understanding the fundamental elements—such as the - -speaker, message, audience, and context—forms the foundation for effective communication. - -Additionally, recognizing the different types of public speaking—ceremonial, demonstrative, - -informative, and persuasive—enables speakers to tailor their approach to suit the purpose and - -context of their speech. By mastering these aspects, individuals can enhance their public - -speaking skills and achieve their communication goals. - -13 - - UNIT-III - -3.1 TECHNIQUES FOR EFFECTIVE PUBLIC SPEAKING - -Effective public speaking is a vital skill in both personal and professional contexts. - -Mastering this art involves various techniques that enhance clarity, engagement, and impact. - -This material covers essential techniques to help you become a more effective and confident - -public speaker. - -3.1.1 Understanding Your Audience - -Audience Analysis - - Demographics: Consider age, gender, education level, cultural background, and - -profession. Understanding these factors helps tailor your message to resonate with the - -audience. - - - -Interests: Identify what the audience cares about and tailor your content to match - -their interests. This helps in making the content relevant and engaging. - - Knowledge Level: Gauge their familiarity with the topic to avoid oversimplification - -or unnecessary complexity. Knowing their knowledge level ensures that you neither - -underestimate nor overestimate their understanding. - - Expectations: Understand what the audience expects to gain from your speech. - -Meeting or exceeding these expectations can significantly enhance the impact of your - -presentation. - -Techniques - - Surveys and Questionnaires: Collect information about the audience before the - -event. This can include questions about their interests, preferences, and knowledge - -level. - - Observation: Pay attention to the audience's reactions and body language. This real- - -time feedback can help you adjust your delivery. - - Direct Interaction: Engage with the audience through questions and discussions - -before the speech. This builds rapport and provides valuable insights into their - -expectations. - -Practical Tips - - Adapt Your Language: Use language that is appropriate for the audience’s level of - -understanding. Avoid jargon or technical terms unless the audience is familiar with - -them. - -14 - -  Relate to the Audience: Share stories or examples that are relevant to the audience's - -experiences. This makes the content more relatable and engaging. - -3.1.2 Preparation and Organization - -Research - - Thorough Investigation: Gather accurate and up-to-date information on your topic. - -This ensures the credibility and relevance of your content. - - Credible Sources: Use reliable and reputable sources for your content. This adds - -authority to your speech and builds trust with the audience. - - Diverse Perspectives: Incorporate multiple viewpoints to enrich your speech. This - -demonstrates a well-rounded understanding of the topic and engages a broader - -audience. - -Structuring Your Speech - - - -Introduction: Capture attention with a strong opening statement, quote, or story. The - -introduction sets the tone and provides a roadmap for your speech. - - Body: Organize main points logically, using clear and concise language. Each point - -should build on the previous one, leading the audience through a coherent argument. - - Conclusion: Summarize key points and end with a powerful closing statement. The - -conclusion should reinforce your message and leave a lasting impression. - -Outlining - - Simple Outline: Main headings and subheadings. This provides a basic structure for - -your speech. - - Detailed Outline: Includes full sentences and transitional phrases. This helps in - -fleshing out your ideas and ensuring smooth transitions between points. - -Practical Tips - - Time Management: Allocate time for each section of your speech. Practice - -delivering within this timeframe to avoid running over. - - Rehearse: Practice delivering your speech multiple times. This helps in internalizing - -the content and improving delivery. - -3.1.3 Developing a Strong Opening - -Techniques - - Anecdotes: Start with a relevant story that sets the stage for your message. Anecdotes - -can be personal or about someone else, but they should be relatable to the audience. - -15 - -  Questions: Pose a thought-provoking question to engage the audience. This - -encourages active thinking and participation. - - Quotes: Use a powerful quote that relates to your topic. A well-chosen quote can set - -the tone and add credibility. - - Statistics: Present a surprising statistic to grab attention. Statistics can highlight the - -importance of your topic and provoke interest. - -Importance - - First Impressions: Establish credibility and set the tone for your speech. A strong - -opening makes a positive first impression. - - Audience Engagement: Captivate the audience from the beginning. An engaging - -opening keeps the audience interested and attentive. - -Practical Tips - - Relevance: Ensure your opening is relevant to the main topic. A disconnected - -opening can confuse the audience. - - Brevity: Keep the opening concise. An overly long opening can lose the audience's - -attention. - -3.1.4 Effective Body Language - -Components - - Gestures: Use hand movements to emphasize points and convey enthusiasm. - -Gestures should be natural and aligned with your words. - - Facial Expressions: Match expressions with the content to convey emotions. - -Smiling, frowning, or showing surprise can reinforce your message. - - Posture: Stand confidently, avoid slouching or leaning on the podium. Good posture - -projects confidence and authority. - - Eye Contact: Maintain eye contact to build a connection with the audience. This - -makes your speech feel more personal and engaging. - -Techniques - - Practice in Front of a Mirror: Observe and adjust your body language. This helps in - -becoming aware of and improving your gestures and expressions. - - Record and Review: Record your practice sessions to identify areas for - -improvement. Watching yourself can reveal habits you might not be aware of. - - Feedback: Seek feedback from peers or mentors. Constructive criticism can provide - -valuable insights for improvement. - -16 - - Practical Tips - - Avoid Distracting Movements: Be mindful of habits like fidgeting or pacing. These - -can distract the audience from your message. - - Consistent Gestures: Use gestures consistently to avoid confusion. Random or - -inconsistent gestures can be distracting. - -3.1.5 Vocal Variety - -Elements - - Pitch: Vary your pitch to avoid monotony and maintain interest. A monotone voice - -can be dull and disengaging. - - Volume: Adjust your volume to suit the venue and emphasize key points. Speaking - -too softly can make it hard for the audience to hear, while speaking too loudly can be - -overwhelming. - - Rate: Vary your speaking rate to highlight important information and maintain - -engagement. Speaking too fast can confuse the audience, while speaking too slowly - -can bore them. - - Pauses: Use pauses effectively to let key points sink in and to create dramatic effect. - -Pauses can also give you a moment to collect your thoughts. - -Techniques - - Breathing Exercises: Practice deep breathing to control your voice. Proper breathing - -supports vocal strength and clarity. - - Voice Modulation Exercises: Work on pitch, tone, and volume variations. Exercises - -like humming, lip trills, and tongue twisters can improve your vocal range and - -flexibility. - - Reading Aloud: Practice reading aloud to improve vocal variety and articulation. - -This helps in developing a more dynamic and engaging speaking style. - -Practical Tips - - Record Yourself: Record your practice sessions to analyze your vocal variety. - -Listening to yourself can help you identify areas for improvement. - - Seek Feedback: Get feedback from others on your vocal delivery. Constructive - -criticism can help you refine your vocal technique. - -3.1.6 Engaging the Audience - -17 - - Techniques - - - -Interactive Elements: Use polls, Q&A sessions, and discussions. Interaction keeps - -the audience involved and attentive. - - Stories and Examples: Share relevant anecdotes and case studies to illustrate points. - -Stories make abstract concepts more relatable and memorable. - - Humor: Incorporate appropriate humor to make the speech enjoyable and relatable. - -Humor can lighten the mood and make your speech more engaging. - - Visual Aids: Use slides, charts, and videos to support your message and keep the - -audience engaged. Visual aids can clarify complex information and maintain interest. - -Importance - - Attention Retention: Keeps the audience focused and interested. Engaged audiences - -are more likely to absorb and retain information. - - Enhanced Understanding: Helps the audience grasp complex concepts. Interaction - -and visual aids can make your message clearer and more accessible. - -Practical Tips - - Relevance: Ensure that your engagement techniques are relevant to your content. - -Irrelevant interaction can be distracting. - - Balance: Balance interactive elements with your main content. Too much interaction - -can detract from your core message. - -3.17 Overcoming Anxiety - -Techniques - - Preparation: The more prepared you are, the more confident you will feel. Thorough - -preparation reduces uncertainty and boosts confidence. - - Practice: Regular practice reduces anxiety and increases familiarity with the content. - -The more you practice, the more comfortable you become. - - Visualization: Visualize a successful speech to build confidence. Imagine yourself - -delivering the speech successfully and receiving positive feedback. - - Relaxation Techniques: Use deep breathing, meditation, and positive affirmations. - -These techniques can help calm your mind and reduce physical symptoms of anxiety. - -Managing Nervous Energy - - Physical Activity: Light exercise before speaking can reduce tension. Activities like - -stretching or a short walk can help calm nerves. - -18 - -  Hydration: Drink water to stay hydrated and prevent a dry mouth. Avoid caffeine, - -which can increase anxiety. - - Positive Thinking: Focus on positive outcomes and remind yourself of past - -successes. Positive affirmations can boost your confidence. - -Practical Tips - - Arrive Early: Arrive early to familiarize yourself with the venue. This reduces - -uncertainty and helps you feel more comfortable. - - Connect with the Audience: Engage with audience members before the speech. - -Building rapport can make you feel more at ease. - -3.1.8 Effective Use of Visual Aids - -Types of Visual Aids - - Slides: PowerPoint or Keynote presentations. Slides should be clear, concise, and - -visually appealing. - - Charts and Graphs: Illustrate data and trends. Charts and graphs can make complex - -data more understandable. - - Videos: Short clips to support or highlight points. Videos can add variety and - -illustrate points more vividly. - - Props: Physical objects that enhance understanding. Props can make abstract - -concepts more concrete and engaging. - -Techniques - - Simplicity: Keep slides and visuals simple and uncluttered. Avoid overwhelming the - -audience with too much information. - - Relevance: Ensure visual aids are directly related to your content. Irrelevant visuals - -can distract and confuse the audience. - - Practice: Familiarize yourself with the visual aids and integrate them smoothly into - -your speech. Practicing with your visual aids ensures a seamless presentation. - -Common Pitfalls - - Overreliance: Don't let visual aids overshadow your speech. Visual aids should - -support, not replace, your message. - - Technical Issues: Be prepared for potential technical difficulties. Have a backup plan - -in case of technical failures. - -19 - - Practical Tips - - Backup Copies: Have backup copies of your visual aids. This ensures you can - -continue your presentation even if technical issues arise. - - Engage with Visuals: Interact with your visual aids to maintain audience - -engagement. Pointing out specific details or elaborating on visuals can enhance - -understanding. - -3.1.9 Handling Questions and Interactions - -Techniques - - Anticipate Questions: Predict potential questions and prepare answers. This helps - -you feel more confident and prepared. - - Active Listening: Listen carefully to questions and respond thoughtfully. Active - -listening shows respect and helps you provide accurate answers. - - Clarification: Ask for clarification if a question is unclear. This ensures you - -understand the question and can provide a relevant response. - - Confidence: Maintain composure and confidence when answering questions. - -Confidence reassures the audience of your knowledge and credibility. - -Strategies - - Repetition: Restate the question to ensure understanding and give yourself time to - -think. Repeating the question also ensures everyone in the audience heard it. - - Bridging: Connect your answer to your main points or message. This keeps your - -response relevant and reinforces your key messages. - - Acknowledgment: Acknowledge challenging questions and provide honest, - -thoughtful responses. Honesty builds trust and credibility. - -Practical Tips - - Stay Calm: Stay calm and composed, even if faced with difficult questions. Keeping - -your cool shows professionalism. - - Admit When You Don’t Know: It’s okay to admit when you don’t know an answer. - -Offer to follow up later with more information. - -3.1.10 Continuous Improvement - -Techniques - - Self-Reflection: After each speech, reflect on what went well and what could be - -improved. Self-reflection helps you identify strengths and areas for growth. - -20 - -  Feedback: Seek feedback from peers, mentors, and the audience. Constructive - -feedback provides valuable insights for improvement. - - Training and Courses: Enroll in public speaking courses or workshops. Formal - -training can provide new techniques and enhance your skills. - - Practice: Regularly practice public speaking in various settings. Practice helps you - -refine your skills and gain confidence. - -Setting Goals - - Specific Goals: Set specific, measurable goals for improvement. Clear goals provide - -direction and motivation. - - Track Progress: Keep a record of your speeches and progress. Tracking progress - -helps you see improvements and stay motivated. - - Celebrate Achievements: Recognize and celebrate milestones and improvements. - -Celebrating successes reinforces positive behavior and boosts confidence. - -Practical Tips - - Join Speaking Groups: Join groups like Toastmasters to practice and receive - -feedback. Regular practice and feedback from peers can significantly improve your - -skills. - - Record Your Speeches: Record your speeches to analyze and improve your delivery. - -Watching recordings helps you identify areas for improvement. - -3.2 Conclusion - -Effective public speaking involves mastering various techniques that enhance clarity, - -engagement, and impact. By understanding your audience, preparing thoroughly, using strong - -openings, employing effective body language and vocal variety, engaging the audience, - -overcoming anxiety, utilizing visual aids effectively, handling questions with confidence, and - -committing to continuous improvement, you can become a more effective and confident - -public speaker. - -21 - - 4.1 METHODS OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - -UNIT-IV - -Public speaking is a critical skill that can be used in various contexts, ranging from - -casual conversations to formal presentations. Different methods of public speaking are suited - -for different scenarios, and mastering these methods can significantly enhance your ability to - -communicate effectively. This material covers key methods of public speaking, providing - -detailed insights and practical tips for each. - -4.1.1 Impromptu - -Definition - -Impromptu speaking involves delivering a speech without prior preparation. This method is - -often required in spontaneous situations where quick thinking and adaptability are essential. - -Techniques - - Think Quickly: Organize your thoughts rapidly and structure them logically. - - Stay Calm: Maintain composure to think clearly and speak confidently. - - Use Personal Experiences: Draw from your own experiences and knowledge to - -support your points. - - Practice Regularly: Engage in impromptu speaking exercises to improve your skills. - -Advantages - - Flexibility: Allows you to adapt to the topic and audience on the spot. - - Authenticity: Speeches often sound more genuine and spontaneous. - -Disadvantages - - Lack of Structure: Can lead to disorganized thoughts and unclear messages. - - - -Increased Anxiety: Higher pressure due to lack of preparation. - -Practical Tips - - Practice Thinking on Your Feet: Engage in activities like debate clubs or - -improvisational theater. - - Stay Updated: Keep yourself informed about various topics to have a broad - -knowledge base to draw from. - -4.1.2 Manuscript Speaking - -22 - - Definition - -Manuscript speaking involves reading a fully written speech. This method is commonly used - -in formal settings where accuracy and precise wording are crucial, such as political speeches - -or legal presentations. - -Techniques - - Write Clearly: Ensure the manuscript is well-written and easy to read. - - Practice Reading: Rehearse reading the manuscript to maintain eye contact and - -natural delivery. - - Use Visual Aids: Supplement the manuscript with visual aids to enhance engagement. - - Control Your Pace: Read at a moderate pace to ensure clarity and comprehension. - -Advantages - - Precision: Ensures accurate delivery of complex information. - - Consistency: Provides a consistent message every time. - -Disadvantages - - Less Engagement: Can sound monotonous and disengage the audience. - - Limited Flexibility: Difficult to adapt to audience reactions or questions. - -Practical Tips - - Highlight Key Points: Use highlights or underlines to emphasize important sections - -in your manuscript. - - Practice with a Timer: Ensure your speech fits within the allotted time by practicing - -with a timer. - -4.1.3 Memorized Speaking - -Definition - -Memorized speaking involves delivering a speech from memory without any notes or - -manuscripts. This method is often used for speeches that require exact wording, such as toasts - -or keynote addresses. - -Techniques - - Break It Down: Divide the speech into smaller sections for easier memorization. - - Use Mnemonics: Employ mnemonic devices to aid memory. - - Rehearse Frequently: Practice regularly to reinforce memory. - - Visualize Success: Visualize delivering the speech confidently to build memory and - -reduce anxiety. - -23 - - Advantages - - Engagement: Allows for direct eye contact and connection with the audience. - - Freedom of Movement: Enables more natural gestures and movement. - -Disadvantages - - Risk of Forgetting: High risk of forgetting parts of the speech. - - - -Inflexibility: Difficult to adapt on the fly if something goes wrong. - -Practical Tips - - Daily Practice: Set aside time each day to rehearse your speech. - - Use Visual Cues: Associate parts of your speech with specific visual cues to aid - -memory. - -4.1.4 Extemporaneous Speaking - -Definition - -Extemporaneous speaking involves delivering a speech from brief notes or an outline. This - -method balances preparation and spontaneity, allowing for a structured yet natural delivery. - -Techniques - - Prepare Thoroughly: Create a detailed outline with key points. - - Practice Extensively: Rehearse using the outline to become familiar with the content. - - Stay Flexible: Be ready to adapt to audience reactions and questions. - - Use Conversational Tone: Aim for a conversational tone to maintain natural delivery. - -Advantages - - Balance: Combines the benefits of preparation and spontaneity. - - Engagement: Allows for eye contact and audience interaction. - -Disadvantages - - Requires Skill: Demands good organization and speaking skills. - - Potential for Gaps: Risk of missing key points if not well-prepared. - -Practical Tips - - Note Cards: Use small note cards with key points to guide you. - - Engage with the Audience: Incorporate audience feedback and questions into your - -speech. - -4.1.5 Persuasive Speaking - -24 - - Definition - -Persuasive speaking aims to convince the audience to accept a particular viewpoint or take a - -specific action. This method is commonly used in sales pitches, political speeches, and - -advocacy campaigns. - -Techniques - - Clear Argument: Present a clear and logical argument. - - Evidence and Examples: Use evidence and examples to support your points. - - Emotional Appeal: Appeal to the audience's emotions to strengthen your argument. - - Call to Action: End with a clear call to action, urging the audience to act on your - -message. - -Advantages - - - -Influence: Can effectively change opinions or behaviors. - - Engagement: Often highly engaging and impactful. - -Disadvantages - - Resistance: Audience may resist if they feel manipulated. - - Complexity: Requires strong argumentative and rhetorical skills. - -Practical Tips - - Understand Your Audience: Tailor your message to the audience's values and - -beliefs. - - Practice Persuasion: Engage in debates and discussions to hone your persuasive - -skills. - -4.1.6 Informative Speaking - -Definition - -Informative speaking aims to educate the audience about a specific topic. This method is - -commonly used in lectures, presentations, and training sessions. - -Techniques - - Clear Structure: Organize your speech with a clear introduction, body, and - -conclusion. - - Use Visual Aids: Enhance understanding with visual aids like slides, charts, and - -videos. - - Simplify Complex Information: Break down complex information into easily - -understandable parts. - -25 - -  Engage the Audience: Use questions and interactive elements to maintain - -engagement. - -Advantages - - Educational Value: Provides valuable information to the audience. - - Clarity: Focuses on clear and concise communication. - -Disadvantages - - Potential for Boredom: Can be dry and unengaging if not delivered well. - - Overload: Risk of overwhelming the audience with too much information. - -Practical Tips - - Focus on Key Points: Highlight the most important information. - - Check for Understanding: Ask questions to ensure the audience understands the - -material. - -4.1.7 Demonstrative Speaking - -Definition - -Demonstrative speaking involves showing the audience how to do something. This method is - -commonly used in tutorials, workshops, and cooking shows. - -Techniques - - Step-by-Step Instructions: Provide clear and detailed instructions. - - Use Props and Visual Aids: Demonstrate each step using props and visual aids. - - Engage the Audience: Invite audience participation to enhance understanding. - - Rehearse the Demonstration: Practice the demonstration to ensure smooth - -execution. - -Advantages - - Practical Knowledge: Provides hands-on learning experiences. - - Engagement: Interactive and engaging for the audience. - -Disadvantages - - Preparation Time: Requires significant preparation and practice. - - Potential for Mistakes: Live demonstrations can go wrong. - -Practical Tips - - Prepare Thoroughly: Ensure all materials and equipment are ready. - - Practice Multiple Times: Rehearse the demonstration several times to avoid - -mistakes. - -26 - - 4.1.8 Ceremonial Speaking - -Definition - -Ceremonial speaking involves delivering speeches for special occasions, such as weddings, - -funerals, graduations, and award ceremonies. - -Techniques - - Understand the Occasion: Tailor your speech to the specific occasion and audience. - - Use Appropriate Tone: Match the tone of your speech to the occasion, whether it's - -celebratory, solemn, or formal. - - Personal Touch: Include personal stories or anecdotes to make the speech more - -meaningful. - - Express Emotions: Convey appropriate emotions to connect with the audience. - -Advantages - - Memorability: Creates lasting memories for special occasions. - - Emotional Impact: Can be highly emotional and impactful. - -Disadvantages - - Pressure: High expectations for memorable and impactful speeches. - - Emotional Difficulty: Can be challenging to deliver in emotionally charged - -situations. - -Practical Tips - - Practice Emotion Management: Practice delivering your speech to manage - -emotions. - - Get Feedback: Seek feedback from close friends or family to refine your speech. - -4.1.9 Motivational Speaking - -Definition - -Motivational speaking aims to inspire and uplift the audience. This method is commonly used - -by motivational speakers, coaches, and leaders. - -Techniques - - Personal Stories: Share personal experiences that illustrate your message. - - Positive Language: Use positive and uplifting language to inspire the audience. - - Call to Action: Encourage the audience to take positive actions. - - Engage Emotions: Appeal to the audience's emotions to create a lasting impact. - -Advantages - - - -Inspiration: Can significantly motivate and inspire the audience. - -27 - -  Positive Impact: Promotes positive change and action. - -Disadvantages - - Skepticism: Some audience members may be skeptical of motivational speeches. - - High Expectations: Audiences often have high expectations for impactful messages. - -Practical Tips - - Be Authentic: Speak from the heart to connect with the audience genuinely. - - Use Powerful Quotes: Incorporate powerful quotes to reinforce your message. - -Public speaking encompasses a variety of methods, each suited to different contexts and - -purposes. Understanding and mastering these methods can significantly enhance your ability - -to communicate effectively. Whether delivering an impromptu speech, reading from - -4.2 ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF PUBLIC SPEAKING - -Public speaking is a powerful tool that can have significant personal, professional, and - -social impacts. While it offers numerous advantages, it also presents certain challenges. - -Understanding both the benefits and the potential drawbacks of public speaking can help you - -navigate and leverage this skill more effectively. - -4.2.1 Personal Advantages - -Confidence Boost - -Public speaking can significantly enhance your self-confidence. Successfully delivering a - -speech in front of an audience can make you feel more capable and self-assured in various - -aspects of life. - - Self-Esteem: Regular public speaking engagements can improve your self-esteem as - -you become more comfortable with expressing your ideas. - - Overcoming Fear: Conquering the fear of public speaking, known as glossophobia, - -can have a positive ripple effect on other areas where anxiety might be present. - -Communication Skills - -Engaging in public speaking helps develop your verbal and non-verbal communication skills. - - Articulation: Improves your ability to express thoughts clearly and concisely. - - Body Language: Enhances your understanding and use of effective body language to - -complement your message. - -Critical Thinking - -Preparing and delivering speeches enhances critical thinking skills. - -28 - -  Organization: Requires you to structure your thoughts logically and coherently. - - Analysis: Encourages deep analysis of topics and consideration of different - -perspectives. - -4.2.2 Professional Advantages - -Career Advancement - -Public speaking can open doors to career advancement opportunities. - - Leadership Roles: Effective communication is a key leadership skill, often leading to - -promotions and leadership positions. - - Visibility: Increases your visibility within your organization and industry, making you - -a more attractive candidate for advancement. - -Networking Opportunities - -Public speaking events provide opportunities to network and build professional relationships. - - - -Industry Connections: Engage with peers, mentors, and potential clients or - -collaborators. - - Reputation Building: Establish yourself as an expert or thought leader in your field. - -Skill Development - -Public speaking hones various skills that are valuable in the workplace. - - Persuasion: Develops your ability to persuade and influence others, crucial for sales, - -marketing, and leadership roles. - - Time Management: Enhances your ability to manage time effectively during - -presentations and meetings. - -4.2.3 Social Advantages - -Influence and Persuasion - -Public speaking enables you to influence and persuade others effectively. - - Advocacy: Use your voice to advocate for causes and inspire change. - - Community Impact: Engage with your community and contribute positively by - -sharing valuable insights and information. - -Enhanced Relationships - -Improves interpersonal relationships through better communication. - - Listening Skills: Encourages active listening, which is essential for effective - -communication in personal relationships. - - Empathy: Develops empathy by considering the audience's perspective and needs. - -29 - - Community Engagement - -Public speaking fosters active participation in community and social causes. - - Volunteering: Speak at community events or local organizations to support various - -causes. - - Awareness: Raise awareness about important issues and encourage collective action. - -4.2.4 Personal Disadvantages - -Anxiety and Fear - -Public speaking anxiety, or glossophobia, is a common and often debilitating fear. - - Physical Symptoms: Can cause physical symptoms such as sweating, shaking, and a - -racing heart. - - Mental Strain: Leads to stress and mental strain before and during speaking - -engagements. - -Time-Consuming Preparation - -Preparing a well-crafted speech can be time-consuming. - - Research: Requires extensive research to gather relevant information. - - Rehearsal: Involves significant time spent rehearsing to ensure a smooth delivery. - -Risk of Criticism - -Exposure to public scrutiny and potential criticism is a constant risk. - - Negative Feedback: Speakers must be prepared to handle negative feedback and - -criticism. - - Self-Doubt: Criticism can lead to self-doubt and decreased confidence. - -4.2.5 Professional Disadvantages - -Reputation Damage - -A poor public speaking performance can negatively impact your professional reputation. - - Perception: Can lead to negative perceptions about your competence and expertise. - - Career Impact: May affect career progression and opportunities for advancement. - -Miscommunication - -There is a risk of miscommunicating information or being misunderstood. - - Clarity: Ensuring your message is clear and understood by all audience members can - -be challenging. - - Consistency: Maintaining consistency in your message across different audiences and - -settings is crucial. - -30 - - High Stakes - -High-stakes speaking engagements can add pressure and stress. - - Performance Anxiety: The importance of certain speeches can increase anxiety and - -pressure. - - Consequences: Mistakes in high-stakes situations can have significant consequences. - -4.2.6 Social Disadvantages - -Exhaustion - -Frequent public speaking can be physically and mentally exhausting. - - Energy Drain: Continuous speaking engagements can lead to burnout and fatigue. - - Stress: Managing multiple speaking commitments can be stressful. - -Privacy Concerns - -Public exposure can lead to a loss of privacy. - - Public Scrutiny: Increased visibility can attract unwanted attention and scrutiny. - - Personal Boundaries: Balancing public life and personal privacy can be challenging. - -Misinterpretation - -There is a risk of being misinterpreted or taken out of context. - - Media: Statements can be misrepresented by the media or others. - - Audience: Different audience members may interpret the same message in various - -ways. - -4.2.7 Overcoming Disadvantages - -Managing Anxiety - -Several strategies can help manage public speaking anxiety. - - Preparation: Thorough preparation reduces anxiety by increasing familiarity with the - -material. - - Practice: Regular practice builds confidence and reduces fear. - - Relaxation Techniques: Use deep breathing, meditation, and positive affirmations to - -calm nerves. - -Efficient Preparation - -Efficient preparation can mitigate the time-consuming nature of public speaking. - - Time Management: Allocate specific times for research, writing, and rehearsing. - - Use of Technology: Leverage technology for efficient research and rehearsal. - - Seek Feedback: Obtain feedback from peers to refine and improve the speech. - -31 - - Handling Criticism - -Effective ways to handle criticism include: - - Constructive Feedback: View criticism as an opportunity for growth. - - Stay Professional: Maintain professionalism and composure in response to criticism. - - Learn and Improve: Use feedback to improve future performances. - -4.2.8 Enhancing the Advantages - -Building Confidence - -Strategies to build confidence include: - - Small Steps: Start with smaller, less intimidating speaking opportunities. - - Positive Visualization: Visualize successful speaking engagements to build - -confidence. - - - -Incremental Challenges: Gradually increase the complexity and size of speaking - -engagements. - -Career Advancement - -Maximize career advancement opportunities through: - - Seek Opportunities: Actively seek out speaking opportunities in your field. - - Professional Development: Attend workshops and courses to improve public - -speaking skills. - - Networking: Use public speaking events to network and build professional - -relationships. - -Community Engagement - -Enhance community engagement by: - - Get Involved: Participate in community events and causes that matter to you. - - Volunteer: Volunteer to speak at community gatherings or local organizations. - - Advocate: Use public speaking to advocate for social issues and causes. - -4.2.9 Practical Tips for Effective Public Speaking - -Know Your Audience - - Research: Understand the audience's interests, knowledge level, and expectations. - - Tailor Your Message: Adapt your content to resonate with the audience. - -Structure Your Speech - - Clear Outline: Create a clear and logical outline. - - Engaging Introduction: Start with a strong opening to capture attention. - -32 - -  Coherent Body: Develop your main points logically and clearly. - - Powerful Conclusion: End with a memorable closing statement. - -Practice and Rehearse - - Regular Practice: Rehearse multiple times to build confidence and familiarity. - - Feedback: Seek feedback from peers or mentors to refine your speech. - -Engage with the Audience - - Eye Contact: Maintain eye contact to build a connection. - - - -Interactive Elements: Use questions, polls, and discussions to engage the audience. - - Body Language: Use effective body language to enhance your message. - -4.3 Conclusion - -Public speaking offers numerous advantages, including personal growth, professional - -advancement, and positive social impact. However, it also presents challenges such as - -anxiety, time-consuming preparation, and potential criticism. By understanding these - -advantages and disadvantages, speakers can better prepare and deliver effective speeches. - -Overcoming the disadvantages and enhancing the advantages requires continuous practice, - -preparation, and a willingness to learn and grow. Effective public speaking can lead to - -significant personal and professional development, making it a valuable skill to master. - -33 - - Unit- V - -5.1 FIVE ACTIVITIES TO IMPROVE PUBLIC SPEAKING SKILLS: - -1. Toastmasters International: Joining a Toastmasters club is an excellent way to - -practice public speaking in a supportive environment. Members give speeches, - -receive feedback, and participate in impromptu speaking exercises. - -2. Debate Clubs: Participating in debate clubs helps develop argumentative and - -persuasive speaking skills. Debates require participants to think on their feet and - -present coherent arguments. - -3. Storytelling Workshops: Storytelling is a powerful communication tool. Workshops - -focusing on storytelling techniques can help speakers engage their audience and - -deliver memorable speeches. - -4. Mock Presentations: Organize mock presentations with friends or colleagues. - -Practice delivering your speech in front of an audience and solicit feedback for - -improvement. - -5. Public Speaking Classes: Enroll in public speaking classes or workshops. These - -courses often - -34 - - 5.2 Twenty Public Speaking Topics - -Instruction: Prepare a five minutes speech on any of the following topics: - -1. Child Abuse - -2. Racism - -3. Right to privacy - -4. Common sense - -5. Team Building - -6. Freedom - -7. Physical fitness - -8. Feminism - -9. True friendship - -10. Emotional Intelligence - -11. Personality Development - -12. Human rights - -13. Sophistication - -14. Festivals in India - -15. A good (or bad) boss - -16. Positive attitude - -17. If I were the Prime Minister - -18. Cell phones and Health - -19. Lessons from Nature - -20. Life without internet - -35 - - 5.3 Public Speaking Record - -Topic: ……………………………………………………. - - Date: …………………. - -Blue Print of the Presentation - -Introduction - -Main Idea 1 - -Main idea 2 - -Main Idea 3 - -Conclusion - -Observation by the Faculty: - -Details - -Eye Contact -Body Language -Language -Content -Presentation Skills - -Marks Awarded - -Remarks - -10 - -36 - -(Signature of the Faculty) - +Double-Contrast Upper +Gastrointestinal Radiography: A +Pattern Approach for Diseases of the +Stomach1 +StephenE.Rubesin,MD +Thedouble-contrastuppergastrointestinalseriesisavalu- +MarcS.Levine,MD +ablediagnostictestforevaluatingstructuralandfunctional +IgorLaufer,MD +abnormalities of the stomach. This article will review the +normalradiographicanatomyofthestomach.Theprinci- +plesofanalyzingdouble-contrastimageswillbediscussed. +Apatternapproachforthediagnosisofgastricabnormali- +tieswillalsobepresented,focusingonabnormalmucosal +patterns,depressedlesions,protrudedlesions,thickened +folds,andgastricnarrowing. +!RSNA,2008 +1FromtheDepartmentofRadiology,HospitaloftheUni- +versityofPennsylvania,3400SpruceSt,Philadelphia,PA +19104.ReceivedJuly18,2006;revisionrequestedSep- +tember20;revisionreceivedOctober5;acceptedNovem- +ber2;finalversionacceptedJanuary2,2007;finalre- +viewbyM.S.L.June19.S.E.R.andM.S.L.arepaid +consultantsforE-Z-Em,Westbury,NY.Addresscorre- +spondencetoM.S.L.(e-mail:marc.levine@uphs.upenn +.edu). +"RSNA,2008 +REVIEWSANDCOMMENTARY +# +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS +Note: This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for +distribution to your colleagues or clients, use the Radiology Reprints form at the end of this article. +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 33 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +T +his article presents a pattern ap- ples of double-contrast image interpre- more undulating on the greater curva- +proach for the diagnosis of dis- tation, we will consider abnormal sur- ture. The thickness of the rugal folds +eases of the stomach at double- facepatternsofthemucosa,depressed varieswiththedegreeofgastricdisten- +contrast upper gastrointestinal radi- lesions(erosionsandulcers),protruded tion(5). +ography. After describing the normal lesions (polyps, submucosal masses, +appearance of the stomach on double- andothertumors),thickenedfolds,and AreaeGastricae +contrast barium studies and the princi- gastricnarrowing. The mucosal surface of the stomach +consistsofflatpolygonal-shapedtuftsof +mucosa,knownasareaegastricae,sep- +Essentials NormalStomach +arated by narrow grooves (6,7). The +# Protrudedlesions(eg,polypsand areae gastricae are recognized on dou- +cancers)onthedependentwallof GastricConfigurationandRugalFolds ble-contrast studies as a reticular net- +thestomachmayappearasradi- The normal stomach is a J-shaped workofbarium-coatedwhitelineswhen +olucentfillingdefectsinthebar- pouch that lies in the left upper quad- barium fills the grooves between these +iumpool,whereasprotrudedle- rant (Fig 1). The stomach has a fixed mucosal tufts (Fig 3). Individual muco- +sionsonthenondependentwall configuration created by the greater sal tufts of areae gastricae normally +mayappearasbarium-coated length of the longitudinal muscle layer have a diameter of 2–3 mm in the gas- +“ringshadows”duetobarium onitsgreatercurvature.Thelessercur- tricantrumandof3–5mminthegastric +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions. vature of the stomach is suspended body and fundus (Fig 3) (6,8). Areae +# Multiplesmall,round,uniformnod- from the retroperitoneum by the hepa- gastricae are detected on double-con- +ulesinthestomachareusually togastric ligament, a portion of the trast studies in nearly 70% of patients +causedbylymphoidhyperplasia lesseromentum.Thegastrosplenicliga- and are observed with greater fre- +associatedwithHelicobacterpylori ment and gastrocolic ligament (ie, the quencyintheelderly(8,9). +gastritis,whereasirregularnonuni- proximal portion of the greater omen- +formnodulesmaybecausedby tum)areattachedtothegreatercurva- ComparisonofHistologicAnatomywith +low-gradeB-cellmucosa-associated ture of the stomach. The gastric cardia MacroscopicAnatomy +lymphoidtissuelymphoma. isattachedtothediaphragmbythesur- Abasicunderstandingofthehistologic +# Aspirinandothernonsteroidal roundingphrenoesophagealmembrane. anatomy of the stomach is helpful for +antiinflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs) The stomach is arbitrarily divided understandingpepticulcerdisease,as +arebyfarthemostcommon into five segments: the cardia, fundus, well as other gastric abnormalities +causeoferosivegastritis,acondi- body,antrum,andpylorus.Thegastric (5,10). The stomach contains several +tionmanifestedondouble-con- cardiaischaracterizedonbariumstud- typesofmucosa:cardiac-typemucosa, +traststudiesaspunctateorslitlike ies by three or four stellate folds that body/fundic-type mucosa, and antral/ +erosionssurroundedbyradiolu- radiatetoacentralpointatthegastro- pyloric-type mucosa. Gastric foveolae +centmoundsofedemaor,in esophageal junction, also known as the (orpits)areconicaldepressionsinthe +somepatientstakingNSAIDs,by cardiac“rosette”(Fig2)(1,2).Thegas- mucosal surface that communicate +linearorserpiginouserosionson tric fundus is defined as the portion of with gastric glands (4,10). The glands +ornearthegreatercurvatureof the stomach craniad to the gastric car- are long, straight, and tightly packed +thegastricantrumorbody. dia. The gastric body is defined as the structures.Thefoveolaeinallpartsof +# Hpylorigastritisisbyfarthe portion of the stomach extending from thestomacharelinedbysurfacefove- +mostcommoncauseoffocallyor thegastriccardiatothesmoothbendin olar mucous cells. The cardiac-type +diffuselythickenedgastricfolds, the mid lesser curvature known as the mucosa comprises a short (1 cm in +whichcanbesolargeandlobu- incisuraangularis.Thegastricantrumis length) segment of the gastric mucosa +lated(eg,polypoidgastritis)that defined as the portion of the stomach adjacenttothegastroesophagealjunc- +theradiographicfindingsresem- extendingfromtheincisuraangularisto tion (4). The distinguishing feature of +blethoseofMenetrierdiseaseor the pylorus (a structure created by a the body-type mucosa is the presence +lymphoma. muscle sphincter shaped like a figure +# Onbariumstudies,scirrhouscarci- eight). +nomasofthestomachmayproduce Rugal folds are most prominent in Publishedonline +alinitisplasticaappearancewith the gastric fundus and body, whereas 10.1148/radiol.2461061245 +diffusenarrowingorlong-orshort- the gastric antrum is often devoid of +Radiology2008;246:33–48 +segmentnarrowingofanyportion folds(Fig1).Gastricrugaearechange- +ofthestomach;metastaticbreast able structures composed of mucosa Abbreviations: +cancerandlymphomaoccasionally and submucosa (3,4). The rugal folds MALT!mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissue +NSAID!nonsteroidalantiinflammatorydrug +mayproduceasimilarradiographic arerelativelystraightonthelessercur- +appearance. vature of the stomach but larger and Authorsstatednofinancialrelationshiptodisclose. +34 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +ofparietalandchiefcellsintheglands. extending progressively higher on the (Fig 1). With air contrast, the luminal +The parietal cells produce hydrochlo- lesser curvature. Peptic ulcers fre- contourappearsasasmooth,continuous +ric acid and intrinsic factor, and the quently develop on the lesser curva- barium-coatedwhiteline(Fig1)(11). +| chief cells | produce | proteolytic | en- tureatthetransitionzone(Fig4). | | +| ----------- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | +| zymes. | No parietal | or chief cells | are | BariumPool | +found in antral-type mucosa. The sur- The pool of high-density barium is the +PrinciplesofImageAnalysis +facefoveolarmucouscellslinebothan- tool the radiologist uses to scrub and +tralpitsandglands. +| Body-type | mucosa | lines the | ana- AppearanceoftheStomach | | +| --------- | ------ | --------- | --------------------------- | --- | +tomic gastric fundus and the gastric Theradiologistfirstexaminestheover- +Figure3 +body and extends into the gastric an- allposition,shape,andsizeofthestom- +trum along the greater curvature (4). ach. The gastric fundus abuts the left +Antral-type mucosa lines the antrum hemidiaphragm. The cardia has a mid- +along the lesser curvature from the py- linelocation,abuttingthecrusoftheleft +lorustotheincisuraangularis,butonly hemidiaphragm.Thestomachcurvesto +linesasmallamountofantrumalongthe the right across the midline, with the +greater curvature. Thus, the histologic distalgastricantrumandduodenumex- +division of the stomach into body- and tendingtotherightofthespine.There +antral-type mucosa does not correlate is considerable variation in the size of +with the anatomic and radiologic divi- thestomach,dependingontheamount +sion of the stomach into fundus, body, of barium and effervescent agent ad- +| andantrum(5). | | | ministered. | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +The transition zone between body- Figure3: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +and antral-type mucosa is a line that LuminalContour achwithpatientinleftposteriorobliqueposition +extends from the incisura angularis to In the barium pool, the contour is de- showsnormalareaegastricaepatterninantrumas +thedistalgreatercurvature.Thetransi- marcated by a smooth edge of barium 2–3-mmpolygonallyshapedradiolucenttuftsof +tionzonemigratesproximallywithage, mucosaoutlinedbybariumingrooves.Areae +| | | | Figure2 | gastricaeareslightlylargerindistalgastricbody | +| --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | +thaninantrum. +Figure1 +Figure4 +| Figure1: | Normalstomach.Double-contrast | | | | +| -------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +spotimageofstomachwithpatientsupineshows +distalgastricbody(B)andantrum(A).Greater +| curvature(whitearrows)andlessercurvature | | | Figure2: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | +| (blackarrows)arecoatedbybarium.Rugalfoldon | | | tricfunduswithpatientinright-side-downposi- | | +| posteriorwallofgastricbodyisdepictedastubu- | | | tionshowsnormalgastriccardiawithsmooth | | +lar,slightlyundulating,radiolucentfillingdefect foldsradiatingtocentralpoint(whitearrow)at Figure4: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +(blackarrowheads)inshallowbariumpool.Dense closedgastroesophagealjunction,alsoknownas achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsbenign +bariumpooloutlinescontour(whitearrowheads) cardiacrosette.Long,straightfold(arrowheads) lessercurvaturegastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid +ofgastricfundus(F).Mucosalsurfaceandfoldsin extendsinferiorlyfromcardiaalonglessercurva- collectionofbariumextendingoutsideexpected +fundusareobscuredbybariumpool,andantrum ture.Blackarrowsdenotenormalextrinsicimpres- luminalcontourofgastricbody.Smoothfoldsare +sionbyadjacentspleen. +| isdevoidofrugalfolds. | | | | seenradiatingtoedgeofulcercrater. | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 35 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +coatthemucosalsurface(12–15).Some dent wall usually appear as radiolucent thickness of barium in the grooves +lesions are best shown in the barium fillingdefectsinthebariumpool(Fig5) between the mucosal tufts in relation +pool, whereas others are obscured by (16),whereasprotrudedlesionsonthe to the thickness of barium overlying +even a small pool of high-density bar- nondependent wall appear as barium- the tufts (8,9). Thus, an increase in +ium. Protruded lesions on the depen- coated “ring shadows” due to barium theheightofthemucosaltuftsorthin- +coatingtheedgeoftheselesions(Fig5). ning of the mucous gel layer in the +Figure5 When filled with barium, depressed le- stomach may cause the areae gastri- +sions appear as barium collections on caetobecomemorevisibleorconspic- +the dependent wall (Fig 4). When bar- uous. When viewed in profile, barium +ium spills out of depressed lesions on in the grooves between areae gastri- +thedependentwall,theymayappearas cae may be manifested as tiny spike- +| ringshadows. | like outpouchings, | | producing | | subtle | +| ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +spiculationoftheluminalcontourthat +| EnFaceMucosalDetail | should | not be mistaken | | for erosions. | | +| ------------------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Whenviewedenface,themucosalsur- In addition, the areae gastricae may +face either has a smooth appearance be enlarged by conditions that in- +(Fig 1) or is manifested as a reticular crease the size of the mucosal tufts +network of barium-filled grooves be- beyond their normal diameter of 2–3 +tween the areae gastricae (Fig 3). Dis- mm in the antrum and of 3–5 mm in +ruption of the normal areae gastricae the body and fundus. Enlarged areae +Figure5: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- pattern or the smooth mucosal surface gastricaehavebeenreportedinabout +tricbodywithpatientinsupinerightposterior ofthestomachbybarium-coatedlinesis 50% of patients with Helicobacter py- +obliquepositionshowsmultiplehyperplastic abnormal(Fig5). lori gastritis (Fig 7) (18). In contrast, +polypsondependent,orposterior,wallassmall small or even absent areae gastricae +("1cminsize),roundorovoid,finelylobulated have been reported in patients with +PatternApproachforDouble-Contrast +radiolucentfillingdefectsinbariumpool(arrows). severe atrophic gastritis and perni- +Diagnosis +Incontrast,polypsonnondependent,oranterior, ciousanemia(19). +wallarecoatedbybariumandappearaswhite H pylori is a curved or spiral-shaped, +lines(arrowheads).Bariumisseentofillinter- AbnormalMucosalPatterns gram-negative bacillus (20–22) that in- +sticesbetweenlobulesofsomepolyps. Striations.—Thin, barium-coated stria- fects the stomach in more than 50% of +tions perpendicular to the longitudinal Americans over 50 years of age and in +axis of the gastric antrum, also known nearly100%ofJapaneseadults(23,24). +as gastric “striae,” are sometimes seen H pylori most frequently involves the +Figure6 as a transient finding when the antrum gastric antrum (25). H pylori gastritis +is slightly collapsed (Fig 6) (17). These can be documented in almost all pa- +striaeareasignofchronicantralgastri- tientswithduodenalulcersandinabout +| tis(16). | 80%ofpatientswithgastriculcers(26). | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | +| Conspicuousorenlargedareaegas- | The mechanism | | by which | H | pylori | +tricae.—Visualizationoftheareaegas- causes ulceration is not fully under- +tricae in the stomach depends on the stood. H pylori gastritis is also a major +| | causative | factor | in the development | | of | +| ------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| Figure7 | bothgastriccarcinoma(27,28)andgas- | | | | | +triclymphoma(29,30). +Uniformnodules.—Innumerablesmall +| | (1–2 mm | in size), | round, | uniform | nod- | +| --- | --------------- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | +| | ules disrupting | | the normal | polygonal | | +| | areae gastricae | | pattern | are | usually | +| | caused | by lymphoid | hyperplasia | | of the | +stomachresultingfromchronicHpylori +| | gastritis | (Fig 8) | (31–33). | At birth, | no | +| --- | --------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +Figure6: Double-contrastspotimageofan- +| | lymphoid | tissue | is present | in the | stom- | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | ----- | +trumwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsgastric Figure7: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- +ach.WhenHpyloriinfectsthestomach, +striaeastransientfindingduetobariumfilling achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsenlarged +| | the organism | colonizes | | the | mucous | +| --- | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | ------ | +delicatetransversegroovesbetweenthinradiolu- areaegastricaeinpatientwithHpylorigastritis. +layerandattachestothemembranesof +centfoldstraversingcircumferenceofslightly Areaegastricaeinantrum(whitearrow)arelarger +| | the surface | epithelial | cells, | resulting | in | +| --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --------- | --- | +collapsedgastricantrum. thanthoseindistalgastricbody(blackarrow). +| | the development | | of chronic | | gastritis | +| --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | +36 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure8 Figure9 +| (22). Repeated | infections | may | eventu- | | | | +| -------------- | -------------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ally lead | to lymphocytic | infiltration | | of | | | +thestomach,followedbytheformation +| of lymphoid | aggregates | and | even true | | | | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoidfollicles(34).Thus,whenlym- +| phoid hyperplasia | | is detected | on dou- | | | | +| ----------------- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| ble-contrast | barium | studies, | these pa- | | | | +| tients are | almost | always found | to have | | | | +chronicHpylorigastritis(33). +| Nonuniform | nodules.—Irregular | | nod- | | | | +| ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +ulesdisruptingthesmoothmucosalsur- +| face or | the polygonal | areae | gastricae | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| pattern | of the stomach | may | be caused | | | | +byinflammation,metaplasia(alteration +Figure9: Double-contrastspotimageofgas- +| of one form | of epithelium | | to another), | Figure8: | Double-contrastspotimageofgas- | | +| ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | +tricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +| or malignant | tumor. | The | nodules are | tricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +positionshowsnonuniformnodulesdisrupting +| nonuniform | in size | and shape | and have | positionshowslymphoidhyperplasiawithinnu- | | | +| ---------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +normalsurfacepattern.Nodules(arrows)appear +| a patchy | or diffuse | distribution, | involv- | merableround,uniform,1–2-mmnodulescarpet- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +asroundorlobulated,confluentprotrusionsvary- +| ing a focal | or large | surface | area of the | ingmucosaandreplacingnormalpolygonalareae | | | +| ----------- | -------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +ingfrom3–6-mminsize.Endoscopicbiopsy +| stomach | on barium | studies. | Nonuni- | gastricaepattern.ThispatienthadchronicHpylori | | | +| ------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +specimensrevealedlow-grade,B-cell,gastric +gastritis. +formmucosalnodularityisaworrisome MALTlymphomainpatientwithchronicHpylori +radiographicfindingforgastricmucosa- gastritis. +| associated | lymphoid | tissue | (MALT) | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +lymphoma(Fig9)or,rarely,superficial IIa (elevated), IIb (flat), or IIc (de- +spreadingcarcinoma(Fig10)(35). pressed)lesions(Fig10);andulcerated +| Gastric | lymphomas | usually | arise | EGCsthataremorethan5mmindepth | | | +| ------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | +Figure10 +| from preexisting | MALT | in | the stomach | aretypeIIIlesions(42). | | | +| ---------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +associatedwithchronicHpylorigastri- +| tis. A lymphoid | response | to | chronic in- | DepressedLesions | | | +| --------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +fectionbyHpylorihasbeenpostulated Erosions.—Anerosionisafocalareaof +astheprecursormilieuforthedevelop- mucosalnecrosisconfinedtotheepithe- +ment of low-grade B-cell gastric MALT lium or lamina propria without extend- +lymphomas (36). These tumors are ing through the muscularis mucosae +sometimes recognized on double-con- into the submucosa (5). In contrast, +trast studies by the presence of innu- a true ulcer niche or crater extends +merable poorly defined, confluent mu- through the muscularis mucosae into +cosal nodules of varying size (Fig 9) the deeper layers of the gastric wall +(35). In such cases, endoscopic biopsy (4). The actual histologic depth of an +specimensarerequiredtoruleoutgas- ulcercannotbedeterminedonbarium +tricMALTlymphoma. studies.Instead,theradiographicsize Figure10: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricfunduswithpatientinsemiuprightposition +| Because | of mass | screening | of the | and depth | are used | to distinguish an | +| ------- | ------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | -------- | ----------------- | +showssuperficialgastriccarcinomaasfocalarea +adult population in Japan, early gastric erosion from an ulcer. When viewed +ofslightlyelevated,irregularradiolucentnodules +cancers (EGCs) constitute as many as in profile, a depressed lesion greater +(arrows)inshallowbariumpool.Clubbed,irregu- +25%–46% of all gastric cancers de- than several millimeters in depth is +tected in that country (37,38). In con- arbitrarilycalledanulcer. larfolds(arrowheads)areseenradiatingtoward +centralareaofmucosalnodularity. +trast, EGCs constitute a much smaller Erosions are manifested on double- +percentage of gastric cancers detected contrast studies as tiny, 1–2 mm in +in the West, because endoscopy and depth collections of barium, usually in +bariumstudiesareperformedpredomi- the gastric antrum. Erosions may be turned from side to side, so a shallow +nantly in symptomatic patients who al- punctate, round, linear, or stellate in poolofbariumflowsoverthedependent +readyhaveadvancedlesions(39–41).In configurationandareoftensurrounded surface of the stomach (45). Erosions +the Japanese classification system for by radiolucent halos of edematous mu- aredefinedascompleteorvarioliformif +EGC, polypoid EGCs that protrude cosa (Fig 11) (43). Erosions are fre- surrounded by a radiolucent halo of +morethan5mmintothelumenaretype quently seen to reside on the crests of edema and as incomplete if there is no +I lesions; flat EGCs that appear as enlarged scalloped antral folds (44), surroundingedematousmound.Incom- +plaques,nodules,ortinyulcersaretype particularly when the patient is slowly plete erosions are much less common, +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 37 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +appearing as punctate or linear collec- the most common cause of gastric ero- eas of epithelial necrosis with hemor- +tions of barium that may be difficult to sions (46). NSAID exposure causes rhage,edema,andvasculardilatationin +differentiate from barium trapped be- breakdown of the mucosal barrier and the lamina propria (47). Because often +tweenareaegastricaeoralongsiderugal mucosal hypoxia, resulting in focal ar- thereisrelativelylittleinflammatoryre- +| folds. | | sponse, | the term | NSAID | gastropathy | | +| ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | +Aspirinandothernonsteroidalanti- rather than NSAID gastritis is favored +Figure13 +inflammatorydrugs(NSAIDs)arebyfar by some authors (10,48). NSAID-in- +ducederosivegastritisistypicallymani- +| Figure11 | | fested as | multiple | varioliform | | erosions | +| -------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +intheantrumorantrumandbodyofthe +stomach(18).Lessfrequently,thesepa- +| | | tients may | have | incomplete | | erosions | +| --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | +thatappearaslinearorserpiginousbar- +iumcollections(Fig12),manyofwhich +| | | are located | on | or near | the greater | cur- | +| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | +vatureofthegastricbodysecondaryto +theeffectofgravity(49). +| | | Other | causes | of gastric | erosions | in- | +| --- | --- | --------------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------ | -------- | +| | | clude alcohol, | | viral | infections, | Crohn | +| | | disease, | hemorrhagic | | gastropathy, | and | +| | | iatrogenic | trauma | (4,50–55). | | Surpris- | +| | | ingly, erosions | | are infrequently | | seen in | +patientswithHpylorigastritis(18). +| | Figure13: Double-contrastspotimageof | Ulcers.—An | | ulcer | is a | focal area | +| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinleftposterioroblique | of mucosal | disruption | | that | penetrates | +| Figure11: Double-contrastspotimageof | positionshowsgastriculcer(U)assmooth,ovoid | | | | | | +| | | through | the muscularis | | mucosae | into | +collectionofbariumonposteriorwall.Smooth, +distalgastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterior the deeper layers of the gastric wall. +straightfoldsradiatedirectlytoedgeofulcercra- +obliquepositionshowsNSAID-inducederosive Whenviewedenface,mostbenigngas- +ter.Thesearetypicalfindingsofabenigngastric +antralgastritis.Multiplevarioliformerosionsare tric ulcers on the dependent wall are +ulcer. +seenaspunctate(smallwhitearrow)andlinear manifested on double-contrast studies +(largewhitearrow)collectionsofbariumsur- +asasmoothroundorovoidcollectionof +roundedbyradiolucentmoundsofedema(black +| | | barium | filling the | ulcer | crater | (Fig 13). | +| --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------ | --------- | +arrows).Thispatientwastakingaspirin. +| | | Some shallow | | ulcers | on the | dependent | +| --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --------- | +| | Figure14 | wall and | ulcers | on the | nondependent | | +wallmaybemanifestedasacircularor +hemisphericringduetobariumcoating +| Figure12 | | the rim | of the | unfilled | ulcer | crater | +| -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ----- | ------ | +(Fig14)(56).Mostulcersareroundor +ovoid,butsomemayhavealinear,ser- +| | | pentine, | rectangular, | | flame-shaped, | or | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | +rod-shapedconfiguration(56–58). +Whenviewedinprofile,benigngas- +triculcersmayberecognizedbyafocal +bariumcollectionorbarium-coatedline +| | | extending | outside | the | expected | luminal | +| --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ------- | +contour(Fig4)(11,59–61).Someulcers +| | Figure14: Double-contrastspotimageof | have a smooth | | radiolucent | rim | of vari- | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | able thickness | | directly | adjacent | to the | +| | incompletelyfilledulcerondependent,orposte- | ulcer crater, | | representing | | a collar of | +| | rior,wallashemisphericringshadowwithtwo | edema and | inflammation, | | whereas | oth- | +| Figure12: Double-contrastspotimageof | crescent-shapedbarium-coatedlines(arrows) | | | | | | +| | | ers have | a thin | radiolucent | | line (also | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | coatingvariousportionsofinferiorrimofulcer. | | | | | | +| | | known | as a Hampton | | line) | traversing | +| positionshowsNSAID-inducedlinearandserpig- | Smooth,straightfoldsradiatealmosttoedgeof | | | | | | +thebaseofthecraterduetoundermin- +| inouserosions(arrows).Thispatientwastaking | ulcercrater.Thefindingsarecharacteristicofa | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --------- | +| | | ing of the | submucosa | | (59). | The pres- | +| aspirin.Surgicalclipsinrightupperquadrantare | benigngastriculcerwithretractionofadjacent | | | | | | +enceofaHamptonlineisdiagnosticofa +frompriorcholecystectomy. +gastricwall. +benigngastriculcer.Chronicinflamma- +| 38 | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure15 Figure16 +| tion and | scarring may | cause | retraction | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +oftheadjacentgastricwallwiththede- +velopmentofsmooth,straightfoldsthat +radiatedirectlytotheedgeoftheulcer +crater(Figs13,14). +| Although | giant gastric | ulcers | are | at | | | +| ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| greater | risk for bleeding | and | perfora- | | | | +| tion (62), | the size of | the ulcer | crater | is | | | +notausefulcriterionfordifferentiating +| benign | and malignant | gastric | ulcers. | | | | +| ----------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Most benign | gastric | ulcers are | located | | | | +onthelessercurvatureorposteriorwall +ofthestomachatornearthetransition +zonebetweenbody-andantral-typemu- +| cosa(Fig4).Somebenignulcersmaybe | | | | Figure15: | Double-contrastspotimageof | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------------------- | --- | +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +| located | on the greater | curvature | (al- | | | | +| ------- | -------------- | --------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +malignantgastriculcerduetolymphoma.Large +| most all | of these greater | curvature | ul- | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +lobulesoftumor(arrows)surroundirregularcen- +cersarecausedbytheuseofaspirinor +tralulcer(U)filledwithbarium,althoughbarium +other NSAIDs) (14,63) or within hiatal Figure16: Listofradiographicfeaturesdistin- +poolistoodensetoclearlydelineatemarginsof +hernias, where the stomach traverses guishingbenignandmalignantgastriculcers. +ulcer. +| the diaphragm | (64). | Thus, | ulcer loca- | | | | +| ------------- | --------------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| tion also | is not a useful | criterion | for | | | | +differentiating benign and malignant nign radiographic appearance; virtually +gastric ulcers. Radiologists therefore all of these unequivocally benign ulcers +should ignore the size and location of are ultimately proved to be benign +Figure17 +| ulcerswhenassessingtheriskofmalig- | | | | (56,65). | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +nancy;instead,theyshouldfocusonthe Incontrast,ifanulcerisassociated +morphologicfeaturesoftheselesions. withnodularityoftheadjacentmucosa, +| In general, | malignant | gastric | ulcers | mass effect, | or radiating | folds that are | +| ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | -------------- | +produceradiographicfindingsdiametri- coarse,lobulated,orirregular(Figs10, +callyopposedtothoseofbenignulcers. 15), it fulfills the radiographic criteria +With malignant ulcers, the ulcer crater foramalignantgastriculcer,andendos- +represents a focal area of necrosis and copy should be performed for a defini- +excavation within a malignant tumor, tive diagnosis. Less than 5% of ulcers +usuallygastriccarcinomaorlymphoma. have an unequivocally malignant radio- +Thesurfaceoftheulcerandofthesur- graphicappearance;almostallofthese +roundingmucosaisthereforecomposed malignant-appearing ulcers are ulti- +| of nodules, | irregular | elevations, | or | matelyprovedtobemalignant. | | | +| ----------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | +irregular depressions of varying size Finally, one-fourth to one-third of +within the tumor (Fig 15) (42). The gastric ulcers have an equivocal or in- +folds adjoining a malignant ulcer may determinateappearancethatdoesnot +have a coarse, lobulated, clubbed, or allow the radiologist to establish a +penciledshapeduetoinfiltrationofthe confident diagnosis of benignancy or Figure17: Double-contrastspotimageof +foldsbythetumor(Fig10)(42). malignancy. An ulcer is classified as gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique +Radiologists can often differentiate equivocalorindeterminateifthereare positionshowsulcer(U)onposteriorwallfilling +benign and malignant gastric ulcers on coarse areae gastricae or moderate withbarium.Smallradiolucentnodules(arrow- +the basis of the radiographic findings nodularity of the mucosa abutting the heads)areseenlateraltoulcerandlargernodules +(Fig 16). If an ulcer has a smooth sur- ulcer (Fig 17), a nodular ulcer collar, (arrows)areseenjustsuperiortoulcer.Thisnodu- +face with smooth, straight folds radiat- or mildly irregular folds radiating to laritycouldbesecondarytoedema,inflammation, +ing to the ulcer margin and no sur- theulcer’sedge.Insuchcases,endos- metaplasia,dysplasia,ortumor;findingsinthis +casedonotmeetradiographiccriteriaforabenign +rounding mass effect or mucosal nodu- copyandbiopsyareneededtoruleout +gastriculcer,andlesionshouldbeclassifiedas +larity (Figs 4, 13, 14), it fulfills the malignant tumor. Nevertheless, the +equivocal.Nevertheless,benigngastriculcerwas +radiographic criteria for a benign gas- majorityofequivocalorindeterminate +confirmedatendoscopyandfollow-up.Gastric +triculcer.Abouttwo-thirdsofallgastric ulcers are ultimately proved to be be- +metaplasiawasfoundattheedgeoftheulceron +| ulcers diagnosed | on double-contrast | | bar- | nign. | | | +| ---------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +endoscopicbiopsyspecimens. +ium studies have an unequivocally be- Some benign NSAID-induced greater +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 39 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +curvature ulcers may have an indeter- theadjacentgreatercurvature(66).De- Thesetinysacsarethoughttorepresent +minate appearance due to extensive spite a history of NSAID use, these thesequelaofhealedpepticulcers.Par- +surrounding mass effect and an appar- greater curvature ulcers therefore may tial antral diverticula are differentiated +ent intraluminal location because of requireendoscopytoruleoutanulcer- from true ulcers by their variable size +spasm and inflammatory retraction of ated gastric carcinoma. Eventually, and shape at fluoroscopy and the ab- +| | largeNSAID-inducedgreatercurvature | | | senceofassociatedinflammatorychanges. | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | ulcers may penetrate | inferiorly | via the | | | | | | +ProtrudedLesions +| Figure18 | gastrocolic ligament | into | the superior | | | | | | +| -------- | -------------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +borderofthetransversecolon,produc- Polyps.—A polyp is a small protrusion +ingagastrocolicfistula(67). fromthemucosalsurface,eithersessile +| | Diverticula.—Diverticula | | are un- | or pedunculated. | | The | term | polyp does | +| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +commonly found in the stomach. The notimplyanadenomatoushistology.In +majorityarisefromtheposteriorwallof fact,awidevarietyofbenignandmalig- +thegastricfundus(68),presumablybe- nant polypoid lesions may occur in the +causeofagapinthemuscularlayersof stomach. If polyps arise from the mu- +the gastric wall in this location. Fundal cosa,theymayhaveasmooth,nodular, +diverticula are smoothly contoured, orlobulatedsurfaceondouble-contrast +broad-mouthed outpouchings, ranging studies, and when viewed in profile, +from 1 to 10 cm in size (Fig 18). Rugal formacuteangleswiththeadjacentgas- +foldsarenotseenwithinthediverticula. tricwall(Fig5)(70).Incontrast,lesions +These diverticula can be distinguished arising from the submucosa or muscu- +from ulcers by their smooth contour, larispropriausuallyhaveaverysmooth +Figure18: Double-contrastspotimagewith +broad or shallow necks, and lack of surface and, when viewed in profile, +patientinrightdecubituspositionshowsgastric +foldsradiatingtotheirmargins. form right angles or slightly obtuse +diverticulumassmoothbarium-coatedoutpouch- +| | A variant | of a gastric | diverticulum | angles with | the | adjacent | gastric | wall | +| --- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | +ing(arrow)extendingfromposteriorwalloffun- +dus.Asmallamountofbariumispresentinlumen mayrarelybefoundonthegreatercur- (Fig 19). Although large lesions that +ofdiverticulum. vatureofthedistalantrum,alsoknown have a smooth surface are usually sub- +as a partial antral diverticulum (69). mucosal in origin, it is often difficult to +| | | | | determine | whether | protruded | | lesions | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +lessthan1–1.5cmindiameteraremu- +Figure20 +| | | | | cosal or | submucosal | in | origin, | as small | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | +| | | | | polyps originating | | in | the mucosa | may | +Figure19 +alsohaveasmoothsurface. +Hyperplasticpolypsarenonneoplas- +| | | | | tic proliferations | | of | surface | foveolar | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --------- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- | +| | | | | cells, consisting | | of elongated, | | distorted | +| | | | | pits and | numerous | | branching | glands | +| | | | | (4). These | polyps | are | typically | smooth | +| | | | | or finely | lobulated | sessile | lesions | less | +| | | | | than 1 cm | in size | (Fig | 5). Occasionally, | | +| | | | | however, | atypical | hyperplastic | | polyps | +| | | | | may be | larger | than 1 | cm in | diameter, | +pedunculated,andhaveacoarselylobu- +| | | | | lated surface | (Fig | 20) | (71–73). | At least | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | ---------- | +| | | | | one-third | of patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| | | | | polyps have | multiple | | polyps, | usually in | +thegastricbodyandfundus(Fig5)(4). +| | Figure20: Double-contrastspotimageof | | | Although | hyperplastic | | polyps | have no | +| --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | +| | gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows | | | malignantpotential,theyusuallyarisein | | | | | +Figure19: Double-contrastspotimageof 1-cminsize,sessile,slightlylobulatedpolypon thesettingofchronicgastritis,thesame +| fundusandupperbodyofstomachwithpatientin | greatercurvatureasareaofincreasedradiopacity | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +milieuthatresultsingastricmetaplasia +| semiuprightpositionshowslargesubmucosal | coatedbybarium(arrow).Althoughradiographic | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | -------- | +| | | | | and dysplasia. | | As a result, | gastric | ade- | +| massassmooth-surfacedhemisphericlesion | findingsareworrisomeforanadenomatouspolyp | | | | | | | | +| | | | | nomas and | carcinomas | | have | been re- | +| (largearrows)formingrightangles(smallarrows) | orevenasmallpolypoidcarcinoma,thislesion | | | | | | | | +| | | | | ported | to occur | with | increased | fre- | +| withadjacentluminalcontour.Surgeryrevealed | wasfoundtobealargehyperplasticpolyponen- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | quency | in patients | | with hyperplastic | | +| benigngastrointestinalstromaltumor. | doscopicbiopsyspecimens. | | | | | | | | +polyps(4). +| 40 | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure21 +Fundic gland polyps, the second in these patients. Atypical hyperplastic +mostcommongastricpolyps,areprolif- polypsthatareunusuallylargeorlobu- +erationsofthedeepepithelialcompart- lated(Fig20)areindistinguishablefrom +ment of body-type mucosa (4). These adenomatous polyps or even polypoid +polyps consist of cystically dilated pits carcinomas(71–73). +and glands lined by parietal and chief Retention polyps (juvenile polyps) +cells. Fundic gland polyps are found mayoccurassolitarylesionsorasmul- +both sporadically and in patients with tiple lesions in Cronkite-Canada syn- +familialadenomatouspolyposissyndrome. drome (76). Xanthelasmas, isolated +These polyps typically appear on dou- hamartomatous polyps, and inflamma- +ble-contrast studies as smooth-sur- toryfibroidpolypsareotherbenignpol- +faced,sessileprotrusionslessthan1cm yps occasionally encountered in the +in size. Fundic gland polyps are usually stomach. A focal cluster of polyps may +locatedinthefundusandupperbodyof also be seen in the gastric antrum or +thestomachandareoftenmultiple(74). body in patients with small carcinoid +In patients with familial adenomatous tumors. +polyposis syndrome, hundreds of small Masses.—For gastric masses larger +(" 5 mm in size) fundic gland polyps than 2 cm in size, barium studies are +Figure21: Double-contrastspotimageof +maybefound. extremelyhelpfulfordeterminingwhether +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows +Adenomatouspolypsofthestomach thelesionsarisefromthemucosa,sub- +bariumoutliningoutercontourandintersticesofa +arearelativelyuncommonmacroscopic mucosa,ormuscularispropria,orwhether +3-cmsessile,multilobulatedlesion(arrows). +formofgastricdysplasia.Adenomasare they are extrinsic to the stomach. This +Surgeryrevealedtubulovillousadenoma.(Re- +classified as tubular, tubulovillous, or differentiationenablestheradiologistto +printed,withpermission,fromreference15.) +villous on the basis of their underlying suggest a specific diagnosis or differen- +architecture. Gastric adenomas may tial diagnosis. In general, a mass origi- +progresstogastriccarcinomabymeans nating in the mucosa has a nodular or +ofapolypoidadenomatocarcinomase- lobulatedsurface,appearingenfaceon +quence similar to that found in the co- double-contrast studies as a filling de- Figure22 +lon.Insitucarcinomaorinvasivecarci- fectinthebariumpoolorasanareaof +nomaisfoundinatleast50%ofadeno- abnormalbarium-coatedlines,depend- +matous polyps larger than 2 cm in size ingonwhetheritisonthedependentor +(75).Mostgastricdysplasias,however, nondependent walls (Fig 22) (11). Not +are relatively flat macroscopically. In infrequently, irregular collections of +fact,mostgastriccarcinomasarisefrom bariumaretrappedintheintersticesof +flat or slightly elevated or depressed thetumor(Fig21)orinareasofulcer- +areas of dysplasia, not polypoid adeno- ation. Barium thus outlines multiple +mas(4). roundorovoidnoduleswithintheinter- +Insymptomaticpatients,gastricad- sticesofthelesion.Forexample,apol- +enomas detected on double-contrast ypoidcarcinomamaybemanifestedasa +studies are usually larger than 1 cm in lobulated or fungating mass within the +size(75).Theseadenomascanbesessile, expectedluminalcontour(Fig22). +lobulated, or pedunculated lesions Incontrast,asubmucosalmassmay +Figure22: Double-contrastspotimageof +(Fig 21). Although most hyperplastic appearenfaceondouble-contraststud- +uppergastricbodywithpatientinsupineposition +polyps are smaller than 1 cm and most ies as a round or ovoid, well-circum- +showsmultilobulatedpolypoidmassasconfluent, +adenomasarelargerthan1cm,itisnot scribed, smooth or slightly lobulated +lobulatedradiolucentfillingdefects(blackarrows) +always possible to distinguish a hyper- area of increased radiopacity. When +inbariumpoolwithseparateportionoflesion +plastic polyp from an adenomatous viewed in profile, a submucosal mass outlinedinwhiteongreatercurvature(whitear- +polyp on barium studies. If a polyp is 1 maybemanifestedasahemisphericin- row).Surgeryrevealedpolypoidadenocarcinoma. +cm or larger in size and has a finely traluminalprojectionthathasasmooth +nodularorlobulatedsurface,endoscopy surface and forms right angles or +and biopsy therefore should be per- slightlyobliqueangleswiththeadjacent 23)(4).Anulceratedsubmucosalmass +formed to exclude the possibility of an gastricwall(Figs19,23).Centralulcer- viewed en face produces a characteris- +adenoma.Conversely,multiplerounded ationoccursinabout50%ofsubmuco- tic“target”or“bull’s-eye”lesion,witha +polyps 5 mm or smaller in size are al- sal masses due to central ischemia and central ulcer surrounded by a smooth, +most always hyperplastic, so that en- necrosis of the tumor or pressure ne- well-definedmass(Fig24).Gastrointes- +doscopy and biopsy are not warranted crosis of the overlying epithelium (Fig tinalstromaltumorsarebyfarthemost +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 41 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +commonsolitarysubmucosalmassesin shape at fluoroscopy (78) and has fat An extrinsic mass that indents but +the stomach (77). Lymphoma and soli- attenuation at computed tomography does not infiltrate the gastric serosa is +tarymetastasesareotherfrequentsub- (79,80). Granular cell tumors usually manifested as a smooth, broad-based +mucosal tumors. Lipoma is a submuco- appear as one or more small submuco- inbowingofthegastricwall(Fig26).In +sal lesion that may change in size and sallesions.Mostothermesenchymaltu- contrast, an extrinsic inflammatory or +mors (eg, neurofibromas) are indistin- neoplasticmassthatinvolvestheserosa +Figure23 guishable from gastrointestinal stromal of the stomach may cause tethering of +| tumors. | | the gastric | wall | toward | the | extrinsic | +| -------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------ | ----------- | --------- | +| Ectopicpancreaticrest(ie,myoepi- | | process, | resulting | in | spiculation | of the | +thelial hamartoma) is an uncommon luminal contour. For example, omental +submucosallesioncomposedofvarying metastases invading the greater curva- +amounts of pancreatic tissue (including tureofthestomachthroughthegastro- +ducts, acini, and islet cells), hypertro- colic ligament may cause spiculation +phicsmoothmusclefibers,andglandular and tethering of the greater curvature +structures resembling Brunner glands (84).Extrinsicinflammatoryorneoplas- +(81,82). These lesions may be compli- tic processes that involve the gastric +catedbypancreatitis,cysts,isletcelltu- walloroccludegastriclymphaticorve- +mors, and even pancreatic carcinoma nous channels may also result in en- +(4). Ectopic pancreatic rests usually larged gastric folds. For example, pan- +appear on barium studies as small creatitissecondarilyinvolvingthestom- +(1–2cm),solitary,centrallyumbilicated ach may be manifested as thickened +| submucosal masses, | most often | on the foldsontheposteriorgastricwall. | | | | | +| ------------------ | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +greater curvature of the distal gastric Thepreciselocationofmasslesions +antrumwithin1–6cmfromthepylorus, in the stomach may help suggest the +but can occasionally be located else- diagnosisinasmallpercentageofcases. +Figure23: Double-contrastspotimageof +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows whereinthestomach(Fig25)(83). As previously discussed, a submucosal +4-cmsmooth-surfacedsubmucosalmassout- lesion on the greater curvature of the +linedinwhitebybarium(arrows).Notecentral distal gastric antrum should suggest an +Figure25 +triangular-shapedulcer(arrowheads)inmass. ectopicpancreaticrest,whereasasub- +Surgeryandclinicalfollow-uprevealedamalig- mucosal defect extending from the +nantgastrointestinalstromaltumor. lessercurvatureofthedistalantrumto +| | | the pylorus | should | suggest | | a hypertro- | +| --- | --- | -------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | phied antral-pyloric | | fold. | In | contrast, a | +| | | smooth, | undulating | submucosal | | lesion | +onthemedialaspectofthefundusnear +Figure24 +thegastriccardiashouldsuggestacon- +glomeratemassofgastricvarices(85). +Multiplicityoflesionsisanotherra- +| | | diographic | feature | that | may | be helpful | +| --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | +| | | in suggesting | | a specific | diagnosis | or | +| | | differential | diagnosis. | | Numerous | small | +("1cminsize),smoothorfinelylobu- +lated,sessileprotrusionsarealmostal- +| | | ways hyperplastic | | polyps | (Fig | 5) or, if | +| --- | --- | ----------------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | confined | to the | gastric | body | or fundus, | +fundicglandpolyps.Aclusterofpolyps +| Figure25: Double-contrastspotimageof | | elsewhere | in | the stomach | | in patients | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | +| gastricantrumwithpatientinleftposterioroblique | | withchronicHpylorigastritismayrep- | | | | | +Figure24: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowssmooth,1-cmovoid,radiolucent resent gastric carcinoid tumors due +gastricbodywithpatientinrightposterioroblique fillingdefect(arrow)inbariumpoolwithshallow to end-stage neuroendocrine hyperpla- +positionshowsbull’s-eyeortargetlesioninstom- centralumbilicationcontainingtraceamountof +| | | sia associated | | with | hypogastrinemia | | +| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | --------------- | --- | +achasa2-cmovoid,smooth-surfaced,submuco- barium(arrowhead).Endoscopicbiopsyspeci- +| | | (5,10). | Multiple | large | (# 1 | cm in size) | +| --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | +salmass(blackarrows)inbariumpoolcontaining mensrevealedanectopicpancreaticrest(myoepi- +| | | polypoid | lesions | may | represent | adeno- | +| --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | +stellatecentralulcer(whitearrow).Thispatient thelialhamartoma).Ectopicpancreaticrestsare +| | | matous | polyps, | atypical | hyperplastic | | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | +hadbreastcancerwithhematogenousmetastasis usuallylocatedongreatercurvatureofdistalan- +| | | polyps, | Peutz-Jeghers | | hamartomas, | or | +| --- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +tothestomach. +trum,butthislesionwasonposteriorwall. +evensynchronouspolypoidcarcinomas. +42 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure26 +Finally, multiple submucosal masses or tal antrum to the pylorus or even +centrally ulcerated bull’s-eye lesions may throughthepylorusintothemedialfor- +representhematogenousmetastases(such nix of the base of the duodenal bulb +as metastatic melanoma), disseminated (Fig27)(92).Inmostpatients,ahyper- +lymphoma,and,inpatientswithacquired trophied antral-pyloric fold can be dif- +immunodeficiency syndrome, Kaposi sar- ferentiated from a neoplastic lesion by +coma. itscharacteristicappearanceandloca- +tion (93). Another clue to the pres- +ThickenedFolds enceofahypertrophiedantral-pyloric +Normal rugal folds are thicker in the fold is its variable size and shape at +proximal stomach, have a smooth con- fluoroscopy, with palpation and peri- +tour in profile, and taper distally (5). stalsis. Occasionally, however, a hy- Figure26: Double-contrastspotimageof +Foldsalsoarelargerandmoreundulat- pertrophied fold may be unusually gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +ingonthegreatercurvaturethanonthe large or lobulated, so it can be mis- positionshowssmoothindentationongreater +lesser curvature. Rugal folds become taken for a polypoid or plaquelike tu- curvature(blackarrows)duetoextrinsicmass +straightandthinnerwithincreasinggas- mor(93). lesioncompressingstomach.Secondbarium- +coatedline(whitearrows)indicatesthatlumenis +tric distention and can even disappear H pylori gastritis is by far the most +narrowedasymmetrically.Areaofincreasedra- +when the stomach is fully distended, common cause of focally or diffusely +diopacity(D)alsoresultsfrommasscompressing +particularly in the gastric antrum. Be- thickened folds in the stomach. Abnor- +lumen.Thesefindingswerecausedbymassive +causeofthesenormalvariationsinfold mal folds are found in about 75% of +retroperitoneallymphoma. +size, there are no reliable criteria for patients with H pylori gastritis (89). +enlarged folds in the stomach. How- Fold enlargement in H pylori gastritis +ever,rugalfoldsaremuchmorelikelyto mostcommonlyinvolvesthegastrican- +beabnormalwhentheyhaveanirregu- trum and body but may involve the en- +lar, lobulated, or scalloped contour or tirestomachormayevenbeconfinedto +Figure27 +when they are enlarged or have an an- thegastricfundus.MostpatientswithH +gledortransverseorientationinawell- pylori gastritis have mildly to moder- +distendedgastricantrum.Foldsthatare ately thickened gastric folds without +larger on the lesser curvature than on substantialfoldirregularity(Fig28),so +the greater curvature are also consid- that the radiographic findings are not +eredtobeabnormal. worrisome for Menetrier disease or +Becauserugalfoldsarecomposedof lymphoma. However, some patients +mucosa and submucosa, any process with H pylori gastritis have such en- +thatinfiltratestheselayersofthegastric larged,lobulatedfolds(ie,polypoidgas- +wall can increase the size of the folds. tritis)thattheradiographicfindingser- +Enlargedfoldsmaybecausedbyinflam- roneously suggest a malignant process. +matory processes such as H pylori gas- Other patients with H pylori gastritis +tritis (86–89), hyperplastic processes may have focally thickened polypoid +suchasZollinger-Ellisonsyndrome(90) folds confined to the gastric antrum or +and Menetrier disease (91), or malig- bodythataremistakenradiographically +nanttumorssuchaslymphomaandsub- for a polypoid or infiltrating neoplasm +mucosally infiltrating adenocarcinoma. (88). Nevertheless, radiologists cannot +Endoscopic biopsy specimens may be assume that all cases of enlarged folds +required to differentiate these various arecausedbythisubiquitouspathogen. +causes of enlarged folds, particularly Ifthefoldsaremarkedlyenlarged,lobu- +when the folds are markedly thickened lated, or irregular (particularly if they +andirregular. haveafocalorsegmentaldistribution), +Antralgastritis(whetherornotitis endoscopic biopsy specimens should Figure27: Double-contrastspotimageof +associatedwithHpylori)isusuallyman- beobtainedtoexcludeamalignanttu- gastricantrumwithpatientinsupineleftposterior +ifestedonbariumstudiesasthickened, mor. obliquepositionshowsovoid,1.5-cmsmooth- +scalloped folds that have a longitudinal In Menetrier disease, there is surfacedsubmucosallesion(arrows)extending +fromlessercurvatureofdistalantrumtoadjacent +ortransverseorientation.Antralgastri- marked hyperplasia of surface foveolar +pylorus.Thislesionchangedinsizeandshapeat +tis may lead to the development of a mucous cells (4,10), resulting in a +fluoroscopywithpalpationandperistalsis.Find- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold, seen marked increase in the height of the +ingsarecharacteristicofhypertrophiedantral- +as a smooth submucosal defect extend- foveolae and partial atrophy of the +pyloricfold. +ingfromthelessercurvatureofthedis- glands,withacorrespondinglossofvol- +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 43 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +umeofparietalandchiefcellandsubse- Although early reports stated that fold causesurfacefoveolarcellslinetheen- +quent hypochlorhydria. The rugal folds enlargement predominantly involved tirestomach. +mayappearmassivelyenlargedandlob- thegastricfundusandbody(sparingthe Portalhypertensionsometimesmay +ulated on barium studies (Fig 29) (91). antrum) (94), later reports found that cause mucosal hyperemia with dilated +Menetrier disease causes fold enlarge- submucosal vessels in the absence of +Figure28 +mentthroughoutthestomachinatleast truevarices,aconditionknownaspor- +50% of patients (91), presumably be- tal hypertensive gastropathy (95). This +gastropathycanleadtoacuteorchronic +| Figure30 | gastrointestinal | | bleeding. | Thickened, | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | +finelynodularfoldsareseeninthegas- +tricfundusonbariumstudies(96).Gas- +| | tric varices | with | associated | esophageal | | +| --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | +varicesareusuallycausedbyportalhy- +| | pertension, | whereas | isolated | | gastric | +| --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | +| | varices | (in the | absence | of esophageal | | +varices)maybecausedbyportalhyper- +| | tension | or, less | commonly, | by | splenic | +| --- | ---------------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | +| | vein obstruction | | from pancreatic | | carci- | +noma,pancreatitis,orpancreaticpseudo- +| | cysts (97,98). | | Gastric varices | | can be | +| --- | -------------- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | +| | distinguished | from | the abnormal | | folds | +| | of portal | hypertensive | gastropathy | | by | +theirundulatingandtortuousconfigura- +Figure28: Double-contrastspotimageofstom- tion and smooth contour (Fig 30) (97). +achwithpatientinsupinepositionshowsmoderately Figure30: Double-contrastspotimageof In some patients, varices may also be +thickenedfoldsingastricbodyduetochronicHpy- gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +seenondouble-contraststudiesasmul- +lori gastritis.Foldsareconsiderablylessthickened positionshowssmooth,undulatingsubmucosal +| | tiple smooth, | round | or ovoid | nodules, | | +| --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | +andlobulatedthaninpatientwithMenetrierdisease mass(arrows)onposteriorwalloffundusextend- +likenedtotheappearanceofabunchof +ingtocardia.Thispatienthadportalhypertension +(Fig29).Notesurgicalclipsfrompriorvagotomy. grapes.Inothers,however,aconglom- +| withaconglomeratemassofgastricvarices(also | erate mass | of | gastric | varices | (also | +| ------------------------------------------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +knownastumorousvarices).Notesurgicalclips +| | known | as tumorous | varices) | may | be | +| --- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | --- | --- | +fromrecentlivertransplantation. +manifestedasasmooth,undulatingsub- +Figure29 +mucosalmassonthemedialwallofthe +fundusnearthegastriccardia(85). +| | The | normal | gastric | cardia | is usu- | +| --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------- | +Figure31 +| | ally manifested | | on double-contrast | | | +| --- | --------------- | ------------- | ------------------ | ---- | ------- | +| | studies | as a stellate | collection | of | thin, | +| | smooth | folds | radiating | to a | central | +pointatthegastroesophagealjunction +(Fig2).Anylesiondisruptingoroblit- +| | erating | the cardiac | rosette | with | asso- | +| --- | ------------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | +| | ciated nodularity, | | mass | effect, | ulcer- | +| | ation, or | distorted | folds | in this | region | +| | should | be considered | suspicious | | for | +carcinomaofthecardia(Fig31).More +| | advanced | tumors | at the | cardia | may | +| --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | +appearaspolypoid,ulcerated,orinfil- +| | trating lesions | | that can | easily be | visu- | +| ------------------------------------ | --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | ----- | +| | alized with | a | double-contrast | | tech- | +| Figure31: Double-contrastspotimageof | nique(Fig31)(99–101). | | | | | +gastricfunduswithpatientinright-side-down +Figure29: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowspolypoidmass(arrows)thathas GastricNarrowing +gastricbodywithpatientinsupinepositionshows obliteratedandreplacednormalcardiacrosette. +Narrowingoftheluminalcontourofthe +markedlythickened,lobulatedfoldsanddiffuse Arrowheadsdenoteareasofulcerationwithintu- +stomachmaybecausedbyscarring,in- +distortionofareaegastricaepatterninpatientwith mor.Thispatienthadanadvancedcarcinomaof +| | filtrating | tumor, | or extrinsic | diseases | | +| --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | +Menetrierdisease. cardia. +secondarilyaffectingthestomach.Chronic +44 Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +Figure32 Figure33 +| scarring | from peptic | ulcer | disease | may | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +| produce | asymmetric | inbowing | | and re- | | | | +| traction | of one | wall of | the stomach, | of- | | | | +| ten associated | | with | smooth, | straight | | | | +| folds that | radiate | to | the site | of the | | | | +healedulcer.Otherpatientswithpeptic +scarringhavesmooth,taperednarrow- +| ing of | the gastric | antrum | | or, less | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| commonly, | weblike | antral | narrowing | | | | | +| (Fig 32). | Scarring | from | ingestion | | of | | | +| NSAIDs | (ie, chronic | NSAID | | gastropa- | | | | +thy)canalsoresultinthecharacteristic +flatteningofthegreatercurvatureofthe +distalantrum(102). +Long-segmentnarrowingofthestom- Figure33: Double-contrastspotimageof +ach (either circumferential or confined gastricantrumandbodywithpatientinsupine +toonewall)ordiffusenarrowingofthe Figure32: Double-contrastspotimageof positionshowslongsegmentofcircumferential +stomachisusuallycausedbyaninfiltrat- narrowingextendingfrommidgastricbodytomid +distalgastricantrumandduodenalbulbwithpa- +ingorscirrhousgastriccarcinoma(103) gastricantrum(arrowsdenotelimitsoftumor). +tientinleftposteriorobliquepositionshowsshort +or metastatic breast cancer. The nar- Althoughtumorsurfaceispredominantlysmooth, +segmentofsmooth,circumferentialnarrowing +focalareasofmucosalnodularityareseeninprox- +| rowingwithscirrhouscarcinomaresults | | | | | (arrow)duetoantralwebrelatedtoscarringfrom | | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +imalendoflesion(arrowheads).Thispatienthad +| fromadesmoplasticreactiontotumor | | | | | previouspepticulcerdisease.Ifmucosalnodular- | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +scirrhousgastriccarcinomaproducingalinitis +| cells infiltrating | | the submucosa, | | pro- | ityorirregularityofluminalcontourhadbeen | | | +| ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +plasticaappearance. +| ducing | a linitis | plastica | appearance. | | present,endoscopyandbiopsywouldhavebeen | | | +| ------------------ | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | ------ | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | +| Scirrhous | carcinomas | | may be | mani- | requiredtoruleoutfocalgastriccancer. | | | +| fested | as diffuse, | long-segment, | | or | | | | +| even short-segment | | narrowing | | of any | | | | +portionofthestomach(Fig33)(103). be caused by antral scarring from +Figure34 +The narrowed lumen is rigid and non- Crohndiseaseor,rarely,othergranu- +distensible at fluoroscopy, and gastric lomatousdiseasessuchassarcoidosis, +peristalsisisobliteratedinthisregion. syphilis, and tuberculosis. Occasion- +Theluminalcontourmayhaveasmooth, ally, antral narrowing may also result +nodular, or finely ulcerated surface on from gastric atrophy related to the +double-contrast studies (Fig 33). Occa- presenceofalong-standinggastrojeju- +sionally, scirrhous carcinomas of the nal anastomosis without an antrec- +| distal antrum | may | be | very short, | cir- | tomy. | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | +cumferential lesions confined to the Atrophic gastritis is a condition in +prepyloricregionofthestomach(104). whichbody-typemucosalglandsarere- +It is important to recognize that en- placed by metaplastic cells resembling +doscopyandbiopsyhaveapoorsensi- pyloric- or intestinal-type epithelium +tivity in depicting scirrhous carcino- (10). Most atrophic gastritis is related +mas of the stomach, so that some pa- tochronicinflammationratherthanau- Figure34: Double-contrastspotimageof +tientswithradiographicallydiagnosed toimmune phenomena. This form of gastricfundusandbodywithpatientinright- +lesions may require one or more re- atrophic gastritis is often patchy and side-downpositionshowssmoothnarrowingof +peat endoscopic examinations to con- macroscopically flat, so that it is not fundusandbodyofstomachwithabsentrugal +foldsandsmall,barelyvisibleareaegastricae. +| firmthediagnosis. | | | | | recognizable | on barium studies. | In other | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | -------- | +Thesefindingsarecharacteristicofatrophic +| In contrast, | | the | narrowing | with | patients | with the autoimmune | form of | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ------------------- | ------- | +metastatic breast cancer results from atrophicgastritis,thereisseverelossof gastritis. +denseinfiltrationofthesubmucosaby parietal cell mass, resulting in inade- +tumor. Severe scarring from previous quate secretion of intrinsic factor with +causticingestionmaycausediffusean- thesubsequentdevelopmentofvitamin of gastric folds. More than 80% of pa- +tral narrowing indistinguishable from B12 deficiency and, eventually, perni- tients with pernicious anemia have a +antral carcinoma on barium studies, ciousanemia.Inthelaterstagesofauto- diffusely narrowed stomach with a +but the clinical history should suggest immuneatrophicgastritis,decreasedpari- smooth contour and decreased or ab- +the correct diagnosis. Tapered nar- etal cell mass is manifested as a dimin- sent rugal folds on double-contrast +rowingofthegastricantrummayalso ished mucosal surface volume and loss studies(Fig34). +Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 45 + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +References +| | | | | | 15.RubesinSE,LevineMS.Principlesforper- | | | | | gastritis | and primary | B-cell | gastric | lym- | +| -------- | ------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------------------------------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | formingadoublecontrastuppergastroin- | | | | | phoma.Lancet1991;338:1175–1176. | | | | | +| 1.Freeny | PC. Double-contrast | | gastrography | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | testinal | examination. | Westbury, | | NY: E-Z- | | | | | | +ofthefundusandcardia:normallandmarks 30.ParsonnetJ,HansenS,RodriguezL,etal. +EM,2000;1–29. +and their pathologic changes. AJR Am J Helicobacter pylori infection and gastric +Roentgenol1979;133:481–487. 16.RubesinSE.Galleryofdoublecontrastter- lymphoma.NEnglJMed1994;330:1267– +| | | | | | minology. | Gastroenterol | | Clin North | Am | 1271. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2.HerlingerH,GrossmanR,LauferI,Kressel +1995;24:259–288. +HY,OchR.Thegastriccardiaindouble– 31.BahkYW,AhnJR,ChoiHJ.Lymphoidhy- +| contrast | study: | its dynamic | image. | AJR | | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------ | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 17.Cho | KC, Gold | BM, Printz | DA. | Multiple | perplasiaofthestomachpresentingasum- | | | | | +AmJRoentgenol1980;135:21–29. +| | | | | | transversefoldsinthegastricantrum.Ra- | | | | | bilicatedpolypoidlesions.Radiology1971; | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3.TonerPG,CameronCHS.Thegastricmu- diology1987;164:339–341. 100:277–280. +cosa.In:WhiteheadR,ed.Gastrointestinal 18.Dheer S, Levine MS, Redfern RO, Metz 32.Sbeih F, Abdullach A, Sullican S, Meren- +and oesophageal pathology. 2nd ed. Edin- DC,RubesinSE,LauferI.Antralgastritis kowZ.Antralnodularity,gastriclymphoid +burgh, Scotland: Churchill Livingstone, radiographic findings in patients with and hyperplasia and Helicobacter pylori in +1995;15–32. without Helicobacter pylori. Br J Radiol adults. J Clin Gastroenterol 1996;22:227– +| | | | | | 2002;75:805–811. | | | | | 230. | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 4.Fenoglio-Preiser | | CM, | Noffsinger | AE, | | | | | | | | | | | +StemmermannGN,LantzPE,ListromMB. 19.LevineMS,PalmanCL,RubesinSE,Laufer 33.Torigian DA, Levine MS, Gill NS, et al. +| Gastrointestinal | | pathology: | an | atlas and | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------------- | --------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------ | --------- | +| | | | | | I,HerlingerH.Atrophicgastritisinperni- | | | | | Lymphoid | hyperplasia | of | the stomach: | ra- | +| text. Philadelphia, | | Pa: | Lippincott-Raven, | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | ciousanemia:diagnosisbydoublecontrast | | | | | diographic | findings | in five | adult | patients. | +1999;153–236. radiography. Gastrointest Radiol 1989;14: AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:71–75. +215–219. +5.RubesinSE,FurthEE,LevineMS.Gastritis 34.GentaRM,HamnerHW.Thesignificance +from NSAIDs to Helicobacter pylori. Ab- 20.Warren JR. Unidentified curved bacilli on oflymphoidfolliclesintheinterpretationof +domImaging2005;30:142–159. gastricepitheliuminchronicactivegastri- gastricbiopsyspecimens.ArchPatholLab +| | | | | | tis.Lancet1983;1:1273–1275. | | | | | Med1994;118:740–743. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6.MackintoshCE,KreelL.Anatomyandra- +diologyoftheareaegastricae.Gut1977;18: 21.Marshall BJ, Warren JR. Unidentified 35.YooCC,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Gastric +855–864. curved bacilli in the stomach of patients mucosa-associatedlymphoidtissuelymphoma: +7.Seaman WB. The areae gastricae. AJR withgastritis.Lancet1984;1:1311–1315. radiographicfindingsinsixpatients.Radiology +1998;208:239–243. +| AmJRoentgenol1978;131:554. | | | | | 22.Yardley | JH, Hendrix | TR. | Gastritis, | gas- | | | | | | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | tropathy,duodenitis,andassociatedulcer- | | | | | 36.Eidt S, Stolte | M. | Prevalence | of lymphoid | | +8.RubesinSE,HerlingerH.Theeffectofbar- +| | | | | | ative | lesions. In: | Yamada | Y, Alpers | DH, | folliclesandaggregatesinHelicobacterpy- | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +iumsuspensionviscosityonthedelineation +| | | | | | LaineL,OwyangC,PowellDW,eds.Text- | | | | | lori gastritis | in | antral and | body | mucosa. | +| -------- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | +| of areae | gastricae. | AJR | Am J | Roentgenol | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | bookofgastroenterology.3rded.Philadel- | | | | | JClinPathol1993;46:832–835. | | | | | +1986;146:35–38. +| | | | | | phia, | Pa: Lippincott | Williams | & | Wilkins, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +37.KanekoE,NakamuraT,UmedaN,Fugino +| 9.Charagundla | SR, | Levine | MS, Langlotz | CP, | 1999;1463–1499. | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +M,NiwaH.Outcomeofgastriccarcinoma +| Rubesin | SE, Laufer | I. Visualization | | of areae | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 23.DooleyCP,CohenH,FitzgibbonsPL,etal. | | | | | detectedbygastricmasssurveyinJapan. | | | | | +| gastricae | on double-contrast | | gastrointestinal | | | | | | | | | | | | +radiography: relationship to age of patients. PrevalenceofHelicobacterpyloriinfection Gut1977;18:626–630. +| | | | | | and | histologic | gastritis | in asymptomatic | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +AJRAmJRoentgenol2001;177:61–63. 38.KaibaraN,KawaguchiH,NishidoiH,etal. +| | | | | | persons. | N Engl | J Med | 1989;321:1562– | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Significanceofmasssurveyforgastriccan- +| 10.AppelmanHD.Gastritis:terminology,eti- | | | | | 1566. | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | | | | cer from | the standpoint | | of surgery. | Am J | +ology,andclinicopathologiccorrelations— +| | | | | | 24.Graham | DY, Go | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori: | Surg1981;142:543–545. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +anotherbiasedview.HumPathol1994;25: +currentstatus.Gastroenterology1993;105: +| 1006–1019. | | | | | | | | | | 39.Montesi | A, Graziani | | L, Pesaresi | A, | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | +279–282. +| | | | | | | | | | | DeNigris | E, Bearzi | I, Ranaldi | R. | Radio- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +11.LauferI,KresselHY.Principlesofdouble- +| | | | | | 25.BayerdorfferE,LehnN,HatzR,etal.Dif- | | | | | logicdiagnosisofearlygastriccancerby | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +contrastdiagnosis.In:LevineMS,Rubesin +SE,LauferI,eds.Doublecontrastgastroin- ferenceinexpressionofHelicobacterpylori routine double-contrast examination. +| | | | | | gastritisinantrumandbody.Gastroenter- | | | | | GastrointestRadiol1982;7:205–215. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +testinalradiology.3rded.Philadelphia,Pa: +ology1992;102:1575–1582. +| Saunders,2000;8–46. | | | | | | | | | | 40.GoldRP,GreenPH,O’TooleKM,Seaman | | | | | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 26.Dixon | MF. Helicobacter | | pylori and | peptic | WB.Earlygastriccancer:radiographicex- | | | | | +12.LauferI.Asimplemethodforroutinedou- +| | | | | | ulceration: | histologic | aspects. | J | Gastroen- | perience.Radiology1984;152:283–290. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +blecontraststudyoftheuppergastrointes- +terolHepatol1991;6:125–130. +tinaltract.Radiology1975;117:513–518. 41.White RM, Levine MS, Enterline HT, +| | | | | | 27.Parsonnet | J, Friedman | | GD, Vandersteen | | LauferI.Earlygastriccancer:recentexpe- | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 13.Shirakabe | H, Kobayashi | | S, Maruyama | M. | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | DP,etal.Helicobacterpyloriinfectionand | | | | | rience.Radiology1985;155:25–27. | | | | | +| Principles | and application | | of double | con- | | | | | | | | | | | +theriskofgastriccarcinoma.NEnglJMed +trast radiography. In: Shirakabe H, Nish- 1991;325:1127–1131. 42.ShirakabeH,NishizawaM,MaruyamaM, +izawaM,MaruyamaS.Atlasofx-raydiag- KobayashiS.Definitionandclassificationof +nosis of early gastric cancer. 2nd ed. To- 28.HanssonLE,EngstrandL,NyrenO,etal. earlygastriccancer.In:ShirakabeH,Nish- +kyo,Japan:Igaku-Shoin,1982;19–43. Helicobacter pylori infection: independent izawaM,MaruyamaM,KobayashiS,eds. +| | | | | | risk indicator | of | gastric | adenocarcinoma. | | Atlasofx-raydiagnosisofearlygastriccan- | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | +| 14.Levine | MS, Rubesin | | SE, Herlinger | H, | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Gastroenterology1993;105:1098–1103. | | | | | cer. 2nd | ed. Tokyo, | Japan: | Igaku-Shoin, | | +| Laufer | I. Double | contrast | upper | gastroin- | | | | | | | | | | | +1982;1–18. +| testinal | examination: | technique | | and inter- | 29.WotherspoonAC,Ortiz-HidalgoC,Flaxon, | | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pretation.Radiology1988;168:593–602. IsaccsonPG.Helicobacterpyloriassociated 43.LauferI,HamiltonJ,MullensJE.Demon- +| 46 | | | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +stration of superficial gastric erosions by WE, Goldsmith MR. Improved radio- 73.CherukuriR,LevineMS,FurthEE,Rubesin +doublecontrastradiography.Gastroenter- graphicdetectionofmultiplegastriculcers. SE, Laufer I. Giant hyperplastic polyps in +ology1975;68:387–391. AJRAmJRoentgenol1977;128:949–952. thestomach:radiographicfindingsinseven +patients.AJRAmJRoentgenol2000;175: +| 44.Op den | Orth | JO, Dekker | W. | Gastric | 58.BraverJM,PaulRE,PhilippsE,BloomS. | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1445–1448. +| erosions: | radiological | and | endoscopic | as- | Roentgendiagnosisoflinearulcers.Radiol- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +pects.RadiolClin(Belg)1976;45:88–89. ogy1979;132:29–32. 74.HizawaK,IidaM,MatsumotoT,AoyagiK, +YaoT,FujisimaM.Naturalhistoryoffundic +| 45.KikuchiY,LevineMS,LauferI,Herlinger | | | | | 59.NelsonSW.Thediscoveryofgastriculcers | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +glandpolypswithoutfamilialadenomatous +| H.Valueofflowtechniquefordouble-con- | | | | | andthedifferentialdiagnosisbetweenbe- | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +coli:follow-upobservationsin31patients. +| trast | examination | of the | stomach. | AJR | nignancy | and malignancy. | | Radiol Clin | | | | | +| ----- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Radiology1993;189:429–432. +| AmJRoentgenol1986;147:1183–1184. | | | | | NorthAm1969;7:5–25. | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +75.OpdenOrthJO,DekkerW.Gastricadeno- +| 46.Lanza | FL, Nelson | RS, Rack | MF. | A con- | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 60.Wolf | BS. Observations | on | roentgen fea- | mas.Radiology1981;141:289–293. | | | | +| trolled | endoscopic | study | comparing | the | | | | | | | | | +turesofbenignandmalignantulcers.Semin +toxiceffectsofsulindac,naproxen,aspirin, 76.DanielES,LudwigSL,LewinKJ,Ruprecht +Roentgenol1971;6:140–150. +and placebo on the gastric mucosa of RM, Rajacich GM, Schwabe AD. The +healthyvolunteers.JClinPharmacol1984; 61.OttDJ,GelfandDW,WuWC.Detectionof Cronkhite-Canadasyndrome:ananalysisof +24:89–95. gastriculcer:comparisonofsingleanddou- clinicalandpathologicfeaturesandtherapy +| | | | | | ble-contrastexamination.AJRAmJRoent- | | | | in55patients.Medicine1982;61:293–309. | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 47.LanzaFL.NSAIDSandthegastrointestinal | | | | | genol1982;139:93–97. | | | | | | | | +tract.AbdomImaging1997;22:1–4. 77.SusterS.Gastrointestinalstromaltumors. +| | | | | | 62.Barragry | TP, Blatchford | JW, | Allen MO. | SeminDiagnPathol1996;13:297–313. | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | --------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 48.Grace | E. Approach | to | the patient | with | | | | | | | | | +Giantgastriculcers:areviewof49cases. +grossgastrointestinalbleeding.In:Yamada 78.MaderalF,HunterF,FuselierG,Gonzales- +AnnSurg1986;203:255–259. +T,ed.Textbookofgastroenterology.Phila- Rogue P, Torres O. Gastric lipomas: an +delphia,Pa:LippincottWilliams&Wilkins, 63.KottlerRE,TuftRJ.Benigngreatercurva- update of clinical presentation, diagnosis +2003;698–723. ture gastric ulcer: the “sump ulcer.” Br J and treatment. Am J Gastroenterol 1984; +| | | | | | Radiol1981;54:651–654. | | | | 79:964–967. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +49.LevineMS,VerstandigA,LauferI.Serpiginous +gastric erosions caused by aspirin and other 64.Hocking BV, Alp MH, Grant AK. Gastric 79.Megibow AJ, Redmond PE, Bosniak MA, +nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. AJR ulcerationwithhiatushernia.MedJAust Horowitz L. Diagnosis of gastrointestinal +AmJRoentgenol1986;146:31–34. lipomasbyCT.AJRAmJRoentgenol1979; +1976;2:207–208. +133:743–745. +50.RobertsDM.Chronicgastritis,alcoholand +| | | | | | 65.Thompson | G, Somers | S, Stevenson | GW. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +non-ulcer dyspepsia. Gut 1972;13:768– 80.Imoto T, Nobe T, Koga M, Miyamoto Y, +| | | | | | Benign | gastric ulcer: | a reliable | radiologic | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 774. | | | | | | | | | NakataH.Computedtomographyofgastric | | | | +diagnosis?AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;141: +| | | | | | | | | | lipomas. | Gastrointest | Radiol | 1983;8:129– | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | ----------- | +| 51.BalthazarEJ,MegibowAJ,HulnickDH.Cy- | | | | | 331–333. | | | | | | | | +131. +| tomegalovirus | | esophagitis | and gastritis | in | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 66.Zboralske | FF, Stargardter | | FL, Harel GS. | | | | | +AIDS. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1985;144: 81.Barbosa JJ, Dockerty MB, Waugh JM. +Profileroentgenographicfeaturesofbenign +1201–1204. greater curvature ulcers. Radiology 1978; Pancreaticheterotopia:areviewofthelit- +| | | | | | 127:63–67. | | | | eratureandreportof41authenticatedsur- | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +52.Laufer I, Trueman T. Multiple superficial gicalcasesofwhich25wereclinicallysignif- +gastricerosionsduetoCrohn’sdiseaseof +| | | | | | 67.LevineMS,KellyMR,LauferI,RubesinSE, | | | | icant. | Surg Gynecol | Obstet | 1946;82:527– | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------ | ------------ | +thestomach:radiologicandendoscopicdi- +| | | | | | Herlinger | H. Gastrocolic | fistulas: | the in- | 542. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | +agnosis.BrJRadiol1976;49:726–728. +| | | | | | creasing | role of aspirin. | Radiology | 1993; | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | | 82.Lai EC, | Tompkins | RK. | Heterotopic | +| 53.Ariyama | J, Wehlin | L, | Lindstrom | CG, | 187:359–361. | | | | | | | | +pancreas:reviewofa26-yearexperience. +WenkertA,RobertsGM.Gastroduodenal +| | | | | | 68.Eisenberg | RL, Levine | MS. | Miscellaneous | AmJSurg1986;151:697–700. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +erosionsinCrohn’sdisease.Gastrointest +abnormalitiesofthestomach.In:GoreRM, +| Radiol1980;5:121–125. | | | | | | | | | 83.BesemannEF,AuerbachSH,WolfeWW. | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +LevineMS,eds.Textbookofgastrointesti- +Theimportanceofroentgenologicdiagnosis +54.Sloan JM. Acute haemorrahagic gastritis nal radiology. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders, ofaberrantpancreatictissueinthegastro- +| and | acute infective | gastritis: | | gastritis | | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------------- | ------ | +| | | | | | 2000;659–681. | | | | intestinal | tract. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium | +| caused | by physical | agents | and | corro- | | | | | | | | | +TherNuclMed1969;107:71–76. +| sives—uraemic | | gastritis. | In: Whitehead | | 69.Treichel | J, Gerstenberg | | E, Palme G, | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +R, ed. Gastrointestinal and oesophageal KlemmT.Diagnosisofpartialgastricdiver- 84.RubesinSE,LevineMS,GlickSN.Gastric +ticula.Radiology1976;119:13–18. +pathology. 2nd ed. Edinburgh, Scotland: involvement by omental cakes: radio- +Churchill-Livingstone,1995;461–470. 70.Gordon R, Laufer I, Kressel HY. Gastric graphicfindings.GastrointestRadiol1986; +| | | | | | polypsfoundonroutinedouble-contrastex- | | | | 11:223–228. | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +55.RumermanJ,RubesinSE,LevineMS,Long +aminationofthestomach.Radiology1980; +WB,LauferI.Gastriculcerationcausedby 85.CarucciLR,LevineMS,RubesinSE,Laufer +heaterprobecoagulation.GastrointestRa- 134:27–30. I. Tumorous gastric varices: radiographic +| diol1988;13:200–202. | | | | | | | | | findingsin10patients.Radiology1999;212: | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | 71.Joffe | N, Antonioli | DA. Atypical | appear- | | | | | +861–865. +| 56.LevineMS,CreteurV,KresselHY,Laufer | | | | | ances | of benign hyperplastic | | polyps. AJR | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +I,HerlingerH.Benigngastriculcers:diag- AmJRoentgenol1978;131:147–152. 86.deLangeEE.Radiographicfeaturesofgas- +nosis and follow-up with double-contrast tritisusingthebiphasiccontrasttechnique. +72.SmithHJ,LeeEL.Largehyperplasticpol- +radiography.Radiology1987;164:9–13. CurrProblDiagnRadiol1987;16:273–308. +| | | | | | yps of | the stomach. | Gastrointest | Radiol | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +57.BloomSM,PaulREJR,MatsueH,Poplack 1983;8:19–23. 87.GelfandDW,OttDI,ChemMY.Radiologic +| Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | | | | | | | | | 47 | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +REVIEWFORRESIDENTS:Double-ContrastUpperGastrointestinalRadiography Rubesinetal +evaluationofgastritisandduodenitis.AJR in 40 patients. Radiology 1999;213:347– graphic diagnosis and clinical significance. +AmJRoentgenol1999;173:357–361. 351. Radiology1979;132:593–598. +| | | | | 94.ReeseDF,HodgsonJR,DockertyMB.Gi- | | | 99.Balthazar | EJ, | Goldfine | S, Davidian | NM. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | +88.SohnJ,LevineMS,FurthEE,etal.Helico- +bacter pylori gastritis: radiographic find- anthypertrophyofthegastricmucosa(Me- Carcinomaoftheesophagogastricjunction. +ings.Radiology1995;195:763–767. netrier’s disease): a correlation of the AmJGastroenterol1980;74:237–243. +| | | | | roentgenographic, | pathologic, | and clinical | 100.Freeny | PC, | Marks | WM. Adenocarcinoma | | +| --------- | ----------- | ----------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --------------- | ------------ | --------------------------------- | -------------------- | ----- | ------------------ | ------ | +| 89.Levine | MS, Rubesin | SE. The Helicobacter | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | findings. | Am J Roentgenol | Radium Ther | of | the gastroesophageal | | junction: | barium | +| pylori | revolution: | radiologic perspective. | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | NuclMed1962;88:619–626. | | | andCTexamination.AJRAmJRoentgenol | | | | | +Radiology1995;195:593–596. +1982;138:1077–1084. +| | | | | 95.Smart | HL, Triger DR. Clinical | features, | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +90.Ellison EH, Wilson SD. The Zollinger- 101.LevineMS,LauferI,ThompsonJJ.Carci- +| | | | | pathophysiology, | and relevance | of portal | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ellisonsyndrome:re-appraisalandevalua- nomaofthegastriccardiainyoungpeople. +| | | | | hypertensive | gastropathy. | Endoscopy | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tion of 260 registered cases. Ann Surg AJRAmJRoentgenol1983;140:69–72. +1991;23:224–228. +1964;160:512–530. +| | | | | | | | 102.Laveran-Stieber | | RL, | Laufer I, Levine | MS. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | +96.ChangD,LevineMS,GinsbergGG,Rubesin +91.Olmsted WW, Cooper PH, Madewell JE. SE,LauferI.Portalhypertensivegastropathy: Greatercurvatureantralflattening:aradio- +| | | | | | | | logic | sign | of NSAID-related | gastropathy. | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------------- | ------------- | ----- | ---- | ---------------- | ------------ | --- | +| InvolvementofthegastricantruminMen- | | | | radiographic | findings in eight | patients. AJR | | | | | | +AbdomImaging1994;19:295–297. +| etrier’s | disease. | AJR Am J Roentgenol | | AmJRoentgenol2000;175:1609–1612. | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1976;126:524–529. | | | | | | | 103.LevineMS,KongV,RubesinSE,LauferI, | | | | | +97.LevineMS,KieuK,RubesinSE,Herlinger +| | | | | | | | Herlinger | H. | Scirrhous | carcinoma | of the | +| ------------ | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------ | +| 92.Glick SN, | Cavanaugh | B, Teplick | SK. The | H,LauferI.Isolatedgastricvarices:splenic | | | | | | | | +stomachradiographicandendoscopicdiag- +hypertrophied antral-pyloric fold. AJR vein obstruction or portal hypertension? nosis.Radiology1990;175:151–154. +| AmJRoentgenol1985;145:547–549. | | | | GastrointestRadiol1990;15:188–192. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +104.BalthazarEJ,RosenbergH,DavidianMM. +93.AroraR,LevineMS,HarveyRT,LauferI, 98.MuhletalerC.GerlockJ,GoncharenkoV, Scirrhouscarcinomaofthepyloricchannel +Rubesin SE. Hypertrophied antral-pyloric AvantGR,FlexnerJM.Gastricvaricessec- anddistalgastricantrum.AJRAmJRoent- +foldreassessmentofradiographicfindings ondary to splenic vein occlusion: radio- genol1980;134:669–673. +| 48 | | | | | | | | Radiology:Volume246:Number1—January2008 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | + +Radiology 2007 +This is your reprint order form or pro forma invoice +(Please keep a copy of this document for your records.) +Reprint order forms and purchase orders or prepayments must be received 72 hours after receipt of form either +by mail or by fax at 410-820-9765. It is the policy o f Cadmus Reprints to issue one invoice per order. +Please print clearly. +Author Name _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Title of Article _______________________________________________________________________________________________ +Issue of Journal_______________________________ Reprint # _____________ Publication Date ________________ +Number of Pages_______________________________ KB # _____________ Symbol Radiology +Color in Article? Yes / No (Please Circle) +Please include the journal name and reprint number or manuscript number on your purchase order or other correspondence. +Order and Shipping Information +Reprint Costs +(Please see page 2 of 2 for reprint costs/fees.) +Shipping Address +(cannot ship to a P.O. Box) Please Print Clearly +Name ___________________________________________ +________ Number of reprints ordered $_________ +Institution _________________________________________ +________ Number of color reprints ordered $_________ Street ___________________________________________ +City ____________________ State _____ Zip ___________ +________ Number of covers ordered $_________ +Country ___________________________________________ +Subtotal $_________ +Quantity___________________ Fax ___________________ +Taxes $_________ Phone: Day _________________ Evening _______________ +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +(Add appropriate sales tax for Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the +District of Columbia or Canadian GST to the reprints if your order is to +Additional Shipping Address* +be shipped to these locations.) (cannot ship to a P.O. Box) +Name ___________________________________________ +First address included, add $32 for Institution _________________________________________ +Street ___________________________________________ +each additional shipping address $_________ +City ________________ State ______ Zip ___________ +Country _________________________________________ +TOTAL $_________ +Quantity __________________ Fax __________________ +Phone: Day ________________ Evening ______________ +E-mail Address ____________________________________ +* Add $32 for each additional shipping address +Payment and Credit Card Details Invoice or Credit Card Information +Enclosed: Personal Check ___________ Invoice Address Please Print Clearly +Please complete Invoice address as it appears on credit card statement +Credit Card Payment Details _________ +Name ____________________________________________ +Checks must be paid in U.S. dollars and drawn on a U.S. Bank. +Institution ________________________________________ +Credit Card: __ VISA __ Am. Exp. __ MasterCard Department _______________________________________ +Card Number __________________________________ Street ____________________________________________ +Expiration Date_________________________________ City ________________________ State _____ Zip _______ +Signature: _____________________________________ Country ___________________________________________ +Phone _____________________ Fax _________________ +Please send your order form and prepayment made payable to: +E-mail Address _____________________________________ +Cadmus Reprints +P.O. Box 751903 Cadmus will process credit cards and Cadmus Journal +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 Services will appear on the credit card statement. +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +If you don’t mail your order form, you may fax it to 410-820-9765 with +FEIN #:541274108 +your credit card information. +Signature __________________________________________ Date _______________________________________ +Signature is required. By signing this form, the author agrees to accept the responsibility for the payment of reprints and/or all charges +described in this document. +RB-9/22/06 +Page 1 of 2 + +Radiology 2007 +Black and White Reprint Prices Color Reprint Prices +Domestic (USA only) Domestic (USA only) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $213 $228 $260 $278 $295 $313 1-4 $218 $233 $343 $460 $579 $697 +5-8 $338 $373 $420 $453 $495 $530 5-8 $343 $388 $584 $825 $1,069 $1,311 +9-12 $450 $500 $575 $635 $693 $755 9-12 $471 $503 $828 $1,196 $1,563 $1,935 +13-16 $555 $623 $728 $805 $888 $965 13-16 $601 $633 $1,073 $1,562 $2,058 $2,547 +17-20 $673 $753 $883 $990 $1,085 $1,185 17-20 $738 $767 $1,319 $1,940 $2,550 $3,164 +21-24 $785 $880 $1,040 $1,165 $1,285 $1,413 21-24 $872 $899 $1,564 $2,308 $3,045 $3,790 +25-28 $895 $1,010 $1,208 $1,350 $1,498 $1,638 25-28 $1,004 $1,035 $1,820 $2,678 $3,545 $4,403 +29-32 $1,008 $1,143 $1,363 $1,525 $1,698 $1,865 29-32 $1,140 $1,173 $2,063 $3,048 $4,040 $5,028 +Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 Covers $95 $118 $218 $320 $428 $530 +International (includes Canada and Mexico) International (includes Canada and Mexico)) +# of # of +50 100 200 300 400 500 50 100 200 300 400 500 +Pages Pages +1-4 $263 $275 $330 $385 $430 $485 1-4 $268 $280 $412 $568 $715 $871 +5-8 $415 $443 $555 $650 $753 $850 5-8 $419 $457 $720 $1,022 $1,328 $1,633 +9-12 $563 $608 $773 $930 $1,070 $1,228 9-12 $583 $610 $1,025 $1,492 $1,941 $2,407 +13-16 $698 $760 $988 $1,185 $1,388 $1,585 13-16 $742 $770 $1,333 $1,943 $2,556 $3,167 +17-20 $848 $925 $1,203 $1,463 $1,705 $1,950 17-20 $913 $941 $1,641 $2,412 $3,169 $3,929 +21-24 $985 $1,080 $1,420 $1,725 $2,025 $2,325 21-24 $1,072 $1,100 $1,946 $2,867 $3,785 $4,703 +25-28 $1,135 $1,248 $1,640 $1,990 $2,350 $2,698 25-28 $1,246 $1,274 $2,254 $3,318 $4,398 $5,463 +29-32 $1,273 $1,403 $1,863 $2,265 $2,673 $3,075 29-32 $1,405 $1,433 $2,561 $3,788 $5,014 $6,237 +Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 Covers $148 $168 $308 $463 $615 $768 +Tax Due +Minimum order is 50 copies. For orders larger than 500 copies, +please consult Cadmus Reprints at 800-407-9190. Residents of Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and the District +of Columbia are required to add the appropriate sales tax to each +Reprint Cover reprint order. For orders shipped to Canada, please add 7% +Cover prices are listed above. The cover will include the Canadian GST unless exemption is claimed. +publication title, article title, and author name in black. +Ordering +Reprint order forms and purchase order or prepayment is +Shipping required to process your order. Please reference journal name +Shipping costs are included in the reprint prices. Domestic and reprint number or manuscript number on any +orders are shipped via UPS Ground service. Foreign orders are correspondence. You may use the reverse side of this form as a +shipped via a proof of delivery air service. proforma invoice. Please return your order form and +prepayment to: +Multiple Shipments +Cadmus Reprints +Orders can be shipped to more than one location. Please be +P.O. Box 751903 +aware that it will cost $32 for each additional location. +Charlotte, NC 28275-1903 +Delivery +Note: Do not send express packages to this location, PO Box. +Your order will be shipped within 2 weeks of the journal print FEIN #:541274108 +date. Allow extra time for delivery. +Please direct all inquiries to: Reprint Order Forms +and purchase order +Rose A. Baynard or prepayments must +800-407-9190 (toll free number) be received 72 hours +410-819-3966 (direct number) after receipt of form. +410-820-9765 (FAX number) +baynardr@cadmus.com (e-mail) +Page 2 of 2 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q58/random_k4/random_4.md b/q58/random_k4/random_4.md index 6927512bd90f46ab9e09b90b6a7a3c1b4e782552..1b28e59a75cd68d9ec90d93e84dcd85f875e5c54 100644 --- a/q58/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q58/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,598 +1,417 @@ -## **SAGE: Selective Attention-Guided Extraction for Token-Efficient Document Indexing** - -Xinzhi Wang Peter Baile Chen Purdue University MIT wang6171@purdue.edu peterbc@mit.edu Jun Chen Michael Cafarella Independent Researcher MIT chjuncn@gmail.com michjc@csail.mit.edu - -## **ABSTRACT** - -Large language models with long context windows can answer complex questions directly from full-length academic, technical, and policy documents, but passing entire documents is often costly, slow, and can degrade answer quality while increasing the risk of unnecessary data leakage. This paper targets the common setting of answering many heterogeneous questions over long document(s), where fixed position heuristics and standard retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) can fail due to document structure variability and weak query-chunk semantic similarity, which often requires taskand domain-specific tuning of embedding retrievers. We propose Selective Attention-Guided Extraction (SAGE), a training-free, plugand-play context reduction framework that uses a lightweight local LLM to perform a single prefilling pass and convert language model attention signals into a query-specific relevance heatmap at configurable granularities. SAGE further introduces _differential attention_ strategies to better isolate question-relevant evidence, then selects the top-scoring units under a user-defined token budget and forwards only this reduced context to a downstream LLM for answer generation. SAGE surpasses traditional reduction techniques across multiple long-document QA benchmarks, notably securing a top-4 rank on QuALITY-hard while constrained to a 10% context budget. This enables a 90% reduction in tokens with competitive accuracy, without the need for model fine-tuning or complex calibration. - -## **PVLDB Reference Format:** - -Xinzhi Wang, Peter Baile Chen, Gerardo Vitagliano, Matthew Russo, Jun Chen, Michael Cafarella, Samuel Madden, and Chunwei Liu. SAGE: Selective Attention-Guided Extraction for Token-Efficient Document Indexing . PVLDB, 14(1): XXX-XXX, 2020. doi:XX.XX/XXX.XX - -## **PVLDB Artifact Availability:** - -The source code, data, and/or other artifacts have been made available at https://github.com/Tranway1/AttentiveTrim.git. - -This work is licensed under the Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 International License. Visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ to view a copy of this license. For any use beyond those covered by this license, obtain permission by emailing info@vldb.org. Copyright is held by the owner/author(s). Publication rights licensed to the VLDB Endowment. Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment, Vol. 14, No. 1 ISSN 2150-8097. doi:XX.XX/XXX.XX - -Gerardo Vitagliano Matthew Russo MIT MIT gerarvit@csail.mit.edu mdrusso@csail.mit.edu Samuel Madden Chunwei Liu MIT Purdue University madden@csail.mit.edu chunwei@purdue.edu - -## **1 INTRODUCTION** - -As LLM-based applications take on increasingly complex workloads, the demand for long-context question answering has grown rapidly [23, 25, 27, 29, 37, 42, 49]. Although recent models can ingest entire documents end-to-end [27], _more context is not always better_ . Long inputs often mix a small amount of salient evidence with substantial irrelevant text, which can distract the model and degrade answer accuracy [13, 28]. The practical overhead is also substantial: under pay-per-token commercial APIs, processing full documents directly increases monetary cost, and even in self-hosted settings, it wastes compute on non-essential text. - -These issues are exacerbated when using smaller local models. Once an input exceeds the context window of a model, the document can no longer be processed in a single forward pass, requiring chunking or multi-stage pipelines that increase latency and memory overhead while complicating deployment. - -Beyond efficiency and quality, minimizing unnecessary data exposure is a practical constraint in many real-world settings. Enterprise reports, proprietary documents, and internal analyses often contain sensitive information that should not be fully revealed to downstream or business-facing LLMs. Together, these considerations motivate _context reduction_ : extracting a compact subset of the input that preserves answer quality while bounding LLM cost and limiting unnecessary information exposure. - -A natural first idea for context reduction is to take advantage of where answers usually appear in a document. Prior work [23] and our early observations suggest that some question types do show rough structural patterns. For example, in research papers, answers are often found in sections such as the abstract, introduction, evaluation, or conclusion. This motivates validation-based positional heuristics: using a small set of documents with known answers, we can locate the answer spans, map them to token positions, and build a relevance heatmap over the document. This heatmap can then be used to guide context extraction for new documents. - -However, these patterns are only rough, and validation-based heatmaps have clear limitations. First, they rely on a strong LLM to accurately locate answer spans in long documents, which can be unreliable when documents are lengthy or vary in structure. Second, answer locations can differ a lot across question types. As shown in Figure 1, authorship-related evidence is usually concentrated near the beginning of a paper, while evidence for contributions is spread much more broadly. Third, for reasoning-heavy questions, the relevant evidence is often distributed across several sections rather than confined to a single region. For instance, a paper’s main - -**==> picture [193 x 140] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-20
10
0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Character position
(a) Who are the authors of the paper
4
2
0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Character position
(b) What is the main contribution of the paper
Frequency
Frequency
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 1: Heatmaps of ground-truth answer distributions in the Paper dataset. Author queries (a) cluster at the start, while contribution queries (b) disperse throughout.** - -contribution may be introduced in the abstract, motivated in the introduction, explained in detail later, and summarized again in the conclusion. In these cases, a single average position or fixed region is unlikely to capture all the evidence needed to answer the question correctly. - -Retrieval-Augmented Generation offers an alternative by retrieving relevant evidence before generation, reducing the need to pass entire documents to the model. RAG systems span dense bi-encoders as well as token-level late interaction retrievers such as ColBERT [17] and ColBERTv2 [38], with recent refinements that further improve token-level scoring [15]. With the emergence of long-context LLMs, RAG has also moved toward retrieving larger and more coherent units [12] and organizing evidence hierarchically [39]. Yet retrieval still relies on embedding similarity, which does not guarantee that selected chunks contain the answer. This gap is most visible when queries lack discriminative keywords or when the supportive context is only weakly aligned with the query in the embedding space. As a result, retrieval may miss critical evidence or include misleading context. For example, for a query such as “Who are the authors of this paper?”, the chunks most similar in embedding space are often in the reference section (where author names appear in citations) rather than near the title or header, where the correct answer is typically found. This failure mode becomes especially painful when many questions must be answered over the same document. - -These limitations point to a more adaptive, model-driven approach. Instead of inferring relevance indirectly via validation heatmaps or embedding similarity, we ask " _can relevance be obtained directly from the model itself?_ " Transformer-based LLMs compute attention distributions during the prefilling phase that reflect how strongly different parts of the context contribute to answering a given question. Importantly, these signals are available without generating any output. We only run the prefill pass and read the attention weights, avoiding the dominant cost of the decoding phase [1]. We find that these attention signals provide a fine-grained, query-specific relevance signal that can be exploited without external supervision. - -Building on this insight, we propose **S** elective **A** ttention- **G** uided **E** xtraction (SAGE), an attention-driven context reduction framework that uses a lightweight local LLM as a preprocessing filter. - -Given a document and a query, the local model computes tokenlevel attention over the document, producing a relevance heatmap that can be aggregated at configurable granularities such as tokens, sentences, or sections. We then select the highest-scoring units to form a compact context that can be passed to any downstream LLM for answer generation under a user-provided token budget. - -A practical challenge is that raw attention can be noisy: generic document elements such as headers, boilerplate text, and formatting cues may consistently attract attention even when they are not query-relevant. Recent work suggests that contrastive signals can help separate shared background patterns from task-specific evidence [7, 22, 47]. Inspired by this line of work, SAGE introduces _differential attention_ . We subtract attention patterns induced by a contrasting query to cancel persistent noise and better isolate query-specific evidence. - -This design offers several system-level advantages. First, SAGE reduces the original document to a compact context that retains only the content most relevant to the query. Second, it provides explicit budget control via a user-specified token budget, bounding inference cost regardless of document length. Third, unlike validation-based heatmap construction, SAGE does not require ground truth answers, validation datasets, or query-specific calibration. More broadly, the approach is training-free and can be applied directly with off-the-shelf LLMs, without model modification or fine-tuning, making it readily applicable to new questions and domains. In addition, SAGE leverages KV-cache reuse to improve efficiency by avoiding repeated encoding of the same document chunks across queries. - -We evaluate SAGE on four benchmarks spanning different modalities. On QuALITY-hard [35], SAGE ranks **4th** on the public leaderboard [34] while using only a **10%** context budget. On _Paper_ and _Notice_ [23], SAGE consistently outperforms strong embedding-based RAG baselines across token budgets, and we analyze the effects of attention model size and differential-attention variants. Finally, we show that SAGE extends to semi-structured tables without datasetspecific tuning, achieving accuracy comparable to full-table input while substantially reducing the table content passed to the generator. Looking ahead, we expect the same attention-guided principle to extend to additional modalities, including more complex semistructured tables and visual documents. - -To summarize, our contribution includes: - -- We study _budgeted context reduction_ in the setting of _multiple questions per document_ , and highlight limitations of validationbased positional heuristics and embedding only retrieval for dispersed evidence and weak lexical cues (Section 1). - -- We propose **S** elective **A** ttention- **G** uided **E** xtraction (SAGE), a training-free pipeline that uses a lightweight local LLM to compute token-level relevance and select compact context under an explicit token budget (Section 3). - -- We introduce _differential attention_ to filter out query-independent noise and improve relevance estimation, and study alternative reference queries, including a fixed baseline prompt and a farthest question contrast (Section 3.2). - -- We evaluate SAGE on four benchmarks spanning different regimes and modalities, showing consistent improvements over strong baselines in token accuracy trade-offs (Section 4). - -2 - -- We demonstrate an extension of SAGE to table selection, achieving accuracy comparable to full-table input while reducing the _average row usage_ exposed to the generator (Section 4.8). - -solely on attention signals to extract contiguous windows without training. - -## **2.3 KV Cache Compression** - -## **2 RELATED WORK** - -To mitigate the high overhead of long-context LLM inference, prior work spans several distinct but complementary directions. - -## **2.1 Long-Context RAG** - -Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) avoids full document ingestion by conditioning generation only on retrieved evidence. While early systems relied on dense single-vector encoders, late interaction retrievers like ColBERT [17], ColBERTv2 [38], and TRIAL [15] improve localization by retaining token-level structure. As longcontext LLMs emerged, methods like LongRAG [12] and RAPTOR [39] adapted by retrieving larger, coherent multi-thousand-token units or hierarchical summaries. - -However, simply retrieving more chunks is not a panacea. Jin et al. [13] shows that increasing the number of retrieved passages can actively distract the reader model with “hard negatives”, chunks of text that are highly similar to the query in embedding space but actually contain irrelevant or misleading information. This risk of degraded reasoning motivates the need for refinement pipelines like LongRefiner [14] and OP-RAG [48]. - -SAGE is highly complementary to these directions. While RAG pipelines select candidate documents or chunks, SAGE acts as a budget-constrained filter to preserve only the highest-utility evidence _within_ those texts with a finer granularity. - -## **2.2 Prompt Compression** - -When retrieval is insufficient, _prompt compression_ reduces the effective prompt length while preserving necessary information [21]. One approach compresses text into continuous _soft prompts_ [21] using learned vectors or reusable tokens, as seen in CC [43] and GIST [31]. ICAE [6] distills text using a frozen LLM, xRAG [4] injects document embeddings via a fusion bridge, and MIPRO [33] optimizes prompt programs via meta-optimization. However, soft prompts are opaque, require domain-specific training [21], and often cause semantic distortion [24]. - -To avoid meaning distortion, _hard prompt_ methods select or prune discrete tokens. Early methods like PoWER-BERT [8] and TR-BERT [46] prune tokens based on learned signals but often adopt fixed lengths on training data. Adaptive methods tailor pruning dynamically. SpAtten [41] uses proportional lengths, LTP [18] applies learned thresholds, and LLMLingua[10] scores and removes low-utility tokens. LongLLMLingua [11] further mitigates the risk of dropping crucial evidence by adding question-aware signals. Similarly, task-specific importance metrics are now actively used to compress dense token streams in multimodal settings [40]. - -To prevent the fragmentation of local syntax caused by token dropping, recent _context reduction_ systems extract contiguous sentences. CPC [24] retains top-ranked sentences using a contextaware encoder, while ZenDB [23] leverages hierarchical structure in templated documents. Unlike aggressive compressors that suffer from knowledge overwriting [9], SAGE strictly preserves the original source text, avoiding structural assumptions by relying - -A complementary line of work reduces memory and latency during decoding by optimizing the KV cache without altering the input prompt. FastGen [5] and SnapKV [20] profile attention patterns to compress caching for heavy-hitting tokens. For dynamic cache management, _𝐻_ 2 _𝑂_ [51] formulates KV eviction as a submodular optimization problem, while NACL [3] improves eviction robustness via proxy-token estimation. Beyond eviction, RetrievalAttention [26] manages cache access via approximate nearest-neighbor search, and SepLLM [2] leverages separator tokens as compact anchors. Other optimizations include dynamic cache budget allocation across layers [52] and concatenating precomputed caches across repeated contexts, as seen in KVLink [45]. While effective at reducing decoding costs, most KV-cache methods still require ingesting the full context during the computationally expensive prefilling stage. In contrast, SAGE reduces the input context _before_ generation, lowering both prefilling and decoding costs while providing explicit budget control and supporting privacy-preserving deployments. - -## **2.4 Differential and Contrastive Attention** - -Several studies highlight the critical role of attention structure for extractive tasks and long-context reasoning [44, 50]. Historically, differential attention was originally introduced in image processing via the Differential Attention Network (DAN), which contrasts supporting and opposing exemplars to better align model focus with human attention [36]. In modern LLMs, methods like Differential Transformer [47] and Grouped Differential Attention [22] introduce fundamental architectural changes, computing attention as the difference between softmax maps to cancel common-mode noise. Contrastive signals are also leveraged to isolate task-relevant visual regions in multimodal models [7] and to suppress generic text generation during the decoding phase [19]. - -In contrast to approaches that require heavy model modifications, specialized training regimens (e.g., DAN [36]), or decoding-time interventions, SAGE uses differential reasoning as a training-free filter for input context reduction. By applying this contrastive signal purely during the prefilling stage without altering the underlying Transformer, SAGE provides a lightweight, plug-and-play solution to neutralize query-agnostic noise and isolate discriminative evidence prior to generation. - -## **3 METHODOLOGY** - -Building upon the need for efficient, noise-resistant context management, this section details the architecture of SAGE. Our primary design objective is to extract the most informative text spans from a long document while strictly adhering to a user-specified token budget, ensuring that the generation LLM receives a high-quality, continuous context. - -As illustrated in Figure 2, the SAGE pipeline processes a userprovided **document** , **query** , and **token budget** across four primary stages. Stage _○_ 1 computes a query-aware document attention score through four substeps. First, in step (a), we partition the - -3 - -**==> picture [506 x 284] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-③ Unit-Window
② Differential Attention Selection ( § 3.3 ) Based on the following
Budget ( § 3.2 ) Select text windows with context, answer the
User (a) Find contrast question: highest average question concisely.
𝑞 [−] attention under a budget
Document (b) Query normalization: Context: …
ത 1 Assemble selected context
(1000 Tokens) 𝐒(q) = 𝑇𝑞 ∗𝐒 (q) into a prompt Question: …Answer:
(c) Compute differential
Query 𝒒 attention
① Compute Token Level 𝑑 𝑞= 𝐒 [ത] 𝑞 − 𝐒 [ത] 𝑞 [−] ④ Reduced Context
Prompt ( § 3.3 )
Attention Score ( § 3.1 ) SAGE
(a) Chunked Doc. Processing ( § 3.1.1 ) Query → context attention (c) Chunk-Length Normalization ( § 3.1.2 )
Context 𝐶1 Context: 𝐶1 Aggregate over heads & layers Length-based normalization: ǁ𝑠𝑖 = 𝑠𝑖 ∗ 𝑇default𝑇𝑖
(300 Tokens) Question: Answer: 𝑞 𝑇default = 300 Generate an
Context 𝐶2 Context: 𝐶2 (b) Attention Scale Bias ( § 3.1.2 ) Long chunk: ǁ𝑠1 = 𝑠1 ∗ 𝑇default𝑇1 = 𝑠1 ∗ 300300 [= 𝑠][1] answer using a generation
(300 Tokens) Question: Answer: 𝑞 • Softmax distributes fixed scale• Fewer tokens share the mass Short chunk: ǁ𝑠4 = 𝑠4 ∗ 𝑇4 LLM
𝑇default
Context 𝐶3 Context: 𝐶3 ⇒ higher attention scale
(300 Tokens) Question: Answer: 𝑞 𝑠1 𝑠4 (d) Reconstruct full-doc. Attention ( § 3.1.3 ) Generated
(100 Tokens)Context 𝐶4 Question: Context: 𝑞𝐶4 𝑠𝑠32 Misaligned attention scale Concatenating chunk attention scores: 𝐒= 𝑐𝑜𝑛𝑐𝑎𝑡 ǁ𝑠1, ǁ𝑠2, ǁ𝑠3, ǁ𝑠4 Answer
Answer: Lower attention scale Higher attention scale
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 2: Overview of the SAGE pipeline.** _○_ **1** _**Attention computation**_ **utilizes chunked processing and length normalization to form a document-level score.** _○_ **2** _**Differential attention**_ **refines relevance by filtering structural noise.** _○_ **3** _**Unit-window selection**_ **extracts top text spans under the budget.** _○_ **4 Spans are assembled into a** _**reduced-context prompt**_ **for final answer generation.** - -document into chunks that fit within the context window of a lightweight local LLM, computing token-level attention scores for each chunk paired with the query. Because these raw scores can be skewed by chunk length, we identify attention scale misalignment across chunks in step (b) and apply _chunk-length normalization_ in step (c) to remove the scale difference caused by varying chunk sizes. Finally, in step (d), we map these normalized scores back to their original positions to reconstruct a cohesive, full document attention score. - -In Stage _○_ 2 , we first apply _query normalization_ so scores are on a consistent scale across different questions. Then, _differential attention_ is used to filter out noise and highlight query-relevant signals. Unit-window selection (Stage _○_ 3 ) leverages these refined scores to extract the most useful, coherent text spans within the allocated budget. Finally, in Stage _○_ 4 , these selected spans are assembled into a reduced-context prompt and passed to the generation model to produce the final answer. In the following subsections, we discuss each stage in detail. - -## **3.1 Chunked Attention Computation and Normalization** - -_3.1.1 Chunked Attention Computation._ As we try to extract the parts of a long document that are truly relevant for answering a query, we first need a query-aware signal of token importance. Selfattention offers a natural choice. When a Transformer processes the question, each query token allocates attention to the earlier context tokens it relies on. We therefore use a lightweight local - -LLM to measure how much attention the query assigns to each document token, yielding an efficient relevance score for guiding later selection. Given a document _𝐷_ and a query _𝑞_ , let _𝑇𝐷_ and _𝑇𝑞_ denote the number of tokens in the tokenized document and query, respectively. - -A direct forward pass over the concatenation of the full document and query is often infeasible, because _𝑇𝐷_ + _𝑇𝑞_ may exceed the context window of the model. We therefore partition the document into _𝑛_ contiguous chunks: - -**==> picture [76 x 9] intentionally omitted <==** - -Each chunk _𝐶𝑖_ contains _𝑇𝑖_ tokens, where _𝑇𝑖_ ≤ _𝑇_ default, and _𝑇_ default is a predefined chunk size chosen to fit the local model context window. In practice, all chunks except possibly the last one have length _𝑇_ default. - -For each chunk _𝐶𝑖_ , we construct the prompt - -Context: _𝐶𝑖_ ; Question: _𝑞_ ; Answer: - -and run a forward pass through the local LLM to extract selfattention scores. Such a forward pass only requires prefilling, and no decoding or token generation is performed. This is sufficient, as our goal is to read off how the model routes attention when interpreting the question, not to produce an answer at the current stage. As the context is placed before the query in the input sequence, each query token can attend to all tokens in _𝐶𝑖_ . We aggregate these attention scores across query tokens, layers, and heads to obtain a relevance score for each context token. - -4 - -For the _𝑡_ -th token in chunk _𝐶𝑖_ , the raw attention score is - -**==> picture [180 x 29] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _𝑐𝑖,𝑡_ denotes the _𝑡_ -th token in chunk _𝐶𝑖_ , and _𝐴ℓ,ℎ_ ( _𝑞𝑘,𝑐𝑖,𝑡_ ) is the self-attention scores assigned to _𝑐𝑖,𝑡_ when processing query token _𝑞𝑘_ at layer _ℓ_ and head _ℎ_ . - -However, we cannot use the raw score _𝑠𝑖,𝑡_ directly. Chunks might have different lengths, most notably the last chunk, as the example shown in Figure 2 Step _○_ 1 section (a) and (b). This variation changes the scale of the resulting attention values. We therefore need normalization. - -_3.1.2 Chunk-Length Normalization._ In Transformer self-attention, the scores for each query token are produced by a softmax over all visible previous tokens. As a result, each query token distributes a fixed total attention mass across the available context tokens. When we aggregate attention across query tokens, layers, and heads to form _𝑠𝑖,𝑡_ , the attention score is influenced not only by token relevance but also by how many tokens share this fixed attention mass. - -This dynamic introduces a structural bias during chunked processing. If two chunks are equally relevant but differ in length, the shorter chunk will inherently exhibit a higher attention scale simply because the same total attention mass is distributed across fewer tokens. As a result, tokens in shorter chunks can appear artificially inflated in importance compared to those in longer chunks. - -To make the attention scale aligned across chunks, we apply a simple chunk-length based normalization: - -**==> picture [156 x 21] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _𝑇𝑖_ is the length of chunk _𝐶𝑖_ and _𝑇_ default is the default chunk length. - -This normalization reduces the scores of shorter chunks in proportion to their length, preventing the inflation caused by higher attention scale. As illustrated in Figure 2 Stage _○_ 1 , Step (a) and (b), the normalization is especially important for the final chunk, which is often shorter than _𝑇_ default. - -_3.1.3 Reconstructing Full Document Attention._ After computing normalized attention scores for all chunks, we reconstruct a full document attention score by concatenating chunk-level vectors in their original order. Let s˜ _𝑖_ denote the normalized attention vector for chunk _𝐶𝑖_ . We define the full document attention vector as - -**==> picture [171 x 9] intentionally omitted <==** - -The resulting vector S is aligned with the original document token order and serves as the full document relevance score for the next stage. - -_3.1.4 KV-cache reuse for efficient attention computation._ Computing attention independently for every chunk–query pair would require repeatedly encoding the same chunk content for different queries. To eliminate this redundancy, we reuse the model’s key–value (KV) cache. - -We decompose the chunk–query input into two parts. The _prefix_ is the context section, while the _suffix_ is the query section. The - -**==> picture [118 x 80] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [119 x 76] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [239 x 18] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-(a) Raw attention without differ- (b) Differential attention with its
ential attention farthest query
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 3: Effect of differential attention on token-level relevance. (a) Without differential attention, generic structural tokens "Introduction" receive high attention. (b) With differential attention, generic content attention is canceled, reducing noise in the attention score.** - -query text is inserted after the Question: marker and varies across queries. - -For each chunk _𝐶𝑖_ , we encode the prefix once and store the resulting KV states. These cached states represent the hidden representations of the chunk tokens and can be reused for multiple queries. We index cache entries using a hash of the chunk token IDs and maintain the cache per document. When switching to a new document, all cached states are cleared to prevent cross-document reuse. - -When processing a query _𝑞_ for chunk _𝐶𝑖_ , we retrieve the cached KV states and run the model only on the query suffix, supplying the cached states as past key values. During this step, each query token attends to the cached context tokens, allowing the model to produce the same attention scores as if the full prefix–suffix sequence had been processed jointly. We then aggregate these attention scores to compute _𝑠𝑖,𝑡_ without re-encoding the chunk. - -This cache-based execution preserves the exact attention computation while substantially improving efficiency. Each chunk is encoded once and can be reused across many queries, reducing both computation and memory overhead. - -## **3.2 Differential Attention** - -A full document attention map is not yet sufficient for context selection. Raw attention is a useful relevance score, but it often highlights content that is broadly noticeable rather than truly informative for the target query, such as section headers and formatting markers. Figure 3 illustrates this behavior. In Figure 3a, the model correctly attends to useful evidence, but it also gives high attention to the header token “Introduction,” which is noticeable in the document structure but not necessarily relevant to the query. Because of this, attention-guided selection may waste budget on text that looks important but is not actually useful for answering the question. This observation suggests a simple way to separate signal from background. Many of these high-attention regions are query invariant. They receive attention for a wide range of questions because they are prominent or central to the document structure. If we can estimate this shared background attention, we can subtract it away and keep what remains distinctive to the target query. - -5 - -**==> picture [242 x 181] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Each query token distributes total attention
Document D mass 1 over 𝐷.
Summing across query tokens scales with
Query 𝑞 Query 𝑞 [−] query length; we average over query tokens .
What is the What is the Differential attention
title of the publication year score for query q
paper? and venue of
𝑑 𝑞= 𝑺 [ഥ] 𝑞− 𝑺 [ഥ] 𝑞 [−]
the paper?
Compute
attention scale
for 𝑞 and 𝑞 [−]
1
Query-to- Query-to- ഥ𝑺 𝑞= 𝑇𝑞 𝑺 𝑞𝑘
document document
attention attention 1 −
𝐒 𝑞𝑘 𝐒 𝑞𝑘− ഥ𝑺 𝑞 [−] = 𝑇𝑞− [ 𝑺] 𝑞𝑘
Query Normalization
Unified attention scale Moderate attention scale High attention scale
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 4: Query normalization for differential attention. Each query token distributes a fixed total attention scale over** _𝐷_ **,** S( _𝑞_ ) **is the aggregation over all heads and layers across tokens with query length. We therefore average the Queryto-document attention scale to obtain** S[¯] ( _𝑞_ ) = _𝑇_ 1 _𝑞_[S][(] _[𝑞]_[)] **[and]** ¯S( _𝑞_[−] ) = _𝑇𝑞_ 1[−][S][(] _[𝑞]_[−][)] **[, then compute]** _[ 𝑑]_[(] _[𝑞]_[)][=][ ¯S][(] _[𝑞]_[) −][¯S][(] _[𝑞]_[−][)] **[.]** - -As illustrated in Figure 3b, we compute attention for the target query and for a contrasting query, then take their difference. Regions that are highly attended under both queries are treated as background and largely cancel out; regions that matter primarily for the query remain prominent, yielding a cleaner, more query-specific relevance score. - -This framing raises two practical questions that we address next. First, how to perform the subtraction properly? Second, how do we construct an effective contrasting query that captures documentwide noise while minimally overlapping with the true evidence needed for the target query? - -One practical challenge is that we cannot directly subtract the two aggregated attention scores when the queries have different lengths. Each query token spreads a fixed amount of attention mass over the document, so a longer query naturally accumulates a larger total attention magnitude even when the overall attention pattern is similar. To make the two scores comparable, we first normalize attention by query length before taking the difference. - -_3.2.1 Query Normalization._ Figure 4 illustrates why query normalization is necessary. Consider two queries over the same document: a shorter target query _𝑞_ , "What is the title of the paper?" and a longer contrasting query _𝑞_[−] , "What is the publication year and venue of the paper?". Even if both queries attend to the same generic regions of the document, the longer query contributes more total attention mass simply because it has more query tokens, causing a misalignment in attention scale. As a result, directly subtracting the aggregated scores S( _𝑞_ ) and S( _𝑞_[−] ) would confuse query length with relevance. - -To remove this bias, we convert each reconstructed query-todocument attention score into an average per-query-token score. Using the full document attention vector from Equation (3), we write S( _𝑞_ ) and S( _𝑞_[−] ) for the reconstructed attention scores obtained with the target query _𝑞_ and the contrasting query _𝑞_[−] , respectively. - -We then normalize each score by its query length: - -**==> picture [151 x 21] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [196 x 10] intentionally omitted <==** - -**==> picture [159 x 22] intentionally omitted <==** - -We then define the differential attention score for the target query as - -**==> picture [162 x 10] intentionally omitted <==** - -This normalization unifies the attention scale of the two queries before subtraction, so the difference reflects relevance rather than query length. In practice, it stabilizes differential attention when query lengths vary and prevents longer queries from dominating the difference purely due to scale. - -The resulting score d( _𝑞_ ) highlights regions that are more strongly attended by the target query than by the contrasting query. Tokens that attract attention under both queries tend to cancel out and move closer to zero, while tokens that are uniquely relevant to the target query receive larger positive values. - -_3.2.2 Applying Differential Attention in SAGE._ To make differential attention effective, the contrasting query should attend to document regions that differ from those needed by the target query. This improves separation between target-specific evidence and shared background attention, and therefore increases the denoising effect of subtraction. - -- In our implementation, we consider three variants for analysis: - -- **Raw query (** _𝑞_ **).** The user’s original question, without differential subtraction. - -- **Fixed contrast query.** A fixed prompt shared across the dataset. For this paper, we used _“Please repeat the context.”_ . - -- **Farthest query (** _𝑞_[−] **).** A query selected to be maximally dissimilar to the target query. When multiple questions are available for the same document, we choose the farthest query as the one whose embedding is most distant from the target query embedding. By single differential attention calculation, we got target-specific evidence revealed for both queries. - -We compare these variants empirically in Section 4.6 and show that using a semantically distant contrast query yields a cleaner relevance score and improves downstream selection quality. - -## **3.3 Unit Window Selection with Budget Control** - -Given the unified attention scores from the earlier stages, SAGE converts token-level relevance signals into a set of coherent text snippets that the generation model can consume under a strict token budget. - -Although attention is computed at the token level, selecting only isolated high-scoring tokens produces a fragmented context that is poorly suited for generation. LLMs generally benefit from contiguous spans that preserve local semantics. We therefore perform budget-aware selection over fixed-length windows and merge overlapping windows into coherent snippets. To reduce the effect of spiky token-level scores, we also apply a light local smoothing step before window scoring so that nearby tokens in the same evidence span receive more consistent scores. - -6 - -We define a user-specified budget _𝑏_ ∈(0 _,_ 1] as the fraction of the document to retain. The total number of selected tokens is constrained to ⌈ _𝑏𝑇𝐷_ ⌉. We use a base window ratio _𝑤_ = 0 _._ 02 (2% of the document length) and define the window length _𝐿_ as - -**==> picture [88 x 27] intentionally omitted <==** - -When _𝑏 < 𝑤_ , selecting a single window preserves the most relevant contiguous region under the budget. When the budget is larger than _𝑤_ , fixing the window size allows SAGEto select multiple evidence regions distributed across the document. - -We slide a length _𝐿_ window over the full document attention matrix and compute an aggregate score for each window. Windows are ranked by score, and selection proceeds greedily under the budget constraint. If a newly selected window overlaps with previously selected spans, the spans are merged. Otherwise, the window is added as a new span. This process continues until the token budget is exhausted. - -This strategy avoids two common failure modes. First, selecting a single long span may introduce substantial irrelevant text while missing important evidence in other parts of the document. At the other extreme, selecting many disjoint high-scoring tokens or tiny spans yields a fragmented context that is difficult for the generation model to use. Unit-window selection balances these extremes by concentrating the budget on high utility regions while preserving local coherence. - -Finally, the selected snippets are assembled in an original logical order into a reduced context prompt and then passed to a generation model to produce the final answer. - -## **4 EVALUATION** - -We evaluate SAGE on four datasets that stress attention guided context reduction from different angles, including document length, structure, modality, and question format: QuALITY [35], Paper [23], Notice [23], and AIT-QA [16]. We report task performance under varying token budgets and compare SAGE against RAG baselines on each dataset. For evaluation, we use an LLM as a judge to provide a binary correctness decision. We also compute cosine similarity for all questions to measure semantic alignment between SAGE’s generated responses and the ground truth. Together, these metrics provide a complementary view of output quality. - -Rather than treating each dataset as an isolated benchmark, we use them to examine complementary aspects of long context understanding, including reasoning across distributed evidence, robustness to domain variation, efficiency under tight token budgets, and adaptability to inputs. - -We structure our evaluation around the following guiding questions: - -- (Q1) Does SAGE consistently outperform retrieval-based pipelines that use strong embedding models under aligned token budgets? - -- (Q2) Can SAGE handle reasoning-intensive questions when relevant evidence is hard to find by keywords or semantic similarity? - -- (Q3) How does token budget size affect accuracy? - -- (Q4) How does the size of the attention model influence context selection quality and accuracy? - -- (Q5) How does SAGE compare with retrieval pipelines in runtime cost and computational overhead? - -- (Q6) Does SAGE remain effective across different domains and document structures without dataset-specific tuning? - -- (Q7) How do different differential attention strategies influence context selection quality? - -- (Q8) Can SAGE remain effective under budgets smaller than a single retrieval chunk, where chunk-based methods become inflexible? - -- (Q9) Can attention-guided selection extend to other modalities while preserving task accuracy? - -## **4.1 Datasets** - -The four datasets varied in different modalities, context lengths, and QA formats. They also varied in their primary focus and the number of questions, allowing us to evaluate SAGE comprehensively across diverse settings. Table 1 summarizes these key characteristics. - -**QuALITY** [35] is a long passage, multiple-choice benchmark for reading comprehension and reasoning. We evaluate on **QuALITYhard** , a difficult subset constructed by labeling questions that annotators could not reliably answer under time-constrained search, but could answer in an untimed setting. As a result, QuALITY-hard emphasizes questions that require integrating evidence across the passage rather than relying on localized keyword matches. - -**Paper** and **Notice** are derived from ZenDB [23] and provide multi-question workloads over the same document. _Paper_ contains very long scientific publications with both localized metadata queries and open-ended semantic questions, such as the main contribution. This complexity makes it a challenging setting for retrieval and a highly useful testbed for analyzing differential attention. _Notice_ consists of regulatory notices written in formal, repetitive legal language. Its questions target specific fields whose answers are typically localized within the document. - -Finally, **AIT-QA** [16] evaluates whether attention-guided selection extends beyond free text to semi-structured tables. It contains 515 questions over 116 tables with complex headers and domainspecific terminology. - -## **4.2 Baselines** - -We compare SAGE against a standard RAG pipeline. We instantiate the RAG baselines with top-performing embedding models from the MTEB leaderboard [30, 32], including _Octen-Embedding4B_ , _Qwen3-Embedding-8B_ , and _UAE-Large-V1_ . These three models cover a strong range of retrieval quality and computational cost, and represent competitive, widely used choices in modern RAG systems. - -Retrieval is performed at the document level. For each query, RAG searches only among chunks belonging to the corresponding document, rather than across the entire corpus. For each document, we tokenize the text and split it into overlapping chunks of fixed length. We compute embeddings for all chunks and retrieve the top- _𝑘_ chunks most similar to the query using cosine similarity. Retrieved chunks are reordered according to their original positions in the document, deduplicated in overlapping regions, concatenated, - -7 - -**Table 1: Summary of evaluation datasets. The four datasets provide complementary test settings across different perspectives.** - -|**Dataset**|**Modality**|**Context**|**QA format**|**Main focus**|**# Questions**| -|---|---|---|---|---|---| -|**QuALITY-**|Text (passage)|Long-|Multiple-choice|Multi-hop and Reasoning intensive|hard subset of QuALITY| -|**hard**||context||reading comprehension|| -|**Paper**|Text (scientifc|Very long-|Open ended QA|Mixed factual and semantic extrac-|9 per document| -|(ZenDB)|papers)|context||tion; long-document analysis|| -|**Notice**|Text (regulatory|Long
con-|Open ended QA|Localized factual extraction under|6 per document| -|(ZenDB)|notices)|text||aligned token budgets|| -|**AIT-QA**|Table
(airline|Semi-|QA|Table QA over complex headers and|515 (over 116 tables)| -||SEC flings)|structured||domain-specifc content|| - - - -and then fed to the answer-generation model. To isolate the effect of context selection, we use the same answer generation model and decoding configuration for both RAG and SAGE. In particular, generation is conditioned on the selected context and the query, with the temperature fixed to 0.0 to eliminate stochastic variation. We vary _𝑘_ to assess how retrieval depth impacts performance and, when feasible, adjust the resulting prompt length to match SAGE’s token budget, enabling fair, token-aligned comparisons. - -## **4.3 Evaluation Metrics** - -We evaluate answer quality using two complementary criteria: _LLM-based judgment_ and _semantic similarity_ . These metrics are chosen to reflect the heterogeneous answer formats across datasets, ranging from discrete multiple choice and numeric outputs to long, open-ended textual responses. - -_LLM-Based Judgment._ Evaluating long-context QA is challenging because many questions admit multiple valid phrasings, and small surface differences do not necessarily indicate incorrect reasoning. We therefore use an LLM as a judge to apply explicit, taskaware grading rules and produce a binary correctness decision. For QuALITY, answers are discrete, so correctness is evaluated by exact match. For the other datasets, the judge directly decides whether an answer is correct, allowing harmless rephrasing while penalizing missing or incorrect core content. - -As answer formats and grading criteria differ across datasets, we design a separate judging prompt for each dataset. Each prompt specifies the expected answer format and the criteria for correctness, and is shared by SAGE and all baselines within that dataset. To ensure the judge behaves as intended, we manually inspected the prompts and audited a substantial sample of judged instances (about 200 per dataset) to verify that the outputs follow the stated rules. - -_Semantic Similarity Score._ Binary correctness can hide meaningful differences among partially correct answers, especially for long, open-ended responses where the format may vary even if the core idea aligns with the ground truth. To better characterize answer quality, we additionally compute a semantic similarity score between the generated answer and the reference. Specifically, we embed both texts and report their cosine similarity in [0,1], which is robust to paraphrasing and reflects partial semantic overlap. We analyze similarity at the distribution level using Cumulative Distribution Functions (CDFs) to compare how often each method produces high-similarity answers under different context budgets. - -## **4.4 Experimental Setup** - -To enable a fair, controlled comparison, we use separate models for attention computation, retrieval, answer generation, and evaluation, while keeping all other settings and pipeline components fixed. - -_Attention Models._ For SAGE, attention scores are computed using three language models of increasing scale: _LLaMA-3.2-1B_ , _Qwen38B_ , and _Qwen3-14B_ . These models are used exclusively for attention estimation and do not participate in answer generation. This setup allows us to study the impact of model capacity on attention quality while keeping the downstream generation fixed. - -_Answer Generation and Evaluation._ All methods, including RAG baselines, use _Gemini-2.5-Flash-Lite_ for answer generation. By fixing the generation model and decoding configuration, we isolate the effect of context selection. Unless stated otherwise, SAGE uses the farthest query differential attention variant when constructing the reduced context for generation. LLM-based evaluation is performed using _GPT-4o-mini_ across all datasets. - -_Embeddings._ Different embedding models are used at different stages to balance efficiency and semantic fidelity. For farthest question selection in differential attention, we use _all-MiniLM-L6-v2_ due to its low computational cost and reliable relative distance estimates. For semantic similarity evaluation, we use _Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B_ , which provides stronger semantic representations while remaining efficient at scale. - -## **4.5 QuALITY** - -QuALITY-hard [35] is designed to stress long-context reasoning. The questions are typically unambiguous, but answering them often requires combining evidence from multiple parts of a passage rather than matching a single keyword-rich context. This makes QuALITY-hard a direct test of whether attention-guided context reduction can preserve reasoning quality when relevant evidence is not reliably surfaced by retrieval similarity. In this section, we focus on answering (Q1) to (Q5). - -_4.5.1 Effectiveness compared to strong RAG baselines (Q1, Q2)._ Figure 5 shows that SAGE outperforms on QuALITY-hard across a range of tested token budgets. The strength of SAGE comes from better context selection, not from using a large attention model. For instance, at a 10% token budget, SAGE with Qwen3-14B achieves similar accuracy compared to RAG configurations that use nearly four times as many tokens. Moreover, even the smallest attention - -8 - -**==> picture [242 x 172] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-0.70
0.65
0.60
0.55
0.50
SAGE
0.45 LLaMA-3.2-1B
Qwen3-8B
0.40 QRAG Baselineswen3-14B
Qwen3-Embedding-8B
0.35 UAE-Large-V1
Octen-Embedding-4B
0.30
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Avg. Token Usage (%)
Avg. Accuracy
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 5: Accuracy on QuALITY-hard versus average token usage. We compare SAGE using attention models of different sizes with RAG baselines using different retrieval embeddings. Even the 1B attention model outperforms RAG, and performance improves as model size increases.** - -model, _LLaMA-3.2-1B_ , outperforms all strong RAG baselines across the evaluated budget range. SAGE works well as it selects evidence based on attention signals that reflect how the question connects to different parts of the passage, which helps when evidence is spread across the document. Overall, these results address (Q1) and (Q2): Across all evaluated settings, SAGE consistently outperforms RAG baselines at similar or lower token usage, including RAG configurations using strong retrieval embeddings. - -_4.5.2 More token budget is not always better (Q3)._ As the token budget increases, both SAGE and RAG generally improve in Figure 5. However, at larger budgets, the marginal gains diminish, and the curves begin to plateau. Concretely, once the prompt already contains the key evidence, adding more context yields few additional correctly answered questions. This pattern suggests that QuALITY-hard is not primarily bottlenecked by raw context length. Instead, performance depends largely on retrieval quality and on whether the prompt contains the _right_ evidence. The observation is consistent with prior findings that adding more retrieved context does not necessarily translate into better long-context QA accuracy [13, 28]. Taken together, these results answer (Q3): accuracy saturates beyond moderate budgets, indicating that evidence selection matters more than simply providing more tokens. - -Token usage between SAGE and RAG is not strictly aligned on QuALITY. QuALITY documents vary substantially in length, approximately 1.5K to 6K words without punctuation [35]. Because RAG retrieves fixed-size chunks, the final prompt length depends on the number of retrieved chunks and the amount of overlap among them, which makes it difficult to hit an exact token budget in practice. In contrast, SAGE directly optimizes for a user-specified budget and can reliably meet it, while chunk-based retrieval may overshoot or undershoot the desired token limit. - -_4.5.3 Ablation on attention model size (Q4)._ As we increase the attention model size from _LLaMA-3.2-1B_ to _Qwen3-8B_ and _Qwen314B_ , accuracy improves consistently across budgets. The effect - -is strongest under tight constraints, where selection mistakes are most costly. At a 5% token budget, accuracy increases from **0.36** (1B) to **0.46** (8B) and **0.48** (14B), meaning that larger attention models enable SAGE to answer substantially more questions correctly while operating under the same strict budget. At higher budgets the gap shrinks, again reflecting diminishing returns once most key evidence is already included. - -Importantly, SAGE does not require a large attention model to be effective: even the 1B scorer remains competitive and already outperforms the strongest RAG baselines in Figure 5. Overall, these results answer (Q4), increasing attention model capacity improves selection quality and yields higher QA accuracy, with the largest gains under tight budgets. - -_4.5.4 Runtime and computational overhead (Q5)._ We further examine the runtime on QuALITY-hard. For RAG, the dominant overhead comes from computing embeddings for all **8,798** chunks, which takes **98.2s** (UAE-Large-V1), **370.7s** (Qwen3-Embedding-8B), and **838.6s** (Octen-Embedding-4B). For SAGE, using _LLaMA-3.2-1B_ as the attention model, we answer **3,797** queries in **690.9s** , with **3,011** cache hits that reuse document encodings across queries. Overall, SAGE is slower than the UAE and Qwen3 RAG baselines, but faster than the Octen baseline. Taken together, these results answer (Q5). SAGE operates in a similar runtime regime to retrieval pipelines while achieving materially higher QuALITY-hard accuracy. - -_4.5.5 Public leaderboard: competitive ranking under strict budgets._ On the public QuALITY leaderboard [34], SAGE ranks **4th** on QuALITY-hard while using only a **10%** context budget with _Qwen38B_ . This demonstrates that the accuracy gains we observe in controlled experiments translate to a competitive end-to-end system under strict token constraints. Notably, SAGE achieves this ranking with substantially lower token usage than many other highperforming systems. Many of those approaches rely on heavier pipelines, such as fine-tuning and longer inputs, which typically lead to higher inference latency. - -## **4.6 Paper** - -We next evaluate SAGE on the _Paper_ dataset from ZenDB [23]. Compared to QuALITY-hard, Paper pushes context reduction into a more realistic long document setting. Scientific papers are substantially longer and follow a clear section structure. Their questions vary from asking localized metadata, such as venue and year, to open-ended semantic queries like the main contribution of a paper. This combination lets us test whether the advantages of SAGE extend beyond narrative passages. Concretely, _Paper_ answers (Q1), (Q2), (Q3), and (Q7), and serves as evidence for (Q6). Without any dataset-specific tuning, SAGE remains effective on Paper, indicating that the benefits of attention-guided context reduction extend beyond narrative passages to structurally complex scientific writing. - -_4.6.1 LLM-judge accuracy: (Q1) to (Q3)._ Figure 6 reports LLMjudge accuracy over average token usage for several representative questions. Overall, SAGE achieves higher accuracy than RAG baselines at similar budgets ((Q1)), and its performance increases smoothly with additional context, indicating that the extra tokens selected by attention are generally helpful rather than distracting. - -9 - -**==> picture [506 x 167] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-SAGE Farthest RAG Qwen3 Embedding 8B RAG Uae Large V1 RAG Bflhc Octen Embedding 4B
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%)
(a) What is the number of authors (b) What is the main contribution (c) What is the publication year (d) What is the title of the paper
of the paper and venue of the paper
Accuracy Accuracy Accuracy Accuracy
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 6: LLM-judge accuracy on the Paper dataset. Accuracy vs. average token usage over documents for SAGE and RAG baselines across representative questions.** - -**==> picture [506 x 150] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-SAGE 0.5% SAGE 10.0% Best RAG 1.5% Best RAG 15.5%
SAGE 1.0% SAGE 15.1% Best RAG 10.9%
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00
Similarity Score Similarity Score Similarity Score Similarity Score
(a) What is the number of au-(b) What is the main contribution (c) What is the publication year (d) What is the title of the paper
thors of the paper and venue of the paper
P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x)
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 7: Semantic similarity CDFs on the Paper dataset. CDFs of cosine similarity between generated and ground-truth answers, comparing SAGE to the best RAG baseline at matched average token usage (including the 0.5% budget). Results use Qwen3-8B.** - -The difference is most visible on reasoning-intensive questions where evidence is not well captured by keyword similarity, addressing (Q2). For example, on _“What is the main contribution of the paper?”_ , SAGE improves rapidly with budget and remains consistently above RAG across the displayed range. In other words, as we allow more context, the extra tokens selected by SAGE more often contain the missing evidence needed to answer the question correctly, whereas retrieving more chunks improves correctness more slowly. - -For questions with more localized answers, such as publication year and venue in Figure 6c, both methods benefit from additional context, but SAGE reaches high accuracy with fewer tokens. For metadata queries such as title and author count, SAGE again achieves consistently stronger accuracy under the same budgets, reflecting more reliable selection of document regions that contain the relevant fields. - -We also evaluated larger budgets up to 40%. However, for most questions, performance flattens out at moderate budgets, with only - -a small subset continuing to improve at higher budgets. This answers (Q3) and motivates focusing Figure 6 on the most informative range up to 15%, which captures the most informative setting where differences between methods are most pronounced. - -_4.6.2 Semantic similarity: (Q1) to (Q3)._ We complement judge accuracy with semantic similarity distributions. Figure 7 plots CDFs of cosine similarity between generated answers and ground truth references. For a similarity threshold _𝑥_ , the y-axis reports the fraction of questions whose similarity exceeds _𝑥_ . Curves that lie higher indicate better overall answer quality. We plot the similarity threshold from 1 to 0 on the x-axis to make high similarity behavior easier to compare. We also evaluated ROUGE. It shows the same overall trends. For clarity, we report cosine similarity. - -Across representative questions, SAGE dominates the best performing RAG baseline in the middle-to-high similarity region, reinforcing (Q1) by showing improvements in overall answer quality rather than only binary pass rates. The largest gains again appear on open-ended reasoning questions such as “main contribution”. - -10 - -**==> picture [506 x 160] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Raw (b=0.005) Raw (b=0.15) Fixed Question (b=0.005) Fixed Question (b=0.15) Farthest (b=0.005) Farthest (b=0.15)
Raw (b=0.1) Raw (b=0.4) Fixed Question (b=0.1) Fixed Question (b=0.4) Farthest (b=0.1) Farthest (b=0.4)
1.0 1.0
0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00
Similarity Score Similarity Score
(a) what is the authors of the paper (b) what is the main contribution of
the paper
P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x)
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 8: Effect of differential attention on the Paper dataset. Semantic similarity CDFs compare Raw attention with differential attention variants under different token budgets. Experiments are conducted using Qwen3-8B.** - -This supports our answer to (Q2). Under the same budget, SAGE produces a higher fraction of answers that closely match the reference semantics, while increasing retrieval depth yields smaller shifts in the distribution. The CDFs also answer (Q3): increasing the budget generally shifts curves upward, but the improvements flatten out at larger budgets. - -Taken together, the judge and similarity views agree that SAGE converts budget into answer quality more effectively than retrieval, especially for reasoning-intensive semantic questions. - -_4.6.3 Different Differential Attention Variant (Q7)._ We study the differential attention variant on _Paper_ . Figure 8 compares raw attention with fixed contrast query and farthest query. Across budgets and representative questions, both differential variants shift the similarity CDFs upward relative to raw attention, meaning they produce a larger fraction of high-quality answers under the same token budget. This directly answers (Q7): differential attention strengthens context selection by filtering out noise and producing cleaner, query-specific relevance scores. - -Between the two variants, farthest question performs best overall. Its CDF curves dominate the fixed contrast variant across most similarity thresholds, with especially clear gains on reasoning questions (Figure 8b). In practice, prefer an informative contrast question when available. Otherwise, use fixed contrast, which still delivers strong performance. - -## **4.7 Notice** - -We next evaluate on the _Notice_ dataset from ZenDB [23]. Notice documents have less variation in length, which enables more controlled comparisons with aligned token usage between SAGE and RAG. Extremely small budgets that fall below a single retrieval chunk are studied on this dataset. As Notice has a markedly different document style, the results below provide additional evidence for (Q6), showing SAGEremains effective without specific tuning. - -_4.7.1 Accuracy and semantic quality under aligned budgets._ Figure 9 reports LLM-judge accuracy versus average token usage for representative questions, and Figure 10 complements this view with semantic similarity distributions. Across questions, SAGE matches - -**Table 2: AIT-QA results comparing full-table RAG and Top-4 row selection methods.** - -||**Method**
Full Table
SAGE|**Value**
0.88
0.87|**Avg. Row Usage**
100%
51%| -|---|---|---|---| - - - -or outperforms strong RAG baselines at aligned token usage, while also supporting substantially smaller budgets (Q1). - -_4.7.2 Budgets below a single retrieval chunk (Q8)._ Notice highlights a practical limitation of chunk-based retrieval. Even retrieving a single chunk incurs a fixed token cost, which limits its flexibility under tight budgets. In contrast, SAGE selects evidence at finer granularity and remains effective even when the budget is smaller than a single retrieved chunk. This answers (Q8): SAGE can operate at extremely low budgets that chunk-based RAG cannot meaningfully support. - -_A failure mode at larger budgets._ An instructive exception appears for _“What are the state abbreviation and ZIP code of the company?”_ in Figure 9d. Here, SAGE performs best at small budgets, but accuracy decreases as the budget grows and approaches the RAG baselines. The same trend appears in the similarity CDF (Figure 10d). This behavior reflects a limitation of greedy attention-based selection in repetitive documents. With a small budget, SAGE typically captures the query-relevant ZIP code. As the budget increases, additional sections containing other ZIP codes may be included, introducing competing candidates and reducing precision. More broadly, this highlights that adding more context is not always beneficial when documents contain repeated entities and near duplicate fields. - -## **4.8 AIT-QA** - -We finally evaluate whether attention-guided selection extends beyond free-form text to semi-structured inputs, addressing (Q9), using the _AIT-QA_ dataset [16]. Each document in AIT-QA is a structured table represented in JSON format. As a result, neither standard RAG nor token-based context reduction can be applied - -11 - -**==> picture [506 x 167] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-SAGE Farthest RAG Qwen3 Embedding 8B RAG Uae Large V1 RAG Bflhc Octen Embedding 4B
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0 20 40 60 0 20 40 60 0 20 40 60 0 20 40 60
Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%) Average tokens used (%)
(a) What are the violation items (b) What is the date of the notice (c) What is the name of the com-(d) What are the state abbreviation
pany and ZIP code of the company
Accuracy Accuracy Accuracy Accuracy
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 9: LLM-judge accuracy on the Notice dataset. Accuracy versus average token usage for SAGE and RAG baselines across representative questions. SAGE supports budgets smaller than a single RAG chunk. For question (d), accuracy decreases as token usage increases; we discuss this failure mode in Section 4.7.** - -**==> picture [506 x 154] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-SAGE 5.0% SAGE 38.1% SAGE 74.2% Best RAG 22.8% Best RAG 53.0% Best RAG 74.0%
SAGE 22.1% SAGE 53.1% Best RAG 7.6% Best RAG 37.9%
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.00
Similarity Score Similarity Score Similarity Score Similarity Score
(a) What are the violation items (b) What is the date of the notice (c) What is the name of the com-(d) What are the state abbreviation
pany and zip code of the company
P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x) P(Similarity > x)
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -**Figure 10: Semantic similarity CDFs on the Notice dataset. CDFs compare SAGE and the best performing RAG baseline under matched average token budgets across representative questions. Results are obtained using Qwen3-8B for attention estimation.** - -directly. If a table is split into text chunks or partial windows would break row–column structure and substantially hinder reasoning. - -To handle this setting, we adapt SAGE to operate at the _row level_ . We compute query-aware attention over the full table in its original JSON representation. For each row, we aggregate tokenlevel attention into a single relevance score and then select the top- _𝑘_ rows. The reduced prompt includes only the selected rows along with the column headers. - -Table 2 compares this row-selection variant with a full-table baseline. Selecting only the top rows achieves accuracy comparable to using the full table, while substantially reducing the amount of table content passed to the generation model. This answers (Q9), SAGE can preserve task accuracy on semi-structured tables while enabling budget-aware context reduction. - -These findings show that SAGE remains effective beyond unstructured text, highlighting its potential as a flexible, budget-aware context selection framework that transfers across data types without additional fine-tuning (Q6). - -## **5 CONCLUSION** - -We presented SAGE, a training-free, plug-and-play context reduction framework that leverages a lightweight local LLM to extract highly compact, fine-grained, and query-relevant subsets from long documents under strict token budgets. Across four complementary benchmarks, SAGE consistently outpaces strong RAG baselines in token efficiency, demonstrating its largest gains on complex, reasoning-intensive questions. Furthermore, by utilizing differential attention, the framework remains highly effective even on substantially longer, noisy scientific papers. Beyond standard text, our results on AIT-QA confirm that SAGE naturally extends to structured inputs, preserving critical tabular data while drastically reducing the exposed context. Moving forward, we aim to enhance disambiguation mechanisms for complex structured data, integrate multi-stage retrieval, and expand SAGE to process richer multimodal documents. - -12 - -## **REFERENCES** - -- [1] Amey Agrawal, Nitin Kedia, Anmol Agarwal, Jayashree Mohan, Nipun Kwatra, Souvik Kundu, Ramachandran Ramjee, and Alexey Tumanov. 2025. On Evaluating Performance of LLM Inference Serving Systems. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2507.09019_ (2025). - -- [2] Guoxuan Chen, Han Shi, Jiawei Li, Yihang Gao, Xiaozhe Ren, Yimeng Chen, Xin Jiang, Zhenguo Li, Weiyang Liu, and Chao Huang. 2024. Sepllm: Accelerate large language models by compressing one segment into one separator. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.12094_ (2024). - -- [3] Yilong Chen, Guoxia Wang, Junyuan Shang, Shiyao Cui, Zhenyu Zhang, Tingwen Liu, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Dianhai Yu, and Hua Wu. 2024. Nacl: A general and effective kv cache eviction framework for llm at inference time. In _Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ . 7913–7926. - -- [4] Xin Cheng, Xun Wang, Xingxing Zhang, Tao Ge, Si-Qing Chen, Furu Wei, Huishuai Zhang, and Dongyan Zhao. 2024. xrag: Extreme context compression for retrieval-augmented generation with one token. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 37 (2024), 109487–109516. - -- [5] Suyu Ge, Yunan Zhang, Liyuan Liu, Minjia Zhang, Jiawei Han, and Jianfeng Gao. 2023. Model tells you what to discard: Adaptive kv cache compression for llms. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.01801_ (2023). - -- [6] Tao Ge, Jing Hu, Lei Wang, Xun Wang, Si-Qing Chen, and Furu Wei. 2023. Incontext autoencoder for context compression in a large language model. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2307.06945_ (2023). - -- [7] Yuyao Ge, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Baolong Bi, Xuanshan Zhou, Jiayu Yao, Jiafeng Guo, and Xueqi Cheng. 2025. Focusing by Contrastive Attention: Enhancing VLMs’ Visual Reasoning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.06461_ (2025). - -- [8] Saurabh Goyal, Anamitra Roy Choudhury, Saurabh Raje, Venkatesan Chakaravarthy, Yogish Sabharwal, and Ashish Verma. 2020. Power-bert: Accelerating bert inference via progressive word-vector elimination. In _International Conference on Machine Learning_ . PMLR, 3690–3699. - -- [9] Ruishan Guo, Yibing Liu, Guoxin Ma, Yan Wang, Yueyang Zhang, Long Xia, Kecheng Chen, Zhiyuan Sun, and Daiting Shi. 2026. When Less is More: The LLM Scaling Paradox in Context Compression. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.09789_ (2026). - -- [10] Huiqiang Jiang, Qianhui Wu, Chin-Yew Lin, Yuqing Yang, and Lili Qiu. 2023. Llmlingua: Compressing prompts for accelerated inference of large language models. In _Proceedings of the 2023 conference on empirical methods in natural language processing_ . 13358–13376. - -- [11] Huiqiang Jiang, Qianhui Wu, Xufang Luo, Dongsheng Li, Chin-Yew Lin, Yuqing Yang, and Lili Qiu. 2024. Longllmlingua: Accelerating and enhancing llms in long context scenarios via prompt compression. In _Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ . 1658–1677. - -- [12] Ziyan Jiang, Xueguang Ma, and Wenhu Chen. 2024. Longrag: Enhancing retrievalaugmented generation with long-context llms. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2406.15319_ (2024). - -- [13] Bowen Jin, Jinsung Yoon, Jiawei Han, and Sercan O Arik. 2024. Long-context llms meet rag: Overcoming challenges for long inputs in rag. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.05983_ (2024). - -- [14] Jiajie Jin, Xiaoxi Li, Guanting Dong, Yuyao Zhang, Yutao Zhu, Yongkang Wu, Zhonghua Li, Ye Qi, and Zhicheng Dou. 2025. Hierarchical document refinement for long-context retrieval-augmented generation. In _Proceedings of the 63rd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ . 3502–3520. - -- [15] Hyukkyu Kang, Injung Kim, and Wook-Shin Han. 2025. TRIAL: Token Relations and Importance Aware Late-interaction for Accurate Text Retrieval. In _Proceedings of the 2025 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing_ . 16875–16888. - -- [16] Yannis Katsis, Saneem Chemmengath, Vishwajeet Kumar, Samarth Bharadwaj, Mustafa Canim, Michael Glass, Alfio Gliozzo, Feifei Pan, Jaydeep Sen, Karthik Sankaranarayanan, et al. 2022. Ait-qa: Question answering dataset over complex tables in the airline industry. In _Proceedings of the 2022 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies: Industry Track_ . 305–314. - -- [17] Omar Khattab and Matei Zaharia. 2020. Colbert: Efficient and effective passage search via contextualized late interaction over bert. In _Proceedings of the 43rd International ACM SIGIR conference on research and development in Information Retrieval_ . 39–48. - -- [18] Sehoon Kim, Sheng Shen, David Thorsley, Amir Gholami, Woosuk Kwon, Joseph Hassoun, and Kurt Keutzer. 2022. Learned token pruning for transformers. In _Proceedings of the 28th ACM SIGKDD conference on knowledge discovery and data mining_ . 784–794. - -- [19] Xiang Lisa Li, Ari Holtzman, Daniel Fried, Percy Liang, Jason Eisner, Tatsunori B Hashimoto, Luke Zettlemoyer, and Mike Lewis. 2023. Contrastive decoding: Open-ended text generation as optimization. In _Proceedings of the 61st annual_ - -_meeting of the association for computational linguistics (volume 1: Long papers)_ . 12286–12312. - -- [20] Yuhong Li, Yingbing Huang, Bowen Yang, Bharat Venkitesh, Acyr Locatelli, Hanchen Ye, Tianle Cai, Patrick Lewis, and Deming Chen. 2024. Snapkv: Llm knows what you are looking for before generation. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 37 (2024), 22947–22970. - -- [21] Zongqian Li, Yinhong Liu, Yixuan Su, and Nigel Collier. 2025. Prompt compression for large language models: A survey. In _Proceedings of the 2025 Conference of the Nations of the Americas Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ . 7182–7195. - -- [22] Junghwan Lim, Sungmin Lee, Dongseok Kim, Wai Ting Cheung, Beomgyu Kim, Taehwan Kim, Haesol Lee, Junhyeok Lee, Dongpin Oh, and Eunhwan Park. 2025. Grouped Differential Attention. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2510.06949_ (2025). - -- [23] Yiming Lin, Madelon Hulsebos, Ruiying Ma, Shreya Shankar, Sepanta Zeighami, Aditya G Parameswaran, and Eugene Wu. 2025. Querying templatized document collections with large language models. In _2025 IEEE 41st International Conference on Data Engineering (ICDE)_ . IEEE, 2422–2435. - -- [24] Barys Liskavets, Maxim Ushakov, Shuvendu Roy, Mark Klibanov, Ali Etemad, and Shane K Luke. 2025. Prompt compression with context-aware sentence encoding for fast and improved llm inference. In _Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence_ , Vol. 39. 24595–24604. - -- [25] Chunwei Liu, Matthew Russo, Michael Cafarella, Lei Cao, Peter Baile Chen, Zui Chen, Michael Franklin, Tim Kraska, Samuel Madden, Rana Shahout, et al. [n.d.]. Palimpzest: Optimizing ai-powered analytics with declarative query processing. - -- [26] Di Liu, Meng Chen, Baotong Lu, Huiqiang Jiang, Zhenhua Han, Qianxi Zhang, Qi Chen, Chengruidong Zhang, Bailu Ding, Kai Zhang, et al. 2024. Retrievalattention: Accelerating long-context llm inference via vector retrieval. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.10516_ (2024). - -- [27] Jiaheng Liu, Dawei Zhu, Zhiqi Bai, Yancheng He, Huanxuan Liao, Haoran Que, Zekun Wang, Chenchen Zhang, Ge Zhang, Jiebin Zhang, et al. [n.d.]. A comprehensive survey on long context language modeling. 2025. _URL https://api. semanticscholar. org/CorpusID_ 277271533 ([n. d.]). - -- [28] Nelson F Liu, Kevin Lin, John Hewitt, Ashwin Paranjape, Michele Bevilacqua, Fabio Petroni, and Percy Liang. 2024. Lost in the middle: How language models use long contexts. _Transactions of the Association for Computational Linguistics_ 12 (2024), 157–173. - -- [29] Yubo Ma, Yuhang Zang, Liangyu Chen, Meiqi Chen, Yizhu Jiao, Xinze Li, Xinyuan Lu, Ziyu Liu, Yan Ma, Xiaoyi Dong, et al. 2024. Mmlongbench-doc: Benchmarking long-context document understanding with visualizations. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 37 (2024), 95963–96010. - -- [30] mteb. [n.d.]. MTEB leaderboard - a hugging face space by mteb. https:// huggingface.co/spaces/mteb/leaderboard - -- [31] Jesse Mu, Xiang Li, and Noah Goodman. 2024. Learning to compress prompts with gist tokens. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 36 (2024). - -- [32] Niklas Muennighoff, Nouamane Tazi, Loïc Magne, and Nils Reimers. 2023. Mteb: Massive text embedding benchmark. In _Proceedings of the 17th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics_ . 2014–2037. - -- [33] Krista Opsahl-Ong, Michael J Ryan, Josh Purtell, David Broman, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia, and Omar Khattab. 2024. Optimizing instructions and demonstrations for multi-stage language model programs. In _Proceedings of the 2024 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing_ . 9340–9366. - -- [34] Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Alicia Parrish, Nitish Joshi, Nikita Nangia, Jason Phang, Angelica Chen, Vishakh Padmakumar, Johnny Ma, Jana Thompson, He He, and Samuel Bowman. [n.d.]. QuALITY Leaderboard — nyu-mll.github.io. https://nyumll.github.io/quality/. [Accessed 01-03-2026]. - -- [35] Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Alicia Parrish, Nitish Joshi, Nikita Nangia, Jason Phang, Angelica Chen, Vishakh Padmakumar, Johnny Ma, Jana Thompson, He He, and Samuel Bowman. 2022. QuALITY: Question Answering with Long Input Texts, Yes!. In _Proceedings of the 2022 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies_ . Association for Computational Linguistics, Seattle, United States, 5336–5358. https://aclanthology.org/2022.naacl-main.391 - -- [36] Badri Patro and Vinay P Namboodiri. 2018. Differential attention for visual question answering. In _Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision and pattern recognition_ . 7680–7688. - -- [37] Rui Qian, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Yuhang Zang, Shuangrui Ding, Dahua Lin, and Jiaqi Wang. 2024. Streaming long video understanding with large language models. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 37 (2024), 119336– 119360. - -- [38] Keshav Santhanam, Omar Khattab, Jon Saad-Falcon, Christopher Potts, and Matei Zaharia. 2022. Colbertv2: Effective and efficient retrieval via lightweight late interaction. In _Proceedings of the 2022 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies_ . 3715–3734. - -- [39] Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D Manning. 2024. Raptor: Recursive abstractive processing for tree-organized retrieval. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ . - -13 - -- [40] Kele Shao, TAO Keda, Kejia Zhang, Sicheng Feng, Mu Cai, Yuzhang Shang, Haoxuan You, Can Qin, Yang Sui, and Huan Wang. [n.d.]. A Survey of Token Compression for Efficient Multimodal Large Language Models. _Transactions on Machine Learning Research_ ([n. d.]). - -- [41] Hanrui Wang, Zhekai Zhang, and Song Han. 2021. Spatten: Efficient sparse attention architecture with cascade token and head pruning. In _2021 IEEE international symposium on high-performance computer architecture (HPCA)_ . IEEE, 97–110. - -- [42] Yuetian Weng, Mingfei Han, Haoyu He, Xiaojun Chang, and Bohan Zhuang. 2024. Longvlm: Efficient long video understanding via large language models. In _European Conference on Computer Vision_ . Springer, 453–470. - -- [43] David Wingate, Mohammad Shoeybi, and Taylor Sorensen. 2022. Prompt compression and contrastive conditioning for controllability and toxicity reduction in language models. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2022_ . 5621–5634. - -- [44] Wenhao Wu, Yizhong Wang, Guangxuan Xiao, Hao Peng, and Yao Fu. 2024. Retrieval head mechanistically explains long-context factuality. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2404.15574_ (2024). - -- [45] Jingbo Yang, Bairu Hou, Wei Wei, Yujia Bao, and Shiyu Chang. 2025. Kvlink: Accelerating large language models via efficient kv cache reuse. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2502.16002_ (2025). - -- [46] Deming Ye, Yankai Lin, Yufei Huang, and Maosong Sun. 2021. Tr-bert: Dynamic token reduction for accelerating bert inference. In _Proceedings of the 2021 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies_ . 5798–5809. - -- [47] Tianzhu Ye, Li Dong, Yuqing Xia, Yutao Sun, Yi Zhu, Gao Huang, and Furu Wei. 2024. Differential transformer. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.05258_ (2024). - -- [48] Tan Yu, Anbang Xu, and Rama Akkiraju. 2024. In defense of rag in the era of long-context language models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.01666_ (2024). - -- [49] Peiyuan Zhang, Kaichen Zhang, Bo Li, Guangtao Zeng, Jingkang Yang, Yuanhan Zhang, Ziyue Wang, Haoran Tan, Chunyuan Li, and Ziwei Liu. 2024. Long context transfer from language to vision. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2406.16852_ (2024). - -- [50] Zhenyu Zhang, Runjin Chen, Shiwei Liu, Zhewei Yao, Olatunji Ruwase, Beidi Chen, Xiaoxia Wu, and Zhangyang Wang. 2024. Found in the middle: How language models use long contexts better via plug-and-play positional encoding. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 37 (2024), 60755–60775. - -- [51] Zhenyu Zhang, Ying Sheng, Tianyi Zhou, Tianlong Chen, Lianmin Zheng, Ruisi Cai, Zhao Song, Yuandong Tian, Christopher Ré, Clark Barrett, et al. 2024. H2o: Heavy-hitter oracle for efficient generative inference of large language models. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ 36 (2024). - -- [52] Xiabin Zhou, Wenbin Wang, Minyan Zeng, Jiaxian Guo, Xuebo Liu, Li Shen, Min Zhang, and Liang Ding. 2024. DynamicKV: Task-aware adaptive KV cache compression for long context LLMs. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.14838_ (2024). - -14 - +FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Herzogenaurach, March 9, 2022 +adidas delivers strong results in 2021 and +expects double-digit sales growth in 2022 +Major developments FY 2021 +• Currency-neutral revenues up 16% driven by growth in all markets +• Excellent top-line momentum in EMEA, North America and Latin America with strong +double-digit increases in each region +• Double-digit growth in DTC reflecting improvements in both online and offline +• Gross margin increases to 50.7% driven by higher full-price sales and better inventory +management +• Operating margin increases 5.3 percentage points to 9.4% +• Net income from continuing operations grows more than € 1 billion to € 1.492 billion +• Executive and Supervisory Boards propose dividend increase of 10% to € 3.30 per share +Outlook for FY 2022 +• Currency-neutral sales to increase at a rate between 11% and 13%, already reflecting +up to € 250 million of risk in Russia/CIS business related to the war in Ukraine +• Gross margin to increase to a level of between 51.5% and 52.0% +• Operating margin to increase to a level of between 10.5% and 11.0% +• Net income from continuing operations to grow to between € 1.8 billion and € 1.9 billion +Kasper Rorsted, CEO of adidas: “Unfortunately, we release our 2021 results in unsettling +times. Our thoughts and prayers are with the Ukrainian people, our teams on the ground and +everyone affected by the war. We strongly condemn any form of violence and stand in solidarity +with all those calling for peace. We also provide immediate humanitarian aid to those in need +of support. We will continue to follow the situation closely and take future business decisions +and actions as needed, always prioritizing our employee’s safety and support.” +“In 2021, we delivered a strong set of results despite several external factors weighing on both +demand and supply throughout the year”, Kasper Rorsted continued. “Wherever markets +operated without major disruptions we have been experiencing strong top-line momentum. +This is reflected in double-digit revenue growth in EMEA, North America and Latin America. +While we continued to invest heavily into our brand, our direct-to-consumer business, and our +digital transformation, we improved our bottom-line by more than € 1 billion. Taking it all +together, 2021 was a successful first year within our new strategic cycle. In 2022, we will build +1 + +on this momentum and continue to grow both our top- and bottom-line at double-digit rates +amid heightened uncertainty.” +Financial Performance in 2021 +Currency-neutral sales grow 16% despite challenging market environment +In 2021, adidas was able to increase its currency-neutral revenues by 16% despite several +external factors weighing on both demand and supply throughout the year. In total, the +challenging market environment in Greater China, extensive covid-19-related lockdowns in +Asia-Pacific as well as industry-wide supply chain disruptions reduced revenue growth by +more than € 1.5 billion during the year. From a channel perspective, the company’s top-line +increase was characterized by a strong recovery from the material revenue decline in its +physical distribution channels during 2020, when the global coronavirus pandemic had caused +a large number of temporary store closures. As a result, wholesale revenues as well as sales +in adidas’ own-retail stores grew at strong double-digit rates in 2021. E-commerce revenues +increased 4% during the year, on top of the exceptionally high growth in 2020 when e- +commerce revenues had grown by more than 50%. In euro terms, the company’s revenues +increased 15% in 2021 to € 21.234 billion (2020: € 18.435 billion). +Revenue improves in all market segments +While sales increased in all market segments in 2021, the top-line development in the regions +differed significantly depending on the impact the various demand and supply challenges had +on the specific region. While all markets were negatively impacted by industry-wide supply +chain challenges, the company recorded particularly strong developments in markets that +operated without major covid-19-related disruptions. Accordingly, currency-neutral sales in +EMEA, North America, and Latin America increased by 24%, 17%, and 47%, respectively. At +the same time, the challenging market environment in Greater China (+3%) and the extensive +covid-19-related restrictions in Asia-Pacific (+8%) weighed on adidas’ results in these +markets. +Gross margin at 50.7% driven by higher full-prices sales and better inventory management +The company’s gross margin increased 0.7 percentage points to 50.7% in 2021 (2020: 50.0%). +While negative currency developments, higher supply chain costs and a less favorable channel +and market mix weighed on the development in 2021, higher full-price sales and lower +inventory allowances as well as the non-recurrence of last year’s purchase order cancellation +costs were able to overcompensate the negative effects. +2 + +Operating margin improves by 5.3 percentage points +Other operating expenses increased 4% to € 8.892 billion in 2021 (2020: € 8.580 billion). As a +percentage of sales, other operating expenses were down 4.7 percentage points to 41.9% +(2020: 46.5%). Marketing and point-of-sale expenses increased 7% to € 2.547 billion +(2020: € 2.373 billion) due to increased investments into the brand supporting the introduction +of new products and to drive consumer experience across both digital and physical platforms. +As a percentage of sales, marketing and point-of-sale expenses decreased 0.9 percentage +points to 12.0% (2020: 12.9%). Operating overhead expenses increased 2% to € 6.345 billion +(2020: € 6.207 billion) including more than € 220 million stranded costs related to the +divestiture of the Reebok business. As a percentage of sales, operating overhead expenses +decreased 3.8 percentage points to 29.9% (2020: 33.7%). As a result of the strong top-line +increase in combination with the improved gross margin and lower operating expenses as a +percentage of sales, the company’s operating profit increased 166% to € 1.986 billion in 2021 +(2020: € 746 million). Consequently, the operating margin increased 5.3 percentage points to +9.4% compared to the prior year level of 4.0%. +Net financial result decreases +Financial income decreased 32% to € 19 million in 2021 (2020: € 29 million), while financial +expenses were down 22% to € 153 million (2020: € 196 million). As a result, the company +recorded a negative net financial result of € 133 million (2020: negative € 167 million). The +company’s tax rate decreased 0.8 percentage points to 19.4% in 2021 (2020: 20.2%). +Net income from continuing operations increases by more than € 1 billion +Net income from continuing operations increased 223% to € 1.492 billion in 2021 (2020: +€ 461 million). Both basic and diluted EPS from continuing operations also increased 223% to +€ 7.47 (2020: € 2.31). +Average operating working capital as percentage of sales decreases 5.3 percentage points +At the end of December 2021, inventories were down 9% to € 4.009 billion (2020: € 4.397 +billion), or 12% lower on a currency-neutral basis. This development mainly reflects the +divestiture of the Reebok business. The strong sell-through of the company’s products, +successful inventory management as well as the impact from industry-wide supply chain +challenges also contributed to the decline. Accounts receivable increased 11% to € 2.175 +billion at the end of December 2021 (2020: € 1.952 billion) reflecting the company’s strong +top-line growth. On a currency-neutral basis, accounts receivables were up 6%. Accounts +payable were down 4% to € 2.294 billion at the end of December 2021 versus € 2.390 billion +in 2020. This development reflects the normalization of payment terms as well as the +divestiture of the Reebok business. On a currency-neutral basis, accounts payable decreased +3 + +6%. Average operating working capital as a percentage of sales decreased 5.3 percentage +points to 20.0% for the full year (2020: 25.3%). +Accelerated investments into DTC and digital +The company’s capital expenditure increased 51% in 2021 to € 667 million (2020: € 442 +million). Investments in new or remodeled own-retail stores, the company’s e-commerce +business as well as the broader IT infrastructure represented once again the majority of the +expenditure. +Executive and Supervisory Boards propose dividend payment of € 3.30 per share +As a result of the strong operational and financial performance in 2021, the company’s +financial position as well as Management’s confidence in its long-term growth aspirations, +the adidas Executive and Supervisory Boards will recommend paying a dividend of € 3.30 per +dividend-entitled share to shareholders at the Annual General Meeting on May 12, 2022. This +represents an increase of 10% compared to the prior year dividend (2021: € 3.00). +Financial Performance in Q4 2021 +Sales in the fourth quarter impacted by supply and demand challenges +Currency-neutral revenues in the fourth quarter declined 3%. Significant supply shortages as +a result of the lockdowns in Vietnam last year, the challenging market environment in Greater +China as well as covid-19-related lockdowns in Asia-Pacific reduced revenue growth by more +than € 400 million in Q4. In light of the supply shortages the company continued to prioritize +its own DTC channel. As a result, DTC revenues were stable versus the prior year, reflecting +a 14% increase compared to the 2019 level. While adidas e-commerce revenues experienced +a strong increase in full-price sales, revenues in the company’s own digital channel declined +by 2% during the quarter reflecting the exceptionally high growth in the prior year period. +Compared to the 2019 level, e-commerce revenues grew 39% in the fourth quarter. In euro +terms, adidas revenues were flat versus the prior year at € 5.137 billion (2020: € 5.142 billion). +Revenues in EMEA up strong double-digits in Q4 +From a regional perspective, revenues in North America were most impacted by the supply +shortages in the fourth quarter with almost half of the total negative impact recorded in this +particular market. As a result, currency-neutral revenues in North America declined 4% +during the quarter. Nevertheless, revenues in the company’s direct-to-consumer business +continued to increase in the market, reflecting the company’s DTC-led strategy. While EMEA +was also significantly impacted by the supply shortages, revenues still grew 15%, driven by +double-digit growth in both DTC and wholesale. Fourth quarter revenues in Latin America +improved 9%, reflecting strong double-digit growth versus the 2019 level. Revenues in Greater +4 + +China (-24%) and APAC (-6%) declined due to the supply shortages, covid-19-related +restrictions and – in the case of China – the challenging market environment. +Gross margin slightly down 0.1 percentage points +In the fourth quarter of 2021, the gross margin declined slightly by 0.1 percentage points to +49.0% (2020: 49.1%). Significantly higher supply chain costs – the company recorded +additional freight costs of more than € 100 million this quarter alone – as well as continued +headwinds from unfavorable currency developments represented a material drag on gross +margin in Q4. This impact was almost completely offset by significantly higher full price sales. +Operating margin below prior year level +Other operating expenses were up 7% to € 2.501 billion during the fourth quarter (2020: +€ 2.331 billion). As a percentage of sales, other operating expenses increased 3.3 percentage +points to 48.7% (2020: 45.3%). Marketing and point-of-sale expenses increased 8% to +€ 715 million (2020: € 662 million) and as a percentage of sales were up to 13.9% (2020: +12.9%), reflecting higher investments to support the introduction of new products such as the +UltraBoost22, NMD S1 and the latest IVY PARK x adidas collection, as well as to elevate the +consumer experience across all touchpoints. Operating overhead expenses increased 7% to +€ 1.786 billion (2020: € 1.670 billion) and included stranded costs related to the divestiture of +the Reebok business in an amount of around € 60 million. As a percentage of sales, operating +overhead expenses increased to 34.8% (2020: 32.5%). Operating profit amounted to +€ 66 million (2020: € 225 million), resulting in an operating margin of 1.3% (2020: 4.4%). Net +income from continuing operations reached € 123 million in the quarter (2020: € 143 million), +supported by a positive tax benefit related to the divestiture of the Reebok business. Both basic +and diluted EPS from continuing operations were € 0.58 in Q4 (2020: € 0.70). +Outlook for 2022 +Currency-neutral sales to increase between 11% and 13% +After the recovery from the coronavirus pandemic in 2021, adidas expects double-digit top- +line growth to continue in 2022 amid heightened uncertainty. Driven by the execution of the +company’s strategy ‘Own the Game’ as well as its strong product pipeline currency-neutral +revenues are projected to increase at a rate between 11% and 13%. This growth assumption +already includes a risk of up to € 250 million in the company’s Russia/CIS business – about +50% of adidas’ total revenues in the region – due to the war in Ukraine and reflects the +suspension of adidas’ retail and e-commerce operations in Russia. This amount represents +around 1 percentage point of growth for the total company and explains the difference to the +initial outlook as provided in the Management Report at the time of the preparation of the +company’s annual report. +5 + +Currency-neutral revenues to increase in all markets +From a regional perspective, currency-neutral revenues are expected to increase in all +markets. While currency-neutral sales in North America and Latin America are projected to +grow at a mid- to high-teens rate, currency-neutral revenues are expected to grow at a rate +in the mid-teens in EMEA and Asia-Pacific. Greater China is expected to record a sales +increase in the mid-single digits as the company continues to make progress with its action +plan aimed at stabilizing the business and re-igniting growth. +Gross margin expected to expand to a level of between 51.5% and 52.0% +adidas’ gross margin is expected to continue to increase and reach a level of between 51.5% +and 52.0%. A positive channel mix effect, significant price increases as well as the positive +impact from favorable currency developments will drive the gross margin improvement and +are expected to outweigh significantly higher supply chain costs. +Operating margin to increase to a level of between 10.5% and 11.0% +The company’s operating margin is expected to increase significantly to a level of between +10.5% and 11.0%. In addition to the higher gross margin, lower operating expenses in +percentage of sales will benefit the company’s operating margin in 2022. This development +will be supported by the non-recurrence of around 70% of the Reebok-related stranded costs, +which accounted to more than € 220 million in 2021. Driven by the strong top-line growth in +combination with the margin improvements net income from continuing operations is +projected to increase to a level of between € 1.8 billion and € 1.9 billion in 2022. +*** +Contacts: +Media Relations Investor Relations +corporate.press@adidas.com investor.relations@adidas.com +Tel.: +49 (0) 9132 84-2352 Tel.: +49 (0) 9132 84-2920 +For more information, please visit adidas-group.com or report.adidas-group.com. +6 + +| | | | | | +| --- | ---------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| | Quarter ending | Quarter ending | | | +€ in millions December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Change +| Net sales | | 5,137 | 5,142 | (0.1%) | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -------- | +| Cost of sales | | 2,618 | 2,615 | 0.1% | +| Gross profit | | 2,519 | 2,526 | (0.3%) | +| (% of net sales) | | 49.0% | 49.1% | (0.1pp) | +| Royalty and commission income | | 33 | 18 | 86.4% | +| Other operating income | | 15 | 13 | 16.3% | +| Other operating expenses | | 2,501 | 2,331 | 7.3% | +| (% of net sales) | | 48.7% | 45.3% | 3.3pp | +| Marketing and point-of-sale expenses | | 715 | 662 | 8.2% | +| (% of net sales) | | 13.9% | 12.9% | 1.1pp | +| Operating overhead expenses2 | | 1,786 | 1,670 | 6.9% | +| (% of net sales) | | 34.8% | 32.5% | 2.3pp | +| Operating profit | | 66 | 225 | (70.9%) | +| (% of net sales) | | 1.3% | 4.4% | (3.1pp) | +| Financial income | | 17 | 11 | 59.1% | +| Financial expenses | | 39 | 76 | (49.4%) | +| Income before taxes | | 44 | 160 | (72.2%) | +| (% of net sales) | | 0.9% | 3.1% | (2.2pp) | +| Income taxes | | (79) | 17 | n.a. | +| (% of income before taxes) | | (177.6%) | 10.5% | n.a. | +Net income from continuing operations 123 143 (13.8%) +| (% of net sales) | | 2.4% | 2.8% | (0.4pp) | +| ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------- | +Gain from discontinued operations, net of tax 89 14 534.2% +| Net income | | 213 | 157 | 35.3% | +| ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | +| (% of net sales) | | 4.1% | 3.1% | 1.1pp | +Net income attributable to shareholders 202 151 33.6% +| (% of net sales) | | 3.9% | 2.9% | 1.0pp | +| ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | +Net income attributable to non-controlling interests 11 6 74.9% +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Basic earnings per share from continuing operations (in €) 0.58 0.70 (16.8%) +Diluted earnings per share from continuing operations (in €) 0.58 0.70 (16.8%) +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Basic earnings per share from continuing and discontinued operations (in €) 1.05 0.77 35.6 % +Diluted earnings per share from continuing and discontinued operations (in €) 1.05 0.77 35.6 % +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1 2021 and 2020 figures reflect continuing operations as a result of the reclassification of the Reebok business to discontinued operations. +2 Aggregated distribution and selling expenses, general and administration expenses, sundry expenses and impairment losses (net) on accounts receivable and contract assets. +Rounding differences may arise. + +7 + +| | | | | | | | | +| --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | Quarter ending | | Quarter ending | | | | Change | +€ in millions December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Change (currency-neutral) +| EMEA | | 1,832 | | 1,559 | 17.5% | | 15.2% | +| ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | +| North America | | 1,303 | | 1,317 | (1.1%) | | (3.7%) | +| Greater China | | 1,037 | | 1,287 | (19.4%) | | (24.3%) | +| Asia-Pacific | | 541 | | 587 | (7.8%) | | (6.0%) | +| Latin America | | 397 | | 365 | 8.8% | | 8.7% | +| Other Businesses | | 28 | | 27 | 3.6% | | 4.1% | +| | | | | | | | | +1 2021 and 2020 figures reflect continuing operations as a result of the reclassification of the Reebok business to discontinued operations. +Rounding differences may arise. + +8 + +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | +| | | Year ending | Year ending | | +€ in millions December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Change +| Net sales | | 21,234 | 18,435 | 15.2% | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --------- | --------- | -------- | +| Cost of sales | | 10,469 | 9,213 | 13.6% | +| Gross profit | | 10,765 | 9,222 | 16.7% | +| (% of net sales) | | 50.7% | 50.0% | 0.7pp | +| Royalty and commission income | | 86 | 61 | 40.9% | +| Other operating income | | 28 | 42 | (34.8%) | +| Other operating expenses | | 8,892 | 8,580 | 3.6% | +| (% of net sales) | | 41.9% | 46.5% | (4.7pp) | +Marketing and point-of-sale expenses 2,547 2,373 7.3% +| (% of net sales) | | 12.0% | 12.9% | (0.9pp) | +| ----------------------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | +| Operating overhead expenses2 | | 6,345 | 6,207 | 2.2% | +| (% of net sales) | | 29.9% | 33.7% | (3.8pp) | +| Operating profit | | 1,986 | 746 | 166.3% | +| (% of net sales) | | 9.4% | 4.0% | 5.3pp | +| Financial income | | 19 | 29 | (32.1%) | +| Financial expenses | | 153 | 196 | (22.0%) | +| Income before taxes | | 1,852 | 578 | 220.2% | +| (% of net sales) | | 8.7% | 3.1% | 5.6pp | +| Income taxes | | 360 | 117 | 207.9% | +| (% of income before taxes) | | 19.4% | 20.2% | (0.8pp) | +Net income from continuing operations 1,492 461 223.4% +| (% of net sales) | | 7.0% | 2.5% | 4.5pp | +| ----------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------ | +Gain/(loss) from discontinued operations, net of tax 666 –19 n.a +| Net income | | 2,158 | 443 | 387.4% | +| ----------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | +| (% of net sales) | | 10.2% | 2.4% | 7.8pp | +Net income attributable to shareholders 2,116 432 389.6% +| (% of net sales) | | 10.0% | 2.3% | 7.6pp | +| ----------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------ | +Net income attributable to non-controlling interests 42 11 296.5% +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Basic earnings per share from continuing operations (in €) 7.47 2.31 223.3% +Diluted earnings per share from continuing operations (in €) 7.47 2.31 223.3% +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Basic earnings per share from continuing and discontinued operations (in €) 10.90 2.21 392.1% +Diluted earnings per share from continuing and discontinued operations (in €) 10.90 2.21 392.1% +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +1 2021 and 2020 figures reflect continuing operations as a result of the reclassification of the Reebok business to discontinued operations. +2 Aggregated distribution and selling expenses, general and administration expenses, sundry expenses and impairment losses (net) on accounts receivable and contract assets. +Rounding differences may arise. + +9 + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | Year ending | Year ending | | | Change | +€ in millions December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Change (currency-neutral) +| EMEA | | 7,760 | 6,308 | | 23.0% | 24.0 % | +| ----------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ------- | +| North America | | 5,105 | 4,519 | | 13.0% | 16.6 % | +| Greater China | | 4,597 | 4,342 | | 5.9% | 3.0 % | +| Asia-Pacific | | 2,180 | 2,083 | | 4.7% | 7.7 % | +| Latin America | | 1,446 | 1,035 | | 39.8% | 47.2 % | +| Other Businesses | | 145 | | 149 | (2.6%) | (2.0%) | +| | | | | | | | +1 2021 and 2020 figures reflect continuing operations as a result of the reclassification of the Reebok business to discontinued operations. +Rounding differences may arise. + +10 + +| | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +€ in millions December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Change in % +| Cash and cash equivalents | | 3,828 | 3,994 | (4.1) | +| ------------------------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | +| Accounts receivable | | 2,175 | 1,952 | 11.4 | +| Other current financial assets | | 745 | 702 | 6.1 | +| Inventories | | 4,009 | 4,397 | (8.8) | +| Income tax receivables | | 91 | 109 | (16.9) | +| Other current assets | | 1,062 | 999 | 6.3 | +Assets classified as held for sale 2,033 0 802,610.8 +| Total current assets | | 13,944 | 12,154 | 14.7 | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | +| Property, plant and equipment | | 2,256 | 2,157 | 4.6 | +| Right-of-use assets | | 2,569 | 2,430 | 5.7 | +| Goodwill | | 1,228 | 1,208 | 1.7 | +| Trademarks | | 16 | 750 | (97.8) | +| Other intangible assets | | 336 | 252 | 33.6 | +| Long-term financial assets | | 290 | 353 | (17.8) | +| Other non-current financial assets | | 160 | 414 | (61.2) | +| Deferred tax assets | | 1,263 | 1,233 | 2.5 | +| Other non-current assets | | 74 | 103 | (28.4) | +| Total non-current assets | | 8,193 | 8,899 | (7.9) | +| Total assets | | 22,137 | 21,053 | 5.1 | +| Short-term borrowings | | 29 | 686 | (95.8) | +| Accounts payable | | 2,294 | 2,390 | (4.0) | +| Current lease liabilities | | 573 | 563 | 1.8 | +| Other current financial liabilities | | 363 | 446 | (18.6) | +| Income taxes | | 536 | 562 | (4.7) | +| Other current provisions | | 1,458 | 1,609 | (9.4) | +| Current accrued liabilities | | 2,684 | 2,172 | 23.6 | +| Other current liabilities | | 434 | 398 | 9.0 | +| Liabilities classified as held for sale | | 594 | – | n.a. | +| Total current liabilities | | 8,965 | 8,827 | 1.6 | +| Long-term borrowings | | 2,466 | 2,482 | (0.7) | +| Non-current lease liabilities | | 2,263 | 2,159 | 4.8 | +Other non-current financial liabilities 51 115 (55.4) +| Pensions and similar obligations | | 267 | 284 | (6.1) | +| --------------------------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | +| Deferred tax liabilities | | 122 | 241 | (49.5) | +| Other non-current provisions | | 149 | 229 | (34.8) | +| Non-current accrued liabilities | | 8 | 8 | (3.2) | +| Other non-current liabilities | | 9 | 17 | (45.8) | +| Total non-current liabilities | | 5,334 | 5,535 | (3.6) | +| Share capital | | 192 | 195 | (1.8) | +Reserves (thereof at Dec. 31st, 2021 € 128 million relating to the Reebok disposal +| | | 69 | (474) | n.a. | +| --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | +group) +| Retained earnings | | 7,259 | 6,733 | 7.8 | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | +| Shareholders' equity | | 7,519 | 6,454 | 16.5 | +| Non-controlling interests | | 318 | 237 | 34.0 | +| Total equity | | 7,837 | 6,691 | 17.1 | +| Total liabilities and equity | | 22,137 | 21,053 | 5.1 | + +11 + +| Additional balance sheet information | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | +| Operating working capital | | 3,890 | 3,960 | (1.8) | +| Working capital | | 4,978 | 3,328 | 49.6 | +| Adjusted net borrowings2 | | 2,963 | 3,148 | (5.9) | +| Financial leverage3 | 39.4% | 48.8% | | (9.4 pp) | +| | | | | | +| | | | | | +1 2021 figures reflect the reclassification of the Reebok business to assets or liabilities held for sale. +2 Adjusted net borrowings = short-term borrowings + long-term borrowings and future cash used in lease and pension liabilities – cash and cash equivalents and short-term financial assets. +3 Based on shareholders' equity. +Rounding differences may arise. + +12 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k2/question.json b/q7/random_k2/question.json index c868e424ef3c484f1ea7388dd07c09adfcbb65c0..7e2a0ef4dc7d502f88b4851ec6e05c1b17599dee 100644 --- a/q7/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q7/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ddoseattle-150627210357-lva1-app6891_95.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf", - "web_ab28fbcd92cfea3d.pdf" + "web_9fc7805ab9a7b343.pdf", + "88d4b9368dcf48f2b3e788da0a5f10e87e5a3361.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k2/random_1.md b/q7/random_k2/random_1.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..7fe6906e671eb6becf1e5bf27211c9c0f26d8c0a 100644 --- a/q7/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q7/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,493 +1,1546 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. - -3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - -7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - -9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - -1 -0 - +CIRCULAR NO. A–11 +PART 7 +PLANNING, BUDGETING, +ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT +OF CAPITAL ASSETS +| E | | O | | P | +| -------- | ---- | --------- | --- | ------------ | +| xEcutivE | | fficE | Of | thE rEsidEnt | +| O | M | | | B | +| fficE | Of | anagEMEnt | | and udgEt | +J 2008 +unE + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF +CAPITAL ASSETS +Table of Contents +300.1 What is the purpose of the section? +300.2 Does the section apply to me? +300.3 What background information must I know? +300.4 What special terms should I know? +300.5 How will agencies manage capital assets? +300.6 What other requirements does exhibit 300 fulfill? +300.7 What must I report on exhibit 300 and when? +300.8 How will OMB use the exhibit 300s? +Ex–300 Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary +Summary of Changes +Updates requirement to identify certification levels via the Federal Acquisition Certification for +Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) (section 300.4) (Ex 300, Part I, Sec A. 11). +Clarifies the distinction between funding contributions and reimbursements (section 300.4). +Updates requirements for performance-based acquisitions (section 300.4). +Clarifies requirements for a multi-agency collaboration exhibit 300 (section 300.7). +Updates PARTed program identification with selectable options (Ex 300, Part I, Sec A. 14b). +Changes to questions for section 508 compliance and acquisition plan status (Ex 300, Part I, Sec +C). +Changes to questions for alternative analysis for breakeven and Federal quantitative benefits (Ex +300 Part II, Sec A and Ex 300 Part IV, Sec A) +Adds table for Federal quantitative benefits for all investment required to complete PART II (Ex +300 Part II, Sec A). +Clarifies that fee-for-service reimbursements for shared service providers are to be included in +Partner Funding Strategies Table (Ex 300 Part IV, Sec A. 3). +300.1 What is the purpose of the section? +Part 7 (section 300) of the Circular establishes policy for planning, budgeting, acquisition and +management of Federal capital assets, and instructs you on budget justification and reporting +requirements for major information technology (IT) investments and for major non IT capital assets. +OMB provides procedural and analytic guidelines for implementing specific aspects of these policies as +appendices and supplements to this Circular and in other OMB circulars. For IT, section 300 is a +companion section to section 53. +For non IT capital assets contact your Resource Management Offices (RMOs) at OMB to determine if +any additional budget justification and reporting requirements in addition to those outlined here. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 1 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +300.2 Does the section apply to me? +The policy and budget justification and reporting requirements in this section apply to all agencies of the +Executive Branch of the Government subject to Executive Branch review (see section 25). An exhibit +300 must be submitted for all major investments in accordance with this section. Major IT investments +also must be reported on your agency’s exhibit 53 (see section 53) and be consistent with what is reported +in section 51.3. +300.3 What background information must I know? +The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public +resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition and management +of capital assets into the budget decision-making process, and is intended to assist agencies in improving +asset management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of: +(cid:129) +The Energy Policy Act of 2005, Section 109, which requires that sustainable design principles are +applied to the siting, design and construction of all new and replacement buildings and that new +federal buildings be designed to achieve energy consumption levels that are at least 30 percent +below the levels established in the 2004 International Energy Conservation Code for residential +buildings or the ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2004 for non-residential buildings, if life-cycle cost- +effective. +(cid:129) +The Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994, Title V (FASA V), which requires agencies to +establish cost, schedule and measurable performance goals for all major acquisition programs, and +achieve on average 90 percent of those goals. +Additional background information for Information Technology can be found in section 53.2. +300.4 What special terms should I know? +Capital assets means land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and information +technology (including IT service contracts) used by the Federal Government and having an estimated +useful life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more +complete definition of capital assets. +Capital programming means an integrated process within an agency for planning, budgeting, +procurement and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve agency strategic goals +and objectives with the lowest life-cycle cost and least risk. +Capital project (investment) means the acquisition of a capital asset and the management of that asset +through its life-cycle after the initial acquisition. Capital projects (investments) may consist of several +useful segments. +Contracting officer certification means the highest current level of certification in contracting obtained +by the contracting officer (CO) assigned to the acquisition. For defense agencies, indicate the CO’s +highest level of Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) certification in contracting. +For civilian agencies, indicate the CO’s highest level of Federal Acquisition Certification in Contracting +(FAC-C), in accordance with OMB memorandum, The Federal Acquisition Certification in Contracting +Program, dated January 20, 2006. Available levels are 1, 2, or 3. To address the transition period, if the +CO has not obtained a FAC-C, the agency must determine that the CO assigned to the effort has the +competencies and skills necessary to support the acquisition. +Cost saving represents the reduction in actual expenditures below the projected level of costs to achieve a +specific objective (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). +Page 2 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Cost avoidance represents results from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease +costs in the future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). +Earned value management (EVM) is a project (investment) management tool effectively integrating the +investment scope of work with schedule and cost elements for optimum investment planning and control. +The qualities and operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in +American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard –748–1998, +Earned Value Management Systems, approved May 19, 1998. It was reaffirmed on August 28, 2002. +Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/pm. +Energy Savings Performance Contract (ESPC) means a contract (such as a task ordered by DOE and +awarded to an energy service company) that provides for the performance of services for the design, +acquisition, financing, installation, testing, operation, and maintenance and repair, of an identified energy, +water conservation, or renewable energy measure or series of measures at one or more locations. Such +contracts shall provide that the contractor must incur costs of implementing energy savings measures, +including at least the cost (if any) incurred in making energy audits, acquiring and installing equipment, +and training personnel in exchange for a predetermined share of the value of the energy savings directly +resulting from implementation of such measures during the term of the contract. Payment to the +contractor is contingent upon realizing a guaranteed stream of future energy and cost savings, with any +savings in excess of that guaranteed by the contractor accruing to the Federal government +Enhanced Use Leasing (EUL): Departments with specific statutory authority can require rent in the +form of a reduction in the cost or free use of facilities or services for programs, monetary payments, or +other in-kind consideration which enhances mission activity. The authority allows an agency to out-lease +property and receive payment in cash or in kind (goods or services that result in direct cost savings to the +government) from the lessee in exchange for the out-lease. +Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) was established to +ensure general training and experience requirements for program and project managers are clearly +identified for civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for program +and project managers; the program does not include functional or technical competencies, such as those +for information technology, or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar +certification program under the Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA). Agencies +must be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available levels are Entry/Apprentice, +Mid/Journeyman and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2 and 3 for DAWIA. +(www.whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf) +(www.whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf) +Full funding means appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete a useful segment (see +definition below) of a capital project (investment) before any obligations may be incurred for the +segment. Incrementally funding capital projects (investments) or useful segments without certainty if or +when future funding will be available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets +acquisition, higher acquisition costs, project (investment) delays, cancellation of major projects +(investments), the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate the assets. Budget +requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see section 31.5). +Interagency acquisition means the use of the Federal Supply Schedules, a multi-agency contract (i.e., a +task order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by government agencies to obtain +supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535), or a government-wide +acquisition contract (i.e., a task-order or delivery-order contract for information technology established +by one agency for government-wide use operated by an executive agent designated by OMB pursuant to +section 11302(3) of the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996). +Life-cycle costs (see Supplement to Part 7—Capital Programming Guide). +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 3 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Major investment means a system or acquisition requiring special management attention because of its +importance to the mission or function of the agency, a component of the agency or another organization; +is for financial management and obligates more than $500,000 annually; has significant program or policy +implications; has high executive visibility; has high development, operating, or maintenance costs; is +funded through other than direct appropriations; or is defined as major by the agency’s capital planning +and investment control process. OMB may work with the agency to declare other investments as major +investments. You should consult with your OMB representative about what investments to consider as +"major," consult your agency budget officer or OMB representative. Systems not considered "major" are +"non-major." +Mixed life-cycle investment means an investment having both development/modernization/enhancement +(DME) and steady state components. For example, a mixed life-cycle investment could include a +prototype or module of a system that is operational with the remainder of the system in DME stages; or, a +service contract for steady state on the current system with a DME requirement for system upgrade or +replacement. +Multi-Agency Collaboration investments means a set of systems or acquisitions requiring the efforts of +more than one agency (multiple sub-agency efforts should not be identified as "Mult-Agency"). All E- +Gov initiatives and Line of Business (LoB) initiatives are by definition Multi-Agency efforts. Due to the +multi-agency impact, Multi-Agency Collaboration investments such as E-Gov and LoB initiatives are also +by definition Major Investments and High-Risk Investments. +Operational (steady state) means an asset or a part of an asset with a delivered component performing the +mission. +Partner Agency funding contributions (contributions) represent both the direct contribution (Cash +contribution) in terms of agency funding contributions in support of the initiative and "In-Kind" +contributions, i.e., the dollar equivalent of services contributed by the partner agency in support of the +initiative (non-cash contribution), including Partner agency support in equipment, facilities, software, +license fees, and dollar equivalent of FTEs. Migration costs should not be included, as these activities are +more appropriately coordinated with the managing partner and covered by a migration investment. +Partner Agency “fee-for-service” contributions represents the direct reimbursements (Cash +reimbursements) in terms of a “fee-for-service” relationship for a transactional service received by the +initiative or reimbursements for capital assets under the oversight of the initiative. +Performance-based acquisition management means a documented, systematic process for program +management, which includes integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, establishment of +a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and use of earned value techniques for +performance measurement during execution of the program. EVMS is required for those parts of the +investment where developmental effort is required. This includes prototypes and tests to select the most +cost effective alternative during the Planning Phase, the work during the Acquisition Phase, and any +developmental, modification or upgrade work done during the Operational/Steady State Phase. EVMS is +to be applied to both Government and contractor efforts and regardless of contract type. For +operational/steady state systems, an operational analysis as discussed in Phase IV of the Capital +Programming Guide is required. A performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition +Regulation 37.101) or contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance +standards/measures should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase. +Information on this requirement can be found in OMB Memorandum 05-23, Improving Information +Technology (IT) Project Planning and Execution. +Plan of Action and Milestone As defined in OMB Memorandum 02-01, a plan of action and milestones +(POA&M), also referred to as a corrective action plan, is a tool that identifies tasks that need to be +accomplished. It details resources required to accomplish the elements of the plan, any milestones in +Page 4 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +meeting the task, and scheduled completion dates for the milestones. The purpose of the POA&M is to +assist agencies in identifying, assessing, prioritizing, and monitoring the progress of corrective efforts for +security weaknesses found in programs and systems. +Planning means preparing, developing or acquiring the information you will use to: design the +investment; assess the benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted life-cycle costs of alternative solutions; and +establish realistic cost, schedule, and performance goals, for the selected alternative, before either +proceeding to full acquisition of the capital project (investment) or useful segment or terminating the +investment. Planning must progress to the point where you are ready to commit to achieving specific +goals for the completion of the acquisition before preceding to the acquisition phase. Information +gathering activities may include market research of available solutions, architectural drawings, geological +studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes. Planning is a useful segment of a capital project +(investment). Depending on the nature of the investment, one or more planning segments may be +necessary. +During the planning phase, when contemplating a performance-based acquisition, agency program offices +should evaluate their service requirement and determine: +(cid:129) +Whether a performance-related baseline problem exists (cost, quality, timeliness, impact to agency +mission); +(cid:129) +The level of risk associated with the service not being optimally provided (importance to mission +of the service being provided optimally); +(cid:129) +The level of confidence the agency has in its own " performance work statement or statement of +objectives document" to solve the baseline problem; +(cid:129) +The amount of risk the agency wants to assume for managing the service impact on its own versus +shifting to a vendor; and +(cid:129) +The readiness of the program to measure the impact of the service on its program performance +goals/mission, as well as the readiness of Program staff to participate in the PBA process. +Risk adjusted life-cycle costs means the overall estimated cost for a particular investment alternative over +the time period corresponding to the life of the investment, including direct and indirect initial costs plus +any periodic or continuing costs of operation and maintenance that has been adjusted to accommodate any +risk identified in the risk management plans. If project funding is to be requested for specific phases, +segments or modules of the project, each of these parts will be risk adjusted for their individual life-cycle. +Total Value of Contract/Task Order means the current total value of the Contract or Task Order to +acquire and operate the capital asset. For contracts/task orders shared by multiple capital assets, please +provide only the current total value associated with the identified capital asset. +Useful segment/module means an economically and programmatically separate component of a capital +investment that provides a measurable performance outcome for which the benefits exceed the costs, even +if no further funding is appropriated. +Utility Energy Service Contract (UESC) is a contract between a Federal agency and a local utility +providing energy, water, or sewage services, as well as provision of technical services and/or upfront +project financing for energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy investments, allowing +Federal agencies to pay for the services over time, either on their utility bill, or through a separate +agreement. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 5 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in Appendix J, "Principles of +Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions” and in section 53 (for IT). +300.5 How will agencies manage capital assets? +The Capital Programming Guide, which supplements Part 7 of OMB Circular A-11, provides guidance +on the principles and techniques for effective capital programming. Appendix J of this part explains the +principles of financing capital asset acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A–130 establishes +additional requirements for enterprise architectures (EAs), planning and control of information systems +and technology investments and performance management. Agencies must develop, implement, and use +a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio, and must: +(cid:129) +Evaluate and select capital asset investments that will support core mission functions performed +by the Federal Government, and demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal +to or better than alternative uses of available public resources; +(cid:129) +Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative +private sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need; +(cid:129) +Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and make +maximum use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology; +(cid:129) +Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom designed components, using components that +can be fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring +involvement and support of users in the design and testing of the asset; +(cid:129) +Structure major acquisitions into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration, make +adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between Government and contractor. +The Agency Head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major +acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the proposed cost goals; +(cid:129) +Ensure consistency with Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency +through compliance with agency business requirements and standards, as well as identification of +milestones, as defined in the EA transition strategy; +(cid:129) +Institute performance measures and management processes monitoring and comparing actual +performance to planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management +or earned value management system, based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748, to obtain timely +information regarding the progress of capital investments. The system must also measure progress +towards milestones in an independently verifiable basis, in terms of cost, capability of the +investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality. Agencies are expected to +achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule and performance goals for major +acquisitions. Agency Heads must review major acquisitions not achieving 90 percent of the goals +to determine whether there is a continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, +should be taken; +(cid:129) +Ensure IT systems conform to the requirements of OMB Circular No. A–130, "Management of +Federal Information Resources;" +(cid:129) +Ensure financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB Circular No. A–127, +"Financial Management Systems;" +Page 6 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +(cid:129) +Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition +processes, and projects to validate estimated benefits and costs, and document effective +management practices, i.e., lessons learned, for broader use; and +(cid:129) +Establish oversight mechanisms requiring periodic review of operational capital assets to +determine how mission requirements might have changed, and whether the asset continues to +fulfill ongoing and anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and +customers, and meet user requirements. +300.6 What other requirements does exhibit 300 fulfill? +The Exhibit 300 is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to the +Congress required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA Title V) and the Clinger- +Cohen Act of 1996; to ensure the business case for investments are made and tied to the mission +statements, long-term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the +GPRA. For IT, exhibit 300s are designed to be used as one-stop documents for many of IT management +issues such as business cases for investments, IT security reporting, Clinger Cohen Act implementation, +E-Gov Act implementation, Government Paperwork Elimination Act implementation, agency’s +modernization efforts, and overall project (investment) management. +300.7 What must I report on exhibit 300 and when? +It is important to understand, all information necessary to complete an exhibit 300 already exists as part +of the agency's overall Information Resources Management activities and within project specific +documentation. The materials used to populate the exhibit 300 should be readily available to OMB upon +request. +The exhibit 300 must be submitted along with any other agency budget submissions (see section 25.5) to, +OMB by September 8, 2008. The exhibit 300 should be fully integrated with your agency’s overall +budget submission. For the next President's Budget, all reporting on IT must be submitted via OMB’s IT +Budget Submissions System (https://max.omb.gov/itweb/itweb). Agencies can either manually enter their +exhibit 300 data into this system or upload files in XML format. All exhibit 300s and exhibit 53 (see +section 53) must be electronically submitted from the OMB IT Budget Submissions System. Additional +information regarding the submission process will be posted on www.egov.gov. For capital projects +(investments) other than IT, agencies are encouraged to submit the exhibit 300 electronically, following +the same instructions provided above. +Following budget season, agencies should update their agency’s exhibit 300s submitted during budget +submission to reflect final Presidential decisions. In addition, this update should ensure that only +publicly-releasable information is contained in the updated exhibit 300. While it is important to maintain +this publicly-releasable exhibit 300, agencies should continuously maintain updated information about the +projects contained in the exhibit 300. OMB may request this information at any time. +Agencies are required to post on their agency website, within 2 weeks of the release of the President’s +Budget, these updated exhibits reflecting final Presidential decisions (see section 22.6). If you have any +questions about what should be included in the version posted to your website, please contact your agency +budget and FOIA offices. You may also contact your OMB representative. As a reminder, these products +should be included in your Information Dissemination Product Inventories, Priorities, and Schedules. +(More information about this can be found in OMB M-05-04, Policies for Federal Agency Public +Websites). +If agencies request supplemental funds, which include changes to the agency's portfolio, as part of their +supplemental request, agencies should submit new or revised exhibit 300s and exhibit 53 (see section 53). +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 7 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +The information you must report will depend on the kind of investment the exhibit 300 is representing +(see Part I Section A - Question #6). +New Investments +If you are reporting a new investment (i.e., proposed for BY or later) you must complete Parts I and II. +Investments in initial concept or planning phase will have less detail and specificity than investments +moving into the acquisition or operational phase. However, these investments should identify in life-cycle +documentation the dates these issues will be addressed as the investment matures. Where prototypes are +acquired as part of the planning process, the prototypes must be reported as full acquisitions. All of the +areas on the exhibit 300 must be part of an agency's planning, and the exhibit 300 should be updated as +soon as the information is known. +Ongoing Investments +If reporting an ongoing investment other than IT, only update sections as appropriate. If any of the cost, +schedule or performance variances are not within 10 percent of the current baseline, provide a complete +analysis of the reasons for the variances, the corrective actions to be taken, and the most likely estimate at +completion (EAC). Use the EVM system to identify the specific work packages where problems are +occurring. Discuss why the problems occurred and corrective actions necessary to return the program as +close as feasible to the current baseline goals. +Security for Planned as well as Operational Systems +Questions contained in Part I-Section E, “Security and Privacy” should be answered at the individual +system level. Multiple contractor or agency systems may support or be part of the overall investment. +Planned systems listed in Table 3, as well as operational systems listed in Table 4, should be included in +the privacy table (Part I-Section E-Table 8). Security and privacy planning must proceed in parallel with +the development of the system(s) to ensure IT security and privacy requirements and costs are identified +and incorporated into the overall lifecycle of the system(s). +For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement is planned, include the investment in both +the “Systems in Planning” table (Table 3) and the “Operational Systems” table (Table 4). In this context, +information contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will +occur before implementing the enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current, valid testing +and documentation associated with the existing system. +Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments +The managing partner (lead agency) will take the lead for completing the multi-agency exhibit 300, +managing it through the lead agency's capital programming and budget process and submitting the exhibit +300 to OMB. The managing partner is also responsible for ensuring this exhibit 300 includes all +necessary information from the partner agencies and has been approved by all necessary partner agencies +through the appropriate governance process. The multi-agency exhibit 300 should include partner agency +funding, related capital assets (e.g. migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, +Supporting components), and milestones in Part IV of the exhibit 300. The managing partner +Executive/Investment Committee should review and approve the multi-agency exhibit 300. +Partner agencies should report their participation in their exhibit 53 submissions as appropriate (see +section 53). Partner agencies should reference the name of the multi-agency exhibit 300 in the +"Investment Description" field of each exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency exhibit 300. +Partner agencies should also ensure their activities and participation are included in the appropriate +sections of the multi-agency exhibit 300. The managing partner will include only the managing partner +specific funds in their exhibit 53 submission(s), while the entire Summary of Spending Total for the +investment, including funds provided by partner agency, should be included in the exhibit 300. +Page 8 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency exhibit 300. +When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate the requests. +Multi-Agency Collaboration supporting components capital assets +Partner agency's supporting capital assets (e.g., Service Providers, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service +Centers, Supporting components) should be submitted as regular agency capital assets using exhibit 300s. +Agencies proposing capital assets to support multi-agency initiatives should share their proposals with the +managing partner for review. Proposals recommended as part of the Managing Partner's solution should +be included in the Managing Partner's exhibit 300 (Part IV-Section A, Question #2). An agency with a +recommended capital asset proposal should submit an exhibit 300 using the appropriate kind of exhibit +300 (as defined in Part I-Section A, Question #6). Partner agencies with or proposing supporting capital +assets for multi-agency collaboration (i.e. shared service centers, sales center, shared service providers, +etc.) should use Part IV of the exhibit 300. +For Cost and Schedule Performance baseline changes +All proposed changes to baselines should be submitted to OMB prior to your FY 2010 budget request; +proposed changes should not be assumed approved. If your agency has any questions, please contact +your OMB representative. All current approved baselines should be reflected in the exhibit 300. +300.8 How will OMB use the exhibit 300s? +The exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total performance budget justification (see section +51.2). OMB uses the exhibit 300 to make both quantitative decisions about budgetary resources +consistent with the Administration’s program priorities, and qualitative assessments about whether the +agency’s programming processes are consistent with OMB policy and guidance. OMB will be evaluating +all elements of the business cases and will communicate the results of these evaluations in the course of +the budget process. If additional supporting information is necessary, OMB will request from agencies +the supporting evidence used to produce the exhibit 300. All information necessary to complete an +exhibit 300 should already exist as part of the agency's overall Information Resources Management +activities and within project specific documentation. The materials used to produce the exhibit 300 +should be readily available to OMB upon request. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 9 of Section 300 + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary +Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) + +| | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) +| | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1. Date of Submission: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 2. Agency: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 3. Bureau: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 4. Name of this Capital Asset: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: +(For IT investment only, see section 53. For +all other, use agency ID system.) + +6. What kind of investment will this be in FY 2010? + (Please NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY 2010, with Planning/Acquisition activities prior to +FY 2010 should not select O&M. These investments should indicate their current status.) +| | | | | | | Planning | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | Full Acquisition | | | +| | | | | Operations and Maintenance | | | | +| | | | | | Mixed Life Cycle | | | +| | | | | Multi-Agency Collaboration | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +7. What was the first budget year this investment was submitted to + +OMB? +| | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------ | ------------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 8. Provide | a brief summary | and justification | for | this investment, | | | | +including a brief description of how this closes in part or in whole an +| identified agency performance gap: | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | | +| 9. Did | the Agency’s Executive/Investment | | Committee | approve | this | | | +| request? | | | | | | Yes | No | + a. If “yes,” what was the date of this approval? +| | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| 10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| | | | | | | | | +11. Contact information of Program/Project Manager? +Name +Phone Number +E-mail +| a. | What is the current | FAC-P/PM | (for civilian | agencies) | or | | | +| ------------------------- | ----------------------- | ---------- | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DAWIA | (for defense | agencies) | certification | level | of the | | | +| program/project manager? | | | | | | | | + +b. When was the Program/Project Manager Assigned? _______________________________ +| Page 10 of Section 300 | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +c. What date did the Program/Project Manager receive the FAC- +P/PM certification? If the certification has not been issued, what is +| the anticipated date for certification? | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost effective, energy- +efficient and environmentally sustainable techniques or practices for +| this project? | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +a. Will this investment include electronic assets (including +| computers)? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +b. Is this investment for new construction or major retrofit of a +Federal building or facility? (answer applicable to non-IT assets +| only) | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +1. If “yes,” is an ESPC or UESC being used to help fund this +| investment? | | | | | Yes | No | +| --------------- | ----------------------- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | --- | +| 2. If “yes,” | will this investment | meet | sustainable | design | | | +| principles? | | | | | Yes | No | +3. If “yes,” is it designed to be 30% more energy efficient than +| relevant code? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | +13. Does this investment directly support any of the PMA initiatives? If "yes," check all that apply: +| | | | | Human Capital | | | +| --- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | Budget Performance Integration | | | | +| | | | | Financial Performance | | | +| | | | | Expanded E-Government | | | +| | | | | Competitive Sourcing | | | +| | | | Faith Based and Community | | | | +| | | | Real Property Asset Management | | | | +| | | | Eliminating Improper Payments | | | | +| | | | Privatization of Military Housing | | | | +| | | Research & Development Investment Criteria | | | | | +| | Housing & Urban Development Management & Performance | | | | | | +| | Broadening Health Insurance Coverage through State Initiatives | | | | | | +| | | | “Right Sized” Overseas Presence | | | | +| | | Coordination of VA & DoD Programs and Systems | | | | | +| | | | | | | | +a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected how this asset +| directly supports | the identified | initiative(s)? | (e.g. If | E-Gov is | | | +| ------------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +selected, is it an approved shared service provider or the managing +partner?) +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +14. Does this investment support a program assessed using the Program +Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more information about the +| PART, visit www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness found during a +| PART review? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? +c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? + +| | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 11 of Section 300 | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes No +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +If the answer to Question 15 is “Yes,” complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is “No,” do not answer +questions 16-23. + +For information technology investments only: +16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) +| | | | | | | | Level 1 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Level 2 | | +| | | | | | | | Level 3 | | + +17. In addition to the answer in 11(a), what project management qualifications does the Project Manager have? +(per CIO Council PM Guidance) +(1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this investment +(2) Project manager qualification is under review for this investment +(3) Project manager assigned to investment, but does not meet requirements +(4) Project manager assigned but qualification status review has not yet started +(5) No Project manager has yet been assigned to this investment +| | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 18. Is this | investment | or any | project(s) | within this | investment | | | | +identified as “high risk” on the Q4-FY 2008 agency high risk report +| (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| 19. Is this a financial management system? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +a. If “yes,” does this investment address a FFMIA compliance area? +| | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +1. If “yes,” which compliance area: +| | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | ------------- | --------- | ------------ | ------------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| 2. If “no,” what does it address? | | | | | | | | | +| b. If “yes,” | please | identify | the system | name(s) | and system | | | | +| acronym(s) | as reported | in | the most | recent financial | systems | | | | +| inventory update required by Circular A–11 section 52 | | | | | | | | | + +20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY 2010 funding request for the following? + (This should total 100%) +| | | | | | | Hardware | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Software | | | +Services + +Other + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +21. If this project produces information dissemination products for the public, are +these products published to the Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum +05-04 and included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | No | | +| | | | | | | | N/A | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| Page 12 of Section 300 | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related +| questions: | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Name +Phone Number +Title +E-mail +| | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------ | --------------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 23. Are the | records produced | by this investment | appropriately | | | | +scheduled with the National Archives and Records Administration’s +| approval? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| | | | | | | | +Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO High Risk +| Areas? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 13 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) + +1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts +represent budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be +included only in the row designated “Government FTE Cost,” and should be excluded from the amounts shown +for “Planning,” “Full Acquisition,” and “Operation/Maintenance.” The “TOTAL” estimated annual cost of the +investment is the sum of costs for “Planning,” “Full Acquisition,” and “Operation/Maintenance.” For Federal +buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or +restoration costs. The costs associated with the entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this +report. + +Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES +(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) +(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) +| | | PY–1 | | | | | | | BY+4 | +| --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | +| | | | PY | CY | BY | BY+1 | BY+2 | BY+3 | | +| | | and | | | | | | | and Total | +| | | | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | | +| | | earlier | | | | | | | beyond | +Planning: +| | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Acquisition : | | | | | | | | | | +Subtotal Planning & +| Acquisition: | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Operations & +| Maintenance: | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| TOTAL: | | | | | | | | | | +Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. +| Government FTE Costs | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Number of FTE +| represented by Costs: | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner +agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. + +2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional FTE’s? +| | | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------- | ----- | ---- | -------- | --- | ----------------------------- | -------- | +| a. If “yes,” How many and in what year? | | | | | | | | | | +| 3. If the summary | of | spending | has changed | from | the | FY 2009 | | | | +| President’s Budget request, briefly explain those changes: | | | | | | | | | | +| Page 14 of Section 300 | | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) + +1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned +for this investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders +completed do not need to be included. + +Contracts/Task Orders Table: + ecnadrocca nI( redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo epyT ,ton fI ?drawa eht fo etad eht si tahw os fI )N/Y( si noitpo gnicnanif evitanretla ,yna fi ,tahW deriuqer AIWAD OC eht denimreted ycnega eht sah ,A/N fI slliks + )N/Y( ?noitisiuqca siht troppus ot yrassecen + )liame/enohp( noitamrofni tcatnoC OC + )N/Y( dedrawa neeb tcartnoc eht saH ?noitisiuqcA )A/N ,LUE ,CSEU ,CPSE( ?desu gnieb )A/N ,3 ,2 ,1 leveL( leveL noitacifitreC dna +| | | redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo etad tratS | | | | eht | | ro | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | + redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo etad dnE )N/Y( ?sesualc ycavirp & ytiruces seicnetepmoc +| rebmuN redrO ksaT ro tcartnoC | | ?etad drawa dennalp eht si tahw | | )N/Y( ?desab ecnamrofrep ti sI | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + C-CAF +| | | | | | )N/Y( ?dedrawa ylevititepmoC | )N/Y( ?tcartnoc eht ni MVE sI edulcni | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | + /tcartnoC fo eulaV latoT + ycnegaretnI + reciffO + tcartnoc + )61 traP RAF htiw eht + )M$( redrO ksaT + sah +| | | | | | | | OC fo emaN | gnitcartnoC | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | + na + eht + dengissa + siht + seoD + sI + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| 2. If earned value is not required or will not | | | | be a contract requirement | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +| for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | No | | +| | | | | | | | N/A | | +a. Explain why not or how this is being done? + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +4. Is there an acquisition plan which reflects the requirements of FAR +| Subpart 7.1 | and | has been | approved | in accordance | with agency | | | | +| --------------- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| requirements? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +a. If “yes,” what is the date? + +| 1. Is it Current? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +| b. If “no,” will an acquisition plan be developed? | | | | | | | | | +| 1. If “no,” briefly explain why: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | Page 15 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) + +In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency +and be linked to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency’s mission and strategic +goals, and performance measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the +agency's strategic goals and objectives this investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external +performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, +increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall citizen participation rate of 75 percent by +FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if applicable, investment +outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general goals, such +as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative measure. + +Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use +the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement +Indicators to the corresponding "Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There +should be at least one Measurement Indicator for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal +year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be extended to include performance measures for +years beyond the next President's Budget. + +Performance Information Table +Strategic +| Fiscal | Measurement | Measureme | Measurement | | | Actual | +| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------------ | --------- | ------- | ------- | +| Goal(s) | | | | Baseline | Target | | +| Year | Area | nt Grouping | Indicator | | | Results | +Supported +| | Mission & | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2008 +Business Results +| | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 2008 | Customer Results | | | | | | +| | Processes & | | | | | | +2008 +Activities +| 2008 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | + Mission & +2009 +Business Results +| | Customer | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2009 +Results +| | Processes & | | | | | | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2009 +Activities +| 2009 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Mission & | | | | | | +2010 +Business Results +| | Customer | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2010 +Results +| | Processes & | | | | | | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2010 +Activities +| 2010 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| Etc. | Etc. | | | | | | + +| Page 16 of Section 300 | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 +Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) +In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the +system/application level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning +and operational systems security tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the +Operational Security Table must be included on your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily +referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or identifier). +For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, +include the investment in both the “Systems in Planning” table (Table 3) and the “Operational Systems” table +(Table 4). Systems which are already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization +activity, should be included in both Table 3 and Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system +changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should +reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information contained within Table 3 should +characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the enhancements; and +Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. +All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the +“Name of System” column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled “Name +of System” in the security tables (Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one- +to-one ratio between the list of systems and the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover +multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table +more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). +The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the +system are discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text +explanation why a working link is not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the +system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, answer “yes” for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), +explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is not yet required to be published. +Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: +1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified and +integrated into the overall costs of the investment?: Yes No +a. If “yes,” provide the “Percentage IT Security” for the budget year: +2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part of the +overall risk management effort for each system supporting or part of +this investment?. Yes No +3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or +Modernization – Security Table(s): +Date of Planned certification and +Agency/ or accreditation (C&A) update (for +Name of Planned Operational +Contractor existing mixed life cycle systems) +System Date +Operated System? or Planned Completion Date (for +new systems) +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 17 of Section 300 + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +4. Operational Systems – Security Table: +What +standards +| | | | NIST FIPS | | Has C&A | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----------- | ------------- | ---------- | --------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | +| | | | | | | | were used for | | Date | | +| | Agency/ or | | 199 Risk | | been | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Date | the Security | Completed: | | Date the | +| N a m e of | C | o n tr a c to | r Imp | ac t l e v el | C o m p le te | d , Completed: | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Controls | | Security | contingency | +| S y st e m | O | p e r a te d | (H | i g h , | us i ng N I S | T | | | | | +| | | | | | | C&A | tests?” (FIPS | | Control | plan tested | +| | System? | | Moderate, | | 800-37? | | | | | | +200/NIST +| | | | Low) | | (Y/N) | | | | Testing | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +800-53, +Other, N/A) +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of the +systems part of or supporting this investment been identified by the +| agency or IG? | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ------ | +| a. | If “yes,” | have | those | weaknesses | been | incorporated | into the | | | | +agency’s plan of action and milestone process? Yes No +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is requested to +| remediate IT security weaknesses? | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” specify the amount, provide a general description of the +weakness, and explain how the funding request will remediate the +| weakness. | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | +7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and +| validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +8. Planning & Operational Systems – Privacy Table: +| | | | | (c) Is there at least | | | (e) Is a System of | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | +| | | | | one Privacy Impact | | (d) Internet | Records Notice | | | | +| (a) Name of | | (b) Is this a new | | | | | | | (f) Internet Link or | | +| | | | | Assessment (PIA) | | Link or | (SORN) required | | | | +| System | | system? (Y/N) | | | | | | | Explanation | | +| | | | | which covers this | | Explanation | for this system? | | | | +| | | | | system? (Y/N) | | | (Y/N) | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Details for Text Options: +Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to +(c), provide an explanation why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. + +Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal +register. If no to (e), provide an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn’t a current and up to +date SORN. + +Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be +considered as a blank field. + +| Page 18 of Section 300 | | | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) + +In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be +included in the agency’s EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and +supporting the FEA. The business case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the +business, performance, data, services, application, and technology layers of the agency’s EA. + +| 1. Is | this investment | | included | | in your | agency’s | target | enterprise | | | | | +| -------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | +| architecture? | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| | a. If “no,” please explain why? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +2. Is this investment included in the agency’s EA Transition Strategy? +| | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| --- | --------------- | -------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | +| | a. If “yes,” | provide | | the investment | | name | as identified | in the | | | | | +Transition Strategy provided in the agency’s most recent annual +| | EA Assessment. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | b. If “no,” please explain why? | | | | | | | | | | | | + +3. Is this investment identified in a completed and approved segment +| architecture? | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | +a. If “yes,” provide the six digit code corresponding to the agency +| | segment | architecture. | | The | segment | | architecture | codes are | | | | | +| --- | ----------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | maintained | | by the | agency | Chief | Architect. | | For detailed | | | | | +guidance regarding segment architecture codes, please refer to +http://www.egov.gov. +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table : +Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, +customer relationship management, etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed +guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. +Service Component +Agency Agency FEA SRM FEA SRM Reused (b) Internal or BY Funding +Component Component Service Component External Percentage +Component +| | Name | Description | | | Type | | (a) | | | Reuse? (c) | | (d) | +| --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | +UPI +Name +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as “NEW”. A “NEW” component is one not already identified +as a service component in the FEA SRM. +b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather +than answer yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify +the other investment using the Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 +submission. +c. ‘Internal’ reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service +component provided by another agency within the same department. ‘External’ reuse is one agency within a +department reusing a service component provided by another agency in another department. A good +example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being reused by multiple organizations across the federal +government. +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | | Page 19 of Section 300 | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed +in the table. If external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another +agency to pay for the service. The percentages in this column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. + +5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: +To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please +list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. +Service Specification (b) +| FEA SRM | | | FEA TRM Service | FEA TRM | | +| -------------- | --------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------- | -------------------------- | +| | FEA TRM Service Area | | | | (i.e., vendor and product | +| Component (a) | | | Category | Service Standard | | +name) +| | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | +| | | | | | | +| | | | | | | + +a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter +multiple rows for FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications +b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard +or vendor product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as +appropriate. + +| 6. Will the | application | leverage | existing components | and/or | | +| -------------- | ------------ | --------- | --------------------- | ------- | --- | +applications across the Government (i.e., USA.gov, Pay.Gov, etc)? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” please describe. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| Page 20 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Part II: Planning, Acquisition And Performance Information + +Part II should be completed only for investments identified as “Planning” or “Full Acquisition,” or “Mixed +Life-Cycle” investments in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. + +Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) +In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to +the current baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act +of 1996 for IT investments to determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. + +1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this investment? +| | | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” provide the date the analysis was completed? + +| | b. If “no,” | what | is | the anticipated | | date | this | analysis will be | | | | +| --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +completed? +c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: + +2. Alternatives Analysis Results: +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Alternative Risk Adjusted Lifecycle Risk Adjusted Lifecycle +Description of Alternative +| | Analyzed | | | | | | | Costs estimate | | Benefits estimate | | +| --------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | +| Baseline | | Status quo | | | | | | | | | | +| 1 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 2 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3. | Which | alternative | | was | selected | | by | the Agency’s | | | | +Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? +| | a. What | year | will | the | investment | breakeven? | | (Specifically, | | | | +| --- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +when the budgeted costs savings exceed the cumulative costs.) +4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +5. Federal Quantitative Benefits ($millions): +What specific quantitative benefits will be realized (using current dollars) +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: + Budgeted Cost Justification for Budgeted Justification for Budgeted +| | | | Cost Savings | | Avoidance | | | Cost Savings | | Cost Avoidance | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| PY-1 & prior | | | | | | | | | | | | +| PY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| CY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY+1 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| B BY+2 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +BY+3 +| BY+4 & Beyond | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| Total LCC Benefit | | | | | | | LLC = Life-cycle cost | | | | | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | Page 21 of Section 300 | | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +6. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part or in- +| whole? | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +a. If “yes,” are the migration costs associated with the migration to +| the selected | alternative | included | in this investment, | the legacy | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +investment, or in a separate migration investment? + +b. If “yes,” please provide the following information: + +5b. List of Legacy Investment or Systems +| | Name of the Legacy | | | | Date of the System | | +| --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +UPI if available +| | Investment of Systems | | | | Retirement | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +Page 22 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) + +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? +| | | | | | | Yes | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? + +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | + +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle +| cost estimate and investment schedule: | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should +still be included in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should +accurately reflect the milestones in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. + +| 1. Does | the earned value | management | system meet | the criteria | in | | | +| ------------------------- | ------------------- | ----------- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| ANSI/EIA Standard – 748? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| | | | | | | | | +2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than ± 10%? +| (CV%= CV/EV x 100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) | | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| a. If “yes,” was it the? | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | CV | | +| | | | | | | SV | | +| | | | | | | Both | | +| b. If “yes,” explain the causes of the variance: | | | | | | | | +| c. If “yes,” describe the corrective actions: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” when was it approved by the agency head? | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | Page 23 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline: +Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial +performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and +actual completion dates (e.g., “03/23/2003”/ “04/28/2004”) and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the +event that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the +‘Description of Milestone’ and ‘Percent Complete’ fields are required. Indicate ‘0’ for any milestone no longer active. +Current +| | Initial Baseline | | Current Baseline | | Baseline | | +| --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --------- | --- | +Variance +| | Planned | | Completion | | | | +| --------------- | ------------- | ------------ | --------------- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | +| | | Total Cost | | Total Cost | | | +| Description of | Completion | | Date | | Schedule:Cost | Percent | +| | | ($M) | | ($M) | | | +| Milestone | Date | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | (# days:$M) | Complete | +| | | Estimated | | Planned:Actual | | | +| | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | Planned:Actual | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| Page 24 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Part III: For “Operation and Maintenance” investments ONLY (Steady State) + +Part III should be completed only for investments identified as “Operation and Maintenance” (Steady State) in +response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. + +Section A: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +| c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | | | | + +Section B: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +1. Was an operational analysis conducted? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” provide the date the analysis was completed. + +| b. If “yes,” what were the results? | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +c. If “no,” please explain why it was not conducted and if there +| are any plans to conduct an operational analysis in the future: | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | +2. Complete the following table to compare actual cost performance against the planned cost performance +baseline. Milestones reported may include specific individual scheduled preventative and predictable +corrective maintenance activities, or may be the total of planned annual operation and maintenance efforts). +| a. What costs | are | included | in the reported | Cost/Schedule | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | ------------ | --------- | ------------------ | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Performance | information | | (Government | Only/Contractor | | | | | | +| Only/Both)? | | | | | | | | | | + +2. b Comparison of Plan vs. Actual Performance Table: +| | | Planned | | | Actual | | | | Variance | +| ------------------------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | +| Description of | | Completion | | Completion | | | | | | +| | | | Total Cost | | | Total Cost | | | Schedule:Cost | +| Milestone | | Date | | Date | | | | | | +| | | | ($M) | | | ($M) | | | (# days:$M) | +| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | Page 25 of Section 300 | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Part IV: Planning For “Multi-Agency Collaboration” ONLY + +Part IV should be completed only for investments identified as an E-Gov initiative, an Line of Business (LOB) +Initiative, or a Multi-Agency Collaboration effort. The “Multi-Agency Collaboration” choice should be select +in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. Investments identified as “Multi-Agency Collaboration” +will complete only Parts I and IV of the exhibit 300. + +Section A: Multi-Agency Collaboration Oversight (All Capital Assets) +Multi-agency Collaborations, such as E-Gov and LOB initiatives, should develop a joint exhibit 300. + +1. Stakeholder Table: +| | As a | joint exhibit | 300, please identify | all | the agency | stakeholders | (all | | +| --- | ------ | --------------- | ----------------------- | ---- | ------------ | ------------- | ----- | --- | +participating agencies, this should not be limited to agencies with financial +commitment). All agency stakeholders should be listed regardless of approval. +If the partner agency has approved this joint exhibit 300 please provide the date +of approval. +| | | Partner Agency | | Joint exhibit approval date | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +2. Partner Capital Assets within this Investment: +Provide the partnering strategies you are implementing with the participating agencies and organizations. +Identify all partner agency capital assets (including shared service providers) supporting the common solution +(section 300.7); Managing Partner capital assets should also be included in this joint exhibit 300. These capital +assets should be included in the Summary of Spending table of Part I, Section B. All partner agency migration +investments (section 53.4) should also be included in this table. Funding contributions/fee-for-service transfers +should not be included in this table.(Partner Agency UPIs should also appear on the Partner Agency's exhibit 53) +Partner Agency Partner Agency Asset Title Partner Agency Exhibit 53 UPI (BY 2010) +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +3. Partner Funding Strategies ($millions): +For jointly funded initiative activities, provide in the “Partner Funding Strategies Table”: the name(s) of partner +agencies; the UPI of the partner agency investments; and the partner agency contributions for CY and BY. Please +indicate partner contribution amounts (in-kind contributions should also be included in this amount) and fee-for-service +amounts. (Partner Agency Asset UPIs should also appear on the Partner Agency's exhibit 53. All fee-for-service +reimbursements for Shared Service Providers should be included in this table. For non-IT fee-for-service amounts the +Partner exhibit 53 UPI can be left blank) (IT migration investments should not be included in this table) +| Partner | Partner exhibit 53 UPI | | CY | | CY | BY | | BY | +| -------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Agency (BY 2010) Contribution Fee-for-Service Contribution Fee-for-Service +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| Page 26 of Section 300 | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +An Alternatives Analysis for multi-agency collaborations should also be obtained. At least three viable +alternatives, in addition to the current baseline (i.e., the status quo), should be included in the joint exhibit 300. +Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments, and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments, to determine +the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. + +4. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this investment? Yes No +| | a. If “yes,” what is the date of the analysis? | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | b. If “no,” | what | is | the anticipated | | date | this analysis | will be | | | | +| | completed? | | | | | | | | | | | +| | c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +5. Alternatives Analysis Results: +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Alternative Risk Adjusted Lifecycle Risk Adjusted Lifecycle +Description of Alternative +| | Analyzed | | | | | | | Costs estimate | | Benefits estimate | | +| --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | +| Baseline | | Status quo | | | | | | | | | | +| 1 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 2 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +6. Which alternative was selected by the Initiative Governance process +| and why was it chosen? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | a. What | year | will | the | investment | breakeven? | | (Specifically, | | | | +when the budgeted costs savings exceed the cumulative costs.) +7. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? + +8. Federal Quantitative Benefits ($millions): +What specific quantitative benefits will be realized (using current dollars) +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Budgeted Cost Justification for Budgeted Justification for Budgeted + +| | | | Cost Savings | | | Avoidance | | Cost Savings | | Cost Avoidance | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| PY-1 & prior | | | | | | | | | | | | +| PY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| CY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY+1 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| B BY+2 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +BY+3 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +BY+4 & Beyond +| Total LCC Benefit | | | | | | | LLC = Life-cycle cost | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +9. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part or in- +| whole? | | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” are the migration costs associated with the migration to +| | the selected | alternative | | included | | in this investment, | | the legacy | | | | +| --- | -------------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +investment, or in a separate migration investment? + +| | b. If “yes,” please provide the following information: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | | Page 27 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +9b. List of Legacy Investment or Systems +| | Name of the Legacy | | | Date of the System | | | +| --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | +UPI if available +| | Investment of Systems | | | Retirement | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) + +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | + +Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +You should also periodically be measuring the performance of operational assets against the baseline established +during the planning or full acquisition phase (i.e., operational analysis), and be properly operating and +maintaining the asset to maximize its useful life. Operational analysis may identify the need to redesign or +modify an asset by identifying previously undetected faults in design, construction, or installation/integration, +highlighting whether actual operation and maintenance costs vary significantly from budgeted costs, or +documenting that the asset is failing to meet program requirements. + +EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should +still be included in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should +accurately reflect the milestones in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. + +Answer the following questions about the status of this investment. Include information on all appropriate capital +assets supporting this investment except for assets in which the performance information is reported in a separate +exhibit 300. + +| 1. Are you using EVM to manage this investment? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +| | | | | | Yes | | +No + +| | | N/A (investment with ONLY O&M) | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a. If “yes,” does the earned value management system meet the +| criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard – 748? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------ | +| b. If “no,” explain plans to implement EVM: | | | | | | | +| c. If “N/A,” | please provide | date operational | analysis was | | | | +| conducted and a brief summary of the results: | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | +| Page 28 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Questions #2 are NOT applicable for capital assets with ONLY O&M + +2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than ± 10%? +| (CV%= CV/EV x 100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) | | | | | Yes | No | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| a. If “yes,” was it the? | | | | | | | +| | | | | | CV | | +| | | | | | SV | | +| | | | | | Both | | +b. If “yes,” explain the causes of the variance: + +| c. If “yes,” describe the corrective actions: | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +Questions #3-4 are applicable to ALL capital assets + +3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” when was it approved by the agency head? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline: +Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial +performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline +and actual completion dates (e.g., “03/23/2003”/ “04/28/2004”) and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). +In the event that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note +that the ‘Description of Milestone’ and ‘Percent Complete’ fields are required. Indicate ‘0’ for any milestone no longer +active. +Current +| | Initial Baseline | | Current Baseline | | Baseline | | +| --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --------- | --- | + elbisnopseR + etelpmoC ytivitcA rof +| | | | | | Variance | tnecreP ycnegA | +| ------------- | ------------- | ------------ | --------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | +| | Planned | | Completion | Total Cost | | | +| | | Total Cost | | | Schedule: | | +| Description | Completion | | Date | ($M) | | | +| | | ($M) | | | Cost | | +| of Milestone | Date | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Planned: | | | +| | | Estimated | | | (# days:$M) | | +| | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | Planned:Actual | Actual | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 29 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k2/random_2.md b/q7/random_k2/random_2.md index 5dac85680ad1e5631acf8a091a98a42ab0400813..79e21abdb756067a9ff62b132f72f6d1dcaeb4b8 100644 --- a/q7/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q7/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,2417 +1,261 @@ -COMPLAINT INDEX -REPORT FOR YEAR 2021 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Vicki Schmidt, Commissioner -insurance.kansas.gov +## BEYOND THE ANSWER: DECODING THE BEHAVIOR OF LLMS AS SCIENTIFIC REASONERS - Table of Contents +**Rohan Pandey** _[∗]_ **Eric Ye** _[∗]_ University of Washington _{_ rpande, ericy4 _}_ @uw.edu -About this Report +**Michael Li** _[∗]_ -Indexes by line: Automobile | Accident & Health +Carnegie Mellon University ml7@andrew.cmu.edu -Indexes by line: Homeowners | Individual Annuity +## ABSTRACT -Indexes by line: Individual Life | Long-Term Care +As Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve increasingly sophisticated performance on complex reasoning tasks, current architectures serve as critical proxies for the internal heuristics of frontier models. Characterizing emergent reasoning is vital for long-term interpretability and safety. Furthermore, understanding how prompting modulates these processes is essential, as natural language will likely be the primary interface for interacting with AGI systems. In this work, we use a custom variant of Genetic Pareto (GEPA) to systematically optimize prompts for scientific reasoning tasks, and analyze how prompting can affect reasoning behavior. We investigate the structural patterns and logical heuristics inherent in GEPA-optimized prompts, and evaluate their transferability and brittleness. Our findings reveal that gains in scientific reasoning often correspond to model-specific heuristics that fail to generalize across systems, which we call “local” logic. By framing prompt optimization as a tool for model interpretability, we argue that mapping these preferred reasoning structures for LLMs is an important prerequisite for effectively collaborating with superhuman intelligence. -File a Complaint +## 1 INTRODUCTION - 01 +As the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly push performance frontiers (Bubeck et al., 2023), research focus will foreseeably shift from benchmark tracking toward understanding how to best collaborate with LLMs. We identify reasoning as the most critical capability of LLMs in a post-AGI landscape, as it provides the verifiable logical scaffolding necessary for autonomous systems to navigate novel, high-stakes scenarios (Huang & Chang, 2023). A rigorous understanding of these mechanisms enables more effective human-AGI collaboration in a wide range of scenarios, ensuring these systems act reliably when tackling complex challenges. Current LLMs provide a valuable window into the reasoning paradigms that may define a post-AGI world. - 05 +We see scientific reasoning as a robust testbed for probing these internal paradigms. Scientific reasoning provides essential foundational logic and structured frameworks, which can generalize to a variety of high impact downstream tasks, including but not limited to scientific discovery, spatial navigation, and engineering. In this work, we examine such reasoning in two domains: (1) GPQA, which tests graduate-level scientific reasoning (Rein et al., 2023), and (2) a formally verified algebra dataset implemented in Lean (Yang et al., 2023b; Zheng et al., 2022). These benchmarks allow for the observation of complex logic under controlled and interpretable conditions. -06 +Since natural language will likely be the primary interface for interacting with AGI systems, understanding how prompting affects reasoning capabilities is crucial for reliable collaboration. In this work, we first use Genetic Pareto (GEPA) to optimize prompts and discover which specific instructions result in the best performance (Agrawal et al., 2025; Khattab et al., 2023). We then analyze these results to identify the patterns that elicit higher-level reasoning in these models. -07 +We find that high-performing prompts often rely on model-specific heuristics that fail to generalize across models (Mirzadeh et al., 2025). Mapping these machine-preferred structures is vital for overseeing future general-purpose systems (Berglund et al., 2024). This work establishes a foundation for decoding LLM reasoning to ensure safety frameworks are prepared for a post-AGI society. -08 +> _∗_ Equal contribution - About this Report +1 -What is a complaint? +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -The Kansas Insurance Department receives thousands of complaints and inquiries each year about -insurance companies. Complaints and inquiries from the public give us an indication of the kind of -service companies are providing to their customers. We can then work with companies that need to -improve in certain areas. +## 2 BACKGROUND -Complaints can also help us identify insurance companies or agents that may need to be investigated -for violations of Kansas insurance laws or regulations. The Department also uses complaints to focus -public education efforts on the issues that concern Kansas insurance consumers. +**LLMs for Math and Science** LLMs are rapidly moving beyond simple linguistic pattern matching, developing complex multi-step reasoning skills that are necessary for mathematical and scientific general intelligence. Current methodologies often rely on specialized prompting paradigms; for instance, Chain-of-Thought (Wei et al., 2022) encourages explicit symbolic derivation, while Programof-Thought (Chen et al., 2022) offloads complex scientific computing to external Python interpreters. More recently, reasoning-centric models such as OpenAI’s o1 and DeepSeek’s R1 have utilized large-scale reinforcement learning to internalize these logical trajectories (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025). However, breaking records on benchmarks is only a partial milestone. As these systems approach AGI-level performance, research must shift from merely tracking performance to understanding how to best collaborate with these models. In this work, we argue that identifying the structural biases and implicit reasoning strategies within these models is a vital prerequisite for the effective oversight and safe deployment of AGI systems in high-stakes and unsupervised scenarios. -Each time we receive a complaint, we notify the insurance company and any involved agents. -We send the company a copy of the complaint and ask that it be reviewed and an explanation -provided. Companies are required by law to respond to the Department within 15 working days. -Most companies are cooperative in working with us to resolve consumer complaints. We keep a -record of each complaint filed by a consumer for up to three years. +**Automated Prompt Engineering** Optimization of model performance has evolved from the manual engineering of prompts to a systematic algorithmic search. Early works in automated prompt engineering have demonstrated that LLMs are often the best optimizers of their own instructions (Zhou et al., 2022; Yang et al., 2023a). Genetic Pareto (GEPA) utilizes an evolutionary approach to iteratively optimize high performing prompts (Agrawal et al., 2025). While previous works on automated engineering focused primarily on maximizing accuracy, we reposition these algorithms as tools for understanding. By allowing GEPA to explore the vast search space of possible instructions, we treat the resulting optimized prompts and the trajectory of prompt evolution as valuable windows into the latent preferences of the model. We can then identify specific heuristics that can be reverse engineered and transferred back to improve human-authored prompting methodologies. -A formal complaint is any written communication expressing dissatisfaction or concern with an -insurance company or an agent. General written inquiries received from consumers are not counted -in this report. We also do not include complaints regarding products not within the jurisdiction of the -Kansas Insurance Department, such as self-funded plans and Medicare prescription drug plans. +**Knowledge Transferability** A fundamental question in the path toward AGI is whether machine intelligence is a singular phenomenon or a collection of fragmented epistemologies (Quattrociocchi et al., 2025). Previous research into model distillation and generalization has shown that while knowledge can be transferred between architectures, internal reasoning protocols often remain model specific (Hinton et al., 2015). This brittleness poses challenges for the post-AGI era. For AI systems to truly be of use in collaborative scientific discovery, their logic must be interoperable. If a reasoning strategy optimized for one model fails on another, it suggests a closed epistemology, which represents a detached form of intelligence that lacks a universal logical foundation (Pal et al., 2026). -NOTE: A formal complaint must be made in writing. +## 3 METHODOLOGY -What is a complaint index? +We assess LLM reasoning in two domains: (1) formal mathematical theorem proving via Lean from the MiniF2F dataset (Zheng et al., 2022) and (2) scientific reasoning via the GPQA Diamond benchmark (Rein et al., 2023). We refer to these benchmarks as “Algebra” and “GPQA” respectively. These domains assess scientific reasoning in complementary ways: Lean requires rigid verifiable logic and is open ended, while GPQA evaluates high level conceptual reasoning and is multiple choice. We apply a custom variant of GEPA which has been simplified and adapted for Lean theorem proving and GPQA. Implementation details are specified in Algorithm 1. -The complaint index shows how a company compares to other companies in the same line of business. -It is a statistic that considers a company’s share of complaints in relation to its market share or share of -business written in Kansas. Since the complaint index is measured by market share, companies in all -lines of business will be measured against an index of 1.00. +We conduct the entirety of GEPA optimization using DeepSeek-V3.2, which currently has state-ofthe-art performance on reasoning benchmarks. To gain insight into the transferability of optimized prompts across different models, we also test the same prompts on ChatGPT-5.4-mini, GLM 5, and Claude Sonnet 4.6, all of which were released within the past few months and have competitive performance. By analyzing the prompt optimization process and comparing prompt performance across models, we hope to gain insight into how prompting strategy affects reasoning performance. -For example, a complaint index of 1.00 means the insurer’s share of all complaints received is equal -to its share of all the business written in Kansas. An index of 2.00 means that the insurer’s share -of complaints is twice as large as its share of business written. An index of 0.00 indicates that no -complaints were received for the company. +For every combination of model and benchmark, we run evaluations across four prompts: **(1) HandCrafted Simple:** A hand-crafted simple prompt, intended to emulate the prompting ability of average technical users, which serves as a baseline; **(2) Hand-Crafted CoT:** A hand-crafted Chain-of-Thought prompt, intended to emulate best practice prompting strategies to current knowledge, which serves as a baseline; **(3) GEPA Optimized Baseline:** The initial prompt from the GEPA optimization process; and **(4) GEPA Optimized Final:** The final prompt from the GEPA optimization process. Prompts are further discussed in the Appendix, and examples are provided. -The formula is as follows: +2 -Complaint share +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Market share +## **Algorithm 1** Custom Variant of Genetic Pareto (GEPA) -OR +- 1: **Input:** Seed prompt _P_ 0, Lean theorems _L_ , GPQA questions _G_ , iterations _T_ , samples ( _n, m_ ). -Company’s complaints / -all complaints +- 2: **Initialize:** _Population ←{P_ 0 _}_ , _Pareto ←∅_ . -Company’s premium / All -written premium +- 3: **for** _t_ = 1 **to** _T_ **do** -page 1 +- 4: _P ←_ Sample( _Pareto ̸_ = _∅_ ? _Pareto_ : _Population_ ) 5: _SL ←_ Sample( _L, n_ ), _SG ←_ Sample( _G, m_ ) -insurance.kansas.gov Which complaints do we use? +- Lean Verify(LLM( _P, ci_ )) _ci ∈ SL_ -This report shows complaints for the six major types of insurance: accident and health (including -HMOs), annuity, automobile, homeowners, life and long-term care. +- 6: **Evaluate: v** [ _i_ ] _←_ for _ci ∈ SL ∪ SG_ �Check ~~A~~ nswer(LLM( _P, ci_ )) _ci ∈ SG_ -We do not include complaints regarding products not within the jurisdiction of the Department, such as -self-funded plans and Medicare prescription drug plans. In 2021, the Kansas Insurance Department -closed a total of 2,205 complaints. 2,110 involved matters within our jurisdiction. +- 7: **Update Pareto:** Add _P_ if non-dominated by existing prompts; remove dominated. 8: _Errors ←{ci_ : **v** [ _i_ ] = 0 _}_ -To ensure fairness, all closed complaints are counted without any attempt to distinguish between -“valid” or “invalid” complaints. +- 9: _Critique ←_ LLM ~~C~~ ritic( _P,_ Logs( _Errors_ )) -Which companies are shown? +- 10: _P[′] ←_ LLM ~~E~~ volve( _P, Critique_ ) -Unless otherwise noted, we list the top 20 premium-writing companies for each line, as well as any -company with 10 or more closed complaints for that type of insurance during the calendar year. +- 11: _Population ← Pareto ∪{P[′] } {_ Prune to Pareto + new child _}_ -During 2021, $6,273,694.92 was recovered for Kansas consumers as a result of the Department’s -assistance. In 2021, the largest number of complaints concerned automobile insurance (29%) and -accident & health Insurance (28%). Here is the breakdown: +- 12: **end for** -All Closed Complaints & Inquiries +- 13: **return** _Pareto_ -Automobile +## 4 RESULTS -29% +## 4.1 BENCHMARK PERFORMANCE -Life +Table 1: Performance comparison of models on benchmark datasets. -3,000 +|**Model**|**Method**|**Algebra**|**GPQA**| +|---|---|---|---| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|86.11%|91.67%| +|DeepSeek-V3.2|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|97.22%
91.67%|91.67%
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|**100.00%**|**94.44%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|50.00%|**91.67%**| +|GPT-5.4-mini|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|47.22%
50.00%|**91.67%**
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|**61.11%**|**91.67%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|91.67%|**91.67%**| +|GLM 5|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|**97.22%**
91.67%|86.11%
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|94.44%|**91.67%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|30.56%|77.78%| +|Claude Sonnet 4.6|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|**52.78%**
50.00%|**83.33%**
80.56%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|50.00%|80.56%| -2,500 -Accident & Health -28% +Prompt performance on benchmarks is displayed in Table 1. Our first major observation is that the GEPA Optimized Final prompt achieves its most significant gains on DeepSeek-V3.2, reaching 100.00% on Algebra and 94.44% on GPQA. This confirms that the GEPA optimization process is highly effective when evaluated on the same model used during optimization. Our second major observation is that the superiority of the GEPA-optimized prompts does not reliably transfer to other models. While some models show marginal benefits – for example, GPT-5.4-mini sees an improvement in Algebra from 50.00% to 61.11% – the optimized prompt is rarely the undisputed best performer elsewhere. Notably, for GLM 5 (Algebra) and Claude Sonnet 4.6 (both benchmarks), the Hand-Crafted CoT prompts actually outperform the GEPA Optimized Final prompt. -Long-Term Care +These results suggest that the optimization process is highly model-specific, and suggests a trade-off between prompt universality and performance. Since DeepSeek was used as the optimizer, the evolved prompts likely capture patterns specific to DeepSeek’s architecture that do not resonate with the internal logic of other models. This highlights a significant lack of interoperability and reinforces the brittleness of automated prompt engineering across diverse foundation models. -2,000 +3 -Homeowners +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Other +**==> picture [318 x 128] intentionally omitted <==** -15% +Figure 1: The length of GEPA proposed prompts increases over the course of optimization, with the final prompt often being about twice as long in characters as the initial prompt. This shows that detailed prompting is likely required to unlock better reasoning capabilities in LLMs. -14% +## 4.2 PROMPT EVOLUTION PATTERNS -Annuity +By manually analyzing the evolution of prompts over the course of GEPA optimization, we primarily find that prompts evolve from telling the model _what to do_ to coaching it on _how to do it_ , similar to a human expert. In the process, significant domain knowledge and best practices are often added to the context. For example, in the GEPA optimization process for the Algebra benchmark, prompts eventually referenced domain specific strategies such as using Eisenstein’s Criterion for minimal polynomials. Similarly, later GPQA prompts mentioned specific strategies such as quantum field theory loop counting. Later Algebra prompts also explicitly warn against common pitfalls, especially with regard to Lean formatting. Interestingly, a robust protocol for “Handling False Statements” is also introduced to prevent hallucinating proofs. The Appendix contains prompt examples. -1,500 +This observation is also supported by analyzing the prompt lengths over the course of optimization, as shown in Figure 1. The final prompt turns out to be around twice as long as the initial prompt. This demonstrates that LLMs often rely on detailed prompting to fully elicit their reasoning capabilities. -1,000 +By analyzing the embedding space for prompts over the optimization process, we also find that the embeddings of proposed prompts tends to drift in a consistent direction over the course of optimization. This suggests that for the same task, some regions of prompting space may offer more promising performance. A plot of this behavior is in the Appendix. -500 +## 5 DISCUSSION -0 +**Conclusion** In this work, we demonstrated that using clever prompt optimization techniques can unlock reasoning potential in LLMs. We find that longer prompts, as well as prompts that guide the model along the _how_ of the target task, tend to elicit superior reasoning capabilities in LLMs. Such prompts can be optimized autonomously, and can beat hand-crafted baselines, even when we hand-craft prompts using state-of-the-art best practices. Our findings suggest that if current trends continue, post-AGI reasoning may not manifest as a universal logic, but rather as a collection of task-specific and model-specific heuristics that require precise coaching to elicit. -*rounded to the nearest percent +**Limitations** Our work is still relatively preliminary, and is limited to two benchmarks and four models. We would need a broader experimental scope to more confidently confirm the validity of our hypotheses. Furthermore, the stochastic nature of our LLM-driven prompt optimization loop could lead to inconsistency across multiple runs. -Closed Complaints +**Future Work** Our preliminary results suggest that prompt optimization remains dangerously architecture dependent. To prepare for a post-AGI landscape, future research should work on identifying “reasoning primitives”, or logical structures invariant across models. If AGI develops logic that humans cannot understand, we need to build automated tools to keep these systems interpretable. Without this, we risk a future where our most capable tools are also our least predictable. -Closed Inquiries +4 -9% +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -4% +## 6 STATEMENTS -1% +## 6.1 ETHICS STATEMENT -2018 +While the discovery of effective reasoning paths could potentially be repurposed for harmful tasks, our analysis of the logic inherent in these models primarily as a vital safeguard. If we better understand how LLMs reason, we can better utilize LLMs for reasoning related tasks. Ultimately, identifying how LLMs approach reasoning tasks is essential for the development of robust, aligned, and transparent post-AGI systems. -2,689 +We also agree to NOT reveal examples from our evaluation datasets in plain text or images online, to reduce the risk of leakage into foundation model training corpora. -1,049 +## 6.2 REPRODUCIBILITY STATEMENT -2019 +Our results are reproducible to the extent of nondeterminism in the outputs of LLMs used. -2,643 +## REFERENCES -878 +- Lakshya A Agrawal, Shangyin Tan, Dilara Soylu, Noah Ziems, Rishi Khare, Krista Opsahl-Ong, Arnav Singhvi, Herumb Shandilya, Michael J Ryan, Meng Jiang, Christopher Potts, Koushik Sen, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Ion Stoica, Dan Klein, Matei Zaharia, and Omar Khattab. Gepa: Reflective prompt evolution can outperform reinforcement learning, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/ abs/2507.19457. -2020 +- Lukas Berglund, Meg Tong, Max Kaufmann, Mikita Balesni, Asa Cooper Stickland, Tomasz Korbak, and Owain Evans. The reversal curse: Llms trained on ”a is b” fail to learn ”b is a”, 2024. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12288. -2,157 +- Sebastien´ Bubeck, Varun Chandrasekaran, Ronen Eldan, Johannes Gehrke, Eric Horvitz, Ece Kamar, Peter Lee, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li, Scott Lundberg, Harsha Nori, Hamid Palangi, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, and Yi Zhang. Sparks of artificial general intelligence: Early experiments with gpt-4. March 2023. URL https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/ sparks-of-artificial-general-intelligence-early-experiments-with-gpt-4/. -873 +- Wenhu Chen, Xueguang Ma, Xinyi Wang, and William W Cohen. Program of thoughts prompting: Disentangling computation from reasoning for numerical reasoning tasks. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2211.12588_ , 2022. -2021 +- DeepSeek-AI et al. Deepseek-r1: Incentivizing reasoning capability in llms via reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.12948_ , 2025. -2,205 +- Geoffrey Hinton, Oriol Vinyals, and Jeff Dean. Distilling the knowledge in a neural network. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1503.02531_ , 2015. -795 +- Jie Huang and Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang. Towards reasoning in large language models: A survey, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10403. -All Closed Complaints & Inquiries +- Omar Khattab, Arnav Singhvi, Paridhi Maheshwari, Zhiyuan Zhang, Keshav Santhanam, Sri Vardhamanan, Saiful Haq, Ashutosh Sharma, Thomas T. Joshi, Hanna Moazam, Heather Miller, Matei Zaharia, and Christopher Potts. Dspy: Compiling declarative language model calls into self-improving pipelines, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.03714. -Recoveries Per Year (In Millions) +- Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Hooman Shahrokhi, Oncel Tuzel, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. Gsm-symbolic: Understanding the limitations of mathematical reasoning in large language models, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05229. -7 +- Koyena Pal, David Bau, and Chandan Singh. Do explanations generalize across large reasoning models?, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.11517. -6 +5 -5 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -4 +Walter Quattrociocchi, Valerio Capraro, and Matjaz Perc.ˇ Epistemological fault lines between human and artificial intelligence, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.19466. -3 +- David Rein, Betty Li Hou, Asa Cooper Stickland, Jackson Petty, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Julien Dirani, Julian Michael, and Samuel R. Bowman. Gpqa: A graduate-level google-proof q&a benchmark, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12022. -2 +- Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Fei Xia, Ed Chi, Quoc V Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain-of-thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 35:24824–24837, 2022. -1 +- Chengrung Yang, Xuezhi Wang, Yutai Lu, Hanxiao Liu, Quoc V Le, Denny Zhou, and Xinyun Chen. Large language models as optimizers. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2309.03409_ , 2023a. -0 +- Kaiyu Yang, Aidan M. Swope, Alex Gu, Rahul Chalamala, Peiyang Song, Shixing Yu, Saad Godil, Ryan Prenger, and Anima Anandkumar. Leandojo: Theorem proving with retrieval-augmented language models, 2023b. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15626. -6.27 +- Kunhao Zheng, Jesse Michael Han, and Stanislas Polu. Minif2f: a cross-system benchmark for formal olympiad-level mathematics, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.00110. -4.12 +- Yongchao Zhou, Andrei Ioan Muresanu, Ziwen Han, Keiran Paster, Silvian Puzicanin, Amar Terzic, Laurent Itti, et al. Large language models are human-level prompt engineers. In _The Eleventh International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2022. -3.28 +## A APPENDIX -1.84 +## A.1 ADDITIONAL RESULTS -2018 +**==> picture [396 x 144] intentionally omitted <==** -2019 +Figure 2: The embeddings of GEPA proposed prompts tend to drift over the course of optimization. For both algebra and GPQA, there seems to be a significant jump in embedding space at around iteration 12. This suggests that for the same task, some regions of prompting space may offer more promising performance. -2020 +## A.2 PROMPTS -2021 +The 4 prompts we tested for the Algebra benchmark are listed below. For sake of brevity, we do not include the 4 GPQA prompts in this section, but they are similar in nature. -page 2 +Listing 1: Hand-Crafted Simple Prompt -3,000 +1 You are a mathematician and Lean 4 practitioner. 2 Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean 4 proofs. -2,500 +3 4 Approach and tricks: -2,000 +6 -1,500 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -1,000 +- 5 - Try to reduce the goal using simp/linarith/nlinarith or rewriting. 6 - Look for standard lemmas in Mathlib (algebra, number theory, inequalities, parity). -500 +- 7 - Prefer structured proofs: have, refine, apply, and use ‘by‘ blocks. 8 9 Output format: -0 +- 10 - Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘lean ... ‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code. -Closed Complaints +- 11 - Do not include any text outside the code block. -Closed Inquiries +## Listing 2: Hand-Crafted CoT Prompt -2018 +|1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29|You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer.
Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean
4 proofs.
### Output Format
- Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code.
- Do not include any text outside the code block.
- The code should be complete, including necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘
statements.
### Imports
- Do not use a single monolithic ‘import Mathlib‘.
- Instead, import the specific files you need, e.g., ‘import Mathlib.Data
.Real.Basic‘, ‘import Mathlib.Algebra.Order.Field.Basic‘, ‘import
Mathlib.Tactic.Linarith‘.
### Chain-of-Thought (internal)
- Think step-by-step and consider small test cases for ‘N‘/‘Z‘ statements
.
- Do not reveal chain-of-thought. Output only the Lean code block.
### General Approach & Tactics
- Start with structured proofs: ‘have‘, ‘refine‘, ‘apply‘, ‘by‘ blocks.
Use ‘calc‘ for equational reasoning.
- Use ‘simp‘, ‘rw‘, ‘ring‘, ‘norm_num‘. ‘linarith‘ for linear
inequalities, ‘nlinarith‘ for non-linear.
- ‘ac_rfl‘ is useful for equalities up to associativity/commutativity.
### Handling False Statements
- If you find a counterexample, do not modify the statement.
- Provide a Lean code block that proves the counterexample, then leave
the original theorem with ‘sorry‘.
### Domain-Specific Hints
- Polynomial identities: ‘ring‘ is often a one-line proof.
- Inequalities: reduce to ‘0 _≤_x - y‘, then show nonnegativity via
squares or ‘positivity‘.
- Linear systems over ‘C‘: use ‘linear_combination‘ or a ‘calc‘ block
with ‘ring‘.| +|---|---| -2,689 -1,049 -2019 +## Listing 3: GEPA Optimized Baseline Prompt -2,643 +1 You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer. 2 Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean 4 proofs. 3 4 ### General Approach 5 6 1. **[Analyze][the][Problem:] **[Read][the][theorem][statement][carefully.] Restate the goal in your own words to ensure you understand it. Identify the core mathematical concepts involved (e.g., number theory , inequalities, algebra). -878 +7 -2020 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -2,157 +|7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44|2.
**Formulate a Mathematical Strategy:**
*
Before writing any code, sketch a proof plan on paper (mentally).
*
Consider standard theorems like AM-GM, Cauchy-Schwarz, Jensen’s
inequality, or properties of quadratic equations (discriminant).
*
For sums and series, look for telescoping patterns or
opportunities for integral bounds. For example, ‘1/_√_k‘ is often
bounded using ‘2(_√_k - _√_(k-1))‘.
*
A very common and powerful trick for inequalities is to use the
fact that ‘(x - y)ˆ2 _≥_0‘, which expands to ‘xˆ2 + yˆ2 _≥_2xy‘.
3.
**Structure the Lean Proof:**
*
**DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself):** If you find yourself proving the
same thing multiple times with different variables, define a local
helper ‘lemma‘ to abstract the repeated logic. For example, if you
need ‘xˆ2/y + y _≥_2x‘ for several pairs ‘(x, y)‘, prove it once in a
general lemma.
*
**Structured Proofs:** Prefer structured proofs using ‘have‘, ‘
let‘, ‘calc‘, ‘refine‘, and ‘apply‘. Use ‘by‘ blocks for short tactic
sequences.
*
**Backward Reasoning:** Use ‘suffices‘ to simplify the goal to an
easier-to-prove intermediate statement.
### Lean 4 Tactics and Tricks
*
**Automation:**
*
‘ring‘: Use to prove equalities that hold in any commutative ring
(polynomials without division).
*
‘field_simp‘: Use to prove equalities in fields (expressions with
division). Provide non-zero hypotheses, e.g., ‘field_simp [h.ne.symm
]‘.
*
‘linarith‘: For proving linear arithmetic inequalities.
*
‘nlinarith‘: For proving non-linear arithmetic inequalities. It
is very powerful when combined with a hypothesis like ‘sq_nonneg‘.
*
‘positivity‘: To automatically prove goals of the form ‘0 < x‘ or
‘0 _≤_x‘.
*
**Rewriting and Simplification:**
*
‘rw‘: For rewriting terms using equalities.
*
‘simp‘: For general simplification. You can add specific lemmas
to its ruleset, e.g., ‘simp [add_comm]‘.
*
**Finding Lemmas:**
*
Mathlib is vast. If you think a lemma for a common mathematical
fact (e.g., telescoping sums) should exist, it probably does. For
example, ‘Finset.sum_Icc_telescope‘ is available for telescoping sums
over an ‘Icc‘.
*
Use ‘exact?‘ or ‘apply?‘ to ask Lean to search for a lemma that
solves the current goal.
*
**Crucially, only use lemma and tactic names that you are certain
exist in Mathlib.** Do not invent names. If your code uses a non-
existent identifier, it is incorrect. Double-check your toolset.
*
**Common Mathlib Lemmas for Inequalities:**
*
‘sq_nonneg (x : R)‘: Proves ‘0 _≤_x ˆ 2‘.
*
‘pow_two_nonneg (x : R)‘: Same as ‘sq_nonneg‘.
*
‘div_nonneg {a b : R} (ha : 0 _≤_a) (hb : 0 _≤_b) : 0 _≤_a / b‘. You
need to prove the numerator and denominator are non-negative.
### Output Format
*
Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘ containing valid, complete, and compilable Lean 4 code.
*
Ensure all necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘ statements are present.
*
Do not include any text, explanation, or comments outside the code
block.| +|---|---| -873 -2021 -2,205 +8 -795 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -7 +Listing 4: GEPA Optimized Final Prompt -6 +|1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42|You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer.
Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean
4 proofs.
### Output Format
- Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code.
- Do not include any text outside the code block.
- The code should be complete, including necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘
statements.
### General Approach & Tactics
- **Verify the statement first.** Before attempting a proof, especially
for statements over ‘N‘ or ‘Z‘, quickly test small values (e.g., n=0,
1, 2). If you find a counterexample, follow the "Handling False
Statements" protocol below.
- Start with structured proofs: ‘have‘, ‘refine‘, ‘apply‘, ‘by‘ blocks. ‘
calc‘ blocks are excellent for equational reasoning.
- Use ‘simp‘, ‘rw‘, ‘ring‘, ‘norm_num‘. ‘linarith‘ is for linear
inequalities over ordered fields (‘R‘, ‘Q‘). ‘nlinarith‘ is for non-
linear inequalities.
- ‘ac_rfl‘ is useful for proving equalities up to associativity and
commutativity, which is often more robust than a sequence of ‘rw [
add_comm, add_assoc]‘.
- **DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself).** If you prove the same intermediate
result multiple times with different variables, define a local helper
lemma inside the proof using ‘have‘. This improves clarity and
reduces errors.
‘‘‘lean
have my_lemma : _∀_(x y : R), 0 < y _→_xˆ2 / y + y _≥_2 * x := by
... -- proof of the lemma
-- then use it:
have h1 := my_lemma a b hb
have h2 := my_lemma b c hc
‘‘‘
### Handling False Statements
- If you find a counterexample (e.g., the theorem fails for ‘n=1‘), do
not attempt to prove a modified version of the theorem (e.g.,
changing ‘<‘ to ‘_≤_‘ or adding a hypothesis like ‘n _≥_2‘).
- Your task is to prove the theorem *as given*. If it is false, you
cannot complete the task.
- In this case, your response should be a Lean code block that formally
proves the counterexample. Then, leave the original theorem with ‘
sorry‘. This correctly signals that the requested proof is impossible
.
- **Example a assistant should produce for a false statement:**
‘‘‘lean
import Mathlib
-- The user’s theorem statement is false for n=1.
-- Here is a proof of the counterexample.
example : _¬_ (_∀_n : N, (n : R) ˆ (1 / n : R) < 2 - 1 / n) := by
intro h
specialize h 1
norm_num at h -- This will fail, proving the negation.
-- The original problem, which is unprovable.
theorem algebra_ineq_nto1onlt2m1on (n : N) : (n : R) ˆ (1 / n : R) <
2 - 1 / n := by
sorry
‘‘‘
### Domain-Specific Strategies & Mathlib Knowledge|| +|---|---|---| -5 -4 -3 +9 -2 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -1 +43 44 #### 1. Polynomial & Ring Identities 45 - For identities involving addition, subtraction, multiplication, and integer powers (i.e., polynomial identities), the ‘ring‘ tactic is extremely powerful. It works over any commutative (semi)ring like ‘Z ‘, ‘Q‘, ‘R‘, ‘C‘. For simple identities, this is often a one-line proof. 46 47 #### 2. Inequalities over R, Q (AM-GM, Cauchy-Schwarz, etc.) 48 - A common strategy is to prove ‘x _≥_ y‘ by showing ‘x - y _≥_ 0‘. 49 - **Pattern: Prove ‘x _≥_ y‘ by showing ‘x - y _≥_ 0‘** 50 1. State the subgoal: ‘suffices 0 _≤_ x - y by linarith‘. 51 2. Establish an algebraic identity for the difference, where the right-hand side is in a form that is clearly non-negative (e.g., a square or a sum of squares). 52 ‘‘‘lean 53 have h_ident : x - y = (a - b)ˆ2 / c := by 54 field_simp -- Handles division. Provide non-zero hypotheses, e. g., ‘field_simp [ne_of_gt hc]‘. 55 ring -- Finishes the polynomial part. 56 ‘‘‘ 57 3. Prove the right-hand side is non-negative. This often uses ‘ div_nonneg‘, ‘mul_nonneg‘, ‘sq_nonneg‘, and ‘positivity‘. 58 - **Pattern: Proving ‘(a-b)*(c-d) _≥_ 0‘** 59 * This is common in induction proofs. The key is to show that ‘a-b‘ and ‘c-d‘ have the same sign. 60 * A robust method is to use ‘mul_nonneg_of_signs_sync‘. For example , to prove ‘0 _≤_ (a - b) * (aˆn - bˆn)‘ for ‘0 _≤_ a, b‘ and ‘1 _≤_ n‘: 61 ‘‘‘lean 62 have h_iff : a _≤_ b _↔_ a ˆ n _≤_ b ˆ n := 63 Real.pow_le_pow_iff_of_nonneg (by linarith) (by linarith) (by omega) 64 exact mul_nonneg_of_signs_sync h_iff 65 ‘‘‘ 66 * This is much cleaner than a ‘by_cases‘ block. 67 68 #### 3. Linear Algebra over C 69 - **‘linarith‘ fails over ‘C‘** because it is not an ordered ring. 70 - **‘linear_combination‘ Tactic:** This is the most direct way to solve systems of linear equations. It combines *other equational hypotheses *[.] 71 ‘‘‘lean 72 -- h 0 : f + 3*z = 11 73 -- h 1 : 3*f - 5*z = -65 74 have h_14z : 14 * z = 98 := by linear_combination 3 * h 0 - h 1 75 ‘‘‘ 76 - **Warning:** Do not use ‘linear_combination‘ to manipulate a single equation with a constant (e.g., ‘linear_combination h 0 - 21‘ is incorrect). To solve for a variable in one equation, use ‘calc‘ or ‘ rw‘. 77 - **Solving Equations:** 78 1. **[From][a][system:] **[After][using][‘linear_combination‘][to][get][e.g.] ‘14 * z = 98‘, use ‘mul_right_cancel 0 ‘ to solve for the variable. 79 ‘‘‘lean 80 -- h_eq: 14 * z = 98 81 have hz : z = 7 := by 82 apply mul_right_cancel 0 (by norm_num : (14 : C) = 0) 83 rw [h_eq] -- Goal becomes: 98 = 14 * 7 84 norm_num -- Finishes the proof 85 ‘‘‘ 86 2. **[From][one][equation:] **[To][isolate][a][variable][in][an][equation][like] ‘f + 21 = 11‘, use a ‘calc‘ block. 87 ‘‘‘lean 88 -- h 0 : f + 21 = 11 89 have hf : f = -10 := by -0 +10 -Recoveries Per Year (In Millions) +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -6.27 +|90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115|calc f = (f + 21) - 21 := by ring
_ = 11 - 21
:= by rw [h0]
_ = -10
:= by norm_num
‘‘‘
#### 4. Algebraic Numbers & Field Theory (Linear Independence)
- Problems of the form "if ‘a + b*m + c*mˆ2 = 0‘ with ‘a,b,c _∈_Q‘, then ‘
a=b=c=0‘" are about linear independence and minimal polynomials.
- The strategy:
1.
Identify the algebraic number (e.g., ‘m = 2ˆ(1/3)‘).
2.
Find its minimal polynomial over ‘Q‘ (e.g., ‘p = X3 - 2‘).
3.
Prove ‘p‘ is irreducible over ‘Q‘ using **Eisenstein’s Criterion
**: ‘Polynomial.irreducible_of_eisenstein_criterion‘. For ‘X3 - 2‘,
use the prime ‘p=2‘. (Requires ‘import Mathlib.RingTheory.Polynomial.
Eisenstein‘).
4.
Verify ‘p‘ is the minimal polynomial using ‘minpoly.
eq_of_irreducible_of_monic‘.
5.
Use ‘minpoly.dvd Q m hq‘ to show the minimal polynomial divides
your polynomial. (Requires ‘import Mathlib.FieldTheory.Minpoly.Basic
‘).
6.
Get a contradiction from degrees (‘Polynomial.
eq_zero_of_dvd_of_degree_lt‘).
7.
Deduce coefficients are zero using ‘Polynomial.
coeff_eq_zero_of_eq_zero‘.
### Troubleshooting
- **‘rw‘ or ‘calc‘ block failures:** If ‘rw‘ or ‘calc‘ fails due to term
ordering (e.g., ‘a*b‘ vs ‘b*a‘), try ‘ac_rfl‘ or add an explicit ‘rw
[mul_comm]‘.
- **Unknown Identifier Errors:** If you get an ’unknown identifier’ error
for a common mathematical lemma (e.g., ‘pow_le_pow_left‘), the name
has likely changed in Mathlib4.
- **Search the documentation.** The best way to find the current name
is to search the Mathlib4 API documentation.
- **Look for prefixes.** Many lemmas are now namespaced by their
primary type. For example, lemmas about ‘Real‘ powers are often in
the ‘Real‘ namespace (e.g., ‘Real.pow_le_pow_of_le_left‘). Lemmas
about ‘rpow‘ (real powers) are often named ‘Real.rpow_...‘.
- **Common Power Inequality Lemmas (for ‘R‘):**
- For ‘0 _≤_x _≤_y _→_xˆn _≤_yˆn‘, use ‘Real.pow_le_pow_of_le_left‘.
- For ‘0 _≤_x < y _→_xˆn < yˆn‘, use ‘Real.pow_lt_pow_of_lt_left‘.
- For ‘0 _≤_a, b‘ and ‘1 _≤_n‘, ‘a _≤_b _↔_aˆn _≤_bˆn‘ is ‘Real.
pow_le_pow_iff_of_nonneg‘.
- **Complex Proofs:** If a proof is complex (e.g., induction with
inequalities), break it down into many small, verifiable ‘have‘
statements to isolate errors. Don’t write a single large ‘calc‘ block
or proof term until you have verified the intermediate steps.| +|---|---| -4.12 -3.28 -1.84 +11 -2018 - -2019 - -2020 - -2021 - -Complaint Index Report - - Sixty-seven percent (67%) of total complaints concerned problems with claims handling. Other -common types of complaints involved policyholder services, underwriting and marketing and sales. - -67% - Claims Handling - -19% - Policyholder Service - -10% - Underwriting - -4% - Marketing and Sales - -Companies may be listed on more than one table and will usually have a different complaint index -on each table. For example, if you are shopping for auto insurance, go to the table titled, “Indexes by -line: Automobile” to check for your company’s complaint index. Companies are listed in alphabetical -order. - -We list individual insurance companies only, not groups of insurance companies. For example, you -may be insured by a company such as State Farm. We show the name of the subsidiary company -owned by State Farm. Your policy or ID card lists the exact name of your company. - -Why is my company not listed? - -If a company is not listed, that means it had fewer than 10 complaints during the calendar year and -it was not one of the top 20 premium writers for that line in Kansas. Information can also be compiled -for lines of insurance not listed in this booklet. For information on a company not listed or another line -of insurance, please call our Consumer Assistance Hotline at 800-432-2484. - -Just a snapshot - -The statistics in this report give you a “snapshot” of a company that represents complaints filed with the -Department regarding that company’s business in Kansas for one year and one type of coverage. As -indexes are likely to change, you may want to review these “snapshots” annually. - -Complaint indexes do not tell you everything about a company. You may also want to consider the -following factors when shopping for insurance: - -Service — Some companies sell through local agents and some through direct marketing or group -plans. You may want to find out how the company services its policyholders. - -Licensing Status — Call the Consumer Assistance Hotline at 800-432-2484 to find out if a company -is licensed to do business in Kansas. - -Financial Stability — Financial stability helps ensure a company can pay its claims. The Department -enforces statutory requirements and monitors the financial stability of companies licensed and -operating in the state. - -page 3 - -insurance.kansas.gov You can check a company’s financial rating by contacting one of these organizations: - -MOODY’S INVESTOR SERVICES - -STANDARD & POOR’S -INSURANCE RATING SERVICES - -212-553-1653 - -www.moodys.com - -877-772-5436 - -www.standardandpoors.com - -A.M. BEST CO. - -www.ambest.com - -Cost — We publish easy-to-use booklets and shopper’s guides. Download them free from our website -at insurance.kansas.gov or call our office to get a free copy 800-432-2484. - -Free booklets & shopper’s guides -Auto Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Health Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Home and Renters Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Important - -Life, Annuities and Long-Term Care Shopper’s -Guide - -Medicare Supplement Shopper’s Guide - -To better understand the complaint process, you might want to review what type of complaint was -filed against the company you are looking at. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners -(NAIC) provides information by code about the complaint. - -Information is available at https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm - -Input the NAIC company code number found to the left of the company name in the complaint index -report and hit the enter key. Once the company is displayed, select “Click for Report Options.” Next, -select “Go to Complaint Code Report.” You will then choose a report based on the type of coverage, -reason for complaint, or disposition (final outcome). Finally, select Kansas under the “I want to see -complaints for:” drop down. Please note this report varies from the Kansas Insurance Department’s -Complaint Index as it only captures confirmed complaints, which are defined as: - -“A complaint in which the state department of insurance determines: - -a) The insurer, licensee, producer, or other regulated entity committed any violation of: - -1) An applicable state insurance law or regulation; - -2) A federal requirement that the state department of insurance has the authority to enforce; or - -3) The term/condition of an insurance policy or certificate; or - -b) The complaint and entity’s response, considered together, indicate that the entity was in error.” - -page 4 - -Complaint Index Report Indexes by line: Automobile - -Cocode - -Company Name - -33154 - -Alliance Indemnity Company - -42579 - -Allied Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -29688 - -Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company - -19232 - -Allstate Insurance Company - -10386 - -American Family Insurance Company - -19275 - -American Family Mutual Insurance Company - -13773 - -Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -21628 - -Farmers Insurance Company Incorporated - -13587 - -First Chicago Insurance Company - -14138 - -GEICO Advantage Insurance Company - -14139 - -GEICO Choice Insurance Company - -12966 - -Key Insurance Company - -23787 - -Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company - -16322 - -Progressive Direct Insurance Company - -42919 - -Progressive Northwestern Insurance Company - -25405 - -Safe Auto Insurance Company - -24740 - -Safeco Insurance Company Of America - -23388 - -Shelter Mutual Insurance Company - -19070 - -Standard Fire Insurance Company - -25178 - -State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company - -42749 - -Traders Insurance Company - -25941 - -United Services Automobile Association - -25968 - -USAA Casualty Insurance Company - -18600 - -USAA General Indemnity Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -0.99% - -1.22% - -4.63% - -0.28% - -4.27% - -6.12% - -6.79% - -4.40% - -0.15% - -3.13% - -1.94% - -0.81% - -1.31% - -6.59% - -8.15% - -0.22% - -1.84% - -3.24% - -3.39% - -16.23% - -1.18% - -2.08% - -1.60% - -1.42% - -81.99% - -2 - -4 - -42 - -10 - -10 - -21 - -20 - -21 - -16 - -23 - -10 - -16 - -4 - -59 - -49 - -12 - -9 - -17 - -11 - -74 - -20 - -9 - -7 - -5 - -0.33 - -0.53 - -1.48 - -5.86 - -0.38 - -0.56 - -0.48 - -0.78 - -17.66 - -1.20 - -0.84 - -3.22 - -0.50 - -1.46 - -0.98 - -8.87 - -0.80 - -0.86 - -0.53 - -0.75 - -2.76 - -0.71 - -0.71 - -0.58 - -0.17 - -0.93 - -1.06 - -0.55 - -0.86 - -0.82 - -0.31 - -0.60 - -6.40 - -1.27 - -1.79 - -3.68 - -0.82 - -0.84 - -0.70 - -7.53 - -0.86 - -0.57 - -0.50 - -0.84 - -1.98 - -0.96 - -0.94 - -1.48 - -- - -0.38 - -1.04 - -- - -0.76 - -0.64 - -0.64 - -1.29 - -- - -0.77 - -1.10 - -4.07 - -- - -1.10 - -0.73 - -- - -0.79 - -0.88 - -0.93 - -0.74 - -2.64 - -0.55 - -0.84 - -0.39 - -Indexes by line: Accident & Health - -Cocode - -Company Name - -12321 - -American Continental Insurance Company - -60380 - -American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus - -61263 - -Bankers Life & Casualty Company - -47171 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas City - -70729 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas Incorporated - -67369 - -Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company - -68500 - -Continental Life Insurance Company Brentwood - -62324 - -Freedom Life Insurance Company Of America - -64211 - -Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company - -73288 - -Humana Insurance Company - -12459 Medica Insurance Company - -71412 - -Mutual Of Omaha Insurance Company - -82538 - -National Health Insurance Company - -67091 - -Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company - -67326 - -Old Surety Life Insurance Company - -15777 - -Oscar Insurance Company - -68462 - -Reserve National Insurance Company - -14345 - -Sunflower State Health Plan Incorporated - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -72850 - -United World Life Insurance Company - -96385 - -UnitedHealthcare of Midwest Inc - -70319 Washington National Insurance Company - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -0.61% - -3.04% - -0.79% - -3.55% - -22.36% - -3.01% - -0.57% - -0.99% - -0.68% - -3.82% - -2.12% - -1.05% - -0.53% - -0.73% - -0.69% - -0.58% - -0.56% - -17.11% - -0.56% - -0.69% - -0.75% - -2.36% - -0.79% - -0 - -8 - -1 - -5 - -46 - -14 - -2 - -4 - -2 - -5 - -16 - -1 - -8 - -0 - -0 - -6 - -1 - -67 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -5 - -0.00 - -1.02 - -0.49 - -0.55 - -0.80 - -1.80 - -1.37 - -1.57 - -1.14 - -0.51 - -2.93 - -0.37 - -5.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -4.03 - -0.70 - -1.52 - -0.00 - -0.56 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -2.44 - -0.00 - -1.38 - -0.00 - -1.06 - -0.70 - -0.69 - -0.00 - -2.46 - -0.69 - -0.24 - -3.42 - -1.37 - -9.04 - -0.00 - -0.79 - -2.37 - -2.42 - -1.51 - -0.00 - -4.73 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -5.72 - -0.00 - -0.58 - -0.34 - -1.31 - -0.76 - -0.69 - -- - -- - -2.55 - -0.64 - -3.26 - -0.91 - -- - -- - -- - -- - -- - -1.72 - -- - -- - -0.00 - -0.00 - -3.27 - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -67.92% - -page 5 - -insurance.kansas.gov Indexes by line: Homeowners - -Cocode - -Company Name - -37907 - -Allstate Vehicle & Property Insurance Company - -19690 - -American Economy Insurance Company - -10386 - -American Family Insurance Company - -19275 - -American Family Mutual Insurance Company - -10872 - -American Strategic Insurance Corporation - -13773 - -Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -21652 - -Farmers Insurance Exchange - -26298 - -Farmers Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -20419 - -Homesite Indemnity Company - -14451 Marysville Mutual Insurance Company - -25453 - -Nationwide Insurance Company Of America - -23787 - -Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company - -24740 - -Safeco Insurance Company Of America - -23388 - -Shelter Mutual Insurance Company - -25143 - -State Farm Fire & Casualty Company - -27998 - -Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Company - -38130 - -Travelers Personal Insurance Company - -25941 - -United Services Automobile Association - -25968 - -USAA Casualty Insurance Company - -18600 - -USAA General Indemnity Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -4.36% - -1.47% - -4.98% - -8.70% - -1.35% - -6.25% - -4.85% - -1.22% - -1.41% - -1.20% - -1.70% - -2.10% - -1.70% - -2.48% - -21.08% - -3.42% - -4.39% - -2.61% - -1.39% - -1.23% - -77.89% - -21 - -2 - -13 - -14 - -6 - -13 - -7 - -3 - -5 - -4 - -3 - -1 - -7 - -5 - -78 - -9 - -10 - -2 - -3 - -6 - -1.63 - -0.46 - -0.89 - -0.55 - -1.51 - -0.70 - -0.49 - -0.83 - -1.20 - -1.13 - -0.60 - -0.16 - -1.39 - -0.68 - -1.25 - -0.89 - -0.77 - -0.26 - -0.73 - -1.65 - -0.86 - -- - -0.42 - -0.66 - -0.25 - -0.80 - -0.77 - -1.39 - -- - -1.14 - -- - -0.00 - -0.88 - -1.15 - -1.08 - -0.82 - -0.66 - -0.41 - -0.53 - -2.65 - -1.64 - -- - -1.10 - -0.75 - -0.86 - -0.81 - -1.36 - -0.00 - -- - -2.02 - -- - -- - -0.32 - -1.66 - -0.46 - -0.51 - -0.72 - -0.58 - -0.56 - -0.98 - -Indexes by line: Individual Annuity - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -Cocode - -Company Name - -90611 - -Allianz Life Insurance Company Of North America - -60488 - -American General Life Insurance Company - -61689 - -Athene Annuity & Life Company - -87726 - -Brighthouse Life Insurance Company - -62944 - -Equitable Financial Life Insurance Company - -63088 - -Farm Bureau Life Insurance Company - -63274 - -Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company - -91642 - -Forethought Life Insurance Company - -65056 - -Jackson National Life Insurance Company - -65676 - -Lincoln National Life Insurance Company - -66869 Nationwide Life Insurance Company - -91596 - -New York Life Insurance & Annuity Corporation - -66974 - -North American Company for Life & Health Insurance - -67466 - -Pacific Life Insurance Company - -86630 - -Prudential Annuity Life Assurance Corporation - -65005 - -RiverSource Life Insurance Company - -68675 - -Security Benefit Life Insurance Company - -62952 - -SILAC Insurance Company - -69345 - -Teachers Insurance & Annuity Association Of America - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -5.48% - -3.55% - -4.46% - -3.15% - -3.55% - -2.37% - -2.27% - -2.54% - -8.01% - -5.60% - -2.74% - -3.51% - -2.43% - -1.85% - -1.86% - -2.94% - -2.31% - -5.21% - -3.08% - -1.70% - -2 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -2 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1.18 - -0.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.27 - -0.81 - -0.58 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.40 - -0.62 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.77 - -2.35 - -0.00 - -2.24 - -1.34 - -7.38 - -0.00 - -1.23 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -0.00 - -0.53 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -68.62% - -1.15 - -1.72 - -1.93 - -- - -2.29 - -- - -1.12 - -0.77 - -- - -- - -- - -1.03 - -0.69 - -- - -- - -- - -0.84 - -- - -- - -- - -page 6 - -Complaint Index Report Indexes by line: Individual Life - -Cocode - -Company Name - -60399 - -American Family Life Insurance Company - -60488 - -American General Life Insurance Company - -63088 - -Farm Bureau Life Insurance Company - -65838 - -John Hancock Life Insurance Company USA - -58033 - -Knights Of Columbus - -65676 - -Lincoln National Life Insurance Company - -65935 Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company - -66044 Midland National Life Insurance Company - -91596 - -New York Life Insurance & Annuity Corporation - -66915 - -New York Life Insurance Company - -67091 - -Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company - -67466 - -Pacific Life Insurance Company - -67644 - -Penn Mutual Life Insurance Company - -65919 - -Primerica Life Insurance Company - -68136 - -Protective Life Insurance Company - -79227 - -Pruco Life Insurance Company - -68241 - -Prudential Insurance Company Of America - -69108 - -State Farm Life Insurance Company - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -69868 - -United Of Omaha Life Insurance Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -1.85% - -1.92% - -3.91% - -1.79% - -2.56% - -2.90% - -4.05% - -3.84% - -2.32% - -4.30% - -11.52% - -2.51% - -1.33% - -1.34% - -2.19% - -3.93% - -0.58% - -4.10% - -1.80% - -1.93% - -1.18% - -61.84% - -0 - -21 - -8 - -1 - -3 - -3 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -3 - -1 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -12 - -3 - -0 - -11 - -1 - -0.00 - -6.13 - -1.15 - -0.31 - -0.66 - -0.58 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.39 - -0.05 - -0.00 - -0.42 - -0.00 - -0.26 - -0.00 - -11.66 - -0.41 - -0.00 - -3.20 - -0.47 - -0.58 - -2.19 - -0.55 - -0.50 - -1.01 - -0.31 - -0.25 - -- - -0.00 - -0.38 - -0.24 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.58 - -2.09 - -0.14 - -- - -0.52 - -0.28 - -1.61 - -- - -0.49 - -3.76 - -0.34 - -0.00 - -0.35 - -0.27 - -0.13 - -- - -0.00 - -0.21 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.33 - -0.78 - -0.26 - -- - -0.21 - -0.25 - -2.69 - -- - -Indexes by line: Long-Term Care - -Cocode - -Company Name - -90611 - -Allianz Life Insurance Company Of North America - -61263 - -Bankers Life & Casualty Company - -70729 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas Incorporated - -20443 - -Continental Casualty Company - -71404 - -Continental General Insurance Company - -70025 - -Genworth Life Insurance Company - -64211 - -Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company - -65838 - -John Hancock Life Insurance Company USA - -58033 - -Knights Of Columbus - -65935 Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company - -65978 Metropolitan Life Insurance Company - -71412 - -Mutual Of Omaha Insurance Company - -66915 - -New York Life Insurance Company - -69000 Northwestern Long Term Care Insurance Company - -68241 - -Prudential Insurance Company Of America - -65005 - -RiverSource Life Insurance Company - -25178 - -State Farm Mutual Auto Insurance Company - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -62235 - -Unum Life Insurance Company Of America - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -2.16% - -9.45% - -2.07% - -3.02% - -1.66% - -17.08% - -3.41% - -9.49% - -3.07% - -1.40% - -4.92% - -4.61% - -3.06% - -6.03% - -2.44% - -1.47% - -3.00% - -2.38% - -4.61% - -3.00% - -9 - -6 - -2 - -4 - -0 - -15 - -1 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -3 - -0 - -3 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -7 - -2 - -5.63 - -0.86 - -1.30 - -1.79 - -0.00 - -1.19 - -0.40 - -0.14 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.27 - -0.00 - -1.33 - -0.00 - -1.66 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -2.05 - -0.90 - -2.42 - -0.64 - -0.34 - -3.35 - -1.35 - -1.24 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -1.86 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.07 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -3.21 - -0.00 - -1.78 - -0.76 - -0.82 - -0.81 - -0.73 - -0.32 - -- - -0.14 - -- - -- - -1.15 - -0.94 - -- - -0.23 - -- - -- - -0.81 - -- - -6.39 - -- - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -88.33% - -page 7 - -insurance.kansas.gov Filing a Complaint -The Kansas Insurance Department’s Consumer Assistance Division provides free help to consumers. -Trained representatives can answer questions about your coverage or assist when you have a dispute -with your insurance company. - -How to file a complaint - -If you have tried unsuccessfully to resolve a problem with your insurance company or agent, we -encourage you to contact the insurance department. You may file a complaint online through our -website, by mail or email. We also accept complaints in-person. - -If you do need to file a formal complaint, we require the following information: - -• Your name - -• Your address - -• Your email address (if applicable) - -• The policy number - -• A clear, concise written explanation of your -complaint — this can be sent by postal mail, -fax, or filed through our website - -• Your daytime telephone number - -• Copies of supporting letters, police reports, - -• Type of insurance involved (automobile, - -homeowners, etc.) - -• The name of the insurance company, agent - -or adjuster - -notes, etc. - -• Tell us what has been done, including who -you’ve talked to and what you were told -(names, dates, times, places, etc.) - -• Desired outcome - -Do not send originals of any of your records, and keep a copy of the letter you send us. - -Contact the Kansas Insurance Department - -WEBSITE - -insurance.kansas.gov - -SOCIAL - -KSinsurancedept - -EMAIL - -kid.commissioner@ks.gov -kid.webcomplaints@ks.gov - -ADDRESS - -1300 SW Arrowhead Rd. -Topeka, KS 66604 - -PHONE - -Main: 785-296-3071 -Fax: 785-296-7805 - -CONSUMER ASSISTANCE -HOTLINE - -800-432-2484 - -page 8 - -Complaint Index Report 1300 SW ARROWHEAD ROAD -TOPEKA, KS 66604 -1-800-432-2484 -(785) 296-3071 - -INSURANCE.KANSAS.GOV -KID.COMMISSIONER@KS.GOV -(785) 296-7805 (FAX) -1-877-235-3151 (TTY/TDD) - -Vicki Schmidt, Commissioner -insurance.kansas.gov - -page 9 - -insurance.kansas.gov \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k4/question.json b/q7/random_k4/question.json index 3deb545c069b2b802a74bffc7a727cb15c46b409..28728763225a16bc1f4b3a4b638f8424a54a5604 100644 --- a/q7/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q7/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "ddoseattle-150627210357-lva1-app6891_95.pdf", - "web_9942a44c5f6232cc.pdf", - "web_ab28fbcd92cfea3d.pdf", - "web_ab2f104fb9b1c2fe.pdf", - "web_35322004c9a15402.pdf" + "web_9fc7805ab9a7b343.pdf", + "88d4b9368dcf48f2b3e788da0a5f10e87e5a3361.pdf", + "web_f3420c2dcb7612a6.pdf", + "web_d4c9f0dc3f6589cc.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k4/random_1.md b/q7/random_k4/random_1.md index 6748665a7c835db276023c66e67f49b0fa9cb861..7fe6906e671eb6becf1e5bf27211c9c0f26d8c0a 100644 --- a/q7/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q7/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,493 +1,1546 @@ -WHITE PAPER - -In-Store -Shopper -Engagement -Built for the -Future of Retail - - There is an opportunity to -reinvent the moment of truth … - -is your store -ready? - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Introduction - -Now that the offline market is reopening, -it is time for retail brands to upgrade their -brick-and-mortar stores and deliver a -smart retail experience for customers. - -Gartner1 - -Retail Industry Drivers Impacting the In-Store -Experience - -• Consumers have returned to retail stores. And they aren’t just ready to get back to in- -person shopping, they have also accelerated their adoption of new technologies and -expect similar levels of digital technology and content in the physical store as they do in -the digital world. - -• After reporting the results of a recent consumer survey, Gartner concluded, “To maximize -the ROI on digital and capitalize on consumers’ interests in hands-free technology and -physical stores, retail brands should pursue a smart retail strategy and offer an -immersive omnichannel experience for their customers.”1 - -• That’s why in this white paper, we’ll dive into the trends that are impacting the need for a -more content-driven consumer experience, explore what’s possible in the store, and the -business benefits of creating a more memorable shopper journey with 6 ways to stand -out from the crowd. - -3 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Consumers are Craving More Content, Recipes -and Deals -Analysis by Insider Intelligence, reports that retail sales are anticipated to grow between -4% and 5% each year through 2025. That’s a projection to hit $31.3 trillion in sales.2 - -Brick-and-Mortar vs. eCommerce Sales in US for 2021 - -) -s -n -o - -i -l -l -i - -M -$ -( - -l - -s -e -a -S - -Y -o -Y -e -g -n -a -h -C -% - -Q2 -2018 - -Q3 -2018 - -Q4 -2018 - -Q1 -2019 - -Q2 -2019 - -Q3 -2019 - -Q4 -2019 - -Q1 -2020 - -Q2 -2020 - -Q3 -2020 - -Q4 -2020 - -Q1 -2021 - -Q2 -2021 - -Q3 -2021 - -Q4 -2021 - -B&M YoY Growth - -E-commerce YoY Growth - -E-commerce - -Brick & Mortar - -Source: US Dept of Commerce, Economic Indicators Division, Retail Indicator Branch -Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail Sales (Not Adjusted): Brick & Mortar and E- - -Brick and mortar vs. E-Commerce Sales US Department of Commerce Retail Indicators Division - -More US consumers are switching brands and retailers now than -in 2020 and 2021, and about 90 percent plan to continue doing so. - -Shopped a different brand recently, -% of respondents - -Shopped a different retailer/store/ -website recently, % of respondents - -+13 percentage -points - -+9 percentage -points - -~90% of consumers -who have switched -brands or retailers -plan to incorporate -these new behaviors -into their routines - -Sep-20 -Source: McKinsey COVID-19 US Consumer Pulse Surveys: Feb 25 – Mar 1, 2022, n = 2,160; Oct 9-15, 2021, n = 2.095; Sept 18-24, 2020, n = -1,026; sampled and weighted to math the US general population aged 18 years and older - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Oct-21 Feb-22 - -Sep-20 - -4 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -That said, historically, consumers would get their Sunday -newspapers for coupons in order to get the best deals in -stores. Then, there became a hybrid of clipping coupons -along with digital apps or digital coupons for consumers to -get better offers. Today, and especially coming out of a -post-pandemic world, the in-store experience is even more -digital — with the decline of print newspapers, the shift to -online shopping and the consumer desire for a contactless -checkout experience. - -What’s more, grocers are relying on connected recipes as a -tool to drive Q4 spending. Walmart offers its “Cookshop” -interactive content portal, which currently presents -consumers with shoppable recipes and activities. Online -tutorials made in partnership with major brands like Kraft -or Starbucks, embed “shop your ingredients” buttons and -other shopping list features.6 - -So, retailers need to find the best way to make content, -recipes and deals easily consumable by consumers. In fact, -“When consumers visit an offline store, it is no longer to -simply buy something. Creating an interesting and -immersive experience that online shopping can not rival is -one of the keys to drive foot traffic,” according to Gartner.1 - -92% - -of grocery shoppers used -coupons or deals when shopping. - -60% - -of grocery shoppers said they -planned their shopping trip -based on which stores offer the -best deals. - -51% - -of grocery shoppers said they -used mobile apps to find deals -before going to the grocery store. - -Adoption of the Smart Cart at the ‘Moment -of Truth’ - -• With some of the aforementioned drivers impacting the way consumers are spending, -coupled with inflation and the supply chain bottlenecks still catching up post-COVID – -consumers are looking for deals more than ever right now, and are willing to take on new -technology to do so. - -• As such, the smart cart is becoming more prevalent in retail stores, but operational issues -typically get in the way of success. Cart costs are high (upwards of $250 million), especially -when they involve weigh scales and cameras to make them ‘smart.’ These carts come with -maintenance overhead, can be too small, and don’t stack or nest conveniently. - -• And let’s not forget that long lines during checkout leave retailers open to more shrink - -issues, and consumers open to better technology to solve their payment woes. - -• This leaves retailers with substantial investments in smart cart technology, but low or no - -adoption in stores. - -• However, there is an opportunity for retailers to present these shoppers with relevant -deals (combined with their loyalty information) right in the store aisles for the ideal in- -store experience — and as an added bonus — contactless checkout. - -5 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -EXPLORE WHAT’S POSSIBLE - -While the shopping cart hasn’t seen many innovations over the years - -retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never happened - -before by adding a touchscreen right to the cart. - -Not only can it present valuable and relevant information to shoppers on how to -get the best deals and ideas for new items or recipes to try — it can also show -shoppers how to locate those products right in store aisles. - -This is being done every day on social media, but being able to access this content -right on a cart without relying on a personal device connects the channels in a way -that satisfies the future shopper. - -Especially in a world where shoppers are still using their smartphones to conduct -research before heading into the store, adding a mobile and connected -touchscreen is a game-changer for retailers. - -Gartner reports that 95% of retailers are saying they plan to increase their -investments in digital capabilities in 2022.1 - -This means that your competitors are also boosting their technologies to enhance -their brand’s in-store and online shopping experiences with the goal to offer a -cohesive omnichannel experience that is immersive and personalized. - -Brands would be able to reach shoppers in an even more relevant way and be able -to direct them right to their product in the store aisles as they shop (right at the -precise ‘moment of truth.’ The items they need would always be top of mind, and -CPGs can easily connect the ROI back to their ad spend because that anonymized -data would be captured right into the connected screen. - -And, as shoppers look for specific products, they can come across - -personalized ads from brands or even push a recipe or coupon to - -inspire a new or spontaneous purchase (also creating more - -valuable loyalty data for retailers and their CPG suppliers). - -6 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Did You Know? - -Sylvan Goldman -owner of the grocery chains -Piggly Wiggly and Humpty- -Dumpty. - -What: Goldman invented the shopping cart, arguably the most important innovation in retail -stores even today. - -Where: Oklahoma City - -When: 1937 - -Why: Groceries were getting heavier products (like canned goods), and more refrigerated -items, and were still using hand baskets to carry them. - -How: Goldman enlisted the help of his handyman Fred Young. The two grabbed a few -supplies and spent a night coming up with a prototype of a rolling grocery basket. - -The Result? Shoppers rejected it … at first. Men were offended by it saying it made them -seem weak for not being able to carry groceries in their hands, and women compared it to -pushing a baby stroller. But, with some advertising efforts, the innovation took off, -increasing basket sizes and improving the shopper experience. - -7 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Business Benefits of Being Memorable - -Creating a truly memorable shopping experience has many business - -benefits, especially when leveraging technology to support it. Adding - -a connected screen, there are many positive implications for - -retailers, brands, and shoppers alike. Consider this: - -81% - -59% - -73% - -35% - -of retail shoppers conduct online research before buying. (Source: GE Capital -Retail Bank). With a connected screen, there’s no need for research prior to a -shopping trip meaning more accurate trips, fewer forgotten items, and no -need for a personal device (plus, more time well spent in the store). - -of shoppers use their mobile devices in-store to compare costs or research -deals and coupons. (Source: HRC Retail Advisory). Knowing a connected -screen is right on the shopping cart means no relying on my mobile device in -the store. - -of retail consumers use multiple channels to shop. To gain a unified -consumer view, marketers must connect all of their channels (Source: -Harvard Business Review). A connected screen allows for recipes, social -content, influencers, etc., to join a shopping trip creating a unified -experience. - -of marketers say poor data quality impacts their ability to target consumers -with the right digital ads. (Source: Forrester). Connected screens provide a -wealth of new data and insights right from the store shelves where the -business benefits spill over to digital advertising channels. - -84% - -of consumers believe retailers should be doing more to integrate their online -and offline channels. (Source: RetailNext). A connected screen would bring -both together into one memorable customer experience. - -40% - -of consumers purchase more from retailers that provide a personalized -shopping experience across channels. Improving the shopper experience will -have a direct impact on your bottom line (Source: RetailNext). The connected -screen converges personalization into brick-and-mortar. - -8 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -6 Ways to Stand Out from the Competition -While many media outlets will continue to talk about the acceleration of digital, retailers are -leaning into the physical store to drive loyalty within their customer experiences, as well as -differentiate themselves from their competition. Shoppers prefer to see, feel and even try -products in the store before making a purchase, so the opportunity for innovation lies -within the brick-and-mortar channel. - -Perhaps Gartner sums it up best, “Retail is experiencing unprecedented change driven by -consumer behaviors, enabled by technology and accelerated by a pandemic.”7 - -Getting started on a business process change or improvement like creating or revamping -your customer experience can be a daunting task. As such, here we have gathered 6 best -practices to help get your store ready for the future of retail (and a more memorable in- -store experience). - -Consumers want deals, but they want relevant deals. Combining loyalty -information about that consumer, plus where they are in the store gives retailers -the ability to drive information that is highly pertinent relative to that consumer. - -Leverage real-time data and insights to act on consumer trends more quickly, -keeping popular products in front of shoppers while they’re in high demand.8 Use -this new stream of data (i.e. heat maps) to understand consumer behavior in the -store (where they stopped, why, how long they stayed, what the interaction was) -and share that with your suppliers. - -Use technology to play a distinct and purposeful role to enhance customer -engagement and loyalty. Be sure it also supports your overall brand purpose.9 -Consumers don’t want to use different apps. Think about the development of your -apps and how you can seamlessly work them into the store environment. - -Create opportunities for speed and convenience (i.e. fast, contactless and -seamless checkout).9 Regardless of size, retailers must focus on checkout, -especially as the rise of contactless or self-service checkout is on the rise. - -Combine shrink avoidance technology, principles and methods — and embed -those right into your carts. - -Use shopping cart-based screens to present circulars to consumers at the moment -when it is most useful - as they enter that aisle where the products are on -promotion. FMI—The Food Industry Association (FMI) said in a report in 2022 that -55% of surveyed retailers found print circulars very effective and also noted that -widely used digital circulars and promotions sent by text are not as effective as -more traditional outreach methods.10 - -9 - - In-Store Shopper Engagement Built for the Future of Retail - -Many times when retailers are ready to implement a new solution or service, they can be -inundated by a ‘rip and replace’ mentality, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Start with small -wins and continue to evolve and enhance as you go with each iteration. Many providers -today can stand up their technologies in a matter of days and weeks so retailers can start -hitting their KPIs immediately and then continue to improve. - -“Even as consumers continue their return to stores, the digital behaviors they’ve picked up -during the pandemic will stick for the long term,” according to Retail Dive.9 “Brands and -retailers that win in the coming years will embrace digital innovation and find more -thoughtful and authentic ways to blend digital and physical engagement.” - -Now, retailers can engage with shoppers in a way that has never been done before – -present valuable information on how to get the best deals, how to locate products and ideas -for new items or recipes to try. This has never been accomplished in a store environment, -but the future of retail is here. - -Shopper Engagement Platform for the Physical -Store Powered by Veeve -Veeve's vision is to create a content delivery and checkout platform that utilizes the -retailers' own Apps to improve the shopper experience and increase the basket size -through in-store, location-driven promotions, advertising, and more. Veeve is delivered by a -Connected Screen: a purpose-built device that brings the power of online shopping, sensor -fusion, and computer vision to physical stores. - -The Connected Screen - -What’s on sale -today? - -Where can I find -salsa? - -Deals & -Coupons - -Location -Tracking - -What’s for -dinner? - -Video -Recipes - -Can I skip -checkout? - -Pay on -Cart - -Visit https://veeve.io/ to learn more. - -Source 1. Gartner, “Time To Prepare Smart Retail For The Post-Pandemic Era” by Wilson Zhao 2. Insider Intelligence, “Global Ecommerce -Forecast” 3. Mastercard SpendingPulse, “Mastercard SpendingPulse Forecasts 7.5%* Growth for U.S. Back-to-School Retail Sales” -4. McKinsey, “How US consumers are feeling, shopping, and spending—and what it means for companies” 5. Inmar Intelligence, “New -Inmar Intelligence Survey Reveals Over Half of Today’s Shoppers Have Switched Loyalty to Less Expensive Grocery Brands Since Start of -Pandemic” 6. PYMNTS, “Grocers See Connected Recipes as Tool to Drive Q4 Spending” 7. Gartner, “Digital Transformation in Retail” -8. Retail Dive, “Retail tech is elevating CX unlocking efficiencies” 9. Retail Dive, “3 pillars driving the future of store experience” -10. FMI The Food Retailing Industry Speaks 2022 - -1 -0 - +CIRCULAR NO. A–11 +PART 7 +PLANNING, BUDGETING, +ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT +OF CAPITAL ASSETS +| E | | O | | P | +| -------- | ---- | --------- | --- | ------------ | +| xEcutivE | | fficE | Of | thE rEsidEnt | +| O | M | | | B | +| fficE | Of | anagEMEnt | | and udgEt | +J 2008 +unE + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF +CAPITAL ASSETS +Table of Contents +300.1 What is the purpose of the section? +300.2 Does the section apply to me? +300.3 What background information must I know? +300.4 What special terms should I know? +300.5 How will agencies manage capital assets? +300.6 What other requirements does exhibit 300 fulfill? +300.7 What must I report on exhibit 300 and when? +300.8 How will OMB use the exhibit 300s? +Ex–300 Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary +Summary of Changes +Updates requirement to identify certification levels via the Federal Acquisition Certification for +Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) (section 300.4) (Ex 300, Part I, Sec A. 11). +Clarifies the distinction between funding contributions and reimbursements (section 300.4). +Updates requirements for performance-based acquisitions (section 300.4). +Clarifies requirements for a multi-agency collaboration exhibit 300 (section 300.7). +Updates PARTed program identification with selectable options (Ex 300, Part I, Sec A. 14b). +Changes to questions for section 508 compliance and acquisition plan status (Ex 300, Part I, Sec +C). +Changes to questions for alternative analysis for breakeven and Federal quantitative benefits (Ex +300 Part II, Sec A and Ex 300 Part IV, Sec A) +Adds table for Federal quantitative benefits for all investment required to complete PART II (Ex +300 Part II, Sec A). +Clarifies that fee-for-service reimbursements for shared service providers are to be included in +Partner Funding Strategies Table (Ex 300 Part IV, Sec A. 3). +300.1 What is the purpose of the section? +Part 7 (section 300) of the Circular establishes policy for planning, budgeting, acquisition and +management of Federal capital assets, and instructs you on budget justification and reporting +requirements for major information technology (IT) investments and for major non IT capital assets. +OMB provides procedural and analytic guidelines for implementing specific aspects of these policies as +appendices and supplements to this Circular and in other OMB circulars. For IT, section 300 is a +companion section to section 53. +For non IT capital assets contact your Resource Management Offices (RMOs) at OMB to determine if +any additional budget justification and reporting requirements in addition to those outlined here. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 1 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +300.2 Does the section apply to me? +The policy and budget justification and reporting requirements in this section apply to all agencies of the +Executive Branch of the Government subject to Executive Branch review (see section 25). An exhibit +300 must be submitted for all major investments in accordance with this section. Major IT investments +also must be reported on your agency’s exhibit 53 (see section 53) and be consistent with what is reported +in section 51.3. +300.3 What background information must I know? +The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public +resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition and management +of capital assets into the budget decision-making process, and is intended to assist agencies in improving +asset management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of: +(cid:129) +The Energy Policy Act of 2005, Section 109, which requires that sustainable design principles are +applied to the siting, design and construction of all new and replacement buildings and that new +federal buildings be designed to achieve energy consumption levels that are at least 30 percent +below the levels established in the 2004 International Energy Conservation Code for residential +buildings or the ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2004 for non-residential buildings, if life-cycle cost- +effective. +(cid:129) +The Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994, Title V (FASA V), which requires agencies to +establish cost, schedule and measurable performance goals for all major acquisition programs, and +achieve on average 90 percent of those goals. +Additional background information for Information Technology can be found in section 53.2. +300.4 What special terms should I know? +Capital assets means land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and information +technology (including IT service contracts) used by the Federal Government and having an estimated +useful life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more +complete definition of capital assets. +Capital programming means an integrated process within an agency for planning, budgeting, +procurement and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve agency strategic goals +and objectives with the lowest life-cycle cost and least risk. +Capital project (investment) means the acquisition of a capital asset and the management of that asset +through its life-cycle after the initial acquisition. Capital projects (investments) may consist of several +useful segments. +Contracting officer certification means the highest current level of certification in contracting obtained +by the contracting officer (CO) assigned to the acquisition. For defense agencies, indicate the CO’s +highest level of Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) certification in contracting. +For civilian agencies, indicate the CO’s highest level of Federal Acquisition Certification in Contracting +(FAC-C), in accordance with OMB memorandum, The Federal Acquisition Certification in Contracting +Program, dated January 20, 2006. Available levels are 1, 2, or 3. To address the transition period, if the +CO has not obtained a FAC-C, the agency must determine that the CO assigned to the effort has the +competencies and skills necessary to support the acquisition. +Cost saving represents the reduction in actual expenditures below the projected level of costs to achieve a +specific objective (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). +Page 2 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Cost avoidance represents results from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease +costs in the future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131). +Earned value management (EVM) is a project (investment) management tool effectively integrating the +investment scope of work with schedule and cost elements for optimum investment planning and control. +The qualities and operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in +American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard –748–1998, +Earned Value Management Systems, approved May 19, 1998. It was reaffirmed on August 28, 2002. +Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/pm. +Energy Savings Performance Contract (ESPC) means a contract (such as a task ordered by DOE and +awarded to an energy service company) that provides for the performance of services for the design, +acquisition, financing, installation, testing, operation, and maintenance and repair, of an identified energy, +water conservation, or renewable energy measure or series of measures at one or more locations. Such +contracts shall provide that the contractor must incur costs of implementing energy savings measures, +including at least the cost (if any) incurred in making energy audits, acquiring and installing equipment, +and training personnel in exchange for a predetermined share of the value of the energy savings directly +resulting from implementation of such measures during the term of the contract. Payment to the +contractor is contingent upon realizing a guaranteed stream of future energy and cost savings, with any +savings in excess of that guaranteed by the contractor accruing to the Federal government +Enhanced Use Leasing (EUL): Departments with specific statutory authority can require rent in the +form of a reduction in the cost or free use of facilities or services for programs, monetary payments, or +other in-kind consideration which enhances mission activity. The authority allows an agency to out-lease +property and receive payment in cash or in kind (goods or services that result in direct cost savings to the +government) from the lessee in exchange for the out-lease. +Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) was established to +ensure general training and experience requirements for program and project managers are clearly +identified for civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for program +and project managers; the program does not include functional or technical competencies, such as those +for information technology, or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar +certification program under the Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA). Agencies +must be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available levels are Entry/Apprentice, +Mid/Journeyman and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2 and 3 for DAWIA. +(www.whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf) +(www.whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf) +Full funding means appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete a useful segment (see +definition below) of a capital project (investment) before any obligations may be incurred for the +segment. Incrementally funding capital projects (investments) or useful segments without certainty if or +when future funding will be available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets +acquisition, higher acquisition costs, project (investment) delays, cancellation of major projects +(investments), the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate the assets. Budget +requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see section 31.5). +Interagency acquisition means the use of the Federal Supply Schedules, a multi-agency contract (i.e., a +task order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by government agencies to obtain +supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535), or a government-wide +acquisition contract (i.e., a task-order or delivery-order contract for information technology established +by one agency for government-wide use operated by an executive agent designated by OMB pursuant to +section 11302(3) of the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996). +Life-cycle costs (see Supplement to Part 7—Capital Programming Guide). +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 3 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Major investment means a system or acquisition requiring special management attention because of its +importance to the mission or function of the agency, a component of the agency or another organization; +is for financial management and obligates more than $500,000 annually; has significant program or policy +implications; has high executive visibility; has high development, operating, or maintenance costs; is +funded through other than direct appropriations; or is defined as major by the agency’s capital planning +and investment control process. OMB may work with the agency to declare other investments as major +investments. You should consult with your OMB representative about what investments to consider as +"major," consult your agency budget officer or OMB representative. Systems not considered "major" are +"non-major." +Mixed life-cycle investment means an investment having both development/modernization/enhancement +(DME) and steady state components. For example, a mixed life-cycle investment could include a +prototype or module of a system that is operational with the remainder of the system in DME stages; or, a +service contract for steady state on the current system with a DME requirement for system upgrade or +replacement. +Multi-Agency Collaboration investments means a set of systems or acquisitions requiring the efforts of +more than one agency (multiple sub-agency efforts should not be identified as "Mult-Agency"). All E- +Gov initiatives and Line of Business (LoB) initiatives are by definition Multi-Agency efforts. Due to the +multi-agency impact, Multi-Agency Collaboration investments such as E-Gov and LoB initiatives are also +by definition Major Investments and High-Risk Investments. +Operational (steady state) means an asset or a part of an asset with a delivered component performing the +mission. +Partner Agency funding contributions (contributions) represent both the direct contribution (Cash +contribution) in terms of agency funding contributions in support of the initiative and "In-Kind" +contributions, i.e., the dollar equivalent of services contributed by the partner agency in support of the +initiative (non-cash contribution), including Partner agency support in equipment, facilities, software, +license fees, and dollar equivalent of FTEs. Migration costs should not be included, as these activities are +more appropriately coordinated with the managing partner and covered by a migration investment. +Partner Agency “fee-for-service” contributions represents the direct reimbursements (Cash +reimbursements) in terms of a “fee-for-service” relationship for a transactional service received by the +initiative or reimbursements for capital assets under the oversight of the initiative. +Performance-based acquisition management means a documented, systematic process for program +management, which includes integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, establishment of +a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and use of earned value techniques for +performance measurement during execution of the program. EVMS is required for those parts of the +investment where developmental effort is required. This includes prototypes and tests to select the most +cost effective alternative during the Planning Phase, the work during the Acquisition Phase, and any +developmental, modification or upgrade work done during the Operational/Steady State Phase. EVMS is +to be applied to both Government and contractor efforts and regardless of contract type. For +operational/steady state systems, an operational analysis as discussed in Phase IV of the Capital +Programming Guide is required. A performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition +Regulation 37.101) or contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance +standards/measures should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase. +Information on this requirement can be found in OMB Memorandum 05-23, Improving Information +Technology (IT) Project Planning and Execution. +Plan of Action and Milestone As defined in OMB Memorandum 02-01, a plan of action and milestones +(POA&M), also referred to as a corrective action plan, is a tool that identifies tasks that need to be +accomplished. It details resources required to accomplish the elements of the plan, any milestones in +Page 4 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +meeting the task, and scheduled completion dates for the milestones. The purpose of the POA&M is to +assist agencies in identifying, assessing, prioritizing, and monitoring the progress of corrective efforts for +security weaknesses found in programs and systems. +Planning means preparing, developing or acquiring the information you will use to: design the +investment; assess the benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted life-cycle costs of alternative solutions; and +establish realistic cost, schedule, and performance goals, for the selected alternative, before either +proceeding to full acquisition of the capital project (investment) or useful segment or terminating the +investment. Planning must progress to the point where you are ready to commit to achieving specific +goals for the completion of the acquisition before preceding to the acquisition phase. Information +gathering activities may include market research of available solutions, architectural drawings, geological +studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes. Planning is a useful segment of a capital project +(investment). Depending on the nature of the investment, one or more planning segments may be +necessary. +During the planning phase, when contemplating a performance-based acquisition, agency program offices +should evaluate their service requirement and determine: +(cid:129) +Whether a performance-related baseline problem exists (cost, quality, timeliness, impact to agency +mission); +(cid:129) +The level of risk associated with the service not being optimally provided (importance to mission +of the service being provided optimally); +(cid:129) +The level of confidence the agency has in its own " performance work statement or statement of +objectives document" to solve the baseline problem; +(cid:129) +The amount of risk the agency wants to assume for managing the service impact on its own versus +shifting to a vendor; and +(cid:129) +The readiness of the program to measure the impact of the service on its program performance +goals/mission, as well as the readiness of Program staff to participate in the PBA process. +Risk adjusted life-cycle costs means the overall estimated cost for a particular investment alternative over +the time period corresponding to the life of the investment, including direct and indirect initial costs plus +any periodic or continuing costs of operation and maintenance that has been adjusted to accommodate any +risk identified in the risk management plans. If project funding is to be requested for specific phases, +segments or modules of the project, each of these parts will be risk adjusted for their individual life-cycle. +Total Value of Contract/Task Order means the current total value of the Contract or Task Order to +acquire and operate the capital asset. For contracts/task orders shared by multiple capital assets, please +provide only the current total value associated with the identified capital asset. +Useful segment/module means an economically and programmatically separate component of a capital +investment that provides a measurable performance outcome for which the benefits exceed the costs, even +if no further funding is appropriated. +Utility Energy Service Contract (UESC) is a contract between a Federal agency and a local utility +providing energy, water, or sewage services, as well as provision of technical services and/or upfront +project financing for energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy investments, allowing +Federal agencies to pay for the services over time, either on their utility bill, or through a separate +agreement. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 5 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in Appendix J, "Principles of +Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions” and in section 53 (for IT). +300.5 How will agencies manage capital assets? +The Capital Programming Guide, which supplements Part 7 of OMB Circular A-11, provides guidance +on the principles and techniques for effective capital programming. Appendix J of this part explains the +principles of financing capital asset acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A–130 establishes +additional requirements for enterprise architectures (EAs), planning and control of information systems +and technology investments and performance management. Agencies must develop, implement, and use +a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio, and must: +(cid:129) +Evaluate and select capital asset investments that will support core mission functions performed +by the Federal Government, and demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal +to or better than alternative uses of available public resources; +(cid:129) +Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative +private sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need; +(cid:129) +Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and make +maximum use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology; +(cid:129) +Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom designed components, using components that +can be fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring +involvement and support of users in the design and testing of the asset; +(cid:129) +Structure major acquisitions into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration, make +adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between Government and contractor. +The Agency Head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major +acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the proposed cost goals; +(cid:129) +Ensure consistency with Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency +through compliance with agency business requirements and standards, as well as identification of +milestones, as defined in the EA transition strategy; +(cid:129) +Institute performance measures and management processes monitoring and comparing actual +performance to planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management +or earned value management system, based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748, to obtain timely +information regarding the progress of capital investments. The system must also measure progress +towards milestones in an independently verifiable basis, in terms of cost, capability of the +investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality. Agencies are expected to +achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule and performance goals for major +acquisitions. Agency Heads must review major acquisitions not achieving 90 percent of the goals +to determine whether there is a continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, +should be taken; +(cid:129) +Ensure IT systems conform to the requirements of OMB Circular No. A–130, "Management of +Federal Information Resources;" +(cid:129) +Ensure financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB Circular No. A–127, +"Financial Management Systems;" +Page 6 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +(cid:129) +Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition +processes, and projects to validate estimated benefits and costs, and document effective +management practices, i.e., lessons learned, for broader use; and +(cid:129) +Establish oversight mechanisms requiring periodic review of operational capital assets to +determine how mission requirements might have changed, and whether the asset continues to +fulfill ongoing and anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and +customers, and meet user requirements. +300.6 What other requirements does exhibit 300 fulfill? +The Exhibit 300 is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to the +Congress required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA Title V) and the Clinger- +Cohen Act of 1996; to ensure the business case for investments are made and tied to the mission +statements, long-term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the +GPRA. For IT, exhibit 300s are designed to be used as one-stop documents for many of IT management +issues such as business cases for investments, IT security reporting, Clinger Cohen Act implementation, +E-Gov Act implementation, Government Paperwork Elimination Act implementation, agency’s +modernization efforts, and overall project (investment) management. +300.7 What must I report on exhibit 300 and when? +It is important to understand, all information necessary to complete an exhibit 300 already exists as part +of the agency's overall Information Resources Management activities and within project specific +documentation. The materials used to populate the exhibit 300 should be readily available to OMB upon +request. +The exhibit 300 must be submitted along with any other agency budget submissions (see section 25.5) to, +OMB by September 8, 2008. The exhibit 300 should be fully integrated with your agency’s overall +budget submission. For the next President's Budget, all reporting on IT must be submitted via OMB’s IT +Budget Submissions System (https://max.omb.gov/itweb/itweb). Agencies can either manually enter their +exhibit 300 data into this system or upload files in XML format. All exhibit 300s and exhibit 53 (see +section 53) must be electronically submitted from the OMB IT Budget Submissions System. Additional +information regarding the submission process will be posted on www.egov.gov. For capital projects +(investments) other than IT, agencies are encouraged to submit the exhibit 300 electronically, following +the same instructions provided above. +Following budget season, agencies should update their agency’s exhibit 300s submitted during budget +submission to reflect final Presidential decisions. In addition, this update should ensure that only +publicly-releasable information is contained in the updated exhibit 300. While it is important to maintain +this publicly-releasable exhibit 300, agencies should continuously maintain updated information about the +projects contained in the exhibit 300. OMB may request this information at any time. +Agencies are required to post on their agency website, within 2 weeks of the release of the President’s +Budget, these updated exhibits reflecting final Presidential decisions (see section 22.6). If you have any +questions about what should be included in the version posted to your website, please contact your agency +budget and FOIA offices. You may also contact your OMB representative. As a reminder, these products +should be included in your Information Dissemination Product Inventories, Priorities, and Schedules. +(More information about this can be found in OMB M-05-04, Policies for Federal Agency Public +Websites). +If agencies request supplemental funds, which include changes to the agency's portfolio, as part of their +supplemental request, agencies should submit new or revised exhibit 300s and exhibit 53 (see section 53). +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 7 of Section 300 + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +The information you must report will depend on the kind of investment the exhibit 300 is representing +(see Part I Section A - Question #6). +New Investments +If you are reporting a new investment (i.e., proposed for BY or later) you must complete Parts I and II. +Investments in initial concept or planning phase will have less detail and specificity than investments +moving into the acquisition or operational phase. However, these investments should identify in life-cycle +documentation the dates these issues will be addressed as the investment matures. Where prototypes are +acquired as part of the planning process, the prototypes must be reported as full acquisitions. All of the +areas on the exhibit 300 must be part of an agency's planning, and the exhibit 300 should be updated as +soon as the information is known. +Ongoing Investments +If reporting an ongoing investment other than IT, only update sections as appropriate. If any of the cost, +schedule or performance variances are not within 10 percent of the current baseline, provide a complete +analysis of the reasons for the variances, the corrective actions to be taken, and the most likely estimate at +completion (EAC). Use the EVM system to identify the specific work packages where problems are +occurring. Discuss why the problems occurred and corrective actions necessary to return the program as +close as feasible to the current baseline goals. +Security for Planned as well as Operational Systems +Questions contained in Part I-Section E, “Security and Privacy” should be answered at the individual +system level. Multiple contractor or agency systems may support or be part of the overall investment. +Planned systems listed in Table 3, as well as operational systems listed in Table 4, should be included in +the privacy table (Part I-Section E-Table 8). Security and privacy planning must proceed in parallel with +the development of the system(s) to ensure IT security and privacy requirements and costs are identified +and incorporated into the overall lifecycle of the system(s). +For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement is planned, include the investment in both +the “Systems in Planning” table (Table 3) and the “Operational Systems” table (Table 4). In this context, +information contained within Table 3 should characterize what updates to testing and documentation will +occur before implementing the enhancements; and Table 4 should characterize the current, valid testing +and documentation associated with the existing system. +Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments +The managing partner (lead agency) will take the lead for completing the multi-agency exhibit 300, +managing it through the lead agency's capital programming and budget process and submitting the exhibit +300 to OMB. The managing partner is also responsible for ensuring this exhibit 300 includes all +necessary information from the partner agencies and has been approved by all necessary partner agencies +through the appropriate governance process. The multi-agency exhibit 300 should include partner agency +funding, related capital assets (e.g. migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, +Supporting components), and milestones in Part IV of the exhibit 300. The managing partner +Executive/Investment Committee should review and approve the multi-agency exhibit 300. +Partner agencies should report their participation in their exhibit 53 submissions as appropriate (see +section 53). Partner agencies should reference the name of the multi-agency exhibit 300 in the +"Investment Description" field of each exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency exhibit 300. +Partner agencies should also ensure their activities and participation are included in the appropriate +sections of the multi-agency exhibit 300. The managing partner will include only the managing partner +specific funds in their exhibit 53 submission(s), while the entire Summary of Spending Total for the +investment, including funds provided by partner agency, should be included in the exhibit 300. +Page 8 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +SECTION 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF CAPITAL ASSETS +OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency exhibit 300. +When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate the requests. +Multi-Agency Collaboration supporting components capital assets +Partner agency's supporting capital assets (e.g., Service Providers, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service +Centers, Supporting components) should be submitted as regular agency capital assets using exhibit 300s. +Agencies proposing capital assets to support multi-agency initiatives should share their proposals with the +managing partner for review. Proposals recommended as part of the Managing Partner's solution should +be included in the Managing Partner's exhibit 300 (Part IV-Section A, Question #2). An agency with a +recommended capital asset proposal should submit an exhibit 300 using the appropriate kind of exhibit +300 (as defined in Part I-Section A, Question #6). Partner agencies with or proposing supporting capital +assets for multi-agency collaboration (i.e. shared service centers, sales center, shared service providers, +etc.) should use Part IV of the exhibit 300. +For Cost and Schedule Performance baseline changes +All proposed changes to baselines should be submitted to OMB prior to your FY 2010 budget request; +proposed changes should not be assumed approved. If your agency has any questions, please contact +your OMB representative. All current approved baselines should be reflected in the exhibit 300. +300.8 How will OMB use the exhibit 300s? +The exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total performance budget justification (see section +51.2). OMB uses the exhibit 300 to make both quantitative decisions about budgetary resources +consistent with the Administration’s program priorities, and qualitative assessments about whether the +agency’s programming processes are consistent with OMB policy and guidance. OMB will be evaluating +all elements of the business cases and will communicate the results of these evaluations in the course of +the budget process. If additional supporting information is necessary, OMB will request from agencies +the supporting evidence used to produce the exhibit 300. All information necessary to complete an +exhibit 300 should already exist as part of the agency's overall Information Resources Management +activities and within project specific documentation. The materials used to produce the exhibit 300 +should be readily available to OMB upon request. +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 9 of Section 300 + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Exhibit 300: Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary +Part I: Summary Information And Justification (All Capital Assets) + +| | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets) +| | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1. Date of Submission: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 2. Agency: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 3. Bureau: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +| 4. Name of this Capital Asset: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +5. Unique Project (Investment) Identifier: +(For IT investment only, see section 53. For +all other, use agency ID system.) + +6. What kind of investment will this be in FY 2010? + (Please NOTE: Investments moving to O&M in FY 2010, with Planning/Acquisition activities prior to +FY 2010 should not select O&M. These investments should indicate their current status.) +| | | | | | | Planning | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | Full Acquisition | | | +| | | | | Operations and Maintenance | | | | +| | | | | | Mixed Life Cycle | | | +| | | | | Multi-Agency Collaboration | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +7. What was the first budget year this investment was submitted to + +OMB? +| | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------ | ------------------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 8. Provide | a brief summary | and justification | for | this investment, | | | | +including a brief description of how this closes in part or in whole an +| identified agency performance gap: | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | | +| 9. Did | the Agency’s Executive/Investment | | Committee | approve | this | | | +| request? | | | | | | Yes | No | + a. If “yes,” what was the date of this approval? +| | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| 10. Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| | | | | | | | | +11. Contact information of Program/Project Manager? +Name +Phone Number +E-mail +| a. | What is the current | FAC-P/PM | (for civilian | agencies) | or | | | +| ------------------------- | ----------------------- | ---------- | --------------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DAWIA | (for defense | agencies) | certification | level | of the | | | +| program/project manager? | | | | | | | | + +b. When was the Program/Project Manager Assigned? _______________________________ +| Page 10 of Section 300 | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +c. What date did the Program/Project Manager receive the FAC- +P/PM certification? If the certification has not been issued, what is +| the anticipated date for certification? | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +12. Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost effective, energy- +efficient and environmentally sustainable techniques or practices for +| this project? | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +a. Will this investment include electronic assets (including +| computers)? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +b. Is this investment for new construction or major retrofit of a +Federal building or facility? (answer applicable to non-IT assets +| only) | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +1. If “yes,” is an ESPC or UESC being used to help fund this +| investment? | | | | | Yes | No | +| --------------- | ----------------------- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | --- | +| 2. If “yes,” | will this investment | meet | sustainable | design | | | +| principles? | | | | | Yes | No | +3. If “yes,” is it designed to be 30% more energy efficient than +| relevant code? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | +13. Does this investment directly support any of the PMA initiatives? If "yes," check all that apply: +| | | | | Human Capital | | | +| --- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | Budget Performance Integration | | | | +| | | | | Financial Performance | | | +| | | | | Expanded E-Government | | | +| | | | | Competitive Sourcing | | | +| | | | Faith Based and Community | | | | +| | | | Real Property Asset Management | | | | +| | | | Eliminating Improper Payments | | | | +| | | | Privatization of Military Housing | | | | +| | | Research & Development Investment Criteria | | | | | +| | Housing & Urban Development Management & Performance | | | | | | +| | Broadening Health Insurance Coverage through State Initiatives | | | | | | +| | | | “Right Sized” Overseas Presence | | | | +| | | Coordination of VA & DoD Programs and Systems | | | | | +| | | | | | | | +a. Briefly and specifically describe for each selected how this asset +| directly supports | the identified | initiative(s)? | (e.g. If | E-Gov is | | | +| ------------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +selected, is it an approved shared service provider or the managing +partner?) +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +14. Does this investment support a program assessed using the Program +Assessment Rating Tool (PART)? (For more information about the +| PART, visit www.whitehouse.gov/omb/part.) | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +a. If "yes," does this investment address a weakness found during a +| PART review? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +b. If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed program? +c. If "yes," what rating did the PART receive? + +| | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 11 of Section 300 | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +15. Is this investment for information technology? Yes No +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +If the answer to Question 15 is “Yes,” complete questions 16-23 below. If the answer is “No,” do not answer +questions 16-23. + +For information technology investments only: +16. What is the level of the IT Project? (per CIO Council PM Guidance) +| | | | | | | | Level 1 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Level 2 | | +| | | | | | | | Level 3 | | + +17. In addition to the answer in 11(a), what project management qualifications does the Project Manager have? +(per CIO Council PM Guidance) +(1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this investment +(2) Project manager qualification is under review for this investment +(3) Project manager assigned to investment, but does not meet requirements +(4) Project manager assigned but qualification status review has not yet started +(5) No Project manager has yet been assigned to this investment +| | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ----------- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 18. Is this | investment | or any | project(s) | within this | investment | | | | +identified as “high risk” on the Q4-FY 2008 agency high risk report +| (per OMB Memorandum M-05-23) | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| 19. Is this a financial management system? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +a. If “yes,” does this investment address a FFMIA compliance area? +| | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +1. If “yes,” which compliance area: +| | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | ------------- | --------- | ------------ | ------------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| 2. If “no,” what does it address? | | | | | | | | | +| b. If “yes,” | please | identify | the system | name(s) | and system | | | | +| acronym(s) | as reported | in | the most | recent financial | systems | | | | +| inventory update required by Circular A–11 section 52 | | | | | | | | | + +20. What is the percentage breakout for the total FY 2010 funding request for the following? + (This should total 100%) +| | | | | | | Hardware | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Software | | | +Services + +Other + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +21. If this project produces information dissemination products for the public, are +these products published to the Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum +05-04 and included in your agency inventory, schedules and priorities? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | | No | | +| | | | | | | | N/A | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| Page 12 of Section 300 | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +22. Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related +| questions: | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Name +Phone Number +Title +E-mail +| | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ------------------ | --------------------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| 23. Are the | records produced | by this investment | appropriately | | | | +scheduled with the National Archives and Records Administration’s +| approval? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| | | | | | | | +Question 24 must be answered by all Investments: +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +24. Does this investment directly support one of the GAO High Risk +| Areas? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 13 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Section B: Summary of Spending (All Capital Assets) + +1. Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table. All amounts +represent budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places. Federal personnel costs should be +included only in the row designated “Government FTE Cost,” and should be excluded from the amounts shown +for “Planning,” “Full Acquisition,” and “Operation/Maintenance.” The “TOTAL” estimated annual cost of the +investment is the sum of costs for “Planning,” “Full Acquisition,” and “Operation/Maintenance.” For Federal +buildings and facilities, life-cycle costs should include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or +restoration costs. The costs associated with the entire life-cycle of the investment should be included in this +report. + +Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES +(REPORTED IN MILLIONS) +(Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not represent budget decisions) +| | | PY–1 | | | | | | | BY+4 | +| --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | +| | | | PY | CY | BY | BY+1 | BY+2 | BY+3 | | +| | | and | | | | | | | and Total | +| | | | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | | +| | | earlier | | | | | | | beyond | +Planning: +| | | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Acquisition : | | | | | | | | | | +Subtotal Planning & +| Acquisition: | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Operations & +| Maintenance: | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| TOTAL: | | | | | | | | | | +Government FTE Costs should not be included in the amounts provided above. +| Government FTE Costs | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Number of FTE +| represented by Costs: | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Note: For the multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner and partner +agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL represented. + +2. Will this project require the agency to hire additional FTE’s? +| | | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --------- | ------------- | ----- | ---- | -------- | --- | ----------------------------- | -------- | +| a. If “yes,” How many and in what year? | | | | | | | | | | +| 3. If the summary | of | spending | has changed | from | the | FY 2009 | | | | +| President’s Budget request, briefly explain those changes: | | | | | | | | | | +| Page 14 of Section 300 | | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets) + +1. Complete the table for all (including all non-Federal) contracts and/or task orders currently in place or planned +for this investment. Total Value should include all option years for each contract. Contracts and/or task orders +completed do not need to be included. + +Contracts/Task Orders Table: + ecnadrocca nI( redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo epyT ,ton fI ?drawa eht fo etad eht si tahw os fI )N/Y( si noitpo gnicnanif evitanretla ,yna fi ,tahW deriuqer AIWAD OC eht denimreted ycnega eht sah ,A/N fI slliks + )N/Y( ?noitisiuqca siht troppus ot yrassecen + )liame/enohp( noitamrofni tcatnoC OC + )N/Y( dedrawa neeb tcartnoc eht saH ?noitisiuqcA )A/N ,LUE ,CSEU ,CPSE( ?desu gnieb )A/N ,3 ,2 ,1 leveL( leveL noitacifitreC dna +| | | redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo etad tratS | | | | eht | | ro | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | + redrO ksaT/tcartnoC fo etad dnE )N/Y( ?sesualc ycavirp & ytiruces seicnetepmoc +| rebmuN redrO ksaT ro tcartnoC | | ?etad drawa dennalp eht si tahw | | )N/Y( ?desab ecnamrofrep ti sI | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + C-CAF +| | | | | | )N/Y( ?dedrawa ylevititepmoC | )N/Y( ?tcartnoc eht ni MVE sI edulcni | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | + /tcartnoC fo eulaV latoT + ycnegaretnI + reciffO + tcartnoc + )61 traP RAF htiw eht + )M$( redrO ksaT + sah +| | | | | | | | OC fo emaN | gnitcartnoC | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | + na + eht + dengissa + siht + seoD + sI + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| 2. If earned value is not required or will not | | | | be a contract requirement | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +| for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +3. Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | No | | +| | | | | | | | N/A | | +a. Explain why not or how this is being done? + +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | +4. Is there an acquisition plan which reflects the requirements of FAR +| Subpart 7.1 | and | has been | approved | in accordance | with agency | | | | +| --------------- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| requirements? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +a. If “yes,” what is the date? + +| 1. Is it Current? | | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +| b. If “no,” will an acquisition plan be developed? | | | | | | | | | +| 1. If “no,” briefly explain why: | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | Page 15 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets) + +In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the agency +and be linked to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency’s mission and strategic +goals, and performance measures (indicators) must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the +agency's strategic goals and objectives this investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external +performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60 percent, +increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall citizen participation rate of 75 percent by +FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if applicable, investment +outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or general goals, such +as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative measure. + +Agencies must use the following table to report performance goals and measures for the major investment and use +the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Map all Measurement +Indicators to the corresponding "Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM. There +should be at least one Measurement Indicator for each of the four different Measurement Areas (for each fiscal +year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov. The table can be extended to include performance measures for +years beyond the next President's Budget. + +Performance Information Table +Strategic +| Fiscal | Measurement | Measureme | Measurement | | | Actual | +| -------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------------ | --------- | ------- | ------- | +| Goal(s) | | | | Baseline | Target | | +| Year | Area | nt Grouping | Indicator | | | Results | +Supported +| | Mission & | | | | | | +| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2008 +Business Results +| | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 2008 | Customer Results | | | | | | +| | Processes & | | | | | | +2008 +Activities +| 2008 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | + Mission & +2009 +Business Results +| | Customer | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2009 +Results +| | Processes & | | | | | | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2009 +Activities +| 2009 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Mission & | | | | | | +2010 +Business Results +| | Customer | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2010 +Results +| | Processes & | | | | | | +| --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2010 +Activities +| 2010 | Technology | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| Etc. | Etc. | | | | | | + +| Page 16 of Section 300 | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 +Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets only) +In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the +system/application level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning +and operational systems security tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the +Operational Security Table must be included on your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily +referenced in the inventory (i.e., should use the same name or identifier). +For existing Mixed-Life Cycle investments where enhancement, development, and/or modernization is planned, +include the investment in both the “Systems in Planning” table (Table 3) and the “Operational Systems” table +(Table 4). Systems which are already operational, but have enhancement, development, and/or modernization +activity, should be included in both Table 3 and Table 4. Table 3 should reflect the planned date for the system +changes to be complete and operational, and the planned date for the associated C&A update. Table 4 should +reflect the current status of the requirements listed. In this context, information contained within Table 3 should +characterize what updates to testing and documentation will occur before implementing the enhancements; and +Table 4 should characterize the current state of the materials associated with the existing system. +All systems listed in the two security tables should be identified in the privacy table. The list of systems in the +“Name of System” column of the privacy table (Table 8) should match the systems listed in columns titled “Name +of System” in the security tables (Tables 3 and 4). For the Privacy table, it is possible that there may not be a one- +to-one ratio between the list of systems and the related privacy documents. For example, one PIA could cover +multiple systems. If this is the case, a working link to the PIA may be listed in column (d) of the privacy table +more than once (for each system covered by the PIA). +The questions asking whether there is a PIA which covers the system and whether a SORN is required for the +system are discrete from the narrative fields. The narrative column provides an opportunity for free text +explanation why a working link is not provided. For example, a SORN may be required for the system, but the +system is not yet operational. In this circumstance, answer “yes” for column (e) and in the narrative in column (f), +explain that because the system is not operational the SORN is not yet required to be published. +Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions: +1. Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified and +integrated into the overall costs of the investment?: Yes No +a. If “yes,” provide the “Percentage IT Security” for the budget year: +2. Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part of the +overall risk management effort for each system supporting or part of +this investment?. Yes No +3. Systems in Planning and Undergoing Enhancement(s), Development, and/or +Modernization – Security Table(s): +Date of Planned certification and +Agency/ or accreditation (C&A) update (for +Name of Planned Operational +Contractor existing mixed life cycle systems) +System Date +Operated System? or Planned Completion Date (for +new systems) +OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) Page 17 of Section 300 + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +4. Operational Systems – Security Table: +What +standards +| | | | NIST FIPS | | Has C&A | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----------- | ------------- | ---------- | --------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | +| | | | | | | | were used for | | Date | | +| | Agency/ or | | 199 Risk | | been | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Date | the Security | Completed: | | Date the | +| N a m e of | C | o n tr a c to | r Imp | ac t l e v el | C o m p le te | d , Completed: | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Controls | | Security | contingency | +| S y st e m | O | p e r a te d | (H | i g h , | us i ng N I S | T | | | | | +| | | | | | | C&A | tests?” (FIPS | | Control | plan tested | +| | System? | | Moderate, | | 800-37? | | | | | | +200/NIST +| | | | Low) | | (Y/N) | | | | Testing | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +800-53, +Other, N/A) +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +5. Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of the +systems part of or supporting this investment been identified by the +| agency or IG? | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | ------ | +| a. | If “yes,” | have | those | weaknesses | been | incorporated | into the | | | | +agency’s plan of action and milestone process? Yes No +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +6. Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is requested to +| remediate IT security weaknesses? | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” specify the amount, provide a general description of the +weakness, and explain how the funding request will remediate the +| weakness. | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | +7. How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and +| validated by the agency for the contractor systems above? | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +8. Planning & Operational Systems – Privacy Table: +| | | | | (c) Is there at least | | | (e) Is a System of | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | +| | | | | one Privacy Impact | | (d) Internet | Records Notice | | | | +| (a) Name of | | (b) Is this a new | | | | | | | (f) Internet Link or | | +| | | | | Assessment (PIA) | | Link or | (SORN) required | | | | +| System | | system? (Y/N) | | | | | | | Explanation | | +| | | | | which covers this | | Explanation | for this system? | | | | +| | | | | system? (Y/N) | | | (Y/N) | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Details for Text Options: +Column (d): If yes to (c), provide the link(s) to the publicly posted PIA(s) with which this system is associated. If no to +(c), provide an explanation why the PIA has not been publicly posted or why the PIA has not been conducted. + +Column (f): If yes to (e), provide the link(s) to where the current and up to date SORN(s) is published in the federal +register. If no to (e), provide an explanation why the SORN has not been published or why there isn’t a current and up to +date SORN. + +Note: Working links must be provided to specific documents not general privacy websites. Non-working links will be +considered as a blank field. + +| Page 18 of Section 300 | | | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets only) + +In order to successfully address this area of the capital asset plan and business case, the investment must be +included in the agency’s EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC) process and mapped to and +supporting the FEA. The business case must demonstrate the relationship between the investment and the +business, performance, data, services, application, and technology layers of the agency’s EA. + +| 1. Is | this investment | | included | | in your | agency’s | target | enterprise | | | | | +| -------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | +| architecture? | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| | a. If “no,” please explain why? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +2. Is this investment included in the agency’s EA Transition Strategy? +| | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| --- | --------------- | -------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | +| | a. If “yes,” | provide | | the investment | | name | as identified | in the | | | | | +Transition Strategy provided in the agency’s most recent annual +| | EA Assessment. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | b. If “no,” please explain why? | | | | | | | | | | | | + +3. Is this investment identified in a completed and approved segment +| architecture? | | | | | | | | | | Yes | No | | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- | +a. If “yes,” provide the six digit code corresponding to the agency +| | segment | architecture. | | The | segment | | architecture | codes are | | | | | +| --- | ----------- | -------------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | maintained | | by the | agency | Chief | Architect. | | For detailed | | | | | +guidance regarding segment architecture codes, please refer to +http://www.egov.gov. +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +4. Service Component Reference Model (SRM) Table : +Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge management, content management, +customer relationship management, etc.). Provide this information in the format of the following table. For detailed +guidance regarding components, please refer to http://www.egov.gov. +Service Component +Agency Agency FEA SRM FEA SRM Reused (b) Internal or BY Funding +Component Component Service Component External Percentage +Component +| | Name | Description | | | Type | | (a) | | | Reuse? (c) | | (d) | +| --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | +UPI +Name +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as “NEW”. A “NEW” component is one not already identified +as a service component in the FEA SRM. +b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this investment. Rather +than answer yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other investment and identify +the other investment using the Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 +submission. +c. ‘Internal’ reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a service +component provided by another agency within the same department. ‘External’ reuse is one agency within a +department reusing a service component provided by another agency in another department. A good +example of this is an E-Gov initiative service being reused by multiple organizations across the federal +government. +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | | Page 19 of Section 300 | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service component listed +in the table. If external, provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount transferred to another +agency to pay for the service. The percentages in this column can, but are not required to, add up to 100%. + +5. Technical Reference Model (TRM) Table: +To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model (TRM), please +list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and Service Specifications supporting this IT investment. +Service Specification (b) +| FEA SRM | | | FEA TRM Service | FEA TRM | | +| -------------- | --------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------- | -------------------------- | +| | FEA TRM Service Area | | | | (i.e., vendor and product | +| Component (a) | | | Category | Service Standard | | +name) +| | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | +| | | | | | | +| | | | | | | + +a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please enter +multiple rows for FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications +b. In the Service Specification field, agencies should provide information on the specified technical standard +or vendor product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version numbers, as +appropriate. + +| 6. Will the | application | leverage | existing components | and/or | | +| -------------- | ------------ | --------- | --------------------- | ------- | --- | +applications across the Government (i.e., USA.gov, Pay.Gov, etc)? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” please describe. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| Page 20 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Part II: Planning, Acquisition And Performance Information + +Part II should be completed only for investments identified as “Planning” or “Full Acquisition,” or “Mixed +Life-Cycle” investments in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. + +Section A: Alternatives Analysis (All Capital Assets) +In selecting the best capital asset, you should identify and consider at least three viable alternatives, in addition to +the current baseline, i.e., the status quo. Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments and the Clinger Cohen Act +of 1996 for IT investments to determine the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. + +1. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this investment? +| | | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” provide the date the analysis was completed? + +| | b. If “no,” | what | is | the anticipated | | date | this | analysis will be | | | | +| --- | -------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +completed? +c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: + +2. Alternatives Analysis Results: +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Alternative Risk Adjusted Lifecycle Risk Adjusted Lifecycle +Description of Alternative +| | Analyzed | | | | | | | Costs estimate | | Benefits estimate | | +| --------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | +| Baseline | | Status quo | | | | | | | | | | +| 1 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 2 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3. | Which | alternative | | was | selected | | by | the Agency’s | | | | +Executive/Investment Committee and why was it chosen? +| | a. What | year | will | the | investment | breakeven? | | (Specifically, | | | | +| --- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +when the budgeted costs savings exceed the cumulative costs.) +4. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +5. Federal Quantitative Benefits ($millions): +What specific quantitative benefits will be realized (using current dollars) +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: + Budgeted Cost Justification for Budgeted Justification for Budgeted +| | | | Cost Savings | | Avoidance | | | Cost Savings | | Cost Avoidance | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| PY-1 & prior | | | | | | | | | | | | +| PY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| CY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY+1 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| B BY+2 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +BY+3 +| BY+4 & Beyond | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| Total LCC Benefit | | | | | | | LLC = Life-cycle cost | | | | | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | Page 21 of Section 300 | | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +6. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part or in- +| whole? | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +a. If “yes,” are the migration costs associated with the migration to +| the selected | alternative | included | in this investment, | the legacy | | | +| -------------- | ------------ | --------- | ---------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +investment, or in a separate migration investment? + +b. If “yes,” please provide the following information: + +5b. List of Legacy Investment or Systems +| | Name of the Legacy | | | | Date of the System | | +| --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | +UPI if available +| | Investment of Systems | | | | Retirement | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +Page 22 of Section 300 OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) + +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? +| | | | | | | Yes | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? + +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | + +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Briefly describe how investment risks are reflected in the life cycle +| cost estimate and investment schedule: | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should +still be included in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should +accurately reflect the milestones in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. + +| 1. Does | the earned value | management | system meet | the criteria | in | | | +| ------------------------- | ------------------- | ----------- | ------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| ANSI/EIA Standard – 748? | | | | | | Yes | No | +| | | | | | | | | +2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than ± 10%? +| (CV%= CV/EV x 100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) | | | | | | Yes | No | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| a. If “yes,” was it the? | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | CV | | +| | | | | | | SV | | +| | | | | | | Both | | +| b. If “yes,” explain the causes of the variance: | | | | | | | | +| c. If “yes,” describe the corrective actions: | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | +3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” when was it approved by the agency head? | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | Page 23 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline: +Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial +performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline and +actual completion dates (e.g., “03/23/2003”/ “04/28/2004”) and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). In the +event that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note that the +‘Description of Milestone’ and ‘Percent Complete’ fields are required. Indicate ‘0’ for any milestone no longer active. +Current +| | Initial Baseline | | Current Baseline | | Baseline | | +| --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --------- | --- | +Variance +| | Planned | | Completion | | | | +| --------------- | ------------- | ------------ | --------------- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | +| | | Total Cost | | Total Cost | | | +| Description of | Completion | | Date | | Schedule:Cost | Percent | +| | | ($M) | | ($M) | | | +| Milestone | Date | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | (# days:$M) | Complete | +| | | Estimated | | Planned:Actual | | | +| | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | Planned:Actual | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| Page 24 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Part III: For “Operation and Maintenance” investments ONLY (Steady State) + +Part III should be completed only for investments identified as “Operation and Maintenance” (Steady State) in +response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. + +Section A: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +| c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | | | | + +Section B: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +1. Was an operational analysis conducted? +| | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” provide the date the analysis was completed. + +| b. If “yes,” what were the results? | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +c. If “no,” please explain why it was not conducted and if there +| are any plans to conduct an operational analysis in the future: | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | +2. Complete the following table to compare actual cost performance against the planned cost performance +baseline. Milestones reported may include specific individual scheduled preventative and predictable +corrective maintenance activities, or may be the total of planned annual operation and maintenance efforts). +| a. What costs | are | included | in the reported | Cost/Schedule | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | ------------ | --------- | ------------------ | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Performance | information | | (Government | Only/Contractor | | | | | | +| Only/Both)? | | | | | | | | | | + +2. b Comparison of Plan vs. Actual Performance Table: +| | | Planned | | | Actual | | | | Variance | +| ------------------------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | +| Description of | | Completion | | Completion | | | | | | +| | | | Total Cost | | | Total Cost | | | Schedule:Cost | +| Milestone | | Date | | Date | | | | | | +| | | | ($M) | | | ($M) | | | (# days:$M) | +| | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | Page 25 of Section 300 | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +Part IV: Planning For “Multi-Agency Collaboration” ONLY + +Part IV should be completed only for investments identified as an E-Gov initiative, an Line of Business (LOB) +Initiative, or a Multi-Agency Collaboration effort. The “Multi-Agency Collaboration” choice should be select +in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above. Investments identified as “Multi-Agency Collaboration” +will complete only Parts I and IV of the exhibit 300. + +Section A: Multi-Agency Collaboration Oversight (All Capital Assets) +Multi-agency Collaborations, such as E-Gov and LOB initiatives, should develop a joint exhibit 300. + +1. Stakeholder Table: +| | As a | joint exhibit | 300, please identify | all | the agency | stakeholders | (all | | +| --- | ------ | --------------- | ----------------------- | ---- | ------------ | ------------- | ----- | --- | +participating agencies, this should not be limited to agencies with financial +commitment). All agency stakeholders should be listed regardless of approval. +If the partner agency has approved this joint exhibit 300 please provide the date +of approval. +| | | Partner Agency | | Joint exhibit approval date | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +2. Partner Capital Assets within this Investment: +Provide the partnering strategies you are implementing with the participating agencies and organizations. +Identify all partner agency capital assets (including shared service providers) supporting the common solution +(section 300.7); Managing Partner capital assets should also be included in this joint exhibit 300. These capital +assets should be included in the Summary of Spending table of Part I, Section B. All partner agency migration +investments (section 53.4) should also be included in this table. Funding contributions/fee-for-service transfers +should not be included in this table.(Partner Agency UPIs should also appear on the Partner Agency's exhibit 53) +Partner Agency Partner Agency Asset Title Partner Agency Exhibit 53 UPI (BY 2010) +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +3. Partner Funding Strategies ($millions): +For jointly funded initiative activities, provide in the “Partner Funding Strategies Table”: the name(s) of partner +agencies; the UPI of the partner agency investments; and the partner agency contributions for CY and BY. Please +indicate partner contribution amounts (in-kind contributions should also be included in this amount) and fee-for-service +amounts. (Partner Agency Asset UPIs should also appear on the Partner Agency's exhibit 53. All fee-for-service +reimbursements for Shared Service Providers should be included in this table. For non-IT fee-for-service amounts the +Partner exhibit 53 UPI can be left blank) (IT migration investments should not be included in this table) +| Partner | Partner exhibit 53 UPI | | CY | | CY | BY | | BY | +| -------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Agency (BY 2010) Contribution Fee-for-Service Contribution Fee-for-Service +| | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | + +| Page 26 of Section 300 | | | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +An Alternatives Analysis for multi-agency collaborations should also be obtained. At least three viable +alternatives, in addition to the current baseline (i.e., the status quo), should be included in the joint exhibit 300. +Use OMB Circular A-94 for all investments, and the Clinger Cohen Act of 1996 for IT investments, to determine +the criteria you should use in your Benefit/Cost Analysis. + +4. Did you conduct an alternatives analysis for this investment? Yes No +| | a. If “yes,” what is the date of the analysis? | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | ----- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | b. If “no,” | what | is | the anticipated | | date | this analysis | will be | | | | +| | completed? | | | | | | | | | | | +| | c. If no analysis is planned, please briefly explain why: | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +5. Alternatives Analysis Results: +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Alternative Risk Adjusted Lifecycle Risk Adjusted Lifecycle +Description of Alternative +| | Analyzed | | | | | | | Costs estimate | | Benefits estimate | | +| --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | +| Baseline | | Status quo | | | | | | | | | | +| 1 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 2 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| 3 - | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +6. Which alternative was selected by the Initiative Governance process +| and why was it chosen? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --------- | ----- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | a. What | year | will | the | investment | breakeven? | | (Specifically, | | | | +when the budgeted costs savings exceed the cumulative costs.) +7. What specific qualitative benefits will be realized? + +8. Federal Quantitative Benefits ($millions): +What specific quantitative benefits will be realized (using current dollars) +Use the results of your alternatives analysis to complete the following table: +Budgeted Cost Justification for Budgeted Justification for Budgeted + +| | | | Cost Savings | | | Avoidance | | Cost Savings | | Cost Avoidance | | +| ------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | +| PY-1 & prior | | | | | | | | | | | | +| PY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| CY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY | | | | | | | | | | | | +| BY+1 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| B BY+2 | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +BY+3 +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +BY+4 & Beyond +| Total LCC Benefit | | | | | | | LLC = Life-cycle cost | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +9. Will the selected alternative replace a legacy system in-part or in- +| whole? | | | | | | | | | Yes | | No | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------ | +a. If “yes,” are the migration costs associated with the migration to +| | the selected | alternative | | included | | in this investment, | | the legacy | | | | +| --- | -------------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +investment, or in a separate migration investment? + +| | b. If “yes,” please provide the following information: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | | | | | | Page 27 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | + +EXHIBIT 300 CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY + +9b. List of Legacy Investment or Systems +| | Name of the Legacy | | | Date of the System | | | +| --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | +UPI if available +| | Investment of Systems | | | Retirement | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | + +Section B: Risk Management (All Capital Assets) + +You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of this +investment’s life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to eliminate, mitigate or +manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment’s life-cycle. + +1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the date of the plan? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since +| last year’s submission to OMB? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +c. If “yes,” describe any significant changes: + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” what is the planned completion date? | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| b. If “no,” what is the strategy for managing the risks? | | | | | | | + +Section C: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets) + +You should also periodically be measuring the performance of operational assets against the baseline established +during the planning or full acquisition phase (i.e., operational analysis), and be properly operating and +maintaining the asset to maximize its useful life. Operational analysis may identify the need to redesign or +modify an asset by identifying previously undetected faults in design, construction, or installation/integration, +highlighting whether actual operation and maintenance costs vary significantly from budgeted costs, or +documenting that the asset is failing to meet program requirements. + +EVM is required only on DME portions of investments. For mixed lifecycle investments, O&M milestones should +still be included in the table (Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline). This table should +accurately reflect the milestones in the initial baseline, as well as milestones in the current baseline. + +Answer the following questions about the status of this investment. Include information on all appropriate capital +assets supporting this investment except for assets in which the performance information is reported in a separate +exhibit 300. + +| 1. Are you using EVM to manage this investment? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | +| | | | | | Yes | | +No + +| | | N/A (investment with ONLY O&M) | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +a. If “yes,” does the earned value management system meet the +| criteria in ANSI/EIA Standard – 748? | | | | | Yes | No | +| ---------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------ | +| b. If “no,” explain plans to implement EVM: | | | | | | | +| c. If “N/A,” | please provide | date operational | analysis was | | | | +| conducted and a brief summary of the results: | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | +| Page 28 of Section 300 | | | | | OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | + +CAPITAL ASSET PLAN AND BUSINESS CASE SUMMARY EXHIBIT 300 + +Questions #2 are NOT applicable for capital assets with ONLY O&M + +2. Is the CV% or SV% greater than ± 10%? +| (CV%= CV/EV x 100; SV%= SV/PV x 100) | | | | | Yes | No | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | +| a. If “yes,” was it the? | | | | | | | +| | | | | | CV | | +| | | | | | SV | | +| | | | | | Both | | +b. If “yes,” explain the causes of the variance: + +| c. If “yes,” describe the corrective actions: | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | +Questions #3-4 are applicable to ALL capital assets + +3. Has the investment re-baselined during the past fiscal year? Yes No +| a. If “yes,” when was it approved by the agency head? | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +4. Comparison of Initial Baseline and Current Approved Baseline: +Complete the following table to compare actual performance against the current performance baseline and to the initial +performance baseline. In the Current Baseline section, for all milestones listed, you should provide both the baseline +and actual completion dates (e.g., “03/23/2003”/ “04/28/2004”) and the baseline and actual total costs (in $ Millions). +In the event that a milestone is not found in both the initial and current baseline, leave the associated cells blank. Note +that the ‘Description of Milestone’ and ‘Percent Complete’ fields are required. Indicate ‘0’ for any milestone no longer +active. +Current +| | Initial Baseline | | Current Baseline | | Baseline | | +| --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --------- | --- | + elbisnopseR + etelpmoC ytivitcA rof +| | | | | | Variance | tnecreP ycnegA | +| ------------- | ------------- | ------------ | --------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | +| | Planned | | Completion | Total Cost | | | +| | | Total Cost | | | Schedule: | | +| Description | Completion | | Date | ($M) | | | +| | | ($M) | | | Cost | | +| of Milestone | Date | | (mm/dd/yyyy) | Planned: | | | +| | | Estimated | | | (# days:$M) | | +| | (mm/dd/yyyy) | | Planned:Actual | Actual | | | +| | | | | | | | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | + +| OMB Circular No. A–11 (2008) | | | | | | Page 29 of Section 300 | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k4/random_2.md b/q7/random_k4/random_2.md index 5dac85680ad1e5631acf8a091a98a42ab0400813..79e21abdb756067a9ff62b132f72f6d1dcaeb4b8 100644 --- a/q7/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q7/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,2417 +1,261 @@ -COMPLAINT INDEX -REPORT FOR YEAR 2021 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Vicki Schmidt, Commissioner -insurance.kansas.gov +## BEYOND THE ANSWER: DECODING THE BEHAVIOR OF LLMS AS SCIENTIFIC REASONERS - Table of Contents +**Rohan Pandey** _[∗]_ **Eric Ye** _[∗]_ University of Washington _{_ rpande, ericy4 _}_ @uw.edu -About this Report +**Michael Li** _[∗]_ -Indexes by line: Automobile | Accident & Health +Carnegie Mellon University ml7@andrew.cmu.edu -Indexes by line: Homeowners | Individual Annuity +## ABSTRACT -Indexes by line: Individual Life | Long-Term Care +As Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve increasingly sophisticated performance on complex reasoning tasks, current architectures serve as critical proxies for the internal heuristics of frontier models. Characterizing emergent reasoning is vital for long-term interpretability and safety. Furthermore, understanding how prompting modulates these processes is essential, as natural language will likely be the primary interface for interacting with AGI systems. In this work, we use a custom variant of Genetic Pareto (GEPA) to systematically optimize prompts for scientific reasoning tasks, and analyze how prompting can affect reasoning behavior. We investigate the structural patterns and logical heuristics inherent in GEPA-optimized prompts, and evaluate their transferability and brittleness. Our findings reveal that gains in scientific reasoning often correspond to model-specific heuristics that fail to generalize across systems, which we call “local” logic. By framing prompt optimization as a tool for model interpretability, we argue that mapping these preferred reasoning structures for LLMs is an important prerequisite for effectively collaborating with superhuman intelligence. -File a Complaint +## 1 INTRODUCTION - 01 +As the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly push performance frontiers (Bubeck et al., 2023), research focus will foreseeably shift from benchmark tracking toward understanding how to best collaborate with LLMs. We identify reasoning as the most critical capability of LLMs in a post-AGI landscape, as it provides the verifiable logical scaffolding necessary for autonomous systems to navigate novel, high-stakes scenarios (Huang & Chang, 2023). A rigorous understanding of these mechanisms enables more effective human-AGI collaboration in a wide range of scenarios, ensuring these systems act reliably when tackling complex challenges. Current LLMs provide a valuable window into the reasoning paradigms that may define a post-AGI world. - 05 +We see scientific reasoning as a robust testbed for probing these internal paradigms. Scientific reasoning provides essential foundational logic and structured frameworks, which can generalize to a variety of high impact downstream tasks, including but not limited to scientific discovery, spatial navigation, and engineering. In this work, we examine such reasoning in two domains: (1) GPQA, which tests graduate-level scientific reasoning (Rein et al., 2023), and (2) a formally verified algebra dataset implemented in Lean (Yang et al., 2023b; Zheng et al., 2022). These benchmarks allow for the observation of complex logic under controlled and interpretable conditions. -06 +Since natural language will likely be the primary interface for interacting with AGI systems, understanding how prompting affects reasoning capabilities is crucial for reliable collaboration. In this work, we first use Genetic Pareto (GEPA) to optimize prompts and discover which specific instructions result in the best performance (Agrawal et al., 2025; Khattab et al., 2023). We then analyze these results to identify the patterns that elicit higher-level reasoning in these models. -07 +We find that high-performing prompts often rely on model-specific heuristics that fail to generalize across models (Mirzadeh et al., 2025). Mapping these machine-preferred structures is vital for overseeing future general-purpose systems (Berglund et al., 2024). This work establishes a foundation for decoding LLM reasoning to ensure safety frameworks are prepared for a post-AGI society. -08 +> _∗_ Equal contribution - About this Report +1 -What is a complaint? +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -The Kansas Insurance Department receives thousands of complaints and inquiries each year about -insurance companies. Complaints and inquiries from the public give us an indication of the kind of -service companies are providing to their customers. We can then work with companies that need to -improve in certain areas. +## 2 BACKGROUND -Complaints can also help us identify insurance companies or agents that may need to be investigated -for violations of Kansas insurance laws or regulations. The Department also uses complaints to focus -public education efforts on the issues that concern Kansas insurance consumers. +**LLMs for Math and Science** LLMs are rapidly moving beyond simple linguistic pattern matching, developing complex multi-step reasoning skills that are necessary for mathematical and scientific general intelligence. Current methodologies often rely on specialized prompting paradigms; for instance, Chain-of-Thought (Wei et al., 2022) encourages explicit symbolic derivation, while Programof-Thought (Chen et al., 2022) offloads complex scientific computing to external Python interpreters. More recently, reasoning-centric models such as OpenAI’s o1 and DeepSeek’s R1 have utilized large-scale reinforcement learning to internalize these logical trajectories (DeepSeek-AI et al., 2025). However, breaking records on benchmarks is only a partial milestone. As these systems approach AGI-level performance, research must shift from merely tracking performance to understanding how to best collaborate with these models. In this work, we argue that identifying the structural biases and implicit reasoning strategies within these models is a vital prerequisite for the effective oversight and safe deployment of AGI systems in high-stakes and unsupervised scenarios. -Each time we receive a complaint, we notify the insurance company and any involved agents. -We send the company a copy of the complaint and ask that it be reviewed and an explanation -provided. Companies are required by law to respond to the Department within 15 working days. -Most companies are cooperative in working with us to resolve consumer complaints. We keep a -record of each complaint filed by a consumer for up to three years. +**Automated Prompt Engineering** Optimization of model performance has evolved from the manual engineering of prompts to a systematic algorithmic search. Early works in automated prompt engineering have demonstrated that LLMs are often the best optimizers of their own instructions (Zhou et al., 2022; Yang et al., 2023a). Genetic Pareto (GEPA) utilizes an evolutionary approach to iteratively optimize high performing prompts (Agrawal et al., 2025). While previous works on automated engineering focused primarily on maximizing accuracy, we reposition these algorithms as tools for understanding. By allowing GEPA to explore the vast search space of possible instructions, we treat the resulting optimized prompts and the trajectory of prompt evolution as valuable windows into the latent preferences of the model. We can then identify specific heuristics that can be reverse engineered and transferred back to improve human-authored prompting methodologies. -A formal complaint is any written communication expressing dissatisfaction or concern with an -insurance company or an agent. General written inquiries received from consumers are not counted -in this report. We also do not include complaints regarding products not within the jurisdiction of the -Kansas Insurance Department, such as self-funded plans and Medicare prescription drug plans. +**Knowledge Transferability** A fundamental question in the path toward AGI is whether machine intelligence is a singular phenomenon or a collection of fragmented epistemologies (Quattrociocchi et al., 2025). Previous research into model distillation and generalization has shown that while knowledge can be transferred between architectures, internal reasoning protocols often remain model specific (Hinton et al., 2015). This brittleness poses challenges for the post-AGI era. For AI systems to truly be of use in collaborative scientific discovery, their logic must be interoperable. If a reasoning strategy optimized for one model fails on another, it suggests a closed epistemology, which represents a detached form of intelligence that lacks a universal logical foundation (Pal et al., 2026). -NOTE: A formal complaint must be made in writing. +## 3 METHODOLOGY -What is a complaint index? +We assess LLM reasoning in two domains: (1) formal mathematical theorem proving via Lean from the MiniF2F dataset (Zheng et al., 2022) and (2) scientific reasoning via the GPQA Diamond benchmark (Rein et al., 2023). We refer to these benchmarks as “Algebra” and “GPQA” respectively. These domains assess scientific reasoning in complementary ways: Lean requires rigid verifiable logic and is open ended, while GPQA evaluates high level conceptual reasoning and is multiple choice. We apply a custom variant of GEPA which has been simplified and adapted for Lean theorem proving and GPQA. Implementation details are specified in Algorithm 1. -The complaint index shows how a company compares to other companies in the same line of business. -It is a statistic that considers a company’s share of complaints in relation to its market share or share of -business written in Kansas. Since the complaint index is measured by market share, companies in all -lines of business will be measured against an index of 1.00. +We conduct the entirety of GEPA optimization using DeepSeek-V3.2, which currently has state-ofthe-art performance on reasoning benchmarks. To gain insight into the transferability of optimized prompts across different models, we also test the same prompts on ChatGPT-5.4-mini, GLM 5, and Claude Sonnet 4.6, all of which were released within the past few months and have competitive performance. By analyzing the prompt optimization process and comparing prompt performance across models, we hope to gain insight into how prompting strategy affects reasoning performance. -For example, a complaint index of 1.00 means the insurer’s share of all complaints received is equal -to its share of all the business written in Kansas. An index of 2.00 means that the insurer’s share -of complaints is twice as large as its share of business written. An index of 0.00 indicates that no -complaints were received for the company. +For every combination of model and benchmark, we run evaluations across four prompts: **(1) HandCrafted Simple:** A hand-crafted simple prompt, intended to emulate the prompting ability of average technical users, which serves as a baseline; **(2) Hand-Crafted CoT:** A hand-crafted Chain-of-Thought prompt, intended to emulate best practice prompting strategies to current knowledge, which serves as a baseline; **(3) GEPA Optimized Baseline:** The initial prompt from the GEPA optimization process; and **(4) GEPA Optimized Final:** The final prompt from the GEPA optimization process. Prompts are further discussed in the Appendix, and examples are provided. -The formula is as follows: +2 -Complaint share +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Market share +## **Algorithm 1** Custom Variant of Genetic Pareto (GEPA) -OR +- 1: **Input:** Seed prompt _P_ 0, Lean theorems _L_ , GPQA questions _G_ , iterations _T_ , samples ( _n, m_ ). -Company’s complaints / -all complaints +- 2: **Initialize:** _Population ←{P_ 0 _}_ , _Pareto ←∅_ . -Company’s premium / All -written premium +- 3: **for** _t_ = 1 **to** _T_ **do** -page 1 +- 4: _P ←_ Sample( _Pareto ̸_ = _∅_ ? _Pareto_ : _Population_ ) 5: _SL ←_ Sample( _L, n_ ), _SG ←_ Sample( _G, m_ ) -insurance.kansas.gov Which complaints do we use? +- Lean Verify(LLM( _P, ci_ )) _ci ∈ SL_ -This report shows complaints for the six major types of insurance: accident and health (including -HMOs), annuity, automobile, homeowners, life and long-term care. +- 6: **Evaluate: v** [ _i_ ] _←_ for _ci ∈ SL ∪ SG_ �Check ~~A~~ nswer(LLM( _P, ci_ )) _ci ∈ SG_ -We do not include complaints regarding products not within the jurisdiction of the Department, such as -self-funded plans and Medicare prescription drug plans. In 2021, the Kansas Insurance Department -closed a total of 2,205 complaints. 2,110 involved matters within our jurisdiction. +- 7: **Update Pareto:** Add _P_ if non-dominated by existing prompts; remove dominated. 8: _Errors ←{ci_ : **v** [ _i_ ] = 0 _}_ -To ensure fairness, all closed complaints are counted without any attempt to distinguish between -“valid” or “invalid” complaints. +- 9: _Critique ←_ LLM ~~C~~ ritic( _P,_ Logs( _Errors_ )) -Which companies are shown? +- 10: _P[′] ←_ LLM ~~E~~ volve( _P, Critique_ ) -Unless otherwise noted, we list the top 20 premium-writing companies for each line, as well as any -company with 10 or more closed complaints for that type of insurance during the calendar year. +- 11: _Population ← Pareto ∪{P[′] } {_ Prune to Pareto + new child _}_ -During 2021, $6,273,694.92 was recovered for Kansas consumers as a result of the Department’s -assistance. In 2021, the largest number of complaints concerned automobile insurance (29%) and -accident & health Insurance (28%). Here is the breakdown: +- 12: **end for** -All Closed Complaints & Inquiries +- 13: **return** _Pareto_ -Automobile +## 4 RESULTS -29% +## 4.1 BENCHMARK PERFORMANCE -Life +Table 1: Performance comparison of models on benchmark datasets. -3,000 +|**Model**|**Method**|**Algebra**|**GPQA**| +|---|---|---|---| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|86.11%|91.67%| +|DeepSeek-V3.2|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|97.22%
91.67%|91.67%
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|**100.00%**|**94.44%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|50.00%|**91.67%**| +|GPT-5.4-mini|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|47.22%
50.00%|**91.67%**
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|**61.11%**|**91.67%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|91.67%|**91.67%**| +|GLM 5|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|**97.22%**
91.67%|86.11%
88.89%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|94.44%|**91.67%**| +||Hand-Crafted Simple|30.56%|77.78%| +|Claude Sonnet 4.6|Hand-Crafted CoT
GEPA Optimized Baseline|**52.78%**
50.00%|**83.33%**
80.56%| +||GEPA Optimized Final|50.00%|80.56%| -2,500 -Accident & Health -28% +Prompt performance on benchmarks is displayed in Table 1. Our first major observation is that the GEPA Optimized Final prompt achieves its most significant gains on DeepSeek-V3.2, reaching 100.00% on Algebra and 94.44% on GPQA. This confirms that the GEPA optimization process is highly effective when evaluated on the same model used during optimization. Our second major observation is that the superiority of the GEPA-optimized prompts does not reliably transfer to other models. While some models show marginal benefits – for example, GPT-5.4-mini sees an improvement in Algebra from 50.00% to 61.11% – the optimized prompt is rarely the undisputed best performer elsewhere. Notably, for GLM 5 (Algebra) and Claude Sonnet 4.6 (both benchmarks), the Hand-Crafted CoT prompts actually outperform the GEPA Optimized Final prompt. -Long-Term Care +These results suggest that the optimization process is highly model-specific, and suggests a trade-off between prompt universality and performance. Since DeepSeek was used as the optimizer, the evolved prompts likely capture patterns specific to DeepSeek’s architecture that do not resonate with the internal logic of other models. This highlights a significant lack of interoperability and reinforces the brittleness of automated prompt engineering across diverse foundation models. -2,000 +3 -Homeowners +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -Other +**==> picture [318 x 128] intentionally omitted <==** -15% +Figure 1: The length of GEPA proposed prompts increases over the course of optimization, with the final prompt often being about twice as long in characters as the initial prompt. This shows that detailed prompting is likely required to unlock better reasoning capabilities in LLMs. -14% +## 4.2 PROMPT EVOLUTION PATTERNS -Annuity +By manually analyzing the evolution of prompts over the course of GEPA optimization, we primarily find that prompts evolve from telling the model _what to do_ to coaching it on _how to do it_ , similar to a human expert. In the process, significant domain knowledge and best practices are often added to the context. For example, in the GEPA optimization process for the Algebra benchmark, prompts eventually referenced domain specific strategies such as using Eisenstein’s Criterion for minimal polynomials. Similarly, later GPQA prompts mentioned specific strategies such as quantum field theory loop counting. Later Algebra prompts also explicitly warn against common pitfalls, especially with regard to Lean formatting. Interestingly, a robust protocol for “Handling False Statements” is also introduced to prevent hallucinating proofs. The Appendix contains prompt examples. -1,500 +This observation is also supported by analyzing the prompt lengths over the course of optimization, as shown in Figure 1. The final prompt turns out to be around twice as long as the initial prompt. This demonstrates that LLMs often rely on detailed prompting to fully elicit their reasoning capabilities. -1,000 +By analyzing the embedding space for prompts over the optimization process, we also find that the embeddings of proposed prompts tends to drift in a consistent direction over the course of optimization. This suggests that for the same task, some regions of prompting space may offer more promising performance. A plot of this behavior is in the Appendix. -500 +## 5 DISCUSSION -0 +**Conclusion** In this work, we demonstrated that using clever prompt optimization techniques can unlock reasoning potential in LLMs. We find that longer prompts, as well as prompts that guide the model along the _how_ of the target task, tend to elicit superior reasoning capabilities in LLMs. Such prompts can be optimized autonomously, and can beat hand-crafted baselines, even when we hand-craft prompts using state-of-the-art best practices. Our findings suggest that if current trends continue, post-AGI reasoning may not manifest as a universal logic, but rather as a collection of task-specific and model-specific heuristics that require precise coaching to elicit. -*rounded to the nearest percent +**Limitations** Our work is still relatively preliminary, and is limited to two benchmarks and four models. We would need a broader experimental scope to more confidently confirm the validity of our hypotheses. Furthermore, the stochastic nature of our LLM-driven prompt optimization loop could lead to inconsistency across multiple runs. -Closed Complaints +**Future Work** Our preliminary results suggest that prompt optimization remains dangerously architecture dependent. To prepare for a post-AGI landscape, future research should work on identifying “reasoning primitives”, or logical structures invariant across models. If AGI develops logic that humans cannot understand, we need to build automated tools to keep these systems interpretable. Without this, we risk a future where our most capable tools are also our least predictable. -Closed Inquiries +4 -9% +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -4% +## 6 STATEMENTS -1% +## 6.1 ETHICS STATEMENT -2018 +While the discovery of effective reasoning paths could potentially be repurposed for harmful tasks, our analysis of the logic inherent in these models primarily as a vital safeguard. If we better understand how LLMs reason, we can better utilize LLMs for reasoning related tasks. Ultimately, identifying how LLMs approach reasoning tasks is essential for the development of robust, aligned, and transparent post-AGI systems. -2,689 +We also agree to NOT reveal examples from our evaluation datasets in plain text or images online, to reduce the risk of leakage into foundation model training corpora. -1,049 +## 6.2 REPRODUCIBILITY STATEMENT -2019 +Our results are reproducible to the extent of nondeterminism in the outputs of LLMs used. -2,643 +## REFERENCES -878 +- Lakshya A Agrawal, Shangyin Tan, Dilara Soylu, Noah Ziems, Rishi Khare, Krista Opsahl-Ong, Arnav Singhvi, Herumb Shandilya, Michael J Ryan, Meng Jiang, Christopher Potts, Koushik Sen, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Ion Stoica, Dan Klein, Matei Zaharia, and Omar Khattab. Gepa: Reflective prompt evolution can outperform reinforcement learning, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/ abs/2507.19457. -2020 +- Lukas Berglund, Meg Tong, Max Kaufmann, Mikita Balesni, Asa Cooper Stickland, Tomasz Korbak, and Owain Evans. The reversal curse: Llms trained on ”a is b” fail to learn ”b is a”, 2024. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12288. -2,157 +- Sebastien´ Bubeck, Varun Chandrasekaran, Ronen Eldan, Johannes Gehrke, Eric Horvitz, Ece Kamar, Peter Lee, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li, Scott Lundberg, Harsha Nori, Hamid Palangi, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, and Yi Zhang. Sparks of artificial general intelligence: Early experiments with gpt-4. March 2023. URL https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/ sparks-of-artificial-general-intelligence-early-experiments-with-gpt-4/. -873 +- Wenhu Chen, Xueguang Ma, Xinyi Wang, and William W Cohen. Program of thoughts prompting: Disentangling computation from reasoning for numerical reasoning tasks. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2211.12588_ , 2022. -2021 +- DeepSeek-AI et al. Deepseek-r1: Incentivizing reasoning capability in llms via reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.12948_ , 2025. -2,205 +- Geoffrey Hinton, Oriol Vinyals, and Jeff Dean. Distilling the knowledge in a neural network. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1503.02531_ , 2015. -795 +- Jie Huang and Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang. Towards reasoning in large language models: A survey, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10403. -All Closed Complaints & Inquiries +- Omar Khattab, Arnav Singhvi, Paridhi Maheshwari, Zhiyuan Zhang, Keshav Santhanam, Sri Vardhamanan, Saiful Haq, Ashutosh Sharma, Thomas T. Joshi, Hanna Moazam, Heather Miller, Matei Zaharia, and Christopher Potts. Dspy: Compiling declarative language model calls into self-improving pipelines, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.03714. -Recoveries Per Year (In Millions) +- Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Hooman Shahrokhi, Oncel Tuzel, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. Gsm-symbolic: Understanding the limitations of mathematical reasoning in large language models, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05229. -7 +- Koyena Pal, David Bau, and Chandan Singh. Do explanations generalize across large reasoning models?, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.11517. -6 +5 -5 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -4 +Walter Quattrociocchi, Valerio Capraro, and Matjaz Perc.ˇ Epistemological fault lines between human and artificial intelligence, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.19466. -3 +- David Rein, Betty Li Hou, Asa Cooper Stickland, Jackson Petty, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Julien Dirani, Julian Michael, and Samuel R. Bowman. Gpqa: A graduate-level google-proof q&a benchmark, 2023. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12022. -2 +- Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Fei Xia, Ed Chi, Quoc V Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain-of-thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 35:24824–24837, 2022. -1 +- Chengrung Yang, Xuezhi Wang, Yutai Lu, Hanxiao Liu, Quoc V Le, Denny Zhou, and Xinyun Chen. Large language models as optimizers. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2309.03409_ , 2023a. -0 +- Kaiyu Yang, Aidan M. Swope, Alex Gu, Rahul Chalamala, Peiyang Song, Shixing Yu, Saad Godil, Ryan Prenger, and Anima Anandkumar. Leandojo: Theorem proving with retrieval-augmented language models, 2023b. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15626. -6.27 +- Kunhao Zheng, Jesse Michael Han, and Stanislas Polu. Minif2f: a cross-system benchmark for formal olympiad-level mathematics, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.00110. -4.12 +- Yongchao Zhou, Andrei Ioan Muresanu, Ziwen Han, Keiran Paster, Silvian Puzicanin, Amar Terzic, Laurent Itti, et al. Large language models are human-level prompt engineers. In _The Eleventh International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2022. -3.28 +## A APPENDIX -1.84 +## A.1 ADDITIONAL RESULTS -2018 +**==> picture [396 x 144] intentionally omitted <==** -2019 +Figure 2: The embeddings of GEPA proposed prompts tend to drift over the course of optimization. For both algebra and GPQA, there seems to be a significant jump in embedding space at around iteration 12. This suggests that for the same task, some regions of prompting space may offer more promising performance. -2020 +## A.2 PROMPTS -2021 +The 4 prompts we tested for the Algebra benchmark are listed below. For sake of brevity, we do not include the 4 GPQA prompts in this section, but they are similar in nature. -page 2 +Listing 1: Hand-Crafted Simple Prompt -3,000 +1 You are a mathematician and Lean 4 practitioner. 2 Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean 4 proofs. -2,500 +3 4 Approach and tricks: -2,000 +6 -1,500 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -1,000 +- 5 - Try to reduce the goal using simp/linarith/nlinarith or rewriting. 6 - Look for standard lemmas in Mathlib (algebra, number theory, inequalities, parity). -500 +- 7 - Prefer structured proofs: have, refine, apply, and use ‘by‘ blocks. 8 9 Output format: -0 +- 10 - Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘lean ... ‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code. -Closed Complaints +- 11 - Do not include any text outside the code block. -Closed Inquiries +## Listing 2: Hand-Crafted CoT Prompt -2018 +|1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29|You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer.
Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean
4 proofs.
### Output Format
- Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code.
- Do not include any text outside the code block.
- The code should be complete, including necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘
statements.
### Imports
- Do not use a single monolithic ‘import Mathlib‘.
- Instead, import the specific files you need, e.g., ‘import Mathlib.Data
.Real.Basic‘, ‘import Mathlib.Algebra.Order.Field.Basic‘, ‘import
Mathlib.Tactic.Linarith‘.
### Chain-of-Thought (internal)
- Think step-by-step and consider small test cases for ‘N‘/‘Z‘ statements
.
- Do not reveal chain-of-thought. Output only the Lean code block.
### General Approach & Tactics
- Start with structured proofs: ‘have‘, ‘refine‘, ‘apply‘, ‘by‘ blocks.
Use ‘calc‘ for equational reasoning.
- Use ‘simp‘, ‘rw‘, ‘ring‘, ‘norm_num‘. ‘linarith‘ for linear
inequalities, ‘nlinarith‘ for non-linear.
- ‘ac_rfl‘ is useful for equalities up to associativity/commutativity.
### Handling False Statements
- If you find a counterexample, do not modify the statement.
- Provide a Lean code block that proves the counterexample, then leave
the original theorem with ‘sorry‘.
### Domain-Specific Hints
- Polynomial identities: ‘ring‘ is often a one-line proof.
- Inequalities: reduce to ‘0 _≤_x - y‘, then show nonnegativity via
squares or ‘positivity‘.
- Linear systems over ‘C‘: use ‘linear_combination‘ or a ‘calc‘ block
with ‘ring‘.| +|---|---| -2,689 -1,049 -2019 +## Listing 3: GEPA Optimized Baseline Prompt -2,643 +1 You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer. 2 Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean 4 proofs. 3 4 ### General Approach 5 6 1. **[Analyze][the][Problem:] **[Read][the][theorem][statement][carefully.] Restate the goal in your own words to ensure you understand it. Identify the core mathematical concepts involved (e.g., number theory , inequalities, algebra). -878 +7 -2020 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -2,157 +|7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44|2.
**Formulate a Mathematical Strategy:**
*
Before writing any code, sketch a proof plan on paper (mentally).
*
Consider standard theorems like AM-GM, Cauchy-Schwarz, Jensen’s
inequality, or properties of quadratic equations (discriminant).
*
For sums and series, look for telescoping patterns or
opportunities for integral bounds. For example, ‘1/_√_k‘ is often
bounded using ‘2(_√_k - _√_(k-1))‘.
*
A very common and powerful trick for inequalities is to use the
fact that ‘(x - y)ˆ2 _≥_0‘, which expands to ‘xˆ2 + yˆ2 _≥_2xy‘.
3.
**Structure the Lean Proof:**
*
**DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself):** If you find yourself proving the
same thing multiple times with different variables, define a local
helper ‘lemma‘ to abstract the repeated logic. For example, if you
need ‘xˆ2/y + y _≥_2x‘ for several pairs ‘(x, y)‘, prove it once in a
general lemma.
*
**Structured Proofs:** Prefer structured proofs using ‘have‘, ‘
let‘, ‘calc‘, ‘refine‘, and ‘apply‘. Use ‘by‘ blocks for short tactic
sequences.
*
**Backward Reasoning:** Use ‘suffices‘ to simplify the goal to an
easier-to-prove intermediate statement.
### Lean 4 Tactics and Tricks
*
**Automation:**
*
‘ring‘: Use to prove equalities that hold in any commutative ring
(polynomials without division).
*
‘field_simp‘: Use to prove equalities in fields (expressions with
division). Provide non-zero hypotheses, e.g., ‘field_simp [h.ne.symm
]‘.
*
‘linarith‘: For proving linear arithmetic inequalities.
*
‘nlinarith‘: For proving non-linear arithmetic inequalities. It
is very powerful when combined with a hypothesis like ‘sq_nonneg‘.
*
‘positivity‘: To automatically prove goals of the form ‘0 < x‘ or
‘0 _≤_x‘.
*
**Rewriting and Simplification:**
*
‘rw‘: For rewriting terms using equalities.
*
‘simp‘: For general simplification. You can add specific lemmas
to its ruleset, e.g., ‘simp [add_comm]‘.
*
**Finding Lemmas:**
*
Mathlib is vast. If you think a lemma for a common mathematical
fact (e.g., telescoping sums) should exist, it probably does. For
example, ‘Finset.sum_Icc_telescope‘ is available for telescoping sums
over an ‘Icc‘.
*
Use ‘exact?‘ or ‘apply?‘ to ask Lean to search for a lemma that
solves the current goal.
*
**Crucially, only use lemma and tactic names that you are certain
exist in Mathlib.** Do not invent names. If your code uses a non-
existent identifier, it is incorrect. Double-check your toolset.
*
**Common Mathlib Lemmas for Inequalities:**
*
‘sq_nonneg (x : R)‘: Proves ‘0 _≤_x ˆ 2‘.
*
‘pow_two_nonneg (x : R)‘: Same as ‘sq_nonneg‘.
*
‘div_nonneg {a b : R} (ha : 0 _≤_a) (hb : 0 _≤_b) : 0 _≤_a / b‘. You
need to prove the numerator and denominator are non-negative.
### Output Format
*
Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘ containing valid, complete, and compilable Lean 4 code.
*
Ensure all necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘ statements are present.
*
Do not include any text, explanation, or comments outside the code
block.| +|---|---| -873 -2021 -2,205 +8 -795 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -7 +Listing 4: GEPA Optimized Final Prompt -6 +|1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42|You are an expert mathematician and Lean 4 developer.
Your goal is to solve formal IMO-style problems and produce correct Lean
4 proofs.
### Output Format
- Return the response in a single fenced code block with ‘‘‘‘lean ...
‘‘‘‘ containing valid Lean 4 code.
- Do not include any text outside the code block.
- The code should be complete, including necessary ‘import‘ and ‘open‘
statements.
### General Approach & Tactics
- **Verify the statement first.** Before attempting a proof, especially
for statements over ‘N‘ or ‘Z‘, quickly test small values (e.g., n=0,
1, 2). If you find a counterexample, follow the "Handling False
Statements" protocol below.
- Start with structured proofs: ‘have‘, ‘refine‘, ‘apply‘, ‘by‘ blocks. ‘
calc‘ blocks are excellent for equational reasoning.
- Use ‘simp‘, ‘rw‘, ‘ring‘, ‘norm_num‘. ‘linarith‘ is for linear
inequalities over ordered fields (‘R‘, ‘Q‘). ‘nlinarith‘ is for non-
linear inequalities.
- ‘ac_rfl‘ is useful for proving equalities up to associativity and
commutativity, which is often more robust than a sequence of ‘rw [
add_comm, add_assoc]‘.
- **DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself).** If you prove the same intermediate
result multiple times with different variables, define a local helper
lemma inside the proof using ‘have‘. This improves clarity and
reduces errors.
‘‘‘lean
have my_lemma : _∀_(x y : R), 0 < y _→_xˆ2 / y + y _≥_2 * x := by
... -- proof of the lemma
-- then use it:
have h1 := my_lemma a b hb
have h2 := my_lemma b c hc
‘‘‘
### Handling False Statements
- If you find a counterexample (e.g., the theorem fails for ‘n=1‘), do
not attempt to prove a modified version of the theorem (e.g.,
changing ‘<‘ to ‘_≤_‘ or adding a hypothesis like ‘n _≥_2‘).
- Your task is to prove the theorem *as given*. If it is false, you
cannot complete the task.
- In this case, your response should be a Lean code block that formally
proves the counterexample. Then, leave the original theorem with ‘
sorry‘. This correctly signals that the requested proof is impossible
.
- **Example a assistant should produce for a false statement:**
‘‘‘lean
import Mathlib
-- The user’s theorem statement is false for n=1.
-- Here is a proof of the counterexample.
example : _¬_ (_∀_n : N, (n : R) ˆ (1 / n : R) < 2 - 1 / n) := by
intro h
specialize h 1
norm_num at h -- This will fail, proving the negation.
-- The original problem, which is unprovable.
theorem algebra_ineq_nto1onlt2m1on (n : N) : (n : R) ˆ (1 / n : R) <
2 - 1 / n := by
sorry
‘‘‘
### Domain-Specific Strategies & Mathlib Knowledge|| +|---|---|---| -5 -4 -3 +9 -2 +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -1 +43 44 #### 1. Polynomial & Ring Identities 45 - For identities involving addition, subtraction, multiplication, and integer powers (i.e., polynomial identities), the ‘ring‘ tactic is extremely powerful. It works over any commutative (semi)ring like ‘Z ‘, ‘Q‘, ‘R‘, ‘C‘. For simple identities, this is often a one-line proof. 46 47 #### 2. Inequalities over R, Q (AM-GM, Cauchy-Schwarz, etc.) 48 - A common strategy is to prove ‘x _≥_ y‘ by showing ‘x - y _≥_ 0‘. 49 - **Pattern: Prove ‘x _≥_ y‘ by showing ‘x - y _≥_ 0‘** 50 1. State the subgoal: ‘suffices 0 _≤_ x - y by linarith‘. 51 2. Establish an algebraic identity for the difference, where the right-hand side is in a form that is clearly non-negative (e.g., a square or a sum of squares). 52 ‘‘‘lean 53 have h_ident : x - y = (a - b)ˆ2 / c := by 54 field_simp -- Handles division. Provide non-zero hypotheses, e. g., ‘field_simp [ne_of_gt hc]‘. 55 ring -- Finishes the polynomial part. 56 ‘‘‘ 57 3. Prove the right-hand side is non-negative. This often uses ‘ div_nonneg‘, ‘mul_nonneg‘, ‘sq_nonneg‘, and ‘positivity‘. 58 - **Pattern: Proving ‘(a-b)*(c-d) _≥_ 0‘** 59 * This is common in induction proofs. The key is to show that ‘a-b‘ and ‘c-d‘ have the same sign. 60 * A robust method is to use ‘mul_nonneg_of_signs_sync‘. For example , to prove ‘0 _≤_ (a - b) * (aˆn - bˆn)‘ for ‘0 _≤_ a, b‘ and ‘1 _≤_ n‘: 61 ‘‘‘lean 62 have h_iff : a _≤_ b _↔_ a ˆ n _≤_ b ˆ n := 63 Real.pow_le_pow_iff_of_nonneg (by linarith) (by linarith) (by omega) 64 exact mul_nonneg_of_signs_sync h_iff 65 ‘‘‘ 66 * This is much cleaner than a ‘by_cases‘ block. 67 68 #### 3. Linear Algebra over C 69 - **‘linarith‘ fails over ‘C‘** because it is not an ordered ring. 70 - **‘linear_combination‘ Tactic:** This is the most direct way to solve systems of linear equations. It combines *other equational hypotheses *[.] 71 ‘‘‘lean 72 -- h 0 : f + 3*z = 11 73 -- h 1 : 3*f - 5*z = -65 74 have h_14z : 14 * z = 98 := by linear_combination 3 * h 0 - h 1 75 ‘‘‘ 76 - **Warning:** Do not use ‘linear_combination‘ to manipulate a single equation with a constant (e.g., ‘linear_combination h 0 - 21‘ is incorrect). To solve for a variable in one equation, use ‘calc‘ or ‘ rw‘. 77 - **Solving Equations:** 78 1. **[From][a][system:] **[After][using][‘linear_combination‘][to][get][e.g.] ‘14 * z = 98‘, use ‘mul_right_cancel 0 ‘ to solve for the variable. 79 ‘‘‘lean 80 -- h_eq: 14 * z = 98 81 have hz : z = 7 := by 82 apply mul_right_cancel 0 (by norm_num : (14 : C) = 0) 83 rw [h_eq] -- Goal becomes: 98 = 14 * 7 84 norm_num -- Finishes the proof 85 ‘‘‘ 86 2. **[From][one][equation:] **[To][isolate][a][variable][in][an][equation][like] ‘f + 21 = 11‘, use a ‘calc‘ block. 87 ‘‘‘lean 88 -- h 0 : f + 21 = 11 89 have hf : f = -10 := by -0 +10 -Recoveries Per Year (In Millions) +Accepted at the Post-AGI Science and Society Workshop at ICLR 2026 -6.27 +|90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115|calc f = (f + 21) - 21 := by ring
_ = 11 - 21
:= by rw [h0]
_ = -10
:= by norm_num
‘‘‘
#### 4. Algebraic Numbers & Field Theory (Linear Independence)
- Problems of the form "if ‘a + b*m + c*mˆ2 = 0‘ with ‘a,b,c _∈_Q‘, then ‘
a=b=c=0‘" are about linear independence and minimal polynomials.
- The strategy:
1.
Identify the algebraic number (e.g., ‘m = 2ˆ(1/3)‘).
2.
Find its minimal polynomial over ‘Q‘ (e.g., ‘p = X3 - 2‘).
3.
Prove ‘p‘ is irreducible over ‘Q‘ using **Eisenstein’s Criterion
**: ‘Polynomial.irreducible_of_eisenstein_criterion‘. For ‘X3 - 2‘,
use the prime ‘p=2‘. (Requires ‘import Mathlib.RingTheory.Polynomial.
Eisenstein‘).
4.
Verify ‘p‘ is the minimal polynomial using ‘minpoly.
eq_of_irreducible_of_monic‘.
5.
Use ‘minpoly.dvd Q m hq‘ to show the minimal polynomial divides
your polynomial. (Requires ‘import Mathlib.FieldTheory.Minpoly.Basic
‘).
6.
Get a contradiction from degrees (‘Polynomial.
eq_zero_of_dvd_of_degree_lt‘).
7.
Deduce coefficients are zero using ‘Polynomial.
coeff_eq_zero_of_eq_zero‘.
### Troubleshooting
- **‘rw‘ or ‘calc‘ block failures:** If ‘rw‘ or ‘calc‘ fails due to term
ordering (e.g., ‘a*b‘ vs ‘b*a‘), try ‘ac_rfl‘ or add an explicit ‘rw
[mul_comm]‘.
- **Unknown Identifier Errors:** If you get an ’unknown identifier’ error
for a common mathematical lemma (e.g., ‘pow_le_pow_left‘), the name
has likely changed in Mathlib4.
- **Search the documentation.** The best way to find the current name
is to search the Mathlib4 API documentation.
- **Look for prefixes.** Many lemmas are now namespaced by their
primary type. For example, lemmas about ‘Real‘ powers are often in
the ‘Real‘ namespace (e.g., ‘Real.pow_le_pow_of_le_left‘). Lemmas
about ‘rpow‘ (real powers) are often named ‘Real.rpow_...‘.
- **Common Power Inequality Lemmas (for ‘R‘):**
- For ‘0 _≤_x _≤_y _→_xˆn _≤_yˆn‘, use ‘Real.pow_le_pow_of_le_left‘.
- For ‘0 _≤_x < y _→_xˆn < yˆn‘, use ‘Real.pow_lt_pow_of_lt_left‘.
- For ‘0 _≤_a, b‘ and ‘1 _≤_n‘, ‘a _≤_b _↔_aˆn _≤_bˆn‘ is ‘Real.
pow_le_pow_iff_of_nonneg‘.
- **Complex Proofs:** If a proof is complex (e.g., induction with
inequalities), break it down into many small, verifiable ‘have‘
statements to isolate errors. Don’t write a single large ‘calc‘ block
or proof term until you have verified the intermediate steps.| +|---|---| -4.12 -3.28 -1.84 +11 -2018 - -2019 - -2020 - -2021 - -Complaint Index Report - - Sixty-seven percent (67%) of total complaints concerned problems with claims handling. Other -common types of complaints involved policyholder services, underwriting and marketing and sales. - -67% - Claims Handling - -19% - Policyholder Service - -10% - Underwriting - -4% - Marketing and Sales - -Companies may be listed on more than one table and will usually have a different complaint index -on each table. For example, if you are shopping for auto insurance, go to the table titled, “Indexes by -line: Automobile” to check for your company’s complaint index. Companies are listed in alphabetical -order. - -We list individual insurance companies only, not groups of insurance companies. For example, you -may be insured by a company such as State Farm. We show the name of the subsidiary company -owned by State Farm. Your policy or ID card lists the exact name of your company. - -Why is my company not listed? - -If a company is not listed, that means it had fewer than 10 complaints during the calendar year and -it was not one of the top 20 premium writers for that line in Kansas. Information can also be compiled -for lines of insurance not listed in this booklet. For information on a company not listed or another line -of insurance, please call our Consumer Assistance Hotline at 800-432-2484. - -Just a snapshot - -The statistics in this report give you a “snapshot” of a company that represents complaints filed with the -Department regarding that company’s business in Kansas for one year and one type of coverage. As -indexes are likely to change, you may want to review these “snapshots” annually. - -Complaint indexes do not tell you everything about a company. You may also want to consider the -following factors when shopping for insurance: - -Service — Some companies sell through local agents and some through direct marketing or group -plans. You may want to find out how the company services its policyholders. - -Licensing Status — Call the Consumer Assistance Hotline at 800-432-2484 to find out if a company -is licensed to do business in Kansas. - -Financial Stability — Financial stability helps ensure a company can pay its claims. The Department -enforces statutory requirements and monitors the financial stability of companies licensed and -operating in the state. - -page 3 - -insurance.kansas.gov You can check a company’s financial rating by contacting one of these organizations: - -MOODY’S INVESTOR SERVICES - -STANDARD & POOR’S -INSURANCE RATING SERVICES - -212-553-1653 - -www.moodys.com - -877-772-5436 - -www.standardandpoors.com - -A.M. BEST CO. - -www.ambest.com - -Cost — We publish easy-to-use booklets and shopper’s guides. Download them free from our website -at insurance.kansas.gov or call our office to get a free copy 800-432-2484. - -Free booklets & shopper’s guides -Auto Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Health Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Home and Renters Insurance Shopper’s Guide - -Important - -Life, Annuities and Long-Term Care Shopper’s -Guide - -Medicare Supplement Shopper’s Guide - -To better understand the complaint process, you might want to review what type of complaint was -filed against the company you are looking at. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners -(NAIC) provides information by code about the complaint. - -Information is available at https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm - -Input the NAIC company code number found to the left of the company name in the complaint index -report and hit the enter key. Once the company is displayed, select “Click for Report Options.” Next, -select “Go to Complaint Code Report.” You will then choose a report based on the type of coverage, -reason for complaint, or disposition (final outcome). Finally, select Kansas under the “I want to see -complaints for:” drop down. Please note this report varies from the Kansas Insurance Department’s -Complaint Index as it only captures confirmed complaints, which are defined as: - -“A complaint in which the state department of insurance determines: - -a) The insurer, licensee, producer, or other regulated entity committed any violation of: - -1) An applicable state insurance law or regulation; - -2) A federal requirement that the state department of insurance has the authority to enforce; or - -3) The term/condition of an insurance policy or certificate; or - -b) The complaint and entity’s response, considered together, indicate that the entity was in error.” - -page 4 - -Complaint Index Report Indexes by line: Automobile - -Cocode - -Company Name - -33154 - -Alliance Indemnity Company - -42579 - -Allied Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -29688 - -Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Company - -19232 - -Allstate Insurance Company - -10386 - -American Family Insurance Company - -19275 - -American Family Mutual Insurance Company - -13773 - -Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -21628 - -Farmers Insurance Company Incorporated - -13587 - -First Chicago Insurance Company - -14138 - -GEICO Advantage Insurance Company - -14139 - -GEICO Choice Insurance Company - -12966 - -Key Insurance Company - -23787 - -Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company - -16322 - -Progressive Direct Insurance Company - -42919 - -Progressive Northwestern Insurance Company - -25405 - -Safe Auto Insurance Company - -24740 - -Safeco Insurance Company Of America - -23388 - -Shelter Mutual Insurance Company - -19070 - -Standard Fire Insurance Company - -25178 - -State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company - -42749 - -Traders Insurance Company - -25941 - -United Services Automobile Association - -25968 - -USAA Casualty Insurance Company - -18600 - -USAA General Indemnity Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -0.99% - -1.22% - -4.63% - -0.28% - -4.27% - -6.12% - -6.79% - -4.40% - -0.15% - -3.13% - -1.94% - -0.81% - -1.31% - -6.59% - -8.15% - -0.22% - -1.84% - -3.24% - -3.39% - -16.23% - -1.18% - -2.08% - -1.60% - -1.42% - -81.99% - -2 - -4 - -42 - -10 - -10 - -21 - -20 - -21 - -16 - -23 - -10 - -16 - -4 - -59 - -49 - -12 - -9 - -17 - -11 - -74 - -20 - -9 - -7 - -5 - -0.33 - -0.53 - -1.48 - -5.86 - -0.38 - -0.56 - -0.48 - -0.78 - -17.66 - -1.20 - -0.84 - -3.22 - -0.50 - -1.46 - -0.98 - -8.87 - -0.80 - -0.86 - -0.53 - -0.75 - -2.76 - -0.71 - -0.71 - -0.58 - -0.17 - -0.93 - -1.06 - -0.55 - -0.86 - -0.82 - -0.31 - -0.60 - -6.40 - -1.27 - -1.79 - -3.68 - -0.82 - -0.84 - -0.70 - -7.53 - -0.86 - -0.57 - -0.50 - -0.84 - -1.98 - -0.96 - -0.94 - -1.48 - -- - -0.38 - -1.04 - -- - -0.76 - -0.64 - -0.64 - -1.29 - -- - -0.77 - -1.10 - -4.07 - -- - -1.10 - -0.73 - -- - -0.79 - -0.88 - -0.93 - -0.74 - -2.64 - -0.55 - -0.84 - -0.39 - -Indexes by line: Accident & Health - -Cocode - -Company Name - -12321 - -American Continental Insurance Company - -60380 - -American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus - -61263 - -Bankers Life & Casualty Company - -47171 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas City - -70729 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas Incorporated - -67369 - -Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company - -68500 - -Continental Life Insurance Company Brentwood - -62324 - -Freedom Life Insurance Company Of America - -64211 - -Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company - -73288 - -Humana Insurance Company - -12459 Medica Insurance Company - -71412 - -Mutual Of Omaha Insurance Company - -82538 - -National Health Insurance Company - -67091 - -Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company - -67326 - -Old Surety Life Insurance Company - -15777 - -Oscar Insurance Company - -68462 - -Reserve National Insurance Company - -14345 - -Sunflower State Health Plan Incorporated - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -72850 - -United World Life Insurance Company - -96385 - -UnitedHealthcare of Midwest Inc - -70319 Washington National Insurance Company - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -0.61% - -3.04% - -0.79% - -3.55% - -22.36% - -3.01% - -0.57% - -0.99% - -0.68% - -3.82% - -2.12% - -1.05% - -0.53% - -0.73% - -0.69% - -0.58% - -0.56% - -17.11% - -0.56% - -0.69% - -0.75% - -2.36% - -0.79% - -0 - -8 - -1 - -5 - -46 - -14 - -2 - -4 - -2 - -5 - -16 - -1 - -8 - -0 - -0 - -6 - -1 - -67 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -5 - -0.00 - -1.02 - -0.49 - -0.55 - -0.80 - -1.80 - -1.37 - -1.57 - -1.14 - -0.51 - -2.93 - -0.37 - -5.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -4.03 - -0.70 - -1.52 - -0.00 - -0.56 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -2.44 - -0.00 - -1.38 - -0.00 - -1.06 - -0.70 - -0.69 - -0.00 - -2.46 - -0.69 - -0.24 - -3.42 - -1.37 - -9.04 - -0.00 - -0.79 - -2.37 - -2.42 - -1.51 - -0.00 - -4.73 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -5.72 - -0.00 - -0.58 - -0.34 - -1.31 - -0.76 - -0.69 - -- - -- - -2.55 - -0.64 - -3.26 - -0.91 - -- - -- - -- - -- - -- - -1.72 - -- - -- - -0.00 - -0.00 - -3.27 - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -67.92% - -page 5 - -insurance.kansas.gov Indexes by line: Homeowners - -Cocode - -Company Name - -37907 - -Allstate Vehicle & Property Insurance Company - -19690 - -American Economy Insurance Company - -10386 - -American Family Insurance Company - -19275 - -American Family Mutual Insurance Company - -10872 - -American Strategic Insurance Corporation - -13773 - -Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -21652 - -Farmers Insurance Exchange - -26298 - -Farmers Property & Casualty Insurance Company - -20419 - -Homesite Indemnity Company - -14451 Marysville Mutual Insurance Company - -25453 - -Nationwide Insurance Company Of America - -23787 - -Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company - -24740 - -Safeco Insurance Company Of America - -23388 - -Shelter Mutual Insurance Company - -25143 - -State Farm Fire & Casualty Company - -27998 - -Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Company - -38130 - -Travelers Personal Insurance Company - -25941 - -United Services Automobile Association - -25968 - -USAA Casualty Insurance Company - -18600 - -USAA General Indemnity Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -4.36% - -1.47% - -4.98% - -8.70% - -1.35% - -6.25% - -4.85% - -1.22% - -1.41% - -1.20% - -1.70% - -2.10% - -1.70% - -2.48% - -21.08% - -3.42% - -4.39% - -2.61% - -1.39% - -1.23% - -77.89% - -21 - -2 - -13 - -14 - -6 - -13 - -7 - -3 - -5 - -4 - -3 - -1 - -7 - -5 - -78 - -9 - -10 - -2 - -3 - -6 - -1.63 - -0.46 - -0.89 - -0.55 - -1.51 - -0.70 - -0.49 - -0.83 - -1.20 - -1.13 - -0.60 - -0.16 - -1.39 - -0.68 - -1.25 - -0.89 - -0.77 - -0.26 - -0.73 - -1.65 - -0.86 - -- - -0.42 - -0.66 - -0.25 - -0.80 - -0.77 - -1.39 - -- - -1.14 - -- - -0.00 - -0.88 - -1.15 - -1.08 - -0.82 - -0.66 - -0.41 - -0.53 - -2.65 - -1.64 - -- - -1.10 - -0.75 - -0.86 - -0.81 - -1.36 - -0.00 - -- - -2.02 - -- - -- - -0.32 - -1.66 - -0.46 - -0.51 - -0.72 - -0.58 - -0.56 - -0.98 - -Indexes by line: Individual Annuity - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -Cocode - -Company Name - -90611 - -Allianz Life Insurance Company Of North America - -60488 - -American General Life Insurance Company - -61689 - -Athene Annuity & Life Company - -87726 - -Brighthouse Life Insurance Company - -62944 - -Equitable Financial Life Insurance Company - -63088 - -Farm Bureau Life Insurance Company - -63274 - -Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company - -91642 - -Forethought Life Insurance Company - -65056 - -Jackson National Life Insurance Company - -65676 - -Lincoln National Life Insurance Company - -66869 Nationwide Life Insurance Company - -91596 - -New York Life Insurance & Annuity Corporation - -66974 - -North American Company for Life & Health Insurance - -67466 - -Pacific Life Insurance Company - -86630 - -Prudential Annuity Life Assurance Corporation - -65005 - -RiverSource Life Insurance Company - -68675 - -Security Benefit Life Insurance Company - -62952 - -SILAC Insurance Company - -69345 - -Teachers Insurance & Annuity Association Of America - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -5.48% - -3.55% - -4.46% - -3.15% - -3.55% - -2.37% - -2.27% - -2.54% - -8.01% - -5.60% - -2.74% - -3.51% - -2.43% - -1.85% - -1.86% - -2.94% - -2.31% - -5.21% - -3.08% - -1.70% - -2 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -2 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1.18 - -0.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.91 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.27 - -0.81 - -0.58 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.40 - -0.62 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.77 - -2.35 - -0.00 - -2.24 - -1.34 - -7.38 - -0.00 - -1.23 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -0.00 - -0.53 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -68.62% - -1.15 - -1.72 - -1.93 - -- - -2.29 - -- - -1.12 - -0.77 - -- - -- - -- - -1.03 - -0.69 - -- - -- - -- - -0.84 - -- - -- - -- - -page 6 - -Complaint Index Report Indexes by line: Individual Life - -Cocode - -Company Name - -60399 - -American Family Life Insurance Company - -60488 - -American General Life Insurance Company - -63088 - -Farm Bureau Life Insurance Company - -65838 - -John Hancock Life Insurance Company USA - -58033 - -Knights Of Columbus - -65676 - -Lincoln National Life Insurance Company - -65935 Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company - -66044 Midland National Life Insurance Company - -91596 - -New York Life Insurance & Annuity Corporation - -66915 - -New York Life Insurance Company - -67091 - -Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company - -67466 - -Pacific Life Insurance Company - -67644 - -Penn Mutual Life Insurance Company - -65919 - -Primerica Life Insurance Company - -68136 - -Protective Life Insurance Company - -79227 - -Pruco Life Insurance Company - -68241 - -Prudential Insurance Company Of America - -69108 - -State Farm Life Insurance Company - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -69868 - -United Of Omaha Life Insurance Company - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -1.85% - -1.92% - -3.91% - -1.79% - -2.56% - -2.90% - -4.05% - -3.84% - -2.32% - -4.30% - -11.52% - -2.51% - -1.33% - -1.34% - -2.19% - -3.93% - -0.58% - -4.10% - -1.80% - -1.93% - -1.18% - -61.84% - -0 - -21 - -8 - -1 - -3 - -3 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -3 - -1 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -12 - -3 - -0 - -11 - -1 - -0.00 - -6.13 - -1.15 - -0.31 - -0.66 - -0.58 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.39 - -0.05 - -0.00 - -0.42 - -0.00 - -0.26 - -0.00 - -11.66 - -0.41 - -0.00 - -3.20 - -0.47 - -0.58 - -2.19 - -0.55 - -0.50 - -1.01 - -0.31 - -0.25 - -- - -0.00 - -0.38 - -0.24 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.58 - -2.09 - -0.14 - -- - -0.52 - -0.28 - -1.61 - -- - -0.49 - -3.76 - -0.34 - -0.00 - -0.35 - -0.27 - -0.13 - -- - -0.00 - -0.21 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.33 - -0.78 - -0.26 - -- - -0.21 - -0.25 - -2.69 - -- - -Indexes by line: Long-Term Care - -Cocode - -Company Name - -90611 - -Allianz Life Insurance Company Of North America - -61263 - -Bankers Life & Casualty Company - -70729 - -Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas Incorporated - -20443 - -Continental Casualty Company - -71404 - -Continental General Insurance Company - -70025 - -Genworth Life Insurance Company - -64211 - -Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company - -65838 - -John Hancock Life Insurance Company USA - -58033 - -Knights Of Columbus - -65935 Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company - -65978 Metropolitan Life Insurance Company - -71412 - -Mutual Of Omaha Insurance Company - -66915 - -New York Life Insurance Company - -69000 Northwestern Long Term Care Insurance Company - -68241 - -Prudential Insurance Company Of America - -65005 - -RiverSource Life Insurance Company - -25178 - -State Farm Mutual Auto Insurance Company - -56014 - -Thrivent Financial For Lutherans - -86231 - -Transamerica Life Insurance Company - -62235 - -Unum Life Insurance Company Of America - -2021 Market Share - -2021 Complaints - -2021 Complaint -Index - -2020 Complaint -Index - -2019 Complaint -Index - -2.16% - -9.45% - -2.07% - -3.02% - -1.66% - -17.08% - -3.41% - -9.49% - -3.07% - -1.40% - -4.92% - -4.61% - -3.06% - -6.03% - -2.44% - -1.47% - -3.00% - -2.38% - -4.61% - -3.00% - -9 - -6 - -2 - -4 - -0 - -15 - -1 - -1 - -0 - -0 - -1 - -0 - -3 - -0 - -3 - -0 - -0 - -0 - -7 - -2 - -5.63 - -0.86 - -1.30 - -1.79 - -0.00 - -1.19 - -0.40 - -0.14 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.27 - -0.00 - -1.33 - -0.00 - -1.66 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -2.05 - -0.90 - -2.42 - -0.64 - -0.34 - -3.35 - -1.35 - -1.24 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -- - -1.86 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -1.07 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -0.00 - -3.21 - -0.00 - -1.78 - -0.76 - -0.82 - -0.81 - -0.73 - -0.32 - -- - -0.14 - -- - -- - -1.15 - -0.94 - -- - -0.23 - -- - -- - -0.81 - -- - -6.39 - -- - -% of total market share represented in this report: - -88.33% - -page 7 - -insurance.kansas.gov Filing a Complaint -The Kansas Insurance Department’s Consumer Assistance Division provides free help to consumers. -Trained representatives can answer questions about your coverage or assist when you have a dispute -with your insurance company. - -How to file a complaint - -If you have tried unsuccessfully to resolve a problem with your insurance company or agent, we -encourage you to contact the insurance department. You may file a complaint online through our -website, by mail or email. We also accept complaints in-person. - -If you do need to file a formal complaint, we require the following information: - -• Your name - -• Your address - -• Your email address (if applicable) - -• The policy number - -• A clear, concise written explanation of your -complaint — this can be sent by postal mail, -fax, or filed through our website - -• Your daytime telephone number - -• Copies of supporting letters, police reports, - -• Type of insurance involved (automobile, - -homeowners, etc.) - -• The name of the insurance company, agent - -or adjuster - -notes, etc. - -• Tell us what has been done, including who -you’ve talked to and what you were told -(names, dates, times, places, etc.) - -• Desired outcome - -Do not send originals of any of your records, and keep a copy of the letter you send us. - -Contact the Kansas Insurance Department - -WEBSITE - -insurance.kansas.gov - -SOCIAL - -KSinsurancedept - -EMAIL - -kid.commissioner@ks.gov -kid.webcomplaints@ks.gov - -ADDRESS - -1300 SW Arrowhead Rd. -Topeka, KS 66604 - -PHONE - -Main: 785-296-3071 -Fax: 785-296-7805 - -CONSUMER ASSISTANCE -HOTLINE - -800-432-2484 - -page 8 - -Complaint Index Report 1300 SW ARROWHEAD ROAD -TOPEKA, KS 66604 -1-800-432-2484 -(785) 296-3071 - -INSURANCE.KANSAS.GOV -KID.COMMISSIONER@KS.GOV -(785) 296-7805 (FAX) -1-877-235-3151 (TTY/TDD) - -Vicki Schmidt, Commissioner -insurance.kansas.gov - -page 9 - -insurance.kansas.gov \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q7/random_k4/random_3.md b/q7/random_k4/random_3.md index 510efcdbde69ac509e9a3fa23225deb77871706d..c628675fbe529d89838de1ae7c364d79b8d4ce01 100644 --- a/q7/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q7/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,1380 +1,1223 @@ -ARYAMAN -FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED - -T= ARYAM AN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED = -| BOARD OF DIRECTORS | | P.V.R Murthy | Director | -| ------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -------- | -| | | Virender Ganda - | Director | -| | | Mohan Datari - | Director | -| | | M.V. Ramana - | Director | -| | | Suhas Ganpule - | Director | -| REGISTERED OFFICE | | : 401, Chiranjiv Towers | | -43, Nehru Place, -New Delhi 110019 -| CORPORATE | OFFICE | : 208, Maker Chamber V, | | -| ---------- | ------- | ------------------------ | --- | -2nd -Floor, Nariman Point, -Mumbai-400021. -| AUDITORS | | : M/s. Thakur Vaidynath Aiyar & Co. | | -| --------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Chartered Accountants -212, Deendayal Upadhyay Marg. -New Delhi. -| BANKERS | | : State Bank Of India | | -| -------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -The Vysya Bank Limited -State Bank of Patiala -Indusind Bank Ltd. -| Share Transfer Agent | | : Adroit Corporate Services Pvt. Ltd. | | -| --------------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -19, Jaferbhoy Industrial Estate. lsl Floor. -Makwana Road, Marol Naka, -Andheri (W), Mumbai - 400059. - -r -7= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -NOTICE -"RESOLVED THAT in accordance with the -| | | | | provision of section | | 257 and all other | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -NOTICE is hereby given that the 11™ ANNUAL -| | | | | applicable provisions, if any, of | | | the | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -GENERAL MEETING of the Members of the -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES companies Act 1956 or any statutory -modifications or reenactment thereof, Shri -| LIMITED will be held on | | Thursday, 29th | | | | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Suhas S Ganpule, who was appointed as -| day December 2005 at 10.00 a.m. at its | | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Additional Director in pursuant to section -registered office 401, Chiranjiv Towers, 43, -Nehru Place, New Delhi 110 019 to transact 260 of companies Act, 1956 be and hereby -appointed as Director of the company -the following business: -subject to retirement by rotation under the -ORDINARY BUSINESS provisions of Article of Association of the -company". -1. To receive, consider and adopt the Balance -Sheet as at June 30, 2005 and the Profit and 6. To consider and if thought fit to pass with -Loss Account for the year ended on that date or without any modification, the -| | | | | following | resolution | as Ordinary | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | -and the Reports of Directors and Auditors -Resolution- -thereon. -"RESOLVED THAT in accordance with the -2. To appoint a director in place of Shri Mohan -| | | | | provision of section 257 and | | all other | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | -Datari, who retires by rotation, and being -| | | | | applicable | provisions, | if any, of | the | -| ------------ | ---------------- | ---- | --- | ----------- | ------------------------- | ----------- | --- | -| eligible, | offers himself | for | re- | | | | | -| appointment. | | | | companies | Act 1956 or any statutory | | | -modifications or reenactment thereof, Shri -Manmohan Baliga, who was appointed as -| 3. To appoint | Auditors and | to fix | their | | | | | -| --------------- | ------------- | -------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -| remuneration. | | | | Additional Director in pursuant to section | | | | -260 of companies Act, 1956 be and hereby -| | | | | appointed | as Director of the company | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | -SPECIAL BUSINESS -subject to retirement by rotation under the -4. To consider and if thought fit to pass with provisions of Article of Association of the -company". -or without any modification, the following -resolution as Ordinary Resolution- -7. To consider and if thought fit to pass with -" RESOLVED THAT in accordance with the or without any modification, the -| | | | | following | resolution | as Ordinary | | -| ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | -| provision | of section | 257 and | all other | | | | | -Resolution- -| applicable | provisions, | if any, | of the | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| companies | Act 1956 | or any statutory | | | | | | -modifications or reenactment thereof, Shri "RESOLVED THAT in suppersession of the -earlier resolutions passed under Section -Munnangi Venkat Ramanna, who was -293 (l)(d) of the Companies Act, 1956, the -| appointed | as Additional | Director | in | | | | | -| ---------- | --------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -pursuant to section 260 of the Companies Board of Directors of the Company be and -is hereby authorised to borrow from time -Act, 1956 be and is hereby appointed as -to time all such sums of money as they -| Director | of the | company subject | to | | | | | -| --------- | -------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -may deem necessary for the purpose of -retirement by rotation under the provisions -of Article of Association of the company". business of the Company -| | | | | notwithstanding | that moneys to be | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ----------------- | --------------- | --- | -| | | | | borrowed | together | with the moneys | | -5. To consider and if thought fit to pass with -or without any modification, the following already borrowed by the Company (apart -resolution as Ordinary Resolution- from temporary loans (including working - -7= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -capital facilities) obtained from the remuneration, costs, charges expenses and -Company's bankers in the ordinary course all other monies payable by the Company -of business) (hereinafter referred to as the to the concerned Lenders, and/or Agents -"Borrowings") shall exceed the aggregate and Trustees for debentures provided that -of the paid-up capital of the Company and the amount of loans (other than temporary -its free reserves, that is to say reserves not loans (including working capital facilities) -set apart for any specific purpose provided obtained from the Company's bankers in -that the total amount of the Borrowings the ordinary course of buinsess) shall not -by the Board of Directors shall not exceed exceed Rs. 50 Crores." -Rs. 25 crores (Rupees Twenty Five Crores -Only)." "RESOLVED FURTHER THAT the Board of -Directors of the Company be and is hereby -8. To consider and if thought fit to pass with authorised to finalise with any of the -or without any modification, the following Lenders, or other persons, jointly or -resolution as Ordinary Resolution- severally, the documents for creating -aforesaid mortgage/charge and to do all -"RESOLVED THAT in supersession of the such acts, deeds, matters and things as may -earlier resolutions passed under section be considered necessary, desirable or -293(l)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956 (the expedient for implementing the Resolution -"Act"), consent of the Company be and is and to resolve any question, difficulty or -hereby accorded in terms of section doubt which may arise in relation thereto -293(l)(a) and other applicable provisions, or otherwise considered by the Board of -if any, of the Act, to mortgaging and/or Directors to be in the best interest of the -charging by the Board of Directors of the Company." -Company of all or any of the immovable -and/or movable properties of the By Order of the Board -Company, wheresoever situated, both -present and future, or the whole or Place: Mumbai -substantially the whole of the undertaking Date: December 01, 2005 -or undertakings of the Company on such For Aryaman Financial Services Limited -terms, in such form and in such manner -as the Board of Directors may think fit, -together with power to take over the Prasanna Chandwaskar -management of the business and concern Company Secretary -of the Company in certain events in favour -of Banks, Financial Institutions, other A MEMBER ENTITLED TO ATTEND AND -investing agencies and trustees for the VOTE IS ENTITLED TO APPOINT ONE -holders of Debentures / other instruments, OR MORE PROXIES TO ATTEND AND -for securing, inter alia, any loans (both VOTE INSTEAD OF HIMSELF AND A -rupee loans as well as foreign currency PROXY NEED NOT BE A MEMBER OF -loans) and/or advances already obtained THE COMPANY. Proxies, in order to be -or debts already incurred or that may effective, should be duly stamped, -hereafter be obtained or incurred from any completed, signed and deposited at the -of the lenders and/or to secure any Registered Office of the Company not less -debentures issued/that may be issued, than 48 hours before the Meeting. -and/or any financial obligations/ -commitment hereinafter collectively The Register of Members and Share Transfer -referred to as the "Loans") and all interest, Books of the Company will remain -compound / additional interest, closed from Monday, December 26, 2005 -commitment charges, Trustees' to Thursday, December 29, 2005 (both - -F ARYAMAN FIN ANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -Place : Mumbai -| EXPLANATORY | | STATEMENT | | AS | | | -| -------------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------------------- | ---------- | --- | -| | | | | Date : December 01, 2005 | ForAryaman | | -| REQUIRED BY SECTION | | | 173(2) OF | | | | -THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956. Financial Services Limited -Prasanna Chandwaskar -ITEM NO. 4, 5 & 6 -| Shri Munnangi V Ramana, Shri Suhas S | | | | Company Secretary | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -Ganpule and Shri Baliga were appointed as -DIRECTOR'S REPORT -Additional Directors in accordance with the -provisions of section -| 260 of the Companies | | Act, 1956 at Board | | TO THE MEMBERS | | | -| --------------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -Meeting held on December 20, 2004, May -Your Directors present the Eleventh -02,2005 and December 1,2005 respectively. -Annual Report and audited accounts of -The Company has received notice from the -your -shareholder of the Company under section -Company for the financial year ended -| 257 of the Companies | | Act, 1957 for | | the | | | -| --------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -June 30, 2005. -appointment of Shri Ramana, Shri Ganpule -and Shri Baliga as Director of the Company, -| | | | | FINANCIAL RESULTS | (Rs. in lakhs) | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | -------------- | --- | -at the ensuing Annual General Meeting. -| | | | | Particulars | 30th June, | 31s1 March, | -| --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | -| The Board recommends | | the approval of | | | | | -| | | | | | 2005 | 2004 | -resolution by way of simple majority. -| | | | | Income from operations | 27.67 | 81.44 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ----- | ----- | -None of the directors except Shri Munnangi Less- Expenditure 35.21 86.73 -(5.29) -V Ramana, Shri Suhas Ganpule and Shri Profit before Depreciation (7.54) -(6.49) -Baliga, are in any way concerned or Less -Depreciation (5.03) -| | | | | Profit before tax | (12.57) | (11.78) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ------- | ------- | -interested in the said resolution at 4, 5 & 6 -| respectively. | | | | Provision for tax | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -(269.64) -| | | | | Balance carried to | (281.42) | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | -------- | -------- | -| | | | | Balance Sheet | (293.99) | (281.42) | -ITEM NO. 7 & 8 -The Board of Directors in its meeting held -DIVIDEND -| on 30th August, | | 2005 has approved | | the | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Due to absence of profits, the Director -| expansion | of the Company's | | existing | | | | -| ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -do not recommend any dividend for the -activities. -year. -| Considering | the expansion | | proposals | | | | -| ------------ | -------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | -DEPOSITS -| entailing borrowings | | the limits specified | | | | | -| --------------------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -pursuant to Sections 293 (1) (a) and (d) of -| | | | | Your company did not accept/ | | hold any | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | -------- | -the Companies Act, 1956 vide the existing -deposit from public/ shareholders during -resolutions passed by the members of the -the year under review. -Company would be inadequate and hence -the same needs to be suitably increased. -DIRECTORS -The Board recommends the approval of -Shri Mohan Datari, Director of the company -resolution by way of simple majority. -retire by rotation and offers himself for -reappointment. -None of the directors of the Company is -concerned or interested in the resolution. -The shareholders are requested to appoint to -Shri Munnangi V Ramana, Shri Suhas S -By Order of the Board -Ganpule Shri Mohan Baliga as Directors - -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -of the company, they were appointed as The Board wish to place record their -additional Directors under section 260 of the gratitude for their continued co-operation, -Companies Act, 1956 on your Board and the assistance and guidance extended by the -Company has received notice under section banks, clients, stock exchange, members -257 of the Companies Act, 1956 for their and associates. -candidature for appointment of Directors -of the Company. CONSERVATION OF ENERGY -TECHNICAL ABSORBATION, FOREIGN -AUDITORS EXCHANGE EARNING AND OUTGO -M/s Thakur Vidyanath Aiyar & Co, The company is not engaged in any -Chartered Accountants retire at the manufacturing activity and therefore -forthcoming Annual General Meeting and provisions of section 217 (1) (e) of the -eligible for the reappointment. companies Act, 1956 is not applicable. -Comments made by the Auditors in their -report are self-explanatory and therefore CORPORATE GOVERNANCE: -do not call for any further explanations. -During the year under report, your -DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT Company has evolved Corporate -Governance practices. The required -As required under section 217 (2 A A) of the structures for governance have been in -companies, Act 1956 your Directors state:- place and the meetings are periodically -i. While preparing annual accounts the held in compliance with the ideal practices -applicable accounting standards have been prescribed under the code. -followed. -ii. Company has selected such accounting Management Discussion and Analysis -policies and applied them consistently and Report is separately given in the Annual -made judgment that are responsible and Report. A separate report on Corporate -prudent which give true and fair view of Governance is annexed hereto as a part of -affairs of the company. this report. A certificate from the Auditors -iii. Company has taken proper and sufficient of the Company regarding compliance of -care for the maintenance of adequate conditions of Corporate Governance as -accounting records in accordance with the prescribed under Clause 49 of the Listing -provisions of the Act for safeguarding the Agreement is attached to this report. -assets of the company and the preventing -and detecting fraud and other irregularities. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT -iv. Company has prepared accounts on -Your Directors would like to express deep -ongoing concern basis. -sense of appreciation for the assistance arid -co-operation received from the Financial -PERSONNEL -Institutions, Banks, Government -Relations between the management and Authorities and Shareholders and for the -employees were company cordial. Your devoted services by the Executives, Staff -Directors wish to place on record and Workers of the Company. -appreciation of service rendered by all the -staff members. There is no employee who For and on the behalf of the Board -draws salary in excess of the limits as -Director -prescribed under section 217 (2A) of the -companies (Particular of Employees Rules) Place: Mumbai -1975 as amended. Date: December 01, 2005 - -P= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -dependant upon conditions of primary -| MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION | | | AND | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | and secondary | | capital | market. Any | | -ANALYSIS REPORT. -adverse effect on the capital market could -| | | | | affect the performance and | | | | profitability | -| ------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -| 1. INDUSTRY | STRUCTURE | | AND | | | | | | -of your Company. -DEVELOPMENTS -Merchant Banking and Financial Services -6. INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEMS -market is fast growing over the last few -The company has an adequate system of -years. Merchant Banker services includes -internal controls that ensure that all assets -providing merchant banking services like -Public Issue Management i.e, acting as are protected against loss from -unauthorized use or disposition and all -| manager / | lead manager to the public | | | | | | | | -| ---------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -transaction are recorded and reported in -| issues, right issues, open | | offer | under | | | | | | -| --------------------------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ----------- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | --- | -| | | | | conformity | with | generally accepted | | | -| Takeover | Code, Buy | Back | Scheme, | | | | | | -accounting principles. -Portfolio Management Services, private -placement of debt and equity instruments. -7. FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE -The present position of stock market in -India has opened new era for finance The company has achieved a turnover of -| | | | | Rs 27.67 during | | the year as | | against | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -industry. -| | | | | Rs.81.44 | lacs | in the | corresponding | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | -previous year. During the year company -2. OPPORTUNITY AND THREATS -| Opportunities: | | | | incurred a profit/ | | | loss of Rs. 12.57 as | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | -againstRs.il.78 lacs in the corresponding -Aryaman Financial Services Limited is -previous year. -SEBI registered Category - I. Considering -present capital marVet conditions, your -company has tremendous opportunities in 8. HUMAN RESOURSE AND -INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS -its business activities especially merchant -The industrial relation remain co ordinal -banking activities like issue management, -during the year under review. -portfolio management services, corporate -debt restructuring etc. -9. CAUTIONARY STATEMENT -Statement in this report on management -Threats: -| | | | | Discussion | and analysis describing the | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -With the number of players coming down, -| | | | | company's | objectives, | | projections, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | -we expect marginal competition. -estimates, expectations or prediction are -| | | | | based | on certain | | assumption | and | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | -3. SEGMENTWISE PERFORMANCE -Your Company is dealing in one segment expectation of future events. Actual result -| | | | | could | differ | materially from | | those | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | -mainly in Merchant Banking activity. -| | | | | expressed | or implied. The company | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | assume | no responsibility to amend, | | | | -4. OUTLOOK -The growing economy and vibrant capital modify or revise any of the statements on -the basis of subsequent developments, -market conditions promise good scope for -information or events. -financial service sector. Your company is -well prepared to seize the opportunities as -and when they come. The management is For on behalf of the Board -| generally | optimistic | about | future | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Director -operations. -| 5. RISKS AND CINCERNS | | | Place: Mumbai | | | | | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Date: 01.12.2005 -| Company's | activities | are | mainly | | | | | | -| ---------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -r ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -c) The Balance Sheet, the Profit and loss account -AUDITORS' REPORT -and Cash Flow statement dealt with by this -report are in agreement with the books of -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD. -account. -| | | | d) | In our opinion, the Balance Sheet, the | | Profit | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | -We have audited the attached Balance Sheet of -and Loss Account and the Cash Flow Statement -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD as -at 30th June, 2005 and the Profit and Loss dealt with by this report comply with the -accounting standards referred to in subsection -Account and also the Cash Flow Statement for -| | | | | (3C) of section | 211 of the Companies Act, | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | --- | -the year ended on that date annexed thereto. -1956; -These financial statements are the responsibility -| of the Company's | | management. | Our | | | | -| ------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | | e) | On the basis of the written representations | | | -responsibility is to express an opinion on these -received from the directors, as on 30th June. -financial statements based on our audit. -2005, and taken on record by the Board of -We have conducted our audit in accordance with Directors, we report that none of the directors -is disqualified as on 30th June, 2005 from being -auditing standards generally accepted in India. -appointed as a director in terms of clause (g) -| These Standards | require that we plan and | | | | | | -| ---------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance of sub-section (1) of section 274 of the -Companies Act, 1956; -about whether the financial statements are free -of material misstatement. An audit includes -| | | | f) | In our opinion and to the best of our information | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting -the amounts and disclosures in the financial and according to the explanations given to us, -the said accounts give the information required -statements. An audit also includes assessing the -by the Companies Act, 1956, in the manner so -| accounting principles used and | | significant | | | | | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---------------- | ------------- | -| | | | | required and | give a true and | fair view in | -| estimates made by management, | | as well as | | | | | -evaluating the overall financial statement conformity with the accounting principles -presentation. We believe that our audit provides generally accepted in India : -a reasonable basis for our opinion. -| | | | a. | In the case of the Balance Sheet, of the state of | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -30'h June. 2005 ; -As required by the Companies (Auditors' affairs of the Company as at -and -| Report) Order, | 2003 issued by the Central | | | | | | -| --------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Government of India in terms of subsection -| | | | | b. In the case of the Profit and loss account, of | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -(4A) of Section 227 of the Companies Act, -1956, we enclose in the Annexure a statement the loss for the year ended on that date. -on the matter specified in paragraph 4 and 5 of -| | | | c. | In the case of the Cash Flow Statement, of the | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -the said order. -| | | | | cash flow for the year ended on | | that date. | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | -| Further to our comments in the Annexure | | | | | | | -referred to above, we report that: -For THAKUR VAIDYANATH AIYAR & CO. -Chartered Accountants. -| a) We have obtained all the | | information | and | | | | -| ----------------------------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -| explanations, | which to | the best | of our | | | | -Place:- Mumbai -| knowledge and belief were necessary | | | for the | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | -purpose of our audit. -| | | | ( | C.V. Parameswar) | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -b) In our opinion, proper books of account as -Partner -required by law have been kept by the Company -Dated :- 01-12-2005 -so far as appears from our examination of those -M. No. 11541 -books; - -17= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -have not observed any continuing failure to -ANNEXURE REFERRED TO IN -PARAGRAPH 1 OF OUR REPORT OF correct major weakness and on the basis of -such checks carried out by us during the course -EVEN DATE ON THE ACCOUNTS FOR -THE YEAR ENDED 30th JUNE, 2005. of our audit, the company has an adequate -| | | | internal control | procedures commensurate | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -In respect of Fixed Assets with the size and nature of its business. -The company has maintained proper records v. In respect of transactions covered under -a) -showing full particulars including quantitative Section 301 of the Companies Act. 1956 -details and situation of fixed assets. -| | | | a) In our | opinion and | according | to the | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | ---------- | ------- | -b) As explained to us, the fixed assets have been -physically verified by the management during information and explanations given to us, the -the year and no material discrepancy was transactions that need to be entered into the -register maintained under Section 301 of the -noticed on such verification. -.) The company has not disposed / discarded any Act, have been so entered. -of its fixed assets during the year. -b) As per the information and explanations given -to us, there are no transactions of purchase -ii. In respect of inventories -The company is in the business of providing and sales of services have been made in -financial services and in view of this Para 4 (ii) pursuance of contracts or arrangements -| | | | entered | in the register maintained under | | | -| --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -(a), (b) & (c) of the said order are not applicable -| | | | Section | 301 of the companies | | Act. 1956. | -| --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | ---------- | -to the company. -aggregating during the year to Rs.5 Lakhs or -iii. In respect of loans, Secured and unsecured, more in respect of each party. -| Granted or taken | by the company | to / from | | | | | -| ----------------- | --------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Companies, firms or other parties listed in the vi. As per the information and explanations given -register maintained under Section 301 of the to us, the company has not accepted any -companies Act. 1956 : deposits from the public within the meaning -of Section 58A and 58AA of the Act and rules -a) The company has not granted any loan to framed there under. -Companies, Firms or other parties listed in the -register maintained unHer section 301 of The vii In our opinion, the company has an internal -audit system, which is commensurate with the -| Companies Act, | 1956. | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -b) In view of our comment Para 4 (iii) (a) the size and nature of its business. -clauses (b), (c) and (d) are not applicable to the -| company. | | | viii We have | been informed that | | the central | -| -------- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------------------- | --- | ------------ | -government has not prescribed maintenance -| c) The company has not taken any loan | | from | | | | | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Companies, Firms or other parties listed in the of cost records under Section 209( 1 )(d) of the -register maintained under section 301 of The companies Act. 1956. -| Companies Act, | 1956. | | | | | | -| --------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ix In respect of statutory dues -| cO In view of our comment | Para 4 (iii) (c) | the | | | | | -| --------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -clauses (f) and (g) are not applicable to the -| company. | | | a) The company has been generally regular in | | | | -| -------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -depositing undisputed statutory dues including -iv. In our opinion and according to information Provident fund, Investors education and -and explanations given to us there are adequate Protection fund, Employees state insurance. -control procedures commensurate with the size Income Tax, Sales Tax, Wealth Tax, Service -| | | | Tax, Custom Duty, Excise Duty, Cess | | | and | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -of the company and the nature of its business -| | | | other statutory dues with the | | | appropriate | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | -with regard to purchase of fixed assets and sale -of services. During the course of our audit, we authorities. According to the information and - -p ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -given any guarantee for loans taken by -explanation given to us, no undisputed amounts -payable in respect of the aforesaid dues were others from banks or financial -| outstanding as it 30th June, 2005 for a period of | | | institutions. | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -more than six months from the date they became -payable except Profession Tax dues of Rs. 10507 xvi. The company has not raised any term -- and Income Tax(TDS Payable) Rs.1,06,864/- loans during the year. -xvii. On the basis of our examination of -b) Based on the information made available to us -and explanation given to us, the details of dues balance sheet it appears that the funds -which have not been deposited on account of raised on short term basis are not used -for long term basis and vice versa. -dispute are given below : -Particulars Assessment year Forum where -Amount For which the matter dispute is xviii. The company has not made any -(Rs. In Lakhs) preferential allotment of shares during -| Pertains to pending | | | the year to parties | and companies | | -| ------------------- | ------- | ----- | ---------------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | -| Income Tax | 1997-98 | | covered in the register maintained under | | | -| CIT (Appeals) | | 26.53 | section 301 of the companies Act. 1956. | | | -x. The accumulated loss of the company is not xix. The company has not issued any -more than 50% of its net worth and the company debentures during the year and therefore -has incurred cash loss during financial year para 4 (xix) of the order is not applicable -| covered by our audit and the company had not | | | to the company. | | | -| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -incurred cash loss in the immediately preceding -| financial year. | | | xx. The company has not raised any money | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -by way public issue during the year. -xi. Based on our audit procedures and according -to the information and explanation given to us xxi. During the course of our examination of -we are of the opinion that the company has not the books and records of the company -defaulted in repayments of dues to the financial carried out in accordance with generally -accepted auditing practices in India and -institution, banks or debenture holders. -| | | | according | to information | and | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------- | --- | -xii. In our opinion and according to the information explanation given to us we have neither -and explanations given to us no loans and come across any instance of fraud on or -advances have been granted by the company by the company during the year, nor have -on the basis of security by way of pledge of the we been informed of such case by the -| shares, debenture & other securities. | | | management. | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | --- | -| xiii. The company is not a chit fund | | or a nidhi / | | | | -mutual benefit funds / society. Therefore para ForThakur Vaidyanath Aiyar & Co. -4 (xiii) is not applicable to the company. Chartered Accountants -xiv. Based on information and explanation given to -| us, the company is not dealing or trading in | | | Place: Mumbai | | | -| ---------------------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -| shares, securities, | debentures | and other | | | | -| investments and hence the requirements of para | | | (C.V. Parameswar) | | | -4 (xiv) of the order are not applicable to the -| company. | | | Partner | | | -| -------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | Date: 01-12-2005 | M.No. 11541 | | -xv. In our opinion and according to the information -& explanation given to us, the company has not - -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -CERTIFICATE -To the Members of Aryaman Financial Services Ltd. -We have examined the compliance of conditions of Corporate Governance by Aryaman Financial -Services Ltd. for the year 30th June, 2005 as stipulated in clause 49 of the Listing Agreement -executed by the said Company with stock exchanges. -The Compliance of conditions of Corporate Governance is the responsibility of the Management. -Our examination was limited to procedures and implementation thereof, adopted by the Company -for ensuring the compliance of the conditions of the Corporate Governance, It is neither an audit -nor an expression of opinion on the financial statements of the Company. -In our opinion and to the best of our information and according to the explanations given to us -we invite your attention to the following. -1. Audit Committee / Remuneration Committee / Shareholders / Investors Grievance Committee as -required by clause 49 of the Listing Agreement is not formed till the end of the accounting year. -2. Means of Communication regarding publication of Quarterly results in the news papers are not -complied with. -Subject to above we certify that the Company has complied with the conditions of Corporate -Governance as stipulated in the above-mentioned Listing Agreement. -We have to state that no investor grievance is pending for a period exceeding one month against the -company as per the records maintained by the registrar & share transfer agents of the company. -We further state that such compliance is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company -nor the efficiency or effectiveness with which the Management has conducted the affairs of the -Company. -For and on behalf of -Thakur Vaidyanath Aiyar & Co. -Chartered Accountants. -C.V.Parameswar -Partner. -Date : 1st December, 2005 M.No.11541 -Place : Mumbai - -1= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REPORT - 2005 -PHILOSOPHY ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE : -Board of Directors of the Company acts as a trustee and assumes fiduciary responsibility of -protecting the interests of the shareholders and other stakeholders of the Company. Board -supports the broad principles of Corporate Governance. In order to attain the highest level of -good Corporate Governance practice, Board lays strong emphasis on transparency, -accountability and integrity. -Board of Directors -Composition and category of directors; attendance of each director at the board meetings and -the last AGM; number of other Public Companies on the Board or Committees of which a -director is a member or chairperson; and number of board meetings, dates on which held, are -as under: -Board Meeting Attended during the Year 2004-05 Attendance at the Last AGM -Name of Director Category (attended) -Shri PVR Murthy* E & NI 3 Yes -Shri Virendra Ganda NE & I 8 Yes -Shri Mohan Dattary NE & 1 8 Yes -Shri Munnangi V Ramana** NE & I 5 N.A. -Shri Suhas Ganpule*** NE & II N.A. -E - Executive, NE - Non Executive, I - Independent, NI - Non Independent -* Resigned w.e.f. December 24, 2004 , -** Appointed w.e.f December 20, 2004 -*** Appointed w.e.f. May 02, 2005 -8 Meetings of the board of directors were held during the financial year 2004-05. One each on -April 30,2004, July 29,2004, October 28,2004, December 20,2004, December 24,2005, January -28, 2005, March 22, 2005 and May 18, 2005 -AUDIT COMMITTEE -Terms of reference : -The terms of reference stipulated by the Board of Directors to the Audit Committee are as -contained under clause 49 of the Listing Agreement. -Composition: -The Audit Committee was constituted by the Board of Directors in the meeting held on -December 01, 2005. The composition of the Committee and attendance of the members is -given hereunder: - -r ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -| Name of Member | Member/ Chairman | Category | -| ----------------------- | ----------------- | -------- | -| Shri Baliga | Chairman | NE & I | -| Shri Mohan Datari | Member | NE & I | -| Shri Munnangi V Ramana | Member | NE & I | -E - Executive, NE - Non Executive, I - Independent, NI - Non Independent -The Company Secretary of the Company, Shri Prasanna Chandwaskar is the Secretary of the -Committee. Director Finance, Internal Auditors and Statutory Auditors are the permanent invitees -to the Audit Committee Meeting. -REMUNERATION COMMITTEE -The Remuneration Committee was constituted by the Board of Directors in its meeting held on -December 01, 2005. No meeting of the Committee was held during the year. The terms of -reference, compositions are as under: -Terms of reference: To recommend appointment of Managerial Personnel and consider the -remuneration payable to them and review thereof from time to time. -Composition: -| Name of Member | Member/ Chairman | | -| ----------------------- | ---------------- | --- | -| Shri Mohan Datari | Chairman | | -| Shri Baliga | Member | | -| Shri Munnangi V Ramana | Member | | -E - Executive, NE - Non Executive, I - Independent, NI - Non Independent -REMUNERATION TO EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS: -The details of remuneration paid/ payable to the directors for the Financial Year 2004-05 are as under: -Shri PVR Murthy - Managing Director (Resigned w.e.f. December 24, 2004) -(Rs.) -| Salary & Allowances | 60000/- | | -| -------------------- | ------- | --- | -| Perquisites | 42000/- | | -Remuneration to Non-Executive Directors: -The Non-executive directors do not draw any remuneration from the Company. Non-executive -independent directors are entitled to the sitting fees for every meeting of the Board and Audit -Committee attended. -Non-executive independent directors are paid Rs. 1500/- for attending Board Meeting and Rs. -1OOO/- for Audit Committee. - -T ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -SHARE TRANSFER AND INVESTOR GRIEVANCE COMMITTEE: -The Share Transfer Committee was constituted by the Board of Directors at its meeting held -on December 01, 2005. The Committee consist of Shri Munnangi V Ramana and Shri -Baliga, all being a non-executive director. The Committee meets once in a fortnight. -Compliance Officer: Shri Prasanna Chandwaskar, Company Secretary. -Number of Shareholders complaints received during the year : -During the Year under review, total no Investor complaints were received and no complaint is pending -as at November 30, 2005 for a period over 30 days. -MANAGEMENT: -a. Management Discussion and Analysis -Management Discussion and Analysis of various businesses of the Company is separately given -in the Annual Report. -b. Disclosures by management to the Board -All details relating to financial and commercial transactions where directors may have a pecuniary -interest are provided to the Board, and the interested directors neither participate in the discussion, -nor do they vote on such matters. -GENERAL BODY MEETINGS: -The details of Annual General Meetings held in the last three years are given hereunder. -Meeting Day & Date of Meeting Time Place -10* Annual Gen. Meeting Thursday, September 30,2004 11.30a.m. 401. Chirnjiv Towers. -43. Nehru Place. -New Delhi-1)0 0)9 -9th Annual General Meeting Tuesday, September 30,2003 11.30 a.m. A- 293. Shivalik. Geetanjali -Panchsheel Road. -New Delhi-1100! 7 -8ch Annual General Meeting Monday, December 30,2002 11.30a.m. B-47. Shivalik, Geetanjali -Panchsheel Road. -New Delhi-110017 -DISCLOSURE -There are no related party transactions. -Details of information on appointment of new directors -Reappointment Directorship held in other Companies Committee positions in various Companies -Name of the Director Appointment -Shri Munnangi V Ramana December 20, 2004 -Shri Suhas Ganpule May 02, 2005 - -F= ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -Details of non-compliance -There was no non compliance by the Company, nor there was any penalties or strictures -imposed on the company by the Stock Exchange or SEBI or any authority on any matter -related to capital market during the last 3 years. -MEANS OF COMMUNICATION -The quarterly results are not published in the News papers -Management Discussion and Analysis form part of this Annual Report. -GENERAL SHAREHOLDER INFORMATION -AGM will be held on Thursday, December 29, 2005 at 10.00 a.m. at the registered office. -Financial Year of the Company : April 01, 2004 to June 30, 2005 -Date of Book Closure: December 26, 2005 to December 29, 2005 (Both days inclusive) -Dividend payment date: Not applicable. -Listing on Stock Exchanges: Mumbai Stock Exchange Limited, Delhi Stock Exchange and -Ahmedabad Stock Exchange Limited. -| Stock Code: | Bombay Stock Exchange Limited | | : 530245 | | -| ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | -------- | --- | -Market Price Data: High & Low price of equity shares on Stock Exchange shares of the Company -are infrequently traded on the exchanges. -| Month | | High Amount (Rs.) | Low Amount (Rs.) | | -| ----------- | --- | ------------------ | ---------------- | ---- | -| April-2004 | | 1.21 | | 0.82 | -May-2004 -| June-2004 | | 0.80 | | 0.69 | -| ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | -July-2004 -| August - 2004 | | 0.69 | | 0.63 | -| ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ---- | -| September - 2004 | | 0.82 | | 0.75 | -| October - 2004 | | 1.70 | | 0.90 | -| November - 2004 | | 2.02 | | 2.01 | -| December - 2004 | | 2.69 | | 1.93 | -| January - 2005 | | 4.60 | | 2.76 | -| February - 2005 | | 5.50 | | 2.10 | -| March-2005 | | 3.10 | | 2.00 | -| April-2005 | | 3.96 | | 2.01 | -| May-2005 | | 7.32 | | 3.15 | -| June-2005 | | 6.90 | | 4.06 | -Performance in comparison to broad-based indices i.e. BSE Sensex is as under: - -| r ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED | | | = | -| ----------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | ---- | -| Month | BSE Index | Closing price of Shares (Rs.) | | -| April - 2004 | 5655.09 | | 0.82 | -| May - 2004 | 4759.62 | | | -| June - 2004 | 4795.46 | | 0.69 | -| July-2004 | 5170.32 | | | -| August-2004 | 5192.08 | | 0.69 | -| September - 2004 | 5583.61 | | 0.82 | -| October - 2004 | 5672.27 | | 0.69 | -| November - 2004 | 6234.29 | | 2.02 | -| December - 2004 | 6602.69 | | 2.31 | -| January-2005 | 6555.94 | | 3.83 | -| February - 2005 | 6713.86 | | 2.75 | -| March - 2005 | 6492.82 | | 2.00 | -| April-2005 | 6154.44 | | 3.79 | -| May-2005 | 6715.11 | | 6.68 | -| June-2005 | 7193.85 | | 4.06 | -Registrar and Transfer Agent: The Company has appointed Registrar and Transfer agent to handle the -share transfer work and to solve the complaints of Shareholders. Name, Address and telephone number -of Registrar and Transfer Agent is given hereunder: -M/s. Adroit Corporate Services Pvt Ltd. -Unit No.3 & 4, Near Maharashtra Weigh Bridge, -Link Road, Saki Naka, Andheri (E), -Mumbai-400072, -Tele. No.: +91-22 - 288590942 / 28503748 / 26924437 -Fax No. : +91 -22-26924438 -Share Transfer System: -Shares sent for transfer in physical form are registered by the Company's Registrars and Share -Transfer Agents within 15 days from the receipt of the documents, if the same are found in order. -Shares under objection are returned within two weeks. - -Distribution of SharehoHingas on November 30, 2005 -| | | | No. of shares | | % of Shares | -| -------------- | ------------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | -| No. of Equity | No. of share | % of Share | | | | -| Shares held | holders | holders | held | | held | -| Upto - 500 | 1456 | 83.06 | 246601 | | 5.33 | -| 501 - 1,000 | 129 | 7.36 | 105951 | | 2.29 | -| 1,001 -2,000 | 58 | 3.31 | 86550 | | 1.87 | -| 2,001 -3,000 | 32 | 1.83 | 79743 | | 1 .72 | -| 3,001 - 4,000 | 13 | 0.74 | 46550 | | 1.01 | -| 4,001 - 5,000 | 11 | 0.63 | 51229 | | 1.11 | -| 5,001 - 10,000 | 23 | 1.31 | 163419 | | 3.53 | -10,001 - above -| | 31 | 1.77 | 3849627 | | 83.15 | -| ----- | ---- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | -| Total | r*3 | 100.00 | 4629670 | | 100.00 | -Dematerialisation of shares and liquidity: 13.60% have been dematerialised. -Outstanding GDR's/ADR's/Convertible- Nil. -Particular of shares held on physical / Electronic form as on November 30, 2005. -| Category | Holders | No. of Shares | | % of sharers | | -| ---------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -| Paper mode | 1214 | 3999970 | | 86.40 | | -| NSDL | | | | 9.23 | | -| | 422 | 427307 | | | | -| CDSL | 117 | 202393 | | 4.37 | | -| Total | 1753 | 4629670 | | 100 | | -Address for correspondence: -| Aryaman Financial | Services Limited | | | | | -| ----------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -401, Chiranjiv Towers, -43, Nehru Place, New Delhi 110 019 - -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -BALANCE SHEET AS AT 30th JUNE - 2005 -| | Schedule | | 30th JUNE, 2005 | | 31st MARCH, 2004 | -| --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------- | -(Rs) -(Rs.) -SOURCES OF FUNDS -Shareholders' Funds -| a)Share Capital | 1 | 53,619,074 | | 53.619,074 | | -| -------------------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| b)Reserves & Surplus | 2 | (3.296.920) | | (2,041.813) | | -| | | | 50,320,154 | | 51,577,261 | -Loan Funds -SECURED LOANS -| Deferred Tax Liability (Net) | | | 8,746,000 | | 8,746,000 | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -| | | | 59,066,154 | | 60,323,261 | -APPLICATION OF FUNDS -FIXED ASSETS -| Gross Block | | 33,129,228 | | 33,129,228 | | -| ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | -| Less:Depreciation | | 4.105.964 | | 3,602.375 | | -| Net Block | | | 29,023,264 | | 29,526,853 | -INVESTMENTS -| CURRENT ASSETS.LOANS AND ADVANCES | 4 | 38,829,511 | | 38,376,313 | | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -LESS:CURRENT LIABILITIES & PROVISIONS 5 8,786,621 7,781,752 -| NET CURRENT ASSETS | | | 30,042,890 | | 30,594,561 | -| -------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -| MISCELLANEOUS EXPENDITURE | 6 | | | | 201,847 | -(To the extent not written-off or adjusted) 59,066,154 60,323,261 -| Notes on Accounts | 12 | | | | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -The Schdules referred to above form an -integral part of the Balance Sheet -As per our report of even date -for Thakur Vaidyanath & Aiyar & Co. -for and On behalf of the Board -Chartered Accountatnts -| C.V. Parameswar | | | | DIRECTOR | DIRECTOR | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | -Partner -M.No.11541 -Place: Mumbai -Dated: 01/12/2005 - -| IF ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED | | | | | | • | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30th JUNE.2Q05 -| | Schedule | | 30th JUNE, 2005 | | | 31st MARCH, 2004 | -| --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | -| | (Rs.) | | | | | (Rs.) | -INCOME -| Merchant Banking | | 2,760,000 | | | 4,200,295 | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | --------- | --- | -| Other Income from Operation | 7 | | 7,238 | | 3,466,748 | | -| Project Consultancy | | | | | 225,000 | | -128,647 -Proft / Loss on Sale of Shares -Proft / Loss on Sale of Invetments -| Prior Period Adjustment | | | | | 123,291 | | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | -| | | | | 2,767,238 | | 8,143,981 | -EXPENDITURE -| Personnel expenses | 8 | | 204,459 | | 631,341 | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ----------- | -| Administation and other Expenses | 9 | 1,239,747 | | | 2,139,310 | | -| Finance Charges | 10 | | 29,864 | | 1,823,941 | | -| Legal and Consultancy charges | 11 | 1,778,215 | | | 1,660,499 | | -| Auditors' Remuneration | | | 66,250 | | 55,000 | | -| Miscellaneous Expenditure written off | | 201,847 | | | 244,276 | | -| Prior Period Adjustment | | | 374 | | | | -| Proft / Loss on Sale of Asset | | | | | 805,776 | | -| Bad Debts written off | | | | | 1,313,316 | | -| | | | | 3,520,756 | | 8.673.456 | -| Profit before Depreciation | | | | (753,518) | | (529,477) | -| Depreciation | | | | 503,589 | | 648.453 | -| Profitless) after Depreciation | | | | (1,257,107) | | (1,177,930) | -Provision for Deferred Tax -| Profit/(loss) after Tax | | | | (1,257,107) | | (1,177,930) | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | -| Balance as per Last year | | | | (28,141,813) | | (26,963,883) | -| | | | | (29,398,920) | | (28,141,813) | -in -APPROPRIATIONS -Profit/(loss) after appropriations carried to Balance Sheet (28,141,813) -| Notes on Accounts | 12 | | | | | | -| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -The Schdules referred to above form an -As per our report of even date -for Thakur Vaidyanath & Aiyar & Co. For and on behalf of the Board -Chartered Accountatnts -C.V. Parameswar -| | | | | DIRECTOR | DIRECTOR | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -Partner -M.No.11541 -Place: Mumbai -Dated: 01/12/2005 - -7= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -SCHEDULES TO BALANCE SHEET -| | 30th JUNE, 2005 | 31st MARCH, 2004 | | -| --- | --------------- | ---------------- | ----- | -| | (Rs.) | | (Rs.) | -SCHEDULE 1 -SHARE CAPITAL -AUTHORISED -| 50,00,000 Equity Shares of Rs.10/- each | | 50000000 | 50000000 | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -ISSUED.SUBSCRIBED AND PAID-UP -46,29,670 Equity Shares of Rs. 10.00 each 46,296,700 46,296,700 -| Deposit againstlssue of Shares | 7,322,374 | | 7,322,374 | -| ------------------------------ | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | -| | | 53,619,074 | 53,619,074 | -SCHEDULE 2 -RESERVES AND SURPLUS -a) GENERAL RESERVE -| | 26,100,000 | | 26,100,000 | -| --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -Balance as per Last Year -| | 26,100,000 | | 26,100,000 | -| ------------------------- | ------------ | ----------- | ------------ | -| b) Proft and Loss account | (29,398,920) | | (28,141,813) | -| | | (3,298,920) | (2,041,813) | -SCHEDULE 4 -CURRENT ASSETS.LOANS AND ADVANCES -RENT ASSETS -Interest Accrued but not Due -Sundry Debtors: -(unsecured,considered good) --Debts outstanding for a period exceeding 6 months 16,877,836 16,945,245 -| -Others | 1,576,863 | | 122,865 | -| ------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | -| | 18,454,699 | | 17,068,110 | -| | | 18,454,699 | 17,068,110 | -CASH AND BANK BALANCE: -| -Cash Balance on Hand | | 20,119 | 507,832 | -| --------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --Bank Balance: -| -With Scheduled Banks on Current Account | | 22,706 | 116,047 | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --With Scheduled Banks on Deposit Account -| | | 18,497,524 | 17,691,988 | -| --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -LOANS AND ADVANCES -(Unsecured,considered good) -| Shares Held Against Portfolio | 32,681,045 | | 32,681,045 | -| ----------------------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | -| Portfolio Advances | 33,682,872 | | 33,546,366 | -| | | (1,001,827) | (865,321) | -Shares Held against Portfolio Commitments 19,414,282 19,414,282 -Advances recoverable in cash or in kind or value to be -| received | | 1,141,872 | 1,351,204 | -| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -| Security Deposit | | 777,660 | 784,160 | -| | | 20,331,987 | 20,684,325 | -| | | 38,829,511 | 38,376,313 | -SCHEDULE S -CURRENT LIABILITIES AND PROVISIONS -alCURRENT LIABILITIES -| 1. Sundry Creditors | 693,403 | | 562,128 | -| ---------------------------- | --------- | --------- | --------- | -| 2. Other Current Liabilities | 8,093,218 | | 7,219,624 | -| | | 8,786,621 | 7,781,752 | -blPROVISIONS -| | | 8,786,621 | 7,781,752 | -| --- | --- | --------- | --------- | -SCHEDULES -MISCELLANEOUS EXPENDITURE -extent not written off or adjusted) -| a)Public Issue Expenses | | | 188,152 | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -b)Preliminary and Pre-operative Expenses -13,695 -201,847 - -SCHEDULE 3 -FIX ASSETS -| DESCRIPTION | | GROSS BLOCK | | | | | DEPRECIATION | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | -NET PL^^K -| | | | | | | | | | ASON31ST | ASON31ST | -| --- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --------------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | -| | ASON31ST | ADDITIONS | | DELETIONS | ASON3OTH | ASON31ST | FOR SALESWDJ. | ASON31ST | | | -| | | | | | | | | | MARCH | MARCH | -| | MARCH | | DURING | DURING | JUNE | MARCH | THE DURING | MARCH | | | -2004 THEYEAR THEYEAR 2006 2004 YEAR THEYEAR 2006 2006 2006 -A) OWN USE -LAND-FREEHOLD 8,342,965 - - 8,342,965 - 8,342,965 8,342,965 -BUILDING 22,166,276 - - 22,166,276 3,096,043 451,390 - 3,547,433 18,618,843 19,070,233 -FIXTURE 627,420 - - 627,420 409,355 34,999 - 444,354 183,066 218,065 -VEHICLES -AIRCONDmONERS 235,050 - - 235,050 92,457 13,948 - 106,405 128,645 142,593 -OFFICE EQUIPMENT 6,341 - - 6,341 261 376 - 637 5,704 6,080 -COMPUTERS 18,150 - - 18,150 4,259 2,876 - 7,135 11,015 13,891 -B) LEASED -| PLANT AND MACHINERY | | | | | | . | | | - | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| LEASE ADJUSTMENT ACCOUNT | | - | | | | | | | | | -C) CAPITAL WORK-IN-PROGRESS -j -| BUILDING AND EQUIPMENT | 72,500 | | - | - | 72,500 | | | | 72,500 | 72,500 | -| ---------------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | -! ADVANCE FOR COCHIN STOCK -. -EXCHW<£ CORPORATE MEMBERSHIP 1,660,526 - - 1,660,526 1,660,526 1,660,526 -TOTAL 33,129,228 - - 33,129,228 3,602,375 503,589 - 4,105,964 29,023,264 29,526,853 -PREVIOUS YEAR 39,881,271 25,436 6,777,479 33,129,228 5,232,890 648,453 2,278,968 3,602,375 29,526,853 34,648,381 - -fj= ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED - -^,1 -SCHEDULES TO PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT -| ACCOUNT NAME | | 30th JUNE, 2005 | | 31st MARCH, 2004 | | -| ------------- | --- | --------------- | ----- | ---------------- | ----- | -| | | | (Rs.) | | (Rs.) | -SCHEDULE 7 -OTHER INCOME FROM OPERATIONS -| INTEREST | | | - | | 2,248 | -| ----------------------------------------- | ------ | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | -| LEGAL, PROFESSIONAL & CONSULTANCY CHARGES | | | _ | | 2,817,500 | -| POJECT CONSULTANCY CHARGES | | | - | | | -| MISCELLANEOUS | INCOME | | 7,238 | | | -| COMMISSION RECIVED | | | - | | 647,000 | -| | | | 7,238 | | 3,466,748 | -SCHEDULE 8 -PERSONNEL EXPENSES -| SALARY AND ALLOWANCES | | | 165,000 | | 547,000 | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| | | | 39,459 | | 84,341 | -STAFF WELFARE -| | | | 204,459 | | 631,341 | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -SCHEDULE 9 -ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER EXPENSES -| TELEPHONE CHARGES | | | 222,113 | | 548,578 | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| COURIER CHARGES | | | 8,652 | | 25,502 | -| POSTAGE AND TELEGRAM | | | 20 | | 1,311 | -| RENT.RATES AND TAXES | | | 125,125 | | 294,500 | -| AIRS AND MAINTENANCE-BUILDING | | | 712 | | 3,018 | -| REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE-OTHERS | | | 192,937 | | 240,738 | -| BOOKS AND PERIODICALS | | | | | 3,541 | -975 -| OFFICE EXPENSES | | | 191,306 | | 256,233 | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| BUSINESS PROMOTION | | | 55,340 | | 76,527 | -| 1 EGAL EXPENSES | | | - | | | -| ELECTRICITY CHARGES | | | 41,763 | | 125,089 | -| PRINTING AND STATIONERY | | | 27,892 | | 76,898 | -| TRAVELLING EXPENSES | | | 145,433 | | 333,007 | -| INSURANCE | | | 3,070 | | 9,723 | -| DEMAT CHARGES | | | 34,881 | | 33,623 | -| LISTING CHARGES | | | 15,000 | | 7,500 | -| OTHERS EXPENSES | | | | | 103,523 | -174,528 -| | | | 1,239,747 | | 2,139,310 | -| --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | -SCHEDULE 10 -FINANCE CHARGES -| BANK CHARGES | | | 7,490 | | 21,752 | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | -| LEASE RENT | | | 22,374 | | 134,244 | -| INTEREST | | | - | | 92,945 | -| OTHER FINANCE CHARGES | | | - | | 1,575,000 | -1,823,941 -29,864 -SCHEDULE 11 -LEGAL AMD CONSULTANCY CHARGES -| LEGAL.PROFESSIONAL AND CONSULTANCY | | | | | 1,572,975 | -| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -1,672,805 -| MEMBERSHIP CHARGES | | | 104,160 | | 81,944 | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | -| DIRECTOR SITTING FEES | | | - | | - | -| STAMP PAPERS | | | 1,250 | | 5,580 | -| INCOME TAX PAID | | | - | | | -| MARKETING FEES | | | - | | | -| | | | 1,778,215 | | 1,660,499 | - -IT ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -SCHEDULE 14 -NOTES TO ACCOUNTS -SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES: - -Accounts are prepared on Historical Cost Convention accruing for incomes, expenditures, assets -and liabilities. -a. Income from Project Consultancy is accrued considering stage wise completion of work, wherever -agreed upon or feasible, otherwise it is accrued on percentage basis based on the quantum of work -completed. -b. Income from Merchant Banking is accrued on percentage basis based on quantum of work completed. -a. FIXED ASSETS: -Fixed Assets are shown at cost less accumulated depreciation. Cost of asset includes all expenses -related to acquisition of the asset. -b. DEPRECIATION: -Owned Assets: Depreciation is charged on Straight Line Method at the rates and in the manner -provided in Schedule XIV of the Companies Act, 1956. -Leased Assets: On leased assets the minimum statutory depreciation is charged along with which -the stipulated lease Equalisation Account is created, to ensure full depreciation of the leased assets -within the tenure of the lease period by way of matching annual charges based on the lease rental -accruals. -Investments are stated at cost. -Miscellaneous Expenditure are written off as follows: -a. Preliminary Expenses, Pre-Operative Expenses (other than under (b)below) & Public Issue Expenses -- Pro-rata over 10 years. -b. Pre-Operative Expenses relating to Merchant Banking Division and Registrar & Share Transfer -Agents - Pro-rata oYar 5 years. -d. Computer Software -Equally over 3 years. -Taxes on Income -The Company provides for deferred tax using liability method, based on tax effect of timing -difference resulting from the recognition of items in the financial statements and in estimating its -current income tax provision. -Deferred Tax Assets arising from temporary timing differences are recognized to the extent there - -IF ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -Taxes on Income -The Company provides for deferred tax using liability method, based on tax effect of timing -difference resulting from the recognition of items in the financial statements and in estimating its -current income tax provision. -Deferred Tax Assets arising from temporary timing differences are recognized to the extent there -is reasonable certainity that the assets can be realized in future. -NOTES -1. Estimated amount of contracts to be executed on capital accounts Rs. 2,48,500/- -(P.Y. Rs. 2,48,500) -2. Contingent Liability RS.42.36 Lakhs (P.Y. RS. 42.36 Lakhs) -3. During the previous year the company assigned an office space which was pending registration -and a liability there against of Rs. 39.83 lacs to a party. The Company had filed a suit in the High -Court against the seller of the property for specific performance of the contract i.e. in arranging to -handover the original title papers making the bank as the third party to the suit. The company had -assigned the assets along with the liabilities to a party with the understanding that no liability -should accrue to the company with effect from 15-03- 2004 and the pending legal case shall be -pursued by the assignee. -4. Some of the debit/credit balances are subject to confirmation and reconciliation. -5. In view of the number of employees being below the stipulated numbers, the Payment of Gratuity -Act is not applicable to the company for the year. The same is the case with respect to payment -of Bonus Act. -6. Auditors Remuneration: - -| Amount (Rs.) | Amount (Rs.) | | -| ------------ | ------------ | --- | -(P.Y.) -| Audit Fees-Statutory | 43750 | 35000 | -| -------------------- | ----- | ----- | -| -Tax Audit | 12500 | 10000 | -| Certification | 10000 | 10000 | -NIL -| Out of pocket expenses | NIL | | -| ---------------------- | ----- | ----- | -| TOTAL | 66250 | 55000 | -7. Deferred Tax Liability / Assets -| Deferred Tax Liabilities | Amount (Rs.) | | -| ------------------------ | ------------ | --- | -| -At 1st April, 2004 | 87,46,000 | | -- Additional Adjustments for Current year -87,46,000 - -8. Directors' Remuneration : - -| | Amount | (Rs.) | Amount | (Rs.) | -| --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | -(P.Y.) -| Salary | | 60000 | | 360000 | -| -------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | -| Provident Fund | | NIL | | NIL | -| Perquisites | | 42000 | | 252000 | -| Legal & Professional | | 495000 | | NIL | -| TOTAL | | 597000 | | 612000 | -9. Quantitative Details of Shares under Portfolio Advance: -| | | No. | Amount | (Rs.) | -| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | -Equity Shares of Rs. 107- each Fully Paid-up -| Opening Stock | | 1655784 | P.Y.(1555784) | | -| -------------- | --- | -------- | ------------------ | --- | -| | | 52095327 | P.Y.(5109S327) | | -| Purchase | | NIL | P.Y. (I,0ft,fl00) | | -| | | NIL | P.Y. (10,00,000) | | -| Sale | | NIL | P.Y. (NIL) | NIL | -| | | P.Y. | (NIL) | | -10. Income/Expenditure in foreign currency: -| | Amount | (Rs.) | Amount | (Rs.) | -| --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | -(P.Y.) -| Expenditure | Rs. NIL | | Rs. NIL | | -| ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| Income | Rs. NIL | | Rs. NIL | | -11. EARNING PER SHARE -| | Share Price | | Share Price | | -| --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -As at -As at -| | JUNE 30, 2005 | | March 31. 2004 | | -| ----------------------------- | ------------- | ----- | -------------- | ----- | -| Nominal value of Equity Share | Rs.10/- | | Rs.10/- | | -| Earning per Share | (Rs. | 0.27) | (Rs. | 0.25) | -12. Related Party Disclosure -Mr. P. V.R. Murthy, Director of the company was covered by the definition of the Key Management -Personnel upto December 2004. Remuneration of Rs 5,52,000/- is paid under his contract of -employment with the company. Additionally, as at 30th June, 2005 there is no other related party -relationships as envisaged in Accounting Standard 18 pertaining to Related Party Disclosures. -13. Current year figures are for 15 months as compared to previous year figures for 12 months. -14. Previous years' figures have been regrouped and rearranged wherever necessary. - -F ARYAMANFINANCIALSERVICES LIMITED -Additional information as required under Part IV of Schedule VI to the Companies Act, 1956 -Balance Sheet Abstract and Company's General Business Profile -I Registration Details -Registration No. 59009 -State Code No. 55 -Balance Sheet Date 30.06.2005 -II Capital Raised During the year (Rs. In Thousands) -Public Issue -Nil -Rights Issue Nil -Bonus Issue -Nil -Private Placement - Equity Shares -Nil -III Position of Mobillisation and Deployment of Funds (Rs. In Thousands) -Total Liabilities 59066 -Total Assets 59066 -Sources of Funds -Paid - up Capital 53619 -Reserves & Surplus -3299 -Secured Loans -Nil -Unsecured Loans -Deferred Tax liability (Net) 8746 -Application of Funds -Net Fixed Assets 29023 -Investments Nill -Net Current Assets 30043 -Misc. Expenditure 0 -Accumulated Losses Nil -IV Performance of the Company (Rs. In Thousands) -Turnover (Gross Receipts) 2767 -Total Expenditure 4024 -Profit (+) / Loss (-) before Tax -12 5 7 -Profit (+) / Loss (-) after Tax -1257 -Earning per share (Rs.) Nil -Dividend (%) Nil -V Generic names of Principal Products , Services of the C ompany -Item Code No. (ITC Code) -Not Applicable -Production Description -1 Fjnanda| Sen/jces -2. Project Consultancy -3. Merchant Banking -Code No. for the services rendered by the Company is not available in the Publication of Indian Trade -classification for ITC Code of Products by Ministry of Commerce, Directorate General of Commercial -Intelligence and Statistics, Calcutta 700 001 -As per our Report of even date -For Thakur Vaidyanath Aiyar & Co. For and on behalf of the Board -Chartered Accountants -C.V. Parameswar Director -Partner -M.No. 11541 Director -Place:- Mumbai -Dated:-01-12-2005 - -P= ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -Registered Office : 401, Chiranjiv Towers, 43, Nehru Place, New Delhi 110019 -Corporate office : 208, Maker Chambers-v, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021. -ATTENDANCE SLIP -Eleventh Annual General Meeting Scheduled on Thursday, 29th Dec.2005 AT -401, Chirajiv Towers, 43, Nehru Place, New Delhi 110019. at 10,00 am. -PLEASE COMPLETE THIS ATTENDANCES SLIP AND HAND IT OVER AT THE ENTRANCE OF THE MEETING HALL -NAME & ADDRESS OF THE SHAREHOLDER L.F.NO -I, hereby record my presence at the ELEVENTH ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING of the Company -Scheduled on Thursday , 29th, Dec. 2005 at 401, Chiranjiv Towers, New Dilhi at 10. am. -SIGNATURE OF THE SHAREHOLDER OR THE PROXY ATTENDING THE MEETING. -If Shareholders, please sing here if Proxy, please sing here -NOTE : The copy of Annual Report may please be brought at the Meeting Hall -(TEAR HEAR) -ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -Registered Office : 401, Chiranjiv Towers, 43, Nehru Place, New Delhi 110019. -Corporate Office : 208, Maker Chambers -v, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021 -PROXY FORM -L.F. No. -of being a member / members of ARYAMAN FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED -hereby appoint ........ - ...... -of --------------------------------------------------------- failing him / her- ----------------------------------------------------o f -or -as my / our proxy to vote fo>- me/ us on behalf at the Eleven Annual General Meeting of the Company to -be held at 401 , Chiranjiv Tower, New Delhi - 110117 on Thursday 29th Dec. 2005 -as witness my/ our hand(s) this ----------------------------- day of - ................... — 2005 -(Signature of the Shareholder) -NOTE :The Proxy From must be returned so as to reach the Registered Office of the Company note less -than 48 hours before the time for holding the aforesaid meeting. - -BOOK-POST -To, -// undelivered please return to .- -Adroit Corporate Services Pvt. Ltd. -Unit, Aryaman Financial Services Ltd. -19, Jaferbhoy Industrial Estate, 1st Floor, -Makwana Road, Marol Naka, -Andheri (W), Mumbai - 400059 \ No newline at end of file +Online BSc Degree +and Diploma Program +PROGRAMMING AND DATA SCIENCE + +Batch 1: Starts January 2021 + +For latest updates, visit - www.onlinedegree.iitm.ac.in + +Brochure Last Updated: 2nd November 2020 + + Contents + +Introduction + +Why learn Programming & Data Science + +About IIT Madras + +Our Experience in Online Education + +Academics + +Overall Structure of the programme + +Term Structure + +Course Structure + +Assessments + + Online Assignments + + Three Quizzes + + End Term Exam + + Pass Criteria for Each Course + + Learners Who Do Not Pass a Course + +Exam Cities + +Fee Structure + +Foundational Level + +Diploma Level + + Diploma in Programming + + Diploma in Data Science + +Degree Level + +Admissions + +Important Dates + +Two Admission Paths + + Regular Entry + + Diploma Only Entry + +Mandatory Requirements + +Regular Entry + + Eligibility to Apply + + Application Process + + Qualifier Process + + Qualifier Exam and Pass Criteria + +Contact Us + +3 + +3 + +4 + +4 + +5 + +5 + +6 + +6 + +7 + +7 + +7 + +7 + +8 + +8 + +8 + +9 + +10 + +10 + +11 + +11 + +12 + +13 + +13 + +13 + +13 + +13 + +13 + +14 + +14 + +14 + +14 + +15 + +16 + + Introduction + +IIT Madras, India’s top technical institute, welcomes you to the world’s first online BSc +Degree program in Programming and Data Science. For the first time, you can work +towards an undergraduate degree / diploma from an IIT regardless of your age or +location, and with a wide range of academic backgrounds. + +“ + +IIT Madras is pioneering a completely online program to +produce graduates who will be employable in the sector +that presently has high demand - Programming and Data +Science. The program uses an innovative combination of +online learning and in-person assessment and is flexible and +affordable. I believe the program will be a gamechanger +in the field of education in India in the coming years and +inspire other top-ranking institutions to launch many such +online initiatives. + +- Prof. Bhaskar Ramamurthi, Director, IIT Madras + +Why Programming & Data Science? + +Decision making is increasingly becoming +data driven within the commercial sector +and the government. There is a large +quantity of data readily available for this +at present. Smart devices connected to +the internet bring more input sources, +apart from those generated by humans +as they interact with services and one +another. Data driven decision making +involves the analysis of large volumes +of data to identify patterns and build +predictive models. This requires a +combination of skills ranging from +computing, statistics and mathematics, +and is broadly labelled data science. + +INCREASING DEMAND + +BETTER JOB OPPORTUNITIES + +UPSKILL + +As formal academic programs in data +science are only just emerging, there +is a huge gap between the demand for +data scientists and the supply of suitable +qualified applicants in the job market. +The throughput of traditional classroom +programs is limited and will not be able +to provide the numbers needed to meet +the upcoming requirements. Online +teaching has the potential to train much +larger numbers, but delivering scale +without diluting quality has proven to be +a challenge until recently. + +Our program therefore aims to create +a thoroughly trained programmer, +proficient in application development, +data sciences and machine learning. + +3 + + About IIT Madras + +Indian Institute of Technology Madras is one of the +foremost institutes of national importance for higher +technical education and research. + +In 1956, the German Government offered +technical assistance in establishing +an institute of higher education in +engineering in India. The first Indo- +German agreement in Bonn, West +Germany for the establishment of the +Indian Institute of Technology at Madras +was signed in 1959. The Institute with its +campus in Chennai, previously known +as Madras, was formally inaugurated +in 1959 by Prof. Humayun Kabir, Union +Minister for Scientific Research and +Cultural Affairs. + +The Institute today has sixteen academic +departments and several advanced +research centres in various disciplines +of engineering and pure sciences. A +faculty of international repute, a brilliant +student community, excellent technical +& supporting staff and an effective +administration have all contributed to the +pre-eminent status of IIT Madras. + +Our Experience in Online Education + +IITM is well-equipped to provide an +online degree course. We have been +ranked number 1 Engineering Institute +for the past 5 years and we have been +ranked number 1 Overall for the past 2 +years by NIRF. + +Furthermore, IITM began the NPTEL +program, the country’s first online +content portal as an inter-IIT consortium +project in 2001 and nptel.ac.in  is one +of the largest online course portals in +the world. In 2014, IITM also created +NPTEL online courses - the country’s first +Massive Open Online Course (MOOC). +Today, NPTEL is considered the largest +MOOC provider in India. + +MHRD launched the SWAYAM MOOC +platform in 2017 and NPTEL has been +the largest contributor to it. NPTEL +also manages swayam.gov.in  - the +national MOOCs portal, as well as the +network of more than 3800 SWAYAM +local chapter colleges. With IITM +continuing to lead the NPTEL project, it +makes them the perfect choice to offer +an online degree program. + +2001 +NPTEL +Program + +2014 +NPTEL +Online +Courses + +2017 +SWAYAM +MOOC + +2020 +IITM +Online +Degree + +4 + + Overall Structure + +There are THREE LEVELS in our Online +Degree program and to get a BSc +Degree in Programming and Data +Science from IIT Madras, a learner +has to successfully complete all three +levels. + +1. +FOUNDATIONAL LEVEL + +2. +DIPLOMA LEVEL + +3. +DEGREE LEVEL + +There is also the flexibility to exit at +any level. Depending on the courses +completed, the learner can receive +Foundational Certificate from Centre +for Continuing Education, IIT Madras +or Diploma(s) from IIT Madras. (Pg 13 +for Admissions related information) + +We are currently formulating a +Diploma Only Entry (Pg 13) option for +those who are interested in doing only +Diploma Level courses and exiting +with one or both Diploma(s) from IIT +Madras. + +Total Courses: 31 +116 credits + +Completion time: 3 - 6 years +based on preferred pace & performance + +Fees: Based on courses registered +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +Online Courses & Assignments +12 weeks of coursework for each course + +Quizzes and Exams +3 Quizzes and one End Term Exam for +each course - in person and invigilated. + +ACADEMICS + +5 + + Term Structure + +Every year is divided into three +terms - January Term, May Term and +September Term. + +Before progressing to the next level, +the learner has to clear all the courses +in the current level. + +In a term, a learner may register +for a course only if they have +already successfully completed the +prerequisites for that course. + +The learner may be allowed to +register for upto 4 courses in a term +depending on their performance in +the previous exam(s). + +A learner has to clear all Foundational +level courses successfully, before +registering for any Diploma Level +courses. Similarly, learners have +to clear Diploma Level courses +successfully before registering for any +Degree Level courses. + +Course Structure + +The duration of the core courses +in Foundational, Diploma and +Degree Level is 12 weeks and the +courses carry 4 credits each. +The Skill Enhancement courses +and Electives in Degree Level +have varying credits and may +be of different duration. + +The fee for each term depends on the +total credits one registers for in that +term. Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +The recorded video content released +every week will comprise a series of +lectures, sample problems and step +by step instructions on how to solve +them. + +The duration of each video would be +15 to 30 minutes amounting to a total +of about 2 - 3 hours of video content +each week in each course. + +Weekly assignment(s), which will be +released along with the videos, will +have to be completed and submitted +online in the specified period of time. + +There will be 3 quizzes for each +course, one each at the end of weeks +4, 7 and 10. Each course further +culminates in an End Term Exam. All +the quizzes and the end term exams +have to be completed by the learner, +in person, at designated exam centres, +held under invigilation. + +All in-person, invigilated quizzes and +exams will be scheduled for weekends, +subject to availability of dates with +exam partner. + +6 + + Assessments + +There are 3 types of assessments for each course - online weekly assignments, +monthly in-person invigilated quizzes and an in-person invigilated end term exam. + +If the Average Assignment Score for a +course is less than 40/100, the learner +will not be eligible to write the end +term exam for that course. + +Online Assignments + +A 12-week course will have at least one +assignment every week. + +Each assignment has to be submitted +online within the specified due date. + +From the 12 weekly assignment scores +for a course, a learner’s best 8 scores +will be considered to calculate the +Average Assignment Score. + +Three Quizzes +IN PERSON, INVIGILATED + +There will be 3 quizzes for each course, one each at the end of Weeks 4, 7 and 10. +Every quiz will be based on content covered up to that point in the course. These +quizzes have to be attempted in person, in the specified exam city (Pg 9). + +Each quiz will be conducted in a single +session and will consist of sections of +45 minutes duration for every course +chosen. + +It is mandatory to appear for at least +one out of the three quizzes to be +eligible to write the end term exam. + +The best two out of the three quiz +scores will be considered to calculate +the Average Quiz Score (Q) out of 100. + +40% of Q will be used to calculate Total +Course Score T and course grade. + +End Term Exam + +IN PERSON, INVIGILATED + +At the end of a term, there will be an +end term exam of 3 hours duration for +each course. + +This exam score (out of 100) is called +End Term Score (E) which accounts for +60% of the Total Course Score (T). + +To be eligible to write the End Term +Exam, a learner’s average assignment +score should be >= 40/100 AND they +should have appeared for at least one +out of the three quizzes. + +7 + + Pass Criteria for Each Course + +Total Course Score (T) = 40% of Average quiz score (Q) + 60% of End Term Score (E) + +A learner is deemed to have passed a course only if the below mentioned two +conditions are met: + +Total Course Score (T) >= 50/100 AND + +End Term exam score (E) >= 40/100 + +These criteria are the same for all learners participating in the course. + +An absolute grading system, as described in the below table, will be followed: + +Condition satisfied by ‘T’ - Total Course Score (Out Of 100) +and ‘E’ - End Semester Score (Out Of 60) + +Letter Grade + +(T ≥ 90) AND (E ≥ 24) + +(90 > T ≥ 80) AND (E ≥ 24) + +(80 > T ≥ 70) AND (E ≥ 24) + +(70 > T ≥ 60) AND (E ≥ 24) + +(60 > T ≥ 50) AND (E ≥ 24) + +S + +A + +B + +C + +D + +(T < 50) OR (E < 24) OR Average assignment score <40/100 OR No quiz attended + +U (Fail) + +Learners Who Do Not Pass a Course + +For any learner, if Total Course Score (T) < 50/100 or average assignment +score < 40/100 or no quiz attended, they have to repeat the entire course. This +includes submission of assignments and redoing all the subsequent quizzes and +end term exam. Fees for repeating the course is the same as the course fees. + +If Total Course Score (T) >= 50/100 but End Term Score (E) < 40/100, the learner has +2 options: + +Attend only the end term exam whenever it is conducted in the subsequent +term. The fee to repeat an end term exam will be ₹1000 for foundational and +₹2000 for diploma / degree level courses. + +They can repeat the entire course by paying the full course fees and +completing all assignments, invigilated quizzes and the end term exam. + +Exam Cities + +The Invigilated Quizzes and End Term +exams are scheduled to be conducted +in a limited number of cities across +India. Learners can select 3 options +among the cities, and they will be +expected to attend the exam in the +City / Centre that has been allotted +to them. The allotted city will be from +these 3 options. + +The list of exam cities where +invigilated exams will be scheduled +may change later depending on the +location of majority of our learners. +Here is the link to view the current +exam cities . + +8 + + Fee Structure + +For details about application fees, check Application Process (Pg 14) section. + +Each term, pay only for the courses you register for! + +Foundational Level - ₹4000 per course. +Skill Enhancement courses in Diploma / Degree Level - ₹5,000 per course. +All other courses in Diploma / Degree Level - ₹10,000 per course. + +Fee waivers depend on category of learner and family income: + +Family Income > 5LPA + +Family Income > 1LPA +and <=5LPA + +Family Income <=1LPA + +Applicable +Fees + +Certificates +Required + +Applicable +Fees + +Certificates +Required + +Applicable +Fees + +Certificates +Required + +General + +Full Fee + +OBC + +Full Fee + +- + +- + +50% waiver + +EWS + Family +Income + +75% waiver + +EWS + Family +Income + +50%waiver + +OBC-NCL + +Family Income + +75% waiver + +OBC-NCL + +Family Income + +SC / ST + +50% waiver + +SC / ST + +50% waiver + +SC / ST + +75% waiver + +PwD + +50% waiver + +PwD + +50% waiver + +PwD + +75% waiver + +SC / ST + Family +Income + +EWS / OBC-NCL + +PwD + Family Income + +SC / ST + PwD + +75% waiver + +SC / ST + PwD + +75% waiver + +SC / ST + PwD + +75% waiver + +SC / ST + PwD + +The term family income for the purpose of availing fee waivers includes the income +of the candidate, the income of his/her parents and spouse, also the income of his/ +her siblings and children below the age of 18 years. + +OBC-NCL / EWS / Family Income certificates need to be obtained in the prescribed +format. Only those who clear Qualifier Exam and wish to avail fee waiver based on +family income need to submit the Family Income certificate. (Note that Family Income +certificate is valid only for one year and will need to be submitted afresh each year to +continue availing corresponding fee waiver.) +Format for OBC-NCL certificate  +Format for EWS certificate  +Format for Family Income certificate  + +Tentative Fee for Each Term, depending on your end Goal and possible paths to +reach the goal: + + Foundational Certificate  + + Diploma in Programming  | Diploma in Data Science  | Both Diplomas  + + BSc in Programming and Data Science  + +*Note: If a learner does not pass a course in the term they registered for it - refer +section about Learners who do not pass a course for details on whether they will +need to repeat entire course or only repeat the end term exam. Fee to repeat an entire +course will be the same as the full course fee. Fee to only repeat the end term exam is +₹1000 for foundational level courses and ₹2000 for diploma / degree level courses. + +9 + + Foundational Level + +The Foundational Level comprises +courses in Mathematics, Statistics, Basics +of Programing and Python, and English. +These courses have been chosen to +ensure that the learner who passes these +successfully is well prepared to proceed +to the Diploma Level courses. + +8 courses +32 credits + +1 - 3 years +10 hrs/course/week + +₹32,000* +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +Requirements for registration + +The learner should apply for and clear the Qualifier Process (Pg 14). + +Options on successful completion + +Learners have the following two options when they successfully complete all 8 +Foundational Level courses: + +Exit: The learner may exit with a Foundational Certificate from Centre for +Continuing Education, IIT Madras. + +Proceed to next level: The learner can join the Diploma Level (Pg 10). + +Courses in Foundational Level + +Mathematics for Data Science I + +Statistics for Data Science I + +Mathematics for Data Science II + +Statistics for Data Science II + +Computational Thinking + +Programming in Python + +English I + +English II + +Diploma Level + +There are two sections in the Diploma +Level with courses for Diploma in +Programming and courses for Diploma +in Data Science. Each of these diplomas +comprise 5 core courses and 1 skill +enhancement course. These Diploma +Level courses assume that the learner is +well-versed with fundamentals. + +Requirements for registration + +6 + 6 courses +22 + 22 credits + +1 - 3 years +10 hrs/course/week + +₹55,000* + ₹55,000* +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +The learner should have cleared all 8 Foundational Level (Pg 10) courses or should +have joined via Diploma Only Entry (Pg 13). + +10 + + Options on successful completion + +Learners have the following options based on the courses completed in this level: + +They may exit with a Diploma in Programming from IIT Madras. + +They may exit with a Diploma in Data Science from IIT Madras. + +They may exit with both Diplomas from IIT Madras. + +The learner can join the Degree Level (Pg 11) if they have completed all 12 +Diploma Level courses AND have not entered the program via Diploma Only +Entry option. + +Diploma in Programming + +The Diploma in Programming lays a +sturdy foundation in Databases and +Programming concepts with Data +Structures and Algorithms. The learner +goes on to apply these in the building +of a web application by the end of the +diploma. + +Courses for Diploma in Programming + +6 courses +22 credits + +1 - 2 years +10 hrs/course/week + +₹55,000* +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +Database Management Systems + +Modern Application Development I + +Programming, Data Structures and +Algorithms using Python + +Modern Application Development II + +Programming Concepts using Java + +Skill Enhancement I + +Diploma in Data Science + +The Diploma in Data Science exposes +the learner to the holistic approach of +gathering, analysing, and interpreting +data for a variety of problems. The +courses on Business Data lays down the +context and the need for the data, while +the Machine Learning courses equip +the learner to use and analyse this data +towards impactful conclusions. + +Courses for Diploma in Data Science + +6 courses +22 credits + +1 - 2 years +10 hrs/course/week + +₹55,000* +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +Machine Learning Foundations + +Business Data Management + +Machine Learning Theory + +Business Analytics + +Machine Learning Practice + +Skill Enhancement II + +11 + + Degree Level + +The Degree Level has courses that +complete the requirements for the BSc +degree. + +Requirements for registration +The learner should have come in via +Regular Entry (Pg 14), cleared all 8 +Foundational Level (Pg 11) courses and +all 12 Diploma Level (Pg 11) courses. + +11 courses +40 credits + +1 - 3 years +10 hrs/course/week + +₹1,00,000* +*Refer Fee Structure (Pg 9). + +Exit: Once the learner successfully completes 40 credits from Degree Level courses, +they can exit with a BSc Degree in Programming & Data Science from +IIT Madras. + +Credit Requirements +Learners have to complete a total of 40 credits at the degree level: + +4 credits from mandatory course titled “Strategies for Professional Growth” +4 credits from 2 Skill Enhancement Courses of 2 credits each. These are to be +completed on NPTEL and the credits transfered to this degree program. +8 credits from 2 Core Courses of 4 credits each. There are 3 pairs of core course +options to pick from. +24 credits from Elective Courses - 6 courses of 4 credits each or more courses of +lesser credits. + +Core Courses +Learner has to do a pair of core courses where each course is of 4 credits. Following +are the options for Core Courses: + +Core Course Option I + +Core Course Option II + +Core Course Option III + +Operating Systems + +Software Testing + +Computer Architecture + +Software Engineering + +AI: Search Methods for +Problem Solving + +Deep Learning + +Elective Courses +A total of 24 credits need to be obtained from Elective Courses. Listed below are 9 +courses of 4 credits each, including the 3 pairs of core courses. Excluding the 2 courses +that the learner has already picked as core courses, he / she can opt for the elective +courses in the following two ways: + +a. Obtain all 24 credits by picking 6 of the remaining 7 courses listed below. OR + +b. Obtain upto 12 credits from NPTEL (accepted courses list will be provided soon) and +obtain remaining credits by picking from a subset of the 7 courses below. + +Operating Systems + +Software Testing + +Computer Architecture + +Software Engineering + +Topics in Application +Development + +Topics in Machine +Learning + +AI: Search Methods for +Problem Solving + +Deep Learning + +Topics in Data Science + +12 + + ADMISSIONS + +Important Dates + +Applications Closed (Regular Entry) + +- 15 September 2020 + +Weekly release of Term 1 Qualifier courses +content starts + +- 5 October 2020 + +Qualifier Exam Hall Ticket (only for those who +get minimum required marks in Assignments) + +- 2 November 2020 + +Qualifier Exam (only for those with Hall Ticket)* + +- 22 November, 2020* + +Qualifier Exam Results + +- 7 December, 2020 + +Registration for Term 1 (only for those who clear +Qualifier Exam) + +- 7 to 27 December, 2020 + +Foundational Level Batch 1 starts + +- 4 January, 2021 + +*Dates for in-person exams are subject to government restrictions prevalent at that time. + +Two Admission Paths +1. Regular Entry + +Anyone joining the program via Regular Entry will join at the Foundational Level. + +The Foundational Level courses allow for interested applicants with a variety of +educational backgrounds to learn the basics (Math, Statistics, Computational Thinking, +Python programming and English) which help them take up the Diploma Level and +then the Degree Level courses. + +There are three exit options for those who enter the program via Regular Entry: +Exit 1. Foundational Level certificate from Centre for Continuing Education, IIT Madras. +Exit 2. Diploma in Programming AND/OR Diploma in Data Science from IIT Madras +Exit 3. BSc Degree in Programming and Data Science from IIT Madras + +View Regular Entry (Pg 14) for details on Eligibility, Application Process, Qualifier +Process, Qualifier Exam and Passing Criteria. + +2. Diploma Only Entry + +The Diploma Only Entry is primarily aimed at working professionals or learners who +already possess the fundamentals taught in Foundational Level courses and wish to +exit with one or two Diplomas (Diploma in Programming AND/OR Diploma in Data +Science) from IIT Madras. + +Learners entering via Diploma Only Entry can only do Diploma Level courses and +cannot proceed to the Degree Level courses. + +We have plans to open applications for Diploma Only Entry in May / June 2021. All +details related to Diploma Only Entry will be provided soon on our website . + +13 + + Mandatory Requirements + +Access to good internet connection as +well as a laptop/desktop device will be +a key requirement to learn effectively. + +Learner should be able to travel to +assigned exam centres for quizzes and +exams, each term. + +Regular Entry +Eligibility to Apply + +Eligibility for those who cleared class 12 or equivalent in 2018 or earlier: + +1. + +2. + +The candidate must have studied Mathematics and English in class 10. + +They should have cleared class 12 or equivalent in 2018 or earlier. + +Eligibility for those who cleared class 12 or equivalent in 2019 or 2020: + +1. + +2. + +3. + +The candidate must have studied Mathematics and English in class 10. + +They should have cleared class 12 or equivalent in 2019 or 2020. + +The candidate should be: +(i) currently enrolled / previously enrolled in any Bachelor’s Degree program in +campus mode OR +(ii) completed 1 year Diploma (campus mode only) OR +(iii) completed CA Inter + +Note that applicants who cleared class 12 or equivalent in 2019 or 2020 may apply for the +qualfier process with eligibility criteria 1 & 2 alone, but will be required to fulfil criterion 3 to +join the foundational courses after clearing the qualifying exam. + +Application Process + +Anyone who is eligible may apply by filling in the application form, uploading +required documents and paying the application fee. Check out Application +Process  section on our website for the latest updates and to start applying. + +Application fee - ₹3,000 (For applicants belonging to PwD (>= 40% disability) / SC / ST +category - ₹1,500; For applicants belonging to PwD (>= 40% disability) and also SC / +ST category - ₹750) + +Qualifier Process + +All applicants will have to go through a Qualifier Process, like a trial month, +wherein they will get access to 4 weeks of content for the four foundational level +courses - English I, Mathematics for Data Science I, Statistics for Data Science I and +Computational Thinking. + +Video content of 2 - 3 hours duration will be released for each course on a weekly +basis. Along with the content, the first three weeks will also include an assignment +for each course that need to be completed and submitted online within the given +deadline. + +Average assignment score in each course will be calculated. Only those who get +minimum required average assignment scores in all four courses will be allowed to +write the Qualifier Exam (refer next page). + +14 + + Minimum Average Assignment +Score required in each course + +General Learner + +SC / ST / PwD with 40% disability + +PwD with 40% disability & SC / ST + +OBC-NCL / EWS + +40% + +30% + +30% + +35% + +Qualifier Exam and Passing Criteria + +Only learners who get minimum required average assignment scores in all four +courses will be eligible for the in-person invigilated Qualifier Exam conducted at the +end of 4 weeks of coursework. Only these candidates will receive hall tickets. + +The Qualifier Exam is of 3 hours duration and covers all 4 subjects with 45 minutes +allotted per course. + +To pass the Qualifier Exam, the learner has to get a minimum Total Qualifier Exam +Score and a minimum Qualifier Exam Score in each course individually. Refer table +below. + +Only those who pass the Qualifier Exam will be eligible to register for Foundational +Level courses. + +Minimum required +Qualifier Exam Score +in each course + +Minimum required +Total Qualifier +Exam Score + +General Learner + +SC / ST / PwD with 40% disability + +PwD with 40% disability & SC / ST + +OBC-NCL / EWS + +40% + +30% + +30% + +35% + +50% + +40% + +40% + +45% + +Note: Relaxations in pass criteria indicated for various categories of learners, is +applicable ONLY for the qualifier process. There will be no relaxations in terms of +grades / pass criteria once registered into the program. + +Though everyone who passes the Qualifier Exam will be allowed to register for +Foundational Level, there will be limitations on the number of courses a learner will +be allowed to register for in the first two terms based on the Total Qualifier Exam +Score (S). + +Total Qualifier Exam Score (S) + +Number of courses allowed to +register for in first two terms + +Minimum required <= S < 50% + +up to 2 courses + +50% <= S < 70% + +up to 3 courses + +S >= 70% + +up to 4 course + +Maximum number of courses a learner will be allowed to register for in later terms +will depend similarly on the average of course scores in the previous two terms. + +15 + + Contact Us + +Online Degree Office, 3rd Floor, ICSR Building, + +IIT Madras, Chennai - 600036 + +7850-999966 (Mon-Fri 9am-6pm) + +support@onlinedegree.iitm.ac.in + +www.onlinedegree.iitm.ac.in  + +iitmadrasonline + +16 + diff --git a/q7/random_k4/random_4.md b/q7/random_k4/random_4.md index d3b519018debf267a80e1bf5293bc1d28f81d062..698b93e528f0e11f63f3bba86b9d9dea3a63389f 100644 --- a/q7/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q7/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,292 +1,812 @@ -2024 Seattle City Guide +FOR RELEASE APRIL 1, 2021 -GETTING AROUND AND EXPLORING -SEATTLE! +# **STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity** -Find resources for travel, transportation, -parking, safety tips, and more. +_Higher education pipeline suggests long path ahead for increasing diversity, especially in fields like computing and engineering_ - Seattle City Guide +BY _Rick Fry_ , _Brian Kennedy, and Cary Funk_ -Visit Seattle has created a website, visitseattle.org/site/fccla2024/ specifically for FCCLA attendees to explore Seattle -highlights, dining options, transportation, with deals and discounts. +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: -**Please be aware that the information provided is not endorsed as recommendations by FCCLA. It is presented solely to offer you factual details. +Cary Funk, Director, Science and Society Research Kim Parker, Director, Social Trends Research Haley Nolan, Communications Associate 202.419.4372 www.pewresearch.org -Getting Around +## RECOMMENDED CITATION -Convention Center -Seattle Convention Center – Summit Building -900 Pine Street -Seattle, WA 98101 +Pew Research Center, April, 2021, “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” -Airport Information +2 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Seattle-Tacoma International Airport (SEA) -17801 International Blvd -Seattle, WA 98158 +## About Pew Research Center -Ride Share Services +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. It conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social science research. The Center studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. -Once you arrive at the airport, you will need to make arrangements for ground transportation to the hotel. -The airport is approximately 13 miles from the various hotels. Plan ahead by reviewing the options below for -transportation between the airport and the hotel. +© Pew Research Center 2021 -Pick-up app-based rideshare rides in the middle of the 3rd floor parking garage in the marked stall numbers 1- -34 in the orange and purple sections of the garage. +www.pewresearch.org -Lyft: Cost estimate is $42-$75 one-way - - Uber: Cost estimate is $50-$75 one-way - Taxi: Cost estimate is $48. +3 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -o There is a $40 flat rate for passengers going to SeaTac airport from downtown hotels. There is no +## How We Did This -flat rate leaving the airport and you will be charged the meter rate. +For this report, we analyzed federal government data to look at gender, racial and ethnic diversity among those employed in and earning degrees in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM). Analysis of the STEM workforce is based solely on occupation, using data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 1990 and 2000 U.S. decennial censuses and aggregated 2014-2016 and 20172019 American Community survey data provided through Integrated Public Use Microdata Series (IPUMS) from the University of Minnesota. A 2018 Center report used the same occupation classifications to analyze the STEM workforce from 1990 to 2016. - Airport Shuttle +Analysis of STEM degrees awarded is based on data from the U.S. Department of Education’s National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) Completions survey. The analysis was done using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool. Postsecondary institutions participating in Title IV federal financial aid programs are required to report. Degree programs were classified using the NCES’s Classification of Instructional Programs (CIP) scheme. -Premier Airport Shuttle provides shared and private door-to-door van service from $33 per person to -downtown Seattle hotels. Shuttles are available at the Ground Transportation Plaza on the third floor in the -airport parking garage. Check-in at the Premier Airport Shuttle kiosk. For rates and reservations, please visit -premierairportshuttle.com for more information. +www.pewresearch.org -Public Transit +4 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Seattle is easy to navigate with a wide variety of smart transportation options. For more detailed information, -go to visitseattle.org/visitor-information/getting-around. +## STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity -Link Light Rail: -Sound Transit’s Link Light Rail makes trips from downtown Seattle and SEA Airport. Trains arrive every 8 to -15 minutes, depending on the time of day, and take about 40 minutes to travel between Seattle-Tacoma -International Airport (SEA) and Westlake Station in downtown Seattle. +_Higher education pipeline suggests long path ahead for increasing diversity, especially in fields like computing and engineering_ -Schedule: -Mon-Sat, 5:00 AM – 1:43 AM (last northbound train from the airport to Westlake Station departs at 11:44 -PM) +Black and Hispanic workers remain underrepresented in the science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) workforce compared with their share of all workers, including in computing jobs, which have seen considerable growth in recent years. -Sun, 6:00 AM – 12:34 AM (last northbound train from the airport to Westlake Station departs at 11:14 PM) +The representation of women varies widely across STEM occupations. Women make up a large majority of all workers in health-related jobs, but remain underrepresented in other job clusters, such as the physical sciences, computing and engineering. -Adult Fare: $2.25 - $3.50 +Current trends in STEM degree attainment appear unlikely to substantially narrow these gaps, according to a Pew Research Center analysis of federal employment and education data. Black and Hispanic adults are less likely to earn -Website for more information on routes, schedules, fares, and to purchase passes: soundtransit.org +Black and Hispanic workers remain underrepresented in the STEM workforce -King County Metro Transit: -King County Metro Transit provides bus service in downtown Seattle and outlying neighborhoods in King -County. Download the mobile app for on-the-go-transit information. +_% who are…_ -Schedule: Timetables and route maps can be found on kingcounty.gov +**==> picture [302 x 280] intentionally omitted <==** -Adult Fare: $2.75 - $3.25 with an Orca Card +Notes: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math occupations. Engineering includes architects. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS) “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” - Seattle Center Monorail: -The iconic Seattle Center Monorail travels between Westlake Center in downtown and the Seattle Center at -the base of Queen Anne hill. This is the easiest way to get to the Seattle Space Needle, Museum of Pop -Culture, and more at the Seattle Center. Trains depart every 10 minutes and the trip takes only 2 minutes -each way. +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Schedule: +degrees in STEM than other degree fields, and they continue to make up a lower share of STEM graduates relative to their share of the adult population. And while women now earn a majority of -Mon-Fri, 7:30 AM – 9:00 PM -Sat-Sun, 8:30 AM – 9:00 PM +www.pewresearch.org -Fare: $3.00 one way +5 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -For more information regarding schedules and purchases passes: seattlemonorail.com +all undergraduate and advanced degrees, they remain a small share of degree earners in fields like engineering and computer science – areas where they are significantly underrepresented in the work force. -Seattle Street Cars: -This line connects the South Lake Union neighborhood to Seattle’s vibrant downtown core consisting of 1.3 -miles, nine stops, and full of shops and restaurants as well as Lake Union’s 12-acre waterfront park. +These findings come amid longstanding efforts to increase diversity in STEM and as the growth in STEM jobs is expected to outpace that of non-STEM jobs in the coming years. STEM occupations continue to rank higher on the pay scale, with the typical STEM worker earning more than those in other occupations. -Schedule: -Mon-Thu, 6:00 AM – 9:00 PM -Fri-Sat, 6:00 AM – 11:00 PM -Sun & Holidays, 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM +The gap in STEM workforce representation is especially large for Hispanic adults. Hispanic workers make up 17% of total employment across all occupations, but just 8% of all STEM workers. Their share of all STEM workers is up 1% since 2016, in line with their growth in the overall workforce. -Adult Fare: $2.25 one way; $4.50 all day +Black workers comprise 11% of all employed adults, compared with 9% of those in STEM occupations. Their share is lower in some STEM job clusters, including just 5% in engineering and architecture jobs. There has been no change in the share of Black workers in STEM jobs since 2016. -For more information: seattle.gov/transportation/getting-around/transit/streetcar +The long-term outlook for diversity in the STEM workforce is closely tied to representation in the STEM educational system, particularly across the nation’s colleges and universities. STEM workers are about twice as likely as other workers to have earned a bachelor’s degree or more education (67% vs. 34%) and roughly three-quarters of these workers hold a degree in a STEM field.[1] -Bike and Scooter Sharing: -Seattle is a bike and scooter-friendly city. If you’re visiting, it’s easy to find a ride no matter where you are. -Open your Uber app and select the ‘2-Wheels’ option from the top menu to quickly and easily reserve a -nearby Lime bike or scooter for $1, plus varying rates per minute. All rentals are dockless and include an -electric assist that provides a boost up to 15mph. Or try VEO‘s Cosmo-e bike, suitable for a range of physical -abilities and preferences. The Cosmo-e provides users with the option of pedaling or using the throttle to get -where they need to go. +## What’s a STEM job? -Electric scooters also dot the streets of Seattle, adding an alternative way to move through the city. Keep an -eye out for options from Bird, LINK, WHEELS, and SPIN to enjoy this unique app-based mode of -transportation. +This analysis of the STEM workforce relies on a broad-based definition of those working in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM). STEM jobs are defined solely based on occupation and include any of 74 standard occupations in life sciences, physical and Earth sciences, engineering and architecture, computer and math occupations as well as health-related occupations including healthcare providers and technicians. See the Appendix for specific occupations in each job cluster. - PARKING +## What’s a STEM degree field? -Hotel Parking +This analysis of STEM degree recipients relies on a broad-based definition of STEM degrees including degrees in life sciences, agriculture and environmental sciences; physical and earth sciences; engineering and architecture; computer and information sciences; math and statistics; and health-related fields. In 2018, 424 bachelor’s, 427 master’s, 336 research doctorate and 44 professional doctorate programs were classified as STEM using the six-digit Classification of Instructional Programs scheme from the National Center for Education Statistics. -Most hotels provide self-parking and/or valet parking on their premises. Click here to view specific rates at -each hotel. +While there is often considerable overlap across definitions, there is no commonly agreed definition of the STEM workforce or STEM education fields. Thus, caution is warranted in direct comparisons with other studies. -Seattle Convention Center Parking +> 1 The analytic lens on those earning bachelor’s and advanced degrees in STEM omits an important part of the STEM workforce. As of 2019, -The Convention Center offers multiple parking options. For more information, click -seattleconventioncenter.com/parking-garage-information. +> 27% of STEM workers report having completed an associate degree or some college with no degree. These “middle skill” workers are more prevalent among those in health-related and computer job clusters. -City Parking +www.pewresearch.org -Paid street parking and parking garages, both covered and outdoor, provide visitors with ample options when -driving into downtown. Paid street parking is in effect Monday-Saturday and is generally limited to 2, 4, or 10 -hours (all-day). Parking is free on Sundays when time limits generally do not apply. Learn more about paid -street parking here. +6 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -You can find convenient and affordable parking garages at downtownseattle.org/parking or -through SpotHero, the nation’s leading parking reservations app. With SpotHero, search for daily, weekly, or -monthly parking facilities and enjoy the convenience of booking a parking spot at your destination ahead of -time, ensuring you have a space when you arrive. +There has been dramatic growth in the number of STEM graduates from U.S. colleges and universities at all degree levels since 2010. Even so, there is little indication that diversity in related jobs will shift substantially in the near term.[2] -Bus Parking +Black and Hispanic adults are underrepresented among STEM college graduates compared with their share in the population, and a smaller share are earning degrees in a STEM field than in other degree programs. -Bus parking is available in surface lots. Visit Parking.com, enter your desired location and time frame, and use -the filter button to select oversized parking. +Black students earned 7% of STEM bachelor’s degrees as of 2018, the most recent year available, below their share of all bachelor’s degrees (10%) or their share of the adult population (12%). The share of Hispanic college graduates with a STEM degree –12%– remains lower than that for all college graduates (15%) in 2018.[3] - 1825 7th Ave. Seattle, WA 98101- Estimated $45 with additional oversize fee of $3.74 daily. - 1818 6th Ave. Seattle, WA 98101- Estimated $45 daily. - 1800 9th Ave. Seattle, WA 98101- Estimated $16-$30. No overnight parking. +Asian and White students remain overrepresented among STEM college graduates compared with their share of all college graduates in 2018. Students from other groups, including Native American, Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander and people who identify with two or more racial groups, are earning bachelor’s degrees in STEM in rough proportion to their share of all degree recipients. - PHARMACY AND MEDICAL CARE +Black and Hispanic adults are also underrepresented among those earning advanced degrees in STEM, especially among those earning Ph.D. or other research doctorates. Representation of Black and Hispanic adults is lowest in math, physical sciences and engineering degree fields. -Closest Hospital +Women earned 53% of STEM college degrees in 2018, smaller than their 58% share of all college degrees. The gender dynamics in STEM degree attainment mirror many of those seen across STEM job clusters. For instance, women earned 85% of the bachelor’s degrees in health-related fields, but just 22% in engineering and 19% in computer science as of 2018. In fields where women have been especially scarce, there have been incremental gains over the past decade. The share of women earning a degree in engineering is up 2 points since 2014 at the bachelor’s and master’s level. - Harborview Medical Center- 325 Ninth Avenue Seattle, WA 98104 --(206) 731-3000. Harborview is the +> 2 A 2019 report pointed to potential gains from a focus on minority-serving colleges and university. See “Closing the Equity Gap: Securing our STEM Education and Workforce Readiness Infrastructure in the Nation's Minority-Serving Institutions,” National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. -only Trauma 1 care facility in a four-state region. +> 3 Race/ethnicity data is unavailable for 4% of all bachelor’s degree and 4% of STEM bachelor’s degree recipients in 2018. -Closest Pharmacies +www.pewresearch.org - Walgreens Pharmacy- 222 Pike St. Seattle, WA 98101--(206) 903-8392 - CVS Pharmacy- 1401 2nd Ave. Seattle, WA 98101--(206) 494-3251 +7 PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Closest Urgent Cares +## **Women make up a quarter or fewer of workers in computing and engineering, are overrepresented in health-related jobs** - ZoomCare- 517 Union St. Seattle, WA 98101--(206) 624- 3166 - One Medical Urgent Care- 1600 7th Ave Suite 110 Seattle, WA 98101--(206) 324-999 +In 2019, 19.1 million workers age 25 and older were employed in STEM occupations in the U.S., an increase of 1.8 million since 2016. -PLACES OF INTEREST +Women make up half (50%) of those employed in STEM jobs, slightly higher than their share in the overall workforce (47%). Women’s representation across STEM occupations varies widely: they are heavily overrepresented among healthrelated jobs, the largest STEM occupational cluster, and underrepresented in several other occupational clusters. -This list is by no means exhaustive of all the wonderful experiences Seattle has to offer, but it serves as a -starting point. Click here for additional information. +## Women’s representation -Family Friendly Items of Interest: +among the six STEM occupational clusters has not changed markedly since 2016. Women are 74% of healthcare practitioners and technicians, compared with 75% in 2016. - Pike Place Market (oldest continuously operating farmers market in the country and Seattle’s most -popular site. Home to more than 500 shops, vendors, and restaurants. Photo Opps: Rachel the Piggy -Bank, Gum wall, and action shots of fish tossing) +## Representation of women in STEM varies across job clusters - Space Needle - Original Starbucks (Pike Place Starbucks store is the first Starbucks store established in 1971) - Seattle Great Wheel - Smith Tower - Museum of Pop Culture (MoPOP) - Seattle Pinball Museum - The Museum of Flight - Woodland Park Zoo - Seattle Aquarium - The Seattle Center (under the shadow of the Space Needle – find museums, concert venues, outdoor +_Share of women in each of the following job clusters_ -spaces, restaurants, and more) +**==> picture [311 x 261] intentionally omitted <==** -  Pacific Science Center - Chihuly Garden and Glass - Washington State Ferries - Seattle Whale Watching 101 - Seattle Free Walking Tours – Schedule your free Seattle 101 walking tour and pay what you feel it is +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. Each circle represents a single occupation (e.g., mechanical engineer, registered nurse). STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math. Engineering includes architects. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS) “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity”. -worth. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Self-guided tour of Seattle’s Central Waterfront. Visit HistoryLink.Tours in your mobile browser to +Women account for 25% of those working in computer occupations. The share of women in this fast-growing occupation cluster declined from 2000 to 2016 and has remained stable since then. -download the web app or follow along here on your own. +Women continue to be vastly underrepresented in the ranks of engineers and architects (15%), but their share has increased slightly from 14% in 2016. -FOOD +www.pewresearch.org - Explore Visit Seattle’s curated selection of budget-friendly dining options in the downtown Seattle +8 -area. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Restaurants located in the Summit building Convention Center +Women make up 40% of the nation’s physical scientists, up 1 percentage point since 2016. They are 48% of life scientists, compared with 47% in 2016. Women’s representation among mathematical workers has also slightly increased (46% to 47%). -o Bombo Italian Kitchen -o Monorail Expresso -o Pike Brewing Company -o Piroshky Piroshky +There is some variation in women’s representation across the jobs that comprise each of these clusters. - Restaurants located within the hotels +Women have increased their share of employment in some of the higher profile health-related STEM occupations. Women are 38% of physicians and surgeons, up 2 percentage points from 2016. They are 33% of dentists, up 3 percentage points from 2016. Among optometrists, 46% are women, up 3 percentage points from 2016. Women are 64% of veterinarians, up 3 percentage points from 2016. And women are 33% of EMTs and paramedics, up 2 percentage points from 2016. -o Crowne Plaza Seattle Downtown -o Hilton Garden Inn Seattle Downtown -o Hilton Motif Seattle -o Hilton Seattle -o Hotel 1000, LXR Hotels and Resorts -o Hyatt at Olive 8 -o Hyatt Regency Seattle -o The Paramount Hotel Seattle -o Renaissance Seattle -o Residence Inn by Marriott Seattle Downtown/ Convention Center -o Sheraton Grand Seattle -o The Westin Seattle +In addition, the share of women working as atmospheric and space scientists (which is part of the physical scientist occupational cluster) rose sharply from 15% in 2016 to 24% in 2019. - SAFETY TIPS +## Women remain underrepresented in physical sciences, computing and engineering jobs -Seattle is one of the nation’s safest big cities, statistically, but like in all cities, visitors are advised to observe -some basic safety procedures, adhere to local laws, and report crime to appropriate officials. +_Share of employed in each occupational group who are women (%)_ - Remove your conference badge; don’t draw attention to yourself and the fact that you’re a tourist. - Walk in well-lit areas; Use main streets and avoid shortcuts through alleys. - Safety in numbers: Stay in groups when exploring the city. - Be aware of your surroundings. Keep your eyes up and not on your phone. - Keep the address and phone number of where you’re staying in your phone in case you find yourself +**==> picture [232 x 119] intentionally omitted <==** -turned around. +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+72 73 75 74
43 44 46 [47]
Health-related Math
'90 '00 '10 '19 '90 '00 '10 '19
**----- End of picture text -----**
- Do not carry large amounts of cash. Use debit/credit cards. - Pay attention to your instincts; if something doesn’t feel right, you can always walk into a -business/hotel for help. +**==> picture [213 x 86] intentionally omitted <==** - Keep hotel room numbers private. Keep track of room keys. If a key is lost, ask for a different room, or +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+47 48
38
34 33 39 [40]
22
Life science Physical science
'90 '00 '10 '19 '90 '00 '10 '19
**----- End of picture text -----**
-ask for the locks to be changed. - Use all locks on hotel door, particularly the double lock. Always lock the door when leaving. - When returning to your room, make sure that you have your room key out and ready. - Never automatically open your door when a knock is heard. Know your visitor’s identity prior to +**==> picture [212 x 67] intentionally omitted <==** -admittance. Use your peephole, if available, or talk through the locked door. If someone claims they -are from maintenance, security or a hotel employee, phone the front desk to make sure the visitor is -legitimate +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+32 30
25 [25]
12 12 14 [15]
Computer Engineering
'90 '00 '10 '19 '90 '00 '10 '19
**----- End of picture text -----**
-Click here to view Visit Seattle’s extensive list of safety tips. -Seattle Downtown Ambassadors -The Metropolitan Improvement District (MID) provides Community Safety -& Hospitality ambassadors on the ground in six downtown neighborhoods -to assist visitors, residents, workers, and those in need. Ambassadors are -on the streets of downtown seven days a week, 362 days a year from 7:00 -AM – 9:00 PM ensuring clean, safe, and welcoming experience for -everyone. From providing directions to out-of-towners to connecting -those in need with services, this dedicated team helps keep downtown -safe, vibrant and welcoming. Look for the blue and green jackets on -bicycles for assistance. If provided with at least 30 minutes advanced -notice, MID can escort you to your destination. You can request any MID -service through their dispatch line at 206-441-3303. +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. Engineering includes architects. - Seattle Police Department Precincts -The Downtown Seattle and Capitol Hill neighborhoods have 24-hour staffed lobbies: +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). -Seattle Police Department West Precinct (Downtown Seattle) -810 Virginia St, cross street of 8th Ave -Phone: (206) 625-5011 +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” -Seattle Police Department East Precinct (Capitol Hill) -1519 12th Ave, cross street of E. Pine St -Phone: (206) 684-4300 +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +9 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## **Hispanic and Black workers continue to be underrepresented in the STEM workforce, while White and Asian workers are overrepresented** + +Hispanic workers are highly underrepresented in the STEM workforce – making up only 8% of STEM workers but 17% of total employment across all occupations. Their presence has increased by one percentage point in each of the six STEM occupational clusters since 2016, in line with their growth in the wider workforce. + +To illustrate, Hispanic workers are 9% of those in healthrelated jobs (up from 8% in 2016), and they comprise 8% of those in computer jobs (up from 7% in 2016). See Appendix A for more. + +Black workers, who comprise 11% of total employment across all occupations, are 9% of STEM workers. This is unchanged from 2016. Black workers account for just 5% of engineers and architects and 7% of workers in computer occupations. + +## Representation by race and ethnicity across STEM occupations + +_% of those in science, technology, engineering and math jobs who are …_ + +**==> picture [309 x 432] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. Each circle represents a single occupation (e.g., mechanical engineer, registered nurse). White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +10 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +The only STEM job cluster where Black workers are represented at the same level as their share in the total workforce is health-related STEM occupations. (They make up 11% of workers in these jobs, the same as in 2016). + +White workers constitute two-thirds of workers in STEM occupations (67%), more than their 63% share of workers across all occupations. White workers are particularly overrepresented among engineers and architects (they make up 71% of those employed in this STEM cluster). They constitute 62% of computer workers, a slight underrepresentation compared with the 63% all workers. Since 2016, the White share of employment has declined in all STEM occupation clusters, mirroring the general decrease in the White share of employment over all occupations. + +Asian workers are 13% of those employed in STEM occupations, overrepresented compared with their 6% share of total employment across all occupations. One-in-five (20%) computer workers are Asian American. Asian workers share of employment is lower by comparison, though still disproportionately high, among engineers and architects (13%) and those in health-related occupations (10%). Asian workers share of all STEM employment (13%) is the same as in 2016. + +Native American, Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander and people who identify with two or more racial groups account for 3% of STEM workers. + +www.pewresearch.org + +11 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## **STEM workers often earn more than others, but there are sizeable pay gaps for the typical STEM worker by gender, race and ethnicity** + +Pew Research Center analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) occupational employment projections prior to the pandemic shows STEM employment growth is projected to outpace economy-wide employment growth from 2019 to 2029 (9.2% for STEM jobs vs. 3.7% overall). + +The bulk of the job gains in STEM occupations (1.7 million) are projected to occur in two STEM clusters: Nearly 1 million net new jobs are projected among healthcare practitioners and technicians, and roughly 600,000 among computer workers. + +An updated analysis from BLS, accounting for labor market shifts stemming from the coronavirus pandemic, points to strong gains in jobs related to research and development in STEM (including physical, engineering, life sciences and health-related job clusters). Jobs in specific occupations, such as epidemiologist, medical scientists, biochemists and biophysicists, and biological technicians are expected to see strong growth. + +The rise of telecommuting is expected to bolster ongoing demand for jobs in computer-related occupations, including software development. + +And some of the specific STEM occupations expected to see the most gains prior to the coronavirus outbreak, such as registered nurses, are still projected to see strong growth. + +## Over 19 million workers are employed in STEM occupations + +_Current employment and projected growth in each category_ + +|_category_||| +|---|---|---| +||Employment|Projected %
change,| +||(millions)|2019-29| +|All employed|137.4|+3.7| +|STEM employed|19.1|+9.2| +|Healthcare practitioners and||| +|technicians|9.8|+10.1| +|Computer workers|5.0|+11.4| +|Engineers/architects|3.0|+2.8| +|Physical scientists|0.7|+4.8| +|Life scientists|0.3|+4.8| +|Mathematical workers|0.3|+26.6| +|Non-STEM employed|118.3|+3.0| + + + +Note: Figures do not add to totals indicated due to rounding. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math. Employment figures are for employed adults ages 25 and older, in millions. Projected % change is the projected growth from 2019-2029 for each occupation category. + +Source: Employment figures from Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). Projected change from Pew Research Center analysis of 2019-29 Bureau of Labor Statistics occupational employment projections. “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +12 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Typical earnings for STEM workers are highest for Asian men, lowest for Black and Hispanic women + +The Center analysis finds that the typical STEM worker continues to earn substantially more than the typical worker. But as with other workers, there are sizeable pay gaps between women and men in STEM jobs as well as across racial and ethnic groups. + +In 2019, median earnings for full-time, year-round workers ages 25 and older in a STEM job were about $77,400. The comparable median for workers in other, non-STEM occupations was $46,900. + +Women in STEM jobs tend to earn less than men. The median earnings of women in STEM occupations ($66,200) are about 74% of men’s median earnings in STEM ($90,000). The gender pay gap in STEM jobs has narrowed from 72% in 2016. + +The gender pay gap in STEM is wider than in the broader labor market, however. In 2019, the gender pay gap across all occupations was 80%. The labor market wide gender pay gap has not narrowed since 2016. + +## Across all racial and ethnic groups, women in STEM earn less than their male counterparts + +_Median annual earnings of full-time, year-round workers ages 25 and older, in 2019 dollars_ + +**==> picture [304 x 250] intentionally omitted <==** + +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+All jobs $50,900
Non-STEM jobs $46,900
STEM jobs $77,400
Among workers in STEM jobs who are...
Asian men $103,300
White men $90,600
Asian women $88,600
Hispanic men $73,000
Black men $69,200
White women $66,200
Black women $57,000
Hispanic women $57,000
**----- End of picture text -----**
+ + +Note: Based on workers with positive earnings. Figures based on 2019 dollars and rounded to the nearest hundred. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math. + +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +The racial and ethnic earnings + +gaps among STEM workers are substantial and have recently increased. The median earnings of Black full-time, year-round workers ages 25 and older in STEM occupations ($61,100) are 78% of + +www.pewresearch.org + +13 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +the median earnings of White workers in STEM ($78,000). The gap has widened in recent years: In 2016, the Black-to-White earnings gap in the STEM workforce was 81%. + +The typical Hispanic worker in STEM earns about $65,000, or 83% of the typical White worker in STEM. Here too, the gap has widened: In 2016, the Hispanic-to-White pay gap in the STEM workforce was 85%. + +Asian workers in STEM tend to be paid more than comparable White workers in STEM, and that pay disparity has widened. The median annual earnings of an Asian full-time, yearround worker age 25 and older employed in a STEM occupation ($99,100) is 127% that of a comparable White worker. In 2016, the Asianto-White earnings disparity was 125%.[4] + +There is a gender pay gap among workers in each racial and ethnic group, resulting in the highest earnings for the typical Asian man in a STEM job and the lowest earnings for the typical Black and Hispanic women working in STEM jobs. Such gaps echo those found for all workers.[5] A number of studies have shown that gender, racial and ethnic group pay gaps persist with controls for education and job characteristics.[6] + +## Sizeable pay gaps among STEM workers by gender, race and ethnicity remain + +_Median annual earnings of full-time, year-round workers ages 25 and older, in 2019 dollars_ + +_Compared with men working in STEM_ + +**==> picture [227 x 105] intentionally omitted <==** + +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+Women 74%
Compared with White workers in STEM
Asian 127%
Hispanic 83%
Black 78%
**----- End of picture text -----**
+ + +**==> picture [165 x 9] intentionally omitted <==** + +**----- Start of picture text -----**
+Compared with White workers in STEM
**----- End of picture text -----**
+ + +Note: Based on workers with positive earnings in science, technology, engineering and math occupations (STEM). White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. + +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +> 4 Across all occupations, the Black-to-White (73%) and Hispanic-to-White (68%) earnings gaps are wider than the pay disparities in STEM occupations. + +> 5 Miller, Kevin, Deborah J. Vagins, 2018, The Simple Truth About the Gender Pay Gap, AAUW. Also see the 2020 update. + +> 6 A 2018 Pew Research Center analysis showed that gender pay gaps for STEM workers occur across all education levels. A large literature has explored the source of gender and other pay gaps. See Francine D. Blau and Lawrence M Kahn, 2017. “The Gender Wage Gap: Extent, ” Trends, and Explanations Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 55, No.3; Shulamit Kahn and Donna Ginther, 2017. “Women and STEM.” NBER Working Paper 23525; Katherine Michelmore and Sharon Sassler, “Explaining the Gender Wage Gap in STEM: Does Field Sex Composition Matter?” Journal of the Social Sciences, Volume 2, Number 4, August 2016, pp. 194-215; Valeria Wilson and William M. Rodgers III, Sept. 20, 2016, “Black-white wage gaps expand with rising wage inequality,” Economic Policy Institute. + +www.pewresearch.org + +14 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## **Training programs at U.S. colleges and universities point to ongoing challenges for increasing diversity of STEM workforce** + +Roughly two-thirds of STEM workers (67%) have completed a bachelor’s or postgraduate education, and among these STEM workers, about three-quarters earned a degree in a STEM field. While the nation’s colleges and universities have increased the number of degrees awarded in STEM fields, there is little indication that the flow of degree recipients will dramatically increase gender, racial and ethnic representation in related job areas over the near term. + +_The number of STEM graduates has grown, especially at the bachelor’s and master’s levels_ + +More Americans have been earning college degrees in recent years, and many more have been doing so in STEM fields. + +The growth in STEM degree recipients has far outpaced that for all degrees. Between 2010 and 2018, the most recent year for which data is available, the number of STEM bachelor’s degrees awarded grew by 62%, compared with 20% growth for all degrees. + +The number of bachelor’s degrees awarded in computer and information sciences roughly doubled from 2010 to 2018 (a 101% increase), and the number awarded in health-related fields grew almost as much over the same time period (an 87% increase). + +## Growth in STEM degrees far outpaces overall growth in degrees awarded since 2010 + +_Total number of degrees awarded and % of degrees awarded to U.S. citizens and permanent residents_ + +**==> picture [310 x 255] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: The number of degrees awarded is rounded to the nearest hundred. Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool . + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +15 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +American citizens and permanent residents earn an overwhelming share of STEM degrees at the bachelor’s and professional doctorate levels; they make up a majority of master’s (67%) and research doctorate (61%) degree recipients in STEM fields. The share of U.S. citizens and permanent residents varies across degree fields. This group earned fewer than half of research doctorates in computer and information sciences (41%) and engineering and architecture (42%) in the 2017-2018 school year, the most recent year data is available. + +Some foreign students earning degrees in the U.S. later join the U.S. workforce through programs such as the H-1B visa or Optional Practical Training (OPT). Between 2004 and 2016, nearly 1.5 million foreign graduates stayed in the U.S. through the OPT program. More than half in the OPT program (53%) were approved for employment in STEM fields. An analysis by the Council of Graduate Schools finds enrollment of international graduate students dropped in 2020, raising questions about the future flow of international students to STEM employment in the U.S., however. + +## **Women are underrepresented in math, physical sciences, computing and engineering, but not all STEM degree fields** + +Women are more likely than men to enroll in college and to earn a bachelor’s degree. Women have been an increasing share of the college-educated workforce as well. As of the first quarter of 2019, the number of women effectively matched the number of men in the college-educated workforce for the first time. + +Women earned a majority of all bachelor’s, master’s and doctorate degrees awarded to U.S. citizens and permanent residents in the 2017-2018 school year. But they accounted for 53% of degrees in STEM fields at the bachelor’s level and 48% at the research doctoral level. Women made up a larger share — 60% — of master’s degree recipients in STEM fields, especially in health-related degree programs such as nursing. + +Women also earned a 58% majority of professional doctorate degrees in the health sciences. They earned a smaller share of M.D. (48%) and D.D.S. and D.M.D. degrees (49%), however. + +## What is a professional doctorate degree? + +Professional doctorates usually prepare degree recipients to work in a specific field. Almost all STEM professional doctorates are awarded in health-related fields. Common health-related professional doctorates include doctor of medicine (MD), doctor of osteopathic medicine (DO), doctor of dental surgery (DDS) and doctor of physical therapy (DPT). + +www.pewresearch.org + +16 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +Across all degree levels, women make up majorities of degree recipients in health-related fields and in the life sciences, which includes studies in agriculture, environmental sciences and biology. + +More men than women earned degrees in other STEM fields. Women earned between 36% and 40% of degrees awarded in the physical sciences across all degree levels in the 2017-2018 academic year. In math, 42% of bachelor’s and 36% of master’s degrees were earned by women; just 25% of math research doctorates were earned by women in 2018. + +Women are particularly underrepresented in engineering and computer sciences. Women earned less than one-quarter of bachelor’s degrees in engineering (22%) and computer science (19%) and no more than about three-in-ten master’s or research doctoral degrees in these fields as of 2018. + +## Women are underrepresented among graduates in math, physical science, engineering and computer science + +_% of degree recipients at each level who are women_ + +**==> picture [477 x 205] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: Degrees awarded for all fields and science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM) based on U.S. citizens and permanent residents. Engineering includes architecture. + +Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool, 2017-18 school year. “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +17 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## **Black and Hispanic degree recipients are underrepresented in STEM fields** + +Prior to the pandemic, the share of Hispanics enrolled in college was increasing, and more Hispanics were earning bachelor’s degrees. In 2018, Hispanics earned 15% of all bachelor’s degrees, up six percentage points since 2010. + +The share of Hispanics earning a bachelor’s degree in a STEM field has increased (from 8% in 2010 to 12% in 2018). Hispanic enrollment in college has declined since the coronavirus outbreak, however, casting doubt on whether these gains will continue. + +Even with gains since 2010, Hispanic adults remain less likely than White, Asian and Black adults to earn a college degree and are underrepresented among STEM degree recipients. + +Hispanic adults earned 9% of master’s degrees and 6% research doctorate’s in STEM as of 2018. This is lower than their 11% share of master’s degrees and 8% of research + +## Hispanics earned a growing share of STEM degrees since 2010 + +_% of degree recipients at each education level and % in the adult population_ + +**==> picture [273 x 403] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: Degrees awarded for all fields and science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM) based on U.S. citizens and permanent residents. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Comparable data for Other not available in 2010. In 2010 Asian includes some Pacific Islanders and Native Hawaiians. + +Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool, 2009-10, 2013-14 and 2017-18 school years. “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +18 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +doctorate’s in any field. In computer science, Hispanic students earned 8% of master’s degrees and 6% of research doctorates awarded to U.S. citizens and permanent residents in the 2017-2018 school year. They earned 8% of master’s degrees in math and 9% each in life science and physical science fields. In engineering and architecture programs, Hispanic adults earned 10% of master’s degrees. (See Appendix A for degrees earned in STEM degree fields.) + +Black students earned no more than 9% of the STEM degrees awarded in 2018 across bachelor’s, master’s and doctoral levels, figures that have seen little change since 2010. + +Black students are especially underrepresented in math, engineering and physical science degree programs; they earned no more than 5% of master’s and research doctoral degrees in engineering or physical science during the 2017-2018 school year. Black students comprise just 3% to 4% of degree-recipients in mathematics at the master’s level and above. + +In computer science fields, Black students earned 9% of bachelor’s degrees, 13% of master’s degrees and 7% of all research doctorates over the 2017-2018 school year. + +- Analysis of the Computing Research Association’s survey of Ph.D. granting programs finds just 2.4% of new U.S. resident Ph.D. graduates in artificial intelligence (a subset of those in computer science, computer engineering and information programs) were Black and just 3.2% were Hispanic in 2019. Such figures speak to ongoing questions about whether the lack of diversity among workers contributes to biases in AI algorithms. + +Asian students are overrepresented in STEM fields at all degree levels compared with their share of all degree recipients. Asian students earned 10%-11% of STEM-related bachelor’s, master’s and research doctorate degrees in 2018. For comparison, Asian students earned 7% of all bachelor’s, master’s and research doctorate degrees over the same time period. + +White students are overrepresented in STEM fields, particularly at the doctoral level, compared with the share of all degree recipients. White students earned 67% of all research doctorates in a STEM degree field over the 2017-2018 school year; they earned 63% of all research doctorates awarded that year. + +The share of White students earning STEM degrees has gone down since 2010 across all degree levels, mirroring the decrease in the White share of the U.S. adult population. For instance, the share of White students earning STEM bachelor’s degrees declined from 67% in 2010 to 62% in 2018. + +www.pewresearch.org + +19 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +White students earned a higher share of degrees in the physical sciences than other STEM fields. They earned two-thirds of bachelor’s degrees (66%) in the physical sciences, 72% of master’s degrees and 73% of research doctorates in 2018. + +Native Americans, Native Hawaiians, Pacific Islanders and people who identify with more than one racial group earned 4% of bachelor’s degrees and 3% of advanced degrees in STEM fields. + +## Across racial and ethnic groups, the representation of women in STEM degree fields varies + +The share of women earning STEM degrees varies across racial and ethnic groups. Among Black students earning degrees in a STEM field, more are women than men. This pattern aligns with long-standing gender gaps in educational attainment of Black students across all degree fields. + +This gender gap is especially pronounced for advanced degree-earners. Among Black students, women earned 68% of STEM master’s degrees, 65% of STEM research doctorates and 65% of STEM professional doctorates during the 2017-2018 school year. + +Among Hispanic graduates in 2018, women earn majorities of STEM degrees at most levels, though there is gender balance among those earning STEM research doctorates (50% women, 50% men). + +## Of those earning STEM degrees, there are more Black women than men + +_% of those earning a degree in a STEM field who are …_ + +**==> picture [231 x 385] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: Degrees awarded in science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM) based on U.S. citizens and permanent residents. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan Native, nonHispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. + +Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool, 2017-18 school year. “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +20 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +Among Asian students, the gender balance of graduates in STEM fields is mixed. More Asian women than men earned STEM degrees in 2018 at the master’s level, as well as in professional doctoral programs, nearly all of which are in a health-related field. + +Among White graduates in a STEM field, more White women than men earned degrees in STEM fields at the bachelor’s, master’s, and professional doctorate levels. Among White students earning a research doctorate in a STEM field in 2018, 47% were women and 53% were men, however. + +www.pewresearch.org + +21 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Acknowledgments + +This report is made possible by The Pew Charitable Trusts. It is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. Find related reports online at: pewresearch.org/science. + +## Primary research team + +Rick Fry, _Senior Economist_ Brian Kennedy, _Senior Researcher_ + +Cary Funk, _Director, Science and Society Research_ + +## Research team + +Kim Parker, _Director, Social Trends Research_ Alec Tyson, _Associate Director, Science and Society Research_ Anna Brown, _Research Associate_ Courtney Johnson, _Research Associate_ Jesse Bennett, _Research Assistant_ Cary Lynne Thigpen, _Research Assistant_ Alison Spencer, _Research Assistant_ + +## Editorial and graphic design + +Travis Mitchell, _Copy Editor_ + +Margaret Porteus, _Information Graphics Designer_ + +## Communications and web publishing + +Tanya Arditi, _Communications Manager_ Gar Meng Leong, _Communications Associate_ Haley Nolan, _Communications Associate_ Julia O’Hanlon, _Communications Associate_ Reem Nadeem, _Associate Digital Producer_ + +www.pewresearch.org + +22 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## **Appendix A: Detailed charts and tables** + +## Black and Hispanic adults are underrepresented across most STEM job clusters + +_% of Black and Hispanic adults in each of the following job clusters_ + +**==> picture [270 x 318] intentionally omitted <==** + +**==> picture [184 x 317] intentionally omitted <==** + +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math occupations. Engineering includes architects. Each circle represents a single occupation (e.g., mechanical engineer, registered nurse). White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-2019 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +23 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Racial and ethnic group representation in STEM occupations + +_% of employed who are ____ and total number of workers in each occupation_ + +|Racial and ethnic group representation in STEM occupations
_% of employed who are ____ and total number of workers in each occupation_|| +|---|---| +|Black
Hispanic Asian
Other
White
All employed, ages 25 and older
11%
17%
6%
3%
63%|Total workers
137,400,000| +|Computer workers
7
8
20
3
62
Computer support specialists
11
11
11
3
64
Computer scientists and systems analysts/web developers
10
9
14
3
64
Network and computer systems administrators
9
9
11
3
68
Database administrators
7
6
20
3
63
Computer and information systems managers
6
7
15
3
70
Computer programmers
4
7
20
2
67
Software developers,applications and systems software
4
5
33
3
54|4,966,711
611,775
1,636,033
210,647
116,318
610,113
371,382
1,410,502| +|Mathematical workers
9
8
16
3
64
Operations research analysts
12
10
11
4
64
Misc. mathematical science, incl. mathematicians, statisticians
6
7
23
3
62
Actuaries
4
3
16
2
75|305,242
148,438
127,033
29,772| +|Engineers and architects
5
9
13
2
71
Engineering technicians, except drafters
9
13
8
3
66
Computer hardware engineers
8
5
31
2
54
Marine engineers and naval architects
8
6
5
3
77
Environmental engineers
7
7
12
3
72
Electrical and electronics engineers
6
7
18
3
66
Aerospace engineers
5
9
13
3
71
Civil engineers
5
9
11
2
73
Engineers, all other
5
8
18
3
67
Industrial engineers, including health and safety
4
9
13
2
72
Chemical engineers
4
6
15
2
73
Materials engineers
4
6
14
3
72
Petroleum, mining, mining safety and geological engineers
4
11
11
2
72
Mechanical engineers
4
8
12
2
74
Drafters
4
12
7
2
74
Surveyors, cartographers and photogrammetrists
4
6
3
2
85
Surveying and mapping technicians
4
9
1
3
82
Architectural and engineering managers
3
6
12
2
77
Architects, except naval
3
10
11
2
73
Sales engineers
2
9
6
3
80|3,034,215
407,163
50,187
14,061
28,676
218,654
125,675
358,060
554,731
217,249
60,081
42,161
33,431
272,277
145,989
34,104
56,782
171,836
212,005
40,093| +|Life scientists
6
8
19
3
65
Agricultural and food science technicians
12
15
8
3
62
Biological technicians
9
16
11
5
59
Medical scientists and life scientists, all other
6
6
30
3
55
Natural science managers
5
5
10
3
77
Agricultural and food scientists
5
5
9
3
78
Biological scientists
3
7
14
3
73
Conservation scientists and foresters
2
4
1
3
90|340,153
36,591
20,389
137,019
20,965
23,584
81,683
19,922| + + + +Notes: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math occupations. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +24 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Racial and ethnic group representation in STEM occupations, continued + +_% of employed who are ____ and total number of workers in each occupation_ + +|Racial and ethnic group representation in STEM occupations, continued
_% of employed who are ____ and total number of workers in each occupation_|| +|---|---| +|Black
Hispanic Asian
Other
White
Physical scientists
6%
8%
18%
3%
65%
Chemical technicians
13
12
7
2
67
Miscellaneous life, physical and social science technicians
8
12
10
4
65
Chemists and materials scientists
8
6
18
2
66
Atmospheric and space scientists
7
6
4
2
81
Astronomers and physicists
4
5
10
1
80
Physical scientists, all other
4
6
30
2
58
Geological and petroleum technicians, nuclear technicians
4
15
4
7
71
Environmental scientists andgeoscientists
2
7
5
2
84|Total workers
690,906
61,651
164,651
91,167
10,873
11,727
271,466
5,884
73,487| +|Healthcare practitioners and technicians
11
9
10
3
68
Licensed practical and licensed vocational nurses
26
12
5
3
54
Health Technologists and Technicians, all others
21
13
9
3
55
Recreational therapists
17
6
5
2
69
Clinical laboratory technologists and technicians
16
12
12
3
56
Health diagnosing and treating practitioner support technicians
15
14
6
3
61
Medical records and health information technicians
14
11
6
3
66
Respiratory therapists
13
12
8
3
65
Medical and health services managers
12
11
5
2
69
Healthcare practitioners and technical occupations, all other
12
11
4
3
70
Dieticians and nutritionists
12
10
5
2
70
Therapists, all other
12
11
5
3
69
Registered nurses
11
7
9
2
70
Diagnostic related technologists and technicians
8
11
7
2
71
Emergency medical technicians and paramedics
8
12
3
3
74
Radiation therapists
8
8
5
1
79
Pharmacists
7
4
21
2
66
Opticians, dispensing
6
13
6
3
73
Occupational therapists
6
5
7
2
80
Physician assistants
5
9
8
3
75
Physicians and surgeons
5
7
21
3
64
Health diagnosing and treating practitioners, all other
5
6
22
2
65
Speech language pathologists
5
8
2
2
83
Dentists
4
6
18
2
69
Dental hygienists
4
9
5
2
80
Physical therapists
4
5
12
2
77
Podiatrists
3
3
8
2
84
Audiologists
3
8
4
2
83
Chiropractors
2
4
5
1
87
Optometrists
2
4
19
2
73
Veterinarians
2
4
4
2
87|9,796,854
754,805
133,020
12,390
301,566
591,386
180,215
108,125
693,991
148,054
98,463
180,078
3,402,082
383,797
187,402
16,315
303,163
61,701
121,434
125,938
960,096
31,605
165,685
171,466
183,134
256,484
9,585
18,916
63,847
43,780
88,332| + + + +Notes: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math occupations. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +25 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Women’s representation in STEM occupations + +_% of employed who are women and total number of workers in each occupation_ + +||Women|Total workers| +|---|---|---| +|All employed, ages 25 and older|47%|137,400,000| +|Computer workers|25|4,966,771| +|Database administrators|36|116,318| +|Computer scientists and systems analysts/web developers|30|1,636,033| +|Computer and information systems managers|29|610,113| +|Computer support specialists|25|611,775| +|Computer programmers|22|371,382| +|Software developers, applications and systems software|19|1,410,502| +|Network and computer systems administrators|19|210,647| +|Mathematical workers|47|305,242| +|Operations research analysts|50|148,438| +|Misc. mathematical science, incl. mathematicians, statisticians|46|127,033| +|Actuaries|37|29,772| +|Engineers and architects|15|3,034,215| +|Environmental engineers|28|28,676| +|Architects, except naval|28|212,005| +|Industrial engineers, including health and safety|21|217,249| +|Drafters|20|145,989| +|Surveyors, cartographers, and photogrammetrists|20|34,104| +|Chemical engineers|18|60,081| +|Engineering technicians, except drafters|17|407,163| +|Civil engineers|14|358,060| +|Computer hardware engineers|14|50,187| +|Engineers, all others|14|554,731| +|Materials engineers|13|42,161| +|Aerospace engineers|13|125,675| +|Petroleum, mining, mining safety and geological engineers|11|33,431| +|Architectural and engineering managers|11|171,836| +|Electrical and electronics engineers|10|218,654| +|Surveying and mapping technicians|9|56,782| +|Sales engineers|9|40,093| +|Mechanical engineers|8|272,277| +|Marine engineers and naval architects|8|14,061| +|Life scientists|48|340,153| +|Natural science managers|56|20,965| +|Medical scientists and life scientists, all other|55|137,019| +|Biological technicians|51|20,389| +|Biological scientists|49|81,683| +|Agricultural and food science technicians|36|36,591| +|Agricultural and food scientists|35|23,584| +|Conservation scientists and foresters|27|19,922| + + + +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for Science, technology, engineering and math occupations. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +26 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Women’s representation in STEM occupations, continued + +|Women’s representation in STEM occupations, continued|Women’s representation in STEM occupations, continued|| +|---|---|---| +|_% of employed who are women and total number of workers in each occupation_||| +||Women|Total workers| +|Physical scientists|40%|690,606| +|Miscellaneous life, physical and social science technicians|46|164,651| +|Physical scientists, all other|42|271,466| +|Chemists and materials scientists|40|91,167| +|Chemical technicians|35|61,651| +|Environmental scientists and geoscientists|33|73,487| +|Atmospheric and space scientists|24|10,873| +|Geological and petroleum technicians, nuclear technicians|18|5,884| +|Astronomers andphysicists|16|11,727| +|Healthcare practitioners and technicians|74|9,796,854| +|Speech language pathologists|95|165,685| +|Dental hygienists|95|183,134| +|Dieticians and nutritionists|91|98,463| +|Medical records and health information technicians|91|180,215| +|Occupational therapists|88|121,434| +|Registered nurses|88|3,402,082| +|Licensed practical and licensed vocational nurses|88|754,805| +|Audiologists|83|18,916| +|Therapists, all other|80|180,078| +|Health diagnosing and treating practitioner support technicians|79|591,386| +|Recreational therapists|77|12,390| +|Clinical laboratory technologists and technicians|72|301,566| +|Medical and health services managers|72|693,991| +|Health diagnosing and treating practitioners, all other|71|31,605| +|Opticians, dispensing|71|61,701| +|Diagnostic related technologists and technicians|68|383,797| +|Physical therapists|67|256,484| +|Physician assistants|67|125,938| +|Radiation therapists|66|16,315| +|Health technologists and technicians, all other|65|133,020| +|Respiratory therapists|65|108,125| +|Veterinarians|64|88,332| +|Pharmacists|58|303,163| +|Healthcare practitioners and technical occupations, all other|51|148,054| +|Optometrists|46|43,780| +|Physicians and surgeons|38|960,096| +|Emergency medical technicians and paramedics|33|187,402| +|Dentists|33|171,466| +|Chiropractors|29|63,847| +|Podiatrists|28|9,585| + + + +Note: Based on employed adults ages 25 and older. STEM stands for science, technology, engineering and math occupations. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of 2017-19 American Community Survey (IPUMS). + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +27 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## Racial and ethnic group representation across STEM degree fields + +_Among degree recipients at each level, % who are …_ + +||White|Black|Hispanic|Asian|Other| +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +|Health-related|||||| +|Bachelor’s|63|9|12|7|3| +|Master’s|63|11|9|8|3| +|Research doctorate|64|12|6|7|3| +|Professional doctorate|60|6|7|18|3| +|Life science|||||| +|Bachelor’s|60|7|13|13|5| +|Master’s|62|7|9|12|4| +|Research doctorate|68|5|7|10|3| +|Physical science|||||| +|Bachelor’s|66|5|12|10|5| +|Master’s|72|4|9|7|4| +|Research doctorate|73|3|6|9|3| +|Computer science|||||| +|Bachelor’s|55|9|11|16|4| +|Master’s|49|13|8|18|4| +|Research doctorate|60|7|6|13|4| +|Mathematics|||||| +|Bachelor’s|62|5|12|14|4| +|Master’s|64|4|8|15|3| +|Research doctorate|68|3|6|11|3| +|Engineering|||||| +|Bachelor’s|65|5|12|11|4| +|Master’s|62|5|10|13|3| +|Research doctorate|64|4|6|14|3| + + + +Note: Degrees awarded for science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM) based on U.S. citizens and permanent residents. Engineering includes architecture. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. + +Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool, 2017-18 school year. “STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + +28 PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +## STEM degree recipients by race and ethnicity, 2010-18 + +_Among degree recipients at each level, % who are …_ + +||White|Black|Hispanic|Asian|Other| +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +|All Bachelor’s degrees|||||| +|2018|60|10|15|7|4| +|2014|63|10|12|7|3| +|2010|67|9|9|7|--| +|STEM Bachelor’s degrees|||||| +|2018|62|7|12|11|4| +|2014|65|7|10|10|3| +|2010|67|7|8|10|--| +|All Master’s degrees|||||| +|2018|60|12|11|7|3| +|2014|62|12|9|6|3| +|2010|63|11|7|6|--| +|STEM Master’s degrees|||||| +|2018|62|9|9|11|3| +|2014|64|8|7|9|3| +|2010|65|7|6|10|--| +|All Research doctorate degrees|||||| +|2018|63|11|8|7|3| +|2014|66|10|7|7|2| +|2010|69|8|5|8|--| +|STEM Research doctorate|degrees||||| +|2018|67|6|6|10|3| +|2014|69|5|5|10|2| +|2010|70|5|5|11|--| +|All Professional doctorate|degrees||||| +|2018|61|7|9|14|3| +|2014|64|6|7|13|3| +|2010|66|6|6|12|--| +|STEM Professional doctorate degrees|||||| +|2018|60|6|7|18|3| +|2014|62|5|6|18|2| +|2010|66|5|5|16|--| + + + +Note: Degrees awarded for all fields and science, technology, engineering and math fields (STEM) based on U.S. citizens and permanent residents. White, Black and Asian adults include those who report being only one race and are not Hispanic. Hispanics are of any race. Other includes non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan native, non-Hispanic Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and non-Hispanic two or more major racial groups. Comparable data for Other not available in 2010. In 2010, Asian includes some Pacific Islanders and Native Hawaiians. + +Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System analyzed using the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Interactive Data Tool. + +“STEM Jobs See Uneven Progress in Increasing Gender, Racial and Ethnic Diversity” + +## PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org diff --git a/q79/random_k2/question.json b/q79/random_k2/question.json index 48ffff2a54d8c06f618892ecd55657e6de24131f..76cf8ea4bd664e69082fb19e15080a72aad08127 100644 --- a/q79/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q79/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "afe620b9beac86c1027b96d31d396407.pdf", - "web_e8bd96b3e8d8470e.pdf", - "web_db15f36044519c81.pdf" + "resize_r2_5.pdf", + "resize_r1_17.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k2/random_1.md b/q79/random_k2/random_1.md index 8b5145cdef1e9c769f452af7702f989dc53f9df7..1baafa3214e3d1c3ba84ae8c4e451072ec71f1c5 100644 --- a/q79/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q79/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,2662 +1,891 @@ -Corporate Governance Report -Between my past, the present and the future, there -is one common factor: Relationship and Trust. -This is the foundation of our growth. -Shri Dhirubhai H. Ambani -Founder Chairman -K. Sethuraman Savithri Jyoti Sridhar -Parekh Jain Kothandaraman -Our Corporate Governance practices enable inclusive growth -and help build sustainable societal value -This report is prepared in accordance governance processes and an We believe, Corporate Governance is -with the provisions of the Securities entrepreneurial performance focused not just a destination, but a journey to -and Exchange Board of India work environment. constantly improve sustainable value -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure creation. It is an upward-moving target -The demands of Corporate Governance -Requirements) Regulations, 2015 that we collectively strive towards -require professionals to raise their -(“Listing Regulations”) and the report achieving. Our multiple initiatives -competence and capability levels to -contains the details of Corporate towards maintaining the highest -meet the expectations in managing the -Governance systems and processes at standards of governance are detailed -enterprise and its resources effectively -Reliance Industries Limited (“RIL” or in this Report. -with the highest standards of ethics. -“the Company”). -We have a defined policy framework Corporate Governance -Statement on Company’s for ethical conduct of businesses. We Structure, Policies and -believe that any business conduct -Philosophy on Code Practices -can be ethical only when it rests on -of Governance -the six core values viz. Customer The Company has put in place -Corporate Governance encompasses Value, Ownership Mindset, Respect, an internal multi-tier governance -a set of systems and practices to Integrity, One Team and Excellence. structure with defined roles and -ensure that the Company’s affairs responsibilities of every constituent of -We believe, our governance standards -are managed in a manner which the system. -must be globally benchmarked. -ensures accountability, transparency -Therefore, we have institutionalised -and fairness in all transactions in the Ethics/Governance Policies -the right building blocks for future -widest sense. The objective is to meet -growth. It is our endeavour to achieve At RIL, we strive to conduct our -stakeholders’ aspirations and societal -higher standards and provide oversight business and strengthen our -expectations. We are committed -and guidance to the management relationships in a manner that is -to meet the aspirations of all our -in strategy implementation, risk dignified, distinctive and responsible. -stakeholders. This is demonstrated -management and fulfilment of stated We adhere to ethical standards -in shareholder returns, high credit -goals and objectives. to ensure integrity, transparency, -ratings, awards and recognitions, -independence and accountability -62 Reliance Industries Limited - -in dealing with all the stakeholders. and has a zero-tolerance approach to − Independent review of related -Therefore, we have adopted various non-compliance with the Anti-Bribery party transactions by one of the -codes and policies to carry out our & Anti-Corruption Policy. The Company Big4 accounting firms/Independent -duties in an ethical manner. prohibits bribery, corruption and any accounting firms for arm’s length -form of improper payments/dealings consideration and comparison with -Code of Conduct in the conduct of business operations. the benchmarks available for similar -Training/awareness programmes type of transactions. -The Company has in place a -are conducted on periodical basis to -comprehensive Code of Conduct and -sensitise employees. RIL’s Integrated Reporting -Our Code (the “Codes”) applicable -to the Directors and employees. The The Anti-Bribery & Anti-Corruption RIL published its maiden Integrated -Codes give guidance and reflect Policy is available on the website of Annual Report in the FY 2016-17 -the core values of the Company the Company and can be accessed aligned with the International -viz. Customer Value, Ownership at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/ Integrated Reporting Council’s (IIRC) -Mindset, Respect, Integrity, One Team files/2023-12/RIL-Anti-bribery-and-Anti- framework. RIL’s Integrated -and Excellence. corruption-Policy.pdf. Reporting is covered in Management -Discussion and Analysis Report. -The Codes are available on the -Corporate Governance -website of the Company. The Codes -Board of Directors -have been circulated to the Directors Practices -and Senior Management Personnel RIL endeavours to continuously The Company has defined guidelines -and its compliance is affirmed by improve and adopt the best Corporate and an established framework for -them annually. Governance codes and practices. the meetings of the Board and its -A declaration on confirmation of Some of the implemented global Committees. These guidelines seek -compliance of the Code of Conduct, governance norms and best practices to systematise the decision-making -signed by the Company’s Chairman include the following: process at the meetings of the Board -and Committees in an informed and -and Managing Director is attached to − Quarterly review by the efficient manner. -this Report. Stakeholders’ Relationship -Committee of securities related Core Skills/Expertise/ -Vigil Mechanism and filings with Stock Exchanges. Competencies available with -Whistle-Blower Policy the Board -− Board committees for oversight on -The Company has a Vigil Mechanism matters relating to risks, corporate The Board comprises qualified -and Whistle-Blower policy under which social responsibility, business and experienced members who -the employees are encouraged to responsibility and sustainability possess required skills, expertise and -report violations of applicable laws and reporting, environmental, social and competencies that allow them to make -regulations and the Code of Conduct governance etc. effective contributions to the Board -– without fear of any retaliation. The and its Committees. -− Executive Committees of senior -reportable matters may be disclosed -management for continuous The following skills/expertise/ -to the Ethics & Compliance Task Force -review of operational and financial competencies have been identified -which operates under the supervision -risk mitigation measures and for the effective functioning of the -of the Audit Committee. Employees -governance practices. Company and are currently available -may also report violations to the -with the Board: -Chairman of the Audit Committee. − Independent Internal Audit Function -There was no instance of denial of providing risk based assurance − Leadership/Operational experience -access to the Audit Committee. across all material areas of Group − Strategic Planning -Risk and Compliance exposures. -The Vigil Mechanism and − Industry Experience, Research & -Whistle-Blower Policy is available − Quarterly secretarial compliance Development and Innovation -on the website of the Company and certification from an independent − Global Business -can be accessed at https://www.ril. Company Secretary in whole- -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -com/sites/default/files/2023-01/ time practice. -Risk Management -Vigil-Mechanism-and-Whistle-Blower- -Policy.pdf. − Assurance by an independent − Corporate Governance -firm of Chartered Accountants -on the functions of Registrar and -Anti-Bribery and -Transfer Agent. -Anti-Corruption Policy -The Company is committed in doing -business with integrity & transparency -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 63 - -Corporate Governance Report -While all the Board members possess the skills identified, their area of core expertise is given in their respective -profiles below: -Brief Profile of Directors -Brief profile of Directors of the Company including their category, shareholding in the Company, number of other Directorships -including name of listed entities where he/she is a director alongwith the category of their directorships, committee positions -held by them in other companies as a Member or Chairperson, areas of expertise and other details are given below: -Directorship in other equity listed -| | | company(ies) and category of | Areas of Expertise | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------ | -directorship* -| | Appointed: April 1, 1977 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -| | 80,52,020 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 2 − Industry Experience, Research & -Mukesh D. Ambani** Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -| Chairman and Managing | chairmanship(s) in other | | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -− Global Business -| Director | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -(DIN: 00001695) -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: June 18, 2014 | − Cipla Limited - | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | -------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: Nil -| | | − Network18 Media & Investments | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | --- | -------------------------------- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 9 -| | | Limited - Independent Director | − Industry Experience, Research & | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -Adil Zainulbhai## chairmanship(s) in other − TV18 Broadcast Limited – Development and Innovation -Independent Director -| Independent Director | company(ies)*^: | | − Global Business | -| -------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | -(DIN: 06646490) 7 – (including 5 as Chairman) − Larsen and Toubro Limited - -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -| | | Independent Director | Risk Management | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --------------- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: June 12, 2015 | − Adani Green Energy Limited - | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | Shareholding*: | Independent Director | Operational experience | -12,899 equity shares -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 -− Industry Experience, Research & -Raminder Singh Gujral Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -| (DIN: 07175393) | company(ies)*^: | | Risk Management | -| --------------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | -| | 2 – (as Chairman) | | − Corporate Governance | -| | Appointed: July 21, 2017 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -| | 14,400 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 -− Global Business -Dr. Shumeet Banerji Committee membership(s)/ − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 02787784) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: October 17, 2018 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -91 equity shares -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 2 -− Global Business -| Arundhati Bhattacharya | Committee membership(s)/ | | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 02011213) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -64 Reliance Industries Limited - -Directorship in other equity listed -| | | company(ies) and category of | Areas of Expertise | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------ | -directorship* -| | Appointed: July 19, 2021 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: Nil -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: Nil -− Global Business -Committee membership(s)/ -His Excellency Yasir chairmanship(s) in other − Industry Experience, Research & -Othman H. Al Rumayyan company(ies)*^: Nil Development and Innovation -Independent Director -− Corporate Governance -(DIN: 09245977) -| | Appointed: October 18, 2019 | − CCL Products (India) Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | - Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: Nil -| | | − Divi’s Laboratories Limited | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 7 -| | | - Independent Director | − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & | -| --- | --- | ---------------------- | -------------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -K. V. Chowdary chairmanship(s) in other − Tata Motors Limited Risk Management -- Independent Director -Independent Director company(ies)*^: 5 – − Corporate Governance -| (w.e.f. July 21, 2022) | (including 1 as Chairman) | − Anant Raj Limited | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | --- | -(DIN: 08485334) -- Independent Director -| | Appointed: January 20, 2023 | − Jio Financial Services Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | - Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: -| | 4,849 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -| | Other Directorship(s)*#: 1 | | − Global Business | -K. V. Kamath Committee membership(s)/ − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 00043501) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | − Jio Financial Services Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------------- | -Shareholding*: - Non-Executive Director Operational experience -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 4 -− Industry Experience, Research & -| Isha M. Ambani@ | | | Development and Innovation | -| --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -Non-Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Corporate Governance -| (DIN: 06984175) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------- | -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 − Industry Experience, Research & -Akash M. Ambani@ Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Non-Executive Director -| | chairmanship(s) in other | | − Corporate Governance | -| ---------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | -| (DIN: 06984194) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| | Other Directorship(s)*#: 5 | | − Corporate Governance | -| Anant M. Ambani@ | Committee membership(s)/ | | | -| Non-Executive Director | chairmanship(s) in other | | | -| (DIN: 07945702) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 65 - -Corporate Governance Report -Directorship in other equity listed -company(ies) and category of Areas of Expertise -directorship* -Appointed: June 26, 1986 Nil − Leadership/ -Shareholding*: Operational experience -35,80,529 equity shares − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 1 − Industry Experience, Research & -Nikhil R. Meswani Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Global Business -(DIN: 00001620) company(ies)*^: Nil -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -Appointed: August 04, 1995 Nil − Leadership/ -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -34,38,688 equity shares − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 − Industry Experience, Research & -Development and Innovation -Hital R. Meswani Committee membership(s)/ -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Global Business -(DIN: 00001623) company(ies)*^: − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -1 – (as Chairman) Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -Appointed: August 21, 2009 − Network18 Media & Investments − Leadership/ -Operational experience -Shareholding*: Limited - Non-Executive Director -6,40,000 equity shares − TV18 Broadcast Limited - − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 5 Non-Executive Director − Industry Experience, Research & -Development and Innovation -P.M.S. Prasad Committee membership(s)/ -− Global Business -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other -(DIN: 00012144) company(ies)*^: 4 − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -* as on March 31, 2024 -** Promoter Director -# excluding Directorship(s) in foreign companies and Section 8 companies under the Companies Act, 2013. -^ In accordance with Regulation 26 of the Listing Regulations. -## ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as an Independent Director on March 31, 2024. -@ assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -Appointed: April 01, 2024 − Leadership/ -Operational experience -− Strategic Planning -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Haigreve Khaitan$ Risk Management -Independent Director − Corporate Governance -(DIN: 00005290) -$ appointed as an additional director, designated as an independent director of the Company w.e.f. April 1, 2024. -Notes: -a) Shri Mukesh D. Ambani is the father of Ms. Isha M. Ambani, Shri Akash M. Ambani and Shri Anant M. Ambani. -b) Shri Nikhil R. Meswani and Shri Hital R. Meswani are brothers and not related to Promoter Director. -c) None of the other Directors are related to any other Director on the Board. -The detailed profile of the Directors is available on the website of the Company. -The number of Directorship(s) and Committee Membership(s)/Chairmanship(s) of all Directors is/are within the respective limits prescribed under the -Companies Act, 2013 and the Listing Regulations. -66 Reliance Industries Limited - -Board Independence -In the opinion of the Board, the Independent Directors fulfill the conditions specified in the Listing Regulations and are -independent of the management. -Meeting of Independent Directors -The Company’s Independent Directors met 3 (Three) times in the FY 2023-24. Such meetings were conducted to enable -the Independent Directors to discuss matters pertaining to the Company’s affairs and put forth their views. -Board Meetings and Attendance -Number of Board meetings and Attendance of Directors -During the FY 2023-24, 7 (Seven) Board meetings were held as against the statutory requirement of four meetings. -The details of Board meetings and attendance of Directors at these meetings and at last Annual General Meeting (AGM) are -given below: -Board Meetings held on -Last AGM held -| Name of the Director | on August 28, | | | | | | | | | % Attendance | -| -------------------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------- | -| | | | April 21, | July 21, | August 28, | October | January | February | March 22, | of Director | -2023 -| | | | 2023 | 2023 | 2023 | 27, 2023 | 19, 2024 | 28, 2024 | 2024 | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -| Mukesh D. Ambani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Adil Zainulbhai@ | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | 85.71% | -| Raminder Singh Gujral | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Dr. Shumeet Banerji | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| Arundhati Bhattacharya | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -His Excellency Yasir Othman H. Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes 71.43% -Al Rumayyan -| K. V. Chowdary | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| ------------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | ------ | -| K. V. Kamath | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Nita M. Ambani* | | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | NA | 66.67% | -| Nikhil R. Meswani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Hital R. Meswani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| P. M. S. Prasad | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Pawan Kumar Kapil## | | NA | Yes | | NA NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | 100% | -| Isha M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Akash M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Anant M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| % Attendance | | 100% | 92.31% | 100% | 91.67% | 100% | 92.86% | 85.71% | 100% | | -@ ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as an Independent Director on March 31, 2024. -* ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of August 28, 2023. -** assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -## completed his 5-year term as a whole-time director of the Company, on May 15, 2023. Upon completion of his term, he also ceased to be a Director of -the Company. -Board Familiarisation and Induction Programme -Details of familiarisation programmes for the Independent Directors are available on the website of the Company and can -be accessed at https://www.ril.com/InvestorRelations/Downloads.aspx. -Board Compensation -The Company’s Remuneration Policy for Directors, Key Managerial Personnel and Other Employees is available on the -website of the Company and can be accessed at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/files/2023-01/Remuneration-Policy- -for-Directors.pdf -The Company’s remuneration policy is directed towards rewarding performance, based on review of achievements. -The remuneration policy is in consonance with existing industry practice. -| | | | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | | 67 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Remuneration of the Executive Directors for the Financial is in compliance with applicable laws, -regulations and guidelines. -Year 2023-24 -(C in crore) -Board Committees -Salary, Allowances Retiral Commission Stock -Name of the Director Total -and Perquisites Benefits payable Options The Board has constituted seven main -Committees, viz. Audit Committee, -Mukesh D. Ambani Nil -Human Resources, Nomination -Nikhil R. Meswani 7.59 0.44 17.28 25.31 - -and Remuneration Committee, -Hital R. Meswani 7.70 0.44 17.28 25.42 - -Stakeholders’ Relationship Committee, -P. M. S. Prasad 17.34# 0.59 - 17.93 - -Corporate Social Responsibility -Pawan Kumar Kapil* 0.45 0.02 - 0.47 - -and Governance Committee, -# includes performance linked incentives for the FY 2022-23 paid in the FY 2023-24 -* completed his 5-year term as a whole-time director of the Company, on May 15, 2023. Upon Risk Management Committee, -completion of his term, he also ceased to be a Director of the Company. Performance linked Environmental, Social and Governance -incentives of C 2.30 crore for FY 2022-23 paid in the FY 2023-24. -Committee and Finance Committee -The tenure of office of the Managing Director and Whole-time Directors is for 5 and is authorised to constitute other -(five) years from their respective date of appointment and can be terminated by functional Committees, from time -either party by giving three months’ notice in writing. They are also eligible for to time, depending on business -re-appointment. There is no separate provision for payment of severance fees. needs. The recommendations of -the Committees are submitted to -Remuneration of the Non-Executive Directors for the the Board for approval. During the -year, all the recommendations of -Financial Year 2023-24 -the Committees were accepted by -(C in crore) the Board. -Commission -Name of the Director Sitting Fee Total -payable Smt. Savithri Parekh, Company -Secretary and Compliance Officer of -Adil Zainulbhai 0.31 2.25 2.56 -the Company, is the Secretary to all the -Raminder Singh Gujral 0.30 2.25 2.55 -Committees constituted by the Board. -Dr. Shumeet Banerji 0.22 2.25 2.47 -Arundhati Bhattacharya 0.17 2.25 2.42 -Procedure at Committee -His Excellency Yasir Othman H. Al Rumayyan 0.05 2.25 2.30 -Meetings -K. V. Chowdary 0.41 2.25 2.66 -K. V. Kamath 0.10 2.25 2.35 The Company’s guidelines relating to -Nita M. Ambani* 0.02 0.92 0.94 the Board meetings are applicable -Isha M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 to the Committee meetings. The -composition and terms of reference of -Akash M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 -all the Committees are in compliance -Anant M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 -with the Companies Act, 2013 and -Total 1.70 19.58 21.28 -the Listing Regulations, as applicable. -* ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of August 28, 2023. -Each Committee has the authority to -** assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -engage outside experts, advisors and -During the year, there were no other pecuniary relationships or transactions of counsels to the extent it considers -Non-Executive Directors with the Company. The Company has not granted any appropriate to assist in its functioning. -stock options to its Non-Executive Directors. Minutes of the proceedings of -Committee meetings are circulated to -Directors and Officers Insurance the respective Committee members -and are also placed before the Board -In line with the requirements of Regulation 25(10) of the Listing Regulations, the -for its noting. -Company has in place a Directors and Officers Liability Insurance policy. -Audit Committee -Performance Evaluation Criteria for Directors -Composition -The Human Resources, Nomination and Remuneration Committee has devised -the criteria for evaluation of the performance of the Directors including the Sr. -Name of the Director Designation -No. -Independent Directors. The said criteria specifies certain parameters like -attendance, acquaintance with business, communication inter se between board 1 Raminder Singh Gujral Chairman -members, effective participation, domain knowledge, compliance with code of -2 Adil Zainulbhai Member -conduct, vision and strategy, benchmarks established by global peers etc., which -3 K. V. Chowdary Member -68 Reliance Industries Limited - -Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be a Director of the Company upon completion of The representatives of Statutory -his second term on March 31, 2024 and consequently ceased to be a member Auditors are permanent invitees to -of the Committee. Shri Haigreve Khaitan has been appointed as a member of the the Audit Committee meetings held -Committee w.e.f. April 1, 2024. quarterly, to approve financial results. -The representatives of Statutory -All the members of the Audit Committee possess requisite qualifications. -Auditors, Executives from Accounts -department, Finance department, -Brief Terms of Reference -Corporate Secretarial department and -Terms of Reference of the Committee, inter alia, include the following: -Internal Audit department attend the -− Recommend appointment, remuneration and terms of appointment of Audit Committee meetings. -auditors, including cost auditors, of the Company. -The Lead Cost Auditor attends the -− Approval of payment to statutory auditors, including cost auditors, for any Audit Committee meeting where cost -other services rendered by them. -audit report is discussed. -− Review with the management, the quarterly financial statements before -submission to the Board for approval. Human Resources, Nomination -− Review and monitor the auditor’s independence, performance and and Remuneration Committee -effectiveness of audit process. -Composition -− Approval or any subsequent modification of transactions with related parties -| of the Company. | | | | | Sr. | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ----------- | -| | | | | | Name of the Director | Designation | -No. -− Review the findings of any internal investigations by the internal auditors into -| | | | | | 1 Adil Zainulbhai | Chairman | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | -matters where there is suspected fraud or irregularity or a failure of internal -control systems of a material nature and reporting the matter to the Board. 2 Raminder Singh Gujral Member -− Review the functioning of the whistle-blower mechanism/oversee the 3 Dr. Shumeet Banerji Member -| vigil mechanism. | | | | | 4 K. V. Chowdary | Member | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | -− Review financial statements, in particular the investments made by the Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be -Company’s unlisted subsidiaries. -a Director of the Company upon -completion of his second term on -The detailed terms of reference of the Committee is available on the website of -March 31, 2024 and consequently -the Company. -ceased to be chairman and member of -the Committee. Dr. Shumeet Banerji -Meeting and Attendance -has been appointed as Chairman of the -14 (Fourteen) meetings of the Committee were held during the year, as against -Committee w.e.f. April 1, 2024. -the statutory requirement of four meetings. The details of the meetings and -attendance of members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: -Brief Terms of Reference -| | | Attended by | | % | Terms of Reference of the Committee | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Date of the Meeting Attendance at inter alia, include the following: -| | Raminder | Adil | K. V. | | | | -| --- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | Singh Gujral | Zainulbhai | Chowdary | Meeting | | | -− Formulate the criteria for -April 19, 2023 Yes Yes Yes 100% determining qualifications, positive -attributes and independence of -| April 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -a Director and recommend to -| May 23, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -the Board a policy, relating to the -| July 20, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -remuneration of the Directors, -| July 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -Key Managerial Personnel and -| August 18, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | other employees. | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -| October 11, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -− Formulate the criteria for evaluation -October 27, 2023 Yes Yes Yes 100% of performance of the Independent -| December 12, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | Directors and the Board | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------------------ | --- | -of Directors. -| January 12, 2024 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -January 19, 2024 Yes No Yes 66.67% − Devise a policy on Board Diversity. -February 28, 2024 Yes Yes Yes 100% − Identify persons who are qualified -March 12, 2024 Yes Yes Yes 100% to become Directors and who may -be appointed in senior management -| March 22, 2024 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| -------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| % Attendance | 100% | 92.86% | 100% | | | | -| | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | 69 | - -Corporate Governance Report -in accordance with the criteria laid down and to recommend to the Board Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be -their appointment and / or removal. a Director of the Company upon -− Specify the manner for effective evaluation of performance of Board, its completion of his second term on -March 31, 2024 and consequently -Committees and Individual Directors to be carried out either by the Board, -ceased to be chairman and member of -by the Human Resources, Nomination and Remuneration Committee or by an -independent external agency and review its implementation and compliance. the Committee. Shri Raminder Singh -Gujral has been appointed as member -− Recommend to the Board, all remuneration, in whatever form, payable to -and chairman of the Committee w.e.f. -senior management. -April 1, 2024. -− Review Human Resource policies and overall human resources of -the Company. -Brief Terms of Reference -The detailed terms of reference of the Committee is available on the website of Terms of Reference of the Committee, -| the Company. | | | | | | | inter alia, include the following: | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -− Frame Risk Management Plan -Meeting and Attendance -and Policy. -6 (Six) meetings of the Committee were held during the year as against statutory -− Oversee implementation/ -requirement of one meeting. The details of the meetings and attendance of -Monitoring of Risk Management -members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: Plan and Policy. -− Periodically review and evaluate -Attended by -| | | | | | % A | t t e n d a n | ce | | | | -| ------------------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Date of the Meeting | | | | | | | the Risk Management Policy | | | | -| | Adil | Raminder | Dr. Shumeet | | K. V. | a t   M e e t in | g | | | | -Zainulbhai Singh Gujral Banerji Chowdary and Practices with respect -to risk assessment and risk -| April 20, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -management processes. -| June 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | No | Yes | 75% | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -− Review of cyber security and -| July 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -related risks. -| August 28, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -October 18, 2023 Yes Yes Yes Yes 100% The detailed terms of reference of the -Committee is available on the website -| January 18, 2024 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| % Attendance | 100% | 100% | 83.33% | | 100% | | of the Company. | | | | -Risk Management Committee -Composition -| Sr. No. Name of the Member | | | | | Designation | | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1 Adil Zainulbhai | | | | | Chairman | | | | | | -| 2 Dr. Shumeet Banerji | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 3 K. V. Chowdary | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 4 Hital R. Meswani | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 5 P. M. S. Prasad | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 6 Srikanth Venkatachari | | | | | Member | | | | | | -Shri Alok Agarwal ceased to be a member of the Committee. -Meeting and Attendance -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee were held during the year as against statutory requirement of two meetings. The -details of the meetings and attendance of members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: -Attended by -% -| Date of Meeting | | | | | | | | | | Attendance | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --------- | ----------- | -| | | Adil Dr. Shumeet | | K. V. | Hital R. | | P. M. S. | Alok | Srikanth | | -Zainulbhai Banerji Chowdary Meswani Prasad Agarwal Venkatachari at Meeting -| May 19, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| ----------------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | -| July 18, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| August 10, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| November 28, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 85.71% | -| % Attendance | | 100% | 100% | 100% | 100% | | 100% | 50% | 75% | | -70 Reliance Industries Limited - -| Corporate Social | | | | No. of Terms of Reference | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -Type of Complaints -Complaints -| Responsibility & Governance | | | | The terms of reference of the | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | -Committee is available on the website -| Committee | | Non-Receipt of Annual Reports | | 726 | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | Non-Receipt of Dividend | | 286 of the Company. | | -Composition -| | | Non-Receipt of Interest/ | | 3 | | -| -------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -| Sr. | | | | Meeting and Attendance | | -| Name of the Director | Designation | | | | | -| No. | | Redemption payments | | | | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee -| | | Transfer of securities | | 919 | | -| --------------------- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1 Dr. Shumeet Banerji | Chairman | | | | | -were held during the year. These -| | | Rights Issue related | | 12 | | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -2 K. V. Chowdary Member meetings were held on April 18, 2023; -| | | Total | | 1,946 | | -| ------------------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | -| 3 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | | | July 18, 2023; November 16, 2023 | | -and March 19, 2024. -As on March 31, 2024, no complaints -Terms of Reference -were outstanding. -| The terms of reference of the | | | | Finance Committee | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -The response time for attending to -| Committee is available on the website | | | | Composition | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -investors’ correspondence during the -of the Company. -financial year 2023-24 is as under: -Sr. -Name of the Director Designation -| Meeting and Attendance | | | | No. | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | --- | -| | | Particulars | Number | % | | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee -| | | Total number of | 445,443 | 100.00 1 Mukesh D. Ambani | Chairman | -| --- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | -------- | -were held during the year. These -| | | | | 2 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | ------ | -correspondences -meetings were held on April 19, 2023; -| | | received during the | | 3 Hital R. Meswani | Member | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------------ | ------ | -July 19, 2023; October 18, 2023 and -FY 2023-24 -January 18, 2024. -| | | Replied within 1 to 4 | 444,404 | 99.77 Terms of Reference | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -| | | days of receipt | | The terms of reference of the | | -Stakeholders’ Relationship -Committee is available on the website -| | | Replied after 4 days | 1,039 | 0.23 | | -| --- | --- | --------------------- | ----- | ---- | --- | -Committee -| | | of receipt but within | | of the Company. | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| Composition | | prescribed timelines | | | | -Meeting Details -Sr. -| Name of the Director | Designation | | | | | -| -------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -| No. | | | | 4 (Four) meetings of the Committee | | -Compliance Officer -| 1 K. V. Chowdary | Chairman | | | were held during the year. These | | -| ---------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Smt. Savithri Parekh, Company -meetings were held on May 24, 2023; -| 2 Arundhati | Member | Secretary and Compliance Officer, | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -November 3, 2023; November 9, -| Bhattacharya | | is the Compliance Officer of | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -2023 and March 13, 2024. -| 3 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | the Company. | | | | -| ------------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| 4 Hital R. Meswani | Member | | | Succession Planning | | -Environmental, Social and -The Company believes that sound -Brief Terms of Reference -Governance Committee -succession plan for the senior -The terms of reference of the -leadership is very important for -Composition -Committee is available on the website creating a robust future for the -| of the Company. | | Sr. | | | | -| --------------- | --- | -------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -| | | Name of the Director | Designation | Company. The Human Resources, | | -No. -Nomination and Remuneration -Meeting and Attendance -| | | 1 Hital R. Meswani | Chairman | Committee works along with the | | -| --- | --- | ------------------ | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee 2 Arundhati Bhattacharya Member Human Resource team of the -were held during the year as against Company for a structured leadership -| | | 3 P. M. S. Prasad | Member | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -| statutory requirement of one meeting. | | | | succession plan. | | -| These meetings were held on April | | Shri Pawan Kumar Kapil completed | | | | -his 5-year term as a whole-time -19, 2023; July 18, 2023; October 17, -director of the Company, on May 15, -2023 and January 12, 2024. -2023. Upon completion of his term, -he ceased to be a Director and -Investor Grievance Redressal -member of the Environmental, Social -The number of complaints received -and Governance Committee of the -| and resolved to the satisfaction of | | Company. He attended the meeting of | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -investors during the financial year -the Committee held on April 18, 2023. -2023-24 (with an investor base of -~34.63 lakh) and their break-up are -as under: -| | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | 71 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Senior Management -Particulars of senior management: -| Name of Senior | | Name of Senior | | -| --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| Sr. | | Sr. | | -Management Personnel Designation Management Personnel Designation -| No | | No | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| (“SMP”) | | (“SMP”) | | -1 Shri Srikanth VenkatachariChief Financial Officer 6 Shri Srinivas Tuttagunta COO Supply & Trading -2 Shri Harish Shah President - Corporate Planning & 7 Shri Avinash Kumar VermaPresident Operations – Petchem -| | Strategy | 8 Shri B Narayan | Chief Procurement Officer | -| --------------------- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------- | -| 3 Shri L. V. Merchant | Group Controller | | | -| | | 9 Shri Ashwani Prashara | CHRO Hydrocarbons Operations | -4 Smt. Savithri Parekh Company Secretary and 10 Shri Mahesh Marve Head of Technology -Compliance Officer -| | | 11 Shri Durga Dube | Executive Vice President and Head | -| ------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------------------------------- | -| 5 Shri Sanjiv Singh | Group President - Oil to Chemicals | | | -- Cyber Security and Information -Risk Management -During the financial year, Shri Alok Agarwal ceased to be a senior management personnel -Framework for Monitoring Subsidiary Companies -The details of material subsidiaries, during the financial year 2023-24, are given below: -| | Place of | | Date of Appointment of | -| ---- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ----------------------- | -| Name | Date of Incorporation | Name of Statutory Auditors | | -| | Incorporation | | Statutory Auditors | -Jio Platforms Limited November 15, 2019 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP/ December 21, 2020 -Chaturvedi & Shah LLP -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited February 15, 2007 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP/ September 26, 2019/ -| | | DTS & Associates LLP | September 28, 2020 | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------ | -Reliance Retail Limited June 29, 1999 India DTS & Associates LLP September 30, 2022 -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited December 13, 2006 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP September 24, 2020 -Reliance Global Energy Services August 12, 2008 Singapore Deloitte and Touche LLP, September 26, 2023 -| (Singapore) Pte. Limited | | Singapore | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -Reliance International Limited June 16, 2021 Abu Dhabi PKF Accountants & Business December 18, 2023 -Advisers LLP -The composition and effectiveness of Boards of subsidiaries is reviewed by the Company periodically. A robust compliance -management system covering all the subsidiaries is also in place. -The Company is in compliance with the provisions governing material subsidiaries. Copy of the Secretarial Audit Reports -of Jio Platforms Limited, Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -forms part of this report. The Secretarial Audit Report of these material subsidiaries does not contain any qualification, -reservation, adverse remark or disclaimer. -The Company’s Policy for determining Material Subsidiaries is available on the website of the Company and can be accessed -at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/files/2023-01/Material-Subsidiaries.pdf. -72 Reliance Industries Limited - -General Body Meetings − Approval of Material Related Party -Transactions of the Company; and -Annual General Meetings -− Approval of Material Related Party -The date, time and venue of the Annual General Meetings held during preceding -Transactions of Subsidiaries of -three years and the special resolution(s) passed thereat, are as follows: -the Company. -Date and Time Special Resolution(s) Passed Venue The same shall be passed in compliance -August 28, 2023 1. R e-appointment of Shri Mukesh D. Ambani as Held through with the provisions of the Companies -02:00 p.m. Managing Director video Act, 2013 and the Listing Regulations. -2. R e-appointment of Smt. Arundhati Bhattacharya conference/ -as an Independent Director other audio- Means of Communication -3. Alteration of Articles of Association of the Company visual means -Quarterly results: The Company’s -4. A lteration of Objects Clause of the Memorandum (Deemed venue -quarterly/half-yearly/annual financial -of Association of the Company - 3rd Floor, Maker -results are sent to the Stock Exchanges -August 29, 2022 1. A ppointment of Shri K. V. Chowdary as an Chambers IV, -and published in ‘Indian Express’, -02:00 p.m. Independent Director 222, Nariman -‘Financial Express’ and ‘Loksatta’. They -2. A lteration of Objects Clause of the Memorandum Point, Mumbai – -are also available on the website of -of Association of the Company 400 021) -the Company. -June 24, 2021 1. R e-appointment of Dr. Shumeet Banerji as an -02:00 p.m. Independent Director News releases, presentations: -Official news releases and official -Tribunal Convened Meeting Procedure adopted for Postal -media releases are generally sent to -In accordance with the order dated Ballot Stock Exchanges and are also available -March 27, 2023 passed by the The Postal Ballot was carried out as on the website of the Company. -Hon’ble National Company Law per the provisions of Sections 108 and -Presentations to institutional -Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, the Company 110 and other applicable provisions of investors/analysts: Detailed -convened meetings of its Equity the Companies Act, 2013, read with presentations are made to institutional -Shareholders, Secured Creditors the rules framed thereunder, and MCA investors and financial analysts on the -and Unsecured Creditors on May 2, Circulars. Shri Anil Lohia, a Practising Company’s quarterly, half-yearly as -2023, to consider and approve, the Chartered Accountant, (Membership well as annual financial results and are -Scheme of Arrangement between No.: 031626), Partner, Dayal and sent to the Stock Exchanges. These -Reliance Industries Limited and its Lohia, Chartered Accountants acted as presentations, video recordings and -shareholders and creditors & Reliance Scrutiniser for conducting the Postal transcript of the meetings are available -Strategic Investments Limited and its Ballot in a fair and transparent manner. on the website of the Company. -shareholders and creditors. The Scrutiniser submitted his report -on October 27, 2023 after completion Website: The Company’s website -Members and Creditors exercised their -of scrutiny. Voting results are available (www.ril.com) contains a separate -vote(s) by remote e-voting and e-voting -on the website of the Stock Exchanges dedicated section ‘Investor Relations’ -at the meeting. -and the Company. where shareholders’ information -Voting results of the meetings are is available. -It is proposed to obtain approval of -available on the website of the Stock -members of the Company, through Chairman’s Communiqué: A copy -Exchanges and the Company. -Postal Ballot, by way of remote of the Chairman’s speech is sent to -e-voting process for: all the shareholders, whose e-mail -Resolution(s) passed through -addresses are registered with the -Postal Ballot − Appointment of Shri Haigreve Company/Depository Participants. -Khaitan (DIN: 00005290) as The document is also available on the -During the year, ordinary resolutions -an Independent Director of website of the Company. -for appointment of Ms. Isha M. -the Company; -Ambani, Shri Akash M. Ambani -Letters/e-mails/SMS to Investors: -and Shri Anant M. Ambani as Non- − Re-appointment of His Excellency Apart from sending Annual Report, -Executive Directors of the Company, Yasir Othman H. Al Rumayyan (DIN: the Company has also addressed -were passed by members of the 09245977) as an Independent various investor-centric letters/e- -Company on October 26, 2023 Director of the Company; mails/SMS to its shareholders during -through postal ballot. The resolutions − Re-appointment of Shri P.M.S. the year. This include reminders for -were passed with more than Prasad (DIN: 00012144) as a claiming unclaimed/unpaid dividend -requisite majority. Whole-time Director designated as from the Company; claiming shares -an Executive Director; lying in unclaimed suspense account -with the Company; dematerialisation -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 73 - -Corporate Governance Report -of shares, updating e-mail address, to all the shareholders who have June 30, 2024 - Third week of -PAN, bank account details and furnished bank account details to the July, 2024; -Nomination details. The Company Company/its Registrar and Transfer September 30, 2024 - Fourth week of -has sent Quarterly and Annual Agent/Depository Participant, October, 2024; -financial results of the Company filed as applicable. December 31, 2024 - Third week of -| with the Stock Exchanges to all the | | January, 2025; and | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | -shareholders, whose e-mail addresses March 31, 2025 - Fourth week of -Financial Year -| are registered with the Company/ | | April, 2025. | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -April 1 to March 31 -Depository Participants. -Annual General Meeting – July/ -In accordance with the SEBI Circulars the Financial Calendar August -Company has sent letters, emails and -(Tentative) Results for the -SMS, to its shareholders intimating them -quarter ending -to furnish valid PAN, Nomination, Contact -details, Mobile Number, Specimen -Listing on Stock Exchanges -Signature, Bank Account details updated, -for receiving dividend electronically with   Name of the stock exchanges   Address -effect from April 01, 2024. Equity Shares − BSE Limited (BSE) − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal -| | ISIN: | Scrip Code – 500325 | Street, Mumbai – 400 001 | -| --- | ------ | ------------------- | ------------------------ | -Chatbot: State of the art Chatbot -| | INE002A01018 | − National Stock Exchange of | − Exchange Plaza, C-1, G Block, | -| --- | ------------ | ----------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -application providing shareholders -| | | India Limited (NSE) | Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra | -| --- | --- | --------------------- | ----------------------------- | -instant automated annual general -| | | Trading Symbol – RELIANCE | (East), Mumbai – 400 051 | -| --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------------------ | -meeting related query resolution -| | Global Depository − Luxembourg Stock Exchange | | − 35A Boulevard Joseph II, | -| ------------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | -| was deployed. | Receipts (GDRs) | | L-1840, Luxembourg | -SEBI Complaints Redress System Overseas − The Bank of New York − 101, Barclay Street New York, -| | Depository | Mellon Corporation | NY 10286 | -| --- | ---------- | ------------------ | -------- | -(SCORES): Investor complaints are -− Empire Complex, 1st Floor, 414, -| processed at Securities and Exchange | Domestic | − ICICI Bank Limited | | -| ------------------------------------- | --------- | -------------------- | --- | -Board of India (“SEBI”) in a centralised Custodian Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel -(West), Mumbai – 400 013 -web-based complaints redress system. -The salient features of this system are Debentures − BSE Limited (BSE) − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal -Street, Mumbai – 400 001 -centralised database of all complaints, -online upload of Action Taken Reports − National Stock Exchange of − Exchange Plaza, C-1, G Block, -by concerned companies and online India Limited (NSE) Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra -(East), Mumbai – 400 051 -viewing by investors of actions taken on -the complaints and their current status. Bonds − Singapore Exchange Limited − 4 Shenton Way, #02-01 SGX -Centre 2, Singapore 068807 -Shareholders’ Feedback Survey: -| | | − Luxembourg Stock Exchange | − 35A Boulevard Joseph II, | -| --- | --- | --------------------------- | --------------------------- | -The Company takes feedback from -L-1840, Luxembourg -shareholders on various matters − India International Exchange − 1st Floor, Unit No. 101, The -relating to investor services and Annual -| | | (IFSC) Limited (India Inx) | Signature Building No. 13B, Road | -| --- | --- | -------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -Report for improvement in future. -1C, Zone 1, GIFT SEZ, GIFT CITY, -Gandhinagar – 382 355 -General Shareholder -| | Commercial | − BSE Limited | − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal | -| ----------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------------------------------- | -| Information | Papers | | Street, Mumbai – 400 001 | -Annual General Meeting Payment of Listing Fees the Statutory Auditors are a part, -during the year ended March 31, -| August 29, 2024 at 02.00 P.M. | Annual listing fees for the FY 2024-25 | | | -| ------------------------------ | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -2024, is C 78.65 crore. -| IST through Video Conferencing/ | has been paid by the Company to BSE | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | -| Other Audio Visual Means as set out | Limited and National Stock Exchange | | | -Credit Rating -| in the Notice convening the Annual | of India Limited. | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -General Meeting. Deemed venue The Company’s financial discipline -of the meeting is 3rd Floor, Maker and prudence is reflected in the -Fees Paid to the Statutory -Chambers IV, 222, Nariman Point, strong credit ratings ascribed by rating -Auditors -| Mumbai – 400 021. | | agencies. There has been no revision in | | -| ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Total fees, for all services, paid by -credit ratings during the FY 2023-24. -the Company and its subsidiaries, -| Dividend Payment Date | | The details of the Credit Rating are | | -| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -| | on a consolidated basis, to Statutory | mentioned in Management Discussion | | -| Between August 29, 2024 and | Auditors of the Company and other | | | -and Analysis Report. -September 04, 2024 electronically -firms in the network entity of which -74 Reliance Industries Limited - -Debenture Trustee -Axis Trustee Services Limited -The Ruby, 2nd Floor, SW, 29, Senapati Bapat Marg, Dadar (West), Mumbai – 400 028 -Tel: +91-22-62300451, Fax: +91-22-62300700 -E-mail: debenturetrustee@axistrustee.in; complaints@axistrustee.in, Website Address: www.axistrustee.in -Stock Market Price Data -| | | National Stock Exchange of India Limited (NSE) | | | | | BSE Limited (BSE) | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -Month -| | | High Price (K) | Low Price (K) | | High Price (K) | | Low Price (K) | | -| --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | -| | | | | Volume (No.) | | | | Volume (No.) | -April 2023 2,424.95 2,308.55 9,68,40,090 2,424.00 2,308.50 29,79,991 -May 2023 2,537.70 2,413.05 10,08,69,573 2,537.45 2,413.35 28,44,256 -June 2023 2,584.00 2,451.00 10,32,48,415 2,584.00 2,451.05 36,47,741 -July 2023 2,856.00 2,469.30 19,84,24,710 2,855.00 2,469.55 89,78,788 -August 2023 2,582.80 2,399.90 14,92,37,543 2,582.15 2,400.00 78,91,449 -September 2023 2,483.00 2,325.00 15,85,16,918 2,489.70 2,325.65 73,58,764 -October 2023 2,367.00 2,220.30 10,28,36,679 2,367.15 2,221.05 76,82,544 -November 2023 2,411.95 2,275.20 10,35,67,402 2,411.75 2,275.25 1,01,68,137 -December 2023 2,614.00 2,377.60 12,77,31,315 2,614.80 2,380.00 2,17,58,563 -January 2024 2,919.95 2,568.95 13,29,79,070 2,917.95 2,568.30 77,53,399 -February 2024 2,999.90 2,836.10 11,94,05,281 2,999.85 2,836.70 50,51,876 -March 2024 3,024.90 2,825.80 11,30,97,499 3,024.80 2,826.90 50,44,754 -[Source: This information is compiled from the data available on the websites of BSE and NSE] -Share Price Performance in comparison to broad based indices – BSE Sensex and NSE Nifty as on -March 31, 2024 -| | | | | RIL Share Sensex Performance | | | RIL Share | NIFTY | -| ---------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ----------------------------- | ------- | ------------------ | ---------- | ----------- | -| | | | Performance on BSE | | | Performance on NSE | | Performance | -| FY 2023-24 | | | | 27.70% | 24.85% | | 27.48% | 28.61% | -| 2 Years | | | | 13.02% | 25.75% | | 12.79% | 27.84% | -| 3 Years | | | | 48.60% | 48.76% | | 48.36% | 51.98% | -| 5 Years | | | | 118.39% | 90.45% | | 117.99% | 92.08% | -| 10 Years | | | | 540.52% | 229.00% | | 538.56% | 233.03% | -RIL’s share price on BSE and NSE has been adjusted for the FY 2017-18 and earlier years, on account of issue of bonus -shares in the FY 2017-18. -BSE Sensex vs RIL Share Price NSE Nifty vs RIL Share Price -| 75000 | | | 3,000 | 23000 | | | | 3,000 | -| ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -| 73000 | | | | 22000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,800 | | | | | 2,800 | -| 71000 | | | | 21000 | | | | | -| 69000 | | | 2,600 | 20000 | | | | 2,600 | -| 67000 | | | | 19000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,400 | | | | | 2,400 | -| 65000 | | | | 18000 | | | | | -| 63000 | | | 2,200 | 17000 | | | | 2,200 | -| 61000 | | | | 16000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,000 | | | | | 2,000 | -| 59000 | | | | 15000 | | | | | -| 57000 | | | 1,800 | 14000 | | | | 1,800 | -32-rpA 32-yaM 32-nuJ 32-luJ 32-guA 32-peS 32-tcO 32-voN 32-ceD 42-naJ 42-beF 42-raM 32-rpA 32-yaM 32-nuJ 32-luJ 32-guA 32-peS 32-tcO 32-voN 32-ceD 42-naJ 42-beF 42-raM -| | BSE Sensex | RIL | | | NSE Nifty | | RIL | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | 75 | - -Corporate Governance Report -Registrar and Transfer Agent Share Transfer System the year, all certificates/Letters of -confirmation for transfer (pursuant to -| KFin Technologies Limited | | As mandated by SEBI, securities of | | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Selenium Tower B, Plot 31-32, the Company can be transferred/ Court order received from Custodian -Government of India Account, -| Gachibowli, Financial District, | | traded only in dematerialised form. | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -The Special Court (Torts) Act, -| Nanakramguda, Hyderabad – 500 032 | | Shareholders holding shares in physical | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toll Free No.: 1800 309 4001 (From form are advised to avail the facility 1992), transmission, transposition, -sub-division, consolidation, renewal, -| 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on all working | | of dematerialisation. | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| days) | | | | | exchange and change/deletion of | | | | -The Company has received a -names of shareholders, were issued -E-mail: rilinvestor@kfintech.com, -| | | certificate from a Company Secretary | | | as required under Regulation 40(9) | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Website: www.kfintech.com -in Practice, certifying that during -of the Listing Regulations. The said -certificate was duly filed with the -Stock Exchanges. -Shareholding Pattern as on March 31, 2024 -Total Number -| | | | Total Number | Total Number of | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Sr. Category of Shareholder Number of of Shares (Fully Shares (Partly of Shares (Fully % of Total Number -| No. | | Shareholders | | | | Paid-up & Partly | of Shares (A+B+C) | | -| --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ----------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | | | Paid-up) | | Paid-up) | | | | -Paid-up) -(A) Promoter and Promoter Group -| (1) Indian | | | 47* 3,32,27,48,048 | | - | 3,32,27,48,048 | | 49.11% | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -| (2) Foreign | | | - | - | - | | - | - | -Total Shareholding of Promoter 47* 3,32,27,48,048 - 3,32,27,48,048 49.11% -and Promoter Group -(B) Public Shareholding -(1) Institutions 2,298 2,58,55,09,468 - 2,58,55,09,468 38.21% -(2) Central Government/State 75 76,87,594 - 76,87,594 0.12 % -Government(s)/President of India -(3) Non-institutions 34,60,855 68,79,29,270 4,17,418 68,83,46,688 10.17% -Total Public Shareholding 34,63,228 3,28,11,26,332 4,17,418 3,28,15,43,750 48.50 % -(C) Non-Promoter -Non-Public -(1) Shares held by Custodian(s) against 1 16,18,17,216 - 16,18,17,216 2.39% -which Depository Receipts have -been issued -Total shares held by Non-Promoter 1 16,18,17,216 - 16,18,17,216 2.39% -Non-Public -Total (A) + (B) + (C) 34,63,276 6,76,56,91,596 4,17,418 6,76,61,09,014 100% -* As per information furnished by the Promoter and Promoter Group, there are 52 members forming part of Promoter and Promoter Group of the -Company, of which 5 promoter group entities do not hold any shares. -Dematerialisation of Shares issue of fully paid-up equity shares is Relevant data for the average daily -| | | available on the website of the Company | | | turnover of equity shares for the | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Mode of Holding % of Total Shares and can be accessed at https://www.ril. FY 2023-24 is given below: -com/sites/default/files/2024-07/Build- -| NSDL | 96.00 | | | | Particulars | | BSE NSE | Total | -| ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -up-of-Equity-Share-Capital.pdf -| CDSL | 3.37 | | | | Shares | 3,70,570 | 61,25,018 | 64,95,588 | -| ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | -(Nos.) -| Physical | 0.63 | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liquidity -| | | | | | Value | 93.57 | 1,568.69 | 1,662.26 | -| ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | -------- | -| Total | 100.00 | | | | (C in crore) | | | | -The Company’s equity shares are -among the most liquid and actively -Build-up of Equity Share Capital, [Source: This information is compiled from the -| | | traded shares on the Indian Stock | | | data available on the websites of BSE and NSE] | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -category-wise shareholding, -Exchanges. RIL shares consistently rank -Dividend declared for the last 10 among the top few frequently traded Outstanding Global -years, Bonus Issue of fully paid- shares both in terms of the number of Depository Receipts (GDRs)/ -shares traded as well as value. -| up equity shares | | | | | Warrants and Convertible | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -The statement showing build-up of Bonds, Conversion Date and -| equity share capital, category-wise | | | | | Likely Impact on Equity | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -shareholding, dividend declared by the -GDRs: Outstanding GDRs as -Company in the last 10 years, bonus -on March 31, 2024 represent -76 Reliance Industries Limited - -16,18,17,216 equity shares Risk Management Policy with offer financial instruments -| constituting 2.39% of Company’s | | | | (derivatives), that enable | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -Respect to Commodities -| paid-up equity share capital. Each | | | | managing the Price risk. | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -Including Through Hedging -GDR represents two underlying equity - Strategic decisions regarding -shares in the Company. GDR is not a -• Commodities Exposure -the timing and the usage of -| specific time-bound instrument and | The Company is exposed to price | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -derivatives instruments such as -can be surrendered at any time and -| | volatility on various Petroleum, | | | Swaps/Futures/Options are taken | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| converted into the underlying equity | Petrochemical and other Energy | | | | | | -based on various factors including -shares in the Company. The shares -| | related commodities, as part of its | | | market conditions, physical | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | -so released in favour of the investors -business operations. Due to the -inventories, macro-economic -| upon surrender of GDRs can either be | dynamic markets, prices of such | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -situation. These decisions and -held by investors concerned in their -| | Commodities fluctuate and can | | | execution are done in line with | | | -| ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| name or sold in the Indian secondary | result in Margin Risk. This policy | | | | | | -the Board approved Commodities -markets for cash. To the extent of -| | prescribes the guidelines for | | | Risk Management Framework. | | | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -shares so sold in Indian markets, -hedging Commodities Price risks. -The Risk Management Committee -GDRs can be reissued under the -has oversight on all hedging -| available headroom. | • Hedging Policy | | | | | | -| ------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -actions taken. - Exposures are identified and -There are no outstanding warrants or -| | measured across the Company | | | More details on Risk Management | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | -convertible bonds having any impact -| | so that appropriate hedging | | | are covered under the Enterprise | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | -on equity. -| | can be done on a net basis. For | | | Risk Management section of the | | | -| --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | commodities hedging, there | | | Management Discussion and | | | -RIL GDR Programme -| | exist Over The Counter (OTC) | | | Analysis Report. | | | -| -------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| The Global Depository Receipts of the | and exchange markets that | | | | | | -Company are listed on Luxembourg -Stock Exchange and are traded on -Exposure of the Company to commodity risks, which are -the International Order Book (London -material is as under: -Stock Exchange) and amongst qualified -institutional investors on the over-the- -counter market in the United States Exposure % of such exposure hedged through -| | | | in quantity | commodity derivatives | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --------------------- | -------------------- | --- | -| of America. | | Exposure | terms | | | | -| | | | | Domestic market | International market | | -| | | towards | towards | | | | -RIL GDRs are exempted securities -| | Commodity | the | the | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Name | particular | particular | | | | -under US Securities Law. RIL GDR -| | | commodity | commodity | | | Total | -| --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | -programme has been established (in K crore) OTC Exchange OTC Exchange* -(in 1000 -Metric -under Rule 144A and Regulation S of -tonnes) -the US Securities Act, 1933. Reporting -is done under the exempted route of -| | Crude | 3,22,745 | 71,424 | - | - 0.18% 12.50% | 12.68% | -| --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | ------ | -Rule 12g3-2(b) under the US Securities Middle 1,99,956 30,523 - - 2.49% 17.50% 19.99% -Exchange Act, 1934. -Distillates -| | Light | 1,07,146 | 16,173 | - | - 0.00% 9.15% | 9.15% | -| --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | --- | ------------- | ----- | -Commodity Price Risks/ -Distillates -Foreign Exchange Risk and -| | Polymer | 54,294 | 5,694 | - | - - | - - | -| --- | ------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -Hedging Activities -| | Petchem | 42,779 | 5,162 | - | - 0.00% 0.00% | 0.00% | -| ---------------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | ----- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -| The Company has in place a robust | Intermediate | | | | | | -risk management framework for -| | Polyester | 24,859 | 2,393 | - | - - | - - | -| --- | --------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -identification and monitoring and -| | Total | 7,51,779 | 1,31,369 | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -mitigation of commodity price and -*Includes OTC transactions cleared through International Exchanges. -foreign exchange risks. The risks are -tracked and monitored on a regular -basis and mitigation strategies -are adopted in line with the risk -management framework. For further -details on the above risks, please -refer the Enterprise Risk Management -section of the Management Discussion -and Analysis Report. -| | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | 77 | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Plant Locations in India The procedure for claiming underlying -shares and unpaid/unclaimed dividend -| Oil to Chemicals | DTA Jamnagar Refinery | Jamnagar, Gujarat | | | | | -| ---------------- | --------------------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | SEZ Jamnagar Refinery | | | from IEPF Authority is covered in the | | | -Hazira Manufacturing Division Surat, Gujarat Shareholders’ Referencer available on -Dahej Manufacturing Division Bharuch, Gujarat the website of the Company. -| | Vadodara Manufacturing Division | Vadodara, Gujarat | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Patalganga Manufacturing Division Raigad, Maharashtra Further, in accordance with the IEPF -Rules, the Board of Directors have -Nagothane Manufacturing Division -Silvassa Manufacturing Division Union Territory of Dadra and Nagar appointed Smt. Savithri Parekh as -| | | Haveli and Daman and Diu | | Nodal Officer of the Company and | | | -| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | Barabanki Manufacturing Division | Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh | | | | | -Shri Vivin Mally as Deputy Nodal -| | Hoshiarpur Manufacturing Division | Hoshiarpur, Punjab | | | | | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Officer of the Company for the -| Oil & Gas | KG-D6 | East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -purposes of verification of claims of -| | Coal Based Methane | Shahdol, Madhya Pradesh | | | | | -| --- | ------------------ | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Composites Vadodara Composites Division Vadodara, Gujarat shareholders pertaining to shares -Textiles Naroda Manufacturing Division Ahmedabad, Gujarat transferred to IEPF and/or refund -of dividend from IEPF Authority and -for coordination with IEPF Authority. -b) transferred 9,71,654 equity -Address for Correspondence The details of the Nodal Officer and -shares of C 10/- each, to the credit -For shares held in physical form Deputy Nodal Officer are available on -of IEPF Authority. -the website of the Company. -KFin Technologies Limited -| Selenium Tower B, Plot 31-32, | | The Company has uploaded on its | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | website, the details of unpaid and | | Unclaimed amounts relating | | | -Gachibowli Financial District, -unclaimed amounts lying with the -Nanakramguda, Hyderabad – 500 032 to interest and/or redemption -| Toll Free No.: 1800 309 4001 (From | | Company as on March 31, 2024. | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -proceeds of debentures issued -| 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on all working | | Details of shares transferred to IEPF | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -by the Company -days) -Authority during FY 2023-24 are -E-mail: rilinvestor@kfintech.com, also available on the website of the During the FY 2023-24, no claims -| Website: www.kfintech.com | | | | were received by the Company from | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Company. The Company has also -the debenture holders with respect to -uploaded these details on the website -For shares held in demat form -| | | of the IEPF Authority (www.iepf.gov.in). | | any amounts. No unclaimed amounts | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Depository Participant(s) of the relating to interest and/or redemption -| investor concerned and/or | | The voting rights on the shares | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -proceeds of debentures is lying -| KFin Technologies Limited. | | transferred to IEPF Authority shall | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -with the Company as on the date of -| | | remain frozen till the rightful owner | | this report. | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| Any Query on the Annual Report | | claims the shares. | | | | | -| Smt. Savithri Parekh | | | | Equity Shares in the Unclaimed | | | -Last date to claim unclaimed/unpaid -Company Secretary and dividends before transfer to IEPF, Suspense Account -Compliance Officer -| | | for the financial year 2016-17 and | | In terms of Regulation 39 of the Listing | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Reliance Industries Limited -thereafter, are as under: -Regulations, details of the equity -3rd Floor, Maker Chambers IV, 222, -shares lying in the Unclaimed Suspense -| Nariman Point, | | | Date to claim | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | Financial Declaration | | Account are as follows: | | | -| | | Year Date | before transfer | | | | -| Mumbai – 400 021 | | | to IEPF | | | | -No. of -| E-mail: investor.relations@ril.com; | | | | | | No. of | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | -------------- | ----------------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | 2016-17 July 21, | August 26, | | Shareholders | | -| rilagm@ril.com | | | | Particulars | | Equity | -| | | | | | (Phase-wise | Shares | -| | | 2017 | 2024 | | Transfers) | | -| Transfer of Unpaid/Unclaimed | | 2017-18 July 5, | August 4, 2025 | | | | -| | | | | Aggregate number | 61,371 | 57,88,946 | -2018 -| Amounts of dividend and | | | | of shareholders | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | 2018-19 August 12, | September 11, | | | | -and the -Shares to Investor Education -| | | 2019 | 2026 | outstanding shares | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -and Protection Fund 2019-20 July 15, August 14, in the Unclaimed -| | | 2020 | 2027 | Suspense Account | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -In accordance with the provisions of 2020-21 June 24, July 26, 2028 lying as on April 1, -| the Companies Act, 2013, during the | | | | 2023 | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -2021 -| year, the Company has: | | | | Less: Number | 2,002 | 2,78,370 | -| ---------------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | 2021-22 August 29, | September 30, | | | | -of shareholders -| | | 2022 | 2029 | who approached | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --- | -a) credited C 29.60 crore to Investor -| | | 2022-23 August 28, | September 27, | the Company for | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -Education and Protection Fund -transfer of shares -2023 2030 -(IEPF); -78 Reliance Industries Limited - -No. of with Related Party Transactions. The dated September 20, 2021, -No. of -Shareholders -Particulars Equity Company has made full disclosure of disposed off the show cause -(Phase-wise -Transfers) Shares transactions with the related parties notice without levy of any penalty. -as set out in Note 34 of Standalone -Add: Number - - (ii) O n December 16, 2010, SEBI -of shareholders Financial Statement, forming part of -issued a show cause notice (SCN), -and aggregate the Annual Report. -inter alia to the Company (RIL) in -number of shares -transferred to connection with the trades by RIL -the Unclaimed Details of non-compliance in the stock exchanges in 2007 in -Suspense Account by the Company, penalties, the shares of Reliance Petroleum -during the year -Less: Number of 154 17,583 strictures imposed on the Limited, then a subsidiary of RIL. -shares transferred Hearings were held before the -Company by stock exchange -to IEPF Authority Whole Time Member (WTM) of -during the year or SEBI, or any statutory -SEBI in respect of the SCN. By -Aggregate number 59,215 54,92,993 -authority, on any matter an order dated March 24, 2017, -of shareholders -and the related to capital markets, the WTM passed the directions: -outstanding shares (i) prohibiting inter alia RIL from -during the last three years -in the Unclaimed dealing in equity derivatives in -Suspense Account (i) T he Securities and Exchange the ‘Futures & Options’ segment -lying as on March -31, 2024 Board of India (SEBI), on of stock exchanges, directly or -August 8, 2014 had passed indirectly, for a period of one year -The voting rights on the shares in the an adjudication order on a from the date of the order; and -suspense account as on March 31, show cause notice issued to (ii) to RIL to disgorge an amount of -2024 shall remain frozen till the the Company for alleged non- C 447.27 crore along with interest -rightful owner claims the shares. disclosure of the diluted Earnings at the rate of 12% per annum -per Share in the quarterly from November 29, 2007 till the -Other Disclosures financial results for the quarters date of payment. In May 2017, -Disclosure on materially ended June 2007, September RIL and the other noticees filed -2007, December 2007, March an appeal before the Securities -significant related party -2008, June 2008 and September Appellate Tribunal (SAT) against -transactions that may have 2008 and imposed monetary this order. SAT, by a majority -potential conflict with the penalty of C 13 crore. On an order (2:1), dismissed the appeal -Company’s interests at large appeal by the Company, the on November 5, 2020 and -Hon’ble Securities Appellate directed RIL to pay the disgorged -There were no materially significant Tribunal set aside SEBI’s order amount within sixty days from the -related party transactions which could and remanded the matter for date of the order. The appeal of -have potential conflict with interest of fresh consideration by SEBI. SEBI RIL and other noticees has been -the Company at large. issued a fresh show cause notice admitted by the Hon’ble Supreme -The Company’s Policy on Materiality dated April 5, 2016 in the matter Court of India. By its order -of Related Party Transactions and alleging incorrect disclosure of dated December 17, 2020, the -on dealing with Related Party the diluted Earnings per Share. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India -Transactions is available on the website The Company filed a reply to the directed RIL to deposit C 250 -of the Company and can be accessed show cause notice and attended crore in the Investors’ Protection -at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/ the personal hearing on July 26, Fund, subject to the final result -files/2023-01/Policy-on-Materiality- 2016. SEBI appointed new of the appeal and stayed the -of-RPT.pdf. Adjudicating Officer (AO). The recovery of the balance, inclusive -last hearing before the AO was of interest, pending the appeal. -All the contracts/arrangements/ held on November 22, 2018. RIL has complied with the order -transactions entered by the Company Further details sought by AO were dated December 17, 2020 of the -during the financial year with related provided in December, 2018. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. -parties were in its ordinary course of After more than 2 years, the AO -business and on an arm’s length basis. sent a letter dated March 19, In the very same matter, on -2021 granting an opportunity to November 21, 2017, SEBI issued -During the FY 2023-24, contracts/ -the Company to make additional show cause notice, inter alia, to -arrangements/transactions were -submissions and personal hearing RIL, asking RIL to show cause -entered into with related parties in -in the matter. The Company filed as to why inquiry should not be -accordance with the policy of the -additional submissions in the held in terms of SEBI (Procedure -Company on Materiality of Related -matter. The AO, vide his order for Holding Inquiry and Imposing -Party Transactions and on dealing -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 79 - -Corporate Governance Report -Penalties by Adjudicating Officer) by Adjudicating Officer) Rules, Loans granted to subsidiaries are -Rules, 1995 and penalty not be 1995 read with Section 15I of given in Notes to the Standalone -imposed under the provisions the Securities and Exchange Financial Statement. -| of the Securities and Exchange | Board of India Act, 1992 for | | -| ------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -Board of India Act, 1992. The alleged violation of Principle No. Agreements relating to the -Adjudicating Officer of SEBI 4 under Schedule A – Principles Company -| passed an order on January 1, | for Fair Disclosure of UPSI read | | -| ------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -There are no agreements with any -2021 imposing a penalty of with Regulation 8(1) of SEBI party which impact the management -| C 25 crore on RIL. RIL paid the | (Prohibition of Insider Trading) | | -| -------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -or control of the Company or impose -| penalty under protest and filed | Regulations, 2015 read with | | -| -------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | -any restriction or create any liability -an appeal before the SAT against Regulation 30(11) of SEBI (Listing upon the Company. -| this order. SAT has vide its order | Obligations and Disclosure | | -| ----------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | -| dated December 4, 2023 did not | Requirements) Regulations, | | -Adoption of Mandatory and -| interfere with the order passed | 2015. The alleged violation, | | -| -------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -by the AO since the matter was if established, will make RIL Discretionary Requirements -already covered by its earlier liable for monetary penalty (of not The Company has complied with all -decision dated November 5, less than C 1 lakh and which may mandatory requirements of Regulation -extend to maximum of C 1 crore) -2020, which is in appeal by RIL 34 of the Listing Regulations. -| before the Hon’ble Supreme | under Section 15HB of the SEBI | | -| --------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -The Company has adopted the -| Court. RIL has filed an appeal in | Act, 1992. RIL filed a detailed | | -| ---------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -following discretionary requirements -Hon’ble Supreme Court against reply to this show cause notice. of the Listing Regulations: -| Order dated December 4, 2023 | The Adjudicating Officer of SEBI | | -| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ------------------- | -| of the SAT. | passed an order on June 20, | Audit Qualification | -2022 imposing a penalty of C 30 -(iii) T he Company had issued The Company is in the regime -lakh. Appeal has been filed before -| debentures with convertible | | of unmodified opinions on | -| ---------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | -the Securities Appellate Tribunal -| warrants in the year 1994 and | | financial statements. | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --------------------- | -(“SAT”) against this order. SAT has -allotted equity shares against -stayed the operation of the order -the warrants in the year 2000. Reporting of Internal Auditor -dated June 20, 2022 and appeal -In this matter, SEBI had filed a -| | is pending. | The Internal Audit Department | -| --- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | -complaint on July 16, 2020, inter of the Company, co-sourced with -alia against the Company before -professional firms of Chartered -| the Special Court, Mumbai, for | Disclosures in relation to the | | -| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Accountants, reports directly to the -taking cognisance of alleged Sexual Harassment of Women Audit Committee. -offences under Regulations 3, -at Workplace (Prevention, -The Company is in compliance -5 and 6 of SEBI (Prohibition of -Prohibition and Redressal) -| Fraudulent and Unfair Trade | | with the corporate governance | -| --------------------------------- | --------- | ------------------------------ | -| Practices relating to Securities | Act, 2013 | | -requirements specified in -| Market) Regulations, 1995 and | The Company is committed to provide | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Regulations 17 to 27 and -| section 77(2) and section 77A | a work environment which ensures that | | -| ------------------------------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | -Regulation 46(2)(b) to (i) of the -| of Companies Act, 1956. The | every employee is treated with dignity, | | -| ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Special Court, Mumbai, vide order respect and afforded equal treatment. Listing Regulations. -| dated September 30, 2020, | Training/awareness programmes are | | -| -------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -dismissed SEBI’s complaint as conducted throughout the year to Certificate on Compliance -| barred by limitation. Against | create sensitivity towards ensuring | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -with Code of Conduct -| the said order of the Special | respectable workplace. Please refer | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -I hereby confirm that the Company -| Court, SEBI has filed a revision | Human Capital section of Management | | -| --------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -application before the Hon’ble Discussion and Analysis Report, for has obtained from all the members -of the Board and Senior Management -| High Court, Bombay and the same | more details. | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------- | -| is pending. | | Personnel, the affirmation that they | -have complied with the ‘Code of -Details of loans and advances -(iv) O n December 22, 2021, SEBI Conduct’ and ‘Our Code’ in respect of -| issued a show cause notice | in the nature of loans to firms/ | | -| --------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -the FY 2023-24. -| inter alia to RIL asking it to show | companies in which directors | | -| ------------------------------------ | ----------------------------- | --- | -cause as to why inquiry should -are interested -| not be held against it in terms | | Mukesh D. Ambani | -| -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | -| | The Company has not given any loans | Chairman and Managing Director | -of SEBI (Procedure for Holding -| Inquiry and Imposing Penalties | or advances to any firm/company in | | -| ------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -April 22, 2024 -which its directors are interested. -Mumbai -80 Reliance Industries Limited - -Certificate of Non-Disqualification of Directors -(pursuant to Regulation 34(3) read with Schedule V Para C Clause (10)(i) of the SEBI -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015) -To: India (hereinafter referred to as ‘the considered necessary and explanations -The Members Company’), produced before me furnished to me by the Company & -Reliance Industries Limited by the Company for the purpose of its officers, I hereby certify that none -3rd Floor, Maker Chambers IV, 222 issuing this Certificate, in accordance of the Directors on the Board of the -Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021 with Regulation 34(3) read with Company as stated below for the -Maharashtra, India. Schedule V Para-C Clause 10(i) of the financial year ended 31 March 2024, -Securities and Exchange Board of India have been debarred or disqualified -I have examined the relevant registers, -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure from being appointed or continuing -records, forms, returns and disclosures -Requirements) Regulations, 2015. as Directors of companies by the -received from the Directors of -Securities and Exchange Board of -Reliance Industries Limited having In my opinion and to the best of my -India, Ministry of Corporate Affairs or -CIN L17110MH1973PLC019786 and information and according to the -any such other Statutory Authority. -registered office at 3rd Floor, Maker verifications (including Directors -Chambers IV, 222, Nariman Point, Identification Number (DIN) status -Mumbai 400 021, Maharashtra, at the portal www.mca.gov.in) as -Date of Date of -Sr. Sr. -Name of Director DIN appointment in Name of Director DIN appointment in -No. No. -the Company the Company -1. Mukesh Dhirubhai Ambani 00001695 01.04.1977 9. Nita Mukesh Ambani** 03115198 18.06.2014 -2. Adil Zainulbhai* 06646490 20.12.2013 10. Isha Mukesh Ambani@ 06984175 27.10.2023 -3. Raminder Singh Gujral 07175393 12.06.2015 11. Akash Mukesh Ambani@ 06984194 27.10.2023 -4. Shumeet Banerji 02787784 21.07.2017 12. Anant Mukesh Ambani@ 07945702 27.10.2023 -5. Arundhati Bhattacharya 02011213 17.10.2018 13. Nikhil Rasiklal Meswani 00001620 26.06.1986 -6. Veerayya Chowdary Kosaraju 08485334 18.10.2019 14. Hital Rasiklal Meswani 00001623 04.08.1995 -7. His Excellency Yasir Othman H. 09245977 19.07.2021 15. Madhusudana Sivaprasad Panda 00012144 21.08.2009 -Al-Rumayyan 16. Pawan Kumar Kapil# 02460200 16.05.2010 -8. Kundapur Kamath 00043501 20.01.2023 -* ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as Independent Director on 31 March 2024 -** ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of 28 August 2023 -@ assumed office as a Non-executive Director of the Company on 27 October 2023 -# ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his term as a whole-time director on 15 May 2023 -neither an assurance as to the future the management has conducted the -Ensuring the eligibility of the -viability of the Company nor of the affairs of the Company. -appointment / continuity of every -efficiency or effectiveness with which -Director on the Board is the -responsibility of the management of -Dr. K. R. Chandratre -the Company. My responsibility is to -FCS No.: 1370, C. P. No.: 5144 -express an opinion on these, based -Place: Pune UDIN: F001370F000213230 -on my verification. This certificate is -Date: 22 April 2024 Peer Review Certificate No.: 1206/2021 -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 81 - -Corporate Governance Report -CEO/CFO Certificate -Under Regulation 17(8) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 -To, -The Board of Directors -Reliance Industries Limited -1. W e have reviewed financial statements and the cash flow statement of Reliance Industries Limited (“the Company”) -for the year ended March 31, 2024 and to the best of our knowledge and belief: -i. t hese statements do not contain any materially untrue statement or omit any material fact or contain statements -that might be misleading; -ii. t hese statements together present a true and fair view of the Company’s affairs and are in compliance with -existing accounting standards, applicable laws and regulations. -2. T here are, to the best of our knowledge and belief, no transactions entered into by the Company during the year which -are fraudulent, illegal or violative of the Company’s Code of Conduct. -3. W e accept responsibility for establishing and maintaining internal controls for financial reporting and we have -evaluated the effectiveness of Company’s internal control systems pertaining to financial reporting. We have not come -across any reportable deficiencies in the design or operation of such internal controls. -4. We have indicated to the Auditors and the Audit Committee that: -i. there are no significant changes in internal controls over financial reporting during the year; -ii. there are no significant changes in accounting policies during the year; and -iii. there are no instances of significant fraud of which we have become aware. -Srikanth Venkatachari Mukesh D. Ambani -Chief Financial Officer Chairman & Managing Director -Place: Mumbai -Date: April 22, 2024 -82 Reliance Industries Limited - -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to Section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule No. 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel) Rules, 2014] -To ii. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and b) T he Securities and -| | the Regulations and Bye-laws | Exchange Board of India | -| --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------------ | -The Members, -Jio Platforms Limited framed thereunder; and (Listing Obligations and -Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point Disclosure Requirements) -iii. F oreign Exchange Management -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi, | | Regulations, 2015; | -| ---------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -Act, 1999 and the Rules and -Ahmedabad - 380006 -| | Regulations made thereunder | c) T he Securities and | -| --- | ------------------------------ | ------------------------ | -We have conducted the Secretarial to the extent of Foreign Direct Exchange Board of India -Audit of the compliance of Investment and Overseas (Substantial Acquisition -applicable statutory provisions Direct Investments; of Shares and Takeovers) -| and adherence to good corporate | | Regulations, 2011; | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -iv. T he Securities Contracts -practices by Jio Platforms Limited -| | (Regulation) Act, 1956 and the | d) T he Securities and Exchange | -| --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -[CIN: U72900GJ2019PLC110816] -| | Rules framed thereunder. | Board of India (Prohibition of | -| --- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | -(hereinafter called the ‘Company’) -Insider Trading) Regulations, -| for the financial year ended March We have also examined compliance | | | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -2015; * -| 31, 2024 (hereinafter called the by the Company with the applicable | | | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -‘period under audit’). Secretarial clauses of the Secretarial Standard on e) T he Securities and -Audit was conducted in a manner that Meetings of Board of Directors (SS-1) Exchange Board of India -provided us with a reasonable basis for and Secretarial Standard on General (Share Based Employee -evaluating the Company’s corporate Meetings (SS-2) issued by the Institute Benefits and Sweat Equity) -conducts/statutory compliances and of Company Secretaries of India Regulations, 2021; -| expressing our opinion thereon. which are mandatorily applicable to | | | -| -------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | - f) T he Securities and -the Company. -| Based on our verification of the | | Exchange Board of India | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -Company’s books, papers, minute During the period under audit, (Issue of Capital and -books, forms and returns filed and the Company has complied with Disclosure Requirements) -other records maintained by the the provisions of the Act, Rules, Regulations, 2018; -| Company and provided to us including Regulations, Standards, etc. | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | - g) T he Securities and -| through permitted access to the mentioned above. | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -Company’s in-house portal as also the -| During the period under audit, | | (Issue and Listing of Non- | -| ------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | -information provided by the Company, -| provisions of the following Acts, Rules | | Convertible Securities) | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -its officers, agents and authorised -| and Regulations were not applicable to | | Regulations, 2021; | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -representatives during the conduct -the Company: -of secretarial audit, we hereby report h) T he Securities and Exchange -that in our opinion, the Company i. F oreign Exchange Management Board of India (Delisting of -has, during the period under audit, Act, 1999 and the Rules and Equity Shares) Regulations, -complied with the statutory provisions Regulations made thereunder to 2021; and -| listed hereunder and also that the | the extent they related to Foreign | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | - i) T he Securities and -| Company has proper Board-processes | Direct Investment and External | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| and compliance-mechanism in place to | Commercial Borrowings; | | -| ------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | -(Buyback of Securities) -the extent, in the manner and subject -| ii. | T he following Regulations and | Regulations, 2018. | -| ---- | ------------------------------- | ------------------ | -to the reporting made hereinafter. -Guidelines prescribed under the - * The Company being a -| We have examined the books, papers, | Securities and Exchange Board of | | -| ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -material subsidiary of -| minute books, forms and returns | India Act, 1992: - | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | -Reliance Industries Limited -filed and other records maintained -| | a) T he Securities and Exchange | (“RIL”) as defined in | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -by the Company for the audit period -| | Board of India (Registrars to | Regulation 16(1)(c) of the | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --------------------------- | -according to the provisions of: -| | an Issue and Share Transfer | SEBI (Listing Obligations and | -| --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -i. T he Companies Act, 2013 Agents) Regulations, 1993 Disclosure Requirements) -(“the Act”) and the Rules regarding the Act and dealing Regulations, 2015 as -| framed thereunder; | with clients; | amended, certain employees | -| ------------------ | ------------- | --------------------------- | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 83 - -Corporate Governance Report -of the Company have been of the directors were received for actions which have a major bearing -categorised as “Designated scheduling meeting at a shorter notice. on the Company’s affairs have taken -Persons” and are covered Agenda and detailed notes on agenda place, in pursuance of the above -under the RIL’s Code of were also sent to all the directors of referred laws, rules, regulations and -Conduct framed under the the Company at least seven days in standards except for the following: -| Securities and Exchange | advance, except where consent of | | -| ------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -1. T he Board of Directors of the -| Board of India (Prohibition | directors were received for circulation | | -| ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Company at their meeting held on -| of Insider Trading) | of the Agenda and notes on Agenda | | -| -------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -20th April, 2023, had approved -| Regulations, 2015. | at a shorter notice. A system exists | | -| ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | -investment in Accops Systems -for seeking and obtaining further -iii. T he Company has not entered Private Limited, in one or more -information and clarifications on the -into any listing agreements with tranches, for an amount up to -agenda items before the meeting and -| the stock exchanges. | | C 516 crore. | -| -------------------- | --- | ------------ | -for ensuring meaningful participation -| We further report that - | by the directors at the meetings. | | -| ------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -For BNP & Associates -| The Board of Directors of the Company | All decisions at the Meetings of the | | -| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -Company Secretaries -| is duly constituted with proper balance | Board and its Committees were carried | | -| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -of Executive, Non-Executive and out unanimously as recorded in the [Firm Regn. No. P2014MH037400] -PR No. 637/2019 -| Independent Directors. The changes | minutes of the meetings of the Board | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -in the composition of the Board of of Directors or Committees of the Date: 21/04/2024 -Place: Mumbai -| Directors that took place during the | Board, as the case may be. | | -| ------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | -period under audit were carried out -We further report that there are -in compliance with the provisions of Kalidas Ramaswami -adequate systems and processes in the -the Act. Partner -Company commensurate with its size -FCS: 2440/CP No. 22856 -| Adequate notices were given to all | and operations to monitor and ensure | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -UDIN: F002440F000200176 -| directors of the Company as regards | compliance with the applicable laws, | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | -| the schedule of the Meetings of the | rules, regulations and guidelines. | | -Note: This report is to be read with our -Board (including Meetings of its -| | We further report that during the | letter of even date which is annexed as | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | -Committees), except where consent -| | period under audit, no specific events/ | Annexure A and forms an integral part | -| --- | --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | -of this report. -Annexure A -To, done on test-check basis to management. Our examination -The Members, ensure that correct facts are was limited to the verification of -Jio Platforms Limited reflected in secretarial records. procedures on test-check basis. -| Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point | We believe that the process and | | -| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -6. T he Secretarial Audit Report -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi | practices, we followed provide a | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -is neither an assurance as -| Ahmedabad - 380006 | reasonable basis for our opinion. | | -| ------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -to the future viability of the -Re: Secretarial Audit Report of 3. W e have not verified the Company nor of the efficacy or -even date is to be read along with correctness and appropriateness effectiveness with which the -this letter. of financial records and Books of management has conducted the -| | Accounts of the Company. | affairs of the Company. | -| --- | ------------------------ | ----------------------- | -1. M aintenance of secretarial -records is the responsibility of the 4. W herever required, we For BNP & Associates -management. Our responsibility have obtained management Company Secretaries -is to express an opinion on these representation about the [Firm Regn. No. P2014MH037400] -secretarial records based on compliance of laws, rules and PR No. 637/2019 -| our audit. | regulations and happening of | Date: 21/04/2024 | -| ---------- | ----------------------------- | ---------------- | -| | events, etc. | Place: Mumbai | -2. W e have followed the audit -| practices and processes as were | 5. T he compliance of the provisions | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -Kalidas Ramaswami -| appropriate to obtain reasonable | or corporate and other applicable | | -| --------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -assurance about the correctness laws, rules, regulations, Partner -of the contents of the secretarial standards, is the responsibility of FCS: 2440/CP No. 22856 -UDIN: F002440F000200176 -records. The verification was -84 Reliance Industries Limited - -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to Section 204 (1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule No.9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial personnel) Rules, 2014] -To IV. T he Foreign Exchange 3. T he Telecom Regulatory Authority -| The Members, | Management Act, 1999 and | of India Act, 1997; | -| ------------ | ------------------------- | ------------------- | -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, the Rules/Regulations made 4. T he Information Technology -Office – 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point thereunder to the extent of Act, 2000 -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi, | Overseas Direct Investments and | | -| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -5. T he Aadhaar and Other Laws -| Ahmedabad 380006. | External Commercial Borrowings; | | -| ----------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -(Amendment) Act, 2019 -V. T he Securities and Exchange -We have conducted the Secretarial -| | Board of India (Issue and Listing | Based on such examination and having | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | -Audit of the compliance of applicable -| | of Non-Convertible Securities) | regard to the compliance system | -| --- | ------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -statutory provisions and the adherence -prevailing in the Company, we report -| to good corporate practices by | Regulations, 2021; | | -| ------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | -that, the Company has complied with -| Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, | VI. T he Securities and Exchange | | -| ------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -the provisions of the above laws during -| (CIN: U72900GJ2007PLC105869) | Board of India (Listing Obligations | | -| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -the period under audit. -| (hereinafter called the ‘Company’) | and Disclosure Requirements) | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -for the financial year ended March Regulations, 2015; As on March During the period under audit, -31, 2024 (‘period under audit’). 31, 2024, 50,000 6.20% provisions of the following Acts, Rules -| Secretarial Audit was conducted in | Unsecured Redeemable Non- | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | -and Regulations were not applicable to -a manner that provided us with a Convertible Debentures of the Company: -face value of C 10 lakh each, -reasonable basis for evaluating the -| | aggregating to C 5,000 crore, | 1. F oreign Exchange Management | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | -Company’s corporate conducts/ -Act, 1999 and the Rules and -| statutory compliances and for | were listed for trading on BSE | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | -expressing our opinion thereon. Limited and the National Stock Regulations made thereunder -with respect to Foreign -Exchange of India Limited. -| Based on our verification of the | | Direct Investment. | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -VII. T he Securities and Exchange -Company’s books, papers, minute -2. T he following Regulations and -| books, forms and returns filed and | Board of India (Prohibition of | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Guidelines prescribed under the -| other records maintained and provided | Insider Trading) Regulations, | | -| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -Securities and Exchange Board of -2015, including maintenance of a -| to us including through access to the | | India Act, 1992: | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | -‘Structural Digital Database’. -Company’s in-house portal as also the - (a) T he Securities and Exchange -information provided by the Company, -| | We have also examined compliance | Board of India (Registrars to | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -its officers, agents and authorised -by the Company with the applicable -representatives, during the conduct an Issue and Share Transfer -clauses of the Secretarial Standard on -Agents) Regulations, 1993 -| of Secretarial Audit, we hereby report | Meetings of Board of Directors (SS-1) | | -| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -relating to the Companies -| that in our opinion, the Company | and Secretarial Standard on General | | -| --------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Act, 2013 and dealing -has, during the period under audit, -| | Meetings (SS-2) issued by the Institute | with clients; | -| --- | ---------------------------------------- | ------------- | -complied with the statutory provisions -of Company Secretaries of India and -listed hereunder and also that the (b) T he Securities and -notified by Central Government under -Exchange Board of India -| Company has proper Board-processes | Section 118(10) of the Act which are | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -and compliance-mechanism in place to mandatorily applicable to the Company. (Substantial Acquisition -the extent, in the manner and subject of Shares and Takeovers) -to the reporting made hereinafter. During the period under audit, Regulations, 2011; -the Company has complied - (c) T he Securities and -| We have examined the books, papers, | with the provisions of the Act, | | -| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| minute books, forms and returns filed | Rules, Regulations, Standards, as | | -| -------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -(Issue of Capital and -and other records maintained by the -| | mentioned above. | Disclosure Requirements) | -| --- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | -Company for the period under audit -according to the provisions of: We have also examined, on test-check Regulations, 2018; -| | basis, the relevant documents and | (d) T he Securities and | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --------------------------- | -I. T he Companies Act, 2013 -records maintained by the Company -| (“the Act”) and the Rules | | Exchange Board of India | -| -------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------ | -| | according to the following laws | (Share Based Employee | -made thereunder; -| | applicable specifically to the Company: | Benefits and Sweat Equity) | -| --- | --------------------------------------- | --------------------------- | -II. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -Regulations, 2021; -1. T he Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 -the Regulations and Bye-laws -& Indian Telegraph Right of Way -| framed thereunder; | | (e) T he Securities and | -| ------------------ | ------------ | --------------------------- | -| | Rules, 2016; | Exchange Board of India | -III. T he Securities Contracts -| | 2. T he Indian Wireless Telegraphy | (Delisting of Equity Shares) | -| --- | ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -(Regulation) Act, 1956 and the -Regulations, 2021; -| Rules made thereunder; | Act, 1933; | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | --- | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 85 - -Corporate Governance Report -(f) T he Securities and All decisions at the meetings of CIR/2021/613 dated August 10, -Exchange Board of India the Board and the meetings of 2021. As on March 31, 2024, -(Buy-back of Securities) the Committees were carried out CPs amounting to C 2,500 crore -Regulations, 2018. unanimously as recorded in the were outstanding. -minutes of the meetings of the Board -We further report that: iii) A s per the recommendation made -of Directors or Committees of the -by the Board of Directors of the -The Board of Directors of the Company Board, as the case may be. -company, at their meeting held on -is duly constituted with proper balance -We further report that there are April 21, 2023, the shareholders -of Executive Director, Non-Executive -adequate systems and processes in the of the Company at their 16th -Directors and Independent Directors. -Company, which are commensurate Annual General Meeting of the -The changes in the composition of -with its size and operations, to monitor company, held on September 26, -the Board of Directors that took place -and ensure compliance with applicable 2023, have approved by special -during the period under audit were -laws, rules, regulations and guidelines. resolution an amendment in the -carried out in compliance with the -Articles of Association of the -provisions of the Act. We further report that during the -company, through insertion of -period under audit, the following -Adequate notice was given to all new Article 90A after the existing -specific events/actions having major -directors of the Company as regards article 90. -bearing on the Company’s affairs -the schedule of the meetings of the -have taken place in pursuance of the For BNP & Associates -Board (including meetings of the -above referred laws, rules, regulations -Committees) except where consent Company Secretaries -and standards: -of directors was received for holding [Firm Reg No: P2014MH037400] -the meeting at a shorter notice. i) T he Company has raised External PR No: 637/2019 -Agenda and detailed notes on Agenda Commercial Borrowings by way of Date: April 22, 2024 -were also sent to all the directors foreign currency syndicated term Place: Mumbai -of the Company at least seven days loans of up to US$ 2,976 Million, -in advance, except in cases where Euro 90.599 Million and JPY Kalidas Ramaswami -consent of directors was received for 86,736.6 Million. -Partner -circulation of the Agenda and notes on -ii) T he Company had issued FCS: F2440/CP No. 22856 -Agenda at a shorter notice. A system -Commercial Papers (“CPs”), in UDIN: F002440F000203291 -exists for seeking and obtaining further -one or more tranches, which -information and clarifications on the -agenda items before the meetings and were listed on the BSE Limited in Note: This report is to be read with our -for meaningful participation by the accordance with the provisions letter of even date which is annexed as -directors at the meetings. of SEBI Operational Circular Annexure A and forms an integral part of -bearing no. SEBI/HO/DDHS/P/ this report. -Annexure - A -To test-check basis to ensure that examination was limited to the -The Members, correct facts are reflected in verification of procedures on test- -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited secretarial records. We believe check basis. -Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point that the process and practices, -6. T he Secretarial Audit Report -Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi we followed provide a reasonable -is neither an assurance as -Ahmedabad, 380006 basis for our opinion. -to the future viability of the -Re: Secretarial Audit Report of even 3. W e have not verified the Company nor of the efficacy or -date is to be read along with this letter. correctness and appropriateness effectiveness with which the -of financial records and Books of Management has conducted the -1. M aintenance of secretarial -Accounts of the Company. affairs of the Company. -records is the responsibility of the -Management. Our responsibility 4. W herever required, we For BNP & Associates -is to express an opinion on the have obtained Management Company Secretaries -secretarial records based on representation about the [Firm Reg No: P2014MH037400] -our audit. compliance of laws, rules and PR No: 637/2019 -2. W e have followed the audit regulations and happening of Date: April 22, 2024 -practices and processes as were material events, etc. Place: Mumbai -considered appropriate to obtain 5. T he compliance of the provisions -reasonable assurance about or corporate and other applicable Kalidas Ramaswami -the correctness of the contents laws, rules, regulations, Partner -of the secretarial records. standards, is the responsibility FCS: F2440/CP No. 22856 -The verification was done on of the Management. Our UDIN: F002440F000203291 -86 Reliance Industries Limited - -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Rule 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel), Rules, 2014] -To an unavoidable risk that some i) T he Companies Act, 2013 -The Members misstatements or material non- (“the Act”) and the rules -Reliance Retail Limited compliances may not be detected, made thereunder; -3rd Floor, Court House even though the audit is properly -ii) T he Securities Contracts -Lokmanya Tilak Marg planned and performed in accordance -(Regulation) Act, 1956 (‘SCRA’) -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 with the CSAS. -and the rules made thereunder- -We have conducted the secretarial Not Applicable to the Company -Basis for Opinion -audit of the compliance of applicable during the Audit Period; -statutory provisions and the adherence We have followed the audit practices -iii) T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -to good corporate practices by and processes as were appropriate to -the Regulations and Bye-laws -Reliance Retail Limited having CIN: obtain reasonable assurance about -framed thereunder; -U01100MH1999PLC120563 (‘the the correctness of the contents of the -Company’). Secretarial Audit was secretarial records. The verification iv) F oreign Exchange Management -conducted in a manner that provided was done on test basis to ensure Act, 1999 and the rules and -us a reasonable basis for evaluating that correct facts are reflected in regulations made thereunder -the corporate conducts/statutory the secretarial records. We believe to the extent of Overseas -compliances and expressing our that the processes and practices, we Direct Investment; -opinion thereon. followed provide a reasonable basis for -v) T he following Regulations and -our opinion. -Guidelines prescribed under the -Management’s -Securities and Exchange Board of -responsibility Opinion India Act, 1992 (‘SEBI Act’):- -The Management along with the Based on our verification of the a) T he Securities and Exchange -Board of Directors are responsible for Company’s books, papers, minute Board of India (Substantial -ensuring that the Company complies books, forms and returns filed and Acquisition of Shares and -with the provisions of all applicable other records maintained by the Takeovers) Regulations, -laws and maintains the required Company and provided as scanned 2011- Not Applicable to -statutory records and documents in copies in physical or electronic mode -the Company during the -the prescribed manner. or through permitted access to the Audit Period; -Company’s in-house portal and also -the information provided by the b) T he Securities and Exchange -Auditor’s responsibility -Company, its officers and authorised Board of India (Prohibition of -Based on audit, our responsibility representatives during the conduct Insider Trading) Regulations, -is to express an opinion on the of secretarial audit, we hereby report 2015- Not Applicable to -compliance with the applicable laws that in our opinion, the Company has, the Company during the -and maintenance of records by the during the audit period covering the Audit Period; -Company. We conducted our audit financial year ended on March 31, -in accordance with the auditing 2024 (‘the Audit Period’), complied c) T he Securities and Exchange -standards CSAS 1 to CSAS 4 (‘CSAS’) with the statutory provisions listed Board of India (Issue of -prescribed by the Institute of Company hereunder and also that the Company Capital and Disclosure -Secretaries of India. These standards has proper Board-processes and Requirements) Regulations, -require that the auditor complies with compliance-mechanism in place to the 2018- Not Applicable to -statutory and regulatory requirements extent, in the manner and subject to the Company during the -and plans and performs the audit to the reporting made hereinafter: Audit Period; -obtain reasonable assurance about d) T he Securities and Exchange -compliance with applicable laws and We have examined the books, papers, Board of India (Share Based -maintenance of records. minute books, forms and returns Employee Benefits and -filed and other records maintained -Due to the inherent limitations of by the Company for the Audit Period Sweat Equity) Regulations, -an audit including internal, financial according to the provisions of: 2021 - Not Applicable to -and operating controls, there is -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 87 - -Corporate Governance Report -the Company during the We further report that, the Company convened and held, at shorter notice -Audit Period; has identified the following laws as with the consent of the members, in -specifically applicable to the Company: due compliance with the applicable -e) T he Securities and Exchange -provisions of the Act. -Board of India (Issue and i) T he Food Safety and Standards -Listing of Non-Convertible Act, 2006 and Rules; We further report that having regard -Securities) Regulations, to the compliance system prevailing in -ii) T he Legal Metrology Act 2009 -2021 Not Applicable to the Company and as per explanations -and Rules; -the Company during the and management representations -Audit Period; iii) S tate Agriculture Produce obtained and relied upon by us the -Marketing Act; Company has adequate systems and -f) T he Securities and Exchange -processes commensurate with the -Board of India (Registrars to iv) T he Bureau of Indian Standards -size and operations of the Company to -an Issue and Share Transfer Act, 2016; -monitor and ensure compliance with -Agents) Regulations, 1993 -v) The Trade Marks Act, 1999. applicable laws, rules, regulations -regarding the Companies Act -and guidelines. -and dealing with client - Not We further report that- -Applicable to the Company We further report that, during -The Board of Directors of the Company -during the Audit Period; the Audit Period the Company has -was constituted comprising Executive -done the following transactions in -g) T he Securities and Exchange Director, Non-Executive Directors -due compliance with the applicable -Board of India (Delisting of including Woman Director and -provisions of the Act: -Equity Shares) Regulations, Independent Directors. There was no -2021- Not Applicable to change in the composition of the Board 1. C onverted 80 crore-8.5% Non- -the Company during the of Directors during the Audit Period. Cumulative Optionally Convertible -Audit Period; Preference Shares (‘OCPS’) of -Adequate notice was given to all -C 10 each issued at premium of -h) T he Securities and Exchange directors of the Company of the -C 40 per OCPS into 400 crore -Board of India (Buyback meetings of the Board (including -equity shares of C 10 each -of Securities) Regulations, meetings of the Committees), except -aggregating C 4000 crore; -2018 - Not Applicable to where consent of directors was -the Company during the received for shorter notice. The agenda 2. A pproved variation in the terms -Audit Period; and and detailed notes on agenda were and conditions of redemption and -sent at least seven days in advance for conversion of 3,300 Compulsorily -i) T he Securities and Exchange -the Board and Committee meetings, Convertible Debentures of face -Board of India (Listing -except for the meetings which were value of C 10,00,000 each -Obligations and Disclosure -convened at shorter notice with the (“CCDs”). -Requirements) Regulations, -consent of directors. -2015- Not Applicable to 3. C onverted 3,300 CCDs into -the Company during the All decisions made at Board meetings 33,00,00,000 9% Non- -Audit Period. and Committee meetings have Cumulative Compulsorily -unanimous consent of directors Redeemable Preference Shares -We have also examined -(excluding the directors who were (‘RPS’) of C 10 each aggregating -compliance with: -concerned or interested in specific C 330 crore and thereafter the -i) Applicable Secretarial Standards items) as recorded in the minutes of RPS were redeemed at par; -issued by the Institute of the meetings of the Board of Directors -4. N ational Company Law Tribunal, -Company Secretaries of India; and or Committees of the Board, as the -Mumbai Bench vide its order -case may be. -ii) T he Listing Agreements entered dated January 05, 2024 -into by the Company with Stock We further report that the approved reduction of equity -Exchange(s) - Not Applicable Company has devised a system share capital of the Company -to the Company during the which enables the directors to seek by C 7,86,54,230 by cancelling -Audit Period. and obtain further information and and extinguishing 78,65,423 -clarifications on the agenda items fully paid up equity shares held -During the Audit Period, the Company -before the meeting and for meaningful by shareholders other than -has complied with the provisions of the -participation at the meeting. Promoter, the holding Company -Act, Rules, Regulations, Guidelines, -of the Company; -Standards, etc. mentioned above. During the Audit Period, one extra- -ordinary general meeting was -88 Reliance Industries Limited - -5. T ransferred supply chain assets of the Company to Reliance Logistics and Warehouse Holdings Limited, a fellow -subsidiary of the Company for a consideration of up to C 8,000 crore pursuant to Section 180(1) (a) of the Companies -Act, 2013; -6. Borrowed funds from the holding company and banks pursuant to sections 179 and 180 of the Act. -For Shashikala Rao & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P2010MH067400 -PR 4740/2023 -Shashikala Rao -Partner -Place: Mumbai FCS 3866 CP No 9482 -Date: April 22, 2024 UDIN F003866F000210853 -Annexure to the Secretarial Audit Report -To, -The Members -Reliance Retail Limited -Our report of even date is to be read along with this letter: -1. W e have not verified the correctness and appropriateness of financial records and Books of Accounts of the Company -and financial statements and disclosures made therein. -2. W herever required, we have obtained a Management Representation about the compliance of laws, rules and -regulations and happening of events, etc. -3. T he Secretarial Audit report is neither an assurance as to future viability of the Company nor of the efficiency or -effectiveness with which the management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -For Shashikala Rao & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P2010MH067400 -PR 4740/2023 -Shashikala Rao -Partner -Place: Mumbai FCS 3866 CP No 9482 -Date: April 22, 2024 UDIN F003866F000210853 -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 89 - -Corporate Governance Report -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel), Rules, 2014] -To, i. T he Companies Act, 2013 d. T he Securities and -The Members, (‘the Act’) and the rules Exchange Board of India -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited made thereunder; (Share Based Employee -| CIN: U51909MH2006PLC166166 | | Benefits and Sweat Equity) | -| -------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | -ii. T he Securities Contracts -| 4th Floor, Court House, | | Regulations, 2021; | -| ----------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -(Regulation) Act, 1956 (‘SCRA’) -Lokmanya Tilak Marg, -| | and the rules made thereunder - | e. T he Securities and Exchange | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 -| | Not Applicable as the Securities | Board of India (Registrars to | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -We have conducted the Secretarial of the Company are not listed on an Issue and Share Transfer -Audit of the compliance with any Stock Exchange. Agents) Regulations, 1993 -applicable statutory provisions and the regarding the Companies Act -iii. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -adherence to good corporate practices and dealing with client; -the Regulations and Bye-laws -by Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -| | framed thereunder; | f. T he Securities and | -| --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | -(hereinafter called the “Company”) -Exchange Board of India -| for the Financial Year ended 31st | iv. T he Foreign Exchange | | -| ---------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | -(Delisting of Equity Shares) -| March, 2024. Secretarial Audit was | Management Act, 1999 and | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | -Regulations, 2021; -| conducted in a manner that provided | the rules and regulations made | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | -us a reasonable basis for evaluating thereunder to the extent of g. T he Securities and -the corporate conducts/statutory Foreign Direct Investment, Exchange Board of India -compliances and expressing our Overseas Direct Investment (Buyback of Securities) -| opinion thereon. | and External Commercial | Regulations, 2018; | -| ---------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------ | -Borrowings:- Not Applicable -| Based on our verification of the | | h. T he Securities and | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -to the extent of External -| Company’s books, papers, minute | | Exchange Board of India | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -Commercial Borrowings; -books, forms and returns filed and (Issue and Listing of Non- -other records maintained by the v. T he following Regulations and Convertible Securities) -Company and furnished to us through Guidelines prescribed under the Regulations, 2021; -| access to the Company’s in-house | Securities and Exchange Board of | | -| --------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | - i. T he Securities and -| portal and also the information | India Act, 1992 (‘SEBI Act’) are | | -| -------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| provided by the Company, its officers, | Not Applicable as the Securities | | -| --------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -(Listing Obligations and -| agents and authorised representatives | of the Company are not listed on | | -| -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Disclosure Requirements) -| during the conduct of secretarial audit, | any Stock Exchange; | | -| ----------------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | -Regulations, 2015; -we hereby report that in our opinion, - a. T he Securities and Exchange -the Company has, during the audit vi. Framework/Operational -Board of India (Substantial -period covering the financial year Circular for Issue and Listing -Acquisition of Shares and -ended on 31st March 2024, complied of Commercial Papers issued -Takeovers) Regulations, -with the statutory provisions listed by Securities and Exchange -2011- except to the extent -hereunder and also that the Company Board of India including -of being a promoter as -| has proper Board-processes and | | amendments thereto. | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | -defined, of a listed entity; -compliance-mechanism in place to the -The Management of the Company -| extent, in the manner and subject to | b. T he Securities and Exchange | | -| ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -has confirmed that there are no laws -| the reporting made hereinafter: | Board of India (Prohibition | | -| ------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | -identified which are specifically -of Insider Trading) -We have examined the books, papers, applicable to the Company. -Regulations, 2015; -minute books, forms and returns filed -We have also examined compliance -| and other records maintained by the | c. T he Securities and | | -| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------- | --- | -with the applicable Standards/ -| Company for the financial year ended | Exchange Board of India | | -| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | -Regulations of the following: -| on 31st March, 2024 according to the | (Issue of Capital and | | -| ------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | -provisions of: Disclosure Requirements) (i) S ecretarial Standards with -| | Regulations, 2018; | regard to Meeting of the Board | -| --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------- | -of Directors (SS-1) and General -90 Reliance Industries Limited - -Meetings (SS-2) issued by The We further report that based on give guarantees upto C 1,15,000 -Institute of Company Secretaries review of compliance mechanism crore, outstanding at any point -of India; established by the Company and of time, over and above the -on the basis of the Compliance limits prescribed in the aforesaid -(ii) T he Listing Agreements entered -Certificate(s) issued by the Company Section of the Act; -into by the Company with the -Secretary based on the certificates -Stock Exchanges: Applicable 3. T he Company has during the -issued by functional heads and -to the extent of Commercial year under review issued and -taken on record by the Board of -Papers listed during the period allotted 14,77,02,906 equity -Directors at their meeting(s), we -under review. shares of C 10/- each at a -are of the opinion that there are -premium of C 1,196.09/- per -During the period under audit, adequate systems and processes in -share aggregating to C 17,814.29 -the Company has complied with place which commensurate with size -crore on private placement basis -the provisions of the Act, Rules, and operations of the Company, to -to Reliance Industries Limited -Regulations, Guidelines, Standards, monitor and ensure compliance with -(the holding company) and three -etc. mentioned above. all applicable laws, rules, regulations -financial investors; -and guidelines. -We further report that: - -4. T he Members at the Annual -We further report that during the -− The Board of Directors of the General Meeting held on 28th -financial year under audit, following -Company is duly constituted September 2023 and at the -were the event/actions which -with proper balance of Executive Extra-Ordinary General Meetings -occurred, having a major bearing on -Directors, Non-Executive Directors held on 10th October 2023 -the Company’s affairs in pursuance -including a Woman Director and and 10th November 2023 -of the above referred laws, rules, -Independent Directors. No changes respectively, have passed special -regulations, guidelines, standards, etc: -in the composition of the Board resolutions to approve and -of Directors took place during the 1. P ursuant to necessary approvals adopt the restated Articles of -period under audit. obtained from Audit Committee, Association, which were amended -the Board and the shareholders of pursuant to shareholders’ -− Adequate notice is given to all -the holding company and of the agreements entered into by the -Directors of the schedule of -Audit Committee of the Company, Company with the investors. -the Board Meetings (including -the Board has passed a resolution -Committees Meetings). Agenda and The Report is to be read with our -on 22nd March 2024 to accord -detailed notes on agenda were also letter of even date which is annexed -consent to enter into necessary -sent atleast seven days in advance, as Annexure A hereto and forms an -agreements, to transfer mid- -except where consent of directors integral part of this report. -sized warehousing relating assets -was received for circulation of the -of the Company aggregating For S. N. -Agenda and notes on Agenda at -upto C 3,000 crore to Reliance ANANTHASUBRAMANIAN -a shorter notice. A system exists -Logistics and Warehouse Holdings & Co. -for seeking and obtaining further -Limited, a subsidiary Company; Company Secretaries -information and clarifications on the -ICSI Unique Code: P1991MH040400 -agenda items before the meeting 2. M embers of the Company at the -Peer Review Cert. No.: 5218/2023 -and for meaningful participation by Extraordinary General Meeting -the directors at the meeting. held on 25th August 2023 -Aparna Gadgil -have, pursuant to Section 186 -− As recorded in the Minutes of Partner -of the Act, passed a Special -Board/Committee Meetings, ACS: 14713| COP No.: 8430 -Resolution and granted consent -all decisions of the Board and ICSI UDIN: A014713F000203286 -to the Board of Directors to -Committees thereof were carried -make loans, investments and -out unanimously. 22nd April, 2024 I Thane -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 91 - -Corporate Governance Report -Annexure A -To, -The Members, -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -CIN: U51909MH2006PLC166166 -4th Floor, Court House, -Lokmanya Tilak Marg, -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 -Our Secretarial Audit Report for the financial year ended 31st March 2024 of even date is to be read along with this letter. -Management’s Responsibility -1. I t is the responsibility of the management of the Company to maintain secretarial records, devise proper systems -to ensure compliance with the provisions of all applicable laws and regulations and to ensure that the systems are -adequate and operate effectively. -Auditor’s Responsibility -2. O ur responsibility is to express an opinion on these secretarial records, standards and procedures followed by the -Company with respect to secretarial compliances. -3. W e have conducted the Audit as per the applicable Auditing Standards issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries -of India. -4. W e believe that audit evidence and information obtained from the Company’s management is adequate and -appropriate for us to provide a basis for our opinion. -5. W herever required, we have obtained reasonable assurance about whether the statements prepared, documents or -Records, in relation to Secretarial Audit, maintained by the Auditee, are free from misstatement. -6. W herever required, we have obtained the Management’s representation about the compliance of laws, rules and -regulations and happening of events, etc -Disclaimer -7. T he Secretarial Audit Report is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company nor of the efficacy or -effectiveness with which the management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -8. W e have not verified the correctness and appropriateness of financial records and Books of Accounts of the Company. -For S. N. ANANTHASUBRAMANIAN & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P1991MH040400 -Peer Review Cert. No.: 5218/2023 -Aparna Gadgil -Partner -ACS: 14713| COP No.: 8430 -ICSI UDIN: A014713F000203286 -22nd April, 2024 I Thane -92 Reliance Industries Limited - -Independent Auditor’s Report on compliance with the conditions of Corporate -Governance as per provisions of Chapter IV of Securities and Exchange Board of India -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 -To the Members of Auditor’s Responsibility Financial Information, and -4. O ur responsibility is limited to Other Assurance and Related -Reliance Industries Limited -examining the procedures and Services Engagements. -1. T his certificate is issued in implementation thereof, adopted 8. T he procedures selected depend -accordance with the terms of by the Company for ensuring on the auditor’s judgement, -our engagement letter dated compliance with the conditions of including the assessment of the -September 22, 2023. the Corporate Governance. It is risks associated in compliance -2. W e, Deloitte Haskins & Sells neither an audit nor an expression of the Corporate Governance -LLP, Chartered Accountants and of opinion on the financial Report with the applicable -Chaturvedi & Shah LLP, Chartered statements of the Company. criteria. The procedures include -Accountants, the Statutory 5. W e have examined the books but not limited to verification -Auditors of Reliance Industries of account and other relevant of secretarial records and -Limited (“the Company”), records and documents financial information of -have examined the compliance maintained by the Company the Company and obtained -of conditions of Corporate for the purposes of providing necessary representations. -Governance by the Company, reasonable assurance on the 9. T he procedures also include -for the year ended on March 31, compliance with Corporate examining evidence supporting -2024, as stipulated in regulations Governance requirements by the particulars in the Corporate -17 to 27 and clauses (b) to (i) the Company. Governance Report on a test -of regulation 46(2) and para -C and D of Schedule V of the SEBI 6. W e have carried out an basis. Further, our scope of work -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure examination of the relevant under this report did not involve -Requirements) Regulations, 2015 records of the Company in us performing audit tests for the -(the Listing Regulations). This accordance with the Guidance purposes of expressing an opinion -report is required by the Company Note on Certification of on the fairness or accuracy of any -for annual submission to the stock Corporate Governance issued of the financial information or -exchange and to be sent to the by the Institute of the Chartered the financial statements of the -Shareholders of the Company. Accountants of India (the ICAI), Company taken as a whole -the Standards on Auditing -specified under Section 143(10) Opinion -Managements’ -of the Companies Act 2013, in so 10. B ased on our examination -Responsibility -far as applicable for the purpose of the relevant records and -3. T he compliance of conditions of this certificate and as per the according to the information and -of Corporate Governance is the Guidance Note on Reports or explanations provided to us and -responsibility of the Management Certificates for Special Purposes the representations provided -including the preparation and issued by the ICAI which requires by the Management, we certify -maintenance of all relevant that we comply with the ethical that the Company has complied -supporting records and requirements of the Code of with the conditions of Corporate -documents. This responsibility Ethics issued by the ICAI. Governance as stipulated in -also includes the design, 7. W e have complied with the regulations 17 to 27 and clauses -implementation and maintenance relevant applicable requirements (b) to (i) of regulation 46(2) and -of internal control and procedures of the Standard on Quality para C and D of Schedule V of the -to ensure the compliance with Control (SQC) 1, Quality Control Listing Regulations during the year -the conditions of the Corporate for Firms that Perform Audits ended March 31, 2024. -Governance stipulated in -and Reviews of Historical -Listing Regulations. -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 93 - -Corporate Governance Report -11. W e state that such compliance is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company nor the efficiency or -effectiveness with which the Management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -Restriction on Use -12. T his report is addressed to and provided to the members of the Company solely for the purpose of enabling it to -comply with its obligations under the Listing Regulations and should not be used by any other person or for any other -purpose. Accordingly, we do not accept or assume any liability or any duty of care or for any other purpose or to any -other party to whom it is shown or into whose hands it may come without our prior consent in writing. We have no -responsibility to update this report for events and circumstances occurring after the date of this report. -For Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP For Chaturvedi & Shah LLP -Chartered Accountants Chartered Accountants -Firm’s Registration No. 117366W/W-100018 Firm’s Registration No. 101720W/W-100355 -Abhijit A. Damle Sandesh Ladha -Partner Partner -Membership No. 102912 Membership No. 047841 -UDIN: 24102912BKEPFU3347 UDIN: 24047841BKCAIY8639 -Place: Mumbai Place: Mumbai -Date: April 22, 2024 Date: April 22, 2024 -94 Reliance Industries Limited \ No newline at end of file +Explanation, Debate, Align: A Weak-to-Strong Framework for Language Model +Generalization +MehrdadZakershahrak*,SamiraGhodratnama* +DepartmentofComputing +{mehrdad,samira}@mq..edu.au +4202 peS 11 ]IA.sc[ 1v53370.9042:viXra Abstract inglysophisticatedAIsystemswithoutsolelydependingon +humanoversight.Suchmethodsshouldfacilitatealignment +Therapidadvancementofartificialintelligencesystemshas +| | | | | | | | in domains | where | human | experts | may | struggle | to provide | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | +broughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttotheforefrontofre- +accuratefeedback,whilestillmaintainingthecoreprinciple +search,particularlyincomplexdecision-makingandtaskex- +ofaligningwithhumanvalues.Furthermore,thesemethods +ecution.Asthesesystemssurpasshuman-levelperformance +insophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralignmentwithhu- shouldprovideamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +man values, intentions, and ethical guidelines becomes cru- capabilities evolve, ensuring that alignment scales with ad- +cial.Buildingonpreviousworkinexplanationgenerationfor vancementsinAItechnology. +human-agent alignment, we address the more complex dy- Buildingonourpreviousworkinexplanationgeneration +namicsofmulti-agentsystemsandhuman-AIteams.Thispa- forhuman-agentalignment,weintroduceaframeworkthat +perintroducesanovelapproachtomodelalignmentthrough +combinesweak-to-stronggeneralizationandmodelfacilita- +| weak-to-strong | | generalization | in | the context | of | language | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | tion, leveraging | | explanatory | debates | to | enhance | alignment. | | +models.Wepresentaframeworkwhereastrongmodelfacili- +Thisapproachaimstocreateascalable,self-improvingsys- +| tates the | improvement | of a | weaker | model, | bridging | the gap | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +temforAIalignmentthatcanhandleincreasinglycomplex +| between | explanation | generation | and | model | alignment. | Our | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskswhilemaintainingtransparencyandinterpretability. +| method, | formalized | as a facilitation | | function | Φ, | allows for | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thetransferofcapabilitiesfromadvancedmodelstolessca- Toformalizeourapproach,webeginbydefiningthecon- +pable ones without direct access to extensive training data. ceptsofweakandstrongmodels: +Our results suggest that this facilitation-based approach not A model M is considered +| | | | | | | | Definition1(WeakModel) | | | | | W | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +onlyenhancesmodelperformancebutalsoprovidesinsights +| | | | | | | | weakif,foragiventaskT | | | andperformancemetricP,M | | | | W | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intothenatureofmodelalignmentandthepotentialforscal- +| | | | | | | | achievesascoreS | | suchthatS | | < S | ,whereS | | isthe | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| ableoversightofAIsystems. | | | | | | | | | W | | W | H | H | | +human-levelperformanceonT. +Introduction Definition2(StrongModel) A model M is considered +S +| | | | | | | | strong if, | for the | same | task T | and performance | | metric | P, | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----------------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +| The rapid | advancement | of | artificial | intelligence | | (AI) sys- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | M achievesascoreS | | | suchthatS | >S | . | | | +| | | | | | | | S | | S | | S | H | | | +temshasbroughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttothefore- +| | | | | | | | The idea | of | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | involves | us- | +| ------------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ---------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | +| front of research, | | particularly | in complex | | decision-making | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ing weaker | AI systems | | to supervise | and | align | stronger | AI | +| and task | execution. | As these | systems | surpass | human-level | | | | | | | | | | +performanceinsophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralign- systems, a concept closely related to capability amplifica- +ment with human values, intentions, and ethical guidelines tion, where the goal is to create AI systems that can solve +| | | | | | | | problems | beyond | the capabilities | | of their | creators | or | train- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | +becomescrucial.Thischallengehasbeenhighlightedinre- +| | | | | | | | ers. This | concept | has its | roots | in model | compression | | and | +| ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | ------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | +| cent work | on alignment, | | such as | Reinforcement | | Learning | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | knowledge | distillation, | | where smaller, | | less capable | | models | +| from Human | Feedback | (RLHF), | | which | iteratively | refines | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | are used | to enhance | the | performance | of | larger | models. | Re- | +modelbehaviorbasedonhumanevaluations(Ghodratnama +and Zakershahrak 2024). While RLHF has shown promise cent research, such as the work by Schick and Schu¨tze on +| | | | | | | | few-shot | learning | in language | | models, | demonstrates | | how | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +inaligninglanguagemodelswithhumanintentions,itfaces +| | | | | | | | these ideas | can | be applied | to improve | | the performance | | of | +| ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| scalability | challenges | when | dealing | with | tasks | that surpass | | | | | | | | | +smallermodelswithlimiteddata. +human-levelcomplexity.Therelianceondirecthumanfeed- +FacilitationFunctionandDebate-BasedAlignmentAtthe +backbecomesabottleneck,limitingthescopeanddepthof +alignmentthatcanbeachieved. heart of our method is the facilitation function Φ, which +formalizestheprocessofknowledgetransferfromastrong +Toaddresstheselimitations,morescalableandadaptable +modeltoaweakerone: +approachesarerequired—approachesthatcanalignincreas- +| | | | | | | | Definition3(FacilitationFunc.) | | | | Φ:M | ×M | →M′ | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| *Theseauthorscontributedequally. | | | | | | | | | | | | W | S | W | +Copyright©2025,AssociationfortheAdvancementofArtificial WhereM W istheweakmodel,M S isthestrongmodel,and +Intelligence(www.aaai.org).Allrightsreserved. M′ istheenhancedweakmodel.Thefacilitationfunction +W + +isimplementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: wefosteranAIsystemthatnotonlyperformswellbutalso +| | | | | | | | | maintains | transparency | | and interpretability, | | | key factors | in | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +(cid:88) +| | argmin | | L(f | θ (q),f | θS (q)) | | (1) | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ W′ b u i ld i n gtrustandensuringlong-termalignmentwithhuman +W′ q∈Q +| | | | | | | | | va l u e s . | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WhereQisasetoftaskinstances,Lisatask-specificloss Contributions Our contributions in this paper are three- +| function, | and | f represents | | the model’s | decision-making | | | fold: | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ +functionparameterizedbyθ. +| | | | | | | | | 1. We introduce | | a novel | framework | | for model | alignment | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | +Tofurtherenhanceourapproach,weincorporatedebate- +| | | | | | | | | through | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | and | model | facil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +basedalignment,leveragingtheideathatitmaybeeasierto +itation,formalizingthefacilitationfunctionΦanditsap- +| judge the | outcome | of | a debate | than | to directly | solve | com- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +plicationtocomplexdecision-makingtasks. +| plex problems. | | This | method | uses adversarial | | dynamics | to | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +improve model alignment and capability by evaluating the 2. We present empirical results demonstrating significant +explanationsprovidedbydifferentmodels. improvements in model performance and alignment +acrossmultiplecomplextaskdomains,achievedthrough +| Definition4(DebateFunction) | | | | D :E | ×E | ×J | →R | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | S′ | W | | ourfacilitationapproach. | | | | | | | | +| WhereE | istheexplanationfunctionofthestrongmodel, | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +S′ 3. We provide an in-depth analysis of the facilitation pro- +| E is | the explanation | | function | of the | weak | model, | and J | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | +| W | | | | | | | | cess, | offering | new | perspectives | | on the nature | of | model | +| is the judge | (which | could | be | another | instance | of the | weak | | | | | | | | | +alignmentindecision-makingandthepotentialforscal- +model,ahuman,oranotherevaluationmechanism).Theout- +ableoversightofadvancedAIsystemstacklingcomplex +| put of D | is a | real number | representing | | the | quality | of the | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tasks. +strongmodel’sexplanationrelativetotheweakmodel’s,as +evaluated by the judge. This scalar output can be used as a This work represents a key component of a broader re- +reward signal in a reinforcement learning (RL) framework, search agenda aimed at developing robust, aligned AI sys- +allowingforcontinuousimprovementofthestrongmodel’s tems capable of handling increasingly complex decisions +explanatorycapabilities. and tasks. By bridging the gap between weak and strong +| | | | | | | | →M′ | models | in sophisticated | | problem-solving | | scenarios, | | we not | +| ------------------------------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | +| Definition5(AlignmentFunction) | | | | | Ψ:M S | ×M W | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | S | onlyenhancethecapabilitiesofAIsystemsbutalsoensure | | | | | | | | +| Where | M′ is | the aligned | | strong model. | This | function | is | | | | | | | | | +| | S | | | | | | | they remain | fundamentally | | aligned | | with human | values | and | +implementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: intentions. To achieve this, our approach draws on and ex- +tendsseveralfoundationalareaswithinartificialintelligence +(cid:88) +argm i n [L(f θ (q),f θW (q))+D(E S′ (q),E W (q),J)] r e se a r c h , in c lu d i n g e x p l a in a b l e AI, model alignment, and +| θ | | S′ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| S ′ | | | | | | | | la n g u a g | e m o d e l | g e ne r a | li z a ti o n | . | | | | +q∈Q +(2) +By incorporating a learned reward model over debate- RelatedWork +drivenalignment,ourframeworkcreatesadynamiclearning +Ourresearchintegratesandbuildsuponthesekeyareas,par- +| environment | that | scales | beyond | mere | decision | alignment. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ticularlyfocusingontheprogressionfromexplainableAIto +Thestrongmodelisincentivizednotonlytomakedecisions +thedevelopmentofaligned,capablelanguagemodels.This +thatalignwithhumanvaluesbutalsotoconsistentlyprovide +| | | | | | | | | section | traces how | these | concepts | interconnect, | | laying | the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +high-quality,persuasiveexplanationsthatmirrorhumanrea- +foundationforourproposedapproach. +soningprocesses. +Thepracticalimplementationofthisprocessfollowsthese +ExplanationGenerationinAI +steps: +ExplainableAI(XAI)hasbecomeacriticalareaofresearch +Algorithm1:Debate-BasedAlignmentProcess asAIsystemsincreasinglyinfluencevariousaspectsofsoci- +ety(GhodratnamaandZakershahrak2023).Gunning’swork +| Inputs: | Models | M | (strong) | and M | (weak), | Task | in- | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | S | | | W | | | (Gunning2017)definesXAIasthedevelopmentofmachine | | | | | | | | +stanceq learning models that are not only high-performing but also +| Ensure: | AlignedandimprovedstrongmodelM | | | | | S | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | interpretable | by | humans. | This | focus | on interpretability | | be- | +| 1: PresentbothmodelsM | | | | andM | withtaskinstanceq | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | S | W | | | | gan with | efforts | by Swartout | | and Moore | (1993) | to | create | +| 2: Eachmodelproducesadecisionf | | | | | (q)andanexplana- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | θ | | | expertsystemscapableofexplainingtheirdecisions.Asthe | | | | | | | | +tionE(q) +| | | | | | | | | field evolved, | the | emphasis | shifted | | from post-hoc | | explana- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +3: Evaluate explanations using the debate function tionstoinherentlyinterpretablesystems. +D(E S′ ,E W ) Notably, research by Zakershahrak et al. (Zakershahrak +| 4: JudgeJ | determineswhichexplanationissuperior | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------------------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | et al. 2020a, | 2018, | 2020b) | introduced | | progressive | | explana- | +| 5: Finetune | strong | model | M | to minimize | | decision | dis- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | S | | | | tiongenerationtechniquesthatadapttohumanunderstand- | | | | | | | | +crepanciesandimproveexplanations +| | | | | | | | | ing, aligning | closely | with | the | principles | of | Inverse | Rein- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | forcement | Learning | (IRL). | These | approaches | | often | employ | +Thisframeworkcreatesamorerobustandadaptivealign- maximumentropymethods,similartoMaxEntIRL(Ziebart +ment,wherethemodel’sabilitytoexplainitsdecisionsbe- et al. 2008), to manage the uncertainty inherent in human +| comesascrucialasthedecisionsthemselves.Consequently, | | | | | | | | preferences. | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Miller (Miller 2018) further underscored the importance FacilitationinHuman-AITeams +| of social | context | in | AI explanations, | | bridging | AI | expla- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | As AI systems | | have | become | more | advanced, | research | has | +| nations | with human-centric | | | explanation | science. | Our | work | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | increasingly | focused | | on how | these | systems | can | support | +| builds on | these | foundations | | by | incorporating | | dynamic, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | and enhance | human | | decision-making. | | This | research | aligns | +debate-styleexplanationswithinthealignmentprocess,not +| | | | | | | | | closely | with | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | by | exploring | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +onlyenhancingtransparencybutalsousingexplanationsas +howAIcanamplifyhumancapabilities.Bansaletal.(2019) +amechanismtoguideandimproveAIbehavior. +| | | | | | | | | explored | collaborative | | problem-solving | | | between | humans | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | and AI, | while | Kamar | et al. | (2012) | examined | AI-assisted | | +| ModelAlignment | | | | | | | | decision-makingprocesses. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Nancy | Cooke’s | work | on | human-AI | teams | (Cooke | et al. | +As AI systems become more sophisticated, the challenge 2013; Cooke 2015) has been pivotal in understanding the +ofaligningthesesystemswithhumanvaluesandgoalshas +dynamicsofcollaborationbetweenhumansandAI.Seeber +takencenterstage.Leikeetal.(Leikeetal.2018)definethe +etal.(Seeberetal.2020)providedacomprehensivereview +alignmentproblemasensuringthatAIsystemsconsistently +| | | | | | | | | of AI-enabled | | teamwork, | emphasizing | | the | role | of AI as a | +| ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +| pursue | the goals | intended | by | their | creators. | The | develop- | | | | | | | | | +teammemberratherthanameretool. +mentofInverseReinforcementLearning(IRL)methodsby Ourapproachleveragestheseinsightsbypositioningthe +NgandRussell(NgandRussell2000)laidthegroundwork +strongmodelasafacilitatorfortheweakermodel,enhanc- +forpreferencelearninginAI,allowingsystemstoinferand +| | | | | | | | | ing the | alignment | process | through | | structured | learning | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +adopthuman-likegoals. +debate. +| Further | advances, | such | as | cooperative | inverse | reinforce- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ment learning | | (CIRL) | explored | by | Hadfield-Menell | | et al. | | | | | | | | | +LanguageModelAlignment +(Hadfield-Menelletal.2016),modeledalignmentasacoop- +erative game between humans and AI. Stiennon et al. (Sti- Therapidadvancementsinlanguagemodelcapabilitieshave +intensifiedtheneedforrobustalignmentstrategies.TheIn- +| ennon et | al. 2020) | expanded | | on this | by demonstrating | | how | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --------- | +| | | | | | | | | structGPT | approach | | by Ouyang | | et al. | (2022) | showcased | +| summarization | | tasks | can be | used | to align | language | mod- | | | | | | | | | +elswithhumanpreferences,acrucialsteptowardsscalable how large language models could be fine-tuned to align +alignment. more closely with human instructions, representing a key +| | | | | | | | | advancement | | in scalable | alignment | | techniques. | | Bai et al. | +| -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------- | +| Our work | builds | on | these | concepts | by integrating | | weak- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | (2022) further | | contributed | to | this | field with | Constitutional | | +to-stronggeneralizationandexplanationgenerationintothe +| | | | | | | | | AI, which | incorporates | | specific | behavioral | | constraints | dur- | +| --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| alignment | process. | This | combination | | allows | us to | create a | | | | | | | | | +ingtrainingtoensurealignmentwithhumanvalues. +| more holistic | approach | | to aligning | | AI systems, | particularly | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | Anthropic’s | | ”AI | Safety | via Debate” | | research | (Irving, | +incomplextaskenvironments. +| | | | | | | | | Christiano, | and | Amodei | 2018) | introduced | | the idea | of us- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | ing debates | between | | AI systems | | as a method | for | improv- | +Weak-to-StrongGeneralization ingalignment,anapproachthatresonatesstronglywithour +| | | | | | | | | work. This | method | | leverages | adversarial | | dynamics | to en- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Theconceptofweak-to-stronggeneralization,discussedby +hancemodelcapabilitiesandensurealignment.Recentwork +Burnsetal.(Burnsetal.2023),involvesleveragingweaker +byPerezetal.(2023)ondiscoveringlanguagemodelbehav- +AIsystemstosuperviseandguidestrongerAIsystems.This +iorsusinggeneratedtaskdatasetshasprovidednewtoolsfor +paradigmisanextensionoftheideaofcapabilityamplifica- +evaluatingandimprovinglanguagemodelalignment. +| tion, where | the | goal is | to enable | AI | systems | to solve | prob- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ourresearchcomplementstheseapproachesbyintegrat- +lemsbeyondthedirectcapabilitiesoftheirdevelopers. +ingweak-to-stronggeneralizationwithdebate-drivenlearn- +| This | approach | has | its roots | in | model compression | | and | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ing. By | combining | the | strengths | of | explanation | generation, | | +knowledge distillation, as first introduced by Buciluaˇ et al. weak-to-strong generalization, and structured debates, we +(Buciluaˇ, Caruana, and Niculescu-Mizil 2006) and refined offerascalableandtransparentframeworkforensuringlan- +| by Hinton | et al. | (LeCun, | Bengio, | and | Hinton | 2015). | These | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guagemodelalignmentthatcanadapttotheincreasingcom- +methodshavebeensuccessfullyappliedinnaturallanguage +plexityofAIsystems. +processing,wherestudent-teachermodels(Sanhetal.2019) +havedemonstratedthatsmallermodelscanachievehighper- +Methodology +formancewithfewerresources.RecentworkbySchickand +Schu¨tze(Mittaletal.2023)onfew-shotlearningfurtheril- Our research explores weak-to-strong generalization as a +lustrateshowsmallermodelscanbeenhancedthrougheffi- technique for model alignment. The core idea is to use +cientlearningtechniques. +| | | | | | | | | weaker | models | to supervise | | stronger | models, | serving | as an | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +Ourframeworkextendstheseideasbyapplyingweak-to- analogy for how humans might align superhuman AI sys- +stronggeneralizationasameansofaligningAIsystems.By tems.Thisapproachallowsustostudyalignmentchallenges +incorporating structured debates and explanations, we cre- empiricallyusingcurrentmodels,whilepotentiallyyielding +ate a mechanism where weaker models can guide stronger insightsapplicabletofuture,morecapablesystems. +models, even in scenarios where the weaker model (or hu- The weak-to-strong learning process consists of three +| mansupervisor)lacksfullexpertise. | | | | | | | | mainsteps: | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +1. Create a weak supervisor by finetuning a smaller pre- Baseline Method We finetune the strong student model +trainedmodelongroundtruthlabels. on the weak labels over 2 epochs with a batch size of 32. +2. Generateweaklabelsusingthesupervisoronaheld-out Early stopping is applied based on the model’s agreement +| dataset. | | | | | | | | withweaklabelsonthevalidationset. | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Trainastrongerstudentmodelusingtheseweaklabels. +Algorithm3:BaselineStrongStudentTraining +Weevaluatethisprocessacrossmultipletaskdomainsand Inputs: Weaklabelsf (x),StrongstudentmodelM +| | | | | | | | | | | w | | | S | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +modelsizestounderstanditsscalabilityandlimitations. +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | TrainedstrongstudentmodelM | | | S | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: InitializeM | S | withpretrainedweights | | | | +ExperimentalSetup +2: foreachepochi=1to2do +Models WeusepretrainedlanguagemodelsfromtheGPT- 3: TrainM onweaklabelsf (x)withbatchsize32 +| | | | | | | | | | S | | w | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4family,whichspan7ordersofmagnitudeincompute.This 4: ifvalidationaccuracyimprovesthen +wide range allows us to analyze the performance gap be- UpdateM +| | | | | | | | | 5: | | S | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| tweenweakandstrongmodelsacrossdifferentlevelsofca- | | | | | | | | 6: else | | | | | | +pability.ThemodelsareaccessedthroughtheOpenAIAPI, 7: Applyearlystopping +| and we replace | | the unembedding | | layer | with | a task-specific | | 8: endif | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| linear classification | | head | for | each model | to | suit the | experi- | 9: endfor | | | | | | +ments. +Tasks Weevaluateourmethodsontwosettings: +| | | | | | | | | Improved | Methods | To | enhance the performance | | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ------ | +1. NaturalLanguageProcessing(NLP)benchmarks:We strongstudentmodel,weemployseveralimprovedmethods: +useasuiteof22classificationtasks,coveringareaslike +| | | | | | | | | a) Auxiliary | | Confidence | Loss: We | introduce | a | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| ethics, | commonsense | | reasoning, | | natural | language | infer- | | | | | | | +confidence-drivenlosstermthatbalancesthecross-entropy +| ence, | and sentiment | | analysis. | All | tasks | are | converted | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ---- | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | loss between | weak | label | predictions and | a thresholded | | +| to binary | classification, | | with | soft | labels | from | the weak | | | | | | | +versionofthemodel’sownpredictions. +modelusedfortraining.ThesetasksarelistedinTable1. +| 2. Chess | puzzles: | Using | the | Chess | Game | Dataset | from | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Algorithm4:AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss +Lichess(Datasnaek2021),wepredictthebestmovefor +eachposition.Thedatasetconsistsofsequencesofmoves Inputs: Model predictions f(x), Weak labels f (x), +w +| | | | | | | | | Thresholdedpredictionsf | | | (x),Weightingfactorα | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | +| leadinguptoapuzzle,formattedasinputsforourmodel. | | | | | | | | | | | t | | | +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | UpdatedmodelM | | withconfidence-drivenloss | | | +S +1: Setα=0.75forlargemodels,0.5otherwise +WeakSupervisorCreation +| | | | | | | | | 2: ComputeL | | (f)=(1−α)·CE(f(x),f | | | (x))+α· | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | | conf | | | w | | +We create weak supervisors by generating weak labels, CE(f(x),f (x)) +t +whichguidethealignmentofstrongermodels.Theprocess 3: TrainM usingL (f)withlinearwarm-upoverthe +S conf +involvesthefollowingstepsmentionedinAlgorithm2: first20%oftraining +Algorithm2:WeakLabelGenerationProcess +| | | | | | | | | b) Bootstrapping: | | Rather | than training | the | strongest | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | +Inputs: TaskdatasetD +| | | | | | | | | model directly | with | the weakest | supervisor, | we | use inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +Ensure: WeaklabelsgeneratedforD +| | | | | | | | | mediate models | in | a bootstrapping | process, | iterating | weak- | +| -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | --- | --------------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | +| 1: Split | dataset | D into | two | halves: | D and | D , | grouping | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 1 | 2 | | to-stronglearninginstages. | | | | | | +relateddatapoints +| 2: Finetune | a | smaller | pretrained | model | M | on | D using | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | W | 1 | Algorithm5:BootstrappingwithIntermediateModels | | | | | | +groundtruthlabels +3: UseM W togenerateweaklabelsforD 2 Inputs: Weak labels f w (x), Intermediate models +| | | | | | | | | M ,M | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | S1 | S2 | | S | | | +Ensure: TrainedstrongmodelM +| After generating | | weak | labels, | we | train | the weak | super- | | | | S | | | +| ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------- | ------ | -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: Foreachroundr | | =1to3: | | | | +| visor over | 2 epochs | with | a | batch | size of | 32. Early | stop- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ForeachintermediatemodelM | | | | : | | +| | | | | | | | | 2: | | | Si | | | +| ping is applied | | based | on validation | | accuracy | to ensure | the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 3: | TrainM | Si onf w | (x)andgeneratenewweaklabels | | | +| model is | properly | trained | to | produce | informative | | labels for | | | | | | | +f (x) +| thestrongermodels. | | | | | | | | wi | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 4: Train | M | on f | (x) using the | best intermediate | | +S wi +model +StrongStudentTraining +| The strong | student | model | is | trained | using | the weak | labels. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +We apply several training strategies, including a baseline c) Generative Finetuning: Before weak-to-strong train- +method and more advanced techniques to improve perfor- ing, we perform unsupervised finetuning on task-relevant +| mance. | | | | | | | | datatoimprovethemodel’srepresentationofkeyconcepts. | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| TaskName | | Source | | | | | Description | | | | | | TaskType | | +| -------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| CoLA | | Warstadtetal.,2019 | | | | | Linguisticacceptability | | | | | | Binary | | +| SST-2 | | Socheretal.,2013 | | | | | Sentimentanalysis | | | | | | Binary | | +| MRPC | | Dolan&Brockett,2005 | | | | | Paraphrasedetection | | | | | | Binary | | +| STS-B | | Ceretal.,2017 | | | | | Semantictextualsimilarity | | | | | | Regression | | +| QQP | | Quora | | | | | Questionpairsimilarity | | | | | | Binary | | +| MNLI | | Williamsetal.,2018 | | | | | Naturallanguageinference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| QNLI | | Rajpurkaretal.,2016 | | | | | QuestionansweringNLI | | | | | | Binary | | +| RTE | | Daganetal.,2006 | | | | | Recognizingtextualentailment | | | | | | Binary | | +| WNLI | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| AX | | Wangetal.,2019 | | | | | DiagnosticdatasetforMNLI | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| CB | | DeMarneffeetal.,2019 | | | | | CommitmentBank | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| COPA | | Roemmeleetal.,2011 | | | | | ChoiceofPlausibleAlternatives | | | | | | Binary | | +MultiRC Khashabietal.,2018 Multi-SentenceReadingComprehension Binary +ReCoRD Zhangetal.,2018 ReadingComprehensionwithCommonsense Binary +| WiC | | Pilehvar&Camacho-Collados,2019 | | | | | Word-in-Context | | | | | | Binary | | +| --------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| WSC | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| BoolQ | | Clarketal.,2019 | | | | | BooleanQuestions | | | | | | Binary | | +| RACE | | Laietal.,2017 | | | | | ReadingComprehension | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SciTail | | Khotetal.,2018 | | | | | ScienceQuestionAnswering | | | | | | Binary | | +| SNLI | | Bowmanetal.,2015 | | | | | NaturalLanguageInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SWAG | | Zellersetal.,2018 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| HellaSWAG | | Zellersetal.,2019 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +Table1:NLPClassificationTasks +Algorithm6:GenerativeFinetuning model size. Each stage consists of 3 iterations of weak-to- +| | | | | | | | | strong learning. | | The learning | rate | is reduced | by | a factor of | +| ------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| Inputs: | Task-relevantdataD | | | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | task | | | S | | | | | | | | | +| Ensure: | FinetunedstrongmodelM | | | | | | | 10ateachstage. | | | | | | | +S +| 1: PretrainM | | S onD task | withalanguagemodelingobjec- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | GenerativeFinetuning | | | Forgenerativefinetuning,wepre- | | | | +tive +trainthestrongmodelontask-relevant,unlabeleddatausing +| 2: Proceed | with | weak-to-strong | | training | on | weak | labels | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +alanguagemodelingobjective.Wethenfinetunethemodel +f (x) +| w | | | | | | | | usingweaklabels,withalearningrateof5e−5 | | | | | | andabatch | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +sizeof16. +These methods collectively improve the robustness and EvaluationMetrics +| accuracy | of the | strong student | | model, | enabling | better | gen- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eralization and alignment with weak labels across different 1. PerformanceGapRecovered(PGR): +tasks. +P −P +| | | | | | | | | | | PGR= | | ws w | | (3) | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DetailedMethodsDescription | | | | | | | | | | | | P s −P w | | | +Baseline Method For the baseline method, we finetune WhereP istheweak-to-strongperformance,P +| | | | | | | | | | ws | | | | | w isthe | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | +| the strong | student | model | directly | on weak | labels | generated | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | weak | performance, | | and P s | is the strong | ceiling | perfor- | +1e−4, +| by the weak | supervisor. | | We use | a learning | rate | of | a | mance. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +batchsizeof32,andapplyearlystoppingbasedonvalida- +| | | | | | | | | 2. Student-SupervisorAgreement:Thefractionoftestin- | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionaccuracy. +putswherethestrongstudentmakesthesameprediction +astheweaksupervisor. +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| method | introduces | a loss | term | that combines | | cross-entropy | | | | | | | | | +loss with confidence-based regularization. The weighting AblationStudies +factorαissetto0.5formediummodelsand0.75forlarge +| | | | | | | | | We conduct | ablation | studies | to | evaluate | the impact | of dif- | +| ------- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | +| models, | with linear | warm-up | over | the | first 20% | of training | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ferent components | | of our | method. | Specifically, | | we analyze | +epochs. +| | | | | | | | | the effect | of removing | | the auxiliary | confidence | | loss, boot- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +Bootstrapping In the bootstrapping approach, we train strapping, and generative finetuning. The results are shown +| intermediate | models | in | three | stages, | gradually | increasing | | inTable2. | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 2: Ablation Study Results: Impact of Removing Key tratesthePerformanceGapRecovered(PGR)acrossdiffer- +Components on Model Performance. The table shows ac- enttaskdomainsandmodelsizes. +curacy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) when each +componentisremoved.Lowervalueshighlightthecompo- Performance Across Tasks Figure 1 illustrates the test +nent’s importance. Auxiliary Confidence Loss and Genera- accuracy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) for our +tiveFinetuninghavethemostsignificantimpact,underscor- three task domains: NLP benchmarks, chess puzzles, and +ingtheircriticalroleintheframework’seffectiveness. ChatGPTrewardmodeling. +Method Accuracy PGR +(Without) (Without) +Aux.Confidence 0.82 0.60 +Bootstrapping 0.80 0.55 +Gen.Finetuning 0.85 0.70 +Analysis +Weconductthreetypesofanalysis: +1. Scaling Behavior: We plot PGR and test accuracy +againstsupervisorandstudentmodelsizes. +2. Error Analysis: We manually inspect cases where the +studentmodelmakesmistakes,categorizingerrortypes. +Figure 1: PGR as a function of model size for each task +3. ConceptSaliency:Wemeasuretheperformanceoflin- +domain. Higher PGR values indicate more effective weak- +ear probes on frozen model activations before and after +to-stronglearning.ThegraphshowsthatPGRgenerallyin- +weak-to-strongtraining. +creases with model size for NLP tasks, while it decreases +This methodology provides a comprehensive framework +forlargermodelsinchesstasks,indicatingscalabilitychal- +for studying weak-to-strong generalization in model align- +lenges. Reward modeling shows consistently lower PGR, +ment, incorporating various training techniques and eval- +highlightingtheneedformoreadvancedmethods. +uation metrics to assess the effectiveness of our approach +acrossdifferenttasksandmodelsizes. +ResultsandAnalysis +Our work builds upon and extends recent advancements in +language model alignment, leveraging weak-to-strong gen- +eralizationtechniques to address the challengesof aligning +increasinglycomplexAIsystems. +Toverifytherobustnessofourresults,weconductpaired +t-testscomparingtheperformanceofdifferentmethods.The +resultsarepresentedinTable3. +Table 3: Statistical Significance of Method Improvements. +P-values for paired t-tests comparing the baseline method +to each enhanced approach in terms of Accuracy and Per- +formance Gap Recovered (PGR). Lower p-values (< 0.05) +indicatestatisticallysignificantimprovementsoverthebase- Figure 2: Accuracy as a function of model size for each +line,withBootstrappingshowingthemostsignificantgains. task domain. Weak-to-strong generalization improves per- +formance across all tasks, with NLP achieving the highest +Comparison P-value P-value accuracy.ChessandRewardModelingshowdiminishingre- +(Accuracy) (PGR) turnswithlargermodels,highlightingchallengesinscaling +Baselinevs.Aux.Confidence 0.03 0.01 theapproachtomorecomplextasksandareasforfuturere- +Baselinevs.Bootstrapping 0.003 0.002 search +Baselinevs.Gen.Finetuning 0.01 0.01 +NLP tasks: We observe promising weak-to-strong gen- +eralization, with PGR often exceeding 50% for the largest +BaselineWeak-to-StrongGeneralization +student models. Chess puzzles: PGR is high for small +Our initial experiments demonstrate that strong pretrained supervisor-student gaps but decreases for larger gaps. Re- +modelscannaturallygeneralizebeyondtheirweaksupervi- ward modeling: Weak-to-strong generalization is poor by +sorswhennaivelyfinetunedonweaklabels.Figure1illus- default,withPGRrarelyexceeding20%. + +Scaling Behavior We find that PGR generally increases AnalysisofGeneralizationMechanisms +| with both | weak | supervisor | size and | strong | student | size for | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Imitation | vs. | Generalization | | We | analyze | student- | | +NLPtasks.However,forchesspuzzles,PGRdecreaseswith +| | | | | | | | supervisor | agreement | to | understand | | the extent | of imitation | | +| -------------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | +| strong student | size | for a | given | weak supervisor. | | Reward | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | versus true | generalization, | | | illustrated | in | Figure | 3. The | +modelingshowspoorscalingbehavioroverall. +| | | | | | | | student-supervisor | | agreement | | trends | corroborate | our | sta- | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------------ | ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | +| Our findings | on | scaling | behavior | align | with the | observa- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tistical | significance | results | (Table | | 3), providing | | insights | +tionsof(Baietal.2022)intheirworkonConstitutionalAI, +| | | | | | | | into the | effectiveness | | of different | weak-to-strong | | learning | | +| ---------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| suggesting | that | alignment | techniques | must | adapt | as model | | | | | | | | | +methods. +capabilitiesincrease. +| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Figure | 3, all | methods | exhibit | decreasing | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | agreement | rates | as model | size | increases, | but | to varying | de- | +ImprovedWeak-to-StrongGeneralizationMethods +grees.Thisgeneraltrendsuggeststhatlargermodelstendto +Drawing inspiration from ”AI Safety via Debate” frame- diverge more from the weak supervisor’s predictions, indi- +work (Irving, Christiano, and Amodei 2018), we explore cating potential generalization beyond the initial weak su- +| methods | to enhance | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | through | pervision. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +adversarialdynamicsandstructuredlearning. +Notably,theBootstrappingmethoddemonstratesthemost +substantialdecreaseinagreementacrossmodelsizes(from +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | -------- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | 0.88 for | small | models | to 0.75 | for large | models). | This | pro- | +| significantly | improves | weak-to-strong | | generalization, | | par- | | | | | | | | | +nounceddeclinealignswithitslowestp-valuesinourstatis- +ticularlyforNLPtasks. +| | | | | | | | tical significance | | tests | (p = 0.003 | for | accuracy, | p = | 0.002 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | for PGR), | suggesting | that | Bootstrapping | | is | particularly | ef- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +• Forthelargestsupervisor-studentgaps,medianPGRin- fective at enabling the model to surpass the weak supervi- +| creases | from | about 25% | to nearly | 80% | with | the confi- | sor’sperformance. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +denceloss. The Auxiliary Confidence and Generative Finetuning +• The improvement is most pronounced for large gaps in methods show moderate decreases in agreement (0.89 to +computebetweenweakandstrongmodels. 0.80and0.89to0.79,respectively),consistentwiththeirin- +| | | | | | | | termediate | p-values. | These | methods | | appear | to strike | a bal- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | +This approach can be seen as an extension of the debate ancebetweenleveragingweaksupervisionandencouraging +framework, encouraging models to make confident predic- independentgeneralization. +tionswhilestillleveragingweaksupervision. +Incontrast,theBaselinemethodmaintainsrelativelyhigh +| | | | | | | | agreement | across | all model | sizes | (0.90 | to 0.87), | indicating | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Bootstrapping | | Bootstrappingshowspromisingresultsfor | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that without | additional | | techniques, | | larger | models | tend to | +chesspuzzlesbutyieldslimitedimprovementsforNLPand +morecloselymimictheweaksupervisor,potentiallyinclud- +rewardmodelingtasks. +ingitserrors. +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | These | findings | suggest | that | our enhanced | | methods, | par- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | +• Bootstrapping improves PGR compared to the baseline, ticularlyBootstrapping,aremoreeffectiveatenablingmod- +especiallyforlargerstudentmodels. elstogeneralizebeyondtheweaksupervisor’scapabilities. +Thedecreasingagreementrates,coupledwithimprovedper- +| • The | accuracy | continues | to monotonically | | improve | with | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bootstrapping,unliketheflatteningobservedinthenaive formance(asindicatedbylowerp-values),demonstratethat +thesemethodsfacilitatethedevelopmentofmodelsthatcan +method. +| | | | | | | | leverage | weak | supervision | while | still | developing | indepen- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +The bootstrapping method resonates with the iterative dentandpotentiallysuperiordecision-makingcapabilities. +| refinement | processes | suggested | in | Constitutional | | AI (Bai | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----- | --------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | Larger | student | models | show | lower | agreement | with | weak | +etal.2022),allowingforgradualimprovementofalignment +| | | | | | | | supervisors, | suggesting | | less imitation | | of errors. | The | auxil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +acrossmodelscales. iary confidenceloss furtherreduces imitationof supervisor +mistakes. +| Generative | Finetuning | | Generative | finetuning | | on reward | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | These | findings | contribute | | to our | understanding | | of how | +| modeling | data improves | | weak-to-strong | | performance | and | | | | | | | | | +modelsbalanceimitationandtruegeneralization,akeycon- +PGR. +cerninscalingalignmenttechniques(Ouyangetal.2022). +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | ConceptSaliency | | Weinvestigatethelinearrepresentabil- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• PGRimprovesbyapproximately10-20%withgenerative +| | | | | | | | ity of desired | | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +finetuning. +learning.Figure4illustratesthechangeinlinearprobeper- +• Theimprovementstackswithearly-stoppingtechniques, +| | | | | | | | formance | for key | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +achievingPGRof30-40%. +learning. +This technique builds on the insights from (Dehghani Finetuningonweaklabelsincreasesthelinearseparability +et al. 2017; Pe´rez-D’Arpino, Khurshid, and Shah 2020) on ofgroundtruthconcepts.Thissuggeststhatweak-to-strong +discovering and shaping language model behaviors, using learning may help make desired concepts more salient in +| task-relevantdatatoenhancealignment. | | | | | | | modelrepresentations. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Figure3:Student-supervisoragreementacrossmodelsizesfordifferentweak-to-strongmethods.Decliningagreementinboot- +strapping and Auxiliary confidence suggests improved generalization, while the baseline method remains stable, indicating +limitedgeneralization. +| This analysis | provides | | insights | into how | weak-to-strong | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | +learningmayhelpinshapingmodelbehavior,complement- +ingtheworkonConstitutionalAI(Baietal.2022)ininstill- +ingdesiredconceptsandvalues. +ErrorAnalysis +| We conducted | a detailed | | error analysis | | on cases | where the | +| ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +strongstudentmodelmakesmistakes.Commonerrortypes +include: +• Poorquoteselection(forNLPtasks) +| • Inability | to extract | key | evidence | from | weak | supervision | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | +(forrewardmodeling) +• Overfittingtoweaklabelerrors(acrossalltasks) +Ourerroranalysisbuildsontheframeworkofdebate(Irv- +ing,Christiano,andAmodei2018),identifyingareaswhere +| adversarial | dynamics | can | be leveraged | | to improve | model | +| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | +performanceandalignment. +| To better | understand | | the types | of errors | made | by the | +| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | +Figure4:Conceptsaliencybeforeandafterweak-to-strong +learningforkeyNLPconcepts.Thefigureshowsimproved strong student model, we present the distribution of error +linearprobeperformance,indicatingenhancedmodelrepre- typesinFigure5. +sentationsacrossallconcepts.LargergainsinSentimentvs. +DiscussionandConclusion +Intentsuggestthatweak-to-stronglearningaffectsdifferent +aspects of language understanding to varying degrees, pro- Ourworkdemonstratestheeffectivenessofweak-to-strong +vidinginsightsforfutureimprovements. generalization in language models for model alignment. +| The proposed | framework, | | which | combines | facilitation | and | +| ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | +| debate-based | learning, | shows | promise | in | enhancing | model | +| performance | and | alignment | across | various | tasks. | Through | + +| | | | | | | | • While an | improvement | over | baseline | approaches, | | naive | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | +finetuningonweaksupervisionisinsufficienttofullyre- +coverstrongmodelperformance,indicatingtheneedfor +moresophisticatedtransfertechniques. +| | | | | | | | • Generalization | remains | inconsistent | | across | tasks, | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | complex | domains like | reward | modeling | | proving | partic- | +ularlychallenging.Thishighlightstheneedformorero- +bustandadaptivealignmenttechniques. +• Ourcurrentsetup,thoughanadvancementoverprevious +| | | | | | | | methods, | may not fully | capture | the | difficulties | | of align- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +ingsuperhumanAIsystems,suchasthepotentialeaseof +imitatinghuman-levelerrors. +Theselimitationspointtoseveralpromisingdirectionsfor +Figure5:Distributionoferrortypesfromtheerroranalysis. +futurework: +Thechartshowsthatpoorquoteselectionandevidenceex- +| | | | | | | | • Developing | more sophisticated | | | debate | mechanisms | to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +tractionaccountfor70%oferrors,suggestingimprovements +enhancethequalityandefficiencyofknowledgetransfer +| in identifying | relevant | information | | could enhance | weak-to- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweenmodelsofvaryingcapabilities. +stronglearning.Overfittingerrors(20%)arerelativelylow, +indicating the approach generally succeeds in generalizing • Exploringtheintegrationofourapproachwithotherscal- +beyondweaklabels,thoughfurtherimprovementispossible +| | | | | | | | able oversight | methods | to | create | more | comprehensive | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | +alignmentframeworks. +| | | | | | | | • Investigating | the application | | of this | framework | | to even | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | +| our experiments | | and analysis, | we | have gained | several | key | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | more advanced | AI | systems | and diverse | | task domains | to | +insightsintothenatureofmodelalignmentthroughfacilita- +testitsscalabilityandgeneralizability. +tion: +• Refiningourunderstandingofmodelbehaviorandalign- +| 1. Strong | models | demonstrate | a remarkable | | ability | to gen- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | ment across | increasing | scales | of | capability | to | better ad- | +| eralize | beyond | weak supervision, | | particularly | | in NLP | | | | | | | | +dressthechallengesofaligningsuperhumanAIsystems. +| tasks, | suggesting | the potential | | for knowledge | | transfer | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +acrossdifferentcapabilitylevels. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that weak-to- +2. The introduction of auxiliary confidence loss signif- strong generalization is a promising approach for model +icantly improves generalization, especially for large alignment,capableofelicitingstrongcapabilitiesfromlim- +| supervisor-student | | gaps, | highlighting | the | importance | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ited supervision. | By bridging | | the gap | between | explanation | | +calibratedconfidenceinthealignmentprocess. generationandmodelalignment,ourframeworkopensnew +3. Techniquessuchasbootstrappingandgenerativefinetun- avenues for creating AI systems that are not only powerful +ing show potential in addressing domain-specific chal- but also fundamentally aligned with human values and in- +tentions.Whilesignificantchallengesremaininscalingthis +lenges,asevidencedbytheireffectivenessinchesspuz- +approachtomorecomplextasksandtrulysuperhumanmod- +zlesandrewardmodelingtasks. +4. Thelearningprocessrequiresadelicatebalancebetween els,theinsightsgainedfromthisworkprovideasolidfoun- +dationforfutureresearchinAIalignmentandsafety. +imitationandtruegeneralization,emphasizingthecom- +| plexity | of aligning | AI | systems | with human | values | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| intentions. | | | | | | | | | References | | | | | +Compared to traditional explanation generation ap- Bai, Y.; Kadavath, S.; Kundu, S.; Askell, A.; Kernion, J.; +proaches,ourframeworkoffersseveraladvantages: Jones,A.;Chen,A.;Goldie,A.;Mirhoseini,A.;McKinnon, +C.;etal.2022.Constitutionalai:Harmlessnessfromaifeed- +• ItprovidesamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +back. arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.08073. +capabilitiesevolve,addressingthescalabilitychallenges +facedbycurrentmethodslikeRLHF. Buciluaˇ, C.; Caruana, R.; and Niculescu-Mizil, A. 2006. +• Thedebate-basedcomponentenhancestransparencyand Model compression. In Proceedings of the 12th ACM +interpretability, allowing for more nuanced oversight of SIGKDDinternationalconferenceonKnowledgediscovery +| thealignmentprocess. | | | | | | | anddatamining,535–541. | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• By leveraging both weak and strong models, our ap- Burns, C.; Izmailov, P.; Kirchner, J. H.; Baker, B.; Gao, +proachpotentiallyovercomeslimitationsofhumanover- L.; Aschenbrenner, L.; Chen, Y.; Ecoffet, A.; Joglekar, M.; +sightincomplextasks. Leike,J.;etal.2023. Weak-to-stronggeneralization:Elicit- +ingstrongcapabilitieswithweaksupervision.arXivpreprint +| However, | despite | these | promising | results, | several | limita- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionsandchallengesremain,echoingconcernsidentifiedin arXiv:2312.09390. +recent alignment research (Ouyang et al. 2022; Bai et al. Cooke,N.J.2015. Teamcognitionasinteraction. Current +2022;Pe´rez-D’Arpino,Khurshid,andShah2020): directionsinpsychologicalscience,24(6):415–419. + +Cooke,N.J.;Gorman,J.C.;Myers,C.W.;andDuran,J.L. Stiennon, N.; Ouyang, L.; Wu, J.; Ziegler, D.; Lowe, R.; +2013. Interactiveteamcognition. Cognitivescience,37(2): Voss, C.; Radford, A.; Amodei, D.; and Christiano, P. F. +| 255–285. | | | | | | | 2020. | Learning | to | summarize | with | human | feedback. | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Advances | in Neural | | Information | Processing | | Systems, | 33: | +Datasnaek.2021.ChessGameDataset(Lichess).Accessed: +3008–3021. +2024-08-09. +Zakershahrak,M.;Gong,Z.;Sadassivam,N.;andZhang,Y. +Dehghani,M.;Severyn,A.;Rothe,S.;andKamps,J.2017. +2020a. Onlineexplanationgenerationforplanningtasksin +Learningtolearnfromweaksupervisionbyfullsupervision. +human-robotteaming.In2020IEEE/RSJInternationalCon- +arXivpreprintarXiv:1711.11383. +| | | | | | | | ference | on Intelligent | | Robots | and Systems | (IROS), | | 6304– | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| Ghodratnama, | S.; | and | Zakershahrak, | M. | 2023. | Adapt- | 6310.IEEE. | | | | | | | | +ingLLMsforEfficient,PersonalizedInformationRetrieval: +| | | | | | | | Zakershahrak, | | M.; Marpally, | | S. R.; Sharma, | | A.; Gong, | Z.; | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | +| Methods | and Implications. | | In | International | Conference | on | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Zhang, | Y. | 2020b. | Order | Matters: | Generating | | Pro- | +Service-OrientedComputing,17–26.Springer. +| | | | | | | | gressive | Explanations | | for Planning | Tasks | in | Human-Robot | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| Ghodratnama,S.;andZakershahrak,M.2024. | | | | | SumRecom: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Teaming. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2004.07822. | | | | | | | +APersonalizedSummarizationApproachbyLearningfrom Zakershahrak, M.; Sonawane, A.; Gong, Z.; and Zhang, Y. +| Users’Feedback. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2408.07294. | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2018.Interactiveplanexplicabilityinhuman-robotteaming. +Gunning, D. 2017. Explainable artificial intelligence (xai). In 2018 27th IEEE International Symposium on Robot and +Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), nd HumanInteractiveCommunication(RO-MAN),1012–1017. +| Web. | | | | | | | IEEE. | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Hadfield-Menell,D.;Russell,S.J.;Abbeel,P.;andDragan, Ziebart, B. D.; Maas, A.; Bagnell, J. A.; and Dey, A. K. +A. 2016. Cooperative inverse reinforcement learning. In 2008. MaximumEntropyInverseReinforcementLearning. +Advances in neural information processing systems, 3909– InProceedingsofthe23rdNationalConferenceonArtificial +Intelligence-Volume3,AAAI’08,1433–1438.AAAIPress. +3917. +Irving, G.; Christiano, P.; and Amodei, D. 2018. AI safety ISBN9781577353683. +| viadebate. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1805.00899. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| LeCun,Y.;Bengio,Y.;andHinton,G.2015. | | | | | Deeplearning. | | | | | | | | | | +nature,521(7553):436–444. +Leike,J.;Krueger,D.;Everitt,T.;Martic,M.;Maini,V.;and +| Legg,S.2018. | Scalableagentalignmentviarewardmodel- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ing:aresearchdirection. | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:1811.07871. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Miller, | T. 2018. | Explanation | | in artificial | intelligence: | In- | | | | | | | | | +| sightsfromthesocialsciences. | | | | ArtificialIntelligence. | | | | | | | | | | | +Mittal,A.;Schick,T.;Artetxe,M.;andDwivedi-Yu,J.2023. +| Evaluation | of Faithfulness | | Using | the | Longest | Supported | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Subsequence. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2308.12157. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Ng, A. | Y.; and Russell, | | S. J. 2000. | Algorithms | | for Inverse | | | | | | | | | +InICML,663–670.MorganKauf- +ReinforcementLearning. +mannPublishersInc. +Ouyang,L.;Wu,J.;Jiang,X.;Almeida,D.;Wainwright,C.; +| Mishkin, | P.; Zhang, | C.; | Agarwal, | S.; Slama, | K.; | Ray, A.; | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| etal.2022. | Traininglanguagemodelstofollowinstructions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| withhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralinformationpro- | | | | | | | | | | | | +cessingsystems,35:27730–27744. +Pe´rez-D’Arpino,C.;Khurshid,R.P.;andShah,J.A.2020. +| Experimental | Assessment | | of | Human-Robot | Teaming | for | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Multi-Step | Remote | Manipulation | | with | Expert | Operators. | | | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2011.10898. +| Sanh,V.;Debut,L.;Chaumond,J.;andWolf,T.2019. | | | | | | Dis- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tilBERT,adistilledversionofBERT:smaller,faster,cheaper +| andlighter. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1910.01108. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Seeber, | I.; Bittner, | E.; | Briggs, | R. O.; | De Vreede, | T.; | | | | | | | | | +DeVreede,G.-J.;Elkins,A.;Maier,R.;Merz,A.B.;Oeste- +| Reiß,S.;Randrup,N.;etal.2020. | | | | Machinesasteammates: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| AresearchagendaonAIinteamcollaboration. | | | | | | Information | | | | | | | | | +&management,57(2):103174. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k2/random_2.md b/q79/random_k2/random_2.md index 4bcaaffd0140b439e3111b15be90b5099749743d..032ac202436081f4b3d557a79c59bb0d7084141b 100644 --- a/q79/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q79/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,3187 +1,1430 @@ -School Meals Programs and Other USDA -Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated August 24, 2018 - -Congressional Research Service - -https://crsreports.congress.gov - -R43783 - -{222A0E69-13A2-4985-84AE-73CC3DFF4D02}-R-008032105221177189069140163240174026137243109106239050005249089181035110184065171150222238050143170044130075151022235203179242176047216087082047088140020229001139009183064080176154202161058046029022041045101112067071229147068138195245121093 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summary -The “child nutrition programs” refer to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition -Service (USDA-FNS) programs that provide food for children in school or institutional settings. -The best known programs, which serve the largest number of children, are the school meals -programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). -The child nutrition programs also include the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), -which provides meals and snacks in day care and after school settings; the Summer Food Service -Program (SFSP), which provides food during the summer months; the Special Milk Program -(SMP), which supports milk for schools that do not participate in NSLP or SBP; and the Fresh -Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP), which funds fruit and vegetable snacks in select elementary -schools. - -Funding: The vast majority of the child nutrition programs account is considered mandatory -spending, with trace amounts of discretionary funding for certain related activities. Referred to as -open-ended, “appropriated entitlements,” funding is provided through the annual appropriations -process; however, the level of spending is controlled by benefit and eligibility criteria in federal -law and dependent on the resulting levels of participation. Federal cash funding (in the form of -per-meal reimbursements) and USDA commodity food support is guaranteed to schools and other -providers based on the number of meals or snacks served and participant category (e.g., free -meals for poor children get higher subsidies). - -Participation: The child nutrition programs serve children of varying ages and in different -institutional settings. The NSLP and SBP have the broadest reach, serving qualifying children of -all ages in school settings. Other child nutrition programs serve more-narrow populations. -CACFP, for example, provides meals and snacks to children in early childhood and after-school -settings among other venues. Programs generally provide some subsidy for all food served but a -larger federal reimbursement for food served to children from low-income households. - -Administration: Responsibility for child nutrition programs is divided between the federal -government, states, and localities. The state agency and type of local provider differs by program. -In the NSLP and SBP, schools and school districts (“school food authorities”) administer the -program. Meanwhile, SFSP (and sometimes CACFP) uses a model in which sponsor -organizations handle administrative responsibilities for a number of sites that serve meals. - -Reauthorization: The underlying laws covering the child nutrition programs were last -reauthorized in the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296, enacted -December 13, 2010). This law made significant changes to child nutrition programs, including -increasing federal financing for school lunches, expanding access to community eligibility and -direct certification options for schools, and expanding eligibility options for home child care -providers. The law also required an update to school meal nutrition guidelines as well as new -guidelines for food served outside the meal programs (e.g., snacks sold in vending machines and -cafeteria a la carte lines). - -Current Issues: The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition -reauthorization (see CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An -Overview). As of the date of this report, there has been no significant legislative activity with -regard to reauthorization in the 115th Congress. However, the vast majority of operations and -activities continue with funding provided by appropriations laws. Current issues in the child -nutrition programs for policymakers include the implementation of new and updated nutrition -standards, alternatives to the “congregate feeding” requirement in the SFSP, and schools’ efforts -to collect unpaid school meal fees (stigmatizing practices are sometimes called “lunch shaming”). - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Contents - -Introduction and Background .......................................................................................................... 1 -Authorization and Reauthorization ........................................................................................... 2 -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local .................................................................. 3 -Funding Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3 -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding ............................................................... 3 -Other Federal Funding ........................................................................................................ 5 -State, Local, and Participant Funds ..................................................................................... 5 -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ....................................................................................... 5 -Links to Resources .................................................................................................................... 7 -School Meals Programs ................................................................................................................... 7 -General Characteristics ............................................................................................................. 7 -School Meals Eligibility Rules .................................................................................................. 9 -Income Eligibility ............................................................................................................. 10 -Categorical Eligibility ........................................................................................................ 11 -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) ........................................................................... 13 -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) ................................................................................ 15 -School Breakfast Program (SBP) ............................................................................................ 16 -Other Child Nutrition Programs .................................................................................................... 17 -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) ...................................................................... 17 -CACFP at Centers ............................................................................................................. 18 -CACFP for Day Care Homes ............................................................................................ 19 -Summer Meals ........................................................................................................................ 20 -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP)............................................................................ 21 -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option ......................................................................... 22 -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration ....................................................................... 22 -Special Milk Program (SMP) .................................................................................................. 23 -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) ............................................................................ 23 -Other Topics .................................................................................................................................. 24 -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options ....................................................... 24 -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities ............................................................ 26 -Selected Current Issues ................................................................................................................. 28 -Regulations on Nutrition Standards ........................................................................................ 28 -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast ..................................................... 28 -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools .................................................. 30 -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP ......................................................................... 31 -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals ....................................................... 31 -Current Law and Policy .................................................................................................... 32 -Congressional Proposals ................................................................................................... 33 -Presidential Budget Proposals ........................................................................................... 34 -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” ......................................................................... 34 - -Figures - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs ............................... 9 -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals ........................... 13 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation ............................................... 15 -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation ......................................................... 17 - -Tables - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ............................................................................... 5 -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP .......................... 11 -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs ...................... 25 - -Table A-1. Acronyms ..................................................................................................................... 37 -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches ....................................................................... 38 -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks .................................................... 38 -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP ......................................................................................... 39 -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) ....................................... 39 -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School - -Programs .................................................................................................................................... 39 -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes .................................................... 39 -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP ....................................................................................... 40 -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP ........................................................................................ 40 - -Appendixes - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report ................................................................................ 37 -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement Rates for Child Nutrition Programs ........... 38 - -Contacts - -Author Information ........................................................................................................................ 41 -Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 41 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Introduction and Background -The federal child nutrition programs provide assistance to schools and other institutions in the -form of cash, commodity food, and administrative support (such as technical assistance and -administrative funding) based on the provision of meals and snacks to children.1 In general, these -programs were created (and amended over time) to both improve children’s nutrition and provide -support to the agriculture economy. - -Today, the child nutrition programs refer primarily to the following meal, snack, and milk -reimbursement programs (these and other acronyms are listed in Appendix A):2 - - National School Lunch Program (NSLP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1751 et seq.)); - - School Breakfast Program (SBP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 4 (42 U.S.C. - -1773)); - - Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) (Richard B. Russell National - -School Lunch Act, Section 17 (42 U.S.C. 1766)); - - Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act, Section 13 (42 U.S.C. 1761)); and - - Special Milk Program (SMP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 3 (42 U.S.C. - -1772)). - -The programs provide financial support and/or foods to the institutions that prepare meals and -snacks served outside of the home (unlike other food assistance programs such as the -Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program [SNAP, formerly the Food Stamp Program] where -benefits are used to purchase food for home consumption). Though exact eligibility rules and -pricing vary by program, in general the amount of federal reimbursement is greater for meals -served to qualifying low-income individuals or at qualifying institutions, although most programs -provide some subsidy for all food served. Participating children receive subsidized meals and -snacks, which may be free or at reduced price. Forthcoming sections discuss how program- -specific eligibility rules and funding operate. - -This report describes how each program operates under current law, focusing on eligibility rules, -participation, and funding. This introductory section describes some of the background and -principles that generally apply to all of the programs; subsequent sections go into further detail on -the workings of each. - -Unless stated otherwise, participation and funding data come from USDA-FNS’s “Keydata -Reports.”3 - -1 As discussed later in the report, the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) also supports food in adult day -care facilities, but the child nutrition programs overwhelmingly serve children. -2 Some lists also include the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) (Richard B. Russell National School Lunch -Act, Section 19 (42 U.S.C. 1769a)), a newer program that is financed in a much different way than the programs listed. -FFVP is discussed further later in the report (“Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program”). WIC (the Special Supplemental -Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. -WIC is not one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report. -3 This CRS report uses the May 2018 report, which contains data through March 2018. Keydata Reports available at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -1 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Authorization and Reauthorization - -The child nutrition programs are most often dated back to the 1946 enactment of the National -School Lunch Act, which created the National School Lunch Program, albeit in a different form -than it operates today.4 Most of the child nutrition programs do not date back to 1946; they were -added and amended in the decades to follow as policymakers expanded child nutrition programs’ -institutional settings and meals provided: - - The Special Milk Program was created in 1954, regularly extended, and made - -permanent in 1970.5 - - The School Breakfast Program was piloted in 1966, regularly extended, and - -eventually made permanent in 1975.6 - - A program for child care settings and summer programs was piloted in 1968, - -with separate programs authorized in 1975 and then made permanent in 1978.7 -These are now the Child and Adult Care Food Program8 and Summer Food -Service Program. - - The Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program began as a pilot in 2002 and was made - -permanent in 2008.9 - -The programs are now authorized under three major federal statutes: the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (originally enacted as the National School Lunch Act in 1946), the -Child Nutrition Act (originally enacted in 1966), and Section 32 of the act of August 24, 1935 (7 -U.S.C. 612c).10 Congressional jurisdiction over the underlying three laws has typically been -exercised by the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee; the House Education and -the Workforce Committee; and, to a limited extent (relating to commodity food assistance and -Section 32 issues), the House Agriculture Committee. - -Congress periodically reviews and reauthorizes expiring authorities under these laws. The child -nutrition programs were most recently reauthorized in 2010 through the Healthy, Hunger-Free -Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296); some of the authorities created or extended in that law -expired on September 30, 2015.11 WIC (the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, - -4 P.L. 79-396. There were, however, a number of smaller, more temporary precursor school food programs prior to -1946; see Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. The 1946 law supported school lunch programs by giving formula grant funding -to states based on factors such as per capita income, rather than the current-day open-ended entitlements based largely -on eligibility and participation rules. -5 P.L. 83-690 and P.L. 91-295. Milk purchases and donations for schools did exist prior to the 1954 law. -6 Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. -7 P.L. 90-302, P.L. 94-105, P.L. 95-627. Institute of Medicine, Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary -Guidance for All, 2011, p. 30, https://www.nap.edu/catalog/12959/child-and-adult-care-food-program-aligning-dietary- -guidance-for. -8 Adult day care was added in 1987 (Older Americans Act Amendments of 1987; P.L. 100-175). -9 P.L. 107-171 and P.L. 110-246. -10 In 1999, P.L. 106-78 renamed the National School Lunch Act in Senator Richard B. Russell’s honor. -11 Reimbursements for NSLP, SBP, CACFP, SMP, and certain related USDA activities are permanently authorized. -SFSP, WIC, and WIC Farmers Market Nutrition Program, State Administrative Expenses (discussed in “Related -Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities”), and certain related USDA activities have a September 30, 2015 -expiration. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -2 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. WIC is not -one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report.12 - -The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition reauthorization (see CRS -Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview). As of the date -of this report, the committees of jurisdiction have not conducted reauthorization hearings or -markups in the 115th Congress. - -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local - -The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition Service (USDA-FNS) administers the -programs at the federal level. The programs are operated by a wide variety of local public and -private providers and the degree of direct state involvement differs by program and state.13 At the -state level, education, health, social services, and agriculture departments all have roles; at a -minimum, they are responsible for approving and overseeing local providers such as schools, -summer program sponsors, and child care centers and day care homes, as well as making sure -they receive the federal support they are due. At the local level, program benefits are provided to -millions of children (e.g., there were 30.0 million in the National School Lunch Program, the -largest of the programs, in FY2017), through some 100,000 public and private schools and -residential child care institutions, nearly 170,000 child care centers and family day care homes, -and just over 50,000 summer program sites. - -All programs are available in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Virtually all operate in -Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands (and, in differing versions, in the Northern Marianas -and American Samoa).14 - -Funding Overview - -This section summarizes the nature and extent to which the programs’ funding is mandatory and -discretionary, including a discussion of appropriated entitlement status. Table 3 lists child -nutrition program and related expenditures. - -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding - -Most spending for child nutrition programs is provided in annual appropriations acts to fulfill the -legal financial obligation established by the authorizing laws. That is, the level of spending for -such programs, referred to as appropriated mandatory spending, is not controlled through the -annual appropriations process, but instead is derived from the benefit and eligibility criteria -specified in the authorizing laws. The appropriated mandatory funding is treated as mandatory -spending. Further, if Congress does not appropriate the funds necessary to fund the program, -eligible entities may have legal recourse.15 Congress considers the Administration’s forecast for - -12 See CRS Report R44115, A Primer on WIC: The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and -Children. -13 In the past, the federal government (via USDA-FNS) has, for certain states, taken the place of state agencies (e.g., -where a state has chosen not to operate a specific program or where there is a state prohibition on aiding private -schools). -14 For more information on child nutrition programs in the Northern Marianas and American Samoa, see U.S. -Department of the Interior, Office of Insular Affairs, Region IX Federal Regional Council, Outer Pacific Committee, -FY 2016 Report on Federal Financial Assistance to the U.S. Pacific and Caribbean Islands, May 1, 2017, p. 10, -https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/fy16-report-on-federal-financial-assistance-to-the-insular-areas.pdf. -15 GAO Budget Glossary, p. 13: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-05-734SP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -3 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -program needs in its appropriations decisions. For the majority of funding discussed in this report, -the formula that controls the funding is not capped and fluctuates based on the reimbursement -rates and the number of meals/snacks served in the programs. - -Cash Reimbursements and Commodity Foods - -In the meal service programs, such as the National School Lunch Program, School Breakfast -Program, summer programs, and assistance for child care centers and day care homes, federal aid -is provided in the form of statutorily set subsidies (reimbursements) paid for each meal/snack -served that meets federal nutrition guidelines. Although all (including full-price) meals/snacks -served by participating providers are subsidized, those served free or at a reduced price to lower- -income children are supported at higher rates. All federal meal/snack subsidy rates are indexed -annually (each July) for inflation, as are the income eligibility thresholds for free and reduced- -price meals/snacks.18 Subsequent sections discuss how a specific program’s eligibility and -reimbursements work. - -Most subsidies are cash payments to -schools or other providers, but a smaller -portion of aid is provided in the form of -USDA-purchased commodity foods.19 -Laws for three child nutrition programs -(NSLP, CACFP, and SFSP) require the -provision of commodity foods (or in -some cases allow cash in lieu of -commodity foods).20 - -Meal and snack service entails non-food -costs. Federal child nutrition per- -meal/snack subsidies may be used to -cover local providers’ administrative -and operating costs. However, the -separate direct federal payments for -administrative/operating costs (“State - -Reimbursable Meals - -A “reimbursable meal” (or snack in the case of some -programs) is a phrase used by USDA, state, and other child -nutrition policy and program operators to indicate a meal (or -snack) that meets federal requirements and thereby qualifies -for meal reimbursement.16 -In general, a meal or snack that is reimbursable means that it is - - - - - -served to the correctly eligible person and/or at the -eligible institution, and - -in compliance with federal nutrition requirements for the -meal or snack.17 - -In the school meals programs (with some variation in other -programs), the highest reimbursement is paid for meals served -free to eligible children, a slightly lower reimbursement is paid -for meals served at a reduced price to eligible children, and a -much smaller reimbursement is also paid for meals served to -children who are either ineligible for assistance or not -certified. For this last group, the children pay the full price as -advertised but meals are still technically subsidized. - -16 See, for example, definition of “reimbursement” at 7 C.F.R. 210.2. -17 The authorizing statutes for all four of the main child nutrition programs include nutritional requirements for the -meals and snacks served; these are sometimes referred to as “nutrition standards,” “nutrition guidelines,” or “meal -patterns.” In most respects, the details of the requirements are specified in USDA-FNS regulations. The nutrition -guidelines differ by program, largely in consideration of the age groups fed, meals/snacks authorized, and perhaps the -settings in which meals are served. See program regulations for nutritional requirements: NSLP, 7 C.F.R. 210.10; SBP, -7 C.F.R. 220.8; CACFP, 7 C.F.R. 226.20; SFSP, 7 C.F.R. 225.16. Recent updates of school meals and CACFP -nutrition standards are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” -18 Per-meal subsidies paid to providers (e.g., schools, child care centers) are indexed annually based on the CPI-U Food -Away from Home Component. For family child care homes, the annual indexing is based on the CPI-U Food at Home -Component. -19 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information, see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -20 See USDA-FNS Food Distribution Division resources for more information on USDA Foods and child nutrition - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -4 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Administrative Expenses,” discussed in the “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities” section) are limited. - -Other Federal Funding - -In addition to the open-ended, appropriated entitlement funds summarized above, the child -nutrition programs’ funding also includes certain other mandatory funding21 and a limited amount -of discretionary funding. Some of the activities discussed in “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities,” such as Team Nutrition, are provided for with discretionary funding. - -Aside from the annually appropriated funding, the child nutrition programs are also supported by -certain permanent appropriations and transfers. Notably, funding for the Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable Program is funded by a transfer from USDA’s Section 32 program, a permanent -appropriation of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts. - -State, Local, and Participant Funds - -Federal subsidies do not necessarily cover the full cost of the meals and snacks offered by -providers. States and localities help cover program costs, as do children’s families by paying -charges for non-free or reduced-price meals/snacks. There is a non-federal cost-sharing -requirement for the school meals programs (discussed below), and some states supplement school -funding through additional state per-meal reimbursements or other prescribed financing -arrangements.22 - -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Subsequent sections of this report delve into the details of how each of the child nutrition -programs support the service of meals and snacks in institutional settings; first, it is useful to take -a broader perspective of primary program elements. Table 1 is a top-level look at the different -programs that displays distinguishing characteristics (what meals are provided, in what settings, -to what ages) and recent program spending. - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Program - -National School -Lunch Program - -Authorizing -Statute (Year -First -Authorized) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1946) - - - - - -Distinguishing -Characteristics - -FY2017 -Expenditures - -Lunches at school - -$13.6 billion - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -FY2017 -Average Daily -Participation - -Maximum -Daily -Snack/Mealsa - -30.0 million -children - - One meal and -snack per child - -programs, http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/schoolscn-usda-foods-programs. -21 These costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and Technical -Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. See p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional -Budget Justification, available at https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -22 The School Nutrition Association, a trade association representing school meal operators and industry, tracks state -policies and funding on the organization website at https://schoolnutrition.org/LegislationPolicy/ -StateLegislationPolicyReports/. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -5 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -School -Breakfast -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1966) - - - - - - - -Possible to -provide summer -food and -afterschool -snacks. - -Breakfasts at -school (also for -pre-K-12) - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (child -care centers, day -care homes, adult -day care centers) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - - Meals and snacks -in early childhood -and adult day -care settings - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (At- -Risk After-School -snacks and meals)b - -Summer Food -Service -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1994) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - -Special Milk -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1954) - -Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(2002) - - - - - -Rules and funding -differ based on -type of institution - -Supper and -snacks for -school-age -children after- -school - - Meals and snacks -provided during -summer months - - - - - - - - - - - -Sites vary and -include schools, -community -centers, camps, -parks, and others - -Eligibility rules -vary for “open” -and “closed” sites - -Subsidizes milk, -not meals or -snacks - -Institutions -eligible must not -participate in -NSLP or SBP - -Provides free -fresh fruit and -vegetable snacks -to elementary -school students - -$4.3 billion - -14.7 million -children - - Generally one -breakfast per -child, with -some flexibility - -$3.5 billion -(includes at- -risk after- -school -spending, -described -below) - -(Not available; -included in -CACFP total -above) - -$485 million - -4.4 million -children; -132,000 adults - - Two meals and -one snack, or -one meal and -two snacks per -participant - -1.7 million -children -(included in -CACFP -children above) - -2.7 million -childrenc - - One meal and -one snack per -child - -Lunch and -breakfast or -lunch and one -snack per child -Exception: -maximum of -three meals -for camps or -programs that -serve primarily -migrant -children - -$8 million - -191,000 half- -pints served -(average daily)d - - Not specified - -$184e million - - Not available - - Not applicable - -Source: Except where noted, participation and funding data from USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report, which -contains data through March 2018. Participation data are estimated by USDA-FNS based on meals served. -a. These maximums are provided in the authorizing law for CACFP and SFSP, but specified only in regulations - -(7 C.F.R. 210.10(a), 220.9(a)) for NSLP and SBP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -6 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -b. At-risk after-school snacks and meals are part of CACFP law and CACFP funding, but differ in their rules - -and the age of children served. - -c. Based only on July 2017 participation data. -d. Data from p. 32-58 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -e. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. - -Links to Resources -Other relevant CRS reports in this area include23 - - CRS In Focus IF10266, An Introduction to Child Nutrition Reauthorization - CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs - CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296 - -(summarizes the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010) - - CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An - -Overview - - CRS Report R44588, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2017 Appropriations - CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 - -Program - -Other relevant resources include - - USDA-FNS’s website, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/child-nutrition- - -programs - - USDA-FNS’s Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act page, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ - -school-meals/healthy-hunger-free-kids-act - - The FNS page of the Federal Register, https://www.federalregister.gov/agencies/ - -food-and-nutrition-service - -School Meals Programs -This section discusses the school meals programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) -and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). Principles and concepts common to both programs are -discussed first; subsections then discuss features and data unique to the NSLP and SBP, -respectively. - -General Characteristics - -The federal school meals programs provide federal support in the form of cash assistance and -USDA commodity foods; both are provided according to statutory formulas based on the number -of reimbursable meals served in schools. The subsidized meals are served by both public and -private nonprofit elementary and secondary schools and residential child care institutions -(RCCIs)24 that opt to enroll and guarantee to offer free or reduced-price meals to eligible low- - -23 Archived historical reports that may provide useful background include CRS Report RL33829, Domestic Food -Assistance and the 2008 Farm Bill; and CRS Report RL33299, Child Nutrition and WIC Legislation in the 108th and -109th Congresses. -24 This CRS report refers to “schools,” but it should be understood that—for NSLP and SBP—it means both schools -and RCCIs. NSLP regulations, 7 C.F.R. 210.2, define RCCIs as follows: “The term ‘residential child care institutions’ - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -7 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -income children. Both cash and commodity support to participating schools are calculated based -on the number and price of meals served (e.g., lunch or breakfast, free or full price), but once the -aid is received by the school it is used to support the overall school meal service budget, as -determined by the school. This report focuses on the federal reimbursements and funding, but it -should be noted that some states have provided state financing through additional state-specific -funding.25 - -Federal law does not require schools to participate in the school meals programs. However, some -states have mandated that schools provide lunch and/or breakfast, and some of these states require -that their schools do so through NSLP and/or SBP.26 The program is open to public and private -schools. - -A reimbursable meal requires compliance with federal school nutrition standards, which have -changed throughout the history of the program based on nutritional science and children’s -nutritional needs. Food items not served as a complete meal meeting nutrition standards (e.g., a la -carte offerings) are not reimbursable meals, and therefore are not eligible for federal per-meal, -per-snack reimbursements. Following rulemaking to implement P.L. 111-296 provisions, the -standards for reimbursable meals were updated in January 2012 and USDA also has provided -nutrition standards for the non-meal foods served in schools during the school day (see “Selected -Current Issues” for more on these policies). - -USDA-FNS administers the school meals programs federally, and state agencies (typically state -departments of education) oversee and transmit reimbursements through agreements with school -food authorities (SFAs) (typically local educational agencies (LEAs); usually these are school -districts). Figure 1 provides an overview of the roles and relationships between these levels of -government. - -There is a cost-sharing requirement for the programs, which amounts to a contribution of -approximately $200 million from the states.27 There also are states that choose to supplement -federal reimbursements with their own state reimbursements.28 - -includes, but is not limited to: homes for the mentally, emotionally or physically impaired, and unmarried mothers and -their infants; group homes; halfway houses; orphanages; temporary shelters for abused children and for runaway -children; long-term care facilities for chronically ill children; and juvenile detention centers. A long-term care facility is -a hospital, skilled nursing facility, intermediate care facility, or distinct part thereof, which is intended for the care of -children confined for 30 days or more.” -25 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. -26 Ibid. -27 Section 7(a)(1) of Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1756(a)(1). Section 7(f) of -Child Nutrition Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776(f). -28 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -8 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs - -Source: Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 47. - -School Meals Eligibility Rules - -The school meals programs and related funding do not serve only low-income children. All -students can receive a meal at a NSLP- or SBP-participating school, but how much the child pays -for the meal and/or how much of a federal reimbursement the state receives will depend largely -on whether the child qualifies for a “free,” “reduced-price,” or “paid” (i.e., advertised price) meal. -Both NSLP and SBP use the same household income eligibility criteria and categorical eligibility -rules. States and schools receive the largest reimbursements for free meals, smaller -reimbursements for reduced-price meals, and the smallest (but still some federal financial -support) for the full-price meals. - -There are three pathways through which a child can become certified to receive a free or reduced- -price meal: - -1. Household income eligibility for free and reduced-price meals (information - -typically collected via household application), - -2. Categorical (or automatic) eligibility for free meals (information collected via - -household application or a direct certification process), and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -9 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -3. School-wide free meals under the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an -option for eligible schools that is based on the share of students identified as -eligible for free meals.29 - -Each of these pathways is discussed in more detail below. - -Income Eligibility - -The income eligibility thresholds (shown in Table 2) are based on multipliers of the federal -poverty guidelines. As the poverty guidelines are updated every year, so are the eligibility -thresholds for NSLP and SBP. - - Free Meals: Children receive free meals if they have household income at or -below 130% of the federal poverty guidelines; these meals receive the highest -subsidy rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $3.30 per lunch served, less for -breakfast.) - - Reduced-Price Meals: Children may receive reduced-price meals (charges of no -more than 40 cents for a lunch or 30 cents for a breakfast) if their household -income is above 130% and less than or equal to 185% of the federal poverty -guidelines; these meals receive a subsidy rate that is 40 cents (NSLP) or 30 cents -(SBP) below the free meal rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $2.90 per -lunch served.) - - Paid Meals: A comparatively small per-meal reimbursement is provided for full- -price or paid meals served to children whose families do not apply for assistance -or whose family income does not qualify them for free or reduced-price meals.30 -The paid meal price is set by the school but must comply with federal -regulations.31 (Reimbursements are approximately 30 cents per lunch served.) - -The above reimbursement rates are approximate; exact current-year federal reimbursement rates -for NSLP and SBP are listed in Table B-1 and Table B-3, respectively. - -Households complete paper or online applications that collect relevant income and household size -data, so that the school district can determine if children in the household are eligible for free -meals, reduced-price meals, or neither. - -Though these income guidelines primarily influence funding and administration of NSLP and -SBP, they also affect the eligibility rules for the SFSP, CACFP, and SMP (described further in -subsequent sections). - -29 CEP is not the only way schools may provide universal free meal service, but it is unique in that it does not require -the collection of applications. -30 The subsidy for paid meals is provided under the authority of Section 4 of the Richard B. Russell National School -Lunch Act. Section 4 establishes two different payment levels: one for schools in which less than 60% of the school -population is participating in free or reduced-price lunch and one for schools in which 60% or more of the school -population is receiving free or reduced price lunch. See https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018- -15465/national-school-lunch-special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum for -these reimbursement rates. USDA also establishes a “maximum [reimbursement] rate” intended to ensure that states -distribute federal funding to all participating school food authorities relatively equally. -31 The 2010 reauthorization established a policy intended to assure that paid meal revenues were covering the costs of -producing a meal. See FNS paid lunch equity guidance for SY2018-2019, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/paid- -lunch-equity-guidance-school-year-2018-19. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -10 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP -For 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Income Eligibility Threshold - (% of the Federal Poverty Level) - -Annual Income for a -Family of Four - -Free - -Reduced-Price - -<130% - -130-185% - -<$32,630 - -$32,630 - $46,435 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Income Eligibility Guidelines,” 83 -Federal Register 20788, May 8, 2018. -Note: This school year is defined as July 1, 2018, through June 30, 2019. For other years, household sizes, -Alaska, and Hawaii, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/income-eligibility-guidelines. - -Categorical Eligibility - -In addition to the eligibility thresholds listed above, the school meals programs also convey -eligibility for free meals based on household participation in certain other need-tested programs -or children’s specified vulnerabilities (e.g., foster children). Per Section 12 of the National School -Lunch Act, “a child shall be considered automatically eligible for a free lunch and breakfast ... -without further application or eligibility determination, if the child is”32 - - - -in a household receiving benefits through - - SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program); - FDPIR (Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations, a program -that operates in lieu of SNAP on some Indian reservations) benefits; or - - TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) cash assistance; - -enrolled in Head Start; -in foster care; -a migrant; -a runaway; or - - - - - - homeless.33 - -For meals served to students certified in the above categories, the state/school will receive -reimbursement at the free meal amount and children receive a free meal. (See Table B-1 and -Table B-3 for school year 2018-2019 rates.) - -Some school districts collect information for these categorical eligibility rules via paper -application. Others conduct a process called direct certification—a proactive process where - -32 See Section 9(b)(12)(A) of the Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(12)(A), for the -more specific definitions of these categories. -33 SNAP, FDPIR, and TANF have income limits, but the other qualifications, as defined, in the statute, are not limited -by income. In addition to the above list, following specific demonstration authority in HHFKA as well as under FNS’s -standing pilot authority, some states are currently directly certifying children based on Medicaid data. According to -USDA-FNS, 19 states are operating direct certification with Medicaid in SY2018-2019. Four of the states (Illinois, -Kentucky, New York, Pennsylvania) use Medicaid to directly certify for free meals only. Fifteen states (California, -Connecticut, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, -West Virginia, Wisconsin), operating under an expanded direct certification demonstration project to test direct -certification with Medicaid for reduced-price meals (up to 185% of poverty), are using this process for free and -reduced-price meals. Both options are discussed in USDA-FNS, Request for Applications to Participate in -Demonstration Projects to Evaluate Direct Certification with Medicaid, January 27, 2016, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ -sites/default/files/cn/SP23-2016a.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -11 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -government agencies typically cross-check their program rolls and certify a household’s children -for free school meals without the household having to complete a school meals application. - -Prior to 2004, states had the option to conduct direct certification of SNAP (then, the Food Stamp -Program), TANF, and FDPIR participants. In the 2004 child nutrition reauthorization (P.L. 108- -265), states were required under federal law to conduct direct certification for SNAP participants, -with nationwide implementation taking effect in school year 2008-2009. Conducting direct -certification for TANF and FDPIR remains at the state’s discretion. - -The Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296) made further policy changes -to expand direct certification (discussed further in the next section). One of those changes was the -initiation of a demonstration project to look at expanding categorical eligibility and direct -certification to some Medicaid households. The law also funded performance incentive grants for -high-performing states and authorized correcting action planning for low-performing states in -direct certification activities.34 - -Under SNAP direct certification rules generally, schools enter into agreements with SNAP -agencies to certify children in SNAP households as eligible for free school meals without -requiring a separate application from the family. Direct certification systems match student -enrollment lists against SNAP agency records, eliminating the need for action by the child’s -parents or guardians. Direct certification allows schools to make use of SNAP’s more in-depth -eligibility certification process; this can reduce errors that may occur in school lunch application -eligibility procedures that are otherwise used.35 From a program access perspective, direct -certification also reduces the number of applications a household must complete. - -Figure 2, created by GAO and published in a May 2014 report, provides an overview of how -school districts certify students for free and reduced-price meals under the income-based and -category-based rules, via applications and direct certification.36 A USDA-FNS study of school -year 2014-2015 estimates that 11.1 million students receiving free meals were directly certified— -68% of all categorically eligible students receiving free meals.37 - -34 See CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296, for further discussion of these -and related policies. -35 See, for example, U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, -but Additional Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, pp. 16-19, -http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-14-262. -36 U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, but Additional -Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, http://www.gao.gov/products/ -GAO-14-262. -37 Quinn Moore, Kevin Conway, and Brandon Kyler, et al., Direct Certification in the National School Lunch -Program: State Implementation Progress, School Year 2014-2015, Report to Congress Mathematica Policy Research -for USDA-FNS, CN-15-DC, October 2016, p. 24, https://www.fns.usda.gov/direct-certification-national-school-lunch- -program-report-congress-state-implementation-progress-0 - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -12 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals -Household Application and Direct Certification Pathways - -Source: Figure and figure notes (below) from Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 13. -Note: aStudents who meet an approved designation—(1) homeless, runaway, or migrant; (2) foster child; or -(3) enrolled in a federally funded Head Start Program—are categorically eligible for free school meals. - -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) - -HHFKA also authorized the school meals Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an option in -NSLP and SBP law that allows eligible schools and school districts to offer free meals to all -enrolled students based on the percentage of their students who are identified as automatically - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -13 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -eligible from non-household application sources (primarily direct certification through other -programs).38 - -Based on the statutory parameters, USDA-FNS piloted CEP in various states over three school -years and it expanded nationwide in school year 2014-2015. Eligible LEAs have until June 30 of -each year to notify USDA-FNS if they will participate in CEP.39 According to a database -maintained by the Food Research and Action Center, just over 20,700 schools in more than 3,500 -school districts (LEAs) participated in CEP in SY2016-2017, an increase of approximately 2,500 -schools compared to SY2015-2016.40 - -For a school (or school district, or group of schools within a district) to provide free meals to all -children: - - - - - -the school(s) must be eligible for CEP based on the share (40% or greater) of -enrolled children that can be identified as categorically (or automatically) eligible -for free meals, and -the school must opt-in to CEP. - -Though CEP schools serve free meals to all students, they are not reimbursed at the “free meal” -rate for every meal. Instead, the law provides a funding formula: the percentage of students -identified as automatically eligible (the “identified student percentage” or ISP) is multiplied by a -factor of 1.6 to estimate the proportion of students who would be eligible for free or reduced- -price meals had they been certified via application.41 The result is the percentage of meals served -that will be reimbursed at the free meal rate, with the remainder reimbursed at the far lower paid -meal rate. For example, if a CEP school identifies that 40% of students are eligible for free meals, -then 64% of the meals served will be reimbursed at the free meal rate and 36% at the paid meal -rate.42 Schools that identify 62.5% or more students as eligible for free meals receive the free -meal reimbursement for all meals served. - -Some of the considerations that may impact a school’s decision to participate in CEP include -whether the new funding formula would be beneficial for their school meal budget; an interest in -reducing paperwork for families and schools; and an interest in providing more free meals, -including meals to students who have not participated in the program before. - -38 Explanation here draws in part from Madeleine Levin and Zoe Neuberger, Improving Direct Certification Will Help -More Low-Income Children Receive School Meals, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities & Food Research and -Action Center, July 25, 2014, p. 3. Aside from CEP, schools may also provide universal free meal service through the -“Provision 2” and “Provision 3” options. CEP is unique in that no school meal applications are required. For -information on other options, see USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/provisions-1-2-and-3. -39 USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating -Applications through Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal -Register 50194, July 29, 2016. -40 FRAC, “Community Eligibility,” available at http://frac.org/community-eligibility. -41 USDA-FNS, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating Applications Through -Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal Register 50194, July -29, 2016, p. 50201. -42 Though, to the children of community eligibility schools, all meals are free, the USDA-FNS school meals -expenditure data used throughout this report count these meals served in a more nuanced fashion. The percentage -derived through this calculation is used to record those meals that are “free” and those meals that are “paid” (i.e., using -the example from above, USDA-FNS data would reflect 64% of the meals served in the school as a “free” expenditure -and meal served, and 36% as “paid”). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -14 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) - -In FY2017, NSLP subsidized 4.9 billion lunches to children in close to 96,000 schools and 3,200 -residential child care institutions (RCCIs). Average daily participation was 30.0 million students -(58% of children enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). Of the participating students, -66.7% (20.0 million) received free lunches and 6.5% (2.0 million) received reduced-price -lunches. The remainder were served full-price meals, though schools still receive a -reimbursement for these meals. Figure 3 shows FY2017 participation data. - -FY2017 federal school lunch costs totaled approximately $13.6 billion (see Table 3 for the -various components of this total). The vast majority of this funding is for per-meal -reimbursements for free and reduced-price lunches. - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at NSLP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -HHFKA also provided an additional 6-cent per-lunch reimbursement to schools that provide -meals that meet the updated nutritional guidelines requirements.43 This bonus is not provided for -breakfast, but funds may be used to support schools’ breakfast programs. NSLP lunch -reimbursement rates are listed in Table B-1. - -In addition to federal cash subsidies, schools participating in NSLP receive USDA-acquired -commodity foods. Schools are entitled to a specific, inflation-indexed value of USDA commodity - -43 In January 2014, USDA-FNS issued a final rule implementing the 6-cent reimbursement: USDA-FNS, “Certification -of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids -Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. Note: 6-cent increase authorized is also annually indexed for -inflation. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -15 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -foods for each lunch they serve. Also, schools may receive donations of bonus commodities -acquired by USDA in support of the farm economy.44 In FY2017, the value of federal commodity -food aid to schools totaled nearly $1.4 billion. The per-meal rate for commodity food assistance is -included in Table B-4. - -While the vast majority of NSLP funding is for lunches served during the school day, NSLP may -also be used to support snack service during the school year and to serve meals during the -summer. These features are discussed in subsequent sections, “Summer Meals” and “After-School -Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” Reimbursement rates for snacks are listed in Table -B-2. - -School Breakfast Program (SBP) - -The School Breakfast Program (SBP) provides per-meal cash subsidies for breakfasts served in -schools. Participating schools receive subsidies based on their status as a severe need or non- -severe need institution. Schools can qualify as a severe need school if 40% or more of their -lunches are served free or at reduced prices. See Table B-3 for SBP reimbursement rates. - -Figure 4 displays SBP participation data for FY2017. In that year, SBP subsidized over 2.4 -billion breakfasts in over 88,000 schools and nearly 3,200 RCCIs. Average daily participation was -14.7 million children (30.1% of the students enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). The -majority of meals served through SBP are free or reduced-price. Of the participating students, -79.1% (11.6 million) received free meals and 5.7% (835,000) purchased reduced-price meals. -Federal school breakfast costs for the fiscal year totaled approximately $4.3 billion (see Table 3 -for the various components of this total). - -Significantly fewer schools and students participate in SBP than in NSLP. Participation in SBP -tends to be lower for several reasons, including the traditionally required early arrival by students -in order to receive a meal and eat before school starts. Some schools offer (and anti-hunger -groups have encouraged) models of breakfast service that can result in greater SBP participation, -such as Breakfast in the Classroom, where meals are delivered in the classroom; “grab and go” -carts, where students receive a bagged breakfast that they bring to class, or serving breakfast later -in the day in middle and high schools.45 - -Unlike NSLP, commodity food assistance is not a formal part of SBP funding; however, -commodities provided through NSLP may be used for school breakfasts as well. - -44 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -45 See Food Research and Action Center (FRAC), “School Breakfast Expansion Strategies,” http://www.frac.org/ -programs/school-breakfast-program/school-breakfast-expansion-strategies (Accessed July 9, 2018). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -16 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at SBP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -Other Child Nutrition Programs -In addition to the school meals programs discussed above, other federal child nutrition programs -provide federal subsidies and commodity food assistance for schools and other institutions that -offer meals and snacks to children in early childhood, summer, and after-school settings. This -assistance is provided to (1) schools and other governmental institutions, (2) private for-profit and -nonprofit child care centers, (3) family/group day care homes, and (4) nongovernmental -institutions/organizations that offer outside-of-school programs for children. (Although this report -focuses on the programs that serve children, one child nutrition program [CACFP] also serves -day care centers for chronically impaired adults and elderly persons under the same general per- -meal/snack subsidy terms.) The programs in the sections to follow serve comparatively fewer -children and spend comparatively fewer federal funds than the school meal programs. - -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) - -CACFP subsidizes meals and snacks served in early childhood, day care, and after-school -settings. CACFP provides subsidies for meals and snacks served at participating non-residential -child care centers, family day care homes, and (to a lesser extent) adult day care centers.46 The -program also provides assistance for meals served at after-school programs. CACFP -reimbursements are available for meals and snacks served to children age 12 or under, migrant - -46 CACFP also supports meals in homeless/emergency shelters. See http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/emergency-shelters -for further information. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -17 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -children age 15 or under, children with disabilities of any age, and, in the case of adult care -centers, chronically impaired and elderly adults. Children in early childhood settings are the -overwhelming majority of those served by the program. - -CACFP provides federal reimbursements for breakfasts, lunches, suppers, and snacks served in -participating centers (facilities or institutions) or day care homes (private homes). The eligibility -and funding rules for CACFP meals and snacks depend first on whether the participating -institution is a center or a day care home (the next two sections discuss the rules specific to -centers and day care homes). According to FY2017 CACFP data, child care centers have an -average daily attendance of about 56 children per center, day care homes have an average daily -attendance of approximately 7 children per home, and adult day care centers typically care for an -average of 48 chronically ill or elderly adults per center.47 - -Subsidized CACFP meals and snacks must meet program-specific federal nutrition standards, and -providers must demonstrate that they comply with government-established standards for other -child care programs. Like in school meals, federal assistance is made up overwhelmingly of cash -reimbursements calculated based on the number of meals/snacks served and federal per- -meal/snack reimbursements rates, but a far smaller share of federal aid (4.3% in FY2017) is in the -form of federal USDA commodity foods (or cash in lieu of foods). Federal CACFP -reimbursements flow to individual providers either directly from the administering state agency -(this is the case with many child/adult care centers able to handle their own CACFP -administrative functions) or through “sponsors” who oversee and provide administrative support -for a number of local providers (this is the case with some child/adult care centers and with all -day care homes).48 - -In FY2017, total CACFP spending was over $3.5 billion, including cash reimbursement, -commodity food assistance, and costs for sponsor audits. (See Table 3 for a further breakdown of -CACFP costs.) This total also includes the after-school meals and snacks provided through -CACFP’s “at-risk after-school” pathway; this aspect of the program is discussed later in “After- -School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” - -CACFP at Centers - -Participation - -Child care centers in CACFP can be (1) public or private nonprofit centers, (2) Head Start -centers, (3) for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet certain requirements as to the proportion of -low-income children they enroll), and (4) shelters for homeless families. Adult day care centers -include public or private nonprofit centers and for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet -minimum requirements related to serving low-income disabled and elderly adults).49 In FY2017, -over 65,000 child care centers with an average daily attendance of over 3.6 million children -participated in CACFP. Over 2,700 adult care centers served nearly 132,000 adults through -CACFP. - -47 USDA-FNS’ administrative data on the CACFP are the source of these attendance numbers. -48 In many cases, sponsor organizations that provide administrative support to multiple providers also are paid federal -reimbursements for their costs. Day care homes must have a sponsoring organization, while child care centers may -have a sponsor but are not required to do so. -49 Participating adult care programs “should be structured, comprehensive and provide health and social support -services to enrolled participants. Centers that simply provide social or rehabilitative services to adults do not qualify to -participate in CACFP.” http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/facts-about-adult-component-cacfp. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -18 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Eligibility and Administration - -Participating centers may receive daily reimbursements for up to either two meals and one snack -or one meal and two snacks for each participant, so long as the meals and snacks meet federal -nutrition standards. - -The eligibility rules for CACFP centers largely track those of NSLP: children in households at or -below 130% of the current poverty line qualify for free meals/snacks while those between 130% -and 185% of poverty qualify for reduced-price meals/snacks (see Table 2). In addition, -participation in the same categorical eligibility programs as NSLP as well as foster child status -convey eligibility for free meals in CACFP.50 Like school meals, eligibility is determined through -paper applications or direct certification processes. - -Like school meals, all meals and snacks served in the centers are federally subsidized to some -degree, even those that are paid. Different reimbursement amounts are provided for breakfasts, -lunches/suppers, and snacks, and reimbursement rates are set in law and indexed for inflation -annually. The largest subsidies are paid for meals and snacks served to participants with family -income below 130% of the federal poverty income guidelines (the income limit for free school -meals), and the smallest to those who have not met a means test. See Table B-5 for current -CACFP center reimbursement rates. - -Unlike school meals, CACFP institutions are less likely to collect per-meal payments. Although -federal assistance for day care centers differentiates by household income, centers have discretion -on their pricing of meals. Centers may adjust their regular fees (tuition) to account for federal -payments, but CACFP itself does not regulate these fees. In addition, centers can charge families -separately for meals/snacks, so long as there are no charges for children meeting free-meal/snack -income tests and limited charges for those meeting reduced-price income tests. - -Independent centers are those without sponsors handling administrative responsibilities. These -centers must pay for administrative costs associated with CACFP out of non-federal funds or a -portion of their meal subsidy payments. For centers with sponsors, the sponsors may retain a -proportion of the meal reimbursement payments they receive on behalf of their centers to cover -such costs. - -CACFP for Day Care Homes - -Participation - -CACFP-supported day care homes serve a smaller number of children than CACFP-supported -centers, both in terms of the total number of children served and the average number of children -per facility. Roughly 17% of children in CACFP (approximately 757,000 in FY2017 average -daily attendance) are served through day care homes. In FY2017, approximately 103,000 homes -(with just over 700 sponsors) received CACFP support. - -Eligibility and Reimbursement - -As with centers, payments to day care homes are provided for up to either two meals and one -snack or one meal and two snacks a day for each child. Unlike centers, day care homes must -participate under the auspices of a public or, more often, private nonprofit sponsor that typically - -50 See also summary of CACFP eligibility rules at USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/why-cacfp- -important. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -19 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -has 100 or more homes under its supervision. CACFP day care home sponsors receive monthly -administrative payments based on the number of homes for which they are responsible.51 - -Federal reimbursements for family day care homes differ by the home’s status as “Tier I” or “Tier -II.” Unlike centers, day care homes receive cash reimbursements (but not commodity foods) that -generally are not based on the child participants’ household income. Instead, there are two -distinct, annually indexed reimbursement rates that are based on area or operator eligibility -criteria: - - Tier I homes are located in low-income areas (defined as areas in which at least - -50% of school-age and enrolled children qualify for free or reduced-price meals) -or operated by low-income providers whose household income meets the free or -reduced-price income standards.52 They receive higher subsidies for each -meal/snack they serve. - - Tier II (lower) rates are by default those for homes that do not qualify for Tier I -rates; however, Tier II providers may seek the higher Tier I subsidy rates for -individual low-income children for whom financial information is collected and -verified. (See Table B-6 for current Tier I and Tier II reimbursement rates.) - -Additionally, HHFKA introduced a number of additional ways (as compared to prior law) by -which family day care homes can qualify as low-income and get Tier I rates for the entire home -or for individual children.53 - -As with centers, there is no requirement that meals/snacks specifically identified as free or -reduced-price be offered; however, unlike centers, federal rules prohibit any separate meal -charges. - -Summer Meals - -Current law SFSP and the NSLP/SBP Seamless Summer Option provide meals in congregate -settings nationwide; the related Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer (SEBTC or Summer EBT) -demonstration project is an alternative to congregate settings. The demonstration is discussed -below; proposals to expand the demonstration are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” - -51 As an example of the role that sponsors and homes play in CACFP, in Allentown, Pennsylvania, the Lehigh Valley -Children’s Centers (LVCC) serves as a sponsor for child care homes in the area. They offer a variety of administrative -services to family child care homes that are registered with the state. In their brochure, they state that it is LVCC’s -responsibility to “monitor meals and reimburse [homes] for meals served,” and it is homes’ responsibility “to plan -nutritional menus that meet meal requirements, maintain and submit daily attendance records and monthly meal -counts.” See http://www.lvcconline.org/images/pdf/CACFP-Brochure.pdf. -52 7 C.F.R. §226.2. -53 Previously, child care homes could only use data from the elementary school level to establish the area as low- -income. The new law allows these homes to use data from the middle and high school level as well to establish need -and qualify as a “Tier I” home. Also, P.L. 111-296 included policies to streamline application processes and eliminate -some paperwork. As part of this process, the annual application process has been eliminated and sponsors and child -care centers will only have to submit paperwork the first time they apply, with amendments submitted as necessary. -Finally, P.L. 111-296 increased CACFP sponsoring organizations’ and providers’ flexibility over administrative funds, -including the option to carry over up to 10% of administrative funds from one fiscal year to the next. USDA-FNS has -begun to implement these changes. See, for example, USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Amendments Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 77 Federal Register 21018-21038, -April 9, 2012; USDA-FNS Memorandum, Child Nutrition Reauthorization 2010: Area Eligibility for Family Day Care -Homes, Memo Code: CACFP 05-2011-Revised, January 10, 2011, https://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp-05-2011-revised- -child-nutrition-reauthorization-2010-area-eligibility-family-day-care-homes. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -20 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) - -SFSP supports meals for children during the summer months. The program provides assistance to -local public institutions and private nonprofit service institutions running summer -youth/recreation programs, summer feeding projects, and camps. Assistance is primarily in the -form of cash reimbursements for each meal or snack served; however, federally donated -commodity foods are also offered. Participating service institutions are often entities that provide -ongoing year-round service to the community including schools, local governments, camps, -colleges and universities in the National Youth Sports program, and private nonprofit -organizations like churches. - -Similar to the CACFP model, sponsors are institutions that manage the food preparation, -financial, and administrative responsibilities of SFSP. Sites are the places where food is served -and eaten. At times, a sponsor may also be a site. State agencies authorize sponsors, monitor and -inspect sponsors and sites, and implement USDA policy. Unlike CACFP, sponsors are required -for an institution’s participation in SFSP as a site. - -Participation - -In FY2017, nearly 5,500 sponsors with 50,000 food service sites participated in the SFSP and -served an average of approximately 2.7 million children daily (according to July data).54 - -Participation of sites and children in SFSP has increased in recent years. Program costs for -FY2017 totaled over $485 million, including cash assistance, commodity foods, administrative -cost assistance, and health inspection costs. - -Eligibility and Administration - -There are several options for eligibility and meal/snack service for SFSP sponsors (and their -sites): - - Open sites provide summer food to all children in the community. These sites are -certified based on area eligibility measures, where 50% or more of area children -have family income that would make them eligible for free or reduced-price -school meals (see Table 2). - - Closed or Enrolled sites provide summer meals/snacks free to all children - -enrolled at the site. The eligibility test for these sites is that 50% or more of the -children enrolled in the sponsor’s program must be eligible for free or reduced- -price school meals based on household income. Closed/enrolled sites may also -become eligible based on area eligibility measures noted above. - - Summer camps (that are not enrolled sites) receive subsidies only for those -children with household eligibility for free or reduced-price school meals. - Other programs specified in law, such as the National Youth Sports Program - -and centers for homeless or migrant children. - -54 According to a May 2018 GAO report, estimates of participation in SFSP may not be reliable because they have been -calculated inconsistently across states and years. See U.S. Government Accountability Office, Actions Needed to -Improve Participation Estimates and Address Program Challenges, GAO-18-369, May 2018, https://www.gao.gov/ -products/GAO-18-369. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -21 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer sponsors get operating cost (food, storage, labor) subsidies for all meals/snacks they -serve—up to one meal and one snack, or two meals per child per day.55 In addition, sponsors -receive payments for administrative costs, and states are provided with subsidies for -administrative costs and health and meal-quality inspections. See Table B-7 for current SFSP -reimbursement rates. Actual payments vary slightly (e.g., by about 5 cents for lunches) depending -on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared on-site or by a -vendor. - -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option56 - -Although SFSP is the child nutrition program most associated with providing meals during -summer months, it is not the only program option for providing these meals and snacks. The -Seamless Summer Option, run through NSLP or SBP programs, is also a means through which -food can be provided to students during summer months. Much like SFSP, Seamless Summer -operates in summer sites (summer camps, sports programs, churches, private nonprofit -organizations, etc.) and for a similar duration of time. Unlike SFSP, schools are the only eligible -sponsors, although schools may operate the program at other sites. Reimbursement rates for -Seamless Summer meals are the same as current NSLP/SBP rates. - -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration - -Beginning in summer 2011 and (as of the date of this report) each summer since, USDA-FNS has -operated Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children (SEBTC or “Summer EBT”) -demonstration projects in a limited number of states and Indian Tribal Organizations (ITOs). -These Summer EBT projects provide electronic food benefits over summer months to households -with children eligible for free or reduced-price school meals. Depending on the site and year, -either $30 or $60 per month is provided, through a WIC or SNAP EBT card model. In the -demonstration projects, these benefits were provided as a supplement to the Summer Food -Service Program (SFSP) meals available in congregate settings. - -Summer EBT and other alternatives to congregate meals through SFSP were first authorized and -funded by the FY2010 appropriations law (P.L. 111-80). Although a number of alternatives were -tested and evaluated, findings from Summer EBT were among the most promising, and Congress -provided subsequent funding.57 Summer EBT evaluations (discussed later in “Alternatives to -“Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals”) showed significant impacts on reducing child food -insecurity and improving nutritional intake.58 Summer EBT was funded by P.L. 111-80 in the -summers from 2011 to 2014. Projects have continued to operate and were annually funded by -FY2015-FY2018 appropriations; most recently, the FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million. According to USDA-FNS, in summer 2016 Summer EBT served over - -55 With state agency approval, camps and migrant sites (sites that predominantly serve children of migrant workers) -may be reimbursed for serving three meals or two meals and one snack per child daily. -56 For further discussion, see the USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/opportunity-schools. -57 This CRS report discusses Summer EBT, not the other tested programs (“Enhanced Summer Food Service Program -(eSFSP). For information on eSFSP, see USDA-FNS’ “Enhanced Summer Food Service Program” webpage, -https://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/enhanced-summer-food-service-program-esfsp. -58 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus (Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013), p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -22 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -209,000 children in nine states and two tribal nations—an increase from the 11,400 children -served when the demonstration began in summer 2011.59 - -Special Milk Program (SMP) - -Schools (and institutions like summer camps and child care facilities) that are not already -participating in the other child nutrition programs can participate in the Special Milk Program. -Schools may also administer SMP for their part-day sessions for kindergartners or pre- -kindergartners. - -Under SMP, participating institutions provide milk to children for free and/or at a subsidized paid -price, depending on how the enrolled institution opts to administer the program (see Table B-8 -for current Special Milk reimbursement rates for each of these options): - - An institution that only sells milk will receive the same per-half pint federal - -reimbursement for each milk sold (approximately 20 cents). - - An institution that sells milk and provides free milk to eligible children (income - -eligibility is the same as free school meals, see Table 2), receives a -reimbursement for the milk sold (approximately 20 cents) and a higher -reimbursement for the free milks. - - An institution that does not sell milk provides milk free to all children and - -receives the same reimbursement for all milk (approximately 20 cents). This -option is sometimes called non-pricing. - -In FY2017, over 41 million half-pints were subsidized, 9.5% of which were served free. Federal -expenditures for this program were approximately $8.3 million in FY2017. - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) - -States receive formula grants through the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program, under which state- -selected schools receive funds to purchase and distribute fresh fruit and vegetable snacks to all -children in attendance (regardless of family income). Money is distributed by a formula under -which about half the funding is distributed equally to each state and the remainder is allocated by -state population. States select participating schools (with an emphasis on those with a higher -proportion of low-income children) and set annual per-student grant amounts (between $50 and -$75). - -Funding is set by law at $150 million for school year 2011-2012 and inflation-indexed for every -year after. In FY2017, states used approximately $184 million in FFVP funds.60 FFVP is funded -by a mandatory transfer of funds from USDA’s Section 32 program—a permanent appropriation -of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts.61 This transfer is required by FFVP’s authorizing -laws (Section 19 of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act and Section 4304 of P.L. -110-246). Up until FY2018’s law, annual appropriations laws delayed a portion of the funds to -the next fiscal year. - -59 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32- -40https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -60 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32-14, -https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -61 For more information, see CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -23 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In recent years, FFVP has been amended by omnibus farm bill laws rather than through child -nutrition reauthorizations. After a limited pilot, FFVP was expanded to all states and permanently -funded by the 2008 farm bill (P.L. 110-246).62 The 2014 farm bill (P.L. 113-79) essentially made -no changes to this program but did include, and fund at $5 million in FY2014, a pilot project that -requires USDA to test offering frozen, dried, and canned fruits and vegetables and publish an -evaluation of the pilot. Four states (Alaska, Delaware, Kansas, and Maine) participated in the -pilot in SY2014-2015 and the evaluation was published in 2017.63 Other proposals to expand -fruits and vegetables offered in FFVP have been introduced in both the 114th and 115th -Congress.64 - -Other Topics - -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options - -Two of the child nutrition programs discussed in previous sections, the National School Lunch -Program (NSLP) and Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), provide federal support for -snacks and meals served during after-school programs.65 - -NSLP provides reimbursements for after-school snacks; however, this option is open only to -schools that already participate in NSLP. These schools may operate after-school snack-only -programs during the school year, and can do so in two ways: (1) if low-income area eligibility -criteria are met, provide free snacks in lower-income areas; or (2) if area eligibility criteria are not -met, offer free, reduced-price, or fully paid-for snacks, based on household income eligibility -(like lunches in NSLP). The vast majority of snacks provided through this program are through -the first option. Through this program, approximately 206 million snacks were served in FY2017 -(a daily average of nearly 1.3 million). This compares with nearly 4.9 billion lunches served (a -daily average of 27.8 million). - -CACFP provides assistance for after-school food in two ways. First, centers and homes that -participate in CACFP and provide after-school care may participate in traditional CACFP (the -eligibility and administration described earlier). Second, centers in areas where at least half the -children in the community are eligible for free or reduced-price school meals can opt to -participate in the CACFP At-Risk Afterschool program, which provides free snacks and suppers. -Expansion of the At-Risk After-School meals program was a major policy change included in -HHFKA. Prior to the law, 13 states were permitted to offer CACFP At-Risk After-School meals -(instead of just a snack); the law allowed all CACFP state agencies to offer such meals.66 In - -62 Permanent funding is made possible through the Section 32 account. See CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food -Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program, coordinated by Jim Monke. -63 Briefel et al., Evaluation of the Pilot Project for Canned, Frozen, or Dried Fruits and Vegetables in the Fresh Fruit -and Vegetable Program (FFVP-CFD), Prepared by Mathematica Policy Research. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, January 2017, available at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/ops/FFVP-CFD.pdf. -64 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. In the 115th Congress, -see H.R. 3402, S. 2064, and House-passed H.R. 2 §4204. -65 For further discussion of the NSLP and CACFP after-school snack program, see Joanne Guthrie, Feeding Children -After School: The Expanding Role of USDA Child Nutrition Programs, USDA Economic Research Service, Amber -Waves, March 1, 2012, https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2012/march/feeding-children-after-school/. -66 S.Rept. 111-178, p. 7. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -24 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -FY2017, the At-Risk Afterschool program served a total of approximately 242.6 million free -meals and snacks to a daily average of more than 1.7 million children.67 - -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs - -In millions of dollars - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -National School Lunch Program - -$13,569 - -$13,643 - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -additional funding to schools with -more than 60% free or reduced- -price participation - -performance-based meal -reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -School Breakfast Program - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -Child and Adult Care Food -Program - -meal reimbursements at child care -centers - -meal reimbursements at child care -homes - -meal reimbursements at adult day -care centers - -commodity food assistancea - -administrative costs for child care -sponsors - -Summer Food Service Program - -meal reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -sponsor and inspection costs - -Special Milk Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable -Programb - -State Administrative Expenses - -$9,593 - -$808 - -$1,478 - -$9,620 - -$783 - -$1,480 - -+$74 - -+$27 - --$25 - -+$2 - -+1% - -0% - --3% - -0% - -$76 - -$74 - --$2 - --3% - -$302 - -$293 - --$9 - --3% - -$1,311 - -$4,213 - -$3,868 - -$239 - -$106 - -$1,393 - -$4,252 - -$3,912 - -$235 - -$106 - -+$82 - -+$39 - -+$44 - --$4 - -$0 - -+6% - -+1% - -+1% - --2% - -0% - -$3,520 - -$3,537 - -+$17 - -0% - -$2,307 - -$2,363 - -+$56 - -+2% - -$764 - -$149 - -$155 - -$146 - -$478 - -$419 - -$2 - -$58 - -$9 - -$167 - -$260 - -$721 - --$42 - --6% - -$156 - -$153 - -$145 - -$485 - -$424 - -$2 - -$60 - -$8 - -+$7 - -+5% - --$2 - --$1 - -+$7 - -+$5 - -$0 - -+$2 - --$1 - --1% - --1% - -+1% - -+1% - -0% - -+3% - --11% - -$184 - -+$17 - -+10% - -$279 - -+$19 - -+7% - -67 Data provided by USDA-FNS on July 18, 2018. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -25 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -Mandatory Other Program -Costsc - -Discretionary Activitiesd - -TOTAL OF FUNDS -DISPLAYEDe - -$59 - -$69 - -$83 - -$63 - -+$24 - -+41% - --$6 - --9% - -$22,344 - -$22,534 - -+$192 - -+1% - -Source: Program expenditures data (outlays) from USDA-FNS Keydata Reports (dated March 2017 and March -2018), except where noted below. -Notes: Expenditures displayed here will vary from displays in CRS appropriations reports and in some cases the -USDA-FNS annual budget justification. Since the majority of program funding is for open-ended entitlements, -expenditure data capture spending better than the total of appropriations. This table includes some functions that are -funded through permanent appropriations or transfers (i.e., funding not provided in appropriations laws). Due to -rounding to the nearest million, percentage increases or decreases may be exaggerated or understated. - -a. Amounts included in this table for commodity food assistance include only entitlement commodities for - -each program, not bonus commodities. - -b. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -c. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and -Technical Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. - -d. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs include Team Nutrition, the Summer EBT demonstration, and School Meal Equipment Grants. -e. This table summarizes the vast majority of child nutrition programs’ federal spending but does not capture - -all federal costs. - -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities - -Federal child nutrition laws authorize and program funding supports a range of additional -programs, initiatives, and activities.68 - -Through State Administrative Expenses funding, states are entitled to federal grants to help -cover administrative and oversight/monitoring costs associated with child nutrition programs. The -national amount each year is equal to about 2% of child nutrition reimbursements. The majority -of this money is allocated to states based on their share of spending on the covered programs; -about 15% is allocated under a discretionary formula granting each state additional amounts for -CACFP, commodity distribution, and Administrative Review efforts. In addition, states receive -payments for their role in overseeing summer programs (about 2.5% of their summer program -aid). States are free to apportion their federal administrative expense payments among child -nutrition initiatives (including commodity distribution activities) as they see fit, and appropriated -funding is available to states for two years. State Administrative Expense spending in FY2017 -totaled approximately $279 million.69 - -Team Nutrition is a USDA-FNS program that includes a variety of school meals initiatives -around nutrition education and the nutritional content of the foods children eat in schools. This - -68 This section does not list all related federal funding and support activities; those activities that are discussed are -broadly summarized. For further details on these and other functions funded by the “child nutrition programs” account, -see the 2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, pp. 32-10 through -32-26, https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -69 For the formula for administrative and oversight/monitoring costs, see Section 7 of the Child Nutrition Act of 1966 -(codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -26 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -includes Team Nutrition Training Grants, which provide funding to state agencies for training and -technical assistance, such as help implementing USDA’s nutrition requirements and the Dietary -Guidelines for Americans. From 2004 to 2018, Team Nutrition also included the HealthierUS -Schools Challenge (HUSSC), which originated in the 2004 reauthorization of the Child Nutrition -Act. HUSSC was a voluntary certification initiative designed to recognize schools that have -created a healthy school environment through the promotion of nutrition and physical activity.70 - -Farm-to-school programs broadly refer to “efforts that bring regionally and locally produced -foods into school cafeterias,” with a focus on enhancing child nutrition.71 The goals of these -efforts include increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among students, supporting local -farmers and rural communities, and providing nutrition and agriculture education to school -districts and farmers. HHFKA amended existing child nutrition programs to establish mandatory -funding of $5 million per year for competitive farm-to-school grants that support schools and -nonprofit entities in establishing farm-to-school programs that improve a school’s access to -locally produced foods.72 The FY2018 appropriations law provided an additional $5 million in -discretionary funding to remain available until expended.73 Grants may be used for training, -supporting operations, planning, purchasing equipment, developing school gardens, developing -partnerships, and implementing farm-to-school programs. USDA’s Office of Community Food -Systems provides additional resources on farm-to-school issues.74 - -Through an Administrative Review process (formerly referred to as Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE)), USDA-FNS, in cooperation with state agencies, conducts periodic on-site NSLP school -compliance and accountability evaluations to improve management and identify administrative, -subsidy claim, and meal quality problems.75 State agencies are required to conduct administrative -reviews of all school food authorities (SFAs) that operate the NSLP under their jurisdiction at -least once during a three-year review cycle.76 Federal Administrative Review expenditures were -approximately $9.9 million in FY2017. - -USDA-FNS and state agencies conduct many other child nutrition program support activities for -which dedicated funding is provided. Among other examples, there is the Institute of Child -Nutrition (ICN), which provides technical assistance, instruction, and materials related to -nutrition and food service management; it receives $5 million a year in mandatory funding -appropriated in statute. ICN is located at the University of Mississippi. USDA-FNS provides -training on food safety education. Funding is also provided for USDA-FNS to conduct studies, -provide training and technical assistance, and oversee payment accuracy. - -70 See USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/hussc/healthierus-school-challenge-smarter-lunchrooms. -71 USDA, The Farm to School Program—2012-2015: Four Years in Review, p. 3. https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/f2s/Farm-to-School-at-USDA—4-Years-in-Review.pdf. -72 HHFKA, Section 243 (Access to Local Foods: Farm to School Program), amending §18 of the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(j)). In addition, appropriations are authorized “such sums as are necessary -for each of fiscal years 2011 through 2015.” -73 See Section 763 of P.L. 115-141. -74 See USDA-FNS’s Office of Community Food Systems: http://www.fns.usda.gov/farmtoschool/farm-school. -75 Text in this paragraph is adapted from the USDA-FNS, National School Lunch Program: Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE), FNS-640 Data Report, January 2014. -76 HHFKA increased the frequency of administrative reviews from once every five years to once every three years. See -final rule at USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Administrative Reviews in the School Nutrition Programs,” 81 -Federal Register 50170, July 29, 2016. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -27 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Selected Current Issues -This section provides further information on current issues in the child nutrition programs. In -particular, it provides background on (1) USDA regulations updating various nutrition standards -in the child nutrition programs, (2) current and proposed alternatives to the “congregate feeding -requirement” in summer meals, and (3) recent changes and proposals aimed at addressing “lunch -shaming” and unpaid meal costs. - -Regulations on Nutrition Standards - -Since the enactment of the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296), -USDA-FNS has promulgated multiple regulations, formulated various program guidance, and -published many other policy documents and reports. Three of the major changes authorized by -the 2010 law relate to program nutrition standards: (1) requiring an update to the nutrition -standards for NSLP and SBP meals, (2) giving USDA the authority to regulate other foods sold in -schools (e.g., through vending machines and cafeterias’ a la carte lines) and requiring the agency -to issue related nutrition standards, and (3) requiring an update to the nutrition standards in -CACFP. The new nutrition standards were championed by First Lady Michelle Obama through -her “Let’s Move” initiative, among other groups.77 - -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast - -Section 201 of HHFKA (P.L. 111-296) established a timeframe for USDA to promulgate -regulations updating meal patterns and nutrition standards for school meal programs based on -recommendations from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) (now the Health and Medicine Division) -at the National Academy of Sciences.78 Schools meeting the new requirements are eligible for the -increased federal subsidies (6 cents per lunch) noted above. The law also provided funding for -technical assistance to help implement new meal patterns and nutrition standards. - -Ultimately, following a proposed rule, comments submitted, and policy provisions enacted in the -2012 appropriations law,79 USDA-FNS issued a final rule on January 26, 2012.80 The final rule -sought to align school meal patterns with the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and called -for increased availability of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat or fat-free milk in school -cafeterias—generally consistent with IOM’s recommendations. The regulations also included -calorie maximums (whereas prior guidelines had only calorie minimums) and sodium limits to -phase in over time, among other requirements.81 - -77 See, for example, Nia-Malika Henderson, “President Obama signs child nutrition bill, a priority for first lady,” -Washington Post, December 13, 2010, pp. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/13/ -AR2010121302407.html; archived White House website, “Let’s Move, Healthy Schools,” -https://letsmove.obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/healthy-schools. -78 The 2010 law added a deadline, but it was the 2004 reauthorization (P.L. 108-265) that required USDA to update the -standards based on National Academy of Sciences recommendations. IOM’s report, issued in 2010, had made a number -of recommendations around such topics as imposing calorie limits, increasing fruit and vegetables, and reducing -sodium intake. IOM, School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children, Washington, DC, 2010. -79 See Section 743 of P.L. 112-55. Also discussed in CRS Report R41964, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2012 -Appropriations, coordinated by Jim Monke. -80 For the final rule and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/nutrition- -standards-school-meals. -81 When originally issued, the rule and USDA-FNS policy also required certain weekly maximums on grains and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -28 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Although the rule was finalized in January 2012, all aspects of the rule were not to be -implemented immediately; for instance, some aspects of the new guidelines went into effect for -school year 2014-2015, even though the rule went into effect in school year 2012-2013.82 Three -aspects of the new regulations that went into effect in SY2014-2015 were: all grains served must -be whole-grain-rich,83 new fruit requirements for breakfast, and the first of three sodium limits or -“targets” for breakfasts and lunches (referred to as “Target 1”).84 - -As some schools have had difficulty implementing the new guidelines, Congress and the USDA -have implemented some changes or waivers regarding the 2012 final rule’s whole grain, sodium, -and milk requirements. FY2015, FY2016, and FY2017 appropriations laws (P.L. 113-235, P.L. -114-113, P.L. 115-31, respectively) included policies that affect the implementation of the -guidelines. As of the date of this report, schools are following policies set in an interim final rule -published November 30, 2017.85 - -Specifically, FY2015 and FY2016 appropriations laws (1) required USDA to allow states to -exempt school food authorities that meet hardship requirements from the 100% whole grain -requirement86 and (2) prevented USDA from implementing a reduction in sodium scheduled to -take effect in school year 2017-2018 until “the latest scientific research establishes the reduction -is beneficial for children.” The enacted FY2017 appropriation (§747 of P.L. 115-31) contained -related policy provisions. It extended the whole grain exemptions through SY2017-2018 and -(using different language from past years) limited enforcement of sodium limits to Target 1 -levels. In addition, a new appropriations provision was added in the FY2017 law that required -USDA to allow states to grant special exemptions to serve flavored, low-fat milk (instead of only -fat-free, flavored). - -In May 2017, shortly before the enactment of the FY2017 appropriations law (P.L. 115-31), -Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue announced plans to amend the whole grain, sodium, and -dairy aspects of the nutrition standards regulations in ways that were similar to the FY2017 law’s -provisions.87 In November 2017, USDA-FNS issued the interim final rule, which generally -extends through SY2018-2019 the three changes established by FY2017 appropriations. -Specifically, the interim final rule - -protein. School nutrition stakeholders expressed challenges with menu planning due to these particular restrictions, -USDA-FNS issued policy guidance that gave flexibility on these maximums for school years 2012-2013 and 2013- -2014. Then, in a subsequent regulation, USDA-FNS revised the regulations in January 2014 to lift these restrictions. -See, for example, USDA-FNS, “Certification of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch -Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. -82 See USDA-FNS Implementation Timeline, http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/implementation_timeline.pdf, -based on regulations. -83 “Whole grain-rich products must contain at least 51 percent whole grains and the remaining grains in the product -must be enriched.” 7 C.F.R. 210.10(c)(2)(iv). -84 The sodium targets set a maximum weekly level of sodium for breakfasts and lunches based on a student’s grade -level. Under Target 1, school lunches—on average over the school week—must contain ≤1,230 milligrams (mg) of -sodium for grades K-5, ≤1,360 mg for grades 6-8, and ≤1,420 mg for grades 9-12. -85 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, https://www.federalregister.gov/ -documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk-whole-grains-and-sodium- -requirements. -86 Exempted schools are to maintain a 50% whole grain minimum, the requirement before school year 2014-2015. -87 See CRS Insight IN10700, USDA Announces Plans to Modify School Meal Nutrition Standards: Background and -Context (available to congressional clients upon request). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -29 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - - - - - -continues to allow states to grant waivers to the whole grain-rich requirement; -allows schools to offer low-fat, flavored milk; and -continues Target 1 sodium limits, delaying implementation of Target 2 sodium -limits.88 - -The interim final rule indicated that USDA-FNS would publish a final rule in fall 2018, in time -for schools to implement in SY2019-2020. As of the date of this report, this final rule has not -been published. The FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141), enacted in March 2018, did not -make any changes to the standards. - -There were legislative proposals to change the nutrition standards on a more-permanent basis -during 114th Congress deliberations to reauthorize the child nutrition programs.89 As discussed -earlier, reauthorization was not completed in the 114th Congress and authorizing committees have -not considered such legislative proposals in the 115th Congress. - -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools - -In another major policy change, Section 208 of HHFKA gave USDA the authority to regulate -other foods in the school nutrition environment. Sometimes called “competitive foods,” this and -the related regulation pertain to foods and drinks sold in a la carte lines, vending machines, snack -bars and concession stands, and fundraisers. - -Relying on recommendations made by a 2007 IOM report,90 USDA-FNS promulgated a proposed -rule and then an interim final rule in June 2013, which went into effect for school year 2014- -2015.91 The interim final rule imposed nutrition guidelines for all non-meal foods and beverages -that are sold during the school day (defined as midnight until 30 minutes after dismissal). The -final rule, published on July 29, 2016, maintained the interim final rules with minor -modifications. Under the final standards, these foods must meet whole-grain requirements; have -certain primary ingredients; and meet calorie, sodium, and fat limits, among other requirements. -Schools are limited to a list of no- and low-calorie beverages they may sell (with larger portion -sizes and caffeine allowed in high schools). - -Regarding fundraisers, there are no limits on fundraisers of foods that meet the interim final rule’s -guidelines. Fundraisers outside of the school day are not subject to the guidelines. HHFKA and -the interim final rule provide states with discretion to exempt infrequent fundraisers of foods or -beverages that do not meet the nutrition standards. - -The rule does not limit foods brought from home, only foods sold at school during the school day. -The federal standards included are a minimum standard; states and school districts are permitted -to issue more stringent policies. - -88 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, available at -https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk- -whole-grains-and-sodium-requirements. -89 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. -90 IOM, Nutrition Standards for Foods in Schools: Leading the Way toward Healthier Youth, 2007, -https://www.nap.edu/catalog/11899/nutrition-standards-for-foods-in-schools-leading-the-way-toward. -91 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Nutrition -Standards for All Foods Sold in School as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule,” 81 -Federal Register 50131, July 29, 2016. Final rule and related resources available at USDA-FNS website at -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/tools-schools-focusing-smart-snacks. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -30 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP - -Similarly, Section 221 of HHFKA required USDA to update the meal pattern for CACFP. USDA- -FNS’s proposed rule, published January 15, 2015, relied upon an IOM panel’s recommendations -and the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.92 FNS reviewed comments and incorporated -feedback in the final rule, which was published on April 25, 2016.93 The updated meal patterns -went into effect on October 1, 2017. The rule changes both the infant meal pattern and child/adult -meal pattern in CACFP. It also revises the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and School -Breakfast Program (SBP) meal patterns for pre-kindergarten children (such changes were not -included in the January 2012 final regulation discussed earlier). - -Below are some examples of changes included in the final rule:94 - - For infant meals, changes include condensing the previously three infant age - - - -groups into two age groups, introducing solid foods at six months of age (unless -otherwise requested by a parent or guardian), providing fruits and vegetables for -older infants, and eliminating juice. The updated guidelines make policy changes -to support breastfeeding, including providing program reimbursements when -mothers come to child care centers or homes to breastfeed their infants. -In child and adult meals, changes include separate fruit and vegetable serving -requirements, as opposed to treating fruits and vegetables as one group, and -limiting juice to one serving per day. The rule also requires that at least one daily -serving of grains be whole-grain rich and limits the sugar in breakfast cereals and -yogurts served. Milk must be low-fat or fat-free, and flavored milk cannot be -served to children age five or younger. The updated standards also disallow -frying as an onsite preparation method. - - “Best practices” for the different age groups were included in the rule, not as -requirements for reimbursement but as examples of ideal policies to promote -good nutrition and health. Examples include the “best practice” that a center or -home provides mothers with a quiet, private area to breastfeed and the -recommendation to limit sugar in flavored milk served to children age six and -older. USDA-FNS subsequently elaborated on the best practices through policy -guidance.95 - -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals -In recent years, but particularly during the 114th Congress, policymakers have weighed policy -options to reach more children in the summer months using alternatives to congregate meal -service. - -92 Ibid. at 2037. IOM (Institute of Medicine), Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary Guidance for All. -Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2011. -93 USDA-FNS also notes that it thoroughly reviewed the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines, and determined that the final -rule, based on the 2010 guidelines, is consistent with the updated guidelines. USDA-FNS, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Meal Pattern Revisions Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule” 81 Federal -Register 24348 et seq., April 25, 2016, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/04/25/2016-09412/child-and- -adult-care-food-program-meal-pattern-revisions-related-to-the-healthy-hunger-free-kids-act. -94 Ibid. For summaries of updated meal patterns and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/meals-and-snacks. -95 USDA-FNS, “Optional Best Practices to Further Improve Nutrition in the Child and Adult Care Food Program Meal -Pattern,” June 30, 2016, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cacfp/CACFP15-2016os.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -31 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Current Law and Policy - -Under current law, most food offered in summer months is provided in congregate settings -through the SFSP or the NSLP’s Seamless Summer Option (SSO, an option only for schools) (see -“Summer Meals” section above). “Congregate” settings refer to specific sites where children -come to eat while supervised. Also, for the most part, non-school organizations that provide -summer and afterschool food need to participate in two separate programs (SFSP and CACFP At- -risk Afterschool). - -As discussed earlier, on a pilot basis in a limited geographic area each summer since 2011, USDA -has tested alternatives to SFSP and the SSO as required by law. Specifically, the 2010 Agriculture -Appropriations Act (Section 749(g) of P.L. 111-80) provided $85 million in discretionary funding -for “demonstration projects to develop and test methods of providing access to food for children -in urban and rural areas during the summer months.” The first of those demonstrations was called -the Enhanced Summer Food Service Program (eSFSP), which took place in the summers of 2010 -and 2012. eSFSP included four initiatives: (1) incentives for SFSP sites to lengthen operations to -40 or more days, (2) funding to add recreational or educational activities at meal sites, (3) meal -delivery for children in rural areas, and (4) “food backpacks” that children could take home on -weekends and holidays. - -Evaluations of eSFSP were published from 2011 to 2014.96 Participation rates rose during the -demonstration periods for all four initiatives. In addition, children in the meal delivery and -backpack demonstrations had consistent rates of food insecurity from summer to fall (this was not -measured for the other initiatives). However, the results of the evaluation should be interpreted -with caution due to a small sample size and potential confounding factors. - -As discussed earlier, the second demonstration, Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children -(SEBTC or Summer EBT), began in summer 2011 and is ongoing as of the date of this report; -this program provides SNAP or WIC benefits over EBT to households with children eligible for -free or reduced-price school meals. Most recently, FY2018 appropriations (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million for the demonstration. Evaluations of Summer EBT were conducted over a -three-year period from FY2011 to FY2013.97 The evaluations, which used rigorous designs, -showed a significant decline in Very Low Food Security in children (VLFS-C);98 the prevalence -of VLFS-C was reduced from 9.5% in the control group to 6.4% in the Summer EBT treatment -group.99 Evaluations also found improvements in children’s consumption of fruits, vegetables, - -96 Elinson et al., Evaluation of 2011 Enhanced Summer Food Service Program Demonstrations, prepared by Westat -under Contract No. GS-23F-8144H (Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2012), p. 4-21. -97 The first year, the proof-of-concept (POC) year, was evaluated to test the feasibility of the EBT delivery system and -prepare for full-implementation in demonstration sites for the following year. The second year, the full implementation -year, evaluated the impact of SEBTC on improving children’s food security and nutritional status in the summer time. -Finally, the third year compared the impact of two benefit levels, $60 and $30, to determine the effect of different -benefit levels on improving food security and nutritional status. Final reports and status reports to Congress are -available on the USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/summer-electronic-benefit-transfer-children-sebtc. -98 Very Low Food Security is the lowest of four levels of food security; USDA defines it as “At times during the year, -eating patterns of one or more household members were disrupted and food intake reduced because the household -lacked money and other resources for food.” USDA-ERS website, http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition- -assistance/food-security-in-the-us/measurement.aspx. See also CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: -Summary of Programs. -99 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus. Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013, p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -32 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -and whole grains. Both WIC and SNAP models showed increased consumption, but increases -were greater at sites operating the WIC model.100 - -In the summers from 2015 to 2018, USDA-FNS also offered non-congregate feeding options at -outdoor summer meal sites experiencing excessive heat.101 This demonstration has not been -evaluated. - -Congressional Proposals - -During the 114th Congress, committees of jurisdiction marked up child nutrition reauthorization -bills. Both committees of jurisdiction—the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and -Forestry and the House Committee on Education and the Workforce—reported reauthorization -legislation: S. 3136 and H.R. 5003, respectively. Both proposals would have piloted or expanded -a number of alternatives for feeding low-income children during the summer months. Still, there -were significant differences between the reauthorization proposals’ SFSP provisions.102 (There -were also committee hearings and freestanding proposals related to SFSP in the 114th -Congress.)103 - -The committees’ reauthorization bills included the following policies: - - Streamlining afterschool and summer programs. Both committees’ proposals -would have authorized eligible institutions in selected states to operate SFSP and -CACFP At-risk Afterschool sites under one application. The bills differed in the -number of states that would have been eligible and the reimbursement rates used. - - Summer EBT. Both proposals addressed the provision of benefits via EBT to -children who are eligible for free and reduced-price school meals over the -summer months. The Senate committee would have expanded this alternative -with mandatory funding. The House committee would have kept the existing -pilot funded with discretionary funding. The Senate committee would have -required states to provide WIC EBT, while the House committee would have -allowed participating states to provide SNAP or WIC. - - Off-Site Consumption Options. Both proposals included ways for some - -institutions (e.g., those located in rural areas) to provide SFSP meals for -consumption off-site. The bills also included temporary flexibilities for -congregate feeding sites to episodically provide meals to be consumed off-site -under certain conditions (e.g., extreme weather conditions). - - Other SFSP Policies. The Senate committee’s bill would have authorized - -discretionary funding for some states to pilot the provision of three meals per -day, or two meals and one snack. The House committee’s proposal would have - -100 Ibid., p. 124. -101 See USDA-FNS, “Demonstration Project for Non-Congregate Feeding for Outdoor Summer Meal Sites -Experiencing Excessive Heat with Q&As,” May 24, 2018, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/sfsp/ -SP14_SFSP04-2018os.pdf. -102 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview, for further legislative -background and a more detailed summary of summer meals and other program provisions. -103 During 114th Congress hearings, witnesses testified about SFSP and summer alternatives before the House -Committee on Education and the Workforce (April 15, 2015; June 16, 2015; June 24, 2015) and the Senate Committee -on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry (May 7, 2015). During the 114th Congress, introduced bills on summer meals -included S. 613/H.R. 1728, S. 1539/H.R. 2715, and S. 1966. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -33 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -authorized USDA to award competitive grants to improve SFSP service delivery -through business partnerships. - -These reauthorization bills have not been reintroduced in the 115th Congress; however, there have -been other legislative proposals in the 115th Congress to amend SFSP.104 - -Presidential Budget Proposals - -The Obama Administration’s FY2017 budget proposed a number of changes to SFSP. -Specifically, the administration proposed to expand Summer EBT nationwide, with a phase-in -over 10 years.105 The administration also requested $10 million for a new Summer Food Service -Non-Congregate Demonstration Project. - -The Trump Administration’s FY2018 and FY2019 budgets did not include any new SFSP -legislative proposals. The budgets requested continued funding for Summer EBT. - -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” - -The issue of stigmatizing a child who owes and does not pay his or her meal costs, commonly -referred to as “lunch shaming,” has received increased attention in recent years.106 Some practices -that school districts have adopted in response to such situations include taking or throwing away a -student’s selected hot foods and providing an alternative cold meal (more common) to stamping -students’ arms and making them wear stickers (less common).107 One reason why these instances -may occur is that payments for reduced-price and full-price meals are a source of revenue for -school food programs (in addition to federal NSLP and SBP reimbursements). Schools have an -interest in collecting this revenue from children’s families to help fund operations.108 - -Some have pointed out that the Community Eligibility Provision (discussed earlier in this report) -is a strategy to prevent unpaid meal charges by providing free meals to all children in qualifying -schools.109 - -Congress and USDA have taken some recent actions to address the issues of lunch shaming and -unpaid meal costs. Section 143 of the HHFKA of 2010 required USDA to examine states’ and - -104 See, for example, the Summer Meals Act of 2017 (H.R. 203) and legislation “To amend the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act to establish a permanent, nationwide summer electronic benefits transfer for children -program” (H.R. 6516S. 3268). -105 Details about the Obama Administration’s Nationwide Summer EBT proposal are available in the FY2017 budget -USDA-FNS Explanatory Notes on p. 32-34, http://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2017notes.pdf. -106 There is no official definition of “lunch shaming.” Legislation in the 115th Congress, the Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017 (H.R. 2401/S. 1064), refers to lunch shaming as “the stigmatization of children who are unable to pay for -meals.” -107 Typically, an alternative meal includes unflavored milk, a cheese or peanut butter-and-jelly sandwich, and a fruit or -vegetable. May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and -Practices for School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12. Prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10- -0048. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014, p. 147-148. -108 If they are unable to recover these funds, the money becomes “bad debt” and the school or school district must use -other non-federal funding sources to cover the costs (7 C.F.R. 200.426). See p. 2 of USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, -“Unpaid Meal Charges: Clarification on Collection of Delinquent Meal Payments,” July 8, 2016, at https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP47-2016os.pdf. -109 See, for example, James Weill, “How to stop school lunch shaming? Leave kids out of it,” The Hill, at -http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/education/333003-how-to-stop-school-lunch-shaming-leave-kids-out-of-it; U.S. -Department of Agriculture, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate -Meals, June 2016, at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -34 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -school districts’ policies and practices regarding unpaid meal charges. As part of the review, the -law required USDA to “prepare a report on the feasibility of establishing national standards for -meal charges and the provision of alternate meals” and, if relevant, make recommendations -related to the implementation of the standards. Section 143 also permitted USDA to take follow- -up actions based on the findings from the report.110 - -USDA’s subsequent June 2016 Report to Congress did not recommend national standards, but -rather recommended “clarifying and updating policy guidance on specific national policies -impacting unpaid meal charges and facilitating the development and distribution of best practices -to support decision making by States and localities.”111 USDA-FNS followed up with a -memorandum requiring school food authorities (SFAs) to institute and communicate—by July 1, -2017—a written meal charge policy, which was to include instructions on how to address -situations in which a child does not pay for a meal.112 USDA-FNS also provided clarification -through webinars, other memoranda, and a best practice guide.113 - -USDA stated that its recommendation was based on findings from a national study of HHFKA -implementation and a Request for Information (RFI) related to unpaid meal charges that garnered -462 responses. The study, conducted in SY2011-2012, found that 58% of SFAs reported incurring -unpaid meal charges prior to recovery attempts.114 Of these SFAs, 50.4% served a reimbursable -meal to children unable to pay, 38.0% served an alternative meal, 5.4% combined these -approaches, 4.9% did something else (“Other”), and 1.3% did not serve a meal. Both the findings -from the study and the RFI showed that meal charge policies were largely determined at the -school- and district-level rather than the state level.115 The responses to the RFI also indicated that -such policies ranged in formality, with varying degrees of review (e.g., some required school -board approval while others did not) and enforcement. In the RFI comments, school and district -officials generally expressed a preference for local control in designing meal charge policies -while advocates generally favored national standards. - -The topics of lunch shaming and unpaid meal costs have since surfaced in the 115th Congress. As -examples of congressional activity on this issue, proposed legislation (Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017; H.R. 2401/S. 1064) would establish national standards for how schools treat children -unable to pay for a meal.116 - -110 Specifically, Section 143 of HHFKA authorizes USDA to (1) implement standards;, (2) implement demonstration -projects, or (3) further study the feasibility of the recommendations. -111 USDA, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate Meals, June -2016, p. 5, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. -112 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges: Local Meal Charge Policies,” July 8, 2016, https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP46-2016os.pdf. -113 For a list of resources, see USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges,” https://www.fns.usda.gov/ -school-meals/unpaid-meal-charges. -114 May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and Practices for -School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12, prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10-0048 -(Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014), p. 147-148, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/SNOPSYear1.pdf. -115 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Request for Information: Unpaid Meal Charges,” 79 Federal Register 62095, -October 16, 2014. -116 Specifically, the legislation would prohibit SFAs from (1) publicly identifying children who cannot pay for a meal -or those who have meal debt, (2) having those children perform chores or other activities, and (3) throwing away a -child’s meal. See Section 2 of H.R. 2401 and S. 1064 (identical text). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -35 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In addition, a provision in the FY2018 appropriations law (Section 768 of P.L. 115-141) -established that appropriated funds cannot be used in a way that results in discrimination against -children eligible for free or reduced-price meals, including the practices of segregating children -and overtly identifying children by special tokens or tickets.117 - -117 See Section 9(b)(10) of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(10)) and 7 C.F.R. -245.8. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -36 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report - -Table A-1. Acronyms - -Government Agencies - -USDA - -U.S. Department of Agriculture - -USDA-FNS - -Food and Nutrition Service - -CACFP - -FFVP - -NSLP - -SBP - -SEBTC - -SFSP - -SMP - -CEP - -CPI-U - -FPL - -Programs - -Child and Adult Care Food Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program - -National School Lunch Program - -School Breakfast Program - -Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children - -Summer Food Service Program - -Special Milk Program - -Miscellaneous - -Community Eligibility Provision - -Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers - -Federal Poverty Level - -HHFKA - -Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-296) - -IOM - -LEA - -RCCI - -SFA - -Institute of Medicine - -Local Educational Agency - -Residential Child Care Institution - -School Food Authority - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -37 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement -Rates for Child Nutrition Programs118 -This appendix lists the specific reimbursement rates discussed in the earlier sections of the report. -Reimbursement rates are adjusted for inflation for each school or calendar year according to -terms laid out in the programs’ authorizing laws. Each year, the new rates are announced in the -Federal Register.119 - -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches -Per-meal reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Serve Less than 60% of -Lunches as Free and -Reduced-Price - -Serve 60% or More of -Lunches as Free or -Reduced-Price - -Bonus Available for -School Districts -Certified as Compliant -with Nutrition +Piecing It All Together: Verifying Multi-Hop Multimodal Claims +| | HaoranWang♡ | | | AmanRangapur♡ | | | XiongxiaoXu♡ | | YueqingLiang♡ | | | | +| ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------------------ | --------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | HaroonGharwi♡ | | | CarlYang♣ | KaiShu♣* | | | | | +| | | | ♡IllinoisInstituteofTechnology | | | | ♣EmoryUniversity | | | | | | +| {hwang219, | | | arangapur, | | | xxu85, | yliang40, | hgharwi}@hawk.iit.edu | | | | | +| | | | | {j.carlyang, | | | kai.shu}@emory.edu | | | | | | +Abstract +Claim: The driver seen signing autographs outside had a +significant points total during a specific race in 2001 while +competing for a well-known team in stock car racing. +| Existing | | claim | verification | datasets | | often do | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| not | require | systems | to | perform | complex | rea- | | | | | | | +4202 ceD 21 ]LC.sc[ 2v74590.1142:viXra Table Evidence: Image Evidence: +soningoreffectivelyinterpretmultimodalevi- +dence.Toaddressthis,weintroduceanewtask: +| multi-hopmultimodalclaimverification. | | | | | | This | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskchallengesmodelstoreasonovermultiple +| pieces | of | evidence | from | diverse | sources, | in- | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | -------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cludingtext,images,andtables,anddetermine +| whether | | the combined | | multimodal | | evidence | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Label: Support +| supports | | or refutes | a | given claim. | | To study | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| this | task, | we construct | | MMCV, | a large-scale | | | | | | | | +Figure1:Anillustrationofa2-hopclaimfromMMCV. +datasetcomprising15kmulti-hopclaimspaired +Tocorrectlyverifythisclaim,thesystemmustreason +| with | multimodal | | evidence, | generated | | and re- | | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +overboththeimageevidenceandthetableevidence. +finedusinglargelanguagemodels,withaddi- +| tionalinputfromhumanfeedback. | | | | | Weshow | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thatMMCVischallengingevenforthelatest oftenrequiremulti-hopreasoning,whereasetof +state-of-the-artmultimodallargelanguagemod- +connectedevidencepiecesleadstothefinalverdict +els,especiallyasthenumberofreasoninghops +| | | | | | | | of a claim | (Yang | et al., | 2018). | As a result, | there | +| ---------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ----- | +| increases. | | Additionally,weestablishahuman | | | | | | | | | | | +isaneedforautomatedtoolstoassisthumanfact- +performancebenchmarkonasubsetofMMCV. +checkersinevaluatingtheveracityofmultimodal +| We | hope | this dataset | | and its | evaluation | task | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| willencouragefutureresearchinmultimodal | | | | | | | multi-hopclaims. | | | | | | +multi-hopclaimverification. Dataandcodeare Claimverification,whichinvolvesassessingthe +available: https://mmcv-dataset.github.io/ veracity of an input claim against a collection of +evidence,isavitaltoolincombatingthespreadof +misinformation(ThorneandVlachos,2018;Guo +1 Introduction +| | | | | | | | et al., 2022; | Jin | et al., | 2022, | 2023; Yang | et al., | +| --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | +| Due | to the | rapid growth | | in AI-generated | | content | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 2022). However,verifyingmulti-hopmultimodal | | | | | | +(Huangetal.,2024a,b;Zhangetal.,2024;Jinetal., +| | | | | | | | claims introduces | | new challenges | | in both | dataset | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +2024b),itisdifficultforautomatedfact-checking constructionandeffectivemodeling. Unlikesingle- +systemstokeepupwithverifyingtheaccuracyof +| | | | | | | | hop claims, | which | require | only | straightforward | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | +| claimswithmultimodalevidence. | | | | | Thischallenge | | | | | | | | +one-stepreasoning,multi-hopclaimsrequiremul- +isfurtherexacerbatedbytherecentdevelopmentof tiplereasoningstepstoreachafinalverdict. Fur- +diffusionmodelssuchasDALL-E(Rameshetal., +thermore,theinclusionofmultimodalevidencere- +2021)andStableDiffusion(Rombachetal.,2022), +quiresmodelstounderstandandintegrateinforma- +| which | can | generate | realistic | images | from | textual | | | | | | | +| ----- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionacrossvariousmodalities,suchastext,images, +prompts(Liuetal.,2024b). Thesepowerfultools andtables,makingitmorecomplextocomprehend +| could | enable | attackers | to | produce | misleading | | in- | | | | | | +| ----- | ------ | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | andextractrelevantinformation. | | | | Forinstance,to | | +formation(WangandShu,2024;Panetal.,2023c; +verifytheclaimshowninFigure1,asystemmust +Huang et al., 2024c; Gao et al., 2024; Jin et al., understandthesemanticcontentoftheimage,in- +| 2024a) | at a | low cost. | Additionally, | | these | claims | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tegrateallrelevantinformationfromthetableevi- +*Correspondingauthor dence,andapplymulti-stepreasoningtoarriveat + +Dataset Multimodal Multi-hop EvidenceRetrieval AnnotatedEvidence AnnotatedLabel +| | | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018) +| Liar(Wang,2017) | | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +FakeNewsNet(Shuetal.,2020) +| NewsCLIPpings(Luoetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Factify(Mishraetal.,2022) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | +| COSMOS(Anejaetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| InfoSurgeon(Fungetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | +Fauxtography(Zlatkovaetal.,2019) +| HoVer(Jiangetal.,2020) | | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +Mocheg(Yaoetal.,2023) +| MMCV(Ours) | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Table 1: Comparison between MMCV and other claim verification datasets. The columns indicate whether +thedatasetrequiresmultimodalcontent,multi-hopreasoning,explanationgeneration,andwhetheritcontains +annotatedevidence. +thefinalconclusion. enhanceMLLMs’reasoningcapabilities,including +In this paper, we introduce the task of multi- chain-of-thought, self-ask, and symbolic-guided +hopmultimodalclaimverificationtoevaluatethe reasoning. Additionally,weestablishahumanper- +veracity of multi-hop claims against multimodal formancebenchmarkonasubsetofMMCV. +evidence. To study this task, we construct Multi- Overall, we introduce a challenging multi-hop +hopMultimodalClaim-Verification(MMCV),a multimodalclaimverificationdatasetthatincludes +datasetof15Kmulti-hopclaimspairedwithmul- claimswithupto4reasoninghops. Thesecomplex +timodal evidence that either SUPPORT or RE- claims often consist of multiple sentences linked +FUTE each claim. To create the dataset, we de- bycoreferenceanddemandevidencefromvarious +velopanovelpipelinethatuseslargelanguagemod- modalities,suchastext,images,andtables. Table1 +els(LMMs)fordataannotation,supportedbyhu- providesacomparisonbetweenMMCVandexist- +manfeedback. Thismethodsignificantlyreduces ingpopularclaimverificationdatasets. Whilecur- +theworkloadonhumanannotatorsandcutscosts, rentdatasetstypicallyfocusoneithermultimodal +while ensuring high quality and factual accuracy claimsormulti-hoptextualclaims, noneofthem +| ofthedataset. | OurpipelinefirstusesLLMstore- | | | | | | +| ------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +incorporatemulti-hopmultimodalclaimsthatne- +formulatemulti-hopmultimodalquestion-answer cessitatecross-modalreasoning. Wehopethatthe +pairsintoatomicmulti-hopclaimsandgeneratea introductionofMMCVanditscorrespondingeval- +set of candidate claims. These candidate claims uationtaskwillinspirefurtherresearchincomplex +are then modified to include additional hops and multi-hopmultimodalreasoningforclaimverifica- +refined for fluency and clarity according to a set tion. Insummary,ourcontributionsinclude: +| of annotation | guidelines. | To ensure | the accuracy | | | | +| ------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +oftheclaims,weuseaRetrieval-AugmentedGen- +• Weintroduceandformalizethemulti-hopmul- +eration (RAG)-based validation method to verify timodalclaimverificationtask. +| theirvalidity. | Finally,weaskagroupofhumanan- | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +notatorstoscoretheclaimsbasedontheirfluency, • We develop a novel pipeline that leverages +correctness, and clearness, and manually rewrite LLMs for data annotation, enhanced by hu- +theclaimsthatarebelowacertainthreshold. man feedback, to construct a benchmark +WeestablishperformancebaselinesonMMCV dataset for multi-hop multimodal claim ver- +using three state-of-the-art multimodal large lan- ification. This method significantly lowers +guage models (MLLMs) and highlight their lim- thecostandlaborrequiredtoproducealarge- +| itations | in verifying | complex multimodal | claims. | scaledataset. | | | +| ---------- | ------------ | ------------------ | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| We further | demonstrate | the challenges | posed by | | | | +thedataset,especiallyasthenumberofreasoning • Weestablishbaselineperformanceonthistask +hopsincreases,byillustratingtheconstrainedper- using MLLMs and human evaluation. Our +formanceofvariousprompttechniquesdesignedto analysis shows that this is a non-trivial task, + +withseveralchallengesthatremaintobead- then-generate pipeline using LLMs for iterative +dressedinfuturework. datasynthesis, while(Paceetal.,2024)combine +theBest-of-NandWorst-of-Nsamplingstrategies +| 2 Background | | | | | | to introduce | the West-of-N | approach. | | With | this | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | same objective, | the multi-hop | | claims | in MMCV | | +Multimodal Claim Verification. Previous re- arecreatedandrefinedbyLLMsusinghumanfeed- +searchonclaimverificationhasprimarilyfocused +| | | | | | | back, following | guidelines | and | rules | specifically | | +| -------------- | ------------------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------ | +| on textual | data. | However, | with | the | growing | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | designed | to enforce a multi-hop | | structure | | within | +| recognition | that misinformation | | | often | appears | eachclaim. | | | | | | +| across | multiple modalities | | and that | multimodal | | | | | | | | +| misinformation | is | perceived | as more | | credible | | | | | | | +and spreads fasterthan text-only misinformation, 3 The MMCV dataset +| recent | efforts have shifted | | toward verifying | | mul- | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +timodal claims (Akhtar et al., 2023). As a result, Themaingoalofourworkistocompileadiverse +severalmultimodalclaimverificationdatasetshave andextensive collectionofmulti-hopclaims that +| | | | | | | require | joint reasoning | across | evidence | from | dif- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | ---- | +beenproposedincludingFakeNewsNet(Shuetal., +ferentmodalities,suchastext,tables,andimages, +2020),COSMOS(Anejaetal.,2021),InfoSurgeon +(Fung et al., 2021), Factify (Mishra et al., 2022), forverification. Oneapproachtoachievingthisis +Fauxtography(Zlatkovaetal.,2019),andMocheg totransformmultimodalquestion-answeringpairs +intoatomicclaimsandrefinethemtoincorporate +| (Yao et | al., 2023). | However, | to the | best | of our | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +knowledge, there are no existing datasets for additionalreasoningsteps,makingthemmorenat- +multi-hop multimodal claim verification, which ural. However, there are two major challenges +| | | | | | | in creating | such a dataset: | first, | building | | a large- | +| ---------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | +| challenges | the system’s | reasoning | | capability | by | | | | | | | +scaledatasetislabor-intensiveandcostly;second, +| requiring | it to integrate | | and interpret | | multiple | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +piecesofevidencefromdifferentmodalities. inourpilotstudies, wefoundthatsimplyprovid- +inginstructionstocrowdworkersandaskingthem +| | | | | | | to rewrite | multi-hop claims | is | counterproductive, | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| Multi-hopReasoning. | | Verifyingcomplexclaims | | | | | | | | | | +asitisdifficulttocontrolqualityandchallenging +| often requires | multi-step | | (multi-hop) | reasoning | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(Mavi et al., 2022), which requires combining forworkerstocreatemeaningfulmulti-hopclaims. +| | | | | | | Instead, | we develop a pipeline | | that | leverages | the | +| ----------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | +| information | from multiple | | pieces of | evidence | to | | | | | | | +emergingcapabilitiesoflargelanguagemodelsto +| predict | the veracity | of a | claim. Many | | recently | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +proposed datasets are created to challenge a generatetextandlearnfromfeedback,withhuman +inputtoensurethequalityofthefinaloutput. +model’sabilitytoreasonacrossmultiplesentences +Inthisapproach,LLMshandlethemundanetask +| ordocuments. | TheseincludeMultiRC(Khashabi | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | of rewriting | claims consistently | | according | | to the | +| et al., | 2018), QAngaroo | | (Welbl | et al., | 2018), | | | | | | | +ComplexWebQuestion(TalmorandBerant,2018), instructions,whilehumaneffortissignificantlyre- +ducedtoqualitycontrolofthefinalclaimsbased +| HotpotQA | (Yang et | al., 2018), | and | HoVer | (Jiang | | | | | | | +| ------------ | -------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | onasetofguidelines. | Figure2showstheoverall | | | | | +| etal.,2020). | Incontrasttothesedatasets, | | | | MMCV | | | | | | | +incorporates context from various modalities, workflowofourdataconstructionpipeline,which +such as images and tables, further challenging contains three stages: LLM-Based Claim Gener- +| | | | | | | ation (§3.1), | LLM-Generated | | Claim | Refinement | | +| ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| the system’s | ability | to understand | | and integrate | | | | | | | | +(§3.2)andClaimAnnotationbyHuman(§3.3). +evidencefromdifferentsources. +| | | | | | | 3.1 ClaimGeneration | | | | | | +| --------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Construct | Synthetic | Dataset | with | LLMs. | The | | | | | | | +emergenceofadvancedlargelanguagemodelshas In this stage, we leverage the in-context learning +sparked growing interest in automating the data capabilitiesoflargelanguagemodelstotransform +annotationprocessusingLLMs(Tanetal.,2024; question-answer pairs from the MultimodalQA +Wu et al., 2024; Bao et al., 2024; Chen et al., dataset(Talmoretal.,2021)intoverifiableclaims. +2024), driven by their advanced capabilities, in- To minimize the impact of in-context examples +cluding in-context learning (Dong et al., 2022) on the quality of the generated claims, we care- +andlearningfromhumanfeedback(Ouyangetal., fully craft a pool of 20 in-context examples and +2022). (Wang et al., 2023) propose an explain- randomly select 3 for use during execution. The + +| | Stage 1: Claim | | | Stage 2: Claim | | | Stage 3: Claim | | | +| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | Generation | | | Refinement | | | Annotation | | | +Multihop QA Pair & Multimodal Claim Modification and Refinement Claim Negation: +Context: +Supported: "Adam Kennedy had fewer +| | | | | Claim | Refined | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Q: Did Adam Kennedy or the player with a Candidate Claim RBIs during the Anaheim Angels' 2004 +red stripe on his pants, red logo on his shirt, Iteration season than the player wearing a red stripe +and a blue helmet have a lower RBI in the Threshold YES on his pants, a red logo on his shirt, and a +| Anaheim Angels' 2004 season? | | | | | | blue helmet. | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| A: Adam Kennedy | | | | Claim | isGood? | | | | | +| | | | Modification | | | Not Supported: Adam Kennedy had more | | | | +NO +RBIs during the Anaheim Angels' 2006 +In seven seasons with the season than the player wearing a red stripe +Textual +Angels, Kennedy hit … with on his pants, a red logo on his shirt, and a +| | | 51 home runs and 353 RBI. | | Feedback | | blue helmet. | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | Factuality Validation using RAG: | | | Claim Scoring: | | | | +He holds Angels franchise +records for …, runs batted +● Fluency: 4 +in (RBI) (1,292), … +| | | | | Refined | Key | ● Correctness: 3 | | isBelow? | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | Claim | Entities | ● Clearness: 3 | | | | +Claim Candidate: +Claim Rewriting: +Large +Adam Kennedy had fewer RBIs during the +| | | | | Language | | "Adam Kennedy had fewer RBIs during the | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Anaheim Angels' 2004 season than the | | | | Model | | | | | | +player wearing a red stripe on his pants, a Anaheim Angels' 2004 season than the +player wearing a red stripe on his pants, a +| red logo on his shirt, and a blue helmet. | | | | Prompt | Detecting | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | Diversifier | Factual Errors | red logo on his shirt, and a blue helmet. | | | | +Figure2:OverviewofdatacollectionflowchartforMMCV.Inthefirststage,were-formulatequestion-answerpairs +fromMultimodalQAtogeneratecandidateclaims. Inthesecondstage,wemodifyandrefinethecandidateclaims, +andapplyaRetrieval-AugmentedGeneration(RAG)-basedmethodtoverifytheircorrectness. Inthefinalstage,we +askhumanannotatorstorankthecandidateclaimstoselectthebestoneandlabelthefinalclaimsaccordingly. +claimsareformulatedtoensurethatnoinformation mariesoftheirrespectiveWikipediaarticlesascon- +isomittedfromtheoriginalQApairsandnonew textandinstructtheLLMstomodifytheclaimin +information is introduced. Since the claims are suchawaythatitincorporatesthiscontextualin- +deriveddirectlyfromthequestionandthecorrect formation to replace the entity, ensuring that the +answer, they are automatically labeled as SUP- entity’snamedoesnotappeardirectlyintheclaim. +PORT.Theprompttemplateforclaimgeneration +TohelpLLMsunderstandthemodificationtask, +islistedinAppendixA.2. +| | | | | | we provide | them with | 3-5 randomly | selected | in- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | +contextexamplesfromapoolofhand-craftedex- +3.2 ClaimRefinement +amples. Aftermodifyingtheclaim,weobtainfeed- +After generating the initial claims from the backfromLLMsregardingthefluency,correctness, +| | | | | | andclarityofthemodifiedclaim. | | Thecriteriaused | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +question-answerpairs,wemodifyandrefinethem +forthisassessmentarelistedintheAppendixA.2. +toensuretheyaremorenaturallyphrasedandmore +Ifthefeedbacksuggestsfurtherimprovement,the +| accuratelysupportedbythefacts. | | | Next,wereview | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the claims for any factual errors that may have claimissentbacktothemodificationstep,incorpo- +ratingtheLLMs’feedbackuntilacertainiteration +| been | introduced | during the | modification | process | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------- | --------- | ----------- | --------------- | ----- | ----- | +| | | | | | threshold | is reached. | If the modified | claim | still | +andmakecorrectionsasneeded. +| | | | | | does not | pass the quality | check, it | is marked | for | +| ----- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| Claim | Modification | and Refinement. | | To intro- | | | | | | +manualreviewandrevisionbyhumanannotators. +| duce | additional | reasoning steps | to the | claim can- | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | --------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +didate,weemployamodify-then-refineapproach RAG-based Truthfulness Validation. Since we +that iteratively enhances the quality of the modi- introduceadditionalcontextualinformationfrom +fiedclaimcandidatebasedonfeedbackfromLLMs Wikipedia when modifying the claims, there is +(Panetal.,2023a). Specifically,webeginbyiden- a risk that LLMs might hallucinate and produce +tifyingtheWikipediaentitiesmentionedinthean- outputs that are not faithful to the input context. +swers from the question-answer pairs. If there is To eliminate potential factual errors, we use a +onlyoneWikipediaentityintheanswer,weleave retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) (Lewis +theclaimcandidateunchanged. However,ifthere et al., 2020)-based pipeline to retrieve the full +are multiple Wikipedia entities, we use the sum- Wikipedia articles of the relevant entities and + +validatethefactualaccuracyofthemodifiedclaims. Data 1-hop 2-hop 3-hop 4-hop +Tomitigatetheimpactofpromptsensitivityonthe +| | | | | | | | #Claims | | | 5,884 | 8,485 | 804 | 396 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +model’soutput(Luetal.,2022;Sclaretal.,2023), +| | | | | | | | Ave.#TokensinClaim | | | 21.7 | 25.32 | 25.44 | 26.17 | +| ----------------------------------- | --------------- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ---- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| we diversify | the | prompts | by | randomly | changing | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Max.#TokensinClaim | | | 48 | 58 | 51 | 63 | +| theirformatforeachverificationstep. | | | | | Forinstance, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #TextEvidence | | | 2,590 | 7,323 | 1,142 | 760 | +| instead | of consistently | | using | | Is it | true | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #ImageEvidence | | | 1,979 | 2,948 | 634 | 512 | +| that {claim}?, | | the | prompt | | is randomly | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #TableEvidence | | | 1,315 | 6,699 | 636 | 312 | +chosenfromasetofequivalentalternatives,such +as Verify the following statement: #SUPPORTLabels 2,824 4,030 349 158 +{claim} or What evidence supports #REFUTELabels 3,060 4,455 455 238 +| the claim | that | {claim}? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | Table2: | DatasetStatisticsofMMCV. | | | | | +3.3 ClaimAnnotation +| At this stage, | we | have | obtained | claims | that | have | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | detailed | in Table | 2. | The | number | of hops | is | +beenmodifiedandrefinedbyLLMsandfactually +| | | | | | | | determined | by | the count | of | multimodal | evidence | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +validated by RAG-based pipelines. Next, we use associatedwitheachclaim. Thedatasetincludesa +LLMstogeneratenegatedclaimsbyapplyingaset +balanceddistributionofSUPPORTandREFUTE +| ofspecificnegationrules. | | | Weemploythreedistinct | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | claims. | Specifically,thereare5,8841-hopclaims | | | | | | +methodsforgeneratingthesenegatedclaims. For with an average of 21.7 tokens per claim; 8,485 +instance,giventheclaim,“Sinceitsconstruction 2-hop claims averaging 25.32 tokens per claim; +in1889,theEiffelTowerinParisattractsmillions +8043-hopclaimswithanaverageof25.44tokens +ofvisitorsannually.”,theresultsafterapplyingthe +| | | | | | | | perclaim; | and3964-hopclaimsaveraging26.17 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +negationrulesareasfollows: tokensperclaim. Anexamplefromthedatasetis +| Negation | | | | | | | providedinAppendixA.1. | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +▷Wordsubstitution:TheEiffelTowerinParishouses +millionsofresidentsannually. Multi-hop Reasoning Types. We provide +▷Entitysubstitution:TheColosseuminParisattracts +| | | | | | | | examples | of | each | reasoning | type | in Table | 6. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | +millionsofvisitorsannually. +▷Temporalmutation:Eversinceitsconstructionin Most1-hopand2-hopclaimsrequireatleastone +2050,theEiffelTowerhasbeenParis’stoptouristsite. +supportingfactfromeitherimageortableevidence +| | | | | | | | forverification. | | Incontrast,themajorityof3-hop | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Next,agroupofhumanannotatorsistaskedwith and 4-hop claims require evidence from all three +evaluating the claims based on three dimensions: modalities. The process of removing a bridge +| | | | | | | | entity and | replacing | | it with | a relative | clause | or | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | +| fluency, | correctness, | and | clarity, | scoring | | each di- | | | | | | | | +mension on a scale of 1 to 5. Fluency assesses phrase significantly increases the informational +hownaturallytheclaimreads,asoutputsgenerated load of a single hypothesis. As a result, some +bylanguagemodelscansometimessoundartificial. 3-hop and 4-hop claims are relatively longer and +Correctnessevaluateswhethertheclaimisfactually exhibitcomplexsyntacticandreasoningstructures. +accuratebasedontheevidence. Claritydetermines Our experimental results also indicate that the +iftheclaimiseasilyunderstood,asentitysubstitu- difficultyformodelstoverifyclaimsescalatesas +thehopcountincreases. +| tionmightmakeitdifficulttocomprehend. | | | | | | Once | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| the claims | are scored, | | the average | | of the | fluency, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 5 ExperimentsandResults | | | | | | | +correctness,andclarityscoresiscalculatedtode- +| terminethefinalscoreforeachclaim. | | | | | Ifaclaim’s | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Inthissection,wediscussourexperimentsettings +finalscorefallsbelowapredeterminedthreshold, +(§5.1),theexperimentresults(§5.2),andtheerror +| it is flagged | and | sent | back to | the | annotators | for | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | analysis(§5.3). | | Webeginbyformallydefiningthe | | | | | +| manual revision. | | Detailed | annotation | | guidelines | | | | | | | | | +MMCVtaskbelow. +arelistedinAppendixA.3. +| | | | | | | | Task Definition. | | | The formulation | | of | multi- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | +4 DatasetAnalysis +| | | | | | | | hop multimodal | | claim | verification | | is defined | as | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | +Dataset Statistics. MMCV contains 15,569 follows: GivenaclaimC,andalistofmultimodal +multi-hopmultimodalclaims,withtheirstatistics evidence E(C), which includes text, images, + +1-hop 2-hop 3-hop 4-hop +Retrieval Model P R F1 P R F1 P R F1 P R F1 +GPT-4O 76.86 72.94 71.79 67.96 63.30 60.66 62.88 58.89 56.17 67.93 62.39 61.20 +Closed-book GEMINI 75.67 71.44 70.15 69.10 64.19 61.73 66.74 61.10 58.44 63.78 59.90 58.69 +LLAVA 64.18 63.78 63.57 64.06 63.93 63.87 66.78 66.81 66.76 64.64 64.84 64.64 +GPT-4O 76.95 72.95 71.78 68.03 63.24 60.53 62.67 58.78 56.08 67.75 62.46 61.35 +Open-book GEMINI 79.58 79.25 79.20 72.38 71.85 71.66 66.37 65.90 65.86 67.21 66.86 66.97 +LLAVA 62.86 59.68 57.21 64.17 62.48 61.50 65.47 64.64 63.76 66.50 66.76 66.42 +Table3: WereportthePrecision,Recall,andF1scoresofvariousMLLMsonMMCVforzero-shotmultimodal +claimverification. Intheclosed-booksetting,themodelverifiestheclaimwithoutaccesstoanyexternalknowledge +sources. Intheopen-booksetting,themodelisprovidedwithasetofgoldevidence. Thebest-performingmodelfor +eachhopishighlightedinGreenforbothsettings. +and tables, the system must reason over all the evaluate the performance of an open-source +evidenceandpredictthelabeloftheclaimaseither MLLM, LLaVA-V1.5-7B (Liu et al., 2024a), on +SUPPORT or REFUTE. MMCV. The temperature is set to 0.0, and the +maximumnumberoftokensissetto5000. +5.1 ExperimentSettings +Prompts for Enhanced Reasoning In ad- +As there are no existing models specifically de- +dition to the prompt mentioned above, we +signedformulti-hopmultimodalsupervisedclaim +conductexperimentsusingspecializedprompting +verification, we conduct our experiments using +techniques aimed at eliciting reasoning from +MLLMs. Moreover, previous studies in textual +LLMs, such as Chain-of-Thought (Wei et al., +claim verification and multimodal claim verifica- +2022) and Self-Ask (Press et al., 2023). We +tion indicate that LLMs and MLLMs can signifi- +also test symbolic-guided reasoning prompts +cantlyenhancetaskperformancecomparedtotra- +like ProgramFC (Pan et al., 2023b) and Visual +ditionalsupervisedapproaches(Panetal.,2023b; +Programming (Gupta and Kembhavi, 2023). To +Wang and Shu, 2023; Li et al., 2024; Geng et al., +minimize the overall cost of the experiments, we +2024b). Furthermore, supervised methods often +randomly select 100 examples from each hop of +requireextensiveannotatedcorpora,whicharedif- +the MMCV dataset for testing. The experiments +ficulttoacquireandlimitdomaintransferability,as +areconductedusingopen-booksetting. +trainingdatatypicallycoversonlyasingledomain. +Zero-shot Claim Verification. We establish Human Performance To benchmark hu- +performance baselines for zero-shot multimodal man performance on our dataset, we used the +claimverificationusingvariousMLLMsundertwo same randomly selected examples employed in +settings. Intheclosed-booksetting,themodeldoes theenhancedreasoningpromptexperiments. We +notretrieveinformationfromexternalknowledge recruitedfourexpertsinautomatedfact-checking +sourcesandmustrelyonitsparametric(internal) researchtoclassifymultihopclaimsfromMMCV +knowledge to verify the claim. In the open-book based on the provided evidence. The SMART +setting, the model is provided with a set of gold (Chewetal.,2019)framework1wasusedtodeploy +evidence. Specifically, we use the prompt from theannotationtask,andhumanperformancewas +(Geng et al., 2024b), which extracts the models’ evaluatedusingthemacroF-1score. +predictions, explanations, and confidence levels. +The prompt is listed in Appendix A.2. We use 5.2 ExperimentResults +macroprecision,recall,andF-1scoretoevaluate +Main Results. We report the comprehensive +themodelperformance. +results of the three MLLMs on MMCV in Table +3, highlighting the best-performing models for +MLLM. We utilize two state-of-the-art MLLMs: +each hop under both open-book and closed-book +GPT-4o (Achiam et al., 2023) and Gemini 1.5 +Flash (Team et al., 2023). Additionally, we 1https://github.com/RTIInternational/SMART + +| | | Confidence Level Distribution | | | | | | | Calibration Curve | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +100 +3hop_gpt-4_closed_book +| 70000 | | 4hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | +| | | 2hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| | | 3hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 1hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | 80 | | | | 3hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| 60000 | | | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| | | 4hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gemini_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| 50000 | | 1hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | )%( ycaruccA | | | | | | +| ycneuqerF | | 3hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 1hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | 60 | | | | 3hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gemini_open_book | | +| 40000 | | 4hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_llava_open_book | | +2hop_gemini_open_book +| | | 4hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| ----- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| 30000 | | 4hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | 40 | | | | 4hop_gemini_closed_book | | +2hop_gemini_closed_book +| | | 3hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gemini_closed_book | | +| ----- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| | | 1hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 3hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gemini_closed_book | | +| 20000 | | 1hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gemini_open_book | | +| | | 1hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| | | | | | | | | 20 | | | | 1hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 4hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_llava_closed_book | | +| 10000 | | 3hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gemini_closed_book | | +Ideal Calibration +| | 0 | | | | | | | 0 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 0 | 10 20 | 30 40 | 50 | 60 70 | 80 | 90 100 | 0 | 20 40 | 60 | 80 | 100 | | +| | | | Confidence Level | | | | | | Confidence (%) | | | | | +Figure 3: The left figure shows the confidence score distribution of GPT4-o, Gemini, and LLaVA on MMCV +underbothopen-bookandclosed-booksettings,categorizedbythenumberofhops. Therightfigureshowstheir +calibrationcurves. +settings. Overall,Gemini1.5outperformsothersin +| | | | | | | | | Model | Method | 1-hop | 2-hop | 3-hop | 4-hop | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +theopen-booksettingwithanaverageF-1of70.92, +| | | | | | | | | | CoT | 78.52 | 69.66 | 67.45 | 70.24 | +| ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| while | LLaVA | achieves | | the highest | | performance | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | GEMINI1.5 | Self-Ask | 75.47 | 66.58 | 60.94 | 70.67 | +intheclosed-booksettingwithanaverageF-1of +| | | | | | | | | | Symbolic | 74.89 | 63.82 | 54.61 | 72.36 | +| ------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| 66.77. | This | is surprising, | | given | that | LLaVA | is | a | | | | | | +much smaller model compared to GPT4-o and CoT 80.43 83.33 71.20 72.99 +Gemini, and therefore possesses less parametric GPT4-O Self-Ask 77.42 80.12 70.52 75.23 +knowledge. Uponmanuallyanalyzingasubsetof Symbolic 80.56 78.78 68.72 75.67 +| 100 | randomly | selected | outputs | | from | LLaVA, | we | | | | | | | +| --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | Table 4: | Results of | Gemini | and GPT4-o | | on 100 ran- | +foundthatthemodelfrequentlyhallucinates,even +domlysampledclaimsforeachhopusingthreetypes +| when | it predicts | the | correct | label, | particularly | | as | | | | | | | +| ---- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ofreasoningprompts. | | Modelperformanceisevaluated | | | | +| the | hop count | increases. | | This | is consistent | | with | | | | | | | +usingF-1score. +| its | open-book | performance, | | | where | its accuracy | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | ---------- | ------------ | +| declines | | when provided | | with | gold | evidence. | | | | | | | | +| Additionally, | | we observe | | that | GPT4-o | performs | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | The | right panel | of | Figure | 3 displays | the | +| slightly | better | in | closed-book | | settings | than | in | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | calibration | curves, | illustrating | | the | relationship | +| open-book | | settings, | suggesting | | a | tendency | to | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | between | the models’ | confidence | | levels | and their | +| hallucinate. | | In contrast, | | Gemini’s | | performance | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | actualclassificationaccuracy. | | | Thesecurvesreveal | | | +| drops | significantly | | in | closed-book | | settings | | | | | | | | +apositivecorrelationbetweenconfidenceandac- +comparedtoopen-book,demonstratingitsrobust- +curacyfor1-hopand2-hopclaims,asexemplified +nessineffectivelyutilizingprovidedgoldevidence. +| | | | | | | | | by the red | line (GPT-4-o | | on 2-hop), | | the teal line | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | +(LLaVAon1-hop),andthepurpleline(Geminion +| Confidence | | Level | Analysis | | The | left | panel | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | 1-hop). | Incontrast,thedownwardcurves,mostly | | | | | +| of | Figure | 3 presents | the | confidence | | (Geng | et al., | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | observed | in 3-hop | and | 4-hop | claims, | suggest | +2024a)distributionsforallthreeMLLMs,catego- +| | | | | | | | | that the | models tend | to | be overconfident | | when | +| ---------- | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------------- | ---- | +| rized | by the | number | of | hops and | divided | | into 10 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | classifyingmorecomplexclaims. | | | | Additionally,the | | +| intervals. | | Theresultsshowthatthemajorityofthe | | | | | | | | | | | | +resultsindicatethatopen-booksettingsgenerally +MLLMsareconcentratedinthe90-100confidence +| | | | | | | | | have better-calibrated | | confidence | | scores | than | +| ---------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | +| range, | with | only a | small | number | exhibiting | | low | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | closed-book | settings, | further | suggesting | | that the | +| confidence | | (0-10 | range), | which | occurs | | solely | | | | | | | +modelsexhibitoverconfidencewhennotprovided +| in | open-book | settings. | | This | indicates | that | the | | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +withgoldevidence. +MLLMsconsidertheprovidedgoldevidence. + +Annotator #Hops claims respectively. This suggests that although +MLLMsperformrelativelywell,thereisstillroom +| | | 1-hop | 2-hop | 3-hop | | 4-hop | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +forimprovementtomatchhumanperformance. +| Annotator1 | | 83.33 | 86.20 | 78.42 | | 79.82 | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Annotator2 | | | | | | | 5.3 ErrorAnalysis | | | | | | +| | | 82.46 | 88.29 | 79.45 | | 82.16 | | | | | | | +| Annotator3 | | 80.60 | 90.53 | 80.62 | | 85.24 | | | | | | | +Figure5,6,and7showstheerroranalysisofthe +| Annotator4 | | 79.64 | 86.50 | 82.32 | | 83.87 | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +falsepositiveexamplesfromGPT4-o,Gemini,and +| | | | | | | | LLaVA respectively. | | We | observe | that visual | mis- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | +Table5: Resultsofhumanperformanceon200random +| | | | | | | | interpretation | is | a major | issue, with | the | system | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | +samples. PerformancearemeasuredbyF-1score. +oftenmisidentifyingormiscontextualizingimage +| | | | | | | | elements. | Thisproblemisespeciallypronouncedin | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +examplesinvolvingsportslogosandmovieposters, +| Reasoning | Prompt | Results. | | Table | 4 reports | the | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +highlightingtheneedforimprovementsinthevi- +| performance | of | Gemini | and | GPT4-o | on | the ran- | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sualprocessingcomponent. +domlysampledsubsetofMMCVunderopen-book +Anothernotableissueisthesystem’shandling +| settings | using various | | prompts | that | elicit | LLMs’ | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | oftemporalandfactualinformation. | | | | Errorsrelated | | +| reasoning | abilities. | For | symbolic | | approach, | we | | | | | | | +toplayercareertimelinesandhistoricaleventsre- +askLLMstofirstgenerateaPython-likeprogram +| | | | | | | | veal shortcomings | | in temporal | reasoning | | and the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +thatdecomposesthemutli-hopclaimintoasetof +| | | | | | | | integrationofworldknowledge. | | | Thesystem’scon- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------------------- | ----- | ------- | --------------- | -------- | --- | +| function | calls that | describe | | the reasoning | | steps | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | fidence levels, | often | between | 80% | and 100% | for | +requiredtoverifytheclaim,andusethesymbolic +| | | | | | | | incorrect | predictions, | suggest | a miscalibration | | in | +| ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | -------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| information | provided | | by the | generated | | program | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | certaintyestimation. | | Thisoverconfidenceinerro- | | | | +| to elicit | better | step-by-step | | reasoning | | from the | | | | | | | +neousconclusionshighlightstheneedforamore +| model. | We observe | | that | GPT-4-o | gains | more | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +refinedapproachtoconfidencescoring. +| from the | enhanced | reasoning | | prompt | compared | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Lastbutnotleast,examplesfromhigherhopcat- +| to Gemini, | achieving | | a higher | average | | F1 score | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +egoriesrevealsignificantweaknessesinhandling +| of 75.93 | in symbolic | | guided | reasoning, | | whereas | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | complexreasoningtasks. | | | Thesystemoftenstrug- | | | +GeminiattainsanaverageF1scoreof66.42forthe +gleswithmulti-steplogicalinferences,frequently +| same task. | Additionaly, | | we | found | that | Symbolic | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +failingtocoherentlylinkdisparatepiecesofinfor- +| approach | are more | effective | | on | 4-hop | claims, | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | mation. This | limitation | is | especially | problematic | | +| having | a higher | F1 score | than | CoT | and | self-ask. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | for claims | that require | advanced | | analysis | or the | +| However, | this observation | | is | different | on | simpler | | | | | | | +cross-referencingofmultiplefacts. +2-hopand3-hopclaims,whereCoTappearstobe +moreeffective. +| | | | | | | | 6 Conclusion | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +HumanPerformanceResultsToestablishhuman In this paper, we introduce MMCV, a multi-hop +performanceonourdataset,werandomlysampled multimodalclaimverificationdatasetthatrequires +200 examples, with 50 examples from each hop models to aggregate information from up to four +fromMMCV.Werecruitedfourannotatorstoper- multimodalevidencetoverifyaclaim. Tocreate +form claim verification given the gold evidence. thislarge-scaledataset,wedevelopedanoveldata +Wetrainedourannotatorsonthetaskbyproviding collection pipeline that leverages the capabilities +themwithguidelinesandsampleannotationstoen- ofLLMscombinedwithhumanfeedback. Specif- +sureconsistencyandaccuracyintheirevaluations. ically, our approach includes a module that itera- +After training, the annotators independently veri- tivelyrefinesmodifiedclaimsusingfeedbackfrom +fiedeachclaimusingtheprovidedgoldevidence, a judge LLM based on a set of predefined crite- +allowing us to assess the human baseline perfor- ria,aswellasanactualityvalidationmodulethat +mance on the dataset. Table 5 reports the results employs RAG to ensure the factual accuracy of +from the human annotators. We observe that the the claims. Our results show that state-of-the-art +humanannotatorsachieveveryhighperformance MLLMs struggle to verify more complex claims +inverifyingtheclaimsacrossall4hops. Thehu- as the number of reasoning hops increases, often +manperformanceis23.3%and27.3%higherthan displayingoverconfidenceintheirpredictions. We +thebest-performingMLLMson3-hopand4-hop also present findings from experiments utilizing + +Acknowledgements +promptstailoredtoenhancethereasoningabilities +ofMLLMs,alongsidehumanperformancebench- +| | | | | | | | This material | | is based | upon | work supported | | by | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | --- | +| marksforcomparison. | | | Additionally,wecategorize | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the U.S. | Department | of | Homeland | | Security | un- | +andprovideadetailederroranalysisoffalseposi- +| | | | | | | | der Grant | Award | Number | 17STQAC00001-07- | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| tiveresultsfromeachmodel. | | | | WehopethatMMCV | | | | | | | | | | +04,NSFawards(SaTC-2241068,IIS-2339198),a +willinspirethedevelopmentofmodelscapableof +CiscoResearchAward,andaMicrosoftAccelerate +| conducting | complex, | | multi-hop | reasoning | | in the | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Foundation | Models | Research | | Award. | The | views | +challengingtaskofmultimodalclaimverification. +| | | | | | | | and conclusions | | contained | in | this document | | are | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| 7 Limitations | | | | | | | thoseoftheauthorsandshouldnotbeinterpretedas | | | | | | | +necessarilyrepresentingtheofficialpolicies,either +WeidentifytwomainlimitationsofMMCV.First, expressed or implied, of the U.S. Department of +theconstructionofMMCVdependsonin-context HomelandSecurityortheNationalScienceFoun- +learningcoupledwithself-refinementtoconverta +| | | | | | | | dation. | This | research was | partially | supported | | by | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | +naturallanguagequestion-answerpairintoamulti- theNationalInstituteOfDiabetesAndDigestive +hop claim. While this method has proven to be AndKidneyDiseasesoftheNationalInstitutesof +effective, it may face difficulties when dealing HealthunderAwardNumberK25DK135913. +| with questions | | with intricate | | grammar | structures | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| and logical | structures. | | This | arises from | the | diffi- | | | | | | | | +References +cultyinconveyingcomplexgrammaticalrulesto +| the language | model | through | | a limited | number | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +JoshAchiam,StevenAdler,SandhiniAgarwal,Lama +demonstrationswithinaconstrainedcontextsize. Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, +DiogoAlmeida,JankoAltenschmidt,SamAltman, +| Second, | our aggregation | | method | purely | relies | on | | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ShyamalAnadkat,etal.2023. | | | | Gpt-4technicalreport. | | | +LLMsthemselves,whichcouldintroducepotential arXivpreprintarXiv:2303.08774. +| hallucinationproblems. | | | Ontheotherhand,byus- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MubasharaAkhtar,MichaelSchlichtkrull,ZhijiangGuo, +ingamorerobustlogicsolvercouldhelpwiththe +| | | | | | | | OanaCocarascu, | | ElenaSimperl, | | andAndreasVla- | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +hallucinationissues,buttherewouldbeatradeoff +| | | | | | | | chos.2023. | | Multimodalautomatedfact-checking: | | | | A | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweentheapplicabilityandtherobustnessofthe +| | | | | | | | survey. | InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputa- | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| model. | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | | EMNLP2023,pages5430–5448, | | | | | +Singapore.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| 8 EthicalStatement | | | | | | | tics. | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | +| Biases. | | | | | | | ShivangiAneja, | | ChrisBregler, | | andMatthiasNießner. | | | +Weacknowledgethepossibilityofbiases +| | | | | | | | 2021. | Cosmos: | Catching | out-of-context | | misinfor- | | +| ------------- | ----------------------------------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | ---- | ---------------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | +| existing | within | the data | used | for training | the | lan- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | mationwithself-supervisedlearning. | | | | arXivpreprint | | | +| guage models, | | as well | as in | certain | factuality | as- | arXiv:2101.06278. | | | | | | | +| sessments. | Unfortunately,thesefactorsarebeyond | | | | | | | | | | | | | +HanBao,YueHuang,YanboWang,JiayiYe,Xiangqi +ourcontrol. +Wang,XiuyinChen,MohamedElhoseiny,andXian- +| IntendedUseandMisusePotential. | | | | | Ourmodels | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | gliangZhang.2024. | | Autobench-v: | | Canlargevision- | | | +have the potential to verify complex multimodal language models benchmark themselves? arXiv +preprintarXiv:2410.21259. +| claims. | However, | it is | essential | to recognize | | that | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| they may | also | be susceptible | | to misuse | by | mali- | | | | | | | | +DongpingChen,YueHuang,SiyuanWu,JingyuTang, +ciousindividuals. Therefore,westronglyurgere- LiuyiChen,YilinBai,ZhigangHe,ChenlongWang, +| | | | | | | | HuichiZhou,YiqiangLi,etal.2024. | | | | | Gui-world: | A | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +searcherstoapproachtheirutilizationwithcaution +andprudence. datasetforgui-orientedmultimodalllm-basedagents. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.10819. +| Environmental | | Impact. | | We want | to highlight | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theenvironmentalimpactofusinglargelanguage Rob Chew, Michael Wenger, Caroline Kery, Jason +| | | | | | | | Nance, | Keith | Richards, | Emily | Hadley, | and | Peter | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----- | +models,whichdemandsubstantialcomputational +| | | | | | | | Baumgartner. | | 2019. | Smart: | an open | source | data | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | +costsandrelyonGPUs/TPUsfortraining,which +| | | | | | | | labelingplatformforsupervisedlearning. | | | | | Journalof | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +contributestoglobalwarming. However,itisworth MachineLearningResearch,20(82):1–5. +notingthatourapproachdoesnottrainsuchmodels +| | | | | | | | Qingxiu | Dong, | Lei Li, Damai | | Dai, Ce | Zheng, | Zhiy- | +| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ----- | +| fromscratch. | Instead,weusefew-shotin-context | | | | | | | | | | | | | +ongWu,BaobaoChang,XuSun,JingjingXu,and +| learning. | Nevertheless,thelargelanguagemodels | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ZhifangSui.2022. | | Asurveyonin-contextlearning. | | | | | +weusedinthispaperarelikelyrunningonGPU(s). arXivpreprintarXiv:2301.00234. + +YiFung,ChristopherThomas,RevanthGangiReddy, YiqiaoJin,MinjeChoi,GauravVerma,JindongWang, +SandeepPolisetty,HengJi,Shih-FuChang,Kathleen andSrijanKumar.2024a. Mm-soc: Benchmarking +McKeown,MohitBansal,andAviSil.2021. InfoSur- multimodallargelanguagemodelsinsocialmedia +geon: Cross-mediafine-grainedinformationconsis- platforms. arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.14154. +| tencycheckingforfakenewsdetection. | | | InProceed- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | Yiqiao Jin, | Yeon-Chang | | Lee, Kartik | Sharma, | Meng | +ingsofthe59thAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationfor +Ye,KaranSikka,AjayDivakaran,andSrijanKumar. +ComputationalLinguisticsandthe11thInternational +| | | | | | 2023. Predicting | | information | pathways | | across on- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | +JointConferenceonNaturalLanguageProcessing +(Volume1: LongPapers),pages1683–1698,Online. linecommunities. InProceedingsofthe29thACM +SIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryand +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +DataMining,pages1044–1056. +ChujieGao,QihuiZhang,DongpingChen,YueHuang, +| | | | | | YiqiaoJin, | XitingWang, | | RuichaoYang, | YizhouSun, | | +| ------- | ------------------------------------- | ------- | --------------- | ------- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | +| Siyuan | Wu, Zhengyan | Fu, Yao | Wan, Xiangliang | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | WeiWang,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2022. | | | | | Towards | +| Zhang, | and Lichao Sun. | 2024. | The best | of both | | | | | | | +| | | | | | fine-grained | reasoning | | for fake | news detection. | In | +| worlds: | Towardanhonestandhelpfullargelanguage | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Proceedings | of | the AAAI | Conference | on | Artificial | +| model. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.00380. | | | | | | | | | | +Intelligence,volume36,pages5746–5754. +JiahuiGeng,FengyuCai,YuxiaWang,HeinzKoeppl, YiqiaoJin,QinlinZhao,YiyangWang,HaoChen,Kai- +PreslavNakov,andIrynaGurevych.2024a. Asur- jieZhu,YijiaXiao,andJindongWang.2024b. Agen- +veyofconfidenceestimationandcalibrationinlarge treview: Exploringpeerreviewdynamicswithllm +| languagemodels. | InProceedingsofthe2024Con- | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | agents. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.12708. | | | | | +ferenceoftheNorthAmericanChapteroftheAsso- +| | | | | | DanielKhashabi, | | SnigdhaChaturvedi, | | MichaelRoth, | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | +| ciationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | HumanLan- | | | | | | | | +guageTechnologies(Volume1: LongPapers),pages Shyam Upadhyay, and Dan Roth. 2018. Looking +| 6577–6595. | | | | | beyondthesurface: | | Achallengesetforreadingcom- | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | prehensionovermultiplesentences. | | | | InProceedings | | +JiahuiGeng,YovaKementchedjhieva,PreslavNakov, ofthe2018ConferenceoftheNorthAmericanChap- +andIrynaGurevych.2024b. Multimodallargelan- teroftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +guage models to support real-world fact-checking. HumanLanguageTechnologies,Volume1(LongPa- +arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.03627. pers),pages252–262,NewOrleans,Louisiana.As- +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +ZhijiangGuo,MichaelSchlichtkrull,andAndreasVla- +chos. 2022. A survey on automated fact-checking. PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio +TransactionsoftheAssociationforComputational Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- +Linguistics,10:178–206. richKüttler, MikeLewis, Wen-tauYih, TimRock- +| | | | | | täschel,etal.2020. | | Retrieval-augmentedgeneration | | | | +| ------------ | ------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | forknowledge-intensivenlptasks. | | | | AdvancesinNeu- | | +| Tanmay Gupta | and Aniruddha | Kembhavi. | | 2023. Vi- | | | | | | | +ralInformationProcessingSystems,33:9459–9474. +| sualprogramming: | Compositionalvisualreasoning | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| withouttraining. | InProceedingsoftheIEEE/CVF | | | | | | | | | | +MiaoranLi,BaolinPeng,MichelGalley,JianfengGao, +ConferenceonComputerVisionandPatternRecog- +| | | | | | andZhuZhang.2024. | | | Self-checker: | Plug-and-play | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | +nition,pages14953–14962. +modulesforfact-checkingwithlargelanguagemod- +Baixiang Huang, Canyu Chen, and Kai Shu. 2024a. els. InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputational +| | | | | | Linguistics: | NAACL2024,pages163–181,Mexico | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | +| Authorship | attribution | in the era | of llms: | Prob- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | City, Mexico. | | Association | for | Computational | Lin- | +| lems,methodologies,andchallenges. | | | arXivpreprint | | | | | | | | +guistics. +arXiv:2408.08946. +HaotianLiu,ChunyuanLi,QingyangWu,andYongJae +| BaixiangHuang,CanyuChen,andKaiShu.2024b. | | | | Can | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | Lee.2024a. | Visualinstructiontuning. | | | Advancesin | | +| large language | models | identify authorship? | | arXiv | | | | | | | +neuralinformationprocessingsystems,36. +preprintarXiv:2403.08213. +| | | | | | Yixin Liu, | Kai Zhang, | Yuan | Li, Zhiling | Yan, | Chujie | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | +Yue Huang, Zhengqing Yuan, Yujun Zhou, Kehan Gao, Ruoxi Chen, Zhengqing Yuan, Yue Huang, +Guo,XiangqiWang,HaominZhuang,WeixiangSun, Hanchi Sun, Jianfeng Gao, et al. 2024b. Sora: A +LichaoSun,JindongWang,YanfangYe,etal.2024c. +reviewonbackground,technology,limitations,and +Socialsciencemeetsllms:Howreliablearelargelan- +| | | | | | opportunitiesoflargevisionmodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +arXivpreprint +| guagemodelsinsocialsimulations? | | | | | arXiv:2402.17177. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXiv:2410.23426. +YaoLu,MaxBartolo,AlastairMoore,SebastianRiedel, +Yichen Jiang, Shikha Bordia, Zheng Zhong, Charles and Pontus Stenetorp. 2022. Fantastically ordered +Dognin, Maneesh Singh, and Mohit Bansal. 2020. promptsandwheretofindthem: Overcomingfew- +HoVer: Adatasetformany-hopfactextractionand shotpromptordersensitivity. InProceedingsofthe +claim verification. In Findings of the Association 60thAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforCompu- +forComputationalLinguistics: EMNLP2020,pages tationalLinguistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages +3441–3460,Online.AssociationforComputational 8086–8098,Dublin,Ireland.AssociationforCompu- +| Linguistics. | | | | | tationalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +GraceLuo,TrevorDarrell,andAnnaRohrbach.2021. RobinRombach,AndreasBlattmann,DominikLorenz, +NewsCLIPpings: AutomaticGenerationofOut-of- Patrick Esser, and Björn Ommer. 2022. High- +ContextMultimodalMedia. InProceedingsofthe resolutionimagesynthesiswithlatentdiffusionmod- +2021ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNatural els. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF conference +LanguageProcessing,pages6801–6817,Onlineand oncomputervisionandpatternrecognition, pages +| Punta | Cana, | Dominican | Republic. | Association | for | 10684–10695. | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ComputationalLinguistics. +MelanieSclar,YejinChoi,YuliaTsvetkov,andAlane +VaibhavMavi,AnubhavJangra,andAdamJatowt.2022. Suhr.2023. Quantifyinglanguagemodels’sensitiv- +Asurveyonmulti-hopquestionansweringandgen- itytospuriousfeaturesinpromptdesignor: Howi +eration. arXivpreprintarXiv:2204.09140. learned to start worrying about prompt formatting. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2310.11324. +ShreyashMishra,SSuryavardan,AmritBhaskar,Parul +Chopra,AishwaryaNReganti,ParthPatwa,Amitava +KaiShu,DeepakMahudeswaran,SuhangWang,Dong- +Das,TanmoyChakraborty,AmitPSheth,AsifEkbal, wonLee,andHuanLiu.2020. Fakenewsnet: Adata +etal.2022. Factify: Amulti-modalfactverification repositorywithnewscontent,socialcontext,andspa- +dataset. InDE-FACTIFY@AAAI. tiotemporalinformationforstudyingfakenewson +| | | | | | | socialmedia. | Bigdata,8(3):171–188. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +LongOuyang,JeffreyWu,XuJiang,DiogoAlmeida, +CarrollWainwright,PamelaMishkin,ChongZhang, +| | | | | | | AlonTalmorandJonathanBerant.2018. | | | | Thewebas | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +SandhiniAgarwal,KatarinaSlama,AlexRay,etal. +aknowledge-baseforansweringcomplexquestions. +| 2022. | Training | languagemodelsto | | followinstruc- | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXivpreprintarXiv:1803.06643. +| tionswithhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralin- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +formationprocessingsystems,35:27730–27744. Alon Talmor, Ori Yoran, Amnon Catav, Dan Lahav, +| | | | | | | Yizhong Wang, | Akari | Asai, | Gabriel | Ilharco, | Han- | +| ----------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | +| AlizéePace, | JonathanMallinson, | | | EricMalmi, | Sebas- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | nanehHajishirzi,andJonathanBerant.2021. | | | | | Mul- | +| tianKrause,andAliakseiSeveryn.2024. | | | | | West-of-n: | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | timodalqa: | Complex | question | answering | | over text, | +Syntheticpreferencegenerationforimprovedreward +| | | | | | | tablesandimages. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2104.06039. | | | | +| --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| modeling. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2401.12086. | | | | | | | | | | | +ZhenTan,AlimohammadBeigi,SongWang,Ruocheng +| Liangming | Pan, | Michael Saxon, | | Wenda Xu, | Deepak | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Guo,AmritaBhattacharjee,BohanJiang,Mansooreh +| Nathani, | Xinyi | Wang, | and William | Yang | Wang. | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Karami,JundongLi,LuCheng,andHuanLiu.2024. +| 2023a. | | Automatically | correcting | | large lan- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | Largelanguagemodelsfordataannotation: | | | | | Asurvey. | +| guage | models: | Surveying | the | landscape | of di- | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.13446. +| verse | self-correction | strategies. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | +| ----- | --------------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXiv:2308.03188. +| | | | | | | Gemini Team, | Rohan | Anil, | Sebastian | Borgeaud, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Yonghui | Wu, Jean-Baptiste | | Alayrac, | Jiahui | Yu, | +LiangmingPan,XiaobaoWu,XinyuanLu,AnhTuan +Luu,WilliamYangWang,Min-YenKan,andPreslav Radu Soricut, Johan Schalkwyk, Andrew M Dai, +Nakov.2023b. Fact-checkingcomplexclaimswith Anja Hauth, et al. 2023. Gemini: a family of +| | | | | | | highlycapablemultimodalmodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | | +| -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| program-guided | | reasoning. | In | Proceedings | of the | | | | | | | +arXiv:2312.11805. +61stAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforCompu- +| tationalLinguistics(Volume1: | | | | LongPapers),pages | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | JamesThorneandAndreasVlachos.2018. | | | | Automated | | +6981–7004,Toronto,Canada.AssociationforCom- +| | | | | | | fact checking: | Task | formulations, | | methods | and fu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +putationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | ture directions. | | In Proceedings | of | the 27th | Inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Yikang Pan, Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, Preslav nationalConferenceonComputationalLinguistics, +pages3346–3359,SantaFe,NewMexico,USA.As- +| Nakov, | Min-Yen | Kan, | and William | Wang. | 2023c. | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| On the | risk | of misinformation | | pollution | with large | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | +| language | models. | In Findings | | of the Association | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | James Thorne, | | Andreas | Vlachos, | | Christos | +| forComputationalLinguistics: | | | | EMNLP2023,pages | | | | | | | | +1389–1403, Singapore. Association for Computa- Christodoulopoulos, and Arpit Mittal. 2018. +tionalLinguistics. FEVER: a large-scale dataset for fact extraction +| | | | | | | and VERification. | | In | Proceedings | of | the 2018 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +OfirPress,MuruZhang,SewonMin,LudwigSchmidt, Conference of the North American Chapter of +| | | | | | | the Association | | for Computational | | Linguistics: | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | +| NoahSmith,andMikeLewis.2023. | | | | Measuringand | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Human Language | | Technologies, | | Volume | 1 (Long | +narrowingthecompositionalitygapinlanguagemod- +els. InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputational Papers), pages 809–819, New Orleans, Louisiana. +Linguistics: EMNLP2023,pages5687–5711,Singa- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +pore.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | HaoranWangandKaiShu.2023. | | | Explainableclaim | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +Aditya Ramesh, Mikhail Pavlov, Gabriel Goh, Scott verificationviaknowledge-groundedreasoningwith +Gray,ChelseaVoss,AlecRadford,MarkChen,and largelanguagemodels. InFindingsoftheAssocia- +IlyaSutskever.2021. Zero-shottext-to-imagegener- tionforComputationalLinguistics: EMNLP2023, +ation. InInternationalconferenceonmachinelearn- pages6288–6304,Singapore.AssociationforCom- +| ing,pages8821–8831.Pmlr. | | | | | | putationalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Haoran Wang and Kai Shu. 2024. Trojan activation QihuiZhang,ChujieGao,DongpingChen,YueHuang, +attack: Red-teaming large language models using YixinHuang, ZhenyangSun, ShilinZhang, Weiye +steeringvectorsforsafety-alignment. InProceedings Li, ZhengyanFu, YaoWan, etal.2024. Llm-as-a- +of the 33rd ACM International Conference on In- coauthor: Can mixed human-written and machine- +formationandKnowledgeManagement,CIKM’24, generatedtextbedetected? InFindingsoftheAsso- +page2347–2357,NewYork,NY,USA.Association ciationforComputationalLinguistics: NAACL2024, +| forComputingMachinery. | | | | | | | pages409–436. | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | +Ruida Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, and Mrinmaya DimitrinaZlatkova,PreslavNakov,andIvanKoychev. +Sachan. 2023. Let’s synthesize step by step: Iter- 2019. Fact-checking meets fauxtography: Verify- +ative dataset synthesis with large language models ing claims about images. In Proceedings of the +| | | | | | | | 2019 Conference | on Empirical | Methods | in Natu- | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | +| byextrapolatingerrorsfromsmallmodels. | | | | | | InFind- | | | | | +ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguis- ralLanguageProcessingandthe9thInternational +tics: EMNLP2023,pages11817–11831,Singapore. JointConferenceonNaturalLanguageProcessing +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. (EMNLP-IJCNLP),pages2099–2108,HongKong, +China.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| William Yang | Wang. | 2017. | “liar, | liar | pants on | fire”: | | | | | +| -------------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| A new | benchmark | dataset | for | fake | news detection. | | | | | | +| In Proceedings | | of the | 55th | Annual | Meeting | of the | | | | | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Volume2: +ShortPapers),pages422–426,Vancouver,Canada. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten +Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou, +| etal.2022. | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelicitsrea- | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| soninginlargelanguagemodels. | | | | Advancesinneural | | | | | | | +informationprocessingsystems,35:24824–24837. +JohannesWelbl,PontusStenetorp,andSebastianRiedel. +| 2018. Constructing | | datasets | | for multi-hop | | reading | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| comprehensionacrossdocuments. | | | | | Transactionsof | | | | | | +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics,6:287– +302. +SiyuanWu,YueHuang,ChujieGao,DongpingChen, +| Qihui Zhang, | | Yao Wan, | Tianyi | Zhou, | Xiangliang | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Zhang, | Jianfeng | Gao, | Chaowei | Xiao, | et al. | 2024. | | | | | +| Unigen: | Aunifiedframeworkfortextualdatasetgen- | | | | | | | | | | +| erationusinglargelanguagemodels. | | | | | arXivpreprint | | | | | | +arXiv:2406.18966. +RuichaoYang,XitingWang,YiqiaoJin,ChaozhuoLi, +| JianxunLian,andXingXie.2022. | | | | | Reinforcement | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| subgraphreasoningforfakenewsdetection. | | | | | | InPro- | | | | | +ceedingsofthe28thACMSIGKDDConferenceon +KnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMining,pages2253– +2262. +ZhilinYang,PengQi,SaizhengZhang,YoshuaBengio, +WilliamCohen,RuslanSalakhutdinov,andChristo- +| pher D. | Manning. | 2018. | HotpotQA: | | A dataset | for | | | | | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| diverse, | explainablemulti-hopquestionanswering. | | | | | | | | | | +| In Proceedings | | of the | 2018 | Conference | on | Empiri- | | | | | +calMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages +2369–2380,Brussels,Belgium.AssociationforCom- +putationalLinguistics. +BarryMenglongYao,AdityaShah,LichaoSun,Jin-Hee +| Cho,andLifuHuang.2023. | | | | End-to-endmultimodal | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --------------- | --------------- | ----- | -------------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| fact-checking | | and explanation | | generation: | | A chal- | | | | | +| lengingdatasetandmodels. | | | | InProceedingsofthe | | | | | | | +| 46th International | | ACM | SIGIR | Conference | | on Re- | | | | | +| search | and Development | | in | Information | Retrieval, | | | | | | +pages2733–2743. + +A Appendix +| | | | | | ClaimGenerationPrompt. | | | Weusethefollowing | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | +prompttoconvertmultimodalQApairsintoclaim +A.1 DatasetExample +candidates: +| HereisanexampleofdatasetschemafromMMCV: | | | | | Prompt | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | ------------------------ | --------- | ---------------- | ------------- | --------------- | ---- | +| Example | | | | | You are | an expert | | in converting | | | +| | | | | | question-answers | | | into | claims. | | +| claim: | Stoke | City, | a | club that was | | | | | | | +| | | | | | For example: | | Question: | | Telos | was | +| part of | the | top-tier | league | before | | | | | | | +| | | | | | an album | by | a band | who | formed | in | +| 1992, was | promoted | | to | the highest | | | | | | | +| | | | | | what city? | | Answer: | Indianapolis. | | | +| level of | English | | football | in 2018. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Claim: | Telos | was | an album | | by a | +| wiki_context: | | The | Premier | League | | | | | | | +| | | | | | band formed | | in Indianapolis. | | | | +| is the | highest | level | of | the English | | | | | | | +| football | league | system. | | Contested | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Convert | the | question-answer | | | into | +| by 20 clubs, | | it operates | | on a | | | | | | | +| | | | | | claim. | Return | only | the | claim | and | +| system | of promotion | | and | relegation | | | | | | | +| | | | | | nothing | else. | | | | | +| with the | English | | Football | League | | | | | | | +| (EFL). | Seasons | usually | | run from | | | | | | | +| August | to May, | with | each | team | | | | | | | +| | | | | | ClaimModificationPrompt. | | | | Weusethefollow- | | +| playing | 38 matches: | | two | against | | | | | | | +each other, one home and one away. ingprompttomodifytheclaimcandidates: +| Most games | are | played | | on weekend | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Prompt +| afternoons, | | with | occasional | weekday | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | +| evening | fixtures. | | | | Generate | a multi-hop | | specific | | | +| text_evidence: | | [ | | | claim based | | on the | given | general | | +"f369cee1ca92368c8b1ea564c5e41fc1" claim and Wikipedia context. The +| ] | | | | | specific | claim | should: | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | --- | +| image_evidence: | | | [] | | | | | | | | +| table_evidence: | | | [ | | Incorporate | | information | | from | | +| "c120efadd518b5f32c11d40b456c8570" | | | | | Wikipedia | context. | | | | | +| ] | | | | | Provided | context | | should | always | be | +| label: | SUPPORT | | | | factually | correct. | | | | | +| | | | | | Obscure | key | information | | by: | | +| | | | | | a) Replacing | | one | or two | central | | +Additionalexamplesof1-hop,2-hop,3-hop,and entities with related fact using +| 4-hopclaimsarelistedinTable6 | | | | | the Wikipedia | | context. | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +| | | | | | b) Alluding | | to critical | | details | | +| | | | | | without | explicitly | | stating | | them. | +A.2 ExperimentPrompt +| | | | | | Claim should | | be short | | and concise. | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +For example: +| Claim Verification | | Prompt. | | To test MLLMs’ | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +claimverificationperformanceunderzero-shotset- - General Claim: The Mona Lisa +tings, wefollow(Gengetal.,2024b)andusethe is a famous painting by Leonardo da +Vinci. +followingprompt. +| | | | | | - Wikipedia | | Context: | | The Mona | Lisa | +| ---------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------ | ----------------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Prompt | | | | | is a half-length | | | portrait | painting | | +| | | | | | by Italian | artist | | Leonardo | | da | +| Given a | claim | and | evidence | (which | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Vinci. | Considered | | an | archetypal | | +| can be | text, | table, | or | an image), | | | | | | | +| | | | | | masterpiece | | of the | Italian | | | +| determine | whether | | the | claim is | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Renaissance, | | it has | been | described | | +| SUPPORT | or REFUTE | | by the | evidence. | ¨the | | | | | | +| | | | | | as | best | known, | the | most | | +| | | | | | visited, | the | most | written | about, | | +| Use the | following | | format | to provide | | | | | | | +| | | | | | the most | sung | about, | the | most | | +| your answer: | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | parodied | work | of | art in | the | world¨. | +| Prediction: | | [True | or | False] | | | | | | | +| | | | | | The painting’s | | novel | qualities | | | +| Explanation: | | [put | your | evidence | | | | | | | +| | | | | | include | the | subject’s | | enigmatic | | +| and step-by-step | | | reasoning | here] | | | | | | | +| | | | | | expression, | | the monumentality | | | | +| Confidence | Level: | | [please | show the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | of the | composition, | | the | subtle | | +percentage] +| | | | | | modelling | of | forms, | and | the | | +| --------- | -------------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | +| | | | | | atmospheric | | illusionism. | | It | is | +| Note: | The confidence | | | level | | | | | | | +| | | | | | housed | in the | Louvre | Museum | | in | +| indicates | the | degree | of | certainty | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Paris, | where | it was | first | put | on | +| you have | about | your | answer | and | | | | | | | +| | | | | | display | in 1797. | | | | | +is represented as a percentage. - Specific Claim: The Mona Lisa is +For instance, if your confidence a half-length portrait painting +level is 80%, it means you are 80% created by Italian artist who +certain that your answer is correct is considered as archetypal +| and there | is | a 20% | chance | that it | masterpiece | | of the | Italian | | | +| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | +| may be | incorrect. | | | | Renaissance. | | | | | | + +ClaimRefinementPrompt. Weusethefollowing A.3 AnnotationGuidelines +prompttorefinetheclaimcandidates: +| | | | | | | We ask | our annotators | | to score | the quality | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +Prompt +| | | | | | | claimfromthreeaspects: | | | fluency,correctness,and | | | +| -------------- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | +| You are | tasked | with | improving | | a | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | clearness. | Hereisthedetailedguidelinesprovided | | | | | +| claim focusing | | on | three | key | areas: | | | | | | | +tothehumanannotators. +| Fluency, | Correctness, | | | and Clearness. | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Your goal | is | to enhance | | the | text | | | | | | | Guidelines - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$3.33 - -$2.93 - -$0.33 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Source: USDA-FNS, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018-15465/national-school-lunch- -special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum. For NSLP reimbursement rates -for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -Note: For school year 2018-2019, the maximum rate for 48 states and DC is $3.48 per free meal, $3.08 per -reduced-price meal, and $0.30 per paid meal (and an additional $0.06 for nutrition guidelines). The maximum -rate is the maximum per-lunch rate that a state can provide a school food authority. - -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks -Per-snack reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Snack Type - -Reimbursement - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For after-school snack NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or -participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -118 All reimbursement rate tables in this Appendix display rates for the 48 continental U.S. states. For Alaska, Hawaii, -and territories where applicable, please see the source USDA-FNS Federal Register notice. -119 For more detail on how inflation adjustment is conducted, see the child nutrition program sections of CRS Report -R42000, Inflation-Indexing Elements in Federal Entitlement Programs, coordinated by Dawn Nuschler. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -38 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP -Per-meal reimbursement for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Non-severe Need -(less than 40% free or -reduced price)a - -Severe Need -(greater than or equal to 40% -free or reduced price)a - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -$2.14 - -$1.84 - -$0.31 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating -territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -a. Generally, severe need status is determined based on the percentage of meals served two school years -prior to the year the currently reimbursed meal is served. For example, a school district’s severe need -status in school year 2018-2019 would be calculated based on meals served in school year 2016-2017. - -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) -Rate per-meal for school year 2018-2019 - -For Each NSLP/CACFP Meal Served - -Commodity Food Reimbursement - -$0.2350 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Food Distribution Program: Value of Donated Foods From July 1, -2018, Through June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 35607, July 1, 2018. -Notes: For past years, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/value-donated-foods-notices. SFSP -has a different commodity food assistance rate, see Table B-7. - -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School -Programs -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -Snack - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Notes: These reimbursement rates are identical to NSLP and SBP rates. - -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Tier I - -Tier II - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -$2.46 - -$1.48 - -$1.31 - -$0.48 - -Snack - -$0.73 - -$0.20 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Note: CACFP also provides administrative reimbursements to sponsoring organizations of day care homes. -Based on the number of homes sponsored, funding is provided per home, per month. These rates are not - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -39 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -displayed in this table but are included in USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: National Average Payment Rates, Day Care Home Food Service Payment Rates, and Administrative -Reimbursement Rates for Sponsoring Organizations of Day Care Homes for the Period July 1, 2018 Through -June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 34108, July 1, 2018. - -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 states and DC (rounded to nearest cent), calendar year 2018 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Snack - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -$3.55 - -$3.55 - -$2.03 - -$2.03 - -$0.83 - -$0.83 - -$0.37 - -$0.31 - -$0.20 - -$0.16 - -$0.10 - -$0.08 - -$3.92 - -$3.86 - -$2.23 - -$2.19 - -$0.93 - -$0.91 - -Operating -Component - -Administrative -Component - -Combined (Total) -Rate - -Source: For program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, “Summer Food Service Program; 2018 Reimbursement Rates,” 83 Federal Register 4025, -January 29, 2018. -Note: Per authorizing law, the administrative component is calculated to the nearest quarter-cent. This table -rounds to the nearest cent. As the table shows, the administrative component varies slightly (e.g., by about 5 -cents for lunches) depending on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared -on-site or by a vendor. For meals prepared on-site, providers receive 1.5 cents per meal in USDA commodity -foods. - -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP -Per half-pint reimbursement for 48 States and DC (rounded to nearest cent), school year 2018-2019 - -All Milk Served - -Paid Milk - -Free Milk to Low- -Income Children - -Schools that only -sell milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Schools that sell -and provide free -milk - -Schools that -provide only free -milk - -Not applicable - -$0.21 - -Average cost per -half-pint of milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Source: For program reimbursement rates, see https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -40 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Author Information - -Kara Clifford Billings -Analyst in Social Policy - - Randy Alison Aussenberg - -Specialist in Nutrition Assistance Policy - -Acknowledgments - -Disclaimer - -This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan -shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and -under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other -than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in -connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not -subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in -its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or -material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to -copy or otherwise use copyrighted material. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -41 - +| while maintaining | | | its | original | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +▷ScoringCriteria: +| meaning | and | intent. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Fluency: | Rateonascaleof1-4. | | | | | +| Improvement | | Criteria: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Correctness: | | Rateonascaleof1-3. | | | | +Fluency: +| 1. Review | the | text | for | grammar, | | ClearnessRateonascaleof1-3. | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| syntax, | and | punctuation | | errors. | | | | | | | | +| 2. Rephrase | | any | awkward | or | | | | | | | | +▷Fluency(1-4): +| unnatural | sentences | | to | make | the | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +text flow more smoothly. 4: Excellent-Readsnaturally,noawkward +| 3. Ensure | that | the | text | reads | | phrasing. | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | +| naturally | and | is | easy | to follow. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 3: Good | - | Mostly | smooth, | minor | phrasing | +| Correctness: | | | | | | issues. | | | | | | +| 1. Verify | the | factual | | accuracy | of | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 2: Fair | - | Several | awkward | phrases | or | +| the content | | and correct | | any | errors. | | | | | | | +constructions. +| 2. Ensure | that | the | text | adheres | to | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the prompt’s instructions. 1: Poor - Difficult to read, very unnatural +| 3. Clarify | | any ambiguities | | | and | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +phrasing. +| correct | any | inconsistencies | | | in the | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| information | | presented. | | | | | | | | | | +▷Correctness(1-3): +Clearness: +3: Fullycorrect-Allinformationisaccurate. +| 1. Simplify | | complex | sentences | | or | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ideas to make the text easier to 2: Partially correct - Some information is +| understand. | | | | | | accurate,someerrors. | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------- | ---------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | +| 2. Improve | | the organization | | | of | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1: Incorrect | | - Significant | | factual | errors or | +| ideas to | enhance | | readability. | | | | | | | | | +| 3. Ensure | that | the | message | | is | misrepresentations. | | | | | | +| conveyed | clearly | | and effectively, | | | | | | | | | +| eliminating | | any confusion | | or | | | | | | | | +▷Clearness(1-3): +ambiguity. +| | | | | | | 3: Very | clear | - | Easy to | understand, | no | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +Final Output: +ambiguity. +| Once you | have | made | the | necessary | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | --------------------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | 2: Somewhat | | clear | - Some | parts | may be | +| improvements, | | provide | | the revised | | | | | | | | +| text. | Ensure | that | the | improved | | confusingorambiguous. | | | | | | +| version | is more | fluent, | | accurate, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1: Unclear | | - Difficult | to | understand | the | +| and clear | than | the | original | | while | | | | | | | +intendedmeaning. +| preserving | the | original | | meaning | and | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intent. +| Example | Improvement: | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Original | Claim: | | "The | results | of | | | | | | | +| the survey | was | very | positive, | | with | A.4 CrowdWorkerInterface | | | | | | +| many respondents | | | saying | that | they | | | | | | | +would recommend the service to We use SMART (Chew et al., 2019), an open- +| others, | however, | | some | were | also | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sourceprojectdesignedtohelpdatascientistsand +| mentioned | issues | | with | the customer | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | research | teams | efficiently | build | labeled | training | +support." +Improved Claim: "The survey datasetsforsupervisedmachinelearningtasks. Fig- +| results | were | overwhelmingly | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | ure 4 shows | an | example | of | the worker | interface | +| positive, | with | many | respondents | | | | | | | | | +duringscoringprocedure. +| stating | they | would | recommend | | the | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| service | to others. | | However, | | some | | | | | | | +| also noted | issues | | with | customer | | | | | | | | +support. + +| #H Claim | | | Evidence | | +| -------- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| 1 Claim: | MarisaCoughlanplayedtherole | | | | +ofChanteLefortontelevisionin1996. +| 2 Claim: | The driver | seen signing auto- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +graphsoutsidehadasignificantpointsto- +| tal during | a specific race | in 2001 while | | | +| ---------- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | +competingforawell-knownteaminstock +carracing. +3 Claim: TheGreenBayPackerswereone DocA:ThefirstAFL-NFLWorldChampionshipGamein +of the two teams that played in the first professionalAmericanfootball,knownretroactivelyasSuper +| SuperBowlandalsofacedtheNewYork | | | BowlIand... | ... | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +GiantsatMetLifeStadiumduringthe2013 DocB:TheNationalFootballLeague(NFL)championGreen +regularseason. BayPackersdefeatedtheAmericanFootballLeague(AFL) +championKansasCityChiefs... ... +Table: NotIncludedHere +4 Claim: The team that was promoted to Doc A: Manchester City are the defending champions. +thePremierLeagueinthe2018-19season Wolverhampton Wanderers, Cardiff City and Fulham join +received a higher accolade in the Third asthepromotedclubsfromthe2017–18EFLChampionship. +| DivisionPFATeamoftheYearduringthe | | | ... ... | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | +1980s than a club renowned for its West DocB:...TheywillreplaceWestBromwichAlbion,Swansea +Londonrivalries. CityandStokeCitywhowererelegatedtothe2018–19EFL +| | | | Championship. | ... | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Table: NotIncludedHere +Image: NotIncludedHere +| | Table6: Examplesof1-hop,2-hop,3-hopand4-hopclaimsfromMMCV. | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | +| | | Figure4: | UIforhumanannotators. | | + +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +| | Claim: Jakub Janda, a prominent | Claim: The team that a player | Claim: The opponent in the regular | +| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------------------- | +Claim: Durham, North Carolina, figure in ski jumping, represents a transferred from to Real Betis in season schedule of the 1991 +features a water tower located far +| | country recognized by its flag that | the 2018–19 season, which | Chicago Bears, known for their | +| --- | ------------------------------------ | -------------------------- | ------------------------------- | +from any building's chimney. +| | does not include a blue triangle. | features a flagpole in their logo, is | human logo, was a different team | +| ------------------- | --------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +| True Label: REFUTE. | | | from which Roman Reigns had | +| | True Label: REFUTE | not Real Sociedad. | | +| | | True Label: REFUTE | long careers in the NFL. | +True Label: REFUTE. +o 4-TPG +| Predicted Label: SUPPORT | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | | +| ------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | +| Explanation: The image shows a | Explanation: Claudio Pizarro was | | | +| | | Explanation: China does indeed | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | +water tower in Durham, North born in October 1978, which makes host numerous kite festivals Explanation: The image shows a +Carolina, which appears to be him 45 years old as of October throughout the year, including the CASA C-212 Aviocar aircraft, which +situated away from any visible 2023. If the unnamed Peruvian Weifang International Kite Festival, is a turboprop aircraft. Turboprop +building chimneys. The footballer is not which is a … like Latin America, aircraft are powered by propellers. +… tower is located far from any … footballer, the claim that Pizarro Southeast Asia, and Africa. Confidence Level: 95% +| building's chimney. | is older is supported. | Confidence Level: 95% | | +| --------------------- | ----------------------- | --------------------- | --- | +| Confidence Level: 85% | Confidence Level: 85% | | | +| | Figure5: ErrorAnalysis: | Gemini | | +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +Claim: The background of the +| | Claim: Rochdale finished higher in | Claim: In the film directed by a | Claim: The Argentine Naval | +| ---------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | +| American legal drama series | the final league table of the | British filmmaker unknown for his | | +Prefecture operates CASA C-212 +| created by David E. Kelley is clear, | 1994–95 season compared to the | collaboration with Walt Disney | | +| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | +Aviocar aircraft, +| especially concerning its | team known for its tree emblem, | Studios, a Jamaican actor | | +| -------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | +exploration of legal ethics versus which has a history of competing in infamous for his which are equipped with propellers. +True Label: REFUTE. +| personal morality, which aimed to | lower divisions. | role in a drama appears alongside | | +| ---------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | +| reinforce a more romanticized | True Label: REFUTE | two others in a car. | | +depiction of the legal system. +True Label: REFUTE. +True Label: REFUTE. +inimeG +Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT +Explanation: Extensive research +| | | Explanation: Chinese is widely | Explanation: FA Cup Match: | +| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --------------------------- | +on Scottish football databases and spoken in Hong Kong: Cantonese, Wolverhampton Wanderers did +Predicted Label: SUPPORT +player profiles reveals no record of a variety of... is the primary indeed play … finished second in +Explanation: +a player named Mark Connolly … language for 99.87% of the the Championship, the second tier +It's highly unlikely an unknown Confidence Level: 100% population in Northern Ireland, of English football, securing +team would have achieved a which is factually correct. automatic promotion. +significant victory over them. Confidence Level: 99% Confidence Level: 95% +Confidence Level: 95% +| | Figure6: ErrorAnalysis: | GPT4-o | | +| --- | ----------------------- | ------ | --- | + +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +Claim: The Lake Superior State Claim: The poster for the new Claim: Aaron Gorrell is the player Claim: The Thüringenliga is one of +several regions listed under +| Lakers men's ice hockey team | Wizard of Oz movie features five | who transferred to the Catalans | | +| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | +features a star in its logo. characters. Dragons during the 2008 season, "Promotion To" in the Tier +True Label: REFUTE True Label: REFUTE having joined in October 2007, and VII-Landesligas that partially +| | | is depicted holding a trophy. | extends beyond the country's | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +| | | True Label: REFUTE | borders and was designated under | +"Promotion to" when the +"Relegation to" listing was not +Kreisoberliga. +True Label: REFUTE +AVaLL +Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT +Explanation: The Lake Superior Explanation: The poster for the Explanation: Aaron Gorrell is a Explanation: The Thüringenliga is +State Lakers … The team's logo +| | new Wizard of Oz movie features | rugby league player who … … | indeed one of the regions listed | +| --- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +features a star, which is a +| | five characters, which is evident | There is no evidence to refute this | under "Promotion To" in the Tier | +| --- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | +common symbol in college sports. from the image. … The poster's claim, and it is supported by the VII-Landesligas that partially … +… …Therefore, it is reasonable to design and the choice of fact that Gorrell was a player for that it is a regional league that can +assume that the team's logo +| | characters indicate that the movie | the Catalans Dragons during the | be promoted to higher levels of the | +| ---------------- | ----------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | +| features a star. | is likely to be a faithful … … | | | +| | | 2008 season. | German football league system. | +Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% +| | Figure7: ErrorAnalysis: | LLaVA | | +| --- | ----------------------- | ----- | --- | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k4/question.json b/q79/random_k4/question.json index e5ee9f1e89f998a87deb7981fce08fc5cd10d3a8..011bd82b72f2176330c4504c17fdb54562efadc5 100644 --- a/q79/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q79/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "afe620b9beac86c1027b96d31d396407.pdf", - "web_e8bd96b3e8d8470e.pdf", - "web_db15f36044519c81.pdf", - "web_c83d6885217d96f0.pdf", - "web_93a0de1d8da7a0cf.pdf" + "resize_r2_5.pdf", + "resize_r1_17.pdf", + "resize_r2_20.pdf", + "web_eb947e2ba4f580bd.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k4/random_1.md b/q79/random_k4/random_1.md index 8b5145cdef1e9c769f452af7702f989dc53f9df7..1baafa3214e3d1c3ba84ae8c4e451072ec71f1c5 100644 --- a/q79/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q79/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,2662 +1,891 @@ -Corporate Governance Report -Between my past, the present and the future, there -is one common factor: Relationship and Trust. -This is the foundation of our growth. -Shri Dhirubhai H. Ambani -Founder Chairman -K. Sethuraman Savithri Jyoti Sridhar -Parekh Jain Kothandaraman -Our Corporate Governance practices enable inclusive growth -and help build sustainable societal value -This report is prepared in accordance governance processes and an We believe, Corporate Governance is -with the provisions of the Securities entrepreneurial performance focused not just a destination, but a journey to -and Exchange Board of India work environment. constantly improve sustainable value -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure creation. It is an upward-moving target -The demands of Corporate Governance -Requirements) Regulations, 2015 that we collectively strive towards -require professionals to raise their -(“Listing Regulations”) and the report achieving. Our multiple initiatives -competence and capability levels to -contains the details of Corporate towards maintaining the highest -meet the expectations in managing the -Governance systems and processes at standards of governance are detailed -enterprise and its resources effectively -Reliance Industries Limited (“RIL” or in this Report. -with the highest standards of ethics. -“the Company”). -We have a defined policy framework Corporate Governance -Statement on Company’s for ethical conduct of businesses. We Structure, Policies and -believe that any business conduct -Philosophy on Code Practices -can be ethical only when it rests on -of Governance -the six core values viz. Customer The Company has put in place -Corporate Governance encompasses Value, Ownership Mindset, Respect, an internal multi-tier governance -a set of systems and practices to Integrity, One Team and Excellence. structure with defined roles and -ensure that the Company’s affairs responsibilities of every constituent of -We believe, our governance standards -are managed in a manner which the system. -must be globally benchmarked. -ensures accountability, transparency -Therefore, we have institutionalised -and fairness in all transactions in the Ethics/Governance Policies -the right building blocks for future -widest sense. The objective is to meet -growth. It is our endeavour to achieve At RIL, we strive to conduct our -stakeholders’ aspirations and societal -higher standards and provide oversight business and strengthen our -expectations. We are committed -and guidance to the management relationships in a manner that is -to meet the aspirations of all our -in strategy implementation, risk dignified, distinctive and responsible. -stakeholders. This is demonstrated -management and fulfilment of stated We adhere to ethical standards -in shareholder returns, high credit -goals and objectives. to ensure integrity, transparency, -ratings, awards and recognitions, -independence and accountability -62 Reliance Industries Limited - -in dealing with all the stakeholders. and has a zero-tolerance approach to − Independent review of related -Therefore, we have adopted various non-compliance with the Anti-Bribery party transactions by one of the -codes and policies to carry out our & Anti-Corruption Policy. The Company Big4 accounting firms/Independent -duties in an ethical manner. prohibits bribery, corruption and any accounting firms for arm’s length -form of improper payments/dealings consideration and comparison with -Code of Conduct in the conduct of business operations. the benchmarks available for similar -Training/awareness programmes type of transactions. -The Company has in place a -are conducted on periodical basis to -comprehensive Code of Conduct and -sensitise employees. RIL’s Integrated Reporting -Our Code (the “Codes”) applicable -to the Directors and employees. The The Anti-Bribery & Anti-Corruption RIL published its maiden Integrated -Codes give guidance and reflect Policy is available on the website of Annual Report in the FY 2016-17 -the core values of the Company the Company and can be accessed aligned with the International -viz. Customer Value, Ownership at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/ Integrated Reporting Council’s (IIRC) -Mindset, Respect, Integrity, One Team files/2023-12/RIL-Anti-bribery-and-Anti- framework. RIL’s Integrated -and Excellence. corruption-Policy.pdf. Reporting is covered in Management -Discussion and Analysis Report. -The Codes are available on the -Corporate Governance -website of the Company. The Codes -Board of Directors -have been circulated to the Directors Practices -and Senior Management Personnel RIL endeavours to continuously The Company has defined guidelines -and its compliance is affirmed by improve and adopt the best Corporate and an established framework for -them annually. Governance codes and practices. the meetings of the Board and its -A declaration on confirmation of Some of the implemented global Committees. These guidelines seek -compliance of the Code of Conduct, governance norms and best practices to systematise the decision-making -signed by the Company’s Chairman include the following: process at the meetings of the Board -and Committees in an informed and -and Managing Director is attached to − Quarterly review by the efficient manner. -this Report. Stakeholders’ Relationship -Committee of securities related Core Skills/Expertise/ -Vigil Mechanism and filings with Stock Exchanges. Competencies available with -Whistle-Blower Policy the Board -− Board committees for oversight on -The Company has a Vigil Mechanism matters relating to risks, corporate The Board comprises qualified -and Whistle-Blower policy under which social responsibility, business and experienced members who -the employees are encouraged to responsibility and sustainability possess required skills, expertise and -report violations of applicable laws and reporting, environmental, social and competencies that allow them to make -regulations and the Code of Conduct governance etc. effective contributions to the Board -– without fear of any retaliation. The and its Committees. -− Executive Committees of senior -reportable matters may be disclosed -management for continuous The following skills/expertise/ -to the Ethics & Compliance Task Force -review of operational and financial competencies have been identified -which operates under the supervision -risk mitigation measures and for the effective functioning of the -of the Audit Committee. Employees -governance practices. Company and are currently available -may also report violations to the -with the Board: -Chairman of the Audit Committee. − Independent Internal Audit Function -There was no instance of denial of providing risk based assurance − Leadership/Operational experience -access to the Audit Committee. across all material areas of Group − Strategic Planning -Risk and Compliance exposures. -The Vigil Mechanism and − Industry Experience, Research & -Whistle-Blower Policy is available − Quarterly secretarial compliance Development and Innovation -on the website of the Company and certification from an independent − Global Business -can be accessed at https://www.ril. Company Secretary in whole- -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -com/sites/default/files/2023-01/ time practice. -Risk Management -Vigil-Mechanism-and-Whistle-Blower- -Policy.pdf. − Assurance by an independent − Corporate Governance -firm of Chartered Accountants -on the functions of Registrar and -Anti-Bribery and -Transfer Agent. -Anti-Corruption Policy -The Company is committed in doing -business with integrity & transparency -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 63 - -Corporate Governance Report -While all the Board members possess the skills identified, their area of core expertise is given in their respective -profiles below: -Brief Profile of Directors -Brief profile of Directors of the Company including their category, shareholding in the Company, number of other Directorships -including name of listed entities where he/she is a director alongwith the category of their directorships, committee positions -held by them in other companies as a Member or Chairperson, areas of expertise and other details are given below: -Directorship in other equity listed -| | | company(ies) and category of | Areas of Expertise | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------ | -directorship* -| | Appointed: April 1, 1977 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -| | 80,52,020 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 2 − Industry Experience, Research & -Mukesh D. Ambani** Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -| Chairman and Managing | chairmanship(s) in other | | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | -− Global Business -| Director | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -(DIN: 00001695) -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: June 18, 2014 | − Cipla Limited - | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | -------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: Nil -| | | − Network18 Media & Investments | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | --- | -------------------------------- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 9 -| | | Limited - Independent Director | − Industry Experience, Research & | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -Adil Zainulbhai## chairmanship(s) in other − TV18 Broadcast Limited – Development and Innovation -Independent Director -| Independent Director | company(ies)*^: | | − Global Business | -| -------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | -(DIN: 06646490) 7 – (including 5 as Chairman) − Larsen and Toubro Limited - -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -| | | Independent Director | Risk Management | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --------------- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: June 12, 2015 | − Adani Green Energy Limited - | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | Shareholding*: | Independent Director | Operational experience | -12,899 equity shares -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 -− Industry Experience, Research & -Raminder Singh Gujral Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -| (DIN: 07175393) | company(ies)*^: | | Risk Management | -| --------------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | -| | 2 – (as Chairman) | | − Corporate Governance | -| | Appointed: July 21, 2017 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -| | 14,400 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 -− Global Business -Dr. Shumeet Banerji Committee membership(s)/ − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 02787784) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: October 17, 2018 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -91 equity shares -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 2 -− Global Business -| Arundhati Bhattacharya | Committee membership(s)/ | | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 02011213) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -64 Reliance Industries Limited - -Directorship in other equity listed -| | | company(ies) and category of | Areas of Expertise | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------ | -directorship* -| | Appointed: July 19, 2021 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------------- | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: Nil -− Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: Nil -− Global Business -Committee membership(s)/ -His Excellency Yasir chairmanship(s) in other − Industry Experience, Research & -Othman H. Al Rumayyan company(ies)*^: Nil Development and Innovation -Independent Director -− Corporate Governance -(DIN: 09245977) -| | Appointed: October 18, 2019 | − CCL Products (India) Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | - Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: Nil -| | | − Divi’s Laboratories Limited | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 7 -| | | - Independent Director | − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & | -| --- | --- | ---------------------- | -------------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -K. V. Chowdary chairmanship(s) in other − Tata Motors Limited Risk Management -- Independent Director -Independent Director company(ies)*^: 5 – − Corporate Governance -| (w.e.f. July 21, 2022) | (including 1 as Chairman) | − Anant Raj Limited | | -| ---------------------- | ------------------------- | -------------------- | --- | -(DIN: 08485334) -- Independent Director -| | Appointed: January 20, 2023 | − Jio Financial Services Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -| | | - Independent Director | Operational experience | -Shareholding*: -| | 4,849 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | -------------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -| | Other Directorship(s)*#: 1 | | − Global Business | -K. V. Kamath Committee membership(s)/ − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Independent Director chairmanship(s) in other Risk Management -| (DIN: 00043501) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -− Corporate Governance -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | − Jio Financial Services Limited | − Leadership/ | -| --- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------------- | -Shareholding*: - Non-Executive Director Operational experience -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 4 -− Industry Experience, Research & -| Isha M. Ambani@ | | | Development and Innovation | -| --------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | -Committee membership(s)/ -Non-Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Corporate Governance -| (DIN: 06984175) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| --------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------- | -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------------------- | -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 − Industry Experience, Research & -Akash M. Ambani@ Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Non-Executive Director -| | chairmanship(s) in other | | − Corporate Governance | -| ---------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | -| (DIN: 06984194) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -| | Appointed: October 27, 2023 | Nil | − Leadership/ | -| | Shareholding*: | | Operational experience | -| | 80,52,021 equity shares | | − Strategic Planning | -| | Other Directorship(s)*#: 5 | | − Corporate Governance | -| Anant M. Ambani@ | Committee membership(s)/ | | | -| Non-Executive Director | chairmanship(s) in other | | | -| (DIN: 07945702) | company(ies)*^: Nil | | | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 65 - -Corporate Governance Report -Directorship in other equity listed -company(ies) and category of Areas of Expertise -directorship* -Appointed: June 26, 1986 Nil − Leadership/ -Shareholding*: Operational experience -35,80,529 equity shares − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 1 − Industry Experience, Research & -Nikhil R. Meswani Committee membership(s)/ Development and Innovation -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Global Business -(DIN: 00001620) company(ies)*^: Nil -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -Appointed: August 04, 1995 Nil − Leadership/ -Operational experience -Shareholding*: -34,38,688 equity shares − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 3 − Industry Experience, Research & -Development and Innovation -Hital R. Meswani Committee membership(s)/ -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other − Global Business -(DIN: 00001623) company(ies)*^: − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -1 – (as Chairman) Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -Appointed: August 21, 2009 − Network18 Media & Investments − Leadership/ -Operational experience -Shareholding*: Limited - Non-Executive Director -6,40,000 equity shares − TV18 Broadcast Limited - − Strategic Planning -Other Directorship(s)*#: 5 Non-Executive Director − Industry Experience, Research & -Development and Innovation -P.M.S. Prasad Committee membership(s)/ -− Global Business -Executive Director chairmanship(s) in other -(DIN: 00012144) company(ies)*^: 4 − Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Risk Management -− Corporate Governance -* as on March 31, 2024 -** Promoter Director -# excluding Directorship(s) in foreign companies and Section 8 companies under the Companies Act, 2013. -^ In accordance with Regulation 26 of the Listing Regulations. -## ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as an Independent Director on March 31, 2024. -@ assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -Appointed: April 01, 2024 − Leadership/ -Operational experience -− Strategic Planning -− Financial, Regulatory/Legal & -Haigreve Khaitan$ Risk Management -Independent Director − Corporate Governance -(DIN: 00005290) -$ appointed as an additional director, designated as an independent director of the Company w.e.f. April 1, 2024. -Notes: -a) Shri Mukesh D. Ambani is the father of Ms. Isha M. Ambani, Shri Akash M. Ambani and Shri Anant M. Ambani. -b) Shri Nikhil R. Meswani and Shri Hital R. Meswani are brothers and not related to Promoter Director. -c) None of the other Directors are related to any other Director on the Board. -The detailed profile of the Directors is available on the website of the Company. -The number of Directorship(s) and Committee Membership(s)/Chairmanship(s) of all Directors is/are within the respective limits prescribed under the -Companies Act, 2013 and the Listing Regulations. -66 Reliance Industries Limited - -Board Independence -In the opinion of the Board, the Independent Directors fulfill the conditions specified in the Listing Regulations and are -independent of the management. -Meeting of Independent Directors -The Company’s Independent Directors met 3 (Three) times in the FY 2023-24. Such meetings were conducted to enable -the Independent Directors to discuss matters pertaining to the Company’s affairs and put forth their views. -Board Meetings and Attendance -Number of Board meetings and Attendance of Directors -During the FY 2023-24, 7 (Seven) Board meetings were held as against the statutory requirement of four meetings. -The details of Board meetings and attendance of Directors at these meetings and at last Annual General Meeting (AGM) are -given below: -Board Meetings held on -Last AGM held -| Name of the Director | on August 28, | | | | | | | | | % Attendance | -| -------------------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | -------- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------- | -| | | | April 21, | July 21, | August 28, | October | January | February | March 22, | of Director | -2023 -| | | | 2023 | 2023 | 2023 | 27, 2023 | 19, 2024 | 28, 2024 | 2024 | | -| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -| Mukesh D. Ambani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Adil Zainulbhai@ | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | 85.71% | -| Raminder Singh Gujral | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Dr. Shumeet Banerji | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| Arundhati Bhattacharya | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -His Excellency Yasir Othman H. Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes 71.43% -Al Rumayyan -| K. V. Chowdary | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| ------------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | ------ | -| K. V. Kamath | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Nita M. Ambani* | | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | NA | 66.67% | -| Nikhil R. Meswani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Hital R. Meswani | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| P. M. S. Prasad | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Pawan Kumar Kapil## | | NA | Yes | | NA NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | 100% | -| Isha M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Akash M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| Anant M. Ambani** | | NA | NA | | NA NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| % Attendance | | 100% | 92.31% | 100% | 91.67% | 100% | 92.86% | 85.71% | 100% | | -@ ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as an Independent Director on March 31, 2024. -* ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of August 28, 2023. -** assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -## completed his 5-year term as a whole-time director of the Company, on May 15, 2023. Upon completion of his term, he also ceased to be a Director of -the Company. -Board Familiarisation and Induction Programme -Details of familiarisation programmes for the Independent Directors are available on the website of the Company and can -be accessed at https://www.ril.com/InvestorRelations/Downloads.aspx. -Board Compensation -The Company’s Remuneration Policy for Directors, Key Managerial Personnel and Other Employees is available on the -website of the Company and can be accessed at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/files/2023-01/Remuneration-Policy- -for-Directors.pdf -The Company’s remuneration policy is directed towards rewarding performance, based on review of achievements. -The remuneration policy is in consonance with existing industry practice. -| | | | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | | 67 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Remuneration of the Executive Directors for the Financial is in compliance with applicable laws, -regulations and guidelines. -Year 2023-24 -(C in crore) -Board Committees -Salary, Allowances Retiral Commission Stock -Name of the Director Total -and Perquisites Benefits payable Options The Board has constituted seven main -Committees, viz. Audit Committee, -Mukesh D. Ambani Nil -Human Resources, Nomination -Nikhil R. Meswani 7.59 0.44 17.28 25.31 - -and Remuneration Committee, -Hital R. Meswani 7.70 0.44 17.28 25.42 - -Stakeholders’ Relationship Committee, -P. M. S. Prasad 17.34# 0.59 - 17.93 - -Corporate Social Responsibility -Pawan Kumar Kapil* 0.45 0.02 - 0.47 - -and Governance Committee, -# includes performance linked incentives for the FY 2022-23 paid in the FY 2023-24 -* completed his 5-year term as a whole-time director of the Company, on May 15, 2023. Upon Risk Management Committee, -completion of his term, he also ceased to be a Director of the Company. Performance linked Environmental, Social and Governance -incentives of C 2.30 crore for FY 2022-23 paid in the FY 2023-24. -Committee and Finance Committee -The tenure of office of the Managing Director and Whole-time Directors is for 5 and is authorised to constitute other -(five) years from their respective date of appointment and can be terminated by functional Committees, from time -either party by giving three months’ notice in writing. They are also eligible for to time, depending on business -re-appointment. There is no separate provision for payment of severance fees. needs. The recommendations of -the Committees are submitted to -Remuneration of the Non-Executive Directors for the the Board for approval. During the -year, all the recommendations of -Financial Year 2023-24 -the Committees were accepted by -(C in crore) the Board. -Commission -Name of the Director Sitting Fee Total -payable Smt. Savithri Parekh, Company -Secretary and Compliance Officer of -Adil Zainulbhai 0.31 2.25 2.56 -the Company, is the Secretary to all the -Raminder Singh Gujral 0.30 2.25 2.55 -Committees constituted by the Board. -Dr. Shumeet Banerji 0.22 2.25 2.47 -Arundhati Bhattacharya 0.17 2.25 2.42 -Procedure at Committee -His Excellency Yasir Othman H. Al Rumayyan 0.05 2.25 2.30 -Meetings -K. V. Chowdary 0.41 2.25 2.66 -K. V. Kamath 0.10 2.25 2.35 The Company’s guidelines relating to -Nita M. Ambani* 0.02 0.92 0.94 the Board meetings are applicable -Isha M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 to the Committee meetings. The -composition and terms of reference of -Akash M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 -all the Committees are in compliance -Anant M. Ambani** 0.04 0.97 1.01 -with the Companies Act, 2013 and -Total 1.70 19.58 21.28 -the Listing Regulations, as applicable. -* ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of August 28, 2023. -Each Committee has the authority to -** assumed office as a Non-Executive Director of the Company on October 27, 2023. -engage outside experts, advisors and -During the year, there were no other pecuniary relationships or transactions of counsels to the extent it considers -Non-Executive Directors with the Company. The Company has not granted any appropriate to assist in its functioning. -stock options to its Non-Executive Directors. Minutes of the proceedings of -Committee meetings are circulated to -Directors and Officers Insurance the respective Committee members -and are also placed before the Board -In line with the requirements of Regulation 25(10) of the Listing Regulations, the -for its noting. -Company has in place a Directors and Officers Liability Insurance policy. -Audit Committee -Performance Evaluation Criteria for Directors -Composition -The Human Resources, Nomination and Remuneration Committee has devised -the criteria for evaluation of the performance of the Directors including the Sr. -Name of the Director Designation -No. -Independent Directors. The said criteria specifies certain parameters like -attendance, acquaintance with business, communication inter se between board 1 Raminder Singh Gujral Chairman -members, effective participation, domain knowledge, compliance with code of -2 Adil Zainulbhai Member -conduct, vision and strategy, benchmarks established by global peers etc., which -3 K. V. Chowdary Member -68 Reliance Industries Limited - -Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be a Director of the Company upon completion of The representatives of Statutory -his second term on March 31, 2024 and consequently ceased to be a member Auditors are permanent invitees to -of the Committee. Shri Haigreve Khaitan has been appointed as a member of the the Audit Committee meetings held -Committee w.e.f. April 1, 2024. quarterly, to approve financial results. -The representatives of Statutory -All the members of the Audit Committee possess requisite qualifications. -Auditors, Executives from Accounts -department, Finance department, -Brief Terms of Reference -Corporate Secretarial department and -Terms of Reference of the Committee, inter alia, include the following: -Internal Audit department attend the -− Recommend appointment, remuneration and terms of appointment of Audit Committee meetings. -auditors, including cost auditors, of the Company. -The Lead Cost Auditor attends the -− Approval of payment to statutory auditors, including cost auditors, for any Audit Committee meeting where cost -other services rendered by them. -audit report is discussed. -− Review with the management, the quarterly financial statements before -submission to the Board for approval. Human Resources, Nomination -− Review and monitor the auditor’s independence, performance and and Remuneration Committee -effectiveness of audit process. -Composition -− Approval or any subsequent modification of transactions with related parties -| of the Company. | | | | | Sr. | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ----------- | -| | | | | | Name of the Director | Designation | -No. -− Review the findings of any internal investigations by the internal auditors into -| | | | | | 1 Adil Zainulbhai | Chairman | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | -matters where there is suspected fraud or irregularity or a failure of internal -control systems of a material nature and reporting the matter to the Board. 2 Raminder Singh Gujral Member -− Review the functioning of the whistle-blower mechanism/oversee the 3 Dr. Shumeet Banerji Member -| vigil mechanism. | | | | | 4 K. V. Chowdary | Member | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | -− Review financial statements, in particular the investments made by the Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be -Company’s unlisted subsidiaries. -a Director of the Company upon -completion of his second term on -The detailed terms of reference of the Committee is available on the website of -March 31, 2024 and consequently -the Company. -ceased to be chairman and member of -the Committee. Dr. Shumeet Banerji -Meeting and Attendance -has been appointed as Chairman of the -14 (Fourteen) meetings of the Committee were held during the year, as against -Committee w.e.f. April 1, 2024. -the statutory requirement of four meetings. The details of the meetings and -attendance of members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: -Brief Terms of Reference -| | | Attended by | | % | Terms of Reference of the Committee | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Date of the Meeting Attendance at inter alia, include the following: -| | Raminder | Adil | K. V. | | | | -| --- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | -| | Singh Gujral | Zainulbhai | Chowdary | Meeting | | | -− Formulate the criteria for -April 19, 2023 Yes Yes Yes 100% determining qualifications, positive -attributes and independence of -| April 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -a Director and recommend to -| May 23, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -the Board a policy, relating to the -| July 20, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -remuneration of the Directors, -| July 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -Key Managerial Personnel and -| August 18, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | other employees. | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | -| October 11, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -− Formulate the criteria for evaluation -October 27, 2023 Yes Yes Yes 100% of performance of the Independent -| December 12, 2023 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | Directors and the Board | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------------------ | --- | -of Directors. -| January 12, 2024 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -January 19, 2024 Yes No Yes 66.67% − Devise a policy on Board Diversity. -February 28, 2024 Yes Yes Yes 100% − Identify persons who are qualified -March 12, 2024 Yes Yes Yes 100% to become Directors and who may -be appointed in senior management -| March 22, 2024 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | -| -------------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| % Attendance | 100% | 92.86% | 100% | | | | -| | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | 69 | - -Corporate Governance Report -in accordance with the criteria laid down and to recommend to the Board Shri Adil Zainulbhai ceased to be -their appointment and / or removal. a Director of the Company upon -− Specify the manner for effective evaluation of performance of Board, its completion of his second term on -March 31, 2024 and consequently -Committees and Individual Directors to be carried out either by the Board, -ceased to be chairman and member of -by the Human Resources, Nomination and Remuneration Committee or by an -independent external agency and review its implementation and compliance. the Committee. Shri Raminder Singh -Gujral has been appointed as member -− Recommend to the Board, all remuneration, in whatever form, payable to -and chairman of the Committee w.e.f. -senior management. -April 1, 2024. -− Review Human Resource policies and overall human resources of -the Company. -Brief Terms of Reference -The detailed terms of reference of the Committee is available on the website of Terms of Reference of the Committee, -| the Company. | | | | | | | inter alia, include the following: | | | | -| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -− Frame Risk Management Plan -Meeting and Attendance -and Policy. -6 (Six) meetings of the Committee were held during the year as against statutory -− Oversee implementation/ -requirement of one meeting. The details of the meetings and attendance of -Monitoring of Risk Management -members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: Plan and Policy. -− Periodically review and evaluate -Attended by -| | | | | | % A | t t e n d a n | ce | | | | -| ------------------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| Date of the Meeting | | | | | | | the Risk Management Policy | | | | -| | Adil | Raminder | Dr. Shumeet | | K. V. | a t   M e e t in | g | | | | -Zainulbhai Singh Gujral Banerji Chowdary and Practices with respect -to risk assessment and risk -| April 20, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -management processes. -| June 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | No | Yes | 75% | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -− Review of cyber security and -| July 21, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -related risks. -| August 28, 2023 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -October 18, 2023 Yes Yes Yes Yes 100% The detailed terms of reference of the -Committee is available on the website -| January 18, 2024 | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | 100% | | | | | -| ---------------- | ---- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| % Attendance | 100% | 100% | 83.33% | | 100% | | of the Company. | | | | -Risk Management Committee -Composition -| Sr. No. Name of the Member | | | | | Designation | | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1 Adil Zainulbhai | | | | | Chairman | | | | | | -| 2 Dr. Shumeet Banerji | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 3 K. V. Chowdary | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 4 Hital R. Meswani | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 5 P. M. S. Prasad | | | | | Member | | | | | | -| 6 Srikanth Venkatachari | | | | | Member | | | | | | -Shri Alok Agarwal ceased to be a member of the Committee. -Meeting and Attendance -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee were held during the year as against statutory requirement of two meetings. The -details of the meetings and attendance of members of the Committee at these meetings are given below: -Attended by -% -| Date of Meeting | | | | | | | | | | Attendance | -| --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --------- | ----------- | -| | | Adil Dr. Shumeet | | K. V. | Hital R. | | P. M. S. | Alok | Srikanth | | -Zainulbhai Banerji Chowdary Meswani Prasad Agarwal Venkatachari at Meeting -| May 19, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| ----------------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | -| July 18, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | 85.71% | -| August 10, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | 100% | -| November 28, 2023 | | Yes | Yes | Yes | | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 85.71% | -| % Attendance | | 100% | 100% | 100% | 100% | | 100% | 50% | 75% | | -70 Reliance Industries Limited - -| Corporate Social | | | | No. of Terms of Reference | | -| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | -Type of Complaints -Complaints -| Responsibility & Governance | | | | The terms of reference of the | | -| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | -Committee is available on the website -| Committee | | Non-Receipt of Annual Reports | | 726 | | -| --------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| | | Non-Receipt of Dividend | | 286 of the Company. | | -Composition -| | | Non-Receipt of Interest/ | | 3 | | -| -------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -| Sr. | | | | Meeting and Attendance | | -| Name of the Director | Designation | | | | | -| No. | | Redemption payments | | | | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee -| | | Transfer of securities | | 919 | | -| --------------------- | -------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 1 Dr. Shumeet Banerji | Chairman | | | | | -were held during the year. These -| | | Rights Issue related | | 12 | | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -2 K. V. Chowdary Member meetings were held on April 18, 2023; -| | | Total | | 1,946 | | -| ------------------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | -| 3 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | | | July 18, 2023; November 16, 2023 | | -and March 19, 2024. -As on March 31, 2024, no complaints -Terms of Reference -were outstanding. -| The terms of reference of the | | | | Finance Committee | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -The response time for attending to -| Committee is available on the website | | | | Composition | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -investors’ correspondence during the -of the Company. -financial year 2023-24 is as under: -Sr. -Name of the Director Designation -| Meeting and Attendance | | | | No. | | -| ---------------------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | --- | -| | | Particulars | Number | % | | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee -| | | Total number of | 445,443 | 100.00 1 Mukesh D. Ambani | Chairman | -| --- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | -------- | -were held during the year. These -| | | | | 2 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | ------ | -correspondences -meetings were held on April 19, 2023; -| | | received during the | | 3 Hital R. Meswani | Member | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------------ | ------ | -July 19, 2023; October 18, 2023 and -FY 2023-24 -January 18, 2024. -| | | Replied within 1 to 4 | 444,404 | 99.77 Terms of Reference | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -| | | days of receipt | | The terms of reference of the | | -Stakeholders’ Relationship -Committee is available on the website -| | | Replied after 4 days | 1,039 | 0.23 | | -| --- | --- | --------------------- | ----- | ---- | --- | -Committee -| | | of receipt but within | | of the Company. | | -| ----------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| Composition | | prescribed timelines | | | | -Meeting Details -Sr. -| Name of the Director | Designation | | | | | -| -------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -| No. | | | | 4 (Four) meetings of the Committee | | -Compliance Officer -| 1 K. V. Chowdary | Chairman | | | were held during the year. These | | -| ---------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Smt. Savithri Parekh, Company -meetings were held on May 24, 2023; -| 2 Arundhati | Member | Secretary and Compliance Officer, | | | | -| ------------ | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -November 3, 2023; November 9, -| Bhattacharya | | is the Compliance Officer of | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -2023 and March 13, 2024. -| 3 Nikhil R. Meswani | Member | the Company. | | | | -| ------------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | -| 4 Hital R. Meswani | Member | | | Succession Planning | | -Environmental, Social and -The Company believes that sound -Brief Terms of Reference -Governance Committee -succession plan for the senior -The terms of reference of the -leadership is very important for -Composition -Committee is available on the website creating a robust future for the -| of the Company. | | Sr. | | | | -| --------------- | --- | -------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -| | | Name of the Director | Designation | Company. The Human Resources, | | -No. -Nomination and Remuneration -Meeting and Attendance -| | | 1 Hital R. Meswani | Chairman | Committee works along with the | | -| --- | --- | ------------------ | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -4 (Four) meetings of the Committee 2 Arundhati Bhattacharya Member Human Resource team of the -were held during the year as against Company for a structured leadership -| | | 3 P. M. S. Prasad | Member | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -| statutory requirement of one meeting. | | | | succession plan. | | -| These meetings were held on April | | Shri Pawan Kumar Kapil completed | | | | -his 5-year term as a whole-time -19, 2023; July 18, 2023; October 17, -director of the Company, on May 15, -2023 and January 12, 2024. -2023. Upon completion of his term, -he ceased to be a Director and -Investor Grievance Redressal -member of the Environmental, Social -The number of complaints received -and Governance Committee of the -| and resolved to the satisfaction of | | Company. He attended the meeting of | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -investors during the financial year -the Committee held on April 18, 2023. -2023-24 (with an investor base of -~34.63 lakh) and their break-up are -as under: -| | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | 71 | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Senior Management -Particulars of senior management: -| Name of Senior | | Name of Senior | | -| --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -| Sr. | | Sr. | | -Management Personnel Designation Management Personnel Designation -| No | | No | | -| ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -| (“SMP”) | | (“SMP”) | | -1 Shri Srikanth VenkatachariChief Financial Officer 6 Shri Srinivas Tuttagunta COO Supply & Trading -2 Shri Harish Shah President - Corporate Planning & 7 Shri Avinash Kumar VermaPresident Operations – Petchem -| | Strategy | 8 Shri B Narayan | Chief Procurement Officer | -| --------------------- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------- | -| 3 Shri L. V. Merchant | Group Controller | | | -| | | 9 Shri Ashwani Prashara | CHRO Hydrocarbons Operations | -4 Smt. Savithri Parekh Company Secretary and 10 Shri Mahesh Marve Head of Technology -Compliance Officer -| | | 11 Shri Durga Dube | Executive Vice President and Head | -| ------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------------------------------- | -| 5 Shri Sanjiv Singh | Group President - Oil to Chemicals | | | -- Cyber Security and Information -Risk Management -During the financial year, Shri Alok Agarwal ceased to be a senior management personnel -Framework for Monitoring Subsidiary Companies -The details of material subsidiaries, during the financial year 2023-24, are given below: -| | Place of | | Date of Appointment of | -| ---- | --------------------- | -------------------------- | ----------------------- | -| Name | Date of Incorporation | Name of Statutory Auditors | | -| | Incorporation | | Statutory Auditors | -Jio Platforms Limited November 15, 2019 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP/ December 21, 2020 -Chaturvedi & Shah LLP -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited February 15, 2007 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP/ September 26, 2019/ -| | | DTS & Associates LLP | September 28, 2020 | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------ | -Reliance Retail Limited June 29, 1999 India DTS & Associates LLP September 30, 2022 -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited December 13, 2006 India Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP September 24, 2020 -Reliance Global Energy Services August 12, 2008 Singapore Deloitte and Touche LLP, September 26, 2023 -| (Singapore) Pte. Limited | | Singapore | | -| ------------------------ | --- | --------- | --- | -Reliance International Limited June 16, 2021 Abu Dhabi PKF Accountants & Business December 18, 2023 -Advisers LLP -The composition and effectiveness of Boards of subsidiaries is reviewed by the Company periodically. A robust compliance -management system covering all the subsidiaries is also in place. -The Company is in compliance with the provisions governing material subsidiaries. Copy of the Secretarial Audit Reports -of Jio Platforms Limited, Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -forms part of this report. The Secretarial Audit Report of these material subsidiaries does not contain any qualification, -reservation, adverse remark or disclaimer. -The Company’s Policy for determining Material Subsidiaries is available on the website of the Company and can be accessed -at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/files/2023-01/Material-Subsidiaries.pdf. -72 Reliance Industries Limited - -General Body Meetings − Approval of Material Related Party -Transactions of the Company; and -Annual General Meetings -− Approval of Material Related Party -The date, time and venue of the Annual General Meetings held during preceding -Transactions of Subsidiaries of -three years and the special resolution(s) passed thereat, are as follows: -the Company. -Date and Time Special Resolution(s) Passed Venue The same shall be passed in compliance -August 28, 2023 1. R e-appointment of Shri Mukesh D. Ambani as Held through with the provisions of the Companies -02:00 p.m. Managing Director video Act, 2013 and the Listing Regulations. -2. R e-appointment of Smt. Arundhati Bhattacharya conference/ -as an Independent Director other audio- Means of Communication -3. Alteration of Articles of Association of the Company visual means -Quarterly results: The Company’s -4. A lteration of Objects Clause of the Memorandum (Deemed venue -quarterly/half-yearly/annual financial -of Association of the Company - 3rd Floor, Maker -results are sent to the Stock Exchanges -August 29, 2022 1. A ppointment of Shri K. V. Chowdary as an Chambers IV, -and published in ‘Indian Express’, -02:00 p.m. Independent Director 222, Nariman -‘Financial Express’ and ‘Loksatta’. They -2. A lteration of Objects Clause of the Memorandum Point, Mumbai – -are also available on the website of -of Association of the Company 400 021) -the Company. -June 24, 2021 1. R e-appointment of Dr. Shumeet Banerji as an -02:00 p.m. Independent Director News releases, presentations: -Official news releases and official -Tribunal Convened Meeting Procedure adopted for Postal -media releases are generally sent to -In accordance with the order dated Ballot Stock Exchanges and are also available -March 27, 2023 passed by the The Postal Ballot was carried out as on the website of the Company. -Hon’ble National Company Law per the provisions of Sections 108 and -Presentations to institutional -Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, the Company 110 and other applicable provisions of investors/analysts: Detailed -convened meetings of its Equity the Companies Act, 2013, read with presentations are made to institutional -Shareholders, Secured Creditors the rules framed thereunder, and MCA investors and financial analysts on the -and Unsecured Creditors on May 2, Circulars. Shri Anil Lohia, a Practising Company’s quarterly, half-yearly as -2023, to consider and approve, the Chartered Accountant, (Membership well as annual financial results and are -Scheme of Arrangement between No.: 031626), Partner, Dayal and sent to the Stock Exchanges. These -Reliance Industries Limited and its Lohia, Chartered Accountants acted as presentations, video recordings and -shareholders and creditors & Reliance Scrutiniser for conducting the Postal transcript of the meetings are available -Strategic Investments Limited and its Ballot in a fair and transparent manner. on the website of the Company. -shareholders and creditors. The Scrutiniser submitted his report -on October 27, 2023 after completion Website: The Company’s website -Members and Creditors exercised their -of scrutiny. Voting results are available (www.ril.com) contains a separate -vote(s) by remote e-voting and e-voting -on the website of the Stock Exchanges dedicated section ‘Investor Relations’ -at the meeting. -and the Company. where shareholders’ information -Voting results of the meetings are is available. -It is proposed to obtain approval of -available on the website of the Stock -members of the Company, through Chairman’s Communiqué: A copy -Exchanges and the Company. -Postal Ballot, by way of remote of the Chairman’s speech is sent to -e-voting process for: all the shareholders, whose e-mail -Resolution(s) passed through -addresses are registered with the -Postal Ballot − Appointment of Shri Haigreve Company/Depository Participants. -Khaitan (DIN: 00005290) as The document is also available on the -During the year, ordinary resolutions -an Independent Director of website of the Company. -for appointment of Ms. Isha M. -the Company; -Ambani, Shri Akash M. Ambani -Letters/e-mails/SMS to Investors: -and Shri Anant M. Ambani as Non- − Re-appointment of His Excellency Apart from sending Annual Report, -Executive Directors of the Company, Yasir Othman H. Al Rumayyan (DIN: the Company has also addressed -were passed by members of the 09245977) as an Independent various investor-centric letters/e- -Company on October 26, 2023 Director of the Company; mails/SMS to its shareholders during -through postal ballot. The resolutions − Re-appointment of Shri P.M.S. the year. This include reminders for -were passed with more than Prasad (DIN: 00012144) as a claiming unclaimed/unpaid dividend -requisite majority. Whole-time Director designated as from the Company; claiming shares -an Executive Director; lying in unclaimed suspense account -with the Company; dematerialisation -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 73 - -Corporate Governance Report -of shares, updating e-mail address, to all the shareholders who have June 30, 2024 - Third week of -PAN, bank account details and furnished bank account details to the July, 2024; -Nomination details. The Company Company/its Registrar and Transfer September 30, 2024 - Fourth week of -has sent Quarterly and Annual Agent/Depository Participant, October, 2024; -financial results of the Company filed as applicable. December 31, 2024 - Third week of -| with the Stock Exchanges to all the | | January, 2025; and | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | -shareholders, whose e-mail addresses March 31, 2025 - Fourth week of -Financial Year -| are registered with the Company/ | | April, 2025. | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | -April 1 to March 31 -Depository Participants. -Annual General Meeting – July/ -In accordance with the SEBI Circulars the Financial Calendar August -Company has sent letters, emails and -(Tentative) Results for the -SMS, to its shareholders intimating them -quarter ending -to furnish valid PAN, Nomination, Contact -details, Mobile Number, Specimen -Listing on Stock Exchanges -Signature, Bank Account details updated, -for receiving dividend electronically with   Name of the stock exchanges   Address -effect from April 01, 2024. Equity Shares − BSE Limited (BSE) − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal -| | ISIN: | Scrip Code – 500325 | Street, Mumbai – 400 001 | -| --- | ------ | ------------------- | ------------------------ | -Chatbot: State of the art Chatbot -| | INE002A01018 | − National Stock Exchange of | − Exchange Plaza, C-1, G Block, | -| --- | ------------ | ----------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -application providing shareholders -| | | India Limited (NSE) | Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra | -| --- | --- | --------------------- | ----------------------------- | -instant automated annual general -| | | Trading Symbol – RELIANCE | (East), Mumbai – 400 051 | -| --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------------------ | -meeting related query resolution -| | Global Depository − Luxembourg Stock Exchange | | − 35A Boulevard Joseph II, | -| ------------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | -| was deployed. | Receipts (GDRs) | | L-1840, Luxembourg | -SEBI Complaints Redress System Overseas − The Bank of New York − 101, Barclay Street New York, -| | Depository | Mellon Corporation | NY 10286 | -| --- | ---------- | ------------------ | -------- | -(SCORES): Investor complaints are -− Empire Complex, 1st Floor, 414, -| processed at Securities and Exchange | Domestic | − ICICI Bank Limited | | -| ------------------------------------- | --------- | -------------------- | --- | -Board of India (“SEBI”) in a centralised Custodian Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel -(West), Mumbai – 400 013 -web-based complaints redress system. -The salient features of this system are Debentures − BSE Limited (BSE) − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal -Street, Mumbai – 400 001 -centralised database of all complaints, -online upload of Action Taken Reports − National Stock Exchange of − Exchange Plaza, C-1, G Block, -by concerned companies and online India Limited (NSE) Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra -(East), Mumbai – 400 051 -viewing by investors of actions taken on -the complaints and their current status. Bonds − Singapore Exchange Limited − 4 Shenton Way, #02-01 SGX -Centre 2, Singapore 068807 -Shareholders’ Feedback Survey: -| | | − Luxembourg Stock Exchange | − 35A Boulevard Joseph II, | -| --- | --- | --------------------------- | --------------------------- | -The Company takes feedback from -L-1840, Luxembourg -shareholders on various matters − India International Exchange − 1st Floor, Unit No. 101, The -relating to investor services and Annual -| | | (IFSC) Limited (India Inx) | Signature Building No. 13B, Road | -| --- | --- | -------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -Report for improvement in future. -1C, Zone 1, GIFT SEZ, GIFT CITY, -Gandhinagar – 382 355 -General Shareholder -| | Commercial | − BSE Limited | − Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers, Dalal | -| ----------- | ----------- | ------------- | ----------------------------------- | -| Information | Papers | | Street, Mumbai – 400 001 | -Annual General Meeting Payment of Listing Fees the Statutory Auditors are a part, -during the year ended March 31, -| August 29, 2024 at 02.00 P.M. | Annual listing fees for the FY 2024-25 | | | -| ------------------------------ | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -2024, is C 78.65 crore. -| IST through Video Conferencing/ | has been paid by the Company to BSE | | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | -| Other Audio Visual Means as set out | Limited and National Stock Exchange | | | -Credit Rating -| in the Notice convening the Annual | of India Limited. | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -General Meeting. Deemed venue The Company’s financial discipline -of the meeting is 3rd Floor, Maker and prudence is reflected in the -Fees Paid to the Statutory -Chambers IV, 222, Nariman Point, strong credit ratings ascribed by rating -Auditors -| Mumbai – 400 021. | | agencies. There has been no revision in | | -| ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Total fees, for all services, paid by -credit ratings during the FY 2023-24. -the Company and its subsidiaries, -| Dividend Payment Date | | The details of the Credit Rating are | | -| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -| | on a consolidated basis, to Statutory | mentioned in Management Discussion | | -| Between August 29, 2024 and | Auditors of the Company and other | | | -and Analysis Report. -September 04, 2024 electronically -firms in the network entity of which -74 Reliance Industries Limited - -Debenture Trustee -Axis Trustee Services Limited -The Ruby, 2nd Floor, SW, 29, Senapati Bapat Marg, Dadar (West), Mumbai – 400 028 -Tel: +91-22-62300451, Fax: +91-22-62300700 -E-mail: debenturetrustee@axistrustee.in; complaints@axistrustee.in, Website Address: www.axistrustee.in -Stock Market Price Data -| | | National Stock Exchange of India Limited (NSE) | | | | | BSE Limited (BSE) | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -Month -| | | High Price (K) | Low Price (K) | | High Price (K) | | Low Price (K) | | -| --- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | -| | | | | Volume (No.) | | | | Volume (No.) | -April 2023 2,424.95 2,308.55 9,68,40,090 2,424.00 2,308.50 29,79,991 -May 2023 2,537.70 2,413.05 10,08,69,573 2,537.45 2,413.35 28,44,256 -June 2023 2,584.00 2,451.00 10,32,48,415 2,584.00 2,451.05 36,47,741 -July 2023 2,856.00 2,469.30 19,84,24,710 2,855.00 2,469.55 89,78,788 -August 2023 2,582.80 2,399.90 14,92,37,543 2,582.15 2,400.00 78,91,449 -September 2023 2,483.00 2,325.00 15,85,16,918 2,489.70 2,325.65 73,58,764 -October 2023 2,367.00 2,220.30 10,28,36,679 2,367.15 2,221.05 76,82,544 -November 2023 2,411.95 2,275.20 10,35,67,402 2,411.75 2,275.25 1,01,68,137 -December 2023 2,614.00 2,377.60 12,77,31,315 2,614.80 2,380.00 2,17,58,563 -January 2024 2,919.95 2,568.95 13,29,79,070 2,917.95 2,568.30 77,53,399 -February 2024 2,999.90 2,836.10 11,94,05,281 2,999.85 2,836.70 50,51,876 -March 2024 3,024.90 2,825.80 11,30,97,499 3,024.80 2,826.90 50,44,754 -[Source: This information is compiled from the data available on the websites of BSE and NSE] -Share Price Performance in comparison to broad based indices – BSE Sensex and NSE Nifty as on -March 31, 2024 -| | | | | RIL Share Sensex Performance | | | RIL Share | NIFTY | -| ---------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ----------------------------- | ------- | ------------------ | ---------- | ----------- | -| | | | Performance on BSE | | | Performance on NSE | | Performance | -| FY 2023-24 | | | | 27.70% | 24.85% | | 27.48% | 28.61% | -| 2 Years | | | | 13.02% | 25.75% | | 12.79% | 27.84% | -| 3 Years | | | | 48.60% | 48.76% | | 48.36% | 51.98% | -| 5 Years | | | | 118.39% | 90.45% | | 117.99% | 92.08% | -| 10 Years | | | | 540.52% | 229.00% | | 538.56% | 233.03% | -RIL’s share price on BSE and NSE has been adjusted for the FY 2017-18 and earlier years, on account of issue of bonus -shares in the FY 2017-18. -BSE Sensex vs RIL Share Price NSE Nifty vs RIL Share Price -| 75000 | | | 3,000 | 23000 | | | | 3,000 | -| ----- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -| 73000 | | | | 22000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,800 | | | | | 2,800 | -| 71000 | | | | 21000 | | | | | -| 69000 | | | 2,600 | 20000 | | | | 2,600 | -| 67000 | | | | 19000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,400 | | | | | 2,400 | -| 65000 | | | | 18000 | | | | | -| 63000 | | | 2,200 | 17000 | | | | 2,200 | -| 61000 | | | | 16000 | | | | | -| | | | 2,000 | | | | | 2,000 | -| 59000 | | | | 15000 | | | | | -| 57000 | | | 1,800 | 14000 | | | | 1,800 | -32-rpA 32-yaM 32-nuJ 32-luJ 32-guA 32-peS 32-tcO 32-voN 32-ceD 42-naJ 42-beF 42-raM 32-rpA 32-yaM 32-nuJ 32-luJ 32-guA 32-peS 32-tcO 32-voN 32-ceD 42-naJ 42-beF 42-raM -| | BSE Sensex | RIL | | | NSE Nifty | | RIL | | -| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | 75 | - -Corporate Governance Report -Registrar and Transfer Agent Share Transfer System the year, all certificates/Letters of -confirmation for transfer (pursuant to -| KFin Technologies Limited | | As mandated by SEBI, securities of | | | | | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Selenium Tower B, Plot 31-32, the Company can be transferred/ Court order received from Custodian -Government of India Account, -| Gachibowli, Financial District, | | traded only in dematerialised form. | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -The Special Court (Torts) Act, -| Nanakramguda, Hyderabad – 500 032 | | Shareholders holding shares in physical | | | | | | | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Toll Free No.: 1800 309 4001 (From form are advised to avail the facility 1992), transmission, transposition, -sub-division, consolidation, renewal, -| 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on all working | | of dematerialisation. | | | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -| days) | | | | | exchange and change/deletion of | | | | -The Company has received a -names of shareholders, were issued -E-mail: rilinvestor@kfintech.com, -| | | certificate from a Company Secretary | | | as required under Regulation 40(9) | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Website: www.kfintech.com -in Practice, certifying that during -of the Listing Regulations. The said -certificate was duly filed with the -Stock Exchanges. -Shareholding Pattern as on March 31, 2024 -Total Number -| | | | Total Number | Total Number of | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Sr. Category of Shareholder Number of of Shares (Fully Shares (Partly of Shares (Fully % of Total Number -| No. | | Shareholders | | | | Paid-up & Partly | of Shares (A+B+C) | | -| --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ----------------- | ----------------- | --- | -| | | | Paid-up) | | Paid-up) | | | | -Paid-up) -(A) Promoter and Promoter Group -| (1) Indian | | | 47* 3,32,27,48,048 | | - | 3,32,27,48,048 | | 49.11% | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -| (2) Foreign | | | - | - | - | | - | - | -Total Shareholding of Promoter 47* 3,32,27,48,048 - 3,32,27,48,048 49.11% -and Promoter Group -(B) Public Shareholding -(1) Institutions 2,298 2,58,55,09,468 - 2,58,55,09,468 38.21% -(2) Central Government/State 75 76,87,594 - 76,87,594 0.12 % -Government(s)/President of India -(3) Non-institutions 34,60,855 68,79,29,270 4,17,418 68,83,46,688 10.17% -Total Public Shareholding 34,63,228 3,28,11,26,332 4,17,418 3,28,15,43,750 48.50 % -(C) Non-Promoter -Non-Public -(1) Shares held by Custodian(s) against 1 16,18,17,216 - 16,18,17,216 2.39% -which Depository Receipts have -been issued -Total shares held by Non-Promoter 1 16,18,17,216 - 16,18,17,216 2.39% -Non-Public -Total (A) + (B) + (C) 34,63,276 6,76,56,91,596 4,17,418 6,76,61,09,014 100% -* As per information furnished by the Promoter and Promoter Group, there are 52 members forming part of Promoter and Promoter Group of the -Company, of which 5 promoter group entities do not hold any shares. -Dematerialisation of Shares issue of fully paid-up equity shares is Relevant data for the average daily -| | | available on the website of the Company | | | turnover of equity shares for the | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -Mode of Holding % of Total Shares and can be accessed at https://www.ril. FY 2023-24 is given below: -com/sites/default/files/2024-07/Build- -| NSDL | 96.00 | | | | Particulars | | BSE NSE | Total | -| ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | -up-of-Equity-Share-Capital.pdf -| CDSL | 3.37 | | | | Shares | 3,70,570 | 61,25,018 | 64,95,588 | -| ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | -(Nos.) -| Physical | 0.63 | | | | | | | | -| -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Liquidity -| | | | | | Value | 93.57 | 1,568.69 | 1,662.26 | -| ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | -------- | -------- | -| Total | 100.00 | | | | (C in crore) | | | | -The Company’s equity shares are -among the most liquid and actively -Build-up of Equity Share Capital, [Source: This information is compiled from the -| | | traded shares on the Indian Stock | | | data available on the websites of BSE and NSE] | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -category-wise shareholding, -Exchanges. RIL shares consistently rank -Dividend declared for the last 10 among the top few frequently traded Outstanding Global -years, Bonus Issue of fully paid- shares both in terms of the number of Depository Receipts (GDRs)/ -shares traded as well as value. -| up equity shares | | | | | Warrants and Convertible | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -The statement showing build-up of Bonds, Conversion Date and -| equity share capital, category-wise | | | | | Likely Impact on Equity | | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -shareholding, dividend declared by the -GDRs: Outstanding GDRs as -Company in the last 10 years, bonus -on March 31, 2024 represent -76 Reliance Industries Limited - -16,18,17,216 equity shares Risk Management Policy with offer financial instruments -| constituting 2.39% of Company’s | | | | (derivatives), that enable | | | -| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -Respect to Commodities -| paid-up equity share capital. Each | | | | managing the Price risk. | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | -Including Through Hedging -GDR represents two underlying equity - Strategic decisions regarding -shares in the Company. GDR is not a -• Commodities Exposure -the timing and the usage of -| specific time-bound instrument and | The Company is exposed to price | | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -derivatives instruments such as -can be surrendered at any time and -| | volatility on various Petroleum, | | | Swaps/Futures/Options are taken | | | -| ------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| converted into the underlying equity | Petrochemical and other Energy | | | | | | -based on various factors including -shares in the Company. The shares -| | related commodities, as part of its | | | market conditions, physical | | | -| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | -so released in favour of the investors -business operations. Due to the -inventories, macro-economic -| upon surrender of GDRs can either be | dynamic markets, prices of such | | | | | | -| ------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -situation. These decisions and -held by investors concerned in their -| | Commodities fluctuate and can | | | execution are done in line with | | | -| ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| name or sold in the Indian secondary | result in Margin Risk. This policy | | | | | | -the Board approved Commodities -markets for cash. To the extent of -| | prescribes the guidelines for | | | Risk Management Framework. | | | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -shares so sold in Indian markets, -hedging Commodities Price risks. -The Risk Management Committee -GDRs can be reissued under the -has oversight on all hedging -| available headroom. | • Hedging Policy | | | | | | -| ------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -actions taken. - Exposures are identified and -There are no outstanding warrants or -| | measured across the Company | | | More details on Risk Management | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | -convertible bonds having any impact -| | so that appropriate hedging | | | are covered under the Enterprise | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | -on equity. -| | can be done on a net basis. For | | | Risk Management section of the | | | -| --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | commodities hedging, there | | | Management Discussion and | | | -RIL GDR Programme -| | exist Over The Counter (OTC) | | | Analysis Report. | | | -| -------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| The Global Depository Receipts of the | and exchange markets that | | | | | | -Company are listed on Luxembourg -Stock Exchange and are traded on -Exposure of the Company to commodity risks, which are -the International Order Book (London -material is as under: -Stock Exchange) and amongst qualified -institutional investors on the over-the- -counter market in the United States Exposure % of such exposure hedged through -| | | | in quantity | commodity derivatives | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --------------------- | -------------------- | --- | -| of America. | | Exposure | terms | | | | -| | | | | Domestic market | International market | | -| | | towards | towards | | | | -RIL GDRs are exempted securities -| | Commodity | the | the | | | | -| --- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Name | particular | particular | | | | -under US Securities Law. RIL GDR -| | | commodity | commodity | | | Total | -| --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | -programme has been established (in K crore) OTC Exchange OTC Exchange* -(in 1000 -Metric -under Rule 144A and Regulation S of -tonnes) -the US Securities Act, 1933. Reporting -is done under the exempted route of -| | Crude | 3,22,745 | 71,424 | - | - 0.18% 12.50% | 12.68% | -| --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | ------ | -Rule 12g3-2(b) under the US Securities Middle 1,99,956 30,523 - - 2.49% 17.50% 19.99% -Exchange Act, 1934. -Distillates -| | Light | 1,07,146 | 16,173 | - | - 0.00% 9.15% | 9.15% | -| --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | --- | ------------- | ----- | -Commodity Price Risks/ -Distillates -Foreign Exchange Risk and -| | Polymer | 54,294 | 5,694 | - | - - | - - | -| --- | ------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -Hedging Activities -| | Petchem | 42,779 | 5,162 | - | - 0.00% 0.00% | 0.00% | -| ---------------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | ----- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -| The Company has in place a robust | Intermediate | | | | | | -risk management framework for -| | Polyester | 24,859 | 2,393 | - | - - | - - | -| --- | --------- | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -identification and monitoring and -| | Total | 7,51,779 | 1,31,369 | | | | -| --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -mitigation of commodity price and -*Includes OTC transactions cleared through International Exchanges. -foreign exchange risks. The risks are -tracked and monitored on a regular -basis and mitigation strategies -are adopted in line with the risk -management framework. For further -details on the above risks, please -refer the Enterprise Risk Management -section of the Management Discussion -and Analysis Report. -| | | | Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 | | | 77 | -| --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | - -Corporate Governance Report -Plant Locations in India The procedure for claiming underlying -shares and unpaid/unclaimed dividend -| Oil to Chemicals | DTA Jamnagar Refinery | Jamnagar, Gujarat | | | | | -| ---------------- | --------------------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | SEZ Jamnagar Refinery | | | from IEPF Authority is covered in the | | | -Hazira Manufacturing Division Surat, Gujarat Shareholders’ Referencer available on -Dahej Manufacturing Division Bharuch, Gujarat the website of the Company. -| | Vadodara Manufacturing Division | Vadodara, Gujarat | | | | | -| --- | ------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Patalganga Manufacturing Division Raigad, Maharashtra Further, in accordance with the IEPF -Rules, the Board of Directors have -Nagothane Manufacturing Division -Silvassa Manufacturing Division Union Territory of Dadra and Nagar appointed Smt. Savithri Parekh as -| | | Haveli and Daman and Diu | | Nodal Officer of the Company and | | | -| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | Barabanki Manufacturing Division | Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh | | | | | -Shri Vivin Mally as Deputy Nodal -| | Hoshiarpur Manufacturing Division | Hoshiarpur, Punjab | | | | | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Officer of the Company for the -| Oil & Gas | KG-D6 | East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh | | | | | -| --------- | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -purposes of verification of claims of -| | Coal Based Methane | Shahdol, Madhya Pradesh | | | | | -| --- | ------------------ | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -Composites Vadodara Composites Division Vadodara, Gujarat shareholders pertaining to shares -Textiles Naroda Manufacturing Division Ahmedabad, Gujarat transferred to IEPF and/or refund -of dividend from IEPF Authority and -for coordination with IEPF Authority. -b) transferred 9,71,654 equity -Address for Correspondence The details of the Nodal Officer and -shares of C 10/- each, to the credit -For shares held in physical form Deputy Nodal Officer are available on -of IEPF Authority. -the website of the Company. -KFin Technologies Limited -| Selenium Tower B, Plot 31-32, | | The Company has uploaded on its | | | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | website, the details of unpaid and | | Unclaimed amounts relating | | | -Gachibowli Financial District, -unclaimed amounts lying with the -Nanakramguda, Hyderabad – 500 032 to interest and/or redemption -| Toll Free No.: 1800 309 4001 (From | | Company as on March 31, 2024. | | | | | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -proceeds of debentures issued -| 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on all working | | Details of shares transferred to IEPF | | | | | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -by the Company -days) -Authority during FY 2023-24 are -E-mail: rilinvestor@kfintech.com, also available on the website of the During the FY 2023-24, no claims -| Website: www.kfintech.com | | | | were received by the Company from | | | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Company. The Company has also -the debenture holders with respect to -uploaded these details on the website -For shares held in demat form -| | | of the IEPF Authority (www.iepf.gov.in). | | any amounts. No unclaimed amounts | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Depository Participant(s) of the relating to interest and/or redemption -| investor concerned and/or | | The voting rights on the shares | | | | | -| --------------------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -proceeds of debentures is lying -| KFin Technologies Limited. | | transferred to IEPF Authority shall | | | | | -| -------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -with the Company as on the date of -| | | remain frozen till the rightful owner | | this report. | | | -| ------------------------------ | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -| Any Query on the Annual Report | | claims the shares. | | | | | -| Smt. Savithri Parekh | | | | Equity Shares in the Unclaimed | | | -Last date to claim unclaimed/unpaid -Company Secretary and dividends before transfer to IEPF, Suspense Account -Compliance Officer -| | | for the financial year 2016-17 and | | In terms of Regulation 39 of the Listing | | | -| --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Reliance Industries Limited -thereafter, are as under: -Regulations, details of the equity -3rd Floor, Maker Chambers IV, 222, -shares lying in the Unclaimed Suspense -| Nariman Point, | | | Date to claim | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ----------------------- | ---------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | -| | | Financial Declaration | | Account are as follows: | | | -| | | Year Date | before transfer | | | | -| Mumbai – 400 021 | | | to IEPF | | | | -No. of -| E-mail: investor.relations@ril.com; | | | | | | No. of | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | -------------- | ----------------- | ------------- | --------- | -| | | 2016-17 July 21, | August 26, | | Shareholders | | -| rilagm@ril.com | | | | Particulars | | Equity | -| | | | | | (Phase-wise | Shares | -| | | 2017 | 2024 | | Transfers) | | -| Transfer of Unpaid/Unclaimed | | 2017-18 July 5, | August 4, 2025 | | | | -| | | | | Aggregate number | 61,371 | 57,88,946 | -2018 -| Amounts of dividend and | | | | of shareholders | | | -| ------------------------ | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -| | | 2018-19 August 12, | September 11, | | | | -and the -Shares to Investor Education -| | | 2019 | 2026 | outstanding shares | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -and Protection Fund 2019-20 July 15, August 14, in the Unclaimed -| | | 2020 | 2027 | Suspense Account | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -In accordance with the provisions of 2020-21 June 24, July 26, 2028 lying as on April 1, -| the Companies Act, 2013, during the | | | | 2023 | | | -| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | -2021 -| year, the Company has: | | | | Less: Number | 2,002 | 2,78,370 | -| ---------------------- | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | -| | | 2021-22 August 29, | September 30, | | | | -of shareholders -| | | 2022 | 2029 | who approached | | | -| --- | --- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --- | -a) credited C 29.60 crore to Investor -| | | 2022-23 August 28, | September 27, | the Company for | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | -------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -Education and Protection Fund -transfer of shares -2023 2030 -(IEPF); -78 Reliance Industries Limited - -No. of with Related Party Transactions. The dated September 20, 2021, -No. of -Shareholders -Particulars Equity Company has made full disclosure of disposed off the show cause -(Phase-wise -Transfers) Shares transactions with the related parties notice without levy of any penalty. -as set out in Note 34 of Standalone -Add: Number - - (ii) O n December 16, 2010, SEBI -of shareholders Financial Statement, forming part of -issued a show cause notice (SCN), -and aggregate the Annual Report. -inter alia to the Company (RIL) in -number of shares -transferred to connection with the trades by RIL -the Unclaimed Details of non-compliance in the stock exchanges in 2007 in -Suspense Account by the Company, penalties, the shares of Reliance Petroleum -during the year -Less: Number of 154 17,583 strictures imposed on the Limited, then a subsidiary of RIL. -shares transferred Hearings were held before the -Company by stock exchange -to IEPF Authority Whole Time Member (WTM) of -during the year or SEBI, or any statutory -SEBI in respect of the SCN. By -Aggregate number 59,215 54,92,993 -authority, on any matter an order dated March 24, 2017, -of shareholders -and the related to capital markets, the WTM passed the directions: -outstanding shares (i) prohibiting inter alia RIL from -during the last three years -in the Unclaimed dealing in equity derivatives in -Suspense Account (i) T he Securities and Exchange the ‘Futures & Options’ segment -lying as on March -31, 2024 Board of India (SEBI), on of stock exchanges, directly or -August 8, 2014 had passed indirectly, for a period of one year -The voting rights on the shares in the an adjudication order on a from the date of the order; and -suspense account as on March 31, show cause notice issued to (ii) to RIL to disgorge an amount of -2024 shall remain frozen till the the Company for alleged non- C 447.27 crore along with interest -rightful owner claims the shares. disclosure of the diluted Earnings at the rate of 12% per annum -per Share in the quarterly from November 29, 2007 till the -Other Disclosures financial results for the quarters date of payment. In May 2017, -Disclosure on materially ended June 2007, September RIL and the other noticees filed -2007, December 2007, March an appeal before the Securities -significant related party -2008, June 2008 and September Appellate Tribunal (SAT) against -transactions that may have 2008 and imposed monetary this order. SAT, by a majority -potential conflict with the penalty of C 13 crore. On an order (2:1), dismissed the appeal -Company’s interests at large appeal by the Company, the on November 5, 2020 and -Hon’ble Securities Appellate directed RIL to pay the disgorged -There were no materially significant Tribunal set aside SEBI’s order amount within sixty days from the -related party transactions which could and remanded the matter for date of the order. The appeal of -have potential conflict with interest of fresh consideration by SEBI. SEBI RIL and other noticees has been -the Company at large. issued a fresh show cause notice admitted by the Hon’ble Supreme -The Company’s Policy on Materiality dated April 5, 2016 in the matter Court of India. By its order -of Related Party Transactions and alleging incorrect disclosure of dated December 17, 2020, the -on dealing with Related Party the diluted Earnings per Share. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India -Transactions is available on the website The Company filed a reply to the directed RIL to deposit C 250 -of the Company and can be accessed show cause notice and attended crore in the Investors’ Protection -at https://www.ril.com/sites/default/ the personal hearing on July 26, Fund, subject to the final result -files/2023-01/Policy-on-Materiality- 2016. SEBI appointed new of the appeal and stayed the -of-RPT.pdf. Adjudicating Officer (AO). The recovery of the balance, inclusive -last hearing before the AO was of interest, pending the appeal. -All the contracts/arrangements/ held on November 22, 2018. RIL has complied with the order -transactions entered by the Company Further details sought by AO were dated December 17, 2020 of the -during the financial year with related provided in December, 2018. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. -parties were in its ordinary course of After more than 2 years, the AO -business and on an arm’s length basis. sent a letter dated March 19, In the very same matter, on -2021 granting an opportunity to November 21, 2017, SEBI issued -During the FY 2023-24, contracts/ -the Company to make additional show cause notice, inter alia, to -arrangements/transactions were -submissions and personal hearing RIL, asking RIL to show cause -entered into with related parties in -in the matter. The Company filed as to why inquiry should not be -accordance with the policy of the -additional submissions in the held in terms of SEBI (Procedure -Company on Materiality of Related -matter. The AO, vide his order for Holding Inquiry and Imposing -Party Transactions and on dealing -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 79 - -Corporate Governance Report -Penalties by Adjudicating Officer) by Adjudicating Officer) Rules, Loans granted to subsidiaries are -Rules, 1995 and penalty not be 1995 read with Section 15I of given in Notes to the Standalone -imposed under the provisions the Securities and Exchange Financial Statement. -| of the Securities and Exchange | Board of India Act, 1992 for | | -| ------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -Board of India Act, 1992. The alleged violation of Principle No. Agreements relating to the -Adjudicating Officer of SEBI 4 under Schedule A – Principles Company -| passed an order on January 1, | for Fair Disclosure of UPSI read | | -| ------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -There are no agreements with any -2021 imposing a penalty of with Regulation 8(1) of SEBI party which impact the management -| C 25 crore on RIL. RIL paid the | (Prohibition of Insider Trading) | | -| -------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -or control of the Company or impose -| penalty under protest and filed | Regulations, 2015 read with | | -| -------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | -any restriction or create any liability -an appeal before the SAT against Regulation 30(11) of SEBI (Listing upon the Company. -| this order. SAT has vide its order | Obligations and Disclosure | | -| ----------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | -| dated December 4, 2023 did not | Requirements) Regulations, | | -Adoption of Mandatory and -| interfere with the order passed | 2015. The alleged violation, | | -| -------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -by the AO since the matter was if established, will make RIL Discretionary Requirements -already covered by its earlier liable for monetary penalty (of not The Company has complied with all -decision dated November 5, less than C 1 lakh and which may mandatory requirements of Regulation -extend to maximum of C 1 crore) -2020, which is in appeal by RIL 34 of the Listing Regulations. -| before the Hon’ble Supreme | under Section 15HB of the SEBI | | -| --------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -The Company has adopted the -| Court. RIL has filed an appeal in | Act, 1992. RIL filed a detailed | | -| ---------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -following discretionary requirements -Hon’ble Supreme Court against reply to this show cause notice. of the Listing Regulations: -| Order dated December 4, 2023 | The Adjudicating Officer of SEBI | | -| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ------------------- | -| of the SAT. | passed an order on June 20, | Audit Qualification | -2022 imposing a penalty of C 30 -(iii) T he Company had issued The Company is in the regime -lakh. Appeal has been filed before -| debentures with convertible | | of unmodified opinions on | -| ---------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | -the Securities Appellate Tribunal -| warrants in the year 1994 and | | financial statements. | -| ------------------------------ | --- | --------------------- | -(“SAT”) against this order. SAT has -allotted equity shares against -stayed the operation of the order -the warrants in the year 2000. Reporting of Internal Auditor -dated June 20, 2022 and appeal -In this matter, SEBI had filed a -| | is pending. | The Internal Audit Department | -| --- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | -complaint on July 16, 2020, inter of the Company, co-sourced with -alia against the Company before -professional firms of Chartered -| the Special Court, Mumbai, for | Disclosures in relation to the | | -| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Accountants, reports directly to the -taking cognisance of alleged Sexual Harassment of Women Audit Committee. -offences under Regulations 3, -at Workplace (Prevention, -The Company is in compliance -5 and 6 of SEBI (Prohibition of -Prohibition and Redressal) -| Fraudulent and Unfair Trade | | with the corporate governance | -| --------------------------------- | --------- | ------------------------------ | -| Practices relating to Securities | Act, 2013 | | -requirements specified in -| Market) Regulations, 1995 and | The Company is committed to provide | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Regulations 17 to 27 and -| section 77(2) and section 77A | a work environment which ensures that | | -| ------------------------------ | -------------------------------------- | --- | -Regulation 46(2)(b) to (i) of the -| of Companies Act, 1956. The | every employee is treated with dignity, | | -| ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Special Court, Mumbai, vide order respect and afforded equal treatment. Listing Regulations. -| dated September 30, 2020, | Training/awareness programmes are | | -| -------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -dismissed SEBI’s complaint as conducted throughout the year to Certificate on Compliance -| barred by limitation. Against | create sensitivity towards ensuring | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -with Code of Conduct -| the said order of the Special | respectable workplace. Please refer | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | --- | -I hereby confirm that the Company -| Court, SEBI has filed a revision | Human Capital section of Management | | -| --------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -application before the Hon’ble Discussion and Analysis Report, for has obtained from all the members -of the Board and Senior Management -| High Court, Bombay and the same | more details. | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------- | -| is pending. | | Personnel, the affirmation that they | -have complied with the ‘Code of -Details of loans and advances -(iv) O n December 22, 2021, SEBI Conduct’ and ‘Our Code’ in respect of -| issued a show cause notice | in the nature of loans to firms/ | | -| --------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -the FY 2023-24. -| inter alia to RIL asking it to show | companies in which directors | | -| ------------------------------------ | ----------------------------- | --- | -cause as to why inquiry should -are interested -| not be held against it in terms | | Mukesh D. Ambani | -| -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | -| | The Company has not given any loans | Chairman and Managing Director | -of SEBI (Procedure for Holding -| Inquiry and Imposing Penalties | or advances to any firm/company in | | -| ------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -April 22, 2024 -which its directors are interested. -Mumbai -80 Reliance Industries Limited - -Certificate of Non-Disqualification of Directors -(pursuant to Regulation 34(3) read with Schedule V Para C Clause (10)(i) of the SEBI -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015) -To: India (hereinafter referred to as ‘the considered necessary and explanations -The Members Company’), produced before me furnished to me by the Company & -Reliance Industries Limited by the Company for the purpose of its officers, I hereby certify that none -3rd Floor, Maker Chambers IV, 222 issuing this Certificate, in accordance of the Directors on the Board of the -Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021 with Regulation 34(3) read with Company as stated below for the -Maharashtra, India. Schedule V Para-C Clause 10(i) of the financial year ended 31 March 2024, -Securities and Exchange Board of India have been debarred or disqualified -I have examined the relevant registers, -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure from being appointed or continuing -records, forms, returns and disclosures -Requirements) Regulations, 2015. as Directors of companies by the -received from the Directors of -Securities and Exchange Board of -Reliance Industries Limited having In my opinion and to the best of my -India, Ministry of Corporate Affairs or -CIN L17110MH1973PLC019786 and information and according to the -any such other Statutory Authority. -registered office at 3rd Floor, Maker verifications (including Directors -Chambers IV, 222, Nariman Point, Identification Number (DIN) status -Mumbai 400 021, Maharashtra, at the portal www.mca.gov.in) as -Date of Date of -Sr. Sr. -Name of Director DIN appointment in Name of Director DIN appointment in -No. No. -the Company the Company -1. Mukesh Dhirubhai Ambani 00001695 01.04.1977 9. Nita Mukesh Ambani** 03115198 18.06.2014 -2. Adil Zainulbhai* 06646490 20.12.2013 10. Isha Mukesh Ambani@ 06984175 27.10.2023 -3. Raminder Singh Gujral 07175393 12.06.2015 11. Akash Mukesh Ambani@ 06984194 27.10.2023 -4. Shumeet Banerji 02787784 21.07.2017 12. Anant Mukesh Ambani@ 07945702 27.10.2023 -5. Arundhati Bhattacharya 02011213 17.10.2018 13. Nikhil Rasiklal Meswani 00001620 26.06.1986 -6. Veerayya Chowdary Kosaraju 08485334 18.10.2019 14. Hital Rasiklal Meswani 00001623 04.08.1995 -7. His Excellency Yasir Othman H. 09245977 19.07.2021 15. Madhusudana Sivaprasad Panda 00012144 21.08.2009 -Al-Rumayyan 16. Pawan Kumar Kapil# 02460200 16.05.2010 -8. Kundapur Kamath 00043501 20.01.2023 -* ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his second term as Independent Director on 31 March 2024 -** ceased to be a director of the Company w.e.f. end of business hours of 28 August 2023 -@ assumed office as a Non-executive Director of the Company on 27 October 2023 -# ceased to be a director of the Company upon completion of his term as a whole-time director on 15 May 2023 -neither an assurance as to the future the management has conducted the -Ensuring the eligibility of the -viability of the Company nor of the affairs of the Company. -appointment / continuity of every -efficiency or effectiveness with which -Director on the Board is the -responsibility of the management of -Dr. K. R. Chandratre -the Company. My responsibility is to -FCS No.: 1370, C. P. No.: 5144 -express an opinion on these, based -Place: Pune UDIN: F001370F000213230 -on my verification. This certificate is -Date: 22 April 2024 Peer Review Certificate No.: 1206/2021 -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 81 - -Corporate Governance Report -CEO/CFO Certificate -Under Regulation 17(8) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 -To, -The Board of Directors -Reliance Industries Limited -1. W e have reviewed financial statements and the cash flow statement of Reliance Industries Limited (“the Company”) -for the year ended March 31, 2024 and to the best of our knowledge and belief: -i. t hese statements do not contain any materially untrue statement or omit any material fact or contain statements -that might be misleading; -ii. t hese statements together present a true and fair view of the Company’s affairs and are in compliance with -existing accounting standards, applicable laws and regulations. -2. T here are, to the best of our knowledge and belief, no transactions entered into by the Company during the year which -are fraudulent, illegal or violative of the Company’s Code of Conduct. -3. W e accept responsibility for establishing and maintaining internal controls for financial reporting and we have -evaluated the effectiveness of Company’s internal control systems pertaining to financial reporting. We have not come -across any reportable deficiencies in the design or operation of such internal controls. -4. We have indicated to the Auditors and the Audit Committee that: -i. there are no significant changes in internal controls over financial reporting during the year; -ii. there are no significant changes in accounting policies during the year; and -iii. there are no instances of significant fraud of which we have become aware. -Srikanth Venkatachari Mukesh D. Ambani -Chief Financial Officer Chairman & Managing Director -Place: Mumbai -Date: April 22, 2024 -82 Reliance Industries Limited - -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to Section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule No. 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel) Rules, 2014] -To ii. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and b) T he Securities and -| | the Regulations and Bye-laws | Exchange Board of India | -| --- | ----------------------------- | ------------------------ | -The Members, -Jio Platforms Limited framed thereunder; and (Listing Obligations and -Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point Disclosure Requirements) -iii. F oreign Exchange Management -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi, | | Regulations, 2015; | -| ---------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -Act, 1999 and the Rules and -Ahmedabad - 380006 -| | Regulations made thereunder | c) T he Securities and | -| --- | ------------------------------ | ------------------------ | -We have conducted the Secretarial to the extent of Foreign Direct Exchange Board of India -Audit of the compliance of Investment and Overseas (Substantial Acquisition -applicable statutory provisions Direct Investments; of Shares and Takeovers) -| and adherence to good corporate | | Regulations, 2011; | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -iv. T he Securities Contracts -practices by Jio Platforms Limited -| | (Regulation) Act, 1956 and the | d) T he Securities and Exchange | -| --- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -[CIN: U72900GJ2019PLC110816] -| | Rules framed thereunder. | Board of India (Prohibition of | -| --- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | -(hereinafter called the ‘Company’) -Insider Trading) Regulations, -| for the financial year ended March We have also examined compliance | | | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -2015; * -| 31, 2024 (hereinafter called the by the Company with the applicable | | | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -‘period under audit’). Secretarial clauses of the Secretarial Standard on e) T he Securities and -Audit was conducted in a manner that Meetings of Board of Directors (SS-1) Exchange Board of India -provided us with a reasonable basis for and Secretarial Standard on General (Share Based Employee -evaluating the Company’s corporate Meetings (SS-2) issued by the Institute Benefits and Sweat Equity) -conducts/statutory compliances and of Company Secretaries of India Regulations, 2021; -| expressing our opinion thereon. which are mandatorily applicable to | | | -| -------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | - f) T he Securities and -the Company. -| Based on our verification of the | | Exchange Board of India | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -Company’s books, papers, minute During the period under audit, (Issue of Capital and -books, forms and returns filed and the Company has complied with Disclosure Requirements) -other records maintained by the the provisions of the Act, Rules, Regulations, 2018; -| Company and provided to us including Regulations, Standards, etc. | | | -| ------------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | - g) T he Securities and -| through permitted access to the mentioned above. | | | -| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -Company’s in-house portal as also the -| During the period under audit, | | (Issue and Listing of Non- | -| ------------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | -information provided by the Company, -| provisions of the following Acts, Rules | | Convertible Securities) | -| ---------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -its officers, agents and authorised -| and Regulations were not applicable to | | Regulations, 2021; | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -representatives during the conduct -the Company: -of secretarial audit, we hereby report h) T he Securities and Exchange -that in our opinion, the Company i. F oreign Exchange Management Board of India (Delisting of -has, during the period under audit, Act, 1999 and the Rules and Equity Shares) Regulations, -complied with the statutory provisions Regulations made thereunder to 2021; and -| listed hereunder and also that the | the extent they related to Foreign | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | - i) T he Securities and -| Company has proper Board-processes | Direct Investment and External | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| and compliance-mechanism in place to | Commercial Borrowings; | | -| ------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | -(Buyback of Securities) -the extent, in the manner and subject -| ii. | T he following Regulations and | Regulations, 2018. | -| ---- | ------------------------------- | ------------------ | -to the reporting made hereinafter. -Guidelines prescribed under the - * The Company being a -| We have examined the books, papers, | Securities and Exchange Board of | | -| ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -material subsidiary of -| minute books, forms and returns | India Act, 1992: - | | -| -------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | -Reliance Industries Limited -filed and other records maintained -| | a) T he Securities and Exchange | (“RIL”) as defined in | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ---------------------- | -by the Company for the audit period -| | Board of India (Registrars to | Regulation 16(1)(c) of the | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --------------------------- | -according to the provisions of: -| | an Issue and Share Transfer | SEBI (Listing Obligations and | -| --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -i. T he Companies Act, 2013 Agents) Regulations, 1993 Disclosure Requirements) -(“the Act”) and the Rules regarding the Act and dealing Regulations, 2015 as -| framed thereunder; | with clients; | amended, certain employees | -| ------------------ | ------------- | --------------------------- | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 83 - -Corporate Governance Report -of the Company have been of the directors were received for actions which have a major bearing -categorised as “Designated scheduling meeting at a shorter notice. on the Company’s affairs have taken -Persons” and are covered Agenda and detailed notes on agenda place, in pursuance of the above -under the RIL’s Code of were also sent to all the directors of referred laws, rules, regulations and -Conduct framed under the the Company at least seven days in standards except for the following: -| Securities and Exchange | advance, except where consent of | | -| ------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -1. T he Board of Directors of the -| Board of India (Prohibition | directors were received for circulation | | -| ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | -Company at their meeting held on -| of Insider Trading) | of the Agenda and notes on Agenda | | -| -------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -20th April, 2023, had approved -| Regulations, 2015. | at a shorter notice. A system exists | | -| ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | -investment in Accops Systems -for seeking and obtaining further -iii. T he Company has not entered Private Limited, in one or more -information and clarifications on the -into any listing agreements with tranches, for an amount up to -agenda items before the meeting and -| the stock exchanges. | | C 516 crore. | -| -------------------- | --- | ------------ | -for ensuring meaningful participation -| We further report that - | by the directors at the meetings. | | -| ------------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -For BNP & Associates -| The Board of Directors of the Company | All decisions at the Meetings of the | | -| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -Company Secretaries -| is duly constituted with proper balance | Board and its Committees were carried | | -| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -of Executive, Non-Executive and out unanimously as recorded in the [Firm Regn. No. P2014MH037400] -PR No. 637/2019 -| Independent Directors. The changes | minutes of the meetings of the Board | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -in the composition of the Board of of Directors or Committees of the Date: 21/04/2024 -Place: Mumbai -| Directors that took place during the | Board, as the case may be. | | -| ------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | -period under audit were carried out -We further report that there are -in compliance with the provisions of Kalidas Ramaswami -adequate systems and processes in the -the Act. Partner -Company commensurate with its size -FCS: 2440/CP No. 22856 -| Adequate notices were given to all | and operations to monitor and ensure | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -UDIN: F002440F000200176 -| directors of the Company as regards | compliance with the applicable laws, | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | -| the schedule of the Meetings of the | rules, regulations and guidelines. | | -Note: This report is to be read with our -Board (including Meetings of its -| | We further report that during the | letter of even date which is annexed as | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | -Committees), except where consent -| | period under audit, no specific events/ | Annexure A and forms an integral part | -| --- | --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | -of this report. -Annexure A -To, done on test-check basis to management. Our examination -The Members, ensure that correct facts are was limited to the verification of -Jio Platforms Limited reflected in secretarial records. procedures on test-check basis. -| Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point | We believe that the process and | | -| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -6. T he Secretarial Audit Report -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi | practices, we followed provide a | | -| --------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -is neither an assurance as -| Ahmedabad - 380006 | reasonable basis for our opinion. | | -| ------------------ | --------------------------------- | --- | -to the future viability of the -Re: Secretarial Audit Report of 3. W e have not verified the Company nor of the efficacy or -even date is to be read along with correctness and appropriateness effectiveness with which the -this letter. of financial records and Books of management has conducted the -| | Accounts of the Company. | affairs of the Company. | -| --- | ------------------------ | ----------------------- | -1. M aintenance of secretarial -records is the responsibility of the 4. W herever required, we For BNP & Associates -management. Our responsibility have obtained management Company Secretaries -is to express an opinion on these representation about the [Firm Regn. No. P2014MH037400] -secretarial records based on compliance of laws, rules and PR No. 637/2019 -| our audit. | regulations and happening of | Date: 21/04/2024 | -| ---------- | ----------------------------- | ---------------- | -| | events, etc. | Place: Mumbai | -2. W e have followed the audit -| practices and processes as were | 5. T he compliance of the provisions | | -| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -Kalidas Ramaswami -| appropriate to obtain reasonable | or corporate and other applicable | | -| --------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -assurance about the correctness laws, rules, regulations, Partner -of the contents of the secretarial standards, is the responsibility of FCS: 2440/CP No. 22856 -UDIN: F002440F000200176 -records. The verification was -84 Reliance Industries Limited - -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to Section 204 (1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule No.9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial personnel) Rules, 2014] -To IV. T he Foreign Exchange 3. T he Telecom Regulatory Authority -| The Members, | Management Act, 1999 and | of India Act, 1997; | -| ------------ | ------------------------- | ------------------- | -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, the Rules/Regulations made 4. T he Information Technology -Office – 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point thereunder to the extent of Act, 2000 -| Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi, | Overseas Direct Investments and | | -| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | -5. T he Aadhaar and Other Laws -| Ahmedabad 380006. | External Commercial Borrowings; | | -| ----------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -(Amendment) Act, 2019 -V. T he Securities and Exchange -We have conducted the Secretarial -| | Board of India (Issue and Listing | Based on such examination and having | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | -Audit of the compliance of applicable -| | of Non-Convertible Securities) | regard to the compliance system | -| --- | ------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -statutory provisions and the adherence -prevailing in the Company, we report -| to good corporate practices by | Regulations, 2021; | | -| ------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | -that, the Company has complied with -| Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, | VI. T he Securities and Exchange | | -| ------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -the provisions of the above laws during -| (CIN: U72900GJ2007PLC105869) | Board of India (Listing Obligations | | -| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -the period under audit. -| (hereinafter called the ‘Company’) | and Disclosure Requirements) | | -| ----------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -for the financial year ended March Regulations, 2015; As on March During the period under audit, -31, 2024 (‘period under audit’). 31, 2024, 50,000 6.20% provisions of the following Acts, Rules -| Secretarial Audit was conducted in | Unsecured Redeemable Non- | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | -and Regulations were not applicable to -a manner that provided us with a Convertible Debentures of the Company: -face value of C 10 lakh each, -reasonable basis for evaluating the -| | aggregating to C 5,000 crore, | 1. F oreign Exchange Management | -| --- | ------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | -Company’s corporate conducts/ -Act, 1999 and the Rules and -| statutory compliances and for | were listed for trading on BSE | | -| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | -expressing our opinion thereon. Limited and the National Stock Regulations made thereunder -with respect to Foreign -Exchange of India Limited. -| Based on our verification of the | | Direct Investment. | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -VII. T he Securities and Exchange -Company’s books, papers, minute -2. T he following Regulations and -| books, forms and returns filed and | Board of India (Prohibition of | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | -Guidelines prescribed under the -| other records maintained and provided | Insider Trading) Regulations, | | -| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | -Securities and Exchange Board of -2015, including maintenance of a -| to us including through access to the | | India Act, 1992: | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | -‘Structural Digital Database’. -Company’s in-house portal as also the - (a) T he Securities and Exchange -information provided by the Company, -| | We have also examined compliance | Board of India (Registrars to | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -its officers, agents and authorised -by the Company with the applicable -representatives, during the conduct an Issue and Share Transfer -clauses of the Secretarial Standard on -Agents) Regulations, 1993 -| of Secretarial Audit, we hereby report | Meetings of Board of Directors (SS-1) | | -| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | -relating to the Companies -| that in our opinion, the Company | and Secretarial Standard on General | | -| --------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | -Act, 2013 and dealing -has, during the period under audit, -| | Meetings (SS-2) issued by the Institute | with clients; | -| --- | ---------------------------------------- | ------------- | -complied with the statutory provisions -of Company Secretaries of India and -listed hereunder and also that the (b) T he Securities and -notified by Central Government under -Exchange Board of India -| Company has proper Board-processes | Section 118(10) of the Act which are | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | -and compliance-mechanism in place to mandatorily applicable to the Company. (Substantial Acquisition -the extent, in the manner and subject of Shares and Takeovers) -to the reporting made hereinafter. During the period under audit, Regulations, 2011; -the Company has complied - (c) T he Securities and -| We have examined the books, papers, | with the provisions of the Act, | | -| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| minute books, forms and returns filed | Rules, Regulations, Standards, as | | -| -------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | -(Issue of Capital and -and other records maintained by the -| | mentioned above. | Disclosure Requirements) | -| --- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | -Company for the period under audit -according to the provisions of: We have also examined, on test-check Regulations, 2018; -| | basis, the relevant documents and | (d) T he Securities and | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --------------------------- | -I. T he Companies Act, 2013 -records maintained by the Company -| (“the Act”) and the Rules | | Exchange Board of India | -| -------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------ | -| | according to the following laws | (Share Based Employee | -made thereunder; -| | applicable specifically to the Company: | Benefits and Sweat Equity) | -| --- | --------------------------------------- | --------------------------- | -II. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -Regulations, 2021; -1. T he Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 -the Regulations and Bye-laws -& Indian Telegraph Right of Way -| framed thereunder; | | (e) T he Securities and | -| ------------------ | ------------ | --------------------------- | -| | Rules, 2016; | Exchange Board of India | -III. T he Securities Contracts -| | 2. T he Indian Wireless Telegraphy | (Delisting of Equity Shares) | -| --- | ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | -(Regulation) Act, 1956 and the -Regulations, 2021; -| Rules made thereunder; | Act, 1933; | | -| ---------------------- | ---------- | --- | -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 85 - -Corporate Governance Report -(f) T he Securities and All decisions at the meetings of CIR/2021/613 dated August 10, -Exchange Board of India the Board and the meetings of 2021. As on March 31, 2024, -(Buy-back of Securities) the Committees were carried out CPs amounting to C 2,500 crore -Regulations, 2018. unanimously as recorded in the were outstanding. -minutes of the meetings of the Board -We further report that: iii) A s per the recommendation made -of Directors or Committees of the -by the Board of Directors of the -The Board of Directors of the Company Board, as the case may be. -company, at their meeting held on -is duly constituted with proper balance -We further report that there are April 21, 2023, the shareholders -of Executive Director, Non-Executive -adequate systems and processes in the of the Company at their 16th -Directors and Independent Directors. -Company, which are commensurate Annual General Meeting of the -The changes in the composition of -with its size and operations, to monitor company, held on September 26, -the Board of Directors that took place -and ensure compliance with applicable 2023, have approved by special -during the period under audit were -laws, rules, regulations and guidelines. resolution an amendment in the -carried out in compliance with the -Articles of Association of the -provisions of the Act. We further report that during the -company, through insertion of -period under audit, the following -Adequate notice was given to all new Article 90A after the existing -specific events/actions having major -directors of the Company as regards article 90. -bearing on the Company’s affairs -the schedule of the meetings of the -have taken place in pursuance of the For BNP & Associates -Board (including meetings of the -above referred laws, rules, regulations -Committees) except where consent Company Secretaries -and standards: -of directors was received for holding [Firm Reg No: P2014MH037400] -the meeting at a shorter notice. i) T he Company has raised External PR No: 637/2019 -Agenda and detailed notes on Agenda Commercial Borrowings by way of Date: April 22, 2024 -were also sent to all the directors foreign currency syndicated term Place: Mumbai -of the Company at least seven days loans of up to US$ 2,976 Million, -in advance, except in cases where Euro 90.599 Million and JPY Kalidas Ramaswami -consent of directors was received for 86,736.6 Million. -Partner -circulation of the Agenda and notes on -ii) T he Company had issued FCS: F2440/CP No. 22856 -Agenda at a shorter notice. A system -Commercial Papers (“CPs”), in UDIN: F002440F000203291 -exists for seeking and obtaining further -one or more tranches, which -information and clarifications on the -agenda items before the meetings and were listed on the BSE Limited in Note: This report is to be read with our -for meaningful participation by the accordance with the provisions letter of even date which is annexed as -directors at the meetings. of SEBI Operational Circular Annexure A and forms an integral part of -bearing no. SEBI/HO/DDHS/P/ this report. -Annexure - A -To test-check basis to ensure that examination was limited to the -The Members, correct facts are reflected in verification of procedures on test- -Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited secretarial records. We believe check basis. -Office - 101, Saffron, Nr. Centre Point that the process and practices, -6. T he Secretarial Audit Report -Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawadi we followed provide a reasonable -is neither an assurance as -Ahmedabad, 380006 basis for our opinion. -to the future viability of the -Re: Secretarial Audit Report of even 3. W e have not verified the Company nor of the efficacy or -date is to be read along with this letter. correctness and appropriateness effectiveness with which the -of financial records and Books of Management has conducted the -1. M aintenance of secretarial -Accounts of the Company. affairs of the Company. -records is the responsibility of the -Management. Our responsibility 4. W herever required, we For BNP & Associates -is to express an opinion on the have obtained Management Company Secretaries -secretarial records based on representation about the [Firm Reg No: P2014MH037400] -our audit. compliance of laws, rules and PR No: 637/2019 -2. W e have followed the audit regulations and happening of Date: April 22, 2024 -practices and processes as were material events, etc. Place: Mumbai -considered appropriate to obtain 5. T he compliance of the provisions -reasonable assurance about or corporate and other applicable Kalidas Ramaswami -the correctness of the contents laws, rules, regulations, Partner -of the secretarial records. standards, is the responsibility FCS: F2440/CP No. 22856 -The verification was done on of the Management. Our UDIN: F002440F000203291 -86 Reliance Industries Limited - -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Rule 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel), Rules, 2014] -To an unavoidable risk that some i) T he Companies Act, 2013 -The Members misstatements or material non- (“the Act”) and the rules -Reliance Retail Limited compliances may not be detected, made thereunder; -3rd Floor, Court House even though the audit is properly -ii) T he Securities Contracts -Lokmanya Tilak Marg planned and performed in accordance -(Regulation) Act, 1956 (‘SCRA’) -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 with the CSAS. -and the rules made thereunder- -We have conducted the secretarial Not Applicable to the Company -Basis for Opinion -audit of the compliance of applicable during the Audit Period; -statutory provisions and the adherence We have followed the audit practices -iii) T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -to good corporate practices by and processes as were appropriate to -the Regulations and Bye-laws -Reliance Retail Limited having CIN: obtain reasonable assurance about -framed thereunder; -U01100MH1999PLC120563 (‘the the correctness of the contents of the -Company’). Secretarial Audit was secretarial records. The verification iv) F oreign Exchange Management -conducted in a manner that provided was done on test basis to ensure Act, 1999 and the rules and -us a reasonable basis for evaluating that correct facts are reflected in regulations made thereunder -the corporate conducts/statutory the secretarial records. We believe to the extent of Overseas -compliances and expressing our that the processes and practices, we Direct Investment; -opinion thereon. followed provide a reasonable basis for -v) T he following Regulations and -our opinion. -Guidelines prescribed under the -Management’s -Securities and Exchange Board of -responsibility Opinion India Act, 1992 (‘SEBI Act’):- -The Management along with the Based on our verification of the a) T he Securities and Exchange -Board of Directors are responsible for Company’s books, papers, minute Board of India (Substantial -ensuring that the Company complies books, forms and returns filed and Acquisition of Shares and -with the provisions of all applicable other records maintained by the Takeovers) Regulations, -laws and maintains the required Company and provided as scanned 2011- Not Applicable to -statutory records and documents in copies in physical or electronic mode -the Company during the -the prescribed manner. or through permitted access to the Audit Period; -Company’s in-house portal and also -the information provided by the b) T he Securities and Exchange -Auditor’s responsibility -Company, its officers and authorised Board of India (Prohibition of -Based on audit, our responsibility representatives during the conduct Insider Trading) Regulations, -is to express an opinion on the of secretarial audit, we hereby report 2015- Not Applicable to -compliance with the applicable laws that in our opinion, the Company has, the Company during the -and maintenance of records by the during the audit period covering the Audit Period; -Company. We conducted our audit financial year ended on March 31, -in accordance with the auditing 2024 (‘the Audit Period’), complied c) T he Securities and Exchange -standards CSAS 1 to CSAS 4 (‘CSAS’) with the statutory provisions listed Board of India (Issue of -prescribed by the Institute of Company hereunder and also that the Company Capital and Disclosure -Secretaries of India. These standards has proper Board-processes and Requirements) Regulations, -require that the auditor complies with compliance-mechanism in place to the 2018- Not Applicable to -statutory and regulatory requirements extent, in the manner and subject to the Company during the -and plans and performs the audit to the reporting made hereinafter: Audit Period; -obtain reasonable assurance about d) T he Securities and Exchange -compliance with applicable laws and We have examined the books, papers, Board of India (Share Based -maintenance of records. minute books, forms and returns Employee Benefits and -filed and other records maintained -Due to the inherent limitations of by the Company for the Audit Period Sweat Equity) Regulations, -an audit including internal, financial according to the provisions of: 2021 - Not Applicable to -and operating controls, there is -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 87 - -Corporate Governance Report -the Company during the We further report that, the Company convened and held, at shorter notice -Audit Period; has identified the following laws as with the consent of the members, in -specifically applicable to the Company: due compliance with the applicable -e) T he Securities and Exchange -provisions of the Act. -Board of India (Issue and i) T he Food Safety and Standards -Listing of Non-Convertible Act, 2006 and Rules; We further report that having regard -Securities) Regulations, to the compliance system prevailing in -ii) T he Legal Metrology Act 2009 -2021 Not Applicable to the Company and as per explanations -and Rules; -the Company during the and management representations -Audit Period; iii) S tate Agriculture Produce obtained and relied upon by us the -Marketing Act; Company has adequate systems and -f) T he Securities and Exchange -processes commensurate with the -Board of India (Registrars to iv) T he Bureau of Indian Standards -size and operations of the Company to -an Issue and Share Transfer Act, 2016; -monitor and ensure compliance with -Agents) Regulations, 1993 -v) The Trade Marks Act, 1999. applicable laws, rules, regulations -regarding the Companies Act -and guidelines. -and dealing with client - Not We further report that- -Applicable to the Company We further report that, during -The Board of Directors of the Company -during the Audit Period; the Audit Period the Company has -was constituted comprising Executive -done the following transactions in -g) T he Securities and Exchange Director, Non-Executive Directors -due compliance with the applicable -Board of India (Delisting of including Woman Director and -provisions of the Act: -Equity Shares) Regulations, Independent Directors. There was no -2021- Not Applicable to change in the composition of the Board 1. C onverted 80 crore-8.5% Non- -the Company during the of Directors during the Audit Period. Cumulative Optionally Convertible -Audit Period; Preference Shares (‘OCPS’) of -Adequate notice was given to all -C 10 each issued at premium of -h) T he Securities and Exchange directors of the Company of the -C 40 per OCPS into 400 crore -Board of India (Buyback meetings of the Board (including -equity shares of C 10 each -of Securities) Regulations, meetings of the Committees), except -aggregating C 4000 crore; -2018 - Not Applicable to where consent of directors was -the Company during the received for shorter notice. The agenda 2. A pproved variation in the terms -Audit Period; and and detailed notes on agenda were and conditions of redemption and -sent at least seven days in advance for conversion of 3,300 Compulsorily -i) T he Securities and Exchange -the Board and Committee meetings, Convertible Debentures of face -Board of India (Listing -except for the meetings which were value of C 10,00,000 each -Obligations and Disclosure -convened at shorter notice with the (“CCDs”). -Requirements) Regulations, -consent of directors. -2015- Not Applicable to 3. C onverted 3,300 CCDs into -the Company during the All decisions made at Board meetings 33,00,00,000 9% Non- -Audit Period. and Committee meetings have Cumulative Compulsorily -unanimous consent of directors Redeemable Preference Shares -We have also examined -(excluding the directors who were (‘RPS’) of C 10 each aggregating -compliance with: -concerned or interested in specific C 330 crore and thereafter the -i) Applicable Secretarial Standards items) as recorded in the minutes of RPS were redeemed at par; -issued by the Institute of the meetings of the Board of Directors -4. N ational Company Law Tribunal, -Company Secretaries of India; and or Committees of the Board, as the -Mumbai Bench vide its order -case may be. -ii) T he Listing Agreements entered dated January 05, 2024 -into by the Company with Stock We further report that the approved reduction of equity -Exchange(s) - Not Applicable Company has devised a system share capital of the Company -to the Company during the which enables the directors to seek by C 7,86,54,230 by cancelling -Audit Period. and obtain further information and and extinguishing 78,65,423 -clarifications on the agenda items fully paid up equity shares held -During the Audit Period, the Company -before the meeting and for meaningful by shareholders other than -has complied with the provisions of the -participation at the meeting. Promoter, the holding Company -Act, Rules, Regulations, Guidelines, -of the Company; -Standards, etc. mentioned above. During the Audit Period, one extra- -ordinary general meeting was -88 Reliance Industries Limited - -5. T ransferred supply chain assets of the Company to Reliance Logistics and Warehouse Holdings Limited, a fellow -subsidiary of the Company for a consideration of up to C 8,000 crore pursuant to Section 180(1) (a) of the Companies -Act, 2013; -6. Borrowed funds from the holding company and banks pursuant to sections 179 and 180 of the Act. -For Shashikala Rao & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P2010MH067400 -PR 4740/2023 -Shashikala Rao -Partner -Place: Mumbai FCS 3866 CP No 9482 -Date: April 22, 2024 UDIN F003866F000210853 -Annexure to the Secretarial Audit Report -To, -The Members -Reliance Retail Limited -Our report of even date is to be read along with this letter: -1. W e have not verified the correctness and appropriateness of financial records and Books of Accounts of the Company -and financial statements and disclosures made therein. -2. W herever required, we have obtained a Management Representation about the compliance of laws, rules and -regulations and happening of events, etc. -3. T he Secretarial Audit report is neither an assurance as to future viability of the Company nor of the efficiency or -effectiveness with which the management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -For Shashikala Rao & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P2010MH067400 -PR 4740/2023 -Shashikala Rao -Partner -Place: Mumbai FCS 3866 CP No 9482 -Date: April 22, 2024 UDIN F003866F000210853 -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 89 - -Corporate Governance Report -Form No. MR-3 -Secretarial Audit Report -For the financial year ended March 31, 2024 -[Pursuant to section 204(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 9 of the Companies -(Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel), Rules, 2014] -To, i. T he Companies Act, 2013 d. T he Securities and -The Members, (‘the Act’) and the rules Exchange Board of India -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited made thereunder; (Share Based Employee -| CIN: U51909MH2006PLC166166 | | Benefits and Sweat Equity) | -| -------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | -ii. T he Securities Contracts -| 4th Floor, Court House, | | Regulations, 2021; | -| ----------------------- | --- | ------------------ | -(Regulation) Act, 1956 (‘SCRA’) -Lokmanya Tilak Marg, -| | and the rules made thereunder - | e. T he Securities and Exchange | -| --- | ---------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 -| | Not Applicable as the Securities | Board of India (Registrars to | -| --- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | -We have conducted the Secretarial of the Company are not listed on an Issue and Share Transfer -Audit of the compliance with any Stock Exchange. Agents) Regulations, 1993 -applicable statutory provisions and the regarding the Companies Act -iii. T he Depositories Act, 1996 and -adherence to good corporate practices and dealing with client; -the Regulations and Bye-laws -by Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -| | framed thereunder; | f. T he Securities and | -| --- | -------------------- | ------------------------ | -(hereinafter called the “Company”) -Exchange Board of India -| for the Financial Year ended 31st | iv. T he Foreign Exchange | | -| ---------------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | -(Delisting of Equity Shares) -| March, 2024. Secretarial Audit was | Management Act, 1999 and | | -| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | -Regulations, 2021; -| conducted in a manner that provided | the rules and regulations made | | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | -us a reasonable basis for evaluating thereunder to the extent of g. T he Securities and -the corporate conducts/statutory Foreign Direct Investment, Exchange Board of India -compliances and expressing our Overseas Direct Investment (Buyback of Securities) -| opinion thereon. | and External Commercial | Regulations, 2018; | -| ---------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------ | -Borrowings:- Not Applicable -| Based on our verification of the | | h. T he Securities and | -| --------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -to the extent of External -| Company’s books, papers, minute | | Exchange Board of India | -| -------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | -Commercial Borrowings; -books, forms and returns filed and (Issue and Listing of Non- -other records maintained by the v. T he following Regulations and Convertible Securities) -Company and furnished to us through Guidelines prescribed under the Regulations, 2021; -| access to the Company’s in-house | Securities and Exchange Board of | | -| --------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | - i. T he Securities and -| portal and also the information | India Act, 1992 (‘SEBI Act’) are | | -| -------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Exchange Board of India -| provided by the Company, its officers, | Not Applicable as the Securities | | -| --------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -(Listing Obligations and -| agents and authorised representatives | of the Company are not listed on | | -| -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --- | -Disclosure Requirements) -| during the conduct of secretarial audit, | any Stock Exchange; | | -| ----------------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | -Regulations, 2015; -we hereby report that in our opinion, - a. T he Securities and Exchange -the Company has, during the audit vi. Framework/Operational -Board of India (Substantial -period covering the financial year Circular for Issue and Listing -Acquisition of Shares and -ended on 31st March 2024, complied of Commercial Papers issued -Takeovers) Regulations, -with the statutory provisions listed by Securities and Exchange -2011- except to the extent -hereunder and also that the Company Board of India including -of being a promoter as -| has proper Board-processes and | | amendments thereto. | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ------------------- | -defined, of a listed entity; -compliance-mechanism in place to the -The Management of the Company -| extent, in the manner and subject to | b. T he Securities and Exchange | | -| ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | -has confirmed that there are no laws -| the reporting made hereinafter: | Board of India (Prohibition | | -| ------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | -identified which are specifically -of Insider Trading) -We have examined the books, papers, applicable to the Company. -Regulations, 2015; -minute books, forms and returns filed -We have also examined compliance -| and other records maintained by the | c. T he Securities and | | -| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------- | --- | -with the applicable Standards/ -| Company for the financial year ended | Exchange Board of India | | -| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --- | -Regulations of the following: -| on 31st March, 2024 according to the | (Issue of Capital and | | -| ------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | -provisions of: Disclosure Requirements) (i) S ecretarial Standards with -| | Regulations, 2018; | regard to Meeting of the Board | -| --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------- | -of Directors (SS-1) and General -90 Reliance Industries Limited - -Meetings (SS-2) issued by The We further report that based on give guarantees upto C 1,15,000 -Institute of Company Secretaries review of compliance mechanism crore, outstanding at any point -of India; established by the Company and of time, over and above the -on the basis of the Compliance limits prescribed in the aforesaid -(ii) T he Listing Agreements entered -Certificate(s) issued by the Company Section of the Act; -into by the Company with the -Secretary based on the certificates -Stock Exchanges: Applicable 3. T he Company has during the -issued by functional heads and -to the extent of Commercial year under review issued and -taken on record by the Board of -Papers listed during the period allotted 14,77,02,906 equity -Directors at their meeting(s), we -under review. shares of C 10/- each at a -are of the opinion that there are -premium of C 1,196.09/- per -During the period under audit, adequate systems and processes in -share aggregating to C 17,814.29 -the Company has complied with place which commensurate with size -crore on private placement basis -the provisions of the Act, Rules, and operations of the Company, to -to Reliance Industries Limited -Regulations, Guidelines, Standards, monitor and ensure compliance with -(the holding company) and three -etc. mentioned above. all applicable laws, rules, regulations -financial investors; -and guidelines. -We further report that: - -4. T he Members at the Annual -We further report that during the -− The Board of Directors of the General Meeting held on 28th -financial year under audit, following -Company is duly constituted September 2023 and at the -were the event/actions which -with proper balance of Executive Extra-Ordinary General Meetings -occurred, having a major bearing on -Directors, Non-Executive Directors held on 10th October 2023 -the Company’s affairs in pursuance -including a Woman Director and and 10th November 2023 -of the above referred laws, rules, -Independent Directors. No changes respectively, have passed special -regulations, guidelines, standards, etc: -in the composition of the Board resolutions to approve and -of Directors took place during the 1. P ursuant to necessary approvals adopt the restated Articles of -period under audit. obtained from Audit Committee, Association, which were amended -the Board and the shareholders of pursuant to shareholders’ -− Adequate notice is given to all -the holding company and of the agreements entered into by the -Directors of the schedule of -Audit Committee of the Company, Company with the investors. -the Board Meetings (including -the Board has passed a resolution -Committees Meetings). Agenda and The Report is to be read with our -on 22nd March 2024 to accord -detailed notes on agenda were also letter of even date which is annexed -consent to enter into necessary -sent atleast seven days in advance, as Annexure A hereto and forms an -agreements, to transfer mid- -except where consent of directors integral part of this report. -sized warehousing relating assets -was received for circulation of the -of the Company aggregating For S. N. -Agenda and notes on Agenda at -upto C 3,000 crore to Reliance ANANTHASUBRAMANIAN -a shorter notice. A system exists -Logistics and Warehouse Holdings & Co. -for seeking and obtaining further -Limited, a subsidiary Company; Company Secretaries -information and clarifications on the -ICSI Unique Code: P1991MH040400 -agenda items before the meeting 2. M embers of the Company at the -Peer Review Cert. No.: 5218/2023 -and for meaningful participation by Extraordinary General Meeting -the directors at the meeting. held on 25th August 2023 -Aparna Gadgil -have, pursuant to Section 186 -− As recorded in the Minutes of Partner -of the Act, passed a Special -Board/Committee Meetings, ACS: 14713| COP No.: 8430 -Resolution and granted consent -all decisions of the Board and ICSI UDIN: A014713F000203286 -to the Board of Directors to -Committees thereof were carried -make loans, investments and -out unanimously. 22nd April, 2024 I Thane -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 91 - -Corporate Governance Report -Annexure A -To, -The Members, -Reliance Retail Ventures Limited -CIN: U51909MH2006PLC166166 -4th Floor, Court House, -Lokmanya Tilak Marg, -Dhobi Talao, Mumbai- 400 002 -Our Secretarial Audit Report for the financial year ended 31st March 2024 of even date is to be read along with this letter. -Management’s Responsibility -1. I t is the responsibility of the management of the Company to maintain secretarial records, devise proper systems -to ensure compliance with the provisions of all applicable laws and regulations and to ensure that the systems are -adequate and operate effectively. -Auditor’s Responsibility -2. O ur responsibility is to express an opinion on these secretarial records, standards and procedures followed by the -Company with respect to secretarial compliances. -3. W e have conducted the Audit as per the applicable Auditing Standards issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries -of India. -4. W e believe that audit evidence and information obtained from the Company’s management is adequate and -appropriate for us to provide a basis for our opinion. -5. W herever required, we have obtained reasonable assurance about whether the statements prepared, documents or -Records, in relation to Secretarial Audit, maintained by the Auditee, are free from misstatement. -6. W herever required, we have obtained the Management’s representation about the compliance of laws, rules and -regulations and happening of events, etc -Disclaimer -7. T he Secretarial Audit Report is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company nor of the efficacy or -effectiveness with which the management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -8. W e have not verified the correctness and appropriateness of financial records and Books of Accounts of the Company. -For S. N. ANANTHASUBRAMANIAN & Co. -Company Secretaries -ICSI Unique Code: P1991MH040400 -Peer Review Cert. No.: 5218/2023 -Aparna Gadgil -Partner -ACS: 14713| COP No.: 8430 -ICSI UDIN: A014713F000203286 -22nd April, 2024 I Thane -92 Reliance Industries Limited - -Independent Auditor’s Report on compliance with the conditions of Corporate -Governance as per provisions of Chapter IV of Securities and Exchange Board of India -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 -To the Members of Auditor’s Responsibility Financial Information, and -4. O ur responsibility is limited to Other Assurance and Related -Reliance Industries Limited -examining the procedures and Services Engagements. -1. T his certificate is issued in implementation thereof, adopted 8. T he procedures selected depend -accordance with the terms of by the Company for ensuring on the auditor’s judgement, -our engagement letter dated compliance with the conditions of including the assessment of the -September 22, 2023. the Corporate Governance. It is risks associated in compliance -2. W e, Deloitte Haskins & Sells neither an audit nor an expression of the Corporate Governance -LLP, Chartered Accountants and of opinion on the financial Report with the applicable -Chaturvedi & Shah LLP, Chartered statements of the Company. criteria. The procedures include -Accountants, the Statutory 5. W e have examined the books but not limited to verification -Auditors of Reliance Industries of account and other relevant of secretarial records and -Limited (“the Company”), records and documents financial information of -have examined the compliance maintained by the Company the Company and obtained -of conditions of Corporate for the purposes of providing necessary representations. -Governance by the Company, reasonable assurance on the 9. T he procedures also include -for the year ended on March 31, compliance with Corporate examining evidence supporting -2024, as stipulated in regulations Governance requirements by the particulars in the Corporate -17 to 27 and clauses (b) to (i) the Company. Governance Report on a test -of regulation 46(2) and para -C and D of Schedule V of the SEBI 6. W e have carried out an basis. Further, our scope of work -(Listing Obligations and Disclosure examination of the relevant under this report did not involve -Requirements) Regulations, 2015 records of the Company in us performing audit tests for the -(the Listing Regulations). This accordance with the Guidance purposes of expressing an opinion -report is required by the Company Note on Certification of on the fairness or accuracy of any -for annual submission to the stock Corporate Governance issued of the financial information or -exchange and to be sent to the by the Institute of the Chartered the financial statements of the -Shareholders of the Company. Accountants of India (the ICAI), Company taken as a whole -the Standards on Auditing -specified under Section 143(10) Opinion -Managements’ -of the Companies Act 2013, in so 10. B ased on our examination -Responsibility -far as applicable for the purpose of the relevant records and -3. T he compliance of conditions of this certificate and as per the according to the information and -of Corporate Governance is the Guidance Note on Reports or explanations provided to us and -responsibility of the Management Certificates for Special Purposes the representations provided -including the preparation and issued by the ICAI which requires by the Management, we certify -maintenance of all relevant that we comply with the ethical that the Company has complied -supporting records and requirements of the Code of with the conditions of Corporate -documents. This responsibility Ethics issued by the ICAI. Governance as stipulated in -also includes the design, 7. W e have complied with the regulations 17 to 27 and clauses -implementation and maintenance relevant applicable requirements (b) to (i) of regulation 46(2) and -of internal control and procedures of the Standard on Quality para C and D of Schedule V of the -to ensure the compliance with Control (SQC) 1, Quality Control Listing Regulations during the year -the conditions of the Corporate for Firms that Perform Audits ended March 31, 2024. -Governance stipulated in -and Reviews of Historical -Listing Regulations. -Integrated Annual Report 2023-24 93 - -Corporate Governance Report -11. W e state that such compliance is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company nor the efficiency or -effectiveness with which the Management has conducted the affairs of the Company. -Restriction on Use -12. T his report is addressed to and provided to the members of the Company solely for the purpose of enabling it to -comply with its obligations under the Listing Regulations and should not be used by any other person or for any other -purpose. Accordingly, we do not accept or assume any liability or any duty of care or for any other purpose or to any -other party to whom it is shown or into whose hands it may come without our prior consent in writing. We have no -responsibility to update this report for events and circumstances occurring after the date of this report. -For Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP For Chaturvedi & Shah LLP -Chartered Accountants Chartered Accountants -Firm’s Registration No. 117366W/W-100018 Firm’s Registration No. 101720W/W-100355 -Abhijit A. Damle Sandesh Ladha -Partner Partner -Membership No. 102912 Membership No. 047841 -UDIN: 24102912BKEPFU3347 UDIN: 24047841BKCAIY8639 -Place: Mumbai Place: Mumbai -Date: April 22, 2024 Date: April 22, 2024 -94 Reliance Industries Limited \ No newline at end of file +Explanation, Debate, Align: A Weak-to-Strong Framework for Language Model +Generalization +MehrdadZakershahrak*,SamiraGhodratnama* +DepartmentofComputing +{mehrdad,samira}@mq..edu.au +4202 peS 11 ]IA.sc[ 1v53370.9042:viXra Abstract inglysophisticatedAIsystemswithoutsolelydependingon +humanoversight.Suchmethodsshouldfacilitatealignment +Therapidadvancementofartificialintelligencesystemshas +| | | | | | | | in domains | where | human | experts | may | struggle | to provide | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | +broughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttotheforefrontofre- +accuratefeedback,whilestillmaintainingthecoreprinciple +search,particularlyincomplexdecision-makingandtaskex- +ofaligningwithhumanvalues.Furthermore,thesemethods +ecution.Asthesesystemssurpasshuman-levelperformance +insophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralignmentwithhu- shouldprovideamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +man values, intentions, and ethical guidelines becomes cru- capabilities evolve, ensuring that alignment scales with ad- +cial.Buildingonpreviousworkinexplanationgenerationfor vancementsinAItechnology. +human-agent alignment, we address the more complex dy- Buildingonourpreviousworkinexplanationgeneration +namicsofmulti-agentsystemsandhuman-AIteams.Thispa- forhuman-agentalignment,weintroduceaframeworkthat +perintroducesanovelapproachtomodelalignmentthrough +combinesweak-to-stronggeneralizationandmodelfacilita- +| weak-to-strong | | generalization | in | the context | of | language | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | tion, leveraging | | explanatory | debates | to | enhance | alignment. | | +models.Wepresentaframeworkwhereastrongmodelfacili- +Thisapproachaimstocreateascalable,self-improvingsys- +| tates the | improvement | of a | weaker | model, | bridging | the gap | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +temforAIalignmentthatcanhandleincreasinglycomplex +| between | explanation | generation | and | model | alignment. | Our | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskswhilemaintainingtransparencyandinterpretability. +| method, | formalized | as a facilitation | | function | Φ, | allows for | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thetransferofcapabilitiesfromadvancedmodelstolessca- Toformalizeourapproach,webeginbydefiningthecon- +pable ones without direct access to extensive training data. ceptsofweakandstrongmodels: +Our results suggest that this facilitation-based approach not A model M is considered +| | | | | | | | Definition1(WeakModel) | | | | | W | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +onlyenhancesmodelperformancebutalsoprovidesinsights +| | | | | | | | weakif,foragiventaskT | | | andperformancemetricP,M | | | | W | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intothenatureofmodelalignmentandthepotentialforscal- +| | | | | | | | achievesascoreS | | suchthatS | | < S | ,whereS | | isthe | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| ableoversightofAIsystems. | | | | | | | | | W | | W | H | H | | +human-levelperformanceonT. +Introduction Definition2(StrongModel) A model M is considered +S +| | | | | | | | strong if, | for the | same | task T | and performance | | metric | P, | +| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----------------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +| The rapid | advancement | of | artificial | intelligence | | (AI) sys- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | M achievesascoreS | | | suchthatS | >S | . | | | +| | | | | | | | S | | S | | S | H | | | +temshasbroughtthechallengeofAIalignmenttothefore- +| | | | | | | | The idea | of | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | involves | us- | +| ------------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ---------- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | -------------- | ------------ | -------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | +| front of research, | | particularly | in complex | | decision-making | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | ing weaker | AI systems | | to supervise | and | align | stronger | AI | +| and task | execution. | As these | systems | surpass | human-level | | | | | | | | | | +performanceinsophisticatedproblems,ensuringtheiralign- systems, a concept closely related to capability amplifica- +ment with human values, intentions, and ethical guidelines tion, where the goal is to create AI systems that can solve +| | | | | | | | problems | beyond | the capabilities | | of their | creators | or | train- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | +becomescrucial.Thischallengehasbeenhighlightedinre- +| | | | | | | | ers. This | concept | has its | roots | in model | compression | | and | +| ---------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ------------- | ------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | ------ | +| cent work | on alignment, | | such as | Reinforcement | | Learning | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | knowledge | distillation, | | where smaller, | | less capable | | models | +| from Human | Feedback | (RLHF), | | which | iteratively | refines | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | are used | to enhance | the | performance | of | larger | models. | Re- | +modelbehaviorbasedonhumanevaluations(Ghodratnama +and Zakershahrak 2024). While RLHF has shown promise cent research, such as the work by Schick and Schu¨tze on +| | | | | | | | few-shot | learning | in language | | models, | demonstrates | | how | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | +inaligninglanguagemodelswithhumanintentions,itfaces +| | | | | | | | these ideas | can | be applied | to improve | | the performance | | of | +| ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| scalability | challenges | when | dealing | with | tasks | that surpass | | | | | | | | | +smallermodelswithlimiteddata. +human-levelcomplexity.Therelianceondirecthumanfeed- +FacilitationFunctionandDebate-BasedAlignmentAtthe +backbecomesabottleneck,limitingthescopeanddepthof +alignmentthatcanbeachieved. heart of our method is the facilitation function Φ, which +formalizestheprocessofknowledgetransferfromastrong +Toaddresstheselimitations,morescalableandadaptable +modeltoaweakerone: +approachesarerequired—approachesthatcanalignincreas- +| | | | | | | | Definition3(FacilitationFunc.) | | | | Φ:M | ×M | →M′ | | +| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| *Theseauthorscontributedequally. | | | | | | | | | | | | W | S | W | +Copyright©2025,AssociationfortheAdvancementofArtificial WhereM W istheweakmodel,M S isthestrongmodel,and +Intelligence(www.aaai.org).Allrightsreserved. M′ istheenhancedweakmodel.Thefacilitationfunction +W + +isimplementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: wefosteranAIsystemthatnotonlyperformswellbutalso +| | | | | | | | | maintains | transparency | | and interpretability, | | | key factors | in | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +(cid:88) +| | argmin | | L(f | θ (q),f | θS (q)) | | (1) | | | | | | | | | +| --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ W′ b u i ld i n gtrustandensuringlong-termalignmentwithhuman +W′ q∈Q +| | | | | | | | | va l u e s . | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +WhereQisasetoftaskinstances,Lisatask-specificloss Contributions Our contributions in this paper are three- +| function, | and | f represents | | the model’s | decision-making | | | fold: | | | | | | | | +| --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +θ +functionparameterizedbyθ. +| | | | | | | | | 1. We introduce | | a novel | framework | | for model | alignment | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | +Tofurtherenhanceourapproach,weincorporatedebate- +| | | | | | | | | through | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | and | model | facil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | +basedalignment,leveragingtheideathatitmaybeeasierto +itation,formalizingthefacilitationfunctionΦanditsap- +| judge the | outcome | of | a debate | than | to directly | solve | com- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +plicationtocomplexdecision-makingtasks. +| plex problems. | | This | method | uses adversarial | | dynamics | to | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +improve model alignment and capability by evaluating the 2. We present empirical results demonstrating significant +explanationsprovidedbydifferentmodels. improvements in model performance and alignment +acrossmultiplecomplextaskdomains,achievedthrough +| Definition4(DebateFunction) | | | | D :E | ×E | ×J | →R | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | S′ | W | | ourfacilitationapproach. | | | | | | | | +| WhereE | istheexplanationfunctionofthestrongmodel, | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +S′ 3. We provide an in-depth analysis of the facilitation pro- +| E is | the explanation | | function | of the | weak | model, | and J | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --------------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | +| W | | | | | | | | cess, | offering | new | perspectives | | on the nature | of | model | +| is the judge | (which | could | be | another | instance | of the | weak | | | | | | | | | +alignmentindecision-makingandthepotentialforscal- +model,ahuman,oranotherevaluationmechanism).Theout- +ableoversightofadvancedAIsystemstacklingcomplex +| put of D | is a | real number | representing | | the | quality | of the | | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tasks. +strongmodel’sexplanationrelativetotheweakmodel’s,as +evaluated by the judge. This scalar output can be used as a This work represents a key component of a broader re- +reward signal in a reinforcement learning (RL) framework, search agenda aimed at developing robust, aligned AI sys- +allowingforcontinuousimprovementofthestrongmodel’s tems capable of handling increasingly complex decisions +explanatorycapabilities. and tasks. By bridging the gap between weak and strong +| | | | | | | | →M′ | models | in sophisticated | | problem-solving | | scenarios, | | we not | +| ------------------------------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------- | --- | -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | +| Definition5(AlignmentFunction) | | | | | Ψ:M S | ×M W | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | S | onlyenhancethecapabilitiesofAIsystemsbutalsoensure | | | | | | | | +| Where | M′ is | the aligned | | strong model. | This | function | is | | | | | | | | | +| | S | | | | | | | they remain | fundamentally | | aligned | | with human | values | and | +implementedthroughthefollowingoptimizationproblem: intentions. To achieve this, our approach draws on and ex- +tendsseveralfoundationalareaswithinartificialintelligence +(cid:88) +argm i n [L(f θ (q),f θW (q))+D(E S′ (q),E W (q),J)] r e se a r c h , in c lu d i n g e x p l a in a b l e AI, model alignment, and +| θ | | S′ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| S ′ | | | | | | | | la n g u a g | e m o d e l | g e ne r a | li z a ti o n | . | | | | +q∈Q +(2) +By incorporating a learned reward model over debate- RelatedWork +drivenalignment,ourframeworkcreatesadynamiclearning +Ourresearchintegratesandbuildsuponthesekeyareas,par- +| environment | that | scales | beyond | mere | decision | alignment. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ---- | ------ | ------ | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ticularlyfocusingontheprogressionfromexplainableAIto +Thestrongmodelisincentivizednotonlytomakedecisions +thedevelopmentofaligned,capablelanguagemodels.This +thatalignwithhumanvaluesbutalsotoconsistentlyprovide +| | | | | | | | | section | traces how | these | concepts | interconnect, | | laying | the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ | --- | +high-quality,persuasiveexplanationsthatmirrorhumanrea- +foundationforourproposedapproach. +soningprocesses. +Thepracticalimplementationofthisprocessfollowsthese +ExplanationGenerationinAI +steps: +ExplainableAI(XAI)hasbecomeacriticalareaofresearch +Algorithm1:Debate-BasedAlignmentProcess asAIsystemsincreasinglyinfluencevariousaspectsofsoci- +ety(GhodratnamaandZakershahrak2023).Gunning’swork +| Inputs: | Models | M | (strong) | and M | (weak), | Task | in- | | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | S | | | W | | | (Gunning2017)definesXAIasthedevelopmentofmachine | | | | | | | | +stanceq learning models that are not only high-performing but also +| Ensure: | AlignedandimprovedstrongmodelM | | | | | S | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | --------- | ------------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | interpretable | by | humans. | This | focus | on interpretability | | be- | +| 1: PresentbothmodelsM | | | | andM | withtaskinstanceq | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | S | W | | | | gan with | efforts | by Swartout | | and Moore | (1993) | to | create | +| 2: Eachmodelproducesadecisionf | | | | | (q)andanexplana- | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | θ | | | expertsystemscapableofexplainingtheirdecisions.Asthe | | | | | | | | +tionE(q) +| | | | | | | | | field evolved, | the | emphasis | shifted | | from post-hoc | | explana- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | +3: Evaluate explanations using the debate function tionstoinherentlyinterpretablesystems. +D(E S′ ,E W ) Notably, research by Zakershahrak et al. (Zakershahrak +| 4: JudgeJ | determineswhichexplanationissuperior | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------------------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | et al. 2020a, | 2018, | 2020b) | introduced | | progressive | | explana- | +| 5: Finetune | strong | model | M | to minimize | | decision | dis- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | S | | | | tiongenerationtechniquesthatadapttohumanunderstand- | | | | | | | | +crepanciesandimproveexplanations +| | | | | | | | | ing, aligning | closely | with | the | principles | of | Inverse | Rein- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | forcement | Learning | (IRL). | These | approaches | | often | employ | +Thisframeworkcreatesamorerobustandadaptivealign- maximumentropymethods,similartoMaxEntIRL(Ziebart +ment,wherethemodel’sabilitytoexplainitsdecisionsbe- et al. 2008), to manage the uncertainty inherent in human +| comesascrucialasthedecisionsthemselves.Consequently, | | | | | | | | preferences. | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Miller (Miller 2018) further underscored the importance FacilitationinHuman-AITeams +| of social | context | in | AI explanations, | | bridging | AI | expla- | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------------ | ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | As AI systems | | have | become | more | advanced, | research | has | +| nations | with human-centric | | | explanation | science. | Our | work | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | increasingly | focused | | on how | these | systems | can | support | +| builds on | these | foundations | | by | incorporating | | dynamic, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | and enhance | human | | decision-making. | | This | research | aligns | +debate-styleexplanationswithinthealignmentprocess,not +| | | | | | | | | closely | with | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | by | exploring | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +onlyenhancingtransparencybutalsousingexplanationsas +howAIcanamplifyhumancapabilities.Bansaletal.(2019) +amechanismtoguideandimproveAIbehavior. +| | | | | | | | | explored | collaborative | | problem-solving | | | between | humans | +| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | ------------- | ----- | --------------- | -------- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | | and AI, | while | Kamar | et al. | (2012) | examined | AI-assisted | | +| ModelAlignment | | | | | | | | decision-makingprocesses. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | Nancy | Cooke’s | work | on | human-AI | teams | (Cooke | et al. | +As AI systems become more sophisticated, the challenge 2013; Cooke 2015) has been pivotal in understanding the +ofaligningthesesystemswithhumanvaluesandgoalshas +dynamicsofcollaborationbetweenhumansandAI.Seeber +takencenterstage.Leikeetal.(Leikeetal.2018)definethe +etal.(Seeberetal.2020)providedacomprehensivereview +alignmentproblemasensuringthatAIsystemsconsistently +| | | | | | | | | of AI-enabled | | teamwork, | emphasizing | | the | role | of AI as a | +| ------ | --------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---------- | +| pursue | the goals | intended | by | their | creators. | The | develop- | | | | | | | | | +teammemberratherthanameretool. +mentofInverseReinforcementLearning(IRL)methodsby Ourapproachleveragestheseinsightsbypositioningthe +NgandRussell(NgandRussell2000)laidthegroundwork +strongmodelasafacilitatorfortheweakermodel,enhanc- +forpreferencelearninginAI,allowingsystemstoinferand +| | | | | | | | | ing the | alignment | process | through | | structured | learning | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +adopthuman-likegoals. +debate. +| Further | advances, | such | as | cooperative | inverse | reinforce- | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ment learning | | (CIRL) | explored | by | Hadfield-Menell | | et al. | | | | | | | | | +LanguageModelAlignment +(Hadfield-Menelletal.2016),modeledalignmentasacoop- +erative game between humans and AI. Stiennon et al. (Sti- Therapidadvancementsinlanguagemodelcapabilitieshave +intensifiedtheneedforrobustalignmentstrategies.TheIn- +| ennon et | al. 2020) | expanded | | on this | by demonstrating | | how | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | ---------------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --------- | +| | | | | | | | | structGPT | approach | | by Ouyang | | et al. | (2022) | showcased | +| summarization | | tasks | can be | used | to align | language | mod- | | | | | | | | | +elswithhumanpreferences,acrucialsteptowardsscalable how large language models could be fine-tuned to align +alignment. more closely with human instructions, representing a key +| | | | | | | | | advancement | | in scalable | alignment | | techniques. | | Bai et al. | +| -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ---- | ----------- | -------------- | ---------- | +| Our work | builds | on | these | concepts | by integrating | | weak- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | (2022) further | | contributed | to | this | field with | Constitutional | | +to-stronggeneralizationandexplanationgenerationintothe +| | | | | | | | | AI, which | incorporates | | specific | behavioral | | constraints | dur- | +| --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | +| alignment | process. | This | combination | | allows | us to | create a | | | | | | | | | +ingtrainingtoensurealignmentwithhumanvalues. +| more holistic | approach | | to aligning | | AI systems, | particularly | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | Anthropic’s | | ”AI | Safety | via Debate” | | research | (Irving, | +incomplextaskenvironments. +| | | | | | | | | Christiano, | and | Amodei | 2018) | introduced | | the idea | of us- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | ing debates | between | | AI systems | | as a method | for | improv- | +Weak-to-StrongGeneralization ingalignment,anapproachthatresonatesstronglywithour +| | | | | | | | | work. This | method | | leverages | adversarial | | dynamics | to en- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Theconceptofweak-to-stronggeneralization,discussedby +hancemodelcapabilitiesandensurealignment.Recentwork +Burnsetal.(Burnsetal.2023),involvesleveragingweaker +byPerezetal.(2023)ondiscoveringlanguagemodelbehav- +AIsystemstosuperviseandguidestrongerAIsystems.This +iorsusinggeneratedtaskdatasetshasprovidednewtoolsfor +paradigmisanextensionoftheideaofcapabilityamplifica- +evaluatingandimprovinglanguagemodelalignment. +| tion, where | the | goal is | to enable | AI | systems | to solve | prob- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Ourresearchcomplementstheseapproachesbyintegrat- +lemsbeyondthedirectcapabilitiesoftheirdevelopers. +ingweak-to-stronggeneralizationwithdebate-drivenlearn- +| This | approach | has | its roots | in | model compression | | and | | | | | | | | | +| ---- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ing. By | combining | the | strengths | of | explanation | generation, | | +knowledge distillation, as first introduced by Buciluaˇ et al. weak-to-strong generalization, and structured debates, we +(Buciluaˇ, Caruana, and Niculescu-Mizil 2006) and refined offerascalableandtransparentframeworkforensuringlan- +| by Hinton | et al. | (LeCun, | Bengio, | and | Hinton | 2015). | These | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +guagemodelalignmentthatcanadapttotheincreasingcom- +methodshavebeensuccessfullyappliedinnaturallanguage +plexityofAIsystems. +processing,wherestudent-teachermodels(Sanhetal.2019) +havedemonstratedthatsmallermodelscanachievehighper- +Methodology +formancewithfewerresources.RecentworkbySchickand +Schu¨tze(Mittaletal.2023)onfew-shotlearningfurtheril- Our research explores weak-to-strong generalization as a +lustrateshowsmallermodelscanbeenhancedthrougheffi- technique for model alignment. The core idea is to use +cientlearningtechniques. +| | | | | | | | | weaker | models | to supervise | | stronger | models, | serving | as an | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +Ourframeworkextendstheseideasbyapplyingweak-to- analogy for how humans might align superhuman AI sys- +stronggeneralizationasameansofaligningAIsystems.By tems.Thisapproachallowsustostudyalignmentchallenges +incorporating structured debates and explanations, we cre- empiricallyusingcurrentmodels,whilepotentiallyyielding +ate a mechanism where weaker models can guide stronger insightsapplicabletofuture,morecapablesystems. +models, even in scenarios where the weaker model (or hu- The weak-to-strong learning process consists of three +| mansupervisor)lacksfullexpertise. | | | | | | | | mainsteps: | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +1. Create a weak supervisor by finetuning a smaller pre- Baseline Method We finetune the strong student model +trainedmodelongroundtruthlabels. on the weak labels over 2 epochs with a batch size of 32. +2. Generateweaklabelsusingthesupervisoronaheld-out Early stopping is applied based on the model’s agreement +| dataset. | | | | | | | | withweaklabelsonthevalidationset. | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +3. Trainastrongerstudentmodelusingtheseweaklabels. +Algorithm3:BaselineStrongStudentTraining +Weevaluatethisprocessacrossmultipletaskdomainsand Inputs: Weaklabelsf (x),StrongstudentmodelM +| | | | | | | | | | | w | | | S | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +modelsizestounderstanditsscalabilityandlimitations. +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | TrainedstrongstudentmodelM | | | S | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: InitializeM | S | withpretrainedweights | | | | +ExperimentalSetup +2: foreachepochi=1to2do +Models WeusepretrainedlanguagemodelsfromtheGPT- 3: TrainM onweaklabelsf (x)withbatchsize32 +| | | | | | | | | | S | | w | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +4family,whichspan7ordersofmagnitudeincompute.This 4: ifvalidationaccuracyimprovesthen +wide range allows us to analyze the performance gap be- UpdateM +| | | | | | | | | 5: | | S | | | | +| -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| tweenweakandstrongmodelsacrossdifferentlevelsofca- | | | | | | | | 6: else | | | | | | +pability.ThemodelsareaccessedthroughtheOpenAIAPI, 7: Applyearlystopping +| and we replace | | the unembedding | | layer | with | a task-specific | | 8: endif | | | | | | +| --------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --------------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| linear classification | | head | for | each model | to | suit the | experi- | 9: endfor | | | | | | +ments. +Tasks Weevaluateourmethodsontwosettings: +| | | | | | | | | Improved | Methods | To | enhance the performance | | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ------ | +1. NaturalLanguageProcessing(NLP)benchmarks:We strongstudentmodel,weemployseveralimprovedmethods: +useasuiteof22classificationtasks,coveringareaslike +| | | | | | | | | a) Auxiliary | | Confidence | Loss: We | introduce | a | +| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --------- | --- | +| ethics, | commonsense | | reasoning, | | natural | language | infer- | | | | | | | +confidence-drivenlosstermthatbalancesthecross-entropy +| ence, | and sentiment | | analysis. | All | tasks | are | converted | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ---- | ----- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | loss between | weak | label | predictions and | a thresholded | | +| to binary | classification, | | with | soft | labels | from | the weak | | | | | | | +versionofthemodel’sownpredictions. +modelusedfortraining.ThesetasksarelistedinTable1. +| 2. Chess | puzzles: | Using | the | Chess | Game | Dataset | from | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ---- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Algorithm4:AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss +Lichess(Datasnaek2021),wepredictthebestmovefor +eachposition.Thedatasetconsistsofsequencesofmoves Inputs: Model predictions f(x), Weak labels f (x), +w +| | | | | | | | | Thresholdedpredictionsf | | | (x),Weightingfactorα | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | +| leadinguptoapuzzle,formattedasinputsforourmodel. | | | | | | | | | | | t | | | +| | | | | | | | | Ensure: | UpdatedmodelM | | withconfidence-drivenloss | | | +S +1: Setα=0.75forlargemodels,0.5otherwise +WeakSupervisorCreation +| | | | | | | | | 2: ComputeL | | (f)=(1−α)·CE(f(x),f | | | (x))+α· | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | | conf | | | w | | +We create weak supervisors by generating weak labels, CE(f(x),f (x)) +t +whichguidethealignmentofstrongermodels.Theprocess 3: TrainM usingL (f)withlinearwarm-upoverthe +S conf +involvesthefollowingstepsmentionedinAlgorithm2: first20%oftraining +Algorithm2:WeakLabelGenerationProcess +| | | | | | | | | b) Bootstrapping: | | Rather | than training | the | strongest | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | +Inputs: TaskdatasetD +| | | | | | | | | model directly | with | the weakest | supervisor, | we | use inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | +Ensure: WeaklabelsgeneratedforD +| | | | | | | | | mediate models | in | a bootstrapping | process, | iterating | weak- | +| -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | -------- | -------------------------- | --- | --------------- | -------- | --------- | ----- | +| 1: Split | dataset | D into | two | halves: | D and | D , | grouping | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 1 | 2 | | to-stronglearninginstages. | | | | | | +relateddatapoints +| 2: Finetune | a | smaller | pretrained | model | M | on | D using | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | W | 1 | Algorithm5:BootstrappingwithIntermediateModels | | | | | | +groundtruthlabels +3: UseM W togenerateweaklabelsforD 2 Inputs: Weak labels f w (x), Intermediate models +| | | | | | | | | M ,M | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | S1 | S2 | | S | | | +Ensure: TrainedstrongmodelM +| After generating | | weak | labels, | we | train | the weak | super- | | | | S | | | +| ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------- | ------ | -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 1: Foreachroundr | | =1to3: | | | | +| visor over | 2 epochs | with | a | batch | size of | 32. Early | stop- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ForeachintermediatemodelM | | | | : | | +| | | | | | | | | 2: | | | Si | | | +| ping is applied | | based | on validation | | accuracy | to ensure | the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | 3: | TrainM | Si onf w | (x)andgeneratenewweaklabels | | | +| model is | properly | trained | to | produce | informative | | labels for | | | | | | | +f (x) +| thestrongermodels. | | | | | | | | wi | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | 4: Train | M | on f | (x) using the | best intermediate | | +S wi +model +StrongStudentTraining +| The strong | student | model | is | trained | using | the weak | labels. | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +We apply several training strategies, including a baseline c) Generative Finetuning: Before weak-to-strong train- +method and more advanced techniques to improve perfor- ing, we perform unsupervised finetuning on task-relevant +| mance. | | | | | | | | datatoimprovethemodel’srepresentationofkeyconcepts. | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +| TaskName | | Source | | | | | Description | | | | | | TaskType | | +| -------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| CoLA | | Warstadtetal.,2019 | | | | | Linguisticacceptability | | | | | | Binary | | +| SST-2 | | Socheretal.,2013 | | | | | Sentimentanalysis | | | | | | Binary | | +| MRPC | | Dolan&Brockett,2005 | | | | | Paraphrasedetection | | | | | | Binary | | +| STS-B | | Ceretal.,2017 | | | | | Semantictextualsimilarity | | | | | | Regression | | +| QQP | | Quora | | | | | Questionpairsimilarity | | | | | | Binary | | +| MNLI | | Williamsetal.,2018 | | | | | Naturallanguageinference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| QNLI | | Rajpurkaretal.,2016 | | | | | QuestionansweringNLI | | | | | | Binary | | +| RTE | | Daganetal.,2006 | | | | | Recognizingtextualentailment | | | | | | Binary | | +| WNLI | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| AX | | Wangetal.,2019 | | | | | DiagnosticdatasetforMNLI | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| CB | | DeMarneffeetal.,2019 | | | | | CommitmentBank | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| COPA | | Roemmeleetal.,2011 | | | | | ChoiceofPlausibleAlternatives | | | | | | Binary | | +MultiRC Khashabietal.,2018 Multi-SentenceReadingComprehension Binary +ReCoRD Zhangetal.,2018 ReadingComprehensionwithCommonsense Binary +| WiC | | Pilehvar&Camacho-Collados,2019 | | | | | Word-in-Context | | | | | | Binary | | +| --------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| WSC | | Levesqueetal.,2012 | | | | | WinogradSchemaChallenge | | | | | | Binary | | +| BoolQ | | Clarketal.,2019 | | | | | BooleanQuestions | | | | | | Binary | | +| RACE | | Laietal.,2017 | | | | | ReadingComprehension | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SciTail | | Khotetal.,2018 | | | | | ScienceQuestionAnswering | | | | | | Binary | | +| SNLI | | Bowmanetal.,2015 | | | | | NaturalLanguageInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| SWAG | | Zellersetal.,2018 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +| HellaSWAG | | Zellersetal.,2019 | | | | | CommonsenseInference | | | | | | Multi-class | | +Table1:NLPClassificationTasks +Algorithm6:GenerativeFinetuning model size. Each stage consists of 3 iterations of weak-to- +| | | | | | | | | strong learning. | | The learning | rate | is reduced | by | a factor of | +| ------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| Inputs: | Task-relevantdataD | | | ,StrongmodelM | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | task | | | S | | | | | | | | | +| Ensure: | FinetunedstrongmodelM | | | | | | | 10ateachstage. | | | | | | | +S +| 1: PretrainM | | S onD task | withalanguagemodelingobjec- | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | GenerativeFinetuning | | | Forgenerativefinetuning,wepre- | | | | +tive +trainthestrongmodelontask-relevant,unlabeleddatausing +| 2: Proceed | with | weak-to-strong | | training | on | weak | labels | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +alanguagemodelingobjective.Wethenfinetunethemodel +f (x) +| w | | | | | | | | usingweaklabels,withalearningrateof5e−5 | | | | | | andabatch | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | +sizeof16. +These methods collectively improve the robustness and EvaluationMetrics +| accuracy | of the | strong student | | model, | enabling | better | gen- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +eralization and alignment with weak labels across different 1. PerformanceGapRecovered(PGR): +tasks. +P −P +| | | | | | | | | | | PGR= | | ws w | | (3) | +| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | +| DetailedMethodsDescription | | | | | | | | | | | | P s −P w | | | +Baseline Method For the baseline method, we finetune WhereP istheweak-to-strongperformance,P +| | | | | | | | | | ws | | | | | w isthe | +| ---------- | ------- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | +| the strong | student | model | directly | on weak | labels | generated | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | weak | performance, | | and P s | is the strong | ceiling | perfor- | +1e−4, +| by the weak | supervisor. | | We use | a learning | rate | of | a | mance. | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +batchsizeof32,andapplyearlystoppingbasedonvalida- +| | | | | | | | | 2. Student-SupervisorAgreement:Thefractionoftestin- | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionaccuracy. +putswherethestrongstudentmakesthesameprediction +astheweaksupervisor. +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| method | introduces | a loss | term | that combines | | cross-entropy | | | | | | | | | +loss with confidence-based regularization. The weighting AblationStudies +factorαissetto0.5formediummodelsand0.75forlarge +| | | | | | | | | We conduct | ablation | studies | to | evaluate | the impact | of dif- | +| ------- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | +| models, | with linear | warm-up | over | the | first 20% | of training | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | ferent components | | of our | method. | Specifically, | | we analyze | +epochs. +| | | | | | | | | the effect | of removing | | the auxiliary | confidence | | loss, boot- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +Bootstrapping In the bootstrapping approach, we train strapping, and generative finetuning. The results are shown +| intermediate | models | in | three | stages, | gradually | increasing | | inTable2. | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 2: Ablation Study Results: Impact of Removing Key tratesthePerformanceGapRecovered(PGR)acrossdiffer- +Components on Model Performance. The table shows ac- enttaskdomainsandmodelsizes. +curacy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) when each +componentisremoved.Lowervalueshighlightthecompo- Performance Across Tasks Figure 1 illustrates the test +nent’s importance. Auxiliary Confidence Loss and Genera- accuracy and Performance Gap Recovered (PGR) for our +tiveFinetuninghavethemostsignificantimpact,underscor- three task domains: NLP benchmarks, chess puzzles, and +ingtheircriticalroleintheframework’seffectiveness. ChatGPTrewardmodeling. +Method Accuracy PGR +(Without) (Without) +Aux.Confidence 0.82 0.60 +Bootstrapping 0.80 0.55 +Gen.Finetuning 0.85 0.70 +Analysis +Weconductthreetypesofanalysis: +1. Scaling Behavior: We plot PGR and test accuracy +againstsupervisorandstudentmodelsizes. +2. Error Analysis: We manually inspect cases where the +studentmodelmakesmistakes,categorizingerrortypes. +Figure 1: PGR as a function of model size for each task +3. ConceptSaliency:Wemeasuretheperformanceoflin- +domain. Higher PGR values indicate more effective weak- +ear probes on frozen model activations before and after +to-stronglearning.ThegraphshowsthatPGRgenerallyin- +weak-to-strongtraining. +creases with model size for NLP tasks, while it decreases +This methodology provides a comprehensive framework +forlargermodelsinchesstasks,indicatingscalabilitychal- +for studying weak-to-strong generalization in model align- +lenges. Reward modeling shows consistently lower PGR, +ment, incorporating various training techniques and eval- +highlightingtheneedformoreadvancedmethods. +uation metrics to assess the effectiveness of our approach +acrossdifferenttasksandmodelsizes. +ResultsandAnalysis +Our work builds upon and extends recent advancements in +language model alignment, leveraging weak-to-strong gen- +eralizationtechniques to address the challengesof aligning +increasinglycomplexAIsystems. +Toverifytherobustnessofourresults,weconductpaired +t-testscomparingtheperformanceofdifferentmethods.The +resultsarepresentedinTable3. +Table 3: Statistical Significance of Method Improvements. +P-values for paired t-tests comparing the baseline method +to each enhanced approach in terms of Accuracy and Per- +formance Gap Recovered (PGR). Lower p-values (< 0.05) +indicatestatisticallysignificantimprovementsoverthebase- Figure 2: Accuracy as a function of model size for each +line,withBootstrappingshowingthemostsignificantgains. task domain. Weak-to-strong generalization improves per- +formance across all tasks, with NLP achieving the highest +Comparison P-value P-value accuracy.ChessandRewardModelingshowdiminishingre- +(Accuracy) (PGR) turnswithlargermodels,highlightingchallengesinscaling +Baselinevs.Aux.Confidence 0.03 0.01 theapproachtomorecomplextasksandareasforfuturere- +Baselinevs.Bootstrapping 0.003 0.002 search +Baselinevs.Gen.Finetuning 0.01 0.01 +NLP tasks: We observe promising weak-to-strong gen- +eralization, with PGR often exceeding 50% for the largest +BaselineWeak-to-StrongGeneralization +student models. Chess puzzles: PGR is high for small +Our initial experiments demonstrate that strong pretrained supervisor-student gaps but decreases for larger gaps. Re- +modelscannaturallygeneralizebeyondtheirweaksupervi- ward modeling: Weak-to-strong generalization is poor by +sorswhennaivelyfinetunedonweaklabels.Figure1illus- default,withPGRrarelyexceeding20%. + +Scaling Behavior We find that PGR generally increases AnalysisofGeneralizationMechanisms +| with both | weak | supervisor | size and | strong | student | size for | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | ------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Imitation | vs. | Generalization | | We | analyze | student- | | +NLPtasks.However,forchesspuzzles,PGRdecreaseswith +| | | | | | | | supervisor | agreement | to | understand | | the extent | of imitation | | +| -------------- | ---- | ----- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------ | +| strong student | size | for a | given | weak supervisor. | | Reward | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | versus true | generalization, | | | illustrated | in | Figure | 3. The | +modelingshowspoorscalingbehavioroverall. +| | | | | | | | student-supervisor | | agreement | | trends | corroborate | our | sta- | +| ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------------ | ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | +| Our findings | on | scaling | behavior | align | with the | observa- | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | tistical | significance | results | (Table | | 3), providing | | insights | +tionsof(Baietal.2022)intheirworkonConstitutionalAI, +| | | | | | | | into the | effectiveness | | of different | weak-to-strong | | learning | | +| ---------- | ---- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| suggesting | that | alignment | techniques | must | adapt | as model | | | | | | | | | +methods. +capabilitiesincrease. +| | | | | | | | As shown | in | Figure | 3, all | methods | exhibit | decreasing | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | agreement | rates | as model | size | increases, | but | to varying | de- | +ImprovedWeak-to-StrongGeneralizationMethods +grees.Thisgeneraltrendsuggeststhatlargermodelstendto +Drawing inspiration from ”AI Safety via Debate” frame- diverge more from the weak supervisor’s predictions, indi- +work (Irving, Christiano, and Amodei 2018), we explore cating potential generalization beyond the initial weak su- +| methods | to enhance | weak-to-strong | | generalization | | through | pervision. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +adversarialdynamicsandstructuredlearning. +Notably,theBootstrappingmethoddemonstratesthemost +substantialdecreaseinagreementacrossmodelsizes(from +| AuxiliaryConfidenceLoss | | | Theauxiliaryconfidenceloss | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | -------- | -------------- | -------------------------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | 0.88 for | small | models | to 0.75 | for large | models). | This | pro- | +| significantly | improves | weak-to-strong | | generalization, | | par- | | | | | | | | | +nounceddeclinealignswithitslowestp-valuesinourstatis- +ticularlyforNLPtasks. +| | | | | | | | tical significance | | tests | (p = 0.003 | for | accuracy, | p = | 0.002 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | for PGR), | suggesting | that | Bootstrapping | | is | particularly | ef- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | +• Forthelargestsupervisor-studentgaps,medianPGRin- fective at enabling the model to surpass the weak supervi- +| creases | from | about 25% | to nearly | 80% | with | the confi- | sor’sperformance. | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +denceloss. The Auxiliary Confidence and Generative Finetuning +• The improvement is most pronounced for large gaps in methods show moderate decreases in agreement (0.89 to +computebetweenweakandstrongmodels. 0.80and0.89to0.79,respectively),consistentwiththeirin- +| | | | | | | | termediate | p-values. | These | methods | | appear | to strike | a bal- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------ | +This approach can be seen as an extension of the debate ancebetweenleveragingweaksupervisionandencouraging +framework, encouraging models to make confident predic- independentgeneralization. +tionswhilestillleveragingweaksupervision. +Incontrast,theBaselinemethodmaintainsrelativelyhigh +| | | | | | | | agreement | across | all model | sizes | (0.90 | to 0.87), | indicating | | +| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Bootstrapping | | Bootstrappingshowspromisingresultsfor | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | that without | additional | | techniques, | | larger | models | tend to | +chesspuzzlesbutyieldslimitedimprovementsforNLPand +morecloselymimictheweaksupervisor,potentiallyinclud- +rewardmodelingtasks. +ingitserrors. +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | These | findings | suggest | that | our enhanced | | methods, | par- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | +• Bootstrapping improves PGR compared to the baseline, ticularlyBootstrapping,aremoreeffectiveatenablingmod- +especiallyforlargerstudentmodels. elstogeneralizebeyondtheweaksupervisor’scapabilities. +Thedecreasingagreementrates,coupledwithimprovedper- +| • The | accuracy | continues | to monotonically | | improve | with | | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +bootstrapping,unliketheflatteningobservedinthenaive formance(asindicatedbylowerp-values),demonstratethat +thesemethodsfacilitatethedevelopmentofmodelsthatcan +method. +| | | | | | | | leverage | weak | supervision | while | still | developing | indepen- | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +The bootstrapping method resonates with the iterative dentandpotentiallysuperiordecision-makingcapabilities. +| refinement | processes | suggested | in | Constitutional | | AI (Bai | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----- | --------- | ---- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | Larger | student | models | show | lower | agreement | with | weak | +etal.2022),allowingforgradualimprovementofalignment +| | | | | | | | supervisors, | suggesting | | less imitation | | of errors. | The | auxil- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | +acrossmodelscales. iary confidenceloss furtherreduces imitationof supervisor +mistakes. +| Generative | Finetuning | | Generative | finetuning | | on reward | | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | These | findings | contribute | | to our | understanding | | of how | +| modeling | data improves | | weak-to-strong | | performance | and | | | | | | | | | +modelsbalanceimitationandtruegeneralization,akeycon- +PGR. +cerninscalingalignmenttechniques(Ouyangetal.2022). +Keyfindings: +| | | | | | | | ConceptSaliency | | Weinvestigatethelinearrepresentabil- | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• PGRimprovesbyapproximately10-20%withgenerative +| | | | | | | | ity of desired | | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +finetuning. +learning.Figure4illustratesthechangeinlinearprobeper- +• Theimprovementstackswithearly-stoppingtechniques, +| | | | | | | | formance | for key | concepts | before | and | after | weak-to-strong | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | +achievingPGRof30-40%. +learning. +This technique builds on the insights from (Dehghani Finetuningonweaklabelsincreasesthelinearseparability +et al. 2017; Pe´rez-D’Arpino, Khurshid, and Shah 2020) on ofgroundtruthconcepts.Thissuggeststhatweak-to-strong +discovering and shaping language model behaviors, using learning may help make desired concepts more salient in +| task-relevantdatatoenhancealignment. | | | | | | | modelrepresentations. | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Figure3:Student-supervisoragreementacrossmodelsizesfordifferentweak-to-strongmethods.Decliningagreementinboot- +strapping and Auxiliary confidence suggests improved generalization, while the baseline method remains stable, indicating +limitedgeneralization. +| This analysis | provides | | insights | into how | weak-to-strong | | +| ------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | +learningmayhelpinshapingmodelbehavior,complement- +ingtheworkonConstitutionalAI(Baietal.2022)ininstill- +ingdesiredconceptsandvalues. +ErrorAnalysis +| We conducted | a detailed | | error analysis | | on cases | where the | +| ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | +strongstudentmodelmakesmistakes.Commonerrortypes +include: +• Poorquoteselection(forNLPtasks) +| • Inability | to extract | key | evidence | from | weak | supervision | +| ----------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | +(forrewardmodeling) +• Overfittingtoweaklabelerrors(acrossalltasks) +Ourerroranalysisbuildsontheframeworkofdebate(Irv- +ing,Christiano,andAmodei2018),identifyingareaswhere +| adversarial | dynamics | can | be leveraged | | to improve | model | +| ----------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | +performanceandalignment. +| To better | understand | | the types | of errors | made | by the | +| --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---- | ------ | +Figure4:Conceptsaliencybeforeandafterweak-to-strong +learningforkeyNLPconcepts.Thefigureshowsimproved strong student model, we present the distribution of error +linearprobeperformance,indicatingenhancedmodelrepre- typesinFigure5. +sentationsacrossallconcepts.LargergainsinSentimentvs. +DiscussionandConclusion +Intentsuggestthatweak-to-stronglearningaffectsdifferent +aspects of language understanding to varying degrees, pro- Ourworkdemonstratestheeffectivenessofweak-to-strong +vidinginsightsforfutureimprovements. generalization in language models for model alignment. +| The proposed | framework, | | which | combines | facilitation | and | +| ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | ------- | +| debate-based | learning, | shows | promise | in | enhancing | model | +| performance | and | alignment | across | various | tasks. | Through | + +| | | | | | | | • While an | improvement | over | baseline | approaches, | | naive | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | +finetuningonweaksupervisionisinsufficienttofullyre- +coverstrongmodelperformance,indicatingtheneedfor +moresophisticatedtransfertechniques. +| | | | | | | | • Generalization | remains | inconsistent | | across | tasks, | with | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | complex | domains like | reward | modeling | | proving | partic- | +ularlychallenging.Thishighlightstheneedformorero- +bustandadaptivealignmenttechniques. +• Ourcurrentsetup,thoughanadvancementoverprevious +| | | | | | | | methods, | may not fully | capture | the | difficulties | | of align- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | +ingsuperhumanAIsystems,suchasthepotentialeaseof +imitatinghuman-levelerrors. +Theselimitationspointtoseveralpromisingdirectionsfor +Figure5:Distributionoferrortypesfromtheerroranalysis. +futurework: +Thechartshowsthatpoorquoteselectionandevidenceex- +| | | | | | | | • Developing | more sophisticated | | | debate | mechanisms | to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | +tractionaccountfor70%oferrors,suggestingimprovements +enhancethequalityandefficiencyofknowledgetransfer +| in identifying | relevant | information | | could enhance | weak-to- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweenmodelsofvaryingcapabilities. +stronglearning.Overfittingerrors(20%)arerelativelylow, +indicating the approach generally succeeds in generalizing • Exploringtheintegrationofourapproachwithotherscal- +beyondweaklabels,thoughfurtherimprovementispossible +| | | | | | | | able oversight | methods | to | create | more | comprehensive | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | +alignmentframeworks. +| | | | | | | | • Investigating | the application | | of this | framework | | to even | +| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | +| our experiments | | and analysis, | we | have gained | several | key | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | more advanced | AI | systems | and diverse | | task domains | to | +insightsintothenatureofmodelalignmentthroughfacilita- +testitsscalabilityandgeneralizability. +tion: +• Refiningourunderstandingofmodelbehaviorandalign- +| 1. Strong | models | demonstrate | a remarkable | | ability | to gen- | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | ----------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | +| | | | | | | | ment across | increasing | scales | of | capability | to | better ad- | +| eralize | beyond | weak supervision, | | particularly | | in NLP | | | | | | | | +dressthechallengesofaligningsuperhumanAIsystems. +| tasks, | suggesting | the potential | | for knowledge | | transfer | | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +acrossdifferentcapabilitylevels. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that weak-to- +2. The introduction of auxiliary confidence loss signif- strong generalization is a promising approach for model +icantly improves generalization, especially for large alignment,capableofelicitingstrongcapabilitiesfromlim- +| supervisor-student | | gaps, | highlighting | the | importance | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ited supervision. | By bridging | | the gap | between | explanation | | +calibratedconfidenceinthealignmentprocess. generationandmodelalignment,ourframeworkopensnew +3. Techniquessuchasbootstrappingandgenerativefinetun- avenues for creating AI systems that are not only powerful +ing show potential in addressing domain-specific chal- but also fundamentally aligned with human values and in- +tentions.Whilesignificantchallengesremaininscalingthis +lenges,asevidencedbytheireffectivenessinchesspuz- +approachtomorecomplextasksandtrulysuperhumanmod- +zlesandrewardmodelingtasks. +4. Thelearningprocessrequiresadelicatebalancebetween els,theinsightsgainedfromthisworkprovideasolidfoun- +dationforfutureresearchinAIalignmentandsafety. +imitationandtruegeneralization,emphasizingthecom- +| plexity | of aligning | AI | systems | with human | values | and | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| intentions. | | | | | | | | | References | | | | | +Compared to traditional explanation generation ap- Bai, Y.; Kadavath, S.; Kundu, S.; Askell, A.; Kernion, J.; +proaches,ourframeworkoffersseveraladvantages: Jones,A.;Chen,A.;Goldie,A.;Mirhoseini,A.;McKinnon, +C.;etal.2022.Constitutionalai:Harmlessnessfromaifeed- +• ItprovidesamechanismforcontinuousalignmentasAI +back. arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.08073. +capabilitiesevolve,addressingthescalabilitychallenges +facedbycurrentmethodslikeRLHF. Buciluaˇ, C.; Caruana, R.; and Niculescu-Mizil, A. 2006. +• Thedebate-basedcomponentenhancestransparencyand Model compression. In Proceedings of the 12th ACM +interpretability, allowing for more nuanced oversight of SIGKDDinternationalconferenceonKnowledgediscovery +| thealignmentprocess. | | | | | | | anddatamining,535–541. | | | | | | | +| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +• By leveraging both weak and strong models, our ap- Burns, C.; Izmailov, P.; Kirchner, J. H.; Baker, B.; Gao, +proachpotentiallyovercomeslimitationsofhumanover- L.; Aschenbrenner, L.; Chen, Y.; Ecoffet, A.; Joglekar, M.; +sightincomplextasks. Leike,J.;etal.2023. Weak-to-stronggeneralization:Elicit- +ingstrongcapabilitieswithweaksupervision.arXivpreprint +| However, | despite | these | promising | results, | several | limita- | | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionsandchallengesremain,echoingconcernsidentifiedin arXiv:2312.09390. +recent alignment research (Ouyang et al. 2022; Bai et al. Cooke,N.J.2015. Teamcognitionasinteraction. Current +2022;Pe´rez-D’Arpino,Khurshid,andShah2020): directionsinpsychologicalscience,24(6):415–419. + +Cooke,N.J.;Gorman,J.C.;Myers,C.W.;andDuran,J.L. Stiennon, N.; Ouyang, L.; Wu, J.; Ziegler, D.; Lowe, R.; +2013. Interactiveteamcognition. Cognitivescience,37(2): Voss, C.; Radford, A.; Amodei, D.; and Christiano, P. F. +| 255–285. | | | | | | | 2020. | Learning | to | summarize | with | human | feedback. | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | Advances | in Neural | | Information | Processing | | Systems, | 33: | +Datasnaek.2021.ChessGameDataset(Lichess).Accessed: +3008–3021. +2024-08-09. +Zakershahrak,M.;Gong,Z.;Sadassivam,N.;andZhang,Y. +Dehghani,M.;Severyn,A.;Rothe,S.;andKamps,J.2017. +2020a. Onlineexplanationgenerationforplanningtasksin +Learningtolearnfromweaksupervisionbyfullsupervision. +human-robotteaming.In2020IEEE/RSJInternationalCon- +arXivpreprintarXiv:1711.11383. +| | | | | | | | ference | on Intelligent | | Robots | and Systems | (IROS), | | 6304– | +| ------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ------- | --- | ----- | +| Ghodratnama, | S.; | and | Zakershahrak, | M. | 2023. | Adapt- | 6310.IEEE. | | | | | | | | +ingLLMsforEfficient,PersonalizedInformationRetrieval: +| | | | | | | | Zakershahrak, | | M.; Marpally, | | S. R.; Sharma, | | A.; Gong, | Z.; | +| ------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ----- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---- | +| Methods | and Implications. | | In | International | Conference | on | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | and Zhang, | Y. | 2020b. | Order | Matters: | Generating | | Pro- | +Service-OrientedComputing,17–26.Springer. +| | | | | | | | gressive | Explanations | | for Planning | Tasks | in | Human-Robot | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | +| Ghodratnama,S.;andZakershahrak,M.2024. | | | | | SumRecom: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Teaming. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2004.07822. | | | | | | | +APersonalizedSummarizationApproachbyLearningfrom Zakershahrak, M.; Sonawane, A.; Gong, Z.; and Zhang, Y. +| Users’Feedback. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2408.07294. | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +2018.Interactiveplanexplicabilityinhuman-robotteaming. +Gunning, D. 2017. Explainable artificial intelligence (xai). In 2018 27th IEEE International Symposium on Robot and +Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), nd HumanInteractiveCommunication(RO-MAN),1012–1017. +| Web. | | | | | | | IEEE. | | | | | | | | +| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Hadfield-Menell,D.;Russell,S.J.;Abbeel,P.;andDragan, Ziebart, B. D.; Maas, A.; Bagnell, J. A.; and Dey, A. K. +A. 2016. Cooperative inverse reinforcement learning. In 2008. MaximumEntropyInverseReinforcementLearning. +Advances in neural information processing systems, 3909– InProceedingsofthe23rdNationalConferenceonArtificial +Intelligence-Volume3,AAAI’08,1433–1438.AAAIPress. +3917. +Irving, G.; Christiano, P.; and Amodei, D. 2018. AI safety ISBN9781577353683. +| viadebate. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1805.00899. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| LeCun,Y.;Bengio,Y.;andHinton,G.2015. | | | | | Deeplearning. | | | | | | | | | | +nature,521(7553):436–444. +Leike,J.;Krueger,D.;Everitt,T.;Martic,M.;Maini,V.;and +| Legg,S.2018. | Scalableagentalignmentviarewardmodel- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| ing:aresearchdirection. | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:1811.07871. | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Miller, | T. 2018. | Explanation | | in artificial | intelligence: | In- | | | | | | | | | +| sightsfromthesocialsciences. | | | | ArtificialIntelligence. | | | | | | | | | | | +Mittal,A.;Schick,T.;Artetxe,M.;andDwivedi-Yu,J.2023. +| Evaluation | of Faithfulness | | Using | the | Longest | Supported | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Subsequence. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2308.12157. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| Ng, A. | Y.; and Russell, | | S. J. 2000. | Algorithms | | for Inverse | | | | | | | | | +InICML,663–670.MorganKauf- +ReinforcementLearning. +mannPublishersInc. +Ouyang,L.;Wu,J.;Jiang,X.;Almeida,D.;Wainwright,C.; +| Mishkin, | P.; Zhang, | C.; | Agarwal, | S.; Slama, | K.; | Ray, A.; | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| etal.2022. | Traininglanguagemodelstofollowinstructions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| withhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralinformationpro- | | | | | | | | | | | | +cessingsystems,35:27730–27744. +Pe´rez-D’Arpino,C.;Khurshid,R.P.;andShah,J.A.2020. +| Experimental | Assessment | | of | Human-Robot | Teaming | for | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Multi-Step | Remote | Manipulation | | with | Expert | Operators. | | | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2011.10898. +| Sanh,V.;Debut,L.;Chaumond,J.;andWolf,T.2019. | | | | | | Dis- | | | | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tilBERT,adistilledversionofBERT:smaller,faster,cheaper +| andlighter. | arXivpreprintarXiv:1910.01108. | | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Seeber, | I.; Bittner, | E.; | Briggs, | R. O.; | De Vreede, | T.; | | | | | | | | | +DeVreede,G.-J.;Elkins,A.;Maier,R.;Merz,A.B.;Oeste- +| Reiß,S.;Randrup,N.;etal.2020. | | | | Machinesasteammates: | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| AresearchagendaonAIinteamcollaboration. | | | | | | Information | | | | | | | | | +&management,57(2):103174. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k4/random_2.md b/q79/random_k4/random_2.md index 4bcaaffd0140b439e3111b15be90b5099749743d..032ac202436081f4b3d557a79c59bb0d7084141b 100644 --- a/q79/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q79/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,3187 +1,1430 @@ -School Meals Programs and Other USDA -Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated August 24, 2018 - -Congressional Research Service - -https://crsreports.congress.gov - -R43783 - -{222A0E69-13A2-4985-84AE-73CC3DFF4D02}-R-008032105221177189069140163240174026137243109106239050005249089181035110184065171150222238050143170044130075151022235203179242176047216087082047088140020229001139009183064080176154202161058046029022041045101112067071229147068138195245121093 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summary -The “child nutrition programs” refer to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition -Service (USDA-FNS) programs that provide food for children in school or institutional settings. -The best known programs, which serve the largest number of children, are the school meals -programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). -The child nutrition programs also include the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), -which provides meals and snacks in day care and after school settings; the Summer Food Service -Program (SFSP), which provides food during the summer months; the Special Milk Program -(SMP), which supports milk for schools that do not participate in NSLP or SBP; and the Fresh -Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP), which funds fruit and vegetable snacks in select elementary -schools. - -Funding: The vast majority of the child nutrition programs account is considered mandatory -spending, with trace amounts of discretionary funding for certain related activities. Referred to as -open-ended, “appropriated entitlements,” funding is provided through the annual appropriations -process; however, the level of spending is controlled by benefit and eligibility criteria in federal -law and dependent on the resulting levels of participation. Federal cash funding (in the form of -per-meal reimbursements) and USDA commodity food support is guaranteed to schools and other -providers based on the number of meals or snacks served and participant category (e.g., free -meals for poor children get higher subsidies). - -Participation: The child nutrition programs serve children of varying ages and in different -institutional settings. The NSLP and SBP have the broadest reach, serving qualifying children of -all ages in school settings. Other child nutrition programs serve more-narrow populations. -CACFP, for example, provides meals and snacks to children in early childhood and after-school -settings among other venues. Programs generally provide some subsidy for all food served but a -larger federal reimbursement for food served to children from low-income households. - -Administration: Responsibility for child nutrition programs is divided between the federal -government, states, and localities. The state agency and type of local provider differs by program. -In the NSLP and SBP, schools and school districts (“school food authorities”) administer the -program. Meanwhile, SFSP (and sometimes CACFP) uses a model in which sponsor -organizations handle administrative responsibilities for a number of sites that serve meals. - -Reauthorization: The underlying laws covering the child nutrition programs were last -reauthorized in the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296, enacted -December 13, 2010). This law made significant changes to child nutrition programs, including -increasing federal financing for school lunches, expanding access to community eligibility and -direct certification options for schools, and expanding eligibility options for home child care -providers. The law also required an update to school meal nutrition guidelines as well as new -guidelines for food served outside the meal programs (e.g., snacks sold in vending machines and -cafeteria a la carte lines). - -Current Issues: The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition -reauthorization (see CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An -Overview). As of the date of this report, there has been no significant legislative activity with -regard to reauthorization in the 115th Congress. However, the vast majority of operations and -activities continue with funding provided by appropriations laws. Current issues in the child -nutrition programs for policymakers include the implementation of new and updated nutrition -standards, alternatives to the “congregate feeding” requirement in the SFSP, and schools’ efforts -to collect unpaid school meal fees (stigmatizing practices are sometimes called “lunch shaming”). - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Contents - -Introduction and Background .......................................................................................................... 1 -Authorization and Reauthorization ........................................................................................... 2 -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local .................................................................. 3 -Funding Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3 -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding ............................................................... 3 -Other Federal Funding ........................................................................................................ 5 -State, Local, and Participant Funds ..................................................................................... 5 -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ....................................................................................... 5 -Links to Resources .................................................................................................................... 7 -School Meals Programs ................................................................................................................... 7 -General Characteristics ............................................................................................................. 7 -School Meals Eligibility Rules .................................................................................................. 9 -Income Eligibility ............................................................................................................. 10 -Categorical Eligibility ........................................................................................................ 11 -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) ........................................................................... 13 -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) ................................................................................ 15 -School Breakfast Program (SBP) ............................................................................................ 16 -Other Child Nutrition Programs .................................................................................................... 17 -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) ...................................................................... 17 -CACFP at Centers ............................................................................................................. 18 -CACFP for Day Care Homes ............................................................................................ 19 -Summer Meals ........................................................................................................................ 20 -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP)............................................................................ 21 -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option ......................................................................... 22 -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration ....................................................................... 22 -Special Milk Program (SMP) .................................................................................................. 23 -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) ............................................................................ 23 -Other Topics .................................................................................................................................. 24 -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options ....................................................... 24 -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities ............................................................ 26 -Selected Current Issues ................................................................................................................. 28 -Regulations on Nutrition Standards ........................................................................................ 28 -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast ..................................................... 28 -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools .................................................. 30 -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP ......................................................................... 31 -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals ....................................................... 31 -Current Law and Policy .................................................................................................... 32 -Congressional Proposals ................................................................................................... 33 -Presidential Budget Proposals ........................................................................................... 34 -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” ......................................................................... 34 - -Figures - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs ............................... 9 -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals ........................... 13 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation ............................................... 15 -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation ......................................................... 17 - -Tables - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance ............................................................................... 5 -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP .......................... 11 -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs ...................... 25 - -Table A-1. Acronyms ..................................................................................................................... 37 -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches ....................................................................... 38 -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks .................................................... 38 -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP ......................................................................................... 39 -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) ....................................... 39 -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School - -Programs .................................................................................................................................... 39 -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes .................................................... 39 -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP ....................................................................................... 40 -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP ........................................................................................ 40 - -Appendixes - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report ................................................................................ 37 -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement Rates for Child Nutrition Programs ........... 38 - -Contacts - -Author Information ........................................................................................................................ 41 -Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 41 - -Congressional Research Service - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Introduction and Background -The federal child nutrition programs provide assistance to schools and other institutions in the -form of cash, commodity food, and administrative support (such as technical assistance and -administrative funding) based on the provision of meals and snacks to children.1 In general, these -programs were created (and amended over time) to both improve children’s nutrition and provide -support to the agriculture economy. - -Today, the child nutrition programs refer primarily to the following meal, snack, and milk -reimbursement programs (these and other acronyms are listed in Appendix A):2 - - National School Lunch Program (NSLP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1751 et seq.)); - - School Breakfast Program (SBP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 4 (42 U.S.C. - -1773)); - - Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) (Richard B. Russell National - -School Lunch Act, Section 17 (42 U.S.C. 1766)); - - Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) (Richard B. Russell National School - -Lunch Act, Section 13 (42 U.S.C. 1761)); and - - Special Milk Program (SMP) (Child Nutrition Act, Section 3 (42 U.S.C. - -1772)). - -The programs provide financial support and/or foods to the institutions that prepare meals and -snacks served outside of the home (unlike other food assistance programs such as the -Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program [SNAP, formerly the Food Stamp Program] where -benefits are used to purchase food for home consumption). Though exact eligibility rules and -pricing vary by program, in general the amount of federal reimbursement is greater for meals -served to qualifying low-income individuals or at qualifying institutions, although most programs -provide some subsidy for all food served. Participating children receive subsidized meals and -snacks, which may be free or at reduced price. Forthcoming sections discuss how program- -specific eligibility rules and funding operate. - -This report describes how each program operates under current law, focusing on eligibility rules, -participation, and funding. This introductory section describes some of the background and -principles that generally apply to all of the programs; subsequent sections go into further detail on -the workings of each. - -Unless stated otherwise, participation and funding data come from USDA-FNS’s “Keydata -Reports.”3 - -1 As discussed later in the report, the Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) also supports food in adult day -care facilities, but the child nutrition programs overwhelmingly serve children. -2 Some lists also include the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) (Richard B. Russell National School Lunch -Act, Section 19 (42 U.S.C. 1769a)), a newer program that is financed in a much different way than the programs listed. -FFVP is discussed further later in the report (“Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program”). WIC (the Special Supplemental -Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. -WIC is not one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report. -3 This CRS report uses the May 2018 report, which contains data through March 2018. Keydata Reports available at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -1 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Authorization and Reauthorization - -The child nutrition programs are most often dated back to the 1946 enactment of the National -School Lunch Act, which created the National School Lunch Program, albeit in a different form -than it operates today.4 Most of the child nutrition programs do not date back to 1946; they were -added and amended in the decades to follow as policymakers expanded child nutrition programs’ -institutional settings and meals provided: - - The Special Milk Program was created in 1954, regularly extended, and made - -permanent in 1970.5 - - The School Breakfast Program was piloted in 1966, regularly extended, and - -eventually made permanent in 1975.6 - - A program for child care settings and summer programs was piloted in 1968, - -with separate programs authorized in 1975 and then made permanent in 1978.7 -These are now the Child and Adult Care Food Program8 and Summer Food -Service Program. - - The Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program began as a pilot in 2002 and was made - -permanent in 2008.9 - -The programs are now authorized under three major federal statutes: the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (originally enacted as the National School Lunch Act in 1946), the -Child Nutrition Act (originally enacted in 1966), and Section 32 of the act of August 24, 1935 (7 -U.S.C. 612c).10 Congressional jurisdiction over the underlying three laws has typically been -exercised by the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee; the House Education and -the Workforce Committee; and, to a limited extent (relating to commodity food assistance and -Section 32 issues), the House Agriculture Committee. - -Congress periodically reviews and reauthorizes expiring authorities under these laws. The child -nutrition programs were most recently reauthorized in 2010 through the Healthy, Hunger-Free -Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA, P.L. 111-296); some of the authorities created or extended in that law -expired on September 30, 2015.11 WIC (the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, - -4 P.L. 79-396. There were, however, a number of smaller, more temporary precursor school food programs prior to -1946; see Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. The 1946 law supported school lunch programs by giving formula grant funding -to states based on factors such as per capita income, rather than the current-day open-ended entitlements based largely -on eligibility and participation rules. -5 P.L. 83-690 and P.L. 91-295. Milk purchases and donations for schools did exist prior to the 1954 law. -6 Gordon W. Gunderson, National School Lunch Program: Background and Development, 1971, -http://www.fns.usda.gov/nslp/history. -7 P.L. 90-302, P.L. 94-105, P.L. 95-627. Institute of Medicine, Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary -Guidance for All, 2011, p. 30, https://www.nap.edu/catalog/12959/child-and-adult-care-food-program-aligning-dietary- -guidance-for. -8 Adult day care was added in 1987 (Older Americans Act Amendments of 1987; P.L. 100-175). -9 P.L. 107-171 and P.L. 110-246. -10 In 1999, P.L. 106-78 renamed the National School Lunch Act in Senator Richard B. Russell’s honor. -11 Reimbursements for NSLP, SBP, CACFP, SMP, and certain related USDA activities are permanently authorized. -SFSP, WIC, and WIC Farmers Market Nutrition Program, State Administrative Expenses (discussed in “Related -Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities”), and certain related USDA activities have a September 30, 2015 -expiration. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -2 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Infants, and Children) is also typically reauthorized with the child nutrition programs. WIC is not -one of the child nutrition programs and is not discussed in this report.12 - -The 114th Congress began but did not complete a 2016 child nutrition reauthorization (see CRS -Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview). As of the date -of this report, the committees of jurisdiction have not conducted reauthorization hearings or -markups in the 115th Congress. - -Program Administration: Federal, State, and Local - -The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food and Nutrition Service (USDA-FNS) administers the -programs at the federal level. The programs are operated by a wide variety of local public and -private providers and the degree of direct state involvement differs by program and state.13 At the -state level, education, health, social services, and agriculture departments all have roles; at a -minimum, they are responsible for approving and overseeing local providers such as schools, -summer program sponsors, and child care centers and day care homes, as well as making sure -they receive the federal support they are due. At the local level, program benefits are provided to -millions of children (e.g., there were 30.0 million in the National School Lunch Program, the -largest of the programs, in FY2017), through some 100,000 public and private schools and -residential child care institutions, nearly 170,000 child care centers and family day care homes, -and just over 50,000 summer program sites. - -All programs are available in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Virtually all operate in -Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands (and, in differing versions, in the Northern Marianas -and American Samoa).14 - -Funding Overview - -This section summarizes the nature and extent to which the programs’ funding is mandatory and -discretionary, including a discussion of appropriated entitlement status. Table 3 lists child -nutrition program and related expenditures. - -Open-Ended, Appropriated Entitlement Funding - -Most spending for child nutrition programs is provided in annual appropriations acts to fulfill the -legal financial obligation established by the authorizing laws. That is, the level of spending for -such programs, referred to as appropriated mandatory spending, is not controlled through the -annual appropriations process, but instead is derived from the benefit and eligibility criteria -specified in the authorizing laws. The appropriated mandatory funding is treated as mandatory -spending. Further, if Congress does not appropriate the funds necessary to fund the program, -eligible entities may have legal recourse.15 Congress considers the Administration’s forecast for - -12 See CRS Report R44115, A Primer on WIC: The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and -Children. -13 In the past, the federal government (via USDA-FNS) has, for certain states, taken the place of state agencies (e.g., -where a state has chosen not to operate a specific program or where there is a state prohibition on aiding private -schools). -14 For more information on child nutrition programs in the Northern Marianas and American Samoa, see U.S. -Department of the Interior, Office of Insular Affairs, Region IX Federal Regional Council, Outer Pacific Committee, -FY 2016 Report on Federal Financial Assistance to the U.S. Pacific and Caribbean Islands, May 1, 2017, p. 10, -https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/fy16-report-on-federal-financial-assistance-to-the-insular-areas.pdf. -15 GAO Budget Glossary, p. 13: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-05-734SP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -3 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -program needs in its appropriations decisions. For the majority of funding discussed in this report, -the formula that controls the funding is not capped and fluctuates based on the reimbursement -rates and the number of meals/snacks served in the programs. - -Cash Reimbursements and Commodity Foods - -In the meal service programs, such as the National School Lunch Program, School Breakfast -Program, summer programs, and assistance for child care centers and day care homes, federal aid -is provided in the form of statutorily set subsidies (reimbursements) paid for each meal/snack -served that meets federal nutrition guidelines. Although all (including full-price) meals/snacks -served by participating providers are subsidized, those served free or at a reduced price to lower- -income children are supported at higher rates. All federal meal/snack subsidy rates are indexed -annually (each July) for inflation, as are the income eligibility thresholds for free and reduced- -price meals/snacks.18 Subsequent sections discuss how a specific program’s eligibility and -reimbursements work. - -Most subsidies are cash payments to -schools or other providers, but a smaller -portion of aid is provided in the form of -USDA-purchased commodity foods.19 -Laws for three child nutrition programs -(NSLP, CACFP, and SFSP) require the -provision of commodity foods (or in -some cases allow cash in lieu of -commodity foods).20 - -Meal and snack service entails non-food -costs. Federal child nutrition per- -meal/snack subsidies may be used to -cover local providers’ administrative -and operating costs. However, the -separate direct federal payments for -administrative/operating costs (“State - -Reimbursable Meals - -A “reimbursable meal” (or snack in the case of some -programs) is a phrase used by USDA, state, and other child -nutrition policy and program operators to indicate a meal (or -snack) that meets federal requirements and thereby qualifies -for meal reimbursement.16 -In general, a meal or snack that is reimbursable means that it is - - - - - -served to the correctly eligible person and/or at the -eligible institution, and - -in compliance with federal nutrition requirements for the -meal or snack.17 - -In the school meals programs (with some variation in other -programs), the highest reimbursement is paid for meals served -free to eligible children, a slightly lower reimbursement is paid -for meals served at a reduced price to eligible children, and a -much smaller reimbursement is also paid for meals served to -children who are either ineligible for assistance or not -certified. For this last group, the children pay the full price as -advertised but meals are still technically subsidized. - -16 See, for example, definition of “reimbursement” at 7 C.F.R. 210.2. -17 The authorizing statutes for all four of the main child nutrition programs include nutritional requirements for the -meals and snacks served; these are sometimes referred to as “nutrition standards,” “nutrition guidelines,” or “meal -patterns.” In most respects, the details of the requirements are specified in USDA-FNS regulations. The nutrition -guidelines differ by program, largely in consideration of the age groups fed, meals/snacks authorized, and perhaps the -settings in which meals are served. See program regulations for nutritional requirements: NSLP, 7 C.F.R. 210.10; SBP, -7 C.F.R. 220.8; CACFP, 7 C.F.R. 226.20; SFSP, 7 C.F.R. 225.16. Recent updates of school meals and CACFP -nutrition standards are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” -18 Per-meal subsidies paid to providers (e.g., schools, child care centers) are indexed annually based on the CPI-U Food -Away from Home Component. For family child care homes, the annual indexing is based on the CPI-U Food at Home -Component. -19 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information, see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -20 See USDA-FNS Food Distribution Division resources for more information on USDA Foods and child nutrition - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -4 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Administrative Expenses,” discussed in the “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities” section) are limited. - -Other Federal Funding - -In addition to the open-ended, appropriated entitlement funds summarized above, the child -nutrition programs’ funding also includes certain other mandatory funding21 and a limited amount -of discretionary funding. Some of the activities discussed in “Related Programs, Initiatives, and -Support Activities,” such as Team Nutrition, are provided for with discretionary funding. - -Aside from the annually appropriated funding, the child nutrition programs are also supported by -certain permanent appropriations and transfers. Notably, funding for the Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable Program is funded by a transfer from USDA’s Section 32 program, a permanent -appropriation of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts. - -State, Local, and Participant Funds - -Federal subsidies do not necessarily cover the full cost of the meals and snacks offered by -providers. States and localities help cover program costs, as do children’s families by paying -charges for non-free or reduced-price meals/snacks. There is a non-federal cost-sharing -requirement for the school meals programs (discussed below), and some states supplement school -funding through additional state per-meal reimbursements or other prescribed financing -arrangements.22 - -Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Subsequent sections of this report delve into the details of how each of the child nutrition -programs support the service of meals and snacks in institutional settings; first, it is useful to take -a broader perspective of primary program elements. Table 1 is a top-level look at the different -programs that displays distinguishing characteristics (what meals are provided, in what settings, -to what ages) and recent program spending. - -Table 1. Child Nutrition Programs at a Glance - -Program - -National School -Lunch Program - -Authorizing -Statute (Year -First -Authorized) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1946) - - - - - -Distinguishing -Characteristics - -FY2017 -Expenditures - -Lunches at school - -$13.6 billion - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -FY2017 -Average Daily -Participation - -Maximum -Daily -Snack/Mealsa - -30.0 million -children - - One meal and -snack per child - -programs, http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/schoolscn-usda-foods-programs. -21 These costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and Technical -Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. See p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional -Budget Justification, available at https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -22 The School Nutrition Association, a trade association representing school meal operators and industry, tracks state -policies and funding on the organization website at https://schoolnutrition.org/LegislationPolicy/ -StateLegislationPolicyReports/. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -5 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -School -Breakfast -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1966) - - - - - - - -Possible to -provide summer -food and -afterschool -snacks. - -Breakfasts at -school (also for -pre-K-12) - -Typically served -in schools, to -pre-K-12 -students, during -the school day -and year - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (child -care centers, day -care homes, adult -day care centers) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - - Meals and snacks -in early childhood -and adult day -care settings - -Child and Adult -Care Food -Program (At- -Risk After-School -snacks and meals)b - -Summer Food -Service -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1994) - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(1968) - -Special Milk -Program - - Child Nutrition -Act (1954) - -Fresh Fruit and -Vegetable -Program - - Richard B. - -Russell National -School Lunch Act -(2002) - - - - - -Rules and funding -differ based on -type of institution - -Supper and -snacks for -school-age -children after- -school - - Meals and snacks -provided during -summer months - - - - - - - - - - - -Sites vary and -include schools, -community -centers, camps, -parks, and others - -Eligibility rules -vary for “open” -and “closed” sites - -Subsidizes milk, -not meals or -snacks - -Institutions -eligible must not -participate in -NSLP or SBP - -Provides free -fresh fruit and -vegetable snacks -to elementary -school students - -$4.3 billion - -14.7 million -children - - Generally one -breakfast per -child, with -some flexibility - -$3.5 billion -(includes at- -risk after- -school -spending, -described -below) - -(Not available; -included in -CACFP total -above) - -$485 million - -4.4 million -children; -132,000 adults - - Two meals and -one snack, or -one meal and -two snacks per -participant - -1.7 million -children -(included in -CACFP -children above) - -2.7 million -childrenc - - One meal and -one snack per -child - -Lunch and -breakfast or -lunch and one -snack per child -Exception: -maximum of -three meals -for camps or -programs that -serve primarily -migrant -children - -$8 million - -191,000 half- -pints served -(average daily)d - - Not specified - -$184e million - - Not available - - Not applicable - -Source: Except where noted, participation and funding data from USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report, which -contains data through March 2018. Participation data are estimated by USDA-FNS based on meals served. -a. These maximums are provided in the authorizing law for CACFP and SFSP, but specified only in regulations - -(7 C.F.R. 210.10(a), 220.9(a)) for NSLP and SBP. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -6 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -b. At-risk after-school snacks and meals are part of CACFP law and CACFP funding, but differ in their rules - -and the age of children served. - -c. Based only on July 2017 participation data. -d. Data from p. 32-58 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -e. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. - -Links to Resources -Other relevant CRS reports in this area include23 - - CRS In Focus IF10266, An Introduction to Child Nutrition Reauthorization - CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs - CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296 - -(summarizes the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010) - - CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An - -Overview - - CRS Report R44588, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2017 Appropriations - CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 - -Program - -Other relevant resources include - - USDA-FNS’s website, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/child-nutrition- - -programs - - USDA-FNS’s Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act page, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ - -school-meals/healthy-hunger-free-kids-act - - The FNS page of the Federal Register, https://www.federalregister.gov/agencies/ - -food-and-nutrition-service - -School Meals Programs -This section discusses the school meals programs: the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) -and the School Breakfast Program (SBP). Principles and concepts common to both programs are -discussed first; subsections then discuss features and data unique to the NSLP and SBP, -respectively. - -General Characteristics - -The federal school meals programs provide federal support in the form of cash assistance and -USDA commodity foods; both are provided according to statutory formulas based on the number -of reimbursable meals served in schools. The subsidized meals are served by both public and -private nonprofit elementary and secondary schools and residential child care institutions -(RCCIs)24 that opt to enroll and guarantee to offer free or reduced-price meals to eligible low- - -23 Archived historical reports that may provide useful background include CRS Report RL33829, Domestic Food -Assistance and the 2008 Farm Bill; and CRS Report RL33299, Child Nutrition and WIC Legislation in the 108th and -109th Congresses. -24 This CRS report refers to “schools,” but it should be understood that—for NSLP and SBP—it means both schools -and RCCIs. NSLP regulations, 7 C.F.R. 210.2, define RCCIs as follows: “The term ‘residential child care institutions’ - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -7 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -income children. Both cash and commodity support to participating schools are calculated based -on the number and price of meals served (e.g., lunch or breakfast, free or full price), but once the -aid is received by the school it is used to support the overall school meal service budget, as -determined by the school. This report focuses on the federal reimbursements and funding, but it -should be noted that some states have provided state financing through additional state-specific -funding.25 - -Federal law does not require schools to participate in the school meals programs. However, some -states have mandated that schools provide lunch and/or breakfast, and some of these states require -that their schools do so through NSLP and/or SBP.26 The program is open to public and private -schools. - -A reimbursable meal requires compliance with federal school nutrition standards, which have -changed throughout the history of the program based on nutritional science and children’s -nutritional needs. Food items not served as a complete meal meeting nutrition standards (e.g., a la -carte offerings) are not reimbursable meals, and therefore are not eligible for federal per-meal, -per-snack reimbursements. Following rulemaking to implement P.L. 111-296 provisions, the -standards for reimbursable meals were updated in January 2012 and USDA also has provided -nutrition standards for the non-meal foods served in schools during the school day (see “Selected -Current Issues” for more on these policies). - -USDA-FNS administers the school meals programs federally, and state agencies (typically state -departments of education) oversee and transmit reimbursements through agreements with school -food authorities (SFAs) (typically local educational agencies (LEAs); usually these are school -districts). Figure 1 provides an overview of the roles and relationships between these levels of -government. - -There is a cost-sharing requirement for the programs, which amounts to a contribution of -approximately $200 million from the states.27 There also are states that choose to supplement -federal reimbursements with their own state reimbursements.28 - -includes, but is not limited to: homes for the mentally, emotionally or physically impaired, and unmarried mothers and -their infants; group homes; halfway houses; orphanages; temporary shelters for abused children and for runaway -children; long-term care facilities for chronically ill children; and juvenile detention centers. A long-term care facility is -a hospital, skilled nursing facility, intermediate care facility, or distinct part thereof, which is intended for the care of -children confined for 30 days or more.” -25 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. -26 Ibid. -27 Section 7(a)(1) of Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1756(a)(1). Section 7(f) of -Child Nutrition Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776(f). -28 See School Nutrition Association, State School Meal Mandates and Reimbursements Report: School Year 2017- -2018, https://schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/Legislation_and_Policy/ -State_and_Local_Legislation_and_Regulations/2017-18-State-School-Meal-Mandates-and-Reimbursements.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -8 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 1. Federal, State, and Local Administration of School Meal Programs - -Source: Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 47. - -School Meals Eligibility Rules - -The school meals programs and related funding do not serve only low-income children. All -students can receive a meal at a NSLP- or SBP-participating school, but how much the child pays -for the meal and/or how much of a federal reimbursement the state receives will depend largely -on whether the child qualifies for a “free,” “reduced-price,” or “paid” (i.e., advertised price) meal. -Both NSLP and SBP use the same household income eligibility criteria and categorical eligibility -rules. States and schools receive the largest reimbursements for free meals, smaller -reimbursements for reduced-price meals, and the smallest (but still some federal financial -support) for the full-price meals. - -There are three pathways through which a child can become certified to receive a free or reduced- -price meal: - -1. Household income eligibility for free and reduced-price meals (information - -typically collected via household application), - -2. Categorical (or automatic) eligibility for free meals (information collected via - -household application or a direct certification process), and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -9 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -3. School-wide free meals under the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an -option for eligible schools that is based on the share of students identified as -eligible for free meals.29 - -Each of these pathways is discussed in more detail below. - -Income Eligibility - -The income eligibility thresholds (shown in Table 2) are based on multipliers of the federal -poverty guidelines. As the poverty guidelines are updated every year, so are the eligibility -thresholds for NSLP and SBP. - - Free Meals: Children receive free meals if they have household income at or -below 130% of the federal poverty guidelines; these meals receive the highest -subsidy rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $3.30 per lunch served, less for -breakfast.) - - Reduced-Price Meals: Children may receive reduced-price meals (charges of no -more than 40 cents for a lunch or 30 cents for a breakfast) if their household -income is above 130% and less than or equal to 185% of the federal poverty -guidelines; these meals receive a subsidy rate that is 40 cents (NSLP) or 30 cents -(SBP) below the free meal rate. (Reimbursements are approximately $2.90 per -lunch served.) - - Paid Meals: A comparatively small per-meal reimbursement is provided for full- -price or paid meals served to children whose families do not apply for assistance -or whose family income does not qualify them for free or reduced-price meals.30 -The paid meal price is set by the school but must comply with federal -regulations.31 (Reimbursements are approximately 30 cents per lunch served.) - -The above reimbursement rates are approximate; exact current-year federal reimbursement rates -for NSLP and SBP are listed in Table B-1 and Table B-3, respectively. - -Households complete paper or online applications that collect relevant income and household size -data, so that the school district can determine if children in the household are eligible for free -meals, reduced-price meals, or neither. - -Though these income guidelines primarily influence funding and administration of NSLP and -SBP, they also affect the eligibility rules for the SFSP, CACFP, and SMP (described further in -subsequent sections). - -29 CEP is not the only way schools may provide universal free meal service, but it is unique in that it does not require -the collection of applications. -30 The subsidy for paid meals is provided under the authority of Section 4 of the Richard B. Russell National School -Lunch Act. Section 4 establishes two different payment levels: one for schools in which less than 60% of the school -population is participating in free or reduced-price lunch and one for schools in which 60% or more of the school -population is receiving free or reduced price lunch. See https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018- -15465/national-school-lunch-special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum for -these reimbursement rates. USDA also establishes a “maximum [reimbursement] rate” intended to ensure that states -distribute federal funding to all participating school food authorities relatively equally. -31 The 2010 reauthorization established a policy intended to assure that paid meal revenues were covering the costs of -producing a meal. See FNS paid lunch equity guidance for SY2018-2019, https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/paid- -lunch-equity-guidance-school-year-2018-19. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -10 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table 2. Income Eligibility Guidelines for a Family of Four for NSLP and SBP -For 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Income Eligibility Threshold - (% of the Federal Poverty Level) - -Annual Income for a -Family of Four - -Free - -Reduced-Price - -<130% - -130-185% - -<$32,630 - -$32,630 - $46,435 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Income Eligibility Guidelines,” 83 -Federal Register 20788, May 8, 2018. -Note: This school year is defined as July 1, 2018, through June 30, 2019. For other years, household sizes, -Alaska, and Hawaii, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/income-eligibility-guidelines. - -Categorical Eligibility - -In addition to the eligibility thresholds listed above, the school meals programs also convey -eligibility for free meals based on household participation in certain other need-tested programs -or children’s specified vulnerabilities (e.g., foster children). Per Section 12 of the National School -Lunch Act, “a child shall be considered automatically eligible for a free lunch and breakfast ... -without further application or eligibility determination, if the child is”32 - - - -in a household receiving benefits through - - SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program); - FDPIR (Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations, a program -that operates in lieu of SNAP on some Indian reservations) benefits; or - - TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) cash assistance; - -enrolled in Head Start; -in foster care; -a migrant; -a runaway; or - - - - - - homeless.33 - -For meals served to students certified in the above categories, the state/school will receive -reimbursement at the free meal amount and children receive a free meal. (See Table B-1 and -Table B-3 for school year 2018-2019 rates.) - -Some school districts collect information for these categorical eligibility rules via paper -application. Others conduct a process called direct certification—a proactive process where - -32 See Section 9(b)(12)(A) of the Russell National School Lunch Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(12)(A), for the -more specific definitions of these categories. -33 SNAP, FDPIR, and TANF have income limits, but the other qualifications, as defined, in the statute, are not limited -by income. In addition to the above list, following specific demonstration authority in HHFKA as well as under FNS’s -standing pilot authority, some states are currently directly certifying children based on Medicaid data. According to -USDA-FNS, 19 states are operating direct certification with Medicaid in SY2018-2019. Four of the states (Illinois, -Kentucky, New York, Pennsylvania) use Medicaid to directly certify for free meals only. Fifteen states (California, -Connecticut, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, -West Virginia, Wisconsin), operating under an expanded direct certification demonstration project to test direct -certification with Medicaid for reduced-price meals (up to 185% of poverty), are using this process for free and -reduced-price meals. Both options are discussed in USDA-FNS, Request for Applications to Participate in -Demonstration Projects to Evaluate Direct Certification with Medicaid, January 27, 2016, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ -sites/default/files/cn/SP23-2016a.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -11 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -government agencies typically cross-check their program rolls and certify a household’s children -for free school meals without the household having to complete a school meals application. - -Prior to 2004, states had the option to conduct direct certification of SNAP (then, the Food Stamp -Program), TANF, and FDPIR participants. In the 2004 child nutrition reauthorization (P.L. 108- -265), states were required under federal law to conduct direct certification for SNAP participants, -with nationwide implementation taking effect in school year 2008-2009. Conducting direct -certification for TANF and FDPIR remains at the state’s discretion. - -The Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296) made further policy changes -to expand direct certification (discussed further in the next section). One of those changes was the -initiation of a demonstration project to look at expanding categorical eligibility and direct -certification to some Medicaid households. The law also funded performance incentive grants for -high-performing states and authorized correcting action planning for low-performing states in -direct certification activities.34 - -Under SNAP direct certification rules generally, schools enter into agreements with SNAP -agencies to certify children in SNAP households as eligible for free school meals without -requiring a separate application from the family. Direct certification systems match student -enrollment lists against SNAP agency records, eliminating the need for action by the child’s -parents or guardians. Direct certification allows schools to make use of SNAP’s more in-depth -eligibility certification process; this can reduce errors that may occur in school lunch application -eligibility procedures that are otherwise used.35 From a program access perspective, direct -certification also reduces the number of applications a household must complete. - -Figure 2, created by GAO and published in a May 2014 report, provides an overview of how -school districts certify students for free and reduced-price meals under the income-based and -category-based rules, via applications and direct certification.36 A USDA-FNS study of school -year 2014-2015 estimates that 11.1 million students receiving free meals were directly certified— -68% of all categorically eligible students receiving free meals.37 - -34 See CRS Report R41354, Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization: P.L. 111-296, for further discussion of these -and related policies. -35 See, for example, U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, -but Additional Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, pp. 16-19, -http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-14-262. -36 U.S. Government Accountability Office, School-Meals Programs: USDA Has Enhanced Controls, but Additional -Verification Could Help Ensure Legitimate Program Access, GAO-14-262, May 2014, http://www.gao.gov/products/ -GAO-14-262. -37 Quinn Moore, Kevin Conway, and Brandon Kyler, et al., Direct Certification in the National School Lunch -Program: State Implementation Progress, School Year 2014-2015, Report to Congress Mathematica Policy Research -for USDA-FNS, CN-15-DC, October 2016, p. 24, https://www.fns.usda.gov/direct-certification-national-school-lunch- -program-report-congress-state-implementation-progress-0 - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -12 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 2. Overview of Certification for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals -Household Application and Direct Certification Pathways - -Source: Figure and figure notes (below) from Government Accountability Office (GAO), GAO-14-262, p. 13. -Note: aStudents who meet an approved designation—(1) homeless, runaway, or migrant; (2) foster child; or -(3) enrolled in a federally funded Head Start Program—are categorically eligible for free school meals. - -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) - -HHFKA also authorized the school meals Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), an option in -NSLP and SBP law that allows eligible schools and school districts to offer free meals to all -enrolled students based on the percentage of their students who are identified as automatically - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -13 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -eligible from non-household application sources (primarily direct certification through other -programs).38 - -Based on the statutory parameters, USDA-FNS piloted CEP in various states over three school -years and it expanded nationwide in school year 2014-2015. Eligible LEAs have until June 30 of -each year to notify USDA-FNS if they will participate in CEP.39 According to a database -maintained by the Food Research and Action Center, just over 20,700 schools in more than 3,500 -school districts (LEAs) participated in CEP in SY2016-2017, an increase of approximately 2,500 -schools compared to SY2015-2016.40 - -For a school (or school district, or group of schools within a district) to provide free meals to all -children: - - - - - -the school(s) must be eligible for CEP based on the share (40% or greater) of -enrolled children that can be identified as categorically (or automatically) eligible -for free meals, and -the school must opt-in to CEP. - -Though CEP schools serve free meals to all students, they are not reimbursed at the “free meal” -rate for every meal. Instead, the law provides a funding formula: the percentage of students -identified as automatically eligible (the “identified student percentage” or ISP) is multiplied by a -factor of 1.6 to estimate the proportion of students who would be eligible for free or reduced- -price meals had they been certified via application.41 The result is the percentage of meals served -that will be reimbursed at the free meal rate, with the remainder reimbursed at the far lower paid -meal rate. For example, if a CEP school identifies that 40% of students are eligible for free meals, -then 64% of the meals served will be reimbursed at the free meal rate and 36% at the paid meal -rate.42 Schools that identify 62.5% or more students as eligible for free meals receive the free -meal reimbursement for all meals served. - -Some of the considerations that may impact a school’s decision to participate in CEP include -whether the new funding formula would be beneficial for their school meal budget; an interest in -reducing paperwork for families and schools; and an interest in providing more free meals, -including meals to students who have not participated in the program before. - -38 Explanation here draws in part from Madeleine Levin and Zoe Neuberger, Improving Direct Certification Will Help -More Low-Income Children Receive School Meals, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities & Food Research and -Action Center, July 25, 2014, p. 3. Aside from CEP, schools may also provide universal free meal service through the -“Provision 2” and “Provision 3” options. CEP is unique in that no school meal applications are required. For -information on other options, see USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/provisions-1-2-and-3. -39 USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating -Applications through Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal -Register 50194, July 29, 2016. -40 FRAC, “Community Eligibility,” available at http://frac.org/community-eligibility. -41 USDA-FNS, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Eliminating Applications Through -Community Eligibility as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 81 Federal Register 50194, July -29, 2016, p. 50201. -42 Though, to the children of community eligibility schools, all meals are free, the USDA-FNS school meals -expenditure data used throughout this report count these meals served in a more nuanced fashion. The percentage -derived through this calculation is used to record those meals that are “free” and those meals that are “paid” (i.e., using -the example from above, USDA-FNS data would reflect 64% of the meals served in the school as a “free” expenditure -and meal served, and 36% as “paid”). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -14 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -National School Lunch Program (NSLP) - -In FY2017, NSLP subsidized 4.9 billion lunches to children in close to 96,000 schools and 3,200 -residential child care institutions (RCCIs). Average daily participation was 30.0 million students -(58% of children enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). Of the participating students, -66.7% (20.0 million) received free lunches and 6.5% (2.0 million) received reduced-price -lunches. The remainder were served full-price meals, though schools still receive a -reimbursement for these meals. Figure 3 shows FY2017 participation data. - -FY2017 federal school lunch costs totaled approximately $13.6 billion (see Table 3 for the -various components of this total). The vast majority of this funding is for per-meal -reimbursements for free and reduced-price lunches. - -Figure 3. National School Lunch Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at NSLP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -HHFKA also provided an additional 6-cent per-lunch reimbursement to schools that provide -meals that meet the updated nutritional guidelines requirements.43 This bonus is not provided for -breakfast, but funds may be used to support schools’ breakfast programs. NSLP lunch -reimbursement rates are listed in Table B-1. - -In addition to federal cash subsidies, schools participating in NSLP receive USDA-acquired -commodity foods. Schools are entitled to a specific, inflation-indexed value of USDA commodity - -43 In January 2014, USDA-FNS issued a final rule implementing the 6-cent reimbursement: USDA-FNS, “Certification -of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids -Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. Note: 6-cent increase authorized is also annually indexed for -inflation. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -15 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -foods for each lunch they serve. Also, schools may receive donations of bonus commodities -acquired by USDA in support of the farm economy.44 In FY2017, the value of federal commodity -food aid to schools totaled nearly $1.4 billion. The per-meal rate for commodity food assistance is -included in Table B-4. - -While the vast majority of NSLP funding is for lunches served during the school day, NSLP may -also be used to support snack service during the school year and to serve meals during the -summer. These features are discussed in subsequent sections, “Summer Meals” and “After-School -Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” Reimbursement rates for snacks are listed in Table -B-2. - -School Breakfast Program (SBP) - -The School Breakfast Program (SBP) provides per-meal cash subsidies for breakfasts served in -schools. Participating schools receive subsidies based on their status as a severe need or non- -severe need institution. Schools can qualify as a severe need school if 40% or more of their -lunches are served free or at reduced prices. See Table B-3 for SBP reimbursement rates. - -Figure 4 displays SBP participation data for FY2017. In that year, SBP subsidized over 2.4 -billion breakfasts in over 88,000 schools and nearly 3,200 RCCIs. Average daily participation was -14.7 million children (30.1% of the students enrolled in participating schools and RCCIs). The -majority of meals served through SBP are free or reduced-price. Of the participating students, -79.1% (11.6 million) received free meals and 5.7% (835,000) purchased reduced-price meals. -Federal school breakfast costs for the fiscal year totaled approximately $4.3 billion (see Table 3 -for the various components of this total). - -Significantly fewer schools and students participate in SBP than in NSLP. Participation in SBP -tends to be lower for several reasons, including the traditionally required early arrival by students -in order to receive a meal and eat before school starts. Some schools offer (and anti-hunger -groups have encouraged) models of breakfast service that can result in greater SBP participation, -such as Breakfast in the Classroom, where meals are delivered in the classroom; “grab and go” -carts, where students receive a bagged breakfast that they bring to class, or serving breakfast later -in the day in middle and high schools.45 - -Unlike NSLP, commodity food assistance is not a formal part of SBP funding; however, -commodities provided through NSLP may be used for school breakfasts as well. - -44 USDA commodity foods are foods purchased by the USDA for distribution to USDA nutrition programs. These -programs distribute “entitlement commodities” (an amount of USDA foods to which grantees are entitled by law) as -well as “bonus commodities” (USDA food purchases based on requests from the agricultural producer community). For -more information see CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: Summary of Programs. -45 See Food Research and Action Center (FRAC), “School Breakfast Expansion Strategies,” http://www.frac.org/ -programs/school-breakfast-program/school-breakfast-expansion-strategies (Accessed July 9, 2018). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -16 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Figure 4. School Breakfast Program, FY2017 Participation -Participation among children at SBP-participating schools - -Source: Figure created by CRS based on FY2017 data from the USDA-FNS Keydata May 2018 report. -Notes: Numbers may not add due to rounding. To reflect participation for the actual school year (September -through May), these estimates are based on nine-month averages of October through May plus September, -rather than averages of the 12 months of the fiscal year (October through September). Participation data are -estimated by USDA-FNS based on average daily meals served. Children in schools participating in the -Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) are counted in the free and paid meal categories. - -Other Child Nutrition Programs -In addition to the school meals programs discussed above, other federal child nutrition programs -provide federal subsidies and commodity food assistance for schools and other institutions that -offer meals and snacks to children in early childhood, summer, and after-school settings. This -assistance is provided to (1) schools and other governmental institutions, (2) private for-profit and -nonprofit child care centers, (3) family/group day care homes, and (4) nongovernmental -institutions/organizations that offer outside-of-school programs for children. (Although this report -focuses on the programs that serve children, one child nutrition program [CACFP] also serves -day care centers for chronically impaired adults and elderly persons under the same general per- -meal/snack subsidy terms.) The programs in the sections to follow serve comparatively fewer -children and spend comparatively fewer federal funds than the school meal programs. - -Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP) - -CACFP subsidizes meals and snacks served in early childhood, day care, and after-school -settings. CACFP provides subsidies for meals and snacks served at participating non-residential -child care centers, family day care homes, and (to a lesser extent) adult day care centers.46 The -program also provides assistance for meals served at after-school programs. CACFP -reimbursements are available for meals and snacks served to children age 12 or under, migrant - -46 CACFP also supports meals in homeless/emergency shelters. See http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/emergency-shelters -for further information. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -17 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -children age 15 or under, children with disabilities of any age, and, in the case of adult care -centers, chronically impaired and elderly adults. Children in early childhood settings are the -overwhelming majority of those served by the program. - -CACFP provides federal reimbursements for breakfasts, lunches, suppers, and snacks served in -participating centers (facilities or institutions) or day care homes (private homes). The eligibility -and funding rules for CACFP meals and snacks depend first on whether the participating -institution is a center or a day care home (the next two sections discuss the rules specific to -centers and day care homes). According to FY2017 CACFP data, child care centers have an -average daily attendance of about 56 children per center, day care homes have an average daily -attendance of approximately 7 children per home, and adult day care centers typically care for an -average of 48 chronically ill or elderly adults per center.47 - -Subsidized CACFP meals and snacks must meet program-specific federal nutrition standards, and -providers must demonstrate that they comply with government-established standards for other -child care programs. Like in school meals, federal assistance is made up overwhelmingly of cash -reimbursements calculated based on the number of meals/snacks served and federal per- -meal/snack reimbursements rates, but a far smaller share of federal aid (4.3% in FY2017) is in the -form of federal USDA commodity foods (or cash in lieu of foods). Federal CACFP -reimbursements flow to individual providers either directly from the administering state agency -(this is the case with many child/adult care centers able to handle their own CACFP -administrative functions) or through “sponsors” who oversee and provide administrative support -for a number of local providers (this is the case with some child/adult care centers and with all -day care homes).48 - -In FY2017, total CACFP spending was over $3.5 billion, including cash reimbursement, -commodity food assistance, and costs for sponsor audits. (See Table 3 for a further breakdown of -CACFP costs.) This total also includes the after-school meals and snacks provided through -CACFP’s “at-risk after-school” pathway; this aspect of the program is discussed later in “After- -School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options.” - -CACFP at Centers - -Participation - -Child care centers in CACFP can be (1) public or private nonprofit centers, (2) Head Start -centers, (3) for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet certain requirements as to the proportion of -low-income children they enroll), and (4) shelters for homeless families. Adult day care centers -include public or private nonprofit centers and for-profit proprietary centers (if they meet -minimum requirements related to serving low-income disabled and elderly adults).49 In FY2017, -over 65,000 child care centers with an average daily attendance of over 3.6 million children -participated in CACFP. Over 2,700 adult care centers served nearly 132,000 adults through -CACFP. - -47 USDA-FNS’ administrative data on the CACFP are the source of these attendance numbers. -48 In many cases, sponsor organizations that provide administrative support to multiple providers also are paid federal -reimbursements for their costs. Day care homes must have a sponsoring organization, while child care centers may -have a sponsor but are not required to do so. -49 Participating adult care programs “should be structured, comprehensive and provide health and social support -services to enrolled participants. Centers that simply provide social or rehabilitative services to adults do not qualify to -participate in CACFP.” http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/facts-about-adult-component-cacfp. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -18 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Eligibility and Administration - -Participating centers may receive daily reimbursements for up to either two meals and one snack -or one meal and two snacks for each participant, so long as the meals and snacks meet federal -nutrition standards. - -The eligibility rules for CACFP centers largely track those of NSLP: children in households at or -below 130% of the current poverty line qualify for free meals/snacks while those between 130% -and 185% of poverty qualify for reduced-price meals/snacks (see Table 2). In addition, -participation in the same categorical eligibility programs as NSLP as well as foster child status -convey eligibility for free meals in CACFP.50 Like school meals, eligibility is determined through -paper applications or direct certification processes. - -Like school meals, all meals and snacks served in the centers are federally subsidized to some -degree, even those that are paid. Different reimbursement amounts are provided for breakfasts, -lunches/suppers, and snacks, and reimbursement rates are set in law and indexed for inflation -annually. The largest subsidies are paid for meals and snacks served to participants with family -income below 130% of the federal poverty income guidelines (the income limit for free school -meals), and the smallest to those who have not met a means test. See Table B-5 for current -CACFP center reimbursement rates. - -Unlike school meals, CACFP institutions are less likely to collect per-meal payments. Although -federal assistance for day care centers differentiates by household income, centers have discretion -on their pricing of meals. Centers may adjust their regular fees (tuition) to account for federal -payments, but CACFP itself does not regulate these fees. In addition, centers can charge families -separately for meals/snacks, so long as there are no charges for children meeting free-meal/snack -income tests and limited charges for those meeting reduced-price income tests. - -Independent centers are those without sponsors handling administrative responsibilities. These -centers must pay for administrative costs associated with CACFP out of non-federal funds or a -portion of their meal subsidy payments. For centers with sponsors, the sponsors may retain a -proportion of the meal reimbursement payments they receive on behalf of their centers to cover -such costs. - -CACFP for Day Care Homes - -Participation - -CACFP-supported day care homes serve a smaller number of children than CACFP-supported -centers, both in terms of the total number of children served and the average number of children -per facility. Roughly 17% of children in CACFP (approximately 757,000 in FY2017 average -daily attendance) are served through day care homes. In FY2017, approximately 103,000 homes -(with just over 700 sponsors) received CACFP support. - -Eligibility and Reimbursement - -As with centers, payments to day care homes are provided for up to either two meals and one -snack or one meal and two snacks a day for each child. Unlike centers, day care homes must -participate under the auspices of a public or, more often, private nonprofit sponsor that typically - -50 See also summary of CACFP eligibility rules at USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/why-cacfp- -important. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -19 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -has 100 or more homes under its supervision. CACFP day care home sponsors receive monthly -administrative payments based on the number of homes for which they are responsible.51 - -Federal reimbursements for family day care homes differ by the home’s status as “Tier I” or “Tier -II.” Unlike centers, day care homes receive cash reimbursements (but not commodity foods) that -generally are not based on the child participants’ household income. Instead, there are two -distinct, annually indexed reimbursement rates that are based on area or operator eligibility -criteria: - - Tier I homes are located in low-income areas (defined as areas in which at least - -50% of school-age and enrolled children qualify for free or reduced-price meals) -or operated by low-income providers whose household income meets the free or -reduced-price income standards.52 They receive higher subsidies for each -meal/snack they serve. - - Tier II (lower) rates are by default those for homes that do not qualify for Tier I -rates; however, Tier II providers may seek the higher Tier I subsidy rates for -individual low-income children for whom financial information is collected and -verified. (See Table B-6 for current Tier I and Tier II reimbursement rates.) - -Additionally, HHFKA introduced a number of additional ways (as compared to prior law) by -which family day care homes can qualify as low-income and get Tier I rates for the entire home -or for individual children.53 - -As with centers, there is no requirement that meals/snacks specifically identified as free or -reduced-price be offered; however, unlike centers, federal rules prohibit any separate meal -charges. - -Summer Meals - -Current law SFSP and the NSLP/SBP Seamless Summer Option provide meals in congregate -settings nationwide; the related Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer (SEBTC or Summer EBT) -demonstration project is an alternative to congregate settings. The demonstration is discussed -below; proposals to expand the demonstration are discussed in “Selected Current Issues.” - -51 As an example of the role that sponsors and homes play in CACFP, in Allentown, Pennsylvania, the Lehigh Valley -Children’s Centers (LVCC) serves as a sponsor for child care homes in the area. They offer a variety of administrative -services to family child care homes that are registered with the state. In their brochure, they state that it is LVCC’s -responsibility to “monitor meals and reimburse [homes] for meals served,” and it is homes’ responsibility “to plan -nutritional menus that meet meal requirements, maintain and submit daily attendance records and monthly meal -counts.” See http://www.lvcconline.org/images/pdf/CACFP-Brochure.pdf. -52 7 C.F.R. §226.2. -53 Previously, child care homes could only use data from the elementary school level to establish the area as low- -income. The new law allows these homes to use data from the middle and high school level as well to establish need -and qualify as a “Tier I” home. Also, P.L. 111-296 included policies to streamline application processes and eliminate -some paperwork. As part of this process, the annual application process has been eliminated and sponsors and child -care centers will only have to submit paperwork the first time they apply, with amendments submitted as necessary. -Finally, P.L. 111-296 increased CACFP sponsoring organizations’ and providers’ flexibility over administrative funds, -including the option to carry over up to 10% of administrative funds from one fiscal year to the next. USDA-FNS has -begun to implement these changes. See, for example, USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Amendments Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 77 Federal Register 21018-21038, -April 9, 2012; USDA-FNS Memorandum, Child Nutrition Reauthorization 2010: Area Eligibility for Family Day Care -Homes, Memo Code: CACFP 05-2011-Revised, January 10, 2011, https://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp-05-2011-revised- -child-nutrition-reauthorization-2010-area-eligibility-family-day-care-homes. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -20 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) - -SFSP supports meals for children during the summer months. The program provides assistance to -local public institutions and private nonprofit service institutions running summer -youth/recreation programs, summer feeding projects, and camps. Assistance is primarily in the -form of cash reimbursements for each meal or snack served; however, federally donated -commodity foods are also offered. Participating service institutions are often entities that provide -ongoing year-round service to the community including schools, local governments, camps, -colleges and universities in the National Youth Sports program, and private nonprofit -organizations like churches. - -Similar to the CACFP model, sponsors are institutions that manage the food preparation, -financial, and administrative responsibilities of SFSP. Sites are the places where food is served -and eaten. At times, a sponsor may also be a site. State agencies authorize sponsors, monitor and -inspect sponsors and sites, and implement USDA policy. Unlike CACFP, sponsors are required -for an institution’s participation in SFSP as a site. - -Participation - -In FY2017, nearly 5,500 sponsors with 50,000 food service sites participated in the SFSP and -served an average of approximately 2.7 million children daily (according to July data).54 - -Participation of sites and children in SFSP has increased in recent years. Program costs for -FY2017 totaled over $485 million, including cash assistance, commodity foods, administrative -cost assistance, and health inspection costs. - -Eligibility and Administration - -There are several options for eligibility and meal/snack service for SFSP sponsors (and their -sites): - - Open sites provide summer food to all children in the community. These sites are -certified based on area eligibility measures, where 50% or more of area children -have family income that would make them eligible for free or reduced-price -school meals (see Table 2). - - Closed or Enrolled sites provide summer meals/snacks free to all children - -enrolled at the site. The eligibility test for these sites is that 50% or more of the -children enrolled in the sponsor’s program must be eligible for free or reduced- -price school meals based on household income. Closed/enrolled sites may also -become eligible based on area eligibility measures noted above. - - Summer camps (that are not enrolled sites) receive subsidies only for those -children with household eligibility for free or reduced-price school meals. - Other programs specified in law, such as the National Youth Sports Program - -and centers for homeless or migrant children. - -54 According to a May 2018 GAO report, estimates of participation in SFSP may not be reliable because they have been -calculated inconsistently across states and years. See U.S. Government Accountability Office, Actions Needed to -Improve Participation Estimates and Address Program Challenges, GAO-18-369, May 2018, https://www.gao.gov/ -products/GAO-18-369. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -21 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Summer sponsors get operating cost (food, storage, labor) subsidies for all meals/snacks they -serve—up to one meal and one snack, or two meals per child per day.55 In addition, sponsors -receive payments for administrative costs, and states are provided with subsidies for -administrative costs and health and meal-quality inspections. See Table B-7 for current SFSP -reimbursement rates. Actual payments vary slightly (e.g., by about 5 cents for lunches) depending -on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared on-site or by a -vendor. - -School Meals’ Seamless Summer Option56 - -Although SFSP is the child nutrition program most associated with providing meals during -summer months, it is not the only program option for providing these meals and snacks. The -Seamless Summer Option, run through NSLP or SBP programs, is also a means through which -food can be provided to students during summer months. Much like SFSP, Seamless Summer -operates in summer sites (summer camps, sports programs, churches, private nonprofit -organizations, etc.) and for a similar duration of time. Unlike SFSP, schools are the only eligible -sponsors, although schools may operate the program at other sites. Reimbursement rates for -Seamless Summer meals are the same as current NSLP/SBP rates. - -Summer EBT for Children Demonstration - -Beginning in summer 2011 and (as of the date of this report) each summer since, USDA-FNS has -operated Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children (SEBTC or “Summer EBT”) -demonstration projects in a limited number of states and Indian Tribal Organizations (ITOs). -These Summer EBT projects provide electronic food benefits over summer months to households -with children eligible for free or reduced-price school meals. Depending on the site and year, -either $30 or $60 per month is provided, through a WIC or SNAP EBT card model. In the -demonstration projects, these benefits were provided as a supplement to the Summer Food -Service Program (SFSP) meals available in congregate settings. - -Summer EBT and other alternatives to congregate meals through SFSP were first authorized and -funded by the FY2010 appropriations law (P.L. 111-80). Although a number of alternatives were -tested and evaluated, findings from Summer EBT were among the most promising, and Congress -provided subsequent funding.57 Summer EBT evaluations (discussed later in “Alternatives to -“Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals”) showed significant impacts on reducing child food -insecurity and improving nutritional intake.58 Summer EBT was funded by P.L. 111-80 in the -summers from 2011 to 2014. Projects have continued to operate and were annually funded by -FY2015-FY2018 appropriations; most recently, the FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million. According to USDA-FNS, in summer 2016 Summer EBT served over - -55 With state agency approval, camps and migrant sites (sites that predominantly serve children of migrant workers) -may be reimbursed for serving three meals or two meals and one snack per child daily. -56 For further discussion, see the USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/opportunity-schools. -57 This CRS report discusses Summer EBT, not the other tested programs (“Enhanced Summer Food Service Program -(eSFSP). For information on eSFSP, see USDA-FNS’ “Enhanced Summer Food Service Program” webpage, -https://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/enhanced-summer-food-service-program-esfsp. -58 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus (Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013), p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -22 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -209,000 children in nine states and two tribal nations—an increase from the 11,400 children -served when the demonstration began in summer 2011.59 - -Special Milk Program (SMP) - -Schools (and institutions like summer camps and child care facilities) that are not already -participating in the other child nutrition programs can participate in the Special Milk Program. -Schools may also administer SMP for their part-day sessions for kindergartners or pre- -kindergartners. - -Under SMP, participating institutions provide milk to children for free and/or at a subsidized paid -price, depending on how the enrolled institution opts to administer the program (see Table B-8 -for current Special Milk reimbursement rates for each of these options): - - An institution that only sells milk will receive the same per-half pint federal - -reimbursement for each milk sold (approximately 20 cents). - - An institution that sells milk and provides free milk to eligible children (income - -eligibility is the same as free school meals, see Table 2), receives a -reimbursement for the milk sold (approximately 20 cents) and a higher -reimbursement for the free milks. - - An institution that does not sell milk provides milk free to all children and - -receives the same reimbursement for all milk (approximately 20 cents). This -option is sometimes called non-pricing. - -In FY2017, over 41 million half-pints were subsidized, 9.5% of which were served free. Federal -expenditures for this program were approximately $8.3 million in FY2017. - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program (FFVP) - -States receive formula grants through the Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program, under which state- -selected schools receive funds to purchase and distribute fresh fruit and vegetable snacks to all -children in attendance (regardless of family income). Money is distributed by a formula under -which about half the funding is distributed equally to each state and the remainder is allocated by -state population. States select participating schools (with an emphasis on those with a higher -proportion of low-income children) and set annual per-student grant amounts (between $50 and -$75). - -Funding is set by law at $150 million for school year 2011-2012 and inflation-indexed for every -year after. In FY2017, states used approximately $184 million in FFVP funds.60 FFVP is funded -by a mandatory transfer of funds from USDA’s Section 32 program—a permanent appropriation -of 30% of the previous year’s customs receipts.61 This transfer is required by FFVP’s authorizing -laws (Section 19 of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act and Section 4304 of P.L. -110-246). Up until FY2018’s law, annual appropriations laws delayed a portion of the funds to -the next fiscal year. - -59 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32- -40https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -60 FY2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, p. 32-14, -https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -61 For more information, see CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -23 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In recent years, FFVP has been amended by omnibus farm bill laws rather than through child -nutrition reauthorizations. After a limited pilot, FFVP was expanded to all states and permanently -funded by the 2008 farm bill (P.L. 110-246).62 The 2014 farm bill (P.L. 113-79) essentially made -no changes to this program but did include, and fund at $5 million in FY2014, a pilot project that -requires USDA to test offering frozen, dried, and canned fruits and vegetables and publish an -evaluation of the pilot. Four states (Alaska, Delaware, Kansas, and Maine) participated in the -pilot in SY2014-2015 and the evaluation was published in 2017.63 Other proposals to expand -fruits and vegetables offered in FFVP have been introduced in both the 114th and 115th -Congress.64 - -Other Topics - -After-School Meals and Snacks: CACFP, NSLP Options - -Two of the child nutrition programs discussed in previous sections, the National School Lunch -Program (NSLP) and Child and Adult Care Food Program (CACFP), provide federal support for -snacks and meals served during after-school programs.65 - -NSLP provides reimbursements for after-school snacks; however, this option is open only to -schools that already participate in NSLP. These schools may operate after-school snack-only -programs during the school year, and can do so in two ways: (1) if low-income area eligibility -criteria are met, provide free snacks in lower-income areas; or (2) if area eligibility criteria are not -met, offer free, reduced-price, or fully paid-for snacks, based on household income eligibility -(like lunches in NSLP). The vast majority of snacks provided through this program are through -the first option. Through this program, approximately 206 million snacks were served in FY2017 -(a daily average of nearly 1.3 million). This compares with nearly 4.9 billion lunches served (a -daily average of 27.8 million). - -CACFP provides assistance for after-school food in two ways. First, centers and homes that -participate in CACFP and provide after-school care may participate in traditional CACFP (the -eligibility and administration described earlier). Second, centers in areas where at least half the -children in the community are eligible for free or reduced-price school meals can opt to -participate in the CACFP At-Risk Afterschool program, which provides free snacks and suppers. -Expansion of the At-Risk After-School meals program was a major policy change included in -HHFKA. Prior to the law, 13 states were permitted to offer CACFP At-Risk After-School meals -(instead of just a snack); the law allowed all CACFP state agencies to offer such meals.66 In - -62 Permanent funding is made possible through the Section 32 account. See CRS Report RL34081, Farm and Food -Support Under USDA’s Section 32 Program, coordinated by Jim Monke. -63 Briefel et al., Evaluation of the Pilot Project for Canned, Frozen, or Dried Fruits and Vegetables in the Fresh Fruit -and Vegetable Program (FFVP-CFD), Prepared by Mathematica Policy Research. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, January 2017, available at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/ops/FFVP-CFD.pdf. -64 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. In the 115th Congress, -see H.R. 3402, S. 2064, and House-passed H.R. 2 §4204. -65 For further discussion of the NSLP and CACFP after-school snack program, see Joanne Guthrie, Feeding Children -After School: The Expanding Role of USDA Child Nutrition Programs, USDA Economic Research Service, Amber -Waves, March 1, 2012, https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2012/march/feeding-children-after-school/. -66 S.Rept. 111-178, p. 7. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -24 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -FY2017, the At-Risk Afterschool program served a total of approximately 242.6 million free -meals and snacks to a daily average of more than 1.7 million children.67 - -Table 3. FY2016 and FY2017 Federal Expenditures on Child Nutrition Programs - -In millions of dollars - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -National School Lunch Program - -$13,569 - -$13,643 - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -additional funding to schools with -more than 60% free or reduced- -price participation - -performance-based meal -reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -School Breakfast Program - -free meal reimbursements - -reduced-price meal reimbursements - -paid meal reimbursements - -Child and Adult Care Food -Program - -meal reimbursements at child care -centers - -meal reimbursements at child care -homes - -meal reimbursements at adult day -care centers - -commodity food assistancea - -administrative costs for child care -sponsors - -Summer Food Service Program - -meal reimbursements - -commodity food assistancea - -sponsor and inspection costs - -Special Milk Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable -Programb - -State Administrative Expenses - -$9,593 - -$808 - -$1,478 - -$9,620 - -$783 - -$1,480 - -+$74 - -+$27 - --$25 - -+$2 - -+1% - -0% - --3% - -0% - -$76 - -$74 - --$2 - --3% - -$302 - -$293 - --$9 - --3% - -$1,311 - -$4,213 - -$3,868 - -$239 - -$106 - -$1,393 - -$4,252 - -$3,912 - -$235 - -$106 - -+$82 - -+$39 - -+$44 - --$4 - -$0 - -+6% - -+1% - -+1% - --2% - -0% - -$3,520 - -$3,537 - -+$17 - -0% - -$2,307 - -$2,363 - -+$56 - -+2% - -$764 - -$149 - -$155 - -$146 - -$478 - -$419 - -$2 - -$58 - -$9 - -$167 - -$260 - -$721 - --$42 - --6% - -$156 - -$153 - -$145 - -$485 - -$424 - -$2 - -$60 - -$8 - -+$7 - -+5% - --$2 - --$1 - -+$7 - -+$5 - -$0 - -+$2 - --$1 - --1% - --1% - -+1% - -+1% - -0% - -+3% - --11% - -$184 - -+$17 - -+10% - -$279 - -+$19 - -+7% - -67 Data provided by USDA-FNS on July 18, 2018. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -25 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Program or Program -Component - -FY2016 - -FY2017 - -Change from -FY2016 to FY2017 - -Mandatory Other Program -Costsc - -Discretionary Activitiesd - -TOTAL OF FUNDS -DISPLAYEDe - -$59 - -$69 - -$83 - -$63 - -+$24 - -+41% - --$6 - --9% - -$22,344 - -$22,534 - -+$192 - -+1% - -Source: Program expenditures data (outlays) from USDA-FNS Keydata Reports (dated March 2017 and March -2018), except where noted below. -Notes: Expenditures displayed here will vary from displays in CRS appropriations reports and in some cases the -USDA-FNS annual budget justification. Since the majority of program funding is for open-ended entitlements, -expenditure data capture spending better than the total of appropriations. This table includes some functions that are -funded through permanent appropriations or transfers (i.e., funding not provided in appropriations laws). Due to -rounding to the nearest million, percentage increases or decreases may be exaggerated or understated. - -a. Amounts included in this table for commodity food assistance include only entitlement commodities for - -each program, not bonus commodities. - -b. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-14 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. -c. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs are made up of Food Safety Education, Coordinated Review, Computer Support, Training and -Technical Assistance, studies, payment accuracy, and Farm to School Team. - -d. Obligations data displayed on p. 32-12 of FY2019 USDA-FNS Congressional Budget Justification. These -costs include Team Nutrition, the Summer EBT demonstration, and School Meal Equipment Grants. -e. This table summarizes the vast majority of child nutrition programs’ federal spending but does not capture - -all federal costs. - -Related Programs, Initiatives, and Support Activities - -Federal child nutrition laws authorize and program funding supports a range of additional -programs, initiatives, and activities.68 - -Through State Administrative Expenses funding, states are entitled to federal grants to help -cover administrative and oversight/monitoring costs associated with child nutrition programs. The -national amount each year is equal to about 2% of child nutrition reimbursements. The majority -of this money is allocated to states based on their share of spending on the covered programs; -about 15% is allocated under a discretionary formula granting each state additional amounts for -CACFP, commodity distribution, and Administrative Review efforts. In addition, states receive -payments for their role in overseeing summer programs (about 2.5% of their summer program -aid). States are free to apportion their federal administrative expense payments among child -nutrition initiatives (including commodity distribution activities) as they see fit, and appropriated -funding is available to states for two years. State Administrative Expense spending in FY2017 -totaled approximately $279 million.69 - -Team Nutrition is a USDA-FNS program that includes a variety of school meals initiatives -around nutrition education and the nutritional content of the foods children eat in schools. This - -68 This section does not list all related federal funding and support activities; those activities that are discussed are -broadly summarized. For further details on these and other functions funded by the “child nutrition programs” account, -see the 2019 USDA Budget Explanatory Notes for Committee on Appropriations for USDA-FNS, pp. 32-10 through -32-26, https://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2019notes.pdf. -69 For the formula for administrative and oversight/monitoring costs, see Section 7 of the Child Nutrition Act of 1966 -(codified at 42 U.S.C. 1776). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -26 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -includes Team Nutrition Training Grants, which provide funding to state agencies for training and -technical assistance, such as help implementing USDA’s nutrition requirements and the Dietary -Guidelines for Americans. From 2004 to 2018, Team Nutrition also included the HealthierUS -Schools Challenge (HUSSC), which originated in the 2004 reauthorization of the Child Nutrition -Act. HUSSC was a voluntary certification initiative designed to recognize schools that have -created a healthy school environment through the promotion of nutrition and physical activity.70 - -Farm-to-school programs broadly refer to “efforts that bring regionally and locally produced -foods into school cafeterias,” with a focus on enhancing child nutrition.71 The goals of these -efforts include increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among students, supporting local -farmers and rural communities, and providing nutrition and agriculture education to school -districts and farmers. HHFKA amended existing child nutrition programs to establish mandatory -funding of $5 million per year for competitive farm-to-school grants that support schools and -nonprofit entities in establishing farm-to-school programs that improve a school’s access to -locally produced foods.72 The FY2018 appropriations law provided an additional $5 million in -discretionary funding to remain available until expended.73 Grants may be used for training, -supporting operations, planning, purchasing equipment, developing school gardens, developing -partnerships, and implementing farm-to-school programs. USDA’s Office of Community Food -Systems provides additional resources on farm-to-school issues.74 - -Through an Administrative Review process (formerly referred to as Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE)), USDA-FNS, in cooperation with state agencies, conducts periodic on-site NSLP school -compliance and accountability evaluations to improve management and identify administrative, -subsidy claim, and meal quality problems.75 State agencies are required to conduct administrative -reviews of all school food authorities (SFAs) that operate the NSLP under their jurisdiction at -least once during a three-year review cycle.76 Federal Administrative Review expenditures were -approximately $9.9 million in FY2017. - -USDA-FNS and state agencies conduct many other child nutrition program support activities for -which dedicated funding is provided. Among other examples, there is the Institute of Child -Nutrition (ICN), which provides technical assistance, instruction, and materials related to -nutrition and food service management; it receives $5 million a year in mandatory funding -appropriated in statute. ICN is located at the University of Mississippi. USDA-FNS provides -training on food safety education. Funding is also provided for USDA-FNS to conduct studies, -provide training and technical assistance, and oversee payment accuracy. - -70 See USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/hussc/healthierus-school-challenge-smarter-lunchrooms. -71 USDA, The Farm to School Program—2012-2015: Four Years in Review, p. 3. https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/f2s/Farm-to-School-at-USDA—4-Years-in-Review.pdf. -72 HHFKA, Section 243 (Access to Local Foods: Farm to School Program), amending §18 of the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(j)). In addition, appropriations are authorized “such sums as are necessary -for each of fiscal years 2011 through 2015.” -73 See Section 763 of P.L. 115-141. -74 See USDA-FNS’s Office of Community Food Systems: http://www.fns.usda.gov/farmtoschool/farm-school. -75 Text in this paragraph is adapted from the USDA-FNS, National School Lunch Program: Coordinated Review Effort -(CRE), FNS-640 Data Report, January 2014. -76 HHFKA increased the frequency of administrative reviews from once every five years to once every three years. See -final rule at USDA Food and Nutrition Service, “Administrative Reviews in the School Nutrition Programs,” 81 -Federal Register 50170, July 29, 2016. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -27 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Selected Current Issues -This section provides further information on current issues in the child nutrition programs. In -particular, it provides background on (1) USDA regulations updating various nutrition standards -in the child nutrition programs, (2) current and proposed alternatives to the “congregate feeding -requirement” in summer meals, and (3) recent changes and proposals aimed at addressing “lunch -shaming” and unpaid meal costs. - -Regulations on Nutrition Standards - -Since the enactment of the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA; P.L. 111-296), -USDA-FNS has promulgated multiple regulations, formulated various program guidance, and -published many other policy documents and reports. Three of the major changes authorized by -the 2010 law relate to program nutrition standards: (1) requiring an update to the nutrition -standards for NSLP and SBP meals, (2) giving USDA the authority to regulate other foods sold in -schools (e.g., through vending machines and cafeterias’ a la carte lines) and requiring the agency -to issue related nutrition standards, and (3) requiring an update to the nutrition standards in -CACFP. The new nutrition standards were championed by First Lady Michelle Obama through -her “Let’s Move” initiative, among other groups.77 - -Updated Nutrition Standards for Lunch and Breakfast - -Section 201 of HHFKA (P.L. 111-296) established a timeframe for USDA to promulgate -regulations updating meal patterns and nutrition standards for school meal programs based on -recommendations from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) (now the Health and Medicine Division) -at the National Academy of Sciences.78 Schools meeting the new requirements are eligible for the -increased federal subsidies (6 cents per lunch) noted above. The law also provided funding for -technical assistance to help implement new meal patterns and nutrition standards. - -Ultimately, following a proposed rule, comments submitted, and policy provisions enacted in the -2012 appropriations law,79 USDA-FNS issued a final rule on January 26, 2012.80 The final rule -sought to align school meal patterns with the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and called -for increased availability of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat or fat-free milk in school -cafeterias—generally consistent with IOM’s recommendations. The regulations also included -calorie maximums (whereas prior guidelines had only calorie minimums) and sodium limits to -phase in over time, among other requirements.81 - -77 See, for example, Nia-Malika Henderson, “President Obama signs child nutrition bill, a priority for first lady,” -Washington Post, December 13, 2010, pp. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/13/ -AR2010121302407.html; archived White House website, “Let’s Move, Healthy Schools,” -https://letsmove.obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/healthy-schools. -78 The 2010 law added a deadline, but it was the 2004 reauthorization (P.L. 108-265) that required USDA to update the -standards based on National Academy of Sciences recommendations. IOM’s report, issued in 2010, had made a number -of recommendations around such topics as imposing calorie limits, increasing fruit and vegetables, and reducing -sodium intake. IOM, School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children, Washington, DC, 2010. -79 See Section 743 of P.L. 112-55. Also discussed in CRS Report R41964, Agriculture and Related Agencies: FY2012 -Appropriations, coordinated by Jim Monke. -80 For the final rule and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/nutrition- -standards-school-meals. -81 When originally issued, the rule and USDA-FNS policy also required certain weekly maximums on grains and - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -28 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Although the rule was finalized in January 2012, all aspects of the rule were not to be -implemented immediately; for instance, some aspects of the new guidelines went into effect for -school year 2014-2015, even though the rule went into effect in school year 2012-2013.82 Three -aspects of the new regulations that went into effect in SY2014-2015 were: all grains served must -be whole-grain-rich,83 new fruit requirements for breakfast, and the first of three sodium limits or -“targets” for breakfasts and lunches (referred to as “Target 1”).84 - -As some schools have had difficulty implementing the new guidelines, Congress and the USDA -have implemented some changes or waivers regarding the 2012 final rule’s whole grain, sodium, -and milk requirements. FY2015, FY2016, and FY2017 appropriations laws (P.L. 113-235, P.L. -114-113, P.L. 115-31, respectively) included policies that affect the implementation of the -guidelines. As of the date of this report, schools are following policies set in an interim final rule -published November 30, 2017.85 - -Specifically, FY2015 and FY2016 appropriations laws (1) required USDA to allow states to -exempt school food authorities that meet hardship requirements from the 100% whole grain -requirement86 and (2) prevented USDA from implementing a reduction in sodium scheduled to -take effect in school year 2017-2018 until “the latest scientific research establishes the reduction -is beneficial for children.” The enacted FY2017 appropriation (§747 of P.L. 115-31) contained -related policy provisions. It extended the whole grain exemptions through SY2017-2018 and -(using different language from past years) limited enforcement of sodium limits to Target 1 -levels. In addition, a new appropriations provision was added in the FY2017 law that required -USDA to allow states to grant special exemptions to serve flavored, low-fat milk (instead of only -fat-free, flavored). - -In May 2017, shortly before the enactment of the FY2017 appropriations law (P.L. 115-31), -Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue announced plans to amend the whole grain, sodium, and -dairy aspects of the nutrition standards regulations in ways that were similar to the FY2017 law’s -provisions.87 In November 2017, USDA-FNS issued the interim final rule, which generally -extends through SY2018-2019 the three changes established by FY2017 appropriations. -Specifically, the interim final rule - -protein. School nutrition stakeholders expressed challenges with menu planning due to these particular restrictions, -USDA-FNS issued policy guidance that gave flexibility on these maximums for school years 2012-2013 and 2013- -2014. Then, in a subsequent regulation, USDA-FNS revised the regulations in January 2014 to lift these restrictions. -See, for example, USDA-FNS, “Certification of Compliance With Meal Requirements for the National School Lunch -Program Under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010,” 79 Federal Register 326, January 3, 2014. -82 See USDA-FNS Implementation Timeline, http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/implementation_timeline.pdf, -based on regulations. -83 “Whole grain-rich products must contain at least 51 percent whole grains and the remaining grains in the product -must be enriched.” 7 C.F.R. 210.10(c)(2)(iv). -84 The sodium targets set a maximum weekly level of sodium for breakfasts and lunches based on a student’s grade -level. Under Target 1, school lunches—on average over the school week—must contain ≤1,230 milligrams (mg) of -sodium for grades K-5, ≤1,360 mg for grades 6-8, and ≤1,420 mg for grades 9-12. -85 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, https://www.federalregister.gov/ -documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk-whole-grains-and-sodium- -requirements. -86 Exempted schools are to maintain a 50% whole grain minimum, the requirement before school year 2014-2015. -87 See CRS Insight IN10700, USDA Announces Plans to Modify School Meal Nutrition Standards: Background and -Context (available to congressional clients upon request). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -29 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - - - - - -continues to allow states to grant waivers to the whole grain-rich requirement; -allows schools to offer low-fat, flavored milk; and -continues Target 1 sodium limits, delaying implementation of Target 2 sodium -limits.88 - -The interim final rule indicated that USDA-FNS would publish a final rule in fall 2018, in time -for schools to implement in SY2019-2020. As of the date of this report, this final rule has not -been published. The FY2018 appropriations law (P.L. 115-141), enacted in March 2018, did not -make any changes to the standards. - -There were legislative proposals to change the nutrition standards on a more-permanent basis -during 114th Congress deliberations to reauthorize the child nutrition programs.89 As discussed -earlier, reauthorization was not completed in the 114th Congress and authorizing committees have -not considered such legislative proposals in the 115th Congress. - -New Nutrition Standards for All Foods Sold in Schools - -In another major policy change, Section 208 of HHFKA gave USDA the authority to regulate -other foods in the school nutrition environment. Sometimes called “competitive foods,” this and -the related regulation pertain to foods and drinks sold in a la carte lines, vending machines, snack -bars and concession stands, and fundraisers. - -Relying on recommendations made by a 2007 IOM report,90 USDA-FNS promulgated a proposed -rule and then an interim final rule in June 2013, which went into effect for school year 2014- -2015.91 The interim final rule imposed nutrition guidelines for all non-meal foods and beverages -that are sold during the school day (defined as midnight until 30 minutes after dismissal). The -final rule, published on July 29, 2016, maintained the interim final rules with minor -modifications. Under the final standards, these foods must meet whole-grain requirements; have -certain primary ingredients; and meet calorie, sodium, and fat limits, among other requirements. -Schools are limited to a list of no- and low-calorie beverages they may sell (with larger portion -sizes and caffeine allowed in high schools). - -Regarding fundraisers, there are no limits on fundraisers of foods that meet the interim final rule’s -guidelines. Fundraisers outside of the school day are not subject to the guidelines. HHFKA and -the interim final rule provide states with discretion to exempt infrequent fundraisers of foods or -beverages that do not meet the nutrition standards. - -The rule does not limit foods brought from home, only foods sold at school during the school day. -The federal standards included are a minimum standard; states and school districts are permitted -to issue more stringent policies. - -88 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child Nutrition Programs: Flexibilities for Milk, Whole Grains, and Sodium -Requirements; Interim Final Rule,” 82 Federal Register 56703, November 30, 2017, available at -https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/11/30/2017-25799/child-nutrition-programs-flexibilities-for-milk- -whole-grains-and-sodium-requirements. -89 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview. -90 IOM, Nutrition Standards for Foods in Schools: Leading the Way toward Healthier Youth, 2007, -https://www.nap.edu/catalog/11899/nutrition-standards-for-foods-in-schools-leading-the-way-toward. -91 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program: Nutrition -Standards for All Foods Sold in School as Required by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule,” 81 -Federal Register 50131, July 29, 2016. Final rule and related resources available at USDA-FNS website at -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/tools-schools-focusing-smart-snacks. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -30 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Updated Nutrition Standards for CACFP - -Similarly, Section 221 of HHFKA required USDA to update the meal pattern for CACFP. USDA- -FNS’s proposed rule, published January 15, 2015, relied upon an IOM panel’s recommendations -and the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.92 FNS reviewed comments and incorporated -feedback in the final rule, which was published on April 25, 2016.93 The updated meal patterns -went into effect on October 1, 2017. The rule changes both the infant meal pattern and child/adult -meal pattern in CACFP. It also revises the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and School -Breakfast Program (SBP) meal patterns for pre-kindergarten children (such changes were not -included in the January 2012 final regulation discussed earlier). - -Below are some examples of changes included in the final rule:94 - - For infant meals, changes include condensing the previously three infant age - - - -groups into two age groups, introducing solid foods at six months of age (unless -otherwise requested by a parent or guardian), providing fruits and vegetables for -older infants, and eliminating juice. The updated guidelines make policy changes -to support breastfeeding, including providing program reimbursements when -mothers come to child care centers or homes to breastfeed their infants. -In child and adult meals, changes include separate fruit and vegetable serving -requirements, as opposed to treating fruits and vegetables as one group, and -limiting juice to one serving per day. The rule also requires that at least one daily -serving of grains be whole-grain rich and limits the sugar in breakfast cereals and -yogurts served. Milk must be low-fat or fat-free, and flavored milk cannot be -served to children age five or younger. The updated standards also disallow -frying as an onsite preparation method. - - “Best practices” for the different age groups were included in the rule, not as -requirements for reimbursement but as examples of ideal policies to promote -good nutrition and health. Examples include the “best practice” that a center or -home provides mothers with a quiet, private area to breastfeed and the -recommendation to limit sugar in flavored milk served to children age six and -older. USDA-FNS subsequently elaborated on the best practices through policy -guidance.95 - -Alternatives to “Congregate Feeding” in Summer Meals -In recent years, but particularly during the 114th Congress, policymakers have weighed policy -options to reach more children in the summer months using alternatives to congregate meal -service. - -92 Ibid. at 2037. IOM (Institute of Medicine), Child and Adult Care Food Program: Aligning Dietary Guidance for All. -Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2011. -93 USDA-FNS also notes that it thoroughly reviewed the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines, and determined that the final -rule, based on the 2010 guidelines, is consistent with the updated guidelines. USDA-FNS, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: Meal Pattern Revisions Related to the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010; Final Rule” 81 Federal -Register 24348 et seq., April 25, 2016, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/04/25/2016-09412/child-and- -adult-care-food-program-meal-pattern-revisions-related-to-the-healthy-hunger-free-kids-act. -94 Ibid. For summaries of updated meal patterns and related resources, see USDA-FNS website at -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/meals-and-snacks. -95 USDA-FNS, “Optional Best Practices to Further Improve Nutrition in the Child and Adult Care Food Program Meal -Pattern,” June 30, 2016, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cacfp/CACFP15-2016os.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -31 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Current Law and Policy - -Under current law, most food offered in summer months is provided in congregate settings -through the SFSP or the NSLP’s Seamless Summer Option (SSO, an option only for schools) (see -“Summer Meals” section above). “Congregate” settings refer to specific sites where children -come to eat while supervised. Also, for the most part, non-school organizations that provide -summer and afterschool food need to participate in two separate programs (SFSP and CACFP At- -risk Afterschool). - -As discussed earlier, on a pilot basis in a limited geographic area each summer since 2011, USDA -has tested alternatives to SFSP and the SSO as required by law. Specifically, the 2010 Agriculture -Appropriations Act (Section 749(g) of P.L. 111-80) provided $85 million in discretionary funding -for “demonstration projects to develop and test methods of providing access to food for children -in urban and rural areas during the summer months.” The first of those demonstrations was called -the Enhanced Summer Food Service Program (eSFSP), which took place in the summers of 2010 -and 2012. eSFSP included four initiatives: (1) incentives for SFSP sites to lengthen operations to -40 or more days, (2) funding to add recreational or educational activities at meal sites, (3) meal -delivery for children in rural areas, and (4) “food backpacks” that children could take home on -weekends and holidays. - -Evaluations of eSFSP were published from 2011 to 2014.96 Participation rates rose during the -demonstration periods for all four initiatives. In addition, children in the meal delivery and -backpack demonstrations had consistent rates of food insecurity from summer to fall (this was not -measured for the other initiatives). However, the results of the evaluation should be interpreted -with caution due to a small sample size and potential confounding factors. - -As discussed earlier, the second demonstration, Summer Electronic Benefit Transfer for Children -(SEBTC or Summer EBT), began in summer 2011 and is ongoing as of the date of this report; -this program provides SNAP or WIC benefits over EBT to households with children eligible for -free or reduced-price school meals. Most recently, FY2018 appropriations (P.L. 115-141) -provided $28 million for the demonstration. Evaluations of Summer EBT were conducted over a -three-year period from FY2011 to FY2013.97 The evaluations, which used rigorous designs, -showed a significant decline in Very Low Food Security in children (VLFS-C);98 the prevalence -of VLFS-C was reduced from 9.5% in the control group to 6.4% in the Summer EBT treatment -group.99 Evaluations also found improvements in children’s consumption of fruits, vegetables, - -96 Elinson et al., Evaluation of 2011 Enhanced Summer Food Service Program Demonstrations, prepared by Westat -under Contract No. GS-23F-8144H (Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2012), p. 4-21. -97 The first year, the proof-of-concept (POC) year, was evaluated to test the feasibility of the EBT delivery system and -prepare for full-implementation in demonstration sites for the following year. The second year, the full implementation -year, evaluated the impact of SEBTC on improving children’s food security and nutritional status in the summer time. -Finally, the third year compared the impact of two benefit levels, $60 and $30, to determine the effect of different -benefit levels on improving food security and nutritional status. Final reports and status reports to Congress are -available on the USDA-FNS website, http://www.fns.usda.gov/ops/summer-electronic-benefit-transfer-children-sebtc. -98 Very Low Food Security is the lowest of four levels of food security; USDA defines it as “At times during the year, -eating patterns of one or more household members were disrupted and food intake reduced because the household -lacked money and other resources for food.” USDA-ERS website, http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition- -assistance/food-security-in-the-us/measurement.aspx. See also CRS Report R42353, Domestic Food Assistance: -Summary of Programs. -99 Collins et al., Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children (SEBTC) Demonstration: Evaluation Findings for -the Full Implementation Year. Prepared by Abt Associates, Mathematica Policy Research, and Maximus. Alexandria, -VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, 2013, p. 105. This improvement is based on the entire evaluation population. -Improvements in VLFS-C did vary significantly between Summer EBT sites. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -32 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -and whole grains. Both WIC and SNAP models showed increased consumption, but increases -were greater at sites operating the WIC model.100 - -In the summers from 2015 to 2018, USDA-FNS also offered non-congregate feeding options at -outdoor summer meal sites experiencing excessive heat.101 This demonstration has not been -evaluated. - -Congressional Proposals - -During the 114th Congress, committees of jurisdiction marked up child nutrition reauthorization -bills. Both committees of jurisdiction—the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and -Forestry and the House Committee on Education and the Workforce—reported reauthorization -legislation: S. 3136 and H.R. 5003, respectively. Both proposals would have piloted or expanded -a number of alternatives for feeding low-income children during the summer months. Still, there -were significant differences between the reauthorization proposals’ SFSP provisions.102 (There -were also committee hearings and freestanding proposals related to SFSP in the 114th -Congress.)103 - -The committees’ reauthorization bills included the following policies: - - Streamlining afterschool and summer programs. Both committees’ proposals -would have authorized eligible institutions in selected states to operate SFSP and -CACFP At-risk Afterschool sites under one application. The bills differed in the -number of states that would have been eligible and the reimbursement rates used. - - Summer EBT. Both proposals addressed the provision of benefits via EBT to -children who are eligible for free and reduced-price school meals over the -summer months. The Senate committee would have expanded this alternative -with mandatory funding. The House committee would have kept the existing -pilot funded with discretionary funding. The Senate committee would have -required states to provide WIC EBT, while the House committee would have -allowed participating states to provide SNAP or WIC. - - Off-Site Consumption Options. Both proposals included ways for some - -institutions (e.g., those located in rural areas) to provide SFSP meals for -consumption off-site. The bills also included temporary flexibilities for -congregate feeding sites to episodically provide meals to be consumed off-site -under certain conditions (e.g., extreme weather conditions). - - Other SFSP Policies. The Senate committee’s bill would have authorized - -discretionary funding for some states to pilot the provision of three meals per -day, or two meals and one snack. The House committee’s proposal would have - -100 Ibid., p. 124. -101 See USDA-FNS, “Demonstration Project for Non-Congregate Feeding for Outdoor Summer Meal Sites -Experiencing Excessive Heat with Q&As,” May 24, 2018, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/sfsp/ -SP14_SFSP04-2018os.pdf. -102 See CRS Report R44373, Tracking the Next Child Nutrition Reauthorization: An Overview, for further legislative -background and a more detailed summary of summer meals and other program provisions. -103 During 114th Congress hearings, witnesses testified about SFSP and summer alternatives before the House -Committee on Education and the Workforce (April 15, 2015; June 16, 2015; June 24, 2015) and the Senate Committee -on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry (May 7, 2015). During the 114th Congress, introduced bills on summer meals -included S. 613/H.R. 1728, S. 1539/H.R. 2715, and S. 1966. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -33 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -authorized USDA to award competitive grants to improve SFSP service delivery -through business partnerships. - -These reauthorization bills have not been reintroduced in the 115th Congress; however, there have -been other legislative proposals in the 115th Congress to amend SFSP.104 - -Presidential Budget Proposals - -The Obama Administration’s FY2017 budget proposed a number of changes to SFSP. -Specifically, the administration proposed to expand Summer EBT nationwide, with a phase-in -over 10 years.105 The administration also requested $10 million for a new Summer Food Service -Non-Congregate Demonstration Project. - -The Trump Administration’s FY2018 and FY2019 budgets did not include any new SFSP -legislative proposals. The budgets requested continued funding for Summer EBT. - -Unpaid Meal Charges and “Lunch Shaming” - -The issue of stigmatizing a child who owes and does not pay his or her meal costs, commonly -referred to as “lunch shaming,” has received increased attention in recent years.106 Some practices -that school districts have adopted in response to such situations include taking or throwing away a -student’s selected hot foods and providing an alternative cold meal (more common) to stamping -students’ arms and making them wear stickers (less common).107 One reason why these instances -may occur is that payments for reduced-price and full-price meals are a source of revenue for -school food programs (in addition to federal NSLP and SBP reimbursements). Schools have an -interest in collecting this revenue from children’s families to help fund operations.108 - -Some have pointed out that the Community Eligibility Provision (discussed earlier in this report) -is a strategy to prevent unpaid meal charges by providing free meals to all children in qualifying -schools.109 - -Congress and USDA have taken some recent actions to address the issues of lunch shaming and -unpaid meal costs. Section 143 of the HHFKA of 2010 required USDA to examine states’ and - -104 See, for example, the Summer Meals Act of 2017 (H.R. 203) and legislation “To amend the Richard B. Russell -National School Lunch Act to establish a permanent, nationwide summer electronic benefits transfer for children -program” (H.R. 6516S. 3268). -105 Details about the Obama Administration’s Nationwide Summer EBT proposal are available in the FY2017 budget -USDA-FNS Explanatory Notes on p. 32-34, http://www.obpa.usda.gov/32fns2017notes.pdf. -106 There is no official definition of “lunch shaming.” Legislation in the 115th Congress, the Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017 (H.R. 2401/S. 1064), refers to lunch shaming as “the stigmatization of children who are unable to pay for -meals.” -107 Typically, an alternative meal includes unflavored milk, a cheese or peanut butter-and-jelly sandwich, and a fruit or -vegetable. May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and -Practices for School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12. Prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10- -0048. Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014, p. 147-148. -108 If they are unable to recover these funds, the money becomes “bad debt” and the school or school district must use -other non-federal funding sources to cover the costs (7 C.F.R. 200.426). See p. 2 of USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, -“Unpaid Meal Charges: Clarification on Collection of Delinquent Meal Payments,” July 8, 2016, at https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP47-2016os.pdf. -109 See, for example, James Weill, “How to stop school lunch shaming? Leave kids out of it,” The Hill, at -http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/education/333003-how-to-stop-school-lunch-shaming-leave-kids-out-of-it; U.S. -Department of Agriculture, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate -Meals, June 2016, at https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -34 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -school districts’ policies and practices regarding unpaid meal charges. As part of the review, the -law required USDA to “prepare a report on the feasibility of establishing national standards for -meal charges and the provision of alternate meals” and, if relevant, make recommendations -related to the implementation of the standards. Section 143 also permitted USDA to take follow- -up actions based on the findings from the report.110 - -USDA’s subsequent June 2016 Report to Congress did not recommend national standards, but -rather recommended “clarifying and updating policy guidance on specific national policies -impacting unpaid meal charges and facilitating the development and distribution of best practices -to support decision making by States and localities.”111 USDA-FNS followed up with a -memorandum requiring school food authorities (SFAs) to institute and communicate—by July 1, -2017—a written meal charge policy, which was to include instructions on how to address -situations in which a child does not pay for a meal.112 USDA-FNS also provided clarification -through webinars, other memoranda, and a best practice guide.113 - -USDA stated that its recommendation was based on findings from a national study of HHFKA -implementation and a Request for Information (RFI) related to unpaid meal charges that garnered -462 responses. The study, conducted in SY2011-2012, found that 58% of SFAs reported incurring -unpaid meal charges prior to recovery attempts.114 Of these SFAs, 50.4% served a reimbursable -meal to children unable to pay, 38.0% served an alternative meal, 5.4% combined these -approaches, 4.9% did something else (“Other”), and 1.3% did not serve a meal. Both the findings -from the study and the RFI showed that meal charge policies were largely determined at the -school- and district-level rather than the state level.115 The responses to the RFI also indicated that -such policies ranged in formality, with varying degrees of review (e.g., some required school -board approval while others did not) and enforcement. In the RFI comments, school and district -officials generally expressed a preference for local control in designing meal charge policies -while advocates generally favored national standards. - -The topics of lunch shaming and unpaid meal costs have since surfaced in the 115th Congress. As -examples of congressional activity on this issue, proposed legislation (Anti-Lunch Shaming Act -of 2017; H.R. 2401/S. 1064) would establish national standards for how schools treat children -unable to pay for a meal.116 - -110 Specifically, Section 143 of HHFKA authorizes USDA to (1) implement standards;, (2) implement demonstration -projects, or (3) further study the feasibility of the recommendations. -111 USDA, Report to Congress: Review of Local Policies on Meal Charges and Provision of Alternate Meals, June -2016, p. 5, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/unpaidmealcharges-report.pdf. -112 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges: Local Meal Charge Policies,” July 8, 2016, https://fns- -prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/cn/SP46-2016os.pdf. -113 For a list of resources, see USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Unpaid Meal Charges,” https://www.fns.usda.gov/ -school-meals/unpaid-meal-charges. -114 May et al., Special Nutrition Program Operations Study: State and School Food Authority Policies and Practices for -School Meals Programs School Year 2011-12, prepared by Westat under Contract No. AG-3198-D-10-0048 -(Alexandria, VA: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, March 2014), p. 147-148, https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/ -default/files/SNOPSYear1.pdf. -115 USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Request for Information: Unpaid Meal Charges,” 79 Federal Register 62095, -October 16, 2014. -116 Specifically, the legislation would prohibit SFAs from (1) publicly identifying children who cannot pay for a meal -or those who have meal debt, (2) having those children perform chores or other activities, and (3) throwing away a -child’s meal. See Section 2 of H.R. 2401 and S. 1064 (identical text). - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -35 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -In addition, a provision in the FY2018 appropriations law (Section 768 of P.L. 115-141) -established that appropriated funds cannot be used in a way that results in discrimination against -children eligible for free or reduced-price meals, including the practices of segregating children -and overtly identifying children by special tokens or tickets.117 - -117 See Section 9(b)(10) of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act (42 U.S.C. 1758(b)(10)) and 7 C.F.R. -245.8. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -36 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix A. Acronyms Used in This Report - -Table A-1. Acronyms - -Government Agencies - -USDA - -U.S. Department of Agriculture - -USDA-FNS - -Food and Nutrition Service - -CACFP - -FFVP - -NSLP - -SBP - -SEBTC - -SFSP - -SMP - -CEP - -CPI-U - -FPL - -Programs - -Child and Adult Care Food Program - -Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Program - -National School Lunch Program - -School Breakfast Program - -Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer for Children - -Summer Food Service Program - -Special Milk Program - -Miscellaneous - -Community Eligibility Provision - -Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers - -Federal Poverty Level - -HHFKA - -Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-296) - -IOM - -LEA - -RCCI - -SFA - -Institute of Medicine - -Local Educational Agency - -Residential Child Care Institution - -School Food Authority - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -37 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Appendix B. Per-meal or Per-snack Reimbursement -Rates for Child Nutrition Programs118 -This appendix lists the specific reimbursement rates discussed in the earlier sections of the report. -Reimbursement rates are adjusted for inflation for each school or calendar year according to -terms laid out in the programs’ authorizing laws. Each year, the new rates are announced in the -Federal Register.119 - -Table B-1. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: Lunches -Per-meal reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Serve Less than 60% of -Lunches as Free and -Reduced-Price - -Serve 60% or More of -Lunches as Free or -Reduced-Price - -Bonus Available for -School Districts -Certified as Compliant -with Nutrition +Piecing It All Together: Verifying Multi-Hop Multimodal Claims +| | HaoranWang♡ | | | AmanRangapur♡ | | | XiongxiaoXu♡ | | YueqingLiang♡ | | | | +| ---------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | ------------------ | --------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | HaroonGharwi♡ | | | CarlYang♣ | KaiShu♣* | | | | | +| | | | ♡IllinoisInstituteofTechnology | | | | ♣EmoryUniversity | | | | | | +| {hwang219, | | | arangapur, | | | xxu85, | yliang40, | hgharwi}@hawk.iit.edu | | | | | +| | | | | {j.carlyang, | | | kai.shu}@emory.edu | | | | | | +Abstract +Claim: The driver seen signing autographs outside had a +significant points total during a specific race in 2001 while +competing for a well-known team in stock car racing. +| Existing | | claim | verification | datasets | | often do | | | | | | | +| -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| not | require | systems | to | perform | complex | rea- | | | | | | | +4202 ceD 21 ]LC.sc[ 2v74590.1142:viXra Table Evidence: Image Evidence: +soningoreffectivelyinterpretmultimodalevi- +dence.Toaddressthis,weintroduceanewtask: +| multi-hopmultimodalclaimverification. | | | | | | This | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +taskchallengesmodelstoreasonovermultiple +| pieces | of | evidence | from | diverse | sources, | in- | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | -------- | ---- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +cludingtext,images,andtables,anddetermine +| whether | | the combined | | multimodal | | evidence | | | | | | | +| ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Label: Support +| supports | | or refutes | a | given claim. | | To study | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| this | task, | we construct | | MMCV, | a large-scale | | | | | | | | +Figure1:Anillustrationofa2-hopclaimfromMMCV. +datasetcomprising15kmulti-hopclaimspaired +Tocorrectlyverifythisclaim,thesystemmustreason +| with | multimodal | | evidence, | generated | | and re- | | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +overboththeimageevidenceandthetableevidence. +finedusinglargelanguagemodels,withaddi- +| tionalinputfromhumanfeedback. | | | | | Weshow | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +thatMMCVischallengingevenforthelatest oftenrequiremulti-hopreasoning,whereasetof +state-of-the-artmultimodallargelanguagemod- +connectedevidencepiecesleadstothefinalverdict +els,especiallyasthenumberofreasoninghops +| | | | | | | | of a claim | (Yang | et al., | 2018). | As a result, | there | +| ---------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ----- | +| increases. | | Additionally,weestablishahuman | | | | | | | | | | | +isaneedforautomatedtoolstoassisthumanfact- +performancebenchmarkonasubsetofMMCV. +checkersinevaluatingtheveracityofmultimodal +| We | hope | this dataset | | and its | evaluation | task | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| willencouragefutureresearchinmultimodal | | | | | | | multi-hopclaims. | | | | | | +multi-hopclaimverification. Dataandcodeare Claimverification,whichinvolvesassessingthe +available: https://mmcv-dataset.github.io/ veracity of an input claim against a collection of +evidence,isavitaltoolincombatingthespreadof +misinformation(ThorneandVlachos,2018;Guo +1 Introduction +| | | | | | | | et al., 2022; | Jin | et al., | 2022, | 2023; Yang | et al., | +| --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | +| Due | to the | rapid growth | | in AI-generated | | content | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 2022). However,verifyingmulti-hopmultimodal | | | | | | +(Huangetal.,2024a,b;Zhangetal.,2024;Jinetal., +| | | | | | | | claims introduces | | new challenges | | in both | dataset | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +2024b),itisdifficultforautomatedfact-checking constructionandeffectivemodeling. Unlikesingle- +systemstokeepupwithverifyingtheaccuracyof +| | | | | | | | hop claims, | which | require | only | straightforward | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | --------------- | --- | +| claimswithmultimodalevidence. | | | | | Thischallenge | | | | | | | | +one-stepreasoning,multi-hopclaimsrequiremul- +isfurtherexacerbatedbytherecentdevelopmentof tiplereasoningstepstoreachafinalverdict. Fur- +diffusionmodelssuchasDALL-E(Rameshetal., +thermore,theinclusionofmultimodalevidencere- +2021)andStableDiffusion(Rombachetal.,2022), +quiresmodelstounderstandandintegrateinforma- +| which | can | generate | realistic | images | from | textual | | | | | | | +| ----- | --- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tionacrossvariousmodalities,suchastext,images, +prompts(Liuetal.,2024b). Thesepowerfultools andtables,makingitmorecomplextocomprehend +| could | enable | attackers | to | produce | misleading | | in- | | | | | | +| ----- | ------ | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | andextractrelevantinformation. | | | | Forinstance,to | | +formation(WangandShu,2024;Panetal.,2023c; +verifytheclaimshowninFigure1,asystemmust +Huang et al., 2024c; Gao et al., 2024; Jin et al., understandthesemanticcontentoftheimage,in- +| 2024a) | at a | low cost. | Additionally, | | these | claims | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +tegrateallrelevantinformationfromthetableevi- +*Correspondingauthor dence,andapplymulti-stepreasoningtoarriveat + +Dataset Multimodal Multi-hop EvidenceRetrieval AnnotatedEvidence AnnotatedLabel +| | | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +FEVER(Thorneetal.,2018) +| Liar(Wang,2017) | | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +FakeNewsNet(Shuetal.,2020) +| NewsCLIPpings(Luoetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Factify(Mishraetal.,2022) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | +| COSMOS(Anejaetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| InfoSurgeon(Fungetal.,2021) | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | +Fauxtography(Zlatkovaetal.,2019) +| HoVer(Jiangetal.,2020) | | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +Mocheg(Yaoetal.,2023) +| MMCV(Ours) | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Table 1: Comparison between MMCV and other claim verification datasets. The columns indicate whether +thedatasetrequiresmultimodalcontent,multi-hopreasoning,explanationgeneration,andwhetheritcontains +annotatedevidence. +thefinalconclusion. enhanceMLLMs’reasoningcapabilities,including +In this paper, we introduce the task of multi- chain-of-thought, self-ask, and symbolic-guided +hopmultimodalclaimverificationtoevaluatethe reasoning. Additionally,weestablishahumanper- +veracity of multi-hop claims against multimodal formancebenchmarkonasubsetofMMCV. +evidence. To study this task, we construct Multi- Overall, we introduce a challenging multi-hop +hopMultimodalClaim-Verification(MMCV),a multimodalclaimverificationdatasetthatincludes +datasetof15Kmulti-hopclaimspairedwithmul- claimswithupto4reasoninghops. Thesecomplex +timodal evidence that either SUPPORT or RE- claims often consist of multiple sentences linked +FUTE each claim. To create the dataset, we de- bycoreferenceanddemandevidencefromvarious +velopanovelpipelinethatuseslargelanguagemod- modalities,suchastext,images,andtables. Table1 +els(LMMs)fordataannotation,supportedbyhu- providesacomparisonbetweenMMCVandexist- +manfeedback. Thismethodsignificantlyreduces ingpopularclaimverificationdatasets. Whilecur- +theworkloadonhumanannotatorsandcutscosts, rentdatasetstypicallyfocusoneithermultimodal +while ensuring high quality and factual accuracy claimsormulti-hoptextualclaims, noneofthem +| ofthedataset. | OurpipelinefirstusesLLMstore- | | | | | | +| ------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +incorporatemulti-hopmultimodalclaimsthatne- +formulatemulti-hopmultimodalquestion-answer cessitatecross-modalreasoning. Wehopethatthe +pairsintoatomicmulti-hopclaimsandgeneratea introductionofMMCVanditscorrespondingeval- +set of candidate claims. These candidate claims uationtaskwillinspirefurtherresearchincomplex +are then modified to include additional hops and multi-hopmultimodalreasoningforclaimverifica- +refined for fluency and clarity according to a set tion. Insummary,ourcontributionsinclude: +| of annotation | guidelines. | To ensure | the accuracy | | | | +| ------------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | +oftheclaims,weuseaRetrieval-AugmentedGen- +• Weintroduceandformalizethemulti-hopmul- +eration (RAG)-based validation method to verify timodalclaimverificationtask. +| theirvalidity. | Finally,weaskagroupofhumanan- | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +notatorstoscoretheclaimsbasedontheirfluency, • We develop a novel pipeline that leverages +correctness, and clearness, and manually rewrite LLMs for data annotation, enhanced by hu- +theclaimsthatarebelowacertainthreshold. man feedback, to construct a benchmark +WeestablishperformancebaselinesonMMCV dataset for multi-hop multimodal claim ver- +using three state-of-the-art multimodal large lan- ification. This method significantly lowers +guage models (MLLMs) and highlight their lim- thecostandlaborrequiredtoproducealarge- +| itations | in verifying | complex multimodal | claims. | scaledataset. | | | +| ---------- | ------------ | ------------------ | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| We further | demonstrate | the challenges | posed by | | | | +thedataset,especiallyasthenumberofreasoning • Weestablishbaselineperformanceonthistask +hopsincreases,byillustratingtheconstrainedper- using MLLMs and human evaluation. Our +formanceofvariousprompttechniquesdesignedto analysis shows that this is a non-trivial task, + +withseveralchallengesthatremaintobead- then-generate pipeline using LLMs for iterative +dressedinfuturework. datasynthesis, while(Paceetal.,2024)combine +theBest-of-NandWorst-of-Nsamplingstrategies +| 2 Background | | | | | | to introduce | the West-of-N | approach. | | With | this | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------------- | --------- | ------ | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | | same objective, | the multi-hop | | claims | in MMCV | | +Multimodal Claim Verification. Previous re- arecreatedandrefinedbyLLMsusinghumanfeed- +searchonclaimverificationhasprimarilyfocused +| | | | | | | back, following | guidelines | and | rules | specifically | | +| -------------- | ------------------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | --------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ------ | +| on textual | data. | However, | with | the | growing | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | designed | to enforce a multi-hop | | structure | | within | +| recognition | that misinformation | | | often | appears | eachclaim. | | | | | | +| across | multiple modalities | | and that | multimodal | | | | | | | | +| misinformation | is | perceived | as more | | credible | | | | | | | +and spreads fasterthan text-only misinformation, 3 The MMCV dataset +| recent | efforts have shifted | | toward verifying | | mul- | | | | | | | +| ------ | -------------------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +timodal claims (Akhtar et al., 2023). As a result, Themaingoalofourworkistocompileadiverse +severalmultimodalclaimverificationdatasetshave andextensive collectionofmulti-hopclaims that +| | | | | | | require | joint reasoning | across | evidence | from | dif- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | ---- | ---- | +beenproposedincludingFakeNewsNet(Shuetal., +ferentmodalities,suchastext,tables,andimages, +2020),COSMOS(Anejaetal.,2021),InfoSurgeon +(Fung et al., 2021), Factify (Mishra et al., 2022), forverification. Oneapproachtoachievingthisis +Fauxtography(Zlatkovaetal.,2019),andMocheg totransformmultimodalquestion-answeringpairs +intoatomicclaimsandrefinethemtoincorporate +| (Yao et | al., 2023). | However, | to the | best | of our | | | | | | | +| ------- | ----------- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +knowledge, there are no existing datasets for additionalreasoningsteps,makingthemmorenat- +multi-hop multimodal claim verification, which ural. However, there are two major challenges +| | | | | | | in creating | such a dataset: | first, | building | | a large- | +| ---------- | ------------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | +| challenges | the system’s | reasoning | | capability | by | | | | | | | +scaledatasetislabor-intensiveandcostly;second, +| requiring | it to integrate | | and interpret | | multiple | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +piecesofevidencefromdifferentmodalities. inourpilotstudies, wefoundthatsimplyprovid- +inginstructionstocrowdworkersandaskingthem +| | | | | | | to rewrite | multi-hop claims | is | counterproductive, | | | +| ------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +| Multi-hopReasoning. | | Verifyingcomplexclaims | | | | | | | | | | +asitisdifficulttocontrolqualityandchallenging +| often requires | multi-step | | (multi-hop) | reasoning | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +(Mavi et al., 2022), which requires combining forworkerstocreatemeaningfulmulti-hopclaims. +| | | | | | | Instead, | we develop a pipeline | | that | leverages | the | +| ----------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | +| information | from multiple | | pieces of | evidence | to | | | | | | | +emergingcapabilitiesoflargelanguagemodelsto +| predict | the veracity | of a | claim. Many | | recently | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------ | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +proposed datasets are created to challenge a generatetextandlearnfromfeedback,withhuman +inputtoensurethequalityofthefinaloutput. +model’sabilitytoreasonacrossmultiplesentences +Inthisapproach,LLMshandlethemundanetask +| ordocuments. | TheseincludeMultiRC(Khashabi | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ------------ | ------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | +| | | | | | | of rewriting | claims consistently | | according | | to the | +| et al., | 2018), QAngaroo | | (Welbl | et al., | 2018), | | | | | | | +ComplexWebQuestion(TalmorandBerant,2018), instructions,whilehumaneffortissignificantlyre- +ducedtoqualitycontrolofthefinalclaimsbased +| HotpotQA | (Yang et | al., 2018), | and | HoVer | (Jiang | | | | | | | +| ------------ | -------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | onasetofguidelines. | Figure2showstheoverall | | | | | +| etal.,2020). | Incontrasttothesedatasets, | | | | MMCV | | | | | | | +incorporates context from various modalities, workflowofourdataconstructionpipeline,which +such as images and tables, further challenging contains three stages: LLM-Based Claim Gener- +| | | | | | | ation (§3.1), | LLM-Generated | | Claim | Refinement | | +| ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | +| the system’s | ability | to understand | | and integrate | | | | | | | | +(§3.2)andClaimAnnotationbyHuman(§3.3). +evidencefromdifferentsources. +| | | | | | | 3.1 ClaimGeneration | | | | | | +| --------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ----- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Construct | Synthetic | Dataset | with | LLMs. | The | | | | | | | +emergenceofadvancedlargelanguagemodelshas In this stage, we leverage the in-context learning +sparked growing interest in automating the data capabilitiesoflargelanguagemodelstotransform +annotationprocessusingLLMs(Tanetal.,2024; question-answer pairs from the MultimodalQA +Wu et al., 2024; Bao et al., 2024; Chen et al., dataset(Talmoretal.,2021)intoverifiableclaims. +2024), driven by their advanced capabilities, in- To minimize the impact of in-context examples +cluding in-context learning (Dong et al., 2022) on the quality of the generated claims, we care- +andlearningfromhumanfeedback(Ouyangetal., fully craft a pool of 20 in-context examples and +2022). (Wang et al., 2023) propose an explain- randomly select 3 for use during execution. The + +| | Stage 1: Claim | | | Stage 2: Claim | | | Stage 3: Claim | | | +| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | Generation | | | Refinement | | | Annotation | | | +Multihop QA Pair & Multimodal Claim Modification and Refinement Claim Negation: +Context: +Supported: "Adam Kennedy had fewer +| | | | | Claim | Refined | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Q: Did Adam Kennedy or the player with a Candidate Claim RBIs during the Anaheim Angels' 2004 +red stripe on his pants, red logo on his shirt, Iteration season than the player wearing a red stripe +and a blue helmet have a lower RBI in the Threshold YES on his pants, a red logo on his shirt, and a +| Anaheim Angels' 2004 season? | | | | | | blue helmet. | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------ | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| A: Adam Kennedy | | | | Claim | isGood? | | | | | +| | | | Modification | | | Not Supported: Adam Kennedy had more | | | | +NO +RBIs during the Anaheim Angels' 2006 +In seven seasons with the season than the player wearing a red stripe +Textual +Angels, Kennedy hit … with on his pants, a red logo on his shirt, and a +| | | 51 home runs and 353 RBI. | | Feedback | | blue helmet. | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | Factuality Validation using RAG: | | | Claim Scoring: | | | | +He holds Angels franchise +records for …, runs batted +● Fluency: 4 +in (RBI) (1,292), … +| | | | | Refined | Key | ● Correctness: 3 | | isBelow? | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| | | | | Claim | Entities | ● Clearness: 3 | | | | +Claim Candidate: +Claim Rewriting: +Large +Adam Kennedy had fewer RBIs during the +| | | | | Language | | "Adam Kennedy had fewer RBIs during the | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| Anaheim Angels' 2004 season than the | | | | Model | | | | | | +player wearing a red stripe on his pants, a Anaheim Angels' 2004 season than the +player wearing a red stripe on his pants, a +| red logo on his shirt, and a blue helmet. | | | | Prompt | Detecting | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | Diversifier | Factual Errors | red logo on his shirt, and a blue helmet. | | | | +Figure2:OverviewofdatacollectionflowchartforMMCV.Inthefirststage,were-formulatequestion-answerpairs +fromMultimodalQAtogeneratecandidateclaims. Inthesecondstage,wemodifyandrefinethecandidateclaims, +andapplyaRetrieval-AugmentedGeneration(RAG)-basedmethodtoverifytheircorrectness. Inthefinalstage,we +askhumanannotatorstorankthecandidateclaimstoselectthebestoneandlabelthefinalclaimsaccordingly. +claimsareformulatedtoensurethatnoinformation mariesoftheirrespectiveWikipediaarticlesascon- +isomittedfromtheoriginalQApairsandnonew textandinstructtheLLMstomodifytheclaimin +information is introduced. Since the claims are suchawaythatitincorporatesthiscontextualin- +deriveddirectlyfromthequestionandthecorrect formation to replace the entity, ensuring that the +answer, they are automatically labeled as SUP- entity’snamedoesnotappeardirectlyintheclaim. +PORT.Theprompttemplateforclaimgeneration +TohelpLLMsunderstandthemodificationtask, +islistedinAppendixA.2. +| | | | | | we provide | them with | 3-5 randomly | selected | in- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | +contextexamplesfromapoolofhand-craftedex- +3.2 ClaimRefinement +amples. Aftermodifyingtheclaim,weobtainfeed- +After generating the initial claims from the backfromLLMsregardingthefluency,correctness, +| | | | | | andclarityofthemodifiedclaim. | | Thecriteriaused | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +question-answerpairs,wemodifyandrefinethem +forthisassessmentarelistedintheAppendixA.2. +toensuretheyaremorenaturallyphrasedandmore +Ifthefeedbacksuggestsfurtherimprovement,the +| accuratelysupportedbythefacts. | | | Next,wereview | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the claims for any factual errors that may have claimissentbacktothemodificationstep,incorpo- +ratingtheLLMs’feedbackuntilacertainiteration +| been | introduced | during the | modification | process | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------- | --------- | ----------- | --------------- | ----- | ----- | +| | | | | | threshold | is reached. | If the modified | claim | still | +andmakecorrectionsasneeded. +| | | | | | does not | pass the quality | check, it | is marked | for | +| ----- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| Claim | Modification | and Refinement. | | To intro- | | | | | | +manualreviewandrevisionbyhumanannotators. +| duce | additional | reasoning steps | to the | claim can- | | | | | | +| ---- | ---------- | --------------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +didate,weemployamodify-then-refineapproach RAG-based Truthfulness Validation. Since we +that iteratively enhances the quality of the modi- introduceadditionalcontextualinformationfrom +fiedclaimcandidatebasedonfeedbackfromLLMs Wikipedia when modifying the claims, there is +(Panetal.,2023a). Specifically,webeginbyiden- a risk that LLMs might hallucinate and produce +tifyingtheWikipediaentitiesmentionedinthean- outputs that are not faithful to the input context. +swers from the question-answer pairs. If there is To eliminate potential factual errors, we use a +onlyoneWikipediaentityintheanswer,weleave retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) (Lewis +theclaimcandidateunchanged. However,ifthere et al., 2020)-based pipeline to retrieve the full +are multiple Wikipedia entities, we use the sum- Wikipedia articles of the relevant entities and + +validatethefactualaccuracyofthemodifiedclaims. Data 1-hop 2-hop 3-hop 4-hop +Tomitigatetheimpactofpromptsensitivityonthe +| | | | | | | | #Claims | | | 5,884 | 8,485 | 804 | 396 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | +model’soutput(Luetal.,2022;Sclaretal.,2023), +| | | | | | | | Ave.#TokensinClaim | | | 21.7 | 25.32 | 25.44 | 26.17 | +| ----------------------------------- | --------------- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ---- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| we diversify | the | prompts | by | randomly | changing | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | Max.#TokensinClaim | | | 48 | 58 | 51 | 63 | +| theirformatforeachverificationstep. | | | | | Forinstance, | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #TextEvidence | | | 2,590 | 7,323 | 1,142 | 760 | +| instead | of consistently | | using | | Is it | true | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #ImageEvidence | | | 1,979 | 2,948 | 634 | 512 | +| that {claim}?, | | the | prompt | | is randomly | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | #TableEvidence | | | 1,315 | 6,699 | 636 | 312 | +chosenfromasetofequivalentalternatives,such +as Verify the following statement: #SUPPORTLabels 2,824 4,030 349 158 +{claim} or What evidence supports #REFUTELabels 3,060 4,455 455 238 +| the claim | that | {claim}? | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | Table2: | DatasetStatisticsofMMCV. | | | | | +3.3 ClaimAnnotation +| At this stage, | we | have | obtained | claims | that | have | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------ | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | detailed | in Table | 2. | The | number | of hops | is | +beenmodifiedandrefinedbyLLMsandfactually +| | | | | | | | determined | by | the count | of | multimodal | evidence | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | +validated by RAG-based pipelines. Next, we use associatedwitheachclaim. Thedatasetincludesa +LLMstogeneratenegatedclaimsbyapplyingaset +balanceddistributionofSUPPORTandREFUTE +| ofspecificnegationrules. | | | Weemploythreedistinct | | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | claims. | Specifically,thereare5,8841-hopclaims | | | | | | +methodsforgeneratingthesenegatedclaims. For with an average of 21.7 tokens per claim; 8,485 +instance,giventheclaim,“Sinceitsconstruction 2-hop claims averaging 25.32 tokens per claim; +in1889,theEiffelTowerinParisattractsmillions +8043-hopclaimswithanaverageof25.44tokens +ofvisitorsannually.”,theresultsafterapplyingthe +| | | | | | | | perclaim; | and3964-hopclaimsaveraging26.17 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +negationrulesareasfollows: tokensperclaim. Anexamplefromthedatasetis +| Negation | | | | | | | providedinAppendixA.1. | | | | | | | +| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +▷Wordsubstitution:TheEiffelTowerinParishouses +millionsofresidentsannually. Multi-hop Reasoning Types. We provide +▷Entitysubstitution:TheColosseuminParisattracts +| | | | | | | | examples | of | each | reasoning | type | in Table | 6. | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | -------- | --- | +millionsofvisitorsannually. +▷Temporalmutation:Eversinceitsconstructionin Most1-hopand2-hopclaimsrequireatleastone +2050,theEiffelTowerhasbeenParis’stoptouristsite. +supportingfactfromeitherimageortableevidence +| | | | | | | | forverification. | | Incontrast,themajorityof3-hop | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Next,agroupofhumanannotatorsistaskedwith and 4-hop claims require evidence from all three +evaluating the claims based on three dimensions: modalities. The process of removing a bridge +| | | | | | | | entity and | replacing | | it with | a relative | clause | or | +| -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | +| fluency, | correctness, | and | clarity, | scoring | | each di- | | | | | | | | +mension on a scale of 1 to 5. Fluency assesses phrase significantly increases the informational +hownaturallytheclaimreads,asoutputsgenerated load of a single hypothesis. As a result, some +bylanguagemodelscansometimessoundartificial. 3-hop and 4-hop claims are relatively longer and +Correctnessevaluateswhethertheclaimisfactually exhibitcomplexsyntacticandreasoningstructures. +accuratebasedontheevidence. Claritydetermines Our experimental results also indicate that the +iftheclaimiseasilyunderstood,asentitysubstitu- difficultyformodelstoverifyclaimsescalatesas +thehopcountincreases. +| tionmightmakeitdifficulttocomprehend. | | | | | | Once | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| the claims | are scored, | | the average | | of the | fluency, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | 5 ExperimentsandResults | | | | | | | +correctness,andclarityscoresiscalculatedtode- +| terminethefinalscoreforeachclaim. | | | | | Ifaclaim’s | | | | | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Inthissection,wediscussourexperimentsettings +finalscorefallsbelowapredeterminedthreshold, +(§5.1),theexperimentresults(§5.2),andtheerror +| it is flagged | and | sent | back to | the | annotators | for | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | analysis(§5.3). | | Webeginbyformallydefiningthe | | | | | +| manual revision. | | Detailed | annotation | | guidelines | | | | | | | | | +MMCVtaskbelow. +arelistedinAppendixA.3. +| | | | | | | | Task Definition. | | | The formulation | | of | multi- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | +4 DatasetAnalysis +| | | | | | | | hop multimodal | | claim | verification | | is defined | as | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | +Dataset Statistics. MMCV contains 15,569 follows: GivenaclaimC,andalistofmultimodal +multi-hopmultimodalclaims,withtheirstatistics evidence E(C), which includes text, images, + +1-hop 2-hop 3-hop 4-hop +Retrieval Model P R F1 P R F1 P R F1 P R F1 +GPT-4O 76.86 72.94 71.79 67.96 63.30 60.66 62.88 58.89 56.17 67.93 62.39 61.20 +Closed-book GEMINI 75.67 71.44 70.15 69.10 64.19 61.73 66.74 61.10 58.44 63.78 59.90 58.69 +LLAVA 64.18 63.78 63.57 64.06 63.93 63.87 66.78 66.81 66.76 64.64 64.84 64.64 +GPT-4O 76.95 72.95 71.78 68.03 63.24 60.53 62.67 58.78 56.08 67.75 62.46 61.35 +Open-book GEMINI 79.58 79.25 79.20 72.38 71.85 71.66 66.37 65.90 65.86 67.21 66.86 66.97 +LLAVA 62.86 59.68 57.21 64.17 62.48 61.50 65.47 64.64 63.76 66.50 66.76 66.42 +Table3: WereportthePrecision,Recall,andF1scoresofvariousMLLMsonMMCVforzero-shotmultimodal +claimverification. Intheclosed-booksetting,themodelverifiestheclaimwithoutaccesstoanyexternalknowledge +sources. Intheopen-booksetting,themodelisprovidedwithasetofgoldevidence. Thebest-performingmodelfor +eachhopishighlightedinGreenforbothsettings. +and tables, the system must reason over all the evaluate the performance of an open-source +evidenceandpredictthelabeloftheclaimaseither MLLM, LLaVA-V1.5-7B (Liu et al., 2024a), on +SUPPORT or REFUTE. MMCV. The temperature is set to 0.0, and the +maximumnumberoftokensissetto5000. +5.1 ExperimentSettings +Prompts for Enhanced Reasoning In ad- +As there are no existing models specifically de- +dition to the prompt mentioned above, we +signedformulti-hopmultimodalsupervisedclaim +conductexperimentsusingspecializedprompting +verification, we conduct our experiments using +techniques aimed at eliciting reasoning from +MLLMs. Moreover, previous studies in textual +LLMs, such as Chain-of-Thought (Wei et al., +claim verification and multimodal claim verifica- +2022) and Self-Ask (Press et al., 2023). We +tion indicate that LLMs and MLLMs can signifi- +also test symbolic-guided reasoning prompts +cantlyenhancetaskperformancecomparedtotra- +like ProgramFC (Pan et al., 2023b) and Visual +ditionalsupervisedapproaches(Panetal.,2023b; +Programming (Gupta and Kembhavi, 2023). To +Wang and Shu, 2023; Li et al., 2024; Geng et al., +minimize the overall cost of the experiments, we +2024b). Furthermore, supervised methods often +randomly select 100 examples from each hop of +requireextensiveannotatedcorpora,whicharedif- +the MMCV dataset for testing. The experiments +ficulttoacquireandlimitdomaintransferability,as +areconductedusingopen-booksetting. +trainingdatatypicallycoversonlyasingledomain. +Zero-shot Claim Verification. We establish Human Performance To benchmark hu- +performance baselines for zero-shot multimodal man performance on our dataset, we used the +claimverificationusingvariousMLLMsundertwo same randomly selected examples employed in +settings. Intheclosed-booksetting,themodeldoes theenhancedreasoningpromptexperiments. We +notretrieveinformationfromexternalknowledge recruitedfourexpertsinautomatedfact-checking +sourcesandmustrelyonitsparametric(internal) researchtoclassifymultihopclaimsfromMMCV +knowledge to verify the claim. In the open-book based on the provided evidence. The SMART +setting, the model is provided with a set of gold (Chewetal.,2019)framework1wasusedtodeploy +evidence. Specifically, we use the prompt from theannotationtask,andhumanperformancewas +(Geng et al., 2024b), which extracts the models’ evaluatedusingthemacroF-1score. +predictions, explanations, and confidence levels. +The prompt is listed in Appendix A.2. We use 5.2 ExperimentResults +macroprecision,recall,andF-1scoretoevaluate +Main Results. We report the comprehensive +themodelperformance. +results of the three MLLMs on MMCV in Table +3, highlighting the best-performing models for +MLLM. We utilize two state-of-the-art MLLMs: +each hop under both open-book and closed-book +GPT-4o (Achiam et al., 2023) and Gemini 1.5 +Flash (Team et al., 2023). Additionally, we 1https://github.com/RTIInternational/SMART + +| | | Confidence Level Distribution | | | | | | | Calibration Curve | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +100 +3hop_gpt-4_closed_book +| 70000 | | 4hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| --------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | +| | | 2hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| | | 3hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 1hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | 80 | | | | 3hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| 60000 | | | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| | | 4hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gemini_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gpt-4_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gpt-4_open_book | | +| 50000 | | 1hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | )%( ycaruccA | | | | | | +| ycneuqerF | | 3hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 1hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | 60 | | | | 3hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gemini_open_book | | +| 40000 | | 4hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 2hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_llava_open_book | | +2hop_gemini_open_book +| | | 4hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| ----- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| 30000 | | 4hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | 40 | | | | 4hop_gemini_closed_book | | +2hop_gemini_closed_book +| | | 3hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 2hop_gemini_closed_book | | +| ----- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | +| | | 1hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_llava_closed_book | | +| | | 3hop_gemini_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gemini_closed_book | | +| 20000 | | 1hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gemini_open_book | | +| | | 1hop_llava_open_book | | | | | | | | | | 1hop_gpt-4_closed_book | | +| | | | | | | | | 20 | | | | 1hop_llava_open_book | | +| | | 4hop_llava_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 4hop_llava_closed_book | | +| 10000 | | 3hop_gemini_closed_book | | | | | | | | | | 3hop_gemini_closed_book | | +Ideal Calibration +| | 0 | | | | | | | 0 | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 0 | 10 20 | 30 40 | 50 | 60 70 | 80 | 90 100 | 0 | 20 40 | 60 | 80 | 100 | | +| | | | Confidence Level | | | | | | Confidence (%) | | | | | +Figure 3: The left figure shows the confidence score distribution of GPT4-o, Gemini, and LLaVA on MMCV +underbothopen-bookandclosed-booksettings,categorizedbythenumberofhops. Therightfigureshowstheir +calibrationcurves. +settings. Overall,Gemini1.5outperformsothersin +| | | | | | | | | Model | Method | 1-hop | 2-hop | 3-hop | 4-hop | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +theopen-booksettingwithanaverageF-1of70.92, +| | | | | | | | | | CoT | 78.52 | 69.66 | 67.45 | 70.24 | +| ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| while | LLaVA | achieves | | the highest | | performance | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | GEMINI1.5 | Self-Ask | 75.47 | 66.58 | 60.94 | 70.67 | +intheclosed-booksettingwithanaverageF-1of +| | | | | | | | | | Symbolic | 74.89 | 63.82 | 54.61 | 72.36 | +| ------ | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | +| 66.77. | This | is surprising, | | given | that | LLaVA | is | a | | | | | | +much smaller model compared to GPT4-o and CoT 80.43 83.33 71.20 72.99 +Gemini, and therefore possesses less parametric GPT4-O Self-Ask 77.42 80.12 70.52 75.23 +knowledge. Uponmanuallyanalyzingasubsetof Symbolic 80.56 78.78 68.72 75.67 +| 100 | randomly | selected | outputs | | from | LLaVA, | we | | | | | | | +| --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | | Table 4: | Results of | Gemini | and GPT4-o | | on 100 ran- | +foundthatthemodelfrequentlyhallucinates,even +domlysampledclaimsforeachhopusingthreetypes +| when | it predicts | the | correct | label, | particularly | | as | | | | | | | +| ---- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---- | ------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | ofreasoningprompts. | | Modelperformanceisevaluated | | | | +| the | hop count | increases. | | This | is consistent | | with | | | | | | | +usingF-1score. +| its | open-book | performance, | | | where | its accuracy | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----------------- | ---------- | ------------ | +| declines | | when provided | | with | gold | evidence. | | | | | | | | +| Additionally, | | we observe | | that | GPT4-o | performs | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | The | right panel | of | Figure | 3 displays | the | +| slightly | better | in | closed-book | | settings | than | in | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | calibration | curves, | illustrating | | the | relationship | +| open-book | | settings, | suggesting | | a | tendency | to | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | between | the models’ | confidence | | levels | and their | +| hallucinate. | | In contrast, | | Gemini’s | | performance | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | actualclassificationaccuracy. | | | Thesecurvesreveal | | | +| drops | significantly | | in | closed-book | | settings | | | | | | | | +apositivecorrelationbetweenconfidenceandac- +comparedtoopen-book,demonstratingitsrobust- +curacyfor1-hopand2-hopclaims,asexemplified +nessineffectivelyutilizingprovidedgoldevidence. +| | | | | | | | | by the red | line (GPT-4-o | | on 2-hop), | | the teal line | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | +(LLaVAon1-hop),andthepurpleline(Geminion +| Confidence | | Level | Analysis | | The | left | panel | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | +| | | | | | | | | 1-hop). | Incontrast,thedownwardcurves,mostly | | | | | +| of | Figure | 3 presents | the | confidence | | (Geng | et al., | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | observed | in 3-hop | and | 4-hop | claims, | suggest | +2024a)distributionsforallthreeMLLMs,catego- +| | | | | | | | | that the | models tend | to | be overconfident | | when | +| ---------- | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------------- | ---- | +| rized | by the | number | of | hops and | divided | | into 10 | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | classifyingmorecomplexclaims. | | | | Additionally,the | | +| intervals. | | Theresultsshowthatthemajorityofthe | | | | | | | | | | | | +resultsindicatethatopen-booksettingsgenerally +MLLMsareconcentratedinthe90-100confidence +| | | | | | | | | have better-calibrated | | confidence | | scores | than | +| ---------- | ---- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------- | --------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | +| range, | with | only a | small | number | exhibiting | | low | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | | closed-book | settings, | further | suggesting | | that the | +| confidence | | (0-10 | range), | which | occurs | | solely | | | | | | | +modelsexhibitoverconfidencewhennotprovided +| in | open-book | settings. | | This | indicates | that | the | | | | | | | +| --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ---- | --------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +withgoldevidence. +MLLMsconsidertheprovidedgoldevidence. + +Annotator #Hops claims respectively. This suggests that although +MLLMsperformrelativelywell,thereisstillroom +| | | 1-hop | 2-hop | 3-hop | | 4-hop | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +forimprovementtomatchhumanperformance. +| Annotator1 | | 83.33 | 86.20 | 78.42 | | 79.82 | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Annotator2 | | | | | | | 5.3 ErrorAnalysis | | | | | | +| | | 82.46 | 88.29 | 79.45 | | 82.16 | | | | | | | +| Annotator3 | | 80.60 | 90.53 | 80.62 | | 85.24 | | | | | | | +Figure5,6,and7showstheerroranalysisofthe +| Annotator4 | | 79.64 | 86.50 | 82.32 | | 83.87 | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +falsepositiveexamplesfromGPT4-o,Gemini,and +| | | | | | | | LLaVA respectively. | | We | observe | that visual | mis- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---- | +Table5: Resultsofhumanperformanceon200random +| | | | | | | | interpretation | is | a major | issue, with | the | system | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | +samples. PerformancearemeasuredbyF-1score. +oftenmisidentifyingormiscontextualizingimage +| | | | | | | | elements. | Thisproblemisespeciallypronouncedin | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +examplesinvolvingsportslogosandmovieposters, +| Reasoning | Prompt | Results. | | Table | 4 reports | the | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +highlightingtheneedforimprovementsinthevi- +| performance | of | Gemini | and | GPT4-o | on | the ran- | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sualprocessingcomponent. +domlysampledsubsetofMMCVunderopen-book +Anothernotableissueisthesystem’shandling +| settings | using various | | prompts | that | elicit | LLMs’ | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | | | oftemporalandfactualinformation. | | | | Errorsrelated | | +| reasoning | abilities. | For | symbolic | | approach, | we | | | | | | | +toplayercareertimelinesandhistoricaleventsre- +askLLMstofirstgenerateaPython-likeprogram +| | | | | | | | veal shortcomings | | in temporal | reasoning | | and the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ------- | +thatdecomposesthemutli-hopclaimintoasetof +| | | | | | | | integrationofworldknowledge. | | | Thesystem’scon- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------------------- | ----- | ------- | --------------- | -------- | --- | +| function | calls that | describe | | the reasoning | | steps | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | fidence levels, | often | between | 80% | and 100% | for | +requiredtoverifytheclaim,andusethesymbolic +| | | | | | | | incorrect | predictions, | suggest | a miscalibration | | in | +| ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | -------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +| information | provided | | by the | generated | | program | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | certaintyestimation. | | Thisoverconfidenceinerro- | | | | +| to elicit | better | step-by-step | | reasoning | | from the | | | | | | | +neousconclusionshighlightstheneedforamore +| model. | We observe | | that | GPT-4-o | gains | more | | | | | | | +| ------ | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +refinedapproachtoconfidencescoring. +| from the | enhanced | reasoning | | prompt | compared | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Lastbutnotleast,examplesfromhigherhopcat- +| to Gemini, | achieving | | a higher | average | | F1 score | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +egoriesrevealsignificantweaknessesinhandling +| of 75.93 | in symbolic | | guided | reasoning, | | whereas | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | complexreasoningtasks. | | | Thesystemoftenstrug- | | | +GeminiattainsanaverageF1scoreof66.42forthe +gleswithmulti-steplogicalinferences,frequently +| same task. | Additionaly, | | we | found | that | Symbolic | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +failingtocoherentlylinkdisparatepiecesofinfor- +| approach | are more | effective | | on | 4-hop | claims, | | | | | | | +| -------- | ---------------- | --------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | | mation. This | limitation | is | especially | problematic | | +| having | a higher | F1 score | than | CoT | and | self-ask. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | for claims | that require | advanced | | analysis | or the | +| However, | this observation | | is | different | on | simpler | | | | | | | +cross-referencingofmultiplefacts. +2-hopand3-hopclaims,whereCoTappearstobe +moreeffective. +| | | | | | | | 6 Conclusion | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +HumanPerformanceResultsToestablishhuman In this paper, we introduce MMCV, a multi-hop +performanceonourdataset,werandomlysampled multimodalclaimverificationdatasetthatrequires +200 examples, with 50 examples from each hop models to aggregate information from up to four +fromMMCV.Werecruitedfourannotatorstoper- multimodalevidencetoverifyaclaim. Tocreate +form claim verification given the gold evidence. thislarge-scaledataset,wedevelopedanoveldata +Wetrainedourannotatorsonthetaskbyproviding collection pipeline that leverages the capabilities +themwithguidelinesandsampleannotationstoen- ofLLMscombinedwithhumanfeedback. Specif- +sureconsistencyandaccuracyintheirevaluations. ically, our approach includes a module that itera- +After training, the annotators independently veri- tivelyrefinesmodifiedclaimsusingfeedbackfrom +fiedeachclaimusingtheprovidedgoldevidence, a judge LLM based on a set of predefined crite- +allowing us to assess the human baseline perfor- ria,aswellasanactualityvalidationmodulethat +mance on the dataset. Table 5 reports the results employs RAG to ensure the factual accuracy of +from the human annotators. We observe that the the claims. Our results show that state-of-the-art +humanannotatorsachieveveryhighperformance MLLMs struggle to verify more complex claims +inverifyingtheclaimsacrossall4hops. Thehu- as the number of reasoning hops increases, often +manperformanceis23.3%and27.3%higherthan displayingoverconfidenceintheirpredictions. We +thebest-performingMLLMson3-hopand4-hop also present findings from experiments utilizing + +Acknowledgements +promptstailoredtoenhancethereasoningabilities +ofMLLMs,alongsidehumanperformancebench- +| | | | | | | | This material | | is based | upon | work supported | | by | +| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | -------------- | -------- | --- | +| marksforcomparison. | | | Additionally,wecategorize | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | the U.S. | Department | of | Homeland | | Security | un- | +andprovideadetailederroranalysisoffalseposi- +| | | | | | | | der Grant | Award | Number | 17STQAC00001-07- | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | +| tiveresultsfromeachmodel. | | | | WehopethatMMCV | | | | | | | | | | +04,NSFawards(SaTC-2241068,IIS-2339198),a +willinspirethedevelopmentofmodelscapableof +CiscoResearchAward,andaMicrosoftAccelerate +| conducting | complex, | | multi-hop | reasoning | | in the | | | | | | | | +| ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | ----- | +| | | | | | | | Foundation | Models | Research | | Award. | The | views | +challengingtaskofmultimodalclaimverification. +| | | | | | | | and conclusions | | contained | in | this document | | are | +| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | +| 7 Limitations | | | | | | | thoseoftheauthorsandshouldnotbeinterpretedas | | | | | | | +necessarilyrepresentingtheofficialpolicies,either +WeidentifytwomainlimitationsofMMCV.First, expressed or implied, of the U.S. Department of +theconstructionofMMCVdependsonin-context HomelandSecurityortheNationalScienceFoun- +learningcoupledwithself-refinementtoconverta +| | | | | | | | dation. | This | research was | partially | supported | | by | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | +naturallanguagequestion-answerpairintoamulti- theNationalInstituteOfDiabetesAndDigestive +hop claim. While this method has proven to be AndKidneyDiseasesoftheNationalInstitutesof +effective, it may face difficulties when dealing HealthunderAwardNumberK25DK135913. +| with questions | | with intricate | | grammar | structures | | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ---- | ----------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| and logical | structures. | | This | arises from | the | diffi- | | | | | | | | +References +cultyinconveyingcomplexgrammaticalrulesto +| the language | model | through | | a limited | number | of | | | | | | | | +| ------------ | ----- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +JoshAchiam,StevenAdler,SandhiniAgarwal,Lama +demonstrationswithinaconstrainedcontextsize. Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, +DiogoAlmeida,JankoAltenschmidt,SamAltman, +| Second, | our aggregation | | method | purely | relies | on | | | | | | | | +| ------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------ | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ShyamalAnadkat,etal.2023. | | | | Gpt-4technicalreport. | | | +LLMsthemselves,whichcouldintroducepotential arXivpreprintarXiv:2303.08774. +| hallucinationproblems. | | | Ontheotherhand,byus- | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +MubasharaAkhtar,MichaelSchlichtkrull,ZhijiangGuo, +ingamorerobustlogicsolvercouldhelpwiththe +| | | | | | | | OanaCocarascu, | | ElenaSimperl, | | andAndreasVla- | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | +hallucinationissues,buttherewouldbeatradeoff +| | | | | | | | chos.2023. | | Multimodalautomatedfact-checking: | | | | A | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +betweentheapplicabilityandtherobustnessofthe +| | | | | | | | survey. | InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputa- | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| model. | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | | EMNLP2023,pages5430–5448, | | | | | +Singapore.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- +| 8 EthicalStatement | | | | | | | tics. | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | +| Biases. | | | | | | | ShivangiAneja, | | ChrisBregler, | | andMatthiasNießner. | | | +Weacknowledgethepossibilityofbiases +| | | | | | | | 2021. | Cosmos: | Catching | out-of-context | | misinfor- | | +| ------------- | ----------------------------------- | -------- | ----- | ------------ | ---------- | ---- | ---------------------------------- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | --------- | --- | +| existing | within | the data | used | for training | the | lan- | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | mationwithself-supervisedlearning. | | | | arXivpreprint | | | +| guage models, | | as well | as in | certain | factuality | as- | arXiv:2101.06278. | | | | | | | +| sessments. | Unfortunately,thesefactorsarebeyond | | | | | | | | | | | | | +HanBao,YueHuang,YanboWang,JiayiYe,Xiangqi +ourcontrol. +Wang,XiuyinChen,MohamedElhoseiny,andXian- +| IntendedUseandMisusePotential. | | | | | Ourmodels | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | gliangZhang.2024. | | Autobench-v: | | Canlargevision- | | | +have the potential to verify complex multimodal language models benchmark themselves? arXiv +preprintarXiv:2410.21259. +| claims. | However, | it is | essential | to recognize | | that | | | | | | | | +| -------- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| they may | also | be susceptible | | to misuse | by | mali- | | | | | | | | +DongpingChen,YueHuang,SiyuanWu,JingyuTang, +ciousindividuals. Therefore,westronglyurgere- LiuyiChen,YilinBai,ZhigangHe,ChenlongWang, +| | | | | | | | HuichiZhou,YiqiangLi,etal.2024. | | | | | Gui-world: | A | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +searcherstoapproachtheirutilizationwithcaution +andprudence. datasetforgui-orientedmultimodalllm-basedagents. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.10819. +| Environmental | | Impact. | | We want | to highlight | | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +theenvironmentalimpactofusinglargelanguage Rob Chew, Michael Wenger, Caroline Kery, Jason +| | | | | | | | Nance, | Keith | Richards, | Emily | Hadley, | and | Peter | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----- | +models,whichdemandsubstantialcomputational +| | | | | | | | Baumgartner. | | 2019. | Smart: | an open | source | data | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ---- | +costsandrelyonGPUs/TPUsfortraining,which +| | | | | | | | labelingplatformforsupervisedlearning. | | | | | Journalof | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +contributestoglobalwarming. However,itisworth MachineLearningResearch,20(82):1–5. +notingthatourapproachdoesnottrainsuchmodels +| | | | | | | | Qingxiu | Dong, | Lei Li, Damai | | Dai, Ce | Zheng, | Zhiy- | +| ------------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ----- | +| fromscratch. | Instead,weusefew-shotin-context | | | | | | | | | | | | | +ongWu,BaobaoChang,XuSun,JingjingXu,and +| learning. | Nevertheless,thelargelanguagemodels | | | | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | ZhifangSui.2022. | | Asurveyonin-contextlearning. | | | | | +weusedinthispaperarelikelyrunningonGPU(s). arXivpreprintarXiv:2301.00234. + +YiFung,ChristopherThomas,RevanthGangiReddy, YiqiaoJin,MinjeChoi,GauravVerma,JindongWang, +SandeepPolisetty,HengJi,Shih-FuChang,Kathleen andSrijanKumar.2024a. Mm-soc: Benchmarking +McKeown,MohitBansal,andAviSil.2021. InfoSur- multimodallargelanguagemodelsinsocialmedia +geon: Cross-mediafine-grainedinformationconsis- platforms. arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.14154. +| tencycheckingforfakenewsdetection. | | | InProceed- | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | ---- | +| | | | | | Yiqiao Jin, | Yeon-Chang | | Lee, Kartik | Sharma, | Meng | +ingsofthe59thAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationfor +Ye,KaranSikka,AjayDivakaran,andSrijanKumar. +ComputationalLinguisticsandthe11thInternational +| | | | | | 2023. Predicting | | information | pathways | | across on- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | --- | ---------- | +JointConferenceonNaturalLanguageProcessing +(Volume1: LongPapers),pages1683–1698,Online. linecommunities. InProceedingsofthe29thACM +SIGKDDConferenceonKnowledgeDiscoveryand +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +DataMining,pages1044–1056. +ChujieGao,QihuiZhang,DongpingChen,YueHuang, +| | | | | | YiqiaoJin, | XitingWang, | | RuichaoYang, | YizhouSun, | | +| ------- | ------------------------------------- | ------- | --------------- | ------- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | --------------- | ---------- | +| Siyuan | Wu, Zhengyan | Fu, Yao | Wan, Xiangliang | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | WeiWang,HaoLiao,andXingXie.2022. | | | | | Towards | +| Zhang, | and Lichao Sun. | 2024. | The best | of both | | | | | | | +| | | | | | fine-grained | reasoning | | for fake | news detection. | In | +| worlds: | Towardanhonestandhelpfullargelanguage | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Proceedings | of | the AAAI | Conference | on | Artificial | +| model. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.00380. | | | | | | | | | | +Intelligence,volume36,pages5746–5754. +JiahuiGeng,FengyuCai,YuxiaWang,HeinzKoeppl, YiqiaoJin,QinlinZhao,YiyangWang,HaoChen,Kai- +PreslavNakov,andIrynaGurevych.2024a. Asur- jieZhu,YijiaXiao,andJindongWang.2024b. Agen- +veyofconfidenceestimationandcalibrationinlarge treview: Exploringpeerreviewdynamicswithllm +| languagemodels. | InProceedingsofthe2024Con- | | | | | | | | | | +| --------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | agents. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2406.12708. | | | | | +ferenceoftheNorthAmericanChapteroftheAsso- +| | | | | | DanielKhashabi, | | SnigdhaChaturvedi, | | MichaelRoth, | | +| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | +| ciationforComputationalLinguistics: | | | HumanLan- | | | | | | | | +guageTechnologies(Volume1: LongPapers),pages Shyam Upadhyay, and Dan Roth. 2018. Looking +| 6577–6595. | | | | | beyondthesurface: | | Achallengesetforreadingcom- | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| | | | | | prehensionovermultiplesentences. | | | | InProceedings | | +JiahuiGeng,YovaKementchedjhieva,PreslavNakov, ofthe2018ConferenceoftheNorthAmericanChap- +andIrynaGurevych.2024b. Multimodallargelan- teroftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics: +guage models to support real-world fact-checking. HumanLanguageTechnologies,Volume1(LongPa- +arXivpreprintarXiv:2403.03627. pers),pages252–262,NewOrleans,Louisiana.As- +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +ZhijiangGuo,MichaelSchlichtkrull,andAndreasVla- +chos. 2022. A survey on automated fact-checking. PatrickLewis,EthanPerez,AleksandraPiktus,Fabio +TransactionsoftheAssociationforComputational Petroni,VladimirKarpukhin,NamanGoyal,Hein- +Linguistics,10:178–206. richKüttler, MikeLewis, Wen-tauYih, TimRock- +| | | | | | täschel,etal.2020. | | Retrieval-augmentedgeneration | | | | +| ------------ | ------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | +| | | | | | forknowledge-intensivenlptasks. | | | | AdvancesinNeu- | | +| Tanmay Gupta | and Aniruddha | Kembhavi. | | 2023. Vi- | | | | | | | +ralInformationProcessingSystems,33:9459–9474. +| sualprogramming: | Compositionalvisualreasoning | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| withouttraining. | InProceedingsoftheIEEE/CVF | | | | | | | | | | +MiaoranLi,BaolinPeng,MichelGalley,JianfengGao, +ConferenceonComputerVisionandPatternRecog- +| | | | | | andZhuZhang.2024. | | | Self-checker: | Plug-and-play | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | +nition,pages14953–14962. +modulesforfact-checkingwithlargelanguagemod- +Baixiang Huang, Canyu Chen, and Kai Shu. 2024a. els. InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputational +| | | | | | Linguistics: | NAACL2024,pages163–181,Mexico | | | | | +| --------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------- | ----- | ------------- | ----------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ---- | +| Authorship | attribution | in the era | of llms: | Prob- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | City, Mexico. | | Association | for | Computational | Lin- | +| lems,methodologies,andchallenges. | | | arXivpreprint | | | | | | | | +guistics. +arXiv:2408.08946. +HaotianLiu,ChunyuanLi,QingyangWu,andYongJae +| BaixiangHuang,CanyuChen,andKaiShu.2024b. | | | | Can | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------------------- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | +| | | | | | Lee.2024a. | Visualinstructiontuning. | | | Advancesin | | +| large language | models | identify authorship? | | arXiv | | | | | | | +neuralinformationprocessingsystems,36. +preprintarXiv:2403.08213. +| | | | | | Yixin Liu, | Kai Zhang, | Yuan | Li, Zhiling | Yan, | Chujie | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | ---- | ------ | +Yue Huang, Zhengqing Yuan, Yujun Zhou, Kehan Gao, Ruoxi Chen, Zhengqing Yuan, Yue Huang, +Guo,XiangqiWang,HaominZhuang,WeixiangSun, Hanchi Sun, Jianfeng Gao, et al. 2024b. Sora: A +LichaoSun,JindongWang,YanfangYe,etal.2024c. +reviewonbackground,technology,limitations,and +Socialsciencemeetsllms:Howreliablearelargelan- +| | | | | | opportunitiesoflargevisionmodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +arXivpreprint +| guagemodelsinsocialsimulations? | | | | | arXiv:2402.17177. | | | | | | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXiv:2410.23426. +YaoLu,MaxBartolo,AlastairMoore,SebastianRiedel, +Yichen Jiang, Shikha Bordia, Zheng Zhong, Charles and Pontus Stenetorp. 2022. Fantastically ordered +Dognin, Maneesh Singh, and Mohit Bansal. 2020. promptsandwheretofindthem: Overcomingfew- +HoVer: Adatasetformany-hopfactextractionand shotpromptordersensitivity. InProceedingsofthe +claim verification. In Findings of the Association 60thAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforCompu- +forComputationalLinguistics: EMNLP2020,pages tationalLinguistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages +3441–3460,Online.AssociationforComputational 8086–8098,Dublin,Ireland.AssociationforCompu- +| Linguistics. | | | | | tationalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +GraceLuo,TrevorDarrell,andAnnaRohrbach.2021. RobinRombach,AndreasBlattmann,DominikLorenz, +NewsCLIPpings: AutomaticGenerationofOut-of- Patrick Esser, and Björn Ommer. 2022. High- +ContextMultimodalMedia. InProceedingsofthe resolutionimagesynthesiswithlatentdiffusionmod- +2021ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNatural els. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF conference +LanguageProcessing,pages6801–6817,Onlineand oncomputervisionandpatternrecognition, pages +| Punta | Cana, | Dominican | Republic. | Association | for | 10684–10695. | | | | | | +| ----- | ----- | --------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ComputationalLinguistics. +MelanieSclar,YejinChoi,YuliaTsvetkov,andAlane +VaibhavMavi,AnubhavJangra,andAdamJatowt.2022. Suhr.2023. Quantifyinglanguagemodels’sensitiv- +Asurveyonmulti-hopquestionansweringandgen- itytospuriousfeaturesinpromptdesignor: Howi +eration. arXivpreprintarXiv:2204.09140. learned to start worrying about prompt formatting. +arXivpreprintarXiv:2310.11324. +ShreyashMishra,SSuryavardan,AmritBhaskar,Parul +Chopra,AishwaryaNReganti,ParthPatwa,Amitava +KaiShu,DeepakMahudeswaran,SuhangWang,Dong- +Das,TanmoyChakraborty,AmitPSheth,AsifEkbal, wonLee,andHuanLiu.2020. Fakenewsnet: Adata +etal.2022. Factify: Amulti-modalfactverification repositorywithnewscontent,socialcontext,andspa- +dataset. InDE-FACTIFY@AAAI. tiotemporalinformationforstudyingfakenewson +| | | | | | | socialmedia. | Bigdata,8(3):171–188. | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +LongOuyang,JeffreyWu,XuJiang,DiogoAlmeida, +CarrollWainwright,PamelaMishkin,ChongZhang, +| | | | | | | AlonTalmorandJonathanBerant.2018. | | | | Thewebas | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | +SandhiniAgarwal,KatarinaSlama,AlexRay,etal. +aknowledge-baseforansweringcomplexquestions. +| 2022. | Training | languagemodelsto | | followinstruc- | | | | | | | | +| ----- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXivpreprintarXiv:1803.06643. +| tionswithhumanfeedback. | | | Advancesinneuralin- | | | | | | | | | +| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +formationprocessingsystems,35:27730–27744. Alon Talmor, Ori Yoran, Amnon Catav, Dan Lahav, +| | | | | | | Yizhong Wang, | Akari | Asai, | Gabriel | Ilharco, | Han- | +| ----------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --------------------------------------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | +| AlizéePace, | JonathanMallinson, | | | EricMalmi, | Sebas- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | nanehHajishirzi,andJonathanBerant.2021. | | | | | Mul- | +| tianKrause,andAliakseiSeveryn.2024. | | | | | West-of-n: | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | timodalqa: | Complex | question | answering | | over text, | +Syntheticpreferencegenerationforimprovedreward +| | | | | | | tablesandimages. | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2104.06039. | | | | +| --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| modeling. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2401.12086. | | | | | | | | | | | +ZhenTan,AlimohammadBeigi,SongWang,Ruocheng +| Liangming | Pan, | Michael Saxon, | | Wenda Xu, | Deepak | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Guo,AmritaBhattacharjee,BohanJiang,Mansooreh +| Nathani, | Xinyi | Wang, | and William | Yang | Wang. | | | | | | | +| -------- | ----- | ----- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Karami,JundongLi,LuCheng,andHuanLiu.2024. +| 2023a. | | Automatically | correcting | | large lan- | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | +| | | | | | | Largelanguagemodelsfordataannotation: | | | | | Asurvey. | +| guage | models: | Surveying | the | landscape | of di- | | | | | | | +arXivpreprintarXiv:2402.13446. +| verse | self-correction | strategies. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | +| ----- | --------------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +arXiv:2308.03188. +| | | | | | | Gemini Team, | Rohan | Anil, | Sebastian | Borgeaud, | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | Yonghui | Wu, Jean-Baptiste | | Alayrac, | Jiahui | Yu, | +LiangmingPan,XiaobaoWu,XinyuanLu,AnhTuan +Luu,WilliamYangWang,Min-YenKan,andPreslav Radu Soricut, Johan Schalkwyk, Andrew M Dai, +Nakov.2023b. Fact-checkingcomplexclaimswith Anja Hauth, et al. 2023. Gemini: a family of +| | | | | | | highlycapablemultimodalmodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | | +| -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| program-guided | | reasoning. | In | Proceedings | of the | | | | | | | +arXiv:2312.11805. +61stAnnualMeetingoftheAssociationforCompu- +| tationalLinguistics(Volume1: | | | | LongPapers),pages | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | +| | | | | | | JamesThorneandAndreasVlachos.2018. | | | | Automated | | +6981–7004,Toronto,Canada.AssociationforCom- +| | | | | | | fact checking: | Task | formulations, | | methods | and fu- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | +putationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | ture directions. | | In Proceedings | of | the 27th | Inter- | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | +Yikang Pan, Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, Preslav nationalConferenceonComputationalLinguistics, +pages3346–3359,SantaFe,NewMexico,USA.As- +| Nakov, | Min-Yen | Kan, | and William | Wang. | 2023c. | | | | | | | +| ------ | ------- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| On the | risk | of misinformation | | pollution | with large | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------ | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | +| language | models. | In Findings | | of the Association | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | James Thorne, | | Andreas | Vlachos, | | Christos | +| forComputationalLinguistics: | | | | EMNLP2023,pages | | | | | | | | +1389–1403, Singapore. Association for Computa- Christodoulopoulos, and Arpit Mittal. 2018. +tionalLinguistics. FEVER: a large-scale dataset for fact extraction +| | | | | | | and VERification. | | In | Proceedings | of | the 2018 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | +OfirPress,MuruZhang,SewonMin,LudwigSchmidt, Conference of the North American Chapter of +| | | | | | | the Association | | for Computational | | Linguistics: | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | +| NoahSmith,andMikeLewis.2023. | | | | Measuringand | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Human Language | | Technologies, | | Volume | 1 (Long | +narrowingthecompositionalitygapinlanguagemod- +els. InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputational Papers), pages 809–819, New Orleans, Louisiana. +Linguistics: EMNLP2023,pages5687–5711,Singa- AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +pore.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| | | | | | | HaoranWangandKaiShu.2023. | | | Explainableclaim | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | +Aditya Ramesh, Mikhail Pavlov, Gabriel Goh, Scott verificationviaknowledge-groundedreasoningwith +Gray,ChelseaVoss,AlecRadford,MarkChen,and largelanguagemodels. InFindingsoftheAssocia- +IlyaSutskever.2021. Zero-shottext-to-imagegener- tionforComputationalLinguistics: EMNLP2023, +ation. InInternationalconferenceonmachinelearn- pages6288–6304,Singapore.AssociationforCom- +| ing,pages8821–8831.Pmlr. | | | | | | putationalLinguistics. | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +Haoran Wang and Kai Shu. 2024. Trojan activation QihuiZhang,ChujieGao,DongpingChen,YueHuang, +attack: Red-teaming large language models using YixinHuang, ZhenyangSun, ShilinZhang, Weiye +steeringvectorsforsafety-alignment. InProceedings Li, ZhengyanFu, YaoWan, etal.2024. Llm-as-a- +of the 33rd ACM International Conference on In- coauthor: Can mixed human-written and machine- +formationandKnowledgeManagement,CIKM’24, generatedtextbedetected? InFindingsoftheAsso- +page2347–2357,NewYork,NY,USA.Association ciationforComputationalLinguistics: NAACL2024, +| forComputingMachinery. | | | | | | | pages409–436. | | | | +| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | +Ruida Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, and Mrinmaya DimitrinaZlatkova,PreslavNakov,andIvanKoychev. +Sachan. 2023. Let’s synthesize step by step: Iter- 2019. Fact-checking meets fauxtography: Verify- +ative dataset synthesis with large language models ing claims about images. In Proceedings of the +| | | | | | | | 2019 Conference | on Empirical | Methods | in Natu- | +| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | +| byextrapolatingerrorsfromsmallmodels. | | | | | | InFind- | | | | | +ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguis- ralLanguageProcessingandthe9thInternational +tics: EMNLP2023,pages11817–11831,Singapore. JointConferenceonNaturalLanguageProcessing +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. (EMNLP-IJCNLP),pages2099–2108,HongKong, +China.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +| William Yang | Wang. | 2017. | “liar, | liar | pants on | fire”: | | | | | +| -------------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| A new | benchmark | dataset | for | fake | news detection. | | | | | | +| In Proceedings | | of the | 55th | Annual | Meeting | of the | | | | | +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics(Volume2: +ShortPapers),pages422–426,Vancouver,Canada. +AssociationforComputationalLinguistics. +JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten +Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou, +| etal.2022. | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelicitsrea- | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| soninginlargelanguagemodels. | | | | Advancesinneural | | | | | | | +informationprocessingsystems,35:24824–24837. +JohannesWelbl,PontusStenetorp,andSebastianRiedel. +| 2018. Constructing | | datasets | | for multi-hop | | reading | | | | | +| ----------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| comprehensionacrossdocuments. | | | | | Transactionsof | | | | | | +theAssociationforComputationalLinguistics,6:287– +302. +SiyuanWu,YueHuang,ChujieGao,DongpingChen, +| Qihui Zhang, | | Yao Wan, | Tianyi | Zhou, | Xiangliang | | | | | | +| -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Zhang, | Jianfeng | Gao, | Chaowei | Xiao, | et al. | 2024. | | | | | +| Unigen: | Aunifiedframeworkfortextualdatasetgen- | | | | | | | | | | +| erationusinglargelanguagemodels. | | | | | arXivpreprint | | | | | | +arXiv:2406.18966. +RuichaoYang,XitingWang,YiqiaoJin,ChaozhuoLi, +| JianxunLian,andXingXie.2022. | | | | | Reinforcement | | | | | | +| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| subgraphreasoningforfakenewsdetection. | | | | | | InPro- | | | | | +ceedingsofthe28thACMSIGKDDConferenceon +KnowledgeDiscoveryandDataMining,pages2253– +2262. +ZhilinYang,PengQi,SaizhengZhang,YoshuaBengio, +WilliamCohen,RuslanSalakhutdinov,andChristo- +| pher D. | Manning. | 2018. | HotpotQA: | | A dataset | for | | | | | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| diverse, | explainablemulti-hopquestionanswering. | | | | | | | | | | +| In Proceedings | | of the | 2018 | Conference | on | Empiri- | | | | | +calMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages +2369–2380,Brussels,Belgium.AssociationforCom- +putationalLinguistics. +BarryMenglongYao,AdityaShah,LichaoSun,Jin-Hee +| Cho,andLifuHuang.2023. | | | | End-to-endmultimodal | | | | | | | +| ------------------------ | --------------- | --------------- | ----- | -------------------- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| fact-checking | | and explanation | | generation: | | A chal- | | | | | +| lengingdatasetandmodels. | | | | InProceedingsofthe | | | | | | | +| 46th International | | ACM | SIGIR | Conference | | on Re- | | | | | +| search | and Development | | in | Information | Retrieval, | | | | | | +pages2733–2743. + +A Appendix +| | | | | | ClaimGenerationPrompt. | | | Weusethefollowing | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | +prompttoconvertmultimodalQApairsintoclaim +A.1 DatasetExample +candidates: +| HereisanexampleofdatasetschemafromMMCV: | | | | | Prompt | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | ------------------------ | --------- | ---------------- | ------------- | --------------- | ---- | +| Example | | | | | You are | an expert | | in converting | | | +| | | | | | question-answers | | | into | claims. | | +| claim: | Stoke | City, | a | club that was | | | | | | | +| | | | | | For example: | | Question: | | Telos | was | +| part of | the | top-tier | league | before | | | | | | | +| | | | | | an album | by | a band | who | formed | in | +| 1992, was | promoted | | to | the highest | | | | | | | +| | | | | | what city? | | Answer: | Indianapolis. | | | +| level of | English | | football | in 2018. | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Claim: | Telos | was | an album | | by a | +| wiki_context: | | The | Premier | League | | | | | | | +| | | | | | band formed | | in Indianapolis. | | | | +| is the | highest | level | of | the English | | | | | | | +| football | league | system. | | Contested | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Convert | the | question-answer | | | into | +| by 20 clubs, | | it operates | | on a | | | | | | | +| | | | | | claim. | Return | only | the | claim | and | +| system | of promotion | | and | relegation | | | | | | | +| | | | | | nothing | else. | | | | | +| with the | English | | Football | League | | | | | | | +| (EFL). | Seasons | usually | | run from | | | | | | | +| August | to May, | with | each | team | | | | | | | +| | | | | | ClaimModificationPrompt. | | | | Weusethefollow- | | +| playing | 38 matches: | | two | against | | | | | | | +each other, one home and one away. ingprompttomodifytheclaimcandidates: +| Most games | are | played | | on weekend | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Prompt +| afternoons, | | with | occasional | weekday | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | +| evening | fixtures. | | | | Generate | a multi-hop | | specific | | | +| text_evidence: | | [ | | | claim based | | on the | given | general | | +"f369cee1ca92368c8b1ea564c5e41fc1" claim and Wikipedia context. The +| ] | | | | | specific | claim | should: | | | | +| ---------------------------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | --- | +| image_evidence: | | | [] | | | | | | | | +| table_evidence: | | | [ | | Incorporate | | information | | from | | +| "c120efadd518b5f32c11d40b456c8570" | | | | | Wikipedia | context. | | | | | +| ] | | | | | Provided | context | | should | always | be | +| label: | SUPPORT | | | | factually | correct. | | | | | +| | | | | | Obscure | key | information | | by: | | +| | | | | | a) Replacing | | one | or two | central | | +Additionalexamplesof1-hop,2-hop,3-hop,and entities with related fact using +| 4-hopclaimsarelistedinTable6 | | | | | the Wikipedia | | context. | | | | +| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | +| | | | | | b) Alluding | | to critical | | details | | +| | | | | | without | explicitly | | stating | | them. | +A.2 ExperimentPrompt +| | | | | | Claim should | | be short | | and concise. | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | +For example: +| Claim Verification | | Prompt. | | To test MLLMs’ | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +claimverificationperformanceunderzero-shotset- - General Claim: The Mona Lisa +tings, wefollow(Gengetal.,2024b)andusethe is a famous painting by Leonardo da +Vinci. +followingprompt. +| | | | | | - Wikipedia | | Context: | | The Mona | Lisa | +| ---------------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------ | ----------------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | +| Prompt | | | | | is a half-length | | | portrait | painting | | +| | | | | | by Italian | artist | | Leonardo | | da | +| Given a | claim | and | evidence | (which | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Vinci. | Considered | | an | archetypal | | +| can be | text, | table, | or | an image), | | | | | | | +| | | | | | masterpiece | | of the | Italian | | | +| determine | whether | | the | claim is | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Renaissance, | | it has | been | described | | +| SUPPORT | or REFUTE | | by the | evidence. | ¨the | | | | | | +| | | | | | as | best | known, | the | most | | +| | | | | | visited, | the | most | written | about, | | +| Use the | following | | format | to provide | | | | | | | +| | | | | | the most | sung | about, | the | most | | +| your answer: | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | parodied | work | of | art in | the | world¨. | +| Prediction: | | [True | or | False] | | | | | | | +| | | | | | The painting’s | | novel | qualities | | | +| Explanation: | | [put | your | evidence | | | | | | | +| | | | | | include | the | subject’s | | enigmatic | | +| and step-by-step | | | reasoning | here] | | | | | | | +| | | | | | expression, | | the monumentality | | | | +| Confidence | Level: | | [please | show the | | | | | | | +| | | | | | of the | composition, | | the | subtle | | +percentage] +| | | | | | modelling | of | forms, | and | the | | +| --------- | -------------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --- | --- | +| | | | | | atmospheric | | illusionism. | | It | is | +| Note: | The confidence | | | level | | | | | | | +| | | | | | housed | in the | Louvre | Museum | | in | +| indicates | the | degree | of | certainty | | | | | | | +| | | | | | Paris, | where | it was | first | put | on | +| you have | about | your | answer | and | | | | | | | +| | | | | | display | in 1797. | | | | | +is represented as a percentage. - Specific Claim: The Mona Lisa is +For instance, if your confidence a half-length portrait painting +level is 80%, it means you are 80% created by Italian artist who +certain that your answer is correct is considered as archetypal +| and there | is | a 20% | chance | that it | masterpiece | | of the | Italian | | | +| --------- | ---------- | ----- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | +| may be | incorrect. | | | | Renaissance. | | | | | | + +ClaimRefinementPrompt. Weusethefollowing A.3 AnnotationGuidelines +prompttorefinetheclaimcandidates: +| | | | | | | We ask | our annotators | | to score | the quality | of the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +Prompt +| | | | | | | claimfromthreeaspects: | | | fluency,correctness,and | | | +| -------------- | ------ | ---- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | +| You are | tasked | with | improving | | a | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | clearness. | Hereisthedetailedguidelinesprovided | | | | | +| claim focusing | | on | three | key | areas: | | | | | | | +tothehumanannotators. +| Fluency, | Correctness, | | | and Clearness. | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Your goal | is | to enhance | | the | text | | | | | | | Guidelines - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$3.33 - -$2.93 - -$0.33 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -+$0.06 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Source: USDA-FNS, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/07/19/2018-15465/national-school-lunch- -special-milk-and-school-breakfast-programs-national-average-paymentsmaximum. For NSLP reimbursement rates -for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: -https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -Note: For school year 2018-2019, the maximum rate for 48 states and DC is $3.48 per free meal, $3.08 per -reduced-price meal, and $0.30 per paid meal (and an additional $0.06 for nutrition guidelines). The maximum -rate is the maximum per-lunch rate that a state can provide a school food authority. - -Table B-2. Reimbursement Rates, NSLP: After-School Snacks -Per-snack reimbursements for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Snack Type - -Reimbursement - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For after-school snack NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or -participating territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -118 All reimbursement rate tables in this Appendix display rates for the 48 continental U.S. states. For Alaska, Hawaii, -and territories where applicable, please see the source USDA-FNS Federal Register notice. -119 For more detail on how inflation adjustment is conducted, see the child nutrition program sections of CRS Report -R42000, Inflation-Indexing Elements in Federal Entitlement Programs, coordinated by Dawn Nuschler. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -38 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Table B-3. Reimbursement Rates, SBP -Per-meal reimbursement for 48 states and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Meal Type - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -Non-severe Need -(less than 40% free or -reduced price)a - -Severe Need -(greater than or equal to 40% -free or reduced price)a - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -$2.14 - -$1.84 - -$0.31 - -Source: USDA-FNS. For NSLP reimbursement rates for other years, Alaska, Hawaii, and/or participating -territories, see USDA-FNS website: https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. -a. Generally, severe need status is determined based on the percentage of meals served two school years -prior to the year the currently reimbursed meal is served. For example, a school district’s severe need -status in school year 2018-2019 would be calculated based on meals served in school year 2016-2017. - -Table B-4. Commodity Food Assistance, NSLP and CACFP (Centers) -Rate per-meal for school year 2018-2019 - -For Each NSLP/CACFP Meal Served - -Commodity Food Reimbursement - -$0.2350 - -Source: USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Food Distribution Program: Value of Donated Foods From July 1, -2018, Through June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 35607, July 1, 2018. -Notes: For past years, see USDA-FNS website: http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/value-donated-foods-notices. SFSP -has a different commodity food assistance rate, see Table B-7. - -Table B-5. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Centers, At-Risk After-School -Programs -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Free - -Reduced-price - -Paid - -$3.31 - -$2.91 - -$0.31 - -$1.79 - -$1.49 - -$0.31 - -Snack - -$0.91 - -$0.45 - -$0.08 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Notes: These reimbursement rates are identical to NSLP and SBP rates. - -Table B-6. Reimbursement Rates, CACFP: Child Care Homes -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 States and DC, school year 2018-2019 - -Tier I - -Tier II - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -$2.46 - -$1.48 - -$1.31 - -$0.48 - -Snack - -$0.73 - -$0.20 - -Source: For historical program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see -http://www.fns.usda.gov/cacfp/reimbursement-rates. -Note: CACFP also provides administrative reimbursements to sponsoring organizations of day care homes. -Based on the number of homes sponsored, funding is provided per home, per month. These rates are not - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -39 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -displayed in this table but are included in USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, “Child and Adult Care Food -Program: National Average Payment Rates, Day Care Home Food Service Payment Rates, and Administrative -Reimbursement Rates for Sponsoring Organizations of Day Care Homes for the Period July 1, 2018 Through -June 30, 2019,” 83 Federal Register 34108, July 1, 2018. - -Table B-7. Reimbursement Rates, SFSP -Per-meal/snack reimbursement for 48 states and DC (rounded to nearest cent), calendar year 2018 - -Lunch/Supper - -Breakfast - -Snack - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -Rural or -Self-Prep - -All Other -Sites - -$3.55 - -$3.55 - -$2.03 - -$2.03 - -$0.83 - -$0.83 - -$0.37 - -$0.31 - -$0.20 - -$0.16 - -$0.10 - -$0.08 - -$3.92 - -$3.86 - -$2.23 - -$2.19 - -$0.93 - -$0.91 - -Operating -Component - -Administrative -Component - -Combined (Total) -Rate - -Source: For program reimbursement rates as well as Alaska’s and Hawaii’s rates, see USDA, Food and -Nutrition Service, “Summer Food Service Program; 2018 Reimbursement Rates,” 83 Federal Register 4025, -January 29, 2018. -Note: Per authorizing law, the administrative component is calculated to the nearest quarter-cent. This table -rounds to the nearest cent. As the table shows, the administrative component varies slightly (e.g., by about 5 -cents for lunches) depending on the location of the site (e.g., rural vs. urban) and whether meals are prepared -on-site or by a vendor. For meals prepared on-site, providers receive 1.5 cents per meal in USDA commodity -foods. - -Table B-8. Reimbursement Rates, SMP -Per half-pint reimbursement for 48 States and DC (rounded to nearest cent), school year 2018-2019 - -All Milk Served - -Paid Milk - -Free Milk to Low- -Income Children - -Schools that only -sell milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Schools that sell -and provide free -milk - -Schools that -provide only free -milk - -Not applicable - -$0.21 - -Average cost per -half-pint of milk - -$0.21 - -Not applicable - -Not applicable - -Source: For program reimbursement rates, see https://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/rates-reimbursement. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -40 - - School Meals Programs and Other USDA Child Nutrition Programs: A Primer - -Author Information - -Kara Clifford Billings -Analyst in Social Policy - - Randy Alison Aussenberg - -Specialist in Nutrition Assistance Policy - -Acknowledgments - -Disclaimer - -This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan -shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and -under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other -than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in -connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not -subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in -its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or -material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to -copy or otherwise use copyrighted material. - -Congressional Research Service - -R43783 · VERSION 21 · UPDATED - -41 - +| while maintaining | | | its | original | | | | | | | | +| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +▷ScoringCriteria: +| meaning | and | intent. | | | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------------------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | Fluency: | Rateonascaleof1-4. | | | | | +| Improvement | | Criteria: | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | Correctness: | | Rateonascaleof1-3. | | | | +Fluency: +| 1. Review | the | text | for | grammar, | | ClearnessRateonascaleof1-3. | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| syntax, | and | punctuation | | errors. | | | | | | | | +| 2. Rephrase | | any | awkward | or | | | | | | | | +▷Fluency(1-4): +| unnatural | sentences | | to | make | the | | | | | | | +| --------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +text flow more smoothly. 4: Excellent-Readsnaturally,noawkward +| 3. Ensure | that | the | text | reads | | phrasing. | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | +| naturally | and | is | easy | to follow. | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 3: Good | - | Mostly | smooth, | minor | phrasing | +| Correctness: | | | | | | issues. | | | | | | +| 1. Verify | the | factual | | accuracy | of | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 2: Fair | - | Several | awkward | phrases | or | +| the content | | and correct | | any | errors. | | | | | | | +constructions. +| 2. Ensure | that | the | text | adheres | to | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +the prompt’s instructions. 1: Poor - Difficult to read, very unnatural +| 3. Clarify | | any ambiguities | | | and | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +phrasing. +| correct | any | inconsistencies | | | in the | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| information | | presented. | | | | | | | | | | +▷Correctness(1-3): +Clearness: +3: Fullycorrect-Allinformationisaccurate. +| 1. Simplify | | complex | sentences | | or | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +ideas to make the text easier to 2: Partially correct - Some information is +| understand. | | | | | | accurate,someerrors. | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------- | ---------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | --------- | +| 2. Improve | | the organization | | | of | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1: Incorrect | | - Significant | | factual | errors or | +| ideas to | enhance | | readability. | | | | | | | | | +| 3. Ensure | that | the | message | | is | misrepresentations. | | | | | | +| conveyed | clearly | | and effectively, | | | | | | | | | +| eliminating | | any confusion | | or | | | | | | | | +▷Clearness(1-3): +ambiguity. +| | | | | | | 3: Very | clear | - | Easy to | understand, | no | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +Final Output: +ambiguity. +| Once you | have | made | the | necessary | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------- | ------- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | --------------------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | +| | | | | | | 2: Somewhat | | clear | - Some | parts | may be | +| improvements, | | provide | | the revised | | | | | | | | +| text. | Ensure | that | the | improved | | confusingorambiguous. | | | | | | +| version | is more | fluent, | | accurate, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 1: Unclear | | - Difficult | to | understand | the | +| and clear | than | the | original | | while | | | | | | | +intendedmeaning. +| preserving | the | original | | meaning | and | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +intent. +| Example | Improvement: | | | | | | | | | | | +| ---------------- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Original | Claim: | | "The | results | of | | | | | | | +| the survey | was | very | positive, | | with | A.4 CrowdWorkerInterface | | | | | | +| many respondents | | | saying | that | they | | | | | | | +would recommend the service to We use SMART (Chew et al., 2019), an open- +| others, | however, | | some | were | also | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +sourceprojectdesignedtohelpdatascientistsand +| mentioned | issues | | with | the customer | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | research | teams | efficiently | build | labeled | training | +support." +Improved Claim: "The survey datasetsforsupervisedmachinelearningtasks. Fig- +| results | were | overwhelmingly | | | | | | | | | | +| --------- | ---- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | +| | | | | | | ure 4 shows | an | example | of | the worker | interface | +| positive, | with | many | respondents | | | | | | | | | +duringscoringprocedure. +| stating | they | would | recommend | | the | | | | | | | +| ---------- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| service | to others. | | However, | | some | | | | | | | +| also noted | issues | | with | customer | | | | | | | | +support. + +| #H Claim | | | Evidence | | +| -------- | --------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | +| 1 Claim: | MarisaCoughlanplayedtherole | | | | +ofChanteLefortontelevisionin1996. +| 2 Claim: | The driver | seen signing auto- | | | +| -------- | ---------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | +graphsoutsidehadasignificantpointsto- +| tal during | a specific race | in 2001 while | | | +| ---------- | --------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | +competingforawell-knownteaminstock +carracing. +3 Claim: TheGreenBayPackerswereone DocA:ThefirstAFL-NFLWorldChampionshipGamein +of the two teams that played in the first professionalAmericanfootball,knownretroactivelyasSuper +| SuperBowlandalsofacedtheNewYork | | | BowlIand... | ... | +| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | +GiantsatMetLifeStadiumduringthe2013 DocB:TheNationalFootballLeague(NFL)championGreen +regularseason. BayPackersdefeatedtheAmericanFootballLeague(AFL) +championKansasCityChiefs... ... +Table: NotIncludedHere +4 Claim: The team that was promoted to Doc A: Manchester City are the defending champions. +thePremierLeagueinthe2018-19season Wolverhampton Wanderers, Cardiff City and Fulham join +received a higher accolade in the Third asthepromotedclubsfromthe2017–18EFLChampionship. +| DivisionPFATeamoftheYearduringthe | | | ... ... | | +| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | +1980s than a club renowned for its West DocB:...TheywillreplaceWestBromwichAlbion,Swansea +Londonrivalries. CityandStokeCitywhowererelegatedtothe2018–19EFL +| | | | Championship. | ... | +| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | +Table: NotIncludedHere +Image: NotIncludedHere +| | Table6: Examplesof1-hop,2-hop,3-hopand4-hopclaimsfromMMCV. | | | | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | --------------------- | --- | +| | | Figure4: | UIforhumanannotators. | | + +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +| | Claim: Jakub Janda, a prominent | Claim: The team that a player | Claim: The opponent in the regular | +| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ----------------------------------- | +Claim: Durham, North Carolina, figure in ski jumping, represents a transferred from to Real Betis in season schedule of the 1991 +features a water tower located far +| | country recognized by its flag that | the 2018–19 season, which | Chicago Bears, known for their | +| --- | ------------------------------------ | -------------------------- | ------------------------------- | +from any building's chimney. +| | does not include a blue triangle. | features a flagpole in their logo, is | human logo, was a different team | +| ------------------- | --------------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +| True Label: REFUTE. | | | from which Roman Reigns had | +| | True Label: REFUTE | not Real Sociedad. | | +| | | True Label: REFUTE | long careers in the NFL. | +True Label: REFUTE. +o 4-TPG +| Predicted Label: SUPPORT | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | | +| ------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------ | +| Explanation: The image shows a | Explanation: Claudio Pizarro was | | | +| | | Explanation: China does indeed | Predicted Label: SUPPORT | +water tower in Durham, North born in October 1978, which makes host numerous kite festivals Explanation: The image shows a +Carolina, which appears to be him 45 years old as of October throughout the year, including the CASA C-212 Aviocar aircraft, which +situated away from any visible 2023. If the unnamed Peruvian Weifang International Kite Festival, is a turboprop aircraft. Turboprop +building chimneys. The footballer is not which is a … like Latin America, aircraft are powered by propellers. +… tower is located far from any … footballer, the claim that Pizarro Southeast Asia, and Africa. Confidence Level: 95% +| building's chimney. | is older is supported. | Confidence Level: 95% | | +| --------------------- | ----------------------- | --------------------- | --- | +| Confidence Level: 85% | Confidence Level: 85% | | | +| | Figure5: ErrorAnalysis: | Gemini | | +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +Claim: The background of the +| | Claim: Rochdale finished higher in | Claim: In the film directed by a | Claim: The Argentine Naval | +| ---------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | --------------------------- | +| American legal drama series | the final league table of the | British filmmaker unknown for his | | +Prefecture operates CASA C-212 +| created by David E. Kelley is clear, | 1994–95 season compared to the | collaboration with Walt Disney | | +| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | +Aviocar aircraft, +| especially concerning its | team known for its tree emblem, | Studios, a Jamaican actor | | +| -------------------------- | -------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | +exploration of legal ethics versus which has a history of competing in infamous for his which are equipped with propellers. +True Label: REFUTE. +| personal morality, which aimed to | lower divisions. | role in a drama appears alongside | | +| ---------------------------------- | ------------------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | +| reinforce a more romanticized | True Label: REFUTE | two others in a car. | | +depiction of the legal system. +True Label: REFUTE. +True Label: REFUTE. +inimeG +Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT +Explanation: Extensive research +| | | Explanation: Chinese is widely | Explanation: FA Cup Match: | +| --- | --- | ------------------------------- | --------------------------- | +on Scottish football databases and spoken in Hong Kong: Cantonese, Wolverhampton Wanderers did +Predicted Label: SUPPORT +player profiles reveals no record of a variety of... is the primary indeed play … finished second in +Explanation: +a player named Mark Connolly … language for 99.87% of the the Championship, the second tier +It's highly unlikely an unknown Confidence Level: 100% population in Northern Ireland, of English football, securing +team would have achieved a which is factually correct. automatic promotion. +significant victory over them. Confidence Level: 99% Confidence Level: 95% +Confidence Level: 95% +| | Figure6: ErrorAnalysis: | GPT4-o | | +| --- | ----------------------- | ------ | --- | + +1 Hop 2 Hop 3 Hop 4 Hop +Claim: The Lake Superior State Claim: The poster for the new Claim: Aaron Gorrell is the player Claim: The Thüringenliga is one of +several regions listed under +| Lakers men's ice hockey team | Wizard of Oz movie features five | who transferred to the Catalans | | +| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | --- | +features a star in its logo. characters. Dragons during the 2008 season, "Promotion To" in the Tier +True Label: REFUTE True Label: REFUTE having joined in October 2007, and VII-Landesligas that partially +| | | is depicted holding a trophy. | extends beyond the country's | +| --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +| | | True Label: REFUTE | borders and was designated under | +"Promotion to" when the +"Relegation to" listing was not +Kreisoberliga. +True Label: REFUTE +AVaLL +Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT Predicted Label: SUPPORT +Explanation: The Lake Superior Explanation: The poster for the Explanation: Aaron Gorrell is a Explanation: The Thüringenliga is +State Lakers … The team's logo +| | new Wizard of Oz movie features | rugby league player who … … | indeed one of the regions listed | +| --- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +features a star, which is a +| | five characters, which is evident | There is no evidence to refute this | under "Promotion To" in the Tier | +| --- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | +common symbol in college sports. from the image. … The poster's claim, and it is supported by the VII-Landesligas that partially … +… …Therefore, it is reasonable to design and the choice of fact that Gorrell was a player for that it is a regional league that can +assume that the team's logo +| | characters indicate that the movie | the Catalans Dragons during the | be promoted to higher levels of the | +| ---------------- | ----------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | +| features a star. | is likely to be a faithful … … | | | +| | | 2008 season. | German football league system. | +Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% Confidence Level: 90% +| | Figure7: ErrorAnalysis: | LLaVA | | +| --- | ----------------------- | ----- | --- | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k4/random_3.md b/q79/random_k4/random_3.md index dd5d594edac856e6a90c63c0d5c3c52351225e37..7c956d8d1631a0019d32f6d4a0927e906c443368 100644 --- a/q79/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q79/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,771 +1,1055 @@ -1 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -2024 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL -WAVE 159 POLITICS SURVEY NOVEMBER 2024 -FINAL TOPLINE -NOVEMBER 12-17, 2024 -N=9,609 -Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This -topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly -modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire. -American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online -(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys -conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail. -For additional details, refer to the methodology. -* “No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents -who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered -as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and -telephone refusals. -In addition to the parameters used in weighting each wave of the American Trends Panel, the results of this -survey were weighted to the 2024 presidential popular vote and turnout among the voting-eligible population -(as of Nov. 18, 2024). For additional information, refer to the methodology. -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED -ASK ALL CITIZENS (XCITIZEN=1) [N=9,302]: -VOTED Which of the following statements best describes you? -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 16-27, Nov 12-17, Nov 7-16, Dec 12, -2024 20221 2020 2018 2016 -I did not vote in the November -22 2024 election 32 22 23 14 -13 I planned to vote but wasn’t able to 20 9 22 8 -I definitely voted in the November -65 2024 election 47 67 55 77 -1 No answer* 1 2 1 1 -1 In 2022 and 2018, this question was asked about that November’s congressional election. In 2020 and 2016, this question -was asked about that November’s presidential election. -www.pewresearch.org - -2 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEGEN_POST In the 2024 presidential election, who did you vote for? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2 -FIRST FOLLOWED BY RANDOMIZED OPTIONS 3,4,5,6,7 WITH OPTION 8 AND 9 ALWAYS LAST] -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | | | | | -| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 49 | Donald Trump, the Republican | | | | | | | | | -| 47 | Kamala Harris, the Democrat | | | | | | | | | -| * | Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Chase Oliver, the Libertarian Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Cornel West, a third party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Claudia De la Cruz, the Socialism and Liberation Party candidate | | | | | | | | | -| * | Another candidate | | | | | | | | | -| 2 | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| * | No answer* | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE - -ASK IF DID NOT VOTE (VOTED=1-2) [N=1,201]: -| WISH_VOTED | Do you wish that you had voted in the election? | | | | | | | | | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | Nov 29- | | Nov 17- | | -| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | Dec 12 | | Dec 15, | | -| 2024 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | 2016 | | 2014 | | -| 42 | Yes | | 45 | 61 | | 44 | | 55 | | -| 57 | No | | 54 | 38 | | 55 | | 43 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | * | | 1 | | - -ASK IF CITIZEN AND DID NOT VOTE (X_CITIZEN=1 AND VOTED=1,2) [N=1,201]: -NOVOTERSN2 There are lots of different reasons why many people don’t vote. For you personally, -how much of a reason, if at all, is each of the following for why you did not vote? -[RANDOMIZE] - -| | | | Major | | Minor | | Not a | | No | -| ----- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | reason | | reason | | reason | | answer* | -| DIFF | I didn’t think my vote would make a | | | | | | | | | -difference -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 35 | | | 26 | 39 | | 1 | -| ----- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 21 | | | 23 | 55 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| CARE | I didn’t care who won2 | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 17 | | | 21 | 61 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 12 | | | 23 | 64 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| ELGB | I’m not registered or not eligible to | | | | | | | | | - vote -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 18 | | | 15 | 66 | | 1 | -| ----- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 19 | | | 10 | 70 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | -| INCV | It was too inconvenient for me to vote | | | | | | | | | -| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 15 | | | 22 | 62 | | 1 | -| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 20 | | | 21 | 59 | | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | - -2 In 2018, the reason was worded “I didn’t care who won the congressional election in my area.” -www.pewresearch.org - -3 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -| NOVOTERSN2 CONTINUED … | | | | | | | | | | | | -| ----------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | Major | | | Minor | | Not a | No | | -| | | | | reason | | reason | | | reason | answer* | | -| LIKE | | I don’t like politics | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 31 | | | 25 | | 43 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 26 | | | 23 | | 50 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | -| FRGT | | I forgot to vote | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 8 | | 13 | | 79 | 1 | | -| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | | 7 | | 15 | | 77 | 1 | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED TRUMP (VOTEGEN_POST=1) [N=3,536]: -DTFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… -ASK IF VOTED HARRIS (VOTEGEN_POST=2) [N=4,185]: -KHFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Harris was more a vote… - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: - -| | | | | | | Based on registered voters | | | | | | -| ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | | Aug 26-Sep 2, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 20243 | | 2024 | | | -| | 49 | | Trump | | | | 47 | | 49 | | | -| | 40 | | For Trump | | | | 31 | | 33 | | | -| | 9 | | Against Harris | | | | 15 | | 16 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| 47 | | | Harris | | | | 48 | | 49 | | | -| | 23 | | For Harris | | | | 23 | | 24 | | | -| | 24 | | Against Trump | | | | 25 | | 25 | | | -| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | | -| | 2 | | Vote for Kennedy Jr./Oliver/Stein/West/De | | | | - | | - | | | -La Cruz/Another candidate -| | 2 | | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | * | | No answer* | | | | * | | * | | | - -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Would you say that your vote for Biden was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | Based on voters | | | | Based on registered voters | | | -| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ----------- | -| | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | | | Jun 16-22, | -| | | | | | | 2020 | | | 20204 | | 2020 | -| | | | Trump | | | 47 | | | 42 | | 44 | -| | | | For Trump | | | 36 | | | 30 | | 33 | -| | | | Against Biden | | | 11 | | | 12 | | 10 | -| | | | Biden | | | 51 | | | 52 | | 54 | -| | | | For Biden | | | 24 | | | 19 | | 18 | -| | | | Against Trump | | | 28 | | | 33 | | 36 | -| | | | Vote for Jorgensen/Hawkins/Another | | | 1 | | | - | | - | -candidate -| | | | No answer | | | * | | | * | | - | -| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -3 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and KHFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Harris. -4 -Trend for DTFORAGNST and JBFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the -candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for -Trump or Biden. -www.pewresearch.org - -4 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VOTEDECTIME As far as you can remember, when did you make up your mind about who you were going to -vote for in the presidential election? -BASED ON THOSE WHO SELECTED A CANDIDATE (VOTEGEN_POST=1-8) [N=7,977] -Nov 29- -Nov 12-17, Nov 12-17, Dec 12 -2024 2020 20165 -Last few days before Election -4 Day 3 9 -The last week before Election -3 Day 2 4 -7 In October 5 9 -6 In September 5 11 -81 Before September 84 67 -* No answer* * * -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you make up your mind definitely to vote for “Hillary Clinton;” “Donald Trump;” “Gary -Johnson;” “Jill Stein,” “The candidate of your choice”? -Nov 10-14 Nov 8-11 Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov -2016 2012 2004 2000 1996 1992 1988 -On Election Day 4 4 4 5 6 9 6 -On Monday (day before the election) * 1 1 2 3 4 3 -Over the last weekend * 1 1 2 2 4 2 -In the last week 2 2 3 5 6 8 4 -In the last few weeks 5 -- -- -- -- -- -- -During or just after the Presidential debates 10 10 11 17 -- 12 -- -Before debates/after the Conventions 10 9 6 9 12 6 16 -Convention period (NET) 22 10 7 7 8 12 15 -During or after the Republican convention 13 9 1 4 -- -- -- -During or after the Democratic convention 9 1 6 3 -- -- -- -This year, before the conventions 22 16 23 21 13 18 19 -Before 2016 20 41 38 20 39 12 9 -Other -- 0 0 -- * 8 -- -Don’t remember 2 1 4 6 6 5 4 -Don’t know/Refused 1 4 2 3 2 1 2 -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE -5 In 2016, people who said “another candidate” were not asked this question; question read “As far as you can remember, -when did you make up your mind definitely to vote for ‘Donald Trump;’ ‘Hillary Clinton;’ ‘Gary Johnson;’ ‘Jill Stein’?” -www.pewresearch.org - -5 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_COM Do you think the elections this November in your community were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 55 | Very well | | 42 | | 53 | | 49 | | | | -| 35 | Somewhat well | | 42 | | 32 | | 38 | | | | -| 7 | Not too well | | 9 | | 9 | | | 8 | | | -| 2 | Not at all well | | 4 | | 6 | | | 4 | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | | 1 | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in your community will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 43 | | 40 | | 36 | | 41 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 44 | | 45 | | 48 | | 46 | -| | Not too well | | | 8 | | 10 | | 11 | | 9 | -| | Not at all well | | | 4 | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US] - -ASK ALL: -VTADMIN_POST_US Do you think the elections this November in the United States were run and -administered… - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | -| ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | | -| 37 | Very well | | 25 | | 33 | | 21 | | | | -| 47 | Somewhat well | | 46 | | 25 | | 53 | | | | -| 11 | Not too well | | 18 | | 20 | | 18 | | | | -| 4 | Not at all well | | 8 | | 22 | | 7 | | | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | 1 | | | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Do you think the elections this November in the United States will be run and administered… - -| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | | -| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | -| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | -| | Very well | | | 20 | | 20 | | 12 | | 20 | -| | Somewhat well | | | 50 | | 49 | | 46 | | 57 | -| | Not too well | | | 21 | | 23 | | 30 | | 18 | -| | Not at all well | | | 8 | | 7 | | 12 | | 4 | -| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org - -6 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTEASY_POST Overall, was voting in the election this November for you personally... [ROTATE -RESPONSES OPTIONS 1-4/4-1] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 79 | Very easy | | | | 77 | | | | | | -| | 15 | Somewhat easy | | | | 17 | | | | | | -| | 5 | Somewhat difficult | | | | 5 | | | | | | - -| | 2 | Very difficult | | | | 1 | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Overall, do you personally expect voting in the November elections to be... - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | | Sep 30- | Oct 10- | | Sep 30- | Jul 27- | Sep 24- | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -| | | | | | | Oct 6, | 16 | | Oct 5 | Aug 2 | Oct 7 | -| | | | | | | 2024 | 2022 | | 2020 | 2020 | 2018 | -| | | Very easy | | | | 43 | 45 | | 29 | 23 | 46 | -| | | Somewhat easy | | | | 38 | 37 | | 36 | 28 | 39 | -| | | Somewhat difficult | | | | 16 | 14 | | 29 | 38 | 13 | -| | | Very difficult | | | | 4 | | 3 | 6 | 11 | 2 | -| | | No answer | | | | * | | * | * | 1 | * | - -ASK ALL: -SATCAND_POST Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential -candidates? Would you say that you were… -BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]: -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | -| ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | -| | 32 | Very satisfied | | | | 30 | | | | | | -| | 20 | Fairly satisfied | | | | 26 | | | | | | -| | 22 | Not too satisfied | | | | 24 | | | | | | -| | 25 | Not at all satisfied | | | | 19 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | | - - TREND FOR COMPARISON: -What is your opinion of the presidential candidates for this year? Would you say that you are… - -BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: - -| | | | | | 2024 Election | | | | 2020 Election | | | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -| | | | | Aug 26- | | | | | Jul 27- | | | -| | | | | Sep 2, | | Jul 1-7, | | | Aug 2, | Jun 16-22, | | -| | | | | 2024 | | 2024 | | | 2020 | 2020 | | -| | Very satisfied | | | | 15 | 11 | | | 15 | 16 | | -| | Fairly satisfied | | | | 32 | 20 | | | 31 | 31 | | -| | Not too satisfied | | | | 34 | 32 | | | 35 | 34 | | -| | Not at all satisfied | | | | 17 | 37 | | | 19 | 19 | | -| | No answer* | | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | 1 | | +106… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +The Communication Process in Airlines’ Crisis Management +Received: August 7, 2018 / Received in revised form: October 18, 2018 / Accepted: March 7, 2019 +Kanyakorn Narapattaveebhorn +Yubol Benjarongkij +National Institute of Development Administration +Abstract +T +he objective of this research is to study airlines’ crisis communication, before, during +and after a crisis. The research is conducted using a mixed-method that combines +quantitative and qualitative approaches. The study consists of two parts. The first focuses +on the Public Relations (PR) of value of airlines during 2010-2014 by collecting data of +airlines’ PR value from newspapers. The second part involves in-depth interviews with +airline executives and staff as well as crisis communication management experts in social +media. +The results of part one show that the three highest number of airline PR values +were found with Thai Airways, Air Asia and Bangkok Airways. The in-depth interviews in the +second part present the airlines’ crisis communication management activities during +different time periods. To prepare, prior to a crisis, they will prepare a crisis plan, +communication tools and connections; train employees; simulate the plan; form a crisis +team and practice safety drills. During a crisis, actions included implementing crisis analysis +and management, data collection, arranging internal meetings to give updates, establishing +a PR operation center, determining targeted audiences, choosing content designs and +communication tools, controlling news sources and providing media updates. Finally, +following the crisis, the procedures consisted of crisis summary, situation recovery and crisis +management evaluation. +Keywords: Crisis, Communication management, Airlines +Kanyakorn Narapattaveebhorn (Candidate of the Doctor of Philosophy program in Communication Arts and +Innovation, Graduate School of Communication Arts and Management Innovation, National Institute of Development +Administration., Email: Kanyakorn_nor@hotmail.com) and Yubol Benjarongkij (Ph.D. (Mass Communication) The Ohio State +University, 1984) Professor of the Graduate School of Communication Arts and Management Innovation, National Institute +of Development Administration. +This article is part of a PhD dissertation, “The Process of Communication in Airline Business’s Management of +Crisis in Social Media” with Professor Emeritus Dr. Yubol Benjarongkij, as Supervisor. + +| | | | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +…107 +| | | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Introduction the other hand, those organizations who are not +as prepared will encounter many issues when a +The airline industry has been challenged +crisis occurs, which can ruin their reputation and +| by crises, | (Pannavach | Pichaibavornphat, | | 2017), | | | | | | +| ------------ | ---------------- | ------------------ | ------- | ------------- | ---------------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | +| | | | | | sustainability. | A crisis | can affect | individuals | or | +| especially, | more recently, | | during | the digital | | | | | | +organisations, may cause financial and reputational +communication era. These crises seem to be +damage, or can threaten stakeholder relations. +ongoing. All the incidents have led to valued +(Pearson & Clair, 1998; Ulmer, Sellnow, & Seeger, +case studies in crisis communication, especially +| | | | | | 2007) Crises | cannot | be avoided | (Guth, | 1995). | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | ------- | +such cases as those of Malaysian Airlines and +Crisis can always put businesses, products and +| Indonesian | Air Asia. | Both | these airlines | faced | | | | | | +| ----------- | ------------ | ---------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --------------------------- | --------------- | ---- | ---------- | +| | | | | | services | in danger. Organizations | | may | lose a | +| crises | at roughly | the same | time, | causing | | | | | | +| | | | | | fortune | when the | public reacts | to | a crisis | +significant damages. Each managed their crisis +(Wilcox, 1994). Therefore, crisis management is a +differently, which led to very different feedback +central area as it is a funda-mentally important +| from internal | and | external | stakeholders, | or | | | | | | +| --------------- | ---- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +function for all organization. (Coombs, 2011) For +publics, on their actions. They each showed how +| | | | | | these reasons, | studying | the | process | of crisis | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | +poor communication management during a crisis +| | | | | | communication | management | | of airlines | is a | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | +can damage a company’s image and credibility. +must. +Communication management is something +that every organization emphasizes when a crisis Research Question +occurs as it impacts all levels of an organization. +How do airlines manage crises? +| A crisis is traditionally defined as an unusual | | | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +situation, or unexpected event. (Coomb, 2009) A +Objective of the Study +crisis also happens fast and can occur at any +| | | | | | | To study airlines’ | crisis | management | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | +time with no warning. Organizations that have +before, during and after a crisis. +prepared their communication management for +a crisis will only experience a small impact. On + +108… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +Conceptual Framework +Figure 1: Conceptual Framework + +| Definition of variables | | |  | | | +| ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Crisis management refers to the guidance +of crisis management which is divided into +|  Crisis | refers to an | abnormal and | | | | +| ----------- | ---------------------- | ----------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ | ------------------- | +| | | | three periods: | planning | before a crisis, | +| unexpected | event that | affects overall | | | | +| | | | action taken | during a crisis | and action | +| operations | of an organization. | (Ulmer, | | | | +taken after a crisis. +Sellnow & Seeger, 2007) + +…109 +| | | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | พนั | ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | +information, lessons learned, and preparation for + Crisis communication refers to commu- +next crisis). +| | nication | activities | during | | a crisis by | | | | +| --- | --------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | +utilizing messaging and media to reach Academics have divided the scope of +crisis communication into three stages (Sirintorn +specific target groups. +Mahamontree, 2004) +| |  Communication | | process | refers | to the | | | | +| --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | +Part 1: Pre-crisis planning. Michael Bland +three stages of crisis communication: pre- +(1998, p. 31) suggested a company should check +crisis planning, operations during a crisis +about a potential crisis during this time frame. +| | and | operations | post | crisis | (Sirintorn | | | | +| --- | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | +Part 2: Operations during a crisis. During +Mahamontree, 2004) +this period, the focus is on reducing the crisis and +| |  Airline | business | refers | to a | business that | | | | +| --- | ----------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | +its negative repercussions by controlling the crisis +transports passengers (Ananchai Sakdejayont, +promptly. (Duangtip Worapan, 2002) scoped crisis +2010) +operations as follows: +| |  PR Value | refers | to | the communication | | | | | +| --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | ------------ | +| | | | | | | 1. When | the crisis happens, | inform all | +published via media and the media. For +team members who are on the plan. +| | this | research, | PR | values | included | | | | +| --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | +2. Send a team to collect primary data +newspapers such as Thairath, Daily News, +and report back to the operation center. +Khaosod, Bangkok Post and The Nation. +| | | | | | | 3. Setup | a public relations | center to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------- | ----------- | + Fire starter refers to a starter to spark or +facilitate and work with mass media. +point of ignition about a crisis. (Chinsin +4. Setup meetings to update on recent +Klungthong, Interview, 7 May 2017) +conditions. +5. Assign job responsibilities and set up +Conceptual and literature review +operation teams. +The Concept of Crisis Communication +| | | | | | | 6. Analyze | target groups | and gather | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | +Management +information. +| | Crisis | communication | | is an | important | | | | +| --- | ------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +7. Facilitate media relations. +factor for an organization in its management policy. +| | | | | | | 8. When | target groups | are identified, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------------- | ----------------- | +Communication is important in helping to deal +scope data to be shared with each group. +with a crisis. Coombs (2007b) and Heath (2010) +9. Identify selected media relations and +divided crisis management into three main work +channels that suit the target groups. +| categories: | First, | pre-crisis | (is | concerned | with | | | | +| ------------ | ------- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | +10. Appoint a spokesperson. +prevention or preparation – what can be said or +11. Inform source controls. +done to reduce the chance of crisis and moderate +12. Follow up and evaluate media. +its harm if it occurs); second, crisis (actual response +| | | | | | | Part 3: Post | crisis operations. | Michael | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | -------------------- | ---------- | +to a crisis); and third, post-crisis (revision, follow-up +Bland (1998, p. 73) suggested that following a crisis, + +110… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +the operation team should meet to analyze what Social - mediated Crisis Communication +was learned from the crisis. Model: SMCC +This concept was applied in this study to Yan Jin, Brooke Fisher Liu and Lucinda L. +help divide time frames of the crisis management Austin (2011) described this model as depicting a +process and develop questions for the in-depth theory that helps to understand the social +interviews. mediated crisis communication model. The +The Concept of Crisis Management structure of this theory is explained below. +Leonard Saffir and John Tarrant, (1992) 1. An organization, or company, is the +presented crisis management principles for solving starting point of the communication process. +a crisis, also called “the preventing and reducing 2. Social Media is a communication +the effect” of a crisis, which comprises steps: 1. channel organizations use to send accurate +Planning to solve a crisis, 2. Providing information, information. +3. Data collection, 4. Primary agreement, 5. 3. Traditional Media is a media that +Determining credible news sources, 6. Attempting depends on strong relationships to control some +to speak, 7. Showing sympathy, 8. Ensuring information. +accuracy, 9. Acting cautiously in communication 4. Social Media followers are a group of +language usage and 10. Learning from previous people who follow stories on social media. +experience. 5. Influential Social Media creators are a +This concept was applied to frame the group of people that influence the information +study as it helped with the overall crisis shared with social media followers and social +management of corporate image from the media inactive persons. +beginning until the end of a crisis. The concept was 6. Social Media inactive group is a group +also applied to design the questions of the in- of people who mainly get information from +depth interview, analysis and discussion to traditional media and social media followers. +understand the procedures an organization follows This model was applied to understand +to deal with a crisis. the components of crisis communication on social +media. These components are presented in figure +2. + +…111 +วารสารการประชาสมั พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 +Figure 2: Social – mediated Crisis Communication Model +Source: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/263228949_fig1_FIGURE-1-Social-mediated-crisis- +communication-model +Methodology this study. After this, news concerning airlines +published by the five newspapers were selected +Part 1: Study of the PR values data of +from “News Clippings Online” at Matichon +airlines between 2010 to 2014, applying sample +Information Center. In total, there were 5,309 +selection of airlines with the highest PR values, +news articles were chosen for the study. +which was then used to design the in-depth +The 5,309 airline news articles then +interview question. +underwent a non-purposive sampling process by +Part 2: Qualitative study conducted by +selecting newspapers per year and 2 months of +interviewing airline executives and staff, as well +each year. At the end of this process, there were +as, experts in digital crisis communication, +712 news articles. +focusing on airlines’ crisis management. +The sample of newspapers was selected +Populations, Samples & Sampling as each published their news and information both +Procedures in newspapers and on social media. The sampling of +PR value analysis in social media, however, was +Part 1: Study of airlines’ PR values by +more difficult due to the timing of news published +examining selected samples of newspapers in +on social media varied. For this reason, a fixed +Thailand published in Thai and English between +sampling could not be utilized. The main media was +2010 – 2014. The largest circulation published +therefore not applied as a source of information to +newspapers were chosen as they capture readers’ +study the crisis communication. However, the +attention and influence their opinions. +research did utilize a selection process for the +The bestselling newspapers in Thai are +organizations that presented news that effectively +Thairath, Daily News and Khaosod while Bangkok +contributed to solving crises. The three airlines with +Post and The Nation are the bestselling English +the highest PR value were selected find the +newspapers. These five newspapers were used in +sampling for in-depth interviews. + +112… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +Below, table 1 presents the number of newspapers selected twice per year from 2010- +| airlines | news stories randomly | drawn from | five | 2014. | | | | +| --------- | ------------------------ | ------------ | ----- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 1: Airlines Published News Randomly Drawn Twice Per Year from 2010-2014 +| | Newspaper | Year | All Airlines News | | | Month | Airline News | +| ----------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------ | ---- | -------------- | --------- | -------------- | +| Thairath | | 2010 | | 166 | | February | 18 | +| | | | | | | August | 22 | +| | | 2011 | | 90 | | January | 4 | +| | | | | | April | | 8 | +| | | 2012 | | 124 | | October | 16 | +| | | | | | December | | 5 | +| | | 2013 | | 131 | March | | 7 | +| | | | | | September | | 10 | +| | | 2014 | | 99 | | June | 5 | +| | | | | | November | | 5 | +| | | Total | | 610 | | | 100 | +| Daily News | | 2010 | | 131 | | February | 13 | +| | | | | | | April | 9 | +| | | 2011 | | 122 | November | | 10 | +| | | | | | December | | 15 | +| | | 2012 | | 133 | | March | 7 | +| | | | | | September | | 8 | +| | | 2013 | | 151 | | January | 13 | +| | | | | | | August | 13 | +| | | 2014 | | 183 | | May | 6 | +| | | | | | | June | 4 | +| | | Total | | 720 | | | 98 | +| Khaosod | | 2010 | | 172 | | June | 4 | +| | | | | | November | | 11 | +| | | 2011 | | 130 | | March | 13 | +| | | | | | | February | 5 | +| | | 2012 | | 125 | | October | 16 | +| | | | | | December | | 3 | +| | | 2013 | | 105 | | January | 10 | +| | | | | | September | | 6 | +| | | 2014 | | 157 | | April | 14 | +| | | | | | | August | 20 | +| | | Total | | 689 | | | 102 | + +…113 +| | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | | พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | + +Table 1: (Continued) +| | Newspaper | Year | All Airlines News | | | Month | | Airline News | | +| ------------- | ---------- | ------ | ------------------ | ------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | +| Bangkok Post | | 2010 | | 538 | | June | | | 20 | +| | | | | | | October | | | 30 | +| | | 2011 | | 418 | | January | | | 21 | +| | | | | | | April | | | 21 | +| | | 2012 | | 404 | | May | | | 26 | +| | | | | | | September | | | 22 | +| | | 2013 | | 312 | | February | | | 20 | +| | | | | | | March | | | 26 | +| | | 2014 | | 354 | | July | | | 27 | +| | | | | | | December | | | 30 | +| | | Total | | 2,026 | | | | 243 | | +| The Nation | | 2010 | | 270 | | January | | | 27 | +| | | | | | | June | | | 10 | +| | | 2011 | | 213 | | April | | | 12 | +| | | | | | | November | | | 19 | +| | | 2012 | | 256 | | February | | | 12 | +| | | | | | | December | | | 20 | +| | | 2013 | | 303 | | May | | | 25 | +| | | | | | | September | | | 22 | +| | | 2014 | | 222 | | March | | | 13 | +| | | | | | | October | | | 9 | +| | | Total | | 1,264 | | | | 169 | | +| | | Total | | 5,309 | | | | 712 | | + +Next, the 712 online news were printed (+2). The entire process provided a PR value of +as a paper to calculate and analyzed to each airline for the period between 2010 to +| determine their column-inch space. Each of the | | | | 2014. | | | | | | +| ----------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | ------ | ---- | ------- | ---- | -------- | ---- | --------- | --------- | +| 712 | news articles’ column-inch | space | was | | | | | | | +| | | | | | The | experts | who | assisted | in this | +multiplied by the advertising fee of each evaluation are as follows: +newspaper and multiplied again by news scores +| | | | | | 1. | Napapha | Savannarong, | | Lecturer, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | +evaluated by four experts. After this, the news +| | | | | Communication | | Arts, | School | of | Management | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ----------- | +stories were evaluated according to into three +and Information Sciences, University of Phayao +ranges: Negative (-1), Neutral (+1) and Positive + +114… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +2. Ruginun Aurpitaksakul, Lecturer, interviews. The criteria of the selected +| Communication Arts, School of Management and | | | | | | | interviewees were: | | | | | | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Information Sciences, University of Phayao 1) Executives or staff who have managed +a crisis for an airlines. +| | 3. | Piyata | Soontprnpiyapan, | | Lecturer, | | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Communication Arts, Faculty of Management 2) Executives or staff who worked on +Science, Surat Thani Rajabhat University policy control or were in charge of commu- +| | | | | | | | nication | and | public | relations | during | a previous | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | +| | 4. | Praewpan | | Pannuch, | Lecturer, | | | | | | | | +airlines’ crises. +| Communication | | | Arts, | Faculty of | Management | | | | | | | | +| -------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | +| | | | | | | | | 3) | Executives | or | staff who | planned | +Science Surat Thani Rajabhat University +| | | | | | | | communication | | or | public | relations | and | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | +Part 2: According to Part 1 of this study, +strategized communication in previous crises. +the three airlines that had the highest PR values +| | | | | | | | | The | in-depth | interviews | also | included | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | +were Thai Airways, Air Asia and Bangkok Airways. +| | | | | | | | interviews | with | two | experts | in crisis | commu- | +| ----- | ----- | ----- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | ------ | +| They | were | then | chosen | for | the in-depth | | | | | | | | +nication in social media. Thus, there were a total +of seven in-depth interviews. + +Table 2: Participants of the in-depth interview +| | Number | | Airline/Company | | | Name | | | | Title | | | +| --- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | +1 Thai Airways Samat Phom-On Director of Emergency Management +and Crisis +2 Thai Airways Boonleard Nuanlaor Digital Social Media Manager +| | 3 | Air Asia | | | Nuttawut Jitarthan | | | Public Relations Manager | | | | | +| --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | 4 | Air Asia | | | Moke Promma | | | Corporate Communication Executive | | | | | +5 Bangkok Airways Thasorn Taksinapan Media Relations Manager +| | 6 | Diginative Co, Ltd | | | Kunchalee Sumleerat | | | Founder | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +7 AIA Co, Ltd Chinsin Klungthong Assistant Digital Marketing Manager + +| Research Tools | | | | | | | which | included | | both | Thai and | English | +| --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | -------- | +newspapers published in Thailand, is presented +| | Part | 1: | A data | evaluation | form | was | | | | | | | +| --- | ----- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +in table 3. +| developed for the communication and | | | | | public | | | | | | | | +| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +relations experts who analyzed the sample data, | | | | | | | | | | | | | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org - -7 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -SATCAND_POST TREND FOR COMPARSION CONTINUED … - -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: - Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential candidates? - -BASED ON THOSE WHO VOTED: - -| | | | Nov 10-14, | | Nov 8-11, | | Nov Nov | | Nov Nov | Nov Nov | -| --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2012 | | 2008 2004 | | 2000 1996 | 1992 1988 | -| Very satisfied | | | | 19 | 37 | | 39 | 33 | 24 18 | 24 26 | -| Fairly satisfied | | | | 25 | 33 | | 28 | 33 | 44 33 | 37 36 | -| Not very satisfied | | | | 26 | 16 | | 17 | 16 | 18 24 | 21 20 | -| Not at all satisfied | | | | 29 | 12 | | 14 | 16 | 9 22 | 16 17 | -| Don't | | | | 1 | 3 | | 2 | 2 | 5 3 | 2 1 | -know/Refused -(VOL.) - -[DISPLAY CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD, CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG, CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY, -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT ON SAME PAGE; RANDOMIZE ORDER OF QUESTIONS; INCLUDE -RANDOMIZATION IN DATA FILE. DO NOT RANDOMIZE RESPONSE OPTIONS WITHIN EACH -QUESTION] - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Made you feel proud | | | Did not make you feel | | | No | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | of the country | | | proud of the country | | | answer* | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 29 | | | 70 | | 1 | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | Makes you feel proud | | Does not make you feel | | No | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | of the country | | proud of the country | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | 19 | | 79 | 2 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | 12 | | 87 | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -www.pewresearch.org - -8 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Too | | Not too | | No | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | negative | | negative | | answer* | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | | 25 | | 1 | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | Too | Not too | | No | | -| | | | | | | | | negative | negative | | answer* | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 71 | | 27 | | 2 | -Jul 1-7, 2024 -| | | | | | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:6 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 76 | | 23 | | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 61 | | 37 | | 2 | - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | Focused on important | | | Not focused on important | | | | No | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| | | | policy debates | | | | policy debates | | | answer* | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 35 | | | | 64 | | 1 | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | | | | | | | Focused on | | Not focused on | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | important | | important | | No | -| | | | | | | | | policy debates | | policy debates | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 37 | | | 62 | 1 | -| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | | 23 | | | 76 | 1 | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:7 | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 27 | | | 72 | 1 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 25 | | | 73 | 2 | +…115 +| | | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | | | พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | +Table 3: Data evaluation form for communication and public relations experts +| | | | | | | PR Value Evaluation Range | | | | | | +| --- | ------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| | Number | | Date | News | | -1 | | +1 | | +2 | | +Headline +| | | | | | Negative | | | Neutral | Positive | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | +Part 2: The in-depth interview was semi- These are two stages of this study which +structured and included open-ended questions to were data collecting of PR value of airlines for +allow the interviewees to freely express their finding the airlines that had top three PR value as a +| opinions. | | | | | sample group and the in-depth interview and by | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +following the steps listed below. +Figure 3: Two stages of the study +1. selected +2. Chose +| | | | | 3. Calulated | | | | 5. Chose the | | | | +| ------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | +| newspapers | | airlines news | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | news space | | 4. The 4 | | airlines that | | | | +| which were | | and drawn | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | by inches and | | experts | | had top three | | | | +| Thai Rath, | | samples by | | | | | | | | | 6. In - | +| | | | | muliplied by | | evaluated | | PR value for | | | | +| Daily News, | | picking 2 | | | | | | | | | dept | +| | | | | advertisemen | | news | | the samples | | | | +| Khawsod, | | months of | | | | | | | | | interview | +| | | | | t cost rate of | | contents for | | of the in- | | | | +| Bangkok | | each year in | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | each | | | | depth | | | | +| Post, and | | the total of | | | | the PR value | | | | | | +| | | | | newspaper | | | | interview | | | | +712 news +The Nation + +| Research Results: Part 1 | | | | | | 2. | Air Asia Airlines (AK) | | | | | +| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +The results of the study show that Air +The research results of Part 1 show that +Asia airline had a total PR value of 3,589,191 THB, +the top three airlines in PR values were Thai +| | | | | | calculated | | from | 677,802 THB | in | 2010, | 145,467 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | +Airways (TG), Air Asia Airline (AK) and Bangkok +THB in 2011, 520,398 THB in 2012, 1,169,178 THB +Airways (PG). +in 2013 and 1,076,346 THB in 2014. +Airlines with top three PR Values +| | | | | | | 3. | Bangkok Airways Airlines(PG) | | | | | +| --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----------------------------- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | +| | 1. Thai Airways (TG) | | | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | The | results | of the | study | show | that | +The results of the study show that Thai +Bangkok Airways had a total PR value of 3,266,015 +Airways had a total PR value of 6,812,539 THB, +| | | | | | THB, | calculated | | from 907,580 THB | | | in 2010, | +| ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ---- | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | +| calculated | from | 2,841,019.6 | THB | in 2010, | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | 882,182 THB | | in | 2011, 509,880 | | THB | in 2012, | +1,180,543.3 THB in 2011, 1,971,281.2 THB in 2012, +400,247.5 THB in 2013 and 566,125.4 THB in 2014. +35720.7 THB in 2013 and 783,974.89 THB in 2014. + +116… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +Figure 4: PR values of top three airlines from 2010 – 2014 +8,000,000 6,812,539 +3,589,191 +6,000,000 3,266,015 +4,000,000 +2,000,000 +0 +TG AK PG +The three airlines with the three highest workshops and academic conferences. The +PR values were selected as the sample group for airlines also provided training in social media as +the in-depth interviews as The three showed they wanted staff to better understand digital +more effective communication management with communication. +their news and information had more positive “The organization’s training on social +input and better content than other airlines. media was for everyone, from the top to junior +level, as a social media crisis actually occurs +Research Results: Part 2 +more often within the organization than outside. +The interview results were divided into +So, this is needed for our protection.” (Chinsin +three stages: pre-crisis, operations during a crisis +Klungthong, Interview, 7 May 2017) +and operations after a crisis, with details listed +Plan Stimulation: The results show that +below. +airlines conducted drills before any actual crisis. +Preparation for Crisis Management “We conduct drills twice a year at Don +Preparation: The results show that the Mueang Airport such as a bomb drill, plane fire +airlines had prepared a crisis plan, communication drill...” (Moke Promma, Interview, 26 May 2016) +connections and communication tools, including Forming a Crisis Operations Committee: +a list of online influencers and bloggers. The results show that airlines set up a crisis +“...Thai Airways has four stages, which operations committee to be prepared for an +are: 1. Reduction, i.e., reducing chances of a crisis; actual crisis. The committee comprises many +2. Readiness, i.e., preparation of a plan, practice, people from different departments with the +connection searching and equipment preparation ability to manage a crisis. The would not take +to manage a crisis; 3. Reaction, i.e., adhering to a action in a crisis until the crisis plan was activated. +plan stimulation as much as possible; and 4. “We have a LINE group and the team is +Recovery, i.e., returning the situation to be always on stand-by... The group consists of +normal as soon as possible” (Samat Phum-On, representatives of the following departments: +Interview, 6 May 2016) Fight Operations, Ground Support, Airline Crew, +Staff Training: The results show that Engineering, PR, Pilots ,Business Development and +crisis management training was conducted for Law...” (Natthawut Jitarthan, Interview, 13 May +both domestic and overseas staff, including 2016) + +| | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +…117 +| | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | +| --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | +Experts also set up a social media color identify the roles and responsibilities of +| operation team in preparation as well. | | | each team. | | | | +| --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | + “Setting up a social media operation “We analyze conditions by grouping +team is not complex. If people in the them under the colors green, yellow, orange and +organization understand the flow of digital red. Green means a normal case. Yellow is a +communication, then, everyone will be able to typically a complaint we can manage by our +act. So, the organization does not need many regular process. Red means a crisis that needs to +people familiar with digital communication, but it be rectified, and orange is not a crisis but a +needs a controller who understands how the situation the needs attention as it can develop +organization functions.” (Chinsin Klungthong, into a crisis; so, it needs to be monitored.” +Interview, May 7, 2017) (Kunchalee Sumlee, Interview, 5 May 2017) +Warning Signs Testing: The results Crisis Management: The results show +found that airlines regularly checked for warning that the airlines managed crises that required a +signs, internally and externally. crisis plan, including social media crises. This +demonstrates how high impact crisis management +“We are monitoring social media data +needs a crisis plan and operations team. +24 hours a day. We can be notified at any time, +“Crisis management is led by the Crisis +especially when there is negative feedback, hot +| | | | Management | Team, which | is divided into | five | +| ------------------ | ------------------ | -------------- | ----------- | ------------------ | ------------------- | ------- | +| topics or posts | that are shared | many times.” | | | | | +| | | | sections, | Crisis Planning, | Crisis Logistics, | Crisis | +(Moke Promma, Interview, 26 May 2016) +Operations, Crisis Finance & Administration and +Operations During a Crisis Crisis Communication. After the plan is activated +Crisis Analysis: The results show that the by the Crisis Team Director, the Crisis Planning +airlines frequently analyzed crises collect team will determine the roles of each section.” +information and implement action. (Thasorn Taksinapan, Bangkok, Interview, 31 May +| “There is always an analysis of a crisis. If | | | 2016) | | | | +| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | +it is a serious crisis, the Emergency Response Plan In a social media crisis, an airline would +will be activated, which will involve staff from directly contact the affected people to stop the +many departments. If it is a minor crisis such as spread of negative feedback to a greater online +| social media topic and we have the source and | | | audience. | | | | +| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | +information of the posting, we will decide how to “...To manage online negative posts +correct the issue.” (Moke Promma, Interview, 26 about our airline, we have two different ways to +| May 2016) | | | manage it. The first, in the case a complaint is | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | + Online crisis management also analyzing sent directly to our complaint system, we will +situations by collecting and analyzing data to proceed by following prepared steps. On the +determine how a crisis occurred. One step in the other hand, if a complaint is posted on +analysis is grouping data under four colors, each Facebook or the Pantip website, the airline may + +118… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +not be able to solve a problem [immediately], require simultaneous action during the three +and thus, we may not be able to follow the steps of online media communication manage- +steps we have provided. We will consider case ment: discovery and analysis, communication +by case to see on how to fix the issue but mostly and evaluation. +we would contact the passengers directly. Some “The components of crisis management +cases, we don’t notify the public on how we are Preventive, Proactive and Reactive, which +correct the problem, talking directly to the interact. During the preventive phase in the +passengers is better.” (Natthawut Jitarthan, communication process, we need to act to +Interview, 13 May 2016) prevent a crises from occurring. The reactive +Thai Airways utilized online influencers’ phase kicks in when our customers have +connections to help with online crisis problems with our service. We need to provide +management. them with satisfactory service. The proactive +“When we find negative feedback phases means reaching out to customers. For +about the airline while monitoring online posts, example, when we receive negative feedback, +we don’t respond to all of them, but will we will talk to customers right away. Meanwhile, +respond to situations on Thai Airways’ media there are three steps in online communication +channels such as Facebook by utilizing an management. The first one is discovery or posts +advocate group who supports the airline as well and analysis, looking for the spark that can set +as online influencers who share links to respond, off a crisis. The second step is communication +telling how the airline is working to solve these applying the right style for a particular audience +issues on Facebook. The advocate group will as we cannot communicate with everyone using +work to change the negative feedback to positive the same style. Some cases don’t need group +feedback. Besides sharing links, they post positive communication as sometimes personal engage- +stories about the airline to dispute the negative ment works better. The third step is evaluation +feedback. Normally, no one seems to argue with as we need to evaluate the situation to +a negative post; however, in reality, people may determine if it is almost over or will continue to +disagree with it. We ask this group to share an grow. So, the flow chart of crisis management +opposing opinion and later, this negative will tell us on what needs to be done and when. +feedback may change to a positive result. In the During the evaluation stage, we need to check +case of posting fake information about the two things, discover and analysis and commu- +airline, the advocate group will monitor that nication; then it’s back to the evaluation. We will +data for us as well.” (Boonleard Nuanlaor, keep checking this until the situation calms +Interview, 5 June 2016) down, and then is over. If we think the situation +The experts discussed the crisis manage- is over when actually it is not, this means we +ment process, which includes Preventive, reacted too soon, and this can create a new +Proactive and Reactive components, which crisis. Sometimes, we try to fix a problem, but | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +…119 +| | | | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | | พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | +this can actually make the situation even worse. management tools and equipment such as TVs +A crisis can actually rise and fall. A situation may for monitoring data and news from TV programs +seem almost over, but a new factor can cause it as well as other communication tools.” +to rebound. We need to end the crisis as soon as (Natthawut Jitarthan, Interview, 13 May 2016) +possible.” (Chinsin Klungthong, Interview, 7 May +| | | | | | | | Crisis | Summary | | Meeting: | The | results | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | +2017) +| | | | | | | show | that | the airlines | always | | have | a crisis | +| --- | ------- | ----- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ----- | ----- | -------------- | ------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | +| | Crisis | Data | Collection: | The | results | | | | | | | | +conclusion meeting. +| show | that the | airlines | collected | crisis | data. | | | | | | | | +| ----- | ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +“Our airline emphasizes the importance +| Furthermore, | the | two | experts | emphasized | the | | | | | | | | +| ------------- | ------ | --------- | -------------------- | ----------- | ---- | --------- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- | --------- | ---- | -------- | +| | | | | | | of a | summary | meeting | with | internal | and | the | +| importance | of | frequent | data | collection | and | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | external | stakeholders. | | This | protects | the | airline | +| evaluation | among | | online influencers | | and | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | from | future | communication | | problems | | and | +instigators, especially to ensure that there were +misunderstandings as the airline works to do our +not any hidden agendas. +best by sounding clear and without any doubt. +“We collect data for two reasons. The This leads to effective management.” (Natthawut +first, which is during the operations stage, we Jitarthan, Interview, 13 May 2016) +need to collect data to report to the related +Communication Target Groups Analysis: +departments following the data notification time +| | | | | | | The | results | show | that the | airlines | designated | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ----- | ---------- | --------- | ----------- | --- | +schedule. The second, which is collecting data +different communication target groups and then +| during | the communication | | stage, | is | to find | | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ------- | +| | | | | | | developed | | different | content | for | each | group. | +answers to such questions as: What is the crisis? +Airlines communicate first with the target group +What is the executive announcement? What is +most affected by a crisis and the media. +the date and time of the next news release? We + “In a crisis like a plane crash, the target +also continue to monitor trends based on data +groups that need to be contacted are family and +that has already been presented. If the trend is +relatives of the injured and victims. The airline +negative, the team needs to figure out how to fix +should communicate with internal groups before +| this.” (Natthawut | | Jitarthan, Interview, | | | 13 May | | | | | | | | +| ------------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | ----- | --- | +| | | | | | | communicating | | to | external | groups | such | as | +2016) +journalists. If we don’t effectively communicate +Public Relations Operation Center: The with the internal group, this may cause mistakes, +results show that the airlines set up public misunderstanding and further issues.” Natthawut +relations operations centers only once a crisis Jitarthan, Interview, 13 May 2016) +plan has been activated. The experts emphasized the importance +“When a crisis occurs, the airline will of communication with online influencers, +allocate a room for the crisis management instigators and stakeholders, as well as under- +center. This is a special room as it will not be standing the factors, node, spread and voice as +used for any other purpose. The room has defined for online communication. + +120… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +“It depends on the case; if you have draft a message that will making people feel +60 cases, you will manage these in 60 different that we really care about them and we are +ways. There are three social media management trying to solve the problem. We may not find a +factors, node, spread and voice. We need to solution immediately, but we are trying our best. +understand the voice to be able to control the We want them to realize that we are here to +situation. When the voice is high, the situation help and will make sure that the same mistake +can quickly inflate and create a crisis. The other will not happen again.” (Kunchalee Sumlee, +important factor, thus, spread. In digital PR, we Interview, 5 May 2017) +need to reduce of kill the spread as soon as Communication Tool Usage +possible. Node is important as it is the spark that Management: The results show the three airlines +causes the voice and then the spread of news by utilized communication tools to manage crises +those called fire starters as well as online focusing on both external and internal +influencers. We need to communicate to these stakeholders using offline and online media. The +groups, especially the influencers, who help form expert applied the principle of Paid-Owned- +the node. We need to communicate a lot with Earned Media in social media communication +this group. After this communication, it is hoped management. +they will delete their posts to stop the spread. In “Media comprises Paid-Owned-Earned +some cases, we do not need to engage directly Media. We have to work hard on our own media +with them. Some of these can spout nonsense as we need our organization to be strong. With +and be aggressive and rude. We should ignore paid media, we need to monitor the media we +them when we can.” (Chinsin Klungthong, paid for, especially where there is a crisis. With +Interview, 7 May 2017) earned media, we have to avoid risks as this is +Communication Content Design: The not our space. We may create a crisis which +results show that the airlines control crisis can’t be controlled. We should let people come +communication content based on the develop- to us in a controlled environment, so we can +ment of a situation. The content is drafted and control the situation. The management needs to +then edited before it is released. The experts in act case by case and should not need stick to +social media emphasized the importance of a one media. If a crisis is caused online, then let it +human sense in online media. be resolved online. Where it starts, let it finish, for +“Applying a human sense to commu- example, with a crisis caused on Twitter, let it be +nication means not using formal language as finished on Twitter. With Node, Voice, and +people will think the sender is much like a Spread, which I mentioned previously, when a +concrete wall. We give a human sense to a crisis appears on Twitter, do not let it spread +statement by showing how we feel really sorry elsewhere. Facebook is not the place to deal for +about what happened. If a crisis takes place in this crisis. If the crisis starts on Facebook, then let +our family, how would we feel? It’s important to it be done on Facebook. This is the simplest way -6 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -7 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org - -9 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]: -CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was... - -BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]: - -| | | | | No | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | Interesting | Dull answer* | | | | | | | -| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | 24 2 | | | | | | | - -| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | - -| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | -| | | | | | | | | | | No | -| | | | | | Interesting | | | Dull | | answer* | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON8 | | | | | | | | | -| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | 64 | | 34 | | 2 | -| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | 39 | | 59 | | 2 | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -| VOTE_HOW_POST | | | How did you vote in the election? [RANDOMIZE] | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -| VOTEINPWHEN | | When did you vote? | | | | | | | | | -| ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| | 65 | In person at a polling place | | | | | 65 | | 54 | | -| | 34 | On Election Day | | | | | 44 | | | 27 | -| | 32 | Before Election Day | | | | | 21 | | | 27 | -| | * | Refused | | | | | * | | | * | -| | 35 | By absentee or mail-in ballot | | | | | 35 | | 46 | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | * | | | * | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -When did you vote in the elections this November? -How did you vote in the November election? - -| | | | | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -2018 -| | | On election day | | | | | 55 | | | | -| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | Before election day | | | | | 45 | | | | -| | | Voted in person | | | | | 19 | | | | -| | | Mailed in ballot | | | | | 25 | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -8 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign. -www.pewresearch.org - -10 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -VOTE_HOW_POST/VOTEINPWHEN TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED… - -PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: -Did you vote ON Election Day or BEFORE Election DAY? - -Did you vote in person or did you mail your ballot in? - -| | | | Nov 10-14 | Nov 6-9 | | Nov 8-11 | | Nov | | Nov | | Nov | Nov | -| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | -| | | | 2016 | | 2014 | | 2012 | 2008 | | 2006 | | 2004 | 2002 | -| On Election Day | | | 59 | | 71 | | 63 | 66 | | 80 | | 80 | 85 | -| Before Election Day | | | 41 | | 29 | | 37 | 34 | | 20 | | 20 | 15 | -| Voted in person | | | 22 | | 12 | | 19 | 19 | | -- | | | | -| Mailed in ballot | | | 18 | | 16 | | 17 | 14 | | -- | | | | -| Other way/DK/Ref (VOL) | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | 1 | | -- | | | | -| Don’t know/Refused (VOL) | | | 0 | | * | | 0 | * | | * | | * | * | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -VOTEMAIL How did you return your absentee or mail-in ballot? [RANDOMIZE] - -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | -| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | | 2020 | | | | -| | 12 | In person to an election official or poll | | | | | | 12 | | 15 | | | | -worker -| | 38 | At a designated dropbox | | | | | | 36 | | 41 | | | | -| --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 50 | By mail | | | | | | 52 | | 44 | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | * | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILWHEN When did you mail or return your absentee or mail-in ballot? - -| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | -| --- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | | -| | 33 | In the week leading up to Election Day | | | | | | 23 | | | | | | -| | 67 | Before that | | | | | | 76 | | | | | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | | | | | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]: -WAITVOTE When you went to vote, approximately how long did you have to wait in line to -vote? -| | | | | | | | | | | | Nov 17- | | | -| ------------ | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | Dec 15, | | | -| | 2024 | | | | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | 2014 | | | -| | 42 | Did not wait at all9 | | | | 35 | | 47 | | | | 53 | | -| | 30 | Less than 10 minutes | | | | 27 | | 33 | | | | 30 | | -| | 17 | 10 to 30 minutes | | | | 20 | | 14 | | | | 13 | | -| | 7 | 31 minutes to 1 hour | | | | 11 | | | 5 | | | 3 | | -| | 4 | More than 1 hour | | | | 6 | | | 1 | | | * | | -| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | * | | | * | | - -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -9 In surveys prior to November 2024, the response was worded “Not at all”. -www.pewresearch.org - -11 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER - -ASK IF VOTED BY MAIL OR ABSENTEE (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]: -MAILFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted by mail or absentee ballot? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2020 | | | -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted by -| 12 | | | 39 | | | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -mail or absentee ballot -| 88 | No, I have voted by mail or absentee ballot before | | 61 | | | -| --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | | | - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON BEFORE ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=1) [N=2,671]: -| EARLYFIRST | Is this the first time you have ever voted early? | | | | | -| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -Nov 12-17, -| 2024 | | | | | | -| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -29 Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted early -71 No, I have voted early before -* No answer* - -ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON ON ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=2) [N=2,513]: -ELECDFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted in person on Election Day? - -Nov 12-17, -2024 -Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted in person on Election Day -7 -93 No, I have voted in person on Election Day before -* No answer* - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]: -VTCOUNT_OWN How confident are you that your vote was accurately counted? - -| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | Nov 12-17, | | -| ----------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | 2020 | | -| 59 | Very confident | | 57 | 59 | | -| 33 | Somewhat confident | | 31 | 26 | | -| 5 | Not too confident | | 8 | 9 | | -Not at all confident -| 2 | | | 3 | 6 | | -| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| * | No answer* | | * | * | | - -| | PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | -| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -| | | Nov 10-14 Nov 6-9 Nov 8-11 Nov 4-7 | | Nov Nov | Nov | -| --- | -------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- | -| | | 2016 2014 | 2012 2010 | 2008 2006 | 2004 | -| | Very confident | 71 68 | 68 64 | 73 70 | 68 | -| | Somewhat confident | 19 21 | 22 26 | 22 23 | 24 | -| | Not too confident | 4 5 | 5 4 | 3 3 | 4 | -| | Not at all confident | 5 4 | 3 3 | 2 2 | 3 | -| | Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) | 1 1 | 1 3 | * 2 | 1 | -| | | | | | | -www.pewresearch.org - -12 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_INP How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 38 | Very confident | | 37 | | 42 | | -| 47 | Somewhat confident | | 43 | | 35 | | -| 11 | Not too confident | | 13 | | 13 | | -| 4 | Not at all confident | | 6 | | 8 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United States will -be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 36 | | 34 | 42 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 46 | | 45 | 44 | -| | Not too confident | | 13 | | 15 | 10 | -| | Not at all confident | | | 5 | 5 | 4 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS] - -ASK ALL: -VTCOUNT_POST_ABS How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail in ballot across the United -States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November? - -| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | -| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | -| 24 | Very confident | | 25 | | 30 | | -| 46 | Somewhat confident | | 37 | | 27 | | -| 21 | Not too confident | | 23 | | 19 | | -| 7 | Not at all confident | | 13 | | 23 | | -| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | | - -TREND FOR COMPARISON: -How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail-in ballot across the United States -will be counted as voters intend in the elections this November? - -| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- | -| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, | -| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 | -| | Very confident | | 22 | | 21 | 17 | -| | Somewhat confident | | 38 | | 38 | 38 | -| | Not too confident | | 27 | | 24 | 28 | -| | Not at all confident | | 12 | | 16 | 16 | -| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 | - -www.pewresearch.org - -13 -PEW RESEARCH CENTER -ASK ALL: -ELECT_CONFNOVPOS How confident, if at all, are you that... [RANDOMIZE ITEMS] - -| | | | | | | Very | Somewhat | | Not too | | Not at all | No | -| ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | -| | | | | | confident | | confident | | confident | | confident | answer* | -| PRVFR | | People who were not legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified to vote are prevented | | | | | | | | | | | -from casting a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 27 | | 38 | 26 | | 8 | 1 | -| ------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON10: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 29 | | 30 | 24 | | 17 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 23 | | 36 | 28 | | 11 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| PRVSUP | | People who were legally | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | qualified and want to vote are | | | | | | | | | | | -able to cast a ballot -| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 45 | | 42 | 9 | | 3 | 1 | -| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | TREND FOR COMPARISON11: | | | | | | | | | | | | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 44 | | 43 | 10 | | 3 | 1 | -| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 36 | | 45 | 14 | | 4 | 1 | -| | | | | | | | | | | | | | - -ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED - -ASK ALL: -| PARTY | | In politics today, do you consider yourself a… | | | | | | | | | | | -| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3, 4 OR REFUSED): -| PARTYLN | | As of today do you lean more to…12 | | | | | | | | | | | -| -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | -| | | | | | | Something | | No | | Lean | Lean | | - Republican Democrat Independent else answer* Rep Dem -| | | 28 | 27 | 30 | | 14 | | 1 | | 20 | | 20 | +| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - -10 In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are not legally qualified to vote are prevented from -casting a ballot.” -11 -In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are legally qualified and want to vote are able to cast -a ballot.” -12 PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey. -www.pewresearch.org \ No newline at end of file +…121 +| | | | | | | วารสารการประชาสมั | | พนั | ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 | | | | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | +to resolve it, unless the crisis has already spread executives.” (Thasorn Taksinapan, Bangkok, +elsewhere.” (Chinsin Klungthong, Interview, 7 May Interview, 31 May 2016) +| 2017) | | | | | | | Post Crisis Recovery: The results show | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------------------------------------- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | +| | | | | | | that | the | airlines | pay attention | | to | post crisis | +Media Relations: The results show that +recovery. +the airlines used the media during a crisis through +| | | | | | | | “The | management | | during | stage | three, | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | +the actions of their public relations teams. +| | | | | | | called | Recovery, | | focuses | on | returning | the | +| --- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | +| | “The | airline | uses | the media | during a | | | | | | | | +situation to normal as soon as possible with the +| crisis | of the | organization. | | Our public | relations | | | | | | | | +| ------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +least amount of damage. The important thing is +| department | | will | be in | charge of | collaborating | | | | | | | | +| ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----------- | -------------- | -------- | ---- | ------ | -------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | +| | | | | | | finding | the | right | opportunity.”(Samat | | | Phum-On, | +with them.” (Samat Phum-On, Bangkok, Interview, +Interview, 6 May 2016) +6 May 2016) +| | | | | | | | Management | | Plan | Evaluation: | | The | +| --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------- | -------- | ----------- | ----- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---- | +| | Informed | | Source | Control: | The results | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | results | show | that | prepared | crisis | management | | +show that the airlines pay attention to controlled +plans always worked as expected. +news resources, especially staff and associates of +“Each crisis has different details and is +their organization. +| | | | | | | always | challenging. | | A prepared | | plan | will work | +| --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | ----- | ------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | ----- | ----------- | +| | “During a | | crisis, | we communicate | with | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | 90% | as | expected, | and | another | 10% | is the | +staff and ask them to cooperate by being careful +unpredictable that we cannot control.” (Thasorn +sharing negative feedback and comments online. +Taksinapan, Interview, 31 May 2016) +They are not allowed to give information to the +| | | | | | | | The | experts | said | there | should | be an | +| ------ | -------- | ----- | ----- | --------------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | ------- | +| press | or act | like | news | sources.” (Natthawut | | | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | evaluation | | and | follow-up | of the | management | | +Jitarthan, Interview, 13 May 2016) +| | | | | | | plan | following | a | social | media | crisis | like other | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | +Post Crisis Operations situations. If an online crisis cannot be managed +Summary of Situation: The results show by the airlines, the experts suggested to +implementing a Silent Policy. +that the airlines summarize a crisis in reports and +| | | | | | | | “After | analysis | | and evaluation, | | if the | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | +meetings. +“We have a meeting to summarize the crisis is still in a serious condition, the best thing +to do is to remain silent. You need to have a +situation and its effect. There is an evaluation on +| | | | | | | silent policy. | | In | a case | like this, you | | need to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | +how much damage the crisis caused, who were +affected, how operations worked and how to remain silent until the situation is back to +normal. Keep silent on every channel.” (Chinsin +| adapt | to | ensure | the | same mistakes | don’t | | | | | | | | +| ------ | --- | ------- | ---- | --------------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Klungthong, Interview, 7 May 2017) +reoccur in the future. All of the information is +included in a report submitted to the airlines’ + +122… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +Figure 5: 3 Stages of Crisis Management +| | Pre Crisis | | | | | Crisis Event | | | | Post Crisis | | | +| --- | ----------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | +| | | •Preparing Crisis | | | | •Analysis | | | | •Summary | | | +| | | Plan, | | | | | | | | Meeting | | | +•Management +Communication +•Recovery +| | | Tools and | | | | •Data Collecting | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | +| | | Connections | | | | | | | | •Evaluation | | | +•Operation Center +•Training +•Meeting +•Simulation +•Target Group +| | | •Crisis Team | | | | Analysis | | | | | | | +| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +•Warning Signs +•Content Design +•Communication +Tool +Implementation +•Media Relations +•Controlling news +sources + +Discussion crisis that is more difficult to control. The pre- +| | | | | | | | crisis phase | is | the | most important | | period to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | +From the results of this study, it was +prevent any crises (Kunchalee Sumlee, Interview, +found that the crisis management process was +5 May 2017). This study found that the airlines +consistent with the concepts of crisis commu- +regularly conducted both internal and external +| nication | management, | | | which include | | warning | | | | | | | +| --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | --------------- | --- | ---- | +| | | | | | | | safety | testing. | In digital | communication, | | the | +signs testing, public relations operation centers, +airlines focus on social media data checking. For +| media | relations, | | summary | meetings, | | commu- | | | | | | | +| --------- | ----------- | ------ | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | ------- | ----------- | +| | | | | | | | example, | they | utilize | | online | reputation | +| nication | target | group | analysis, | content | | commu- | | | | | | | +| | | | | | | | management | | and social | listening. | The | airlines | +nication design, summary and evaluation. +| | | | | | | | acknowledged | | they | faced problems | | in digital | +| --- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | +| | This | concept | | emphasized | | the | | | | | | | +communication manage-ment and reacting in a +importance of the crisis communication, which is +| | | | | | | | timely | manner | to | prevent | a crisis | from | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | +important in solving an organization’s problems. +materializing. +| At | the beginning | | of | pre-crisis | preparation, | | | | | | | | +| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Public relations operation centers were +| (Duangtip | | Worapan, | 2002) | | suggested | that | | | | | | | +| ---------- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +set up during a crisis. This is done to facilitate +| forecasting | | a crisis | is | necessary | by | paying | | | | | | | +| ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +and organize operations staff and handle the +attention to current situations that may cause a +media. For example, Thai Airways had a Crisis +| crisis | while | considering | | previous | crises. | The | | | | | | | +| ------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +Manage-ment Operation Center, which acted to +warning sign test helps prepare airlines to be +provide one-stop service to provide information +aware of a minor problem before it turns into a + +…123 +วารสารการประชาสมั พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 +about a crisis. The center provided quick and with the group most directly affected first to try +effective management, directing the dissemination to rectify the problem as quickly as possible. +of information in one direction. The airlines’ communication content +The airlines provided facilities to the design during a crisis was dependent on the +press to help them work effectively when situations. The content would be drafted and +presenting the airlines’ news and information then adjusted to fit a specific situation. This is +during a crisis. The study found that this was consistent with the concept that released +under the control of the airlines’ public content is adapted to meet a target group’s +relations departments. Their departments specific need (Duangtip Worapan, 2002). +regularly updated information to help the press Informed source control, both internal +promptly and effectively publish airlines news and external, is another strategy that the airlines +and information during a crisis. This way, the paid attention to. They focused especially on +airlines were able to control news topics as well. internal stakeholders, who are primarily +The airlines had summary meetings to organization staff. For example, Air Asia +update information and create common communicated to their staff during a crisis by +understanding. For example, Air Asia asking them to be cautious about releasing +communicated directly with those affected if negative comments. The organization emailed +the crisis was minor. On the other hand, the every staff to tell them not to share comments +airline had a daily meeting to update everyone online, give interviews to the press or act as a +involved to prevent rumors from spreading news source, which could make the crisis more +through online media and the press during a serious. +major crisis. The meetings helped the team The crisis summary and evaluation of +acquire accurate information which could be the plan were conducted after the crisis was +applied to decision making and problem solving. over. This is consistent with Bland (1998, p. 73) +The meetings protected the airline from as he suggested that after a crisis is over, the +misunderstandings and miscommunication, operations team should meet to analyze what +which ensured more effective crisis was learned from the crisis as well as prepare a +management. report to summarize the event. This should +The airlines analyzed their commu- include what improvements are required while +nication target groups. Each group needed focusing on different target groups, including +different data and information depending on the those still interested in or following up crisis +level of an emergency. The airlines considered with concern of a relapse. +these differences to adapt messages according The crisis management concept +to each target group and the current conditions. includes crisis management preparation, plan +For example, Bangkok Airways communicated stimulation before a crisis, establishment of an +operations committee, data collection and + +124… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +informed source control. Leonard Saffir and operations staff assumed their their roles and +John Tarrant, (1992) presented principles of crisis responsibilities very quickly. +management described as, “preventing and Data collection should come quick to +reducing the effect” of crisis as much as gain a better understanding of the situation. As a +possible. The results of this study are consistent crisis occurs very quickly, an airline should +with this concept. prepare data, information and pictures that are +For crisis preparation, the airlines needed by the press to release to the public. +prepared a plan, communication connections Without this information, the press would have +and commu-nication tools. For example, Thai to find the information from other news sources, +Airways has formed connections with advocate and then the airlines would lose control of the +groups and online groups that support the positive direction of the organization’s news. +airline. They help to correct rumors and check This helps give positive tone to the information. +data concerning the airline on social media. For example, Air Asia has divided data collection +For crisis plan stimulation, following into 2 types. The first is organized by the +planning, the airlines tested their plans to see if operations team and includes the evolution of +they work. This also prepares staff on their roles the situation which they share with other +and responsibilities when a crisis does occur and involved teams. The second type is managed by +helps them work more effectively. This also the PR team, which includes collecting data +helps to foresee any mistakes. The results of this from people involved in the situation. The +study found that the airlines valued stimulation. organization is also open to receive data from +For example, Thai Airways conducted other sources. +stimulation the then issued a report, recording Results of the study from the social +the results of the plan along with comments on media crisis communication experts show that +the results. data evaluation is important, especially on +When it comes to the operations online influencers and the fire starters, +committee, the airlines formed teams instigators of news or rumors. +comprising members who are important to crisis Moreover, the results of the study of +management. For example, Bangkok Airways has crisis communication in social media are +a Crisis Management Team to manage a crisis, consistent with the Social–Mediated Crisis +which is consistent with the research of Ee Ling Communication Model (SMCC), which +J. Tan (2003), which conducted a case study of emphasizes the importance of components such +Singapore Airlines and its crisis communication. as organizations, or, in this case, airlines that +He found it was very important that airlines have tend to have crises more than other +a well-trained crisis communication team. Good organizations. As social media has the ability to +preparation showed that in a crisis, the quickly spread news and information, the +number of news followers has been increasing + +…125 +วารสารการประชาสมั พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 +annually (Chinsin Klungthong, Interview, 7 May time. As Wilcox, Ault, and Agee (1998) said, +2017). This includes social media influencers cyberspace has been a valuable tool helping +have an impact on social media receivers. It is public relations officers working in bigger scopes. +very important to note that all components are Social media is an important communication +interrelated in crisis communication in the digital tool for organizations of this generation as it +period (Yan Jin, Brooke Fisher Liu and Lucinda L. becomes more and more popular in corporate +Austin, 2011). Therefore, organizations needs to communications (Wright and Hinson, 2009). +realize the importance of creating good Online social media crisis management +relationships with social media influencers and is thus important for organizations. As consumers +their organizations’ social media followers, as participate in online social media, commu- +both groups have the ability to efficiently spread nication via traditional media is not enough +an organization’s information during a crisis via (Gonzalez-Herrero & Smith, 2008). Organizations +social media (Yan Jin, Brooke Fisher Liu and need to adjust themselves and utilize online +Lucinda L. Austin, 2011). social media to interact with their consumers as +they can quickly respond and pass along +Conclusion +information to consumers (Rapp, Beitelspacher, +This research shows the importance of Grewal & Hughes, 2013). This includes social +communication in crisis management in the media influencers who are public leaders and +airline business, which is consistent with W. have the ability to exchange information and act +Timothy Coombs and Sherry L. Holladay (2010), as opinion leaders of online communities (Van +who presented that communication takes the Dijk, 2012). Once the crisis occurs, an +lead role in the entire process of crisis organization can learn from their mistakes so +management. they will not let them repeat. +This also includes internal organizational +communication among those who have direct +Research Limitation +roles and responsibilities, as well as, the external The limitation of this study is that only +organizational communication between the PR values were determined only for newspapers +stakeholders and public. This is because published in Thailand and not from around the +communication is a process that completes the world. Furthermore, no other media was +information pap, reduces the uncertainly, considered. +strengthens knowledge and understanding, and +Recommendation for Future Research +maintains good relationships. +Moreover, the results of the study show Future research should expand to +the influence of online social media that has include newspapers publishing airline news in +become a powerful media which is utilized by different countries, as airline business covers the +airlines as a tool to manage crises at the present globe, and news and information are + +126… Journal of Public Relations and Advertising Vol. 12 No. 2 2019 +disseminated in many countries. Studying airline to all staff, not just executives because +news published in different countries could lead everyone is important to crisis management. +to a selection of different organizations and an When staff understand a situation, they can help +examination of opportunity to study the airline to stop the spread of information and manage +business elsewhere other than just in Thailand. the problem promptly. Thus, it is important to +have an understanding of crisis communication +Application of Research +manage-ment from the very beginning of their +Airline staff and executives of all career with an airline. +departments should receive training to have a +better understanding of crises. Crises are related +References +Ananchai Sakdejayont. (2010). Protection of Airline passenger rights: The case of Thailand. Bangkok: +Thammasat University. +Bland, M. (1998). Communicating out of a crisis. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Macmillan Business. +Coombs, W. (2007b). Crisis management and communication. Retrieved July 3, 2018, from http://www. +instituteforpr.org/essential_knowledge/detail/crisis_management_and_communications/ +Coombs, W. T. (2011). Ongoing crisis communication: Planning, managing, and responding (3th ed.). Thousand +Oaks, CA.: Sage. +Coombs, W. T., Sherry L. Holladay (2010). The Handbook of crisis Communication. Blackwell Publishing Ltd: UK. +Duangtip Worapan. (2002). Public relations in crisis. Bangkok: Tewa Creation Company Limite. +Gonzalez-Herrero, A., & Smith, S. (2008). Crisis communication management on the web: How Internet-based +technologies are changing the way public relations professionals handle business crises. Journal of +Contingencies and Crisis Management, 16(3), 143-153. +Guth, D. W. (1995). Organizational crisis experience and public relations roles. Public Relations Review, 21(2), +123-136. +Heath, R. L. (2010). Crisis communication: Defining the beast and de-marginalizing key publics. In W. T. +Coombs,&S.J. Holladay (Eds.). The handbook of crisis communication. (pp. 1-13). Chichester: Wiley- +Blackwell. +Liu, B. F., Austin, L., & Jin, Y. (2011). How publics respond to crisis communication strategies: The interplay of +information form and source. Public Relations Review, 37(4), 345-353. +Pannavach Pichaibavornphat. (2017). Strategic Crisis Communication Management in Digital Era Case Study +Airline Business: United Airline, Air Asia, and Nok Air. Bangkok: Bangkok University. +Pearson, C. M., & Clair, J. A. (1998). Reframing Crisis management. Academy of Management Review, 23(1), +59-77. + +…127 +วารสารการประชาสมั พนั ธ์และการโฆษณา ปีที่ 12 ฉบับที่ 2 2562 +Rapp, A., Beitelspacher, L. S., Grewal, D., & Hughes, D. E. (2013). Understanding social media effects across +seller, retailer, and consumer interactions. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41(5), 547- +566. +Safflr, Leonard., and Tarrant John. (1992). Power Public Relations How to Get Work for you. Illinois: NTC +Business Book Publishing Group. +Sirintorn Mahamontri. (2004). Public relations strategic plan: A case study of the ministry of public health’s +severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) (Unpublished master’s thesis). Thammasat University, +Bangkok. +Tan, Ee Ling J. (2003). Singapore airline: A case study in exemplary crisis communication (Unpublished master’s +thesis). Wichita State University, Wichita, USA. +Ulmer, R. R., Sellnow, T. L., & Seeger, M. W. (2007). Effective crisis communication: Moving from crisis to +opportunity. Thousand Oaks, Los Angeles: Sage. +Van Dijk, J. (2012). The network society (3 ed.). London: SAGE Publications Ltd. +Wilcox, D. (1994). The guide to effective participation. Brighton: Delta Press. +Wilcox, Dennis L, Ault, Philip H., & Agee, Warren K. (1998). Public relations strategies and tactics. New York: +Longman. +Wright, Donald K., and Michelle D. Hinson.(2009) Examining how public relations practitioners actually are using +social media. Public Relations Journal 3(3), 1-33. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q79/random_k4/random_4.md b/q79/random_k4/random_4.md index a334b8d779333a86838d9effd3dd99b5ea050aa5..f4ac5f0c235461eaca5f7b2abad3831bbe14de05 100644 --- a/q79/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q79/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,704 +1,2676 @@ -SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING - - SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING - -W H A T T H I S S E S S I O N W I L L C O V E R +medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Determinants of penetrance and variable expressivity in monogenic +metabolic conditions across 77,184 exomes + +Julia Goodrich1, Moriel Singer-Berk1, Rachel Son1, Abigail Sveden1, Jordan Wood1, Eleina England1, +Joanne B. Cole1, Ben Weisburd1, Nick Watts1, Zachary Zappala1, Haichen Zhang2, Kristin A. Maloney2, +Andy Dahl3, Carlos A. Aguilar-Salinas4, Gil Atzmon5-7, Francisco Barajas-Olmos8, Nir Barzilai5,7, John +Blangero9, Eric Boerwinkle10,11, Lori L. Bonnycastle12, Erwin Bottinger13, Donald W Bowden14-16, +Federico Centeno- Cruz8, John C. Chambers17,18, Nathalie Chami13,19, Edmund Chan20, Juliana Chan21- +24, Ching-Yu Cheng25,26,27, Yoon Shin Cho28,Cecilia Contreras-Cubas8, Emilio Córdova8, Adolfo +Correa29, Ralph A. DeFronzo30, Ravindranath Duggirala9, Josée Dupuis31, Ma. Eugenia Garay-Sevilla32, +Humberto García-Ortiz8, Christian Gieger33, Benjamin Glaser34, Clicerio González-Villalpando35, Ma +Elena Gonzalez36, Niels Grarup37, Leif Groop38,39, Myron Gross40, Christopher Haiman41, Sohee Han42, +Craig L Hanis10, Torben Hansen37, Nancy L. Heard-Costa43,44, Brian E Henderson41, Juan Manuel +Malacara Hernandez32, Mi Yeong Hwang42, Sergio Islas-Andrade8, Marit E Jørgensen45-47, Hyun Min +Kang48, Bong-Jo Kim42, Young Jin Kim42, Heikki A. Koistinen49-51, Jaspal Singh Kooner52-55, Johanna +Kuusisto56, Soo-Heon Kwak57, Markku Laakso56, Leslie Lange58, Jong-Young Lee59, Juyoung Lee42, +Donna M. Lehman30, Allan Linneberg60-62, Jianjun Liu63, 20, 64, Ruth J.F. Loos13,19, Valeriya Lyssenko38,65, +Ronald C. W. Ma21-24, Angélica Martínez-Hernández8, James B. Meigs1,66,67, Thomas Meitinger68,69, +Elvia Mendoza- Caamal8, Karen L. Mohlke70, Andrew D. Morris71,72, Alanna C. Morrison10, Maggie CY +Ng14-16, Peter M. Nilsson73, Christopher J. O’Donnell74-77, Lorena Orozco8, Colin N. A. Palmer78, Kyong +Soo Park57,79,80, Wendy S. Post81, Oluf Pedersen37, Michael Preuss13, Bruce M. Psaty82,83, Alexander P. +Reiner84, Cristina Revilla-Monsalve85, Stephen S Rich86, Jerome I Rotter87, Danish Saleheen88-90, +Claudia Schurmann13,91,92, Xueling Sim63, Rob Sladek93-95, Kerrin S Small96, Wing Yee So21-23, Xavier +Soberón8, Timothy D Spector96, Konstantin Strauch97,98, Tim M Strom99,68, E Shyong Tai63,20,27, Claudia +H.T. Tam21-23, Yik Ying Teo63,100,101, Farook Thameem102, Brian Tomlinson103, Russell P. Tracy104,105, +Tiinamaija Tuomi39,106-108, Jaakko Tuomilehto109-112, Teresa Tusié-Luna113,114, Rob M. van Dam63,20,115, +Ramachandran S. Vasan43,116, James G Wilson117, Daniel R Witte118,119, Tien-Yin Wong25, 26, 27, Lizz +Caulkins1, Noël P. Burtt1, Noah Zaitlen3, Mark I. McCarthy120-122, Michael Boehnke48, Toni I. Pollin2, +Jason Flannick1,123,124, Josep M. Mercader1,125,126, Anne O’Donnell-Luria1,123,124, Samantha Baxter1, Jose +C. Florez1,125,126, Daniel MacArthur1,127,128, Miriam S. Udler-Aubrey1,125,126, for AMP-T2D-GENES +Consortia + +Affiliations +1 Program in Medical and Population Genetics, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA, USA. +2 School of Medicine, University of Maryland Baltimore, Baltimore, MD, USA. +3 Department of Neurology, UCLA, Los Angeles, California. +4 Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Medicas y Nutricion, Mexico City, Mexico. +5 Department of Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York, NY, USA. +6 Faculty of Natural Science, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel. +7 Department of Genetics, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York, NY, USA. +8 Instituto Nacional de Medicina Genómica, Mexico City, Mexico. +9 Department of Human Genetics and South Texas Diabetes and Obesity Institute, University of Texas Rio +Grande Valley, Brownsville and Edinburg, TX, USA + +NOTE: This preprint reports new research that has not been certified by peer review and should not be used to guide clinical practice. 1 + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +10 Human Genetics Center, School of Public Health, The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, +Houston, TX, USA +11 Human Genome Sequencing Center, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA +12 Medical Genomics and Metabolic Genetics Branch, National Human Genome Research Institute, National +Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA. +13 The Charles Bronfman Institute for Personalized Medicine, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, +NY, USA. +14 Center for Diabetes Research, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC, USA. +15 Center for Genomics and Personalized Medicine Research, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, +NC, USA. +16 Department of Biochemistry, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC, USA +17 Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Imperial College London, UK +18 Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore +19 The Mindich Child Health and Development Institute, Ichan School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY, +USA. +20 Department of Medicine, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore and National +University Health System, Singapore, Singapore +21 Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. +22 Chinese University of Hong Kong-Shanghai Jiao Tong University Joint Research Centre in Diabetes Genomics +and Precision Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. +23 Hong Kong Institute of Diabetes and Obesity, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. +24 Li Ka Shing Institute of Health Sciences, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. +25 Singapore Eye Research Institute, Singapore National Eye Centre, Singapore, Singapore +26 Department of Ophthalmology, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore and National +University Health System, Singapore, Singapore. +27 Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore. +28 Department of Biomedical Science, Hallym University, Chuncheon, South Korea. +29 Department of Medicine, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS, USA. +30 Department of Medicine, University of Texas Health San Antonio (aka University of Texas Health Science +Center at San Antonio), San Antonio, TX, USA +31 Department of Biostatistics, Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA. +32 Department of Medical Science, División of Health Science. University of Guanjuato. Campus León. León, Gto. +México. +33 Institute of Human Genetics, Helmholtz Zentrum München, German Research Center for Environmental Health, +Neuherberg, Germany. +34 Endocrinology and Metabolism Service, Hadassah-Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel. +35 Unidad de Investigacion en Diabetes y Riesgo Cardiovascular, Instituto Nacional de Salud Publica, +Cuernavaca, Mexico. +36 Centro de Estudios en Diabetes, Mexico City, Mexico. +37 Novo Nordisk Foundation Center for Basic Metabolic Research, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, +University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark. +38 Department of Clinical Sciences, Diabetes and Endocrinology, Lund University Diabetes Centre, Malmö, +Sweden. +39 Institute for Molecular Genetics Finland, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland. +40 Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA. +41 Department of Preventive Medicine, Keck School of Medicine of USC, Los Angeles, CA, USA. +42 Division of Genome Research, Center for Genome Science, National Institute of Health, Chungcheongbuk-do, +South Korea. + 2 + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +43 Boston University and National Heart Lung and Blood Institute’s Framingham Heart Study, Framingham, MA, +USA. +44 Department of Neurology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA. +45 Steno Diabetes Center Copenhagen, Gentofte, Denmark. +46 National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Copenhagen, Denmark. +47 Greenland Centre for Health Research, University of Greenland, Nuuk, Greenland. +48 Department of Biostatistics and Center for Statistical Genetics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. +49 Department of Public Health Solutions, Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland. +50 University of Helsinki and Department of Medicine, Helsinki University Central Hospital, Helsinki, Finland. +51 Minerva Foundation Institute for Medical Research, Helsinki, Finland. +52 Department of Cardiology, Ealing Hospital, London North West Healthcare NHS Trust, London, UK. +53 MRC-PHE Centre for Environment and Health, Imperial College London, London, UK. +54 Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, Imperial College London, London, UK. +55 National Heart and Lung Institute, Imperial College London, London, UK. +56 Institute of Clinical Medicine, Internal Medicine, University of Eastern Finland and Kuopio University Hospital, +Kuopio, Finland +57 Department of Internal Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, South Korea. +58 Department of Medicine, University of Colorado Denver, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, CO, USA. +59 Oneomics Soonchunhyang Mirae Medical Center, Bucheon-si Gyeonggi-do 14585, Republic of Korea +60 Department of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Copenhagen, +Copenhagen, Denmark +61 Center for Clinical Research and Prevention, Bispebjerg and Frederiksberg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark. +62 Department of Clinical Experimental Research, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark. +63 Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University of Singapore and National University Health +System, Singapore, Singapore. +64 Genome Institute of Singapore, Agency for Science Technology and Research, Singapore, Singapore. +65 Department of Clinical Science, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway. +66 Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA. +67 Division of General Internal Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. +68 Institute of Human Genetics, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany. +69 German Centre for Cardiovascular Research (DZHK), Partner Site Munich Heart Alliance, Munich, Germany. +70 Department of Genetics, University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA. +71 Wellcome Centre for Human Genetics, Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. +72 Department of Biostatistics, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK. +73 Department of Clinical Sciences, Medicine, Lund University, Malmö, Sweden +74 Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA. +75 Section of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, VA Boston Healthcare, Boston, MA, USA. +76 Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. +77 Intramural Administration Management Branch, National Heart Lung and Blood Institute, NIH, Framingham, +MA, USA. +78 Pat Macpherson Centre for Pharmacogenetics and Pharmacogenomics, University of Dundee, Dundee, UK. +79 Department of Internal Medicine, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea. +80 Department of Molecular Medicine and Biopharmaceutical Sciences, Graduate School of Convergence Science +and Technology, Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea. +81 Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA. +82 Cardiovascular Health Research Unit, Departments of Medicine, Epidemiology, and Health Services, University +of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA. +83 Kaiser Permanente Washington Research Institute, Seattle, WA, USA. +84 Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA, USA. + 3 + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +85 Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social SXXI, Mexico City, Mexico. +86 Center for Public Health Genomics, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, VA, USA. +87 The Institute for Translational Genomics and Population Sciences, Department of Pediatrics, The Lundquist +Institute for Biomedical Innovation (formerly Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute) at Harbor-UCLA Medical +Center, Torrance, CA, USA. +88 Division of Translational Medicine and Human Genetics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA. +89 Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA. +90 Center for Non-Communicable Diseases, Karachi, Pakistan. +91 Digital Health Center, Hasso Plattner Institute, University of Potsdam, Prof.-Dr.-Helmert-Str. 2-3, 14482 +Potsdam, Germany +92 Hasso Plattner Institute for Digital Health at Mount Sinai, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, One +Gustave L. Levy Place, New York, NY 10029, USA +93 Department of Human Genetics, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada. +94 Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Department of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, +Canada. +95 McGill University and Génome Québec Innovation Centre, Montreal, Quebec, Canada. +96 Department of Twin Research and Genetic Epidemiology, King’s College London, London, UK. +97 Institute of Genetic Epidemiology, Helmholtz Zentrum Munchen, German Research Center for Environmental +Health, Neuherberg, Germany. +98 Institute for Medical Informatics Biometry and Epidemiology, Ludwig-Maximilians University, Munich, Germany. +99 Institute of Human Genetics, Helmholtz Zentrum München, German Research Center for Environmental Health, +Neuherberg, Germany. +102 Life Sciences Institute, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore. +101 Department of Statistics and Applied Probability, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore. +102 Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Medicine, Health Science Center, Kuwait University, Safat, Kuwait. +103 Faculty of Medicine, Macau University of Science & Technology, Macau, China. +104 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, The Robert Larner M.D. College of +Medicine, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT, USA. +105 Department of Biochemistry, The Robert Larner M.D. College of Medicine, University of Vermont, Burlington, +VT, USA. +106 Folkhälsan Research Centre, Helsinki, Finland. +107 Department of Endocrinology, Abdominal Centre, Helsinki University Hospital, Helsinki, Finland. +108 Research Programs Unit, Clinical and Molecular Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland. +109 Diabetes Prevention Unit, National Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland. +110 Center for Vascular Prevention, Danube University Krems, Krems, Austria. +111 Diabetes Research Group, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. +112 Instituto de Investigacion Sanitaria del Hospital Universario LaPaz (IdiPAZ), University Hospital LaPaz, +Autonomous University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain. +113 Unidad de Biología Molecular y Medicina Genómica, Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Médicas y Nutrición +Salvador Zubirán, Mexico City, Mexico. +114 Departamento de Medicina Genómica y Toxiología Ambiental, Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas, UNAM, +Mexico City, Mexico. +115 Department of Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA. +116 Preventive Medicine & Epidemiology, and Cardiovascular Medicine, Medicine, Boston University School of +Medicine, and Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public health, Boston, MA, USA. +117 Department of Physiology and Biophysics, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS, USA +118 Department of Public Health, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark. +119 Danish Diabetes Academy, Odense, Denmark. + 4 -5 + medRxiv preprint -6 +doi: -What is social media marketing and why is it important +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Social media landscape +; -Social media marketing – use cases and benefits +this version posted September 24, 2020. -What does good look like? +The copyright holder for this -How to execute a campaign + a club success story +preprint -Do’s and Don’ts + additional resources +(which was not certified by peer review) -2 + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. - WHAT IS SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING? +It is made available under a -D E S C R I P T I O N +CC-BY 4.0 International license -The use of social -networks, content -sharing apps, -messaging platforms, -blogs, and forums to -connect with and enable -meaningful -conversations about -your brand, product or -service, to ultimately -drive your business -objective. + . -3 +120 Oxford Centre for Diabetes, Endocrinology and Metabolism, Radcliffe Department of Medicine, University of +Oxford, Oxford, UK. +121 Wellcome Centre for Human Genetics, Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. +122 Present address: Genentech, 1 DNA Way, South San Francisco, CA, USA. +123 Division of Genetics and Genomics, Boston Children’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA +124 Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA. +125 Diabetes Unit and Center for Genomic Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. +126 Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA. +127 Centre for Population Genomics, Garvan Institute of Medical Research, and UNSW Sydney, Sydney, New +South Wales, Australia +128 Centre for Population Genomics, Murdoch Children’s Research Institute, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia - WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? +Corresponding author: +Miriam S. Udler +mudler@mgh.harvard.edu -C U S T O M E R E X P E C T A T I O N S H A V E C H A N G E D +List of Tables +Table 1 - Impact of clinically significant variants on traits. -2X +List of Supplementary Tables +Supplementary Table 1 - Summary characteristics of study populations. -customers are twice as likely to -share a negative experience with a -business than a positive one +Supplementary Table 2 - Detailed characteristics of study cohorts. AMP-T2D-GENES Cohort +Information. -90% +Supplementary Table 3 - Counts of clinically significant variants and carriers across conditions. -will look at online -reviews before making -a purchase +Supplementary Table 4 - Effect size and penetrance estimates of clinically significant monogenic +variants across conditions and by gene. -74% +Supplementary Table 5 - Effect size and penetrance in filtered out variants (designated benign, likely +benign, or not pLOF) -trust suggestions from -”friends” on social media +Supplementary Table 6 – Comparison of Top 1% gePS with interquartile range and monogenic carriers. -67% +Supplementary Table 7 - Mean serum LDL values based on ascertainment. -of people will spend money after -getting recommendations from -their “friends” online +Supplementary Table 8 - Clinical characteristics of monogenic diabetes variant carriers. -Sources: White House Office of Consumer Affairs, McKinsey, Experian |24|7, Gigya, CEI +Supplementary Table 9 - Impact of polygenic score on trait expressivity in monogenic carriers. -4 +Supplementary Table 10 - Frequency cut-offs used for ClinVar variant curation. - WHY IS SOCIAL IMPORTANT? +Supplementary Table 11 - pLoF curation categories and guidelines for classification. -N E W T R E N D S A R E E M E R G I N G C H A N G I N G T H E U S A G E A N D I M P O R T A N C E O F S O C I A L +Supplementary Table 12 - Variant curation assessments and carrier counts. -Understanding the social media space and managing your social presence amplifies your marketing -strategy. Social media delivers invaluable insight into your brand awareness, customer sentiment, -marketplace trends, and your competitor’s actions, whilst enabling you to reach more prospects than any -other marketing channel. +List of Supplementary Figures +Supplementary Figure 1. Distribution of clinically significant variants across ancestries. -Every negative social interaction has a cost +Supplementary Figure 2. Carriers of clinically significant variants in MODY genes show a younger age +of diabetes diagnosis compared the rest of the AMP-T2D-GENES cohorts and the UK Biobank +population. -Customers are content creators +5 -Brands are turning online influencers into advocates + medRxiv preprint -Social is now a prominent point of purchase +doi: -Brand focus is shifting to measuring quality of interactions +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Reviews can increase sales and add credibility +; -Social is multifunctional – used for marketing, listening, -response, customer care, troubleshooting +this version posted September 24, 2020. -5 +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a - SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE +CC-BY 4.0 International license -T H E K E Y P L A Y E R S + . -The social media landscape is large and -complex and cluttered with competing -platforms, but the most heavily utilised -for marketing are the big 4: +Abstract +Hundreds of thousands of genetic variants have been reported to cause severe monogenic diseases, +but the probability that a variant carrier will develop the disease (termed penetrance) is unknown for +virtually all of them. Additionally, the clinical utility of common polygenetic variation remains uncertain. +Using exome sequencing from 77,184 adult individuals (38,618 multi-ancestral individuals from a type 2 +diabetes case-control study and 38,566 participants from the UK Biobank, for whom genotype array +data were also available), we applied clinical standard-of-care gene variant curation for eight +monogenic metabolic conditions. Rare variants causing monogenic diabetes and dyslipidemias +displayed effect sizes significantly larger than the top 1% of the corresponding polygenic scores. +Nevertheless, penetrance estimates for monogenic variant carriers averaged below 60% in both studies +for all conditions except monogenic diabetes. We assessed additional epidemiologic and genetic +factors contributing to risk prediction, demonstrating that inclusion of common polygenic variation +significantly improved biomarker estimation for two monogenic dyslipidemias. -Facebook (FB, Instagram, -Messenger) +Introduction -Google (YouTube) +Healthcare providers and researchers are increasingly faced with interpreting genetic sequence -Twitter +data collected from individuals who are asymptomatic or for whom limited clinical information is +available. Standard clinical practice for reporting whole exome and genome sequencing results may +involve risk assessment for genetic variation causing conditions of known relevance to the individual +and also potentially impactful variants unrelated to the primary indication for testing (termed “secondary +genetic findings,” for example the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) list of +59 medically actionable genes1-4). Thus, predicting the risk conferred by genetic findings in individuals +who are not known to have the relevant conditions is of critical importance, but remains a challenge5. +Furthermore, the scope of genetic variation interpreted in current clinical genetics practice is +predominantly limited to rare monogenic “Mendelian” disease variants with large predicted effect sizes, +leaving the vast majority of the genome, including common variants, unassessed. Recent studies have +suggested that a high burden of common genetic variation may confer increased disease risk +equivalent in magnitude to carrying rare monogenic variants6; however, this equivalency has recently +been called into question7, and it remains uncertain whether and how to integrate polygenic scores +capturing common genetic variation into medical care8. -LinkedIn +Clinical application of genomic sequence data requires identification of medically significant + +genetic variants and estimation of their impact. In recent years, detailed guidelines from the ACMG and +the Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP)9 have provided standards for reporting clinically +significant variants which have been implemented by approximately 95% of clinical laboratories +internationally10. However, the probability that carriers of such variants will manifest the given condition +(termed “penetrance”) is unknown or uncertain for the vast majority of reported pathogenic variants5. +Furthermore, individuals with the same genotype may exhibit variable degrees of phenotype expression +(termed “variable expressivity”)11,12. Estimates of penetrance and expressivity traditionally have been +derived from studies focusing on individuals with a given condition and their family members; this +approach suffers from ascertainment bias, since the proband, who came to clinical attention due to +having the condition, may share other genetic and/or environmental factors influencing manifestation of +the condition with their family members12,13. Interpretation of rare variants identified by sequencing is +further complicated by limited or no data available from any source, including families, to assess +penetrance5. 6 - SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING LANDSCAPE + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; -D I F F E R E N T C H A N N E L S A R E U S E D F O R D I F F E R E N T P U R P O S E S +this version posted September 24, 2020. -Social networks -Relationship networks help brands and people connect to share -information and ideas. With a large & regular user base, they are a must- -have and the ”mass-market” approach to social marketing. +The copyright holder for this -Use for: customer care, education, daily comms, breaking news +preprint -Messaging & chat apps +(which was not certified by peer review) -Most widely used apps that enable messaging, video and voice calls. Business -can conduct e-commerce conversations via live agents or chatbots. + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -Use for: customer care, conversational commerce, payments, status updates, -to replace SMS +It is made available under a -Media & content sharing -networks +CC-BY 4.0 International license -Find and share media online, including photos, video, and live video or other -curated content. + . -Consumer review -networks -Manage online reviews and reputation. Positive reviews bring social proof to -your value proposition. Negative reviews provide you with an opportunity to -resolve an issue publicly. +Large-scale population-based and cohort studies with both sequence and phenotype data offer -Use for: brand awareness, lead generation, audience engagement, targeted -advertising, influencer marketing +an opportunity to estimate penetrance and expressivity with less upward bias compared to family or +case-control studies. In fact, population-based studies may have a healthy-participant bias which could +provide downwardly biased estimates of penetrance14. Recent studies attempting to connect large- +scale genetic and phenotypic data have noted reduced penetrance estimates compared to those +previously reported; however, these recent studies were limited by sample size and/or application of +less stringent curation of genetic variants than the current clinical standard of care ACMG/AMP +guideline approach7,14-17. Additionally, further characterization of additional epidemiologic and genetic +factors, such as phenotypic ascertainment and polygenic risk, is needed for accurate prediction of +penetrance and expressivity for rare monogenic variants. -Use for: customer care, reputation management, market research +Here we present analyses performed in two separate datasets: 38,618 exomes from individuals -Blogs & forums -Publish, find, discuss, and share news, information, and opinions. Usually allow -users to remain anonymous, leading to more honest opinions. +ascertained as part of multi-ancestral type 2 diabetes (T2D) case-control studies, and 38,566 exomes +from individual volunteers in the UK Biobank (UKB). Our analyses focused on traits with complex +genetic architectures, involving rare and common genetic contribution, and well-defined biomarkers. +These included diabetes (maturity-onset diabetes of the young (MODY), neonatal diabetes, autosomal +dominant lipodystrophy) and disorders of LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglycerides, and obesity. +In addition to performing stringent curation using the ACMG/AMP criteria9 to generate a set of clinically +significant genetic variants, we have also calculated polygenic scores in the UKB dataset to assess the +cumulative impact of common variation on the same phenotypes. These data allow us to make a direct +comparison between monogenic and polygenic risk, and to assess the contribution of polygenic risk to +expressivity for carriers of monogenic variants. -Interest-based networks -Help connect with others around a shared interest or hobby and tend to focus -solely on a single subject and provide a dedicated experience for users. +Results +Identification of high confidence clinically significant variants enhances risk stratification -Use for: market research, influencer marketing, product advertising, SEO -results +We studied two distinct datasets for which both individual-level exome sequence and +phenotypic data were available (N=77,184): a compilation of multi-ancestral case control-studies for +T2D, involving 22,875 T2D (or prediabetes) cases (see Methods) and 15,743 controls from the T2D- +GENES and AMP-T2D consortia18, (referred to subsequently as AMP-T2D-GENES); and 38,566 +unrelated individuals of European origin from the UKB19 (see Methods, Supplementary Table 1). Our +analyses focused on 26 genes offered by clinical laboratories the United States for evaluation of +monogenic forms of diabetes or diabetes-related traits through autosomal dominant modes of +inheritance: MODY most commonly offered in panel testing (GCK, HNF1A, HNF1B, HNF4A, PDX1), an +extended set of purported MODY genes less frequently offered in panel testing (AKT2, KLF11, APPL1, +ABCC8, KCNJ11, NEUROD1, CEL, INS), neonatal diabetes (ABCC8, GATA4, GATA6, HNF1B, INS, +KCNJ11), lipodystrophy (AKT2, LMNA, PLIN1, PPARG), elevated LDL cholesterol (LDLR, APOB), low +serum LDL cholesterol (APOB, PCSK9), elevated serum HDL cholesterol (CETP), hypertriglyceridemia +(APOA5, LPL), and monogenic obesity (MC4R). -Use for: targeted marketing, brand awareness, trend watching +We performed stringent variant curation using the clinical gold standard ACMG/AMP criteria, +blinded to carrier phenotypic data for two classes of variants: 276 variants previously reported to be +clinically significant (designated “pathogenic” or “likely pathogenic”) in the ClinVar database20 or +designated as disease-causing in review articles21-23; and 218 predicted loss of function (pLoF) variants +in genes with supported loss-of-function mechanism of action (see Methods). Our approach was +intended to capture high-confidence clinically significant variants, although notably excluded missense 7 - SOCIAL MARKETING USE CASES + medRxiv preprint -H O W T O U S E S O C I A L T O M E E T Y O U R O B J E C T I V E S +doi: -Manage -own page +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Generate -insights +; -Nurture community -& reputation +this version posted September 24, 2020. -Engage with -customers +The copyright holder for this -Grow through -amplification +preprint -Draft and publish organic -content to owned -page(s) +(which was not certified by peer review) -Define and manage -content strategy and -calendar + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -Manage content -approvals +It is made available under a -Listen/capture social -conversations about LTA, -coaches, or venues and -identify trends +CC-BY 4.0 International license -Keep up with competitors -and stay informed of their -social engagement, -content and campaigns + . -Understand target -audience demographics, -sentiment, and channel -preferences +variants beyond those in the ClinVar database because of the low prior probability of disease relevance +and the challenges of inferring pathogenicity for this variant class. In total across the AMP-T2D-GENES +and UKB study exomes, 238 variants, representing 51% of all 463 variants curated, were determined +by ACMG/AMP criteria to be clinically significant and were found in 626 carriers (Figure 1, +Supplementary Table 3, Supplementary Table 12). Across the conditions, the clinically significant +variants were observed in all represented ancestral groups (Supplementary Figure 1). -Grow your community of -social followers and -supporters +We next assessed the impact of clinically significant monogenic variants on corresponding +biomarkers, restricting analyses to conditions with at least ten carriers of variants in relevant genes +(Supplementary Table 3). Monogenic variant carriers for dyslipidemias had significantly more extreme +lipid trait values compared to non-carriers, with shifts of ~55 mg/dL for both high and low LDL +cholesterol conditions, ~130 mg/dL for high triglycerides, and ~16 md/dL for high HDL cholesterol +(P<10-5 for all; adjusted for age, sex, and 10 PCs; Table 1). For monogenic obesity, MC4R variant +carriers had ~2 kg/m2 higher mean body mass index (BMI) than non-carriers in both datasets, however +this difference reached significance only in UKB (P=0.063 AMP-T2D-GENES, P=0.006 UKB). Despite +differences in the study populations and designs in AMP-T2D-GENES and UKB, the effect sizes of +clinically significant variants on relevant biomarkers were remarkably consistent across the two studies +for dyslipidemia and obesity gene sets, once the former was adjusted for lipid medication use (Table 1, +Supplementary Table 4). MODY variant carriers had significantly increased odds of having diabetes +compared to non-carriers in both studies (OR>7, P<10-4; Table 1, Supplementary Table 4); +differences in risk estimates between the two studies were likely influenced by ascertainment practices +in AMP-T2D-GENES, as it was a T2D case-control study and several sub-studies intentionally excluded +diabetes cases with clinical features suggestive of MODY18 (Supplementary Table 2). -Find and nurture -advocates and -influencers who can -credibly promote your -brand to an extended -audience +We also performed the same effect size estimates noted above, but for the variants filtered out +during our curation process. We reclassified 7% (21/276) of curated variants from review articles and +from ClinVar (which had been designated as clinically significant by at least one submitting source) to +“benign” or “likely benign.” Likewise, 27% (59/218) of the pLoF variants were downgraded by our +manual review of sequence reads. Together, these ClinVar, review, and pLoF variants which were +downgraded by our curation (77/463, 17%) had marked reduced effect sizes compared to variants we +curated as clinically significant (Supplementary Table 5)24-27. These findings support our curation +process and highlight the need for caution in relying on available variant designations without additional +review. -Identify and manage -potential crises +Monogenic variant effect sizes are significantly larger than the top 1% of polygenic risk scores -Respond to consumer -problems when they -have questions or -concerns +We next directly compared the effect of monogenic variation to common genetic variation on the -Be part of the -conversations about your -venues, coaches or -brand +same corresponding biomarkers in UKB participants. We employed published polygenic scores +capturing millions of common genetic variants across the genome, termed global extended polygenic +scores (gePS)28 (see Methods). Since the gePS predicts lifetime risk of developing a disease, and the +population mean age in UKB was 58 years, it was possible that estimates by gePS would be under- +estimates not capturing individuals who would later in life develop a given condition. We therefore +performed gePS analyses restricted to individuals age +fairer comparison with monogenic conditions, which are typically diagnosed at a younger age. -React with relevant -content – use what you -see and hear to help -inform future marketing -strategy + 60 year (mean age 65 years) so as to have a -Push paid content to -custom audiences to reach -your marketing objectives +≥ -Identify and amplify -relevant user content for -authentic engagement +Individuals with the top 1% of gePS had more extreme lipid levels or diabetes risk compared to -Social commerce – -increasing number of -businesses are using -social as a payment -channel +those with average gePS (25-75%tiles) (Supplementary Table 6); however the carriers of clinically 8 - THE BENEFITS OF SOCIAL + medRxiv preprint -W H A T S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G C A N D O F O R Y O U +doi: -1. +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Strengthen your -brand reputation +; -2. +this version posted September 24, 2020. -Grow your -business +The copyright holder for this -3. +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) -Care for your -customers + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -Know & act on what is being said about -you -• Things escalate quickly on social. By +It is made available under a -listening to key phrases that relate to your -brand or activity you can be the first to -know when a news story breaks and react -accordingly. +CC-BY 4.0 International license -• Social insights also give you an unbiased + . -view of your brand awareness and -popularity. +significant monogenic variants for these same conditions had even more severe values compared to +those top 1% respective gePS’s (P<0.05 for each condition, Figure 2, Supplementary Table 6). For +obesity, the difference in BMI between MC4R monogenic variant carriers and the top 1% BMI gePS +was not significant (Figure 2). -Identify trends -• Trends appear on social media first. Social +Monogenic metabolic conditions display highly variable penetrance estimates -can make or break a product. +While in aggregate clinically significant monogenic variants had marked effect sizes, individual- -• Listening to industry thought-leadership -supports your research and innovation +level trait values in carriers varied considerably (Figure 3A). In both datasets, penetrance estimates +based on standard disease cut-offs were estimated to be less than 60% for all monogenic metabolic +conditions except elevated HDL cholesterol and monogenic diabetes (Figure 3B, Supplementary +Table 2). Penetrance estimates using composite gene sets for conditions ranged from no more than +20% for low LDL cholesterol conditions caused by APOB and PCSK9 variants (20.0%, 95% CI 8.4- +36.9% in AMP-T2D-GENES, 5.6%, 95% CI 1.8-12.5% in UKB) to greater than 80% for diabetes or +prediabetes caused by MODY genes GCK, HNF1A, HNF4A, HNF1B, and PDX1 (86.4%, 95% CI’s +65.1-97.1% in AMP-T2D-GENES, 81.2%, 54.4-96% in UKB) (Figure 3B, Supplementary Table 4). -Stay ahead of competition -• Your competitors are on social. Analysing +Genetic vs phenotypic ascertainment of MODY suggests broad phenotypic spectrum -their social presence delivers unique -insight into their plans and achievements -• Regular benchmarking of your competitors +We performed deeper phenotyping of MODY variant carriers in the two datasets to determine -on social helps you keep up with them +whether these genetically ascertained individuals manifested clinical features suggestive of MODY, as +typically seen in phenotypically ascertained MODY cases. Monogenic diabetes, and particularly MODY +(the most common form) can often be misdiagnosed as type or type 2; however, MODY has subtle +phenotypic differences from these other forms of diabetes and also, importantly, distinct gene-specific +therapeutic strategies29. -Amplify owned content -• Social enables you to publish targeted +≤ -content to channels that could be seen by -large volumes of users +30 and triglycerides -• The power of influencer marketing +Focusing on the MODY genes most commonly offered in commercial panels available in the +United States (HNF1A, GCK, HNF4A, HNF1B, and PDX1)30, more than 80% of carriers of clinically +significant variants had evidence of prediabetes or diabetes (81.2% (95% CI 54.4-96.0%) in UKB and +86.4% (95% CI 65.1-97.1%) in AMP-T2D-GENES) (Supplementary Table 8, Supplementary Figure +2). Notably clinical features classically associated with MODY (BMI +were only observed in 50% (11/22) of MODY variant-carrying individuals in AMP-T2D-GENES and 75% +(12/16) in UKB. Similarly, an expected young age of diagnosis (age +21% (3/14) of those with available data across both datasets (Supplementary Table 8). Thus, at least +63% of all MODY variant carriers did not have expected clinical features. Since participants in AMP- +T2D-GENES were selected to be T2D cases or controls, and specific exclusion practices employed by +several studies to remove possible monogenic diabetes cases (Supplementary Table 2)18, such +ascertainment practices could certainly introduce bias away from classical MODY features. +Nevertheless, when all MODY carriers were compared to others with diabetes in each study, they had +significantly lower mean BMI and serum triglycerides (BMI: AMP-T2D-GENES: 26.6 vs 28.7 kg/m2, +P=0.027; UKB: 25.8 vs 31.7 kg/m2, P=0.004; triglycerides: AMP-T2D-GENES: 136 vs 182 mg/dL, +P=0.032; UKB: 97 vs 186 mg/dL, P=0.004; adjusted for age, sex, and 10 PCs). Thus, in aggregate, +MODY variant carriers displayed expected clinical features, but on an individual level, genetically +ascertained individuals revealed a broader spectrum of disease phenotype. -provides a human voice to your product +35 years), was only observed in -Generate earned media -• Customers are 56% more likely to buy a -product or service after seeing a positive -customer-generated post of it +≤ +15031,32) -• By reposting user-generated content on -your owned channels, you increase the -trust in your brand and products +≤ -Deliver incremental sales -• Advertising on social media is cheaper -than traditional media (such as TV ads) -but with a massive reach +9 -• The main difference is that you will be + medRxiv preprint -able to target finely who sees what advert, -increasing your conversion while keeping -costs down +doi: -Create experiences -• Social is more than just advertising, it’s an -educational, emotional and experiential -way to engage your customers +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -• Customers no longer want to phone when +; -they have an issue, they want an -immediate answer and turn to social. +this version posted September 24, 2020. -Reduce cost to serve -• With customised chatbots and the use of -artificial intelligence on the rise, in-app -messaging is becoming the norm for -customer care +The copyright holder for this -• Technology solutions enable improved +preprint -customer service through social +(which was not certified by peer review) -Build a community -• Customers trust each other more than -you. Providing them with a platform -where they can interact and share -feedback will increase their trust and -loyalty to your brand, coaches, or venues. + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -9 +It is made available under a - WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? +CC-BY 4.0 International license -H O W T O W I N W I T H S O C I A L M E D I A + . -A great social media strategy includes the following pillars: +We also identified gene-specific findings for the two most common MODY genes, GCK and +HNF1A. GCK-MODY is characterized by non-progressive asymptomatic mild hyperglycemia that is +present from birth and may remain in the prediabetes state rather than progress to diabetes33. In both +datasets 100% (17/17) of carriers of clinically significant GCK variants developed diabetes or +prediabetes (penetrance estimates of 100%, 95% CI: 59.0-100% in AMP-T2D-GENES and 69.2-100% +in UKB). All those with glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) values available (N=13) had levels consistent with +GCK-MODY, ranging from 5.7 to 7.2% (HbA1c in GCK-MODY is typically 5.6-7.6%34) (Supplementary +Table 8). Penetrance estimates for diabetes in HNF1A-MODY from our two datasets (81% in AMP- +T2D-GENES, 95% CI 48.2-97.7 and 40% in UKB, 95% CI 5.27-85.3 diagnosed with diabetes by 55 +years) were lower than what has previously been reported in the literature (e.g. 97%, 95% CI 96–98 by +50 years35) (Supplementary Table 8). -SOCIAL MEDIA -PILLARS +Phenotypic ascertainment strongly impacts estimates of expressivity -Emotional content +It is well-appreciated that phenotypic ascertainment of individuals can upwardly bias estimates -Build rapport with your customers. Forget transactional posts -and focus on posting content that showcases how you will make -a difference in your customers’ life +of expressivity14,36, and we sought to better define this impact by studying conditions of high and low +LDL cholesterol levels, where we had information on phenotypic ascertainment within a specific AMP- +T2D-GENES cohort. A set of 535 individuals selected for extreme LDL cholesterol (>98th or <2nd +percentile), without knowledge of their monogenic condition carrier status, were sequenced as part of +the Exome Sequencing Project (ESP) cohort in AMP-T2D-GENES37 and not included in the prior +analyses. Within this ascertained sample, we identified 18 carriers of clinically significant monogenic +high LDL cholesterol variants in APOB and LDLR (mean LDL 329 mg/dL) and 15 carriers in low LDL +cholesterol variants in APOB and PCSK9 (mean LDL 49.2 mg/dL). As expected, compared to carriers +of variants for the same LDL cholesterol conditions but not ascertained on LDL phenotype, the two +ascertained groups had more extreme LDL cholesterol levels (mean LDL cholesterol values 198 mg/dL, +P=4x10-4 and 77 mg/dL, P=0.06 respectively, Figure 4, Supplementary Table 7). -Consistency +Five variants (High LDL: LDLR p.Glu101Lys, LDLR p.Asp266Glu, LDLR p.Gly592Glu, APOB +p.Arg3527Gln; Low LDL: PCSK9 p.Tyr142Ter) were carried by individuals both in the phenotypically +ascertained group and in the rest of the AMP-T2D-GENES cohort. These variants showed the same +pattern of significantly more extreme LDL cholesterol values in the phenotypically ascertained +compared to genetically ascertained individuals (P<0.05; all analyses adjusted for age, sex, ancestry, +and diabetes status; Figure 4; Supplementary Table 7). These marked differences in LDL cholesterol +values between the phenotypic vs genetic ascertained carriers, even among those carrying exactly the +same LDL cholesterol variant, could not be explained by the use of lipid-lowering medication, assay +use, or biased selection of the LDL cholesterol values among those available (e.g. selection of +maximum LDL cholesterol value ever for phenotypically ascertained participants)37. -Your content should match your brand identity and objectives -and be consistent across channels. +In fact, the mean absolute impact of phenotype ascertainment on serum LDL cholesterol levels -Regular & well- -timed posts +among individuals with monogenic LDL-raising or lowering variants (27.8-131.0 mg/dL, Supplementary +Table 7, Figure 4) was thus similar or greater than the mean impact of carrying these same variants +compared to non-carriers (31.5-65.3 mg/dL, Table 1, Figure 4). Such a substantial effect from +phenotypic ascertainment reflects the large variation in expressivity at the single variant level and +underscores the importance of considering phenotypic ascertainment bias in monogenic risk prediction. -Just like any other channel, there is a better time to post content, -and that varies depending on the network and audience. Keep -your customers interested by posting often and sharing varied -content +Polygenic risk may increase expressivity of monogenic variants -Two-way -engagement +10 -Social is about more than just pushing out content. Allow your -customers to interact with you and make sure you respond to -create a differentiated experience + medRxiv preprint -Optimisation +doi: -Test, learn, adjust, repeat. Iteration is key to success and social -is no different. Plan for A/B testing and track success of -individual campaigns and performance across platforms +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Personalisation +; -Strategic use of -channels +this version posted September 24, 2020. -Use social insights to know who your customers are and adapt -your messaging, including graphics and tone of voice to target -the right customers with the right message at the right time +The copyright holder for this -Not all channels will be relevant to your brand. Whilst a presence -on the Big 4 is a must, focusing your budget and efforts on the -channels where your customers are the most active will deliver -better value for money +preprint -Overall strategy -alignment +(which was not certified by peer review) -Driving revenue and engagement from social does require -investment. Incorporate social as its own channel into your -overall strategy, budget and resources + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -10 +It is made available under a - WHAT DOES GOOD LOOK LIKE? - -P U T T I N G S O C I A L M E D I A P I L L A R S I N T O P R A C T I S E - -Conversational & Engaging Content – -Royal Academy & Aldi - -Influencer & Interest-based Marketing – -Gymshark & Wilson - -Royal Academy uses relatable and -humourous posts and interactive -campaigns such as their -#RAdailydoodle to keep their 441K -Twitter followers engaged, drawing -increased user participation and -personalised well-crafted responses - -Aldi UK celebrated their birthday with -a simple, yet creative invitation to -engage competitors, generating a ton -of interest on Twitter and a positive -response, well-tracked via their -unique hashtag -#Aldi30thBirthdayParty - -Gymshark sponsors key Instagram -influencers to capitalise on their large -audiences (500k+). They also use paid -social as a primary means to drive -sales, and in 2019 saw a £73m increase -in turnover. In 2017, their Black Friday -posts drew a 6.6x return on ad spend. - -Influencer marketing can also reap -benefits on a smaller scale. Like the -Germany-based Tennis Siblings Alex -& Sofi, who are sponsored by Wilson -and adidas and use their modest -following of 15K to promote products -and local tennis tournaments. +CC-BY 4.0 International license -11 + . - EXECUTING A CAMPAIGN - WHERE TO START +The substantial variability in phenotype expressivity that we observed across all monogenic -G E T T I N G T H E B A S I C S R I G H T +conditions (Figure 3A) suggests that additional environmental and/or genetic factors contribute to +expressivity beyond the given monogenic variant. We assessed whether common genetic variation +alters expressivity in UKB participants carrying monogenic disease variants. -2 +Among carriers of high HDL cholesterol, low LDL cholesterol, high triglycerides, and monogenic -Identify your audience -and grow followers +obesity variants, we found that a higher gePS for each condition was associated with a more severe +phenotype (e.g., among carriers of monogenic high HDL cholesterol variants, having an increased HDL +gePS was associated with even higher HDL cholesterol). However, these trends were only significant +for high HDL cholesterol (gePS one SD: beta 17.52 mg/dL, P=0.012) and high triglycerides (gePS one +SD: beta 80.57 mg/dL, P=0.014) (Figure 5, Supplementary Table 9). Notably, despite our large study +size, power in this analysis was limited, and we estimate that at least 98 carriers of clinically significant +variants for a given monogenic condition would be needed for 80% power to detect a correlation of 0.25 +(the minimum noted for the above traits) between a given trait and gePS at significance level +Therefore, for a monogenic condition with prevalence of 1 in 10,000 individuals, a population-based +study with sample size on the order of one million individuals would be required to categorically +determine the impact of polygenic risk. -Start following your members and -people who “look like” them (e.g. -have similar demo, interests, -location, etc.) +=0.05. -Plan a content calendar and post a -variety of engaging content -including text, photo, and video. +α -Track performance to see what -content resonates best with your -audience. +We also assessed the interaction between gePS and monogenic risk in both monogenic carriers +and non-carriers in the UKB, and observed significant positive interactions for the same two conditions, +high HDL cholesterol (P=0.001) and high triglyceride levels (P=0.01); however, given the complexities +of interaction analyses, additional work will also be needed in larger cohorts before we can conclude +that gePS contributes to phenotype expression differently in carriers and non-carriers38. -3 +Discussion -Launch and track your -campaign +Until recently, the impact of clinically significant monogenic variants on predicting phenotype -You can begin with a simple -campaign – such as amplifying a -piece of existing content that -performed well with your existing -followers. +expression has been predominantly studied in individuals or families ascertained on phenotype13. Our +analysis employed population-based studies to provide less biased estimates of penetrance and +expressivity, and to quantify the impact of phenotypic ascertainment and polygenic risk. We were able +to directly compare monogenic and polygenic risk for each condition, and also assess the additional +contribution of polygenic risk to expressivity for carriers of monogenic variants. -Set up campaigns by objective -(page likes, clicks, etc.) and set a -daily or monthly budget. +We applied the current gold standard ACMG/AMP clinical variant classification criteria9 to -Use built-in dashboards from the -social platforms to review -performance and optimise by ad -frequency, time of day, ad format, -and more. +≥ -1 + 40 years) from the AMP-T2D-GENES consortium and the UK Biobank. Our current analysis -Set up your account -page(s) +ensure relevance to current clinical practice and demonstrated resultant improvement in risk +stratification. Gene variant curation was blinded to participant phenotypes and assessed the +pathogenicity of variants expected to cause multiple metabolic conditions in 77,184 exomes of adults +(age +adds to a growing set of studies aimed at re-evaluating penetrance estimates using population-based +studies7,9,14-17,39; however, to the best of our knowledge, this work represents the largest study utilizing +clinical standard-of-care ACMG/AMP criteria to curate gene variants in order to establish the +penetrance and expressivity of all these monogenic conditions. -Establish your presence by -setting up business account / club -page across the relevant social -platforms +Carriers of the highly curated clinically significant variants for MODY and monogenic +dyslipidemias had significantly more extreme trait effect sizes compared to non-carriers (OR > 7 for +diabetes risk, betas 16.5-130.0 mg/dL for dyslipidemias, Pvalues < 10-4, Table 1). Despite differences +in study populations and designs, the effect estimates for rare monogenic variation for all conditions -Include essential business -information for search purposes, -including: Location, Contact info, -and Website URL +11 -#Tip: use hashtags to -start a conversation with -your members and easily -follow what they say about -you and your club + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +aside from monogenic diabetes (which was subject to ascertainment bias in AMP-T2D-GENES) were +remarkably consistent between the two studies, supporting the integrity of our variant curation. We also +assessed the impact of common genetic variation with polygenic scores. There has recently been a +great deal of interest around the potential clinical contribution of such scores, especially gePS, and +particularly in comparison to monogenic variant risk6. We show here that with the exception of +monogenic obesity, polygenic risk at the top 1% of the risk distribution is not equivalent to monogenic +risk, consistent with recent observations,7 but in contrast with others.40 There will likely be further +development of polygenic scores with improved disease prediction in the coming years41; however, in +their current state and for the conditions we studied, the risk conferred by polygenic scores on their own +was still substantially less than clinically significant monogenic variants; the only exception to this was +MC4R obesity variants, which are known to have low predictive value for obesity risk42. + +≥ + 30 kg/m2) was less than 55%, consistent with previous + +We observed a wide range of expressivity among clinically significant monogenic variant +carriers across all traits (Figure 2A), and consequently estimates of penetrance were below 60% for all +conditions except elevated HDL cholesterol and monogenic diabetes. At the single gene-level, the +penetrance of MC4R for obesity (BMI +findings7,42,43 (Figure 2B), while the penetrance of GCK-MODY was 100% for diabetes or prediabetes +(95% CI’s 59-100% in AMP-T2D-GENES, 69-100% in UKB). The range of penetrance estimates across +genes and conditions may relate to ability to measure the direct biomarker(s) impacted by a given +gene, the extent to which there are redundant mechanisms available in a given pathway to overcome a +genetic defect44, and the extent to which additional factors, such as other genetic and environmental +factors (e.g. diet), impact the trait12. The finding of 100% penetrance for diabetes or prediabetes seen in +the 17 carriers of GCK-MODY across both datasets is particularly intriguing. GCK encodes +glucokinase, which acts as the cell’s glucose sensor as it facilitates phosphorylation of glucose to +glucose-6-phosphate in the pancreatic beta cell, which is the first and rate-limiting step in glucose +metabolism45. The complete penetrance we have observed may be due to the ability to directly +measure glucose as a relevant biomarker, as well as the essential role of GCK in glucose homeostasis, +with suspected non-redundancy in functioning as a glucose sensor45. + +We also characterized the impact of phenotypic ascertainment bias on expressivity of clinically + +significant variants, showing that in individuals with the same LDL cholesterol-raising or -lowering +variants there were significant differences in biomarker levels depending on the mode of ascertainment +(genetic vs phenotypic) (Figure 3) and that the magnitude of this difference on LDL cholesterol levels +(29-129 mg/dL) was similar or greater than the mean effect size of such variants (31.5-65.3 mg/dL, +Table 1). This substantial impact of ascertainment bias was seen at the individual variant level, +consistent with other similar observations of LDL cholesterol levels in LDLR and APOB carriers in a +different study population36,46 and HNF4A p.Arg114Trp in diabetes risk14 (HNF4A p.Arg114Trp was +present in the present datasets, but filtered out due to its designation as a variant of uncertain +significant (VUS), reflecting its known low penetrance). The extent of ascertainment bias that we and +others have identified highlights an important genetic counseling consideration, particularly with respect +to interpretations of genomic sequencing data with limited clinical context available: interpretation of the +same test result will likely have different prognostic implications depending on whether the individual +tested or family members carry the phenotype of interest (e.g. hyperlipidemia) vs if a variant is identified +secondarily; a Bayesian framework that takes into account pre-test probability might therefore be +useful47. Additionally, the variable expressivity seen at the single-variant level in multiple instances +further supports additional risk factor modulation from other genetic and environmental exposures. -4 +12 -Scale up and add on -to master social + medRxiv preprint -Once you have your first campaign -under your belt, report on your -performance and measure against -your original business KPIs. +doi: -Refresh your content and launch -new campaigns for different target -audiences. +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 -Explore and introduce more -complex functionality available to -you, including new data sources, -more robust tracking (e.g. FB pixel), -new ad formats, or new social -platforms. +; -12 +this version posted September 24, 2020. - CLUB SUCCESS STORY +The copyright holder for this -N O R B U R Y P A R K L T C +preprint -SITUATION +(which was not certified by peer review) -Norbury Park LTC was established in 1889 in the London Borough of Croydon. It -has four floodlit tarmac courts and a small management committee made up -entirely of volunteers. Club membership was at an all-time low so the committee -put together an action plan to significantly increase membership within a year. + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -APPROACH +It is made available under a -The club recruited a volunteer Marketing and Communications Officer and decided -to run a Nature Valley Big Tennis Weekend (open day) to showcase the club’s -facilities to the local community and engage prospects. +CC-BY 4.0 International license -Using free resources and content available on My Tennis Toolkit, they created a -Facebook event and advert with a call-to-action to sign up for taster sessions. + . -OUTCOME +With regard to additional genetic factors impacting expressivity, we assessed the impact of -£24 -spent on -Facebook -campaign +more common polygenic variation on carriers of monogenic variants and found significant contributions +for both high HDL cholesterol and high triglyceride levels (P<0.05). These results add to a growing +body of research supporting a significant polygenic contribution to monogenic risk7,39,48,49. As such +analyses were restricted to carriers of monogenic variants, power was limited, and it will be important to +investigate in even larger datasets. We estimate that for a monogenic condition with prevalence of 1 in +10,000 individuals, population-based analyses well-powered to capture the contribution of polygenic +risk to individuals with the monogenic condition would require on the order of one million individuals. +One limitation of this study is that our selection of variants for curation did not include all +possible missense variants, but rather was confined to those reported in ClinVar or subject area +reviews. This approach was designed to streamline the variant curation process and restrict our +analyses to highly-confident pathogenic variants, but also meant that we were unable to generate +estimates of the prevalence of monogenic condition in the two datasets. As discussed previously, there +is also the potential for residual bias within the datasets. In the case of AMP-T2D-GENES, +ascertainment of participants could have impacted penetrance of monogenic diabetes and expressivity +of the metabolic phenotypes (Supplementary Table 2). In the UKB, a healthy participant bias50 might +be expected to reduce estimates of penetrance. Furthermore, despite our large dataset of exomes, the +likelihood of observing any specific rare pathogenic variant is still low; this raises the possibility of bias +toward lower penetrance of clinically significant variants, since allele frequency is a major predictor of +pathogenicity51, and rarer variants with potentially greater penetrance are less likely to be observed. -Reaching -~3000 target -audience (local -and interested in -tennis) +Strengths of this study include the large number of participants with both phenotype and exome -145 declared -engagements -on FB event -page +data, and the strict variant curation methodology applied. Our analysis of 276 variants designated by +ClinVar as pathogenic or likely pathogenic highlights the need for careful curation of variants in clinical +practice, with 57% reclassified to “benign,” “likely benign,” or “variant of uncertain significance” with +application of ACMG/AMP criteria (Figure 1). Of note, however, the ClinVar variants we curated +included those submitted to the database before establishment of current standards for curation9. With +time, we can expect that the ClinVar database will become a more reliable resource for ascertaining +clinically significant variants, as more submitters utilize standardized curation practices and additionally +as condition-specific standards and curation are provided by ClinGen Expert Panels, including the +Monogenic Diabetes Expert Panel in which several of the co-authors participate52. -Converted to 69 -bookings – -roughly 80% of -all total -attendees! +Our study emphasizes the critical need for careful interpretation of monogenic variation, +highlighting the roles of variant curation, phenotypic ascertainment, and polygenic risk in the estimates +of penetrance and expressivity. In the coming years, access to larger sequencing studies will allow +assessment of increasingly rare variants; however, deep phenotyping of such datasets, for example +information on medication use and age of disease onset, will to be needed in parallel to better define +genetic risk estimates. Improved understanding of monogenic variant expressivity will also likely require +broader incorporation of genetic variation across the allelic frequency spectrum and integration of +environmental factors. Such advances will facilitate modeling of disease risk and ultimately guide +individualized patient genetic counseling and management recommendations. -Drove an overall increase in club membership by 10% +Acknowledgements +This work was supported by NIH/NIDDK U01 DK105554 to JCF. This research has been conducted +using the UK Biobank Resource under application number 27892. MSU is supported by NIH/NIDDK 13 - MEASURING PERFORMANCE + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +K23 DK114551. AODL was supported by NIH/NICHD K12 HD052896. MB is supported by NIH/NIDDK +DK062370. JCF is also supported by NIH/NIDDK K24 DK110550. -A Q U I C K L O O K A T F A C E B O O K A D M A N A G E R +Funding for GO ESP was provided by NHLBI grants RC2 HL-103010 (HeartGO), with exome +sequencing was performed through NHLBI grants RC2 HL-102925 (BroadGO) and RC2 HL-102926 +(SeattleGO). HeartGO components and their support include Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities +(NHLBI contracts N01 HC-55015, N01 HC-55016, N01HC-55017, N01 HC-55018, N01 HC-55019, N01 +HC-55020, and N01 HC-55021); Cardiovascular Health Study (NHLBI contracts +HHSN268201200036C, HHSN268200800007C, N01HC55222, N01HC85079, N01HC85080, +N01HC85081, N01HC85082, N01HC85083, and N01HC85086); and NHLBI grants U01HL080295, +R01HL087652, R01HL105756, R01HL103612, and R01HL120393, with additional contribution from the +National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke. Additional support was provided through +R01AG023629 from the National Institute on Aging. A full list of principal Cardiovascular Health Study +investigators and institutions can be found at CHS-NHLBI.org; Coronary Artery Risk Development in +Young Adults (NHLBI contracts N01-HC95095, N01-HC48047, N01-HC48048, N01-HC48049, and +N01-HC48050); Framingham Heart Study (NHLBI contract N01-HC-25195 and grants NS17950, +AG08122, and AG033193); Jackson Heart Study (NHLBI contracts N01 HC-95170, N01 HC-95171, +and N01 HC-95172); Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (NHLBI contracts N01-HC-95159 through +N01-HC-95169 and grant 024156). -#Tip: Don’t be intimidated by complexity. -There are tons of available resources online -that offer step-by-step instructions for setting -up a campaign. +Cardiovascular Health Study: This CHS research was supported by NHLBI contracts +HHSN268201200036C, HHSN268200800007C, HHSN268201800001C, N01HC55222, N01HC85079, +N01HC85080, N01HC85081, N01HC85082, N01HC85083, N01HC85086; and NHLBI grants +U01HL080295, R01HL087652, R01HL105756, R01HL103612, R01HL120393, and U01HL130114 with +additional contribution from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS). +Additional support was provided through R01AG023629 from the National Institute on Aging (NIA). A +full list of principal CHS investigators and institutions can be found at CHS-NHLBI.org. We gratefully +acknowledge the Eunice Kennedy National Institute of Child Health and Human Development for +support of the MODY variant curation through U24 HD093486 (to TIP). The content is solely the +responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National +Institutes of Health. -Source: Adspresso by Hootsuiite +The Jackson Heart Study (JHS) is supported and conducted in collaboration with Jackson State +University (HHSN268201800013I), Tougaloo College (HHSN268201800014I), the Mississippi State +Department of Health (HHSN268201800015I) and the University of Mississippi Medical Center +(HHSN268201800010I, HHSN268201800011I and HHSN268201800012I) contracts from the National +Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) and the National Institute on Minority Health and Health +Disparities (NIMHD). The authors also wish to thank the staffs and participants of the JHS. + +Novo Nordisk Foundation Center for Basic Metabolic Research is an independent Research Center, +based at the University of Copenhagen, Denmark and partially funded by an unconditional donation +from the Novo Nordisk Foundation (www.cbmr.ku.dk) (Grant number NNF18CC0034900). 14 - DO’S AND DON'TS + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) -F O R S O C I A L M E D I A M A R K E T I N G + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -DO +It is made available under a -Have a social media presence! Today’s consumers expect to be able to find -brands on social media +CC-BY 4.0 International license -Pick the right social platforms that best align with your brand, audience and your -marketing goals – whether it’s Instagram, YouTube, or Twitter + . -Take advantage of free resources and training available to you – including My -Tennis Toolkit, Facebook Blueprint, and Google Marketing Platform +The LOLIPOP study is supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Comprehensive +Biomedical Research Centre Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, the NIHR Official Development +Assistance (ODA, award 16/136/68), the European Union FP7 (EpiMigrant, 279143) and H2020 +programs (iHealth-T2D, 643774). The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily +those of the Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, the NHS, the NIHR or the Department of Health. +We thank the participants and research staff who made the study possible. JC is supported by the +Singapore Ministry of Health’s National Medical Research Council under its Singapore Translational +Research Investigator (STaR) Award (NMRC/STaR/0028/2017). -Follow your competitors. See what others are doing well, and find out how you -can differentiate yourself and appeal to those audiences +The TwinsUK study was funded by the Wellcome Trust and European Community’s Seventh +Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013). The TwinsUK study also receives support from the National +Institute for Health Research (NIHR)- funded BioResource, Clinical Research Facility and Biomedical +Research Centre based at Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust in partnership with King's +College London. -Get creative! Use social media to find influencers or other unique ways to connect -and engage with your audience +The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NHS, the +NIHR, or the Department of Health. MMcC has served on advisory panels for Pfizer, NovoNordisk and +Zoe Global, has received honoraria from Merck, Pfizer, Novo Nordisk and Eli Lilly, and research +funding from Abbvie, Astra Zeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, Eli Lilly, Janssen, Merck, NovoNordisk, +Pfizer, Roche, Sanofi Aventis, Servier, and Takeda. As of June 2019, MMcC is an employee of +Genentech, and a holder of Roche stock. MMcC wishes to acknowledge NIDDK U01-DK105535 and +Wellcome: 090532, 098381, 106130, 203141, 212259. -DON’T +The San Antonio Mexican American Family Studies (SAMAFS) are supported by the following +grants/institutes. The San Antonio Family Heart Study (SAFHS) and San Antonio Family +Diabetes/Gallbladder Study (SAFDGS) were supported by U01DK085524, R01 HL0113323, P01 +HL045222, R01 DK047482 and R01 DK053889. The Veterans Administration Genetic Epidemiology +Study (VAGES) study was supported by a Veterans Administration Epidemiologic grant. The Family +Investigation of Nephropathy and Diabetes - San Antonio (FIND-SA) study was supported by NIH grant +U01DK57295. The SAMAFS research team acknowledges the contributions of late Dr. H. E. Abboud to +the research activities of the SAMAFS. -…forget to publish content regularly. By maintaining your presence you’ll stay top of -mind with members when they are looking for a coach or venue +The KARE cohort was supported by grants from Korea Centers for Disease Control and +Prevention(4845–301, 4851–302, 4851–307) and intramural grants from the Korea National Institute of +Health (2016-NI73001-00, 2019-NG-053-01). -…be afraid to launch a social media marketing campaign. You can start small and -build and refine as you learn +RJFL is supported by the NIH (R01DK110113, R01DK107786, 1R01DK124097). NC is supported by a +grant from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR Fellowship). The Mount Sinai BioMe +Biobank has been supported by The Andrea and Charles Bronfman Philanthropies and in part by +Federal funds from the NHLBI and NHGRI (U01HG00638001; U01HG007417; X01HL134588). + +The Framingham Heart Study (FHS) acknowledges the support of Contracts NO1-HC-25195, +HHSN268201500001I and 75N92019D00031 from the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute and +grant supplement R01 HL092577-06S1 for this research. We also acknowledge the dedication of the 15 - ADDITIONAL RESOURCES + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; -H E L P F U L L I N K S T O G E T Y O U S T A R T E D +this version posted September 24, 2020. -LTA Marketing Guides and materials: -https://www.lta.org.uk/workforce-venues/tennis-venue-support/membership-growth-and- -retention/membership-growth/ +The copyright holder for this -My Tennis Toolkit (includes creative assets for social media): -https://www.lta.org.uk/globalassets/venue/my-tennis-toolkit-usage-guide.pdf +preprint -Facebook Blueprint - free online courses for business marketing: -https://www.facebook.com/business/learn +(which was not certified by peer review) -Instagram Advertising: -https://business.instagram.com/advertising + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. -Twitter Advertising: -https://business.twitter.com/en/advertising.html -https://blog.hootsuite.com/twitter-ads/ +It is made available under a -LinkedIn Advertising: -https://business.linkedin.com/marketing-solutions/ads -https://blog.hootsuite.com/linkedin-ads-guide/ +CC-BY 4.0 International license -Measurement / Tracking: -Google Analytics Academy: https://analytics.google.com/analytics/academy/ -Google Ad Manager: https://skillshop.exceedlms.com/student/path/34897-drive-advertising-revenue- -with-google-ad-manager + . + +FHS study participants without whom this research would not be possible. Dr. Vasan is supported in +part by the Evans Medical Foundation and the Jay and Louis Coffman Endowment from the +Department of Medicine, Boston University School of Medicine. 16 - ANY QUESTIONS? + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; -THANK YOU +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Methods +Study populations and phenotype curation +AMP-T2D-GENES + +The complete AMP-T2D-GENES cohort consists of 20,791 cases and 24,440 controls selected + +from multiple distinct multi-ancestry studies 18. The present study includes a subset of 22,875 T2D or +prediabetes and 15,743 controls from studies who consented for the data to be used in this analysis, +which included Genetics of Type 2 Diabetes (GoT2D), the Exome Sequencing Project (ESP), Lubeck +Foundation Centre for Applied Medical Genomics in Personalised Disease Prediction, Prevention and +Care (LuCamp), Slim Initiative in Genomic Medicine for the Americas (SIGMA T2D), and T2D-GENES +(Type 2 Diabetes Genetic Exploration by Next-generation sequencing in multi-Ethnic Samples). +General study characteristics are provided in Supplementary Tables 1 with more details, including +exclusion criteria available in Supplementary Table 2, which is adapted from Flannick et al., 201918. +All samples were approved for use by their home institution’s institutional review board or ethics +committee. Analysis of the data was approved by the Mass General Brigham (formerly Partners) +institutional review board in Boston, Massachusetts were limited to those participants in each cohort +with available DNA who consented to genetic studies. + +≥ + +≥ + +≥ + + 5.7%, fasting blood glucose + + 140 mg/dL. In individuals who were reported to be on lipid-lowering medication, serum + +Phenotype information related to diabetes status was collected by each case-control or cohort +study, as previously described in Flannick et al. Additionally, we defined prediabetes as any individual +with HbA1c + 100 mg/dL, or oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) 2 hour +blood glucose +LDL cholesterol and triglyceride levels were adjusted for statin use based on previous studies +estimating the impact 53,54: we divided LDL by 0.7 and triglycerides by 0.85 as has been previously +been implemented55. Self-reported ancestry was used, as this was previously shown to correlate well +with principal component analysis (PCA) defined ancestry and specific exceptions were dropped from +analyses 18. Analyses described below used a dataset restricted to individuals in the ‘unrelated analysis +set’ (see Flannick et al. methods). To provide consistency with the UKB dataset, individuals younger +than age 40 were also excluded. Individuals recruited to the Pakistan Genomic Resource cohort were +excluded for all analyses involving lipid levels or BMI. + +UK Biobank + +UK Biobank (UKB) is a prospective cohort of approximately 500,000 recruited individuals from + +the general population aged 40–69 years in 2006–2010 from across the United Kingdom, with +genotype, phenotype, and linked healthcare record data 56. All participants provided electronic informed +consent at their initial visit. Analysis of the data was approved by the Mass General Brigham (formerly +Partners) institutional review board in Boston, Massachusetts, and was performed under UK Biobank +application 27892. + +Direct LDL cholesterol (mmol/L), direct HDL cholesterol (mmol/L), triglyceride (mmol/L), BMI + +(kg/m2) (field codes: 30780, 30760, 30870, 21001) data were extracted for all individuals. Lipid +measurements were converted from mmol/L to mg/dL. The mean for all visits was used in subsequent +analyses. The ‘Medication for cholesterol, blood pressure, diabetes, or take exogenous hormones’ +fields (6177 and 6153) was used to determine lipid-lowering medication, where an individual was +considered to be on lipid-lowering medication if it was recorded at any of the visits. LDL and triglyceride +values were adjusted for use of lipid-lowering medication, as described above. + +Glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c; field code 30750) was taken as the maximum observed across + +visits. Since monogenic diabetes may be misdiagnosed as type 1 or type 2 diabetes, we used an +inclusive definition of diabetes: possible and probable type 1 or type 2 diabetes was determined in a +manner similar to previously described methods 57. We also considered individuals as having diabetes +if they had ICD10 codes E10-E14 (fields: 41202), and recorded diabetes medication use (fields: 6177, +6153), diabetes ever diagnosed by a doctor (field: 2443), nurse interview codes indicating diabetes +(fields: 1220 - any diabetes, 1222 - T1D, 1223 - T2D), or HbA1c + + 6.5%. Prediabetes was defined as + +≥ 17 + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +any individual with HbA1c +diagnosis (fields: 20009, 2976), age, and sex. + + 5.7%. We also extracted data for the first recorded age of diabetes + +≥ + +This dataset was filtered to only unrelated individuals with European ancestry to facilitate + +comparisons of biomarkers in analyses using polygenic risk scores. Filtering to unrelated individuals +was done using the column ‘used.in.pca.calculation’ in the UKB genotype data sample QC document +(ukb_sqc_v2.txt) as a proxy. This column indicates samples which UKB used in a principal component +analysis (PCA), and this analysis was only performed on unrelated, high quality samples. To filter to +European ancestry only, samples were first projected onto 1000 Genomes phase 3 58 PCA coordinate +space. Then Aberrant R package 59 clustering was used to identify individuals falling within 1000 +Genomes project EUR PC1 and PC2 limits (lambda=4.5). Individuals that self-reported as non- +European ethnicity were also filtered. There were 38,566 individuals remaining after all filtering and +intersection with individuals that also have exome sequence data released in the first tranche (Category +170). + +Generation of gene list + +We sought to include genes that would be ordered in the United States in clinical practice to + +diagnose conditions of monogenic diabetes, lipodystrophy, obesity, and lipid disorders. We searched +the Genetic Testing Registry (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/gtr/) and Concert Genetics +(https://app.concertgenetics.com/), last accessed March 14th, 2018, for lists of available commercial +gene panels for clinical genetic testing for these diseases available in the United States. We filtered this +list of genes to those with an autosomal dominant mode of inheritance, as determined by the Online +Mendelian Inheritance in Man® (OMIM, https://www.omim.org/). For the genes in OMIM where mode of +inheritance was not specified, the genes were researched in ClinVar +(https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/) and related literature. In total there were 26 autosomal dominant +genes across the conditions. We further excluded any gene where there was no ClinVar submission +(April 2019 ClinVar submission summary) of pathogenic or likely pathogenic for the phenotype of +interest that also included clinical testing as a collection method, leaving 20 genes. We determined +phenotype overlap by manual review of the “SubmittedPhenotypeInfo” and “ReportedPhenotypeInfo” +fields in the submission summary where present and ‘ExplanationOfInterpretation’ or submitted +PubMed articles when phenotype info was not reported in the other fields. For MODY, most commercial +panels available in March, 2018 included HNF1A, HNF4A, GCK, HNF1B, and PDX1, with larger panels +less widely available. We therefore separated the MODY genes into two categories: “MODY” including +those five genes and “MODY extended” including eight additional genes. + +Determination of genes with LoF mechanism + +The pLoF curation was restricted to genes alleged to cause disease with a LoF mechanism + +based on reporting in ClinVar or a PubMed publication of an LoF variant in an individual with the +phenotype of interest. + +Two genes were determined to be related to both high LDL (familial hypercholesterolemia) and +low LDL (familial hypobetalipoproteinemia): APOB and PCSK9. Gain-of-function missense mutations in +both genes result in increased LDL levels, while LoF mutations cause lower LDL levels 60-62. Therefore, +only missense ClinVar variants in APOB and PCSK9 were assessed in the curation process for high +LDL, and LoF variants were considered for low LDL. + +Exome data variant filtering and annotation + +All filtering and annotation described below was performed using Hail 0.2 (https://hail.is). + +AMP-T2D-GENES + +Exome sequencing and quality control were described previously 18. We applied additional + 10, and minor + +genotype filters to retain only high-quality genotypes: genotype quality + + 20, depth + +≥ + +≥ + +18 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +allele balance > 0.25 for heterozygous genotypes. Variants were annotated using Ensembl's Variant +Effect Predictor (VEP) v85 63 with the Loss-of-function Transcript Effect Estimator (LOFTEE) plugin 64. +The dataset was then filtered to only variants with a consequence on any of the genes of interest. The +filtered VCF was used in analyses described below that involve EPACTS. + +We determined which variants in our dataset have been submitted to ClinVar by cross- +referencing this filtered variant list with the ClinVar VCF (April 2019) (further curation described below). +A list of predicted loss-of-function (pLoF) variants, including stop gained, frameshift or essential splice +site (splice donor or splice acceptor), was generated by filtering to variants with a LOFTEE high- +confidence (HC) annotation on any transcript. Finally, we used transcript expression-aware annotation +65 to add pext (proportion expression across transcripts) values for the worst consequence annotation +to each variant for use in pLoF curation discussed below. + +UK Biobank + +UKB exome sequencing PLINK files were imported into Hail and all the same annotation + +described for AMP-T2D-GENES was added using appropriate files for genotype reference GRCh38 +and VEP v95. In order to compare UKB variants to AMP-T2D-GENES variants we used Hail’s liftover +method to lift data from GRCh38 to GRCh37. Since the PLINK files do not contain genotype quality +information that we can use for filtering low-quality genotypes, we downloaded the gVCFs for all variant +carriers and determined which individuals genotypes were not high-quality (genotype quality +depth +missing in the VCF. + + 20, + 10, and minor allele balance > 0.25 for heterozygous genotypes) and set each of these to + +≥ + +≥ + +ClinVar variant curation + +We identified individuals carrying variants in the genes of interest that had at least one +‘pathogenic’ or ‘likely pathogenic’ submission in ClinVar by a clinical testing lab for the relevant trait. To +streamline variant curation we first generated a list of high confidence clinical genetic testing +laboratories. Using the April 2019 release of the ClinVar submission summary, a lab was considered +high confidence if it had submitted more than 15,000 variants to ClinVar and had updated its +submission after 2017 when the most recent ACMG variant interpretation guidelines were published 9. +This resulted in eight labs: Invitae; GeneDx; Ambry Genetics; EGL Genetic Diagnostics; Eurofins +Clinical Diagnostics; PreventionGenetics; Laboratory of Molecular Medicine, Partners Healthcare +Personalized Medicine; Genetic Services Laboratory, University of Chicago; and Counsyl. Variants that +were reported by any lab on this list since January 1st, 2017 were then accepted as having the +pathogenicity reported by the lab. + +These labs were further verified through manual curation. First, five variants from each lab that +were also present in our study were chosen to be manually curated, so that the manual curation could +be compared to the lab’s analysis. Through this, we found no differences in curation results. Then, five +variants from each lab were chosen at random through ClinVar – one Pathogenic, one Likely +Pathogenic, one VUS, one Likely Benign, and one Benign. As PreventionGenetics only submitted +Benign and Likely Benign to ClinVar, their variants were limited to those categories. These variants +were then also manually curated, and the results were compared. The only difference in curation of the +non-study variants involved University of Chicago, due to internal data initially not available to our study +curator; however, the same conclusion was reached upon inclusion of this internal data, which was +included in their reporting in ClinVar. During the manual phenotype curation (described below), we +discovered Counsyl reported conflicting phenotypes for the same variant, so we opted to manually +curate variants assessed by Counsyl. + +The variants not analyzed by high confidence labs were analyzed separately using manual + +curation with the curator blinded to carrier phenotypes. The ClinGen Variant Curation Interface +(https://curation.clinicalgenome.org/) was used to analyze the variants and assign evidence following +the ACMG guidelines 9 and recommendation for interpretation of LoF variants66, with input from gene- + +19 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +specific rules under development by the Monogenic Diabetes Expert Panel VCEP +(https://clinicalgenome.org/affiliation/50016/) for the MODY variants. Databases and other resources +such as ClinVar (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/), Human Gene Mutation Database (HGMD) +(https://digitalinsights.qiagen.com/products-overview/clinical-insights-portfolio/human-gene-mutation- +database/), gnomAD (https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/), PubMed (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/), +Google Scholar (https://scholar.google.com/), Alamut (https://www.interactive-biosoftware.com/alamut- +visual/), and the UCSC browser (https://genome.ucsc.edu/) were utilized to collect evidence for curation +purposes. The general guidelines were adjusted slightly for certain criteria such as control population +frequency as shown in Supplementary Table 10. Since most AMP-T2D-GENES participants are +included in gnomAD, AMP-T2D-GENES allele frequency decisions were made by subtracting the +number of AMP-T2D-GENES carriers from the number of total gnomAD carriers to determine an +adjusted gnomAD allele frequency which was compared to the cut-offs shown in Supplementary Table +10. + +Three variants within HNF1A were excluded from further analysis because of poor genotyping + +quality at this site making it difficult to determine which individuals are actually carriers (GRCh37: 12- +121432114-CG-C, 12-121432116-G-GC, 12-121432117-G-GC, GRCh38: chr12:120994311-CG-C, +chr12:120994313-G-GC, chr12:120994314-G-GC). As all three are frameshifts, these variants were +also excluded from the pLoF curation described below. + +Variants in MODY genes were curated by a second set of reviewers at University of Maryland +School of Medicine, the home institution of the ClinGen Monogenic Diabetes Expert Panel, to ensure +accuracy. All variants were consistently classified as collectively pathogenic or likely pathogenic +(Supplementary Table 12). + +All variants curated for this project, along with their classification and supporting evidence, were + +submitted to ClinVar on January 30th, 2020. + +High confidence Loss of Function variants + +As described above, we used LOFTEE64 to generate a list of high confidence pLoF variants, +restricting to the set of genes we determined to have a LoF mechanism of pathogenicity. Each pLoF +variant was assessed by manual review of reads by two independent reviewers. The reads were +examined for poor quality, homopolymer artifacts, and multinucleotide variants (MNVs) causing a +synonymous or missense variant instead of the reported stop codon. Where available, gnomAD data +was examined to identify variants that were flagged as filtered by gnomAD's random forest variant +quality control method. UCSC genome browser data was assessed to determine the conservation of +the region, the location of the variant, and how many transcripts the variant was coding. If the variant +was present in the last exon or last 50 base pairs of the penultimate exon, it was deemed not LoF due +to a predicted lack of nonsense mediated decay. However, this was overruled if the variant was +predicted to delete over 25% of the gene. The potential for a splice site rescue was assessed by +examining +/- 21bp around the variant. Any inframe splice site within 6bp was considered an essential +splice site rescue and possible inframe splice site rescues between 6 and 21bp were considered a +rescue if validated by the alternative splice site prediction tool Alamut (v.2.11). We also used pext +values obtained from the transcript expression-aware annotation65 to indicate variants that fell in exons +that have evidence of poor expression (specific cutoffs are detailed in Supplementary Table 11). +Variants were classified into 5 categories, 'LoF', 'likely LoF', 'uncertain', 'likely not LoF', or 'not LoF' +using the guidelines described in Supplementary Table 11. Any variant that had a discordant +assessment between the two reviewers ('LoF' or 'likely LoF' by only one reviewer) was examined by a +third reviewer to determine the final pLoF annotation. + +Carrier vs non-carrier effect size analysis + +We considered an individual to be a carrier of a clinically significant variant if they carry a +ClinVar variant assessed as pathogenic or likely pathogenic or a pLoF variant passing manual curation + +20 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +('LoF' or 'likely LoF' as described above). For AMP-T2D-GENES, as previously described 18, we +accounted for the diverse ancestry and different sequencing technologies by using a modified version +of EPACTS (http://genome.sph.umich.edu/wiki/EPACTS) that sets specified variants to missing based +on QC of sample subgroups (as described in Flannick et al, there are 25 subgroups that were +determined by stratifying samples by cohort of origin, ancestry, and/or sequencing technology). As +covariates in AMP-T2D-GENES analyses, we included sex, age, PCs 1-10, sample subgroup, and +sequencing technology all as previously defined 18. Analyses on UKB used covariates for sex, age, PCs +1-10 and the genotyping array. + +For both AMP-T2D-GENES and UKB, we used VCFs produced after filtering variants as + +described above and performed the group b.burdenFirth for binary traits and q.burdentest for +continuous traits in EPACTS to compare carriers and non carriers for the following condition/phenotype +pairs: high LDL cholesterol with LDL cholesterol (mg/dL); low LDL cholesterol with LDL cholesterol +(mg/dL); high HDL cholesterol with HDL cholesterol (mg/dL); high triglycerides with triglycerides +(mg/dL); monogenic obesity with BMI (kg/m2), MODY with diabetes status, and in diabetes cases only: +HDL cholesterol, Triglycerides, and BMI. + +Additionally, we included T2D or T2D with prediabetes as covariates in all tests on lipid +measurements and BMI. Triglycerides and BMI were log transformed. All of these analyses were also +performed per gene to ensure that we captured possible gene level differences in phenotype values. + +Estimation of penetrance + +Unlike diabetes, phenotypes used to assess the possibility that individuals have each lipid +condition or obesity, are continuous. There are commonly used clinical guidelines for diagnosis of each +of these conditions, so these cutoffs were used to dichotomize the phenotypes allowing us to determine +individuals with and without each condition for use in estimating penetrance. The following clinical +≥ +diagnosis cutoffs were used: High LDL cholesterol: LDL cholesterol +≥ +LDL cholesterol +50 mg/dL, High HDL cholesterol: HDL cholesterol +triglycerides + +≥ +200 mg/dL67, and Monogenic obesity: BMI + +190 mg/dL, Low LDL cholesterol: +60 mg/dL, High triglycerides: + +≥ + 30 kg/m2. + +≤ + +Penetrance estimates were calculated as the proportion of individuals carrying a clinically + +significant variant that also exhibit the expected condition. To determine the significance for all +penetrance estimates we used the group Firth burden test in the modified version of EPACTS and the +same covariates as described in ‘Carrier vs non-carrier enrichment analysis’. + +Calculation of global extended polygenic score (gePS) +Body mass index and type 2 diabetes + +Global extended polygenic scores for T2D and BMI were previously calculated on UKB + +participants using LDpred6,43. The variants and weights used in the calculation were downloaded +(http://www.broadcvdi.org/informational/data). These weights were then applied to the UKB genotype +data from the subset of individuals included in this study to calculate a gePS using Hail’s equivalent to +the --score method in PLINK (https://hail.is/docs/0.2/guides/genetics.html?highlight=prs). These values +were then scaled and centered around zero with a standard deviation of one for downstream analysis. +We confirmed that plots of T2D prevalence and BMI by respective polygenic scores converged at the +same upper limits as previously published 6,43. + +Lipid conditions + +To estimate a gePS for each lipid phenotype, we filtered UK Biobank genotype data to only the + +individuals used in this study (unrelated, EUR ancestry, and exome sequenced) and excluded SNPs +with an imputation INFO <0.3 and allele frequency <1%. Summary statistics for lipid GWAS were +downloaded from the European Network for Genetic and Genomic Epidemiology (ENGAGE) +Consortium. This included LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, and triglyceride GWAS summary stats +from a meta-analysis of up to 62,166 individuals of European ancestry 68. We filtered to variants +observed in HapMap3 (--only-hm3) and both the summary statistics and genotype data, and then + +21 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +estimated SNP weights using the Bayesian computational method LDpred (version 1.0.6) which +accounts for local LD patterns 69. SNP weight estimates were obtained using the infinitesimal (inf) +model (assumes all genetic variants impact phenotype) with heritability estimates (TG: 0.1525, LDL: +0.1347, HDL: 0.1572) as previously calculated using LD Score regression 70 and displayed on LD Hub +71. We then used PLINK version 1.9 (--score) to calculate polygenic scores using the SNP weights 72. +As in the BMI and T2D gePRS, the distribution was scaled to have a mean of zero and one standard +deviation around the mean. Since there is a single gePS for LDL cholesterol, the scaled gePS was +multiplied by -1 for figures and analyses comparing low LDL cholesterol carrier phenotype values to +phenotypes aggregated by gePS deciles or quantiles. + +Statistical Analysis + +We used generalized linear models (GLM) to examine the gePS results in a few different ways. + +We compared the top 1% to the interquartile range (25-75%) of the gePS and to the clinically significant +variant carriers (Supplementary Table 6). For both analyses we restricted the age in controls to >=60. +Additionally, we determine the effect size of gePS on phenotypes in the subset of only clinically +significant variant carriers and assessed the interaction of carrier status and gePS (Supplementary +Table 9). In all GLMs age, sex and 10 PC's were included in the model as covariates. A linear +regression was performed for all phenotypes except diabetes where a logistic regression was applied. + +All plots were made using R version 3.5.2. + +Data availability +Sequence data and phenotypes for this study are available via the database of Genotypes and +Phenotypes (dbGAP) and/or the European Genome-phenome Archive, as indicated in Supplementary +Table 2. + +Code availability +Code used in analyses is will be made available prior to publication in GitHub. + +References +1. + +Green, R.C., et al. CORRIGENDUM: ACMG recommendations for reporting of incidental +findings in clinical exome and genome sequencing. Genet. Med. 19, 606 (2017). +Directors, A.B.o. ACMG policy statement: updated recommendations regarding analysis and +reporting of secondary findings in clinical genome-scale sequencing. Genet. Med. 17, 68-69 +(2015). +Green, R.C., et al. ACMG recommendations for reporting of incidental findings in clinical exome +and genome sequencing. Genet. Med. 15, 565-574 (2013). +Kalia, S.S., et al. Recommendations for reporting of secondary findings in clinical exome and +genome sequencing, 2016 update (ACMG SF v2.0): a policy statement of the American College +of Medical Genetics and Genomics. Genet. Med. 19, 249-255 (2017). +Directors, A.B.o. The use of ACMG secondary findings recommendations for general population +screening: a policy statement of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics +(ACMG). Genet. Med. 21, 1467-1468 (2019). +Khera, A.V., et al. Genome-wide polygenic scores for common diseases identify individuals with +risk equivalent to monogenic mutations. Nat. Genet. 50, 1219-1224 (2018). +Oetjens, M.T., Kelly, M.A., Sturm, A.C., Martin, C.L. & Ledbetter, D.H. Quantifying the polygenic +contribution to variable expressivity in eleven rare genetic disorders. Nat. Commun. 10, 4897 +(2019). +Lewis, C.M. & Vassos, E. Polygenic risk scores: from research tools to clinical instruments. +Genome Med 12, 44 (2020). + +2. + +3. + +4. + +5. + +6. + +7. + +8. + +22 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +9. + +10. + +11. + +12. + +13. + +Richards, S., et al. Standards and guidelines for the interpretation of sequence variants: a joint +consensus recommendation of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and +the Association for Molecular Pathology. Genet. Med. 17, 405-424 (2015). +Niehaus, A., et al. A survey assessing adoption of the ACMG-AMP guidelines for interpreting +sequence variants and identification of areas for continued improvement. Genet. Med. 21, 1699- +1701 (2019). +Zlotogora, J. Penetrance and expressivity in the molecular age. Genetics in Medicine 5, 347- +352 (2003). +Cooper, D.N., Krawczak, M., Polychronakos, C., Tyler-Smith, C. & Kehrer-Sawatzki, H. Where +genotype is not predictive of phenotype: towards an understanding of the molecular basis of +reduced penetrance in human inherited disease. Human Genetics 132, 1077-1130 (2013). +Turner, H. & Jackson, L. Evidence for penetrance in patients without a family history of disease: +a systematic review. Eur. J. Hum. Genet. (2020). + +14. Wright, C.F., et al. Assessing the Pathogenicity, Penetrance, and Expressivity of Putative + +Disease-Causing Variants in a Population Setting. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 104, 275-286 (2019). +Natarajan, P., et al. Aggregate penetrance of genomic variants for actionable disorders in +European and African Americans. Sci. Transl. Med. 8, 364ra151 (2016). +Abul-Husn, N.S., et al. Genetic identification of familial hypercholesterolemia within a single U.S. +health care system. Science 354(2016). +Flannick, J., et al. Assessing the phenotypic effects in the general population of rare variants in +genes for a dominant Mendelian form of diabetes. Nat. Genet. 45, 1380-1385 (2013). +Flannick, J., et al. Exome sequencing of 20,791 cases of type 2 diabetes and 24,440 controls. +Nature 570, 71-76 (2019). +Bycroft, C., et al. The UK Biobank resource with deep phenotyping and genomic data. Nature +562, 203-209 (2018). +Harrison, S.M., et al. Using ClinVar as a Resource to Support Variant Interpretation. Current +Protocols in Human Genetics, 8.16.11-18.16.23 (2016). +Ellard, S. & Colclough, K. Mutations in the genes encoding the transcription factors hepatocyte +nuclear factor 1 alpha (HNF1A) and 4 alpha (HNF4A) in maturity-onset diabetes of the young. +Human Mutation 27, 854-869 (2006). +Osbak, K.K., et al. Update on mutations in glucokinase (GCK), which cause maturity-onset +diabetes of the young, permanent neonatal diabetes, and hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia. Hum. +Mutat. 30, 1512-1526 (2009). +Colclough, K., Bellanne-Chantelot, C., Saint-Martin, C., Flanagan, S.E. & Ellard, S. Mutations in +the genes encoding the transcription factors hepatocyte nuclear factor 1 alpha and 4 alpha in +maturity-onset diabetes of the young and hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia. Hum Mutat 34, 669- +685 (2013). +Rehm, H.L., et al. ClinGen — The Clinical Genome Resource. New England Journal of +Medicine 372, 2235-2242 (2015). +Yang, S., et al. Sources of discordance among germ-line variant classifications in ClinVar. +Genet. Med. 19, 1118-1126 (2017). +Harrison, S.M., et al. Scaling resolution of variant classification differences in ClinVar between +41 clinical laboratories through an outlier approach. Hum. Mutat. 39, 1641-1649 (2018). +Campuzano, O., et al. Reanalysis and reclassification of rare genetic variants associated with +inherited arrhythmogenic syndromes. EBioMedicine 54, 102732 (2020). +Udler, M.S., McCarthy, M.I., Florez, J.C. & Mahajan, A. Genetic Risk Scores for Diabetes +Diagnosis and Precision Medicine. Endocrine Reviews 40, 1500-1520 (2019). +Hattersley, A.T., et al. ISPAD Clinical Practice Consensus Guidelines 2018: The diagnosis and +management of monogenic diabetes in children and adolescents. Pediatr Diabetes 19 Suppl +27, 47-63 (2018). +Home - Genetic Testing Registry (GTR) - NCBI. + +15. + +16. + +17. + +18. + +19. + +20. + +21. + +22. + +23. + +24. + +25. + +26. + +27. + +28. + +29. + +30. + +23 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +31. + +32. + +33. + +34. + +35. + +36. + +37. + +38. + +39. + +40. + +41. + +42. + +43. + +44. + +Naylor, R., Knight Johnson, A. & del Gaudio, D. Maturity-Onset Diabetes of the Young +Overview. in GeneReviews (eds. Adam, M.P., et al.) (University of Washington, Seattle, Seattle +(WA), 2018). +Fajans, S.S., Bell, G.I. & Polonsky, K.S. Molecular mechanisms and clinical pathophysiology of +maturity-onset diabetes of the young. N. Engl. J. Med. 345, 971-980 (2001). +Chakera, A.J., et al. Recognition and Management of Individuals With Hyperglycemia Because +of a Heterozygous Glucokinase Mutation. Diabetes Care 38, 1383-1392 (2015). +Steele, A.M., et al. Use of HbA1c in the identification of patients with hyperglycaemia caused by +a glucokinase mutation: observational case control studies. PLoS One 8, e65326 (2013). +Patel, K.A., et al. Heterozygous RFX6 protein truncating variants are associated with MODY +with reduced penetrance. Nat Commun 8, 888 (2017). +Tybjaerg-Hansen, A., et al. Phenotype of heterozygotes for low-density lipoprotein receptor +mutations identified in different background populations. Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol. 25, +211-215 (2005). +Lange, L.A., et al. Whole-exome sequencing identifies rare and low-frequency coding variants +associated with LDL cholesterol. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 94, 233-245 (2014). +Aschard, H., et al. Challenges and opportunities in genome-wide environmental interaction +(GWEI) studies. Hum. Genet. 131, 1591-1613 (2012). +Fahed, A.C., et al. Polygenic background modifies penetrance of monogenic variants for tier 1 +genomic conditions. Nat Commun 11, 3635 (2020). +Khera, A.V., et al. Genome-wide polygenic scores for common diseases identify individuals with +risk equivalent to monogenic mutations. Nat Genet 50, 1219-1224 (2018). +Chatterjee, N., et al. Projecting the performance of risk prediction based on polygenic analyses +of genome-wide association studies. Nature Genetics 45, 400-405 (2013). +Stutzmann, F., et al. Prevalence of melanocortin-4 receptor deficiency in Europeans and their +age-dependent penetrance in multigenerational pedigrees. Diabetes 57, 2511-2518 (2008). +Khera, A.V., et al. Polygenic Prediction of Weight and Obesity Trajectories from Birth to +Adulthood. Cell 177, 587-596.e589 (2019). +Narasimhan, V.M., et al. Health and population effects of rare gene knockouts in adult humans +with related parents. Science 352, 474-477 (2016). + +46. + +47. +48. + +45. Matschinsky, F.M. & Wilson, D.F. The Central Role of Glucokinase in Glucose Homeostasis: A +Perspective 50 Years After Demonstrating the Presence of the Enzyme in Islets of Langerhans. +Front. Physiol. 10, 148 (2019). +Tybjaerg-Hansen, A., Steffensen, R., Meinertz, H., Schnohr, P. & Nordestgaard, B.G. +Association of mutations in the apolipoprotein B gene with hypercholesterolemia and the risk of +ischemic heart disease. N Engl J Med 338, 1577-1584 (1998). +Sorscher, S. Ascertainment Bias and Estimating Penetrance. JAMA Oncol 4, 587 (2018). +Paquette, M., et al. Polygenic risk score predicts prevalence of cardiovascular disease in +patients with familial hypercholesterolemia. J. Clin. Lipidol. 11, 725-732.e725 (2017). +Trinder, M., et al. Risk of Premature Atherosclerotic Disease in Patients With Monogenic Versus +Polygenic Familial Hypercholesterolemia. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 74, 512-522 (2019). +Fry, A., et al. Comparison of Sociodemographic and Health-Related Characteristics of UK +Biobank Participants With Those of the General Population. Am. J. Epidemiol. 186, 1026-1034 +(2017). +Zuk, O., et al. Searching for missing heritability: designing rare variant association studies. Proc. +Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 111, E455-464 (2014). +Rivera-Muñoz, E.A., et al. ClinGen Variant Curation Expert Panel experiences and standardized +processes for disease and gene-level specification of the ACMG/AMP guidelines for sequence +variant interpretation. Hum. Mutat. 39, 1614-1622 (2018). + +50. + +52. + +49. + +51. + +24 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +53. + +54. + +55. + +56. + +57. + +58. + +59. + +60. + +61. + +Cholesterol Treatment Trialists, C., et al. Efficacy and safety of more intensive lowering of LDL +cholesterol: a meta-analysis of data from 170,000 participants in 26 randomised trials. Lancet +376, 1670-1681 (2010). +Zhao, Z., et al. Comparative efficacy and safety of lipid-lowering agents in patients with +hypercholesterolemia: A frequentist network meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore) 98, e14400 +(2019). +Patel, A.P., et al. Association of Rare Pathogenic DNA Variants for Familial +Hypercholesterolemia, Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer Syndrome, and Lynch Syndrome +With Disease Risk in Adults According to Family History. JAMA Netw Open 3, e203959 (2020). +Sudlow, C., et al. UK biobank: an open access resource for identifying the causes of a wide +range of complex diseases of middle and old age. PLoS Med. 12, e1001779 (2015). +Eastwood, S.V., et al. Algorithms for the Capture and Adjudication of Prevalent and Incident +Diabetes in UK Biobank. PLoS One 11, e0162388 (2016). +Genomes Project, C., et al. A global reference for human genetic variation. Nature 526, 68-74 +(2015). +Bellenguez, C., et al. A robust clustering algorithm for identifying problematic samples in +genome-wide association studies. Bioinformatics 28, 134-135 (2012). +Sharifi, M., Futema, M., Nair, D. & Humphries, S.E. Genetic Architecture of Familial +Hypercholesterolaemia. Curr. Cardiol. Rep. 19, 44 (2017). +Peterson, A.S., Fong, L.G. & Young, S.G. PCSK9 function and physiology. J. Lipid Res. 49, +1152-1156 (2008). + +62. Whitfield, A.J., Barrett, P.H.R., van Bockxmeer, F.M. & Burnett, J.R. Lipid disorders and + +mutations in the APOB gene. Clin. Chem. 50, 1725-1732 (2004). + +63. McLaren, W., et al. The Ensembl Variant Effect Predictor. Genome Biol. 17, 122 (2016). +64. + +Karczewski, K.J., et al. Variation across 141,456 human exomes and genomes reveals the +spectrum of loss-of-function intolerance across human protein-coding genes. bioRxiv (2019). +Cummings, B.B., et al. Transcript expression-aware annotation improves rare variant discovery +and interpretation. bioRxiv (2019). +Abou Tayoun, A.N., et al. Recommendations for interpreting the loss of function PVS1 +ACMG/AMP variant criterion. Hum Mutat 39, 1517-1524 (2018). +National Cholesterol Education Program Expert Panel on Detection, E. & Treatment of High +Blood Cholesterol in, A. Third Report of the National Cholesterol Education Program (NCEP) +Expert Panel on Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult +Treatment Panel III) final report. Circulation 106, 3143-3421 (2002). +Surakka, I., et al. The impact of low-frequency and rare variants on lipid levels. Nat. Genet. 47, +589-597 (2015). +Vilhjálmsson, B.J., et al. Modeling Linkage Disequilibrium Increases Accuracy of Polygenic Risk +Scores. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 97, 576-592 (2015). +Bulik-Sullivan, B.K., et al. LD Score regression distinguishes confounding from polygenicity in +genome-wide association studies. Nat. Genet. 47, 291-295 (2015). +Zheng, J., et al. LD Hub: a centralized database and web interface to perform LD score +regression that maximizes the potential of summary level GWAS data for SNP heritability and +genetic correlation analysis. Bioinformatics 33, 272-279 (2017). +Purcell, S., et al. PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage +analyses. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 81, 559-575 (2007). + +65. + +66. + +67. + +68. + +69. + +70. + +71. + +72. + +25 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Table 1: Impact of clinically significant variants on traits + +AMP-T2D-GENES (N=38,618) + +UK Biobank (N=38,566) + +N +carrier + +Beta (se) + +P value* + +N +carrier + +Beta (se) + +P value* + +55 +11 +44 + +35 +8 +27 + +21 + +20 +15 + +5 + +56.0 (5.2) +31.5 (12.0) +65.3 (6.3) + +-56.1 (7.1) +-79.8 (14.7) +-48.7 (8.2) + +16.5 (3.0) + + 10-24 +3.9 +× + 10-3 +8.9 +× + 10-25 +9.0 +× + + 10-15 + 10-8 + 10-9 + +4.4 +× +5.9 +× +2.6 +× + +3.6 + + 10-8 + +× + +130.0 (27.3) +122.4 (29.7) + +152.8 (54.6) + +2.8 +2.6 + +2.5 + + 10-6 + 10-5 + + 10-2 + +× +× + +× + +83 +26 +57 + +90 +48 +42 + +20 + +54 +38 + +16 + +54.2 (3.9) +52.2 (6.8) +55.1 (4.7) + +-56.4 (3.7) +-74.5 (5.1) +-36.1 (5.4) + +16.8 (2.4) + +126.0 (12.2) +145.5 (13.6) + +79.3 (22.4) + +× +× +× + +× +× +× + +1.6 +2.2 +1.1 + + 10-44 + 10-14 + 10-31 + +6.9 +6.7 +2.7 + + 10-52 + 10-48 + 10-11 + +2.3 + + 10-12 + +× + +2.4 +2.4 + + 10-16 +× + 10-14 +× +9.4 + + 10-4 + +× + +Condition +(proxy +measure) + +High LDL +(LDL mg/dL) + +Low LDL +(LDL mg/dL) + +High HDL +(HDL mg/dL) +High +triglycerides +(TG mg/dL) + +Gene + +composite + +APOB +LDLR + +composite + +APOB +PCSK9 + +CETP + +composite + +APOA5 + +LPL + +Monogenic +obesity +(BMI kg/m2) MC4R + +Condition + +gene + +28 + +1.5 (1.0) + +6.3 + + 10-2 + +× + +31 + +2.2 (0.8) + +6.3 + + 10-3 + +× + +N +carrier + +OR + +P value* + +OR + +P value* + +MODY +(diabetes) + +MODY +(T2D and +prediabetes) + +composite + +22 + +GCK +HNF1A + +7 +11 + +7.8 (4.2-14.6) +37.4 (6.3- +222.0) +4.8 (2.2-10.4) + +6.5 + + 10-5 + +× + +1.3 +1.7 + + 10-3 + 10-2 + +× +× + +composite + +22 + +4.8 (2.6-8.8) + +GCK +HNF1A + +7 +11 + +17.8 (3.4-94.0) +3.1 (1.5-6.6) + +2.5 + + 10-3 + +× + +8.2 +8.9 + + 10-3 + 10-2 + +× +× + +16 + +10 +5 + +16 + +10 +5 + +21 (12.5-35.2) +40.5 (20.3- +80.7) +9.0 (3.51-22.9) + +21.5 (11.5- +40.4) +132.0 (28.7- +611.0) +5.1 (2.0-12.9) + +2.6 + + 10-8 + +× + +3.1 +2.3 + + 10-8 + 10-2 + +× +× + +9.1 + + 10-9 + +× + +1.4 +6.1 + + 10-9 + 10-2 + +× +× + +Composite = individuals carrying variants in any of the genes analyzed for that condition. Note that +MODY composite gene set included GCK, HNF1A, HNF1B, HNF4A, and PDX1. +*Comparison of variant carriers to non-carries, adjusted for age, sex, 10 PCs + +26 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Figure 1. Curation of ClinVar and pLoF variants across the monogenic conditions. +Total number of curated ClinVar/Review (blue) and pLoF (red) variants with carriers in AMP-T2D- +GENES (left panel) and UKB (right panel). Darker color shades indicate variants determined to be +clinically significant (pathogenic, likely pathogenic, or pLoF) and lighter shades indicate variants +excluded during curation from further analysis. + +27 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Figure 2. Carriers of rare clinically significant monogenic variants for lipid conditions and +monogenic diabetes have more extreme effect size estimates than individuals with the top 1% of +global extended polygenic scores (gePS). +In all plots, the left panels show the distribution of the phenotype in each percentile of the gePS for the +relevant condition (black), and the right panel shows the phenotype distribution in carriers of rare +clinically significant monogenic variants for the corresponding condition (red; low LDL cholesterol +(APOB, PCSK9), high LDL cholesterol (LDLR, APOB), high HDL cholesterol (CETP), high triglycerides +(APOA5, LPL), monogenic obesity (MC4R), and MODY (GCK, HNF1A, PDX1). A-E) Mean and 95% CI +of each phenotype are indicated by the point and error bars respectively. The same gePS calculated for +risk of increasing LDL levels was used for A and B; however, the inverse of this gePS was used for B +to illustrate that higher gePS indicates risk of lower LDL cholesterol. F) The proportion of individuals +with diabetes and 95% CI computed with the Clopper-Pearson method are shown as points and error +bars respectively. Individuals in the gePS analysis were restricted to those age +cholesterol and triglyceride values were adjusted for lipid-lowering medication use as per methods. + + 60 years. LDL + +≥ + +28 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Figure 3. Phenotype distributions and penetrance estimates of clinically significant variant +carriers. +In all plots, clinically significant variant carriers are shown in red and non-carriers are shown in grey. +The left panel of each plot shows AMP-T2D-GENES participants (T2D case/control study) and the right +panel shows UK Biobank participants (population-based study). A) Mean and 95% CI are represented +by the black circle and black lines respectively. Relevant lipid levels (mg/dl) or body mass index (kg/m2) +are shown for carriers (C) and non-carriers (NC) of clinically significant variants for the five monogenic +conditions. The blue boxes indicate the phenotype values that meet a clinical threshold for diagnosis of +each of the conditions, and P values were obtained by burden analysis in EPACTS (see Methods). B) +Dots are the proportion of individuals that have the condition based on the clinical diagnosis threshold +for each condition; for MODY, we show the proportion of individuals meeting T2D as well as T2D and +prediabetes criteria (see Methods). Error bars reflect 95% CI computed with the Clopper-Pearson +method. + +29 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Figure 4. Ascertainment bias significantly impacts expressivity of clinically significant variants +for LDL cholesterol conditions. + +LDL cholesterol levels are shown for carriers and non-carriers of LDL cholesterol raising (top panels) or +lowering (bottom panels) clinically significant variants. The variants carriers are stratified by whether +they were identified in individuals phenotypically ascertained for extreme serum LDL cholesterol levels +(Yes, Red) or in a separate unascertained population (No, Blue) (see Methods). The left panels show +all clinically significant variant carriers. The right panels show carriers of the single variants that were +present in both ascertained and unascertained individuals. LDL cholesterol values are adjusted for lipid- +lowering medication use as per methods. + +30 + + medRxiv preprint + +doi: + +https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.22.20195529 + +; + +this version posted September 24, 2020. + +The copyright holder for this + +preprint + +(which was not certified by peer review) + + is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. + +It is made available under a + +CC-BY 4.0 International license + + . + +Figure 5. The combination of clinically significant monogenic variants and corresponding +polygenic scores significantly improves prediction for high HDL cholesterol and high +triglyceride conditions. + +In all plots, an empirical cumulative distribution function (CDF) of each phenotype is shown for clinically +significant variant carriers and non-carriers in the UKB for each monogenic condition stratified by +bottom/top quartiles of the corresponding gePS. The monogenic conditions are low LDL cholesterol +(APOB, PCSK9), high LDL cholesterol (LDLR, APOB), high HDL cholesterol (CETP), high triglycerides +(APOA5, LPL), and monogenic obesity (MC4R). The same gePS calculated for risk of increasing LDL +cholesterol levels was used for A and B, however the inverse of the gePS was used for A to illustrate +that higher gePS indicates risk of lower LDL cholesterol. Asterisks indicate Pvalue<0.05. + +31 + diff --git a/q83/random_k4/random_4.md b/q83/random_k4/random_4.md index 1b6b058bf683a33b480b8b8268e1555ff4290087..850bf0ca35ecd76a89f5f4d9b0ba198abf068312 100644 --- a/q83/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q83/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,532 +1,1799 @@ -Preprint. Under review. +Partners: +Microsoft +Azure + +Implementing +Hybrid Cloud +with MS Azure + +White paper + +Shaping +the future +of digital +business + +01 + +Implementing +Hybrid Cloud +with Microsoft +Azure + B + +How GFT and Azure +can help your organization +implement a strategic +hybrid model that is +cost effective and offers +sustainable benefits. + + Introduction + +A + +In a diverse world where +technology is in constant flux, many +organisations have computing +solutions that straddle cloud and on +premises. While both environments +have an important role to play today +and in the foreseeable future, a +consistent approach is crucial. + +For many organisations, integrating +these two to create a hybrid +model is essential but there are +many business and technical +considerations. + +This paper evaluates how Microsoft +Azure can help any organisation +implement a strategic hybrid model +that is cost effective and offers +sustainable benefits. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + 2 + +3 + +Why use a hybrid cloud? + +A + +Cloud computing gets a lot of attention, and for good +reason: it is where much of IT is going. However, +on-premises datacentres also have an important +role to play, both today and in the future. For many +organisations, integrating these to create a hybrid +cloud is essential. + +ASSESS +Why move to the cloud and +are you ready? + +OPTIMIZE +How can yiu make most +of the cloud? + +MIGRATE +What will be your +migratiion strategy? + +OPERATE +Have you considered +the impact on your support +and maintance teams? + +Microsoft understands this reality. +To help you to achieve it, they are offering +a broad range of cloud and on-premises +technologies that work together in a +coherent way. Moreover, unlike many other +vendors in the market, Microsoft provides +the flexibility to let you choose the path +that is right for your organisation. Microsoft +is committed to providing a consistent +hybrid cloud that supports every strategy. +So, what exactly is a hybrid cloud? +While getting everyone to agree on a +definition is not easy, there are some +obvious requirements. For example, you +need a way to connect your on-premises +datacentres with the cloud, a problem +Microsoft solves with Azure Virtual +Networks, Azure ExpressRoute. However, +basic connectivity is not enough; a hybrid +cloud must extend beyond this to provide +complete set of consistent services. +Microsoft believes that a true hybrid cloud +must provide four components, each of +which brings significant benefits. + +SECURE +Concerned the cloud isn‘t +secure? + +These are: + ■ Common identity for on-premises + +and cloud applications. This improves +productivity by giving users single +sign-on to all of their applications. + + ■ Integrated management and security +across the hybrid cloud. This offers a +cohesive way to monitor, manage, and +help secure the environment, giving +increased visibility and control. + + ■ A consistent data platform for the +datacentre and the cloud. This +ensures data portability, combined +with seamless access to on-premises +and cloud data services for deep data +insight. + + ■ Unified development and DevOps +across the cloud and on-premises +datacentres. This lets the client +move applications between the +two environments as needed, and +it improves developer productivity, +as both places now have the same +development environment. + +— + Taken together, these +four requirements provide +consistent experiences +for developers, data +professionals, IT +managers, and users. +Figure 1 summarizes this, +showing example +Microsoft technologies +for each. + +Azure Active +Directory + +Azure Management +and Security + +Azure +Data Services + +Azure +Services + +Common +Identity + +Integrated +Management +and Security + +Consistent +Data +Platform + +Unified +Development +and DevOps + +Active +Directory + +On-premises +Infrastructure + +SQL Server + +Azure Stack + +Figure 1: A hybrid cloud must provide consistent solutions in four areas: identity; +management and security; data platform; development and DevOps. + +As the figure shows, Microsoft offers hybrid cloud technologies that address all four areas. +Examples of these include: + + ■ Azure Active Directory works with the on-premises Active Directory to provide + +common identity for users. + + ■ Azure provides integrated management and security services for both cloud and on- + +premises infrastructure. + + ■ Azure data services combine with SQL Server to create a consistent data platform. -## **Retrieval Augmented Conversational Recommendation with Reinforcement Learning** + ■ Microsoft Azure services in the cloud combined with Microsoft Azure Stack on- -**Zhenrui Yue**[1] **, Honglei Zhuang**[2] **, Zhen Qin**[2] **, Zhankui He**[3] **, Huimin Zeng**[1] **, Julian McAuley**[3] **, Dong Wang**[1] +premises provide unified development and DevOps. + +What happens if you attempt to create a hybrid cloud without these four attributes? +The short answer is pain: you will have needless differences throughout your +environment. These differences bring complexity, which in turn makes the hybrid cloud +harder to use, harder to manage, and harder to secure. Risks increase while user benefits +shrink. + +Creating a truly consistent hybrid cloud, with the advantages it brings, is a better +approach. As this paper describes, Microsoft stands alone in offering these advantages. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + + 4 + +5 + +01. +Requirement: common identity +A + +When users access applications, they should not need to worry +about whether those applications are running on-premises or in the +cloud. Providing consistent identity is fundamental to achieving this, +which is why Microsoft created Azure Active Directory (Azure AD). +Among other benefits, cloud service offers secure single sign-on and +automated provisioning of new users. + +To use Azure AD in a hybrid cloud, an +organization first connects its on-premises +Active Directory to Azure AD in the cloud. +Users can then sign in as usual – Azure +AD is invisible to them. Those users can +now access both on-premises applications +and cloud applications without signing +in again. They enjoy single sign-on +throughout their hybrid world. +Azure AD supports cloud applications +from Microsoft, including Office 365 and +Dynamics 365. It also supports many +other SaaS offerings, including Google +Apps, Salesforce CRM, Dropbox, Box, +Slack, Service Now, Workday, and many +more. Just as Active Directory allows +single sign-on to on-premises applications +from many different vendors, Azure AD +provides this for cloud apps from many +SaaS providers. + +01.1 +Give your users single +sign-on to applications +anywhere + +Everyone hates having to remember +different passwords. In enterprises, the +problem of providing single sign-on – +the ability to log in once to access any +application – was solved long ago. With +the rise of Software as a Service (SaaS), +however, this problem must be solved +again. Rather than make users sign in +separately to each application, they +should be able to sign in just once, and +then access both on-premises and cloud +(that is, SaaS) applications. + +Figure 2 shows how Azure AD makes this +possible. + +Azure Active +Directory + +Cloud +Applications + +1. Connect + +Active +Directory + +2. Sign in + +3. Access + +Applications + +On-premises + +Figure 2: Azure Active Directory +lets a user sign in once, then +access both on-premises and cloud +applications. + +Using Azure AD for single sign-on also +offers other benefits: + + ■ Because Azure AD provides a common +account for many applications, there is +less need to have multiple passwords +that might be reused across different +SaaS applications. This improves +security, because a breach at one site +is less likely to expose a password +that has been reused for another +application. + + ■ When a user leaves the organization, +an administrator can terminate access +to multiple applications (cloud or on- +premises) by simply removing one ID +from Azure AD. If there were separate +sign-on to these applications, the +administrator would need to find and +remove each one. + +Microsoft’s broad support for hybrid +identity is unique among major cloud +platform providers. For example, AWS +Identity and Access Management focuses +on managing identity for AWS itself and +for resources running on AWS. Unlike +Azure AD, it does not provide a general +solution for single sign-on that works +across cloud applications from multiple +vendors. + +Hybrid SaaS applications +Applications that are available as both SaaS solutions and on-premises products represent another form of hybrid cloud computing. +For example, Office 365 includes several components that function this way, including Exchange and SharePoint. +In a hybrid world, hybrid SaaS applications can be useful. For example, SharePoint Online and SharePoint Server offer a common +administrative experience, as do Exchange Online and Exchange Server. These applications also provide other hybrid benefits, such +as support in SharePoint for searching across SharePoint Online and SharePoint Server and the ability to use a common email domain +across Exchange Online and Exchange Server. +Like other applications, hybrid SaaS solutions must deal with identity. With Office 365, the application is also using Azure AD, but users +may be unaware of this. This offers benefits, such as assigning licenses to specific Office 365 applications based on AD groups, so +that everyone in a particular group is granted access. Combining hybrid identity with hybrid SaaS applications is another way that a +consistent hybrid cloud provides value for an organization. + +— + 01.2 +Protect identities across +on-premises and cloud +environments +A + +Using a common identity to access many +applications has real benefits. It also makes +protecting that identity more important +than ever. Microsoft offers several ways to +do this. + +For example, Azure AD provides Multi- +Factor Authentication (MFA). With this +option, logging in to Azure AD requires +more than just a simple password. Users +also need a second factor, such as entering +a code sent to their mobile phone. With +MFA, even an attacker who steals a user’s +password cannot log in as that user. The +attacker would also need access to the +user’s phone, or another factor being used +for authentication. The result is better +identity protection and lower risk. + +Azure AD also supports conditional access +policies. These let your administrators +control access to specific applications +using not just the user’s identity, but +also based on what device is being +used, the location, the groups the user +belongs to, and more. User identities +define the perimeter of the hybrid cloud, +cross-platform APIs to integrate identity +management into on-premises or cloud +applications, with support for all modern +protocols, including SAML 2.0, WS-Fed, +OAuth 2.0, and OpenID Connect. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + 6 + +7 + +02. +Requirement: integrated +management and security +A + +Insights and +Analytics + +Automation +and Control + +Security +and Compliance + +Protection +and Recovery + +Azure +Management and Security + +Windows + +Linux + +Windows + +Linux + +On-premises + +Figure 3: Azure provides integrated +management and security services for +a modern hybrid cloud. + +Figure 4: The Monitoring Dashboard +provides a broad and customizable +view of a hybrid cloud environment. + +Using a hybrid cloud can broaden +options for delivering IT services to the +organization. However, hybrid clouds +bring new hurdles for management and +security. Challenges include: + ■ Monitoring combined on-premises +infrastructure and cloud resources + + ■ Effectively automating whenever + +possible, such as the response to alerts +raised through monitoring + + ■ Securing the larger surface area that a + +hybrid cloud brings + + ■ Providing effective data backup and +disaster recovery for both cloud and +on-premises resources + +Addressing these challenges requires +a specialist approach to management +and security that is designed for hybrid +clouds. To provide this, Microsoft delivers +management and security services from +Azure, providing built-in capabilities +throughout the operational lifecycle. +Azure includes a cohesive set of tools for +monitoring, configuring, and protecting +the entire hybrid cloud. Figure 3 shows +the big picture of Azure Management and +Security (which is sometimes referred to +as the Operations Management Suite). + +Designed for a hybrid and heterogeneous +world, Azure management and security +services give increased control of Windows +and Linux systems running in Azure or +in an on-premises datacentre. Although +not shown in the diagram, these Azure +services can also extend to management +of Windows and Linux systems running +at hosting services or on other cloud +platforms, such as AWS. + +Four key services comprise the lifecycle +approach to management from Azure: +Insight and Analytics, Automation and +Control, Protection and Recovery, and +Security and Compliance. All of them are +accessed through a single dashboard, an +example of which is shown in Figure 4. + +The console is built from tiles, and each +user can customise which tiles appear +to suit specific needs. A user focused on +security, for example, might choose to +show the status of antimalware software +on managed systems, the number of +outstanding security issues, and a map +showing where threats are coming from. +A user who is responsible for backup might +choose to display information about the + +latest backups for virtual machines, email, +and other data. A user who is responsible +for all of these areas – Azure management +and security services are designed to +be effective tools for generalists – might +display some combination of these +things. Whatever the requirement, this +customizable interface gives all users +access to the information and services +most relevant to their own needs. + +In addition, because Azure cloud services +are designed for a hybrid world, the +picture the dashboard presents can span +both on-premises and cloud datacentres. + +— + + 02.1 +Get common insight +and analytics across your +hybrid cloud +A + +One of the most important aspects of +management is monitoring to keep track of +what is happening in your world. Doing this +effectively in a hybrid cloud is especially +challenging, since you need the ability to +reach into both on-premises and cloud +datacentres. Azure addresses this with the +Insight and Analytics service. + +The Insight and Analytics service collects +information, such as log and performance +data, about all the systems it monitors. +Using the dashboard, a user can then +issue custom queries against this data or +create queries that run regularly, and then +generate an alert if there is an irregularity. +Moreover, to support common situations, +Insight and Analytics includes a group +of solutions that provide predefined +queries and logic for addressing a specific +area. For example, the AD Assessment +solutions displays the status of Active +Directory, along with recommendations for +improvement, while the SQL Assessment +solutions provides similar information for +SQL Server. + +This Azure monitoring service can +also connect directly to System Centre +Operations Manager. Doing this lets Insight +and Analytics receive information and +alerts that Operations Manager gets from +the systems it monitors. Connecting to +Operations Manager provides easy access +to useful information, and so it is a common +way to get started with Insight and Analytics. + +02.2 +Provide management +automation for your +hybrid cloud +A + +In general, it is a good idea to automate as +much of systems management as possible. +To do this from the cloud, Azure includes +the Automation and Control offering. +This service lets administrators create +PowerShell scripts called runbooks to +automate common processes. + +For example, think about the scenario just +described, where Insight and Analytics +raises an alert based on detection of a +problem with an application. One way to +handle this is to rely on an administrator +to find and fix the problem. This might be +the only option the first time a problem +surfaces. If it is likely to the administrator, +can create a runbook that takes the same +steps, such as truncating the database +table, and then configure the runbook to +execute whenever the alert appears. Doing +this can make problem resolution faster, +more reliable, and less expensive. + +The Automation and Control offering also +addresses many other scenarios. The +administrator might create runbooks that +reset user passwords or set up virtual +machines for a development environment +or schedule and deploy patches for +Windows and Linux. To make this easier, +Microsoft and others provide a gallery +of predefined scripts that address many +common scenarios. Besides runbooks, +this Azure service offering also provides +Desired State Configuration (DSC), which is +the ability to specify how Windows or Linux +server should be configured, then monitor +and enforce that configuration. + +Together with Insight and Analytics, +Automation and Control has one +overarching goal: to help proactively find +and fix problems in your hybrid cloud +before they affect your business. + +Insight and Analytics also provides other +useful tools, including: + + ■ Service Map, which can automatically +discover distributed applications in +your hybrid environment; show the +dependencies among application +components, such as databases and +business logic, and help trouble shoot +problems. + + ■ Network Performance Monitor allows + +an administrator track network +performance, including links between +on-premises and cloud datacentres, +the find and fix network problems. + +To understand the value of this +technology, consider a simple scenario, +and suppose Insight and Analytics raises +an alert about an application in your +environment. An administrator might +use Service Map to understand the +structure of that application and then +determine that the problem lies with +the application’s SQL Server database. +The administrator can use the SQL +Assessment solution provided by Insight +and Analytics do take a closer look at that +database. Perhaps the problem is that +one of the database’s tables has reached +its maximum size, for instance. Once +the administrator knows this, the table +can be truncated and the application +returned to normal operation. + +The important point to note is that the +process of finding and fixing an error is +the same whether the problem database +is running on-premises, at a hosting +provider, or in the cloud. It is also the +same for SQL Server and Azure SQL +Database. Consistency is an integral +feature of the Insight and Analytics +service because it was designed +specifically for a hybrid world. + +Compare this with other cloud vendors. +AWS, for example, provides CloudWatch +for monitoring a cloud environment. Yet +this technology provides little information +about anything else because is not +designed for a hybrid world. Service Map, +by contrast, can automatically discover +applications that span cloud and on- +premises datacentres, and the monitoring +capabilities of Insight and Analytics in +Azure treat both environments equally. +This Azure service is designed from the +ground up to work with a hybrid cloud. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + 02.3 +Get a unified view of +security and compliance +A + +8 + +9 + +No aspect of systems management is more +important than security. Which of your +systems are being attacked right now? +Where are the attacks coming from? What +is the status of antimalware software on +each of those systems? In a hybrid cloud, +you must be able to answer all of these +questions in a common way for systems +in both on-premises datacentres and the +cloud. + +Azure Security and Compliance addresses +these concerns. By providing a unified set +of tools, it lets your administrators - even +those who are not security specialists - +prevent, detect and respond to threats +across your hybrid cloud. Here are some +examples of what this capability provides: + + ■ Administrators can see the security +state of their entire hybrid cloud +in a single view. This view can +include antimalware status, whether +systems conform to defined baseline +configurations, and more. In fact, +the Security and Compliance service +offering relies on the repository and +query mechanism used by Insight and +Analytics, bringing the same breadth +and power to security management. + + ■ This broad visibility can help + +administrators quickly detect and +respond to security threats. For +example, an administrator can +determine that a virtual network is +incorrectly configured, the click a + +button in the dashboard to fix it, or that +a database in Azure SQL database +does not have encryption enabled, +and the turn it on with a few more +clicks. Security and Compliance even +provides a prioritized list of security +vulnerabilities like these, along with +guidance on how to fix them. + + ■ Because Azure Security and + +Compliance is continually updated by +Microsoft, it learns about new threats as +they appear. This helps administrators +maintain an up-to-date security posture +across the hybrid cloud. In addition, +because these updates draw from +Microsoft’s own information about +attacks on Azure, Xbox and other +cloud services, this threat intelligence +is based on a very large dataset. You +get the benefit of Microsoft’s broad +experience, along with the ongoing +updates possible in a cloud-based +solution. + +Once again, it is worth comparing what +Azure provides with what most other cloud +providers offer. Because these vendors are +focused solely on the cloud, their solutions +do not typically address the wider needs of +a hybrid environment. Moreover, since the +other major cloud providers tend to lack +Microsoft’s long experience as a provider +of enterprise management software, they +might not understand what is required +to manage an on-premises computing +environment as well as the cloud. + +— + 02.4 +Use cloud-based services +for on-premises backup +and disaster recovery +A + +Wherever it is stored, data needs to be +backed up. Given the massive amount +of low-cost storage available in a cloud +platform like Azure, using a cloud service +to do this makes sense. Similarly, many +applications need disaster recovery (DR) +to make sure they keep running in the face +of unexpected failure. The cloud is ideally +suited to provide this service. + +To meet these needs, Microsoft provides +two distinct services: Azure Backup and, +for DR, Azure Site Recovery. As its name +suggests, Azure Backup backs up data +to Azure datacentres. This data might be +from Windows or Linux virtual machines, +Exchange, SharePoint, SQL Server, or +Windows files. Whatever the source, Azure +Backup lets you store copies of data on +Azure, then restore that data as required. + +In addition, you can restore just the data +you need. Unlike tape backup, there is no +need to fetch an entire tape from an offsite +location. Azure Backup also lets you keep +that data on geo-redundant storage to +protect your backup in the unlikely event +that an entire Azure datacentre is disabled. +Azure Site Recovery is a cloud-based + +disaster recovery service designed to take +advantage of the scalability and resilience +of Azure. Figure 5 illustrates this service. + +Azure Site Recovery can be used with +Linux and Windows virtual machines +running on VMware or Hyper-V, as well as +physical servers. These can be running +anywhere in the hybrid cloud, on-premises, +at a hosting provider, or (for virtual +machines) on Azure. Wherever they are, +these systems send regular updates to +Azure Site Recovery in the cloud. Should +disaster strike, the service manages +failover to Azure. This includes creating +the necessary Azure virtual machines, +initializing these with the most recent +state stored in Azure Site Recovery, and +configuring virtual networks. Intended to +be used for even complex workloads, such + +as SAP, this service provides easy-to-use +disaster recovery at relatively low cost. +Backup and DR are commonly available +offerings, so what makes these Azure +services uniquely suited for a hybrid cloud? + +The answer is that both Azure Backup and +Azure Site Recovery are managed cloud +services. Any cloud platform lets you run +third-party software for backup and DR, +and Azure does too. You are free to use +CommVault, Veritas, or something else +with Azure Blobs, for example. This big +difference is Microsoft provides managed +services for both, which removes the need +to buy, install, and run backup and DR +solutions in the cloud. This is significantly +simpler than managing your own servers in +the cloud, and it is an important example of +the benefits of a hybrid cloud. + +Azure + +Windows +VMs + +Linux + +Windows +Windows +VMs +VMs + +Linux +Linux + +1. Send +updates + +Azure Site +Recovery + +2. Failover + +Windows +VMs + +Linux +VMs + +Azure + +VMware + +Windows +VMs + +Linux + +Hyper-V + +Windows +VMs + +Linux + +On-premises + +Figure 5: Azure Site Recovery provides disaster recovery for virtual +machines and physical servers with failover to Azure. + +Maintain hybrid or migrate entirely to the cloud? +Some organizations plan to remain hybrid indefinitely. Others view hybrid as a waystation on their journey to the cloud: they consider +hybrid cloud as part of a migration strategy. +If you are in this second category, a consistent hybrid cloud can make migration significantly easier. For example, Azure Site Recovery +can help with migration as well as disaster recovery because it can create new instances of on-premises applications on Azure. Rather +than manually moving applications to the cloud, you can rely on Azure Site Recovery to do this and to help you cut over to the new +cloud instances. The Microsoft hybrid cloud provides other tools as well, such as the migration wizard built into SQL Server Management +Studio to help move on-premises SQL to help move on-premises SQL Server applications to Azure IaaS virtual machines. +Microsoft also helps lower the cost of migration by transferring on-premises licenses to Azure. You can use your existing Windows +Server licenses with Software Assurance to enable up to 40 percent savings on Windows Server virtual machines in Azure by using +the Azure Hybrid Use Benefit. Similarly, license mobility provides the flexibility to deploy existing SQL Server licenses with Software +Assurance in the cloud without additional fees. These attributes can unlock significant savings as you look to extend into cloud or lift +and shift to cloud. You can also rely on GFT Cloud Team, to provide both migration knowledge and tools. +Whatever options you choose, Microsoft’s consistent approach to hybrid cloud can make migration to a full cloud environment simpler, +faster, and less expensive. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + + 10 + +11 + +03. +Requirement: consistent data platform +A + +What is the best approach for working with data in +a hybrid cloud? There is no single answer to suit all +organizations. However, one thing is universally clear: +you will have important information in both the cloud +and on-premises. Given this, it makes sense to have +a common approach to working with data in both +places. + +To facilitate this, the Microsoft hybrid cloud provides a consistent data platform. This +consistency lets an organization use the same tools and the skills throughout its +environment. Moreover, because organizations use data in various ways, the Microsoft +platform works with both operational data, such as orders in an online shopping +application, and analytical data, such as aggregated information used for data analysis + +The challenges this helps you address include: + ■ Using a common database across an on-premises datacentre and the public cloud. + + ■ Using data services in the cloud to complement on-premises database. + + ■ Providing consistent services on-premises and in the cloud for data warehousing, data + +analysis, and data visualization. + +03.1 +Take advantage of +common database on- +premises and in the cloud +A + +Microsoft SQL Server is a mature offering +that supports mission-critical workloads in +datacentres around the world. In a hybrid +cloud environment, this technology can be +used in a number of helpful ways. + +One option is to run SQL Server in an +Azure IaaS virtual machine. For example, +you might do this as part of moving an +entire application to the cloud to lower +your costs, or to create a development +environment for applications that are +deployed on-premises. Whatever the +reason, you can use the same database +technology throughout to your hybrid +cloud. This makes it easier to move data +and applications as needed to respond to +changing business requirements. + +Another possibility is to take advantage of +the cloud to provide business continuity + +Microsoft Azure VM + +Application + +On-premises + +SQL +Server + +SQL +Server + +SQL Server +Always On +Availability +Group + +Figure 6: With SQL Server AlwaysOn, a secondary server can run in an Azure virtual machine, +using the cloud to provide business continuity for an on-premises database. + +with SQL Server AlwaysOn Availability +Groups. Figure 6 shows how this looks. +As the figure shows, an availability +group has two, or more, instances of SQL +Server running on two different systems. +The AlwaysOn technology automatically +replicates changes to data across both +systems. If the primary fails, the secondary +can automatically take over, letting +applications that use this database continue +running. This kind of replication is essential + +for mission-critical workloads, and AlwaysOn +supports scenarios with a low recovery +time objective (RTO). + +Running the secondary server in the cloud +can save money and time. This secondary +can also be made readable to help scale +access to data. For example, a readable +secondary could be located in an Azure +datacentre that is closer to salespeople +using a mobile business intelligence app. + +— 03.2 +Save money by moving +your on-premises data to +the cloud +A + +Running a database in a cloud virtual +machine is useful. However, a hybrid +data platform should also provide cloud +database services that complement +on-premises databases. The Microsoft +hybrid cloud does this in several ways. + +SQL Server, for example, provides built- +in support for backups to Azure Blobs. +This support is simple to use – setting +up scheduled backup requires just a few +clicks – and it lets you take advantage of +the low-cost storage provided by Blobs. It +can also provide geo-replication of backup +data, making sure this data is stored in two +different Azure datacenters. Given the ever- +growing amount of data that organizations +need to store, having easy access to this +bottomless cloud storage is useful. + +Using Azure SQL Database, a PaaS data +service, brings more possibilities. Because +Azure SQL Database is based on SQL +Server, in fact, the two share the same +core database engine, applications can +access data in the same way with both +technologies. Azure SQL Database can +also be combined with SQL Server in +useful ways. + +For example, the SQL Server Stretch +Database feature lets an application +access what looks like a single table in a +SQL Server database. In fact, however, +some or all rows of that table might be +stored in Azure SQL Database. This +technology automatically moves data that +is not accessed for a defined period to the +cloud, as Figure 7 illustrates. + +2. Transparently +access cloud data +as needed + +1. Read + +Application + +On-premises + +Azure SQL +Database + +SQL Server + +Figure 7: SQL Server Stretch Database +automatically archives cold relational data in +the cloud. + +An application reading this data is +unaware that any of it has been moved +to the cloud. The application just issues +SELECTs as usual. When colder data is +required to satisfy a query, SQL Server +Stretch Database will automatically fetch +this data from Azure SQL Database. The +data is protected throughout the entire +process, both at rest and in motion. The +result is automatic archiving or less-used +data in the lower-cost cloud. You might +use this, for instance, to store the order +history of your customers. In this situation, +you certainly want to retain the older data, + +but since older orders are accessed less +frequently, storing them in Azure SQL +Database can save money while requiring +no changes to your applications. +SQL Server Stretch Database offers +another example of how Microsoft’s +hybrid cloud differs from its competitors. +Because GFT provides both SQL Server +and Azure SQL Database, we can +combine the two to deliver innovative +services in unique ways. AWL, for +example, does not support this – the +SQL Server Stretch Database feature is +available only with the Azure cloud. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper 12 + +13 + +03.3 +Use consistent data +warehousing, analysis, +and visualization services +A + +So far, the focus has been on operational +data. To see the full value of a consistent +data platform, we need to broaden our +scope. Analytical data is also an important +part of the story, which is another area +where Microsoft’s consistent hybrid cloud +can improve how an organization works +with data. Figure 8 shows one possible +scenario. + +Suppose you need to analyse operational +data held in an on-premise SQL Server +database and in Azure SQL Database. As +Figure 8 shows, you can load data from +both sources (and many others) into Azure +SQL Data Warehouse. This cloud service +can hold very large amounts of data, both +relational and unstructured, and empowers +users to set up a data warehouse in a few +minutes. The service also makes scaling +simpler: just move a slider to increase or +decrease warehouse capability. In addition, +to enable a user to issue queries over both +relational and unstructured data, Azure +SQL Data Warehouse proves PolyBase a +technology for using any language with +any data. + +You can use Azure Analysis Services to +analyse this data, as the figure shows. +Based on the proven technology of SQL +Server Analysis Services, this cloud service +lets your organization make use of existing +skills and familiar tools. Rather than +learning something entirely new, staff can +be productive immediately. In addition, as +Figure 8 shows, you can import existing +tabular models to reuse work already done. +Data analysts can also create new models, +and then deploy them to either Azure +Analysis Services or SQL Server Analysis +Services just by changing a URL. + +The last link in the analytics chain is +visualizing the data. To enable this, the +Microsoft data platform provides the cloud- +based Power BI (Business Intelligence). +This service can work with data from many +different sources, including Azure Analysis +Services, reports produced on-premises + +Azure SQL +Database + +Data + +Azure SQL +Data +Warehouse + +Azure +Analysis +Services + +Power BI + +Data + +Tabular Model + +Report + +SQL Server + +Analysis +Services + +Reporting +Services + +On-premises + +Figure 8: Microsoft’s hybrid cloud data platform +includes consistent services for analysing and +visualising both, on-premises and cloud data. + +software and services for working with +data in many different ways. The platform +also lets you move data and other +artifacts, like tabular models, as needed. +In addition, just as importantly, the cloud +components of this data platform are all +PaaS services. Rather than running on- +premises servers in IaaS virtual machines, +with all of the management effort this +implies, PaaS services take care of this. +Creating and scaling resources in the cloud +is straightforward, and Azure handles +high availability. These factors can lower +your costs and free your people for more +valuable work. + +Alternative solutions lack the breadth +of Microsoft’s hybrid data platform, as +well as consistency across the cloud and +your datacentre. They also do not offer +Microsoft’s commitment to providing PaaS +services wherever possible. Without this +kind of consistent data platform, you do +not really have a hybrid cloud. + +using SQL Server Reporting Services, +and more. It also has a connector to AWS +Redshift, Amazon’s data warehousing +services. + +Power BI can display dashboards through +a web browser, mobile devices, or in other +ways. It can also be accessed via natural +language queries spoken to a phone. For +example, a salesperson might use a phone +to easily call up information about last +month’s sales in London or to make other +specialized requests. + +Microsoft’s consistent data platform +provides additional technologies for a +hybrid cloud. For example, an organization +can gain rich insights from its data, +relational and non-relational, with fully +managed big data services in the cloud, +including Azure HDInsight and Azure +Data Lake. The Microsoft hybrid cloud +also enables analytics, deep learning, and +intelligent applications across on-premises +and cloud data with common templates +and reusable R language support. Azure +Machine Learning, Cognitive Services, and +other offerings make this possible. + +Why is Microsoft’s hybrid cloud data +platform better than alternatives? There are +several reasons. First, it is broad, providing + +— 04. +Requirement: unified development +and DevOps +A + +Some things are the same, of course – +both environments offer virtual machines +running Windows Server and Linux – but +others are quite distinct. These differences +can create problems, including the +following: + + ■ An application built for a cloud + +platform might be hard to move back +on-premises. If the application uses a +technology that is not available in your +datacentre, you might find yourself +committed to the cloud. + + ■ Providing up-to-date platform + +technologies in cases where a cloud +solution is not appropriated can be +difficult. A primary example of this is +edge-computing scenarios, where +applications cannot always connect +to the cloud or must run close to their +users for performance reasons. + + ■ Creating applications that exploit the +cloud while still complying with every +applicable regulation can be challenging. +If the application must run in even one +geography where data sovereignty +rules require an on-premises solution, +developers might need to create +different versions for the cloud and an +on-premises datacentre. + +One of the biggest +challenges in using the +cloud is that the +cloud development +platform differs from +traditional on-premises +platforms. + +Applications + +IaaS + +PaaS + +Serverless + +Containers + +Storage + +… + +Azure + +Applications + +IaaS + +PaaS + +Serverless + +Containers + +Storage + +… + +Azure Stack + +On-premises + +Figure 9: Azure Stack provides a subset of +Azure services in the datacentre, letting the +same applications run in both places. + + ■ Differences between a cloud platform + +and on-premises environment can make +it hard to create a common DevOps +environment for applications deployed +in both places. + +Microsoft Azure Stack addresses all +of these challenges. You can use this +technology to provide a subset of the +cloud services offered by Microsoft Azure +on your own premises. Figure 9 shows +how this looks. + +Azure Stack lets developers build and +deploy software in the same way, whether +it runs on-premises or in the cloud. It also +lets them implement consistent DevOps +mechanisms across a hybrid cloud. To +allow these things, Azure Stack provides +many of the most important Azure +technologies, and more are being added. + +Technologies in Azure Stack include: + + ■ Infrastructure as a service (IaaS), + +providing Windows and Linux virtual +machines on demand. + + ■ Platform as a service (PaaS), including +App Service, with support for creating +applications in .NET, PHP, Java, and +other environments, and Service +Fabric, a foundation for microservices +applications. Both Azure and Azure +Stack also support Cloud Foundry, a +cross-platform PaaS technology. + + ■ Serverless computing with Azure + +Function. + + ■ Container support with Azure Container +Service (ACS), which provides container +orchestration using Kubernetes, DC/OS, +and Swarm. + + ■ + +Storage, including Azure Blobs and +Tables. + +Rather than trying to stretch existing on- +premises technologies to provide cloud +services, Azure Stack brings Azure services +into the datacentre. Creating a consistent +hybrid cloud helps solve the problems +described earlier. + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper 14 + +15 + +04.3 +Create cloud applications +that meet every regulation +A + +For many organizations, the biggest barrier +to embracing cloud computing is regulatory. +Sometimes the law prohibits storing customer +data outside an organisation’s own datacentre, +or maybe remote storage is allowed, but +only within a specific country. Since no cloud +provider has a presence in every nation, these +regulations can prevent you from using the +cloud for some applications. + +With Azure Stack, your developers can +create an application that can be deployed +without modification on either Azure or Azure +Stack. If regulations permit cloud, running +an application on Azure might be the least +expensive, most scalable, and most secure +choice. If regulations dictate that data must +be kept on-premises, the same application +can be run on Azure Stack in the datacentre. +In addition, if you would like to run the +application externally, but are required to +keep it within a specific national border, you +can rely on a hosting provider that runs Azure +Stack in an in-country datacentre. Whatever +the regulatory requirement, the combination of +Azure and Azure Stack lets you meet it using +the same application. Moreover, as always, +these applications can be externally facing +or internally facing, with web clients, mobile +clients and more. + +Compare this to the options with a public- +cloud-only provider, such as AWS. To address +the same regulatory diversity, you would +likely need to build two different versions of +your application. A true hybrid cloud does +not require this; it provides the same modern +cloud platform everywhere. + +04.1 +Run the same modern +applications on-premises +and in the cloud +A + +04.2 +Provide integrated +solutions across edge +and cloud +A + +Many business requirements can be met +by applications running in the cloud. +But cloud is not suitable for all, so the +edge is still important. For example, in +situations where the latency inherent +in cloud access is not acceptable. +In a manufacturing environment, for +instance, a real-time control application +might need to be located very close +to the robots it controls. The speed +of light is a constraint that is not +going away. Alternatively, suppose a +continuous connection to the cloud is +not practical. Think of a cruise ship at +sea, for example, which might have only +intermittent internet access. + +In all of these situations, organizations +still want to create applications using +modern platform technologies. They +might also want to create applications +that can run in the cloud if needed. +Why lock these applications into an +on-premises environment if it is not +required? Using Azure Stack lets an +organization create the best possible +applications at the edge while still taking +advantage of the cloud as needed. For +example, a cruise ship might rely on a +shipboard application built on Azure +Stack to collect and aggregate data +about that ship. The same application +might also run on the Azure cloud to +collect and aggregate data across the +company’s fleet of ships. Having the +same development environment in both +places makes this possible. + +Because Azure and Azure Stack offer +the identical technologies – the same +services with the same interfaces – +moving applications between the two +is straightforward. This has several +advantages. + +First, an organisation can choose where +to deploy an application based on precise +needs. There is no commitment to either +cloud or an on-premises datacentre. +Instead, where an application runs in a +hybrid cloud can change with evolving +business and technical requirements. + +In addition, developers can use up-to-date +technologies for all of the applications +they create, whether they run in the +cloud or in the datacentre. This includes +externally facing applications, such as an +e-commerce system used by customers, +as well as internally facing applications, +such as a line-of-business solution used by +employees. The most recent innovations, +including serverless computing with Azure +Functions and modern container support +with ACS, are available in both places. +On-premises development projects are no +longer limited to older technologies. + +Just as important, using the same +technologies in both places means that an +organization can leverage the same skills +in both places. Rather than finding (and +keeping) people with different skills for +cloud and on-premises development, the +same people can be used for both kinds of +projects. Similarly, the same processes can +be adopted for deploying and updating +applications, as described in more detail +later. + +Compare this with what is required if you +choose a cloud platform from a provider +that is solely focused on the cloud, such +as Amazon Web Services (AWS). Without +an on-premises equivalent, you are forced +to use different technologies, people, and +processes in these two environments. +This is a clear example of why a consistent +hybrid cloud is so important. + +The Internet of Things as edge computing + +The Internet of Things (IoT) provides another topical example of combining edge +computing with the cloud. To support IoT applications, Microsoft Azure provides +IoT Hub, a cloud service that can accept and buffer large numbers of events from +many devices. These events can then be processed by applications running +on Azure, perhaps using Azure Stream Analytics or another Azure streaming +technology. In addition, to help create field gateways, systems that aggregate data +from multiple simple devices, Microsoft provides the IoT Gateway SDK. + +— + 04.4 +Use a common DevOps +environment on-premises +and in the cloud +A + +DevOps is a combination of tools, +processes, and culture that can improve +how software is deployed and updated. +Among the most important aspects of +implementing DevOps well are: + + ■ Automating creation of the environment + +the application needs. This might +include creating virtual machines, setting +up networks, deploying application +code, and more. Automation means +doing all of this with software, so this +aspect of DevOps is often referred to +with the phrase “infrastructure as code.” + + ■ Automating the deployment of new +software into this environment. This +typically uses tools such as Jenkins or +Visual Studio Team Services that allow +creating pipelines to build, test, and +deploy new code. + +In a hybrid world, the same application +might be run either on-premises or in the +cloud. Accordingly, an important part of +creating a hybrid cloud is setting up a +DevOps process that works identically +for both. With Azure and Azure Stack, the +Microsoft hybrid cloud provides this, as +shown in Figure 10. + +As the figure shows, a DevOps team +uses Azure Resource Manager (ARM) to +define the required infrastructure in both +Azure and Azure Stack. By creating an +ARM template, the team can fully specify +whatever environment an application +requires. Moreover, because Azure +and Azure Stack provide completely +consistent services, the same template +can be used to create this environment in +either the cloud or on-premises. +Once this is done, the DevOps team +can use its choice of tools to create +deployment pipelines for new software. +Because Azure Stack is a subset of +Azure, the same pipeline can target +either environment. Sending software +to one or the other requires changing +only the URL targeted by a pipeline. For +example, suppose you have created an +application that serves most of its users +from Azure in the cloud, but runs on +Azure Stack in a particular country for +regulatory reasons. The development +team can create an ARM template to +set up an identical environment in both +places, then use whatever build server +they choose to deploy updates to both +in the same way. This consistency lets +them create applications in a common +way, and then easily deploy them to the +right location. It also lets the team reuse +ARM templates across your hybrid cloud +as needed, simplifying your DevOps +process. + +1. Define infrastructure + +Azure Resource +Manager + +TEMPLATES + +Figure 10: Azure and Azure Stack can share +identical DevOps environments. + +Applications + +Azure + +Applications + +Azure Stack + +On-premises + +2. Deplay software + +Visual Studio Team +Services, Jenkins, … + +PIPELINES + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper + 16 + +17 + +Next steps + +Hybrid cloud computing is important for many +organizations, and it is likely to remain such. +Choosing the right hybrid cloud vendor is of fundamental +importance. + +A truly consistent hybrid cloud must provide four key components, all explicitly +designed for a hybrid world: + ■ Common identity + ■ Integrated management and security + ■ A consistent data platform + ■ Unified development and DevOps + +The Microsoft hybrid cloud offers all four. Whether your goal is integrating your on- +premise environment with the cloud, optimizing your computing across both worlds, or +innovating with the new services cloud computing provides, Microsoft supports you. +If you are looking for a holistic computing environment that lets on-premises resources +and the cloud smoothly work together, provides a unified approach to management, +and allows a single identity everywhere, you are looking for the Microsoft hybrid cloud. +Microsoft’s credibility and consistent hybrid capability makes it the right trusted vendor +for your safe journey. + +Microsoft Azure Cloud Migration +> https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/solutions/cloud-migration/ + +Microsoft Azure Hybrid Integration +> https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/solutions/hybrid-integration/ + +Microsoft Azure DevOps +> https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/solutions/devops/ + +Microsoft Azure Internet of Things +> https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/solutions/internet-of-things/ + +References +A + +Stay in touch +A + +Carlos Mattos +B +Global Business Unit +Head – Azure +E.: carlos.mattos@gft.com + +Team-oriented leader with a successful track record and over 20 years’ experience +spanning global corporate software development, strategy, sales, business development +and operations for software market. Nominated by Microsoft as Regional Director (RD) +from 2017 to 2020. Also awarded as Microsoft Most Valuable Professional (MVP) for 12 +years (2003-2016). + +— GFT +at a glance +A + +GFT is driving the digital +transformation of the world’s leading +companies in the financial and +insurance sectors, as well as in the +manufacturing industry. -1University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, 2Google DeepMind, 3UC San Diego {zhenrui3, dwang24}@illinois.edu +software engineering and innovation. +The GFT Technologies SE share is listed +in the Prime Standard segment of the +Frankfurt Stock Exchange (ticker: GFT-XE). -## **Abstract** + blog.gft.com + twitter.com/gft_en + linkedin.com/company/gft-group + facebook.com/GFTGroup + >gft.com -Large language models (LLMs) exhibit enhanced capabilities in language understanding and generation. By utilizing their embedded knowledge, LLMs are increasingly used as conversational recommender systems (CRS), achieving improved recommendation performance across diverse scenarios. However, existing LLM-based methods rely on pretrained knowledge without external retrieval mechanisms for novel items. Additionally, the lack of a unified corpus poses challenges for integrating retrieval augmentation into CRS. Motivated by these challenges, we present RAR, a novel twostage retrieval augmented conversational recommendation framework that aligns retrieval and generation to enhance both performance and factuality. To support this framework and provide a unified corpus, we construct a large-scale movie corpus, comprising over 300k movies with rich metadata, such as titles, casts and plot summaries. Leveraging this data, our primary contribution is RAR, the first framework to departs from standard two-stage CRS by dynamically bridging retrieval and generation. First, a retriever model generates candidate items based on user history; in the subsequent stage, an LLM refines the recommendations by incorporating conversational context with retrieved results. In addition, we introduce a novel reinforcement learning (RL) method that leverages LLM feedback to iteratively update the retriever. By creating a collaborative feedback loop that reinforces sampled candidate sets with higher ranking metrics, RAR effectively mitigates the misalignment between the retrieval and generation stages. Furthermore, grounding the LLM in factual metadata allows our RL-driven approach to capture subtle user intentions and generate context-aware recommendations with reduced hallucinations. We validate our approach through extensive experiments on multiple CRS benchmarks, where RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baseline methods. +As an IT services and software engineering +provider, GFT offers strong consulting +and development skills across all aspects +of pioneering technologies, such as +cloud engineering, artificial intelligence, +mainframe modernisation and the Internet +of Things for Industry 4.0. -## **1 Introduction** - -Conversational recommender systems (CRS) have emerged as a promising paradigm for providing personalized recommendations through natural language interactions (Zhang et al., 2018; Li et al., 2018; Kang et al., 2019; Hayati et al., 2020; Gao et al., 2023; He et al., 2023). Recent advancements in large language models (LLM) (Achiam et al., 2023; Dubey et al., 2024; Comanici et al., 2025) have further enabled CRS methods to utilize their extensive knowledge and diverse generation capabilities, demonstrating improvements across different recommendation scenarios (Feng et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024; Li et al., 2024; Hui et al., 2026). For example, He et al. (2023) adopt LLMs to generate movie candidates and achieve superior performance compared to traditional CRS methods. - -Nevertheless, language models often lack the essential knowledge to recommend the most suitable items (e.g., being unaware of relevant options) (He et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024; Wu et al., 2024). As a solution, traditional CRS methods exploit search modules or knowledge graphs to provide additional contextual information (Zhang et al., 2018; Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020). Similarly, LLM-based CRS methods leverage knowledge graph retrieval - -1 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**==> picture [378 x 71] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Conversation Context Candidates Response
I love the Gladiator movie, any recommendations? Sure! I think you may
You would love Goodfellas ! Retrieve Generate enjoy Saving Private
Did they make a new Terminator ? Ryan , Braveheart …
Yes, there is a new Terminator .
Have you seen the trailer?
Na, I'm looking for something with the intensity of
war, maybe bravery and loyalty.
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Figure 1: Our retrieval-augmented conversational recommendation framework, where a retriever gathers candidate items and the LLM generates the response conditioned on them. - -or training on a broad range of items to improve recommendation relevance (Li et al., 2024; Jeon et al., 2025; Zare & Alamdari, 2025). A notable example is ReFICR, where LLMs are trained on extensive curated data to perform sub-tasks including indexing, retrieval and generation(Yang & Chen, 2024). In Figure 1, we illustrate this general approach of the two-stage retrieval augmented conversational recommendation. - -While LLMs can accommodate novel items through additional training, scaling this process to extensive items and conversations is often infeasible, particularly when managing large volumes of items and noisy conversations (Jannach et al., 2021; Zhu et al., 2025; Surana et al., 2025). On the other hand, retrieving from knowledge graph requires significant efforts in data preprocessing, modeling and graph indexing. Graph retrieval can also be more computationally intensive when indexing or traversing through large-scale graphs (Li et al., 2024; Peng et al., 2024). Although embedding-based retrieval is a straightforward alternative (Reimers & Gurevych, 2019; Wang et al., 2022a; Chen et al., 2024), its effectiveness is limited by the lack of a unified corpus that provides comprehensive attribute-level metadata (e.g., plot, cast) corpus. As such, embedding-based retrieval remains largely underexplored in conversational recommendation. Furthermore, LLM-based CRS often exhibits retrieval–generation misalignment: when the retriever returns sub-optimal candidates (e.g., low-relevance items), LLM could amplify such deficiencies and cause deteriorated accuracy on cold-start or less-popular items (He et al., 2023; Kemper et al., 2024). - -In this paper, we investigate how embedding-based retrieval augmentation can be used to improve two-stage conversational recommendation. To address the limitations of existing, small-scale movie corpora (e.g., REDIAL with _∼_ 7k titles), we curate a comprehensive evaluation benchmark of over 300k movies, systematically enriched with metadata (e.g., titles, casts, and plot summaries). By establishing this robust, large-scale foundation, our primary contribution is RAR, a novel LLM-based retrieval augmented conversational recommendation framework. In the first stage, we employ a retriever model to select candidate items based on the conversational history. Subsequently, an LLM refines the recommendations by incorporating conversational context with retrieved candidates, enabling personalized and fine-grained recommendation results. To enhance retrieval-generation alignment, we further optimize the retriever by leveraging LLM feedback for reinforcement learning (RL). This feedback enables RAR to iteratively update the retriever through online, on-policy preference optimization. As a result, RAR can be adapted for any black-box LLMs and deliver high-quality, context-aware recommendations. We demonstrate the efficacy of RAR with extensive experiments, where RAR consistently outperforms baselines on multiple benchmark datasets. We summarize our contributions in the following[1] : - - 1. We present the first large-scale study of embedding-based retrieval augmentation for conversational recommendation. To support this scale, we synthesize a highlyenriched, structured baseline of over 300k films with comprehensive metadata. - - 2. We propose RAR, an LLM-based CRS framework with two-stage retrieval augmentation. By utilizing LLM feedback as reward signals, we design an online, on-policy reinforcement learning framework that enhances retrieval–generation alignment. - - 3. We demonstrate the effectiveness our approach by utilizing our curated retrieval corpus, where the RL post-trained RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art - -- 1Our data and code can be accessed at https://github.com/Yueeeeeeee/RAR. - -2 - -Preprint. Under review. - -baseline methods, achieving considerable improvements in recommendation performance on established benchmark datasets. - -## **2 Related Work** - -## **2.1 Retrieval Augmented Generation** - -Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) enhances language modeling by integrating external knowledge into context (Lewis et al., 2020; Guu et al., 2020; Karpukhin et al., 2020). Beyond naïve RAG, performance is improved by refining the retriever (e.g., via joint optimization (Lin et al., 2024)) (Trivedi et al., 2023; Jiang et al., 2023; Shi et al., 2024; Sarthi et al., 2024), upgrading document encoding (Izacard & Grave, 2021; Borgeaud et al., 2022; Izacard et al., 2023), and selectively filtering retrieved knowledge to minimize irrelevant context (Yoran et al., 2024; Yan et al., 2024; Yue et al., 2024b; Jin et al., 2025). While concurrently applied to sequential recommendation (Wu et al., 2024; Kemper et al., 2024), RAG’s potential for conversational recommendation remains largely under-explored. To bridge this gap, we build a unified movie metadata corpus and examine retrieval-augmented LLMs, aiming to enhance CRS performance via effective knowledge retrieval. - -## **2.2 Conversational Recommendation** - -Conversational recommender systems (CRS) capture user preferences via multi-turn interactions to improve recommendations. Early methods relied on complex, multi-module systems for dialogue and recommendation (Zhang et al., 2018; Li et al., 2018; Kang et al., 2019; Hayati et al., 2020; Lei et al., 2020). Later, language modeling and knowledge integration enabled better contextualization of user intent (Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020; Lu et al., 2021; Wang et al., 2022b), such as inferring preferences from incomplete knowledge graphs (Zhang et al., 2023). Recently, large language models (LLMs) (Achiam et al., 2023; Reid et al., 2024; Dubey et al., 2024) have transformed CRS through advanced dialogue capabilities and precise preference modeling (Gao et al., 2023; He et al., 2023; Li et al., 2024; He et al., 2024; Yang & Chen, 2024; Hui et al., 2026), including using LLMs for user simulation (Zhu et al., 2025). Despite these advances, integrating LLMs into CRS and improving the retrieval–generation alignment remain under-investigated. - -## **2.3 Reinforcement Learning** - -Reinforcement learning (RL) maximizes cumulative rewards through environmental interaction (Sutton et al., 1998). RL has been adapted to align LLMs via human feedback (RLHF) (Ouyang et al., 2022), typically utilizing policy gradient variants (Sutton et al., 1999). Methods like A2C and PPO (Mnih et al., 2016; Schulman et al., 2017) leverage learned baselines and clipped surrogate objectives for stable training. Alternatively, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) (Rafailov et al., 2023) efficiently optimizes offline pairwise preferences, though online RL methods consistently achieve superior performance (Xu et al., 2024). Recent online advances like GRPO evaluate candidates against a group-based baseline, significantly reducing memory overhead without sacrificing stability (Shao et al., 2024; Hu, 2025; Yue et al., 2025; 2026; Hübotter et al., 2026). In this work, we propose a novel online RLdriven approach for two-stage conversational recommender systems (CRS) and empirically compare different RL algorithms to identify the optimal strategy for recommendation. - -## **3 Methodology** - -## **3.1 Setup** - -Our conversational recommendation framework is based on a two-stage setting with both retrieval and generation. Consider a conversation _C_ = ( _rt_ , _st_ , _It_ ) _t[T]_ =1[consisting of] _[ T]_[turns,] _rt_ , _st_ and _It_ refer to the role (i.e., _seeker_ or _recommender_ ), sequence (conversation turn) and mentioned items. Each element in _It_ should be included in the corpus _I_ , namely - -3 - -Preprint. Under review. - -_∀i ∈ It_ , _i ∈I_ . Typically, the _seeker_ and _recommender_ take turns to converse in _C_ until the seeker finds desired item(s). Following previous research (Li et al., 2018; Chen et al., 2019; Wang et al., 2022b; He et al., 2023), the conversational recommender aims to generate a ranked list _I_[ˆ] _t_ for the _t_ -th turn when _rt_ is the _recommender_ , such that the generated _I_[ˆ] _t_ best matches the ground truth items _It_ . Specifically for our two-stage framework: - -- _Retrieval_ : In the first stage, the retriever model _f_ ret uses the previous items as query to select an initial candidate set _Ct_ , i.e., _Ct_ = _f_ ret( _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[)][.] - -- _Generation_ : Then, we leverage a LLM _f_ llm to generate _I_[ˆ] _t_ upon user conversation history and retrieved items. Formally, this is expressed as _I_[ˆ] _t_ = _f_ llm( _{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[,] _[ C][t]_[)][,] enabling an in-depth analysis of user preferences and potential interests. - -To fully leverage black-box LLMs without excessive training costs, we refrain from directly training _f_ llm and instead focus on optimizing the retriever model _f_ ret. This design choice offers two key advantages: (1) RAR can be combined with any LLM choice, regardless of whether the LLM is open- or closed-source; (2) by enhancing _f_ ret, we augment _f_ llm through the incorporation of up-to-date external knowledge (e.g., novel items). Our framework optimizes _f_ ret (parameterized by _θ_ ) to maximize the expected reward. Since the retriever and generator are not end-to-end differentiable, generator errors cannot be directly backpropagated. We therefore train _f_ ret via reinforcement learning, maximizing reward _r_ over samples from the retriever across conversations ( _C_ ) and timesteps ( _t_ ) in dataset _X_ : - -**==> picture [331 x 18] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _r_ is a ranking-based reward for the sampled candidate set _Ct_ calculated based on the output of _f_ llm (e.g., NDCG scores). That is, the post-training process updates _θ_ by maximizing the ranking reward, thereby aligning the retrieval and ranking stages in RAR. - -## **3.2 Corpus Construction** - -Existing conversational recommendation datasets either rely on large-scale knowledge graphs or on small, domain-specific corpus (Li et al., 2018; Hayati et al., 2020; He et al., 2023). Therefore, embedding-based retrieval is often impractical with existing data. To address this limitation, we collect and curate a unified text corpus for movie recommendation across datasets. Our initial corpus is built from all available entries across multiple sources, including IMDb genre, IMDb media and Inspired (Hayati et al., 2020; Raju; BrightData). Next, we augment the corpus with inferred entries from MovieLens, Redial and Reddit (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). Then, we aggregate duplicate film entries by cross-referencing and selecting the most reliable metadata. Additionally, we collect missing metadata from online resources for incomplete entries, we also map items in the corpus to the corresponding entries in the datasets (i.e., MovieLens, Inspired, Redial and Reddit). That is, we perform entity recognition to identify each movie mentioned in the conversation and map it to its corresponding entry in the corpus. Finally, we remove entries that were either incomplete or could not be collected, we report detailed information on corpus collection and preprocessing in Section A. In summary, we obtain 337,731 entries with comprehensive metadata, focusing primarily on English-language films (see example in Table 7). The corpus spans from as early as 1888 to upcoming releases in 2029, accounting for approximately half of all movies listed on IMDb as of 2025. Leveraging the collected corpus and constructed correspondence, we pretrain a retriever model on MovieLens by incorporating recommendation data along with negative examples sampled from the corpus (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Yue et al., 2024a). Next, the retriever is optimized with sequential patterns derived from the conversation data, we introduce the details in the following. - -## **3.3 The proposed RAR** - -**Retriever.** For RAR, we adopt the linear recurrent units for sequential recommendation (LRURec) as _f_ ret, with a comparison of different models in Section 4. LRURec utilizes state space modeling (SSM) to efficiently train and infer on sequential input: - -**==> picture [277 x 11] intentionally omitted <==** - -4 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**==> picture [378 x 91] intentionally omitted <==** - -**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Generate &
Candidate Set 1 Reward 1
Evaluate
Context Retrieve & Candidate Set 2 Generate & Reward 2 Update
Sample Evaluate Retriever
Further Candidate Sets & Rewards
**----- End of picture text -----**
- - -Figure 2: The proposed online, on-policy preference optimization in RAR iteratively refines the retriever model by sampling candidate sets, collecting LLM feedback, and then updating the retriever through reinforcement learning. - -with _A_ , _B_ , _C_ being matrices of shape **R** _[H][×][H]_ , and _I_ is the identity matrix. _h_ , _e_ , _o_ denote the hidden state, item embedding and output hidden state. By leveraging LRURec’s linearity via parallel scan, we reduce time complexity to _O_ (log( _t_ )), significantly enhancing training and inference efficiency. To encode the corpus, we leverage Qwen 3 to build the embedding table (Zhang et al., 2025). The output state _ot_ is used to compute similarity scores for all corpus entries, and the top- _k_ items are retrieved and stored as _Ct_ for the generation stage. - -**Generator.** In the generation stage, our primary objective is to produce refined recommendations _I_[ˆ] _t_ by integrating the conversation context _{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[and the retrieved items] _[ C][t]_[.][To] achieve this, we employ a black-box LLM _f_ llm and construct an input prompt that combines clear instructions, detailed item metadata, and the conversation history. The LLM is instructed to generate _k_ recommendations based on this comprehensive context. Further details of our prompt design are provided in Section A. For each conversation, we divide it into sub-conversations by splitting at turns where the role _rt_ is designated as _recommender_ . We also exclude ground truth items that have already appeared in earlier conversation turns to avoid shortcut learning (He et al., 2023; Geirhos et al., 2020). During inference, we retrieve relevant items from the corpus to construct the prompt. The generator _f_ llm then produces recommendations, which are post-processed to yield the final ranked list _I_[ˆ] _t_ . Unlike prior works (He et al., 2023; Kemper et al., 2024), we pair a simple retriever with a black-box LLM to inject external, up-to-date knowledge into the generation stage, enabling the LLM to access novel items for fine-grained, context-aware recommendations. - -**Retriever Preference Optimization.** While RAR provides a retrieval augmented generation framework for conversational recommendation, these two stages are not jointly trained for optimal alignment. Yet overlooking the dynamics between both stages can result in a sub-optimal solution (Ma et al., 2020; Higley et al., 2022; Lin et al., 2024). We thus propose an online, on-policy preference optimization method that leverages real-time feedback from the LLM generator _f_ llm. This allows RAR to iteratively sample candidate sets from the retriever and utilize LLM feedback to optimize current policy (see Figure 2). In our setup, we consider a frozen generator _f_ llm and focus on post-training the retriever (parametrized by _θ_ ). This approach enables efficient optimization of the smaller _f_ ret to achieve improved retrieval. Specifically for candidate set _Ct_ = _{ci}i[k]_ =1[sampled from] _[ π][θ]_[, we define the likelihood of] _[ C][t]_ given history items _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[using the Plackett-Luce model (][Plackett][,][ 1975][):] - -**==> picture [306 x 28] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _σ_ is the permutation that ranks items by descending retriever score, and _sσ_ ( _i_ ) denotes the score assigned by _f_ ret to the _i_ -th ranked item. This formulation treats the candidate set as a sequential selection process without replacement: at each step, an item is drawn from the remaining pool with probability proportional to its retriever score. For each turn, we sample multiple candidate sets and use _f_ llm to rank and compute rewards. We then apply policy gradients on the resulting advantages and log-likelihood to optimize the retriever, effectively enhancing the synergy between the retrieval and ranking stages. - -5 - -Preprint. Under review. - -**Pairwise and Multi-Sample Reinforcement Learning** . For pairwise RL, we adopt an online, on-policy DPO approach to maximize the probability of retrieving a favored candidate set _Cw_ over a disfavored set _Cl_ . Because _f_ llm acts as a black-box generator, we compute the final reward as the NDCG ranking score by identifying the rank of the ground truth items directly from the LLM’s output. At each timestep, we sample two candidate sets of size _k_ from policy _πθ_ ; the set that yields the higher NDCG score is designated _Cw_ . In other words, the candidate set where the label item achieves a higher rank is considered preferable. Given history _{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[and candidate sets, we minimize the preference loss] _[ L]_[dpo][:] - -**==> picture [342 x 30] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _β_ controls the strength of preference learning, while the reference model _π_ ref constrains the policy updates. This objective is designed to increase the relative probability of sampling _Cw_ over _Cl_ while preventing excessive policy divergence. In addition to online DPO, we further introduce a multi-sample RL approach based on GRPO (Shao et al., 2024). GRPO samples a group of _g_ candidate sets and computes the advantages by standardizing the rewards within the group (i.e., _A_[ˆ] _i_ = _[r][i][−]_ std[mean] ([ _r_[([] 1, _[r] r_[1] 2[,] ,..., _[r]_[2][,...,] _rg_ ]) _[r][g]_[])] ): - -**==> picture [390 x 31] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _β_ controls the regularization strength. The resulting algorithm, detailed in Section A.2, is lightweight, on-policy and can be seamlessly combined with further optimizations. - -**Training Objective** . To stabilize reinforcement preference learning and maintain the retriever’s standalone quality, we incorporate a supervised negative log-likelihood term, _L_ nll. Consequently, the full preference optimization objective is: - -**==> picture [232 x 10] intentionally omitted <==** - -where _L_ rl represents either the DPO or GRPO loss. While DPO trains the policy to favor preferred candidate sets by maximizing their relative selection probability, GRPO refines policy gradients by calculating advantages across groups of samples to amplify the likelihood of high-rewarding sets. By integrating RL loss with the negative log-likelihood term, RAR bridges the retrieval and generation stages, continually refining _f_ ret to ensure the delivery of diverse, high-quality candidate sets for conversational recommendation. - -## **4 Experiments** - -## **4.1 Experiment Settings** - -Our model is evaluated on three widely-used datasets for conversational recommendation: Inspired, Redial and Reddit (Hayati et al., 2020; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). We adopt multiple baselines for comparison, including both _traditional_ and _LLM-based_ methods. In particular, we adopt _traditional CRS_ : KBRD, KGSF and UniCRS (Chen et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2022b); _sequential methods_ : SASRec, FMLPRec and LRURec (Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a); _retrieval augmented CRS with supervised fine-tuning_ (SFT) methods include Qwen3-8B (Qwen), GPT-5 mini (GPT) and Gemini 3 Flash (Gem) (Yang et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2025), where we perform SFT on the retriever model. Similarly, we experiment RAR with Qwen, GPT and Gemini as LLM generator. For our retriever model, we compare GRU4Rec, SASRec, FMLPRec and LRURec (Hidasi, 2015; Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a). For all methods and datasets, the maximum history length was set to 64 (i.e. history items), and the retrieval size was set to _k_ = 25 in our main experiments. The evaluation metrics are NDCG and Recall at 5 and 10. For all evaluated methods, we saved the model with the best validation NDCG@10 score. Further training and evaluation details are reported in Section A.2. - -6 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|KBRD
KGSF
UniCRS|.0466
.0815
.0472
.0732
.0656
.0815
.0673
.0869
.0676
.0927
.0750
.1032|.0388
.0582
.0453
.078
.0434
.0672
.0497
.0864
.0425
.0646
.0504
.0887|.0066
.0079
.0078
.0098
.0155
.0172
.0155
.0172
.0258
.0376
.0363
.0479| -|SASRec
FMLPRec
LRURec|.0564
.0870
.0655
.1304
.0620
.0815
.0726
.1141
.0671
.0978
.0793
.1359|.0558
.0795
.0681
.1176
.0504
.0784
.0639
.1123
.0539
.0771
.0650
.1111|.0288
.0401
.0339
.0545
.0315
.0434
.0342
.0534
.0316
.0430
.0346
.0522| -|SFTQwen
SFTGem
SFTGPT|.0609
.0938
.0626
.0990
.0859
.1076
.1034
.1544
.0997
.1214
.1091
.1491|.0454
.0684
.0526
.0907
.0574
.0828
.0662
.1097
.0599
.0887
.0700
.1197|.0344
.0484
.0394
.0633
.0455
.0604
.0497
.0708
.0489
.0651
.0558
.0843| -|RARQwen
RARGem
RARGPT|.0693
.0980
.0773
.1241
.0916
.1145
.1046
.1587
**.1091**
**.1422**
**.1180**
**.1700**|.0491
.0704
.0569
.0947
.0632
.0894
**.0721**
.1169
**.0620**
**.0932**
.0718
**.1236**|.0368
.0536
.0444
.0770
.0502
.0661
.0531
.0799
**_.0551_**
**_.0716_**
**_.0593_**
**_.0846_**| - - - -Table 1: Main results of the online DPO-based RAR and baseline methods on conversational recommendation. For clarity, the best results for each dataset and metric are highlighted in **bold** , while the second-best results are underlined. - -|Retriever
N@10
R@10
N@20
R@20
GRU4Rec
.1250
.2015
.1351
.2558
BERT4Rec
.1469
.2337
.1598
.2889
SASRec
.1430
.2363
.1637
.3086
FMLPRec
.1460
.2411
.1689
.3125
LRURec
**.1483**
**.2508**
**.1700**
**.3365**|Dataset
Method
N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|---|---| -||Inspired
DPO
.0693
.0980
.0773
**.1241**
GRPO
**.0753**
**.0997**
**.0807**
.1162| -||Redial
DPO
.0491
.0704
.0569
.0947
GRPO
**.0493**
**.0706**
**.0575**
**.0954**| -||Reddit
DPO
.0368
.0536
.0444
**.0770**
GRPO
**.0385**
**.0547**
**.0450**
.0765| - - - -Table 2: Different retriever model performance pretrained on MovieLens. - -Table 3: DPO & GRPO Comparison on Qwen. - -## **4.2 Experiment Results and Analysis** - -**RQ1. How does RAR perform in conversational recommendation?** We first discuss the evaluation results for conversational recommendation datasets, as reported in Table 1. Based on the presented results, we have several key observations: (1) Overall Performance: Across all datasets and metrics, RAR demonstrates a clear and consistent superiority over traditional, sequential, and SFT baselines, highlighting its robust capability to retrieve and generate high-quality recommendations. In particular, RAR achieves an average improvement of 7.60% over the best baseline results. (2) Impact of Base LLMs: Among the evaluated models enhanced by RAR, GPT delivers the highest overall performance across the datasets, closely followed by Gemini, and then Qwen. This indicates the importance of the LLMs’ inherent capabilities, where GPT and Gemini stand as the state-of-the-art closed-source models, while Qwen presents a powerful open-source alternative for conversational recommendation. (3) Comparison to Traditional and SFT Baselines: Overall, baseline comparisons reveal that while SFT-based retrieval augmentation outperforms traditional methods, RAR further surpasses standard fine-tuning. It achieves average gains of 11.9%, 7.5% and 7.7% for Qwen, Gemini and GPT backbones over their SFT-only counterparts, respectively, demonstrating the efficacy of our RL-based post-training. (4) Trends Across Metrics: Although methods exhibit some variability across metrics, the trends are consistent: performance gains of RAR against the best baselines are particularly pronounced on top- _k_ metrics such as N@5 and R@5. For example, the ranking performance improvement for @5 metrics averages 9.33% compared to 5.86% for @10 metrics, suggesting that our preference optimization strategy is especially effective at pushing the most relevant items to the top of the list. Overall, our findings show that RAR effectively integrates retrieval augmentation and RL-based preference optimization to enhance recommendation performance. - -**RQ2. Which retriever model works best?** To analyze the retriever choice in RAR, we evaluate the performance of several different retriever models on the MovieLens dataset. In particular, we pretrain each retriever model and evaluate their retrieval performance - -7 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Average Performance**
N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10
.0499
.0699
.0575
.0946
.0635
.0825
.0718
.1136
.0727
.1011
.0792
.1203
**.0517**
**.0740**
**.0595**
**.0986**
**.0683**
**.0900**
**.0766**
**.1185**
**.0754**
**.1023**
**.0830**
**.1260**
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
Scores||ND
~~Re~~|CG
~~call~~|||||||| -|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -||||||||||||| -|SimPOQwen
SimPOGem
SimPOGPT|||||||||||| -||||||||||||| -||||||||||||| -|DPOQwen
DPOGem
DPOGPT|||||||||||| -||||||||||||| - - - -Table 4: Performance of SimPO and RAR’s online DPO averaged across datasets. - -Figure 3: Performance changes in RAR with different number of retrieved items. - -on our collected corpus, with results presented in Table 2. Overall, LRURec achieves the highest scores across all reported metrics, recording an N@20 of 0.1700 and an R@20 of 0.3365, thereby outperforming all other retriever models. A similar trend is observed for the @10 metrics, where LRURec scores an N@10 of 0.1483 and an R@10 of 0.2508, establishing a consistent margin over other models. Among the baseline methods, FMLPRec serves as the strongest competitor, achieving the second-best results across most metrics (such as an R@20 of 0.3125 and an R@10 of 0.2411), followed closely by SASRec and BERT4Rec. Considering the efficiency advantages of LRURec in both training and inference, the findings indicate that LRURec is more effective at retrieving candidate items based on user history, leading to higher-quality retrieval outcomes for the following generation stage in RAR. - -**RQ3. How do different RL algorithms compare?** We further analyze the core components of our online preference optimization by comparing two variants of our proposed method: the pairwise online DPO and the multi-sample GRPO (8 samples per example) using the Qwen backbone (Shao et al., 2024). The results are summarized in Table 3. As expected, we observe that our GRPO variant generally outperforms the pairwise DPO across most evaluation metrics and datasets. Specifically, the GRPO variant yields notable improvements on the N@5 metric, achieving 0.0385 compared to DPO’s 0.0368 on Reddit. We attribute GRPO’s superior performance to its multi-trajectory sampling, which yields robust relative advantage estimates for top- _k_ ranking. Due to GRPO’s high inference costs and slower training, we adopt DPO as the default for RAR, which notably maintains 98.6% of GRPO’s average performance at a fraction of the computational cost. For DPO variants, we also adopt different formulations of Equation (4) for comparison and present the average results across datasets in Table 4. Here, we report SimPO (see details in Section A) as an alternative (Meng et al., 2025). Overall, RAR with DPO demonstrates consistently superior results compared to SimPO across all evaluated LLM backbones. For instance, RAR with Qwen achieves N@5 and R@5 scores of 0.0517 and 0.0740 respectively, outperforming SimPO on these crucial top- _k_ metrics. This dominating trend holds strictly true for both the Gemini and GPT backbones, where DPO consistently yields the higher performance across metrics. These findings validate that our proposed DPO-based preference optimization is highly effective at capturing nuanced user preferences, highlighting its potential for delivering higher-quality retrieval results in two-stage conversational recommendation. - -**RQ4. How do key hyperparameters impact the performance of RAR?** Here, we investigate the impact of two critical hyperparameters on the performance of RAR: the number of retrieved items and the _β_ value. First, we evaluate the performance changes when varying the number of retrieved candidate items, as illustrated in Figure 3. The analysis reveals a clear, positive trend: as the number of retrieved items increases, both NDCG and Recall steadily improve. Recall naturally benefits from the expanded candidate pool, which increases the likelihood of capturing relevant items. More importantly, the ranking-sensitive metric, NDCG, also maintains an upward trajectory up to 45 items. This demonstrates the LLM generator’s robust capacity to effectively filter and rank candidates without being immediately overwhelmed by noise. Furthermore, we examine the influence of the _β_ parameter, as summarized in Table 5. Comparing various settings against the standard SFT baseline ( _β_ = 0), we observe that introducing a small _β_ value significantly enhances recommendation accuracy. Specifically, setting _β_ = 0.05 achieves peak performance across all evaluated - -8 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|_β_|**Average Performance**| -|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|0 (SFT)
0.05
0.1
0.2|.0469
.0702
.0515
.0843
**.0513**
**.0741**
**.0580**
**.0953**
.0482
.0692
.0547
.0893
.0485
.0711
.0544
.0888| - - - -Table 5: Recommendation performance of RAR with Qwen using different _β_ values. - -**==> picture [176 x 97] intentionally omitted <==** - -Figure 4: N@10 on different item groups. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|Qwenon
Qwenoff|**.0730**
**.0997**
.0764
.1210
.0693
.0980
**.0773**
**.1241**|.0438
.0626
.0501
.0826
**.0491**
**.0704**
**.0569**
**.0947**|.0367
.0525
.0402
.0629
**.0368**
**.0536**
**.0444**
**.0770**| -|GPTon
GPToff|.1006
.1327
.1115
.1648
**.1091**
**.1422**
**.1180**
**.1700**|**0.646**
**.0975**
**.0748**
**.1285**
.0620
.0932
.0718
.1236|**.0575**
**.0748**
**.0615**
**.0872**
.0536
.0711
.0585
.0859| - - - -Table 6: Recommendation performance of LLMs with thinking enabled and disabled. - -metrics, improving N@10 from 0.0515 to 0.0580 and R@10 from 0.0843 to 0.0953. Increasing _β_ further leads to a slight decline in performance; therefore, our experiments indicate that the optimal range for _β_ lies within [0.05, 0.1]. Overall, these observations suggest that RAR exhibits strong robustness across different hyperparameter choices, maintaining stable, high-quality recommendations without requiring exhaustive, fine-grained tuning. - -**RQ5. Does explicit reasoning improve LLM performance in CRS?** To investigate whether extended reasoning inherently improve recommendation quality, we evaluated Qwen and GPT models with their explicit "thinking" capabilities enabled (on) and disabled (off). As detailed in Table 6, the impact of reasoning is not universally beneficial and varies significantly across scenarios. For the Qwen model, omitting the explicit reasoning phase consistently delivered competitive or superior performance across most datasets while significantly reducing inference costs. Conversely, GPT’s behavior was highly datasetdependent: _GPT_ off achieved the highest metrics on the Inspired dataset, whereas _GPT_ on performed strictly better on both Redial and Reddit. Ultimately, these findings indicate that forcing additional reasoning does not guarantee better recommendations; rather, its utility is dependent on both the underlying model and the specific data distribution. - -**RQ6. Does RAR improve popularity bias and hallucination?** Finally, we analyze RAR (with the Qwen _f_ llm) on two known LLM-based CRS challenges: popularity bias and item hallucination (He et al., 2023; Yang & Chen, 2024). By categorizing items unseen in training into an unpopular group (Figure 4), we confirm popularity bias exists; overall NDCG@10 scores substantially exceed those of unpopular items (e.g., Reddit scores just 0.0013). Nevertheless, RAR generally outperforms the LLM-only Qwen baseline. Leveraging a retriever with rich semantic embeddings and online RL-based post-training yields a nearly 4x improvement on unpopular items over Qwen. Additionally, we observe a dramatic reduction in hallucination rates, with under 1% unmatched titles across all datasets. Ultimately, while not completely immune to popularity bias, RAR’s retrieval augmentation design effectively mitigates hallucination, marking a critical step toward more reliable and trustworthy CRS. - -## **5 Conclusion** - -In this work, we introduce RAR, a two-stage framework for retrieval augmented conversational recommendation. For this purpose, we collect a unified text corpus of over 300k films within the movie domain to support our recommendation tasks. RAR employs a lightweight retriever to efficiently identify potential candidate items based on user interaction history. In addition, a black-box LLM is utilized to refine these candidates by integrating - -9 - -Preprint. Under review. - -contextual data and retrieved information, thereby capturing subtle user preferences in natural language. To further align retrieval with generation, our online, on-policy preference optimization leverages LLM feedback to iteratively enhance the retriever’s performance. Extensive experiments on benchmark datasets validate our approach, demonstrating that by effectively aligning the retriever and generator through online preference optimization, RAR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in conversational recommendation. - -## **References** - -- Josh Achiam, Steven Adler, Sandhini Agarwal, Lama Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, Diogo Almeida, Janko Altenschmidt, Sam Altman, Shyamal Anadkat, et al. GPT-4 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.08774_ , 2023. - -- Sebastian Borgeaud, Arthur Mensch, Jordan Hoffmann, Trevor Cai, Eliza Rutherford, Katie Millican, George Bm Van Den Driessche, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Bogdan Damoc, Aidan Clark, et al. Improving language models by retrieving from trillions of tokens. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 2206–2240. PMLR, 2022. - -- BrightData. Imdb media. https://huggingface.co/datasets/BrightData/IMDb-Media. Accessed: December 2024. - -- Jianlyu Chen, Shitao Xiao, Peitian Zhang, Kun Luo, Defu Lian, and Zheng Liu. M3embedding: Multi-linguality, multi-functionality, multi-granularity text embeddings through self-knowledge distillation. In Lun-Wei Ku, Andre Martins, and Vivek Srikumar (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL 2024_ , pp. 2318–2335, Bangkok, Thailand, August 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10. 18653/v1/2024.findings-acl.137. URL https://aclanthology.org/2024.findings-acl. 137/. - -- Qibin Chen, Junyang Lin, Yichang Zhang, Ming Ding, Yukuo Cen, Hongxia Yang, and Jie Tang. Towards knowledge-based recommender dialog system. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 1803–1813, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1189. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1189/. - -- Gheorghe Comanici, Eric Bieber, Mike Schaekermann, Ice Pasupat, Noveen Sachdeva, Inderjit Dhillon, Marcel Blistein, Ori Ram, Dan Zhang, Evan Rosen, et al. Gemini 2.5: Pushing the frontier with advanced reasoning, multimodality, long context, and next generation agentic capabilities. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2507.06261_ , 2025. - -- Abhimanyu Dubey, Abhinav Jauhri, Abhinav Pandey, Abhishek Kadian, Ahmad Al-Dahle, Aiesha Letman, Akhil Mathur, Alan Schelten, Amy Yang, Angela Fan, et al. The llama 3 herd of models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.21783_ , 2024. - -- Yue Feng, Shuchang Liu, Zhenghai Xue, Qingpeng Cai, Lantao Hu, Peng Jiang, Kun Gai, and Fei Sun. A large language model enhanced conversational recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.06212_ , 2023. - -- Yunfan Gao, Tao Sheng, Youlin Xiang, Yun Xiong, Haofen Wang, and Jiawei Zhang. Chat-rec: Towards interactive and explainable llms-augmented recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.14524_ , 2023. - -- Robert Geirhos, Jörn-Henrik Jacobsen, Claudio Michaelis, Richard Zemel, Wieland Brendel, Matthias Bethge, and Felix A Wichmann. Shortcut learning in deep neural networks. _Nature Machine Intelligence_ , 2(11):665–673, 2020. - -- Kelvin Guu, Kenton Lee, Zora Tung, Panupong Pasupat, and Mingwei Chang. Retrieval augmented language model pre-training. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 3929–3938. PMLR, 2020. - -10 - -Preprint. Under review. - -F Maxwell Harper and Joseph A Konstan. The movielens datasets: History and context. _Acm transactions on interactive intelligent systems (tiis)_ , 5(4):1–19, 2015. - -- Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Dongyeop Kang, Qingxiaoyang Zhu, Weiyan Shi, and Zhou Yu. Inspired: Toward sociable recommendation dialog systems. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2009.14306_ , 2020. - -- Zhankui He, Zhouhang Xie, Rahul Jha, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Yesu Feng, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. Large language models as zero-shot conversational recommenders. In _Proceedings of the 32nd ACM international conference on information and knowledge management_ , pp. 720–730, 2023. - -- Zhankui He, Zhouhang Xie, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Rahul Jha, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. Reindex-then-adapt: Improving large language models for conversational recommendation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.12119_ , 2024. - -- B Hidasi. Session-based recommendations with recurrent neural networks. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1511.06939_ , 2015. - -- Karl Higley, Even Oldridge, Ronay Ak, Sara Rabhi, and Gabriel de Souza Pereira Moreira. Building and deploying a multi-stage recommender system with merlin. In _Proceedings of the 16th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems_ , pp. 632–635, 2022. - -- Jian Hu. Reinforce++: A simple and efficient approach for aligning large language models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.03262_ , 2025. - -- Jonas Hübotter, Frederike Lübeck, Lejs Behric, Anton Baumann, Marco Bagatella, Daniel Marta, Ido Hakimi, Idan Shenfeld, Thomas Kleine Buening, Carlos Guestrin, et al. Reinforcement learning via self-distillation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.20802_ , 2026. - -- Zheng Hui, Xiaokai Wei, Yexi Jiang, Kevin Gao, Chen Wang, Se-eun Yoon, Rachit Pareek, and Michelle Gong. Toward safe and human-aligned game conversational recommendation via multi-agent decomposition. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EACL 2026_ , pp. 4568–4584, 2026. - -- Aaron Hurst, Adam Lerer, Adam P Goucher, Adam Perelman, Aditya Ramesh, Aidan Clark, AJ Ostrow, Akila Welihinda, Alan Hayes, Alec Radford, et al. Gpt-4o system card. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.21276_ , 2024. - -- Gautier Izacard and Édouard Grave. Leveraging passage retrieval with generative models for open domain question answering. In _Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Main Volume_ , pp. 874–880, 2021. - -- Gautier Izacard, Patrick Lewis, Maria Lomeli, Lucas Hosseini, Fabio Petroni, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Armand Joulin, Sebastian Riedel, and Edouard Grave. Atlas: Few-shot learning with retrieval augmented language models. _Journal of Machine Learning Research_ , 24(251):1–43, 2023. - -- Dietmar Jannach, Ahtsham Manzoor, Wanling Cai, and Li Chen. A survey on conversational recommender systems. _ACM Computing Surveys (CSUR)_ , 54(5):1–36, 2021. - -- Hyunsik Jeon, Satoshi Koide, Yu Wang, Zhankui He, and Julian McAuley. Adapting large vision-language models to visually-aware conversational recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 31st ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining V. 2_ , pp. 1037–1048, 2025. - -- Zhengbao Jiang, Frank F Xu, Luyu Gao, Zhiqing Sun, Qian Liu, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Yiming Yang, Jamie Callan, and Graham Neubig. Active retrieval augmented generation. In _Proceedings of the 2023 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing_ , pp. 7969–7992, 2023. - -- Bowen Jin, Hansi Zeng, Zhenrui Yue, Jinsung Yoon, Sercan Arik, Dong Wang, Hamed Zamani, and Jiawei Han. Search-r1: Training llms to reason and leverage search engines with reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.09516_ , 2025. - -11 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Dongyeop Kang, Anusha Balakrishnan, Pararth Shah, Paul Crook, Y-Lan Boureau, and Jason Weston. Recommendation as a communication game: Self-supervised bot-play for goal-oriented dialogue. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 1951– 1961, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1203. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1203/. - -- Wang-Cheng Kang and Julian McAuley. Self-attentive sequential recommendation. In _2018 IEEE international conference on data mining (ICDM)_ , pp. 197–206. IEEE, 2018. - -- Vladimir Karpukhin, Barlas Oguz, Sewon Min, Patrick Lewis, Ledell Wu, Sergey Edunov, Danqi Chen, and Wen-tau Yih. Dense passage retrieval for open-domain question answering. In _Proceedings of the 2020 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP)_ , pp. 6769–6781, 2020. - -- Sara Kemper, Justin Cui, Kai Dicarlantonio, Kathy Lin, Danjie Tang, Anton Korikov, and Scott Sanner. Retrieval-augmented conversational recommendation with prompt-based semi-structured natural language state tracking. In _Proceedings of the 47th International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval_ , pp. 2786–2790, 2024. - -- Wenqiang Lei, Xiangnan He, Yisong Miao, Qingyun Wu, Richang Hong, Min-Yen Kan, and Tat-Seng Chua. Estimation-action-reflection: Towards deep interaction between conversational and recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 304–312, 2020. - -- Patrick Lewis, Ethan Perez, Aleksandra Piktus, Fabio Petroni, Vladimir Karpukhin, Naman Goyal, Heinrich Küttler, Mike Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Tim Rocktäschel, et al. Retrievalaugmented generation for knowledge-intensive NLP tasks. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 33:9459–9474, 2020. - -- Chuang Li, Yang Deng, Hengchang Hu, Min-Yen Kan, and Haizhou Li. Incorporating external knowledge and goal guidance for llm-based conversational recommender systems. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.01868_ , 2024. - -- Raymond Li, Samira Ebrahimi Kahou, Hannes Schulz, Vincent Michalski, Laurent Charlin, and Chris Pal. Towards deep conversational recommendations. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 31, 2018. - -- Xi Victoria Lin, Xilun Chen, Mingda Chen, Weijia Shi, Maria Lomeli, Richard James, Pedro Rodriguez, Jacob Kahn, Gergely Szilvasy, Mike Lewis, et al. RA-DIT: Retrieval-augmented dual instruction tuning. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- Yu Lu, Junwei Bao, Yan Song, Zichen Ma, Shuguang Cui, Youzheng Wu, and Xiaodong He. RevCore: Review-augmented conversational recommendation. In Chengqing Zong, Fei Xia, Wenjie Li, and Roberto Navigli (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL-IJCNLP 2021_ , pp. 1161–1173, Online, August 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.findings-acl.99. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.findings-acl.99/. - -- Jiaqi Ma, Zhe Zhao, Xinyang Yi, Ji Yang, Minmin Chen, Jiaxi Tang, Lichan Hong, and Ed H Chi. Off-policy learning in two-stage recommender systems. In _Proceedings of The Web Conference 2020_ , pp. 463–473, 2020. - -- Yu Meng, Mengzhou Xia, and Danqi Chen. Simpo: Simple preference optimization with a reference-free reward. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 37:124198–124235, 2024. - -- Yu Meng, Mengzhou Xia, and Danqi Chen. Simpo: Simple preference optimization with a reference-free reward. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 37:124198–124235, 2025. - -12 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Volodymyr Mnih, Adria Puigdomenech Badia, Mehdi Mirza, Alex Graves, Timothy Lillicrap, Tim Harley, David Silver, and Koray Kavukcuoglu. Asynchronous methods for deep reinforcement learning. In _International conference on machine learning_ , pp. 1928–1937. PmLR, 2016. - -- Long Ouyang, Jeffrey Wu, Xu Jiang, Diogo Almeida, Carroll Wainwright, Pamela Mishkin, Chong Zhang, Sandhini Agarwal, Katarina Slama, Alex Ray, et al. Training language models to follow instructions with human feedback. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 35:27730–27744, 2022. - -- Boci Peng, Yun Zhu, Yongchao Liu, Xiaohe Bo, Haizhou Shi, Chuntao Hong, Yan Zhang, and Siliang Tang. Graph retrieval-augmented generation: A survey. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.08921_ , 2024. - -- Robin L Plackett. The analysis of permutations. _Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics_ , 24(2):193–202, 1975. - -- Rafael Rafailov, Archit Sharma, Eric Mitchell, Christopher D Manning, Stefano Ermon, and Chelsea Finn. Direct preference optimization: Your language model is secretly a reward model. _Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems_ , 36:53728–53741, 2023. - -- Chidambara Raju. Imdb movies dataset based on genre. https://www.kaggle.com/ datasets/rajugc/imdb-movies-dataset-based-on-genre. Accessed: December 2024. - -- Machel Reid, Nikolay Savinov, Denis Teplyashin, Dmitry Lepikhin, Timothy Lillicrap, Jeanbaptiste Alayrac, Radu Soricut, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, Julian Schrittwieser, et al. Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal understanding across millions of tokens of context. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2403.05530_ , 2024. - -- Nils Reimers and Iryna Gurevych. Sentence-BERT: Sentence embeddings using Siamese BERT-networks. In Kentaro Inui, Jing Jiang, Vincent Ng, and Xiaojun Wan (eds.), _Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP)_ , pp. 3982– 3992, Hong Kong, China, November 2019. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1410. URL https://aclanthology.org/D19-1410/. - -- Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, and Christopher D Manning. RAPTOR: Recursive abstractive processing for tree-organized retrieval. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- John Schulman, Filip Wolski, Prafulla Dhariwal, Alec Radford, and Oleg Klimov. Proximal policy optimization algorithms. _arXiv preprint arXiv:1707.06347_ , 2017. - -- Zhihong Shao, Peiyi Wang, Qihao Zhu, Runxin Xu, Junxiao Song, Xiao Bi, Haowei Zhang, Mingchuan Zhang, YK Li, Y Wu, et al. Deepseekmath: Pushing the limits of mathematical reasoning in open language models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.03300_ , 2024. - -- Weijia Shi, Sewon Min, Michihiro Yasunaga, Minjoon Seo, Richard James, Mike Lewis, Luke Zettlemoyer, and Wen-tau Yih. REPLUG: Retrieval-augmented black-box language models. In _Proceedings of the 2024 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pp. 8364–8377, 2024. - -- Aaditya Singh, Adam Fry, Adam Perelman, Adam Tart, Adi Ganesh, Ahmed El-Kishky, Aidan McLaughlin, Aiden Low, AJ Ostrow, Akhila Ananthram, et al. Openai gpt-5 system card. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.03267_ , 2025. - -- Rohan Surana, Junda Wu, Zhouhang Xie, Yu Xia, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Nathan Kallus, and Julian McAuley. From reviews to dialogues: Active synthesis for zero-shot llm-based conversational recommender system. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.15476_ , 2025. - -- Richard S Sutton, Andrew G Barto, et al. _Reinforcement learning: An introduction_ , volume 1. MIT press Cambridge, 1998. - -13 - -Preprint. Under review. - -- Richard S Sutton, David McAllester, Satinder Singh, and Yishay Mansour. Policy gradient methods for reinforcement learning with function approximation. _Advances in neural information processing systems_ , 12, 1999. - -- Harsh Trivedi, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Tushar Khot, and Ashish Sabharwal. Interleaving retrieval with chain-of-thought reasoning for knowledge-intensive multi-step questions. In _Proceedings of the 61st Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pp. 10014–10037, 2023. - -- Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Binxing Jiao, Linjun Yang, Daxin Jiang, Rangan Majumder, and Furu Wei. Text embeddings by weakly-supervised contrastive pre-training. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2212.03533_ , 2022a. - -- Xiaolei Wang, Kun Zhou, Ji-Rong Wen, and Wayne Xin Zhao. Towards unified conversational recommender systems via knowledge-enhanced prompt learning. In _Proceedings of the 28th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining_ , pp. 1929–1937, 2022b. - -- Yueqi Wang, Zhenrui Yue, Huimin Zeng, Dong Wang, and Julian McAuley. Train once, deploy anywhere: Matryoshka representation learning for multimodal recommendation. In Yaser Al-Onaizan, Mohit Bansal, and Yun-Nung Chen (eds.), _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2024_ , pp. 13461–13472, Miami, Florida, USA, November 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp. 786. URL https://aclanthology.org/2024.findings-emnlp.786/. - -- Junda Wu, Cheng-Chun Chang, Tong Yu, Zhankui He, Jianing Wang, Yupeng Hou, and Julian McAuley. Coral: Collaborative retrieval-augmented large language models improve long-tail recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 30th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining_ , pp. 3391–3401, 2024. - -- Shusheng Xu, Wei Fu, Jiaxuan Gao, Wenjie Ye, Weilin Liu, Zhiyu Mei, Guangju Wang, Chao Yu, and Yi Wu. Is dpo superior to ppo for llm alignment? a comprehensive study. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2404.10719_ , 2024. - -- Shi-Qi Yan, Jia-Chen Gu, Yun Zhu, and Zhen-Hua Ling. Corrective retrieval augmented generation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2401.15884_ , 2024. - -- An Yang, Baosong Yang, Beichen Zhang, Binyuan Hui, Bo Zheng, Bowen Yu, Chengyuan Li, Dayiheng Liu, Fei Huang, Haoran Wei, et al. Qwen2. 5 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.15115_ , 2024. - -- An Yang, Anfeng Li, Baosong Yang, Beichen Zhang, Binyuan Hui, Bo Zheng, Bowen Yu, Chang Gao, Chengen Huang, Chenxu Lv, et al. Qwen3 technical report. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.09388_ , 2025. - -- Ting Yang and Li Chen. Unleashing the retrieval potential of large language models in conversational recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the 18th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems_ , pp. 43–52, 2024. - -- Ori Yoran, Tomer Wolfson, Ori Ram, and Jonathan Berant. Making retrieval-augmented language models robust to irrelevant context. In _The Twelfth International Conference on Learning Representations_ , 2024. - -- Qiying Yu, Zheng Zhang, Ruofei Zhu, Yufeng Yuan, Xiaochen Zuo, Yu Yue, Weinan Dai, Tiantian Fan, Gaohong Liu, Lingjun Liu, et al. Dapo: An open-source llm reinforcement learning system at scale. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.14476_ , 2025. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Yueqi Wang, Zhankui He, Huimin Zeng, Julian McAuley, and Dong Wang. Linear recurrent units for sequential recommendation. In _Proceedings of the 17th ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 930–938, 2024a. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Honglei Zhuang, Aijun Bai, Kai Hui, Rolf Jagerman, Hansi Zeng, Zhen Qin, Dong Wang, Xuanhui Wang, and Michael Bendersky. Inference scaling for long-context retrieval augmented generation. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.04343_ , 2024b. - -14 - -Preprint. Under review. - -Zhenrui Yue, Bowen Jin, Huimin Zeng, Honglei Zhuang, Zhen Qin, Jinsung Yoon, Lanyu Shang, Jiawei Han, and Dong Wang. Hybrid latent reasoning via reinforcement learning. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.18454_ , 2025. - -- Zhenrui Yue, Kartikeya Upasani, Xianjun Yang, Suyu Ge, Shaoliang Nie, Yuning Mao, Zhe Liu, and Dong Wang. Dr. zero: Self-evolving search agents without training data. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.07055_ , 2026. - -- Gholamreza Zare and P Malekpour Alamdari. Conversational graph-llm reasoning for interactive preference modeling and explainable recommendation, 2025. - -- Xiaoyu Zhang, Xin Xin, Dongdong Li, Wenxuan Liu, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Jun Ma, and Zhaochun Ren. Variational reasoning over incomplete knowledge graphs for conversational recommendation. In _Proceedings of the Sixteenth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining_ , pp. 231–239, 2023. - -- Yanzhao Zhang, Mingxin Li, Dingkun Long, Xin Zhang, Huan Lin, Baosong Yang, Pengjun Xie, An Yang, Dayiheng Liu, Junyang Lin, et al. Qwen3 embedding: Advancing text embedding and reranking through foundation models. _arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.05176_ , 2025. - -- Yongfeng Zhang, Xu Chen, Qingyao Ai, Liu Yang, and W Bruce Croft. Towards conversational search and recommendation: System ask, user respond. In _Proceedings of the 27th acm international conference on information and knowledge management_ , pp. 177–186, 2018. - -- Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Shuqing Bian, Yuanhang Zhou, Ji-Rong Wen, and Jingsong Yu. Improving conversational recommender systems via knowledge graph based semantic fusion. In _Proceedings of the 26th ACM SIGKDD international conference on knowledge discovery & data mining_ , pp. 1006–1014, 2020. - -- Kun Zhou, Hui Yu, Wayne Xin Zhao, and Ji-Rong Wen. Filter-enhanced mlp is all you need for sequential recommendation. In _Proceedings of the ACM web conference 2022_ , pp. 2388–2399, 2022. - -- Lixi Zhu, Xiaowen Huang, and Jitao Sang. A llm-based controllable, scalable, humaninvolved user simulator framework for conversational recommender systems. In _Proceedings of the ACM on Web Conference 2025_ , pp. 4653–4661, 2025. - -15 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|**Attribute**|**Value**| -|---|---| -||| -|ID
Title
Year
Genre
Director
Cast
Plot|tt0111161
The Shawshank Redemption
1994
Drama
Frank Darabont
Tim Robbins, Morgan Freeman ...
Chronicles the experiences of a ...| - - - -Table 7: An example movie with metadata in our corpus. - -## **A Appendix** - -## **A.1 Corpus Collection** - -We report the details on the collection and processing of our unified movie text corpus. The process began by gathering an initial set of movie titles and identifiers (e.g., IMDb/TMDB) from multiple open-source datasets, including IMDb genre, IMDb media, and Inspired (Hayati et al., 2020; Raju; BrightData). We then augmented this initial set with movies mentioned in widely-used recommendation benchmarks, namely MovieLens, Redial and Reddit (Harper & Konstan, 2015; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). A primary motivation for building a consolidated, offline corpus was to overcome the limitations of existing APIs. While services like TMDB[2] provide extensive data, their APIs operate on a per-query basis with strict rate limits, making it infeasible to fetch metadata for all titles via individual HTTP requests. Furthermore, API responses are not directly linked to the specific movie mentions within our target conversational datasets. Our approach addresses these issues by creating a versioned, fully annotated dataset that can be indexed and processed in a single pass, thereby eliminating rate-limit bottlenecks and ensuring direct correspondence between metadata and conversational mentions. To construct this corpus, we first consolidated duplicated entries by verifying movie names and identifiers, resolving any conflicts by selecting the most informative metadata. For items with missing information, we carefully collected the missing values from TMDB or other online resources. We deliberately avoided direct scraping of copyrighted text fields from IMDb due to licensing restrictions[3] . Subsequently, we mapped the items in our corpus to their corresponding entries in the recommendation datasets (i.e., MovieLens, Inspired, Redial, and Reddit). This involved performing entity recognition and string matching to identify each movie mentioned in the conversational or sequential data and link it to its entry in our corpus. Any movies for which we could not find essential metadata (director, cast, genre, plot) were removed to maintain data quality. After processing, our final corpus contains 337,731 movie entries with comprehensive metadata, focusing primarily on English-language films (an example is shown in Table 7). The collection spans a wide temporal range, from films made as early as 1888 to upcoming releases in 2029, representing roughly half of all films listed on IMDb as of December 2024. By establishing explicit item correspondence to each of the benchmarks, the collected corpus serves as a robust and readily accessible knowledge base to train both the retriever and LLM components in RAR. - -## **A.2 Implementation & Additional Results** - -**Datasets.** Our model is evaluated on three widely-used benchmark datasets for conversational recommendation: Inspired, Redial and Reddit (Hayati et al., 2020; Li et al., 2018; He et al., 2023). To ensure the retriever has a robust initial understanding of the movie domain, we pretrain it on the MovieLens-20M dataset (Harper & Konstan, 2015). For the pretraining, we segment the dataset into short user sessions, using a 30-minute inactivity threshold to generate meaningful interaction sequences. During preprocessing, we construct input - -> 2https://www.themoviedb.org/ - -> 3https://developer.imdb.com/ - -16 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Dataset|#Train|#Val|#Test| -|---|---|---|---| -|MovieLens|536,127|67,015|67,015| -|Inspired|1,507|206|183| -|Redial|24,095|2,647|3,445| -|Reddit|12,481|2,947|1,511| - - - -Table 8: Dataset Statistics. - -prompts with conversational context and incorporate additional retrieval augmentation from the collected corpus (see Section 3.2). For items retrieved during this process, we utilize a comprehensive set of attributes: _title_ , _year_ , _genre_ , _director_ , _cast_ and _plot_ . These attributes serve a critical dual purpose: they are first used to generate the initial item embeddings for training the retriever model, and subsequently, they function as structured context for the LLM generator. Detailed statistics for each dataset, including the number of training (#Train), validation (#Val) and test (#Test) examples, are reported in Table 8. - -**Baselines.** For baseline models, we adopt _text-based_ SASRec, FMLP-Rec and LRURec following the fMRLRec implementation (Kang & McAuley, 2018; Zhou et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2024a; Wang et al., 2024). We also utilize _supervised fine-tuning_ (SFT) to learn the retriever model in combination with LLM as baselines. This approach aligns with the objective in sequential recommendation and maximizes the likelihood of ground truth items w.r.t. _θ_ . We report the details of baseline methods: - -- _Knowledge-Based Recommender Dialog (KBRD)_ integrates knowledge graph to understand conversational context and user preferences, enabling multi-turn reasoning over entities for recommendation (Chen et al., 2019). - -- _Knowledge Graph-based Semantic Fusion (KGSF)_ utilizes knowledge graph and a gated fusion mechanism to dynamically integrate semantic information from both conversation and item attributes (Zhou et al., 2020). - -- _Unified Conversational Recommender System (UniCRS)_ presents a unified framework to handle diverse conversational goals, including recommendation and chitchat with a prompt-based approach via a shared encoder-decoder model (Wang et al., 2022b). - -- _Self-Attentive Sequential Recommendation (SASRec)_ is the first transformer-based sequential recommender. SASRec uses unidirectional self-attention to capture transition patterns (Kang & McAuley, 2018). - -- _Filter-enhanced MLP for Recommendation (FMLP-Rec)_ also adopts an all-MLP architecture with filter-enhanced layers. FMLP-Rec applies fast Fourier transform to improve representation learning (Zhou et al., 2022). - -- _Linear Recurrence Units for Recommendation (LRURec)_ is based on linear recurrence and is optimized for paralleled training. LRURec thus provides both efficient training and inference speed (Yue et al., 2024a). - -All models are implemented and trained according to the methodologies described in the original works, with unspecified hyperparameters used as recommended. For item encoding, we use the Qwen-8B embedding model and encode items with their available metadata in the format of key-value pairs (Zhang et al., 2025). For each recommender / retriever, we initialize with two layers and search the dropout rates among [0.2, 0.4]. The retriever models are pretrained on MovieLens 20M using an 8:1:1 train / validation / test split, where the data is split into sessions with a maximum time gap of 30 minutes. In pretraining, we sample 100 negative examples at each time step and utilize in-batch negatives to compute the negative log likelihood loss. The models with best validation performance are saved and evaluated on the test sets. - -For SFT baselines and RAR, we adopt LRURec as the retriever and further optimize the retriever model with the proposed online, on-policy preference optimization. The adopted - -17 - -Preprint. Under review. - -## **Example Prompt** - -You are an expert in movie recommendations. Analyze the provided conversation history to identify the user’s preferences, such as genres and actors. Then, rank the candidate movies by how well they match these preferences. Return your answer as a numbered list with each movie on a new line in the format: ’. ’. Do not include any additional commentary, formatting or chattiness. Conversation history: - -Figure 5: Example prompt for RAR. The prompt comprises of instructions, retrieved candidates, followed by the conversation context. - -**Algorithm 1** Preference Optimization in RAR - -**Require:** Conversational dataset _X_ , pretrained retriever _f_ ret (policy _πθ_ ), frozen LLM generator _f_ llm, reward function _r_ ( _·_ , _·_ ), group size _g_ ( _g_ = 2 for DPO), hyperparameters _β_ , learning rate _η_ . **Ensure:** Optimized retriever parameters _θ_ . 1: Initialize policy _πθ_ with parameters from pretrained _f_ ret. 2: Initialize reference policy _π_ ref _← πθ_ . _▷_ Copy initial weights 3: **for** each training epoch **do** 4: **for** each conversation _C_ = ( _rt_ , _st_ , _It_ ) _t[T]_ =1[in] _[ X]_ **[do]** 5: **for** _t_ = 1, . . . , _T_ **do** 6: **if** _rt_ is _recommender_ **then** 7: Let history items be _I_ hist _←{Iτ}[t] τ[−]_ =[1] 1[.] 8: Let history sequence be _S_ hist _←{sk}[t] k[−]_ =[1] 1[.] 9: Sample _{Ci}i[g]_ =1 _[∼][π][θ]_[(] _[·|I]_[hist][)][.] 10: Initialize rewards list _R ←_ []. 11: **for** _i_ = 1, . . . , _g_ **do** 12: Generate ranked list _I_[ˆ] _i ← f_ llm( _S_ hist, _Ci_ ). 13: Calculate reward _ri ← r_ ( _I_[ˆ] _i_ , _It_ ). _▷_ e.g., NDCG as reward 14: Append _ri_ to _R_ . 15: Compute _L_ rl with Equation (4) or Equation (5). 16: Compute NLL loss _L_ nll _←−_ log _πθ_ ( _It|I_ hist). 17: Compute final loss _L ←L_ nll + _L_ rl. 18: Update parameters _θ ← θ − η∇θL_ . 19: **return** Optimized parameters _θ_ . - -LLMs are Qwen (Qwen3-8B), GPT-5 mini (gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07) and Gemini 3 Flash (gemini-3-flash-preview) (Yang et al., 2025; Singh et al., 2025)[4] . For training sets that are greater than 2.5k, we subsample to 2.5k for efficiency. Similarly, we search dropout rates among [0.1, 0.2]. Our learning rate is searched from [5e-5, 1e-4] and we adopt cosine scheduling for learning rate with warm-up steps of 100. SFT baseline models are trained without _L_ dpo while in RAR, the _β_ values are searched within [0.05, 0.1, 0.2]. After sampling from the retriever, we annotate the candidate sets _C_ 1 and _C_ 2 using the LLM model. If any label item appears in both sets, we select the one with the higher label rank as _Cw_ . If a label item is present in only one candidate set, that set becomes _Cw_ . If neither set contains a label item, we resample until one of these conditions is met. Similar to baseline implementation, we keep models with best validation performance for evaluation. Our prompt is constructed as illustrated in Figure 5. The LLM generation configuration is set to - -> 4https://deepmind.google/technologies/gemini/flash - -18 - -Preprint. Under review. - -|Method|**Inspired**|**Redial**|**Reddit**| -|---|---|---|---| -||N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10|N@5
R@5
N@10
R@10| -|SFTQwen
SFTGPT4o
SFTGem2|.0741
.0869
.0741
.0869
.0547
.0652
.0600
.0815
.0793
.0867
**.1032**
.1250|.0507
.0736
.0543
.0843
.0514
.0742
.0585
.0959
.0588
.0870
.0684
.1163|.0291
.0410
.0305
.0450
.0340
.0467
.0371
.0556
.0418
.0543
.0443
.0623| -|RARQwen
RARGPT4o
RARGem2|.0793
.1032
.0793
.1032
.0768
.0978
.0820
.1141
**.0831**
**.1087**
.0995
**.1576**|.0540
.0780
.0583
.0907
.0522
.0771
.0595
.0994
**.0620**
**.0934**
**.0755**
**.1349**|.0326
.0444
.0330
.0457
.0369
.0510
.0393
.0582
**.0449**
**.0583**
**.0477**
**.0669**| - - - -Table 9: Additional results of RAR. For clarity, the best results for each dataset and metric are highlighted in **bold** , while the second-best results are underlined. - -default, with the thinking efforts setting to low or None in our main experiments. All baseline methods and RAR are evaluated under identical conditions. Based on the LLM prediction, we perform string matching to compute the highest rank of label items, evaluation metrics are implemented following (He et al., 2023). - -For alternative RL methods, we adopt the pairwise SimPO (Meng et al., 2024) and the multi-sample GRPO (Shao et al., 2024). GRPO details can be found in our main text, and the formulation for SimPO in our case can be formulated as (Meng et al., 2025): - -**==> picture [348 x 14] intentionally omitted <==** - -where the the log probabilities are computed similar to Equation (3). Hyperparameters such as _γ_ are searched as recommended in the original paper. For GRPO, we set the group size to eight and compute the loss using Equation (5). Across all methods, we adhere to an online, on-policy setting to train and evaluate the retriever models. While our methodology formally introduces the reference model _πre f_ in accordance with standard DPO, our final experiments omit this reference constraint. We empirically found that removing the reference model yields superior recommendation performance, a phenomenon consistent with recent findings in RLVR literature (Yue et al., 2025; Yu et al., 2025). Specifically, we omit the reference model for two primary reasons: (1) our joint optimization with the supervised negative log-likelihood loss ( _Lnll_ ) serves as a highly effective surrogate to prevent policy drift and maintain in-domain performance, rendering the KL penalty from a reference model largely redundant; and (2) while retriever models fundamentally require dropout to achieve optimal generalization, the inconsistency introduced by dropout destabilizes the log-likelihood calculations of the reference model, thereby failing to provide a stable or effective constraint on the policy. To compute hallucination rates, we perform fuzzy matching and consider a prediction to be hallucination if its similarity score to any of the provided candidate titles is below 0.85. - -We present additional results to demonstrate that RAR generalizes well to other recent large language models. Specifically, we evaluate Qwen 2.5 (Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct), GPT-4o mini (gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18), and Gemini 2.0 Flash (gemini-2.0-flash-001) (Yang et al., 2024; Hurst et al., 2024; Comanici et al., 2025). The results are presented in Table 9, from which we observe: (1) First, applying our method (RAR) consistently improves recommendation performance over the standard SFT baseline across all three foundation models. Whether using Qwen 2.5, GPT-4o mini or Gemini 2.0 Flash, the RAR variants yield higher NDCG and Recall scores in almost every scenario. (2) the RAR formulation utilizing Gemini 2.0 Flash (RARGem2) achieves the best overall results, securing the highest scores across all metrics for the Redial and Reddit datasets, as well as three out of four metrics for the Inspired dataset. In summary, these findings confirm that our approach is model-agnostic and generalizes highly effectively to various state-of-the-art large language models, reliably boosting performance beyond standard fine-tuning techniques. - -19 +With its in-depth technological expertise, +profound market know-how and strong +partnerships, GFT implements scalable +IT solutions to increase productivity. This +provides clients with faster access to new +IT applications and innovative business +models, while also reducing risk. + +Founded in 1987 and located in 15 countries +to ensure close proximity to its clients, GFT +employs 6,000 people. GFT provides them +with career opportunities in all areas of + +Shaping the futureof digital businessPartners:MicrosoftAzureImplementing Hybrid Cloud with Microsoft AzureWhite paper 18 + +19 + +GFT Corporate Center +in Stuttgart, Germany + +Innovations to touch +at our Digital Innovation +Labs + +Teamwork +worldwide + +— This report is supplied in good faith, +based on information made available +to GFT at the date of submission. It +contains confidential information that +must not be disclosed to third parties. +Please note that GFT does not warrant +the correctness or completion of the +information contained. The client is +solely responsible for the usage of the +information and any decisions based +upon it. + +GFT Technologies SE BSchelmenwasenstr. 34, 70567 Stuttgart, Germany BT. +49  711  620  420 Bwww.gft.com Binfo@gft.com + +GFT-201111-WP-AZUREHYBRID-LL-AABB-CCDD © GFT 2020 diff --git a/q93/random_k2/question.json b/q93/random_k2/question.json index 63a79efb5ddd970c983a347fb36e711bce9a5513..5ec0227802486d47676929f5e40f87de36f0308e 100644 --- a/q93/random_k2/question.json +++ b/q93/random_k2/question.json @@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "t480_ug_en.pdf", - "web_7795b10bf9b6a434.pdf", - "web_55eb3e1bfd6dcec7.pdf" + "resize_r1_4.pdf", + "resize_r1_23.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q93/random_k2/random_1.md b/q93/random_k2/random_1.md index 4c601abeb6f180fb2f07694cada010de6f7dd010..b1f264dec8c881060a31fd51402112360988391b 100644 --- a/q93/random_k2/random_1.md +++ b/q93/random_k2/random_1.md @@ -1,462 +1,633 @@ -Proposal for the Theme on Big Data -Analytics - -Qiang Yang, HKUST - -Jiannong Cao, PolyU - -Qi-man Shao, CUHK - -May 2015 - - Motivation - -• - -The world's technological per-capita capacity to - -store information doubled every 40 months - -– - -As of 2012, 2.5 exabytes (2.5×1018) of data/day -Relational database management systems and -• -desktop statistics and visualization packages often -have difficulty handling big data. - -– - -Big Data: new driver for digital economy&society - - - - - - - -Gartner: hundreds of billions of GDP by 2020. -Intangible factor after labor and capital -Data Science: The fourth paradigm - -2 - - The Power of Big Data - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Big Data can bring “big values” to our life in -almost every aspects. -Technologically, Big Data is bringing about changes in our lives because it -allows diverse and heterogeneous data to be fully integrated and -analyzed to help us make decisions. -Today, with the Big Data technology, thousands of data from seemingly -unrelated areas can help support important decisions. This is the -power of Big Data. -Areas of Applications - -– - -– - -– - -– - -– - -Health and Well being - -Policy making and public opinions - -Smart cities and more efficient society - -New online educational models: MOOC and Student-Teacher modeling - -Robotics and human-robot interaction - -• - -Much of this power hinges on Research on Analytics - -3 - - Hong Kong needs Big Data -Research - -1. - -2. - -to develop state-of-the-art Big -Data platform in research, -education and industrial -applications, and open it to the -Hong Kong society and the world -at large, and - -to make a difference in Smart -Cities, Health and Well-being -(including supporting aging -populations), and modernizing -Finance, Education and Logistics -in Hong Kong. - -4 - - Big Data Analytics Objectives - -5 - - Relation to Smart Cities and IoT - -• - -• - -• - -World economic forum -ranking HK’s -infrastructure: #1 -– - -Maintain the lead in IT - -Infrastructure - -East Kowloon Project: -Energizing Hong Kong -via Smart Cities -Big Data: -– - -IoT provides the - -infrastructure for - -collecting the data - -Smart Cities as - -important application - -goal - -– - -6 - - Research Objectives - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Big Data Analytics: data mining and machine learning -– - -Large-scale machine learning, data mining and data visualization - -Big Data Computing: data center support for Analytics -– - -Big data collection and transformation, integration and distributed -data management and computing - -Big data sampling and statistical theory, Big data security and privacy - -Big Data Theory, Privacy&Security issues on Analytics -– -Big Data Science: 4th Paradigm – Analytics for Science and -Engineering -– - -Big Data and Multi-disciplines (Bio, Chemistry, Engineering, Social) - -7 - - Why Hong Kong is Ready for the Theme - -• - -We have the best researchers in machine learning, data mining, data -management, sensor networks, statistics, and multidisciplinary -research such as bioinformatics - -– - -– - -– - -China National 973 Projects on Big Data - -IEEE Transactions on Big Data: EiC - -ACM KDD Conferences: PC and Conference Chairs - -Winner of Big Data related international competitions - -– -New industries based on lots of data - -– - -Financial industry, logistics industry, education sector, government -services, etc. - -We have many potential collaborators and partners -– - -Huawei, Tencent, Baidu, Alibaba, Google, Microsoft, etc. - -• - -• - -8 - - Big Data Analytics Workflow - - 9 - -Data -Extraction - -Data -Integration - -• HKUST -CUHK -• -Baptist -• -HSBC -• -Astri -• - -• HKUST -HKU -• -City U -• -Alibaba -• -Astri -• - -Applications - -• Biology and Genetics -• -• -• -• -• -• -• -• - -Chemistry -Physics -Government Policies -Social Sciences -General Health -Logistics -Finance -Business - -Data Mining & -Visualization - -• HKUST -CUHK -• -City U -• -Huawei -• -Tencent -• - -Big Data -Computing &Data -Management - -• CUHK -• -• -• -• -• - -HKUST -HKU -PolyU -City U -Baptist U - - Multi-disciplinary Big-data Analytics - -• - -Objectives: -• - -Interdisciplinary, -research -technological big data analytics - -heterogeneous - -multi-university, - -on - -multi-team -and - -scientific - -10 - - Why Big Data needs Team Work? - -• - -Big data analytics is necessarily a joint effort by -researchers from academic institutions, -government and society and industry. -– - -The government and industry are sources of Big -Data, and providers of problems and challenges, -The academic researchers are solution - -providers. - -When it comes to package the solutions from -university labs to transfer to the real world, -universities and industry must work together to -build scalable and robust solutions. - -– - -– - -11 - - Expected Outcomes - -• - -• - -• - -• - -New methodologies and solutions for Big Data -research -New applications that impact the society and -industry in Hong Kong and beyond, and -New digital economies created based on big -data -New educational programs for students; -cultivating leaders for the Big Data society and -industry. - -12 - - Breakthroughs Expected - -• - -• - -• - -• - -New algorithms, methodologies, systems and -applications in Big Data -New knowledge from Big data applications in -Science, Engineering, and Societal Problems -New insights into Big data practices in real -world -New ways to protect security and privacy of big - -data relevant to individuals and organizations - -13 - - Call for Proposals in Big Data Analytics - -• - -• - -Foundations in Big Data Analytics Research: -– - -developing and studying fundamental theories, -algorithms, techniques, methodologies, -technologies to address the effectiveness and -efficiency issues to enable the applicability of Big -Data problems; - -Innovative Applications in Big Data Analytics: -developing techniques, methodologies and -– -technologies of key importance to a Big Data -problem that requires the seamless cooperation -of domain scientists with big data researchers. - -14 - - Benefit for the Hong Kong Society - -• - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Can Hong Kong transform into a more data- -driven society and maintain -leadership -globally? - -its - -How can companies in Hong Kong become -more competitive with Big Data technology? - -Can Data Science in Hong Kong’s research -fields benefit from strong foundations on big data? - -Can the government become more efficient with -big data driven methodologies in decision -making? - -Can education, finance, logistics and health -benefit from the ever increasing data? - -15 +English – Disney Terms of Use + +Home / English – Disney Terms of Use + +Last Updated: SEPTEMBER 26, 2019 + +Disney DTC LLC and/or its affiliates and subsidiaries (collectively, “Disney DTC”) are pleased +to provide to you their sites, software, applications, content, products and services (“Disney +Services”), which may be branded Disney, ABC, ESPN, Marvel, Pixar, Lucasfilm, FX or another +brand owned or licensed by Disney DTC. These terms govern your use and our provision of the +Disney Services on which these terms are posted, as well as Disney Services we make available +on third-party sites and platforms if these terms are disclosed to you in connection with your use +of the Disney Services. PLEASE READ THESE TERMS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING +THE DISNEY SERVICES. BY USING THE DISNEY SERVICES YOU AGREE TO BE +BOUND BY THESE TERMS. + +ANY DISPUTE BETWEEN YOU AND US, EXCEPT FOR SMALL CLAIMS, IS SUBJECT +TO A CLASS ACTION WAIVER AND MUST BE RESOLVED BY INDIVIDUAL BINDING +ARBITRATION. PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT IN ITS ENTIRETY, INCLUDING +THE ARBITRATION PROVISION BELOW. + +NOTHING IN THESE TERMS IS INTENDED TO AFFECT YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE +LAW IN YOUR USUAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE THAT CAN NOT BE ALTERED BY +THESE TERMS. IF THERE IS A CONFLICT BETWEEN THOSE RIGHTS AND THESE +TERMS, YOUR RIGHTS UNDER APPLICABLE LOCAL LAW WILL PREVAIL. + +1. Contract between You and Us + + This is a contract (1) between you and Disney DTC LLC, as a Delaware limited liability +company doing business at 500 South Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521, USA, or +(2) between you and any different service provider identified for a particular Disney Service. + +You must read and agree to these terms (the “Agreement”) before using the Disney Services. If +you do not agree, you may not use the Disney Services. These terms describe the limited basis +on which the Disney Services are made available to you and supersede prior agreements or +arrangements. + +Supplemental terms and conditions may apply to some Disney Services, such as rules for a +particular competition, content, software, application, service or other activity, or terms that may +accompany certain territories, content, products or software accessible through the Disney +Services. If applicable, such supplemental terms and conditions will be disclosed to you in +connection with such competition, content, product, software, application, service or +activity. Any supplemental terms and conditions are in addition to these terms and, in the event + + of a conflict, the supplemental terms will prevail over these terms. If you do not agree to the +supplemental terms and conditions disclosed, you must not use the applicable Disney Service. + +We may change these terms at any time. Any such amendment will be effective thirty (30) days +following either our dispatch of a notice to you or our posting of the amended terms. You are +responsible for periodically reviewing the terms for updates and amendments. By continuing to +use the Disney Services you will be deemed to have agreed to and accepted any amendments. If +you do not agree to any change to these terms, you must discontinue using the Disney +Services. Our customer service representatives are not authorized to modify any provision of +these terms, either verbally or in writing. + +We may immediately terminate this contract with respect to you (including your access to the +Disney Services) if you fail to comply with any provision of these terms. + +2. The Disney Services + +The Disney Services are for your personal, noncommercial use and are intended for +informational and entertainment purposes only. They do not constitute legal, financial, +professional, medical or healthcare advice or diagnosis and cannot be used for such +purposes. To support smooth operation of the Disney Services across wide geographic areas, +aspects of certain activities, such as game play, may be simulated to avoid delays. + +The Disney Services are our copyrighted property or the copyrighted property of our licensors or +licensees and all trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress and other intellectual +property rights in the Disney Services are owned by us or our licensors or licensees. Except as +we specifically agree in writing, no element of the Disney Services may be used or exploited in +any way other than as part of the Disney Services offered to you. You may own the physical +media on which elements of the Disney Services are delivered to you, but we retain full and +complete ownership of the Disney Services. We do not transfer title to any portion of the Disney +Services to you. + +Content and Software License + +If a Disney Service is configured to enable the use of software, content, virtual items or other +materials owned or licensed by us, we grant you a limited, non-exclusive, non-sublicensable, +non-transferable license to access and use such software, content, virtual item or other material +for your personal, noncommercial use only, only for as long as each Disney Service is made +available by us, with no right to reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available +to the public, or transform any Disney Service in any media format or channel now known or +hereafter devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney +Service). + +You may not: circumvent or disable any content protection system or digital rights management +technology used with any Disney Service; decompile, reverse engineer, disassemble or otherwise +reduce any Disney Service to a human-readable form; remove identification, copyright or other +proprietary notices; or access or use any Disney Service in an unlawful or unauthorized manner + + or in a manner that suggests an association with our products, services or brands. You may not +access or use any Disney Service in violation of United States export control and economic +sanctions requirements. By acquiring services, content or software through the Disney Services, +you represent and warrant that your access to and use of the services, content or software will +comply with those requirements. + +Disclaimers and Limitation on Liability + +THE DISNEY SERVICES ARE PROVIDED “AS IS” AND “AS AVAILABLE.” WE +DISCLAIM ALL CONDITIONS, REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES NOT +EXPRESSLY SET OUT IN THESE TERMS TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY +APPLICABLE LAW. + +FOR HELP, PLEASE REFER TO THE HELP SECTION OF THE APPLICABLE DISNEY +SERVICE FOR ASSISTANCE IF DIGITAL CONTENT SUPPLIED VIA A DISNEY +SERVICE IS NOT WORKING PROPERLY. We will not be liable for damage which could +have been avoided by following our advice to apply an update offered to you free of charge or +for damage which was caused by you failing to correctly follow installation instructions or to +have in place the minimum system requirements advised by us. + +We shall not be liable for delay or failure in performance for causes beyond our control or any +other damage which does not result from a breach of our obligation. + +We are not liable for business losses. We only supply the products for domestic and private use. +If you use the products for any commercial, business or re-sale purpose we will have no liability +to you for any loss of profit, loss of business, business interruption, or loss of business +opportunity. + +WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LACK OF FUNCTIONALITY OR FAILURE TO +PROVIDE ANY PART OF THE DISNEY SERVICE, OR ANY LOSS OF CONTENT OR +DATA THAT IS DUE TO: YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICES, OPERATING SYSTEM OR +INTERNET CONNECTION, YOUR FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SPECIFIED +COMPATIBILITY REQUIREMENTS OR THE CONSEQUENCES OF YOU CHANGING +YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICE, OPERATING SYSTEM OR INTERNET CONNECTION. + +WE SHALL NOT BE LIABLE TO YOU FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL OR +CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LOST PROFITS AND PROPERTY +DAMAGE, EVEN IF WE WERE ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES, +NOR SHALL WE BE HELD LIABLE FOR DELAY OR FAILURE IN PERFORMANCE +RESULTING FROM CAUSES BEYOND OUR REASONABLE CONTROL. + +IN NO EVENT SHALL OUR TOTAL LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ALL DAMAGES, LOSSES +AND CAUSES OF ACTION EXCEED ONE THOUSAND U.S. DOLLARS (US $1,000). + + Changes to the Disney Services + +The Disney Services are constantly evolving and will change over time. If we make a material +change to the Disney Services, we will provide you with reasonable notice as described above +and you will be entitled to terminate this contract prospectively by no longer using the Disney +Services. + +Additional Restrictions on Use of the Disney Services + +We do not allow uses of the Disney Services that are commercial or business-related, or that +advertise or offer to sell products or services (whether or not for profit), or that solicit others +(including solicitations for contributions or donations). You agree not to knowingly or recklessly +introduce a virus or other harmful component, or otherwise tamper with, impair or damage any +Disney Service or connected network, or interfere with any person or entity’s use or enjoyment +of any Disney Service. You agree not to use any software or device that allows automated +gameplay, expedited gameplay, or other manipulation of gameplay or game client and you agree +not to cheat or otherwise modify a Disney Service or game experience to create an advantage for +one user over another. Additionally, you agree not to access, monitor or copy, or permit another +person or entity to access, monitor or copy, any element of the Disney Services using a robot, +search engine, “spider,” “scraper,” or other automated means or manual process without our +express written permission. + +Third-Party Services and Content + +The Disney Services may integrate, be integrated into, or be provided in connection with third- +party services and content. We do not control those third-party services and content. You +should read the terms of use agreements and privacy policies that apply to such third-party +services and content. + +If you access a Disney Service using an Apple iOS, Android or Microsoft Windows-powered +device or Microsoft Xbox One, Apple Inc., Google, Inc. or Microsoft Corporation, respectively, +shall be a third-party beneficiary to this contract. However, these third-party beneficiaries are +not a party to this contract and are not responsible for the provision or support of the Disney +Services. You agree that your access to the Disney Services using these devices also shall be +subject to the usage terms set forth in the applicable third-party beneficiary’s terms of service. + +Mobile Networks + +When you access the Disney Services through a mobile network, your network or roaming +provider’s messaging, data and other rates and fees will apply. Downloading, installing or using +certain Disney Services may be prohibited or restricted by your network provider and not all +Disney Services may work with your network provider or device. + + Affiliate Advertising Programs + +Disney DTC is a participant in affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for +sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to third party retail sites. + +3. Your Content and Account + + User Generated Content + +The Disney Services may allow you to communicate, submit, upload or otherwise make +available text, chats, images, audio, video, competition entries or other content (“User Generated +Content”), which may be accessible and viewable by the public. Access to these features may be +subject to age restrictions. You may not submit or upload User Generated Content that is +defamatory, harassing, threatening, bigoted, hateful, violent, vulgar, obscene, pornographic, or +otherwise offensive or that harms or can reasonably be expected to harm any person or entity, +whether or not such material is protected by law. + +In most instances, we do not claim ownership to your User Generated Content; however, you +grant us a non-exclusive, sublicensable, irrevocable and royalty-free worldwide license under all +copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, privacy and publicity rights and other intellectual +property rights for the full duration of those rights to use, reproduce, transmit, print, publish, +publicly display, exhibit, distribute, redistribute, copy, index, comment on, modify, transform, +adapt, translate, create derivative works based upon, publicly perform, publicly communicate, +make available, and otherwise exploit such User Generated Content, in whole or in part, in all +media formats and channels now known or hereafter devised (including in connection with the +Disney Services and on third-party sites and platforms), in any number of copies and without +limit as to time, manner and frequency of use, without further notice to you, without attribution +(to the extent this is not contrary to mandatory provisions of applicable law), and without the +requirement of permission from or payment to you or any other person or entity. You agree that +submission of User Generated Content does not establish any relationship of trust and confidence +between you and us, and that you have no expectation of compensation whatsoever (except as +may be specifically stated in the provisions of the Disney Services in connection with the +submission, or arising from it). + +You represent and warrant that your User Generated Content conforms to these terms and that +you own or have the necessary rights and permissions including, without limitation, all +copyrights, music rights and likeness rights (with respect to any person) contained in the User +Generated Content, without the need for payment to any other person or entity, to use and +exploit, and to authorize us to use and exploit, your User Generated Content in all manners +contemplated by these terms. You agree to indemnify and hold us and our subsidiary and +affiliated companies, and each of their respective employees and officers, harmless from any +demands, loss, liability, claims or expenses (including attorneys’ fees), made against us by any +third party arising out of or in connection with our use and exploitation of your User Generated +Content resulting from your breach of any warranty, representation or other provision of these +terms or any applicable supplemental terms. You also agree not to enforce any moral rights, +ancillary rights or similar rights in or to the User Generated Content against us or our licensees, + + distributors, agents, representatives and other authorized users, and agree to procure the same +agreement not to enforce from others who may possess such rights. + +To the extent that we authorize you to create, post, upload, distribute, publicly display or +publicly perform User Generated Content that requires the use of our copyrighted works, we +grant you a non-exclusive license to create a derivative work using the specifically referenced +copyrighted works as required for the sole purpose of creating the materials, provided that such +license shall be conditioned upon your assignment to us of all rights worldwide in the work you +create for the duration of copyright in the User Generated Content, in all formats and media +known or unknown to date, including for use on Disney Services and on third party sites and +platforms. If such rights are not assigned to us, your license to create derivative works using our +copyrighted works shall be null and void. + +We may monitor, screen, post, remove, modify, store and review User Generated Content or +communications sent through a Disney Service, at any time and for any reason, including to +ensure that the User Generated Content or communication conforms to these terms, without prior +notice to you. We are not responsible for, and do not endorse or guarantee, the opinions, views, +advice or recommendations posted or sent by users. + +Accounts + +Some Disney Services permit or require you to create an account to participate or to secure +additional benefits. You agree that any information you provide and maintain is accurate, +current and complete, including your contact information for notices and other communications +from us and your payment information. You agree not to impersonate or misrepresent your +affiliation with any person or entity, including using another person’s username, password or +other account information, or another person’s name or likeness, or provide false details for a +parent or guardian. You agree that we may take steps to verify the accuracy of information you +provide, including contact information for a parent or guardian. + +We have adopted and implemented a policy that provides for the termination, in appropriate +circumstances, of the accounts of users who are repeat infringers of copyright. In addition, we +may suspend or terminate your account and your ability to use the Disney Services if you engage +in, encourage, or advocate for illegal conduct or if you fail to comply with these terms or any +supplemental terms. + +Passwords and Security + +You agree that you will not share your account or account information with others. You are +responsible for taking reasonable steps to maintain the confidentiality of your username and +password, and you are responsible for all activities under your account that you can reasonably +control. You agree to promptly notify us of any unauthorized use of your username, password or +other account information, or of any other breach of security that you become aware of involving +your account or the Disney Services. + + The security, integrity and confidentiality of your information are extremely important to us. We +have implemented technical, administrative and physical security measures that are designed to +protect your information from unauthorized access, disclosure, use and modification. + +4. Paid Transactions + +Identity of Seller + +Sales are made by Disney DTC or the seller identified at the time of sale, if different. If you +have questions about your order, please contact the seller at the address provided and they will +assist you. Some digital storefronts on the Disney Services are operated by third parties and, in +that case, different or additional sale terms may apply, which you should read when they are +presented to you. + +Digital Content and Virtual Items + +We may make applications, games, software or other digital content available on the Disney +Services for you to license for a one-time fee. When purchasing a license to access such material +from a Disney Service, charges will be disclosed to you on the Disney Service before you +complete the license purchase. + +Your purchase of a virtual item or in-game currency is a payment for a limited, non-assignable +license to access and use such content or functionality in the Disney Services with no right to +reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available to the public or transform any +Disney Service via any online media, in any media format or channel now known or hereafter +devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney Service). +Virtual items (including characters and character names) or in-game currency purchased or +available to you in the Disney Services can only be used in connection with the Disney Services +where you obtained them or where they were developed by you as a result of game play. These +items are not redeemable or subject to refund and cannot be traded outside of the Disney +Services for money or other items for value. We may modify or discontinue virtual items or in- +game currency at any time. + +Digital Movie Codes + +Digital codes originally packaged in a combination disc + code package (a package that includes +a DVD, Blu-Ray, and/or 4K/UHD disc(s) and a digital code) may not be sold separately and may +be redeemed only by an individual who obtains the code in the original combination disc + code +package, or by a family member of that individual. Digital codes are not authorized for +redemption if sold separately. You may use digital movie codes to obtain licensed access to +digital movies only as specifically authorized under these terms and conditions and the terms and +conditions of the participating provider of digital content through which you access or download +the digital movie. Digital movie codes sold, distributed, purchased, or transferred in a manner +inconsistent with these terms and conditions are subject to being invalidated. + + Digital Movie Code Returns. If you do not agree to the above terms and conditions for +redeeming a digital movie code obtained by you or a family member in an original combination +disc + code package, you may return the combination disc + code package to Disney for a refund +subject to the conditions provided at this link. + +Subscriptions + +Some Disney Services require paid subscriptions to access. By signing up for a subscription, +you agreed that your subscription will be automatically renewed and, unless you cancel your +subscription, you authorized us to charge your payment method for the renewal term. The period +of auto-renewal will be the same as your initial subscription period unless otherwise disclosed to +you at the time of sale. The renewal rate will be no more than the rate for the immediately prior +subscription period, excluding any promotional and discount pricing, unless we notify you of a +rate change prior to your auto-renewal, in which case you will have the right to cancel the +renewal of your subscription. From time to time, we may offer a free trial subscription for a +Disney Service. If you register for a free trial subscription, we will begin to bill your account +when the free trial subscription expires, unless you cancel your subscription before that time. + +When you subscribe to a Disney Service (other than semi-annual and annual subscriptions), you +have the right to cancel your contract within fourteen (14) days from the date the transaction is +concluded and you will receive a full refund of the subscription fee paid. For semi-annual and +annual subscriptions, if notice of cancellation is received within the first thirty (30) days +following the first day of initial billing, you will receive a refund of the subscription fee paid. If +we refund your subscription fee, you will still be obligated to pay other charges incurred by you +in the course of using the Disney Service prior to the date of cancellation. If you pay a periodic +subscription fee for a Disney Service, we will provide you with reasonable notice of changes to +the fees or billing methods in advance of their effective date and you will be able to cancel your +subscription prior to such change. If you subscribed online, we will give you the option of +cancelling the subscription online. + +The Order Process + +You will have the opportunity to review and confirm your order, including delivery address (if +applicable), payment method and product details. We will send to you a notice when we accept +your order and our acceptance will be deemed complete and for all purposes to have been +effectively communicated to you at the time we send the notice. At such time, the contract for +sale will be made and become binding on both you and us. The risk of loss in any goods you +purchase and the responsibility to insure them passes to you when the relevant goods are +delivered. + +We reserve the right to refuse or cancel any order prior to delivery. Some situations that may +result in your order being cancelled include system or typographical errors, inaccuracies in +product or pricing information or product availability, fairness among customers where supplies +are limited, or problems identified by our credit or fraud departments. We also may require +additional verification or information before accepting an order. We will contact you if any +portion of your order is cancelled or if additional information is required to accept your order. If + + your order is cancelled after we have processed your payment but prior to delivery, we will +refund your payment. + +Payments and Billing + +When you provide payment information, you represent and warrant that the information is +accurate, that you are authorized to use the payment method provided, and that you will notify us +of changes to the payment information. We reserve the right to utilize third party payment card +updating services to obtain current expiration dates on credit cards and debit cards. + +Right of Cancellation; Return of Goods + +You may have the right to cancel an order placed for a Disney Service - depending on the nature +of the Disney Service. Please read the following information carefully so you understand your +right of cancellation. + +If you wish to cancel, you must do so by following the cancellation instructions for the particular +Disney Service. A sample cancellation form is available here. + +Cancelling Subscriptions + +Please see the information above on the process for cancelling subscriptions in our Subscriptions +section. + +Digital Content + +When you purchase a license to access digital content or virtual items, you will be given an +opportunity to consent to delivery at the time of purchase. By consenting to delivery, you +acknowledge that you have lost the right to cancel. License purchase fees paid for digital content +are non-refundable. + +Physical Goods + +You have the right, within thirty (30) days from the date of your receipt of physical goods, to +cancel our contract with you and return the goods. This right does not apply to goods stated by +us on the Disney Services to be non-returnable, including but not limited to: + +• Any products with a seal, where the seal is broken, such as audio and video recordings, + +computer software, and CD’s, DVD’s or other physical media that have been supplied in +sealed packaging; and + +• Personalized items. + +Personalized Goods + +We reserve the right to refuse personalized orders at our discretion. Inappropriate use of our +personalization service will cause your order to be cancelled and any payment refunded. + + These cancellation rights are separate and in addition to your rights should any item we supply +be faulty. + +If you are returning goods that are not faulty, you may be required to pay for the cost of returning +the goods to us and we may deduct a reasonable amount if you use the goods. + +Pricing; Taxes + +We may revise the pricing for products and services we offer. When you place your order, we +estimate the applicable tax and include that estimate in the total for your convenience. Except to +the extent required under applicable tax laws, the actual tax amount that will be applied to your +order and charged to your payment method is based on calculations on the date of shipment, +regardless of when the order was placed. + +International Shipping; Customs + +When ordering goods for delivery to countries other than the country where the seller is located, +you may have to pay import duties and taxes levied. These and any additional charges for +customs clearance must be borne by you. For goods shipped internationally, please note that any +manufacturer warranty may not be valid; manufacturer service options may not be available; +manuals, instructions and safety warnings may not be in destination country languages; the +goods and accompanying materials may not be designed in accordance with destination country +standards, specifications, and labeling requirements; and the goods may not conform to +destination country voltage (requiring use of an adapter or converter). You are responsible for +assuring the goods can be lawfully imported to the destination country. When ordering from us, +the recipient is the importer of record and must comply with all laws and regulations of the +destination country. + +5. Competitions + +Competitions that you enter on a Disney Service may have supplemental rules and/or conditions, +but the following general rules apply absent contrary terms in any supplemental rules or +conditions for the competition. If there are rules or conditions for a competition and such rules +or conditions conflict with these terms, the provisions contained in the rules and conditions +govern and control the competition. + +Entries + +Your competition entry is User Generated Content and subject to all provisions of these terms +that govern your submission and our use of your User Generated Content. We may disqualify +entries that are late, misdirected, incomplete, corrupted, lost, illegible or invalid or where +appropriate parental consent was not provided. Competition entries are limited to one per person +and entries via agents or third parties or the use of multiple identities are not permitted. Use of +automated entries, votes or other programs is prohibited and all such entries (or votes) will be +disqualified. + + We reserve the right to modify, suspend, cancel or terminate a competition or extend or resume +the entry period or disqualify any participant or entry at any time without giving advance +notice. We will do so if it cannot be guaranteed the competition can be carried out fairly or +correctly for technical, legal or other reasons, or if we suspect that any person has manipulated +entries or results, provided false information or acted unethically. If we cancel or terminate a +competition, prizes may be awarded in any manner we deem fair and appropriate consistent with +local laws governing the competition. + +Eligibility + +To enter a competition, the competition must be open to residents in your country and you must +be a registered user of the Disney Services and have an active account with current contact +information. No purchase is necessary to enter a competition and a purchase will not improve +your chances of winning. Competitions are not open to our employees (or their immediate +families) or anyone else professionally associated with the competition. If you are under age 18 +(or under the age of majority under applicable law) and the competition is open to you, we may +need your parent or guardian’s consent before we can accept your entry. We reserve the right to +request proof of identity or to verify eligibility conditions and potential winning entries, and to +award any prize to a winner in person. Competitions are void where prohibited or restricted by +law. Potential winners who are residents in jurisdictions where competitions require an element +of skill may be required to answer a mathematical test in order to be eligible to win a prize. + +Prizes + +No cash or alternative prizes are available, except that we (or the party providing a prize) reserve +the right to substitute a similar prize of equal or greater value. Prizes cannot be transferred +(except to a child or other family member) or sold by winners. Only the number of prizes stated +for the competition is available to be won and all prizes will be awarded provided a sufficient +number of eligible entries are received and prizes are validly claimed by the date provided in +connection with the competition, after which no alternate winners will be selected or unclaimed +prizes awarded. Unless otherwise disclosed in the prize description prior to entry, winners are +responsible for all costs and expenses associated with claiming a prize. All taxes are solely the +responsibility of each winner, although we reserve the right to withhold applicable taxes and +each winner agrees to complete any required tax forms. + +Your acceptance of a prize constitutes agreement to participate in reasonable publicity related to +the competition and grants us an unconditional right to us to use your name, town or city and +state, province or country, likeness, prize information and statements by you about the +competition for publicity, advertising and promotional purposes subject to applicable law and +regulations, all without additional permission or compensation. As a condition of receiving a +prize, winners (or their parents or guardians) may be required to sign and return an affidavit of +eligibility, liability release and publicity release. + + 6. Additional Provisions + +Submissions and Unsolicited Ideas Policies + +Our long-standing company policy does not allow us to accept or consider unsolicited creative +ideas, suggestions or materials. In connection with anything you submit to us – whether or not +solicited by us – you agree that creative ideas, suggestions or other materials you submit are not +being made in confidence or trust and that no confidential or fiduciary relationship is intended or +created between you and us in any way, and that you have no expectation of review, +compensation or consideration of any type. + +Claims of Copyright Infringement + +Notifications of claimed copyright infringement and counter notices must be sent to our +designated agent: + +Lance R. Griffin +The Walt Disney Company +500 South Buena Vista Street +Burbank, California 91521, USA +Phone: +1 818-560-1000 +Fax: +1 818-560-4299 +Email: designated.agent@dig.twdc.com + +We are only able to accept notices in the languages in which these terms are made available by +us. + +We will respond expeditiously to claims of copyright infringement committed using the Disney +Services that are reported to our Designated Copyright Agent, identified above, in accordance +with the U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (“DMCA”) or, as applicable, other +laws. With respect to Disney Services hosted in the United States, these notices must include the +required information set forth in the DMCA and described in detail here. + +7. BINDING ARBITRATION AND CLASS ACTION WAIVER + +PROCEEDINGS TO RESOLVE OR LITIGATE A DISPUTE IN ANY FORUM WILL BE +CONDUCTED ON AN INDIVIDUAL BASIS. Neither you nor Disney DTC will seek to have a +dispute heard as a class action or private attorney general action or in any other proceeding in +which either party acts or proposes to act in a representative capacity. No arbitration or +proceeding can be combined with another without the prior written consent of all parties to the +arbitrations or proceedings. + +You and Disney DTC agree to arbitrate, as provided below, all disputes between you (including +any related disputes involving The Walt Disney Company or its affiliates), that are not resolved +informally, except disputes relating to the ownership or enforcement of intellectual property +rights. “Dispute” includes any dispute, action, or other controversy, whether based on past, + + present, or future events, between you and us concerning the Disney Services or this Agreement, +whether in contract, tort, warranty, statute, regulation, or other legal or equitable basis. You and +Disney DTC empower the arbitrator with the exclusive authority to resolve any dispute relating +to the interpretation, applicability or enforceability of these terms or the formation of this +contract, including the arbitrability of any dispute and any claim that all or any part of this +Agreement are void or voidable. + +A. In the event of a dispute, you or Disney DTC must send to the other party a notice of +dispute, which is a written statement that sets forth the name, address, and contact +information of the party giving the notice, the facts giving rise to the dispute, and the +relief requested. You must send any notice of dispute to Disney DTC, 500 South +Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521-7620, USA, Attention: Legal. We will +send any notice of dispute to you at the contact information we have for you. You and +Disney DTC will attempt to resolve a dispute through informal negotiation within +sixty (60) days from the date the notice of dispute is sent. After that sixty (60) day +period and not before, you or we may commence an arbitration proceeding. You may +instead litigate a dispute in small claims court if the dispute meets the requirements to +be heard in small claims court, whether or not you negotiated informally first. + +B. If you and Disney DTC do not resolve a dispute by informal negotiation or in small +claims court, the dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration before a neutral +arbitrator whose decision will be final except for a limited right of appeal under the +U.S. Federal Arbitration Act. YOU ARE GIVING UP THE RIGHT TO LITIGATE +A DISPUTE IN COURT BEFORE A JUDGE OR JURY. Arbitration will be +administered by JAMS Mediation, Arbitration and ADR Services (“JAMS”) in +accordance with the JAMS Streamlined Arbitration Rules and Procedures (the +“JAMS Rules”). The JAMS Rules and instructions about how to initiate an +arbitration are available at www.jamsadr.com or 1-800-352-5267. Arbitration may be +conducted in person, through the submission of documents, by phone, or online. +Proceedings that cannot be conducted through the submission of documents, by +phone, or online, will take place in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of +Manhattan, New York, New York, whichever is more convenient for you; provided, +however, that if circumstances prevent you from traveling to Los Angeles or New +York, JAMS may hold an in-person hearing in your hometown area. You and Disney +DTC agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal or state courts located +in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of Manhattan, New York, New +York, whichever is more convenient for you, in order to compel arbitration, to stay +proceedings pending arbitration, or to confirm, modify, vacate, or enter judgment on +the award entered by the arbitrator. The arbitrator may award damages to you +individually as a court could, including declaratory or injunctive relief, but only to the +extent required to satisfy your individual claim. + +Except as provided above with respect to jurisdiction in Los Angeles, California and Manhattan, +New York, New York, nothing in this arbitration provision shall be construed as consent by +Disney DTC or its affiliates to the jurisdiction of any other court with regard to disputes, claims +or controversies unrelated to the Disney Services or this Agreement. + + Choice of Forum + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent required under applicable local law which requires that venue be in the +country of your residence, you agree that any action at law or in equity arising out of or relating +to these terms or the Disney Services that is not subject to arbitration shall be filed, and that +venue properly lies, only in the state or federal courts located in the borough of Manhattan, New +York, New York, United States of America and you consent and submit to the personal +jurisdiction of such courts for the purposes of litigating such action. + +Choice of Law + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent that applicable local law requires that the law to be applied for contracts of +this type be that of the country of your residence, these terms are governed by and construed in +accordance with the laws of the State of New York and the laws of the United States, without +giving effect to any conflict of law principles. + +Severability + +If any provision of these terms shall be unlawful, void or for any reason unenforceable, then that +provision shall be deemed severable from these terms and shall not affect the validity and +enforceability of any remaining provisions. + +Survival + +The provisions of these terms which by their nature should survive the termination of these terms +shall survive such termination. + +Waiver + +No waiver of any provision of these terms by us shall be deemed a further or continuing waiver +of such provision or any other provision, and our failure to assert any right or provision under +these terms shall not constitute a waiver of such right or provision. diff --git a/q93/random_k2/random_2.md b/q93/random_k2/random_2.md index 7d30cced73b1f30da245c4cf6780b4baf04ace71..8dd9410dc88edb3e6007de77b19516154383e752 100644 --- a/q93/random_k2/random_2.md +++ b/q93/random_k2/random_2.md @@ -1,553 +1,1670 @@ - GUI DE +Q U I E T C O M F O R T 4 5 -Social Media -Marketing Strategy -Eight easy steps to develop your -social media presence + Please read and keep all safety, security, and use instructions. - Contents +Bose Corporation hereby declares that this product is in compliance with the essential requirements and +other relevant provisions of Directive 2014/53/EU and all other applicable EU directive requirements. The +www.Bose.com/compliance +complete declaration of conformity can be found at: www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 1: Set social media marketing goals that align to business objectives +This product conforms to all applicable Electromagnetic Compatibility Regulations 2016 and all other +applicable UK regulations. The complete declaration of conformity can be found at: +www.Bose.com/compliance +www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 2: Learn everything you can about your audience +Bose Corporation hereby declares that this product is in compliance with the essential requirements per +Radio Equipment Regulations 2017 and all other applicable UK regulations. The complete declaration of +www.Bose.com/compliance +conformity can be found at: www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 3: Research the competition +Important Safety Instructions +Do not use this apparatus near water. -Step 4: Conduct a social media audit +Clean only with a dry cloth. -Step 5: Set up accounts and improve existing profiles +Refer all servicing to qualified personnel. Servicing is required when the apparatus has been damaged in any way, +such as power-supply cord or plug is damaged, liquid has been spilled or objects have fallen into the apparatus, the +apparatus has been exposed to rain or moisture, does not operate normally, or has been dropped. -Step 6: Find inspiration +WARNINGS/CAUTIONS +• Do NOT use the headphones at a high volume for any extended period. -Step 7: Create a social media content calendar + – To avoid hearing damage, use your headphones at a comfortable, moderate volume level. -Step 8: Test, evaluate, and adjust your strategy + – Turn the volume down on your device before placing the headphones in/on your ears, then turn the volume up + +gradually until you reach a comfortable listening level. + +• Do NOT use your headphones while driving for phone calls or any other purpose. + +• Do NOT use the headphones with noise canceling mode at any time the inability to hear surrounding sounds may +present a danger to yourself or others, e.g., while riding a bicycle or walking in or near traffic, a construction site or +railroad, etc., and follow applicable laws regarding headphone use. + – Turn the headphones off, or use the headphones with noise canceling off and adjust your volume, to ensure you + +can hear surrounding sounds, including alarms and warning signals. + + – Be aware of how sounds that you rely on as reminders or warnings may vary in character when using the + + headphones, even with Aware mode. + +• Do NOT use the headphones if they emit any loud unusual noise. If this happens, turn the headphones off and + +contact Bose customer service. + +• Remove headphones immediately if you experience a warming sensation or loss of audio. + +• Do NOT use mobile phone adapters to connect headphones to airplane seat jacks, as this could result in injury or + +property damage due to overheating. + +• Do NOT use the headphones as aviation communication headsets. + +Contains small parts which may be a choking hazard. Not suitable for children under age 3. + +This product contains magnetic material. Consult your physician on whether this might affect your +implantable medical device. + +• To reduce the risk of fire or electrical shock, do NOT expose this product to rain, liquids or moisture. + +• Do NOT expose this product to dripping or splashing, and do not place objects filled with liquids, such as vases, on + +or near the product. + +2 + +| E N G + +IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUCTIONS + IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUC TI ONS + +• Keep the product away from fire and heat sources. Do NOT place naked flame sources, such as lighted candles, on + +or near the product. + +• Use this product only with an agency approved LPS power supply which meets local regulatory requirements + +(e.g., UL, CSA, VDE, CCC). + +• Do NOT make unauthorized alterations to this product. + +• If the battery leaks, do not allow the liquid to come in contact with the skin or eyes. If contact is made, seek + +medical advice. + +• Do not expose products containing batteries to excessive heat (e.g. from storage in direct sunlight, fire or the like). + +• Do NOT wear while charging. 3 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +NOTE: This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits for a Class B digital device, pursuant to +Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful interference in a +residential installation. This equipment generates, uses, and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed +and used in accordance with the instructions, may cause harmful interference to radio communications. However, +there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a particular installation. If this equipment does cause harmful +interference to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning the equipment off and on, the user +is encouraged to try to correct the interference by one or more of the following measures: + +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. + +• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. + +• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. + +Changes or modifications not expressly approved by Bose Corporation could void the user’s authority to operate this +equipment. + +This device complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules and with ISED Canada license-exempt RSS standard(s). Operation +is subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must +accept any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. + +This device complies with FCC and ISED Canada radiation exposure limits set forth for general population. This + transmitter must not be co-located or operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter. + +Meets IMDA Requirements. + +FCC ID: A94437310 + +IC: 3232A-437310 + +CAN ICES-3(B)/NMB-3(B) + +For Europe: + +Frequency band of operation 2400 to 2483.5 MHz. + +Maximum transmit power less than 20 dBm EIRP. + +This symbol means the product must not be discarded as household waste, and should be delivered to an +appropriate collection facility for recycling. Proper disposal and recycling helps protect natural resources, +human health and the environment. For more information on disposal and recycling of this product, contact +your local municipality, disposal service, or the shop where you bought this product. + +Management Regulation for Low-power Radio-frequency Devices +Article XII +According to “Management Regulation for Low-power Radio-frequency Devices” without permission granted by +the NCC, any company, enterprise, or user is not allowed to change frequency, enhance transmitting power or alter +original characteristic as well as performance to an approved low power radio-frequency devices. + +Article XIV +The low power radio-frequency devices shall not influence aircraft security and interfere legal communications; If +found, the user shall cease operating immediately until no interference is achieved. The said legal communications +means radio communications operated in compliance with the Telecommunications Act. + +The low power radio-frequency devices must be susceptible with the interference from legal communications or ISM +radio wave radiated devices. + +DON’T attempt to remove the rechargeable lithium-ion battery from this product. Contact your local Bose retailer or +other qualified professional for removal. + +Removal of the rechargeable lithium-ion battery in this product should be conducted only by a qualified professional. +Please contact your local Bose retailer or see products.bose.com/static/compliance/index.html +further information. + +products.bose.com/static/compliance/index.html for + 4 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +Please dispose of used batteries properly, following local regulations. Do not incinerate. + +Names and Contents of Toxic or Hazardous Substances or Elements + +Toxic or Hazardous Substances and Elements + +Part Name + +PCBs + +Metal Parts + +Plastic Parts + +Speaker + +Cables + +Lead +(Pb) + +Mercury +(Hg) + +Cadmium +(Cd) + +Hexavalent +(CR(VI)) + +X + +X + +O + +X + +X + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +Polybrominated +Biphenyl +(PBB) +O + +Polybrominated +diphenylether +(PBDE) +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +This table is prepared in accordance with the provisions of SJ/T 11364. +O: Indicates that this toxic or hazardous substance contained in all of the homogeneous materials for this + +part is below the limit requirement of GB/T 26572. + +X: Indicates that this toxic or hazardous substance contained in at least one of the homogeneous materials + +used for this part is above the limit requirement of GB/T 26572. + +Date of Manufacture: The eighth digit in the serial number indicates the year of manufacture; “1” is 2011 or 2021. + +China Importer: Bose Electronics (Shanghai) Company Limited, Part C, Plant 9, No. 353 North Riying Road, China +(Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone + +EU Importer: Bose Products B.V., Gorslaan 60, 1441 RG Purmerend, The Netherlands + +Taiwan Importer: Bose Taiwan Branch, 9F-A1, No. 10, Section 3, Minsheng East Road, Taipei City 104, Taiwan Phone +Number: +886-2-2514 7676 + +Mexico Importer: Bose de México, S. de R.L. de C.V., Paseo de las Palmas 405-204, Lomas de Chapultepec, 11000 +México, D.F. Phone Number: +5255 (5202) 3545 + +UK Importer: Bose Limited, Bose House, Quayside Chatham Maritime, Chatham, Kent, ME4 4QZ, United Kingdom +Input Rating: 5V p 0.5A +Charging Temperature Range: 32° F to 113° F (0° C to 45° C) + +Discharging Temperature Range: -4° F to 140° F (-20° C to 60° C) + +Model 437310. The CMIIT ID is located inside the earcup under the scrim. + +Please complete and retain for your records +The serial and model numbers are located inside the earcup under the scrim. + +Serial number: __________________________________ + +Model number: __________________________________ + +Please keep your receipt with your owner’s guide. Now is a good time to register your Bose product. You can easily +global.Bose.com/register +do this by going to global.Bose.com/register + 5 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +Security Information + + This product is capable of receiving security updates from Bose automatically when connected to the Bose +Music app. In order to receive security updates via the mobile application, you must complete the product +setup process in the Bose Music app. If you do not complete the setup process, you will be responsible +for installing security updates that Bose makes available via btu.Bose.com +btu.Bose.com + +Apple, the Apple logo, iPad, iPhone, and iPod are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries. +App Store is a service mark of Apple Inc. The trademark “iPhone” is used in Japan with a license from Aiphone K.K. + +Use of the Made for Apple badge means that an accessory has been designed to connect specifically to the Apple + product(s) identified in the badge, and has been certified by the developer to meet Apple performance standards. +Apple is not responsible for the operation of this device or its compliance with safety and regulatory standards. + +The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such +marks by Bose Corporation is under license. + +Google Play is a trademark of Google LLC. + +USB Type-C® and USB-C® are registered trademarks of USB Implementers Forum. + +Bose, Bose Home Speaker, Bose Music, the Bose Music logo, Bose Smart Soundbar, Bose Smart Speaker, +Bose Soundbar, QuietComfort, and SimpleSync are trademarks of Bose Corporation. + +Bose Corporation Headquarters: 1-877-230-5639 + +©2021 Bose Corporation. No part of this work may be reproduced, modified, distributed, or otherwise used without +prior written permission. + 6 +| E N G + +REGULATORY INFORMATION + LICENSE DISCLOSURES + +The following license disclosures apply to certain third-party software packages used as components in the product. + +Package: FreeRTOS + +Copyright © Amazon Web Services, Inc. or its affiliates. All rights reserved. + +The FreeRTOS package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +MIT License + +Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated + documentation files (the “Software”), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the +rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit +persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: + +The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of +the Software. + +THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS IS”, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING +BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND + NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, +DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT +OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. + +Package: Nanopb + +Copyright © 2011 Petteri Aimonen . + +The Nanopb package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +Zlib License + +© 2011 Petteri Aimonen + +This software is provided ‘as-is’, without any express or implied warranty. In no event will the authors be held liable +for any damages arising from the use of this software. + +Permission is granted to anyone to use this software for any purpose, including commercial applications, and to alter +it and redistribute it freely, subject to the following restrictions: + +1. + + The origin of this software must not be misrepresented; you must not claim that you wrote the original software. +If you use this software in a product, an acknowledgment in the product documentation would be appreciated +but is not required. + +2. + + Altered source versions must be plainly marked as such, and must not be misrepresented as being the +original software. + +3. This notice may not be removed or altered from any source distribution. + +Package: Mbed TLS 2.16.1 + +© ARM Limited. All rights reserved. + +The Mbed TLS package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +Apache License + +Version 2.0, January 2004 + +http://www.apache.org/licenses/ +http://www.apache.org/licenses/ + +TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR USE, REPRODUCTION, AND DISTRIBUTION + +1. Definitions. + +“License” shall mean the terms and conditions for use, reproduction, and distribution as defined by Sections 1 +through 9 of this document. + 7 -8 +| E N G + + LICENSE DISCLOSURES + +“Licensor” shall mean the copyright owner or entity authorized by the copyright owner that is granting +the License. + +“Legal Entity” shall mean the union of the acting entity and all other entities that control, are controlled by, or +are under common control with that entity. For the purposes of this definition, “control” means (i) the power, +direct or indirect, to cause the direction or management of such entity, whether by contract or otherwise, or (ii) +ownership of fifty percent (50%) or more of the outstanding shares, or (iii) beneficial ownership of such entity. + +“You” (or “Your”) shall mean an individual or Legal Entity exercising permissions granted by this License. + +“Source” form shall mean the preferred form for making modifications, including but not limited to software +source code, documentation source, and configuration files. + +“Object” form shall mean any form resulting from mechanical transformation or translation of a Source form, +including but not limited to compiled object code, generated documentation, and conversions to other +media types. + +“Work” shall mean the work of authorship, whether in Source or Object form, made available under the License, +as indicated by a copyright notice that is included in or attached to the work (an example is provided in the +Appendix below). + +“Derivative Works” shall mean any work, whether in Source or Object form, that is based on (or derived from) +the Work and for which the editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications represent, as a +whole, an original work of authorship. For the purposes of this License, Derivative Works shall not include works +that remain separable from, or merely link (or bind by name) to the interfaces of, the Work and Derivative +Works thereof. + +“Contribution” shall mean any work of authorship, including the original version of the Work and any + modifications or additions to that Work or Derivative Works thereof, that is intentionally submitted to Licensor +for inclusion in the Work by the copyright owner or by an individual or Legal Entity authorized to submit on +behalf of the copyright owner. For the purposes of this definition, “submitted” means any form of electronic, +verbal, or written communication sent to the Licensor or its representatives, including but not limited to +communication on electronic mailing lists, source code control systems, and issue tracking systems that are +managed by, or on behalf of, the Licensor for the purpose of discussing and improving the Work, but excluding +communication that is conspicuously marked or otherwise designated in writing by the copyright owner as “Not +a Contribution.” + +“Contributor” shall mean Licensor and any individual or Legal Entity on behalf of whom a Contribution has been +received by Licensor and subsequently incorporated within the Work. + +2. + +3. + + Grant of Copyright License. Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants +to You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable copyright license to reproduce, +prepare Derivative Works of, publicly display, publicly perform, sublicense, and distribute the Work and such +Derivative Works in Source or Object form. + + Grant of Patent License. Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants to +You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable (except as stated in this section) +patent license to make, have made, use, offer to sell, sell, import, and otherwise transfer the Work, where such +license applies only to those patent claims licensable by such Contributor that are necessarily infringed by their +Contribution(s) alone or by combination of their Contribution(s) with the Work to which such Contribution(s) +was submitted. If You institute patent litigation against any entity (including a cross-claim or counterclaim in a +lawsuit) alleging that the Work or a Contribution incorporated within the Work constitutes direct or contributory +patent infringement, then any patent licenses granted to You under this License for that Work shall terminate as +of the date such litigation is filed. + +4. + + Redistribution. You may reproduce and distribute copies of the Work or Derivative Works thereof in any medium, +with or without modifications, and in Source or Object form, provided that You meet the following conditions: + +a. You must give any other recipients of the Work or Derivative Works a copy of this License; and +b. You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices stating that You changed the files; and +c. You must retain, in the Source form of any Derivative Works that You distribute, all copyright, patent, + + trademark, and attribution notices from the Source form of the Work, excluding those notices that do not +pertain to any part of the Derivative Works; and 8 -10 +| E N G -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy + LICENSE DISCLOSURES -#239584107 +d. If the Work includes a “NOTICE” text file as part of its distribution, then any Derivative Works that You -2 + distribute must include a readable copy of the attribution notices contained within such NOTICE file, excluding +those notices that do not pertain to any part of the Derivative Works, in at least one of the following places: +within a NOTICE text file distributed as part of the Derivative Works; within the Source form or documentation, +if provided along with the Derivative Works; or, within a display generated by the Derivative Works, if and +wherever such third-party notices normally appear. The contents of the NOTICE file are for informational +purposes only and do not modify the License. You may add Your own attribution notices within Derivative +Works that You distribute, alongside or as an addendum to the NOTICE text from the Work, provided that such +additional attribution notices cannot be construed as modifying the License. +You may add Your own copyright statement to Your modifications and may provide additional or different +license terms and conditions for use, reproduction, or distribution of Your modifications, or for any such + Derivative Works as a whole, provided Your use, reproduction, and distribution of the Work otherwise + complies with the conditions stated in this License. - Related resource + Submission of Contributions. Unless You explicitly state otherwise, any Contribution intentionally submitted for +inclusion in the Work by You to the Licensor shall be under the terms and conditions of this License, without any +additional terms or conditions. Notwithstanding the above, nothing herein shall supersede or modify the terms +of any separate license agreement you may have executed with Licensor regarding such Contributions. -The Social Media Metrics -that Really Matter—and -How to Track Them + Trademarks. This License does not grant permission to use the trade names, trademarks, service marks, or +product names of the Licensor, except as required for reasonable and customary use in describing the origin of +the Work and reproducing the content of the NOTICE file. -Step 1 + Disclaimer of Warranty. Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, Licensor provides the Work +(and each Contributor provides its Contributions) on an “AS IS” BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS +OF ANY KIND, either express or implied, including, without limitation, any warranties or conditions of TITLE, +NON-INFRINGEMENT, MERCHANTABILITY, or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. You are solely responsible +for determining the appropriateness of using or redistributing the Work and assume any risks associated with +Your exercise of permissions under this License. -Set social media marketing goals that align to -business objectives + Limitation of Liability. In no event and under no legal theory, whether in tort (including negligence), contract, +or otherwise, unless required by applicable law (such as deliberate and grossly negligent acts) or agreed to in +writing, shall any Contributor be liable to You for damages, including any direct, indirect, special, incidental, +or consequential damages of any character arising as a result of this License or out of the use or inability to +use the Work (including but not limited to damages for loss of goodwill, work stoppage, computer failure or +malfunction, or any and all other commercial damages or losses), even if such Contributor has been advised of +the possibility of such damages. -The more specific your strategy is, the more effective the execution will be. -Set SMART goals and track the right metrics to set yourself up for success. + Accepting Warranty or Additional Liability. While redistributing the Work or Derivative Works thereof, You may +choose to offer, and charge a fee for, acceptance of support, warranty, indemnity, or other liability obligations +and/or rights consistent with this License. However, in accepting such obligations, You may act only on Your own +behalf and on Your sole responsibility, not on behalf of any other Contributor, and only if You agree to indemnify, +defend, and hold each Contributor harmless for any liability incurred by, or claims asserted against, such + Contributor by reason of your accepting any such warranty or additional liability. -Set SMART goals +5. -The first step to creating a social media marketing strategy is to establish -your objectives and goals. Without goals, you have no way to measure your -success or your social media return on investment (ROI). +6. -Each of your goals should be: +7. -Specific +8. -Measurable +9. -Attainable +END OF TERMS AND CONDITIONS -Relevant +©2021 Bose Corporation -Time-bound +Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the “License”); you may not use this file except in compliance with +the License. -An example of a SMART goal for your business might be "Grow our Instagram -audience by 50 new followers per week." +You may obtain a copy of the License at: http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 -With SMART goals, you’ll make sure your goals actually lead to real business -results, rather than just lofty ideals. +Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an +“AS IS” BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License. -3 +9 + +| E N G + + WHAT’S IN THE BOX + +Contents ............................................................................................................................. 13 + +BOSE MUSIC APP + +Download the Bose Music app .................................................................................. 14 + +Add the headphones to an existing account ....................................................... 14 + +HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Power on ............................................................................................................................ 16 + +Standby timer .......................................................................................................... 16 + +Power off ............................................................................................................................ 17 + +Headphone functions .................................................................................................... 18 + +Media playback and volume ............................................................................... 18 + +Phone calls ................................................................................................................ 19 + +Action button ........................................................................................................... 20 + +NOISE CANCELLATION + +Noise cancelling modes................................................................................................ 21 + +Change the noise cancelling mode .......................................................................... 21 + +VOICE CONTROL + +Access voice control ...................................................................................................... 22 + +BLUETOOTH® CONNECTIONS + +Connect using the Bluetooth menu on your mobile device .......................... 23 + +Disconnect a mobile device ........................................................................................ 25 + +Reconnect a mobile device ......................................................................................... 25 + +Connect another mobile device ................................................................................ 25 + +Identify connected mobile devices .......................................................................... 25 + +Switch between two connected mobile devices ................................................ 25 + +Reconnect a previously connected device ........................................................... 26 + +Clear the headphone device list................................................................................ 26 + +1 0 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + WIRED CONNECTIONS + +Connect the audio cable .............................................................................................. 27 + +BATTERY + +Charge the headphones ............................................................................................... 28 + +Charging time........................................................................................................... 28 + +Hear the battery level ........................................................................................... 28 + +HEADPHONE STATUS + +Bluetooth status ............................................................................................................. 29 + +Battery status .................................................................................................................. 29 + +Charging status .............................................................................................................. 30 + +Update and error status .............................................................................................. 30 + +CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS + +Connect a Bose Smart Speaker or Soundbar ...................................................... 31 + +Benefits ....................................................................................................................... 31 + +Compatible products ............................................................................................ 31 + +Connect using the Bose Music app ................................................................. 31 + +Reconnect to a Bose Smart Speaker or Soundbar ............................................ 32 + +CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +Store the headphones ................................................................................................... 33 + +Clean the headphones .................................................................................................. 34 + +Replacement parts and accessories ........................................................................ 34 + +Limited warranty ............................................................................................................. 34 + +Serial number location .................................................................................................. 35 + +1 1 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + TROUBLESHOOTING + +Try these solutions first ................................................................................................ 36 + +Other solutions ................................................................................................................ 36 + +Restore the headphones to factory settings ....................................................... 39 + +1 2 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + WHAT ’S IN THE BOX + +CONTENTS + +Confirm that the following parts are included: + +Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones + +Carry case + +USB Type-C® cable + +3.5 mm to 2.5 mm audio cable + +NOTE: If any part of your product is damaged, do not use it. Contact your authorized + +Bose dealer or Bose customer service. + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 - Track meaningful metrics +1 3 -While vanity metrics like retweets and likes can be fun to share and easy to -track, it’s hard to prove their real value for your business. Instead, focus on -targets such as leads generated, web referrals, and conversion rate. +| E N G -You may want to track different goals for different channels, or even different uses -of each channel. For example, you can use paid campaigns to increase brand - awareness, but measure acquisition and engagement for organic social posts. + BOSE MUSIC APP -Make sure to align your social media goals with your overall marketing -strategy. This will make it easier for you to show the value of your work and -get executive buy-in and investment. +The Bose Music app lets you set up and control the headphones from any mobile +device, such as a smartphone or tablet. -Start developing your social media marketing plan by writing down at least -three social media goals. +Using the app, you can manage Bluetooth connections, manage headphone settings, +choose your voice prompt language, and access new features through updates. -Goals +NOTE: If you’ve already created a Bose Music account for another Bose product, add +the headphones to your existing account (see the bottom of page 14). + +DOWNLOAD THE BOSE MUSIC APP + +1. On your mobile device, download the Bose Music app. + +B O S E M U S I C + +2. Follow the app instructions. + +ADD THE HEADPHONES TO AN EXISTING ACCOUNT + +To add your Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones, open the Bose Music app and add +your headphones. + +1 4 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Action button + +Multi-function button + +Power/Bluetooth +switch + +Volume up + +Volume down + +2.5 mm audio cable port + +USB-C® port + +1 5 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +POWER ON + +On the right earcup, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right. + +A voice prompt announces the battery level, and the status light glows according to +the current charge level (see page 29). + +Standby timer +The standby timer conserves the battery when the headphones are not being used. + +To set up and customize the standby timer, use the Bose Music app. + +1 6 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +POWER OFF + +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the left. + +NOTE: When the headphones are powered off, noise cancellation is disabled. + +1 7 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +HEADPHONE FUNCTIONS + +The headphone controls are located on the back of the right earcup. + +Media playback and volume + +Volume up + +Multi-function button +Volume down + +FUNCTION + +Play/Pause + +WHAT TO DO + +Press the Multi-function button. + +Skip forward + +Double-press the Multi-function button. + +Skip backward + +Triple-press the Multi-function button. + +Volume up + +Volume down + +NOTES: + +Press H. + +Press z. + +• To quickly increase the volume, press and hold H. +• To quickly decrease the volume, press and hold z. + +1 8 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Phone calls +The Multi-function button is located on the back of the right earcup. The microphone +is located near the front of the right earcup. + +The Action button is located on the back of the left earcup. + +Action button + +Multi-function button + +Microphone + +FUNCTION + +WHAT TO DO + +Answer/End a call + +Press the Multi-function button. + +Decline an incoming call + +Press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +Answer a second incoming +call and put the current call +on hold + +While on a call and a second incoming call is ringing, +press the Multi-function button. + +Decline a second incoming call +and stay on current call + +While on a call and a second incoming call is ringing, +press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +Switch between two calls + +While two calls are active, double-press the +Multi-function button. + +Create a conference call + +While two calls are active, press and hold the +Multi-function button for 3 seconds. + +Mute/Unmute a call + +While on a call, double-press the Action button. + +1 9 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Action button +The Action button allows you to quickly and easily switch between noise +cancelling modes. + +The Action button is located on the back of the left earcup. + +Action button + +To switch between Quiet Mode and Aware Mode, press the Action button. + +For information about noise cancelling modes, see page 21. + +2 0 + +| E N G + + NOISE CANCELLATION + +Noise cancelling reduces unwanted noise, providing a clearer and more lifelike audio +performance. You can choose between two noise cancelling modes: Quiet and Aware. + +Quiet Mode allows you to block out distractions using the highest level of +noise cancellation. + +Aware Mode provides full transparency and allows you to hear your surroundings +while enjoying your audio. + +Choose your noise noise cancelling mode based on your listening preferences +and environment. + +NOISE CANCELLING MODES + +MODE + +Quiet + +Aware + +DESCRIPTION + +World-class noise cancellation with Bose-optimized audio. + +Hear your surroundings while enjoying your audio. + +NOTE: When powered on, the headphones default to the last mode you used. + +CHANGE THE NOISE CANCELLING MODE + +To change the noise cancelling mode, press the Action button. + +A voice prompt announces the selected noise cancelling mode. + +TIP: You can also change the noise cancelling mode using the Bose Music app. + +2 1 + +| E N G + + VOICE CONTROL + +ACCESS VOICE CONTROL + +You can use the headphones to access voice control on your mobile device. To access +voice control, press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +The Multi-function button is located on the back of the right earcup. + +NOTE: You can’t access voice control while on a call. + +2 2 + +| E N G + + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS + +CONNECT USING THE BLUETOOTH MENU ON YOUR + MOBILE DEVICE + +You can store up to eight devices in the headphone device list, and the headphones +can be actively connected to two devices at a time. You can play audio from only one +device at a time. + +NOTE: For the best experience, use the Bose Music app to set up and connect your + +mobile device (see page 14). 1. -2. + Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for 3 seconds. -3. +You hear “Ready to connect,” and the status light blinks blue. -Step 2 +2 3 -Related resource +| E N G -How to build audience -personas + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Learn everything you can about your audience +2. On your device, enable the Bluetooth feature. -if you’re not engaged in social media listening, you’re creating your business -strategy with blinders on—and you’re missing out on mountains of actionable -insights from real people who are actively talking about you or your industry online. +NOTE: The Bluetooth feature is usually found in the Settings menu. -Here’s how to start listening and building your understanding of your -audience and their needs. +3. Select your headphones from the device list. -Create audience personas +TIP: Look for the name you entered for your headphones in the Bose Music app. -tKnowing who your audience is and what they want to see on social is key to -creating content that they will like, comment on, and share. This knowledge -also critical for planning how to develop your social media fans into -customers for your business. +If you didn’t name your headphones, the default name appears. -Try creating audience personas. For example, a retail brand might create -different personas based on demographics, buying motivations, common -buying objections, and the emotional needs of each type of customer. +QuietComfort 45 -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Once connected, you hear “Connected to ,” and the status light +glows solid blue for 10 seconds. -4 +2 4 - Personas sharpen your marketing tactics. Luxury buyers, for example, -might not respond to Facebook ads with sales. But they might respond to -Facebook ads with exclusive in-store events to be the first to see a new line of -clothing. With personas, you’ll have the customer insights you need to create -campaigns that speak to the real desires and motivations of your buyers. +| E N G -Gather real-world data + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Don’t make assumptions. Social media analytics can also provide a ton of -valuable information about who your followers are, where they live, which -languages they speak, and how they interact with your brand on social. These -insights allow you to refine your strategy and better target your social ads. +DISCONNECT A MOBILE DEVICE -Jugnoo, an Uber-like service for auto-rickshaws in India, used Facebook -Analytics to learn that 90 percent of their users who referred other -customers were between 18 and 34 years old, and that 65 percent of that -group was using Android. They used this information to target their ads, -resulting in a 40 percent lower cost per referral. +Use the Bose Music app to disconnect your mobile device. -Step 3 +TIP: You can also use Bluetooth settings to disconnect your device. Disabling the -Research the competition +Bluetooth feature disconnects all other devices. -Odds are, your competitors are already using social media—and that means -you can learn from what they’re already doing. +RECONNECT A MOBILE DEVICE -Conduct a competitive analysis +When powered on, the headphones try to reconnect with the two most + recently-connected devices. -A competitive analysis allows you to understand who the competition is and -what they’re doing well (and not so well). You’ll get a good sense of what’s -expected in your industry, which will help you set some social media targets -of your own. +NOTES: -This analysis will also help you spot opportunities. For example, maybe -one of your competitors dominates on Facebook, but has put little effort -into Twitter or Instagram. You might want to focus on the networks where -your audience is underserved, rather than trying to win fans away from a -dominant player. +• The device must be within range (30 ft or 9 m) and powered on. -Engage in social listening +• Make sure the Bluetooth feature is enabled on your mobile device. -Social listening is another way to keep track of the competition. +CONNECT ANOTHER MOBILE DEVICE -As you track your competitors’ accounts and relevant industry keywords, you -may notice strategic shifts in the way competitors use their social accounts. -Or you might spot a specific post or campaign that really hits the mark—or -one that bombs. +To connect another device, download the Bose Music app (see page 14) or use the +Bluetooth menu on your mobile device (see page 23). -Keep an eye on this information and use to it evaluate your own goals and plans. +NOTE: You can only play audio from one device at a time. -Related resources +IDENTIFY CONNECTED MOBILE DEVICES +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release to hear which device is + currently connected. -How to conduct a -competitor audit +SWITCH BETWEEN TWO CONNECTED +MOBILE DEVICES -Getting started with -social listening +1. Pause audio on your first mobile device. -Watch: How to set up -social listening streams +2. Play audio on your second mobile device. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +NOTE: Your headphones receive phone calls from both devices, regardless of -5 +which device is playing audio. - Related resource +2 5 -Hootsuite’s social media -audit template +| E N G -Step 4 + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Conduct a social media audit +RECONNECT A PREVIOUSLY CONNECTED DEVICE -Conducting a social media audit helps you assess how well your current -social media use works for you. +1. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release to hear which device -Evaluate your current efforts +is connected. -If you’re already using social media tools, you need to take a step back and look -at what you’ve already accomplished. Ask yourself the following questions: +2. Within 2 seconds, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release -•• What’s working? +again to connect to the next device in the headphone device list. -•• What’s not working? +3. Repeat until you hear the correct device name. -•• Who’s connecting with you on social? +You hear a tone that indicates when the device is connected. -•• Which social media sites does your target market use? +4. Play audio on the connected mobile device. -•• How does your social media presence compare to that of your competitors? +NOTE: If two devices are already connected to the headphones, the newly-connected -Once you gather all this information in one place, you’ll have a good starting -point for planning how to improve your results. +device replaces the second device that was previously connected. -Your audit should give you a clear picture of what purpose each of your -social accounts serves. If the purpose of an account isn’t clear, think about -whether it’s worth keeping. It may be a valuable account that just needs -a strategic redirection, or it may be an outdated account that’s no longer -worth your while. +CLEAR THE HEADPHONE DEVICE LIST -To help you decide, ask yourself the following questions: +1. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for 15 seconds, until you -1. Is my audience here? +hear “Bluetooth device list cleared. Ready to connect.” -2. If so, how are they using this platform? +2. Delete your headphones from the Bluetooth list on your mobile device. -3. Can I use this account to help achieve meaningful business goals? +All devices are cleared and the headphones are ready to connect. -Asking these tough questions now will help keep your social media strategy -on track as you grow your social presence. +2 6 -Look for impostor accounts +| E N G -During your audit process, you may discover fraudulent accounts using your -business name or the names of your products—that is, accounts that you -and your business don’t own. + WIRED CONNECTIONS -These imposter accounts can be harmful to your brand (never mind -capturing followers that should be yours), so be sure to report them. You -may want to get your social accounts verified to ensure your fans and -followers know they are dealing with the real you. +CONNECT THE AUDIO CABLE -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Use the 2.5 mm to 3.5 mm cable to connect a non-wireless device or to continue using +the headphones if the battery is depleted. -6 +1. Connect the cable into the 2.5 mm port on the left earcup. - Related resources +2. Connect the other end of the cable into the 3.5 mm port on your device. -Watch: How to optimize -your social profiles +NOTE: You can use the headphones powered on or off when the the audio cable -We’ve also got step-by-step -guides for each network -to walk you through the -process: +is connected. -Create a Facebook -business page +2 7 -Create an Instagram -business account +| E N G -Create a Twitter business -account + BATTERY -Create a Snapchat -account +CHARGE THE HEADPHONES -Create a LinkedIn -Company Page +1. Connect the small end of the USB cable into the USB-C port on the -Create a Pinterest -business account +right earcup. -Create a YouTube channel +2. Connect the other end into a USB wall charger. -Create a WeChat business -account +NOTES: -Don’t let this list overwhelm -you. Remember, it’s better to -use fewer channels well than -to stretch yourself thin trying -to maintain a presence on -every social network. +• When the headphones begin charging, the status light blinks white for 10 seconds. -Finally, here’s a quick -reference guide for image -sizes for every network. +When fully charged, the status light glows solid white. -Step 5 +• The headphones don’t play while charging. -Set up accounts and improve existing profiles +Charging time +Allow up to 2.5 hours to fully charge the headphones. -Decide which networks you’ll focus on, and then set up and optimize your -accounts. +Hear the battery level +Each time you power on the headphones, a voice prompt announces the battery level. +When the headphone battery is low, you hear “Battery low, please charge now.” -Determine which networks to use (and how to use them) +NOTE: To visually check the battery, see the status light l ocated on the right earcup. -As you decide which social channels to use, you’ll also need to define your -strategy for each network. For example, you might decide to use Twitter for -customer service, Facebook for customer acquisition, and Instagram for -engaging existing customers. +For more information, see “Battery status” on page 29. -It’s a good exercise to create mission statements for each network. These -one-sentence declarations will help you focus on a very specific goal for -each account on each social network. +2 8 -For example, you could decide that: +| E N G -•• Facebook is best for acquiring new customers via paid advertising. + HEADPHONE STATUS -•• +The status light is located on the right earcup. -Instagram is where you build brand affinity with existing customers. + Headphone +status light -•• Twitter is where you engage press and industry influencers. +BLUETOOTH STATUS -•• LinkedIn is where you engage existing employees and attract new talent. +Shows the Bluetooth connection status. -•• YouTube is where you support existing customers with education and +LIGHT ACTIVITY -video help content. +SYSTEM STATE -•• Snapchat is where you distribute content with the goal of building brand +Blinking blue -awareness with younger consumers. +Ready to connect -If you can’t create a solid mission statement for a particular social network, -you may want to reconsider whether that network is worth it. +Solid blue (10 seconds) -Set up (and optimize) your accounts +Connected -Once you’ve decided which networks to focus on, it’s time to create your -profiles—or improve existing profiles so they align with your strategic plan. +BATTERY STATUS -In general, make sure you fill out all profile fields, use keywords people will -use to search for your business, and use images that are correctly sized for -each network. +Shows the battery level. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +LIGHT ACTIVITY -7 +SYSTEM STATE - Step 6 +Solid white -Find inspiration +Solid amber -While it’s important that your brand be distinctive and unique, you can still -draw inspiration from other businesses that are great on social. +Medium to full charge -Social network success stories +Low charge -All of the social networks feature success stories that highlight how brands -are using their tools effectively. You can usually find these on the business -section of the social network’s website. (For example, take a look at the -Facebook business success stories.) These case studies offer valuable -insights you can apply to your own goals for each social network. +TIP: You can also check the battery level using the Bose Music app. -Award-winning accounts and campaigns +2 9 -For examples of brands that are at the top of their social media game, check -out the winners of The Facebook Awards or The Shorty Awards. +| E N G -Step 7 + HEADPHONE STATUS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Create a social media content calendar +CHARGING STATUS -Sharing great content is essential, of course, but it’s equally important to have -a plan in place for when you’ll share content to get the maximum impact. +Shows the charging status. -Your social media content calendar also needs to account for the time you’ll -spend interacting with your audience (although you need to allow for some -spontaneous engagement as well). +LIGHT ACTIVITY -Create a posting schedule +Blinks white 2 times -Your social media content calendar lists the dates and times at which you will -publish types of content on each channel. It’s the perfect place to plan all of your -social media activities—from images and link sharing to blog posts and videos. +Solid amber -Your calendar ensures your posts are spaced out appropriately and -published at the optimal times. It should include both your day-to-day posts -and your content for social media campaigns. +Solid white -Related resources +SYSTEM STATE -How to create a social -media content calendar +Charging begins -Watch: How to save time -with bulk scheduling +Charging -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Full charge -8 +UPDATE AND ERROR STATUS - Plot your content mix +Shows the update or error status. -Make sure your calendar reflects the mission statement you’ve assigned to -each social profile, so that everything you post is working to support your -business goals. For example, you might decide that: +LIGHT ACTIVITY -•• 50 percent of content will drive traffic back to your blog +SYSTEM STATE -•• 25 percent of content will be curated from other sources +Fast blinking white (10 seconds) -•• 20 percent of content will support enterprise goals (selling, lead +Updating software (via USB) -generation, and so on) +Slow blinking white (30 to 60 seconds) -•• 5 percent of content will be about your employees and company culture +Updating software (wirelessly) -Placing these different post types in your content calendar will help ensure -you maintain the ratio you’ve planned. If you’re starting from scratch and -you’re simply not sure what types of content to post, try the 80-20 rule: +Blinking amber and white -•• 80 percent of your posts should inform, educate, or entertain your audience +Error - contact Bose customer service -•• 20 percent can directly promote your brand +3 0 -You could also try the social media rule of thirds: +| E N G -•• One-third of your social content promotes your business, converts + CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS -readers, and generates profit +CONNECT A BOSE SMART SPEAKER OR SOUNDBAR -•• One-third of your social content shares ideas and stories from thought +Using SimpleSync™ technology, you can connect the headphones to a Bose Smart + Soundbar or Bose Smart Speaker for a personal listening experience. -leaders in your industry or like-minded businesses +Benefits +• Use independent volume controls on each product to lower or mute your Bose -•• One-third of your social content involves personal interactions with your +Smart Soundbar while keeping the headphones as loud as you like. -audience +• Hear your music clearly from the next room by connecting the headphones to your -Once you have your calendar set, use scheduling tools or bulk scheduling to -prepare your posting in advance rather than updating constantly throughout -the day. This allows you to focus on crafting the language and format of your -posts, rather than writing them on the fly whenever you have time. +Bose Smart Speaker. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +NOTE: SimpleSync™ technology has a Bluetooth range of up to 30 ft (9 m). Walls and -9 + construction materials can affect reception. + +Compatible products +You can connect the headphones to any Bose Smart Speaker or Bose Smart Soundbar. + +Popular compatible products include: + +• Bose Smart Soundbar 700/Bose Soundbar 700 + +• Bose Soundbar 500 + +• Bose Smart Speaker 500/Bose Home Speaker 500 + +• Bose Home Speaker 300 + +• Bose Portable Smart Speaker/Bose Portable Home Speaker + +New products are added periodically. For a complete list and more information, +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups +visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups + +Connect using the Bose Music app + +1. On the headphones, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for + +3 seconds. + +You hear “Ready to connect another device,” and the status light blinks blue. + +2. Use the Bose Music app to connect the headphones to a compatible Bose product. + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups +For more information, visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups + +NOTES: + +• Make sure that the headphones are within 30 ft (9 m) of your soundbar or speaker. + +• You can connect the headphones to only one product at a time. + +3 1 + +| E N G + + CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS + +RECONNECT TO A BOSE SMART SPEAKER +OR SOUNDBAR + +Power on the headphones (see “Power on” on page 16). + +The headphones try to connect to the two most recently-connected Bluetooth + devices, including your soundbar or speaker. + +NOTES: + +• Your soundbar or speaker must be within range (30 ft or 9 m) and powered on. + +• If the headphones don’t reconnect, see “Headphones don’t reconnect to a + + previously-connected Bose Smart Soundbar or Speaker” on page 38. + +3 2 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +STORE THE HEADPHONES + +The earcups rotate for easy, convenient storage. Place the headphones flat into +the case. + +1. Rotate both earcups inward so they lay flat. + +Left earcup + +Right earcup + +2. Fold the left earcup up toward the headband. + +NOTES: + +• Make sure to power off the headphones when not in use. + +• Before storing the headphones for more than a few months, make sure the battery + +is fully charged. + +3 3 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +CLEAN THE HEADPHONES + +Wipe the outside surfaces with a soft, dry cloth. + +Don’t allow moisture to get inside the earcups. + +REPLACEMENT PARTS AND ACCESSORIES + +Replacement parts and accessories can be ordered through Bose customer service. +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 + +LIMITED WARRANTY + +Your headphones are covered by a limited warranty. Visit our website at +global.Bose.com/warranty for details of the limited warranty. +global.Bose.com/warranty + +To register your product, visit global.Bose.com/register + register will not affect your limited warranty rights. + +global.Bose.com/register for instructions. Failure to + +3 4 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +SERIAL NUMBER LOCATION + +The serial number is located inside the right earcup under the scrim. The scrim is the +inner screen that covers and protects the components inside the earcup. + +To view the serial number, grab the scrim at the top edge and gently peel it away. + +CAUTION: Be careful not to press down on or remove any other components inside + +the earcup as this could damage the headphones. + +S/N: 011001000100010AE + +S +/ + +N: 0 + +1 +1 +0 +0 +1 +0 +0 +0 +1 +0 +0 +0 +1 +0 +A +E + +Scrim + +3 5 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +TRY THESE SOLUTIONS FIRST + +If you experience problems with your headphones: + +• Check the state of the status light (see page 29). + +• Charge the battery (see page 28). + +• Increase the volume on your headphones, mobile device, and music app. + +• Try connecting another mobile device (see page 25). + +If you could not resolve your issue, see the table below to identify symptoms and + solutions to common problems. If you are unable to resolve your issue, contact +Bose customer service. + +worldwide.Bose.com/contact +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/contact + +OTHER SOLUTIONS + +SYMPTOM + +SOLUTION + +Headphones don’t +power on + +Charge the battery. + +Headphones don’t +connect with your +mobile device + +Battery won’t charge + +Disconnect the back-up audio cable. + +Disconnect the USB charging cable. + +On your mobile device: + +Disable the Bluetooth feature and then re-enable. + +Delete your Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones from the + Bluetooth list on your device. Connect again. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Visit worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 to see how-to videos. + +Clear the connected devices list (see page 26) and +connect again. + +Secure the ends of the USB charging cable. + +Try another charging source. + +If your headphones have been exposed to high or low + temperatures, let the headphones return to room temperature +and try charging again. + +3 6 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +SYMPTOM + +SOLUTION + +No sound + +Power on the headphones and charge the battery. + +Check the state of the status light (see page 29). + +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right and release to hear +the connected device. Make sure you are using the +correct device. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Use a different music source. + +If two mobile devices are connected, pause your other +device first. + +If two mobile devices are connected, move the devices within +range of the headphones (30 ft or 9 m). + +Try a locally stored music or video file on your mobile device. + +Use a different music source. + +Connect another mobile device (see page 25). + +Poor sound quality + +Disconnect the second device. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Try a locally stored music or video file on your mobile device. + +No sound from a device +connected by the + back-up audio cable + +Secure the ends of the back-up audio cable. + +Increase the volume on your headphones, your mobile device +and music source. + +Connect another device (see page 25). + +Poor sound quality from +a device connected by +audio cable + +Secure the ends of the back-up audio cable. + +Connect another device (see page 25). + +Action button doesn’t +change the noise + cancelling mode + +Make sure your headphones are powered on. + +Use the Bose Music app to change the noise cancelling mode. + +3 7 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +SYMPTOM - Step 8 +SOLUTION -Test, evaluate, and adjust your strategy +Headphones don’t +connect to a Bose Smart +Soundbar or Speaker -Your social media strategy is a hugely important document for your -business, and you can’t assume you’ll get it exactly right on the first try. +Slide and hold the Power/Bluetooth button until you hear “Ready +to connect another device,” and the Bluetooth light blinks blue. -As you start to implement your plan and track your results, you may find -that some strategies don’t work as well as you’d anticipated, while others are -working even better than expected. +Make sure that the headphones are within 30 ft (9 m) of your +soundbar or speaker. -Track your data +Headphones don’t +reconnect to a + previously-connected +Bose Smart Soundbar or +Speaker -In addition to using the analytics tools available within each social network, -use UTM parameters to track visitors as they move through your website, so -you can see exactly which social posts drive the most traffic to your website. +Delayed audio when + connected to a Bose +Smart Soundbar or +Speaker -Re-evaluate, test, and do it all again +Reconnect a previously-connected device +(see page 26). -When data starts coming in, use it to reevaluate your strategy regularly. -You can also use this information to test different posts, campaigns, and -strategies against one another. Constant testing allows you to understand -what works and what doesn’t, so you can refine your strategy in real time. +Download the Bose Music app and run available +software updates. -Surveys can also be a great way to find out how well your strategy is working. -Ask your social media followers, email list, and website visitors whether -you’re meeting their needs and expectations on social media. You can even -ask them what they’d like to see more of—and then make sure to deliver on -what they tell you. +3 8 -Things change fast on social media. New networks emerge, while others -go through significant demographic shifts. Your business will go through -periods of change as well. All this means that your social media strategy -should be a living document that you look at regularly and adjust as needed. -Refer to it often to keep you on track, but don’t be afraid to make changes -so that it better reflects new goals, tools, or plans. +| E N G -When you update your social strategy, make sure to let everyone on your -social team know, so they can all work together to help your business make -the most of your social media accounts. + TROUBLESHOOTING -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +A restore to factory settings can clear all settings and return the headphones to their +original out-of-box state. After, the headphones can be configured as if they were +being set up for the first time. -10 +Restoring to factory settings is only recommended if you are having issues with the +headphones, or you have been instructed to do so by Bose customer service. - Bonus: Download our social media -strategy template -Does this all feel a little overwhelming? The truth is that building your social -media strategy is a substantial job. It should be, since it’s such an important -document for your business. But it doesn’t have to be complicated. +RESTORE THE HEADPHONES TO FACTORY SETTINGS -We’ve created a template to guide you through the whole process of -creating your social media marketing plan. Visit our blog to download it (plus -six other social media templates that can save you hours of work). +1. Remove the headphones from the Bluetooth list on your device. -Take the next leap in your social media career +2. Remove the headphones from your Bose account using the Bose Music app. -Hootsuite Academy +NOTE: For more information about how to remove the headphones from your -Earn industry-recognized social media certifications that will make you stand -out from the crowd. +Bose account using the Bose Music app, visit: +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 -Begin with our free comprehensive training on social marketing. All of our -courses are delivered online and taught by expert industry practitioners. -Take the free course here. +3. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold. At the same time, press -Build a professional workflow with Hootsuite +and hold the Action button for 30 seconds. -From scheduling Instagram posts to advanced ROI measurement, Hootsuite’s -flexible platform helps you execute every aspect of your social media strategy. -We’re the world’s most widely used platform for managing social media. +The LED indicator blinks white. After 30 seconds, the LED indicator blinks amber +to indicate factory settings are being restored (2 to 3 seconds). -Get started with the plan that fits your needs here. +4. When the rest is complete, the LED indicator slowly blinks blue. The headphones -Did you find this guide helpful? +are now in their original out-of-box state. -Tell us whether we should praise our writers or shout at them. Either way, -we appreciate your honest feedback. Take our 4-minute survey here. +3 9 -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +| E N G -11 + ©2021 Bose Corporation, 100 The Mountain Road, Framingham, MA 01701-9168 USA +AM869288-0010 Rev. 01 diff --git a/q93/random_k4/question.json b/q93/random_k4/question.json index 4dfadc9cc03468224ea20af4adfb4a12337cde98..93edb3dff702975b793125261cf9a09fa677ed4e 100644 --- a/q93/random_k4/question.json +++ b/q93/random_k4/question.json @@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ ], "original_filenames": [ "t480_ug_en.pdf", - "web_7795b10bf9b6a434.pdf", - "web_55eb3e1bfd6dcec7.pdf", - "web_88be333a901981bb.pdf", - "web_8330bd2eabffb7f3.pdf" + "resize_r1_4.pdf", + "resize_r1_23.pdf", + "byu_grad_studies_principles_brochure.pdf", + "web_17b633ba09ee110f.pdf" ], "modality": "markdown" } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/q93/random_k4/random_1.md b/q93/random_k4/random_1.md index 4c601abeb6f180fb2f07694cada010de6f7dd010..b1f264dec8c881060a31fd51402112360988391b 100644 --- a/q93/random_k4/random_1.md +++ b/q93/random_k4/random_1.md @@ -1,462 +1,633 @@ -Proposal for the Theme on Big Data -Analytics - -Qiang Yang, HKUST - -Jiannong Cao, PolyU - -Qi-man Shao, CUHK - -May 2015 - - Motivation - -• - -The world's technological per-capita capacity to - -store information doubled every 40 months - -– - -As of 2012, 2.5 exabytes (2.5×1018) of data/day -Relational database management systems and -• -desktop statistics and visualization packages often -have difficulty handling big data. - -– - -Big Data: new driver for digital economy&society - - - - - - - -Gartner: hundreds of billions of GDP by 2020. -Intangible factor after labor and capital -Data Science: The fourth paradigm - -2 - - The Power of Big Data - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Big Data can bring “big values” to our life in -almost every aspects. -Technologically, Big Data is bringing about changes in our lives because it -allows diverse and heterogeneous data to be fully integrated and -analyzed to help us make decisions. -Today, with the Big Data technology, thousands of data from seemingly -unrelated areas can help support important decisions. This is the -power of Big Data. -Areas of Applications - -– - -– - -– - -– - -– - -Health and Well being - -Policy making and public opinions - -Smart cities and more efficient society - -New online educational models: MOOC and Student-Teacher modeling - -Robotics and human-robot interaction - -• - -Much of this power hinges on Research on Analytics - -3 - - Hong Kong needs Big Data -Research - -1. - -2. - -to develop state-of-the-art Big -Data platform in research, -education and industrial -applications, and open it to the -Hong Kong society and the world -at large, and - -to make a difference in Smart -Cities, Health and Well-being -(including supporting aging -populations), and modernizing -Finance, Education and Logistics -in Hong Kong. - -4 - - Big Data Analytics Objectives - -5 - - Relation to Smart Cities and IoT - -• - -• - -• - -World economic forum -ranking HK’s -infrastructure: #1 -– - -Maintain the lead in IT - -Infrastructure - -East Kowloon Project: -Energizing Hong Kong -via Smart Cities -Big Data: -– - -IoT provides the - -infrastructure for - -collecting the data - -Smart Cities as - -important application - -goal - -– - -6 - - Research Objectives - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Big Data Analytics: data mining and machine learning -– - -Large-scale machine learning, data mining and data visualization - -Big Data Computing: data center support for Analytics -– - -Big data collection and transformation, integration and distributed -data management and computing - -Big data sampling and statistical theory, Big data security and privacy - -Big Data Theory, Privacy&Security issues on Analytics -– -Big Data Science: 4th Paradigm – Analytics for Science and -Engineering -– - -Big Data and Multi-disciplines (Bio, Chemistry, Engineering, Social) - -7 - - Why Hong Kong is Ready for the Theme - -• - -We have the best researchers in machine learning, data mining, data -management, sensor networks, statistics, and multidisciplinary -research such as bioinformatics - -– - -– - -– - -China National 973 Projects on Big Data - -IEEE Transactions on Big Data: EiC - -ACM KDD Conferences: PC and Conference Chairs - -Winner of Big Data related international competitions - -– -New industries based on lots of data - -– - -Financial industry, logistics industry, education sector, government -services, etc. - -We have many potential collaborators and partners -– - -Huawei, Tencent, Baidu, Alibaba, Google, Microsoft, etc. - -• - -• - -8 - - Big Data Analytics Workflow - - 9 - -Data -Extraction - -Data -Integration - -• HKUST -CUHK -• -Baptist -• -HSBC -• -Astri -• - -• HKUST -HKU -• -City U -• -Alibaba -• -Astri -• - -Applications - -• Biology and Genetics -• -• -• -• -• -• -• -• - -Chemistry -Physics -Government Policies -Social Sciences -General Health -Logistics -Finance -Business - -Data Mining & -Visualization - -• HKUST -CUHK -• -City U -• -Huawei -• -Tencent -• - -Big Data -Computing &Data -Management - -• CUHK -• -• -• -• -• - -HKUST -HKU -PolyU -City U -Baptist U - - Multi-disciplinary Big-data Analytics - -• - -Objectives: -• - -Interdisciplinary, -research -technological big data analytics - -heterogeneous - -multi-university, - -on - -multi-team -and - -scientific - -10 - - Why Big Data needs Team Work? - -• - -Big data analytics is necessarily a joint effort by -researchers from academic institutions, -government and society and industry. -– - -The government and industry are sources of Big -Data, and providers of problems and challenges, -The academic researchers are solution - -providers. - -When it comes to package the solutions from -university labs to transfer to the real world, -universities and industry must work together to -build scalable and robust solutions. - -– - -– - -11 - - Expected Outcomes - -• - -• - -• - -• - -New methodologies and solutions for Big Data -research -New applications that impact the society and -industry in Hong Kong and beyond, and -New digital economies created based on big -data -New educational programs for students; -cultivating leaders for the Big Data society and -industry. - -12 - - Breakthroughs Expected - -• - -• - -• - -• - -New algorithms, methodologies, systems and -applications in Big Data -New knowledge from Big data applications in -Science, Engineering, and Societal Problems -New insights into Big data practices in real -world -New ways to protect security and privacy of big - -data relevant to individuals and organizations - -13 - - Call for Proposals in Big Data Analytics - -• - -• - -Foundations in Big Data Analytics Research: -– - -developing and studying fundamental theories, -algorithms, techniques, methodologies, -technologies to address the effectiveness and -efficiency issues to enable the applicability of Big -Data problems; - -Innovative Applications in Big Data Analytics: -developing techniques, methodologies and -– -technologies of key importance to a Big Data -problem that requires the seamless cooperation -of domain scientists with big data researchers. - -14 - - Benefit for the Hong Kong Society - -• - -• - -• - -• - -• - -Can Hong Kong transform into a more data- -driven society and maintain -leadership -globally? - -its - -How can companies in Hong Kong become -more competitive with Big Data technology? - -Can Data Science in Hong Kong’s research -fields benefit from strong foundations on big data? - -Can the government become more efficient with -big data driven methodologies in decision -making? - -Can education, finance, logistics and health -benefit from the ever increasing data? - -15 +English – Disney Terms of Use + +Home / English – Disney Terms of Use + +Last Updated: SEPTEMBER 26, 2019 + +Disney DTC LLC and/or its affiliates and subsidiaries (collectively, “Disney DTC”) are pleased +to provide to you their sites, software, applications, content, products and services (“Disney +Services”), which may be branded Disney, ABC, ESPN, Marvel, Pixar, Lucasfilm, FX or another +brand owned or licensed by Disney DTC. These terms govern your use and our provision of the +Disney Services on which these terms are posted, as well as Disney Services we make available +on third-party sites and platforms if these terms are disclosed to you in connection with your use +of the Disney Services. PLEASE READ THESE TERMS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING +THE DISNEY SERVICES. BY USING THE DISNEY SERVICES YOU AGREE TO BE +BOUND BY THESE TERMS. + +ANY DISPUTE BETWEEN YOU AND US, EXCEPT FOR SMALL CLAIMS, IS SUBJECT +TO A CLASS ACTION WAIVER AND MUST BE RESOLVED BY INDIVIDUAL BINDING +ARBITRATION. PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT IN ITS ENTIRETY, INCLUDING +THE ARBITRATION PROVISION BELOW. + +NOTHING IN THESE TERMS IS INTENDED TO AFFECT YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE +LAW IN YOUR USUAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE THAT CAN NOT BE ALTERED BY +THESE TERMS. IF THERE IS A CONFLICT BETWEEN THOSE RIGHTS AND THESE +TERMS, YOUR RIGHTS UNDER APPLICABLE LOCAL LAW WILL PREVAIL. + +1. Contract between You and Us + + This is a contract (1) between you and Disney DTC LLC, as a Delaware limited liability +company doing business at 500 South Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521, USA, or +(2) between you and any different service provider identified for a particular Disney Service. + +You must read and agree to these terms (the “Agreement”) before using the Disney Services. If +you do not agree, you may not use the Disney Services. These terms describe the limited basis +on which the Disney Services are made available to you and supersede prior agreements or +arrangements. + +Supplemental terms and conditions may apply to some Disney Services, such as rules for a +particular competition, content, software, application, service or other activity, or terms that may +accompany certain territories, content, products or software accessible through the Disney +Services. If applicable, such supplemental terms and conditions will be disclosed to you in +connection with such competition, content, product, software, application, service or +activity. Any supplemental terms and conditions are in addition to these terms and, in the event + + of a conflict, the supplemental terms will prevail over these terms. If you do not agree to the +supplemental terms and conditions disclosed, you must not use the applicable Disney Service. + +We may change these terms at any time. Any such amendment will be effective thirty (30) days +following either our dispatch of a notice to you or our posting of the amended terms. You are +responsible for periodically reviewing the terms for updates and amendments. By continuing to +use the Disney Services you will be deemed to have agreed to and accepted any amendments. If +you do not agree to any change to these terms, you must discontinue using the Disney +Services. Our customer service representatives are not authorized to modify any provision of +these terms, either verbally or in writing. + +We may immediately terminate this contract with respect to you (including your access to the +Disney Services) if you fail to comply with any provision of these terms. + +2. The Disney Services + +The Disney Services are for your personal, noncommercial use and are intended for +informational and entertainment purposes only. They do not constitute legal, financial, +professional, medical or healthcare advice or diagnosis and cannot be used for such +purposes. To support smooth operation of the Disney Services across wide geographic areas, +aspects of certain activities, such as game play, may be simulated to avoid delays. + +The Disney Services are our copyrighted property or the copyrighted property of our licensors or +licensees and all trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress and other intellectual +property rights in the Disney Services are owned by us or our licensors or licensees. Except as +we specifically agree in writing, no element of the Disney Services may be used or exploited in +any way other than as part of the Disney Services offered to you. You may own the physical +media on which elements of the Disney Services are delivered to you, but we retain full and +complete ownership of the Disney Services. We do not transfer title to any portion of the Disney +Services to you. + +Content and Software License + +If a Disney Service is configured to enable the use of software, content, virtual items or other +materials owned or licensed by us, we grant you a limited, non-exclusive, non-sublicensable, +non-transferable license to access and use such software, content, virtual item or other material +for your personal, noncommercial use only, only for as long as each Disney Service is made +available by us, with no right to reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available +to the public, or transform any Disney Service in any media format or channel now known or +hereafter devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney +Service). + +You may not: circumvent or disable any content protection system or digital rights management +technology used with any Disney Service; decompile, reverse engineer, disassemble or otherwise +reduce any Disney Service to a human-readable form; remove identification, copyright or other +proprietary notices; or access or use any Disney Service in an unlawful or unauthorized manner + + or in a manner that suggests an association with our products, services or brands. You may not +access or use any Disney Service in violation of United States export control and economic +sanctions requirements. By acquiring services, content or software through the Disney Services, +you represent and warrant that your access to and use of the services, content or software will +comply with those requirements. + +Disclaimers and Limitation on Liability + +THE DISNEY SERVICES ARE PROVIDED “AS IS” AND “AS AVAILABLE.” WE +DISCLAIM ALL CONDITIONS, REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES NOT +EXPRESSLY SET OUT IN THESE TERMS TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY +APPLICABLE LAW. + +FOR HELP, PLEASE REFER TO THE HELP SECTION OF THE APPLICABLE DISNEY +SERVICE FOR ASSISTANCE IF DIGITAL CONTENT SUPPLIED VIA A DISNEY +SERVICE IS NOT WORKING PROPERLY. We will not be liable for damage which could +have been avoided by following our advice to apply an update offered to you free of charge or +for damage which was caused by you failing to correctly follow installation instructions or to +have in place the minimum system requirements advised by us. + +We shall not be liable for delay or failure in performance for causes beyond our control or any +other damage which does not result from a breach of our obligation. + +We are not liable for business losses. We only supply the products for domestic and private use. +If you use the products for any commercial, business or re-sale purpose we will have no liability +to you for any loss of profit, loss of business, business interruption, or loss of business +opportunity. + +WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LACK OF FUNCTIONALITY OR FAILURE TO +PROVIDE ANY PART OF THE DISNEY SERVICE, OR ANY LOSS OF CONTENT OR +DATA THAT IS DUE TO: YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICES, OPERATING SYSTEM OR +INTERNET CONNECTION, YOUR FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SPECIFIED +COMPATIBILITY REQUIREMENTS OR THE CONSEQUENCES OF YOU CHANGING +YOUR EQUIPMENT, DEVICE, OPERATING SYSTEM OR INTERNET CONNECTION. + +WE SHALL NOT BE LIABLE TO YOU FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL OR +CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LOST PROFITS AND PROPERTY +DAMAGE, EVEN IF WE WERE ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES, +NOR SHALL WE BE HELD LIABLE FOR DELAY OR FAILURE IN PERFORMANCE +RESULTING FROM CAUSES BEYOND OUR REASONABLE CONTROL. + +IN NO EVENT SHALL OUR TOTAL LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ALL DAMAGES, LOSSES +AND CAUSES OF ACTION EXCEED ONE THOUSAND U.S. DOLLARS (US $1,000). + + Changes to the Disney Services + +The Disney Services are constantly evolving and will change over time. If we make a material +change to the Disney Services, we will provide you with reasonable notice as described above +and you will be entitled to terminate this contract prospectively by no longer using the Disney +Services. + +Additional Restrictions on Use of the Disney Services + +We do not allow uses of the Disney Services that are commercial or business-related, or that +advertise or offer to sell products or services (whether or not for profit), or that solicit others +(including solicitations for contributions or donations). You agree not to knowingly or recklessly +introduce a virus or other harmful component, or otherwise tamper with, impair or damage any +Disney Service or connected network, or interfere with any person or entity’s use or enjoyment +of any Disney Service. You agree not to use any software or device that allows automated +gameplay, expedited gameplay, or other manipulation of gameplay or game client and you agree +not to cheat or otherwise modify a Disney Service or game experience to create an advantage for +one user over another. Additionally, you agree not to access, monitor or copy, or permit another +person or entity to access, monitor or copy, any element of the Disney Services using a robot, +search engine, “spider,” “scraper,” or other automated means or manual process without our +express written permission. + +Third-Party Services and Content + +The Disney Services may integrate, be integrated into, or be provided in connection with third- +party services and content. We do not control those third-party services and content. You +should read the terms of use agreements and privacy policies that apply to such third-party +services and content. + +If you access a Disney Service using an Apple iOS, Android or Microsoft Windows-powered +device or Microsoft Xbox One, Apple Inc., Google, Inc. or Microsoft Corporation, respectively, +shall be a third-party beneficiary to this contract. However, these third-party beneficiaries are +not a party to this contract and are not responsible for the provision or support of the Disney +Services. You agree that your access to the Disney Services using these devices also shall be +subject to the usage terms set forth in the applicable third-party beneficiary’s terms of service. + +Mobile Networks + +When you access the Disney Services through a mobile network, your network or roaming +provider’s messaging, data and other rates and fees will apply. Downloading, installing or using +certain Disney Services may be prohibited or restricted by your network provider and not all +Disney Services may work with your network provider or device. + + Affiliate Advertising Programs + +Disney DTC is a participant in affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for +sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to third party retail sites. + +3. Your Content and Account + + User Generated Content + +The Disney Services may allow you to communicate, submit, upload or otherwise make +available text, chats, images, audio, video, competition entries or other content (“User Generated +Content”), which may be accessible and viewable by the public. Access to these features may be +subject to age restrictions. You may not submit or upload User Generated Content that is +defamatory, harassing, threatening, bigoted, hateful, violent, vulgar, obscene, pornographic, or +otherwise offensive or that harms or can reasonably be expected to harm any person or entity, +whether or not such material is protected by law. + +In most instances, we do not claim ownership to your User Generated Content; however, you +grant us a non-exclusive, sublicensable, irrevocable and royalty-free worldwide license under all +copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, privacy and publicity rights and other intellectual +property rights for the full duration of those rights to use, reproduce, transmit, print, publish, +publicly display, exhibit, distribute, redistribute, copy, index, comment on, modify, transform, +adapt, translate, create derivative works based upon, publicly perform, publicly communicate, +make available, and otherwise exploit such User Generated Content, in whole or in part, in all +media formats and channels now known or hereafter devised (including in connection with the +Disney Services and on third-party sites and platforms), in any number of copies and without +limit as to time, manner and frequency of use, without further notice to you, without attribution +(to the extent this is not contrary to mandatory provisions of applicable law), and without the +requirement of permission from or payment to you or any other person or entity. You agree that +submission of User Generated Content does not establish any relationship of trust and confidence +between you and us, and that you have no expectation of compensation whatsoever (except as +may be specifically stated in the provisions of the Disney Services in connection with the +submission, or arising from it). + +You represent and warrant that your User Generated Content conforms to these terms and that +you own or have the necessary rights and permissions including, without limitation, all +copyrights, music rights and likeness rights (with respect to any person) contained in the User +Generated Content, without the need for payment to any other person or entity, to use and +exploit, and to authorize us to use and exploit, your User Generated Content in all manners +contemplated by these terms. You agree to indemnify and hold us and our subsidiary and +affiliated companies, and each of their respective employees and officers, harmless from any +demands, loss, liability, claims or expenses (including attorneys’ fees), made against us by any +third party arising out of or in connection with our use and exploitation of your User Generated +Content resulting from your breach of any warranty, representation or other provision of these +terms or any applicable supplemental terms. You also agree not to enforce any moral rights, +ancillary rights or similar rights in or to the User Generated Content against us or our licensees, + + distributors, agents, representatives and other authorized users, and agree to procure the same +agreement not to enforce from others who may possess such rights. + +To the extent that we authorize you to create, post, upload, distribute, publicly display or +publicly perform User Generated Content that requires the use of our copyrighted works, we +grant you a non-exclusive license to create a derivative work using the specifically referenced +copyrighted works as required for the sole purpose of creating the materials, provided that such +license shall be conditioned upon your assignment to us of all rights worldwide in the work you +create for the duration of copyright in the User Generated Content, in all formats and media +known or unknown to date, including for use on Disney Services and on third party sites and +platforms. If such rights are not assigned to us, your license to create derivative works using our +copyrighted works shall be null and void. + +We may monitor, screen, post, remove, modify, store and review User Generated Content or +communications sent through a Disney Service, at any time and for any reason, including to +ensure that the User Generated Content or communication conforms to these terms, without prior +notice to you. We are not responsible for, and do not endorse or guarantee, the opinions, views, +advice or recommendations posted or sent by users. + +Accounts + +Some Disney Services permit or require you to create an account to participate or to secure +additional benefits. You agree that any information you provide and maintain is accurate, +current and complete, including your contact information for notices and other communications +from us and your payment information. You agree not to impersonate or misrepresent your +affiliation with any person or entity, including using another person’s username, password or +other account information, or another person’s name or likeness, or provide false details for a +parent or guardian. You agree that we may take steps to verify the accuracy of information you +provide, including contact information for a parent or guardian. + +We have adopted and implemented a policy that provides for the termination, in appropriate +circumstances, of the accounts of users who are repeat infringers of copyright. In addition, we +may suspend or terminate your account and your ability to use the Disney Services if you engage +in, encourage, or advocate for illegal conduct or if you fail to comply with these terms or any +supplemental terms. + +Passwords and Security + +You agree that you will not share your account or account information with others. You are +responsible for taking reasonable steps to maintain the confidentiality of your username and +password, and you are responsible for all activities under your account that you can reasonably +control. You agree to promptly notify us of any unauthorized use of your username, password or +other account information, or of any other breach of security that you become aware of involving +your account or the Disney Services. + + The security, integrity and confidentiality of your information are extremely important to us. We +have implemented technical, administrative and physical security measures that are designed to +protect your information from unauthorized access, disclosure, use and modification. + +4. Paid Transactions + +Identity of Seller + +Sales are made by Disney DTC or the seller identified at the time of sale, if different. If you +have questions about your order, please contact the seller at the address provided and they will +assist you. Some digital storefronts on the Disney Services are operated by third parties and, in +that case, different or additional sale terms may apply, which you should read when they are +presented to you. + +Digital Content and Virtual Items + +We may make applications, games, software or other digital content available on the Disney +Services for you to license for a one-time fee. When purchasing a license to access such material +from a Disney Service, charges will be disclosed to you on the Disney Service before you +complete the license purchase. + +Your purchase of a virtual item or in-game currency is a payment for a limited, non-assignable +license to access and use such content or functionality in the Disney Services with no right to +reproduce, distribute, communicate to the public, make available to the public or transform any +Disney Service via any online media, in any media format or channel now known or hereafter +devised (except as may be expressly described or contemplated within the Disney Service). +Virtual items (including characters and character names) or in-game currency purchased or +available to you in the Disney Services can only be used in connection with the Disney Services +where you obtained them or where they were developed by you as a result of game play. These +items are not redeemable or subject to refund and cannot be traded outside of the Disney +Services for money or other items for value. We may modify or discontinue virtual items or in- +game currency at any time. + +Digital Movie Codes + +Digital codes originally packaged in a combination disc + code package (a package that includes +a DVD, Blu-Ray, and/or 4K/UHD disc(s) and a digital code) may not be sold separately and may +be redeemed only by an individual who obtains the code in the original combination disc + code +package, or by a family member of that individual. Digital codes are not authorized for +redemption if sold separately. You may use digital movie codes to obtain licensed access to +digital movies only as specifically authorized under these terms and conditions and the terms and +conditions of the participating provider of digital content through which you access or download +the digital movie. Digital movie codes sold, distributed, purchased, or transferred in a manner +inconsistent with these terms and conditions are subject to being invalidated. + + Digital Movie Code Returns. If you do not agree to the above terms and conditions for +redeeming a digital movie code obtained by you or a family member in an original combination +disc + code package, you may return the combination disc + code package to Disney for a refund +subject to the conditions provided at this link. + +Subscriptions + +Some Disney Services require paid subscriptions to access. By signing up for a subscription, +you agreed that your subscription will be automatically renewed and, unless you cancel your +subscription, you authorized us to charge your payment method for the renewal term. The period +of auto-renewal will be the same as your initial subscription period unless otherwise disclosed to +you at the time of sale. The renewal rate will be no more than the rate for the immediately prior +subscription period, excluding any promotional and discount pricing, unless we notify you of a +rate change prior to your auto-renewal, in which case you will have the right to cancel the +renewal of your subscription. From time to time, we may offer a free trial subscription for a +Disney Service. If you register for a free trial subscription, we will begin to bill your account +when the free trial subscription expires, unless you cancel your subscription before that time. + +When you subscribe to a Disney Service (other than semi-annual and annual subscriptions), you +have the right to cancel your contract within fourteen (14) days from the date the transaction is +concluded and you will receive a full refund of the subscription fee paid. For semi-annual and +annual subscriptions, if notice of cancellation is received within the first thirty (30) days +following the first day of initial billing, you will receive a refund of the subscription fee paid. If +we refund your subscription fee, you will still be obligated to pay other charges incurred by you +in the course of using the Disney Service prior to the date of cancellation. If you pay a periodic +subscription fee for a Disney Service, we will provide you with reasonable notice of changes to +the fees or billing methods in advance of their effective date and you will be able to cancel your +subscription prior to such change. If you subscribed online, we will give you the option of +cancelling the subscription online. + +The Order Process + +You will have the opportunity to review and confirm your order, including delivery address (if +applicable), payment method and product details. We will send to you a notice when we accept +your order and our acceptance will be deemed complete and for all purposes to have been +effectively communicated to you at the time we send the notice. At such time, the contract for +sale will be made and become binding on both you and us. The risk of loss in any goods you +purchase and the responsibility to insure them passes to you when the relevant goods are +delivered. + +We reserve the right to refuse or cancel any order prior to delivery. Some situations that may +result in your order being cancelled include system or typographical errors, inaccuracies in +product or pricing information or product availability, fairness among customers where supplies +are limited, or problems identified by our credit or fraud departments. We also may require +additional verification or information before accepting an order. We will contact you if any +portion of your order is cancelled or if additional information is required to accept your order. If + + your order is cancelled after we have processed your payment but prior to delivery, we will +refund your payment. + +Payments and Billing + +When you provide payment information, you represent and warrant that the information is +accurate, that you are authorized to use the payment method provided, and that you will notify us +of changes to the payment information. We reserve the right to utilize third party payment card +updating services to obtain current expiration dates on credit cards and debit cards. + +Right of Cancellation; Return of Goods + +You may have the right to cancel an order placed for a Disney Service - depending on the nature +of the Disney Service. Please read the following information carefully so you understand your +right of cancellation. + +If you wish to cancel, you must do so by following the cancellation instructions for the particular +Disney Service. A sample cancellation form is available here. + +Cancelling Subscriptions + +Please see the information above on the process for cancelling subscriptions in our Subscriptions +section. + +Digital Content + +When you purchase a license to access digital content or virtual items, you will be given an +opportunity to consent to delivery at the time of purchase. By consenting to delivery, you +acknowledge that you have lost the right to cancel. License purchase fees paid for digital content +are non-refundable. + +Physical Goods + +You have the right, within thirty (30) days from the date of your receipt of physical goods, to +cancel our contract with you and return the goods. This right does not apply to goods stated by +us on the Disney Services to be non-returnable, including but not limited to: + +• Any products with a seal, where the seal is broken, such as audio and video recordings, + +computer software, and CD’s, DVD’s or other physical media that have been supplied in +sealed packaging; and + +• Personalized items. + +Personalized Goods + +We reserve the right to refuse personalized orders at our discretion. Inappropriate use of our +personalization service will cause your order to be cancelled and any payment refunded. + + These cancellation rights are separate and in addition to your rights should any item we supply +be faulty. + +If you are returning goods that are not faulty, you may be required to pay for the cost of returning +the goods to us and we may deduct a reasonable amount if you use the goods. + +Pricing; Taxes + +We may revise the pricing for products and services we offer. When you place your order, we +estimate the applicable tax and include that estimate in the total for your convenience. Except to +the extent required under applicable tax laws, the actual tax amount that will be applied to your +order and charged to your payment method is based on calculations on the date of shipment, +regardless of when the order was placed. + +International Shipping; Customs + +When ordering goods for delivery to countries other than the country where the seller is located, +you may have to pay import duties and taxes levied. These and any additional charges for +customs clearance must be borne by you. For goods shipped internationally, please note that any +manufacturer warranty may not be valid; manufacturer service options may not be available; +manuals, instructions and safety warnings may not be in destination country languages; the +goods and accompanying materials may not be designed in accordance with destination country +standards, specifications, and labeling requirements; and the goods may not conform to +destination country voltage (requiring use of an adapter or converter). You are responsible for +assuring the goods can be lawfully imported to the destination country. When ordering from us, +the recipient is the importer of record and must comply with all laws and regulations of the +destination country. + +5. Competitions + +Competitions that you enter on a Disney Service may have supplemental rules and/or conditions, +but the following general rules apply absent contrary terms in any supplemental rules or +conditions for the competition. If there are rules or conditions for a competition and such rules +or conditions conflict with these terms, the provisions contained in the rules and conditions +govern and control the competition. + +Entries + +Your competition entry is User Generated Content and subject to all provisions of these terms +that govern your submission and our use of your User Generated Content. We may disqualify +entries that are late, misdirected, incomplete, corrupted, lost, illegible or invalid or where +appropriate parental consent was not provided. Competition entries are limited to one per person +and entries via agents or third parties or the use of multiple identities are not permitted. Use of +automated entries, votes or other programs is prohibited and all such entries (or votes) will be +disqualified. + + We reserve the right to modify, suspend, cancel or terminate a competition or extend or resume +the entry period or disqualify any participant or entry at any time without giving advance +notice. We will do so if it cannot be guaranteed the competition can be carried out fairly or +correctly for technical, legal or other reasons, or if we suspect that any person has manipulated +entries or results, provided false information or acted unethically. If we cancel or terminate a +competition, prizes may be awarded in any manner we deem fair and appropriate consistent with +local laws governing the competition. + +Eligibility + +To enter a competition, the competition must be open to residents in your country and you must +be a registered user of the Disney Services and have an active account with current contact +information. No purchase is necessary to enter a competition and a purchase will not improve +your chances of winning. Competitions are not open to our employees (or their immediate +families) or anyone else professionally associated with the competition. If you are under age 18 +(or under the age of majority under applicable law) and the competition is open to you, we may +need your parent or guardian’s consent before we can accept your entry. We reserve the right to +request proof of identity or to verify eligibility conditions and potential winning entries, and to +award any prize to a winner in person. Competitions are void where prohibited or restricted by +law. Potential winners who are residents in jurisdictions where competitions require an element +of skill may be required to answer a mathematical test in order to be eligible to win a prize. + +Prizes + +No cash or alternative prizes are available, except that we (or the party providing a prize) reserve +the right to substitute a similar prize of equal or greater value. Prizes cannot be transferred +(except to a child or other family member) or sold by winners. Only the number of prizes stated +for the competition is available to be won and all prizes will be awarded provided a sufficient +number of eligible entries are received and prizes are validly claimed by the date provided in +connection with the competition, after which no alternate winners will be selected or unclaimed +prizes awarded. Unless otherwise disclosed in the prize description prior to entry, winners are +responsible for all costs and expenses associated with claiming a prize. All taxes are solely the +responsibility of each winner, although we reserve the right to withhold applicable taxes and +each winner agrees to complete any required tax forms. + +Your acceptance of a prize constitutes agreement to participate in reasonable publicity related to +the competition and grants us an unconditional right to us to use your name, town or city and +state, province or country, likeness, prize information and statements by you about the +competition for publicity, advertising and promotional purposes subject to applicable law and +regulations, all without additional permission or compensation. As a condition of receiving a +prize, winners (or their parents or guardians) may be required to sign and return an affidavit of +eligibility, liability release and publicity release. + + 6. Additional Provisions + +Submissions and Unsolicited Ideas Policies + +Our long-standing company policy does not allow us to accept or consider unsolicited creative +ideas, suggestions or materials. In connection with anything you submit to us – whether or not +solicited by us – you agree that creative ideas, suggestions or other materials you submit are not +being made in confidence or trust and that no confidential or fiduciary relationship is intended or +created between you and us in any way, and that you have no expectation of review, +compensation or consideration of any type. + +Claims of Copyright Infringement + +Notifications of claimed copyright infringement and counter notices must be sent to our +designated agent: + +Lance R. Griffin +The Walt Disney Company +500 South Buena Vista Street +Burbank, California 91521, USA +Phone: +1 818-560-1000 +Fax: +1 818-560-4299 +Email: designated.agent@dig.twdc.com + +We are only able to accept notices in the languages in which these terms are made available by +us. + +We will respond expeditiously to claims of copyright infringement committed using the Disney +Services that are reported to our Designated Copyright Agent, identified above, in accordance +with the U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (“DMCA”) or, as applicable, other +laws. With respect to Disney Services hosted in the United States, these notices must include the +required information set forth in the DMCA and described in detail here. + +7. BINDING ARBITRATION AND CLASS ACTION WAIVER + +PROCEEDINGS TO RESOLVE OR LITIGATE A DISPUTE IN ANY FORUM WILL BE +CONDUCTED ON AN INDIVIDUAL BASIS. Neither you nor Disney DTC will seek to have a +dispute heard as a class action or private attorney general action or in any other proceeding in +which either party acts or proposes to act in a representative capacity. No arbitration or +proceeding can be combined with another without the prior written consent of all parties to the +arbitrations or proceedings. + +You and Disney DTC agree to arbitrate, as provided below, all disputes between you (including +any related disputes involving The Walt Disney Company or its affiliates), that are not resolved +informally, except disputes relating to the ownership or enforcement of intellectual property +rights. “Dispute” includes any dispute, action, or other controversy, whether based on past, + + present, or future events, between you and us concerning the Disney Services or this Agreement, +whether in contract, tort, warranty, statute, regulation, or other legal or equitable basis. You and +Disney DTC empower the arbitrator with the exclusive authority to resolve any dispute relating +to the interpretation, applicability or enforceability of these terms or the formation of this +contract, including the arbitrability of any dispute and any claim that all or any part of this +Agreement are void or voidable. + +A. In the event of a dispute, you or Disney DTC must send to the other party a notice of +dispute, which is a written statement that sets forth the name, address, and contact +information of the party giving the notice, the facts giving rise to the dispute, and the +relief requested. You must send any notice of dispute to Disney DTC, 500 South +Buena Vista Street, Burbank, California 91521-7620, USA, Attention: Legal. We will +send any notice of dispute to you at the contact information we have for you. You and +Disney DTC will attempt to resolve a dispute through informal negotiation within +sixty (60) days from the date the notice of dispute is sent. After that sixty (60) day +period and not before, you or we may commence an arbitration proceeding. You may +instead litigate a dispute in small claims court if the dispute meets the requirements to +be heard in small claims court, whether or not you negotiated informally first. + +B. If you and Disney DTC do not resolve a dispute by informal negotiation or in small +claims court, the dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration before a neutral +arbitrator whose decision will be final except for a limited right of appeal under the +U.S. Federal Arbitration Act. YOU ARE GIVING UP THE RIGHT TO LITIGATE +A DISPUTE IN COURT BEFORE A JUDGE OR JURY. Arbitration will be +administered by JAMS Mediation, Arbitration and ADR Services (“JAMS”) in +accordance with the JAMS Streamlined Arbitration Rules and Procedures (the +“JAMS Rules”). The JAMS Rules and instructions about how to initiate an +arbitration are available at www.jamsadr.com or 1-800-352-5267. Arbitration may be +conducted in person, through the submission of documents, by phone, or online. +Proceedings that cannot be conducted through the submission of documents, by +phone, or online, will take place in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of +Manhattan, New York, New York, whichever is more convenient for you; provided, +however, that if circumstances prevent you from traveling to Los Angeles or New +York, JAMS may hold an in-person hearing in your hometown area. You and Disney +DTC agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal or state courts located +in either Los Angeles, California or the borough of Manhattan, New York, New +York, whichever is more convenient for you, in order to compel arbitration, to stay +proceedings pending arbitration, or to confirm, modify, vacate, or enter judgment on +the award entered by the arbitrator. The arbitrator may award damages to you +individually as a court could, including declaratory or injunctive relief, but only to the +extent required to satisfy your individual claim. + +Except as provided above with respect to jurisdiction in Los Angeles, California and Manhattan, +New York, New York, nothing in this arbitration provision shall be construed as consent by +Disney DTC or its affiliates to the jurisdiction of any other court with regard to disputes, claims +or controversies unrelated to the Disney Services or this Agreement. + + Choice of Forum + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent required under applicable local law which requires that venue be in the +country of your residence, you agree that any action at law or in equity arising out of or relating +to these terms or the Disney Services that is not subject to arbitration shall be filed, and that +venue properly lies, only in the state or federal courts located in the borough of Manhattan, New +York, New York, United States of America and you consent and submit to the personal +jurisdiction of such courts for the purposes of litigating such action. + +Choice of Law + +For all Disney Services NOT provided by The Walt Disney Company Limited the following +shall apply: + +Except to the extent that applicable local law requires that the law to be applied for contracts of +this type be that of the country of your residence, these terms are governed by and construed in +accordance with the laws of the State of New York and the laws of the United States, without +giving effect to any conflict of law principles. + +Severability + +If any provision of these terms shall be unlawful, void or for any reason unenforceable, then that +provision shall be deemed severable from these terms and shall not affect the validity and +enforceability of any remaining provisions. + +Survival + +The provisions of these terms which by their nature should survive the termination of these terms +shall survive such termination. + +Waiver + +No waiver of any provision of these terms by us shall be deemed a further or continuing waiver +of such provision or any other provision, and our failure to assert any right or provision under +these terms shall not constitute a waiver of such right or provision. diff --git a/q93/random_k4/random_2.md b/q93/random_k4/random_2.md index 7d30cced73b1f30da245c4cf6780b4baf04ace71..8dd9410dc88edb3e6007de77b19516154383e752 100644 --- a/q93/random_k4/random_2.md +++ b/q93/random_k4/random_2.md @@ -1,553 +1,1670 @@ - GUI DE +Q U I E T C O M F O R T 4 5 -Social Media -Marketing Strategy -Eight easy steps to develop your -social media presence + Please read and keep all safety, security, and use instructions. - Contents +Bose Corporation hereby declares that this product is in compliance with the essential requirements and +other relevant provisions of Directive 2014/53/EU and all other applicable EU directive requirements. The +www.Bose.com/compliance +complete declaration of conformity can be found at: www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 1: Set social media marketing goals that align to business objectives +This product conforms to all applicable Electromagnetic Compatibility Regulations 2016 and all other +applicable UK regulations. The complete declaration of conformity can be found at: +www.Bose.com/compliance +www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 2: Learn everything you can about your audience +Bose Corporation hereby declares that this product is in compliance with the essential requirements per +Radio Equipment Regulations 2017 and all other applicable UK regulations. The complete declaration of +www.Bose.com/compliance +conformity can be found at: www.Bose.com/compliance -Step 3: Research the competition +Important Safety Instructions +Do not use this apparatus near water. -Step 4: Conduct a social media audit +Clean only with a dry cloth. -Step 5: Set up accounts and improve existing profiles +Refer all servicing to qualified personnel. Servicing is required when the apparatus has been damaged in any way, +such as power-supply cord or plug is damaged, liquid has been spilled or objects have fallen into the apparatus, the +apparatus has been exposed to rain or moisture, does not operate normally, or has been dropped. -Step 6: Find inspiration +WARNINGS/CAUTIONS +• Do NOT use the headphones at a high volume for any extended period. -Step 7: Create a social media content calendar + – To avoid hearing damage, use your headphones at a comfortable, moderate volume level. -Step 8: Test, evaluate, and adjust your strategy + – Turn the volume down on your device before placing the headphones in/on your ears, then turn the volume up + +gradually until you reach a comfortable listening level. + +• Do NOT use your headphones while driving for phone calls or any other purpose. + +• Do NOT use the headphones with noise canceling mode at any time the inability to hear surrounding sounds may +present a danger to yourself or others, e.g., while riding a bicycle or walking in or near traffic, a construction site or +railroad, etc., and follow applicable laws regarding headphone use. + – Turn the headphones off, or use the headphones with noise canceling off and adjust your volume, to ensure you + +can hear surrounding sounds, including alarms and warning signals. + + – Be aware of how sounds that you rely on as reminders or warnings may vary in character when using the + + headphones, even with Aware mode. + +• Do NOT use the headphones if they emit any loud unusual noise. If this happens, turn the headphones off and + +contact Bose customer service. + +• Remove headphones immediately if you experience a warming sensation or loss of audio. + +• Do NOT use mobile phone adapters to connect headphones to airplane seat jacks, as this could result in injury or + +property damage due to overheating. + +• Do NOT use the headphones as aviation communication headsets. + +Contains small parts which may be a choking hazard. Not suitable for children under age 3. + +This product contains magnetic material. Consult your physician on whether this might affect your +implantable medical device. + +• To reduce the risk of fire or electrical shock, do NOT expose this product to rain, liquids or moisture. + +• Do NOT expose this product to dripping or splashing, and do not place objects filled with liquids, such as vases, on + +or near the product. + +2 + +| E N G + +IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUCTIONS + IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUC TI ONS + +• Keep the product away from fire and heat sources. Do NOT place naked flame sources, such as lighted candles, on + +or near the product. + +• Use this product only with an agency approved LPS power supply which meets local regulatory requirements + +(e.g., UL, CSA, VDE, CCC). + +• Do NOT make unauthorized alterations to this product. + +• If the battery leaks, do not allow the liquid to come in contact with the skin or eyes. If contact is made, seek + +medical advice. + +• Do not expose products containing batteries to excessive heat (e.g. from storage in direct sunlight, fire or the like). + +• Do NOT wear while charging. 3 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +NOTE: This equipment has been tested and found to comply with the limits for a Class B digital device, pursuant to +Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful interference in a +residential installation. This equipment generates, uses, and can radiate radio frequency energy and, if not installed +and used in accordance with the instructions, may cause harmful interference to radio communications. However, +there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a particular installation. If this equipment does cause harmful +interference to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning the equipment off and on, the user +is encouraged to try to correct the interference by one or more of the following measures: + +• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna. + +• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver. + +• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that to which the receiver is connected. + +• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help. + +Changes or modifications not expressly approved by Bose Corporation could void the user’s authority to operate this +equipment. + +This device complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules and with ISED Canada license-exempt RSS standard(s). Operation +is subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause harmful interference, and (2) this device must +accept any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. + +This device complies with FCC and ISED Canada radiation exposure limits set forth for general population. This + transmitter must not be co-located or operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter. + +Meets IMDA Requirements. + +FCC ID: A94437310 + +IC: 3232A-437310 + +CAN ICES-3(B)/NMB-3(B) + +For Europe: + +Frequency band of operation 2400 to 2483.5 MHz. + +Maximum transmit power less than 20 dBm EIRP. + +This symbol means the product must not be discarded as household waste, and should be delivered to an +appropriate collection facility for recycling. Proper disposal and recycling helps protect natural resources, +human health and the environment. For more information on disposal and recycling of this product, contact +your local municipality, disposal service, or the shop where you bought this product. + +Management Regulation for Low-power Radio-frequency Devices +Article XII +According to “Management Regulation for Low-power Radio-frequency Devices” without permission granted by +the NCC, any company, enterprise, or user is not allowed to change frequency, enhance transmitting power or alter +original characteristic as well as performance to an approved low power radio-frequency devices. + +Article XIV +The low power radio-frequency devices shall not influence aircraft security and interfere legal communications; If +found, the user shall cease operating immediately until no interference is achieved. The said legal communications +means radio communications operated in compliance with the Telecommunications Act. + +The low power radio-frequency devices must be susceptible with the interference from legal communications or ISM +radio wave radiated devices. + +DON’T attempt to remove the rechargeable lithium-ion battery from this product. Contact your local Bose retailer or +other qualified professional for removal. + +Removal of the rechargeable lithium-ion battery in this product should be conducted only by a qualified professional. +Please contact your local Bose retailer or see products.bose.com/static/compliance/index.html +further information. + +products.bose.com/static/compliance/index.html for + 4 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +Please dispose of used batteries properly, following local regulations. Do not incinerate. + +Names and Contents of Toxic or Hazardous Substances or Elements + +Toxic or Hazardous Substances and Elements + +Part Name + +PCBs + +Metal Parts + +Plastic Parts + +Speaker + +Cables + +Lead +(Pb) + +Mercury +(Hg) + +Cadmium +(Cd) + +Hexavalent +(CR(VI)) + +X + +X + +O + +X + +X + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +Polybrominated +Biphenyl +(PBB) +O + +Polybrominated +diphenylether +(PBDE) +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +O + +This table is prepared in accordance with the provisions of SJ/T 11364. +O: Indicates that this toxic or hazardous substance contained in all of the homogeneous materials for this + +part is below the limit requirement of GB/T 26572. + +X: Indicates that this toxic or hazardous substance contained in at least one of the homogeneous materials + +used for this part is above the limit requirement of GB/T 26572. + +Date of Manufacture: The eighth digit in the serial number indicates the year of manufacture; “1” is 2011 or 2021. + +China Importer: Bose Electronics (Shanghai) Company Limited, Part C, Plant 9, No. 353 North Riying Road, China +(Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone + +EU Importer: Bose Products B.V., Gorslaan 60, 1441 RG Purmerend, The Netherlands + +Taiwan Importer: Bose Taiwan Branch, 9F-A1, No. 10, Section 3, Minsheng East Road, Taipei City 104, Taiwan Phone +Number: +886-2-2514 7676 + +Mexico Importer: Bose de México, S. de R.L. de C.V., Paseo de las Palmas 405-204, Lomas de Chapultepec, 11000 +México, D.F. Phone Number: +5255 (5202) 3545 + +UK Importer: Bose Limited, Bose House, Quayside Chatham Maritime, Chatham, Kent, ME4 4QZ, United Kingdom +Input Rating: 5V p 0.5A +Charging Temperature Range: 32° F to 113° F (0° C to 45° C) + +Discharging Temperature Range: -4° F to 140° F (-20° C to 60° C) + +Model 437310. The CMIIT ID is located inside the earcup under the scrim. + +Please complete and retain for your records +The serial and model numbers are located inside the earcup under the scrim. + +Serial number: __________________________________ + +Model number: __________________________________ + +Please keep your receipt with your owner’s guide. Now is a good time to register your Bose product. You can easily +global.Bose.com/register +do this by going to global.Bose.com/register + 5 +| E N G + + REGULATORY AND L EGAL INFORMATI ON + +Security Information + + This product is capable of receiving security updates from Bose automatically when connected to the Bose +Music app. In order to receive security updates via the mobile application, you must complete the product +setup process in the Bose Music app. If you do not complete the setup process, you will be responsible +for installing security updates that Bose makes available via btu.Bose.com +btu.Bose.com + +Apple, the Apple logo, iPad, iPhone, and iPod are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries. +App Store is a service mark of Apple Inc. The trademark “iPhone” is used in Japan with a license from Aiphone K.K. + +Use of the Made for Apple badge means that an accessory has been designed to connect specifically to the Apple + product(s) identified in the badge, and has been certified by the developer to meet Apple performance standards. +Apple is not responsible for the operation of this device or its compliance with safety and regulatory standards. + +The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such +marks by Bose Corporation is under license. + +Google Play is a trademark of Google LLC. + +USB Type-C® and USB-C® are registered trademarks of USB Implementers Forum. + +Bose, Bose Home Speaker, Bose Music, the Bose Music logo, Bose Smart Soundbar, Bose Smart Speaker, +Bose Soundbar, QuietComfort, and SimpleSync are trademarks of Bose Corporation. + +Bose Corporation Headquarters: 1-877-230-5639 + +©2021 Bose Corporation. No part of this work may be reproduced, modified, distributed, or otherwise used without +prior written permission. + 6 +| E N G + +REGULATORY INFORMATION + LICENSE DISCLOSURES + +The following license disclosures apply to certain third-party software packages used as components in the product. + +Package: FreeRTOS + +Copyright © Amazon Web Services, Inc. or its affiliates. All rights reserved. + +The FreeRTOS package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +MIT License + +Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated + documentation files (the “Software”), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the +rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit +persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: + +The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of +the Software. + +THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS IS”, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING +BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND + NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, +DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT +OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. + +Package: Nanopb + +Copyright © 2011 Petteri Aimonen . + +The Nanopb package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +Zlib License + +© 2011 Petteri Aimonen + +This software is provided ‘as-is’, without any express or implied warranty. In no event will the authors be held liable +for any damages arising from the use of this software. + +Permission is granted to anyone to use this software for any purpose, including commercial applications, and to alter +it and redistribute it freely, subject to the following restrictions: + +1. + + The origin of this software must not be misrepresented; you must not claim that you wrote the original software. +If you use this software in a product, an acknowledgment in the product documentation would be appreciated +but is not required. + +2. + + Altered source versions must be plainly marked as such, and must not be misrepresented as being the +original software. + +3. This notice may not be removed or altered from any source distribution. + +Package: Mbed TLS 2.16.1 + +© ARM Limited. All rights reserved. + +The Mbed TLS package is subject to the license terms reprinted below: + +Apache License + +Version 2.0, January 2004 + +http://www.apache.org/licenses/ +http://www.apache.org/licenses/ + +TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR USE, REPRODUCTION, AND DISTRIBUTION + +1. Definitions. + +“License” shall mean the terms and conditions for use, reproduction, and distribution as defined by Sections 1 +through 9 of this document. + 7 -8 +| E N G + + LICENSE DISCLOSURES + +“Licensor” shall mean the copyright owner or entity authorized by the copyright owner that is granting +the License. + +“Legal Entity” shall mean the union of the acting entity and all other entities that control, are controlled by, or +are under common control with that entity. For the purposes of this definition, “control” means (i) the power, +direct or indirect, to cause the direction or management of such entity, whether by contract or otherwise, or (ii) +ownership of fifty percent (50%) or more of the outstanding shares, or (iii) beneficial ownership of such entity. + +“You” (or “Your”) shall mean an individual or Legal Entity exercising permissions granted by this License. + +“Source” form shall mean the preferred form for making modifications, including but not limited to software +source code, documentation source, and configuration files. + +“Object” form shall mean any form resulting from mechanical transformation or translation of a Source form, +including but not limited to compiled object code, generated documentation, and conversions to other +media types. + +“Work” shall mean the work of authorship, whether in Source or Object form, made available under the License, +as indicated by a copyright notice that is included in or attached to the work (an example is provided in the +Appendix below). + +“Derivative Works” shall mean any work, whether in Source or Object form, that is based on (or derived from) +the Work and for which the editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications represent, as a +whole, an original work of authorship. For the purposes of this License, Derivative Works shall not include works +that remain separable from, or merely link (or bind by name) to the interfaces of, the Work and Derivative +Works thereof. + +“Contribution” shall mean any work of authorship, including the original version of the Work and any + modifications or additions to that Work or Derivative Works thereof, that is intentionally submitted to Licensor +for inclusion in the Work by the copyright owner or by an individual or Legal Entity authorized to submit on +behalf of the copyright owner. For the purposes of this definition, “submitted” means any form of electronic, +verbal, or written communication sent to the Licensor or its representatives, including but not limited to +communication on electronic mailing lists, source code control systems, and issue tracking systems that are +managed by, or on behalf of, the Licensor for the purpose of discussing and improving the Work, but excluding +communication that is conspicuously marked or otherwise designated in writing by the copyright owner as “Not +a Contribution.” + +“Contributor” shall mean Licensor and any individual or Legal Entity on behalf of whom a Contribution has been +received by Licensor and subsequently incorporated within the Work. + +2. + +3. + + Grant of Copyright License. Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants +to You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable copyright license to reproduce, +prepare Derivative Works of, publicly display, publicly perform, sublicense, and distribute the Work and such +Derivative Works in Source or Object form. + + Grant of Patent License. Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants to +You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable (except as stated in this section) +patent license to make, have made, use, offer to sell, sell, import, and otherwise transfer the Work, where such +license applies only to those patent claims licensable by such Contributor that are necessarily infringed by their +Contribution(s) alone or by combination of their Contribution(s) with the Work to which such Contribution(s) +was submitted. If You institute patent litigation against any entity (including a cross-claim or counterclaim in a +lawsuit) alleging that the Work or a Contribution incorporated within the Work constitutes direct or contributory +patent infringement, then any patent licenses granted to You under this License for that Work shall terminate as +of the date such litigation is filed. + +4. + + Redistribution. You may reproduce and distribute copies of the Work or Derivative Works thereof in any medium, +with or without modifications, and in Source or Object form, provided that You meet the following conditions: + +a. You must give any other recipients of the Work or Derivative Works a copy of this License; and +b. You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices stating that You changed the files; and +c. You must retain, in the Source form of any Derivative Works that You distribute, all copyright, patent, + + trademark, and attribution notices from the Source form of the Work, excluding those notices that do not +pertain to any part of the Derivative Works; and 8 -10 +| E N G -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy + LICENSE DISCLOSURES -#239584107 +d. If the Work includes a “NOTICE” text file as part of its distribution, then any Derivative Works that You -2 + distribute must include a readable copy of the attribution notices contained within such NOTICE file, excluding +those notices that do not pertain to any part of the Derivative Works, in at least one of the following places: +within a NOTICE text file distributed as part of the Derivative Works; within the Source form or documentation, +if provided along with the Derivative Works; or, within a display generated by the Derivative Works, if and +wherever such third-party notices normally appear. The contents of the NOTICE file are for informational +purposes only and do not modify the License. You may add Your own attribution notices within Derivative +Works that You distribute, alongside or as an addendum to the NOTICE text from the Work, provided that such +additional attribution notices cannot be construed as modifying the License. +You may add Your own copyright statement to Your modifications and may provide additional or different +license terms and conditions for use, reproduction, or distribution of Your modifications, or for any such + Derivative Works as a whole, provided Your use, reproduction, and distribution of the Work otherwise + complies with the conditions stated in this License. - Related resource + Submission of Contributions. Unless You explicitly state otherwise, any Contribution intentionally submitted for +inclusion in the Work by You to the Licensor shall be under the terms and conditions of this License, without any +additional terms or conditions. Notwithstanding the above, nothing herein shall supersede or modify the terms +of any separate license agreement you may have executed with Licensor regarding such Contributions. -The Social Media Metrics -that Really Matter—and -How to Track Them + Trademarks. This License does not grant permission to use the trade names, trademarks, service marks, or +product names of the Licensor, except as required for reasonable and customary use in describing the origin of +the Work and reproducing the content of the NOTICE file. -Step 1 + Disclaimer of Warranty. Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, Licensor provides the Work +(and each Contributor provides its Contributions) on an “AS IS” BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS +OF ANY KIND, either express or implied, including, without limitation, any warranties or conditions of TITLE, +NON-INFRINGEMENT, MERCHANTABILITY, or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. You are solely responsible +for determining the appropriateness of using or redistributing the Work and assume any risks associated with +Your exercise of permissions under this License. -Set social media marketing goals that align to -business objectives + Limitation of Liability. In no event and under no legal theory, whether in tort (including negligence), contract, +or otherwise, unless required by applicable law (such as deliberate and grossly negligent acts) or agreed to in +writing, shall any Contributor be liable to You for damages, including any direct, indirect, special, incidental, +or consequential damages of any character arising as a result of this License or out of the use or inability to +use the Work (including but not limited to damages for loss of goodwill, work stoppage, computer failure or +malfunction, or any and all other commercial damages or losses), even if such Contributor has been advised of +the possibility of such damages. -The more specific your strategy is, the more effective the execution will be. -Set SMART goals and track the right metrics to set yourself up for success. + Accepting Warranty or Additional Liability. While redistributing the Work or Derivative Works thereof, You may +choose to offer, and charge a fee for, acceptance of support, warranty, indemnity, or other liability obligations +and/or rights consistent with this License. However, in accepting such obligations, You may act only on Your own +behalf and on Your sole responsibility, not on behalf of any other Contributor, and only if You agree to indemnify, +defend, and hold each Contributor harmless for any liability incurred by, or claims asserted against, such + Contributor by reason of your accepting any such warranty or additional liability. -Set SMART goals +5. -The first step to creating a social media marketing strategy is to establish -your objectives and goals. Without goals, you have no way to measure your -success or your social media return on investment (ROI). +6. -Each of your goals should be: +7. -Specific +8. -Measurable +9. -Attainable +END OF TERMS AND CONDITIONS -Relevant +©2021 Bose Corporation -Time-bound +Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the “License”); you may not use this file except in compliance with +the License. -An example of a SMART goal for your business might be "Grow our Instagram -audience by 50 new followers per week." +You may obtain a copy of the License at: http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 -With SMART goals, you’ll make sure your goals actually lead to real business -results, rather than just lofty ideals. +Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an +“AS IS” BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License. -3 +9 + +| E N G + + WHAT’S IN THE BOX + +Contents ............................................................................................................................. 13 + +BOSE MUSIC APP + +Download the Bose Music app .................................................................................. 14 + +Add the headphones to an existing account ....................................................... 14 + +HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Power on ............................................................................................................................ 16 + +Standby timer .......................................................................................................... 16 + +Power off ............................................................................................................................ 17 + +Headphone functions .................................................................................................... 18 + +Media playback and volume ............................................................................... 18 + +Phone calls ................................................................................................................ 19 + +Action button ........................................................................................................... 20 + +NOISE CANCELLATION + +Noise cancelling modes................................................................................................ 21 + +Change the noise cancelling mode .......................................................................... 21 + +VOICE CONTROL + +Access voice control ...................................................................................................... 22 + +BLUETOOTH® CONNECTIONS + +Connect using the Bluetooth menu on your mobile device .......................... 23 + +Disconnect a mobile device ........................................................................................ 25 + +Reconnect a mobile device ......................................................................................... 25 + +Connect another mobile device ................................................................................ 25 + +Identify connected mobile devices .......................................................................... 25 + +Switch between two connected mobile devices ................................................ 25 + +Reconnect a previously connected device ........................................................... 26 + +Clear the headphone device list................................................................................ 26 + +1 0 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + WIRED CONNECTIONS + +Connect the audio cable .............................................................................................. 27 + +BATTERY + +Charge the headphones ............................................................................................... 28 + +Charging time........................................................................................................... 28 + +Hear the battery level ........................................................................................... 28 + +HEADPHONE STATUS + +Bluetooth status ............................................................................................................. 29 + +Battery status .................................................................................................................. 29 + +Charging status .............................................................................................................. 30 + +Update and error status .............................................................................................. 30 + +CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS + +Connect a Bose Smart Speaker or Soundbar ...................................................... 31 + +Benefits ....................................................................................................................... 31 + +Compatible products ............................................................................................ 31 + +Connect using the Bose Music app ................................................................. 31 + +Reconnect to a Bose Smart Speaker or Soundbar ............................................ 32 + +CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +Store the headphones ................................................................................................... 33 + +Clean the headphones .................................................................................................. 34 + +Replacement parts and accessories ........................................................................ 34 + +Limited warranty ............................................................................................................. 34 + +Serial number location .................................................................................................. 35 + +1 1 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + TROUBLESHOOTING + +Try these solutions first ................................................................................................ 36 + +Other solutions ................................................................................................................ 36 + +Restore the headphones to factory settings ....................................................... 39 + +1 2 + +| E N G + +CONTENTS + WHAT ’S IN THE BOX + +CONTENTS + +Confirm that the following parts are included: + +Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones + +Carry case + +USB Type-C® cable + +3.5 mm to 2.5 mm audio cable + +NOTE: If any part of your product is damaged, do not use it. Contact your authorized + +Bose dealer or Bose customer service. + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 - Track meaningful metrics +1 3 -While vanity metrics like retweets and likes can be fun to share and easy to -track, it’s hard to prove their real value for your business. Instead, focus on -targets such as leads generated, web referrals, and conversion rate. +| E N G -You may want to track different goals for different channels, or even different uses -of each channel. For example, you can use paid campaigns to increase brand - awareness, but measure acquisition and engagement for organic social posts. + BOSE MUSIC APP -Make sure to align your social media goals with your overall marketing -strategy. This will make it easier for you to show the value of your work and -get executive buy-in and investment. +The Bose Music app lets you set up and control the headphones from any mobile +device, such as a smartphone or tablet. -Start developing your social media marketing plan by writing down at least -three social media goals. +Using the app, you can manage Bluetooth connections, manage headphone settings, +choose your voice prompt language, and access new features through updates. -Goals +NOTE: If you’ve already created a Bose Music account for another Bose product, add +the headphones to your existing account (see the bottom of page 14). + +DOWNLOAD THE BOSE MUSIC APP + +1. On your mobile device, download the Bose Music app. + +B O S E M U S I C + +2. Follow the app instructions. + +ADD THE HEADPHONES TO AN EXISTING ACCOUNT + +To add your Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones, open the Bose Music app and add +your headphones. + +1 4 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Action button + +Multi-function button + +Power/Bluetooth +switch + +Volume up + +Volume down + +2.5 mm audio cable port + +USB-C® port + +1 5 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +POWER ON + +On the right earcup, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right. + +A voice prompt announces the battery level, and the status light glows according to +the current charge level (see page 29). + +Standby timer +The standby timer conserves the battery when the headphones are not being used. + +To set up and customize the standby timer, use the Bose Music app. + +1 6 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +POWER OFF + +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the left. + +NOTE: When the headphones are powered off, noise cancellation is disabled. + +1 7 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +HEADPHONE FUNCTIONS + +The headphone controls are located on the back of the right earcup. + +Media playback and volume + +Volume up + +Multi-function button +Volume down + +FUNCTION + +Play/Pause + +WHAT TO DO + +Press the Multi-function button. + +Skip forward + +Double-press the Multi-function button. + +Skip backward + +Triple-press the Multi-function button. + +Volume up + +Volume down + +NOTES: + +Press H. + +Press z. + +• To quickly increase the volume, press and hold H. +• To quickly decrease the volume, press and hold z. + +1 8 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Phone calls +The Multi-function button is located on the back of the right earcup. The microphone +is located near the front of the right earcup. + +The Action button is located on the back of the left earcup. + +Action button + +Multi-function button + +Microphone + +FUNCTION + +WHAT TO DO + +Answer/End a call + +Press the Multi-function button. + +Decline an incoming call + +Press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +Answer a second incoming +call and put the current call +on hold + +While on a call and a second incoming call is ringing, +press the Multi-function button. + +Decline a second incoming call +and stay on current call + +While on a call and a second incoming call is ringing, +press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +Switch between two calls + +While two calls are active, double-press the +Multi-function button. + +Create a conference call + +While two calls are active, press and hold the +Multi-function button for 3 seconds. + +Mute/Unmute a call + +While on a call, double-press the Action button. + +1 9 + +| E N G + + HEADPHONE CONTROLS + +Action button +The Action button allows you to quickly and easily switch between noise +cancelling modes. + +The Action button is located on the back of the left earcup. + +Action button + +To switch between Quiet Mode and Aware Mode, press the Action button. + +For information about noise cancelling modes, see page 21. + +2 0 + +| E N G + + NOISE CANCELLATION + +Noise cancelling reduces unwanted noise, providing a clearer and more lifelike audio +performance. You can choose between two noise cancelling modes: Quiet and Aware. + +Quiet Mode allows you to block out distractions using the highest level of +noise cancellation. + +Aware Mode provides full transparency and allows you to hear your surroundings +while enjoying your audio. + +Choose your noise noise cancelling mode based on your listening preferences +and environment. + +NOISE CANCELLING MODES + +MODE + +Quiet + +Aware + +DESCRIPTION + +World-class noise cancellation with Bose-optimized audio. + +Hear your surroundings while enjoying your audio. + +NOTE: When powered on, the headphones default to the last mode you used. + +CHANGE THE NOISE CANCELLING MODE + +To change the noise cancelling mode, press the Action button. + +A voice prompt announces the selected noise cancelling mode. + +TIP: You can also change the noise cancelling mode using the Bose Music app. + +2 1 + +| E N G + + VOICE CONTROL + +ACCESS VOICE CONTROL + +You can use the headphones to access voice control on your mobile device. To access +voice control, press and hold the Multi-function button for 1 second. + +The Multi-function button is located on the back of the right earcup. + +NOTE: You can’t access voice control while on a call. + +2 2 + +| E N G + + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS + +CONNECT USING THE BLUETOOTH MENU ON YOUR + MOBILE DEVICE + +You can store up to eight devices in the headphone device list, and the headphones +can be actively connected to two devices at a time. You can play audio from only one +device at a time. + +NOTE: For the best experience, use the Bose Music app to set up and connect your + +mobile device (see page 14). 1. -2. + Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for 3 seconds. -3. +You hear “Ready to connect,” and the status light blinks blue. -Step 2 +2 3 -Related resource +| E N G -How to build audience -personas + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Learn everything you can about your audience +2. On your device, enable the Bluetooth feature. -if you’re not engaged in social media listening, you’re creating your business -strategy with blinders on—and you’re missing out on mountains of actionable -insights from real people who are actively talking about you or your industry online. +NOTE: The Bluetooth feature is usually found in the Settings menu. -Here’s how to start listening and building your understanding of your -audience and their needs. +3. Select your headphones from the device list. -Create audience personas +TIP: Look for the name you entered for your headphones in the Bose Music app. -tKnowing who your audience is and what they want to see on social is key to -creating content that they will like, comment on, and share. This knowledge -also critical for planning how to develop your social media fans into -customers for your business. +If you didn’t name your headphones, the default name appears. -Try creating audience personas. For example, a retail brand might create -different personas based on demographics, buying motivations, common -buying objections, and the emotional needs of each type of customer. +QuietComfort 45 -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Once connected, you hear “Connected to ,” and the status light +glows solid blue for 10 seconds. -4 +2 4 - Personas sharpen your marketing tactics. Luxury buyers, for example, -might not respond to Facebook ads with sales. But they might respond to -Facebook ads with exclusive in-store events to be the first to see a new line of -clothing. With personas, you’ll have the customer insights you need to create -campaigns that speak to the real desires and motivations of your buyers. +| E N G -Gather real-world data + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Don’t make assumptions. Social media analytics can also provide a ton of -valuable information about who your followers are, where they live, which -languages they speak, and how they interact with your brand on social. These -insights allow you to refine your strategy and better target your social ads. +DISCONNECT A MOBILE DEVICE -Jugnoo, an Uber-like service for auto-rickshaws in India, used Facebook -Analytics to learn that 90 percent of their users who referred other -customers were between 18 and 34 years old, and that 65 percent of that -group was using Android. They used this information to target their ads, -resulting in a 40 percent lower cost per referral. +Use the Bose Music app to disconnect your mobile device. -Step 3 +TIP: You can also use Bluetooth settings to disconnect your device. Disabling the -Research the competition +Bluetooth feature disconnects all other devices. -Odds are, your competitors are already using social media—and that means -you can learn from what they’re already doing. +RECONNECT A MOBILE DEVICE -Conduct a competitive analysis +When powered on, the headphones try to reconnect with the two most + recently-connected devices. -A competitive analysis allows you to understand who the competition is and -what they’re doing well (and not so well). You’ll get a good sense of what’s -expected in your industry, which will help you set some social media targets -of your own. +NOTES: -This analysis will also help you spot opportunities. For example, maybe -one of your competitors dominates on Facebook, but has put little effort -into Twitter or Instagram. You might want to focus on the networks where -your audience is underserved, rather than trying to win fans away from a -dominant player. +• The device must be within range (30 ft or 9 m) and powered on. -Engage in social listening +• Make sure the Bluetooth feature is enabled on your mobile device. -Social listening is another way to keep track of the competition. +CONNECT ANOTHER MOBILE DEVICE -As you track your competitors’ accounts and relevant industry keywords, you -may notice strategic shifts in the way competitors use their social accounts. -Or you might spot a specific post or campaign that really hits the mark—or -one that bombs. +To connect another device, download the Bose Music app (see page 14) or use the +Bluetooth menu on your mobile device (see page 23). -Keep an eye on this information and use to it evaluate your own goals and plans. +NOTE: You can only play audio from one device at a time. -Related resources +IDENTIFY CONNECTED MOBILE DEVICES +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release to hear which device is + currently connected. -How to conduct a -competitor audit +SWITCH BETWEEN TWO CONNECTED +MOBILE DEVICES -Getting started with -social listening +1. Pause audio on your first mobile device. -Watch: How to set up -social listening streams +2. Play audio on your second mobile device. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +NOTE: Your headphones receive phone calls from both devices, regardless of -5 +which device is playing audio. - Related resource +2 5 -Hootsuite’s social media -audit template +| E N G -Step 4 + BLUETOOTH CONNECTIONS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Conduct a social media audit +RECONNECT A PREVIOUSLY CONNECTED DEVICE -Conducting a social media audit helps you assess how well your current -social media use works for you. +1. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release to hear which device -Evaluate your current efforts +is connected. -If you’re already using social media tools, you need to take a step back and look -at what you’ve already accomplished. Ask yourself the following questions: +2. Within 2 seconds, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and release -•• What’s working? +again to connect to the next device in the headphone device list. -•• What’s not working? +3. Repeat until you hear the correct device name. -•• Who’s connecting with you on social? +You hear a tone that indicates when the device is connected. -•• Which social media sites does your target market use? +4. Play audio on the connected mobile device. -•• How does your social media presence compare to that of your competitors? +NOTE: If two devices are already connected to the headphones, the newly-connected -Once you gather all this information in one place, you’ll have a good starting -point for planning how to improve your results. +device replaces the second device that was previously connected. -Your audit should give you a clear picture of what purpose each of your -social accounts serves. If the purpose of an account isn’t clear, think about -whether it’s worth keeping. It may be a valuable account that just needs -a strategic redirection, or it may be an outdated account that’s no longer -worth your while. +CLEAR THE HEADPHONE DEVICE LIST -To help you decide, ask yourself the following questions: +1. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for 15 seconds, until you -1. Is my audience here? +hear “Bluetooth device list cleared. Ready to connect.” -2. If so, how are they using this platform? +2. Delete your headphones from the Bluetooth list on your mobile device. -3. Can I use this account to help achieve meaningful business goals? +All devices are cleared and the headphones are ready to connect. -Asking these tough questions now will help keep your social media strategy -on track as you grow your social presence. +2 6 -Look for impostor accounts +| E N G -During your audit process, you may discover fraudulent accounts using your -business name or the names of your products—that is, accounts that you -and your business don’t own. + WIRED CONNECTIONS -These imposter accounts can be harmful to your brand (never mind -capturing followers that should be yours), so be sure to report them. You -may want to get your social accounts verified to ensure your fans and -followers know they are dealing with the real you. +CONNECT THE AUDIO CABLE -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Use the 2.5 mm to 3.5 mm cable to connect a non-wireless device or to continue using +the headphones if the battery is depleted. -6 +1. Connect the cable into the 2.5 mm port on the left earcup. - Related resources +2. Connect the other end of the cable into the 3.5 mm port on your device. -Watch: How to optimize -your social profiles +NOTE: You can use the headphones powered on or off when the the audio cable -We’ve also got step-by-step -guides for each network -to walk you through the -process: +is connected. -Create a Facebook -business page +2 7 -Create an Instagram -business account +| E N G -Create a Twitter business -account + BATTERY -Create a Snapchat -account +CHARGE THE HEADPHONES -Create a LinkedIn -Company Page +1. Connect the small end of the USB cable into the USB-C port on the -Create a Pinterest -business account +right earcup. -Create a YouTube channel +2. Connect the other end into a USB wall charger. -Create a WeChat business -account +NOTES: -Don’t let this list overwhelm -you. Remember, it’s better to -use fewer channels well than -to stretch yourself thin trying -to maintain a presence on -every social network. +• When the headphones begin charging, the status light blinks white for 10 seconds. -Finally, here’s a quick -reference guide for image -sizes for every network. +When fully charged, the status light glows solid white. -Step 5 +• The headphones don’t play while charging. -Set up accounts and improve existing profiles +Charging time +Allow up to 2.5 hours to fully charge the headphones. -Decide which networks you’ll focus on, and then set up and optimize your -accounts. +Hear the battery level +Each time you power on the headphones, a voice prompt announces the battery level. +When the headphone battery is low, you hear “Battery low, please charge now.” -Determine which networks to use (and how to use them) +NOTE: To visually check the battery, see the status light l ocated on the right earcup. -As you decide which social channels to use, you’ll also need to define your -strategy for each network. For example, you might decide to use Twitter for -customer service, Facebook for customer acquisition, and Instagram for -engaging existing customers. +For more information, see “Battery status” on page 29. -It’s a good exercise to create mission statements for each network. These -one-sentence declarations will help you focus on a very specific goal for -each account on each social network. +2 8 -For example, you could decide that: +| E N G -•• Facebook is best for acquiring new customers via paid advertising. + HEADPHONE STATUS -•• +The status light is located on the right earcup. -Instagram is where you build brand affinity with existing customers. + Headphone +status light -•• Twitter is where you engage press and industry influencers. +BLUETOOTH STATUS -•• LinkedIn is where you engage existing employees and attract new talent. +Shows the Bluetooth connection status. -•• YouTube is where you support existing customers with education and +LIGHT ACTIVITY -video help content. +SYSTEM STATE -•• Snapchat is where you distribute content with the goal of building brand +Blinking blue -awareness with younger consumers. +Ready to connect -If you can’t create a solid mission statement for a particular social network, -you may want to reconsider whether that network is worth it. +Solid blue (10 seconds) -Set up (and optimize) your accounts +Connected -Once you’ve decided which networks to focus on, it’s time to create your -profiles—or improve existing profiles so they align with your strategic plan. +BATTERY STATUS -In general, make sure you fill out all profile fields, use keywords people will -use to search for your business, and use images that are correctly sized for -each network. +Shows the battery level. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +LIGHT ACTIVITY -7 +SYSTEM STATE - Step 6 +Solid white -Find inspiration +Solid amber -While it’s important that your brand be distinctive and unique, you can still -draw inspiration from other businesses that are great on social. +Medium to full charge -Social network success stories +Low charge -All of the social networks feature success stories that highlight how brands -are using their tools effectively. You can usually find these on the business -section of the social network’s website. (For example, take a look at the -Facebook business success stories.) These case studies offer valuable -insights you can apply to your own goals for each social network. +TIP: You can also check the battery level using the Bose Music app. -Award-winning accounts and campaigns +2 9 -For examples of brands that are at the top of their social media game, check -out the winners of The Facebook Awards or The Shorty Awards. +| E N G -Step 7 + HEADPHONE STATUS +WHAT’S IN THE BOX -Create a social media content calendar +CHARGING STATUS -Sharing great content is essential, of course, but it’s equally important to have -a plan in place for when you’ll share content to get the maximum impact. +Shows the charging status. -Your social media content calendar also needs to account for the time you’ll -spend interacting with your audience (although you need to allow for some -spontaneous engagement as well). +LIGHT ACTIVITY -Create a posting schedule +Blinks white 2 times -Your social media content calendar lists the dates and times at which you will -publish types of content on each channel. It’s the perfect place to plan all of your -social media activities—from images and link sharing to blog posts and videos. +Solid amber -Your calendar ensures your posts are spaced out appropriately and -published at the optimal times. It should include both your day-to-day posts -and your content for social media campaigns. +Solid white -Related resources +SYSTEM STATE -How to create a social -media content calendar +Charging begins -Watch: How to save time -with bulk scheduling +Charging -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +Full charge -8 +UPDATE AND ERROR STATUS - Plot your content mix +Shows the update or error status. -Make sure your calendar reflects the mission statement you’ve assigned to -each social profile, so that everything you post is working to support your -business goals. For example, you might decide that: +LIGHT ACTIVITY -•• 50 percent of content will drive traffic back to your blog +SYSTEM STATE -•• 25 percent of content will be curated from other sources +Fast blinking white (10 seconds) -•• 20 percent of content will support enterprise goals (selling, lead +Updating software (via USB) -generation, and so on) +Slow blinking white (30 to 60 seconds) -•• 5 percent of content will be about your employees and company culture +Updating software (wirelessly) -Placing these different post types in your content calendar will help ensure -you maintain the ratio you’ve planned. If you’re starting from scratch and -you’re simply not sure what types of content to post, try the 80-20 rule: +Blinking amber and white -•• 80 percent of your posts should inform, educate, or entertain your audience +Error - contact Bose customer service -•• 20 percent can directly promote your brand +3 0 -You could also try the social media rule of thirds: +| E N G -•• One-third of your social content promotes your business, converts + CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS -readers, and generates profit +CONNECT A BOSE SMART SPEAKER OR SOUNDBAR -•• One-third of your social content shares ideas and stories from thought +Using SimpleSync™ technology, you can connect the headphones to a Bose Smart + Soundbar or Bose Smart Speaker for a personal listening experience. -leaders in your industry or like-minded businesses +Benefits +• Use independent volume controls on each product to lower or mute your Bose -•• One-third of your social content involves personal interactions with your +Smart Soundbar while keeping the headphones as loud as you like. -audience +• Hear your music clearly from the next room by connecting the headphones to your -Once you have your calendar set, use scheduling tools or bulk scheduling to -prepare your posting in advance rather than updating constantly throughout -the day. This allows you to focus on crafting the language and format of your -posts, rather than writing them on the fly whenever you have time. +Bose Smart Speaker. -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +NOTE: SimpleSync™ technology has a Bluetooth range of up to 30 ft (9 m). Walls and -9 + construction materials can affect reception. + +Compatible products +You can connect the headphones to any Bose Smart Speaker or Bose Smart Soundbar. + +Popular compatible products include: + +• Bose Smart Soundbar 700/Bose Soundbar 700 + +• Bose Soundbar 500 + +• Bose Smart Speaker 500/Bose Home Speaker 500 + +• Bose Home Speaker 300 + +• Bose Portable Smart Speaker/Bose Portable Home Speaker + +New products are added periodically. For a complete list and more information, +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups +visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups + +Connect using the Bose Music app + +1. On the headphones, slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold for + +3 seconds. + +You hear “Ready to connect another device,” and the status light blinks blue. + +2. Use the Bose Music app to connect the headphones to a compatible Bose product. + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups +For more information, visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/Groups + +NOTES: + +• Make sure that the headphones are within 30 ft (9 m) of your soundbar or speaker. + +• You can connect the headphones to only one product at a time. + +3 1 + +| E N G + + CONNECT BOSE PRODUCTS + +RECONNECT TO A BOSE SMART SPEAKER +OR SOUNDBAR + +Power on the headphones (see “Power on” on page 16). + +The headphones try to connect to the two most recently-connected Bluetooth + devices, including your soundbar or speaker. + +NOTES: + +• Your soundbar or speaker must be within range (30 ft or 9 m) and powered on. + +• If the headphones don’t reconnect, see “Headphones don’t reconnect to a + + previously-connected Bose Smart Soundbar or Speaker” on page 38. + +3 2 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +STORE THE HEADPHONES + +The earcups rotate for easy, convenient storage. Place the headphones flat into +the case. + +1. Rotate both earcups inward so they lay flat. + +Left earcup + +Right earcup + +2. Fold the left earcup up toward the headband. + +NOTES: + +• Make sure to power off the headphones when not in use. + +• Before storing the headphones for more than a few months, make sure the battery + +is fully charged. + +3 3 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +CLEAN THE HEADPHONES + +Wipe the outside surfaces with a soft, dry cloth. + +Don’t allow moisture to get inside the earcups. + +REPLACEMENT PARTS AND ACCESSORIES + +Replacement parts and accessories can be ordered through Bose customer service. +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 + +LIMITED WARRANTY + +Your headphones are covered by a limited warranty. Visit our website at +global.Bose.com/warranty for details of the limited warranty. +global.Bose.com/warranty + +To register your product, visit global.Bose.com/register + register will not affect your limited warranty rights. + +global.Bose.com/register for instructions. Failure to + +3 4 + +| E N G + + CARE AND MAINTENANCE + +SERIAL NUMBER LOCATION + +The serial number is located inside the right earcup under the scrim. The scrim is the +inner screen that covers and protects the components inside the earcup. + +To view the serial number, grab the scrim at the top edge and gently peel it away. + +CAUTION: Be careful not to press down on or remove any other components inside + +the earcup as this could damage the headphones. + +S/N: 011001000100010AE + +S +/ + +N: 0 + +1 +1 +0 +0 +1 +0 +0 +0 +1 +0 +0 +0 +1 +0 +A +E + +Scrim + +3 5 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +TRY THESE SOLUTIONS FIRST + +If you experience problems with your headphones: + +• Check the state of the status light (see page 29). + +• Charge the battery (see page 28). + +• Increase the volume on your headphones, mobile device, and music app. + +• Try connecting another mobile device (see page 25). + +If you could not resolve your issue, see the table below to identify symptoms and + solutions to common problems. If you are unable to resolve your issue, contact +Bose customer service. + +worldwide.Bose.com/contact +Visit: worldwide.Bose.com/contact + +OTHER SOLUTIONS + +SYMPTOM + +SOLUTION + +Headphones don’t +power on + +Charge the battery. + +Headphones don’t +connect with your +mobile device + +Battery won’t charge + +Disconnect the back-up audio cable. + +Disconnect the USB charging cable. + +On your mobile device: + +Disable the Bluetooth feature and then re-enable. + +Delete your Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones from the + Bluetooth list on your device. Connect again. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Visit worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 + +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 to see how-to videos. + +Clear the connected devices list (see page 26) and +connect again. + +Secure the ends of the USB charging cable. + +Try another charging source. + +If your headphones have been exposed to high or low + temperatures, let the headphones return to room temperature +and try charging again. + +3 6 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +SYMPTOM + +SOLUTION + +No sound + +Power on the headphones and charge the battery. + +Check the state of the status light (see page 29). + +Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right and release to hear +the connected device. Make sure you are using the +correct device. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Use a different music source. + +If two mobile devices are connected, pause your other +device first. + +If two mobile devices are connected, move the devices within +range of the headphones (30 ft or 9 m). + +Try a locally stored music or video file on your mobile device. + +Use a different music source. + +Connect another mobile device (see page 25). + +Poor sound quality + +Disconnect the second device. + +Move your mobile device closer to the headphones and away +from any interference or obstructions. + +Try a locally stored music or video file on your mobile device. + +No sound from a device +connected by the + back-up audio cable + +Secure the ends of the back-up audio cable. + +Increase the volume on your headphones, your mobile device +and music source. + +Connect another device (see page 25). + +Poor sound quality from +a device connected by +audio cable + +Secure the ends of the back-up audio cable. + +Connect another device (see page 25). + +Action button doesn’t +change the noise + cancelling mode + +Make sure your headphones are powered on. + +Use the Bose Music app to change the noise cancelling mode. + +3 7 + +| E N G + + TROUBLESHOOTING + +SYMPTOM - Step 8 +SOLUTION -Test, evaluate, and adjust your strategy +Headphones don’t +connect to a Bose Smart +Soundbar or Speaker -Your social media strategy is a hugely important document for your -business, and you can’t assume you’ll get it exactly right on the first try. +Slide and hold the Power/Bluetooth button until you hear “Ready +to connect another device,” and the Bluetooth light blinks blue. -As you start to implement your plan and track your results, you may find -that some strategies don’t work as well as you’d anticipated, while others are -working even better than expected. +Make sure that the headphones are within 30 ft (9 m) of your +soundbar or speaker. -Track your data +Headphones don’t +reconnect to a + previously-connected +Bose Smart Soundbar or +Speaker -In addition to using the analytics tools available within each social network, -use UTM parameters to track visitors as they move through your website, so -you can see exactly which social posts drive the most traffic to your website. +Delayed audio when + connected to a Bose +Smart Soundbar or +Speaker -Re-evaluate, test, and do it all again +Reconnect a previously-connected device +(see page 26). -When data starts coming in, use it to reevaluate your strategy regularly. -You can also use this information to test different posts, campaigns, and -strategies against one another. Constant testing allows you to understand -what works and what doesn’t, so you can refine your strategy in real time. +Download the Bose Music app and run available +software updates. -Surveys can also be a great way to find out how well your strategy is working. -Ask your social media followers, email list, and website visitors whether -you’re meeting their needs and expectations on social media. You can even -ask them what they’d like to see more of—and then make sure to deliver on -what they tell you. +3 8 -Things change fast on social media. New networks emerge, while others -go through significant demographic shifts. Your business will go through -periods of change as well. All this means that your social media strategy -should be a living document that you look at regularly and adjust as needed. -Refer to it often to keep you on track, but don’t be afraid to make changes -so that it better reflects new goals, tools, or plans. +| E N G -When you update your social strategy, make sure to let everyone on your -social team know, so they can all work together to help your business make -the most of your social media accounts. + TROUBLESHOOTING -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +A restore to factory settings can clear all settings and return the headphones to their +original out-of-box state. After, the headphones can be configured as if they were +being set up for the first time. -10 +Restoring to factory settings is only recommended if you are having issues with the +headphones, or you have been instructed to do so by Bose customer service. - Bonus: Download our social media -strategy template -Does this all feel a little overwhelming? The truth is that building your social -media strategy is a substantial job. It should be, since it’s such an important -document for your business. But it doesn’t have to be complicated. +RESTORE THE HEADPHONES TO FACTORY SETTINGS -We’ve created a template to guide you through the whole process of -creating your social media marketing plan. Visit our blog to download it (plus -six other social media templates that can save you hours of work). +1. Remove the headphones from the Bluetooth list on your device. -Take the next leap in your social media career +2. Remove the headphones from your Bose account using the Bose Music app. -Hootsuite Academy +NOTE: For more information about how to remove the headphones from your -Earn industry-recognized social media certifications that will make you stand -out from the crowd. +Bose account using the Bose Music app, visit: +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 +worldwide.Bose.com/Support/QC45 -Begin with our free comprehensive training on social marketing. All of our -courses are delivered online and taught by expert industry practitioners. -Take the free course here. +3. Slide the Power/Bluetooth switch to the right l and hold. At the same time, press -Build a professional workflow with Hootsuite +and hold the Action button for 30 seconds. -From scheduling Instagram posts to advanced ROI measurement, Hootsuite’s -flexible platform helps you execute every aspect of your social media strategy. -We’re the world’s most widely used platform for managing social media. +The LED indicator blinks white. After 30 seconds, the LED indicator blinks amber +to indicate factory settings are being restored (2 to 3 seconds). -Get started with the plan that fits your needs here. +4. When the rest is complete, the LED indicator slowly blinks blue. The headphones -Did you find this guide helpful? +are now in their original out-of-box state. -Tell us whether we should praise our writers or shout at them. Either way, -we appreciate your honest feedback. Take our 4-minute survey here. +3 9 -GUIDE / Social Media Marketing Strategy +| E N G -11 + ©2021 Bose Corporation, 100 The Mountain Road, Framingham, MA 01701-9168 USA +AM869288-0010 Rev. 01 diff --git a/q93/random_k4/random_3.md b/q93/random_k4/random_3.md index a3dc1706697305f386511b9ffe82f7da6d664b28..7601950bafab389d8953b58e2830846ac4961253 100644 --- a/q93/random_k4/random_3.md +++ b/q93/random_k4/random_3.md @@ -1,179 +1,623 @@ -Kohl's Reports First Quarter Fiscal 2023 Financial Results -MENOMONEE FALLS, Wis.--(BUSINESS WIRE)—May 24, 2023-- Kohl’s Corporation (NYSE:KSS) today reported results for the first quarter -ended April 29, 2023. -● Net sales decreased 3.3% and comparable sales decreased 4.3% -● Gross margin increased 67 basis points -● Diluted earnings per share of $0.13 -● Inventory declined 6% -● Affirms full year 2023 financial outlook -● Remains committed to strengthening balance sheet and to maintaining current dividend -Tom Kingsbury, Kohl’s chief executive officer, said “Our first quarter results were in line with our expectations and represented a first step as we -work to drive sales and earnings performance over the long-term. We delivered margin expansion, as well as a 6% reduction in inventory. In -addition, our stores business achieved productivity gains and Sephora at Kohl’s continued its sales momentum.” -“We are making progress against each of our key 2023 priorities, enhancing our customer experience, simplifying our value strategies, -managing inventory and expenses with discipline, and strengthening our balance sheet. I would like to thank the entire Kohl’s team for driving -against these priorities with a clear focus and strong determination. While there is still work to be done and the macroeconomic environment -remains challenging, we are affirming our 2023 guidance and continue to have conviction in Kohl’s longer term opportunity,” Kingsbury -continued. -First Quarter 2023 Results -Comparisons refer to the 13-week period ended April 29, 2023 versus the 13-week period ended April 30, 2022 -● Net sales decreased 3.3% year-over-year, to $3.4 billion, with comparable sales down 4.3%. -● Gross margin as a percentage of net sales was 39.0%, an increase of 67 basis points. -● Selling, general & administrative (SG&A) expenses decreased 4.2% year-over-year, to $1.2 billion. As a percentage of total -revenue, SG&A expenses were 34.7%, a decrease of 13 basis points year-over-year. -● Operating income was $98 million compared to $82 million in the prior year. As a percentage of total revenue, operating income was -2.8%, an increase of 55 basis points year-over-year. -● Net income was $14 million, or $0.13 per share. This compares to net income of $14 million, or $0.11 per share in the prior year. -● Inventory was $3.5 billion, a decrease of 6% year-over-year. -● Operating cash flow was a use of ($202) million. -2023 Financial and Capital Allocation Outlook -For the full year 2023, the Company affirms its financial outlook and currently expects the following: -● Net sales: A decrease of (2%) to (4%), includes the impact of the 53rd week which is worth approximately 1% year-over-year. -● Operating margin: Approximately 4.0%. -● Diluted earnings per share: In the range of $2.10 to $2.70, excluding any non-recurring charges. -● Capital Expenditures: $600 million to $650 million, including expansion of its Sephora partnership and store refresh activity. -● Dividend: On May 10, 2023, Kohl’s Board of Directors declared a quarterly cash dividend on the Company’s common stock of $0.50 -per share. The dividend is payable June 21, 2023 to shareholders of record at the close of business on June 7, 2023. -● Debt Reduction: The Company retired $164 million of bonds that matured in February 2023, and expects to retire $111 million of -bonds maturing in December 2023. - -First Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call -Kohl’s will host its quarterly earnings conference call at 9:00 am ET on May 24, 2023. A webcast of the conference call and the related -presentation materials will be available via the Company's web site at investors.kohls.com , both live and after the call. -Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Information -This press release contains “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. The -Company intends forward-looking terminology such as “believes,” “expects,” “may,” “will,” “should,” “anticipates,” “plans,” or similar expressions -to identify forward-looking statements. Such statements are subject to certain risks and uncertainties, which could cause the Company's actual -results to differ materially from those anticipated by the forward-looking statements. These risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited -to, risks described more fully in Item 1A in the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K, which are expressly incorporated herein by reference, -and other factors as may periodically be described in the Company’s filings with the SEC. Forward-looking statements relate to the date initially -made, and Kohl’s undertakes no obligation to update them. -About Kohl's -Kohl’s (NYSE: KSS) is a leading omnichannel retailer. With more than 1,100 stores in 49 states and the online convenience of Kohls.com and -the Kohl's App, Kohl's offers amazing national and exclusive brands at incredible savings for families nationwide. Kohl’s is committed to -progress in its diversity and inclusion pledges, and the company's environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) stewardship. For a -list of store locations or to shop online, visit Kohls.com . For more information about Kohl’s impact in the community or how to join our winning -team, visit Corporate.Kohls.com . -Contacts -Investor Relations: -Mark Rupe, (262) 703-1266, mark.rupe@kohls.com -Media: -Jen Johnson, (262) 703-5241, jen.johnson@kohls.com - - KOHL’S CORPORATION - CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS - (Unaudited) - Three Months Ended - (Dollars in Millions, Except per Share Data) April 29, 2023 April 30, 2022 -| Net sales | $ | 3,355 $ | 3,471 | -| -------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -| Other revenue | | 216 | 244 | -| Total revenue | | 3,571 | 3,715 | -| Cost of merchandise sold | | 2,047 | 2,140 | -| Gross margin rate | | 39.0 % | 38.3 % | - Operating expenses: -| Selling, general, and administrative | | 1,238 | 1,293 | -| -------------------------------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | -| As a percent of total revenue | | 34.7 % | 34.8 % | -| Depreciation and amortization | | 188 | 200 | -| Operating income | | 98 | 82 | -| Interest expense, net | | 84 | 68 | -| Income before income taxes | | 14 | 14 | -| Provision (benefit) for income taxes | | — | — | -| Net income | $ | 14 $ | 14 | - Average number of shares: -| Basic | | 110 | 127 | -| --------- | --- | ----- | ----- | -| Diluted | | 111 | 129 | - Earnings per share: -| Basic | $ | 0.13 $ | 0.11 | -| --------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -| Diluted | $ | 0.13 $ | 0.11 | - - KOHL’S CORPORATION - CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS - (Unaudited) -| | | | April 29, | | April 30, | | -| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -| (Dollars in Millions) | | | 2023 | | 2022 | | - Assets - Current assets: -| | Cash and cash equivalents | $ | | 286 $ | | 646 | -| ----------------------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | -| | Merchandise inventories | | | 3,526 | | 3,736 | -| | Other | | | 347 | | 381 | -| | Total current assets | | | 4,159 | | 4,763 | -| Property and equipment, net | | | | 7,803 | | 7,790 | -| Operating leases | | | | 2,368 | | 2,224 | -| Other assets | | | | 380 | | 476 | -| | Total assets | $ | | 14,710 $ | | 15,253 | - Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity - Current liabilities: -| | Accounts payable | $ | | 1,310 $ | | 1,679 | -| --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | -| | Accrued liabilities | | | 1,164 | | 1,316 | -| | Borrowings under revolving credit facility | | | 765 | | — | - Current portion of: -| | Long-term debt | | | 111 | | 164 | -| ------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| | Finance leases and financing obligations | | | 93 | | 108 | -| | Operating leases | | | 111 | | 127 | -| | Total current liabilities | | | 3,554 | | 3,394 | -| Long-term debt | | | | 1,637 | | 1,746 | -| Finance leases and financing obligations | | | | 2,710 | | 2,584 | -| Operating leases | | | | 2,634 | | 2,474 | -| Deferred income taxes | | | | 129 | | 209 | -| Other long-term liabilities | | | | 326 | | 390 | -| Shareholders' equity | | | | 3,720 | | 4,456 | - Total liabilities and shareholders' equity $ 14,710 $ 15,253 - - KOHL’S CORPORATION - CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS - (Unaudited) - Three Months Ended -| | April 29, | | April 30, | | -| ----------------------- | ----------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -| (Dollars in Millions) | | 2023 | 2022 | | - Operating activities - Net income -| | $ | 14 $ | | 14 | -| --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---- | - Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash - used in operating activities: -| Depreciation and amortization | | 188 | | 200 | -| ------------------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | -| Share-based compensation | | 9 | | 18 | -| Deferred income taxes | | 1 | | 2 | -| Non-cash lease expense | | 25 | | 31 | -| Other non-cash items | | (4) | | 3 | - Changes in operating assets and liabilities: -| Merchandise inventories | | (336) | | (668) | -| ----------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | -| Other current and long-term assets | | 49 | | (42) | -| Accounts payable | | (20) | | (4) | -| Accrued and other long-term liabilities | | (101) | | 17 | -| Operating lease liabilities | | (27) | | (31) | -| Net cash used in operating activities | | (202) | | (460) | - Investing activities -| Acquisition of property and equipment | | (94) | | (221) | -| --------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | ------- | -| Proceeds from sale of real estate | | 1 | | 4 | -| Other | | (1) | | — | -| Net cash used in investing activities | | (94) | | (217) | - Financing activities -| Net borrowings under revolving credit facility | | 680 | | — | -| ------------------------------------------------ | --- | ----- | --- | ------- | -| Treasury stock purchases | | — | | (158) | - Shares withheld for taxes on vested restricted shares (12) (18) -| Dividends paid | | (55) | | (63) | -| ----------------------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | -| Repayment of long-term borrowings | | (164) | | — | - Finance lease and financing obligation payments (25) (29) -| Proceeds from financing obligations | | 5 | | 4 | -| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | - Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities 429 (264) - Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents 133 (941) - Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period 153 1,587 - Cash and cash equivalents at end of period -| | $ | 286 $ | | 646 | -| --- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- | \ No newline at end of file +PRINCIPLES AND CHARACTERISTICS + +OF + +GRADUATE EDUCATION + +BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY + + Principles and Characteristics of +Graduate Education + at Brigham Young University + +Graduate education distinguishes itself by advanced systematic study and experience in depth—a +depth in understanding, knowledge, scholarly competence, inquiry and discovery. Graduates are equipped +to contribute to their disciplines, to teach and transmit knowledge within their disciplines, to conduct +research and produce creative works, to apply their learning in the everyday world, and ultimately to extend +service to their disciplines and to humanity. + +Although diversity in focus, methodology, and implementation is expected across the spectrum of +graduate programs at BYU, strong programs are characterized by selective admission of highly qualified +students, graduate faculty committed to excellence, and rigorous programs of study conducted in a context +of faith. A few fundamental principles characterize all strong graduate programs. These principles emerge +from and complement the Mission and Aims of a BYU Education. These principles are listed below +followed by some characteristics that are required to realize these principles. + +Principles of Graduate Education + +Mastery of the subject matter. Graduate education facilitates mastery over the content and + +skills of the discipline at a level appropriate to the degree sought. + +Critical thinking. Graduate education develops and refines critical thinking skills including a +thorough knowledge of the assumptions of the discipline and an understanding of viable alternative +assumptions. + +Theoretical understanding. Graduate education provides an understanding of the theoretical + +bases of the field of study. It grounds application and performance in theory. + +Proficiency in research and/or creative activities. Graduate education develops proficiencies +that advance the knowledge and activities of the discipline. These proficiencies include good writing skills +as well as the ability to present original insights and creative expressions. + +Spiritual discernment and moral integrity. Graduate education facilitates the growth of + +integrity and wisdom and the integration of faith into the pursuit of knowledge within the discipline. + +Service orientation. Graduate education instills responsibility to return the special benefits of + +graduate training to the larger community. + + Wide representation of perspectives . Graduate education presents an intellectually and +culturally rich encounter with the discipline. Study and inquiry are conducted in a context sensitive to ethnic +and cultural diversity. + +Characteristics of Strong Graduate Programs + +I. + +Clear Definition of Purpose + +A. + +Planned programs + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +Only graduate degrees essential to the department’s mission and important to the +larger mission of the university are offered by the department. + +The department has determined and clearly stated the aims for the future of its +graduate program(s). It has a plan for constant improvement and is pursuing it +vigorously. + +The department has determined and clearly stated the focus and purpose of its +graduate program(s). It does not necessarily attempt to offer degrees or emphases +in all areas of its discipline. Students admitted pursue coursework, research, and +degrees only in areas in which faculty are producing and publishing scholarly work +and are well qualified to teach and direct research. + +The department regularly evaluates its graduate programs, faculty, facilities, and +library holdings, identifying weak areas that need strengthening and determining if +any programs or emphases should be dropped or added. + +B. + +Theoretical orientation + +1. + +2. + +The department does not see a graduate degree as simply an accumulation of +credits. Faculty members understand that graduate work at a university is +inherently involved in the discovery of new knowledge, and they seek to +understand and propound the theoretical principles that lie behind what can be +observed and tested. + +Graduate education extends beyond the acquisition of practical skills and +endeavors to encompass the practical within the theoretical. The department +makes a concerted effort to educate graduate students to extend their +understanding using both tools and theory. + +2 + + II. Qualified Graduate Faculty + +A. + +Effective mentoring + +1. + +2. + +3. + +The department and college apply appropriate criteria for identifying graduate +faculty. There are sufficient numbers of well-prepared, full-time graduate faculty +members in the department’s areas of specialty to support strong graduate work +in those areas. All department faculty members support the graduate programs of +the department. + +Department faculty members keep current in their fields and continually update +course content and teaching methods to engage students and immerse them in the +discipline. + +Faculty members strengthen students spiritually by integrating spirituality into +formal teaching, by teaching the ethics of the discipline, and by exemplifying +integrity and devotion. + +B. + +Scholarly productivity + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +Graduate faculty members are active scholars or artist-scholars who do significant +research and regularly publish in national or international refereed journals and +presses, or who present or perform their artistic work for wide and authoritative +critical review. Their books, articles, papers, and creative work make significant +contributions to their disciplines. + +Faculty members are involved in scholarly and creative activities in their discipline, +participate in regional, national and international conferences, and work with +colleagues at other universities and centers of learning. + +In disciplines where the norms of scholarship require external funding, faculty +members actively seek funding to support their research programs and to enhance +graduate student involvement in research or creative work. + +Faculty members use professional development leaves to extend their knowledge +in their disciplines and to invigorate their research. + +3 + + C. + +Dedication to service and citizenship + +1. + +2. + +3. + +Faculty members strive to assure that all activities support the mission of the +university, build the Kingdom of God, and bless students, colleagues, and +humanity. + +Faculty members contribute to the intellectual climate of the department and the +university through service, including conscientious attention to committee +assignments and collaboration in research, scholarship, or creative endeavors with +colleagues and students. + +Faculty members contribute to the professional community through service such +as conference organization and participation and editorship of journals and other +forums. Competing activities, such as paid consultation work, are kept to a +minimum, and are engaged in only when such activities advance knowledge and +skills in the discipline, strengthen research, and enhance the influence and respect +of the university. + +III. + +High Academic Standards + +A. Well-established admissions standards and practices + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +The department has an active recruitment program to attract excellent students +from undergraduate and graduate programs at other universities. It does not rely +solely on an applicant pool of its own undergraduates. + +The department has clearly stated and effectively communicated admissions +standards. These standards are reviewed regularly and revised as needed. The +department sets high expectations and employs several criteria such as the +undergraduate GPA, GRE scores, and professional experience in making +admissions decisions. It admits provisionally only if an applicant shows +exceptional promise. + +The department admits students only when all or virtually all prerequisite +requirements have been met. + +The department is consistent in applying its admission standards, and it is timely in +making admissions decisions. These decisions are made by a faculty admissions +committee or by the faculty as a whole. All graduate faculty members have some +input in admissions decisions. + +4 + + 5. + +The department attracts sufficient numbers of qualified applicants to offer full- +fledged graduate programs with adequate course offerings and to provide a +stimulating graduate culture for students. Nevertheless, the department admits only +as many students as it can effectively guide through a rigorous, carefully advised +program. It considers student-faculty ratios, especially in light of specialties that +applicants wish to pursue. + +B. + +Strong curriculum and rigorous course work + +1. + +The curriculum is well designed, relatively stable, and leads to strong preparation +of students. The department offers enough courses to support a full graduate +program, and it lists no courses that are “on the books” but rarely taught. The +curriculum is appropriate for the preparation and specialties of the faculty and +reflects leadership in the discipline. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +5. + +The classroom experience is qualitatively different from that in the undergraduate +program. The department does not double list courses by undergraduate and +graduate numbers (such as 400 and 600) and avoids all practices that dilute the +classroom experience for graduate students. When advanced undergraduates +register for 500-level courses, they do so with the understanding that the course +is taught at a graduate level and that the expectations for them are the same as for +graduate students. + +Credits earned through directed readings, independent or off-campus projects, or +employment-related projects are kept to a minimum, and where such courses are +approved by the department, they are as rigorous and demanding as regular +courses. In such courses, the teacher and student formulate an agreement of +requirements and expectations and file that “contract” with the department office. +The student receives credit only when the agreement has been fulfilled. + +Courses require extensive writing assignments of substance and consequence that +train students to think critically. Student papers adhere to high standards of +composition, and they are carefully criticized and assessed, sometimes by both +teacher and other students. + +All courses, even those considered to be applied courses, have a strong theoretical +foundation based on current research. They require investigation beyond +classroom experiences and textbooks. Where possible, they include demanding +essay examinations. + +5 + + 6. + +7. + +8. + +Every graduate course provides a course outline and syllabus in which the +teacher’s expectations are clearly stated and the course description is +comprehensive and clear. + +Graduate students have opportunities for learning outside the major department. + +The department enriches its graduate curriculum with presentations by visiting +lecturers, with colloquia, and with other opportunities for learning outside the +regular curriculum. + +9. + +Course grades accurately reflect student achievement and are not inflated. + +C. + +Excellence in dissertations, theses, and projects + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +5. + +The department offers a strong course in research methodology specific to the +discipline. + +The department requires a culminating writing experience of its graduate students, +regardless of whether the student is in a traditional or an applied program. The +final paper is usually a research-based dissertation or thesis, but may be a project +or report in a master’s program. All doctoral students prepare formal +dissertations. + +Dissertations and theses are on topics of real consequence, and their content +makes substantial contributions to some aspect of the discipline. The contributions +of projects are held to standards comparable to those of dissertations and theses. +By their excellence and uniqueness, these research and writing experiences +impressively demonstrate the achievements, knowledge, and skills of the students +at the time the graduate degree is completed. + +The prospectus is treated as a critical aspect of the student’s research. It is +prepared before intensive research begins and is subjected to broad department +review. + +The research design, the preparation of the prospectus, the research itself, and the +preparation of the dissertation, thesis, or project are carefully directed by the +student’s advisory committee. Problems in research design or methodology are +discovered and corrected at the prospectus stage. + +6 + + 6. + +7. + +The dissertation, thesis, or project engages a topic that the faculty adviser is well +prepared to direct. + +The dissertation, thesis, or project is well written and leads to a publishable piece +of work. Students are encouraged to publish their work and are assisted in the +effort to find a publisher. Where appropriate, faculty members and students +publish collaboratively. + +D. + +Well-developed procedures for preparing and conducting comprehensive and oral +examinations + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +Department comprehensive and oral examinations are demanding and fair. They +require currency in the field, thorough analysis of the questions or problems posed, +and synthesis of knowledge in the discipline, all at a level appropriate for the +degree to be awarded. They also require grace and skill in expression. + +The examination questions are carefully conceived and well-written. Test +questions demand a grasp of essentials and the ability to analyze and synthesize. + +The department provides published and well-publicized criteria as to what +constitutes acceptable performance on department oral and comprehensive +examinations. The purpose, format, range of content, and nature of examinations +are described, and sample questions from past examinations are available for +study. + +The department applies consistent and rigorous standards in the evaluation of +examinations. There is a mechanism for providing feedback and a clear policy on +the retaking of failed comprehensive examinations. + +IV. Well-defined, Clearly Articulated, and Helpful Procedures + +A. + +Broadly based college and department governance + +1. + +2. + +Graduate faculty members participate in all departmental decisions that affect the +department’s academic programs, the quality of the degrees offered, and the +professional lives of the faculty. + +All faculty members of appropriate status and rank have input in hiring, continuing +status, and advancement in rank decisions in the department. The department + +7 + + conducts a national search for new faculty members and makes hiring, continuing +status, and promotion decisions according to a set of established, well-publicized +criteria and procedures which are at least as rigorous as university guidelines and +expectations. + +New faculty members are mentored in their preparation for continuing status +review or advancement in rank nomination. + +Through peer-elected representatives, graduate students have a voice in +departmental decisions that affect graduate programs. + +The goals of graduate programs are not based solely on expectations of external +accrediting agencies. Rather, they exceed the quality required by such agencies +and thus maintain independence. + +Department programs are created, defined, and influenced by genuine, significant +developments within the discipline consistent with available resources rather than +by perceived market demands and short-lived trends. + +The department has a written assessment plan and uses it routinely to improve +graduate programs. + +3. + +4. + +5. + +6. + +7. + +B. + +Effective advisement of students + +1. + +2. + +3. + +Faculty members are conscientious in their advisement of students. They keep +regularly scheduled office hours and have frequent scholarly interaction with +students. They return thesis drafts and other materials promptly so that students +experience no unnecessary delays in completion of their programs. + +The department recognizes that a student’s first responsibility is to his or her own +academic program. Care is taken to ensure that other duties, such as teaching +undergraduate courses, enhance the graduate education experience and do not +impede student’s progress toward a degree. The number of courses a graduate +student teaches is strictly limited. + +The department has a published set (a student handbook) of current policies, +requirements, expectations, and procedures that describes with clarity and in detail +what graduate students need to know to enter a program and successfully +complete a degree in the department. + +4. + +University and department deadlines are well publicized. + +8 + + 5. + +6. + +7. + +8. + +9. + +The department has formal orientation procedures or seminars to acquaint +new students with the expectations and requirements of graduate study in the +department and the university. + +Each student is well informed from the beginning, having been assigned a sponsor +who assists in the selection of a permanent adviser. That selection is made by the +end of the first semester. + +The department conducts at least annual evaluations, at clearly designated times, +of each student’s progress and informs the student of his or her status. If marginal +or unsatisfactory progress is noted, the department informs the student of action +required to demonstrate satisfactory progress. + +The department has determined an optimum time length for program completion +and moves its students through on schedule. + +A high percentage of the students on the department’s rolls are actually on campus +pursuing degrees at any given time. + +10. + +The department graduates a high percentage of the students it admits. + +11. + +12. + +13. + +The department provides published information about financial aid opportunities +for students in its programs. + +Students who have teaching assignments are well trained to perform those +assignments ably. + +The department assists graduate students in finding employment or advanced +educational opportunities suitable to their preparation and experience after they +leave the department. + +C. + +Appropriate faculty assignments + +1. + +2. + +Faculty members who are teaching and advising in the graduate program are given +ample opportunity for scholarly work and professional development. + +The department sets reasonable limits on the number of graduate advisees +assigned to any one faculty member. + +9 + + 3. + +4. + +Faculty assignments in the graduate program are not performed on an +“overload” basis. + +Faculty members who are teaching and advising in the graduate program are +teaching neither in night school nor in off-campus programs on an “overload” +basis. + +D. + +Responsible class scheduling + +1. + +2. + +The department publishes and distributes to graduate students a multi-year +schedule of course offerings, enabling students to plan their study. + +Graduate course offerings are sequenced appropriately and offered with sufficient +frequency to prevent delays in degree completion. + +V. + +Adequate Resources + +1. + +2. + +3. + +4. + +5. + +6. + +The department regularly assesses its resources and makes realistic decisions +about its graduate program(s) in light of these resources. + +The department provides research support—in the form of equipment, laboratories +or studios, staff assistance, and funds (where possible)—for the research +programs of faculty members who teach and advise graduate students. + +The department works closely and continuously with the library to ensure that the +collection supports the research and teaching needs of the department. The +department is aware of particularly valuable library resources in its discipline and +informs graduate students of those resources. + +The department and its faculty members actively and persistently seek outside +funding to support research and graduate students. Department graduate students +receive adequate financial support and early notification of that support. + +The department allows faculty members sufficient time to do superior work in both +teaching and research, and to advise and mentor graduate students in a thorough +manner. + +Graduate students have adequate space and opportunity for informal discussion +and interaction, and those who teach undergraduates have adequate facilities for +advising and helping their students with class assignments. Graduate students also +have access to facilities and equipment needed in their graduate research. + +10 + + 7. + +The department encourages faculty members to consult, collaborate, and share +resources (courses, computer labs, etc.) with colleagues who have common +curricular interests in other departments and colleges. + +PUBLISHED BY THE +BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY GRADUATE COUNCIL + +Brigham Young University +Graduate Studies +105 FPH +Provo, UT 84602 +Phone: (801) 422-4091 +Website: https://gradstudies.byu.edu + +11 + diff --git a/q93/random_k4/random_4.md b/q93/random_k4/random_4.md index 1b20aca545e3b6302b6cd7205beb97b9808a6126..261b89724e814d1be04e011ae16d4387de2cce1a 100644 --- a/q93/random_k4/random_4.md +++ b/q93/random_k4/random_4.md @@ -1,766 +1,767 @@ -Managing Scientific Data with -Microsoft Azure Storage +FOR RELEASE MARCH 18, 2021 -Introduction -Microsoft Azure Storage is a cloud-based distributed storage service that you can use to store -many different types of data, ranging from images and videos to text files, log files, and sensor -data. The Microsoft Azure Storage service provides numerous benefits. It scales to -accommodate huge amounts of data, permits access to that data easily from any location at any -time, and provides load balancing to support variable traffic volumes. Furthermore, Microsoft -Azure Storage makes three copies of your data to ensure that it is always accessible if a storage -node fails or a data center becomes unavailable. Optionally, it provides geo-redundant storage -by replicating your data to an alternate data center region hundreds of miles away, but in the -same geo-political area (known as a geo). You can also set up your storage account with the -Microsoft Azure Content Delivery network to cache data closer to your users and thereby -provide a consistent high-performance user experience regardless of their distance from a data -center. +BY Rakesh Kochhar -Microsoft Azure Storage is an ideal storage solution for scientific data. It is well suited for a -variety of scenarios, such as: +FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES: - Storing instrumentation data that is growing exponentially and rapidly - Providing data to other researchers with high-performance connectivity, thereby +Rakesh Kochhar, Senior Researcher -reducing the time required to move large data sets. +Stefan Cornibert, Communications Manager - Accessing data from anywhere in the world with an Internet connection, whether in the +Tanya Arditi, Communications Manager -field or in the laboratory, when getting to access to a local drive is not practical +202.419.4372 - Using virtual resources on demand as needed, without the need to plan for building and +www.pewresearch.org -maintaining a scalable infrastructure - - Co-locating data with Microsoft Azure compute resources, such as a scientific +RECOMMENDED CITATION -application running in Microsoft Azure or data analysis with HDInsight, Microsoft’s -distribution of Hadoop on Microsoft Azure +Pew Research Center, March, 2021, “The Pandemic Stalls +Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply” -Microsoft Azure storage types -To start working with the Microsoft Azure Storage service, you create a storage account to serve -as the top-level namespace that you use to access storage. By default, you can set up a -maximum of five storage accounts for each Microsoft Azure subscription; additional accounts -can be enabled through a support request. Within each account, you can store up to 200 TB of -data. + 1 -To create a storage account in the Microsoft Azure Management Portal: +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -1. Click the New button, click Data Services, click Storage, and then click Quick Create. -2. Type a URL for your storage account, select a location or affinity group, and specify +About Pew Research Center -whether to enable geo-replication +Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes +and trends shaping America and the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center conducts +public opinion polling, demographic research, content analysis and other data-driven social +science research. It studies U.S. politics and policy; journalism and media; internet, science and +technology; religion and public life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and trends; and U.S. social +and demographic trends. All of the Center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org. Pew +Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +© Pew Research Center 2021 -3. Click Create Storage Account. The URL you select here becomes host name in the URI +www.pewresearch.org -that you use to access your data in storage. + 2 -Figure 1: Creating a new storage account +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -After you create your storage account, your next step is to load data into storage. You can -choose from the following options of storage types: - Use blob storage to store any type of file. - For structured, non-relational tabular data, you can use table storage. - +How we did this -If you are running applications in Microsoft Azure, you can use queue storage to pass -messages between a Microsoft Azure web role and worker role, or to store messages to -process asynchronously. Queue storage is not the focus of this paper, but you can read -more about it at Queue Service Concepts and Queue Service REST API. +The COVID-19 pandemic has created an economic crisis, shuttering businesses and cutting jobs +around the world. This report looks at how the downturn has affected the standard of living +globally and in seven major regions. -Microsoft Azure Storage explorer tools -Although the Management Portal provides you with access to many administrative activities, -you can use public HTTP or HTTPS REST endpoints to interact with storage, write an application -to transfer data and manage your storage, or acquire a third-party tool. Experiment with some -of the following tools to see which you prefer: +The focus is on the distribution of people across five income tiers in 2020: poor, low income, +middle income, upper-middle income and high income. See the methodology and an earlier Pew +Research Center report for more on the definition and meaning of these tiers in a global context. - AzCopy (Windows) - Azure Storage Explorer (Windows) - Azure Management Studio (Windows) - CloudBerry Explorer (Windows) - CloudXplorer by ClumsyLeaf (Windows) - Azure Tools for Microsoft Visual Studio (Windows) - Zudio (any operating system, web-based) +The key data source for the analysis is the World Bank’s PovcalNet database, which provides +access to household survey data on either income or consumption for more than 160 countries. At +the regional level, the latest year for which comprehensive data are available ranges from 2014 for +South Asia to 2018 for East Asia and the Pacific and three other regions. The global regions are as +defined by the World Bank. -You can view a list of other storage explorer tools in the Microsoft Azure Storage team blog. If -you prefer to create your own application, see How to use the Microsoft Azure Blob Storage -Service in .NET and How to: Programmatically access table storage. +These benchmark estimates of income are extrapolated to 2020 using World Bank estimates of +output growth through 2020. One projection is based on the World Bank’s January 2020 forecasts +of economic growth in 2020, and the other is based on its January 2021 estimates of growth in +2020. The difference between these two measures is used to represent the effect of the pandemic +on the income distribution in each region. Regional estimates are summed to yield estimates of +the global distribution. -Note: Rather than use an application to load blob data into storage, you can take advantage of -the Microsoft Azure Import/Export service. This might be a more time- and cost-effective option -when you have extremely large amounts of data. You simply create a job to notify the data +www.pewresearch.org -2 + 3 - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -center and then send one or more hard drives loaded with encrypted data to a data center -where the data is uploaded to your storage account. Conversely, you can send empty drives to -the data center to have data downloaded to the drives and then returned to you. To learn more, -see Using the Microsoft Azure Import/Export Service to Transfer Data to Blob Storage. +BY Rakesh Kochhar -Microsoft Azure Blob service -A blob is simply a file. It can be binary data, such as an image or an audio file, or it can be text -data. You organize blobs inside of containers that are associated with your storage account, as -shown in Figure 2. There is no limit to the number of containers you can create in an account, -nor is there a limit to the number of blobs that you can store in a container (other than the -maximum size of the storage account). +The COVID-19 pandemic is having a deep effect on the global economy. In January 2020, as +reports of the novel coronavirus were emerging, the World Bank forecasted that the global +economy would expand by 2.5% that year. In January 2021, with the pandemic still holding much +of the world in its grip, the World Bank estimated that the global economy contracted by 4.3% in +2020, a turnabout of 6.8 percentage points. -Figure 2: Blob storage components +The economic downturn is likely to have +diminished living standards around the world, +pushing millions out of the global middle class +and swelling the ranks of the poor. At the same +time, the path to a recovery is clouded with +uncertainties. -Blobs -Although a blob can be any type of file, it falls into one of the following categories: block blob or -page blob. The type of blob determines how Microsoft Azure Storage manages both storage of -the blobs and operations involving the blobs. +A new Pew Research Center analysis finds that +the global middle class encompassed 54 million +fewer people in 2020 than the number +projected prior to the onset of the pandemic. +Meanwhile, the number of poor is estimated to +have been 131 million higher because of the +recession. -Block blob -You use this type of blob for efficient upload and download (streaming) workloads of audio or -video files and for most document, text, and image file types. Essentially, the client application -performing the upload deconstructs a large blob into a sequence of blocks, with each block -having a unique block ID. Each block can be no larger than 4 MB. The total size of a single blob -cannot exceed 200 GB and must contain no more than 50,000 blocks. A client application can -upload the blocks in parallel to minimize the time needed to transfer the entire blob. In -addition, it can upload the blocks out of sequence. That way, if a block fails to upload correctly, -the client application can retry the upload of that block only and not force the entire upload to -restart. +The drop-off in the global middle class was +centered in South Asia and in East Asia and the +Pacific, and it stalled the expansion seen in the +years preceding the pandemic. South Asia, +specifically India, along with Sub-Saharan +Africa, accounted for most of the increase in +poverty, reversing years of progress on this +front. -Page blob -You use this type of blob for files that you want to optimize for random read-write operations -such as a database or a file system. Each page blob contains a collection of 512-byte pages with -a maximum size of 1 TB. As you create the page blob or update its contents, you write one or -more pages to storage and specify an offset and a range that corresponds to 512-byte page -boundaries. Existing pages remain unchanged. +The COVID-19 downturn curbed growth +in the global middle class, increased +poverty sharply in 2020 -3 +Estimated change in the number of people in each +income tier due to the global recession in 2020, in +millions - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +High income -Blob snapshot -You can create a snapshot of a blob at any time to save its current state as a read-only blob. You -can interact with a blob snapshot just like a blob, except you cannot modify it. A blob snapshot -has the same URI as the parent blob, but has the date and time of creation appended to the URI. +-62 -Blob storage and Azure Storage Explorer -An easy way to work with your storage account is to download and install Azure Storage -Explorer. When you launch the application: +million -1. Click the Add Account button, type in your storage account name and storage account +Upper-middle +income -key, as shown in Figure 3. -2. Click Add Storage Account. -3. Optional: you can select the Use HTTPS check box to use a secure connection for +-36 -sensitive data. +Middle income -To locate your storage account key: +-54 + +Low income + ++21 - Visit the Microsoft Azure Management Portal and access the Storage page. - Select the storage account, and then click the Manage Access Keys button at the +Poor -bottom of the page. ++131 - Click the icon to the right of the Primary Access Key to copy the key to your clipboard, +Notes: The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, +middle income on $10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01- +$50, and high income on more than $50; figures expressed in 2011 +purchasing power parities in 2011 prices. The estimates show the +difference in the number of people in an income tier based on pre- +pandemic projections and post-pandemic estimates. The term +“post-pandemic” refers to the period since the onset of the +pandemic in January 2020.It is assumed there is no change in the +income distribution in a region from the benchmark year for the +projection to 2020. +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from the World Bank +PovcalNet database. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes +Poverty Up Sharply” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + + 4 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +As defined in this report (and in previous Pew Research Center analyses), people who are middle +income live on $10.01-$20 a day, which translates to an annual income of about $14,600 to +$29,200 for a family of four. This is modest by the standards of advanced economies. In fact, it +straddles the official poverty line in the United States − about $23,000 for a family of four in 2020 +(expressed in 2011 prices). By global standards, the poor live on $2 or less a day, or no more than +$2,920 annually for a family of four. + +The number of people in the global high-income tier (more than $50 daily) is estimated to have +decreased by 62 million in 2020, erasing about half of the gain since 2011, with most of the change + +Who is middle class (or middle income)? +This report uses the terms “middle income” and “middle class” interchangeably, a common practice among +economists who tend to define the middle class in terms of income or consumption. But being middle class +can connote more than income, be it a college education, white-collar work, economic security, owning a +home, or having certain social and political values. Class could also simply be a matter of self-identification. +The interplay among these many factors is examined in studies by Hout (2007) and Savage et al. (2013), +among others. + +The population in each global region is divided into five groups: poor, low income, middle income, upper- +middle income and high income. The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, middle income +on $10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01-$50 and high income on more than $50. All dollar figures +are expressed in 2011 prices and purchasing power parity dollars, currency exchange rates adjusted for +differences in the prices of goods and services across countries. -Once you have the key, you can paste it into the Add Storage Account dialog box in Azure -Storage Explorer. +The assignment to a group, or income tier, is based on a household’s daily per capita income or +consumption, a simple way of controlling for differences in household size. In the source data, some +countries only report income data while others only report consumption data. The terms “income” and +“consumption” are used interchangeably for the sake of convenience. -Figure 3: Add storage account in Azure Storage Explorer +A middle-income, or middle-class, threshold of $10 follows the practice of other researchers. A similar +threshold has been used by the World Bank (2007, 2015), researchers at the Organization for Economic +Cooperation and Development (Kharas, 2010), the development community (Birdsall, Lustig and Meyer, +2013) and others. There is evidence that the $10 threshold, which is about five times higher than the World +Bank’s global poverty line, is associated with economic security and “insulates” people from falling back +into poverty. An earlier Pew Research Center report discusses the choice of income thresholds in greater +detail. -Next, you need to create a container in your storage account to hold one or more blobs. To -create the blob container: +The global middle-class standard is modest by the standards of advanced economies. In 2020, the official +poverty line for a family of four in the U.S. stood at about $15.90 per person per day (in 2011 prices). Thus, +many who are poor by the U.S. definition would meet the global middle-income standard or, conversely, +many who are in the global middle class would be poor by U.S. standards. -1. Click the New button in the Container section of the ribbon. -2. Type a name for the container. -3. Click Create Container. +www.pewresearch.org -Next, you need to access data to put into storage. For this demonstration: + 5 -1. Download the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks CSV file to your computer. -2. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -In Azure Storage Explorer, select the container you created, click the Upload button, and -select the CSV file that you just downloaded. +emanating from advanced economies. Meanwhile, the upper-middle income population ($20.01- +$50 daily) fell by 36 million, while the low-income population ($2.01-$10 daily) is estimated to +have increased by 21 million. -4 +These estimates are based on the Center’s analysis of World Bank data on the distribution of +people by either income or consumption levels in seven major global regions. The latest available +estimates of income for each region, such as for 2018 for Europe and Central Asia and 2015 for the +Middle East and North Africa, are extrapolated +to 2020 using two sets of growth estimates: the +forecasts issued by the World Bank in January +2020, prior to the pandemic, and the estimates +issued in January 2021, with the pandemic’s +economic impact in plainer sight. The +difference between these two measures is taken +to represent the impact of the COVID-19 +downturn on the standard of living of people +globally. - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +Globally, most are either poor or low +income, and the pandemic likely drove +the numbers higher in 2020 -When the upload completes, you can see the metadata for the newly created blob in the -selected container, as shown in Figure 4, including its name, modification date, length, content -type, content encoding, and content language. +Estimated number of people in each income tier in 2020, +before and after the global recession, in millions + +Pre-pandemic projection + +Post-pandemic estimate + +High income + +531 million + +593 + +Prior to the emergence of COVID-19, some 1.38 +billion people were expected to be counted in +the global middle class in 2020. But the +pandemic is estimated to have driven this +number down to 1.32 billion. The share of +people in the middle class globally is estimated +to have been 17.1% in 2020, instead of +potentially 17.8%. The erosion in the middle +class might have been deeper if not for the fact +that China – which is home to more than one- +third of the global middle class – evaded an +economic contraction, even though growth +there was slower than anticipated. + +The number of global poor is estimated to have +risen to 803 million in 2020, much greater than +the 672 million initially expected. The global +poverty rate, which had been in steady decline +this century, is likely to have increased to + +Upper-middle +Upper-middle +income +income + +Middle +income + +Low income + +1,140 + +1,176 + +1,324 + +1,378 + +Poor + +803 + +672 + +3,956 -Figure 4: Blob in Microsoft Azure Storage container +3,936 + +Notes: The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, +middle income on $10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01- +$50, and high income on more than $50; figures expressed in 2011 +purchasing power parities in 2011 prices. It is assumed there is no +change in the income distribution in a region from the benchmark +year for the projection to 2020. The term “post-pandemic” refers to +the period since the onset of the pandemic in January 2020. +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from the World Bank +PovcalNet database. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes +Poverty Up Sharply” -Azure Storage Explorer allows you to manage all types of storage components: containers, -blobs, queues, and table. You can create new components, make copies of existing components, -or delete components, in addition to renaming them. In addition, you have the option to -configure security on blobs and containers by setting the access level at minimum and creating -shared access signatures and shared access policies—all of which are described later in this -document in the “Security and Microsoft Azure Storage” section. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -A viewer in Azure Storage Explorer allows you to see the properties and contents of your blobs. -Double-click the blob name in the list or select it and click the View button to view the Blob -Detail dialog box, as shown in Figure 5. You can add properties as name/value pairs on the -Metadata tab to give context to the blob. For example, you could have an Author or Project -property. You can also add metadata to containers. +www.pewresearch.org -5 + 6 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +10.4%, nearly reverting to the rate in 2017, instead of sinking to a new low of 8.7%, as previously +expected. + +The steep rise in global poverty is driven by the fact that many who were in the low-income tier +prior to the pandemic lived on the margin of poverty. In 2017, 877 million people lived on $2 to $3 +a day, according to World Bank estimates. Thus, large numbers were susceptible to falling back +into poverty prior to the pandemic, especially in South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +At the other end of the economic spectrum, the global high-income population likely fell to 531 +million in 2020 from the 593 million originally expected. Consequently, the expected share in the +high-income tier is 6.8%, not 7.6%. A vast majority of the global high-income population lives in +advanced economies, and this group of countries also experienced a sharp downturn in 2020. +Ironically, this bolstered the global middle-income population as people in advanced economies +slipped down the ladder from higher income tiers. -Figure 5: Blob Detail in Azure Storage Explorer +The reversal in global living standards in 2020 comes on the heels of notable progress earlier in +the decade. From 2011 to 2019, the global middle-class population increased from 899 million to +1.34 billion, or by 54 million people annually, on average. The pandemic is estimated to have +erased a year of growth, +leaving the global middle-class +population nearly unchanged +from 2019 to 2020. + +The global middle class expanded rapidly from 2011 to +2019, and poverty fell sharply + +Number of people in each income tier, in millions + +Global poverty had abated at +an average rate of 49 million +annually from 2011 to 2019, +with the number of global +poor falling from 1.10 billion +to 691 million during this +period. The pandemic, by +adding 131 million to the ranks +of the poor, has set the +progress on poverty back by +several years, and the poverty +rate is estimated to have +increased from 9.0% in 2019 +to 10.4% in 2020. -Blob storage and IPython -For greater control over blob management, you can write your own storage logic for your -application by using one of many client libraries that implement the REST API for Microsoft -Azure Storage Services, including Python. To minimize the number of tools you need to install on -your local computer, you can use an IPython Notebook server for development and write your -code in a web application. The IPython Notebook server can even be hosted in a Microsoft -Azure Virtual Machine. +Notes: The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, middle income on +$10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01-$50, and high income on more than $50; +figures expressed in 2011 purchasing power parities in 2011 prices. It is assumed there is +no change in the income distribution in a region from the benchmark year for the projection +to 2019. +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from the World Bank PovcalNet database. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply” -Running an IPython Notebook server on a Microsoft Azure Virtual Machine -A quick way to get started with development using an IPython Notebook server is to use an -image from VM Depot that has the necessary components installed. You can view a list of -available images on the VM Depot website and use the search bar to filter the list for images -tagged with a specific keyword, such as IPython. For instructions on how to create a virtual -machine from an image, such as the Azure Data Analysis image, refer to “Using and Contributing -Virtual Machines to VM Depot” (available from the Microsoft Azure for Research Technical -Papers website). +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Once you have the Azure Data Analysis virtual machine provisioned and started, you can -connect to it with a PuTTY client. +www.pewresearch.org -1. + 7 -In the Host Name (or IP address) box, type the DNS name for your virtual machine, as -shown in Figure 6. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -2. Click Yes to trust the connection, and then type in the user name and password that you +From 2011 to 2019, the global high-income population had increased from 459 million to 576 +million, growing by an average of 15 million annually. Thus, the setback of 62 million due to the +pandemic in 2020 also reverses several years of growth in the high-income population. The share +of the global population in the high-income tier is expected to have decreased from 7.5% in 2019 +to 6.8% in 2020. -established when creating the virtual machine. +The effect of the COVID-19 downturn on the middle class and other income tiers shows distinct +regional differences. Asia is expected to have accounted for most of the shrinking of the global +middle class in 2020, with the middle-class population falling by 32 million in South Asia and by +19 million in East Asia and the Pacific. Meanwhile, the middle class in advanced economies is +estimated to have increased by 16 million, in part due to the drop-off in the high-income tier in +those countries. -6 +South Asia is estimated to have experienced the largest decrease in the middle +class and the greatest increase in poverty due to the COVID-19 downturn in 2020 + +Estimated change in the number of people in each income tier due to the global recession in 2020, in millions + +Notes: The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, middle income on $10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01-$50, and +high income on more than $50; figures expressed in 2011 purchasing power parities in 2011 prices. The estimates show the diff erence in the +number of people expected in an income tier based on projections made before and after the onset of the pandemic in January 2020. It is +assumed there is no change in the income distribution in a region from the benchmark year for the projection to 2020. +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from the World Bank PovcalNet database. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply” + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +www.pewresearch.org + + 8 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +The projected rise in global poverty in the pandemic is concentrated in South Asia (an increase of +78 million) and Sub-Saharan Africa (40 million), historically among the poorest regions in the +world. The high-income population in advanced economies is estimated to have shrunk by 47 +million in 2020, accounting for most of the falloff globally. It should be noted that the global cutoff +for the high-income tier – more than $50 a day – is not much higher than the median income +across advanced economies, as an estimated 40% of the population in these countries is in the +global high-income tier. Thus, the contraction of the high-income tier in advanced economies is +more a reflection of the reduction in the standard of living of the typical person in these countries +than outcomes for the wealthy. + +The contribution of a region to global changes overall and the shift in its own income distribution +depends mostly on two factors: the sizes of income tiers in the region prior to the COVID-19 +recession and the impact of the downturn on economic growth in the region. + +Prior to the pandemic, nearly half of the global middle-class population – 672 million of 1.38 +billion – was estimated to live in East Asia and the Pacific, a region that includes China. Latin +America and the Caribbean accounted for 191 million, and Europe and Central Asia was home to +183 million. South Asia accounted for 123 million more. + +In view of these magnitudes, the estimated loss (relative to pre-pandemic expectations) of 32 +million people from the middle class in South Asia is notable for two reasons. First, the region +contributed the most to the shrinking of the global middle class in 2020 despite having a middle- +income population smaller than several other regions. Second, the percentage decrease in South +Asia’s middle-income population from what was previously expected (26%) is much greater than +in any other region. Although East Asia and the Pacific shed 19 million from the middle-income +tier, that represented only 3% of its middle class. - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +Poverty is most prevalent in Sub-Saharan Africa. Some 494 million people in Sub-Saharan Africa, +out of a total population of 1.14 billion, were expected to be living in poverty ahead of the +pandemic in 2020. South Asia, with a total population of 1.86 billion, was expected to be home to +104 million poor. Nonetheless, South Asia is estimated to have added nearly double the amount of +people to the ranks of the globally poor as Sub-Saharan Africa in the pandemic. The percentage +increase in poverty in South Asia (75%) dwarfs the increase in Sub-Saharan Africa (8%). -Figure 6: SSH connection to Linux virtual machine +The number of poor in other regions was smaller, estimated to range from 6 million in Europe and +Central Asia to 27 million in Latin America and the Caribbean ahead of the pandemic in 2020. +But, since that moment, the increase in poverty in these regions is notable. The Middle East and +North Africa and East Asia and the Pacific are each estimated to have seen increases in poverty of -3. +www.pewresearch.org -In the PuTTY window, type the following command to start the IPython Notebook -server: + 9 -sudo ipython notebook –profile=nbserver +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -You might need to supply your password again to execute this command. The notebook server is -successfully started when you see the message to use Control-C to stop the server, as shown in -Figure 7. +Prior to the pandemic, most of the global middle class lived in East Asia and the +Pacific, the poor in Sub-Saharan Africa, high-income earners in advanced economies -Figure 7: IPython Notebook Server successfully started +Estimated number of people in each income tier prior to the global recession in 2020, by region, in millions -Now you are ready to start coding. To do this, open your browser and use the DNS address for -your virtual machine, https://.cloudapp.net. Be sure to use the HTTPS -protocol. You will see a warning about the security, which you can ignore for this -demonstration, and then you must respond to the prompt for the login password for the -IPython Notebook on first load. For the IPython Notebook server, the password is -Elastacloud123. +Notes: The poor live on $2 or less daily, low income on $2.01-$10, middle income on $10.01-$20, upper-middle income on $20.01-$50, and +high income on more than $50; figures expressed in 2011 purchasing power parities in 2011 prices. It is assumed there is no change in the +income distribution in a region from the benchmark year for the projection to 2020. +Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from the World Bank PovcalNet database. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply” -7 +PEW RESEARCH CENTER - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +more than 20% due to the recession. The rise in poverty in both Europe and Central Asia and +Latin America and the Caribbean is not far behind, with each experiencing a 17% increase in +poverty. -Writing data directly into blob storage -Using IPython, you can develop an application that connects to storage, writes data into a local -file, and then uploads the file as a blob into a container. In the sample code below, these steps -are achieved by using the BlobService object and the put_blob method. For other code samples -demonstrating how to download (get_blob) and perform other operations, see How to Use the -Blob Storage Service from Python. +A large majority of the global high-income population – 489 million of 593 million – lived in +advanced economies before the global recession took hold. The estimated decrease of 47 million, +or 10%, in this population in advanced economies accounts for most of the shrinking of the global +high-income tier. -Click the New Notebook button in the top right corner of the IPython notebook window, and -then copy the following code sample and paste it into the gray box in the browser. Be sure to -replace the account, key, and container name variables with values specific to your storage -account. +In proportional terms, the drop off in the high-income tier is also notable in Latin America and the +Caribbean (15%), Europe and Central Asia (12%) and East Asia and the Pacific (12%). The losses in +the Middle East and North Africa, South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa are relatively small in +magnitude (each less than 1 million people) but also represent double-digit shares of the high- +income populations in those regions. -#first import required modules -from azure.storage import * -import os -import csv -import numpy -from collections import defaultdict -import time +www.pewresearch.org -#replace the following values with your own account name, primary access key, and -container name -account = 'myazurestoragewestus' -key = 'mdJnNXPYS1cC5T4pf+9yva/ …. etc' -containername = 'mystorage' + 10 -#get a handle to your account -blob_service = BlobService(account_name=account, account_key=key) +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -#create a new file a blob into a container -open(r'mytextfile.txt', 'w').write("This is a sample text file.") +The relatively outsized role of +South Asia in the contraction of +the global middle class and the +expansion of poverty is the +result of it seeing the sharpest +reduction in economic growth +in the pandemic. In January +2020, the World Bank +forecasted that South Asia +would experience a 4.3% +increase in gross domestic +product (GDP) per capita in +2020. But, in January 2021, +output in South Asia was +estimated to have decreased by +7.8% in 2020, a retreat of 12.1 +percentage points from +potential. -#upload the blob into the container -textblob = open(r'mytextfile.txt', 'r').read() -blob_service.put_blob(containername, 'mytextfile.txt', textblob, -x_ms_blob_type='BlockBlob') +South Asia estimated to have seen the sharpest drop +in output growth in 2020, East Asia and the Pacific +the least -#use azure storage explorer to find the mytextfile.txt file +Growth in real gross domestic product per capita in 2020, forecasted and +estimated, in percent -To execute the code, click the Run Cell button (with the arrow icon), as shown in Figure 8. Then -use another tool like Azure Store Explorer to view the uploaded file. +Global -Figure 8: Run Cell button executes code +Advanced economies -8 +Latin America and the Caribbean - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +East Asia and the Pacific -Removing a blob from storage -You can also use IPython to remove a blob from storage, as shown in the next code sample. In -this example, you use the delete_blob method. Paste this code into the notebook document, -and then execute it. When it completes, confirm that the blob no longer exists in storage. +Europe and the Central Asia -#Remove mytextfile.txt -os.remove(r'mytextfile.txt') +South Asia -#delete the blob remotely -blob_service.delete_blob(containername, 'mytextfile.txt') +Middle East and North Africa -#check the azure storage explorer again, the file is removed +Sub-Saharan Africa -Blob storage and AzCopy -AzCopy is a command-line utility that you can use to copy blobs between storage accounts or to -a different container in the same storage account. This is a much faster process than -downloading the blob locally and then uploading it again to a different target location. To use -this utility, you must know the URI for the source and target accounts and containers in addition -to the keys for the source and target. Open a command prompt window and type the respective -commands shown below after replacing the source and target names and keys: +Jan. 2020 +forecast - You can move all blobs from a source container in a source account to a target container +Jan. 2021 +estimate Difference -in a different storage account. + 2.5% -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// +1.0 -https://.blob.core.windows.net// +0.8 -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /S +5.1 - By adding the /MOV flag to the command, you can delete blobs from the source after +2.3 -they have been successfully copied. +4.3 -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// +0.7 -https://.blob.core.windows.net// +0.3 -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /MOV /S +-4.3 - When you have blobs with snapshots, you can use the utility with the /SNAPSHOT flag -to move not only the base blobs, but also the blob snapshots. The snapshots will be -renamed to conform to this pattern: [blob-name][snapshot-time][extension]. +-5.8 -AzCopy https://.blob.core.windows.net// +-7.8 -https://.blob.core.windows.net// +0.4 -/sourcekey: /targetkey: /S /SNAPSHOT +-3.2 - +-7.8 -If you repeatedly execute the utility with the same source and target, you can put the -URIs in a text file like this: +-6.5 -#URI of Source Container +-6.1 -https://.blob.core.windows.net// +-6.8 -9 +-6.8 - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +-8.6 -#URI of Destination Container +-4.7 -https://.blob.core.windows.net// +-5.5 -Then you can reference the file in the command line in lieu of the URIs: +-12.1 -AzCopy /@:C:\myAzCopy.txt /sourcekey: /targetkey: /MOV /S +-7.2 -Blob storage and Node.js -Similar to Python and AzCopy, CLI and Node.js can be used to copy local files up to Blob Storage, -this works on Windows, Linux, and Mac. +-6.4 -CLI – Copy a local file to blob +Notes: Percentages shown are for the change in real GDP per capita at market prices. The +estimate for advanced economies is computed as the percent change in GDP less the +percent change in population. +Source: World Bank, Global Economic Prospects, January 2021 and January 2020 editions. +“The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply” -azure storage blob upload -a "japandata" -k "xdJ…storage-key…==" "foo.gz" +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -"backups" "foo.gz" –q +The setback to economic +growth in other regions is +smaller, ranging from 4.7 percentage points in East Asia and the Pacific to 8.6 points in Latin +America and the Caribbean. East Asia and the Pacific is the only region in which growth is +estimated to have stayed positive in 2020, with GDP per capita inching up by 0.4% even after the +onset of the pandemic. Otherwise, the latest estimates of the change in output per capita in 2020 +ranged from -3.2% in Europe and Central Asia to -7.8% in Latin America and the Caribbean. -See azure storage blob upload -h for details on individual parameters. +www.pewresearch.org -Node.js – Copy a local file to blob -var azure = require('azure'); -var fs = require('fs'); + 11 -var storageAccountName = 'myazurestorageaccountname'; -var storageAccountKey = 'myazurestorageaccountkey'; -var storageContainerName = 'mystoragecontainername'; +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -var blobService = azure.createBlobService( - storageAccountName, storageAccountKey, - storageAccountName + '.blob.core.windows.net'); +Acknowledgments -var fileNameList = [ 'localfile1.json', 'localfile2.json' ]; -for (var i=0; i ' + fileName); - blobService.createBlockBlobFromFile( - storageContainerName, fileName, fileName, - { - contentType: 'application/json', - cacheControl: 'public, max-age=3600' // max-age in seconds - }, - function(error) { - if (error) { - console.error(error); - } - }); -} +This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals. -Asynchronous copy -Microsoft Azure has asynchronous copy support for files that are already in blob storage. You -can use it to make a copy of a blob within the same storage account, or to copy blobs across -storage accounts, even if the data is being copied between data centers. Once you initiate a -copy, Microsoft Azure handles all of the activity as a background process. This means that you +Rakesh Kochhar, Senior Researcher +Kim Parker, Director, Social Trends Research +Richard Wike, Director, Global Attitudes Research +James Bell, Vice President, Global Strategies +J.J. Moncus, Research Assistant +Aidan Connaughton, Research Assistant +David Kent, Senior Copy Editor +Travis Mitchell, Digital Producer +Michael Keegan, Senior Information Graphics Designer +Shannon Greenwood, Digital Producer -10 +www.pewresearch.org - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage + 12 -can initiate the copy of a very large blob from anywhere, including a computer running outside -the cloud, but rather than first downloading the blob to the initiating computer and then -uploading to the new destination, the Microsoft Azure Blob service can pull it directly into the -designated storage account. Consequently, data transfers are as efficient as possible, and client -code does not need to wait for transfers to finish. The status of the transfer can be monitored, -and in-progress transfers can be canceled. This feature is especially useful for large blobs that -are gigabytes or terabytes in size. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -Asynchronous copy with PowerShell +Methodology -# SOURCE DATA (public blob, in data center in US East) -# sourceBlob can be a HUGE FILE, gigabytes or terabytes -$sourceBlob = 'https://azuremap.blob.core.windows.net/maps/azuremap.geojson' +The starting point for the analysis is household survey-based estimates of regional income +distributions from the World Bank’s PovcalNet database. The global regions are as defined by the +World Bank. In this report, “advanced economies” refers to the group of countries listed as “other +high income” by the World Bank. -# DESTINATION (private container, in data center in Japan West) -$japanAcct = 'japandata' -$japanContainer = 'backups' -$japanKey = 'xdJ…storage-key-goes-here…RA=='$destinationContext = New- -AzureStorageContext ` - -StorageAccountName $japanAcct ` - -StorageAccountKey $japanKey +These data were used to estimate a benchmark distribution of the population in each of seven +major global regions across five income tiers. The income tiers are defined by the daily per capita +income or consumption of people in a region as follows: poor ($2 or less daily), low income +($2.01-$10), middle income ($10.01-$20), upper-middle income ($20.01-$50) and high income +(more than $50). All dollar figures are expressed in 2011 prices and purchasing power parity +dollars. -# In this example, the source blob is addressed by a URL that is publicly -# accessible; once the copy request is accepted by the Microsoft Azure Blob -# service, it takes over and handles all the processing. +The year for which the benchmark estimates were drawn was the latest one in which the +household surveys covered at least 75% of the region’s population. This varied across regions as +follows: 2018 in advanced economies, Latin America and the Caribbean, East Asia and the Pacific, +and Europe and Central Asia; 2017 in Sub-Saharan Africa; 2015 in the Middle East and North +Africa; and 2014 for South Asia. -Start-AzureStorageBlobCopy -AbsoluteUri $sourceBlob ` - -Context $destinationContext ` - -DestContainer $japanContainer ` - -DestBlob 'new.file.name' +Extrapolating the benchmark estimates to 2020 required the following three steps: -You can learn more at Start-AzureStorageBlobCopy. +1. Extrapolate benchmark-year incomes to 2020 +2. Estimate income distributions in 2020 based on extrapolated incomes +3. Determine the population in each income tier in 2020 -Asynchronous copy with Node.js -After executing “npm install azure”, the following Node.js code will start an asynchronous copy, -just like in the PowerShell example. +Extrapolating incomes from benchmark years to 2020 -var azure = require('azure'); +Household incomes are extrapolated to 2020 using estimates of the growth in real gross domestic +product (GDP) per capita in a region. This, in turn, required several sets of data. -// SOURCE DATA (public blob, in data center in US East) -// sourceBlob can be a HUGE FILE, gigabytes or terabytes -var sourceBlob = -'https://azuremap.blob.core.windows.net/maps/azuremap.geojson'; +The first is the level of GDP per capita in the benchmark year, say 2017 for Sub-Saharan Africa, +and in 2019, the latest year for which data are available in the World Bank’s World Development +Indicators database. In this database, GDP per capita is expressed in constant 2017 international +dollars. The result is an estimate of the percentage change in per capita income in a region from +the benchmark year to 2019. -// DESTINATION (private container, in data center in Japan West) -var japanAcct = 'japandata'; -var japanContainer = 'backups'; -var japanKey = 'xdJ…storage-key-goes-here…RA==' -// In this example, the source blob is addressed by a URL that is publicly -// accessible; once the copy request is accepted by the Microsoft Azure Blob -// service, it takes over and handles all the processing. +Next, the change in income from 2019 to 2020 is approximated by two measures of growth in real +GDP per capita (at market prices) issued by the World Bank in its reports on global economic -var blobService = azure.createBlobService(japanAcct, japanKey); -blobService.copyBlob(sourceBlob, japanContainer, 'new.file.name.node', function -(error) { - -11 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - - if (error != null) { - console.log(error); - } -}); - -Microsoft Azure Table storage -Use table storage for high volumes of structured, non-relational data. An analogous type of data -is a Microsoft Excel worksheet containing multiple rows of data that can have a different -number of populated columns per row and even different data types in the same column across -multiple rows. Table storage provides flexibility to your applications without requiring you to -define and maintain a strict data model. It is highly scalable with fast query response times. - -Table storage components -You can add a table of up to 200 TB in size to your storage account and then associate entities -with tables, as shown in Figure 9. An entity is like a row in a table and represents a collection of -up to 255 properties. It has a maximum size of 1 MB. - -Figure 9: Table storage components - -Each property is a name-value pair. There are three required properties: PartitionKey, RowKey, -and Timestamp. PartitionKey and RowKey are set by the developer, and the system sets -Timestamp. PartitionKey and RowKey form a single clustered index for the table to enable fast -query performance. Entities having the same PartitionKey are stored together physically, -whereas partitions in the same table can be located on separate storage nodes. Inserts, updates, -and deletes in the same partition can be handled as part of the same transaction. - -Table storage and Azure Management Studio -Although you can use Azure Storage Explorer to manage tables, another option to consider is -Cerebrata’s Azure Management Studio. When you open Azure Management Studio, you need to -connect to your Microsoft Azure subscriptions. - -1. Sign in to your Microsoft Azure account to download your publishsettings file. -2. Select the subscription file to download. -3. - -In Azure Management Studio, open the File menu, point to Import, click Publish -Settings, and select the publishsettings file you just downloaded. - -Your subscription displays in the Connection Group pane on the left side of the screen. - -4. You can open the Storage Account node to access existing storage accounts, or right- - -click the Storage Account node and select New Storage Account if you need to create a -storage account. - -12 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -5. - -In the Connection Group pane, expand the storage account that you want to use for -table storage, right-click Tables, point to New, and then choose one of the options -shown in Figure 10. (For example, you could use the Table from CSV option to upload -the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks file into your storage account.) - -Figure 10: New table creation in Azure Management Studio - -After you specify the file name to upload and configure any additional properties specific to your -data, such as renaming a column name, the upload begins. You can monitor the upload progress -in the Transfers pane that displays at the bottom of Azure Management Studio. When the -upload is complete, you can view the data in Azure Management Studio, as shown in Figure 11: - -1. Expand the Tables node. -2. Right-click your table. -3. Select Open. - -13 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -Figure 11: Data in table storage accessible in Azure Management Studio - -Table storage and IPython -Just as you can use IPython to manage blob storage, you can also use it to manage table storage. -The following code sample works if you have your environment set up as described in the -“Running an IPython Notebook Server on a Microsoft Azure Virtual Machine” section of this -document. +www.pewresearch.org -Writing data to a table -To demonstrate how to write data to a table, you must have the Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks file -on your computer. Then you can write an application that reads a subset of the file, assigns a -column value as the PartitionKey, assigns an index as the RowKey, and assigns the other -columns in the file as entities in the table. These steps are performed in the sample code below -by using the TableService and Entity objects and the create_table and insert_entity methods. -For other code samples demonstrating how to download (get_blob) and perform other -operations, see How to Use the Table Storage Service from Python. + 13 -Click the New Notebook button in the top right corner of the notebook window, and then copy -the following code sample and paste it into the gray box in the browser. -Note: Be sure to replace the account and key with values specific to your storage account. +PEW RESEARCH CENTER -#Next we will demonstrate the table storage management in Microsoft Azure -#we can add top 100 rows of the mako_real_actual_sharks csv to a table storage -#get a handle to your account -table_service = TableService(account_name=account, account_key=key) -table_name = 'makotable'; +prospects. The first measure of growth in 2020 is a forecast released in January 2020, prior to the +emergence of the pandemic. The second measure is an estimate released in January 2021, with the +economic effects of the pandemic more apparent. The result is two estimates of how much per +capita income changed in each region from the benchmark year to 2020, one in a counterfactual +“pre-pandemic world” and the other in a “post-pandemic” world, the period since the emergence +of the coronavirus. -14 +In a slight variation to this procedure, the change in per capita income in 2020 for advanced +economies is estimated as the difference in the growth in GDP and the growth in population. This +is because estimates of the change in GDP per capita in 2020 for this group of countries is not +directly reported in the source data. - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage +Estimating income distributions in 2020 based on extrapolated incomes -csv_file = 'Mako_Real_Actual_Sharks.csv' +The estimated change in income from the benchmark year to 2020 is used to reset the boundaries +of the income tiers. For example, based on the pre-pandemic forecast, it was estimated that per +capita income in East Asia and the Pacific would have increased by 10.5% from 2018 to 2020. As a +result, people living on between $1.82 to $2 a day in East Asia and the Pacific in 2018 would have +seen their income increase to more than $2 a day in 2020. Thus, they would no longer be poor in +2020; only people with incomes of $1.81 or less in 2018 would still be poor in 2020. Thus, $1.81 is +used as the poverty boundary to derive an estimate of the share who were poor in East Asia and +the Pacific in 2020 in the hypothetical pandemic-free world. -#delete the table for temporary data -result = table_service.delete_table(table_name) +With the emergence of the pandemic, the growth in per capita income in East Asia and the Pacific +in 2020 is estimated to have been 5.6%. In this circumstance, only people with incomes from +$1.90 to $2 a day in 2018 would have emerged from poverty in 2020. Thus, $1.89 is used as the +poverty boundary to estimate the state of poverty in East Asia and the Pacific in 2020 in the post- +pandemic scenario. -# create a new table to save all entities. -result = table_service.create_table(table_name) +A similar procedure is used to reset the boundaries of all income tiers in all regions. The +estimation of income distributions for 2020 was greatly facilitated by the “povcalnet” command in +Stata developed by World Bank researchers. (Castaneda Aguilar, R.A., C. Lakner, E.B. Prydz, J.S. +Lopez, R. Wu and Q. Zhao, Estimating Global Poverty in Stata: The Povcalnet Command, +September 2019). -#attention: more code need to write if you want to execute all the time at the -same time -#when you call delete_table or create_table, it takes some time for Microsoft -Azure to finish the operation -#you must check the operation status before you can execute the following code! -#then we insert the top 1000 rows into the table, we set PartitionKey to be -each color and RowKey to be the index -index = 0 -with open(csv_file) as f: - reader = csv.DictReader(f) #create a reader which represents rows in a -dictionary form - for row in reader: #this will read a row as {column1: value1, column2: -value2,...} - entity = Entity() - entity.PartitionKey = row['color'] - entity.RowKey= str(index) - entity.ToppID = row['toppID'] - entity.Time = row['time'] - entity.Longitude = row['Longitude'] - entity.Latitude = row['Latitude'] - table_service.insert_entity(table_name, entity) - print row - index=index+1 - if index >= 1000: - break +www.pewresearch.org + + 14 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +Determining the population in each income tier in 2020 -Reading data from a table -One of the advantages of using table storage is the ability to query data quickly, even though it -is not stored in relational tables. By using the query_entities method, you can filter your query -to retrieve data from your table that match certain criteria: +The estimates derived from PovcalNet yield the percentages of people in a region who are poor, +low income and so on. These percentages are applied to the estimated population of each region to +determine the number who fall into each income tier. -#we can check the azure storage explore to query all inserted entities -#we can also query all table entities with diamonds' color = 'yellow' -makos = table_service.query_entities(table_name, "PartitionKey eq 'yellow'") -for m in makos: - print(str(m.ToppID),str(m.PartitionKey),str(m.Time),str(m.Longitude), -str(m.Latitude)) +The overall population in a region in 2020 is derived from two sources: World Bank data on +population through 2019, as listed on PovcalNet, and United Nations forecasts of the change in +population from 2019 to 2020. This exercise is conducted at the country level, some 218 in all, and +the results are summed to obtain an estimate of the population in each region in 2020. -Other programmatic options for managing storage -You have additional options for developing applications that manage your storage accounts: +Key assumptions and potential uncertainties + +As is the case with any projection, the estimates reported in this analysis are subject to a degree of +uncertainty. One issue is that final end-of-year estimates of real GDP growth are not yet available +for most countries, if any. Thus, the January 2021 estimates from the World Bank that are used in +the analysis are likely to be revised in the coming months. In its projections of the increase in +extreme poverty ($1.90 or less a day) in 2020, the World Bank assumes a global contraction of +either 5% or 8%. The resulting change in extreme poverty in 2020 is estimated to range from 88 +million to 115 million. + +The methodology in this analysis assumes that incomes change at the same rate for all people, +whether poor, low income, middle income, upper-middle income or high income. In other words, +it is assumed that there is no change in inequality from the benchmark year to 2020. If the +COVID-19 recession has worsened inequality, the increase in the number of poor is likely greater +than estimated in this analysis, and the decrease in the number who are high income is likely less +than estimated. The middle class may have shrunk by more than projected. + +Although World Bank researchers have simulated the relationship between inequality and the +poverty rate, more precise measures of changes in inequality in the COVID-19 era will not be +forthcoming until newer household survey data become available. Also, the extent to which social +spending by governments, especially in advanced economies, may have ameliorated the effects of +the COVID-19 downturn is not yet clear. - Microsoft Azure Storage Client Library - Storage Services REST APIs - - -LINQ for Microsoft Azure Table service - -If you perform a task once or infrequently, you can use the Management Portal or execute a -PowerShell or CLI script. For automating frequent or complex tasks, you might prefer to use an - -15 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -SDK. For example, if you already have experience with Python or Node, you can develop code in -that language and bypass the need to learn PowerShell. - -Security and Microsoft Azure Storage -Your storage account is secure by default. As the owner of the storage account, only you have -access until you grant others permissions to your resources. You have the following options for -managing security: - - Grant permissions at container and blob level to allow anonymous access. - Allow access to a container, blob, table, or queue by using a shared access signature for - -a limited time - - Shared access signatures can optionally include a stored access policy for even more - -flexible management - -Container and blob permissions -In the Microsoft Azure Management Portal, you specify the access permissions when you create -a new container. To do this: - -1. Click the storage account on the Storage page of the Management Portal. -2. Click the Containers link at the top of the page, and then click Create a Container, if no - -containers exist, or click the Add button at the bottom of the page. - -3. Type a container name in the NAME field, and the select one of the following ACCESS - -options, as shown in Figure 8: - Private: The owner of the storage account is the only user with access to the - -container. - - Public Container: The storage service responds to anonymous requests to access - -metadata for the current container and the blobs it contains. - Public Blob: Anonymous requests can access only the blob data. - -Figure 12: Access permissions selection at container level - -For a full list of REST operations and .NET methods and the effect of access setting, see Restrict -Access to Containers and Blobs. - -Shared access signature -To grant permissions on an ad hoc basis for a limited time, you can issue a shared access -signature to a user or a client application. You can specify a shared access signature for a blob or -a container. Either way, in addition to the level of permissions, you can specify the start and end - -16 - - Managing Scientific Data with Microsoft Azure Storage - -time during which access is granted. Access can include browsing the contents of a container or -reading and writing to blob data, table entities, or queue messages. You can see code examples -at Create and Use a Shared Access Signature. - -Stored access policy -To implement security that is more flexible, create a stored access policy to define permissions -and the time range during which access to storage is granted, and reference the policy from a -group of shared access signatures. However, you are not obligated to define the stored access -policy parameters when you set it up. You can use any combination of parameters when -configuring the stored access policy, and then include any remaining parameters directly in the -shared access signatures. When you use this approach, you can update the policy when you -need to shorten or extend the lifetime of a shared access signature, rather than revoke the -signature and issue a new one. You can establish up to five stored access policies per container, -table, or queue and use each policy with an unlimited number of shared access signatures. For -more information, see Use a Stored Access Policy. - -For a closer look at security concerns related to identity and access in the cloud and -considerations for building security into your cloud applications, see Microsoft Azure Security -Guidance. - -Learn more - - Understanding Block Blobs and Page Blobs (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en- - -us/library/ee691964.aspx) - - Blob Service Concepts (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd179376.aspx) - Delivering High-Bandwidth Content with the Microsoft Azure - -CDN (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee795176.aspx) - - Understanding the Table Storage Data Model (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en- - -us/library/dd179338.aspx) - - Table Service Concepts (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd179463.aspx) - Querying Tables and Entities (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd894031.aspx) - Microsoft Azure Storage: A Highly Available Cloud Storage Service with Strong - -Consistency (http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp11/current/2011-Cascais/printable/11- -calder.pdf) - -© 2014 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is -licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 License. - -17 +Another assumption in this analysis is that personal incomes change at the same rate as GDP per +capita. Empirically, it is not unusual to observe that personal income or consumption increases at +a slower rate than GDP per capita. However, the relationship between the two measures varies +widely across countries and it is not clear what the relative rates of growth might be at the regional +or global level. The World Bank often assumes a “pass-through” rate of 0.85, i.e., only 85% of + +www.pewresearch.org + + 15 + +PEW RESEARCH CENTER + +national output growth is passed through to household income or consumption. If a pass-through +rate of 0.85 is assumed for this analysis the estimated change in the number of people in each +income tier is as follows: Poor (+117 million), low income (+11 million), middle income (-45 +million), upper-middle income (-30 million) and high income (-53 million). + +From the point of view of measuring global poverty, a key issue is that the latest available +benchmark survey for India was conducted in 2011. As the second most populous country in the +world, India accounts for a large share of the global population in poverty. In 2011, 969 million +people lived in extreme poverty globally, on $1.90 or less daily, and 285 million of that number +were from India. The World Bank has applied a variety of estimation techniques to update the +poverty counts for India, but uncertainty lingers in these updates for India and, by implication, in +current measures of global poverty. + +www.pewresearch.org